1
00:20:40,000 --> 00:20:43,600
>> this meeting will come to order.

2
00:20:44,100 --> 00:20:47,100
meeting will come to order.

3
00:20:47,100 --> 00:20:49,100
is student trustee heather brandt

4
00:20:49,100 --> 00:20:52,100
logged in as a panelist?

5
00:20:53,100 --> 00:20:54,100
okay.

6
00:20:54,100 --> 00:20:55,100
ms. Esteban, will you please call the

7
00:20:55,100 --> 00:20:57,100
roll starting with student trustee

8
00:20:57,100 --> 00:20:59,100
heather brandt when she comes and with

9
00:20:59,100 --> 00:21:02,601
the other trustees who are here.

10
00:21:04,100 --> 00:21:06,100
>> student trustee brandt?

11
00:21:15,100 --> 00:21:16,100
president anita martinez?

12
00:21:16,100 --> 00:21:18,100
>> here.

13
00:21:18,100 --> 00:21:20,401
>> vice president luis zamora?

14
00:21:21,100 --> 00:21:22,100
>> here

15
00:21:22,100 --> 00:21:23,100
>> trustee chisti?

16
00:21:23,100 --> 00:21:24,100
>> present.

17
00:21:24,100 --> 00:21:25,100
>> trustee wong?

18
00:21:25,100 --> 00:21:26,100
>> trustee solomon?

19
00:21:26,100 --> 00:21:27,100
>> here.

20
00:21:27,100 --> 00:21:28,100
>> trustee chung?

21
00:21:28,100 --> 00:21:29,100
trustee mccarty?

22
00:21:29,100 --> 00:21:30,100
>> here.

23
00:21:30,100 --> 00:21:32,100
>> student trustee brandt?

24
00:21:35,100 --> 00:21:37,100
you have a quorum.

25
00:21:37,100 --> 00:21:39,401
>> thank you very much.

26
00:21:40,100 --> 00:21:43,601
we start with the land acknowledgment

27
00:21:48,100 --> 00:21:50,100
statement.

28
00:22:07,100 --> 00:22:08,100
>> [inaudible].

29
00:22:08,100 --> 00:22:10,100
>> thank you.

30
00:22:10,100 --> 00:22:13,100
is there a way to send a message or to

31
00:22:13,100 --> 00:22:14,100
put something on screen so they can

32
00:22:14,100 --> 00:22:17,100
can see that there's a technical issue

33
00:22:17,100 --> 00:22:22,100
and that we're fixing it and in a script

34
00:22:22,100 --> 00:22:24,401
rather than in announcement?

35
00:22:57,100 --> 00:22:58,100
>> [inaudible].

36
00:22:58,100 --> 00:23:00,100
>> thank you, in the meantime, let me

37
00:23:00,100 --> 00:23:02,100
acknowledge that we couldn't do

38
00:23:02,100 --> 00:23:03,100
anything, we couldn't have this

39
00:23:03,100 --> 00:23:06,100
meeting if it weren't for our

40
00:23:06,100 --> 00:23:07,100
classified professionals.

41
00:23:07,100 --> 00:23:10,100
we couldn't do much at this college

42
00:23:10,100 --> 00:23:12,100
without our classified professionals.

43
00:23:12,100 --> 00:23:14,100
so, we are truly grateful for them and

44
00:23:14,100 --> 00:23:15,100
appreciate all the work that they do.

45
00:23:15,100 --> 00:23:16,100
we're set.

46
00:23:16,100 --> 00:23:18,100
thank you.

47
00:23:24,100 --> 00:23:26,100
[applause].

48
00:23:28,100 --> 00:23:29,100
student trustee brandt has now joined

49
00:23:29,100 --> 00:23:33,100
and I would like to acknowledge her

50
00:23:33,100 --> 00:23:34,100
presence.

51
00:23:34,100 --> 00:23:37,601
today we have a special land

52
00:23:38,100 --> 00:23:40,100
acknowledgment statement.

53
00:23:41,100 --> 00:23:43,100
sarah moncada the instructor of

54
00:23:43,100 --> 00:23:46,100
our first native american indigenous

55
00:23:49,100 --> 00:23:52,100
studies course niis38, introduction to

56
00:23:53,100 --> 00:23:55,100
indigenous studies will assist in this

57
00:23:55,100 --> 00:23:57,100
part of our agenda.

58
00:23:57,100 --> 00:24:00,100
we celebrate this new course and thank

59
00:24:00,100 --> 00:24:03,100
its first teacher because with this

60
00:24:03,100 --> 00:24:05,100
course, city college fully honors

61
00:24:05,100 --> 00:24:07,100
first peoples and more completely

62
00:24:07,100 --> 00:24:09,100
fills our college's commitment to

63
00:24:09,100 --> 00:24:11,401
diversity, equity and inclusion.

64
00:24:16,100 --> 00:24:18,100
adolfo velasquez will therefore read

65
00:24:18,100 --> 00:24:21,100
the land acknowledgment statement and

66
00:24:23,100 --> 00:24:26,100
ms. Moncada will speak after.

67
00:24:28,100 --> 00:24:32,100
will you step up to the microphone,

68
00:24:32,100 --> 00:24:34,100
please.

69
00:24:36,100 --> 00:24:38,100
>> testing.

70
00:24:49,100 --> 00:24:50,100
"we acknowledge that we are on the

71
00:24:50,100 --> 00:24:51,100
unceded ancestral homeland of the

72
00:24:51,100 --> 00:24:52,100
ramaytush ohlone who are the original

73
00:24:52,100 --> 00:24:53,100
inhabitants of the san francisco

74
00:24:53,100 --> 00:24:54,100
peninsula, as the indigenous stewards

75
00:24:54,100 --> 00:24:55,100
of this land and in accordance with

76
00:24:55,100 --> 00:24:56,100
their traditions, the ramaytush ohlone

77
00:24:56,100 --> 00:24:57,100
have never ceded, lost nor forgotten

78
00:24:57,100 --> 00:24:58,100
their responsibilities as the

79
00:24:58,100 --> 00:24:59,100
caretakers of this place, as well as

80
00:24:59,100 --> 00:25:00,100
for all peoples who reside in their

81
00:25:00,100 --> 00:25:01,100
traditional territory, as guests, we

82
00:25:01,100 --> 00:25:02,100
recognize that we benefit from living

83
00:25:02,100 --> 00:25:03,100
and working on their traditional

84
00:25:03,100 --> 00:25:04,100
homeland, we wish to pay our respects

85
00:25:04,100 --> 00:25:05,100
by acknowledging the ancestors, elders

86
00:25:05,100 --> 00:25:06,100
and relatives of the ramaytush

87
00:25:06,100 --> 00:25:07,100
community and by affirming their

88
00:25:07,100 --> 00:25:10,100
sovereign rights as first peoples."

89
00:25:22,100 --> 00:25:23,100
>> thank you.

90
00:25:23,100 --> 00:25:25,100
ms. Moncada?

91
00:25:28,100 --> 00:25:30,100
>> [inaudible].

92
00:25:44,100 --> 00:25:47,100
thank you very much for having me, any

93
00:25:47,100 --> 00:25:51,201
name is sarah moncada, I carry apache

94
00:25:53,100 --> 00:25:55,100
ancestry and [inaudible] ancestry on

95
00:25:55,100 --> 00:25:58,100
my mother's side, I'm honored to dance

96
00:25:58,100 --> 00:26:00,100
with these circles with you all today.

97
00:26:00,100 --> 00:26:03,100
I come mere as a good guest so that

98
00:26:03,100 --> 00:26:06,100
should you have an opportunity to

99
00:26:06,100 --> 00:26:09,100
visit my territories, you will have an

100
00:26:09,100 --> 00:26:10,100
opportunity to be a good guest in

101
00:26:10,100 --> 00:26:11,100
return.

102
00:26:11,100 --> 00:26:12,100
I want to thank you all for the

103
00:26:12,100 --> 00:26:15,100
opportunity to stand on shoulders of

104
00:26:15,100 --> 00:26:19,201
many people who have come together to

105
00:26:20,100 --> 00:26:22,100
create an engaged action, the

106
00:26:22,100 --> 00:26:25,100
commitment beyond the words to open up

107
00:26:25,100 --> 00:26:27,100
to native american studies and enrich

108
00:26:27,100 --> 00:26:29,100
and deepen your commitment to ethnic

109
00:26:29,100 --> 00:26:33,100
studies and what it means to broaden

110
00:26:33,100 --> 00:26:36,100
our awareness, understanding and deep

111
00:26:36,100 --> 00:26:37,100
relationship and responsibility

112
00:26:37,100 --> 00:26:38,100
together as human beings.

113
00:26:38,100 --> 00:26:41,100
thank you for the opportunity to teach

114
00:26:41,100 --> 00:26:43,100
its first course, it was really,

115
00:26:43,100 --> 00:26:44,100
really wonderful.

116
00:26:44,100 --> 00:26:47,100
we had really, really good

117
00:26:47,100 --> 00:26:49,100
conversations with really good minds

118
00:26:49,100 --> 00:26:51,100
and hearts in the room.

119
00:26:51,100 --> 00:26:54,100
I look forward to the opportunity to

120
00:26:54,100 --> 00:26:55,100
continue that work should that

121
00:26:55,100 --> 00:26:57,100
continue and for the opportunity to

122
00:26:57,100 --> 00:26:59,100
share it all with you more.

123
00:26:59,100 --> 00:27:02,100
you're all welcome to come to the

124
00:27:02,100 --> 00:27:03,100
class.

125
00:27:03,100 --> 00:27:05,100
thank you very much in a time when we

126
00:27:05,100 --> 00:27:07,100
feel constriction and walls and

127
00:27:07,100 --> 00:27:08,100
barriers coming up around the

128
00:27:08,100 --> 00:27:11,601
potentials that we have in our

129
00:27:12,100 --> 00:27:13,100
continued education and higher

130
00:27:13,100 --> 00:27:15,100
education arenas, it's wouldn't to see

131
00:27:15,100 --> 00:27:17,100
the ongoing commitment to rather than

132
00:27:17,100 --> 00:27:19,100
seeing the barriers dancing through

133
00:27:19,100 --> 00:27:20,100
possibilities.

134
00:27:20,100 --> 00:27:22,100
so, thank you.

135
00:27:22,100 --> 00:27:24,401
>> thank you very much.

136
00:27:26,100 --> 00:27:28,100
[applause].

137
00:27:30,100 --> 00:27:34,201
we now turn to honors and recognition

138
00:27:35,100 --> 00:27:38,100
and the first honors and recognition

139
00:27:38,100 --> 00:27:41,601
item is letter a, recognition of

140
00:27:42,100 --> 00:27:44,401
engineering club 2025 solar regatta

141
00:27:45,100 --> 00:27:47,100
victory.

142
00:27:48,100 --> 00:27:51,100
could we have the teacher step up to

143
00:27:51,100 --> 00:27:52,100
the microphone.

144
00:27:52,100 --> 00:27:55,601
>> yeah, I think we have --

145
00:27:56,100 --> 00:27:57,100
>> thank you.

146
00:27:57,100 --> 00:28:00,100
>> good afternoon, my name is keith

147
00:28:00,100 --> 00:28:03,100
mueller, I'm the advisor of ccsf's

148
00:28:03,100 --> 00:28:04,100
engineering club.

149
00:28:04,100 --> 00:28:08,100
we're one of oldest clubs on campus.

150
00:28:08,100 --> 00:28:10,100
we started as an advisor, I was

151
00:28:10,100 --> 00:28:13,601
advisor back in 2006 and we've been

152
00:28:17,100 --> 00:28:19,100
continuing on basically ever since.

153
00:28:19,100 --> 00:28:20,100
we live in the basement of the

154
00:28:20,100 --> 00:28:21,100
engineering club -- I mean the science

155
00:28:21,100 --> 00:28:23,100
building, I forgot.

156
00:28:23,100 --> 00:28:26,100
the science building, occasionally we go

157
00:28:26,100 --> 00:28:27,100
out and play and we like to

158
00:28:27,100 --> 00:28:30,100
go out and build things and we do

159
00:28:30,100 --> 00:28:32,100
enjoy going to different events in

160
00:28:32,100 --> 00:28:35,601
order to show off engineering projects

161
00:28:37,100 --> 00:28:40,601
and also robo games, something we've

162
00:28:42,100 --> 00:28:45,100
been doing for the past 8, 9 years

163
00:28:45,100 --> 00:28:47,100
which is the california solar regatta

164
00:28:47,100 --> 00:28:50,100
as you can see on the screen up above.

165
00:28:50,100 --> 00:28:53,601
what the solar regatta is, is

166
00:28:54,100 --> 00:28:57,601
basically a race between solar powered

167
00:28:58,100 --> 00:29:02,100
boats on a lake up near sacramento

168
00:29:02,100 --> 00:29:03,100
which espouses solar power, promotes

169
00:29:03,100 --> 00:29:06,100
it and it is something for colleges to

170
00:29:06,100 --> 00:29:08,100
compete against and so there are a

171
00:29:08,100 --> 00:29:09,100
number of colleges that enter the

172
00:29:09,100 --> 00:29:12,100
event, there is a speed competition,

173
00:29:12,100 --> 00:29:16,201
there is a slalom xe ising, endurance

174
00:29:17,100 --> 00:29:18,100
competition and presentation and we

175
00:29:18,100 --> 00:29:20,100
have been competing in this event

176
00:29:20,100 --> 00:29:21,100
for many years.

177
00:29:21,100 --> 00:29:22,100
to explain a little bit more about how

178
00:29:22,100 --> 00:29:25,100
we did this year, what was our theme

179
00:29:25,100 --> 00:29:27,100
are year and how we did if the overall

180
00:29:27,100 --> 00:29:29,100
events and would we compete against,

181
00:29:29,100 --> 00:29:30,100
I'm going to present the current

182
00:29:30,100 --> 00:29:33,100
president of the engineering club,

183
00:29:34,100 --> 00:29:36,100
aiden, so aiden?

184
00:29:38,100 --> 00:29:39,100
[applause].

185
00:29:39,100 --> 00:29:41,100
>> thank you.

186
00:29:42,100 --> 00:29:45,100
so, as he said, we have a theme and

187
00:29:45,100 --> 00:29:46,100
we've been doing this for a long time

188
00:29:46,100 --> 00:29:48,100
so we have fun with our themes.

189
00:29:48,100 --> 00:29:50,100
this year we wanted something iconic

190
00:29:50,100 --> 00:29:54,100
so as most of you can tell, we did

191
00:29:54,100 --> 00:29:55,100
lego.

192
00:29:55,100 --> 00:29:57,100
it was fun to design our boat to make

193
00:29:57,100 --> 00:30:02,100
it look like a lego boat, but yeah, as

194
00:30:02,100 --> 00:30:04,100
for our performance this year, as you

195
00:30:04,100 --> 00:30:06,100
mentioned, the three are a sprint, a

196
00:30:06,100 --> 00:30:08,100
slalom and endurance, our sprin,

197
00:30:08,100 --> 00:30:12,100
with came in first place again, we did

198
00:30:12,100 --> 00:30:13,100
that last year as well.

199
00:30:13,100 --> 00:30:17,100
that got us one of our trophies,

200
00:30:17,100 --> 00:30:20,601
another thing that we got a

201
00:30:22,100 --> 00:30:25,601
trophy was for our drive train,

202
00:30:27,100 --> 00:30:29,100
e we did well enough where they gave

203
00:30:29,100 --> 00:30:32,100
us a trophy for that,

204
00:30:34,100 --> 00:30:36,100
another one slalom, we have a

205
00:30:36,100 --> 00:30:38,100
boat that excels at slalom, we got

206
00:30:38,100 --> 00:30:42,100
first place in that, we beat second

207
00:30:42,100 --> 00:30:45,100
place by a goaded 15 seconds.

208
00:30:45,100 --> 00:30:48,100
we did really well on that one.

209
00:30:48,100 --> 00:30:50,100
the endurance one, we did come in

210
00:30:50,100 --> 00:30:52,100
second, that is mostly not due to us,

211
00:30:52,100 --> 00:30:54,100
that's because our batteries decided

212
00:30:54,100 --> 00:30:56,401
to not work twice.

213
00:30:57,100 --> 00:31:00,100
so, we ended up accidentally burning a

214
00:31:00,100 --> 00:31:01,100
battery.

215
00:31:01,100 --> 00:31:06,100
so, we did not get one for that but

216
00:31:06,100 --> 00:31:09,100
other parts -- other non-racing items

217
00:31:09,100 --> 00:31:11,100
are scored and ranked.

218
00:31:11,100 --> 00:31:14,100
one of them we did well on this year

219
00:31:14,100 --> 00:31:16,100
was art theming, we made our boat look

220
00:31:16,100 --> 00:31:21,100
like a lego boat so we got yet another

221
00:31:21,100 --> 00:31:22,100
one.

222
00:31:22,100 --> 00:31:25,100
I can't even -- and another one that

223
00:31:25,100 --> 00:31:28,100
we always do pretty poorly on, this

224
00:31:28,100 --> 00:31:30,100
year we decided to do again, put a

225
00:31:30,100 --> 00:31:32,100
little bit of effort was

226
00:31:32,100 --> 00:31:35,100
sustainability, so we did a lifetime

227
00:31:35,100 --> 00:31:38,100
impact analysis of our boat to see

228
00:31:38,100 --> 00:31:41,100
what was -- how good it was and they

229
00:31:41,100 --> 00:31:42,100
appreciated the effort.

230
00:31:42,100 --> 00:31:45,100
so, we got these as well as -- because

231
00:31:45,100 --> 00:31:47,100
we got all of these, we ended up

232
00:31:47,100 --> 00:31:50,100
winning the total overall regatta so

233
00:31:50,100 --> 00:31:52,401
we got another one.

234
00:31:56,100 --> 00:31:58,100
[applause].

235
00:32:00,100 --> 00:32:02,100
as you can see, that's a photo of our

236
00:32:02,100 --> 00:32:04,100
boat, we're kind of standing in the

237
00:32:04,100 --> 00:32:08,100
way of it, but that is our boat we got

238
00:32:08,100 --> 00:32:12,100
all of these trophies and as you

239
00:32:12,100 --> 00:32:15,100
can see, we're running out of space

240
00:32:15,100 --> 00:32:17,100
out here.

241
00:32:17,100 --> 00:32:19,100
that leaded me to one issue, mueller

242
00:32:19,100 --> 00:32:20,100
will talk about it.

243
00:32:20,100 --> 00:32:21,100
yes.

244
00:32:21,100 --> 00:32:23,100
>> we did a new display case.

245
00:32:23,100 --> 00:32:27,100
we now have 36 trophies, we have won

246
00:32:27,100 --> 00:32:30,601
this event 6 out of 8 times now.

247
00:32:31,100 --> 00:32:36,401
we are maybe the best and it's kind of

248
00:32:37,100 --> 00:32:40,100
-- I guess it's good but it's also

249
00:32:40,100 --> 00:32:41,100
pretty brutal.

250
00:32:41,100 --> 00:32:45,100
so, we just wanted to thank you for

251
00:32:45,100 --> 00:32:46,100
entertaining us and bingeing with us

252
00:32:46,100 --> 00:32:50,100
today and we wanted to show these

253
00:32:50,100 --> 00:32:52,100
trophies with you, since we are so

254
00:32:52,100 --> 00:32:54,100
famous, you may take a picture with us.

255
00:32:54,100 --> 00:32:57,100
we hope you can join us in a photo

256
00:32:57,100 --> 00:33:00,601
with our trophies here, thank you.

257
00:33:01,100 --> 00:33:02,100
[applause].

258
00:33:02,100 --> 00:33:06,201
>> and I am referring the request for

259
00:33:08,100 --> 00:33:10,100
a bigger display case or another --

260
00:33:10,100 --> 00:33:12,401
acting chancellor cooper wilkins.

261
00:33:13,100 --> 00:33:17,801
>> come on, guys, let's get -- I think

262
00:33:19,100 --> 00:33:22,100
we've done it over there.

263
00:33:23,100 --> 00:33:24,100
yeah.

264
00:33:24,100 --> 00:33:26,100
( taking photograph ).

265
00:35:12,100 --> 00:35:14,100
[applause].

266
00:35:52,100 --> 00:35:55,601
>> the meeting will come back to

267
00:35:56,100 --> 00:35:57,100
order.

268
00:35:57,100 --> 00:35:58,100
acting chancellor cooper wilkins, can

269
00:35:58,100 --> 00:36:01,100
you present the next honors and

270
00:36:01,100 --> 00:36:03,100
recognition?

271
00:36:04,100 --> 00:36:08,801
>> yes, so we do have a recognition of

272
00:36:11,100 --> 00:36:13,100
shella cervantes, she received the

273
00:36:13,100 --> 00:36:16,601
honor of the 2025 academic senate of

274
00:36:17,100 --> 00:36:19,401
california community colleges' regina

275
00:36:20,100 --> 00:36:21,100
stanback stroud diversity award and I

276
00:36:21,100 --> 00:36:22,100
know it was short notice.

277
00:36:22,100 --> 00:36:25,100
I'm not sure if current academic

278
00:36:25,100 --> 00:36:28,100
senate president katia fuchs would

279
00:36:28,100 --> 00:36:31,100
like to come forward and be a part of

280
00:36:31,100 --> 00:36:32,100
making that presentation.

281
00:36:32,100 --> 00:36:35,601
>> I would never pass up an

282
00:36:38,100 --> 00:36:40,100
opportunity to celebrate shella, thank

283
00:36:40,100 --> 00:36:43,601
you, dr. Cooper wilkins for the

284
00:36:44,100 --> 00:36:47,100
introduction, I'm katia fuchs and the

285
00:36:47,100 --> 00:36:49,100
freshly minted academic senate

286
00:36:49,100 --> 00:36:50,100
president.

287
00:36:50,100 --> 00:36:54,201
a little bit of the regina stanback

288
00:36:55,100 --> 00:36:57,100
stroud award, so as educators, our

289
00:36:57,100 --> 00:37:00,100
challenge is to help as many of our

290
00:37:00,100 --> 00:37:01,100
students as possible reach their

291
00:37:01,100 --> 00:37:03,401
personal and academic goals.

292
00:37:05,100 --> 00:37:08,100
the regina stanback stroud testy award

293
00:37:08,100 --> 00:37:09,100
gives public recognition to the value

294
00:37:09,100 --> 00:37:12,100
the community college places on equity

295
00:37:12,100 --> 00:37:13,100
and diversity.

296
00:37:13,100 --> 00:37:15,100
this award seeks to publicly

297
00:37:15,100 --> 00:37:17,100
acknowledge a member of the faculty

298
00:37:17,100 --> 00:37:18,100
who consistently demonstrates

299
00:37:18,100 --> 00:37:21,100
commitment to the equity and diversity

300
00:37:21,100 --> 00:37:23,100
goals of the college.

301
00:37:23,100 --> 00:37:24,100
it recognizes the individual who

302
00:37:24,100 --> 00:37:27,601
performs in an exceptional manner to

303
00:37:28,100 --> 00:37:30,100
advance intercultural harmony, equity

304
00:37:30,100 --> 00:37:32,100
and campus diversity by making

305
00:37:32,100 --> 00:37:34,100
exceptional contributions to the

306
00:37:34,100 --> 00:37:37,100
college beyond their usual obligations

307
00:37:37,100 --> 00:37:40,100
and you couldn't do any better than to

308
00:37:40,100 --> 00:37:43,100
give this award to the amazing shella

309
00:37:43,100 --> 00:37:46,100
cervantes who is here with us and

310
00:37:46,100 --> 00:37:50,201
shella, I hand it over to you.

311
00:37:53,100 --> 00:37:55,100
>> I have two faculty that really want

312
00:37:55,100 --> 00:37:57,100
o the say something.

313
00:37:57,100 --> 00:38:01,801
I'm going to put a pause on that.

314
00:38:02,100 --> 00:38:05,100
>> hi, alyssa messier, I am also in

315
00:38:05,100 --> 00:38:08,100
women's and genders study ask here

316
00:38:08,100 --> 00:38:11,100
with leslie simon from omens and

317
00:38:11,100 --> 00:38:13,100
gender studies ask we want to be here

318
00:38:13,100 --> 00:38:15,100
the celebrate shella and their amazing

319
00:38:15,100 --> 00:38:17,100
work for our students and the college

320
00:38:17,100 --> 00:38:19,100
and since katia so kindly gave a

321
00:38:19,100 --> 00:38:21,100
presentation about the award, I will

322
00:38:21,100 --> 00:38:24,100
leave it to that and pass it to leslie.

323
00:38:24,100 --> 00:38:26,100
>> just a few words.

324
00:38:26,100 --> 00:38:28,100
shella was a student of mine so I'm

325
00:38:28,100 --> 00:38:30,100
very happy today.

326
00:38:31,100 --> 00:38:33,100
brilliant, creative, compassionate and

327
00:38:33,100 --> 00:38:35,100
I want to stay with compassion and I'm

328
00:38:35,100 --> 00:38:39,100
going to be a little sentimental, it

329
00:38:39,100 --> 00:38:42,100
was khai who said revolutionary is

330
00:38:42,100 --> 00:38:46,100
guided by love, she opens many hearts

331
00:38:46,100 --> 00:38:48,100
the many spaces, she deserves it more

332
00:38:48,100 --> 00:38:50,100
than anyone that I know, she openers

333
00:38:50,100 --> 00:38:51,100
my heart and brings people together

334
00:38:51,100 --> 00:38:53,100
and we are so lucky to have her at

335
00:38:53,100 --> 00:38:55,100
this college.

336
00:38:57,100 --> 00:38:59,100
[applause].

337
00:39:00,100 --> 00:39:03,100
>> so, I'm very glad to that have

338
00:39:03,100 --> 00:39:04,100
really great introduction.

339
00:39:04,100 --> 00:39:07,100
I'm going share with you some

340
00:39:07,100 --> 00:39:09,100
reflections on the stanback stroud

341
00:39:09,100 --> 00:39:13,100
award, if you didn't watch the video,

342
00:39:13,100 --> 00:39:15,100
it happened on my birthday, that was

343
00:39:15,100 --> 00:39:18,601
cool, the regina stanback stroud award

344
00:39:19,100 --> 00:39:22,100
describes the award -- so, regina

345
00:39:22,100 --> 00:39:24,100
stanback stroud stories the award as

346
00:39:24,100 --> 00:39:26,100
call to action and that those who are

347
00:39:26,100 --> 00:39:28,100
honored by it embody excellence and

348
00:39:28,100 --> 00:39:31,601
equity as well as make rigor

349
00:39:33,100 --> 00:39:35,100
inseparable from justice, regina

350
00:39:35,100 --> 00:39:37,100
stanback stroud in honoring me

351
00:39:37,100 --> 00:39:39,401
launched the african american

352
00:39:40,100 --> 00:39:42,100
resource center as a supported

353
00:39:42,100 --> 00:39:44,100
resource center and championing that

354
00:39:44,100 --> 00:39:45,100
the african american resource sent and

355
00:39:45,100 --> 00:39:47,100
her the women's resource center both

356
00:39:47,100 --> 00:39:49,100
be housed in the new student success

357
00:39:49,100 --> 00:39:51,100
building.

358
00:39:51,100 --> 00:39:54,100
she highlighted the importance of

359
00:39:54,100 --> 00:39:55,100
advancing facilities justice for

360
00:39:55,100 --> 00:39:58,100
students of color across cam pus and

361
00:39:58,100 --> 00:40:01,100
that equity minded facilities planning

362
00:40:01,100 --> 00:40:02,100
understands that environments are one

363
00:40:02,100 --> 00:40:05,100
of the conditions that make a

364
00:40:05,100 --> 00:40:07,100
significant impact on student success.

365
00:40:07,100 --> 00:40:10,100
what that actually looked like was

366
00:40:10,100 --> 00:40:12,100
mentoring faculty and students alike

367
00:40:12,100 --> 00:40:14,100
as well as truly listening to students

368
00:40:14,100 --> 00:40:16,100
when they did not have someone to go

369
00:40:16,100 --> 00:40:17,100
to.

370
00:40:17,100 --> 00:40:19,100
or when no one else was listening.

371
00:40:19,100 --> 00:40:22,100
when I think of this, this gives me

372
00:40:22,100 --> 00:40:25,100
unease because what I thought was one

373
00:40:25,100 --> 00:40:28,601
for students is yet again unfinished,

374
00:40:30,100 --> 00:40:31,100
contentious business.

375
00:40:31,100 --> 00:40:33,100
I think the part that many may have

376
00:40:33,100 --> 00:40:35,100
not taken into consideration in all

377
00:40:35,100 --> 00:40:37,100
the accomplishments that are being

378
00:40:37,100 --> 00:40:39,100
celebrated right now for me is that

379
00:40:39,100 --> 00:40:42,100
I'm a part timer and the many things

380
00:40:42,100 --> 00:40:46,100
that I'm being celebrated for were not

381
00:40:46,100 --> 00:40:48,100
mine to carry.

382
00:40:48,100 --> 00:40:50,100
as a part timer, my role, my

383
00:40:50,100 --> 00:40:52,100
influence, my time is limited.

384
00:40:52,100 --> 00:40:54,100
I know there is little chance my

385
00:40:54,100 --> 00:40:56,100
position will ever change despite the

386
00:40:56,100 --> 00:40:57,100
need for it.

387
00:40:57,100 --> 00:41:00,100
and yet at this moment and for as long

388
00:41:00,100 --> 00:41:02,100
as I've been here, I choose to give

389
00:41:02,100 --> 00:41:04,401
more and be more.

390
00:41:05,100 --> 00:41:09,100
who I am here at the college is

391
00:41:09,100 --> 00:41:12,100
inspired by measuring love and the

392
00:41:12,100 --> 00:41:15,100
journey for justice, a brown paper by

393
00:41:15,100 --> 00:41:18,100
shelley tang and sammy nunez,

394
00:41:19,100 --> 00:41:21,401
they share transformative and

395
00:41:22,100 --> 00:41:24,100
catalytic love, self-love, love other,

396
00:41:24,100 --> 00:41:27,100
love as a community practice and

397
00:41:27,100 --> 00:41:30,100
lastly love infused with power.

398
00:41:32,100 --> 00:41:36,100
as city of college of san francisco

399
00:41:36,100 --> 00:41:39,100
transforms yet bargaining I transform

400
00:41:40,100 --> 00:41:42,100
of catalytic love and I now call on

401
00:41:42,100 --> 00:41:43,100
others to do so as well.

402
00:41:43,100 --> 00:41:45,100
thank you.

403
00:41:47,100 --> 00:41:49,100
[applause].

404
00:41:58,100 --> 00:42:00,100
>> congratulations, it was my

405
00:42:00,100 --> 00:42:03,100
privilege to serve on the academic at

406
00:42:03,100 --> 00:42:06,100
the same time as regina stanback

407
00:42:06,100 --> 00:42:08,100
stroud, the statewide senate and I got

408
00:42:08,100 --> 00:42:10,100
to know her there.

409
00:42:10,100 --> 00:42:12,100
then I had the opportunity to know her

410
00:42:12,100 --> 00:42:15,100
once again when she was vice-president

411
00:42:15,100 --> 00:42:18,100
of instruction at skyline college and

412
00:42:18,100 --> 00:42:22,801
she recommended my hire as the dean of

413
00:42:24,100 --> 00:42:26,100
language arts and it was a wonderful

414
00:42:26,100 --> 00:42:27,100
opportunity to work with her.

415
00:42:27,100 --> 00:42:29,100
so, I know who she is and I know that

416
00:42:29,100 --> 00:42:31,100
you justly deserve this award, so

417
00:42:31,100 --> 00:42:33,100
thank you very much for all of your

418
00:42:33,100 --> 00:42:36,601
work and your enthusiasm and your

419
00:42:38,100 --> 00:42:39,100
love.

420
00:42:39,100 --> 00:42:40,100
trustee chung?

421
00:42:40,100 --> 00:42:43,100
>> and I can't pass off the

422
00:42:43,100 --> 00:42:46,601
opportunity to talk about your impact

423
00:42:47,100 --> 00:42:48,100
on my life.

424
00:42:48,100 --> 00:42:52,801
when I was a project survive mentor, I

425
00:42:55,100 --> 00:42:59,100
have lived through what it's like to

426
00:42:59,100 --> 00:43:01,100
have you guide me through a really

427
00:43:01,100 --> 00:43:04,100
difficult time in my life and empower

428
00:43:04,100 --> 00:43:08,100
me and I've seen you in that space and

429
00:43:08,100 --> 00:43:10,100
I'm so -- you are so deserving of this

430
00:43:10,100 --> 00:43:12,100
award, so thank you, shella, for being

431
00:43:12,100 --> 00:43:16,100
at this college and continuing to give

432
00:43:16,100 --> 00:43:18,100
into it.

433
00:43:18,100 --> 00:43:20,401
>> comments from other trustees?

434
00:43:22,100 --> 00:43:24,100
well, thank you very, very much, and

435
00:43:24,100 --> 00:43:28,801
find a nice place to put that award.

436
00:43:30,100 --> 00:43:32,100
[applause].

437
00:43:35,100 --> 00:43:38,100
>> we move to item 4, closed session.

438
00:43:38,100 --> 00:43:41,100
first we need the approval of the

439
00:43:41,100 --> 00:43:42,100
closed session agenda.

440
00:43:42,100 --> 00:43:44,401
who moves to approve?

441
00:43:47,100 --> 00:43:48,100
>> so moved.

442
00:43:48,100 --> 00:43:49,100
>> trustee solomon moves to the

443
00:43:49,100 --> 00:43:50,100
approve.

444
00:43:50,100 --> 00:43:51,100
who seconds?

445
00:43:51,100 --> 00:43:53,100
>> second.

446
00:43:53,100 --> 00:43:55,100
>> second from vice-president zamora.

447
00:43:55,100 --> 00:43:57,100
could we have a roll call vote, please.

448
00:43:57,100 --> 00:43:58,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

449
00:43:58,100 --> 00:44:00,100
advisory vote?

450
00:44:10,100 --> 00:44:11,100
president martinez?

451
00:44:11,100 --> 00:44:12,100
>> yes.

452
00:44:12,100 --> 00:44:13,100
>> vice-president zamora?

453
00:44:13,100 --> 00:44:15,100
>> aye.

454
00:44:15,100 --> 00:44:16,100
>> trustee chisti?

455
00:44:16,100 --> 00:44:17,100
>> aye.

456
00:44:17,100 --> 00:44:18,100
>> trustee solomon?

457
00:44:18,100 --> 00:44:19,100
>> aye.

458
00:44:19,100 --> 00:44:20,100
>> trustee chung?

459
00:44:20,100 --> 00:44:21,100
>> aye.

460
00:44:21,100 --> 00:44:22,100
>> trustee mccarty?

461
00:44:22,100 --> 00:44:23,100
>> aye.

462
00:44:23,100 --> 00:44:24,100
>> the motion passes.

463
00:44:24,100 --> 00:44:25,100
>> thank you.

464
00:44:25,100 --> 00:44:28,100
we will recess to closed session and

465
00:44:28,100 --> 00:44:31,601
we will reconvene back here at 6:00

466
00:44:32,100 --> 00:44:34,401
p.m., thank you.

467
00:44:38,100 --> 00:44:41,100
( meeting recesses to closed session ).

468
00:44:48,100 --> 00:44:50,401
( meeting will reconvene at 6:00 ).

469
02:19:15,000 --> 02:19:17,100
>> we have taken a brief recess from

470
02:19:17,100 --> 02:19:19,100
closed session.

471
02:19:20,100 --> 02:19:21,100
no reportable actions have been taken.

472
02:19:21,100 --> 02:19:23,100
we would like to take public comment

473
02:19:23,100 --> 02:19:26,100
on the closed session agenda items now.

474
02:19:26,100 --> 02:19:29,100
is there any public comment on the

475
02:19:29,100 --> 02:19:30,100
closed session agendas?

476
02:19:30,100 --> 02:19:32,401
>> we don't have any.

477
02:19:33,100 --> 02:19:35,100
>> 6a.

478
02:19:36,100 --> 02:19:38,401
>> we have a lot.

479
02:19:39,100 --> 02:19:41,401
first is angelica campos.

480
02:19:50,100 --> 02:19:52,100
>> alright, I was not expected it to

481
02:19:52,100 --> 02:19:54,100
be that soon.

482
02:19:55,100 --> 02:19:56,100
hi, good evening, afternoon, board,

483
02:19:56,100 --> 02:19:59,100
sorry, I am on the east coast so

484
02:19:59,100 --> 02:20:01,100
it's a bit confusing.

485
02:20:01,100 --> 02:20:03,000
I'm here tonight to speak to you all

486
02:20:03,000 --> 02:20:07,800
in support of dr. Cortez, I as an

487
02:20:09,100 --> 02:20:11,401
incoming student leader, student

488
02:20:13,100 --> 02:20:16,100
trustee elect believe we do need to

489
02:20:16,100 --> 02:20:18,100
support our college by approving dr.

490
02:20:18,100 --> 02:20:20,100
cortez as the new chancellor.

491
02:20:20,100 --> 02:20:22,100
I think again it's really important we

492
02:20:22,100 --> 02:20:25,601
also support queer and latin voices

493
02:20:29,100 --> 02:20:33,100
in the current climate we live in where

494
02:20:33,100 --> 02:20:36,100
united states where queer latinx

495
02:20:37,100 --> 02:20:39,100
individuals are under attack and I'm

496
02:20:39,100 --> 02:20:42,601
disappointed in things I'm seeing in

497
02:20:43,100 --> 02:20:45,100
the media targeting this person, it is

498
02:20:45,100 --> 02:20:47,100
unfair and I believe dr. Cortez will

499
02:20:47,100 --> 02:20:50,100
be something that will help push our

500
02:20:50,100 --> 02:20:51,100
college forward into a better future.

501
02:20:51,100 --> 02:20:53,100
thank you.

502
02:20:56,100 --> 02:20:58,401
>> next is eddie escota.

503
02:21:19,100 --> 02:21:21,401
next is luis miranda.

504
02:21:35,100 --> 02:21:37,401
next is malinalli villalobos.

505
02:21:47,100 --> 02:21:50,100
>> can you all hear me?

506
02:21:50,100 --> 02:21:51,100
>> yes.

507
02:21:51,100 --> 02:21:53,100
>> okay.

508
02:21:54,100 --> 02:21:57,100
let me see, I'm trying to turn my

509
02:21:57,100 --> 02:21:59,100
camera on, there is no camera.

510
02:21:59,100 --> 02:22:00,100
alright.

511
02:22:00,100 --> 02:22:02,401
okay, here we go.

512
02:22:03,100 --> 02:22:06,100
saludos, good evening, my name is

513
02:22:06,100 --> 02:22:07,100
malinalli villalobos, I serve as

514
02:22:07,100 --> 02:22:09,100
student chancellor, I'm here tonight

515
02:22:09,100 --> 02:22:13,100
to speak in strong support of approving

516
02:22:13,100 --> 02:22:15,100
the chancellor employment contract

517
02:22:15,100 --> 02:22:18,100
with carlos cortez, as student, we

518
02:22:18,100 --> 02:22:20,100
know firsthand the importance of

519
02:22:20,100 --> 02:22:21,100
consistent visionary leadership,

520
02:22:21,100 --> 02:22:22,100
someone who understands the challenges

521
02:22:22,100 --> 02:22:25,100
we face and the potential of what ccsf

522
02:22:25,100 --> 02:22:27,100
can become.

523
02:22:27,100 --> 02:22:30,100
dr. Cortez brings leadership in the

524
02:22:30,100 --> 02:22:32,100
california community college system, a

525
02:22:32,100 --> 02:22:34,100
deep commitment to equity, a strong

526
02:22:34,100 --> 02:22:37,100
understanding of the unique needs of

527
02:22:37,100 --> 02:22:39,100
diverse student population like ours.

528
02:22:39,100 --> 02:22:42,100
he has spooned stabilize budgets while

529
02:22:42,100 --> 02:22:44,100
expanding access which is something

530
02:22:44,100 --> 02:22:46,100
ccsf critically needs.

531
02:22:47,100 --> 02:22:49,100
he's also someone who listens to

532
02:22:49,100 --> 02:22:51,100
student, faculty, to classified

533
02:22:51,100 --> 02:22:52,100
professionals including community

534
02:22:52,100 --> 02:22:53,100
overall.

535
02:22:53,100 --> 02:22:55,100
right now ccsf needs a steady hand and

536
02:22:55,100 --> 02:22:57,100
a bold vision, we cannot afford more

537
02:22:57,100 --> 02:22:59,100
turn over in leadership.

538
02:22:59,100 --> 02:23:01,100
every delay affects students.

539
02:23:01,100 --> 02:23:03,100
our classes, our services, our future.

540
02:23:03,100 --> 02:23:06,100
approving this crack is not just about

541
02:23:06,100 --> 02:23:08,100
filling a position, it's about giving

542
02:23:08,100 --> 02:23:11,100
cshs csf the stability and [inaudible]

543
02:23:11,100 --> 02:23:12,100
it needs to thrive.

544
02:23:12,100 --> 02:23:14,100
as student chancellor, I urge you to

545
02:23:14,100 --> 02:23:16,100
move forward with confidence and

546
02:23:16,100 --> 02:23:18,100
approve the employment contract with

547
02:23:18,100 --> 02:23:21,100
dr. Cortez, let's give him a chance to

548
02:23:21,100 --> 02:23:23,100
lead ccsf in a stronger, more

549
02:23:23,100 --> 02:23:25,100
sustainable future and one last thing

550
02:23:25,100 --> 02:23:29,100
that I want to add about dr. Cortez,

551
02:23:29,100 --> 02:23:32,100
when we had the pleasure of having to

552
02:23:32,100 --> 02:23:36,100
give him a tour of our campuses and a

553
02:23:36,100 --> 02:23:38,100
can couple of our centers, he was

554
02:23:38,100 --> 02:23:39,100
engaging with students and really

555
02:23:39,100 --> 02:23:41,100
wanted the student input.

556
02:23:41,100 --> 02:23:44,100
students at the forefront, that's what

557
02:23:44,100 --> 02:23:45,100
we need, leadership with students a

558
02:23:45,100 --> 02:23:46,100
the forefront.

559
02:23:46,100 --> 02:23:48,100
advocating for the

560
02:23:48,100 --> 02:23:51,100
approval of dr. Carlos cortez's

561
02:23:51,100 --> 02:23:54,100
contract, thank you very much.

562
02:23:55,100 --> 02:23:57,401
>> next is mary bravewoman.

563
02:24:04,100 --> 02:24:06,100
>> good wantoning, trustees, I've

564
02:24:06,100 --> 02:24:07,100
been at city college for 35 years and

565
02:24:07,100 --> 02:24:10,100
I have experienced every high and

566
02:24:10,100 --> 02:24:12,100
low ccsf has been through since 1990.

567
02:24:12,100 --> 02:24:14,100
and this is just one of the reasons

568
02:24:14,100 --> 02:24:16,100
that I was so thrilled to read the

569
02:24:16,100 --> 02:24:17,100
press release announcing the

570
02:24:17,100 --> 02:24:19,100
appointment of dr. Carlos cortez as

571
02:24:19,100 --> 02:24:20,100
our next chancellor.

572
02:24:20,100 --> 02:24:22,100
I had the honor of serving on the

573
02:24:22,100 --> 02:24:25,100
hiring committee and reviewed all the

574
02:24:25,100 --> 02:24:27,100
c vehicles of a broadly talented pool

575
02:24:27,100 --> 02:24:30,100
of am kant but for me, one candidate

576
02:24:30,100 --> 02:24:32,100
stood out among the others, dr.

577
02:24:32,100 --> 02:24:34,100
cortez, now I'm not naive enough to

578
02:24:34,100 --> 02:24:36,100
believe that one person holds all the

579
02:24:36,100 --> 02:24:38,100
answers to the struggles we face as a

580
02:24:38,100 --> 02:24:40,100
college community but the reality is

581
02:24:40,100 --> 02:24:43,100
that we're in better shape than we

582
02:24:43,100 --> 02:24:46,100
have been for some time despite the

583
02:24:46,100 --> 02:24:47,100
narratives currently circulating.

584
02:24:47,100 --> 02:24:49,100
but I am hopeful that with the

585
02:24:49,100 --> 02:24:51,100
appointment of an experienced

586
02:24:51,100 --> 02:24:53,100
permanent chancellor, one with a

587
02:24:53,100 --> 02:24:55,100
proven track record of putting into

588
02:24:55,100 --> 02:24:57,100
practice policies and practice that

589
02:24:57,100 --> 02:25:00,100
reflect the values of ccsf and their

590
02:25:00,100 --> 02:25:02,100
community, we can embark on positive

591
02:25:02,100 --> 02:25:04,100
change for our college.

592
02:25:04,100 --> 02:25:06,100
thank you, trustees, for making the

593
02:25:06,100 --> 02:25:08,100
right choice for our college and our

594
02:25:08,100 --> 02:25:10,100
community and for standing strong in

595
02:25:10,100 --> 02:25:14,100
your values and not giving into the

596
02:25:14,100 --> 02:25:17,601
trump dog whistles recently traded by

597
02:25:22,100 --> 02:25:24,100
the press of a talented queer

598
02:25:24,100 --> 02:25:26,100
educator, thank you.

599
02:25:27,100 --> 02:25:29,401
>> next is asia duncan.

600
02:25:39,100 --> 02:25:41,100
>> good evening, trustees.

601
02:25:41,100 --> 02:25:46,401
my name is asia and I'm one the harvey

602
02:25:47,100 --> 02:25:49,100
milk democratic clubbing I'm the v.p.

603
02:25:49,100 --> 02:25:51,100
of the political action committee and

604
02:25:51,100 --> 02:25:54,100
I'm here to voice my support for dr.

605
02:25:54,100 --> 02:25:57,100
cortez as your next chancellor.

606
02:25:58,100 --> 02:26:01,100
dr. Cortez is not only an accomplished

607
02:26:01,100 --> 02:26:03,100
educator with a record of strong

608
02:26:03,100 --> 02:26:06,100
leadership, he is a visionary who

609
02:26:06,100 --> 02:26:09,100
understands the power of community

610
02:26:11,100 --> 02:26:13,100
colleges as an engine of justice,

611
02:26:13,100 --> 02:26:16,100
access and upward mobility for working

612
02:26:16,100 --> 02:26:18,100
class students,

613
02:26:18,100 --> 02:26:20,401
immigrants and lgbtq folks.

614
02:26:22,100 --> 02:26:25,100
I believe city college deserves as

615
02:26:25,100 --> 02:26:28,100
bold leader rooted in justice and I

616
02:26:28,100 --> 02:26:29,100
believe dr. Cortez is that leader and

617
02:26:29,100 --> 02:26:33,100
I urge you to move forward with

618
02:26:33,100 --> 02:26:35,100
integrity and a vision of the future

619
02:26:35,100 --> 02:26:38,100
to appoint dr. Cortez as your next

620
02:26:38,100 --> 02:26:39,100
chancellor.

621
02:26:39,100 --> 02:26:41,100
thank you the.

622
02:26:43,100 --> 02:26:45,401
>> next is leslie simon.

623
02:26:56,100 --> 02:26:58,401
>> good evening, trustees, vice

624
02:27:03,100 --> 02:27:04,100
chancellors, I enthusiastically

625
02:27:04,100 --> 02:27:07,100
support hiring dr. Cortez, I want to

626
02:27:07,100 --> 02:27:09,401
address the chronicle's reapportioning

627
02:27:10,100 --> 02:27:13,100
of cortez's invitation to [inaudible]

628
02:27:15,100 --> 02:27:19,201
as a former ccsf omens and genders

629
02:27:20,100 --> 02:27:22,100
studies chair and women in literature,

630
02:27:22,100 --> 02:27:25,601
I'm familiar with the highly respected

631
02:27:26,100 --> 02:27:30,201
poetry fiction of alice walker, I had

632
02:27:31,100 --> 02:27:33,100
not learned that she had an affinity

633
02:27:33,100 --> 02:27:36,601
with a known anti-semite which shocked

634
02:27:37,100 --> 02:27:39,100
and disturbed me.

635
02:27:39,100 --> 02:27:42,100
that year an invitation with walker

636
02:27:42,100 --> 02:27:44,100
was withdrawn when the association

637
02:27:44,100 --> 02:27:46,100
became known.

638
02:27:46,100 --> 02:27:48,100
I am jewish and among my jewish

639
02:27:48,100 --> 02:27:51,100
friends, there were mixed feelings

640
02:27:52,100 --> 02:27:55,100
about the disinvitation, though even

641
02:27:55,100 --> 02:27:56,100
among those of us who thought she

642
02:27:56,100 --> 02:27:57,100
should be welcomed, there was the

643
02:27:57,100 --> 02:27:58,100
understanding her recommendation of

644
02:27:58,100 --> 02:28:00,100
the work of an anti-semite was

645
02:28:00,100 --> 02:28:01,100
disturbing.

646
02:28:01,100 --> 02:28:03,100
it is sad that so much is being made

647
02:28:03,100 --> 02:28:06,100
of dr. Cortez's invitation to walker

648
02:28:06,100 --> 02:28:09,100
also in 2022 which he subsequently

649
02:28:11,100 --> 02:28:13,100
withdrew, walker's ex-husband a jew,

650
02:28:13,100 --> 02:28:16,100
insists walker is not an anti-semite

651
02:28:16,100 --> 02:28:17,100
herself.

652
02:28:17,100 --> 02:28:20,100
even if she were, I ask you to think

653
02:28:20,100 --> 02:28:21,100
about how english departments teach

654
02:28:21,100 --> 02:28:25,100
the work of ts elliott, a known

655
02:28:25,100 --> 02:28:27,401
anti-semite and a nazi

656
02:28:28,100 --> 02:28:31,100
sympathizer, some of our greater

657
02:28:31,100 --> 02:28:34,100
artist, writers and thinkers are

658
02:28:34,100 --> 02:28:35,100
flawed, as we teach their work,

659
02:28:35,100 --> 02:28:37,100
we have a responsibility to

660
02:28:37,100 --> 02:28:38,100
share those flaws and allow our

661
02:28:38,100 --> 02:28:41,601
students to make their own assessments.

662
02:28:43,100 --> 02:28:44,100
censorship is ill advised, criticism

663
02:28:44,100 --> 02:28:45,100
is not.

664
02:28:45,100 --> 02:28:48,601
I look forward to welcoming carlos

665
02:28:49,100 --> 02:28:52,601
cortez, a respected academic who I

666
02:28:53,100 --> 02:28:55,100
believe will enrich the college and

667
02:28:55,100 --> 02:28:57,401
will enrich challenging conversations.

668
02:28:59,100 --> 02:29:01,401
>> next is robin pew.

669
02:29:07,100 --> 02:29:10,601
>> hello, I'm robin pew, I'm business

670
02:29:11,100 --> 02:29:14,100
faculty, the vice-president of aft 2121,

671
02:29:15,100 --> 02:29:18,100
the a member of the academic executive

672
02:29:18,100 --> 02:29:21,100
council, a voter in district 7, but

673
02:29:21,100 --> 02:29:25,100
I'm here speaking to you today as

674
02:29:25,100 --> 02:29:26,100
myself.

675
02:29:26,100 --> 02:29:27,100
this institution exists to serve

676
02:29:27,100 --> 02:29:29,401
students and this community.

677
02:29:30,100 --> 02:29:31,100
this institution does not exist to

678
02:29:31,100 --> 02:29:34,100
serve me as faculty, this institution

679
02:29:34,100 --> 02:29:37,100
does not exist to serve you as

680
02:29:37,100 --> 02:29:38,100
trustees.

681
02:29:38,100 --> 02:29:41,100
instead, we are all here to serve this

682
02:29:41,100 --> 02:29:43,401
institution and its mission.

683
02:29:44,100 --> 02:29:47,100
and this very large incredibly

684
02:29:49,100 --> 02:29:52,100
complex, beautiful, ugly falling down

685
02:29:52,100 --> 02:29:54,100
brand new charging ahead, limping

686
02:29:54,100 --> 02:29:57,100
along institutions that are still

687
02:29:57,100 --> 02:29:59,100
recovering from external attacks that

688
02:29:59,100 --> 02:30:01,100
were weaponized to

689
02:30:05,100 --> 02:30:08,100
accreditation to shut us down, this

690
02:30:08,100 --> 02:30:10,100
needs leadership and carlos has that

691
02:30:10,100 --> 02:30:12,100
experience, he has a proven track

692
02:30:12,100 --> 02:30:14,100
record of creating programs and

693
02:30:14,100 --> 02:30:16,100
serving students like ours.

694
02:30:16,100 --> 02:30:19,100
he has both the successful large

695
02:30:19,100 --> 02:30:21,100
institution leadership experience that

696
02:30:21,100 --> 02:30:23,100
we desperately need and he has also

697
02:30:23,100 --> 02:30:26,100
been in the classroom which is an

698
02:30:26,100 --> 02:30:28,100
important combination and something we

699
02:30:28,100 --> 02:30:30,100
have been missing in our recent

700
02:30:30,100 --> 02:30:31,100
leadership.

701
02:30:31,100 --> 02:30:32,100
we are in a very challenging place

702
02:30:32,100 --> 02:30:33,100
right now.

703
02:30:33,100 --> 02:30:35,100
I don't have to tell you that, you

704
02:30:35,100 --> 02:30:36,100
know.

705
02:30:36,100 --> 02:30:38,100
and we need a proven leader with the

706
02:30:38,100 --> 02:30:40,100
creativity to seek the path between

707
02:30:40,100 --> 02:30:44,100
the rock and the hard place where we

708
02:30:44,100 --> 02:30:47,100
are, so I urge you to approve dr.

709
02:30:47,100 --> 02:30:48,100
carlos cortez for chancellor.

710
02:30:48,100 --> 02:30:50,100
thank you.

711
02:30:51,100 --> 02:30:52,100
[applause].

712
02:30:52,100 --> 02:30:54,401
>> next is jen levinson.

713
02:31:01,100 --> 02:31:04,100
>> good evening, my name is jen, I'm

714
02:31:04,100 --> 02:31:06,100
english faculty.

715
02:31:06,100 --> 02:31:08,100
I'm guessing that you may have read

716
02:31:08,100 --> 02:31:11,100
the recent article by nanette

717
02:31:14,100 --> 02:31:16,100
criticizing the board for your choice

718
02:31:16,100 --> 02:31:18,100
to hire carlos cortez as our next ccsf

719
02:31:18,100 --> 02:31:19,100
chancellor.

720
02:31:19,100 --> 02:31:23,100
I think by now we're all familiar with

721
02:31:23,100 --> 02:31:24,100
disingenuous anti-semitism claims

722
02:31:24,100 --> 02:31:27,601
weaponized in an attempt to divide

723
02:31:28,100 --> 02:31:30,100
and left in a justified state of

724
02:31:30,100 --> 02:31:31,100
oppression of movements for human

725
02:31:31,100 --> 02:31:32,100
rights.

726
02:31:32,100 --> 02:31:34,100
as a jewish person, I have said more

727
02:31:34,100 --> 02:31:36,100
times I can count in the past 19

728
02:31:36,100 --> 02:31:38,100
months, not in my name.

729
02:31:38,100 --> 02:31:41,100
this article also deploys common

730
02:31:46,100 --> 02:31:49,601
tropes, let not let the inflammatory

731
02:31:51,100 --> 02:31:54,100
attempt of character assassination to

732
02:31:55,100 --> 02:31:58,100
[inaudible] he has strategic planning

733
02:32:00,100 --> 02:32:01,100
that reduces disproportionate impact

734
02:32:01,100 --> 02:32:03,100
on the most marginalized student and

735
02:32:03,100 --> 02:32:05,100
is has secured the fund to implement

736
02:32:05,100 --> 02:32:06,100
those plans.

737
02:32:06,100 --> 02:32:08,100
in his interview, he talked about how

738
02:32:08,100 --> 02:32:09,100
at san diego community college I

739
02:32:09,100 --> 02:32:12,100
believe it was, he identified 7

740
02:32:13,100 --> 02:32:15,100
obstacles to student success, gathered

741
02:32:15,100 --> 02:32:17,401
from students themselves, housing,

742
02:32:18,100 --> 02:32:21,100
child care, jobs, transportation, food

743
02:32:21,100 --> 02:32:23,100
security, textbook affordability,

744
02:32:23,100 --> 02:32:24,100
mental health supporters.

745
02:32:24,100 --> 02:32:26,100
he raised over 200 million dollars to

746
02:32:26,100 --> 02:32:28,100
address those needs including 85

747
02:32:28,100 --> 02:32:31,100
million for housing and 100 million

748
02:32:31,100 --> 02:32:33,100
for direct student support.

749
02:32:33,100 --> 02:32:35,100
I'm incredibly heartened this board

750
02:32:35,100 --> 02:32:36,100
has found us a chancellor who I

751
02:32:36,100 --> 02:32:39,100
believe can lead the college with

752
02:32:39,100 --> 02:32:41,100
integrity in these times of rising

753
02:32:41,100 --> 02:32:44,100
fascism and make a real difference for

754
02:32:44,100 --> 02:32:46,100
students and the community.

755
02:32:46,100 --> 02:32:47,100
so, please stand firm in your choice.

756
02:32:47,100 --> 02:32:49,100
thank you.

757
02:32:52,100 --> 02:32:53,100
[applause].

758
02:32:53,100 --> 02:32:55,401
>> next is eric christians.

759
02:33:01,100 --> 02:33:04,100
>> I want to congratulate your

760
02:33:04,100 --> 02:33:06,100
decision to hire the new chancellor,

761
02:33:06,100 --> 02:33:09,100
you made an excellent choice, you have

762
02:33:09,100 --> 02:33:10,100
picketed somebody student centered

763
02:33:10,100 --> 02:33:12,100
hastening a prover track record and

764
02:33:12,100 --> 02:33:15,100
I'm speaking to somebody that's a

765
02:33:15,100 --> 02:33:17,100
returning adult to city college who's

766
02:33:17,100 --> 02:33:19,100
also queer, city college is now why

767
02:33:19,100 --> 02:33:21,100
I'm called doctor by my student, the

768
02:33:21,100 --> 02:33:23,401
doctorate was an organization

769
02:33:24,100 --> 02:33:25,100
leadership, I've taught leadership

770
02:33:25,100 --> 02:33:26,100
development at a graduate level.

771
02:33:26,100 --> 02:33:29,100
what I see in dr. Cortez is a

772
02:33:29,100 --> 02:33:31,100
leadership that we need to move

773
02:33:31,100 --> 02:33:33,100
forward, I see inspired leadership, I

774
02:33:33,100 --> 02:33:35,100
see the type of leadership I would use

775
02:33:35,100 --> 02:33:37,100
an example in those courses to my

776
02:33:37,100 --> 02:33:39,100
students to say this is somebody who

777
02:33:39,100 --> 02:33:43,201
can make a change, this is something

778
02:33:44,100 --> 02:33:45,100
body who has vision, the vision comes

779
02:33:45,100 --> 02:33:46,100
from listening to the to the people

780
02:33:46,100 --> 02:33:48,100
they serve, we need him and I thank

781
02:33:48,100 --> 02:33:51,100
you again for your choice.

782
02:33:53,100 --> 02:33:55,401
>> next is marlan vasquez.

783
02:34:08,100 --> 02:34:11,100
>> okay, good evening, board of trustees,

784
02:34:11,100 --> 02:34:14,601
my name is dr. Marlan vasquez,

785
02:34:16,100 --> 02:34:18,100
I'm an english faculty member and a

786
02:34:18,100 --> 02:34:20,100
leader of the latino education

787
02:34:20,100 --> 02:34:22,100
association here at city college,

788
02:34:22,100 --> 02:34:24,100
while others today have spoken to the

789
02:34:24,100 --> 02:34:27,100
recent article by nanette, I don't

790
02:34:27,100 --> 02:34:30,100
want to spend time on it, I'm heart

791
02:34:30,100 --> 02:34:33,100
broken that somebody leaked dr.

792
02:34:35,100 --> 02:34:37,401
cortez's to provoke that.

793
02:34:42,100 --> 02:34:45,100
it offered none of the complexity or

794
02:34:45,100 --> 02:34:47,100
depth that our community heard

795
02:34:47,100 --> 02:34:49,100
debiting from dr. Cortez during his

796
02:34:49,100 --> 02:34:51,100
extensive interviews.

797
02:34:52,100 --> 02:34:54,100
what he spoke about was thoughtful and

798
02:34:54,100 --> 02:34:57,100
forward looking, he staged about

799
02:34:57,100 --> 02:34:59,100
building strong pipelines from k-12 to

800
02:34:59,100 --> 02:35:01,100
community college.

801
02:35:01,100 --> 02:35:04,100
he talked about using on the ground

802
02:35:04,100 --> 02:35:06,100
data of centering leadership, that's

803
02:35:06,100 --> 02:35:09,100
the kind of vision that should guide

804
02:35:09,100 --> 02:35:11,100
this college, complex, student

805
02:35:11,100 --> 02:35:12,100
centered and rooted in care.

806
02:35:12,100 --> 02:35:16,100
as a latino educator and researcher of

807
02:35:16,100 --> 02:35:18,100
latino student experiences at city

808
02:35:18,100 --> 02:35:20,100
college, a hispanic serving

809
02:35:20,100 --> 02:35:23,100
institution, I must emphasize that our

810
02:35:23,100 --> 02:35:24,100
latino students are struggling.

811
02:35:24,100 --> 02:35:27,100
they make up 28% of our credit

812
02:35:27,100 --> 02:35:30,100
enrollment and for every 100 students,

813
02:35:31,100 --> 02:35:33,100
only 11 are completing their vision

814
02:35:33,100 --> 02:35:34,100
goal.

815
02:35:34,100 --> 02:35:37,100
we know from research including my own

816
02:35:37,100 --> 02:35:38,100
that representation matters.

817
02:35:38,100 --> 02:35:41,100
dr. Cortez is a first generation

818
02:35:41,100 --> 02:35:43,100
latino college student.

819
02:35:43,100 --> 02:35:46,100
his presence as chancellor would send

820
02:35:46,100 --> 02:35:48,100
a powerful message to our latino

821
02:35:48,100 --> 02:35:49,100
students that they belong, that they

822
02:35:49,100 --> 02:35:52,100
can lead and that education can

823
02:35:52,100 --> 02:35:53,100
transform their lives.

824
02:35:53,100 --> 02:35:56,100
at a time when so many of our students

825
02:35:56,100 --> 02:35:57,100
are navigating uncertainty, his

826
02:35:57,100 --> 02:36:00,100
leadership offers the kind of

827
02:36:00,100 --> 02:36:01,100
stability, understanding and bold

828
02:36:01,100 --> 02:36:04,100
vision that we urgently need.

829
02:36:04,100 --> 02:36:05,100
I'm excited to be in the audience

830
02:36:05,100 --> 02:36:07,100
today when the board of trustees votes

831
02:36:07,100 --> 02:36:09,100
him in.

832
02:36:09,100 --> 02:36:11,100
our students deserve this kind of

833
02:36:11,100 --> 02:36:12,100
leadership.

834
02:36:12,100 --> 02:36:14,401
thank you so much.

835
02:36:17,100 --> 02:36:18,100
[applause].

836
02:36:18,100 --> 02:36:20,401
>> next is melissa hernandez.

837
02:36:28,100 --> 02:36:30,401
>> hi, good evening, honorable

838
02:36:31,100 --> 02:36:34,100
trustees, my name is melissa, the

839
02:36:34,100 --> 02:36:37,100
co-president of the harvey milk

840
02:36:37,100 --> 02:36:39,100
democratic club, I'm here to lend my

841
02:36:39,100 --> 02:36:41,100
voice in support of the appointment of

842
02:36:41,100 --> 02:36:42,100
dr. Cortez.

843
02:36:42,100 --> 02:36:45,601
dr. Cortez is a respected chicano

844
02:36:46,100 --> 02:36:47,100
scholar, former community college leader

845
02:36:47,100 --> 02:36:50,601
and a fierce advocate for equity,

846
02:36:51,100 --> 02:36:53,100
reinvestment and academic freedom all

847
02:36:53,100 --> 02:36:56,100
of which makes city college special.

848
02:36:56,100 --> 02:36:59,100
I won't spend too much time singing

849
02:36:59,100 --> 02:37:03,100
his praises eh as I'm sure you heard a

850
02:37:03,100 --> 02:37:05,100
lot here today.

851
02:37:06,100 --> 02:37:09,100
I believe city college will continue

852
02:37:09,100 --> 02:37:13,201
to serve the city of san francisco,

853
02:37:14,100 --> 02:37:17,100
and also on a personal level, I think

854
02:37:17,100 --> 02:37:20,100
dr. Cortez will serve people like my

855
02:37:20,100 --> 02:37:24,100
little sister who is a full time

856
02:37:24,100 --> 02:37:26,100
student here and who has been for a

857
02:37:26,100 --> 02:37:29,100
few years and I hope you will

858
02:37:29,100 --> 02:37:30,100
support him.

859
02:37:30,100 --> 02:37:32,100
thank you.

860
02:37:34,100 --> 02:37:36,401
>> next is michael rapay.

861
02:37:42,100 --> 02:37:44,100
>> hello, good evening, president

862
02:37:44,100 --> 02:37:47,100
martinez and trustees, my name is

863
02:37:47,100 --> 02:37:48,100
michael, the co-vice-president of

864
02:37:48,100 --> 02:37:51,100
police cal affairs for latino

865
02:37:51,100 --> 02:37:53,100
democratic club here in san francisco.

866
02:37:53,100 --> 02:37:56,100
and I have to say how incredibly proud

867
02:37:56,100 --> 02:37:59,100
I am right now to be standing in front

868
02:37:59,100 --> 02:38:03,100
of you speaking in support of dr.

869
02:38:03,100 --> 02:38:04,100
cortez.

870
02:38:04,100 --> 02:38:07,100
at a time our community is so under

871
02:38:07,100 --> 02:38:09,100
attack right now, recently just

872
02:38:09,100 --> 02:38:11,100
yesterday, there were reports of ice

873
02:38:11,100 --> 02:38:12,100
attacking people.

874
02:38:12,100 --> 02:38:15,100
our communities are under attack, we

875
02:38:15,100 --> 02:38:16,100
need this visibility right now,

876
02:38:16,100 --> 02:38:18,100
particularly in leadership positions.

877
02:38:18,100 --> 02:38:21,100
I've been so moved by so many of the

878
02:38:21,100 --> 02:38:23,100
speakers before me, some things I venn

879
02:38:23,100 --> 02:38:26,100
learned about dr. Cortez that solidify

880
02:38:26,100 --> 02:38:28,100
my belief that this would be an

881
02:38:28,100 --> 02:38:31,100
excellent choice for city college.

882
02:38:31,100 --> 02:38:35,100
as former student, I took the ethnic

883
02:38:35,100 --> 02:38:38,601
and cultural minority studies I took

884
02:38:39,100 --> 02:38:40,100
lgbtq studies and these studies

885
02:38:40,100 --> 02:38:42,100
support my belief this would be the

886
02:38:42,100 --> 02:38:45,601
right direction, not only just by

887
02:38:46,100 --> 02:38:48,100
person alone but remember the

888
02:38:48,100 --> 02:38:49,100
chancellor has to have a vision that

889
02:38:49,100 --> 02:38:51,100
aligns with all of you and I believe

890
02:38:51,100 --> 02:38:53,100
that this is really the critical issue

891
02:38:53,100 --> 02:38:56,100
here and I hope you take that into

892
02:38:56,100 --> 02:38:58,100
consideration with your support and

893
02:38:58,100 --> 02:38:59,100
hopefully a vote yes.

894
02:38:59,100 --> 02:39:01,401
thank you so much.

895
02:39:05,100 --> 02:39:07,401
>> next is rosa shields.

896
02:39:10,100 --> 02:39:12,100
>> good evening, my name is rosa

897
02:39:12,100 --> 02:39:14,100
shields, I'm the political director of

898
02:39:14,100 --> 02:39:16,100
the san francisco labor council.

899
02:39:16,100 --> 02:39:18,401
we represent 100 unions and 100

900
02:39:19,100 --> 02:39:21,100
union members in the city and county

901
02:39:21,100 --> 02:39:22,100
of san francisco.

902
02:39:22,100 --> 02:39:24,100
I was also born and raised here in the

903
02:39:24,100 --> 02:39:28,100
city and I'm the proud daughter of a

904
02:39:28,100 --> 02:39:29,100
professor and department chair,

905
02:39:29,100 --> 02:39:31,100
retired, I experienced first hand the

906
02:39:31,100 --> 02:39:34,100
stress of the accreditation fight and

907
02:39:34,100 --> 02:39:36,100
how that affected my family.

908
02:39:36,100 --> 02:39:39,100
I would not wish that upon anyone.

909
02:39:39,100 --> 02:39:42,100
the fight for free city college was my

910
02:39:42,100 --> 02:39:43,100
entry into local politics and I

911
02:39:43,100 --> 02:39:45,100
would hope this board would support

912
02:39:45,100 --> 02:39:48,100
the needs of the unions, the community

913
02:39:48,100 --> 02:39:50,100
and the students who have worked so

914
02:39:50,100 --> 02:39:54,100
hard for equity and justice at this

915
02:39:54,100 --> 02:39:55,100
institution.

916
02:39:55,100 --> 02:39:57,100
the chronicle article smearing carlos

917
02:39:57,100 --> 02:39:59,100
cortez was an attack on labor, this is

918
02:39:59,100 --> 02:40:03,100
part of a broader attack on labor

919
02:40:03,100 --> 02:40:04,100
where are being called all sorts of

920
02:40:04,100 --> 02:40:05,100
things.

921
02:40:05,100 --> 02:40:08,100
these are the peel that teach the

922
02:40:08,100 --> 02:40:10,100
class, clean the classes and respond

923
02:40:10,100 --> 02:40:12,100
to emergencies, we are vested

924
02:40:12,100 --> 02:40:14,100
stakeholders and we all support the

925
02:40:14,100 --> 02:40:16,100
approval of carlos cortez's contract.

926
02:40:16,100 --> 02:40:18,100
right now as I'm sure you know, labor

927
02:40:18,100 --> 02:40:20,100
is under attack federally.

928
02:40:20,100 --> 02:40:23,100
and unions are fighting back against

929
02:40:23,100 --> 02:40:24,100
cuts at all levels of government.

930
02:40:24,100 --> 02:40:26,100
the board of trustees of city college

931
02:40:26,100 --> 02:40:28,100
support the needs and wishes of the

932
02:40:28,100 --> 02:40:30,100
workers of city college and of the

933
02:40:30,100 --> 02:40:32,100
students and of the community who are

934
02:40:32,100 --> 02:40:34,100
all calling for approval of this

935
02:40:34,100 --> 02:40:35,100
contract.

936
02:40:35,100 --> 02:40:36,100
we have worked so hard to support the

937
02:40:36,100 --> 02:40:38,100
college and its programs and we will

938
02:40:38,100 --> 02:40:40,100
continue to do so.

939
02:40:40,100 --> 02:40:42,100
we will also be very disappointed if

940
02:40:42,100 --> 02:40:44,100
the elected officials who represent

941
02:40:44,100 --> 02:40:47,601
the college side with an austerity

942
02:40:48,100 --> 02:40:49,100
administration rather than with the

943
02:40:49,100 --> 02:40:50,100
workers, the students and the

944
02:40:50,100 --> 02:40:51,100
community.

945
02:40:51,100 --> 02:40:52,100
we did not forget the accreditation

946
02:40:52,100 --> 02:40:55,100
fight, I know I didn't, we did not

947
02:40:55,100 --> 02:40:58,100
forget the fight for free city college

948
02:40:58,100 --> 02:41:00,100
t the fight to keep free city college

949
02:41:00,100 --> 02:41:01,100
and we will not forget this vote.

950
02:41:01,100 --> 02:41:03,100
thank you.

951
02:41:07,100 --> 02:41:09,401
>> next is alex cough.

952
02:41:18,100 --> 02:41:19,100
>> good evening, san francisco city

953
02:41:19,100 --> 02:41:22,100
college, board of trustees, my

954
02:41:22,100 --> 02:41:25,100
name is alex, the president of san

955
02:41:25,100 --> 02:41:27,100
francisco firefighters local 798.

956
02:41:27,100 --> 02:41:31,100
I'm here to speak in support of your

957
02:41:31,100 --> 02:41:32,100
original choice, your first choice,

958
02:41:32,100 --> 02:41:35,601
the right choice, dr. Carlos cortez.

959
02:41:36,100 --> 02:41:40,100
hundreds of our members who are now

960
02:41:40,100 --> 02:41:42,100
firefighters, emt and paramedics

961
02:41:42,100 --> 02:41:45,100
attended san francisco city college

962
02:41:46,100 --> 02:41:49,100
obtain their emt, paramedic licenses

963
02:41:49,100 --> 02:41:51,401
and firefighter 1 certificates along

964
02:41:52,100 --> 02:41:55,100
with attend a multitude of other fire

965
02:41:55,100 --> 02:41:56,100
science classes.

966
02:41:56,100 --> 02:41:58,100
our members respond now to the

967
02:41:58,100 --> 02:42:01,100
communities all over the city, to

968
02:42:01,100 --> 02:42:02,100
medical emergencies and structure

969
02:42:02,100 --> 02:42:04,401
fires every single day.

970
02:42:05,100 --> 02:42:08,100
for the sake of the future

971
02:42:08,100 --> 02:42:10,100
firefighters, emt's and paramedics of

972
02:42:10,100 --> 02:42:11,100
san francisco, and for the sake of the

973
02:42:11,100 --> 02:42:14,601
communities that we serve, we support

974
02:42:18,100 --> 02:42:21,601
your original choice of chancellor for

975
02:42:22,100 --> 02:42:24,100
san francisco city college.

976
02:42:24,100 --> 02:42:27,100
the institution that educates more

977
02:42:27,100 --> 02:42:30,100
ssfd members than any other

978
02:42:31,100 --> 02:42:32,100
institution.

979
02:42:32,100 --> 02:42:35,100
dr. Carlos cortez has already proven

980
02:42:35,100 --> 02:42:38,100
his excellent ability to work with

981
02:42:38,100 --> 02:42:40,401
labor and across constituencies.

982
02:42:43,100 --> 02:42:46,100
he has experience in classrooms and

983
02:42:46,100 --> 02:42:49,100
board rooms, he's proven -- he's got a

984
02:42:49,100 --> 02:42:52,100
vision and track record of growing

985
02:42:52,100 --> 02:42:54,401
student enrollment and enhancing

986
02:42:56,100 --> 02:42:58,100
programs.

987
02:42:59,100 --> 02:43:02,100
he's proven his student centered

988
02:43:02,100 --> 02:43:03,100
leadership and he has active roots in

989
02:43:03,100 --> 02:43:06,100
social welfare and education policy.

990
02:43:08,100 --> 02:43:10,100
and he's already proven the ability

991
02:43:10,100 --> 02:43:13,100
and willingness to build partnership

992
02:43:13,100 --> 02:43:15,100
with community leaders.

993
02:43:15,100 --> 02:43:18,100
he's already proven his commitment to

994
02:43:18,100 --> 02:43:21,100
economic, racial and gender equality.

995
02:43:21,100 --> 02:43:25,801
you've all already as a board made the

996
02:43:26,100 --> 02:43:29,100
right choice and please we ask you to

997
02:43:29,100 --> 02:43:30,100
stand firm in your choice.

998
02:43:30,100 --> 02:43:33,100
our members along with the san

999
02:43:33,100 --> 02:43:35,100
francisco communities that we serve

1000
02:43:35,100 --> 02:43:38,100
all deserve a high quality chancellor

1001
02:43:38,100 --> 02:43:42,801
to lead and to continue to grow and

1002
02:43:43,100 --> 02:43:45,100
improve san francisco -- or city

1003
02:43:45,100 --> 02:43:47,100
college of san francisco, thank you

1004
02:43:47,100 --> 02:43:49,100
very much.

1005
02:43:49,100 --> 02:43:51,401
>> next is ronald gonzalez.

1006
02:44:01,100 --> 02:44:02,100
>> hello.

1007
02:44:02,100 --> 02:44:04,401
can you hear me?

1008
02:44:05,100 --> 02:44:06,100
sorry, hello, can you confirm --

1009
02:44:06,100 --> 02:44:08,100
>> we can hear you.

1010
02:44:08,100 --> 02:44:10,100
>> awesome, thank you.

1011
02:44:15,100 --> 02:44:18,601
welcome on behalf of the mission

1012
02:44:19,100 --> 02:44:22,100
center, I'm the president of the

1013
02:44:22,100 --> 02:44:23,100
association there and I have a

1014
02:44:23,100 --> 02:44:25,100
question for the board of trustees,

1015
02:44:25,100 --> 02:44:28,100
can I move to go ahead and start the

1016
02:44:28,100 --> 02:44:31,100
voting in favor or no?

1017
02:44:31,100 --> 02:44:35,201
but you can probably answer later, but

1018
02:44:36,100 --> 02:44:39,100
I want to go ahead and get this voting

1019
02:44:39,100 --> 02:44:40,100
started.

1020
02:44:40,100 --> 02:44:43,100
go ahead and approve the process and

1021
02:44:43,100 --> 02:44:45,100
dr. Cortez, just a reminder, we are the

1022
02:44:45,100 --> 02:44:47,100
students are going to keep you

1023
02:44:47,100 --> 02:44:48,100
accountable, hold you accountable and

1024
02:44:48,100 --> 02:44:50,100
we're going to be in your office if

1025
02:44:50,100 --> 02:44:55,401
you're not on the field or -- we read

1026
02:44:56,100 --> 02:44:58,100
a lot about you, heard about you and I

1027
02:44:58,100 --> 02:45:01,100
think we are fortunate to have you as

1028
02:45:01,100 --> 02:45:04,100
our next chancellor and I would love

1029
02:45:04,100 --> 02:45:06,100
to continue working with you in person

1030
02:45:06,100 --> 02:45:10,801
now and here in san francisco but be

1031
02:45:11,100 --> 02:45:14,100
sure that if things change and things

1032
02:45:14,100 --> 02:45:17,100
are not coming out as expected, you're

1033
02:45:17,100 --> 02:45:19,100
going hear from the students and with

1034
02:45:19,100 --> 02:45:21,100
all the love and with all the respect

1035
02:45:21,100 --> 02:45:24,100
and we want to learn from you, teach

1036
02:45:24,100 --> 02:45:27,100
us you how to be better leaders, let

1037
02:45:27,100 --> 02:45:31,100
us -- show us how you achieved all

1038
02:45:31,100 --> 02:45:33,100
those goals and what else have you

1039
02:45:33,100 --> 02:45:36,100
done to improve the lives of students

1040
02:45:36,100 --> 02:45:37,100
from san diego.

1041
02:45:37,100 --> 02:45:39,100
so, we want to see that here in san

1042
02:45:39,100 --> 02:45:42,100
francisco and again welcome, I hope we

1043
02:45:42,100 --> 02:45:46,100
can get started with the voting and

1044
02:45:46,100 --> 02:45:48,100
remember, we look forward to working

1045
02:45:48,100 --> 02:45:51,100
with you, however, we will keep you

1046
02:45:51,100 --> 02:45:52,100
accountable.

1047
02:45:52,100 --> 02:45:55,100
we will check and make sure that what

1048
02:45:55,100 --> 02:45:57,100
was proposed and what was told in

1049
02:45:57,100 --> 02:45:59,100
interviews do happen.

1050
02:45:59,100 --> 02:46:02,100
this is our livelihood, it's

1051
02:46:03,100 --> 02:46:04,100
important for us and we're happy

1052
02:46:04,100 --> 02:46:06,100
you're here, so thank you so much,

1053
02:46:06,100 --> 02:46:08,100
take care.

1054
02:46:08,100 --> 02:46:10,401
>> next is harry bernstein.

1055
02:46:23,100 --> 02:46:24,100
>> thank you.

1056
02:46:24,100 --> 02:46:28,201
you've heard a number of things about

1057
02:46:29,100 --> 02:46:31,401
dr. Cortez's scholarship, his

1058
02:46:33,100 --> 02:46:36,100
leadership, his teaching and his

1059
02:46:36,100 --> 02:46:38,100
advocacy for colleges.

1060
02:46:38,100 --> 02:46:41,100
he's been at many different

1061
02:46:41,100 --> 02:46:42,100
institutions.

1062
02:46:42,100 --> 02:46:45,100
I was going to note that president

1063
02:46:45,100 --> 02:46:49,201
martinez in referring to the -- well,

1064
02:46:50,100 --> 02:46:52,100
incoming chancellor let's say noted

1065
02:46:52,100 --> 02:46:55,601
his commitment to programs for new

1066
02:46:56,100 --> 02:46:57,100
americans, non-credit workforce

1067
02:46:57,100 --> 02:46:59,100
development and older adults.

1068
02:46:59,100 --> 02:47:03,801
I just want to highlight one part of

1069
02:47:05,100 --> 02:47:06,100
that.

1070
02:47:06,100 --> 02:47:08,100
dr. Cortez led the execution of a

1071
02:47:08,100 --> 02:47:11,100
statewide study and report which was

1072
02:47:11,100 --> 02:47:15,100
called the past, present and future of

1073
02:47:15,100 --> 02:47:17,100
adult non-credit education in

1074
02:47:17,100 --> 02:47:19,100
california from 1856 to 2018.

1075
02:47:22,100 --> 02:47:23,100
he was well situated for doing that

1076
02:47:23,100 --> 02:47:28,100
because he was the head of one of the

1077
02:47:28,100 --> 02:47:30,100
colleges in san diego, the san diego

1078
02:47:30,100 --> 02:47:32,100
college of continuing education which

1079
02:47:32,100 --> 02:47:36,201
has the most robust offerings of free

1080
02:47:40,100 --> 02:47:41,100
non-credit education in california.

1081
02:47:41,100 --> 02:47:44,100
I believe it's an entire college

1082
02:47:44,100 --> 02:47:47,601
devoted -- the college of continuing

1083
02:47:49,100 --> 02:47:50,100
education.

1084
02:47:50,100 --> 02:47:54,100
and since the program that we've had

1085
02:47:54,100 --> 02:47:58,100
in city college has been lagging since

1086
02:47:58,100 --> 02:48:00,100
it was decimated a few years ago,

1087
02:48:00,100 --> 02:48:03,100
I'm opining this is one of the many

1088
02:48:03,100 --> 02:48:06,100
hicks that he can champion along with

1089
02:48:06,100 --> 02:48:07,100
all the other demands we've been

1090
02:48:07,100 --> 02:48:08,100
hearing.

1091
02:48:08,100 --> 02:48:12,201
thank you very much for your selection.

1092
02:48:13,100 --> 02:48:15,401
>> next is kathy burick.

1093
02:48:22,100 --> 02:48:24,100
>> good evening, trustees, I can't

1094
02:48:24,100 --> 02:48:27,100
believe we're having this conversation.

1095
02:48:27,100 --> 02:48:29,100
for there to be any question about the

1096
02:48:29,100 --> 02:48:31,100
qualifications of this man and who and

1097
02:48:31,100 --> 02:48:35,201
what he represents at a time when

1098
02:48:36,100 --> 02:48:38,401
lgbtq, latinx are being

1099
02:48:41,100 --> 02:48:43,100
trivialized, annette, she has not had

1100
02:48:43,100 --> 02:48:46,601
written I don't think one trustworthy

1101
02:48:47,100 --> 02:48:48,100
article of city college from the

1102
02:48:48,100 --> 02:48:51,100
beginning of the accreditation so how

1103
02:48:51,100 --> 02:48:53,100
on earth -- everything she's written

1104
02:48:53,100 --> 02:48:55,100
has been biased, a lot of it has been

1105
02:48:55,100 --> 02:48:57,100
inaccurate, to have any doubt in your

1106
02:48:57,100 --> 02:49:00,100
mind, there is too much integrity

1107
02:49:00,100 --> 02:49:03,100
among you to base your decision on

1108
02:49:03,100 --> 02:49:07,100
anything that annette azmof has to say

1109
02:49:07,100 --> 02:49:08,100
in the chronicle.

1110
02:49:08,100 --> 02:49:10,100
I don't know who her editor is, they

1111
02:49:10,100 --> 02:49:12,100
have been unfriendly, unfair and

1112
02:49:12,100 --> 02:49:15,601
untruthful since the beginning of the

1113
02:49:20,100 --> 02:49:22,100
accreditation scandal, don't give into

1114
02:49:22,100 --> 02:49:24,100
your -- I won't say bullshit.

1115
02:49:24,100 --> 02:49:25,100
[applause].

1116
02:49:25,100 --> 02:49:27,401
>> next is maria rodriguez.

1117
02:49:35,100 --> 02:49:38,100
>> hello, good evening, my name is

1118
02:49:38,100 --> 02:49:40,100
maria rodriguez ramirez, I'm here

1119
02:49:40,100 --> 02:49:43,100
speak on behalf of the city dream

1120
02:49:43,100 --> 02:49:46,100
program in support of carlos cortez

1121
02:49:46,100 --> 02:49:49,601
and moving forward with the contract

1122
02:49:51,100 --> 02:49:53,100
as our new chancellor.

1123
02:49:53,100 --> 02:49:55,100
the work that we're doing at city

1124
02:49:55,100 --> 02:49:58,100
dream is very critical in this time

1125
02:49:58,100 --> 02:50:01,100
and even more than that, we are really

1126
02:50:01,100 --> 02:50:03,100
in need of institutional support.

1127
02:50:03,100 --> 02:50:05,100
when I speak of institutional support,

1128
02:50:05,100 --> 02:50:07,100
I speak of action that is really

1129
02:50:07,100 --> 02:50:09,100
needed at the leadership level.

1130
02:50:09,100 --> 02:50:12,100
what this means in terms of the new

1131
02:50:12,100 --> 02:50:14,100
chancellor coming in is hope.

1132
02:50:14,100 --> 02:50:17,100
hope that we can really be an

1133
02:50:17,100 --> 02:50:19,100
established center to widen the

1134
02:50:19,100 --> 02:50:21,100
resources that we are really needing

1135
02:50:21,100 --> 02:50:22,100
to us.

1136
02:50:22,100 --> 02:50:24,100
when thinking about the leadership our

1137
02:50:24,100 --> 02:50:26,100
students are in need of, they need

1138
02:50:26,100 --> 02:50:28,100
someone who will listen to them, that

1139
02:50:28,100 --> 02:50:29,100
will lead them and that will also

1140
02:50:29,100 --> 02:50:31,100
learn with us and this is something

1141
02:50:31,100 --> 02:50:33,100
that I really do believe carlos will

1142
02:50:33,100 --> 02:50:35,100
be bringing to the table to really

1143
02:50:35,100 --> 02:50:38,100
allow our students to flourish, have

1144
02:50:38,100 --> 02:50:40,100
the resources they need to be

1145
02:50:40,100 --> 02:50:42,100
successful in their steps and to be

1146
02:50:42,100 --> 02:50:45,100
able to feel like they have a sense of

1147
02:50:45,100 --> 02:50:47,100
belonging here on campus, that's

1148
02:50:47,100 --> 02:50:48,100
something that's hard for us to do on

1149
02:50:48,100 --> 02:50:50,100
behalf of the whole campus community

1150
02:50:50,100 --> 02:50:52,100
if we're not receiving that backing

1151
02:50:52,100 --> 02:50:53,100
from the chancellor themselves.

1152
02:50:53,100 --> 02:50:55,100
and that's the vision that we really

1153
02:50:55,100 --> 02:50:58,100
want to make sure that does come to

1154
02:50:58,100 --> 02:51:00,100
fruition through this new chancellor

1155
02:51:00,100 --> 02:51:05,100
and why we do urge the approval of the

1156
02:51:05,100 --> 02:51:07,100
contract for carlos cortez to be our

1157
02:51:07,100 --> 02:51:09,100
new chancellor, it's something our

1158
02:51:09,100 --> 02:51:11,100
students have been advocating for is

1159
02:51:11,100 --> 02:51:14,100
to simply be heard, to simply be seen,

1160
02:51:14,100 --> 02:51:16,100
that is something they felt during the

1161
02:51:16,100 --> 02:51:18,100
time of the interview process and

1162
02:51:18,100 --> 02:51:21,100
things like that because they were one

1163
02:51:21,100 --> 02:51:24,100
of very, very few candidates that

1164
02:51:24,100 --> 02:51:25,100
mentioned undocumented students and

1165
02:51:25,100 --> 02:51:27,100
what they had done in previous

1166
02:51:27,100 --> 02:51:29,100
institutions to really have this

1167
02:51:29,100 --> 02:51:31,100
support for students through the

1168
02:51:31,100 --> 02:51:33,100
institution themselves and not just

1169
02:51:33,100 --> 02:51:36,100
solely relying on people that do this

1170
02:51:36,100 --> 02:51:38,100
labor but be able to equip them and be

1171
02:51:38,100 --> 02:51:41,601
able to provide them with the

1172
02:51:42,100 --> 02:51:44,401
resources needed to [inaudible]

1173
02:51:48,100 --> 02:51:50,401
>> that concludes public comments.

1174
02:51:53,100 --> 02:51:56,100
>> are any of the commenters that you

1175
02:51:56,100 --> 02:51:58,401
called on before present?

1176
02:52:00,100 --> 02:52:03,100
>> one more time, eddie escoto.

1177
02:52:09,100 --> 02:52:13,201
>> yes, I'm eddie, I just wanted to

1178
02:52:14,100 --> 02:52:17,100
say that I was as a student, I was

1179
02:52:17,100 --> 02:52:21,100
present for all the interviews of all

1180
02:52:21,100 --> 02:52:24,100
of the candidates for chancellor and

1181
02:52:24,100 --> 02:52:28,100
cortez was the on the one who had in

1182
02:52:28,100 --> 02:52:29,100
mind everybody's benefit.

1183
02:52:29,100 --> 02:52:31,401
the student, the faculty,

1184
02:52:32,100 --> 02:52:33,100
administration, everybody's benefit.

1185
02:52:33,100 --> 02:52:36,100
he was the only one who had a clear

1186
02:52:36,100 --> 02:52:38,100
picture going forward.

1187
02:52:38,100 --> 02:52:41,100
it's very obvious he has already

1188
02:52:41,100 --> 02:52:43,100
proven in many other places as

1189
02:52:43,100 --> 02:52:45,100
everybody else has already said and I

1190
02:52:45,100 --> 02:52:48,100
just want to say that students are not

1191
02:52:48,100 --> 02:52:50,100
blind, we see, we can see, we see what

1192
02:52:50,100 --> 02:52:54,100
the best choice is and yes, please,

1193
02:52:54,100 --> 02:52:56,100
board, you've already taken it this

1194
02:52:56,100 --> 02:52:59,100
far, bring it home and just vote

1195
02:52:59,100 --> 02:53:00,100
carlos in already.

1196
02:53:00,100 --> 02:53:01,100
thank you.

1197
02:53:01,100 --> 02:53:03,401
>> next is tj miaki.

1198
02:53:08,100 --> 02:53:10,401
>> hi, board, trustees, ironically

1199
02:53:11,100 --> 02:53:14,100
I'm not going to be speaking about

1200
02:53:14,100 --> 02:53:15,100
possible chancellor cortez, so you

1201
02:53:15,100 --> 02:53:17,100
guys can breathe for a moment.

1202
02:53:17,100 --> 02:53:20,100
I wanted to -- and I wish chancellor

1203
02:53:20,100 --> 02:53:21,100
bailey was here because I wanted to

1204
02:53:21,100 --> 02:53:24,100
say that he renewed my faith in what a

1205
02:53:24,100 --> 02:53:27,601
chancellor could be as a student

1206
02:53:29,100 --> 02:53:31,100
attending since 2019.

1207
02:53:31,100 --> 02:53:34,100
the lack of student centered

1208
02:53:34,100 --> 02:53:36,100
chancellor leadership on campus has

1209
02:53:36,100 --> 02:53:37,100
been ridiculous.

1210
02:53:37,100 --> 02:53:40,601
I've had them ignore me completely,

1211
02:53:41,100 --> 02:53:44,100
not respond to my e-mail, not have

1212
02:53:44,100 --> 02:53:47,100
assistants get back to me, mitchell

1213
02:53:47,100 --> 02:53:49,100
who introduced himself to me the first

1214
02:53:49,100 --> 02:53:51,100
time I met him did.

1215
02:53:51,100 --> 02:53:52,100
I really appreciate it and I look

1216
02:53:52,100 --> 02:53:54,100
forward to whatever happens with the

1217
02:53:54,100 --> 02:53:55,100
new chancellor.

1218
02:53:55,100 --> 02:53:58,100
I did want to say last year, august

1219
02:53:58,100 --> 02:54:02,100
29, 2004, I came and spoke to you guys

1220
02:54:02,100 --> 02:54:03,100
about ada issues.

1221
02:54:03,100 --> 02:54:05,100
I have come back several times over

1222
02:54:05,100 --> 02:54:08,100
the last few months and bringing them

1223
02:54:08,100 --> 02:54:09,100
up.

1224
02:54:09,100 --> 02:54:12,100
right in this building on the front

1225
02:54:12,100 --> 02:54:15,100
door, that door still does not work,

1226
02:54:15,100 --> 02:54:16,100
okay.

1227
02:54:16,100 --> 02:54:18,100
so, as of monday, I'm going to have to

1228
02:54:18,100 --> 02:54:20,100
file with the u.s. Department of

1229
02:54:20,100 --> 02:54:22,100
justice civil rights division an ada

1230
02:54:22,100 --> 02:54:24,100
complaint because I have video going

1231
02:54:24,100 --> 02:54:26,100
back five years of this door not

1232
02:54:26,100 --> 02:54:27,100
working.

1233
02:54:27,100 --> 02:54:29,100
as a student leader, tried to work

1234
02:54:29,100 --> 02:54:31,100
with the facilities person to find out

1235
02:54:31,100 --> 02:54:33,100
what the process was, could never get

1236
02:54:33,100 --> 02:54:34,100
a response.

1237
02:54:34,100 --> 02:54:37,100
why ada issues are not priority for

1238
02:54:37,100 --> 02:54:41,100
facilities to fix is criminal on this

1239
02:54:41,100 --> 02:54:42,100
campus.

1240
02:54:42,100 --> 02:54:45,100
so, I'm going to be doing that and I

1241
02:54:45,100 --> 02:54:47,100
can't believe I have to do that.

1242
02:54:47,100 --> 02:54:51,100
I tried to work on this as a student

1243
02:54:51,100 --> 02:54:54,100
leader, I tried to work on this as a

1244
02:54:54,100 --> 02:54:55,100
student at large, this is ridiculous,

1245
02:54:55,100 --> 02:54:56,100
there's no excuse why that door is not

1246
02:54:56,100 --> 02:54:59,100
fixed and the other ada issues on

1247
02:54:59,100 --> 02:55:01,100
campus are not taken care of and they

1248
02:55:01,100 --> 02:55:04,100
should be prioritized, thank you.

1249
02:55:04,100 --> 02:55:06,401
>> next is alyssa messier.

1250
02:55:08,100 --> 02:55:09,100
>> I'll be very quick.

1251
02:55:09,100 --> 02:55:14,401
I just wanted to say I was so hopeful

1252
02:55:15,100 --> 02:55:18,100
when I saw the chronicle article which

1253
02:55:18,100 --> 02:55:21,100
said that dr. Cortez was incoming as

1254
02:55:21,100 --> 02:55:22,100
our new chancellor.

1255
02:55:22,100 --> 02:55:25,100
I just -- my heart soared until I

1256
02:55:25,100 --> 02:55:28,100
clicked on the article and saw what

1257
02:55:28,100 --> 02:55:30,100
was inside.

1258
02:55:30,100 --> 02:55:33,100
I particularly want to say as a jewish

1259
02:55:33,100 --> 02:55:36,100
woman that the weaponization of

1260
02:55:37,100 --> 02:55:40,100
anti-semitism in this case is

1261
02:55:40,100 --> 02:55:42,100
despicable and want to also say in

1262
02:55:42,100 --> 02:55:46,100
line with my sisters jen and leslie

1263
02:55:46,100 --> 02:55:50,100
who have already spoken on this that

1264
02:55:50,100 --> 02:55:53,601
as a omens and genders studies

1265
02:55:54,100 --> 02:55:56,100
instructor, as someone who has taught

1266
02:55:56,100 --> 02:55:58,100
these things for a long time, the fact

1267
02:55:58,100 --> 02:56:00,100
that alice walker has some

1268
02:56:00,100 --> 02:56:03,100
questionable views lately does not

1269
02:56:03,100 --> 02:56:07,201
remove the many, many years she's had

1270
02:56:08,100 --> 02:56:11,601
of her work for feminism and

1271
02:56:15,100 --> 02:56:18,100
particularly for woman-ism which is

1272
02:56:19,100 --> 02:56:21,100
something she create sod the idea that

1273
02:56:21,100 --> 02:56:23,100
dr. Cortez would be attacked for not

1274
02:56:23,100 --> 02:56:24,100
knowing this small thing that few

1275
02:56:24,100 --> 02:56:26,100
people know about as opposed to all of

1276
02:56:26,100 --> 02:56:30,801
the work that walker has done was just

1277
02:56:32,100 --> 02:56:36,201
extremely upsetting to me to see that

1278
02:56:38,100 --> 02:56:39,100
happen.

1279
02:56:39,100 --> 02:56:41,100
I have been through a lot of leaders

1280
02:56:41,100 --> 02:56:42,100
at city college and a lot of

1281
02:56:42,100 --> 02:56:45,601
chancellors at this point, many, many

1282
02:56:48,100 --> 02:56:49,100
years.

1283
02:56:49,100 --> 02:56:52,100
I took notes at the forums and I just

1284
02:56:52,100 --> 02:56:53,100
was looking back at the many notes

1285
02:56:53,100 --> 02:56:56,100
that I took when dr. Cortez was here

1286
02:56:56,100 --> 02:56:58,100
and if you could see it, there are

1287
02:56:58,100 --> 02:57:00,100
little stars and things underlined and

1288
02:57:00,100 --> 02:57:02,100
a lot of really wonderful things.

1289
02:57:02,100 --> 02:57:04,100
he talked about enrollment growth in a

1290
02:57:04,100 --> 02:57:06,100
way that seems serious and to have

1291
02:57:06,100 --> 02:57:08,100
some ideas, he talked about non-credit

1292
02:57:08,100 --> 02:57:12,100
in a way that valued non-credit, in a

1293
02:57:12,100 --> 02:57:14,100
way I've never heard at this college

1294
02:57:14,100 --> 02:57:15,100
for a dozen years.

1295
02:57:15,100 --> 02:57:17,100
it was amazing.

1296
02:57:17,100 --> 02:57:18,100
dr. Cortez is the right choice.

1297
02:57:18,100 --> 02:57:20,100
thank you.

1298
02:57:22,100 --> 02:57:24,401
>> next is luis miranda.

1299
02:57:32,100 --> 02:57:34,401
next is brianna smith.

1300
02:57:46,100 --> 02:57:51,401
>> I will just say as my name is brianna

1301
02:57:52,100 --> 02:57:54,100
smith, the president of the black

1302
02:57:54,100 --> 02:57:58,100
student union and we are in complete

1303
02:57:58,100 --> 02:58:00,100
support of carlos cortez.

1304
02:58:00,100 --> 02:58:01,100
>> thank you.

1305
02:58:01,100 --> 02:58:03,100
any other speakers?

1306
02:58:20,100 --> 02:58:22,100
>> that concludes public comment.

1307
02:58:22,100 --> 02:58:25,601
>> the board will recess to closed

1308
02:58:26,100 --> 02:58:27,100
session, we will return shortly to

1309
02:58:27,100 --> 02:58:29,100
report on our vote.

1310
02:58:29,100 --> 02:58:30,100
it shouldn't take very long, we have

1311
02:58:30,100 --> 02:58:31,100
to go upstairs and down.

1312
02:58:31,100 --> 02:58:33,100
okay, thank you.

1313
02:58:36,100 --> 02:58:39,100
(meeting recesses into closed session).

1314
03:07:08,000 --> 03:07:09,100
>> we are back in order.

1315
03:07:09,100 --> 03:07:13,100
as president, I made a mistake and the

1316
03:07:13,100 --> 03:07:17,100
mistake that I made is that I did not

1317
03:07:17,100 --> 03:07:18,100
call for the student trustee's

1318
03:07:18,100 --> 03:07:19,100
advisory vote before we recessed to

1319
03:07:19,100 --> 03:07:20,100
closed session.

1320
03:07:20,100 --> 03:07:23,100
so, we will now do that, we will call

1321
03:07:23,100 --> 03:07:26,100
for trustee -- student trustee heather

1322
03:07:26,100 --> 03:07:27,100
brandt's advisory vote and then we

1323
03:07:27,100 --> 03:07:30,601
will go back to closed session.

1324
03:07:32,100 --> 03:07:33,100
sorry.

1325
03:07:33,100 --> 03:07:36,100
trustee, can you call for the vote,

1326
03:07:36,100 --> 03:07:37,100
please.

1327
03:07:37,100 --> 03:07:39,100
>> may I know the motion?

1328
03:07:39,100 --> 03:07:41,100
>> 6a.

1329
03:07:46,100 --> 03:07:48,401
>> it's 6a, number 6a.

1330
03:07:50,100 --> 03:07:52,100
>> is it a--

1331
03:07:52,100 --> 03:07:55,100
>> approval of the chancellor employment

1332
03:07:59,100 --> 03:08:00,100
contract with carlos cortez, we're

1333
03:08:00,100 --> 03:08:03,100
taking the student advisory vote,

1334
03:08:03,100 --> 03:08:04,100
that's all we're doing.

1335
03:08:04,100 --> 03:08:06,401
heather, are you online?

1336
03:08:18,100 --> 03:08:19,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

1337
03:08:19,100 --> 03:08:21,100
advisory vote?

1338
03:08:26,100 --> 03:08:29,100
>> yes, can somebody text --

1339
03:08:29,100 --> 03:08:31,100
>> I did.

1340
03:08:31,100 --> 03:08:34,100
>> the mistake again is that before we

1341
03:08:34,100 --> 03:08:38,100
recessed into closed session to take a

1342
03:08:38,100 --> 03:08:41,100
vote of the trustees who are present

1343
03:08:41,100 --> 03:08:43,100
here, we did not take the advisory

1344
03:08:43,100 --> 03:08:46,100
vote of the student trustee.

1345
03:08:46,100 --> 03:08:48,100
she cannot go to closed session to

1346
03:08:48,100 --> 03:08:50,100
vote so we always take an advisory

1347
03:08:50,100 --> 03:08:53,100
vote first, so that's why we all came

1348
03:08:53,100 --> 03:08:55,100
back and then we'll go back up.

1349
03:08:55,100 --> 03:08:58,100
we're getting our steps in.

1350
03:09:00,100 --> 03:09:02,100
it's on 6a.

1351
03:09:08,100 --> 03:09:11,100
>> I guess I have a question, maybe we

1352
03:09:11,100 --> 03:09:15,100
can ask legal counsel to the clarify

1353
03:09:15,100 --> 03:09:18,100
whether procedure-wise can we have --

1354
03:09:18,100 --> 03:09:21,100
in terms of this voting for a closed

1355
03:09:21,100 --> 03:09:24,601
session item publicly by a student

1356
03:09:26,100 --> 03:09:27,100
trustee, what are the rules and

1357
03:09:27,100 --> 03:09:28,100
processes around that.

1358
03:09:28,100 --> 03:09:29,100
I don't think -- yeah, so I want to

1359
03:09:29,100 --> 03:09:31,100
understand that.

1360
03:09:35,100 --> 03:09:37,100
>> is counsel present?

1361
03:09:39,100 --> 03:09:43,100
well, instead of taking a vote, is

1362
03:09:43,100 --> 03:09:47,201
this a possibility, could we just ask

1363
03:09:48,100 --> 03:09:51,100
student trustee heather brandt to

1364
03:09:52,100 --> 03:09:55,100
express her opinion on 6a.

1365
03:09:59,100 --> 03:10:03,201
that's what all the comment was on.

1366
03:10:04,100 --> 03:10:06,100
then we're going to go back into

1367
03:10:06,100 --> 03:10:09,100
closed session to vote on it.

1368
03:10:09,100 --> 03:10:10,100
pardon?

1369
03:10:10,100 --> 03:10:12,100
>> [inaudible].

1370
03:10:21,100 --> 03:10:24,601
>> we're voting on 6a because that's

1371
03:10:25,100 --> 03:10:28,100
what all the public comment was taken

1372
03:10:28,100 --> 03:10:29,100
on.

1373
03:10:29,100 --> 03:10:31,100
when the student trustee reminded us,

1374
03:10:31,100 --> 03:10:33,100
she texted us and reminded us we had

1375
03:10:33,100 --> 03:10:36,100
not taken her advisory vote, both

1376
03:10:36,100 --> 03:10:39,100
because of my forgetfulness and

1377
03:10:39,100 --> 03:10:41,100
because we owe it to student trustee

1378
03:10:41,100 --> 03:10:43,100
heather brandt to take her vote on

1379
03:10:43,100 --> 03:10:44,100
that.

1380
03:10:44,100 --> 03:10:47,100
I see student trustee heather brandt's

1381
03:10:47,100 --> 03:10:49,100
hand up.

1382
03:10:49,100 --> 03:10:51,100
>> yes, sorry, let me know if you're

1383
03:10:51,100 --> 03:10:53,100
ready too obtain my vote as I'm not

1384
03:10:53,100 --> 03:10:55,100
able to participate in closed session.

1385
03:10:55,100 --> 03:10:58,100
I just wanted to be clear that in the

1386
03:10:58,100 --> 03:11:00,100
past when we've opened up the

1387
03:11:00,100 --> 03:11:01,100
chancellor search, the student trustee

1388
03:11:01,100 --> 03:11:03,100
has had an advisory vote and so I

1389
03:11:03,100 --> 03:11:06,100
wasn't sure why this would be any

1390
03:11:06,100 --> 03:11:09,100
different but I don't want to -- it

1391
03:11:09,100 --> 03:11:11,100
sounds like there's some sort of

1392
03:11:11,100 --> 03:11:12,100
discussion happening that I can't

1393
03:11:12,100 --> 03:11:13,100
fully hear in the room.

1394
03:11:13,100 --> 03:11:16,100
please let me know when you're ready

1395
03:11:16,100 --> 03:11:17,100
for my vote.

1396
03:11:17,100 --> 03:11:19,100
>> the chair has already ruled.

1397
03:11:19,100 --> 03:11:21,100
ms. Esteban, can you take the student

1398
03:11:21,100 --> 03:11:23,100
trustee's advisory vote? Student

1399
03:11:23,100 --> 03:11:26,100
>> trustee brandt, your advisory vote?

1400
03:11:26,100 --> 03:11:29,100
>> can you please state what exactly

1401
03:11:29,100 --> 03:11:30,100
I'm voting for.

1402
03:11:30,100 --> 03:11:32,100
I know we're on item 6a, but typically

1403
03:11:32,100 --> 03:11:35,100
there's a motion and then -- so --

1404
03:11:35,100 --> 03:11:38,100
>> can we pull up the motion on the

1405
03:11:38,100 --> 03:11:41,601
screen and I will read it.

1406
03:11:43,100 --> 03:11:44,100
>> the recommended action is that the

1407
03:11:44,100 --> 03:11:47,100
board of trustees approve the

1408
03:11:47,100 --> 03:11:49,100
appointment of dr. Carlos cortez

1409
03:11:49,100 --> 03:11:52,100
effective july 1, 2025 to serve as

1410
03:11:52,100 --> 03:11:55,100
chancellor of city college of san

1411
03:11:55,100 --> 03:11:56,100
francisco.

1412
03:11:56,100 --> 03:11:57,100
that's what you are voting on.

1413
03:11:57,100 --> 03:11:58,100
>> thank you.

1414
03:11:58,100 --> 03:12:00,100
I appreciate the clarity and my vote

1415
03:12:00,100 --> 03:12:01,100
is yes or aye.

1416
03:12:01,100 --> 03:12:03,100
>> thank you very much.

1417
03:12:03,100 --> 03:12:06,100
we will now recess to closed session

1418
03:12:06,100 --> 03:12:07,100
to take the vote we were up there to

1419
03:12:07,100 --> 03:12:08,100
take originally.

1420
03:12:08,100 --> 03:12:10,401
sorry for the inconvenience.

1421
03:12:14,100 --> 03:12:17,100
(meeting resumes into closed session).

1422
04:54:39,000 --> 04:54:42,000
>> we are reconvening from closed

1423
04:54:43,100 --> 04:54:44,100
session.

1424
04:54:44,100 --> 04:54:46,100
we shall be make a motion to extend

1425
04:54:46,100 --> 04:54:49,100
the time of the meeting.

1426
04:54:49,100 --> 04:54:53,100
>> so moved, I move that we extend

1427
04:54:53,100 --> 04:54:56,601
the business meeting to 10:00 for now?

1428
04:55:03,100 --> 04:55:04,100
10:30?

1429
04:55:04,100 --> 04:55:05,100
11:00.

1430
04:55:05,100 --> 04:55:06,100
>> thank you.

1431
04:55:06,100 --> 04:55:07,100
>> is there a second to the motion?

1432
04:55:07,100 --> 04:55:08,100
>> second.

1433
04:55:08,100 --> 04:55:10,401
>> motion by vice-president zamora,

1434
04:55:11,100 --> 04:55:15,100
second by trustee chisti to extend the

1435
04:55:15,100 --> 04:55:16,100
meeting until 11:00.

1436
04:55:16,100 --> 04:55:20,100
let's take a vote on, that starting

1437
04:55:20,100 --> 04:55:21,100
with the student trustee.

1438
04:55:21,100 --> 04:55:23,401
>> student trustee brandt, your

1439
04:55:24,100 --> 04:55:25,100
advisory vote?

1440
04:55:25,100 --> 04:55:27,100
>> aye.

1441
04:55:27,100 --> 04:55:28,100
>> president martinez?

1442
04:55:28,100 --> 04:55:29,100
>> yes.

1443
04:55:29,100 --> 04:55:30,100
>> vice-president zamora?

1444
04:55:30,100 --> 04:55:31,100
>> aye.

1445
04:55:31,100 --> 04:55:32,100
>> trustee chisti?

1446
04:55:32,100 --> 04:55:33,100
>> aye.

1447
04:55:33,100 --> 04:55:34,100
>> trustee wong?

1448
04:55:34,100 --> 04:55:35,100
>> yes.

1449
04:55:35,100 --> 04:55:36,100
>> trustee solomon?

1450
04:55:36,100 --> 04:55:37,100
>> yes.

1451
04:55:37,100 --> 04:55:38,100
>> trustee chung?

1452
04:55:38,100 --> 04:55:39,100
>> aye.

1453
04:55:39,100 --> 04:55:40,100
>> trustee mccarty?

1454
04:55:40,100 --> 04:55:41,100
>> aye.

1455
04:55:41,100 --> 04:55:42,100
>> the motion passes.

1456
04:55:42,100 --> 04:55:45,100
>> thank you, the meeting is extended

1457
04:55:45,100 --> 04:55:46,100
until 11:00.

1458
04:55:46,100 --> 04:55:49,100
no reportable action was taken during

1459
04:55:49,100 --> 04:55:51,100
closed seg, therefore we will remove

1460
04:55:51,100 --> 04:55:54,100
item 6a from the open session agenda

1461
04:55:54,100 --> 04:55:58,201
and continue with the rest of the

1462
04:55:59,100 --> 04:56:01,100
meeting.

1463
04:56:01,100 --> 04:56:05,100
we now move to item 6b, approval of

1464
04:56:05,100 --> 04:56:07,100
employment agreements with college

1465
04:56:07,100 --> 04:56:08,100
executives.

1466
04:56:08,100 --> 04:56:10,100
who will move the resolution?

1467
04:56:10,100 --> 04:56:12,100
>> so moved.

1468
04:56:13,100 --> 04:56:15,100
>> trustee zamora, vice-president

1469
04:56:15,100 --> 04:56:16,100
zamora moves, who will second?

1470
04:56:16,100 --> 04:56:18,100
>> second.

1471
04:56:19,100 --> 04:56:22,601
>> was that trustee chisti will second.

1472
04:56:25,100 --> 04:56:27,100
okay, we need to take a roll call vote.

1473
04:56:27,100 --> 04:56:29,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

1474
04:56:29,100 --> 04:56:30,100
advisory vote?

1475
04:56:30,100 --> 04:56:31,100
>> aye.

1476
04:56:31,100 --> 04:56:32,100
>> president martinez?

1477
04:56:32,100 --> 04:56:33,100
>> yes.

1478
04:56:33,100 --> 04:56:35,100
>> vice-president zamora?

1479
04:56:36,100 --> 04:56:39,100
>> I just wanted to point out public

1480
04:56:39,100 --> 04:56:40,100
comment.

1481
04:56:40,100 --> 04:56:42,100
>> thank you very much.

1482
04:56:42,100 --> 04:56:44,100
we will -- let not take the vote on

1483
04:56:44,100 --> 04:56:45,100
that.

1484
04:56:45,100 --> 04:56:48,100
let's take trustee questions or

1485
04:56:50,100 --> 04:56:53,100
comments and then we'll take public

1486
04:56:53,100 --> 04:56:54,100
comments.

1487
04:56:54,100 --> 04:56:57,100
any trustee comments on item 6b?

1488
04:56:57,100 --> 04:56:59,100
any public comments?

1489
04:57:00,100 --> 04:57:03,100
>> we don't have any public comments

1490
04:57:03,100 --> 04:57:04,100
on item 6b.

1491
04:57:04,100 --> 04:57:08,201
>> okay, then let's go ahead with the

1492
04:57:14,100 --> 04:57:15,100
motion.

1493
04:57:15,100 --> 04:57:16,100
the vote on the motion.

1494
04:57:16,100 --> 04:57:18,401
>> student trustee brandt, your

1495
04:57:21,100 --> 04:57:22,100
advisory vote?

1496
04:57:22,100 --> 04:57:23,100
>> aye.

1497
04:57:23,100 --> 04:57:24,100
>> president martinez?

1498
04:57:24,100 --> 04:57:25,100
>> yes.

1499
04:57:25,100 --> 04:57:26,100
>> vice-president zamora?

1500
04:57:26,100 --> 04:57:27,100
>> aye.

1501
04:57:27,100 --> 04:57:28,100
>> trustee chisti?

1502
04:57:28,100 --> 04:57:29,100
>> aye.

1503
04:57:29,100 --> 04:57:30,100
>> trustee wong?

1504
04:57:30,100 --> 04:57:31,100
>> yes.

1505
04:57:31,100 --> 04:57:32,100
>> trustee solomon?

1506
04:57:32,100 --> 04:57:33,100
>> yes.

1507
04:57:33,100 --> 04:57:34,100
>> trustee chung?

1508
04:57:34,100 --> 04:57:35,100
>> aye.

1509
04:57:35,100 --> 04:57:36,100
>> trustee mccarty?

1510
04:57:36,100 --> 04:57:37,100
>> aye.

1511
04:57:37,100 --> 04:57:38,100
>> the motion passes.

1512
04:57:38,100 --> 04:57:40,100
>> thank you, we move to item 6c,

1513
04:57:40,100 --> 04:57:43,601
adoption of resolution number -- I'm

1514
04:57:44,100 --> 04:57:46,100
sorry?

1515
04:57:47,100 --> 04:57:49,100
>> [inaudible].

1516
04:58:02,100 --> 04:58:05,100
>> we can take public comments

1517
04:58:05,100 --> 04:58:08,100
under item 8, that's when we can take

1518
04:58:08,100 --> 04:58:10,100
public comments.

1519
04:58:12,100 --> 04:58:16,201
yeah, the item's been removed from the

1520
04:58:17,100 --> 04:58:18,100
agenda.

1521
04:58:18,100 --> 04:58:20,100
>> [inaudible].

1522
04:58:24,100 --> 04:58:26,100
>> I apologize for that but there's

1523
04:58:26,100 --> 04:58:30,201
not much I can do about it.

1524
04:58:32,100 --> 04:58:34,100
>> it's disrespectful.

1525
04:58:37,100 --> 04:58:40,100
>> let's move now to item 6c.

1526
04:58:40,100 --> 04:58:42,100
>> president martinez, there is an

1527
04:58:42,100 --> 04:58:45,100
item I need to read associated with

1528
04:58:45,100 --> 04:58:46,100
item 6b.

1529
04:58:46,100 --> 04:58:48,401
>> I'm sorry, thank you.

1530
04:58:54,100 --> 04:58:56,100
>> chancellor -- acting chancery

1531
04:58:56,100 --> 04:58:57,100
cooper wilkins?

1532
04:58:57,100 --> 04:59:01,201
>> this is an oral summary for the

1533
04:59:02,100 --> 04:59:04,100
executive contracts up for item 6b,

1534
04:59:04,100 --> 04:59:07,100
with the agenda item 6b, the board is

1535
04:59:07,100 --> 04:59:10,100
being asked to approve the two year

1536
04:59:10,100 --> 04:59:12,100
contract for david yee in the position

1537
04:59:12,100 --> 04:59:14,100
of vice chancellor for academic and

1538
04:59:14,100 --> 04:59:16,100
institutional affairs.

1539
04:59:16,100 --> 04:59:18,100
the two year contract would run from

1540
04:59:18,100 --> 04:59:20,100
july 1, 2025 to june 30, 2027.

1541
04:59:21,100 --> 04:59:24,100
the annual salary for the position of

1542
04:59:24,100 --> 04:59:27,100
vice chancellor for academic and

1543
04:59:27,100 --> 04:59:29,401
institutional affairs is 249 thousand

1544
04:59:31,100 --> 04:59:34,100
234 dollars with health and welfare

1545
04:59:34,100 --> 04:59:35,100
benefits consistent with

1546
04:59:35,100 --> 04:59:37,401
administrators of the district.

1547
04:59:40,100 --> 04:59:43,100
with the second agenda item, 6b, the

1548
04:59:43,100 --> 04:59:47,100
board is being asked to approve a two

1549
04:59:47,100 --> 04:59:50,601
year contract for patrick acawa many

1550
04:59:51,100 --> 04:59:54,100
the position of associate vice

1551
04:59:55,100 --> 04:59:58,100
chancellor for it/chief technology

1552
04:59:59,100 --> 05:00:00,100
officer.

1553
05:00:00,100 --> 05:00:04,201
the two year contract would also run

1554
05:00:05,100 --> 05:00:06,100
from july 1, 2025 to june 30, 2027.

1555
05:00:06,100 --> 05:00:08,100
the annual salary for the position of

1556
05:00:08,100 --> 05:00:11,100
associate vice chancellor for it/chief

1557
05:00:11,100 --> 05:00:13,401
technology officer is 238 thousand 503

1558
05:00:14,100 --> 05:00:17,100
dollars with health and welfare

1559
05:00:18,100 --> 05:00:19,100
benefits consistent with

1560
05:00:19,100 --> 05:00:20,100
administrators of the district.

1561
05:00:20,100 --> 05:00:21,100
>> thank you.

1562
05:00:21,100 --> 05:00:26,100
are we now ready to move to item 6c?

1563
05:00:26,100 --> 05:00:27,100
>> president martinez, is there a way

1564
05:00:27,100 --> 05:00:30,100
for us to just jump to 8a first, I

1565
05:00:30,100 --> 05:00:31,100
think members of the public even

1566
05:00:31,100 --> 05:00:33,100
though we can cannot share with

1567
05:00:33,100 --> 05:00:35,100
things, perhaps they have something to

1568
05:00:35,100 --> 05:00:36,100
say to us.

1569
05:00:36,100 --> 05:00:38,100
>> for members of the public and the

1570
05:00:38,100 --> 05:00:41,100
onuses that are outside, trustee chung

1571
05:00:41,100 --> 05:00:44,601
has suggested that we move item 8,

1572
05:00:45,100 --> 05:00:46,100
public comments, up to this point in

1573
05:00:46,100 --> 05:00:47,100
the agenda.

1574
05:00:47,100 --> 05:00:49,401
is there any objection?

1575
05:00:50,100 --> 05:00:53,601
>> sorry, really quickly, chair, I had

1576
05:00:54,100 --> 05:00:55,100
my hand up regarding the current item

1577
05:00:55,100 --> 05:00:57,100
we're on.

1578
05:00:57,100 --> 05:00:58,100
>> sorry, say it again.

1579
05:00:58,100 --> 05:00:59,100
>> I had my hand up.

1580
05:00:59,100 --> 05:01:00,100
>> yes, I see you.

1581
05:01:00,100 --> 05:01:03,100
>> okay, thank you, my apologies, so I

1582
05:01:03,100 --> 05:01:05,100
think before moving if I can speak, is

1583
05:01:05,100 --> 05:01:06,100
that okay?

1584
05:01:06,100 --> 05:01:08,100
>> what are you going to speak on?

1585
05:01:08,100 --> 05:01:11,100
>> current item we're on, 6b.

1586
05:01:11,100 --> 05:01:14,601
>> 6 become, -- 6b, we're going to

1587
05:01:16,100 --> 05:01:20,100
move the order of the agenda to item

1588
05:01:20,100 --> 05:01:22,100
8, public comments at which time

1589
05:01:22,100 --> 05:01:24,100
members of the audience can make

1590
05:01:24,100 --> 05:01:26,100
public comment on tenses not on the

1591
05:01:26,100 --> 05:01:29,601
agenda but at this point, student

1592
05:01:31,100 --> 05:01:33,100
trustee brandt has comments she would

1593
05:01:33,100 --> 05:01:35,100
like the make.

1594
05:01:37,100 --> 05:01:38,100
is that correct?

1595
05:01:38,100 --> 05:01:39,100
>> yeah, we just

1596
05:01:39,100 --> 05:01:41,100
voted on 6b but then information was

1597
05:01:41,100 --> 05:01:42,100
provided.

1598
05:01:42,100 --> 05:01:43,100
I don't know if that changes anything

1599
05:01:43,100 --> 05:01:46,100
or if we need to vote again, at least

1600
05:01:46,100 --> 05:01:50,100
when I click on 6b, the contract only

1601
05:01:50,100 --> 05:01:51,100
shows a template, it doesn't have the

1602
05:01:51,100 --> 05:01:54,100
titles or the dollar figures has were

1603
05:01:54,100 --> 05:01:56,100
mentioned by dr. Cooper wilkins, so I

1604
05:01:56,100 --> 05:01:59,100
don't know if we need to revote on not.

1605
05:01:59,100 --> 05:02:02,100
>> counsel, can you share an opinion.

1606
05:02:02,100 --> 05:02:03,100
>> yes, thank you, student trustee

1607
05:02:03,100 --> 05:02:08,401
brandt, I had my hand up for the same

1608
05:02:09,100 --> 05:02:12,100
reason is the brown act does not

1609
05:02:12,100 --> 05:02:13,100
require that oral summary to occur

1610
05:02:13,100 --> 05:02:16,100
before the board vote, so

1611
05:02:17,100 --> 05:02:19,100
now the acting chancellor has reported

1612
05:02:19,100 --> 05:02:22,100
out, we should take an additional vote

1613
05:02:22,100 --> 05:02:23,100
on item 6b.

1614
05:02:23,100 --> 05:02:24,100
>> thank you, ms. Esteban, will you

1615
05:02:24,100 --> 05:02:27,601
take that vote once again please.

1616
05:02:29,100 --> 05:02:30,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

1617
05:02:30,100 --> 05:02:31,100
advisory vote?

1618
05:02:31,100 --> 05:02:33,100
>> aye.

1619
05:02:33,100 --> 05:02:34,100
>> president martinez?

1620
05:02:34,100 --> 05:02:35,100
>> yes.

1621
05:02:35,100 --> 05:02:36,100
>> vice-president zamora?

1622
05:02:36,100 --> 05:02:37,100
>> aye.

1623
05:02:37,100 --> 05:02:38,100
>> trustee chisti?

1624
05:02:38,100 --> 05:02:39,100
>> aye.

1625
05:02:39,100 --> 05:02:40,100
>> trustee wong?

1626
05:02:40,100 --> 05:02:41,100
>> yes.

1627
05:02:41,100 --> 05:02:42,100
>> trustee solomon?

1628
05:02:42,100 --> 05:02:43,100
>> aye.

1629
05:02:43,100 --> 05:02:44,100
>> trustee chung?

1630
05:02:44,100 --> 05:02:45,100
>> aye.

1631
05:02:45,100 --> 05:02:46,100
>> trustee mccarty?

1632
05:02:46,100 --> 05:02:47,100
>> aye.

1633
05:02:47,100 --> 05:02:48,100
>> the motion passes.

1634
05:02:48,100 --> 05:02:52,100
>> we are now moving to item 8, we

1635
05:02:52,100 --> 05:02:55,100
will come back to item 6c.

1636
05:02:55,100 --> 05:02:57,100
item 8 is public comments.

1637
05:02:57,100 --> 05:03:00,100
we will take public comments on items

1638
05:03:00,100 --> 05:03:02,401
not on the agenda

1639
05:03:05,100 --> 05:03:07,100
received, we will listen to public

1640
05:03:07,100 --> 05:03:09,100
comment but cannot respond or act on

1641
05:03:09,100 --> 05:03:10,100
these items because they are not on

1642
05:03:10,100 --> 05:03:11,100
the agenda.

1643
05:03:11,100 --> 05:03:14,100
there's a two limit time limit, ms.

1644
05:03:14,100 --> 05:03:16,100
esteban, are there any pub luck

1645
05:03:16,100 --> 05:03:18,100
comment for items not on the agenda.

1646
05:03:18,100 --> 05:03:19,100
>> yes, we do.

1647
05:03:19,100 --> 05:03:22,601
the first one is ramona coltz.

1648
05:03:39,100 --> 05:03:41,100
>> can you hear me?

1649
05:03:41,100 --> 05:03:43,100
>> a little louder.

1650
05:03:43,100 --> 05:03:45,100
>> I can be loud, let me turn my

1651
05:03:45,100 --> 05:03:47,100
volume up.

1652
05:03:47,100 --> 05:03:51,201
grand evening, my name is dr. Ramona

1653
05:03:52,100 --> 05:03:55,100
coltz, a part time faculty member, on

1654
05:03:55,100 --> 05:03:57,401
october 22, 2020, our strand stroud

1655
05:04:03,100 --> 05:04:05,100
awardee and I came before the board of

1656
05:04:05,100 --> 05:04:07,100
trustees asking that the women's

1657
05:04:07,100 --> 05:04:09,100
resource center being located in the

1658
05:04:09,100 --> 05:04:10,100
new student success center.

1659
05:04:10,100 --> 05:04:13,100
you responded, you heard us and many

1660
05:04:13,100 --> 05:04:14,100
students including from the black

1661
05:04:14,100 --> 05:04:15,100
student union.

1662
05:04:15,100 --> 05:04:18,100
we had several meetings with the

1663
05:04:18,100 --> 05:04:20,100
company kitchell, they made changes to

1664
05:04:20,100 --> 05:04:23,100
the floor plan and added square

1665
05:04:23,100 --> 05:04:26,100
footage for the aarc, for the african

1666
05:04:26,100 --> 05:04:28,100
american resource center and the wrc

1667
05:04:28,100 --> 05:04:32,100
to have dedicated space in the new

1668
05:04:32,100 --> 05:04:33,100
student success center, thank you.

1669
05:04:33,100 --> 05:04:35,100
the new student success center is the

1670
05:04:35,100 --> 05:04:37,100
new front and center face of the

1671
05:04:37,100 --> 05:04:38,100
college.

1672
05:04:38,100 --> 05:04:41,100
there are pansies not to put the aarc,

1673
05:04:41,100 --> 05:04:44,100
african american resource center, in the

1674
05:04:44,100 --> 05:04:46,100
new student success center.

1675
05:04:46,100 --> 05:04:49,100
the african resource center is part of

1676
05:04:49,100 --> 05:04:51,100
the associated students, not an

1677
05:04:51,100 --> 05:04:52,100
academic program, counseling or

1678
05:04:52,100 --> 05:04:53,100
retention center.

1679
05:04:53,100 --> 05:04:54,100
there's a difference between retention

1680
05:04:54,100 --> 05:04:57,100
sent and he iser resource centers.

1681
05:04:57,100 --> 05:04:59,100
the aarc should not be merged with

1682
05:04:59,100 --> 05:05:02,100
other programs or centers tucked away

1683
05:05:02,100 --> 05:05:04,100
in mub with two other programs.

1684
05:05:04,100 --> 05:05:06,100
it's not what students want.

1685
05:05:06,100 --> 05:05:08,100
more support is needed to keep the

1686
05:05:08,100 --> 05:05:11,100
faculty advisory position molded dell

1687
05:05:11,100 --> 05:05:13,100
which provides supervisory support and

1688
05:05:13,100 --> 05:05:16,100
allows students to have the autonomy

1689
05:05:16,100 --> 05:05:20,100
in their student led space for student

1690
05:05:20,100 --> 05:05:21,100
meet-ups.

1691
05:05:21,100 --> 05:05:22,100
the african american resource

1692
05:05:22,100 --> 05:05:24,100
center has not had a formal roll out

1693
05:05:24,100 --> 05:05:27,100
for students to know about it nor has

1694
05:05:27,100 --> 05:05:29,401
it been included in

1695
05:05:30,100 --> 05:05:31,100
ccsf publications or print materials

1696
05:05:31,100 --> 05:05:34,100
for students to find as other centers

1697
05:05:34,100 --> 05:05:35,100
have.

1698
05:05:35,100 --> 05:05:38,100
at a time when black history is being

1699
05:05:38,100 --> 05:05:41,100
erased for revision history, dei and

1700
05:05:41,100 --> 05:05:44,100
the critical race theory disked, we

1701
05:05:44,100 --> 05:05:46,100
need to stand firm on our commitment

1702
05:05:46,100 --> 05:05:49,100
to black students and all students.

1703
05:05:49,100 --> 05:05:51,100
their educational safe haven is the

1704
05:05:51,100 --> 05:05:54,100
city college of san francisco.

1705
05:05:54,100 --> 05:05:57,601
listen to students, listen to student

1706
05:05:58,100 --> 05:05:59,100
readers, please, let's wait for the

1707
05:05:59,100 --> 05:06:00,100
[inaudible].

1708
05:06:00,100 --> 05:06:02,100
thank you.

1709
05:06:03,100 --> 05:06:05,100
>> next is jing shi.

1710
05:06:05,100 --> 05:06:07,100
>> if I may take a moment, I want to

1711
05:06:07,100 --> 05:06:11,100
read to those in person, if I may,

1712
05:06:11,100 --> 05:06:12,100
president martinez, in person requests

1713
05:06:12,100 --> 05:06:14,100
for public comment on this item here,

1714
05:06:14,100 --> 05:06:17,100
please submit a written request to

1715
05:06:17,100 --> 05:06:19,100
address the board using the form

1716
05:06:19,100 --> 05:06:22,100
supplied by the board liaison, if you

1717
05:06:22,100 --> 05:06:25,601
would like to make public comment.

1718
05:06:34,100 --> 05:06:36,100
>> who is the next person.

1719
05:06:36,100 --> 05:06:38,401
>> next is emily farson.

1720
05:06:46,100 --> 05:06:48,100
>> who's next after that?

1721
05:06:48,100 --> 05:06:50,401
>> next is charlie kooey.

1722
05:06:54,100 --> 05:06:56,401
next is brianna smith.

1723
05:07:00,100 --> 05:07:02,100
>> thank you so much.

1724
05:07:02,100 --> 05:07:04,100
my name is brianna smith, I am the

1725
05:07:04,100 --> 05:07:06,100
current president of the black student

1726
05:07:06,100 --> 05:07:09,100
union here at ccsf I'm also a student

1727
05:07:09,100 --> 05:07:11,100
worker with project survive.

1728
05:07:11,100 --> 05:07:14,100
I'm also a student worker at the

1729
05:07:14,100 --> 05:07:16,100
african american resource center, I'm

1730
05:07:16,100 --> 05:07:18,100
a student leader here on campus, I'm

1731
05:07:18,100 --> 05:07:20,100
here the request that the african

1732
05:07:20,100 --> 05:07:22,100
american resource center still be put

1733
05:07:22,100 --> 05:07:25,100
in the student success center as was

1734
05:07:25,100 --> 05:07:27,100
promised and agreed to by the board

1735
05:07:27,100 --> 05:07:28,100
back in 2020.

1736
05:07:28,100 --> 05:07:31,100
I think it's important as though this

1737
05:07:31,100 --> 05:07:34,100
idea of putting all of the things that

1738
05:07:34,100 --> 05:07:36,100
are black things in one space is

1739
05:07:36,100 --> 05:07:39,100
problematic because she should be

1740
05:07:39,100 --> 05:07:41,100
expanding student faces especially

1741
05:07:41,100 --> 05:07:42,100
from marginalized students.

1742
05:07:42,100 --> 05:07:43,100
the board did also make a commitment

1743
05:07:43,100 --> 05:07:46,100
back in the february to support

1744
05:07:46,100 --> 05:07:47,100
marginalized students against the

1745
05:07:47,100 --> 05:07:50,100
attacks that were coming in from the

1746
05:07:50,100 --> 05:07:51,100
administration, the trump

1747
05:07:51,100 --> 05:07:52,100
administration, I think this is

1748
05:07:52,100 --> 05:07:55,100
inclusive of that support that was

1749
05:07:55,100 --> 05:07:56,100
promised.

1750
05:07:56,100 --> 05:07:57,100
and when we take away resources and

1751
05:07:57,100 --> 05:08:00,100
spaces, we're not supporting students,

1752
05:08:00,100 --> 05:08:03,100
so, as a black student, as a black

1753
05:08:03,100 --> 05:08:05,100
leader here on campus, as a student

1754
05:08:05,100 --> 05:08:07,100
parent, I think it's important we have

1755
05:08:07,100 --> 05:08:10,100
more spaces spread out throughout

1756
05:08:10,100 --> 05:08:12,100
campus, autonomy spaces that are

1757
05:08:12,100 --> 05:08:14,100
student led that help promote student

1758
05:08:14,100 --> 05:08:15,100
leadership.

1759
05:08:15,100 --> 05:08:17,100
if you think about the history of

1760
05:08:17,100 --> 05:08:20,100
ccsf, our student leaders come from

1761
05:08:20,100 --> 05:08:22,100
the resource centers, these are people

1762
05:08:22,100 --> 05:08:23,100
who come and become student trustees,

1763
05:08:23,100 --> 05:08:25,100
these are people who come and be on

1764
05:08:25,100 --> 05:08:26,100
the board, these are people who come

1765
05:08:26,100 --> 05:08:28,100
back and teach at the college.

1766
05:08:28,100 --> 05:08:30,100
and as we're talking about

1767
05:08:30,100 --> 05:08:32,100
enrollment and we need to make our

1768
05:08:32,100 --> 05:08:34,100
school look attractive to those who

1769
05:08:34,100 --> 05:08:36,100
already feel like they are ousted from

1770
05:08:36,100 --> 05:08:37,100
the city of san francisco.

1771
05:08:37,100 --> 05:08:40,100
those are our black students, those

1772
05:08:40,100 --> 05:08:42,100
are our marginalized students to

1773
05:08:42,100 --> 05:08:45,100
putting us in spaces where we are in

1774
05:08:45,100 --> 05:08:47,100
one would've is similar to the model

1775
05:08:47,100 --> 05:08:48,100
happening in the city for us rather

1776
05:08:48,100 --> 05:08:51,100
than a new model we're supposed to

1777
05:08:51,100 --> 05:08:54,100
stand as an innovative college,

1778
05:08:54,100 --> 05:08:56,100
promoting global leaders and citizens

1779
05:08:56,100 --> 05:08:58,100
and having the next generation of

1780
05:08:58,100 --> 05:08:59,100
board members that may be here.

1781
05:08:59,100 --> 05:09:02,100
as we talk about that, I think it's

1782
05:09:02,100 --> 05:09:04,100
important as we talk about expansion,

1783
05:09:04,100 --> 05:09:07,100
it means spreading our wings, having

1784
05:09:07,100 --> 05:09:09,100
voices in the student success center

1785
05:09:09,100 --> 05:09:11,100
representing all of the diverse

1786
05:09:11,100 --> 05:09:12,100
students on campus.

1787
05:09:12,100 --> 05:09:13,100
thank you very much.

1788
05:09:13,100 --> 05:09:15,401
>> next is abigail bornstein.

1789
05:09:20,100 --> 05:09:24,100
>> so, I wanted to talk about opeb.

1790
05:09:24,100 --> 05:09:28,100
this is a follow-up from a discussion

1791
05:09:28,100 --> 05:09:31,601
back in september 12, so, in the

1792
05:09:36,100 --> 05:09:40,100
budget, there was a request made on

1793
05:09:40,100 --> 05:09:42,100
september 12th and there just hasn't

1794
05:09:42,100 --> 05:09:45,601
been the follow-up which was basically

1795
05:09:46,100 --> 05:09:50,201
that on page 18 of the budget after

1796
05:09:51,100 --> 05:09:54,100
the 1% payroll notation of 2020, an

1797
05:09:55,100 --> 05:09:57,401
additional sentence stating "in

1798
05:09:58,100 --> 05:10:00,100
october 2023, the board of trustees

1799
05:10:00,100 --> 05:10:02,100
were presented four scenarios and

1800
05:10:02,100 --> 05:10:05,100
voted to pay the service cost from

1801
05:10:05,100 --> 05:10:07,100
this point forward".

1802
05:10:07,100 --> 05:10:10,100
so, that was requested in september, I

1803
05:10:10,100 --> 05:10:13,100
believe trustee chisti asked about

1804
05:10:13,100 --> 05:10:15,100
that as well because all we had was

1805
05:10:15,100 --> 05:10:17,100
what happened in 2020 but the board

1806
05:10:17,100 --> 05:10:21,100
had taken a different vote in 2023 and

1807
05:10:21,100 --> 05:10:25,801
so that should be noted on page 18 and

1808
05:10:26,100 --> 05:10:28,100
especially since we keep having

1809
05:10:28,100 --> 05:10:29,100
different administrators come in and

1810
05:10:29,100 --> 05:10:32,100
out, I think it's really important

1811
05:10:32,100 --> 05:10:35,100
that we include that in the actual

1812
05:10:35,100 --> 05:10:37,100
wording and it was supposed to come

1813
05:10:37,100 --> 05:10:40,100
back in january and it just -- it

1814
05:10:40,100 --> 05:10:44,100
didn't come back, that's what we were

1815
05:10:44,100 --> 05:10:46,100
told, it's okay, we're bringing this

1816
05:10:46,100 --> 05:10:49,100
back in january and it didn't come

1817
05:10:49,100 --> 05:10:50,100
back.

1818
05:10:50,100 --> 05:10:52,100
I'm reminding that language needs to

1819
05:10:52,100 --> 05:10:54,100
go back in if we're going to talk

1820
05:10:54,100 --> 05:10:55,100
about that.

1821
05:10:55,100 --> 05:10:56,100
thank you.

1822
05:10:56,100 --> 05:10:58,401
>> next is harry bernstein.

1823
05:11:08,100 --> 05:11:10,100
>> good evening.

1824
05:11:12,100 --> 05:11:14,100
I'm just reminding you that last year,

1825
05:11:14,100 --> 05:11:17,100
I think it was I'm pretty sure

1826
05:11:17,100 --> 05:11:19,401
it was april of 2024.

1827
05:11:21,100 --> 05:11:24,601
you had an interesting presentation, I

1828
05:11:25,100 --> 05:11:27,401
believe then vice-president martinez

1829
05:11:28,100 --> 05:11:31,601
had asked for information to be

1830
05:11:32,100 --> 05:11:34,100
parented about the older adults

1831
05:11:34,100 --> 05:11:35,100
department.

1832
05:11:35,100 --> 05:11:39,201
so, you had dean kedae, the department

1833
05:11:40,100 --> 05:11:43,100
chair, calvin young and faculty member

1834
05:11:43,100 --> 05:11:45,100
judy hubble were here and they made

1835
05:11:45,100 --> 05:11:48,100
their presentation for 30-40 minutes

1836
05:11:48,100 --> 05:11:51,100
and it went on for another 20 minutes

1837
05:11:51,100 --> 05:11:54,100
of your questions and the public

1838
05:11:54,100 --> 05:11:55,100
comments.

1839
05:11:55,100 --> 05:11:58,100
the one thing that they made very

1840
05:11:58,100 --> 05:12:01,601
clear was the program had been

1841
05:12:03,100 --> 05:12:06,100
literally decimated losing 90% of its

1842
05:12:07,100 --> 05:12:10,100
programs and faculty, which way

1843
05:12:11,100 --> 05:12:12,100
forward.

1844
05:12:12,100 --> 05:12:13,100
they needed a needs assessment to find

1845
05:12:13,100 --> 05:12:15,100
out how many people in the general

1846
05:12:15,100 --> 05:12:18,601
public do they serve, city college

1847
05:12:20,100 --> 05:12:22,100
serves the entire adult population of

1848
05:12:22,100 --> 05:12:23,100
san francisco.

1849
05:12:23,100 --> 05:12:25,401
what do they need?

1850
05:12:26,100 --> 05:12:28,100
so, in fact, there was even a

1851
05:12:28,100 --> 05:12:31,100
follow-up question from a member of

1852
05:12:31,100 --> 05:12:34,100
the board to see that that happened.

1853
05:12:34,100 --> 05:12:37,100
now, I can't be here for that but

1854
05:12:37,100 --> 05:12:41,801
later in program, 14c I think is --

1855
05:12:42,100 --> 05:12:45,100
there's a needs assessment, a contract

1856
05:12:45,100 --> 05:12:47,100
that was for almost 100 thousand

1857
05:12:47,100 --> 05:12:49,100
dollars from west ed consulting

1858
05:12:49,100 --> 05:12:51,100
research services for the adult

1859
05:12:51,100 --> 05:12:52,100
education program needs assessment.

1860
05:12:52,100 --> 05:12:56,201
I am just encouraging, I know that

1861
05:12:58,100 --> 05:13:00,100
david yee is interested in something

1862
05:13:00,100 --> 05:13:03,100
like this but it seems that there

1863
05:13:03,100 --> 05:13:05,100
should be a possibility of doing a

1864
05:13:05,100 --> 05:13:08,100
needs assessment for this tiny

1865
05:13:09,100 --> 05:13:12,601
fraction of the programs that serve

1866
05:13:13,100 --> 05:13:17,100
the older adult program and not just

1867
05:13:17,100 --> 05:13:20,601
what survives for sacramento as adult

1868
05:13:21,100 --> 05:13:22,100
education.

1869
05:13:22,100 --> 05:13:23,100
thank you.

1870
05:13:23,100 --> 05:13:25,401
>> next is mary bravewoman.

1871
05:13:31,100 --> 05:13:33,100
>> thank you, trustee chung, for

1872
05:13:33,100 --> 05:13:35,100
reminding us to put in our comment

1873
05:13:35,100 --> 05:13:36,100
cards when you have already heard

1874
05:13:36,100 --> 05:13:38,100
from us.

1875
05:13:38,100 --> 05:13:39,100
this college community and the number

1876
05:13:39,100 --> 05:13:42,601
of people that are standing back

1877
05:13:43,100 --> 05:13:46,100
there, multiply them by tens, they

1878
05:13:46,100 --> 05:13:48,100
represent the entire college community

1879
05:13:48,100 --> 05:13:51,100
and we waiting for months, this is an

1880
05:13:51,100 --> 05:13:52,100
embarrassment.

1881
05:13:52,100 --> 05:13:55,100
I don't understand what the hold-up is.

1882
05:13:55,100 --> 05:13:58,100
I know you're going to tell us you

1883
05:13:58,100 --> 05:14:00,100
can't tell us anything and I'm not

1884
05:14:00,100 --> 05:14:02,100
directing this at all of you, that

1885
05:14:02,100 --> 05:14:03,100
you're not going to tell us anything

1886
05:14:03,100 --> 05:14:06,100
that came out of closed session but

1887
05:14:06,100 --> 05:14:09,100
this is a travesty and I don't

1888
05:14:09,100 --> 05:14:13,201
understand why there is a lack of

1889
05:14:15,100 --> 05:14:16,100
leadership and direction.

1890
05:14:16,100 --> 05:14:21,401
we have a clear choice in front of us.

1891
05:14:22,100 --> 05:14:25,100
I'm going to refrain from swearing

1892
05:14:25,100 --> 05:14:26,100
right now, everybody right here, each

1893
05:14:26,100 --> 05:14:28,100
one of those people back there

1894
05:14:28,100 --> 05:14:30,100
represent the voters of the city.

1895
05:14:30,100 --> 05:14:33,100
we voted to put you in this seat to

1896
05:14:33,100 --> 05:14:36,100
help lead your college in a good

1897
05:14:36,100 --> 05:14:37,100
direction.

1898
05:14:37,100 --> 05:14:38,100
you heard from the community.

1899
05:14:38,100 --> 05:14:40,100
you heard from students, you heard

1900
05:14:40,100 --> 05:14:44,100
from faculty, what the actual fuck is

1901
05:14:44,100 --> 05:14:45,100
the hold-up?

1902
05:14:45,100 --> 05:14:49,100
this is an embarrassment, you guys can

1903
05:14:49,100 --> 05:14:53,100
have the rest of your meeting, we're

1904
05:14:53,100 --> 05:14:54,100
done.

1905
05:14:54,100 --> 05:14:56,100
>> that concludes public comments.

1906
05:14:56,100 --> 05:14:58,100
>> thank you.

1907
05:15:04,100 --> 05:15:06,100
we now return to the regular order of

1908
05:15:06,100 --> 05:15:08,100
the agenda.

1909
05:15:11,100 --> 05:15:14,100
action items 6a, adoption of

1910
05:15:15,100 --> 05:15:16,100
resolution number 2025-08 in

1911
05:15:16,100 --> 05:15:19,100
recognition of asian american pacific

1912
05:15:19,100 --> 05:15:20,100
islander month.

1913
05:15:20,100 --> 05:15:23,100
who will move the resolution?

1914
05:15:23,100 --> 05:15:24,100
>> I will move 6c.

1915
05:15:24,100 --> 05:15:26,100
>> second.

1916
05:15:27,100 --> 05:15:29,401
>> moved by vice-president zamora,

1917
05:15:30,100 --> 05:15:32,401
seconded by trustee chung.

1918
05:15:33,100 --> 05:15:35,100
acting chancellor, is there any

1919
05:15:35,100 --> 05:15:36,100
comment from the chancellor's office

1920
05:15:36,100 --> 05:15:38,100
on this one?

1921
05:15:43,100 --> 05:15:46,601
>> I think just the importance of

1922
05:15:47,100 --> 05:15:49,100
recognizing, you know, important

1923
05:15:49,100 --> 05:15:51,100
members of our college community and

1924
05:15:51,100 --> 05:15:55,100
this opportunity that we have to offer

1925
05:15:55,100 --> 05:15:56,100
this celebration and support.

1926
05:15:56,100 --> 05:15:57,100
>> thank you.

1927
05:15:57,100 --> 05:16:00,100
are there any trustee questions or

1928
05:16:00,100 --> 05:16:01,100
comments?

1929
05:16:01,100 --> 05:16:02,100
trustee chung?

1930
05:16:02,100 --> 05:16:04,100
>> I think I've mentioned this in

1931
05:16:04,100 --> 05:16:07,100
previous resolutions and I appreciate

1932
05:16:07,100 --> 05:16:10,100
that the same way that we make land

1933
05:16:10,100 --> 05:16:11,100
acknowledgment statements every

1934
05:16:11,100 --> 05:16:13,100
meeting, the same way that we take the

1935
05:16:13,100 --> 05:16:16,100
time to pass a resolution during that

1936
05:16:16,100 --> 05:16:20,100
time of month to celebrate, to be

1937
05:16:20,100 --> 05:16:23,601
present, to remember the struggles of

1938
05:16:24,100 --> 05:16:26,100
marginalized communities in the past,

1939
05:16:26,100 --> 05:16:31,100
I think what I hope for is -- and we

1940
05:16:31,100 --> 05:16:34,100
will see this in later resolutions

1941
05:16:34,100 --> 05:16:38,201
where we improved on it, added more

1942
05:16:39,100 --> 05:16:40,100
substantial information especially

1943
05:16:40,100 --> 05:16:43,601
information that is local to our

1944
05:16:44,100 --> 05:16:47,100
college, to our city as well as things

1945
05:16:47,100 --> 05:16:50,601
that are substantive of the time.

1946
05:16:51,100 --> 05:16:53,100
I know I didn't have a ton of capacity

1947
05:16:53,100 --> 05:16:55,100
-- I know we talk about this concept

1948
05:16:55,100 --> 05:16:57,100
about just because you're a member of

1949
05:16:57,100 --> 05:16:58,100
the community doesn't mean the

1950
05:16:58,100 --> 05:17:01,100
burden's on you to do the work.

1951
05:17:01,100 --> 05:17:04,100
I hope there's allies, but I

1952
05:17:04,100 --> 05:17:06,100
understand when allies feel the need

1953
05:17:06,100 --> 05:17:08,100
that they're like, I can't -- I need

1954
05:17:08,100 --> 05:17:12,801
to make space for the person in that

1955
05:17:13,100 --> 05:17:16,100
community to speak but I'm hoping

1956
05:17:16,100 --> 05:17:18,100
because we're going to have a whole

1957
05:17:18,100 --> 05:17:22,801
year between now and the next time we

1958
05:17:25,100 --> 05:17:26,100
pass this resolution if we can give

1959
05:17:26,100 --> 05:17:27,100
ample time to our asian american

1960
05:17:27,100 --> 05:17:28,100
studies faculty who are experts in

1961
05:17:28,100 --> 05:17:31,100
this topic and the history especially

1962
05:17:31,100 --> 05:17:34,100
local to city college to write a

1963
05:17:34,100 --> 05:17:36,100
resolution that is even more

1964
05:17:36,100 --> 05:17:37,100
meaningful.

1965
05:17:37,100 --> 05:17:39,100
thank you.

1966
05:17:41,100 --> 05:17:44,100
>> are there any other trustee

1967
05:17:45,100 --> 05:17:46,100
comments?

1968
05:17:46,100 --> 05:17:48,100
student trustee brandt?

1969
05:17:48,100 --> 05:17:50,100
>> thank you so much.

1970
05:17:50,100 --> 05:17:53,100
as is often the case when resolutions

1971
05:17:53,100 --> 05:17:56,100
are drafted, I was just curious

1972
05:17:56,100 --> 05:18:00,201
who was spoken with or how this

1973
05:18:01,100 --> 05:18:02,100
resolution was drafted.

1974
05:18:02,100 --> 05:18:04,100
there's particular individuals that

1975
05:18:04,100 --> 05:18:06,100
come to mind for me when I think about

1976
05:18:06,100 --> 05:18:09,100
the asian american pacific islander

1977
05:18:10,100 --> 05:18:12,100
community, particularly dr. Palita,

1978
05:18:12,100 --> 05:18:16,201
and I know the college has previously

1979
05:18:18,100 --> 05:18:21,100
had vasa conferences which did not

1980
05:18:21,100 --> 05:18:25,100
take place for the first time this

1981
05:18:25,100 --> 05:18:26,100
year in I don't know how long.

1982
05:18:26,100 --> 05:18:29,100
I hope the resolved would include

1983
05:18:29,100 --> 05:18:32,601
while we're recognizing our asian and

1984
05:18:35,100 --> 05:18:36,100
pacific islander students and

1985
05:18:36,100 --> 05:18:38,100
community intentionality about putting

1986
05:18:38,100 --> 05:18:41,100
funds towards supporting a vasa

1987
05:18:41,100 --> 05:18:42,100
conference.

1988
05:18:42,100 --> 05:18:43,100
>> thank you the.

1989
05:18:43,100 --> 05:18:45,401
any other trustee comments?

1990
05:18:48,100 --> 05:18:49,100
is there any public comment?

1991
05:18:49,100 --> 05:18:51,100
>> we don't have.

1992
05:18:52,100 --> 05:18:54,100
>> vice-president zamora?

1993
05:18:58,100 --> 05:19:00,100
>> yeah, just, I think this has been

1994
05:19:00,100 --> 05:19:01,100
mentioned before in prior meetings,

1995
05:19:01,100 --> 05:19:05,801
but -- and I know it's difficult with

1996
05:19:06,100 --> 05:19:08,100
the administration's bandwidth but

1997
05:19:08,100 --> 05:19:11,100
having these types of resolutions at

1998
05:19:11,100 --> 05:19:13,100
the beginning of the actual month as

1999
05:19:13,100 --> 05:19:16,100
opposed to the end of the month would

2000
05:19:16,100 --> 05:19:20,100
be helpful and frankly would allow us

2001
05:19:20,100 --> 05:19:22,100
to celebrate it much earlier and be

2002
05:19:22,100 --> 05:19:24,100
intentional around that.

2003
05:19:24,100 --> 05:19:25,100
>> thank you.

2004
05:19:25,100 --> 05:19:28,601
I've made this request before that

2005
05:19:29,100 --> 05:19:30,100
they not come at the end of the month

2006
05:19:30,100 --> 05:19:32,100
which means they have to come at the

2007
05:19:32,100 --> 05:19:35,100
end of the prior month in order for us

2008
05:19:35,100 --> 05:19:36,100
to celebrate them.

2009
05:19:36,100 --> 05:19:38,100
trustee solomon?

2010
05:19:40,100 --> 05:19:42,100
>> right, and as trustees, we can

2011
05:19:42,100 --> 05:19:43,100
request that, it's also our

2012
05:19:43,100 --> 05:19:44,100
responsible to do it, it's really not

2013
05:19:44,100 --> 05:19:46,100
the administrator's responsibility

2014
05:19:54,100 --> 05:19:56,100
only, they are a month ahead.

2015
05:19:56,100 --> 05:19:59,100
>> are there any public comments on

2016
05:19:59,100 --> 05:20:00,100
this?

2017
05:20:00,100 --> 05:20:02,100
okay, ms. Esteban, roll call vote,

2018
05:20:02,100 --> 05:20:03,100
please.

2019
05:20:03,100 --> 05:20:05,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

2020
05:20:05,100 --> 05:20:06,100
advisory vote?

2021
05:20:06,100 --> 05:20:07,100
>> aye.

2022
05:20:07,100 --> 05:20:08,100
>> president martinez?

2023
05:20:08,100 --> 05:20:09,100
>> yes.

2024
05:20:09,100 --> 05:20:10,100
>> vice-president zamora?

2025
05:20:10,100 --> 05:20:11,100
>> aye.

2026
05:20:11,100 --> 05:20:12,100
>> trustee chisti?

2027
05:20:12,100 --> 05:20:13,100
>> aye.

2028
05:20:13,100 --> 05:20:14,100
>> trustee wong?

2029
05:20:14,100 --> 05:20:15,100
>> yes.

2030
05:20:15,100 --> 05:20:16,100
>> trustee solomon?

2031
05:20:16,100 --> 05:20:17,100
>> aye.

2032
05:20:17,100 --> 05:20:18,100
>> trustee chung?

2033
05:20:18,100 --> 05:20:19,100
>> aye.

2034
05:20:19,100 --> 05:20:20,100
>> trustee mccarty?

2035
05:20:20,100 --> 05:20:21,100
>> aye.

2036
05:20:21,100 --> 05:20:22,100
>> the motion passes.

2037
05:20:22,100 --> 05:20:24,100
>> thank you, we move to action item

2038
05:20:24,100 --> 05:20:27,100
6d, adoption of resolution 2025-09,

2039
05:20:31,100 --> 05:20:33,100
supporting the recommendations of the

2040
05:20:33,100 --> 05:20:36,100
free city college oversight committee.

2041
05:20:36,100 --> 05:20:39,100
who will move the resolution?

2042
05:20:39,100 --> 05:20:41,100
moved by trustee wong, seconded by

2043
05:20:41,100 --> 05:20:42,100
trustee solomon, any trustee comments

2044
05:20:42,100 --> 05:20:44,100
or questions?

2045
05:20:45,100 --> 05:20:47,100
>> trustee chung?

2046
05:20:49,100 --> 05:20:51,100
>> sure, I'll present, so student

2047
05:20:51,100 --> 05:20:55,801
trustee brandt and I are on the free

2048
05:20:56,100 --> 05:20:59,601
city college overside committee and so

2049
05:21:01,100 --> 05:21:04,100
I think folks know about my history of

2050
05:21:04,100 --> 05:21:06,100
working on the legislation in 2019 at

2051
05:21:06,100 --> 05:21:09,100
city hall for free city, so last year,

2052
05:21:09,100 --> 05:21:13,100
there was the change in the city

2053
05:21:13,100 --> 05:21:16,100
budget that reduced funding for free

2054
05:21:16,100 --> 05:21:18,100
city college from I think it was about

2055
05:21:18,100 --> 05:21:21,100
16.9 million dollars to 9.3 and then

2056
05:21:21,100 --> 05:21:24,601
this coming fiscal year as was

2057
05:21:26,100 --> 05:21:29,100
budgeted in the previous budget, 7.2

2058
05:21:29,100 --> 05:21:30,100
million dollars.

2059
05:21:30,100 --> 05:21:33,601
and that proposal would undermine the

2060
05:21:34,100 --> 05:21:36,100
principal of free city college in

2061
05:21:36,100 --> 05:21:38,401
providing tuition, free enrollment

2062
05:21:39,100 --> 05:21:42,100
regardless of their background, income

2063
05:21:43,100 --> 05:21:45,100
or basically having education as a

2064
05:21:45,100 --> 05:21:47,100
fundamental right.

2065
05:21:48,100 --> 05:21:51,100
and during that time when we had a

2066
05:21:51,100 --> 05:21:54,100
meeting with then mayor's office, we

2067
05:21:54,100 --> 05:21:57,100
were informed that their intent was to

2068
05:21:57,100 --> 05:22:00,100
take any surplus money that we had and

2069
05:22:00,100 --> 05:22:03,100
also further reduce the program in

2070
05:22:03,100 --> 05:22:05,100
future years, so that only some

2071
05:22:05,100 --> 05:22:08,601
classes would be covered by tuition

2072
05:22:09,100 --> 05:22:11,100
free enrollment, so this is a meeting

2073
05:22:11,100 --> 05:22:12,100
between interim chancellor bailey and

2074
05:22:12,100 --> 05:22:15,100
I and the chief of staff for the

2075
05:22:15,100 --> 05:22:17,100
mayor's office.

2076
05:22:17,100 --> 05:22:20,100
so, since then, the budget cuts kind

2077
05:22:20,100 --> 05:22:23,100
of caught us off guard and we weren't

2078
05:22:23,100 --> 05:22:27,100
able to advocate on that this coming

2079
05:22:27,100 --> 05:22:29,100
year, the budget for the mayor's

2080
05:22:29,100 --> 05:22:32,601
office is combining out either friday

2081
05:22:34,100 --> 05:22:39,401
or monday and we want to see a budget

2082
05:22:40,100 --> 05:22:43,100
that restores the free city college

2083
05:22:43,100 --> 05:22:44,100
program.

2084
05:22:44,100 --> 05:22:46,100
and so our oversight committee, this

2085
05:22:46,100 --> 05:22:48,100
is a little bit behind, I wish we got

2086
05:22:48,100 --> 05:22:50,100
this earlier and we're working to

2087
05:22:50,100 --> 05:22:53,100
establish processes where we're on a

2088
05:22:53,100 --> 05:22:54,100
regular basis providing

2089
05:22:54,100 --> 05:22:56,401
recommendations and reviewing what's

2090
05:22:57,100 --> 05:23:00,100
-- yeah, reviewing and providing

2091
05:23:00,100 --> 05:23:03,100
recommendations sooner, so this was a

2092
05:23:03,100 --> 05:23:06,100
proposal offered by supervisor chan

2093
05:23:06,100 --> 05:23:09,100
who's also the budget committee at the

2094
05:23:09,100 --> 05:23:10,100
board of supervisors, so she offered

2095
05:23:10,100 --> 05:23:14,100
most of the language from this motion

2096
05:23:14,100 --> 05:23:17,100
that was adopted by our free city

2097
05:23:17,100 --> 05:23:19,100
college oversight committee.

2098
05:23:19,100 --> 05:23:23,801
and so she mentioned that we needed to

2099
05:23:25,100 --> 05:23:28,601
consider after the audits for previous

2100
05:23:30,100 --> 05:23:31,100
fiscal years, then they would be

2101
05:23:31,100 --> 05:23:34,601
willing to consider the addition of

2102
05:23:38,100 --> 05:23:40,100
indirect expenses from prior 2025-2026

2103
05:23:40,100 --> 05:23:44,100
fiscal year and then one of the most

2104
05:23:44,100 --> 05:23:47,100
important ones for me, number 2, was

2105
05:23:47,100 --> 05:23:50,100
bringing back our funding to

2106
05:23:51,100 --> 05:23:53,100
approximately 16 million dollars and

2107
05:23:53,100 --> 05:23:56,100
then compounded by cpi and future

2108
05:23:56,100 --> 05:24:00,100
years as opposed to 9.3 this year and

2109
05:24:00,100 --> 05:24:03,601
7.2 as originally budgeted and then to

2110
05:24:05,100 --> 05:24:08,100
consider students also made a

2111
05:24:09,100 --> 05:24:12,601
proposal, there were folks from smack

2112
05:24:15,100 --> 05:24:17,100
and other groups that came and

2113
05:24:17,100 --> 05:24:20,100
presented us a proposal on how to

2114
05:24:20,100 --> 05:24:22,100
potentially spend some of the surplus

2115
05:24:22,100 --> 05:24:25,100
dollars that had been provided by --

2116
05:24:25,100 --> 05:24:28,100
that had been there until it was taken

2117
05:24:28,100 --> 05:24:31,100
out from the free city college program.

2118
05:24:31,100 --> 05:24:33,100
so, we support that in years where the

2119
05:24:33,100 --> 05:24:36,601
city doesn't have budget deficit and

2120
05:24:38,100 --> 05:24:41,100
also to -- for point number 4, a

2121
05:24:41,100 --> 05:24:43,100
desire to change the language so that

2122
05:24:43,100 --> 05:24:46,100
there's a deficit trigger, so right

2123
05:24:46,100 --> 05:24:49,100
now there's flexibility for the city

2124
05:24:49,100 --> 05:24:51,100
when they want to reduce funding for

2125
05:24:51,100 --> 05:24:55,100
the free city college program, kind of

2126
05:24:55,100 --> 05:24:56,100
at their whim.

2127
05:24:56,100 --> 05:24:59,100
in a lot of the set asides we have at

2128
05:24:59,100 --> 05:25:01,100
the city level, there's a deficit

2129
05:25:01,100 --> 05:25:04,100
trigger where if the city's budget

2130
05:25:04,100 --> 05:25:08,100
goes below a certain amount, then that

2131
05:25:08,100 --> 05:25:12,201
the's when they may pause increases or

2132
05:25:13,100 --> 05:25:16,100
something to that effect and so

2133
05:25:16,100 --> 05:25:17,100
supervisor chan mentioned including

2134
05:25:17,100 --> 05:25:20,100
something like that instead of giving

2135
05:25:20,100 --> 05:25:22,100
more discretion to the city to have

2136
05:25:22,100 --> 05:25:24,100
that in there, and then for the city

2137
05:25:24,100 --> 05:25:27,100
to consider to reimburse student fees

2138
05:25:27,100 --> 05:25:30,100
and tuition both retroactively and

2139
05:25:30,100 --> 05:25:32,100
moving forward but not limited to

2140
05:25:32,100 --> 05:25:35,100
ongoing student debt fee, covering

2141
05:25:37,100 --> 05:25:40,100
health care, existing session in mou

2142
05:25:40,100 --> 05:25:42,100
appendix a, students who withdraw from

2143
05:25:42,100 --> 05:25:44,100
courses because students that have

2144
05:25:44,100 --> 05:25:46,100
withdrawn in past, they've ended up

2145
05:25:46,100 --> 05:25:49,100
having money that they owe to the

2146
05:25:49,100 --> 05:25:50,100
college.

2147
05:25:50,100 --> 05:25:51,100
so, if we get rid of that, we don't

2148
05:25:51,100 --> 05:25:54,100
have to do this retroactive

2149
05:25:54,100 --> 05:25:57,100
reimbursement of I guess unpaid fees

2150
05:25:57,100 --> 05:26:00,100
if they withdraw from their classes

2151
05:26:00,100 --> 05:26:03,100
and for number 6, for the city and all

2152
05:26:03,100 --> 05:26:05,100
entities involved in the

2153
05:26:05,100 --> 05:26:08,100
implementation for mou evaluation and

2154
05:26:08,100 --> 05:26:10,100
amend the language of use of punds and

2155
05:26:10,100 --> 05:26:12,100
adjustments in mou's, so going

2156
05:26:12,100 --> 05:26:13,100
forward, having an open conversation

2157
05:26:13,100 --> 05:26:17,100
how we want to do this, and I just

2158
05:26:17,100 --> 05:26:21,801
want to note, kind of throw the ball

2159
05:26:22,100 --> 05:26:26,100
at our -- dr. Lisa cooper wilkins was

2160
05:26:26,100 --> 05:26:27,100
there along with student trustee

2161
05:26:27,100 --> 05:26:30,100
brandt, so I want to if possible, if

2162
05:26:30,100 --> 05:26:32,100
trustee chung wouldn't mind allowing

2163
05:26:32,100 --> 05:26:34,100
more context to be added in case I

2164
05:26:34,100 --> 05:26:35,100
missed some stuff and I'm sure I did.

2165
05:26:35,100 --> 05:26:37,100
>> okay.

2166
05:26:38,100 --> 05:26:41,100
no, I think you were very thorough.

2167
05:26:41,100 --> 05:26:44,100
there's a smaller group, a subgroup

2168
05:26:44,100 --> 05:26:46,100
from the oversight committee that had

2169
05:26:46,100 --> 05:26:48,100
been meeting as a small equity I guess

2170
05:26:48,100 --> 05:26:52,201
group to look at equity -- potential

2171
05:26:53,100 --> 05:26:57,100
equity goals for the program to expand

2172
05:26:57,100 --> 05:27:01,100
its impact for other citizens in the

2173
05:27:01,100 --> 05:27:03,100
city and so there were also

2174
05:27:03,100 --> 05:27:05,100
recommendations that sort of aligned

2175
05:27:05,100 --> 05:27:08,601
with item 5 around other ways that

2176
05:27:09,100 --> 05:27:12,100
student support could be extended

2177
05:27:12,100 --> 05:27:15,100
through basic needs, addressing basic

2178
05:27:15,100 --> 05:27:16,100
needs.

2179
05:27:16,100 --> 05:27:19,601
also thinking about ways to offer

2180
05:27:20,100 --> 05:27:23,100
maybe more structures that with

2181
05:27:23,100 --> 05:27:25,100
programmatic elements to free city

2182
05:27:25,100 --> 05:27:27,100
similar to other promise programs at

2183
05:27:27,100 --> 05:27:29,100
other institutions but essentially the

2184
05:27:29,100 --> 05:27:33,100
item said -- trustee wong covered 1-6

2185
05:27:33,100 --> 05:27:35,100
are things that were discussed in

2186
05:27:35,100 --> 05:27:36,100
those subcommittees and brought

2187
05:27:36,100 --> 05:27:38,100
forward and discussed holistically as

2188
05:27:38,100 --> 05:27:40,100
an oversight committee so those are

2189
05:27:40,100 --> 05:27:43,100
the recommendations that are being

2190
05:27:43,100 --> 05:27:44,100
brought forward to this board to

2191
05:27:44,100 --> 05:27:46,100
support as well.

2192
05:27:46,100 --> 05:27:49,100
>> are there any trustee comments or

2193
05:27:49,100 --> 05:27:50,100
questions?

2194
05:27:50,100 --> 05:27:51,100
okay, trustee chung?

2195
05:27:51,100 --> 05:27:52,100
>> yes.

2196
05:27:52,100 --> 05:27:55,000
I wanted to take the time and again

2197
05:27:55,000 --> 05:27:58,100
echo the gratitude -- the underlying

2198
05:27:58,100 --> 05:28:01,100
gratitude to trustees historically and

2199
05:28:01,100 --> 05:28:03,100
as well as administrators working on

2200
05:28:03,100 --> 05:28:06,100
this, I want to thank supervisor chan

2201
05:28:06,100 --> 05:28:08,100
for her leadership in this.

2202
05:28:08,100 --> 05:28:11,100
I mean, as far as allies who

2203
05:28:11,100 --> 05:28:12,100
understand the importance of city

2204
05:28:12,100 --> 05:28:15,601
college, thank you so much, supervisor

2205
05:28:16,100 --> 05:28:17,100
chan.

2206
05:28:17,100 --> 05:28:21,801
I also want to thank the grass root

2207
05:28:22,100 --> 05:28:24,100
non-profit coalition that has also

2208
05:28:24,100 --> 05:28:26,100
advocated for this, particularly the

2209
05:28:26,100 --> 05:28:27,100
students.

2210
05:28:27,100 --> 05:28:29,100
I think trustee wong had touched on

2211
05:28:29,100 --> 05:28:32,601
this but the students, the historical

2212
05:28:34,100 --> 05:28:35,100
courage of coleman advocates and

2213
05:28:35,100 --> 05:28:39,201
the fellows that they recently brought on.

2214
05:28:40,100 --> 05:28:44,801
I mean, I only heard second hand how

2215
05:28:45,100 --> 05:28:47,100
incredible and how moving they were

2216
05:28:47,100 --> 05:28:49,100
and how effective they were, so thank

2217
05:28:49,100 --> 05:28:51,100
you so much, please, if there's anyone

2218
05:28:51,100 --> 05:28:55,201
else to also relay that to them.

2219
05:28:56,100 --> 05:29:00,801
and I want to take the time to

2220
05:29:01,100 --> 05:29:04,100
thank vito mendes who was the mentor

2221
05:29:04,100 --> 05:29:05,100
for those students and supported

2222
05:29:05,100 --> 05:29:08,601
them and the overarching idea of

2223
05:29:09,100 --> 05:29:12,100
empowering but holistically caring for

2224
05:29:13,100 --> 05:29:16,100
them and seeing over them, thank you,

2225
05:29:16,100 --> 05:29:17,100
vito, for doing that.

2226
05:29:17,100 --> 05:29:18,100
>> trustee chisti?

2227
05:29:18,100 --> 05:29:20,100
>> I want to echo some of those

2228
05:29:20,100 --> 05:29:23,100
statements, thank you, trustee wong,

2229
05:29:26,100 --> 05:29:29,601
and I'm grateful to supervisor chan

2230
05:29:30,100 --> 05:29:32,100
for bringing us to where we are.

2231
05:29:32,100 --> 05:29:35,100
I am specifically interested in number

2232
05:29:35,100 --> 05:29:37,100
6 and I guess I had a follow-up

2233
05:29:37,100 --> 05:29:40,100
question for the deficit trigger too.

2234
05:29:40,100 --> 05:29:44,201
what is the amount where that trigger

2235
05:29:45,100 --> 05:29:46,100
happens in general?

2236
05:29:46,100 --> 05:29:49,100
because think -- they're projecting

2237
05:29:51,100 --> 05:29:52,100
a deficit right now.

2238
05:29:52,100 --> 05:29:55,100
>> I think the intent was to keep the

2239
05:29:55,100 --> 05:29:57,100
motion broad so that there's space to

2240
05:29:57,100 --> 05:30:00,601
have the conversation between dcyf and

2241
05:30:01,100 --> 05:30:04,100
our administrators so have that

2242
05:30:04,100 --> 05:30:05,100
operational discussion and bring it

2243
05:30:05,100 --> 05:30:08,100
back to the larger bodies for final

2244
05:30:08,100 --> 05:30:11,100
say or recommendation or feedback.

2245
05:30:11,100 --> 05:30:14,100
>> and I think the other thing and you

2246
05:30:14,100 --> 05:30:17,100
started to allude to this, trustee

2247
05:30:17,100 --> 05:30:21,100
wong, is that already plans have been

2248
05:30:21,100 --> 05:30:24,601
made to have meetings align better

2249
05:30:25,100 --> 05:30:28,601
with the city's budget process because

2250
05:30:29,100 --> 05:30:30,100
we're obviously well behind the curve

2251
05:30:30,100 --> 05:30:33,100
this year in making some of these

2252
05:30:33,100 --> 05:30:35,100
recommendations but recognizing that

2253
05:30:35,100 --> 05:30:37,100
they're going to be critical periods

2254
05:30:37,100 --> 05:30:40,100
in the year where they'll have to be

2255
05:30:40,100 --> 05:30:41,100
oversight meetings to, one, monitor

2256
05:30:41,100 --> 05:30:43,100
where the budget is and then to be

2257
05:30:43,100 --> 05:30:46,100
able to make recommendations that will

2258
05:30:46,100 --> 05:30:48,100
have impact before the budget is

2259
05:30:48,100 --> 05:30:49,100
formulated.

2260
05:30:49,100 --> 05:30:53,100
>> and then for number 6, is there a

2261
05:30:53,100 --> 05:30:56,100
timeline that was identified for this?

2262
05:30:56,100 --> 05:30:58,100
because I think it alludes to

2263
05:30:58,100 --> 05:30:59,100
modifications around changes to the

2264
05:30:59,100 --> 05:31:03,100
use of funds, so is that within a

2265
05:31:03,100 --> 05:31:05,100
year, is that -- was there a proposed

2266
05:31:05,100 --> 05:31:06,100
timeline for has?

2267
05:31:06,100 --> 05:31:09,100
>> so, there is a new timeline for

2268
05:31:09,100 --> 05:31:12,601
dates for this upcoming year that

2269
05:31:13,100 --> 05:31:15,100
better align with the budget

2270
05:31:15,100 --> 05:31:16,100
formulation process.

2271
05:31:16,100 --> 05:31:20,201
also there is a set of recommendations

2272
05:31:21,100 --> 05:31:26,100
that are sort of scaled I guess is the

2273
05:31:26,100 --> 05:31:29,100
word I want to use so -- I don't know

2274
05:31:29,100 --> 05:31:31,100
that it matches whatever the city's

2275
05:31:31,100 --> 05:31:35,100
trigger point is but there are sort of

2276
05:31:35,100 --> 05:31:37,100
baseline budgetary needs that have

2277
05:31:37,100 --> 05:31:39,100
been outlined plus some additional

2278
05:31:39,100 --> 05:31:42,601
considerations for some of these other

2279
05:31:43,100 --> 05:31:47,201
recommended uses of the funds that are

2280
05:31:50,100 --> 05:31:52,100
based -- aligned also with our

2281
05:31:52,100 --> 05:31:54,401
enrollment growth projections, both

2282
05:31:55,100 --> 05:31:59,201
our most I guess ambitious growth foes

2283
05:32:00,100 --> 05:32:01,100
versus what we think will be baseline

2284
05:32:01,100 --> 05:32:04,100
that also help to think about how

2285
05:32:04,100 --> 05:32:06,100
funding at various levels could be

2286
05:32:06,100 --> 05:32:07,100
utilized.

2287
05:32:07,100 --> 05:32:11,100
so, I think it is meant to offer some

2288
05:32:11,100 --> 05:32:14,100
flexibility with what the city's

2289
05:32:15,100 --> 05:32:17,100
budgetary challenges are as well, so

2290
05:32:17,100 --> 05:32:20,100
washes we can think about skillfully

2291
05:32:20,100 --> 05:32:22,100
funding our students but also offering

2292
05:32:22,100 --> 05:32:23,100
additional support.

2293
05:32:23,100 --> 05:32:25,100
>> and then what about the money in

2294
05:32:25,100 --> 05:32:28,100
the reserve, was there any discussion

2295
05:32:28,100 --> 05:32:30,100
about that, has that been clawed back?

2296
05:32:30,100 --> 05:32:33,601
>> that is a very still unclear

2297
05:32:35,100 --> 05:32:37,100
discussion until I think the final

2298
05:32:37,100 --> 05:32:39,100
audits are finished.

2299
05:32:39,100 --> 05:32:42,100
there still isn't a lot of clarity yet

2300
05:32:42,100 --> 05:32:45,100
around both unspent funds and what if

2301
05:32:45,100 --> 05:32:47,100
any is left in the reserve.

2302
05:32:47,100 --> 05:32:48,100
>> okay, thank you for that.

2303
05:32:48,100 --> 05:32:52,100
I wanted to again offer the more we

2304
05:32:52,100 --> 05:32:54,100
can be in loop with some of these

2305
05:32:54,100 --> 05:32:56,100
discussions that -- and just from my

2306
05:32:56,100 --> 05:32:59,100
own experience of previously working

2307
05:32:59,100 --> 05:33:01,100
at dcyf and overseeing the free city

2308
05:33:01,100 --> 05:33:03,100
program, if I can help with this

2309
05:33:03,100 --> 05:33:05,100
process in any way, I wanted to

2310
05:33:05,100 --> 05:33:07,100
reiterate that.

2311
05:33:08,100 --> 05:33:11,100
>> any further trustee comments or

2312
05:33:11,100 --> 05:33:12,100
questions?

2313
05:33:12,100 --> 05:33:13,100
any public comments?

2314
05:33:13,100 --> 05:33:14,100
>> yes, we do.

2315
05:33:14,100 --> 05:33:16,401
first is alyssa messier.

2316
05:33:20,100 --> 05:33:23,100
>> next is mary lee hearn.

2317
05:33:30,100 --> 05:33:33,601
>> good evening, earlier today, I was

2318
05:33:35,100 --> 05:33:37,100
with our students, a good number of

2319
05:33:37,100 --> 05:33:41,201
them in front of city hall protesting

2320
05:33:44,100 --> 05:33:47,601
against the fact that this program,

2321
05:33:48,100 --> 05:33:51,100
free city, has not been fully funded.

2322
05:33:51,100 --> 05:33:53,100
the students are very aware and feel

2323
05:33:53,100 --> 05:33:56,100
that they've been ripped off which

2324
05:33:56,100 --> 05:33:59,601
they have been with greater than 50%

2325
05:34:00,100 --> 05:34:03,601
of what had been promised being

2326
05:34:06,100 --> 05:34:07,100
withdrawn.

2327
05:34:07,100 --> 05:34:11,100
now, most of the stories today had to

2328
05:34:11,100 --> 05:34:14,601
do with students coming into an

2329
05:34:15,100 --> 05:34:18,100
academic situation who thought that

2330
05:34:20,100 --> 05:34:23,100
they never would have had that

2331
05:34:23,100 --> 05:34:25,100
experience had it not been for free

2332
05:34:25,100 --> 05:34:26,100
city.

2333
05:34:26,100 --> 05:34:27,100
other students talking about the fact

2334
05:34:27,100 --> 05:34:31,100
that they couldn't afford to take, you

2335
05:34:31,100 --> 05:34:34,100
know, more than x amount of classes

2336
05:34:34,100 --> 05:34:36,100
because of the cost.

2337
05:34:36,100 --> 05:34:39,100
so, I would like to thank all those

2338
05:34:39,100 --> 05:34:41,100
who have been working on this.

2339
05:34:41,100 --> 05:34:42,100
I appreciate that.

2340
05:34:42,100 --> 05:34:46,201
they appreciate it I'm sure, but what

2341
05:34:47,100 --> 05:34:51,100
I would like to see happen is that you

2342
05:34:51,100 --> 05:34:54,601
keep students informed as you go

2343
05:34:55,100 --> 05:34:58,100
along, that what is being done and

2344
05:34:58,100 --> 05:35:01,100
that you are definitely working on it

2345
05:35:01,100 --> 05:35:04,100
because they are very concerned right

2346
05:35:04,100 --> 05:35:07,100
now and we need to shore up our

2347
05:35:07,100 --> 05:35:10,100
students, we need to the say we're

2348
05:35:10,100 --> 05:35:11,100
right there behind you and we're

2349
05:35:11,100 --> 05:35:12,100
trying to get this done, so

2350
05:35:12,100 --> 05:35:15,100
anything that can be done to expedite

2351
05:35:15,100 --> 05:35:19,801
it would I'm sure be very -- students

2352
05:35:20,100 --> 05:35:23,100
would be very grateful, but please be

2353
05:35:23,100 --> 05:35:25,100
aware that there are many students who

2354
05:35:25,100 --> 05:35:26,100
are very concerned right now.

2355
05:35:26,100 --> 05:35:28,100
thank you.

2356
05:35:29,100 --> 05:35:31,401
>> next is michael adams.

2357
05:35:41,100 --> 05:35:42,100
>> hello, everyone, thank you for your

2358
05:35:42,100 --> 05:35:43,100
patience.

2359
05:35:43,100 --> 05:35:46,100
I too was at city hall with students

2360
05:35:46,100 --> 05:35:50,100
and some of you passed through I'm

2361
05:35:50,100 --> 05:35:51,100
sure.

2362
05:35:51,100 --> 05:35:54,100
I won't repeat everything you've heard

2363
05:35:54,100 --> 05:35:57,100
about the anxiety, the uncertainty,

2364
05:36:00,100 --> 05:36:03,100
the questioning projecting the worst

2365
05:36:05,100 --> 05:36:07,100
case scenario so folks are preparing

2366
05:36:07,100 --> 05:36:10,100
themselves for not being able to come

2367
05:36:10,100 --> 05:36:12,100
to school.

2368
05:36:12,100 --> 05:36:15,100
and they're wise enough to anticipate

2369
05:36:15,100 --> 05:36:18,100
potential in the process that it will

2370
05:36:18,100 --> 05:36:19,100
fail.

2371
05:36:19,100 --> 05:36:21,100
we just sat through you all going to a

2372
05:36:21,100 --> 05:36:24,601
closed meeting and coming back with

2373
05:36:25,100 --> 05:36:28,100
for us nothing but questions and not

2374
05:36:28,100 --> 05:36:30,100
an answer to what we thouk you were

2375
05:36:30,100 --> 05:36:33,100
going -- so, things happen

2376
05:36:35,100 --> 05:36:38,100
and we appreciate your perseverance and

2377
05:36:38,100 --> 05:36:40,100
your courage to sticking together when

2378
05:36:40,100 --> 05:36:42,100
stuff happens.

2379
05:36:44,100 --> 05:36:46,100
it's sometimes unexpected.

2380
05:36:49,100 --> 05:36:51,100
the thing that keeps coming to mind to

2381
05:36:51,100 --> 05:36:53,100
me is and what else.

2382
05:36:53,100 --> 05:36:57,100
free city is one source of potential

2383
05:36:57,100 --> 05:36:59,100
support but I think I've mentioned

2384
05:36:59,100 --> 05:37:02,100
before, I come from midwest colleges

2385
05:37:02,100 --> 05:37:05,100
and I get mail every month from the

2386
05:37:05,100 --> 05:37:06,100
foundations asking for money.

2387
05:37:06,100 --> 05:37:10,100
I don't hear anything about the city

2388
05:37:10,100 --> 05:37:13,601
college of san francisco foundation as

2389
05:37:14,100 --> 05:37:16,100
a potential source along with free

2390
05:37:16,100 --> 05:37:17,100
city.

2391
05:37:17,100 --> 05:37:20,100
if we put all of our hopes in one

2392
05:37:20,100 --> 05:37:23,100
basket and there's another one kind of

2393
05:37:23,100 --> 05:37:26,100
waiting out there by the curb that

2394
05:37:26,100 --> 05:37:29,100
hasn't been stimulated to participate

2395
05:37:30,100 --> 05:37:33,100
and the last time I looked online, the

2396
05:37:33,100 --> 05:37:36,100
last two years of reports of the

2397
05:37:36,100 --> 05:37:38,100
foundation are missing.

2398
05:37:38,100 --> 05:37:42,100
the information is old, so I would

2399
05:37:42,100 --> 05:37:47,401
plead with you all to use free city as

2400
05:37:48,100 --> 05:37:52,201
a core but think about other pathways

2401
05:37:54,100 --> 05:37:57,100
to raising money for this institution.

2402
05:37:57,100 --> 05:38:00,100
it just makes sense and we're all

2403
05:38:00,100 --> 05:38:04,100
subject to those mailers that go out

2404
05:38:04,100 --> 05:38:06,100
very friendly, hi, alumni, send us

2405
05:38:06,100 --> 05:38:07,100
some money, you know.

2406
05:38:07,100 --> 05:38:11,100
and the stories that we hear about at

2407
05:38:11,100 --> 05:38:14,601
city hall from the stories are

2408
05:38:15,100 --> 05:38:17,100
powerful stories to deliver a message,

2409
05:38:17,100 --> 05:38:19,100
not just to free city, but to the

2410
05:38:19,100 --> 05:38:22,100
foundation and any other sources that

2411
05:38:22,100 --> 05:38:26,100
we can think about, so thank you for

2412
05:38:26,100 --> 05:38:30,100
what you're doing and we're here to

2413
05:38:30,100 --> 05:38:31,100
help.

2414
05:38:31,100 --> 05:38:32,100
>> that concludes public comment.

2415
05:38:32,100 --> 05:38:34,401
>> thank you very much.

2416
05:38:39,100 --> 05:38:40,100
okay.

2417
05:38:40,100 --> 05:38:41,100
ms. Esteban, roll call vote, please.

2418
05:38:41,100 --> 05:38:42,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

2419
05:38:42,100 --> 05:38:43,100
advisory vote?

2420
05:38:43,100 --> 05:38:44,100
>> aye.

2421
05:38:44,100 --> 05:38:45,100
>> president martinez?

2422
05:38:45,100 --> 05:38:46,100
>> yes.

2423
05:38:46,100 --> 05:38:47,100
>> vice-president zamora?

2424
05:38:47,100 --> 05:38:48,100
>> aye.

2425
05:38:48,100 --> 05:38:49,100
>> trustee chisti?

2426
05:38:49,100 --> 05:38:50,100
>> aye.

2427
05:38:50,100 --> 05:38:51,100
>> trustee wong?

2428
05:38:51,100 --> 05:38:52,100
>> yes.

2429
05:38:52,100 --> 05:38:53,100
>> trustee solomon?

2430
05:38:53,100 --> 05:38:54,100
>> yes.

2431
05:38:54,100 --> 05:38:55,100
>> trustee chung?

2432
05:38:55,100 --> 05:38:56,100
>> aye.

2433
05:38:56,100 --> 05:38:57,100
>> trustee mccarty?

2434
05:38:57,100 --> 05:38:58,100
>> aye.

2435
05:38:58,100 --> 05:38:59,100
>> the motion passes.

2436
05:38:59,100 --> 05:39:00,100
>> thank you.

2437
05:39:00,100 --> 05:39:03,100
we now move to the adoption of 6e, the

2438
05:39:03,100 --> 05:39:06,100
adoption of resolution 2025-10 in

2439
05:39:06,100 --> 05:39:08,100
recognition of pride month.

2440
05:39:08,100 --> 05:39:11,100
I believe the resolution is being

2441
05:39:11,100 --> 05:39:15,201
moved by trustee chung and seconded by

2442
05:39:16,100 --> 05:39:17,100
trustee solomon.

2443
05:39:17,100 --> 05:39:20,100
would you like to address this

2444
05:39:20,100 --> 05:39:23,601
resolution before we take questions or

2445
05:39:24,100 --> 05:39:26,100
comments?

2446
05:39:26,100 --> 05:39:30,100
>> yes, do you want to move in and

2447
05:39:30,100 --> 05:39:32,100
then I'll reverse.

2448
05:39:36,100 --> 05:39:40,801
>> I wanted to move it but with some

2449
05:39:41,100 --> 05:39:43,100
amendments that supplement and take

2450
05:39:43,100 --> 05:39:45,100
nothing away with what's very good and

2451
05:39:45,100 --> 05:39:46,100
what's there.

2452
05:39:46,100 --> 05:39:48,100
so, if I could proceed, hopefully what

2453
05:39:48,100 --> 05:39:52,100
I sent to ms. Esteban was easy enough

2454
05:39:52,100 --> 05:39:56,100
to follow but I can walk through it as

2455
05:39:56,100 --> 05:39:57,100
well.

2456
05:39:57,100 --> 05:39:59,100
so, the first -- just in order from

2457
05:39:59,100 --> 05:40:03,801
the top of the resolution to the bottom

2458
05:40:04,100 --> 05:40:08,201
of the resolution, in the -- okay.

2459
05:40:14,100 --> 05:40:17,100
in the 7th whereas, in whereas that

2460
05:40:17,100 --> 05:40:20,100
starts with whereas city college a hah

2461
05:40:20,100 --> 05:40:23,601
a proud tradition of combining culture

2462
05:40:24,100 --> 05:40:26,100
and education and I think there's an

2463
05:40:26,100 --> 05:40:30,201
extra in there, and sorry, in 1989, the

2464
05:40:34,100 --> 05:40:37,100
addition is lgbt, studies faculty jack

2465
05:40:37,100 --> 05:40:40,100
collins created the first freestanding

2466
05:40:41,100 --> 05:40:44,100
lgbt studies department in the nature,

2467
05:40:44,100 --> 05:40:47,100
it's in addition of those five words,

2468
05:40:47,100 --> 05:40:49,401
lgbt studies faculty jack

2469
05:40:51,100 --> 05:40:54,100
collins, everything else stays the

2470
05:40:54,100 --> 05:40:56,100
same.

2471
05:40:56,100 --> 05:41:00,100
the next amendment is to add a

2472
05:41:00,100 --> 05:41:01,100
whereas, after the whereas that's

2473
05:41:01,100 --> 05:41:04,100
about -- that starts with the whereas

2474
05:41:04,100 --> 05:41:06,100
the college's queer resource centers

2475
05:41:06,100 --> 05:41:08,401
empowers and unites lgtqia+

2476
05:41:11,100 --> 05:41:13,401
students, an additional whereas

2477
05:41:14,100 --> 05:41:18,201
that is taken from the resolution that

2478
05:41:22,100 --> 05:41:25,601
we passed on june 22, 2023, and I

2479
05:41:27,100 --> 05:41:31,100
thought it was important to put that

2480
05:41:31,100 --> 05:41:33,100
in there because what we said back

2481
05:41:33,100 --> 05:41:36,100
then is we're going to do this every

2482
05:41:36,100 --> 05:41:39,100
year, just as a reminder to us of what

2483
05:41:39,100 --> 05:41:43,801
we did make a commitment to two years

2484
05:41:46,100 --> 05:41:47,100
ago.

2485
05:41:47,100 --> 05:41:48,100
the next amendment is to delete the

2486
05:41:48,100 --> 05:41:51,100
next whereas and just to replace it

2487
05:41:51,100 --> 05:41:54,601
with whereas the first annual flag

2488
05:41:56,100 --> 05:41:58,100
raising -- pride flag raising ceremony

2489
05:41:58,100 --> 05:42:01,601
was held in 2024, the new whereas

2490
05:42:04,100 --> 05:42:07,601
includes that we voted on that.

2491
05:42:08,100 --> 05:42:11,100
so, just to cut out a little

2492
05:42:11,100 --> 05:42:12,100
repetition.

2493
05:42:12,100 --> 05:42:16,100
and then the final one which came from

2494
05:42:16,100 --> 05:42:18,100
trustee chung is -- sorry, trustee

2495
05:42:18,100 --> 05:42:21,100
chung gave us the jack collins

2496
05:42:21,100 --> 05:42:22,100
language.

2497
05:42:22,100 --> 05:42:25,100
then a final resolved, finally

2498
05:42:25,100 --> 05:42:27,100
the board of

2499
05:42:27,100 --> 05:42:29,100
trustees of city college of san

2500
05:42:29,100 --> 05:42:30,100
francisco strongly reaffirms its

2501
05:42:30,100 --> 05:42:33,100
commitments as resolved in its june

2502
05:42:33,100 --> 05:42:35,100
22, 2023 resolution, honorees the city

2503
05:42:35,100 --> 05:42:38,100
college of san francisco's lgbtqia+

2504
05:42:42,100 --> 05:42:43,100
community for their ongoing courage

2505
05:42:43,100 --> 05:42:44,100
and compassion and offers its

2506
05:42:44,100 --> 05:42:45,100
profound thanks for to them for making

2507
05:42:45,100 --> 05:42:48,100
our world a better place.

2508
05:42:49,100 --> 05:42:50,100
>> trustee chung, do you have anything

2509
05:42:50,100 --> 05:42:51,100
to add?

2510
05:42:51,100 --> 05:42:54,601
>> I just want to thank trustee

2511
05:42:55,100 --> 05:42:59,100
solomon for being a wonderful ally to

2512
05:42:59,100 --> 05:43:02,601
our community and dinging all these

2513
05:43:03,100 --> 05:43:05,100
amendments and letting me second it.

2514
05:43:05,100 --> 05:43:06,100
>> vice-president zamora?

2515
05:43:06,100 --> 05:43:08,100
>> I would like to thank both trustee

2516
05:43:08,100 --> 05:43:11,100
chung and trustee solomon for bringing

2517
05:43:11,100 --> 05:43:13,100
this forward.

2518
05:43:17,100 --> 05:43:19,100
>> trustee mccarty?

2519
05:43:20,100 --> 05:43:21,100
>> and I would like the thank them for

2520
05:43:21,100 --> 05:43:22,100
bringing it forward the month before

2521
05:43:22,100 --> 05:43:25,100
so we can have this for the full month.

2522
05:43:25,100 --> 05:43:26,100
>> any other trustee comments?

2523
05:43:26,100 --> 05:43:28,100
trustee chisti?

2524
05:43:29,100 --> 05:43:31,100
>> I think we worked on it together

2525
05:43:31,100 --> 05:43:33,100
in 2023, so thank you so much for

2526
05:43:33,100 --> 05:43:35,100
bringing this forward and I'm excited

2527
05:43:35,100 --> 05:43:38,100
for our flagging raising ceremony

2528
05:43:38,100 --> 05:43:41,100
which was beautiful last year and I'm

2529
05:43:41,100 --> 05:43:44,100
excited for it for this year.

2530
05:43:44,100 --> 05:43:46,401
>> any other trustee comments?

2531
05:43:47,100 --> 05:43:49,100
I would like to thank you for adding

2532
05:43:49,100 --> 05:43:52,601
the name of jack collins who

2533
05:43:54,100 --> 05:43:56,100
originated the lgbtq studies.

2534
05:43:56,100 --> 05:43:58,100
I had the privilege of also working

2535
05:43:58,100 --> 05:44:00,100
with him as did many of us at that

2536
05:44:00,100 --> 05:44:03,100
time and so it's good to see him

2537
05:44:03,100 --> 05:44:05,100
finally acknowledged, a lot of hard

2538
05:44:05,100 --> 05:44:06,100
work, thank you very much.

2539
05:44:06,100 --> 05:44:09,100
are there any public comments?

2540
05:44:09,100 --> 05:44:11,100
ms. Esteban, can you take the vote

2541
05:44:11,100 --> 05:44:12,100
please.

2542
05:44:12,100 --> 05:44:13,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

2543
05:44:13,100 --> 05:44:14,100
advisory vote?

2544
05:44:14,100 --> 05:44:15,100
>> aye.

2545
05:44:15,100 --> 05:44:16,100
>> president martinez?

2546
05:44:16,100 --> 05:44:17,100
>> yes.

2547
05:44:17,100 --> 05:44:18,100
>> vice-president zamora?

2548
05:44:18,100 --> 05:44:19,100
>> aye.

2549
05:44:19,100 --> 05:44:20,100
>> trustee chisti?

2550
05:44:20,100 --> 05:44:21,100
>> aye.

2551
05:44:21,100 --> 05:44:22,100
>> trustee wong?

2552
05:44:22,100 --> 05:44:23,100
>> yes.

2553
05:44:23,100 --> 05:44:24,100
>> trustee solomon?

2554
05:44:24,100 --> 05:44:25,100
>> aye.

2555
05:44:25,100 --> 05:44:26,100
>> trustee chung?

2556
05:44:26,100 --> 05:44:27,100
>> aye.

2557
05:44:27,100 --> 05:44:28,100
>> trustee mccarty?

2558
05:44:28,100 --> 05:44:29,100
>> aye.

2559
05:44:29,100 --> 05:44:31,100
>> the motion passes.

2560
05:44:31,100 --> 05:44:33,100
>> we now move to the approval of the

2561
05:44:33,100 --> 05:44:34,100
minutes, are there any corrections to

2562
05:44:34,100 --> 05:44:38,100
any of the minutes, if so, please

2563
05:44:38,100 --> 05:44:41,100
specify the meeting date and

2564
05:44:43,100 --> 05:44:44,100
corrections.

2565
05:44:44,100 --> 05:44:45,100
seeing none, is there a motion to

2566
05:44:45,100 --> 05:44:48,100
approve the minutes of april 24, 2025.

2567
05:44:51,100 --> 05:44:54,100
>> we have one public comment,

2568
05:44:54,100 --> 05:44:55,100
abigail bornstein.

2569
05:44:55,100 --> 05:44:57,100
>> thank you, sorry.

2570
05:44:59,100 --> 05:45:03,201
>> so, for the umpteenth time, one of

2571
05:45:04,100 --> 05:45:06,100
my written public comments was left

2572
05:45:06,100 --> 05:45:10,801
off, which one this time, it was the

2573
05:45:11,100 --> 05:45:15,100
april 24th 10a budget update, at this

2574
05:45:15,100 --> 05:45:18,100
point, this leaving off of my written

2575
05:45:18,100 --> 05:45:21,100
comment feels intentional and I will

2576
05:45:21,100 --> 05:45:23,100
read it back into the record and ask

2577
05:45:23,100 --> 05:45:26,100
the board to approve the april 24th

2578
05:45:26,100 --> 05:45:28,100
minute with the addition of my written

2579
05:45:28,100 --> 05:45:30,100
comment which was left off.

2580
05:45:30,100 --> 05:45:33,601
so, item 10a budget update, 137 words,

2581
05:45:34,100 --> 05:45:36,100
when did the board receive the slides

2582
05:45:36,100 --> 05:45:38,100
with the draft budget assumptions, this

2583
05:45:38,100 --> 05:45:40,100
was not posted for the

2584
05:45:40,100 --> 05:45:42,100
public until sometime today.

2585
05:45:42,100 --> 05:45:44,100
on occasion, this last minute upload

2586
05:45:44,100 --> 05:45:46,100
may happen but it has now become

2587
05:45:46,100 --> 05:45:48,100
common place.

2588
05:45:48,100 --> 05:45:51,100
as either madeline or harry states a

2589
05:45:51,100 --> 05:45:54,100
place holder agenda is released on

2590
05:45:54,100 --> 05:45:56,100
monday but only shortly before the

2591
05:45:56,100 --> 05:45:58,100
actual meeting on thursday do the

2592
05:45:58,100 --> 05:45:59,100
attachments appear.

2593
05:45:59,100 --> 05:46:02,100
if these assumptions were shown at the

2594
05:46:02,100 --> 05:46:05,100
pgc budget committee on tuesday, why

2595
05:46:05,100 --> 05:46:08,100
weren't they posted on tuesday instead

2596
05:46:08,100 --> 05:46:09,100
of last minute today.

2597
05:46:09,100 --> 05:46:11,100
you state that you receive bead

2598
05:46:11,100 --> 05:46:13,100
feedback from the pgc budget committee

2599
05:46:13,100 --> 05:46:15,100
but provide no insight into that

2600
05:46:15,100 --> 05:46:16,100
feedback.

2601
05:46:16,100 --> 05:46:17,100
were they supportive of the

2602
05:46:17,100 --> 05:46:19,100
assumptions, asked for change, we never

2603
05:46:19,100 --> 05:46:21,100
share the actual feedback with the

2604
05:46:21,100 --> 05:46:23,100
board which would be educational.

2605
05:46:23,100 --> 05:46:26,100
what was the position of the pgc budget

2606
05:46:26,100 --> 05:46:28,100
committee on the assumptions?

2607
05:46:28,100 --> 05:46:30,100
again, I ask that the minutes be seconded

2608
05:46:30,100 --> 05:46:34,201
and my written comment included in the

2609
05:46:35,100 --> 05:46:36,100
minutes, thank you.

2610
05:46:36,100 --> 05:46:38,401
>> that concludes public comments.

2611
05:46:39,100 --> 05:46:41,100
>> with that amendments, is there a

2612
05:46:41,100 --> 05:46:43,100
motion to approve all three of the

2613
05:46:43,100 --> 05:46:45,100
sets of minutes?

2614
05:46:45,100 --> 05:46:46,100
>> so moved.

2615
05:46:46,100 --> 05:46:48,401
>> is there a second?

2616
05:46:49,100 --> 05:46:52,100
>> second, but if I may add to the

2617
05:46:52,100 --> 05:46:53,100
discussion.

2618
05:46:53,100 --> 05:46:54,100
>> yes.

2619
05:46:54,100 --> 05:46:57,100
>> I wonder, and again, I completely

2620
05:46:57,100 --> 05:47:00,100
understand, all our staff are so

2621
05:47:00,100 --> 05:47:03,100
overworked, they're so overworked, we

2622
05:47:03,100 --> 05:47:04,100
don't have enough staffing.

2623
05:47:04,100 --> 05:47:07,100
I can relate, I'm in workers comp,

2624
05:47:07,100 --> 05:47:10,100
we're two secretaries short and I'm so

2625
05:47:10,100 --> 05:47:14,100
tired, but I hope perhaps maybe we can

2626
05:47:14,100 --> 05:47:15,100
just double check to make sure if

2627
05:47:15,100 --> 05:47:18,601
there are any other written public

2628
05:47:19,100 --> 05:47:20,100
comment tobies make sure they're added

2629
05:47:20,100 --> 05:47:22,100
if we can conditionally approve these

2630
05:47:22,100 --> 05:47:24,100
minutes, that would be wonderful,

2631
05:47:24,100 --> 05:47:25,100
thank you.

2632
05:47:25,100 --> 05:47:29,201
>> and if with that, that would be

2633
05:47:30,100 --> 05:47:32,100
delegated to interim chancellor

2634
05:47:32,100 --> 05:47:34,100
bailey, thank you.

2635
05:47:36,100 --> 05:47:37,100
alright.

2636
05:47:37,100 --> 05:47:41,100
are we ready for the roll call vote?

2637
05:47:41,100 --> 05:47:42,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

2638
05:47:42,100 --> 05:47:43,100
advisory vote?

2639
05:47:43,100 --> 05:47:45,100
>> aye.

2640
05:47:45,100 --> 05:47:46,100
>> president martinez?

2641
05:47:46,100 --> 05:47:48,100
>> yes.

2642
05:47:48,100 --> 05:47:49,100
>> vice-president zamora?

2643
05:47:49,100 --> 05:47:50,100
>> aye.

2644
05:47:50,100 --> 05:47:51,100
>> trustee chisti?

2645
05:47:51,100 --> 05:47:52,100
>> aye.

2646
05:47:52,100 --> 05:47:53,100
>> trustee wong?

2647
05:47:53,100 --> 05:47:54,100
>> yes.

2648
05:47:54,100 --> 05:47:55,100
>> trustee solomon?

2649
05:47:55,100 --> 05:47:56,100
>> yes.

2650
05:47:56,100 --> 05:47:57,100
>> trustee chung?

2651
05:47:57,100 --> 05:47:58,100
>> aye.

2652
05:47:58,100 --> 05:47:59,100
>> trustee mccarty?

2653
05:47:59,100 --> 05:48:00,100
>> aye.

2654
05:48:00,100 --> 05:48:01,100
>> the motion passes.

2655
05:48:01,100 --> 05:48:03,100
>> we're now at the constituent group

2656
05:48:03,100 --> 05:48:07,201
report, the first one is the student

2657
05:48:08,100 --> 05:48:10,100
chancellor's report, malinalli

2658
05:48:11,100 --> 05:48:13,100
villalobos.

2659
05:48:17,100 --> 05:48:18,100
I know that -- is he here?

2660
05:48:18,100 --> 05:48:20,100
thank you.

2661
05:48:43,100 --> 05:48:45,100
mr. Villalobos is also an the encore

2662
05:48:45,100 --> 05:48:47,401
convention so it's understandable.

2663
05:48:51,100 --> 05:48:52,100
>> can you hear me?

2664
05:48:52,100 --> 05:48:53,100
>> there you are, thank you.

2665
05:48:53,100 --> 05:48:55,100
>> yes, thank you.

2666
05:48:57,100 --> 05:49:00,100
saludos, good evening, ccsf community,

2667
05:49:00,100 --> 05:49:03,100
especially our amazing ccsf students,

2668
05:49:03,100 --> 05:49:07,201
I hope you're doing well this evening.

2669
05:49:09,100 --> 05:49:10,100
as student chancellor, I would like to

2670
05:49:10,100 --> 05:49:12,100
report on behalf of the associated

2671
05:49:12,100 --> 05:49:14,100
students this evening, I do want to

2672
05:49:14,100 --> 05:49:17,601
let you know that it's very

2673
05:49:20,100 --> 05:49:22,100
troublesome, it's very troublesome

2674
05:49:22,100 --> 05:49:24,100
wherein when we have student voices

2675
05:49:24,100 --> 05:49:26,100
not being heard.

2676
05:49:27,100 --> 05:49:31,201
it has been a very upsetting and

2677
05:49:33,100 --> 05:49:37,201
emotional night as far as with our

2678
05:49:39,100 --> 05:49:42,100
contract with the incoming chancellor,

2679
05:49:45,100 --> 05:49:47,100
dr. Cortez.

2680
05:49:48,100 --> 05:49:51,100
as stated earlier in public comment,

2681
05:49:51,100 --> 05:49:53,401
students overwhelmingly have shown

2682
05:49:57,100 --> 05:50:00,100
their support for dr. Cortez, and dr.

2683
05:50:00,100 --> 05:50:02,100
cortez, if you can hear us, be patient

2684
05:50:02,100 --> 05:50:04,100
with us as we're trying to figure

2685
05:50:04,100 --> 05:50:05,100
this out.

2686
05:50:05,100 --> 05:50:07,100
when you come in, there's a lot of

2687
05:50:07,100 --> 05:50:11,100
work to be done and students, don't

2688
05:50:11,100 --> 05:50:13,100
lose any hope.

2689
05:50:13,100 --> 05:50:17,100
our voices are strong and we will be

2690
05:50:17,100 --> 05:50:18,100
heard.

2691
05:50:18,100 --> 05:50:21,100
when we're not heard, we're going

2692
05:50:21,100 --> 05:50:23,100
to go ahead and take action.

2693
05:50:23,100 --> 05:50:25,100
every board member there was elected,

2694
05:50:25,100 --> 05:50:28,100
was elected with the support of

2695
05:50:28,100 --> 05:50:31,601
students during campaigns and we have

2696
05:50:32,100 --> 05:50:34,100
to restructure that and go back to the

2697
05:50:34,100 --> 05:50:37,100
drawing board and question board

2698
05:50:38,100 --> 05:50:40,100
members, if they deserve to be in

2699
05:50:40,100 --> 05:50:42,100
their elected positions, we'll go

2700
05:50:42,100 --> 05:50:44,401
ahead and do that.

2701
05:50:45,100 --> 05:50:49,201
as stated earlier in the public comment

2702
05:50:52,100 --> 05:50:55,100
, the advocacy for the african

2703
05:50:56,100 --> 05:50:59,100
american resource center needs to be

2704
05:50:59,100 --> 05:51:02,100
present by action and the action is

2705
05:51:02,100 --> 05:51:05,100
having the african american resource

2706
05:51:05,100 --> 05:51:09,201
center be moved to the new student

2707
05:51:10,100 --> 05:51:14,100
success center, there are no ands, ifs

2708
05:51:14,100 --> 05:51:16,100
or buts about it, the students have

2709
05:51:16,100 --> 05:51:18,100
spoken, the workers within those

2710
05:51:18,100 --> 05:51:19,100
spaces have spoken.

2711
05:51:19,100 --> 05:51:23,201
this has been years in the making.

2712
05:51:24,100 --> 05:51:26,100
we have to make sure we have the space

2713
05:51:26,100 --> 05:51:28,100
for the african american resource

2714
05:51:28,100 --> 05:51:29,100
center.

2715
05:51:29,100 --> 05:51:31,100
we have to make sure we have the space

2716
05:51:31,100 --> 05:51:33,100
for city dream

2717
05:51:34,100 --> 05:51:38,100
to be able to conduct the amazing they

2718
05:51:38,100 --> 05:51:40,100
do in their those spaces, we have to

2719
05:51:40,100 --> 05:51:42,100
make sure the resource center have

2720
05:51:42,100 --> 05:51:45,601
ample spaces to serve student/parent

2721
05:51:46,100 --> 05:51:49,100
needs and children as well.

2722
05:51:50,100 --> 05:51:53,100
as I'm finishing up my last few days

2723
05:51:53,100 --> 05:51:55,100
as student chancellor, I want to

2724
05:51:55,100 --> 05:51:57,401
congratulate the incoming executive

2725
05:52:00,100 --> 05:52:03,100
student council for this new academic

2726
05:52:03,100 --> 05:52:06,100
year, congratulations to angelica pam

2727
05:52:07,100 --> 05:52:10,100
poes for becoming our new student

2728
05:52:10,100 --> 05:52:11,100
trustee, heather brandt for becoming

2729
05:52:11,100 --> 05:52:14,100
our student chancellor and myself as

2730
05:52:14,100 --> 05:52:15,100
student vice chancellor.

2731
05:52:15,100 --> 05:52:18,100
I do want to finish up, I know I'm out

2732
05:52:18,100 --> 05:52:20,100
of time, I want to finish up with a

2733
05:52:20,100 --> 05:52:22,401
few seconds to share.

2734
05:52:23,100 --> 05:52:26,100
on behalf of the students of the san

2735
05:52:26,100 --> 05:52:27,100
francisco community college district,

2736
05:52:27,100 --> 05:52:30,100
I want to extend a heartfelt

2737
05:52:30,100 --> 05:52:33,100
appreciation to heather brandt, your

2738
05:52:33,100 --> 05:52:34,100
leadership, advocacy and unwavering

2739
05:52:34,100 --> 05:52:36,100
commitment to representing the student

2740
05:52:36,100 --> 05:52:38,100
voice have made a lasting impact.

2741
05:52:38,100 --> 05:52:41,100
these last few years, you brought

2742
05:52:41,100 --> 05:52:43,100
thoughtfulness, energy and integrity

2743
05:52:43,100 --> 05:52:46,100
to every discussion in your

2744
05:52:46,100 --> 05:52:47,100
contributions will continue to inspire

2745
05:52:47,100 --> 05:52:50,100
students throughout the many years to

2746
05:52:50,100 --> 05:52:51,100
come.

2747
05:52:51,100 --> 05:52:53,100
gracias, thank you for your dedicated

2748
05:52:53,100 --> 05:52:55,100
service, you truly made a difference in

2749
05:52:55,100 --> 05:52:58,100
students' lives, that is the work that

2750
05:52:58,100 --> 05:53:00,100
the students have been putting forward

2751
05:53:00,100 --> 05:53:02,100
for the last two years, thank you, I

2752
05:53:02,100 --> 05:53:04,100
appreciate you, even when the board

2753
05:53:04,100 --> 05:53:06,100
does not get it together, you have

2754
05:53:06,100 --> 05:53:08,100
been one of the only people there that

2755
05:53:08,100 --> 05:53:11,100
students can count on, so I appreciate

2756
05:53:11,100 --> 05:53:14,100
you and with that, I leave my hat to

2757
05:53:14,100 --> 05:53:16,100
the next student chancellor, heather

2758
05:53:16,100 --> 05:53:17,100
brandt, thank you, everybody, thank

2759
05:53:17,100 --> 05:53:19,100
you, all the students for being able

2760
05:53:19,100 --> 05:53:22,100
to support me these last two years as

2761
05:53:22,100 --> 05:53:24,401
student chancellor and as

2762
05:53:30,100 --> 05:53:31,100
student trustee previously.

2763
05:53:31,100 --> 05:53:32,100
thank you.

2764
05:53:32,100 --> 05:53:33,100
>> very good.

2765
05:53:33,100 --> 05:53:37,100
we now turn to the student trustee's

2766
05:53:37,100 --> 05:53:39,100
report.

2767
05:53:42,100 --> 05:53:44,100
student trustee brandt, you're muted.

2768
05:53:44,100 --> 05:53:48,100
>> I'm trying to unmute, are you able

2769
05:53:48,100 --> 05:53:49,100
to hear me?

2770
05:53:49,100 --> 05:53:50,100
>> yes.

2771
05:53:50,100 --> 05:53:51,100
>> I'm going to try to keep it within

2772
05:53:51,100 --> 05:53:54,100
time, this is my last and

2773
05:53:54,100 --> 05:53:56,100
final report.

2774
05:53:56,100 --> 05:54:00,201
I was trying not to get emotional.

2775
05:54:05,100 --> 05:54:07,401
well, I apologize for

2776
05:54:09,100 --> 05:54:11,100
coming in late tonight, I was

2777
05:54:11,100 --> 05:54:13,100
experiencing audio challenges earlier

2778
05:54:13,100 --> 05:54:15,100
and hopefully those have since been

2779
05:54:15,100 --> 05:54:18,100
involved, I too am in new york and

2780
05:54:18,100 --> 05:54:19,100
encore and I wish I could be in person

2781
05:54:19,100 --> 05:54:21,100
with you all.

2782
05:54:21,100 --> 05:54:23,100
I sit here tonight having recently

2783
05:54:23,100 --> 05:54:26,100
wrapped up the 2024-25 academic year

2784
05:54:26,100 --> 05:54:30,100
and my second and final term as your

2785
05:54:30,100 --> 05:54:33,100
student trustee and want to express my

2786
05:54:33,100 --> 05:54:36,100
deepest gratitude for the honor of

2787
05:54:36,100 --> 05:54:38,100
serving students at the city college

2788
05:54:38,100 --> 05:54:40,100
of san francisco representing a

2789
05:54:40,100 --> 05:54:41,100
vibrant, diverse and resilient student

2790
05:54:41,100 --> 05:54:45,100
body has been one of the humbling and

2791
05:54:45,100 --> 05:54:47,100
transformative experiences of my life.

2792
05:54:47,100 --> 05:54:49,100
over the paster two years, I have

2793
05:54:49,100 --> 05:54:51,100
advocated for student needs on a

2794
05:54:51,100 --> 05:54:54,100
number of issues and make no mistake,

2795
05:54:54,100 --> 05:54:56,100
there's so much more to be done as we

2796
05:54:56,100 --> 05:54:58,100
have heard from city dream, the family

2797
05:54:58,100 --> 05:55:01,100
resource center and the african

2798
05:55:01,100 --> 05:55:02,100
american resource center with regard

2799
05:55:02,100 --> 05:55:03,100
to the use of space.

2800
05:55:03,100 --> 05:55:05,100
I did not, have not and will not ever

2801
05:55:05,100 --> 05:55:09,100
shy away from speaking truth to power

2802
05:55:09,100 --> 05:55:11,100
including calling out

2803
05:55:11,100 --> 05:55:13,100
atrocities that continue to take

2804
05:55:13,100 --> 05:55:15,100
place in palestine, I thank this board

2805
05:55:15,100 --> 05:55:17,100
for their support which came in the

2806
05:55:17,100 --> 05:55:19,100
form of a cease fire resolution.

2807
05:55:19,100 --> 05:55:21,100
my voice at this table has come from a

2808
05:55:21,100 --> 05:55:24,100
place of lived experience, a deep love

2809
05:55:24,100 --> 05:55:27,601
for ccsf and our community college

2810
05:55:30,100 --> 05:55:31,100
system as well as a recognition that

2811
05:55:31,100 --> 05:55:32,100
equity and access are not abstract

2812
05:55:32,100 --> 05:55:34,401
ideals but urgent necessities.

2813
05:55:35,100 --> 05:55:37,100
this journey has not been without lots

2814
05:55:37,100 --> 05:55:39,100
of struggle and personal hardship.

2815
05:55:39,100 --> 05:55:42,100
I want to share in the hopes of

2816
05:55:42,100 --> 05:55:43,100
building understanding of what life is

2817
05:55:43,100 --> 05:55:46,100
and can be like for our students, over

2818
05:55:46,100 --> 05:55:49,100
the course of the last two years, my

2819
05:55:49,100 --> 05:55:52,100
mother was placed on hospice as her

2820
05:55:52,100 --> 05:55:55,100
alzheimer's advanced, my siblings and

2821
05:55:56,100 --> 05:55:58,100
spouse were diagnosed with different

2822
05:55:58,100 --> 05:55:59,100
stages and forms of cancer and have

2823
05:55:59,100 --> 05:56:02,601
has had to go radiation, chemotherapy

2824
05:56:04,100 --> 05:56:06,100
and various procedures, I lost two of

2825
05:56:06,100 --> 05:56:09,100
my first cousins who were in their

2826
05:56:09,100 --> 05:56:11,100
30's, the one to brain kans and her

2827
05:56:11,100 --> 05:56:13,100
the other to khakis, if you know

2828
05:56:13,100 --> 05:56:16,100
anything about coming from latino

2829
05:56:16,100 --> 05:56:19,601
family, our cousins is like our

2830
05:56:20,100 --> 05:56:21,100
siblings too.

2831
05:56:21,100 --> 05:56:25,100
I mourn the ongoing loss of palestine

2832
05:56:25,100 --> 05:56:27,100
where many of my loved onuses continue

2833
05:56:27,100 --> 05:56:28,100
the fight for survival.

2834
05:56:28,100 --> 05:56:30,100
all of this while navigating

2835
05:56:30,100 --> 05:56:33,100
the demands of life while I work to

2836
05:56:33,100 --> 05:56:35,100
raise my three children holding down

2837
05:56:35,100 --> 05:56:37,100
two part time job, attending school

2838
05:56:37,100 --> 05:56:40,100
full time to help ot with our ftes

2839
05:56:40,100 --> 05:56:43,601
numbers, there were times the weight

2840
05:56:44,100 --> 05:56:46,100
felt unbearable and I questioned

2841
05:56:46,100 --> 05:56:47,100
whether I could carry the

2842
05:56:47,100 --> 05:56:49,100
responsibilities of this role and

2843
05:56:49,100 --> 05:56:51,100
still show up fully for my family and

2844
05:56:51,100 --> 05:56:53,100
community but with the support of my

2845
05:56:53,100 --> 05:56:56,100
peers and the ccsf family, I kept

2846
05:56:56,100 --> 05:56:59,601
showing up, I leave this role

2847
05:57:01,100 --> 05:57:04,601
proud, not just of accomplished but

2848
05:57:07,100 --> 05:57:09,100
the persistence and heart that it took

2849
05:57:09,100 --> 05:57:11,100
the get here and to carry me through

2850
05:57:11,100 --> 05:57:12,100
through.

2851
05:57:12,100 --> 05:57:16,801
as I prepare to step away from the

2852
05:57:17,100 --> 05:57:21,100
seat, I await what lays ahead for me,

2853
05:57:21,100 --> 05:57:24,100
it is a great pleasure the introduce

2854
05:57:24,100 --> 05:57:27,100
your incoming student trustee for the

2855
05:57:27,100 --> 05:57:30,601
25-26 academic year angel koe campos,

2856
05:57:31,100 --> 05:57:34,100
she brings a wealth of knowledge and

2857
05:57:34,100 --> 05:57:36,401
experience in community advocacy,

2858
05:57:37,100 --> 05:57:39,100
coalition bid, having previously

2859
05:57:39,100 --> 05:57:41,100
served as associated student council

2860
05:57:41,100 --> 05:57:43,100
of ocean president, student

2861
05:57:43,100 --> 05:57:45,401
chancellor, a current representative

2862
05:57:46,100 --> 05:57:47,100
within participatory governance, a

2863
05:57:47,100 --> 05:57:49,100
former member of the free city

2864
05:57:49,100 --> 05:57:51,100
oversight committee as well as having

2865
05:57:51,100 --> 05:57:53,100
held various roles other the years

2866
05:57:53,100 --> 05:57:56,100
within the student senate for

2867
05:57:56,100 --> 05:57:57,100
community colleges, ultimately

2868
05:57:57,100 --> 05:57:58,100
concludes her time in the organization

2869
05:57:58,100 --> 05:57:59,100
as president.

2870
05:57:59,100 --> 05:58:02,100
she currently serves on the boards of

2871
05:58:02,100 --> 05:58:05,601
san francisco young dams and the

2872
05:58:06,100 --> 05:58:09,601
harvey milk club, her background is

2873
05:58:12,100 --> 05:58:14,100
deeply engaged in justice and

2874
05:58:14,100 --> 05:58:15,100
inclusion.

2875
05:58:15,100 --> 05:58:17,100
I have full confidence she will lead

2876
05:58:17,100 --> 05:58:19,100
with integrity, compassion and advice,

2877
05:58:19,100 --> 05:58:22,100
please welcome her with the same

2878
05:58:22,100 --> 05:58:24,100
encouragement and collaboration that I

2879
05:58:24,100 --> 05:58:26,100
have been so fortunate to receive.

2880
05:58:26,100 --> 05:58:28,100
to student, I hope you never forget

2881
05:58:28,100 --> 05:58:31,100
your voice matters, you belong in

2882
05:58:31,100 --> 05:58:33,100
every room where decisions are made.

2883
05:58:33,100 --> 05:58:35,100
to those who continue this work, thank

2884
05:58:35,100 --> 05:58:37,100
you, thank you for believing in

2885
05:58:37,100 --> 05:58:39,100
student leadership and for your

2886
05:58:39,100 --> 05:58:42,100
commitment to keeping ccsf a place

2887
05:58:42,100 --> 05:58:44,100
where opportunity begins and futures

2888
05:58:44,100 --> 05:58:45,100
are transformed.

2889
05:58:45,100 --> 05:58:47,100
thank you.

2890
05:58:47,100 --> 05:58:49,100
>> thank you very much.

2891
05:58:49,100 --> 05:58:52,100
and now we come to the academic senate

2892
05:58:52,100 --> 05:58:54,100
president's report.

2893
05:59:02,100 --> 05:59:04,100
>> good evening, everyone, exactly one

2894
05:59:04,100 --> 05:59:07,100
week ago today, we came together to

2895
05:59:07,100 --> 05:59:09,100
celebrate the achievement of our

2896
05:59:09,100 --> 05:59:11,100
students at our annual commencement

2897
05:59:11,100 --> 05:59:14,100
ceremony, this year our student peek

2898
05:59:14,100 --> 05:59:16,100
speaker was especially moving,

2899
05:59:16,100 --> 05:59:17,100
commencement reminds us why we have

2900
05:59:17,100 --> 05:59:20,100
been here for 90 years and why it is

2901
05:59:20,100 --> 05:59:22,100
critical we continue to be here for

2902
05:59:22,100 --> 05:59:24,100
decades to come.

2903
05:59:24,100 --> 05:59:27,100
also last week as happens every year,

2904
05:59:27,100 --> 05:59:29,100
the academic senate seated a new

2905
05:59:29,100 --> 05:59:30,100
council.

2906
05:59:30,100 --> 05:59:32,100
we were glad to see some new faces and

2907
05:59:32,100 --> 05:59:34,100
welcome back some familiar ones and

2908
05:59:34,100 --> 05:59:36,100
grateful to those who cycled off the

2909
05:59:36,100 --> 05:59:38,100
council this year.

2910
05:59:38,100 --> 05:59:40,100
the academic senate represents faculty

2911
05:59:40,100 --> 05:59:43,601
voice in all matters concerning the 10

2912
05:59:45,100 --> 05:59:47,100
plus 1 and I would like to underscore

2913
05:59:47,100 --> 05:59:49,100
the value of the campus that would

2914
05:59:49,100 --> 05:59:53,100
like to step up to run for executive

2915
05:59:53,100 --> 05:59:55,100
council.

2916
05:59:56,100 --> 05:59:57,100
as we continue to navigate a series of

2917
05:59:57,100 --> 05:59:58,100
complex realities in the coming year,

2918
05:59:58,100 --> 05:59:59,100
the work of the academic senate will

2919
05:59:59,100 --> 06:00:00,100
remain as important as ever.

2920
06:00:00,100 --> 06:00:02,100
my name is katia fuchs, a math faculty

2921
06:00:02,100 --> 06:00:05,100
and I stand before you today again as

2922
06:00:05,100 --> 06:00:08,100
the newly elected academic senate

2923
06:00:09,100 --> 06:00:10,100
president.

2924
06:00:10,100 --> 06:00:12,100
during my time serving in the academic

2925
06:00:12,100 --> 06:00:15,100
senate and now as senate president, I

2926
06:00:15,100 --> 06:00:17,100
am very conscious of the purpose and

2927
06:00:17,100 --> 06:00:20,601
value of open and inclusive processes.

2928
06:00:21,100 --> 06:00:24,100
when we honor the process, we create a

2929
06:00:24,100 --> 06:00:27,100
culture of accountability and trust.

2930
06:00:27,100 --> 06:00:30,100
this is crucial to the work of any

2931
06:00:30,100 --> 06:00:33,100
successful team and that's what we are

2932
06:00:33,100 --> 06:00:34,100
here, a team.

2933
06:00:34,100 --> 06:00:36,100
tonight you could have closed the loop

2934
06:00:36,100 --> 06:00:39,100
on a crucial process, one that would

2935
06:00:39,100 --> 06:00:42,100
have put us on a path to credible and

2936
06:00:42,100 --> 06:00:44,100
stable leadership, a key facet of

2937
06:00:44,100 --> 06:00:45,100
providing an excellent learning

2938
06:00:45,100 --> 06:00:48,100
environment for each and every one of

2939
06:00:48,100 --> 06:00:51,100
our students and maintaining our

2940
06:00:53,100 --> 06:00:54,100
accreditation.

2941
06:00:54,100 --> 06:00:56,100
I thought I would fill you in on some

2942
06:00:56,100 --> 06:00:58,100
important business that the executive

2943
06:00:58,100 --> 06:01:00,100
council has done since our last

2944
06:01:00,100 --> 06:01:01,100
meeting.

2945
06:01:01,100 --> 06:01:04,100
we endorsed an enrollment philosophy

2946
06:01:05,100 --> 06:01:07,100
we are proud of.

2947
06:01:07,100 --> 06:01:10,100
it prioritizes a holistic student

2948
06:01:11,100 --> 06:01:12,100
centered approach towards enrollment

2949
06:01:12,100 --> 06:01:14,100
management and program support.

2950
06:01:14,100 --> 06:01:16,100
the adult education program through

2951
06:01:16,100 --> 06:01:19,100
your plan and an updated two year

2952
06:01:19,100 --> 06:01:21,100
comprehensive program review process

2953
06:01:21,100 --> 06:01:22,100
which will provide tools and support

2954
06:01:22,100 --> 06:01:24,100
to reflect on the way we currently

2955
06:01:24,100 --> 06:01:25,100
serve our students and collectively

2956
06:01:25,100 --> 06:01:28,100
plan for a future centering student

2957
06:01:28,100 --> 06:01:29,100
success.

2958
06:01:29,100 --> 06:01:31,100
as a body, we feel these tenses move

2959
06:01:31,100 --> 06:01:33,100
our institution forward in servicing

2960
06:01:33,100 --> 06:01:36,100
our students and our broader community.

2961
06:01:36,100 --> 06:01:39,100
our meeting also featured a budget

2962
06:01:39,100 --> 06:01:42,100
update from bc dr. Ligoso which came

2963
06:01:42,100 --> 06:01:45,100
directly on the heels of a budget

2964
06:01:45,100 --> 06:01:48,601
flavored report from robin pew from

2965
06:01:50,100 --> 06:01:53,100
aft, it highlighted the importance of

2966
06:01:53,100 --> 06:01:55,100
ongoing dialogue and constructive

2967
06:01:55,100 --> 06:01:57,100
engagement to get to a place of mutual

2968
06:01:57,100 --> 06:01:59,100
understanding and consensus.

2969
06:02:00,100 --> 06:02:03,100
and thus I conclude my first ever

2970
06:02:03,100 --> 06:02:06,100
report before you, though summer is a

2971
06:02:06,100 --> 06:02:08,100
relatively quiet time on our campus,

2972
06:02:08,100 --> 06:02:11,100
there is work to be done as we're

2973
06:02:11,100 --> 06:02:13,100
recharging getting ready for the full

2974
06:02:13,100 --> 06:02:14,100
steam of the academic year.

2975
06:02:14,100 --> 06:02:18,100
I will continue to come before you to

2976
06:02:18,100 --> 06:02:22,201
speak to and celebrate the faculty in

2977
06:02:24,100 --> 06:02:28,100
my role as senate president this year.

2978
06:02:28,100 --> 06:02:31,100
>> will michael snider be making a

2979
06:02:31,100 --> 06:02:32,100
report?

2980
06:02:32,100 --> 06:02:33,100
thank you.

2981
06:02:33,100 --> 06:02:35,100
>> michael asked me to deliver his

2982
06:02:35,100 --> 06:02:37,100
report for him.

2983
06:02:37,100 --> 06:02:39,100
I would like to thank -- I would like

2984
06:02:39,100 --> 06:02:41,100
to begin by thanking interim chancellor

2985
06:02:41,100 --> 06:02:43,100
bailey for his leadership and support

2986
06:02:43,100 --> 06:02:45,100
over the past year.

2987
06:02:45,100 --> 06:02:48,100
his presence at classified senate

2988
06:02:48,100 --> 06:02:50,100
meetings, his encouragement of

2989
06:02:50,100 --> 06:02:51,100
classified voices in governance and

2990
06:02:51,100 --> 06:02:54,601
his participation in events like the

2991
06:02:55,100 --> 06:02:57,100
holiday breakfast, toy drive and

2992
06:02:57,100 --> 06:02:58,100
graduation ceremonies have been

2993
06:02:58,100 --> 06:02:59,100
greatly appreciated.

2994
06:02:59,100 --> 06:03:02,100
and most of all, we thank him for

2995
06:03:02,100 --> 06:03:04,100
leading the college through difficult

2996
06:03:04,100 --> 06:03:05,100
times.

2997
06:03:05,100 --> 06:03:08,100
we wish him all the best in his next

2998
06:03:08,100 --> 06:03:09,100
chapter.

2999
06:03:09,100 --> 06:03:12,601
I'll skip over michael's next comments

3000
06:03:13,100 --> 06:03:16,100
which were welcoming dr. Cortez.

3001
06:03:16,100 --> 06:03:17,100
at our may meeting, our final session

3002
06:03:17,100 --> 06:03:18,100
before the fall, we certified the

3003
06:03:18,100 --> 06:03:21,100
results of the classified senate

3004
06:03:21,100 --> 06:03:23,100
elections, a heartfelt thank you to the

3005
06:03:23,100 --> 06:03:25,100
election committee for their time and

3006
06:03:25,100 --> 06:03:26,100
effort.

3007
06:03:26,100 --> 06:03:28,100
I also want to acknowledge and thank

3008
06:03:28,100 --> 06:03:30,100
all our outgoing senators, your

3009
06:03:30,100 --> 06:03:31,100
commitment over the past two years

3010
06:03:31,100 --> 06:03:35,100
made a real and lasting impact and we

3011
06:03:35,100 --> 06:03:36,100
sincerely hope to welcome you back in

3012
06:03:36,100 --> 06:03:38,100
the future.

3013
06:03:38,100 --> 06:03:40,100
congratulations to our newly elected

3014
06:03:40,100 --> 06:03:43,601
senators for the 25-27 term, blane

3015
06:03:46,100 --> 06:03:49,100
augustine and jeffrey kelley and

3016
06:03:50,100 --> 06:03:53,100
congratulations to suzanne, maria and

3017
06:03:53,100 --> 06:03:55,100
tanya who will continue her role for a

3018
06:03:55,100 --> 06:03:56,100
second term.

3019
06:03:56,100 --> 06:03:58,100
finally thank you to all classified

3020
06:03:58,100 --> 06:04:01,100
professionals if for your continued

3021
06:04:01,100 --> 06:04:03,100
support and confidence in re-electing

3022
06:04:03,100 --> 06:04:05,100
me as classified senate president for

3023
06:04:05,100 --> 06:04:06,100
a second term.

3024
06:04:06,100 --> 06:04:08,100
it is an honor to serve and advocate

3025
06:04:08,100 --> 06:04:10,100
for our community.

3026
06:04:10,100 --> 06:04:13,100
as we head into summer, here's a

3027
06:04:13,100 --> 06:04:16,100
reminder ore seize candy fundraiser

3028
06:04:16,100 --> 06:04:19,100
will continue through december supporting

3029
06:04:20,100 --> 06:04:21,100
the classified senate development

3030
06:04:21,100 --> 06:04:23,100
and the toy drive.

3031
06:04:23,100 --> 06:04:25,401
this month's classified governance

3032
06:04:28,100 --> 06:04:31,100
spotlight award goes to cecilia,

3033
06:04:31,100 --> 06:04:32,100
educational credential training in

3034
06:04:32,100 --> 06:04:35,601
human resources, an active member of

3035
06:04:39,100 --> 06:04:42,100
the pgc member, it contributes

3036
06:04:42,100 --> 06:04:44,100
manfully to the work of the college,

3037
06:04:44,100 --> 06:04:46,100
we thank her for her dedication and

3038
06:04:46,100 --> 06:04:47,100
service.

3039
06:04:47,100 --> 06:04:49,100
thank you, michael snider, classified

3040
06:04:49,100 --> 06:04:50,100
senate president.

3041
06:04:50,100 --> 06:04:52,100
>> thank you.

3042
06:04:52,100 --> 06:04:56,100
we now move to the service employees

3043
06:04:56,100 --> 06:04:57,100
international union local 1021

3044
06:04:57,100 --> 06:04:59,100
president's report.

3045
06:04:59,100 --> 06:05:01,100
>> hi, can you hear me?

3046
06:05:01,100 --> 06:05:02,100
>> yes.

3047
06:05:02,100 --> 06:05:04,100
>> okay, good.

3048
06:05:04,100 --> 06:05:06,100
evening, board of trustees, seiu is

3049
06:05:06,100 --> 06:05:10,100
pleased to see we have finally got our

3050
06:05:10,100 --> 06:05:12,100
tentative agreement regarding our wage

3051
06:05:12,100 --> 06:05:15,100
for the fiscal year 24-25 on the

3052
06:05:15,100 --> 06:05:17,100
agenda for your approval.

3053
06:05:17,100 --> 06:05:19,100
however, it is concerning that the

3054
06:05:19,100 --> 06:05:20,100
process has taken this long.

3055
06:05:20,100 --> 06:05:23,100
>> it doesn't make sense to me that so

3056
06:05:23,100 --> 06:05:25,100
much excessive money is being spent on

3057
06:05:25,100 --> 06:05:28,100
the law firm and we still are not

3058
06:05:28,100 --> 06:05:30,100
completely done with negotiations on

3059
06:05:30,100 --> 06:05:32,100
our full reopener.

3060
06:05:33,100 --> 06:05:34,100
so that's that.

3061
06:05:34,100 --> 06:05:38,100
now with the stuff that went on

3062
06:05:38,100 --> 06:05:41,100
tonight which is don't understand

3063
06:05:41,100 --> 06:05:42,100
what's going on, a what on earth is

3064
06:05:42,100 --> 06:05:43,100
happening here.

3065
06:05:43,100 --> 06:05:44,100
you've published your choice for

3066
06:05:44,100 --> 06:05:47,601
a permanent chancellor, seiu has been

3067
06:05:48,100 --> 06:05:49,100
trusting your process, hasn't had

3068
06:05:49,100 --> 06:05:51,100
conversations with you all, letting

3069
06:05:51,100 --> 06:05:54,100
you go ahead and do your thing for

3070
06:05:54,100 --> 06:05:57,100
once, right, and not interfering.

3071
06:05:57,100 --> 06:06:00,100
but now we have some doubt.

3072
06:06:00,100 --> 06:06:02,100
after you went into closed session

3073
06:06:02,100 --> 06:06:05,100
tonight for the third time, we

3074
06:06:05,100 --> 06:06:08,100
expected a brief discussion but it

3075
06:06:08,100 --> 06:06:11,100
lasted much longer without any

3076
06:06:11,100 --> 06:06:12,100
explanation.

3077
06:06:12,100 --> 06:06:13,100
it's clear you could have sought some

3078
06:06:13,100 --> 06:06:15,100
of that expensive legal advice to

3079
06:06:15,100 --> 06:06:18,100
provide us with information that is

3080
06:06:18,100 --> 06:06:19,100
sharable.

3081
06:06:19,100 --> 06:06:21,100
labor is not a mood for your bullshit

3082
06:06:21,100 --> 06:06:23,100
and you are pissing us all off in a

3083
06:06:23,100 --> 06:06:24,100
bad way.

3084
06:06:24,100 --> 06:06:27,100
this does not look good, you guys, it

3085
06:06:27,100 --> 06:06:28,100
doesn't.

3086
06:06:28,100 --> 06:06:30,100
so, figure out from the law firm what

3087
06:06:30,100 --> 06:06:34,801
you can share and get a message out

3088
06:06:36,100 --> 06:06:38,100
there.

3089
06:06:38,100 --> 06:06:39,100
good night.

3090
06:06:39,100 --> 06:06:41,100
>> thank you.

3091
06:06:41,100 --> 06:06:44,100
american federation of teachers local

3092
06:06:44,100 --> 06:06:46,100
2121 president's report.

3093
06:06:51,100 --> 06:06:53,100
administrator's association co-chair's

3094
06:06:55,100 --> 06:06:57,100
report?

3095
06:06:57,100 --> 06:06:58,100
the department chair council

3096
06:06:58,100 --> 06:07:00,100
president's report and I understand

3097
06:07:00,100 --> 06:07:03,100
that madeline mueller will be

3098
06:07:04,100 --> 06:07:06,100
reporting.

3099
06:07:20,100 --> 06:07:22,100
>> [inaudible].

3100
06:07:27,100 --> 06:07:31,201
you didn't want to hear that anyway.

3101
06:07:32,100 --> 06:07:34,100
darlene at the last minute said she

3102
06:07:34,100 --> 06:07:36,100
couldn't make it, she had a speech but

3103
06:07:36,100 --> 06:07:39,100
she wanted to give her speech next

3104
06:07:39,100 --> 06:07:42,100
time, she said improvise, okay.

3105
06:07:42,100 --> 06:07:45,100
but to keep a few issues as we started

3106
06:07:45,100 --> 06:07:49,100
the meeting a year ago, grades were

3107
06:07:49,100 --> 06:07:51,100
due and I don't know if you noticed

3108
06:07:51,100 --> 06:07:54,100
out here, a lot of us were getting --

3109
06:07:54,100 --> 06:07:57,100
making sure that all those thousands

3110
06:07:57,100 --> 06:08:01,100
of grades went in today absolutely no

3111
06:08:01,100 --> 06:08:04,100
later than 5:00 because wilbur said

3112
06:08:04,100 --> 06:08:06,100
so, this has taken a lot of energy

3113
06:08:06,100 --> 06:08:09,100
from a lot of faculty and grades are

3114
06:08:09,100 --> 06:08:12,100
very difficult because students as we

3115
06:08:12,100 --> 06:08:15,100
know tonight, life happens, things

3116
06:08:16,100 --> 06:08:18,100
happen and they want extensions and

3117
06:08:18,100 --> 06:08:21,100
it's just very hard to make these kind

3118
06:08:21,100 --> 06:08:22,100
of judgments.

3119
06:08:22,100 --> 06:08:25,100
it's a crucial time for all the

3120
06:08:25,100 --> 06:08:26,100
faculty.

3121
06:08:26,100 --> 06:08:27,100
but we got them, I think we got

3122
06:08:27,100 --> 06:08:29,100
everything in by 5:00.

3123
06:08:30,100 --> 06:08:32,100
also will

3124
06:08:35,100 --> 06:08:38,601
wilbur had another way of looking

3125
06:08:39,100 --> 06:08:41,100
at ghost students, but our real

3126
06:08:41,100 --> 06:08:44,100
student would are online and then stop

3127
06:08:44,100 --> 06:08:46,100
coming and we have to be careful in

3128
06:08:46,100 --> 06:08:49,100
the future not to confuse the bots and

3129
06:08:49,100 --> 06:08:53,801
the fakes and the cabals that are out

3130
06:08:54,100 --> 06:08:56,100
with students who really start and

3131
06:08:56,100 --> 06:09:00,100
want to conclude, then as you get

3132
06:09:00,100 --> 06:09:01,100
closer, then life happens and people

3133
06:09:01,100 --> 06:09:04,100
stress and so forth so we have to make

3134
06:09:04,100 --> 06:09:07,100
sure we don't intermingle our real

3135
06:09:07,100 --> 06:09:11,100
students have a hard time and need to

3136
06:09:11,100 --> 06:09:14,100
get fresh starts with the absolute

3137
06:09:14,100 --> 06:09:15,100
fake folk.

3138
06:09:15,100 --> 06:09:16,100
but I'm glad we're having that

3139
06:09:16,100 --> 06:09:17,100
conversation and we are, the chaises

3140
06:09:17,100 --> 06:09:20,100
are all having that conversation right

3141
06:09:20,100 --> 06:09:21,100
now.

3142
06:09:21,100 --> 06:09:24,100
then I wanted to thank whoever really

3143
06:09:24,100 --> 06:09:26,100
put this wonderful booklet together

3144
06:09:26,100 --> 06:09:28,100
for the graduation ceremony.

3145
06:09:28,100 --> 06:09:30,100
I've been on the committee for many

3146
06:09:30,100 --> 06:09:33,100
years and I designed the process in

3147
06:09:33,100 --> 06:09:36,100
the 70's, but it's -- this is

3148
06:09:36,100 --> 06:09:39,100
spectacular and especially about the

3149
06:09:39,100 --> 06:09:40,100
90th anniversary.

3150
06:09:40,100 --> 06:09:43,100
you maybe all were there and, yeah,

3151
06:09:43,100 --> 06:09:45,100
you were, but try to get people that

3152
06:09:45,100 --> 06:09:48,100
you know to look over this booklet

3153
06:09:48,100 --> 06:09:50,100
because it has some really wonderful

3154
06:09:50,100 --> 06:09:54,201
history in it going back the to 90

3155
06:09:55,100 --> 06:09:58,100
years, before my time barely.

3156
06:09:58,100 --> 06:10:02,801
and then I wanted to share with you

3157
06:10:04,100 --> 06:10:05,100
this evening a booklet, raise your

3158
06:10:05,100 --> 06:10:06,100
hands, how many of you have this?

3159
06:10:06,100 --> 06:10:07,100
nobody?

3160
06:10:07,100 --> 06:10:08,100
good.

3161
06:10:08,100 --> 06:10:11,100
then I'm going to give you one

3162
06:10:11,100 --> 06:10:14,100
if we ever have another break, I have

3163
06:10:14,100 --> 06:10:17,100
one with you and you'll have to look

3164
06:10:17,100 --> 06:10:21,100
at page 90, I won't tell you why, it

3165
06:10:21,100 --> 06:10:25,201
is an normative book that was written

3166
06:10:27,100 --> 06:10:28,100
for our 70's anniversary, very

3167
06:10:28,100 --> 06:10:29,100
complete, lots of pictures.

3168
06:10:29,100 --> 06:10:30,100
you know, any time we have these tense

3169
06:10:30,100 --> 06:10:31,100
meetings, I think we have to recollect

3170
06:10:31,100 --> 06:10:35,201
the school has a long history and

3171
06:10:36,100 --> 06:10:39,601
there's been interesting moments, so I

3172
06:10:40,100 --> 06:10:44,100
want to have a chance maybe now or a

3173
06:10:44,100 --> 06:10:45,100
little later that you all get a copy

3174
06:10:45,100 --> 06:10:47,100
of this.

3175
06:10:49,100 --> 06:10:51,100
>> chair mueller, if you can stay here

3176
06:10:51,100 --> 06:10:54,100
for a moment, does it have anything in

3177
06:10:54,100 --> 06:10:57,100
that book about charter day?

3178
06:10:57,100 --> 06:10:59,100
>> [inaudible].

3179
06:11:00,100 --> 06:11:04,801
>> but is it included in the history so

3180
06:11:05,100 --> 06:11:07,100
when we have it, we can remember

3181
06:11:07,100 --> 06:11:11,100
that it's a commemoration we need to

3182
06:11:11,100 --> 06:11:12,100
celebrate?

3183
06:11:12,100 --> 06:11:13,100
>> [inaudible]

3184
06:11:13,100 --> 06:11:15,100
>> thank you.

3185
06:11:16,100 --> 06:11:18,100
>> [inaudible].

3186
06:11:34,100 --> 06:11:35,100
>> thank you.

3187
06:11:35,100 --> 06:11:37,100
>> pardon my ignorance, what is

3188
06:11:37,100 --> 06:11:39,100
charter day?

3189
06:11:44,100 --> 06:11:47,601
>> can you come to the microphone.

3190
06:11:48,100 --> 06:11:50,100
>> we have -- I have to go back into

3191
06:11:50,100 --> 06:11:53,100
my boxes and we're reading some

3192
06:11:53,100 --> 06:11:55,100
materials about it but we still don't

3193
06:11:55,100 --> 06:11:58,100
have the exact charter language.

3194
06:12:01,100 --> 06:12:03,100
uc berkeley was the first charter

3195
06:12:03,100 --> 06:12:05,100
school way back and subsequently when

3196
06:12:05,100 --> 06:12:07,100
the schools became real, they had a

3197
06:12:07,100 --> 06:12:11,100
charter and we used to have charter

3198
06:12:11,100 --> 06:12:12,100
days, april 17th which we haven't had

3199
06:12:12,100 --> 06:12:13,100
for a while.

3200
06:12:13,100 --> 06:12:17,100
so, maybe we can resurrect that for

3201
06:12:17,100 --> 06:12:18,100
the 90th, I don't know.

3202
06:12:18,100 --> 06:12:20,100
>> it's kind of like a birthday.

3203
06:12:20,100 --> 06:12:22,100
>> yes, but anyway, as I say, I don't

3204
06:12:22,100 --> 06:12:24,100
want the interrupt the meeting but

3205
06:12:24,100 --> 06:12:28,100
I'll let you one of these, these are

3206
06:12:28,100 --> 06:12:29,100
very informative.

3207
06:12:29,100 --> 06:12:31,100
>> and now we turn to item 10,

3208
06:12:31,100 --> 06:12:32,100
chancellor's report.

3209
06:12:32,100 --> 06:12:35,100
do you have a report?

3210
06:12:37,100 --> 06:12:39,100
>> I know it's late, I wanted to take

3211
06:12:39,100 --> 06:12:41,100
a moment to again thank everyone who

3212
06:12:41,100 --> 06:12:45,100
was a part of last week's commencement.

3213
06:12:45,100 --> 06:12:48,100
there was an incredible commencement

3214
06:12:48,100 --> 06:12:49,100
committee working really hard behind

3215
06:12:49,100 --> 06:12:52,100
the scenes, more than 65 volunteers

3216
06:12:53,100 --> 06:12:55,100
and I was just reminded after

3217
06:12:55,100 --> 06:12:57,100
madeline's comments that we even

3218
06:12:57,100 --> 06:13:01,201
engaged one of our librarians to help

3219
06:13:02,100 --> 06:13:03,100
with the archival information and

3220
06:13:03,100 --> 06:13:05,100
photostats that appear in the

3221
06:13:05,100 --> 06:13:06,100
commencement booklet.

3222
06:13:06,100 --> 06:13:08,100
there were a number of fobs who were a

3223
06:13:08,100 --> 06:13:11,100
a part of the platform party and

3224
06:13:11,100 --> 06:13:13,100
everyone has an interesting role and a

3225
06:13:13,100 --> 06:13:15,100
very diverse real to play, but all of

3226
06:13:15,100 --> 06:13:18,100
that came together to celebrate an

3227
06:13:18,100 --> 06:13:20,100
incredible milestone for our students,

3228
06:13:20,100 --> 06:13:24,100
many of whom it can take many years

3229
06:13:24,100 --> 06:13:27,601
for them to reach that incredible

3230
06:13:29,100 --> 06:13:30,100
achievement, we awarded almost 3

3231
06:13:30,100 --> 06:13:33,100
thousand certificates at this time and

3232
06:13:33,100 --> 06:13:36,100
graduated a little over 500 students

3233
06:13:36,100 --> 06:13:38,100
on thursday and so many thanks again

3234
06:13:38,100 --> 06:13:41,100
to all the folks who played a really

3235
06:13:41,100 --> 06:13:42,100
pivotal role in that.

3236
06:13:42,100 --> 06:13:45,100
it's not just an achievement for the

3237
06:13:45,100 --> 06:13:49,100
students but many of us walk alongside

3238
06:13:49,100 --> 06:13:51,100
those students a long time before

3239
06:13:51,100 --> 06:13:53,100
they're students and until they reach

3240
06:13:53,100 --> 06:13:55,100
this milestone, so it's an achievement

3241
06:13:55,100 --> 06:13:56,100
for the community as well as the

3242
06:13:56,100 --> 06:13:58,100
students, I want to thank everyone for

3243
06:13:58,100 --> 06:14:02,100
that and I also just want to -- I

3244
06:14:02,100 --> 06:14:05,100
don't know if reassure is the right

3245
06:14:05,100 --> 06:14:07,100
word, I'm definitely hearing the

3246
06:14:07,100 --> 06:14:10,100
voices that are speaking about student

3247
06:14:10,100 --> 06:14:12,100
spaces and trying to engage as many

3248
06:14:12,100 --> 06:14:15,601
folks in conversation to address those

3249
06:14:16,100 --> 06:14:18,100
concerns, the thoughts, the ideas that

3250
06:14:18,100 --> 06:14:20,100
are coming forward, so I just wanted

3251
06:14:20,100 --> 06:14:22,100
to again reassure folks that their

3252
06:14:22,100 --> 06:14:25,100
voices are being heard and doing our

3253
06:14:25,100 --> 06:14:28,100
very best to incorporate everyone's

3254
06:14:28,100 --> 06:14:30,100
perspectives as we make

3255
06:14:30,100 --> 06:14:31,100
decisions about moving forward.

3256
06:14:31,100 --> 06:14:33,100
thank you.

3257
06:14:33,100 --> 06:14:35,100
>> thank you.

3258
06:14:37,100 --> 06:14:40,100
>> we're now at presentations and

3259
06:14:40,100 --> 06:14:42,401
discussions, accreditation update a,

3260
06:14:44,100 --> 06:14:47,100
would you lead us off please.

3261
06:14:47,100 --> 06:14:51,100
>> we have avc charles here to prepare

3262
06:14:51,100 --> 06:14:53,100
some details but I know she is not

3263
06:14:53,100 --> 06:14:56,100
feeling well so I have a few

3264
06:14:56,100 --> 06:14:59,100
comments from her if she is not still

3265
06:14:59,100 --> 06:15:00,100
online.

3266
06:15:00,100 --> 06:15:01,100
she wanted to -- is she?

3267
06:15:01,100 --> 06:15:02,100
>> I am.

3268
06:15:02,100 --> 06:15:04,401
>> thank you, avc charles.

3269
06:15:08,100 --> 06:15:11,100
>> you do have my written report but I

3270
06:15:11,100 --> 06:15:13,100
would like to highlight that the

3271
06:15:13,100 --> 06:15:14,100
commission is meeting next wednesday

3272
06:15:14,100 --> 06:15:16,100
and thursday, the time has come, it

3273
06:15:16,100 --> 06:15:19,100
felt like forever and now it is almost

3274
06:15:19,100 --> 06:15:20,100
here.

3275
06:15:20,100 --> 06:15:23,100
we are receive their determination

3276
06:15:23,100 --> 06:15:25,100
regarding our sanction within 30 days

3277
06:15:25,100 --> 06:15:29,100
of that meeting, so we will know soon.

3278
06:15:29,100 --> 06:15:31,100
and then I would also like to

3279
06:15:31,100 --> 06:15:33,100
highlight that whatever the commission

3280
06:15:33,100 --> 06:15:36,100
decides as we all know, we need to

3281
06:15:36,100 --> 06:15:39,601
base our budget decisions on realistic

3282
06:15:40,100 --> 06:15:42,401
assumptions about enrollment, revenue

3283
06:15:43,100 --> 06:15:45,100
and expenditures to ensure that we

3284
06:15:45,100 --> 06:15:47,100
have solid financial footing from here

3285
06:15:47,100 --> 06:15:51,100
on out and I know -- we all know that

3286
06:15:51,100 --> 06:15:53,100
but it's worth saying again and again.

3287
06:15:53,100 --> 06:15:55,100
happy to answer any questions,

3288
06:15:55,100 --> 06:15:57,100
otherwise, also happy to have you move

3289
06:15:57,100 --> 06:15:59,100
on so you can finish your meeting soon.

3290
06:15:59,100 --> 06:16:02,100
>> thank you, trustees, any questions?

3291
06:16:04,100 --> 06:16:06,100
I don't see any questions.

3292
06:16:06,100 --> 06:16:08,100
thank you for signing on when you're

3293
06:16:08,100 --> 06:16:09,100
not feeling well.

3294
06:16:09,100 --> 06:16:11,100
we all wish you good health.

3295
06:16:11,100 --> 06:16:13,100
>> thank you so much.

3296
06:16:13,100 --> 06:16:15,401
I really appreciate that.

3297
06:16:16,100 --> 06:16:19,100
>> and let's move now to the budget

3298
06:16:19,100 --> 06:16:20,100
update.

3299
06:16:20,100 --> 06:16:22,100
item 12.

3300
06:16:26,100 --> 06:16:28,401
>> thank you, president martinez,

3301
06:16:31,100 --> 06:16:33,100
trustees, colleagues, here and online,

3302
06:16:33,100 --> 06:16:37,100
the first item is our 311q which is

3303
06:16:37,100 --> 06:16:39,100
the third quarter report that we file

3304
06:16:39,100 --> 06:16:42,100
with the state and it's really an

3305
06:16:42,100 --> 06:16:44,100
alignment of what you previously saw

3306
06:16:44,100 --> 06:16:46,401
in our monthly financials.

3307
06:16:48,100 --> 06:16:51,100
the revenues are tracking as expected.

3308
06:16:51,100 --> 06:16:54,100
a little bit low because this is for

3309
06:16:54,100 --> 06:16:56,100
the month ended march so we don't see

3310
06:16:56,100 --> 06:16:58,100
all of our property taxes as well as

3311
06:16:58,100 --> 06:17:00,100
parcel taxes in there which you will

3312
06:17:00,100 --> 06:17:04,100
see in the next report which is the

3313
06:17:04,100 --> 06:17:06,100
april monthly.

3314
06:17:06,100 --> 06:17:07,100
the expenditures and we're trying

3315
06:17:07,100 --> 06:17:10,100
to align that, the current process as

3316
06:17:10,100 --> 06:17:13,100
it's employed here at city college is

3317
06:17:13,100 --> 06:17:16,100
that we don't do the adjustments for

3318
06:17:16,100 --> 06:17:17,100
the parcel tax until the end of the

3319
06:17:17,100 --> 06:17:19,100
year, so hence the quarterly reports

3320
06:17:19,100 --> 06:17:22,100
we send to the chancellor's office

3321
06:17:22,100 --> 06:17:24,100
include the parcel tax expense which

3322
06:17:24,100 --> 06:17:27,100
at the end of the year, we transfer to

3323
06:17:27,100 --> 06:17:29,100
the parcel tax.

3324
06:17:29,100 --> 06:17:31,100
in the future, we're going to set it

3325
06:17:31,100 --> 06:17:33,100
up right from the beginning of the

3326
06:17:33,100 --> 06:17:36,100
fiscal year so that the 311 will align

3327
06:17:36,100 --> 06:17:38,401
with the monthly reports.

3328
06:17:40,100 --> 06:17:44,201
everything is tracking as you will see

3329
06:17:47,100 --> 06:17:49,100
will also occur in the april monthly

3330
06:17:49,100 --> 06:17:50,100
financials.

3331
06:17:50,100 --> 06:17:52,100
>> shall we take all the reports and

3332
06:17:52,100 --> 06:17:53,100
then --

3333
06:17:53,100 --> 06:17:55,100
>> yes, that would be good.

3334
06:17:55,100 --> 06:17:58,601
the next item is the monthly

3335
06:18:00,100 --> 06:18:03,100
financials, so the end of april, and

3336
06:18:03,100 --> 06:18:07,100
here we do include and have received

3337
06:18:07,100 --> 06:18:10,100
the second portion of our property

3338
06:18:10,100 --> 06:18:13,601
taxes, so generally we receive about

3339
06:18:16,100 --> 06:18:19,100
50 plus percent in december, another

3340
06:18:19,100 --> 06:18:22,601
45% in april and then about 5% in

3341
06:18:24,100 --> 06:18:26,100
close-outs in june timeframe.

3342
06:18:26,100 --> 06:18:30,801
so, you see that our revenues are up,

3343
06:18:32,100 --> 06:18:34,100
you'll see that we also received the

3344
06:18:34,100 --> 06:18:37,100
second half of our parcel tax and so

3345
06:18:37,100 --> 06:18:41,201
when you then compare the revenues to

3346
06:18:43,100 --> 06:18:46,601
our expenditures, we see a sizable

3347
06:18:47,100 --> 06:18:49,100
difference between what we brought in

3348
06:18:49,100 --> 06:18:52,100
versus what we're paying out.

3349
06:18:53,100 --> 06:18:55,100
that of course -- the bulk of our

3350
06:18:55,100 --> 06:18:57,100
property taxes of the local monies

3351
06:18:57,100 --> 06:19:01,801
just came in and, you know, we'll now

3352
06:19:02,100 --> 06:19:04,100
just be seining revenues from the

3353
06:19:04,100 --> 06:19:06,100
apportionment so that we'll now just

3354
06:19:06,100 --> 06:19:07,100
be seining revenues from the

3355
06:19:07,100 --> 06:19:09,100
apportionment so that will slow down

3356
06:19:09,100 --> 06:19:10,100
we expect to receive our revenues

3357
06:19:10,100 --> 06:19:13,100
because in the may revise, the

3358
06:19:13,100 --> 06:19:16,100
governor noted he will fully fund the

3359
06:19:16,100 --> 06:19:18,100
scff and then our expenditures will

3360
06:19:18,100 --> 06:19:21,100
continue at the same pace so we still

3361
06:19:21,100 --> 06:19:24,100
expect to be at a surplus which you'll

3362
06:19:24,100 --> 06:19:27,100
see in the following report.

3363
06:19:29,100 --> 06:19:33,201
and so then I'll transition to the

3364
06:19:36,100 --> 06:19:38,100
budget update.

3365
06:19:38,100 --> 06:19:40,100
thank you, shawn.

3366
06:19:41,100 --> 06:19:43,100
or the second slide first, please,

3367
06:19:43,100 --> 06:19:44,100
number 2.

3368
06:19:44,100 --> 06:19:47,100
and this is just to provide some

3369
06:19:47,100 --> 06:19:48,100
context.

3370
06:19:48,100 --> 06:19:51,100
we are presenting to you as per board

3371
06:19:51,100 --> 06:19:53,100
policy what the shape of the tentative

3372
06:19:53,100 --> 06:19:56,100
budge will look like, so this will be

3373
06:19:56,100 --> 06:19:59,100
a very, very preliminary draft report

3374
06:19:59,100 --> 06:20:02,100
just to kind of show where we expect

3375
06:20:02,100 --> 06:20:04,100
to be.

3376
06:20:07,100 --> 06:20:08,100
we will bring a more in-depth

3377
06:20:08,100 --> 06:20:10,100
analysis and discussion and reports to

3378
06:20:10,100 --> 06:20:14,100
you at the june committee of the whole

3379
06:20:14,100 --> 06:20:18,100
meeting and then of course at the

3380
06:20:18,100 --> 06:20:21,100
end of june present to you the

3381
06:20:21,100 --> 06:20:23,100
tentative budget for

3382
06:20:23,100 --> 06:20:26,601
acceptance which will allow them to

3383
06:20:30,100 --> 06:20:33,100
begin spending july 1, what I'll be

3384
06:20:33,100 --> 06:20:34,100
presenting is various scenarios for us

3385
06:20:34,100 --> 06:20:37,100
as an institution to really understand

3386
06:20:37,100 --> 06:20:39,100
the types of decisions we will have to

3387
06:20:39,100 --> 06:20:42,100
make and the potential impact those

3388
06:20:42,100 --> 06:20:46,201
decisions will have in the out years.

3389
06:20:47,100 --> 06:20:49,100
slide number 12 please.

3390
06:20:49,100 --> 06:20:51,100
I'm going to start from the back with

3391
06:20:51,100 --> 06:20:54,601
the assumptions and then walk you

3392
06:20:57,100 --> 06:20:59,100
through the scenarios.

3393
06:21:00,100 --> 06:21:03,100
and so I listed the major assumptions

3394
06:21:03,100 --> 06:21:06,100
here and tried to compile it into one

3395
06:21:06,100 --> 06:21:09,100
sheet rather than listing assumptions

3396
06:21:10,100 --> 06:21:13,100
for each scenario because some of the

3397
06:21:13,100 --> 06:21:17,201
varian -- variance is in those yellow

3398
06:21:19,100 --> 06:21:21,100
line items, we're assuming cola, 2.3%

3399
06:21:21,100 --> 06:21:25,801
of course for upcoming year as per the

3400
06:21:27,100 --> 06:21:28,100
governor's may revise, the following

3401
06:21:28,100 --> 06:21:31,100
numbers are really the statutory

3402
06:21:31,100 --> 06:21:34,100
increases for the department of finance

3403
06:21:34,100 --> 06:21:37,100
which also was adopted by school

3404
06:21:37,100 --> 06:21:39,100
services and employed by the

3405
06:21:39,100 --> 06:21:40,100
chancellor's office.

3406
06:21:40,100 --> 06:21:44,100
so, I put those in there and they'll

3407
06:21:44,100 --> 06:21:47,601
affect the calculations in the out

3408
06:21:48,100 --> 06:21:49,100
years.

3409
06:21:49,100 --> 06:21:51,100
hold harmless funding will remain at

3410
06:21:51,100 --> 06:21:54,100
the 166.7 million over the next four

3411
06:21:54,100 --> 06:21:55,100
years.

3412
06:21:55,100 --> 06:21:57,100
we will also continue to have to pay

3413
06:21:57,100 --> 06:22:01,100
back that 1.8 million, so we have I

3414
06:22:01,100 --> 06:22:05,100
think five more years, it's going to

3415
06:22:05,100 --> 06:22:08,100
take us 13 years to repay the

3416
06:22:08,100 --> 06:22:10,100
overpayment from

3417
06:22:15,100 --> 06:22:16,100
8 years ago.

3418
06:22:16,100 --> 06:22:19,100
for 25-26, we did not include the

3419
06:22:19,100 --> 06:22:21,100
deficit factor because that's also was

3420
06:22:21,100 --> 06:22:24,601
outlined in the governor's may revise

3421
06:22:29,100 --> 06:22:31,100
he will fully fund the scff.

3422
06:22:31,100 --> 06:22:34,100
the state of the state, the state of

3423
06:22:34,100 --> 06:22:37,100
the nation and of course we'll have a

3424
06:22:37,100 --> 06:22:41,100
new governor in the next 18 months, so

3425
06:22:41,100 --> 06:22:43,100
it's unclear -- I guess there's quite

3426
06:22:43,100 --> 06:22:47,801
a bit of uncertainty so I built a 1.6%

3427
06:22:48,100 --> 06:22:51,100
deficit factor in 26-27 and then the

3428
06:22:51,100 --> 06:22:54,100
following two years as well.

3429
06:22:54,100 --> 06:22:57,601
on the enrollment growth, I examined

3430
06:22:58,100 --> 06:23:01,100
various factors from 3% to 3% year

3431
06:23:03,100 --> 06:23:06,100
over year, to 6% and then 9% and the

3432
06:23:06,100 --> 06:23:09,100
intention really was to see how we

3433
06:23:09,100 --> 06:23:12,100
might be able to optimize the

3434
06:23:12,100 --> 06:23:15,100
restoration authority that ends in

3435
06:23:15,100 --> 06:23:18,100
25-26 and then of course in the

3436
06:23:18,100 --> 06:23:22,100
following year of 26-27 is when the

3437
06:23:22,100 --> 06:23:24,100
growth authority kicks in that limits

3438
06:23:24,100 --> 06:23:28,801
really the amount of ftes that will be

3439
06:23:29,100 --> 06:23:32,100
counted towards the scff for us and

3440
06:23:32,100 --> 06:23:36,201
anything over and above that would be

3441
06:23:38,100 --> 06:23:40,100
unfunded ftes.

3442
06:23:40,100 --> 06:23:44,201
based on the scenarios, I estimated on

3443
06:23:45,100 --> 06:23:48,100
a productivity ratio of 15 which is

3444
06:23:48,100 --> 06:23:51,601
very high for this institution, the

3445
06:23:53,100 --> 06:23:56,100
number of faculty positions required

3446
06:23:56,100 --> 06:24:00,201
to achieve the ftes goals at those

3447
06:24:01,100 --> 06:24:05,100
varying ranges and then I used an

3448
06:24:05,100 --> 06:24:07,401
average adjunct faculty or

3449
06:24:08,100 --> 06:24:11,100
compensation base of 20 thousand, I

3450
06:24:11,100 --> 06:24:12,100
previously talked about 150 thousand

3451
06:24:12,100 --> 06:24:16,201
for full timers but I ratcheted that

3452
06:24:17,100 --> 06:24:19,100
down and to calculate what the

3453
06:24:19,100 --> 06:24:22,601
increased cost might be to really

3454
06:24:24,100 --> 06:24:27,100
achieve the ftes target, additional

3455
06:24:27,100 --> 06:24:29,100
ftes targets.

3456
06:24:29,100 --> 06:24:33,100
15 is probably pretty high and I say

3457
06:24:33,100 --> 06:24:34,100
that because historically our

3458
06:24:34,100 --> 06:24:37,100
institution at least this the last few

3459
06:24:37,100 --> 06:24:40,100
years has only achieved about 13.3.

3460
06:24:41,100 --> 06:24:45,100
so, if I were to bring that down to

3461
06:24:45,100 --> 06:24:48,100
13.5 for example from 15, that would

3462
06:24:48,100 --> 06:24:51,601
add an additional 11% ftef and/or

3463
06:24:54,100 --> 06:24:57,100
result in cost so this is an

3464
06:24:57,100 --> 06:24:59,100
optimistic picture, even with the

3465
06:24:59,100 --> 06:25:01,100
optimistic picture, you can see in the

3466
06:25:01,100 --> 06:25:03,100
scenarios we have a lot of work to do.

3467
06:25:03,100 --> 06:25:06,100
we need to engage in a lot of

3468
06:25:06,100 --> 06:25:08,100
discussions with colleagues in the

3469
06:25:08,100 --> 06:25:12,100
college community to see how we might

3470
06:25:12,100 --> 06:25:14,100
be able to not only optimize

3471
06:25:14,100 --> 06:25:16,100
restoration but of course ultimately

3472
06:25:16,100 --> 06:25:20,201
get us back to more solid financial

3473
06:25:22,100 --> 06:25:24,100
footing.

3474
06:25:24,100 --> 06:25:28,801
I listed for 26-27 the -- at least

3475
06:25:30,100 --> 06:25:32,401
calculated loss incentive funding,

3476
06:25:33,100 --> 06:25:35,100
about 7.3 million, and that will of

3477
06:25:35,100 --> 06:25:38,100
course factor into the minimum funding

3478
06:25:38,100 --> 06:25:41,100
that the state provides us,

3479
06:25:41,100 --> 06:25:43,100
essentially that gap, the hold

3480
06:25:43,100 --> 06:25:45,100
harmless gap.

3481
06:25:48,100 --> 06:25:51,100
the adult education program committed

3482
06:25:52,100 --> 06:25:54,100
1.2 million in additional funding for

3483
06:25:54,100 --> 06:25:58,100
us to put on non-credit courses and

3484
06:25:58,100 --> 06:26:01,100
the 400 thousand is the unrestricted

3485
06:26:01,100 --> 06:26:05,100
match required for us to be able to

3486
06:26:05,100 --> 06:26:08,100
take advantage of categorical funds

3487
06:26:08,100 --> 06:26:10,100
and ftes.

3488
06:26:10,100 --> 06:26:15,401
at this point in time, I have a tbd

3489
06:26:16,100 --> 06:26:19,100
there for seiu non-represented and

3490
06:26:19,100 --> 06:26:21,401
administrative salary increases for

3491
06:26:25,100 --> 06:26:26,100
25-26.

3492
06:26:26,100 --> 06:26:28,100
aft and dcc have settled, this is the

3493
06:26:28,100 --> 06:26:31,601
year of the contract, that's 2% for

3494
06:26:32,100 --> 06:26:33,100
25-26.

3495
06:26:33,100 --> 06:26:37,801
in the out years, I didn't put any

3496
06:26:38,100 --> 06:26:40,100
salary increases to again highlight

3497
06:26:40,100 --> 06:26:43,601
the impact of certain decisions we're

3498
06:26:46,100 --> 06:26:47,100
going to make, obviously we'll be

3499
06:26:47,100 --> 06:26:48,100
working on that in the out years,

3500
06:26:48,100 --> 06:26:49,100
particularly since we know the

3501
06:26:49,100 --> 06:26:53,100
contracts are going to renew next year.

3502
06:26:53,100 --> 06:26:57,201
I listed again some of the major

3503
06:26:58,100 --> 06:27:01,601
increases, health and welfare, we have

3504
06:27:03,100 --> 06:27:06,100
a rate of about 5.8% and that's sort

3505
06:27:06,100 --> 06:27:09,100
of like a combo rate because our

3506
06:27:09,100 --> 06:27:11,100
health plans renew calendar year

3507
06:27:11,100 --> 06:27:14,100
based, so half the rate is associated

3508
06:27:14,100 --> 06:27:16,100
with the previous year and then the

3509
06:27:16,100 --> 06:27:19,100
second half is with the new year or

3510
06:27:19,100 --> 06:27:21,100
new rate increase.

3511
06:27:28,100 --> 06:27:31,100
the biggest item was the increases in

3512
06:27:31,100 --> 06:27:33,100
the utility, it's stepping down to

3513
06:27:33,100 --> 06:27:35,100
just under 16 to get back to 11, I

3514
06:27:35,100 --> 06:27:39,100
think that was the attempt of sfpuc to

3515
06:27:39,100 --> 06:27:40,100
get us in alignment institutional

3516
06:27:40,100 --> 06:27:42,100
rates back in alignment with

3517
06:27:42,100 --> 06:27:43,100
commercial rates.

3518
06:27:43,100 --> 06:27:44,100
last year for example, we benefited

3519
06:27:44,100 --> 06:27:47,100
from about a 5.8% rate increase.

3520
06:27:48,100 --> 06:27:52,201
it's still high but -- I listed

3521
06:27:54,100 --> 06:27:56,100
elections every other cycle here and

3522
06:27:56,100 --> 06:27:59,100
the next cycle, you know, there's

3523
06:27:59,100 --> 06:28:02,100
three trustees, three of you going up

3524
06:28:02,100 --> 06:28:05,601
for re-election and two years later,

3525
06:28:06,100 --> 06:28:07,100
four.

3526
06:28:07,100 --> 06:28:09,100
all other operating expenses, we

3527
06:28:09,100 --> 06:28:11,100
pegged at about 2%.

3528
06:28:11,100 --> 06:28:14,601
we did build in contingency for

3529
06:28:15,100 --> 06:28:17,100
retirement incentive and you'll see

3530
06:28:17,100 --> 06:28:20,601
that in some of the scenarios.

3531
06:28:22,100 --> 06:28:24,100
slide number 10 please.

3532
06:28:26,100 --> 06:28:29,601
so, this scenario here, so I'm

3533
06:28:31,100 --> 06:28:34,100
starting really sort of like worst

3534
06:28:34,100 --> 06:28:38,201
case if you will in terms of

3535
06:28:39,100 --> 06:28:40,100
financial picture but perhaps the

3536
06:28:40,100 --> 06:28:43,100
highest case in terms of increasing

3537
06:28:43,100 --> 06:28:46,601
ftes, so this scenario assumes a 9%

3538
06:28:51,100 --> 06:28:53,100
increase for 25-26 to be able to take

3539
06:28:53,100 --> 06:28:55,401
advantage of the restoration.

3540
06:28:58,100 --> 06:29:00,100
we have approximately as of the last

3541
06:29:00,100 --> 06:29:03,100
report from the chancellor's office,

3542
06:29:03,100 --> 06:29:07,201
we had about almost 6 thousand ftes in

3543
06:29:08,100 --> 06:29:11,601
restoration of which about 4300 is in

3544
06:29:13,100 --> 06:29:16,601
the credit side, about 1100 in cdcp

3545
06:29:20,100 --> 06:29:23,601
and about 500 in non-credit and about

3546
06:29:25,100 --> 06:29:28,100
100 in the special admin, so 6

3547
06:29:32,100 --> 06:29:35,100
thousand, the value is about 35 million.

3548
06:29:35,100 --> 06:29:39,100
so, meaning that even if we could do

3549
06:29:39,100 --> 06:29:42,601
9%, that's still a far cry from

3550
06:29:43,100 --> 06:29:45,401
taking advantage of the

3551
06:29:46,100 --> 06:29:47,100
restoration of 6 thousand.

3552
06:29:47,100 --> 06:29:51,100
so, you can see if we were to do that

3553
06:29:51,100 --> 06:29:53,100
in 25-26.

3554
06:29:53,100 --> 06:29:54,100
while that might increase the 01:47:09

3555
06:29:54,100 --> 06:29:56,100
base,

3556
06:29:59,100 --> 06:30:02,601
depending on where the ftes falsest,

3557
06:30:03,000 --> 06:30:05,100
if it's credit, if it's non-credit, we

3558
06:30:05,100 --> 06:30:07,100
will get the full value, but you can

3559
06:30:07,100 --> 06:30:11,100
see that because of the cost, it would

3560
06:30:11,100 --> 06:30:15,801
drive us into a deficit in 25-26 and

3561
06:30:17,100 --> 06:30:20,601
that's at the 15% -- at the 15

3562
06:30:22,100 --> 06:30:23,100
productivity level.

3563
06:30:23,100 --> 06:30:26,100
you know, again, if I were to ratchet

3564
06:30:26,100 --> 06:30:29,100
it down to 13.5 which is more in

3565
06:30:29,100 --> 06:30:32,601
alignment with how we have achieved

3566
06:30:37,100 --> 06:30:40,100
efficiencies, that would add another

3567
06:30:42,100 --> 06:30:43,100
11% to the cost.

3568
06:30:43,100 --> 06:30:46,601
it would be 12 million in additional

3569
06:30:47,100 --> 06:30:48,100
adjunct salary costs.

3570
06:30:48,100 --> 06:30:53,100
and then you can see that by 28-29, we

3571
06:30:53,100 --> 06:30:56,601
will have totally wiped out the

3572
06:30:58,100 --> 06:30:59,100
reserves.

3573
06:30:59,100 --> 06:31:03,201
understand that at this point in time,

3574
06:31:06,100 --> 06:31:10,201
the surplus for 24-25 and the result

3575
06:31:11,100 --> 06:31:13,100
in reserve levels are the best they've

3576
06:31:13,100 --> 06:31:15,100
ever been in the last ten years.

3577
06:31:15,100 --> 06:31:18,100
the flip side of that of course is

3578
06:31:18,100 --> 06:31:21,100
that means that it took us ten years

3579
06:31:21,100 --> 06:31:23,100
to re-establish that.

3580
06:31:23,100 --> 06:31:27,100
so, it wasn't just a few years ago

3581
06:31:27,100 --> 06:31:31,100
that the reserves were so low that the

3582
06:31:31,100 --> 06:31:35,100
district had to take back some of the

3583
06:31:35,100 --> 06:31:36,100
opeb contributions, 21 million, to

3584
06:31:36,100 --> 06:31:39,601
even get above the state chancellor's

3585
06:31:41,100 --> 06:31:44,100
required reserve balance revenue or

3586
06:31:45,100 --> 06:31:46,100
reserves.

3587
06:31:46,100 --> 06:31:48,100
and I mention that because we want to

3588
06:31:48,100 --> 06:31:52,201
be very careful as we step through

3589
06:31:53,100 --> 06:31:54,100
this.

3590
06:31:54,100 --> 06:31:56,100
frankly I think 9% additional growth

3591
06:31:56,100 --> 06:32:00,100
might be very difficult to attain for

3592
06:32:00,100 --> 06:32:03,601
a host of reasons including what's

3593
06:32:04,100 --> 06:32:06,100
happening at sfusd.

3594
06:32:06,100 --> 06:32:09,100
of course besides the additional costs

3595
06:32:09,100 --> 06:32:13,100
and then there may be facilities needs

3596
06:32:13,100 --> 06:32:16,100
that we may not be able to have.

3597
06:32:16,100 --> 06:32:20,801
when I look at our schedule, we are

3598
06:32:21,100 --> 06:32:24,601
completely full between the hours of

3599
06:32:25,100 --> 06:32:28,100
8-1, so, that's the highest demands

3600
06:32:28,100 --> 06:32:30,100
for both faculty and students.

3601
06:32:30,100 --> 06:32:33,100
we have white space if you will after

3602
06:32:33,100 --> 06:32:36,100
1:00 until we begin evening classes,

3603
06:32:37,100 --> 06:32:40,100
but -- so we need the carefully

3604
06:32:40,100 --> 06:32:42,100
examine our schedule to see how we

3605
06:32:42,100 --> 06:32:45,100
might be able to take advantage of the

3606
06:32:45,100 --> 06:32:48,100
time slots and then besides that, are

3607
06:32:48,100 --> 06:32:52,201
we able to attract enough faculty or

3608
06:32:54,100 --> 06:32:57,100
maybe even increase the load for

3609
06:32:57,100 --> 06:33:00,100
adjunct, carefully monitoring that so

3610
06:33:01,100 --> 06:33:05,100
we don't go over 67% and/or maybe

3611
06:33:05,100 --> 06:33:09,100
overload to be able to achieve that.

3612
06:33:09,100 --> 06:33:12,601
this 9% is a very optimistic target

3613
06:33:14,100 --> 06:33:17,601
that has some very serious cost

3614
06:33:19,100 --> 06:33:20,100
consequences.

3615
06:33:20,100 --> 06:33:22,100
slide number 8, please.

3616
06:33:23,100 --> 06:33:27,201
and this one I'm looking at a 6%

3617
06:33:29,100 --> 06:33:33,201
increase in ftes and so that would

3618
06:33:34,100 --> 06:33:37,601
mean about -- on the 15 thousand,

3619
06:33:41,100 --> 06:33:43,100
about 900 ftes.

3620
06:33:43,100 --> 06:33:46,100
the associated cost with that is about

3621
06:33:46,100 --> 06:33:48,401
7.2 million on the adjunct.

3622
06:33:49,100 --> 06:33:53,100
and you could see again that by year

3623
06:33:53,100 --> 06:33:56,601
4, 28-29, if everything else stays the

3624
06:33:58,100 --> 06:34:01,100
same, that again the fund balance will

3625
06:34:01,100 --> 06:34:03,100
be wiped out.

3626
06:34:06,100 --> 06:34:09,100
one of the discussion items at the

3627
06:34:09,100 --> 06:34:11,100
budget committee was, well, perhaps we

3628
06:34:11,100 --> 06:34:16,100
can bump it one time in 25-26 to take

3629
06:34:16,100 --> 06:34:19,100
advantage of the restoration meaning

3630
06:34:19,100 --> 06:34:22,100
that you're going to put on classes

3631
06:34:22,100 --> 06:34:26,100
in 25-26, but then reduce them in

3632
06:34:26,100 --> 06:34:28,100
26-27 just to be able to take

3633
06:34:28,100 --> 06:34:29,100
advantage of the restoration, 01:51:48

3634
06:34:29,100 --> 06:34:31,100
but

3635
06:34:34,100 --> 06:34:37,100
there are serious consequences for

3636
06:34:44,100 --> 06:34:47,601
that, there are ped gsh pedagogical

3637
06:34:50,100 --> 06:34:52,100
impact, if we have to hire people that

3638
06:34:52,100 --> 06:34:55,100
we only hire them basically for one

3639
06:34:55,100 --> 06:34:58,100
fiscal year and then they have to go

3640
06:34:58,100 --> 06:34:59,100
away.

3641
06:34:59,100 --> 06:35:01,100
then you're looking at what is the

3642
06:35:01,100 --> 06:35:04,100
impact on students, so if I have

3643
06:35:04,100 --> 06:35:07,100
additional let's say 900 ftes, let's

3644
06:35:07,100 --> 06:35:10,601
say that translates to 30 section, it

3645
06:35:15,100 --> 06:35:19,201
will be more than that, that's quite

3646
06:35:23,100 --> 06:35:26,100
a number of sessions, if we bump them

3647
06:35:26,100 --> 06:35:28,100
up like that and take them away the

3648
06:35:28,100 --> 06:35:32,801
next year, what's that going to do to

3649
06:35:33,100 --> 06:35:35,100
student completions, to the success

3650
06:35:35,100 --> 06:35:39,801
and for them to be able to attain

3651
06:35:40,100 --> 06:35:42,100
their goal.

3652
06:35:42,100 --> 06:35:45,601
we have to have discussions and

3653
06:35:46,100 --> 06:35:48,100
collaborative kind of discussions and

3654
06:35:48,100 --> 06:35:50,100
be thoughtful on how we're going to

3655
06:35:50,100 --> 06:35:54,100
deploy our resorts so we don't find

3656
06:35:54,100 --> 06:35:56,100
ourselves in three, four years having

3657
06:35:56,100 --> 06:36:01,100
to tap the opeb funds if we can even

3658
06:36:01,100 --> 06:36:03,100
do that at this point in time because

3659
06:36:03,100 --> 06:36:05,100
the opeb funds have grown again but I

3660
06:36:05,100 --> 06:36:07,100
think the trust may not allow us to do

3661
06:36:07,100 --> 06:36:08,100
that in the future.

3662
06:36:08,100 --> 06:36:12,100
I think that was a one-time event last

3663
06:36:12,100 --> 06:36:13,100
time.

3664
06:36:13,100 --> 06:36:15,100
slide 6, please.

3665
06:36:17,100 --> 06:36:21,201
this one just displays what a year

3666
06:36:22,100 --> 06:36:25,100
over year increase -- how that might

3667
06:36:25,100 --> 06:36:26,100
impact our finance system.

3668
06:36:26,100 --> 06:36:29,601
this is 3%, so that's roughly 350 to

3669
06:36:32,100 --> 06:36:35,601
500 every year over the next five

3670
06:36:38,100 --> 06:36:40,100
years and you can see that too

3671
06:36:40,100 --> 06:36:44,100
will wipe out the reserves in four

3672
06:36:44,100 --> 06:36:48,100
years, so again I know that through

3673
06:36:48,100 --> 06:36:49,100
enrollment management, they're working

3674
06:36:49,100 --> 06:36:53,100
up on what the future targets might

3675
06:36:53,100 --> 06:36:54,100
be, ftes goals.

3676
06:36:54,100 --> 06:36:57,100
they're looking at how productivity

3677
06:36:57,100 --> 06:37:00,100
might be increased by assigning

3678
06:37:02,100 --> 06:37:04,100
classes with students to larger

3679
06:37:04,100 --> 06:37:06,100
classrooms rather than putting them

3680
06:37:06,100 --> 06:37:07,100
into classrooms that limit the seats.

3681
06:37:07,100 --> 06:37:11,201
there's also -- we're looking at for

3682
06:37:15,100 --> 06:37:18,100
example as I mentioned using

3683
06:37:19,100 --> 06:37:20,100
categorical funds.

3684
06:37:20,100 --> 06:37:23,100
the chancellor's office is beginning

3685
06:37:23,100 --> 06:37:26,100
-- yeah, they have begun to mandate

3686
06:37:26,100 --> 06:37:29,100
the change in the methodology as to

3687
06:37:29,100 --> 06:37:31,100
how we account for our ftes and it is

3688
06:37:31,100 --> 06:37:33,100
going to be required by next year.

3689
06:37:33,100 --> 06:37:36,100
my estimate is just by us changing

3690
06:37:36,100 --> 06:37:39,100
that, that we might be able increase

3691
06:37:39,100 --> 06:37:42,601
our ftes by maybe 1 to maybe 1.5

3692
06:37:47,100 --> 06:37:49,100
percent, when you look at a whole

3693
06:37:49,100 --> 06:37:51,100
host of these things, we might be able

3694
06:37:51,100 --> 06:37:53,100
to -- at least in this coming year,

3695
06:37:53,100 --> 06:37:56,100
25-26, not only meet the 3% but

3696
06:37:56,100 --> 06:37:59,100
perhaps meet the stretch goal of 5%.

3697
06:37:59,100 --> 06:38:01,100
certainly as we go into the out years,

3698
06:38:01,100 --> 06:38:03,100
you want to seriously consider how we

3699
06:38:03,100 --> 06:38:07,100
continue that, it can't be just ftes

3700
06:38:07,100 --> 06:38:09,100
growth, it has to be a combination of

3701
06:38:09,100 --> 06:38:11,100
things but also a lot of focus on

3702
06:38:11,100 --> 06:38:14,601
expenditure reductions to be able to

3703
06:38:15,100 --> 06:38:17,401
maintain that fiscal stability.

3704
06:38:18,100 --> 06:38:20,100
slide 4, please.

3705
06:38:23,100 --> 06:38:26,100
and this slide 4 is the 3% growth

3706
06:38:26,100 --> 06:38:30,100
that we built into the budget for

3707
06:38:30,100 --> 06:38:33,100
25-26, that's also in alignment with

3708
06:38:33,100 --> 06:38:35,401
enrollment management targets for

3709
06:38:38,100 --> 06:38:39,100
25-26.

3710
06:38:39,100 --> 06:38:41,100
when implemented and this is really

3711
06:38:41,100 --> 06:38:44,100
the one that we propose to move

3712
06:38:44,100 --> 06:38:45,100
forward with, with this particular

3713
06:38:45,100 --> 06:38:49,201
one, at least in the preliminary draft

3714
06:38:52,100 --> 06:38:53,100
is a small surplus but even with this,

3715
06:38:53,100 --> 06:38:56,100
you know, we project that if

3716
06:38:56,100 --> 06:38:58,100
everything else stays even, because

3717
06:38:58,100 --> 06:39:01,100
our top line revenues will stay the

3718
06:39:01,100 --> 06:39:04,100
same, we're going to see column

3719
06:39:04,100 --> 06:39:07,100
movement, we're going to see increases

3720
06:39:07,100 --> 06:39:10,100
in major accounts like health and

3721
06:39:10,100 --> 06:39:13,100
welfare, increases in utilities, that

3722
06:39:14,100 --> 06:39:18,801
by next year, it's going to drive us

3723
06:39:20,100 --> 06:39:22,100
negative, 2.2 million deficit and then

3724
06:39:22,100 --> 06:39:25,100
of course the number gets larger in

3725
06:39:25,100 --> 06:39:26,100
the out years.

3726
06:39:26,100 --> 06:39:31,100
so, we have a lot of work to do and

3727
06:39:31,100 --> 06:39:35,100
that factors in that contingency for a

3728
06:39:35,100 --> 06:39:37,100
retirement incentive where we budgeted

3729
06:39:37,100 --> 06:39:39,401
approximately 25 thousand dollars for

3730
06:39:40,100 --> 06:39:43,601
about 50 positions, we're going to be

3731
06:39:44,100 --> 06:39:47,100
able to attract 50 retirees, it's

3732
06:39:50,100 --> 06:39:53,100
really not certain at this point.

3733
06:39:53,100 --> 06:39:56,601
I think traditionally we've seen about

3734
06:39:58,100 --> 06:40:00,100
20-25 positions or so retire from the

3735
06:40:00,100 --> 06:40:02,100
college on an annual basis.

3736
06:40:02,100 --> 06:40:04,100
if that's the case, we might be able

3737
06:40:04,100 --> 06:40:08,201
to take advantage of that and then

3738
06:40:09,100 --> 06:40:11,100
hopefully take that contingent forward

3739
06:40:11,100 --> 06:40:15,100
into the out years to then again try

3740
06:40:15,100 --> 06:40:17,401
to attract additional retirements.

3741
06:40:19,100 --> 06:40:21,100
if we can lower the head counts

3742
06:40:21,100 --> 06:40:24,100
through attrition like that, I think

3743
06:40:24,100 --> 06:40:27,100
that would certainly help us in terms

3744
06:40:27,100 --> 06:40:30,100
of someone made a comment earlier that

3745
06:40:30,100 --> 06:40:32,100
I think -- was it early, maybe it was

3746
06:40:32,100 --> 06:40:34,100
the budget committee that we have fo

3747
06:40:34,100 --> 06:40:35,100
structural deficit.

3748
06:40:35,100 --> 06:40:37,100
that's far from it.

3749
06:40:37,100 --> 06:40:40,100
when you look for example and I define

3750
06:40:40,100 --> 06:40:43,601
the structural imbalance or really as

3751
06:40:44,100 --> 06:40:46,100
our percentage of compensation to

3752
06:40:46,100 --> 06:40:49,601
either expenditure or revenues, and I

3753
06:40:50,100 --> 06:40:52,100
think I shared these statistics

3754
06:40:52,100 --> 06:40:54,100
before, the chancellor's office did a

3755
06:40:54,100 --> 06:40:58,201
study just for us where they compared

3756
06:40:59,100 --> 06:41:01,100
our compensation on the unrestricted

3757
06:41:01,100 --> 06:41:05,100
general fund to the general fund in

3758
06:41:05,100 --> 06:41:07,100
comparison to statewide averages, so

3759
06:41:07,100 --> 06:41:10,100
in the unrestricted, we're running

3760
06:41:12,100 --> 06:41:15,100
about 88-89%, statewide average is about

3761
06:41:15,100 --> 06:41:16,100
87%.

3762
06:41:16,100 --> 06:41:17,100
when it comes to the general fund,

3763
06:41:17,100 --> 06:41:20,100
we're running about 90 and the

3764
06:41:23,100 --> 06:41:24,100
statewide average is about in the low

3765
06:41:24,100 --> 06:41:28,100
80's, like 80 -- I think it was 82-83,

3766
06:41:28,100 --> 06:41:29,100
so that's not sustainable.

3767
06:41:29,100 --> 06:41:32,100
we need to be able to shift from

3768
06:41:32,100 --> 06:41:35,601
really the compensation area into the

3769
06:41:36,100 --> 06:41:39,100
non-personnel area to effect a lower

3770
06:41:39,100 --> 06:41:41,100
percentage of compensation to total

3771
06:41:41,100 --> 06:41:44,100
expense and/or total revenues.

3772
06:41:44,100 --> 06:41:48,201
so, this scenario here is what we

3773
06:41:49,100 --> 06:41:53,100
would likely come back with in more

3774
06:41:53,100 --> 06:41:56,100
details at the june committee of the

3775
06:41:56,100 --> 06:41:59,100
whole meeting and go over this in

3776
06:41:59,100 --> 06:42:03,100
depth and I would like to at that time

3777
06:42:03,100 --> 06:42:06,100
discuss in further detail the

3778
06:42:06,100 --> 06:42:08,100
restoration versus growth authority

3779
06:42:08,100 --> 06:42:12,801
and the impact on our budgets and then

3780
06:42:16,100 --> 06:42:20,100
of course then bring to you a

3781
06:42:20,100 --> 06:42:23,100
tentative budget for acceptance at the

3782
06:42:23,100 --> 06:42:26,100
end of the june meeting.

3783
06:42:27,100 --> 06:42:31,801
so, really this is sort of the next

3784
06:42:32,100 --> 06:42:36,100
steps placed in the context early on,

3785
06:42:36,100 --> 06:42:39,100
right, that's meet with not only --

3786
06:42:39,100 --> 06:42:41,100
well, begin the meeting with our budge

3787
06:42:41,100 --> 06:42:44,100
committee, we have a special meeting

3788
06:42:44,100 --> 06:42:46,100
set for tuesday the 10th, so two days

3789
06:42:46,100 --> 06:42:49,100
prior to the meeting -- the committee

3790
06:42:49,100 --> 06:42:51,100
meeting of the whole, so that they

3791
06:42:51,100 --> 06:42:53,401
will have additional input.

3792
06:42:55,100 --> 06:42:57,100
we scheduled two additional meetings

3793
06:42:57,100 --> 06:42:59,100
so they could continue to participate

3794
06:42:59,100 --> 06:43:00,100
in the budget development.

3795
06:43:00,100 --> 06:43:03,100
I know last year the meetings were

3796
06:43:03,100 --> 06:43:04,100
cancelled.

3797
06:43:04,100 --> 06:43:06,100
I don't think that served us well as

3798
06:43:06,100 --> 06:43:08,100
an institution, we want to highly

3799
06:43:08,100 --> 06:43:09,100
encourage our budget committee members

3800
06:43:09,100 --> 06:43:12,100
to meet during the summer.

3801
06:43:13,100 --> 06:43:16,100
during the committee of the whole

3802
06:43:16,100 --> 06:43:18,100
meeting, we'll hopefully be able to

3803
06:43:18,100 --> 06:43:21,100
flush out in much greater detail this

3804
06:43:21,100 --> 06:43:24,100
framework of going towards fiscal

3805
06:43:25,100 --> 06:43:28,100
stability and it will be closely tied

3806
06:43:28,100 --> 06:43:31,100
to our program review including

3807
06:43:33,100 --> 06:43:35,100
vitalization or revitalization

3808
06:43:39,100 --> 06:43:40,100
criteria.

3809
06:43:40,100 --> 06:43:44,100
and then as I said, we'll hopefully be

3810
06:43:44,100 --> 06:43:45,100
able to finalize that and bring to you

3811
06:43:45,100 --> 06:43:49,201
at the end of june the tentative

3812
06:43:51,100 --> 06:43:52,100
budget.

3813
06:43:52,100 --> 06:43:55,100
with that, I'm certainly open to your

3814
06:43:55,100 --> 06:43:56,100
questions.

3815
06:43:56,100 --> 06:43:57,100
>> it's 11:00, we need a motion to

3816
06:43:57,100 --> 06:43:58,100
extend the meeting.

3817
06:43:58,100 --> 06:44:01,100
I move we extend the meeting until

3818
06:44:01,100 --> 06:44:02,100
midnight.

3819
06:44:02,100 --> 06:44:03,100
>> thank you, is there a second?

3820
06:44:03,100 --> 06:44:04,100
>> second.

3821
06:44:04,100 --> 06:44:07,100
>> moved by trustee -- vice-president

3822
06:44:07,100 --> 06:44:10,100
zamora, seconded by trustee chung.

3823
06:44:12,100 --> 06:44:13,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

3824
06:44:13,100 --> 06:44:14,100
advisory vote?

3825
06:44:14,100 --> 06:44:15,100
>> aye.

3826
06:44:15,100 --> 06:44:16,100
>> president martinez?

3827
06:44:16,100 --> 06:44:17,100
>> yes.

3828
06:44:17,100 --> 06:44:18,100
>> vice-president zamora?

3829
06:44:18,100 --> 06:44:20,100
>> aye.

3830
06:44:22,100 --> 06:44:23,100
>> trustee chisti?

3831
06:44:23,100 --> 06:44:24,100
>> aye.

3832
06:44:24,100 --> 06:44:25,100
>> trustee wong?

3833
06:44:25,100 --> 06:44:26,100
>> yes.

3834
06:44:26,100 --> 06:44:27,100
>> trustee solomon?

3835
06:44:27,100 --> 06:44:28,100
>> sure.

3836
06:44:28,100 --> 06:44:29,100
>> trustee chung?

3837
06:44:29,100 --> 06:44:30,100
>> aye.

3838
06:44:30,100 --> 06:44:31,100
>> trustee mccarty?

3839
06:44:31,100 --> 06:44:32,100
>> aye.

3840
06:44:32,100 --> 06:44:33,100
>> the motion passes.

3841
06:44:33,100 --> 06:44:35,100
>> thank you.

3842
06:44:35,100 --> 06:44:38,100
>> so, we are now at the point where

3843
06:44:38,100 --> 06:44:41,100
we can have trustee questions or

3844
06:44:41,100 --> 06:44:42,100
comments.

3845
06:44:42,100 --> 06:44:43,100
trustee, any questions or comments?

3846
06:44:43,100 --> 06:44:45,100
trustee chung?

3847
06:44:47,100 --> 06:44:51,201
>> I want to thank vc ligoso for

3848
06:44:52,100 --> 06:44:56,801
taking on our input and also the work

3849
06:44:57,100 --> 06:44:59,100
that obviously got us to the plan

3850
06:44:59,100 --> 06:45:02,100
of the collective vision of growing

3851
06:45:02,100 --> 06:45:04,100
and thank you for hearing us out on

3852
06:45:04,100 --> 06:45:07,100
the idea of taking advantage the

3853
06:45:07,100 --> 06:45:08,100
restoration authority.

3854
06:45:08,100 --> 06:45:12,100
I think the piece that I imagine all

3855
06:45:12,100 --> 06:45:14,100
our trustees are agreeing to is we

3856
06:45:14,100 --> 06:45:17,100
want a balanced budge so the matter

3857
06:45:17,100 --> 06:45:20,100
is, you know, and I think this was

3858
06:45:20,100 --> 06:45:23,100
somewhat flushed out in a little bit

3859
06:45:23,100 --> 06:45:26,601
more detail in the enrollment packet,

3860
06:45:30,100 --> 06:45:31,100
the strategic enrollment management

3861
06:45:31,100 --> 06:45:35,801
scenario for how to do this but I

3862
06:45:38,100 --> 06:45:42,801
think there is -- you know, -- there

3863
06:45:44,100 --> 06:45:47,100
has to be a way for us, we've been

3864
06:45:47,100 --> 06:45:48,100
doing it for a long time, there has to

3865
06:45:48,100 --> 06:45:52,100
be a way for us still to be

3866
06:45:52,100 --> 06:45:55,100
innovative, for example, when you

3867
06:45:55,100 --> 06:45:58,100
joined our college, you corrected

3868
06:45:58,100 --> 06:46:00,100
something that we've been banging our

3869
06:46:00,100 --> 06:46:02,100
heads on the wall about, about how so

3870
06:46:02,100 --> 06:46:07,100
much of the funding -- so much of the

3871
06:46:07,100 --> 06:46:10,100
expenditures that came out of

3872
06:46:10,100 --> 06:46:12,100
unexpended fund didn't need to come

3873
06:46:12,100 --> 06:46:16,201
out of there, they come out of

3874
06:46:20,100 --> 06:46:22,100
uncategorical funds, we have to bolster

3875
06:46:22,100 --> 06:46:24,100
revenue for the college, we have

3876
06:46:24,100 --> 06:46:28,100
to do it through free city, through

3877
06:46:28,100 --> 06:46:31,100
fundraising because it's not okay to

3878
06:46:31,100 --> 06:46:35,801
balance our budget on the backs of our

3879
06:46:38,100 --> 06:46:39,100
workers.

3880
06:46:39,100 --> 06:46:41,100
I understand the rationale behind

3881
06:46:41,100 --> 06:46:45,201
using the percentage to -- as one

3882
06:46:47,100 --> 06:46:49,100
method of seining whether or not we

3883
06:46:49,100 --> 06:46:53,801
are sustainable, but it is very -- it

3884
06:46:55,100 --> 06:46:59,100
is a lens has doesn't lend to, one,

3885
06:46:59,100 --> 06:47:02,100
the cost of living here in the city,

3886
06:47:02,100 --> 06:47:05,100
it doesn't lend to what other

3887
06:47:05,100 --> 06:47:07,100
expenditures other districts are

3888
06:47:07,100 --> 06:47:09,100
spending on.

3889
06:47:09,100 --> 06:47:11,100
you know, are they spending it on

3890
06:47:11,100 --> 06:47:13,100
rent, I don't know, I don't know how

3891
06:47:13,100 --> 06:47:15,100
they're getting the percentage they're

3892
06:47:15,100 --> 06:47:18,601
getting to average out to around 80%

3893
06:47:19,100 --> 06:47:22,100
of their expenditures going to

3894
06:47:24,100 --> 06:47:25,100
personnel.

3895
06:47:25,100 --> 06:47:27,100
but I'm hoping

3896
06:47:31,100 --> 06:47:34,100
the plan -- I hope the pgc

3897
06:47:34,100 --> 06:47:36,100
budget committee can meet and

3898
06:47:36,100 --> 06:47:38,100
recommend a plan that is a little bit

3899
06:47:38,100 --> 06:47:41,100
more detailed and bridges that

3900
06:47:42,100 --> 06:47:44,100
strategic enrollment plan and helping

3901
06:47:44,100 --> 06:47:47,100
us understand how we're going to

3902
06:47:47,100 --> 06:47:50,100
balance the budget and as you had

3903
06:47:50,100 --> 06:47:53,100
mentioned where we're relying on the

3904
06:47:53,100 --> 06:47:56,100
academic senate to understand we're

3905
06:47:59,100 --> 06:48:00,100
not compromising on the able for the

3906
06:48:00,100 --> 06:48:03,601
students to complete or to interrupt

3907
06:48:04,100 --> 06:48:07,601
their educational plan but rather in

3908
06:48:09,100 --> 06:48:12,100
the vision of what is -- what are

3909
06:48:12,100 --> 06:48:14,100
those few sections that will help them

3910
06:48:14,100 --> 06:48:17,100
that we can add for that one year,

3911
06:48:17,100 --> 06:48:19,100
which specific strategic sections that

3912
06:48:19,100 --> 06:48:22,100
will have high productivity but will

3913
06:48:22,100 --> 06:48:24,100
also help students finally fulfill the

3914
06:48:24,100 --> 06:48:27,100
rimers they need to continue along

3915
06:48:27,100 --> 06:48:29,100
their educational plan.

3916
06:48:30,100 --> 06:48:33,601
so, thank you for providing these

3917
06:48:34,100 --> 06:48:37,100
scenarios and I look forward to the

3918
06:48:37,100 --> 06:48:41,201
balanced budget we're going to vote on.

3919
06:48:42,100 --> 06:48:44,100
>> vice-president zamora?

3920
06:48:44,100 --> 06:48:46,100
>> thank you.

3921
06:48:47,100 --> 06:48:50,100
just some feedback, thank you, I

3922
06:48:50,100 --> 06:48:51,100
really appreciated seeing the

3923
06:48:51,100 --> 06:48:53,100
different scenarios,

3924
06:48:55,100 --> 06:48:57,100
that was helpful to

3925
06:48:57,100 --> 06:48:59,100
envision some options.

3926
06:49:00,100 --> 06:49:04,201
kind of to trustee chung's point, and

3927
06:49:06,100 --> 06:49:10,201
it just came to me, but the

3928
06:49:11,100 --> 06:49:14,100
restoration authority, I've heard in

3929
06:49:14,100 --> 06:49:17,100
the past that sometimes we plan for a

3930
06:49:17,100 --> 06:49:19,100
particular course for students and

3931
06:49:19,100 --> 06:49:23,100
this is just me repeating what I heard.

3932
06:49:23,100 --> 06:49:27,100
but we don't think out the next class

3933
06:49:27,100 --> 06:49:29,100
so they can't complete whatever it is

3934
06:49:29,100 --> 06:49:33,100
they're trying to do and I'm almost

3935
06:49:33,100 --> 06:49:37,201
wondering if there is a possibility in

3936
06:49:38,100 --> 06:49:40,100
this restoration authority option to

3937
06:49:40,100 --> 06:49:43,601
see if there are particular classes

3938
06:49:46,100 --> 06:49:48,100
that need, maybe not need, but that

3939
06:49:48,100 --> 06:49:50,100
students need to

3940
06:49:51,100 --> 06:49:53,100
complete a certain track and whether

3941
06:49:53,100 --> 06:49:55,100
maybe that's a narrowing of that

3942
06:49:55,100 --> 06:49:56,100
particular option.

3943
06:49:56,100 --> 06:49:58,100
I don't know, I'm just kind of spit

3944
06:49:58,100 --> 06:50:01,100
balling here but it kind of came to

3945
06:50:01,100 --> 06:50:04,601
you as you were mentioning that.

3946
06:50:09,100 --> 06:50:11,100
maybe something that you could look

3947
06:50:11,100 --> 06:50:12,100
into.

3948
06:50:12,100 --> 06:50:14,100
>> other trustees?

3949
06:50:14,100 --> 06:50:16,100
and we'll go to public comments in

3950
06:50:16,100 --> 06:50:17,100
just a moment.

3951
06:50:17,100 --> 06:50:20,100
you mentioned that the pgc budget

3952
06:50:20,100 --> 06:50:21,100
committee will meet in the summer.

3953
06:50:21,100 --> 06:50:23,100
>> yes.

3954
06:50:23,100 --> 06:50:27,100
>> is it possible -- the board usually

3955
06:50:27,100 --> 06:50:30,100
does not meet in the summer in the month

3956
06:50:30,100 --> 06:50:31,100
of july.

3957
06:50:31,100 --> 06:50:35,801
would you let us know as you go

3958
06:50:36,100 --> 06:50:39,100
through this with the pgc committee if

3959
06:50:39,100 --> 06:50:41,100
there are times that it might be

3960
06:50:41,100 --> 06:50:43,100
helpful for the board to meet so we

3961
06:50:43,100 --> 06:50:47,100
can plan our time away efficiently and

3962
06:50:47,100 --> 06:50:50,100
effectively, just in case we need --

3963
06:50:50,100 --> 06:50:52,100
or even in june if we need another

3964
06:50:52,100 --> 06:50:56,201
meeting or two in june, I'm recalling

3965
06:50:58,100 --> 06:51:01,100
how important the budget workshops

3966
06:51:02,100 --> 06:51:03,100
were in our understanding and the

3967
06:51:03,100 --> 06:51:04,100
community's understanding about the

3968
06:51:04,100 --> 06:51:06,100
budget but this is a different

3969
06:51:06,100 --> 06:51:08,100
dimension, this is a dimension about

3970
06:51:08,100 --> 06:51:11,601
how do you do educational planning,

3971
06:51:14,100 --> 06:51:16,100
classes, student support services, so

3972
06:51:16,100 --> 06:51:18,100
that they meet with the budget, so

3973
06:51:18,100 --> 06:51:21,601
that there's an integration of those

3974
06:51:22,100 --> 06:51:24,100
two and I like this because this is a

3975
06:51:24,100 --> 06:51:27,100
first start but that may be something

3976
06:51:27,100 --> 06:51:31,100
that really needs to be flushed out

3977
06:51:31,100 --> 06:51:35,100
so we know that when you're talking

3978
06:51:35,100 --> 06:51:38,601
about ftef, what the strategies are

3979
06:51:41,100 --> 06:51:44,100
that are being talked about in terms

3980
06:51:44,100 --> 06:51:46,100
of the assignment of those

3981
06:51:46,100 --> 06:51:49,601
to certain places because perhaps they

3982
06:51:50,100 --> 06:51:53,100
present more opportunities for growth

3983
06:51:53,100 --> 06:51:57,100
with a lower cost for example, so I'm

3984
06:51:57,100 --> 06:52:00,100
glad this is beginning to happen.

3985
06:52:00,100 --> 06:52:03,100
one of the things that was presented

3986
06:52:03,100 --> 06:52:07,801
to us in a prior presentation was the

3987
06:52:08,100 --> 06:52:10,100
possibility of the district

3988
06:52:10,100 --> 06:52:13,100
reorganization as a cost saving -- to

3989
06:52:13,100 --> 06:52:15,100
find some efficiencies.

3990
06:52:17,100 --> 06:52:20,100
if that is something that is being

3991
06:52:20,100 --> 06:52:24,801
worked on, it would be helpful if as

3992
06:52:27,100 --> 06:52:28,100
the conversations are proceeding, that

3993
06:52:28,100 --> 06:52:31,100
we are kept informed so that we have a

3994
06:52:31,100 --> 06:52:34,100
better understanding and are more

3995
06:52:36,100 --> 06:52:38,100
prepared when things come to us for a

3996
06:52:38,100 --> 06:52:39,100
final recommendation if you would.

3997
06:52:39,100 --> 06:52:41,100
anyone else?

3998
06:52:42,100 --> 06:52:44,100
is there any public comment?

3999
06:52:44,100 --> 06:52:48,100
>> yes, we do, the first one is

4000
06:52:48,100 --> 06:52:50,100
abigail bornstein.

4001
06:52:55,100 --> 06:52:59,201
>> so, when I look at the multiyear

4002
06:53:03,100 --> 06:53:06,100
budget assumptions, I find them

4003
06:53:09,100 --> 06:53:10,100
offensive, I can't describe the

4004
06:53:10,100 --> 06:53:13,100
feeling I have when I look at them, we

4005
06:53:13,100 --> 06:53:16,100
have 380 full time faculty when you

4006
06:53:16,100 --> 06:53:18,100
count this year's resignations and

4007
06:53:18,100 --> 06:53:20,100
retirements, the assumption here will

4008
06:53:20,100 --> 06:53:24,201
bring that count down on to roughly

4009
06:53:25,100 --> 06:53:27,100
300 full time faculty.

4010
06:53:27,100 --> 06:53:31,100
well, at the same bringing the head

4011
06:53:31,100 --> 06:53:34,100
count from roughly 600 to possibly

4012
06:53:34,100 --> 06:53:37,100
over 800 or more, the committee

4013
06:53:37,100 --> 06:53:39,100
work does not decrease, the curriculum

4014
06:53:39,100 --> 06:53:42,100
work does not decrease for full time

4015
06:53:42,100 --> 06:53:44,100
faculty, the workload increases in

4016
06:53:44,100 --> 06:53:46,100
the remaining full time faculty,

4017
06:53:46,100 --> 06:53:48,100
pretending that you can change out a

4018
06:53:48,100 --> 06:53:50,100
full time faculty for two or three

4019
06:53:50,100 --> 06:53:53,100
part time faculty is so very offensive.

4020
06:53:53,100 --> 06:53:55,100
the lack of recognition of the work

4021
06:53:55,100 --> 06:53:58,100
that full time faculty do is out right

4022
06:53:58,100 --> 06:53:59,100
offensive.

4023
06:53:59,100 --> 06:54:02,100
on top of that, full time faculty are

4024
06:54:02,100 --> 06:54:05,100
currently working ot a non-except tif

4025
06:54:05,100 --> 06:54:07,100
wages which are 1500 to 2 thousand

4026
06:54:07,100 --> 06:54:09,401
dollars each mother non-competitive,

4027
06:54:10,100 --> 06:54:11,100
right now, no other employees at this

4028
06:54:11,100 --> 06:54:14,100
school are asked to work at such a

4029
06:54:14,100 --> 06:54:16,100
non-competitive wages.

4030
06:54:16,100 --> 06:54:19,601
then, then we put assumptions down

4031
06:54:20,100 --> 06:54:23,100
showing zero percent for salary

4032
06:54:24,100 --> 06:54:25,100
increases.

4033
06:54:25,100 --> 06:54:26,100
again, offensive.

4034
06:54:26,100 --> 06:54:27,100
if we cannot have all employees

4035
06:54:27,100 --> 06:54:30,100
working with competitive wages and

4036
06:54:31,100 --> 06:54:33,100
within 10-15% of a competitive range

4037
06:54:33,100 --> 06:54:35,100
with everyone, then we have a

4038
06:54:35,100 --> 06:54:37,100
structural problem.

4039
06:54:40,100 --> 06:54:41,100
as long as the spendable reserve

4040
06:54:41,100 --> 06:54:42,100
percentage above 5%, is that going

4041
06:54:42,100 --> 06:54:44,100
to be a passable multiyear budget?

4042
06:54:44,100 --> 06:54:47,100
is that all you're considering?

4043
06:54:48,100 --> 06:54:50,100
accjc is watching this, the state

4044
06:54:50,100 --> 06:54:53,100
financial office is watching this,

4045
06:54:54,100 --> 06:54:56,100
these assumptions cannot stand, we

4046
06:54:56,100 --> 06:54:57,100
cannot continue to treat the full time

4047
06:54:57,100 --> 06:54:59,401
faculty in this offensive,

4048
06:55:00,100 --> 06:55:03,100
disrespectful and a discounted labor

4049
06:55:04,100 --> 06:55:06,100
manner.

4050
06:55:06,100 --> 06:55:07,100
these assumptions are offensive.

4051
06:55:07,100 --> 06:55:09,100
thank you.

4052
06:55:09,100 --> 06:55:11,401
>> next is susana atwood.

4053
06:55:19,100 --> 06:55:22,601
>> susana atwood, there's going to be

4054
06:55:28,100 --> 06:55:31,100
lots of ongoing discussions on all

4055
06:55:31,100 --> 06:55:33,100
these scenarios I think, I think there

4056
06:55:33,100 --> 06:55:35,100
might be missing revenue at the top

4057
06:55:35,100 --> 06:55:37,100
two that's going to make these figures

4058
06:55:37,100 --> 06:55:41,100
look a little bit better, the part

4059
06:55:41,100 --> 06:55:43,100
time faculty, reimbursements and the

4060
06:55:43,100 --> 06:55:47,100
moving other of indirect cost from the

4061
06:55:47,100 --> 06:55:49,100
categorical, there are places that we

4062
06:55:49,100 --> 06:55:51,100
can make this look a little better

4063
06:55:51,100 --> 06:55:53,100
than it is, overall, what I tried to

4064
06:55:53,100 --> 06:55:58,100
do is look at which of the -- the

4065
06:55:58,100 --> 06:56:00,100
fifth scenario is the one that dr.

4066
06:56:00,100 --> 06:56:03,100
ligoso spoke to which is that you just

4067
06:56:03,100 --> 06:56:07,100
go up next year and then down after

4068
06:56:07,100 --> 06:56:08,100
that, back to where you were before,

4069
06:56:08,100 --> 06:56:11,100
there is an inverse relationship

4070
06:56:12,100 --> 06:56:14,100
between which scenario helps narrow

4071
06:56:14,100 --> 06:56:17,100
that gap we're trying to narrow and

4072
06:56:17,100 --> 06:56:19,401
which scenario looks better

4073
06:56:20,100 --> 06:56:22,100
financially.

4074
06:56:24,100 --> 06:56:27,100
that scenario at the back

4075
06:56:27,100 --> 06:56:31,801
of the napkin is the worst ones with

4076
06:56:34,100 --> 06:56:36,100
narrowing the gap but it is similar or

4077
06:56:36,100 --> 06:56:38,100
a bit better in making us look

4078
06:56:38,100 --> 06:56:40,100
financially well.

4079
06:56:41,100 --> 06:56:42,100
I would recommend if you have the time

4080
06:56:42,100 --> 06:56:44,100
and I know you folks have lots of

4081
06:56:44,100 --> 06:56:48,100
things to look at, when the recording

4082
06:56:48,100 --> 06:56:51,100
is up from the pgc budget that

4083
06:56:51,100 --> 06:56:54,100
happened on tuesday, there were

4084
06:56:55,100 --> 06:56:57,100
detailed assumptions for each of these

4085
06:56:57,100 --> 06:56:59,100
four scenarios and I found that more

4086
06:56:59,100 --> 06:57:02,100
helpful to be able to look at what

4087
06:57:02,100 --> 06:57:05,100
each one was but nonetheless, we're

4088
06:57:05,100 --> 06:57:08,100
going to have to have further

4089
06:57:08,100 --> 06:57:11,100
discussions and figure out if there's

4090
06:57:11,100 --> 06:57:13,100
places where we can't find more

4091
06:57:13,100 --> 06:57:17,801
revenue that would apply to all of the

4092
06:57:18,100 --> 06:57:19,100
scenarios.

4093
06:57:19,100 --> 06:57:20,100
after we close the year, we always

4094
06:57:20,100 --> 06:57:23,100
find a little bit, a couple of million

4095
06:57:23,100 --> 06:57:27,801
more, so it will be ongoing and pgc

4096
06:57:28,100 --> 06:57:31,601
budget will be talking about it.

4097
06:57:32,100 --> 06:57:33,100
>> that concludes public comment.

4098
06:57:33,100 --> 06:57:35,401
>> thank you very much.

4099
06:57:38,100 --> 06:57:41,100
are there any -- we went past that,

4100
06:57:41,100 --> 06:57:43,100
the consent items are next.

4101
06:57:43,100 --> 06:57:46,100
are there any public comments on the

4102
06:57:46,100 --> 06:57:48,100
consent items?

4103
06:57:48,100 --> 06:57:50,100
>> yes, we do.

4104
06:57:50,100 --> 06:57:53,100
first one is abigail bornstein.

4105
06:58:01,100 --> 06:58:02,100
>> so, I'm speaking on 15a.

4106
06:58:02,100 --> 06:58:06,801
and I wanted to say that I am

4107
06:58:11,100 --> 06:58:13,401
absolutely all for reopeners.

4108
06:58:14,100 --> 06:58:17,601
I think it's important to have

4109
06:58:18,100 --> 06:58:20,100
reopeners on contracts to maintain

4110
06:58:20,100 --> 06:58:21,100
competitive wages.

4111
06:58:21,100 --> 06:58:25,801
and to keep all the employees within a

4112
06:58:27,100 --> 06:58:28,100
10-15% competitive range of one

4113
06:58:28,100 --> 06:58:29,100
another.

4114
06:58:29,100 --> 06:58:30,100
I think that's important.

4115
06:58:30,100 --> 06:58:33,601
but if we're having reopeners, we're

4116
06:58:35,100 --> 06:58:37,100
making wage decisions based on well

4117
06:58:37,100 --> 06:58:40,100
they got this so we should get that,

4118
06:58:40,100 --> 06:58:42,100
this one got this so I should get

4119
06:58:42,100 --> 06:58:45,100
that, that is not how you handle

4120
06:58:45,100 --> 06:58:46,100
budgets.

4121
06:58:46,100 --> 06:58:49,100
that is not good -- financing, when I

4122
06:58:49,100 --> 06:58:51,100
looked at the chancellor's contract,

4123
06:58:51,100 --> 06:58:54,100
it was like if they get this, I get

4124
06:58:54,100 --> 06:58:55,100
that.

4125
06:58:55,100 --> 06:58:56,100
if they get that, I get this.

4126
06:58:56,100 --> 06:58:59,100
that is not how we should be budgeting.

4127
06:58:59,100 --> 06:59:02,601
we should be looking at competitive

4128
06:59:04,100 --> 06:59:05,100
wages.

4129
06:59:05,100 --> 06:59:07,100
we need tok to be looking at not just

4130
06:59:07,100 --> 06:59:10,100
competitive wages but also within the

4131
06:59:10,100 --> 06:59:11,100
whole school structure that everyone

4132
06:59:11,100 --> 06:59:13,100
has the competitive wages, whatever

4133
06:59:13,100 --> 06:59:17,100
that may be within a 10-15% range and

4134
06:59:17,100 --> 06:59:21,100
that is how we peg these wages.

4135
06:59:21,100 --> 06:59:22,000
I'm also concerned that we're going to

4136
06:59:22,000 --> 06:59:24,100
go into contract negotiations for

4137
06:59:24,100 --> 06:59:26,100
multiple years and we do not have a

4138
06:59:26,100 --> 06:59:28,100
multiyear plan.

4139
06:59:30,100 --> 06:59:33,100
I wanted to point this out is we

4140
06:59:33,100 --> 06:59:35,100
literally did a reopener to say they

4141
06:59:35,100 --> 06:59:39,100
got this so we should get that.

4142
06:59:39,100 --> 06:59:43,100
and we had some pretty big blinders

4143
06:59:43,100 --> 06:59:45,100
because the two years before, we had

4144
06:59:45,100 --> 06:59:47,100
0%, 0% so, the years we chose, but I'm

4145
06:59:47,100 --> 06:59:50,100
just saying in either way, I'm okay

4146
06:59:50,100 --> 06:59:52,100
with the reopener if it has to do with

4147
06:59:52,100 --> 06:59:54,100
competitive wages and also keeping

4148
06:59:54,100 --> 06:59:55,100
everyone within that same range.

4149
06:59:55,100 --> 06:59:58,100
we need to stop doing the this for

4150
06:59:58,100 --> 07:00:00,100
that, I got this, you got that.

4151
07:00:00,100 --> 07:00:03,100
we have to look at competitive wages

4152
07:00:03,100 --> 07:00:04,100
and within the same range.

4153
07:00:04,100 --> 07:00:06,100
thank you.

4154
07:00:07,100 --> 07:00:10,100
>> next is andre spear man.

4155
07:00:15,100 --> 07:00:16,100
>> can you hear me?

4156
07:00:16,100 --> 07:00:17,100
>> yes.

4157
07:00:17,100 --> 07:00:18,100
>> great.

4158
07:00:18,100 --> 07:00:22,100
my name is andre and I'm the field

4159
07:00:22,100 --> 07:00:24,100
representative with seiu, 1021

4160
07:00:25,100 --> 07:00:27,100
working closely with the employees urn

4161
07:00:27,100 --> 07:00:30,100
the leadership of maria salazar-colon.

4162
07:00:34,100 --> 07:00:36,100
we are very excited about the

4163
07:00:36,100 --> 07:00:37,100
possibility that you will follow

4164
07:00:37,100 --> 07:00:39,100
through on the hire og the chancellor

4165
07:00:39,100 --> 07:00:42,100
that everyone seem to be excited

4166
07:00:42,100 --> 07:00:44,100
about, chancellor cortez, I'm sure

4167
07:00:44,100 --> 07:00:46,100
there's things that happened many

4168
07:00:46,100 --> 07:00:48,100
closed session we're not privy too, we

4169
07:00:48,100 --> 07:00:52,100
hope that you will continue on the

4170
07:00:52,100 --> 07:00:53,100
path towards finding a conclusion of

4171
07:00:53,100 --> 07:00:55,100
that contract.

4172
07:00:55,100 --> 07:00:59,100
we are encouraging you to approve our

4173
07:00:59,100 --> 07:01:00,100
contract that's item 15a that's gone

4174
07:01:00,100 --> 07:01:03,100
through the process of negotiations,

4175
07:01:03,100 --> 07:01:07,801
the back and forth and the give and

4176
07:01:09,100 --> 07:01:10,100
take.

4177
07:01:10,100 --> 07:01:11,100
we also encourage the district to take

4178
07:01:11,100 --> 07:01:15,100
a closer look at who they may be using

4179
07:01:15,100 --> 07:01:17,100
as their lead negotiator, we spent

4180
07:01:17,100 --> 07:01:21,100
quite a bit of time explaining things

4181
07:01:21,100 --> 07:01:25,100
that were simple to understand bah the

4182
07:01:25,100 --> 07:01:26,100
lead negotiator seemed to not

4183
07:01:26,100 --> 07:01:30,100
understand it or drag us backwards, so

4184
07:01:30,100 --> 07:01:33,100
we're hoping you'll reconsider who may

4185
07:01:33,100 --> 07:01:36,100
lead you in your negotiations with

4186
07:01:36,100 --> 07:01:37,100
seiu 1021.

4187
07:01:37,100 --> 07:01:41,100
I'm not sure about the other labor

4188
07:01:41,100 --> 07:01:44,100
groups and who they had as their lead

4189
07:01:44,100 --> 07:01:45,100
negotiator.

4190
07:01:45,100 --> 07:01:47,100
we also encourage you to take a look

4191
07:01:47,100 --> 07:01:50,100
at -- as you look at your scenarios,

4192
07:01:50,100 --> 07:01:53,100
also remember that workers have costs

4193
07:01:53,100 --> 07:01:57,201
that are not simply static but are

4194
07:01:59,100 --> 07:02:00,100
subject to scenarios outside their

4195
07:02:00,100 --> 07:02:03,100
control and so we hope that you remain

4196
07:02:03,100 --> 07:02:07,100
competitive as we look at our 25-26

4197
07:02:07,100 --> 07:02:09,100
reopener in terms of the fiscal year

4198
07:02:09,100 --> 07:02:13,100
coming up, so we encourage you to

4199
07:02:13,100 --> 07:02:15,100
engage the classified employees also

4200
07:02:15,100 --> 07:02:17,100
in your scenarios and how best to

4201
07:02:17,100 --> 07:02:20,601
balance the budget and remain fiscally

4202
07:02:21,100 --> 07:02:22,100
responsible and you remain competitive.

4203
07:02:22,100 --> 07:02:24,100
thank you so much.

4204
07:02:24,100 --> 07:02:27,100
>> next is maria salazar colon.

4205
07:02:36,100 --> 07:02:37,100
>> can you guys hear me again?

4206
07:02:37,100 --> 07:02:39,100
>> yes.

4207
07:02:39,100 --> 07:02:42,100
>> so, I'm going to tell you guys

4208
07:02:42,100 --> 07:02:45,100
something, well, for that big mouth

4209
07:02:45,100 --> 07:02:49,100
that's always in there, I really wish

4210
07:02:49,100 --> 07:02:51,401
that colonizer, abigail dumbstein

4211
07:02:52,100 --> 07:02:55,100
will shut her damn mouth and not speak

4212
07:02:55,100 --> 07:02:57,100
on seiu items, we don't need her

4213
07:02:57,100 --> 07:02:59,100
permission when it comes to our

4214
07:02:59,100 --> 07:03:01,100
negotiations but as usual she doesn't

4215
07:03:01,100 --> 07:03:03,100
have a clue and is dumber than a bag

4216
07:03:03,100 --> 07:03:07,100
of rocks and has no place whatsoever

4217
07:03:07,100 --> 07:03:09,401
in our damn business.

4218
07:03:10,100 --> 07:03:12,100
but she continues to have a fixation

4219
07:03:12,100 --> 07:03:16,100
on stirring up her bullshit when it

4220
07:03:16,100 --> 07:03:19,100
comes to seiu, maybe she should go do

4221
07:03:19,100 --> 07:03:23,100
math or maybe shut the fuck up.

4222
07:03:23,100 --> 07:03:26,601
she needs to go focus on

4223
07:03:27,100 --> 07:03:30,100
[inaudible], I'm sick of her

4224
07:03:31,100 --> 07:03:33,100
shit.

4225
07:03:33,100 --> 07:03:35,401
shut the fuck up.

4226
07:03:36,100 --> 07:03:39,601
>> president martinez, we have to be

4227
07:03:40,100 --> 07:03:42,100
mindful of whatever comments are being

4228
07:03:42,100 --> 07:03:43,100
made.

4229
07:03:43,100 --> 07:03:44,100
>> you guys constantly let her and

4230
07:03:44,100 --> 07:03:47,100
other people go up there and attack

4231
07:03:47,100 --> 07:03:49,100
seiu all day every day when it comes

4232
07:03:49,100 --> 07:03:52,100
to these board meetings and nobody

4233
07:03:52,100 --> 07:03:55,100
stops her from saying anything, nobody

4234
07:03:55,100 --> 07:03:59,100
corrects her, I've had enough of it,

4235
07:03:59,100 --> 07:04:00,100
enough.

4236
07:04:00,100 --> 07:04:01,100
I'm serious.

4237
07:04:01,100 --> 07:04:04,100
so, until you guys put her in her

4238
07:04:04,100 --> 07:04:06,100
place or someone has a conversation

4239
07:04:06,100 --> 07:04:10,801
with her, don't tell me how to speak.

4240
07:04:16,100 --> 07:04:17,100
good-bye.

4241
07:04:17,100 --> 07:04:19,401
>> that concludes public comments.

4242
07:04:20,100 --> 07:04:22,100
>> thank you.

4243
07:04:28,100 --> 07:04:30,100
>> does any trustee wish to pull an

4244
07:04:30,100 --> 07:04:32,100
item for discussion and a separate

4245
07:04:32,100 --> 07:04:34,100
vote in the consent items.

4246
07:04:34,100 --> 07:04:36,100
>> president item, there is a an

4247
07:04:36,100 --> 07:04:39,601
item, 14d, that I believe trustee

4248
07:04:40,100 --> 07:04:42,100
wong wants to address.

4249
07:04:42,100 --> 07:04:45,100
>> for 14d, I need that for a

4250
07:04:45,100 --> 07:04:47,100
separate vote so that way I can

4251
07:04:47,100 --> 07:04:49,100
abstain on it, I'm not able to vote

4252
07:04:49,100 --> 07:04:51,100
for that one for obvious reasons.

4253
07:04:51,100 --> 07:04:53,100
>> is that 14d?

4254
07:04:53,100 --> 07:04:55,100
>> 14d.

4255
07:04:55,100 --> 07:04:58,100
>> approval of no contract extension

4256
07:04:58,100 --> 07:05:00,100
with west ed?

4257
07:05:01,100 --> 07:05:03,100
>> no, children's council.

4258
07:05:07,100 --> 07:05:09,100
14e?

4259
07:05:09,100 --> 07:05:11,100
>> 14d.

4260
07:05:12,100 --> 07:05:15,100
>> maybe it got updated because

4261
07:05:16,100 --> 07:05:19,100
sometimes there's a slight change.

4262
07:05:19,100 --> 07:05:23,100
I can move fast so I didn't get to

4263
07:05:23,100 --> 07:05:25,100
thank our finance staff for the

4264
07:05:25,100 --> 07:05:26,100
different scenarios that were

4265
07:05:26,100 --> 07:05:29,100
provided so that way we can see some

4266
07:05:29,100 --> 07:05:31,100
of the potential opportunities and

4267
07:05:31,100 --> 07:05:33,100
challenges that we may face going

4268
07:05:33,100 --> 07:05:36,100
forward and just give us a perspective

4269
07:05:36,100 --> 07:05:40,201
view on what may be forthcoming and

4270
07:05:41,100 --> 07:05:43,100
how we can potentially overcome some

4271
07:05:43,100 --> 07:05:45,100
of those things and I want to comment

4272
07:05:45,100 --> 07:05:49,100
a little bit about the sexier iu

4273
07:05:49,100 --> 07:05:51,100
reopener too, just glad as somebody

4274
07:05:51,100 --> 07:05:54,100
who used to be a field representative,

4275
07:05:54,100 --> 07:05:58,100
I'm glad we're able to have that give

4276
07:05:58,100 --> 07:06:01,100
and take and too bad the process

4277
07:06:01,100 --> 07:06:02,100
didn't move sooner.

4278
07:06:02,100 --> 07:06:06,801
I think a lot of times service sector

4279
07:06:07,100 --> 07:06:11,100
employees do get -- are not fully as

4280
07:06:11,100 --> 07:06:13,100
fully appreciated, when I worked at

4281
07:06:13,100 --> 07:06:17,201
hospitals in san francisco, a lot of

4282
07:06:19,100 --> 07:06:21,100
times the disparity between the

4283
07:06:21,100 --> 07:06:23,100
service sector workers and the other

4284
07:06:23,100 --> 07:06:24,100
staff at the hospital, so I think it

4285
07:06:24,100 --> 07:06:26,100
is important to recognize the

4286
07:06:26,100 --> 07:06:29,100
importance of getting cola increases

4287
07:06:29,100 --> 07:06:31,100
and appropriate cola increases and

4288
07:06:31,100 --> 07:06:33,100
adjustments to them especially as we

4289
07:06:33,100 --> 07:06:37,201
have rising costs of living in the

4290
07:06:39,100 --> 07:06:41,100
city.

4291
07:06:42,100 --> 07:06:43,100
I'll leave it at that.

4292
07:06:43,100 --> 07:06:44,100
>> does anyone wish to push any item

4293
07:06:44,100 --> 07:06:47,601
for a separate discussion and vote?

4294
07:06:48,100 --> 07:06:50,100
trustee chung?

4295
07:06:50,100 --> 07:06:52,100
>> I don't know if it's -- I'm going

4296
07:06:52,100 --> 07:06:55,100
to go in order to make it easier on me

4297
07:06:55,100 --> 07:06:57,100
if that's okay.

4298
07:06:57,100 --> 07:06:59,100
I think 14b, I want to make a comment

4299
07:06:59,100 --> 07:07:03,201
on it, so not a separate vote.

4300
07:07:04,100 --> 07:07:06,401
>> 14 -- say it again.

4301
07:07:07,100 --> 07:07:08,100
>>itis the approval of course and

4302
07:07:08,100 --> 07:07:10,100
program actions recommended by the

4303
07:07:10,100 --> 07:07:11,100
curriculum committee.

4304
07:07:11,100 --> 07:07:13,100
>> can you make that -- we agreed if

4305
07:07:13,100 --> 07:07:15,100
we just want to comment, it might be

4306
07:07:15,100 --> 07:07:16,100
good the put it in a report.

4307
07:07:16,100 --> 07:07:18,100
>> at the end of the meeting?

4308
07:07:18,100 --> 07:07:19,100
>> yeah.

4309
07:07:19,100 --> 07:07:20,100
>> okay, we can absolutely do that.

4310
07:07:20,100 --> 07:07:21,100
>> thank you.

4311
07:07:21,100 --> 07:07:26,401
>> I do want to point -- or I have

4312
07:07:27,100 --> 07:07:30,100
questions about -- sorry, just quickly

4313
07:07:30,100 --> 07:07:32,100
again I'm just scrolling in order, the

4314
07:07:32,100 --> 07:07:36,201
thing that we usually do for employees

4315
07:07:38,100 --> 07:07:40,100
that are retiring and are we also

4316
07:07:40,100 --> 07:07:42,100
doing that in reports?

4317
07:07:42,100 --> 07:07:43,100
we're going to do that in reports,

4318
07:07:43,100 --> 07:07:44,100
okay.

4319
07:07:44,100 --> 07:07:46,100
>> yes.

4320
07:07:47,100 --> 07:07:50,601
>> as usual, I have questions about

4321
07:07:55,100 --> 07:07:58,601
16a, I know you're so excited.

4322
07:08:02,100 --> 07:08:05,601
I also have questions about 17b.

4323
07:08:09,100 --> 07:08:12,100
that's the terracon consultants inc.

4324
07:08:14,100 --> 07:08:15,100
and I have -- 17e, I'm sorry I didn't

4325
07:08:15,100 --> 07:08:19,201
catch this earlier and again thank you

4326
07:08:20,100 --> 07:08:22,100
for avc vasquez for bringing this to

4327
07:08:22,100 --> 07:08:24,100
the committee as a whole by I didn't

4328
07:08:24,100 --> 07:08:27,601
catch it until now, the attachment

4329
07:08:28,100 --> 07:08:31,100
that's attached, the exhibits are

4330
07:08:32,100 --> 07:08:34,100
blank.

4331
07:08:38,100 --> 07:08:41,100
>> okay, are you asking to have these

4332
07:08:41,100 --> 07:08:42,100
pulled or just discussion?

4333
07:08:42,100 --> 07:08:46,100
>> well, I mean, unless we can see the

4334
07:08:46,100 --> 07:08:47,100
contract -- unless that can be pulled

4335
07:08:47,100 --> 07:08:50,100
up on to 17e, I imagine that would

4336
07:08:50,100 --> 07:08:51,100
have to be tabled.

4337
07:08:51,100 --> 07:08:53,100
>> okay.

4338
07:08:54,100 --> 07:08:58,100
well, then let's -- 17e, why don't we

4339
07:08:58,100 --> 07:08:59,100
pull that for discussion.

4340
07:08:59,100 --> 07:09:00,100
>> okay.

4341
07:09:00,100 --> 07:09:01,100
>> and separate vote.

4342
07:09:01,100 --> 07:09:03,100
>> okay.

4343
07:09:04,100 --> 07:09:07,100
>> and 17b, the terracon consultants,

4344
07:09:08,100 --> 07:09:09,100
is that just for --

4345
07:09:09,100 --> 07:09:12,601
>> I have questions, but yes, I'm

4346
07:09:13,100 --> 07:09:14,100
willing to pass it.

4347
07:09:14,100 --> 07:09:15,100
>> that's just for discussion?

4348
07:09:15,100 --> 07:09:16,100
>> yes.

4349
07:09:16,100 --> 07:09:18,401
>> I'm sorry, president martinez,

4350
07:09:21,100 --> 07:09:24,100
anything that -- the consent calendar,

4351
07:09:24,100 --> 07:09:27,100
anything that anyone has discussion or

4352
07:09:27,100 --> 07:09:29,100
questions about should be pulled from

4353
07:09:29,100 --> 07:09:30,100
the consent calendar.

4354
07:09:30,100 --> 07:09:31,100
>> okay, thank you.

4355
07:09:31,100 --> 07:09:34,100
>> the calendar approval is just a

4356
07:09:34,100 --> 07:09:35,100
pro forma approval of the items that

4357
07:09:35,100 --> 07:09:38,100
are there, but if a board member has

4358
07:09:38,100 --> 07:09:40,100
questions about any of those items,

4359
07:09:40,100 --> 07:09:42,100
they really should pull that off the

4360
07:09:42,100 --> 07:09:43,100
consent calendar.

4361
07:09:43,100 --> 07:09:45,100
>> thank you for that correction.

4362
07:09:45,100 --> 07:09:49,100
at one point when we were talking

4363
07:09:49,100 --> 07:09:51,401
about meeting efficiencies, perhaps

4364
07:09:53,100 --> 07:09:55,100
we were guided in the wrong direction

4365
07:09:55,100 --> 07:09:58,100
and being told this is one way of

4366
07:09:58,100 --> 07:10:01,100
doing a meeting efficiency, so we will

4367
07:10:01,100 --> 07:10:02,100
pull these tenses for discussion.

4368
07:10:02,100 --> 07:10:05,100
>> I think that when I hear trustee

4369
07:10:05,100 --> 07:10:09,100
chung saying is a couple of them she

4370
07:10:09,100 --> 07:10:10,100
has comments about which she can make

4371
07:10:10,100 --> 07:10:13,100
in the board report, but --

4372
07:10:13,100 --> 07:10:15,100
>> my pronouns are they/them.

4373
07:10:15,100 --> 07:10:18,100
>> I am so sorry, that was -- it's

4374
07:10:18,100 --> 07:10:21,100
just late and I made a mistake on that.

4375
07:10:21,100 --> 07:10:25,201
but what I heard trustee chung talk

4376
07:10:26,100 --> 07:10:29,100
about is if trustee chung has comments

4377
07:10:29,100 --> 07:10:31,100
about something but not questions, she

4378
07:10:31,100 --> 07:10:35,100
could -- I'm sorry, I'm going to stop

4379
07:10:35,100 --> 07:10:36,100
talking at this point.

4380
07:10:36,100 --> 07:10:39,100
comments could be made in the board

4381
07:10:39,100 --> 07:10:41,100
report but questions about a particular

4382
07:10:41,100 --> 07:10:44,100
item on consent calendar should be

4383
07:10:44,100 --> 07:10:45,100
taken off consent calendar to be

4384
07:10:45,100 --> 07:10:47,100
discussed separately.

4385
07:10:47,100 --> 07:10:50,601
>> so, for 14b, you have questions?

4386
07:10:57,100 --> 07:11:00,100
but you do not want to pull it for a

4387
07:11:00,100 --> 07:11:02,100
separate vote, is that accurate?

4388
07:11:02,100 --> 07:11:04,401
>> yes, that is correct.

4389
07:11:05,100 --> 07:11:07,100
well, no, 14b, I can hold to my report.

4390
07:11:07,100 --> 07:11:08,100
>> okay.

4391
07:11:08,100 --> 07:11:09,100
>> but 16a, 17b and 17e.

4392
07:11:09,100 --> 07:11:11,100
>> okay.

4393
07:11:22,100 --> 07:11:23,100
>> for discussion and I guess also a

4394
07:11:23,100 --> 07:11:27,201
separate vote is what I'm hearing from

4395
07:11:29,100 --> 07:11:30,100
counsel.

4396
07:11:30,100 --> 07:11:33,100
>> 16b for discussion and separate

4397
07:11:35,100 --> 07:11:37,100
vote.

4398
07:11:37,100 --> 07:11:39,100
>> 16a, 17b, 17e.

4399
07:11:40,100 --> 07:11:43,601
>> yeah, you're going a little fast,

4400
07:11:44,100 --> 07:11:45,100
sorry, 16a, discussion.

4401
07:11:45,100 --> 07:11:46,100
>> yes.

4402
07:11:46,100 --> 07:11:48,100
>> okay.

4403
07:11:49,100 --> 07:11:50,100
17b, you have questions.

4404
07:11:50,100 --> 07:11:51,100
>> yes.

4405
07:11:51,100 --> 07:11:53,100
>> okay.

4406
07:11:55,100 --> 07:11:58,100
and 16a -- let's go back, discussion

4407
07:11:58,100 --> 07:12:01,601
and separate vote or just discussion?

4408
07:12:04,100 --> 07:12:05,100
>> just discussion.

4409
07:12:05,100 --> 07:12:07,100
>> okay.

4410
07:12:08,100 --> 07:12:11,100
16b, you have just questions.

4411
07:12:12,100 --> 07:12:13,100
so we'll pull that --

4412
07:12:13,100 --> 07:12:17,801
>> no, I heard 16, so just -- so, 16a,

4413
07:12:23,100 --> 07:12:25,100
17b, 17e.

4414
07:12:26,100 --> 07:12:27,100
>> 16a, 17b and --

4415
07:12:27,100 --> 07:12:29,100
>> 17.

4416
07:12:32,100 --> 07:12:36,100
>> I know, 16a, 17b, then you listed

4417
07:12:36,100 --> 07:12:37,100
another one.

4418
07:12:37,100 --> 07:12:38,100
>> and then 17e.

4419
07:12:38,100 --> 07:12:40,100
>> okay.

4420
07:12:40,100 --> 07:12:44,100
so, on each one, let's go through

4421
07:12:44,100 --> 07:12:47,100
slowly, 16a, you want -- you don't

4422
07:12:47,100 --> 07:12:48,100
want a separate vote?

4423
07:12:48,100 --> 07:12:51,100
>> no, I just have questions.

4424
07:12:53,100 --> 07:12:55,100
counsel mentioned if we're discussing

4425
07:12:55,100 --> 07:12:57,100
it, we should pull it out separately

4426
07:12:57,100 --> 07:12:59,100
and vote on it as well.

4427
07:12:59,100 --> 07:13:01,100
>> so it's a discussion and separate vote

4428
07:13:01,100 --> 07:13:03,100
so we'll pull it.

4429
07:13:03,100 --> 07:13:04,100
17b.

4430
07:13:04,100 --> 07:13:05,100
>> correct.

4431
07:13:05,100 --> 07:13:06,100
>> same thing?

4432
07:13:06,100 --> 07:13:09,100
>> yes, let's just do that for all of

4433
07:13:09,100 --> 07:13:10,100
them to follow counsel.

4434
07:13:10,100 --> 07:13:13,100
>> anyone else have anything they want

4435
07:13:13,100 --> 07:13:16,601
to pull for discussion and separate

4436
07:13:17,100 --> 07:13:19,100
vote?

4437
07:13:21,100 --> 07:13:22,100
alright.

4438
07:13:22,100 --> 07:13:26,100
>> madam president, if I make a motion

4439
07:13:26,100 --> 07:13:28,100
that we approve the consent items that

4440
07:13:28,100 --> 07:13:32,100
have not been pulled for discussion, I

4441
07:13:32,100 --> 07:13:36,100
also would like to point out that

4442
07:13:36,100 --> 07:13:38,100
student trustee heather brandt has her

4443
07:13:38,100 --> 07:13:39,100
hand up.

4444
07:13:39,100 --> 07:13:41,100
>> thank you.

4445
07:13:41,100 --> 07:13:43,100
>> my apologies, I don't want to derail

4446
07:13:43,100 --> 07:13:45,100
what we're doing, I'm hoping at some

4447
07:13:45,100 --> 07:13:48,100
point we can take a bile break.

4448
07:13:48,100 --> 07:13:52,100
>> we have a half hour to go but let's

4449
07:13:52,100 --> 07:13:54,100
take a 10 minute bile break and then

4450
07:13:54,100 --> 07:13:57,601
we're going to have to extend.

4451
07:13:58,100 --> 07:14:01,100
is that okay with everybody?

4452
07:14:01,100 --> 07:14:02,100
alright.

4453
07:14:02,100 --> 07:14:04,100
ten minutes.

4454
07:14:04,100 --> 07:14:06,100
( meeting in recess ).

4455
07:22:30,100 --> 07:22:33,100
>> we are back in order.

4456
07:22:33,100 --> 07:22:35,100
hearing no other requests to either

4457
07:22:35,100 --> 07:22:38,601
pull for discussion and separate vote

4458
07:22:39,100 --> 07:22:42,601
or just report in your regular

4459
07:22:44,100 --> 07:22:46,100
reports, let's go ahead and move the

4460
07:22:46,100 --> 07:22:47,100
resolutions, is there a motion to

4461
07:22:47,100 --> 07:22:50,100
approve the resolutions we have not --

4462
07:22:50,100 --> 07:22:51,100
that we have not pulled?

4463
07:22:51,100 --> 07:22:52,100
>> so moved.

4464
07:22:52,100 --> 07:22:53,100
>> second.

4465
07:22:53,100 --> 07:22:54,100
>> thank you.

4466
07:22:54,100 --> 07:22:56,100
roll call vote.

4467
07:22:57,100 --> 07:22:59,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

4468
07:22:59,100 --> 07:23:00,100
advisory vote?

4469
07:23:00,100 --> 07:23:01,100
>> aye.

4470
07:23:01,100 --> 07:23:02,100
>> president martinez?

4471
07:23:02,100 --> 07:23:03,100
>> yes.

4472
07:23:03,100 --> 07:23:04,100
>> vice-president zamora?

4473
07:23:04,100 --> 07:23:05,100
>> aye.

4474
07:23:05,100 --> 07:23:06,100
>> trustee chisti?

4475
07:23:06,100 --> 07:23:07,100
>> aye.

4476
07:23:07,100 --> 07:23:08,100
>> trustee wong?

4477
07:23:08,100 --> 07:23:09,100
>> yes.

4478
07:23:09,100 --> 07:23:10,100
>> trustee solomon?

4479
07:23:10,100 --> 07:23:11,100
>> aye.

4480
07:23:11,100 --> 07:23:12,100
>> trustee chung?

4481
07:23:12,100 --> 07:23:13,100
>> aye.

4482
07:23:13,100 --> 07:23:14,100
>> trustee mccarty?

4483
07:23:14,100 --> 07:23:15,100
>> aye.

4484
07:23:15,100 --> 07:23:16,100
>> the motion passes.

4485
07:23:16,100 --> 07:23:19,100
>> now we'll discuss item 16a,

4486
07:23:23,100 --> 07:23:25,100
trustee chung?

4487
07:23:25,100 --> 07:23:29,100
>> we're going to have a callback to the

4488
07:23:29,100 --> 07:23:31,100
tennis ballets conversation.

4489
07:23:32,100 --> 07:23:35,100
no, and maybe we might not have to

4490
07:23:35,100 --> 07:23:39,801
bother, I don't know if vc ligoso can

4491
07:23:40,100 --> 07:23:42,100
answer this.

4492
07:23:44,100 --> 07:23:47,601
for badminton, the shuttle cox, why

4493
07:23:48,100 --> 07:23:50,100
are they categorical?

4494
07:23:53,100 --> 07:23:56,601
aren't they included with tennis balls?

4495
07:23:57,100 --> 07:24:01,100
the equivalent to -- the shuttle cox

4496
07:24:01,100 --> 07:24:04,100
that badminton team uses or it's on

4497
07:24:04,100 --> 07:24:08,201
here, we can find this, one second.

4498
07:24:10,100 --> 07:24:15,401
yes, in line 54, why is it -- or line

4499
07:24:19,100 --> 07:24:23,100
55, I'm sorry, this is the trouble with --

4500
07:24:23,100 --> 07:24:25,100
it's one of those lines but it

4501
07:24:25,100 --> 07:24:29,100
says, yes, the shuttle cox are for

4502
07:24:29,100 --> 07:24:31,100
badminton team is a categorical, I

4503
07:24:31,100 --> 07:24:35,201
thought that was the whole point about

4504
07:24:37,100 --> 07:24:40,100
the tennis balls that had to be

4505
07:24:40,100 --> 07:24:41,100
unrestricted, the tennis nets were

4506
07:24:41,100 --> 07:24:44,100
categorical but the tennis balls were

4507
07:24:44,100 --> 07:24:45,100
not.

4508
07:24:45,100 --> 07:24:49,100
>> I think one was a supply item

4509
07:24:49,100 --> 07:24:51,100
whereas another one was the equipment

4510
07:24:51,100 --> 07:24:55,201
item, the one was an equipment item

4511
07:24:56,100 --> 07:24:58,100
where the tennis balls was a supply

4512
07:24:58,100 --> 07:25:01,100
item and these badminton items are

4513
07:25:01,100 --> 07:25:05,100
also supply items so they qualify as

4514
07:25:05,100 --> 07:25:07,100
restricted lottery funds and

4515
07:25:07,100 --> 07:25:08,100
instructional supply.

4516
07:25:08,100 --> 07:25:10,100
>> got it.

4517
07:25:10,100 --> 07:25:11,100
okay.

4518
07:25:11,100 --> 07:25:13,100
and then in the unrestricted funds for

4519
07:25:13,100 --> 07:25:18,401
the -- so, I noted a couple of these

4520
07:25:19,100 --> 07:25:23,801
hicks, I'm glad we get catering and we

4521
07:25:24,100 --> 07:25:27,100
feed employees, but there's one item

4522
07:25:27,100 --> 07:25:29,100
that was unrestricted but came

4523
07:25:29,100 --> 07:25:31,100
specifically for -- the catering for

4524
07:25:31,100 --> 07:25:33,100
the summer food program for the

4525
07:25:33,100 --> 07:25:34,100
financial aid office.

4526
07:25:34,100 --> 07:25:37,100
why was that unrestricted instead of

4527
07:25:37,100 --> 07:25:40,100
-- like, is it because the financial

4528
07:25:40,100 --> 07:25:43,100
aid office, nothing funded through the

4529
07:25:43,100 --> 07:25:45,100
financial aid office can be funded

4530
07:25:45,100 --> 07:25:47,100
through anything categorical?

4531
07:25:49,100 --> 07:25:52,100
>> I don't believe the financial aid

4532
07:25:52,100 --> 07:25:54,401
office has any categorical.

4533
07:25:59,100 --> 07:26:02,100
that's really sort of like indirect.

4534
07:26:02,100 --> 07:26:03,100
>> I see.

4535
07:26:03,100 --> 07:26:06,601
>> so, that's presumably why that was

4536
07:26:07,100 --> 07:26:08,100
funded like that.

4537
07:26:08,100 --> 07:26:11,601
>> I see, thank you for that.

4538
07:26:13,100 --> 07:26:15,100
>> I had one more, I should have

4539
07:26:15,100 --> 07:26:17,100
written this down but it will probably

4540
07:26:17,100 --> 07:26:19,100
come to me at the next purchase order,

4541
07:26:19,100 --> 07:26:23,100
thank you so much for answering my

4542
07:26:23,100 --> 07:26:24,100
questions.

4543
07:26:24,100 --> 07:26:26,100
>> yes, vice-president zamora?

4544
07:26:26,100 --> 07:26:30,100
>> I just want to take note that I did

4545
07:26:30,100 --> 07:26:33,100
notice the numbered line items and I

4546
07:26:33,100 --> 07:26:36,601
very much appreciate it, thank you.

4547
07:26:37,100 --> 07:26:38,100
>> yes, trustee chung?

4548
07:26:38,100 --> 07:26:40,100
>> sorry, president martinez, I

4549
07:26:40,100 --> 07:26:42,100
remember it now, it was -- I noticed,

4550
07:26:42,100 --> 07:26:46,100
so when it comes to copies, copying

4551
07:26:46,100 --> 07:26:48,100
paper, when it's a specific

4552
07:26:48,100 --> 07:26:50,100
department, it is able to fund through

4553
07:26:50,100 --> 07:26:53,100
categorical funding but when it's the

4554
07:26:53,100 --> 07:26:55,100
duplicating department, I assume all

4555
07:26:55,100 --> 07:26:57,100
duplications by the department are in

4556
07:26:57,100 --> 07:27:00,601
service to a specific department or

4557
07:27:02,100 --> 07:27:04,100
program, would it not be beneficial to

4558
07:27:04,100 --> 07:27:06,100
be specific and that way we can pay

4559
07:27:06,100 --> 07:27:09,100
for it through categorical funding?

4560
07:27:14,100 --> 07:27:16,100
>> so, generally the institutional

4561
07:27:16,100 --> 07:27:17,100
copying that comes to our copying

4562
07:27:17,100 --> 07:27:20,100
department is funded through u funds,

4563
07:27:20,100 --> 07:27:23,100
some of the categorical may have

4564
07:27:23,100 --> 07:27:26,100
special needs, so hence they purchase

4565
07:27:26,100 --> 07:27:29,100
their own plus there may be available

4566
07:27:29,100 --> 07:27:30,100
funds for them.

4567
07:27:30,100 --> 07:27:32,100
they want to ensure they spend down

4568
07:27:32,100 --> 07:27:34,100
the entire restricted allocation, so

4569
07:27:34,100 --> 07:27:37,100
we don't have any unspent that we have

4570
07:27:37,100 --> 07:27:38,100
to return.

4571
07:27:38,100 --> 07:27:42,100
sometimes they may be special kind of

4572
07:27:42,100 --> 07:27:44,100
paper needs, you know, that we don't

4573
07:27:44,100 --> 07:27:46,100
normally accommodate.

4574
07:27:46,100 --> 07:27:49,100
our general paper that we purchase for

4575
07:27:49,100 --> 07:27:52,100
copying is the 20 pound probably stark

4576
07:27:52,100 --> 07:27:56,100
white kind of paper and that's our

4577
07:27:56,100 --> 07:27:59,100
standard here just for straight

4578
07:27:59,100 --> 07:28:02,100
copying and that's what we supply to

4579
07:28:02,100 --> 07:28:05,100
our user departments but if there is

4580
07:28:05,100 --> 07:28:07,100
special needs and there's categorical

4581
07:28:07,100 --> 07:28:10,100
funds available, then likely they'll

4582
07:28:10,100 --> 07:28:13,100
use that to be able to purchase that.

4583
07:28:13,100 --> 07:28:17,801
>> so, are you ready to move the item?

4584
07:28:19,100 --> 07:28:22,100
>> yes, I'll move item 16a.

4585
07:28:27,100 --> 07:28:28,100
>> I second.

4586
07:28:28,100 --> 07:28:30,100
>> okay.

4587
07:28:31,100 --> 07:28:35,100
let's take the roll call vote on

4588
07:28:35,100 --> 07:28:36,100
that.

4589
07:28:36,100 --> 07:28:38,401
>> student trustee brandt, your

4590
07:28:39,100 --> 07:28:41,100
advisory vote, please.

4591
07:28:41,100 --> 07:28:42,100
>> aye.

4592
07:28:42,100 --> 07:28:43,100
>> president martinez?

4593
07:28:43,100 --> 07:28:44,100
>> yes.

4594
07:28:44,100 --> 07:28:45,100
>> vice-president zamora?

4595
07:28:45,100 --> 07:28:46,100
>> aye.

4596
07:28:46,100 --> 07:28:47,100
>> trustee chisti?

4597
07:28:47,100 --> 07:28:48,100
>> aye.

4598
07:28:48,100 --> 07:28:49,100
>> trustee wong?

4599
07:28:49,100 --> 07:28:51,100
>> yes.

4600
07:28:52,100 --> 07:28:53,100
>> trustee chung?

4601
07:28:53,100 --> 07:28:54,100
>> aye.

4602
07:28:54,100 --> 07:28:55,100
>> trustee mccarty?

4603
07:28:55,100 --> 07:28:56,100
>> aye.

4604
07:28:56,100 --> 07:28:58,100
>> the motion passes.

4605
07:29:00,100 --> 07:29:01,100
item 17b, trustee chung?

4606
07:29:01,100 --> 07:29:05,100
>> yes, and excuse me if I missed any

4607
07:29:05,100 --> 07:29:09,100
detail on this, but there isn't quite

4608
07:29:09,100 --> 07:29:13,201
an explanation for why it's going to

4609
07:29:15,100 --> 07:29:18,601
take longer, why it was originally 22

4610
07:29:19,100 --> 07:29:23,100
months and then -- did I pull the

4611
07:29:23,100 --> 07:29:25,100
right agenda item?

4612
07:29:25,100 --> 07:29:28,601
>> I think the 22 month to additional

4613
07:29:29,100 --> 07:29:31,401
duration is for 17e.

4614
07:29:36,100 --> 07:29:37,100
that is completely correct.

4615
07:29:37,100 --> 07:29:40,100
I did not need to pull this item, I'm

4616
07:29:40,100 --> 07:29:42,100
sorry for that, trustees, my

4617
07:29:42,100 --> 07:29:43,100
colleagues.

4618
07:29:43,100 --> 07:29:45,401
can I move 17b.

4619
07:29:46,100 --> 07:29:47,100
>> is there a second.

4620
07:29:47,100 --> 07:29:48,100
>> second.

4621
07:29:48,100 --> 07:29:49,100
>> okay.

4622
07:29:49,100 --> 07:29:51,100
let's take the vote.

4623
07:29:51,100 --> 07:29:53,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

4624
07:29:53,100 --> 07:29:54,100
advisory vote?

4625
07:29:54,100 --> 07:29:56,100
>> aye.

4626
07:29:57,100 --> 07:29:58,100
>> president martinez?

4627
07:29:58,100 --> 07:29:59,100
>> yes.

4628
07:29:59,100 --> 07:30:00,100
>> vice-president zamora?

4629
07:30:00,100 --> 07:30:01,100
>> aye.

4630
07:30:01,100 --> 07:30:02,100
>> trustee chisti?

4631
07:30:02,100 --> 07:30:03,100
>> aye.

4632
07:30:03,100 --> 07:30:04,100
>> trustee wong?

4633
07:30:04,100 --> 07:30:05,100
>> aye.

4634
07:30:05,100 --> 07:30:06,100
>> trustee solomon?

4635
07:30:06,100 --> 07:30:07,100
>> yes.

4636
07:30:07,100 --> 07:30:08,100
>> trustee chung?

4637
07:30:08,100 --> 07:30:09,100
>> aye.

4638
07:30:09,100 --> 07:30:10,100
>> trustee mccarty?

4639
07:30:10,100 --> 07:30:11,100
>> aye.

4640
07:30:11,100 --> 07:30:12,100
>> the motion passes.

4641
07:30:12,100 --> 07:30:13,100
>> 17e.

4642
07:30:13,100 --> 07:30:16,601
>> returning to you, avc vasquez, so

4643
07:30:17,100 --> 07:30:18,100
--

4644
07:30:18,100 --> 07:30:19,100
>> go ahead, please ask your question.

4645
07:30:19,100 --> 07:30:23,201
>> yes, so I was wondering why the

4646
07:30:26,100 --> 07:30:29,100
construction -- the second piece of the

4647
07:30:29,100 --> 07:30:33,100
project is taking -- or I guess in

4648
07:30:33,100 --> 07:30:35,100
totally, the original contract was 22

4649
07:30:35,100 --> 07:30:38,601
months and now it's 30 months and

4650
07:30:39,100 --> 07:30:41,100
could you provide a little bit more of

4651
07:30:41,100 --> 07:30:43,100
an explanation for that.

4652
07:30:43,100 --> 07:30:47,100
>> yes, so, on the first part under

4653
07:30:47,100 --> 07:30:50,100
the bold authorization, there's a one

4654
07:30:50,100 --> 07:30:53,100
and a two, when we made the

4655
07:30:53,100 --> 07:30:55,100
selection rudolph and sletten, there

4656
07:30:55,100 --> 07:30:58,100
were two contracts we were going to

4657
07:30:58,100 --> 07:31:01,100
go into is, one was going to be a

4658
07:31:01,100 --> 07:31:02,100
preconstruction service agreement that

4659
07:31:02,100 --> 07:31:05,601
they were able to start soon

4660
07:31:09,100 --> 07:31:11,401
afterwards and give other

4661
07:31:13,100 --> 07:31:14,100
additional support to streamline the

4662
07:31:14,100 --> 07:31:18,801
design a little bit and that was just

4663
07:31:19,100 --> 07:31:20,100
997 thousand, they've been under that

4664
07:31:20,100 --> 07:31:23,601
contract and working with us and

4665
07:31:24,100 --> 07:31:27,100
getting pricing and estimates for that.

4666
07:31:27,100 --> 07:31:31,100
as part of that process, they were

4667
07:31:31,100 --> 07:31:34,100
given the item 2 which is -- what was

4668
07:31:34,100 --> 07:31:36,100
going to be the future construction

4669
07:31:36,100 --> 07:31:37,100
services agreement which is the

4670
07:31:37,100 --> 07:31:41,100
contract for them to build a project,

4671
07:31:41,100 --> 07:31:43,100
some of these parameters we

4672
07:31:43,100 --> 07:31:45,100
established because we wanted a fair

4673
07:31:45,100 --> 07:31:47,100
playing field and at the time, the

4674
07:31:47,100 --> 07:31:50,601
project was not designed in its

4675
07:31:55,100 --> 07:31:58,100
totality, so we made the item 2a, a

4676
07:31:58,100 --> 07:32:01,601
construction fee, we had the different

4677
07:32:02,100 --> 07:32:03,100
firms what 2a would be as a percentage

4678
07:32:03,100 --> 07:32:08,100
of a fee which is a cost of the

4679
07:32:08,100 --> 07:32:10,100
construction, item 2b which was base

4680
07:32:10,100 --> 07:32:12,100
on a consistent 22 month schedule that

4681
07:32:12,100 --> 07:32:15,100
all of them had so it would be about an

4682
07:32:15,100 --> 07:32:16,100
even playing field for everybody submitting

4683
07:32:16,100 --> 07:32:19,100
submitting on the 22 month schedule.

4684
07:32:19,100 --> 07:32:22,100
as part of -- and also item c which

4685
07:32:22,100 --> 07:32:25,100
was a rate of insurance would be

4686
07:32:25,100 --> 07:32:29,201
1.51% and item d, those will all be

4687
07:32:30,100 --> 07:32:32,100
consistent as they submitted as part

4688
07:32:32,100 --> 07:32:34,100
of this initial submittal for the

4689
07:32:34,100 --> 07:32:36,100
construction manager at risk.

4690
07:32:36,100 --> 07:32:39,601
what's changed from the 22 month to

4691
07:32:40,100 --> 07:32:43,100
the now revised 30 month is the

4692
07:32:43,100 --> 07:32:45,100
drawings, details, all that

4693
07:32:45,100 --> 07:32:48,100
information is now complete and in

4694
07:32:48,100 --> 07:32:51,100
their analysis of the construction

4695
07:32:53,100 --> 07:32:56,601
timeframe, they've shared with us that

4696
07:32:58,100 --> 07:33:00,100
the initial construction schedule that

4697
07:33:00,100 --> 07:33:03,100
was prepared was not adequate, so we

4698
07:33:03,100 --> 07:33:06,100
did a lot of review research

4699
07:33:06,100 --> 07:33:07,100
confirming of that schedule and

4700
07:33:07,100 --> 07:33:09,100
understanding how they were going to

4701
07:33:09,100 --> 07:33:11,100
build it.

4702
07:33:11,100 --> 07:33:15,100
the concrete walls as part the project

4703
07:33:15,100 --> 07:33:17,100
and we acknowledged that the

4704
07:33:17,100 --> 07:33:18,100
construction schedule that we

4705
07:33:18,100 --> 07:33:20,100
initially had without a complete set

4706
07:33:20,100 --> 07:33:22,100
of documents for fair, equal pricing

4707
07:33:22,100 --> 07:33:25,100
across the board for anybody

4708
07:33:25,100 --> 07:33:27,100
submitting the proposals was short 8

4709
07:33:27,100 --> 07:33:29,100
months and that's where we're coming

4710
07:33:29,100 --> 07:33:33,201
to the board to acknowledge that the

4711
07:33:34,100 --> 07:33:35,100
actual duration should have been 30

4712
07:33:35,100 --> 07:33:40,100
months at the time if we had a more

4713
07:33:40,100 --> 07:33:42,100
complete project pansies completed and

4714
07:33:42,100 --> 07:33:45,100
be able to have had our estimate give

4715
07:33:45,100 --> 07:33:49,100
us that analysis, so that's why we're

4716
07:33:49,100 --> 07:33:52,100
-- they prorated it at the same 22

4717
07:33:52,100 --> 07:33:55,100
month schedule for 30 months, a little

4718
07:33:55,100 --> 07:33:58,100
bit less, but we did acknowledge our

4719
07:33:58,100 --> 07:34:00,401
construction duration was short 8

4720
07:34:03,100 --> 07:34:04,100
months.

4721
07:34:04,100 --> 07:34:06,100
>> it does -- and I did do the

4722
07:34:06,100 --> 07:34:08,100
calculation, it is right, it should

4723
07:34:08,100 --> 07:34:11,100
have came out to 19 million 900

4724
07:34:12,100 --> 07:34:15,100
thousand or so, a little bit about

4725
07:34:15,100 --> 07:34:16,100
that number, it's a little bit

4726
07:34:16,100 --> 07:34:20,100
discounted in a way but it seems like

4727
07:34:20,100 --> 07:34:23,601
-- I'm just trying to understand

4728
07:34:24,100 --> 07:34:28,100
because if what they had designed is

4729
07:34:28,100 --> 07:34:31,100
leading to them having a contract that

4730
07:34:31,100 --> 07:34:34,601
now costs 4 million dollars more, I'm

4731
07:34:35,100 --> 07:34:36,100
trying to --

4732
07:34:36,100 --> 07:34:38,100
>> yeah, no, I can clarify.

4733
07:34:38,100 --> 07:34:39,100
they have not designed this project,

4734
07:34:39,100 --> 07:34:42,100
this is a different model

4735
07:34:43,100 --> 07:34:45,100
than our design build projects.

4736
07:34:45,100 --> 07:34:48,100
the steam and the student success

4737
07:34:48,100 --> 07:34:51,100
center was a different model where we

4738
07:34:51,100 --> 07:34:55,100
had procured a design build team that

4739
07:34:55,100 --> 07:34:58,100
they -- the builder and the designer,

4740
07:34:58,100 --> 07:35:02,100
and this example, our architect tef is

4741
07:35:02,100 --> 07:35:04,100
under our -- under a contract with us,

4742
07:35:04,100 --> 07:35:08,201
and at the time of this contract,

4743
07:35:09,100 --> 07:35:11,100
there were drawings but not complete

4744
07:35:11,100 --> 07:35:15,201
enough where we could get a full

4745
07:35:17,100 --> 07:35:19,100
contractibility and we have made some

4746
07:35:19,100 --> 07:35:21,100
sunsets through our internal team to

4747
07:35:21,100 --> 07:35:23,100
review and develop a 22 month

4748
07:35:23,100 --> 07:35:25,100
schedule but after the documents were

4749
07:35:25,100 --> 07:35:27,100
completed enough to get a more

4750
07:35:27,100 --> 07:35:29,401
complete estimate and construction

4751
07:35:31,100 --> 07:35:33,100
timeline, the rudolph and sletten came

4752
07:35:33,100 --> 07:35:36,100
back with a longer schedule, we then

4753
07:35:36,100 --> 07:35:37,100
had to review and confirm that and we

4754
07:35:37,100 --> 07:35:41,801
were able to confirm that it was a 30

4755
07:35:43,100 --> 07:35:46,100
month schedule, they did not design

4756
07:35:46,100 --> 07:35:48,100
the buildings they took a design we

4757
07:35:48,100 --> 07:35:50,100
did independently of them.

4758
07:35:50,100 --> 07:35:52,100
>> I see.

4759
07:35:53,100 --> 07:35:55,100
is there -- was there any manner in

4760
07:35:55,100 --> 07:35:56,100
which we would have had a better

4761
07:35:56,100 --> 07:36:00,100
estimate that it was 30 -- it would

4762
07:36:00,100 --> 07:36:04,100
have taken a 30 month duration to construct

4763
07:36:04,100 --> 07:36:07,100
so it was factored in, in the bidding

4764
07:36:07,100 --> 07:36:08,100
process?

4765
07:36:08,100 --> 07:36:12,201
>> so, the bidding process was just as

4766
07:36:13,100 --> 07:36:17,100
in the document, the 2a, b, c and d

4767
07:36:17,100 --> 07:36:20,601
items , those were all fixed numberers

4768
07:36:21,100 --> 07:36:22,100
early on.

4769
07:36:22,100 --> 07:36:24,100
we did not have a complete

4770
07:36:24,100 --> 07:36:26,100
architectural set to be able to bid

4771
07:36:26,100 --> 07:36:28,100
all the details we have now and this

4772
07:36:28,100 --> 07:36:30,100
information comes back from us from

4773
07:36:30,100 --> 07:36:33,100
earlier this year where they

4774
07:36:33,100 --> 07:36:36,100
acknowledged that the duration of the

4775
07:36:36,100 --> 07:36:39,100
all the details if building

4776
07:36:41,100 --> 07:36:42,100
infrastructure would be a 30 month

4777
07:36:42,100 --> 07:36:43,100
schedule.

4778
07:36:43,100 --> 07:36:46,100
at the time we put the original

4779
07:36:46,100 --> 07:36:48,100
request for cmr, we did not have the

4780
07:36:48,100 --> 07:36:52,201
level of detail needed to establish a

4781
07:36:53,100 --> 07:36:55,100
more accurate 30 month schedule we

4782
07:36:55,100 --> 07:36:58,601
have now, that's about two years

4783
07:37:00,100 --> 07:37:01,100
later.

4784
07:37:01,100 --> 07:37:02,100
>> and so I think I'll have to think

4785
07:37:02,100 --> 07:37:04,100
about this a little bit more to figure

4786
07:37:04,100 --> 07:37:07,601
out the if there is additional

4787
07:37:08,100 --> 07:37:10,100
questions I can throw at you for

4788
07:37:10,100 --> 07:37:14,100
another agenda item in the future, avc

4789
07:37:14,100 --> 07:37:17,100
vasquez, as far as the attachment, the

4790
07:37:17,100 --> 07:37:19,401
exhibits that are blank.

4791
07:37:21,100 --> 07:37:23,100
>> yeah, so I was looking at that

4792
07:37:23,100 --> 07:37:26,100
when I heard during the break time and

4793
07:37:26,100 --> 07:37:28,100
I'm not sure, this was kind of a

4794
07:37:28,100 --> 07:37:31,100
document that was put together.

4795
07:37:31,100 --> 07:37:35,201
I think the initial amendment too but

4796
07:37:37,100 --> 07:37:41,201
the main substance of it was that

4797
07:37:42,100 --> 07:37:45,100
duration cost and the contract will

4798
07:37:45,100 --> 07:37:47,100
obviously come to the board once we

4799
07:37:47,100 --> 07:37:51,201
get the plan approval from dsa and

4800
07:37:53,100 --> 07:37:54,100
we're able submit a full contract, all

4801
07:37:54,100 --> 07:37:57,100
of the items will be included at that

4802
07:37:57,100 --> 07:37:59,100
time.

4803
07:38:00,100 --> 07:38:03,601
>> I mean, I think since it's

4804
07:38:05,100 --> 07:38:08,100
substantively within the summary of

4805
07:38:09,100 --> 07:38:11,100
the board agenda, it will make it to

4806
07:38:11,100 --> 07:38:14,100
the contract, so I'm --

4807
07:38:14,100 --> 07:38:16,100
>> yes, salute.

4808
07:38:17,100 --> 07:38:19,100
>> I'm going to move the item.

4809
07:38:19,100 --> 07:38:20,100
>> is there a second?

4810
07:38:20,100 --> 07:38:22,100
>> second.

4811
07:38:24,100 --> 07:38:26,100
>> student roust brandt, your advisory

4812
07:38:26,100 --> 07:38:27,100
vote?

4813
07:38:27,100 --> 07:38:28,100
>> aye.

4814
07:38:28,100 --> 07:38:29,100
>> president martinez?

4815
07:38:29,100 --> 07:38:30,100
>> yes.

4816
07:38:30,100 --> 07:38:31,100
>> vice-president zamora?

4817
07:38:31,100 --> 07:38:32,100
>> aye.

4818
07:38:32,100 --> 07:38:33,100
>> trustee chisti?

4819
07:38:33,100 --> 07:38:34,100
>> aye.

4820
07:38:34,100 --> 07:38:35,100
>> trustee wong?

4821
07:38:35,100 --> 07:38:36,100
>> yes.

4822
07:38:36,100 --> 07:38:37,100
>> trustee solomon?

4823
07:38:37,100 --> 07:38:38,100
>> aye.

4824
07:38:38,100 --> 07:38:39,100
>> trustee chung?

4825
07:38:39,100 --> 07:38:40,100
>> aye.

4826
07:38:40,100 --> 07:38:41,100
>> trustee mccarty?

4827
07:38:41,100 --> 07:38:42,100
>> aye.

4828
07:38:42,100 --> 07:38:43,100
>> the motion passes.

4829
07:38:43,100 --> 07:38:45,100
>> thank you, we're now

4830
07:38:45,100 --> 07:38:48,100
at the item committee reports.

4831
07:38:50,100 --> 07:38:53,100
>> I'm sorry, president martinez, item

4832
07:38:55,100 --> 07:38:57,100
14d.

4833
07:38:57,100 --> 07:39:00,601
>> item 14d, I appreciate the heads-up.

4834
07:39:01,100 --> 07:39:02,100
>> I have a procedural question.

4835
07:39:02,100 --> 07:39:04,100
>> yes.

4836
07:39:06,100 --> 07:39:09,100
>> thank you, trustee wong, for

4837
07:39:09,100 --> 07:39:10,100
identifying your abstention.

4838
07:39:10,100 --> 07:39:12,100
but I'm curious, does trustee wong

4839
07:39:12,100 --> 07:39:14,100
have to leave the room if there's

4840
07:39:14,100 --> 07:39:17,100
discussion or -- I just don't know

4841
07:39:17,100 --> 07:39:19,100
what that -- yeah.

4842
07:39:19,100 --> 07:39:22,100
>> that part might be addressed by

4843
07:39:22,100 --> 07:39:23,100
kathy.

4844
07:39:23,100 --> 07:39:24,100
I know that he can't participate in

4845
07:39:24,100 --> 07:39:27,100
the discussion but does he need to

4846
07:39:27,100 --> 07:39:28,100
also leave the room?

4847
07:39:28,100 --> 07:39:30,100
>> the proper -- I don't know whether

4848
07:39:30,100 --> 07:39:34,100
the source of the abstention or --

4849
07:39:34,100 --> 07:39:38,801
>> I can share, it's obvious, it is my

4850
07:39:39,100 --> 07:39:41,100
employer.

4851
07:39:41,100 --> 07:39:44,100
>> so, then you likely have a

4852
07:39:44,100 --> 07:39:45,100
financial interest in this particular

4853
07:39:45,100 --> 07:39:49,100
item and so, yes, the proper procedure

4854
07:39:49,100 --> 07:39:52,100
under the fppc is the recuse yourself

4855
07:39:52,100 --> 07:39:54,100
which is announce the financial

4856
07:39:54,100 --> 07:39:56,100
interest and leave the room while the

4857
07:39:56,100 --> 07:39:58,100
item is being voted upon and discussed.

4858
07:39:58,100 --> 07:40:00,100
>> I will leave the room right now,

4859
07:40:00,100 --> 07:40:02,100
somebody tell me when to come back in.

4860
07:40:02,100 --> 07:40:04,100
>> thank you.

4861
07:40:05,100 --> 07:40:07,100
>> before we move forward, I think it

4862
07:40:07,100 --> 07:40:10,100
would be appropriate for a motion to

4863
07:40:10,100 --> 07:40:11,100
extend the time of this meeting.

4864
07:40:11,100 --> 07:40:13,100
>> yes, I was going to ask for that

4865
07:40:13,100 --> 07:40:14,100
motion.

4866
07:40:14,100 --> 07:40:16,100
>> to I'm hoping 12:15.

4867
07:40:16,100 --> 07:40:17,100
>> second.

4868
07:40:17,100 --> 07:40:20,100
>> let's just put it to 12:30, we can

4869
07:40:20,100 --> 07:40:21,100
adjourn earlier.

4870
07:40:21,100 --> 07:40:22,100
>> I agree.

4871
07:40:22,100 --> 07:40:25,100
>> moved and seconded to adjourn the

4872
07:40:25,100 --> 07:40:27,100
meeting at 12:30, vice-president

4873
07:40:28,100 --> 07:40:31,100
zamora moved, seconded by trustee

4874
07:40:31,100 --> 07:40:32,100
chung.

4875
07:40:32,100 --> 07:40:33,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

4876
07:40:33,100 --> 07:40:34,100
advisory vote?

4877
07:40:34,100 --> 07:40:35,100
>> aye.

4878
07:40:35,100 --> 07:40:36,100
>> president martinez?

4879
07:40:36,100 --> 07:40:37,100
>> yes.

4880
07:40:37,100 --> 07:40:38,100
>> vice-president zamora?

4881
07:40:38,100 --> 07:40:39,100
>> aye.

4882
07:40:39,100 --> 07:40:40,100
>> trustee chung?

4883
07:40:40,100 --> 07:40:41,100
>> aye.

4884
07:40:41,100 --> 07:40:42,100
>> trustee chisti?

4885
07:40:42,100 --> 07:40:43,100
>> aye.

4886
07:40:43,100 --> 07:40:44,100
>> trustee solomon?

4887
07:40:44,100 --> 07:40:45,100
>> yes.

4888
07:40:45,100 --> 07:40:46,100
>> trustee mccarty?

4889
07:40:46,100 --> 07:40:47,100
>> aye.

4890
07:40:47,100 --> 07:40:49,100
>> the motion passes.

4891
07:40:49,100 --> 07:40:51,100
>> we will now -- is there any

4892
07:40:51,100 --> 07:40:53,401
discussion on this item?

4893
07:40:55,100 --> 07:40:58,100
will somebody move the item?

4894
07:40:59,100 --> 07:41:00,100
>> so moved.

4895
07:41:00,100 --> 07:41:01,100
>> second.

4896
07:41:01,100 --> 07:41:02,100
>> thank you.

4897
07:41:02,100 --> 07:41:03,100
will you call the roll, please.

4898
07:41:03,100 --> 07:41:05,100
>> sorry, please, we were extending

4899
07:41:05,100 --> 07:41:07,401
time, so not yet.

4900
07:41:10,100 --> 07:41:12,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

4901
07:41:12,100 --> 07:41:13,100
advisory vote?

4902
07:41:13,100 --> 07:41:15,100
>> aye.

4903
07:41:15,100 --> 07:41:16,100
>> president martinez?

4904
07:41:16,100 --> 07:41:17,100
>> yes.

4905
07:41:17,100 --> 07:41:18,100
>> vice-president zamora?

4906
07:41:18,100 --> 07:41:19,100
>> aye.

4907
07:41:19,100 --> 07:41:20,100
>> trustee chisti?

4908
07:41:20,100 --> 07:41:22,100
>> aye

4909
07:41:24,100 --> 07:41:25,100
>> trustee solomon?

4910
07:41:25,100 --> 07:41:26,100
>> yes.

4911
07:41:26,100 --> 07:41:27,100
>> trustee chung?

4912
07:41:27,100 --> 07:41:28,100
>> aye.

4913
07:41:28,100 --> 07:41:29,100
>> trustee mccarty?

4914
07:41:29,100 --> 07:41:30,100
>> aye.

4915
07:41:30,100 --> 07:41:31,100
>> the motion passes.

4916
07:41:31,100 --> 07:41:32,100
>> thank you.

4917
07:41:32,100 --> 07:41:36,100
we are now at committee reports and

4918
07:41:36,100 --> 07:41:37,100
can you pull it up.

4919
07:41:37,100 --> 07:41:39,100
item 20.

4920
07:41:42,100 --> 07:41:44,401
>> I think we're at 19.

4921
07:41:49,100 --> 07:41:50,100
>> informational items.

4922
07:41:50,100 --> 07:41:52,100
that's 19.

4923
07:42:03,100 --> 07:42:04,100
>> number 19a.

4924
07:42:04,100 --> 07:42:07,100
>> yeah, so trustees, these are all

4925
07:42:07,100 --> 07:42:09,100
items that have been brought before

4926
07:42:09,100 --> 07:42:13,100
you previously for a first read I

4927
07:42:13,100 --> 07:42:16,601
believe at the most recent committee

4928
07:42:18,100 --> 07:42:21,100
of all meeting, so we can start with

4929
07:42:21,100 --> 07:42:25,201
item 19a if there are any additional

4930
07:42:26,100 --> 07:42:29,100
questions about ap6.36, the course

4931
07:42:29,100 --> 07:42:31,100
auditing and auditing fees.

4932
07:42:31,100 --> 07:42:34,601
>> trustees, are there any comments or

4933
07:42:35,100 --> 07:42:36,100
questions?

4934
07:42:36,100 --> 07:42:38,100
any public comments?

4935
07:42:40,100 --> 07:42:41,100
okay.

4936
07:42:41,100 --> 07:42:42,100
since this is an informational items,

4937
07:42:42,100 --> 07:42:46,100
I'm assuming we do not have to take a

4938
07:42:46,100 --> 07:42:48,100
vote.

4939
07:42:48,100 --> 07:42:49,100
okay, item 19b?

4940
07:42:49,100 --> 07:42:52,100
>> this one is regarding student

4941
07:42:54,100 --> 07:42:55,100
activities and including a name change

4942
07:42:55,100 --> 07:42:57,401
to the associated students

4943
07:43:00,100 --> 07:43:02,100
organization ap5.01.

4944
07:43:04,100 --> 07:43:07,100
>> trustee, any questions or comments?

4945
07:43:07,100 --> 07:43:09,401
thank you, number 19c?

4946
07:43:11,100 --> 07:43:13,401
>> ap5.08 regarding credit card

4947
07:43:14,100 --> 07:43:16,100
solicitation on campus.

4948
07:43:16,100 --> 07:43:19,100
>> trustees, any questions or comments?

4949
07:43:22,100 --> 07:43:23,100
thank you.

4950
07:43:23,100 --> 07:43:25,100
now we go to number 20, I was trying

4951
07:43:25,100 --> 07:43:27,100
to get the to this one because it

4952
07:43:27,100 --> 07:43:31,100
notes that there's supposed to be a

4953
07:43:31,100 --> 07:43:32,100
report today.

4954
07:43:32,100 --> 07:43:34,100
number 20.

4955
07:43:39,100 --> 07:43:40,100
vice-president zamora, do you have a

4956
07:43:40,100 --> 07:43:42,100
report today?

4957
07:43:43,100 --> 07:43:47,201
>> unless folks would like me to add

4958
07:43:49,100 --> 07:43:51,100
additional context, I feel like we

4959
07:43:51,100 --> 07:43:54,100
covered this at the committee of the

4960
07:43:54,100 --> 07:43:56,100
whole and nothing has changed since

4961
07:43:56,100 --> 07:43:59,100
then, so just for expediency.

4962
07:43:59,100 --> 07:44:01,100
>> okay, thank you.

4963
07:44:04,100 --> 07:44:08,201
I will ask interim chancellor bailey to

4964
07:44:11,100 --> 07:44:14,601
in the next consultation about the

4965
07:44:16,100 --> 07:44:20,100
agenda that we remove this item unless

4966
07:44:20,100 --> 07:44:22,100
we inform him there's a need to have

4967
07:44:22,100 --> 07:44:25,601
it on the agenda, thank you.

4968
07:44:28,100 --> 07:44:29,100
okay.

4969
07:44:29,100 --> 07:44:31,100
trustee reports.

4970
07:44:31,100 --> 07:44:33,100
trustees, any reports?

4971
07:44:35,100 --> 07:44:38,100
I'll defer and go last.

4972
07:44:39,100 --> 07:44:42,100
anybody have a report, yes?

4973
07:44:42,100 --> 07:44:44,100
>> public comments on?

4974
07:44:45,100 --> 07:44:47,100
>> reports.

4975
07:44:47,100 --> 07:44:49,100
>> on reports?

4976
07:44:49,100 --> 07:44:50,100
okay.

4977
07:44:50,100 --> 07:44:52,100
could we go ahead and take public

4978
07:44:52,100 --> 07:44:54,100
comments on reports.

4979
07:44:54,100 --> 07:44:56,100
>> abigail bornstein.

4980
07:45:03,100 --> 07:45:07,100
>> so, I wanted to take a moment to

4981
07:45:07,100 --> 07:45:08,100
address the board.

4982
07:45:08,100 --> 07:45:12,201
I wanted to remind the board about

4983
07:45:16,100 --> 07:45:18,100
board policy 1.12.

4984
07:45:19,100 --> 07:45:21,100
board policy 1.12 and let me read this

4985
07:45:21,100 --> 07:45:24,100
to you, it is the standards of

4986
07:45:24,100 --> 07:45:26,100
decorum, the following may be ruled

4987
07:45:26,100 --> 07:45:30,100
out of order by the president's offer,

4988
07:45:30,100 --> 07:45:33,100
by the presiding officer, profanity,

4989
07:45:38,100 --> 07:45:39,100
obscenity and other offensive

4990
07:45:39,100 --> 07:45:42,100
language, I think we very clearly

4991
07:45:42,100 --> 07:45:43,100
witnessed that and yet I didn't hear

4992
07:45:43,100 --> 07:45:46,100
-- I want to say thank you to trustee

4993
07:45:46,100 --> 07:45:48,100
chisti but I didn't hear an out of

4994
07:45:48,100 --> 07:45:50,100
order and this was something the

4995
07:45:50,100 --> 07:45:51,100
president should have jumped on.

4996
07:45:51,100 --> 07:45:55,201
it is not acceptable, it is disgusting

4997
07:45:56,100 --> 07:46:00,100
language and I want you to know

4998
07:46:00,100 --> 07:46:03,601
immediately after that was spoken, I

4999
07:46:05,100 --> 07:46:08,100
received another vial, nasty, bullying

5000
07:46:09,100 --> 07:46:10,100
and threatening e-mail.

5001
07:46:10,100 --> 07:46:12,100
that is going to be going to hr but

5002
07:46:12,100 --> 07:46:14,100
someone at this school, this school

5003
07:46:14,100 --> 07:46:17,100
has got to address it, you are now on

5004
07:46:17,100 --> 07:46:19,100
notice we have a problem here.

5005
07:46:19,100 --> 07:46:21,100
we have a big problem here.

5006
07:46:21,100 --> 07:46:24,601
I should not be bullied, I

5007
07:46:25,100 --> 07:46:28,601
should not be threatened or have

5008
07:46:29,100 --> 07:46:30,100
disgusting language directed at me or

5009
07:46:30,100 --> 07:46:32,401
anyone at the school.

5010
07:46:33,100 --> 07:46:36,100
this is not the first time we've heard

5011
07:46:36,100 --> 07:46:37,100
things like this.

5012
07:46:37,100 --> 07:46:41,100
we have it almost after every single

5013
07:46:41,100 --> 07:46:44,100
board meeting, the type of language

5014
07:46:44,100 --> 07:46:46,100
that is inappropriate, the bullying

5015
07:46:46,100 --> 07:46:49,100
behavior that we witness, when I say

5016
07:46:49,100 --> 07:46:52,100
we, I mean every single one of you

5017
07:46:52,100 --> 07:46:53,100
board members have witnessed it and I

5018
07:46:53,100 --> 07:46:57,801
want you to think for a moment what

5019
07:46:59,100 --> 07:47:02,100
did you witness and what did you do.

5020
07:47:02,100 --> 07:47:06,100
what action did you take while that

5021
07:47:06,100 --> 07:47:08,100
was happening?

5022
07:47:09,100 --> 07:47:13,201
you heard it, I have another e-mail,

5023
07:47:14,100 --> 07:47:15,100
the school has got a problem and it

5024
07:47:15,100 --> 07:47:18,100
has to be addressed and this isn't

5025
07:47:18,100 --> 07:47:20,100
just towards me, it's towards many but

5026
07:47:20,100 --> 07:47:24,201
I have very specific language in here

5027
07:47:25,100 --> 07:47:27,401
which is disgusting, vial.

5028
07:47:29,100 --> 07:47:31,100
and saying, oh, I'm sorry, having

5029
07:47:31,100 --> 07:47:34,100
people say, oh, I'm sorry you had to

5030
07:47:34,100 --> 07:47:35,100
hear, that is not enough, the school has

5031
07:47:35,100 --> 07:47:38,100
to do something about this.

5032
07:47:38,100 --> 07:47:41,100
>> thank you for your comment, I wish

5033
07:47:41,100 --> 07:47:43,100
to offer my personal apology and

5034
07:47:43,100 --> 07:47:46,100
acknowledge that I was wrong in not

5035
07:47:46,100 --> 07:47:50,201
stopping it and it won't happen again.

5036
07:47:51,100 --> 07:47:53,100
yes, student trustee brandt?

5037
07:47:53,100 --> 07:47:55,100
>> yeah, thank you, sorry.

5038
07:47:55,100 --> 07:47:59,100
I was just trying to better understand

5039
07:47:59,100 --> 07:48:00,100
process and procedure and what that

5040
07:48:00,100 --> 07:48:04,201
has to do with board member reports.

5041
07:48:06,100 --> 07:48:10,100
>> I think we needed to take that

5042
07:48:10,100 --> 07:48:11,100
public comment because it was

5043
07:48:11,100 --> 07:48:13,100
necessary given the situation and it

5044
07:48:13,100 --> 07:48:16,100
may have been slightly out of order

5045
07:48:16,100 --> 07:48:18,100
but I think it was a comment that we

5046
07:48:18,100 --> 07:48:20,100
had to hear.

5047
07:48:20,100 --> 07:48:21,100
>> understood.

5048
07:48:21,100 --> 07:48:22,100
>> and acknowledged.

5049
07:48:22,100 --> 07:48:24,100
>> I was just curious, thank you.

5050
07:48:24,100 --> 07:48:25,100
>> thank you, okay.

5051
07:48:25,100 --> 07:48:27,100
board reports?

5052
07:48:29,100 --> 07:48:31,100
okay, I see vice-president zamora?

5053
07:48:31,100 --> 07:48:35,100
>> I just wanted to take a brief

5054
07:48:35,100 --> 07:48:38,601
moment to congratulate katia fuchs on

5055
07:48:39,100 --> 07:48:42,100
her election and all the new and

5056
07:48:42,100 --> 07:48:44,100
returning academic senate leadership.

5057
07:48:44,100 --> 07:48:47,601
I also wanted to congratulate michael

5058
07:48:48,100 --> 07:48:50,100
snider and all the and rushing senate

5059
07:48:50,100 --> 07:48:52,100
leadership on their elections.

5060
07:48:52,100 --> 07:48:56,801
I wanted to take a moment to thank

5061
07:48:57,100 --> 07:48:59,100
student chancellor malinalli

5062
07:48:59,100 --> 07:49:03,100
villalobos for all of his work, his

5063
07:49:03,100 --> 07:49:06,601
blood, sweat, tear, his passion and

5064
07:49:08,100 --> 07:49:10,100
always bringing that everywhere he

5065
07:49:10,100 --> 07:49:13,100
goes including here to the board.

5066
07:49:13,100 --> 07:49:16,100
I wish him luck in his next role.

5067
07:49:16,100 --> 07:49:19,601
I also want to welcome and

5068
07:49:21,100 --> 07:49:25,100
congratulate an jael ka campos, I have

5069
07:49:25,100 --> 07:49:27,100
berated with angelica on a number of

5070
07:49:27,100 --> 07:49:29,100
occasions and every single time

5071
07:49:29,100 --> 07:49:33,801
angelica has been a ray of sunshine and

5072
07:49:35,100 --> 07:49:37,100
open to hearing every point of view,

5073
07:49:37,100 --> 07:49:41,100
so I look forward to working with

5074
07:49:41,100 --> 07:49:44,601
angelica but finally I wanted to

5075
07:49:45,100 --> 07:49:47,401
personally thank and appreciate

5076
07:49:48,100 --> 07:49:51,100
student trustee heather brandt for a

5077
07:49:51,100 --> 07:49:53,100
number of reasons, not just because of

5078
07:49:53,100 --> 07:49:56,601
your role as student trustee but

5079
07:49:57,100 --> 07:50:01,100
because whether or not you know this or

5080
07:50:01,100 --> 07:50:03,100
have been told this, there's very few

5081
07:50:03,100 --> 07:50:08,100
people I have met in my life that have

5082
07:50:08,100 --> 07:50:11,100
exhibited the strength that you have,

5083
07:50:11,100 --> 07:50:14,601
like, you're tougher than nails, not

5084
07:50:15,100 --> 07:50:17,100
as tough as nails, you're

5085
07:50:17,100 --> 07:50:19,100
tougher than nails and frankly you had

5086
07:50:19,100 --> 07:50:23,100
confided in me a lot of what you

5087
07:50:23,100 --> 07:50:25,401
shared publicly today and

5088
07:50:29,100 --> 07:50:32,100
juggling any of the challenges

5089
07:50:33,100 --> 07:50:37,801
that most students at ccsf have is very

5090
07:50:40,100 --> 07:50:44,801
common but I feel like you're kind of

5091
07:50:45,100 --> 07:50:49,801
forged in the fire and I feel like

5092
07:50:50,100 --> 07:50:52,100
you've gone above and beyond and I

5093
07:50:52,100 --> 07:50:55,100
just would like you to know that, so I

5094
07:50:55,100 --> 07:50:57,100
wish you were here.

5095
07:50:57,100 --> 07:51:00,100
you're being amazing over an encore

5096
07:51:00,100 --> 07:51:03,100
along with our other students and

5097
07:51:03,100 --> 07:51:05,100
faculty and administration but I just

5098
07:51:05,100 --> 07:51:07,100
personally wanted to say it's been

5099
07:51:07,100 --> 07:51:11,201
such a pleasure getting to know you

5100
07:51:12,100 --> 07:51:13,100
and working with you and I look

5101
07:51:13,100 --> 07:51:15,100
forward to your new role as student

5102
07:51:15,100 --> 07:51:17,100
chancellor which I believe either

5103
07:51:17,100 --> 07:51:19,100
begins at the beginning of next month

5104
07:51:19,100 --> 07:51:21,100
or at the adjournment of this meeting

5105
07:51:21,100 --> 07:51:24,100
so I wish you luck.

5106
07:51:25,100 --> 07:51:27,401
>> I saw trustee solomon.

5107
07:51:29,100 --> 07:51:32,100
>> thank you, and I would like to

5108
07:51:32,100 --> 07:51:34,100
thank you, dr. Lisa cooper wilkins for

5109
07:51:34,100 --> 07:51:37,100
all the work you did so we could have

5110
07:51:37,100 --> 07:51:39,100
a beautiful commencement ceremony, it

5111
07:51:39,100 --> 07:51:41,100
was the highlight of the week, not

5112
07:51:41,100 --> 07:51:44,601
just the day, so thank you.

5113
07:51:46,100 --> 07:51:48,100
just wanted to remind people that

5114
07:51:48,100 --> 07:51:51,100
we've received an e-mail on may 27

5115
07:51:51,100 --> 07:51:53,100
about pride events, city college will

5116
07:51:53,100 --> 07:51:54,100
be participating in the pride parade

5117
07:51:54,100 --> 07:51:57,601
which is on sunday june 29 and

5118
07:51:58,100 --> 07:52:01,100
reporting time will be announced soon.

5119
07:52:01,100 --> 07:52:02,100
also something new, city college will

5120
07:52:02,100 --> 07:52:06,201
be tabling at the pride celebration at

5121
07:52:08,100 --> 07:52:09,100
civic center plaza on saturday

5122
07:52:09,100 --> 07:52:11,401
june 28 and sunday june 29.

5123
07:52:12,100 --> 07:52:16,201
if you can look up that e-mail,

5124
07:52:17,100 --> 07:52:18,100
there's somewhere where you can sign

5125
07:52:18,100 --> 07:52:21,100
up to the table or the parade

5126
07:52:21,100 --> 07:52:22,100
contingent.

5127
07:52:22,100 --> 07:52:24,100
there also is going to be the annual

5128
07:52:24,100 --> 07:52:28,100
flag raising on a date to be decided.

5129
07:52:28,100 --> 07:52:30,100
I think it might be as early as the

5130
07:52:30,100 --> 07:52:31,100
first week of june, so stay tuned.

5131
07:52:31,100 --> 07:52:33,100
thank you.

5132
07:52:33,100 --> 07:52:35,100
>> thank you.

5133
07:52:36,100 --> 07:52:37,100
and any other trustee reports?

5134
07:52:37,100 --> 07:52:39,100
trustee chisti?

5135
07:52:40,100 --> 07:52:42,401
>> thank you, president martinez.

5136
07:52:43,100 --> 07:52:45,100
I think everything has been said but I

5137
07:52:45,100 --> 07:52:49,100
want to take a few moments and really

5138
07:52:49,100 --> 07:52:51,100
center student trustee brandt and just

5139
07:52:51,100 --> 07:52:52,100
really thank you for all of your work

5140
07:52:52,100 --> 07:52:54,100
and your advocacy.

5141
07:52:56,100 --> 07:52:59,601
I've especially enjoyed working on our

5142
07:53:01,100 --> 07:53:03,100
annual iftars that are going on right

5143
07:53:03,100 --> 07:53:05,100
now and you're a force to be wrecked

5144
07:53:05,100 --> 07:53:07,100
with and everyone that I have talked

5145
07:53:07,100 --> 07:53:10,100
to has also mentioned like the

5146
07:53:10,100 --> 07:53:13,100
magnitude of your support, your

5147
07:53:13,100 --> 07:53:15,100
compassion and I personally have

5148
07:53:15,100 --> 07:53:16,100
always really appreciated when there's

5149
07:53:16,100 --> 07:53:19,100
a student that's reached out to me and

5150
07:53:19,100 --> 07:53:21,100
they're looking for connections that I

5151
07:53:21,100 --> 07:53:24,100
could connect them with you, so thank

5152
07:53:24,100 --> 07:53:26,100
you for -- I know that you have a lot

5153
07:53:26,100 --> 07:53:28,100
that you've dealt with on a personal

5154
07:53:28,100 --> 07:53:32,100
level but you still show up, you're

5155
07:53:32,100 --> 07:53:35,100
present, super articulate and just

5156
07:53:35,100 --> 07:53:37,100
really, really appreciate you and want

5157
07:53:37,100 --> 07:53:40,100
to thank you for your service.

5158
07:53:40,100 --> 07:53:41,100
>> other board reports?

5159
07:53:41,100 --> 07:53:43,100
trustee chung?

5160
07:53:46,100 --> 07:53:49,100
>> well, student trustee brandt and

5161
07:53:51,100 --> 07:53:54,100
vice chancellor -- sorry, chancellor

5162
07:53:55,100 --> 07:53:58,100
elect, student chancellor elect, you

5163
07:54:00,100 --> 07:54:03,100
know that I have always felt like you

5164
07:54:03,100 --> 07:54:05,100
were more deserving of

5165
07:54:05,100 --> 07:54:07,100
being a student trustee than I was.

5166
07:54:07,100 --> 07:54:11,100
before I took a run for it, I thought

5167
07:54:11,100 --> 07:54:15,801
you should have run and I am so

5168
07:54:18,100 --> 07:54:21,100
honored that you have been a member of

5169
07:54:21,100 --> 07:54:24,100
this board for two years.

5170
07:54:26,100 --> 07:54:30,801
you have been -- are -- you have

5171
07:54:31,100 --> 07:54:35,100
spoken out on things when so many of

5172
07:54:35,100 --> 07:54:37,100
us across this nation have been silent

5173
07:54:37,100 --> 07:54:39,100
about it.

5174
07:54:40,100 --> 07:54:42,100
and I really wish you had a vote on

5175
07:54:42,100 --> 07:54:43,100
this board.

5176
07:54:43,100 --> 07:54:47,100
I think you would have -- I think you

5177
07:54:47,100 --> 07:54:48,100
really would have changed the

5178
07:54:48,100 --> 07:54:51,100
trajectory and the work we do on this

5179
07:54:51,100 --> 07:54:52,100
board if you had a vote.

5180
07:54:52,100 --> 07:54:55,100
and with that said, I also want to

5181
07:54:55,100 --> 07:54:57,100
still take the time and highlight some

5182
07:54:57,100 --> 07:54:59,100
hinges on our board agenda because I

5183
07:54:59,100 --> 07:55:03,100
just want to state that I'm really

5184
07:55:03,100 --> 07:55:06,100
excited about -- I know it took

5185
07:55:06,100 --> 07:55:08,100
a minute for me to be excited about

5186
07:55:08,100 --> 07:55:10,100
this but there's no course work on ai

5187
07:55:10,100 --> 07:55:12,100
and cloud and cyber security that's

5188
07:55:12,100 --> 07:55:14,100
really exciting because when we talk

5189
07:55:14,100 --> 07:55:16,100
about the future and it's still

5190
07:55:16,100 --> 07:55:19,100
balanced with the wholistic view of

5191
07:55:19,100 --> 07:55:22,100
social work and health care and dental

5192
07:55:22,100 --> 07:55:23,100
assisting, so it's so exciting, thank

5193
07:55:23,100 --> 07:55:26,100
you so much for the academic senate

5194
07:55:26,100 --> 07:55:27,100
for doing that work.

5195
07:55:27,100 --> 07:55:30,100
we also have a new credit program in

5196
07:55:30,100 --> 07:55:32,100
climate change and response, that's a

5197
07:55:32,100 --> 07:55:35,100
new certificate of achievement, that's

5198
07:55:35,100 --> 07:55:37,100
really exciting to know that we're

5199
07:55:37,100 --> 07:55:40,100
going to be training those who are

5200
07:55:40,100 --> 07:55:43,100
going to be trying to keep this earth

5201
07:55:43,100 --> 07:55:45,401
alive for many generations.

5202
07:55:49,100 --> 07:55:52,100
and trustee chisti, you usually do

5203
07:55:52,100 --> 07:55:54,100
this honor of reading out those who

5204
07:55:54,100 --> 07:55:58,801
are going to be retired but I don't

5205
07:55:59,100 --> 07:56:00,100
know if any other trustee would like

5206
07:56:00,100 --> 07:56:03,100
to do that honor tonight.

5207
07:56:04,100 --> 07:56:05,100
>> you're up.

5208
07:56:05,100 --> 07:56:06,100
>> okay.

5209
07:56:06,100 --> 07:56:08,100
thank you.

5210
07:56:09,100 --> 07:56:13,201
let's see if we can expand this.

5211
07:56:18,100 --> 07:56:19,100
to dominique valerie would is a

5212
07:56:19,100 --> 07:56:22,100
faculty member at esl who has worked

5213
07:56:22,100 --> 07:56:26,100
here for 31 years, I know we're having

5214
07:56:26,100 --> 07:56:28,100
harold brown iii come back from

5215
07:56:28,100 --> 07:56:30,100
retirement, thank you for already

5216
07:56:30,100 --> 07:56:32,100
servicing our college for 38 year and

5217
07:56:32,100 --> 07:56:34,000
is still coming back from

5218
07:56:34,000 --> 07:56:37,600
retirement to help out our athletics

5219
07:56:41,100 --> 07:56:44,100
department, bruce ingram, part time

5220
07:56:47,100 --> 07:56:50,100
faculty if mathematics, 20 years and

5221
07:56:52,100 --> 07:56:55,100
six months, jimel, full time faculty

5222
07:56:55,100 --> 07:56:58,601
in business, 34 years and five months,

5223
07:56:59,100 --> 07:57:02,100
loft house, full time faculty esl, 27

5224
07:57:02,100 --> 07:57:05,601
years and 4 months, a -- michelle,

5225
07:57:10,100 --> 07:57:13,100
full time faculty and nursing, 40

5226
07:57:20,100 --> 07:57:22,100
years.

5227
07:57:22,100 --> 07:57:24,100
steven robertson, apprenticeship, 24

5228
07:57:25,100 --> 07:57:26,100
years.

5229
07:57:26,100 --> 07:57:28,100
john, visual media design, 29 years

5230
07:57:28,100 --> 07:57:30,100
and 4 months.

5231
07:57:33,100 --> 07:57:36,100
and andreas, buildings and grounds, 17

5232
07:57:37,100 --> 07:57:38,100
years.

5233
07:57:38,100 --> 07:57:40,100
and him potter, student affairs

5234
07:57:40,100 --> 07:57:41,100
division, two years and 8 months.

5235
07:57:41,100 --> 07:57:44,100
thank you so much for your service.

5236
07:57:44,100 --> 07:57:46,401
>> any other trustee reports?

5237
07:57:50,100 --> 07:57:53,100
I have a brief one.

5238
07:57:53,100 --> 07:57:58,401
I want to add my thanks to you, acting

5239
07:57:59,100 --> 07:58:01,100
chancellor cooper wilkins for a

5240
07:58:01,100 --> 07:58:02,100
wonderful commencement.

5241
07:58:02,100 --> 07:58:04,100
I really appreciated the innovation

5242
07:58:04,100 --> 07:58:06,100
and I'm going to the give them the

5243
07:58:06,100 --> 07:58:10,100
wrong name of the two honor lines,

5244
07:58:10,100 --> 07:58:13,100
next year, maybe after we've had this

5245
07:58:13,100 --> 07:58:16,100
practice, we'll do them a little bit

5246
07:58:16,100 --> 07:58:17,100
better.

5247
07:58:17,100 --> 07:58:18,100
and just appreciate your patience with

5248
07:58:18,100 --> 07:58:21,100
those of us on the platform, thank

5249
07:58:21,100 --> 07:58:24,100
you, and learning our ways.

5250
07:58:24,100 --> 07:58:28,100
and then I will report -- I will

5251
07:58:28,100 --> 07:58:29,100
comment on 13a.

5252
07:58:29,100 --> 07:58:32,100
as noted in the commencement booklet,

5253
07:58:32,100 --> 07:58:35,100
I appreciate we're celebrating the

5254
07:58:35,100 --> 07:58:36,100
90th anniversary of city college from

5255
07:58:36,100 --> 07:58:39,100
the date it was founded in 1935.

5256
07:58:39,100 --> 07:58:43,801
it was still part of the k14 district.

5257
07:58:45,100 --> 07:58:47,100
and I appreciate the change language

5258
07:58:47,100 --> 07:58:49,100
in the fourth button on the mission

5259
07:58:49,100 --> 07:58:52,100
statements, our programs and services

5260
07:58:52,100 --> 07:58:55,100
lead to the attainment of other

5261
07:58:55,100 --> 07:58:56,100
educational goals including learning

5262
07:58:56,100 --> 07:58:59,100
english as a second language and high

5263
07:58:59,100 --> 07:59:01,100
school completion both part of our

5264
07:59:01,100 --> 07:59:04,100
commitment to adult education which

5265
07:59:04,100 --> 07:59:07,100
acknowledges that some of our roots

5266
07:59:07,100 --> 07:59:10,601
are older, leslie smith, a retired

5267
07:59:12,100 --> 07:59:14,100
administrator researched origins

5268
07:59:15,100 --> 07:59:17,401
sharing that bishop alemany

5269
07:59:23,100 --> 07:59:26,100
initiated san francisco's first post

5270
07:59:27,100 --> 07:59:29,100
secondary instruction for newcomers

5271
07:59:29,100 --> 07:59:31,100
arriving in san francisco during the

5272
07:59:31,100 --> 07:59:33,100
1849 gold rush.

5273
07:59:33,100 --> 07:59:35,401
john sweat officially inaugurated

5274
07:59:36,100 --> 07:59:39,601
public adult education in 1856 and was

5275
07:59:40,100 --> 07:59:41,100
its first principal.

5276
07:59:41,100 --> 07:59:45,801
adult ed was part of the k-12 district,

5277
07:59:46,100 --> 07:59:49,100
it was k-14 district when city college

5278
07:59:49,100 --> 07:59:51,100
was founded.

5279
07:59:52,100 --> 07:59:55,601
when san francisco's split into two

5280
07:59:59,100 --> 08:00:01,100
districts in 1970, the san francisco

5281
08:00:01,100 --> 08:00:04,100
community college was established and

5282
08:00:04,100 --> 08:00:06,100
included adult education forming city

5283
08:00:06,100 --> 08:00:07,100
college.

5284
08:00:07,100 --> 08:00:11,201
so, in 2026, we have a potential 170th

5285
08:00:12,100 --> 08:00:14,100
anniversary to celebrate.

5286
08:00:14,100 --> 08:00:16,100
fitting because the biggest pool of

5287
08:00:16,100 --> 08:00:19,601
student who is matriculate to credit

5288
08:00:21,100 --> 08:00:22,100
instruction are non-credit, santa

5289
08:00:22,100 --> 08:00:25,100
clara university known as california's

5290
08:00:26,100 --> 08:00:29,100
molest post secondary institution was

5291
08:00:29,100 --> 08:00:32,100
founded in 1851, just five years

5292
08:00:32,100 --> 08:00:33,100
before.

5293
08:00:33,100 --> 08:00:35,401
uc berkeley, in 1868, stanford, 1885

5294
08:00:39,100 --> 08:00:42,100
and lowell high school was established

5295
08:00:42,100 --> 08:00:45,100
in 1956, the same year as adult education,

5296
08:00:45,100 --> 08:00:47,100
so let's know about that.

5297
08:00:47,100 --> 08:00:50,601
I think the mission statement really

5298
08:00:51,100 --> 08:00:53,100
in acknowledging that we have two

5299
08:00:53,100 --> 08:00:55,100
parts of our college that are really

5300
08:00:55,100 --> 08:00:58,100
important and also notice that there

5301
08:00:58,100 --> 08:01:02,201
were two presidents because we had two

5302
08:01:03,100 --> 08:01:05,100
divisions for a long time and that's

5303
08:01:05,100 --> 08:01:09,801
why we have a title of chancellor and

5304
08:01:10,100 --> 08:01:12,100
I noted it's accurate missing just the

5305
08:01:12,100 --> 08:01:14,100
last few years.

5306
08:01:14,100 --> 08:01:16,100
graduate students interviewed me in

5307
08:01:16,100 --> 08:01:19,100
late april as part of san francisco's

5308
08:01:19,100 --> 08:01:21,100
state university's ethnic studies oral

5309
08:01:21,100 --> 08:01:24,100
histories project to collect mel ris

5310
08:01:24,100 --> 08:01:26,100
of the dwindling numbers of the

5311
08:01:26,100 --> 08:01:28,100
veterans of the five month long

5312
08:01:28,100 --> 08:01:32,801
student strike led by the bsu and the

5313
08:01:34,100 --> 08:01:35,100
twlf.

5314
08:01:35,100 --> 08:01:38,100
bsu, black student's union, twlf,

5315
08:01:39,100 --> 08:01:40,100
third world liberation front, those

5316
08:01:40,100 --> 08:01:43,100
were the rest of our students who are

5317
08:01:43,100 --> 08:01:46,100
not african american, it was

5318
08:01:48,100 --> 08:01:49,100
latinos, chinese, all

5319
08:01:49,100 --> 08:01:52,100
of the rest of us, the student strike,

5320
08:01:52,100 --> 08:01:55,100
the longest in u.s. History as well as

5321
08:01:55,100 --> 08:01:57,100
the most inclusive led to the

5322
08:01:57,100 --> 08:02:00,100
establishment of the school now

5323
08:02:00,100 --> 08:02:01,100
college of ethnic studies.

5324
08:02:01,100 --> 08:02:05,100
the first of its kind in the u.s..

5325
08:02:05,100 --> 08:02:09,100
that was the origin of all of our

5326
08:02:09,100 --> 08:02:12,100
ethnic studies and we at city college

5327
08:02:12,100 --> 08:02:15,100
accomplished our ethnic studies pretty

5328
08:02:15,100 --> 08:02:17,401
much shortly after that.

5329
08:02:19,100 --> 08:02:21,100
this was also and continues to be a

5330
08:02:21,100 --> 08:02:23,100
keystone event in bringing diversity,

5331
08:02:23,100 --> 08:02:25,100
equity and inclusion into public

5332
08:02:25,100 --> 08:02:27,100
higher education.

5333
08:02:27,100 --> 08:02:30,100
and my experience in learning as much

5334
08:02:30,100 --> 08:02:32,100
outside the classroom as inside has

5335
08:02:32,100 --> 08:02:35,100
informed my opinion about the critical

5336
08:02:35,100 --> 08:02:37,100
role that student life plays in

5337
08:02:37,100 --> 08:02:39,100
student achievement.

5338
08:02:40,100 --> 08:02:42,100
finally I learned recently city

5339
08:02:42,100 --> 08:02:45,601
college is officially an hsi, hispanic

5340
08:02:46,100 --> 08:02:48,100
serving institution.

5341
08:02:49,100 --> 08:02:50,100
faculty acquired because they wanted

5342
08:02:50,100 --> 08:02:54,201
to attend a haku conference at a

5343
08:02:57,100 --> 08:02:59,100
reduced registration rate for hsi

5344
08:02:59,100 --> 08:03:00,100
colleges.

5345
08:03:00,100 --> 08:03:02,100
we should remember this when a new

5346
08:03:02,100 --> 08:03:03,100
federal administration is elected in

5347
08:03:03,100 --> 08:03:07,100
case we can qualify and apply for

5348
08:03:07,100 --> 08:03:09,100
federal funding allocated to hsi's and

5349
08:03:09,100 --> 08:03:12,601
it's in the millions, it's quite

5350
08:03:13,100 --> 08:03:15,100
substantial but I didn't know we were

5351
08:03:15,100 --> 08:03:18,100
an hsi until a faculty member inquired

5352
08:03:18,100 --> 08:03:20,100
so I want to appreciate that faculty

5353
08:03:20,100 --> 08:03:21,100
member for checking it out.

5354
08:03:21,100 --> 08:03:23,100
that's all I have for my report.

5355
08:03:23,100 --> 08:03:26,100
is there a motion to adjourn?

5356
08:03:26,100 --> 08:03:27,100
>> moved.

5357
08:03:27,100 --> 08:03:28,100
>> moved by trustee chung.

5358
08:03:28,100 --> 08:03:30,100
>> second.

5359
08:03:31,100 --> 08:03:33,100
>> second by vice-president zamora.

5360
08:03:33,100 --> 08:03:35,100
roll call vote, please.

5361
08:03:35,100 --> 08:03:37,100
>> student trustee brandt, your

5362
08:03:37,100 --> 08:03:38,100
advisory vote?

5363
08:03:38,100 --> 08:03:39,100
>> aye.

5364
08:03:39,100 --> 08:03:40,100
>> president martinez?

5365
08:03:40,100 --> 08:03:41,100
>> yes.

5366
08:03:41,100 --> 08:03:42,100
>> vice-president zamora?

5367
08:03:42,100 --> 08:03:43,100
>> aye.

5368
08:03:43,100 --> 08:03:44,100
>> trustee chisti?

5369
08:03:44,100 --> 08:03:45,100
>> aye.

5370
08:03:45,100 --> 08:03:46,100
>> trustee wong?

5371
08:03:46,100 --> 08:03:47,100
>> yes.

5372
08:03:47,100 --> 08:03:48,100
>> trustee solomon?

5373
08:03:48,100 --> 08:03:49,100
>> yes.

5374
08:03:49,100 --> 08:03:50,100
>> trustee chung?

5375
08:03:50,100 --> 08:03:51,100
>> aye.

5376
08:03:51,100 --> 08:03:52,100
>> trustee mccarty?

5377
08:03:52,100 --> 08:03:53,100
>> aye.

5378
08:03:53,100 --> 08:03:54,100
>> motion passes

5379
08:03:54,100 --> 08:03:56,100
>> meeting is adjourned.

5380
08:03:57,100 --> 08:03:59,100
( meeting adjourned ).