[0:00] [Music] [0:07] foreign [0:11] [Music] [0:49] foreign [1:04] [Music] [1:16] foreign [1:26] [Music] [2:05] thank you [2:07] [Music] [2:33] thank you [3:15] [Music] [3:48] thank you [4:19] [Music] [4:38] thank you [4:40] [Music] [5:10] thank you [5:11] [Music] [5:40] thank you [5:43] foreign [5:44] [Music] [6:28] thank you [6:30] [Music] [7:01] oh yeah [7:15] calling to order the city Caucus meeting [7:17] for Monday August 14 2023 [7:21] we have one public hearing this evening [7:23] if the clerk would please read [7:26] public hearing number one establishing a [7:28] six-month moratorium on the submission [7:30] and processing of building permits [7:32] certificate of occupancy certificate of [7:34] use and land use approvals for a smoke [7:37] shop vape shops and tobacco tobacco or [7:40] vape consumption businesses within the [7:42] city of Schenectady [7:44] we have eight items for original [7:45] consideration if the clerk would please [7:47] read item number one item number one for [7:49] final consideration an ordinance [7:51] pursuant to section 101 of the second [7:53] class cities law abandoning a portion of [7:55] large Street [7:57] discussed and committee with objection [7:58] on consent item number two item number [8:01] two for original consideration a [8:02] resolution authorizing the city to enter [8:04] into a contract with New York state [8:06] division of criminal justices to secure [8:08] give grant funding discussed in [8:10] committee with objection on consent item [8:12] number three item number three for [8:14] original consideration a resolution [8:15] authorizing the city to enter into a [8:17] contract with New York state division of [8:19] criminal justices [8:21] to secure research and evaluation grant [8:24] funding regarding the community hiring [8:25] panel discussed in committee with an [8:27] objection on consent item number four for original [8:31] consideration a resolution revoking the [8:33] appropriation of American Rescue plan [8:35] act arpa funds for the construction of [8:37] the capital region Aquatic Center as [8:40] authorized by resolution 2022-14 and [8:43] amended by resolution [8:45] 2023-029 discussed in committee with [8:48] objection on consent item number five for original [8:52] consideration a resolution authorizing [8:54] the settlement of a claim by Carol riggy [8:56] discussed and committed without [8:58] objection on consent item number six for original [9:02] consideration a resolution recognizing [9:04] 2023 black business month this item will [9:07] be taken out of order and presented by [9:09] councilman Williams item number seven for original [9:13] consideration and resolution authorizing [9:15] the issuance of revocable permit number [9:17] 677 to Herbies burgers for a sign with [9:20] accent lighting in an online they were [9:22] overhang the cities right away at 175 J [9:25] Street discussed in committee with the [9:27] objection on consent item number eight for original [9:31] consideration a resolution awarding the [9:33] bid in contract for the Schenectady [9:35] Municipal Golf Course irrigation system [9:37] installation base bid and add alternate [9:40] number one to George E lay company in [9:43] the amount of three million three [9:45] hundred and fifty two thousand nine [9:47] hundred and thirty four dollars and [9:48] twenty one cents discuss some committee [9:50] with objection on consent if there's [9:52] nothing more to come before the city [9:53] council caucus I would ask for a motion [9:55] to adjourn movement Miss Patrick second [9:57] by Mr Williams all those in favor we are [10:00] adjourned I'd like to call to order the [10:02] city council meeting [10:03] for Monday Monday August 14 2023 [10:08] and I'd like to call on Pastor Mark [10:09] Thompson for the prayer invocation [10:18] Eternal God our Father we thank you [10:20] again for the favors of this day and how [10:21] you've blessed us and kept us father we [10:24] thank you for [10:26] the reason why we are called here today [10:27] taking care of the business of the city [10:29] of Schenectady we give honor to the [10:32] mayor of this city councilman Porter [10:33] Phil all those elected officials and [10:35] everyone in their respective places [10:36] father we pray that you bless them and [10:38] Grant them your wisdom because they [10:40] might be the stewards of this city Lord [10:42] God the caretakers of this city and the [10:44] service of the city father I ask a [10:46] special blessing upon each of them as [10:48] they lay things aside to do the business [10:49] of the city take care of the things that [10:51] they've laid aside while they are here [10:53] to do your business father B Grant your [10:55] wisdom Grant your provision and Grant [10:58] your leadership into this place father [11:00] last but not least we send our hearts [11:02] and prayers out to the people in Hawaii [11:05] right now who are suffering great loss [11:07] but act that you would be with them as [11:08] you are here with us we ask these things [11:10] in Jesus name amen amen as a [11:13] councilwoman Patrick to lead us in the [11:15] pledge [11:16] Allegiance [11:18] United States [11:24] [Music] [11:30] thank you [11:35] if the clerk would please complete the [11:36] Roll Call [11:38] with tavarian is absent Mr Toro Mr [11:42] Farley [11:43] Mr Williams [11:45] Miss Patrick [11:47] Mr palamini is absent Miss Porterfield [11:50] here thank you [11:54] hold on one second oh thank you [12:02] one second [12:06] I think [12:07] that's on us it's ours okay [12:19] is lost [12:21] okay [12:23] yep [12:25] okay [12:27] I'd like to ask the clerk to read any [12:29] Communications and petitions [12:36] Communications presented to city council [12:39] for Monday August 14 2023 under official [12:42] there were none under General there was [12:44] an email from Emily treforest and in [12:47] opposition to a proposed Bill in [12:49] Congress to raise the federal weight [12:51] limit of heavy trucks on the nation's [12:53] roads [12:54] under petitions there was a petition of [12:57] 22 signatures for sidewalk improvements [12:59] and special assessment District on [13:01] McLennan McClellan [13:05] thank you and saw council members for [13:08] any committee reports [13:14] we do have one public I'm sorry we do [13:17] have one out of order resolution [13:21] and we asked councilman Williams to [13:22] present that [13:35] foreign [13:42] we have Asia priests unique priests [13:46] Mrs if you could join us behind the rail [13:49] Mrs Thompson [13:51] Yaya [13:58] all right Kenneth Brooks If Kenneth's [14:00] here and Tanika Smith [14:17] beautiful beautiful but before I begin [14:18] I'd like to First say how privilege and [14:20] honor I am to be presenting this [14:22] resolution to you all today and to all [14:24] the other businesses that have not [14:25] joined us tonight may I have the floor [14:27] you may so I'll be presenting a [14:29] resolution recognizing the 2023 national [14:32] black business month [14:33] whereas black business month is [14:35] celebrated in August it is a time to [14:37] acknowledge and appreciate black owned [14:39] businesses Across the Nation and all [14:41] that they represent in the country's [14:42] continual striving for diversity and [14:44] equality black business month provides [14:47] an opportunity to focus [14:49] on a community that is far too often [14:51] underrepresented when it comes to access [14:53] to Capital and opportunities to build [14:55] wealth and whereas the history of black [14:57] business month can be traced back to the [14:59] year 2004 when engineering entrepreneur [15:01] Frederick e Jordan partnered with the [15:04] president and executive editor of this [15:06] scholarly Publishing Company e-access [15:08] Corporation John William Templeton to [15:11] start this annual event their intention [15:13] was to drive the policy agenda affecting [15:15] the 2.6 million African-American [15:18] businesses in order to highlight and [15:20] Empower black business owners everywhere [15:23] given the continued challenges faced by [15:26] black business owners [15:27] and whereas since the late 1700s both [15:30] free and enslaved black people began to [15:33] open their own small businesses from [15:35] barber shops to tobacco shops and [15:37] shoemaking as emancipation grew so did [15:40] the establishment of black owned [15:41] businesses and this led to the period [15:43] between 1900 and 1930 being labeled as [15:46] the Golden Age of black owned businesses [15:49] and whereas this historic annual event [15:51] provides a chance for consumers and [15:53] Proprietors to not only support black [15:55] businesses but provide them with a [15:57] platform to grow their own their [15:59] Enterprises and build wealth for current [16:02] and future generations of African [16:04] Americans celebrating the contribution [16:06] of black business owners and [16:07] entrepreneurs pays homage to them and [16:10] their legacies and celebrating this [16:12] month recognizes the importance of black [16:14] owned businesses when it comes to [16:16] contributing to the nation's economy as [16:18] well [16:19] and whereas the value of [16:20] Entrepreneurship has long been a major [16:22] influence in the black community today [16:24] approximately 10 percent of All American [16:27] businesses are black owned the primary [16:29] sectors in which black-owned businesses [16:31] operate include Health Care Social Work [16:33] repair and maintenance beauty salons [16:36] restaurants barber shops arts and [16:38] entertainment and the list continues to [16:40] grow [16:41] and whereas black business month ensures [16:43] that black owned businesses get the [16:45] recognition and patronage that they so [16:47] richly deserve especially those that are [16:49] struggling to stay afloat [16:51] celebrating black owned businesses [16:53] empowers more people from the [16:54] African-American communities to dream [16:56] big and begin their own entrepreneurial [16:58] Journey [16:59] and whereas when you choose to support [17:01] black owned businesses you are [17:03] supporting black pride unity and kuji [17:06] jacquelia or self-determination black [17:09] entrepreneurship is a tool for survival [17:12] now therefore be it resolved that the [17:14] Schenectady city council and Mayor Gary [17:16] R McCarthy do hereby pause in our [17:18] deliberations to recognize black [17:20] business month and the city of [17:21] Schenectady and encourages all residents [17:24] to support black owned businesses in the [17:26] city of Schenectady the capital region [17:28] and at every other opportunity I'd like [17:30] to move the resolution [17:31] in a second by Mr Farley all those in favor [17:37] aye aye congratulations the motion [17:39] passes [17:40] [Applause] [17:51] um yes no [17:55] you're so excited okay [18:01] and please please I would love for you [18:03] all to share some words uh of [18:05] encouragement and also of your journey [18:06] if you wouldn't mind [18:08] hello everybody I'm Asia priest this is [18:11] unique priests and kahin priest we are [18:13] accepting this award in regards to our [18:15] brother DJ ketchup and ketchup [18:16] Enterprise which is us we are check [18:19] ketchup Enterprise we are black business [18:21] we are Schenectady and we want to say [18:23] we're thankful for the recognition that [18:25] you're giving us and we just strive to [18:27] do better for our community and for the [18:30] ones beneath you know underneath us that [18:32] are looking up to us [18:33] and we're just appreciative that you [18:36] guys have taken this time to pass this [18:37] and [18:38] we love you thank you [18:40] [Applause] [18:45] truly I think it's an honor and a [18:48] privilege to be able to stand here and [18:51] represent little yayas located in the [18:55] city of Schenectady at 135 Broadway and [18:58] I truly think the council and I think [19:01] the mayor for recognizing that Yaya's [19:05] a mom-and-pop business [19:07] a black owned business [19:10] for this area for such a time as this is [19:14] able to still be standing after seven [19:16] years [19:17] I think it's a wonderful thing that [19:19] we're doing down there and I and I just [19:21] think my team my team is here so I think [19:24] and my husband who's my biggest [19:27] supporter for Yaya's house I appreciate [19:30] and I really really thank you for the [19:34] [Applause] [19:40] um thank you so much city of Schenectady [19:43] my name is Kenneth Brooks I represent [19:46] Community fathers ground up Landscaping [19:49] cuts and blends Barbershop [19:51] and uh [19:54] o-i-o-i which stands for occupations [19:56] instead of incarceration that's a [19:58] program we started with Community [19:59] fathers because when I was a youth uh [20:03] what kept me out of trouble was gaining [20:05] self-worth and being able to help out [20:07] and feed my family help my mom help my [20:09] sisters help my siblings [20:11] so I knew that that was the opportunity [20:14] and that's what I wanted to do with my [20:15] life to provide that same path for the [20:17] Youth that follows me so there's one [20:21] youth who's not here who works with me [20:22] his name is Yaya Yasir Washington he [20:25] actually became my youth because he was [20:28] appointed to me as like you know a big [20:30] brother because he was getting in [20:31] trouble in school so it started from me [20:34] going to his house under a mentorship to [20:37] him being one of my finest best workers [20:39] he's like a son to me and my operations [20:41] manager David Cooper he's not here [20:43] that's my childhood friend we've been [20:45] friends since we was 12 years old we [20:47] came from a group home so uh the support [20:50] of the city the family the [20:53] not-for-profits in Schenectady the mayor [20:55] the people of Schenectady the city of [20:58] Schenectady supporting my business and [21:01] supporting me and bringing me to where I [21:03] am today there's David Cooper operations [21:06] manager right there [21:07] thank you uh my business would not have [21:10] grown through trials and tribulations [21:12] through you know uh pluses and minuses [21:15] with the support and the help and the [21:18] love of everybody in this room everybody [21:20] in Schenectady I was able to grow and be [21:22] successful and I appreciate everybody [21:24] thank you [21:28] my name is Tanika Smith I'm with kitchen [21:31] love and Kenneth is my fiance I say with [21:35] a good team you can get anything done [21:37] and I think that's what Schenectady is a [21:40] great team to have access to everything [21:42] that we need in order to grow in order [21:45] to do in order to give back you can have [21:47] any lemonade stand as my cliche verbiage [21:50] but to know what it takes to do that and [21:53] the limit how much they cost and how [21:55] much that uh support you need from the [21:57] community in order to be able to sell is [22:00] definitely a difference and I thank you [22:02] Schenectady for allowing me to do that [22:04] and give back because it's not just [22:06] about being here it's about giving back [22:07] also and teaching the youth as well but [22:10] thank you so much [22:13] can I say one thing there is one black [22:16] owned business that's here that's not [22:18] standing up and I just want to [22:20] appreciate her because she's a wonderful [22:22] person and that's the dandelion that's [22:24] Pauline Saunders and she has a black [22:26] owned business [22:27] thank you [22:32] and I just wanted to recognize her [22:34] myself [23:11] I just need to go down [23:34] one two [23:36] three and don't move the library [24:03] okay all right and everybody everybody [24:27] thank you [24:54] we do have one public hearing this [24:56] evening [25:03] we have one public hearing this evening [25:05] and just a reminder that we've extended [25:07] the public hearing public comment [25:09] hearing time to four minutes and I also [25:12] respectfully ask the first people [25:14] speaking only speak to the topic of the [25:17] public hearing number one [25:24] establishing a six-month moratorium on [25:26] the submission and processing of [25:28] building permits certificates of [25:29] occupancy certificates of use and land [25:32] use approvals for smoke shops vape shops [25:34] and tomato and tobacco or vape [25:38] consumption businesses within the city [25:39] of Schenectady [25:41] I have four people signed up to speak [25:44] the first person is Jeannie Orr [25:53] good evening my name is Jeannie Orr I'm [25:55] a Schenectady County resident and a [25:56] program manager for Capital District [25:58] tobacco-free communities we're a New [26:00] York State Department of Health funded [26:02] program that covers Schenectady Albany [26:03] and Redstone counties [26:05] and our goal is to improve the health of [26:07] our communities by creating environments [26:09] that decrease exposure to second-hand [26:11] smoke that support smokers who want to [26:13] quit and prevent young people from Ever [26:15] starting because we know that tobacco is [26:17] still the number one cause of [26:20] preventable death and disease [26:22] as you consider a moratorium on vape and [26:25] smoke shops in the city of Schenectady I [26:27] wanted to provide you with some facts [26:29] according to the Surgeon General there's [26:31] overwhelming evidence that the more [26:33] young people see tobacco the more likely [26:35] they are to start smoking tobacco [26:38] companies spend a half million dollars [26:39] every day aggressively marketing tobacco [26:42] products including e-cigarettes in [26:43] stores throughout New York state with [26:45] colorful walls and tobacco products [26:47] special discounts and other marketing [26:49] materials all of which are highly [26:51] appealing to youth [26:53] in Schenectady County the amount of [26:55] tobacco marketing that residents [26:56] including young people are exposed to [26:58] depends on where they live [27:00] we graph the density of tobacco [27:02] retailers in Schenectady County by ZIP [27:04] code and observed a very obvious trend [27:08] I have graphs here that I can distribute [27:10] to you afterwards but you will see on [27:12] this graph [27:13] that the zip codes with the highest [27:16] poverty rate 12304 05 and O7 have the [27:21] highest density of tobacco retailers [27:23] compared to Niskayuna which has the [27:25] lowest poverty rate Hamilton Hill with [27:28] the highest poverty rate has more than [27:30] five times the tobacco retailers per [27:32] capita [27:33] we also looked at where these tobacco [27:36] retailers are located with their within [27:37] the various zip codes [27:39] specifically we looked at how many were [27:41] located within 1500 feet of a school [27:45] in Schenectady County of the 173 [27:48] licensed tobacco retailers 53 or 31 are [27:52] within 1500 feet of a school [27:54] in the city of Schenectady 41 of the 111 [27:58] or 37 are within 1500 feet of schools [28:02] Hamilton Elementary School has 10 [28:04] licensed tobacco retailers within 1500 [28:07] feet of its property the most of any [28:09] school in the county [28:11] we also looked at smoke and vape shops [28:13] that are separate from just regular [28:16] licensed tobacco retailers which include [28:17] convenience stores and they we found [28:19] that five were located within 1500 feet [28:21] of a school [28:23] and in the spring of 2019 our staff held [28:26] four neighborhood conversations with 40 [28:27] residents living in the city of [28:29] Schenectady and one of the questions we [28:31] asked participants was whether they [28:32] thought limiting the number of tobacco [28:34] retailers in the neighborhoods would [28:35] make a difference [28:37] and here's some of what we recorded in [28:39] their own words [28:41] kids shouldn't see tobacco marketing I [28:43] want my babies I don't want my babies to [28:45] start I think they should take it out of [28:47] the neighborhoods cold turkey if kids [28:49] don't see it they're less likely to [28:51] start it [28:52] I think the harder it is if you've got [28:55] to walk them out to get it you might [28:56] think about taking that walk [28:58] we also asked what these Schenectady [29:01] residents want to see less of and more [29:03] of in their communities and again in [29:05] their own words they said Les Bodega [29:07] selling bootleg cigarettes [29:09] corner stores look mostly abandoned [29:11] there are more cigarette choices than [29:13] candy [29:14] everything that's killing us in our [29:16] neighborhood we want to see less of put [29:18] a cap on the number of stores selling [29:19] tobacco [29:20] they wanted a real neighborhood with [29:22] everything you need in one place a good [29:24] Park in Hamilton Hill things for people [29:27] for kids to do basketball courts Fields [29:29] pool Recreation Center positive things [29:32] more stuff for families to do it deters [29:34] young people from smoking when they take [29:36] care of themselves [29:38] we released a full report in 2020 [29:40] detailing our conversations along with [29:43] the data around tobacco marketing and [29:44] Schenectady this report titled [29:46] addressing tobacco use Health inequities [29:49] in the county of Schenectady is [29:50] available on our website [29:51] smokefreecapital.org [29:54] and I can also send you a link along [29:56] with the data I just mentioned tonight [29:58] please feel to contact me with any [30:00] questions you may have thank you so much [30:02] and I do have the graphs [30:06] thank you [30:09] Genevieve Hart [30:17] hello my name is Genevieve I've lived in [30:19] Schenectady County for most of my life [30:20] and I am a member of the reality check [30:22] Capital District faculty communities [30:25] growing up I learned about the dangers [30:26] of smoking in school and at home like [30:28] most children do but in the stores and [30:31] in the media smoking and eventually [30:32] vaping were constantly advertised to me [30:34] this year I'm going to be a junior in [30:36] high school for years vaping has been a [30:38] problem in school the administration [30:40] struggles to solve the issue because [30:42] when you take away the Vape the student [30:43] usually has another one at home or can [30:44] easily get another one in the last few [30:46] years the problem has gotten much worse [30:48] every Locker break during homeroom [30:50] during lunch and after school sports [30:52] games there are students vaping in the [30:53] bathroom it's almost a given now that [30:56] anytime I use the restroom during the [30:57] school day at least one of the Stalls [30:59] will be taken up by a group of girls [31:00] vaping [31:01] smell of cotton candy or mango fills the [31:03] bathroom and the hallway outside and [31:05] lately it's not just vaping occasionally [31:07] you'll walk into the bathroom and be [31:09] greeted with the smell of marijuana or [31:10] even cigarette smoke every one of my [31:12] teenage peers sees vaping at school [31:15] every single day even my younger brother [31:17] who is 12 years old comes home from [31:19] school some days detailing his [31:20] experience smelling Vape or even [31:22] marijuana in the middle school bathrooms [31:24] he's 12 and he can't go to school [31:26] without smelling drugs in the bathroom [31:28] the most heartbreaking part of it for me [31:30] is when I see my friends and my peers [31:32] becoming addicted to nicotine as a [31:33] result of vaping and the downward spiral [31:35] that their life takes as a result of [31:37] their Addiction in middle school I was [31:39] an advanced math class with a boy who [31:41] was smart kind and motivated and we were [31:43] very good friends however he began to [31:45] hang out with a group of kids who were [31:46] vaping I expressed my concern to him [31:48] about the issue but he brushed it off [31:49] because Vapes aren't as dangerous as [31:51] cigarettes within less than a year I [31:53] watched them become addicted to his Vape [31:54] drop out of advanced classes get [31:56] suspended and then he even began selling [31:58] Vapes himself to other middle schoolers [32:00] my other friends and I watched [32:01] hopelessly as he lost interest in life [32:03] and closed himself off from us but what [32:05] were we supposed to do he was in too [32:07] deep and he wouldn't listen to a word we [32:08] said for that old friend of mine the [32:10] spiral continues he is still vaping [32:11] today years later addictions are hard to [32:13] break and he's just a kid [32:15] the way that Vapes and other tobacco [32:16] products are marketed often targets [32:18] young people and disturbingly resembles [32:20] candy packaging is bright and colorful [32:22] and the products come in flavors such as [32:24] strawberry watermelon and blue raspberry [32:25] such flavors and products you could also [32:28] find packaging Styles you could also [32:30] find in the candy aisle [32:31] as marketing tactic only feeds into the [32:33] narrative that for years has been spread [32:35] by tobacco sellers that Vapes and other [32:37] form of tobacco are less dangerous than [32:38] cigarettes though in some cases this [32:40] might be true Vapes in particular still [32:42] contain dangerous chemicals that can [32:44] still kill you these harmful drugs are [32:46] foremost very accessible seeing as [32:47] they're found in gas stations and corner [32:49] stores that are within walking distance [32:50] from schools and homes regulating the [32:52] retailers of tobacco and vape products [32:54] along with advertising and paraphernalia [32:56] of these products could expose less to [32:57] the manipulative marketing tactics that [32:59] trick people into believing that they're [33:00] safe and hopefully there will be yes [33:02] less young people like my friend who [33:04] became addicted to nicotine at such a [33:06] young age thank you for your time [33:08] thank you [33:12] Rock Creek Caldwell hope I got your [33:15] first name right [33:26] hello everyone my name is [33:31] I live in also reside in the city of [33:33] Schenectady [33:34] well I'm sorry I live in also work [33:36] within the city of Schenectady my [33:38] apologies I'm very nervous [33:41] um so basically I was raised in a family [33:44] with [33:45] basically smoking with nothing but [33:48] smokers within my family my mother [33:51] smoked my father's smoke my grandmother [33:53] smoked my great-grandmother smoked [33:56] um [33:58] and [34:00] due to the fact that that cigarettes [34:03] were basically a norm within my family I [34:06] bought my first pack of cigarettes at [34:08] the age of 18. [34:10] less than 10 years later I was like [34:13] diagnosed with a pulmonary embolism [34:16] which I had a clot in my lung [34:19] um [34:20] at the time I had one choice [34:23] which was to con [34:25] stop smoking and be there for my my [34:28] children my fault daughters [34:30] which I did [34:32] and [34:34] you know I'm here today [34:36] just to [34:38] just an advocate for [34:40] individuals like myself [34:43] um that experience a hardship from [34:47] smoking tobacco products [34:51] um [34:54] and also [34:57] I'm hoping that you know my story can [35:00] make a change or a difference in someone [35:01] else's life [35:03] also [35:05] you know as I said I'm a mother of four [35:09] so [35:11] showing [35:14] sorry [35:15] I'm a mother of four and [35:18] it's very important for me to be the [35:22] change that I that I that my family need [35:25] basically the generational chain breaker [35:28] you know I thank God that I'm standing [35:31] here today [35:32] um years ago I woke up coughing up blood [35:35] and I had no choice but to live for my [35:39] kids and you know [35:43] especially like in regards to the well [35:47] at that time I was a menthol smoker you [35:50] know now they have other flavors [35:52] of tobacco products you know which [35:56] it's like [35:59] it's just you know it's horrible and I [36:02] you know I'm just here today just to [36:05] tell my story [36:07] um and you know thank you guys for your [36:10] time [36:10] sorry thank you [36:13] [Applause] [36:19] P divorce [36:33] um I'm just going to talk about the [36:35] Practical side of this because I've been [36:37] listening to the committee meeting and [36:39] you all know what you're going to be [36:40] facing there are people already [36:42] participating in some of these venues [36:46] smokeless cigarettes and all those [36:49] different forms I'm just not that [36:51] acquainted with it but I know they're [36:53] around and I see people using them and [36:55] thinking I've heard that there's even [36:57] like a hundred different flavors and [37:02] peanut butter still King but anyway [37:05] you know you're going to run into [37:08] problems with people who have been doing [37:10] this for their lifestyle their income [37:14] and so practically speaking you've had [37:18] very good discussions about what's going [37:21] to happen you know what's going to [37:22] happen there are going to be people who [37:26] are going to [37:27] come forth and present it to the city I [37:31] mean it's just like Mr kosher with this [37:33] plastic straws nobody's arresting [37:37] stewards for plastic straws [37:40] the [37:41] but anyway [37:43] um [37:44] you know there's going to be a lot of [37:46] contention in section number five [37:49] section one says there will be [37:52] exceptions so right there [37:54] whatever you say is going to [37:57] give the onus to those with exceptions [38:02] and [38:03] there's a payback for it I think there [38:07] may even be a remuneration for [38:09] embarrassment and it depends on how far [38:13] you go with this [38:15] whether you actively participate in [38:19] stopping people from participating in [38:23] the buying of these things I wouldn't [38:25] want to be the one to walk up to [38:28] somebody who wants to do business there [38:30] and start a [38:32] chastising them about what they're doing [38:35] so but you've had some very good [38:37] discussions on this you know it's going [38:39] to be a big problem [38:40] and what's government for [38:45] thank you [38:48] I have no one else signed up to speak so [38:50] I declare the public hearing that I [38:52] declare the public hearing closed [38:57] ask for approved [38:59] I asked for approval of minutes for July [39:01] 24 2023 [39:03] moved by Mr Williams second by Miss [39:05] Patrick all those in favor [39:07] aye [39:09] this time we'll have privilege of the [39:11] floor related to the legislative agenda [39:13] I see three people signed up to speak [39:16] uh the first person Neil golub [39:24] thank you it's my pleasure to be here [39:26] today I would just say everybody's [39:29] sitting up front it's very hard to hear [39:30] you speak and it comes through in a very [39:34] garbled way in the back so I would [39:36] suggest people try to project themselves [39:38] I want to talk about the [39:42] Aquatic Center which is being planned [39:45] for Schenectady about a year ago the [39:47] lady who was heading up [39:49] came to me and asked for my opinion and [39:53] I thought I liked the idea very much [39:54] we're pattering it after Greensboro [39:57] which has had an enormous impact on [40:00] their business community and the message [40:02] I want to deliver to all of Schenectady [40:04] is that the benefit of the Aquatic [40:07] Center which would be built in in [40:09] Rotterdam because it's the only place [40:11] available all of the benefit in business [40:14] will come to Schenectady hotels will be [40:17] loaded restaurants will be loaded [40:19] businesses will be will be bending [40:23] we've seen in Greensboro you know 120 [40:26] 000 people coming into town over a [40:28] period of time [40:30] Greensboro has benefited so dramatically [40:33] from having the Aquatic Center in town [40:36] that we should take a very close look [40:39] and before Schenectady says well that's [40:41] not us recognize that the major business [40:45] economic benefit will accrue to [40:48] Schenectady New York because all of our [40:51] restaurants and all of our hotels and [40:54] all of our entertainment is downtown and [40:57] all of that comes back to us so please [40:59] consider your decision about supporting [41:02] it very carefully thank you for hearing [41:04] me thank you [41:09] P.D Boris [41:21] well [41:23] again let's say [41:25] number two you're taking in 481 [41:29] 687 and number three you're taking in 49 [41:34] 977 of County Legislature last week took [41:40] in one a quarter million dollars so [41:44] keep trying [41:46] uh [41:48] also [41:51] um [41:53] regarding the award [41:56] the ceremonial reward there's uh I went [42:01] to a meeting the other night about [42:02] zoning from a to X [42:06] Y and Z were left out [42:08] big things are going to happen in [42:10] Hamilton Hill huge it's just starting [42:13] and you didn't even speak to the address [42:16] of person that started it all about a [42:20] year or two ago when the y'all got [42:23] together on the properties up there and [42:26] they uh [42:28] new [42:30] rentals huge rental spaces up there so [42:34] if you really want to see something [42:36] that's challenging and go back to the [42:39] zoning meeting committee meeting on a a [42:43] through X [42:44] no y and z [42:46] so there's a project going to start [42:49] there that'll employ a lot of people [42:52] from some place and for several years to [42:57] come I've drove every one of those [43:00] addresses the other day and saw reptiles [43:04] rodents just it was scary very scary I [43:09] saw things up there that should be fine [43:11] and they have gone to seed there's [43:14] somebody your bus was up there I took [43:16] two pictures of your bus uh the boys [43:20] girls club it's a mess Burrell Park [43:23] third time I've been I've seen [43:26] Renovations there the first time they [43:29] surrendered the court with fence for [43:31] basketball the second time they went and [43:34] redid the the field room and the [43:38] bathroom and put fences around that now [43:41] all of it's been demoed and they're [43:43] going to have a splash park so think on [43:47] these things and also the money being [43:50] used for the golfing I think to play at [43:54] a municipal golf course cost fifteen [43:58] hundred dollars a year to play there [44:03] as a member of the municipality [44:06] extraordinary [44:10] thank you thank you [44:13] Justin cherish [44:24] how we doing thank you for having me and [44:26] allowing me speak this evening I want to [44:27] speak on the resolution that allows the [44:29] city to enter into contract New York [44:31] state division of Criminal Justice to [44:33] secure the regarding Grant funds uh that [44:36] is with the community new hire panel I [44:38] just want to say thank you to all the [44:39] council and the mayor for considering [44:40] going into contract with CDG to get the [44:45] con the grant money for it for those [44:47] that don't know what the new hire panel [44:48] does it vets all of the young officers [44:51] that want to come into SPD so it is one [44:53] of the initiatives that we started that [44:56] allows us to work with SPD to Chief [44:59] Clifford and the other sergeants there [45:01] that have set in to bring in a group of [45:04] young officers that actually want to be [45:06] a part of this city uh for those that [45:08] didn't get a chance to go down to the [45:09] community father event this weekend [45:11] you've seen a lot of plain clothes young [45:12] officers that decided to frequent it on [45:15] their off day something I haven't seen [45:17] in the city in a long time so I just [45:19] want to make sure that everyone [45:20] understands the importance that this new [45:22] hired panel does as we bring in officers [45:24] that actually want to be a part of the [45:26] city want to police properly not over [45:29] police our communities and want to be [45:30] community members one of the officers [45:33] and I I don't want to use his name [45:34] because I did speak to him he doesn't [45:35] like credit but he received five merits [45:38] for exceptional Duty on just recently [45:41] that is one that came through one of the [45:44] first that came to the new hire panel so [45:46] this is something that we take very [45:48] seriously the people that we are vetting [45:49] and I hope that the council you know [45:52] takes it very seriously when they vote [45:53] on getting the grant to continue to work [45:55] with the community new hire panel thank [45:57] you [46:00] I have no one else to speak so I declare [46:02] the public comment on the legislative [46:04] agenda close [46:06] I'll ask for approval of the legislative [46:09] cassette agenda [46:11] moved by Mr Williams second by Mr Farley [46:14] all those in favor [46:19] we have a privilege of the floor on [46:22] General City business [46:24] and I have three four people signed up [46:27] to speak [46:33] Edmund Lavin [46:39] good evening [46:41] city of Ethics New York Board of Ethics [46:44] city of Schenectady New York Board of [46:45] ethics [46:47] we explained to you at the meeting June [46:49] 27 23 the city Ethics Committee has a [46:52] statutorial or prescribed charge and at [46:54] your complaints does not fall within the [46:56] scope of our jurisdiction [46:58] we have also received your follow-up [46:59] letter on July 14th [47:01] the appropriate Forum to address [47:03] criminal complaints it is certainly not [47:05] the appropriate for him to seek redress [47:07] for alleged moral failings [47:09] it's an Ethics Committee that is what an [47:11] Ethics complaint is about that Valentino [47:13] write the complaint for him this was [47:15] from father Dominic isopo [47:19] my office complaint is that I have a [47:21] parent at City Council meetings a [47:22] minimum four times in complain of Judges [47:24] Frost balotico and Hoffman depriving me [47:27] of my constitutional rights the mayor of [47:30] council members [47:31] have done nothing [47:33] they have all sworn in their oath of [47:35] office to prep the laws protect the laws [47:37] of the Constitution ethically they will [47:39] almost Act my complaint against these [47:42] three corrupt judges is obstruction of [47:43] justice and treason it is the same [47:46] complaint I am making now against the [47:47] mayor who refuses to meet with me and [47:50] all council members are guilty of [47:52] obstruction of justice [47:54] the mayor is to enforce all laws in the [47:56] city of Schenectady obstruction of [47:58] justice is considered a crime against [47:59] Justice itself [48:01] by obstructing justice one is seeking to [48:03] thwart the process of justice and the [48:05] operation of the justice system the [48:07] mayor must meet with me and you must act [48:09] on my complaint doing nothing [48:12] and not meeting with me is not ethical [48:14] but it is pride [48:18] if the mayor or city council members are [48:20] brought the crime of treason perpetrated [48:22] by a judge against the citizen to the [48:24] city council meeting [48:25] what is the civic duty of the mayor and [48:27] city council members [48:31] the civic duty of the mayor and City [48:33] Council Members is to ensure that the [48:35] judge is held accountable for their [48:36] actions they can do this by reporting [48:39] the judge to the appropriate authorities [48:40] and by taking legal action against them [48:42] the mayor and City Council Members can [48:44] also work to ensure that the judges rule [48:46] from their position if necessary it is [48:49] important for them to take action in [48:51] order to protect the rights of citizens [48:53] and uphold the law [48:59] when a citizen reports a crime of [49:01] obstruction of justice treason committed [49:02] by judges against a citizen the law [49:04] enforcement official is required to [49:06] investigate the matter the official will [49:09] take down the details of the complaint [49:10] and may ask for supporting evidence if [49:13] the complaint is filed to be true the [49:14] official will take appropriate action [49:16] against the judges [49:19] in addition to the Constitutional [49:20] violations the Department of Justice [49:22] prosecutes laws law enforcement officers [49:25] for related instances of obstruction of [49:27] justice [49:28] this includes attempting to prevent a [49:30] victim of or Witnesses from reporting [49:33] the misconduct lying to federal state or [49:36] local officials during the course of [49:38] Investigation into a potential [49:40] misconduct writing a false report to [49:42] conceal misconduct or fabricating [49:44] evidence [49:46] or keeping my office complaint out of [49:48] the newspaper [49:51] thank you [49:57] Petey Voris [50:07] EX [50:10] I think this community knows that I've [50:13] had everything I own [50:15] taken away from me [50:17] the door was locked the keys at the door [50:20] the locks were changed and I had a half [50:23] hour to vacate my the home I've been in [50:26] for the last three years I have [50:28] absolutely nothing except what I'm [50:30] wearing and what's in my car that's the [50:33] only thing that I have [50:35] and [50:37] that's devastating but that followed [50:41] after after my car had been shot at with [50:44] an assault weapon on Albany and Henry [50:47] Street and blew the tire out and I guess [50:52] somebody thought they'd make a good [50:53] story and they had maybe a [50:56] PhD and make a good write-up but within [50:59] 10 days this arm looked like a boxing [51:03] glove [51:04] and it was vibrating it was hot I [51:07] couldn't stand the pain of it it was a [51:09] trimmer [51:11] it was a trauma [51:13] from the having the tire shot at and I [51:17] was in several Emergency Care things [51:21] given medication given steroids given [51:24] and then ended up in the hospital for [51:27] several three times for surgery put in [51:31] isolation and then they tell me that I'm [51:33] not that I'm not being hospitalized I'm [51:37] there three four days and the fifth day [51:39] they say well we don't feel like [51:41] operating on you now so here I am going [51:44] through all this Hospital mumbo jumbo [51:47] and they should have had an MD on this [51:50] thing instead of a PhD there's a lot of [51:53] difference in just writing something up [51:55] about it [51:56] a lot of difference when you end up with [52:00] trauma [52:01] and now [52:03] on top of all that [52:06] I get thrown out of my apartment they [52:09] have everything I've I've been able to [52:12] gather [52:13] it's just everything all my books you've [52:17] seen some of my you saw one of my books [52:19] about the Caribbean crowd didn't you so [52:22] yeah the slavers yeah that's gone [52:25] and a whole bunch of other books Plus [52:28] work that I've done on my own [52:30] it's all gone everybody knows it I don't [52:34] know how you reconcile yourself with it [52:36] happening in this community it was an [52:38] assault weapon the niski and a police [52:41] told me only an assault weapon could [52:44] have done that and [52:46] not any police weapon I've also been [52:50] learning things like other people that [52:53] you know and I find out that our people [52:56] and the Warriors that do we can do to [52:59] get two paychecks a month [53:02] won the first and won the 15th for their [53:05] Warrior are [53:07] service [53:08] I do not have at this time because of [53:13] what's been done to me my only income is [53:16] social security retirement and it is [53:20] less than the first check you get every [53:22] first of the month [53:28] thank you [53:30] Wayne Harper [53:36] eight weeks two days picketing net [53:39] Albany VA hospital to get what I was [53:42] entitled to [53:43] but so far it looks like I'm going to [53:45] get it [53:47] now I'm sorry the mayor left I wanted to [53:49] address him [53:51] hopefully he watches the meetings [53:53] uh [53:54] [Music] [53:57] I think he's prepared to let Bellevue go [54:00] the Bellevue neighborhood go the way of [54:02] the rest of the city [54:05] I had been calling about a code [54:08] enforcement making complaints [54:10] about a residence that was in a fire [54:14] a major fire the roof was taken off [54:17] a lot of water went into that building [54:20] and tore down the garage built a new [54:23] garage put a back porch on and when I [54:26] foiled to get the um and Chris one by [54:29] the way [54:30] said to me oh yeah they've been cited [54:32] and he's been going to court and paying [54:34] fines [54:35] I said really Chris that's hard to [54:37] believe because I wouldn't think that [54:39] someone that was doing that would con [54:41] continue to [54:43] reviolate or continue to violate [54:46] and of course there are great violators [54:48] on the weekends I guess they know code [54:50] enforcement doesn't work on the weekend [54:51] and maybe we ought to get some people [54:53] out there on weekends [54:55] somebody ought to have a discussion [54:57] about that maybe this Council [55:00] um [55:01] so I foiled [55:06] and there's no records of any [55:08] inspections at all so far [55:11] maybe they'll find some no Plumbing no [55:15] electrical and you know when a when a [55:17] home is been in a fire they put a lot of [55:19] water in there that can jeopardize the [55:21] electrical system I don't know if you [55:23] folks are aware of that [55:24] no no framing permits for the roof the [55:27] garage and nothing [55:29] so I don't know if this is because [55:33] um [55:35] we're selectively [55:38] enforcing code enforcement and I don't [55:41] expect Perfection but this this [55:44] homeowners also in construction and I [55:47] see a dump trailer there debris he was [55:49] bringing in appliances from all over [55:51] probably jobs he did right now there's a [55:54] bobcat with a little front end bucket on [55:56] the front and this is a residential [55:59] neighborhood and I'm sick and tired and [56:01] here's an address maybe somebody ought [56:02] to write it down 24 26 2428 Campbell [56:07] Avenue and this individual used to drive [56:10] a truck that said either Nissan or [56:12] Colony so I don't know if he works but [56:14] he backs up to the front door of that [56:16] two family like that's a park on the [56:19] lawn [56:20] and I complained to the mayor I don't [56:22] know months ago gave him the address [56:24] so [56:26] you know this is what happens to a city [56:28] this is how it breaks it down we [56:30] Hamilton Hill was the first and I lived [56:33] through all of this Mount Pleasant [56:35] Central State Street up around [56:36] Brandywine Avenue now Bellevue and we're [56:40] well on our way [56:41] so I hope Gary watches these meetings I [56:44] hope Andrew there is going to respond to [56:47] my email and we maybe get to the bottom [56:49] of why there were no permits and and [56:52] think about permits going forward thank [56:55] you thank you [56:58] Daniel Castillo [57:06] good evening everyone [57:09] my name is Daniel Castillo the last time [57:11] I was here I formally requested the [57:13] removal of an unconstitutional sign [57:15] regarding identification to enter this [57:17] building that was posted at the entrance [57:19] I made the request because of the lawful [57:21] arrest of a citizen that invoked their [57:23] Fourth Amendment right the right of the [57:25] people to be secure in their persons [57:26] houses papers and their effects against [57:28] unreasonable searches and seizures [57:31] tonight I'm here to formally request the [57:34] removal of the unconstitutional [57:35] executive order of the mayor that [57:37] prohibits photographs audio and video [57:39] recording of any kind in the city hall [57:42] without the consent of all persons whose [57:44] voice or images being recorded [57:46] I would also like to explain how it was [57:48] treated here by some of the special [57:50] police officers that work in this [57:51] building before the executive order was [57:54] actually put up [57:55] after the citizens arrest [57:57] I came here to address my grievances I [58:00] filmed my visit and disseminated the [58:01] video to my viewers on my YouTube [58:03] channel that goes by the name New York [58:06] State audit [58:07] on my visit I declined to provide ID and [58:10] invoke my Fourth Amendment right after [58:12] doing so [58:14] special police officer Raymond [58:15] faffenbach rummages through my wallet [58:18] and steals my private information while [58:20] I was distracted conversing with another [58:22] special police officer [58:23] I can confirm this with my video as well [58:26] as the city hall camera footage that I [58:29] received through my Freedom of [58:30] Information law request that I made [58:32] after the incident [58:33] naturally I've returned to file a [58:35] complaint against Mr faffenbach and I [58:38] stopped by the mayor's office to make an [58:39] appointment so we can have a [58:40] conversation about the unconstitutional [58:42] sign and the lengths that the special [58:45] police officers are willing to go to [58:47] enforce it [58:48] again I invoked my Fourth Amendment [58:50] right to Mr faffenbach who just so [58:52] happened to be there once again [58:54] he turns and picks up a clipboard that [58:56] had my information on it calls me by my [58:59] name as he printed on my name tag [59:01] confirming even more that he went [59:03] through my wallet without my consent on [59:04] my first visit [59:06] I went to the mayor's office but he [59:08] wasn't in so I left my information with [59:10] his secretary I did this several times within a five-month span [59:16] but no one has ever called me [59:18] during this period I have been treated [59:20] with disdain by the special police [59:22] officers that are employed by the city [59:23] hall [59:24] I have been verbally and physically [59:26] harassed by them I have physically been [59:28] prevented from entering offices that are [59:31] open to the public especially the [59:33] mayor's office on one visit they would [59:35] even let me in the building [59:38] all these instant incidents were [59:39] captured on camera and disseminated on [59:42] my channel [59:43] why wouldn't the mayor speak with me [59:46] was it because the citizen was acquitted [59:48] of all charges when they were arrested [59:50] in this building in 2022 because they [59:52] used my video the video that I filmed [59:55] the video that proved their innocence [59:58] was it because the story I did about him [1:00:00] chasing a woman in his car from his home [1:00:01] to the police station allegedly drunk at [1:00:04] times even crying in front of the police [1:00:07] or is it because he looks at the citizen [1:00:09] as ratchet as it said on his Instagram [1:00:12] post during the last year's Super Bowl [1:00:14] halftime show as he does it because [1:00:16] that's what it seems like I can only [1:00:18] speculate regardless he took an oath to [1:00:20] the New York State and the United States [1:00:22] constitutions when he became the mayor [1:00:24] how can he preserve protect or defend [1:00:27] the constitution of this state or of the [1:00:30] United States [1:00:32] like it says in his oath [1:00:34] when he creates an executive order that [1:00:36] violates our First Amendment right [1:00:37] freedom of the press that violates [1:00:39] section one of the 14th Amendment all [1:00:42] persons born or naturalized in the [1:00:43] United States and subject to the [1:00:45] jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the [1:00:47] United States and the state wherein they [1:00:49] reside no State shall make or sir I need [1:00:52] you to summarize please your time is [1:00:54] expired This is the End right here no [1:00:56] States shall enforce or any law will [1:00:58] shallow Bridge the Privileges or [1:00:59] immunities of the citizens of the United [1:01:01] States nor shall any state deprive any [1:01:03] person of life liberty or property [1:01:05] without due process of law that's pretty [1:01:07] much the end of the gist of it so thank [1:01:09] you for your time this is right here you [1:01:11] guys took an off to this as well [1:01:13] okay not just the mayor so I'm I'm thank [1:01:16] you sir your time is expired okay thank [1:01:18] you thank you [1:01:21] I have no one else signed up to speak so [1:01:23] I declare the public comment of City [1:01:25] business close [1:01:27] any miscellaneous business of the [1:01:29] council [1:01:31] Mr Toro [1:01:37] good evening I'd like to thank everyone [1:01:39] for coming out I'd like to thank one of [1:01:41] our own councilman John palomini John [1:01:45] sits on a panel for the inflation [1:01:47] reduction act and he spent the past week [1:01:49] in Washington DC [1:01:52] um [1:01:53] on the anniversary of the act and did a [1:01:55] national press conference on the [1:01:57] economic and environmental benefits of [1:01:59] the legislation so John will be [1:02:01] continuing with that and I think we're [1:02:03] very blessed and lucky to have John on [1:02:06] our Council and working on all of our [1:02:09] behalf [1:02:14] anyone else okay the mayor has left so I [1:02:18] just want to thank everyone also for [1:02:20] coming out this evening to State [1:02:22] whatever your position is on our um the [1:02:24] various things on our agenda as other [1:02:26] things that are going on in our city and I invite you to continue to do that [1:02:31] as we move forward so thank you again [1:02:33] all for coming and with that I ask for a [1:02:36] motion to adjourn moved by Miss Patrick [1:02:39] second by Mr Williams all those in favor [1:02:41] we're adjourned have a good night