1
00:00:01,960 --> 00:00:15,280
You can hear me, mayor. I can hear you. I can hear you. You can't hear me. I can hear you now. I can hear you. Yeah, perfect. We're just going to promote councilor LZB before we start.

2
00:00:20,260 --> 00:00:21,220
All right, Madam Mayor.

3
00:00:24,450 --> 00:00:29,290
Hey. It's five thirty. Great. And we have a quorum.

4
00:00:33,100 --> 00:00:40,460
Yes, you do. Great. Good evening, everyone. A quorum of the city council being present.

5
00:00:40,480 --> 00:00:48,500
I wanted to call tonight's January 26th, 2026 regular meeting of the Cambridge City Council

6
00:00:48,500 --> 00:00:49,100
to order.

7
00:00:49,660 --> 00:00:52,900
The first order of visits is a role call of members present, please.

8
00:00:53,460 --> 00:00:55,580
The term Quirk, Quaint, Crane.

9
00:00:56,140 --> 00:01:02,480
Councillor Azubi, President, President Vice-Mirazim, President, President, Council of Flaherty,

10
00:01:03,360 --> 00:01:04,860
President, President, Council of McEvern,

11
00:01:07,540 --> 00:01:10,640
Council of McEvern is absent, Councillor Nolan,

12
00:01:14,260 --> 00:01:20,080
Councillor Nolan, is listed as absent, Councillor Simmons, present and notable.

13
00:01:20,460 --> 00:01:27,140
Present, Councillor Sabrina Wheeler, present, Councillor Zucy, present, present, near Sadiki,

14
00:01:27,460 --> 00:01:27,640
present.

15
00:01:28,220 --> 00:01:31,740
Yes, and you have seven members recorded as present and two recorded as absent.

16
00:01:33,000 --> 00:01:33,600
Thank you.

17
00:01:33,860 --> 00:01:34,680
Hear the rules.

18
00:01:34,980 --> 00:01:38,540
Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance and Pause for a Moment of Silence.

19
00:01:39,440 --> 00:01:44,480
Congratulations to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands.

20
00:01:45,100 --> 00:01:48,780
One nation under God and divisible with liberty and justice for all.

21
00:01:54,630 --> 00:01:59,910
Her chapter 2 of the Acts of 2025 adopted by Massachusetts General Court and approved by the governor.

22
00:02:00,510 --> 00:02:04,910
The city is authorized to use remote participation at meetings of the Cambridge City Council.

23
00:02:05,630 --> 00:02:08,150
In addition to having members of the Council participate remotely,

24
00:02:08,390 --> 00:02:11,210
we've set up Zoom teleconference for public comment.

25
00:02:11,210 --> 00:02:17,310
You can also view the meeting via the city's open meeting portal or on the city's cable channel 22.

26
00:02:17,630 --> 00:02:24,350
To speak during public comment, you must sign up at www.kamerjame.gov slash public comment.

27
00:02:24,990 --> 00:02:30,310
You can also email your written comments for the record to the city clerk at city clerk at kamerjame.gov.

28
00:02:30,710 --> 00:02:33,870
We welcome your participation and you can sign up until 6 p.m.

29
00:02:34,650 --> 00:02:40,570
Please note that the city of Cambridge Audio and Video records this meeting and makes it available to the public for future viewing.

30
00:02:40,570 --> 00:02:46,370
In addition, third parties may also be audio and video recording this meeting.

31
00:02:47,910 --> 00:02:49,810
We will now move on to public comment.

32
00:02:50,110 --> 00:02:59,370
Public comment may be made in the court with Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 38, Section 20G and the City Council rules 23D and 37.

33
00:03:00,090 --> 00:03:02,950
Once you finish speaking, the next speaker will be called.

34
00:03:03,370 --> 00:03:06,870
Individuals are not permitted to allocate the remainder of their time to other speakers.

35
00:03:06,870 --> 00:03:09,170
I ask that you state your name.

36
00:03:09,230 --> 00:03:12,930
That is for the record and the item on the agenda that you are speaking on.

37
00:03:13,390 --> 00:03:18,050
We have over 59 speakers who have signed up.

38
00:03:18,250 --> 00:03:20,790
Each speaker will have two minutes for the rules.

39
00:03:21,430 --> 00:03:22,110
So we will start.

40
00:03:22,770 --> 00:03:24,250
Go ahead to public comment.

41
00:03:24,530 --> 00:03:25,310
Madam Mayor.

42
00:03:25,870 --> 00:03:26,090
Yes.

43
00:03:26,470 --> 00:03:28,110
Council of Nolan is listed as present.

44
00:03:29,150 --> 00:03:29,530
Great.

45
00:03:29,870 --> 00:03:29,890
Present.

46
00:03:30,410 --> 00:03:30,830
Thank you.

47
00:03:31,450 --> 00:03:35,610
Our first speaker will be Elizabeth Rucker, followed by Louise Vendon,

48
00:03:35,610 --> 00:03:40,090
then Denise Jolson. Elizabeth, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

49
00:03:44,240 --> 00:03:50,080
My name is Elizabeth Rucker, and I live at 94 Monobello Road in Jamaica Plane. I managed

50
00:03:50,080 --> 00:03:54,800
the Democracy Center for eight years as the sole employee assigned to it within the Foundation

51
00:03:54,800 --> 00:03:59,280
for civic leadership, and I'm here to speak on the landmark petition for the Nathaniel

52
00:03:59,280 --> 00:04:04,120
Stigney House. I continue to work, play and participate in the Cambridge Community

53
00:04:04,120 --> 00:04:10,960
multiple days per week. In my former position, I handled all aspects of 45 monoburn street,

54
00:04:11,280 --> 00:04:15,920
including its physical structures and all programs. Please vote in favor of landmarking the

55
00:04:15,920 --> 00:04:20,900
building at 45 monoburn street. Landmarking this building is key to ensuring the appropriateness

56
00:04:20,900 --> 00:04:25,580
of new construction and additions and to celebrate the robust history of civic engagement

57
00:04:25,580 --> 00:04:31,040
that was led from this building. The Historic Commission's Favorable Report lays out key architectural

58
00:04:31,040 --> 00:04:35,500
points at length so I will speak to the importance of 45 on Auburn Street to the people and

59
00:05:00,000 --> 00:05:05,620
To see from the ground up. For 22 years, this building was a crossroads of good people doing good work.

60
00:05:06,120 --> 00:05:11,460
Here, generations came together to share wisdom and support, and to nuclear activists mentored those who

61
00:05:11,460 --> 00:05:15,960
would lead the movement for black lives. Here, community leaders used our space to feed,

62
00:05:15,980 --> 00:05:20,920
clothing, shelter immigrants turned out of shelters and Massachusetts. Here, Cambridge by Xafety,

63
00:05:21,000 --> 00:05:26,160
even organized to pass a city by Xafety ordinance. Here, Harvard students from fossil fuel

64
00:05:26,160 --> 00:05:31,400
I vest planned their first direct actions, and 2019 trans people in their allies successfully

65
00:05:31,400 --> 00:05:34,220
mounted a campaign to defend transgender rights statewide.

66
00:05:35,020 --> 00:05:38,940
Aaron Swartz, the legendary internet freedom activist, had an office on the third floor.

67
00:05:39,560 --> 00:05:43,260
I do not have time to list everyone who has made history big and small at the Democracy

68
00:05:43,260 --> 00:05:43,780
Center.

69
00:05:44,260 --> 00:05:49,860
But the Cambridge we are building together has much of the positive history toward the

70
00:05:49,860 --> 00:05:54,240
hearts of 45 Mount Auburn Street, and I encourage you at this time when so much history

71
00:05:54,240 --> 00:05:59,060
is being maliciously rewritten. To preserve our history and celebrate our victories across

72
00:05:59,060 --> 00:06:03,160
generations by landmarking 45 Mount Auburn Street for all of us. Thank you.

73
00:06:05,950 --> 00:06:08,570
Thank you, our next speaker will be Louise Vendon,

74
00:06:08,850 --> 00:06:11,430
followed by Denise Jilsen, then Dan Taien.

75
00:06:12,710 --> 00:06:19,850
Louise has not joined, we will go to Denise Jilsen. Denise, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

76
00:06:20,990 --> 00:06:26,970
Good evening, Denise Jolson, the Executive Director for the Harvard Square Business Association.

77
00:06:27,170 --> 00:06:33,630
And I'm here speaking tonight on policy order, 2026-17.

78
00:06:34,010 --> 00:06:38,390
But before I do, I also want to just weigh in on 45-mile Auburn Street.

79
00:06:39,330 --> 00:06:48,570
I think landmarking that building is a, it makes good sense, and we should consider doing it.

80
00:06:48,570 --> 00:06:58,070
I think it means a lot to Harvard Square and Harvard Square's history, and we should consider the recommendation from Charlie Sullivan.

81
00:06:58,470 --> 00:07:18,090
Thank you. Here tonight to speak about policy order regarding pedestrianization, and I want to first of all thank

82
00:07:18,090 --> 00:07:23,310
here and thoughtfulness. Especially so when we consider a business district like Harvard Square,

83
00:07:23,770 --> 00:07:28,810
which is comprised of approximately 44 acres, about a million square feet of retail restaurant,

84
00:07:29,550 --> 00:07:32,510
services, hotels and social service providers.

85
00:07:34,730 --> 00:07:38,390
And we, of which, by the way, 70% are still

86
00:07:38,390 --> 00:07:47,870
locally owned independent. We also received between 68 million visitors per year. And when we consider

87
00:07:48,090 --> 00:08:15,730
The talent that we have within the city within the department heads and staff of the, I think we're not calling it Department of Transportation, within community development, within the Harvard Square Business Association, as well as the Harvard Square Advisory, and this body, this, this, you know, the City Council, as well as neighbors and property owners who have weighed in over the years regarding pedestrianization.

88
00:08:15,730 --> 00:08:23,330
I feel confident that there is not a group of people better suited who understand the cadence

89
00:08:23,330 --> 00:08:29,970
of Harvard Square and will work to enhance not only the pedestrianization but the curation

90
00:08:29,970 --> 00:08:35,090
of the public space. We want to partner with the city of Cambridge and hope that all of you

91
00:08:35,090 --> 00:08:37,910
will support this council order. Thank you.

92
00:08:40,290 --> 00:08:44,210
Our next speaker is Dan Taun followed by Ian Simmons

93
00:08:44,210 --> 00:08:50,010
than Jerry Pouchello. Dan, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

94
00:08:52,750 --> 00:08:59,770
Yes, hi. My name is Dan Totten. I live at 54 Bishop Malindrive and I also want to speak

95
00:08:59,770 --> 00:09:07,510
in support of Landmarking the building at 4335 Mount Auburn Street. I am a community member,

96
00:09:07,750 --> 00:09:11,970
a former frequent user of the Democracy Center and a signatory to the original Landmark

97
00:09:13,210 --> 00:09:19,570
The building does have objective historical and architectural significance when it was built nearly 200 years ago.

98
00:09:20,010 --> 00:09:21,670
The surrounding area was pasture land.

99
00:09:22,150 --> 00:09:30,350
It was one of the few surviving structures from that era in a neighborhood who is a peal as a global tourist destination is inseparable from its historic building.

100
00:09:30,990 --> 00:09:41,610
The fact that this building has been listed since 1982 on the National Register of Historic Places as a contributing resource is evidence that these concerns did not come out of thin air over the past year.

101
00:10:00,000 --> 00:10:08,120
Last 25 years, the building served as the Democracy Center, one of the city's last remaining affordable gathering spaces for working class organizers and community groups.

102
00:10:08,500 --> 00:10:14,940
As Cambridge has transformed into a playground for the wealthy, working class residents and the spaces that serve them have been systematically erased.

103
00:10:15,420 --> 00:10:18,200
The closure of the Democracy Center is part of that problem.

104
00:10:18,680 --> 00:10:27,600
I do agree that discretion is important, and I share concerns about the historical process, potentially blocking housing in some cases,

105
00:10:27,600 --> 00:10:32,460
but I think in this case, we have no promise of housing, I would love it if Mr. Simmons

106
00:10:32,460 --> 00:10:34,820
would promise us some housing on the site.

107
00:10:35,700 --> 00:10:44,920
But I think that it's very important that we maintain a degree of accountability over what

108
00:10:44,920 --> 00:10:53,920
happens on this site so that as we go forward, as we go forward that the owner is not allowed

109
00:10:53,920 --> 00:11:00,240
do whatever he wants, carte blanche. It's been almost two years since this happened and the promise

110
00:11:00,240 --> 00:11:05,060
of bringing the community in engaging with us and meeting with us has never come to fruition

111
00:11:05,060 --> 00:11:13,060
and I would really value an opportunity to have that discussion respectfully and with Mr. Simmons

112
00:11:13,060 --> 00:11:18,580
regardless of how this turns out. Thank you very much. Thank you. Our next speaker is the

113
00:11:18,580 --> 00:11:23,900
Simons followed by Jerry Pujillo, then Marilyn Frankenstein, Frankenstein.

114
00:11:24,100 --> 00:11:26,440
The end you have two minutes, please go ahead.

115
00:11:29,270 --> 00:11:32,090
Hi, this is Ian Simmons, thanks for allowing us to speak tonight.

116
00:11:33,770 --> 00:11:35,490
I'm President of the Foundation for Civic Leadership,

117
00:11:36,290 --> 00:11:40,990
a small nonprofit that created the Moxie Center at 45 Med Auburn Street more than 20 years ago.

118
00:11:41,430 --> 00:11:45,150
I'm here tonight to respectfully reaffirm our opposition to landmarking 45 Med Auburn.

119
00:11:45,670 --> 00:11:49,690
We appreciate the work of the Cambridge Store Commission and want to thank Charlie Sullivan and the staff

120
00:11:49,690 --> 00:11:54,270
that said 3 key points remain. First, the property is already appropriately protected within

121
00:11:54,270 --> 00:11:58,790
this dark Harvard Square conservation district where changes already require a certificate

122
00:11:58,790 --> 00:12:03,530
of appropriateness. The city's current framework already provides the right kind of oversight.

123
00:12:04,470 --> 00:12:08,990
Second, while the 19th century Greek revival facade is notable, it already has adequate protection

124
00:12:08,990 --> 00:12:14,250
and the history of 45 in Auburn does not meet the threshold for historic landmark designation

125
00:12:14,250 --> 00:12:19,410
when compared to other landmarks across the city. Finally, we would, I've always been deeply

126
00:12:19,410 --> 00:12:24,670
committed to improving 45-minute Auburn as a civic hub, a landmark designation creates

127
00:12:24,670 --> 00:12:28,890
undue burdens and undue to risk for the nonprofit civic project going forward and would

128
00:12:28,890 --> 00:12:33,330
limit the amount of civic stability to continue to expand civic space on site.

129
00:12:34,170 --> 00:12:40,050
We would strongly encourage the council to keep our ability to maximize the expansion of

130
00:12:40,050 --> 00:12:44,790
civic space to help us improve civic, Cambridge civic and community life.

131
00:12:46,170 --> 00:12:47,590
Thank you so much for your time and consideration.

132
00:12:53,060 --> 00:12:58,400
Thank you, and I'm just going to call and I'm comes to my government. He's been here for a while for his role call.

133
00:12:58,580 --> 00:13:01,760
Council, look, Evan, present.

134
00:13:02,960 --> 00:13:08,440
The next speaker is Jerry Puchillo followed by Maryland Frankenstein, the Neil Miller.

135
00:13:08,900 --> 00:13:11,360
Jerry, you have the floor. Please go ahead two minutes.

136
00:13:12,700 --> 00:13:17,640
Thank you. My name is Jerry Puchillo, and I'm a consultant to the foundation for civic leadership.

137
00:13:17,860 --> 00:13:20,780
I'll keep my comments very brief, since you just heard from Ian.

138
00:13:20,780 --> 00:13:27,080
I have had decades of real estate development experience, including for 15 years, a position

139
00:13:27,080 --> 00:13:31,680
as the director of housing development for the Archdiocese of Boston. In that role,

140
00:13:31,800 --> 00:13:36,320
and others, I have acquired extensive experience in the rehab of existing historic assets,

141
00:13:36,580 --> 00:13:41,960
and I deeply appreciate the value of preserving such assets. It's partially due to that experience

142
00:13:41,960 --> 00:13:46,780
that the foundation has asked me to assist in the redevelopment of the property at 45 monoblin

143
00:13:46,780 --> 00:14:03,020
Much of my work has been focused on building low and moderate income housing for people with disabilities as well as repositioning these assets to serve ongoing strategic goals and nonprofit organizations such as the foundation for civic leadership.

144
00:14:03,920 --> 00:14:15,500
I accepted this specific assignment from the foundation because I believe they have demonstrated that they are aligned with the city schools and have worked for decades to provide civic space to enrich and build community at this location.

145
00:14:15,500 --> 00:14:27,500
As you've heard from me and they help to only deepen this commitment going forward and it would limit their resolve if you were to add further constraints on their ability to do so.

146
00:14:28,400 --> 00:14:29,380
Thank you very much.

147
00:14:31,520 --> 00:14:41,900
Thank you our next speaker is Marilyn Frankenstein followed by Neil Miller than David Helper and Marilyn you have the floor two minutes.

148
00:14:42,640 --> 00:14:44,180
Please go ahead.

149
00:14:47,890 --> 00:14:49,810
Sorry, am I unmuted?

150
00:14:50,730 --> 00:14:52,190
You are, please go ahead.

151
00:14:52,490 --> 00:14:54,710
Sorry, I couldn't see the sign.

152
00:14:55,650 --> 00:14:59,350
Marilyn Frankenstein, 40 plus year resident of West Cambridge.

153
00:15:00,000 --> 00:15:08,540
Cambridge will value by designating it a landmark. Beyond that historical concern is also that building's

154
00:15:08,540 --> 00:15:14,120
more current quarter of a century history is the democracy center, a comfortable and safe space

155
00:15:14,120 --> 00:15:21,460
for a variety of social justice organizations to meet and host events. I'm a community coalition member

156
00:15:21,460 --> 00:15:27,800
of heart, Cambridge's holistic emergency alternative response team, which developed their model

157
00:15:27,800 --> 00:15:30,740
for unarmed prices response in this space,

158
00:15:31,240 --> 00:15:33,760
and which also hosted a number of community gatherings

159
00:15:33,760 --> 00:15:35,580
at the Democracy Center.

160
00:15:36,760 --> 00:15:40,080
I've been to other organizations, educational events there,

161
00:15:40,400 --> 00:15:43,060
and art builds in that same building.

162
00:15:43,620 --> 00:15:47,300
It was an important space, not just for each individual organization,

163
00:15:47,980 --> 00:15:51,200
but for the natural, significant collaborations

164
00:15:51,200 --> 00:15:53,620
among social justice organizations.

165
00:15:54,420 --> 00:15:56,720
This is also an important part of the history

166
00:15:56,720 --> 00:16:03,780
a 45-minute urban street that I urge you to consider invoting yes to approve its landmark designation.

167
00:16:12,620 --> 00:16:17,480
Apologies. I just wanted to make a quick announcement. Some folks are having some issues with the

168
00:16:17,480 --> 00:16:23,200
stream. We're working on that, but this meeting is being recorded. So we'll have a video of it up

169
00:16:23,200 --> 00:16:31,580
immediately after. Our next speaker is Neil Miller followed by David Helperin, then Kelsey Kelter.

170
00:16:31,580 --> 00:16:34,580
Neil, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

171
00:16:36,980 --> 00:16:39,780
Hi, Neil Miller, four, two, five, MassAv.

172
00:16:39,900 --> 00:16:43,760
First, I wanted to just give a note of appreciation.

173
00:16:44,340 --> 00:16:46,880
Thank you to all the folks at DPW,

174
00:16:47,180 --> 00:16:47,940
Living on MassAv.

175
00:16:47,980 --> 00:16:51,380
I could see and hear people working through the night

176
00:16:51,380 --> 00:16:53,020
for the night, into the morning,

177
00:16:53,580 --> 00:16:54,640
keeping the road clear.

178
00:16:54,840 --> 00:16:58,740
So thank you so much for everything that they do.

179
00:16:58,740 --> 00:17:05,160
I'm calling in in support of passing tonight the Cambridge Street Zone in petition,

180
00:17:05,940 --> 00:17:14,360
given the, I'm especially excited that the sites on Webster Street and Windsor Street going towards

181
00:17:14,360 --> 00:17:22,260
units where we'll now be encouraged and incentivized to turn into homes that we really need

182
00:17:22,260 --> 00:17:24,560
near jobs, near transit,

183
00:17:26,620 --> 00:17:35,480
I am disappointed that it seems like there is a push to move the

184
00:17:35,480 --> 00:17:42,100
zoning or the allowable heights on the rest of Cambridge Street down below what it even was

185
00:17:42,100 --> 00:17:49,020
already moved down to. It's stories to six stories. Everyone on this council basically says that

186
00:17:49,020 --> 00:17:56,780
the poor transit oriented development, and this was part of a long time plan to zone for

187
00:17:56,780 --> 00:18:01,740
more homes in our squares and corridors. And with the amendments, it does not do that,

188
00:18:01,840 --> 00:18:08,100
but I support passing the plan for the Webster Windsor Street sub-district to allow housing

189
00:18:08,100 --> 00:18:14,880
there. But before the amendments are voted on, it would encourage us to ask city staff,

190
00:18:14,880 --> 00:18:20,620
whether the changes on Cambridge Street will make rents higher or lower for people's

191
00:18:20,620 --> 00:18:25,900
struggling to stay in Cambridge, whether it will provide more opportunities for small businesses,

192
00:18:26,240 --> 00:18:32,960
for fewer, whether it will make Cambridge Street more or less friendly to other forms of

193
00:18:32,960 --> 00:18:38,380
transportation. I think these are important questions to ask as we're making these decisions. Thank you.

194
00:18:38,440 --> 00:18:38,880
Have a good night.

195
00:18:41,300 --> 00:18:44,960
Thank you. Our next speaker is David Halper and followed by Kelsey

196
00:18:44,960 --> 00:18:53,000
counter than Ethan Frank. David, you have two minutes. Please go ahead. Good evening David

197
00:18:53,000 --> 00:18:59,940
happened in 14 Valentine Street Unit 3. I'm also calling in to express my support for

198
00:18:59,940 --> 00:19:06,160
passing the Cambridge Street. It's owning Petition, not letting expire. Back during the multi-handly

199
00:19:06,160 --> 00:19:12,520
housing process. We were showing how under any scenario we're not going to hit our housing production

200
00:19:12,520 --> 00:19:19,460
goals and, you know, the multi-family housing would be one component of, you know, getting us back

201
00:19:19,460 --> 00:19:26,760
on track, a third something more reasonable, but the majority of our housing was projected to still

202
00:19:26,760 --> 00:19:32,780
be built on our squares and corridors. So, you know, and, you know, on our all these processes,

203
00:19:33,160 --> 00:19:36,920
we're always told, you know, well, the place that we should really be able to have something is

204
00:20:00,000 --> 00:20:29,500
And you know, continuing to water it down, we're going to have, you know, most of Cambridge Street be the same height as the neighborhoods, then, you know, it's, you know, like how is most of our housing going to be on our corridors, you know, it doesn't make sense, it's not consistent with what people have said they wanted in the past. So you know, I, you know,

205
00:20:29,500 --> 00:20:34,920
We can really, like move our with the best compromise that we can tonight,

206
00:20:37,020 --> 00:20:37,220
but, you know,

207
00:20:40,760 --> 00:20:50,180
but yeah, like we continue under every scenario where we are falling behind our housing goals,

208
00:20:50,280 --> 00:20:58,840
and we need to take that seriously, and we need to continue to find new strategies to move that forward,

209
00:20:58,840 --> 00:21:03,580
And you know, to get the housing, we built both market rate and affordable as

210
00:21:03,580 --> 00:21:06,200
inclusionary and you know, every tool in the toolbox.

211
00:21:06,380 --> 00:21:07,380
Thank you.

212
00:21:09,380 --> 00:21:09,740
Thank you.

213
00:21:09,860 --> 00:21:15,800
Our next speaker is Kelsey Keltzer, followed by Ethan Frank, then Dana Bullister.

214
00:21:16,760 --> 00:21:19,420
Kelsey, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

215
00:21:21,020 --> 00:21:21,400
Excellent.

216
00:21:21,920 --> 00:21:26,500
Distinguished City Councilors, thank you for pivoting to a virtual setting amid the New England

217
00:21:26,500 --> 00:21:27,120
Snowfall.

218
00:21:27,120 --> 00:21:31,720
My name is Kelsey Kelter, and I'm a resident of 71 Thorndike Street in Cambridge.

219
00:21:32,460 --> 00:21:37,160
I'm here to share my strong support for Policy Order 2, regarding the incorporation

220
00:21:37,160 --> 00:21:42,800
of plant-based solutions into the Sustainable Cambridge Initiative, which aligns with the plant-based treaty.

221
00:21:43,560 --> 00:21:48,540
In a professional capacity, I am dedicated and a dedicated environmentalist and sustainability consultant,

222
00:21:48,980 --> 00:21:51,320
specializing in enterprise-wide corporate decarbonization.

223
00:21:51,320 --> 00:21:57,260
As I volunteer, I co-lead the Sierra clubs of Massachusetts Energy Justice team, and I am a nine-year

224
00:21:57,260 --> 00:22:00,520
vegan for the planet, going back to my undergrad at Boston College.

225
00:22:01,380 --> 00:22:06,700
At the nexus of sustainability, environmentalism, and equitable justice, sits the plant-based

226
00:22:06,700 --> 00:22:07,100
treaty.

227
00:22:07,840 --> 00:22:13,080
My fellow campaigners will share more detail of the campaign in due course, but I am here to

228
00:22:13,080 --> 00:22:17,940
speak on the environmental effects of plant-based defaults, which can be included in the city's

229
00:22:17,940 --> 00:22:20,340
plant-based food strategy for events.

230
00:22:21,100 --> 00:22:28,680
Defaults make plant-based options the standard no-action choice with meat and daily of dairy available upon request.

231
00:22:28,960 --> 00:22:35,340
Studies have shown that serving plant-based food as the default option decreases meat consumption by up to 87%.

232
00:22:35,880 --> 00:22:42,340
Thus reducing foods GHD emissions by an average of 40% and the water footprint therein by 24%.

233
00:22:42,340 --> 00:22:48,620
percent. This behavioral nudging technique increases sustainable, healthy, healthier eating,

234
00:22:49,100 --> 00:22:54,440
while preserving freedom of choice. Thus, serving meals that work for all dietary restrictions,

235
00:22:55,020 --> 00:23:00,900
reduces overhead and food waste within our boundaries. Cambridge can use plant-based defaults

236
00:23:00,900 --> 00:23:06,080
and it's effective tool at the events to meet our carbon reduction goals while saving on food costs

237
00:23:06,080 --> 00:23:11,120
and improving health and inclusivity in the community. This will help Cambridge reach its net zero

238
00:23:11,120 --> 00:23:15,600
she emissions by 2020, 2050. I asked this council to formally adopt

239
00:23:15,600 --> 00:23:20,080
potency water too, and I thank you to the councilors thus forward who have endorsed

240
00:23:20,080 --> 00:23:24,220
this petition, and for the whole council for considering the adoption of the plant-based

241
00:23:24,220 --> 00:23:25,200
treaty for Cambridge.

242
00:23:27,320 --> 00:23:29,460
Thank you, our next speaker is Ethan Frank,

243
00:23:29,460 --> 00:23:36,680
followed by Dana Bullister, then Jason House. Ethan, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

244
00:23:38,020 --> 00:23:40,120
Hello. Can you hear me?

245
00:23:42,690 --> 00:23:52,670
Yes, we can. Please go ahead. My name is Ethan. I live at 632 MassAv and the NVTA's

246
00:23:52,670 --> 00:24:02,270
cancellation of their L-Wi-3 development plan reminds me why it's so important that we use all of

247
00:24:02,270 --> 00:24:10,770
space we have available as efficiently as possible, which is just one of the many reasons

248
00:24:10,770 --> 00:24:13,330
that we should upzone Cambridge Street tonight.

249
00:24:14,390 --> 00:24:15,110
Thank you.

250
00:24:21,310 --> 00:24:21,690
Thank you.

251
00:24:21,770 --> 00:24:24,070
Our next speaker is Dana Ballister.

252
00:24:26,130 --> 00:24:27,090
Dana has not joined.

253
00:24:27,270 --> 00:24:32,710
We will go to Jason Alves followed by Jim Monteverde, then Taylor Cross.

254
00:24:33,170 --> 00:24:34,330
Jason, you have two minutes.

255
00:24:34,590 --> 00:24:35,310
Please go ahead.

256
00:24:37,710 --> 00:24:42,290
Hi, this is Jason Alves, Executive Director of these Cambridge Business Association,

257
00:24:42,630 --> 00:24:44,710
544 Cambridge Street.

258
00:24:45,170 --> 00:24:49,130
I want to just speak on the Cambridge Street Zoning and the communication tonight.

259
00:24:50,030 --> 00:24:59,970
So just a thanks to Council of Newell and I'm here to D.C. for recommending what I think is a pretty some good change.

260
00:25:00,000 --> 00:25:18,280
The communication tonight, so just a thanks to Councillor Nolan and Mayor Sediki for recommending what I think is a pretty some some good changes and it makes for a nice compromise on the Cambridge Street zone in petition.

261
00:25:18,960 --> 00:25:26,940
I think for us it's important that the the website of intersection, it's something we've been advocating for close to a decade now.

262
00:25:26,940 --> 00:25:30,880
I think there was a missed opportunity because of some previous zoning, but I think getting

263
00:25:30,880 --> 00:25:35,720
that up zone there as a transition transition into the point in yards area of someable

264
00:25:35,720 --> 00:25:42,220
and union square can really help create some good transit oriented housing development that

265
00:25:42,220 --> 00:25:44,240
doesn't really cause much displacement.

266
00:25:45,160 --> 00:25:51,200
Think the reduction along Cambridge Street to six stories is a nice compromise.

267
00:25:51,200 --> 00:25:56,800
I think it gets in line with some of the recommendations of the R Camus Street study.

268
00:25:57,220 --> 00:26:03,280
You know, Camus Street is basically, has been up zone recently to six stories, and this kind

269
00:26:03,280 --> 00:26:10,220
of refines that zoning to make it more manageable for the neighborhood.

270
00:26:11,200 --> 00:26:16,620
So I think that that's a nice compromise, and I think we're supportive of all this knowing

271
00:26:16,620 --> 00:26:22,240
that you will be revisiting the ground floor commercial requirements and a subsequent petition.

272
00:26:23,080 --> 00:26:27,020
That is very, very important to the district and something that we want to see happen.

273
00:26:30,080 --> 00:26:36,900
I guess quickly. So, hope you can pass this tonight. Again, I think it's a good compromise

274
00:26:36,900 --> 00:26:42,580
that can hopefully make a lot of different parties that have concerns and hopes for

275
00:26:42,580 --> 00:26:45,360
me street and bring everybody in line. So thank you all very much.

276
00:26:47,560 --> 00:26:58,020
Thank you. Our next speaker is Jim Monteverde. Followed by Taylor Cross then and it's holy bore a soft. Jim you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

277
00:27:05,100 --> 00:27:08,080
Jim Monteverde if you can unmute yourself you have the floor two minutes.

278
00:27:09,760 --> 00:27:20,780
Sorry. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Jim Monteverde of 12 oak street in mid square. I asked that you let the Cambridge street zoning petition expire and require the be revised with

279
00:27:20,800 --> 00:27:24,260
benefit of a robust open public review process.

280
00:27:25,060 --> 00:27:29,780
I support the Nolan Sediki Amendment to change the height limit in the new district

281
00:27:30,480 --> 00:27:36,920
C.A.M. eight to six stories and ask that that same limit applied to the new district

282
00:27:36,920 --> 00:27:44,000
C.A.M. ten in the heart of image square. I suggest that the proposed design review thresholds

283
00:27:44,000 --> 00:27:50,780
of 75,000 square feet for residential projects be reduced so that most if not all of new

284
00:27:50,780 --> 00:27:56,380
development along Cambridge Street require review by the planning board to force their design

285
00:27:56,380 --> 00:28:02,500
competence. The zoning proposal should also be revised to allow existing retail uses to

286
00:28:02,500 --> 00:28:08,800
continue in any new construction to maintain the retail character and vibrancy of the street.

287
00:28:09,340 --> 00:28:14,620
Please let the zoning petition expire so that it can be improved to reflect the public

288
00:28:14,620 --> 00:28:18,560
to vision for Cambridge Street through public review and comment.

289
00:28:19,000 --> 00:28:20,020
Thank you.

290
00:28:23,540 --> 00:28:26,620
Thank you, our next speaker is Taylor Cross,

291
00:28:26,620 --> 00:28:30,460
followed by Anatolia Borosov, then Hannah Roach.

292
00:28:30,920 --> 00:28:33,440
Taylor, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

293
00:28:35,140 --> 00:28:35,700
Good evening.

294
00:28:35,840 --> 00:28:37,180
My name is Taylor Cross,

295
00:28:37,200 --> 00:28:41,020
and my address is 1315 Harvard Yard Male Center Cambridge,

296
00:28:41,340 --> 00:28:43,280
and I'm here in strong supportive Cambridge

297
00:28:43,280 --> 00:28:46,680
endorsing the plant-based treaty and policy order number two.

298
00:28:46,680 --> 00:28:53,940
I'm a lifelong classical ballet dancer and a first year pre-med student at Harvard, planning to pursue cardiovascular surgery.

299
00:28:54,500 --> 00:28:58,460
Through years of intensive ballet training and internships with the Vascular Surgeons,

300
00:28:58,920 --> 00:29:04,420
I became deeply interested in the intersection of nutrition, chronic disease and preventative medicine.

301
00:29:04,920 --> 00:29:12,340
That journey led me to study Whole Foods Plant-based Nutrition and to see firsthand how powerful it can be for long-term health.

302
00:29:12,940 --> 00:29:15,280
We are living in a chronic disease epidemic.

303
00:29:15,280 --> 00:29:21,060
heart disease, diabetes, and many cancers are now the leading causes of death and disability

304
00:29:21,060 --> 00:29:26,840
in the U.S. These are largely preventable conditions. Yet our health care system spends

305
00:29:26,840 --> 00:29:33,020
trillions of dollars treating symptoms rather than addressing root causes. One of the most

306
00:29:33,020 --> 00:29:39,360
effective evidence-based tools we have is also one of the simplest food. A whole foods plant-based

307
00:29:39,360 --> 00:29:45,260
diet has been shown to prevent, treat, and in many cases reverse chronic disease. Leading physician

308
00:29:45,260 --> 00:29:50,680
and researchers, including many within the Cambridge and Harvard Medical Community, have demonstrated

309
00:29:50,680 --> 00:29:55,640
that plant-based diets can lower cholesterol, improve insulin sensitivity, and significantly

310
00:29:55,640 --> 00:29:59,980
reduce cardiovascular risk. What I find especially meaningful about the—

311
00:30:00,000 --> 00:30:07,000
Is a clear, responsible step in the right direction. Thank you so much for your leadership and for considering this important vote.

312
00:30:09,820 --> 00:30:19,400
Our next speaker is Annette Holi, Borisov, followed by Hannah Roach, then Rosa Diaz Rivera, Annette Holi, two minutes.

313
00:30:21,040 --> 00:30:30,520
Thank you. My name is Annette Holi, Borisov. I live at 153 Webster Avenue, and I'm speaking about the proposed amendment to the Cambridge Zoningordinates near Cambridge Street,

314
00:30:30,520 --> 00:30:35,780
which I am strongly in support of. I'd argue that it is the responsibility of any city to balance

315
00:30:35,780 --> 00:30:40,580
its ability to provide housing, services, and job opportunities to its residents. There are

316
00:30:40,580 --> 00:30:44,180
currently many great reasons to live in Cambridge and frankly, it's unlikely that people will

317
00:30:44,180 --> 00:30:49,180
stop wanting to move to and remain in Cambridge. Between the vibrant communities, job opportunities,

318
00:30:50,060 --> 00:30:54,380
and being a part of the extensive Boston metropolitan area, populations will likely continue to

319
00:30:54,380 --> 00:30:59,220
grow in Cambridge. And to handle this transition gracefully and equitably, it is important that

320
00:30:59,220 --> 00:31:01,500
provide enough housing to meet their demand.

321
00:31:02,200 --> 00:31:05,920
The exceedingly low vacancy rate of apartments in high housing and rental prices indicate

322
00:31:05,920 --> 00:31:08,820
that despite the historical effort, Cambridge still lags behind.

323
00:31:09,280 --> 00:31:13,440
When this occurs, the wealthiest that can handle these prices are made in the rest are excluded

324
00:31:13,440 --> 00:31:14,720
from the Cambridge community.

325
00:31:15,920 --> 00:31:20,260
I think an important part of a graceful transition to demands that higher population brings comes

326
00:31:20,260 --> 00:31:23,440
with recognizing that housing and transportation are needed in tandem.

327
00:31:24,060 --> 00:31:27,940
As a result, the proposed upselling of Cambridge Street serves as a prime candidate as an effective

328
00:31:27,940 --> 00:31:32,260
to provide housing due to its accessibility to means of public transport.

329
00:31:32,720 --> 00:31:37,420
While there can and should be discussion about if these zoning changes in themselves are adequate

330
00:31:37,420 --> 00:31:42,700
to promote the development of housing, to me there's little doubt that this is a step in the

331
00:31:42,700 --> 00:31:47,700
direction of building more housing in Cambridge. Thus for that reason I am in support of the proposed

332
00:31:47,700 --> 00:31:53,140
establishment of New Zoning District on Cambridge Street, as a necessary albeit not sufficient

333
00:31:53,140 --> 00:31:57,520
set to allow Cambridge to equitably meet housing demand. Thank you.

334
00:31:57,900 --> 00:32:02,420
Thank you, our next speaker is Hannah Roach. Hannah, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

335
00:32:06,020 --> 00:32:11,640
Hi, this is Hannah Roach. I live at 20 Orchard Street in Cambridge, and I am a master student of nutrition at Tufts,

336
00:32:11,700 --> 00:32:16,500
and volunteer for the local plant-based community campaign. And I am testifying to ask you to vote for your

337
00:32:16,500 --> 00:32:26,000
verbally on policy order number two. As a volunteer, I wanted to use this time to talk a bit about the

338
00:32:26,000 --> 00:32:30,320
through the initiative that brings food systems into the climate crisis conversation.

339
00:32:31,140 --> 00:32:35,820
Plant-based diets are proven to be the most environmentally sustainable and can also be the

340
00:32:35,820 --> 00:32:42,580
healthiest diets for us. Currently, 65 other cities worldwide have endorsed the plant-based

341
00:32:42,580 --> 00:32:48,360
treaty with campaigns spreading across every continent. One notable recent endorsement that

342
00:32:48,360 --> 00:32:54,020
I would like to mention is from the City of Belém in Brazil. Belém is located in the Amazon

343
00:32:54,020 --> 00:33:00,260
where mass deforestation has been ceaselessly occurring, often illegally, in order to raise

344
00:33:00,260 --> 00:33:04,960
and feed cattle and meet the rising demands for meat exports to the global north.

345
00:33:05,580 --> 00:33:09,080
They recognize the need for a plant-based treaty, and so should we.

346
00:33:09,900 --> 00:33:14,220
Cambridge already deeply acknowledges the climate crisis, encircled for the health of those

347
00:33:14,220 --> 00:33:18,020
who live here, so it logically follows that the city would join the squabble coalition

348
00:33:18,020 --> 00:33:19,580
and promote plant-based eating.

349
00:33:20,280 --> 00:33:27,180
Also, I'd like to clarify that this policy order does not take away any existing food options from any city resident.

350
00:33:27,680 --> 00:33:32,140
It only aims to increase accessibility and education regarding plant-based foods and diets.

351
00:33:32,860 --> 00:33:39,620
On top of that, the local plant-based 3D team is here to provide any assistance the city may need when implementing this new policy order.

352
00:33:40,580 --> 00:33:47,660
Thank you for your time counselors, and I again ask for all of you to vote in support of informally-adowed policy order number two.

353
00:33:47,940 --> 00:33:48,220
Thank you.

354
00:33:49,660 --> 00:34:00,060
Our next speaker is Rosa Diaz Rivera followed by N.J. Park, then Carl Schmepper. Rosa, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

355
00:34:05,950 --> 00:34:14,090
Council members. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Rosa Diaz Rivera, and I have lived in 50 Cambridge Park Drive for two and a half years.

356
00:34:14,090 --> 00:34:19,410
I am here to ask the Council to vote favorably on policy order number 2.

357
00:34:19,710 --> 00:34:24,470
Research shows that shifting towards plant-based eating delivers real economic benefits

358
00:34:24,470 --> 00:34:30,330
for households and governments, reducing reliance on animal agricultural globally would allow

359
00:34:30,330 --> 00:34:34,250
us to produce enough additional food to feed hundreds of millions of people.

360
00:35:00,000 --> 00:35:12,960
Of dollars each year in healthcare costs. While a broader shift towards a plant-based diet could save up to 250 billion annually and prevent hundreds of thousands of deaths linked to chronic disease.

361
00:35:13,580 --> 00:35:18,220
Importantly, plant-based diets are not more expensive for households, that is often assumed.

362
00:35:18,220 --> 00:35:23,400
Oxford University research found that vegan diets are the most affordable, cutting food costs

363
00:35:23,400 --> 00:35:29,080
by up to one third, a separate study confirmed that plant-based consumers spend less

364
00:35:29,080 --> 00:35:31,260
on food than omnivores overall.

365
00:35:31,720 --> 00:35:36,140
These findings directly challenge the idea that healthy, sustainable eating is financially

366
00:35:36,140 --> 00:35:37,740
out of reach for many people.

367
00:35:38,380 --> 00:35:43,180
For a city-like Cambridge, where cost of living is a major concern, this evidence highlights

368
00:35:43,180 --> 00:35:48,540
the importance of public information campaigns that promote plant-based eating as a budget-friendly

369
00:35:48,540 --> 00:35:54,500
option. But clearly communicating the financial benefits, Cambridge can empower residents to

370
00:35:54,500 --> 00:36:00,200
make choices that stretch household budgets and reduce long-term healthcare costs. Public education

371
00:36:00,200 --> 00:36:06,460
is a low-cost, high-impact tool that benefits everyone in the community. Thank you so much for your time.

372
00:36:08,120 --> 00:36:15,040
Our next speaker is N.J. Park followed by Carl Schmeck, Pepper, the Nina Wu.

373
00:36:15,480 --> 00:36:18,300
N.J., you have the floor of two minutes. Please go ahead.

374
00:36:26,390 --> 00:36:30,590
Good evening, Councillor. My name is N.J., and I'm a Cambridge resident at 332

375
00:36:30,590 --> 00:36:33,250
Broadway and an MBA student at Northeastern University.

376
00:36:33,950 --> 00:36:35,650
Thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight.

377
00:36:36,550 --> 00:36:40,770
I'm here not as a policy expert, but as some of who comes from a long lineage of

378
00:36:40,770 --> 00:36:42,890
Korean home cooks and professional chefs.

379
00:36:42,890 --> 00:36:45,070
Food is how my family show love.

380
00:36:45,610 --> 00:36:50,050
My uncle owns a Korean sushi restaurant in Austin called Opusushi, where we serve classic sushi

381
00:36:50,050 --> 00:36:51,670
and popular Korean dishes.

382
00:36:52,550 --> 00:36:57,290
Like many immigrant own restaurants, it's built on tradition, pride, and hard work.

383
00:36:58,290 --> 00:37:02,770
At the same time, I've seen how traditional Korean cuisine can unintentionally exclude people.

384
00:37:03,390 --> 00:37:08,830
Many staple dishes like Jigae stews and even kimchi rely on animal-based ingredients.

385
00:37:08,830 --> 00:37:13,650
When vegan friends or family die in a Korean restaurant, their options are often limited.

386
00:37:14,390 --> 00:37:16,210
They're there, but not fully included.

387
00:37:17,190 --> 00:37:19,950
I don't see plant-based treaty as an attack on tradition.

388
00:37:20,550 --> 00:37:25,770
I see it as an invitation, an invitation for creativity, evolution, and inclusion.

389
00:37:27,130 --> 00:37:31,030
This policy encourages restaurant across cuisine to expand who they serve,

390
00:37:31,410 --> 00:37:36,370
and gives chef the space to interpret tradition, while responding to today's climate realities.

391
00:37:36,370 --> 00:37:41,530
It also supports local businesses, like Cambridge's own Moments on Kitchen.

392
00:37:42,170 --> 00:37:46,250
While they're not exclusively plant-based Korean business, they're catering model

393
00:37:46,250 --> 00:37:50,930
allow them to adopt menus more flexibly than many brick and mortar restaurants, making

394
00:37:50,930 --> 00:37:56,610
them a valuable resource for individuals and city-sponsored events, looking to include plant-based

395
00:37:56,610 --> 00:37:57,430
Korean options.

396
00:37:58,950 --> 00:38:05,170
Cambridge had long led on climate and equity, and I urge you to vote favorably on policy

397
00:38:05,170 --> 00:38:12,150
order number two for the climate for local businesses and for more inclusive food culture. Thank you.

398
00:38:14,410 --> 00:38:22,170
Our next speaker is Carl Schlockpepper followed by Nina Wu, the young Kim. Carl, you have two

399
00:38:22,170 --> 00:38:23,650
minutes. Please go ahead.

400
00:38:30,240 --> 00:38:35,920
My name is Carl Schlocker. I live in 249 third street in East Cambridge,

401
00:38:35,920 --> 00:38:39,960
And I'd like to speak today on the Cambridge Street Building petition.

402
00:38:41,740 --> 00:38:46,100
I urge the Council to please adopt the Cambridge Street Building petition,

403
00:38:47,040 --> 00:38:49,720
increase the density along our squares and corridors,

404
00:38:50,680 --> 00:38:54,340
is something that's critical to meeting the city's goals,

405
00:38:55,140 --> 00:38:57,820
on housing reduction, making housing more affordable for everybody,

406
00:38:58,540 --> 00:39:01,980
and environmentally by making it so people are able to live

407
00:39:01,980 --> 00:39:07,100
close to public transportation and a less current dependent.

408
00:39:09,680 --> 00:39:13,520
Further we do this in the heights of this own inclusion via mistake,

409
00:39:13,980 --> 00:39:16,500
the women how many people would be able to live here, which would

410
00:39:16,500 --> 00:39:20,060
limit how many people would be able to have cheaper housing.

411
00:39:22,020 --> 00:39:25,460
So I urge the council to adopt the donation

412
00:39:25,460 --> 00:39:27,920
with no further questions.

413
00:39:28,320 --> 00:39:29,380
Thank you.

414
00:39:30,910 --> 00:39:34,750
Your next speaker is Nina Wu.

415
00:39:35,190 --> 00:39:37,370
We're at speaker number 22 for those waiting.

416
00:39:37,930 --> 00:39:39,910
Nina, you have two minutes.

417
00:39:40,650 --> 00:39:41,570
Please go ahead.

418
00:39:44,170 --> 00:39:45,670
Good evening, city counselors.

419
00:40:01,020 --> 00:40:12,100
I am a first student at Harvard College and the co-president of Harvard Undergrab campus. I am here to ask you to vote favorably on policy order number two and endorse the plant-based treaty.

420
00:40:12,980 --> 00:40:17,580
Many others are speaking on environmental and health benefits that come up promoting plant-based sites.

421
00:40:18,040 --> 00:40:23,220
But I would like to use opportunity to speak on what I believe to be the greatest and the benefit of all.

422
00:40:23,220 --> 00:40:26,900
promoting plant-based food allows us to shift towards a more compassionate

423
00:40:26,900 --> 00:40:29,560
free system through improving animal welfare.

424
00:40:30,460 --> 00:40:35,240
An animal agriculture, sentient animals, each with their own personality and lived experiences,

425
00:40:35,860 --> 00:40:40,020
are viewed as nothing more than a surgery food. Their entire lives are predetermined

426
00:40:40,020 --> 00:40:46,880
beings to an end. We're victimized animals being victimized animals being so hidden behind this industrial

427
00:40:46,880 --> 00:40:51,160
system, even the kindness people have trouble viewing the ones in their place and in the fridge

428
00:40:51,160 --> 00:40:57,580
as they don't settle. This policy order of morning and face guides helps not only protect the planet

429
00:40:57,580 --> 00:41:02,380
but also animal welfare. Thank you for your time counselors and I again ask you to book

430
00:41:02,380 --> 00:41:09,160
by Ripley on policy order number two. Thank you. Our next speaker is Young Kim followed by

431
00:41:10,920 --> 00:41:17,360
K.C. Karenfield and Sarah Suzuki. Young, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

432
00:41:18,930 --> 00:41:22,030
You understand the knowledge to it,

433
00:41:22,430 --> 00:41:26,590
people are based on laying the chemicals with corridors on intuition.

434
00:41:27,710 --> 00:41:32,330
Because when stuff descriptions are accepted without the independent verification,

435
00:41:33,290 --> 00:41:40,710
the public record, the causes were all just from less selective oversight to rubber stamping.

436
00:41:41,270 --> 00:41:44,030
And that creates a really institutional risk.

437
00:41:44,030 --> 00:41:54,790
If you both like to, they are in the Cambridge field called Corridor Zone in Petition and so on, together with the Mass Avenue amendment already adopted,

438
00:41:55,550 --> 00:41:58,230
we shall always have some conflict.

439
00:41:58,890 --> 00:42:06,350
Both Corridor maps and descriptive texts will enter the zone where the results were implemented by the CDC.

440
00:42:08,070 --> 00:42:16,710
I'm supposed to overlay such as the mass having overlay, and the overlay, and the replays,

441
00:42:16,730 --> 00:42:22,690
means that say five and 30 districts will also be left gambling in the cold.

442
00:42:23,550 --> 00:42:29,230
They say consistency is the sign of small money, but in the only ordinance, because this

443
00:42:29,230 --> 00:42:35,250
The first thing is the background and must be verified each time on your non-manious introduced.

444
00:42:36,050 --> 00:42:44,110
That particular has been neglected for far too long, and the Cambridge Street corridor may be

445
00:42:44,110 --> 00:42:49,290
where those of cumulative risk finally destabilized the zoning ordinance.

446
00:42:50,070 --> 00:42:58,870
One practical consequence is the rapid up zoning allowing polar project and sub-right is now

447
00:42:58,870 --> 00:43:05,770
According to incentives for city, you were treated to give the perfect affordable developers

448
00:43:05,770 --> 00:43:09,410
of a competitive edge or market developers.

449
00:43:10,430 --> 00:43:17,790
One concrete example, even with the main net sense, I could not find in the engineering

450
00:43:17,790 --> 00:43:23,970
materials, I could not rely on the interest, but put a spirit boundaries, and say any

451
00:43:26,510 --> 00:43:39,150
Thank you, Kim Apologies. Your time is expired. Please email the remainder of your comment. Our next speaker is KC Karen Phil. KC you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

452
00:43:46,380 --> 00:43:51,840
KC you're on the phone. You need to unmute. I believe it's star six to unmute on the phone.

453
00:44:03,240 --> 00:44:05,440
All right. There you go. There you go.

454
00:44:05,440 --> 00:44:07,480
Okay, I'm so sorry for that.

455
00:44:07,480 --> 00:44:07,860
Thank you.

456
00:44:07,920 --> 00:44:09,140
My name is Cotton Phil Casey.

457
00:44:09,760 --> 00:44:11,660
Although I'm currently a resident, I've had

458
00:44:11,660 --> 00:44:13,000
in stack, crowed in Boston.

459
00:44:13,720 --> 00:44:16,620
I am a longtime Cambridge community member

460
00:44:16,620 --> 00:44:19,100
through family work, organizing,

461
00:44:20,920 --> 00:44:21,280
and whatnot.

462
00:44:21,460 --> 00:44:23,780
I am speaking in support of the landmark

463
00:44:23,780 --> 00:44:26,480
designation for 45 Mont Arban Street,

464
00:44:27,140 --> 00:44:28,380
the Nathaniel Stickney House.

465
00:44:28,460 --> 00:44:30,000
I'm not only because of its 200 years

466
00:44:30,900 --> 00:44:33,440
it's historical significance for Cambridge,

467
00:44:33,440 --> 00:44:41,380
but because this is home to the democracy center for a quarter of a century, and I may not be

468
00:44:41,380 --> 00:44:47,040
as elegant as my peers and the former speakers, but I just speak from my heart. I have personally

469
00:44:47,040 --> 00:44:54,240
been, I guess, the participant and an organizer of many gatherings and initiatives that have been

470
00:44:54,240 --> 00:44:59,980
housed and took in place in the former democracy center. We, as far as I know,

471
00:45:00,000 --> 00:45:23,640
Great historical significance. We saw everything from standing rock, black lives matter, trans rights, and these are things that have become a very important part of the history in not just our community, but across many communities. And so I ask that you please consider supporting our request for historical designation.

472
00:45:23,640 --> 00:45:33,590
And I am very grateful to thank you, Council members, for your time and for your commitment.

473
00:45:34,610 --> 00:45:42,570
And I hope that you can remember to consider how important this is to the people, not just in our communities,

474
00:45:43,910 --> 00:45:46,950
that Cambridge has such a commitment to...

475
00:45:48,210 --> 00:45:54,710
Apologies, Karen Phil, if you can please email the remainder of your comment to City Council at CambridgeMade.gov.

476
00:45:55,290 --> 00:45:58,430
Our next speaker is Sarah Suzuki.

477
00:46:00,030 --> 00:46:07,510
I do not see Sarah and the Zoom. We're going to go to James Zall, followed by William Hughes, then Trudy Goodman.

478
00:46:08,030 --> 00:46:10,330
James, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

479
00:46:13,020 --> 00:46:16,460
Thank you. This is James Zall, 203, Pemberton Street.

480
00:46:16,460 --> 00:46:28,340
Since 2022, zoning along Cambridge Street was the subject of community meeting surveys, hearings, lots of public comment and online discussions.

481
00:46:28,980 --> 00:46:34,360
People who participated in these efforts got a chance to contribute to the resulting zoning.

482
00:46:35,040 --> 00:46:42,580
Each participant did not, yet, nor should they get, a set of zoning amendments that exactly match what they asked for.

483
00:46:42,580 --> 00:46:51,080
The claims that the results before you is somehow not legitimate and needs to be done over merely

484
00:46:51,080 --> 00:46:56,700
demonstrates the fact that Cambridge Street and probably every other street in neighborhood

485
00:46:56,700 --> 00:47:02,440
is home to some residents who don't need or don't want more housing in their area.

486
00:47:03,980 --> 00:47:08,660
Citywide surveys and the past several elections indicate that the majority of residents

487
00:47:08,660 --> 00:47:13,760
It's recognized the harmful consequences of our long running shortage of housing.

488
00:47:14,440 --> 00:47:21,000
Even if the requested doover of public engagement is accomplished quickly, the slow start-up

489
00:47:21,000 --> 00:47:27,260
time for new housing and Cambridge ensures that our housing crisis will be no less severe

490
00:47:27,260 --> 00:47:32,520
when the next version of this zoning proposal would come here for a vote.

491
00:47:33,080 --> 00:47:38,200
Please do not toss aside all the work that has been done so far and proceed to enact

492
00:47:38,200 --> 00:47:41,980
the Cambridge Street zoning tonight. Thank you.

493
00:47:43,450 --> 00:47:46,910
You are next speaker is William Hughes.

494
00:47:48,050 --> 00:47:50,470
William, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

495
00:47:50,850 --> 00:47:53,170
Followed by Trudy Goodman. William, you have two minutes.

496
00:47:56,820 --> 00:48:00,060
My name is Liam Hughes. William Hughes, and I live at 20

497
00:48:00,060 --> 00:48:01,420
orcher Street in North Cambridge.

498
00:48:02,480 --> 00:48:05,540
So I came here today to voice my support for policy order number two,

499
00:48:05,720 --> 00:48:09,440
and specifically to discuss the environmental need for a plant-based treaty.

500
00:48:09,440 --> 00:48:15,280
I've been masters degree in mechanical engineering and I work as a mechanical energy systems designer

501
00:48:15,280 --> 00:48:19,040
where I've dedicated my life to decarbonizing buildings throughout Massachusetts.

502
00:48:20,160 --> 00:48:25,560
I chose this career path because I deeply care about taking action to combat the climate crisis

503
00:48:25,560 --> 00:48:34,140
and when I learned about the devastating environmental impact of animal agriculture, that's when I had to adopt a plant-based diet.

504
00:48:34,140 --> 00:48:43,680
Our food system accounts for about 1-3rd of all greenhouse gas emissions, which is larger than even the transportation sector.

505
00:48:44,960 --> 00:48:50,700
So shifting towards a plant-based diet is a huge component of addressing climate change.

506
00:48:52,100 --> 00:49:02,180
When it comes to the decarbonization, every little bit counts and similarly, when we choose to purchase plant-based products or meals instead of animal products,

507
00:49:02,180 --> 00:49:07,560
we're doing our part to mitigate the demand for environmentally harmful animal products and

508
00:49:07,560 --> 00:49:12,800
to show our grocery stores, restaurants, and cafes that we are, that we as consumers

509
00:49:13,500 --> 00:49:15,720
want sustainable plant-based foods.

510
00:49:16,760 --> 00:49:22,520
I know the city of Cambridge has counterduction goals already in place and by enacting

511
00:49:22,520 --> 00:49:26,640
policy order number two, and formally endorsing the plant-based treaty, the city will become

512
00:49:26,640 --> 00:49:30,320
further aligned with sustainable best practices.

513
00:50:00,000 --> 00:50:09,080
It's true. Goodman. Followed by Adrian Apprat, then Mark Keyblur, treaty. You have two minutes. Please go ahead.

514
00:50:09,460 --> 00:50:14,200
Good evening. I live. Can you hear me, okay? We can. Please go ahead.

515
00:50:14,200 --> 00:50:19,740
are the 1221 Cambridge Street Eomans Square cast two apartments in

516
00:50:19,740 --> 00:50:24,040
Eomans Square. I've lived there for 33 years now. There's a lot of

517
00:50:24,040 --> 00:50:28,180
misinformation floating around here this evening. I'm not going to

518
00:50:28,180 --> 00:50:30,840
necessarily address that, but here's what I do want to address.

519
00:50:31,300 --> 00:50:36,220
I'm going to building this 15 stories high. Down this tree for me is,

520
00:50:36,380 --> 00:50:39,880
Miller's River, which I believe is 18 stories high.

521
00:50:39,880 --> 00:50:45,920
There are higher rises in this area already, those high rises basically the people who

522
00:50:45,920 --> 00:50:49,640
live in those high rises are section 8, tenants are voucher tenants.

523
00:50:50,260 --> 00:50:55,660
New high rises will not help people like me and the people who live in Miller's river.

524
00:50:56,300 --> 00:50:59,060
For people to believe that is misinformation.

525
00:51:00,960 --> 00:51:08,440
Inclusionary will not assist people predominantly who are 11 to 20 AMI which is the people in

526
00:51:08,440 --> 00:51:14,820
building. There are 126 units in this building, most of these people are low income. They will

527
00:51:14,820 --> 00:51:19,740
not be able to get into these high rises and into the inclusionary that some of these people

528
00:51:19,740 --> 00:51:25,480
are suggesting. Here more importantly is the people in this neighborhood have not been given

529
00:51:25,480 --> 00:51:31,180
an opportunity to discuss any of this, including the merchants who have long-term businesses

530
00:51:31,180 --> 00:51:37,620
here in Inman Square. So everybody who wants to ram this through, what would be the problem if we

531
00:51:37,620 --> 00:51:44,400
Just a couple of months and heard from everybody and found out just what people in this neighborhood want.

532
00:51:44,760 --> 00:51:47,740
Instead of people trying to ram this down everyone's throat.

533
00:51:48,140 --> 00:51:50,620
Please put a gender item three on hold.

534
00:51:50,980 --> 00:51:58,380
So the people in this neighborhood have the opportunity to speak about what they need because we actually live here.

535
00:51:58,760 --> 00:52:01,340
Thank you very much and have a very good evening.

536
00:52:02,360 --> 00:52:09,300
Thank you, our next speaker is Adriana Pratt, followed by Mark Keibler, then Marley Meyer.

537
00:52:10,000 --> 00:52:12,140
Adriana, please go ahead, two minutes.

538
00:52:18,640 --> 00:52:20,620
Adriana, if you can unmute yourself, you have the floor.

539
00:52:23,800 --> 00:52:24,180
Yes.

540
00:52:24,180 --> 00:52:24,420
Hello.

541
00:52:26,480 --> 00:52:27,120
Good evening.

542
00:52:27,360 --> 00:52:27,940
Council members.

543
00:52:28,280 --> 00:52:33,700
I am Adriana Pratt at 543 Patnam Avenue, and I'm here to strongly support policy order

544
00:52:33,700 --> 00:52:35,820
number two, the plant-based treaty.

545
00:52:35,820 --> 00:52:43,260
I am an artist, scientist, mother, immigrant, and my passion is to inspire urgently needed action

546
00:52:43,260 --> 00:52:48,600
for the human-made environmental crisis through my art and through the artist's collective

547
00:52:48,600 --> 00:52:50,100
I found it I3C.

548
00:52:50,800 --> 00:52:55,660
I do not need to speak about the environmental and climate crisis that we are experiencing.

549
00:52:56,580 --> 00:53:01,920
When seven of the nine planetary boundaries have been surpassed, I am an agricultural

550
00:53:01,920 --> 00:53:07,720
is a major contributor to this in addition to the cruelty inflicted to species that never agreed

551
00:53:07,720 --> 00:53:14,620
to become a human commodity. As it has been eloquently described before me, a clan-based diet

552
00:53:14,620 --> 00:53:20,240
can prevent and even reverse chronic diseases, so it is dramatically better for the health

553
00:53:20,240 --> 00:53:26,800
of all of our community's members. I would have loved it if my daughter had had more plan-based

554
00:53:26,800 --> 00:53:30,120
food options when she was at Sierra Lees years ago.

555
00:53:31,540 --> 00:53:36,860
In the time when our federal government is pushing us into a dystopian world, having you

556
00:53:36,860 --> 00:53:41,660
indoors the plant-based treaty in Cambridge will be a tremendous win for the

557
00:53:41,660 --> 00:53:48,620
environmental cost and exemplary leadership and priest president for other cities and states and

558
00:53:48,620 --> 00:53:54,620
world regions. Thank you for all your ongoing work on climate issues and for embracing

559
00:53:54,620 --> 00:53:57,880
the clan-based reading today to contribute to a

560
00:53:57,880 --> 00:54:00,700
livable future for all populations on our

561
00:54:00,700 --> 00:54:01,840
cherished planet.

562
00:54:04,070 --> 00:54:05,990
Thank you, our next speaker is Mark Keebler,

563
00:54:06,130 --> 00:54:09,150
followed by Merley Meyer, then Susanne Bleey.

564
00:54:09,650 --> 00:54:13,130
Mark, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

565
00:54:15,350 --> 00:54:17,150
All right, I think I'm on me the day off.

566
00:54:17,730 --> 00:54:19,730
So good evening, counselor is my name is Mark Keebler,

567
00:54:19,730 --> 00:54:22,070
and I live at 52 Fort Street in East Cambridge,

568
00:54:22,430 --> 00:54:23,650
and thank you very much for your time,

569
00:54:24,010 --> 00:54:25,490
and all the work that you put into

570
00:54:25,490 --> 00:54:32,030
He's doing proposals, I'm speaking today to strongly urge you to support the Cambridge Street

571
00:54:32,030 --> 00:54:37,790
rezoning proposal and to move it forward, so this city has spent years engaging residents

572
00:55:00,000 --> 00:55:09,780
Issue facing the city through residents surveys. And there is no way to address this without making more housing with this ordinance.

573
00:55:10,120 --> 00:55:15,700
The city would be following through on its commitments and engaging with residents longstanding concerns.

574
00:55:15,700 --> 00:55:25,660
And in particular, this proposal focuses both where it makes the most sense, while major corridors, your transit, jobs, and neighborhoods, businesses.

575
00:55:27,040 --> 00:55:32,520
So, this proposal height is not just a developer giveaway, it's tied directly to public benefits.

576
00:55:33,180 --> 00:55:37,000
Like active ground floor uses better street design, inclusionary housing.

577
00:55:37,000 --> 00:55:43,940
So that means that new development has to contribute to the daily life on Cambridge Street to make things more walkable,

578
00:55:44,440 --> 00:55:50,380
at more support for local businesses and the greater potential for sustainable livings.

579
00:55:50,580 --> 00:55:55,040
So we often talk about equity, affordability and sustainability as our values in Cambridge,

580
00:55:55,880 --> 00:56:02,060
and if you don't, enable housing and places like this, places with transit jobs and services,

581
00:56:02,060 --> 00:56:06,640
available these values remain to be just talk so this wouldn't

582
00:56:06,640 --> 00:56:10,600
it says it's all to everything but it's a concrete step in the right direction

583
00:56:10,600 --> 00:56:15,820
that aligns our zoning with our stated values. Thank you.

584
00:56:16,300 --> 00:56:20,740
Thank you our next speaker is Marlee Meyer. Marlee you have two minutes please

585
00:56:20,740 --> 00:56:21,520
go ahead.

586
00:56:24,850 --> 00:56:28,110
I'm Marlee Meyer and Dana Street. Well I remember reducing

587
00:56:28,110 --> 00:56:33,650
heights on Cambridge Street to six stories excluding in men's square. It doesn't

588
00:56:33,650 --> 00:56:38,370
include other egregious issues. Please let Cambridge Street expire for a more

589
00:56:38,370 --> 00:56:44,170
comprehensive urban plan. Expiration often pointed out by Councilor McGuvern is

590
00:56:44,170 --> 00:56:49,050
not the final word. A continuation is not re-ledicating, but a more efficient

591
00:56:49,050 --> 00:56:53,750
consolidating of amendments, possibly even helping central square.

592
00:56:54,810 --> 00:56:59,770
Forcing this petition ignores the unresolved issues, including evictions of residents,

593
00:56:59,770 --> 00:57:07,350
small businesses, labs as of right, insufficient open space, setbacks, parking, residential and

594
00:57:07,350 --> 00:57:14,270
commercial projects should have the same design and planning board review at 20,000 square feet.

595
00:57:14,890 --> 00:57:21,290
Inclusionary is unpredictable and unqualifiable, and there is no mention of affordable housing at all.

596
00:57:21,690 --> 00:57:27,810
Vote now, fix later, leaves this plan wanting in its piecemeal state.

597
00:57:27,810 --> 00:57:44,850
A pro developer counselor has been reshaping Cambridge into the lightless playgrounds of this super rich, except for some tone deaf housing efforts, passed as of right without compromise, and that's the problem without compromise.

598
00:57:44,850 --> 00:57:47,170
Such as the case of the Harvard Square,

599
00:57:47,290 --> 00:57:53,250
a historic district, where a proposed or initially proposed

600
00:57:53,250 --> 00:57:57,210
residential 12-tower project was proposed

601
00:57:57,210 --> 00:58:04,530
for the democracy sector and on a small footprint,

602
00:58:05,110 --> 00:58:06,570
it would be essentially a dorm.

603
00:58:07,010 --> 00:58:10,550
Strict of size, shape, and design oversight.

604
00:58:10,550 --> 00:58:17,990
the CHC had on landmarked because of its importance. We continue to see the council's arbitrary

605
00:58:17,990 --> 00:58:28,870
number crunching in all upzoning without nuance. Nose is you need nuance. Do better think holistically

606
00:58:28,870 --> 00:58:36,370
about ramifications. This is not an all or nothing for a formula against me. There has to be a pathway.

607
00:58:36,370 --> 00:58:38,770
Thank you.

608
00:58:38,770 --> 00:58:39,030
Thank you.

609
00:58:39,170 --> 00:58:44,170
Our next speaker is Susan Blee, followed by Timothy Koski, then Ruth Feffer.

610
00:58:45,090 --> 00:58:46,710
Susan, you have two minutes.

611
00:58:46,870 --> 00:58:47,990
Please go ahead.

612
00:58:50,460 --> 00:58:50,920
Thank you.

613
00:58:50,920 --> 00:58:52,860
Suzanne Blee, a five-filer place.

614
00:58:53,440 --> 00:58:58,960
First, please landmark the democracy center, not only because it's really important, historically

615
00:58:58,960 --> 00:59:04,160
in Harvard Square, but because also the democracy of this country is really under threat.

616
00:59:04,160 --> 00:59:09,720
and this has been a critically important place within the city of Cambridge and within the

617
00:59:09,720 --> 00:59:16,840
area. Secondly, on the Cambridge Street Obsoning, my first choice would be to let this expire.

618
00:59:17,060 --> 00:59:22,200
At the same time, I want to thank Mayor Siddiqui and Councillor Nolan for bringing parts of this

619
00:59:22,200 --> 00:59:28,620
down to six stories. At the same time, going forward, we have to realize that this is going to bring

620
00:59:28,620 --> 00:59:35,400
or lease terminations, and that it's unlikely to have any affordable housing, particularly with the

621
00:59:35,400 --> 00:59:42,100
Patrick Barrett lawsuit in play. I, for once, actually agreed with something that Neil Miller said,

622
00:59:42,140 --> 00:59:47,740
which is, we need to find out if this is going to make rents lower or higher. And my feeling

623
00:59:47,740 --> 00:59:51,820
based on what we're seeing around the city is that this is not only going to cause people to

624
00:59:51,820 --> 00:59:59,700
lose their leases but also will be making rents higher. I urge you if this if the amendment does

625
00:59:59,700 --> 00:59:59,960
pass.

626
01:00:00,000 --> 01:00:06,140
We all know that we can do better and good design generally is no more expensive than really bad design.

627
01:00:06,700 --> 01:00:15,800
So I urge you to let this lab at the labs that have the same time, I think, Mayor Siddiqui and Councillor Nolan and happy snow day.

628
01:00:18,420 --> 01:00:27,880
Thank you. Our next speaker is Timothy Koski, followed by Ruth Feffer than Lee Faris. Timothy, please go ahead. You have two minutes.

629
01:00:29,770 --> 01:00:32,530
Hi, my name is Timothy Koski.

630
01:00:33,010 --> 01:00:37,670
I live on 97 Elmwood Street in Cambridge.

631
01:00:38,970 --> 01:00:44,850
I'm here to ask the counselors to get support

632
01:00:44,850 --> 01:00:49,190
to the Cambridge Street Obsoning Amendment.

633
01:00:49,650 --> 01:00:54,570
From what I have read, it seems deeply moderate

634
01:00:54,570 --> 01:01:04,490
in scope and but we do desperately need more housing and more building in the city.

635
01:01:06,970 --> 01:01:12,670
And so I would hope that the counselors would support this event. Thank you

636
01:01:18,330 --> 01:01:19,230
for those waiting.

637
01:01:19,450 --> 01:01:27,530
We are at speaker number 34 of 65 speakers. Our next speaker is Ruth Feffer followed by

638
01:01:27,530 --> 01:01:33,010
the fairest and Zion Sharon. Ruth, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

639
01:01:37,010 --> 01:01:42,190
My name is city counselors. My name is Ruth Feffer, and I'm a high school senior who

640
01:01:42,190 --> 01:01:48,830
was lived at 171 Harvey Street for my entire life. I'm here to support policy order

641
01:01:48,830 --> 01:01:55,090
number two, the plant-based treaty. I've loved this city since I was little. While I grew

642
01:01:55,090 --> 01:02:00,730
up here, I learned about the extreme and widespread violence towards animals involved in

643
01:02:00,730 --> 01:02:07,610
food system. As a pacifist, I found this cruelty unconscionable and I was inspired to become

644
01:02:07,610 --> 01:02:14,610
an advocate. Last year, I organized the Ed for Impact Campaign to add plant-based options to

645
01:02:14,610 --> 01:02:20,210
restaurants and Cambridge. I'd like to thank the city for supporting me, including some of you

646
01:02:20,210 --> 01:02:26,070
in this meeting. It's easy to feel despair when I think of the billions of animals struggling

647
01:02:26,070 --> 01:02:31,830
every day, but Cambridge's longstanding commitment to environmentalism gives me hope.

648
01:02:33,130 --> 01:02:37,330
As I go off to college, I plan to keep advocating for the world that I believe in.

649
01:02:37,990 --> 01:02:44,270
I dream of someday living in a country with a non-violent food system that's based on bringing

650
01:02:44,270 --> 01:02:51,190
communities together and building that food system starts right here with a plant-based treaty.

651
01:02:52,050 --> 01:02:56,930
Thank you for your time and for considering this important policy order.

652
01:02:58,690 --> 01:03:05,030
Thank you. Our next speaker is Lee Ferris, followed by Science Sharing, then Helen Walker.

653
01:03:05,410 --> 01:03:07,470
Lee, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

654
01:03:12,630 --> 01:03:18,710
Good evening. Lee Ferris from Norfolk Street in the port. I'm speaking for the Cambridge Residence Alliance.

655
01:03:19,330 --> 01:03:23,190
We encourage counselors to vote for the Nolan Amendment for six floors.

656
01:03:23,190 --> 01:03:29,350
However, the Cambridge Residence Alliance still thinks the petition should expire, followed by a brief

657
01:03:29,350 --> 01:03:34,850
community process on the proposed zoning, and then all the remaining issues, including the

658
01:03:34,850 --> 01:03:40,930
act of ground floor requirement, can be resolved and presented in one comprehensive petition.

659
01:03:41,470 --> 01:03:48,130
It is the wrong approach to conduct a planning study then design the zoning, but not allow residents

660
01:03:48,130 --> 01:03:53,310
and businesses to discuss that zoning, except during public comment to the council.

661
01:03:54,490 --> 01:04:00,390
Our biggest concern is not knowing the amount of inclusionary housing estimated to result from

662
01:04:00,390 --> 01:04:07,030
the zoning. We asked the council that council required those inclusionary estimates before passing

663
01:04:07,030 --> 01:04:12,690
the zoning and state-to-city staff that those estimates must be produced for every future zoning

664
01:04:12,690 --> 01:04:19,110
petition. We believe that the proposed zoning will result in six floor buildings with

665
01:04:19,730 --> 01:04:27,930
not even active ground floor and not having inclusionary units. That could be fixed, but it would

666
01:04:27,930 --> 01:04:35,850
take another petition to do that. We ask the council to delay implementation. If the Cambridge

667
01:05:00,000 --> 01:05:04,000
Will require active ground floor space is passed.

668
01:05:06,140 --> 01:05:09,280
In summary, we ask councillors to vote in favor of the

669
01:05:09,280 --> 01:05:15,940
Nolan amendment for six floors and to not support the petition as a whole. Some outstanding issues

670
01:05:15,940 --> 01:05:22,220
that could be addressed include not allowing labs as a right increased project review requirements

671
01:05:22,220 --> 01:05:28,220
increased open space and street carry requirements and through requirements for active ground floor

672
01:05:28,220 --> 01:05:36,100
Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Zion sharing. Followed by Helen Walker, then Brennan

673
01:05:36,100 --> 01:05:39,240
Waters. Zion, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

674
01:05:41,950 --> 01:05:49,330
Hi Zion, Sharon, for when Washington Street. I am calling and asking the council to let the

675
01:05:49,330 --> 01:05:54,590
Cambridge Street zoning petition expire. I do think that the amendments being proposed would

676
01:05:54,590 --> 01:06:02,410
better. However, while looking at the amendment, I still have not content with the lack of addressing

677
01:06:03,210 --> 01:06:07,910
zoning issues when it comes to people with disabilities and accessibility, whether it be proper

678
01:06:07,910 --> 01:06:13,350
loading zones or handicapped spaces. I brought this up several times and shared the story that I had

679
01:06:13,350 --> 01:06:20,310
with my mother who recently passed the cancer and her experiences getting in and out of vehicles

680
01:06:20,310 --> 01:06:26,470
and how difficult that was. And I think that the council had taken the time to make amendments

681
01:06:26,470 --> 01:06:32,810
when it came to high up buildings, but not properly addressed disabled residents is really

682
01:06:32,810 --> 01:06:39,990
telling to the priorities the council is pushing. Additionally, I'd like to state that if this is

683
01:06:39,990 --> 01:06:45,290
truly about a housing crisis and we're working on making sure more residents come live here,

684
01:06:45,290 --> 01:06:48,110
having labs by right does the exact opposite,

685
01:06:48,710 --> 01:06:51,310
encourages space that may not even be used properly,

686
01:06:51,410 --> 01:06:53,450
due to the fact that right now,

687
01:06:53,630 --> 01:06:56,730
about a third of labs facing the greater Boston area is vacant.

688
01:06:57,150 --> 01:06:59,170
So overall, I do think that the amendment

689
01:06:59,170 --> 01:07:01,350
would be better for the zoning,

690
01:07:01,670 --> 01:07:03,410
but I am requesting that people,

691
01:07:04,010 --> 01:07:05,910
that counselors allow it to expire

692
01:07:05,910 --> 01:07:08,910
and that they focus on priorities such as accessibility

693
01:07:09,410 --> 01:07:12,610
and potentially reigning in the lab space.

694
01:07:13,190 --> 01:07:13,230
Thanks.

695
01:07:14,810 --> 01:07:22,410
Thank you, our next speaker is Helen Walker, followed by Brennan Waters, then Halley trial.

696
01:07:22,930 --> 01:07:24,350
Helen, you have two minutes.

697
01:07:24,850 --> 01:07:25,690
Please go ahead.

698
01:07:28,180 --> 01:07:28,760
Sorry about that.

699
01:07:28,760 --> 01:07:31,300
Helen, if you can try to unmute yourself now, you have two minutes.

700
01:07:31,700 --> 01:07:32,680
Can you hear me now?

701
01:07:33,000 --> 01:07:33,280
Yes.

702
01:07:33,360 --> 01:07:34,360
Please go ahead.

703
01:07:35,300 --> 01:07:37,240
Helen Walker 43, many in Street.

704
01:07:37,800 --> 01:07:40,960
Thank you for the chance to speak about the Cambridge Street zoning petition.

705
01:07:40,960 --> 01:07:46,900
For just thanks to Councillor Nolan and Mayor Sadiki for their amendments, of course the

706
01:07:46,900 --> 01:07:51,760
results of the study involving significant taxpayer funds and working group time should

707
01:07:51,760 --> 01:07:54,400
not be set aside without a legitimate process.

708
01:07:55,300 --> 01:07:59,860
And thanks for highlighting many for further action to protect ground floor business, especially

709
01:07:59,860 --> 01:08:00,720
small business.

710
01:08:01,600 --> 01:08:02,700
But there's more to do.

711
01:08:03,200 --> 01:08:08,300
On December 15, Council voted to reduce the maximum height of inventory from 10 stories

712
01:08:08,300 --> 01:08:14,860
to eight stories, hasn't happened, hasn't in this agenda package? When is that going to happen?

713
01:08:15,900 --> 01:08:22,200
There's no zoning map or descriptive text. How do we verify the boundaries of Cambridge 812 and 15?

714
01:08:23,160 --> 01:08:28,900
And where the amendments the community keeps asking for, inclusionary units required at over four

715
01:08:28,900 --> 01:08:36,120
stories, same as seeing one district. Rear setbacks over five feet. New and existing residents

716
01:08:36,120 --> 01:08:39,620
staring into each other's bedroom's ten feet away will be miserable.

717
01:08:40,500 --> 01:08:44,720
These will not be home for casting routes and raising families in.

718
01:08:46,060 --> 01:08:51,200
Open space, comparable to all other residential districts at least 15 percent,

719
01:08:51,560 --> 01:08:55,620
and should be mostly green and that grade. Remember the planning board comment.

720
01:08:56,160 --> 01:08:59,720
No open space will need to a really crappy urban streetscape.

721
01:09:00,780 --> 01:09:05,800
Projects with you at a lower threshold, all projects over four stories or 20,000 square feet.

722
01:09:06,560 --> 01:09:12,520
accessible drop-off and delivery. As I say more to do, and thank you for your efforts.

723
01:09:19,760 --> 01:09:26,300
I guess that was the end. We will go to Brennan Waters, followed by Halley Trial,

724
01:09:27,080 --> 01:09:28,280
then Laurie Sheffield.

725
01:09:36,740 --> 01:09:38,980
Brennan, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

726
01:09:41,280 --> 01:09:51,820
Hi. Thank you. Brennan Waters. I leave a 14 Remington Street. I previously lived at

727
01:09:52,260 --> 01:09:56,560
street. Housing is supposed to come to the Cambridge and I really love to stay in the city long

728
01:09:56,560 --> 01:09:59,980
term and hopefully raise a family here. But, today it's...

729
01:10:00,880 --> 01:10:11,000
I want to voice my support for increased housing in the Cambridge Street. Housing is so expensive, the Cambridge and I really love to stay in the city long term and hopefully raise a family here.

730
01:10:11,540 --> 01:10:17,680
But today it's hard to envision it with housing prices so high in the premium of staying in Cambridge being so large.

731
01:10:19,180 --> 01:10:27,180
More housing will help drive down costs for everyone, for young people who want to join the Great Job Market.

732
01:10:27,180 --> 01:10:32,860
also for family to want to stay here long-term and help residents like me who want to contribute to

733
01:10:32,860 --> 01:10:35,400
Cambridge, both life and Cambridge, be able to stay in Cambridge.

734
01:10:35,940 --> 01:10:39,680
This is a great opportunity to build more housing on underutilized lots, as well as

735
01:10:39,680 --> 01:10:43,940
can contribute to increased density in our quarters.

736
01:10:44,940 --> 01:10:45,540
Thank you very much.

737
01:10:54,880 --> 01:10:57,460
Apologies, I'm having a little delay with my internet.

738
01:10:58,020 --> 01:11:04,960
Our next speaker is Halley Trial, followed by Lori Sheffield, then Camilla Elviss.

739
01:11:05,660 --> 01:11:08,380
Howie, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

740
01:11:09,960 --> 01:11:10,160
Hello.

741
01:11:10,440 --> 01:11:12,600
Thank you for the opportunity to speak here.

742
01:11:12,740 --> 01:11:17,300
And thank you to the counselors for bringing this proposal to

743
01:11:18,680 --> 01:11:20,740
Upzone Cambridge Street forward.

744
01:11:20,960 --> 01:11:25,000
Really appreciate this as well as the community engagement that led to it.

745
01:11:25,660 --> 01:11:28,860
I'm one of the officers of the MIT graduate student council,

746
01:11:29,020 --> 01:11:32,500
which represents over 6,000 graduate students living

747
01:11:32,500 --> 01:11:39,640
you know, around MIT and Cambridge Summerville in Boston, and I'm here to share the perspective of graduate students.

748
01:11:42,460 --> 01:11:51,920
This zoning change will help limit market rate rent increases by mitigating housing scarcity while also allowing the construction of desperately needed affordable units.

749
01:11:51,920 --> 01:12:01,880
And data from two surveys, one conducted by the GSC and one conducted by my home department highlight the urgency of the housing crisis as an equity issue.

750
01:12:02,460 --> 01:12:18,040
Only 40% of graduate students in my department who identifies first-generation college students agreed that they were able to transition to MIT without severe financial burden compared to a much higher percentage 75% of non-first-generation students.

751
01:12:18,040 --> 01:12:23,500
The financial burden of relocation is primarily driven by high housing costs in the area.

752
01:12:24,340 --> 01:12:31,000
And our GSC survey similarly found that first-generation and low-income students were those most impacted by high housing costs.

753
01:12:31,460 --> 01:12:41,580
Multiple students even reported having to live in Airbnb's for the first few weeks in Cambridge because our low vacancy rate made it impossible for them to find a place to live before they needed to start their program.

754
01:12:41,580 --> 01:12:49,340
Our striking results motivated us to continue pressuring both local government and the MIT administration to reduce the cost of housing.

755
01:12:50,020 --> 01:12:58,620
Failure to address our housing crisis will not diminish the desirability of the excellent educational, professional, cultural and professional experiences Cambridge has to offer.

756
01:12:59,100 --> 01:13:01,960
But it will limit who can take advantage of these opportunities.

757
01:13:01,960 --> 01:13:07,080
If we want Cambridge to be a place that welcomes people of all backgrounds, we cannot allow housing

758
01:13:07,080 --> 01:13:12,360
scarcity to continue acting as a barrier to low income people who are here to pursue their dreams.

759
01:13:15,070 --> 01:13:15,710
Thank you, Holly.

760
01:13:16,050 --> 01:13:22,010
We will go to Lori Sheffield, followed by Kamila Elvis, Sydney Snow, then Kathy Hoffman.

761
01:13:23,170 --> 01:13:24,410
Lori, you have two minutes.

762
01:13:24,530 --> 01:13:25,450
Please go ahead.

763
01:13:29,900 --> 01:13:30,280
Okay.

764
01:13:30,540 --> 01:13:31,120
I'm unmuted.

765
01:13:31,120 --> 01:13:36,800
Hello, I'm a Cambridge part resident and I've lived in Cambridge for decades.

766
01:13:37,280 --> 01:13:45,420
I'm sure that all the speakers in favor of increased housing are both speaking from their

767
01:13:45,420 --> 01:13:52,020
hearts and absolutely correct in terms of the pressures that many people face in terms of housing

768
01:13:52,020 --> 01:13:58,260
cost. There are other speakers who have gone through the proposed amendments in more detail.

769
01:13:58,260 --> 01:14:07,940
I'd like to speak to the active use of the ground floor issue which was spelled out pretty carefully related to existing businesses on Cambridge Street.

770
01:14:08,200 --> 01:14:15,940
This is one of the few semi-entact shopping districts in Cambridge and includes businesses I regularly use.

771
01:14:17,100 --> 01:14:22,060
The hardware store, the craft store, the rug store, the paint store.

772
01:14:22,480 --> 01:14:26,160
This is one of the places in Cambridge where you can actually shop locally.

773
01:14:27,180 --> 01:14:32,160
As a property owner and a homeowner and someone who brought up children in the city, I want

774
01:14:32,160 --> 01:14:37,700
these types of shopping areas to be possible and I think that careful work on this proposal

775
01:14:37,700 --> 01:14:43,660
can make that more possible. So I would like to support the Nolan Amendment about the number

776
01:14:43,660 --> 01:14:48,640
of stories included and would like to particularly emphasize the parts of the proposal which

777
01:14:48,640 --> 01:14:56,380
address existing businesses, the size, the square footage of businesses on the ground floors and part

778
01:14:56,380 --> 01:14:59,740
of that is because of having observed development on other major quarters.

779
01:15:00,590 --> 01:15:12,710
Thank you. Our next speaker is Camilla Elvis. Camilla has not joined the Zoom. We're going to go to Sydney Snow, followed by Kathy Hoffman. Sydney, please go ahead. You have two minutes.

780
01:15:15,460 --> 01:15:26,060
Thank you all. Good evening. My name is Sydney Snow, a 43 fifth street, just off Cambridge. I'm here to discuss the proposition to amend the zoning map and zoning ordinances and item number three on the table.

781
01:15:26,060 --> 01:15:30,360
Well, I think added residential space would be beneficial to those who live in this corridor.

782
01:15:30,800 --> 01:15:34,120
There just not seem to be a guarantee of inclusionary housing projects or other types

783
01:15:34,120 --> 01:15:38,600
of affordable housing being mandated in the future with this zoning plan, which is why I would

784
01:15:38,600 --> 01:15:43,300
like to suggest that the council allows the amendment to expire and to add language in revisions

785
01:15:43,300 --> 01:15:47,400
to the amendment for guaranteed inclusionary housing and or other types of affordable housing

786
01:15:47,400 --> 01:15:48,580
in any future projects.

787
01:15:49,100 --> 01:15:53,100
My concern is that the inclusionary housing will be avoided in new developments if it is below the

788
01:15:53,100 --> 01:16:00,780
and unit in 10,000 square foot threshold for inclusionary housing mandates outlined in section 11.203 of the current zoning ordinance.

789
01:16:01,260 --> 01:16:06,040
And that we will continue to see expensive units come up even with the zoning changes if they go through.

790
01:16:06,740 --> 01:16:11,760
This would make an already expensive area even more and affordable pushing out long time residents in the working class.

791
01:16:12,340 --> 01:16:19,220
On a more personal note, I'm a teacher and I honestly already struggle to live in the area due to the cost of living, specifically the housing costs.

792
01:16:19,220 --> 01:16:26,340
And I think it would be really beneficial to working class residents as a whole, not just those who would qualify for the inclusionary housing.

793
01:16:26,840 --> 01:16:34,420
If there was a guarantee of that type of housing amid rising rent prices, I know it's been suggested by some that there is naturally occurring affordable housing.

794
01:16:34,580 --> 01:16:39,740
But in all honesty, I was looking for housing 68 months before I plan to move to Cambridge this past year.

795
01:16:40,180 --> 01:16:46,300
And the housing prices are astronomical, I think, across the board, especially considering the state of a lot of the older housing stock.

796
01:16:47,400 --> 01:16:51,340
Thank you all for your time. Again, I would urge a council to just put this on hold and

797
01:16:51,880 --> 01:16:56,520
like some other folks have said, please review it. I also agree with you know the other

798
01:16:56,520 --> 01:17:02,080
comments about kind of reviewing some other parts of the plan. It seems like some more specific

799
01:17:02,080 --> 01:17:06,560
verbiage would be helpful in a couple of different sections. So thank you all for your time.

800
01:17:07,480 --> 01:17:12,600
Thank you our next speaker is Kathy Hoffman followed by Barrel Lipton then Max Kaplan.

801
01:17:12,600 --> 01:17:16,860
Kathy, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

802
01:17:25,800 --> 01:17:28,500
Can you hear me? We can. Please go ahead.

803
01:17:29,060 --> 01:17:35,090
Beautiful. Good snowy evening. I want to begin thanking the city workers out there,

804
01:17:35,880 --> 01:17:40,240
making it possible for us to move around and keep our lives sort of on track.

805
01:17:41,100 --> 01:17:47,560
With so much blowing up and dividing us around the country, it shows the cooperation and mutual care we really need.

806
01:17:47,560 --> 01:17:53,020
It's in that spirit that I'm adding my voice to those asking for the unimended Cambridge

807
01:17:53,020 --> 01:17:54,420
treat zoning to expire.

808
01:17:55,380 --> 01:18:00,360
So we can reorient, stop fighting each other, or putting time into a fraught proposal,

809
01:18:01,000 --> 01:18:06,380
which has the possibility of heights without benefits, or even with benefits, which might

810
01:18:06,380 --> 01:18:11,160
disappear, leaving us with tall, as of right heights led by developers.

811
01:18:13,520 --> 01:18:31,460
As we see, I also want to mention to the graduate student from MIT, I appreciate your remarks and that is part of why there has been an ongoing struggle to hold MIT responsible for housing its graduate students, not putting that burden on the city of Cambridge to build buildings for you.

812
01:18:32,060 --> 01:18:40,260
As we see the divides between the haves and have not dramatically played out around us, this council should take the time to find solutions to housing,

813
01:18:40,260 --> 01:18:46,440
as well as health care public safety transit, which benefit the good of the whole while

814
01:18:46,440 --> 01:18:52,100
catering those most left out. We don't have to vilify anyone to lift up those

815
01:18:52,100 --> 01:18:58,300
most in need in our city and choosing things like social housing, CLTs, or maximum

816
01:18:58,300 --> 01:19:01,720
affordability over market rate giveaways for developers.

817
01:19:02,980 --> 01:19:07,340
Finally, I just want to mention I'm in support of Landmarking the Democracy Center

818
01:19:07,340 --> 01:19:13,480
As someone who was in and out of that building with many hats on over the past 25 years,

819
01:19:13,900 --> 01:19:22,960
it was an extraordinary, extraordinary place of vibrancy on the whole breadth of what democracy

820
01:19:22,960 --> 01:19:29,860
can mean from feeding people to envisioning new ways of being serving high school students

821
01:19:29,860 --> 01:19:36,820
in the Cambridge and many others, creating this statute, I think my apologies, Kathy, please

822
01:20:00,140 --> 01:20:02,680
Barrel, two minutes, please go ahead.

823
01:20:03,760 --> 01:20:11,860
Thank you so much. Barrel looked in Oak Street. I've spoken with many Cambridge Street people of diverse backgrounds and clones and levels of comfort with public testimony.

824
01:20:12,620 --> 01:20:25,180
Our concerns about community engagement, planning and details, transparency, our beloved small businesses, environment, history, and vibrancy in the public realm, the love. I and we have expressed all that in good faith.

825
01:20:25,180 --> 01:20:32,660
While I've worked and volunteered for nonprofits, I've spent more than a quarter million dollars in rent alone in Cambridge and I've never owned a car.

826
01:20:33,020 --> 01:20:35,920
I'm still trying to make the numbers pencil for my own life.

827
01:20:36,400 --> 01:20:43,800
And I respect this place and it's people and those who share and want to share this home in the great cultural center that is Cambridge, a place worthy of quality thought.

828
01:20:44,600 --> 01:20:54,180
On that note, I want to share that last week, friends made me aware of an unfortunate blog post by a local commentator featuring images of the Webster Wins or Area regarding this petition in all of Cambridge Street.

829
01:20:54,180 --> 01:21:00,340
It stated, in part, City Council needs to decide, will it maintain the character of gas stations and tow lots?

830
01:21:01,060 --> 01:21:04,460
I've walked to these streets, including Webster literally thousands of times.

831
01:21:05,040 --> 01:21:10,820
Development there is a chamber bill issue, and it's wild to encounter such confusion about the character of Cambridge Street we've referenced,

832
01:21:11,100 --> 01:21:17,280
and suggests that we don't see both room for serious progress and the empty spaces and labs that already exist.

833
01:21:17,940 --> 01:21:21,400
This kind of low quality framing of important community issues is crap.

834
01:21:21,400 --> 01:21:24,740
And to it I say, miss me with that kind of bad faith BS.

835
01:21:25,480 --> 01:21:29,080
I did appreciate hearing interest tonight, and some of the same questions we've been asking,

836
01:21:29,620 --> 01:21:34,180
and I've truly appreciated the conversations and actual care some of you have shown to me in my neighborhood.

837
01:21:34,980 --> 01:21:40,360
I welcome more discussion with anyone interested in Cambridge Street's future as I'm optimistic that our values are not so different.

838
01:21:41,040 --> 01:21:47,440
While I want this particular split shot petition to expire, I know that it isn't the last word on what happens to Cambridge Street,

839
01:21:47,740 --> 01:21:49,780
and I'll be here for those next conversations.

840
01:21:49,780 --> 01:21:53,220
The bones here are good, and it should be truly thoughtful about the renovation.

841
01:21:54,020 --> 01:21:57,840
I urge you counselors as you move forward with this term and plans for Central Square and

842
01:21:57,840 --> 01:22:02,740
sewage and transit in our city. Please, show us what real consideration and deliberation and

843
01:22:02,740 --> 01:22:07,780
quality conversation looks like. Model the local leadership and good government governance

844
01:22:07,780 --> 01:22:10,940
our city deserves and our country needs. Thank you.

845
01:22:17,180 --> 01:22:23,760
All right, I could not mute there. Our next speaker is Max Kaplan, followed by Mary Ann Quinn,

846
01:22:23,760 --> 01:22:25,900
and then Amina Bubuakar.

847
01:22:26,260 --> 01:22:29,160
Max, you have two minutes.

848
01:22:35,200 --> 01:22:36,420
Max, if you can unmute yourself,

849
01:22:37,320 --> 01:22:38,000
you have two minutes.

850
01:22:38,040 --> 01:22:38,740
Please go ahead.

851
01:22:39,060 --> 01:22:39,300
Yep.

852
01:22:40,120 --> 01:22:42,380
Hi, Max Kaplan, 45 years of road.

853
01:22:43,160 --> 01:22:45,240
If you look at which cities across the country

854
01:22:45,240 --> 01:22:47,140
have managed to halt or reverse

855
01:22:47,140 --> 01:22:50,060
of control rent prices, they all have one thing in common.

856
01:22:50,440 --> 01:22:51,500
They built more units.

857
01:22:52,140 --> 01:22:54,160
I support the Cambridge Street Obsoning

858
01:22:54,160 --> 01:22:55,440
because we need the housing.

859
01:22:55,700 --> 01:22:56,400
Thank you.

860
01:22:59,120 --> 01:23:13,540
Thank you, our next speaker is Marianne Quinn followed by Amina Bubakar, the Nancy Ryan, Marianne, if you can unmute yourself please go ahead you have two minutes.

861
01:23:14,800 --> 01:23:20,420
Hi, it's Marianne Quinn. I live at 29 out of three and I would like to comment on the up zoning.

862
01:23:20,420 --> 01:23:28,880
So 29 Otis Street is part of the one-first complex that takes up the city block of Cambridge and Otis and first and second streets.

863
01:23:29,440 --> 01:23:35,740
Our building has more than 400 residents in a six-story complex of building situated around a courtyard.

864
01:23:36,760 --> 01:23:46,180
We understood that the empty parcel of land directly across Cambridge Street was zoned to become a six-story building with a seven-floor building utilities such as HVAC.

865
01:23:46,180 --> 01:23:54,260
We now understand that the City Council is considering upzoning this lot and allowing a developer to put up a 15-story building,

866
01:23:54,720 --> 01:23:56,580
more than double the original footprint.

867
01:23:57,500 --> 01:24:02,860
Communication about this potential change was not well disseminated, we only learned about it by chance.

868
01:24:03,560 --> 01:24:09,280
A 15-story building would dwarf our building, along with the triple deckers adjacent to this lot,

869
01:24:09,400 --> 01:24:12,780
and the glass factory apartment building across McGrath highway.

870
01:24:12,780 --> 01:24:17,940
and East Cambridge is a whole which is mostly two and three story buildings. It is not

871
01:24:17,940 --> 01:24:22,840
in keeping with the neighborhood. Residents of the neighborhood recently endured the demolition

872
01:24:22,840 --> 01:24:27,880
of the Sullivan courthouse in the building of Forty Thorndike, a process that went on for months

873
01:24:27,880 --> 01:24:33,500
and months. Forty Thorndike has only three occupied floors, the rest of the building at empty.

874
01:24:34,400 --> 01:24:39,540
We do not want another large noisy, disruptive lengthy construction project. The proposed

875
01:25:00,000 --> 01:25:15,000
That up for blocks during rush hour on Cambridge Street. Finally, a 15-story building will result in a permanent loss of day like to our apartments, as well as to the community roof deck and courtyard. Please vote against this proposal. Thank you.

876
01:25:15,700 --> 01:25:26,220
Thank you. Our next speaker is Amina Rubikar followed by Nancy Ryan, then Mark Truent. Amina, you have the floor. Please go ahead two minutes.

877
01:25:26,220 --> 01:25:27,140
I

878
01:25:36,550 --> 01:25:41,570
mean, I see you listed as different name possibly if you can unmute yourself. You have the floor.

879
01:25:46,640 --> 01:25:55,320
Okay, we're going to move on to Nancy Ryan followed by Mark Truett. Nancy, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

880
01:25:58,540 --> 01:26:02,080
Hi, good evening and thanks for this discussion.

881
01:26:03,140 --> 01:26:08,980
I urge you to let this Cambridge Street up zoning petition expire.

882
01:26:08,980 --> 01:26:23,620
We do have a housing crisis in Cambridge, but the name of the crisis is affordability, and there is nothing built into this petition that guarantees any kinds of affordability.

883
01:26:23,620 --> 01:26:43,800
I just want to note that recently, leaders of the so-called Yimbee Abundance Housing Movement in Massachusetts and in Cambridge have been quoted as saying that essentially inclusionary zoning gets in the way of development.

884
01:26:43,800 --> 01:26:52,860
So it's kind of becoming clear that this is not a priority for the intense advocates of the height and density agenda.

885
01:26:53,800 --> 01:27:11,540
So let's take a breath, let this petition expire, and take a look at how Cambridge Street can, we can plan Cambridge Street for the future that is genuinely inclusive of low and moderate income earners in particular,

886
01:27:11,540 --> 01:27:17,640
But of a broad range of residents. Thanks so much. Thank you.

887
01:27:18,380 --> 01:27:26,460
We already heard from Jerry Puchillo. We're going to go to Mark Truett followed by Steven Gardner, then Susan Markowitz.

888
01:27:27,440 --> 01:27:31,340
Mark, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

889
01:27:38,500 --> 01:27:40,940
Mark Truett? Yep. Please go ahead. Okay.

890
01:27:43,720 --> 01:27:50,340
Okay, hi, it's ironic that the long-time home of the democracy center was mentioned by

891
01:27:50,340 --> 01:27:55,120
a couple of my fellow can't to bridge in earlier this evening because the way that the

892
01:27:55,120 --> 01:27:59,300
up zoning along Cambridge Street has been enacted over the past year has been anything

893
01:27:59,300 --> 01:28:00,100
but democratic.

894
01:28:00,780 --> 01:28:04,600
It is a good example of how our government acts without first understanding the impact

895
01:28:04,600 --> 01:28:10,920
of major zoning chances and crafting regulations that will achieve goals without destroying

896
01:28:10,920 --> 01:28:12,020
the built environment.

897
01:28:12,720 --> 01:28:16,540
The our Cambridge Street study had been cited by counselors and other supporters of up

898
01:28:16,540 --> 01:28:18,640
zoning as a justification for it.

899
01:28:18,940 --> 01:28:25,920
For the record, the study stated that in the public, that stated that the public in general

900
01:28:25,920 --> 01:28:32,400
was okay with an increase in density, as long as the additional housing was affordable and

901
01:28:32,400 --> 01:28:37,220
sunlight, open space, trees, traffic, and parking were all counted for, so that the character

902
01:28:37,220 --> 01:28:39,420
of the neighborhood was respected and strengthened.

903
01:28:39,420 --> 01:28:45,300
The ordinances which have been passed and those proposed are not responsive to the study.

904
01:28:46,500 --> 01:28:51,720
Cambridge Shree is 65 feet wide. The study itself recognized that increasing building heights

905
01:28:51,720 --> 01:28:57,580
on the street beyond four stories would have a negative impact unless buildings were required

906
01:28:57,580 --> 01:29:02,700
to have step backs so that sunlight would reach people and trees on the street and the building's

907
01:29:02,700 --> 01:29:06,920
massing would be in scale and responsive to the context of the neighborhood.

908
01:29:07,460 --> 01:29:12,240
Redder, whose company famously fought oil field fires to bring them under control, said

909
01:29:12,240 --> 01:29:12,860
to a client.

910
01:29:13,220 --> 01:29:18,400
If you think it's expensive to hire professional to do the job, wait until you hire an amateur.

911
01:29:21,160 --> 01:29:27,520
I respect the desire to increase density and housing, but the ordinances that have been

912
01:29:27,520 --> 01:29:30,300
worked on today are works of an amateur.

913
01:29:31,580 --> 01:29:36,480
We need to hold this press redo all of these ordinances.

914
01:29:36,920 --> 01:29:38,840
Thank you.

915
01:29:39,420 --> 01:29:39,880
Thank you.

916
01:29:40,000 --> 01:29:45,300
Our next speaker is Stephen Gardiner followed by Susan Markowitz, then Deborah Kovar.

917
01:29:46,660 --> 01:29:48,420
Stephen, you have two minutes.

918
01:29:52,770 --> 01:29:55,210
Stephen, if you can try to admit yourself, you have the floor.

919
01:29:56,690 --> 01:29:57,990
I'm Stephen Gardiner.

920
01:29:58,030 --> 01:29:59,870
I live at 29 out of street.

921
01:30:00,000 --> 01:30:07,940
The idea of triple-deckerers, storm fronts, and modest mid-rise properties. Thankfully, that compromise included

922
01:30:08,400 --> 01:30:15,700
an increase in affordable housing. Most recent developments like CBS, pharmacy, and buildings

923
01:30:15,700 --> 01:30:23,200
long first street have maintained that low-rise profile. With the proposed up zoning of Cambridge

924
01:30:23,200 --> 01:30:29,460
treated Parsons 7, the city of Cambridge may once again impose an out of scale tower

925
01:30:29,460 --> 01:30:32,120
or our community, albeit residential.

926
01:30:33,620 --> 01:30:39,900
At the entry point, the residential east Cambridge, if allowed to proceed, this tower will

927
01:30:39,900 --> 01:30:43,000
stand out as an unwelcoming sewer thump.

928
01:30:44,600 --> 01:30:49,900
This site should not be an extension of Cambridge crossing rather a welcoming addition to east

929
01:30:49,900 --> 01:30:53,500
a reflection of the residential and storefront community

930
01:30:53,500 --> 01:30:55,400
bullet war at its beginning.

931
01:30:56,760 --> 01:31:00,500
As one first condominium association owner,

932
01:31:01,140 --> 01:31:03,380
I could certainly urge the council to reduce the

933
01:31:03,380 --> 01:31:07,020
zoning height to force the seven because of its negative impact

934
01:31:07,020 --> 01:31:11,280
on our particular community from congestion at an albeit challenging

935
01:31:11,280 --> 01:31:15,360
intersection to a necessary blocking sunshine to our

936
01:31:15,360 --> 01:31:19,540
complex that the more compelling argument against this

937
01:31:19,540 --> 01:31:26,420
zoning is a negative impact. It's such a sore comb would have on our entire community. I

938
01:31:26,420 --> 01:31:32,520
close the proposed up zoning of parcel, seven, and herbs that council to allow the petition to

939
01:31:32,520 --> 01:31:39,120
expire. Thank you very much. Thank you. Our next speaker is Susan Markowitz followed by

940
01:31:39,120 --> 01:31:46,880
Deborah Kovar, then Sophia Sanchez. We have about 11 speakers left for those who are waiting.

941
01:31:47,480 --> 01:31:51,100
Susan, you have two minutes, please go ahead.

942
01:31:54,520 --> 01:31:55,440
Hi, thank you.

943
01:31:55,680 --> 01:31:59,800
Thank you to Patty Nolan and Symbol Sadiki for your recent amendment.

944
01:32:00,220 --> 01:32:03,140
This is a compromise and I really appreciate it.

945
01:32:03,520 --> 01:32:11,660
I still say they'll let the petition expire, because the overwhelming majority of people in the community do not know that this petition exists.

946
01:32:12,180 --> 01:32:18,620
This morning when I was struggling, I spoke to my next or neighbor in a neighbor across the street, both of whom I met for the first time.

947
01:32:18,620 --> 01:32:22,060
neither of them knew anything about the petition. One responded,

948
01:32:22,560 --> 01:32:24,620
that's horrible. How did you find out about this?

949
01:32:24,840 --> 01:32:26,880
The other one who moved in in September said,

950
01:32:27,040 --> 01:32:29,620
oh no, they're going my favorite shops down the street.

951
01:32:30,360 --> 01:32:31,720
When is this going to happen?

952
01:32:32,400 --> 01:32:37,180
I really don't understand why it's not important for residents to be notified about this

953
01:32:37,180 --> 01:32:41,600
petition. Most people do not go to or read the city council meetings.

954
01:32:42,040 --> 01:32:45,100
They have not been informed about the major changes that you're planning

955
01:32:45,100 --> 01:32:52,200
in contrast to the Cambridge Street study. We've suggested a two-month democratic community process

956
01:32:52,200 --> 01:32:56,540
to give people a chance to hear what and why you were proposing this precision.

957
01:32:57,300 --> 01:33:02,200
There would get a chance to be heard. The outstanding issues could that we could discuss

958
01:33:02,200 --> 01:33:06,760
could include the amount of inclusionary housing that will be generated because it's not known

959
01:33:06,760 --> 01:33:13,560
and it's likely small. The need for increased project review, labs that are currently as of

960
01:33:13,560 --> 01:33:19,600
increasing step-backs, increasing open space, increased street trees, increased protections

961
01:33:19,600 --> 01:33:25,340
for small, small, first floor businesses. You've said the petition as amended needs to be

962
01:33:25,340 --> 01:33:30,240
passed now in order to move on to central square. Really, is this how you're going to treat

963
01:33:30,240 --> 01:33:35,980
the residents in central square? What is the rush? If you think that this is what Cambridge

964
01:33:35,980 --> 01:33:40,940
Street needs engage us in the legitimate two-month community process, we'll ask some questions

965
01:33:40,940 --> 01:33:47,500
express what we like and you can do the same. Please do not short-change us. This will renew our trust

966
01:33:47,500 --> 01:33:55,440
and faith in you. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Deborah Kovar, followed by Sophia Sanchez,

967
01:33:55,720 --> 01:34:01,400
then Kirin Vaya. I really thank you. I don't.

968
01:34:08,280 --> 01:34:11,560
Deborah, if you can please unmute yourself, you have the floor.

969
01:34:13,420 --> 01:34:15,580
Can you hear me now?

970
01:34:16,080 --> 01:34:17,520
We can. Please go have a great.

971
01:34:17,940 --> 01:34:19,620
I'm Deborah Kovar and I'm an owner

972
01:34:19,620 --> 01:34:22,760
at one first condominium at 150 Cambridge Street.

973
01:34:23,340 --> 01:34:26,880
I'm here tonight to address policy number three

974
01:34:26,880 --> 01:34:29,440
and to ask the city council to oppose

975
01:34:29,440 --> 01:34:33,160
the up zoning proposal to a 15 story building

976
01:34:33,160 --> 01:34:34,620
along Cambridge Street.

977
01:34:35,280 --> 01:34:38,120
While I support responsible development

978
01:35:00,000 --> 01:35:13,420
We'll contribute to a heavily congested area. Cohesion with surrounding structures would be best served by a six to eight story structure, which also makes provisions for parking.

979
01:35:14,360 --> 01:35:22,740
This would also maintain and respect the well-vetted process that was previously undertaken for zoning to allow a six to eight story building.

980
01:35:22,740 --> 01:35:30,800
Please vote no to up zoning along the Cambridge corridor. No on policy number three. Thank you for your time

981
01:35:31,640 --> 01:35:34,580
Our next speaker is Sofia Sanchez

982
01:35:34,580 --> 01:35:39,140
then Karen via followed by Ann Cover. Sofia.

983
01:35:41,770 --> 01:35:42,450
I

984
01:35:42,450 --> 01:35:48,030
Don't see Sofia on the Zoom. We will go to Karen via Karen two minutes. Please go ahead

985
01:35:49,210 --> 01:35:55,430
Hi, I live in one first Cambridge, which overlooks this parking, the space, which was the

986
01:35:55,430 --> 01:36:01,450
erstwhile beach beach station, and I urge the city council members to oppose the

987
01:36:01,450 --> 01:36:07,570
up zoning for converting this previously approved six story building into a proposed 15 story

988
01:36:07,570 --> 01:36:07,950
building.

989
01:36:08,570 --> 01:36:14,250
Like the rest of them before me have mentioned the reduction in sunlight, which is going to force

990
01:36:14,250 --> 01:36:18,950
us to turn our lights on during the day, increasing our electricity bills, the parking, no

991
01:36:18,950 --> 01:36:24,050
requirement for parking increases the traffic, which is, which is almost beginning to be a nightmare

992
01:36:24,050 --> 01:36:32,090
already. This, no, there's already 40 thundry, which we see very scarcely occupied. So,

993
01:36:32,310 --> 01:36:38,090
is there really a requirement for more housing when we can't fill in what exists already? And this

994
01:36:38,090 --> 01:36:43,030
totally changes, the look and feel of Cambridge state where we've lived for almost 15 years now.

995
01:36:43,030 --> 01:36:51,250
That said, apart from the fact that the burden is going to fall on the rest of us who have been living here and serving this community and contributing to this community,

996
01:36:51,970 --> 01:36:57,230
it's also not going to increase, improve, provide a good quality of life for people living in this new building,

997
01:36:57,710 --> 01:37:06,530
with no parking, with congested areas, no grocery stores in, in walkable distance, which means everybody will have to have a car or some public transportation or ubers.

998
01:37:06,530 --> 01:37:12,710
It's going to convert this whole street and area into extremely unlivable surroundings.

999
01:37:14,450 --> 01:37:21,170
So in the name of affordable housing, is this what we're providing to the folks who would want to come and live in these buildings.

1000
01:37:21,450 --> 01:37:32,490
So I respectfully urge you to please let this expire, rethink how this gels with the Cambridge Street community and not necessarily the Cambridge Crossing community,

1001
01:37:32,710 --> 01:37:35,750
which is completely different while it's just across the street.

1002
01:37:35,750 --> 01:37:43,330
And I do appreciate all the hard work that's being done in this, but respectfully urge to please reconsider this proposal.

1003
01:37:44,270 --> 01:37:45,070
Thank you.

1004
01:37:45,290 --> 01:37:45,650
Thank you.

1005
01:37:45,770 --> 01:37:48,030
Our next speaker is Jamie Hayg.

1006
01:37:48,130 --> 01:37:48,470
Jamie.

1007
01:37:49,130 --> 01:37:49,790
We have two minutes.

1008
01:37:50,050 --> 01:37:50,910
Please go ahead.

1009
01:37:59,180 --> 01:37:59,480
Jamie.

1010
01:38:01,420 --> 01:38:03,580
Sorry, Jamie, if you can try to unmute yourself again.

1011
01:38:04,220 --> 01:38:04,820
Oh, sure.

1012
01:38:05,240 --> 01:38:05,580
Yep.

1013
01:38:05,580 --> 01:38:06,140
Go ahead.

1014
01:38:06,560 --> 01:38:07,900
Thank you.

1015
01:38:07,920 --> 01:38:09,120
My name is Jamie Hayg.

1016
01:38:09,120 --> 01:38:37,880
and my wife and I live at 17 out of street in Cambridge at one first. And, like many of the other speakers have said, we oppose the proposed up zoning petition, especially as it pertains to the development of the parcel across the street from one first as either parcels six or seven.

1017
01:38:37,880 --> 01:38:44,520
the former Leachmeer Station site to construct up to 15 stories.

1018
01:38:45,220 --> 01:38:53,600
That is completely out of character with the character of the rest of the neighboring property.

1019
01:38:54,560 --> 01:39:06,600
It will affect traffic and congestion in the area, and will not be designed or developed for affordable housing.

1020
01:39:06,600 --> 01:39:20,040
A 15-story complex, as I understand, is this is being proposed as a benefit for a particular

1021
01:39:20,040 --> 01:39:28,260
developer who is interested in developing high-end residential housing and just increasing

1022
01:39:28,260 --> 01:39:34,620
profit, but it's going to affect the Cambridge community as a whole to have this high-density

1023
01:40:00,000 --> 01:40:11,360
On another day. Thank you. Thank you. Next, we have Anne Coburn followed by John Gagliardi, then James Williamson, and you have the floor two minutes.

1024
01:40:12,120 --> 01:40:22,240
Thank you. Hi, my name is Anne Coburn. I live at 117A. Oh, it's a strange language. Tonight, I am speaking to urge that the city council pass.

1025
01:40:22,240 --> 01:40:27,480
able motion number three to allow this Cambridge Street rezoning petition to move forward.

1026
01:40:28,380 --> 01:40:33,260
I usually urge elected officials to do things because it's the right thing to do for people,

1027
01:40:33,340 --> 01:40:39,760
because everybody should be able to afford a place to live because there's enough housing for folks, et cetera.

1028
01:40:40,720 --> 01:40:42,520
But tonight, well, this is the right thing to do.

1029
01:40:42,620 --> 01:40:47,860
I'm also going to mention that I believe that passing this motion is a necessary first step to

1030
01:40:47,860 --> 01:40:54,320
first in diversifying the size and number of businesses in Cambridge by revisiting the ground

1031
01:40:54,320 --> 01:40:56,580
slow commercial requirements in the future.

1032
01:40:57,620 --> 01:41:02,420
Or at least the last few decades, Cambridge has relied on a restrictive economic

1033
01:41:02,420 --> 01:41:04,580
monoculture of biotech and academics.

1034
01:41:05,420 --> 01:41:10,300
The cities available commercial and housing spaces speak to that economic framework.

1035
01:41:10,800 --> 01:41:16,120
Well-funded venture capital back businesses or universities with massive endowments versus

1036
01:41:16,120 --> 01:41:24,620
the ability to create the capacity for small businesses to grow more gradually and more sustainably.

1037
01:41:25,940 --> 01:41:32,000
But now, the real-life concrete and long-term effects of the Trump administration's assault on those kinds of industries

1038
01:41:32,000 --> 01:41:37,500
deeply affects the city of Cambridge's current property tax revenue sources.

1039
01:41:38,240 --> 01:41:43,440
I believe that by passing this motion, the City of Cambridge may be positioned to cultivate

1040
01:41:43,440 --> 01:41:49,080
more small to medium-sized industries and more space to welcome new ideas, new businesses

1041
01:41:49,080 --> 01:41:54,320
and new residents, residents who can actually afford to live here, because I think that this

1042
01:41:54,320 --> 01:41:58,360
city needs that kind of energy-hope and movement. Thank you so much for your time.

1043
01:41:59,340 --> 01:42:05,560
Thank you, our next speaker is John Gagliardi, followed by James Williamson, then Ed Henry.

1044
01:42:05,560 --> 01:42:09,660
John, you have the floor you have two minutes. Please go ahead

1045
01:42:17,310 --> 01:42:18,710
on your unmuted.

1046
01:42:25,140 --> 01:42:39,980
We're not getting any sound from John. We're going to move on to James Williamson followed by Ed Henley. Then Jose Estrella James, you have the floor you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

1047
01:42:39,980 --> 01:42:41,580
Can you hear me?

1048
01:42:41,760 --> 01:42:42,480
We can.

1049
01:42:43,080 --> 01:42:44,420
That's probably a study.

1050
01:42:45,280 --> 01:42:47,700
But anyway, thank you.

1051
01:42:49,120 --> 01:42:52,260
I want to talk a first about the Cambridge Street

1052
01:42:52,260 --> 01:42:53,880
Upsoning proposal.

1053
01:42:55,520 --> 01:42:57,560
I learned for the first time tonight,

1054
01:42:57,900 --> 01:42:59,600
here listen to some people on Otis Street

1055
01:43:00,320 --> 01:43:03,980
in the Leachmere about this

1056
01:43:04,920 --> 01:43:08,280
idea of the proposal for a major

1057
01:43:08,280 --> 01:43:13,960
a development in excess of what they, their previous understanding had been.

1058
01:43:15,100 --> 01:43:22,980
I think what we need to know among other things before anything gets passed is, when developers

1059
01:43:22,980 --> 01:43:30,000
go in and have private meetings with city staff, are we entitled to know what the details

1060
01:43:30,000 --> 01:43:31,140
are of those conversations?

1061
01:43:31,700 --> 01:43:37,700
I'm not necessarily against city staff talking to developers, but I think we who live here

1062
01:43:37,700 --> 01:43:44,520
have a right to know what transpires in those conversations. Our city staff making deals

1063
01:43:44,520 --> 01:43:50,220
privately to accommodate developers and we're not told about it. And now we have to hear

1064
01:43:50,220 --> 01:43:56,120
about it as city council meeting. I do think there are a lot of problems with this Cambridge

1065
01:43:56,120 --> 01:44:02,740
Street proposal. It seems like a real mess. The more I listen to other speakers. By the way,

1066
01:44:02,740 --> 01:44:08,180
MIT, and there was a time when the graduate student council there demanded that MIT

1067
01:44:08,180 --> 01:44:15,700
fouls all of their graduate students on land they already own in attractive housing

1068
01:44:15,700 --> 01:44:22,700
at affordable prices. But anyway, I want to say a word about the stigma landmark petition.

1069
01:44:22,820 --> 01:44:29,300
I think it's flawed, and I don't think you should pass it. It did remind me of the addition,

1070
01:44:29,300 --> 01:44:35,820
the East addition to the White House that was demolished recently, to the horror of many people,

1071
01:44:36,180 --> 01:44:41,140
and now you're going to allow an addition that makes that building, gives it the integrity

1072
01:44:41,140 --> 01:44:46,860
that it currently has, and it seems like a sellout, so I hope you don't pass it.

1073
01:44:47,920 --> 01:44:56,600
Thank you, our next speaker is Ed Henley followed by Jose Estrella. Ed, you have two minutes,

1074
01:44:56,600 --> 01:44:57,980
Please go ahead.

1075
01:45:00,000 --> 01:45:11,160
Local homes for new housing in for everyday and especially lower income residents to live in and live in over the course of a lifetime, especially if they're raising a family.

1076
01:45:12,480 --> 01:45:28,040
Community in Cambridge is everything. It is that community of people that wants affordable housing, but wants it including the ability to drive, park and shop, attain medical services and medical goods, those kinds of things locally.

1077
01:45:28,040 --> 01:45:34,340
locally is where we spend the majority of our incomes, whether that's from our retirement

1078
01:45:34,340 --> 01:45:43,740
income from work or from renting apartments that some people have worked for a lifetime

1079
01:45:43,740 --> 01:45:48,920
to own enter rent, of people to own their own homes.

1080
01:45:49,500 --> 01:45:55,620
I can personally name small family owned businesses and they probably own the actual building

1081
01:45:55,620 --> 01:46:02,040
as well as opposed to renting on Cambridge Street, as well as Inman Square, which regularly

1082
01:46:02,040 --> 01:46:08,420
makes the, which I regularly make the rounds of when I'm shopping. Typically, it'll do a

1083
01:46:08,420 --> 01:46:14,140
medical appointment and then stop in a couple places on Cambridge Street, a couple places in

1084
01:46:14,140 --> 01:46:22,880
Inman Square. Please do not change Cambridge in such that a way that large mega-mogles own

1085
01:46:22,880 --> 01:46:30,680
large development, property, and constantly test tenets ability to pay without

1086
01:46:30,680 --> 01:46:40,200
religious rent increases in whatever added cost they can add to that tenets cost of

1087
01:46:40,200 --> 01:46:46,660
living there. This creates such instability for families trying to match, trying

1088
01:46:46,660 --> 01:46:52,180
to maintain consistency, especially with regards to living situations,

1089
01:46:54,640 --> 01:47:00,580
in their children's schooling as well as ability to get around the community. Please don't

1090
01:47:00,580 --> 01:47:08,100
put these community features at risk. I guess please do the right thing the right way for

1091
01:47:08,100 --> 01:47:15,440
the right reason. Thank you very much. Thank you. We are going to skip Jose as he is not joined.

1092
01:47:15,600 --> 01:47:19,700
We will go to Kathleen Higgins followed by Heather Hoffman. Kathleen,

1093
01:47:22,360 --> 01:47:23,440
you have two minutes. Please

1094
01:47:23,440 --> 01:47:24,140
Go ahead.

1095
01:47:26,170 --> 01:47:29,750
Hi, my name is Kathy and I live at 345 North Extreme.

1096
01:47:30,430 --> 01:47:32,850
A few houses in from Cambridge Street and in from Square.

1097
01:47:33,050 --> 01:47:37,590
I strongly support acting favorably on the Cambridge Street petition to change the

1098
01:47:37,590 --> 01:47:39,110
going to allow for more homes.

1099
01:47:39,810 --> 01:47:40,930
I have also lived for me.

1100
01:47:40,930 --> 01:47:45,410
I also live for many years at Inmond Square apartments and can only hope that more buildings

1101
01:47:45,410 --> 01:47:50,330
like this can be built with this zoning and thus add to the vibrancy of Cambridge Street.

1102
01:47:50,330 --> 01:47:58,130
I experienced the wonderful caring people who lived in immense correspondence who created a community of support despite yes challenges.

1103
01:47:58,890 --> 01:48:08,010
If HRI working with the residents had not preserved the approximately 100 apartments as affordable, many people who found a home there would have had to leave Cambridge.

1104
01:48:08,590 --> 01:48:13,150
We need a wide range of housing tools and more of all types of housing build.

1105
01:48:13,150 --> 01:48:21,930
Of course, we should do all we can to increase deeply affordable housing and the possibility of social housing being developed and Cambridge is an exciting new type.

1106
01:48:22,490 --> 01:48:29,970
But we also need to provide options for those in the affordable ranges that qualify for 100% affordable housing that take just to start nature.

1107
01:48:30,170 --> 01:48:39,570
I build as well as those who don't qualify to these or in claims in our units, but who may be paying exorbitant rents, 50% of their income are in rent.

1108
01:48:39,570 --> 01:48:50,150
As we, as others have said, disowning for more housing represents another step forward by removing the barriers to allowing all types of housing in all neighborhoods.

1109
01:48:50,850 --> 01:48:56,150
It is part of undoing a history, a sad history of exclusionary and racist zoning.

1110
01:48:56,150 --> 01:49:02,510
If a compromise was entertaining the ability to build denser and taller near such areas

1111
01:49:02,510 --> 01:49:08,010
as Webster, then that should be, that should be rezoned for housing, then I would support

1112
01:49:08,010 --> 01:49:12,330
that rather than see the petition die. We don't need more process. Thank you.

1113
01:49:13,790 --> 01:49:19,290
Thank you, our next speaker is Heather Hoffman. Heather, you have two minutes. Please go ahead.

1114
01:49:20,410 --> 01:49:37,290
Hello, Heather Hoffman, 213 Hurley Street, like to start off with the court cases once again and I would just love to hear how the inclusionary zoning case is doing and whether you actually got the answer in today along with the three new lawyers.

1115
01:50:00,000 --> 01:50:14,500
We're worth anything. And did anything to make it so we could get around better. Look at how you set up construction and what you want is construction everywhere all the time.

1116
01:50:15,440 --> 01:50:20,560
And pedastrians just get shunted from one side of the street to the other if they're lucky.

1117
01:50:20,560 --> 01:50:23,620
With respect to the Cambridge Street zoning,

1118
01:50:25,640 --> 01:50:28,600
I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but there

1119
01:50:28,600 --> 01:50:35,300
is, as someone said before me, absolutely nothing in this zoning to expect that you will

1120
01:50:35,300 --> 01:50:42,500
build anything affordable. This is simply a giveaway to developers, and I understand that

1121
01:50:42,500 --> 01:50:50,140
that is the way Cambridge does things, take a look at what's being built now, such as it is.

1122
01:50:51,020 --> 01:50:58,560
people are regularly avoiding providing a single inclusionary apartment.

1123
01:51:00,520 --> 01:51:06,460
They will build bigger, they'll make more money, and it will be nothing affordable to it.

1124
01:51:07,280 --> 01:51:18,180
I will also note as was noted before me that there doesn't seem to be a zoning map or a description anywhere in the packet.

1125
01:51:20,080 --> 01:51:29,640
And I'm just wondering if you guys are two overworked at CDD to get your act together or what?

1126
01:51:30,320 --> 01:51:40,400
Because I have not seen such screw up in the past just on a regular basis.

1127
01:51:41,040 --> 01:51:42,720
So please let it left.

1128
01:51:43,060 --> 01:51:44,060
Thank you.

1129
01:51:46,700 --> 01:51:49,080
Madam Mayor, that is all that we're signed up to speak.

1130
01:51:51,070 --> 01:51:56,170
Thank you Naomi for leading us to public comment

1131
01:52:00,900 --> 01:52:09,100
and that concludes public comment on a motion by

1132
01:52:09,100 --> 01:52:12,780
Councillor Simmons to close public comment.

1133
01:52:13,200 --> 01:52:14,140
We'll do a roll call.

1134
01:52:14,460 --> 01:52:15,050
Councillor Azubi.

1135
01:52:16,060 --> 01:52:16,620
Yes.

1136
01:52:16,620 --> 01:52:16,860
Yes.

1137
01:52:16,860 --> 01:52:17,740
Vice-merezine.

1138
01:52:18,240 --> 01:52:18,480
Yes.

1139
01:52:18,760 --> 01:52:19,080
Yes.

1140
01:52:19,080 --> 01:52:20,020
Councillor Flaherty.

1141
01:52:20,860 --> 01:52:21,000
Yes.

1142
01:52:21,360 --> 01:52:21,680
Yes.

1143
01:52:21,700 --> 01:52:22,520
Councillor McGovern.

1144
01:52:24,220 --> 01:52:24,280
Yes.

1145
01:52:24,280 --> 01:52:29,280
Councilor Nolan? Yes. Yes. Councilor Simmons? Yes. Yes.

1146
01:52:29,360 --> 01:52:32,680
Councilor Sabrina Wheeler? Yes. Yes. Councilor Zucy?

1147
01:52:37,370 --> 01:52:38,530
Yes. Yes.

1148
01:52:38,930 --> 01:52:42,730
Mayor Sadiki? Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

1149
01:52:43,550 --> 01:52:47,950
Public comment is now closed. There's no submission of their record.

1150
01:52:48,270 --> 01:52:54,550
There are no reconsiderations. So we'll move on to city managers agenda.

1151
01:52:54,550 --> 01:52:59,350
I had hold counselors on items that they'd like to pull.

1152
01:53:00,190 --> 01:53:04,350
So what I'm going to do to make it as easy as possible is I'm going to

1153
01:53:04,350 --> 01:53:12,470
pull the ones that my colleagues had inquired about and then we'll do a

1154
01:53:12,470 --> 01:53:19,410
motion on the balance and when I and I'll sign particular counselors to the

1155
01:53:19,410 --> 01:53:24,530
ones that they had pulled and when we get to each item I'll ask for you to

1156
01:53:24,530 --> 01:53:30,730
raise your hands when after the counselor is spoken, you have additional questions.

1157
01:53:32,290 --> 01:53:40,270
So we'll pull number one, and then number three was pulled by counselor Juicy. And

1158
01:53:40,270 --> 01:53:46,930
number four was also pulled by counselor Juicy. We have number five that was pulled by

1159
01:53:46,930 --> 01:53:53,730
Councillor Nolan. We have number seven. That was pulled by Councillor Simmons. And then we have

1160
01:53:54,830 --> 01:54:02,410
City Manager agenda item number 10. That was pulled by Councillor Zousie. And then finally we have

1161
01:54:03,010 --> 01:54:10,970
City Manager agenda item number 11 that was pulled by Councillor Nolan. After we just have

1162
01:54:10,970 --> 01:54:17,170
exposed to the city matters of agenda. We do have a late city matters of agenda and I'll come

1163
01:54:17,170 --> 01:54:22,330
to the motion at that time, along with some of the other motions, we'll have to do. So for the record,

1164
01:54:22,570 --> 01:54:30,530
we've pulled number one, number three, number four, number five, number seven, number 10, and 11.

1165
01:54:31,550 --> 01:54:35,830
Are there any in addition to this? My colleagues would like to pull.

1166
01:54:37,860 --> 01:54:39,380
Hearing none, we'll go ahead

1167
01:54:39,380 --> 01:54:42,500
into a roll call on city manager agenda.

1168
01:54:42,740 --> 01:54:47,820
I have number two, six, eight, nine, please.

1169
01:54:48,620 --> 01:54:49,800
Councilor L. Zubi.

1170
01:54:50,300 --> 01:54:50,440
Yes.

1171
01:54:50,860 --> 01:54:51,180
Yes.

1172
01:54:51,260 --> 01:54:52,140
Vice-Mayor Azine.

1173
01:54:52,980 --> 01:54:53,340
Yes.

1174
01:54:53,340 --> 01:54:54,300
Council of laFlarity.

1175
01:54:54,800 --> 01:54:54,920
Yes.

1176
01:54:55,280 --> 01:54:55,600
Yes.

1177
01:54:55,860 --> 01:54:56,460
Council of McEvern.

1178
01:54:57,440 --> 01:54:57,640
Yes.

1179
01:54:58,200 --> 01:54:58,540
Yes.

1180
01:54:58,540 --> 01:54:59,180
Councilor Nolan.

1181
01:54:59,880 --> 01:54:59,960
Yes.

1182
01:55:00,000 --> 01:55:05,140
We'll go to city manager agenda item number one, which is a communication transmitted from

1183
01:55:05,140 --> 01:55:10,700
Anne Wong City Manager relative to a federal updating, including an update on relevant court cases.

1184
01:55:11,220 --> 01:55:12,640
City Manager, you have before.

1185
01:55:16,480 --> 01:55:18,760
I can't hear you. We can't hear you.

1186
01:55:24,850 --> 01:55:27,350
It's just not me, right? People can't hear city manager.

1187
01:55:27,810 --> 01:55:29,850
Is that better? Great. Great.

1188
01:55:29,930 --> 01:55:30,070
Great.

1189
01:55:30,750 --> 01:55:32,170
Okay. Good for in business.

1190
01:55:33,470 --> 01:55:37,790
Thank you, Mayor Sediki. I want to provide an update on all that's been happening.

1191
01:55:37,790 --> 01:55:42,690
on ice enforcement across the country and how we are both responding and preparing

1192
01:55:42,690 --> 01:55:49,290
in our own community. We have held cross-pensive departmental meetings to discuss

1193
01:55:49,290 --> 01:55:53,390
immigration surges that we are seeing particularly in Minnesota and Maine and to

1194
01:55:53,390 --> 01:55:57,610
review preparations for potential surge in the Greater Boston area. We've also

1195
01:55:57,610 --> 01:56:01,630
begun meeting across the 17 Metro Mayor's communities in Greater Boston on

1196
01:56:01,630 --> 01:56:07,230
sharing practices and coordinate responses across the region. Within Cambridge we've

1197
01:56:07,230 --> 01:56:11,070
take in a number of city actions over the last year, including holding

1198
01:56:11,070 --> 01:56:14,690
know your rights trainings in partnership with Mira and the State Office for

1199
01:56:14,690 --> 01:56:18,910
refugees and immigrants, discretion of red cards and multiple languages to help

1200
01:56:18,910 --> 01:56:23,070
people assert their constitutional rights and difficult situations, providing

1201
01:56:23,070 --> 01:56:27,690
education and information on family preparedness, continuing to talk closely and

1202
01:56:27,690 --> 01:56:32,330
partner where we can with local organizations, like Luce, B. John, Dinovo, and

1203
01:56:32,330 --> 01:56:36,370
Greater Boston Legal Services. We've provided funding for Dinovo to provide

1204
01:56:36,370 --> 01:56:41,450
legal assistance to low-income families and hosted a monthly legal clinic, and thank you as

1205
01:56:41,450 --> 01:56:45,030
well to the City Council for the work to strengthen our welcoming community's ordinance,

1206
01:56:45,290 --> 01:56:50,310
which includes specific reporting requirements for ICE actions in the City at regular intervals.

1207
01:56:51,230 --> 01:56:56,010
We've also transitioned mixed out as families from federal to municipal housing vouchers to avoid

1208
01:56:56,010 --> 01:57:01,810
the impact of changing HUD policies and potential data sharing with ICE. We provided training

1209
01:57:01,810 --> 01:57:05,670
and protocols to frontline city staff on what to do of ICE shows up,

1210
01:57:06,030 --> 01:57:10,430
demarcating public versus private spaces in city buildings and establishing a hotline

1211
01:57:10,430 --> 01:57:15,590
for city staff to reach out to the law department or in business iris to review any potential

1212
01:57:16,170 --> 01:57:20,730
administrative or judicial warrants that are being presented by ICE agents and finally

1213
01:57:20,730 --> 01:57:25,330
we've taken significant legal action where we can. Related to immigration and ICE, the city

1214
01:57:25,330 --> 01:57:30,710
is a plaintiff in two cases and filed nine Amicus briefs and litigations related to immigration

1215
01:57:30,710 --> 01:57:37,330
enforcement and actions. So this is a growing list. I'm really appreciative for counselors and people

1216
01:57:37,330 --> 01:57:42,670
in our community who continue to bring us great ideas. And in particular, thank you to Karolina

1217
01:57:42,670 --> 01:57:46,930
Almante and the work that the Commission and Immigrant Rights and Citizenship has been doing in

1218
01:57:46,930 --> 01:57:53,310
this space. Please continue to be in contact with Karolina and the Commission. Give us those ideas

1219
01:57:53,310 --> 01:57:58,730
we're excited to assess new things that we can be doing and how we can support our community in this time.

1220
01:57:58,730 --> 01:58:05,750
I know many of us over this weekend have been really horrified by the tragic second killing

1221
01:58:05,750 --> 01:58:10,970
of a U.S. citizen in Minneapolis, Alex Pretty, who contrary to federal statements seems

1222
01:58:10,970 --> 01:58:15,210
from video footage to have clearly been restrained by multiple agents when he was shot and

1223
01:58:15,210 --> 01:58:15,530
killed.

1224
01:58:16,490 --> 01:58:21,250
I know that many of us have been so deeply disturbed and as co-chairs of Metromares,

1225
01:58:21,810 --> 01:58:26,750
Mayor Briata Lungel Kern of Medford and I released a statement to crying the ice occupation

1226
01:58:26,750 --> 01:58:32,410
that we are seeing in Minnesota and Maine, we note that an occupying force does not belong

1227
01:58:32,410 --> 01:58:36,970
in our communities or anywhere in the United States or America, and that these unconstitutional

1228
01:58:36,970 --> 01:58:42,490
and unnecessary actions are making us less safe. The city of Cambridge also has filed an

1229
01:58:42,490 --> 01:58:47,330
Amicus brief in the Minnesota verse known litigation that held a hearing earlier today,

1230
01:58:47,830 --> 01:58:52,690
which requested an injunction on the isers that has caused so much harm in Minneapolis.

1231
01:58:52,690 --> 01:58:52,830
this.

1232
01:58:53,470 --> 01:58:58,110
The judge did not rule today from the bench, but promised that, quote, if I had a burner

1233
01:58:58,110 --> 01:59:02,830
in front of the front burner, this would be on it, and that a decision would come

1234
01:59:02,830 --> 01:59:03,330
quickly.

1235
01:59:04,450 --> 01:59:07,970
Well, the judge was critical of the federal government's intent for the surge, as well

1236
01:59:07,970 --> 01:59:09,730
as the long list of troubling actions.

1237
01:59:09,730 --> 01:59:15,630
He also appeared skeptical of issuing a sweeping order for ICE to leave the state, rather

1238
01:59:15,630 --> 01:59:19,350
than more narrow solutions targeting specific wrongs.

1239
01:59:19,350 --> 01:59:27,350
What I think is actually very unprecedented in this case is that it's being built on the coercive nature of the ice surge,

1240
02:00:00,000 --> 02:00:20,120
Common Constitutional use a federal power to coerced state action. In this line of argument, the court is being asked not to focus on a, quote, line by line, person by person analysis, or oversight of DHS operations, how many agents are too many, what the right practice should be, but rather that the act itself is illegitimate by its intent.

1241
02:00:20,780 --> 02:00:25,440
We'll keep the city council updated, but this line of argument feels relevant because it's

1242
02:00:25,440 --> 02:00:29,800
a similar pattern that we're litigating in other cases where the federal government is seeking

1243
02:00:29,800 --> 02:00:34,800
to, for instance, withhold funds to coerce cities toward policy changes that are irrelevant

1244
02:00:35,260 --> 02:00:38,260
to the program goals of that funding.

1245
02:00:40,180 --> 02:00:45,940
So I think there's still ultimately a lot to be understood in terms of where that court ruling

1246
02:00:45,940 --> 02:00:51,460
will land and even as we speak, I think decisions are being made but just know that we are

1247
02:00:51,460 --> 02:00:55,760
certainly wanting to continue to be in close conversation with this city council with

1248
02:00:55,760 --> 02:01:00,740
our community about how we're preparing actions that we can take and following and supporting

1249
02:01:00,740 --> 02:01:06,260
communities around the country that are struggling with with what the federal government is doing.

1250
02:01:07,700 --> 02:01:12,640
I also want to touch on the potential for a federal government shutdown after the upcoming

1251
02:01:12,640 --> 02:01:17,840
deadline, which is the end of day this Friday, January 30th. We've been watching that deadline

1252
02:01:17,840 --> 02:01:23,660
since the government reopened in the fall. At this point, it appears clear that Democrats in the

1253
02:01:23,660 --> 02:01:28,340
Senate are unlikely to vote for funding packages that include more budget for the Department of

1254
02:01:28,340 --> 02:01:33,680
Homeland Security and ICE without some reform, which may threaten the passage of these bills before

1255
02:01:33,680 --> 02:01:39,460
the deadline. I think it's hard to know exactly how the next four days will unfold and there isn't

1256
02:01:39,460 --> 02:01:44,200
a lot of time for them to figure out how to get all of these bills passed.

1257
02:01:45,200 --> 02:01:50,060
The remaining agencies that need to be funded include the departments of defense, labor,

1258
02:01:50,720 --> 02:01:55,140
health and human services, education, transportation, and housing and urban development.

1259
02:01:55,220 --> 02:01:59,560
This represents about, I believe, 75% of the government's annual spending.

1260
02:02:00,760 --> 02:02:04,880
And I think I would say as we experienced during the last recent shutdown, it will take

1261
02:02:04,880 --> 02:02:11,260
time to better understand even after the government shuts down when appropriations run out and

1262
02:02:11,260 --> 02:02:15,800
where there may be an impact that filters to states and cities. So we'll keep watching

1263
02:02:15,800 --> 02:02:20,020
developments and we can provide a fuller update with more information in two weeks when we meet

1264
02:02:20,020 --> 02:02:26,920
on Monday, February 9th, but just know that we're definitely in touch to try and figure out how

1265
02:02:26,920 --> 02:02:30,740
this might affect our community and ultimately the programs that we're running.

1266
02:02:31,380 --> 02:02:36,340
A final update just in terms of things that are happening that the council and the community

1267
02:02:36,340 --> 02:02:39,640
may be thinking about in the next couple of weeks.

1268
02:02:40,640 --> 02:02:44,840
A number of people in our community are very concerned over the expiration of temporary

1269
02:02:44,840 --> 02:02:46,880
protected status for Haitians.

1270
02:02:47,500 --> 02:02:50,280
That expires next Tuesday, February 3rd.

1271
02:02:50,680 --> 02:02:55,520
There is a court decision that is scheduled to be made the day before next Monday, February

1272
02:02:55,520 --> 02:02:59,460
2nd, and it may be possible that an injunction or an extension may be issued.

1273
02:02:59,460 --> 02:03:03,780
Certainly, the judge during a prior hearing was skeptical that the federal government had

1274
02:03:03,780 --> 02:03:07,740
sufficiently reviewed whether conditions in the ground and Haiti had improved.

1275
02:03:08,660 --> 02:03:13,400
Apparently, the only evidence of an actual review being conducted was a one sentence email

1276
02:03:13,400 --> 02:03:19,300
sent about an hour after an inquiry was made to the State Department, but we will find out

1277
02:03:19,300 --> 02:03:24,220
more in the coming week. I really wish there was more certainty that we could provide on what may

1278
02:03:24,220 --> 02:03:32,460
happen. It is generally the case that even without temporary protected status, people who are

1279
02:03:32,460 --> 02:03:37,360
in some pending asylum case would have legal protection. But given what we're seeing around the

1280
02:03:37,360 --> 02:03:42,220
country, it's also clear that ICE is picking people up, detaining folks and putting people

1281
02:03:42,220 --> 02:03:51,420
into deportation proceedings beyond, I think, what we have understood to be legal or policy within

1282
02:03:52,660 --> 02:03:58,620
within DHS. And so I think this is sort of a case where I would really continue to encourage

1283
02:03:58,620 --> 02:04:06,540
folks who are in these complicated statuses to be in touch with an immigration lawyer. We are

1284
02:04:06,540 --> 02:04:11,860
trying to provide resources so that anybody can get in touch with an immigration lawyer and have their

1285
02:04:11,860 --> 02:04:18,660
case worked on. But this is a tough time and really my heart is with everybody that's in these

1286
02:04:18,660 --> 02:04:24,100
situations. So I think those are the major updates, things that we have been tracking and watching,

1287
02:04:24,580 --> 02:04:31,000
and that will unfold over the next two weeks and very open to questions or comments from the

1288
02:04:31,000 --> 02:04:32,700
council. So thank you all.

1289
02:04:37,240 --> 02:04:41,160
Yes, thank you City Manager and you know, as has been mentioned,

1290
02:04:42,920 --> 02:04:48,120
these are really challenging times and sometimes it feels like we have more questions than answers

1291
02:04:48,120 --> 02:04:54,400
and as much information we can provide the community the better. I know my colleagues,

1292
02:04:54,840 --> 02:04:59,460
and I have all thought about and asked about how we can even strengthen.

1293
02:05:00,700 --> 02:05:09,460
So, I will ask that you raise your hand and I will then call on you in turn. And the raise hand feature is at the end. In the bottom of the screen.

1294
02:05:13,040 --> 02:05:15,580
I'll go to Councillor Malzubi.

1295
02:05:18,350 --> 02:05:23,810
Yeah, hey. Just want to say thank you for addressing the ways that our city is trying to be active about protecting our residents.

1296
02:05:24,310 --> 02:05:30,250
It'd be great to get a list of the resources and opportunities that you noted here.

1297
02:05:30,250 --> 02:05:36,090
And I also just want to also acknowledge the pain that you noted with the recent killings by ICE.

1298
02:05:36,710 --> 02:05:41,230
I will personally be continuing to work on an assessment of our welcoming city ordinance,

1299
02:05:41,390 --> 02:05:48,570
some are to what Mayor Sadiki noted, to ensure that our federal administration knows that when they are blurring the lines on who is what,

1300
02:05:48,690 --> 02:05:53,470
that we will be moving to ensure that we are as explicit as possible in non-cooperation.

1301
02:05:54,530 --> 02:05:56,670
I'll yield no questions there.

1302
02:05:58,050 --> 02:05:59,170
Councillor Fairety.

1303
02:06:01,640 --> 02:06:09,340
Thank you. Through you, Madam Mayor. I just note that the 9th Circuit is a problematic circuit and we just had a big win there.

1304
02:06:09,620 --> 02:06:24,700
One of the Amicus briefs that the city of Cambridge filed so congratulations to that. I've got a thought on our response to unlawful detention for a residence of city of Cambridge and maybe.

1305
02:06:24,700 --> 02:06:32,380
you know, the city solicitor and and the city manager is interested in establishing a

1306
02:06:32,940 --> 02:06:38,480
a volunteer network of lawyers, maybe 30 or 40 or 50 lawyers in the city of Cambridge,

1307
02:06:38,560 --> 02:06:44,020
everybody could take a day and be the only call lawyer if somebody is detained if there's

1308
02:06:44,020 --> 02:06:51,000
a surge in Cambridge, then we have a person who's identified for that day to go and file a

1309
02:06:51,000 --> 02:06:53,300
maybe as corpus petition in the federal court.

1310
02:06:53,540 --> 02:06:58,020
So the body's not removed because we're seeing this everywhere.

1311
02:06:58,980 --> 02:07:02,980
Just a thought and we can talk about it, but I can graduate the city on its efforts.

1312
02:07:03,680 --> 02:07:05,520
And let's keep it up.

1313
02:07:05,560 --> 02:07:06,740
Thank you so much.

1314
02:07:08,800 --> 02:07:10,260
I have councilor Nolan.

1315
02:07:13,700 --> 02:07:18,420
Thank you Mayor and thank you city manager and thank you my colleagues.

1316
02:07:18,920 --> 02:07:20,700
I do have a question on it.

1317
02:07:20,700 --> 02:07:27,120
It's a sensitive area to know how many of our residents are in temporary protected status,

1318
02:07:27,700 --> 02:07:34,200
but as the city manager referenced, one of the most, I think horrifying things that has

1319
02:07:34,200 --> 02:07:40,600
been happening is that this particular federal administration is literally taking people even at

1320
02:07:40,600 --> 02:07:48,920
the very point of when they are about to get their citizenship. They are not only ignoring the fact that

1321
02:07:48,920 --> 02:07:55,240
many folks are here legally seeking asylum, but even when they've gone through the entire process

1322
02:07:55,960 --> 02:08:02,100
followed every single rule and are about to finalize it. They have had no qualms about

1323
02:08:03,340 --> 02:08:10,500
picking up people and detaining them unlawfully. Do we have standing if it is and I realize this is a

1324
02:08:10,500 --> 02:08:17,200
question I'm throwing out? Would we have standing as a city if a resident is illegally detained to

1325
02:08:17,200 --> 02:08:19,340
and sue the federal government back.

1326
02:08:19,700 --> 02:08:22,500
Is that one of the tools in our toolkit

1327
02:08:22,500 --> 02:08:24,320
that we will be able to use?

1328
02:08:24,520 --> 02:08:27,340
I mean, one of the things that since they have no

1329
02:08:27,340 --> 02:08:28,800
coins at all about breaking the law,

1330
02:08:28,920 --> 02:08:31,620
the question is, can we, as a city, actually,

1331
02:08:31,620 --> 02:08:32,860
have standing them just curious?

1332
02:08:34,000 --> 02:08:36,480
And if we don't know then, I'll just,

1333
02:08:36,620 --> 02:08:38,880
I'll just, and I think the other related question

1334
02:08:38,880 --> 02:08:41,700
is, do we have a sense of how many families,

1335
02:08:41,900 --> 02:08:43,760
as Councilor Zumi said, getting information

1336
02:08:43,760 --> 02:08:46,200
out to the community to make sure all the families know

1337
02:08:47,320 --> 02:08:54,700
what their options are and as Councillor Flaherty said, if we could make sure that any residents have access to

1338
02:08:54,700 --> 02:08:59,420
perhaps in Pribono lawyers to help. Do we have any sense of how many residents this TPS affects?

1339
02:09:01,870 --> 02:09:03,450
I have solicitor, Mayor.

1340
02:09:05,330 --> 02:09:11,110
Thank you and through you, Madam Mayor. Just to the question on whether the city would have standing.

1341
02:09:12,550 --> 02:09:20,430
Unfortunately, I don't think the city would have standing in that instance where there's an individual who's unlawfully detained.

1342
02:09:22,690 --> 02:09:30,630
But I hear the points that several of you raised on looking at volunteer attorney services.

1343
02:10:00,880 --> 02:10:29,880
Once a month I believe answering questions and then also connecting clinic participants with ongoing legal support, but I think we will be continuing to look at ways we can partner with our legal service providers and partner with volunteer attorneys and see if there's any other programs that the city can be part of to help get the necessary legal services out to the immigrants.

1344
02:10:33,120 --> 02:10:35,980
And then Councilor Nill and you're taking question on the number.

1345
02:10:36,120 --> 02:10:36,580
Right.

1346
02:10:36,680 --> 02:10:38,560
Can we have any sense of that?

1347
02:10:39,380 --> 02:10:44,210
I'm sure that maybe a city manager, maybe we can look into that.

1348
02:10:45,500 --> 02:10:47,360
Yeah, we can look into it.

1349
02:10:47,960 --> 02:10:48,420
Yeah.

1350
02:10:49,000 --> 02:10:57,300
And then I actually think I just remind all of us that as we move forward, our welcoming ordinance is quite strong.

1351
02:10:57,440 --> 02:11:01,240
You know, we can always look at it to see if we can improve it.

1352
02:11:01,240 --> 02:11:05,820
The other thing we need to remember is that we need to insist on our rights if there are

1353
02:11:05,820 --> 02:11:15,760
laws broken in our city to make sure we will be the ones to ensure that they are taking

1354
02:11:15,760 --> 02:11:21,360
care of, you know, we know in many, in theapolis there's been a concerted effort to not even

1355
02:11:21,360 --> 02:11:26,560
allow local law enforcement to be involved and it's something we should probably proactively

1356
02:11:26,560 --> 02:11:34,100
think about how do we ensure that if if if I assault someone on the street our law enforcement

1357
02:11:34,100 --> 02:11:41,120
officers right fully so will be in charge of adjudicating that and looking at it and if

1358
02:11:41,120 --> 02:11:46,480
an isopist or assault someone which we have seen happen time and time again across the country

1359
02:11:46,880 --> 02:11:51,440
we need to make sure that we can hold them accountable we will not interfere with the federal

1360
02:11:51,440 --> 02:11:57,860
immigration work, however, when our own laws are broken, I think we need to proactively think about

1361
02:11:57,860 --> 02:12:06,280
how do we ensure that our law enforcement can enforce law and order when the laws are being broken by

1362
02:12:06,280 --> 02:12:12,000
federal officials. So I'm not sure that's an answerable question, but I do want to raise it now because we have

1363
02:12:12,000 --> 02:12:16,820
certainly seen it and clearly it will come up at some point here because they will be after us given

1364
02:12:16,820 --> 02:12:21,420
particularly our status as a as a city that stands strong.

1365
02:12:25,080 --> 02:12:32,710
We're going to concentrate on that matter through you, Mr. Manager, can you just remind

1366
02:12:34,630 --> 02:12:38,630
remind us that reports that we get from the police department on

1367
02:12:39,350 --> 02:12:42,630
Is activity in the city. Those are what every three months.

1368
02:12:43,930 --> 02:12:44,670
Oh, I'll have to do we get those.

1369
02:12:45,870 --> 02:12:50,190
I thought it might have been every it's either every three months every quarter or every six months.

1370
02:12:50,310 --> 02:12:55,130
check and I think we had one fairly recently in the fall.

1371
02:12:56,470 --> 02:13:00,750
I would just maybe recommend, especially if we're looking at there's going to be a potential

1372
02:13:00,750 --> 02:13:03,050
surge that maybe we get those reports more frequently.

1373
02:13:03,630 --> 02:13:09,550
I think people, as much as we communicate with folks in the community about what is actually

1374
02:13:09,550 --> 02:13:15,130
happening to the best of our knowledge, I think the better, I see on social media a lot

1375
02:13:15,130 --> 02:13:20,090
about people saying, you know, I just was spotted here, I just was spotted there, a lot

1376
02:13:20,090 --> 02:13:26,910
times those turn out not to be accurate. But again, everyone is so anxious and so on edge

1377
02:13:28,130 --> 02:13:35,150
that the more information we can provide and then going, you know, going for months or longer to

1378
02:13:35,150 --> 02:13:39,970
to give people information is probably too long given the way things are going and potentially

1379
02:13:39,970 --> 02:13:45,210
going to go. So if we can do that maybe more often, I think that would be helpful.

1380
02:13:46,430 --> 02:13:48,630
Yeah, that's all I have, Madam Mayor, I will.

1381
02:13:48,870 --> 02:13:49,730
Thank you, Madam Chair.

1382
02:13:49,950 --> 02:13:50,750
Through you, Mayor Sediki.

1383
02:13:51,270 --> 02:13:54,210
I think we can definitely, we can maybe be in touch

1384
02:13:54,210 --> 02:13:57,070
in terms of what is, what is better.

1385
02:13:57,210 --> 02:13:58,870
I mean, I think doing it monthly would be fine.

1386
02:13:59,130 --> 02:14:00,230
We currently have it quarterly.

1387
02:14:01,550 --> 02:14:05,930
There has not been a significant amount of ice

1388
02:14:05,930 --> 02:14:08,870
to tensions within the city of Cambridge,

1389
02:14:09,010 --> 02:14:11,330
but certainly I think our understanding is there's been more

1390
02:14:11,330 --> 02:14:14,410
activity in many of our surrounding communities

1391
02:14:14,410 --> 02:14:20,270
and of course we are very much watching for if there would be any indication that there's

1392
02:14:20,270 --> 02:14:25,730
going to be some sort of a surge or an uptick. So I appreciate that thought.

1393
02:14:25,950 --> 02:14:33,370
Councilor McGovern. Other questions comments from the City Council on this?

1394
02:14:35,620 --> 02:14:35,720
Seeing

1395
02:14:35,720 --> 02:14:45,300
then we'll be in touch with the City Manager on other items. So on our motion by Councillor

1396
02:14:45,300 --> 02:14:51,200
Simmons to place city manager gender number one on file. We'll do a roll call.

1397
02:14:51,500 --> 02:14:59,260
Councillor Azubi. Yes. Yes. Vice Mayor Azim. Yes. Yes. Council of Flaherty. Yes. Yes. Council of McGuvern.

1398
02:15:00,000 --> 02:15:05,260
Number 1 is placed on file. We'll move on to city manager agenda item number 3. This has

1399
02:15:05,260 --> 02:15:12,040
transmitted communication from Ian Wong City manager. Relative for the appropriation of $100,000 received

1400
02:15:12,040 --> 02:15:17,180
from the Massachusetts School Building Authority to the public investment fund school, exterior

1401
02:15:17,180 --> 02:15:24,000
ordinary expenditures account to fund the feasibility study and schematic design costs for the

1402
02:15:24,000 --> 02:15:26,960
roof replacement project at the Cambridge Sports School,

1403
02:15:27,140 --> 02:15:29,040
located at 89 Elm Street.

1404
02:15:29,620 --> 02:15:31,100
Counselors, do you see you have the four?

1405
02:15:31,580 --> 02:15:34,360
Thank you, Mayor Sedicki.

1406
02:15:35,280 --> 02:15:36,480
I think it's great.

1407
02:15:36,600 --> 02:15:37,420
We got this grant.

1408
02:15:37,640 --> 02:15:42,140
I just wondered why a feasibility study,

1409
02:15:42,260 --> 02:15:45,420
or whether a feasibility study and a design

1410
02:15:45,420 --> 02:15:48,100
is needed for roof replacement, having,

1411
02:15:48,380 --> 02:15:51,020
I know a school is more complicated than a house,

1412
02:15:51,020 --> 02:16:03,220
But wouldn't a good roof or be able to come up with a plan and not need a hundred thousand dollars for feasibility study in a formal design.

1413
02:16:04,420 --> 02:16:08,100
So that's a question through you, Mayor Sediki, for the city manager.

1414
02:16:10,520 --> 02:16:16,820
So we have a bunch of school staff here, so we'll go to meet that.

1415
02:16:17,400 --> 02:16:18,460
Sure, thank you, Mayor.

1416
02:16:19,020 --> 02:16:29,380
Hi, my name is Gidad Konjukam, director of facilities for Cambridge Public Schools. I'm not sure if you can see me, but you can hear me, right?

1417
02:16:29,620 --> 02:16:29,680
Yeah.

1418
02:16:30,240 --> 02:16:30,900
Okay, excellent.

1419
02:16:31,680 --> 02:16:38,460
So I just want to explain, you know, Massachusetts School Building of Authority process.

1420
02:16:38,460 --> 02:16:53,960
So in order to get a program for accelerated repair, which is for replacement of roofs,

1421
02:16:54,480 --> 02:17:00,720
boilers and windows, we need to submit the statement of interest last year around this time.

1422
02:17:00,960 --> 02:17:06,440
After that, we get invited if we are selected based on the criteria that they have,

1423
02:17:06,440 --> 02:17:11,900
which is usually the age and the condition of the roof or the boiler or the window.

1424
02:17:12,540 --> 02:17:20,460
You get invited to do a feasibility study or a schematic design to see if we qualify

1425
02:17:21,600 --> 02:17:24,260
for being accepted into their program.

1426
02:17:25,060 --> 02:17:31,620
We finance the entire cost of the project and once the project is completed, we are

1427
02:17:31,620 --> 02:17:38,600
burst, certain rate, which is roughly between 30 and 40% of cost of the project.

1428
02:17:39,980 --> 02:17:47,260
These are MSB requirements. They're required us to do feasibility study. They also, if

1429
02:17:47,260 --> 02:17:58,900
we are selected to go forward with the process, they will assign us a designer and the

1430
02:17:59,520 --> 02:18:06,000
process, those are their rules. We've completed several projects, you know, with them in a past,

1431
02:18:08,180 --> 02:18:14,920
and it is definitely, you know, something, if we were doing it on our own, which we had

1432
02:18:14,920 --> 02:18:20,640
right now, we were in the midst of replacing a roof at a long-tailed Broadway, we would hire an architect

1433
02:18:21,240 --> 02:18:28,140
ourselves. This is required, these roofs are a little more complex. There's a lot to go into,

1434
02:18:28,140 --> 02:18:34,580
There's a lot of curves, a lot of things up on the roof is not just kind of like a flat

1435
02:18:34,580 --> 02:18:41,840
roof that can easily be done, so there's definitely some design that goes into it.

1436
02:18:41,840 --> 02:18:49,820
And we also need a design to go out to bed to the competitive buildings so that roof and

1437
02:18:49,820 --> 02:18:56,900
contractor know what they're building on, what the condition of substructure is and all

1438
02:18:56,900 --> 02:19:02,920
that so they can make up meaningful bid on the project. Thank you.

1439
02:19:03,020 --> 02:19:08,420
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you so much. Again, through you, Mayor Sadiki. That's really

1440
02:19:08,420 --> 02:19:16,720
helpful, helpful, Mr. Conject. And so we're not guaranteed of the funding from the state

1441
02:19:16,720 --> 02:19:22,560
or partial funding for the repair of the roof, but it sounds like it's likely if we follow

1442
02:19:22,560 --> 02:19:30,120
this procedure is that right? Yes, that is correct. Yeah. Anyway, sounds great and I thank you very

1443
02:19:30,120 --> 02:19:38,180
much for making this happen. Thank you. Do my colleagues have any other questions on this?

1444
02:19:39,940 --> 02:19:47,320
Thank you to the school staff who joined. Hearing none, we'll go ahead and do on a motion by

1445
02:19:47,320 --> 02:19:51,860
Councillor Zuzzi, a roll call on the appropriation and placing

1446
02:19:51,860 --> 02:19:54,840
city manager agenda item number three on file.

1447
02:19:55,280 --> 02:19:56,040
Councillor Luzzi.

1448
02:19:56,420 --> 02:19:56,960
Yes.

1449
02:19:57,260 --> 02:19:57,660
Yes.

1450
02:19:57,660 --> 02:19:58,500
Vice-mayorazine.

1451
02:19:59,040 --> 02:19:59,240
Yes.

1452
02:20:00,000 --> 02:20:07,600
The council of plurality. Yes. Yes. Council of McGuvern. Yes. Yes. Yes. Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes.

1453
02:20:07,600 --> 02:20:19,400
Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes. Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes. Mayor Sediki. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

1454
02:20:21,700 --> 02:20:29,820
We have placed the item on file, the money has been appropriated, will move on to City Manager

1455
02:20:29,820 --> 02:20:31,280
agenda item number four.

1456
02:20:31,800 --> 02:20:36,260
This is transmitting a communication from Ian Wong City Manager relative to the appointment

1457
02:20:36,260 --> 02:20:41,360
of the following person's as public weirers for the calendar year 206 to operate scales

1458
02:20:41,360 --> 02:20:47,420
at 500 fronts street, Cambridge Massachusetts, 0.142, Councilor Suzy, you have a four.

1459
02:20:47,420 --> 02:20:53,280
Thank you so much, Mayor Siddiqui. I just wanted to hear more about this because it sounded very

1460
02:20:53,280 --> 02:21:00,960
mysterious to me. How long is the term? What is the function of the public wayers? I've never

1461
02:21:00,960 --> 02:21:07,160
heard of a public wayer. What are their qualifications? Are they paid? And I was looking at

1462
02:21:07,160 --> 02:21:13,340
500 front street. It looks like it's very close to MIT. Is it right beside MIT? I've never

1463
02:21:13,340 --> 02:21:18,660
noted a scale there. So I'm just eager to learn more about this through you Mayor Siddiqui.

1464
02:21:18,920 --> 02:21:23,920
I guess to Deputy City Manager, Kathy Watkins.

1465
02:21:25,540 --> 02:21:32,600
Hi, through you, Madam Mayor. I think we are having some technical difficulties. So ISD is trying to

1466
02:21:32,600 --> 02:21:39,360
log on who would be the best people to answer these questions. And so I genuinely apologize.

1467
02:21:39,360 --> 02:21:43,660
So I know Peter was trying to apologize, trying to log on.

1468
02:21:44,000 --> 02:21:46,080
We may have to get back to you on some of these questions.

1469
02:21:46,920 --> 02:21:47,720
So thank you, Anthony.

1470
02:21:48,660 --> 02:21:49,120
Yes.

1471
02:21:49,780 --> 02:21:51,000
Sorry about that.

1472
02:21:51,240 --> 02:21:51,540
Oh, perfect.

1473
02:21:51,700 --> 02:21:52,420
Thank you, Anthony.

1474
02:21:52,640 --> 02:21:54,140
I'm like, try to do it.

1475
02:21:54,140 --> 02:21:54,580
Thank you.

1476
02:21:54,680 --> 02:21:55,560
Anthony is here.

1477
02:21:55,720 --> 02:21:56,680
We're a good ambulance.

1478
02:21:57,180 --> 02:21:57,340
Sure.

1479
02:21:57,340 --> 02:21:58,340
I thank you, Councilor.

1480
02:21:58,340 --> 02:21:59,020
For that question.

1481
02:21:59,320 --> 02:22:00,360
Through you, Madam Mass.

1482
02:22:00,840 --> 02:22:01,320
Publicways.

1483
02:22:01,660 --> 02:22:03,460
In Massachusetts, cities and towns.

1484
02:22:04,600 --> 02:22:05,660
Swear and Publicways.

1485
02:22:06,240 --> 02:22:08,920
For businesses to ensure accuracy and fairness.

1486
02:22:08,920 --> 02:22:14,300
with their state consumer protection laws of sale of goods and weights and measures.

1487
02:22:14,500 --> 02:22:20,800
This practice is mandated by Mass General Law, Chapter 41, Section 85, which requires

1488
02:22:20,800 --> 02:22:29,280
mass and city councils to appoint wares upon request to verify accuracy of commodities, particularly

1489
02:22:29,280 --> 02:22:32,020
in heavy materials like stone and sand.

1490
02:22:32,780 --> 02:22:40,960
When it is, as Boston Senator Gravel had, sell such large volumes of goods, these public

1491
02:22:40,960 --> 02:22:49,100
ways sworn in to certify that the goods that they sell weigh to according to law.

1492
02:22:49,780 --> 02:22:58,420
They do go through quarterly third-party inspection, and we do join them once a year on

1493
02:22:58,420 --> 02:23:04,700
third party, especially in Sean, is our inspector who does that, is online also.

1494
02:23:06,760 --> 02:23:12,180
I think one of your questions was, do they get paid? They get paid by Boston Sending Gravel,

1495
02:23:13,280 --> 02:23:20,660
not by us, and it's just to safeguard against public fraud and carelessness

1496
02:23:22,500 --> 02:23:23,880
involving weights and measures.

1497
02:23:25,500 --> 02:23:26,380
So, is there anything?

1498
02:23:26,640 --> 02:23:28,620
Yeah, through Mayor Sadikis,

1499
02:23:28,620 --> 02:23:30,620
if I wanted to be a public wear

1500
02:23:30,620 --> 02:23:33,520
what sort of credentials would I need to have?

1501
02:23:34,800 --> 02:23:36,660
Well, I, through you, Madam Mayor,

1502
02:23:37,740 --> 02:23:41,920
trust you would work for the company that you're being sworn in to.

1503
02:23:43,340 --> 02:23:45,340
You know, we have a weights and measures

1504
02:23:46,080 --> 02:23:48,900
department that go, that's fuel and special services.

1505
02:23:48,900 --> 02:23:58,640
we do all of the smaller scales. This particular business, the such large volumes, we don't, we

1506
02:23:58,640 --> 02:24:04,580
we don't have the equipment to do this. A lot of cities and towns and Massachusetts that have this

1507
02:24:04,580 --> 02:24:10,900
type of business do swearing publicoyers.

1508
02:24:12,580 --> 02:24:27,220
So are they so are they like civil and so mostly it's a check-in balance system it sounds like so you just you need a reliable honest person who might have some mechanical ability that would check this scales

1509
02:24:27,220 --> 02:24:32,960
Is that it I mean why so why would why would we need like nine of those?

1510
02:24:34,240 --> 02:24:36,960
People because do they take turns or?

1511
02:24:38,660 --> 02:24:45,220
through you, through you matter, yes, I think they all work in different shifts in different

1512
02:24:45,220 --> 02:24:51,820
capacities I've fostered seeing and gravel, whether it's what they're selling or what

1513
02:24:51,820 --> 02:24:57,160
they're weighing, what materials are going out, it's a different different people.

1514
02:24:57,740 --> 02:24:59,800
Okay, I'm just absolutely fascinated.

1515
02:25:00,000 --> 02:25:06,220
But I never heard of the square occupation, and thank you for telling me about it. Thank you, I yield.

1516
02:25:07,240 --> 02:25:08,100
Councillor Simmons.

1517
02:25:08,700 --> 02:25:14,940
Thank you, Mayor Chair. I'm just kind of following up behind council, Zuzzi, and I want to thank her for raising

1518
02:25:14,940 --> 02:25:21,220
this question, because as I was reading through the agenda and became to this particular item,

1519
02:25:21,320 --> 02:25:25,880
one thought I had was I went to how many members actually know what these folks do, so

1520
02:25:25,880 --> 02:25:27,720
of us do have been around for a while.

1521
02:25:27,720 --> 02:25:29,880
Some of us might have known and didn't remember.

1522
02:25:30,660 --> 02:25:34,700
And so I raised this and support my colleague and her queries.

1523
02:25:36,080 --> 02:25:38,220
So I don't have any objections to concerns.

1524
02:25:38,760 --> 02:25:41,940
But I do want to point out that the city manager

1525
02:25:43,200 --> 02:25:47,300
should be better about providing information

1526
02:25:47,300 --> 02:25:50,220
of sentence or to this is, you know, wait some measures.

1527
02:25:50,360 --> 02:25:51,700
And this is what the person does

1528
02:25:51,700 --> 02:25:53,680
because everyone doesn't know.

1529
02:25:53,720 --> 02:25:55,340
Including the people that might be viewing in.

1530
02:25:55,340 --> 02:25:57,760
We're not only identifying ourselves as counselors,

1531
02:25:57,760 --> 02:25:59,600
but we're telling the people that are viewing in.

1532
02:25:59,760 --> 02:26:01,520
So, what are these people that they're appointing?

1533
02:26:01,560 --> 02:26:02,140
What do they do?

1534
02:26:02,360 --> 02:26:03,120
What are they for?

1535
02:26:03,780 --> 02:26:05,420
The other thing that we don't know,

1536
02:26:05,840 --> 02:26:07,080
because we don't know who they are,

1537
02:26:07,580 --> 02:26:10,000
we don't know why they're qualified for these roles,

1538
02:26:10,340 --> 02:26:11,460
or even what the roles are.

1539
02:26:11,660 --> 02:26:12,480
So, thank you again.

1540
02:26:12,660 --> 02:26:15,400
That's what it now is by calling for raising that.

1541
02:26:15,400 --> 02:26:17,260
And I just think as we go forward,

1542
02:26:18,100 --> 02:26:20,200
it would be helpful to have some consistency

1543
02:26:21,000 --> 02:26:23,360
across the appointments of boards and commissions,

1544
02:26:23,360 --> 02:26:30,980
And quasi-employees, if you will, because I don't know what, really, to identify these individuals

1545
02:26:32,260 --> 02:26:39,560
as, but having some consistency on the communication and the information that we render on these

1546
02:26:39,560 --> 02:26:46,080
appointments that we're supposed to approve, the information in the context that we're getting

1547
02:26:46,080 --> 02:26:51,920
is in the record and that anyone has access to it. And I think it's better for us as counselors

1548
02:26:51,920 --> 02:26:54,660
that we know who and what we're voting to approve.

1549
02:26:55,080 --> 02:26:56,240
So with that, I yield a floor.

1550
02:26:56,460 --> 02:26:57,020
Thank you, Manager.

1551
02:26:59,300 --> 02:27:00,320
Thank you, Councillor Simmons.

1552
02:27:00,760 --> 02:27:02,640
Any other questions on this?

1553
02:27:05,640 --> 02:27:07,500
Hearing then, the clerk claimed,

1554
02:27:07,520 --> 02:27:08,980
Crayon, did you have your hand up?

1555
02:27:09,620 --> 02:27:12,440
I did. I just wanted to add that these terms

1556
02:27:12,440 --> 02:27:14,040
are usually for one year.

1557
02:27:14,420 --> 02:27:17,280
The City Clerk's office goes out on site yearly

1558
02:27:17,280 --> 02:27:20,440
and swiss these public wares in.

1559
02:27:20,720 --> 02:27:21,960
I know that was a question.

1560
02:27:23,340 --> 02:27:23,940
Thank you, Kirk.

1561
02:27:24,860 --> 02:27:31,560
And to folks' points, I think, you know, if there's a way we can get some more information

1562
02:27:31,560 --> 02:27:38,080
about what this is, what public wares are, so that it's on the record.

1563
02:27:39,760 --> 02:27:48,700
Seeing no one else, we'll, on a motion by Councillor Zusie to approve the appointments and

1564
02:27:48,700 --> 02:27:53,300
place, city manager, agenda, and before on file, we'll do a real call.

1565
02:27:53,740 --> 02:27:57,540
Councilor LZB. Yes. Yes. Vice Mayor Azine. Yes.

1566
02:27:57,820 --> 02:28:03,400
Yes. Councilor Flaherty. Yes. Yes. Councilor McGuvern. Yes.

1567
02:28:03,400 --> 02:28:08,560
Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councilor Simmons. Yes.

1568
02:28:09,060 --> 02:28:13,320
Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes. Councilor Zucy. Yes.

1569
02:28:13,720 --> 02:28:16,120
Yes. Mayor Sediki. Yes. Yes.

1570
02:28:16,120 --> 02:28:18,060
of nine members recorded in the affirmative.

1571
02:28:19,540 --> 02:28:22,300
The appointments have been approved and City Manager,

1572
02:28:22,600 --> 02:28:24,360
Gender and Forest placed on file.

1573
02:28:24,860 --> 02:28:28,040
We're moving on to City Manager agenda item of five.

1574
02:28:28,400 --> 02:28:31,240
Transmitting communication from Ian Wong City Manager relative

1575
02:28:31,240 --> 02:28:33,940
to the appointment, reappointment of the following people

1576
02:28:33,940 --> 02:28:37,700
to the recycling advisory committee for terms of three years.

1577
02:28:38,200 --> 02:28:39,700
Councillor Nolan, you have before.

1578
02:28:40,900 --> 02:28:41,760
Thank you, Mayor Sedik.

1579
02:28:41,760 --> 02:28:43,900
You're very excited to see this on the agenda.

1580
02:28:43,900 --> 02:29:12,520
And the reason I pulled is I do have a question on how the appointments were made in the process by which both the reappointments and the new members, it's it's great that while there's a total of nine that are required it can be as many as 20 or 24 so this last term we spent a lot of time working to make updates to the zero waste master plan and there's been many many discussions around how it is that we can improve all of the city operations related to recycling.

1581
02:29:12,520 --> 02:29:17,440
And part of that initiative around the changes we're making more aggressive benchmarks or

1582
02:29:17,440 --> 02:29:21,880
dense changes to reduce waste, take the first steps for the first time toward a single

1583
02:30:00,000 --> 02:30:15,720
This is a look at candidates who were inclined to advocate for strong improvements in waste reduction and or additionally specifically looking for candidates who would help oversight of existing and future city practices. I just want to make sure candidates for these boards and commissions.

1584
02:30:16,380 --> 02:30:28,880
And this is just one of them, as we go through them, there will be a lot more boards and commissions are not only dedicated residents, but really able to help us perform a very critical role in oversight and management.

1585
02:30:28,880 --> 02:30:36,120
not just given input or hearing about plans of the city, but to actually be able to inform

1586
02:30:36,120 --> 02:30:41,440
develop, create, and push the city to be the best that it can be in these areas.

1587
02:30:41,680 --> 02:30:45,300
And particularly for this advisor committee, I think it's critically important role,

1588
02:30:46,100 --> 02:30:50,820
so that we can have a successful implementation of the zero waste master plan for already behind

1589
02:30:50,820 --> 02:30:56,040
on a couple of the ideas that were supposed to be promulgated up by now, so I'm just really

1590
02:30:56,040 --> 02:31:08,060
I wanted to understand how the process included that somewhat expanded vision for what our zero waste master plan will bring to the city and this RAC will be key to that.

1591
02:31:09,080 --> 02:31:10,720
What are the deputy city manager?

1592
02:31:11,540 --> 02:31:13,920
Thank you through your mayor, city key.

1593
02:31:14,560 --> 02:31:17,120
So I think they were trying to get promoted, hopefully they did.

1594
02:31:17,700 --> 02:31:24,680
We have Jennifer Matthews who is the deputy commissioner of public works in Michael or who is the recycling director who I will turn it over to that.

1595
02:31:24,680 --> 02:31:28,120
can talk about respond to your questions, Councilor Nolan.

1596
02:31:29,980 --> 02:31:33,300
Hi. This is my gore through you, Madam Mayor.

1597
02:31:34,160 --> 02:31:39,700
So the interview process was, you know, first of all, we look at, you know, how many

1598
02:31:39,700 --> 02:31:45,300
people applied. We look at geographic diversity of applicants. You know, we want to just make

1599
02:31:45,300 --> 02:31:50,940
sure we have like a well-rounded group of people on the committee. But then we do look at

1600
02:31:50,940 --> 02:31:56,620
specific qualifications like we have one candidate who was a chief communications officer

1601
02:31:56,620 --> 02:32:01,820
and has a lot of insight as to like how to communicate around zero waste or things in the

1602
02:32:01,820 --> 02:32:08,040
climate realm. But then we also have different kind of candidates that are maybe newer to the

1603
02:32:08,040 --> 02:32:14,240
zero waste kind of lifestyle or lack of a better word that can offer different insights.

1604
02:32:14,920 --> 02:32:19,440
So we like to balance different ages, different backgrounds, different parts of the city,

1605
02:32:20,200 --> 02:32:24,680
people that are in the industry and so people that are not in the industry, so we have

1606
02:32:25,720 --> 02:32:31,240
a representative from Harvard and MIT that are both in the zero-waste kind of like their

1607
02:32:31,240 --> 02:32:37,700
job descriptions fully covered the zero-waste initiatives and then we have people that

1608
02:32:37,700 --> 02:32:44,480
that have worked in industry as plastics manufacturers or different kind of individuals and

1609
02:32:44,480 --> 02:32:50,300
circularity thing. So, I think we have a pretty well-rounded group here. It is a relatively

1610
02:32:50,300 --> 02:32:55,180
large advisor committee, but we do like giving a lot of different people inside. When we have

1611
02:32:55,180 --> 02:33:00,740
so many applicants that are volunteering for voluntary committee, we like to give them the opportunity.

1612
02:33:05,000 --> 02:33:11,860
One thing I would add to that through Madam Mayor, Councillor Nolan, we are in the process of

1613
02:33:11,860 --> 02:33:17,740
finalizing draft ordinance changes to affect the changes that were anticipated in the zero

1614
02:33:17,740 --> 02:33:23,040
waste master plan 2.0 and one of the changes that we will be proposing that I think is consistent

1615
02:33:23,040 --> 02:33:27,460
with some of the issues you braised is changing the name of the recycling advisory committee

1616
02:33:27,460 --> 02:33:33,380
to the waste reduction advisory committee and really refocusing their work on zero waste initiatives

1617
02:33:33,380 --> 02:33:39,820
broadly. So again, looking at this and thinking about it not simply as recycling but the very

1618
02:33:39,820 --> 02:33:46,160
the varied ways that that this group will be helping to advise on zero waste initiatives.

1619
02:33:49,000 --> 02:33:54,140
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm speaking. Thank you. My gore and Jennifer.

1620
02:33:54,920 --> 02:33:58,780
That's terrific. It wasn't really responsive to the question though. The question really was,

1621
02:33:59,180 --> 02:34:04,700
as we were recruiting and talking to these people, was it very clear that oversight monitoring,

1622
02:34:05,040 --> 02:34:09,000
not just being told that the issues are not just communicating the issues,

1623
02:34:09,000 --> 02:34:14,340
but actually taking a much more intentional approach

1624
02:34:15,240 --> 02:34:16,420
to our zero-wise offline.

1625
02:34:16,500 --> 02:34:19,740
We've had some successes in the zero-waste

1626
02:34:19,740 --> 02:34:20,680
and recycling area.

1627
02:34:20,820 --> 02:34:22,660
And we've had some really stalled out,

1628
02:34:22,740 --> 02:34:24,920
which is part of why zero-waste master plan 2.0

1629
02:34:24,920 --> 02:34:26,880
was really significant, exciting.

1630
02:34:27,120 --> 02:34:29,620
However, this committee, again,

1631
02:34:29,960 --> 02:34:31,760
like, as I've said with many of our other committees,

1632
02:34:31,820 --> 02:34:33,260
let's really make use of the volunteers

1633
02:34:33,260 --> 02:34:35,280
in the community who are very interested in this.

1634
02:34:35,820 --> 02:34:38,720
So my question was that part of the interview process

1635
02:34:38,720 --> 02:34:45,060
to let them know that they do have a role that we want them to push us and, again, go forward

1636
02:34:45,060 --> 02:34:48,540
with this renaming the committee as good, that the other ordinance changes are ones

1637
02:34:48,540 --> 02:34:53,580
who are really eagerly awaiting for commercial food waste, you know, and terminology matters

1638
02:34:53,580 --> 02:34:57,960
as, you know, we thought really hard to have it be food waste, not compost, however, there's

1639
02:34:57,960 --> 02:34:59,980
so many other things we really need to work on.

1640
02:35:00,000 --> 02:35:29,340
And meet our goals that I'm just curious, again, in this interview process, whether that was part of the approach to ensure that people coming on are going to be the types of people who are not only capable of creating and giving input, because that's our job is into listen to them, but also have an attitude that, you know, to push the city to really do all we can, because that's what we all need and hopefully want from these boards and commissions. If that makes sense as a question, I just want to be very clear about that part of the question.

1641
02:35:32,460 --> 02:35:37,800
Sure, through you, Madam Mayor, you know, we did talk extensively about how we do have a

1642
02:35:37,800 --> 02:35:43,220
news zero waste master plan and we do want this committee to have a lot of

1643
02:35:43,900 --> 02:35:49,720
kind of stake in helping us reach those goals. And you know, I think that's something that we can

1644
02:35:49,720 --> 02:35:56,020
continue to work on is kind of like, on our monthly meetings and even between meetings, just trying

1645
02:35:56,020 --> 02:36:02,020
to figure out like how to empower the committee as much as possible to like help push us along.

1646
02:36:02,020 --> 02:36:31,860
to meeting these goals. I mean, it is a little bit tricky. I mean, because, you know, there's a lot of people that are coming from different backgrounds, and they may not fully understand everything in the waste world or like the operations, but, you know, as we start getting more versed, and as we get a lot of these new candidates, interested and more involved in the DPW, it'll help kind of bring out, I think, a better kind of opportunity for them to not just along. And so that's something that we can definitely look a lot more closely at.

1647
02:36:33,490 --> 02:36:47,310
Great, thank you. And again, this is going to be triple boards and commission. I think that we're going to be doing our job better if we take advantage and really use these boards and commissions and particularly in this area. I think it's going to be critically important.

1648
02:36:48,070 --> 02:36:58,490
As you know, I'm I'm that this is a great plan and yet it could have been even more aggressive and any other timeline is we really need to meet these timelines so we can get on to zero waste master plan.

1649
02:36:59,270 --> 02:37:00,390
D.C.M.

1650
02:37:00,430 --> 02:37:04,290
Walkins may not like this, but I'm already thinking of their way to master plan 3.0.

1651
02:37:04,590 --> 02:37:05,790
Once we get through this.

1652
02:37:06,430 --> 02:37:09,050
So thank you with that Mayor Siddiqui, I yield.

1653
02:37:09,250 --> 02:37:10,330
I will be approving these.

1654
02:37:10,430 --> 02:37:11,930
There's a terrific array of people.

1655
02:37:12,270 --> 02:37:24,090
And I do hope they hear the message and the staff hear the message that we'd really love to have this group be part of the solution to so many of these issues that are critically important for the city moving forward.

1656
02:37:24,150 --> 02:37:24,990
Thank you, I yield.

1657
02:37:24,990 --> 02:37:32,690
Councillor Nolan yields, don't see any other questions on this item, so on a motion by Councillor

1658
02:37:32,690 --> 02:37:40,610
Nolan to prove the appointments placed in the agenda item number five on file, will

1659
02:37:40,610 --> 02:37:48,410
do a roll call please? Councillor Elzuby. Yes. Yes. Vice-marazine. Yes. Yes. Councillor Flaherty. Yes.

1660
02:37:48,410 --> 02:37:53,430
Yes, Councilwoman govern. Yes. Yes, Councilor Nolan.

1661
02:37:57,910 --> 02:38:10,310
Yes. Yes, Councilor Simmons. Yes, Councilor Sabrina Wailer. Yes. Yes, Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes, Mayor Sediki. Yes. Yes, and you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

1662
02:38:10,310 --> 02:38:16,510
The appointments are approved and City Manager Agenda I Amr5 is placed on file.

1663
02:38:17,350 --> 02:38:20,270
We are moving on to City Manager Agenda I Amr7.

1664
02:38:20,670 --> 02:38:29,690
Transmanic Communication from Ian Huang City Manager relative to the appropriation of 226,880 dollars

1665
02:38:29,990 --> 02:38:37,550
from the Emergency Solutions grant to the grant fund Human Services salary and wages and other ordinary maintenance accounts.

1666
02:38:37,550 --> 02:38:39,370
Councillor Simmons, you have before.

1667
02:38:40,090 --> 02:38:40,970
Thank you, Madam Chair.

1668
02:38:41,570 --> 02:38:47,870
So tonight we're off to rising the 226,880 dollars in emergency solutions grant funding.

1669
02:38:48,510 --> 02:38:53,470
In every dollar of this allocation is directed to a homeless assistance and shelter operation

1670
02:38:53,470 --> 02:38:58,250
for central services, private housing, and homelessness prevention.

1671
02:38:59,410 --> 02:39:05,150
And so this is not discretionary spending, it is core, it is core to how we need our obligations

1672
02:39:05,150 --> 02:39:10,950
to some of our most vulnerable residents, and the city, but at the same time I think it's important

1673
02:39:10,950 --> 02:39:11,710
to be candid.

1674
02:39:13,270 --> 02:39:18,050
Over the past several years, this council and the city has encountered some troubling concerns

1675
02:39:18,050 --> 02:39:22,850
related to the experiences of people utilizing some of our local shelters.

1676
02:39:23,470 --> 02:39:28,570
Those concerns of comfort residents, advocates, and service users themselves.

1677
02:39:28,570 --> 02:39:34,630
They range from safety issues to dignity and respect to how complaints that we see and address.

1678
02:39:35,050 --> 02:39:40,170
And so while the city does not directly operate these shelters, we are not without responsibility.

1679
02:39:41,950 --> 02:39:47,870
From my point of view, when public dollars are being invested, especially federal dollars,

1680
02:40:00,000 --> 02:40:11,720
Expectations. So, for me, oversight cannot be symbolic, accountability cannot be cosmetic. My support for this appropriation comes with the expectation that the city will most

1681
02:40:11,720 --> 02:40:21,280
strangely assert its influence with the shelter partners. And what does that mean? That means insisting upon meaningful responses from concerns are raised,

1682
02:40:21,820 --> 02:40:29,060
not procedural box checking or temporary fixes designated to quiet criticism. It needs a willingness to look honestly

1683
02:40:29,060 --> 02:40:35,960
at patterns, not just individual incidents, and to push for real improvements in the practice

1684
02:40:35,960 --> 02:40:40,720
in the culture. I particularly trust that the city manager's approaching these agreements

1685
02:40:40,720 --> 02:40:46,060
carefully and deliberately, and that when this funding is dispersed, it is paired with

1686
02:40:46,060 --> 02:40:53,160
clear standards, active monitoring, and sharing understanding that the partnership does not mean

1687
02:40:53,160 --> 02:40:55,100
application of our responsibility.

1688
02:40:56,100 --> 02:40:59,680
So our most vulnerable residents deserve better than lip service.

1689
02:40:59,940 --> 02:41:05,020
And our partnership understand that continued public investment carries real expectations.

1690
02:41:05,940 --> 02:41:07,620
Thank you, and I yield the floor.

1691
02:41:10,290 --> 02:41:11,250
Thank you, Councillor Simmons.

1692
02:41:11,470 --> 02:41:13,070
I see Councillor Susie's.

1693
02:41:14,730 --> 02:41:19,350
For you, Mayor Siddiqui, I just wanted to thank this is great news that we got this grant.

1694
02:41:19,350 --> 02:41:28,230
So is it a federal grant and were we anticipating it or are we just thrilled that we got this money?

1695
02:41:31,080 --> 02:41:36,540
Do you know what I mean? Was it budgeted? Were we anticipating, is this something we get every year? Is this something new?

1696
02:41:36,540 --> 02:41:38,180
Does this incident manage the seminar?

1697
02:41:39,840 --> 02:41:46,420
To you, Madam Mayor, this is a federal grant that we have received for a very long time.

1698
02:41:46,820 --> 02:41:56,120
This was, as you may recall, many of our HUD related grants were subject to conditions.

1699
02:41:56,560 --> 02:42:03,700
Either we weren't getting the money or they were subject to conditions that it wasn't clear we could agree to.

1700
02:42:03,700 --> 02:42:21,700
The fact that we are appropriating the money now is a result of HUD having entered into agreements which included our, and the, and if Megan still here, if you have more question, she could join in.

1701
02:42:21,700 --> 02:42:42,020
But, which included are being able to cross out the conditions that were unacceptable because of the pending injunction in the King lawsuit that is which we've talked about a number of times here.

1702
02:42:42,020 --> 02:42:52,300
but this particular funding, the city manager, knowing that we had the federal funding allowed

1703
02:42:52,300 --> 02:42:59,300
us to actually contract with these shelters beginning in July because although it's not

1704
02:42:59,300 --> 02:43:05,730
a lot of money for each of the individual shelters, they count on this money and so we were

1705
02:43:06,710 --> 02:43:14,450
operating under the assumption that if those funds did not ultimately get released by HUD,

1706
02:43:14,950 --> 02:43:20,650
that these would be covered through that federal stabilization fund fortunately.

1707
02:43:22,510 --> 02:43:26,570
We now have been given authority by HUD to go ahead,

1708
02:43:26,890 --> 02:43:34,570
and so we will be able to continue this funding to the various shelters.

1709
02:43:34,570 --> 02:43:51,610
And if I might say something in response to Councillor Simmons, I appreciate your comments and I know that we worked closely with your office over the course of the last year, last two years.

1710
02:43:51,610 --> 02:44:11,750
When there were some complaints and we were able to develop stronger systems for supporting individuals who had complaints in the shelters and I want to say that something which we would expect

1711
02:44:11,750 --> 02:44:16,070
to continue to happen as we move forward.

1712
02:44:18,120 --> 02:44:20,260
That's what's associated with you, have anything else?

1713
02:44:20,740 --> 02:44:27,920
Yeah, I just thank you so much, and I'm so grateful, former assistant city manager,

1714
02:44:28,660 --> 02:44:35,280
seven off that you are still here and engaged in helping us in so many different ways.

1715
02:44:35,340 --> 02:44:36,240
Thank you so much.

1716
02:44:36,700 --> 02:44:42,140
Through you, Madam Mayor, I just want to say, I'm just here through this weekend,

1717
02:44:42,460 --> 02:44:45,160
and then we will have a new assistant city manager.

1718
02:44:45,160 --> 02:44:51,060
So you will just be seeing me as a constituent no longer as the assistant city manager.

1719
02:44:51,660 --> 02:44:54,310
Thank you. We're very lucky to have you so close by.

1720
02:44:55,220 --> 02:44:57,520
Councillor Simmons did you have anything else?

1721
02:45:00,080 --> 02:45:07,580
Our, our treating our clients and residents some respectfully. So thank you for that.

1722
02:45:07,700 --> 02:45:11,760
And it's all the way. I was going to say, I thought you'd be tired, but I'm glad you're here.

1723
02:45:12,080 --> 02:45:15,040
It's always good to see you. Are you the floor madam, too?

1724
02:45:16,080 --> 02:45:29,640
I do not see any other hands on this. So on our motion by Councillor Simmons on the appropriation and placing city manager agenda item number seven on file will do a roll call.

1725
02:45:29,640 --> 02:45:40,200
Councilor Elzumbi. Yes. Yes. Vice Mayor Azine. Yes. Yes. Councilor Flarrady. Yes. Yes. Councilor McGuvern. Yes. Yes.

1726
02:45:40,220 --> 02:45:47,540
Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes.

1727
02:45:47,540 --> 02:45:53,580
Councilor Susie. Yes. Yes. Mayor Sediki. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

1728
02:45:53,580 --> 02:46:01,730
If the money has been appropriated and city manager agenda item number seven is placed on file.

1729
02:46:02,120 --> 02:46:05,220
We're moving on to city manager agenda item number 10.

1730
02:46:05,480 --> 02:46:09,800
A communication transmitted from the N. Wong city manager relative to the appointment or

1731
02:46:09,800 --> 02:46:14,440
re-appointment of the following people as possible for terms of three years.

1732
02:46:14,620 --> 02:46:16,080
Councillor Azusa, you have the floor.

1733
02:46:17,280 --> 02:46:18,500
Thank you so much, Mayor City.

1734
02:46:18,640 --> 02:46:19,700
Just a quick question.

1735
02:46:19,700 --> 02:46:24,840
And again, I know there's a constable that opens up the Harvard Commencement every year.

1736
02:46:25,220 --> 02:46:34,780
I did a little Googling and I understand that they serve legal process, eviction, provide eviction notices and do other law enforcement.

1737
02:46:35,620 --> 02:46:39,480
Are these usually police members of our police force that do this work?

1738
02:46:40,240 --> 02:46:43,400
And again, is it a paid position?

1739
02:46:43,800 --> 02:46:44,960
Is it a full-time position?

1740
02:46:45,460 --> 02:46:47,400
Or is it an honorary position?

1741
02:46:53,080 --> 02:47:05,540
Thank you through you Madam Mayor, so a constable is a position established under state law and we also have an ordinance on constables.

1742
02:47:06,220 --> 02:47:15,200
We don't employ them, they're not employees of the city but it's a designation that the city is authorized to appoint someone with.

1743
02:47:15,200 --> 02:47:25,440
Often, private security companies employ constables, or, as you mentioned, service, you know,

1744
02:47:25,740 --> 02:47:29,660
process service servers are often, are constables.

1745
02:47:30,580 --> 02:47:36,480
So when in constable is appointed with the power to serve process, they are process servers.

1746
02:47:37,900 --> 02:47:53,500
And the city's role is doing a background investigation that if you want to hear more about the police commissioner can speak to, and then the city manager appoints the Constable for a term of three years.

1747
02:47:53,500 --> 02:47:54,500
So,

1748
02:47:57,120 --> 02:47:59,860
do we have one or do we have many?

1749
02:48:01,380 --> 02:48:03,540
I'm not sure you might have there are multiple

1750
02:48:04,380 --> 02:48:04,900
Constables.

1751
02:48:06,160 --> 02:48:08,400
So when they're they're term is up there.

1752
02:48:08,740 --> 02:48:10,820
Re-appointed or someone new is appointed.

1753
02:48:11,660 --> 02:48:13,460
It comes up before the council.

1754
02:48:14,820 --> 02:48:16,400
I don't know the exact number.

1755
02:48:16,560 --> 02:48:20,380
The city manager's office might have that information of how many have been appointed.

1756
02:48:21,600 --> 02:48:22,920
Through you, Mayor Citikey.

1757
02:48:22,920 --> 02:48:24,920
I think councilors use to you may be thinking

1758
02:48:24,920 --> 02:48:28,100
in terms of Harvard commencement of the middle sex sheriff,

1759
02:48:28,580 --> 02:48:30,260
of which there is only one.

1760
02:48:32,840 --> 02:48:37,100
OK, again, it's just a mystery to me about who these people are.

1761
02:48:37,280 --> 02:48:41,920
So a private security firm might provide them,

1762
02:48:41,940 --> 02:48:43,440
make them accessible to the city,

1763
02:48:43,620 --> 02:48:47,040
and we hire them, who hires them.

1764
02:48:47,400 --> 02:48:48,720
Did you hire them?

1765
02:48:49,000 --> 02:48:49,580
City manager.

1766
02:48:49,580 --> 02:49:00,980
But so if I may, through you, Madam Mayor, it's the title and the authority is designated

1767
02:49:00,980 --> 02:49:07,460
by the City Manager by state law, but they're not city employees, they're not police officers,

1768
02:49:08,160 --> 02:49:13,940
we do not, the city does not employ constables, just the City Manager by state law has the

1769
02:49:13,940 --> 02:49:18,160
authority to designate to appoint someone to be a constable.

1770
02:49:18,160 --> 02:49:32,180
And so like I said, some are employed by private security firms, some work for a process server company or themselves have a, you know, self-employed doing process serving.

1771
02:49:32,900 --> 02:49:35,040
So that that type of work.

1772
02:49:35,540 --> 02:49:35,560
Yeah.

1773
02:49:36,080 --> 02:49:36,880
Thank you.

1774
02:49:37,080 --> 02:49:39,060
Yeah, thank you so much for that clarification.

1775
02:49:40,320 --> 02:49:40,920
I yield.

1776
02:49:41,920 --> 02:49:44,160
Any other questions on this?

1777
02:49:45,020 --> 02:49:56,840
Hearing none, seeing none, we'll go ahead on a motion by Councillor Zuzzi to prove the appointments and place City Manager at Gender Item 10 on file.

1778
02:49:57,560 --> 02:49:58,520
Councillor Zuzzi.

1779
02:49:58,900 --> 02:49:59,200
Yes.

1780
02:50:00,000 --> 02:50:16,780
Yes. Yes, Councillor Zucing. Yes. Yes. Mayor Sediki. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative. The appointments are approved. And city manager agenda item number 10 is placed on file for moving on to city manager agenda item number 11.

1781
02:50:17,240 --> 02:50:29,980
A communication transmitted from Iran wants to imagine relative to a waiting report item number 25-69 regarding review of the previous home real petition and preparing a new petition that would allow Cambridge and that.

1782
02:50:29,980 --> 02:50:33,380
to real estate transfer fee to be sent to the state legislature.

1783
02:50:33,900 --> 02:50:35,300
Councillor Nolan, you have the floor.

1784
02:50:36,320 --> 02:50:37,280
Thank you, Mayor Sediki.

1785
02:50:38,120 --> 02:50:46,060
I am this is an exciting time to, we have to refile this petition because the council has

1786
02:50:46,060 --> 02:50:51,760
sent several into the state legislature each time it is not gone through, but we do have to

1787
02:50:51,760 --> 02:50:53,220
refile it in order to be heard.

1788
02:50:53,240 --> 02:50:57,780
There have been some questions raised about, for instance, whether we can do, we got an email

1789
02:50:57,780 --> 02:51:01,880
about ensuring that this does not end up raising

1790
02:51:01,880 --> 02:51:05,220
rents for multifamily zoning because that is something

1791
02:51:05,220 --> 02:51:09,260
apparently LA is concerned about and some other housing

1792
02:51:09,260 --> 02:51:10,440
advocates are concerned about.

1793
02:51:10,820 --> 02:51:12,920
I did reach out to the city solicitor earlier today,

1794
02:51:13,100 --> 02:51:16,940
and she didn't think some of the ways that the council

1795
02:51:16,940 --> 02:51:19,240
could change us in the future would be possible,

1796
02:51:19,460 --> 02:51:20,100
but she's not certain.

1797
02:51:20,240 --> 02:51:22,840
So I will exercise my charter rights so that I can make sure

1798
02:51:22,840 --> 02:51:23,940
that those questions are enforced.

1799
02:51:24,040 --> 02:51:27,340
The next time that we are looking at this before we file it

1800
02:51:27,340 --> 02:51:33,000
state legislature to ensure that we're all in sync with what it is that we can and may not do with

1801
02:51:33,000 --> 02:51:37,440
this petition. But again, I'm in favor of that. I had filed some of this, but I think there's

1802
02:51:37,440 --> 02:51:42,540
some on answer questions. Thank you, Councillor Nolan. Councillor Nolan exercises are chartered

1803
02:51:42,540 --> 02:51:45,700
on city manager agenda item number 11.

1804
02:51:48,020 --> 02:51:52,520
At this time, I'll entertain a motion to suspend the rules

1805
02:51:52,520 --> 02:51:59,560
to bring forward late communication late city manager agenda item and I'm going to

1806
02:52:00,080 --> 02:52:05,480
I'm going to other items I'm going to go to go to the co-chair of the ordinance committee

1807
02:52:05,480 --> 02:52:07,340
Council from the government.

1808
02:52:08,220 --> 02:52:08,760
Excuse me.

1809
02:52:08,820 --> 02:52:09,520
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

1810
02:52:09,720 --> 02:52:10,500
Through you.

1811
02:52:10,840 --> 02:52:15,020
There's a number of things we can do right now to bring Cambridge Street in front of us.

1812
02:52:15,960 --> 02:52:16,040
So.

1813
02:52:16,920 --> 02:52:22,820
I'd like to move first to suspend the rules to bring forward the late communication from the city manager,

1814
02:52:23,580 --> 02:52:30,780
as well as the late communication from other city officers filed by yourself and Councilor Nolan.

1815
02:52:31,820 --> 02:52:35,020
Who do roll call on bringing forward those two items?

1816
02:52:42,330 --> 02:52:43,410
I'm sorry, Clara.

1817
02:52:43,650 --> 02:52:44,650
Are you Councilor Azubi?

1818
02:52:45,050 --> 02:52:45,490
Yes.

1819
02:52:45,890 --> 02:52:46,210
Yes.

1820
02:52:46,250 --> 02:52:47,030
Vice Mayor Azim?

1821
02:52:47,390 --> 02:52:47,710
Yes.

1822
02:52:48,130 --> 02:52:48,510
Yes.

1823
02:52:48,510 --> 02:52:49,530
Council of the Flaherty?

1824
02:52:49,590 --> 02:52:49,930
Yes.

1825
02:52:49,930 --> 02:52:58,070
Yes, Council of McGuvern? Yes. Yes, Councilor Nolan? Yes. Yes, Councilor Simmons? Yes.

1826
02:52:58,070 --> 02:53:04,770
Yes, Councilor Sabrina Wheeler? Yes. Yes, Councilor Zucy? Yes. Yes. Yes, Mayor Sediki? Yes. Yes.

1827
02:53:04,770 --> 02:53:10,990
And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative. So we have the lead. The need manager agenda item.

1828
02:53:11,970 --> 02:53:14,290
That's the revisions to Cambridge Street.

1829
02:53:14,290 --> 02:53:21,170
So any petition and the communications from other city officers, we have one more vote council member govern?

1830
02:53:21,750 --> 02:53:25,330
Yeah, I think we should move suspension to bring forward.

1831
02:53:25,950 --> 02:53:30,370
But we have to vote to take the chambered street zoning off the table.

1832
02:53:30,750 --> 02:53:34,110
So I like to move suspension to do that.

1833
02:53:34,610 --> 02:53:36,030
Councilor Alzubi.

1834
02:53:36,370 --> 02:53:36,550
Yes.

1835
02:53:37,170 --> 02:53:37,570
Yes.

1836
02:53:37,590 --> 02:53:38,550
Vice Mayor Zene.

1837
02:53:39,530 --> 02:53:40,830
Council of Larrady.

1838
02:53:41,770 --> 02:53:41,790
Yes.

1839
02:53:41,790 --> 02:53:42,090
Yes.

1840
02:53:43,190 --> 02:53:47,170
Yes. Yes, Councillor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1841
02:53:47,270 --> 02:53:49,630
Councillor Simmons. Yes. Yes.

1842
02:53:50,010 --> 02:53:52,530
Councillor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes.

1843
02:53:52,790 --> 02:53:56,270
Councillor Susie. Yes. Yes.

1844
02:53:56,290 --> 02:53:56,970
Yes. Yes. Yes.

1845
02:53:58,250 --> 02:54:00,310
And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

1846
02:54:02,810 --> 02:54:05,270
Madam Mayor, I'll turn it back to you for discussion.

1847
02:54:06,150 --> 02:54:07,450
And then depending on how that goes,

1848
02:54:07,450 --> 02:54:12,510
they're potential other votes after that. Great. Thank you, Councillor. We're

1849
02:54:12,510 --> 02:54:18,810
governed. So we have multiple items before us. We have the City Manager

1850
02:54:21,450 --> 02:54:26,210
late. The revisions. We have the communication from other city officers. The actual

1851
02:54:26,210 --> 02:54:30,030
petition itself. I'll go to Councillor Nolan to talk about the communication from

1852
02:54:30,030 --> 02:54:34,650
other city officers. Thank you. But before we do that, Mayor

1853
02:54:34,650 --> 02:54:39,090
to seek the late communication from city manager.

1854
02:54:39,750 --> 02:54:44,930
Is that on grant a kiss or whatever the new system is?

1855
02:54:45,010 --> 02:54:47,110
I'm just making sure that we all have access to it.

1856
02:54:47,310 --> 02:54:49,090
Or was it email to us or?

1857
02:54:49,110 --> 02:54:51,970
Yeah, it was for very-

1858
02:54:51,970 --> 02:54:56,550
I'm just having trouble seeing it on the regular screen now,

1859
02:54:56,550 --> 02:54:57,850
but I know it was email to us separately.

1860
02:54:57,990 --> 02:54:59,310
So I guess we could just use that.

1861
02:55:01,770 --> 02:55:08,410
Yes, all of us should have it and remind our standing that it was also on the

1862
02:55:10,790 --> 02:55:15,410
We can have Naya, we pull it up as well, or someone.

1863
02:55:18,640 --> 02:55:20,140
Can you imagine if you want to say anything?

1864
02:55:20,320 --> 02:55:25,240
Through your university, I believe the meeting portal is updated,

1865
02:55:25,660 --> 02:55:31,760
and so it is showing up as an agenda item number 12 on the city manager's agenda,

1866
02:55:32,340 --> 02:55:33,160
but it did go off late.

1867
02:55:37,250 --> 02:55:39,990
Okay, thank you.

1868
02:55:43,760 --> 02:55:49,040
Yeah, so if I think all of our colleagues receiving as part of the agenda may or

1869
02:55:49,040 --> 02:55:52,480
seducing I worked on the chemistry petition.

1870
02:55:52,680 --> 02:55:57,740
This is a compromise from what was originally on the agenda.

1871
02:55:58,500 --> 02:56:02,480
There's a it's laid out in the memo company in this.

1872
02:56:02,480 --> 02:56:09,380
these zoning changes which respond to many of the community feedback that we have, this is

1873
02:56:10,440 --> 02:56:18,180
as in any time we take on a very important and also quite far reaching zoning

1874
02:56:19,300 --> 02:56:24,040
conversation across the city. There are a range of voices. There are people who would like

1875
02:56:24,040 --> 02:56:30,420
something the original or something even more aggressive. There are people who want nothing. There are

1876
02:56:30,420 --> 02:56:32,340
people who wants everything in between.

1877
02:56:33,000 --> 02:56:38,260
And thank you, Mayor Siddiqui, for working with me on what seems to me to be, and I hope

1878
02:56:38,260 --> 02:56:44,580
the council agrees, to be a reasonable compromise of ensuring that a development can happen

1879
02:56:44,580 --> 02:56:48,820
and will happen in line with many of the goals of the community, including some additional

1880
02:56:48,820 --> 02:56:51,480
setbacks, some open space, allowing housing.

1881
02:56:51,960 --> 02:56:58,540
We have already put in place the process by which we would look at ground floor retail, which

1882
02:56:58,540 --> 02:57:10,360
was something that Jason Alex from the East Cambridge Business Association, many of the other small business owners, Patrick McGee, also signed a letter, encouraged us to pass these amendments and then pass the zoning instead of waiting.

1883
02:57:11,100 --> 02:57:18,540
I know there are many people who are disappointed that I have said that when these, if these amendments pass that I will be supporting the,

1884
02:57:18,540 --> 02:57:23,280
the underlying zoning petition instead of letting it expire.

1885
02:57:23,840 --> 02:57:30,280
We can always improve things and I don't believe in acting in a way that is

1886
02:57:30,280 --> 02:57:32,260
Capricious or just too quickly.

1887
02:57:32,440 --> 02:57:34,820
However, this process has been going on for several years.

1888
02:57:35,260 --> 02:57:41,360
These amendments are very much in line with the R Cambridge State Work that a huge range of people in the city were involved in.

1889
02:57:41,580 --> 02:57:44,680
So I'm very glad that we are presenting this to the council.

1890
02:57:44,680 --> 02:57:49,480
we hope that they pass so that we can more than as a city and adopt the petition tonight,

1891
02:57:49,660 --> 02:57:54,500
which before it expires, and then move on to a range of other issues that the city is facing.

1892
02:57:54,520 --> 02:57:58,680
I'm going to trip you want me to go on to more detail on this. Mayor Sediki, it is laid out

1893
02:57:58,680 --> 02:58:02,400
in a memo, but I'm happy to talk a little bit more about it. That isn't raised by our colleagues

1894
02:58:02,400 --> 02:58:03,860
in the ensuing discussion.

1895
02:58:06,080 --> 02:58:10,840
Thank you, Councillor Nolan. You know, I think we can open it up.

1896
02:58:11,380 --> 02:58:21,840
two questions and comments. So I have confidence in. Thank you, Madam Mayor. So happy to support

1897
02:58:21,840 --> 02:58:29,900
these amendments. I did want to say that, you know, from my perspective, it's a very, very mild improvement

1898
02:58:29,900 --> 02:58:35,240
over the current zoning. You know, Cambridge Street is already six stories. This would keep it six stories. The leach

1899
02:58:35,240 --> 02:58:40,820
your parcel, you know, before it was 15 in the Cambridge Street Study was 12 this would bring

1900
02:58:40,820 --> 02:58:46,540
you down to 10 but already it's been zoned or permitted for six at 11 and a half percent inclusionary.

1901
02:58:46,800 --> 02:58:51,340
So the odds that someone would re permitted at 20 just to get to 10 which is kind of a dead zone

1902
02:58:51,340 --> 02:58:57,720
I think is unlikely. The only, I think, new housing work expected to get from this is the

1903
02:58:57,720 --> 02:59:03,180
Webster Street parcel which is something but also I would say that, you know, with this plus the

1904
02:59:03,180 --> 02:59:09,500
changes open space and the follow-up will do on first floor retail, which is even less profitable

1905
02:59:09,500 --> 02:59:15,340
than housing, means that overall, I think that Cambridge Street, once it's all done, will make housing

1906
02:59:15,340 --> 02:59:22,820
harder to pencil in the city, not easier. Having said that, a lot of work has been done by city staff,

1907
02:59:23,140 --> 02:59:28,380
this is now more restricted than the Cambridge Street study presented, and I think that it's important

1908
02:59:28,380 --> 02:59:33,180
for us to, you know, feel like we finished our process, even if I'm not entirely excited

1909
02:59:33,180 --> 02:59:38,260
about the results, but, you know, thank you to Councillor Nolan and Mayor Siddiqui for coming

1910
02:59:38,260 --> 02:59:41,640
together and trying to get us something that helps us get this over the finish line.

1911
02:59:43,700 --> 02:59:47,480
Hi, we'll go to Councillor Gibbons Arena Wheeler.

1912
03:00:00,000 --> 03:00:04,040
Madam Mayor, believe other folks out there can't stop if anybody wants to go first. I'm happy to go.

1913
03:00:05,200 --> 03:00:11,320
I really appreciate the amendment from Councillor Nolan and sort of the thought that went to it.

1914
03:00:11,380 --> 03:00:14,900
Just briefly on the amendment itself that I'm, we'll be at a note for the same reasons.

1915
03:00:14,980 --> 03:00:23,400
I was the know on the previous amendment and the amendment on Massav and that's because anything above six stories is in the range where we're getting inclusionary housing.

1916
03:00:23,620 --> 03:00:28,180
So if we're reducing from eight stories to six stories, those are two stories where we're going to be getting affordable housing.

1917
03:00:28,180 --> 03:00:34,940
I just can't cautionably reduce that. I do expect the amendment will pass that and so on the underlying

1918
03:00:34,940 --> 03:00:39,220
petition, you know, I have spent a bunch of time over the last few weeks and months

1919
03:00:39,220 --> 03:00:43,580
looking at the current buildings on Cambridge Street, looking at the lot sizes on Cambridge Street,

1920
03:00:43,740 --> 03:00:47,580
looking at the city's building permit log to see what is being built under the current zoning

1921
03:00:47,580 --> 03:00:52,560
that log is all online in public. I think the important context for this discussion tonight

1922
03:00:52,560 --> 03:00:57,060
is that whether this proposal passes or not, buildings are going to continue to be redeveloped on

1923
03:00:57,060 --> 03:01:01,680
like they are now, whether the council does anything or if we just, we just call it an A right now,

1924
03:01:01,800 --> 03:01:05,640
buildings are going to keep happening. The choice is not between development and no development.

1925
03:01:05,880 --> 03:01:10,760
The choice is between shorter buildings that are 100% market rate, which is what we're getting now,

1926
03:01:10,980 --> 03:01:14,240
or slightly taller buildings that are going to create hundreds of new affordable homes.

1927
03:01:15,180 --> 03:01:20,920
The buildings that are being now are like the one I came up with my research on Cambridge Street.

1928
03:01:20,940 --> 03:01:24,160
It's right near the King Open School in the Valente Library branch.

1929
03:01:24,160 --> 03:01:29,420
was built in 2024. You can find it on the city's development log and on Zillow if you're curious

1930
03:01:29,420 --> 03:01:34,500
which one exactly I'm talking about. It's a six unit, four story building, it replaced the

1931
03:01:34,500 --> 03:01:40,200
existing building and each of the units in that building was built recently, sold for around

1932
03:01:40,200 --> 03:01:46,440
a million dollars or more. One of them sold for 1.75 million dollars which the vast majority of

1933
03:01:46,440 --> 03:01:51,060
folks in Cambridge cannot afford and that building had zero affordable housing in it because it was

1934
03:01:51,060 --> 03:01:55,180
less than 10 units, which is where the city's inclusionary zoning picks in.

1935
03:01:55,680 --> 03:01:59,220
That is what's being built right now, and that's when it's going to continue to get built on

1936
03:01:59,220 --> 03:02:02,820
Cambridge Street if we take no action, $1 million units and no affordable housing.

1937
03:02:03,420 --> 03:02:07,000
The affordable housing overlay that we've passed has worked really well in a lot of places.

1938
03:02:07,020 --> 03:02:10,100
It has not worked on quarters like Cambridge Street for a number of reasons.

1939
03:02:10,440 --> 03:02:15,440
We've not seen a HO projects there, and there's basically no IZ units there being built on Cambridge Street.

1940
03:02:15,680 --> 03:02:20,460
When we talked about the multifamily housing ordinance to end exclusionary zoning last term.

1941
03:02:20,460 --> 03:02:23,340
There are many folks who argued it wouldn't actually lead to affordable housing,

1942
03:02:23,740 --> 03:02:28,200
that is not what's happened in a reality. We've seen lots of six-story buildings with affordable

1943
03:02:28,200 --> 03:02:31,820
housing and them being proposed even under the current economic conditions.

1944
03:02:32,220 --> 03:02:35,260
Anything with the objections we're hearing at that there's too many six-story buildings

1945
03:02:35,260 --> 03:02:39,740
with affordable housing being proposed and we should have shorter buildings that are all market rate.

1946
03:02:39,860 --> 03:02:44,420
And I disagree with that. There's no reason to think that we would see different

1947
03:02:44,420 --> 03:02:48,560
result here on Cambridge Street where the lots are similar sizes and corridors are more

1948
03:02:48,560 --> 03:02:52,060
effective for taller buildings. This is the place that everybody says. We should be having taller

1949
03:02:52,060 --> 03:02:57,580
buildings. That's where we're going to see taller buildings with affordable housing. I appreciate

1950
03:02:59,480 --> 03:03:05,200
the amendment from Councillor Nolan and really worked to engage on this and figure out how to get

1951
03:03:05,200 --> 03:03:10,460
to yes. I think the main concerns I heard the last few times we talked about this was that about the

1952
03:03:10,460 --> 03:03:17,340
height. Eight stories being total. Parts was being total. That's been addressed. The local businesses

1953
03:03:17,340 --> 03:03:21,480
might be impacted. The local business association as we've heard tonight is in favor of this.

1954
03:03:22,840 --> 03:03:26,400
With the the amendments that the concerns that folks get bring a report were addressed.

1955
03:03:26,680 --> 03:03:29,740
So when it comes to say they would really like to vote for a proposal because they care about

1956
03:03:29,740 --> 03:03:34,240
affordable housing, but they can't because they're there's an important concern and then the the concern

1957
03:03:34,240 --> 03:03:38,420
gets addressed. And then then there's another concern. It begins to be a little like

1958
03:03:38,420 --> 03:03:41,780
sort of Lucy in the football from Charlie Brown sort of pulling it out the last minute.

1959
03:03:42,080 --> 03:03:46,240
If you say what you want more housing and corridors, but this isn't quite right. You come

1960
03:03:46,240 --> 03:03:49,560
bring an amendment work on it. I really appreciate Councillor Nolan for doing that.

1961
03:03:49,700 --> 03:03:52,220
I mean, the reason similar reason we passed the multi-family housing ordinance,

1962
03:03:52,400 --> 03:03:55,620
eight to one was not because we had city counselors totally in lockstap,

1963
03:03:55,700 --> 03:03:59,200
because we worked together and we had amendments and changes and we got to something.

1964
03:04:00,080 --> 03:04:04,680
I think the last piece I want to make on this was something I've been thinking about a lot recently,

1965
03:04:04,980 --> 03:04:08,800
you know, in the last term there was a vote to delay bike lanes on Cambridge Street and the

1966
03:04:08,800 --> 03:04:14,080
arguments and favor of not making any changes there was that needed more time for study and

1967
03:04:14,080 --> 03:04:18,520
progress before we did any changes to Cambridge Street. I listened to those arguments, I heard

1968
03:04:18,520 --> 03:04:22,340
them, I sat with them, but I voted against that delay because I have gotten to know a number

1969
03:04:22,340 --> 03:04:26,720
of people whose loved ones were killed by King on Cambridge Street. I could not bear to be responsible

1970
03:04:26,720 --> 03:04:33,880
for another death due to delay. We know this will create more affordable housing, which is the

1971
03:04:33,880 --> 03:04:37,600
main question I need answered, and it feels hypocritical for me to vote for an additional delay

1972
03:04:37,600 --> 03:04:43,340
here when we know the answer already. The people who need affordable housing are just as important to

1973
03:04:43,340 --> 03:04:48,260
every month, every week, every day matters to that person whose life could be changed by having a affordable housing.

1974
03:04:49,000 --> 03:04:53,200
I gave this a little more time from December because we had another big proposal on North Mass Ave.

1975
03:04:53,700 --> 03:04:54,980
We've given that more time.

1976
03:04:55,760 --> 03:04:59,980
We're not getting any more housing on Cambridge Street under the status quo, and I can't defend that.

1977
03:05:02,680 --> 03:05:20,260
Thank you, Mayor Siddiqui. I have a couple points of information. So, one, someone brought up during public testimony that with the six stories, does that, would that be for admin square as well? So, that's one question.

1978
03:05:20,260 --> 03:05:31,820
And another is a question, is some have suggested that there wouldn't be inclusionary at six stories?

1979
03:05:33,500 --> 03:05:42,960
And is that true or not? And then third of all, will we be discussing the overall zoning proposal for Cambridge Street afterwards?

1980
03:05:42,960 --> 03:05:50,060
should I be sharing all my thoughts about the proposal right here and now. So those are my three questions.

1981
03:05:50,980 --> 03:05:58,940
So this is the space for all of it. Okay, so can you maybe through you Mayor City,

1982
03:05:59,160 --> 03:06:07,640
can you maybe Assistant City Manager Peters can answer whether this whether Inmond Square would be

1983
03:06:07,640 --> 03:06:10,680
Six stories or eight stories with this amendment?

1984
03:06:11,720 --> 03:06:16,080
Yes, thank you for the question, Councillor Zuzzi, through you, Mayor Siddiqui,

1985
03:06:16,400 --> 03:06:20,920
Invin Square, under this revised petition text, is that six stories?

1986
03:06:21,700 --> 03:06:27,700
Okay, so everything is six stories except for Webster Windsor, which would be ten to twelve

1987
03:06:27,700 --> 03:06:29,960
and then Leachmeer would be ten.

1988
03:06:29,960 --> 03:06:30,480
this thought.

1989
03:06:30,860 --> 03:06:37,520
Webster, Webster Windsor would be at 12, and then bleach merit is at 10 under these proposed amendments.

1990
03:06:38,080 --> 03:06:44,540
Okay. Great. And then maybe through you, Mayor Sadiki, maybe for our solicitor, or

1991
03:06:44,540 --> 03:06:50,320
one of our solicitors, I'd love to understand, so there, some have suggested that, you

1992
03:06:50,320 --> 03:06:58,560
know, so we know currently when we pass multi-family housing, or when you pass multi-family

1993
03:06:58,560 --> 03:07:05,940
housing that the six stories along all our quarters, all of the quarters were upzoned so that

1994
03:07:05,940 --> 03:07:14,520
we would still be incentivizing taller buildings on the quarters. So the question is, so are we

1995
03:07:14,520 --> 03:07:23,680
so is it still if you're building six stories two stories or 20% is inclusionary or is that not

1996
03:07:23,680 --> 03:07:29,960
part of the six stories on Cambridge Street now.

1997
03:07:32,060 --> 03:07:37,880
So, so maybe I'll take the first attempt at that in Solster Bear, can jump in as needed.

1998
03:07:38,720 --> 03:07:47,040
But the current inclusionary zoning ordinance, as you know, applies for any project over 10,000 square feet or 10 units.

1999
03:07:47,040 --> 03:07:52,040
It's part of the conversation around this Cambridge Street in the Mass Ave,

2000
03:07:52,400 --> 03:07:53,100
Resonings.

2001
03:07:53,980 --> 03:07:58,240
The City Council contemplated an amendment that we've included in this draft,

2002
03:07:58,460 --> 03:08:05,060
that would require projects over six stories to be subject to inclusionary,

2003
03:08:05,280 --> 03:08:10,180
regardless if they met that 10,000 square foot threshold.

2004
03:08:10,540 --> 03:08:13,680
So that would require projects to be inclusionary.

2005
03:08:13,680 --> 03:08:19,600
I did want to note that, you know, there's been a lot of talk that a lot of projects

2006
03:08:19,600 --> 03:08:27,540
could, you know, we'll go up to six stories or five stories without meeting the inclusionary

2007
03:08:27,540 --> 03:08:34,140
zoning requirement. Given the size of the parcels that we consider soft size or

2008
03:08:34,140 --> 03:08:40,480
developmental sites, we are quite significantly over that 10,000 square foot threshold. So

2009
03:08:40,480 --> 03:08:45,600
There's always a case where someone could significantly underbuild their site, but just given

2010
03:08:45,600 --> 03:08:52,760
the likelihood in the developers' desire to maximize development potential, we do think

2011
03:08:52,760 --> 03:08:59,120
it's going to be over 10,000 square feet, and then certainly with this additional requirement

2012
03:08:59,120 --> 03:09:02,360
and includes rezoning would be required.

2013
03:09:03,920 --> 03:09:08,380
Okay, again, through you, Mayor City, thank you.

2014
03:09:08,580 --> 03:09:12,200
Assistant City Manager, Peter, so much for that,

2015
03:09:12,200 --> 03:09:13,920
explain or that clarification.

2016
03:09:15,900 --> 03:09:20,540
So, so it's likely that some affordable units will be built

2017
03:09:20,540 --> 03:09:24,520
but we don't have any calculated calculation of how many,

2018
03:09:25,400 --> 03:09:29,040
we're not, we have no idea how much affordable

2019
03:09:29,120 --> 03:09:34,860
units will be built, right? And if people are building over six stories, so this would

2020
03:09:34,860 --> 03:09:39,420
allow people to build over six stories. So if they want to build over six stories,

2021
03:09:39,920 --> 03:09:45,260
then do they have what do they have? If they want to go to eight stories and build inclusionary

2022
03:09:45,260 --> 03:09:54,100
units, what reviews would they have to, they wouldn't need a special permit to what was they

2023
03:09:54,100 --> 03:09:55,740
to go through.

2024
03:09:56,420 --> 03:09:59,980
Yeah, thank you for your mayor, City G.

2025
03:10:00,000 --> 03:10:12,220
So, the special permit, threshold, kicks in at 75,000 square feet. So, projects exceed that, they would have to go at the planning board for a special permit.

2026
03:10:12,920 --> 03:10:26,480
We do have design review at different thresholds. So, all of these projects would go through staff review and different degrees of advisory or project review with staff and public meetings.

2027
03:10:28,740 --> 03:10:39,360
What I don't understand though is if the street is zone for six stories, if someone wanted to go to eight stories, what would they have to do?

2028
03:10:39,940 --> 03:10:42,340
The street is zone for six stories.

2029
03:10:42,340 --> 03:10:45,760
Yes, so thank you for clarifying the question.

2030
03:10:46,320 --> 03:10:53,700
So if this proposed amendment were to pass and the cap was six stories, you could not go

2031
03:10:53,700 --> 03:10:57,000
to eight stories regardless if you were to get an additional permit.

2032
03:10:57,160 --> 03:10:58,860
So six stories would be the cap.

2033
03:10:59,960 --> 03:11:07,320
Except in those, again, those two areas on Cambridge Street that we've said could go potentially

2034
03:11:07,320 --> 03:11:08,600
up to 10 or 12.

2035
03:11:08,600 --> 03:11:15,260
So, but if long the corridor and men's square, if you could only build up to six stories.

2036
03:11:16,600 --> 03:11:20,380
So, there would not be any inclusionary units in this story building.

2037
03:11:20,460 --> 03:11:22,240
So, unless they're over 10,000 square feet.

2038
03:11:22,580 --> 03:11:23,600
That's correct.

2039
03:11:23,920 --> 03:11:23,940
Correct.

2040
03:11:25,580 --> 03:11:26,960
So, here's, okay.

2041
03:11:27,320 --> 03:11:34,320
So, over the weekend, I attended the Mass Municipal Association meeting at the Convention Center in Boston.

2042
03:11:34,320 --> 03:11:39,440
And so I was walking down Summer Street, which is a much wider street.

2043
03:11:39,660 --> 03:11:41,880
It's about the width of MassAv.

2044
03:11:42,460 --> 03:11:45,860
So it's 90, I guess MassAv isn't about 100 feet or anyway.

2045
03:11:47,080 --> 03:11:48,920
Summer Street is 98 feet.

2046
03:11:49,140 --> 03:11:50,780
So it's a very broad avenue.

2047
03:11:51,720 --> 03:11:57,980
And there are beautiful brick buildings there that are five story, six stories, seven stories.

2048
03:11:58,020 --> 03:12:02,840
And then of course there's some taller buildings as you get deeper into the support district.

2049
03:12:02,840 --> 03:12:12,760
But what walking down that street made me realize is, like those buildings really looked handsome on that wide street.

2050
03:12:13,480 --> 03:12:24,360
But I really worry about Cambridge Street. I think I also walked Cambridge Street on a very, very cold day last week.

2051
03:12:24,360 --> 03:12:34,900
And we were walking on the south side of the street, and it was very cold, but we had sun because the buildings on the other side of the street were lower.

2052
03:12:35,660 --> 03:12:37,460
So we could still be in the sunlight.

2053
03:12:37,700 --> 03:12:51,000
So what I'm aware of since it's an east west street, that if we build Cambridge Street taller, like to even six stories, we really need setbacks.

2054
03:12:51,000 --> 03:13:01,860
A setback would allow for light to penetrate the street so that it isn't a dark corridor in the winter.

2055
03:13:02,360 --> 03:13:08,000
So I do worry about that and I feel like the proper from my walk of Cambridge Street.

2056
03:13:08,600 --> 03:13:18,660
I really feel as though for or six stories or four stories with a ten-foot stepback is what would really be best for Cambridge Street.

2057
03:13:18,660 --> 03:13:24,320
But I realize that is an under consideration at this point.

2058
03:13:24,320 --> 03:13:27,120
I think six stories is much better than eight stories.

2059
03:13:27,940 --> 03:13:32,960
But I think that the step back at four stories will really be critical.

2060
03:13:34,440 --> 03:13:40,400
What I worry about, the other thing that's come to my realization is like how much I love

2061
03:13:40,400 --> 03:13:41,220
Cambridge Street.

2062
03:13:41,680 --> 03:13:47,820
Because I think I feel like it's the last vestige of a street with local retail

2063
03:13:47,820 --> 03:14:02,660
in the city. I mean, it's rich with local retail. It's rich with ethnic businesses, you know, organizations, residents, there's a great diversity there.

2064
03:15:00,000 --> 03:15:07,580
Developers without any guarantee of the production of affordable units or any community benefits.

2065
03:15:08,460 --> 03:15:18,520
I feel as though it's too much that we're giving away. I do think it makes sense to have more height in the Webster Windsor area.

2066
03:15:18,800 --> 03:15:22,920
I really appreciate that as a place that could use more height.

2067
03:15:22,920 --> 03:15:28,140
And I think you could have more height at Leachmeer, though I feel for the people in the

2068
03:15:28,140 --> 03:15:31,760
chocolate factory across the street, because they're like, well, be blocked.

2069
03:15:32,000 --> 03:15:36,160
I mean, I really hope DIVCO West does build a sixth story building there, because I do

2070
03:15:36,160 --> 03:15:41,240
think it would be more in keeping with neighborhood.

2071
03:15:41,800 --> 03:15:47,760
And I worry about all the concerns Cambridge Street residents have shared.

2072
03:15:48,060 --> 03:15:49,980
They're already as a lot of congestion.

2073
03:15:49,980 --> 03:15:54,900
There's a great concern about no parking minimum and adding density to the street.

2074
03:15:55,240 --> 03:15:57,400
There's a, you know, concerns about labs.

2075
03:15:58,220 --> 03:16:04,440
I, I, I will support this amendment because I think six stories is better than eight stories.

2076
03:16:04,980 --> 03:16:11,740
But overall, I, I think we should, like, wait a month.

2077
03:16:11,920 --> 03:16:15,240
Maybe this should go to neighborhood and long-term planning for further discussion.

2078
03:16:15,240 --> 03:16:20,660
But I think we should work out the kinks of the zoning and like consider the step-backs

2079
03:16:21,200 --> 03:16:26,740
Consider other things people have discussed like they're really worried about the wet labs apparently

2080
03:16:26,740 --> 03:16:29,240
They're already arson wet labs on Cambridge street

2081
03:16:31,000 --> 03:16:33,740
So residents don't want them there

2082
03:16:34,460 --> 03:16:42,940
I think we should make sure we're gonna get inclusionary units. I think we should make sure that we're gonna get that first floor retail

2083
03:16:44,120 --> 03:16:49,940
I think the ideas residents have shared during public testimony about saying

2084
03:16:51,760 --> 03:16:58,860
smaller, requiring smaller ground floor retail should be part of the zoning way pass.

2085
03:16:59,520 --> 03:17:03,220
And we do want to discourage banks and larger businesses.

2086
03:17:03,780 --> 03:17:09,380
So putting in something about you can't have huge spaces for banks.

2087
03:17:09,400 --> 03:17:11,920
I think that would be important to include as well.

2088
03:17:11,920 --> 03:17:19,060
So, again, I will support this amendment because I think six stories is much better for

2089
03:17:19,060 --> 03:17:20,680
then eight stories on that street.

2090
03:17:20,680 --> 03:17:25,060
I think when we think about up zoning, we have to really think about the context of the

2091
03:17:25,060 --> 03:17:37,040
neighborhood and the access of the street and look at shadow studies and I wish, assistant

2092
03:17:37,040 --> 03:17:40,600
city manager, Peter's, I wish, I think it's really important.

2093
03:17:40,600 --> 03:17:45,940
And I know you've got the tools to share what the street would look like at four stories,

2094
03:17:46,120 --> 03:17:50,500
what it would look like at six stories, what it would look like with the ten foot step back

2095
03:17:50,500 --> 03:17:54,360
at four stories, what it would look like at eight stories, what it would look like with ten

2096
03:17:54,360 --> 03:17:54,580
stories.

2097
03:17:54,700 --> 03:18:00,300
I think it's really important that you as the head of the planning department share those

2098
03:18:00,300 --> 03:18:01,320
images with us.

2099
03:18:01,480 --> 03:18:06,040
So we understand the implications of the zoning that we're considering.

2100
03:18:06,040 --> 03:18:10,680
And then also it would be good to have stats to really better understand.

2101
03:18:11,500 --> 03:18:15,900
I thought I actually really thought that our Cambridge Street study was strong.

2102
03:18:16,560 --> 03:18:20,720
But you know what it talks about is the goals are support small businesses.

2103
03:18:20,920 --> 03:18:25,260
And I worry this will force them out.

2104
03:18:25,340 --> 03:18:28,560
It'll improve mobility while our bike lanes will improve mobility.

2105
03:18:29,060 --> 03:18:32,120
It'll increase housing supply, especially affordable housing.

2106
03:18:32,120 --> 03:18:47,020
But again, it doesn't look like we're going to be increasing affordable housing, increase public open space. I don't see this increasing public open space that seems like we need to be adding a 15% requirement for open space.

2107
03:18:47,020 --> 03:18:54,300
have a few people anyway. So those are my thoughts. I am committed to

2108
03:18:55,340 --> 03:19:01,320
up zoning or coming up with thoughtful zoning for Cambridge Street, but I don't think we're there

2109
03:19:01,320 --> 03:19:08,060
and I think we should hold off. Let this petition expire and and be a little bit more thoughtful

2110
03:19:08,060 --> 03:19:13,060
and then push something through in the next month or two with the corrections that people

2111
03:19:13,060 --> 03:19:17,880
recommend it. Thank you, I yield. We'll go to Councilor Zubi and Councilor Mugover next.

2112
03:19:19,420 --> 03:19:24,020
Thank you, Mayor Sediki. I'm going to specifically speak on the amendment piece and later on

2113
03:19:24,020 --> 03:19:30,680
the final petition after we vote on this amendment for clarity. I want to share why I will abstain

2114
03:19:30,680 --> 03:19:35,200
on this amendment. I currently don't feel like I've been a part of the process around the

2115
03:19:35,200 --> 03:19:41,200
zoning petition and my concerns are deeper than just the height of the buildings. I'm right now

2116
03:19:41,200 --> 03:19:46,780
focused on who gets to benefit from the new buildings, not just how tall they are, I appreciate

2117
03:19:46,780 --> 03:19:52,280
that a last minute deal has been struck and that this will likely move forward tonight, but

2118
03:19:52,280 --> 03:19:57,440
that's not how I think we should do this work and it's not how I hope we do this work going forward

2119
03:19:57,440 --> 03:19:59,980
and again, I'd love to speak to the overall-

2120
03:20:00,000 --> 03:20:08,940
Sure, yeah. So on the second half of the overall petition, and again, I really purchased from the side of clarity for residents to understand the two pieces.

2121
03:20:09,940 --> 03:20:16,900
I also want to be clear about why I will be voting no on the overall zoning petition tonight over the last few weeks.

2122
03:20:17,060 --> 03:20:24,940
Things have been very intensive listening to community perspectives understanding the particulars of this petition, getting up to speed on zoning more broadly.

2123
03:20:24,940 --> 03:20:31,240
I mean, I'm I'm grateful to have had the opportunity to weigh in and disrupt the status quo on housing in our city

2124
03:20:31,760 --> 03:20:35,900
But with that said, I don't feel like I've been a part of this process thoroughly enough

2125
03:20:35,900 --> 03:20:39,740
I would have appreciated a committee hearing time pack the issue

2126
03:20:39,740 --> 03:20:44,800
But I also understand that you all went through that last term and that there's a desire to finish this tonight

2127
03:20:44,800 --> 03:20:50,480
It's just hard for me right now to coast sign on a process that I was in part of that I didn't help shape

2128
03:20:50,480 --> 03:20:54,900
Especially when there are concerns about how it went and pieces that aren't in the zoning

2129
03:20:54,940 --> 03:20:57,040
and I can't ignore those in good faith.

2130
03:20:57,880 --> 03:21:02,460
My thinking is more fundamental than how tall the buildings will be.

2131
03:21:03,020 --> 03:21:07,060
I want us to think more about who will ultimately benefit from the buildings,

2132
03:21:07,560 --> 03:21:08,680
the affordability aspect.

2133
03:21:09,120 --> 03:21:11,820
I want us to consider working-class people in our city,

2134
03:21:12,180 --> 03:21:14,480
our educators, our service workers and others,

2135
03:21:14,820 --> 03:21:17,580
who largely probably won't be able to benefit at all

2136
03:21:17,580 --> 03:21:19,820
outside of the subsidized units if they're built.

2137
03:21:20,760 --> 03:21:21,920
At the core of the issue,

2138
03:21:21,920 --> 03:21:31,320
I cannot vote to give developers additional value until I can tell our constituents with confidence that our 20% inclusionary housing will actually be delivered.

2139
03:21:32,040 --> 03:21:36,160
We must refuse to hand over massive development rates to private capital without that guarantee.

2140
03:21:36,800 --> 03:21:44,080
Our inclusionary zoning requirement is legally reliant on the economic justification study from 2016 that is now out of date.

2141
03:21:44,080 --> 03:21:52,020
And the new feasibility study arrives in just five months, that's June of 2026, and that's on top of the lawsuit we're now navigating.

2142
03:21:52,980 --> 03:21:59,740
So the next study arriving in June will likely show that the 20% is not economically justifiable under the conditions of this current moment.

2143
03:22:00,160 --> 03:22:08,340
And face with that, the Council will inevitably vote to lower the inclusionary percentage to whatever the study claims is just a file, which I'm quite concerned about.

2144
03:22:08,340 --> 03:22:16,220
And then the question on the promise for inclusionary zoning being at 20% in this zoning petition will pretty much evaporate.

2145
03:22:16,880 --> 03:22:23,000
What makes it really especially difficult for me to support this tonight is we're giving away our leverage for free.

2146
03:22:23,340 --> 03:22:27,980
The taller heights in additional density contemplated in this petition are incredibly valuable to developers.

2147
03:22:28,580 --> 03:22:34,280
And if we were to frame these as a density bonus, condition, condition explicitly on delivering 20% affordable housing,

2148
03:22:34,280 --> 03:22:40,400
And rather than giving them away in the base zoning, which we have under section 11.203,

2149
03:22:40,860 --> 03:22:44,980
we would preserve our ability to maintain that 20% requirement, even if the next study

2150
03:22:44,980 --> 03:22:46,600
forces us slower the base requirement.

2151
03:22:46,780 --> 03:22:49,740
I mean, we had this conversations even in the last year.

2152
03:22:50,300 --> 03:22:53,840
So under the density bonus framework developers who want to build these new heights would

2153
03:22:53,840 --> 03:22:58,300
have to deliver 20% of fortability, those that don't want to meet the threshold can build

2154
03:22:58,300 --> 03:23:02,640
to whatever the base zoning allows with whatever lower percentage the next study supports.

2155
03:23:02,640 --> 03:23:10,420
And this is one way we might actually be able to guarantee affordability outcomes, rather than making promises that we probably know will be broken.

2156
03:23:11,140 --> 03:23:18,440
20% is the minimum threshold we can accept for economically stratified buildings to also feel dignified and integrated.

2157
03:23:19,160 --> 03:23:27,980
And especially according to our own resident experience study, 50% of renters in inclusionary units reported experiencing bias where race was seen as the primary cause.

2158
03:23:27,980 --> 03:23:34,340
So it's obvious that as the buildings get more economically segregated by race and class, the potential for harm increases.

2159
03:23:35,500 --> 03:23:44,020
But I also just want to address directly the argument that waiting until June 2026 will delay housing production because for me, it's not about a delay.

2160
03:23:44,200 --> 03:23:45,580
It's about doing our due diligence.

2161
03:23:46,100 --> 03:23:49,740
Developers right now are waiting to see where inclusionary program lands.

2162
03:23:50,380 --> 03:23:56,980
And why would they move forward with projects under 20% requirement when they know that in five months we might just lower that to 12 or 15%.

2163
03:23:56,980 --> 03:24:03,360
percent. So in a way, our failure to resolve on this uncertainty is in itself freezing development.

2164
03:24:04,380 --> 03:24:09,860
The position acts as a subzone significant portions of Cambridge Street, which, again, gives developers

2165
03:24:09,860 --> 03:24:14,780
really go right to extract significantly more value from the land while the legal foundation for our

2166
03:24:14,780 --> 03:24:20,160
only community benefit is most likely crumbling beneath us. And I also want to just talk about

2167
03:24:20,160 --> 03:24:24,800
who benefits from rushing this through. It's not working class contributions who desperately need

2168
03:24:24,800 --> 03:24:28,860
affordable housing, it's not small developers who are frozen out by the market by financing

2169
03:24:28,860 --> 03:24:29,440
costs.

2170
03:24:29,460 --> 03:24:34,240
Anyways, it's landowners and large developers who want to lock in new development rights

2171
03:24:34,240 --> 03:24:38,620
before the inclusionary program is legally tested before we've had the chance to structure

2172
03:24:38,620 --> 03:24:40,160
this as a density bonus.

2173
03:24:40,920 --> 03:24:43,160
Right now, the alternative is right in front of us.

2174
03:25:00,000 --> 03:25:28,180
We have our own rep. My colleague, who's indicated that the state would entertain a proposal, as part of the June 2026 state capital budget, if something actionable were submitted. So we know that social housing is built by the public for the public remain inter remain for the public. And it's proven that it works, but it is available to us right now, if we choose to prioritize it. Yet in this policy order, the council that had passed last September, it was unceremoniously white from the awaiting report,

2175
03:25:28,180 --> 03:25:30,780
list without the report back from the manager that was requested.

2176
03:25:31,360 --> 03:25:35,700
The December hearing was informative, a good start, but produced no productive

2177
03:25:35,700 --> 03:25:40,800
progress from staff. I have to ask why because my assumption is most likely that

2178
03:25:40,800 --> 03:25:44,840
staff are being asked to spend all their time running from a zoning petition to another,

2179
03:25:45,480 --> 03:25:49,240
essentially chasing the false blagues that we can build our way out of the affordability crisis

2180
03:25:49,780 --> 03:25:54,900
through inclusionary zoning alone. So I'm hoping that we can spend the next five months prioritizing

2181
03:25:54,900 --> 03:25:59,040
social housing and getting a proposal together for the state capital budget. And when the next

2182
03:25:59,040 --> 03:26:04,100
study arrives in June, we have a serious conversation about restructuring our approach. And if we

2183
03:26:04,100 --> 03:26:09,540
aren't facing or focusing on solutions like social housing that actually decommodify housing and treated

2184
03:26:09,540 --> 03:26:14,360
as a human right, we'll almost be trading the line of reburining gentrification as abundance.

2185
03:26:15,080 --> 03:26:19,920
My bottom line is observing conversations are usually framed as creating opportunity for working

2186
03:26:19,920 --> 03:26:25,940
class people which can be true but oftentimes they serve profit and not people and right now

2187
03:26:25,940 --> 03:26:30,640
we're being asked to give away development rights while the only mechanism we have to ensure

2188
03:26:30,640 --> 03:26:37,320
community benefit is under intense legal and economic threat. The only emergency we're facing tonight

2189
03:26:37,320 --> 03:26:42,060
is again the affordable housing crisis as we all know and this potential this petition specifically

2190
03:26:42,060 --> 03:26:47,040
has written with the inclusionary requirement that will likely not be relevant in five months.

2191
03:26:47,040 --> 03:26:50,400
It is going to be making things worse by transferring

2192
03:26:50,400 --> 03:26:54,160
while to landowners without a guarantee of meaningful community benefits.

2193
03:26:54,760 --> 03:26:58,940
I'm open to voting yes on zoning proposals that deliver meaningful guaranteed community benefits.

2194
03:26:59,580 --> 03:27:04,600
I just need to feel confident with what we can deliver on affordability when proceeding with these.

2195
03:27:04,820 --> 03:27:07,960
And I don't think this petition does that for me right now at this time.

2196
03:27:08,060 --> 03:27:11,660
I know we can do better and we should all yield.

2197
03:27:12,100 --> 03:27:14,980
I'll go to a council member government and then a council authority.

2198
03:27:17,070 --> 03:27:19,030
Thank you, Madam Mayor, through you.

2199
03:27:19,970 --> 03:27:21,010
There's a lot here.

2200
03:27:21,770 --> 03:27:25,010
I had a statement that I'm going to go a little bit off that for a second.

2201
03:27:26,650 --> 03:27:32,650
First, I want to address the continued suggestion that rushing this through.

2202
03:27:33,710 --> 03:27:35,970
This is better conversation that's been going on for years.

2203
03:27:37,950 --> 03:27:41,690
And this council, this is why I felt it was important for the previous council

2204
03:27:41,690 --> 03:27:44,530
to take ownership of this good or bad

2205
03:27:45,070 --> 03:27:55,490
Because we were the ones that were doing the work and I understand that it's probably difficult if you are a new counselor to be coming on in the last minute and being asked to take a very difficult and controversial vote.

2206
03:27:56,670 --> 03:28:05,790
And so I still believe that we should have taken responsibility and people are going to get mad when I'm getting mad at us because we were the ones that have been doing this.

2207
03:28:06,590 --> 03:28:11,110
But that doesn't mean it's rushed and I don't believe that this has been rushed.

2208
03:28:13,330 --> 03:28:20,890
Second of all, you know, when we hear, when folks say, you know, I support building

2209
03:28:20,890 --> 03:28:26,810
more housing, but then list off 15 other things that they want addressed that make building

2210
03:28:26,810 --> 03:28:30,950
that housing impossible to actually build.

2211
03:28:32,330 --> 03:28:36,870
Not that those things are important, setbacks, setbacks, trees, all of those things.

2212
03:28:36,870 --> 03:28:45,890
But if you put so many requirements that you then make it impossible to build the housing,

2213
03:28:46,350 --> 03:28:50,110
you allegedly say you want, then you're not going to get it.

2214
03:28:50,610 --> 03:28:57,190
And no one zoning ordinance is going to solve all the hills that we have,

2215
03:28:57,230 --> 03:29:00,790
which is why we have to have multiple tools.

2216
03:29:01,450 --> 03:29:02,550
We need social housing.

2217
03:29:02,910 --> 03:29:04,230
We need inclusionary zoning.

2218
03:29:04,230 --> 03:29:15,010
we need market rent housing, so this ordinance is not necessarily going to solve every single problem that everybody has and that we all share.

2219
03:29:16,370 --> 03:29:31,890
So, I'll just say that, you know, I continue to believe we have a housing shortage, and I think that allowing eight stories on Cambridge Street would provide more homes for people, more customers for our local businesses, and more inclusionary units.

2220
03:29:31,890 --> 03:29:43,970
Toler buildings will deliver more low income units through IZ and let's remember that close to 50% of the people who live in inclusionary units are less than the minimum income requirements.

2221
03:29:44,530 --> 03:29:51,110
The qualified for IZ and they are in those units because of vouchers including many formerly on-house people.

2222
03:29:53,130 --> 03:29:57,510
So in order to get more inclusionary units when you limit the amount of units that can be built,

2223
03:29:57,650 --> 03:29:59,750
you're going to therefore get less inclusionary units.

2224
03:30:00,000 --> 03:30:06,360
Housing or for a voucher, but are still paying about 50% or income on rent. That is the middle

2225
03:30:06,360 --> 03:30:13,580
class of Cambridge now. And those are the folks who earn too much money to get any kind of help

2226
03:30:13,580 --> 03:30:19,140
or subsidy, but those are the ones who are leaving because after a couple years they can no longer

2227
03:30:19,140 --> 03:30:27,320
pay 50% or income on rent. So those people are going to suffer too. But I will say, in terms

2228
03:30:27,320 --> 03:30:35,320
of the amendments, I don't believe that there are six votes to pass this ordinance without

2229
03:30:35,320 --> 03:30:36,140
the amendments.

2230
03:30:40,540 --> 03:30:47,760
And I do believe that we need to pass this. I think it is better than

2231
03:30:47,760 --> 03:30:54,340
the current zoning. It is a step forward. Unfortunately, it is not the leap forward that

2232
03:30:54,340 --> 03:31:02,560
think we need if we're going to address our housing shortage, but it is better to pass this

2233
03:31:02,560 --> 03:31:06,540
and to not pass this. I don't think taking two more months for more community conversation

2234
03:31:06,540 --> 03:31:13,780
is going to make that much of a difference. I think people who, the same people who are upset about

2235
03:31:14,660 --> 03:31:23,720
age stories and six stories on the corridors or the same people who are upset about that on mass

2236
03:31:23,720 --> 03:31:25,700
I don't think that's going to change.

2237
03:31:27,300 --> 03:31:32,060
So I think we've had the conversation, I will vote for the amendments, I will vote for the

2238
03:31:32,060 --> 03:31:33,580
final ordinance.

2239
03:31:33,940 --> 03:31:40,240
Again, I think it's not what I think we need, but it's better than what we have, thank you

2240
03:31:40,240 --> 03:31:40,520
men and men.

2241
03:31:41,400 --> 03:31:47,540
And I do, before I go, I do want to thank our staff who, let's see, D.D., our professional

2242
03:31:47,540 --> 03:31:52,560
staff who worked really, really hard on this and I know how difficult it is to balance all

2243
03:31:52,560 --> 03:31:58,440
different visions and wants and desires in the community because there are so many different

2244
03:31:58,440 --> 03:32:02,590
opinions. And I do want to just make sure that I appreciate you. Thank you.

2245
03:32:03,780 --> 03:32:05,960
Thank you, Kasim or Governor. Casa Ferdin?

2246
03:32:09,320 --> 03:32:11,110
Thank you, Madam Mayor and through you.

2247
03:32:13,840 --> 03:32:19,160
It's a complicated issue. And I don't think anyone here denies their fact.

2248
03:32:20,340 --> 03:32:27,280
I will say, like Councilor Al Zubi, I was not a part of the public process, and I regret

2249
03:32:27,280 --> 03:32:34,700
that because I know that there was a valuable exchange of ideas, and I know that say, staff,

2250
03:32:37,300 --> 03:32:40,660
spent an exhaustible effort on all of this.

2251
03:32:41,200 --> 03:32:48,740
But I'm here to represent the people who voted for me, and I'm not going to have those people

2252
03:32:48,740 --> 03:32:56,460
in disenfranchised because I was not involved in that public process. So I'm going to

2253
03:32:58,680 --> 03:33:07,020
I'm in favor of allowing the petition to expire and I'm also not going to support this well-intentioned

2254
03:33:07,020 --> 03:33:14,400
amendment because as Council McGuven just mentioned, I don't want to see an amendment pass.

2255
03:33:14,400 --> 03:33:25,540
I would like to see the entire petition expire and I speak about this issue from I come from maybe a more global issue

2256
03:33:26,240 --> 03:33:34,340
standpoint of viewpoint, then many of my brother and sister counselors do because I fully

2257
03:33:34,340 --> 03:33:41,640
recognize, appreciate and understand that our housing shortage issue is a regional issue.

2258
03:33:41,640 --> 03:33:46,940
This is not a local issue. This is not a Cambridge only issue. We don't live in a silo.

2259
03:33:47,640 --> 03:33:53,080
This is something that we're experiencing, regionally, nationally, and in my lifetime,

2260
03:33:53,740 --> 03:33:59,840
the city of Cambridge has done it continues to do more than all of the other 351 cities

2261
03:33:59,840 --> 03:34:05,640
in towns and Massachusetts to alleviate the housing shortage. And we have done that.

2262
03:34:06,380 --> 03:34:12,520
And over the last maybe decade, in partnership with the State and the federal government

2263
03:34:12,520 --> 03:34:19,260
would spend $2.2 billion on the green line extension to make the communities of some

2264
03:34:19,260 --> 03:34:27,140
of all the method easily accessible to the high-paying jobs in Kendall Square, yet in

2265
03:34:27,740 --> 03:34:35,620
the wake of all of that, the city council and the last term, I guess in February 10th of

2266
03:34:35,620 --> 03:34:41,440
decided that we should upzone the entire city. Every block, every street, every neighborhood,

2267
03:34:41,620 --> 03:34:50,920
any size one. So as of right, on any size one, a structure of four stores can be built,

2268
03:34:51,380 --> 03:34:59,980
thereby incentivizing the demolition of single two family and three family homes without any element of a

2269
03:35:00,000 --> 03:35:07,180
Resolving, ordinance, which has dramatic negative impacts on the city as a whole.

2270
03:35:07,260 --> 03:35:11,800
And if we take it to its logical, some people would say,

2271
03:35:11,900 --> 03:35:19,840
Firm-wongering conclusion, and we consider the availability of money at a maybe a major

2272
03:35:19,840 --> 03:35:24,260
real estate developers' hands to be deployed to the city of Cambridge.

2273
03:35:24,260 --> 03:35:31,160
He would recognize and let's say, for example, just hypothetically, that person's name might be Donald Trump.

2274
03:35:31,620 --> 03:35:37,260
He would recognize the massive investment opportunity in the city of Cambridge.

2275
03:35:37,640 --> 03:35:42,600
And in one generation, we could eradicate this city, and lose neighborhoods.

2276
03:35:43,740 --> 03:35:48,980
And I look at the city of Cambridge in its future as a sustainable city.

2277
03:35:48,980 --> 03:35:56,360
One way we're doing all we can to support and incentivize families here in the city so that we remain

2278
03:35:56,360 --> 03:36:00,440
the historically fabulous place to live and raise a family.

2279
03:36:00,920 --> 03:36:07,780
And I think that that multifamily housing zoning ordinance has the unintended consequences

2280
03:36:08,700 --> 03:36:11,400
of the fairity that's before us.

2281
03:36:11,560 --> 03:36:12,480
So you have to know what's back.

2282
03:36:12,900 --> 03:36:17,660
I'm trying to link it to this and I'm by linking it to this.

2283
03:36:17,660 --> 03:36:25,080
I think that it creates, in my view, a dangerous precedent, and I think that the

2284
03:36:25,080 --> 03:36:31,300
up zoning of Cambridge Street does the exact same thing in that region. It creates an

2285
03:36:31,300 --> 03:36:38,620
as of right development of six stories along that corridor, which in turn will have the same

2286
03:36:38,620 --> 03:36:44,880
impact of causing the displacement of the middle class in that region of Cambridge. And I think

2287
03:36:44,880 --> 03:36:45,820
It's a bad idea.

2288
03:36:46,480 --> 03:36:50,900
I'm fully in favor of the up zoning on the Webster Avcarta,

2289
03:36:50,960 --> 03:36:52,240
because I think it's appropriate.

2290
03:36:52,960 --> 03:36:54,180
And like Councilor Alzubi,

2291
03:36:54,180 --> 03:37:00,620
I think that we have as a city when we allow these zoning

2292
03:37:00,620 --> 03:37:04,380
amendments like this one, we're giving up our leverage.

2293
03:37:05,280 --> 03:37:09,940
And if we do anything in terms of housing development,

2294
03:37:09,940 --> 03:37:17,220
along the Cambridge Recorder to six stories, eight stories, ten stories, all of this should be through

2295
03:37:17,220 --> 03:37:24,320
every view which requires a special permit hearing with community involvement, the opportunity

2296
03:37:24,320 --> 03:37:32,660
for input, and with specific capacity to be met. And without that component in this particular

2297
03:37:35,260 --> 03:37:42,360
zoning woodenance. And again, without being involved in the public process, I would have to,

2298
03:37:42,360 --> 03:37:48,600
you know, for the racket, not that it makes any difference at this point, but I have to say that I,

2299
03:37:48,600 --> 03:37:55,680
I just, I can't, I can't vote in favor of it. So thank you, Madam Mayor, and I yield, and I'm sorry

2300
03:37:55,680 --> 03:38:02,180
to be as low as I was. I know that we're, we're listening to each one of us, and I appreciate

2301
03:38:02,660 --> 03:38:07,260
you're attention in your respect and I I don't mean to belive. Thank you.

2302
03:38:08,340 --> 03:38:14,940
Thank you, Councillor Ferry. Everyone who's wanted to speak on this issue of spoken, at least once.

2303
03:38:17,620 --> 03:38:20,820
I'm going to just briefly speak and then go to Councillor Zeeam.

2304
03:38:21,600 --> 03:38:26,660
You know, I'll say that I hear right colleagues on their various points of view.

2305
03:38:26,940 --> 03:38:32,200
Oh, Councillor Simmons did you want to speak before I go? Okay. I hear you all

2306
03:38:32,660 --> 03:38:38,560
on the various points of view. I think I won't repeat what so my colleagues have said. I'll

2307
03:38:38,560 --> 03:38:46,000
just say that I think the amendments were an attempt to incorporate some of that feedback that we

2308
03:38:46,000 --> 03:38:50,840
had heard. And this process started in the fall of 2021.

2309
03:38:52,940 --> 03:38:55,180
And it, you know, if you look,

2310
03:38:55,180 --> 03:39:04,120
There's 105 page community engagement summary about this process and exactly what was done,

2311
03:39:05,040 --> 03:39:05,780
105 pages.

2312
03:39:06,780 --> 03:39:13,640
And so the assertion around this being rushed and this not having enough process.

2313
03:39:14,420 --> 03:39:18,100
I think I come out a little differently than that.

2314
03:39:18,100 --> 03:39:20,900
I think there are arguments that folks have made

2315
03:40:00,000 --> 03:40:29,980
And I hear that. I think we are trying to be, we're trying to do a lot of things. And we have our 100% overlay. We have, we've, we're going, there's a lot of, further over, multi-family housing. And I know many of us are open to amendments. We're talking about social housing. So, I do think there's no lack of commitment from, most of this council on, many of these important things.

2316
03:40:30,000 --> 03:40:34,680
And I think right now, before us is an attempt to say,

2317
03:40:34,700 --> 03:40:38,280
look, we did hear that the process didn't recommend

2318
03:40:38,280 --> 03:40:42,220
six stories and with some greater heights.

2319
03:40:42,800 --> 03:40:45,880
And sure, there can be critiques of process.

2320
03:40:46,100 --> 03:40:47,740
And I'm so open to that.

2321
03:40:47,740 --> 03:40:49,820
I'm open to improving on a lot of different things.

2322
03:40:49,920 --> 03:40:52,560
But I think on substance, I do think we

2323
03:40:52,560 --> 03:40:55,000
are taking into account a number of things.

2324
03:40:55,420 --> 03:40:58,040
And namely, also, the feedback from our business

2325
03:40:58,040 --> 03:41:05,900
Association from others who at first were saying, you know, you should let this expire, you know, we don't like what happened here.

2326
03:41:06,440 --> 03:41:13,160
And so I do think there are people who've come and said, we've come forward on this.

2327
03:41:13,160 --> 03:41:15,400
And so I, you know, I did want to recognize that.

2328
03:41:15,580 --> 03:41:18,000
So I wanted to just make that brief point.

2329
03:41:18,220 --> 03:41:18,880
I'll go to a conversation.

2330
03:41:20,620 --> 03:41:21,920
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

2331
03:41:22,880 --> 03:41:24,320
I just had a few remarks.

2332
03:41:24,320 --> 03:41:29,000
I typically tend to keep my comments short, but I didn't want to just address some misconceptions.

2333
03:41:30,280 --> 03:41:36,780
You know, my colleague, Councillor Flaherty said, you know, he supports a Webster part, but all the other changes, you know, are a bit too much.

2334
03:41:36,820 --> 03:41:41,740
I would just say that, you know, in-minute staying at six, it's already at six. There is no change there.

2335
03:41:42,620 --> 03:41:45,520
Cambridge Street is at six. It's staying at six. There's no change there.

2336
03:41:46,440 --> 03:41:51,780
And the leech mirror parcel has already been permitted at six at a lower inclusionary. So there's functionally no change there.

2337
03:41:51,780 --> 03:41:59,080
So, it is what the proposal of my fellow council are wanted, and that basically this is just a change to Webster.

2338
03:41:59,300 --> 03:42:03,220
It was also concerned about it not being better right, but requiring special permit, congratulations.

2339
03:42:03,620 --> 03:42:06,600
The Webster block requires a special permit.

2340
03:42:07,000 --> 03:42:08,640
So, I think we should check off those boxes.

2341
03:42:09,480 --> 03:42:11,880
The process has been going around until 2021.

2342
03:42:12,140 --> 03:42:16,180
And I agree that a three year process or really four year process was way too long.

2343
03:42:16,340 --> 03:42:21,520
Every term we have new counselors, if we want to make sure that all of our counselors are part of the entire process,

2344
03:42:21,520 --> 03:42:22,940
which should make our processes shorter.

2345
03:42:24,220 --> 03:42:26,140
I would say that there's been concerns about displacement,

2346
03:42:26,680 --> 03:42:28,360
but also I would say that it's notable

2347
03:42:28,360 --> 03:42:30,440
that the first buildings that were really proposed

2348
03:42:30,440 --> 03:42:32,500
at a multi-family housing where you know

2349
03:42:32,500 --> 03:42:34,580
the spirit's funeral home, the Harriet Jacobs house,

2350
03:42:34,740 --> 03:42:36,840
buildings that had no residence living in there,

2351
03:42:36,960 --> 03:42:39,900
because the place where the economics were best

2352
03:42:39,900 --> 03:42:42,160
are places that aren't already residential.

2353
03:42:42,760 --> 03:42:44,620
And so what we've seen has actually been

2354
03:42:44,620 --> 03:42:45,780
a lot of development in places

2355
03:42:45,780 --> 03:42:47,620
where we would want to see it.

2356
03:42:48,180 --> 03:42:50,940
I would say that it was concerned that the study will come back

2357
03:42:50,940 --> 03:42:56,400
and say that like inclusionary zoning needs to be adjusted. I would say the nexus is not based on the feasibility,

2358
03:42:56,740 --> 03:43:02,840
the economic field is the ability of inclusionary zoning. It's based on diversity, which is inherently built in economic diversity.

2359
03:43:03,580 --> 03:43:10,840
So, I think that that's just not how the nexus studies failed up on like what on how inclusionary zoning is built up.

2360
03:43:10,860 --> 03:43:15,080
There was concerns about other communities on Cambridge doing way more than everyone else.

2361
03:43:15,080 --> 03:43:17,620
Housing is a portion of the city,

2362
03:43:18,180 --> 03:43:20,360
Everett, Revere, Boston, lots of other places

2363
03:43:20,360 --> 03:43:23,500
have been building more housing per capita than we have.

2364
03:43:23,960 --> 03:43:25,800
Just a few more short responses was,

2365
03:43:27,360 --> 03:43:30,620
this is basically just a zoning for Webster at this point.

2366
03:43:31,180 --> 03:43:32,400
And there's lots of great ideas.

2367
03:43:32,440 --> 03:43:33,620
It is a housing emergency.

2368
03:43:33,980 --> 03:43:35,800
And we can either take a stance of, like, yes,

2369
03:43:35,840 --> 03:43:37,520
and we all have slightly different approaches.

2370
03:43:37,720 --> 03:43:39,740
Some people really love the age.

2371
03:43:39,740 --> 03:43:41,340
We'll a little bit more, some the multifamily,

2372
03:43:41,380 --> 03:43:42,340
some other proposals.

2373
03:43:42,840 --> 03:43:44,880
And then we're going to try to build each other up

2374
03:43:44,880 --> 03:43:49,720
try to yes and approach with all different sorts of answers. Or we can break each other down.

2375
03:43:50,240 --> 03:43:54,740
Like I have my issues with South Soil Housing. I think of it as a way of weakening the AHO and actually

2376
03:43:54,740 --> 03:43:58,900
saying that we should pay more for 33% of affordable housing. I don't think the numbers make sense.

2377
03:43:59,260 --> 03:44:02,660
But I understand that other colleagues want to. And I'm like, okay, let's explore. Let's try to

2378
03:44:02,660 --> 03:44:08,880
prove the thing of it. But I see social housing as a way to, you know, actually make more market

2379
03:44:08,880 --> 03:44:13,640
housing and less affordable housing at worst economic. So I don't really understand that. But like,

2380
03:44:13,640 --> 03:44:17,020
we give each other the opportunity and grace to try to make our points.

2381
03:44:17,700 --> 03:44:21,540
And I would just finally just end off by saying that I think that this is an approach that other places are

2382
03:44:21,540 --> 03:44:27,880
visiting both the new mayor of New York and the new mayor of Seattle, Zorad and Kate Wilson are

2383
03:44:27,880 --> 03:44:31,300
really looking at our examples and saying that this is the approach that we want to take between

2384
03:44:31,300 --> 03:44:35,660
multifamily housing and Cambridge Street. I think that we've had a long enough discussion.

2385
03:44:35,780 --> 03:44:39,100
I would just like to vote on the amendments, but I just wanted to address those points.

2386
03:44:40,480 --> 03:44:43,260
Councillor Simmons, anything you'd like to say?

2387
03:44:47,400 --> 03:44:48,320
Thank you, madam.

2388
03:44:48,540 --> 03:44:52,320
I think it's all been said quite well and quite often.

2389
03:44:53,260 --> 03:44:56,160
So if anything, I would like to move that Lee Vodam's.

2390
03:44:56,160 --> 03:44:56,540
Thank you.

2391
03:44:56,780 --> 03:44:57,200
I yield.

2392
03:44:57,800 --> 03:44:59,980
And I will go to Councillor McGurkey.

2393
03:45:00,000 --> 03:45:26,080
Thank you, Madam Mayor, through you. So the next order of business would be for the council to vote to amend the Cambridge Street zoning petition by substitution with the attached petition text revised map and revised map boundary descriptions put forward in the late order by the city manager. So that's on the amendments.

2394
03:45:29,760 --> 03:45:33,440
So, would the motion, before us, Councilor Noon?

2395
03:45:34,060 --> 03:45:37,260
Just to be clear, thank you through you, Mayor City,

2396
03:45:37,360 --> 03:45:39,640
to ordinance chair of my govern.

2397
03:45:40,800 --> 03:45:44,360
These, this would mean we'd be voting on the amendments proposed

2398
03:45:44,360 --> 03:45:46,640
in the communication from other city officers,

2399
03:45:46,740 --> 03:45:48,700
is that what we're, this vote.

2400
03:45:49,220 --> 03:45:49,420
Okay.

2401
03:45:50,560 --> 03:45:52,580
So the, just by the, just in case people haven't,

2402
03:45:52,940 --> 03:45:57,720
so the, so the late city manager agenda item,

2403
03:45:57,720 --> 03:46:01,700
talk what was in the communication filed by

2404
03:46:01,700 --> 03:46:05,220
Mayor City, Game Concerned, all and put that into ordinance language.

2405
03:46:05,820 --> 03:46:09,860
We would have vote on that so that that will be substituted into the

2406
03:46:09,860 --> 03:46:14,080
Cambridge Street language, and then that will become the language that we

2407
03:46:14,080 --> 03:46:18,500
eventually in a few minutes vote on as amended.

2408
03:46:20,920 --> 03:46:22,300
That's no end, does that make sense?

2409
03:46:22,660 --> 03:46:24,300
Yes, thank you for the clarification.

2410
03:46:24,840 --> 03:46:27,240
Mayor, City, Kian, Chairman govern.

2411
03:46:28,780 --> 03:46:36,380
So, per customer governance motion, we have to first vote on the amendments, and then the underlying

2412
03:46:36,380 --> 03:46:36,840
petition.

2413
03:46:38,460 --> 03:46:41,860
So, clerk, will you please call the roll on the amendments?

2414
03:46:44,850 --> 03:46:50,370
So, we're calling the roll on the amendments by the late City Council agenda by the City

2415
03:46:50,370 --> 03:46:52,070
Manager, correct, man, a mayor?

2416
03:46:52,550 --> 03:46:52,570
Yes.

2417
03:46:52,950 --> 03:46:53,190
Okay.

2418
03:46:53,630 --> 03:46:54,810
Councilor Elzubi.

2419
03:46:55,110 --> 03:46:55,470
Present.

2420
03:46:57,470 --> 03:46:58,370
Vice Mayor Zeme.

2421
03:46:58,550 --> 03:46:58,890
Yes.

2422
03:46:58,890 --> 03:47:08,910
Yes, Council of Flaherty. No. No, Council of McGuvern. Yes. Yes, Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes.

2423
03:47:08,950 --> 03:47:18,330
Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. No. No. Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes.

2424
03:47:18,330 --> 03:47:30,570
Yes, yes, and you have six members recorded in the affirmative. Two members recorded in the negative and one recorded is present.

2425
03:47:39,970 --> 03:47:49,470
So the next vote would be to vote the Cambridge Street zoning ordinance as amended.

2426
03:47:52,460 --> 03:47:55,320
We'll go hand with that real call, seeing no hands.

2427
03:47:57,020 --> 03:48:09,220
Councilor Alzubi. No. No. Vice-Mayor Zim. Yes. Yes. Councilor Flaherty. No. No. Councilor Luma-Govern. Yes. Yes.

2428
03:48:09,280 --> 03:48:17,000
Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes.

2429
03:48:17,000 --> 03:48:24,960
answers you see? No. No. Mayor Sadiki. Yes. Yes. And you have six members recorded in

2430
03:48:24,960 --> 03:48:27,640
the affirmative and three recorded in the negative.

2431
03:48:29,680 --> 03:48:32,780
The, the, we're almost there. We're almost there. Go ahead,

2432
03:48:33,000 --> 03:48:40,600
come soon. We now need to vote. Um, the city manager, the late city manager at that agenda. I don't

2433
03:48:40,600 --> 03:48:47,720
number 12, and communication and report from other city officers, it's number 2 to be placed on

2434
03:48:47,720 --> 03:48:48,140
file.

2435
03:48:50,380 --> 03:48:55,860
So we'll go ahead on that motion from Councillor Gouverne to place those two items on

2436
03:48:55,860 --> 03:48:56,620
file.

2437
03:49:00,400 --> 03:49:01,500
Councillor Alzubi.

2438
03:49:02,520 --> 03:49:02,720
Yes.

2439
03:49:02,860 --> 03:49:03,540
Yes.

2440
03:49:03,540 --> 03:49:04,340
Vice-merzine.

2441
03:49:04,960 --> 03:49:05,120
Yes.

2442
03:49:05,500 --> 03:49:05,860
Yes.

2443
03:49:05,900 --> 03:49:06,820
Councillor Flaherty.

2444
03:49:07,260 --> 03:49:07,660
Yes.

2445
03:49:08,040 --> 03:49:08,500
Yes.

2446
03:49:08,500 --> 03:49:09,320
Councillor McGuvern.

2447
03:49:10,000 --> 03:49:10,420
Yes.

2448
03:49:10,800 --> 03:49:11,280
Yes.

2449
03:49:11,280 --> 03:49:11,840
Councillor Nolan.

2450
03:49:13,180 --> 03:49:13,580
Yes.

2451
03:49:13,580 --> 03:49:17,080
Yes, Councillor Simmons. Yes. Yes.

2452
03:49:17,420 --> 03:49:19,960
Councillor Sabrina Wailer. Yes. Yes.

2453
03:49:20,120 --> 03:49:22,020
Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2454
03:49:22,040 --> 03:49:23,980
Yes. Mayor Sediki. Yes. Yes.

2455
03:49:23,980 --> 03:49:25,860
And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

2456
03:49:27,660 --> 03:49:28,640
So those are one more.

2457
03:49:29,140 --> 03:49:30,400
One more. We have one more.

2458
03:49:30,740 --> 03:49:32,880
And we'll go ahead and to Councillor Montgomery.

2459
03:49:33,940 --> 03:49:35,660
Thank you, Madam Mayor, through you.

2460
03:49:35,660 --> 03:49:39,580
I would like to move suspicion of the rules to move reconsideration,

2461
03:49:40,280 --> 03:49:41,700
hoping the same will not prevail.

2462
03:49:43,590 --> 03:49:51,490
So there's two going to be two votes here. So clerk, I'll lead you. You'll lead us through those votes.

2463
03:49:51,850 --> 03:49:54,770
So the first is to move the suspension, Councilor Azubi.

2464
03:49:56,070 --> 03:49:59,970
Can I do a point of order here and ask them, ask you all to explain what is.

2465
03:50:00,000 --> 03:50:09,700
The expansion of the rules basically means that we are going out of order of the regular agenda of the meeting to bring something else forward.

2466
03:50:10,160 --> 03:50:29,250
So, we're suspending the rules. So, by so council of a government can move reconsideration, which means if reconsideration is approved, then there will be no reconsideration allowable before the 12 o'clock Wednesday final.

2467
03:50:30,080 --> 03:50:32,500
I don't know if I was very clear with that.

2468
03:50:32,820 --> 03:50:36,700
Yeah, I'll just add that basically a motion to,

2469
03:50:36,700 --> 03:50:40,740
if there's a motion to reconsider under Robert's rule,

2470
03:50:41,640 --> 03:50:45,920
you can bring back something that was already voted on.

2471
03:50:45,960 --> 03:50:49,540
voted on and that can be re-debated and possibly changed.

2472
03:50:49,780 --> 03:50:53,020
And so we're saying that we want this matter to be closed.

2473
03:50:53,800 --> 03:50:55,800
And so you wouldn't allow reconsideration

2474
03:50:55,800 --> 03:50:57,340
so that would be a no vote.

2475
03:50:57,340 --> 03:51:01,940
And historically, on various matters, we've done

2476
03:51:01,940 --> 03:51:07,180
no votes on reconsideration, because we feel that the matter should be closed.

2477
03:51:07,240 --> 03:51:11,700
And you have a certain amount of time to do the reconsideration.

2478
03:51:11,800 --> 03:51:15,040
If I've missed anything, anyone feel free to add?

2479
03:51:15,520 --> 03:51:16,480
I'm not sure.

2480
03:51:17,040 --> 03:51:17,260
Yes.

2481
03:51:17,600 --> 03:51:18,080
I'm sorry.

2482
03:51:18,080 --> 03:51:18,180
I'm sorry.

2483
03:51:19,140 --> 03:51:19,760
Thank you.

2484
03:51:20,380 --> 03:51:22,660
Also, we consideration can only be done.

2485
03:51:23,160 --> 03:51:26,140
But I want to make sure we're correct if you were on the prevailing side.

2486
03:51:27,880 --> 03:51:31,840
Yeah. Yes. So, any further questions?

2487
03:51:34,200 --> 03:51:35,940
Okay. So, who?

2488
03:51:36,780 --> 03:51:38,580
Consulate, answer your question.

2489
03:51:39,040 --> 03:51:39,280
Yes.

2490
03:51:39,360 --> 03:51:43,220
My understanding is the first, first vote is on the suspension of the rules and the second

2491
03:51:43,220 --> 03:51:44,520
vote is on the reconsideration.

2492
03:51:44,660 --> 03:51:44,920
Yes.

2493
03:51:45,320 --> 03:51:46,280
Okay. That's it.

2494
03:51:46,640 --> 03:51:49,340
I have questions, clarifying questions.

2495
03:51:49,620 --> 03:51:50,400
I'll go to Councillor.

2496
03:51:50,400 --> 03:51:52,820
for Flair any of the concerns, is he?

2497
03:51:53,900 --> 03:51:58,240
No, no, I'd consider Simmons answered my question.

2498
03:51:58,700 --> 03:52:01,020
Under the point, I was going to make a point of

2499
03:52:01,020 --> 03:52:03,480
parliamentary procedure to ask him to rub its rules

2500
03:52:05,960 --> 03:52:12,200
that the only movement under a most

2501
03:52:12,200 --> 03:52:15,000
reconsideration must be the prevailing party,

2502
03:52:15,060 --> 03:52:16,100
not the agreeable party.

2503
03:52:16,680 --> 03:52:18,140
So it's been answered, thank you.

2504
03:52:18,140 --> 03:52:21,240
You've been studying cancer, where did I appreciate it all these days?

2505
03:52:21,720 --> 03:52:23,560
Well, we'll go to a councillor, as I was saying.

2506
03:52:23,600 --> 03:52:29,120
I just wanted to say, I was talking to a, like, a contributing lawyer who was saying that

2507
03:52:29,120 --> 03:52:37,200
the councillor didn't use to ask for the suspension of rules and the inability to reconsider

2508
03:52:37,200 --> 03:52:37,800
things.

2509
03:52:37,940 --> 03:52:40,960
It's just something that we've been doing more recently.

2510
03:52:40,960 --> 03:52:46,460
I mean, they're actually having more time to think about things,

2511
03:52:46,480 --> 03:52:48,380
can sometimes be a good thing.

2512
03:52:48,580 --> 03:52:55,360
So it doesn't seem like we should always be locking every vote into a final vote.

2513
03:52:56,140 --> 03:52:59,400
And we'll have roles discussion this week.

2514
03:53:00,360 --> 03:53:02,520
So feel free to bring that out there.

2515
03:53:03,060 --> 03:53:05,420
Yes, I would say, Matt, I would say about America.

2516
03:53:05,680 --> 03:53:08,220
This is something that we've been doing.

2517
03:53:08,220 --> 03:53:14,140
is I got elected in this full committee 22 years ago. So I'm not sure who says who I gave that

2518
03:53:14,140 --> 03:53:19,740
advice on that counselors as a result, but we have done this very very long to on important issues.

2519
03:53:19,800 --> 03:53:27,240
This is not unusual. So now that we've had questions answered, clarified, we'll go back to the vote please.

2520
03:53:28,400 --> 03:53:37,660
on suspension, counselor LZB. Yes. Yes, vice-marison. Yes. Yes, counsel authority. No. No,

2521
03:53:37,660 --> 03:53:38,340
counsel Montgomery.

2522
03:53:41,820 --> 03:53:49,880
Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Counselor Simmons. Yes. Counselor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes.

2523
03:53:50,020 --> 03:53:56,720
Counselor Zucy. No. No. Mayor C. D. K. Yes. Yes. And you have seven members recorded in the affirmative

2524
03:53:56,720 --> 03:53:58,540
and to record it in the negative.

2525
03:53:58,920 --> 03:54:02,020
Suspension prevails. We'll go on to the reconsideration vote, please.

2526
03:54:02,480 --> 03:54:04,000
On reconsideration.

2527
03:54:04,440 --> 03:54:05,580
Councilor Alzubi.

2528
03:54:05,800 --> 03:54:06,320
No.

2529
03:54:06,820 --> 03:54:08,200
No, Vice-Mirazine.

2530
03:54:09,300 --> 03:54:10,720
No, Councilor Flaherty.

2531
03:54:11,520 --> 03:54:11,700
No.

2532
03:54:12,280 --> 03:54:13,580
No, Councilor McGovern.

2533
03:54:14,540 --> 03:54:15,040
No.

2534
03:54:15,260 --> 03:54:16,460
No, Councilor Nolan.

2535
03:54:16,920 --> 03:54:17,500
No.

2536
03:54:17,820 --> 03:54:18,880
No, Councilor Simmons.

2537
03:54:20,640 --> 03:54:20,800
No.

2538
03:54:20,900 --> 03:54:22,120
No, Councilor Sabrina Wheeler.

2539
03:54:22,480 --> 03:54:22,780
No.

2540
03:54:23,340 --> 03:54:24,540
No, Councilor Zucy.

2541
03:54:24,880 --> 03:54:25,300
Yes.

2542
03:54:25,860 --> 03:54:26,280
Yes.

2543
03:54:26,280 --> 03:54:32,440
Mayor Siddiqui. No. No, and you have one member recorded in the affirmative in eight recorded in the

2544
03:54:32,440 --> 03:54:37,760
in the negative. Councillor Montgomery, was there anything else? I think we've wrapped up.

2545
03:55:00,000 --> 03:55:05,980
Thank you everyone. Thank you for going through this at the Cambridge Street Petitions.

2546
03:55:05,980 --> 03:55:24,360
It's only petition has been ordained as amended. We are now done with the city managers agenda. So, we will go ahead to policy orders, pressure of the city council. And I ask that you raise your hands.

2547
03:55:27,380 --> 03:55:28,520
We'll go to council.

2548
03:55:28,520 --> 03:55:40,530
Would you like to pull one and three counselor I'll do be pulls one and three counselors you see

2549
03:55:44,850 --> 03:55:46,190
your mutate counselors.

2550
03:55:46,810 --> 03:55:50,510
I apologize two and nine

2551
03:55:51,390 --> 03:55:52,730
two and

2552
03:55:58,600 --> 03:55:59,680
nine

2553
03:55:59,680 --> 03:56:14,680
It's been pulled mayor city camp. Okay, so we've pulled 1, 2, 3 and 9 and so we'll go ahead and do a roll call.

2554
03:56:14,700 --> 03:56:17,400
Consular as if you're not pulling number eight.

2555
03:56:19,090 --> 03:56:31,330
No, but yeah, okay. So we'll do a roll call on adopting pulse orders 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8.

2556
03:56:33,050 --> 03:56:41,010
Counts, Laura, Zubi. Yes. Yes, Vice-Mayor Zim. Yes. Yes, Council of Flaherty. Yes. Yes, Council of McGovern.

2557
03:56:42,090 --> 03:56:47,670
Yes, Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes, Councilor Simmons. Yes.

2558
03:56:47,670 --> 03:56:59,810
Yes, Councillor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative. The balance of the policy orders.

2559
03:57:00,590 --> 03:57:16,170
The adopted will go to positive number one that the city manager asked the appropriate departments review the city's digital equity work to date, including the studies recommendations and all steps taken since the study inclusion in order to update the evaluation

2560
03:57:16,170 --> 03:57:23,290
of existing internet access programs, assessing whether residents' digital needs are or could be provided for

2561
03:57:23,290 --> 03:57:28,630
and to propose how we could better meet their needs and to report back to the council by June 20,

2562
03:57:28,910 --> 03:57:31,250
26 on internet access programs.

2563
03:57:31,250 --> 03:57:35,870
This was filed by Councilor Zuzzi, Councilor Nolan, Councilor Serena Wheeler, and Vice Mayor Azim.

2564
03:57:36,010 --> 03:57:41,890
This was pulled by Councillor Azubi, I'll go to the lead sponsor, Councillor Azuzzi, and

2565
03:57:41,890 --> 03:57:44,590
And she yields to Casper, I am. Casper, does he?

2566
03:57:45,990 --> 03:57:53,550
This is a policy order that we introduce less spring and with the same co-sponsors.

2567
03:57:54,370 --> 03:57:56,730
But we forgot to ask for a report back.

2568
03:57:56,930 --> 03:58:01,570
So we've resubmitted this policy order asking for a report back,

2569
03:58:02,690 --> 03:58:09,710
because I realize at least that we may not have the 150 to 200 million estimated

2570
03:58:09,710 --> 03:58:18,270
to invest in municipal broadband right now over the next five years, but it's absolutely essential

2571
03:58:18,270 --> 03:58:26,270
that all of our residents have digital access. And I'm really happy for the $100,000 grant

2572
03:58:26,270 --> 03:58:32,930
that we just received, the Cambridge Public Library just received, for their digital navigator program.

2573
03:58:33,450 --> 03:58:39,530
But what I wanted and I guess what we wanted was a broader report back on what else is happening

2574
03:58:39,530 --> 03:58:48,910
in Cambridge housing, in CHA properties and other, there are all these other programs that

2575
03:58:48,910 --> 03:58:53,970
have existed over time, and we would like to update on the status of them because we

2576
03:58:53,970 --> 03:59:00,590
want to make sure that everybody really has digital access with that. I yield.

2577
03:59:01,590 --> 03:59:02,590
What are Councilor Zubby?

2578
03:59:03,930 --> 03:59:08,410
Thank you Madam Mayor. I would like to exercise my charter right on this policy order to

2579
03:59:08,410 --> 03:59:13,750
understand, to better understand it, especially as it can actually relates to municipal broadband.

2580
03:59:15,250 --> 03:59:19,690
Councillor Osubi. Exercise is return rate and policy number one will move to

2581
03:59:19,690 --> 03:59:25,530
policy number two. That the city manager is requested to work with a relevant city.

2582
03:59:25,870 --> 03:59:32,850
Departments regarding incorporating plant-based solutions into the Sustainable Cambridge Initiative

2583
03:59:32,850 --> 03:59:39,330
incorporating plant-based practices and city-operated events and using municipal communication

2584
03:59:39,330 --> 03:59:44,710
channels to promote sustainable and affordable food and drink practices throughout the city.

2585
03:59:45,370 --> 03:59:49,450
This was filed by Councillor Nolan, a Councillor Serena Wheeler, Councillor McGovern and myself.

2586
03:59:49,990 --> 03:59:55,630
It was pulled by Councillor Susie, but I will go to Councillor Nolan as the lead sponsor,

2587
03:59:55,830 --> 03:59:58,830
Councillor Nolan, unless you yield Councillor Nolan, you have the four.

2588
03:59:59,230 --> 03:59:59,890
Thank you, Mayor.

2589
04:00:00,000 --> 04:00:05,140
Thank you, Mayor Siddiqui, and I'll just make a few remarks related to this policy or to before

2590
04:00:05,140 --> 04:00:10,400
yielding to Councillor Susie. As we heard in public comment, I want to thank all the folks

2591
04:00:10,400 --> 04:00:15,420
from the plant-based treaty who came to public comment. I know they met with, I think, many

2592
04:00:15,420 --> 04:00:20,320
city councilors, and they're really working to ensure that Cambridge is part of the leading edge

2593
04:00:20,320 --> 04:00:25,280
of cities across the country and in fact the world that are looking into every single way that

2594
04:00:25,280 --> 04:00:31,220
can address not only a mission in climate, but this is also gets at the heart of a lot of

2595
04:00:31,220 --> 04:00:36,500
public health as well. So again, it also improves social justice, economic well-being.

2596
04:00:37,200 --> 04:00:41,200
This whole policy order is about supporting Cambridge and reducing its consumption-based

2597
04:00:41,200 --> 04:00:48,360
emissions and getting the word out to the public at large, about the importance of this for

2598
04:00:48,360 --> 04:00:52,080
for that climate work, but also for public health. As some of the public comment noted,

2599
04:00:52,080 --> 04:00:58,600
doesn't restrict anybody's individual choices. What it does do is what it would do if we move

2600
04:00:58,600 --> 04:01:03,700
forward and it asks the city staff to really incorporate plant-based solutions not only into

2601
04:01:03,700 --> 04:01:09,520
sustainable Cambridge but into everything that we do and incorporate purchasing practices across

2602
04:01:09,520 --> 04:01:14,940
the city. Again, no one's diet has to change overnight but I would say everyone's diet can be

2603
04:01:14,940 --> 04:01:21,920
improved. The emission pollution that is directly caused by all of our diets is something that we

2604
04:01:21,920 --> 04:01:26,520
be prioritizing because it's something we control and also it's easy. And you can still have

2605
04:01:26,520 --> 04:01:32,080
a lot of tasty things and still just reduce the emission pollution that comes with every single

2606
04:01:32,080 --> 04:01:37,620
choice we make related to eating. So I would be really excited for the Council to pass this

2607
04:01:37,620 --> 04:01:42,420
policy order to there's a lot of folks in the community, many of whom came to public comment

2608
04:01:42,420 --> 04:01:47,700
who are willing to work with us on this. And again, this is really about setting the stage for

2609
04:01:47,700 --> 04:02:00,620
to be a lead to join some of the leaders in the country and in the world who are working on this really, really important issue related to our public health goals as well as our climate reduction and emission pollution reduction goals.

2610
04:02:01,380 --> 04:02:15,620
So I hope these more plant-based food choices is going to be a great way for residents also to work with each other and educate each other and help the city and therefore then the world as a role model move towards a more sustainable lifestyle.

2611
04:02:15,620 --> 04:02:22,280
So that's my reason for bringing this for it and I'm really grateful I know there's there's several other

2612
04:02:22,280 --> 04:02:26,700
counselors including Councilman Governor who'd worked with this a lot and he is a

2613
04:02:26,700 --> 04:02:34,210
co-sponsor he might want to speak before we go to Councilor Zizzi who was a co-sponsor

2614
04:02:34,210 --> 04:02:41,030
it was yeah any of the co-sponsors Councilman Governor I Councilman I don't see oh yeah

2615
04:02:41,030 --> 04:02:46,650
your head is up go ahead thank you man I've been through you I just want to thank

2616
04:02:47,610 --> 04:02:53,450
for putting this policy order together, I actually got a approach with this issue.

2617
04:02:53,630 --> 04:02:59,650
Maybe a year and a half ago through the MSPCA,

2618
04:03:01,530 --> 04:03:04,890
that was endorsing this work through some of their animal rights work,

2619
04:03:06,790 --> 04:03:08,430
and then as Councillor Nolan said,

2620
04:03:08,730 --> 04:03:12,410
we were approached again more recently by some of the other groups

2621
04:03:12,410 --> 04:03:14,770
that wanted us to put this forward.

2622
04:03:14,770 --> 04:03:19,990
I just, I want to thank Councilor Nolan for actually writing it and putting it together because

2623
04:03:19,990 --> 04:03:28,050
I dropped the ball on it, but I appreciate her taking the lead and sponsoring this.

2624
04:03:28,510 --> 04:03:33,690
And I think important point that she said is that, you know, this doesn't force anybody to, you know,

2625
04:03:33,770 --> 04:03:34,850
to do anything.

2626
04:03:35,990 --> 04:03:43,010
You know, but it is so that we have a greater awareness of this issue and can make some progress and do a better job with,

2627
04:03:43,010 --> 04:03:49,230
with how the eating and environmental issues. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Are you all?

2628
04:03:49,230 --> 04:03:54,750
Thank you. What about the councillors? Thank you. Through Madam Mayor, I just I wanted to

2629
04:03:54,750 --> 04:04:01,170
think councillor Nolan. It also for initiating this. I also met with the plant based treaty people last

2630
04:04:01,170 --> 04:04:08,150
fall and I was really impressed with their presentation and she councillor Nolan just speak me to

2631
04:04:08,150 --> 04:04:15,030
drafting a policy order about it. I think it's great to get information out about this and for the

2632
04:04:15,030 --> 04:04:21,330
city to model it. And I would like to be added as a co-sponsor for the policy order.

2633
04:04:23,640 --> 04:04:31,520
Would anyone else like to be added as a co-sponsor? Would anyone do any folks have any questions or

2634
04:04:31,520 --> 04:04:37,940
comments on this before we go ahead and ask Councillor, ask that Councillor Susie me added?

2635
04:04:39,220 --> 04:04:42,220
So, on that motion, we'll do a roll call to add

2636
04:04:42,220 --> 04:04:44,740
Councillor Zuzi to the policy order.

2637
04:04:45,200 --> 04:04:46,300
Councillor Lzubi.

2638
04:04:46,320 --> 04:04:46,960
Yes.

2639
04:04:47,220 --> 04:04:47,620
Yes.

2640
04:04:47,620 --> 04:04:48,440
Vice-merzine.

2641
04:04:48,920 --> 04:04:49,040
Yes.

2642
04:04:49,460 --> 04:04:49,780
Yes.

2643
04:04:50,040 --> 04:04:50,720
Councillor Flaherty.

2644
04:05:00,560 --> 04:05:11,880
Yes, Councillor Nolan? Yes. Yes, Councillor Simmons? Yes. Yes, Councillor Sabrina Wheeler? Yes. Yes, Councillor Susie? Yes. Yes, Mayor Sadiki? Yes. Yes.

2645
04:05:11,880 --> 04:05:13,540
And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

2646
04:05:14,320 --> 04:05:28,900
Also, number two, as amended is passed, we'll go to policy number three, that the city manager's requested to work with relevant city departments to prioritize pilot projects in 26 with that the use of a consultant or an extensive.

2647
04:05:30,800 --> 04:05:38,900
pedestrianization study and in the medium term consider how additional pedestrianization is a long word.

2648
04:05:39,620 --> 04:05:48,420
I was section of Rattles Street by restoring two-way traffic to JFK Street could enhance the square.

2649
04:05:48,800 --> 04:05:52,440
This was filed by Councillor Nolan, Councillor Simmons, myself and Councillor Susie.

2650
04:05:52,440 --> 04:05:56,300
This is pulled by Councillor Azubi.

2651
04:05:56,440 --> 04:06:00,880
We'll go to Councillor Nolan and any of the co-sponsors to speak on that.

2652
04:06:00,940 --> 04:06:02,600
Councillor Nolan and then Councillor Simmons.

2653
04:06:03,520 --> 04:06:04,440
Thank you, Mayor Sediki.

2654
04:06:05,580 --> 04:06:11,520
This policy order is about something that Councillor has been working on as I think is noted

2655
04:06:11,520 --> 04:06:13,020
for many, many years.

2656
04:06:13,640 --> 04:06:18,480
There's been lots of folks across the city who are interested in this and the Harvard

2657
04:06:18,480 --> 04:06:24,300
business association as we heard in public comment wants us to move forward with some

2658
04:06:24,300 --> 04:06:30,440
pilots and the whole idea is that we are all on record the Council's been on record in

2659
04:06:30,440 --> 04:06:34,340
a number of ways of supporting more opportunities to pedestrian eye sections of the public

2660
04:06:34,340 --> 04:06:41,180
way in order to in live in the community, help local businesses build community. We have worked as a

2661
04:06:41,180 --> 04:06:45,960
group to pilot a number of pedestrianization opportunities. We can continue that work in

2662
04:06:45,960 --> 04:06:51,380
The policy order really asked the city staff to prioritize these pilot opportunities pretty much immediately.

2663
04:06:52,120 --> 04:06:56,140
We have several streets that are named in the policy order to move forward.

2664
04:06:56,300 --> 04:07:00,480
And I think if we pass this, it really says to the city, we want these to happen as soon as possible.

2665
04:07:01,120 --> 04:07:10,600
We also believe partly because the world has changed in the last few years in terms of availability of information and availability of data,

2666
04:07:10,600 --> 04:07:16,800
particularly in transportation or traffic that we do not need a very expensive and time-consuming

2667
04:07:16,800 --> 04:07:22,640
consultant study to move forward. I hope that the city will understand that we can move forward with

2668
04:07:22,640 --> 04:07:30,320
some pilots but that also the dream for me is still to make sure that we take, we follow the example

2669
04:07:30,320 --> 04:07:36,820
of leading cities in Europe and several in this country as well to use pedestrianization as a strategy

2670
04:07:36,820 --> 04:07:41,280
for building community and helping small businesses, including that stretch of battle street, which

2671
04:07:41,280 --> 04:07:49,260
is identified in earlier policy orders, which would require some re-direction of some

2672
04:07:49,260 --> 04:07:54,160
of the other streets, but it's eminently feasible and does not require inexpensive lengthy study.

2673
04:07:54,180 --> 04:08:00,900
So, I hope that we can move forward and have on-the-ground problems solved by joint and collaborative

2674
04:08:00,900 --> 04:08:03,780
efforts of local property owners businesses in the council.

2675
04:08:05,380 --> 04:08:09,540
Thank you, Councillor Nolan. We'll go to Councillor Simmons.

2676
04:08:10,180 --> 04:08:14,420
Thank you, Madam Chair. Let me just stop by acknowledging Councillor Nolan for taking a lead

2677
04:08:14,420 --> 04:08:19,100
on this policy order and for doing the work of hard work of keeping your focus practical

2678
04:08:19,100 --> 04:08:25,440
and achievable, especially in tonight's in this tight budget environment. I also wanted to

2679
04:08:25,440 --> 04:08:30,040
recognize Denise Jielson, whose long-standing advocacy for more welcoming people selected

2680
04:08:30,040 --> 04:08:33,320
Harvard School has been a real spark behind this effort.

2681
04:08:34,080 --> 04:08:35,940
This ought to be flexious of community conversation,

2682
04:08:36,300 --> 04:08:38,840
careful walkthrough, shared interest, and testing ideas

2683
04:08:38,840 --> 04:08:41,060
thoughtfully better than of a study in them.

2684
04:08:41,340 --> 04:08:42,340
Size of Portland is the approach

2685
04:08:42,340 --> 04:08:45,600
because it prioritizes real world pilots.

2686
04:08:46,520 --> 04:08:48,700
Respects, fiscal constraints, and gives us

2687
04:08:48,700 --> 04:08:51,140
an opportunity to learn quickly collaboratively

2688
04:08:51,140 --> 04:08:51,960
and transparently.

2689
04:08:52,380 --> 04:08:54,520
But what works of residence, businesses, and business

2690
04:08:54,520 --> 04:08:57,100
is all I. So I hope our colleagues will see fit to support

2691
04:08:57,100 --> 04:08:58,600
this, and with the obvious faculty,

2692
04:08:58,600 --> 04:09:02,360
the flow back to you. Thank you, Councillor Simmons.

2693
04:09:03,620 --> 04:09:04,800
Councillor, is this you did you want to speak?

2694
04:09:07,880 --> 04:09:10,040
Okay, great. Now, we'll go to

2695
04:09:10,040 --> 04:09:14,960
Councillor Azubi, who will this? Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. I'm okay with voting

2696
04:09:14,960 --> 04:09:19,280
yes on this policy order and appreciate the work put into it. I do just want to

2697
04:09:19,280 --> 04:09:23,100
quickly let some thoughts and questions that I have that I'll be curious about. I'm

2698
04:09:23,100 --> 04:09:28,180
excited about the potential to betestrianize Harvard Square, but as someone who was

2699
04:09:28,180 --> 04:09:39,080
I think JFK going to ways this likely dangerous, especially when you consider how heavy pedestrian traffic is in that area despite the fact that there is traffic moving there.

2700
04:09:39,280 --> 04:09:45,860
I'm worried about the safety of pedestrian drivers, bikers and anyone else, and I'm looking forward to understanding the feedback on this report.

2701
04:09:46,080 --> 04:09:50,280
Just a few questions on are we thinking outside of the box here as much as we can?

2702
04:09:50,280 --> 04:09:59,980
Are we only going to consider one way forward toward pedestrianization or can we leave room for a range of options, but this just need more

2703
04:10:00,000 --> 04:10:05,200
Our adjustments then what is on this policy order currently, is it simply enough to go back to

2704
04:10:05,200 --> 04:10:10,320
two-way traffic? I have a lot of questions and we'll be curious as I do care about the pedestrianization

2705
04:10:10,320 --> 04:10:15,200
of Harvard Square since it's such a busy area in our city. So I'll be checking out the report and

2706
04:10:15,200 --> 04:10:15,640
would love to.

2707
04:10:18,380 --> 04:10:22,860
Any other questions on the policy order before us?

2708
04:10:25,120 --> 04:10:27,360
I don't see any. So we can go ahead and

2709
04:10:27,360 --> 04:10:31,380
roll call on adopting Paul's your number three.

2710
04:10:31,800 --> 04:10:35,740
Councilor L. Zubi. Yes. Yes. Vice-Mayor Zene. Yes.

2711
04:10:35,980 --> 04:10:39,620
Yes. Council of Flaherty. Yes. Yes. Council of McGuvern.

2712
04:10:40,780 --> 04:10:44,160
Yes. Yes. Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes.

2713
04:10:44,160 --> 04:10:48,760
Yes. Councilor Simon. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes.

2714
04:10:49,080 --> 04:10:52,940
Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes. Yes. Mayor Sediki. Yes.

2715
04:10:53,240 --> 04:10:55,420
Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

2716
04:10:56,520 --> 04:11:04,660
policy order number three is adopted. We now are on to policy order number nine that the

2717
04:11:04,660 --> 04:11:08,100
Mayor he arrived points the committee to screen applicants for the position of city clerk.

2718
04:11:08,120 --> 04:11:13,420
This was filed by myself and Vice Mayor Azim and pulled by Councillor Azuzi before I go to

2719
04:11:13,420 --> 04:11:21,260
Councillor Azuzi. I will ask for a motion by Councillor Azim to on suspension to bring forward

2720
04:11:22,100 --> 04:11:29,980
communications from other city officers number four, which is a communication from me

2721
04:11:29,980 --> 04:11:34,880
transmitting information about the search process for permanent city clerk so that we

2722
04:11:34,880 --> 04:11:42,060
can have both of those together as we talk about the policy order and where things left off

2723
04:11:42,060 --> 04:11:48,540
with the previous search. So on that motion we'll do a real call for suspension.

2724
04:11:48,540 --> 04:11:53,880
Councillor Al-Zubi? Yes. Yes. Vice-Mayor Azine? Yes. Yes.

2725
04:11:53,880 --> 04:11:59,040
Councillor Flaherty? Yes. Yes. Councillor Luma-Govern? Yes. Yes.

2726
04:11:59,040 --> 04:12:03,200
Councillor Nolan? Yes. Yes. Councillor Simmons? Yes.

2727
04:12:03,680 --> 04:12:05,720
Yes. Councillor Sabrina Wheeler? Yes.

2728
04:12:06,200 --> 04:12:08,640
Yes. Councillor Zucy? Yes. Yes.

2729
04:12:08,640 --> 04:12:12,540
Yes. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

2730
04:12:14,300 --> 04:12:17,840
The communication and from other city officers and before

2731
04:12:17,840 --> 04:12:25,720
is before us alongside this policy order and I'll just quickly briefly brief the

2732
04:12:26,340 --> 04:12:33,000
half the communication kind of outlines the history of the city clerk search process

2733
04:12:33,840 --> 04:12:43,200
and the fact that there was a process and I want to thank Councillor Simmons who has

2734
04:12:43,200 --> 04:12:49,300
We're led that process and many of the several of the city councillors who were involved.

2735
04:12:50,340 --> 04:12:59,080
And as was mentioned, you know, I think there was thought put into the fact that, well,

2736
04:12:59,380 --> 04:13:06,400
there was a process that were folks who were evaluated for the position that we,

2737
04:13:07,100 --> 04:13:12,080
the committee at the time was not ready to bring forward recommended finalists.

2738
04:13:12,080 --> 04:13:16,080
Councillor Simmons, if you want to add anything, I'll yield to you.

2739
04:13:17,300 --> 04:13:21,360
Thank you, Madam Mayor, and thank you for bringing this forward and restarting the process.

2740
04:13:21,800 --> 04:13:26,140
As you had said, there was a committee convened.

2741
04:13:26,460 --> 04:13:33,460
I want to thank and Naomi Steffen, who helped us by, we sent out the job description.

2742
04:13:33,660 --> 04:13:37,520
We got a number of resumes, back those resumes were bedded.

2743
04:13:37,520 --> 04:13:44,780
We sat down and looked over finalists, got those finalists down to another finalists, and at the end of that,

2744
04:13:44,860 --> 04:13:51,640
although we came very close without saying too much, we did not feel confident that we should go

2745
04:13:51,640 --> 04:13:56,100
forward with the final product. I'm trying to be vague on purpose.

2746
04:13:58,540 --> 04:14:00,200
So, sorry, I guess you could say,

2747
04:14:00,280 --> 04:14:05,920
tag your it. Madam Mayor, but it was, I do want to thank my colleagues for the worth they put in.

2748
04:14:05,920 --> 04:14:13,480
It was well-run, it we did our best work but this is an important job and as an important

2749
04:14:13,480 --> 04:14:18,380
job we wanted to make sure we got the best candidate and one of the candidates that we were

2750
04:14:18,380 --> 04:14:24,080
very interested in dropped out at the end and did not want to say well let's take whose left

2751
04:14:24,080 --> 04:14:25,240
let's restart.

2752
04:14:25,760 --> 04:14:28,620
So thank you for that opportunity to explain that and I yield the floor.

2753
04:14:29,040 --> 04:14:35,180
Thank you Councillor Simmons and I'll say to my colleagues, you know, being on the City Clerk

2754
04:14:35,180 --> 04:14:39,340
Search Process is all the rage, and so please do,

2755
04:14:39,420 --> 04:14:40,640
let me know if you're interested,

2756
04:14:41,880 --> 04:14:43,120
because we do need you.

2757
04:14:43,120 --> 04:14:44,040
We need you.

2758
04:15:00,000 --> 04:15:26,800
I just wanted to thank Paula Creme for continuing to serve as our clerk. Yeah, when you had signed up for a six-month job, and I wanted to express interest in being on the committee, I think it's very important that we fill this position and soon, and I understand that summer bill is just about to hire a new clerk too.

2759
04:15:26,800 --> 04:15:29,980
So I hope they haven't snatched the best candidate.

2760
04:15:30,300 --> 04:15:32,500
So I think we need to get on it.

2761
04:15:33,100 --> 04:15:37,420
And again, Paula, thank you so much for all of your service.

2762
04:15:38,320 --> 04:15:46,440
But anyway, so I'm eager for us to advance and to find someone that can do the job.

2763
04:15:46,920 --> 04:15:47,620
Thank you.

2764
04:15:48,240 --> 04:15:48,800
Thank you.

2765
04:15:48,920 --> 04:15:49,880
Thank you, Councillor Susanne.

2766
04:15:51,020 --> 04:15:52,320
Look forward to hearing from others.

2767
04:15:52,640 --> 04:15:53,200
Yes, Councillor.

2768
04:15:54,620 --> 04:16:16,400
I'm happy to serve on the committee, Madam Mia, but I confess that, no matter how hot I work in it, we're not going to find anybody as talented and as experienced and as racist, gracious as Paul a crane. So maybe I shouldn't serve on the committee because I don't want to be blamed for hiring her replacement because she's irreplaceable.

2769
04:16:17,860 --> 04:16:21,500
We appreciate your part. Thank you so much. Thank you.

2770
04:16:22,340 --> 04:16:27,560
And I think the best gift to you would be to find someone. And so we will, we're on it.

2771
04:16:28,500 --> 04:16:34,760
So on that on a counselor on a motion by Councillor Zousie to adopt this policy order.

2772
04:16:35,240 --> 04:16:40,520
And then place communication at the from other city officers on file. We'll do a roll call.

2773
04:16:40,520 --> 04:16:45,400
Councillor Azubi. Yes. Yes. Vice-Mairzine. Yes. Yes.

2774
04:16:45,400 --> 04:16:51,260
Council of Plarity. Yes. Yes. Council of Montgomery. Yes. Yes.

2775
04:16:51,280 --> 04:16:54,060
Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councilor Simmons.

2776
04:16:56,200 --> 04:16:56,420
Yes.

2777
04:16:56,940 --> 04:16:59,920
Sorry. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes.

2778
04:16:59,920 --> 04:17:01,960
Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes.

2779
04:17:01,960 --> 04:17:05,660
Mayor C. D. K. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

2780
04:17:07,380 --> 04:17:15,800
policy order number nine is adopted, and the city manager, the communications from other city

2781
04:17:15,800 --> 04:17:24,180
officers is placed on file or done with policy orders, but we're not done with the calendar,

2782
04:17:24,500 --> 04:17:31,740
so we'll move on to the calendar. There are two items on the calendar, so we'll go to the number one item,

2783
04:17:31,740 --> 04:17:37,340
which is a communication transmitted from the on-wallung city manager relative to the final landmark

2784
04:17:37,340 --> 04:17:44,180
designation report for the Nathaniel Sikney House at 45-month Auburn Street. This

2785
04:17:44,180 --> 04:17:50,360
charter rate was exercised by Councilor Alzubi at our last Councilor meeting, January 12th,

2786
04:17:50,440 --> 04:17:57,200
so I will go to Councilor Alzubi. Thank you Madam Mayor. So some context I exercised my charter

2787
04:17:57,200 --> 04:18:00,920
right to better understand what was going on in the case of this landmarking decision.

2788
04:18:01,960 --> 04:18:06,260
Tonight, I will be voting in favor of landmarking the Nathaniel Stichney House for two

2789
04:18:06,260 --> 04:18:11,140
main reasons that I just wanted to note the first is recognizing the significance of the space

2790
04:18:11,140 --> 04:18:16,060
within a historical district such as Harvard's and I believe that landmarking can assist with

2791
04:18:16,060 --> 04:18:19,780
appreciating its significance historically, culturally and socially.

2792
04:18:20,100 --> 04:18:23,160
I mean, we're talking about one of the most historical areas in the United States.

2793
04:18:23,160 --> 04:18:28,980
The second is out of support for the organizations and people who made the Democracy Center what it was.

2794
04:18:29,200 --> 04:18:38,020
My understanding is that there could have been significantly more intentionality placed into bringing community members and organizations into the conversation about next steps.

2795
04:18:38,700 --> 04:18:47,380
It has been almost two years since this has started, granted probably more because it's not easy to take the step to close down and think about the future.

2796
04:18:47,380 --> 04:18:59,840
And I know Ian is interested in doing that work and I believe him in good faith and because of that, I think this landmarking could help give us a chance to bring in more of that collaboration on the historic community pieces, all yield.

2797
04:19:02,570 --> 04:19:06,210
We'll go to Conther, as Ian and then Councillor Serena Wheeler.

2798
04:19:07,210 --> 04:19:07,930
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

2799
04:19:09,130 --> 04:19:12,230
I will not be voting in favor of this today.

2800
04:19:12,230 --> 04:19:20,890
You know, first of all, I would say that Harvard's quiz already a conservation district is in large, ready and extensive process in place to make sure that buildings fit the character.

2801
04:19:21,750 --> 04:19:24,190
And it's a conservation district that I strongly support.

2802
04:20:01,660 --> 04:20:06,020
Vindictive, you know, rapport in that sense that like we all know that the real reason

2803
04:20:06,020 --> 04:20:10,120
here is not because certain, suddenly people had a very different feeling about like the

2804
04:20:10,120 --> 04:20:15,780
historical nature of the house, but rather because, you know, in order to do the renovations,

2805
04:20:16,020 --> 04:20:20,000
people had to be moved out, but also like, you know, for a long time the democracy center

2806
04:20:20,000 --> 04:20:25,080
was providing low income space as a benefit to the community and it's unfair. I think in my

2807
04:20:25,080 --> 04:20:30,000
for them to be punished for doing that as a community service and also I think that it's

2808
04:20:30,000 --> 04:20:35,000
abusing our historical process because this in no way will keep that use the same or anything

2809
04:20:35,000 --> 04:20:39,000
else. It will just keep the building in the same way that those renovations can't happen because

2810
04:20:39,000 --> 04:20:44,220
people are upset about the fact that you know people had to be moved but I will also say that like

2811
04:20:44,220 --> 04:20:50,620
you know the owners of the property have indicated every desire to welcome people back in after

2812
04:20:50,620 --> 04:20:54,660
everything is done and so and work with the community to help people

2813
04:20:54,660 --> 04:20:58,880
going forward. So for all those reasons I don't think I can support this as a nation. Thank you.

2814
04:21:00,060 --> 04:21:04,340
We're going to consider being a winner. Thanks so much through you. I spent a lot of time

2815
04:21:04,340 --> 04:21:09,060
in this building at organizing meetings at campaign launches at South Bayesian Community

2816
04:21:09,060 --> 04:21:12,920
Open mics and I was proud to be the lead sponsor of a policy order last term

2817
04:21:12,920 --> 04:21:17,000
calling on the foundation for civic leadership to keep the democracy center open and

2818
04:21:17,000 --> 04:21:20,300
listen to the community groups that were impacted and sit down and have more meetings with them

2819
04:21:20,300 --> 04:21:26,600
and come to our resolution, we need more community gathering spaces like the one that served,

2820
04:21:26,800 --> 04:21:30,820
we have some wonderful public libraries and meeting rooms and public buildings and Cambridge,

2821
04:21:31,060 --> 04:21:35,920
but there's a real demand for more. This lane-marking petition by the historical commission

2822
04:21:35,920 --> 04:21:41,220
unfortunately doesn't do anything to mandate that the foundation for civic leadership or any other

2823
04:21:41,220 --> 04:21:45,860
entity that would be in this building actually use this building as a community gathering space

2824
04:21:45,860 --> 04:21:55,580
If the historical commission had submitted a petition that did that, or if the still commission put forward a proposal for the city to purchase this building, I would vote for that in a heartbeat.

2825
04:21:56,080 --> 04:22:05,460
But in reading through the report, it's pretty clear that it would only preserve specific architectural features of the building and not any protections for actual community use.

2826
04:22:05,460 --> 04:22:08,600
The landmarking would still even allow for major changes to the building.

2827
04:22:08,980 --> 04:22:11,340
There's a line directly from the prediction, quote,

2828
04:22:11,840 --> 04:22:16,360
the proposed designation offers approval in principle for removal of the L and one strict

2829
04:22:16,360 --> 04:22:21,040
brick addition, as well as relocation of the house to the corner of Duolf Street to accommodate

2830
04:22:21,040 --> 04:22:27,280
new construction. The only thing the land provides landmark protection for our specific

2831
04:22:27,280 --> 04:22:31,760
features and keeping the building roughly the same size, but even that could change.

2832
04:22:31,760 --> 04:22:40,520
provide another layer of bureaucracy, but not any meaningful protections for the building itself that the Harvard Square historic district doesn't already provide.

2833
04:22:41,140 --> 04:22:50,180
The importance of the building has been in its use as a community gathering space, not in the architectural features that are honestly pretty similar to hundreds of other buildings in Cambridge.

2834
04:22:50,680 --> 04:22:56,560
If the landmark process did anything to actually guarantee its use as a community space, I would gladly vote for it.

2835
04:22:56,560 --> 04:23:07,420
I think that's the situation also, you really underlines that we shouldn't have to rely on private entities like the Foundation Pacific Leadership to voluntarily provide affordable public meeting and gathering spaces for Cambridge residents.

2836
04:23:08,080 --> 04:23:15,560
You know, the city of Cambridge as a public entity should be the one ensuring that we provide more of those spaces. I hope that's where we can continue to pursue this term. I go back.

2837
04:23:16,640 --> 04:23:18,560
We will go to concert fairity.

2838
04:23:21,410 --> 04:23:26,610
Thank you for supporting the landmark designation of this building.

2839
04:23:26,970 --> 04:23:28,610
I know the building very well.

2840
04:23:28,890 --> 04:23:37,470
So matter of fact, I visited the building many years ago before the democracy centre was in there.

2841
04:23:38,510 --> 04:23:41,470
And I'm familiar with it's decay.

2842
04:23:41,470 --> 04:23:52,670
And I would say I agree with Councillor Azim that this seems to me to be sort of an abuse

2843
04:23:52,670 --> 04:23:57,590
of the historical process because this is a building that falls in the jurisdiction of the

2844
04:23:57,590 --> 04:24:04,210
Harvard Square neighborhood conservation district and this is a further encombrance that

2845
04:24:04,210 --> 04:24:09,150
I think erodes from the importance of the historical commission.

2846
04:24:09,150 --> 04:24:16,110
Now, I fully appreciate the work that the historical commission does and Mr. Sullivan,

2847
04:24:16,310 --> 04:24:19,490
at the historical commission, I think, is outstanding.

2848
04:24:20,610 --> 04:24:22,990
But when I looked at this, I did a little research.

2849
04:24:23,530 --> 04:24:31,650
I think, as a initial report, it was to recommend to decline the petition for the reasons

2850
04:24:31,650 --> 04:24:33,070
in his original report.

2851
04:24:33,130 --> 04:24:34,730
And I think I'm correct about that.

2852
04:24:34,730 --> 04:24:41,910
So I will not be voting to designate this as a landmark because then it would be I think

2853
04:24:41,910 --> 04:24:47,970
only the 44th building in the history of the city of Cambridge to be a landmark and

2854
04:24:47,970 --> 04:24:50,990
this building does not fit that criteria might be.

2855
04:24:50,990 --> 04:24:53,570
We'll go to the Constitutional Assembly.

2856
04:24:55,550 --> 04:24:59,970
Point of information, can we bring Charlie Sullivan from the Historic?

2857
04:25:00,000 --> 04:25:09,240
I apologize. He was on prior, and I don't see him in the Zoom at all now. We can try to get him a link.

2858
04:25:10,160 --> 04:25:29,220
Yeah. I don't think we should be making a decision tonight without hearing from Charlie. And I mean, when I day would be to move this discussion to a neighborhood in long-term planning, committee meeting to better understand his arguments for why it should be landmarked.

2859
04:25:29,220 --> 04:25:36,620
I mean, what I took from the report was that the building has significance for many different

2860
04:25:36,620 --> 04:25:41,740
reasons, not only because of its association with the democracy center.

2861
04:25:41,840 --> 04:25:49,920
It was really powerful to hear so many of our public presenters talk tonight about the important

2862
04:25:49,920 --> 04:25:55,420
role that a democracy center has played in their lives and in the history of Cambridge and

2863
04:25:55,420 --> 04:26:03,980
square. The history of Nathaniel Stickney as someone that was a lumber dealer and a warfoperator,

2864
04:26:04,140 --> 04:26:13,160
but it sounds like it's really the rare wooden frame building that the historic commission union

2865
04:26:13,160 --> 04:26:18,360
and emissary thought, you know, well, all these things they thought it was important, but they also,

2866
04:26:18,360 --> 04:26:19,200
So,

2867
04:26:22,340 --> 04:26:27,500
they were worried about the view shed and as I was walking up Mount Auburn Street from

2868
04:26:27,500 --> 04:26:36,440
Harvard Square towards Central to City Hall, I was really aware, I think what Landmarking

2869
04:26:36,440 --> 04:26:41,800
would allow is for there to be some review in the development of the property.

2870
04:26:41,800 --> 04:26:50,740
And I guess I really would trust the historic commission in helping to facilitate that review.

2871
04:26:52,080 --> 04:27:00,020
I would hate to have the Bell Tower, the view of the Bell Tower, which is one of those quintessential views blocked by the new buildings.

2872
04:27:00,260 --> 04:27:08,520
So I just feel like so instead of it being as of right with this landmarking, there would be some review in the development of the site.

2873
04:27:08,520 --> 04:27:14,640
that was one of the reasons that it seemed really important to do. I was impressed with the

2874
04:27:14,640 --> 04:27:20,940
allowances that the historic commission had made in the development of the site. They said,

2875
04:27:20,940 --> 04:27:25,660
you know, they could change the developer, can change the entrance. He can remove the side,

2876
04:27:25,960 --> 04:27:32,240
addition. He can remove the back addition. He can even move the house. So I felt like there had been

2877
04:27:32,240 --> 04:27:39,200
a lot of flexibility. And I also just wanted to say in talking to Charlie recently about how many

2878
04:27:39,200 --> 04:27:46,340
historical properties have been evaluated for historic review. As of like two weeks ago,

2879
04:27:46,340 --> 04:27:52,420
you know, 240 properties had been reviewed, but the historic commission is really trying to be really

2880
04:27:52,420 --> 04:27:58,000
thoughtful about how many they consider historical because they don't want to get in the way of

2881
04:27:58,000 --> 04:28:07,840
development. So they're only saying like that 60, 60 buildings, that's a quarter of 240 or historically

2882
04:28:07,840 --> 04:28:14,020
significant. But they are saying this building is historically significant. They've been working with

2883
04:28:15,220 --> 04:28:21,140
and Simon's of the foundation for civic leadership for years on it. It seems like they have a

2884
04:28:21,140 --> 04:28:25,520
of a set of relationship. I was asking Charlie about, um, um,

2885
04:28:25,620 --> 04:28:31,460
set counselor Nolan's point that it might add to the expense of the redevelopment of the site.

2886
04:28:31,980 --> 04:28:36,540
And, you know, apparently, you know, this sort of commission doesn't have any control over the interior

2887
04:28:36,540 --> 04:28:43,500
of the building, but only the exterior. But he, he said the interior had basically been gutted.

2888
04:28:43,760 --> 04:28:50,640
Apologies, counselors, Lucy. Um, Mr. Sullivan has joined. Okay. Great. Uh, I yield to Mr. Sullivan.

2889
04:28:51,140 --> 04:28:58,580
And I think it would be good to just go around to those who do want to speak on this so far I've heard.

2890
04:28:58,680 --> 04:29:07,520
One counselor who is supportive, I guess two counselors who are supportive of designation, three who are not.

2891
04:29:08,400 --> 04:29:17,480
Are there particular questions that others have that we can lay out for director Sullivan?

2892
04:29:18,360 --> 04:29:24,480
Anyone who hasn't spoken on this or would do you like to hear from?

2893
04:29:25,640 --> 04:29:27,100
Then you are like the director.

2894
04:29:28,440 --> 04:29:28,560
Okay.

2895
04:29:29,020 --> 04:29:29,800
All right, director Sullivan.

2896
04:29:30,020 --> 04:29:32,720
Do you want to go through us with us?

2897
04:29:34,810 --> 04:29:35,410
Thank you.

2898
04:29:40,640 --> 04:29:42,380
Did you get the questions director Sullivan?

2899
04:29:43,980 --> 04:29:48,280
Or did you hear what was said prior?

2900
04:29:51,520 --> 04:29:52,120
I'll look at you.

2901
04:29:52,240 --> 04:29:53,480
Can you hear us?

2902
04:29:55,560 --> 04:29:59,560
Let me text him, sorry folks. Yeah, I don't think he can hear it.

2903
04:30:00,660 --> 04:30:03,580
Got to love Zoom, right?

2904
04:30:06,040 --> 04:30:24,060
Mayor, did you get my question though? So, it was about whether, if the historic commission was involved, whether it would really increase the cost of renovating the building, whether there was significant detail to increase the cost.

2905
04:30:24,740 --> 04:30:27,200
And Dr. Selen, you're still, we can't hear you.

2906
04:30:30,600 --> 04:30:32,180
Oh, no, we can see, but not here.

2907
04:30:32,420 --> 04:30:34,360
Sorry, we can see you, we can't hear you.

2908
04:30:43,950 --> 04:30:47,970
Charlie, if you can dial in on your phone,

2909
04:30:48,130 --> 04:30:50,730
I'm about to email you the dial in instructions.

2910
04:31:01,040 --> 04:31:03,400
We're just holding, we're materially.

2911
04:31:38,620 --> 04:31:40,480
Sorry, I wasn't prepared to have the exact tonight.

2912
04:31:40,920 --> 04:31:41,320
Sorry.

2913
04:31:42,380 --> 04:31:43,680
You can, I don't know if there's other agenda.

2914
04:31:43,740 --> 04:31:44,980
I know it was Charlie's right next door.

2915
04:31:45,020 --> 04:31:46,900
You can also walk over and go into my office.

2916
04:31:48,700 --> 04:31:49,440
What did you say?

2917
04:31:49,440 --> 04:31:59,620
I was just saying I don't know. There's other agenda items. I think Charlie's right next door and could walk over to my office this quickly as we can figure this out.

2918
04:32:00,140 --> 04:32:03,000
I did also send him the phone dial in.

2919
04:32:03,180 --> 04:32:04,260
I want to say anything.

2920
04:32:05,480 --> 04:32:07,600
Councillor Simmons, what did you say?

2921
04:32:08,000 --> 04:32:11,400
I was going to say to be want to go to the next item and then come back to Charlie.

2922
04:32:12,140 --> 04:32:17,760
Yeah, what we can do is we only have we don't ever have anything else in the calendar,

2923
04:32:17,760 --> 04:32:25,680
but in the meantime, we can go to the right item, this one would try to write. Charlie, do you want

2924
04:32:25,680 --> 04:32:28,700
to go to the city hall and I can meet you there?

2925
04:32:31,040 --> 04:32:33,480
I don't think you can hear you. I'll call on you.

2926
04:32:34,440 --> 04:32:41,680
So we'll go to charter item. That the city manager is requested to conduct a comprehensive review of

2927
04:32:41,680 --> 04:32:46,760
existing safety and security measures at Cambridge City Hall, which shall include an assessment

2928
04:32:46,760 --> 04:32:52,440
physical access controls, visitor screening practices, on-site security staffing, and training,

2929
04:32:52,660 --> 04:32:58,620
emergency response, and evacuation protocols and the use of security technologies such as surveillance

2930
04:32:58,620 --> 04:33:05,200
systems and alarm monitoring. Charterite was exercised by Councillor Simmons. Actually,

2931
04:33:06,800 --> 04:33:12,500
yeah, it was Councillor Simmons, and then I know there was a discussion of amendment that does

2932
04:33:12,500 --> 04:33:18,820
carry over. But Councillor Simmons, please go ahead. Thank you, man in there. I just want to

2933
04:33:18,820 --> 04:33:24,440
start first of all by just a small housekeeping issue. Councillor McGurham had asked to be a

2934
04:33:24,440 --> 04:33:29,840
co-sponsor but in the process of working on the policy order, we had a little technical problem

2935
04:33:29,840 --> 04:33:35,660
when he was not added. So the first thing I'd like to do is to add that we amend the policy order

2936
04:33:35,660 --> 04:33:42,080
by adding Councillor McGurham. We can do that now. I can go through my remarks and come back to what

2937
04:33:42,080 --> 04:33:50,560
question. I think let's just go do that now, in case we'll do. We'll do a real call on

2938
04:33:50,560 --> 04:33:56,340
Councillor Simmons motion to add Councillor McGovern. Councillor Elzuby. Yes. Yes. Vice-Mayor

2939
04:33:56,340 --> 04:34:08,420
Resene. Yes. Yes. Councillor LaFlarity. Yes. Yes. Councillor McGovern. Yes. Yes. Councillor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councillor Simmons. Yes.

2940
04:34:08,420 --> 04:34:16,340
Councillor Sabrina Wheeler? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded

2941
04:34:16,340 --> 04:34:21,520
in the affirmative. Councillor McEvers added. Councillor Simmons, please go ahead.

2942
04:34:22,060 --> 04:34:28,400
Well, thank you. So I exercised my charter, right, because I knew there was a amendment that was

2943
04:34:28,400 --> 04:34:35,140
added by my colleague. I'll do the answer being a Wheeler and I want that opportunity to talk

2944
04:34:35,140 --> 04:34:39,200
who their amendment with them and we did have that opportunity.

2945
04:34:39,480 --> 04:34:44,620
So I want to acknowledge and thank them for taking my call and having an opportunity to talk

2946
04:34:44,620 --> 04:34:50,780
to them a little bit about the reason behind my policy order and they proposed the amendment.

2947
04:34:51,420 --> 04:34:59,400
And so for me, I also want to be very clear to my colleagues at large about the policy order

2948
04:34:59,400 --> 04:34:59,980
and what it is.

2949
04:35:00,000 --> 04:35:07,580
This is not about turning city hall into a fortress. It's not about making this building inhospitable or unwelcoming.

2950
04:35:08,400 --> 04:35:20,600
It's not about flooding city hall with police weapons or aggressive enforcement. City hall, as to be all green must remain open, accessible, and fundamentally democratic, and that is not negotiable.

2951
04:35:20,600 --> 04:35:24,920
But what this is about is safety, plain and simple.

2952
04:35:25,560 --> 04:35:31,480
We're asking for a serious professional review, not saying that I reconcelted, but I am

2953
04:35:31,480 --> 04:35:37,500
looking for a serious professional review, where we stand today, not because something terrible

2954
04:35:37,500 --> 04:35:45,240
is happening to you, but because you recognize that we live in a world, that we live in this

2955
04:35:45,240 --> 04:35:50,200
world, and we have to be responsible to the people who work in the building and the

2956
04:35:50,200 --> 04:35:56,280
gag. Right now, City Hall has very limited mechanisms to know who is entering the building,

2957
04:35:57,060 --> 04:36:03,320
who remains inside it, or how to respond to a situation if it escalates quickly. Over

2958
04:36:03,320 --> 04:36:08,600
the past two decades alone, we have had more than a few moments that were uncomfortable,

2959
04:36:09,460 --> 04:36:14,060
close to something that may be happening worse. And the only reason those moments did not

2960
04:36:14,060 --> 04:36:20,180
turn into tragedies is the lock. And luck is not a safety strategy. Across the country

2961
04:36:20,180 --> 04:36:25,660
three municipal buildings like ours have been the sites of real violence, elected officials

2962
04:36:25,660 --> 04:36:31,620
staff and members of the public have been killed inside spaces designated for civic participation.

2963
04:36:32,400 --> 04:36:36,760
These are not hypothetical scenarios and they're not ancient history.

2964
04:36:37,500 --> 04:36:43,040
The recent incident in Lawrence can, Lawrence Kansas, is a stark reminder that the risk

2965
04:36:43,040 --> 04:36:49,960
remain very veal, and very current. None of us wants to be standing here after an incident,

2966
04:36:50,260 --> 04:36:54,680
whether it happens in Cambridge or somewhere uncomfortable to close the home, being asked

2967
04:36:55,240 --> 04:37:00,220
to, you know, why didn't you do more? Why didn't you do anything when you had a chance?

2968
04:37:00,800 --> 04:37:06,700
So this policy order does not dictate solutions, it does not pre-approose surveillance systems,

2969
04:37:06,700 --> 04:37:13,540
access controls or staffing models, and ask the city manager to do what we should expect any

2970
04:37:13,540 --> 04:37:19,940
responsible administrative to do, take a comprehensive look at existing conditions, identify

2971
04:37:19,940 --> 04:37:24,980
vulnerabilities, and come back to the council with some concrete, thoughtful recommendations,

2972
04:37:25,620 --> 04:37:30,980
recommendations that would require council review and approval, think that's important to say,

2973
04:37:30,980 --> 04:37:35,900
We're not asked to act blindly, we're asked to plan deliberately.

2974
04:37:36,860 --> 04:37:41,020
Other municipalities have found ways to find the balance between openness with lay-up

2975
04:37:41,020 --> 04:37:43,120
proportions of safety measures.

2976
04:37:43,720 --> 04:37:49,000
KVTB capable of doing the same, and in a way that reflex our values, our scale, and our

2977
04:37:49,000 --> 04:37:50,200
commitment to transparency.

2978
04:37:51,320 --> 04:37:56,000
Taking safety seriously does not mean abandoning openness, it means protecting it.

2979
04:37:56,340 --> 04:38:00,680
I hope my college will support this order not out of fear, but out of responsibility

2980
04:38:00,680 --> 04:38:03,840
to our staff, to our constituents and to ourselves,

2981
04:38:06,240 --> 04:38:08,500
so that we are not wishing that we had

2982
04:38:08,500 --> 04:38:15,120
active sooner. I believe Ms. Stefan has a copy of a amendment that I made acknowledging

2983
04:38:15,120 --> 04:38:21,100
my colleagues a concerns around this policy order. She can bring that up on the screen.

2984
04:38:22,140 --> 04:38:28,000
I will be able to flow over for the discussion and I hope that you will favor me and my colleagues

2985
04:38:28,000 --> 04:38:29,840
Thank you.

2986
04:38:30,120 --> 04:38:30,340
Thank you.

2987
04:38:30,340 --> 04:38:30,460
Thank you.

2988
04:38:30,460 --> 04:38:30,580
Thank you.

2989
04:38:30,580 --> 04:38:30,860
Thank you.

2990
04:38:30,860 --> 04:38:31,700
Thank you.

2991
04:38:31,720 --> 04:38:32,580
Thank you.

2992
04:38:44,370 --> 04:38:50,890
Just to kind of piggyback on what Councillor Simmons said, you know, I, I think,

2993
04:38:51,590 --> 04:38:54,570
I think that there is a way to balance

2994
04:38:55,230 --> 04:39:09,700
increased safety without becoming a building that is inhospitable. I certainly do not want people to feel that way. I want people to feel welcome in city hall and I also understand that

2995
04:39:11,810 --> 04:39:23,810
things can happen and things can happen here. You know the one thing that most of these communities that see some some type of

2996
04:39:23,810 --> 04:39:25,930
I'll say, we never thought it could happen here.

2997
04:39:26,070 --> 04:39:30,100
I can't believe this happened here, right?

2998
04:39:30,460 --> 04:39:32,640
So to think that somehow Cambridge is somehow

2999
04:39:32,640 --> 04:39:35,260
magically immune to something bad happening,

3000
04:39:36,320 --> 04:39:37,620
I wish that were the case.

3001
04:39:38,620 --> 04:39:39,080
It's not.

3002
04:39:40,160 --> 04:39:43,040
And so I would like to get a report back from the manager

3003
04:39:43,040 --> 04:39:44,800
with some ideas and some recommendations.

3004
04:39:45,080 --> 04:39:47,120
I may not support all of those recommendations.

3005
04:39:47,320 --> 04:39:48,680
I may not support any of those recommendations.

3006
04:39:49,360 --> 04:39:53,400
If he comes back and says, we should have

3007
04:39:53,400 --> 04:39:59,980
military personnel at every door i would not want that right but if he comes back and says we can put a panic button in each

3008
04:40:00,000 --> 04:40:19,300
Office, so that if, you know, an employee, and let's remember, we also employ a lot of older folks in our building who may not feel as comfortable dealing with someone who is being threatening or being dangerous, or, you know, the button that they're desk that they can press to alert the police officers who's downstairs.

3009
04:40:19,920 --> 04:40:30,480
You know, that's not going to hinder anyone from coming into City Hall, but it would add an extra level of safety for those folks should they find themselves alone in their office with someone who is

3010
04:40:31,780 --> 04:40:35,280
You know threatening them. So there is a way to do this

3011
04:40:36,240 --> 04:40:45,520
Without it without city hall becoming an inhospitable fortress. So I would like to hear those recommendations back from the city manager again

3012
04:40:45,520 --> 04:40:51,180
make support some of them, not others, but let's get this report and get these things in front of

3013
04:40:51,180 --> 04:40:55,800
us so that we can have a broader conversation about it. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I yield.

3014
04:40:56,400 --> 04:41:03,960
Well, good. It comes to a fairity. Thank you, Madam Mayor, through you. I fully support

3015
04:41:03,960 --> 04:41:09,840
what tons of Simmons has put forward. I'm in public buildings throughout this commonwealth every

3016
04:41:09,840 --> 04:41:18,140
single day. I'm in court houses in very urban areas, very rural areas, federal, state,

3017
04:41:18,560 --> 04:41:25,220
a pallet, district, pro-be courts, and there's a metal detector at the front door of every single

3018
04:41:25,220 --> 04:41:32,980
one of them. It does not make the buildings inhospitable, but it elevates decorum, and it's a,

3019
04:41:32,980 --> 04:41:38,820
it's a security measure that I think is necessary in public buildings because

3020
04:41:38,820 --> 04:41:48,620
all of us, as members of the city council, whether we like it or not, in today's age, because

3021
04:41:48,620 --> 04:41:56,020
of our function become a person who's potentially the target of someone,

3022
04:41:58,320 --> 04:41:59,020
because of their

3023
04:41:59,020 --> 04:42:07,980
disagreement or whatever it may be, so I think that it's incumbent on all of us and the entire

3024
04:42:07,980 --> 04:42:15,600
staff in the building to have a thoughtful security plan present in the building in the event

3025
04:42:15,600 --> 04:42:21,700
that there is some sort of an emergency that arises. So I fully support this policy out of

3026
04:42:21,700 --> 04:42:28,800
thank you, I yield. Councillor Azim and then Councillor Nolan. Thank you. I was going to say

3027
04:42:28,800 --> 04:42:33,080
the same thing when I first came into City Hall. I was very skeptical of measures like these,

3028
04:42:33,780 --> 04:42:41,580
But over my time, I've seen both, you know, the Massachusetts State House and Boston City Hall have measures, and I feel like they're still equally welcoming.

3029
04:42:42,980 --> 04:42:49,840
And in fact, I would say that it's more welcoming in some ways. It's nice to be in a space where you feel like automatically a little bit safer than you do outside.

3030
04:42:51,000 --> 04:43:00,140
You know, there's a lot of different sorts of people that walk into Cambridge City Hall, not just residents of Cambridge, or like people who come here for public comment, but really anyone.

3031
04:43:00,140 --> 04:43:06,320
And I think that it really just helps to have a little bit of confirmation of what do we do in terms of emergencies.

3032
04:43:07,040 --> 04:43:15,800
I know that during my time in city hall, people have gotten in myself included letters from people with, you know, sometimes vague, sometimes less than vague threats.

3033
04:43:16,220 --> 04:43:24,000
I still get emails from time to time with threats, especially after inauguration this time from white supremacist sorts of situations.

3034
04:43:25,020 --> 04:43:28,740
And you really do worry like what happens at any particular moment.

3035
04:43:29,800 --> 04:43:35,800
And it's not my intention of any way of making it less welcoming, but hopefully just, you know, a higher assumption of safety.

3036
04:43:36,280 --> 04:43:40,040
And I would say like the small little caveat I would throw out there as well is like,

3037
04:43:40,040 --> 04:43:43,260
oftentimes in these metal detectors, your badges are also thrown.

3038
04:43:43,600 --> 04:43:45,740
And so I know there'll be a separate conversation about,

3039
04:43:46,520 --> 04:43:48,540
I saw if there's in multiple buildings and things like that.

3040
04:43:48,860 --> 04:43:53,220
And so we want to use for them to get their badge out of their pocket and have to put it through the detector.

3041
04:43:54,120 --> 04:43:56,040
So for all those reasons, I'm happy to support.

3042
04:43:57,290 --> 04:43:58,930
Councilor Nolan?

3043
04:44:00,490 --> 04:44:05,510
Thank you, and through you, Mayor Sediki, to my colleagues, I can support this.

3044
04:44:05,710 --> 04:44:10,570
I find myself with appreciative of Councilor Simmons for bringing this forward.

3045
04:44:10,870 --> 04:44:18,650
It makes sense to have a review, and also, as Councilor McGuvern said, depending on what measures

3046
04:44:19,650 --> 04:44:23,630
are suggested, I have no idea what I would support.

3047
04:44:23,630 --> 04:44:29,970
But I am mixed on this, on the one hand, very much understand that we all need to be safe.

3048
04:45:00,000 --> 04:45:14,800
In Salt Lake City, just a couple months ago for National League of Cities, I walked right into an incredibly beautiful state house, the capital of the state house, no security whatsoever.

3049
04:45:15,200 --> 04:45:27,380
It was open to the public. It felt unbelievably welcoming. People were wondering, this is on a weekend yet. It wasn't even during the week. It just felt like, wow, this is the kind of welcoming city hall we should have.

3050
04:45:27,380 --> 04:45:31,580
So I think what's going to be critically important is for us to not feel like a fortress

3051
04:45:31,580 --> 04:45:38,840
whatever happens to obviously balance that safety with an approachable open city hall

3052
04:45:38,840 --> 04:45:45,740
where people are not feeling that they don't belong and I know that is the intention here

3053
04:45:45,740 --> 04:45:51,160
which is why I can support it and I also very much hope that we do everything we can to make

3054
04:45:51,160 --> 04:45:57,720
that people throughout the city feel welcome and to city hall that and yet to address the

3055
04:45:57,720 --> 04:46:03,560
the very real concern about safety makes sense to me. But again, there's plenty of places

3056
04:46:03,560 --> 04:46:09,240
in this country that have managed to have safe environments and have not gone overboard with

3057
04:46:10,280 --> 04:46:15,700
as scaring people and to feeling that they don't feel safe. So I very much look forward to the

3058
04:46:15,700 --> 04:46:19,900
view of our current situation and appreciate the policy order

3059
04:46:19,900 --> 04:46:21,320
who's intent is that.

3060
04:46:23,200 --> 04:46:27,600
I have Councillor Azubi and then I'll go to our city manager and then

3061
04:46:27,600 --> 04:46:29,580
to the amendment by Councillor Simmons.

3062
04:46:30,980 --> 04:46:31,720
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

3063
04:46:31,880 --> 04:46:35,960
It might make sense that I go after because I will be proposing an

3064
04:46:35,960 --> 04:46:40,440
amendment to what I believe is the amended policy order that Councillor

3065
04:46:41,060 --> 04:46:44,980
Simmons is going to pull on the floor with Councillor's

3066
04:46:44,980 --> 04:46:48,360
clarity in the government, if I understood that correctly.

3067
04:46:49,480 --> 04:46:50,500
Councillor Simmons?

3068
04:46:51,820 --> 04:46:52,340
Yes.

3069
04:46:53,100 --> 04:46:54,320
Do you have the amendment?

3070
04:46:54,840 --> 04:46:55,160
I don't know.

3071
04:46:55,260 --> 04:46:55,460
I'm sorry.

3072
04:46:55,620 --> 04:46:56,800
Naomi has it.

3073
04:46:57,040 --> 04:46:58,540
Do you want to walk us through it?

3074
04:46:59,440 --> 04:47:00,460
It's very short.

3075
04:47:00,680 --> 04:47:02,980
It's at the very end and it says.

3076
04:47:04,240 --> 04:47:05,720
I'm waiting for it.

3077
04:47:06,440 --> 04:47:07,920
I'm subject to city council approval.

3078
04:47:08,700 --> 04:47:13,380
If I understood and truly, I understood what my colleagues were saying.

3079
04:47:13,380 --> 04:47:18,960
They want to be sure that nothing went through without the council approval, which, you know,

3080
04:47:19,180 --> 04:47:22,060
and I've having had the benefit of being on the council for a long time.

3081
04:47:22,080 --> 04:47:28,280
I know that we don't usually do things that quickly, but I wanted to, in the spirit of collaboration

3082
04:47:28,280 --> 04:47:34,280
and cooperation and collegiality, I wanted to add this language to assure my colleagues that

3083
04:47:34,280 --> 04:47:42,160
we would not be taking any actions on any proposed implementation without having it approved

3084
04:47:42,160 --> 04:47:48,840
by the city council and it has two pathways directly to the council or if you go through any

3085
04:47:48,840 --> 04:47:49,660
number of committees.

3086
04:47:49,900 --> 04:47:50,740
I yield.

3087
04:47:51,680 --> 04:47:55,240
So, we have this amendment before us discussion on the amendment.

3088
04:47:59,730 --> 04:48:02,230
We will go to Councillor D.C.

3089
04:48:02,890 --> 04:48:03,170
Yes.

3090
04:48:03,470 --> 04:48:03,950
Councillor Nolan?

3091
04:48:06,190 --> 04:48:10,650
I don't understand why there would be parentheses around it.

3092
04:48:10,730 --> 04:48:15,510
I mean, it may seem minor, but it should just be subject to city council approval, right?

3093
04:48:18,950 --> 04:48:21,730
It's just a way to stand out for us to see it.

3094
04:48:21,950 --> 04:48:25,010
It's not how we would say subject to city council,

3095
04:48:25,590 --> 04:48:26,830
wouldn't have parenthesis.

3096
04:48:27,270 --> 04:48:30,370
This is just a way of emphasizing that we are making this change.

3097
04:48:30,690 --> 04:48:32,230
In addition to it being read.

3098
04:48:32,870 --> 04:48:35,250
I might have made it bold in this palace.

3099
04:48:35,850 --> 04:48:37,510
But we didn't.

3100
04:48:39,710 --> 04:48:40,990
Well, if I understand the intent,

3101
04:48:40,990 --> 04:48:43,290
Councillor Simmons, we can take out the parentheses.

3102
04:48:44,310 --> 04:48:44,450
Yes.

3103
04:48:44,570 --> 04:48:44,630
Thank you.

3104
04:48:45,310 --> 04:48:45,890
Got it.

3105
04:48:46,150 --> 04:48:46,370
Okay.

3106
04:48:46,910 --> 04:48:48,390
Because Councillor Nolan, that was your question?

3107
04:48:50,010 --> 04:48:50,290
Yes.

3108
04:48:50,990 --> 04:48:59,510
I mentioned hearing Councillor Azubis amendments because it very much assumes there will be an

3109
04:48:59,510 --> 04:49:00,610
enhanced safety plan.

3110
04:49:01,850 --> 04:49:07,310
And I think what we're all saying is there may be an enhanced safety recommendations for

3111
04:49:07,310 --> 04:49:09,630
a plan and then it would be subject to City Council approval.

3112
04:49:09,630 --> 04:49:13,750
so I support this amendment because I think it's very important that the city council

3113
04:49:13,750 --> 04:49:16,330
be involved before anything happens.

3114
04:49:16,750 --> 04:49:21,150
We'll go to Constell and Zubi and then I know the manager is on so if he wants to

3115
04:49:21,150 --> 04:49:24,410
share anything that would be great. Go ahead Constell and Zubi.

3116
04:49:25,270 --> 04:49:31,870
Yes, so I sent a ver and amended version to Councillor Simmons Flaherty and the governance

3117
04:49:33,370 --> 04:49:39,530
proposed amended policy order. And I just want to preface this conversation first with

3118
04:49:39,530 --> 04:49:44,990
saying that I really appreciate that they're bringing this to the table and I really do care

3119
04:50:00,600 --> 04:50:15,080
They do raise an important concern, and I think I'm coming from a place of wanting to make sure that first, we have a better understanding of what is going on within City Hall, from a public safety perspective, before moving forward on the next steps.

3120
04:50:15,080 --> 04:50:18,780
I mean, even in the conversation that we're having right now, we have people understanding

3121
04:50:18,780 --> 04:50:24,600
it as possibly metal detectors and then Councilor Simmons raising this is not necessarily

3122
04:50:24,600 --> 04:50:31,400
about that, which assumes certain things about the amended piece that Councilor Sabrina Wheeler

3123
04:50:31,400 --> 04:50:36,300
and I are proposing in this conversation, so we're trying to be explicitly thoughtful about this

3124
04:50:36,300 --> 04:50:40,620
because we care about our city staff and our residents as well. And I want to make sure by

3125
04:50:40,620 --> 04:50:44,220
focusing on delivering a solid report on what we currently have.

3126
04:50:44,520 --> 04:50:47,380
We can take the next step on exploring recommendations together.

3127
04:50:47,880 --> 04:50:53,160
That's part of why I decreased the days with Councillor Sabrina Wheeler to, again,

3128
04:50:53,360 --> 04:50:55,700
be thoughtful and proactive about that process.

3129
04:50:55,820 --> 04:51:01,300
And I do think that a strong foundation of understanding what's going on and tying it all together

3130
04:51:02,040 --> 04:51:08,200
with what we currently have on the amended policy order is going to harm the intentionality

3131
04:51:08,200 --> 04:51:11,000
that goes into this process.

3132
04:51:11,640 --> 04:51:14,600
So breaking it down, again, from my perspective,

3133
04:51:15,180 --> 04:51:17,620
will actually help us bring more voices into the process

3134
04:51:17,620 --> 04:51:18,940
that would make it more democratic,

3135
04:51:19,060 --> 04:51:21,440
especially when this is a space that grounds

3136
04:51:21,440 --> 04:51:22,960
the people and government engagement.

3137
04:51:23,600 --> 04:51:26,800
So I'm looking forward to hearing more about what we're doing

3138
04:51:26,800 --> 04:51:29,740
to keep City Hall safe and accessible to our residents,

3139
04:51:29,900 --> 04:51:31,540
but that's just a little bit more about

3140
04:51:31,540 --> 04:51:34,560
the thinking behind this specific amendment.

3141
04:51:39,460 --> 04:51:43,340
Can we go to City Manager?

3142
04:51:47,750 --> 04:51:49,610
Oh, thank you, Mayor Siddiqui.

3143
04:51:51,270 --> 04:51:54,630
I appreciate the discussion, and I think this is actually a really important topic.

3144
04:51:55,670 --> 04:52:00,970
And one that we may want to just approach very thoughtfully.

3145
04:52:01,610 --> 04:52:09,930
Certainly, I think this is a challenge that a lot of organizations are facing in terms of how to be open, welcoming,

3146
04:52:09,930 --> 04:52:16,670
and then real security concerns, especially as we see different incidents happen across the

3147
04:52:16,670 --> 04:52:17,170
country.

3148
04:52:18,330 --> 04:52:24,210
I think my thought would be first that I want to recognize some of the inherent challenges

3149
04:52:24,210 --> 04:52:31,510
in the layout of City Hall, in particular, the front entrance is pretty significantly stepped

3150
04:52:31,510 --> 04:52:39,830
up, and because of the American Disabilities Act and our desire to be accessible, we essentially

3151
04:52:39,830 --> 04:52:45,730
operate two entrances to the public. One in the front that is accessible by staircase, and the

3152
04:52:45,730 --> 04:52:53,230
back entrance is actually the one that you can use that's wheelchair accessible. And so I just

3153
04:52:53,230 --> 04:52:59,830
want to acknowledge that one of the logistical challenges is that we are actually covering two entrances.

3154
04:53:01,210 --> 04:53:09,430
I think the second is that it may be helpful for further engagement perhaps with a smaller group of

3155
04:53:09,430 --> 04:53:16,610
just to be specific. I think from the policy order it feels like the intent of this is mostly

3156
04:53:16,610 --> 04:53:22,730
thinking about security from the standpoint of specifically weapons. And I think that's probably

3157
04:53:22,730 --> 04:53:30,710
a little bit different than potentially a broader sense of safety, but I think that may be just

3158
04:53:30,710 --> 04:53:35,290
something for us to work out because the interventions may be a little bit different if we're thinking

3159
04:53:35,290 --> 04:53:41,610
about gun violence versus a different kind of challenge.

3160
04:53:42,010 --> 04:53:44,950
And I think that actually helps us better understand

3161
04:53:44,950 --> 04:53:49,430
what kind of technology or security solutions would fit.

3162
04:53:50,390 --> 04:53:53,230
I think the other, and so I think the second is just being clear,

3163
04:53:53,690 --> 04:53:55,390
what is the problem that we're trying to solve?

3164
04:53:56,210 --> 04:53:58,470
And the third would be to make sure that,

3165
04:53:58,470 --> 04:54:01,210
especially as we are examining this,

3166
04:54:01,570 --> 04:54:03,630
that we're also getting a sense from the council

3167
04:54:05,050 --> 04:54:09,850
on what level of comfort we have with what amount of budget and that's actually probably

3168
04:54:09,850 --> 04:54:14,110
a bit of a back and forth. I don't want to say like we need a policy or to specifically

3169
04:54:14,110 --> 04:54:18,230
says like this much I think ultimately we're going to want to both understand what the problem

3170
04:54:18,230 --> 04:54:24,650
is and then start doing some research and looking at you know what is the range of potential solutions

3171
04:54:24,650 --> 04:54:31,050
but I just want to acknowledge that some of these potential solutions could be costly and they're

3172
04:54:31,050 --> 04:54:35,150
of those people's solutions and training solutions and technical solutions.

3173
04:54:36,350 --> 04:54:41,130
And certainly if you've been, I think in other city halls or I know there are many

3174
04:54:41,130 --> 04:54:48,490
facilities within our city that have put in place very sophisticated tools, but are very

3175
04:54:48,490 --> 04:54:54,390
expensive, which actually pertain really significant senses of openness, but some of those

3176
04:54:54,390 --> 04:54:58,150
tools are actually pretty expensive.

3177
04:54:59,270 --> 04:54:59,970
So, I think it was the...

3178
04:55:00,000 --> 04:55:10,000
I think this is an important topic, but I want to just call out some expectations that this isn't going to be like the council says.

3179
04:55:10,420 --> 04:55:17,460
Go and give us a perfect answer and then we disappear and within 30 days we come back and there's an answer and we can implement it.

3180
04:55:17,980 --> 04:55:24,820
I think this is probably a longer conversation that will take more research and also more discussion to make sure remaining in the right place.

3181
04:55:26,440 --> 04:55:31,000
I would go to, I have concerts the way we are, and they'll go to concerts and I'm going to

3182
04:55:31,120 --> 04:55:31,820
Thanks, Vladimir.

3183
04:55:32,220 --> 04:55:33,280
I'll try to re-brief you.

3184
04:55:33,500 --> 04:55:35,760
I think I'm happy to support a concert.

3185
04:55:36,340 --> 04:55:37,300
I'll zoom these amendments here.

3186
04:55:37,480 --> 04:55:42,260
I think that's probably on this sort of thinking about public safety and what really

3187
04:55:42,260 --> 04:55:42,920
keeps us safe.

3188
04:55:43,060 --> 04:55:47,120
And I think that is ultimately people and community planning and communication.

3189
04:55:47,620 --> 04:55:52,820
It's easy to spend money on sort of security and public safety solutions and

3190
04:55:52,820 --> 04:55:57,920
but the real hard work is the dialogue and the planning of how do we keep each other safe.

3191
04:55:59,660 --> 04:56:05,360
I think, I had a really good, had a good conversation with councilor Simmons and councilor

3192
04:56:05,360 --> 04:56:09,500
LZB about this and one of the things I had said in that conversation was I think there's just, you know,

3193
04:56:09,500 --> 04:56:14,940
some part of the, the challenge is just the complexities, the policy order process and what are we actually asking for?

3194
04:56:15,000 --> 04:56:21,420
Are we asking for a report back? Are we asking for something to be implemented right away and reviewed and then report back?

3195
04:56:21,420 --> 04:56:33,400
And that's part of the challenge is the impreciseness of this, but I think the amendments from Councillor Zubi do help it be a little more clear in terms of what we're getting for and you know how we really focus on community safety.

3196
04:56:33,780 --> 04:56:35,240
I'll back.

3197
04:56:35,560 --> 04:56:38,560
We'll go to Councillor Simmons.

3198
04:56:40,460 --> 04:56:41,480
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

3199
04:56:42,460 --> 04:56:43,820
Two, three you to the city manager.

3200
04:56:44,740 --> 04:56:50,760
You said, I don't know if this is talking about gun violence or if you said some other things I didn't, I didn't like them all down.

3201
04:56:50,760 --> 04:56:57,580
It's talking about safety and it's brought us way and it's smallest way will it cost money?

3202
04:56:57,900 --> 04:57:08,100
Maybe maybe not but I don't think you can put a price on people's life when it comes to keeping them safe because I don't think anyone wants to be happy in the position of saying

3203
04:57:08,100 --> 04:57:13,240
I wish I would have could have would have if we had known and so again

3204
04:57:13,240 --> 04:57:17,020
It's off it's saying to the administration

3205
04:57:17,020 --> 04:57:23,200
Please look at this and hear some of some of the things that you may want to look at.

3206
04:57:23,920 --> 04:57:30,780
I'd like for the City Manager through his administration to come back with some, have looked at at a topic.

3207
04:57:32,040 --> 04:57:37,380
Given that give us some suggestions and then we work from there as opposed to,

3208
04:57:37,520 --> 04:57:41,180
well, we're going to give you a report without saying,

3209
04:57:41,180 --> 04:57:46,800
Well, this is something that I think you might want to try, and then there's the scale of something that's

3210
04:57:48,440 --> 04:57:53,180
fairly benign, whatever that might be, to something that's more stringent. I, as my colleague

3211
04:57:54,220 --> 04:57:56,260
Tell them a government said

3212
04:57:56,260 --> 04:58:02,900
We don't know until we see what other some of the options are that we might want to take

3213
04:58:03,840 --> 04:58:10,180
If we want to vote it or not, but I want to feel the work. It's a material. So we're in all do we expect to my colleagues

3214
04:58:10,180 --> 04:58:13,020
about, well, let's leave it open and let's get back in 30 days.

3215
04:58:13,420 --> 04:58:16,080
As the city manager says, it's not going to happen that quickly.

3216
04:58:17,620 --> 04:58:22,960
If you wanted to be thoughtful, the city manager and the staff engage in all the people

3217
04:58:22,960 --> 04:58:27,260
that are involved in public safety, because that doesn't quite include fire.

3218
04:58:28,660 --> 04:58:34,560
To have an opportunity to say, we looked at it, we looked at the building, here are some

3219
04:58:34,560 --> 04:58:40,880
issues that we see that could be tightened up. You might say, we think it's all fine. Nothing's

3220
04:58:40,880 --> 04:58:46,980
going to happen here. We're all good. But if we don't allow this administration to at least look

3221
04:58:46,980 --> 04:58:52,900
at our procedures and our protocols, I don't think we've ever done a safety drill, other than

3222
04:58:52,900 --> 04:58:58,120
a fire drill, and this building. And so it's very broad and I think we should keep it bright

3223
04:58:58,120 --> 04:59:03,680
and allow the administration to look at the issue, take the 90 days and if they need a little

3224
04:59:03,680 --> 04:59:08,120
longer, they take a little longer, but they say we're looking at this, we're close to

3225
04:59:08,120 --> 04:59:12,560
coming up with some information. We don't have it yet, we respectfully ask you for an extension,

3226
04:59:12,980 --> 04:59:17,800
so that they can have the time to do it correctly. And then bring it back to the council,

3227
04:59:17,820 --> 04:59:23,800
the council, can then, I think it should be a full council engagement piece, so that we're all

3228
04:59:23,800 --> 04:59:29,440
at the table all the time to talk about this. And the last thing, you said, let me go back to

3229
05:00:00,000 --> 05:00:15,180
And she might remember the name of them, but these folks came to agitate people and gotten to the law department and really rattled this young lady in the way they approached her and talked to her.

3230
05:00:15,480 --> 05:00:19,860
They didn't have any guns or anything like that, but they were very menacing.

3231
05:00:19,860 --> 05:00:22,340
And we want people to feel safe in the building.

3232
05:00:22,900 --> 05:00:25,560
We guard this, a wide idea, whether they're employee,

3233
05:00:26,040 --> 05:00:27,620
or they're here to pay them what a bill.

3234
05:00:28,040 --> 05:00:30,040
So with that, I will yield a little bit.

3235
05:00:30,320 --> 05:00:32,360
I have a constant, as I see.

3236
05:00:33,540 --> 05:00:36,780
Just very quickly, I would support a security assessment.

3237
05:00:36,840 --> 05:00:38,820
I think that's what we're asking for.

3238
05:00:38,980 --> 05:00:40,780
I agree, maybe it'll take 90 days.

3239
05:00:41,020 --> 05:00:47,380
So I would support, I think we should just keep it with,

3240
05:00:47,380 --> 05:00:54,580
the Scouts or Simmons proposal adding the subject to City Council approval.

3241
05:00:54,680 --> 05:01:00,180
And I agree with my colleagues, we want the, we want City Hall to be a welcoming place.

3242
05:01:00,700 --> 05:01:05,540
And I almost wonder if this should be an executive session, and you know, I, I feel like we,

3243
05:01:05,620 --> 05:01:12,480
we know what the bad guys to know about all our security measures, but I, I, I look forward

3244
05:01:12,480 --> 05:01:20,260
hearing more from the city manager and I think there's some way to make sure we have, they're

3245
05:01:20,260 --> 05:01:27,940
probably is a security protocol whole plan in place but it would be a comfort to know more about

3246
05:01:27,940 --> 05:01:39,180
it. Thank you. I yield. I think we've heard from all city counselors, I think one thing to what I've heard

3247
05:01:39,180 --> 05:01:45,600
is from a city manager, and long as that this has to be

3248
05:01:45,600 --> 05:01:47,180
some back and forth here.

3249
05:01:50,120 --> 05:01:58,140
And it's much better to have kind of guidelines around that piece of it.

3250
05:01:58,140 --> 05:02:04,980
So I do think we can perhaps have a public sphere

3251
05:02:04,980 --> 05:02:13,460
to public safety hearing. We could have an executive session. I think it could be permissible

3252
05:02:13,460 --> 05:02:20,120
under the executive session purposes that do exist. So there are different avenues here.

3253
05:02:22,120 --> 05:02:29,460
I think it's clear that we can do this. We could probably do think it's important to get on paper

3254
05:02:29,460 --> 05:02:33,900
what our policies and procedures are. This frankly, there's been a lot of changes to City Hall.

3255
05:02:33,900 --> 05:02:40,080
the last, you know, many years. And I'm not, I'm not actually sure at what everything is. And so

3256
05:02:40,080 --> 05:02:47,560
I do think that's important to get, you know, on other record. And then I do think it is

3257
05:02:47,560 --> 05:02:55,080
important for us to discuss, to give feedback, to, you know, it is subject to us. And so that is,

3258
05:02:55,100 --> 05:02:59,760
you know, important point. I do see Councilor Alzulu, Councilor Zulu, did you want to say

3259
05:02:59,760 --> 05:03:01,900
something before we go ahead on your amendment?

3260
05:03:02,680 --> 05:03:07,620
Yeah, I just wanted to quickly know that, you know, I don't think this is about keeping

3261
05:03:07,620 --> 05:03:08,500
it open and did.

3262
05:03:08,580 --> 05:03:13,420
I actually think it's the opposite about keeping it focused and also democratic because

3263
05:03:13,420 --> 05:03:17,240
the space isn't as this space is about all of us.

3264
05:03:17,440 --> 05:03:20,840
I mean, we're hearing from the city manager that there would also be an expectation that

3265
05:03:20,840 --> 05:03:23,560
it would take a good amount of time.

3266
05:03:23,960 --> 05:03:28,160
And so if we move forward with this larger piece, again, it could bring in a lot of different

3267
05:03:28,160 --> 05:03:30,460
pieces that make it harder to navigate the conversation.

3268
05:03:30,940 --> 05:03:34,880
So this is more so about keeping it focused and making sure it's moving forward with the

3269
05:03:34,880 --> 05:03:35,960
clarity that it deserves.

3270
05:03:36,680 --> 05:03:40,240
And also it'll give the city manager part of what he's looking for and what he listed,

3271
05:03:40,540 --> 05:03:45,380
which is, what are we trying to resolve here and if we're not taking those explicit steps,

3272
05:03:45,760 --> 05:03:51,400
and that's where again, where the amendments coming from, because I share that level of care

3273
05:03:51,400 --> 05:03:55,620
for making sure that we have the right public safety measures in place, oh, yield.

3274
05:03:57,650 --> 05:04:12,310
So, we've heard from everyone we have to, we should move on so we do have to move first on, yes, on the, we have to work, yeah, we have to vote on consoles, we'll be the moment and then vote on.

3275
05:04:13,190 --> 05:04:18,810
Right, so I will not be supporting consoles, we'll be the member by Joe Freishate with thoughtfulness.

3276
05:04:18,810 --> 05:04:26,970
Okay, so we'll put that before us and it was to take out

3277
05:04:29,050 --> 05:04:38,650
the, it's the red line at it's any questions, we can go proceed to the vote.

3278
05:04:38,650 --> 05:04:59,150
Councillor Azubi. Yes. Yes. Vice-marazine? No. No. Councillor Flaherty. No. No. No. Councillor Luma-Govern. No. No. Councillor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councillor Simmons. No. No. No. Councillor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes. Councillor Azuci.

3279
05:05:00,000 --> 05:05:29,420
Present. Present. Vice-marison. Yes. Yes, council of clarity. Yes. Yes, council of Montgomery. Yes. Yes, councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes, councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes, councilor Sabrina Wheeler. No. No, councilor Susie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And you have seven members recorded in the affirmative. One recorded in the negative and one recorded as present.

3280
05:05:30,000 --> 05:05:36,220
The policy order as amended is passed so now we'll go back to

3281
05:05:37,260 --> 05:05:39,140
The first charter rate

3282
05:05:39,140 --> 05:05:43,700
We do have director Sullivan. We do. Yes

3283
05:05:43,700 --> 05:05:49,040
Councilor Susie you had left out. You had left off with your a question

3284
05:05:49,040 --> 05:05:53,400
Do you want to repeat that since it was three hours ago?

3285
05:05:54,840 --> 05:05:56,440
Almost three hours ago

3286
05:05:56,440 --> 05:05:59,920
No, I'm eager to hear from Charles Sullivan.

3287
05:06:00,200 --> 05:06:07,540
I have the historic commission and to see what his thoughts are about why it would be important to landmark the building.

3288
05:06:07,920 --> 05:06:08,920
Great, director.

3289
05:06:09,920 --> 05:06:10,020
Okay.

3290
05:06:10,680 --> 05:06:16,980
Thank you, Madam Mayor, and apologize and I appreciate your accommodation for the technical issues.

3291
05:06:17,980 --> 05:06:26,120
So what the commission is trying to accomplish here is to recapture the authority over size and shape of additions and new construction.

3292
05:06:26,120 --> 05:06:32,480
That was taken away from neighborhood conservation districts by the amendments of October 23.

3293
05:06:34,740 --> 05:06:38,760
So the commission already has jurisdiction over this property.

3294
05:06:39,620 --> 05:06:45,960
It could easily put a pause on future development by saying that,

3295
05:06:46,140 --> 05:06:52,680
no, the additions and the L and the can't be removed in a house has to stay on its current location.

3296
05:06:52,680 --> 05:06:57,240
and that would be basically the end of anything except

3297
05:06:57,240 --> 05:06:59,020
a rehab of the person property.

3298
05:07:00,220 --> 05:07:03,760
We heard very clearly working with the owner

3299
05:07:04,680 --> 05:07:07,640
that he intended to re-develop the site.

3300
05:07:08,060 --> 05:07:09,500
He hoped to re-develop the site.

3301
05:07:09,760 --> 05:07:13,280
We recognized his wishes in that regard.

3302
05:07:14,520 --> 05:07:19,120
And we came up with a designation that would create a

3303
05:07:19,120 --> 05:07:26,120
possible site by allowing the house to be moved to face the Wall Street and then creating

3304
05:07:26,120 --> 05:07:34,880
a space behind it that could accommodate a, as of right, building that could be, theoretically,

3305
05:07:35,000 --> 05:07:42,340
up to 12 stories high. And we crafted the designation order to accommodate that, explicitly

3306
05:07:42,340 --> 05:07:47,240
to accommodate new construction as permitted by the zoning in effect.

3307
05:07:48,680 --> 05:07:56,340
And the reason we need to have the authority on resizing shape in this instance is the

3308
05:07:56,340 --> 05:08:02,580
particular location of a potential tower adjacent to the tower of St. Paul's Church.

3309
05:08:03,780 --> 05:08:09,600
And the sensitivity over all sensitivity of the location, which is subject to distant

3310
05:08:09,600 --> 05:08:12,180
use all the way from JFK Street.

3311
05:08:13,720 --> 05:08:20,520
So the actual design of that tower, which we had said we will allow, is critical.

3312
05:08:21,200 --> 05:08:28,400
Size and shape of that tower is critical to do an appropriate construction on that site.

3313
05:08:29,980 --> 05:08:31,940
So that's still long and short of it.

3314
05:08:32,440 --> 05:08:38,140
We need that jurisdiction back, because we worked with Ian Simmons and his architect

3315
05:08:38,140 --> 05:08:46,540
very imaginative architect who blocked out some high-rise alternatives that included some

3316
05:08:46,540 --> 05:08:53,580
frankly grotesque projections and candle leaders that would have incorporated or encroached

3317
05:08:53,580 --> 05:08:58,980
over that relocated the restored building, which we felt would be really inappropriate.

3318
05:09:00,560 --> 05:09:05,640
I don't think Mr. Simmons or his architect were serious about that, but they are possibilities

3319
05:09:05,640 --> 05:09:09,400
under the zoning, or it could be possibilities under the zoning.

3320
05:09:10,360 --> 05:09:15,260
So the commission is willing to accept a high-rise building on that site.

3321
05:09:15,580 --> 05:09:16,980
We're not trying to prevent it.

3322
05:09:17,020 --> 05:09:23,900
We're just trying to be able to detail to shape its massing and shape its character,

3323
05:09:24,260 --> 05:09:29,720
so that it best accommodates the surroundings, specifically the same Paul's tower.

3324
05:09:30,320 --> 05:09:39,080
So, the other point I would make is that we're totally aware that the motives of some

3325
05:10:00,000 --> 05:10:14,020
Motion is aware that life is complicated. This is an historic resource, an important historic resource and a potential development site that could be done well, could be done not so well.

3326
05:10:14,600 --> 05:10:27,020
And so regardless of the motivations of some of the petitioners, the commissioner recognized that this is an important asset and a critical place in Harvard Square where its jurisdiction needed to be strengthened.

3327
05:10:27,020 --> 05:10:31,360
And so I'll leave it at that, Madam Mayor, thank you very much.

3328
05:10:32,660 --> 05:10:34,700
I have considered as is he.

3329
05:10:36,140 --> 05:10:39,740
Through Madam Mayor, I just wanted to ask Charlie,

3330
05:10:40,220 --> 05:10:57,000
Charlie, I had asked you, I know Councillor Nolan had been concerned about the cost of restoring the exterior of the

3331
05:10:57,000 --> 05:11:02,620
and you had suggested that there isn't that much detailing that, so the question is, just the

3332
05:11:02,620 --> 05:11:09,700
open question is, do you think this would increase the cost of building on the site dramatically,

3333
05:11:10,740 --> 05:11:17,560
with the landmarking of the Sticney building increase the cost of the restoration of the Sticney

3334
05:11:17,560 --> 05:11:23,360
House dramatically? Well, the Sticney House is basically a wood friend, my King's Century House,

3335
05:11:23,360 --> 05:11:29,940
like thousands of houses in Cambridge, and it's had hard treatment. It's covered with

3336
05:11:29,940 --> 05:11:39,800
sighting. It can be treated with a residential grade approach to construction. I don't think

3337
05:11:39,800 --> 05:11:53,340
we're going to cost them significant amount more money, and certainly it's already in the

3338
05:11:53,340 --> 05:11:59,800
work with the property owners, and most of what would be done in a restoration would probably

3339
05:11:59,800 --> 05:12:08,020
be done without, without commission review would be done with staff review. If Mr. Simmons wants

3340
05:12:08,020 --> 05:12:15,960
to redevelop the site, yeah, relocating the house that he might prefer to take to scrape the site

3341
05:12:15,960 --> 05:12:22,080
and make it go away. Of course, that's an extra expense. But that's the nature of

3342
05:12:22,080 --> 05:12:24,360
on property ownership and a

3343
05:12:24,360 --> 05:12:26,380
constitution district or historic district,

3344
05:12:26,560 --> 05:12:27,380
the public interest.

3345
05:12:28,080 --> 05:12:29,900
Years ago, the City Council recognized

3346
05:12:29,900 --> 05:12:32,840
that the public interest imposed certain costs

3347
05:12:32,840 --> 05:12:39,640
on property owners and voted to implement

3348
05:12:39,640 --> 05:12:41,300
districts with that recognition.

3349
05:12:41,860 --> 05:12:43,600
So that's just to give them going forward.

3350
05:12:44,060 --> 05:12:46,300
But the Commission has always tried to be part

3351
05:12:46,300 --> 05:12:49,280
of the solution and not burden on property owners.

3352
05:12:49,280 --> 05:12:57,900
And so I think our track record shows that we've helped property owners deliver projects that

3353
05:12:57,900 --> 05:13:00,640
contribute to the characters, Cambridge and the significant money.

3354
05:13:02,360 --> 05:13:03,400
Thank you so much, I yield.

3355
05:13:03,820 --> 05:13:04,340
Councillor Noan.

3356
05:13:07,910 --> 05:13:08,690
Thank you.

3357
05:13:09,710 --> 05:13:14,970
Marcia Vicki and thank you, Councillor Susie, for inviting and having director Sullivan here.

3358
05:13:15,310 --> 05:13:20,350
This is really hard because I support historical preservation and conservation.

3359
05:13:20,350 --> 05:13:26,350
I respect the work of this director commission. I do want to address and I believe director

3360
05:13:26,350 --> 05:13:34,030
Sullivan alluded to this or actually directly address it. On the question of some other reasons

3361
05:13:34,030 --> 05:13:40,170
for why some people are wanted to landmark, which is not related to the historical commission.

3362
05:13:40,750 --> 05:13:47,350
I just want to reaffirm what several I think has been known to some people. The owners did work

3363
05:13:47,350 --> 05:13:50,770
with the community, and despite no requirement to do so

3364
05:13:50,770 --> 05:13:53,290
had many meetings with the tenants in the building.

3365
05:13:54,350 --> 05:13:57,490
And they do have amazing plans for a great community asset.

3366
05:13:58,530 --> 05:14:01,290
And yes, for those people who came and spoke in public comment,

3367
05:14:01,290 --> 05:14:02,370
I really appreciate it.

3368
05:14:02,410 --> 05:14:04,530
I myself have been to a number of meetings there.

3369
05:14:05,110 --> 05:14:09,930
They were very useful and really great space.

3370
05:14:10,610 --> 05:14:14,790
And many important meetings in probably historic decisions

3371
05:14:14,790 --> 05:14:16,730
are organizing took place in the building.

3372
05:14:16,730 --> 05:14:21,730
But if every space that had important meetings, including political planning, or historically known people,

3373
05:14:22,590 --> 05:14:26,050
where to be landmarked and practically every building in Cambridge can never be altered,

3374
05:14:26,110 --> 05:14:28,930
because our city is the epicenter of so many different things.

3375
05:14:28,970 --> 05:14:36,590
So I just want to acknowledge that of course it's hard to see a building that you've had important space in meetings and to be changed.

3376
05:14:36,830 --> 05:14:43,690
And yet it does seem to not want this building to be developed by this incredible nonprofit to enhance the square.

3377
05:14:44,250 --> 05:14:48,710
would really, we would be timing efforts by responsible owner to create a wonderful space.

3378
05:14:48,810 --> 05:14:51,930
So that is really kind of the community, some of the folks who want land,

3379
05:14:52,510 --> 05:14:54,170
marking just to preserve what they had.

3380
05:15:00,000 --> 05:15:16,220
Report, which director Sullivan just talked about, goes on for different reasons and I really appreciate the ways that the building itself has been allowed to say we could, owners could move it, take off the L which doesn't make any sense to preserve historically.

3381
05:15:17,180 --> 05:15:25,280
However, I agree with Councillor Flaherty that this building to me does not meet the criteria that I believe we should be using for landmarking.

3382
05:15:25,280 --> 05:15:30,780
And has been noted by my points and counselors as you thank you for raising about cost

3383
05:15:30,780 --> 05:15:35,840
is that any additional layer of oversight just raises the cost for any product.

3384
05:15:36,100 --> 05:15:40,940
This still is a nonprofit wanting to develop nonprofit community asset space.

3385
05:15:41,380 --> 05:15:44,900
There's already fairly significant preservation due to the neighborhood conservation

3386
05:15:44,900 --> 05:15:46,260
district requirements.

3387
05:15:46,920 --> 05:15:49,080
The allowed changes to the building are allowed.

3388
05:15:49,260 --> 05:15:51,500
I mean the building site will be dramatically different.

3389
05:15:51,900 --> 05:15:54,500
Why add additional challenges to the project?

3390
05:15:54,500 --> 05:15:56,860
And as we've put more constraints on owners

3391
05:15:56,860 --> 05:15:58,400
without clear historic rationale,

3392
05:15:58,760 --> 05:16:00,620
ironically enough, it may lead to less preservation

3393
05:16:00,620 --> 05:16:03,320
because if you do not have a highly resourced owner,

3394
05:16:03,860 --> 05:16:06,000
they could just let the building completely deteriorate,

3395
05:16:06,100 --> 05:16:08,320
which is what we saw in our scene some

3396
05:16:10,000 --> 05:16:12,980
with the space over on the story street

3397
05:16:12,980 --> 05:16:14,120
to Harriet's makeup house.

3398
05:16:14,200 --> 05:16:15,680
You know, it could just fall into ruin.

3399
05:16:16,100 --> 05:16:18,280
And if we don't allow for proper development,

3400
05:16:18,460 --> 05:16:20,200
it's going to have further deteriorate,

3401
05:16:20,220 --> 05:16:21,560
space is in seven movement forward.

3402
05:16:21,560 --> 05:16:27,820
So I am still voting no on the landmarking, I hope this is not, I want to make sure that

3403
05:16:27,820 --> 05:16:32,380
people understand, I really appreciate the report and the willingness of the Structural

3404
05:16:32,380 --> 05:16:38,640
Commission to consider various changes and I expect them to continue, I know that this

3405
05:16:38,640 --> 05:16:43,600
property in a few years will be a tremendous asset to the city and I'm for one and grateful

3406
05:16:43,600 --> 05:16:49,140
that it's being developed because I think it's going to add tremendously to the civic institutions

3407
05:16:49,140 --> 05:16:54,000
and the city and we'll all be the better off if they are allowed to develop it as soon as possible

3408
05:16:54,520 --> 05:16:57,960
with as few restrictions as possible given the ones that are already on their

3409
05:16:57,960 --> 05:17:03,100
fourth historical commission and their commitment to a really great asset in the city.

3410
05:17:03,400 --> 05:17:05,320
I yield. Councillor McGovern.

3411
05:17:09,740 --> 05:17:11,040
Thank you, Madam Mayor, through you.

3412
05:17:12,500 --> 05:17:20,280
So just because we did hear a number of people talk about the meetings, the community meetings and

3413
05:17:20,280 --> 05:17:26,300
organizations that have been part of the history of that building, which I too have been

3414
05:17:26,300 --> 05:17:30,140
in the Catholic involvement in that building a million times for different reasons.

3415
05:17:31,040 --> 05:17:36,040
But you know, just so make sure that folks know that whether this is landmark or not,

3416
05:17:36,960 --> 05:17:42,260
or say landmarking this building has no influence whatsoever on what happens inside the building.

3417
05:17:43,680 --> 05:17:49,300
So we heard some people say, we should landmark this because we want to preserve the democracy

3418
05:17:49,300 --> 05:17:54,580
center and the meeting that that has nothing to do with landmarking the building.

3419
05:17:55,300 --> 05:17:58,600
The landmarking of the building is what the physical outside structure of the building.

3420
05:17:59,240 --> 05:18:05,540
So even landmarking this doesn't mean that it's going to go back to how it was used before.

3421
05:18:05,580 --> 05:18:11,500
That comes from developing a relationship with the owner of the building and their mission,

3422
05:18:11,680 --> 05:18:14,660
which is one to foster civic space.

3423
05:18:14,680 --> 05:18:17,400
That is their mission, that's what they do.

3424
05:18:18,760 --> 05:18:23,410
And so, landmarking is not going to protect that.

3425
05:18:25,780 --> 05:18:28,420
I would also say, you know, I guess Mr. Sullivan,

3426
05:18:28,420 --> 05:18:31,160
it's about a marathon for you to Mr. Sullivan,

3427
05:18:33,680 --> 05:18:35,640
you know, you outlined a lot of things that, you know,

3428
05:18:35,640 --> 05:18:38,540
why this building should be considered historic,

3429
05:18:38,620 --> 05:18:40,820
I guess, and you maybe can't answer this,

3430
05:18:41,260 --> 05:18:43,820
but, you know, the building's obviously been around for a very long time

3431
05:18:43,820 --> 05:18:47,520
and no one has moved to landmark it before,

3432
05:18:49,560 --> 05:18:51,560
which sort of makes, again, makes me wonder

3433
05:18:51,560 --> 05:18:57,660
around the motivation for this, you know, and I'd like you, if you could talk a little

3434
05:18:57,660 --> 05:19:03,700
bit more, because where I also am a little bit uncomfortable, was your opening statement

3435
05:19:03,700 --> 05:19:10,700
tonight, where you said that basically this is a way for the historic commission to regain

3436
05:19:10,700 --> 05:19:14,940
control over a rule change that the council made back in 2023.

3437
05:19:16,460 --> 05:19:23,560
And I guess what worries me a little bit is that is this about this particular site?

3438
05:19:23,840 --> 05:19:31,000
Or is this about the historical commission not being happy with that rule change and has found a way to work around that rule change?

3439
05:19:32,600 --> 05:19:36,360
For you, Madam Mayor, this is about the particular site.

3440
05:19:37,840 --> 05:19:41,640
I would be, it would be, it doesn't matter if you need to say the Commission was pleased

3441
05:19:41,640 --> 05:19:46,780
about the rule change because size and shape is really critical to any kind of designer

3442
05:19:46,780 --> 05:19:47,360
of you.

3443
05:19:47,840 --> 05:19:54,940
But in this particular case, the possibility of a high-rise building shaped and such a way that

3444
05:19:54,940 --> 05:19:58,780
it would not only block the views of, say, Paul's tower.

3445
05:19:58,780 --> 05:19:59,860
Bye!

3446
05:20:00,000 --> 05:20:14,480
In the first round of this discussion before we came in, where it came in. But someone had said that initially your position was not to landmark it, and then that position change, is that accurate? And then if so, why did it change?

3447
05:20:14,480 --> 05:20:22,280
Well, they could, you know, could block almost any development on this site, just simply

3448
05:20:22,280 --> 05:20:26,540
by its authority to regulate alterations or relocations of the building.

3449
05:20:27,560 --> 05:20:35,680
When we started to get into it with the owner and his plans for redevelopment and

3450
05:20:35,680 --> 05:20:40,600
new construction on the site, we thought it would be advantageous to the district and to

3451
05:20:40,600 --> 05:20:47,900
building itself, if it were relocated, the face, the face east on dual street, that we can accommodate

3452
05:20:48,600 --> 05:20:56,120
the owner's intention to develop on the site and on appropriate way. And so, yes, so then,

3453
05:20:56,980 --> 05:21:03,120
you know, the commission did vote that, and we've worked positively constructively, I think,

3454
05:21:03,120 --> 05:21:06,260
with with the owner without a mind.

3455
05:21:07,240 --> 05:21:09,920
I mean, we could have just dug our heels in

3456
05:21:09,920 --> 05:21:13,080
without this, the commission could dig its heels in and say no.

3457
05:21:13,440 --> 05:21:17,660
And so on that basis, you know, initially, you know,

3458
05:21:17,740 --> 05:21:22,300
I was skeptical of the petition, but as we got into it.

3459
05:21:24,600 --> 05:21:25,180
Thank you.

3460
05:21:25,580 --> 05:21:26,260
Thank you.

3461
05:21:26,260 --> 05:21:26,780
Thank you, madam.

3462
05:21:26,980 --> 05:21:27,380
Thank you, sir.

3463
05:21:28,080 --> 05:21:29,060
And I do, you know,

3464
05:21:29,480 --> 05:21:31,360
and I think Councillor Nolan mentioned this.

3465
05:21:31,360 --> 05:21:34,100
that there was, you did allow for a lot of flexibility

3466
05:21:34,100 --> 05:21:36,220
and a lot of things to happen with the site.

3467
05:21:36,620 --> 05:21:38,380
So, clearly those conversations were very helpful

3468
05:21:38,380 --> 05:21:39,720
and I do appreciate that.

3469
05:21:41,220 --> 05:21:42,580
That will yield for now, Madam Mayor.

3470
05:21:42,640 --> 05:21:43,260
Thank you.

3471
05:21:43,640 --> 05:21:44,360
Councillor Simmons?

3472
05:21:46,360 --> 05:21:47,280
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

3473
05:21:47,980 --> 05:21:51,760
I think my colleagues asked, and it has asked the questions

3474
05:21:51,760 --> 05:21:56,080
that would have asked, I was on the fence from minute,

3475
05:21:56,360 --> 05:22:02,650
but I don't, I think I'm going to stay with my original opinion

3476
05:22:02,830 --> 05:22:09,890
that I would not vote to landmark the side elbow. I do hear and respect Mr. Sullivan in his work

3477
05:22:09,890 --> 05:22:15,830
and I always enjoy any time he puts anything before the council. So it's just relaxing that I

3478
05:22:15,830 --> 05:22:23,730
be two or three times over, but specific to the landmarking. I feel confident that it's going to be

3479
05:22:23,730 --> 05:22:29,190
dealt with in a way that is going to preserve much of the integrity that is spoken about

3480
05:22:29,190 --> 05:22:35,330
in too. So I will not be supporting it and I will be able to move forward. Thank you.

3481
05:22:35,410 --> 05:22:42,410
Thank you, Councillor. And Councillor Ferry? You spoke on this. Yes, and through you, Madam Mayor. Miss

3482
05:22:42,410 --> 05:22:53,110
Assolving, you do actual work. And I understand that the building, whether landmark or not, stays

3483
05:22:53,110 --> 05:22:59,370
under the jurisdiction of the conservation district. Correct? Yes. That's correct through you.

3484
05:22:59,590 --> 05:23:06,930
And so any, in my right it is a certificate of appropriateness that has to be issued

3485
05:23:06,930 --> 05:23:14,390
or am I mistaken for, yes, through you, Madam Mayor, any exterior work that requires a building

3486
05:23:14,390 --> 05:23:21,490
permit requires a certificate of appropriateness. Right. And obviously all the zoning is still in play,

3487
05:23:21,490 --> 05:23:29,410
right? Yes. Okay. All right. Well, I appreciate that. Thank you very much. Thank you. So we've

3488
05:23:29,410 --> 05:23:36,850
heard from all my colleagues and you know I am where I think the majority of the council is around

3489
05:23:36,850 --> 05:23:44,010
not designating this as a landmark based on what's been said. So I think we should go ahead and take a

3490
05:23:44,010 --> 05:23:51,130
on whether or not to approve the final landmark designation

3491
05:23:51,130 --> 05:23:55,930
report for the Nathaniel Sydney House at 45 Mount

3492
05:23:55,930 --> 05:23:57,930
Arbor Street. So we'll do a roll call.

3493
05:23:58,630 --> 05:24:03,650
Councillor Azubi. Yes. Yes. Vice-marisine. No. No.

3494
05:24:03,650 --> 05:24:11,430
Councillor Flaherty. No. No. No. Councillor Nolan. No.

3495
05:24:11,430 --> 05:24:40,610
No, Councilor Simmons. No. No. No, Council Sabrina Wheeler. No. No, Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes. Mayor Sediki. No. No. And you have two members recorded in the affirmative and seven recorded in the negative designation for the report fails. We have disposed of the charter items and the table items. We're moving to applications and petitions. There are three pleasure of the council.

3496
05:24:43,670 --> 05:24:52,670
on a motion by council move to accept them to accept the applications and petitions adopt them.

3497
05:24:53,090 --> 05:24:56,530
Yes on a motion by Councillor Nolan to adopt let's do a roll call please.

3498
05:24:58,150 --> 05:24:59,310
Councillor Azubi. Yes.

3499
05:25:00,000 --> 05:25:11,940
Yes, Vice Mayor Azine. Yes. Yes. Councilful Flaherty. Yes. Yes. Councilwoman Gavin. Yes. Yes. Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councilor Simmons. Yes.

3500
05:25:12,160 --> 05:25:15,180
Yes. Councilor Serena Wheeler. Yes. Yes. Councilor Suzy.

3501
05:25:18,540 --> 05:25:29,500
Yes. Yes. Yes. Mayor city gate. Yes. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative. The applications and petitions are adopted. We'll go to communications.

3502
05:25:29,500 --> 05:25:29,920
Thanks.

3503
05:25:30,860 --> 05:25:31,760
Thanks, I love you.

3504
05:25:31,840 --> 05:25:32,060
Thank you.

3505
05:25:32,060 --> 05:25:36,300
One more motion by Councillor Simmons to place them on fire.

3506
05:25:36,440 --> 05:25:37,600
We'll do a roll call.

3507
05:25:38,140 --> 05:25:39,080
Councillor Aousubee.

3508
05:25:40,240 --> 05:25:40,380
Yes.

3509
05:25:40,380 --> 05:25:40,480
Yes.

3510
05:25:40,640 --> 05:25:41,160
Vice-merzine.

3511
05:25:42,480 --> 05:25:43,840
Councillor Flaherty.

3512
05:25:44,880 --> 05:25:45,160
Yes.

3513
05:25:45,320 --> 05:25:46,040
Councillor McGavin.

3514
05:25:47,060 --> 05:25:47,140
Yes.

3515
05:25:48,230 --> 05:25:49,000
Councillor Nolan.

3516
05:25:49,940 --> 05:25:50,180
Yes.

3517
05:25:50,520 --> 05:25:50,940
Yes.

3518
05:25:50,940 --> 05:25:51,840
Councillor Simmons.

3519
05:25:52,680 --> 05:25:52,860
Yes.

3520
05:25:53,340 --> 05:25:53,720
Yes.

3521
05:25:53,720 --> 05:25:54,740
Councillor Sabrina Wheeler.

3522
05:25:55,940 --> 05:25:56,380
Yes.

3523
05:25:56,380 --> 05:26:02,080
Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

3524
05:26:03,560 --> 05:26:08,400
The communications are dropped in. Well, two resolutions. There are six pleasure of the city council.

3525
05:26:09,160 --> 05:26:11,520
And chair. Yes. Councillor Simmons.

3526
05:26:12,280 --> 05:26:12,740
One.

3527
05:26:13,960 --> 05:26:14,200
One.

3528
05:26:15,300 --> 05:26:17,040
Any others? Councillor 30.

3529
05:26:17,280 --> 05:26:18,440
I pulled two.

3530
05:26:18,700 --> 05:26:19,440
Number two.

3531
05:26:22,200 --> 05:26:28,300
And then we can do a roll call on adopting the balance of the resolutions.

3532
05:26:28,300 --> 05:26:32,520
is making the unanimous upon adoption on our motion by Councillor Simmons.

3533
05:26:34,440 --> 05:26:35,440
Councillor Elzubi.

3534
05:26:35,440 --> 05:26:35,900
Yes.

3535
05:26:36,260 --> 05:26:36,660
Yes.

3536
05:26:36,760 --> 05:26:37,400
Vice-merzine.

3537
05:26:38,020 --> 05:26:38,240
Yes.

3538
05:26:38,560 --> 05:26:38,880
Yes.

3539
05:26:38,880 --> 05:26:39,840
Councillor Flaherty.

3540
05:26:40,700 --> 05:26:40,960
Yes.

3541
05:26:40,960 --> 05:26:42,260
Councillor Nolan.

3542
05:26:44,980 --> 05:26:45,220
Yes.

3543
05:26:45,400 --> 05:26:45,860
Yes.

3544
05:26:45,860 --> 05:26:46,620
Councillor Simmons.

3545
05:26:47,420 --> 05:26:47,700
Yes.

3546
05:26:48,060 --> 05:26:48,480
Yes.

3547
05:26:48,660 --> 05:26:49,460
Councillor Sabrina Wheeler.

3548
05:26:50,340 --> 05:26:50,800
Yes.

3549
05:26:51,520 --> 05:26:51,640
Yes.

3550
05:26:52,300 --> 05:26:52,500
Yes.

3551
05:26:52,640 --> 05:26:53,180
Mayor City.

3552
05:26:53,500 --> 05:26:53,740
Yes.

3553
05:26:54,220 --> 05:26:54,560
Yes.

3554
05:26:54,560 --> 05:26:56,860
of nine members recorded in the affirmative.

3555
05:26:57,660 --> 05:26:59,860
The balance of the resolutions are adopted.

3556
05:26:59,940 --> 05:27:02,780
We'll go to number one, which is a resolution

3557
05:27:02,780 --> 05:27:05,240
wishing down a low means of full recovery

3558
05:27:05,240 --> 05:27:05,700
consequences.

3559
05:27:06,720 --> 05:27:07,980
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

3560
05:27:08,780 --> 05:27:13,520
A couple of things relative to this particular resolution.

3561
05:27:13,980 --> 05:27:16,980
I want to pull it in a men-by-substitution.

3562
05:27:17,720 --> 05:27:21,420
Unfortunately, Mr Williams passed away Saturday at 8.29

3563
05:27:21,420 --> 05:27:33,480
in with all his friends and family around him. It was a very, very sad moment I was able to visit him a few times before I was passing and so it was just very sad.

3564
05:27:33,760 --> 05:27:46,700
So this is not appropriate this time. I do believe or at least I hope Mr. Stefan has an amended resolution to send to his family.

3565
05:27:46,700 --> 05:27:54,380
In fact, his funeral will be this Friday and I can't have details for those that they want to know, but Mr. Fund, do you have the amendment?

3566
05:27:55,320 --> 05:27:57,920
Yes, I do. Did you want to show an on-screen?

3567
05:27:59,120 --> 05:28:00,100
You don't mind,

3568
05:28:04,100 --> 05:28:04,100
please.

3569
05:28:04,840 --> 05:28:09,440
So what we'll do is I'm do a roll call on the...

3570
05:28:09,440 --> 05:28:10,180
By substitution.

3571
05:28:11,220 --> 05:28:16,300
I don't know if my college's have it or not, but it basically is just not acknowledging his life.

3572
05:28:16,300 --> 05:28:20,160
I think he knows how to do that. He has transitioned.

3573
05:28:21,820 --> 05:28:23,120
Madam, Madam Mayor.

3574
05:28:23,460 --> 05:28:24,200
Yes, Councilor Governor.

3575
05:28:26,720 --> 05:28:30,960
Through you, the Councilor Simmons, would you also add me as a co-sponsor?

3576
05:28:31,220 --> 05:28:31,980
Can we vote that, too?

3577
05:28:32,100 --> 05:28:34,080
I knew the family very well as well.

3578
05:28:34,720 --> 05:28:35,280
Absolutely.

3579
05:28:35,580 --> 05:28:36,800
Absolutely. So I would move that.

3580
05:28:37,640 --> 05:28:44,420
We add Councilor McGuven to the policy resolution.

3581
05:28:44,420 --> 05:28:54,860
And because it's made union with the Pana D'Aption, each member will be listed as fully supporting this conversation.

3582
05:28:56,420 --> 05:29:01,420
So the amendment is before us,

3583
05:29:03,470 --> 05:29:09,230
and we can go ahead and adopt and do a roll call on the amendment.

3584
05:29:09,230 --> 05:29:18,990
Councilor Elzubi. Yes. Yes. Vice-Mayor Zim. Yes. Yes. Councilor Flarity. Yes. May God have mercy in the soul.

3585
05:29:19,830 --> 05:29:35,510
Councilor McGavin. Yes. Yes. Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes. Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes. Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes. Mayor Simmons. Yes. Yes.

3586
05:29:35,510 --> 05:29:37,310
of nine members recorded in the affirmative.

3587
05:29:39,390 --> 05:29:44,450
I'm sorry, near City Gate. I didn't even notice.

3588
05:29:45,030 --> 05:29:55,390
Yes, I'm sorry. And thank you. Yes, I'm really through this very quickly and one of the things

3589
05:29:55,390 --> 05:29:59,970
for me. Let's do it out. About Mr. Williams is he loved to-

3590
05:30:00,000 --> 05:30:27,960
Special Square and was found finally regarded as the vice mayor of Central Square. And I don't see it. And I would just like to add that I someplace appropriately like, you know,

3591
05:30:27,960 --> 05:30:36,120
think about shoe-horning founding members' lifelong contribution, A&B, the unofficial mayor,

3592
05:30:36,580 --> 05:30:41,480
a vice mayor of Central Square, I would shoe-horne that any people would accept that without

3593
05:30:41,480 --> 05:30:50,020
having me write it out. Thank you. Mr. Farnish here. So, Mr. Perfect, when it comes to this,

3594
05:30:50,020 --> 05:30:52,460
Thank you, and vice versa.

3595
05:30:52,460 --> 05:30:53,580
And vice versa.

3596
05:30:53,740 --> 05:30:55,160
I'm so interested in it.

3597
05:30:55,620 --> 05:30:55,860
Yes.

3598
05:30:56,140 --> 05:31:00,180
So we can go ahead and maybe that is a friendly amendment.

3599
05:31:00,880 --> 05:31:06,120
But we can add that and then also add

3600
05:31:06,120 --> 05:31:09,400
Councillor McGuvern as the second co-sponsor

3601
05:31:10,160 --> 05:31:12,300
and do a roll call.

3602
05:31:12,940 --> 05:31:14,400
Councillor Azubi.

3603
05:31:14,660 --> 05:31:15,320
Yes.

3604
05:31:15,940 --> 05:31:16,700
Yes, vice versa.

3605
05:31:17,560 --> 05:31:17,880
Yes.

3606
05:31:18,360 --> 05:31:18,640
Yes.

3607
05:31:18,640 --> 05:31:26,360
Council of Flaherty? Yes. Yes. Council of McGuvern? Yes. Yes. Council of Nolan? Yes. Yes.

3608
05:31:26,440 --> 05:31:32,260
Council of Simmons? Yes. Yes. Council of Sabrina Wheeler? Yes. Yes. Council of

3609
05:31:32,260 --> 05:31:36,600
Zucy? Yes. Yes. Mayor City Gate? Yes. Yes. And you have nine members

3610
05:31:36,600 --> 05:31:42,020
recorded in the affirmative. My condolences as well to

3611
05:31:42,020 --> 05:31:50,160
family and I know his daughter. So we'll, we'll miss him. So we'll go ahead and do a

3612
05:31:50,160 --> 05:32:00,020
roll call on adopting the amended resolution. We just did that in there. I thought we added,

3613
05:32:01,020 --> 05:32:12,000
we added, we did the amendment and then we added Mark, but we didn't do a red, we didn't do a

3614
05:32:12,000 --> 05:32:15,500
Councillor McGovern is outed in the previous vote.

3615
05:32:15,860 --> 05:32:16,400
That's fine.

3616
05:32:16,900 --> 05:32:18,640
So on the amendment by substitution,

3617
05:32:19,040 --> 05:32:20,780
Ian to add, Councillor McGovern.

3618
05:32:20,900 --> 05:32:22,020
No, no, we did that.

3619
05:32:22,220 --> 05:32:22,920
We did all that.

3620
05:32:23,100 --> 05:32:25,660
But now we have to vote on the whole resolution.

3621
05:32:27,080 --> 05:32:30,820
As I said, then we just added the Vice Chair line as well.

3622
05:32:31,080 --> 05:32:31,280
Thank you.

3623
05:32:32,620 --> 05:32:32,880
Thank you.

3624
05:32:33,420 --> 05:32:34,560
Councillor Azubi.

3625
05:32:34,780 --> 05:32:35,220
Yes.

3626
05:32:35,640 --> 05:32:35,980
Yes.

3627
05:32:35,980 --> 05:32:36,880
Vice-merzine?

3628
05:32:38,420 --> 05:32:38,660
Yes.

3629
05:32:39,160 --> 05:32:39,540
Yes.

3630
05:32:39,540 --> 05:32:40,440
Councillor Flaherty?

3631
05:32:40,700 --> 05:32:40,960
Yes.

3632
05:32:40,960 --> 05:32:49,020
Yes, Councilwoman govern. Yes. Yes, Councilwoman Nolan. Yes. Yes, Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes.

3633
05:32:49,300 --> 05:32:57,180
Council of Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes, Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes. Mayor Simmons. I'm sorry. Mayor Sediki. Yes.

3634
05:32:57,620 --> 05:33:08,960
I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. The resolution as amended was adopted. We're going on to resolution number two.

3635
05:33:10,140 --> 05:33:15,740
condolences on the death of Renee, and Amara, this was filed by

3636
05:33:15,740 --> 05:33:18,220
muscle clarity, because of where do you have that for?

3637
05:33:18,700 --> 05:33:23,340
Yes, just very briefly, and I know some of my colleagues attended the

3638
05:33:23,340 --> 05:33:27,400
celebration of life for Renee last week at the Charles Hotel.

3639
05:33:28,660 --> 05:33:35,840
And I just wanted to mention that I was struck by her humanity and her generosity,

3640
05:33:35,840 --> 05:33:44,820
there was several speakers that mentioned her impact on their lives and what a vibrant person

3641
05:33:44,820 --> 05:33:54,240
she was beyond being such a talented person and then her husband Paul, you know, told stories

3642
05:33:54,240 --> 05:34:04,060
about how she would, she was a master puzzler whenever there was a 4,000 piece puzzle, she would

3643
05:34:04,060 --> 05:34:11,940
assemble it in the house and they had a laugh about that. But I was struck by just the tremendous

3644
05:34:12,560 --> 05:34:18,460
love they have for one another and the impact she's had on so many different people and one of

3645
05:34:18,460 --> 05:34:25,540
loss she is not just a Paul but to the city of Cambridge and just what a tremendous human being

3646
05:34:25,540 --> 05:34:32,400
in generalment Paul is. He's an outstanding example to all of us and he's been a great friend

3647
05:34:32,400 --> 05:34:38,260
and a wonderful proprietor of the Hong Kong restaurant and Harvard Square.

3648
05:34:39,720 --> 05:34:45,300
And I just want to offer my condolences to him and to the entire family.

3649
05:34:46,360 --> 05:34:47,480
It just excellent people.

3650
05:34:48,240 --> 05:34:49,960
So thank you very much, Madam Mayor.

3651
05:34:50,160 --> 05:34:50,880
I yield.

3652
05:34:51,720 --> 05:34:52,140
I agreed.

3653
05:34:52,460 --> 05:34:53,600
Thank you, Councillor Ferry.

3654
05:34:55,460 --> 05:34:56,720
Any other comments?

3655
05:34:58,300 --> 05:34:59,980
We'll go ahead and do it.

3656
05:35:00,000 --> 05:35:03,260
roll call on adoption, making unanimous upon adoption.

3657
05:35:03,580 --> 05:35:15,540
Councilor L. Zubi. Yes. Yes. Vice-marazine. Yes. Yes. Council of Flaherty. Yes. Yes. Council of McEvern. Yes. Yes. Councilor Nolan. Yes.

3658
05:35:15,820 --> 05:35:25,280
Yes. Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes. Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes. Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes. Mayor C. D. K. Yes. Yes.

3659
05:35:25,280 --> 05:35:27,100
And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

3660
05:35:27,100 --> 05:35:34,320
The resolutions are adopted. We're going to committee reports. There are four measure of the committee to be

3661
05:35:34,320 --> 05:35:34,700
Council.

3662
05:35:36,060 --> 05:35:42,440
It's set to committee reports and points on five on that motion from Councillor Simmons. We'll do a roll call.

3663
05:35:42,660 --> 05:35:42,980
Council.

3664
05:35:43,260 --> 05:35:43,860
Yes.

3665
05:35:44,760 --> 05:35:45,740
Yes. Vice-marison.

3666
05:35:46,400 --> 05:35:46,540
Yes.

3667
05:35:47,000 --> 05:35:47,540
Yes. Council.

3668
05:35:47,960 --> 05:35:47,980
Yes.

3669
05:35:48,960 --> 05:35:49,320
Yes.

3670
05:35:49,360 --> 05:35:49,680
Council.

3671
05:35:51,300 --> 05:35:51,900
Yes.

3672
05:35:51,900 --> 05:35:52,260
Council.

3673
05:35:52,800 --> 05:36:02,300
Yes. Yes, Councilor Simmons. Yes. Yes, Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes, Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes.

3674
05:36:02,320 --> 05:36:10,440
Yes, Mayor Sediki. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative. The four committee committee reports are placed on file.

3675
05:36:10,900 --> 05:36:18,920
There are no roundtable minutes. There are three remaining communications from other city officers.

3676
05:36:20,020 --> 05:36:28,280
We've, well, no, there's two, only one, no, only two, so we can do a roll call on that on the balance.

3677
05:36:28,600 --> 05:36:30,040
Play some file.

3678
05:36:31,020 --> 05:36:33,400
I'm placing them on file from Pastor Nolan.

3679
05:36:34,120 --> 05:36:34,920
Councillor Azubi.

3680
05:36:36,040 --> 05:36:36,140
Yes.

3681
05:36:36,140 --> 05:36:36,200
Yes.

3682
05:36:36,200 --> 05:36:36,660
Vice-marison.

3683
05:36:37,000 --> 05:36:37,360
Yes.

3684
05:36:37,740 --> 05:36:38,100
Yes.

3685
05:36:38,100 --> 05:36:38,280
Yes.

3686
05:36:42,440 --> 05:36:42,700
Yes.

3687
05:36:43,300 --> 05:36:44,200
Councillor Nolan.

3688
05:36:45,160 --> 05:36:45,320
Yes.

3689
05:36:45,580 --> 05:36:46,140
Yes.

3690
05:36:46,920 --> 05:36:47,480
Yes.

3691
05:36:47,980 --> 05:36:48,360
Yes.

3692
05:36:48,480 --> 05:36:48,540
Yes.

3693
05:36:48,540 --> 05:36:49,520
Councillor Sabrina Wheeler.

3694
05:36:50,040 --> 05:36:50,080
Yes.

3695
05:36:50,540 --> 05:36:50,820
Yes.

3696
05:36:51,080 --> 05:36:51,440
Councillor Susie.

3697
05:36:52,260 --> 05:36:52,780
Yes.

3698
05:36:53,000 --> 05:36:53,320
Yes.

3699
05:36:53,320 --> 05:36:53,400
Yes.

3700
05:36:54,080 --> 05:36:54,260
Yes.

3701
05:36:54,780 --> 05:36:57,160
And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

3702
05:36:58,560 --> 05:37:02,220
Those communications that are reports from other city officers are placed on fire.

3703
05:37:02,900 --> 05:37:03,880
We remove on.

3704
05:37:04,320 --> 05:37:06,040
Are there any late resolutions clerk?

3705
05:37:08,300 --> 05:37:08,580
No.

3706
05:37:08,640 --> 05:37:10,180
I do not have any late resolutions.

3707
05:37:10,500 --> 05:37:12,020
I do have one late policy order.

3708
05:37:12,040 --> 05:37:17,500
We have one late policy order, which requires a suspension of the rules.

3709
05:37:17,500 --> 05:37:21,940
So, on to Spension, we'll do a little roll call,

3710
05:37:25,600 --> 05:37:26,440
Councillor Azubi.

3711
05:37:26,720 --> 05:37:26,800
Yes.

3712
05:37:27,200 --> 05:37:27,620
Yes.

3713
05:37:27,620 --> 05:37:28,440
Vice Mayor Azim.

3714
05:37:29,460 --> 05:37:29,840
Yes.

3715
05:37:29,840 --> 05:37:29,940
Yes.

3716
05:37:29,940 --> 05:37:30,120
Yes.

3717
05:37:30,120 --> 05:37:30,500
Yes.

3718
05:37:30,860 --> 05:37:31,220
Yes.

3719
05:37:31,640 --> 05:37:31,880
Yes.

3720
05:37:31,880 --> 05:37:32,080
Yes.

3721
05:37:32,080 --> 05:37:32,420
Yes.

3722
05:37:33,580 --> 05:37:33,860
Yes.

3723
05:37:34,300 --> 05:37:34,820
Yes.

3724
05:37:37,300 --> 05:37:38,740
Councillor Azubi.

3725
05:37:45,120 --> 05:37:45,140
Yes.

3726
05:37:45,140 --> 05:37:45,460
Yes.

3727
05:37:45,820 --> 05:37:46,140
Yes.

3728
05:37:46,840 --> 05:37:47,320
Yes.

3729
05:37:47,420 --> 05:37:52,560
record in the affirmative. We're in suspension so we can bring forward the late policy order

3730
05:37:53,240 --> 05:37:59,740
Councillor Serena Wheelerney. Thanks for coming through you. This policy order asks the city manager

3731
05:37:59,740 --> 05:38:07,380
direct staff to request that flags be lowered to half staff for one week in recognition of the

3732
05:38:07,380 --> 05:38:13,100
horrific killings of people who are trying to exercise their first amendment rights by federal agents

3733
05:38:13,100 --> 05:38:18,580
Minnesota or in some cases we're trying to protect other people. We had a number of residents

3734
05:38:18,580 --> 05:38:23,440
came with residents. We talked about this over the past few days. I think it's a fitting

3735
05:38:23,440 --> 05:38:28,480
way to honor the folks and really recognize what's a tragic moment in our country's history

3736
05:38:28,480 --> 05:38:34,060
that we haven't seen for decades really. We reached out to the city staff and a lot of

3737
05:38:34,060 --> 05:38:38,740
apartments after we started getting questions about this from residents and we clear that

3738
05:38:38,740 --> 05:38:44,180
the city does have the authority to make flag lowering decisions on our own as a city even without

3739
05:38:44,180 --> 05:38:48,880
the order from a governor and that it would be appropriate for us as a council to put

3740
05:38:48,880 --> 05:38:51,740
an elite policy order tonight, directing the city manager to do so.

3741
05:38:52,660 --> 05:38:56,260
I also just want to clear that this is not the only way we are thinking of responding to

3742
05:38:56,260 --> 05:39:00,420
the actions of ice as a public and you know, it shouldn't be interpreted that way.

3743
05:39:00,920 --> 05:39:03,640
It's something we can do, you know, immediately to respond to it.

3744
05:39:03,900 --> 05:39:07,620
We are also, at least for myself, considering additional policy solutions that have been

3745
05:39:07,620 --> 05:39:12,660
touch with city staff and legal advocates about, you know, the horrific act of policing, both out

3746
05:39:12,660 --> 05:39:17,380
of response to them and how to be prepared and protect our residents. I'll defer to the

3747
05:39:17,380 --> 05:39:20,220
thing that the co-sponsors want to speak on this and be all back.

3748
05:39:23,660 --> 05:39:25,760
Any comments? Yes, Councillor McGuvern.

3749
05:39:29,420 --> 05:39:34,880
Thank you, Madam Mayor, through you. I want to thank just Sabrina Wheeler and the other

3750
05:39:34,880 --> 05:39:40,160
co-sponsors for putting this forward and just as the co-sponsors should bring in Wheeler

3751
05:39:40,160 --> 05:39:47,940
have their other actions that a few of us are working on to really try to ensure safety

3752
05:39:47,940 --> 05:39:55,340
in our own community, but also respect and support other cities that are currently seeing

3753
05:39:55,340 --> 05:39:59,260
unsafe conditions on their streets.

3754
05:40:00,000 --> 05:40:09,500
You know, I could certainly go on for quite a while on my feelings about ice and their tactics and the

3755
05:40:09,500 --> 05:40:17,460
violence that they're causing. I will leave that for another time. But I do appreciate this and share

3756
05:40:17,460 --> 05:40:25,720
in solidarity with the people of Minnesota and the families of the victims at the hands of this legalized

3757
05:40:25,720 --> 05:40:27,680
militia by the President. Thank you.

3758
05:40:31,960 --> 05:40:59,520
Thank you, Marcia Vicki. I appreciate this also. I had been also working on something and then was told there was already a late order in process. So I'd love to be added to this order and to recognize for some folks that may have concerns that how do we decide what to do this. Well, this is a time that we need to stand up very clearly and say these deaths are completely different.

3759
05:41:01,060 --> 05:41:08,660
necessary for us to acknowledge that they are beyond the pale, and that we, as a city,

3760
05:41:09,140 --> 05:41:13,640
can stand up and acknowledge just through this symbolic gesture, and yet we've done a lot

3761
05:41:13,640 --> 05:41:18,540
of other work and what continue to do work to make sure that we are standing on the side of

3762
05:41:19,980 --> 05:41:28,000
democracy and justice and against what too many elements of the federal government have become.

3763
05:41:28,000 --> 05:41:37,260
So I appreciate this order and recognize that we are in very scary times.

3764
05:41:37,960 --> 05:41:39,600
Thank you, Councillor Nolan.

3765
05:41:40,340 --> 05:41:41,560
Well, certainly add you.

3766
05:41:42,380 --> 05:41:45,200
I'll just go around to hear from others.

3767
05:41:45,440 --> 05:41:46,140
Councillor Azim.

3768
05:41:47,240 --> 05:41:53,740
I just wanted to thank all those monsters and especially Councillor Sabrina Wheeler for leading on this.

3769
05:41:53,880 --> 05:41:56,000
I just wanted to be added as well.

3770
05:41:57,530 --> 05:42:00,330
Does anyone else like to be added?

3771
05:42:02,510 --> 05:42:05,190
We'll go ahead and just add a counselor,

3772
05:42:05,670 --> 05:42:08,730
Nolan and Azim, and do a role call?

3773
05:42:09,950 --> 05:42:17,130
Councillor Azubi. Yes. Yes. Vice Mayor Azim. Yes. Yes. Council of Larry? Yes. Yes. Council of

3774
05:42:17,130 --> 05:42:20,210
McGuvern? Yes. Yes. Council of Nolan?

3775
05:42:23,960 --> 05:42:29,720
Council of Nolan? Oh, sorry. Yes. Yes. Council of Simmons? Yes. Yes.

3776
05:42:29,720 --> 05:42:36,240
Council Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes, Councillor Zusie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And you have

3777
05:42:36,240 --> 05:42:42,000
nine members recorded in the affirmative. Would anyone else like to be heard on this

3778
05:42:42,000 --> 05:42:49,740
before we adopt? Hearing none, we'll go ahead and do a roll call on the policy order on a late

3779
05:42:49,740 --> 05:42:59,700
policy order as amended. Councillor Azubi. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Council of

3780
05:42:59,700 --> 05:43:13,600
Yes, Councilor Nolan. Yes. Yes, Councilor Simmons. Yes, Councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes, Councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes, Mayor City. Yes. Yes, and you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

3781
05:43:15,560 --> 05:43:18,700
The late policy order as amended is

3782
05:43:20,160 --> 05:43:26,800
adopted, so we're done with the agenda. Any announcements? Yes, Mayor. Yes, thank you.

3783
05:43:27,120 --> 05:43:31,240
Thank you. I just wanted to let people know the specifics for Donald William

3784
05:43:31,240 --> 05:43:36,880
Skinroll. I was a beheld at Rogers funeral home 380 Cambridge Street in Cambridge

3785
05:43:36,880 --> 05:43:48,220
on Friday. That's this Friday. The 30th of January from 4 to 8 p.m. There'll be a

3786
05:43:48,220 --> 05:43:55,100
at church, 49th, 6th Street in Cambridge at 10 a.m. then people will be going to the cemetery,

3787
05:43:55,760 --> 05:44:02,440
they will be a repasse at the American League in March, 442 at 3 going to boulevard in

3788
05:44:02,440 --> 05:44:10,180
that's from 12 to 4. Thank you for sharing that information. Any other announcements from the body?

3789
05:44:11,820 --> 05:44:15,180
you're not going to go ahead.

3790
05:44:15,740 --> 05:44:16,220
Go ahead, Councillor.

3791
05:44:16,820 --> 05:44:22,300
Quick reminder, the basketball game between the Cambridge police and the Cambridge

3792
05:44:22,300 --> 05:44:24,740
Warriors, a special needs.

3793
05:44:25,660 --> 05:44:29,160
A basketball team is this Saturday at the warm memorial.

3794
05:44:29,900 --> 05:44:31,180
Five o'clock.

3795
05:44:32,640 --> 05:44:33,760
Be there a be square.

3796
05:44:35,320 --> 05:44:36,260
Thank you.

3797
05:44:36,260 --> 05:44:37,720
Thank you.

3798
05:44:37,720 --> 05:44:39,180
Thank you.

3799
05:44:39,180 --> 05:44:39,200
Sorry.

3800
05:44:40,000 --> 05:44:41,500
Don't see anyone else.

3801
05:44:41,760 --> 05:44:42,440
Thank you.

3802
05:44:42,860 --> 05:44:46,760
We'll go ahead on Councillor Simmons' motion to adjourn to a roll call.

3803
05:44:46,900 --> 05:44:47,500
Councillor Elzubi.

3804
05:44:48,080 --> 05:44:48,620
Yes.

3805
05:44:48,880 --> 05:44:49,260
Yes.

3806
05:44:49,260 --> 05:44:49,740
Vice-marism.

3807
05:44:50,520 --> 05:44:50,820
Yes.

3808
05:44:51,220 --> 05:44:51,560
Yes.

3809
05:44:51,820 --> 05:44:52,460
Councillor Flaherty.

3810
05:44:52,900 --> 05:44:53,400
Yes.

3811
05:44:53,700 --> 05:44:54,180
Yes.

3812
05:44:57,160 --> 05:44:57,500
Councillor Nolan.

3813
05:44:58,120 --> 05:44:58,660
Yes.

3814
05:44:58,880 --> 05:44:59,360
Yes.

3815
05:44:59,360 --> 05:44:59,500
Yes.

3816
05:44:59,600 --> 05:44:59,800
Councillor Simmons.

3817
05:45:01,260 --> 05:45:11,040
Yes, councilor Sabrina Wheeler. Yes. Yes, councilor Zucy. Yes. Yes. Mayor CDG. Yes. Yes. And you have nine members recorded in the affirmative.

3818
05:45:11,820 --> 05:45:17,420
Good night. Thank you everyone. Nice to meet you. You are only tomorrow. Yes. This and bye.