1
00:03:17,242 --> 00:03:17,944
Good evening and

2
00:03:17,944 --> 00:03:20,944
welcome to the Public Safety

3
00:03:22,114 --> 00:03:23,615
Committee meeting of Tuesday,

4
00:03:23,615 --> 00:03:24,283
7/14/2026, the time is now

5
00:03:24,283 --> 00:03:26,683
06:00:02pm, in this meeting

6
00:03:27,619 --> 00:03:28,287
MAY come to order before

7
00:03:28,287 --> 00:03:28,987
taking roll. I will provide

8
00:03:28,987 --> 00:03:30,789
instructions on how to submit

9
00:03:30,789 --> 00:03:31,690
speaker cards for items on

10
00:03:31,690 --> 00:03:32,357
this agenda. If you here with

11
00:03:32,357 --> 00:03:35,328
us in chamber would like to

12
00:03:35,328 --> 00:03:36,610
submit a speaker card, please.

13
00:03:36,610 --> 00:03:37,429
But we're now in turn one into

14
00:03:37,429 --> 00:03:39,164
myself or clerk

15
00:03:39,164 --> 00:03:39,865
representative. No later than

16
00:03:39,865 --> 00:03:41,200
10 minutes after the start of

17
00:03:41,200 --> 00:03:41,900
this meeting or before the

18
00:03:41,900 --> 00:03:44,900
item is read into record,

19
00:03:45,771 --> 00:03:46,438
whichever occurs first online

20
00:03:46,438 --> 00:03:47,841
speaker request do 24 hours

21
00:03:47,841 --> 00:03:50,142
prior to the start of this

22
00:03:50,142 --> 00:03:50,976
meeting, this to order at

23
00:03:50,976 --> 00:03:52,277
06:00:02pm, and speaker cards

24
00:03:52,277 --> 00:03:54,747
will no longer be accepted. 10

25
00:03:54,747 --> 00:03:56,882
minutes after making that time

26
00:03:56,882 --> 00:03:59,882
06:12pm, will now proceed with

27
00:04:01,120 --> 00:04:01,987
taking roll councilmembers

28
00:04:01,987 --> 00:04:02,621
bound. PRESIDENT Might be

29
00:04:02,621 --> 00:04:05,210
excused. Houston here and

30
00:04:06,580 --> 00:04:08,580
CHAIRMAN Long. PRESIDENT.

31
00:04:08,127 --> 00:04:08,827
Thank you. We have 3 members

32
00:04:08,827 --> 00:04:09,528
present one excused by chair

33
00:04:09,528 --> 00:04:13,650
at this time. Do you have any

34
00:04:13,650 --> 00:04:15,465
announcements? Yes, I do.

35
00:04:16,869 --> 00:04:18,670
First of all, we are going

36
00:04:18,670 --> 00:04:20,539
since we have a packed agenda

37
00:04:20,539 --> 00:04:21,173
today. Committee. I just ask

38
00:04:21,173 --> 00:04:23,509
that everyone keep their

39
00:04:23,509 --> 00:04:25,512
comments succinct and they

40
00:04:25,512 --> 00:04:27,146
should be pointed in an

41
00:04:27,146 --> 00:04:27,846
important and then I'm also

42
00:04:27,846 --> 00:04:30,846
going to limit public comment

43
00:04:30,949 --> 00:04:31,618
to one minute. We do have a

44
00:04:31,618 --> 00:04:32,317
packed agenda and I want to

45
00:04:32,317 --> 00:04:34,653
make sure we get through all

46
00:04:34,653 --> 00:04:38,253
the items. The other thing I

47
00:04:38,557 --> 00:04:39,458
just wanted to mention is

48
00:04:39,458 --> 00:04:40,759
announcement is we do have a

49
00:04:40,759 --> 00:04:41,827
new police chief, of course, a

50
00:04:41,827 --> 00:04:44,163
permanent police chief. So

51
00:04:44,163 --> 00:04:46,498
congratulations to chief beer.

52
00:04:46,498 --> 00:04:48,434
And I also want to acknowledge

53
00:04:48,434 --> 00:04:49,134
that there was an

54
00:04:49,134 --> 00:04:50,200
officer-involved shooting

55
00:04:50,200 --> 00:04:51,737
yesterday on International

56
00:04:51,737 --> 00:04:53,238
Boulevard in the afternoon.

57
00:04:53,238 --> 00:04:55,774
And so there's an ongoing

58
00:04:55,774 --> 00:04:58,774
investigation. And so I'm not

59
00:04:58,844 --> 00:04:59,812
able to provide additional

60
00:04:59,812 --> 00:05:00,512
comment, but that is

61
00:05:00,512 --> 00:05:02,912
incredibly important thing to

62
00:05:05,684 --> 00:05:08,684
knowledge. And then yes, final

63
00:05:08,887 --> 00:05:11,757
piece is we will also be

64
00:05:11,757 --> 00:05:14,527
moving the item 8. This is the

65
00:05:14,527 --> 00:05:16,527
opd surveillance Technology.

66
00:05:19,631 --> 00:05:20,332
2024 annual report. 2 item 3.

67
00:05:20,332 --> 00:05:20,999
It since I know that many of

68
00:05:20,999 --> 00:05:23,399
the public commenters have

69
00:05:27,773 --> 00:05:31,373
come here for that item. Okay.

70
00:05:31,510 --> 00:05:33,479
Noting the change story noting

71
00:05:33,479 --> 00:05:34,446
the change to the order of the

72
00:05:34,446 --> 00:05:37,383
agenda to hear item number 8

73
00:05:37,383 --> 00:05:38,617
after taking items, one in 2

74
00:05:38,617 --> 00:05:39,318
living on to item one approval

75
00:05:39,318 --> 00:05:42,788
of the draft minutes from the

76
00:05:42,788 --> 00:05:43,389
committee meeting of JUNE 23rd

77
00:05:43,389 --> 00:05:44,890
2000. 26, there are no

78
00:05:44,890 --> 00:05:47,689
speakers on this item. So we

79
00:05:49,795 --> 00:05:53,395
just need a motion. I'll move

80
00:05:54,867 --> 00:05:55,567
the meeting minutes. Thank

81
00:05:55,567 --> 00:05:56,301
you. That's a motion made by

82
00:05:56,301 --> 00:05:57,569
council member Brown second by

83
00:05:57,569 --> 00:05:59,539
councilmember. He son to

84
00:05:59,539 --> 00:06:01,939
accept the committee meeting

85
00:06:03,742 --> 00:06:04,743
minutes of JUNE 23rd 2026 on

86
00:06:04,743 --> 00:06:05,778
Real Councilmembers. Brown. I

87
00:06:05,778 --> 00:06:07,780
excused Houston. I chair

88
00:06:07,780 --> 00:06:08,414
along. I thank you. Item one

89
00:06:08,414 --> 00:06:09,915
passes with 3. I has won

90
00:06:09,915 --> 00:06:11,830
excused by to accept the

91
00:06:11,830 --> 00:06:13,483
minutes. The draft minutes

92
00:06:15,988 --> 00:06:16,855
from JUNE 23rd 2026. Read e an

93
00:06:16,855 --> 00:06:17,723
item to determination of

94
00:06:17,723 --> 00:06:18,323
schedule standing committee

95
00:06:18,323 --> 00:06:20,659
items and we do have 2

96
00:06:20,659 --> 00:06:23,659
speakers for this item. Okay.

97
00:06:25,597 --> 00:06:26,231
We'll go to public comment.

98
00:06:26,231 --> 00:06:26,932
Calling in the name that

99
00:06:26,932 --> 00:06:31,132
signed up to speak on item to

100
00:06:31,537 --> 00:06:35,137
Jesse Rose more and Blair be.

101
00:06:35,541 --> 00:06:36,775
Hi. How are you? Just the

102
00:06:36,775 --> 00:06:37,476
first item on this. Penny? No

103
00:06:37,476 --> 00:06:38,177
dates. A specific list is to

104
00:06:38,177 --> 00:06:39,778
adopt a resolution directing

105
00:06:39,778 --> 00:06:41,680
the city administrator

106
00:06:41,680 --> 00:06:42,414
implement approved processes

107
00:06:42,414 --> 00:06:44,516
for civilian icing, certain

108
00:06:44,516 --> 00:06:47,516
sworn positions from opd to

109
00:06:47,721 --> 00:06:48,387
improve public safety services

110
00:06:48,387 --> 00:06:49,540
for communities and create

111
00:06:49,540 --> 00:06:51,123
millions in cost savings by

112
00:06:51,123 --> 00:06:53,192
reducing over time. Hours.

113
00:06:53,192 --> 00:06:55,394
This has been the longest one

114
00:06:55,394 --> 00:06:56,161
on this side pending noted

115
00:06:56,161 --> 00:06:58,197
specifically as it's been

116
00:06:58,197 --> 00:07:01,797
there on over. It's been there

117
00:07:01,900 --> 00:07:03,680
over a We demand that you

118
00:07:03,680 --> 00:07:05,104
schedule is now I'm having

119
00:07:05,104 --> 00:07:07,206
this be the longest item on

120
00:07:07,206 --> 00:07:08,273
yet to be scheduled shows that

121
00:07:08,273 --> 00:07:10,209
Oakland doesn't have a budget

122
00:07:10,209 --> 00:07:13,209
problem. It has a leadership

123
00:07:14,113 --> 00:07:16,115
problem. This goes beyond

124
00:07:16,115 --> 00:07:19,115
malfeasance We need to save

125
00:07:19,184 --> 00:07:19,785
money. We have a city council

126
00:07:19,785 --> 00:07:22,185
that is defunding odot

127
00:07:22,321 --> 00:07:25,321
defining this cpra and, you

128
00:07:26,191 --> 00:07:28,227
know, just doing abjectly

129
00:07:28,227 --> 00:07:29,261
corrupt things as pointed out

130
00:07:29,261 --> 00:07:31,661
by several city employees. 555

131
00:07:33,232 --> 00:07:35,267
Aquinas. The yacht. Thank you

132
00:07:35,267 --> 00:07:36,340
for your comments which into

133
00:07:36,340 --> 00:07:36,769
Zoom user Blair. You can

134
00:07:36,769 --> 00:07:39,769
unmute yourself and begin your

135
00:07:42,508 --> 00:07:43,208
comment. Important public

136
00:07:43,208 --> 00:07:45,608
safety meeting tonight. Thank

137
00:07:48,614 --> 00:07:52,184
you. I with upcoming agenda is

138
00:07:52,184 --> 00:07:55,854
I I can item we're going to be

139
00:07:55,854 --> 00:07:57,854
wanting to Surveillance

140
00:07:59,725 --> 00:08:00,692
technology. Technology. What

141
00:08:00,692 --> 00:08:01,226
are our choices besides

142
00:08:01,226 --> 00:08:01,927
sparked cover those

143
00:08:01,927 --> 00:08:02,628
conversations start to become

144
00:08:02,628 --> 00:08:06,228
a little bit more public and

145
00:08:06,999 --> 00:08:08,100
regular it's important that

146
00:08:08,100 --> 00:08:11,100
we're doing with the subject.

147
00:08:11,770 --> 00:08:13,639
Really have a chance Europe.

148
00:08:13,639 --> 00:08:14,406
We're like practices

149
00:08:14,406 --> 00:08:16,406
corporations and practices

150
00:08:17,509 --> 00:08:18,410
that work more towards

151
00:08:18,410 --> 00:08:20,410
basically open democracy,

152
00:08:23,282 --> 00:08:24,383
clear accountability. Good

153
00:08:24,383 --> 00:08:25,584
luck. How we do that. We have

154
00:08:25,584 --> 00:08:26,285
to start making know that that

155
00:08:26,285 --> 00:08:29,154
that more public and regular

156
00:08:29,154 --> 00:08:29,822
at that point, I think what we

157
00:08:29,822 --> 00:08:33,422
start now by this time next

158
00:08:36,795 --> 00:08:37,496
year. You know, the JANUARY.

159
00:08:37,496 --> 00:08:41,567
Walker is with have a lp, our

160
00:08:41,567 --> 00:08:42,267
vendor next fall. Thank you

161
00:08:42,267 --> 00:08:42,968
for your comments. Sure. That

162
00:08:42,968 --> 00:08:45,968
includes all speakers on this

163
00:08:48,240 --> 00:08:50,777
item. Great any anything from

164
00:08:50,777 --> 00:08:52,777
my colleagues. Administration.

165
00:08:54,460 --> 00:08:54,646
Great. Take a motion. Perfect.

166
00:08:54,646 --> 00:08:57,646
All motion. To move the

167
00:08:59,251 --> 00:09:00,919
penniless. Second, Thank you.

168
00:09:00,919 --> 00:09:02,200
We have a motion made by

169
00:09:02,200 --> 00:09:02,955
Councilmember bound second MAY

170
00:09:02,955 --> 00:09:03,622
councilmember Houston to

171
00:09:03,622 --> 00:09:04,590
accept the determination of

172
00:09:04,590 --> 00:09:07,590
standing committee items as is

173
00:09:08,360 --> 00:09:10,630
on row councilmembers bound.

174
00:09:10,630 --> 00:09:12,898
Excused Houston, I and chair

175
00:09:12,898 --> 00:09:14,833
long. I thank you. Item 2

176
00:09:14,833 --> 00:09:15,467
passes with 3 eyes when

177
00:09:15,467 --> 00:09:16,201
excused by to accept the

178
00:09:16,201 --> 00:09:18,601
determination of schedules and

179
00:09:19,838 --> 00:09:21,173
committee items as is. Reading

180
00:09:21,173 --> 00:09:21,874
in item 8 noting that there

181
00:09:21,874 --> 00:09:25,474
wasn't change to the order of

182
00:09:28,213 --> 00:09:31,150
the agenda. Adopt a resolution

183
00:09:31,150 --> 00:09:31,884
accepting the 2025 annual

184
00:09:31,884 --> 00:09:33,552
reports for the following city

185
00:09:33,552 --> 00:09:35,587
of Oakland Police Department's

186
00:09:35,587 --> 00:09:36,422
surveillance technologies.

187
00:09:36,422 --> 00:09:37,556
Automated license plate

188
00:09:37,556 --> 00:09:39,956
readers be crime lab

189
00:09:40,159 --> 00:09:40,793
biometrics, dna analysis,

190
00:09:40,793 --> 00:09:43,193
technology. See a forward

191
00:09:45,431 --> 00:09:47,266
looking infrared. At Belle ir

192
00:09:47,266 --> 00:09:49,266
livestream transmitter e

193
00:09:50,969 --> 00:09:51,603
unmanned aerial systems

194
00:09:51,603 --> 00:09:53,603
forensic legit coupling,

195
00:09:54,740 --> 00:09:55,908
crime, chase assistance, Jea

196
00:09:55,908 --> 00:09:58,877
pen Register and h celebrate

197
00:09:58,877 --> 00:10:01,180
and to making a dent

198
00:10:01,180 --> 00:10:02,915
determination regarding

199
00:10:02,915 --> 00:10:04,490
whether the city should

200
00:10:04,490 --> 00:10:04,717
continue continue to use each

201
00:10:04,717 --> 00:10:05,384
of these technologies. And

202
00:10:05,384 --> 00:10:06,510
there are 16 speakers that

203
00:10:06,510 --> 00:10:09,651
signed up to speak on this

204
00:10:10,789 --> 00:10:14,389
item. Ok, great. I will turn

205
00:10:15,295 --> 00:10:15,961
it over to Dc does feel as if

206
00:10:15,961 --> 00:10:18,361
I pronounced that correctly

207
00:10:22,167 --> 00:10:23,235
have ok? All right. And then

208
00:10:23,235 --> 00:10:24,169
if I know that you are

209
00:10:24,169 --> 00:10:24,803
requesting a modification to

210
00:10:24,803 --> 00:10:27,940
this item, if you want to

211
00:10:27,940 --> 00:10:28,907
state that up front,

212
00:10:28,907 --> 00:10:31,307
absolutely. So again, acting

213
00:10:33,379 --> 00:10:36,281
deputy chief doesn't get from

214
00:10:36,281 --> 00:10:38,250
Oakland Police Department. Pd

215
00:10:38,250 --> 00:10:39,118
is requesting that Alpr

216
00:10:39,118 --> 00:10:41,518
automated license plate reader

217
00:10:42,121 --> 00:10:43,589
for 2025 annual report be

218
00:10:43,589 --> 00:10:44,490
removed from the agenda.

219
00:10:44,490 --> 00:10:46,490
That's apology changes

220
00:10:47,760 --> 00:10:48,327
recommended in the report.

221
00:10:48,327 --> 00:10:49,561
Accompanying revised

222
00:10:49,561 --> 00:10:51,961
department. Jenna order. I-12

223
00:10:52,898 --> 00:10:53,465
Alp our policy. All right. Not

224
00:10:53,465 --> 00:10:54,133
contained within the

225
00:10:54,133 --> 00:10:56,533
resolution related to this

226
00:10:56,702 --> 00:10:58,570
item. The concern around the

227
00:10:58,570 --> 00:11:00,472
resolution was identified by

228
00:11:00,472 --> 00:11:01,390
opd and then brought to the

229
00:11:01,390 --> 00:11:01,608
attention of the city

230
00:11:01,608 --> 00:11:03,608
attorney's office for

231
00:11:04,243 --> 00:11:06,243
clarification. Opd is

232
00:11:07,413 --> 00:11:09,248
requesting to reschedule the

233
00:11:09,248 --> 00:11:09,948
specific item after the

234
00:11:09,948 --> 00:11:11,984
legislative recess to allow

235
00:11:11,984 --> 00:11:12,785
for the presentation of the

236
00:11:12,785 --> 00:11:15,185
annual report in conjunction

237
00:11:17,256 --> 00:11:18,157
with the amended policy. This

238
00:11:18,157 --> 00:11:18,791
will allow for a more

239
00:11:18,791 --> 00:11:19,758
comprehensive discussion

240
00:11:19,758 --> 00:11:21,758
around potential policy

241
00:11:22,327 --> 00:11:22,961
changes. The reflect the

242
00:11:22,961 --> 00:11:25,361
ongoing analysis, the lpr

243
00:11:26,331 --> 00:11:26,999
program. The movement of this

244
00:11:26,999 --> 00:11:28,934
item will not impact the

245
00:11:28,934 --> 00:11:30,569
presentation of the annual

246
00:11:30,569 --> 00:11:32,969
report within the designated

247
00:11:32,971 --> 00:11:33,672
period. It will also not

248
00:11:33,672 --> 00:11:36,720
impact impact the department

249
00:11:39,912 --> 00:11:40,879
operationally. Thank you.

250
00:11:40,879 --> 00:11:41,780
Since I had some back and

251
00:11:41,780 --> 00:11:42,448
forth discussions with opd

252
00:11:42,448 --> 00:11:44,848
colleagues, does that make

253
00:11:45,984 --> 00:11:49,584
sense to the alpr section is

254
00:11:50,723 --> 00:11:53,580
being This is item. Listed 8

255
00:11:53,580 --> 00:11:56,495
the agenda, some some item a.

256
00:11:56,495 --> 00:11:58,970
Please go ahead. As everyone

257
00:11:58,970 --> 00:12:00,497
knows the Oakland Police

258
00:12:02,000 --> 00:12:02,768
Department is short staffed,

259
00:12:02,768 --> 00:12:04,837
but we do. We are actively

260
00:12:04,837 --> 00:12:06,837
recruiting for additional

261
00:12:08,173 --> 00:12:08,774
resources, but we rely heavily

262
00:12:08,774 --> 00:12:11,110
on technology. And this

263
00:12:11,110 --> 00:12:13,510
technology has assisted us

264
00:12:14,120 --> 00:12:15,781
greatly solving crimes,

265
00:12:15,781 --> 00:12:17,116
identifying potential people

266
00:12:17,116 --> 00:12:20,520
of interest and also assist in

267
00:12:20,520 --> 00:12:21,453
our community and the victims

268
00:12:21,453 --> 00:12:22,821
of crime. We have utilized are

269
00:12:22,821 --> 00:12:25,570
unmanned aerial system which

270
00:12:25,570 --> 00:12:27,457
are drones. Forensic logic,

271
00:12:27,659 --> 00:12:30,659
cop link crime, tracer pen

272
00:12:31,764 --> 00:12:33,599
registers so bright to assist

273
00:12:33,599 --> 00:12:34,533
us greatly in our

274
00:12:34,533 --> 00:12:36,533
investigations. I know

275
00:12:37,936 --> 00:12:38,605
everybody has had a chance to

276
00:12:38,605 --> 00:12:40,500
review these annual reports

277
00:12:40,500 --> 00:12:42,408
and we can go and death in

278
00:12:42,408 --> 00:12:43,142
each one. If you would like,

279
00:12:43,142 --> 00:12:43,876
we can go through each one and

280
00:12:43,876 --> 00:12:46,678
if their specific questions, I

281
00:12:46,678 --> 00:12:47,780
can answer them to make it

282
00:12:47,780 --> 00:12:48,514
easier because I do want to

283
00:12:48,514 --> 00:12:51,514
answer question that you might

284
00:13:00,859 --> 00:13:01,527
already have or I think does

285
00:13:01,527 --> 00:13:02,194
that people's there we go.

286
00:13:02,194 --> 00:13:03,796
That's a better pronounce I

287
00:13:03,796 --> 00:13:05,264
think it would be good if you

288
00:13:05,264 --> 00:13:08,264
could provide just a quick

289
00:13:08,267 --> 00:13:09,134
overview of each of the

290
00:13:09,134 --> 00:13:11,534
technologies for everybody in

291
00:13:11,703 --> 00:13:13,939
this committee absolutely will

292
00:13:13,939 --> 00:13:15,808
make that he again, we have a

293
00:13:15,808 --> 00:13:17,609
amount of technology in our

294
00:13:17,609 --> 00:13:18,343
department. One of the things

295
00:13:18,343 --> 00:13:21,280
we have is our unmanned aerial

296
00:13:21,280 --> 00:13:24,183
system better known as drones

297
00:13:24,183 --> 00:13:25,150
that have says it greatly and

298
00:13:25,150 --> 00:13:27,550
our department, these drones

299
00:13:30,956 --> 00:13:33,356
are program began in 2020 2

300
00:13:37,763 --> 00:13:38,363
and we have deployed in 2025.

301
00:13:38,363 --> 00:13:40,363
131 incident spread we

302
00:13:42,668 --> 00:13:43,368
present. I'm sorry. It says

303
00:13:43,368 --> 00:13:44,570
130 times that it's actually

304
00:13:44,570 --> 00:13:45,170
131 and I clarified that with

305
00:13:45,170 --> 00:13:47,570
the prize. The Privacy

306
00:13:48,474 --> 00:13:49,174
Advisory Commission already,

307
00:13:49,174 --> 00:13:49,843
but the drones have assisted

308
00:13:49,843 --> 00:13:52,100
us greatly in being able to

309
00:13:52,100 --> 00:13:54,100
provide real-time

310
00:13:56,682 --> 00:13:57,316
intelligence. Give us unknown

311
00:13:57,316 --> 00:13:58,684
unknown, have information

312
00:13:58,684 --> 00:14:02,488
where we can't see and also be

313
00:14:02,488 --> 00:14:05,257
deployed and be able to give

314
00:14:05,257 --> 00:14:06,240
better response time. So if

315
00:14:06,240 --> 00:14:06,725
there's an incidents where a

316
00:14:06,725 --> 00:14:09,725
suspect flees from a singles

317
00:14:10,329 --> 00:14:12,564
into a yard, we can deploy

318
00:14:12,564 --> 00:14:14,333
drone. Give us some real time

319
00:14:14,333 --> 00:14:16,235
intelligence just so we don't

320
00:14:16,235 --> 00:14:19,338
send officers in there. So it

321
00:14:19,338 --> 00:14:20,500
mitigates uses of force. Is

322
00:14:20,500 --> 00:14:21,507
this real time intelligence

323
00:14:21,507 --> 00:14:24,430
and also assist us in being

324
00:14:24,430 --> 00:14:24,777
able to get that person safely

325
00:14:24,777 --> 00:14:28,377
out and for officers to safely

326
00:14:30,150 --> 00:14:31,116
take that person into custody.

327
00:14:31,116 --> 00:14:33,516
I provided several incidents

328
00:14:34,887 --> 00:14:36,956
in where they have assisted

329
00:14:36,956 --> 00:14:38,690
us. I through 10 different

330
00:14:38,690 --> 00:14:39,359
types of incidents that we've

331
00:14:39,359 --> 00:14:43,559
had. But as you can see on

332
00:14:44,663 --> 00:14:47,630
pages, 8. 9 and these were

333
00:14:47,800 --> 00:14:50,200
incidents that were. Very

334
00:14:50,836 --> 00:14:52,438
dangerous are barricaded

335
00:14:52,438 --> 00:14:53,105
suspects. There are specific

336
00:14:53,105 --> 00:14:55,505
incidents where people are

337
00:14:56,909 --> 00:14:58,143
armed with firearms and all of

338
00:14:58,143 --> 00:15:00,543
these incidents resulted in

339
00:15:02,614 --> 00:15:03,348
the safe apprehension of armed

340
00:15:03,348 --> 00:15:05,748
suspects and also the

341
00:15:08,253 --> 00:15:11,253
mitigation of uses of force.

342
00:15:12,324 --> 00:15:13,250
We do have our flare, which is

343
00:15:13,250 --> 00:15:13,726
our forward looking infrared.

344
00:15:13,726 --> 00:15:16,161
We do have somebody here from

345
00:15:16,161 --> 00:15:17,129
artist, which is our air

346
00:15:17,129 --> 00:15:18,640
support unit. This technology

347
00:15:18,640 --> 00:15:21,660
was not used in the past year.

348
00:15:21,660 --> 00:15:21,767
And I believe it's also

349
00:15:21,767 --> 00:15:22,301
outdated. So there's not much

350
00:15:22,301 --> 00:15:24,701
to report on that.

351
00:15:28,807 --> 00:15:30,807
Unfortunately.

352
00:15:42,921 --> 00:15:44,490
The next one is our live

353
00:15:44,490 --> 00:15:46,890
stream transmitter feet where

354
00:15:48,527 --> 00:15:49,495
we utilize that for protests.

355
00:15:49,495 --> 00:15:50,162
We did not play that again in

356
00:15:50,162 --> 00:15:53,762
2025, as you can see in the

357
00:15:55,467 --> 00:15:58,270
annual report. The next thing

358
00:15:58,270 --> 00:16:00,439
is our mobile forensic

359
00:16:00,439 --> 00:16:02,439
extraction device basically,

360
00:16:03,342 --> 00:16:03,942
this mobile forensic

361
00:16:03,942 --> 00:16:04,543
extraction device. It's

362
00:16:04,543 --> 00:16:06,645
basically told, used to

363
00:16:06,645 --> 00:16:08,213
extract data from seized

364
00:16:08,213 --> 00:16:09,982
mobile phones and tablets. So

365
00:16:09,982 --> 00:16:12,384
it performs a one-time that

366
00:16:12,384 --> 00:16:14,384
extraction doesn't conduct

367
00:16:14,486 --> 00:16:15,521
live surveillance. You can see

368
00:16:15,521 --> 00:16:17,921
that we extract its 730

369
00:16:23,162 --> 00:16:24,396
devices. 5 are related to

370
00:16:24,396 --> 00:16:25,764
internal administrative opd

371
00:16:25,764 --> 00:16:28,164
searches and 733 were related

372
00:16:28,634 --> 00:16:29,635
to criminal investigations. I

373
00:16:29,635 --> 00:16:30,335
know one of things that has

374
00:16:30,335 --> 00:16:32,710
been brought to our attention

375
00:16:32,710 --> 00:16:34,740
is making sure that we look at

376
00:16:34,740 --> 00:16:35,441
outside potential different

377
00:16:35,441 --> 00:16:37,543
vendors. I can tell you that

378
00:16:37,543 --> 00:16:39,943
we have been testing 2

379
00:16:40,846 --> 00:16:41,447
different than vendors. I'm

380
00:16:41,447 --> 00:16:42,915
not gonna specifically

381
00:16:42,915 --> 00:16:44,450
mentioned those names of those

382
00:16:44,450 --> 00:16:47,200
vendors, but one of the

383
00:16:47,200 --> 00:16:48,921
vendors has had a 3% success

384
00:16:48,921 --> 00:16:52,591
rate. The other one has had a

385
00:16:52,591 --> 00:16:53,492
62% success rate. While our

386
00:16:53,492 --> 00:16:57,920
current so bright has had a

387
00:17:00,499 --> 00:17:02,701
95% success rate. And again,

388
00:17:02,701 --> 00:17:06,301
these are a device that we

389
00:17:06,538 --> 00:17:07,740
utilize in assisting us in

390
00:17:07,740 --> 00:17:09,641
violent crimes. So if there is

391
00:17:09,641 --> 00:17:12,277
a homicide, a robbery, a home

392
00:17:12,277 --> 00:17:14,677
invasion robbery, a sexual

393
00:17:14,813 --> 00:17:16,615
assault, somebody who is being

394
00:17:16,615 --> 00:17:17,883
place than victimized on our

395
00:17:17,883 --> 00:17:19,752
streets for prostitution

396
00:17:19,752 --> 00:17:22,152
activity. And we're looking

397
00:17:22,821 --> 00:17:24,356
for camps. These device that

398
00:17:24,356 --> 00:17:25,230
we utilize to assist in our

399
00:17:25,230 --> 00:17:27,230
investigations. And they've

400
00:17:28,594 --> 00:17:30,994
been extremely helpful. The

401
00:17:31,631 --> 00:17:32,799
other system we have is a pen

402
00:17:32,799 --> 00:17:34,566
register system. And that's

403
00:17:34,566 --> 00:17:35,334
basically it real-time

404
00:17:35,334 --> 00:17:36,680
surveillance tool that reports

405
00:17:36,680 --> 00:17:37,936
meta information about ongoing

406
00:17:37,936 --> 00:17:39,271
and incoming phone

407
00:17:39,271 --> 00:17:41,106
communications such as

408
00:17:41,106 --> 00:17:43,242
outnumbers time stance and

409
00:17:43,242 --> 00:17:43,842
called frequency. It doesn't

410
00:17:43,842 --> 00:17:44,576
capture the content of

411
00:17:44,576 --> 00:17:46,976
communication, which is really

412
00:17:47,713 --> 00:17:49,314
important for me understand.

413
00:17:49,314 --> 00:17:50,115
We currently utilize that

414
00:17:50,115 --> 00:17:51,850
gladiator pin register system

415
00:17:51,850 --> 00:17:53,252
to receive in analyze this

416
00:17:53,252 --> 00:17:56,852
data at we utilize that that

417
00:17:58,123 --> 00:18:00,260
at 86 times last year. 47

418
00:18:00,260 --> 00:18:00,726
separate investigations and we

419
00:18:00,726 --> 00:18:03,726
have team search warrants for

420
00:18:03,930 --> 00:18:05,330
all for 80 of 86 installations

421
00:18:05,330 --> 00:18:07,399
and 6 of those installations

422
00:18:07,399 --> 00:18:09,101
were conducted certain

423
00:18:09,101 --> 00:18:11,101
circumstances. And the

424
00:18:12,971 --> 00:18:15,371
majority work, violent crime,

425
00:18:16,141 --> 00:18:17,743
6 of the uses occurred in 2

426
00:18:17,743 --> 00:18:18,410
incidents. One was where a

427
00:18:18,410 --> 00:18:20,646
suspect ambushed inside and

428
00:18:20,646 --> 00:18:21,380
shot at uniform. Officers and

429
00:18:21,380 --> 00:18:25,580
the other one with a threat of

430
00:18:30,589 --> 00:18:32,725
a potential school shooting.

431
00:18:32,725 --> 00:18:34,526
And then lastly is crime.

432
00:18:34,526 --> 00:18:35,994
Tracer formally known as cop

433
00:18:35,994 --> 00:18:38,994
logic, basically just to make

434
00:18:39,164 --> 00:18:40,299
it easier to kind of look at

435
00:18:40,299 --> 00:18:41,533
Google platform that of a

436
00:18:41,533 --> 00:18:42,201
system where it's just us is

437
00:18:42,201 --> 00:18:45,201
somewhat of a one-stop shop

438
00:18:46,338 --> 00:18:47,973
that assist us and being able

439
00:18:47,973 --> 00:18:48,674
to research and look for a

440
00:18:48,674 --> 00:18:50,744
cross law enforcement records

441
00:18:50,744 --> 00:18:53,545
for calls for service field

442
00:18:53,545 --> 00:18:55,614
interviews, arrest and booking

443
00:18:55,614 --> 00:18:56,281
records in citations and

444
00:18:56,281 --> 00:18:56,982
police reports it does not

445
00:18:56,982 --> 00:18:59,382
contain any automated license

446
00:18:59,785 --> 00:19:01,487
plate reader system and has

447
00:19:01,487 --> 00:19:03,489
discussed and was discussed at

448
00:19:03,489 --> 00:19:04,823
the Privacy Privacy Advisory

449
00:19:04,823 --> 00:19:05,491
Commission. And I believe also

450
00:19:05,491 --> 00:19:07,493
passed a public safety and

451
00:19:07,493 --> 00:19:11,930
city council is we are moving

452
00:19:11,296 --> 00:19:11,930
forward towards peregrine a

453
00:19:11,930 --> 00:19:12,598
different database system

454
00:19:12,598 --> 00:19:14,433
which is similar stills,

455
00:19:14,433 --> 00:19:17,433
similar to a Google platform.

456
00:19:18,771 --> 00:19:19,671
But basically it is cities

457
00:19:19,671 --> 00:19:22,775
across the Bay Area have now

458
00:19:22,775 --> 00:19:25,310
moved away from prying tracer

459
00:19:25,310 --> 00:19:26,460
and have gone to peregrine.

460
00:19:26,460 --> 00:19:27,460
Additionally, there's a better

461
00:19:27,460 --> 00:19:29,446
auditing system on peregrine

462
00:19:30,883 --> 00:19:31,617
and we can also limit access

463
00:19:31,617 --> 00:19:33,285
and we can limit who sees this

464
00:19:33,285 --> 00:19:35,587
information in which shared

465
00:19:35,587 --> 00:19:36,221
with whereas cranked racing

466
00:19:36,221 --> 00:19:36,922
was kind of free for all

467
00:19:36,922 --> 00:19:39,922
anybody could have access to

468
00:19:42,629 --> 00:19:45,629
it. Basically, those are are

469
00:19:46,231 --> 00:19:46,865
surveillance annual reports.

470
00:19:46,865 --> 00:19:48,434
Again, whether we should

471
00:19:48,434 --> 00:19:50,569
continue the use of such

472
00:19:50,569 --> 00:19:51,837
technology. Oakland Police

473
00:19:51,837 --> 00:19:53,238
Department strongly urges you

474
00:19:53,238 --> 00:19:55,874
to obviously vote yes in a

475
00:19:55,874 --> 00:19:58,770
great This technology does

476
00:19:58,770 --> 00:19:58,844
assist us and assisting the

477
00:19:58,844 --> 00:20:01,714
victims of violent crimes but

478
00:20:01,714 --> 00:20:02,347
also helping to identify

479
00:20:02,347 --> 00:20:04,347
suspects committed these

480
00:20:07,319 --> 00:20:08,854
crimes. Thank you so much.

481
00:20:08,854 --> 00:20:11,156
Colleagues. And then I do want

482
00:20:11,156 --> 00:20:11,790
to turn it over public comment

483
00:20:11,790 --> 00:20:14,790
since we have folks here,

484
00:20:17,229 --> 00:20:18,397
Councilmember Houston. Chair

485
00:20:18,397 --> 00:20:19,231
you, sir. And it's amazing

486
00:20:19,231 --> 00:20:21,533
when you you spoke on the pen

487
00:20:21,533 --> 00:20:25,133
register, you sit. Help stop a

488
00:20:25,137 --> 00:20:27,537
school shooting. And shooting

489
00:20:31,343 --> 00:20:32,111
an officer. To get back to

490
00:20:32,111 --> 00:20:32,745
that are going to take your

491
00:20:32,745 --> 00:20:33,345
time time because I got a

492
00:20:33,345 --> 00:20:35,745
couple just come That's

493
00:20:46,658 --> 00:20:47,960
amazing. School shooting. Wow.

494
00:20:47,960 --> 00:20:50,960
Yes. Over the school shooting,

495
00:20:51,290 --> 00:20:52,598
we actually have a listed in

496
00:20:52,598 --> 00:20:54,933
sitting where the where we use

497
00:20:54,933 --> 00:20:55,501
that to facilitate identify

498
00:20:55,501 --> 00:20:56,201
the location of the

499
00:20:56,201 --> 00:20:57,603
individual, making the threat

500
00:20:57,603 --> 00:21:00,205
for school shootings. So you

501
00:21:00,205 --> 00:21:02,605
can obviously just considering

502
00:21:04,143 --> 00:21:04,777
the fact of how dangerous and

503
00:21:04,777 --> 00:21:05,845
just nationwide trying to

504
00:21:05,845 --> 00:21:06,678
prevent such incidents from

505
00:21:06,678 --> 00:21:09,214
occurring, how this can assist

506
00:21:09,214 --> 00:21:09,949
Greatly threats become real.

507
00:21:09,949 --> 00:21:13,549
And what about the shooting of

508
00:21:13,685 --> 00:21:15,387
at the officer? This one? We

509
00:21:15,387 --> 00:21:16,388
very we had some limited

510
00:21:16,388 --> 00:21:17,556
information and it's we're not

511
00:21:17,556 --> 00:21:18,190
talking too much about it, we

512
00:21:18,190 --> 00:21:21,427
did apply it. And it did

513
00:21:21,427 --> 00:21:22,594
assistance in the

514
00:21:22,594 --> 00:21:24,396
investigation. Okay, lasting.

515
00:21:24,396 --> 00:21:25,970
But so bright. You had to

516
00:21:25,970 --> 00:21:26,231
vendors. I know you said you

517
00:21:26,231 --> 00:21:27,166
could mention their names was

518
00:21:27,166 --> 00:21:28,670
the percentage, the 2

519
00:21:28,670 --> 00:21:31,667
percentages and it was a cell

520
00:21:32,370 --> 00:21:33,439
by percentage. Absolutely. So

521
00:21:33,439 --> 00:21:35,441
celebrate has shown us to have

522
00:21:35,441 --> 00:21:37,441
95% success rate in

523
00:21:37,643 --> 00:21:39,545
downloading information from

524
00:21:39,545 --> 00:21:41,113
cell phones. Well, the other 2

525
00:21:41,113 --> 00:21:43,549
vendors, one has 3% and one

526
00:21:43,549 --> 00:21:44,416
has had 62% success rate.

527
00:21:44,416 --> 00:21:45,784
We're not stopping. There are

528
00:21:45,784 --> 00:21:46,885
still looking at other

529
00:21:46,885 --> 00:21:48,885
vendors. Understand that

530
00:21:49,555 --> 00:21:53,155
question to the chair. And you

531
00:21:53,926 --> 00:21:56,926
said that the drones should

532
00:22:03,100 --> 00:22:05,104
131 times it was using 2025.

533
00:22:05,104 --> 00:22:06,638
Yes. That's where he said,

534
00:22:06,638 --> 00:22:08,407
yeah, we had 131 times. I had

535
00:22:08,407 --> 00:22:10,420
listed one 30 as my mistake on

536
00:22:10,420 --> 00:22:13,110
there prior to that in 2024.

537
00:22:13,110 --> 00:22:15,881
We had one. 26. And prior to

538
00:22:15,881 --> 00:22:16,715
that, we had 220 and I like to

539
00:22:16,715 --> 00:22:17,349
bring that to attention

540
00:22:17,349 --> 00:22:20,349
because when it things we

541
00:22:20,719 --> 00:22:21,887
discovered, obviously was 2023

542
00:22:21,887 --> 00:22:22,654
with our first full usage of

543
00:22:22,654 --> 00:22:25,654
utilizing drones. But you can

544
00:22:26,725 --> 00:22:28,660
see that it's gone down. So it

545
00:22:28,660 --> 00:22:29,795
has to be approved by a

546
00:22:29,795 --> 00:22:32,464
commander on scene. So just

547
00:22:32,464 --> 00:22:33,832
because incident MAY warrant a

548
00:22:33,832 --> 00:22:34,701
drone, each commander will

549
00:22:34,701 --> 00:22:36,690
identify the incident and

550
00:22:36,690 --> 00:22:36,769
determine whether or not a

551
00:22:36,769 --> 00:22:39,238
drone is still needed to just

552
00:22:39,238 --> 00:22:40,339
because we have this

553
00:22:40,339 --> 00:22:41,730
technology doesn't mean that

554
00:22:41,730 --> 00:22:44,730
we deployed every single time.

555
00:22:44,209 --> 00:22:45,210
We look at a case by case

556
00:22:45,210 --> 00:22:46,111
thank you because I talked to

557
00:22:46,111 --> 00:22:46,812
the county need to is working

558
00:22:46,812 --> 00:22:48,480
perfectly, but the sheriff's

559
00:22:48,480 --> 00:22:50,880
department, thank you. Council

560
00:22:54,153 --> 00:22:56,550
member Brown. Excellent. Thank

561
00:22:56,550 --> 00:22:57,956
you so much for the report and

562
00:22:57,956 --> 00:23:01,556
the I had a couple questions

563
00:23:02,694 --> 00:23:03,295
about the drone usage this

564
00:23:03,295 --> 00:23:05,695
year. What progress the

565
00:23:07,633 --> 00:23:10,350
department is making on like

566
00:23:10,350 --> 00:23:10,669
the training like the drone

567
00:23:10,669 --> 00:23:12,710
teams because I guess I'm

568
00:23:12,710 --> 00:23:14,600
curious if that actually is

569
00:23:14,600 --> 00:23:17,600
contributing to like the the

570
00:23:17,910 --> 00:23:18,610
lack of usage. So currently

571
00:23:18,610 --> 00:23:22,210
right now, I believe the top

572
00:23:22,648 --> 00:23:26,248
of my head, we have 20 faa

573
00:23:26,285 --> 00:23:27,190
107, certified pilots a We

574
00:23:27,190 --> 00:23:28,821
also have them. So every these

575
00:23:28,821 --> 00:23:31,221
are ancillary positions. So

576
00:23:31,623 --> 00:23:33,592
it's not full time positions.

577
00:23:33,592 --> 00:23:34,326
So a lot of these officers are

578
00:23:34,326 --> 00:23:36,326
working different assignments.

579
00:23:38,464 --> 00:23:40,464
Whether you're patrol

580
00:23:40,733 --> 00:23:42,733
investigations working in

581
00:23:43,469 --> 00:23:45,537
cease-fire, working in special

582
00:23:45,537 --> 00:23:46,271
resources section for

583
00:23:46,271 --> 00:23:47,272
obviously assignments. So

584
00:23:47,272 --> 00:23:47,973
whenever they're very for a

585
00:23:47,973 --> 00:23:49,641
call for service, if someone

586
00:23:49,641 --> 00:23:52,378
is not there, they're trying

587
00:23:52,378 --> 00:23:53,546
to respond to that location.

588
00:23:53,546 --> 00:23:56,115
The other thing we have is

589
00:23:56,115 --> 00:23:56,815
that our drones are depleting

590
00:23:56,815 --> 00:23:58,951
in a sense is the same drones

591
00:23:58,951 --> 00:24:01,351
that we've had since 2022,

592
00:24:03,210 --> 00:24:04,456
these drones were donated to

593
00:24:04,456 --> 00:24:05,223
us, but love the community So

594
00:24:05,223 --> 00:24:08,930
we had to separate donations

595
00:24:08,930 --> 00:24:08,827
totaling $100,000. And these

596
00:24:08,827 --> 00:24:11,280
are the Saint John's we've had

597
00:24:11,280 --> 00:24:13,650
since 2022. So are also being

598
00:24:13,650 --> 00:24:14,466
cautious, too. And when we and

599
00:24:14,466 --> 00:24:18,666
how many times we use it, just

600
00:24:19,171 --> 00:24:21,439
like anything else. It is a

601
00:24:21,439 --> 00:24:25,390
car in a break. So fortunately

602
00:24:25,443 --> 00:24:26,546
for my for for me, I have some

603
00:24:26,546 --> 00:24:27,745
intelligent people our teams

604
00:24:27,745 --> 00:24:28,447
are able to also become

605
00:24:28,447 --> 00:24:30,182
mechanics and try to fix the

606
00:24:30,182 --> 00:24:31,750
drones themselves as little

607
00:24:31,750 --> 00:24:35,350
parts break. So it is a

608
00:24:35,621 --> 00:24:37,689
depleting resources far as

609
00:24:37,689 --> 00:24:39,626
mechanical and also

610
00:24:39,626 --> 00:24:40,325
financially. So we are looking

611
00:24:40,325 --> 00:24:41,293
at other ways to purchase new

612
00:24:41,293 --> 00:24:43,862
drones which are working on

613
00:24:43,862 --> 00:24:46,862
right now. But that's mainly

614
00:24:47,566 --> 00:24:48,535
the biggest issue right now.

615
00:24:48,535 --> 00:24:49,801
Punches. Thank you so much for

616
00:24:49,801 --> 00:24:52,838
that and what is the current

617
00:24:52,838 --> 00:24:53,472
life of You know, it depends

618
00:24:53,472 --> 00:24:56,275
on the battery lights and

619
00:24:56,275 --> 00:24:56,974
we've had to purchase

620
00:24:56,974 --> 00:24:58,977
additional batteries and the

621
00:24:58,977 --> 00:25:01,947
drones we have are from 2022.

622
00:25:01,947 --> 00:25:03,715
So that but the the problem

623
00:25:03,715 --> 00:25:05,918
we're seeing right now is

624
00:25:05,918 --> 00:25:06,519
those purchasing. Those

625
00:25:06,519 --> 00:25:07,186
batteries are extremely

626
00:25:07,186 --> 00:25:08,854
outdated and they're not

627
00:25:08,854 --> 00:25:11,560
lasting as long as they

628
00:25:11,560 --> 00:25:12,958
normally do. So the charges

629
00:25:12,958 --> 00:25:14,260
are holding as long as they

630
00:25:14,260 --> 00:25:14,727
are. So they're constantly

631
00:25:14,727 --> 00:25:16,828
having to purchase new new a

632
00:25:16,828 --> 00:25:19,231
new batteries if that makes

633
00:25:19,231 --> 00:25:21,631
sense. Yeah, absolutely. And

634
00:25:21,900 --> 00:25:23,268
then my next question had a

635
00:25:23,268 --> 00:25:25,604
little bit you with the data

636
00:25:25,604 --> 00:25:27,639
around like the celebrate

637
00:25:27,639 --> 00:25:28,841
usage. And I just wanted to

638
00:25:28,841 --> 00:25:32,441
confirm that in order to use

639
00:25:32,543 --> 00:25:33,278
the celebrate technology, it

640
00:25:33,278 --> 00:25:35,381
actually requires a a warrant.

641
00:25:35,381 --> 00:25:36,490
Is that correct? That's

642
00:25:36,490 --> 00:25:36,749
correct. It does require a

643
00:25:36,749 --> 00:25:39,149
search warrant yet. Okay.

644
00:25:41,553 --> 00:25:42,654
Thank you. Thank you.

645
00:25:42,654 --> 00:25:44,590
Councilmember Before we turn

646
00:25:44,590 --> 00:25:45,556
it over to public comment,

647
00:25:45,556 --> 00:25:46,192
just to confirm is this a

648
00:25:46,192 --> 00:25:48,260
comprehensive list of all

649
00:25:48,260 --> 00:25:50,260
those surveillance technology

650
00:25:50,396 --> 00:25:51,130
like ai notice that shot

651
00:25:51,130 --> 00:25:51,830
spotter is not included in

652
00:25:51,830 --> 00:25:55,430
this set of reports. Why? Why

653
00:25:55,602 --> 00:25:56,535
is that? I believe that those

654
00:25:56,535 --> 00:26:00,380
at different time we did. We

655
00:26:00,380 --> 00:26:00,739
haven't presented Shotspotter.

656
00:26:00,739 --> 00:26:01,407
Okay. So we'll get it to the

657
00:26:01,407 --> 00:26:03,108
next set of reports. Okay.

658
00:26:03,108 --> 00:26:06,708
Great. Okay. Turn it over to

659
00:26:07,460 --> 00:26:07,746
public comment. Calling in the

660
00:26:07,746 --> 00:26:08,714
names that signed up to speak

661
00:26:08,714 --> 00:26:09,449
on item number 8 in no

662
00:26:09,449 --> 00:26:12,449
particular order. You can come

663
00:26:12,484 --> 00:26:13,850
up to the podium state. Your

664
00:26:13,850 --> 00:26:14,118
name before making your

665
00:26:14,118 --> 00:26:15,988
comment or if you're on zoom,

666
00:26:15,988 --> 00:26:19,588
please raise your hands to be

667
00:26:20,910 --> 00:26:22,491
easily identified. Deed on.

668
00:26:23,628 --> 00:26:26,280
Jesse Rose more. Daniel

669
00:26:26,965 --> 00:26:28,965
Hochman, Kendra Ferguson.

670
00:26:29,902 --> 00:26:33,502
Kerry, both a subtle of Allah.

671
00:26:35,374 --> 00:26:37,643
Pena is Adam will. Zarina Diaz

672
00:26:37,643 --> 00:26:39,643
Matalin. Stacey Elizabeth.

673
00:26:41,480 --> 00:26:43,880
Cochran. Noelle Flores, Blair

674
00:26:47,520 --> 00:26:48,821
Beekman Owen. Angela Maddox

675
00:26:48,821 --> 00:26:51,757
and I have one filled out

676
00:26:51,757 --> 00:26:54,157
under tech workers. Coalition.

677
00:26:54,560 --> 00:26:55,260
And if you if you are sitting

678
00:26:55,260 --> 00:26:57,429
time or have someone seating

679
00:26:57,429 --> 00:26:58,630
time tu, they must be present

680
00:26:58,630 --> 00:27:02,230
or on zoom to acknowledge that

681
00:27:03,100 --> 00:27:03,736
they are ceding their to you.

682
00:27:03,736 --> 00:27:07,336
Here's the Don. Thank you very

683
00:27:07,706 --> 00:27:09,641
much. All of these proposals

684
00:27:09,641 --> 00:27:11,310
and all of the research done

685
00:27:11,310 --> 00:27:13,710
on these surveillance systems

686
00:27:14,646 --> 00:27:18,246
is 8 gross misuse of funds for

687
00:27:18,317 --> 00:27:19,218
the people of Oakland. It's a

688
00:27:19,218 --> 00:27:20,486
dangerous actually escalation

689
00:27:20,486 --> 00:27:21,187
of surveillance on the people

690
00:27:21,187 --> 00:27:22,621
of Oakland. We do not need to

691
00:27:22,621 --> 00:27:23,654
encourage a surveillance

692
00:27:23,654 --> 00:27:24,791
state. These drones and

693
00:27:24,791 --> 00:27:27,258
cameras only act as a Band-Aid

694
00:27:27,258 --> 00:27:29,260
solution to sources of crime.

695
00:27:29,260 --> 00:27:31,950
My thoughts research and by

696
00:27:31,950 --> 00:27:31,930
your admission, the so-called

697
00:27:31,930 --> 00:27:33,930
benefited between 10 and 20%

698
00:27:35,234 --> 00:27:35,833
for usage in completed cases.

699
00:27:35,833 --> 00:27:36,467
This statistic does not

700
00:27:36,467 --> 00:27:37,102
indicate that these cases

701
00:27:37,102 --> 00:27:38,970
would have gone unsolved

702
00:27:38,970 --> 00:27:40,372
without flock intervention for

703
00:27:40,372 --> 00:27:41,174
such a widespread

704
00:27:41,174 --> 00:27:43,750
implementation. The residents

705
00:27:43,750 --> 00:27:45,440
deserve more than one in

706
00:27:45,440 --> 00:27:47,790
moment of these devices and

707
00:27:47,790 --> 00:27:47,780
result crime cases mind you.

708
00:27:47,780 --> 00:27:48,414
That's not crime prevention.

709
00:27:48,414 --> 00:27:50,814
You did mention crime

710
00:27:50,917 --> 00:27:51,984
prevention, but only for

711
00:27:51,984 --> 00:27:53,984
specific instances merely

712
00:27:54,920 --> 00:27:55,721
crime resolution for most

713
00:27:55,721 --> 00:27:56,355
cases, thoughtful, short at

714
00:27:56,355 --> 00:27:58,257
every metric by their own

715
00:27:58,257 --> 00:28:00,260
numbers for comparison amount

716
00:28:00,260 --> 00:28:02,327
of time. The we know what

717
00:28:02,327 --> 00:28:02,996
works. It is giving money to

718
00:28:02,996 --> 00:28:05,996
health care and housing for

719
00:28:09,701 --> 00:28:10,402
the citizens vote. Next

720
00:28:10,402 --> 00:28:12,471
speakers you guys can come up

721
00:28:12,471 --> 00:28:14,907
to the podium. It's on Senate

722
00:28:14,907 --> 00:28:16,675
for number 3. Number 8,

723
00:28:16,675 --> 00:28:19,675
because it coming up around

724
00:28:20,779 --> 00:28:24,379
what's Riley. Going to see To

725
00:28:24,550 --> 00:28:25,250
Daniel. Okay. Just noting that

726
00:28:25,250 --> 00:28:29,450
you will no longer be able to

727
00:28:29,855 --> 00:28:30,522
speak on item 3. And Daniel,

728
00:28:30,522 --> 00:28:34,122
give me one moment to just

729
00:28:35,861 --> 00:28:39,310
your time. Yeah. Go for. You

730
00:28:39,310 --> 00:28:39,698
can begin. All My name is

731
00:28:39,698 --> 00:28:41,200
Daniel Hoffman, a minister

732
00:28:41,200 --> 00:28:42,101
resident and I work over at

733
00:28:42,101 --> 00:28:45,101
Livermore, but the key plants

734
00:28:45,671 --> 00:28:48,640
for working their weapons so I

735
00:28:48,640 --> 00:28:50,776
first and foremost think that

736
00:28:50,776 --> 00:28:51,477
this item should on a ballot.

737
00:28:51,477 --> 00:28:55,770
If you look at police about

738
00:28:56,515 --> 00:28:57,549
was measured measure Both of

739
00:28:57,549 --> 00:28:59,718
those combined are not heavily

740
00:28:59,718 --> 00:29:02,718
weighted as what we're talking

741
00:29:03,889 --> 00:29:05,924
about. Now. But to talk about

742
00:29:05,924 --> 00:29:06,725
starting officer owns the U.S.

743
00:29:06,725 --> 00:29:07,826
Is to my knowledge that has

744
00:29:07,826 --> 00:29:10,826
its indoor use for hostile

745
00:29:16,301 --> 00:29:17,200
situations. Mississauga. I

746
00:29:17,200 --> 00:29:20,773
need to see we plot pause the

747
00:29:20,773 --> 00:29:23,173
clock. Mississauga. This is

748
00:29:23,942 --> 00:29:26,912
your first warning you will be

749
00:29:26,912 --> 00:29:27,579
3 warnings or you will be

750
00:29:27,579 --> 00:29:30,579
removed. We need to respect

751
00:29:32,351 --> 00:29:34,751
the first warning went

752
00:29:35,354 --> 00:29:35,954
Councilmember you know, that

753
00:29:35,954 --> 00:29:38,354
is your second morning

754
00:29:39,858 --> 00:29:40,526
Mississauga. I think it's

755
00:29:40,526 --> 00:29:41,193
important to note that, you

756
00:29:41,193 --> 00:29:44,793
know, we want to make sure

757
00:29:45,164 --> 00:29:45,931
that we give everyone's voice

758
00:29:45,931 --> 00:29:46,633
is heard. And so everyone will

759
00:29:46,633 --> 00:29:49,633
get the opportunity to speak

760
00:29:55,507 --> 00:29:58,377
at the mic. And so, It wasn't

761
00:29:58,377 --> 00:30:00,377
easy. 24 7, thank you.

762
00:30:08,887 --> 00:30:11,887
Okay. Security. Can you please

763
00:30:12,591 --> 00:30:15,591
speak with to thank you.

764
00:30:19,965 --> 00:30:23,565
Should done about it. What do

765
00:30:24,970 --> 00:30:25,671
she should An Can you can

766
00:30:25,671 --> 00:30:28,710
continue with your comments.

767
00:30:28,307 --> 00:30:30,442
Your time will continue. All

768
00:30:30,442 --> 00:30:31,900
right. So knowledge the

769
00:30:31,900 --> 00:30:32,678
barricade in hostage

770
00:30:32,678 --> 00:30:33,746
situations. The overwatch for

771
00:30:33,746 --> 00:30:34,713
active scenes and fires. That

772
00:30:34,713 --> 00:30:36,281
makes sense. That is a

773
00:30:36,281 --> 00:30:37,516
tactical advantage. But I

774
00:30:37,516 --> 00:30:38,817
believe that we should

775
00:30:38,817 --> 00:30:39,518
establish some kind of

776
00:30:39,518 --> 00:30:40,219
limiting operating radius of

777
00:30:40,219 --> 00:30:42,855
maybe like a quarter mile of

778
00:30:42,855 --> 00:30:46,125
gives you enough go around the

779
00:30:46,125 --> 00:30:46,658
block without it being this

780
00:30:46,658 --> 00:30:48,360
scary step towards

781
00:30:48,360 --> 00:30:49,962
surveillance state

782
00:30:49,962 --> 00:30:50,662
infrastructure. One thing I do

783
00:30:50,662 --> 00:30:52,664
want to applaud is the crime

784
00:30:52,664 --> 00:30:54,900
of biometric security storing

785
00:30:54,900 --> 00:30:58,500
all the data on the Internet

786
00:30:58,838 --> 00:30:59,705
encrypting information and and

787
00:30:59,705 --> 00:31:01,507
should be the standard for all

788
00:31:01,507 --> 00:31:02,941
of this information, storage

789
00:31:02,941 --> 00:31:06,541
and transfer. Not so much an

790
00:31:06,779 --> 00:31:09,915
sd card on a drone or say

791
00:31:09,915 --> 00:31:11,650
manually inputting the drone.

792
00:31:11,650 --> 00:31:14,650
Log at the Microsoft teams

793
00:31:14,820 --> 00:31:18,420
Excel sheet. I believe can we

794
00:31:19,792 --> 00:31:20,459
pause again? Security? Can you

795
00:31:20,459 --> 00:31:22,859
escort misses, sought out.

796
00:31:28,200 --> 00:31:30,200
Please.

797
00:32:29,995 --> 00:32:31,995
Susan.

798
00:33:04,863 --> 00:33:07,263
You feel ready? Let's

799
00:33:08,680 --> 00:33:08,734
do All right. So lastly, as

800
00:33:08,734 --> 00:33:09,401
complementing the biometric

801
00:33:09,401 --> 00:33:11,270
security and health care as

802
00:33:11,270 --> 00:33:12,938
got moved, let's talk about

803
00:33:12,938 --> 00:33:13,639
some statistics in their

804
00:33:13,639 --> 00:33:15,808
report. It had 638 million

805
00:33:15,808 --> 00:33:18,208
scanned, but only 1.1 million

806
00:33:20,946 --> 00:33:22,810
hot list alerts which is you

807
00:33:22,810 --> 00:33:22,781
divide the 1.1 bytes is

808
00:33:22,781 --> 00:33:25,181
138 Million. That is a 0, 1,

809
00:33:26,318 --> 00:33:27,653
7%, utilization rate. So let's

810
00:33:27,653 --> 00:33:28,487
one scam per hot list alert.

811
00:33:28,487 --> 00:33:30,222
If we multiply that by 20,

812
00:33:30,222 --> 00:33:32,222
that's still only 30%

813
00:33:33,292 --> 00:33:33,959
utilization, right? 97% waste.

814
00:33:33,959 --> 00:33:36,359
1.2 million dollars for not

815
00:33:38,970 --> 00:33:38,964
going 97% refund on and we're

816
00:33:38,964 --> 00:33:39,665
building essentially pan off.

817
00:33:39,665 --> 00:33:41,967
The comet only works 0.1% of

818
00:33:41,967 --> 00:33:44,967
the time. This is a

819
00:33:45,771 --> 00:33:46,472
unfortunately not even if it.

820
00:33:46,472 --> 00:33:49,472
Thank you for comments. Your

821
00:33:56,515 --> 00:33:58,550
time is up. Next that sun come

822
00:33:58,550 --> 00:34:02,150
up to the podium. Police say

823
00:34:03,956 --> 00:34:06,956
your name before beginning. I

824
00:34:08,260 --> 00:34:10,195
think the fact that you chose

825
00:34:10,195 --> 00:34:12,300
to rip move pr is at the last

826
00:34:12,300 --> 00:34:14,933
minute from this agenda shows

827
00:34:14,933 --> 00:34:15,834
exactly why we cannot trust

828
00:34:15,834 --> 00:34:16,902
these kinds of technologies

829
00:34:16,902 --> 00:34:18,170
and why there's a lack of

830
00:34:18,170 --> 00:34:18,904
transparency when you brought

831
00:34:18,904 --> 00:34:19,571
all these people here. Most of

832
00:34:19,571 --> 00:34:22,174
them are there are here to

833
00:34:22,174 --> 00:34:23,809
talk about the surveillance

834
00:34:23,809 --> 00:34:26,809
state and flock cameras on

835
00:34:27,946 --> 00:34:29,480
their corners. Let's see

836
00:34:29,480 --> 00:34:30,883
Clinton already budgeted 2.2,

837
00:34:30,883 --> 00:34:32,551
5 million to flock back in

838
00:34:32,551 --> 00:34:33,219
DECEMBER. Imagine all the

839
00:34:33,219 --> 00:34:35,619
social services that could

840
00:34:36,121 --> 00:34:36,822
have been funded if those

841
00:34:36,822 --> 00:34:38,157
funds went to somewhere else

842
00:34:38,157 --> 00:34:40,192
rather than the surveillance

843
00:34:40,192 --> 00:34:40,959
state policing at this level

844
00:34:40,959 --> 00:34:41,927
of everyday life goes beyond

845
00:34:41,927 --> 00:34:44,327
the Panopticon and transforms

846
00:34:44,563 --> 00:34:46,565
lived actions into data by

847
00:34:46,565 --> 00:34:47,633
which people are watched.

848
00:34:47,633 --> 00:34:48,901
Their behaviors are predicted

849
00:34:48,901 --> 00:34:50,469
and then demonized based on

850
00:34:50,469 --> 00:34:52,571
their skin location and

851
00:34:52,571 --> 00:34:53,272
socioeconomic status, making

852
00:34:53,272 --> 00:34:55,340
every corner the wrong place

853
00:34:55,340 --> 00:34:56,800
to be at the petrol. 24 7,

854
00:34:56,800 --> 00:34:58,408
wrong time. Oakland already

855
00:34:59,745 --> 00:35:01,380
has a habit of violating sb

856
00:35:01,380 --> 00:35:02,810
34, and unlawfully sharing

857
00:35:02,810 --> 00:35:04,481
surveillance data make every

858
00:35:15,160 --> 00:35:18,160
flock camp. Good evening, Wolf

859
00:35:19,131 --> 00:35:21,531
Oakland resident. Your duty

860
00:35:22,267 --> 00:35:23,235
under Omc 9, 6, 4 is not just

861
00:35:23,235 --> 00:35:25,304
accept paperwork is to approve

862
00:35:25,304 --> 00:35:28,904
the usage against us. The cost

863
00:35:29,842 --> 00:35:30,442
to civil liberties. The scale

864
00:35:30,442 --> 00:35:32,277
of the scanning that's

865
00:35:32,277 --> 00:35:34,277
happening 638 million license

866
00:35:39,510 --> 00:35:41,451
plate scanned. A 15062 success

867
00:35:42,254 --> 00:35:44,254
stories. That's 0, 0, 1%. The

868
00:35:47,926 --> 00:35:48,894
99.9, 7, 7%, is all just non

869
00:35:48,894 --> 00:35:50,894
constitutional obstruction

870
00:35:52,798 --> 00:35:55,198
civil liberties in Oakland.

871
00:35:55,401 --> 00:35:56,340
And also approving this

872
00:35:56,340 --> 00:35:59,340
report. Oakland pd is not

873
00:35:59,538 --> 00:36:01,407
following the rules. There are

874
00:36:01,407 --> 00:36:02,441
6 currently approved usages

875
00:36:02,441 --> 00:36:04,610
for flock. But apparently the

876
00:36:04,610 --> 00:36:07,610
33 usages have been in their

877
00:36:08,547 --> 00:36:09,581
system able to be selected for

878
00:36:09,581 --> 00:36:11,650
the last year. I would really

879
00:36:11,650 --> 00:36:13,352
love to have you ask about

880
00:36:13,352 --> 00:36:14,530
that and are they using these

881
00:36:14,530 --> 00:36:17,530
usage is already because you

882
00:36:23,929 --> 00:36:25,197
have not voted on this year.

883
00:36:25,197 --> 00:36:25,931
I'm Kendra Ferguson live in

884
00:36:25,931 --> 00:36:26,565
Oakland and I'm opposed to the

885
00:36:26,565 --> 00:36:29,565
opd expanding the use of

886
00:36:31,236 --> 00:36:31,904
flock. I think that mass

887
00:36:31,904 --> 00:36:33,172
surveillance in the country

888
00:36:33,172 --> 00:36:35,307
that lawfully strips rights,

889
00:36:35,307 --> 00:36:36,208
repressed people that lawfully

890
00:36:36,208 --> 00:36:36,875
in concert incarcerate

891
00:36:36,875 --> 00:36:39,712
families based off of their

892
00:36:39,712 --> 00:36:40,345
deaths at the city and that

893
00:36:40,345 --> 00:36:41,480
law femurs people in the

894
00:36:41,480 --> 00:36:43,148
street will only bring harm to

895
00:36:43,148 --> 00:36:43,749
the people. I think that fun

896
00:36:43,749 --> 00:36:46,149
should be going toward

897
00:36:46,185 --> 00:36:48,585
programs that uplift humanity,

898
00:36:49,922 --> 00:36:51,900
not those that criminalize

899
00:36:51,900 --> 00:36:51,890
manatee. I'm descendant of a

900
00:36:51,890 --> 00:36:52,624
survivor of the Japanese

901
00:36:52,624 --> 00:36:55,240
concentration camps from World

902
00:36:55,594 --> 00:36:58,594
War. 2 and that measure was

903
00:36:58,731 --> 00:36:59,364
taken. Then for safety and was

904
00:36:59,364 --> 00:37:01,633
a safety measure and they

905
00:37:01,633 --> 00:37:02,334
question 820,000 people for

906
00:37:02,334 --> 00:37:05,334
the basis that thing Japanese

907
00:37:07,390 --> 00:37:09,141
Americans yeah, the reality

908
00:37:09,141 --> 00:37:10,242
all safety measures sometimes

909
00:37:10,242 --> 00:37:12,770
do not do what they're meant

910
00:37:12,770 --> 00:37:12,812
to do, right, actually meant

911
00:37:12,812 --> 00:37:13,445
to just harm community. And so

912
00:37:13,445 --> 00:37:14,346
I would hope that we are

913
00:37:14,346 --> 00:37:17,346
choosing not harm, but using

914
00:37:24,123 --> 00:37:26,925
humanity. I'm Zarina. I oppose

915
00:37:26,925 --> 00:37:27,559
flocked to the council members

916
00:37:27,559 --> 00:37:28,228
here. Do you believe the

917
00:37:28,228 --> 00:37:31,228
citizens of Oakland have a

918
00:37:32,698 --> 00:37:33,699
right to privacy from 24 7

919
00:37:33,699 --> 00:37:34,767
warrantless surveillance? Why

920
00:37:34,767 --> 00:37:35,567
is it that you continue to

921
00:37:35,567 --> 00:37:37,503
support the vendor flock when

922
00:37:37,503 --> 00:37:38,470
the public you serve? Opposes

923
00:37:38,470 --> 00:37:41,730
this the way that you and opd

924
00:37:41,730 --> 00:37:42,742
continued to sneak flock,

925
00:37:42,742 --> 00:37:45,770
funding into agendas every

926
00:37:45,770 --> 00:37:46,712
month reflects an allegiance

927
00:37:46,712 --> 00:37:48,213
to the police above your

928
00:37:48,213 --> 00:37:50,182
constituents. I've seen high

929
00:37:50,182 --> 00:37:51,950
schoolers unions, immigration

930
00:37:51,950 --> 00:37:52,684
advocacy groups, church groups

931
00:37:52,684 --> 00:37:55,840
and Constance it. Constituents

932
00:37:55,320 --> 00:37:57,720
all come here practically

933
00:37:58,580 --> 00:38:01,580
every month to oppose flop.

934
00:38:01,193 --> 00:38:04,193
The optics of you continuing

935
00:38:05,697 --> 00:38:06,331
consider funding flop. The

936
00:38:06,331 --> 00:38:08,731
optics is corruption and

937
00:38:14,239 --> 00:38:17,239
collusion with opd. I Anthony

938
00:38:17,810 --> 00:38:18,510
s district 5 residents. I

939
00:38:18,510 --> 00:38:20,910
strongly oppose any contract

940
00:38:21,480 --> 00:38:22,114
with flock safety flock

941
00:38:22,114 --> 00:38:23,749
indiscriminately, collect

942
00:38:23,749 --> 00:38:25,818
enormous volumes of video

943
00:38:25,818 --> 00:38:28,520
footage in Illinois flock has

944
00:38:28,520 --> 00:38:29,588
been caught breaking state

945
00:38:29,588 --> 00:38:31,190
privacy law by sharing that

946
00:38:31,190 --> 00:38:31,757
footage without a state law

947
00:38:31,757 --> 00:38:33,225
enforcement officers,

948
00:38:33,225 --> 00:38:35,600
including Customs and Border

949
00:38:35,600 --> 00:38:35,761
Protection agents and a Texas

950
00:38:35,761 --> 00:38:38,761
sheriff tracking a woman who

951
00:38:39,565 --> 00:38:40,232
had an abortion. Fox Floppy

952
00:38:40,232 --> 00:38:42,632
license plate readings have

953
00:38:43,469 --> 00:38:44,360
led to false accusations and

954
00:38:44,360 --> 00:38:44,770
fox careless security

955
00:38:44,770 --> 00:38:47,639
practices increase the risk of

956
00:38:47,639 --> 00:38:48,674
hackers stealing footage. When

957
00:38:48,674 --> 00:38:49,341
it comes to public safety. In

958
00:38:49,341 --> 00:38:51,944
Oakland, I trust the local

959
00:38:51,944 --> 00:38:53,212
violence prevention programs,

960
00:38:53,212 --> 00:38:54,120
not unaccountable. Tech

961
00:38:54,120 --> 00:38:55,949
companies were increasingly

962
00:38:55,949 --> 00:38:58,349
brutal and lawless federal

963
00:38:58,717 --> 00:39:00,860
agencies. I urge you all not

964
00:39:00,860 --> 00:39:02,121
to accept any expansion or

965
00:39:02,121 --> 00:39:02,821
extension Oakland City

966
00:39:02,821 --> 00:39:05,221
contracts with flock safety.

967
00:39:11,497 --> 00:39:12,431
Not now. We're not ever.

968
00:39:12,431 --> 00:39:14,600
Everyone, mark, I think I'm

969
00:39:14,600 --> 00:39:15,167
the person who put down tech

970
00:39:15,167 --> 00:39:15,901
workers coalition. So

971
00:39:15,901 --> 00:39:18,670
apologies for for that to feel

972
00:39:18,670 --> 00:39:19,338
that my name district, 3

973
00:39:19,338 --> 00:39:22,938
resident and I just want to

974
00:39:23,943 --> 00:39:25,844
say that. I guess I am a

975
00:39:25,844 --> 00:39:26,545
little happy the flock thing

976
00:39:26,545 --> 00:39:27,279
end up getting moved to last

977
00:39:27,279 --> 00:39:28,213
month because I definitely did

978
00:39:28,213 --> 00:39:30,613
look through those documents

979
00:39:31,160 --> 00:39:33,850
and was kind of surprised by

980
00:39:33,850 --> 00:39:34,987
how messy and how many data

981
00:39:34,987 --> 00:39:36,221
and things were missing from

982
00:39:36,221 --> 00:39:39,221
it. And I appreciate, you

983
00:39:40,359 --> 00:39:41,460
know, I pd for pulling that

984
00:39:41,460 --> 00:39:42,127
stuff off, but I can't give

985
00:39:42,127 --> 00:39:42,695
them 24 hours for being the

986
00:39:42,695 --> 00:39:43,896
people who presumably

987
00:39:43,896 --> 00:39:45,330
submitted that stuff in the

988
00:39:45,330 --> 00:39:46,650
first place. And so I would

989
00:39:46,650 --> 00:39:46,766
really urge that especially if

990
00:39:46,766 --> 00:39:49,969
this is the way that they're

991
00:39:49,969 --> 00:39:52,271
going to like handle their own

992
00:39:52,271 --> 00:39:54,239
data you know, we really

993
00:39:54,239 --> 00:39:54,940
treat. We treat them with a

994
00:39:54,940 --> 00:39:55,674
little bit of skepticism when

995
00:39:55,674 --> 00:39:56,542
they say that they're going to

996
00:39:56,542 --> 00:39:59,542
be good stewards for hours.

997
00:40:00,145 --> 00:40:00,879
And I also think that.

998
00:40:00,879 --> 00:40:03,879
Fundamentally, you know, it is

999
00:40:04,249 --> 00:40:05,417
not surveillance or nothing.

1000
00:40:05,417 --> 00:40:06,985
You know, obviously, when you

1001
00:40:06,985 --> 00:40:07,686
you know, when you compare

1002
00:40:07,686 --> 00:40:08,420
lawlessness to surveillance,

1003
00:40:08,420 --> 00:40:09,210
surveillance wins. But I think

1004
00:40:09,210 --> 00:40:09,788
the ultimately there is

1005
00:40:09,788 --> 00:40:12,188
another option, which is

1006
00:40:21,500 --> 00:40:22,167
actually taking them. Hi, Jess

1007
00:40:22,167 --> 00:40:22,835
Heroes. More of the absurd

1008
00:40:22,835 --> 00:40:25,571
things that I've heard. Pro

1009
00:40:25,571 --> 00:40:26,805
flock hawks on the city

1010
00:40:26,805 --> 00:40:28,707
council saying from my

1011
00:40:28,707 --> 00:40:29,641
councilmember Wang, I've heard

1012
00:40:29,641 --> 00:40:30,309
you say that if ice deploys

1013
00:40:30,309 --> 00:40:33,909
here, we will just turn the

1014
00:40:34,546 --> 00:40:36,281
cameras off for So, you know,

1015
00:40:36,281 --> 00:40:37,583
these cameras collect commute

1016
00:40:37,583 --> 00:40:38,851
pattern data. So if you just

1017
00:40:38,851 --> 00:40:41,120
turn them off, it will be too

1018
00:40:41,120 --> 00:40:42,454
late. Ice will have that data.

1019
00:40:42,454 --> 00:40:43,889
They will use it to do

1020
00:40:43,889 --> 00:40:44,523
targeted abductions up our

1021
00:40:44,523 --> 00:40:46,592
neighbors when they go to

1022
00:40:46,592 --> 00:40:47,626
Dublin when they open Dublin

1023
00:40:47,626 --> 00:40:51,630
and when when they pursue that

1024
00:40:51,630 --> 00:40:52,931
to fill up that. That

1025
00:40:52,931 --> 00:40:54,233
facility. So what I would like

1026
00:40:54,233 --> 00:40:55,734
to know from you is what is

1027
00:40:55,734 --> 00:40:59,334
the plan when ice does hear

1028
00:40:59,505 --> 00:41:00,506
what they did in Minneapolis

1029
00:41:00,506 --> 00:41:02,641
to warn every person that

1030
00:41:02,641 --> 00:41:03,342
could be targeted by ice in

1031
00:41:03,342 --> 00:41:04,420
the Trump administration that

1032
00:41:04,420 --> 00:41:06,790
they need to immediately

1033
00:41:06,790 --> 00:41:08,180
change their commute pattern

1034
00:41:08,180 --> 00:41:09,882
data or have targeted

1035
00:41:09,882 --> 00:41:11,250
abductions at them. That is a

1036
00:41:11,250 --> 00:41:12,284
big task. He was going to do

1037
00:41:12,284 --> 00:41:14,953
Are you gonna do it? Which

1038
00:41:14,953 --> 00:41:16,955
department is going to it?

1039
00:41:16,955 --> 00:41:17,624
What is the plan? When are you

1040
00:41:17,624 --> 00:41:20,240
releasing the plan? Because

1041
00:41:25,564 --> 00:41:26,199
this leaves us in danger. My

1042
00:41:26,199 --> 00:41:29,199
name is an ion accidently

1043
00:41:34,306 --> 00:41:35,874
sound up for 3 instead of 8.

1044
00:41:35,874 --> 00:41:36,842
I'm not going to repeat the

1045
00:41:36,842 --> 00:41:39,242
statistics or the information

1046
00:41:41,447 --> 00:41:42,648
that is all really good. That

1047
00:41:42,648 --> 00:41:43,549
my companions are. They're not

1048
00:41:43,549 --> 00:41:44,249
my companions. But the people

1049
00:41:44,249 --> 00:41:47,653
who feel the same way as me,

1050
00:41:47,653 --> 00:41:50,322
which is that I strongly.

1051
00:41:50,322 --> 00:41:50,956
Oppose flock pose celebrate. I

1052
00:41:50,956 --> 00:41:53,356
oppose surveillance. I am

1053
00:41:54,593 --> 00:41:56,428
shocked that. What this like,

1054
00:41:56,428 --> 00:41:57,730
probably the 4th time I've

1055
00:41:57,730 --> 00:41:58,964
been in front of either this

1056
00:41:58,964 --> 00:42:01,964
committee or the full City

1057
00:42:03,268 --> 00:42:06,268
council talking about this and

1058
00:42:06,371 --> 00:42:08,440
what you listen to us. You

1059
00:42:08,440 --> 00:42:11,276
listen to the lies of opd and

1060
00:42:11,276 --> 00:42:13,110
you just go right ahead. So I

1061
00:42:13,110 --> 00:42:14,313
just don't know what to say

1062
00:42:14,313 --> 00:42:17,783
about it. I do want to say

1063
00:42:17,783 --> 00:42:19,685
that we are supposedly a

1064
00:42:19,685 --> 00:42:20,452
sanctuary city and should be

1065
00:42:20,452 --> 00:42:24,652
very clear to each one of you

1066
00:42:24,690 --> 00:42:26,692
at this point that. That ice

1067
00:42:26,692 --> 00:42:27,893
can get into all of these.

1068
00:42:27,893 --> 00:42:30,893
Certainly they can get into

1069
00:42:31,163 --> 00:42:34,763
flock. So. It just seems like

1070
00:42:41,206 --> 00:42:43,606
corruption to me. Madeline,

1071
00:42:48,470 --> 00:42:48,781
Stacey. Alp Ares provide

1072
00:42:48,781 --> 00:42:50,115
indiscriminate retrospectively

1073
00:42:50,115 --> 00:42:53,115
location, data. Any person, no

1074
00:42:53,118 --> 00:42:55,518
intermediary on demand. That

1075
00:42:57,560 --> 00:42:57,856
is a search without a warrant

1076
00:42:57,856 --> 00:42:58,557
with capability and track and

1077
00:42:58,557 --> 00:42:59,124
follow some of the sensitive

1078
00:42:59,124 --> 00:43:01,524
locations such as the

1079
00:43:03,162 --> 00:43:04,196
hospital. Immigration lawyer,

1080
00:43:04,196 --> 00:43:04,763
hospice churches, their home,

1081
00:43:04,763 --> 00:43:05,464
their doctor, Planned

1082
00:43:05,464 --> 00:43:07,464
Parenthood, their therapist,

1083
00:43:07,733 --> 00:43:11,303
their lover's home and it can

1084
00:43:11,303 --> 00:43:12,704
be used against lawful

1085
00:43:12,704 --> 00:43:14,540
protesters. Celebrate will be

1086
00:43:14,540 --> 00:43:16,540
used extrajudicial distance

1087
00:43:16,842 --> 00:43:17,476
Lee in the report attached the

1088
00:43:17,476 --> 00:43:18,143
agenda when the original

1089
00:43:18,143 --> 00:43:18,811
contract was discussed with

1090
00:43:18,811 --> 00:43:21,811
City Council. It states in

1091
00:43:22,614 --> 00:43:25,117
addition to warrants, it will

1092
00:43:25,117 --> 00:43:25,819
be used with documented

1093
00:43:25,819 --> 00:43:26,452
consent to search the mobile

1094
00:43:26,452 --> 00:43:28,120
device by the authorized

1095
00:43:28,120 --> 00:43:28,754
possessor of the device. And

1096
00:43:28,754 --> 00:43:31,754
we know health consent is

1097
00:43:32,524 --> 00:43:34,793
obtained. All this data is

1098
00:43:34,793 --> 00:43:35,494
sensitive and does not prevent

1099
00:43:35,494 --> 00:43:37,894
crime. Stop the surveillance

1100
00:43:44,436 --> 00:43:47,720
state cance the contracts now.

1101
00:43:47,720 --> 00:43:47,773
Hello. My name is Angela Max.

1102
00:43:47,773 --> 00:43:50,943
And I'm against is having any

1103
00:43:50,943 --> 00:43:51,610
contract with flock. I've

1104
00:43:51,610 --> 00:43:52,211
discovered a lot of really

1105
00:43:52,211 --> 00:43:54,611
scary things about this

1106
00:43:55,581 --> 00:43:58,384
company. They claim that they

1107
00:43:58,384 --> 00:43:59,840
don't know where their data is

1108
00:43:59,840 --> 00:44:02,200
being ai centers. It's Amazon

1109
00:44:02,200 --> 00:44:02,621
ai center. Amazon says they to

1110
00:44:02,621 --> 00:44:04,923
a globally depending on

1111
00:44:04,923 --> 00:44:06,258
whatever the local laws are.

1112
00:44:06,258 --> 00:44:07,926
So if it's legal here, they

1113
00:44:07,926 --> 00:44:08,660
can do it in a different

1114
00:44:08,660 --> 00:44:09,294
country or China and we don't

1115
00:44:09,294 --> 00:44:11,463
have any control a piece

1116
00:44:11,463 --> 00:44:13,599
looking at the data on that

1117
00:44:13,599 --> 00:44:14,266
end today. Don't come any

1118
00:44:14,266 --> 00:44:15,234
liability for the abuses in

1119
00:44:15,234 --> 00:44:19,710
the system or try to build any

1120
00:44:19,710 --> 00:44:21,907
way to stop the abuses. They

1121
00:44:21,907 --> 00:44:22,541
retroactively and stop and say

1122
00:44:22,541 --> 00:44:23,275
there was no data breach

1123
00:44:23,275 --> 00:44:23,942
because basically 7 months ago

1124
00:44:23,942 --> 00:44:26,942
that when even passports on

1125
00:44:28,514 --> 00:44:29,348
these cameras. And it did

1126
00:44:29,348 --> 00:44:30,717
partnership that they have

1127
00:44:30,717 --> 00:44:31,517
that give the day to ice. They

1128
00:44:31,517 --> 00:44:32,217
claim that they don't keep the

1129
00:44:32,217 --> 00:44:33,585
data and then the claim that

1130
00:44:33,585 --> 00:44:35,154
they have royalties the data

1131
00:44:35,154 --> 00:44:37,122
indefinitely, meaning they are

1132
00:44:37,122 --> 00:44:38,390
keeping it, they might not be

1133
00:44:38,390 --> 00:44:39,291
doing it now, but they might

1134
00:44:39,291 --> 00:44:40,592
sell it in the future that

1135
00:44:40,592 --> 00:44:41,226
might be bought by a different

1136
00:44:41,226 --> 00:44:42,828
company in the future. It

1137
00:44:42,828 --> 00:44:43,495
would explain why they're not

1138
00:44:43,495 --> 00:44:44,196
scared of liability because

1139
00:44:44,196 --> 00:44:47,796
they plan on selling for just

1140
00:44:54,940 --> 00:44:56,809
selling our data. Welcome

1141
00:44:56,809 --> 00:44:59,111
back, everyone. I am pleased

1142
00:44:59,111 --> 00:44:59,845
to see that after 100 plan

1143
00:44:59,845 --> 00:45:01,380
care to name great public. Can

1144
00:45:01,380 --> 00:45:04,980
you state your name for the

1145
00:45:09,755 --> 00:45:10,489
record? All Satan is Excuse

1146
00:45:10,489 --> 00:45:11,900
Hi. My name is Bree a woman. I

1147
00:45:11,900 --> 00:45:14,900
she her pronouns. I'm a

1148
00:45:14,526 --> 00:45:15,661
constituent for district 3 and

1149
00:45:15,661 --> 00:45:16,361
I am very pleased to what

1150
00:45:16,361 --> 00:45:17,496
happened earlier this member

1151
00:45:17,496 --> 00:45:18,230
of the public eye causing your

1152
00:45:18,230 --> 00:45:21,200
time. Mississauga. Do you give

1153
00:45:21,200 --> 00:45:22,835
her your time? Ma'am? You can

1154
00:45:22,835 --> 00:45:25,771
proceed East Army over then.

1155
00:45:25,771 --> 00:45:26,405
You can proceed. This is not

1156
00:45:26,405 --> 00:45:29,405
as giving your time. All

1157
00:45:30,443 --> 00:45:31,744
right. I'm gonna scratch out

1158
00:45:31,744 --> 00:45:32,778
that first part then because

1159
00:45:32,778 --> 00:45:33,712
if you can't various that it

1160
00:45:33,712 --> 00:45:35,810
to be here today because not

1161
00:45:35,810 --> 00:45:35,781
to not only repeat myself, but

1162
00:45:35,781 --> 00:45:38,150
to also hear my peers repeat

1163
00:45:38,150 --> 00:45:39,618
themselves as well. I play I

1164
00:45:39,618 --> 00:45:40,319
hope that you don't take my

1165
00:45:40,319 --> 00:45:41,754
sarcasm is disrespect to try

1166
00:45:41,754 --> 00:45:42,654
to put yourself in my shoes

1167
00:45:42,654 --> 00:45:44,690
right? That as a young black

1168
00:45:44,690 --> 00:45:46,392
woman, a 4th generation,

1169
00:45:46,392 --> 00:45:47,159
Oakland native, that you as my

1170
00:45:47,159 --> 00:45:49,159
representatives have decided

1171
00:45:50,896 --> 00:45:51,530
to continue the flock

1172
00:45:51,530 --> 00:45:52,131
expansion and explicitly

1173
00:45:52,131 --> 00:45:54,131
expressed the complete

1174
00:45:55,567 --> 00:45:56,902
disregard for my privacy that

1175
00:45:56,902 --> 00:45:58,637
despite our budget deficit and

1176
00:45:58,637 --> 00:45:59,505
utilize resources, a big and

1177
00:45:59,505 --> 00:46:00,205
historical lack of police

1178
00:46:00,205 --> 00:46:02,605
accountability still like to

1179
00:46:02,608 --> 00:46:03,308
dump money into the system of

1180
00:46:03,308 --> 00:46:04,900
enslavement and policing that

1181
00:46:04,900 --> 00:46:06,311
was created to ineffectively

1182
00:46:06,311 --> 00:46:06,979
harms every single day. The

1183
00:46:06,979 --> 00:46:09,214
privacy lawsuit against fox

1184
00:46:09,214 --> 00:46:10,649
should have been enough. The

1185
00:46:10,649 --> 00:46:11,383
open budget deficit should

1186
00:46:11,383 --> 00:46:13,685
have been an up and simply the

1187
00:46:13,685 --> 00:46:14,620
outrage of your constituents

1188
00:46:14,620 --> 00:46:15,754
should have been enough for

1189
00:46:15,754 --> 00:46:17,756
you to say no in NOVEMBER and

1190
00:46:17,756 --> 00:46:18,891
should be enough for you to

1191
00:46:18,891 --> 00:46:19,525
say no. Now I don't appreciate

1192
00:46:19,525 --> 00:46:22,525
the interest and I don't

1193
00:46:31,870 --> 00:46:32,471
appreciate you guys cut. Thank

1194
00:46:32,471 --> 00:46:34,730
you for your comments.

1195
00:46:34,730 --> 00:46:34,740
Switching to Zoom user Blair,

1196
00:46:34,740 --> 00:46:37,140
please unmute yourself and

1197
00:46:40,746 --> 00:46:41,747
begin your comment. We need to

1198
00:46:41,747 --> 00:46:44,747
move next speaker. Thank you

1199
00:46:45,651 --> 00:46:47,886
so much. You no pillow. Hello,

1200
00:46:47,886 --> 00:46:49,555
I'm I'm here. I'm here. Blair

1201
00:46:49,555 --> 00:46:50,222
Beekman hi player. You

1202
00:46:50,222 --> 00:46:52,622
continue. Thank you. Right.

1203
00:46:55,600 --> 00:46:55,728
Thank you. I had kind of be

1204
00:46:55,728 --> 00:46:57,296
moving and take get into a

1205
00:46:57,296 --> 00:46:59,832
good position to speak and

1206
00:46:59,832 --> 00:47:02,832
out. Biden public. Thank you

1207
00:47:02,835 --> 00:47:05,637
for this item. I'm trusting

1208
00:47:05,637 --> 00:47:06,305
your choice of police chief

1209
00:47:06,305 --> 00:47:09,305
I'm not trusting how you're

1210
00:47:09,775 --> 00:47:11,243
talking about block. When you

1211
00:47:11,243 --> 00:47:12,177
voted for blocking DECEMBER of

1212
00:47:12,177 --> 00:47:12,845
last year with the the

1213
00:47:12,845 --> 00:47:14,780
attention, the police that

1214
00:47:14,780 --> 00:47:16,949
they had to get the contract

1215
00:47:16,949 --> 00:47:18,217
signed immediately. Where is

1216
00:47:18,217 --> 00:47:18,851
the contract signing Park?

1217
00:47:18,851 --> 00:47:19,551
That's right. Now is the

1218
00:47:19,551 --> 00:47:21,987
actually been finding was at

1219
00:47:21,987 --> 00:47:23,422
least with not signed. That's

1220
00:47:23,422 --> 00:47:25,124
part of why you're not talking

1221
00:47:25,124 --> 00:47:29,324
to us right now. And I feel

1222
00:47:29,928 --> 00:47:31,563
you owe that Find or not. We

1223
00:47:31,563 --> 00:47:32,264
could have been working you

1224
00:47:32,264 --> 00:47:35,334
have a pay cut plan. Que lead

1225
00:47:35,334 --> 00:47:35,934
to future o'clock. Few years

1226
00:47:35,934 --> 00:47:37,536
time we could have been

1227
00:47:37,536 --> 00:47:38,904
working on a one-year time

1228
00:47:38,904 --> 00:47:39,638
praying. But you guys are

1229
00:47:39,638 --> 00:47:41,240
putting things off and you are

1230
00:47:41,240 --> 00:47:42,400
being incredibly on

1231
00:47:42,400 --> 00:47:44,440
accountable with some really

1232
00:47:48,130 --> 00:47:48,680
basic good ideas. Can we bring

1233
00:47:48,680 --> 00:47:49,348
together good ideas and you

1234
00:47:49,348 --> 00:47:50,490
guys be more accountable to

1235
00:47:50,490 --> 00:47:52,510
the process? I think waiting

1236
00:47:52,510 --> 00:47:52,751
to SEPTEMBER OCTOBER, you kind

1237
00:47:52,751 --> 00:47:55,751
Thank you for your comments.

1238
00:47:58,123 --> 00:48:00,426
Your time is up. Simon. Please

1239
00:48:00,426 --> 00:48:01,260
unmute yourself. Did you sign

1240
00:48:01,260 --> 00:48:01,960
up to speak on item number 8?

1241
00:48:01,960 --> 00:48:05,597
And if so, what name did you

1242
00:48:05,597 --> 00:48:06,832
sign up under? It should be

1243
00:48:06,832 --> 00:48:07,566
Simon, Renee, I'm sorry. I do

1244
00:48:07,566 --> 00:48:11,166
not have a speaker card filled

1245
00:48:12,604 --> 00:48:14,730
out for you. Calling him the

1246
00:48:14,730 --> 00:48:14,740
names that sign up the

1247
00:48:14,740 --> 00:48:16,740
remaining names. Elizabeth

1248
00:48:18,243 --> 00:48:18,911
Cochrane Noel for us and hot.

1249
00:48:18,911 --> 00:48:21,613
Okay at this time on didn't

1250
00:48:21,613 --> 00:48:24,130
have been called. Council

1251
00:48:27,419 --> 00:48:28,954
member Brown. Excellent. Thank

1252
00:48:28,954 --> 00:48:30,355
you so much. I just wanted to

1253
00:48:30,355 --> 00:48:32,324
ask clarifying question

1254
00:48:32,324 --> 00:48:34,293
because I know that when we

1255
00:48:34,293 --> 00:48:35,360
were discussing, I think all

1256
00:48:35,360 --> 00:48:36,428
of these items, you know, one

1257
00:48:36,428 --> 00:48:38,330
of the things that we request,

1258
00:48:38,330 --> 00:48:41,133
it was like an annual report

1259
00:48:41,133 --> 00:48:41,867
back. And I know that these

1260
00:48:41,867 --> 00:48:44,267
reports customarily go through

1261
00:48:44,303 --> 00:48:45,204
the Privacy Commission, right?

1262
00:48:45,204 --> 00:48:46,772
And so can I just get some

1263
00:48:46,772 --> 00:48:48,907
clarity as far as why we have

1264
00:48:48,907 --> 00:48:52,444
the side for us today. And I

1265
00:48:52,444 --> 00:48:56,440
feel like the title is a

1266
00:48:56,615 --> 00:48:57,549
misleading because it says to

1267
00:48:57,549 --> 00:48:59,949
item number 2, making a

1268
00:49:00,686 --> 00:49:02,488
determination, determination,

1269
00:49:02,488 --> 00:49:03,589
whether the city should

1270
00:49:03,589 --> 00:49:04,791
continue its use was the

1271
00:49:04,791 --> 00:49:06,592
report back from the Privacy

1272
00:49:06,592 --> 00:49:08,992
Commission around the annual

1273
00:49:09,361 --> 00:49:10,262
reports. As far as all

1274
00:49:10,262 --> 00:49:10,829
reports. When we presented to

1275
00:49:10,829 --> 00:49:12,829
the Privacy Advisory

1276
00:49:13,299 --> 00:49:16,299
Commission. I know all were

1277
00:49:17,369 --> 00:49:18,570
proven past forward as far as

1278
00:49:18,570 --> 00:49:20,272
delay in time. I'm not too

1279
00:49:20,272 --> 00:49:22,775
sure why. I know there is some

1280
00:49:22,775 --> 00:49:23,442
scheduling issues, but far as

1281
00:49:23,442 --> 00:49:26,442
any more specifics, I'm not

1282
00:49:31,650 --> 00:49:32,351
sure. Go ahead. Councilmember

1283
00:49:32,351 --> 00:49:35,951
Brown. Okay. And then my next

1284
00:49:37,456 --> 00:49:38,157
question since we pull item.

1285
00:49:38,157 --> 00:49:41,894
Since a portion of the eye of

1286
00:49:41,894 --> 00:49:44,960
the item was pulled item a and

1287
00:49:44,960 --> 00:49:47,990
this was supposed to be an up

1288
00:49:47,990 --> 00:49:50,990
day for the 2025. Reports and

1289
00:49:50,869 --> 00:49:51,537
we're going to get this now

1290
00:49:51,537 --> 00:49:54,537
even later where we've well

1291
00:49:54,740 --> 00:49:55,707
into the fall. What's what's

1292
00:49:55,707 --> 00:49:59,307
the status of the reports for,

1293
00:50:00,679 --> 00:50:03,582
I guess like 6 months into

1294
00:50:03,582 --> 00:50:04,783
2026 or we get a report on

1295
00:50:04,783 --> 00:50:05,451
this year, I think normally I

1296
00:50:05,451 --> 00:50:06,885
could be wrong. We normally

1297
00:50:06,885 --> 00:50:08,821
present to the Privacy

1298
00:50:08,821 --> 00:50:11,221
Advisory Commission. Lost my

1299
00:50:12,758 --> 00:50:14,259
voice newsy in APRIL. That's

1300
00:50:14,259 --> 00:50:15,270
if that's something we need to

1301
00:50:15,270 --> 00:50:15,728
re-evaluate. We can but

1302
00:50:15,728 --> 00:50:18,728
usually prevent we present in

1303
00:50:22,670 --> 00:50:24,467
APRIL. So this 2025 reported

1304
00:50:24,837 --> 00:50:25,504
was presented to the Privacy

1305
00:50:25,504 --> 00:50:27,172
Commission in APRIL of this

1306
00:50:27,172 --> 00:50:30,772
year. I have to double check

1307
00:50:36,882 --> 00:50:39,170
that. Do you have another

1308
00:50:39,170 --> 00:50:42,588
question? Are you want to? I'm

1309
00:50:42,588 --> 00:50:45,691
sorry about that I know I

1310
00:50:45,691 --> 00:50:46,325
offer this report. It says MAY

1311
00:50:46,325 --> 00:50:46,992
7, 2026. 0, can I have to

1312
00:50:46,992 --> 00:50:47,626
double check to see exactly

1313
00:50:47,626 --> 00:50:50,626
when it was scheduled and

1314
00:50:51,263 --> 00:50:53,165
present. Yeah, I'm I'm just

1315
00:50:53,165 --> 00:50:54,867
I'm just raising that because,

1316
00:50:54,867 --> 00:50:55,601
you know, by the time we get

1317
00:50:55,601 --> 00:50:58,601
this information and data, you

1318
00:50:58,637 --> 00:50:59,338
know, will be on standby,

1319
00:50:59,338 --> 00:50:59,938
really interested in what the

1320
00:50:59,938 --> 00:51:01,306
data is for the for the

1321
00:51:01,306 --> 00:51:04,306
current year. That's just my

1322
00:51:04,443 --> 00:51:04,977
feedback. Ok? Thank you.

1323
00:51:04,977 --> 00:51:06,977
Councilmember Brown

1324
00:51:07,780 --> 00:51:10,180
Councilmember Houston. To the

1325
00:51:10,749 --> 00:51:13,749
chair. Are you doing sir?

1326
00:51:17,924 --> 00:51:20,324
Still as representative of

1327
00:51:20,692 --> 00:51:21,760
District 7, I get emails calls

1328
00:51:21,760 --> 00:51:23,429
that support his flock. I

1329
00:51:23,429 --> 00:51:27,290
mean, I don't get that many

1330
00:51:30,169 --> 00:51:31,336
that bad. So. What to

1331
00:51:31,336 --> 00:51:33,338
Councilmember Brown of you

1332
00:51:33,338 --> 00:51:34,973
get, you know, e-mails about

1333
00:51:34,973 --> 00:51:35,641
it from my district. I'm not

1334
00:51:35,641 --> 00:51:36,341
saying I'm time my district

1335
00:51:36,341 --> 00:51:38,770
for meals to the schip. Bill

1336
00:51:38,770 --> 00:51:40,446
bill is to Lotus second

1337
00:51:40,446 --> 00:51:43,446
railroad tracks, they say they

1338
00:51:44,183 --> 00:51:45,117
want they want to protection.

1339
00:51:45,117 --> 00:51:47,553
So I'm here and tell

1340
00:51:47,553 --> 00:51:48,287
different. And so I want to

1341
00:51:48,287 --> 00:51:52,487
know the U.S. Is from district

1342
00:51:52,958 --> 00:51:54,958
7. District said district

1343
00:51:56,610 --> 00:51:56,895
saying from District 7, MISS

1344
00:51:56,895 --> 00:52:00,990
It. You how you feel about

1345
00:52:00,990 --> 00:52:03,990
tough love. Okay. So I'm

1346
00:52:05,270 --> 00:52:06,605
saying this that my history

1347
00:52:06,605 --> 00:52:10,805
fly. Right. So I want to move

1348
00:52:11,610 --> 00:52:12,311
this. I want to move Okay. And

1349
00:52:12,311 --> 00:52:15,911
and to be clear, we're going

1350
00:52:16,115 --> 00:52:18,500
to be. Councilmember Houston.

1351
00:52:18,500 --> 00:52:18,784
If you couldn't move the item

1352
00:52:18,784 --> 00:52:21,784
without exhibit a actually are

1353
00:52:23,522 --> 00:52:25,922
exhibit. Subsection a exhibit

1354
00:52:25,991 --> 00:52:29,940
e which is alpr item because

1355
00:52:29,940 --> 00:52:31,764
the request from opd is to

1356
00:52:31,764 --> 00:52:34,764
actually present this in the

1357
00:52:34,800 --> 00:52:38,400
fall time for later this year.

1358
00:52:40,839 --> 00:52:42,274
That's correct. It's exhibit e

1359
00:52:42,274 --> 00:52:44,243
it's the attachment exhibit e

1360
00:52:44,243 --> 00:52:48,443
but it is item. Like some item

1361
00:52:48,948 --> 00:52:50,883
a. That like to move it like

1362
00:52:50,883 --> 00:52:53,883
that? 10, not people want from

1363
00:52:56,256 --> 00:52:58,957
a move. Just so the public was

1364
00:52:58,957 --> 00:52:59,625
clear. This vote actually

1365
00:52:59,625 --> 00:53:01,627
removes the alpr item from

1366
00:53:01,627 --> 00:53:02,294
this from today's vote. We

1367
00:53:02,294 --> 00:53:05,894
will return to this in the

1368
00:53:07,433 --> 00:53:08,670
fall time. And I will to be

1369
00:53:08,670 --> 00:53:10,467
determined. I will second

1370
00:53:15,741 --> 00:53:16,442
that. Thank you. We have a

1371
00:53:16,442 --> 00:53:18,842
motion made by Councilmember

1372
00:53:19,446 --> 00:53:20,245
Houston second by Chair Wang

1373
00:53:20,245 --> 00:53:23,182
to approve as amended the

1374
00:53:23,182 --> 00:53:24,383
recommendations of staff and

1375
00:53:24,383 --> 00:53:27,286
support this item to the JULY

1376
00:53:27,286 --> 00:53:28,420
set 20 for City Council agenda

1377
00:53:28,420 --> 00:53:30,422
with the amendment to the

1378
00:53:30,422 --> 00:53:32,292
legislation removing regarding

1379
00:53:32,292 --> 00:53:33,726
the automated license plate

1380
00:53:33,726 --> 00:53:36,726
readers and exhibit e labeled

1381
00:53:37,663 --> 00:53:41,133
as Attachment e. On role. On

1382
00:53:41,133 --> 00:53:41,800
row councilmembers bout. I by

1383
00:53:41,800 --> 00:53:44,800
excuse Houston, I and chair

1384
00:53:45,700 --> 00:53:45,971
want chair eye. Thank you. And

1385
00:53:45,971 --> 00:53:46,672
to the makers of the motion,

1386
00:53:46,672 --> 00:53:50,872
is this on consent or not on

1387
00:53:52,780 --> 00:53:52,745
consent? Consent? Thank you

1388
00:53:52,745 --> 00:53:56,345
I'm Mike doesn't seem to be

1389
00:53:56,448 --> 00:53:57,683
working area. Threw the chair.

1390
00:53:57,683 --> 00:53:58,884
I just wanted to clarify that.

1391
00:53:58,884 --> 00:53:59,551
The title also changed to

1392
00:53:59,551 --> 00:54:01,951
remove the lpr information.

1393
00:54:03,555 --> 00:54:06,555
Thanks. So noted. Now going

1394
00:54:06,792 --> 00:54:07,459
back to the original order of

1395
00:54:07,459 --> 00:54:10,459
the agenda, reading in item

1396
00:54:15,000 --> 00:54:15,734
number 3. Adopt a resolution

1397
00:54:15,734 --> 00:54:16,435
authorizing the city

1398
00:54:16,435 --> 00:54:18,337
administrator or designee to

1399
00:54:18,337 --> 00:54:19,605
enter into an operation on it

1400
00:54:19,605 --> 00:54:22,500
area agreement with Alameda

1401
00:54:22,341 --> 00:54:23,308
County to participate and

1402
00:54:23,308 --> 00:54:23,976
intermediate level of the

1403
00:54:23,976 --> 00:54:24,676
State of Emergency Services

1404
00:54:24,676 --> 00:54:26,445
organization that will comply

1405
00:54:26,445 --> 00:54:29,810
with the state of California

1406
00:54:29,810 --> 00:54:31,810
Sanitize Emergency management

1407
00:54:31,517 --> 00:54:32,584
systems for the period of For

1408
00:54:32,584 --> 00:54:35,584
the period from edification to

1409
00:54:35,754 --> 00:54:38,154
DECEMBER 31st. 2000. 35 and we

1410
00:54:40,359 --> 00:54:41,160
have 3 speakers on this item.

1411
00:54:41,160 --> 00:54:41,827
Okay. Do we have a

1412
00:54:41,827 --> 00:54:44,227
representative from a lefty

1413
00:54:48,801 --> 00:54:50,803
here? Good afternoon. Good all

1414
00:54:50,803 --> 00:54:51,904
the pro. And this is the

1415
00:54:51,904 --> 00:54:54,540
emergency manager for the city

1416
00:54:54,540 --> 00:54:55,174
of Oakland from the fire

1417
00:54:55,174 --> 00:54:55,841
Department. Okay. It has

1418
00:54:55,841 --> 00:54:58,841
please ahead. The floor is

1419
00:55:02,140 --> 00:55:04,414
yours. The Oakland City

1420
00:55:04,917 --> 00:55:05,484
Council has adopted this

1421
00:55:05,484 --> 00:55:06,185
original 10 year, all

1422
00:55:06,185 --> 00:55:08,585
operational area agreement in

1423
00:55:12,357 --> 00:55:13,492
1990, hi. And then

1424
00:55:13,492 --> 00:55:14,927
subsequently on 1/11/2006, and

1425
00:55:14,927 --> 00:55:17,927
that one has expired on

1426
00:55:19,832 --> 00:55:21,832
DECEMBER 2025. Alameda County

1427
00:55:23,769 --> 00:55:25,404
has just approved their

1428
00:55:25,404 --> 00:55:26,138
agreement with Alameda County

1429
00:55:26,138 --> 00:55:28,538
agencies. Both government, non

1430
00:55:30,342 --> 00:55:32,342
government nonprofit. To

1431
00:55:33,512 --> 00:55:34,813
participate in this

1432
00:55:34,813 --> 00:55:37,213
organization. There's no cost

1433
00:55:37,583 --> 00:55:40,486
to the city of Oakland. It is

1434
00:55:40,486 --> 00:55:41,320
really for coordination of the

1435
00:55:41,320 --> 00:55:41,988
resources, information and

1436
00:55:41,988 --> 00:55:44,388
mutual aid during disasters

1437
00:55:48,460 --> 00:55:49,128
and emergencies. Great. I'm

1438
00:55:49,128 --> 00:55:49,828
not seeing any comments or

1439
00:55:49,828 --> 00:55:50,496
questions from my colleagues.

1440
00:55:50,496 --> 00:55:54,960
So let's first go to public

1441
00:55:54,233 --> 00:55:55,000
comment. Calling in the names

1442
00:55:55,000 --> 00:55:55,934
that signed up to speak on

1443
00:55:55,934 --> 00:55:56,602
item number 3, Jesse Rose

1444
00:55:56,602 --> 00:55:59,602
Morris, not all Linda Blair

1445
00:56:10,150 --> 00:56:10,382
Beekman.

1446
00:56:10,382 --> 00:56:11,550
Hi, sorry on that

1447
00:56:11,550 --> 00:56:13,285
last in that deliberation.

1448
00:56:13,285 --> 00:56:15,554
Just now I'm just here as more

1449
00:56:15,554 --> 00:56:17,489
on. Seems like you guys can

1450
00:56:17,489 --> 00:56:18,357
even get straight what you

1451
00:56:18,357 --> 00:56:19,591
snuck into the agenda and such

1452
00:56:19,591 --> 00:56:20,325
a long, lengthy pack it out.

1453
00:56:20,325 --> 00:56:21,693
Now one of our public speakers

1454
00:56:21,693 --> 00:56:25,298
had a print it out. Can see

1455
00:56:25,298 --> 00:56:26,650
how thick it was. And you gave

1456
00:56:26,650 --> 00:56:26,732
one minute per person for all

1457
00:56:26,732 --> 00:56:30,332
of that. Okay. So for this

1458
00:56:30,869 --> 00:56:31,703
item here. Page who says the

1459
00:56:31,703 --> 00:56:33,839
Alameda County sheriff will be

1460
00:56:33,839 --> 00:56:35,839
the operational area

1461
00:56:35,941 --> 00:56:36,642
coordinator and that we will

1462
00:56:36,642 --> 00:56:39,878
have to count on them in the

1463
00:56:39,878 --> 00:56:41,780
case of a disaster. And since

1464
00:56:41,780 --> 00:56:42,781
we care about flock, we care

1465
00:56:42,781 --> 00:56:43,549
about what's happening with

1466
00:56:43,549 --> 00:56:44,383
flock in Alameda County. And

1467
00:56:44,383 --> 00:56:46,952
we have seen the Alameda

1468
00:56:46,952 --> 00:56:47,619
County Sheriff lie point blank

1469
00:56:47,619 --> 00:56:50,550
to the public about what is

1470
00:56:50,550 --> 00:56:50,756
happening with flock and what

1471
00:56:50,756 --> 00:56:51,824
they've done around. There's

1472
00:56:51,824 --> 00:56:54,226
their public outreach on the

1473
00:56:54,226 --> 00:56:55,227
item. It isn't page 2 and

1474
00:56:55,227 --> 00:56:56,195
looking at page 2, it says

1475
00:56:56,195 --> 00:56:56,862
that that's going that's we're

1476
00:56:56,862 --> 00:57:00,462
going to be counting on for

1477
00:57:00,466 --> 00:57:01,333
these emergency services. They

1478
00:57:01,333 --> 00:57:03,702
in public outreach said that

1479
00:57:03,702 --> 00:57:05,304
nobody had any concerns about

1480
00:57:05,304 --> 00:57:06,238
flock when they ram this

1481
00:57:06,238 --> 00:57:07,473
through the Alameda County

1482
00:57:07,473 --> 00:57:08,107
Board of Supervisors and

1483
00:57:08,107 --> 00:57:10,107
several public commenters

1484
00:57:16,115 --> 00:57:19,651
called them out for line. So

1485
00:57:19,651 --> 00:57:24,451
one of the one of the big that

1486
00:57:24,957 --> 00:57:25,858
is a big challenge. Is when we

1487
00:57:25,858 --> 00:57:28,258
have evacuation procedures and

1488
00:57:30,362 --> 00:57:32,231
it involves all students. Usd

1489
00:57:32,231 --> 00:57:32,865
is not a neighborhood school

1490
00:57:32,865 --> 00:57:35,768
district. It is a choice

1491
00:57:35,768 --> 00:57:38,168
district. We have children

1492
00:57:38,937 --> 00:57:40,973
scattered throughout the city.

1493
00:57:40,973 --> 00:57:41,707
And that's going to be more

1494
00:57:41,707 --> 00:57:42,374
challenging the neighborhoods

1495
00:57:42,374 --> 00:57:44,410
when I lived in New Orleans

1496
00:57:44,410 --> 00:57:45,511
and we had an emergency

1497
00:57:45,511 --> 00:57:47,460
parents will call and he would

1498
00:57:47,460 --> 00:57:51,246
run to come pick up the kids.

1499
00:57:52,451 --> 00:57:53,850
Can't do that. 7 the larger

1500
00:57:53,850 --> 00:57:54,720
percent all children are

1501
00:57:54,720 --> 00:57:55,287
spread throughout the city.

1502
00:57:55,287 --> 00:57:57,687
What happens to those

1503
00:57:57,990 --> 00:58:00,390
children? When they separated

1504
00:58:01,226 --> 00:58:02,661
from their parents? And we

1505
00:58:02,661 --> 00:58:03,395
have to do something to

1506
00:58:03,395 --> 00:58:04,730
protect them house and get

1507
00:58:04,730 --> 00:58:07,130
them back home. This

1508
00:58:10,402 --> 00:58:11,300
challenging Skyline. 1400

1509
00:58:11,300 --> 00:58:13,300
students, no evacuation

1510
00:58:16,410 --> 00:58:16,642
process. In place except to

1511
00:58:16,642 --> 00:58:17,376
shelter in place on the

1512
00:58:17,376 --> 00:58:20,976
football field. In the case of

1513
00:58:23,415 --> 00:58:26,415
love. Thank you for comments.

1514
00:58:31,990 --> 00:58:32,826
Missile of Thank you, sir.

1515
00:58:32,826 --> 00:58:33,460
Switching to Zoom user Blair,

1516
00:58:33,460 --> 00:58:37,600
you use up and begin your

1517
00:58:39,465 --> 00:58:41,233
comment. I'm an agreement with

1518
00:58:41,233 --> 00:58:43,335
the first public comment a lot

1519
00:58:43,335 --> 00:58:45,504
of important items on the

1520
00:58:45,504 --> 00:58:46,205
previous agenda item. Really

1521
00:58:46,205 --> 00:58:47,573
needs like a minute 30, that

1522
00:58:47,573 --> 00:58:49,541
additional 30nd be a lot of

1523
00:58:49,541 --> 00:58:52,778
help. I hope you could learn

1524
00:58:52,778 --> 00:58:53,612
that sort like the ability and

1525
00:58:53,612 --> 00:58:54,279
Peter public meeting mid 30's

1526
00:58:54,279 --> 00:58:55,781
definitely need to win. The

1527
00:58:55,781 --> 00:58:56,448
item is brought to counsel.

1528
00:58:56,448 --> 00:58:57,282
Good luck in that effort to

1529
00:58:57,282 --> 00:58:59,170
consider that concept. We one

1530
00:58:59,170 --> 00:59:01,653
30 a bit more. Think not all

1531
00:59:01,653 --> 00:59:05,853
the time. Just a bit more. I

1532
00:59:06,258 --> 00:59:08,761
want to comment for this item

1533
00:59:08,761 --> 00:59:12,961
yeah, I you know, the work the

1534
00:59:13,932 --> 00:59:14,666
person are weighing doing the

1535
00:59:14,666 --> 00:59:16,666
international boulevard issues

1536
00:59:18,404 --> 00:59:19,400
around 12th Street. And so I

1537
00:59:19,400 --> 00:59:19,671
can office of Emergency

1538
00:59:19,671 --> 00:59:22,710
Services at the California

1539
00:59:23,675 --> 00:59:24,376
state level be of help. And I

1540
00:59:24,376 --> 00:59:25,277
suppose the story of item can

1541
00:59:25,277 --> 00:59:28,113
be helpful in in working with

1542
00:59:28,113 --> 00:59:30,849
Alameda County and such. It's

1543
00:59:30,849 --> 00:59:32,510
towards, you know, not law

1544
00:59:32,510 --> 00:59:34,451
enforcement. That's why part

1545
00:59:34,520 --> 00:59:35,120
of Office of Emergency

1546
00:59:35,120 --> 00:59:35,854
Services to address the

1547
00:59:35,854 --> 00:59:36,555
California Office of Emergency

1548
00:59:36,555 --> 00:59:38,490
Services. Good Luck and that

1549
00:59:38,490 --> 00:59:39,191
content. Thank you. Thank you

1550
00:59:39,191 --> 00:59:39,892
for your comments. Sure. That

1551
00:59:39,892 --> 00:59:42,892
includes all speakers on item

1552
00:59:43,796 --> 00:59:45,864
3. Thank you, Clark. Yes, so

1553
00:59:45,864 --> 00:59:48,864
thank you for bringing this

1554
00:59:49,802 --> 00:59:51,470
item before us. I do have just

1555
00:59:51,470 --> 00:59:52,204
a question around how often

1556
00:59:52,204 --> 00:59:55,204
the mutual aid comes to

1557
00:59:55,841 --> 00:59:56,708
Oakland versus when the city

1558
00:59:56,708 --> 00:59:59,108
of Oakland supporting our

1559
01:00:03,649 --> 01:00:04,883
neighboring jurisdictions.

1560
01:00:04,883 --> 01:00:05,818
There's a mutual aid agreement

1561
01:00:05,818 --> 01:00:08,854
fire and police. And this is

1562
01:00:08,854 --> 01:00:09,888
not part of that. This for

1563
01:00:09,888 --> 01:00:10,622
emergency services for

1564
01:00:10,622 --> 01:00:13,220
planning response and recovery

1565
01:00:16,662 --> 01:00:18,630
purposes. Only. This board.

1566
01:00:18,630 --> 01:00:22,230
They on a county into 2 was

1567
01:00:22,501 --> 01:00:23,202
created after the 1991 Oakland

1568
01:00:23,202 --> 01:00:26,802
And this is in the California

1569
01:00:28,874 --> 01:00:30,800
code. To ensure that we all

1570
01:00:30,800 --> 01:00:32,408
agencies in Alameda County,

1571
01:00:32,778 --> 01:00:33,912
both government, not a

1572
01:00:33,912 --> 01:00:35,130
government and non-profit and

1573
01:00:35,130 --> 01:00:37,983
special districts that we all

1574
01:00:37,983 --> 01:00:39,451
have a way to coordinate with

1575
01:00:39,451 --> 01:00:42,187
each other to create a mutual

1576
01:00:42,187 --> 01:00:42,788
trainings and exercises which

1577
01:00:42,788 --> 01:00:45,188
enhance our capacity to

1578
01:00:47,326 --> 01:00:47,926
respond. And according to

1579
01:00:47,926 --> 01:00:49,926
Sam's the standardized

1580
01:00:50,529 --> 01:00:52,529
emergency management System

1581
01:00:54,700 --> 01:00:55,401
and National Incident Command

1582
01:00:55,401 --> 01:00:57,770
system, the way people work.

1583
01:00:57,770 --> 01:00:58,670
The disaster is always local.

1584
01:00:58,670 --> 01:01:01,670
It starts in in the

1585
01:01:01,707 --> 01:01:02,641
jurisdictions in this case say

1586
01:01:02,641 --> 01:01:05,611
Oakland, then once we lost our

1587
01:01:05,611 --> 01:01:06,979
resources in Oakland in all or

1588
01:01:06,979 --> 01:01:08,781
some capacity, then it goes to

1589
01:01:08,781 --> 01:01:10,716
the operational area, which

1590
01:01:10,716 --> 01:01:12,510
for us is the county. And that

1591
01:01:12,510 --> 01:01:12,985
is what is stop is established

1592
01:01:12,985 --> 01:01:15,385
by the California code

1593
01:01:17,623 --> 01:01:18,424
following the 91 opened fire.

1594
01:01:18,424 --> 01:01:20,325
If the county is out of

1595
01:01:20,325 --> 01:01:22,725
resources can no longer

1596
01:01:23,162 --> 01:01:23,996
support us, then it goes to

1597
01:01:23,996 --> 01:01:24,997
the region and then the state

1598
01:01:24,997 --> 01:01:27,997
and then federal. So that's

1599
01:01:28,700 --> 01:01:31,100
the progression of response

1600
01:01:31,570 --> 01:01:33,739
being closely connected to the

1601
01:01:33,739 --> 01:01:36,108
Alameda County ensures that we

1602
01:01:36,108 --> 01:01:37,943
as all cities get support one

1603
01:01:37,943 --> 01:01:39,780
another if we are affected

1604
01:01:39,780 --> 01:01:40,813
than others and not them, the

1605
01:01:40,813 --> 01:01:41,914
resources can come from them

1606
01:01:41,914 --> 01:01:43,820
through the Alameda County

1607
01:01:43,820 --> 01:01:44,983
Coordination. So that's an

1608
01:01:44,983 --> 01:01:47,119
important part of this

1609
01:01:47,119 --> 01:01:47,820
partnership. Plus, training

1610
01:01:47,820 --> 01:01:49,555
and less exercise because no

1611
01:01:49,555 --> 01:01:51,955
one jurisdiction has the

1612
01:01:52,758 --> 01:01:54,727
capacity or the finances to

1613
01:01:54,727 --> 01:01:56,628
create enough trainings and

1614
01:01:56,628 --> 01:01:57,262
exercises to train city staff

1615
01:01:57,262 --> 01:02:00,262
to train our partners in

1616
01:02:00,566 --> 01:02:01,100
church community. Okay. Great.

1617
01:02:01,100 --> 01:02:03,500
So that's a helpful

1618
01:02:03,569 --> 01:02:04,503
clarification. So this is

1619
01:02:04,503 --> 01:02:06,438
really pertaining to natural

1620
01:02:06,438 --> 01:02:07,172
disaster. Planning it. It

1621
01:02:07,172 --> 01:02:10,375
sounds like not so much mutual

1622
01:02:10,375 --> 01:02:11,478
aid as it pertains to either

1623
01:02:11,478 --> 01:02:12,770
law enforcement Okay. That's

1624
01:02:12,770 --> 01:02:14,477
that's a separate issue

1625
01:02:15,314 --> 01:02:17,116
altogether. Different code.

1626
01:02:17,116 --> 01:02:18,150
Okay. So you know, this

1627
01:02:18,150 --> 01:02:20,850
pertains to preparedness

1628
01:02:20,850 --> 01:02:22,850
reminisce response, recovery

1629
01:02:22,354 --> 01:02:25,900
and mitigation. So we all work

1630
01:02:25,900 --> 01:02:25,824
together to ensure our

1631
01:02:25,824 --> 01:02:27,526
collective reading is not just

1632
01:02:27,526 --> 01:02:29,926
for natural disasters, manmade

1633
01:02:30,262 --> 01:02:33,660
as Cyber attack that we've

1634
01:02:33,660 --> 01:02:34,233
spent a couple of years We

1635
01:02:34,233 --> 01:02:36,235
were we had were heavily

1636
01:02:36,235 --> 01:02:37,369
relying on the county and also

1637
01:02:37,369 --> 01:02:38,404
I think jurisdictional

1638
01:02:38,404 --> 01:02:39,571
experience with similar tax to

1639
01:02:39,571 --> 01:02:40,205
ensure that we take the right

1640
01:02:40,205 --> 01:02:42,605
steps. And employee right

1641
01:02:43,809 --> 01:02:44,543
partnerships. Okay. Great one

1642
01:02:44,543 --> 01:02:46,211
final question. Then I'll turn

1643
01:02:46,211 --> 01:02:47,880
it over to Councilmember Brown

1644
01:02:47,880 --> 01:02:50,616
is just have you all been

1645
01:02:50,616 --> 01:02:52,170
looking into just the or

1646
01:02:52,170 --> 01:02:52,851
coordinating of like the text

1647
01:02:52,851 --> 01:02:55,251
alerts and just notifications

1648
01:02:57,356 --> 01:02:58,424
to residents in the case of a

1649
01:02:58,424 --> 01:03:00,424
serious incident. Absolutely.

1650
01:03:01,326 --> 01:03:02,261
In fact, we're getting ready

1651
01:03:02,261 --> 01:03:04,463
deplore a campaign for a

1652
01:03:04,463 --> 01:03:06,231
sailor which stands for

1653
01:03:06,231 --> 01:03:08,267
Alameda County alerting System

1654
01:03:08,267 --> 01:03:10,135
many of such tools are

1655
01:03:10,135 --> 01:03:10,669
available through the county

1656
01:03:10,669 --> 01:03:11,370
because again, the

1657
01:03:11,370 --> 01:03:13,770
municipalities don't have the

1658
01:03:14,373 --> 01:03:16,975
resources to buy platforms and

1659
01:03:16,975 --> 01:03:17,643
so forth and So we do have a

1660
01:03:17,643 --> 01:03:20,612
see a lurch in the city of

1661
01:03:20,612 --> 01:03:22,681
Oakland. We have 2 levels.

1662
01:03:22,681 --> 01:03:24,750
It's an opt in system. So

1663
01:03:24,750 --> 01:03:25,417
people have to sign We have

1664
01:03:25,417 --> 01:03:27,820
one that is specific to the

1665
01:03:27,820 --> 01:03:29,588
city of Oakland when we have

1666
01:03:29,588 --> 01:03:32,570
something that is important to

1667
01:03:32,570 --> 01:03:33,625
staff based on location or an

1668
01:03:33,625 --> 01:03:35,794
incident. And then we also

1669
01:03:35,794 --> 01:03:36,895
have a resident alert. And in

1670
01:03:36,895 --> 01:03:40,495
fact, those who were signed up

1671
01:03:40,733 --> 01:03:43,635
for a sailor on JULY 4 prior

1672
01:03:43,635 --> 01:03:44,269
to JULY 4th, prior to JULY,

1673
01:03:44,269 --> 01:03:45,137
3rd would have received 2

1674
01:03:45,137 --> 01:03:47,172
alerts indicating the street

1675
01:03:47,172 --> 01:03:49,740
closures for JULY 4th

1676
01:03:49,740 --> 01:03:49,975
celebrations any other

1677
01:03:49,975 --> 01:03:51,975
important information that

1678
01:03:52,311 --> 01:03:54,780
needed to be distributed show

1679
01:03:54,780 --> 01:03:54,813
our residents and our visitors

1680
01:03:54,813 --> 01:03:57,916
knew where when and how to get

1681
01:03:57,916 --> 01:04:00,853
around the city. So we do

1682
01:04:00,853 --> 01:04:02,540
deploy ac alert regularly,

1683
01:04:02,540 --> 01:04:05,230
both for internal staff for

1684
01:04:05,230 --> 01:04:07,259
things that matter to

1685
01:04:07,259 --> 01:04:08,127
particular department and to

1686
01:04:08,127 --> 01:04:08,827
our residents when it doesn't

1687
01:04:08,827 --> 01:04:11,290
have to be disaster. JULY 4th

1688
01:04:11,290 --> 01:04:11,663
with a celebration. That's

1689
01:04:11,663 --> 01:04:14,663
good to know. Thank you.

1690
01:04:16,201 --> 01:04:17,169
Councilmember Brown.

1691
01:04:17,169 --> 01:04:19,304
Excellent. Thank you so much

1692
01:04:19,304 --> 01:04:21,173
for the report. I'm very

1693
01:04:21,173 --> 01:04:22,441
familiar with the emergency

1694
01:04:22,441 --> 01:04:23,142
management kind of protocol

1695
01:04:23,142 --> 01:04:25,344
and system. I got to take a

1696
01:04:25,344 --> 01:04:27,312
handful, of course, is on

1697
01:04:27,312 --> 01:04:28,113
emergency management. And so I

1698
01:04:28,113 --> 01:04:31,518
know that is very complex. But

1699
01:04:31,518 --> 01:04:33,252
it also requires, as you

1700
01:04:33,252 --> 01:04:35,253
mention, you know, working

1701
01:04:35,253 --> 01:04:38,223
across all of our governmental

1702
01:04:38,223 --> 01:04:41,223
systems, right to ensure its

1703
01:04:41,727 --> 01:04:43,529
success. So my question is one

1704
01:04:43,529 --> 01:04:45,431
of can you just at a high

1705
01:04:45,431 --> 01:04:46,398
level, maybe share with me

1706
01:04:46,398 --> 01:04:49,398
given that we're going to

1707
01:04:50,690 --> 01:04:50,937
enter into a contract that

1708
01:04:50,937 --> 01:04:53,806
that is about, you know, a

1709
01:04:53,806 --> 01:04:54,706
years long, pretty lengthy. He

1710
01:04:54,706 --> 01:04:57,209
walked me through, like what

1711
01:04:57,209 --> 01:04:57,976
are some of the court nation

1712
01:04:57,976 --> 01:05:00,976
efforts that will that will

1713
01:05:01,880 --> 01:05:02,514
kind of take place to ensure

1714
01:05:02,514 --> 01:05:04,914
you know, just continued

1715
01:05:05,751 --> 01:05:06,886
coordination like either, you

1716
01:05:06,886 --> 01:05:08,520
know, 6 months check, ins are

1717
01:05:08,520 --> 01:05:11,290
like what? What is the how how

1718
01:05:11,290 --> 01:05:11,857
is the relationship like

1719
01:05:11,857 --> 01:05:13,258
genuinely maintained?

1720
01:05:13,258 --> 01:05:15,462
Absolutely. Is a question.

1721
01:05:15,462 --> 01:05:16,629
Thank you. So this this

1722
01:05:16,629 --> 01:05:17,863
agreement is between as the

1723
01:05:17,863 --> 01:05:20,733
city of Oakland and Alameda

1724
01:05:20,733 --> 01:05:22,634
County in every other

1725
01:05:22,634 --> 01:05:23,736
jurisdiction, governments

1726
01:05:23,736 --> 01:05:25,104
government, non-profit special

1727
01:05:25,104 --> 01:05:26,638
districts also entering into

1728
01:05:26,638 --> 01:05:29,380
this agreement on their

1729
01:05:31,543 --> 01:05:32,244
behalf. So So what happens is

1730
01:05:32,244 --> 01:05:33,612
we need quarterly and by we I

1731
01:05:33,612 --> 01:05:34,513
don't mean that certainly I

1732
01:05:34,513 --> 01:05:37,116
go. But somebody from it will

1733
01:05:37,116 --> 01:05:40,116
go to the quarterly meetings.

1734
01:05:40,719 --> 01:05:41,353
We also have a monthly Check

1735
01:05:41,353 --> 01:05:41,887
just with the government

1736
01:05:41,887 --> 01:05:43,887
entities. So that's

1737
01:05:45,357 --> 01:05:47,226
specialized for government. We

1738
01:05:47,226 --> 01:05:48,560
have joint training

1739
01:05:48,560 --> 01:05:49,295
opportunities several times a

1740
01:05:49,295 --> 01:05:51,430
year. A little bit hard to

1741
01:05:51,430 --> 01:05:52,364
quantify. Sometimes it's

1742
01:05:52,364 --> 01:05:53,310
months. And then sometimes

1743
01:05:53,310 --> 01:05:56,310
it's every other month. You

1744
01:05:56,735 --> 01:05:59,735
know, that sort of probably

1745
01:05:59,905 --> 01:06:02,305
have about dozen training

1746
01:06:02,708 --> 01:06:04,676
opportunities a year just our

1747
01:06:04,676 --> 01:06:05,844
counties. Alameda County's who

1748
01:06:05,844 --> 01:06:07,279
takes that on who runs the the

1749
01:06:07,279 --> 01:06:07,980
expense organization of it and

1750
01:06:07,980 --> 01:06:12,780
all of it for for us to take

1751
01:06:14,686 --> 01:06:16,855
advantage of it. We also

1752
01:06:16,855 --> 01:06:17,956
multiple exercises a years

1753
01:06:17,956 --> 01:06:19,525
some big, some small. What

1754
01:06:19,525 --> 01:06:21,326
also the county does for all

1755
01:06:21,326 --> 01:06:23,263
of our jurisdictions. They

1756
01:06:23,263 --> 01:06:24,629
organize planning one of the

1757
01:06:24,629 --> 01:06:25,297
blessings that we have so far

1758
01:06:25,297 --> 01:06:28,297
this year. What's what's in

1759
01:06:30,169 --> 01:06:32,104
response? And before anybody

1760
01:06:32,104 --> 01:06:34,273
says we are at risk for maybe

1761
01:06:34,273 --> 01:06:35,908
not a huge risk but risk. So

1762
01:06:35,908 --> 01:06:38,900
we city of Oakland

1763
01:06:38,900 --> 01:06:39,144
participated with the city of

1764
01:06:39,144 --> 01:06:40,646
county and the contractor that

1765
01:06:40,646 --> 01:06:43,460
they hired to create

1766
01:06:44,416 --> 01:06:45,149
oakland-alameda specific

1767
01:06:45,149 --> 01:06:46,752
tsunami plan. If that happens,

1768
01:06:46,752 --> 01:06:47,419
what do we do in the county?

1769
01:06:47,419 --> 01:06:49,819
Other county agencies were

1770
01:06:53,358 --> 01:06:53,959
involved but plans

1771
01:06:53,959 --> 01:06:55,394
additionally with just

1772
01:06:55,394 --> 01:06:57,794
planning how train elected

1773
01:07:00,832 --> 01:07:02,680
officials. On emergency

1774
01:07:02,680 --> 01:07:04,870
response. We haven't ruled it

1775
01:07:04,870 --> 01:07:07,720
out. The work has just been

1776
01:07:07,720 --> 01:07:08,774
completed. But at some point

1777
01:07:08,774 --> 01:07:10,109
you all of our elected elected

1778
01:07:10,109 --> 01:07:12,178
officials will get a very nice

1779
01:07:12,178 --> 01:07:14,347
booklet that spells out. And

1780
01:07:14,347 --> 01:07:15,130
this happens. This is what is

1781
01:07:15,130 --> 01:07:17,182
need that if that happens,

1782
01:07:17,182 --> 01:07:19,318
this is what is needed and

1783
01:07:19,318 --> 01:07:20,886
will conduct the training for

1784
01:07:20,886 --> 01:07:21,552
just the city of Oakland

1785
01:07:21,552 --> 01:07:23,288
elected officials. Those in

1786
01:07:23,288 --> 01:07:24,189
just a few examples of how

1787
01:07:24,189 --> 01:07:26,230
county supports the city of

1788
01:07:26,230 --> 01:07:27,192
Oakland in other

1789
01:07:27,192 --> 01:07:28,160
jurisdictions. Excellent.

1790
01:07:28,160 --> 01:07:30,695
Thank you so much. And I know

1791
01:07:30,695 --> 01:07:32,640
last year some of us myself

1792
01:07:32,640 --> 01:07:35,664
and some of the other offices

1793
01:07:35,934 --> 01:07:37,136
attended a training at o c

1794
01:07:37,136 --> 01:07:37,935
Around. You there's a handful

1795
01:07:37,935 --> 01:07:41,606
of things that we that we got

1796
01:07:41,606 --> 01:07:42,641
the opportunity to align. So

1797
01:07:42,641 --> 01:07:44,610
if my colleagues haven't had

1798
01:07:44,610 --> 01:07:45,311
the opportunity to do it was

1799
01:07:45,311 --> 01:07:46,145
very insightful. And the team

1800
01:07:46,145 --> 01:07:49,745
that we have working at the

1801
01:07:49,815 --> 01:07:50,482
dot, they are phenomenal.

1802
01:07:50,482 --> 01:07:51,116
Excellent. So thank you so

1803
01:07:51,116 --> 01:07:54,870
much for that report. I'm

1804
01:07:54,870 --> 01:07:55,870
happy to move the item, ok?

1805
01:07:55,870 --> 01:07:56,654
Great. I will second that I

1806
01:07:56,654 --> 01:07:58,857
just have one more comment to

1807
01:07:58,857 --> 01:07:59,725
make it. I was making the

1808
01:07:59,725 --> 01:08:01,860
connection what actually my

1809
01:08:01,860 --> 01:08:04,260
questions before around the

1810
01:08:05,931 --> 01:08:07,933
alert systems. I remember

1811
01:08:07,933 --> 01:08:09,670
reading about Maui and when

1812
01:08:09,670 --> 01:08:11,503
there was that wildfire and

1813
01:08:11,503 --> 01:08:12,871
the fact that the sirens did

1814
01:08:12,871 --> 01:08:15,741
not deploy and I think it

1815
01:08:15,741 --> 01:08:16,809
looks like in San Francisco.

1816
01:08:16,809 --> 01:08:19,677
Because there has not been the

1817
01:08:19,677 --> 01:08:20,345
funding. The siren system is

1818
01:08:20,345 --> 01:08:20,945
currently offline. I don't

1819
01:08:20,945 --> 01:08:23,649
know the status here in

1820
01:08:23,649 --> 01:08:24,316
Alameda County, but I do think

1821
01:08:24,316 --> 01:08:27,586
that is something for us to

1822
01:08:27,586 --> 01:08:28,253
ensure that we have that up

1823
01:08:28,253 --> 01:08:31,253
and running. Since we know

1824
01:08:32,624 --> 01:08:34,659
with climate change. A natural

1825
01:08:34,659 --> 01:08:35,328
disaster is inevitable as evil

1826
01:08:35,328 --> 01:08:36,628
as you yourself have stated

1827
01:08:36,628 --> 01:08:39,280
with the tsunami risk

1828
01:08:39,465 --> 01:08:40,666
wildfires, everything and so I

1829
01:08:40,666 --> 01:08:42,801
want to make sure that we have

1830
01:08:42,801 --> 01:08:44,670
that in place and that we're

1831
01:08:44,670 --> 01:08:47,139
we're ready is a county and

1832
01:08:47,139 --> 01:08:50,139
the city. Just need Sure.

1833
01:08:51,243 --> 01:08:51,977
Yeah. Sleuthing. So it the

1834
01:08:51,977 --> 01:08:53,278
counting this particular would

1835
01:08:53,278 --> 01:08:53,979
have anything to do with this.

1836
01:08:53,979 --> 01:08:56,979
The city of Oakland maintains

1837
01:08:57,649 --> 01:08:58,484
its own siren system. We test

1838
01:08:58,484 --> 01:09:01,484
sirens every month on the

1839
01:09:01,854 --> 01:09:03,654
first Wednesday at noon, I

1840
01:09:03,654 --> 01:09:05,524
would one sound for a minute

1841
01:09:05,524 --> 01:09:06,225
us out. If you hear the siren

1842
01:09:06,225 --> 01:09:09,927
on any other day of the week,

1843
01:09:09,927 --> 01:09:10,829
any other time. There are 3

1844
01:09:10,829 --> 01:09:13,364
types of Jones, but don't

1845
01:09:13,364 --> 01:09:15,401
expect everyone remember If

1846
01:09:15,401 --> 01:09:17,336
you hear something, then go to

1847
01:09:17,336 --> 01:09:20,336
the official news resource we

1848
01:09:20,406 --> 01:09:21,640
most of our sirens are fully

1849
01:09:21,640 --> 01:09:24,400
functional and operational. We

1850
01:09:24,343 --> 01:09:25,411
have a couple that are

1851
01:09:25,411 --> 01:09:26,545
currently maintenance status.

1852
01:09:26,545 --> 01:09:27,278
But this sirens scheme on

1853
01:09:27,278 --> 01:09:30,149
around the city such that even

1854
01:09:30,149 --> 01:09:32,551
if one is out, there are

1855
01:09:32,551 --> 01:09:33,218
others around the area about

1856
01:09:33,218 --> 01:09:36,218
what that would sound. So

1857
01:09:37,122 --> 01:09:38,456
nobody is without any sound.

1858
01:09:38,456 --> 01:09:40,259
And we do testing regularly

1859
01:09:40,259 --> 01:09:40,992
and we have 3 agency so to

1860
01:09:40,992 --> 01:09:43,395
speak that are responsible for

1861
01:09:43,395 --> 01:09:44,630
activation in case need that.

1862
01:09:44,630 --> 01:09:46,632
And that would be through the

1863
01:09:46,632 --> 01:09:47,366
fire dispatch. Police dispatch

1864
01:09:47,366 --> 01:09:50,366
or emergency management or the

1865
01:09:51,203 --> 01:09:53,500
radio group of Public works

1866
01:09:53,500 --> 01:09:54,139
great. So it sounds like

1867
01:09:54,139 --> 01:09:57,139
Francisco, our siren system is

1868
01:09:57,744 --> 01:09:58,410
in fact working. Correct. And

1869
01:09:58,410 --> 01:10:01,680
we do work with to shop for

1870
01:10:01,680 --> 01:10:03,649
public works. And with public

1871
01:10:03,649 --> 01:10:05,585
electricians and Eugenie and

1872
01:10:05,585 --> 01:10:06,685
so forth to ensure that all of

1873
01:10:06,685 --> 01:10:09,685
our signs or an operational

1874
01:10:10,556 --> 01:10:12,124
condition. But yes, it is

1875
01:10:12,124 --> 01:10:12,858
aging infrastructure. So every

1876
01:10:12,858 --> 01:10:14,760
now and then for one reason or

1877
01:10:14,760 --> 01:10:16,695
another wanted sirens will go

1878
01:10:16,695 --> 01:10:17,329
off line. But we are

1879
01:10:17,329 --> 01:10:19,729
maintaining them. We are

1880
01:10:20,399 --> 01:10:21,834
upgrading them by we I mean,

1881
01:10:21,834 --> 01:10:23,702
the city majority that there's

1882
01:10:23,702 --> 01:10:24,703
only 2 of them that are county

1883
01:10:24,703 --> 01:10:27,103
maintenance. Great. Thank you.

1884
01:10:28,730 --> 01:10:29,308
Let's move to the Thank you.

1885
01:10:29,308 --> 01:10:30,843
We have a motion made by

1886
01:10:30,843 --> 01:10:33,243
Councilmember bound second by

1887
01:10:33,947 --> 01:10:34,613
Chair Wang to approve the

1888
01:10:34,613 --> 01:10:35,314
recommendations of stop and

1889
01:10:35,314 --> 01:10:37,249
support this item to the JULY

1890
01:10:37,249 --> 01:10:37,750
20 per City Council agenda on

1891
01:10:37,750 --> 01:10:39,750
$0.10, honorable

1892
01:10:43,889 --> 01:10:46,289
councilmembers. And Cher. Wang

1893
01:10:49,157 --> 01:10:49,334
I thank you. Item passes with

1894
01:10:49,334 --> 01:10:49,506
3 eyes when excused by to port

1895
01:10:49,506 --> 01:10:52,865
this item to the JULY 21st

1896
01:10:52,865 --> 01:10:53,966
City Council agenda on consent

1897
01:10:53,966 --> 01:10:54,600
reading in item for adopt a

1898
01:10:54,600 --> 01:10:55,267
resolution accepting the

1899
01:10:55,267 --> 01:10:57,267
Department of Violence

1900
01:10:59,304 --> 01:11:01,206
Prevention's 2026 apricots

1901
01:11:01,206 --> 01:11:02,541
annual report and approving

1902
01:11:02,541 --> 01:11:03,108
ended policy has approved by

1903
01:11:03,108 --> 01:11:05,108
the Privacy Advisory

1904
01:11:06,879 --> 01:11:07,579
Commission on JUNE 4th, 2026

1905
01:11:07,579 --> 01:11:08,247
and there are 4 speakers that

1906
01:11:08,247 --> 01:11:11,847
signed up to speak on this

1907
01:11:12,384 --> 01:11:15,984
item. Go ahead and take away

1908
01:11:16,880 --> 01:11:17,189
the floor is yours. Thank you.

1909
01:11:17,189 --> 01:11:18,658
Good evening, Councilmembers.

1910
01:11:18,658 --> 01:11:19,391
Jenny Lind she deputy chief of

1911
01:11:19,391 --> 01:11:21,493
grants programs and evaluation

1912
01:11:21,493 --> 01:11:22,194
for the Department Violence

1913
01:11:22,194 --> 01:11:25,194
Prevention and Wait for most

1914
01:11:27,499 --> 01:11:29,635
lines. Great. So I am

1915
01:11:29,635 --> 01:11:30,369
presenting on our apricot

1916
01:11:30,369 --> 01:11:32,769
3.60, annual report and update

1917
01:11:34,406 --> 01:11:37,242
it. Use policy. High-level pre

1918
01:11:37,242 --> 01:11:38,343
cut 3.60 Is a cloud-based

1919
01:11:38,343 --> 01:11:39,878
system developed by on Terra

1920
01:11:39,878 --> 01:11:40,646
for use by social service

1921
01:11:40,646 --> 01:11:42,614
providers to track service

1922
01:11:42,614 --> 01:11:44,883
delivery and grant management

1923
01:11:44,883 --> 01:11:45,484
tasks. This is the system that

1924
01:11:45,484 --> 01:11:47,484
the Department Violence

1925
01:11:47,720 --> 01:11:49,855
Prevention uses for our own

1926
01:11:49,855 --> 01:11:51,423
internal direct service staff

1927
01:11:51,423 --> 01:11:52,124
and also for the agencies that

1928
01:11:52,124 --> 01:11:55,124
we fund to enter information

1929
01:11:56,595 --> 01:11:57,296
about service delivery. The

1930
01:11:57,296 --> 01:11:59,565
system was first approved by

1931
01:11:59,565 --> 01:12:01,965
the Privacy Advisory Committee

1932
01:12:03,469 --> 01:12:04,169
Shun and City Council JULY of

1933
01:12:04,169 --> 01:12:04,870
2022, it was then customized

1934
01:12:04,870 --> 01:12:07,706
and implemented by the dpp in

1935
01:12:07,706 --> 01:12:10,106
JANUARY of 2023. Replacing our

1936
01:12:10,175 --> 01:12:12,478
old System City's ban. And

1937
01:12:12,478 --> 01:12:13,512
since then, we've had annual

1938
01:12:13,512 --> 01:12:14,380
reports and use policies

1939
01:12:14,380 --> 01:12:16,780
approved by the Privacy

1940
01:12:17,349 --> 01:12:18,417
Advisory Commission. Every

1941
01:12:18,417 --> 01:12:20,817
JUNE since JUNE 2024. 2025 and

1942
01:12:21,887 --> 01:12:24,287
most recently 2026. The system

1943
01:12:25,958 --> 01:12:27,594
has multiple uses for direct

1944
01:12:27,594 --> 01:12:28,260
service staff both employed by

1945
01:12:28,260 --> 01:12:30,662
the dpp and by the agencies

1946
01:12:30,662 --> 01:12:34,566
that we fund the system can be

1947
01:12:34,566 --> 01:12:36,468
used to track enrollment

1948
01:12:36,468 --> 01:12:37,169
service, engagement milestones

1949
01:12:37,169 --> 01:12:39,569
and outcomes for individuals

1950
01:12:40,730 --> 01:12:40,807
who are engaged services and

1951
01:12:40,807 --> 01:12:43,410
then additionally for agencies

1952
01:12:43,410 --> 01:12:44,309
that deliver group level

1953
01:12:44,309 --> 01:12:46,309
services, it tracks

1954
01:12:47,146 --> 01:12:47,846
information such as

1955
01:12:47,846 --> 01:12:49,846
attendance, duration content

1956
01:12:51,717 --> 01:12:53,180
of group services. For

1957
01:12:53,180 --> 01:12:54,787
supervisory staff again within

1958
01:12:54,787 --> 01:12:55,454
the dp and our friend of

1959
01:12:55,454 --> 01:12:57,890
agencies. They can use the

1960
01:12:57,890 --> 01:12:58,690
system to review the services

1961
01:12:58,690 --> 01:12:59,358
that are being delivered by

1962
01:12:59,358 --> 01:13:00,793
the individuals. They

1963
01:13:00,793 --> 01:13:01,727
supervise to monitor service

1964
01:13:01,727 --> 01:13:04,127
delivery and track performance

1965
01:13:08,367 --> 01:13:09,234
metrics. Grant Management

1966
01:13:09,234 --> 01:13:10,469
staff both within the dp and

1967
01:13:10,469 --> 01:13:12,604
are funded agencies use the

1968
01:13:12,604 --> 01:13:13,305
system to track budgets been

1969
01:13:13,305 --> 01:13:14,106
down. So we have reports that

1970
01:13:14,106 --> 01:13:16,106
are automatically generated

1971
01:13:17,209 --> 01:13:19,144
every quarter to to show how

1972
01:13:19,144 --> 01:13:20,279
expenses are being spent

1973
01:13:20,279 --> 01:13:22,114
various categories. It's how

1974
01:13:22,114 --> 01:13:24,149
we track progress on contract

1975
01:13:24,149 --> 01:13:25,284
deliverables that we also have

1976
01:13:25,284 --> 01:13:25,985
a standard report for every

1977
01:13:25,985 --> 01:13:27,753
contract that's based on the

1978
01:13:27,753 --> 01:13:29,354
service deliverables in scopes

1979
01:13:29,354 --> 01:13:30,222
of work. And it shows exactly

1980
01:13:30,222 --> 01:13:32,910
where agencies are supposed to

1981
01:13:32,910 --> 01:13:35,910
be every quarter and then

1982
01:13:36,729 --> 01:13:37,930
where they actually are. And

1983
01:13:37,930 --> 01:13:40,320
then we use it to receive and

1984
01:13:40,320 --> 01:13:40,733
process quarterly invoices. So

1985
01:13:40,733 --> 01:13:43,133
every quarter agencies input

1986
01:13:43,869 --> 01:13:44,503
information about what they

1987
01:13:44,503 --> 01:13:45,170
did a quarter about their

1988
01:13:45,170 --> 01:13:45,838
expenses, we review all the

1989
01:13:45,838 --> 01:13:48,238
information. That's how we

1990
01:13:49,675 --> 01:13:50,909
process voices. A few select

1991
01:13:50,909 --> 01:13:53,579
program staff within the dp

1992
01:13:53,579 --> 01:13:55,647
Use the system to coordinate

1993
01:13:55,647 --> 01:13:56,248
services between agencies and

1994
01:13:56,248 --> 01:13:56,949
support Effective

1995
01:13:56,949 --> 01:13:57,516
implementations of example of

1996
01:13:57,516 --> 01:13:59,916
this is the violence

1997
01:14:01,186 --> 01:14:01,720
interruption services. We fund

1998
01:14:01,720 --> 01:14:02,354
for community-based

1999
01:14:02,354 --> 01:14:03,322
organizations to deliver

2000
01:14:03,322 --> 01:14:05,322
violence interruption in

2001
01:14:05,491 --> 01:14:06,759
services in Oakland. But the

2002
01:14:06,759 --> 01:14:08,127
deep he also has internal the

2003
01:14:08,127 --> 01:14:09,228
eyes to kind of quarterback

2004
01:14:09,228 --> 01:14:12,828
that work. And so the ability

2005
01:14:13,310 --> 01:14:14,320
for them to see updates that

2006
01:14:14,320 --> 01:14:14,666
are being entered by the

2007
01:14:14,666 --> 01:14:15,334
various agencies is very

2008
01:14:15,334 --> 01:14:17,734
helpful in coordinating the

2009
01:14:19,371 --> 01:14:20,873
response. And then lastly, due

2010
01:14:20,873 --> 01:14:21,907
to an evaluation staff use the

2011
01:14:21,907 --> 01:14:24,307
system to summarize service

2012
01:14:25,210 --> 01:14:25,978
delivery information for

2013
01:14:25,978 --> 01:14:28,378
reports to counsel to

2014
01:14:29,715 --> 01:14:30,816
commissions to funders to

2015
01:14:30,816 --> 01:14:31,483
monitor consent form

2016
01:14:31,483 --> 01:14:33,483
completion and eligibility

2017
01:14:34,219 --> 01:14:35,870
criteria. So we have standard

2018
01:14:35,870 --> 01:14:36,922
eligibility criteria for gun

2019
01:14:36,922 --> 01:14:38,590
violence services, for

2020
01:14:38,590 --> 01:14:39,324
instance, or one data

2021
01:14:39,324 --> 01:14:42,324
specialist make sure that that

2022
01:14:42,494 --> 01:14:43,128
those criteria being met and

2023
01:14:43,128 --> 01:14:43,862
then of their data entry

2024
01:14:43,862 --> 01:14:46,262
errors, there's regular checks

2025
01:14:49,301 --> 01:14:51,270
on that. For the annual year

2026
01:14:51,270 --> 01:14:53,572
of 2025, the system was used

2027
01:14:53,572 --> 01:14:55,972
by approximately 36 staff from

2028
01:14:56,410 --> 01:14:58,441
the dp and 170 Community-based

2029
01:14:59,511 --> 01:15:01,911
organizations. There were also

2030
01:15:01,914 --> 01:15:02,514
individual records entered for

2031
01:15:02,514 --> 01:15:04,514
about 2400 individuals.

2032
01:15:07,186 --> 01:15:09,354
Participants in services. In

2033
01:15:09,354 --> 01:15:11,256
terms of data sharing de

2034
01:15:11,256 --> 01:15:12,157
identified data for all

2035
01:15:12,157 --> 01:15:13,325
participants and then

2036
01:15:13,325 --> 01:15:14,827
personally identifiable

2037
01:15:14,827 --> 01:15:15,661
information, which means name

2038
01:15:15,661 --> 01:15:16,395
and date of birth for

2039
01:15:16,395 --> 01:15:18,795
individuals who provided their

2040
01:15:19,732 --> 01:15:21,567
affirmative consent shared

2041
01:15:21,567 --> 01:15:24,169
with the same party in 2

2042
01:15:24,169 --> 01:15:26,305
different occasions. One was

2043
01:15:26,305 --> 01:15:28,273
Urban Institute for their

2044
01:15:28,273 --> 01:15:28,941
evaluation of Measure z funded

2045
01:15:28,941 --> 01:15:29,675
services and one was Urban

2046
01:15:29,675 --> 01:15:32,750
Institute for their evaluation

2047
01:15:33,813 --> 01:15:35,948
of a state grant that we have.

2048
01:15:35,948 --> 01:15:36,849
We have had no complaints or

2049
01:15:36,849 --> 01:15:37,649
concerns raised about the

2050
01:15:37,649 --> 01:15:39,649
system regarding its

2051
01:15:41,420 --> 01:15:42,521
protection of civil rights are

2052
01:15:42,521 --> 01:15:43,589
civil liberties. And our data

2053
01:15:43,589 --> 01:15:44,590
analyst is in frequent

2054
01:15:44,590 --> 01:15:46,558
communication with grantees

2055
01:15:46,558 --> 01:15:47,893
about a number of things. And

2056
01:15:47,893 --> 01:15:48,627
when he receives feedback on

2057
01:15:48,627 --> 01:15:49,294
how ways to improve the system

2058
01:15:49,294 --> 01:15:50,562
are additional things that

2059
01:15:50,562 --> 01:15:53,562
they want. Clark did. We're

2060
01:15:54,266 --> 01:15:54,967
happy to make those changes or

2061
01:15:54,967 --> 01:15:55,634
develop reports that would be

2062
01:15:55,634 --> 01:15:58,634
helpful for them to monitor

2063
01:16:00,939 --> 01:16:01,673
service delivery. Service

2064
01:16:01,673 --> 01:16:03,709
delivery. Information in a pre

2065
01:16:03,709 --> 01:16:04,376
cut is limited to high-level

2066
01:16:04,376 --> 01:16:06,776
information. So it's number

2067
01:16:08,280 --> 01:16:10,215
and duration of contacts and

2068
01:16:10,215 --> 01:16:12,170
service outcomes personally,

2069
01:16:12,170 --> 01:16:12,718
information is only required

2070
01:16:12,718 --> 01:16:14,887
for adults who are receiving

2071
01:16:14,887 --> 01:16:16,210
services related to gun

2072
01:16:16,210 --> 01:16:19,210
violence. It is not required

2073
01:16:19,558 --> 01:16:20,260
for youth at all or for

2074
01:16:20,260 --> 01:16:20,793
individuals who are receiving

2075
01:16:20,793 --> 01:16:22,793
services related to

2076
01:16:25,831 --> 01:16:26,532
gender-based violence. This is

2077
01:16:26,532 --> 01:16:28,867
a high-level overview of the

2078
01:16:28,867 --> 01:16:29,568
reason the city breakdown of

2079
01:16:29,568 --> 01:16:30,769
individuals who are entered a

2080
01:16:30,769 --> 01:16:33,169
neighbor caught being served

2081
01:16:33,405 --> 01:16:35,140
by Dbpr gdp, funded

2082
01:16:35,140 --> 01:16:35,841
organization services. If you

2083
01:16:35,841 --> 01:16:36,475
take away the missing, these

2084
01:16:36,475 --> 01:16:38,310
percentages are actually

2085
01:16:38,310 --> 01:16:39,110
slightly higher. Still, the

2086
01:16:39,110 --> 01:16:41,411
majority of individuals being

2087
01:16:41,680 --> 01:16:44,800
served are African-American or

2088
01:16:44,616 --> 01:16:45,784
Latino that closely mirrors

2089
01:16:45,784 --> 01:16:46,552
the breakdown of recent city

2090
01:16:46,552 --> 01:16:48,530
for individuals impacted by

2091
01:16:48,530 --> 01:16:48,787
gun violence and domestic

2092
01:16:48,787 --> 01:16:50,255
violence and commercial sexual

2093
01:16:50,255 --> 01:16:50,889
exploitation in Oakland, which

2094
01:16:50,889 --> 01:16:53,889
is what we're charged to

2095
01:16:56,228 --> 01:16:58,300
reduce. We regularly review

2096
01:16:58,300 --> 01:16:59,332
There have been not been any

2097
01:16:59,332 --> 01:17:01,332
violations or potential

2098
01:17:01,367 --> 01:17:02,101
violations of use policy to

2099
01:17:02,101 --> 01:17:04,203
date that we're aware of. Also

2100
01:17:04,203 --> 01:17:05,170
been no data breaches are

2101
01:17:05,170 --> 01:17:06,739
unauthorized access. And we

2102
01:17:06,739 --> 01:17:07,372
have had no public records

2103
01:17:07,372 --> 01:17:09,772
request pertaining to the

2104
01:17:13,112 --> 01:17:14,790
system. The annual cost of the

2105
01:17:14,790 --> 01:17:16,382
system in upcoming fiscal year

2106
01:17:16,382 --> 01:17:17,349
is $125,000. Approximately

2107
01:17:17,349 --> 01:17:19,251
half of that will come from

2108
01:17:19,251 --> 01:17:20,419
our general purpose fund. And

2109
01:17:20,419 --> 01:17:21,820
then we try to write in a

2110
01:17:21,820 --> 01:17:22,554
portion of that into every

2111
01:17:22,554 --> 01:17:23,188
extra grant that we got about.

2112
01:17:23,188 --> 01:17:26,788
Half of that is funded by

2113
01:17:30,662 --> 01:17:31,730
external grants. In terms of

2114
01:17:31,730 --> 01:17:32,598
efficacy. Apricot 3.60,

2115
01:17:32,598 --> 01:17:35,598
invaluable in our work. In

2116
01:17:35,667 --> 01:17:37,369
many ways, it's allowed us to

2117
01:17:37,369 --> 01:17:38,700
ensure alignment with best

2118
01:17:38,700 --> 01:17:38,670
practices, specifically ready

2119
01:17:38,670 --> 01:17:40,670
relating to cease-fire

2120
01:17:42,741 --> 01:17:43,575
lifeline. So our Chief Holly

2121
01:17:43,575 --> 01:17:44,810
Joshi, our deputy Chief

2122
01:17:44,810 --> 01:17:47,210
Danielle Medina, who oversee

2123
01:17:48,280 --> 01:17:48,947
all of that word they receive

2124
01:17:48,947 --> 01:17:50,315
weekly performance reports

2125
01:17:50,315 --> 01:17:51,316
where they're able to see

2126
01:17:51,316 --> 01:17:51,884
exactly what all of the life

2127
01:17:51,884 --> 01:17:52,518
coaches and violence

2128
01:17:52,518 --> 01:17:54,753
Interrupters are doing to

2129
01:17:54,753 --> 01:17:55,487
implement the model. And sure,

2130
01:17:55,487 --> 01:17:56,221
but they're having the high

2131
01:17:56,221 --> 01:17:59,221
touch plants that are required

2132
01:18:00,292 --> 01:18:01,360
to achieve impact. It's also

2133
01:18:01,360 --> 01:18:03,228
how we as we discussed in

2134
01:18:03,228 --> 01:18:04,129
prior meetings, how we hold

2135
01:18:04,129 --> 01:18:06,432
CEOs accountable it, how we

2136
01:18:06,432 --> 01:18:07,660
track their performance

2137
01:18:07,660 --> 01:18:07,733
metrics to make sure that

2138
01:18:07,733 --> 01:18:08,434
their meeting, what we said

2139
01:18:08,434 --> 01:18:11,470
that they were going to do in

2140
01:18:11,470 --> 01:18:13,539
their scope support. It's how

2141
01:18:13,539 --> 01:18:14,406
we coordinate service tear. It

2142
01:18:14,406 --> 01:18:15,740
supports rather coordinating

2143
01:18:15,740 --> 01:18:16,108
service delivery within the

2144
01:18:16,108 --> 01:18:18,508
group strategy. As I

2145
01:18:18,644 --> 01:18:19,278
mentioned, specifically around

2146
01:18:19,278 --> 01:18:21,278
violence interruption. It

2147
01:18:21,914 --> 01:18:24,914
allows us to easily summarized

2148
01:18:25,751 --> 01:18:26,418
share data with it. Groups

2149
01:18:26,418 --> 01:18:28,818
like City Council Oversight

2150
01:18:28,887 --> 01:18:30,122
bodies, Public funders and

2151
01:18:30,122 --> 01:18:33,722
then, of course, it is the

2152
01:18:33,792 --> 01:18:34,526
source of data that we use for

2153
01:18:34,526 --> 01:18:35,194
impact evaluations. So for the

2154
01:18:35,194 --> 01:18:35,861
measure z funded evaluation

2155
01:18:35,861 --> 01:18:38,964
evidence to it, this is the

2156
01:18:38,964 --> 01:18:39,631
source of the data for any

2157
01:18:39,631 --> 01:18:40,332
future evaluations that are

2158
01:18:40,332 --> 01:18:43,332
funded measure. This is where

2159
01:18:45,604 --> 01:18:46,672
the data will come from. And

2160
01:18:46,672 --> 01:18:47,306
then lastly, we're proposing a

2161
01:18:47,306 --> 01:18:49,341
one amendment to the use

2162
01:18:49,341 --> 01:18:52,341
policy this year. The current

2163
01:18:53,110 --> 01:18:53,846
use policy states that.

2164
01:18:53,846 --> 01:18:55,214
Personally identify well

2165
01:18:55,214 --> 01:18:56,582
information again, name and

2166
01:18:56,582 --> 01:18:57,483
date of birth is not entered

2167
01:18:57,483 --> 01:18:59,151
for individuals receiving

2168
01:18:59,151 --> 01:19:00,119
services related to

2169
01:19:00,119 --> 01:19:00,853
gender-based violence. We

2170
01:19:00,853 --> 01:19:02,554
would like to just change that

2171
01:19:02,554 --> 01:19:03,555
language to say is not

2172
01:19:03,555 --> 01:19:06,555
required. We would like to

2173
01:19:07,260 --> 01:19:08,260
just as we do for youth, give

2174
01:19:08,260 --> 01:19:10,162
them the opportunity to opt

2175
01:19:10,162 --> 01:19:11,964
into sharing data because it's

2176
01:19:11,964 --> 01:19:13,799
so powerful and hopeful for

2177
01:19:13,799 --> 01:19:14,433
evaluation purposes. That was

2178
01:19:14,433 --> 01:19:15,602
one of the findings from

2179
01:19:15,602 --> 01:19:17,636
Measure z evaluators was that

2180
01:19:17,636 --> 01:19:20,360
they simply didn't have

2181
01:19:20,706 --> 01:19:21,640
enough. They didn't have data

2182
01:19:21,640 --> 01:19:22,574
at the individual level to be

2183
01:19:22,574 --> 01:19:24,209
able to do impact evaluation

2184
01:19:24,209 --> 01:19:25,711
for gender-based violence

2185
01:19:25,711 --> 01:19:26,512
services. So with this change,

2186
01:19:26,512 --> 01:19:27,212
we would simply be giving

2187
01:19:27,212 --> 01:19:29,314
people the opportunity to say

2188
01:19:29,314 --> 01:19:31,116
yes or now, of course, they

2189
01:19:31,116 --> 01:19:31,784
can always ristaino and still

2190
01:19:31,784 --> 01:19:34,784
services. There would be no

2191
01:19:35,287 --> 01:19:35,954
bearing on not. And that

2192
01:19:35,954 --> 01:19:37,954
concludes the presentation.

2193
01:19:38,524 --> 01:19:41,524
I'm happy to take questions.

2194
01:19:43,280 --> 01:19:45,297
Council member Brown. Not

2195
01:19:45,297 --> 01:19:46,310
necessarily question, but more

2196
01:19:46,310 --> 01:19:48,867
of a comment just in reading

2197
01:19:48,867 --> 01:19:51,770
and reviewing the report. He

2198
01:19:51,770 --> 01:19:54,770
seems very clear that program

2199
01:19:55,574 --> 01:19:59,174
and like the system is working

2200
01:19:59,344 --> 01:20:00,120
very well. And it also has a

2201
01:20:00,120 --> 01:20:03,449
clear nexis to win. You all

2202
01:20:03,449 --> 01:20:04,983
come back and share. Hey, how

2203
01:20:04,983 --> 01:20:06,685
are these community-based

2204
01:20:06,685 --> 01:20:08,620
organizations doing with the

2205
01:20:08,620 --> 01:20:10,823
program services? And it also

2206
01:20:10,823 --> 01:20:11,356
sounds like maybe we should

2207
01:20:11,356 --> 01:20:12,570
duplicated in other

2208
01:20:12,570 --> 01:20:13,580
departments, ku that utilize

2209
01:20:13,580 --> 01:20:15,461
it as well because it just

2210
01:20:15,461 --> 01:20:19,610
really seems like that it a

2211
01:20:19,364 --> 01:20:20,733
It's a great tool to really

2212
01:20:20,733 --> 01:20:21,433
collect the data and get the

2213
01:20:21,433 --> 01:20:22,101
clear feedback. But thank you

2214
01:20:22,101 --> 01:20:24,436
so much for that report.

2215
01:20:24,436 --> 01:20:25,300
Really appreciate it. And

2216
01:20:25,300 --> 01:20:27,339
through the chair to

2217
01:20:27,339 --> 01:20:30,339
councilmember and just to add,

2218
01:20:30,776 --> 01:20:31,443
it is a great tool. It's far

2219
01:20:31,443 --> 01:20:33,512
superior to the former tool

2220
01:20:33,512 --> 01:20:35,547
that we're using and allows us

2221
01:20:35,547 --> 01:20:37,820
to again, not only track that

2222
01:20:37,820 --> 01:20:38,117
he did that create all kinds

2223
01:20:38,117 --> 01:20:38,851
of customizable reports that

2224
01:20:38,851 --> 01:20:41,530
are really helpful for

2225
01:20:41,530 --> 01:20:43,530
implementation. One thing

2226
01:20:43,155 --> 01:20:44,223
that's very exciting is that

2227
01:20:44,223 --> 01:20:45,891
we were able to about a year

2228
01:20:45,891 --> 01:20:46,558
and a half ago. Pouch are

2229
01:20:46,558 --> 01:20:48,558
former technical assistance

2230
01:20:49,228 --> 01:20:49,862
provider from Terre and he's

2231
01:20:49,862 --> 01:20:50,462
now an employee of the

2232
01:20:50,462 --> 01:20:52,462
Department of Violence

2233
01:20:54,566 --> 01:20:55,267
Prevention. So we have. Lot of

2234
01:20:55,267 --> 01:20:57,870
this recipe to do really cool

2235
01:20:57,870 --> 01:20:59,204
things if for some reason,

2236
01:20:59,204 --> 01:21:00,939
another department adopt the

2237
01:21:00,939 --> 01:21:02,274
technology would be happy to

2238
01:21:02,274 --> 01:21:03,909
lend his expertise. That's

2239
01:21:03,909 --> 01:21:06,440
phenomenal. Thank all. Make a

2240
01:21:06,440 --> 01:21:07,646
motion to move the item well

2241
01:21:07,646 --> 01:21:08,280
as good. Well done. What a way

2242
01:21:08,280 --> 01:21:10,680
to fill are Councilmember

2243
01:21:13,786 --> 01:21:15,888
Houston. To chair what to wear

2244
01:21:15,888 --> 01:21:18,624
using prior to this the one

2245
01:21:18,624 --> 01:21:21,624
that you're using prior? How's

2246
01:21:21,694 --> 01:21:22,294
it being done before threw the

2247
01:21:22,294 --> 01:21:22,961
chair to councilmember

2248
01:21:22,961 --> 01:21:25,361
Houston. We're easing city

2249
01:21:26,732 --> 01:21:27,399
spam. It's still needs believe

2250
01:21:27,399 --> 01:21:30,399
by the Department of Human

2251
01:21:31,603 --> 01:21:35,203
Services. Was not. We were not

2252
01:21:35,407 --> 01:21:37,807
able to enter personally

2253
01:21:38,310 --> 01:21:40,379
identify or like individual

2254
01:21:40,379 --> 01:21:41,800
level data from the

2255
01:21:41,800 --> 01:21:43,800
community-based organizations

2256
01:21:43,215 --> 01:21:45,250
that we fund and then us

2257
01:21:45,250 --> 01:21:45,851
people to summarize bought

2258
01:21:45,851 --> 01:21:46,485
into deliverables and 2

2259
01:21:46,485 --> 01:21:49,485
reports that were able to

2260
01:21:51,757 --> 01:21:52,725
easily see. So the agencies

2261
01:21:52,725 --> 01:21:53,392
were instant some entering

2262
01:21:53,392 --> 01:21:54,930
already summarize data. So

2263
01:21:54,930 --> 01:21:54,793
that would be boxes that say

2264
01:21:54,793 --> 01:21:57,793
how many individuals that use

2265
01:21:58,697 --> 01:21:59,331
or rather than entries of

2266
01:21:59,331 --> 01:22:00,265
individuals served being

2267
01:22:00,265 --> 01:22:01,366
summarizing reports that we

2268
01:22:01,366 --> 01:22:03,569
can see. It gives us a little

2269
01:22:03,569 --> 01:22:04,203
bit more accountability. And

2270
01:22:04,203 --> 01:22:06,603
also support with service

2271
01:22:15,280 --> 01:22:15,914
coordination. And then before

2272
01:22:15,914 --> 01:22:19,514
I second the item, I just

2273
01:22:19,952 --> 01:22:22,952
have. Of wealth. One comment,

2274
01:22:23,322 --> 01:22:24,256
which is I do agree with my

2275
01:22:24,256 --> 01:22:27,256
colleague. It sounds like this

2276
01:22:27,926 --> 01:22:28,627
system has some use, say, for

2277
01:22:28,627 --> 01:22:31,270
example, human services that

2278
01:22:32,698 --> 01:22:33,866
we know has challenges around.

2279
01:22:33,866 --> 01:22:35,702
Reimbursements that does a

2280
01:22:35,702 --> 01:22:36,435
system actually support the

2281
01:22:36,435 --> 01:22:38,835
reimbursement of the providers

2282
01:22:39,238 --> 01:22:41,974
are. This is simply sort

2283
01:22:41,974 --> 01:22:43,974
tracking performance metrics.

2284
01:22:45,770 --> 01:22:45,811
We use it to prepare the

2285
01:22:45,811 --> 01:22:48,811
invoice that is submitted into

2286
01:22:49,140 --> 01:22:50,160
the ap portal. So the ap

2287
01:22:50,160 --> 01:22:50,649
portal is still the system

2288
01:22:50,649 --> 01:22:52,584
that is used to actually

2289
01:22:52,584 --> 01:22:55,521
process the invoice and issue

2290
01:22:55,521 --> 01:22:56,550
payment. But we use this to

2291
01:22:56,550 --> 01:22:57,423
prepare all of the

2292
01:22:57,423 --> 01:22:59,823
documentation that goes into

2293
01:23:00,459 --> 01:23:01,560
the ap portal, including the

2294
01:23:01,560 --> 01:23:02,261
itemized spend on of

2295
01:23:02,261 --> 01:23:04,630
expenditures and the summary

2296
01:23:04,630 --> 01:23:06,630
deliverables achieved. Okay.

2297
01:23:06,732 --> 01:23:08,734
Interesting. And then just

2298
01:23:08,734 --> 01:23:09,435
with regards to the amendment,

2299
01:23:09,435 --> 01:23:11,570
I'm sure that you thought of

2300
01:23:11,570 --> 01:23:15,707
this, but I just would like to

2301
01:23:15,707 --> 01:23:17,509
vet this is given, of course,

2302
01:23:17,509 --> 01:23:18,644
the data special data privacy

2303
01:23:18,644 --> 01:23:19,211
needs for like a domestic

2304
01:23:19,211 --> 01:23:20,479
violence victim or a

2305
01:23:20,479 --> 01:23:22,479
trafficking victim. What

2306
01:23:24,583 --> 01:23:25,651
privacy controls are privacy.

2307
01:23:25,651 --> 01:23:27,586
Protections are included in

2308
01:23:27,586 --> 01:23:31,186
the system to ensure that that

2309
01:23:32,250 --> 01:23:34,461
the data can be misused so.

2310
01:23:34,461 --> 01:23:35,160
The data are only access.

2311
01:23:35,160 --> 01:23:38,564
Every user of the system has

2312
01:23:38,564 --> 01:23:40,564
very specialized permissions.

2313
01:23:41,600 --> 01:23:42,301
So any staff member to its

2314
01:23:42,301 --> 01:23:43,350
community based organization,

2315
01:23:43,350 --> 01:23:43,836
for instance, can only access

2316
01:23:43,836 --> 01:23:46,973
data that they enter. Not that

2317
01:23:46,973 --> 01:23:49,740
anyone else. And jurors. And

2318
01:23:49,740 --> 01:23:50,943
that's the case for everyone.

2319
01:23:50,943 --> 01:23:51,643
The exception to that is the

2320
01:23:51,643 --> 01:23:52,244
data specialist who works for

2321
01:23:52,244 --> 01:23:54,680
the dp and myself have

2322
01:23:54,680 --> 01:23:56,382
slightly broader credentials.

2323
01:23:56,382 --> 01:23:57,150
But for the most part,

2324
01:23:57,150 --> 01:23:57,750
individuals to access the

2325
01:23:57,750 --> 01:24:00,219
system only have access to the

2326
01:24:00,219 --> 01:24:03,219
data that they enter. Somewhat

2327
01:24:03,822 --> 01:24:04,490
related is in terms of

2328
01:24:04,490 --> 01:24:06,890
providing consent for their

2329
01:24:06,925 --> 01:24:08,930
personally identifiable

2330
01:24:08,930 --> 01:24:09,395
information and to be They've

2331
01:24:09,395 --> 01:24:11,130
they provide that can send it

2332
01:24:11,130 --> 01:24:11,964
is not by any means required

2333
01:24:11,964 --> 01:24:14,990
as part of service delivery

2334
01:24:14,990 --> 01:24:15,330
and that complies with the

2335
01:24:15,330 --> 01:24:16,469
ball. But expectations, which

2336
01:24:16,469 --> 01:24:18,203
is that you give individuals

2337
01:24:18,203 --> 01:24:18,838
the ability to consent or not

2338
01:24:18,838 --> 01:24:21,838
and don't make service is

2339
01:24:23,208 --> 01:24:23,842
contingent on that. So those

2340
01:24:23,842 --> 01:24:26,242
protections are in place.

2341
01:24:31,250 --> 01:24:31,950
Okay. Great. Thank Calling in

2342
01:24:31,950 --> 01:24:33,385
the Navy decided to speak on

2343
01:24:33,385 --> 01:24:34,860
item number 4 in a particular

2344
01:24:34,860 --> 01:24:36,855
order. You can come up to the

2345
01:24:36,855 --> 01:24:37,656
podium state. Your name for

2346
01:24:37,656 --> 01:24:38,290
the record. Muzzy Indigo Jesse

2347
01:24:38,290 --> 01:24:41,290
Rose more outside Ala and

2348
01:24:43,295 --> 01:24:45,397
Blair Beekman. Hi, Jessi rose.

2349
01:24:45,397 --> 01:24:46,465
More on the vp provided a well

2350
01:24:46,465 --> 01:24:48,300
written report compared to

2351
01:24:48,300 --> 01:24:49,635
opd. He did not provide a well

2352
01:24:49,635 --> 01:24:50,335
written report. We got one

2353
01:24:50,335 --> 01:24:51,937
minute to speak on this item

2354
01:24:51,937 --> 01:24:54,907
where per item 8. We also got

2355
01:24:54,907 --> 01:24:55,574
one minute to speak on this

2356
01:24:55,574 --> 01:24:57,843
garbage. As I wrote a Brown

2357
01:24:57,843 --> 01:24:58,777
mentioned just that nonsense

2358
01:24:58,777 --> 01:25:02,977
that we had only one minute to

2359
01:25:03,215 --> 01:25:05,217
speak on this city council. 3

2360
01:25:05,217 --> 01:25:06,852
of the members of this body, 7

2361
01:25:06,852 --> 01:25:08,870
members of the city Council it

2362
01:25:08,870 --> 01:25:09,121
south. Look at opd, anything

2363
01:25:09,121 --> 01:25:11,924
it wants and its austerity and

2364
01:25:11,924 --> 01:25:13,892
means testing for everything

2365
01:25:13,892 --> 01:25:14,793
else. Wang as Councilmember

2366
01:25:14,793 --> 01:25:15,461
one, you're pertain to care

2367
01:25:15,461 --> 01:25:17,629
about data privacy when it

2368
01:25:17,629 --> 01:25:19,665
comes to take the vp. Why do

2369
01:25:19,665 --> 01:25:21,767
you issue that scene care

2370
01:25:21,767 --> 01:25:23,635
about privacy to flock, which

2371
01:25:23,635 --> 01:25:25,404
so many people came to speak

2372
01:25:25,404 --> 01:25:25,971
which is very clearly not

2373
01:25:25,971 --> 01:25:26,572
popular with your

2374
01:25:26,572 --> 01:25:28,572
constituents. And with

2375
01:25:29,775 --> 01:25:30,776
everybody in Oakland we have a

2376
01:25:30,776 --> 01:25:32,444
city council that serves

2377
01:25:32,444 --> 01:25:36,440
Piedmont landlords in the o p

2378
01:25:36,648 --> 01:25:37,249
o a we should be finding a

2379
01:25:37,249 --> 01:25:39,249
violence prevention and

2380
01:25:40,386 --> 01:25:41,120
safety. And you know, we need

2381
01:25:41,120 --> 01:25:44,720
a city council that doesn't do

2382
01:25:48,527 --> 01:25:50,927
austerity. So there's some

2383
01:25:51,830 --> 01:25:53,799
clarity. It needs to be

2384
01:25:53,799 --> 01:25:54,500
explain. The report says that

2385
01:25:54,500 --> 01:25:56,900
you have participant record.

2386
01:25:59,271 --> 01:26:01,271
It's. 2300. Program

2387
01:26:01,340 --> 01:26:03,340
enrollment. 2500. What's the

2388
01:26:04,443 --> 01:26:05,278
difference between the 2? When

2389
01:26:05,278 --> 01:26:06,945
you look, thank you for the

2390
01:26:06,945 --> 01:26:09,945
numbers of what you provided

2391
01:26:10,482 --> 01:26:12,482
services employment. 37.

2392
01:26:13,519 --> 01:26:14,219
Family and victim support 17.

2393
01:26:14,219 --> 01:26:16,522
And I'm not gonna be able to

2394
01:26:16,522 --> 01:26:17,156
go through all the numbers.

2395
01:26:17,156 --> 01:26:20,756
What I didn't see in the

2396
01:26:20,993 --> 01:26:21,693
report. And you got

2397
01:26:21,693 --> 01:26:23,693
distinguish between services

2398
01:26:24,663 --> 01:26:27,630
and referral. Referral means

2399
01:26:28,670 --> 01:26:29,735
you identify the Service mean

2400
01:26:29,735 --> 01:26:32,735
you actually got something in

2401
01:26:34,606 --> 01:26:35,307
terms of in need. But you

2402
01:26:35,307 --> 01:26:37,309
didn't identify anything that

2403
01:26:37,309 --> 01:26:39,309
accommodates trauma recovery.

2404
01:26:40,479 --> 01:26:42,879
Mental health care. Anger

2405
01:26:45,840 --> 01:26:46,151
management, drug treatment.

2406
01:26:46,151 --> 01:26:46,785
And those areas that need to

2407
01:26:46,785 --> 01:26:47,419
be addressed. When you're

2408
01:26:47,419 --> 01:26:50,419
talking about some of the

2409
01:26:58,263 --> 01:26:59,310
issues that thank you for your

2410
01:26:59,310 --> 01:26:59,765
comments, which into Zoom user

2411
01:26:59,765 --> 01:27:01,567
Blair. You can unmute yourself

2412
01:27:01,567 --> 01:27:04,567
and begin your comment. I

2413
01:27:05,738 --> 01:27:06,805
thank you big men. This is

2414
01:27:06,805 --> 01:27:08,307
another item that can serve a

2415
01:27:08,307 --> 01:27:10,707
cause, a person's wearing

2416
01:27:11,210 --> 01:27:13,610
council PRESIDENT Brings work

2417
01:27:13,612 --> 01:27:16,120
I mean, National Avenue.

2418
01:27:17,816 --> 01:27:18,884
Boulevard really well. It was

2419
01:27:18,884 --> 01:27:20,386
nice to hear. It was nice to

2420
01:27:20,386 --> 01:27:23,986
hear that this is really based

2421
01:27:24,256 --> 01:27:24,990
t v p Postal Service And not

2422
01:27:24,990 --> 01:27:26,358
so much law enforcement wasn't

2423
01:27:26,358 --> 01:27:29,270
too much mentioned. And that

2424
01:27:29,270 --> 01:27:31,730
was really helpful. It's up 8.

2425
01:27:31,730 --> 01:27:34,730
That's a resource play. You

2426
01:27:35,670 --> 01:27:35,768
know, the meetings we had on

2427
01:27:35,768 --> 01:27:37,768
the International Boulevard,

2428
01:27:39,171 --> 01:27:42,708
which is a few weeks ago The

2429
01:27:42,708 --> 01:27:43,375
people there, women there,

2430
01:27:43,375 --> 01:27:44,900
they need resources. That's

2431
01:27:44,900 --> 01:27:47,609
what was being fed by the

2432
01:27:47,679 --> 01:27:48,313
public. And it seems an item

2433
01:27:48,313 --> 01:27:50,713
that helps provide those

2434
01:27:51,500 --> 01:27:52,551
concepts, which is just dumb.

2435
01:27:52,551 --> 01:27:53,152
It's just the way to work or

2436
01:27:53,152 --> 01:27:55,552
system how we're going

2437
01:27:57,956 --> 01:27:58,624
understand this best. So. Is

2438
01:27:58,624 --> 01:27:59,691
nice to hear this item and

2439
01:27:59,691 --> 01:28:00,392
what its intentions can be.

2440
01:28:00,392 --> 01:28:03,829
Could look, we can live up to

2441
01:28:03,829 --> 01:28:04,797
his potential. Thank you.

2442
01:28:04,797 --> 01:28:05,464
Thank you for your comments

2443
01:28:05,464 --> 01:28:08,167
your name is called. Please

2444
01:28:08,167 --> 01:28:08,867
come up to the podium. Chair

2445
01:28:08,867 --> 01:28:11,837
at this time. All names have

2446
01:28:11,837 --> 01:28:14,740
been called. We can move to

2447
01:28:14,740 --> 01:28:15,441
the vote. Yes, yes, we have a

2448
01:28:15,441 --> 01:28:18,100
motion made by council member

2449
01:28:18,100 --> 01:28:19,111
Brown, seconded by chair. Want

2450
01:28:19,111 --> 01:28:19,812
to approve the recommendations

2451
01:28:19,812 --> 01:28:21,613
of stop and support this item

2452
01:28:21,613 --> 01:28:22,381
to the JULY 20 per City

2453
01:28:22,381 --> 01:28:25,381
Council agenda on consent on

2454
01:28:26,318 --> 01:28:28,718
rule councilmembers. Brown. I

2455
01:28:29,455 --> 01:28:30,689
buy I he and Cher Wang. I

2456
01:28:30,689 --> 01:28:31,423
thank you. Item 4 passes with

2457
01:28:31,423 --> 01:28:32,570
4. I support this item to the

2458
01:28:32,570 --> 01:28:34,457
JULY 20 for city Council.

2459
01:28:35,227 --> 01:28:35,861
Jenna, on consent reading in

2460
01:28:35,861 --> 01:28:37,529
item 5 adopt a resolution

2461
01:28:37,529 --> 01:28:39,529
authorizing the city

2462
01:28:39,565 --> 01:28:40,132
administrator to enter into

2463
01:28:40,132 --> 01:28:41,500
professional services

2464
01:28:41,500 --> 01:28:42,167
agreement. With the Bright

2465
01:28:42,167 --> 01:28:43,602
Research Group Inc for the

2466
01:28:43,602 --> 01:28:44,403
training and capacity-building

2467
01:28:44,403 --> 01:28:46,772
Services. But the Department

2468
01:28:46,772 --> 01:28:47,506
of Violence Prevention from

2469
01:28:47,506 --> 01:28:49,506
SEPTEMBER 1st 2026 through

2470
01:28:51,410 --> 01:28:52,411
DECEMBER 31st. 2028 por total

2471
01:28:52,411 --> 01:28:53,946
contract amount not to exceed

2472
01:28:53,946 --> 01:28:54,613
$513,000. And there are 3

2473
01:28:54,613 --> 01:28:57,613
speakers that signed up to

2474
01:29:00,285 --> 01:29:02,254
speak. Okay, great. I'll turn

2475
01:29:02,254 --> 01:29:03,455
the floor over to you. I am

2476
01:29:03,455 --> 01:29:04,156
know that we are about half an

2477
01:29:04,156 --> 01:29:06,125
hour left till we get to

2478
01:29:06,125 --> 01:29:07,926
08:00pm. So I would love to if

2479
01:29:07,926 --> 01:29:10,926
you can make it succinct.

2480
01:29:11,764 --> 01:29:12,698
Thank you. No problem. Good

2481
01:29:12,698 --> 01:29:13,766
evening. My name is Thomas and

2482
01:29:13,766 --> 01:29:14,400
the manager that reading euro

2483
01:29:14,400 --> 01:29:16,400
with Department violence

2484
01:29:20,506 --> 01:29:21,708
prevention. So I'm here today

2485
01:29:21,708 --> 01:29:22,841
to talk about adopting a

2486
01:29:22,841 --> 01:29:23,509
resolution award a contract of

2487
01:29:23,509 --> 01:29:25,509
$513,000 to bright research

2488
01:29:29,882 --> 01:29:30,549
groups. For training in the

2489
01:29:30,549 --> 01:29:31,450
past. The billions services

2490
01:29:31,450 --> 01:29:33,850
from SEPTEMBER first to

2491
01:29:38,991 --> 01:29:40,359
DECEMBER 31st. 2028. And

2492
01:29:40,359 --> 01:29:42,127
service Cp's mandate. As you

2493
01:29:42,127 --> 01:29:43,128
all know, our mandate is to

2494
01:29:43,128 --> 01:29:45,528
reduce gun violence, domestic

2495
01:29:46,310 --> 01:29:47,833
violence in commercial sexual

2496
01:29:47,833 --> 01:29:48,834
exploitation. And we do that

2497
01:29:48,834 --> 01:29:51,234
through Point Eric Service

2498
01:29:52,504 --> 01:29:53,605
staff within our community but

2499
01:29:53,605 --> 01:29:55,605
important meeting, community

2500
01:29:55,674 --> 01:29:56,308
services to deliver a violence

2501
01:29:56,308 --> 01:29:57,900
interruption services in

2502
01:29:57,900 --> 01:29:57,676
building the capacity of the

2503
01:29:57,676 --> 01:29:59,676
ecosystem of community

2504
01:30:05,251 --> 01:30:07,251
violence. Interventionists.

2505
01:30:07,286 --> 01:30:09,686
And 2024, the dp received 3.5

2506
01:30:09,988 --> 01:30:11,560
million dollars from Kaiser

2507
01:30:11,560 --> 01:30:14,560
part of the spending included

2508
01:30:14,493 --> 01:30:15,194
hired if a team manager myself

2509
01:30:15,194 --> 01:30:17,194
build maintain infrastructure

2510
01:30:17,663 --> 01:30:20,663
for chaining zvi workers. In

2511
01:30:20,866 --> 01:30:21,834
addition to that last year, dp

2512
01:30:21,834 --> 01:30:22,568
received investment from the

2513
01:30:22,568 --> 01:30:23,268
Greenlight Fund to develop and

2514
01:30:23,268 --> 01:30:25,668
launch Oakland Peace Academy.

2515
01:30:26,572 --> 01:30:27,306
This will be a fellowship for

2516
01:30:27,306 --> 01:30:28,607
community violence.

2517
01:30:28,607 --> 01:30:29,308
Interruption workers through a

2518
01:30:29,308 --> 01:30:31,308
partnership with everybody's

2519
01:30:34,813 --> 01:30:35,547
institute. The purpose of the

2520
01:30:35,547 --> 01:30:37,947
training bureau is essentially

2521
01:30:40,152 --> 01:30:43,389
to be a a for him to spend

2522
01:30:43,389 --> 01:30:44,156
professionalize and Clinton's

2523
01:30:44,156 --> 01:30:46,556
violent. The Raptors life

2524
01:30:47,693 --> 01:30:48,894
coaches a specialist, cetera.

2525
01:30:48,894 --> 01:30:50,829
And our vision is to do this

2526
01:30:50,829 --> 01:30:51,764
through leadership

2527
01:30:51,764 --> 01:30:53,764
development. The Oakland

2528
01:30:55,934 --> 01:30:57,603
Academy and through. Capacity

2529
01:30:57,603 --> 01:30:58,837
ability and that can be a

2530
01:30:58,837 --> 01:31:01,237
variety of things. Trainings

2531
01:31:02,775 --> 01:31:03,509
on harm reduction, self care,

2532
01:31:03,509 --> 01:31:05,909
dealing with compassion, Petit

2533
01:31:06,545 --> 01:31:08,280
supervision. Managing a budget

2534
01:31:08,280 --> 01:31:10,680
for organizational to just

2535
01:31:12,151 --> 01:31:13,419
capacity building for both

2536
01:31:13,419 --> 01:31:14,153
leaders within organizations

2537
01:31:14,153 --> 01:31:18,353
and within the ttp as well. As

2538
01:31:19,910 --> 01:31:19,925
for Derek Service, that. In

2539
01:31:19,925 --> 01:31:21,925
FEBRUARY, request for

2540
01:31:23,595 --> 01:31:26,310
qualifications win. Now for a

2541
01:31:26,310 --> 01:31:26,665
contractor to provide services

2542
01:31:26,665 --> 01:31:27,366
to support the change the

2543
01:31:27,366 --> 01:31:30,366
past, the building efforts of

2544
01:31:32,138 --> 01:31:33,439
the training hero. There were

2545
01:31:33,439 --> 01:31:35,340
5 submissions of 2 were passed

2546
01:31:35,340 --> 01:31:37,340
through disease procurement

2547
01:31:39,440 --> 01:31:39,645
process and of the 2 that pass

2548
01:31:39,645 --> 01:31:40,979
only one vendor, right.

2549
01:31:40,979 --> 01:31:41,647
Research group met all the

2550
01:31:41,647 --> 01:31:43,647
minimum qualifications that

2551
01:31:45,284 --> 01:31:48,253
were listed in the Rfq.

2552
01:31:48,253 --> 01:31:51,253
Research group has over a

2553
01:31:51,457 --> 01:31:51,990
decade of experience providing

2554
01:31:51,990 --> 01:31:53,990
services to various

2555
01:31:56,195 --> 01:31:57,396
departments within the city,

2556
01:31:57,396 --> 01:31:58,430
research capacity really

2557
01:31:58,430 --> 01:31:59,640
designed for that's owned by

2558
01:31:59,640 --> 01:32:01,433
women of color. And based

2559
01:32:01,433 --> 01:32:04,103
right here in Oakland. And

2560
01:32:04,103 --> 01:32:04,837
some examples of work they've

2561
01:32:04,837 --> 01:32:07,273
with the vp, formerly of Unite

2562
01:32:07,273 --> 01:32:10,442
in the past. Is they actually

2563
01:32:10,442 --> 01:32:11,276
where the organization that

2564
01:32:11,276 --> 01:32:13,676
recommended in helped carry

2565
01:32:14,713 --> 01:32:15,414
the killings and act like

2566
01:32:15,414 --> 01:32:16,149
coaching fellowship, which is

2567
01:32:16,149 --> 01:32:18,149
the internationally recognized

2568
01:32:20,152 --> 01:32:20,886
recognized certification.

2569
01:32:20,886 --> 01:32:21,754
They've helped support dp

2570
01:32:21,754 --> 01:32:23,622
Network and the means which

2571
01:32:23,622 --> 01:32:25,391
brings together the grantees.

2572
01:32:25,391 --> 01:32:28,391
Is that time for networking

2573
01:32:28,427 --> 01:32:29,395
and collaborative learning.

2574
01:32:29,395 --> 01:32:31,795
They've developed from the

2575
01:32:33,132 --> 01:32:33,799
trainers models receive ei

2576
01:32:33,799 --> 01:32:36,199
professionals. Learn to be

2577
01:32:39,538 --> 01:32:40,239
peer facilitators. And they

2578
01:32:40,239 --> 01:32:43,839
have also they also just have

2579
01:32:45,644 --> 01:32:47,613
a lot of who with, Oakley to

2580
01:32:47,613 --> 01:32:48,147
cv eco system trusted by has

2581
01:32:48,147 --> 01:32:48,847
let it rest of the

2582
01:32:48,847 --> 01:32:51,247
organizations that we partner

2583
01:32:53,352 --> 01:32:56,952
with. Thank you to have any

2584
01:32:58,223 --> 01:32:58,858
questions. I'll start off with

2585
01:32:58,858 --> 01:33:01,126
a comment. I just want to

2586
01:33:01,126 --> 01:33:02,294
commend you for your work on

2587
01:33:02,294 --> 01:33:04,196
this. I think this is exactly

2588
01:33:04,196 --> 01:33:06,999
the work that ensures that

2589
01:33:06,999 --> 01:33:08,934
Oakland continues to be on the

2590
01:33:08,934 --> 01:33:09,768
front line of community

2591
01:33:09,768 --> 01:33:10,502
violence approaches, their

2592
01:33:10,502 --> 01:33:12,902
interruption approaches. So so

2593
01:33:13,380 --> 01:33:15,438
thank you. Council member

2594
01:33:21,480 --> 01:33:22,614
Brown. Excellent. Thank you so

2595
01:33:22,614 --> 01:33:23,315
much that report. Only have

2596
01:33:23,315 --> 01:33:26,315
one question. I'm looking at

2597
01:33:28,287 --> 01:33:29,154
the funding table noticing

2598
01:33:29,154 --> 01:33:31,924
item the half a million is

2599
01:33:31,924 --> 01:33:32,858
coming from the general fund

2600
01:33:32,858 --> 01:33:35,258
and then it's project

2601
01:33:36,695 --> 01:33:39,950
re-imagining public safety. I

2602
01:33:39,665 --> 01:33:42,569
so question is, was something

2603
01:33:42,569 --> 01:33:43,235
that was budgeted in the in

2604
01:33:43,235 --> 01:33:46,772
the budgeted or is this an

2605
01:33:46,772 --> 01:33:47,740
additional allocation? This is

2606
01:33:47,740 --> 01:33:50,776
in the budget. We tried to get

2607
01:33:50,776 --> 01:33:53,879
the rfq out before for the

2608
01:33:53,879 --> 01:33:54,613
current fiscal year started.

2609
01:33:54,613 --> 01:33:57,613
Unfortunately, there are a lot

2610
01:33:58,830 --> 01:34:00,152
of there are holdups. We were

2611
01:34:00,152 --> 01:34:02,200
able to carry forward that

2612
01:34:02,200 --> 01:34:03,922
money. And so it is within our

2613
01:34:03,922 --> 01:34:05,991
budget. Ok, perfect. Thank you

2614
01:34:05,991 --> 01:34:06,658
for the clarity. I'm not sure

2615
01:34:06,658 --> 01:34:10,258
if there's a motion on the

2616
01:34:16,869 --> 01:34:17,836
floor, but second So yes,

2617
01:34:17,836 --> 01:34:20,836
chair Brent. Yes, my question.

2618
01:34:26,479 --> 01:34:27,112
So job. Lady. Sure I made a

2619
01:34:27,112 --> 01:34:29,512
motion and council member

2620
01:34:29,515 --> 01:34:30,449
Brown made a second. Let's

2621
01:34:30,449 --> 01:34:32,151
proceed. Calling him the

2622
01:34:32,151 --> 01:34:33,652
names. Ascended to speak on

2623
01:34:33,652 --> 01:34:36,652
item 5, Jesse Rose Morris not

2624
01:34:41,827 --> 01:34:42,494
available in Blair Beekman.

2625
01:34:42,494 --> 01:34:45,264
Hi, Jess. Are just like to

2626
01:34:45,264 --> 01:34:46,799
point out that I'm like the

2627
01:34:46,799 --> 01:34:47,466
opd. The Department of

2628
01:34:47,466 --> 01:34:49,866
Violence Prevention in this

2629
01:34:49,868 --> 01:34:51,103
case actually did an rfp rfq

2630
01:34:51,103 --> 01:34:52,304
and didn't ask you all to skip

2631
01:34:52,304 --> 01:34:54,273
all of it so that they can

2632
01:34:54,273 --> 01:34:55,240
have their preferred vendor

2633
01:34:55,240 --> 01:34:57,900
for for this thing. And we

2634
01:34:57,900 --> 01:34:57,910
know that in the future

2635
01:34:57,910 --> 01:34:58,477
they're going to right now.

2636
01:34:58,477 --> 01:34:59,144
Our cue that's geared

2637
01:34:59,144 --> 01:35:01,544
specifically. So that only

2638
01:35:02,147 --> 01:35:02,881
flaw could get it. We had a

2639
01:35:02,881 --> 01:35:05,281
nice presentation from someone

2640
01:35:06,218 --> 01:35:08,153
he did a great job, whereas

2641
01:35:08,153 --> 01:35:10,989
with the flock item, I'm not

2642
01:35:10,989 --> 01:35:12,570
mistaken. That was done by

2643
01:35:12,570 --> 01:35:12,725
homered Heroes, who was

2644
01:35:12,725 --> 01:35:13,358
involved in an

2645
01:35:13,358 --> 01:35:15,358
officer-involved shooting

2646
01:35:18,330 --> 01:35:20,999
against someone he was. Killed

2647
01:35:20,999 --> 01:35:21,734
and he wanted to get lethal

2648
01:35:21,734 --> 01:35:22,401
and that cost the city tens of

2649
01:35:22,401 --> 01:35:24,603
millions of the 10 million

2650
01:35:24,603 --> 01:35:25,871
dollars. I believe in a

2651
01:35:25,871 --> 01:35:28,173
lawsuit. So it's interesting

2652
01:35:28,173 --> 01:35:28,841
that you're having that person

2653
01:35:28,841 --> 01:35:30,709
speak on clock. I'm glad to

2654
01:35:30,709 --> 01:35:32,709
see department about

2655
01:35:32,711 --> 01:35:33,846
prevention doing a great

2656
01:35:33,846 --> 01:35:34,780
thing. We should have less

2657
01:35:34,780 --> 01:35:35,447
officer-involved shootings. We

2658
01:35:35,447 --> 01:35:37,983
should have less flock and

2659
01:35:37,983 --> 01:35:38,951
more violence prevention. How

2660
01:35:38,951 --> 01:35:41,951
about that from my city

2661
01:35:47,292 --> 01:35:50,292
council with that, you know.

2662
01:35:51,830 --> 01:35:56,300
So. You see these a woman of

2663
01:35:58,700 --> 01:35:59,905
color Everybody got Cup. Some

2664
01:35:59,905 --> 01:36:02,905
have local element in other

2665
01:36:03,509 --> 01:36:06,745
months. But this ability to So

2666
01:36:06,745 --> 01:36:08,747
why people feel like Pacific

2667
01:36:08,747 --> 01:36:10,883
They and the group with the

2668
01:36:10,883 --> 01:36:11,517
melanin grew. They just a

2669
01:36:11,517 --> 01:36:13,517
blessing mellow everybody

2670
01:36:14,219 --> 01:36:17,219
Start with that people. Women

2671
01:36:18,230 --> 01:36:19,725
to whatever and just say women

2672
01:36:19,725 --> 01:36:20,392
and I got a problem with this

2673
01:36:20,392 --> 01:36:20,993
issue with women. With this

2674
01:36:20,993 --> 01:36:22,594
Department of Violence

2675
01:36:22,594 --> 01:36:25,594
Prevention. I don't see no

2676
01:36:28,801 --> 01:36:30,350
men. And how does group.

2677
01:36:30,350 --> 01:36:31,937
That's women and most of the

2678
01:36:31,937 --> 01:36:34,937
people you've got to deal

2679
01:36:36,509 --> 01:36:37,309
African-American man. And so

2680
01:36:37,309 --> 01:36:39,478
these women going to deal with

2681
01:36:39,478 --> 01:36:40,179
in they say in their report

2682
01:36:40,179 --> 01:36:43,779
when you look at them online

2683
01:36:43,982 --> 01:36:44,883
at they in. Ok, but we got a

2684
01:36:44,883 --> 01:36:47,883
lot going on with this

2685
01:36:48,887 --> 01:36:49,488
department with women. Being

2686
01:36:49,488 --> 01:36:53,880
in most of the roles of

2687
01:37:00,699 --> 01:37:01,366
leadership. Thank you for your

2688
01:37:01,366 --> 01:37:02,340
comments. Witching to Zoom

2689
01:37:02,340 --> 01:37:05,340
user Blair, you can unmute

2690
01:37:07,106 --> 01:37:07,806
yourself. All there. Big man.

2691
01:37:07,806 --> 01:37:10,206
Hopefully women in leadership

2692
01:37:11,760 --> 01:37:14,676
isn't so much of a problem.

2693
01:37:15,848 --> 01:37:18,717
I'm hoping with this item that

2694
01:37:18,717 --> 01:37:19,385
you it is really stepping up

2695
01:37:19,385 --> 01:37:20,520
their rage parts that they

2696
01:37:20,520 --> 01:37:20,719
can. And guess what? People

2697
01:37:20,719 --> 01:37:23,222
are dying from it again. So

2698
01:37:23,222 --> 01:37:26,191
there's a lot of outrage. I

2699
01:37:26,191 --> 01:37:28,427
think we can be prepared in

2700
01:37:28,427 --> 01:37:30,329
Oakland and I'm hopeful in

2701
01:37:30,329 --> 01:37:32,729
what council person, Brown

2702
01:37:33,599 --> 01:37:36,535
when have been studying in

2703
01:37:36,535 --> 01:37:37,936
data collection, right, we can

2704
01:37:37,936 --> 01:37:38,771
be ready. I think we can be

2705
01:37:38,771 --> 01:37:41,840
ready with with this sort work

2706
01:37:41,840 --> 01:37:42,908
and effort of this item. We

2707
01:37:42,908 --> 01:37:46,178
have a bunch of programs like

2708
01:37:46,178 --> 01:37:47,246
this that I simply I think

2709
01:37:47,246 --> 01:37:49,114
Create something pretty

2710
01:37:49,114 --> 01:37:49,815
important. Is respected at the

2711
01:37:49,815 --> 01:37:52,951
federal level. And we have to

2712
01:37:52,951 --> 01:37:54,420
continue to share what we know

2713
01:37:54,420 --> 01:37:55,988
and what we want to practice

2714
01:37:55,988 --> 01:37:57,990
is how to address our issues

2715
01:37:57,990 --> 01:37:58,657
the community. This can keep

2716
01:37:58,657 --> 01:38:00,759
it the way. So keep up the

2717
01:38:00,759 --> 01:38:01,794
good efforts of this type of

2718
01:38:01,794 --> 01:38:02,461
item, really a composite. A

2719
01:38:02,461 --> 01:38:05,898
lot of things on a lot of

2720
01:38:05,898 --> 01:38:07,990
levels. Thanks for that. Thank

2721
01:38:07,990 --> 01:38:07,966
you for your comments. Sure.

2722
01:38:07,966 --> 01:38:08,867
That includes all speakers and

2723
01:38:08,867 --> 01:38:11,804
we do have a motion made by

2724
01:38:11,804 --> 01:38:12,704
Chair Wang second by council

2725
01:38:12,704 --> 01:38:13,405
member Brown to put the

2726
01:38:13,405 --> 01:38:14,106
recommendations of staff and

2727
01:38:14,106 --> 01:38:15,741
toward this item to the JULY

2728
01:38:15,741 --> 01:38:16,942
20 per City Council agenda on

2729
01:38:16,942 --> 01:38:19,342
consent on row Councilmembers.

2730
01:38:21,447 --> 01:38:23,820
Brown. I buy I use eye and

2731
01:38:23,820 --> 01:38:23,749
chair along. I think you

2732
01:38:23,749 --> 01:38:24,450
motion passes will pour. I

2733
01:38:24,450 --> 01:38:27,152
support this item to the JULY

2734
01:38:27,152 --> 01:38:27,986
20 for City Council agenda on

2735
01:38:27,986 --> 01:38:30,386
consent. Reading in item

2736
01:38:33,125 --> 01:38:34,293
number 6. Adopt sorry, adopt a

2737
01:38:34,293 --> 01:38:35,127
resolution authorizing the

2738
01:38:35,127 --> 01:38:35,928
city administrator to apply

2739
01:38:35,928 --> 01:38:37,928
for except inappropriate.

2740
01:38:38,931 --> 01:38:40,931
Edward Memorial Justice

2741
01:38:42,568 --> 01:38:44,568
Assistance Assistance, Grant

2742
01:38:47,239 --> 01:38:49,808
say up to 324 $1324 for the

2743
01:38:49,808 --> 01:38:51,677
fiscal year 2025 Grand Award

2744
01:38:51,677 --> 01:38:54,770
period of OCTOBER. First 2025

2745
01:38:55,447 --> 01:38:57,820
through SEPTEMBER, 30th 2020

2746
01:38:57,820 --> 01:38:57,850
to support the department like

2747
01:38:57,850 --> 01:38:58,517
training equipment,

2748
01:38:58,517 --> 01:38:59,651
technology, and operational

2749
01:38:59,651 --> 01:39:02,510
enhancements. And we have 4

2750
01:39:03,222 --> 01:39:04,223
speakers on this item. Okay,

2751
01:39:04,223 --> 01:39:07,223
great. Please take it away.

2752
01:39:08,761 --> 01:39:09,995
Yes. Good evening. Chair and

2753
01:39:09,995 --> 01:39:10,662
members of the committee,

2754
01:39:10,662 --> 01:39:11,296
Russian warship, the Fiscal

2755
01:39:11,296 --> 01:39:12,931
division manager for the

2756
01:39:12,931 --> 01:39:14,931
Oakland Police Department.

2757
01:39:18,203 --> 01:39:19,710
Before you is to Justice

2758
01:39:19,710 --> 01:39:20,739
assistant grant for 2025. With

2759
01:39:20,739 --> 01:39:23,139
the total allocation of

2760
01:39:24,410 --> 01:39:24,977
324,000 $324. The Jack Ryan is

2761
01:39:24,977 --> 01:39:27,977
a fund fund a program

2762
01:39:28,148 --> 01:39:29,149
administered. Partnership the

2763
01:39:29,149 --> 01:39:31,160
county which applies for the

2764
01:39:31,160 --> 01:39:31,683
grant on behalf of the

2765
01:39:31,683 --> 01:39:33,652
department and the funding

2766
01:39:33,652 --> 01:39:35,654
allocations are based on the

2767
01:39:35,654 --> 01:39:36,321
population. Opd has been the

2768
01:39:36,321 --> 01:39:36,956
recipient of this award

2769
01:39:36,956 --> 01:39:39,356
approved by council since

2770
01:39:41,627 --> 01:39:42,227
2005. Given the department's

2771
01:39:42,227 --> 01:39:44,227
7.8 million decrease in

2772
01:39:45,364 --> 01:39:46,310
operation and maintenance as

2773
01:39:46,310 --> 01:39:46,632
outlined in the report, the

2774
01:39:46,632 --> 01:39:48,632
department proposed the

2775
01:39:49,635 --> 01:39:50,202
following. 25,000 Floyd

2776
01:39:50,202 --> 01:39:52,202
training professional

2777
01:39:55,474 --> 01:39:56,608
development. Which promote

2778
01:39:56,608 --> 01:39:59,800
ongoing training. That's not

2779
01:40:00,846 --> 01:40:02,981
related to polls. Which would

2780
01:40:02,981 --> 01:40:03,582
support training such as

2781
01:40:03,582 --> 01:40:05,982
women's leaders and law

2782
01:40:07,453 --> 01:40:09,853
enforcement mash. Asian peace

2783
01:40:11,557 --> 01:40:13,957
officers. Secondly, there is

2784
01:40:14,693 --> 01:40:15,861
$66,891 and $0.56 That's

2785
01:40:15,861 --> 01:40:16,562
allocated to technology. A

2786
01:40:16,562 --> 01:40:18,397
great supporting replacements

2787
01:40:18,397 --> 01:40:20,999
of aging computers that cannot

2788
01:40:20,999 --> 01:40:23,399
support Windows 11. Along with

2789
01:40:24,169 --> 01:40:26,939
a bit of software. It hardware

2790
01:40:26,939 --> 01:40:29,339
and other technology. Lastly,

2791
01:40:30,743 --> 01:40:32,111
there's $2000. I mean, 200

2792
01:40:32,111 --> 01:40:34,511
1000 dollars allocated for the

2793
01:40:36,215 --> 01:40:37,483
helicopter marine maintenance,

2794
01:40:37,483 --> 01:40:39,184
which helps support the

2795
01:40:39,184 --> 01:40:41,186
contracts. One of the contract

2796
01:40:41,186 --> 01:40:43,322
is Ashley being reported on

2797
01:40:43,322 --> 01:40:44,220
tonight. And so this helps

2798
01:40:44,220 --> 01:40:47,622
with a vital services for the

2799
01:40:48,761 --> 01:40:49,828
department. These funds apd to

2800
01:40:49,828 --> 01:40:51,597
support operations without

2801
01:40:51,597 --> 01:40:52,197
impacting the city's general

2802
01:40:52,197 --> 01:40:54,597
fund. This concludes my

2803
01:40:57,102 --> 01:40:58,971
presentation. All right. Thank

2804
01:40:58,971 --> 01:41:01,390
you. And I do appreciate since

2805
01:41:01,390 --> 01:41:01,707
one of my questions to opd in

2806
01:41:01,707 --> 01:41:03,242
advance with this was

2807
01:41:03,242 --> 01:41:05,642
providing more specificity on

2808
01:41:05,879 --> 01:41:06,579
those cash, the glories of of

2809
01:41:06,579 --> 01:41:09,579
funding. Any questions for my

2810
01:41:11,550 --> 01:41:13,352
colleagues. Let's go to the

2811
01:41:13,352 --> 01:41:14,553
public comment calling in the

2812
01:41:14,553 --> 01:41:16,388
needs of Senate to speak on

2813
01:41:16,388 --> 01:41:17,560
this item airs Dedan Jesse

2814
01:41:17,560 --> 01:41:19,456
Rose more Asadullah fallen

2815
01:41:27,232 --> 01:41:28,200
Blair Beekman. A high just

2816
01:41:28,200 --> 01:41:32,137
euros you know you can see of

2817
01:41:32,137 --> 01:41:33,720
he's just for the public the

2818
01:41:33,720 --> 01:41:34,773
first paragraph of Page 5 of

2819
01:41:34,773 --> 01:41:35,374
this report and its pretty

2820
01:41:35,374 --> 01:41:36,809
sloppy. There's even a

2821
01:41:36,809 --> 01:41:39,110
grammatical error on the last

2822
01:41:39,110 --> 01:41:40,646
sentence. This is, of course,

2823
01:41:40,646 --> 01:41:41,447
the race inequity part of the

2824
01:41:41,447 --> 01:41:44,447
report and helicopters have a

2825
01:41:48,530 --> 01:41:48,954
history of being using giving

2826
01:41:48,954 --> 01:41:49,489
its pollution in a

2827
01:41:49,489 --> 01:41:51,457
predominantly black

2828
01:41:51,457 --> 01:41:52,791
neighborhood, low-income and

2829
01:41:52,791 --> 01:41:53,659
black neighborhoods. This is

2830
01:41:53,659 --> 01:41:55,594
completely not looked at by

2831
01:41:55,594 --> 01:41:58,430
the opd, whereas you now

2832
01:41:58,430 --> 01:41:59,398
department of violate. I've

2833
01:41:59,398 --> 01:42:01,398
violence prevention actually

2834
01:42:02,534 --> 01:42:03,235
filled out the I racing equity

2835
01:42:03,235 --> 01:42:06,235
portion of this and actually

2836
01:42:06,672 --> 01:42:07,373
care, too. You know, care

2837
01:42:07,373 --> 01:42:08,107
about that part and also care

2838
01:42:08,107 --> 01:42:11,107
about our privacy, which opd

2839
01:42:12,878 --> 01:42:13,879
obviously does not. You know,

2840
01:42:13,879 --> 01:42:14,813
it's be interested in what

2841
01:42:14,813 --> 01:42:16,813
approvals. There are

2842
01:42:17,783 --> 01:42:19,985
helicopters because you just

2843
01:42:19,985 --> 01:42:21,720
try to match opd Zi, Zip lock

2844
01:42:21,720 --> 01:42:22,421
match up. Use policy of flock

2845
01:42:22,421 --> 01:42:23,890
to these use rather than the

2846
01:42:23,890 --> 01:42:26,890
other way around. So what's

2847
01:42:30,397 --> 01:42:30,996
happening here? Before

2848
01:42:30,996 --> 01:42:33,996
beginning of a point of

2849
01:42:35,300 --> 01:42:38,300
inquiry, if that's okay, there

2850
01:42:39,272 --> 01:42:41,106
is mentioned in this report,

2851
01:42:41,106 --> 01:42:41,807
use for the maintenance of the

2852
01:42:41,807 --> 01:42:42,474
helicopter, but that is also

2853
01:42:42,474 --> 01:42:44,874
another agenda item agenda

2854
01:42:45,377 --> 01:42:48,782
item number 7. So I do believe

2855
01:42:48,782 --> 01:42:49,915
there might be some overlap

2856
01:42:49,915 --> 01:42:52,518
with that. And also we don't

2857
01:42:52,518 --> 01:42:55,518
need to provide more funding

2858
01:42:55,654 --> 01:42:56,722
for equipment for the Oakland

2859
01:42:56,722 --> 01:42:57,790
Police Department. They are

2860
01:42:57,790 --> 01:42:59,124
vastly over funded because

2861
01:42:59,124 --> 01:42:59,792
right now by the Oakland

2862
01:42:59,792 --> 01:43:01,792
Police Department admission

2863
01:43:03,280 --> 01:43:03,730
they are understaffed. We do

2864
01:43:03,730 --> 01:43:04,463
not need give them more money

2865
01:43:04,463 --> 01:43:08,630
for equipment that they do not

2866
01:43:08,734 --> 01:43:11,770
eat and will not use and in

2867
01:43:11,770 --> 01:43:14,390
addition, these resources are

2868
01:43:14,390 --> 01:43:14,940
actually not something that

2869
01:43:14,940 --> 01:43:16,742
will actually help prevent

2870
01:43:16,742 --> 01:43:17,743
crime than about a sentencing

2871
01:43:17,743 --> 01:43:19,144
commission really sent a page

2872
01:43:19,144 --> 01:43:19,845
document in 2022. That wants 3

2873
01:43:19,845 --> 01:43:22,147
methods of increasing public

2874
01:43:22,147 --> 01:43:24,547
safety and crime prevention

2875
01:43:24,683 --> 01:43:27,186
rates of up to 51% in multiple

2876
01:43:27,186 --> 01:43:27,920
different categories and none

2877
01:43:27,920 --> 01:43:31,520
of them have to do with

2878
01:43:35,994 --> 01:43:38,394
increasing equipment budget. I

2879
01:43:38,664 --> 01:43:42,670
continue to ask you when any

2880
01:43:42,670 --> 01:43:44,369
grant comes before you look at

2881
01:43:44,369 --> 01:43:45,938
the of the ways that grant can

2882
01:43:45,938 --> 01:43:48,730
be used. So this particular

2883
01:43:48,730 --> 01:43:51,730
grant can be used crime

2884
01:43:53,178 --> 01:43:53,912
prevention and education drug

2885
01:43:53,912 --> 01:43:55,912
treatment, crime victims

2886
01:43:55,948 --> 01:43:57,948
assistance with assistance,

2887
01:43:59,419 --> 01:44:01,419
mental health programs,

2888
01:44:02,554 --> 01:44:03,622
behavior programs, veterans

2889
01:44:03,622 --> 01:44:05,924
Court and Rhis protection

2890
01:44:05,924 --> 01:44:08,924
programs. That money can be

2891
01:44:10,596 --> 01:44:11,563
used for all of that. So we we

2892
01:44:11,563 --> 01:44:13,799
are going to be using it for

2893
01:44:13,799 --> 01:44:14,500
training police go Quitman

2894
01:44:14,500 --> 01:44:17,500
technology. What is that? The

2895
01:44:19,171 --> 01:44:19,905
high a priority. You have a

2896
01:44:19,905 --> 01:44:22,305
responsibility anytime you see

2897
01:44:23,175 --> 01:44:24,276
anything on the agenda. If

2898
01:44:24,276 --> 01:44:26,145
there's options to look at the

2899
01:44:26,145 --> 01:44:29,145
options and aches. Why didn't

2900
01:44:30,149 --> 01:44:30,783
you consider this? Crime

2901
01:44:30,783 --> 01:44:32,783
whatever drug treatment,

2902
01:44:37,890 --> 01:44:37,790
mental health. Switching to

2903
01:44:37,790 --> 01:44:39,958
Zoom user Blair, you yourself

2904
01:44:39,958 --> 01:44:42,358
begin your comments. All

2905
01:44:46,865 --> 01:44:47,566
right. Thank I think

2906
01:44:47,566 --> 01:44:49,966
traditionally cac funding has

2907
01:44:50,903 --> 01:44:51,770
been used for more and severe

2908
01:44:51,770 --> 01:44:54,170
law enforcement tech needs

2909
01:44:54,373 --> 01:44:56,773
helicopters and things like

2910
01:44:57,843 --> 01:45:01,443
that. Nice to hear the items

2911
01:45:03,820 --> 01:45:06,820
so Paulo think thinking how

2912
01:45:09,655 --> 01:45:12,958
can be considered and in more

2913
01:45:12,958 --> 01:45:15,961
under terms the idea it being

2914
01:45:15,961 --> 01:45:16,929
used for office and not

2915
01:45:16,929 --> 01:45:17,596
dipping into the general fund.

2916
01:45:17,596 --> 01:45:18,263
Really nice to hear things

2917
01:45:18,263 --> 01:45:20,399
like that. So thank you. At

2918
01:45:20,399 --> 01:45:23,999
least in those terms. Work on

2919
01:45:27,339 --> 01:45:27,973
the Thank you. Thank you for

2920
01:45:27,973 --> 01:45:29,441
your comments chair. That

2921
01:45:29,441 --> 01:45:32,441
speakers on this item. Thank

2922
01:45:34,646 --> 01:45:36,648
you. Councilmember Brown. All

2923
01:45:36,648 --> 01:45:37,583
right. Thank you so much for

2924
01:45:37,583 --> 01:45:38,384
that I know that the

2925
01:45:38,384 --> 01:45:40,452
application was a joint

2926
01:45:40,452 --> 01:45:42,452
application with Alameda

2927
01:45:42,621 --> 01:45:44,590
County. It is interesting to

2928
01:45:44,590 --> 01:45:45,391
note that Oakland received the

2929
01:45:45,391 --> 01:45:48,391
second largest amount right of

2930
01:45:49,395 --> 01:45:50,162
that allocation. I do think

2931
01:45:50,162 --> 01:45:52,264
that the comment from the

2932
01:45:52,264 --> 01:45:53,980
public speaker around other

2933
01:45:53,980 --> 01:45:55,498
eligible uses would be

2934
01:45:55,901 --> 01:45:57,102
something that maybe consider

2935
01:45:57,102 --> 01:45:58,771
and we get to the helicopter

2936
01:45:58,771 --> 01:46:02,371
item. I know we're not there

2937
01:46:02,608 --> 01:46:03,609
yet, but I do recall in recent

2938
01:46:03,609 --> 01:46:06,900
conversations that that has

2939
01:46:06,379 --> 01:46:09,379
ongoing expense in maybe we

2940
01:46:11,517 --> 01:46:12,785
need to invest in. I think

2941
01:46:12,785 --> 01:46:13,452
I've heard just issues with

2942
01:46:13,452 --> 01:46:15,421
the helicopter we can talk

2943
01:46:15,421 --> 01:46:17,560
more about but I would be

2944
01:46:17,560 --> 01:46:19,124
interested in some of the

2945
01:46:19,124 --> 01:46:21,994
other eligible uses for these

2946
01:46:21,994 --> 01:46:23,162
funds because that list that

2947
01:46:23,162 --> 01:46:26,565
the public speaker and kind of

2948
01:46:26,565 --> 01:46:27,199
named out was very intriguing.

2949
01:46:27,199 --> 01:46:30,702
And we know the all those

2950
01:46:30,702 --> 01:46:31,737
things are services that our

2951
01:46:31,737 --> 01:46:33,739
community could be it could be

2952
01:46:33,739 --> 01:46:35,707
in need But all in all, thank

2953
01:46:35,707 --> 01:46:37,376
you for bringing the item in

2954
01:46:37,376 --> 01:46:38,243
weeks at the we accept free

2955
01:46:38,243 --> 01:46:38,944
money, right? We set the muggy

2956
01:46:38,944 --> 01:46:43,144
So I'm happy to move the item

2957
01:46:43,315 --> 01:46:44,683
along. Councilmember Fife.

2958
01:46:44,683 --> 01:46:47,683
Thank you. Threw the chair.

2959
01:46:47,986 --> 01:46:48,988
I'm also interested in how

2960
01:46:48,988 --> 01:46:51,388
were determining the breakdown

2961
01:46:54,827 --> 01:46:55,527
between marine and aviation

2962
01:46:55,527 --> 01:46:56,195
equipment. And the reason I'm

2963
01:46:56,195 --> 01:46:59,195
asking is because it feels

2964
01:46:59,531 --> 01:47:00,332
like I don't know, the House

2965
01:47:00,332 --> 01:47:01,767
of Dragons came through and

2966
01:47:01,767 --> 01:47:05,771
burned up all the ships in the

2967
01:47:05,771 --> 01:47:06,472
estuary and there's all these

2968
01:47:06,472 --> 01:47:07,806
abandoned boats and they are

2969
01:47:07,806 --> 01:47:10,209
there for a very, very long

2970
01:47:10,209 --> 01:47:12,144
time. And I'm not sure if it's

2971
01:47:12,144 --> 01:47:14,413
staff and that's the issue why

2972
01:47:14,413 --> 01:47:15,614
can't boats be cleared out

2973
01:47:15,614 --> 01:47:17,783
because of then it leads

2974
01:47:17,783 --> 01:47:18,450
environmental pollution in the

2975
01:47:18,450 --> 01:47:21,419
water and so I'd like to

2976
01:47:21,419 --> 01:47:23,819
understand how. Those funds

2977
01:47:27,626 --> 01:47:29,528
are being I guess, divvied up

2978
01:47:29,528 --> 01:47:30,963
between those 2, those 2 areas

2979
01:47:30,963 --> 01:47:33,766
and I would agree I brought an

2980
01:47:33,766 --> 01:47:34,433
item 3 years ago around the

2981
01:47:34,433 --> 01:47:36,835
fixed wing aircraft that is

2982
01:47:36,835 --> 01:47:38,670
better and well, it's debate

2983
01:47:38,670 --> 01:47:40,639
debated. The environmental

2984
01:47:40,639 --> 01:47:41,407
impacts, but definitely the

2985
01:47:41,407 --> 01:47:44,407
sound kuz get. Birds are

2986
01:47:45,277 --> 01:47:47,146
allowed in And we got to do

2987
01:47:47,146 --> 01:47:50,146
better. But and we're spending

2988
01:47:50,182 --> 01:47:51,450
like so much money on

2989
01:47:51,450 --> 01:47:53,850
maintaining equipment that is

2990
01:47:53,919 --> 01:47:57,519
just past its useful life. I

2991
01:47:58,123 --> 01:47:59,324
wouldn't I would like to see.

2992
01:47:59,324 --> 01:48:01,724
Funds going to support

2993
01:48:03,829 --> 01:48:04,797
clearing our waterways and you

2994
01:48:04,797 --> 01:48:05,898
know, using. But anyway, the

2995
01:48:05,898 --> 01:48:08,600
point is how are giving up

2996
01:48:08,600 --> 01:48:11,600
those grant funds? So through

2997
01:48:13,337 --> 01:48:14,338
the Actually, there was just a

2998
01:48:14,338 --> 01:48:17,108
contract and it will land

2999
01:48:17,108 --> 01:48:18,309
Marine for 1.4 million dollars

3000
01:48:18,309 --> 01:48:20,344
that would do the vessel

3001
01:48:20,344 --> 01:48:23,115
removals for the Marine. This

3002
01:48:23,115 --> 01:48:24,717
is actually to just work on

3003
01:48:24,717 --> 01:48:25,384
the Bowden. So there's

3004
01:48:25,384 --> 01:48:27,286
$100,000 allocated for that

3005
01:48:27,286 --> 01:48:29,489
for maintenance for that man.

3006
01:48:29,489 --> 01:48:31,157
The other 100,000 is for the

3007
01:48:31,157 --> 01:48:31,957
helicopter for what? The

3008
01:48:31,957 --> 01:48:33,957
$100,000 for a helicopter.

3009
01:48:35,270 --> 01:48:38,130
That's a drop in the bucket

3010
01:48:38,130 --> 01:48:38,897
wire. So total contract is

3011
01:48:38,897 --> 01:48:41,297
$850,000. So we're going to

3012
01:48:43,350 --> 01:48:43,769
use some general purpose funds

3013
01:48:43,769 --> 01:48:44,403
and then we have a new subject

3014
01:48:44,403 --> 01:48:47,403
funds as well. Our grant

3015
01:48:50,709 --> 01:48:51,776
funds. 2 for the helicopter

3016
01:48:51,776 --> 01:48:52,478
and what will will get to the

3017
01:48:52,478 --> 01:48:53,770
helicopter questions on the

3018
01:48:53,770 --> 01:48:55,477
next Thank you. You're

3019
01:48:57,182 --> 01:48:58,183
welcome. I'll add to the

3020
01:48:58,183 --> 01:49:00,552
helicopter question. So I

3021
01:49:00,552 --> 01:49:02,655
think in the re-imagining

3022
01:49:02,655 --> 01:49:05,655
public for it was established

3023
01:49:06,658 --> 01:49:07,860
helicopter in terms of regular

3024
01:49:07,860 --> 01:49:08,827
operational costs about 4

3025
01:49:08,827 --> 01:49:12,427
times the amount of the fixed

3026
01:49:12,798 --> 01:49:13,966
wing aircraft. Is the

3027
01:49:13,966 --> 01:49:15,501
department's starting to

3028
01:49:15,501 --> 01:49:18,501
explore how to move towards

3029
01:49:19,872 --> 01:49:20,573
the fixed wing aircraft model.

3030
01:49:20,573 --> 01:49:22,206
Good Evening. Council member

3031
01:49:22,206 --> 01:49:24,109
Captain William, the local

3032
01:49:24,109 --> 01:49:26,377
police department. Indeed, we

3033
01:49:26,377 --> 01:49:27,845
are. We've actually proposed

3034
01:49:27,845 --> 01:49:29,515
to the city Council on several

3035
01:49:29,515 --> 01:49:32,217
occasions, a very detailed and

3036
01:49:32,217 --> 01:49:32,984
robust document of the fixed

3037
01:49:32,984 --> 01:49:35,287
wing aircraft to its expected

3038
01:49:35,287 --> 01:49:36,880
life expectancy as well as

3039
01:49:36,880 --> 01:49:36,790
maintenance costs and council

3040
01:49:36,790 --> 01:49:39,790
member of 5 correct. That is

3041
01:49:42,328 --> 01:49:43,428
8. Significant reduction in

3042
01:49:43,428 --> 01:49:45,640
operating costs over the long

3043
01:49:45,640 --> 01:49:46,231
term for that aircraft. It

3044
01:49:46,231 --> 01:49:46,865
result in substantial savings

3045
01:49:46,865 --> 01:49:49,680
long term versus a rotor

3046
01:49:49,680 --> 01:49:52,680
aircraft. And so what is

3047
01:49:53,105 --> 01:49:55,542
holdup? At the time the

3048
01:49:55,542 --> 01:49:59,142
discussion was we talk to the

3049
01:49:59,343 --> 01:50:00,790
portion financing the

3050
01:50:00,790 --> 01:50:03,790
aircraft. Aside from that, the

3051
01:50:03,649 --> 01:50:04,348
proposal was complete. Okay.

3052
01:50:04,348 --> 01:50:06,685
Let's talk about this more in

3053
01:50:06,685 --> 01:50:10,885
the next item. Do I have a

3054
01:50:11,356 --> 01:50:12,459
second otherwise. I'll second

3055
01:50:12,459 --> 01:50:15,600
I want to also explore, as

3056
01:50:15,600 --> 01:50:17,262
I've said now for 6 years,

3057
01:50:17,262 --> 01:50:19,262
alternative uses, particularly

3058
01:50:19,665 --> 01:50:20,532
if there's any way that we can

3059
01:50:20,532 --> 01:50:23,532
investigate rape kits or any

3060
01:50:25,103 --> 01:50:27,720
way we can look into

3061
01:50:27,720 --> 01:50:29,720
supporting more

3062
01:50:29,108 --> 01:50:29,808
investigations. I'm I'm not

3063
01:50:29,808 --> 01:50:30,476
sure if that's possible with

3064
01:50:30,476 --> 01:50:33,476
these funds perhaps you can

3065
01:50:33,644 --> 01:50:34,313
answer for a second to start

3066
01:50:34,313 --> 01:50:37,313
clearing some of these cold

3067
01:50:39,650 --> 01:50:40,619
cases, particularly around you

3068
01:50:40,619 --> 01:50:43,210
know, some of the rape kits

3069
01:50:43,210 --> 01:50:43,856
that have not the process pd.

3070
01:50:43,856 --> 01:50:47,993
I would like to see that if

3071
01:50:47,993 --> 01:50:50,393
possible for additional uses.

3072
01:50:51,290 --> 01:50:52,897
We could use funds for we did

3073
01:50:52,897 --> 01:50:54,600
in the last grant that that

3074
01:50:54,600 --> 01:50:55,334
was in DECEMBER. We allocated

3075
01:50:55,334 --> 01:50:56,702
funds for the not. So we cover

3076
01:50:56,702 --> 01:50:59,702
that in the last great.

3077
01:51:00,338 --> 01:51:02,408
Covered it like like we

3078
01:51:02,408 --> 01:51:05,440
allocated. I'm gonna the crime

3079
01:51:05,440 --> 01:51:05,844
lab was awarded 200 k for

3080
01:51:05,844 --> 01:51:08,244
funds for just different

3081
01:51:08,881 --> 01:51:10,516
things in the crime. Yeah, I

3082
01:51:10,516 --> 01:51:12,351
would continuation of that

3083
01:51:12,351 --> 01:51:15,351
type of processing of grant

3084
01:51:17,623 --> 01:51:20,492
funds and for a second. Thank

3085
01:51:20,492 --> 01:51:21,260
you. We have a motion made by

3086
01:51:21,260 --> 01:51:21,894
council member Brown seconded

3087
01:51:21,894 --> 01:51:22,593
by Councilmember fight to

3088
01:51:22,593 --> 01:51:23,829
approve the recommendation of

3089
01:51:23,829 --> 01:51:26,298
staff and support this item to

3090
01:51:26,298 --> 01:51:29,298
the JULY 20 for City Council

3091
01:51:30,469 --> 01:51:32,469
agenda on Councilmembers.

3092
01:51:32,704 --> 01:51:34,473
Brown. I buy I use to eye and

3093
01:51:34,473 --> 01:51:35,808
chair I thank you. Motion

3094
01:51:35,808 --> 01:51:38,510
passes with more ice to port

3095
01:51:38,510 --> 01:51:39,978
this item to the JULY 20 for

3096
01:51:39,978 --> 01:51:40,679
City Council agenda on

3097
01:51:40,679 --> 01:51:43,790
consent. Reading in item

3098
01:51:45,818 --> 01:51:46,618
number 7. Adopt a resolution

3099
01:51:46,618 --> 01:51:47,285
authorizing the city

3100
01:51:47,285 --> 01:51:47,853
administrator to enter into

3101
01:51:47,853 --> 01:51:49,154
professional services

3102
01:51:49,154 --> 01:51:52,154
agreement with Red Oak wraps

3103
01:51:52,925 --> 01:51:53,525
Rotorcraft Support to provide

3104
01:51:53,525 --> 01:51:54,760
helicopter maintenance

3105
01:51:54,760 --> 01:51:57,610
services to the Oakland Police

3106
01:51:57,610 --> 01:52:00,320
Department for the period of

3107
01:52:00,320 --> 01:52:02,320
JULY. First 2026 to 6/30/2028

3108
01:52:02,702 --> 01:52:03,602
in an amount not to exceed

3109
01:52:03,602 --> 01:52:04,770
1 million, 700,000 dollars

3110
01:52:04,770 --> 01:52:06,206
with an option to extend the

3111
01:52:06,206 --> 01:52:08,206
agreement for 2 additional

3112
01:52:09,942 --> 01:52:12,511
years to JUNE. 30th 2030, for

3113
01:52:12,511 --> 01:52:13,946
total contract not to exceed

3114
01:52:13,946 --> 01:52:14,580
3 million, 400,000 dollars and

3115
01:52:14,580 --> 01:52:17,580
waving to local and small

3116
01:52:17,616 --> 01:52:18,250
local business enterprise

3117
01:52:18,250 --> 01:52:18,951
program requirements. And

3118
01:52:18,951 --> 01:52:21,951
there are 4 speakers on this

3119
01:52:23,822 --> 01:52:26,592
item. Okay. Great. You have a

3120
01:52:26,592 --> 01:52:27,292
few minutes. I know we are

3121
01:52:27,292 --> 01:52:30,829
close to 08:00pm. So would be

3122
01:52:30,829 --> 01:52:31,630
great to keep its the same.

3123
01:52:31,630 --> 01:52:32,331
Thank John. Better again of

3124
01:52:32,331 --> 01:52:35,331
the most prominent coaches to

3125
01:52:36,101 --> 01:52:36,802
Pfizer. Been supervisor for 17

3126
01:52:36,802 --> 01:52:39,202
years been fined helicopters

3127
01:52:40,939 --> 01:52:42,341
for 17 years. Here today for

3128
01:52:42,341 --> 01:52:43,410
the maintenance contract for

3129
01:52:43,410 --> 01:52:45,410
the helicopters. Helicopters

3130
01:52:47,790 --> 01:52:49,790
are. Maintenance intensive.

3131
01:52:49,448 --> 01:52:51,448
And specialized maintenance.

3132
01:52:51,550 --> 01:52:55,150
We put out an rfq. We're

3133
01:52:56,789 --> 01:52:57,523
asking for the same $850,000.

3134
01:52:57,523 --> 01:52:59,580
The same budget that we've had

3135
01:52:59,580 --> 01:53:02,658
for the last 6 years with no

3136
01:53:03,962 --> 01:53:04,630
increase, although. Labor

3137
01:53:04,630 --> 01:53:05,230
costs and parked cars have

3138
01:53:05,230 --> 01:53:07,630
increased, we have not

3139
01:53:07,800 --> 01:53:08,434
increased our budget. It's

3140
01:53:08,434 --> 01:53:10,834
just meant reduced flight

3141
01:53:14,807 --> 01:53:15,908
time. The two-year extension

3142
01:53:15,908 --> 01:53:18,812
is not automatic. Will have to

3143
01:53:18,812 --> 01:53:19,378
come back before you to ask

3144
01:53:19,378 --> 01:53:21,778
too, do the two-year

3145
01:53:24,316 --> 01:53:26,185
extension. It took city staff

3146
01:53:26,185 --> 01:53:27,553
8 months to get this to you.

3147
01:53:27,553 --> 01:53:29,455
So having that extention in

3148
01:53:29,455 --> 01:53:32,455
place will eliminate that. So

3149
01:53:32,491 --> 01:53:35,491
that's very helpful. Also, it

3150
01:53:36,361 --> 01:53:37,497
does lock in the manufacturer

3151
01:53:37,497 --> 01:53:40,497
to that labor rates for 4

3152
01:53:44,903 --> 01:53:48,503
years. Can save us money. So

3153
01:53:49,742 --> 01:53:51,643
your for country. I'm not

3154
01:53:51,643 --> 01:53:54,430
seeing any that Councilmember

3155
01:53:55,614 --> 01:53:57,583
Fife go ahead. I just wanted

3156
01:53:57,583 --> 01:53:58,250
to state because I've heard

3157
01:53:58,250 --> 01:53:59,251
now this presentation a few

3158
01:53:59,251 --> 01:54:01,190
times since I've been on

3159
01:54:01,190 --> 01:54:03,188
council. I think it's

3160
01:54:03,188 --> 01:54:05,588
imperative that this body

3161
01:54:05,991 --> 01:54:08,391
prioritized a fixed wing

3162
01:54:09,161 --> 01:54:10,295
aircraft fiscal purposes. But

3163
01:54:10,295 --> 01:54:11,830
as well as the environmental

3164
01:54:11,830 --> 01:54:14,830
impact that has on communities

3165
01:54:15,501 --> 01:54:18,501
that frequent, we have high

3166
01:54:19,338 --> 01:54:20,539
speed chases which I r

3167
01:54:20,539 --> 01:54:21,173
extremely dangerous and highly

3168
01:54:21,173 --> 01:54:23,173
restricted throughout the

3169
01:54:23,909 --> 01:54:26,440
state of California as being

3170
01:54:26,440 --> 01:54:28,781
potentially deadly and how a

3171
01:54:28,781 --> 01:54:30,983
fixed wing aircraft could

3172
01:54:30,983 --> 01:54:33,983
serve. Those uses. That would

3173
01:54:36,210 --> 01:54:39,458
take patrol cars out of out of

3174
01:54:39,458 --> 01:54:41,560
use when needing to engage a

3175
01:54:41,560 --> 01:54:42,628
suspect versus, you know,

3176
01:54:42,628 --> 01:54:45,280
potentially causing harm. That

3177
01:54:46,331 --> 01:54:47,320
comes from high-speed chases.

3178
01:54:47,320 --> 01:54:47,733
And since we're on the topic

3179
01:54:47,733 --> 01:54:48,700
of high-speed chases, I want

3180
01:54:48,700 --> 01:54:51,503
to say that the chase policy

3181
01:54:51,503 --> 01:54:53,106
was not a city council policy.

3182
01:54:53,106 --> 01:54:55,740
That was something that was

3183
01:54:55,740 --> 01:54:56,608
stated repeatedly over and

3184
01:54:56,608 --> 01:55:00,208
over again. It is a policy

3185
01:55:00,679 --> 01:55:02,481
that is a police department

3186
01:55:02,481 --> 01:55:05,652
policy. But that said, I think

3187
01:55:05,652 --> 01:55:06,385
it's it's important that we

3188
01:55:06,385 --> 01:55:08,785
prioritizing the next biennial

3189
01:55:11,190 --> 01:55:14,190
budget. A fixed wing aircraft

3190
01:55:15,160 --> 01:55:17,463
to save money to save lives.

3191
01:55:17,463 --> 01:55:19,863
And 2 address this outpouring

3192
01:55:20,499 --> 01:55:21,667
of funds that are consistently

3193
01:55:21,667 --> 01:55:22,568
occurring from trying to

3194
01:55:22,568 --> 01:55:25,404
maintain a piece of equipment

3195
01:55:25,404 --> 01:55:28,404
that is clearly outdated until

3196
01:55:30,142 --> 01:55:31,176
we figure out what to do about

3197
01:55:31,176 --> 01:55:33,576
incidents that do require

3198
01:55:35,948 --> 01:55:36,648
pursuit. To eliminate. All

3199
01:55:36,648 --> 01:55:39,618
needs a pursuit. We're going

3200
01:55:39,618 --> 01:55:42,200
to have some type of need for

3201
01:55:42,200 --> 01:55:44,560
equipment. And I think it.

3202
01:55:44,560 --> 01:55:45,491
We've been presented with the

3203
01:55:45,491 --> 01:55:47,891
information time and time

3204
01:55:48,927 --> 01:55:49,595
again. And just the fiscal

3205
01:55:49,595 --> 01:55:51,830
savings alone, I think are

3206
01:55:51,830 --> 01:55:52,364
important for us to consider

3207
01:55:52,364 --> 01:55:53,699
with our fiduciary

3208
01:55:53,699 --> 01:55:56,990
responsibility to this body.

3209
01:56:01,106 --> 01:56:02,341
To the city that I will move

3210
01:56:02,341 --> 01:56:05,611
this item forward, but I just

3211
01:56:05,611 --> 01:56:06,678
want to, again, just point out

3212
01:56:06,678 --> 01:56:09,214
that we are hemorrhaging money

3213
01:56:09,214 --> 01:56:12,214
from trying to maintain and

3214
01:56:12,885 --> 01:56:16,485
old piece of equipment that we

3215
01:56:16,488 --> 01:56:18,230
still have used for. And it

3216
01:56:18,230 --> 01:56:18,690
was, you Councilmember Houston

3217
01:56:18,690 --> 01:56:19,825
and I were talking about it

3218
01:56:19,825 --> 01:56:20,626
and he was like, you know,

3219
01:56:20,626 --> 01:56:21,326
that's what drones are for. I

3220
01:56:21,326 --> 01:56:22,995
do want to point out that in

3221
01:56:22,995 --> 01:56:24,995
inclement weather conditions,

3222
01:56:25,764 --> 01:56:27,660
drones are not useful. We also

3223
01:56:27,660 --> 01:56:28,634
have the issue of privacy when

3224
01:56:28,634 --> 01:56:29,335
it comes to drones. I know it

3225
01:56:29,335 --> 01:56:30,350
would go through the Privacy

3226
01:56:30,350 --> 01:56:33,350
Commission or what have you.

3227
01:56:33,439 --> 01:56:36,439
But I just we've been

3228
01:56:36,875 --> 01:56:38,744
presented enough times that

3229
01:56:38,744 --> 01:56:41,447
this is a fixed wing aircraft

3230
01:56:41,447 --> 01:56:42,514
would be a better use of

3231
01:56:42,514 --> 01:56:44,216
resources for the city. And I

3232
01:56:44,216 --> 01:56:45,484
just want to state that for

3233
01:56:45,484 --> 01:56:46,185
the record. And the

3234
01:56:46,185 --> 01:56:48,754
information is all there. You

3235
01:56:48,754 --> 01:56:51,230
can go to previous council

3236
01:56:51,230 --> 01:56:52,191
meetings previous in full

3237
01:56:52,191 --> 01:56:54,226
reports, Joe De Vries and I

3238
01:56:54,226 --> 01:56:56,295
worked on it a couple 3 years

3239
01:56:56,295 --> 01:56:56,962
ago. And so the information is

3240
01:56:56,962 --> 01:56:57,663
all there. We just need to

3241
01:56:57,663 --> 01:57:00,467
make it happen and we need to

3242
01:57:00,467 --> 01:57:02,467
prioritize it. Councilmember

3243
01:57:08,600 --> 01:57:10,409
Houston. Do and chair. He it.

3244
01:57:10,409 --> 01:57:13,445
So so I'm just So the public

3245
01:57:13,445 --> 01:57:16,115
can hear it is. The Holocaust,

3246
01:57:16,115 --> 01:57:19,151
a helicopter or what are they

3247
01:57:19,151 --> 01:57:19,818
for? What are we use them for?

3248
01:57:19,818 --> 01:57:22,818
There's many things or use

3249
01:57:22,921 --> 01:57:23,589
them for. Primarily. We see

3250
01:57:23,589 --> 01:57:27,292
them as a patrol car in the

3251
01:57:27,292 --> 01:57:29,692
sky. Whatever dispatch Census

3252
01:57:30,950 --> 01:57:31,764
2 will go to and cover. So you

3253
01:57:31,764 --> 01:57:35,364
pick the call, we can assist

3254
01:57:37,469 --> 01:57:39,370
on it. So so we have drones

3255
01:57:39,370 --> 01:57:39,772
that they say are outdated.

3256
01:57:39,772 --> 01:57:40,506
You can use that money for the

3257
01:57:40,506 --> 01:57:44,106
drones. I mean, should be able

3258
01:57:44,109 --> 01:57:45,110
to have drones that can fly.

3259
01:57:45,110 --> 01:57:46,780
And bad weather technology. We

3260
01:57:46,780 --> 01:57:48,580
can go to the moon. Come back,

3261
01:57:48,580 --> 01:57:49,915
you know, do all this right

3262
01:57:49,915 --> 01:57:50,649
along with the flock cameras,

3263
01:57:50,649 --> 01:57:54,586
can't they? I mean, if we got

3264
01:57:54,586 --> 01:57:55,220
flock and he's following. To

3265
01:57:55,220 --> 01:57:56,880
the city where we need to

3266
01:57:56,880 --> 01:57:56,688
helicopters for a fact.

3267
01:57:56,688 --> 01:57:59,880
Technology is he's been

3268
01:58:01,760 --> 01:58:02,494
upgraded. Bunch of things

3269
01:58:02,494 --> 01:58:06,940
there. I'm happy to talk about

3270
01:58:08,330 --> 01:58:08,700
your points, too. Drones and

3271
01:58:08,700 --> 01:58:11,100
helicopters are 2 items in

3272
01:58:13,720 --> 01:58:13,772
your tool box. Jones can't do.

3273
01:58:13,772 --> 01:58:14,473
A helicopters can do to help

3274
01:58:14,473 --> 01:58:16,408
countries can't do it. Drones

3275
01:58:16,408 --> 01:58:18,644
can do. So. For instance,

3276
01:58:18,644 --> 01:58:19,578
Jones are limited on the

3277
01:58:19,578 --> 01:58:22,578
distance. They can travel like

3278
01:58:23,649 --> 01:58:24,383
they can stay in the air.

3279
01:58:24,383 --> 01:58:25,500
Helicopter can stay out for an

3280
01:58:25,500 --> 01:58:28,500
extended period of time and

3281
01:58:29,922 --> 01:58:31,890
go. A farther distance. So

3282
01:58:31,890 --> 01:58:35,490
Jones can also get you. Right

3283
01:58:35,928 --> 01:58:38,764
close. Right? They can come.

3284
01:58:38,764 --> 01:58:39,431
You know, altitude right down

3285
01:58:39,431 --> 01:58:41,400
by the house or the yard or

3286
01:58:41,400 --> 01:58:42,340
wherever the call is and

3287
01:58:42,340 --> 01:58:44,340
obviously helicopter cats

3288
01:58:44,536 --> 01:58:48,136
going to stay farther up. So

3289
01:58:48,674 --> 01:58:49,675
they both have their own

3290
01:58:49,675 --> 01:58:50,409
unique distinct uses and what

3291
01:58:50,409 --> 01:58:50,943
they can be used for what they

3292
01:58:50,943 --> 01:58:52,943
can't. They're not

3293
01:58:53,746 --> 01:58:56,146
interchangeable. So so storms

3294
01:58:58,984 --> 01:59:01,384
us. Sorry, Councilmember. I

3295
01:59:01,920 --> 01:59:02,621
think one of the other

3296
01:59:02,621 --> 01:59:03,222
important mitigating factors

3297
01:59:03,222 --> 01:59:05,222
that wrong technologies

3298
01:59:05,324 --> 01:59:05,991
because it is today, sir. It

3299
01:59:05,991 --> 01:59:07,393
simply cannot maintain any

3300
01:59:07,393 --> 01:59:08,460
type of vehicle pursuits that

3301
01:59:08,460 --> 01:59:11,460
at, you know, speeds over 25

3302
01:59:11,463 --> 01:59:12,164
miles an hour. And as

3303
01:59:12,164 --> 01:59:14,564
councilmember fight that had

3304
01:59:15,330 --> 01:59:15,667
mentioned, just who they are

3305
01:59:15,667 --> 01:59:17,667
susceptible to inclement

3306
01:59:18,370 --> 01:59:19,538
weather and those limitations.

3307
01:59:19,538 --> 01:59:21,373
The helicopter or a fixed wing

3308
01:59:21,373 --> 01:59:23,308
aircraft would not be limited

3309
01:59:23,308 --> 01:59:24,420
by those. So at this point,

3310
01:59:24,420 --> 01:59:27,420
I'd technology wise drones are

3311
01:59:27,679 --> 01:59:28,580
certainly. They're up and

3312
01:59:28,580 --> 01:59:29,515
coming very quickly in terms

3313
01:59:29,515 --> 01:59:30,783
of technology increases of

3314
01:59:30,783 --> 01:59:31,483
usage and speed of things of

3315
01:59:31,483 --> 01:59:32,418
that nature. But they're not

3316
01:59:32,418 --> 01:59:34,620
there yet and they won't be

3317
01:59:34,620 --> 01:59:37,200
there for the foreseeable

3318
01:59:37,322 --> 01:59:39,258
future. The need for a

3319
01:59:39,258 --> 01:59:39,958
aircraft would optional. For

3320
01:59:39,958 --> 01:59:42,358
replacement. So last question

3321
01:59:43,462 --> 01:59:45,998
to chair, have we have we use

3322
01:59:45,998 --> 01:59:46,665
the helicopters for like

3323
01:59:46,665 --> 01:59:47,332
emergency saving someone's

3324
01:59:47,332 --> 01:59:48,634
life. Now you see it tv and

3325
01:59:48,634 --> 01:59:51,634
they say people often mouth.

3326
01:59:52,438 --> 01:59:53,705
That's a great question. The

3327
01:59:53,705 --> 01:59:54,540
helicopters, not a simple uses

3328
01:59:54,540 --> 01:59:55,274
item for local police

3329
01:59:55,274 --> 01:59:58,274
department And a great example

3330
01:59:59,945 --> 02:00:00,679
was just recently started than

3331
02:00:00,679 --> 02:00:02,140
a week and was fined. We had a

3332
02:00:02,140 --> 02:00:02,681
young lady. She felt she was

3333
02:00:02,681 --> 02:00:04,717
on a hike in the hills. She

3334
02:00:04,717 --> 02:00:06,785
and fell into ditch. She

3335
02:00:06,785 --> 02:00:08,785
requested assistance and

3336
02:00:08,787 --> 02:00:09,489
thanks to his expertise as

3337
02:00:09,489 --> 02:00:12,124
well as coordination with the

3338
02:00:12,124 --> 02:00:12,791
patrol division that the heir

3339
02:00:12,791 --> 02:00:14,693
to actually found her in in

3340
02:00:14,693 --> 02:00:17,229
the ditch with fallen directed

3341
02:00:17,229 --> 02:00:19,629
units and actually assisted

3342
02:00:22,367 --> 02:00:23,569
her back to safety. So to the

3343
02:00:23,569 --> 02:00:24,136
chair, you have to share those

3344
02:00:24,136 --> 02:00:24,837
stories. It's ironic

3345
02:00:24,837 --> 02:00:27,272
councilmember that the p I o

3346
02:00:27,272 --> 02:00:28,407
is actually putting that story

3347
02:00:28,407 --> 02:00:29,374
hopefully tomorrow. So so

3348
02:00:29,374 --> 02:00:30,242
those things that people need

3349
02:00:30,242 --> 02:00:33,242
to hear those as real-life

3350
02:00:34,813 --> 02:00:35,514
stories like, wow, if just

3351
02:00:35,514 --> 02:00:37,483
save somebodys life mifa they

3352
02:00:37,483 --> 02:00:39,752
cut because it used to those

3353
02:00:39,752 --> 02:00:42,221
stories need to be heard. So

3354
02:00:42,221 --> 02:00:45,221
this is why we need

3355
02:00:45,224 --> 02:00:47,493
helicopter. All right, ok?

3356
02:00:47,493 --> 02:00:49,893
Council member Brown. All

3357
02:00:50,529 --> 02:00:54,129
right. Well, I don't I'm not

3358
02:00:54,166 --> 02:00:54,867
going tried put a downer on

3359
02:00:54,867 --> 02:00:58,404
this, but gonna up live some

3360
02:00:58,404 --> 02:00:59,571
some some research that we

3361
02:00:59,571 --> 02:01:00,639
were able to find on this item

3362
02:01:00,639 --> 02:01:02,107
and kind of as it was already

3363
02:01:02,107 --> 02:01:03,976
stated. Sounds like we need to

3364
02:01:03,976 --> 02:01:06,376
move towards this investment

3365
02:01:06,745 --> 02:01:07,679
in the an alternative. But I

3366
02:01:07,679 --> 02:01:10,149
just wanted to flag for

3367
02:01:10,149 --> 02:01:12,549
everyone's awareness that this

3368
02:01:13,685 --> 02:01:16,850
particular group rsi in 2000,

3369
02:01:16,221 --> 02:01:18,157
maybe it's on your radar. They

3370
02:01:18,157 --> 02:01:19,992
actually there was a

3371
02:01:19,992 --> 02:01:20,893
50 million dollar wrongful

3372
02:01:20,893 --> 02:01:22,995
death lawsuit about from a

3373
02:01:22,995 --> 02:01:25,995
fatal crash that happened in

3374
02:01:27,200 --> 02:01:30,690
the Hills fire Fresno. And it

3375
02:01:30,690 --> 02:01:30,904
had to do with like

3376
02:01:30,904 --> 02:01:32,838
maintenance issues around,

3377
02:01:32,838 --> 02:01:35,238
like hydraulic issues before

3378
02:01:36,141 --> 02:01:36,742
the crash. And so in

3379
02:01:36,742 --> 02:01:37,910
investigating that they

3380
02:01:37,910 --> 02:01:38,710
actually found that it was, in

3381
02:01:38,710 --> 02:01:40,712
fact, like a wrongful death

3382
02:01:40,712 --> 02:01:42,470
due to like some maintenance

3383
02:01:42,470 --> 02:01:44,316
complications. So just wanted

3384
02:01:44,316 --> 02:01:45,984
to put that on the radar I

3385
02:01:45,984 --> 02:01:48,687
know that we continue to

3386
02:01:48,687 --> 02:01:51,124
invest time and time and

3387
02:01:51,124 --> 02:01:52,891
keeping this helicopter

3388
02:01:52,891 --> 02:01:53,525
operational. But I do think

3389
02:01:53,525 --> 02:01:54,359
that we MAY be at a point

3390
02:01:54,359 --> 02:01:57,959
where we want to invest in

3391
02:01:59,980 --> 02:02:02,980
something that would be better

3392
02:02:06,505 --> 02:02:07,172
long term I just I just want

3393
02:02:07,172 --> 02:02:09,208
to say it I'm not sure that

3394
02:02:09,208 --> 02:02:12,808
that case was on your radar

3395
02:02:13,645 --> 02:02:16,645
happened in 2000. The air unit

3396
02:02:17,383 --> 02:02:20,219
has a very strict policy in

3397
02:02:20,219 --> 02:02:20,819
terms of maintenance and

3398
02:02:20,819 --> 02:02:21,520
operational of modality

3399
02:02:21,520 --> 02:02:22,187
everyday started being a week

3400
02:02:22,187 --> 02:02:22,721
his team, the Golden Speck

3401
02:02:22,721 --> 02:02:24,721
helicopter, Dupree

3402
02:02:25,691 --> 02:02:27,691
inspections, post inspections,

3403
02:02:28,327 --> 02:02:30,229
which again to the fact that

3404
02:02:30,229 --> 02:02:32,464
helicopter is not simply

3405
02:02:32,464 --> 02:02:33,766
maintenance cost situation,

3406
02:02:33,766 --> 02:02:34,333
but also labor, intense

3407
02:02:34,333 --> 02:02:36,635
situation. But we do

3408
02:02:36,635 --> 02:02:37,803
appreciate you bringing that

3409
02:02:37,803 --> 02:02:38,738
they through decades of

3410
02:02:38,738 --> 02:02:40,572
experience have actually

3411
02:02:40,572 --> 02:02:41,206
learned and they have, in

3412
02:02:41,206 --> 02:02:41,907
fact, caught maintenance

3413
02:02:41,907 --> 02:02:42,541
challenges before they go up

3414
02:02:42,541 --> 02:02:43,175
in the air. So we're very

3415
02:02:43,175 --> 02:02:45,575
cognizant of that public

3416
02:02:47,479 --> 02:02:48,680
safety. Great. Thank you.

3417
02:02:48,680 --> 02:02:50,680
Colleagues Councilmember

3418
02:02:51,517 --> 02:02:53,852
Houston. More question to

3419
02:02:53,852 --> 02:02:56,252
chair. What years that

3420
02:02:56,422 --> 02:02:58,822
helicopter. So 2 units the

3421
02:03:00,159 --> 02:03:01,693
first one is 1990. Was what I

3422
02:03:01,693 --> 02:03:03,362
was in middle school and the

3423
02:03:03,362 --> 02:03:06,362
next one answer is 1993, ok,

3424
02:03:08,670 --> 02:03:09,902
cool, cool, cool. So I have a

3425
02:03:09,902 --> 02:03:11,904
question. What is the cost a

3426
02:03:11,904 --> 02:03:14,904
new helicopter? Top of line,

3427
02:03:17,476 --> 02:03:18,177
top of so the replacement cost

3428
02:03:18,177 --> 02:03:18,844
of brand new helicopter, sir,

3429
02:03:18,844 --> 02:03:19,445
would be 1 million dollars

3430
02:03:19,445 --> 02:03:22,445
more than a fixed wing

3431
02:03:23,549 --> 02:03:24,483
aircraft. 1 million dollars

3432
02:03:24,483 --> 02:03:26,483
more. Correct. 6 million

3433
02:03:26,885 --> 02:03:28,754
dollars or 6 Million? Correct?

3434
02:03:28,754 --> 02:03:29,455
Okay. How much does it cost to

3435
02:03:29,455 --> 02:03:31,855
maintain that helicopter per

3436
02:03:35,828 --> 02:03:36,695
year? Goes to those $250,000.

3437
02:03:36,695 --> 02:03:40,295
850, okay. So we just and how

3438
02:03:40,365 --> 02:03:43,365
long we've been doing this.

3439
02:03:45,370 --> 02:03:48,370
Their over 37 All right. So

3440
02:03:49,174 --> 02:03:49,875
great. I know what to do. And

3441
02:03:49,875 --> 02:03:50,576
the for the fixed wing

3442
02:03:50,576 --> 02:03:53,576
aircraft. What is the upfront

3443
02:03:53,779 --> 02:03:56,779
cost versus the annual packs?

3444
02:03:57,450 --> 02:03:59,118
5 million for an airplane and

3445
02:03:59,118 --> 02:04:02,118
we fully support lead relive

3446
02:04:03,122 --> 02:04:03,956
airplane. Also. And, you know,

3447
02:04:03,956 --> 02:04:05,224
what is the annual ongoing

3448
02:04:05,224 --> 02:04:08,224
maintenance costs of the fixed

3449
02:04:09,461 --> 02:04:12,931
wing aircraft? It'll be a 3rd.

3450
02:04:12,931 --> 02:04:14,466
One-third, ok? So 850,000 3,

3451
02:04:14,466 --> 02:04:16,466
correct? Correct. Calculation

3452
02:04:16,635 --> 02:04:17,336
that we did is that the fixed

3453
02:04:17,336 --> 02:04:17,970
wing aircraft dependent upon

3454
02:04:17,970 --> 02:04:19,970
financing options should

3455
02:04:20,939 --> 02:04:22,400
actually pay for itself in as

3456
02:04:22,400 --> 02:04:25,400
little 15 years of that. But

3457
02:04:25,177 --> 02:04:26,110
if you pay for cash would be

3458
02:04:26,110 --> 02:04:28,110
significantly less the

3459
02:04:28,814 --> 02:04:29,615
maintenance savings are are so

3460
02:04:29,615 --> 02:04:31,483
significant that by the time

3461
02:04:31,483 --> 02:04:32,217
to 37 years that we've paying

3462
02:04:32,217 --> 02:04:35,817
for for a rotary aircraft, you

3463
02:04:37,623 --> 02:04:38,323
could at 2 aircraft in service

3464
02:04:38,323 --> 02:04:38,991
at the city of Oakland with a

3465
02:04:38,991 --> 02:04:41,391
life expectancy of over 40

3466
02:04:43,862 --> 02:04:44,530
years, each as opposed to 10.

3467
02:04:44,530 --> 02:04:45,230
That's noteworthy. Just to

3468
02:04:45,230 --> 02:04:47,660
play a little bit of devil's

3469
02:04:47,660 --> 02:04:48,333
advocate. I support the idea,

3470
02:04:48,333 --> 02:04:50,102
but I guess like it's hard for

3471
02:04:50,102 --> 02:04:52,237
me understand for a fixed wing

3472
02:04:52,237 --> 02:04:53,972
aircraft. Do we need an

3473
02:04:53,972 --> 02:04:54,640
airplane like has earned

3474
02:04:54,640 --> 02:04:55,941
airport like how does that

3475
02:04:55,941 --> 02:04:58,877
work in terms of deployment?

3476
02:04:58,877 --> 02:05:00,913
Does it? Because I imagine

3477
02:05:00,913 --> 02:05:02,448
helicopter you know, lift off

3478
02:05:02,448 --> 02:05:03,480
from a helipad, but an

3479
02:05:03,480 --> 02:05:05,480
airplane requires more

3480
02:05:05,851 --> 02:05:07,186
runways. So how does that

3481
02:05:07,186 --> 02:05:09,880
work? Does it require more

3482
02:05:09,880 --> 02:05:11,523
travel time then for opd in

3483
02:05:11,523 --> 02:05:13,692
the case of an emergency

3484
02:05:13,692 --> 02:05:14,393
situation. Our helicopters are

3485
02:05:14,393 --> 02:05:15,600
currently makes to the local

3486
02:05:15,600 --> 02:05:17,460
airport and they're playing

3487
02:05:17,696 --> 02:05:19,631
also be based there. Okay,

3488
02:05:19,631 --> 02:05:20,966
great. And then in the sun air

3489
02:05:20,966 --> 02:05:22,601
that you described, which is

3490
02:05:22,601 --> 02:05:25,601
rescuing woman from the hills,

3491
02:05:26,572 --> 02:05:27,272
can a fixed wing aircraft

3492
02:05:27,272 --> 02:05:29,672
because, again, I'm imagining

3493
02:05:29,808 --> 02:05:31,810
this is just don't civilian

3494
02:05:31,810 --> 02:05:34,790
where helicopter can stays

3495
02:05:34,790 --> 02:05:34,747
static above the person. Can

3496
02:05:34,747 --> 02:05:36,415
the fixed wing aircraft do

3497
02:05:36,415 --> 02:05:39,415
something similar? Does it do?

3498
02:05:40,119 --> 02:05:40,753
We require still helicopter

3499
02:05:40,753 --> 02:05:42,821
equipment to do some sort

3500
02:05:42,821 --> 02:05:45,290
rescue like that the airplane

3501
02:05:45,290 --> 02:05:47,626
will fly and Orbitz and they

3502
02:05:47,626 --> 02:05:51,226
will be able look and direct.

3503
02:05:51,797 --> 02:05:52,631
Ground units to the victim.

3504
02:05:52,631 --> 02:05:54,660
Okay. Know they will not be

3505
02:05:54,660 --> 02:05:54,833
able to do the actual rescue

3506
02:05:54,833 --> 02:05:57,833
rescue. Okay. But it sounds

3507
02:05:58,270 --> 02:05:58,904
like ground units could have

3508
02:05:58,904 --> 02:06:01,904
the capacity to do that.

3509
02:06:04,377 --> 02:06:05,430
Correct, Okay. Go ahead.

3510
02:06:05,430 --> 02:06:07,443
Councilmember. He got let's

3511
02:06:08,213 --> 02:06:09,581
wrap it Last question. The

3512
02:06:09,581 --> 02:06:11,283
mobility is different. I mean,

3513
02:06:11,283 --> 02:06:12,284
if you in helicopter, you can

3514
02:06:12,284 --> 02:06:13,318
just stop you come back up

3515
02:06:13,318 --> 02:06:13,986
mobile in the aircraft. You

3516
02:06:13,986 --> 02:06:17,586
got to go around and around

3517
02:06:18,230 --> 02:06:18,657
and around. That's part of the

3518
02:06:18,657 --> 02:06:19,259
noise aspect also. So the

3519
02:06:19,259 --> 02:06:20,993
airplane is going to be

3520
02:06:20,993 --> 02:06:21,727
significantly higher fly

3521
02:06:21,727 --> 02:06:23,195
significantly higher than what

3522
02:06:23,195 --> 02:06:26,195
the helicopter does. So you're

3523
02:06:26,799 --> 02:06:27,566
not going to hear it. But the

3524
02:06:27,566 --> 02:06:28,834
airplane is going to have a a

3525
02:06:28,834 --> 02:06:30,169
significant camera on board

3526
02:06:30,169 --> 02:06:30,869
and that's how the job will be

3527
02:06:30,869 --> 02:06:32,938
performed is that the camera

3528
02:06:32,938 --> 02:06:34,840
will look down and make the

3529
02:06:34,840 --> 02:06:37,676
radio call ask questions. So

3530
02:06:37,676 --> 02:06:39,979
who's going operate this,

3531
02:06:39,979 --> 02:06:41,980
which big swing, put lot great

3532
02:06:41,980 --> 02:06:44,980
day. Our pilots. How many

3533
02:06:50,856 --> 02:06:51,590
pause? With a red one's is

3534
02:06:51,590 --> 02:06:52,224
operating with a rather have a

3535
02:06:52,224 --> 02:06:55,824
fixed. I have a brand new

3536
02:06:59,131 --> 02:06:59,832
helicopter. I would say that

3537
02:06:59,832 --> 02:07:00,499
week's travel working on this

3538
02:07:00,499 --> 02:07:03,499
project with the council as

3539
02:07:04,203 --> 02:07:05,170
well started in a week. And of

3540
02:07:05,170 --> 02:07:06,939
course, the helicopter is one

3541
02:07:06,939 --> 02:07:08,173
of those tools that is funded

3542
02:07:08,173 --> 02:07:09,675
rifle case. Its you need to

3543
02:07:09,675 --> 02:07:10,375
take specific skill set. So is

3544
02:07:10,375 --> 02:07:13,512
actually in terms of just job

3545
02:07:13,512 --> 02:07:14,246
satisfaction fun. The aircraft

3546
02:07:14,246 --> 02:07:15,848
so advanced that a twin engine

3547
02:07:15,848 --> 02:07:17,182
aircraft to the very low

3548
02:07:17,182 --> 02:07:21,382
profile that it is so safe for

3549
02:07:23,422 --> 02:07:23,956
pets with flies itself. You

3550
02:07:23,956 --> 02:07:26,356
want to second that

3551
02:07:29,328 --> 02:07:31,328
councilmember Houston. Moving

3552
02:07:31,497 --> 02:07:33,532
speaking. Sorry, moving to

3553
02:07:33,532 --> 02:07:34,660
public speakers calling him

3554
02:07:34,660 --> 02:07:37,660
the name that up to

3555
02:07:37,302 --> 02:07:38,360
speak on item number 7 errors

3556
02:07:38,360 --> 02:07:38,704
done just few rows. My thought

3557
02:07:38,704 --> 02:07:42,304
on the ball and Blair, big

3558
02:07:46,412 --> 02:07:47,746
man. Jesse Rose. More upside,

3559
02:07:47,746 --> 02:07:48,380
though pd just said they want

3560
02:07:48,380 --> 02:07:50,380
these helicopters because

3561
02:07:51,830 --> 02:07:53,483
they're fun to drive 1.7

3562
02:07:55,554 --> 02:07:56,255
million for why it like, like

3563
02:07:56,255 --> 02:07:57,356
I said to be in the meeting,

3564
02:07:57,356 --> 02:07:57,956
we could be civilian icing. I

3565
02:07:57,956 --> 02:08:00,956
have Pte. All right. I

3566
02:08:01,427 --> 02:08:03,162
civilian. I seen desk jobs at

3567
02:08:03,162 --> 02:08:05,197
opd. We could be looking into

3568
02:08:05,197 --> 02:08:05,864
their overtime fraud and then

3569
02:08:05,864 --> 02:08:06,699
we we could have the money

3570
02:08:06,699 --> 02:08:09,368
that you're going back and

3571
02:08:09,368 --> 02:08:12,172
forth about and debate about.

3572
02:08:12,172 --> 02:08:13,439
Their staff report says Page

3573
02:08:13,439 --> 02:08:14,407
3, these helicopters will be

3574
02:08:14,407 --> 02:08:16,109
used to surveil and intimidate

3575
02:08:16,109 --> 02:08:16,809
protesters. It's right in So

3576
02:08:16,809 --> 02:08:17,476
it's that they're going to do

3577
02:08:17,476 --> 02:08:19,711
that with these helicopters

3578
02:08:19,711 --> 02:08:21,130
just like they're doing with

3579
02:08:21,130 --> 02:08:21,847
Flock Councilmember one, you

3580
02:08:21,847 --> 02:08:23,782
want this mean and early but

3581
02:08:23,782 --> 02:08:25,951
east not flocking on the the

3582
02:08:25,951 --> 02:08:27,486
agenda. And I think you were

3583
02:08:27,486 --> 02:08:28,253
here when Ken Houston, I

3584
02:08:28,253 --> 02:08:28,921
flipped us off and fell asleep

3585
02:08:28,921 --> 02:08:31,156
on both of those. He means

3586
02:08:31,156 --> 02:08:33,158
when Flock was here before. So

3587
02:08:33,158 --> 02:08:33,826
here we are again. How do you

3588
02:08:33,826 --> 02:08:34,626
expect this mean? And at 8

3589
02:08:34,626 --> 02:08:37,260
o'clock when there's touch

3590
02:08:38,397 --> 02:08:39,298
such nonsense by the opd on

3591
02:08:39,298 --> 02:08:40,432
this agenda, who does this

3592
02:08:40,432 --> 02:08:41,300
council serve? Sam Singer, the

3593
02:08:41,300 --> 02:08:41,967
people of Oakland. That's what

3594
02:08:41,967 --> 02:08:45,567
we want to know. Where seen

3595
02:08:50,409 --> 02:08:52,809
what's happening here? Hello

3596
02:08:56,482 --> 02:08:58,584
Council airs Don. We do. I do

3597
02:08:58,584 --> 02:08:59,319
love that. Councilmember Brown

3598
02:08:59,319 --> 02:09:02,319
account. Number 5, you want to

3599
02:09:02,321 --> 02:09:03,210
lower the cost of what we are

3600
02:09:03,210 --> 02:09:04,123
spending and make it so that

3601
02:09:04,123 --> 02:09:07,123
we are actually helping the

3602
02:09:07,760 --> 02:09:08,761
people of Oakland. There are

3603
02:09:08,761 --> 02:09:10,396
ways to, quote, lower

3604
02:09:10,396 --> 02:09:11,630
emergency room visits by 80%

3605
02:09:11,630 --> 02:09:13,465
reduced the number of jail

3606
02:09:13,465 --> 02:09:14,533
days by 130%, reduce

3607
02:09:14,533 --> 02:09:15,401
probability of committing

3608
02:09:15,401 --> 02:09:17,503
crime by 80% and increase the

3609
02:09:17,503 --> 02:09:19,438
probability of employment by

3610
02:09:19,438 --> 02:09:20,139
24%. None of them are funding

3611
02:09:20,139 --> 02:09:23,139
helicopters. None of them are

3612
02:09:23,342 --> 02:09:25,342
funding surveillance cameras.

3613
02:09:25,544 --> 02:09:27,579
What they are is public income

3614
02:09:27,579 --> 02:09:29,381
programs, things that will

3615
02:09:29,381 --> 02:09:30,349
actually provide income

3616
02:09:30,349 --> 02:09:32,384
through employment or public

3617
02:09:32,384 --> 02:09:33,319
benefits to the people of

3618
02:09:33,319 --> 02:09:33,986
Oakland, access to care,

3619
02:09:33,986 --> 02:09:34,653
whether it's health care,

3620
02:09:34,653 --> 02:09:35,254
mental health services and

3621
02:09:35,254 --> 02:09:36,722
substance abuse. Use a

3622
02:09:36,722 --> 02:09:39,122
substance use treatment. All

3623
02:09:40,192 --> 02:09:41,393
of these things have actual

3624
02:09:41,393 --> 02:09:42,294
research effect that are

3625
02:09:42,294 --> 02:09:42,961
beneficial for the people of

3626
02:09:42,961 --> 02:09:44,763
Oakland. And I think those

3627
02:09:44,763 --> 02:09:46,799
should be prioritized over

3628
02:09:46,799 --> 02:09:48,467
equipment. That is fun to

3629
02:09:48,467 --> 02:09:49,102
drive for the people of

3630
02:09:49,102 --> 02:09:49,802
Oakland for the people of

3631
02:09:49,802 --> 02:09:53,402
Oakland. This is what we need

3632
02:09:56,175 --> 02:09:58,911
to do. Thank you. Thank you

3633
02:09:58,911 --> 02:10:02,511
for your service. That a lot

3634
02:10:03,480 --> 02:10:03,917
of issues with police. But I

3635
02:10:03,917 --> 02:10:05,751
realize we need your service.

3636
02:10:05,751 --> 02:10:07,519
See some of these people out

3637
02:10:07,519 --> 02:10:08,220
here when certain things

3638
02:10:08,220 --> 02:10:11,560
happen, you know, did it all

3639
02:10:11,560 --> 02:10:12,825
call? They all call you? If

3640
02:10:12,825 --> 02:10:15,260
they get robbed or something

3641
02:10:15,260 --> 02:10:16,929
going on. But anyway,

3642
02:10:16,929 --> 02:10:18,231
appreciate your conversation

3643
02:10:18,231 --> 02:10:19,565
about the chase thing. That's

3644
02:10:19,565 --> 02:10:20,332
one of the most important

3645
02:10:20,332 --> 02:10:22,732
aspects of having the

3646
02:10:22,936 --> 02:10:25,336
availability of these cops

3647
02:10:26,805 --> 02:10:27,573
because we can't do the chase

3648
02:10:27,573 --> 02:10:30,573
They can come up broad

3649
02:10:30,809 --> 02:10:31,477
spectrum of territory of

3650
02:10:31,477 --> 02:10:33,846
Somebodys kidnapped. We got

3651
02:10:33,846 --> 02:10:36,715
out and were alert. You can

3652
02:10:36,715 --> 02:10:38,484
follow They drawbacks with the

3653
02:10:38,484 --> 02:10:40,386
expenses that is involved with

3654
02:10:40,386 --> 02:10:41,920
it. But we have cities like

3655
02:10:41,920 --> 02:10:44,857
Los Angeles, San Diego, San

3656
02:10:44,857 --> 02:10:46,857
Jose, Sacramento, Stockton,

3657
02:10:48,360 --> 02:10:50,760
Pasadena. And other cities

3658
02:10:52,564 --> 02:10:53,232
that have invested in us. And

3659
02:10:53,232 --> 02:10:54,500
does have a service quality

3660
02:10:54,500 --> 02:10:56,900
service that exists its

3661
02:10:58,537 --> 02:10:59,204
expensive bill. And from my

3662
02:10:59,204 --> 02:11:01,807
perspective, if we can keep

3663
02:11:01,807 --> 02:11:02,508
it, I would like to keep it.

3664
02:11:02,508 --> 02:11:05,508
Thank you for your comments.

3665
02:11:06,745 --> 02:11:09,145
Missile Apollo. Switching to

3666
02:11:09,481 --> 02:11:12,481
zoom user Blair, you yourself.

3667
02:11:14,486 --> 02:11:16,550
I big Ben. We're talking about

3668
02:11:16,550 --> 02:11:18,455
important policy to beach

3669
02:11:20,159 --> 02:11:22,261
item, I really you know, city

3670
02:11:22,261 --> 02:11:25,970
of Oakland, City Council and

3671
02:11:25,970 --> 02:11:26,165
an opd really take the time

3672
02:11:26,165 --> 02:11:28,000
and care to want to better

3673
02:11:28,000 --> 02:11:28,700
explain to the public what

3674
02:11:28,700 --> 02:11:31,570
exactly is going on with the

3675
02:11:31,570 --> 02:11:32,204
current contract process. You

3676
02:11:32,204 --> 02:11:34,604
guys keeping that really,

3677
02:11:35,740 --> 02:11:36,410
really a we try to practice

3678
02:11:36,410 --> 02:11:37,309
how to be accessible with the

3679
02:11:37,309 --> 02:11:40,309
public on the subject and

3680
02:11:44,216 --> 02:11:47,419
accountable. This item So so I

3681
02:11:47,419 --> 02:11:49,421
I I my personal feeling

3682
02:11:49,421 --> 02:11:52,558
helicopters can be a bit more

3683
02:11:52,558 --> 02:11:53,859
flexible. Picks wing aircraft.

3684
02:11:53,859 --> 02:11:56,361
But I don't know the full

3685
02:11:56,361 --> 02:11:57,620
story. It sounds like picks

3686
02:11:57,620 --> 02:11:57,796
pick. Spring has been slowly

3687
02:11:57,796 --> 02:11:58,597
developing here in Oakland for

3688
02:11:58,597 --> 02:12:00,566
a while where I have

3689
02:12:00,566 --> 02:12:04,166
understand it yet. And so I'm

3690
02:12:04,570 --> 02:12:06,605
just starting to. But I hope

3691
02:12:06,605 --> 02:12:07,272
we respect the maneuverability

3692
02:12:07,272 --> 02:12:09,272
and flexibility helicopters

3693
02:12:13,445 --> 02:12:14,179
can offer. Thank you for your

3694
02:12:14,179 --> 02:12:16,579
comments chair. That concludes

3695
02:12:19,318 --> 02:12:20,586
all speakers on this item. Go

3696
02:12:20,586 --> 02:12:21,954
ahead. Councilmember Houston.

3697
02:12:21,954 --> 02:12:22,654
I just want to thank the

3698
02:12:22,654 --> 02:12:23,322
officers for coming in share

3699
02:12:23,322 --> 02:12:24,456
with them. That is nothing

3700
02:12:24,456 --> 02:12:27,360
wrong with enjoying your job.

3701
02:12:27,360 --> 02:12:30,280
Nothing wrong with that, sir.

3702
02:12:30,280 --> 02:12:30,696
And I do the pursuit and chase

3703
02:12:30,696 --> 02:12:33,696
policy because it has been

3704
02:12:33,899 --> 02:12:36,299
effective. Great. Let's move

3705
02:12:36,435 --> 02:12:37,302
to the vote. Thank you. We

3706
02:12:37,302 --> 02:12:39,104
have a motion made by

3707
02:12:39,104 --> 02:12:41,390
Councilmember 5 0nd by

3708
02:12:41,390 --> 02:12:41,874
Councilmember Houston to put

3709
02:12:41,874 --> 02:12:42,574
the record we move Councilor

3710
02:12:42,574 --> 02:12:43,809
5, give a comment or question

3711
02:12:43,809 --> 02:12:46,812
on this item. Just need to

3712
02:12:46,812 --> 02:12:49,782
extend the meeting. Make a

3713
02:12:49,782 --> 02:12:52,782
motion to extend the meeting.

3714
02:12:55,988 --> 02:12:56,889
Do we have to? It what time?

3715
02:12:56,889 --> 02:12:58,757
Okay. Sounds like we don't

3716
02:12:58,757 --> 02:13:00,692
have to do until 09:00pm 9.

3717
02:13:00,692 --> 02:13:02,895
Make it for 9 because we're

3718
02:13:02,895 --> 02:13:05,895
going to be here tonight.

3719
02:13:08,700 --> 02:13:11,700
Let's take the vote. Thank

3720
02:13:12,571 --> 02:13:14,574
you. We have a motion made

3721
02:13:14,574 --> 02:13:15,207
Councilmember 5 0nd delay,

3722
02:13:15,207 --> 02:13:16,642
Councilmember Houston to

3723
02:13:16,642 --> 02:13:17,342
approve the recommendations of

3724
02:13:17,342 --> 02:13:18,277
staff and board this item to

3725
02:13:18,277 --> 02:13:19,120
the JULY 20 for City Council

3726
02:13:19,120 --> 02:13:21,412
agenda on real councilmembers.

3727
02:13:23,415 --> 02:13:24,983
Brown. I buy use endure one. I

3728
02:13:24,983 --> 02:13:25,684
think you motion passes with

3729
02:13:25,684 --> 02:13:26,318
4. I support this item to the

3730
02:13:26,318 --> 02:13:28,718
JULY 20 per City Council.

3731
02:13:29,621 --> 02:13:30,289
Jenna, on consent item 8 was

3732
02:13:30,289 --> 02:13:32,689
already dispensed with. Now

3733
02:13:34,827 --> 02:13:35,561
reading in item number 9.

3734
02:13:35,561 --> 02:13:36,628
Adopt a resolution authorizing

3735
02:13:36,628 --> 02:13:37,663
the city administrator to

3736
02:13:37,663 --> 02:13:38,263
enter into memorandum of

3737
02:13:38,263 --> 02:13:40,263
understanding with the

3738
02:13:40,833 --> 02:13:41,433
California Highway Patrol to

3739
02:13:41,433 --> 02:13:42,340
some a vehicle accident

3740
02:13:42,340 --> 02:13:44,340
reports electronically

3741
02:13:44,136 --> 02:13:46,138
pursuant to be a vehicle code.

3742
02:13:46,138 --> 02:13:46,839
Section 2, 0, 0, 0, 8, And

3743
02:13:46,839 --> 02:13:49,839
there are 3 speakers on this

3744
02:13:54,913 --> 02:13:57,913
item. All right. Let's call

3745
02:13:58,317 --> 02:13:58,985
them use up here. Good

3746
02:13:58,985 --> 02:13:59,752
evening, councilmembers and

3747
02:13:59,752 --> 02:14:00,486
members of the public

3748
02:14:00,486 --> 02:14:02,321
warnings. The sauce was on the

3749
02:14:02,321 --> 02:14:03,389
deputy chief of the bill risk

3750
02:14:03,389 --> 02:14:05,789
management. It and tonight

3751
02:14:05,991 --> 02:14:08,391
presenting to you requesting

3752
02:14:08,660 --> 02:14:10,950
council to enter into it.

3753
02:14:10,950 --> 02:14:12,950
Memorandum of understanding

3754
02:14:13,766 --> 02:14:15,234
with chp regarding our

3755
02:14:15,234 --> 02:14:16,802
collision data. So I'm not

3756
02:14:16,802 --> 02:14:17,569
sure how many of you are.

3757
02:14:17,569 --> 02:14:19,204
Alright, everybody understands

3758
02:14:19,204 --> 02:14:20,205
where we're at with our record

3759
02:14:20,205 --> 02:14:22,605
management system. We are

3760
02:14:23,242 --> 02:14:24,576
doing an upgrade to a record

3761
02:14:24,576 --> 02:14:26,578
management system long overdo

3762
02:14:26,578 --> 02:14:28,380
At least my career of 26 plus

3763
02:14:28,380 --> 02:14:29,848
years. We've had the same

3764
02:14:29,848 --> 02:14:32,618
system. So now we're upgrading

3765
02:14:32,618 --> 02:14:34,620
to mark 43, which will be the

3766
02:14:34,620 --> 02:14:35,954
overseer of our record

3767
02:14:35,954 --> 02:14:37,823
management system. And in

3768
02:14:37,823 --> 02:14:40,259
doing that, we're going to

3769
02:14:40,259 --> 02:14:42,361
have crash data, which is a

3770
02:14:42,361 --> 02:14:43,395
piece of there, Marc, 40

3771
02:14:43,395 --> 02:14:44,129
threes program. What this is

3772
02:14:44,129 --> 02:14:47,566
going to allow us to do with

3773
02:14:47,566 --> 02:14:48,834
this memorandum of

3774
02:14:48,834 --> 02:14:49,568
understanding is right now.

3775
02:14:49,568 --> 02:14:51,437
Currently, we literally have a

3776
02:14:51,437 --> 02:14:52,671
person that makes photocopies

3777
02:14:52,671 --> 02:14:54,473
of each and every one of our

3778
02:14:54,473 --> 02:14:55,140
collision reports put it in an

3779
02:14:55,140 --> 02:14:58,740
envelope, put a stamp on it

3780
02:14:58,911 --> 02:14:59,812
and put it in the mail. This

3781
02:14:59,812 --> 02:15:02,414
will now allow us to send this

3782
02:15:02,414 --> 02:15:03,615
data and the chronically. So

3783
02:15:03,615 --> 02:15:06,251
as soon as the report is

3784
02:15:06,251 --> 02:15:07,553
approved by the investigators

3785
02:15:07,553 --> 02:15:08,120
and any sites citations that

3786
02:15:08,120 --> 02:15:09,888
were issued from the

3787
02:15:09,888 --> 02:15:12,124
collision, that all gets put

3788
02:15:12,124 --> 02:15:12,991
in. It literally gets sent to

3789
02:15:12,991 --> 02:15:15,391
the system and its

3790
02:15:15,728 --> 02:15:16,462
electronically sent to chp.

3791
02:15:16,462 --> 02:15:19,462
This is important because this

3792
02:15:20,165 --> 02:15:21,667
is where dot get all of their

3793
02:15:21,667 --> 02:15:22,267
information through sweaters,

3794
02:15:22,267 --> 02:15:24,690
which is the statewide

3795
02:15:24,690 --> 02:15:25,700
integration traffic reporting

3796
02:15:25,700 --> 02:15:25,771
system, right? So this is

3797
02:15:25,771 --> 02:15:29,371
where we get our high injury

3798
02:15:30,342 --> 02:15:32,211
network. This is where we draw

3799
02:15:32,211 --> 02:15:32,945
from what intersection to the

3800
02:15:32,945 --> 02:15:36,348
most dangerous. What can we do

3801
02:15:36,348 --> 02:15:37,150
to make them better? How do we

3802
02:15:37,150 --> 02:15:38,751
slow them down? So this is

3803
02:15:38,751 --> 02:15:40,452
just absolutely no cost.

3804
02:15:40,452 --> 02:15:42,154
There's no cost involved in

3805
02:15:42,154 --> 02:15:45,154
this. It literally just takes

3806
02:15:45,324 --> 02:15:46,240
are handwritten reports. Mixon

3807
02:15:46,240 --> 02:15:49,395
Digital and we get to send in

3808
02:15:49,395 --> 02:15:52,264
the chp. It'll save us a lot

3809
02:15:52,264 --> 02:15:52,931
of labor hours. So that they

3810
02:15:52,931 --> 02:15:54,800
can do other things with in

3811
02:15:54,800 --> 02:15:57,603
traffic and catch up. Cut

3812
02:15:57,603 --> 02:15:58,303
right into it. A technical

3813
02:15:58,303 --> 02:16:00,305
adviser that'll help me with

3814
02:16:00,305 --> 02:16:00,906
any technical programming

3815
02:16:00,906 --> 02:16:03,306
officer pull into this,

3816
02:16:04,420 --> 02:16:04,743
helping with that. But that's

3817
02:16:04,743 --> 02:16:05,444
basically it and kind of make

3818
02:16:05,444 --> 02:16:09,248
a fast wide. It is quickly as

3819
02:16:09,248 --> 02:16:09,916
I could. Great. And is this

3820
02:16:09,916 --> 02:16:12,180
actually there was some

3821
02:16:12,180 --> 02:16:14,153
reporting earlier this year

3822
02:16:14,153 --> 02:16:15,320
on, you know, an excessive

3823
02:16:15,320 --> 02:16:15,988
amount of overtime. Was it

3824
02:16:15,988 --> 02:16:18,388
connected to actually the

3825
02:16:18,891 --> 02:16:21,160
collision reports that were

3826
02:16:21,160 --> 02:16:22,594
yes is actually meant to solve

3827
02:16:22,594 --> 02:16:24,363
for. It will help. It won't

3828
02:16:24,363 --> 02:16:25,964
solve all of it, but it will

3829
02:16:25,964 --> 02:16:26,598
help the actual investigation

3830
02:16:26,598 --> 02:16:29,598
takes the man hours to

3831
02:16:29,935 --> 02:16:31,437
actually go through and figure

3832
02:16:31,437 --> 02:16:32,671
out what caused the collision

3833
02:16:32,671 --> 02:16:35,741
who cited what was a problem,

3834
02:16:35,741 --> 02:16:36,875
right? So that part not gonna

3835
02:16:36,875 --> 02:16:39,645
help as much, but it does help

3836
02:16:39,645 --> 02:16:40,379
with then taking it and

3837
02:16:40,379 --> 02:16:43,379
processing it and then getting

3838
02:16:45,918 --> 02:16:46,585
it to the systems. Will give

3839
02:16:46,585 --> 02:16:48,787
all the information hard to

3840
02:16:48,787 --> 02:16:49,521
get all the look better. So it

3841
02:16:49,521 --> 02:16:51,523
will definitely help with that

3842
02:16:51,523 --> 02:16:52,225
because in that person can

3843
02:16:52,225 --> 02:16:55,225
maybe start helping with some

3844
02:16:55,461 --> 02:16:56,129
of the other parts in traffic

3845
02:16:56,129 --> 02:16:56,829
with some of the grandson,

3846
02:16:56,829 --> 02:16:57,696
some of the other things that

3847
02:16:57,696 --> 02:17:01,296
are going on many, many hours

3848
02:17:02,768 --> 02:17:05,471
per day. And then one other

3849
02:17:05,471 --> 02:17:07,539
question I just have is as we

3850
02:17:07,539 --> 02:17:10,375
look to civilian, I certain

3851
02:17:10,375 --> 02:17:11,430
positions is it required by

3852
02:17:11,430 --> 02:17:14,480
law. As opd is required to

3853
02:17:14,480 --> 02:17:16,482
submit collision. Dated 2, the

3854
02:17:16,482 --> 02:17:17,583
chp by law and that it

3855
02:17:17,583 --> 02:17:19,583
references California vehicle

3856
02:17:21,587 --> 02:17:22,121
code code. Excuse me, 2008, a

3857
02:17:22,121 --> 02:17:23,389
does it require law

3858
02:17:23,389 --> 02:17:25,758
enforcement agency to do those

3859
02:17:25,758 --> 02:17:28,127
submittals or is it possible

3860
02:17:28,127 --> 02:17:28,827
to have the Department of

3861
02:17:28,827 --> 02:17:29,561
Transportation at some future

3862
02:17:29,561 --> 02:17:32,898
date take on a portion of this

3863
02:17:32,898 --> 02:17:34,900
work? Not sure if dog could do

3864
02:17:34,900 --> 02:17:37,336
it, but we have professional

3865
02:17:37,336 --> 02:17:37,970
staff that does it right now.

3866
02:17:37,970 --> 02:17:40,720
So they're the ones that

3867
02:17:40,720 --> 02:17:40,706
actually make physical copies.

3868
02:17:40,706 --> 02:17:43,706
Ended up. So that part's

3869
02:17:45,210 --> 02:17:48,210
already done. But it does

3870
02:17:49,148 --> 02:17:49,815
require a sworn officer, too

3871
02:17:49,815 --> 02:17:50,549
investigated an issue, the

3872
02:17:50,549 --> 02:17:52,184
citation. So that's where that

3873
02:17:52,184 --> 02:17:52,851
part comes in. Okay. That's

3874
02:17:52,851 --> 02:17:54,851
couple clarification. Thank

3875
02:17:58,323 --> 02:17:59,291
you. Let's go to public

3876
02:17:59,291 --> 02:17:59,958
comment calling in the names

3877
02:17:59,958 --> 02:18:03,495
that signed up to speak on

3878
02:18:03,495 --> 02:18:04,196
item number 9, just the Rose

3879
02:18:04,196 --> 02:18:07,196
Marie misses settle the ball

3880
02:18:16,376 --> 02:18:18,510
and Libby Pigman. Hi, just you

3881
02:18:18,510 --> 02:18:19,378
brought up the overtime fraud

3882
02:18:19,378 --> 02:18:21,448
issue? It's a good one. Why

3883
02:18:21,448 --> 02:18:22,881
don't they electron when they

3884
02:18:22,881 --> 02:18:24,516
do electronic thing for time

3885
02:18:24,516 --> 02:18:25,784
sheets, they tele could. They

3886
02:18:25,784 --> 02:18:27,453
don't want to. Why don't you

3887
02:18:27,453 --> 02:18:29,388
demand that they do it and

3888
02:18:29,388 --> 02:18:30,122
make them calm with a proposal

3889
02:18:30,122 --> 02:18:32,522
submit their time sheets,

3890
02:18:33,726 --> 02:18:34,460
electronic electronically. So

3891
02:18:34,460 --> 02:18:35,194
we don't have massive overtime

3892
02:18:35,194 --> 02:18:38,194
fraud by this department. When

3893
02:18:38,630 --> 02:18:39,531
is that going to happen?

3894
02:18:39,531 --> 02:18:41,330
Councilmember said as we look

3895
02:18:41,330 --> 02:18:41,600
to civilian certain positions,

3896
02:18:41,600 --> 02:18:43,635
as I mentioned at the

3897
02:18:43,635 --> 02:18:45,537
beginning of this meeting, the

3898
02:18:45,537 --> 02:18:46,839
longest item that has been on

3899
02:18:46,839 --> 02:18:47,339
on the penny. No date

3900
02:18:47,339 --> 02:18:49,339
scheduled list is

3901
02:18:49,675 --> 02:18:51,577
Councilmember Fife's item to

3902
02:18:51,577 --> 02:18:53,712
demand that we civilian eyes

3903
02:18:53,712 --> 02:18:54,413
these positions. Why don't you

3904
02:18:54,413 --> 02:18:56,749
schedule? Will save millions

3905
02:18:56,749 --> 02:18:58,485
and millions of dollars. And

3906
02:18:58,485 --> 02:18:59,151
we can see with this council

3907
02:18:59,151 --> 02:19:02,751
refusing to do it that you

3908
02:19:02,988 --> 02:19:03,655
guys are in the pockets p o a

3909
02:19:03,655 --> 02:19:05,324
piedmont landlords and all

3910
02:19:05,324 --> 02:19:05,991
kinds of other right-wing

3911
02:19:05,991 --> 02:19:06,659
actors. We have one council

3912
02:19:06,659 --> 02:19:09,659
member serving the city of

3913
02:19:10,462 --> 02:19:12,640
Oakland in 7 frauds and the

3914
02:19:12,640 --> 02:19:12,732
staff report lies about Alpr

3915
02:19:12,732 --> 02:19:15,732
here into sb 34 and admits

3916
02:19:22,441 --> 02:19:25,277
that this data is going So it

3917
02:19:25,277 --> 02:19:28,277
mentions in the report. Once

3918
02:19:29,810 --> 02:19:30,182
you submit the data. Related

3919
02:19:30,182 --> 02:19:33,782
to the collisions, you have to

3920
02:19:34,587 --> 02:19:37,456
strip the report of the name

3921
02:19:37,456 --> 02:19:38,157
address. So security number

3922
02:19:38,157 --> 02:19:40,557
driver's license number, what

3923
02:19:43,462 --> 02:19:46,462
are you subcommittee? I mean,

3924
02:19:48,500 --> 02:19:51,500
come What are you submitting

3925
02:19:52,538 --> 02:19:56,708
to chp? A pitch of the call? I

3926
02:19:56,708 --> 02:19:57,876
don't get this sanctuary city

3927
02:19:57,876 --> 02:20:00,876
stuff. This privacy stuff. You

3928
02:20:02,281 --> 02:20:02,948
can submit any information.

3929
02:20:02,948 --> 02:20:05,500
Want nobody to know nothing

3930
02:20:05,500 --> 02:20:06,852
about But you've got these

3931
02:20:06,852 --> 02:20:07,486
telephones and equipment that

3932
02:20:07,486 --> 02:20:10,486
you all use and everybody

3933
02:20:11,356 --> 02:20:13,756
knows your business. So

3934
02:20:13,992 --> 02:20:16,392
privacy. Come y'all. What

3935
02:20:18,630 --> 02:20:19,331
would you submitting?

3936
02:20:19,331 --> 02:20:19,998
Switching to Zoom user Blair?

3937
02:20:19,998 --> 02:20:22,998
You can unmute yourself and

3938
02:20:24,236 --> 02:20:27,390
begin your comment. I as this

3939
02:20:27,390 --> 02:20:27,940
is an item with thp. I feel

3940
02:20:27,940 --> 02:20:30,420
it's important make an

3941
02:20:30,420 --> 02:20:32,442
important time to simply

3942
02:20:34,613 --> 02:20:36,648
remind chp has a large part

3943
02:20:36,648 --> 02:20:38,684
the current lack situation

3944
02:20:38,684 --> 02:20:40,180
with opd and why that contract

3945
02:20:40,180 --> 02:20:41,220
is or is not being signed at

3946
02:20:41,220 --> 02:20:43,210
this time. Really good luck on

3947
02:20:43,210 --> 02:20:45,421
working on accountability and

3948
02:20:47,250 --> 02:20:48,927
explaining that to the public

3949
02:20:48,927 --> 02:20:49,561
before the upcoming opd

3950
02:20:49,561 --> 02:20:51,430
meeting now and September

3951
02:20:51,430 --> 02:20:54,430
October on these items, this

3952
02:20:56,602 --> 02:20:58,637
item Yeah, hopefully it can

3953
02:20:58,637 --> 02:20:59,304
help with agency, but what

3954
02:20:59,304 --> 02:21:01,373
does that efficiency can to

3955
02:21:01,373 --> 02:21:03,375
help with overall good luck.

3956
02:21:03,375 --> 02:21:05,344
How we are. Our policies can

3957
02:21:05,344 --> 02:21:05,978
be we're with each other and

3958
02:21:05,978 --> 02:21:08,978
that we want to practice.

3959
02:21:09,810 --> 02:21:09,782
Well, thanks. Thank you for

3960
02:21:09,782 --> 02:21:12,182
comments. Sure. That speakers

3961
02:21:14,920 --> 02:21:18,520
on this item. Have a motion

3962
02:21:25,431 --> 02:21:26,532
from this body. So moved.

3963
02:21:26,532 --> 02:21:28,233
Thank you. We have a motion

3964
02:21:28,233 --> 02:21:28,934
made by council member bands

3965
02:21:28,934 --> 02:21:29,601
Councilmember Bike to approve

3966
02:21:29,601 --> 02:21:31,136
the recommendations of stop

3967
02:21:31,136 --> 02:21:31,904
and to mark this item to the

3968
02:21:31,904 --> 02:21:34,904
JULY 21st City Council agenda

3969
02:21:34,940 --> 02:21:37,340
real councilmembers. Brown. I

3970
02:21:38,110 --> 02:21:40,746
I use I and Cher Wang, I think

3971
02:21:40,746 --> 02:21:41,447
you motion passes with more. I

3972
02:21:41,447 --> 02:21:42,147
support this item to the JULY

3973
02:21:42,147 --> 02:21:44,383
20 for City Council agenda on

3974
02:21:44,383 --> 02:21:46,652
consent. Be out to open for

3975
02:21:46,652 --> 02:21:50,252
me. Sorry clerk before we move

3976
02:21:51,191 --> 02:21:52,124
on to open forum. I making the

3977
02:21:52,124 --> 02:21:54,524
request of the parliamentary

3978
02:21:56,195 --> 02:21:56,895
can you recap what the amended

3979
02:21:56,895 --> 02:21:58,931
title is for item 8? This was

3980
02:21:58,931 --> 02:22:00,432
at the city administration's

3981
02:22:00,432 --> 02:22:02,432
request. Absolutely through

3982
02:22:02,501 --> 02:22:04,570
the chair. Just clarifying for

3983
02:22:04,570 --> 02:22:06,672
item 8. The motion title was

3984
02:22:06,672 --> 02:22:08,674
to delete the alp. Our

3985
02:22:08,674 --> 02:22:10,743
reference from the original

3986
02:22:10,743 --> 02:22:12,678
resolution. So that was this a

3987
02:22:12,678 --> 02:22:13,245
being stricken and to delete

3988
02:22:13,245 --> 02:22:15,645
the reference to the

3989
02:22:15,681 --> 02:22:17,950
attachment e which was opr

3990
02:22:17,950 --> 02:22:20,850
report which is contained in

3991
02:22:20,850 --> 02:22:20,753
the resolution at the first

3992
02:22:20,753 --> 02:22:22,187
result provisions. So those

3993
02:22:22,187 --> 02:22:25,187
items would be stricken. Thank

3994
02:22:30,295 --> 02:22:31,530
you. Thank you. Moving. Moving

3995
02:22:31,530 --> 02:22:33,332
on to open warm calling in the

3996
02:22:33,332 --> 02:22:33,999
names that signed up to speak

3997
02:22:33,999 --> 02:22:36,999
Matalin. Stacy need to feed

3998
02:22:39,204 --> 02:22:39,872
Jesse Rose more. Joy around.

3999
02:22:39,872 --> 02:22:43,472
Air on us. Not all Loveland

4000
02:22:47,446 --> 02:22:49,348
men. And Seleka Thomas. Hi,

4001
02:22:49,348 --> 02:22:50,315
just euros You know, when we

4002
02:22:50,315 --> 02:22:51,250
consider that corruption and

4003
02:22:51,250 --> 02:22:53,650
feckless malfeasance of the

4004
02:22:55,287 --> 02:22:58,287
city Council I wonder about

4005
02:22:58,491 --> 02:23:01,193
some of the council members to

4006
02:23:01,193 --> 02:23:02,394
dating campaign on being in

4007
02:23:02,394 --> 02:23:04,163
the pockets of Sam Singer and

4008
02:23:04,163 --> 02:23:06,563
the and Piedmont landlords.

4009
02:23:07,433 --> 02:23:09,100
And like a body of team for a

4010
02:23:09,100 --> 02:23:09,635
count commerce is. And I think

4011
02:23:09,635 --> 02:23:11,635
specifically about you're

4012
02:23:12,905 --> 02:23:14,600
going to Brown, you know, I

4013
02:23:14,600 --> 02:23:14,940
think gaslit by several people

4014
02:23:14,940 --> 02:23:18,510
on the city council when it's

4015
02:23:18,510 --> 02:23:19,178
when it comes to plot gaslit

4016
02:23:19,178 --> 02:23:22,178
by Charlie Wong's office. I

4017
02:23:23,820 --> 02:23:23,782
think gaslit by Zac Unger.

4018
02:23:23,782 --> 02:23:25,451
John, I Ramachandran doesn't

4019
02:23:25,451 --> 02:23:26,351
want to respond anything. Your

4020
02:23:26,351 --> 02:23:28,253
office is completely

4021
02:23:28,253 --> 02:23:29,154
unresponsive. Now you say that

4022
02:23:29,154 --> 02:23:29,855
you serve everybody. You see

4023
02:23:29,855 --> 02:23:33,358
the serve, nobody and what I

4024
02:23:33,358 --> 02:23:34,270
would like to now. When did

4025
02:23:34,270 --> 02:23:34,693
when did you turn to become

4026
02:23:34,693 --> 02:23:37,930
this kind of councilmember?

4027
02:23:38,197 --> 02:23:39,298
When did this happen? Who said

4028
02:23:39,298 --> 02:23:39,998
what to you to make are those

4029
02:23:39,998 --> 02:23:41,233
interest and said the people

4030
02:23:41,233 --> 02:23:45,433
of the city, I would like to

4031
02:23:56,415 --> 02:23:56,752
know that. Thank you.

4032
02:23:56,752 --> 02:23:57,416
And it

4033
02:23:57,416 --> 02:23:58,150
is needed the be in a street

4034
02:23:58,150 --> 02:24:00,619
vendor here in Oakland since I

4035
02:24:00,619 --> 02:24:01,420
was 19 years old from what

4036
02:24:01,420 --> 02:24:04,924
we've seen over the past 2 and

4037
02:24:04,924 --> 02:24:06,725
a half The city's treatment of

4038
02:24:06,725 --> 02:24:08,994
an have house from eating that

4039
02:24:08,994 --> 02:24:12,531
he's team hit Steven does has

4040
02:24:12,531 --> 02:24:13,165
been unsafe. The city needs to

4041
02:24:13,165 --> 02:24:15,200
stop all raise on street

4042
02:24:15,200 --> 02:24:17,350
vendors and do a serious legal

4043
02:24:17,350 --> 02:24:17,936
review. Oakland's inforcement

4044
02:24:17,936 --> 02:24:19,738
pot practices and the vendors

4045
02:24:19,738 --> 02:24:21,573
and advocates have collected

4046
02:24:21,573 --> 02:24:23,242
enough factual support that,

4047
02:24:23,242 --> 02:24:25,642
you know, that investigation

4048
02:24:26,278 --> 02:24:27,413
and with open exceeded his

4049
02:24:27,413 --> 02:24:28,130
legal authority. Look pride

4050
02:24:28,130 --> 02:24:30,413
centers of its property

4051
02:24:31,450 --> 02:24:32,418
without adequate processes. Do

4052
02:24:32,418 --> 02:24:34,818
both permitted and unpermitted

4053
02:24:34,920 --> 02:24:37,320
vendors have been impacted.

4054
02:24:37,923 --> 02:24:39,124
Our legal representative

4055
02:24:39,124 --> 02:24:40,192
requested documents. He was

4056
02:24:40,192 --> 02:24:41,827
ignored. He requested them

4057
02:24:41,827 --> 02:24:42,995
again. He was ignored. I

4058
02:24:42,995 --> 02:24:43,962
requested them. My request was

4059
02:24:43,962 --> 02:24:45,962
redirected. Know documents

4060
02:24:48,267 --> 02:24:49,680
were given and either way to

4061
02:24:49,680 --> 02:24:50,869
the documents don't exist,

4062
02:24:50,869 --> 02:24:52,871
which is a problem and unsafe

4063
02:24:52,871 --> 02:24:53,873
or the documents being

4064
02:24:53,873 --> 02:24:57,473
withheld and then was also a

4065
02:25:01,380 --> 02:25:03,382
state visit. My daughter Joy

4066
02:25:03,382 --> 02:25:04,483
summer, Ali, I want talk about

4067
02:25:04,483 --> 02:25:06,719
a few things. One, I don't

4068
02:25:06,719 --> 02:25:07,586
support the flock cameras into

4069
02:25:07,586 --> 02:25:08,787
your time. A public safety but

4070
02:25:08,787 --> 02:25:09,488
never have I ever heard talk

4071
02:25:09,488 --> 02:25:13,625
about a bunker that we can go

4072
02:25:13,625 --> 02:25:14,259
to in case of any type of like

4073
02:25:14,259 --> 02:25:14,960
people's things, not just

4074
02:25:14,960 --> 02:25:15,661
going to happen or something

4075
02:25:15,661 --> 02:25:17,896
like that. I that's something

4076
02:25:17,896 --> 02:25:18,464
I should put of like. Where do

4077
02:25:18,464 --> 02:25:22,640
we go? If our city is

4078
02:25:23,769 --> 02:25:24,970
destroyed? Are we on our own?

4079
02:25:24,970 --> 02:25:26,705
Bridges? Doric Street vending

4080
02:25:26,705 --> 02:25:28,705
culture neighborhood based

4081
02:25:28,874 --> 02:25:29,775
economic system within the

4082
02:25:29,775 --> 02:25:30,743
open community should not

4083
02:25:30,743 --> 02:25:31,343
become the lies are erase. It

4084
02:25:31,343 --> 02:25:31,945
is part of the Oakland

4085
02:25:31,945 --> 02:25:34,179
identity and should be

4086
02:25:34,179 --> 02:25:35,380
protected and supported. This

4087
02:25:35,380 --> 02:25:37,983
is a quality of life for

4088
02:25:37,983 --> 02:25:39,251
working class of black and

4089
02:25:39,251 --> 02:25:40,352
brown floats. Now cause all of

4090
02:25:40,352 --> 02:25:41,487
us have multiple jobs and side

4091
02:25:41,487 --> 02:25:43,288
hustles to be able to exist in

4092
02:25:43,288 --> 02:25:45,224
the city were born in raised

4093
02:25:45,224 --> 02:25:47,292
in our culture and quality of

4094
02:25:47,292 --> 02:25:49,361
life keeps getting negatively

4095
02:25:49,361 --> 02:25:50,280
impacted by and for people who

4096
02:25:50,280 --> 02:25:52,631
are not from here and can't

4097
02:25:52,631 --> 02:25:53,665
figure out how to fit in.

4098
02:25:53,665 --> 02:25:54,333
There has been talk about the

4099
02:25:54,333 --> 02:25:57,933
trash and loud noise at the

4100
02:25:59,405 --> 02:26:00,500
lake. We vendors how all agree

4101
02:26:00,500 --> 02:26:03,605
we have as a city of 4

4102
02:26:08,414 --> 02:26:10,814
cardboard trash can. Hire

4103
02:26:14,119 --> 02:26:14,753
staff. Councilmember Wang

4104
02:26:14,753 --> 02:26:15,487
Councilmember Brown comes

4105
02:26:15,487 --> 02:26:17,887
member Phife and Councilmember

4106
02:26:20,492 --> 02:26:21,260
Houston I sincerely hope that

4107
02:26:21,260 --> 02:26:24,860
you consider what it means for

4108
02:26:25,397 --> 02:26:26,365
a community to be safe. Does

4109
02:26:26,365 --> 02:26:28,300
it make a community safe if we

4110
02:26:28,300 --> 02:26:29,340
have cameras at every corner

4111
02:26:29,340 --> 02:26:29,568
doesn't make a community safe.

4112
02:26:29,568 --> 02:26:30,803
If we have multiple

4113
02:26:30,803 --> 02:26:33,203
helicopters above our heads,

4114
02:26:33,972 --> 02:26:38,172
does it feel safe to have men

4115
02:26:38,544 --> 02:26:39,344
with arms and weapons on

4116
02:26:39,344 --> 02:26:39,978
constantly patrolling every

4117
02:26:39,978 --> 02:26:42,378
street. Corner weather is

4118
02:26:43,782 --> 02:26:45,170
eyesore. Oakland pd. I do not

4119
02:26:45,170 --> 02:26:45,718
believe that a safety safety

4120
02:26:45,718 --> 02:26:48,118
starts with community safety

4121
02:26:48,587 --> 02:26:49,288
starts with housing. Safety

4122
02:26:49,288 --> 02:26:52,191
starts with health care. And

4123
02:26:52,191 --> 02:26:54,260
it starts here in this

4124
02:26:54,260 --> 02:26:55,270
committee. But you

4125
02:26:55,270 --> 02:26:57,270
consistently tonight have

4126
02:26:57,596 --> 02:26:59,565
shown that you will neglect

4127
02:26:59,565 --> 02:27:02,268
safety of Oakland, citizens of

4128
02:27:02,268 --> 02:27:03,936
the people of this town

4129
02:27:03,936 --> 02:27:04,703
because you do not care for

4130
02:27:04,703 --> 02:27:07,703
the safety of the reddest

4131
02:27:08,400 --> 02:27:08,741
residents of Oakland and

4132
02:27:08,741 --> 02:27:11,741
multiple of you have ignored

4133
02:27:19,952 --> 02:27:20,652
multiple public comments, not.

4134
02:27:20,652 --> 02:27:21,520
Madeline, Stacey, I'm opposed

4135
02:27:21,520 --> 02:27:23,555
to the recent direction the

4136
02:27:23,555 --> 02:27:26,555
city has taken against our

4137
02:27:26,825 --> 02:27:27,860
street vendors. It is violent

4138
02:27:27,860 --> 02:27:28,560
gatekeeping. The courts have

4139
02:27:28,560 --> 02:27:29,862
already decided over and over

4140
02:27:29,862 --> 02:27:30,529
again across California. Your

4141
02:27:30,529 --> 02:27:32,331
approach is a violation of

4142
02:27:32,331 --> 02:27:34,331
street vendors, constitutional

4143
02:27:34,500 --> 02:27:35,234
rights. The state government

4144
02:27:35,234 --> 02:27:37,634
recently passed the Safe

4145
02:27:39,138 --> 02:27:39,805
Sidewalk Vending Act sb 946,

4146
02:27:39,805 --> 02:27:40,439
which street decriminalize

4147
02:27:40,439 --> 02:27:41,140
street vending statewide

4148
02:27:41,140 --> 02:27:43,342
shifting of force meant away

4149
02:27:43,342 --> 02:27:45,244
from criminal penalties. What

4150
02:27:45,244 --> 02:27:46,512
the town is doing is in direct

4151
02:27:46,512 --> 02:27:47,513
violation of both the series

4152
02:27:47,513 --> 02:27:49,581
of lawsuits, the side of a

4153
02:27:49,581 --> 02:27:52,581
street vendor's rights and sb

4154
02:27:52,618 --> 02:27:53,752
946, every dollar spent

4155
02:27:53,752 --> 02:27:54,686
policing vendors should be

4156
02:27:54,686 --> 02:27:55,387
redirected into small business

4157
02:27:55,387 --> 02:27:57,387
grants, equipment, subsidies

4158
02:27:57,823 --> 02:27:58,490
and technical assistant

4159
02:27:58,490 --> 02:28:00,490
assistance program. Street

4160
02:28:01,927 --> 02:28:02,628
vendors are entrepreneuers and

4161
02:28:02,628 --> 02:28:03,195
making something or nothing.

4162
02:28:03,195 --> 02:28:04,396
Their skill should be

4163
02:28:04,396 --> 02:28:06,396
recognized, respected and

4164
02:28:07,232 --> 02:28:07,866
honored, not criminalized.

4165
02:28:07,866 --> 02:28:10,866
Tiffany is not just about

4166
02:28:10,903 --> 02:28:11,603
food. Our commerce, it's about

4167
02:28:11,603 --> 02:28:14,603
dignity. It's about who gets

4168
02:28:14,840 --> 02:28:15,541
to exist in public spaces to

4169
02:28:15,541 --> 02:28:16,175
criminalize of regulate. This

4170
02:28:16,175 --> 02:28:16,775
ecosystem is not just bad

4171
02:28:16,775 --> 02:28:19,175
policy is betrayal up.

4172
02:28:26,510 --> 02:28:26,985
Oakland's identity. Hello City

4173
02:28:26,985 --> 02:28:27,953
Council. My name is Seleka

4174
02:28:27,953 --> 02:28:30,456
Time and I would like to

4175
02:28:30,456 --> 02:28:32,856
address the 3 murders violence

4176
02:28:33,959 --> 02:28:36,959
on JANUARY. 3rd, 2026 on 80th

4177
02:28:37,162 --> 02:28:38,997
and another 3 murders plus

4178
02:28:38,997 --> 02:28:40,933
fines by victims injured one

4179
02:28:40,933 --> 02:28:44,690
Avenue by a hit and run on MAY

4180
02:28:44,690 --> 02:28:44,769
16th 2026. I foresee my

4181
02:28:44,769 --> 02:28:47,169
condolences the families and

4182
02:28:47,806 --> 02:28:48,574
to the victims. A 5th Avenue

4183
02:28:48,574 --> 02:28:50,776
has always been known for is

4184
02:28:50,776 --> 02:28:52,778
tragic traffic collisions in

4185
02:28:52,778 --> 02:28:56,810
crime. So can we please sb

4186
02:28:56,810 --> 02:28:56,949
cameras, peak bumps and a

4187
02:28:56,949 --> 02:28:58,851
redesigned to slow down

4188
02:28:58,851 --> 02:29:01,887
traffic in that area to reduce

4189
02:29:01,887 --> 02:29:02,989
crime. And MAY we also please

4190
02:29:02,989 --> 02:29:04,823
reinstate the bliss program

4191
02:29:04,823 --> 02:29:07,823
for Adam Attic. Trash cleanup

4192
02:29:08,594 --> 02:29:09,294
in that area and poor. All

4193
02:29:09,294 --> 02:29:09,995
Oakland high spots so that we

4194
02:29:09,995 --> 02:29:11,197
don't have to wait on anyone

4195
02:29:11,197 --> 02:29:15,000
to report it. Thank you. And I

4196
02:29:15,000 --> 02:29:15,868
just want to say that all of

4197
02:29:15,868 --> 02:29:18,670
you are doing a very good job

4198
02:29:18,670 --> 02:29:20,938
in Oakland has came so far

4199
02:29:20,938 --> 02:29:22,976
even with the murders. We're

4200
02:29:22,976 --> 02:29:23,976
down from about 130 murders

4201
02:29:23,976 --> 02:29:27,576
per year. And we're down to 57

4202
02:29:33,252 --> 02:29:37,452
and so this is one thing I

4203
02:29:38,570 --> 02:29:40,725
know me all the time. I know

4204
02:29:40,725 --> 02:29:43,725
that ms Brown works taught.

4205
02:29:44,430 --> 02:29:47,332
And does homework. And makes

4206
02:29:47,332 --> 02:29:47,966
contribution that a ballot.

4207
02:29:47,966 --> 02:29:50,966
And sometimes we go ahead

4208
02:29:51,369 --> 02:29:52,104
system. But you must system

4209
02:29:52,104 --> 02:29:52,771
some stand and he want to talk

4210
02:29:52,771 --> 02:29:55,750
about something else. But I

4211
02:29:55,750 --> 02:29:57,843
have to defend you. You very

4212
02:29:57,843 --> 02:29:58,578
efficient. Just like Fyffe. We

4213
02:29:58,578 --> 02:30:02,280
fall out all the time. But you

4214
02:30:02,280 --> 02:30:03,820
must system. And anybody say

4215
02:30:03,820 --> 02:30:04,884
you don't do work. You do just

4216
02:30:04,884 --> 02:30:06,852
like in Houston, you do to

4217
02:30:06,852 --> 02:30:07,519
work. Even this Wang. You do

4218
02:30:07,519 --> 02:30:11,119
work. You know, we fall out

4219
02:30:11,523 --> 02:30:13,525
all the But I respect that.

4220
02:30:13,525 --> 02:30:17,696
You do the work. It might not

4221
02:30:17,696 --> 02:30:18,396
be the workout will. But you

4222
02:30:18,396 --> 02:30:21,996
work. And nobody come in here

4223
02:30:22,350 --> 02:30:23,202
and tell you. What are you

4224
02:30:23,202 --> 02:30:26,202
doing? She's doing halt work.

4225
02:30:26,638 --> 02:30:30,238
Ms Brown. And thank you. All

4226
02:30:31,343 --> 02:30:35,543
of you. Okay. So we all fly

4227
02:30:42,186 --> 02:30:43,122
you call the police on. Thank

4228
02:30:43,122 --> 02:30:44,122
you for your ball as switching

4229
02:30:44,122 --> 02:30:47,722
to zoom speak a player. You

4230
02:30:48,794 --> 02:30:50,929
yourself begin your comment.

4231
02:30:50,929 --> 02:30:53,532
Plant thanks to the meeting

4232
02:30:53,532 --> 02:30:55,601
today are I'm pretty

4233
02:30:55,601 --> 02:30:56,235
disappointed. However, I'm

4234
02:30:56,235 --> 02:30:56,802
thankful I the new police

4235
02:30:56,802 --> 02:30:57,770
chief sounds pretty

4236
02:30:57,770 --> 02:31:00,170
interesting. He's been around

4237
02:31:01,540 --> 02:31:03,876
Oakland for a while. He He

4238
02:31:03,876 --> 02:31:04,609
knows the importance of

4239
02:31:04,609 --> 02:31:07,900
community and participation of

4240
02:31:10,784 --> 02:31:11,417
community that's good for

4241
02:31:11,417 --> 02:31:11,916
getting it said that the

4242
02:31:11,916 --> 02:31:12,618
administration is

4243
02:31:12,618 --> 02:31:15,180
understanding that concept as

4244
02:31:15,540 --> 02:31:15,753
well at this time. And,

4245
02:31:15,753 --> 02:31:16,455
Brooke, what did they want to

4246
02:31:16,455 --> 02:31:18,791
practice their their form of

4247
02:31:18,791 --> 02:31:19,824
policy making their

4248
02:31:19,824 --> 02:31:20,393
understanding the community's

4249
02:31:20,393 --> 02:31:21,610
role in what they've

4250
02:31:21,610 --> 02:31:23,270
developer, police oversight

4251
02:31:23,270 --> 02:31:26,130
and other things. I think that

4252
02:31:26,130 --> 02:31:28,000
starting to happen more. Good

4253
02:31:28,000 --> 02:31:30,370
luck. We can talk more about

4254
02:31:30,370 --> 02:31:32,604
clock accountability and that

4255
02:31:32,604 --> 02:31:35,274
we can talk about the concept

4256
02:31:35,274 --> 02:31:35,974
not a better accountability

4257
02:31:35,974 --> 02:31:38,374
would block exactly happened

4258
02:31:38,510 --> 02:31:41,510
with their contact things. But

4259
02:31:41,780 --> 02:31:44,583
we start to really address the

4260
02:31:44,583 --> 02:31:45,784
concept keep more strategic

4261
02:31:45,784 --> 02:31:47,352
placement of our tech that can

4262
02:31:47,352 --> 02:31:50,723
reduce tech year mall in small

4263
02:31:50,723 --> 02:31:51,391
amount and that can Thank you

4264
02:31:51,391 --> 02:31:52,759
for your comments are that

4265
02:31:52,759 --> 02:31:55,159
includes all speakers. Create

4266
02:31:57,262 --> 02:31:59,662
Councilmember Fife. I thank

4267
02:31:59,765 --> 02:32:02,765
you. Chair Wang for allowing

4268
02:32:02,968 --> 02:32:05,137
me the privilege to just

4269
02:32:05,137 --> 02:32:06,138
clarify for some of the public

4270
02:32:06,138 --> 02:32:07,207
speakers about my contribution

4271
02:32:07,207 --> 02:32:10,207
to community in Oakland and

4272
02:32:10,675 --> 02:32:12,911
I'll be brief because I don't

4273
02:32:12,911 --> 02:32:17,315
talk about what I do. I am not

4274
02:32:17,315 --> 02:32:19,160
a social media MAY even where

4275
02:32:19,160 --> 02:32:21,587
and always in the public

4276
02:32:21,587 --> 02:32:23,221
sharing what I do and part of

4277
02:32:23,221 --> 02:32:26,240
the reasons why don't talk

4278
02:32:26,240 --> 02:32:26,859
about it is because the

4279
02:32:26,859 --> 02:32:27,526
conditions that I want to see

4280
02:32:27,526 --> 02:32:29,560
change in the community are

4281
02:32:29,560 --> 02:32:32,398
not solved yet. So I don't go

4282
02:32:32,398 --> 02:32:33,731
out and celebrate the fact

4283
02:32:33,731 --> 02:32:35,634
that I've been a part of the

4284
02:32:35,634 --> 02:32:37,669
study group's political study

4285
02:32:37,669 --> 02:32:39,906
groups to provide political

4286
02:32:39,906 --> 02:32:40,672
education to the community or

4287
02:32:40,672 --> 02:32:43,672
safe houses. When there are

4288
02:32:43,742 --> 02:32:46,142
incidents with Nazis other

4289
02:32:46,344 --> 02:32:49,344
issues in our community were

4290
02:32:49,948 --> 02:32:52,510
my people have had to go into

4291
02:32:52,510 --> 02:32:54,219
hiding because of being docks

4292
02:32:54,219 --> 02:32:55,154
for the work we do in

4293
02:32:55,154 --> 02:32:55,754
community or the birthing

4294
02:32:55,754 --> 02:32:58,154
centers or the medical

4295
02:33:01,126 --> 02:33:02,361
training or the independent

4296
02:33:02,361 --> 02:33:03,262
schools or I could talk about

4297
02:33:03,262 --> 02:33:04,363
the things that I've done in

4298
02:33:04,363 --> 02:33:08,300
this city that most of you all

4299
02:33:08,300 --> 02:33:08,967
had haven't even thought of to

4300
02:33:08,967 --> 02:33:11,700
support my communities. So

4301
02:33:11,700 --> 02:33:11,769
before the public gets up here

4302
02:33:11,769 --> 02:33:13,572
and talks about what I'm not

4303
02:33:13,572 --> 02:33:17,172
doing, any bodies not doing, I

4304
02:33:17,776 --> 02:33:19,711
suggest more research. I don't

4305
02:33:19,711 --> 02:33:21,246
disagree with public being

4306
02:33:21,246 --> 02:33:21,914
able to state what they want.

4307
02:33:21,914 --> 02:33:25,118
I want to say or what they

4308
02:33:25,118 --> 02:33:26,151
want to see. But I take it

4309
02:33:26,151 --> 02:33:27,319
personally when somebody comes

4310
02:33:27,319 --> 02:33:28,880
up here talking about what I'm

4311
02:33:28,880 --> 02:33:31,880
not doing and the community

4312
02:33:31,724 --> 02:33:34,927
and that's how I heard you, my

4313
02:33:34,927 --> 02:33:37,927
friend. So everyone has the

4314
02:33:38,630 --> 02:33:39,832
right to point out the

4315
02:33:39,832 --> 02:33:41,660
criticisms or the critiques or

4316
02:33:41,660 --> 02:33:42,901
the challenges. But what I'm

4317
02:33:42,901 --> 02:33:45,901
saying when it comes to

4318
02:33:46,839 --> 02:33:47,740
Councilmember Fife as I was

4319
02:33:47,740 --> 02:33:48,507
organizer in the streets of

4320
02:33:48,507 --> 02:33:50,907
West Oakland for almost 30

4321
02:33:51,543 --> 02:33:52,978
years before I got here, which

4322
02:33:52,978 --> 02:33:53,679
is what put me here. So check

4323
02:33:53,679 --> 02:33:57,279
my record before you come up

4324
02:33:57,549 --> 02:33:59,451
here talking about me because

4325
02:33:59,451 --> 02:34:00,452
I I got it from the mud and I

4326
02:34:00,452 --> 02:34:01,520
will continue to do what I

4327
02:34:01,520 --> 02:34:03,122
need to do for my people for

4328
02:34:03,122 --> 02:34:06,122
black people in Oakland. We

4329
02:34:06,992 --> 02:34:08,930
got to do both and we can't

4330
02:34:08,930 --> 02:34:08,727
talk about the utopia that we

4331
02:34:08,727 --> 02:34:10,662
want to see if we haven't

4332
02:34:10,662 --> 02:34:13,565
created the systems for that

4333
02:34:13,565 --> 02:34:16,468
in the community today. And

4334
02:34:16,468 --> 02:34:19,838
I'm very well aware of what is

4335
02:34:19,838 --> 02:34:20,672
needed about what is is

4336
02:34:20,672 --> 02:34:21,473
studied, what is research what

4337
02:34:21,473 --> 02:34:23,942
we need to keep people safe.

4338
02:34:23,942 --> 02:34:24,610
But the difference between me

4339
02:34:24,610 --> 02:34:26,779
and most people, especially

4340
02:34:26,779 --> 02:34:29,581
people who were just talking

4341
02:34:29,581 --> 02:34:30,617
and meetings. I put the work

4342
02:34:30,617 --> 02:34:33,552
in and I never this is the

4343
02:34:33,552 --> 02:34:36,789
first time I ever have talked

4344
02:34:36,789 --> 02:34:37,523
at length about I I I with

4345
02:34:37,523 --> 02:34:40,159
sometimes all come up here and

4346
02:34:40,159 --> 02:34:42,610
get it twisted. I have like we

4347
02:34:42,610 --> 02:34:44,830
have my collective. We are

4348
02:34:44,830 --> 02:34:47,830
about shoot. And should know

4349
02:34:48,667 --> 02:34:51,667
that. Thank you. Of course,

4350
02:34:52,838 --> 02:34:53,839
Councilmember Houston. Yeah, i

4351
02:34:53,839 --> 02:34:56,508
just wanted to just say I'm

4352
02:34:56,508 --> 02:34:57,743
glad Council move. If I say we

4353
02:34:57,743 --> 02:34:58,610
she said because I'd like to

4354
02:34:58,610 --> 02:35:02,210
say just a few things about

4355
02:35:02,714 --> 02:35:03,415
just on the strength people

4356
02:35:03,415 --> 02:35:06,185
could tell me that I'm doing

4357
02:35:06,185 --> 02:35:08,530
wrong district 7. If they from

4358
02:35:08,530 --> 02:35:09,956
distance 7 now give a rip what

4359
02:35:09,956 --> 02:35:12,157
they say. But the reason why I

4360
02:35:12,157 --> 02:35:14,827
said saying this is because

4361
02:35:14,827 --> 02:35:17,227
council member Brown. That's

4362
02:35:18,764 --> 02:35:20,733
my girl, right? I mean, she

4363
02:35:20,733 --> 02:35:21,834
guides me through she doing a

4364
02:35:21,834 --> 02:35:24,870
She's across the city and I'll

4365
02:35:24,870 --> 02:35:25,604
stand to fire any day of week.

4366
02:35:25,604 --> 02:35:28,507
So Kuzma really do a good job.

4367
02:35:28,507 --> 02:35:29,341
Keep it up. And if from

4368
02:35:29,341 --> 02:35:32,341
district 7, you know, we you

4369
02:35:33,345 --> 02:35:36,945
know what, I feel. Thank you.

4370
02:35:37,916 --> 02:35:40,916
Colleagues. I think with that.