[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:01] Good evening and welcome back to tonight's city council meeting. Council members are attending this meeting remotely by video conference. [0:08] Tonight's meeting is available to the public on Channel 8 and through live streaming on Brookfield's website. Public participation is encouraged by calling 855-695-3744 and pressing star 3 to be placed in the queue for comment. [0:23] Please don't if you would like to speak on more than one item on tonight's agenda, you will need to press start three each time to be placed back in the queue for comment. [0:32] Public comment will be taken on agenda items following staff presentations. [0:35] as screeners will ask colors for their first and last name, [0:39] neighborhood and the agenda item that color would like to comment on. [0:42] Please call several minutes before the agenda item and press start 3 to ensure you are in the queue for comment. [0:48] Public comment will also be taken during the public comment section for some of you that are not on tonight's agenda. [0:54] All public comments will be limited to three minutes. [0:57] Again, the number is 855-695-3744 and press start 3 to be placed in the queue. [1:04] The City Council meeting is called order. Will the clerk please call the roll. [1:12] Anderson, [1:27] here. [1:30] Do you start a key? [1:31] Here. [1:34] Law 11. [1:35] Here. [1:37] Lenn. [1:38] Here. [1:40] Lenn said. [1:44] Shath. [1:45] Here. [1:48] Tepie. [1:52] A quorum is present to everyone, please rise and join me for [2:04] the [2:04] Congratulations to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which [2:12] it stands. One nation under God, it has been involved with liberty and justice for all. [2:23] In an effort to keep up tonight's order for tonight's meeting, I has counseled the [2:28] utilize the video conferencing tool through razor hand for comment one and when making [2:32] a motion or a second I will call on the first hand raise, the state, the motion, and the second [2:37] raise to make the second as appropriate. I ask council members to limit their comments to [2:41] five minutes. Abby will be assisting with the timekeeping. We'll provide council members with [2:46] an notification via video conferencing chat when one minute remains. Please ensure you are on the [2:51] mute when not speaking. If a council member needs to leave the meeting, please inform me before doing so. [2:57] We will plan on a 10 minute break at approximately 8 p.m. We will begin with council's review and [3:02] approval of the CVS agenda, Council may add, or remove items with the consent agenda or [3:07] Council may revise the order of business for the meeting. Does any member of the council [3:10] have any additional comments or questions regarding the CVS agenda? The Council member of [3:16] Lyons. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So looking at the consent agenda, there's two, I don't mean to [3:22] prolong our meeting tonight, but there's two issues that I'd like to get a little more [3:26] information on have a staff summary item item 7 B is in beta. I'm sorry I'm sorry 7 C the tech 84 [3:40] body scanner I'd like more information on that and then 7 D the two ordinances oh I'm sorry [3:48] those are first reading never mind I'll just go with 7 C and if possible I could we just keep that at the [3:54] Well, after the consent agenda instead of putting it back at the end of the agenda. [4:05] Yeah, yeah, we are. [4:06] So, does anybody have an objection to move that to the first business item? [4:11] The the tax scanner. [4:15] Raise your hand if you have an objection. [4:16] Otherwise we'll go ahead and move the tax scanner. [4:18] Jennifer, would you be prepared to make a staff presentation on that? [4:24] Yes, sir. [4:24] We will. [4:25] Okay. [4:26] So we will go ahead and move. [4:28] seven C to the first item, you know, of the business agenda. Okay? Any other questions [4:37] comments on the agenda? [4:45] So we'll go ahead and move on. I'm gonna make a note here. [5:04] Okay, [5:04] so there are no conditions that communications this evening. We will move to public comment [5:11] next. This is an opportunity for the public to come in on matters other than the agenda items [5:16] So already, listen on this, if you need to agenda to be placed in the queue for comment, [5:20] please call 855-695-3744 and press star three, public comments will be limited to three [5:28] minutes. [5:30] Okay, we do have one person on them, but they want to talk about 11C. [5:34] I don't see anybody else. [5:37] So we will, [5:42] Gary, does anybody in the queue are mayor-protimenting anybody in the queue? [5:46] Trying to be in the queue? [5:51] No, just the person for 11 team air. [5:54] Okay. [5:54] So we will move to community and event updates are next. [5:58] Does any member of council have an update this evening? [6:10] And I'll go ahead and move on. [6:11] I did want to make a comment about, [6:14] Assembly of the point of view that that we made a cut to be seen this way [6:17] through the Metro Mayor's caucus. [6:19] I wanted to share with council of the Metro, [6:20] a Denver home was the initiative. [6:22] Reach out to bring about contributing to the housing stability [6:24] flexibility fund, which is this household to our experience and housing [6:28] crisis by removing financial barriers that were presented from obtaining or remaining to [6:33] permanent housing, the MTHI provides assistance in Brivil County, we're able to contribute [6:38] to the fund again this year as we have enough of the several years. The fund was, the amount [6:43] of country reasons was $1,000, but I wanted to mention that to Council, because it was through [6:47] the Metro Mayor's Caucus. Gene, I'm excuse me, I can't. Council, I don't know, I think. [6:57] I'm a who has their hand raised there this is council number groom. I just wanted to let you guys know I am on the phone [7:08] So I might be coming across as my regular number [7:13] Okay, so so the council member got [7:17] Council member Grome has has joined the phone call council member chef [7:21] Thank you mayor. I just wanted to point out tomorrow is veterans day this is a [7:27] a special day for my kids and I ever [7:30] This year, since they were well-babies, we've attended the Veterans Day celebration at the [7:38] Brimfield High School auditorium and celebrated with the Brimfield Veterans Memorial Museum. [7:44] This year, it's a little bit different, but just encourage everybody to continue to celebrate [7:50] our veterans and celebrate Veterans Day with our local museum. [7:55] Thank you. [7:58] I'm going to go ahead and do we have one public comment? [8:02] I'm going to go ahead and identify a Jackie State to name your name, full name for the record [8:13] and your neighborhood and it says here that you have a general public comment, not a specific [8:18] agenda item. [8:21] You've been in court spots with council, so I don't know specific agenda item but go ahead [8:24] Jackie. [8:25] You have three minutes. [8:27] Yes. Yes, there are. My name is Jacqueline McClashon and I'm a night senior resident of [8:32] country of states and I'd like to thank you mayor and council for taking my call. I [8:37] thought I've gone to bumper sticker the other day that read, speak out for what is right, [8:42] even if your voice shakes. So here I go and this isn't an agenda item. But because I [8:48] dare to ask a question of you, Mr. Mayor and those on council, if you had any relationship [8:53] with the three candidates you selected for the City and County Attorney position. I received [8:58] the following email from Council Member Hinkle and I quote. I don't find your inquiries appropriate [9:05] considering an easy internet search to see who you work with and the same easy internet search [9:12] could be used to find your answers. I find these emails as an attempt to intimidate our hiring [9:18] process and will not tolerate it. Also, our attorney works for the council, not you, or any [9:26] high donors attempting to influence local campaigns which help. Everything you need to know [9:33] without my connections with any of our attorney candidates can be found online. For all the people [9:40] in the back, tell Steve Reynolds, I say, hello, Heidi in quote, because I dare to ask a question, [9:50] my character and integrity were challenged. [9:53] For Ms. Hinkle to insinuate that these were not my own thoughts, is about the most sexist [9:59] comment I have ever received. Ms. Hinkle's response was totally inappropriate and actually [10:05] quite dysfunctional. Because I dared to ask a question, I was described as intimidating. [10:13] Council members law, Evans, and Gruenham were not intimidated by my questions and responded in a timely [10:18] manner. They were the only ones to reply and I appreciate them taking the time. [10:24] Because I dared to ask a question, my employer was insulted again. For the record, I worked [10:31] Mr. Steve Reynolds, a 60-year resident and supporter of the Bloomfield community, but most alarming [10:38] and of great concern to me because I dared to ask a question I have been threatened by a number [10:43] of counsel. I will continue to ask questions and I dare every resident and Bloomfield employee [10:50] to pay attention and ask questions even if they're both voice shakes. Thank you all very much. [11:01] Thank you. Well, move on to to to to is there any other [11:12] comments from council. [11:16] You mean general comment? No, I'm not. No, I'm talking about, you know, I was my place. We were [11:23] Community and event update. Yeah, we're yes. I lost my place. Okay. Are there any other community and event updates? [11:33] Okay, so let's move on to the consent agenda, following the Courts Readier of Consent [11:38] of Gender 9 of 7A, 7B, 7D, 7E and 7F, we will ask for public comments. [11:44] So will the Courts, please read the agenda of 7A, 7B, 7D, 7E and 7F, by title. [11:54] Approval, then it's mentioned the regular meeting of October 25, 2020. [12:00] 7B, resolution number 2020-249, authorizing the approving and agreement with [12:07] Harris Systems, USAID, for cloud software maintenance and support services. [12:14] 7B, ordinance number 2140, amending section 13-2-010 of the Bruce Bell's Needless [12:22] to change the monthly water service charge at first reading. [12:28] An ordinance number 2141, [12:31] Amendment Section 13-12-020, [12:35] of the broomfield municipal code to change the monthly sewer service [12:38] charge at first reading. [12:41] 7A resolution number 2020-255, [12:45] authorizing and approving an agreement [12:47] by and between the city and county of broomfield [12:50] and molar engineering for the ZNF, pump station, and pipeline for a little area design report. [12:58] And 7F, resolution number 2020-227, a grouping of agreement by in between the city and county [13:06] and room bills and turn to key health clinics LLC for inmate health care services. [13:17] We will now proceed with public comments. [13:20] Does any member of the public have comments on these agenda items? [13:24] I'll please press start three and state your first last name and neighborhood for the record. [13:29] I'm not note in any comments. [13:32] Does any member of Council have the comments or questions on this agenda item? [13:39] Councillor Schaff? [13:42] Thank you, Mayor. [13:43] So this is concerning the agenda item 7F. [13:47] The agreement would turn key health for inmate health care. [13:50] So it may have been this last month. It could have been two months of kind of last track of time during this COVID period. [13:57] Or I should say I lose track of the time during this COVID period many times. [14:02] But we took a tour of it. I got to take a tour of the detention center as many of you council members did as well. [14:09] And one of the places that I had gone that I hadn't gone before was the inmate health care section of the detention center. [14:18] There I am, got to learn from many of the staff that work there at the detention center [14:22] about why this is a crucial service for our inmates as well as our staff there at the [14:29] detention center. So I just wanted to say that I fully support this, I fully support that we [14:35] continue to provide health care at our detention center. And I have reached out to the chief [14:41] to start discussing about the possibility of adding dental care to the detention center as well. [14:47] And I hope at some point that we can continue that conversation because that is one area that is lacking in our detention center and and would really ensure that when our inmates are released. [15:00] That there are released in a very healthy way. That's all I have. Thanks, Mayor. Thank you. [15:09] Okay. [15:13] So any of the questions or comments? [15:21] Is there a motion to, is there a motion that the recommendations contain in the staff reports for agenda item 7A, 7B, 7D, 7E, and 7F, be a prouke. [15:34] Casper shaft. [15:35] Don't move. [15:37] Casper 11's. [15:38] Second. [15:39] Will the clerk please call or is there any further discussion? [15:44] Will the clerk please call the roll? [15:54] Can we help him? [15:56] Yes. [15:58] Brune. [16:00] Yes. [16:02] Tango. [16:03] Yes. [16:05] Dividing. [16:06] Yes. [16:08] Law haven't. [16:10] Yes. [16:12] Law haven't. [16:12] lamb, yes, [16:15] lunch set. Yes, [16:22] yes, [16:22] heavy. [16:23] Yes, [16:27] it passes unanimously. [16:29] So we'll move on to, [16:31] there is no business. [16:32] Tonight, before the Board of Social, [16:33] her special service, [16:34] social services. [16:36] This evening, [16:37] we have one item for the Board of Health, [16:38] the COVID-19 update, [16:40] the meeting of the Board of Health is called, [16:42] the Order of Alaska, [16:43] the Clerk to call the roll. [16:44] Anderson [16:50] here. [17:04] You're. [17:08] You're. [17:09] My name is. [17:12] You're. [17:13] Lamb. [17:15] Here. [17:17] Let's set. [17:18] Here. [17:20] Chef. [17:21] Here. [17:23] Happy A. [17:25] Here. [17:25] A corn is present, board members have a copy of the agenda memorandum, which staff will [17:31] summarize. [17:32] You also got the presentation today. [17:34] So [17:37] thank you, Mayor, and for this Director of Public Health, Jason Falling, Jason. [17:45] Yeah, good evening, Mayor, Mayor of Pentemong, Council members, it's the pleasure to be in [17:52] of you again today to provide an update on our COVID situation. This is very timely given what's [18:01] happening in the state in the Denver Metro region. You have a memorandum in front of you [18:08] the outlines a lot of the topics that I'll cover but I wanted to specifically go through this [18:15] presentation and hit some of the key points. So if we could go to the next slide. [18:24] So it [18:24] just as a reminder, Brimfield was categorized into level orange that used to be referred [18:31] to level three by the state on November 26. And the reason for this is they have specific [18:39] threshold that they're monitoring. One is our two-week case incidence rate. That's how much [18:47] the virus is circulating in the county. [18:52] We are obviously, and I'm going to go into this later [18:56] beyond orange in that specific metric. Our percent positivity in this looks at whether there is [19:04] efficient COVID testing to capture the level of virus transmission and in [19:12] level orange, the threshold is no greater than 15% and then finally [19:17] impact on hospitalizations and whether we're seeing an increase in [19:24] stable or declining hospitalizations over a 14 day period, so if we could go [19:28] the next slide. [19:33] So I wanted to talk a little about Colorado Daily case counts. So we've [19:38] surpassed the March levels of our cases. And the first thing this chart shows you is the [19:48] positive cases that have been identified through tests. In March, we know we had way more cases [19:56] than we could detect because there was enough tests available. [20:01] We estimated back in that time we had 10 times as many cases as we were testing. [20:09] But as we started to form contracts with private countries and scaling testing around [20:14] me and June, we ramped up our testing. [20:18] And what we're seeing is as we're looking at the level of virus, [20:25] that is significantly increasing in the state of Colorado. [20:31] So next slide. [20:36] And Brimfield's daily case counts continue to rise [20:39] similar with the metro region. [20:41] What you can see is how quickly and significantly [20:45] are three day and seven day moving averages of cases have gone up. [20:51] And this is extremely concerning to us. [20:55] And we were in the late summer, early polymons. [21:01] We were averaging between 3 to 8 cases. [21:06] Now we're up to average, or around 25 cases. [21:13] And then what that means is we definitely [21:17] do suspect that there's community level transmission happening. [21:22] And so if you go to the next slide, and to further indicate this, this just shows the [21:30] level levels that are according to the state dial. [21:37] R2-week case incidents on 117 was 494.6. [21:44] As of today, it went up to 500.3. [21:48] that back on 117, that was the equivalent to 350 cases in the past two weeks. [21:56] Just by comparison, there were a total of 350 total cases for a March 19 to July 12. [22:04] So you can see how significantly this has been doubling and increasing in our community. [22:10] And on October 24th, the TV case incident was 223 cases per 100,000, obviously where we're at now is 120% increase from October 24th to November 7th. [22:27] And next slide. [22:30] Additionally, we're seeing that our two-week percent positivity rate is going up. [22:39] And we were well below that 5% threshold for a significant period of time, but as we've seen cases going up, we've seen our level of positivity go up. [22:51] The reason that this measure is so important is if you have sufficient testing, which there is indicators that we do have available testing in the community, but you're still seeing your level of [23:06] percent positivity going up. That's a good indicator that you're again seeing community level transmission. [23:16] And we haven't exceeded the level yellow or level orange threshold yet, but I can tell you that the entire state is extremely concerned about the [23:31] percent positivity that we're seeing next slide. [23:38] So one thing I really wanted to highlight is the fact that [23:43] most of our counties actually, this is not just a [23:47] broomfield phenomenon, this is happening in the vast majority of [23:53] the state, but specifically in the Denver Metro region and the [23:58] the front range. And we're seeing our most high two-week case incidents rates specifically in the [24:07] Denver metro region. And so that's concerning for us because we know with increased cases [24:15] leads to increased hospitalizations, which then leads to discussions we're going to have played [24:23] later about hospital capacity, [24:27] so 53 counties or in local mitigation efforts were one of those counties, [24:31] I'll talk about our efforts later. And again, 28 counties are within the state at home levels of [24:39] of incidents. And I got to tell you that when we looked at this framework as a state, [24:45] we were fairly conservative of what that threshold should be to go into a state at home. And so [24:51] It's extremely concerning to see what's happening. [24:55] Next slide. [25:00] So this slide can be a little bit confusing, [25:03] but this chart also shows the predicted number of cases [25:07] according to hospitalizations. [25:10] So we can more readily measure the number of hospitalizations [25:14] because they are not dependent on testing capacity. [25:18] Note the different scales on each vertical axis. [25:21] cases, left access or scale per 100,000, [25:26] whereas hospitalizations, right, access or not. [25:30] We know that based on these projections, [25:33] we've already exceeded our April peak of hospitalizations. [25:39] And also important to note is the red dotted lines [25:42] represent our hospitalizations peak [25:45] back in the spring and our ICU bed capacity. [25:50] And when you look at the slide, what's most concerning to me is work quickly approaching [25:57] or I believe we've surpassed now that hospital peak that we had, and the next step [26:06] is looking at our hospital capacity and I see a capacity and ability to manage that next [26:12] So [26:16] we often hear, is this just a young adult phenomenon and should we really be looking [26:24] at mitigation efforts, the impact, the entire population? [26:31] Well, that was so much true when we saw early on the cases in Boulder and other communities, [26:40] Denver and even here in Brunefield with that 20 to 39 year old age group. What you can see now [26:48] is that we're having cases rise in all age groups. Even more concerning though when you [26:56] look at this data is the fact that our hospitalizations are also rising in all age groups. [27:06] What's concerning to us is to see the hospitalizations in the 65 plus because we know some of the significant outcomes that can happen as a result of that specific age group being hospitalized, but it's also surprising to see the trending line with our 40 to 64 year old age group in the level of hospitalizations occurring there. [27:35] Next slide, [27:40] and this is not unique again to just the state. [27:46] Brumfeld is part of the North Central region. [27:50] And the reason that we, like at the North Central region in data versus just [27:55] Brumfeld hospital data is because we're all reliant on the hospital system in the [28:07] that we look at the total number of hospitalizations, [28:14] those confirmed cases that are were hospitalized from COVID, [28:18] and those persons under investigation that have been hospitalized. [28:23] What you can see again is that we're quickly approaching [28:28] where we were back in April in May. [28:33] We've heard from our North Central region partners [28:36] that ICU bed capacity is at 82.5% and bedelator capacity is at 25% the ICU bed capacity is one [28:48] measure that we're continuing to look at and that's a measure that we're seeing as being impacted [28:56] ventilator occupancy not so much but the more important issue I really want to focus on [29:02] we're hearing this directly and we heard it on our town hall is when a yet community-wide transmission [29:09] our hospital systems are extremely worried about staffing and the staffing projected to hit [29:17] critical levels in the next week. So what that means is they could have shortages and staffing [29:23] in the hospital system doing due to quarantines and also just due to the shifts how much they are [29:32] working. Also primary care, primary shortage areas are ICU, critical care nurses. That's [29:40] what we're hearing the most. And only 18% of staff die-see beds are currently available. [29:48] So as we go through this, I think it's important for us also to realize that a neurosensial [29:55] region does not only accept patients from the Denver Metro region. [30:00] F patients that are transferred in from counties across the state and we're also having patients transferred in from counties or other states. [30:12] So when we look at, well, we could just increase our hospital staffing capacity. All of our states are going through this, which will make it extremely difficult. Next slide. [30:24] So, one thing that the School of Public Health puts out is looking at what is our modeling [30:35] estimate of when we can potentially exceed ICU bed capacity, and again they use that count [30:44] of 1800. [30:49] This bottle shows that we can potentially exceed [30:56] ICU hospital capacity in late December. And the reason for that is due to the fact [31:06] that we're seeing less transmission control happening in our community. Some of [31:13] That's due to COVID fatigue, some of it is due to lack of mask wearing, some of it is doing [31:24] to less social distancing that's occurring in certain populations. [31:30] And the thing that we're really concerned about, especially with holiday season coming up [31:36] is if we see additional spikes where we're at in this baseline. [31:40] And so you can see with that 10% reduction or the 20% reduction, where that puts us with ICU bed capacity. [31:50] There also has been some information shared from the School of Public Health that we could even breach ICU bed capacity in early December. [31:59] And that's why the governor and others are encouraging people to limit their interactions only to household members, [32:07] and with holiday gathering specifically thanksgiving trying to keep those very limited as well. [32:16] Next slide. [32:20] So what does level orange mean? We've put a lot of this guidance out to the [32:28] our sectors, our communications team has been amazing, sharing this information out through all [32:36] our media channels, our economic vitality group has been heavily involved in reaching out to sectors [32:45] to say, what is the shift to level orange mean? And you can see what it is specifically on [32:54] this. One thing that I do want to note is specifically with schools and schools were the one [33:03] where we were really hoping and trying to keep community transmission down because we knew the [33:10] importance of keeping kids in school. Adam's 12 has decided to go fully remote and Boulder Valley [33:19] School District is discussing what their Board of Education's night, the possibility of switching [33:26] to remote as well. So, obviously, as we see high community level transmission impacts our ability [33:35] to effectively operate schools. Next slide, [33:43] so what are we doing? We've been doing these [33:46] mitigation strategies over the last three weeks. One is promoting our reverse-the-trend [33:54] campaign. This has been very successful and being run out of our communications department. [34:02] A second thing, and I think it was Council Member Evans, brought this up last time, is having [34:08] people sign up for the Colorado Exposure notification app. The reason that's so important is that [34:15] if you have your blue tooth on and you're around somebody that tests positive, there's an exchange [34:21] of tokens and from there, you can be notified that you were around somebody that was positive [34:28] and then it gives you the steps that you need to take to potentially either isolate or go get [34:39] tested. And then rampal of applying the governor's message. During this time, it's absolutely [34:51] of state distance and treat everyone like they have COVID-19. They've said in the Denver area [34:57] you could estimate that 1 in 100 people have COVID-19. So if you think throughout your day, [35:04] having a people you may be interacting with, the idea is to treat everyone like they may have it [35:09] and then most importantly as we've talked about is wedding masks. We have increased the number of [35:16] people tested through our HHS clinic by almost 100 people over the past two weeks. [35:24] We're working as quickly as possible around the clock to add a second testing day in December. [35:31] And then we're partnering with CDPHE to increase testing access, healthcare provider settings, and at long term care facilities. [35:41] With epidemiology, we continue to like a EP trends and data, but I got to tell you with the EP trends for finding that it's harder and harder to pinpoint where those specific sources are for people I have been exposed. [35:59] Just due to that community transmission, we're working with CDPAT to implement technology [36:06] solutions that will streamline our contact tracing both internally, but with other [36:12] health departments across the state, and then we're redeploying public health staff [36:18] to assist with our additional case-loading contact tracing. [36:24] And then finally, with enforcement and compliance, we're taking a very proactive compliance [36:29] checks approach to, in addition to our complaint-based approach. [36:35] Just to go out and see what's happening in the community, and then as I mentioned, [36:39] before developing that sector-specific outreach. [36:44] Next slide. [36:48] So, the key takeaways, the epidemic has significantly worsened the past few weeks, [36:54] and especially in the past few days. [36:56] And we're seeing it in the Metro region and in the room film. [36:59] Infection risk is increasing in at risk population. [37:04] That's absolutely what we didn't want to get back to, [37:07] unfortunately we're there. [37:10] We're entering the holiday season with the surge, as I mentioned before. [37:16] So holiday travel will be riskier than travel over the summer [37:20] in contact among people not in the same household should be minimized. [37:25] We need to protect our older family members and friends as we go. [37:30] Through this period of high community transmission. And then we are going to continually closely monitor the data and the impact of the mitigation strategies that we're having during the next two weeks. [37:44] And see the, hopefully we could see us begin to flatten that curve or even start to reverse the curve, both in case counts in our percent positivity. [37:59] But I got to share with you, similar to where we were at back in April. [38:05] or sorry March April and May is at a point when you are beyond your testing capacity and beyond [38:15] your epic capacity with community spread. That's when we have to start and we're looking [38:21] at some of our other lovers and some of those policy lovers. And I just want to do share some [38:27] of the other policy options that are being explored in the Denver Measure Region. We know to [38:34] counties have enacted curfews. We didn't fill based on the evidence and also based on the [38:45] will of our community to have another order like that that that made sense for Brunefield. [38:54] A second thing is Denver and Adams County are limiting alcohol sales to 10 p.m. [39:03] not only in bars with last call, but also in grocery stores and liquor stores. [39:10] We're not seeing as much of that as far as people that are going to restaurants and [39:20] then hitting the liquor store and going home. [39:24] But if we do see more of that that would obviously impact our decision. [39:29] Some counties are looking at canceling recreational sports or limiting spectators at youth sports and other counties are looking at reducing indoor and outdoor gathering sizes. [39:47] And our communications team has really developed the, as I mentioned, the reverse the trend campaign and no spread November, but you can see through all of our social media channels and last slide. [40:03] So you can always find more information on broomfield.org COVID. This has all of our latest up to date data information about testing sites. [40:15] We're really promoting, again, the phone app that Colorado has out there to stop the spread. [40:23] And then we have our Brim filled weekly scorecard that anybody can review and see where we're specifically to be as transparent as possible. [40:31] And with that, that concludes my presentation. [40:36] Thank you. [40:37] So we'll go to public comments if there's anyone who would like to be heard, please press star three. [40:42] State University last name and neighborhood for the record. [40:48] I'm not noting anybody specifically that's here for this item. [40:55] So I will keep my eye on it. [40:57] Mayor Pro Temo as well. [40:59] I'll go to questions from the board. [41:01] Are there any questions from the board? [41:03] Raise your hand. [41:05] Board member Leavance. [41:07] Thank you, Chair. [41:09] Jason, thank you for this update as concerning as it is. [41:13] I wanted to share a couple of thoughts. [41:17] I had to recently wipe everything off my phone [41:21] and reinstall everything. [41:22] It was a really fun process, [41:24] but I did have to re-enable the COVID exposure notification. [41:30] So if anybody else has that, please, [41:32] please remember to do that. [41:34] And as I said last time we discussed this, [41:36] I know that there are people who consider this [41:39] to be an invasion of privacy or something like that, [41:42] but you're already being tracked by the virtue of having a smart phone, just go ahead and do it [41:48] because at least this is tracking for a noble cause to try and keep people yourself included, [41:56] myself included, healthy, as opposed to just tracking you to sell you more stuff. [42:02] I would also note that I watched Church Online again last week, or I think this was a week ago's [42:10] message. And this is the mental health implications of this continue to be huge. And my church [42:18] flyer and community church in Lafayette, Esther Jim noted that in the past three months, [42:25] they've done nine funerals for suicides. So continue to, let's all continue to try and be [42:32] kind to each other. And certainly I need to remember that as much as anyone and help your neighbors [42:38] when you can, any little virtual communication, [42:41] sometimes reaching out will just help a lot. [42:46] So we are, as Council Member Tessia is fond of saying, [42:49] we are all in this together and it's, we're not done yet, [42:54] just because we've got good information on the vaccine, [42:56] doesn't mean we're not, not, we have a road to go through. [43:01] Jason, I did have one question. [43:02] And when I look at the national map of where the virus is most prevalent right now, Colorado [43:11] strangely enough is not one of the worst states. [43:14] Kind of the upper Midwest tends to be right now they're having incidents rates of 1,000 per [43:20] 100,000 in Wisconsin and places like that. [43:24] But it does seem to be, to my untuderdite, it looks like it's clustered in that upper Midwest [43:30] kind of cold planes region is how I think of it. Do we know, is it just random that this is happening [43:39] in places where it's cold and dry right now or or is there an epidemiological [43:47] impetus behind that and why Florida and Arizona are not seeing these things spike right now [43:54] such as the Upper Midwest, is any thoughts on that? [43:57] Yeah, I appreciate that question, council member, live and actually I just received some new data [44:06] to show that Colorado is moving in the top 25% as far as. [44:11] Oh, joy. Yeah, hospitalizations and caseloads. So we're definitely trending in the wrong direction. [44:20] And, you know, we've heard the situation in the Midwest and this is happening, primarily, I believe Colorado is three to four weeks behind some of these other northern states that obviously were moving indoors sooner. [44:41] There's other factors that could obviously come into play with some of those states that [44:48] while we're seeing specifically in Utah. [44:54] We've seen this in North Dakota [44:57] We're also starting to hear about [45:00] This in Nebraska is the idea of having to pull back on elective surgeries due to the overwhelming hospital demand. [45:12] You know, we've always said our North Star is we don't want to be back to that point that those people that do need care if you were going in, like such as my dad who has heart disease and needs to get care and unfortunately I never hope this happens but had another heart attack. [45:29] and we have beds full, what that would mean. [45:32] So this isn't just those people in code that have COVID [45:35] that are impacting ICU, that capacity it impacts us home. [45:40] Indeed, thank you for that. [45:42] I'll just take one of their brief anecdote. [45:44] My stepmother, who is a native New Zealander, [45:47] goes home for back to New Zealand for the holidays, [45:50] most of years. [45:52] And this year, she had to go through a whole extra process. [45:55] She's leaving in about two and a half, three weeks. [45:58] She'll have to get a COVID test when she leaves, get on the plane, get there, and then in New Zealand, [46:03] they're having everyone quarantine for two weeks in a hotel, paid for by the government. [46:08] So she'll be home with her family and whatnot, but won't be able to see them for two weeks. [46:14] So I guess when you're in Ireland, literally, you can handle things differently, but Colorado's [46:18] not in that position. So thank you very much for all your hard work, Jason. [46:22] and prayers for your debt too. [46:25] Thank you. [46:26] That's what we're just thirsty. [46:28] Thank you. [46:29] And to continue with that, [46:30] I had to come to number 11s. [46:33] Even if I wanted to New York is requiring a two week quarantine [46:37] for people that are coming from out of states, [46:38] and that's where my immediate family is from. [46:42] So if I wanted to go back to New York for the holidays, [46:44] they probably are going to be, unfortunately. [46:47] So anyways, Jason, thank you for the presentation. [46:49] very informative as usual. As you know, like my kids are in the Adam 12 schools, my younger [46:56] starter was very bummed yesterday, or I put him in two days ago now, but she found out that [47:00] the schools were, you know, her school was being closed down, but I get it though. I mean, [47:04] it weren't starting to be some cases there that they had been lucky for the first month or so, [47:09] but if they had three or four cases in the last week or two, so, um, disappointing, but it's what it [47:15] as I guess at this point. [47:17] A couple of questions I have that has us some snippets from Polis [47:20] is last governor's last briefing on this. [47:24] You seem to be a little more positive if I'm the hospital's [47:27] situation is it better in the rest of the state [47:29] than it is up here in the north or in my day and in [47:32] October that wrong. [47:34] So yeah, he was talking about the ability to [47:38] look at standing up alternate care sites. [47:42] And while that's good, because it does expand hospital capacity, one of the challenges with that is the level of care that can be delivered in those alternate care sites. [47:55] And so I also didn't notice that. [47:59] He was a little bit more positive about that, [48:03] But everything that I've heard from those individuals in the hospital system goes back to when I was sharing before that just a level of concern, even if we were able to stand up those alternate care sites, do we have the ability to bring in qualified personnel to actually staff them. [48:26] I think that makes sense. I mean, I have the size, but the level of care may not be the same as if they were in an actual hospital. So, okay, get that one thing I just surprised me was there's a very much positivity regarding a possible vaccine and I think he mentioned by the end of the year possible. So I was shocked to hear that. That's great. It's true. I was wondering if you've any comments is that realistic or not from what you're hearing. [48:51] Yeah, so obviously the governor is optimistic about this when I'm hearing from leading scientists across the nation, Dr. Pouchy and others, they're very optimistic. [49:06] It still has to go through the final FDA approval and emergency use authorization. [49:15] That being said, if it does, has that Colorado does anticipate that we could start to [49:22] receive our first vaccine doses and make December and from their start vaccinating our [49:31] chair one groups, which includes health care professionals, first responders, and as we get [49:41] more and more vaccines being able to go down to our tier two and and chair three, the full hope [49:48] would be by March and April we would be able to do broader vaccination in the community, [49:55] And I think the one thing that we are a little bit excited about with this is the partnership [50:02] specifically with the pharmacies and the providers. So instead of having a shift directly to [50:11] local public health or state public health to get out, they're doing the distribution directly [50:17] to those pharmacies centers, which kids speed up the process and make sure that we get people [50:24] back then. So I think it's that that's great. And I was, you know, [50:28] sounds like you think that that's a realistic time when I get that's nothing [50:32] is for sure in this world, but I don't know, two months goes by really fast. [50:37] So when I heard that I was like, whoa, as wait, what may sooner than I was expecting [50:40] than I had to get that ball rolling, but I'm happy to hear that that's [50:44] a possibility, at least, it's a realistic possibility. [50:46] That's awesome. And they thought something that we're doing that we're [50:49] working towards the increased testing and we talked about that last time and [50:52] I hope we're able to get that extra day in there, I'm starting in December. [50:56] And although the last comment I want to make, and this is with that app, which I haven't had a chance to do now. [51:02] I could say that there was a little bit of a concern for me. [51:05] It's not a privacy concern, but it's sort of the concern. [51:08] It's because it's my understanding that if you just brush somebody and public your chances of getting catching COVID, [51:14] it's really slim in the real risk. [51:16] And I think you mentioned this before, and I've seen this written. [51:18] the real risk is that it's long term in door setting and if you're sitting in with your family [51:23] or other friends or hopefully not a restroom, but you know the indoor setting with long term [51:29] up to 15 minutes is where the real risk is. [51:33] So I guess my concern is that I get the help I burst by somebody, I get notification, that's [51:38] why I start panicking and not knowing at all where the context of the exposure and it may [51:45] I've been very brief and very innocent and I mean, [51:48] Leslie put me being sick from it or probably super small. [51:52] Yeah, it's going to cross me to panic. [51:54] So, that's why I'm a little concerned about that. [51:56] So, I don't know where, yeah, I get there a problem. [51:58] Maybe the positive is not the way that those type of negatives, [52:01] but that's what I'm feeling about that was like, [52:04] I don't want to be panic. [52:05] If I'm getting things every day. [52:08] Yeah, council member, Jessica, let me verify [52:11] that when they exchange those tokens, [52:13] if it's for a certain period of time, or if it's just a brief interaction, because I think that [52:19] obviously would address your question. [52:22] I appreciate that, because I'm a few of those of you who have something to say, Deb, Deb, Deb, as well. [52:27] I'm sorry, this is Deb Fetter's spelled WD Public Health. [52:30] Director, I was just going to confirm that the app does have the ability to record cumulative [52:39] 15-minute interaction. So if you just walk by someone, you're not going to get that notification, [52:45] you have to have accumulated that 15-minute duration. [52:50] Okay. Well, that's good to know because, right? I mean, that way, I know if I did get it [52:55] I think it's real as serious and I should pay attention to it as opposed to I don't know how [53:00] being the supermarket and I you know walk by somebody at all a sudden I'm getting a ding [53:04] and then I'm like I have no idea what this kind of sex is and it may be real but it may not be real [53:09] but if I know that's I get the ding as a good chance that it is real and that's then I know that's [53:14] to take that seriously. Okay great thank you appreciate that. That's my overall. [53:22] Thank you chair and thank you Jason and I'm sorry, Mayor. Jason I have two questions in the kind of multiplied part each and you please feel free to get back to me. [53:36] My concern, and I know I've mentioned it before, is the difference, what is the difference [53:43] between the two peaks? [53:44] So for instance, in April, our cases at our peak on a seven day average was 10 cases per [53:54] 100,000, but in that same day in April, the deaths were on the seven day rolling average again [54:03] was 34 cases per 100,000, but yet in this current peak cases are going up extraordinary. So, [54:14] where before it was 10 cases per 100,000 on the seven-day rolling average, now we're at 56.4, [54:21] which is a significant change and impact in the amount of cases. However, the deaths on the [54:33] What I'm looking for is, can you articulate the difference between the two right now or [54:39] case is that it is that a crazy high, but yeah, it seems like the deaths are thankfully [54:49] significantly very low. So we've kind of flipped, and that would be my first question, and I'm [54:57] not sure if you guys need to get back to me on that, or what is your first thought? [55:01] I'm why are we not seeing the death rate like we were before? [55:07] As council member Graham, thank you for that question and we definitely will follow up with you [55:13] with more detailed information. Again, my hypothesis is when we saw cases during the first spike, [55:23] we were significantly undercounting in that bench translated again into [55:30] as focusing more on hospitalizations and then how hospitalizations contributed to death. [55:40] The thing that we're seeing right now is a better capture. There's still maybe some slight [55:47] under-reporting of cases. Hospitalizations is always that key measure. And then we know that deaths [55:56] or a lagging measure, but we also have a lot of improvements in our treatment of COVID when [56:04] people were in the hospitals. So when we were in the March April timeframe, you know, a lot of [56:11] what we were doing was care that was being done honestly with us, making just the best decisions, [56:23] the information we had at that point in time, with the revdesa there and in other things coming [56:30] out, we're seeing or helping to prevent those people that are a hospitalized going to death [56:37] is really important. I do think it's important though that I talked about this a little bit before [56:46] that our greatest concern is a only deaths for people that are a hospitalized or people that come [56:53] down with COVID, we're hearing a lot again about those long haulers, those people that have the [57:00] chronic health effects associated with COVID and that are not able to return to baseline [57:07] health. And so there's both a mortality issue associated with it that there's a quality of life [57:16] issue associated with it. And when we talk about those individuals that cannot [57:23] retain their same level of lung capacity or those individuals that may have cognitive impairments [57:33] individuals that may see more significant damage to certain organs in the body. Those are [57:44] the other impacts that I think gets important as this virus is completely novel and new that we're [57:50] to be learning about more and more and hopefully we balance both the deaths with the quality [58:00] of light impacts of this virus. [58:03] To you have a, what is the percentage of cases that are classified as this percentage of [58:09] quality of life? [58:11] I can tell you, obviously I've experienced it, but other people that is in my world, again, [58:17] And that's my limited filter in my world. [58:21] Sometimes, our definitely not extreme. [58:26] So, I guess I would be looking for [58:29] what is that factoring versus, and again, [58:34] I'm not looking to turn us in a different direction. [58:37] I mean, we gotta get this controlled. [58:39] I'm looking at, is there any different way [58:42] we can look at the statistics to improve our situation? [58:44] So that's why I'm asking, and then my other question is in regards to symptomatics. [58:53] It seems like to me, we really don't have control over what the main symptoms of COVID is. [59:00] We've came out really strong with this fever thing, but it's a 50-50 toss-up, as someone [59:07] with COVID has a fever. [59:09] But yet, getting out of plane, they, you know, will check your temperature, you know, going into work space, they check your temperature. [59:19] But with that being a 50-50 coin toss, I'm not quite sure that's the right direction. [59:25] We should be telling people, are we anywhere closer to narrowing down symptoms of COVID uniqueness of symptoms with COVID? [59:34] So we can change that word, change the fever part to a lot of people are still going around going well. [59:43] I didn't feel well, but I didn't have a fever so I didn't even get check for COVID. [59:47] Yeah, it's a good point. [59:50] Council member Graham, and that's something that continues to evolve as we as both the epidemiology and the literature evolves in this. [1:00:00] We know that temperatures were the major focus early on. We've gone away from that to listing all of the potential COVID symptoms that we feel are validated, [1:00:13] through the medical community and in the literature. [1:00:18] Those are all posted on our website. [1:00:21] It includes fatigue, diarrhea, body aches, [1:00:24] shortness of breath, headaches. [1:00:26] One we often hear is loss of taste and smell. [1:00:30] Sort of throat. [1:00:31] Unfortunately. [1:00:32] The loss of taste and smell is pretty much [1:00:35] a last of your symptoms. [1:00:38] Like the symptoms change. [1:00:40] I think we need to narrow in on what are the first [1:00:42] indicator symptoms. Majority of people, again, in my filter, I know it's extremely small, [1:00:48] based on the data that you're looking at, lots of taste and smell didn't come until the end. [1:00:54] And then, so that was my point, and then I am significantly out of time, but I did want to [1:01:00] leave you with one last question. It still seems like the top three-year four counties in Colorado [1:01:07] are making up greater than 75, if not 90% of the cases. What is dimmer, a Rappelhoge Jefferson, [1:01:16] those types of counties doing? What are the indicators? I mean, they are like 100 times more [1:01:22] than room-filled cases. What are they doing in those specific counties in order to control it? [1:01:30] because they seem to be the leading of Colorado [1:01:34] and the rest of us are kind of paying for their sins. [1:01:39] Yeah, Councilmember Grimm. [1:01:42] Well, one thing is we're all in this together [1:01:44] in the Metro region and I do get your point. [1:01:47] But the second thing I already alluded to [1:01:50] the policy interventions, the Denver and Adams County [1:01:55] have pursued such as curfews [1:01:58] limiting alcohol and sales and in other measures. So I'll be happy to make sure I [1:02:05] sense it out of time. Yeah, I'll look with you directly to get you that information. [1:02:10] I greatly appreciate it. Thank you for you and your team's work. I appreciate you guys. [1:02:14] Bye-bye. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Mayor. [1:02:18] Thank you, Mayor. So I just got an update to Mr. Valley in the school board meeting, [1:02:24] BBSD superintendent recommended preschool through 12th grade switch remotes, only next Tuesday. [1:02:34] So it looks like BBSD will be joined in the other metro school districts in going to [1:02:40] remote only. [1:02:41] So that is a disappointment, you know, we we in Brumfield and we as BBSD and many of the counties [1:02:47] have worked really hard to keep our numbers low so that our students could be in school. [1:02:51] So it looks like the last of these school districts does fall, which is disappointing, but it is where we are and we've got to reverse this trend. [1:03:01] You know, there is a lot of misconception regarding the positive cases of the asymptomatic versus the symptomatic. [1:03:09] could you talk as you've done that contact tracing? What is the breakdown for those positive cases [1:03:17] for people that are experiencing symptoms versus people that aren't experiencing symptoms? Is it 50-50 [1:03:22] or what's that split? Yeah, actually I'm going to lie at Dr. Abina address that. So I [1:03:29] pressed the one to take that. All right, so I was late. I was actually at that bold valley school [1:03:35] domestic meeting where they made that decision. [1:03:39] So, so I've started for being late. [1:03:40] The answer to your question is, we don't know. [1:03:43] We are in the national data and international data, [1:03:45] as well as some of the stuff studies we've seen across the country. [1:03:49] We estimate asymptomatic areas to be about 30 to 40%. [1:03:56] Now, what happens a lot in our contact tracing [1:03:59] is that people don't recognize they have minor symptoms. [1:04:02] They might have the sniffles, [1:04:03] But they don't really count that as a symptom. They may feel kind of achy. And so the challenge is [1:04:09] as we can't, they call that asymptomatic, but it really isn't asymptomatic. So the answer to your [1:04:14] question is a difficult one, but we estimate anywhere between 30 and 40 percent to be asymptomatic. [1:04:24] So I just want to clarify Dr. Abina. So you said that they're not truly asymptomatic though. [1:04:29] Can you talk about some of those maybe more mild symptoms that are being experienced and maybe [1:04:34] that may be being overlooked. [1:04:38] Sure. Well, we try not to overlook anything, council, council person, chef. [1:04:44] And I should have clarified being overlooked by the individual themselves, not by the medical professional. [1:04:50] Sure. So I think you're right. Generally, we see upper respiratory infections. [1:04:56] Upper respiratory symptoms like sore throat, congestion, achy feeling fatigue, headache. [1:05:02] You know, those are, those are really, and I heard the question by another council person earlier, [1:05:08] is that those are the usual early signs, the mild respiratory, upper respiratory symptoms, [1:05:13] sometimes nausea, vomiting, achy feeling, sometimes diarrhea. All of those are the mild symptoms [1:05:19] with people just say, well, it's just the, it's just a common occurrence. I get this symptoms every year. [1:05:25] So, it isn't until we know for sure, and sometimes that, uh, loss of taste or smell can be the [1:05:32] symptom to people present, and they have no other symptoms. So it isn't a late symptom. [1:05:36] It's can be at any time during it depends on the individual. And that's the challenge with [1:05:41] this infection has so many effects on different organs that we can't tell you exactly. And that's [1:05:47] why we encourage people to get tested when they have symptoms. They've come in contact with an [1:05:52] individual or they've been to exposed in an area that has high prevalence of the infection. [1:05:58] Great. Thank you. So the last piece that I would throw out there is, you know, following [1:06:05] up on Dr. Irbina, is with those mild symptoms. We've talked a little bit about the [1:06:09] different testing sites that are available. Mr. Rowling, could you recommend, or what, what [1:06:15] testing facilities would you recommend for room fields resident? Yeah. So obviously, we've been [1:06:23] doing outreach to our partners, specifically our health care facilities to see what testing [1:06:33] they're providing and what those options are. That's something we would be happy to prepare [1:06:39] for council. [1:06:43] The one thing that we heard is we did that outreach is the reason our HHS site is [1:06:49] So popular is when you're going through some of those other sites, some of the, you gotta have that virtual visit first and then you have to schedule a time. [1:07:01] thing sometimes if you're doing the PCR test you're waiting could be two to four days to [1:07:08] get your results back and we see our HHS testing the energy testing just being a complement to [1:07:17] that for those individuals that are positive. We do have all of the testing sites up on our website. [1:07:24] I can share with you that I have been having conversations. [1:07:30] Correctly with CDPHE, Boulder County Public Health and Trich County Public Health of what can we do to bring [1:07:38] a community testing site up to more of the Westminster Brimfield Boulder location. And that would be [1:07:49] something that they would specifically take on the challenge, will be finding a location that's [1:07:56] that's suitable for that, and we're in very initial discussions, but given that we are one [1:08:03] of the hot spots in the state, along with older in Adams, hopefully that can help us [1:08:09] with some of that testing capacity as well. [1:08:12] Great. [1:08:13] Thank you so much. [1:08:13] Appreciate it. [1:08:14] That's all I have, Mayor. [1:08:15] Thank you. [1:08:16] Good. [1:08:17] Mayor. [1:08:17] Thank you, Mayor. [1:08:20] Mr. Belling or Dr. Orbina, how do we combat the dangerous and false information coming from the top that are trying to play it down, say, I got it, I was fine or denying that it's as bad as it is or that masks don't work, how do we combat the misinformation and the disinformation that is being spread by some leaders. [1:08:49] I find it really irresponsible and I just want to call that out because, you know, just because [1:08:56] you had a mild experience in no way makes this pandemic, this virus less dangerous. [1:09:04] And I would like you to comment on that, please. [1:09:08] Yeah, thank you, Councilmember Kestriata and as you know, public health, we go based on the science [1:09:17] and the data, and I'm excited to see that there will be an embrace of the national level [1:09:26] of those public health scientists to get our messaging out and hopefully a national strategy. [1:09:37] The other thing that I think is very important to us is that we're very honest too with what [1:09:45] we know is that we do know that people that have COVID, [1:09:50] some will have mild symptoms and they'll recover, [1:09:53] but others won't. [1:09:54] And so we have to be very objective and direct in [1:10:00] in what our data and our research shows. [1:10:03] And what we know is the most effective mitigation [1:10:07] strategies that we have. [1:10:10] So that's my response to that. [1:10:12] and that's one thing that this public health department will continue to do is I really believe [1:10:22] that this is a public health issue, not a one side of the political aisle or another side of [1:10:28] the political aisle issue and if we can all come together as a community and embrace it as a [1:10:33] true public health issue, I think the skies will look at on what we can actually achieve. [1:10:40] council member Jason Glyat something to that council member. So, our public information officer, [1:10:50] working with the city and county of Bloomfield, have done excellent job of getting information out there. [1:10:56] And so we push, we do very innovative social media campaigns. [1:11:00] We do lots of pushing out information to our schools. [1:11:04] pushing that information to our businesses so that they have in hand, our website is actually [1:11:09] very good, it's not only sharing data, but sharing tools and expertise and education [1:11:16] and our staff spend a lot of time talking individually with daycare centers and schools [1:11:22] and long-term care facilities. [1:11:23] So they get the accurate information that they need and we're also working with our healthcare [1:11:28] systems are providers, you see health, and good Sam, and all the other [1:11:34] central hospitals, so that we can get that information we're closely with [1:11:38] them, because it's just not us, it's providing this information. It really is our [1:11:42] whole network of folks. And I'd like to say often, we want to spread the [1:11:47] information not the infection. So hopefully you can be partners with us and make [1:11:53] a difference in the making that change. [1:11:55] Thank you, Dr. Irbina. I believe we all have a responsibility to support our public health [1:12:02] officials in a data and science-based approach to fighting this virus. Otherwise, we'll [1:12:09] be back in the same situation if people don't take it seriously. So I appreciate your comments. [1:12:16] That's all. Thank you. [1:12:19] Thank you. [1:12:20] Um, I appreciate, uh, council member, um, Mayor Prisham, just, uh, clear five one of the things that I would want to comment on what I want to make is that we really need to be careful about where we're getting our source of information from. So I do just have one question, um, left here is, uh, I know we don't have that exact statistic yet, but I do want to hear just a little bit more, um, about those, the individuals that don't fear so well and the long-term health impacts. I, I just, you know, heard about somebody who has a pulmonary embolism. [1:12:50] And stuff like that, I mean, you know, what are we really looking at here for those individuals [1:12:54] that develop a developed something that's not so easy, that they don't want to do so easily. [1:13:01] Like, what does that really look like? Are we seeing? [1:13:05] Council member Anderson, I appreciate you bringing that up. [1:13:10] And we've been bringing such a strong team, they've actually done a comprehensive literature review of the information that's out there. [1:13:19] And a couple key points that I want to highlight, and then we'll make sure that we get [1:13:26] this out to not only our council members, but to the public, is only 39% of individuals [1:13:34] who were hospitalized, reported a return to baseline health within 2-3 weeks after COVID-19 [1:13:44] testing among individuals not hospitalized 35% reported not having returned to their baseline [1:13:53] health within 2 to 3 weeks. And then we're also looking at some of those chronic symptoms [1:14:02] that extend beyond 12 weeks and what those are. So that we have a, I can hold up a full report [1:14:11] we put together and unfortunately I didn't have the time to put it into a good communications [1:14:20] document that this is something we'd be happy to share with council on the public. [1:14:26] Yeah, I appreciate it very much and thank you. That will be helpful information. [1:14:30] I think for all of us to understand. Thank you. [1:14:34] All [1:14:37] right, council will be grown. [1:14:42] Yes, thank you, Mayor. For a second time and I'll make it very quick. I wanted to address [1:14:46] more pro-times comments. I feel that it's very responsible to address statistics and support [1:14:54] the health and safety of our residents. This is not just- [1:15:00] My opinion, I do get calls and concerns associated with people seeing the other side. You know, I don't know the percentage, but it has nothing to do with any council member or public representative, not believing in COVID and the seriousness of it. Right now we are in serious situation with our cases increasing and I feel like we absolutely need to challenge the way of thinking. [1:15:27] So we understand how we can make public policy for the better, masks and social distancing are not working right now. [1:15:37] We need to do more and what is that. [1:15:41] So I have to say, but I would be happy to have that dialogue with you, Council Member Castraata. [1:15:51] Mayor, we have a long night. [1:15:54] I mean, we could have a point counterpoint for the rest of the evening. [1:15:57] You go ahead, Mayor Funtown. [1:16:01] I just, I'm wondering how a council member has all of a sudden decided that masks and [1:16:06] social distancing don't work. [1:16:09] Okay. [1:16:09] Well, your points are pretty sure you go and Council Member Tessie A. [1:16:14] I just wanted to add to like, it's people wearing the masks that have to happen. [1:16:22] And the three W's are clearly the methods for reducing transmission and that we got to get everybody wearing those masks. [1:16:34] So I would say it's people not wearing masks that is probably not working over the latter. [1:16:40] So I just wanted to put that out there. [1:16:42] And thank you to Dr. Vina and Jason and Deb for, and please pass along our great fullness and our thanks. [1:16:51] gratitude to your team. I know you guys are working super, super hard. So, we appreciate you. [1:16:57] Hey, Kels remember I've already recognized you twice. I'm going to go ahead and go. We do [1:17:00] here. I just wanted to follow up and say, no, we're not going to, we're going to, we're going to [1:17:13] So we have public comments, you know, and we have one public comment and it's Dr. Erickson and he's signed on and he wants to talk about a COVID-19. So I'm going to go ahead and recognize Rick, Rick, would you identify yourself in your neighborhood and you have three minutes. [1:17:36] My name is Rick Erickson. I'm a retired physician. I'm from Ward 4. I've been listening to all of this [1:17:42] COVID and how the hospital ICU beds are increasing. It doesn't look like it's that much. It was [1:17:48] 77% in July and has increased to about 82%. Now, over a big increase is going to happen if people don't get their [1:17:56] flu shots and I've listened to the talent halls and there's been no exhorting people within the community [1:18:03] to obtain flu shots, and people should not neglect that, because influenza is a major contributor [1:18:11] to ICU utilization, and that needs to be pushed very hard in the community. [1:18:18] Number two, and looking at the data that's been presented, I went through a look at who [1:18:26] was getting hit the hardest, and it goes along with the article that I wrote to the Brunford [1:18:31] enterprise in May of this year. If you look at the population between 0 and 50, there were [1:18:39] 830 reported cases and 0 deaths, which goes along with this disease is not effect as greatly [1:18:49] the young people, the mortality rate is extremely, extremely low if you're below 40. I'm watching [1:18:55] And a lot of people in this community who call up to your talent hall and they're terrified. [1:19:01] And this is not a disease that needs to be dismissed. [1:19:04] But I don't think we need to have this much fear, which isn't healthy for the immune system. [1:19:10] And it's also causing that a lot of other dysfunction in the community. [1:19:15] What we need to really push in this community, as as the Swedish, have done. [1:19:19] And if you look at the Swedish data where they don't have any masks, and they set one meter [1:19:23] part for me, each other in the restaurants, along with having their schools open to a [1:19:30] date 16, they've got the same mortality rate as Bloomfield does, by the way, right now. [1:19:36] But they are pushing very hard for people, 65 and 70, that they need to self-isolate. [1:19:42] In this morning when I was picking up my groceries outside of King Supers, I watched a bunch [1:19:47] of older people coming out and looked like they could barely walk to the car, who were picking [1:19:51] groceries and those people really need to stay at home or have some and bring groceries to them. [1:19:58] Or they need to get them picked up, but they shouldn't be. [1:20:03] We need to protect our elderly and they need to realize that if you're over 75, [1:20:08] you're risk compared to someone under 17 as 3,000 times greater and they need to be very cautious, [1:20:15] especially older people and they need to self-isolate as much as possible. [1:20:20] Because they're the ones that are going to be hit, you look at the hospitalization. [1:20:24] Look at the, we've had 43 confirmed deaths in Brufale. [1:20:29] And out of those, 31 were over 80 years old. [1:20:34] If the majority need you to wrap around. [1:20:36] Or elderly are the ones that are going to get affected. [1:20:38] So I think we need to have something on our website. [1:20:41] And we should show what the relationship is between age and the death rate is. [1:20:46] And we need to caution our elder citizens that they need to remain out of public places [1:20:53] essentially. [1:20:55] Thank you. [1:20:55] Thank you. [1:20:55] Thank you. [1:20:58] I'm going to go ahead and close out the Board of Health. [1:21:05] There is no further business before the Board of Health. [1:21:08] The meeting is adjourned. [1:21:10] There is no business tonight before the House of Authority. [1:21:13] And let's move to item 7C, which is 20 resolution, 20, 20 dash 2, 2, 6. [1:21:21] So next is Council's consideration, proposed resolution, number 20, 20 dash 2, 2, 6. [1:21:29] And you know, which, you staff will explain, I didn't write down exactly, it's on the [1:21:33] machine. [1:21:35] I'm, I'm at living here. [1:21:37] So Council has a copy of the agenda memorandum, which staff will summarize. [1:21:45] Thank you, Mayor and Council. Briefly Chief Krieger will walk us through this item and also Deputy Chief Mike Clement is on the line as well to feel any additional questions. Thank you. [1:21:59] Good evening, Mayor and Council. So the tech three is a body scanner. It's a non-invasive scanner to detect anybody coming into the jail that may have ingested or concealed prohibited items prior to getting into the jail. [1:22:14] things like drugs, weapons, contraband, cell phones. It replaces the need for strip searching, [1:22:21] which obviously is quite invasive and as well as a difficult for our staff to do. [1:22:30] Well, it's used in jails throughout the United States. The cost of this is 159,000. It's being paid in total out of [1:22:41] inmate welfare funds, which are restricted funds under state law. And this is an allowable expense under [1:22:48] those funds. And again, I have both deputy chief Mike Clement, who runs the jail as well as Commander [1:22:58] questions you make up. [1:23:01] Okay, so we'll now proceed with public [1:23:03] comments if there's anyone I would like to be heard. The number is 8556953744 [1:23:09] press star three state your first last name in neighborhood for the record. [1:23:16] I'm not noting anybody for this specific item. So we'll go to council questions [1:23:22] to come as next council member livens. [1:23:25] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [1:23:27] And thank you, Chief. [1:23:28] I'm the one who pulled this off the consent agenda. [1:23:31] And in general, I think I favor this, [1:23:34] but one of the questions that I've gotten on this topic [1:23:38] is when, out of Denver Airport, [1:23:41] they do it well, new to me airport, right? [1:23:44] When they put these scanners in, [1:23:47] there was the whole, I guess, scandal [1:23:51] about how they, they were, I don't know how else to save this without just like saying it, [1:23:57] but the, they were revealing, potentially of people's personal body details, things like that. [1:24:03] So I guess that's what the question that I had was, how does this, if it replaces the need for [1:24:09] a strip search, which is certainly invasive, how does it do that without, or does it do that without [1:24:14] about invading the inmates' privacy and other respects? [1:24:22] Well, Councilmember Law Evans, one is an airport, obviously, where the public is going through, [1:24:28] and the other one is entering into a jail facility, and clearly, you know, a strip search is even more invasive, [1:24:34] but I'll ask Commander Hartman if he could kind of explain what is viewed. [1:24:41] Thank you. [1:24:44] I think in your packet, you could probably see some of the pictures that basically shows [1:24:49] the outline, and then it will show anything and highlight anything that's contraband. [1:24:57] So it's not revealing showing body parts or anything like that, basically it kind of looks [1:25:03] like a great dummy with what you see as the contraband that may or may not be on the individual. [1:25:13] interesting. So, and it must just be the software programming that allows it to identify, [1:25:23] I mean, well, you know what I'll follow up offline with you folks. I think that this is a great idea, [1:25:29] and I think if it reduces the invasion of privacy for the inmates, it's a terrific idea, [1:25:35] and certainly if it helps the workload on the staff, I think that's a terrific idea. [1:25:41] I just, I'm confused as to how it works, but I'll follow up offline. [1:25:45] I appreciate this very much. [1:25:46] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [1:25:48] Thank you, Kezmer, Michelle. [1:25:50] Thank you, Mayor. [1:25:51] So back to the council of detention tour with the staff. [1:25:55] I was fortunate enough to go along with many of the detention staff and tour and one of [1:26:01] the things that I heard most often talked about was the body scanner and the need for this [1:26:07] body scanner within the detention center. [1:26:09] But if I'm not mistaken, right now, most of the liability with our detention center exists in our booking area, and that is where this body scanner would be housed in where it would be most critical. [1:26:22] So how does this body scanner reduce that liability for our police department? [1:26:28] So, Councillor Schaff, it's a type of low grade x-ray machine that detects a foreign objects. [1:26:38] And the biggest risk that we have is any time somebody is first entering in the jail. [1:26:44] And so we would use it. Everybody enters the jail through booking. And it's again, [1:26:50] people that are under arrest being housed in the jail. [1:26:52] So it detects any of those items that pose a risk to either the staff or other inmates coming into the jail. [1:27:04] So in the ability, we have to ensure that those, they have either secreted those items or ingested those items help to increase the safety in the jail and decrease liability just simply because we're not having to do that. [1:27:20] and we're invasive kind of search that may subject us to higher levels of liability. [1:27:27] And I can't or hurt anything to add with it. [1:27:30] But obviously if drugs are getting by getting into the facility risk, [1:27:37] and inmate getting seriously ill or even dying from overdoses inside the jail, [1:27:44] let's give us the opportunity to avoid that, [1:27:47] because now if we want to do a scripture, [1:27:50] we have to have probable cause to believe [1:27:53] that they have drugs or a weapon on or in them. [1:27:58] So then we could proceed to do that. [1:28:01] We're this one, we can run everybody through. [1:28:04] And there's people that we have come in here [1:28:06] who are looking normal every day [1:28:10] and have given us no suspicion that they're bringing in drugs or a weapon and could possibly [1:28:20] bring that in because we're not going to be doing that type of search. But with this scanner, [1:28:25] we're able to put everybody that comes into the facility through where to stop those [1:28:30] particular items from getting inside the facility. [1:28:35] It was great to hear. I'm fully supportive of this [1:28:38] I look forward to, you know, really assisting the police department and the attention center staff, [1:28:45] you know, in decreasing their liability, but being much more careful with how they're processing and coming in makes. [1:28:54] Okay. [1:28:56] We. [1:28:59] Next is Council's consideration of proposed resolution 2020-226. [1:29:04] Will the clerk please repurpose resolution of 2020-2265 title? [1:29:13] Resolution number 2020, guys, should keep the [1:29:16] approving an agreement by in between the [1:29:19] D.A. and Brown Bill and tech 84 for a body fairer. [1:29:24] Yes, are the livens. [1:29:26] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Excuse me, I moved that resolution number 2020-2265. [1:29:31] Approved. [1:29:31] Yes, Robert Shaft. [1:29:33] Second. [1:29:33] uh will is there any further discussion uh will they what will the clerk please call the role [1:29:44] Can you show us? [1:29:47] Yes. [1:29:49] Room? [1:29:51] Yes. [1:29:53] Single? [1:29:54] Yes. [1:29:56] Do they see? [1:29:59] Love ever? [1:30:18] We have a public hearing that's next, which is going to take a while. So let's go ahead and take our 10 minute break and come back at 805. We'll come back at 805. [1:30:36] The access live event is in musical. [1:40:33] Okay, Doug, can you hear me? Yes, sir. Let's go ahead, [1:40:42] taking the top music hold in five, four, three, two, one. [1:40:49] Music hold ended. [1:40:51] Okay. Our next item under council business, the ZVN is the public hearing and council's consideration. [1:40:57] a proposed resolution of our 2020-247, approved the final [1:41:02] flat and a site development plan on land within the North Park [1:41:06] unit planned unit development, planned known as the East Village [1:41:10] neighborhood. I'll declare the public hearing open. First, we'll [1:41:14] follow our city standard public hearing procedures. First, the [1:41:17] staff will present a summary of the proposal. Next, we will have the [1:41:21] applicants presentation. If applicable, [1:41:25] then we will ask for [1:41:26] public comments and final comments from the applicant and finally questions and comments from the city council. [1:41:32] Council has a copy of the agenda member and which staff will summarize. [1:41:38] Thank you, Mayor and council. Good evening, Annaburn Zeddy, director of planning will introduce us to [1:41:43] this topic and then of course the applicants will have a very brief presentation and be available for council questions. [1:41:51] Thank you. And thank you and good evening, Mayor and city council. [1:41:56] We have the next slide, please. [1:42:00] The applicant this evening is requesting consideration of a final [1:42:03] plant, a site development plan, and a subdivision improvement [1:42:05] agreement for a property located east of Sheridan Parkway [1:42:09] in South of State Highway 7. [1:42:11] The plant encompasses approximately 263 acres this [1:42:15] is shown in the yellow outline. [1:42:17] And the site development plan includes just over 84 acres, [1:42:20] and that's shown in the red outline. [1:42:22] Next slide, please. [1:42:24] The comprehensive plan-language designation for this site is mixed use commercial and the proposal [1:42:29] deceiving is consistent with that designation. [1:42:33] The final plot establishes lotlines for 232 residential lots, 12 super block larger lots that are [1:42:43] intended for future development and 66 tracks. [1:42:46] The plot also dedicates right away and easements to serve the proposed site development plan. [1:42:51] The 66 tracks are utilized for onsite open area, landscaping street lawns, private alleyways, future public roadways, to be dedicated with future plating of the adjacent superblocks. [1:43:04] Next slide please. [1:43:06] This site development plan includes 232 residential lots, 102 of those are attached units and 130 are detached units. These are interspersed with private open areas and public and private streets. [1:43:18] The development is proposed in six overall phases generally moving from north to south. [1:43:24] Setbacks in off-street parking are consistent with the planned unit development requirements for North Park, [1:43:31] which you may also hear called the baseline community. [1:43:35] And the setbacks and development standards are outlined in more detail in the staff member and the next slide please. [1:43:43] The east village site development plant area is within an area of Brimfield that has existing [1:43:48] plugged in abandoned wells. [1:43:50] The plugged wells are between 450 and 1,350 feet from the site development land boundaries. [1:43:56] The existing extraction pads along our FS Parkway are over 2,500 feet to the south of the site [1:44:03] development plan boundary. [1:44:05] The final plan includes all required notices, notes regarding the future, note, regarding [1:44:12] notices for future property owners, because of the existence of the plugged and abandoned [1:44:18] oil and gas wells in close proximity to the final plot area. Since there are also areas [1:44:25] of the final plan that are within 1320 feet that are not planned for a residential, but could be [1:44:32] for residential and the future subject to a future site development plan proposal that would require [1:44:37] a city council review. There is also a note regarding the proximity of the edges of the final [1:44:43] plat to the existing wells along the Northwest Parkway. And those are all consistent with the [1:44:49] Braubild Municipal Code requirements. Next slide, please. The on-site landscape [1:44:55] accounts for over 25% of the site area. Landscape treatments are [1:45:00] That's in trade at a long streets, within packet parks and a long internal green landscaping. Packet parks include a variety of amenities for residents such as seating and picnic areas, shade structures, place structures and plain lots. [1:45:12] Park lane is a private street that is designated as one way. It's a shared street where pedestrians and vehicles share the road. This is the upper right of the screen. The applicant will provide additional details regarding the parks and park lane as part of their presentation. [1:45:27] The internal trail and sidewalk network will tie together these amenities while also connecting to the adjacent neighborhoods and future parks and trail corridors in the area. [1:45:38] Next slide please. [1:45:40] The plans do not include builder specific architecture because this detail is not known at this time. [1:45:46] The site development plan includes illustrations that convey a general character and all architecture will be required to meet the requirements of the PUD plan. [1:45:54] And we'll also require a review through the North Park Design Review Committee, which is above and beyond the minimum room field standards. [1:46:03] The applicant is requesting consideration that all buildings, builder specific architecture be reviewed through the city's site development plan administrative modification process with a call up provision by city council. [1:46:15] The current process, which is utilized for the West Village area, requires individual home builders to complete a full site development plan amendment process, including two public hearings, one with planning and zoning and one with city council. [1:46:30] The proposal from the applicant this evening would utilize the administrative modification process to be completed at a staff level with final approval from the city manager's office with the call of provision that would allow any single [1:46:43] council member to be able to call up the decision for additional review through public hearing [1:46:49] the city council. Next slide, please. [1:46:54] The concept review for this project was held in January [1:46:56] of 2019. Details regarding how items were addressed from the concept review are provided on the screen [1:47:03] as well as were detailed in the staff member random. [1:47:07] Next slide, please. The subdivision improvement [1:47:11] agreement is proposed to outline the obligations for completing public and private improvements [1:47:16] associated with the project, the tightening for public land educations and the obligations for [1:47:21] affordable housing and off-site infrastructure work. Affordable housing is addressed through an affordable [1:47:28] housing covenant that's referred to as a facilitating covenant or a deed restriction that is on [1:47:32] lot one, block nine of the plant, which I believe has been recorded by the applicant. The [1:47:39] The parcel is located at the southern edge of the site development plan area, and this is that would be the first of many phases of affordable housing as North Park develops in the future. [1:47:51] The parcel will be developed with no less than 35 dwelling units per acre all affordable. [1:47:56] And if the total affordable or attainable, and if the total number of units is less than 12.6% of the total number of residential units within the STP, then the owner has obligations to provide additional land, cash or mail or additional units to ensure that that minimum is met. [1:48:15] The Housing Advisory Committee has reviewed the developers proposal and believes that it's appropriate and has accepted that proposal. [1:48:24] Next slide, please. This just shows the location of the affordable housing and relationship [1:48:30] to the East Village residential. It's directly on a trail corridor and shared in Parkway. [1:48:38] Next slide, please. The public land dedication is part of the subdivision improvement. [1:48:43] Agreement obligations, the honor will be dedicating six parcels along the Northwest Parkway [1:48:49] as identified as required within the planning and development plan for baseline. [1:48:54] This is approximately 27 acres. These will be dedicated as open space. [1:48:59] And it will be done by the end of 2021 for this subdivision improvement agreement. [1:49:03] And this is an addition to the open areas as previously identified that would be constructed as part of the site development plan. [1:49:11] Next slide, please. [1:49:13] The City and County of Springfield Standard Public Notice requirements have meant this is in addition to the applicant completing notices for the homeowner's associations in the area. [1:49:24] Staff, I have not identified any key issues with this proposal. [1:49:28] The Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed the proposal in September of this year on 28. [1:49:33] They recommended approval with one condition. [1:49:35] The Planning and Zoning Commission desired that future architectural plans submitted by individual builders go through the full public hearing process for a site development plan amendment. [1:49:47] The applicant response was to add the provision for a call up by any single council member as previously summarized in my presentation. [1:49:58] The applicant's team is present this evening and I have the presentation as well in this concludes that presentation. [1:50:03] May will we will go with the applicant's presentation, just we encourage staff to keep their [1:50:13] presentation brief, please keep yours concise as well. [1:50:17] Will the applicant's representative please identify themselves for the record prior to [1:50:21] the beginning of their brief presentation. [1:50:24] Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of Council. [1:50:27] This is Kyle Harris on the General Manager of McWinney's baseline project. [1:50:30] Also with me this evening is Alicia Hammett with North's design who's also going to co-present and we have a few other folks who are able to answer questions afterwards. Next slide please. [1:50:42] As indicated, the East Village community is sort of sandwiched between Sheridan Road to the West, the Parklands to the East and Center Street District to the North. Next slide. [1:50:56] This slide shows what we anticipate to be a full buildout projection for East Village which represents approximately 1100 units. [1:51:07] We're showing this to indicate what we anticipate to be the phasing of the project. [1:51:12] At this point we're looking at four phases. [1:51:14] The first one being the perimeter within or bounded by the red perimeter, second one being the teal area, third being purple and the fourth being the yellow. [1:51:25] Next slide please. [1:51:30] We have some requirements within our SAA that are a little unique and those will be the next few slides. [1:51:37] We have agreed to produce or develop the first phase of our parklands portion of the parklands, which is the big green, which is what you see here. [1:51:51] It's just north of five acres in size, and we have agreed to triggers for when this would happen, [1:51:58] which you can see here are at the issuance of 375 building permits. That's when design begins in an [1:52:05] STP specific to this project is submitted, and then construction begins within nine months of [1:52:12] 580 building permits being issued. Next slide, please. [1:52:19] As indicated earlier, we will be [1:52:21] conveying land to the open lands and these are the parcels that you see below 160, 160 at that. [1:52:30] And 27.59 acres is the acreage it will be conveyed. [1:52:38] Next slide please. [1:52:41] Additionally, as was discussed about affordable housing, we are locating that adjacent to shared and road as well as a portion of the parklands is you can see here contextually, which is also adjacent to one of the regional trails that's proposed for baseline next slide please. [1:53:01] This gives you a better sense of where the affordable housing parcel is located relative to the other areas of east village. [1:53:10] Next slide please. [1:53:12] And this I want to be clear that the SDP and proposal that we have this evening is not to approve this, but we wanted to give a sense of the site planning that has already been undertaken for the affordable housing site. [1:53:26] And as I think I've mentioned before to Council, we're looking at 184 for rent units as well as 24 sale units as configured here and it's this site plan that has sort of governed the [1:53:41] in conference that Ms. Burton said he referenced earlier. [1:53:45] Next slide please. [1:53:49] And so just a little more detail on the affordable housing [1:53:52] covenant. It covers approximately 4.5 acres. [1:53:56] It's a parcel we just saw. [1:53:58] We anticipate density of 45 to use for acre based upon that site plan. [1:54:02] The site is restricted for rent at 60% an AMI and or for sale at average 80% [1:54:11] AMI in conformance with the room field ordinance. [1:54:14] And then upon recordation, baseline receives 2024 [1:54:18] affordable housing credits. [1:54:21] And at the end of the eight-year period, [1:54:25] as Ms. Burton said, he said, [1:54:27] if we are unable to achieve the required amount [1:54:31] of affordable housing units on that parcel, [1:54:33] we have to either do cash and loot land and loot [1:54:36] or provide a different location for affordable housing. [1:54:40] next slide please. At this point I'm going to turn it over to Miss Hammett to take us through the next few slides. [1:54:47] It evening. I'm Alicia Hammett. I'm a panoramic nurse design. This shows the first phase and the limits of the East Village STP. [1:54:56] That you all are reviewing tonight. We go to the next slide please. [1:55:03] Connectivity, community and stewardship or pillars of the Urban Design for East Village. [1:55:08] other communities designed around system gardenways and central shared street or a central shared street or a wounded known as park lane. [1:55:17] It's going to be one of the first pollinator districts in the state, which we're really excited about. [1:55:22] And here are all the sustainability goals that this community has incorporated. [1:55:29] So promoting pollinator habitat, a commitment to EV conduit in the garages and all the garages. [1:55:35] It's walkable, there's publicly accessible bicycle parking and the builders will be required to have a hers rating of less than 50. [1:55:48] To go to the next slide, please. [1:55:52] These are the garden ways that connect people and pollinators throughout each village and you can see where they connect the pink line is park lane, which is the shared street. [1:56:04] And they all need to the parklands, which is the long linear park to the east of East Village. [1:56:13] Go to the next slide, please. [1:56:17] We have entry planters at the beginning of the gardenways. [1:56:24] These are all filled with pollinator habitats and really serve as kind of the front yards for the community. [1:56:32] I think the next slide please. [1:56:39] I've found there just another view of the gardenways here. [1:56:42] You go to the next slide, please. [1:56:46] Little green is one of the community neighborhood parks. [1:56:50] That's north of Park Lane. [1:56:52] It has a half moon plaza that's perfect for smoke gatherings and farmers markets. [1:56:57] Scott Festoon lighting, custom shade structures, [1:57:00] picnic tables, hammocks, and pollinator gardens, and an open lawn for volleyball and [1:57:05] lounging in a playground. We can go to the next slide, please. This is a view from Park Lane. [1:57:13] We have these little illuminated pavers that provide this nice warm glow for residents so they [1:57:19] can be an active place day and night. We go to the next slide, please. The yard is a passive park [1:57:28] located at the northwest terminus of Park Lane, the park is mostly an uninterrupted green area [1:57:33] of perfunctory soccer, lounging and picnics. The park also offers plenty of gardens and hammocks, [1:57:40] so this is a more passive space. Go the next slide, please. [1:57:45] Park Lane will live like a [1:57:47] linear park or plaza. The lunar surface design with a 13-foot pedestrian amenity area was [1:57:53] implanters, a 10-foot one direction travel lane is provided along with an 8-foot parking lane. [1:58:00] The entire street is designed with enhanced paving, eliminated pavers, [1:58:04] wafer, soft glow at night. You can see that up close here, along with hanging street lights. [1:58:10] So the next slide, please. So here's another view, park lane. You can east. You go to the next slide, [1:58:19] please. [1:58:22] Reiterating SAS presentation, East Village has included [1:58:25] representative architectural character as part of the STP. [1:58:29] If you could go to the next slide, please. [1:58:32] The future community will offer high quality, small, [1:58:34] small, small, single-family homes along with townhomes. [1:58:37] The architectural character shown here [1:58:38] meets the North Park PD requirements [1:58:40] and has been approved by the North Park [1:58:42] Design Review Committee. [1:58:44] Thank you. [1:58:46] And the design team is here to answer any questions [1:58:49] Thank you, Alicia. We have a few more slides. If we can go to the next one, please. [1:58:56] Just a few comments on DRC. Our DRC is responsible for viewing the plans for all development, [1:59:02] including construction of any type, landscaping, lighting, signage. You can barely turn [1:59:06] a shovel of dirt at baseline without it going through the design review. And the important point [1:59:11] here is that it is not a one and done process. You don't simply submit one time and then you're [1:59:16] finish, but rather it's an iterative process, which really helps to ensure the app [1:59:20] can still get too far down the road before a check-in to make sure that we're in [1:59:25] lock step with the direction which they're headed. [1:59:28] So we have DRC, preliminary sketch review, which is prior to these plans going to [1:59:34] the concept review. [1:59:35] We have schematic design and design development review, which is required before we allow [1:59:40] applicants to go to the SDP process with Springfield, and we have construction document review, [1:59:46] which we require through our DRC before going to the city [1:59:52] for building permit. [1:59:53] And then even once things have been built out, [1:59:57] the applicant has to go back to the DRC via the finals. [1:59:59] . [2:00:00] Certificate of Compliance before they can go to a broomfield for Certificate of occupancy. [2:00:06] Next slide, please. [2:00:09] And so the criteria by which our DRC reviews applicants is shown or a partial view of what they [2:00:17] review it against is shown here. And I would summarize this by saying, we want the projects to be [2:00:22] aesthetically pleasing. We want the elevations to have a variety of materials, check textures. [2:00:27] We want to have appropriate massing the mix of colors. [2:00:32] We want high quality in the design. [2:00:35] Next slide, please. [2:00:39] Next slide, please. [2:00:43] There you are. [2:00:43] Great. [2:00:44] So it was mentioned that we were still hopeful of being able to have administrative review for the [2:00:50] architectural STPs, which in East Village is actually a fairly small amount. [2:00:55] It's really just the three four-sale builders that we have. [2:00:58] the apartment project, other larger project will still go through the normal process. [2:01:03] And then the compromise, as was mentioned earlier, was to have a call-up provision by any [2:01:07] member of Council. And you may ask, well, why are you guys asking for this? And it's really because [2:01:13] of timing and administrative SDP three to four weeks versus the full-bore process of the alternative [2:01:23] what's currently the process, which takes us about three to four months, and when you're trying [2:01:27] to coordinate builder closings. And by the way, the builders will not close until any [2:01:34] discretionary approval, they won't close if those discretionary approvals have not happened. [2:01:39] So in any event, it will help us out immeasurably with these closings, with the builders, we're trying [2:01:45] to coordinate closings. And then at the end of the day, there is hopefully council recognizes there [2:01:50] a very rigorous review process through our DRC. Next slide, please. [2:01:57] Here's who's on the DRC. We've heard comments before about, oh my goodness, it's just [2:02:01] a rubber stamp by McWinney. Nothing could be further from the truth. These are the members [2:02:05] of our DRC Jim Stroll, toll strip pipelines of our mental center, Amy Arger where the butterfly [2:02:10] pavilion, Dave Williams, director of D.T.J., your very own, Annabelle Zetti, and then Kim Perry [2:02:16] is the one person, the one McKinney employee who's on the on the team here. So these are our group [2:02:22] of professionals that are rigorously review all of our projects. I will make just one last [2:02:27] thing, this is our last slide, and that's to say that if Council's not quite ready to do this [2:02:33] and have this administrative review with a call-up provision, if that's the thing that could [2:02:40] potentially tank us tonight, we would rather cleave that off if it's problematic. If we can get it [2:02:46] But if it's something that's too, you're not ready for it, we understand and we could move forward without it. [2:02:52] But we'd love to have it if you're willing. That's an African's presentation. [2:02:58] So we'll now proceed with public comments. If there's anyone who would like to be heard, [2:03:02] please press start three. State your first last name and neighborhood for the record. [2:03:07] I'm not noting anybody that's called in on this item. So we'll go to questions for city council members. [2:03:13] next please raise your hand and you'll be called upon. [2:03:21] Council. Council member Anderson. [2:03:26] Thanks. Sorry, it wasn't quite prepared. Okay, so I'll just address Mr. Harris's first question [2:03:33] about that call provision and the only my only concern with that is that we're also very busy and [2:03:39] I think we're ever making the pandemic this change and I just kind of want to make sure that we're [2:03:48] More through our own staff, maybe, but I would like to know, like other people's feedback on that. [2:03:53] Just to make sure that we're not missing this and that we're not overlooking this opportunity, [2:03:57] what we should be calling it, but we did have a concern. [2:04:00] But I am, I am actually more in the area of being okay with it. [2:04:06] I do want to, you know, so regarding this development, maybe this is premature here. [2:04:13] And the Thundervistic capacity, that remains that the school capacity means a concern and what the plant is. [2:04:21] The near-term plan is for the students of these, of these new homes until that future magnet school is ready. [2:04:28] I know we, I know brought this up before, but if you could just give a quick update on where you're at in the communications with a school that would be super helpful. [2:04:37] I'll be from Mr. Harris, I guess. [2:04:40] Yeah, so, strike on the unmute button. [2:04:43] Yeah, I know worries. [2:04:44] No worries. [2:04:44] So, we actually have been very much involved with Adam's 12, quite recently, as well as a number [2:04:51] of broomfield staff, especially as it relates to the urban renewal area, where in the process [2:04:57] right now of proposing a bifurcated URA and as part of that proposal, we're recommending [2:05:04] baseline is willing to allocate additional mil-levy that would otherwise have come to us through [2:05:12] our urban renewal area and have that go to Adam's 12. Because the big hairy thing that has to [2:05:20] be figured out with that school is financing. It's the funding of the school. And so maybe others [2:05:29] from room field might be able to chime in on where we are with this. But I would say we have made [2:05:34] good progress. We had a meeting with two of the Adams 12 board members. [2:05:43] That was yesterday. I think [2:05:45] I'd lose track of time and COVID, and it was very positive. So we are working through [2:05:51] in ways through our urban renewal area to provide additional funding to make the school a reality. [2:05:57] I will to set expectations though. I think we all believe that in order for that school to happen, [2:06:03] It still will have to go to a vote of residents to issue a bond. [2:06:09] But if through other means, there's a way to achieve approximately 50% [2:06:14] of the cost of the school, that is, you should probably hear it from [2:06:20] Chris Gideoski, but it sounds like that would be a more palatable thing to be able [2:06:23] to go to the voters with if you're almost getting a school for app price. [2:06:27] I hope that answers your question. [2:06:29] Council Member Anderson. [2:06:30] That does help. And then I guess that the project question was the first homes to be built, but they would be bus to another. There's school capacity somewhere that those students. [2:06:40] I don't know the timing of the, did you make a school and when these first homes are built, but there would be, but that isn't the discussions right of where these students would be bus to. [2:06:50] Correct. [2:06:50] I can't speak to where they would be bus two. I think the idea is now that they would be at legacy high school funder vista middle school and I apologize. I don't recall the middle school. [2:07:02] That's where I believe the students are going to be are anticipated to go for these for the homes that are being developed at baseline right now. [2:07:09] Okay, and then ultimately to that maintenance school. Okay, thank you potentially, but even the [2:07:14] magnet school would be partially choice in, so it would be available for folks and other parts of [2:07:19] the community as well as in baseline. Okay, thank you. And then, okay, then also on the, that's why I [2:07:28] that we understand what we're saying. [2:07:30] The E.V. Con do it in all the garages. What exactly does that mean? Is that like 240 volt, 50 amps, circuits, does that have a plug-in, where you just plug it, plug-ins already built in, so you just pop it on the wall and plug it right in. [2:07:45] Okay, that's what I'm going to make sure that. [2:07:47] I want to make sure that we have a E.V. charger, and it wasn't an exactly easy process about having that pretty wired. [2:07:53] Okay, that is good. [2:07:55] And the garden ways, those are excellent. [2:08:00] I love the look and feel of that, but then the park lane, [2:08:04] I have two questions on this and these are my last two questions. [2:08:07] Um, this can't brick road. [2:08:08] That looks similar to the stamp of brick that we had on shared in one three six [2:08:13] a while back before it was removed. [2:08:15] And it was noisy and slippery. [2:08:17] Do you foresee those being an issue on this material theme? [2:08:21] show isn't just we're not, you know, in the same place we were, where the noise was, [2:08:27] but this is the same speed limit, but do you foresee those, especially a slipperyness being [2:08:33] an issue on that stamp break? [2:08:37] I appreciate the question and the speed limit will be maximum 15 miles per hour if not less, [2:08:43] but I think what I'm going to do is I saw Jared pop up there, so I'm going to look to Alicia [2:08:47] or Jared to potentially address the questions about the material and choices there. [2:08:53] Thanks, Kyle. Good evening, council members. My name is Jared Carlin with Norris [2:08:58] design and we've been working on the landscape architecture for the east village. The [2:09:02] pavers are going to be individual pavers, concrete pavers that will have a great texture and feel they [2:09:09] won't be slippery at all. I don't think and we can make sure that there's a slip factor there as we [2:09:16] look at finalizing those and then we can look at selecting a paper that won't have as much of [2:09:24] like create as much noise either even going at that slow speed so we'll keep that in mind as we [2:09:29] camera out those details through the construction trying process. Okay thank you and then on this [2:09:34] private rule my final question is the enforceability I know it's just coming up into discussion [2:09:39] I'm having on a ring road, and I'm going to hand them in right now, and please start [2:09:45] able to enforce the ability issue. [2:09:48] Is that the same? [2:09:49] This might be a room to question, more of our staff is, is that an enforceable road by the [2:09:57] room to please department? [2:09:59] I think it's my question. [2:10:00] I'm going to make sure that we understand what we're getting into here with that, but that [2:10:08] I'm not sure [2:10:14] if the best position answer that. [2:10:20] So perhaps somebody from Brune Field can help us out. [2:10:23] Councilmember Anderson, I would believe that this would be similar to the situation in [2:10:28] Anthem where it's a private road. [2:10:30] I'm not sure if there is Gary Krieger, he'd be able to answer specifically for the police department. [2:10:38] Yes, thank you for the question. [2:10:41] So I'm private roads. [2:10:43] There are certain laws that we can't enforce. [2:10:45] DUI, reckless driving, hit, and run, careless driving, but speed limit and some of those [2:10:50] others, at least enter current color at a law, those are not enforceable on private roads. [2:10:59] Okay. [2:10:59] And then do we need to proceed up being an issue that we should be putting some, I guess that's [2:11:04] a question for you. [2:11:05] You're like, do you see, for the end of the issue where do we think we are, okay, without [2:11:09] being a private road from your standpoint? [2:11:13] Well, that's a little hard for me to say, since it's first time I've seen this, but it usually just comes up when people are disregarding the speed limits and the frustration that comes from citizens when we aren't able to enforce the speed limit. [2:11:31] Generally, I think Mr. Harris indicated that the road is going to be a fairly low speed roadway and really isn't conducive to high speed. [2:11:42] So hopefully that won't be a problem. [2:11:43] Okay, thank you. [2:11:44] And my time is up. [2:11:45] Thank you so much. [2:11:47] Yeah. [2:11:47] How's it going to grow? [2:11:50] Thank you, Mayor. [2:11:52] I do have a handful of questions. [2:11:53] So I'll go through them fairly quickly. [2:11:56] One, I do have to say the open lands there by the part department, I believe that's the part department and then down the road next to 470. [2:12:12] I'm not quite sure how they are going to be public lands. There's really not an ability to access them. [2:12:21] So I would I would like to see what broomfield plans to do with them in the in the future can we plant more grasses, so it's just not a a lead induced environment like they pretty much are right now to make him a little prettier and nicer for for the neighborhood and and before I go to my next question anybody have any comments about that. That's just a concern, but I'll give you an opportunity to reply. [2:12:56] Okay, Jennifer has a, are there any plans for the open space up? [2:13:06] Good moment. [2:13:08] Mayor Queen Kevin Stambert here. [2:13:09] What we would do is we would with other open spaces in the portfolio. [2:13:14] We would program the sites for a management plan and would work with OSTAC [2:13:19] and prepare that the management plan would suggest any improvements any trails. [2:13:25] Obviously, there's oil and gas in the area so we don't, you know, we want to wear that in any planning that goes on. [2:13:34] So we would expect the first step once those lands are acquired is to do a management plan for the open space. [2:13:41] Perfect. [2:13:42] Thank you very much. [2:13:43] I appreciate that. [2:13:44] And then another question, a follow-up question to Council Member Anderson. [2:13:49] I am too worried about that main street there. [2:13:52] I'll jump into my questions because she covered a lot of them, which would be the maintenance of the lights since that's a private road [2:14:00] That would not be broomfield's responsibility, which would be the lights that are in the road. Is that a correct statement? [2:14:10] That is correct. [2:14:11] Okay, and then [2:14:14] Also in regards to the maintenance of snow removal. I'm assuming that would be you guys [2:14:20] have you had any issues with blades hitting those lights and cracking them? I mean I just don't [2:14:27] see how they are good for our Colorado weather or winter environment is what would be your [2:14:36] concerns in that regards. So the product I was specified is actually used in Denmark and all over Scandinavia [2:14:44] So much COVID temperatures, more snowfall than here. [2:14:51] So we anticipate it being a very durable product [2:14:54] and if applied correctly shouldn't be maintenance hassle for. [2:15:00] The Metro District. Wow. Thank you. Okay. Well, technology is a great thing. And then one of my questions I already answered. I had concerns about the great pictures, but if those pictures had architectural requirements and metrics and I believe Mr. Harris already is addressed that. So thank you. [2:15:20] Um, very quickly on the DRC, uh, great idea. [2:15:25] I really appreciate you guys having that rigor before it even comes to [2:15:29] room filled for that metro area and then in regards to the call-up provision, um, [2:15:34] a question for room fields, um, how would it count to remember, [2:15:41] um, no of the changes [2:15:43] to even call it up like where would we look and see those kind of things? [2:15:49] Thank you, come to remember for the opportunity to talk a little bit about that. [2:15:54] This would be unique. [2:15:56] So we believe that as Mr. Harris mentioned, there probably only be three or four builders [2:16:02] bringing through separate site development plans at separate times. [2:16:05] So these would be a communication from staff with a copy of the memorandum outlining [2:16:11] the details of the architecture and providing council with an opportunity to review. [2:16:16] there is a 10 day window with the review as outlined in the proposal, so I would expect that in addition to an initial notice that we have an application that's in and has been reviewed and approved by the city manager. [2:16:31] We would provide additional reminders during that 10 day window to make sure that there's ample opportunity to provide a call up, not just in a Friday, even email, but in a separate communication directly to council. [2:16:45] Yeah, I think that would be also be great just to add it on Tuesday, Council meeting agenda. [2:16:53] Maybe in the managers record or some other just to make sure it's on the agenda, also not just an email. [2:17:00] So thank you for that clarity. [2:17:02] And then also I just want to keep in the forefront of the development in regards to the school, [2:17:09] I, too, am concerned about this, where the kids will be going to school, but also, we are [2:17:18] once again putting a school kind of right smack in the middle of the residential, and I just [2:17:23] want to make sure that we're keeping an open mind and being very inventive like we have for the [2:17:39] historically put schools in the middle of residential areas with the intent of kids actually walking to school. [2:17:46] But that really doesn't necessarily happen in today's world for a number of reasons. [2:17:52] So I do want to start bringing that up as a concern before we design ourselves into a regular whole of school drop-off. [2:18:02] So no comments needed there. That was just a concern of mine. And thank you for bringing for sale units, [2:18:10] a portable unit, it's a attainable units to room felt. I think you guys are doing an amazing job in [2:18:17] working with affordable and attainable housing. Thank you. That's all I have, Mayor. I appreciate it. [2:18:25] Thank you. [2:18:26] Thank you, Mayor. [2:18:28] I'll start at the call-up provision in here. [2:18:32] I appreciate staff talking more about that. [2:18:34] I am concerned about the call-up provision with this application at this time. [2:18:39] You know, Council is currently in conversations about our development process. [2:18:43] And I would really like to have that process play out with Council and the conversations with Council [2:18:48] before we start to allow individual developers to propose outside of that and so I'm a little [2:18:55] uncomfortable with that piece of this project. And I would say that I would like to see this project [2:19:05] really kind of come to fruition. We're just getting into kind of the meat of baseline at this [2:19:12] point. We've kind of started out the fringe area and now we're really kind of getting into the [2:19:17] of baseline and I would like to really kind of see how that's going to progress before I start [2:19:23] to, you know, let out some of that rope in this development. So I would like to just be able to walk [2:19:29] along with as this development gets produced. One piece that has, you know, along with this development [2:19:40] a piece that I've been concerned about is the bike and pedestrian infrastructure there along the [2:19:47] are they're explained the past and the bike infrastructure that is going along with this development? [2:19:55] Yes, so the bike lane along E-Shiridan is a separate bike lane, so it's not a shared, it's a separate [2:20:03] bike path that will lead to a trail that will lead to that underpass. So it's all connected and safe. [2:20:13] So, I don't know if that gives you enough detail about that along Sheridan, but it's a separate, it's an individual pipeline. [2:20:22] Yeah, not really. [2:20:23] So this development looks like it's going to be, and I'm looking at page 16 of the council memo. [2:20:29] There's a great map there, which talks about the proposed multi-use trail, as well as the multi-let's see where is it. [2:20:42] the dedicated bike lanes. [2:20:45] So, you know, so I'm imagining and from looking at this map so correct me if I'm wrong, [2:20:51] but we are approving the infrastructure there along shared and along with this development. [2:20:58] Is that not the case? [2:21:00] That's fine. [2:21:01] Okay. [2:21:02] So, you know, so what we have right now is we have an on-street bike lane on shared in Boulevard. [2:21:11] That's great. [2:21:14] And then the only other bike infrastructure that we have is going to be that multi-use trail with dedicated bike lane. [2:21:22] And it looks like on page 16 that that bike lane goes clear away from shared in Boulevard and goes kind of through the middle of the baseline development. [2:21:32] And while that's not a part of this project that is a piece that I'm just kind of confirming. [2:21:39] That's great. [2:21:40] But we also, you know, this is designed as an urban development and so there are, you know, shared by conditions and slow, slow, local streets. [2:21:54] So we can believe that it will be a safe and bicycle friendly neighborhood. [2:22:00] Okay, I mean, I guess I can see that within the neighborhood itself, but, you know, I brought up my concerns about that on-street bike lane on shared and, you know, my desire was to get that get a separated bike lane, there going parallel with shared and looks like that bike lane is going to end up not going through the middle or not going along shared and or, you know, kind of that separated bike lane, but more that dedicated bike lane going through the middle of baseline instead. [2:22:28] uh MMM [2:22:30] I read in that correctly, Kyle. [2:22:36] If you're just real quick, and then perhaps you can fill in. [2:22:39] I think Kyle and maybe comes on with Chef Kevin Simmer chair. [2:22:43] A long shared in addition to the buffered on-street bike lane. [2:22:47] There is also a fairly wide walk, slash bike path, a long shared in. [2:22:54] What is the dimension of that shared use pathway? [2:23:00] That is 12 feet. [2:23:02] So, 12 feet, that's intended for bicyclists and pedestrians, and that's a number of [2:23:08] staff, you have the on-street bike lane, then you have the off-street 12-foot sidewalks, [2:23:14] that's bike trail. [2:23:17] No, I appreciate that, because it just, it wasn't clear when I was looking through the maps on [2:23:23] that. [2:23:23] So, that does give a lot of clarification on what's going on there, a long share, and I do [2:23:28] think that that's a great improvement over what our current practice is, with the [2:23:32] on street bike lanes, especially south of 144. [2:23:37] There is no buffer and traffic is whipping along [2:23:41] at the belt the same speed. [2:23:43] So I'm glad to see that that added buffer is there, [2:23:46] the infrastructure is there. [2:23:49] And that's not to discount the proposed multi-use trail [2:23:53] with dedicated bike lanes that's going through the baseline. [2:23:55] I think that that's a great addition [2:23:57] and I look forward to seeing that coming to fruition as well [2:24:00] because I do think that that is a great amenity for this development. [2:24:05] So I didn't want to discount it at all. [2:24:07] The other piece that I wanted to touch on was actually two more pieces. [2:24:12] One of them was the baseline specific micro a mass transit. [2:24:15] I believe that there will going to be some baseline specific micro a mass transit options [2:24:23] that were going to serve this area. [2:24:25] are any of those going to be serving a long shared and full of art or crossing shared and full of [2:24:31] art? So we're serving like a micro transit or things like you know scooters or you know other [2:24:40] forms of transit would follow along the trail system that's within East Village and then as far as [2:24:49] And as transit options, I think it's that wherever the city serves is where, you know, residents can walk to and catch the bus. [2:25:02] So I was I was going to go now without knowing what the specific micro transit options are or will be because it's hard to necessarily design for them, but we do have space built into our streets gates where [2:25:18] could accommodate, you know, micro transit stations in the future. [2:25:23] Okay, so for some, like, shuttles, and that's basically what I was trying to get out is [2:25:27] is that there was room that would be dedicated or to accommodate some of those shuttles. [2:25:33] And I see Kyle's not in his head. So that's great to hear because that was my big concern [2:25:38] is that we were going to end up without space for those dedicated stops or pickups, things like that. [2:25:45] because that is another great feature of this development, [2:25:48] is that kind of more micro-transit, [2:25:50] more small, mass-transit options. [2:25:53] If it happens, it becomes a never-shaft, [2:25:55] if I could, I think you would ask a question too, [2:25:57] whether that was going to be going on the other side of Sheridan. [2:26:00] Right, the original plan that we had was for that micro-shuttle [2:26:06] to be interior to the community on the east side of Sheridan, [2:26:10] so it would not be going to the west area. [2:26:12] So there were two loops that we had planned interior, but not to the west of Sheridan. [2:26:18] Right, but there's a bit, I mean, you know, the big, the big one right there is, and I'm not quite sure that the, the, the, the, the, the perpendicular street to Sheridan, but there is a pedestrian underpass. [2:26:31] There are a long Sheridan's. Hopefully one of those quick us is going to be around there. [2:26:35] So at least those folks that are on the west side of Sheridan will be able to cross safely to the east side of Sheridan. [2:26:42] and then be able to pick up that mass, [2:26:44] small mass transit option. [2:26:46] Thanks, David. [2:26:47] Great, good to hear. [2:26:48] All right, that's all I have for Mayor. [2:26:50] Can you count some on a limb? [2:26:52] I wanted to pick up on something with walkability [2:26:55] and connectivity there that Devon was skiing onto. [2:27:00] The, so I see the eventual connectivity here, [2:27:05] but given the phasing of the project [2:27:09] And the unknown timing here, it seems to me like that connectivity to, you know, to, to, to, to, say, [2:27:21] say highway seven in that is somewhere off in the distance and to talk about this as it's connected to say highway seven is not in the current plans. [2:27:34] can can the developer address the timing, otherwise it looks like this little chunk that you're [2:27:40] using as phase one is going to be very isolated and not able to connect to what it should be [2:27:48] connecting to on state Highway 7. Yeah, thank you council member. Lynn, actually the project that [2:27:54] we're working on right now with the expansion of Sheridan Road does have sidewalks on both sides [2:28:01] So that when the East Village neighborhood is put in place, there will be connectivity to that sidewalk, which leads right up to Highway 7. [2:28:12] And it's sidewalks on both sides of the street. [2:28:15] In addition to that, where there is the great separated underpass that Council Member Schaff was just referencing, [2:28:23] part of the first phase of east village is to actually have a ramp, an ADA accessible ramp, [2:28:31] which leads from Sheridan and wins its way down so that you can then access underneath [2:28:36] that great separated crossing to the other components of west village. [2:28:42] Okay, I guess that will have to do for now, but I'm sure eventually it will be helpful for [2:28:49] people to actually cut through, you know, on the diagonal through the development and that's when [2:28:54] that's there. Then my other question is about oil and gas facilities. So it's the staff, [2:29:04] this is directed to the staff, I think first. So we have the practices to the oil and gas facilities [2:29:12] map with a legend, which is very helpful. Thank you. The legend on the map, there is [2:29:21] marked an approved permit to drill in green, 884 feet to the southwest of this development. [2:29:34] Can the staff address that approved permit to drill? I have no idea what that is. [2:29:41] Thank you, Councilmember William. I may have to pull additional information from the COGCCs website to see exactly which well that is. We pull our information from COGCCs website directly and some of these may have been permitted. [2:29:57] But the timeline for that. [2:30:00] That permit, I just would like to pull that information from COJC to be able to provide that to you. If that would be acceptable. [2:30:11] Yes, but I mean, if someone can actually drill there, I mean, I'm not going to prove this development within 800 feet. [2:30:23] I'm just not, so I'm, you know, we're missing information here and there's also wells that are marked on here that are abandoned locations, [2:30:39] Brian abandoned that aren't clearly marked that they're plugged in abandoned. There are other wells that are marked plugged in abandoned, but you know, it's not clear exactly what state all of these wells that are surrounding this development are in. [2:31:00] That's not clear at all to me. [2:31:03] And there should be no additional wells to be drilled other than the extraction wells that obviously are in various stages of process along the Northwest Parkway. [2:31:15] But there are no new wells that should be drilled in this area. [2:31:18] So I can pull that information. [2:31:19] I'm not sure if Tammy Gillico is also looks like she's available. [2:31:23] She need to address them as well. [2:31:26] Tammy was just promoted in Anna. Tammy, can you speak to that briefly and then we can do a follow up with needed? [2:31:33] Sure. So the one that is marked approved permit should drill. In fact, there is an approved permit by COGCC but obviously no drilling has occurred yet. [2:31:47] So that's probably an older permit and we would have to look into a little more deeply with [2:31:55] COGCC to see if it could be, would still be in place given the other activity in the area. [2:32:02] And then as for the plugged in abandoned wells, did you have a question on those Councilmember [2:32:07] Lim? [2:32:08] Well, some of them are marked in green, darker green, plug in the end and some of them are [2:32:16] just pink abandoned location, some of them are, and then there's one that's the closest [2:32:22] that's marked dry in abandoned. [2:32:24] So the abandoned location means the operator plan to drill, but they've never done that. [2:32:30] Okay, but there's an outstanding, outstanding permit is that it also, an outstanding [2:32:37] ability to drill there? Yes. And then the dry in a band in means that the well was drilled [2:32:43] and nothing was found and the location was then abandoned in accordance with the law. [2:32:49] And then I just wanted to mention for the two plugged in abandoned wells that are shown [2:32:55] at 7.58 and 1 at 8.84. In fact, 1 at 7.58, it was plugged in a bandit in May of 2019, and we don't [2:33:11] have any records that showed any contamination at that site. And then the other one to the [2:33:17] Southeast of the project at 8.084 feet did was plugged in a bandit by extraction. There was some [2:33:24] oil contamination, but that was remediated in accordance with the law and signed off on by the [2:33:30] Kara oil and gas conservation commission. [2:33:36] I would like to propose that minimally given this location that we exchange, expand the [2:33:47] notification difference distance on the disclosures. [2:33:51] So, right now we're following our municipal code, which is outdated, I think, and limited in that it only requires notification within 200 feet. [2:34:15] And it's in the final plat, [2:34:20] in the general notes on the first page, on 0.8 and 0.9, what the disclosure distance is, according to the municipal code. [2:34:29] So I would, I would like to ask the developer if he's, if the developer is at least willing to expand the disclosure notification radius to fit what we have adopted as an area of concern for oil and gas development within a distance of residences and that would be 2000 feet. [2:34:55] So I would like to suggest that the developer consider expanding the notification rate of radius there. [2:35:05] For the plug in abandoned wells, and next, and in the distance to the existing producing wells to the south to 2000 feet. [2:35:20] Does the developer want to expand to that or does Anna? [2:35:23] So just for some context, the approved permit to drill is 2,597 feet away from our development. [2:35:36] Thank you, and Council Member Lim, if I could add just a little more context. [2:35:41] I think there's a bit of confusion with what is shown from the COGCC website, and I'm not entirely sure why, but we entered into a right-of-way [2:35:51] development agreement with extraction, which provided for the plugin in abandoning any wells [2:36:00] of all wells that are located within baseline. And there was a time frame associated with [2:36:07] that. And so some of the ones that you see that have already been plugged in abandon are per [2:36:12] that schedule. There may be a few others that have not yet been plugged in abandon, but are on a [2:36:17] to have that be accomplished, and we were very careful to ensure with extraction and others who might have drilling rights that those were in large part. [2:36:35] I can't say definitively entirely because there may be a few small mineral ownership interests, but the vast majority were with extraction. [2:36:46] and we have removed their ability to drill wells on our property. [2:36:56] So, I think it's hard for me to speak to a well that may or may not be within 800 feet. [2:37:04] And I apologize, they just don't have that in front of me. [2:37:06] But we were very careful to ensure that our surface was going to be free from oil and gas drilling. [2:37:14] Councilmember, I would add that our agreement only does not allow extraction to drill any other wells in those that are authorized by the agreement. [2:37:24] Okay, I'll accept, I'll accept that that we're not going to have further drilling up there, even though the, [2:37:30] The legion seems to be misleading there. My request is still that the plug-in abandon, well, the plug-in abandoned wells, my premises that the plug-in abandoned wells can still end up being a problem. We know that. Davis 436 is a problem in Anthem Highlands. We know that. [2:37:54] So, I request, I'm asking the developer if he is willing to expand the radius of notification to 2000 feet. [2:38:07] And I would respectfully ask if we are going to be asked to expand the notification for the plugged in abandoned wells. [2:38:16] is that something that would then extend to all plugged in abandoned wells with [2:38:21] in broomfield because it does seem a little bit odd if we were being singled [2:38:26] out for such notification others. We're similarly tasked with such notification. [2:38:38] I can only speak for myself if you're asking me, I'm going to, I'm going to bring [2:38:43] point. I will bring this point forward in any development that comes forward, but you know that's [2:38:50] just me speaking for myself. So I would answer affirmatively if that becomes a policy [2:38:55] throughout broomfield and does not unfairly disadvents, disadvantages us, then yes we will [2:39:00] to follow that. [2:39:04] Thank you. Thank you, Jean. [2:39:07] Council Member Lens, that. [2:39:09] It is real quick. Thank you, Mayor. I was only going to speak to the call-up, you know, [2:39:14] we're here at 9 o'clock at night and we have five more agenda items and reports left. [2:39:18] And we have an extra meeting on two more meetings. This year and we've added an extra [2:39:23] meeting each month. So I think this is a good opportunity to experiment and try [2:39:29] this call up, but we need to try at some point [2:39:31] because something's got to give. [2:39:34] And I think I'm like winning a proposal [2:39:37] is the perfect time to at least experiment [2:39:42] and attempt it. [2:39:43] So that's all I got, Mayor. [2:39:44] Thank you. [2:39:46] Mayor Broadtemp, yes, Roya? [2:39:49] Thank you, Mayor. [2:39:51] And yeah, I think it's an interesting idea [2:39:56] that you'll remember when set brought up [2:39:59] about, you know, given in a trial run, [2:40:02] but I do have questions because I'm still, [2:40:04] it's a new procedure and we haven't allowed this before. [2:40:08] So I just want to make sure, I understand how it's going to work [2:40:13] because when I read, [2:40:18] there's a time limit, right? [2:40:23] So the call-up can happen in a 10-day period [2:40:27] after the approvals but we won't know until we get [2:40:32] notification from the city manager so I just need to know [2:40:37] what that looks like because we're not doing that now we haven't [2:40:41] finalized our processes so maybe that knows more than me can [2:40:46] explain how that works. Jennifer I think it was a suggestion that [2:40:53] there was a suggestion made that it'd be including on the [2:40:57] agenda of the items that could be called up, so there would be an official notification and [2:41:02] and click on that with Jennifer once you go in and address the question. [2:41:06] Thank you, Mayor Protem. [2:41:08] This is the item that we discussed at the coordination meeting that as we move into the new [2:41:15] policy and procedures that this would be the trial run or the pilot project to see how well [2:41:20] fact it worked. So again it was parallel to what the call-up provision was going to be as we [2:41:29] walked into kind of the the the refresh of planning and zoning and this was the first project [2:41:36] that we wanted to try the capability to see if in fact with that call-up procedure and of course [2:41:43] by adding it to the agenda that would be the heads up to council that there is something [2:41:47] And identified after the group had walked through what the architecture plans looked like, [2:41:54] whether they matched, whether they were in alignment with what Council had given to staff [2:42:01] in prior conversations. [2:42:08] You're muted. [2:42:10] Mayor Pro Tem, you're muted. [2:42:16] Sorry. [2:42:18] It says here that upon receiving the manager's statement and no later than 10 calendar days after [2:42:24] the date of approval. I didn't say agenda. So what agenda are we talking about? Are we supposed [2:42:30] to be looking at P and V agenda now? [2:42:33] I think the intent was that the city manager on the agenda that it would be reported, what [2:42:42] item that are within that 10-day period. And I was suggest that there was a way to formally [2:42:50] to pay us in the public through the agenda and this would be the city manager's report that [2:42:56] it would specifically identify what items are within that period. [2:43:03] Okay, so it's been the manager's [2:43:06] report. That was the suggestion. It's a suggestion because there's no plan and plan yet. [2:43:15] City manager? [2:43:19] I think the suggestion came from Council Member Anderson this evening that it [2:43:23] in fact be a separate item and wouldn't be in the SAMO report and thus wouldn't be lost, [2:43:30] but it would be a separate email and not only an email, but it would in fact be on the agenda, [2:43:39] so it would be calling it out and Council wouldn't have to look for it. [2:43:44] Calling it out where. [2:43:49] I'm really confused now because I've heard now CMO report [2:43:53] update and agenda and I just need to know what this process looks like before I agree to it. [2:44:01] And thank you, Mayor Protem. So we're adapting from three different council member comments on how to make it work tonight. [2:44:12] So we're moving right along with you on how best to communicate this. [2:44:19] If Council member Anderson, she provided some [2:44:27] thoughtful, comprehensive idea that from a staff perspective we all said that's a great idea in order to get that out. Council member Anderson, would you mind restating that for us please? [2:44:41] Sure, all I stated was that there needs to be some type of affirmative, like we all need to [2:44:48] I don't want to get lost anywhere, so I did not indicate a specific place just that I want to make sure that we see it and we acknowledge that we [2:44:56] I don't want to lose this one that's all so no specific place [2:45:01] That's all. That's all I had. Thank you. [2:45:09] Okay, well, the idea, I just really feel like we need to have a process. [2:45:15] Because otherwise, we're agreeing to something we don't even know what we're agreeing to. [2:45:19] Is that fair? If there's no process in place, how can we, is it going to work? [2:45:31] If we recommend that if in fact when this occurs, that we will outside of the email, so not in the CMO update, there's just too much that occurs on those CMA CMO updates and being appreciative of the council's time. [2:45:53] So from Anna's perspective, if it's within that 10 days, [2:45:58] you all will receive a separate notification [2:46:00] and the subject line will indicate the specific project, [2:46:05] the bullets of what it is, what it should be [2:46:09] and what our concerns are if it is. [2:46:20] And so you would be sending us an email? [2:46:28] Yes. [2:46:32] We do get a lot of email and things get missed, [2:46:34] though I think there needs to be a contingency. [2:46:41] Because the clock starts ticking as soon as they make their decision and then we have a 10-day limit to call it up. [2:46:50] So I don't think this was fleshed out. [2:46:52] I'm not against the idea. [2:46:54] I like the streamlining, I like the time saving, but I don't think this process has been fleshed out. [2:47:01] And I would feel more comfortable if it was. [2:47:04] And I do support Council Member Limbs proposal to increase the informed consent radius. [2:47:13] It's not that asking that much. [2:47:15] It doesn't do any harm, but it does ensure that people deciding to live near an oil and gas know that they're doing it. [2:47:24] And I don't think that's asking too much. [2:47:26] We're not trying to to limit your development, but we do ask that as many people that can be informed, [2:47:32] And no, when you're buying, which saw a lot of problems, because that's a big issue right now, [2:47:39] because there was no importance in that, and there was no requirement to let people know. [2:47:44] And I really want to change that. [2:47:48] Now that we know better, we do better. [2:47:52] And yeah, those are my thoughts. [2:47:55] I'm just a little hesitant. [2:47:56] I think it would be a great trial run to try to call up with McWitty, because I do. [2:48:02] trust their product and everything that they've done with baseline so far. But I just [2:48:08] want I want the process to be clear and it didn't sound like it was. [2:48:16] Thank you. [2:48:19] Okay. John, so I have a test CA. [2:48:23] Thanks. These are really good comments. Something that's coming up for me is that the, [2:48:29] you know, when we call a special meeting or whatever, the clerical say, please respond. [2:48:33] And so maybe if there are no responses from a particular council member, there's like a call or something that goes out. [2:48:45] Because even though we get a please respond or must respond by noon, you know, if you're like out, you won't see it before noon. [2:48:55] So I don't know if it is a text, it could be a text or a phone call, and I think that texts for sure along with the email could really sure up a way to I guess alleviate any of the concerns fellow council members have shared I think there's a way to do it. [2:49:22] And quite honestly, I feel like Kyle's been at every meeting we've had for the last three [2:49:29] months. [2:49:29] So I think we're going to see him again. [2:49:33] So I, you know, I just, and I don't want to make light of the seriousness of, you know, [2:49:41] this trial, this pilot, because I think that while I appreciate it, I think, yeah, I don't [2:49:51] want to miss it and I think those who have, you know, I could easily miss it. I'll just put it [2:49:59] that way. So a text would actually be really good for me. And maybe there's a preference that [2:50:05] each council member has, but La La. And I, I remember, council member Tessa, thank you for that. [2:50:14] And so, from a staff perspective, until we iron it out, we will guarantee that we will be in touch with each one of you by some method [2:50:27] to ensure contact. [2:50:32] Like, contact, yes, and like, a reply from the council member, the council member has to equally kind of contribute and say yes, I got it. Thank you very much. Whatever it might be. And then, you know, get back within that time. [2:50:49] So that's kind of all I had. I think there are really great questions that were asked tonight. [2:50:55] I don't have others. [2:50:57] Ki, I'm going to go to the council member, Hank Olnex, and understanding the chef has his hand up. [2:51:04] I don't think she's spoken yet. [2:51:06] Thanks, Mayor. Yeah, I heard all these questions tonight and I had the questions about the [2:51:13] tools, too, so they key council members and some brass and more question. [2:51:18] As far as the call-ups go, I remember when we talked about the streets go and I said, let's [2:51:23] put it on something that's really consistent each week. [2:51:27] If it means that we need an email, and then I even think something on our calendars that [2:51:32] gives us a deadline, I just want us to, you know, always look at our calendars. [2:51:37] And we could put the deadline for that specific project along with the link to that project in that deadline and, you know, a ways to call it up. [2:51:49] So I think, you know, I remember talking about that, that we, you know, should have something that's consistent and they were always looking at. [2:51:56] So, and as far as important consent, I am hesitant to do it project by project, I feel [2:52:04] like we need to make a program make a decision, we should make it a specific decision [2:52:07] for all of room field. If the equipment is willing to do it, I would really appreciate it [2:52:12] because I respect council member Lens in our comments in this. But I really do want to advocate [2:52:19] this should be for you know all development and so I think that that's you know [2:52:26] important to me to make sure that we're being fair to our developers. [2:52:30] And that's it for tonight. Thanks. [2:52:32] That's very shaffled. [2:52:35] Thank you, Mayor, for let me go again. [2:52:38] So, you know, Mr. Harris, he talks about, you know, advantage and disadvantage to your project versus other projects. [2:52:45] And I think by, you know, with this call-up feature and by including that with this proposal and with this approval tonight, [2:52:51] I do think that it disadvantages other projects and it advantages your projects. [2:52:57] And I really do think that this call-up feature needs to be separate from the approval tonight, [2:53:03] that while this may be the test run for it, and maybe that's a staff and council decision, [2:53:08] it should not be tied to the approval of this project tonight. That's my opinion. [2:53:13] So, you know, if I'll be making a substitute motion to, you know, to remove that caveat with this proposal tonight, [2:53:23] But, you know, I would like to see this project go forward. [2:53:28] And I would like to see it go forward with the 2,000 foot notification that Council Member [2:53:33] Lim brought up. [2:53:35] I do think that that is something that I'm going to continue to advocate for for the rest [2:53:39] of room field as well. [2:53:40] I do think that that's very important. [2:53:42] We've seen studies on the effects of oil and gas up to 2,000 and beyond. [2:53:49] So I think 2,000 foot is a minimum. [2:53:51] And for me, and I will continue to advocate for that throughout the rest of the room field. [2:53:55] So I'd like to see that included with this proposal tonight and approval tonight. [2:54:03] The, you had talked about the, the plugging in a banding of these wells and the agreement that you had with extraction is, [2:54:11] is the plugging in a banding, is that tied to when the, the drilling of those mineral, [2:54:16] So at least this happens, so for instance, will these wells be plugged in a ban and when the drilling of the United Pad happens and when the North West A and B happens? [2:54:31] I'm going back into memory a bit, but my recollection of our agreement that we have with extraction oil and gas is that the plug and abandoning deadlines are hard and fast deadlines. [2:54:45] Okay, that's good to know, that was that was something that gave me a little bit of worry is that those weren't going to be [2:54:55] Plunged in a ban and until those those mineral releases were drilled on the United North West pads [2:55:01] Because if that was the case that timeline may be pushed out as those aren't being drilled at this point, so [2:55:08] I'm glad I'm glad to hear that those are hard and fast and those wells will be plugged in in a band and [2:55:14] And if I can't count some members check I apologize. I just got notification from others on our team that all the [2:55:20] wells have been plugged in a band in north of a hundred and sixty-th [2:55:24] Oh, basically. [2:55:25] All right, so we need to make sure that COGCC, up to care of maps on this [2:55:32] Great, we'll put in any email. I'm sure [2:55:35] And so I appreciate this project. [2:55:41] Again, I will make a substitute motion. [2:55:44] I think perhaps along with Council Member Lam for the 2000 foot notification along with the removal of the kind of call-up procedure. [2:55:57] If I can, just in the interest of consistency, I would suggest that if the desire is not to [2:56:06] have a call-up provision because it unfairly advantages us, it seems it's to be consistent to then [2:56:14] say that there is a notification requirement for 2000 feet, which is only on us, similarly [2:56:19] seems to bring up that a little bit of inequity there. So we just offer that up as it seems to me there would be one or the other but again, it's ultimately Council's decision. [2:56:36] Okay. Council member Anderson. [2:56:40] Thank you. And Ashley, I was just going to confirm what Carol Harris has said. I was well, well we're doing this meeting. I was actually on this year to see you website, you know, [2:56:50] So, you know, assuming around there, and yes, there is no no wells that are not plugged in a band, and so it does confirm what you are also saying that, and I think those are dark green dots and not late green dots and so I think they actually were plugged in a band in a recording and that is all consistent. [2:57:07] And I do want to note that I don't think there's going to be much of a change for a 2000 foot notice versus a 13 20 foot. [2:57:16] Um, if you look at where I was also located, um, that is a bigger console discussion that [2:57:21] we need to have after this experience with Davis 436 while I think we, we understand that [2:57:26] the difficulties that we run into with these plugged in the better well. [2:57:28] So I do support that. Um, but still, um, if you, if you could, uh, Mr. Harris, if you could [2:57:35] go over again, the, the reasoning for the, moving this faster and the cop provision and the closing [2:57:41] on homes and trying to help ease cost-own. [2:57:43] Could you reiterate what the benefit of this call [2:57:47] a procedure was in why you were requesting it? [2:57:52] That would be helpful. [2:57:53] Sure, AS Council Member Anderson. [2:57:57] Certainly, the time that it takes to get on agendas [2:58:02] and, as mentioned previously, are experienced [2:58:05] with West Village as it takes about three to four months [2:58:07] to get to the process as it currently stands. [2:58:10] where as administratively we anticipate that that would be three to four weeks. [2:58:15] So that's the first piece and I kind of hinted at this idea of far east village neighborhood trying to coordinate the closings on our builders simultaneously and you may well, well, why you do that? [2:58:29] Well, our infrastructure is so expensive. [2:58:33] We need to get the revenues. [2:58:35] This isn't making more information I should be getting, but we use revenues from the transactions, [2:58:40] from these closings to help pay for the infrastructure that is going into the ground. [2:58:47] And if there is this 3 to 4 month period where you have different builders that there is that much [2:58:54] variability in the process, it is much more difficult for us to say, hey builders, there's [2:59:01] administrative process that you can go through, and we have some reasonable expectation of closing [2:59:07] you all at the same time. Without that, if it's subject to as opposed to three to four weeks, [2:59:12] three to four months, it is much more difficult to coordinate that, and you say, why is that important? [2:59:17] Well, because one builder is not going to close and put their money in escrow if they don't know [2:59:21] that we're immediately going and doing the infrastructure. It's kind of like we all need to have them together. [2:59:25] I hope hopefully that helps. [2:59:30] Yes, that is hopeful and I still think that I can support that as long as we get this piece back from our staff that there's going to be some kind of an affirmative that they know that we did have that opportunity view as I think it's still hinges on on that piece to make sure that we are all prioritizing this and looking into it. [2:59:51] That's my concern. That a date will slip past. And then we will have missed out on opportunity. That remains my main concern. Thank you. [3:00:00] Thank you Mr. Mayor. I have confidence in staff's word and intent to make sure that we have a good communication process. Without in mind, I love the idea of a test drive of our new streamlined process and I'd like to call the question, if Council sir desires. [3:00:29] I'm going to get a chance of our hangle. [3:00:34] Thanks. [3:00:35] I realize I don't know. [3:00:36] And way in, I'm going to call it footage inside. [3:00:38] I apologize. [3:00:38] It's been a long day. [3:00:41] I'm okay with doing a test run, too. [3:00:43] I was called for visual. [3:00:43] And I think we can even over-communicate this time and see what really hits. [3:00:48] And then make sure that we have something in our calendars that you can put it down on. [3:00:52] But if we over-communicate it first, I think we'll be okay. [3:00:55] And then we can adjust for there. [3:01:01] So I mean, Catherine, I'm not sure what you make Catherine for a lot of times if I call the question, that means that you don't take the mayor should have a right to make a comment. [3:01:09] Well, Mr. Mayor, I would never deprive you of the right to make a comment, but how many agenda items do we have left? That's my main point. [3:01:20] Well, I'm still going to make a comment and the list council says I can't. So council, can I make a comment? Okay. [3:01:29] The, you know, I'll go ahead, you know, my comment basically is that the 2,000 point, [3:01:36] and we're talking about 2,000 point, I think if I understand correctly from a plug in a [3:01:39] abandoned wells, Gene is that you're talking about as well, and I guess that wasn't a word. [3:01:46] I mean, is the current regulations that have to 1320, does that include notification or [3:01:50] plug in a abandoned wells as now? [3:01:54] So that's a whole new concept because plug and abandon wells, I mean, that's a real new harsh concept that needs to be debated by council. [3:02:02] And so I think trying to put a two thousand foot notification on that tonight for this project is, [3:02:09] I mean, I just think we really need to discuss that. [3:02:11] And I understand the problems of 43. [3:02:14] And when I saw the, when I saw the trenching that we're talking about doing on on the neighborhood, [3:02:19] I was real concerned about that. [3:02:20] I mean, what that man. [3:02:22] But I think we do need to address a G-New and I've had a lot [3:02:25] or Caspar 11U and I've had a lot of discussions. [3:02:28] On my concerns about, you know, plugging wells [3:02:30] that are legacy wells in. [3:02:32] So I think it's a whole separate issue. [3:02:33] I will say on the call-up provision in the test run, [3:02:37] I will point out that if you saw the committee [3:02:40] that McWenney has, that, you know, [3:02:42] this got, you know, one of my favorite people, [3:02:44] Amy Yardor, you know, wanted and, and, you know, [3:02:48] that's different than any other project in town, to my knowledge and so we're a, it's a great one to have it, you know, the test run, so I'm, I'm just going to make, those are my accounts, thank you council for allowing me to speak tonight. [3:03:04] So, we will go [3:03:11] to Council's Royal Proposed Resolution of 2020-247. [3:03:19] Will the clerk please repropose resolution number 2-020-247 by title? [3:03:27] Resolution 2020-247, approving the North Park filing number 2, [3:03:32] Reflect the dash final clap, site development plan and sub-dividing improvement agreement. [3:03:41] Is there any motion? [3:03:47] Councillor Valencia. [3:03:49] Yeah. [3:03:49] Thank you Mayor. [3:03:50] I move that resolution number 2020-247 be adopted. [3:03:56] All right. [3:03:57] Yeah. [3:03:58] Councillor Valencia. [3:03:59] Second. [3:04:00] Okay. [3:04:01] Is there any discussion? [3:04:05] Thank you, Mayor. [3:04:07] I do have some discussion in a substitute motion. [3:04:10] So I just want to clarify with Councilmember Lim. [3:04:12] When you were talking about a 2,000 foot notification, [3:04:16] that's from all wells or is that from all active wells? [3:04:19] That's from all wells. [3:04:21] Great. [3:04:22] So I would like to make a substitute motion. [3:04:25] This would include Councilmember Lim's notification. [3:04:28] And so it would be that, pardon me, I just lost my page. [3:04:41] I would move it to resolution number 2020-2470 adopted with a 2000 foot notification for all [3:04:49] wells, as well as the call-up provision be removed from this proposal. [3:04:57] I second. [3:04:59] Okay. [3:05:00] Yeah. [3:05:00] Kazuro lives a limb second in. [3:05:03] Any discussion on the substitute motion? [3:05:08] Will the clerk call the roll? [3:05:13] Graham? [3:05:14] No. [3:05:16] Can't go. [3:05:20] You thirsty? [3:05:27] Five in? [3:05:29] No. [3:05:31] Lamb? [3:05:32] Yes. [3:05:34] When is that? [3:05:36] No. [3:05:38] Sarah? Yes. [3:05:42] Cassie? No. [3:05:46] Anderson? No. [3:05:51] Cassie? Yes. [3:05:55] For this year. [3:05:57] Sandra, did you hear that? [3:05:59] I didn't hear you. [3:06:00] Well, let me just say no. [3:06:03] So it fails. [3:06:04] 7 to 3. We'll go to the original emotion. Is there any further discussion in the original [3:06:12] emotion? The 2020 S247S draft to be adopted? I will ask the clerk to call the roll. [3:06:21] Take off? [3:06:24] Yes. [3:06:26] You're working? [3:06:27] Yes. [3:06:30] Well, Evan? [3:06:31] Yes. [3:06:33] Lynn? [3:06:34] No. [3:06:36] Lynn said? [3:06:38] Yes. [3:06:40] Shall? [3:06:41] No. [3:06:44] Cut the egg? [3:06:46] Yes. [3:06:49] Anderson? [3:06:50] Yes. [3:06:52] Calcio. [3:07:00] Yes. [3:07:04] So it passes 73. [3:07:09] Correct. [3:07:13] Samantha. [3:07:14] 23. 73. Okay, it passes 73. So we'll move on to agenda item. [3:07:21] Gender item 11B, which is the public hearing and proposed ordinance number 2145. [3:07:28] Extending them. [3:07:30] We're offering more time on applications for use by special review. We're operating agreements to allow development, our operation of well and gas wells and our facilities within Brumfield. I will declare the public hearing open. [3:07:41] We will follow the city standard for public hearing procedures is previously stated. [3:07:49] Council has a copy of the agenda member and a staff will summarize. [3:07:53] will [3:07:58] shine Sullivan sitting county attorney. [3:08:01] On April 16th of 2019, last year, Governor Full of Science Senate Bill 1981 into law, [3:08:09] which authorized local governments exercise additional regulatory authority over oil and gas [3:08:14] operations without being preempted by state law or regulation. [3:08:19] In order to develop new regulations [3:08:23] to, in a thoughtful manner, that provides more clarity [3:08:26] and certainty to oil and gas operators about room fields requirements without trying to [3:08:31] simultaneously review and process applications to develop oil and gas wells, facilities [3:08:36] and projects, room field determined that a temporary moratorium on processing such applications [3:08:44] was necessary. [3:08:45] For the past 18 months, staff has worked diligently creating a public process, scheduling public [3:08:51] workshops and study sessions, researching regulatory options, and drafting regulations. [3:08:58] Process of drafting, reviewing, and revising regulations is ongoing. [3:09:03] On May 12, 2020 Council adopted ordinance 2123, which approved changes to the zoning code, [3:09:10] regarding oil and gas development, and adopted a 2,000 foot setback. [3:09:15] On May 26th of 2020 Council adopted ordinance 2125 extending the moratorium to December 4th of 2020. [3:09:26] Although the temporary moratorium has given us chance to draft needed amendments [3:09:31] and to the oil gas and other land use regulations, the COVID-19 emergency is delayed [3:09:37] regular city council business, and the business of the COGCC, and requires additional time [3:09:44] for staff to develop complete revisions to the new regulations and present the city council [3:09:49] for its consideration. And additional six months is recommended to provide sufficient time to [3:09:55] finalize oil and gas and land use regulations as authorized by Senate Bill 1981. [3:09:59] 1,88. Ordinance number 2145, which is under consideration, if approved on second reading, [3:10:06] we'll extend the moratorium up to it, including June 4th, 2021. That completes staff's presentation. [3:10:15] Thank you. We will proceed with public comment. If there's anyone who'd like be heard, [3:10:22] please press star three, state your name. First, the last name and neighborhood for the record. [3:10:30] I'm not noting anybody in the queue. [3:10:32] Mayor Pro Tem is there anybody I'm trying to get into the queue that you can see. [3:10:39] We will go to council member comments and questions next. [3:10:45] Is there any member of council as any comments or questions? [3:10:47] Please raise your hand and I will recognize you. [3:10:55] I'm not noting any comments from council. [3:10:57] So I'm going to say close up the public hearing. [3:10:59] There are being no further comments. [3:11:00] The public hearing before the city council is closed. [3:11:03] Next is Council's consideration of proposed ordinance number 2145. [3:11:07] Will the clerk please the clerk please read proposed ordinance number 2145 by title. [3:11:15] Order number 2145 extending the temporary moratorium on the processing or grouping of any applications for used by special review or [3:11:25] authoritative agreements to allow the development or operation of an oil and gas well or oil and gas. [3:11:32] But [3:11:55] the excess live event is in musicals, musicals ended with in [3:12:06] the city of County [3:12:07] of Burnfield in order to evaluate and adopt updated regulations as authorized under Senate [3:12:13] Bill FB-19-181 second reading. [3:12:18] Is there a motion? [3:12:20] Yes, whatever. [3:12:24] Yes, that ordinance, number 2145, be adopted on second reading and published by Title. [3:12:32] Is there a second? [3:12:34] Council. [3:12:35] Council. [3:12:36] I second. [3:12:38] Okay. [3:12:38] Is there any further discussion? [3:12:44] Will the clerk please call the roll? [3:12:48] Good. [3:12:48] Thank you. [3:12:53] Ma'am. [3:12:54] Yes. [3:12:56] Lim. [3:12:58] Yes. [3:13:00] Lim. [3:13:01] Lim sir. [3:13:02] Yes. [3:13:07] Gutier. [3:13:08] Gutier. [3:13:09] Yes. [3:13:10] Anderson. [3:13:12] Yes. [3:13:13] Thank you. Yes? [3:13:17] Burm? Yes. [3:13:22] Yes. [3:13:26] It passes unanimously. We will move on to 11C, which is the public hearing and council [3:13:35] consideration for four or another 2143. [3:13:38] Creating a chapter in the room field, municipal code, [3:13:41] temporarily cap third party restaurant delivery fees within Brookfield. I will now declare the [3:13:46] public hearing open. We will follow the city standard public hearing procedures as previously [3:13:52] stated. Council has a copy of the gentleman memorandum which staff will summarize. [3:13:58] Thank you, Mayor and council. Christine Francis Connie will walk us through the side of Christine. [3:14:05] I think the city and county attorneys office was asked to draft an ordinance [3:14:09] capping delivery fees charged to restaurants within the city due to the impact of the COVID-19 [3:14:15] pandemic on the restaurant industry. As seating in restaurants has been affected by the pandemic [3:14:21] defend a dependence on food delivery has risen and high fees may affect the ability of restaurants [3:14:27] to continue to be viable. When a consumer orders food through companies like Grubhub, [3:14:33] we're eat store dash and close to me if there is a fee that is charged directly to the restaurant. [3:14:37] So, Broomfield's proposed ordinance limits those delivery fees to rest charged for restaurants to 15% and also prohibits reduction in the compensation made to delivery drivers. [3:14:49] Staff has been in such with grubhub, Uber Eats and Dordash and these companies understand the reasoning behind the delivery fee cap. [3:14:57] Staff also checked in with those companies again after. [3:15:00] The October 27th, council meeting, and they provided no further comment on the ordinance. If the ordinance passes, it is set to expire on March 31st, 2021 in anticipation of warmer weather, and returned to outdoor dining. And if this is adopted tonight, it will go into effect on November 17th. That ends my presentation. [3:15:22] Thank you. We will not perceive a public comment. [3:15:27] Molly, identify your full name and I guess [3:15:31] you're with and you have three minutes. [3:15:38] Hi, good evening. My name is Molly Steineman. My name is Molly Steineman. My name is Molly Steineman. [3:15:41] I went to the Colorado Restaurant Association. Since the Council left for this proposal, [3:15:45] the need for this type of legislation has only increased. As you heard earlier, the transmission [3:15:51] of COVID-19 is ramping across the state and unfortunately, restaurants across the state and [3:15:56] the room field specifically are seen lower capacity limits than they are being increasingly [3:16:00] impacted by public health orders and the very unfortunate reality is that many restaurants [3:16:06] will not make it through the winter at 25-50% capacity. They just can't do it. It's an industry [3:16:13] that in the best of time operates on three to five percent margins and they simply just can't [3:16:17] make it work with reducing work capacities. [3:16:20] This temporary cap on the fees that restaurants pay to take out [3:16:22] and delivery third-party companies is incredibly important. [3:16:26] It really just leaves cash in the pocket of restaurants [3:16:28] who need every little bit right now [3:16:30] just to make it through the fall and winter months. [3:16:32] It's a reasonable measure. [3:16:34] It's temporary. [3:16:34] It really is just a temporary release. [3:16:37] Move that a local government can give [3:16:39] to help their restaurant to our survive. [3:16:41] So I would encourage you, yes, folks. [3:16:42] And I would encourage your support [3:16:43] at real estate restaurants. [3:16:44] Thank you. [3:16:44] Thank you. [3:16:47] I'm not seeing any other comments or anybody else of the queue for this item, so we'll go to questions for Council members. Council member Hankle. [3:17:01] Thank you, Mayor. I'll be really as close as possible. I did just a little bit more homework because I was concerned about how much. [3:17:06] The restaurant owners and the restaurants were making, you know, versus, you know, like for [3:17:14] tips, or instance. [3:17:15] I wanted to know if the restaurants are receiving the tips, or if just the drivers, or receiving [3:17:19] the tips. [3:17:21] And the restaurant owners are telling me that not only do they not receive any tips, only [3:17:26] the driver does, but people are adding them to their list for food and they are not being [3:17:34] to be added to those lists and so there's a lot of confusion with that. There's just a [3:17:39] lot of pressure on our restaurant owners right now and I can't try not to get emotional [3:17:43] a lot of it because 25% capacity for these restaurant owners and they're not receiving the [3:17:48] tips. That's really big for me and I want to reiterate that we've had an increase in deliveries [3:17:56] and so these companies are making a lot of money right now and so cap it at 15% you know I think [3:18:03] it's going to be important. I know a lot of people say, it's not a role in government. [3:18:08] Well, it's our role in government right now to help save lives. In that role, we had to step in. [3:18:13] We had to step in to save lives. And so in order to step in to save lives, in that regard, [3:18:19] we have to make sure that we counterbalance the lives of those workers. And those restaurant owners, [3:18:24] we have to make sure that we can do everything that we can to ensure their longevity and so they [3:18:30] you can see it to the winner, so thank you. [3:18:34] That's what we're interested. [3:18:35] Thank you, I just, we received a couple emails on this. [3:18:38] And I just want to clarify that there is, [3:18:42] I'm not sure how this happens [3:18:44] that some of these restaurants don't even have that chance [3:18:46] to weigh in, but this is, this is putting a cap [3:18:48] that is not to exceed 15%. [3:18:50] However, the very next sentence says, [3:18:52] the provisions of the section is [3:18:54] on not limit the ability of any retail [3:18:55] food establishment to choose to pay a higher commission. [3:18:58] So I read that to mean that if the clarification on this, but if this footage that much [3:19:05] didn't wants to, they can actually pay a higher commission on this, because I did not realize [3:19:11] this practice was even going on, and that this caption not reduced the compensation rates [3:19:16] paid to the delivery service driver, and it's only temporary. [3:19:19] So I just want to reiterate those points that this is not limiting that they can still add [3:19:26] on additional cost, whatever it cost to deliver it. [3:19:29] So I think I just want clarification on that bill. [3:19:32] He doesn't do the fact that they can pay more than 15% [3:19:35] than they want to. [3:19:36] And then beyond that, they can add on whatever [3:19:39] fee it takes to deliver the food. [3:19:41] And this is not stopping them from making money. [3:19:45] And is that a correct interpretation? [3:19:50] Council Member Anderson, you are correct. [3:19:52] So if a restaurant does wish to negotiate [3:19:56] a higher fee. They would still be allowed to do that. Okay, thank you very much. [3:20:05] That's where we're going to deserve to be. Thank you. That's just, just to hit that one [3:20:10] really quickly. I don't see any restrooms not going to have to negotiate to get a higher [3:20:14] fee. Just like no one's going to negotiate to be closer to an oil gas well. So I'm not sure if [3:20:19] I mean, it means a whole lot, but, and I'm sorry, Laura, I don't mean to, I mean, it's just [3:20:28] about there. I mean, this is a, I super understand the, the reason behind this is, this is a tough one for me. [3:20:34] Because I, I get what everyone is saying with the, the need to help our restaurants, there's no doubt that this is going to be a, a ridiculously tough, you know, [3:20:49] Just not sure this is the right way to say if you're going about doing it. I do have one question. [3:20:54] I don't know if Jeff is here on the line, remind or not. [3:20:59] But I did have a question about what the actual impact of this would be. [3:21:06] So I get this a few reduction. [3:21:09] But what does that really mean or translate? [3:21:12] I just don't think about that. [3:21:14] And not sure that's been mentioned. [3:21:17] Is that counselors? [3:21:20] Councilmember, if you wouldn't mind, I was being elevated in and saw a missed part of the [3:21:25] part so if you could repeat it. [3:21:27] Yeah, I'm pretty simple. [3:21:29] I just want to read what the actual impact of this is going to be. [3:21:34] So how much are the restaurants going to be saving on an average? [3:21:37] We can be talking, you know, single dollars. [3:21:39] We're talking hundreds of dollars. [3:21:40] I mean, how much? [3:21:41] You know, I'm just wondering how big a deal really is this? [3:21:46] Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem and Council members, we don't have a specific number, but we can all [3:21:53] do the kind of the math of it. A 15% fee, it will be in charge of 25% which is what we've [3:22:01] oftentimes heard was the fee that's a reference of the pain. So if it's a 10% reduction on a, [3:22:07] we'll call it an average $35 bill that would be $3.50. If they were doing, you know, [3:22:15] You know, 20 or 30 of those delivery bills or delivery services per night, then you're going to end up in $100 plus in savings. [3:22:30] To the restaurant. While that seems somewhat immaterial, $100 times $25 nights, it will add up to be $23,000. [3:22:41] And that's just a smaller size restaurant. And oftentimes, the restaurants were really talking about. [3:22:48] And so that $3,000 or so an additional revenue. [3:22:54] Because, again, remember, this is at the cost level of the restaurant, and so that will, [3:23:01] you know, it's going to be one more thing, and that's what's really important in all of this, [3:23:07] is this is not the only thing we're trying to do. As you know, we have enhanced room field, [3:23:13] we're doing other things, including expedited after seeding reviews and other things, [3:23:18] but this is that one more thing for another two or three thousand dollars to the average restaurant. [3:23:23] And that's a rough estimate, but that gives you a kind of a scale of what we think the effect would be. [3:23:29] Okay, I appreciate that. [3:23:31] And of course, some of them may have more savings and some may have less, but I think, okay. [3:23:37] So, I agree if it's a few thousand dollars that that would be real. [3:23:40] I'm not sure if it would save a restaurant that's going to go under, but that's real money though. [3:23:46] and I would never say that there isn't some. So I don't know if there was, I'm going to [3:23:52] definitely think about that one and I'm not sure that's going to change my mind. You know, [3:23:56] similarly, I understand that again, that the restaurants are going to be facing a [3:24:03] tough winter. I totally agree with that. I will mention that we did hear earlier tonight that [3:24:08] there is a light at the end of the tunnel, which is good. And there is a hopefully a vaccine [3:24:12] coming fairly soon. So this need should be fairly short lived. And four to six months [3:24:21] maybe I guess is what I've been hearing. So I think that's a good thing. And Jeff [3:24:26] as you mentioned, what I really do advocate for is that some of the things that we're already [3:24:33] dealing with, that's additional stimulus money from the federal government, whether there's the [3:24:36] enhanced brewfield money from from us specifically, something from the state. I mean, [3:24:41] Those things like a good behind that, I get that where we're putting in a very draconian [3:24:47] restrictions on our restaurants right now and they need to help them and I think for me [3:24:55] that's the way to go about helping them, I have a significant concern still about sort of [3:25:02] overreaching into this a private relationship between a delivery company and a private [3:25:11] restaurants and it's a get it Uber Uber eats whatever all that I don't know what I'm using [3:25:18] the companies grow up I get that they're not a sympathetic characters but by any means and the [3:25:26] restaurants are but they also you know just want to stress that this is a delivery service it's not a [3:25:33] necessary service for the you know for the restaurants or for the consumers and there's not [3:25:39] not play there are a number of different entities that are out there that provide the service, [3:25:44] it's my understanding. So, you know, I'm really, it's really something for the, [3:25:49] for the, if the, if the pressurist can't afford to pay the, then they're back in the [3:25:54] user and then the market will adjust to that and the press is what goes down. Similarly, [3:26:01] on other companies who come in and offer this on service, there were the restaurants themselves [3:26:04] can offer delivery service. So, I just not sure why we need to, to really get involved in [3:26:10] And, you know, in this particular sort of private transaction, and I also, I don't think [3:26:16] this has been mentioned. [3:26:17] It's not really a consumer issue either. [3:26:19] There's something that the data affects the rest are not going to make the food any cheaper [3:26:23] for the people that are actually using the service to have their food delivered. [3:26:31] So I get the reason you're not as special. [3:26:34] This is the, for me, at least not in the way they go to go about saving our restaurants. [3:26:38] certainly do want to do whatever anything we can to to say that Mr. Sir. This is the right thing to to be [3:26:46] sort of delving into. So it is really money. I'll continue to think about it over the next few [3:26:51] minutes, but at this point, I'm hesitant to be to be a yes, though. [3:26:56] Thank you, Mayor. Oh, my did want to clarify a couple things. The negotiation to to pay higher fees isn't [3:27:05] to negotiate to pay higher fees, like other council members, maybe think it's in case they want to pay [3:27:12] for extra advertising services. So say you want to partner with GrubHub and pay more money, [3:27:19] have a higher fee but they put you at the top of the menu or whatever. I mean that's that's why [3:27:23] that language exists. So it's for add-ons so that they have rat restaurants and these these third [3:27:28] the delivery companies have leeway to make those deals. This is for the base service of [3:27:36] just delivery. I did want to push back a little bit on the discussion about monopolies. [3:27:43] These are mostly large-tech companies based in San Francisco and they are consolidating. [3:27:47] There are less and less of these large national third-party delivery companies right now to [3:27:53] of the largest ones are negotiating to consolidate again. [3:27:57] So it's a shrinking field. [3:28:01] And there's a lot of, it takes a lot for the public [3:28:05] to know which companies provide this [3:28:07] and their household names at this point. [3:28:09] So it's very hard for a local restaurant to break in [3:28:13] and provide their own in-house delivery [3:28:16] when they're competing with companies [3:28:17] that are on television all day and advertising. [3:28:21] and you know that it becomes such such well-known things and people don't understand that the [3:28:26] services make it very, very hard for restaurants to make money. So I think this is a very reasonable [3:28:33] restriction to put on an industry that is doing on a on a on a service that is doing you know [3:28:39] remarkably well given the pandemic. They are benefiting immensely from the current situation [3:28:44] and ran, especially while we're limiting restaurants [3:28:47] to 25% capacity or they're the state is. [3:28:51] You know, there's no way these restaurants [3:28:53] are gonna survive and delivery has become [3:28:56] a necessary service. [3:28:57] And these large third-party delivery services [3:29:00] have taken up so much of the volume when it comes to delivery [3:29:05] that I think it's very reasonable. [3:29:08] And it ends at the end of March, you know, [3:29:10] this is not a permanent ordinance, [3:29:12] this is literally that help our restaurants during the during a once-in-a-lifetime, hopefully, [3:29:18] knock-on-wood pandemic. [3:29:20] So I think it's very reasonable. [3:29:22] The restaurants clearly want it. [3:29:25] The last thing I wanted to touch on, we're not the only ones in the metro area doing this. [3:29:30] Denver past it or the most conservative member of the Aurora City Council is actually carrying [3:29:36] the same ordinance. They're derango is considering it. Wheat ridges considering it and, you know, [3:29:44] bolder and long monarch considering a slightly different version of this, but there's a lot of, [3:29:48] a lot of local governments looking at regulating this stuff just for this year, um, in Colorado and [3:29:54] across the country and some form of others. So I just want to lay that out there for folks to think [3:30:00] I'm excited about this ordinance because I think it'll help our local restaurants survive. This is very, very trying time. Thank you, Mayor. [3:30:08] That's where we're going to land. [3:30:09] I agree with everything that Councilman Verlens said just said that this is a temporary measure that is needed under extreme circumstances to lead to keep our local restaurants in business. [3:30:20] I appreciated what economic director Romain said that there is there are needed a variety of measures to keep these at local restaurants afloat. [3:30:33] I noted that the Chamber and the Broomfield Community Foundation just partnered to create the Broomfield Small Business Fund. [3:30:40] That's one such avenue that these local businesses have to keep in operation. [3:30:46] And again, I stated last time, I look at this from the perspective of the workforce and my assignment to the workforce center board. What I'm hearing is that there is a large proportion of restaurant workers who are unemployed are in under long term plans to up scale their skills, but that's a long term plan. They need to feed their family right now. [3:31:16] And this is only over the next four and a half months, [3:31:19] but it may keep these people employed in our local businesses. [3:31:23] Thank you. [3:31:24] Thank you, [3:31:28] Mr. Mayor. [3:31:29] This certainly is an emotional issue. [3:31:34] With regards to the restaurants in town, there's a lot of wonderful restaurants [3:31:39] that are really struggling during this time. [3:31:42] I think we all know that. [3:31:44] But I agree very much with Councilmember Gisersky's comments in that I'm not sure why we're picking this particular relationship to get in the middle of. [3:31:58] Other than that it's it's new it is kind of the wild wild west to a certain extent. [3:32:03] But I'm really not comfortable getting in the middle of that relationship, especially since because it is a relatively new industry. [3:32:13] We don't have a sense and I haven't heard anyone discuss it as to the unintended consequences of this. [3:32:19] I, well, I can't remember Tessia did talk about this, but when we had the first reading on this, a little bit, in that many workers, many people that were employed in the restaurants are now driving for these delivery services. [3:32:36] And in the gig economy, they've simply shifted where, where and the restaurant, where in the food service industry, they are. [3:32:47] So I don't, I really don't have a good sense for if we, what the unintended consequences with this would be. [3:32:55] And I just, I'm really, really hesitant to get in the middle of this. [3:32:59] I would much rather see proactive support of our restaurants such as I think there's no end of [3:33:05] potential ideas. I tossed out one last time that maybe we all should get together and do a virtual [3:33:11] meal before we have our council meetings. I heard I think I'm next or something like that recently [3:33:18] someone putting together a virtual progressive dinner for neighbors or friends within town. I don't [3:33:26] how it worked, but it sounded like a neat idea. We could even, I know this is a radical idea, but [3:33:34] we could even encourage people to pick up their own meals from the restaurant on their way home [3:33:39] from work, which let's face it, would also save traffic and burning additional fuel, etc, etc, [3:33:48] which is just a little bit of planning ahead. So I'm very hesitant to put this into play. [3:33:55] I will notice from the consumer advocacy and this discussion, as I said on email at the council [3:34:03] a while about a week ago, I think there are credit card companies specifically American Express [3:34:11] that are forging partnerships with these folks, and if you have, I think I'm not sure it's [3:34:18] any American Express card, but certainly the one that I have, you can sign up for a year's worth of [3:34:24] membership, I think it's to Uber eats complimentary of American Express. So from the consumer aspect, [3:34:33] that end of it is being taken care of by the free market to a certain extent. That doesn't mean [3:34:40] that the restaurants are seeing any more money, but on the other hand, if that partnership between [3:34:46] American Express and Uber eats encourages people to buy more meals and have them delivered, [3:34:52] maybe the restaurants can survive longer. [3:34:56] So that's what I'm, that's the premise I'm working on, [3:34:58] but as much as I want to help our restaurants, [3:35:01] I'm going to be in no on this. [3:35:02] Thank you very much, Mr. Mayor. [3:35:04] Council Member Shaft. [3:35:07] Thank you, Mayor. [3:35:08] So I was really hoping that we would have some representatives [3:35:10] from Uber Eats or Grubhub or any of those third party delivery [3:35:14] services. [3:35:17] So in part of its clarification from them. [3:35:21] So some of my questions I have [3:35:22] maybe some of these are for staff. I'm not sure who can answer them. So a restaurant hasn't [3:35:26] option to sign up with a third party delivery service. Is that not the case? They aren't forced into [3:35:32] a into an agreement. [3:35:40] Mayor Council members, oftentimes the services also will list menus and list [3:35:49] restaurants. And sometimes the restaurant doesn't know that they're being marketed for on behalf [3:35:55] of them, and that has happened with some of the cases. In other cases, though, the Uber [3:36:02] Eats, RUB Hub, and DoorDash, will actually enter into agreements, specifically dating both [3:36:10] for advertising and marketing for it as well as other things, and that may include them [3:36:15] the delivery service. So in some cases, delivery service is being done without their [3:36:21] back to knowledge and then the bill is coming, that has been one of the consumer complaints that [3:36:26] has been voiced because oftentimes then the many of it has been offered through these services, [3:36:33] one necessary line with the current menu and that's been expressed a couple of times. [3:36:38] But it doesn't seem like this ordinance necessarily takes care of that. I mean that's a concern, [3:36:46] It's a concern that the Uber eats or any of those third-party delivery services are basically signing up. [3:36:53] Restaurants collecting fees from consumers and the restaurants themselves without any agreement by the restaurants. [3:37:00] That seems like something we should take care of. [3:37:03] But it doesn't seem like this is necessarily taking care of that issue. [3:37:06] They're still going to do that. They're just going to do it at 15% instead of a 30% markup. [3:37:10] But you are correct in that, it is something that one of the services when we talk to them [3:37:18] expressed if that was something that we wanted to do also take on, and the family was, [3:37:23] is that was beyond what the Council have proposed for us to consider within this audience. [3:37:30] Was whether we wanted to regulate a further relationship for a transaction that may be between two parties or not. [3:37:38] But that was not the direction that we were given by council as we began this process. [3:37:44] Well, I mean, it seems like that we should be taking care of more of the consumer protection aspect of this, you know, by the kind of more predatory. [3:37:52] The third party delivery services on restaurants and on consumers is opposed to getting involved in a possible negotiation where the, you know, the restaurant has the ability to sign, whether to sign up with a third party delivery service or not. [3:38:07] There are aware of those those delivery charges and the commissions that are going to be taking place. [3:38:12] And that is an agreement that they're signing up. It also seems that the customer themselves received adequate notification what the delivery fee and the tip fee. [3:38:21] are going to be for that delivery service? Is that not the case? [3:38:26] Again, mayor and council members. So this part of the fee, there is a fee that the customer pays. [3:38:34] Do you have the option if they would like to make a tip that is a voluntary transaction [3:38:38] also between them and the driver? But this is a fee that's on the restaurant that is not [3:38:45] that is not paid for by the consumer in a direct manner like you're talking about. So in effect, [3:38:51] What is happening in this relationship is the restaurant is painted delivery fee and the consumer oftentimes is painted delivery fee and then a tip on top of this [3:39:03] Okay, all right. Well, you know, I think that [3:39:06] I think that this is it we've kind of [3:39:11] I don't think we're going down the right road with this [3:39:14] I think that we're not necessarily taking care of the consumer protection problem with this, [3:39:19] whether it's the restaurant or whether it's the individuals, you know, [3:39:23] what kind of just put in a, I don't know, a bandaid on a flesh wound at this point. [3:39:28] There is a problem with the restaurant industry right now, and there's a major [3:39:32] belief with the amount of kind of restrictions that are on them right now in the [3:39:39] capacities in which they can have in their restaurants. [3:39:41] This is basically putting a bandaid on that flesh wound, which is, you know, and as you said, Mr. [3:39:50] Online, you know, that there are a lot of different strategies in which we need to take and we do need to take those. [3:39:56] But this isn't necessarily, in my opinion, the strategy that's going to help help most is what, you know, the idea of ensuring that the third party [3:40:07] delivery services aren't taking advantage of restaurants during this time. I think it's [3:40:12] something that we do need to take care of. We should not have, you know, be having third [3:40:16] party delivery services, imposing extra fees on top of these restaurants without their [3:40:22] consent, and that is something that we should take care of. We shouldn't, and we should ensure [3:40:26] that the notifications are adequate on consumers when they do purchase through these third [3:40:33] hearted delivery services. So I'm going to be a no on this ordinance tonight. [3:40:41] How's my list that? I think Mayor briefly, you know, I would note that the third [3:40:47] party delivery services were required to and they did not send an email or attend this meeting. [3:40:55] They were aware this is happening. They were wearing during first reading and during second reading [3:40:58] because this ordinance is very similar to the one in Denver, which they were very involved with [3:41:04] and stakeholder and, you know, those unintended consequences that people have mentioned, they're [3:41:10] not worried about. [3:41:11] I mean, they don't like the ordinance, but they're not here fighting it. [3:41:14] So that should speak for itself. [3:41:16] I mean, we shouldn't expect them to come and fight against an ordinance because they're [3:41:21] not here in the opposition to answer questions. [3:41:23] I think that's, you know, they had their opportunity to come here and they're not here. [3:41:28] Second of all, I would love if Council members would bring forward ideas to help our restaurant [3:41:34] industry. This is one bandaid that I brought forward as a way to provide that $2 to $3,000 [3:41:41] on two restaurants that they desperately need. So I think, you know, if other council numbers [3:41:46] have better or different ideas, you know, I think they should certainly bring that forward. [3:41:51] This is just one tool in a very full tool box, you know, we've gone out $2 million to [3:41:57] two local businesses impacted by the pandemic. So I don't really understand, you know, don't let [3:42:03] perfect to be the enemy of the good. [3:42:04] This ordinance will save our local restaurants [3:42:08] thousands of dollars a month. [3:42:10] They are asking for it. [3:42:13] So we have a limited time here to get something through [3:42:17] that will hopefully help some of these [3:42:18] the restaurants during this very hard winter. [3:42:21] So we're working in strange and extraordinary times here. [3:42:25] So I don't think we can workshop all of these ordinances [3:42:27] to be absolutely perfect every time, [3:42:30] but a band-day is better than nothing. [3:42:32] So that's all we've got to say, Mayor. [3:42:36] Thank you. [3:42:37] Not knowing any further comments. [3:42:42] The public hearing before the City Council is closed. [3:42:46] Access Council's consideration of proposed ordinance number 2143. [3:42:53] Will a clerk please read proposed ordinance number 2143 by title? [3:42:58] 4 December 2143, creating chapter 5-41 of the Brune Film Municipal Code to temporarily [3:43:06] have third party restaurant delivery fees within the city and county of Bruneville, second [3:43:11] and final reading. [3:43:14] I was going to see if anyone else wanted to, but I moved that ordinance 2143B adopted [3:43:22] on second and final reading in order to publish by title. [3:43:24] Mayor Proteau. [3:43:26] Second. [3:43:28] Is there any further discussion? [3:43:32] Will the clerk please call the roll? [3:43:37] Madam? [3:43:38] No. [3:43:41] Lim? [3:43:42] Yes. [3:43:44] Lim said? [3:43:45] Yes. [3:43:47] Chao? [3:43:48] No. [3:43:51] Chao? [3:43:51] Chao? [3:43:52] Chao? [3:43:54] Anderson? [3:43:56] Yes. [3:43:59] Yes. [3:44:01] Grim? [3:44:03] No. [3:44:05] Pinkle? [3:44:07] Yes. [3:44:09] You're thirsty. [3:44:14] So I have it passing six to four? [3:44:19] Yes, Samantha? [3:44:22] Yes, Mayor. [3:44:23] Six to four. [3:44:26] So we'll move on to 11D, which is Council's consideration. [3:44:30] for those resolution number 2, 0, 2, 0, 4, 10, 2, 60, authorized in approving an agreement between [3:44:36] Brookfield and Brookfield Fish for supplemental funding. [3:44:39] Before we begin our conversation on the side of them, I want to recognize Council Member [3:44:43] Tessie A for a point of personal privilege, Council Member Tessie A. [3:44:47] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [3:44:49] Yes, I'd like to ask for that personal privilege and let you all know that I am a staff member [3:44:57] at Brimfield Fish, and I must remember. [3:45:00] Excuse myself, and I'm hoping that someone will give me a holler when I can jump back on and rejoin the meeting. [3:45:08] Thank you. [3:45:10] Yeah, Jennifer. [3:45:12] I think what you've greeted, somebody was going to text her when we're done. Is that all been set up? [3:45:18] Thank you. [3:45:19] You'll be touched when you can rejoin. [3:45:22] Thank you. [3:45:26] Council has a copy of the agenda memorandum, which I'll ask staff to summarize. [3:45:31] Thank you, Mayor, and Council Dan Casey. Director of Health and Human Services will walk us through this brief item. Dan. [3:45:42] Thanks, Mayor. [3:45:43] Good evening, Mayor. [3:45:45] Mayor, Program and Members of Council, Dan Casey, Director of Human Services. [3:45:49] I wanted to quickly go through the presentation for the proposed resolution for supplemental funding for Greenfield Fish. [3:45:57] The 2021 council priorities include housing related initiatives and support those initiatives and to prevent more profound housing issues related to the effects from coronavirus pandemic in the months to come staff proposals that supplemental funding be provided to broomfield fish. [3:46:13] This recommendation is made, so that timely essential services can be provided to vulnerable [3:46:18] room field residents. [3:46:20] It's been impacted by COVID-19. [3:46:24] As you know, room field fish is a room field non-profit, they are the only non-profit [3:46:29] in room field that runs a food bank and a family resource center, specifically serving [3:46:34] room field residents. [3:46:36] Fish provides emergency basic need services for low-income residents to assist them, moving [3:46:41] towards self-sufficiency. Some of those services include direct financial assistance, keeping families [3:46:49] housed, emergency hotel voucher program, healthy foods, and support mentoring and referrals [3:46:57] through their family resource center program. If this proposal is approved, the fish would receive [3:47:05] $100,000 in supplemental funding to help meet urgent community needs. As part of their spending [3:47:11] plan, they broke down the $100,000, $20,000 would go to preventing hunger, $40,000 would go [3:47:18] to emergency financial assistance, $30,000 would go to keeping family's housed program, and $10,000 [3:47:27] would go to the emergency voucher hotel voucher program. [3:47:33] And I just wanted to also note that [3:47:35] this supplemental funding that's being proposed on this resolution is separate from the non-profit [3:47:41] money that is part of the normal human services grant process and that concludes my presentation. [3:47:53] We'll go to the public. [3:47:57] Does any member of the public cap comments on the side if there was anyone who would like to be heard? [3:48:01] Please press star three, state your first and last name and neighborhood for the record. [3:48:07] Not noting anybody in the queue. [3:48:13] So we'll go to council member comments or questions, council member comments or questions. [3:48:23] We will go with the consideration of proposed resolution number 2020-260. [3:48:31] Will the clerk please read proposed resolution number 2020-260 by title. [3:48:37] Resolution number 2020-260 authorizing and approving an agreement by [3:48:42] between the city and County and Brimfield and Brimfield fish for supplemental funding. [3:48:49] Is there any motion? [3:48:55] Mayor Potent. [3:48:57] Thank you, Mayor. I move that resolution number 2020 dash 260 be adopted. [3:49:04] Chancellor of the livens. Second, is there any further discussion or any discussion? [3:49:09] Will the clerk please call the roll? [3:49:16] Lim, yes. [3:49:19] Lim, yes. [3:49:22] Yes. [3:49:23] Cha. [3:49:24] Yes. [3:49:26] Anderson? [3:49:28] Yes. [3:49:30] Castriata? [3:49:31] Yes. [3:49:33] Brume? [3:49:34] Yes. [3:49:36] Pinkle? [3:49:38] Yes. [3:49:49] Yes. [3:49:50] Yes. [3:49:52] Five. [3:49:54] Yes. [3:49:56] Early. [3:49:56] Good. [3:49:59] Okay. [3:49:59] So it passes unanimously. [3:50:04] So Jennifer, would you text the Council Member of the United States to join the meeting? [3:50:11] I did. [3:50:11] May I ask you to call in and now? [3:50:13] Okay. [3:50:13] Thank you. [3:50:14] So I'll go ahead and and get started. [3:50:23] I'm speaking slowly here waiting for her to come on. [3:50:31] Yeah. [3:50:31] He's on. [3:50:33] So welcome back. [3:50:37] Next is council consideration proposed resolution. [3:50:41] Number 2020 dash 259 authorizing the approval and [3:50:44] Intergovernment between Brookfield and Boulder [3:50:46] Concerning cost rate for temporary shelter housing. [3:50:49] Council has a copy of the Jinn Memorand with Staffel Summaries. [3:50:56] Dan Casey director of Health and Human Services is going at it one more time for a very brief introduction. [3:51:04] Approving an IGA for our COVID shelter. Dan. [3:51:10] Thanks, manager. [3:51:10] We're often at the NKC again, director of Human Services and just quickly I will present the proposed resolution authorizing the Intergovernmental Agreement for a COVID-19 Recovery Center. [3:51:24] The purpose of this agreement is to provide people experiencing homelessness who have COVID-19 positive or symptomatic or who are COVID positive or symptomatic of place to isolate and receive supportive care. [3:51:41] The City and County of Brunefield Public Health and Human Services will work together with our community providers to identify affected individuals and provide COVID-19 testing if necessary. [3:51:55] Some of the services that are provided at the CRC or the COVID-19 Recovery Center include three meals per day. [3:52:06] This IGA does not include transportation, so that will be provided by our Police Department in the detention center. [3:52:13] And in this facility is staffed. [3:52:15] I know we talked about the Jefferson County IGA. [3:52:18] I believe back in June of this year. [3:52:22] This facility is different from that, and that it's not necessarily a non congregate shelter, but more of a congregate shelter. [3:52:30] And they don't provide medical services on site. They do have medical reserve core that will visit regularly and they also can refer to hospitals. [3:52:41] But this care site is not for folks that would need to be hospitalized. It is for folks that will be not requiring hospitalization or being stepped down from hospitalization. [3:52:54] The cost of this care site is 110 dollars per night and broomfield is not billed or not charged if we don't use the site. So it's only four times when we're using the site. [3:53:07] And if approved the city and county and broomfield will partner with the city of Boulder to provide shelter, isolate and quarantine eligible persons. [3:53:13] And the shelter is provided that the CRC is provided for homeless located at 3485 Stanford [3:53:23] Court in Boulder, Colorado. [3:53:25] And I, before I conclude my presentation, I just wanted to give some credit to Dean Bennett [3:53:32] and Kent Davies who did the majority of the legwork and getting this IGA together and may [3:53:38] or that concludes my presentation. [3:53:40] Thank you. We will proceed to public comments. If there's anyone who would like to be heard again, [3:53:47] the number is 855-695-3744 and please press start at 3 to state your first and last name in [3:53:55] the neighborhood for the record. I'm not noticing anybody in the queue or trying to get in the queue. [3:54:02] So, we will then go to Council member questions and comments. [3:54:08] Next, Council. [3:54:09] Council member LEM? [3:54:11] I generally support this, [3:54:13] but I did have a few hopefully quick questions. [3:54:15] In the introduction in the memo under close contacts, [3:54:20] it says receive regular health care and assessments [3:54:24] to determine if they require a higher level of care. [3:54:28] And then when I looked within the agreement itself, [3:54:31] I didn't see anything about that health care assessment, and I'm trying to reconcile there was a difference within the memo, and then there's a little, I'm not sure how that even fits with what you just said. [3:54:45] Mr. Kasey, if you can clarify that. [3:54:47] through Councilman Berlin. Thanks for that question. So it's our understanding that [3:54:52] on-site medical care is not provided, but that there is a rotating, let me make sure I get this [3:54:58] language correct here. [3:55:02] The medical reserve core provides regular visits. And again, this is not a [3:55:09] medical facility, so those visits would be provided by the medical core if they notice something that [3:55:15] they felt needed to be referred either for emergency. [3:55:20] You know, and one ambulance type of call, [3:55:22] or if they needed to have that individual transported to the hospital, [3:55:26] there are staff that would be able to make that call. [3:55:29] Again, they are not there every day. [3:55:31] The facility is staff daily, [3:55:33] so also the staff that are working in that location could potentially make those assessments. [3:55:39] But again, this is not a medical facility. [3:55:43] Okay, thank you. [3:55:45] Is there an, I mean, do we have any kind of ballpark estimate about how many residents we expect to use this, use this service, a broomfield and are there other counties engaging in this agreement with Boulder? [3:56:05] Because there's a limit of 10 persons outside of Boulder County. [3:56:11] Yeah, that is correct. [3:56:13] Again, thanks for the question, Councilmember Lam. [3:56:16] When we did our initial assessment in earlier this year, [3:56:20] we anticipated that we would potentially use the Jefferson County site [3:56:25] with about 50 individuals. [3:56:28] And again, that you said ballpark, and that's exactly what we did. [3:56:31] We tried to figure out a ballpark number based on how many individuals we have [3:56:36] that are experiencing homelessness that are considered room-field [3:56:40] Residents, if you will, and then try to extrapolate out what the positivity rate or the exposure rate was at that time, and that led us to about 50 individuals, but it's really hard to tell it could be five or it could be, you know, a hundred, and again, your correct, there's a limit of 10, if the facility is full, then each county only gets a maximum of 10 beds at this particular site. [3:57:07] If you do quick math, again, just going through the numbers at $110 a day, and let's assume [3:57:15] that it was 14 days, with all 10 of those beds full, that would be about $15,000. [3:57:23] Again, all 10 beds full for 14 days is about $15,000, but yeah, there's no way for us to [3:57:30] put an exact number on that. I think ballpark is the best we can do. [3:57:33] Okay, thank you very much. [3:57:35] That's those are my questions. [3:57:37] That's what I'm going to tell C.A. [3:57:39] Thank you. [3:57:41] Just wanted to reiterate the shout out to Kent Davies. [3:57:45] I know he's been working pretty hard [3:57:47] and for a long period of time with different communities [3:57:50] on figuring out where Brumfield could join some of our neighbors. [3:57:56] So I really appreciate the work he's done on this [3:57:58] and shout out to Dean as well. [3:58:01] I also wanted to just thank the City and County of Boulder for working with us and doing pay [3:58:08] as you go versus charging us without even maybe even using the beds that Jeff Coe want that we [3:58:15] were considering with Jeff Coe. So I really appreciate that perspective and I'm grateful for that. [3:58:26] So, and according to the database, [3:58:32] some of the databases in some of the non-profits, [3:58:35] there was about maybe between 150 people [3:58:39] who are experiencing homelessness right now in Brazil, [3:58:43] be it on the streets or in their vehicles. [3:58:47] And I think that, you know, getting the word out [3:58:50] is going to be crucial. [3:58:52] And I think that there's been a lot of work [3:58:54] the community with a lot of the different partners have that coordinated care that will allow for [3:59:05] seamless process for this to happen. So again I'm really excited about this and I'm really [3:59:13] happy to see that this is happening in our community and thanks again Jam. This is very great. [3:59:23] Thank you Mayor, I want to echo Council Member Tessia's comments and then yeah, just thank you for really looking out for our homeless population. [3:59:33] I said one question just to know what capacity that is at right now and is there like a maximum amount? How does that work? [3:59:44] Yeah, thanks for that question, Councilmember Hinkle. [3:59:48] I believe the maximum capacity of this facility is 60 beds. [3:59:52] I don't know, I can't speak to what their current capacity is. [3:59:57] They have a maximum of 60 beds I believe at this location. [4:00:02] Okay, and is there any indication from my health department that that might go up beyond the 60 and just curious in case we need a backup plan or anything like that? [4:00:15] I'm not sure. I would assume based on the number of positive tests that we're getting that that number would go up. But again, I don't know if the bolder facility has 10 people there right now or 55 people there right now. We can circle back with them and find out what their current capacity is and we can get that information back to you. [4:00:34] Okay, and if is there a preferential, is it whoever gets there first or if there a [4:00:41] Boulder County resident? Like if they stayed the night in Boulder County the night before [4:00:45] they probably could serve a Boulder County resident is there a preference or anything like that. [4:00:51] Yeah, they do have a preference for Boulder City and County of Boulder residents. And they say that [4:00:58] the other counties would get 10 beds. I believe that is guaranteed that we would get 10 beds. [4:01:04] of those 60, and I think right now we are the only other county that's partnering with them. [4:01:12] Obviously, long-mought and eerie and the municipalities within Boulder County are utilizing the same service, [4:01:18] but we're the only other county right now that's in an IGA situation with them. [4:01:24] I would just like to suggest if we could just keep those numbers in our numbers when we hear from the public health department [4:01:31] and just knowing how many is in this facility and we appreciate it. Thank you. [4:01:39] Okay. [4:01:43] Next is Council's consideration. Proposed Resolution Number 2020-259, [4:01:50] Intergovernmental Grimmants Require and Affirmity Vote of 2-3rds of the entire Council. [4:01:55] Will the Clerk please read Proposed Resolution Number 2020-259 by Dile? [4:02:02] Resolution number 2020-259 authorizing and approving an intergovernmental agreement by [4:02:09] between the City of County of Brumfield and the City of Boulder concerning cost sharing [4:02:14] for COVID-19 recovery center for temporary shelter housing. [4:02:19] Now, so I'm TLCA. [4:02:21] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [4:02:22] I moved that resolution number 2020-259, the adopted. [4:02:28] Council member Hagle? [4:02:33] Yes. [4:02:34] Is there any discussion? [4:02:36] Council member Grump? [4:02:37] Oh. [4:02:38] Is there any discussion? [4:02:42] Will the clerk please call the roll? [4:02:45] Yes. [4:02:49] Should I? [4:02:50] Yes. [4:02:52] Should I? [4:02:53] Yes. [4:02:55] Yes. [4:02:56] Yes. [4:03:00] Yes. [4:03:02] Grand. [4:03:03] Yes. [4:03:05] Can you go? [4:03:07] Yes. [4:03:08] Gisborne. [4:03:10] Yes. [4:03:12] My. [4:03:13] Yes. [4:03:15] Land. [4:03:16] Yes. [4:03:20] I see you. [4:03:21] You know, [4:03:22] unanimously. [4:03:23] So, we'll move on to. [4:03:25] We'll move on to 11. [4:03:26] which is the city of County or recruitment and selection process. [4:03:32] I know Amy is going to be talking about the overall process. [4:03:35] I did want to make a comment to the public that we did have an executive session between [4:03:40] five and six, ten this evening. [4:03:42] Which council did discuss this process? [4:03:44] We're going to have a discussion and a vote on who we want to nominate for, [4:03:50] you know, and make an opportunity for the city of County attorney this evening. [4:03:55] It's up, Sean, I don't know, maybe right now, Sean, you want to make a couple comments on what the rules are since these are personal matters as far as casual comments are going to be. [4:04:07] Sure, [4:04:12] in the, in the, in the, [4:04:21] shouldn't be, just got publicly, but if you, if there were [4:04:32] applicants, [4:04:38] now [4:04:40] with, in addition, [4:04:45] so the candidates, if they had, [4:04:49] gave you answers, spotted a basis for you to help. [4:04:54] Come to a decision about who nominate or who you would like to serve as your next city and county attorney. Those things can certainly be stated. [4:05:04] Happy to answer questions if somebody has specific question. [4:05:08] Then we have any questions on how we're going to proceed. [4:05:11] If not, we'll go ahead and have a Miss Collins give the staff report. [4:05:19] Go ahead, Amy. [4:05:21] Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Protem, and Council members, Amy Collins, Deputy Director of Human Resources. [4:05:29] And I appreciate your time to discuss the city and county attorney process as outlined in the memo on based on the discussions and direction of Council. [4:05:38] On June 30, 2020, current city and county attorney Sean Sullivan announced his retirement to be effective by the end of this year. [4:05:46] Mayor Quinn, Mayor Protem Castriata, and Council requested that the [4:05:50] Department be hired to conduct a nationwide recruitment search. [4:05:54] The City and County position was posted on August 20th, [4:05:58] and closed for first review of applications on September 27th, 2020. [4:06:03] 14 applications were received and of those eight applicants were deemed qualified [4:06:08] and were moved forward to the work session review with Council in October 12. [4:06:13] Council identified the top three candidates and interviewed them. [4:06:17] Council requested that three finalists be invited back for virtual interviews with city, [4:06:22] with the city and county manager and deputy city and county attorney. [4:06:26] Council requested that two of the candidates be interviewed by the city and county attorneys office and department heads. [4:06:33] The three finalists are Michael Foot, George Hypalife and Nancy Rogers. [4:06:39] As summary of their qualifications are outlined in the memo, the next step of the process is to nominate and subsequently put the nominations to vote to identify the applicant which council will make a conditional job offer. [4:06:57] For someone to serve as the next city and county attorney, city council's options are number one, nominate one of the finalists, nominate two of the finalists, nominate all of the finalists or nominate none of the finalists and provide direction on next steps. [4:07:20] If a finalist is nominated, the next step would be to adopt a motion, authorizing the mayor and [4:07:25] mayor-protem to work with staff to make a conditional job offer in the Go Shaderinal. [4:07:30] I'm an agreement for paying benefits with the selected applicants. That concludes the staff report. Thank you. [4:07:40] We will not proceed with public comments. If there's anyone who would like to be heard, again, the numbers eight, five, five, six, nine, five, three, seven, four, four, press star three, state your first and last name and neighborhood for the record will go to Kristen. [4:07:54] State your name, your full name, and neighborhood, and you have three minutes. [4:08:01] Hi. [4:08:01] This is Kristen Logan. [4:08:03] I live in Anthem Highlands. [4:08:05] I just wanted to call in today about this attorney search. [4:08:08] I think we as a community have gone through a lot over the last several years. [4:08:13] And it's not very often when we have someone knocking at our door that actually has the experience [4:08:20] working in the arena of making laws, understanding laws, understanding the intent of [4:08:27] And for that reason, when I saw Mike Foot was one of our possible applicants, I was extremely excited. [4:08:34] I've always admired the work that he's done in the legislature. [4:08:37] And I feel like he's always been very fair, upfront, and ethical and honest. [4:08:43] He's the type of person that would really lead our city. [4:08:45] I think in a great direction, he understands our community and the issues that we face. [4:08:51] Not just oil and gas, but looking at rocky flats, [4:08:54] looking at police reform and criminal justice issues, and like I said, just a full understanding [4:08:59] of the law. This really isn't a part of an issue. I know a lot of people automatically assume [4:09:06] based on my only gas stamps that I'm a Democrat, but the reality is that I was a lifelong Republican [4:09:11] who unafiliated a few years ago. And I did that for various reasons, and I still feel despite [4:09:20] My, my meetings and different directions on politics that my foot is the right type of person to lead our community together in a new direction and to be able to provide us insight ideas thoughts into the laws. [4:09:34] So I really hope that this council supports him tonight and select them as our next city and county attorney. [4:09:39] Thank you for your consideration. [4:09:42] A Lizzie you're next. Stitch your full name and your neighborhood and you have three minutes. [4:09:50] Lizzie, Laryo from the progress. Oh can you hear me? [4:09:54] We can't. [4:09:56] Okay, Lizzie, Laryo from the Wildgrass subdivision. [4:09:59] Just wanted to start off with a quick thank you. [4:10:02] I know there are so many of you working countless extra hours to deal with the issues impacting our community right now. [4:10:09] And I appreciate that those time and efforts. [4:10:13] I am also calling to speak and support of Mr. Foot being hired as the next city attorney [4:10:18] of Bromfield. [4:10:20] Mr. Foot would be a tremendous asset for Bromfield, especially right now with what we have [4:10:27] in front of us, although not his only strength he is well versed in oil and gas. [4:10:33] And that is an area we are about to be tested, big time from the industry in regard to [4:10:39] SB 181 and putting forth our new regulations. [4:10:44] It would be nice for anyone to think that oil and gas development is finishing or winding down and broomfield. [4:10:52] Legal batter battles over local rules and regulations are just beginning. [4:10:57] And the industry will be looking to exploit any legal weaknesses. [4:11:02] Mr. Foot is the biggest asset and the biggest strength we can have in that department right now. [4:11:08] As important as that is, I am fully aware it's not the only issue, nor is it Mr. Footh only expertise. [4:11:17] Looking especially what Bruno Footh is facing now, or in the very near future, with police reform and rocky flats as was mentioned earlier. [4:11:26] Mr. Footh brings experience and knowledge about both of those issues, which again are very pressing issues in Bruno Footh. [4:11:32] In addition to his expertise in knowledge, Mr. Buddhism on the Lissons genuinely cares and understands the [4:11:38] important of weighing multiple opinions, even when they are opposing. [4:11:43] He has shamed on experience as a former legislature. [4:11:46] There will be an adjustment for either candidate. [4:11:49] However, having worked with City and County of Brunefield in the past, Mr. Foot has more familiarity with the dynamics in Brunefield. [4:11:58] He is professional and strong yet kind and conscientious and an unaffiliated voter. [4:12:04] I greatly appreciate Mr. Foot's ability and experience working with differing opinions [4:12:09] to come up with a fair resolution. [4:12:11] Please, please make the choice of Mr. Foot through the stronger choice for legal representation [4:12:17] and room field. [4:12:18] Thank you. [4:12:21] Kim, your next state to your full name, your neighborhood, and you have three minutes. [4:12:29] Thank you. Hello, Mayor Quinn and council members. This is Kim McNaughton, Anthem Highland's [4:12:34] word source. So, thank you for considering our comments tonight. I definitely agree with Kristin [4:12:39] and Lizzie's comments before me because I'm also calling it to convey my support for [4:12:44] mexat as choice for the Greenville City and County Attorney. So, I've had the honor to spend [4:12:49] time with him in the community and have found him to be a person who really seeks to understand. [4:12:53] He's open to new ideas and he's familiar with local government issues. [4:12:59] So I really appreciate his creative thinking and I've noticed he's adopted working from a bipartisan mindset as well. [4:13:07] And he's been very fair and honest in his communications. [4:13:11] So with the background and the legislature, it's easy to see where he advocates for his constituents on many very issues. [4:13:18] And yes, he is known, I think most for his environmental work, but there are also many other issues that he's worked on. [4:13:24] And I have a list of those. I sent them not until five o'clock, so I don't know if anyone has seen them. [4:13:30] I'm probably not going to go through them all right now for the six of time. [4:13:33] But I would just like to close by encouraging you to choose Mr. Claude as broomfield's next city in County Attorney. [4:13:39] As I believe he really has a strong capacity to bring a new and fresh perspective to this role. Thank you. [4:13:45] Thank you, Kim. [4:13:51] I'm not noting anybody else in the queue. Mayor Pertham. No, so there's nobody [4:13:59] else in the queue. So the process at this point time is we'll, we'll, we'll now open the [4:14:07] floor for nominations and and and subsequently nominations will vote to identify the applicant [4:14:13] when it's Council will make a conditional job offer to serve as the next city county attorney. [4:14:17] are there any nominations from Council or the Attorney's position? [4:14:24] Mayor Protepe? [4:14:27] Thank you, Mayor. [4:14:28] I would like to nominate Mike Foot. [4:14:33] Council member Anderson? [4:14:37] I was following the second thought for you. [4:14:38] The second, if not, I'm... [4:14:40] I don't think you need a second. [4:14:41] Okay. [4:14:42] But we have one of the case we need one. [4:14:45] So, any other nominations? [4:14:51] Council of Allowance. [4:14:53] Excuse me. [4:14:54] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [4:14:55] I'd like to nominate Nancy Rogers, please. [4:14:57] Okay. Are there any other not? [4:15:15] So I'm trying to look at the process here. Because I don't think there's any, I don't think there's any time for comments here. I mean, I don't think it was put in the script here, but I think now, Sean, it would be the appropriate time to ask for council members. [4:15:28] I see if they want to offer offer comments on why they're going to vote for one or the other, [4:15:34] but we have two people nominated. [4:15:36] We have Nancy Rogers and we have Mike Footnominated and I'll now open up the floor to Council [4:15:43] for if they want to make comments or we can just move right into the vote for the nomination. [4:15:48] Is there any member Council that wants to speak? [4:15:51] Please raise your hand. [4:15:56] Okay, then I'm going to move Council Member Lam. [4:16:00] As a council person, my focus is on the candidate's ability to provide legal advice on important city issues. [4:16:07] So I evaluated both of the candidates in that regard. [4:16:12] In Nancy's supplemental question, she replied that her experience with land use stems mainly from her work on telecommunications issues. [4:16:21] That was the extent that to which I heard her detail for land use work. [4:16:31] Nancy has no elections or county-level experience. [4:16:35] She stated nothing in the interviews with councilor staff about rocky flats. [4:16:40] The council's unanimous stance in protecting health and safety near rocky flats is well-known throughout the area. [4:16:46] Regarding oil and gas issues in her interview, Nancy showed that she does not have a basic grasp of the matter. [4:16:54] She stated that she sees her role as guiding negotiations with regulatory agencies on this issues. [4:17:02] Brunefield's legal challenges are not with regulatory agencies, but with operators. [4:17:07] We are immersed in protecting the operator agreement during the Extractions Bank [4:17:11] Crepsy and our local regulations could be challenged by industry. [4:17:16] In her supplemental essay question, she stated, it is in this area of oil and gas that [4:17:21] Brunefield has seen as a leader and innovator, continually working to find the right balance [4:17:27] between drilling and community interests. [4:17:33] The only thing that I learned from the examples that Nancy gave is that she's done a lot of work in the last two years on public safety issues. [4:17:41] Unfortunately, Aurora has had many high profile public safety issues. [4:17:46] I respect that our police department has not engaged in such conduct, and that our attorneys have not gained prominence in that area. [4:17:56] I have worked with Mike in the state legislature as one of the many grassroots stakeholders. [4:18:03] He is approachable and a great listener, affirming the value of everyone's input. [4:18:08] He never asked if I was a Democrat, he never made anything partisan and I am not a Democrat, I am unafiliated. [4:18:16] He had to work six years to thread the needle to pass SB 181 and never gave up. [4:18:21] When he was attacked by all sides for threading the needle, he always maintained an even temperament and stuck to the facts. [4:18:30] When Mike was asked to consult on oil and gas issues, he has always been reasonable. [4:18:36] He recognized the broomfield may still be facing litigation related to rocky flats, [4:18:41] and he will consider that as part of the public good as he has worked for his entire career. [4:18:47] He cited his work with municipalities as a state legislature as part of his earlier work with municipalities. [4:18:56] Regarding the public safety issues in the police bill, Mike stated that he helped consult on 2017 and recognizes that it needs refinement in the legislature. [4:19:07] So Mike checks all the boxes for the main legal issues that are important to the city. [4:19:11] I see Mike as the perfect bridge between Council and Staff for interpreting the law. [4:19:17] Those are my comments. [4:19:18] Thank you. [4:19:19] Thank you. [4:19:20] Thank you. [4:19:20] Thank you, Mayor. [4:19:22] Thanks for the opportunity to speak. [4:19:25] I know it's getting late, so I appreciate everyone staying up. [4:19:29] I was just pleased that we had three amazing candidates and then I'm also pleased I think [4:19:33] we can have a best of both worlds. [4:19:35] I'm going through the rigorous interview process and hearing from all of these attorneys [4:19:39] and what they had to say was awe inspiring. [4:19:42] Mike at his own attorney practice and legislative work [4:19:44] and Nancy of our municipal work and leading a team [4:19:47] through tough situations as well as George [4:19:49] who's been working for construction corporation [4:19:51] these decisions I never received. [4:19:54] I do think we should shift our focus [4:19:55] and have a strong will and gas front where we [4:19:57] need it the most perhaps to look [4:19:59] to contract with Mike to provide legal guidance [4:20:03] in the future and enhance on type role. [4:20:06] All these emails today receive a very true [4:20:08] and I admire the heck out of Mike, [4:20:10] just as our community guys. [4:20:12] And while we know, he knows oil and gas laws inside and out, [4:20:15] and we see a lot of anxiety in our community over this, [4:20:17] and he has policy and litigation skills [4:20:20] and his experience in grid is irreplaceable. [4:20:23] He also knows the dirty trips of oil and gas [4:20:25] tries to play, and he would be amazing to seek [4:20:27] deeper guidance with. [4:20:29] I would give him mobility, creativity, [4:20:31] and provide the most amount of trust [4:20:33] and confidence we have, been developing already. [4:20:35] and strengthen your systems where it's needed. [4:20:39] I can't emphasize this enough, but our situation isn't something we've brought on ourselves. [4:20:43] We have these wells, forests upon us. [4:20:45] And we're doing all that we can to protect our residents and I'm willing to perhaps seek my [4:20:49] Skydance to help us do what we can to continue to protect our residents. [4:20:53] We have a lot of pastings IED, but I also want to realize that we have a new council, [4:20:57] it's a new staff, and it's a new day that doesn't rely on a one city council [4:21:01] or sorry, one city and county attorney bowl. [4:21:03] So I wanted to take an aerial view of our situation and we've been showing up to nearly all [4:21:08] of our own gas meetings. [4:21:09] I've been pouring in all these hours with other council members as well. [4:21:13] Hundreds of hours of the capital with SB-111 and our council and our community, not necessarily [4:21:17] our attorneys, have come up with solutions for our own gas issues. [4:21:21] And so we don't put all of our faith in one person alone or should we. [4:21:25] Our noise ordinance, our new robust air quality systems with Dr. Helmig and our newly [4:21:30] development regulations. I've had both community and city council input. I have added [4:21:35] strong health and safety and notice idea to be added to our new regs and put forth the idea [4:21:39] that we should put the onus on the operator to prove that they need to our land to develop the [4:21:44] minerals that they desire. [4:21:47] This must always be the case to put the onus on the operator. These are [4:21:50] bold ideas and no offense to our legal team, but they didn't come from our city and county [4:21:54] attorney and I have no doubt Mike's potential guidance could be just as creative and help us [4:21:59] than you lost suits as well in helping us work on our rigs. [4:22:02] We've been winning a court and we had a strong litigation team [4:22:04] who knows full well what council direction is. [4:22:07] So the power to fight well in gases and in one person, [4:22:09] and it's in all of us. [4:22:11] And we've been developed enough structure internally on staff [4:22:14] on council and through the community to keep up this fight, [4:22:16] there's literally no wiggle room in this role [4:22:18] in the matter who fills it. [4:22:20] That being said, for the city and county role, [4:22:22] I wanted to be sure I call it the fair processes [4:22:24] that all of our council agreed upon. [4:22:26] And after two intends of verbal interview, [4:22:28] Processes I think next is [4:22:30] Best equipped for this city in County, trying position. During her interview, she gave detailed descriptions [4:22:34] in how she led teams of attorneys and described tough decisions in ways that let me know exactly [4:22:39] how she leads a team. I received no indication that she would up as be oppositional to our approach [4:22:45] and seemed very open to council direction. She consistently told us she would follow council's direction. [4:22:51] I want to remind everyone, especially the public, that Sean has not been the person litigating, [4:22:56] And we're in the weeds opting with oil and gas issues, and instead focuses on managing [4:23:00] a legal team. [4:23:01] The NCO strong municipal experience, and I know doubt, would welcome additional help in [4:23:05] all local oil and gas issues. [4:23:08] These are issues that we have developed strong internal structures for already, and I want [4:23:11] to remind the public that this person also needs to oversee water rights to have some [4:23:15] parkway and more. [4:23:16] This decision is an easy for me, and Mike is someone I call a professional friend, as he [4:23:21] worked on asking one anyone and hurt us throughout the whole process. [4:23:24] And if he's not here for a specific attorney rule, he would continue to be a friend and ally in this fight to help protect the field. [4:23:32] I have to set aside predispositions, listen to our candidates' interviews, or overwhelmingly leaning staff feedback was very important to me. [4:23:40] And think about what's best for this position, especially during COVID, where we need someone with the experience, Nancy Harris, to hit the ground. [4:23:46] Thank you. [4:23:48] That's what we're addressing. [4:23:51] Thank you. [4:23:52] I want to note here that I think this is safe to say that, you know, Mike Ford and Nancy Rogers both naturally rose to the top with this nationwide search that we did. [4:24:03] That there this just happened naturally. [4:24:07] And if I want to look at what is best from my perspective as a consumer and looking to bring the much near change that I feel that my constituents need as we have struggled. [4:24:18] In the realm of protecting health and safety, and some is biggest issues facing us, that we need proactive leadership. [4:24:24] And somewhere that really understands this big picture, and Mike Foot has extensive knowledge. [4:24:29] He has been very matter of fact. He is a quick thinker, and he is absolutely understands the dynamics of elected officials. [4:24:37] This is, this is council's higher. It's our decision. This is the one person that we pick to represent us. [4:24:42] and I want someone who is strong on Bruno Phil's most important issues right now. [4:24:48] And for me, and what I'm seeing, I think others can relate to this, this oil and gas, rocky [4:24:53] flats, and please reform this, the SB 217. And Mike Foot has all of that experience. He will hit [4:25:01] the ground running. He will be, in my opinion, everything that we are looking for right now, and he [4:25:07] will pick up additional expenses, he goes, he was also a prosecutor, he has a knowledge beyond [4:25:13] those areas, and he has shown leadership in his role, and you want to note that also [4:25:20] as others have said, and I was concerned by some of the emails that were sent in, in particular, [4:25:27] you know, asking us for positions on things. I am a, I was previously a lifelong registered [4:25:31] public end. That is how I entered the realm of working with Mike and others. I am currently [4:25:36] unafiliated. This is not a political issue and I really wish that I had never come into this [4:25:44] picture. But that's that's the reality of it. I just want to make sure people are aware of that. [4:25:52] And that's really it. I am going to be voting from Mike. Thank you. [4:25:58] How's it going to be? [4:26:01] Thank you, Mayor. [4:26:03] Yeah, this has been an incredibly hard decision for me. [4:26:09] And it's certainly been a contentious decision, I think, for city council as well. [4:26:15] And I'm not going to just disparage either either here. [4:26:19] I think they're both great. [4:26:23] I love Mike. [4:26:25] He's like, I consider him a good friend. [4:26:27] I've known him for over 20 years and I think he's a great lawyer. [4:26:34] However, Nancy is great as well, I've heard a lot, and I've heard that she's [4:26:40] well respected. [4:26:41] I've heard a lot of great comments from her from a lot of my peers, and I know this [4:26:46] is very well respected in the industry and well regarded. [4:26:50] So that means a lot as well, and for me it just really came down to that's, when I [4:26:57] I was going to this process, you know, I sort of had in my mind what I was looking for in this position and it was really someone that had the background in the city and county role and, you know, I'm hoping to get a whole lot of a lot of [4:27:27] experience that I think that will really let Harris sort of jump into this [4:27:31] role from from Miguel. And I know she has a respect of a lot of the of our [4:27:38] current staff as well. So from me those are really sort of the the the [4:27:42] kickers and the and the and the type breakers with this one. I totally agree [4:27:48] with them. With Council Member Hancock, I do respect Mike and I would love to [4:27:54] have him on board still with us in a capacity where he could provide guidance on the [4:28:01] oil and gas issues which are so dear to the heart of a lot of our residents and [4:28:07] in our city council and briefly so and I think he does provide and can't provide [4:28:11] a continued to provide guidance and maybe in a data solution in that area and maybe [4:28:17] some other areas as well as been mentioned. But, you know, ultimately, you know, for me, [4:28:24] I have a, I guess, you know, when I came out to, you know, what I was looking for, it was someone that they had the, the background that experience that's, and Nancy has, so, you know, for the, for the city attorney position, I'm going to support her for that and I would love to have, and my convolved in some kind of additional capacity in the future as well. Thank you. [4:28:48] That's where, uh, mayor for temp yesterday. [4:28:52] Thank you, mayor. [4:28:53] And I, yeah, I do need to make a comment about, um, [4:28:58] the policies, the policies, you know what I mean? [4:29:02] It was politicized. [4:29:03] And it shouldn't have been. [4:29:06] Um, I mean, if, if Mike had a political agenda, [4:29:11] he would have run for Senate again in one. [4:29:14] But he chose to not run again because he, [4:29:17] He truly wants to be of service, and he's been practicing private law before he was a legislator. [4:29:25] So I see he brings so much to the table, but yet I also admired a lot of qualities [4:29:34] in Nancy Rogers, but to be honest, they're both going to have a learning curve. [4:29:39] There's no other place like room field, we're a city, and a county. [4:29:43] So the only person that's going to be able to come in ready to hit the ground running [4:29:46] is someone that worked as the top attorney for a city and a county. [4:29:51] There's only one other place like that in its Denver. [4:29:54] So there's a learning curve for both. [4:29:57] And with me, it comes... [4:30:00] Down to relationships and trust. And I believe that the interactions that I've had with Mike, he would give us, you know, cautious advice, but he would be innovative. And he definitely knows what we're going through here in broomfield. [4:30:18] He's connected to broomfield. And that's important to me. I just don't think the issues in Aurora and the culture there is anything like broomfield. [4:30:27] So again, it's that uniqueness and I think that having the unique person to feel that job is important to me. [4:30:37] I believe that in terms of his management style, we have a very expert team of attorneys in our office that know their jobs. [4:30:44] I don't think they need to be my permanent. [4:30:48] And I really wouldn't expect that. [4:30:51] It's more of a support position and a resource position. [4:30:55] But as far as I've known in the three years, we've never denied any extra resources to our attorney's office if they needed outside counsel. [4:31:05] So I'm sure that's still the case if they needed more resources. So if we need to to grow it. [4:31:11] The other thing is he doesn't have a political background and that isn't asset because political acumen is key to dealing with the council. [4:31:20] And it's probably been the demise of attorneys in the past, not being able to speak the language of an elected official. [4:31:29] And that's been my experience. [4:31:32] He's an excellent communicator. [4:31:33] Any is familiar with Korra, Tabor, open meetings. [4:31:38] He's got firsthand experience with all of these things and ethics as an elected official. [4:31:43] And including passing a bill that made a change in public records related to Korra requests. [4:31:50] Beyond the oil and gas he's got 18 years of general litigation experience, 16 years as a prosecutor and the last two doing civil litigation. [4:32:00] So he has elections law experience. [4:32:03] Again, you know, something that the other candidate didn't have. [4:32:07] So I do believe it comes down to, you know, what we individually think needs to fill this role. [4:32:15] And for me, at this time, for Brunefield, it is my foot. [4:32:19] Thank you. [4:32:21] Thank you. [4:32:21] Thank you, Mayor. [4:32:26] So I just wanted to start out by calling attention to my virtual background. [4:32:31] It's an honor of Sesame Street that premiered on PBS on this day in 1969. [4:32:38] I've been feeling a very sesame street lately. [4:32:42] And I just wanted to start my comments tonight with a quote. [4:32:47] This was from Elmo's dad. [4:32:50] And he said, not all streets are like Sesame Street. [4:32:53] On Sesame Street, we all love and respect one another. [4:32:57] And I just, you know, the, I, going through this process, [4:33:01] you know, I appreciated working with Prof. [4:33:04] Man, I think that that was a great decision to go with them. [4:33:08] It, it really kind of streamlined the process, [4:33:10] but it also added another kind of objective component to the hiring process. [4:33:17] I appreciate the openness and inclusion of all council members and all council members being [4:33:23] willing to be involved in this process. [4:33:26] I want to give a shout-out to the Mayor and Mayor of Pro Tem for all of your extra work on this. [4:33:31] I know that you both put in extra hours, extra days on this process and I don't want that to be overlooked. [4:33:40] You know, I want to thank all the applicants for applying and you're interest in the city [4:33:45] and county of Brunefield. [4:33:46] I appreciate Council's extra time dedicated this matter. [4:33:51] And in the end, I truly do believe that we have to find a finalist being considered tonight. [4:33:56] And I'm happy that they're both interested in Brunefield. [4:34:01] And I'm delighted that they wanted to have this position here on Brunefield. [4:34:06] I think the both candidates bring strengths to this position. [4:34:10] Some are similar in some are different. [4:34:13] Both candidates will have learning curves for sure. [4:34:17] Neither of them have served in room field. [4:34:21] And, you know, room fields agenda of a community. [4:34:24] And we're also demanding community as well. [4:34:29] So we have two fine applicants for this position. [4:34:32] And I truly do believe that we'd be lucky to have either applicant. [4:34:37] I also want to take this moment to recognize our outgoing attorney, Sean Sullivan, for his service to Brunefield. [4:34:44] You know, I don't think that we can overlook your dedication for these last couple years. [4:34:52] You know, after our interviews, I got a good picture of both candidates and how they would lead in this role for Brunefield. [4:35:00] For me, I'm really looking for someone that will bring creativity, somebody that will bring adaptability, someone who will be forward looking and pushing the status quo. [4:35:11] I think Mike will do a better job at this and that's why I'm voting for Mike tonight. [4:35:16] Thanks, that's all I have. [4:35:18] Any other questions or comments? [4:35:20] I guess really, it's comments. [4:35:23] any other comments if that I will call for the role and so we have two nominees. [4:35:32] We have like foot and Nancy Rogers nominee when the clerk calls the role, state who you [4:35:40] who you're voting for whether it's Mr. Foot or Ms. Rogers. So clerk, please call the role. [4:35:47] Shia. [4:35:51] I might fit. [4:35:55] Cathy A. [4:35:57] Nancy Rogers. [4:36:00] Anderson. [4:36:04] Mike Flitt. [4:36:07] Kat Shiaada. [4:36:09] Mike Flitt. [4:36:12] Brume. [4:36:15] Mr. Idders. [4:36:18] Kanko. [4:36:20] Nancy Rogers. [4:36:23] Giverky. [4:36:25] Ms. Rogers. [4:36:28] Law Evans. [4:36:30] Nancy Rodgers, thank you. [4:36:33] Well, like, [4:36:37] but let's bet. [4:36:39] Mr. Fitt. [4:36:43] So the vote is tied, and I guess I had expected that it certainly seemed to be that way [4:36:50] for the last week or so. [4:36:52] One of the comments, I guess I want to say is that I'll put it this way, first of all, I really [4:36:57] respect Mikefoot. I think SB 181 was wonderful legislation and his diligence in getting it passed [4:37:04] with something that will always be thankful for in Bromfield and the state of Colorado. [4:37:09] Mr. Foot had called me on Friday. You wanted to talk to me and I decided that I would [4:37:15] talk to him. I never talked to Mr. Foot one on one. I certainly respected his decisions that are [4:37:20] the advice he offered when we were talking about the public health order. He did a great service for [4:37:23] I would like to see Ms. Rogers if she accepts the job because that's that's personal and leaning towards [4:37:30] Bring Mr. Fortin to hop with the oil and gas matters. But what it really got down to me, and I had two or three people that I really [4:37:36] considered that I know I respected who recommended Ms. Rogers. I, you know, one of the things I've learned does I've been involved with big and small [4:37:45] organizations is the ability to leverage yourself and one of the things I guess I was impressed with was the fact that the [4:37:51] Rogers has been a manager and a staff equivalent to the size, I think, of ours in Brunefield. [4:37:58] When she met with staff, she met with staff, or had the interviews with staff staff, staff [4:38:04] seemed to support her fairly strongly in Brunefield. [4:38:07] I think the ability to manage that staff, I don't think you could take it for granted that [4:38:11] they're going to operate without the management of the attorney. [4:38:15] That's probably the most significant factor to me. [4:38:17] I will point out that I talked to Ms. Rogers on Sunday. [4:38:21] And we did talk about Rocky Flats and some of the issues facing Brookfield, because I had not [4:38:25] talked to her directly. [4:38:26] And Ms. Rogers grew up in Denver, understands the issues on Rocky Flats, understood the [4:38:35] issue with the Jeffs and Parkway. [4:38:36] I'm absolutely convinced that on any of these issues that she's going to consult with and consider [4:38:42] counsel to be her client, to understand that you can't just say no to your client. [4:38:46] you need to, you need to work toward Jess, [4:38:48] but have them understand the consequences [4:38:50] on absolutely good she can do that. [4:38:52] So I'm gonna give the vote to Ms. Rogers and I'm going to, [4:38:58] with that said that she gets the nomination. [4:39:03] So therefore based on that decision, [4:39:05] I will entertain a motion to authorize [4:39:07] the Mayor of Mayor Pro Temp to work with staff [4:39:09] to make a conditional job offer [4:39:11] and negotiate an employment agreement for paying benefits [4:39:13] with Ms. Rogers. Is there a motion? [4:39:19] Council member live-ends. [4:39:21] So, I'm Luke Mr. Mayor. Council member, Jerome. [4:39:26] Second. Is there any discussion? And once again, this is on making an offer and [4:39:33] initial offer and negotiate the contract. Is there any discussion? Council member [4:39:39] Well, thank you both for your work, your future work on this and I really hope that Nancy [4:39:46] does accept our offer. [4:39:49] Thank you. [4:39:50] Thank you. [4:39:50] Thank you. [4:39:51] Kazmer-Shab. [4:39:51] So I will go ahead and call the roll. [4:39:56] I won't call it roll. [4:39:57] I'll have to also call it roll. [4:39:59] It's late. [4:40:15] Just to clarify, we're voting on the negotiation part. [4:40:20] Mayor, thank you. [4:40:22] Yes. [4:40:25] Yeah, yes. [4:40:28] Thank you. [4:40:30] Yes. [4:40:32] Is there any key? [4:40:37] Yes. [4:40:46] Yes. [4:40:47] Yes. [4:40:49] Yes. [4:40:49] Yes. [4:40:49] It passes nine to one. [4:40:51] And then Mayor Putem, why don't you and I get together in the morning to talk about how [4:40:54] we're going to proceed. [4:40:57] And I think everybody, you know, what's going on? [4:41:00] I'm going to note for the record here that we had. [4:41:03] we had a really good discussion and executive session and once again another council meeting [4:41:08] in which I really respect how council the deliberated and and will the mayor put them and I'll [4:41:15] be reporting back to council throughout the next week. The goal is to to to vote on the [4:41:20] contract next Tuesday and we will keep I guarantee you we will keep council and price the what [4:41:25] what happens during this next week. The next step for me will be to talk the mayor put them [4:41:30] morning and then and then to the attorney about the contract he's already going to draft contract. [4:41:36] So we have one other item tonight and I know it's passed every deadline ever set my council, [4:41:41] but it isn't an executive session that the attorney has been wanting to do so though. [4:41:46] So let's go ahead and move on and this is the council's consideration of a request for an executive [4:41:52] session for legal advice and direction to negotiate or regarding a lawsuit. [4:41:58] I guess it says we'll take [4:42:00] public comment on this. I'm not sure what they can come out on, but I'm not not in any public comment. [4:42:10] So, I get, well, [4:42:15] I'm a little, I guess, Sean, he'll talk about it when it gives the [4:42:18] the recommendation. So, this is, this is, this is to have a, there's a lawsuit that's pending [4:42:22] and so are there any comments or questions from Council on having this executive session, [4:42:27] which would be held on on Thursday, which is a special meeting after our special meeting. [4:42:35] So I'm noting none of that. So request for the executive says to require a firm [4:42:39] need vote of two thirds of the core of present. Will the city and county attorney please read [4:42:44] the recommended motion? [4:42:48] That an executive session be held on November 12, 2020 following the [4:42:53] special city council meeting for legal advice and to direct negotiators regarding [4:42:58] HN, XRL, A&, a minor versus city and county of Brunefield as permitted by [4:43:04] Section 2464024V and E of the Colorado Revised Statutes. [4:43:10] That's what I'm chef. [4:43:12] I'm moved. [4:43:14] Cassandra Burrara, Mayor for temp castrier out. [4:43:16] Second. [4:43:18] Is there any discussion? [4:43:20] Will the court please call the roll? [4:43:24] Anderson? [4:43:25] Yes. [4:43:28] Cassrier out of? [4:43:30] Yes. [4:43:37] Can you go? [4:43:38] Yes. [4:43:41] Is there any key? [4:43:42] Yes. [4:43:44] Well, I haven't. [4:43:46] Yes. [4:43:49] Yes. [4:43:49] Yes. [4:43:52] Yes. [4:43:58] Yes. [4:44:00] Yes. [4:44:00] Yes. [4:44:00] Yes. [4:44:01] You've passed unanimously. [4:44:02] The City of County Attorney's report is next. [4:44:04] Mr. Sullivan, do you have to report? [4:44:05] You have a report. [4:44:08] A couple of items for council's consideration. [4:44:12] Today, extraction oil and gas piled is most of the appeal of its convictions in the noise case. [4:44:20] For the seven noise citations of their issue. [4:44:22] So that's that appeal be heard by the Brunefield District Court and we'll keep your [4:44:28] prize [4:44:34] for up to see there are a couple of things pending and the letter [4:44:44] to reject some [4:44:46] of its mid-string contracts including elevations, mid-string [4:44:56] cumfield. [4:45:00] Parties before a judge, the judge issued a decision. The parties announced that they reached the settlement that will be filed with the court in early December, that will allow action to continue to use elevation pipelines. [4:45:15] They acknowledged the [4:45:22] ability to move oil and gas within a brewed deal. [4:45:27] Last week and have approved by the bankruptcy court, [4:45:34] that will be sent out to their creditors or vote. [4:45:54] more discussion with City Council without [4:45:58] proceeding an executive session on. [4:46:04] Thank you, Mayor. [4:46:05] Any questions or comments of the [4:46:07] a shot? [4:46:09] We'll move on to Jennifer Jennifer, [4:46:10] do you have a report? [4:46:13] No, I do not. [4:46:16] So we will move on. [4:46:19] There is no less leave update. [4:46:21] There is no business before [4:46:23] the urban renewal authority [4:46:24] or the original local and [4:46:26] private district board of directors. [4:46:27] Additionally, there are no special reports or requests for future action, and this concludes the items on the CDC's agenda. [4:46:35] Is there any other business company for Council? [4:46:39] No need, no further business. The Council meeting is adjourned. Thank you.