[0:01] hello [0:05] [Music] [1:00] [Applause] [1:03] [Music] [4:47] thank you [4:57] [Music] [5:03] do whatever we can [5:36] i need [5:50] so [6:02] yes [6:09] um [6:45] thank you [6:46] i'd like to call city development plans [6:48] to order we have 1600 agenda [6:51] the first i'm on the agenda is approved [6:53] to extend youth agreement with marathon [6:55] craigslist for carbon communities [6:57] redevelopment india [7:13] agreement [7:26] street has a use agreement with the city [7:28] of schenectady that was executed on [7:30] december 19th of 2019 for the parcels [7:33] associated with the farmer community [7:35] redevelopment project in the hamilton [7:37] hill neighborhood [7:39] this current use agreement expires [7:41] december 19 of 2021 um to accommodate [7:45] the delays resulting from proven 19 and [7:47] the associated impacts um we're [7:49] requesting an extension of the use [7:51] agreement [7:52] with the new expiration date of december [7:54] 30th 2022 [7:57] so we're looking for approval from the [7:59] city council to amend this use agreement [8:01] and i know we have representation from [8:03] maryland creek street who can um i don't [8:06] know ray if you just want to come up and [8:08] speak a little bit about you know the [8:10] progress and where the project is [8:12] absolutely [8:15] from blue light development [8:20] it's like a little bit of weird energy [8:22] like we haven't seen each other in [8:23] person for a [8:25] see everyone uh [8:27] trayvon's stuck in traffic uh he's [8:29] supposed to speak to the capital project [8:31] but um we've been experiencing some uh [8:34] extreme delays [8:35] with uh hvac and funding doing hogan 19 [8:39] and bidding but aside from that we've [8:42] been hosting the school of [8:44] community cleanups [8:46] in preparation for the renovations of [8:48] the center [8:50] which we have uh board members coming [8:52] with the individuals as well [8:54] but we've uh gutted the interior we've [8:57] got rid of both gym floors we've started [8:59] paint scraping [9:01] we've put a mural on the north side of [9:03] the building [9:05] we've done a school of landscaping [9:07] reclaimed our playground space [9:09] we also have [9:11] electricity on the panels are finally [9:13] not on that's about nine months [9:16] but we do have electricity on the [9:17] building and we're just waiting for [9:20] hvac ready and the plumbing [9:23] so [9:24] we are moving and making extended [9:25] product [9:27] let's look for the business so [9:29] i know there's been a delay with the [9:31] pandemic and supply chain issues do you [9:34] have any idea what that's going to cost [9:36] you i mean as far as additional [9:38] fundraising and whatnot [9:40] people out there know that you can still [9:41] use money absolutely yeah [9:44] um again trademark is his you know [9:47] speciality [9:48] it's not okay it's fine um [9:51] the the bidding numbers uh are all [9:53] different but it's anywhere from 50 to [9:57] 100k [9:58] and that's a rough estimate this [10:00] nothing's concrete that's a rough [10:01] estimate [10:03] and part of the obstacles that we face [10:05] are [10:06] we do have funds but we can't use the [10:08] funds because we have to use other funds [10:10] which is something that has been [10:12] incredibly um [10:14] confusing right because i know we have [10:16] um you know ties with metroplex but then [10:20] there was [10:21] cdt grant that we were supposed to have [10:23] funds for and use those but when we [10:25] applied for another brand we got turned [10:27] down because they said we have to use [10:28] the 150k from the [10:31] uh previous grant that we [10:33] can't use so there's been additional [10:36] obstacles with that [10:38] um and it's not like we've been sitting [10:40] and not doing anything you know we've [10:42] been reaching out and we're supposed to [10:44] get support from todisco and sinabria [10:47] and once said that if the other two [10:50] uh you know matched us then they'll [10:52] match and then the other two didn't [10:53] agree so it's been a whirlwind bright [10:56] family foundation we had several [10:58] meetings with them to get support and [11:00] they turned us down it's like [11:02] someone's only waiting for someone else [11:03] to support us in order to support us you [11:05] know so [11:07] and if i'm being transparent the most [11:09] support that we have has been from [11:12] uh [11:13] people who have [11:15] are like the most like [11:17] unresourceful or [11:19] have lack of resources which is [11:21] faith-based community and hamilton hill [11:23] community so [11:25] the beautiful thing about our cleanups [11:26] is different people always show up and [11:29] those are the people who have been [11:30] consistent [11:31] um [11:32] so yeah it's been it's been tough [11:34] and i think it's important for us to [11:35] have the [11:36] conversation about [11:38] how [11:39] we can get more resources [11:44] so let me just [11:46] sorry i was just going to say also um [11:48] just because you know working on this [11:49] product for a bit now [11:52] so the cbg funding is 150 000 it is [11:55] reimbursement basis so [11:58] the 300 000 total was the number to [12:01] really do the hvac plumbing and [12:03] electrical work the electrical work has [12:05] been completed but it is they can't [12:08] really do everything at once because [12:10] again it's reimbursement basis so they [12:12] really just do one piece at a time [12:14] um so you know like ray mentioned they [12:16] finished the electrical portion of that [12:18] and now they're moving to try to get you [12:20] know hvac contractors in to just you [12:23] know to give a price um but that's been [12:25] really difficult in the current context [12:27] um so i think that's that's one cases of [12:30] the project right kristen just to be [12:32] clear haven't you spent any of the 150 [12:34] from the cdbg at all not not have yet to [12:36] do [12:42] that was the first step because they [12:44] needed power to be able to then you know [12:46] do the rest of the stuff so the [12:47] challenging part is really having the [12:49] money to do is because it's reimbursed buffalo brand [12:54] right right okay yeah so all right [12:57] so you're asking for this extension and [13:00] as was asked so [13:02] i know we're waiting for um trayvon i'm [13:03] not sure [13:05] [Music] [13:11] in order to [13:13] move forward but not money that's tied [13:15] up in any way you need to feel [13:16] straightforward have that money is that [13:17] what you're testing yeah absolutely [13:19] that's been one of our biggest hurdles [13:20] is if we have money that's sitting but [13:22] we can't use it how can we move forward [13:24] with anything you know and you know if [13:27] we i know it's been a long time but our [13:29] feasibility study uh it's 1.5 million [13:32] dollars and that's what bells and [13:32] whistles have the doors open um and [13:36] the 150k and 350k it's like a raindrop [13:39] in a bucket you know i don't need to be [13:41] frank but i do need to be frank but it's [13:43] just you know just it's been like a slew [13:46] of astounding disparities on our part [13:48] you know i know you've been through [13:49] hurdle after girl after hurdle you know [13:51] we continue to show up and we continue [13:56] um [13:58] we've continued to show up you know we [13:59] continue to do what's being asked of us [14:02] and you know we're just looking for more [14:03] support and more support that makes [14:06] sense you know what i mean and this is [14:08] not to pull anybody or anything like [14:09] that i just you know i think it's [14:11] important to have honest conversations [14:13] and [14:14] one of the barriers you're feeling like [14:16] this is really important [14:18] absolutely 100 100 it's [14:21] and i don't know there's got to be ways [14:23] around where we can have these funds [14:25] where they're not tied up so that we can [14:27] use them or there's not rules against [14:29] the funds where we have to spend some to [14:32] get some especially since we're so early [14:35] on in the states that they're prepping [14:36] for renovations [14:38] um [14:39] you know we don't want to spend all of [14:40] our money then we still have to get the [14:41] hvac and plumbing that the bidding and [14:44] you know we don't have any money for [14:45] that stuff um [14:47] so it's just it's just tough it's tough [14:49] when the the funds are tied up [14:51] so it's not possible that's what's like [14:53] some sold questions did you say that yep [14:56] and is it the same kind of thing but [14:58] reversal yes um yeah i believe so but i [15:01] know there was a tension of we had to [15:03] spend the money that we do have in order [15:06] to get more first one [15:07] the first 150 yes exactly right [15:10] which i i still don't you know [15:13] before i speak for my board and the [15:15] board members you know and if you can [15:17] chime in when you want to um but [15:21] with a project of this magnitude we all [15:23] know it's going to cost quite a bit of [15:24] money so i just again i don't understand [15:28] um [15:29] you know why we have to have to be tied [15:31] down to [15:32] uh funds when when we need all we need [15:35] as many funds we can get you know so [15:38] it's just it's been tough it's been [15:40] tough and i know that [15:42] when the obstacles are alleviated we [15:44] move [15:45] you know um [15:47] granted coleman has slowed us down but [15:49] like i said i think it's really [15:50] important to note that um as a community [15:53] we continue to show up and we continue [15:55] to uh continue to go um george would you [15:58] want to pass individuals around i think [16:00] that visuals are super important just to [16:02] see the progress that we've done [16:05] um [16:06] even though we've had obstacles [16:10] we can talk about all the time without [16:12] seeing it it doesn't it doesn't make it [16:13] real to me [16:14] um just to see the inside of the [16:16] building and see all the work that's [16:17] being done [16:19] to prep for renovation that's one less [16:21] thing that we'll have to worry about but [16:22] the funds we need those you know money is [16:26] what we need [16:28] absolutely so i i recommend that we [16:31] accept the extension at this time and um [16:44] you know sometimes they'll be able to [16:46] help out it's kind of tough for the city [16:48] at this point [16:55] is the challenge itself for sure for [16:58] sure [16:59] that would be my recommendation yeah and [17:01] we have and i appreciate that [17:03] recommendation so much we've reached out [17:05] to [17:06] like i said uh [17:07] foundation um they turned this down if [17:10] you ask me i think that that was a [17:11] personal thing because you know rosa was [17:13] working there and then uh she decided to [17:16] take my marathon proxy full time it's [17:18] like i said from being quite frank i [17:20] think it's important for us to have [17:21] these transparent conversations if we [17:24] um [17:25] didn't want to get ahead you know we [17:27] want to see progress with this [17:29] you know we met with the county [17:31] uh and [17:32] we've i can send you a list of email [17:35] chains and just nothing you know what i [17:37] mean and we thought that [17:40] attaining ownership of the building [17:42] would give us a leg up and [17:45] um i don't know if for some reason uh [17:48] we're still not being believed in even [17:49] though we continue to show up we [17:51] continue to do with being asked of us [17:54] but we're just not getting the support [17:55] that we [17:56] anticipated like i said the most support [17:58] we've gotten was is from the community [18:01] and from big big communities and um [18:04] yeah we're looking for more for more [18:06] resources more for more help you know [18:09] not not a handout but a hand up [18:12] um [18:12] you know we we it and the crazy thing is [18:15] we're running programming we just don't [18:17] have a house for it you know the [18:19] community center we've got our google [18:20] programming going we still have the [18:22] community police basketball league going [18:24] um [18:25] just to give you a couple names of [18:26] partners that have come out to help us [18:29] ask an fbc school district multiple [18:31] principals have come out and supported [18:33] us [18:34] the c center has been incredible with [18:36] support um [18:38] dsa acronym dsa has been incredible with [18:41] coming out and supporting us [18:47] has been incredible so [18:49] i don't want you guys to think that we [18:50] haven't been reaching out and [18:52] uh [18:53] searching for partners in collaboration [18:55] but we've been doing nothing but that um [18:57] like i said especially through the [18:58] pandemic even with all the obstacles [19:00] with the stopping of the attacking thing [19:02] we still have been moving you know doing [19:04] what we can [19:05] just to show uh proof that we're going [19:08] to continue to move until the doors are [19:09] open [19:11] because the community needs it [19:14] i was just going to say that i know that [19:16] um the loan fund is a potential partner [19:18] in this and they [19:19] had committed to a bridge loan tax [19:22] testimony but i think that they're [19:24] waiting to see the full kind of [19:27] scope of work which is difficult to get [19:29] pricing right now for certain things [19:30] that are so far in the future is what's [19:32] you know been communicated to us so [19:35] i think at this at this time they're [19:37] asking for the extension [19:38] to just you know continue to to move [19:41] forward and [19:43] you know get more support so do you have [19:46] any um [19:47] i don't know about the board members [19:48] here so do you like before we move [19:50] forward to [19:51] or any other council members questions [19:54] you know we would actually [19:56] tonight we would act on you know the [19:57] extension and then we'd probably have [19:59] larger conversations about the funding [20:01] so yeah sorry i didn't mean to get in [20:03] the weeds [20:08] right about what's actually going to get [20:09] all the project done and the resources [20:11] that are going to be needed right [20:13] i think it's important that we know yes [20:14] for sure that makes sense [20:20] [Music] [20:26] thank you [20:34] [Music] [20:36] all right the next item on the agenda is [20:38] the transfer of city on [20:45] properties to the legacy [20:50] okay so um the city and the land bank [20:53] are partners on a lot of things mostly [20:55] to return vacant and abandoned [20:57] under utilized property to productive [20:59] use so the legacy city access program is [21:02] funded by the new york state budget [21:04] through hcr [21:05] to provide land banks with [21:08] renovation uh funding for distressed one [21:11] to three unit properties and this is to [21:13] create home home ownership opportunities [21:15] by partnering with local mwbe certified [21:18] and or minority-owned developers so we [21:21] have been working with the land bank to [21:23] identify properties um you know given [21:26] the the recent redevelopment in mount [21:29] pleasant over 40 demolitions the orchard [21:31] park expansion the wallingford park [21:34] splash pad the new boys and girls club [21:36] the libraries um the main street facade [21:39] program there's been a lot of [21:40] reinvestment in mount pleasant and we [21:41] think that one of the that's one of the [21:44] areas where this opportunity for [21:46] homeownership can really help out in [21:49] terms of just creating that [21:50] stabilization in the neighborhood and [21:52] dealing with some of the most difficult [21:53] properties that are there um to really [21:56] just try it and sort of infill and rehab [21:58] um [21:59] you know properties in that area so [22:01] david holding campus here if you're in [22:03] the land bank i don't know if you want [22:04] to add yeah if you have any questions [22:06] about about the program the [22:08] landing funding that we have in past has [22:10] been pretty discretionary we did a lot [22:11] of uh glide home removals in partnership [22:14] with uh kristin the team here [22:17] this is a [22:18] prescriptive program to uh try to create [22:20] homeownership out of uh some of the [22:22] player homes the land needs to have [22:24] control of those properties so we uh [22:26] appreciate your support uh we'll uh [22:30] the program is set up so you can have [22:32] three different uh [22:34] legacy cities projects going in time [22:36] which is five to ten uh properties so [22:38] we'll look for a development team that [22:40] needs the criteria they're looking for [22:42] over in mount pleasant right here where [22:43] we're proposing uh all the uh changes uh [22:47] for the positive on chrome street and [22:48] then uh hopefully uh we'll continue to [22:51] find more opportunities for [22:52] [Music] [22:55] so the request tonight is to for the [22:57] city of schenectady to enter agreements [22:59] with the land bank for the transfer of [23:01] the 10 properties that are existed [23:03] and this is basically for the [23:05] legacy [23:06] program [23:18] uh [23:35] for the is [23:36] snow pollen season as we all know winter [23:39] is going to come hopefully [23:41] tonight but in preparation of that [23:44] we'd like to um [23:46] approve the rates the hourly rates for [23:48] the equipment so that we can move [23:50] forward and [23:52] procure a documented wind law [23:56] to solicit services for the following [23:58] season [24:02] either not [24:16] until you approve the rates and then [24:19] advertise when the final document is you [24:21] know is approved by law [24:23] we'll put that out and then [24:25] hopefully we'll get [24:27] you know contractors coming like we've [24:28] done in the past years uh hopefully the [24:30] establishment [24:39] fuel prices [24:45] [Music] [24:52] um [24:56] [Applause] [25:19] [Music] [25:25] unless you meet your phone and see [25:30] [Music] [25:40] oregon contract for the construction of [25:43] the maintenance storage at the mini dell [25:45] course [25:46] mr wall [25:52] so first item [25:54] as it says in the backup materials we [25:56] had [25:57] three buildings two were original the [25:58] gulf court construction one i believe [26:00] was constructed in the 70s one of the [26:02] original buildings [26:04] we were forced to take down six years [26:06] ago with our larger storage building we [26:08] were hoping to uh close this drought and [26:11] build a new building however we had to [26:12] find a way that was within budget we [26:15] started with a typical building and we [26:17] moved uh terribly to one of the prefab [26:20] building [26:21] so we put out the bid for a pre-fat [26:23] building it's uh basically this is going [26:26] to be a factory slab with a metal bar [26:29] night building that you see kind of out [26:31] in the in the suburbs and we're going to [26:33] be doing a lot of work in house once the [26:35] shell is built so we're [26:37] doing electrical in-house bringing it on [26:38] our plumber's going to help out and then [26:40] we're going to build within the shell so [26:42] it'll take a little while but in the [26:44] meantime it'll give us a large clean [26:48] open area that's outside of the weather [26:50] to keep our equipment in a lot of our [26:51] equipment is being stored currently too [26:53] at the oregon ave parks garage the old [26:55] garage so this will also help keep all [26:57] the equipment in one area on the golf [27:00] course not across from it which is good [27:01] so we've been trying to do this for [27:04] what nine years i think before i got [27:06] here [27:06] this was a project so [27:08] we're hoping to move forward this [27:10] company's worked with the city in the [27:11] past they've worked with the state and [27:12] did our due diligence uh we've already [27:14] had some meetings before i came to you [27:16] with ron and aaron and we're comfortable [27:18] bringing it forward [27:28] [Music] [27:33] uh award come into contract for removal [27:36] uh [27:37] for a cdbg uh aiming presentation [27:42] so this is a second payment program [27:46] what we did is due to the requirements with all the different [27:50] monies that we have now tdd in section [27:52] three um we had quite a bit of money [27:55] left over for coving because we didn't [27:57] do a payment program [27:59] so we decided to put out an independent [28:00] navy program just focused on [28:04] the [28:06] football area which is handling the [28:07] middle in this case um kind of around [28:09] frank street where we're going to be [28:10] doing our work [28:12] it's a cdbg only contract so that we can [28:14] focus on all the requirements on one [28:16] contract we had a lot of bids that do [28:18] five bids below [28:21] newcastle who we've worked with in the [28:22] past on berkshire park we've had a [28:25] discussion with them ron's discussed [28:27] with them already you know the [28:28] requirements that i need we're going to [28:30] use the off season so to speak to you [28:33] motion [28:37] second [28:38] what was in favor [28:41] okay and then on the uh [28:49] so the amphitheater also known as music [28:51] has [28:52] a series of optical partitions that are [28:54] doors that [28:56] go like this and they rotate [28:58] um and they're used for a full sound and [29:00] access the stage the doors uh before we [29:03] put the security fixing up we're [29:04] vandalized they also have seals that are [29:07] broken so animals birds and squirrels [29:10] that they've seen going in and out of [29:11] music maybe making it a hard place to [29:13] clean so [29:14] we put out a bit uh and that huffport [29:17] was really the only supplier such a door [29:20] the same people that supply [29:22] high school gymnasiums those [29:23] opportunities just much smaller [29:26] so we're looking to get the doors [29:28] ordered and then once again installing [29:30] in time for music pavements uh next [29:32] season so we're gonna get that facility [29:35] you know back up it looks great though [29:36] the facilities [29:38] [Music] [29:48] is [30:06] almost in favor aye thank you mr wong [30:08] thank you [30:09] all right the next item is refunding of [30:11] the 2014 volunteers mr ferrari [30:15] mr president [30:17] council [30:18] uh one of the things that we do at the [30:20] finance department is review constantly [30:22] uh opportunities that help the city to [30:25] save money especially uh [30:28] what we're talking about is a [30:29] opportunity to renew and refund our 2014 [30:33] bonds of 28 nine or twenty million or [30:36] fourteen thousand [30:37] now uh we're looking at this opportunity [30:39] with the rates uh [30:41] and we with uh roosevelt lacrosse and [30:43] our physical advisors that we have an [30:45] opportunity to save approximately uh [30:48] four million four point three million [30:49] dollars over the next 16 years the [30:51] average of of over 255 000 a year [30:55] and uh if you looked at the uh when i [30:57] had centuries look at angel one of [31:00] the refunding highlights you would see [31:03] what the total would be [31:05] what we're asking of this is uh [31:07] as you saw in my memos we're asking [31:10] for an ordinance to be a little bit [31:12] higher just in case the fluctuation [31:15] of the market but we're pretty much set [31:17] on that uh 4.3 million that's the best case [31:20] scenario our worst case scenario we're [31:22] thinking of 3.7 million dollar savings [31:24] which [31:25] is still a savings through the savings [31:28] so we're jumping on this opportunity and [31:30] i brought it in a rush only because [31:32] it's just like it's the perfect time [31:36] any questions [31:38] all right [31:39] okay [31:40] thank you [31:42] around [32:03] um [32:12] they [32:13] wrote a letter to us saying that there [32:15] was some [32:16] further information needed [32:18] that we need to pass this resolution [32:21] including [32:23] the last four of the council members [32:25] social security number and registration [32:27] numbers and [32:28] update on record activities and results [32:33] all right so in terms of the last four [32:35] of the social lines things only the last [32:37] four however [32:39] how to have that information i mean how [32:41] public is that information [32:43] so the copy of the resolution that i am [32:46] that i will need to post [32:48] can have that redacted but the [32:50] resolution that is sent to them need to [32:52] have it on there [33:04] bye [33:10] all right see you next time on the [33:12] agenda discussion renaming terrace [33:14] heights from museum drive it was a [33:16] public pairing um [33:17] on 10 25. [33:19] we actually only had one speaker and [33:21] then someone that spoke about it later [33:22] that was in favor of it so [33:24] are there any uh questions here [33:27] all right [33:33] all those in favor [33:38] okay um discussion osn broadcast city [33:41] council committee meetings mr solomon if [33:43] um [33:44] almost weekly i'm sure some of you also [33:47] get the same complaints [33:49] about the broadcast of the [33:52] committee and council meetings people [33:54] either can't hear him the video is not [33:56] running [33:57] there's some sort of issue [34:01] we gotta figure this out we either [34:02] record it and play it so it works or do [34:06] it live and make sure it works [34:08] so [34:11] i would like us to [34:12] see about getting information [34:15] from osm on [34:17] how to fix this problem what it it costs [34:20] what options we would have for the [34:22] broadcast [34:23] i think that might fall into your [34:25] purview mr colvin [34:27] and uh [34:28] just as a discussion tonight bringing it [34:30] forward [34:31] uh in the next weeks because it [34:33] continues to be a problem [34:35] all the time and uh quite frankly and [34:38] tired of hearing the complaints [34:40] then people are like why can't we get [34:42] this right [34:43] and if we can't get it right then we [34:45] need to look for a different vendor so [34:50] i just putting it out there i'll follow [34:53] up with the mayor in [34:55] osm to see what the issues are [34:57] as well as mr coleman to see what [35:01] options we have as far as the [35:02] broadcasting but i'm sure all of you [35:05] have gotten similar complaints [35:07] and [35:09] thought we should take it up [35:12] so um [35:23] maybe we need to set aside some funding [35:25] to accommodate them so this doesn't [35:27] continue to happen [35:34] uh get it out there see what everybody [35:36] else's feelings are assumed [35:40] likewise yeah every week [35:42] absolutely [35:50] because over time people are complaining [35:53] they're having difficulty [35:55] so you'll be moving forward by having [35:56] obsessions [36:00] to your point i mean it was just a few [36:02] years ago [36:04] we upgraded all the equipment that's [36:05] supposed to fix the issue [36:07] and uh [36:09] obviously [36:10] so i don't know why it was working now [36:12] it's not but um hopefully we'll get it [36:14] addressed all right so are you asking me [36:16] to have this on two weeks yep [36:18] okay [36:21] yes [36:23] well i just like to add that [36:34] you can't see any of the speakers [36:52] um [36:57] [Music] [37:09] okay [37:10] all right thank you for those comments [37:12] but yeah but the camera didn't like [37:13] watch before the camera does move [37:18] but even to the speakers [37:22] you'll see a person speaking and i'll [37:23] actually move and go right to that [37:25] person but it's not happening [37:27] broadcast [37:28] oh this is just us this is a website yes [37:31] that's why yes [37:32] that is the right this is the tv [37:34] it's a fixed camera yeah so that's not [37:36] the oh that's not what people see on osm [37:40] you're watching live [37:42] yes [37:43] okay all right so while mr uh mr coleman [37:46] is going to move forward on that and [37:47] talk to us thank you for uh creating [37:49] your butt [37:51] okay um [37:52] any more discussion on that [37:54] all right so our next item our [37:56] discussion is the statue of liberty ms [37:58] zalewski williams and um [38:01] miss patrick that's going to let you go [38:02] first because you're online [38:05] okay [38:06] [Music] [38:17] gateway um our country [38:19] and for me [38:20] you know as a child of movements in the [38:23] city that's just the city of immigrants [38:25] um i just feel like it's very very [38:28] appropriate that the statute of liberty [38:30] returned to [38:31] park [38:32] and welcome all of our visitors to [38:34] schenectady in a park that we've now [38:37] spent so much money renovating um i [38:40] think that [38:42] you know i hear the argument sometimes [38:44] that the park now is supposed to be a [38:45] place of public contemporary art [38:48] um but i do want to suggest that you [38:51] know we don't want to throw up in [38:52] history as we continue to move forward [38:54] with progress and i think that again [38:57] having the new liberty [38:58] there with for example the pride [39:02] sculpture which represents you know [39:04] freedom for a whole nother group of [39:06] individuals in our country that [39:08] worked hard to earn their rights [39:11] i just think it's a very very [39:12] appropriate setting for statute of [39:14] liberty and i really would like to see [39:15] the council support the move of the [39:18] statute back to [39:20] um gateway park so that's that's what i [39:22] want to say and i appreciate this [39:29] so um i'm in agreement um you know this [39:32] has been [39:33] a tough time for this poor little statue [39:36] um she needs to go back to the park and [39:40] i know that um you know if we could get [39:42] support here i'm in hopes that we can [39:45] hopefully get it back over there um so [39:47] i'm in full support of it so i'd like to [39:50] make a motion to [39:52] move it forward [39:53] i could [39:54] so um but we could move forward is [39:56] discussing with the mayor because um my [39:58] understanding is [40:00] he's the final decision maker i wish he [40:02] was still here so he had some input on [40:04] this [40:05] so mr colony [40:08] we could actually move a resolution [40:10] [Music] [40:12] support as a council whatever the mayor [40:14] does the mayor does [40:16] um [40:17] so [40:18] we could do that um [40:21] i think it's [40:22] you know the whole history of [40:24] the movement of the statue [40:26] and all that i don't want against that [40:29] because it's long and complicated and [40:31] quite translated [40:34] but um [40:35] i would be in favor of moving it back at [40:37] this point and maybe we put a statue [40:40] at that corner [40:42] with something to do with the airy canal [40:44] which would be more fitting here oh [40:46] where littering is now yeah i mean this [40:48] doesn't turn out anything but well it [40:51] could be nothing but you know it's [40:52] something we could move forward as a [40:54] council and whatever the mayor chooses [40:56] to do we choose to do it i think what we [40:58] need to do is go back to where we [41:00] originally um when it was originally [41:02] moved [41:03] my understanding was sitting there that [41:04] it would be moved back so we need to go [41:06] back and look at that legislation if [41:07] we're as moving this resolution over [41:10] and and bring that back say this was the [41:12] original plan and we'd like to be able [41:14] to um to do to the resolution that the [41:18] original plan is what we'll stick to [41:21] that's exactly what i was going to ask [41:22] for is that it was a resolution when [41:24] this was a move was the yes the [41:26] discussion was to move it back to the [41:28] over some location so we just go back to [41:30] there and we can do resolution and [41:32] support again i'm totally improving to [41:34] that as long as i'm in this council i [41:36] think the majority of us in this country [41:39] always was constantly supported he [41:41] relocated back to its original place and [41:44] i'm in full support of that [41:47] so um so we're asking for a motion to [41:49] draft the resolution to support the [41:51] original uh [41:53] idea of moving the laboratory i just [41:55] have a [41:57] is that resolution in 2013 climbing or [42:00] non-binary [42:07] [Music] [42:09] 2013 city council class resolution [42:11] 2013-206 [42:15] approving and adopting the 2013 gateway [42:17] positive with a patient [42:19] you know over 100 page plan [42:23] i pulled out one quote from the plan [42:26] that i thought was applicable i was [42:28] asked to look into it just so that [42:30] everybody's on the same page with what i [42:32] saw [42:32] and i did a search so i may have missed [42:34] something but i did search just a [42:37] statue of liberty to see where it was in [42:39] the plan [42:40] and on page 19 of the plan [42:43] it's section 1.12 existing monuments and [42:46] historic markers it says quote [42:49] there are numerous monuments and [42:50] historic markers throughout the park the [42:53] number of monuments and signs coupled [42:55] with a proximity to one and one another [42:58] has the effect of cluttering the park [43:01] each should be evaluated as part of the [43:03] new design and careful consideration [43:05] should be given as to how they are [43:06] placed within the new plaza [43:08] that's what it said [43:11] i did not find anything in there saying [43:13] you know it should be removed [43:15] and not find anything in there that said [43:18] it should be [43:19] relocated i did not find anything in [43:21] there that said it shouldn't be removed [43:23] or it shouldn't be relocated [43:27] that's what i saw in looking at the plan [43:29] so i would say that it you know is it [43:31] binding [43:33] it's a plan that the council adopted [43:35] it's binding to the degree that is [43:37] fitted up by the council but again it's [43:39] a plan right plans sometimes don't [43:41] always reference that [43:43] so i think there is some uh [43:45] maneuverability within the plan because [43:47] as things were developing the plaza in [43:50] terms of what they were doing to the [43:51] park there had to be some flexibility [43:53] within that so it was the ideal of the [43:56] plan and then what actually happened [44:00] so then our resolution should just so we [44:04] get it right [44:05] so our resolution should be to [44:08] recommend the movement back to liberty [44:12] park [44:16] i don't have an opinion on that you know [44:18] that's not a legal question okay the [44:20] council can you [44:37] [Music] [44:41] okay [44:42] so the final five items on the agenda [44:45] are an executive session [44:58] probably will have to leave [45:04] okay