[0:55] good afternoon everyone welcome to the city of Binghamton City Council special [0:58] business meeting for September 15 2022 this meeting is scheduled to start our [1:03] budget process with mayor cram's budget address please join me and stand for the [1:07] pledge of the flag [1:12] pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic [1:17] for which it stands our nation under God indivisible liberty and justice abroad [1:29] thank you everyone I'd ask our city clerk to please do a [1:33] roll call for us for the city council members [1:44] present [1:54] okay thank you Mr clerk to my city council colleagues city hall employees [1:58] and fellow residents joining us here and from home good afternoon [2:03] my name is Phil Strawn city council president [2:05] representative binghamton's sixth district it's my pleasure to welcome you [2:09] today for mayor Jared Graham's 2023 budget address [2:14] this is the first budget mayor cram will present to the city and the public [2:19] when I endorsed mayor cram I said he'd be ready on day one and while he's been [2:22] in office for just eight and a half months mayor Krim has given us some idea [2:26] what we can expect today his actions have followed what he said [2:29] in his inaugural speech and what he talked about since taking office have [2:33] made clear his priorities I think to Residents have seen [2:37] unprecedented investments in public safety and critical upgrades in [2:40] neighborhood streets and parks we've seen a proactive approach in [2:43] Economic Development code and housing and a commitment to deliver delivering [2:47] results for binghamton's families I'm excited to hear what's in store with [2:52] today's address on behalf of my colleagues on city [2:54] council I want to thank the mayor and his team at City Hall [2:57] especially Chuck shager Lori Clift and their teams specifically for their hard [3:01] work preparing this budget my colleagues and I look forward to the [3:05] days and weeks ahead we'll be spending ensuring the 2023 budget is when [3:09] binghamton's residents can be proud of it's my pleasure now to introduce the [3:13] 51st mayor of the city of Binghamton Jared mcream [3:34] good afternoon everyone members of city council City staff [3:39] special guests members of the public those watching at home as I said good [3:44] afternoon the budget process is the most [3:47] time-consuming annual project any mayor will undertake there's no more important [3:52] role for City Council Members than the oversight and stewardship of how we [3:56] spend taxpayer dollars thousands of budget lines hundreds of touch decisions [4:02] the 2023 budget is at its core a plan a road map for how we will fund vital [4:07] services our residents need build the projects that our community deserves [4:13] but budgets also make a statement the one I will present this afternoon is [4:18] reflective of binghamton's priorities and values not just mine but of the [4:23] thousands of residents who call this place home [4:26] today's budget message will speak frankly about the challenges we face [4:30] where we're headed financially in the coming year the difficult decisions that [4:35] must be made to secure a sound financial future for the city [4:40] the last eight months have left a lot for Binghamton residents to talk about [4:43] and every corner of the city our constituents are seeing results [4:50] neighborhood streets paved on the south side lighted buildings torn down making [4:54] way for new housing opportunities on the North side and downtown [4:58] on the east side the city partnered with a startup to change the future of how [5:02] municipalities Port concrete making it cheaper and more sustainable [5:07] we've taken bold steps on student housing on the west side [5:10] turning grassroot discussions into legislative action to protect our [5:14] neighborhoods and we're chasing 10 million dollars for [5:18] Clinton Street and the First Ward to revitalize what could be the next great [5:22] downtown in Upstate New York we've broken down Economic Development [5:27] silos raising binghamton's profile and making headlines Statewide [5:31] with our plans for affordable housing taking on the owners of the Binghamton [5:36] Plaza and as a municipal Trailblazer and the multi-billion dollar New York [5:40] cannabis industry on the horizon we've made unprecedented investments in [5:45] public safety doubling down on the single most important service any local [5:51] government can provide its citizens we've updated our approach to code [5:55] enforcement and neighborhood revitalization and are energizing our [5:59] downtown Arts District with transformative streetscape improvements [6:03] we've delivered these results all in just eight months and we've done it with [6:08] bipartisan votes from city council and Broad support from the community [6:13] the 2023 budget keeps that momentum going so let's talk about some of the [6:18] specifics the city's total budget for 2023 is 97 [6:23] million dollars includes a 67.5 million dollar general fund budget which covers [6:29] day-to-day City operations and several Enterprise funds that guide Services [6:33] vital to the city such as water and sewer Community Development refuse [6:37] collection Golf and parking the general fund budget is what directly [6:42] impacts everyone's property tax rate and where most city services reside and the [6:47] general fund as of today has a healthy 15.6 million dollar fund balance [6:52] the city's largest source of Revenue to support those expenditures is local [6:56] property taxes at 33.9 million dollars in 2023 [7:01] and at 14.5 million dollars sales tax is the city's second highest source of [7:07] Revenue state aid for next year will remain flat [7:10] at 10.2 million dollars and although we anticipate binghamton's first adult use [7:15] Cannabis stores will open in 2023 I have budgeted zero dollars in revenue from [7:21] sales for next year we have no way of estimating expected revenues from the [7:26] local excise tax that will be on the sale of cannabis in which municipalities [7:30] get three cents for every dollar sold of cannabis [7:34] in the broad categories of how we spend taxpayer dollars salaries and employee [7:39] benefits represent the largest budget expenditure at 56.9 million dollars the [7:45] police and fire departments represent 64 percent of all salary costs in the 2023 [7:51] general fund other significant areas in our budget our debt payments at 17.7 [7:57] million dollars 3.4 million dollars for transfers to other funds and 2.4 million [8:03] dollars for parks and next year's budget includes 9.4 [8:08] million dollars in health insurance costs which is a reduction of four [8:12] percent from this year and we will pay 7.1 million dollars to the New York [8:16] State retirement system which is a four percent decrease for this year [8:21] let's talk about some specific departments right now Binghamton is at a [8:26] decision Point as it relates to crime and Public Safety [8:30] Mayors Across America are facing Rising crime rates in their cities and [8:35] shrinking resources to address things like Mental Health [8:38] the same time law enforcement agencies everywhere are struggling to retain and [8:43] recruit members maintaining police Staffing levels is one of our City's [8:47] most pressing challenges today the Binghamton police department [8:51] has 19 vacancies due to retirements and career changes [8:55] specialized details like the community response team and special investigations [9:00] unit they do essential work but they pull officers off the beat leaving a [9:05] smaller pool of officers available for the Patrol Division compared to say 30 [9:09] years ago it's not just urban areas that are [9:13] affected our community what happens in Binghamton has consequences that extend [9:17] beyond city limits as it relates to crime [9:19] the landscape here and how we choose to respond to it directly impacts [9:23] communities throughout Broome County and the Southern Tier [9:27] I view this responsibility seriously and it's not one I will shy away from [9:32] our future will come down to one of two choices [9:35] either we accept this as the new status quo or we respond in kind and meet our [9:40] challenges with action and let me be clear Binghamton chooses [9:45] action we won't be indifferent to a changing [9:48] landscape of crime or wash our hands of an issue because local lawmakers didn't [9:53] cause it instead we will respond by investing in [9:56] the measures we know make communities safer [9:59] that starts with filling every vacant position in the Binghamton police [10:02] department and being aggressive in recruiting a broad and diverse candidate [10:07] pool in a good scenario the next Police test [10:10] will yield 19 strong candidates who will bring the Binghamton Police Department [10:15] back to full Staffing in a best case scenario the tests will yield even more [10:20] quality candidates worthy of higher and if we can hire them we should [10:24] I'm pleased to announce that binghamton's 2023 budget adds three new [10:28] police positions partly funded by grants these positions would bring the size of [10:33] the police department to 145 sworn members which is the largest in more [10:39] than a decade we know the Continuum of Public Safety [10:43] is not limited to police on the street it's not as simple as more cops equal [10:47] less crime but Staffing levels are the foundation of a strong Police Department [10:52] a fully staffed Department means more resources for community policing fewer [10:57] Patrol shifts that are stressed to then responding from call to call improved [11:02] morale for officers and better retention especially for our most experienced [11:06] officers Beyond Personnel in the 2023 budget will [11:10] continue to make investments in other public safety areas including our [11:15] support for data-driven 21st century policing [11:18] that sets Binghamton apart in Upstate New York [11:21] earlier this year I announced the city would allocate a million dollars to [11:25] reduce gun violence in Binghamton the money is supporting community policing [11:29] efforts and other evidence-based strategies prevention [11:33] and other enforcement efforts through the Southern Tier crime analysis Center [11:38] I've heard from residents thrilled to see bike Patrols in their neighborhood [11:41] for the first time ever and we're hopeful on another a number of [11:46] different state and federal grants that would help fund new training new [11:49] vehicles equipment and other resources we're aggressive in pursuing these [11:53] grants to support not just the police department [11:57] but to keep the community safe without overburdening the taxpayer [12:02] for the fire department just a few weeks ago I welcomed 12 new Academy recruits [12:06] to the Binghamton Fire Department the graduating class included four women [12:10] more than any other class in the history of the fire department that's a historic [12:15] accomplishment that signals real progress [12:19] the 12 new graduates mean the department will be fully staffed in 2023 keeping [12:24] overtime costs at a minimum and bolstering emergency response efforts to [12:28] the more than ten thousand calls the fire department responds to every year [12:33] the new graduates are part of the next generation of firefighters continuing a [12:37] legacy of Public Service while ushering the department into a new era [12:42] earlier this year I announced a one million dollar fund to upgrade and [12:46] rehabilitate the city's historic neighborhood fire stations the oldest of [12:51] which was built more than 120 years ago as you can imagine these buildings are [12:56] in need of significant rehabilitation using American Rescue plan act funds [13:01] we're making an unprecedented investment to upgrade these stations with new roofs [13:05] HVAC improvements renovated bathrooms and bunk spaces bring the station up to [13:11] Modern standards these buildings are neighborhood anchors and by working with [13:15] fire Administration and the firefighter Union we're securing their long-term [13:20] future in those neighborhoods and in a few months binghamton's brand [13:25] new fire headquarters will open on Court Street the 9 million dollar [13:28] state-of-the-art facility will support emergency response throughout the city [13:32] Revitalize a key downtown Corridor and provide our firefighters with the modern [13:37] work environment they deserve in 2023 the city will invest 14.8 [13:43] million dollars rebuilding our streets sidewalks and other critical [13:47] infrastructure infrastructure is the foundation of local jobs and commerce so [13:53] it keeps residents and businesses moving new sidewalks and pedestrian [13:57] improvements let kids safely walk to school [14:00] an underground utility upgrades making sure make sure that our families have [14:04] clean and safe drinking water and I'm pleased to announce that my 2023 [14:09] budget includes no increases in water rates or sewer rates [14:14] funding infrastructure projects also mean creating good paying construction [14:18] jobs and more money flowing through the local economy to small businesses [14:22] early next year I will co-host a regional infrastructure Summit with a [14:27] chamber of commerce to bring together the public and private sector working [14:31] side by side to find Solutions about cutting red tape expanding our labor [14:35] force and securing vital state and federal dollars for projects right in [14:39] our backyard local municipalities can look to Binghamton as a regional leader [14:44] in smart infrastructure policy and practice [14:47] one of those Innovative areas is our new pavement rating system a technology [14:52] called robotics utilizes artificial intelligence to map and analyze all 151 [14:59] miles of city streets so we can track the ones in the worst condition [15:02] prioritize funding and get them paid next year we'll pave dozens of [15:08] neighborhood streets and thoroughfares including Floral Ave vestalab Holland [15:13] Street Seminary Ave and Mill Street just to name a few [15:17] we're funding the second phase of a transformative streetscape improvements [15:21] in our downtown with 2.5 million dollars allocated for upgrades on Washington [15:25] Street Henry Street and Water Street to grow our walkable Arts District [15:31] and we'll also begin designs to reimagine Memorial Bridge which connects [15:36] downtown and Riverside Drive upgrades will enhance that bridge which [15:40] is at the true Rivers Greenway make it safer and more attractive to pedestrians [15:45] and cyclists this is a historic piece of infrastructure with some of the best [15:50] views of our two rivers it's about time we invest in it [15:54] moving out of parks the city of Binghamton owns and maintains 36 parks [15:58] and green spaces these public spaces provide residents of every age healthy [16:03] recreational opportunities and make our neighborhoods more attractive to [16:06] families looking to buy a home our parks are some of our most most [16:11] treasured assets we need to care for them not just so they'll be around the [16:15] next Generation but to unlock the potential they have for the city [16:19] on the South Side the city will advance a multi-million dollar project to [16:24] upgrade conlon field replacing the flood-prone playing surface with [16:28] artificial turf the Bluff baseball field at MacArthur [16:31] Park has hosted special moments for generations of kids [16:35] who look forward to playing there every year under the lights but flooding [16:39] issues have caused countless headaches for Parks maintenance staff and led to [16:43] unfavorable playing conditions new flood resilient Turf will make conlon field [16:48] our Region's Premier amateur baseball field it can also be used for soccer [16:52] football lacrosse and other sports in the off season [16:56] I've spoken to councilman Joe Burns uh who is in full support of this [17:00] investment in his district and I I will say you know a year ago myself and [17:04] councilman Burns happened to be on opposite sides of a political campaign [17:08] but in the months since my taking office you would never know it councilman Burns [17:12] has demonstrated a sincere approach to working together and getting things done [17:16] on behalf of the city it's a true Mark of a public servant and I'm likewise [17:21] committed to helping the South Side succeed so Joe thank you for putting the [17:25] residents above politics [17:28] early last year the city changed the management structure at the Ely Park [17:33] Golf Course hiring a national golf management firm to handle operations the [17:38] results have been overwhelmingly positive our municipal course is on Pace [17:43] to host more than 25 000 rounds in 2022. that's a significant [17:48] number of folks coming to the city of Binghamton and Ely Park is safe to say [17:53] one of our Region's most popular public outdoor destinations [17:57] First Ward Park is a very special and historic Place provides affordable [18:02] accessible recreational opportunities for our community especially for [18:06] Binghamton seniors the course has even more unlocked potential and contributing [18:11] to golf tourism which is an Innovative marketing effort led by our Chamber of [18:15] Commerce that attracts tour groups from across the Northeast to play at local [18:20] golf courses these golfers Lodge multiple nights in downtown Binghamton [18:24] spend their dollars at local restaurants and our small businesses by making [18:28] upgrades at Ely Park and supporting this new management will continue to raise [18:32] binghamton's profile as a Northeast golf destination provide residents an [18:37] affordable public course for generations to come [18:41] next year we'll also begin the process of reimagining the Parlor City Commons [18:45] crumbling and utter underutilized public space in our Urban core between [18:50] Washington and State Street new lighting landscaping and other [18:54] upgrades will make the safe safer the space safer and more attractive as [18:59] downtown Binghamton continues its revitalization our public spaces should [19:03] build on that momentum not detract from it [19:06] next year's budget also includes a new Public Works position dedicated to [19:11] downtown beautification and keeping things tidy a busier downtown will mean [19:16] a stronger local economy we should be doing more to make sure downtown is a [19:20] place visitors want to come back to and residents are proud of [19:24] the 2023 budget also adds resources to improve maintenance of code cited [19:29] properties and city-owned vacant Lots two new full-time positions in the parks [19:34] department and new equipment will help the city respond more quickly to High [19:38] Grass violations and other code issues that are bringing down our neighborhoods [19:44] residents deserve to feel safe in their neighborhoods and in their homes [19:48] and right now too many of Binghamton families live in substandard housing [19:53] a shortage of quality affordable housing in Broome County courses many residents [19:58] to choose between housing they can afford and housing that's safe that's [20:03] unacceptable supporting new housing development in [20:06] Binghamton was a pledge I made during the campaign one we're already [20:10] delivering on just a few weeks ago we announced a 24 [20:14] million dollar mixed-use housing project on Henry Street near mirabito Stadium [20:19] lost project will build seven units of Workforce and affordable housing some [20:24] earmarked for artists who will live right near the heart of downtown [20:27] binghamton's Arts District and as I speak there are hundreds of affordable [20:32] units in the city of binghamton's project pipeline totaling conservatively [20:36] tens of millions of dollars in new investments in each of these projects [20:41] will add to the city's affordable housing stock [20:43] we're using our allocation of federal funds and local property tax incentives [20:48] to leverage millions of dollars in private money and state support to make [20:52] these housing projects a reality it's the most effective way we can use grants [20:56] like arpa and other Federal entitlement funds to develop new housing [21:01] in affordable housing like many of the issues I've outlined today Binghamton is [21:06] responding to a crisis that exceeds our borders but it will not sideline City [21:10] Hall instead we're taking a proactive role helping fund plan and break ground [21:15] on these critical projects setting an example for other municipalities in the [21:20] process Binghamton is leading on other housing [21:24] issues too last month the city welcomist first ever [21:27] housing prosecutor a new position we treated created to go after slumlords in [21:33] serious repeat co-defenders it's hard to overstate the impact housing has on [21:38] families especially on the outcomes of young people [21:41] without a safe decent place to call home it's nearly impossible for students to [21:46] focus on school or maintain a healthy lifestyle [21:49] bad landlords don't just affect renters they hurt entire neighborhoods dragging [21:54] down surrounding property values and draining City resources like code [21:58] enforcement and police also make it harder for good landlords [22:01] who play by the rules this new housing prosecutor is focused on holding these [22:06] Bad actors accountable it's funded in the 2023 budget heading up enforcement [22:10] of the city's reformed lockdown law Prosecuting illegal commercial activity [22:14] and other quality of life matters each year the city stewards roughly [22:20] three million dollars in federal funding through the U.S Department of Housing [22:24] and Urban Development to support Community Development projects reduce [22:28] poverty and homelessness and grow affordable housing opportunities in 2023 [22:33] we will advance more than 220 thousand dollars in youth programs through that [22:38] fund 157 thousand dollars in park improvements and a quarter of a million [22:43] dollars Paving roads in low-income neighborhoods more than 245 000 will be [22:49] will support blighted property demolitions so we can continue to [22:53] eradicate dangerous dilapidated eyesores block by block [22:57] these federal dollars help deliver some of the most popular programs and [23:01] projects to Residents and ease the burden on taxpayers [23:05] we have to be strategic and thoughtful with these decisions my thanks to [23:09] members of the citizen driven committee Our Community Development Advisory board [23:13] for their time input and guidance on this process [23:18] last year we got news that Binghamton would receive [23:22] 46 million dollars in federal relief funds through the American Recovery plan [23:27] act also known as arpa as far as I'm concerned this was just a down payment [23:31] to American cities like Binghamton after Decades of disinvestment by the federal [23:36] government with this funding we've allocated [23:39] Millions for projects like upgrading the city's water Network to ensure safe [23:43] quality drinking water we spent it on Hazard pay for essential [23:47] workers child care for families living paycheck to paycheck and cyber security [23:51] infrastructure here at City Hall as I mentioned earlier the city is also [23:57] using millions of dollars in arpa to support affordable and senior housing [24:01] projects across the city six million dollars was earmarked for these projects [24:05] in previous years and we're committed to making more money available to meet the [24:09] demand and support projects in the pipeline we'll also use 2.5 million [24:14] dollars of arpa funding next year to replace more aging Water and Sewer [24:19] infrastructure and today I'm announcing a new one [24:23] million dollar youth fund to support programs and services for Binghamton [24:27] children and teens an investment in our youth is a direct investment in our [24:32] future a portion of the funds will support a [24:35] new partnership with the Binghamton City School District to provide [24:38] trauma-informed care and violence intervention we'll also fund youth [24:42] Mental Health Services and upgrades at the Boys and Girls Club [24:45] building in the First Ward that has served thousands of kids over the years [24:50] the rest will be set aside for local non-profits as part of a competitive [24:54] funding round to develop and expand Youth Services think after school and [24:59] summer opportunities youth employment initiatives and stem programs for teens [25:03] the Community Foundation will serve as our partner to effectively and [25:07] efficiently get funds out the door and into the neighborhoods where youth need [25:12] the most ask any teacher or social worker parent [25:15] or principal the pandemic has affected our youth in a deep way from mental [25:20] health to academic outcomes and behaviors anecdotally we've seen younger [25:25] and younger kids as perpetrators of crime with this funding we're responding [25:30] to this issue in a meaningful way and supporting our kids [25:34] I want to take a moment in detail to speak about the city's refuse fund how [25:38] we collectively pay for garbage and recycling collection [25:42] the 2023 refuse fund is roughly 4 million dollars it's supported by 1.5 [25:47] million dollars in revenue from residents purchasing those blue bags but [25:52] subsidized by 2.5 million dollars in million excuse me 2.5 million dollars [25:57] from local taxpayers and contrary to popular belief blue bag revenue does not [26:03] cover the cost of collecting garbage in the city in fact it covers less than 40 [26:08] percent of it that means binghamton's small businesses [26:11] who use private haulers or homeowners who generate little in terms of garbage [26:15] like our seniors are covering most of the collection costs through their [26:19] property taxes that's 2.5 million dollars that should be buying snow plows [26:24] or paying cops or cleaning up our Parks not bailing out a broken refuse [26:29] collection system next year's budget calls for a slight [26:32] increase per blue bag 25 cents to offset Rising costs of fuel and the cost to [26:38] actually manufacture The Backs themselves it's a first increase in [26:42] seven years however institutional change is needed in the way that the city pays [26:47] for its garbage collection and I do not mean privatization [26:51] if you split the 1.5 million dollar in revenue from the blue bags across some [26:56] 20 000 households in the city Binghamton households on average spend [27:01] about 75 dollars a year on the blue bags even when you include the taxpayer [27:05] subsidy it's still only two hundred dollars per household per year [27:10] and outside the city of Binghamton households are paying private haulers [27:14] sometimes more than double that for refuse collection includes many services [27:18] that don't come as frequently as the city's once a week pick up and some [27:22] haulers have extra charges for yard waste collection in the city it's free [27:27] the issue is not with our dedicated sanitation Crews who are working in 90 [27:32] degree heat and Sub-Zero temperatures but rather the issue is finding a fair [27:37] way of paying for refuse collection that benefits everyone [27:40] reduces our property tax burden and ensures cleaner neighborhoods in all [27:45] parts of the city I do not have those answers today [27:49] but I ran for mayor to be a problem solver over the next months and years it [27:53] will be my focus to deliver Solutions on this issue [27:57] finally let's talk about property taxes I'm pleased to announce that in 2023 the [28:04] city of Binghamton will have no property tax increase in fact it's a very slight [28:10] property tax decrease for both residential and Commercial Property [28:14] Owners a 0.01 percent reduction for those residential and Commercial [28:19] taxpayers next year's budget puts the city's [28:22] constitutional tax limit at under 80 percent [28:26] a decade ago this number was dangerously high in the low 90s [28:30] our community has needs just like any other [28:33] and as it's always the case in local government the wish list that we have [28:38] exceeds what there's funding for and too often local leaders go to [28:42] taxpayers again and again and again asking them to shoulder more of the cost [28:49] I simply won't do it the responsibility of both funding essential services and [28:54] driving progress Falls to our Municipal leaders not the taxpayers it's on us to [28:59] make the tough decisions and protect families from unreasonable tax hikes [29:04] Binghamton cannot expect to compete in job creation population growth and [29:09] economic development if we do not have a competitive property tax rate [29:13] when I took office at the beginning of this year I knew holding the line on [29:17] taxes would be a challenge with inflation and economic uncertainty [29:22] those circumstances also underscored the urgency behind our goal [29:26] with families facing costs rising in every other aspect of their life we [29:32] needed to step up and deliver for them some final thoughts this afternoon [29:37] the 2023 budget took considerable time to compile my sincere thanks to the [29:43] department heads the entire Finance team led by Chuck shager and Lori Clift and [29:48] mayor's office staff for their efforts please join me in thanking them [29:59] the 2023 budget solidifies binghamton's reputation as a city in action [30:05] the decisions Investments and projects outlined today are what make Binghamton [30:10] the best place to start a small business the best place for a young family to [30:14] build their future cities are often pointed to for our [30:17] problems but in Binghamton we're making sure we're known for our Solutions the [30:22] meaningful steps we're taking to revitalize our community [30:25] in cities like Binghamton that give residents the best shot to climb out of [30:30] poverty where artists and entrepreneurs have the greatest chance to thrive it's [30:35] cities like ours that can offer an affordable quality of life and the most [30:39] for everyone who lives here nearly a hundred million dollars [30:43] preparing this budget I asked myself a lot of questions about almost every [30:47] dollar in there doesn't matter to a retiree on the east [30:51] side or a single parent on the south side [30:54] do our policies help make small businesses Thrive do they support [30:58] hard-working homeowners in the neighborhoods they live in does this [31:02] budget make Binghamton Street safer the budget should not be the wishes of [31:07] one elected official which should act on the needs of an [31:10] entire community I heard directly about those needs on [31:14] front porches and at kitchen tables as I campaign last year [31:18] I'm confident this budget reflects those needs [31:21] so with that I present to city council and our citizens binghamton's 2023 [31:26] budget one that both protects the taxpayer and delivers results for the [31:31] great City we all call home thank you very much