[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:35] Good evening. Welcome to the June 30th, 2026 City of Napa, special meeting for the planning [0:40] Commission. I would like to call this meeting to order and ask my request to please conduct a roll call. [0:46] Commissioner E-Bock, President, Commissioner Massaro, President, Commissioner Shantwell, Vice Chair Mayors, [0:55] and Chair Owen, President. We will now rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. [1:19] The Planning Commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph M. Brown Act, and pursuant to the [1:25] Theities rules of order for planning commission meetings policy resolution 10. [1:30] Staff, are there any changes to this evening's agenda or any supplemental reports? [1:34] No changes, but there are three supplemental reports that were afforded to the commission [1:39] and available on the back. [1:41] Thank you. [1:42] Commissioners, are there any proposed changes to this evening's agenda? [1:48] Public comment. [1:49] Public comment provides an opportunity for members of the public to directly address the planning [1:54] commission on items of interest, not otherwise noted on the agenda. [1:58] Each speaker's comments will be limited to three minutes and will comply with the rules [2:02] of order for planning commission meetings. [2:05] Do we have any members of the public who wish to provide public comments on non-agenda [2:09] items? [2:13] Public hearings and appeals. [2:15] These are items that are formally presented to the planning commission and provide [2:18] an opportunity for members of the public to comment. [2:22] Applicants or appellants are allowed 10 minutes to present testimony at the beginning of [2:26] public hearing, and if needed five minutes to present [2:29] rebuttal at the end of the public hearing, all other speakers [2:32] will be limited to three minutes. Tonight we have the following [2:36] item, item 7A, Franklin Station 2, redevelopment project, [2:40] and development agreement. We'll start with Commissioner [2:43] Disclosures, Commissioner Yibog. [2:47] I met with the applicant and [2:49] spoke with staff. [2:53] I also met with the applicant and spoke with staff. [2:56] I too met with the applicant and spoke with staff. [2:59] I also met with the applicant at the project site. [3:03] I served on the CHC, went the Cultural Heritage Commission. [3:07] When we approved the original Franklin Station Development Project, [3:11] I toured the site in 2018 inside and out with Jim Keller and his team. [3:17] For the record, the city's website is showing the incorrect CHC member [3:21] roster during that time, but I know for sure that the city is working on it. [3:26] I recently met with the applicant and have met with staff and read through all of the supplemental correspondence. [3:35] Thank you. [3:36] And we will now hear a report from staff. [3:40] Good evening. [3:41] Chair Owen, commissioners. [3:43] Molly Radigan. [3:44] It's the community resources and development director. [3:46] I for some reason don't have a name, Tykes. [3:47] I hope you can remember my name through this process. [3:51] We are going to get started with our presentation and I'm just going to kick it off by saying [3:55] of thank you to the applicant team for participating with us in the discussions, a huge thank [4:01] you to writer who had a heavy lift last week to get this year to you this week and then [4:06] just kick it off with what is a development agreement overview. So, California Government [4:11] Code section 658-64 and beyond govern the use of development agreements and the purpose is really [4:18] to create certain teeth on the terms of a development between the developer and the city or [4:24] of developer in the county, depending on what jurisdiction is using it. [4:27] In the city of Napa, we typically use the entitlement process, but we will use the development [4:32] agreement process when there is usually a special reason why. [4:37] And usually that is we're looking for something that's outside of the regular entitlement [4:42] process, so the developer is looking for something outside of the regular development process, [4:47] or in most situations, both there's benefits on each side to that agreement. [4:52] So for history purposes, we have used development agreements to some examples of other projects we've used development agreements on the past. [5:00] So, certainly the most big one is the NapaPyte Project. That was also part of an annexation, and it included [5:06] 945 housing units that, with a significant amount of affordable housing, dedicated to it. [5:13] And the city also received some open space commitments to the dedication of those affordable housing lands and some community facilities. [5:22] Another example is what we call this to Tula K, which is really the GASER project, [5:28] breathing apartments, where they were able to build 500 units under a development agreement, [5:34] and in exchange they also did the GASER bridge in the extension, as well as provided [5:39] an in-loop opportunity for affordable housing. [5:42] And then the one that your commission will remember from just I think about a year ago, [5:45] the time that we're sitting here is the first street project, [5:49] where, you know, they got some parking, we got some public improvements, etc. [5:54] So in the case of what you're going to see tonight, you know, the identified benefit, [5:59] significant benefit to the city of Napa is really the preservation of the post office [6:05] and historical resource in our community. [6:08] And while there is a covenant on the property, we just wanted to start out by making sure that, [6:14] you know, we have, we shared that, you know, there is a sentiment in the city [6:18] and amongst staff in city council that preserving historic resources is important. [6:24] So you'll see that this development agreement looks a little bit different than other development [6:27] agreements as writer goes through the process, but really that is what we see as the significant [6:32] benefit of what the applicant team has come forth to offer. There are other things, you know, [6:38] there's TOT, there's property tax revenue, there's sales tax revenue, there is an additional [6:42] contribution to the affordable housing fund proposed. But just wanted to say that not every [6:47] development agreement is going to look alike and not every development agreement is going [6:53] to have the same terms and because it's all because there's different, there's different [6:57] gives and takes to get to your end goal. [6:59] So what we're proposing you to tonight is I think what is our end goal from the city's perspective [7:04] and you'll hear from the developer as well. [7:08] Thank you, Molly and thank you chair members of the commission. [7:11] So Franklin Station is an application consistent in multiple entitlements, some related to [7:16] of the Planning Commission in their recommendation to City Council, some relative to the cultural heritage commission and their recommendation ultimately to City Council. [7:25] Tonight, the application you're considering recommendation of is for multiple entitlements, including a development agreement, [7:32] A zoning amendment, a mending the planned development overlay PD-37 district, [7:38] a tentative parcel map and a design review permit and related approvals to provide for the redevelopment of an approximately 1.44 acre property, [7:47] with two five-story buildings consisting of up to 120 hotel rooms, up to 44 cell hotel units and other amenities, [7:54] and the preservation of Franklin Station post office. [7:57] The applicant is James Keller. [7:59] The project is located at 1251-1351. [8:02] Second Street, 820 Randolph Street, 801, 809, [8:06] Comstree, Unit A, B, C, and D. [8:09] The project location is located generally on the south east side [8:13] of Second Street, generally divided by Randolph Street. [8:17] The primary parcel generally referred to as the post office [8:21] redevelopment consists of the post office and the hotel. [8:25] and we'll get into more details regarding that. [8:28] The mixed use development and when I refer to mixed use development, [8:31] it's going to be the redevelopment of the parking lot parcel [8:35] with the inclusion of the three units that exist within the young building. [8:39] So, they're primarily the the parcels are located along second street [8:44] with frontages along Franklin and Randolph as well. [8:49] The right request entitlements include the planned development overlay PD37 amendment, [8:54] generally consists of different land use provisions, development standards, design guidelines to help facilitate redevelopment of this. [9:03] But in this, what you'll notice in this development agreement, [9:06] we relied a lot on the planned development overlay as kind of the teeth and setting the standard for [9:13] a mending specific processes that have been established by ordinance. [9:17] Part of that and just to paint the picture of the difference in the approvals. [9:22] The plan development overlay will kind of establish the up to amount kind of the maximum [9:29] development that could be constructed upon the property. [9:33] The design review permit and we'll get into more detail of that in the ten-to-parsum [9:37] app generally are facilitating the design that you see in front of you. [9:43] What the plan development overlay consists of the five story hotel building, including basement [9:47] rooftop structures in space with up to 120 rooms within that post office redevelopment with [9:53] some other food and beverage use of spa event fitness amenities, five story mixed use [9:58] building and clean rooftop space. [10:00] 744 hotel units, such units in the past were generally referred to as branded residential, but as part of that joint session of planning commission city council. [10:10] Both planning commission and city council generally saw due to the transient nature of these units that they were more so commercial uses in their eyes. [10:20] With that, when you get into the the minutia of the details that even ties the impact fees that are generally applied to the project for hotel uses. [10:29] That makes use building consists of those 37-4 cell hotel units with the inclusion of the [10:35] three condo units within the existing young building for a total of up to 44 cell hotel units. [10:41] You're considering the development agreement between the city of Napa and the developer tonight, [10:45] and that DA as Molly has suggested address certain conditions, procedures and implementations [10:51] among vesting certain rights for the developer. [10:55] The design review permit and consideration of a recommending adoption to City Council will consist [11:03] of a five-story upper upscale hotel with 94 hotel rooms, the same amenities that I've outlined, [11:10] and then redevelopment of that parking lot parcel that mixed use development with 25-4 cell hotel units, [11:16] ground floor parking, the inclusion of the three young building condo units. [11:22] The alternative parsimap generally, and it's part of the confusing ask is that there are existing [11:29] condo parcels that exist within that young building, but generally what's happened is the parking [11:35] lot parcel and the wine valley box unit parcel being merged to facilitate larger construction [11:40] and then a connection point in through to the young building. [11:44] Not under your purview tonight, but part of the entire development application also the cultural heritage commission will consider a certificate of appropriateness for alterations to the post office specifically and they'll get into the minutia of the historic resources. [12:04] But for context, you were provided with the certificate of appropriateness plans, because I think understanding the big picture of how it all ties together is important in this context. [12:17] We're considering the redevelopment of the Franklin Station post office. [12:22] In other words, it was renamed to the Thomas Kongs Guard Post Office, and in 2010, the [12:28] action by U.S. Congress, and then they had a ceremony in 2011, prior to the earthquake [12:35] that damaged the building. [12:39] Thomas Kongs Guard was the Napa Superior Court Judge serving for a substantial amount of [12:43] time within the community, and so U.S. Congress, and through Mike Thompson, did it in his [12:48] honor. [12:50] Generally, the post office time line is important to understand context was built in 1933, [12:55] architects William Wolk Coralette, and Walter Reed of the Oakland Farm Read and Coralette [12:59] designed the post office. [13:02] January 11th, 1985, it was added to the National Register of Historic Places, which had [13:09] identified certain historic features within that, and then generally the art deco style of [13:15] post office that you see even in its damaged form. In 2010, it was renamed to that Thomas [13:22] Kong's guard post office, but people generally still understand it as the Franklin Station [13:27] post office. August 24, 2014, South Napa Earthquake, substantially damaged the post office, [13:39] and shortly afterwards the U.S. Postal Service was considering demolishing it due to the [13:44] substantial cost that it would take to rehabilitate the structure. [13:49] But going through 2014, primarily into 2015, there were a lot of local efforts in saving [13:54] the post office, kind of spearheaded through many community leaders in the congressman Mike [14:00] Thompson and the postal service did agree and will get into the preservation covenant here [14:05] in a little bit to halt the demolition plans for the Franklin Station Post Office and consider [14:11] to pursue in a sale for the presentation post office. [14:16] Generally, the U.S. Postal Service initiated drafts [14:19] for what a preservation covenant would look like, [14:21] expectation to save that, not to get too far in the detail, [14:25] but there were inspections of the property that occurred [14:28] in through 2014-2015 that's really demonstrated [14:35] to the U.S. Park Service that the building was still [14:40] significant, that there was still a historical significance to it. [14:45] And so in through 2015, up to 2017, when that purchased by the applicant and later executed [14:51] the preservation covenant, [14:54] the post office was willing to consider that primarily because [14:58] of... [15:00] The intent to preserve it. So with the applicant's interest in purchasing the property and the interest in the community as a member of the community to re-evaluate, they took on the obligation with the third party to the city's not party to the preservation covenant with the Napa County landmarks, including the supplemental memo was the sport Napa County landmarks generally, but just understanding the context that there is a legal covenant, but the city is not party to that covenant. [15:30] In February 14th, 2017, there was an initial purchase and salary agreement of the Park-and-Lot [15:36] parcel to help facilitate redevelopment of the post office building in 2018. [15:43] Well, through 2017, really going into effect of 2018, is when the initial entitlements were approved [15:50] by City Council for the redevelopment of that post office, consisting of upper up story [15:55] hotel up to 163 hotel rooms and a mechanized parking garage on the parking lot parcel. [16:04] Through 2018, 2019, up through 2025, you'll see that we're amendments to the purchase [16:12] telegramment further amendments extending the development agreement and then an [16:22] July of 2025 for the project being considered in front of you today. [16:30] I already went into the preservation covenant a little bit, but it outlines specific historic [16:35] and significant features within the post office, not necessarily under the purview of the [16:41] planning commission, but still important for context. [16:45] He project components include the rehabilitation depth of reuse of the structure in the five [16:53] of the parking lot parcel for the up to 40 units, [16:58] 37 and the three inclusive of the young building. [17:01] On-site parking facilities, the ground level, [17:03] and some retail ground level of that. [17:05] The hotel building generally has many different amenities, [17:08] food beverage facilities, basement, bar, rooftop bar, [17:14] event space, and other spa space. [17:18] To get into the meet of the request in front of you tonight, a lot of detail went into the [17:27] plan development overlay amendment. [17:30] The term for cell hotel units based off of feedback received from both planning commission [17:35] city council is what was generally referred to as those branded residential units. [17:39] Further defined those is individually owned units that are developed conveyed operators [17:43] part of the hotel that rely upon the hotel's management services staff and [17:47] amenities for their use and operation. [17:50] It's important to understand owners may occupy these units. [17:53] They may live their full time. [17:55] But if they choose to only live their part of the time, they may [17:58] rent it back through the hotel for periods of shorter than 30 days. [18:02] In the eyes of the city, transient nature, all subject to transient [18:07] occupancy taxes. [18:10] Then another term is lock off. [18:12] So hotel room hotel unit, four cell hotel unit that is designed and constructed with a local internal door or connection that permits a portion of the hotel room or that four cell hotel unit to be separated and occupied independently as a separate hotel room. [18:28] There's an eyes of how we define a lock-off. [18:32] It's typical hotels where you have a shared door [18:34] between your hotel room and another hotel room. [18:37] Maybe rented separately, but sometimes, [18:39] if you have a bigger party, you can have a room [18:43] where you can open up doors in between, same concept here. [18:47] In RIs, when it gets into the parking standards required, [18:52] in generally that cap of the 120 hotel rooms, [18:55] lock-offs are considered hotel rooms under that analysis. [19:01] The PD overlay also defines joint incidental entertainment uses consistently the downtown specific plan. [19:07] If it's incidental to the hotel, it's permitted between hours of 10am and 12am. [19:14] Should there be other considerations, should they request deviations from that in the future? [19:20] They would have to generally conform to the downtown specific plan table [19:23] and processes for that. Outdoor entertainment specifically, because of how new wants outdoor [19:30] entertainment is still subject to an administrative permit through the directors level, [19:36] as long as it complies with the other standards of the downtown specific plan, if it exceeds [19:40] those standards, it would generally conform to the use permit process, which would be seen [19:46] in front of the planning commission. But if it conformed to those standards, it would be [19:53] of those establishes design guidelines for the materials use, the step-back consideration. [20:00] The new edition and the context in the juxtaposition with the old building that's being preserved. [20:10] The plan development over that also establishes parking standards and or refers to the downtown [20:16] specific land for parking standards. [20:19] So project parking, specifically for the 4 cell hotel units and the lock-off units, shall [20:25] be provided on-site or via recorded irrevocable license or easement, that license or easement [20:33] would be for a non-city property with a minimum term of 30 years from the hotel building [20:39] certificate of occupancy, it incorporates with the standards outlined above you, which is the [20:44] parking space per each four cell hotel unit and the 0.8 spaces per lock-off unit that's rounded [20:50] up to the nearest one. Payment of parking development impact fees also apply to the hotel rooms [20:57] generally at 0.8 spaces per hotel room rounded up to the nearest one and then all other uses [21:04] generally parked per the downtown specific plan. And parking for other uses may also be satisfied [21:11] either on-site through recorded irrevocable licensed or easement for a minimum of 30 years, [21:16] non-city property or the applicant may secure approval by the city council on a parking [21:22] license agreement on city owned property. The project amendments and this overlay authorize [21:28] many approvals through the Community Resources and Development Director up to that cap of the [21:44] So that applies to maps, that applies to use permits, applies to the design review permit. [21:51] And then project phasing when we refer to phase one will generally be referring to the post office [21:57] redevelopment phase two. [21:59] If it, and this is if it was to be phase, it would be the mixed use development. [22:03] There are also sunset provisions for obligations that the developer must meet in terms of [22:09] receiving a building permit to be issued, and then substantially constructing, meaning receiving [22:15] another TCO or certificate of occupancy. So, a temporary certificate of occupancy or [22:20] certificate of occupancy for the construction of those buildings. Generally, if they were to [22:24] be phase the hotel building, so post office redevelopment will need to be completed first. [22:31] The priority is the preservation of the post office. The table in front of you and in that [22:37] attachment also goes over the building form standards, so up to 40 floor area ratio, which [22:46] is consistent with the downtown specific plan, but it excludes those subterranean areas. [22:51] Building height max 60 feet, but there are allowances for up to 75 feet for the rooftop [22:57] features that are further defined. [22:59] Front step back is generally max of 15, but because of the historic significant features of [23:07] post office, the building and the massing of the building on both sides have been set back a little bit further [23:15] to emphasize the historical significance of that kind of front third of the post office building. [23:23] So in instances where that massing is intended to be for that purpose, the set back may be greater. [23:31] But it's also understood that space isn't underutilized, it would also be activated as part [23:37] of that frontage. [23:38] It's although the buildings back, it's still generally like a restaurant on one side of [23:44] events, based on the other of that call attention to the space behind it. [23:50] The plan development overlay district map boundaries in the action, if taken by City Council, [23:58] recommended by the Planning Commission would actually be revoking the current boundaries [24:03] of the PD-37 overlay map, which includes that A's hardware parcel to kind of the southeast [24:10] adjoining the property and including the young building as part of it. As far as the development [24:19] agreement, the key benefit of the development agreement really is the rehabilitation of the [24:25] administration post office, the rehabilitation comes at a substantial cost, but there are also [24:30] other benefits of the Transi occupancy tax revenue. And during those initial five years, [24:35] it's estimated the project is expected to generate over 18 million in city allocated tax revenues. [24:41] The applicant is also agreed to paying the hotel motel rate of $6 per square foot for the [24:47] entirety of the project, plus an additional dollar per square foot upon close of each four-cell hotel unit. [24:55] site plan generally shown here, so parcels generally differ. [25:00] Provided by Randolph Street, post office redevelopment to the left to the west, and it makes [25:05] to use development to the right. [25:09] Shown here, kind of bird's eye view, from up above, post office redevelopment called out [25:16] here, located along Franklin Street, second street in Randolph Street. Access to certain [25:22] trash facilities will be located along Franklin Street. Access to the main entrances of the [25:27] building will be off of second street. Same thing with the mixed use development. A lot of [25:36] the entrances will focus on second street with certain service doors and intruates for [25:42] trash collection such located along Randolph Street. Ingress to the garage will be located [25:48] along second street and then certain retail facilities on the ground floor. [25:57] I won't get too far [25:58] And to the details of the architecture and the materials, because that's kind of the intention [26:02] of the applicant's presentation tonight, so I'll let their team generally go into [26:08] the nuances of the materials. [26:10] But substantial consideration and re-looking at how the new additions can fit in the context [26:18] of the historic preservation of the post office. [26:22] There were a lot of key considerations reflected, especially in that certificate of appropriate [26:26] in this document, but also in the project plans generally. [26:30] This is a view from the north side, [26:33] made off his second street facing post office redevelopment. [26:37] South side, so like angle from third street [26:40] back towards the, so it'd be facing north, [26:44] puts the south elevation, [26:46] the post office redevelopment, [26:49] west elevation and east elevation. [26:54] I mean, the post office redevelopment, [26:55] floor plan, there's speak easy on the bottom [26:57] in a lot of back of health space in the basement of the building. [27:04] The first floor plan generally includes lobby, ballroom event space, back of house, [27:09] for that restaurant and other facilities, and then a three-mill restaurant and fine dining. [27:15] It's understand as part of their outreach to different brands, [27:20] that there will be some fluctuation in the floor plan just to facilitate that. [27:25] but the intent is to still stay within the confines of what you see in the footprint of what you see and the overall massing. [27:33] Getting to the second floor, more event space, rooms for the hotel, spa facilities, rooms, third-level, fourth-level, fifth-level, and then rooftop, [27:46] which includes a pool terrace and rooftop bar, and then different gathering opportunities. [27:52] It makes a use development in elevations from second street, facing south, the north elevation. [27:59] You'll see access to the garage down below. [28:03] The south elevation, so it's facing north, just want to understand that there were considerations in discussion, [28:09] and there isn't general interest to discuss this facade here tonight in other considerations. [28:16] If you have any questions, I had some discussions with the chief building official, but the [28:21] applicants team also provide response to that. [28:24] There's a zero lot line here, so there are certain limitations to how you can build limitations [28:30] on openings generally, because the fire rated construction. [28:35] But understanding that there's an interest to maybe elevate or some variation to these walls. [28:41] It's the waste, the west elevation, the general screening to the parking facilities, right [28:47] here in a living wall, and the east elevation, mixed use development, entry to the ground [28:55] level parking facilities. [28:58] You'll get into that second level, getting to some of those 4 cell hotel units, and access [29:04] to the young building, which I'll show you in just a moment. [29:08] The third level, fourth level, fifth level, and then the rooftop because it's put out in other [29:14] gathering space opportunities. [29:16] Young buildings shown here, from that second level, showing access to how you get to those [29:21] three condo units, that will be converted to the four cell hotel units, and the tenor [29:28] of parcel map generally merging the parcels that you see between the parking lot parcel [29:31] and the wine valley box unit parcel. [29:35] With the consideration that either is equal, staff recommends planning commission recommends that [29:41] the City Council finds the project would not have an environmental impacts, and that [29:46] those effects were not examined in the Downtown Napa Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report, [29:51] and that the project is within the scope of the development program analyzed in the Downtown [29:55] Napa Specific Plan EIR, and that no subsequent EIR is required for the... [30:00] The project as document in attachment 9, and that there's a project mitigation monitoring report as exhibit A of that, and alternatively, that the project is exempt from SQL under SQL guidelines section 15332, class 32 exemption. [30:18] In consideration of your recommendation to city council, these are the findings you must make for a zoning amendment. [30:24] for any amendments to the Plan Development Overlay must make these findings for the [30:29] Zoning Amendment in addition to these Plan Development Overlay findings to amend that [30:34] PD overlay. [30:36] Further considering and retouching on what Molly referred to, they have opportunity to [30:42] pursue a development agreement, consistent with both the government code section and [30:46] NAPA Municipal Code Section 1752150 in considering the design review permit for those 94 and the [30:54] the 25 and 8 and other amenity space and your recommendation to city council shall establish [31:02] these findings and for the tenet of parcel map you shall establish these findings and not [31:08] make or have the ability to make these findings which would require you to consider denying it. [31:16] With that that concludes my presentation, staff recommends that the Planning Commission for the recommendation to City Council as outlined in the staff report. [31:26] City staffs here tonight, members of the applicant's team here tonight, to facilitate any questions you have. [31:32] We have a legal team both on teams and in front of you at Dan Dportos of Kylie Auto on teams and in Dan Dporto here tonight. [31:40] Thank you. [31:42] Thank you, writer. [31:43] Any commissioners have any questions for staff at this time? [31:48] I just need clarification on one item. [31:51] Right, or thank you, that was outstanding. [31:54] So incredibly thorough. [31:56] I just wanted to get the actual sunset provisions for the phase one. [32:04] You mentioned it, but not the timeline. [32:07] Yes. So sunset provisions are as follows. [32:10] So, over they shall remain in effect until October 1st, 2029, unless phase 1 has obtained complete building permits. [32:19] October 1st, 2030, unless phase 2 has obtained complete building permits. [32:25] October 1st, 2032, unless phase 1 has obtained a certificate of occupancy, [32:31] and October 1st, 23, unless phase 2 is obtained a certificate of occupancy. [32:36] So if both phase one and phase two have obtained all certificate of occupancies, [32:42] this overlay shall remain valid until emitted by city council. [32:47] Sure, go ahead. [32:51] Sorry, I didn't mean to cut your off. [32:52] I didn't know if that was. [32:53] No, go ahead. [32:54] I have a couple of questions, Raider. [32:57] Can you pull up your parking slide? [33:13] A big part of this is the parking, because this is a major change. [33:17] Kind of maybe only major change from the last. [33:22] development agreement and your slide says that the park is to be provided on site or via [33:31] an irrevocable license or agreement shall provide parking on site and irrevocable license [33:40] or easement. [33:43] That is a little different than what the development agreement says which kind [33:50] talks about an agreement to agree, and I'm just concerned if is the presentation in consistent with the development agreement or is the development agreement? [34:06] Maybe talking about more contingent scenarios than the presentation is talking about because it's unusual not necessarily wrong by any means, [34:20] But I'm unusual to not have the parking figured out, necessarily. [34:26] And I'm just kind of just going right for it here, [34:27] because this is the biggest shoot of me. [34:31] So I just was hoping you could clarify what's in maybe [34:38] lay language for my benefit. [34:42] What's the real plan? [34:43] Sure. [34:44] I can take that question. [34:46] Commissioner Myers. [34:47] I think it's the latter of the two things that you said that this presentation doesn't necessarily reflect everything that is included in the DA. [34:54] So, if there's something that's not fully there in one of the two, it's proper. [35:01] So there's a couple of components to the parking. And I mean, if you since you just called it out, the parking is not fully resolved. At this moment, in time, there are options to resolve the parking on the table, or discussions still going to resolve the parking. So the developer has to provide on-site or via the irrevocable license or easement. And those words are very important to us at the city of Napa. [35:30] We have several projects that have come in with short-term agreements for parking and then the [35:36] person who owns the parking wants to do something different five years later and it puts the [35:40] parking for the projects that got approved at Jeopardy. We're dealing with a situation about that right now. [35:45] So the irrevocable term of 30 years comes consistent with what if the city were to do a license agreement, [35:51] the minimum number of years we would do would be 30 years. So just for that purpose of that. [35:57] So there are kind of three parts to the parking. [35:59] The first is the developer has to provide one parking [36:03] mute spot per for sale hotel unit on site or via some agreement [36:09] with a private property owner. [36:11] It can be off site, but it won't be in a city owned parcel. [36:15] They also have to provide 0.8 rounded up for either on site [36:20] or on some private agreement not involving the city of Napa [36:23] for each lock off unit. [36:25] So that's sort of part one. [36:26] So if you think about how, if they did 40 units of for sale and five lockoffs, they'd have to do 45 parking spaces through either their own provision on site or through some sort of private agreement that the city is not involved in. [36:42] Then you have the hotel rooms and you have the staffing and you have the ballrooms and the rest of that. [36:47] So take out, you're not talking about the for sale unit, but you're talking about the post office building. [36:51] The way that the DA is written right now is they will simply pay the impact fee and not have access to parking [36:59] They will have access to city parking like anybody else has access to city parking [37:06] The city is also agreeing to continue discussing the possibility of [37:12] Leasing spaces to the developer to have least spaces for those hotel rooms and for that site on the post office [37:21] But at this time, we cannot commit to providing parking based on our current parking studies and what we're going through. [37:27] We are working through a project to look at potentially acquiring more land or developing a parking garage. [37:35] But at this moment in time, we cannot commit to providing parking because of where we are in our parking counts downtown. [37:41] If you want to dive into that a little bit more, we do have our parking manager. [37:44] I should say our co-compliance manager who wins our parking programs here in the audience. [37:49] It's not really part of the approvals tonight, but I do think to your point or your question, [37:55] if I'm answering it correctly, is at this point the only parking there are they are required [38:01] to provide relates to the one for one for the four sale and point eight rounded up for each [38:07] walk off. Otherwise, the parking is non-exclusive through the impact fee, and less between now [38:16] and the opening of the hotel, the city, and the developer reach some sort of licensing [38:20] agreement, or, or I guess the alternative was they find it through a private operator, as well, [38:26] too, and then they would not have to pay the in Luffy. They would just go private or build it on [38:31] on somewhere else, yeah. What's the in Loufrey? It is currently, I think it's $23,000. [38:38] First base. First base. How much does it cost to build a parking space? That's what we [38:42] don't know yet. So that we are in the middle of doing a study with in a parking garage analysis [38:51] at which point we will likely change the impact fee or recommend that the city gets to recommend [38:56] that the city council change the impact fee at that time. We know of cities that it's [39:01] across anywhere from 50,000, that includes the land. [39:05] So if you assume it's a city owned parcel, [39:07] the cost of build is a little bit less to depending [39:10] on what the cost of acquisition is up to 120,000. [39:14] But that's the information the city doesn't have now. [39:17] And that is the reason one of the reasons why the city [39:20] cannot commit at this moment to providing exclusive use [39:23] parking for the site. [39:25] If the impact fee is subsequently increased, would that apply to this project? [39:33] The way that it is written right now, the development agreement locks in the current impact fees, all of them, not just parking impact. [39:41] It locks in housing at its current rate. [39:43] It locks in the paramedic and fire fee. [39:47] It locks in the street and utilities fees, and then it locks in the parking impact fee. [39:53] But if at least so I should just say that's if they choose if there's no exclusive use of agreement and exclusive [40:00] Service agreement is completely subject to negotiation on what the term will be for the number of years [40:06] and what the amount to per year presumably would be for that. So it doesn't have to be the same [40:11] amount as the impact fee. The impact fee at this moment in time is simply if they chose to pay the [40:21] impact fee rather than provide parking on site, or we didn't come up with a lease, an alternate [40:26] least agreement. Is the impact fee option. They're right to elect or is that a negotiated [40:37] part of this set of terms. That is an negotiated part of that. So it's not that any applicant [40:43] could say I'm I'm not building park and I'm just going to pay the 23 per spot. It's just that [40:48] that is an option in this deal. So no let me let me clarify what I said. The $23,000 rate [40:55] and walking into a place is an option and then a negotiation in this. [40:58] If someone came in tomorrow through the regular entitlement process, [41:02] let's say they wanted to build a restaurant downtown. [41:05] And so they're in certain streets, which is where this flies, [41:08] and I think Redder's going to pull up the picture for you. [41:11] But if you're in the downtown parking exempt district, [41:14] you do not have to provide parking on site, [41:16] because you are saying you're going to instead use the public facilities [41:19] that are available. [41:20] So if a restaurant came in tomorrow with an application, [41:23] and they were just going to the regular entitlement process. [41:26] They would pay the $23,000 for each parking spot that they didn't provide, that they [41:31] are required to provide based on whatever the square footage calculation that applies [41:35] to their, and the staffing that applies to their situation. [41:39] So does that answer your question? [41:41] You look, they restraught analogy through me a little bit, because usually they would [41:46] lease that spot. [41:48] So do people, that's a whole set of things. [41:49] If anyone came in, let's just say, let's just say someone bought [41:54] Carothers because Carothers is something the market tomorrow. [41:56] Let's use that as like an example. [41:58] And they were going to change the use of Carothers. [42:02] And they have a parking requirement. [42:04] They would have to pay the impact fee of $23,000 as part of their building [42:09] permit process as well, regardless of whether or not they had a development [42:12] agreement. [42:13] So the impact fee does not is not specific to the development agreement. [42:18] And to add to that, I won't go into the map just yet until I have a visual that's just [42:26] easier for people to understand the boundaries of the parking example for the district. [42:31] But we have a chapter within the Title 17 of the Napha Municipal Code that speaks to, if you're [42:38] within the boundaries of the parking example district, when you shall provide on-site parking [42:44] and you always typically have the ability to provide on-site parking through a use permit, [42:50] or in other circumstances of residential development and then transit uses where you're required to [42:56] provide on-site parking for that development. So there's a section that speaks to when it's required [43:05] and then when an impact fee would generally be paid. What does it say about transit uses on-site? [43:12] usually is the standard. [43:15] Yes, that's a good point. [43:16] Thank you, right? [43:16] That we are, we're kind of putting a pin in the parking at this point in time. [43:21] Well, I'm just concerned that the pin is not a very robust one. [43:27] If the option is get at least for parking for 30 years or pay half the price of building parking [43:35] or negotiate something else. [43:37] To me, you're going to go with the most economically efficient one, sure, so that it's sort of an order of preference, right? [43:45] Lease, pay, or negotiate and build. [43:50] But if, if hotels ought not to have the in-loop fee, because that's a lot of parking on a counted four, then [44:08] why is that an option? [44:11] I think that that might be a question we want to ask the applicant team in a few minutes [44:17] or now if you'd like because I think that they need to explain to you how parking and [44:24] the project kind of all come together. If they've just paid the in Luffy they would not have [44:29] exclusive UCs which means they would have spaces which mean Valle would be pretty impossible [44:33] and all of those things and it potentially could have I want them to speak to their operations. [44:37] I'm not a hotel operator, so I want them to speak to their, how it impacts their operations. [44:42] I don't know that the question, I don't know that just paying the in Luffy is a viable option. [44:49] Well, it doesn't seem to be one, but it seems to be the second most enticing one. [44:53] So I guess we'll let them speak to that when it's their journey. [44:55] I think that it would be better for them to get to it from the operational perspective. [44:58] We can come back up like happy. [45:00] We come back to it with questions, but I think that it's okay. That part of the story is getting out of our [45:03] skis on something, but not that of parking arrangement that is not perfectly dialed in advances [45:13] in okay. I mean, I think it's fine to have options in the alternative, but I thought that [45:20] maybe it would be a little more. A little more. It is certainly within the purview of your [45:28] commission to remove that sort of second middle option and leave it as you have to figure out [45:33] your parking, which is either you enter into a lease with the city of Napa, or you enter into [45:39] a private use lease on another site. You could strike that from your recommendation if you like. [45:45] Okay, and then changing gears entirely then, the south facade of the building, the big wall. [45:55] Usually when you see that sort of a big blank wall, it is in the context of either a building [46:02] which used to have a neighbor or a building which was contemplating a neighbor. [46:07] So in the case of this south wall is there, obviously it didn't use to have a 60-foot tall [46:17] So is there an intent in the downtown specific plan and the city's view that the [46:26] buildings adjacent to that south elevation are going to be getting taller? [46:35] I think it would be speculation a little bit, but downtown specific plan would allow for it. [46:42] The way it would be designed would require to conform to California building code requirements, [46:48] which is how fire rated construction requirements for zero-lot line. [46:52] So there are considerations I think that applicants team have to make for both egress, [46:59] and then the form of construction use to maximize the amount of space within the confines of the property. [47:07] So if for some reason they were to recess portions and I'll let them speak to why they [47:13] designed it the way they designed it, it could assume that there could be construction [47:19] up to 60 feet because the downtown specific plan allows for it. [47:23] But as of right now we don't have an application for that. [47:27] And then last question for me is to verify and just to this is for a recommendation to the [47:35] it's not a final determination. [47:37] It is not a final determination. [47:38] It is not a final determination. [47:39] It is not a final determination. [47:41] And dependent also on a recommendation from [47:44] Pultsial Heritage Commission. [47:47] Okay. [47:48] I'm done. Thanks. [47:50] Do any other commissioners have any additional questions for staff? [47:54] I do as well. [47:56] Okay. [47:56] Go ahead, Commissioner Eva. [47:59] Right, when you were mentioning the south, the south of the buildings and what is and is not permissible in terms of the building code and fire rating, what are some types of architectural features or articulation that would be permitted. [48:16] And if that's a question for the the project architect that's fine too. [48:21] Well, it's on my mind, I want to ask. [48:25] What I will say is, as to not miss quote, there are certain fire-rated construction [48:31] requirements within three feet of that property line to assume that if the building next [48:39] door to them burns down for any reason that there are certain ratings that prevent it from [48:44] going to the next building. [48:47] But if it's beyond the three feet, there are other allowances that they could have certain [48:51] openings that they could have, and it really depends on how they program the occupancy [48:58] of the space behind it, as well, of whether it needs egress or not. [49:02] But to not go too far into the details, they're all at the architect and the applicant team [49:07] understand their considerations of why they designed it, the way they designed it. [49:11] But there are theoretically options for not entirely for screen. [49:14] Yeah, they could effectively step back in certain areas, recess or in areas to give them [49:21] ability to have other openings. They're probably other material considerations, paint, variation, [49:26] considerations. Yeah. Thank you. And then I'd like to move back to impact fees real quick. [49:33] If you don't mind, [49:36] it was mentioned that you're currently undergoing or cities and currently [49:40] undergoing a study of impact fees, is that correct for all impact fees? All impact fees. [49:47] And as the developers agreement is written now, as proposed, those impact fees would lock in grant. [49:56] And so should there be a change, should we decide that there's a... [50:00] That there is a nexus to increase that amount. That would not be reflected. [50:07] The way that the development agreement is written, yes, it locks or proposed tonight. It locks the impact fees today. [50:15] In place, I don't have, unfortunately, an estimated time. In fact, fees are, you know, from a significant undertaking and it's better to bring them all together. [50:27] and the case the city is opted to bring them all together so everybody's working through their pieces. [50:32] Maybe by the end of the year, but that's ambitious, I think, at this point. [50:36] Okay, and I understand where this six dollars per square foot number comes from, [50:42] but would you mind speaking to where the one dollar per square foot for the ownership units? [50:48] I realize not all development agreements are alike, [50:52] but when we have seasonal projects, they've been at a rate of two dollars. [50:55] Could you speak to that three? [50:56] Yeah, so the required impact fee is at the $6 rate for, and then we, as we talked about with the Planning Commission in the City Council in the joint session, that we apply the hotel motel rate to even the for sale, because which was it residential and so the hotel motel rate gets applied to the entirety of both buildings in this case, because we'd pick one use. [51:19] The addition of one dollar is what was discussed between city staff and the applicant. [51:26] The like development, the two last like development agreements for hotel projects. [51:31] It was a two dollar additional rate. [51:33] It's not, it doesn't come from anywhere. [51:35] It was offered originally by the Stanley Ranch development. [51:39] And then I believe it was actually at the city council meeting [51:42] meeting when for first straight the city council asks them to add, ask them both to go to the full, [51:49] to go to the sixth dollar rate for the condos, which we've now applied sort of as a general [51:53] standard for the fourth sale, and then ask them to match that $2 and they agreed at the [51:58] dias at that point. So it was an originally written into the first straight agreement. [52:04] Okay, thank you. [52:11] Sorry, one more question. [52:14] Right, or you were speaking to some of the changes that could be made at the community development [52:18] director's discretion. [52:21] Do those include minor design changes as well? [52:24] Yeah, as the way it's written, if the design substantially conforms to the design [52:33] in front of you tonight. [52:34] Massing is really important here. [52:36] there's overlap into the CHE's consideration and their recommendation to city council [52:42] of why the massing was the way the massing was. So it's important to understand [52:47] expectation is that the massing would effectively stay the same. [52:54] There may be some shifting in and around access to the service dock for the waste [53:03] So there may be some shifting there, that flexibility was written into the draft conditions to allow for [53:09] staff to understand if it is specifically ties to accessing trash facilities. [53:14] If there is a shift in the building, but generally the floor plan, [53:22] there is a lot that can occur in minor shifts within the boundaries of the footprint, [53:27] but the spaces will still have to be programmed as envisioned. [53:30] it's just to the up to amount. So if for some reason it changes from 94 hotel rooms up to [53:39] 120, that's within the authority of the director as is drafted. And what about if the [53:45] when there is a hotel partner selected, they have like a similar case we had before requirement [53:50] for a different type of balcony or window or something like that, is that able to be made that [53:56] change at the staff level? [53:59] Yeah, so if it's like number of balconies because of the number of hotel rooms that are [54:03] changing, generally the materials are the same projections in the space or generally pretty [54:09] similar. [54:11] Yes, certain findings like that could be made at the staff level as well. [54:15] Thank you. [54:18] Commissioner Shawa, [54:23] you won't like my question, Molly, where are we with the garage feasibility [54:29] study, when do you anticipate having that in the books? [54:34] I'm going to see if Tony Valeda's our Code Compliance Manager can give you, and then I'll go with the then what, but he can tell you about the study. [54:54] Sorry, Tony Valeda's Compliance Manager. [54:56] So we're currently working on the feasibility. [55:00] We just completed our public outreach just two, three weeks ago. We plan to go to city council in August, and then again in October. [55:10] The plan is to make a termination on which site is most feasible, so that's kind of where we are with the study. [55:17] Do you want to, since it came up and we said, if we come up, we'd have you do it. Would you want to talk about where we are kind of in parking right now in the downtown area, based on our demand counts? [55:26] Yeah, we did a parking demand study last year. [55:30] Our consultant basically came to the determination that once the first street face to project [55:35] comes to completion during peak weekdays around 12 o'clock when a clock we're hitting [55:40] about 85% threshold of the available parking spaces being utilized. [55:47] Industry standard is once you hit about 85% threshold you start getting to the point where [55:51] people feel that they cannot find any more parking spaces. [55:55] You don't typically want to go all the way to 100% capacity because that means you have absolutely nothing left. [56:02] So that is assuming the full completion of the first street face-to-project of the corner of the first and main. [56:08] That basically means any additional parking spaces taken offline if we're looking at more than 100 parking spaces somewhere in the vicinity of about 150 to 120 total parking spaces taken out of [56:24] probably getting very close to that 100% threshold during peak times during the week. [56:30] So, you know, that's assuming all other conditions remain the same, but that's basically [56:35] the termination from our consultant. [56:39] And just, [56:41] if the bill goes a lot, what is converted to condos that takes an additional 55 [56:48] off before you replace the parking, I mean it adds 44 to the buildings that's in that [56:52] of 10, it's a, not loss of 55 parking, public parking spaces, but a total loss of 10 ish [57:00] depending on what they can fit on site parking spaces period. So we're looking at not only the [57:06] spaces that are needed but the loss of lot of, the loss of lot be. What I would just add is, [57:11] you know, the city at this point is considering whether or not to purchase additional land or [57:17] where to potentially look at building a new parking garage. I'll give you a little spoiler alert. [57:22] It's not likely we're going to be able to build economic, you know, in an [57:26] feasible way on anything that the city owns currently. [57:30] So we're looking and having to acquire a property and where that is yet. [57:34] We don't know. [57:34] So that will be something that the city council will discuss. [57:37] But then we have to finance a parking garage structure. [57:40] And that is where the applicant and the developer may become part of the solution is, [57:44] you know, similar to a tax share agreement or similar to some sort of public [57:48] have a partnership like the first street hotel, there could be an option in there. [57:53] So we kind of, the steps are, comes in August at that point we get some direction as to [57:58] what to do in terms of potentially acquiring new spots, then we go into what is building [58:02] look like, although the study will show options on each of the lots that we can potentially [58:07] purchase and how many parking spaces and what the anticipated cost would be, then we would [58:12] have to go into figuring out the financing of that. [58:15] I, we do not have the cash in the bank at this moment in time for a complete, a complete [58:21] build of a parking garage, but we do know that we've got some revenue coming in from various [58:27] lease agreements. We might have some funding capacity because of our infrastructure EIFD, that [58:33] we have, so those are all of the things that were still working out, which is kind of why [58:38] we can't today say we have this to provide you at this point in time. [58:43] I'm sorry Tony, could you restate the scenario where we're approaching 100% parking capacity? [58:54] Sure, so again, this is assuming multiple different variables, but assuming nothing changes with parking demand, [59:01] assuming that during peak periods, 12 o'clock, when a clock, during the week, if we lose an additional say 115 to 120 total parking spaces, [59:10] we're getting pretty close to the threshold of demand meeting the actual inventory that we have [59:15] available for public parking. And what's the condition in which we lose those spots? [59:20] If we were to lease, if we were to agree to lease them now, we would be at a hundred percent. [59:26] Oh, I see. So today we are at 80 to 85 percent depending on the parking garage. [59:33] And so when you get to that, that's sort of considered full parking standards. If we were to lease [59:38] If we were to lease an additional 100 now, let's just say we're getting close. [59:43] That would tap. [59:44] We would be out. [59:45] Then it would be, yes, [59:49] I was going to say something. [59:51] What was it? [59:53] I'll think of it. [59:53] It had to do with parking. [59:55] I'll think of it. [1:00:01] I think this is just another great opportunity for me to recommend to anyone who's interested in the subject to read paved paradise, it's fascinating. [1:00:14] It will change the way you think about parking in the future and how much we actually might need. [1:00:20] or not. I remembered what I was going to say if you don't mind share. If something were to change [1:00:26] like driverless autonomous vehicles came to Napa, you know, wemo has does have the authority [1:00:32] to do it. If they decided tomorrow that they were going to implement in Napa, that could change [1:00:35] our parking demand. So it's not just about looking at what could be potentially provided through a [1:00:40] parking for through acquisition through the city and what the city might be able to build. [1:00:45] There are situations that could change our demand and change our parking management at that point. [1:00:49] Just throwing that out there, that the only option isn't necessarily building a parking garage. [1:00:54] There are options that could be considered, should there be something like that that changes our parking demand to on time? [1:01:02] Commissioner Missara? [1:01:04] All right, just one clarification on the parking. [1:01:10] Where we talk about getting to that 100% threshold, we're talking about if we release them today. [1:01:16] But we're actually not going to be losing those spaces if we release them for a few more years. [1:01:20] So we're not exactly at our 100% capacity yet with this decision, [1:01:30] right? [1:01:32] Assuming, yes, so we're assuming that the demand stays the same into the future. [1:01:38] I cannot, I don't feel a staff that we can comfortably recommend sitting here today that we lease anything more than like 10. [1:01:50] You know, marking spaces at this point, but certainly the amount related to, if we're talking [1:01:55] about this project, they might relate it to this project. [1:01:58] What I am saying is, as we look at increasing supply or changing demand, the opportunity [1:02:04] potentially presents itself depending on what can be worked out and what the council would [1:02:10] recommend. [1:02:10] But if we recommended it today, yes, it wouldn't be an instant impact, because the least [1:02:17] would not actually start until the hotel units were occupied, but it's nothing more to change. [1:02:25] So, a gamble, I guess, in a little bit of a sense that, and why, from a staff perspective, [1:02:32] we're saying the conversation is very relevant, remains on the table, certainly something [1:02:36] we would like to try to do, but we have our pieces to still figure out. [1:02:43] Any additional questions from a commissioner? [1:02:46] Just one more. [1:02:49] In the DA, in the parking section, it references that the parking would be planned in accordance [1:02:56] with Exhibit F. And there is no Exhibit F, but Exhibit F is the project description. [1:03:04] That's somewhere else. I'm looking at section 4.4. [1:03:12] And it refers down to exhibit F, and I didn't know if I just missed it. [1:03:16] We removed, no, we removed the parking exhibits because we stated what the language, so that [1:03:21] must just be, [1:03:25] I'm going to Kylie, if you can hear, I think that was just a language cleanup [1:03:29] we're going to have to make. [1:03:31] Which part? [1:03:32] Yeah, that was a section four. [1:03:34] Will you roll? [1:03:36] Hi, this is Kylie Otto, I worked on the development agreement with staff, that is a error. [1:03:42] It was supposed to be removed. [1:03:44] The topic that is below a section 4.4.1 was contained in the exhibit F. [1:03:50] We simply rolled it into the agreement text itself. [1:03:53] So we will make a note pick that out. [1:03:55] So thank you for catching that. [1:03:56] Didn't mean to point out a script nurse error. [1:04:00] No, we appreciate it. [1:04:02] It was a last minute change, so yes, thank you for correcting that. [1:04:07] Other Mr. things a bit. [1:04:08] Thank you. [1:04:12] Anything else, lawyers? [1:04:14] No. [1:04:14] No, for real now. [1:04:17] All right, Raider. [1:04:23] All right, this is the time where I ask if the applicant [1:04:25] would like to speak, but I know we will be receiving [1:04:28] an application. [1:04:29] I did receive some correspondence from the applicant [1:04:32] requesting a 12 minute time limit, and I do think that is fair, [1:04:35] given the volume of information we are hearing tonight. [1:04:59] Testing test. [1:05:00] Thank you. Good evening, Chair. Really quickly, thank you for the time. The 12 minute acknowledging [1:05:08] that. I'm wondering if it would be helpful, just maybe to reserve a little time and address [1:05:12] that parking question a little bit right now. Just to touch on it informally, we could say that [1:05:17] for later, or could quickly do that. Sure, we can touch on that right now. So I think taking a quick step [1:05:24] back. And my name is Jeff Dodd. I'm here on behalf of the Franklin Station team. [1:05:29] This along with the Jim Keller and David Oliver and our architecture team from Bar [1:05:35] Architects and Mark Holbert for a preservation architecture architecture. [1:05:42] But take us back on the parking issue. The downtown NAPA specific plan has a parking [1:05:47] plan. The main principle is taking us back and looking at the land use policies behind it. [1:05:51] Maybe a little bit talking about, you know, pay paradise, conceptual alignment there is initially the [1:05:58] plan is we don't want to have individual lots have their own parking. [1:06:02] We don't want each business to have their own parking, we want to centralize parking and [1:06:08] really maximize the space and do so through public parking garages. [1:06:13] And through that as part of that, we're going to incorporate this parking exemplary and we're [1:06:17] going to have business owners pay into that fee and ultimately utilize those parking [1:06:22] And Molly had acknowledged that, you know, there certainly is a lot of, I wouldn't say a lot of maybe there's there's there's funds there available maybe not to build an entire entire entire parking the new parking garage. [1:06:36] But there are a lot of things in motion right now, I think they could make that whole to realize that new parking garage. [1:06:42] I mentioned that point because from a practical reality with respect to this project, there is no realistic possibility where this hotel would be solely reliant on a parking impact fee. [1:06:58] Any sort of hotel operator will need to have parking spaces. [1:07:02] And we're talking about an upper upscale operation, so the idea that you would have an upper [1:07:08] upscale operator, have their guests go spin around the block or have their valet, park in [1:07:12] the middle of the street, it's just not feasible, it's not the type of operation that [1:07:17] we're contemplating for this project. [1:07:20] So while it is an option and it's called out as an option, it's not really a realistic or [1:07:27] practical one from the developers perspective, maybe to fill in a couple of backspaces where [1:07:33] the parking demand requirements requires certain amount for retail or spa or restaurant or [1:07:39] whatever, but generally there's we have an idea at least it could be up to 100 spaces that the [1:07:45] project would need. And so it's up to us, we've talked about it, we've talked about a gamble, [1:07:50] it's not the city's gamble, it's the developers gamble, just to be quite frank. [1:07:55] But it's coming at this awkward time, unusual time in a sense where you have a project [1:08:02] is really ready to get going. [1:08:04] There's some urgency there, right? [1:08:06] We want to try to avoid a total loss. [1:08:07] A total disaster for the next earthquake. [1:08:09] So we're trying to move forward. [1:08:11] The city is moving in good faith with us, realizing the possibility of that, and trying [1:08:17] to take advantage of this opportunity while we have it. [1:08:21] So, yeah, again, I think it's a bit of a developers gamble, but there is no aspect of, or there's no possibility where, and I don't know, maybe that idea or hypothetical is spinning in your mind, where it would totally be relying on parking impact fees, and that's just, that's just not going to happen. [1:08:38] So, we're also with this, this unique time, in a sense, where there's a lot of opportunities, there's a lot of properties on downtown that are, will be coming up for sale. [1:08:46] you might have read about them in the newspaper. [1:08:49] So it's a lot of moving parts in the city. [1:08:51] I think is being very thoughtful. [1:08:53] Staff Tony, Neil in particular, [1:08:56] let's not ration and jump into any sort of major decisions [1:08:59] like that. [1:09:00] Let's see how this plays out. [1:09:01] Let's do a feasibility study. [1:09:03] Let's try to get the most optimum spot [1:09:06] where it's going to serve the most people, [1:09:08] where it's going to be the best serving location [1:09:10] for our local businesses. [1:09:12] And let's get the best bang for our buck for each parking spot. [1:09:15] Thank you. [1:09:18] If I could just add to that quickly because I think Jeff brought up a good point that I should have shared. [1:09:25] There are situations with past hotels, particularly the archer and the on-dose, [1:09:30] wasn't called the on-dose at the time, where there were a certain number of uses that, [1:09:38] that the impact fee was paid so like maybe staff, for example. [1:09:41] The parking spaces for staff the impact fee was paid, but then the parking license agreement was related to the rooms. [1:09:48] So there is sort of that middle of the road possibility that I think Jeff mentioned is that we have a number of what parking would be required under the impact fee, [1:09:56] but there could be a split like their 70 license space. [1:10:05] So there's no real hard number at this moment and time it will ultimately depend on what is built and then how we up to split that up. He also referenced the ability to do a parking feasibility study. [1:10:17] you will recall first straight to the parking feasibility study and as part of it we dropped the [1:10:22] requirement from one space per hotel room to 0.8 spaces per hotel room because we determined [1:10:30] based on trends, visitor trends, you know, who is bringing cars and who weren't. So there's [1:10:36] always that option to do a parking feasibility study to determine the actual demand that the [1:10:41] project. We'll generate in terms of meeting reserve spaces versus the impact of these spaces. [1:10:48] Thank you, Molly. [1:10:49] And ultimately, this will be dictated by the hotel partner that's brought in for this project. [1:10:53] It needs to meet that upper upscale criteria. [1:10:56] And they're going to, again, they're going to have their own needs, their own desires. [1:11:00] But we all with our, you know, in-house hotel expert expertise with David and [1:11:05] communications and talking with these potential partners. [1:11:08] There just isn't any sort of scenario where the project would be solely reliant on the parking [1:11:13] impact fee. [1:11:14] It's just not realistic. [1:11:15] Even at a lower rate, it's not feasible to have this project pencil and suit the operators [1:11:22] that we want to bring in. [1:11:26] Thank you. [1:11:28] So, jumping into it, I'd be very appreciative of all this time that staff has spent on this. [1:11:36] It's been an incredible effort. [1:11:39] Like I mentioned, we've kind of been go-go for the past year [1:11:41] and in particular the past month with a lot of late nights. [1:11:45] I know right are working in particular. [1:11:47] So thank you, writer, very, very much. [1:11:49] I appreciate that. [1:11:51] And I'd also be remiss if I didn't thank you commissioners. [1:11:54] We're at a special meeting. [1:11:56] This is your first of two meetings this week. [1:12:00] And we're grateful for your time. [1:12:01] We didn't need to do this. [1:12:02] You probably could have come up with a pretty good excuse [1:12:04] over the summer. [1:12:05] So I do want to acknowledge that commitment and irrespective of what happens here tonight. I just want to say thank you. That means a lot to us [1:12:12] And it's core this project is about saving the historic post office. It's a local landmark [1:12:18] It's on the national register of historic places and it's a legacy that this community is wanted to protect [1:12:25] Since the U.S. Postal Service talked about demolishing it after the earthquake and [1:12:30] But thankfully, the Keller family stepped up and you do acknowledge that. [1:12:34] I'm not sure if Jim regrets that right now, but we're very appreciative. [1:12:40] I am appreciative, particularly. [1:12:43] I'll be very blunt. [1:12:44] This is a difficult project to make work when you consider the significant cost of construction and labor, [1:12:50] which continue to rise. [1:12:51] You're here this all the time from developers who are here in front of you. [1:12:56] So if that's not a secret, it's also no secret to high cost of financing. [1:13:01] What makes this project particularly unique is that before you even get to financing new construction, [1:13:06] the developers starting off in approximately $10 to $13 million whole just to preserve the building [1:13:13] and make it seismically safe. That's a very difficult hole to start in. But that's the reality [1:13:20] if we want to save a building like this. However with this new design, a new and improved design, [1:13:26] and residential component with this for sale hotel units that the writer had mentioned [1:13:30] alongside the Franklin Station hotel. We really believe that there is a pathway to reach [1:13:35] the goal that we started with restoring the post office and bringing new life to this block [1:13:41] of second street. There has been a lot to get here working through, again, as his writer mentioned, [1:13:49] the Preservation Covenant, a 50-page DA, PD overlay amendments, parking affordable housing, [1:13:55] Seqa, I can go on and on and on. [1:13:59] But you guys did a great job. [1:14:00] Thank you very much again, Ryder, for putting together those details and the report and the [1:14:03] presentation. [1:14:05] So I think I'll just step aside and let the star of the show be the design and I'll head [1:14:12] it over to our design team, Earl, from Bar Architects, and then Mark is going to touch in [1:14:16] on the Preservation Aspects. [1:14:18] Thank you. [1:14:21] Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Commissioner. And thank you staff very much for your excellent presentation. [1:14:30] I'm Earl Wilson, Principal with BAAR Architects, and I'm really honored to be here for this particular project. [1:14:37] It's a wonderful project. I want to thank Christine French from the stakeholders from that [1:14:45] for meeting with us on this project and our Preservation Architect, Mark Holbert. [1:14:54] We're about a 70-person firm in San Francisco and we've been... [1:15:00] In here for a long time, working in Nape Valley and working in Nape itself. [1:15:06] But this project is really a proposition, as Jeff said, to preserve a wonderful resource at [1:15:14] the heart of Nape in this south of first district. And this building has been vacant since [1:15:26] In 2014, as Jeff mentioned, almost 12 years and we have a great opportunity in front of us right now to restore this post office and to revitalize this area around the building south of First Street. [1:15:41] And it really is in bad shape right now. There's a lot of structural damage and it's really at risk of further damage and risk of being potentially in another earthquake loss forever. [1:15:59] And that would really be a shame, because it is a tremendous resource, as an architect, [1:16:07] and having toured this building all over and really looked at it. [1:16:11] There are wonderful details all over it that are irreplaceable from the terracotta panels [1:16:17] to the bronze earns, the windows, it's a beautiful building, the brick work, and it's really [1:16:28] would be irreplaceable. [1:16:32] Our process really starts with research. [1:16:41] It starts with a lot of [1:16:44] building my passion in particular is about place making and how to enhance the sense of place [1:16:52] that's already there and working with Jim and David was a wonderful process spending time [1:17:00] up here talking to them really getting into what it means to be downtown Napa and what it means [1:17:07] to add to the post office, and we came up with these three pillars, which were really intended [1:17:14] to be the DNA of the project that had be authentically Napa, authentically downtown Napa, [1:17:23] revered and respect the historic post office, and that ultimately this was about revitalization [1:17:29] in a place to gather, a place of experience, [1:17:34] and, you know, the, with those pillars, a [1:17:40] reverend respect, was really to take direct inspiration from the historic post office, in [1:17:47] the materials, in the symmetry, in the form. We have a list at the end of the slides, but the [1:17:55] This office was really intended to be the centerpiece, the jewel box at the heart. [1:18:01] We want to enter through the building and really make it the centerpiece and also to harmonize [1:18:08] the architectural character with the post office. [1:18:14] Ultimately too, this is relating to the post office but it's relating to downtown Napa and [1:18:21] needs to become a part of the fabric of downtown. [1:18:23] And, you know, we're intentionally showing this back side to show that there is modulation [1:18:30] of the form of the building. [1:18:31] We were thinking about it, but as Raider mentioned, he was right on spot on this is a party [1:18:37] wall condition on the south side here. [1:18:41] And there are things we can do and we're certainly going to listen and want to listen to [1:18:47] comments. [1:18:49] But, you know, it's about really activating the streets and that's, and creating vibrant street life. [1:19:00] You know, we were looking at differentiating the new building from the post office, [1:19:06] but one of the things from really studying the Secretary of Interior standards, [1:19:10] we've worked in the Presidio, we've worked in other historic districts and San Francisco [1:19:14] with historic buildings, [1:19:18] and it's not just differentiation, but it's about creating this [1:19:22] continuity over time. And again, that's part of the Revere and Respect. [1:19:31] And pulling [1:19:31] the post office back, it's something that we wanted to do specifically to allow the post office [1:19:40] continue to be the jewel box that it is, you know, preserving the character of that building [1:19:50] and really renovating it. This project is really about that. It's about restoring this [1:19:57] building back to its glory, and it is a beautiful... [1:20:01] We've tried to differentiate the new addition from the historic. But again, you'll see that these attempts [1:20:08] with the proportion, with the materials, with the brick, to harmonize the architectural character. [1:20:19] And really activating the streets on both sides of the building not only on Randolph, but also on Franklin, was paramount. [1:20:29] And thinking about the scale of the building that it was important to activate the street to maybe not bring our building down and have it be as monumental on the street, but to have a finer grain so that the post office, which really has these monumental pillars coming down to the ground, that that really maintained its monumentality. [1:20:58] and it's kind of iconic character. [1:21:03] Napa's about indoor outdoor living. [1:21:05] We have this wonderful climate, [1:21:07] and so connecting to the outdoors, [1:21:10] connecting to the city and nature, [1:21:14] and bringing in well detailed materials. [1:21:19] Similarly, with the residences, [1:21:21] or the mixed-used building, [1:21:22] we wanted to have that relate. [1:21:25] have it have the relate to the post office and the respect but also have it really contributing [1:21:34] to the street life and you know the great thing about the hotel use is that it's a use that [1:21:44] actually invites the public in and the historic building can be used not only used but really [1:21:51] centerpiece of this project and preserving this landmark for future generations, both locals [1:21:59] and visitors to enjoy. [1:22:03] And, you know, I put this slide in. It was part of our historic [1:22:08] conformance certificate of appropriateness, but it's really, I won't read through them, [1:22:14] but it has all these measures that we went through to really review and respect this historic [1:22:20] process office. [1:22:22] And so I want to do it also allow Mark to speak, our preservation, our contact. [1:22:27] Thank you. [1:22:28] Thank you. [1:22:29] Thank you. [1:22:30] Thank you. [1:22:31] Indeed. [1:22:31] Thank you again. [1:22:32] Well, written and well said, and I'll only speak very briefly, I just hope you'll join me in supporting [1:22:39] this project. [1:22:40] It has been a very long process. [1:22:43] It's gone on for a planning and design process. [1:22:45] It's gone on for nearly a decade at this point in time. [1:22:49] I believe the benefits are in evidence is a very high quality project, both as rehabilitation [1:22:57] and as an addition to a rehabilitated building, it's more than a facade, it's per [1:23:03] the covenant, it's set whole front end of the building that will be very public. [1:23:09] And that is another huge benefit to it, that there is public benefit. [1:23:14] As a real point at out, hotels are ideal, historic buildings, because people walk into [1:23:21] a many, many people over the years can use them, so they have tremendous public benefits. [1:23:27] So again, I hope you'll support this, this very high quality project. [1:23:31] Thank you. [1:23:39] Good evening, commissioners and staff. [1:23:41] I'll echo what Jeff said, thanks for the special meeting. [1:23:44] We appreciate it. [1:23:46] I just want to come up here and express my thanks to my great team. [1:23:54] It's been a long journey with this project. [1:23:57] One of the first conversations that we had when we restarted here was with some council members, [1:24:05] but it was also with landmarks. [1:24:08] Christine, I think she's going to get up here and say a few things too. [1:24:11] But her and Terry Wunderlick have been a pleasure to work with and, you know, it takes a lot of people to get a project like this through and approved and on track, which is what we're really trying to do here. [1:24:28] We're trying to get design review behind us. [1:24:31] I've watched this project from the front row for the last 10 years and you know, we know what needs to happen to get this thing done. [1:24:39] and we've got to clear all this, but I did bring the 18 men here to help and you know I hope [1:24:46] you guys can help us with a nice recommendation of City Council and we're here to answer [1:24:53] any questions we're here to listen and again Molly Ryder, thank you guys for the last. [1:25:01] Especially month, but through the process. So thank you everyone. We're here to answer any questions. [1:25:07] Thank you. [1:25:11] Okay. Are there any questions? Who wants to start with questions for the applicant? [1:25:17] Okay. Go ahead. Commissioner Myers. [1:25:21] This question is, I don't know if it's more for writer or for the architectural team, how [1:25:31] certain are these renderings to be accurate to what is built? Has it gone through [1:25:38] structural? I mean, because the question comes from a recent hotel we had at [1:25:46] first in OXBO where they came back for a new design review because after it had [1:25:54] been approved then they went to structural engineering and realized well we can't [1:26:00] put all these windows on the first floor the building all fall down. So they had to kind of [1:26:05] redesign the facade and just port it and it was still a nice looking project. Don't get me wrong [1:26:11] but because particularly because this is going into development agreement where once that happens [1:26:18] the public participation process kind of goes away I just want to get a better sense of confidence in [1:26:25] how true life is this likely to be? [1:26:34] The applicant may respond. [1:26:36] Yeah, the city has not done a structural review on it, [1:26:40] so that would be an applicant question. [1:26:42] You go. [1:26:43] We have not submitted structural. [1:26:46] So we've not done a complete structural design at this point. [1:26:52] We're 50% into our schematic design process. [1:26:56] That means anything to you. [1:26:59] So I think you can see from all the drawings that we've submitted, it's substantial. [1:27:07] We have been working with us for a time here, in fact, I think he's even here tonight. [1:27:13] So there's been coordination with structure, but it's not fully designed. [1:27:22] And so I don't, you know, and that's fair. [1:27:27] That's fair. [1:27:28] So that does to that extent. Yes, thank you. I guess I would have a follow-up if I could ask of writer. So that answers my question. Thank you [1:27:36] So then in the development agreement if there does need to be a change to the design [1:27:46] due to you know as they need a beam here [1:27:51] What's that process like [1:27:53] So that the amendment language is actually in the plan development overlay where it speaks [1:27:59] to that up to amount, and it speaks to subsequent approvals. [1:28:03] Generally referred to in the development agreement, but the plan development overlay [1:28:09] modifies the ordinance, because otherwise the ordinance for hotels generally [1:28:13] back through council unless it's a minor modification. [1:28:16] But the planned development overlay outlines the types of so-use [1:28:22] permit design review permit and such, and as long as it, the, the, the [1:28:27] grayers that substantial conformance, right? So they're going to be [1:28:30] notable features about the way that this is designed, the map, the [1:28:35] expense, the, the kind of massive facades of glass balconies where [1:28:42] they're directed. Those will all generally have to be the same, the, the [1:28:46] projections and the stepbacks will all have to be consistent with what City Council, ultimately [1:28:54] considers and whether they adopt it, a resolution to approve it or not. [1:29:00] But what I was, it makes it easy about this one is that there are pretty distinguishing [1:29:04] features that staff we would expect to carry over. [1:29:08] So that there could be little things as far as, [1:29:15] oh, and staying corrected there, [1:29:17] there are certain subsequent improvements [1:29:18] that are subject to city manager discretion. [1:29:22] But what you could see in terms of structural changes [1:29:25] and what we've seen is sometimes the windows [1:29:27] get slightly smaller because they need to be [1:29:30] able to be structurally supported. [1:29:33] But where you're looking at large portions of wall [1:29:35] that are generated glass, [1:29:37] our expectation would be that that would be consistent. [1:29:41] So, where there are these distinguishing features, [1:29:44] and maybe commission moves into the verbal record of identifying certain features, [1:29:51] as part of their recommendation that they would like to definitely be maintained. [1:29:56] Staff would look at the elevations, find the distinguishing feature. [1:30:00] There's fine the materials that have been identified in the plans and make sure those are consistent amongst any other considerations. [1:30:07] So, how do you draw the line then? Where is that decision made as to? [1:30:14] So, section 9 of the agreement talks about the city manager, or there does a need, have the authority to determine whether or not an amendment is major or minor, and then the process is for each of those. [1:30:23] So that is up to Mr. Potter or his doesn't he or successor or whatever [1:30:29] perhaps if I don't want that happens. Okay [1:30:32] Okay, thank you that adds clarity to what happens in that circumstance [1:30:39] Do you have any additional questions at this time? [1:30:42] Well, I did ask before about the Southern [1:30:45] exposure of the condo building [1:30:48] you know, I noted that the Southern exposure of the hotel building certainly [1:30:53] We looked different, not [1:31:06] articulate the question, but we'll come up and tell us some ideas [1:31:09] that he has for that wall. [1:31:17] Well, you know, we, I will say, we treated it as a, as a, as a party wall. [1:31:23] So anticipating a future building on either of the bilco building side or at the Zellar [1:31:32] where parcel. So, and I think you set it very well. It's very typical. There's either a [1:31:41] building that was there or a building that's anticipated to be there. And that's why we [1:31:46] end up with these things. But that said we did think about it and you can see returns of the [1:32:01] of materials to give it some further scale and proportion, the center of the hotel building, [1:32:12] that we did set it back so we could get windows in that area, and guest rooms, and then [1:32:18] on the mixed use building, we're using not only two different materials there, but we've [1:32:25] also got a a stair tower that's giving that that facade some articulation. So, but that [1:32:34] said we can continue to look at that. If that is if that is a comment and a concern we [1:32:41] can continue to look at at these walls and continue to evaluate. And we've you know we've [1:32:46] discussing it in turn, since this came up, so, yeah, you know, there's, you know, there's [1:32:56] further articulation, sometimes these walls get painted, there's murals, you know, we'd [1:33:04] be happy to work with city staff, [1:33:08] and to come up with the right solution there. [1:33:13] Okay. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. [1:33:21] Any other questions for at this time? No. No. [1:33:27] Commissioner [1:33:27] Missaro. [1:33:29] Thank you. All right. Just to clarify on this picture that we're looking [1:33:34] out up here. The post office building has the windows in it in this picture. Correct? [1:33:49] It's not the post office, but it's generally referred to as the post office redevelopment. [1:33:55] Sorry. [1:33:55] So basically the Franklin station hotel. [1:33:59] Right, where the post office rehabilitation is. [1:34:02] So as of right now, the way you've designed it does have these windows. [1:34:05] Okay. [1:34:07] Do you have rights to the airspace over the Zeller building? [1:34:12] No. [1:34:13] So, if there's other building where to develop at some point, you would lose the window capacity potentially. [1:34:22] There's, yeah, those windows are set back, the code required. [1:34:26] Right. [1:34:29] And they have balconies. [1:34:32] So, there's a little bit of depth, but yes, those would go suddenly from rooms that are facing out over an empty parcel. [1:34:38] looking at a building adjacent, and we would hope that that building would be, how should I say? [1:34:48] It's likely to form a similar, follow similar requirements. [1:34:53] We hope so. [1:34:54] We hope so. [1:34:55] We hope so. [1:34:56] We hope so. [1:35:00] It's not entirely unusual to do something like this, but yes, it would change. [1:35:04] So, essentially not a concern for you at this point, the way that you designed it. [1:35:10] Okay. In talking about the housing structure, the next structure, where the branded residential [1:35:19] is, I do appreciate the fact that that is a party wall there, because I, for me, [1:35:28] know what our downtown specific plan it says and the approach that we want to take to downtown [1:35:34] having more housing available, having that part of their gives more opportunity for whatever [1:35:40] may happen on that corner. So for me the the blank wall there doesn't bother me as much because [1:35:47] I'm thinking about future possibilities in that area. So that's my only comments about that one, [1:35:55] but I do have a couple of other comments. [1:36:02] Talking about sustainability, [1:36:04] and I know that you are only halfway [1:36:06] into your schematic design at this point. [1:36:10] What sustainable features are you planning [1:36:13] within the branded residential and the hotel? [1:36:16] I know that looking at our climate goals [1:36:19] for NAPI County and also the city [1:36:21] and all of that, we're not mandating any solar [1:36:25] on any of these buildings, [1:36:27] But and it doesn't look like there's any opportunity for solar on these buildings maybe a future solar on these buildings [1:36:35] Oh, no, we would we would be thinking about solar for sure. Okay. Yes, okay. Okay, okay [1:36:43] You know, it's it's very important to us as well and and I think it's becoming increasingly important in the hotel market [1:36:53] This notion of wellness [1:36:55] And so, you know, light and air indoor outdoor connections, [1:37:06] you know, these pillars that we have. [1:37:09] They really are meaningful DNA to us because projects do change throughout their life. [1:37:16] And, you know, but hopefully not in dramatic ways that the design intent is baked into these pillars. [1:37:26] And we use these pillars to start to set a framework for design excellence and a framework [1:37:35] for incorporating sustainability features into the design and its part of our office's process. [1:37:41] And it's probably too much for tonight, but I could walk you through our whole [1:37:46] methodology within our office and in which we start to incorporate sustainability features [1:37:54] into every aspect of the project and the specifications we work with David and Jim and the [1:38:00] development team. That's really great to hear. I appreciate that. One of the things when I met [1:38:07] with the developer we talked a little bit about the features in the kitchen of the branded residential [1:38:15] units. And we talked about appliances and gas appliances and you know those types of things. [1:38:24] I would prefer you to not have any gas appliances in the brand of residential only because of [1:38:35] for a couple reasons. One is they're just in my view toxic things to put into your house, [1:38:43] but that's just my view and in climate sustainability and all of that is it's just important. [1:38:50] But I do want to just mention the fact that if you don't put gas into building, [1:38:56] you actually will save dollars in your construction to not put gas in the building and to do [1:39:03] something different. And I think that just as we might have waymo powers driving down the streets, [1:39:09] There are a lot of really good innovative kitchen materials that are just streamlined, really good looking, into your kitchen that doesn't have to be gas. [1:39:20] So that's just my, um, please don't put gas in the building. [1:39:26] Hey, Earl, before you answer, could you talk a little bit closer to the microphone that the people watching online are having difficulty hearing? [1:39:32] Yeah, thank you. [1:39:33] yeah thanks so that's my my two cents on gas so please don't do that [1:39:39] not something I can mandate to you but just I'm trying to just kind of put the idea in your [1:39:45] ear that there is a there's a savings to not going forward with the PG&E contract to do gas [1:39:50] in the building. [1:39:54] Anyway, how do you feel about that? [1:39:58] Yeah, I think we're... [1:40:00] We're at a point now where going electric is making sense on a lot of levels, and we see it with not only the heating [1:40:10] and ventilation systems, we see it with the cooking appliances, [1:40:17] and yeah, it's not having to put in all those pipes. [1:40:23] It's definitely safe to say things involved with going electric. [1:40:27] Yes. Talking a little bit about the articulation and the front of the building, we'll touch [1:40:34] a little bit on what Alex said about the design features that you have on the post office [1:40:40] Franklin Station building. What I really appreciate when I like about your design is the way [1:40:46] that you've stepped back the architecture of the structure to really showcase the post office. [1:40:53] But I really love the side features of the Florida ceiling glass that you've got going all the way up and down the building. [1:41:01] And then marrying that into the balconies that you've got in your picking up the stone features from the post office. [1:41:10] Those are the features I personally don't want to see change at all. [1:41:15] And those are the things I'd love to be able to carry forward into this discussion and into the city. [1:41:22] Council, it's so if you ever had to come back for a minor minor and then just because you had to make something structurally fit. [1:41:31] I really don't want that look to change because I think it's excellent, it's very well done and it fits within the community of what we have. [1:41:42] Those are, you know, my suggestions on that. [1:41:46] And then my last question, and I think I asked this before, when I was in with the developer, [1:41:55] but I asked about the sidewalks and the curb and gutter that kind of bulb out into the [1:42:04] drive into the street, essentially. And I don't know if I, if those are standard ways to do that, [1:42:14] it looks like it just impedes too much on the cars and then it doesn't give that it gives [1:42:24] the chance for a car to cut a curb essentially. [1:42:29] It's nice that you noted that because I think by design it's intentionally supposed to [1:42:33] slow down the cars give more visibility, bring the pedestrian connection points closer to one [1:42:38] other and it's very common downtown where they had to recognize existing footprint [1:42:44] buildings to give visibility to traffic and then make the pedestrian environment a little safer. [1:42:51] So I think by design that there's an inconvenience to vehicles that that's true and it is typical. [1:43:02] Yes, and I know that we've added those white lines. You know that around the curb areas downtown, [1:43:07] however, it is still increasingly difficult the way that we're parking vehicles downtown [1:43:12] to pull out into those streets in C. [1:43:17] So those are just, it's just a concern, [1:43:18] and I know it's all part of our public works [1:43:20] and are slowing down cars and trying to make things a little bit more safe, [1:43:25] but it just seems to be a little bit excessive on this rendering. [1:43:31] And I think that's something during the building permit process [1:43:36] that in a civil process that our public works department [1:43:38] but look at, um, in terms of that and if change is needed to be made. [1:43:44] And I just had one more question for you. [1:43:45] Okay, and I have a, I actually have a question for you as well. [1:43:48] Could you repeat exactly what you stated, um, for, so that, or it's, or you can think about it. [1:43:54] You mean on that, on the visual as a element that you, [1:43:59] So there's a visual element. [1:44:00] Um, we'll look at each side of the building, the immediate, um, [1:44:05] left and right side of the front of the building. [1:44:06] There's a full glass, I don't know the technical term, the architect, probably knows that better. [1:44:15] But there's a full glass structure. Yeah, you're welcome to explain it for them. [1:44:20] Yeah, the Florida ceiling glass. [1:44:22] Yes. [1:44:22] And we did that exactly as you described to offset or set off the post office building and make a clear separation. [1:44:33] Yes. [1:44:36] While also being able to bring in the brick next to it, but show that it's clearly separated. [1:44:43] And bring in this notion of, I'm sure I say, continuity over time or harmonizing our building, [1:44:52] the new building with the post office, not mimicking it, but relating to it. [1:44:58] Is that good? [1:44:59] Yes. [1:44:59] Okay. [1:44:59] . [1:45:00] Great. Thank you. Okay, my question for you. Okay, my question for you is, how many do you do with the housing impact fees? I believe in the development agreement it says that the housing impact fees would be payable at the time of sale? Did I read that correctly? [1:45:15] Only the additional one dollar at the rest of the fees would be paid at the time of issuance of building permit or, unless an in loop proposal was, was brought to the city council to consider. [1:45:25] Okay, great. Thank you. That's my questions. Thank you. [1:45:30] Commissioner E-Boc? [1:45:39] First, I actually want to say thank you for sharing a sorrow for pointing out the ability of having the party wall and having housing there because I did not think of that before. [1:45:47] I was going to have custom comments about the back wall of the condo property, but it's a perspective I didn't think of. [1:45:54] I appreciate that. [1:45:59] Moving from there, I'm curious, there was a comment that we received, a link comment from Mr. [1:46:07] Kelly suggesting that the North West, most parking stalls in the condo are not condo, [1:46:16] I'm sorry, in the ownership building. [1:46:18] Be converted to an additional retail space to further activate Randall Street. [1:46:24] Is that something that the project team considered? [1:46:26] Is that something you'd be interested in retaining or willing to entertain? [1:46:30] I'd like to hear a thoughts on that. [1:46:35] Sorry, right or should I'm pulling up the, the, the, the, they're in the back, we'll grab you the letter. [1:46:42] It was, it was, it was conveyed as part of the supplemental memorandum. [1:46:46] Sorry, it was a late public comment we received today, [1:46:52] but effectively, yeah, okay. [1:46:56] Yeah, I, I've, I've got it now. [1:46:58] I think as we continue to finalize the residential counts in that building, that's going to give us some more certainty on what can be done on level one. [1:47:14] In fact, David and I talked about that today. [1:47:19] What I would say is that the less parking we need to park the residential units, the more [1:47:27] opportunities that gives us along Randolph to create monetizable, amenetizable space for the hotel, [1:47:40] which as you guys can see, there's a dense project, so we would like to do that and yes, [1:47:46] And that's in our vision to accomplish if the opportunity presents itself. [1:47:52] I'm going to call a question for staff on that. Is that something that can be changed? [1:47:56] I mean, I'm assuming that that's going to have to come back to designer view. [1:47:58] If there's an additional retail unit added. [1:48:01] There could be a motion as part of the recommendation to consider an expansion. [1:48:07] But understanding there's going to be a push pull relationship between their obligation for onsite parking, [1:48:12] as well as having to fall under the envelope and umbrella of what's been analyzed under [1:48:20] sequela. So, not looking to expand upon that too much, but there's probably some [1:48:30] wiggle room there. If commission was so moved to make a recommendation to city [1:48:35] counsel for those considerations, as long as the overall retail consideration still fell [1:48:42] under what was analyzed and they still met their parking obligations, for onsite parking, [1:48:50] I think it generally could be considered. [1:48:52] So if they were for some reason to reduce the number of four cell units and subsequently [1:48:59] add a retail space, if it was under that threshold of what was analyzed, that could be [1:49:04] possibility. Okay. Yeah. This was curious. We're talking about like 2500 feet is probably the [1:49:10] most we could ever get in that kind of space. [1:49:20] I know that the staff report says that the [1:49:26] I believe that the official lighting plan will be submitted for staff review at the time of building [1:49:31] permits. But I did just want to mention that in the rendering's provided to us that demonstrate [1:49:39] the lighting, there's no view of the south facade and imagine just from a safety perspective [1:49:45] that you will want to put some type of lighting where the back of that ownership building meets [1:49:52] the adjacent site where you have the alley but wanted to point that out. I hope to see that there. [1:50:00] May I clarify for the verbal record, between the bill goes patio and the proposed building for the mixed use development, [1:50:08] because it creates a tighter space that lighting considerations for safety? [1:50:18] Yes, if that wasn't in there, then it should be. [1:50:24] To add to this, just to give maybe more comfort to the planning commission, [1:50:29] Staff actually does have an associate planner on staff that has credentials for crime prevention through environmental design. [1:50:38] So through consultation, other considerations can be made. [1:50:43] That's fantastic. [1:50:44] We're lucky to have that. [1:50:45] I didn't realize that. [1:50:47] But I [1:50:54] think my last question for the applicant team is would you be willing to consider? [1:51:06] matching, well, sorry, we back up actually, [1:51:10] did the point eight for parking, [1:51:12] squirted for staff. That was, that's not in code. That came from the [1:51:17] development agreement from the first street project. Correct. It is not in the code. [1:51:21] It's one per hotel unit. We've allowed them to apply the first street parking [1:51:25] study, which was specific to hotel room use. So with that in mind, we [1:51:35] working number. [1:51:38] I would like to ask the applicant if you'd be willing to also then match [1:51:43] that to dollars per score foot of the ownership units for the affordable housing for [1:51:50] consideration. You can think about that. You don't have to answer right now, but when we get into [1:51:56] the little operation that's something I'm thinking about. [1:52:03] Thank you. Commissioner Shotwell. [1:52:08] So, [1:52:12] I've grown attached to the materials that they have proposed on this project. [1:52:18] I am in awe of how great they will look. [1:52:23] They will pay homage to the original, to the post office, [1:52:29] meaning the woodscreens, [1:52:31] the champagne bronze with the panelized facades. [1:52:34] I like the concrete board. I'm absolutely obsessed with the bronze elements, so I mentioned it in the meeting with the applicant and David Oliver that I do hope that this is something that would not change. [1:52:57] Apologies, we were slightly distracted by the garden across the street, but I heard what you said which is the materials for the project would not change. [1:53:03] So I think that in, as you get into your deliberation, I think that I hear two things from [1:53:10] commissioners that maybe would be considered major modifications and would need to come [1:53:15] back which potentially are the left and right side full glass floor to ceiling that enhances [1:53:24] the post the former post office building and then the materials is demonstrated in the [1:53:33] that'll be something that you collectively will have to add to your motion if you'd like us to [1:53:38] to add that language in somehow and I did ping our attorney to ask how if there's a best way to do that. [1:53:44] So we'll maybe figure that out on a break if that's something that the commission wants to do. [1:53:48] But yes, so the materials in general is what I for the entirety of the buildings sounds good. [1:53:55] Thank you. Okay, and then let's see. Perfect. [1:54:00] Which writer just reminded me that we have it in the design guidelines that are attached to. [1:54:04] So fans, very specific. [1:54:05] So those would not change. [1:54:07] Great. [1:54:08] And let's see. [1:54:11] I will be that squeaky wheel on the mixed use building the south elevation that wall. [1:54:20] I think that it's an opportunity for a mural or a really cool, like it could be signaged [1:54:29] on in a mural type of format or it could be a mural of the original post office, which [1:54:38] would be pretty awesome, so that you're looking at what the post office looks like, the [1:54:47] facade of the original post office on that building as a nod, or something of that sort. [1:54:55] I think that, you know, because we, it is undetermined, what will it be? [1:55:00] Eventually, happened to the Sullivan lot. In the event that that becomes housing, you know, with parking, then let's say it's two or three stories or four stories. [1:55:11] Hi, and the bill coes, you know, building stays the same. People on their terraces looking out are going to be looking at a blank wall. So we have to think about the future of that. [1:55:28] is now a parking lot, but that could very well be housing in the future. [1:55:36] So I would like to see something more aesthetically pleasing on that wall. [1:55:44] So I'll add that for this at this time for when you discuss a question for, again, for [1:55:50] our attorney when we break, incorporating some sort of, I heard you say art mural or decor [1:55:58] of some sort on the wall and is that something that the planning commission, you don't have to answer this now, [1:56:04] just something that would come back as sort of a design review permit, like a public art installation, what, [1:56:10] just think about that right. [1:56:11] Anything of this sort? [1:56:12] Anything but a blank, to me it's a canvas, it's a palette, so let's get creative. [1:56:21] I mean, we are dealing with a very creative firm. [1:56:25] I, it's been, it's, that's crystal clear. [1:56:30] Okay. I, [1:56:36] decade in the planning, I will leave it at that. [1:56:42] Thank you. [1:56:45] I don't really have an additional question to ask of you guys, [1:56:49] and I echo already the request we have, [1:56:52] so we can add to that during our deliberation. [1:56:56] I do want to request before we go to public comment if we can have a five minute bathroom break. [1:57:03] All right, you are the chair, okay? [1:57:05] Can we have a five minute bathroom break starting now? [1:57:07] Thank you. [2:04:45] Can everybody please take your seats? [2:05:03] All right. [2:05:09] All right. I'm going to open public comment now. [2:05:13] My red, do we have any public comment cards? Yes. I received one from Christine French. [2:05:25] Oh, I'm Christine French. I'm an executive director of Napa County landmarks. [2:05:30] I want to thank the City, Jim Keller, David Oliver, and all the design team for your perseverance in this project. [2:05:37] I'd also like to recognize the board and former board members who help save the building, people who are in this room today, [2:05:44] in our community. They were instrumental in the stewardship change from the postal service to a private owner. [2:05:53] On behalf of NAPI County landmarks, I'm here to confirm that the Board of Directors has endorsed the plans for the Franklin Station Post Office, [2:06:02] as submitted to the City of NAPI, including the proposed partial demolition of the building and the restoration and the reconstruction of the primary facade, [2:06:12] Exterior Lanterns, Interior Lobby Spaces, and adjacent walls. [2:06:19] As the Project Advances, Plan Marks is committed to working collaboratively with the [2:06:26] property owner and project team to support the thoughtful restoration and reconstruction [2:06:32] of the building's historic features. [2:06:35] Consistent with both the preservation approach endorsed by the Board and the Secretary of [2:06:40] to share your standards for the treatment of historic properties. [2:06:45] At its opening in 1933, the local news called this the most beautiful building in Napa. [2:06:52] And we support bringing the structure back for productive views for the public under this [2:06:57] plan. [2:06:58] Thank you. [2:06:59] Thank you. [2:07:08] And then I received two more, Jerry Hansen and then Jerry McCollock. [2:07:17] Thank you. [2:07:18] evening, chair, and commissioners, Jerry Hansen, [2:07:21] Napa Chamber of Commerce. [2:07:23] From time to time, projects are coming before you [2:07:26] that represent more than a single building, [2:07:28] and they represent an opportunity to advance [2:07:30] several community priorities at once. [2:07:33] We believe Franklin Station is one of those projects. [2:07:36] As a chamber, we spend a lot of time [2:07:38] focusing on economic development. [2:07:40] Sometimes people picture new businesses, [2:07:43] or large employers, but economic development [2:07:46] It also means taking one of Napa's most recognizable historic buildings, sitting vacant for [2:07:51] 12 years, and bringing it back to life in a way that allows it to evolve and that benefits [2:07:56] the community. [2:07:58] This project offers a path to restore and reactivate that landmark while preserving an important [2:08:02] piece of our community's history. [2:08:05] That in itself is meaningful. [2:08:07] But from the Chambers perspective, this project is more than about preservation. [2:08:12] It represents significant private investment in our downtown. [2:08:15] It brings construction activity, permanent jobs, spending by both visitors and locals and [2:08:21] new gathering spaces that can serve our community. [2:08:24] It helps activate a highly visible corner that has remained quiet and dormant for far too long. [2:08:30] We also appreciate that this proposal is not asking the community to choose between preservation [2:08:35] and progress. [2:08:36] Instead, it seeks to accomplish both. [2:08:39] The historic character of the building is retained while creating an economically viable future [2:08:44] for the property, something that is proven challenging at many, for many years. [2:08:49] The project team has also worked with preservation experts, as you just heard from Christine [2:08:53] Napa County landmarks, throughout the design process, which really reflects their thoughtful [2:08:58] approach. [2:08:59] We realize that this is a first step, and like any project of this significance, there are [2:09:04] details that deserve careful review, and we appreciate the commission's work in evaluating [2:09:08] those issues. [2:09:09] More broadly, though, the Chamber believes Franklin Station aligns with many of the priorities we share as a community, [2:09:17] preserving historic assets, strengthening our downtown, encouraging investment, and supporting a vibrant local economy. [2:09:25] We encourage your support and recommendation to the City Council. Thank you. [2:09:29] Thank you. [2:09:36] Do we have any other cards, Myra? [2:09:37] I did receive one more during a call-up. [2:09:44] We're nervous, but done this before. [2:09:47] My name is Jordan McCulloch, and I own Vilcos beers along with my family. [2:09:52] My husband and I came to Napa in 1975, and opened Paris Delay. [2:09:57] In 1995, we opened Vilcos beers in dark. [2:10:01] For nearly 50 years, our businesses were our lives work. We were not just places that business to us. They were part of the community that we love. [2:10:10] I objected this project because it eliminates a parking lot that my customers rely on, rely on adequate parking. [2:10:19] It's essential for small businesses, small businesses, and the loss of these spaces will negatively impact our ability to serve our clientele and may cause financial hardships for our business. [2:10:30] In addition, the project would dramatically change the environment of my business. [2:10:35] My patio, [2:10:38] which currently looks, which will currently look, I'm sorry, which certainly [2:10:42] looks on an open area, will instead be facing a concrete wall, which everybody kind [2:10:47] of saw in there. [2:10:49] This is a significant and undesirable change that diminishes the experience for my customers. [2:10:54] My clientele is basically local residents, neighbors, friends, and families who have supported us for generations. [2:11:03] Napa has quite a few hotels, but what it really cannot afford to lose are the locally owned businesses that give this town its heart and soul. [2:11:13] Thank you for considering my perspective as a long time local business owner and community member. [2:11:20] Thank you. [2:11:21] Thank you, Jerry. [2:11:24] Seeing there are no more requests to speak. Is there a motion to close public comment? [2:11:32] Oh, like a motion to close public comment. [2:11:34] Then a second. Second. All those in favor? [2:11:38] All right. [2:11:44] All right. I guess we'll just bring it back to Civilization now. [2:11:48] Does anybody have any additional questions for the applicant before? Okay. [2:11:58] Anybody want to do we want to start Commissioner Massara with maybe what we want to see written as far as [2:12:03] What would trigger coming back to the commission? [2:12:12] Sure. [2:12:14] The floor to ceiling glass. [2:12:16] Yes. [2:12:17] Sorry. [2:12:18] Okay. [2:12:22] First of all, I just want to say thank you for your time and effort in the project and the design and the thoughtfulness of our post office. [2:12:35] And I do appreciate the other business owner and her comments, our town and our town is evolving in many, many, many ways. [2:12:50] But to reiterate what I would like to see to be preserved in their design is the Florida ceiling windows that are in the left and right of the side of the post office. [2:13:06] the restorative part of the post office and then carrying and then I think we've already [2:13:10] have in our design review the materials. [2:13:15] So we did check in with our attorney in the break and just to make sure that the motion [2:13:20] is clear and what needs to be happened for all of the pieces that were brought up so I'm [2:13:25] going to bring up the three things, not just the way. [2:13:27] So thank you. [2:13:28] The first in regard to the mural, PC could plan a commission could recommend that the City Council [2:13:35] at a condition to the conditions of approval requiring that a mural would be approved by [2:13:40] fill in the blank before the installation or an art piece, however you want to say it's state [2:13:44] who you would like that to be approved by, as well as the plan for maintenance of any said art piece [2:13:51] would be recommended as well just because once you put it up someone's got to do it and [2:13:55] to be clear on that. [2:13:56] In terms of design features, suggestion of adding to zoning [2:14:04] that those features would be considered a major amendment [2:14:06] requiring approval of the Planning Commission, [2:14:08] not the director. [2:14:09] So that would cover the floor to ceiling windows. [2:14:12] And we would probably make recommendations. [2:14:15] We'd probably refer to the attachment [2:14:18] fix in today's for the 630 hearing for the materials. [2:14:22] I've seen that done in some documents before, so we would make a very clear reference in the zoning to both of those things would be the recommendation. [2:14:31] I just heard that for the first time, so he might want to open on that as well, but that is what our attorney recommends. [2:14:39] I would add for the purpose of the art mural is to specify the extent of the facade to specify what the expectation is, maybe that's it. [2:14:48] We could. It would be horrible if a building were built right in front of it and let's say 10 years. You put up this beautiful mural and then a [2:15:00] Board story, building is built and no one is able to enjoy the mural. So I'm not quite sure how [2:15:10] you put those restrictions on the art. [2:15:16] I might recommend that we talk about an alternative solution, because I had that same exact [2:15:21] thought of what happens in a few years when that silence had developed and then does [2:15:29] to see. So, I might suggest that we talk about adding some type of architectural features [2:15:36] or change of materials or something else as a post to a mural. [2:15:39] I would prefer a mural that I just wouldn't want the architects to go through the expense [2:15:47] and the pain of putting, of changing the buildings, actual architectural elements because [2:15:58] that those are residences that they don't need windows there, right? [2:16:03] I mean, what is your point? [2:16:06] So they change the materials or do something [2:16:08] that doesn't actually change the footprint. [2:16:10] I'm not necessarily asking for a step back or something like that. [2:16:13] I just would like to have a larger discussion about [2:16:17] staying away from a mural simply because it could get covered up. [2:16:22] I don't know. [2:16:23] What about if this space could be something that can be utilized by the art walk on a temporary basis or something like that? [2:16:37] The light at art festivals, light at art or even the, does the city still have an art walk program where they bring in? [2:16:46] Yes, I don't know that they've attached, so I was going to say a couple things. [2:16:50] Corridors, which is going through the sale process, that mural is removable and can be replaced somewhere. [2:16:56] So that could be an option as well, it's just on these panels that can come off of the building so that it takes care of the issue of not building over it eventually. [2:17:07] I mean, I would say sure we would be open to using it as part of the art walk, but I am not a Parks and Recreation Expert, so I don't know [2:17:14] that we could put it in as a, I don't even put it in as a condition of approval [2:17:17] just because I don't know that the city of Napa can necessarily use that space. [2:17:22] They would have to evaluate that. [2:17:24] Well, what is very interesting is that you did mention that the Krithers building, [2:17:28] so that has the, actually, the Chamber of Commerce has purview over that art piece, right? [2:17:35] Correct. So they can actually help facilitate maybe moving that to this building on a temporary [2:17:41] basis as it goes through. [2:17:45] I will have to, I don't know what the plan is, I mean, I can, fortunately we have the [2:17:50] chamber in the room so we can grab an answer to that question. Again, I don't know [2:17:53] about the sizing and all of that and how that would exactly work, and careers may sell prior [2:17:59] to that, so where the mural goes in the middle is, is a good question. So, yes, please thank [2:18:05] you. [2:18:06] Yeah, I did discuss this with the team at break and between four or five of us, we had three [2:18:13] for an ideas on what we could do there, but I think the point is well heard, and I think [2:18:20] we're going to make some moves and modifications or add something to that. [2:18:27] What I would ask of you guys is something that is broad because, you know, whether it's [2:18:33] signage, whether it's some sort of painted art mural or something like that, I'd rather [2:18:39] not commit, but I definitely want to do something there, but I don't want to commit to exactly [2:18:46] what it might be because it will affect the marketability of the project, I want to make [2:18:52] sure everything's cohesive, tasteful, all that kind of thing, but we are committed to doing [2:18:56] something in that area. [2:19:00] Do you want to, do you want that written in as a condition, is that's something that the [2:19:07] in commission have to answer. And it also, she's a reviewing, yes, and then who's reviewing [2:19:12] that proposal in the proposal. So yes, that would be. We also did receive one additional [2:19:17] public comment card. It's a discretion of the board if you want to take it, you don't have to, [2:19:23] but just letting you know that it came in. I am okay taking another public comment card, [2:19:27] thank you. Do we need a motion to open the public commenter? I would record well that. I'm not the [2:19:38] one additional public comment card, and that is it. Okay, I received one season. [2:20:01] Can you come a little closer to the microphensis and just because we're having, yes. [2:20:05] I own a building at 817 Franklin Street and where you're proposing the garbage collection is right across from residential units. [2:20:20] So, in addition, [2:20:24] the uptown has their bands roll up right there in Franklin Street, you know, [2:20:32] Tuesday nights, Wednesday nights over the weekend. [2:20:36] So, how is that going to work when these band buses are vying for a position as well? [2:20:45] So I think it needs to be considered moving [2:20:50] where garbage collection happens. [2:20:53] OK, thank you. [2:20:55] Thank you. [2:20:58] Does anybody from the applicant team want [2:21:00] to respond to that comment? [2:21:03] No, OK. [2:21:05] And maybe generally ask if there's any other public comment. [2:21:09] Then we'll now close it. [2:21:11] I allowed one more public comment. [2:21:13] I think, yeah, okay, can I get a motion to close public comment? [2:21:20] Thank you. [2:21:21] I, all those in favor. [2:21:24] Okay. [2:21:27] Now back. [2:21:30] So about that recommendation on those self-facing walls. [2:21:37] How do we make it open ended? [2:21:39] So I was thinking about some sort of large format art as a, as a, as a preference, you know, [2:21:47] another building goes up there, so be it. It'll get preserved in as a time capsule behind that wall. [2:21:54] But alternatively an architectural change and put those out broadly as recommendations to council [2:22:04] that they can choose to refine adopt ignore or whatever. [2:22:09] So on this, I mean, yes, you have the option to make a recommendation to city council. [2:22:14] It can presumably breathe as narrow as broad as you would like to recommend it doesn't mean that City Council will accept it and it's entirety and that they could talk about it. [2:22:23] You know, I think what you just heard from the applicant is they're willing to do something, but they're not sure what yet. [2:22:31] So there's options of that could be refined before City Council after they have a chance to look at it architecturally. [2:22:37] It could be open-ended that something needs to come back and be presented to as the recommendation could be open-ended that something needs to be done differently with that and they can bring back options to the planning commissioner or recommendation to the planning commission for approval as a separate design review or something like that. [2:22:53] So it sort of depends on how narrow or broad in your discussions you want to make it, but what I heard from the applicant was [2:23:01] So more broad at this point would be, I think, preferred as they look at what's possible. [2:23:07] And I'm okay with broad, but it is such a highly visible spot in our downtown that I think that recommendation has to come back to the commission. [2:23:16] My opinion. [2:23:19] I'm opposed to it coming back to us because I feel that 10 years in the making is torture enough and that we really don't want to stall this anymore. [2:23:31] or so I think we can come up with something reasonable where they don't have to come back because [2:23:36] if they come back to us they have to pay a fee to come back right and then it takes time to get [2:23:42] on the agenda and I would prefer that we have some just what is it sensitivity to and also [2:23:58] belief and trust in the applicant and their team because I've seen their projects, you know, [2:24:06] in San Francisco, I'm a huge fan of the procedure, but I believe in them and we can shame them [2:24:14] into, that's actually that's not true, but that's where I'm going. I would prefer that they not have [2:24:20] to come back to us. Okay, so then I would recommend at that point if that's the desire of the [2:24:25] planning commission is to, someone has to approve it, so that could be the city manager, [2:24:30] that could be the community resources and development director. I will say typically, [2:24:39] although it's more in the spirit of in in lieu proposal for the public art fee, which is not [2:24:45] part of of this, so this is in in lieu proposal, it has come back to the planning commission, [2:24:50] I think just a couple weeks ago you had one brought back to you. So if it's not going to be you, [2:24:55] perfectly fine for your recommendation, but we need you to specify who. [2:25:00] It needs to approve [2:25:03] it. Is that a new title, though, resources? [2:25:11] Yeah, the new title is community resources and development because we now have the housing and [2:25:15] homeless services divisions with us. [2:25:19] I mean, from a timing standpoint, [2:25:25] does this need to be figured out, maybe this is a question [2:25:30] for the applicant team. Does this need to be figured out before it gets to council, or just [2:25:34] before it becomes finance or just before it gets built? [2:25:42] Are you I'm sorry are you asking about figured out what is going there? Correct. [2:25:46] That does not need to be done before the city council. What is actually physically potentially going [2:25:52] there does not need to be. It would be a condition of approval of what the process would look like [2:25:57] to approve something between presumably the day that it becomes effective in the day of certificate of occupancy is usually what we look to for completion. [2:26:08] Well, so wouldn't it wouldn't necessarily hold things up? If it were, for example, if it were going to be art and wanted to come back for a sort of normal public art design review, would it hold things up on the project end? [2:26:22] I would say it would depend on when it was submitted. [2:26:27] So the timing would have to be aligned with their certificate of occupancy or seeking a certificate of occupancy. [2:26:34] Generally is the metric that we use that is the last piece that we can withhold before all the standards and conditions are approved. [2:26:44] So, I mean, I think that's more of a question for the applicant in terms of if they came back in three months versus two and a half years. [2:26:51] is the question for them. I would greatly appreciate if we could have it approved at City Council. [2:26:59] Can we put something together to show it at Council by the July 21st City Council? [2:27:07] Yeah. I'm looking at my team, but we'll, yeah, pressures on. That is there's no reason that this body [2:27:17] I couldn't reprove that a piece of that. [2:27:20] Well, then how would we feel about just making a recommendation [2:27:23] to counsel that the South facing, you know, [2:27:27] walls of the hotel next to the Zeller building [2:27:31] and of the residential hotel units be presented [2:27:37] with some form of large format aesthetic improvement? [2:27:44] So, to clarify for years, you'd, the expectations for both buildings. [2:27:50] Well, I think the Zeller building is far more visible even than the, than the residential hotel building, which is set back by Bill, because the Zeller building is right there on the street. [2:27:58] Has articulation? [2:28:00] It has windows and articulation on it, though. [2:28:04] The, the white one. [2:28:08] Do you want to pull it up and make sure we're all talking about that? [2:28:11] I mean, there is a piece of it that's pretty big, but there is also other visual. [2:28:18] Well, maybe I remember it wrong. [2:28:22] Yeah, I'm okay with that when it expresses the bill. [2:28:24] Right there. [2:28:25] You don't mind that? [2:28:26] I don't mind. [2:28:27] I don't mind it either because I spoke with a member of the applicants team and even the architect mentioned that if you put too much, if there's too much going on, [2:28:40] people who have art on every single wall in their home, [2:28:46] where is your eye going, right? [2:28:48] You're not focusing on the beauty of what is happening there [2:28:53] in the center with the living wall and the windows [2:28:58] and everything like that. [2:29:00] So I think it looks really white right now, [2:29:02] but that's not necessarily the actual white [2:29:05] is not the actual color of the walls. [2:29:07] it's what we're seeing from this image and it's not reflecting the actual depth of the real [2:29:17] color. So it looks like a big white two-white walls flanking that center area, but I think it will. [2:29:27] It looks to me as big as the back wall of the native sun's building that gets that big [2:29:35] You know, projection on it during the lighter art festival. I mean, I think it's pretty big, but I don't care that much. [2:29:42] I mean, you guys are the design professionals. I'll defer to that expertise. [2:29:47] Yeah, that building does not bother me. It tells the what's happening with that building and the articulation. [2:29:53] It emphasizes what they've done in the center to have it flint. It's almost like framing. [2:30:00] That, the, the beauty of what they've created in the center. So if I am hearing consensus for potentially a future motion, it's a large format, aesthetic improvements on the mixed use building, only that's how we've defined it in the DA, to be presented and approved by city council upon review of the project. [2:30:24] That sounds good. [2:30:27] That's at least five people loading on that. [2:30:40] I'd like to bring up the discussion of the housing impact fee. [2:30:46] Does anyone else have any thoughts on asking for the $2 as opposed to the one? [2:30:51] Can you reiterate your position on that just what the basis for it? [2:30:59] So there [2:31:02] are portions of this development agreement that borrow from others. [2:31:06] One of which is the parking ratio, so then instead of having to provide one space per unit or room, as they would under the code, they have asked to provide 0.8, which is borrowed from the first street DA. [2:31:25] So we kind of cherry picked that piece, but then have only a $1 per square foot, a affordable housing fee for the ownership units, [2:31:38] where that DA had a $2 per square foot. [2:31:41] So this would be a discussion about potentially increasing that, so that we're consistent with. [2:31:47] We've given a little here and we're going to take a little here. [2:31:50] And if I may add on it's first street paid for a parking study, which reduced their number [2:31:56] to 0.8. [2:31:57] So they're better fitting, like this project benefits from that president from that agreement [2:32:01] in one area, but then can deviate it another, is my first act. [2:32:06] Where does the $2 come from? [2:32:10] At the time of the sale of the ownership unit, so I imagine it would be rolled into the [2:32:14] cost. [2:32:15] But that would be a question for the output. [2:32:16] I'm sorry. [2:32:17] I was vague in my, I just meant, where does that number [2:32:22] originate from. How did you get to two? [2:32:25] It originated originally in the Stanley Ranch development agreement. I don't know how it originated. [2:32:32] I was not here at the city at that time and then it came up as a discussion at City Council [2:32:37] on the first street. Would you add the two dollars to match what Stanley ranced it? And I believe [2:32:41] that what Commissioner E. Bach is asking at this point is will you match what the last two [2:32:47] similar DAs have have done so the $2 is not a real it's not a number that comes from any [2:32:53] feasible. [2:32:54] I want I do want to bring to everyone's attention that they are rehabilitating and historic [2:33:03] treasure and that they have already they will be providing parking because it's already [2:33:09] been made clear that they will they will not be able to sell rooms if you can't have if [2:33:16] can't find parking, they'll go out of business within two years just because they will [2:33:25] provide the parking. [2:33:27] We have to remember that they have been working on this for 10 years and that Jim Keller [2:33:35] purchased this with this good faith vision that he would restore and preserve this historic [2:33:48] Jim. And so I know that we need affordable housing, I know that we need workforce housing, [2:33:56] and I know that we could use those funds, but ultimately I feel that they're taking [2:34:04] a big risk and they're already going to be spending up to, let's say, $12 to $13 million [2:34:11] just saving the post office. I think the Stanley Ranch did not save this type of a historic [2:34:19] structure, nor did the first street phase two, and we just need to also remember what they've [2:34:31] been through. This is not their first rodeo. This is the second design. This is something that we [2:34:38] have to as a city be very clear in that we're setting a precedent of what it takes to develop [2:34:47] here and we want to be respectful and we want to honor what people have already done [2:34:56] to get to this point and they have spent. [2:35:00] A lot of money to get to this point and a lot of blood sweat and tears and a lot of time, it's taken 10 years. [2:35:07] I am opposed to an additional $1 for the housing fund. [2:35:13] And I do believe that we need that money, but I think that we will find that money elsewhere. [2:35:27] I'm conflicted here because we were just discussing, asking the developer to spend more money [2:35:33] to develop something to go on this facade of the south side of the building. [2:35:41] And to me it's like, why'd rather have you not spend the money on the south side of that building [2:35:46] and put the dollar in for the affordable housing? [2:35:49] because I think that's more important than the south side of the building. [2:35:56] I would agree with that as well to me that the impact fee is more important in my opinion. [2:36:02] And something to note is that so this is a development agreement that's locking in what they're paying now. [2:36:09] And we've heard this evening that the city is actively studying, re-evaluating their impact fees. [2:36:16] And so they likely will go up, I mean, I did some comparisons today and not to say that we have to do whatever the community does, but I did a rough calculations and should this project have to be developed in other towns in the county of Napa, they would be paying 2 to 3 times the amount in their affordable housing fee. [2:36:36] that is not at all to diminish the thankfulness that I have for Jim for taking on the financial [2:36:45] kind of stewardship and preservation of this property. But I do think we have to be [2:36:51] just acknowledge that this is a negotiation, it's a development agreement, it's locking them in [2:36:56] a lower rate than likely what they're going to pay in the future. And that's my concern, I guess. [2:37:01] I have some concern about the direction of this conversation only because, so I reviewed [2:37:07] Chuck Shinemans and Napa Housing Coalition letter, and even their letter says they're not in a position [2:37:16] as a housing coalition to have the expertise to determine a fee. [2:37:22] I have really a substantial concern about just ad hoc doubling the fee that is proposed just off the cuff. [2:37:30] But, you know, we are making a recommendation to council. [2:37:35] I wouldn't feel confident setting a number on that because this is really a land use advisory body and not a taxing body. [2:37:43] But we could tell them as the council pay attention to this number and consider if it is appropriate. [2:37:51] and perhaps in the meantime, that would give writer and Molly and the applicant team a chance to say, [2:38:00] well, do we do anything with this? [2:38:03] Judge, do you want to look at what they're doing in Sonoma County? [2:38:06] Are you confident in this number? [2:38:09] Because I just feel like that's a change that is awfully, [2:38:16] to me it seems like a reach of what we should be doing. [2:38:21] I respect that and I guess I would be open to leaving that up to council and I do want to clarify that I'm not necessarily saying that we would have an answer in terms of impact if you go and forward. [2:38:35] Molly State, that would take a year minimum. I'm not going to require a study probably with some type of housing economist. [2:38:42] This would just be a suggestion to match what was previously done not to recommend in the other number. [2:38:49] But if this group was to leave that up to Council, I'm comfortable with that. [2:38:54] We want to make it a recommendation for Council to take a second look at it. [2:38:58] I hate to say, hey, we're the body that you've appointed to give you recommendations and our recommendation is that you think about it. [2:39:09] But, but in this circumstance, I think that might be appropriate. [2:39:15] I feel better saying that than increasing it, ad hoc up here. [2:39:22] I just don't feel that we have the authority. [2:39:24] Okay. [2:39:25] Yes, so maybe we'll just suggest that. [2:39:28] Is that okay? [2:39:29] I mean, I don't want to shut you down. [2:39:32] It's okay. [2:39:33] It's okay. [2:39:33] It's okay. [2:39:34] All right. [2:39:37] All right. [2:39:40] I think it's wonderful that we are all so very concerned about housing, workforce, [2:39:45] housing affordable housing and we're just all of us are trying desperately to fix it. [2:39:53] It's so complicated so I so appreciate your take on it and I am and it's just a challenge. [2:40:00] It's not as challenging as parking. [2:40:04] Yeah, about that. [2:40:08] My suggestion would just be to strike the language regarding the in-lu-fi. [2:40:12] And I'm sure that the council people are probably going to watch a lot of this. [2:40:15] And they'll see our discussion of it. And if they disagree with that change, [2:40:19] or think that maybe a percentage of spots should be eligible for the in-lu-fi. [2:40:27] based on Jeff Dodd statement that it's effectively impossible for the project to go forward with that [2:40:35] in Lou Fee as the primary parking solution. I don't think that's particularly prejudicial to the [2:40:40] application and then you know I just I can't in good conscience recommend a project that says [2:40:47] you don't provide parking and if you choose to you could maybe pay for half the cost of a parking [2:40:51] about first spot. [2:40:54] So if we just took the in-loof the out of our recommendation, [2:40:58] and then that could be either what they think is appropriate, [2:41:03] I mean, I think that the intention of the applicant, [2:41:05] as far as I understood, is to come up with a resolution. [2:41:11] But rather than keep it wildly open-ended, [2:41:14] I would prefer to close the loop on that, [2:41:17] so that at least there is a backstop. [2:41:21] against the outcome of not providing parking. [2:41:25] And you want to take a hundred percent away. [2:41:27] Well, it's, uh, how's it written? [2:41:35] It's, uh, written that, uh, the project may satisfy the city's land use regulations for parking by utilizing the parking spaces on the property or paying the city's development impact fee or a combination of those options consistent. [2:41:48] Well, with 4.4.1, and it subsections down below, Exhibit F is the Airint. [2:41:55] In the event that developer cannot provide all required parking for the project on the property, [2:42:00] the party's main negotiator parking agreement in good faith. [2:42:03] So I mean, my suggestion would be the project, may satisfy the city's and the Relantious Regulations [2:42:07] for parking by utilizing the parking spaces on the property, or by negotiating in good faith, [2:42:16] and then go from there and just kind of omit the in-lu-fi as the full open ended. [2:42:26] You know, we could put a number on it not to exceed 30% of the in-lu-fi, but again, we would be throwing darts in the dark. [2:42:34] I don't know what that number is supposed to be. [2:42:38] Typically, you do some sort of studies specific to the project that would tell you what could be the in-lu-fi. [2:42:44] Or you could say the hotel uses need to have some sort of contract at a certain rate. [2:42:53] I would recommend point eight because that's what we've said for the others. [2:42:57] And then the other uses could be subject to the in-loop fee only. [2:43:02] That would be pretty typical to what would apply to another similar projects. [2:43:10] That makes sense that I- [2:43:12] So the in-loop fee can only apply to certain uses? [2:43:15] Well, maybe we keep it open ended, but not as a built-in alternative. [2:43:19] Maybe we go into section 4.4.1.4. [2:43:24] Make up a new section and say topics of negotiation may not include, but are not limited to. [2:43:31] Paying the city's parking development impact fee for some or any parking uses required by the project. [2:43:44] Something up to that effect. [2:43:45] I mean, so that it's on the table as part of the conversation, but I really [2:43:51] I'm strongly opposed to leaving it as the safety net for the community to bear the brunt without [2:43:58] some sort of backstop [2:44:01] So it is typical for the other uses as Molly said to be able to pay the inluffie in the parking exempt over they district [2:44:08] but if [2:44:10] My understanding, maybe it's striking specifically the hotel's ability to the 0.8 spaces per hotel room rounded up in your one space from that language. [2:44:21] So they'd be able to pay in Luffy for the non-transit uses. [2:44:28] I think that's reasonable. I mean people who work downtown get that benefit, but it's primarily the hotel guest that is the concern, yeah. [2:44:35] Okay, so, and I'm going to look to the developer, or just, or the applicant team, just to make sure that I'm understanding what you're saying, is that the in-luffy, and it really is an update to the zoning not so much the DA, but we'll cover that with your motion. [2:44:50] So, updating a recommendation to the zoning, that the in-luffy can be paid for the non-transient non-residential uses. [2:45:01] I'm writing this down, as I say it. And some sort of parking arrangement, whether it be private or with the city of Napa, needs to be secured by time occupants here building permit. That's question for you. [2:45:19] for that any it would really only be the transient uses because the other uses are covered [2:45:25] the housing uses are the residential is covered already and are we applying the point eight rate [2:45:31] or unit point eight parking spaces or you not it's like something to do. I mean I think that's [2:45:38] probably okay a lot of people are using different. And I would suggest certificate of occupancy [2:45:45] Just a bit at a very, very time to kind of go sheet with the city. [2:45:49] Okay. [2:45:50] I have a follow-up question for staff on that. [2:45:52] One of the proposed options was partnering on the development of a garage or using, [2:46:00] I guess, to staff how many concerns about not receiving the impact fee funds and would that [2:46:08] potentially hinder like a, no, no, that wouldn't be a, no, no, for the hotel use of the [2:46:18] No, that would not be a consideration at the point because even if we entered into a license agreement and had revenue, it would be the same as being able to demonstrate what we could bond for. [2:46:27] So yeah, I don't have concern about that. [2:46:29] Thank you. [2:46:34] Other additional. [2:46:46] This may be a question for the cultural heritage commission, [2:46:52] but I think that this should be submitted to the Office of Historic Preservation to win awards. [2:46:59] So, reach out now before you get any further in C, maybe there's a grant, maybe there's a [2:47:07] Mills Act contract or something of that sort, that was the only other thing that I wanted to mention. [2:47:14] I do have one more thing regarding the timing of the determination of the in Luffy for the parking. [2:47:23] It should probably be made at the time that the parking determination is made as of so, for [2:47:34] example, if the fee goes up in the next whenever, but they haven't figured out the parking, [2:47:43] I think we don't want to make a point where people are hedging a bet or effectively take [2:47:51] you know, a low cost loan from the public in terms of banking artificially reduced fee compared [2:48:03] to what the market cost of the fee ought to be at the time of the parking. Does that make sense? [2:48:11] Follow up to that. Yes, it does, but that's the same argument I'm making in terms of the housing [2:48:15] in fact fee. I'm just saying we shouldn't lock it in as low, [2:48:25] but I'm not trying to put a number on it. [2:48:27] So all of the, so in the, the agreement, as it's written right now, all of the impact fees are locked in and they're listed specifically in their rates by the type of the impact development impact fear and loofy and the rate that it is currently so you'd have to specify what rate you're proposing to change to whatever or remove it from the lock. [2:48:53] It does exhibit H. So you'll see exhibit H lists a small affordable housing, street improvement, utility underground fire, paramedic impact, parking development, and it's a locked list. So it's a list that essentially walks them into places to what they are today. [2:49:11] Again, in your purview to change it, but you have to specify which one do you want to change? [2:49:19] I say since we're removing a lot of them, but it's the same argument of how do you unlock [2:49:27] one? [2:49:34] Do you guys don't want to do it, then we don't have to do it, it's a body. [2:49:40] I think if our rationale for why we can't make a recommendation in terms of housing is that [2:49:46] it's not the role of this body to set impact fees, then that would also apply to parties. [2:49:53] in terms of consistency with that logic. [2:49:55] Well, we've talked about it and so maybe, you know, they'll think about it if they want to make a change. [2:50:03] I also know that with these entitlements, they have three years, right? I mean, to actually, in terms of their [2:50:13] sun setting, they will sunset. [2:50:18] So it isn't as if we are going to be looking at impact fees that are going to change dramatically, perhaps, perhaps I don't know. [2:50:28] But if it's this three-year window of opportunity, hopefully, and I know that they want to build this, and so let's be optimistic and hope that the impact fees don't increase dramatically to what they may be paying now. [2:50:51] All right. Well, we don't have to open Pandora's box then. In my opinion. [2:51:03] Can I just, can I go back to the payment of the enlufi in the determining of that? [2:51:09] My attorney just pointed out to me that typically the enlufi's are paid at the time of building permit. [2:51:17] So, doesn't mean that the agreement necessarily has to be solidified by the time of the building permit fee, [2:51:22] but that the number of parking spaces that would be provided via the fee versus an agreement should be determined by the time. [2:51:31] and then the agreement would be effective, [2:51:33] essentially on the date that's of sort of a bucket of occupancy. [2:51:37] I just, I bring that up and we were just corresponding [2:51:41] about how to get the motion right, [2:51:43] to still make the city council meeting [2:51:45] and so we're trying not to mess up the timing for that, [2:51:48] which is what we're having in mind. [2:51:51] So potentially moving that up to permit would be [2:51:55] an easier metric for us to place, like I said, [2:51:58] the agreement doesn't have to be effective [2:51:59] until certificate of occupancy, but presumably worked out by a building permit. [2:52:04] Issuance. [2:52:05] So not application issuance. [2:52:17] Does anybody else have anything else to add? [2:52:23] Yeah. [2:52:24] Final comments? [2:52:28] The sign is beautiful. [2:52:29] I'm really excited. [2:52:31] Looks great. [2:52:34] And I can't wait. [2:52:35] I wasn't here. [2:52:36] When the post office was open, [2:52:38] so I'm very excited for this two move forward and hopefully get to go inside and look around. [2:52:43] So, great job with the design and appreciate you for getting us something that's so [2:52:47] like quality. [2:52:52] I will say thank you again for your investment in our city. [2:52:59] I echo all of them. I want to thank you for your stewardship and [2:53:03] personal, I say you're revering and you're respecting of the post office. [2:53:08] And it being a place that the community can enjoy a building that will be open to the public. [2:53:15] And I am a fan of B.A.R. I've worked in the city at an architecture program in many years. [2:53:20] So I'm happy to have you guys here in my city. Thank you. [2:53:25] Well, you know, I feel like I owe your team a little bit of an apology because I've sat here and poked holes in your application for the last two three hours. [2:53:36] And I don't mean to blind sighting with those things. [2:53:39] This project should be recognized as a remarkable preservation effort and really nobody in the right mind would have to do that if they didn't really care about the community. [2:53:52] And, you know, it's a beautiful project. It really is. [2:53:55] And compared to what we have now, which is a fenced off, you know, broken building and a parking lot. [2:54:02] Uh, although the notion of hotels is a little bit controversial right now, this will be immense [2:54:09] dramatic improvement to that. [2:54:11] And so the project in principle is phenomenal. [2:54:14] And these are just little nitpicky things that need to get worked out, but they're their [2:54:19] solvable things. [2:54:20] And so, really, thank you guys for a really beautiful project. [2:54:23] Really look forward to getting it completed and thanks for being here tonight. [2:54:31] There's nothing more I can say to add to what I've already said. [2:54:36] I'm very grateful and it's been the monumental effort on Jim Keller's part [2:54:41] and everyone on the team and I'm so appreciative and I look forward [2:54:45] to stepping foot in it and getting the mail that I'm still waiting for [2:54:50] because I had a post office box there during the earthquake. [2:54:56] Who would like to make a motion? [2:54:58] Just real quick, I just want to [2:55:00] I'm going to clarify because what was not discussed or just assuming the five-head nons. Are we, [2:55:06] is the commission an agreement adding to the zoning, the maintaining, or any changes to the full glass structure for the ceiling glass? [2:55:15] Enhancing the post office building is a major modification, and then the same with the materials as attachment six, any changes to the materials is a major modification. [2:55:24] So we would, we will just meet, and I can help you read into what the changes are, but I just [2:55:29] wanted to make sure that all five of you were in agreement on that before we made the motion [2:55:33] on that, and if we had to do them separately. [2:55:34] Any changes to the materials seems like that might be a booby trap? [2:55:39] I would say specifically the bronze earns, the brick work. [2:55:44] No, what I mean is the new building, the materials need to match what they've already presented [2:55:52] that pale mage to the bronze urns and the melt glass and that I mentioned. The champagne bronze [2:56:02] colors, you know the bronze, do I have to go through this one? If it's, if it's, if it's going [2:56:09] to be specific materials that can change or if it's going to be color, like we do need that [2:56:13] specificity as to whether it's a major or yeah, I mean I went through the materials at my initial [2:56:20] meeting with the applicant and they confirmed that those would be the colors and the [2:56:26] materials and then I looked at it again in the packet and they are indeed the materials [2:56:32] that I feel really do reflect the historic integrity of the original post office. [2:56:43] So we say anything that's in substantial deviation from the materials board or consistent with [2:56:49] these materials in our highly, I mean yes, like products could change because I think it [2:57:01] could become unavailable, but if I mean that's that's giving discretion to staff to determine [2:57:05] if it's in substantial performance. So I mean, which is what it sounds like you're driving [2:57:16] at because someone's going to have to make the determination at some point, whether that change [2:57:23] that's proposed is substantial or significant. [2:57:30] And the baseline that you're talking about is what the materials that you reviewed. [2:57:38] Yes, that are reflected in the packet. [2:57:42] And it's some material. [2:57:43] I mean it is pretty specific attachment six. [2:57:47] It's sort of referated metal screen honeycomb M2 too. [2:57:52] So in practice there's the sheet, we don't have the construction details yet, that [2:57:58] know where it's gonna be sourced from and maybe that's the flexibility that's still there [2:58:01] is where they source it, the exact specifications. [2:58:06] But generally, if you made a motion to be consistent with these materials I know what [2:58:11] that means and I know what the expectation is. [2:58:12] what the expectation is. It's much like in kind when you're dealing with historic preservation [2:58:17] and you'll match sighting that's in kind to the original structure. So with colors and texture, [2:58:27] I don't, I would like to not see any vinyl or aluminum, but perhaps bronze actual, you know, [2:58:34] bronze elements in in trim and awnings and things of that sort, or at least make it look as if it's, [2:58:42] know, I mean, it's real, it's metal, not, not vines. So basically color and material type [2:58:49] of material. So any change of materials that is inconsistent with exhibit, attachment [2:58:55] of sex would be considered a mere material. She A4. She A4 lines 1 through 30. Not that part. [2:59:04] I mean, the lighting design is also lovely. So I would hope that doesn't change either. [2:59:12] Right? [2:59:13] That's all. [2:59:14] The concepts generally show that the style of lighting, but we don't have the source and [2:59:19] main factor of lighting yet. [2:59:20] Right. [2:59:20] The style is what I'm talking about. [2:59:22] I mean, it's so, it's lovely how it's, it's so conducive to, like, welcoming [2:59:32] people, but not being stark and everything that they mentioned, even in the packet, with [2:59:39] with how they've created the lighting design so this is part of the design review we are [2:59:49] here to review the design if it turns out that it's built and it looks [2:59:55] It's nothing like what we've approved. [2:59:59] Yes. [3:00:00] That would not be kosher in my humble opinion. [3:00:09] I would recommend that we rely on staff's expertise to ensure substantial conformance with what we're looking at today. [3:00:16] So materials in the lighting plan, I trust their professional expertise to make sure that what we're talking about is reflected. [3:00:23] So substantially conforms with the design color and materials shown in attachment six. [3:00:29] Yes. Okay. [3:00:34] All right. [3:00:36] So I would recommend we do the motions individually, and then we'll all read into the record. [3:00:43] Anything that needs to be added as a recommendation to city council. Does that make sense? [3:00:48] Sure. Sure. So individually we'll read. [3:00:50] Starting with one. Yep. Then too. [3:00:52] Okay. Who would like to make the motion? [3:00:57] Okay. [3:00:57] Can we just get a clarification on the other thing that we discussed the public art piece of it? [3:01:04] I haven't written down, this is how I haven't written down, and it would go, I think, with number one. [3:01:13] What? [3:01:13] Number two. [3:01:18] We'll figure out where, number two. [3:01:19] Okay, excuse me, because there's number two. [3:01:22] Go ahead, Kylie. [3:01:24] All right. [3:01:24] I don't mean interrupt. [3:01:26] Please. [3:01:27] Just for clarification, you could easily do the staff recommendation as one motion. [3:01:32] It sounds like there might be a couple of items that the commission would like to make as additional recommendations. [3:01:41] Might as to just that you do those as individual recommendations. [3:01:45] And it's assuming that the commission is all an agreement on staff's recommendation. [3:01:49] That could be as one motion. [3:01:51] But I've been hearing both foreign against on a couple of topics. [3:01:55] So perhaps if someone made a motion on one of those items such as the material change that has just been [3:02:02] discussed, those could be taken first, and then those would then be rolled up into the [3:02:07] meat, the entirety of the staff recommendation if that makes sense. [3:02:11] So I could chair if you said as I can read what I have written down, [3:02:16] and then if somebody wants to so move in second it, and then you vote individually on those, [3:02:20] and I can read them one by one, and you can, and then we'll go with normal staff recommendations. [3:02:25] So, the motion. So, the first one is disowning be updated to include that the left and right side, [3:02:36] full glass floor-to-sealing panels that enhance the post office building, be considered a major amendment, if changed. [3:02:46] Can I will make that motion in a second? [3:02:50] All those in favor? [3:02:51] Okay. [3:02:56] Do you have to call motion passes? [3:02:57] Thank you. [3:02:58] Did everybody vote? [3:03:00] Sorry. [3:03:00] I wasn't looking at mouse. [3:03:02] The second one is that any substantial change to the design color in design style and color [3:03:14] of the materials presented in attachment 6 planning commission report on June 30, [3:03:19] with 2026 return to the planning commission for review. [3:03:24] So moved, second, all those in favor? [3:03:28] Aye. Motion passes. [3:03:32] Third one would be a large format that the city council [3:03:39] consider changes to the mixed use building wall, [3:03:46] self-well, self-well, with some sort of large format aesthetic improvement when they consider [3:03:54] this on 721. [3:03:57] So moved. [3:03:59] Second, all those in favor? [3:04:01] Bye. [3:04:02] No. [3:04:03] No. [3:04:04] Okay. [3:04:05] And then, so that's a, do you want to call that one? [3:04:08] Motion passes. [3:04:10] Four one. [3:04:10] Do it one. [3:04:11] Thank you. [3:04:14] And then the last one is that language be struck from zoning and DA documents regarding paying the in Luffy for, oh, I'm going to put that for the hotel uses so for the transient uses yes but that and I'll just clarify that the it's for the record that the in Luffy could be paid for the non transient uses. [3:04:43] in the hotel post office we have to build it. [3:04:49] Did I capture that correctly? [3:04:52] Okay. [3:04:56] Second, all those in favor. [3:04:58] Bye. [3:05:00] Motion passes for one. [3:05:07] Now, I believe you're on. Okay, staff, I will do this one real quick. [3:05:10] Staff, planning commission recommends to move forward. [3:05:13] The city council, number one, adopt a resolution, approving, pursuant to section 15168, analysis, and [3:05:19] addendum to the downtown NAPA specific plan, programmatic, environmental impact report. [3:05:24] And alternatively, to the SQL Guidelines section 15332, categorical exemption. [3:05:30] And two, adopt an ordinance, approving amendments to a plan development overlay. [3:05:34] three adopted ordinance approving a development agreement and four adopted resolution [3:05:39] approving a design review permit and tentative parcel map and determined that the [3:05:44] potential environmental effects of the project were adequately analyzed and addressed [3:05:48] by a prior California Environmental Quality Act action as documented in the [3:06:11] All right, let's see where we are now. [3:06:19] There are no administrative reports, unless it's changed since this. [3:06:25] OK, lastly, any final comments by commissioners or staff this evening? [3:06:35] Yes, I have a pretty substantial update with those in the audience, those at home watching. [3:06:42] We have the public draft of the zone ordinance document that was published [3:06:48] of not last week's of the week prior. [3:06:53] Public comment review period extending to July 24th, obviously [3:06:58] opportunity for public comment in through when both planning commission [3:07:02] and city council consider. [3:07:05] The public draft of the conference is during the ordinance update, [3:07:09] but we have a workshop for the general public at the Napa County Library [3:07:15] in the community room at 530 on July 14th and a steady session by the Planning Commission [3:07:23] on the 16th of July. It is a quite the undertaking, I think 474 pages of a draft that we've [3:07:32] had to go through multiple times, Dan, including. [3:07:38] But there's an executive memo and funny to say [3:07:45] high-level summarizes what that consists of. [3:07:50] So I encourage everybody from the general public, [3:07:53] all the stakeholders that are interested, [3:07:55] planning commission, any other members of the commissions [3:08:00] and boards within the City of Napa participate [3:08:02] through the process and the ways appropriate to them. [3:08:07] Should they have any questions? [3:08:09] We have an email dedicated to the ordinance update [3:08:13] zoning update at cityofnapa.org. [3:08:16] I'd prefer emails or sent to that email as a central location, [3:08:21] but we are logging in all comments received through the public comment period [3:08:25] and we will consider the feedback that's been conveyed [3:08:29] among the feedback that's already been conveyed in this effort. [3:08:32] So, encourage everyone to participate. [3:08:35] Lastly, we will be having another planner join in August, [3:08:41] more details to follow and then hopefully in introduction on the horizon. [3:08:46] It's exciting. [3:08:48] Great. [3:08:50] Does anybody else have any comments? [3:08:52] It's been a long evening. [3:08:53] All right. [3:08:54] Well, the next argument we scheduled meeting for the planning commission in the city of Napa is [3:08:57] in two days. [3:08:58] This Thursday, July 2nd, we'll see you guys soon.