1
00:07:55,790 --> 00:08:23,890
Welcome to the Pittsburgh City Council, cablecast post agenda on options for increasing revenue in the city of Pittsburgh. Today is November 6th, 2025. I am Council Member Barbara. I represent district five and online we have Councilwoman Erica Straussberger and I think other members may be joining at some point as well.

2
00:08:23,890 --> 00:08:27,750
So thank you, everybody, for being here.

3
00:08:27,890 --> 00:08:34,130
So just a quick intro, the purpose of this post agenda.

4
00:08:34,450 --> 00:08:43,790
So as there has been lots of talk over the past year about issues

5
00:08:43,790 --> 00:08:47,590
around budget and revenue and some tight years ahead

6
00:08:47,590 --> 00:08:49,330
for the city of Pittsburgh.

7
00:08:49,330 --> 00:09:14,710
And so I thought that it would be worthwhile to talk about ways that we might increase our revenue because it's of course with revenue that we are able to pay for our beautiful parks and our pools and our police and fire and EMS and you know trash pick up and senior centers and rex centers and all all the great stuff that that that we have here in the city of Pittsburgh.

8
00:09:15,610 --> 00:09:22,590
much of which is running great, doing really, really well, other parts of which, like maybe

9
00:09:22,590 --> 00:09:28,510
snow and litter pickup, we're, you know, areas where we could definitely do better, but

10
00:09:28,510 --> 00:09:35,030
all of that takes, takes money, right, running government is expensive, oh, quote, controller

11
00:09:35,030 --> 00:09:36,290
high-slower on that.

12
00:09:37,530 --> 00:09:44,690
So, at any rate, so today we have our council budget director, our director of finance,

13
00:09:44,690 --> 00:09:59,770
We also have the Keystone Research Council as well as the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy and our Controllers Office as well to sort of

14
00:10:00,000 --> 00:10:08,000
Dive through a few options that we have at the city and just to talk a little bit about what revenue

15
00:10:08,000 --> 00:10:15,080
we get and all of that good stuff. So with that, I will kick it off. Why don't we just run

16
00:10:15,080 --> 00:10:23,180
down the table and everyone introduce themselves and then we'll start with Pete McDevitt, our Council

17
00:10:23,180 --> 00:10:26,700
budget director and director Gula from Finance.

18
00:10:27,380 --> 00:10:28,020
Thanks.

19
00:10:28,500 --> 00:10:30,100
I'm Pete McDevitt City Council, Vice Director.

20
00:10:31,120 --> 00:10:34,600
I'm Jane Gula, Department of Finance Director and City Treacher.

21
00:10:35,420 --> 00:10:38,420
Richie Fader, I'm a lawyer for the Keystone Research Center.

22
00:10:39,280 --> 00:10:43,900
Hi, I'm Diana Pulse and I'm a senior policy analyst at the Keystone Research Center.

23
00:10:44,700 --> 00:10:46,780
Rachel Heisler, Controller for the City of Pittsburgh.

24
00:10:48,180 --> 00:10:50,960
Mark DeDak, Research Director in the City Controller's office.

25
00:10:50,960 --> 00:10:51,420
So

26
00:11:00,440 --> 00:11:01,400
I have a question here, Dr.

27
00:11:02,100 --> 00:11:03,540
But, um, come a week ago,

28
00:11:03,960 --> 00:11:05,600
the local tax policy director

29
00:11:05,600 --> 00:11:08,020
Institute on taxation and economic policy.

30
00:11:09,900 --> 00:11:11,400
Great, thank you.

31
00:11:11,660 --> 00:11:13,540
Okay, without we can kick it off.

32
00:11:13,840 --> 00:11:16,420
All right, all right, I'm going to pull up my slide deck.

33
00:11:28,540 --> 00:11:31,140
There's always a lag once you join the Zoom group.

34
00:11:31,560 --> 00:11:33,920
Okay, so I'm going to talk to you about

35
00:11:33,920 --> 00:11:37,120
the budget and sort of how that ties into revenues.

36
00:11:38,200 --> 00:11:39,780
Um, so, um,

37
00:11:40,240 --> 00:11:41,100
what is our budget?

38
00:11:41,100 --> 00:11:47,200
This is how I start the budget over you every year, you'll get hopefully an abbreviated version of this next week.

39
00:11:47,780 --> 00:11:50,580
But the budget isn't just a financial plan, it's not a bunch of numbers.

40
00:11:51,080 --> 00:11:53,520
It is the chief policy document of the city.

41
00:11:54,020 --> 00:11:58,340
This is where we outline what we plan to do and how we plan to do it.

42
00:11:58,360 --> 00:12:03,640
And I like to look at it as the budget tells the story of the city of Pittsburgh and what we're going to do.

43
00:12:04,180 --> 00:12:09,820
So it tells us who's going to do the work, who's going to receive those services, what

44
00:12:09,820 --> 00:12:14,520
those services will be, where we're going to provide them, how people will get there, what

45
00:12:14,520 --> 00:12:19,740
road, bridges, paths, and bike trails will get, and also if you dive into it deeply, you

46
00:12:19,740 --> 00:12:21,640
can see how we're going to do it.

47
00:12:22,380 --> 00:12:28,320
So when people think of core services from the city, I think most people think of like three

48
00:12:28,320 --> 00:12:34,060
specific areas. They'll think of public safety and then public works and do me and parks and recreation.

49
00:12:34,320 --> 00:12:38,220
Those are kind of like the big things that people think of when like this is what city gives you.

50
00:12:38,380 --> 00:12:44,940
So they give you if you if you need to pick up the phone and dial them on one and get a police officer or firefighter in the MS truck.

51
00:12:45,360 --> 00:12:48,440
Those kind of things they pick up your garbage. They clear your streets.

52
00:12:49,260 --> 00:12:52,300
They pave your streets. They take care of the bridges.

53
00:12:52,300 --> 00:12:55,240
We're on record senior centers, they're swimming pools,

54
00:12:55,600 --> 00:12:58,180
partners playgrounds, all your policy fields and sport courts.

55
00:12:58,580 --> 00:13:00,880
That's all city government core services.

56
00:13:03,780 --> 00:13:05,140
That's the who what and where.

57
00:13:05,520 --> 00:13:08,280
But if you look at the how, there's a lot of stuff

58
00:13:08,280 --> 00:13:10,840
that goes on behind the scenes that you can see in the budget.

59
00:13:11,320 --> 00:13:14,640
I like to think of it as the stage crew of city government.

60
00:13:16,520 --> 00:13:19,200
So those are the departments like OMB and finance and planning.

61
00:13:19,200 --> 00:13:20,720
IMP is another one.

62
00:13:20,900 --> 00:13:24,940
The city clerks office does so much that nobody ever gets to see.

63
00:13:25,860 --> 00:13:29,760
They do an excellent job of hurting cats every single week to make sure that we have

64
00:13:29,760 --> 00:13:34,060
agendas that make sense and everything is legislatively going through correctly, but also

65
00:13:34,060 --> 00:13:38,660
things like we have to pay our utilities to keep those swimming pools and rex centers running.

66
00:13:39,660 --> 00:13:44,620
You need a ton of employees to run a city and you need to pay them good benefits.

67
00:13:44,620 --> 00:13:50,840
you need to provide them with tools and equipment and the vehicles that they drive around the city to do that work in.

68
00:13:51,060 --> 00:13:54,100
And we also need computers and networking and software and programs.

69
00:13:55,680 --> 00:14:02,200
We need a new ERSP system desperately and that is not something that is cheap, but is extremely necessary to run a city.

70
00:14:02,680 --> 00:14:10,840
And we also pay for a lot of death service because we don't have enough revenue up front to pay for everything that we need to specifically in the capital budget year after year.

71
00:14:10,840 --> 00:14:15,580
So like that's something that we have to account for in the budget that just makes the city go.

72
00:14:17,660 --> 00:14:18,800
So here's the slide.

73
00:14:19,100 --> 00:14:25,820
We showed a version of this a couple of years ago, but the value of city services that residents receive.

74
00:14:26,000 --> 00:14:26,980
This is what they pay.

75
00:14:27,000 --> 00:14:28,080
This is what they receive.

76
00:14:29,500 --> 00:14:35,340
So in 2025, the city has an operating budget of $669 million.

77
00:14:36,060 --> 00:14:42,360
And according to the, I think, 2023 census, there's 140,000 households in the city of Pittsburgh.

78
00:14:43,080 --> 00:14:59,780
So, per household per month, people receive $396 worth of services every month to drive on our roads and use our bridges and bike lanes and to have trash pick up and snow plows and EMS and firefighters and police.

79
00:15:00,000 --> 00:15:03,580
That's what they get every month.

80
00:15:05,280 --> 00:15:09,640
And some other general fund payments. So these don't show up in the operating budget. These are

81
00:15:09,640 --> 00:15:14,620
just transfers out of the general fund. So all of those revenues that we bring in, this

82
00:15:14,620 --> 00:15:19,680
also goes to the annual transfers out to the stop-of-the-violence trust fund, the housing

83
00:15:19,680 --> 00:15:25,000
opportunity fund, and the URA housing debt service. So right off the top of the budget, that's

84
00:15:25,000 --> 00:15:29,700
$22.5 million. And then the pay-go transfer, which is operating dollars that are left

85
00:15:29,700 --> 00:15:34,200
over after everything else that you have available to transfer to the capital budget.

86
00:15:38,740 --> 00:15:45,640
So this is about revenues and how does this, like, our spending depends on what we have available to spend.

87
00:15:47,340 --> 00:15:52,420
So I'm sure Jen is going to go into this in much more detail and a lot better detail than I could do.

88
00:15:52,420 --> 00:16:00,580
But it's basically for our general fund spending it's tax revenue and non-tax revenue and then sometimes we could grant but like a lot of those times

89
00:16:00,580 --> 00:16:07,620
It's one off so you can account for those every single year you want to make sure you have predictable regular revenues

90
00:16:07,620 --> 00:16:10,420
So that you can make a predictable regular budget

91
00:16:12,700 --> 00:16:22,160
So I want to go over we talked about some great things that the city does do and some some really core services that are top of the line that we do is we have an

92
00:16:22,160 --> 00:16:28,840
in Fire Bureau. They are super expensive, but they are very good at what they do. We also,

93
00:16:28,980 --> 00:16:33,640
this is a newer thing, the Freedom House Academy for EMS, the Chief Co-Crest is doing

94
00:16:33,640 --> 00:16:39,200
really, really good things to make sure that we are hiring as many EMTs as possible so that we're

95
00:16:39,200 --> 00:16:45,040
helping keep our city safe. We do a great job wearing our pools. I put an asterisk there because

96
00:16:45,040 --> 00:16:49,700
sometimes it has been difficult in the past to make sure that we hire enough life guards and that

97
00:16:49,700 --> 00:16:55,440
as put a strain on our budget, but it is such a great resource that the cities able to provide.

98
00:16:55,860 --> 00:16:56,700
And also spray parts.

99
00:16:56,920 --> 00:17:00,520
We've converted a lot of closed pools to spray parts, and they're achieving a run.

100
00:17:00,920 --> 00:17:02,240
It costs a lot of money with water.

101
00:17:02,520 --> 00:17:08,900
But it's an excellent resource for kids and it's safer because you don't need to swim for a spray park.

102
00:17:09,800 --> 00:17:13,640
So like those are really great things that we do every year with our budget.

103
00:17:14,460 --> 00:17:15,920
We also have a lot of shortfalls.

104
00:17:15,920 --> 00:17:26,560
I mentioned the pay-go transfer out, that goes towards things like the fleet and demolition of condemned buildings and traffic calming projects, and it's really not enough every year.

105
00:17:26,640 --> 00:17:33,440
The amount of debt that we have in our capital budget versus pay-go is not a healthy ratio.

106
00:17:34,900 --> 00:17:40,680
We also give money for the URA support for housing and land bank has gotten some money for us.

107
00:17:42,520 --> 00:17:43,740
It's not enough though.

108
00:17:43,840 --> 00:17:47,480
They're going to ask us for more money whenever we have those budget hearings.

109
00:17:48,080 --> 00:17:53,220
Also, we're seeing struggles keeping up with the amount of premium pay.

110
00:17:53,420 --> 00:17:55,160
I talked about how we have a great fire department.

111
00:17:55,720 --> 00:17:57,220
But again, it is very expensive.

112
00:17:57,540 --> 00:18:01,320
And there's going to be over budget on premium pay by eight or nine million dollars this year.

113
00:18:02,060 --> 00:18:06,880
Utilities, the cost of electric and water and things like that is just going to go up and up and up.

114
00:18:07,860 --> 00:18:17,800
And it's something that we're not going to be able to write as many services if we don't have additional revenues to expand because we just need to be able to pay the bills that we have.

115
00:18:18,180 --> 00:18:28,380
And also facilities maintenance, I sat at this table about 10 years ago at this point to talk about the facilities optimization plan that we weren't investing enough in our facilities.

116
00:18:28,380 --> 00:18:33,080
And we've done a better job since then, but we still have a ways to go.

117
00:18:33,240 --> 00:18:38,000
Anybody that has spent any time in this building can tell you that our facilities need

118
00:18:38,000 --> 00:18:38,840
a lot of work.

119
00:18:40,220 --> 00:18:42,460
So that's just another example of a shortfall.

120
00:18:43,880 --> 00:18:46,320
So then lastly, I wanted to go through, I think this is the last.

121
00:18:47,260 --> 00:18:52,460
But quickly, we're on to our budget process in September, and when we meet in August,

122
00:18:52,640 --> 00:18:55,740
but in Vice-September, the revenues are certified by the controllers office.

123
00:18:55,740 --> 00:19:01,820
We meet with all branches of government and go over them and sit down and ask questions and then the

124
00:19:02,500 --> 00:19:08,860
the controller certifies those revenues and upon that the mayor can build his budget and give us his spending plan.

125
00:19:09,280 --> 00:19:14,920
And he gives the first draft in the 30th and next Monday he'll release his official budget to City Council

126
00:19:14,920 --> 00:19:20,940
and then it's the everybody's funnest time of the year where we get to come in here like three or four days

127
00:19:20,940 --> 00:19:26,220
So we can talk about the budget and City Council will have an opportunity to make changes to

128
00:19:26,220 --> 00:19:26,400
that.

129
00:19:26,440 --> 00:19:27,320
You can make cuts.

130
00:19:27,680 --> 00:19:31,860
You can add stuff assuming you add revenue and there are ways to do that.

131
00:19:32,000 --> 00:19:33,180
The agenda will tell you about.

132
00:19:33,620 --> 00:19:38,900
But then by the end of the year, we will have the officials budget for the City of Pittsburgh.

133
00:19:39,840 --> 00:19:40,960
That's all I have.

134
00:19:45,650 --> 00:19:50,270
Oh, and just briefly, we are joined by Councilwoman Kale Smith as what did anyone else join?

135
00:19:50,270 --> 00:19:58,010
and also Councilman Bobby Wilson, Councilman Bob Scharlin, Councilman Daniel Level,

136
00:19:58,630 --> 00:19:59,970
Council President Daniel Level.

137
00:20:00,050 --> 00:20:06,990
So that's everyone here. Okay, last one. Yes, she was here at the start. Yeah, thank you. All right.

138
00:20:20,140 --> 00:20:22,940
We're here. Technical difficulty solved.

139
00:20:24,480 --> 00:20:39,500
So as my counterpart over here mentioned, the taxes pay a play of really huge role in our budget overall, about 60% or more of our budget is actually funded through tax revenue.

140
00:20:41,040 --> 00:20:48,320
the largest, there's basically two buckets, one bucket being real estate tax and the other

141
00:20:48,320 --> 00:20:54,960
one known is mostly comprised of what they call app 511 taxes, which are ones that are

142
00:20:54,960 --> 00:21:03,320
enabled, we're enabled to charge via state law and it's app 511. So just to give you a brief

143
00:21:03,320 --> 00:21:10,820
review of what real estate tax is, the city's current military is 0.06 mills, which is like

144
00:21:10,820 --> 00:21:18,780
$1,000 of a dollar. So basically, for every $100,000 worth of assessment, you can expect

145
00:21:18,780 --> 00:21:29,160
to pay about $800 and $6 in city tax revenue, only. Obviously, the school is at 10 and a quarter,

146
00:21:29,160 --> 00:21:36,060
Library is a quarter of a mail, parks is 50 or half a mail and the county is at 6.43.

147
00:21:36,980 --> 00:21:39,500
And the way we actually do this is a county sets an assessment.

148
00:21:40,320 --> 00:21:44,800
And it's a value based on what they think your property is worth.

149
00:21:45,020 --> 00:21:48,780
And that assessment is what we actually use to apply your millage to.

150
00:21:50,760 --> 00:21:54,260
In order to tell you how much tax that you're actually going to pay to us.

151
00:22:01,140 --> 00:22:09,840
The largest of the at 501 taxes is actually earned income tax, and that is actually superseded

152
00:22:09,840 --> 00:22:12,940
our collections over real estate.

153
00:22:13,220 --> 00:22:21,100
So in the past years, the real estate revenue was the real estate tax revenue was the largest revenue generator for the city of Pittsburgh.

154
00:22:22,000 --> 00:22:31,120
And due to something called the common-level ratio, which keeps reducing based on the fact that we are many, many years away from the last county reassess.

155
00:22:31,120 --> 00:22:34,420
that actual tax base is shrinking.

156
00:22:35,480 --> 00:22:40,000
So now earned income actually supersedes the amount of collections.

157
00:22:40,320 --> 00:22:44,780
It's the highest earner of tax revenue for the city's budget.

158
00:22:45,740 --> 00:22:49,740
So earned income actually includes some things like salaries, tips,

159
00:22:50,140 --> 00:22:54,340
wages and bonuses, severance pay, taxable fringe benefits,

160
00:22:54,640 --> 00:22:58,880
over time, vacation, things that are not considered earned income,

161
00:22:58,880 --> 00:23:01,820
more things like investment income, retirement benefits,

162
00:23:02,420 --> 00:23:05,800
any other government benefits, rental income, or alimony.

163
00:23:06,120 --> 00:23:09,240
So basically things that you would get from not actually

164
00:23:09,240 --> 00:23:12,920
performing a job of wage earnings.

165
00:23:14,400 --> 00:23:17,140
So currently, the City of Pittsburgh earned income tax rate

166
00:23:17,140 --> 00:23:21,960
is about 1% and the school district is 2%.

167
00:23:21,960 --> 00:23:27,460
So which means that any individual that earns about $72,000,

168
00:23:27,460 --> 00:23:31,380
which is the median income for the Pittsburgh metro area,

169
00:23:31,820 --> 00:23:36,280
they can expect to pay about $2,100 or $2,200

170
00:23:36,280 --> 00:23:39,500
in city earned income tax.

171
00:23:44,760 --> 00:23:48,060
So I just ran a little comparison because I think some people

172
00:23:49,080 --> 00:23:52,680
think that living in the city could potentially be

173
00:23:52,680 --> 00:23:56,900
more expensive tax-wise than in surrounding burrows

174
00:23:57,520 --> 00:23:58,680
or municipalities.

175
00:23:59,980 --> 00:24:08,840
as you can see and that this is added altogether. So what you would pay for city tax against what you would actually pay. Well,

176
00:24:08,880 --> 00:24:14,820
it's city tax and school anything that we would actually tax you on is in this calculation.

177
00:24:16,000 --> 00:24:24,980
As you can see it's definitely not the highest and if you sort of take a look at the EIT rates,

178
00:24:24,980 --> 00:24:34,440
They are set and they are pretty much stable for all of the municipalities basically because the P.A. State

179
00:24:34,440 --> 00:24:38,900
Local Tax Enabling Act has caps on most of those taxes.

180
00:24:40,240 --> 00:24:49,400
So we don't have the power or the authority to change anything with them if they've exceeded the cap.

181
00:24:49,400 --> 00:24:52,920
so we can only change the collection rates to the cap,

182
00:24:53,060 --> 00:24:53,700
and that's it.

183
00:24:53,900 --> 00:24:56,160
The only thing that we have true control over

184
00:24:56,160 --> 00:24:57,800
is our city-militrate.

185
00:24:59,640 --> 00:24:59,960
Um, a dick.

186
00:25:00,000 --> 00:25:26,040
Additionally, do I put in there? A lot of these other surrounding municipalities also pay for trash pickup, and that's notable because we do not. We do not have a separate charge for trash pickup. So just one of the services that you get, I wouldn't say, for free, but it's all included in the taxes that you pay to the city. It's not separate.

187
00:25:27,620 --> 00:25:36,240
And just going back to Act 511, so the taxing power for these taxes was given to us by the state of Pennsylvania.

188
00:25:37,000 --> 00:25:40,260
And as I said before, the taxing rates and limits are set by the state.

189
00:25:41,100 --> 00:25:51,400
And these taxes include specifically earned income, payroll prep or payroll expense tax, amusement tax, local service tax, the parking tax,

190
00:25:51,400 --> 00:25:56,360
and the ever-popular sports residents for its utility usage.

191
00:25:58,180 --> 00:26:00,340
These are any changes to these as I stayed

192
00:26:00,340 --> 00:26:04,200
before are absolutely limited at the municipal level.

193
00:26:09,190 --> 00:26:15,060
So just taking a look at, as I stayed in our biggest option

194
00:26:15,060 --> 00:26:19,000
for revenue generation is an increase to the milledrate.

195
00:26:19,000 --> 00:26:34,740
So, assuming a 1% increase from the current 8.06 mills, it would raise the miller rate to about 8.14 mills for city tax only.

196
00:26:35,940 --> 00:26:45,980
That would mean that you would pay $814 per 100,000 of assessment, which would be an increase of $8 per household.

197
00:26:46,860 --> 00:26:55,720
So, but overall the total revenue generation then would equal about 1.7 million additional

198
00:26:55,720 --> 00:27:04,960
dollars. So, we did the same for three, five, and ten years and the largest attempt,

199
00:27:05,000 --> 00:27:11,680
I mean percent, I'm sorry. So, 10 percent would actually increase the military up to 8.87,

200
00:27:11,680 --> 00:27:20,560
which would be an increase to $187 per $100,000 which would mean an increase of $81

201
00:27:20,560 --> 00:27:25,360
per household per $100,000 worth of assessment.

202
00:27:26,340 --> 00:27:31,760
So just to give you an idea of what that looks like and just to clarify

203
00:27:31,760 --> 00:27:38,200
$100,000 worth of assessment does not equal $100,000 worth of tax.

204
00:27:38,200 --> 00:27:40,160
it is not a one-to-one comparison.

205
00:27:41,860 --> 00:27:41,860
So,

206
00:27:47,690 --> 00:27:48,670
thank you.

207
00:27:58,680 --> 00:28:00,140
Oops, sorry for the members who joined.

208
00:28:00,620 --> 00:28:05,080
So, the way we're sort of formatting this post agenda is,

209
00:28:05,100 --> 00:28:08,400
we started out with P2Gavis are kind of what the bug,

210
00:28:08,400 --> 00:28:10,560
you know, what we pay for the things that we do.

211
00:28:10,900 --> 00:28:13,100
Director Gula is presenting, you know,

212
00:28:13,200 --> 00:28:15,140
the impacts of village increase, you know,

213
00:28:15,260 --> 00:28:18,460
how much we pay, how much Pittsburghers pay in taxes

214
00:28:18,460 --> 00:28:20,840
and the impacts of the village increase.

215
00:28:20,840 --> 00:28:29,820
And now we're hearing from Keystone Research Center about what an unearned income tax

216
00:28:29,820 --> 00:28:30,320
could look at.

217
00:28:30,440 --> 00:28:37,300
And then to finish, we'll have the Controllers Office and the Institute on Taxation and

218
00:28:37,300 --> 00:28:43,740
Economic Policy talk about pilot programs payment in lieu of taxes from our large non-profit.

219
00:28:43,820 --> 00:28:46,440
So that's just to clarify for the council members who are here.

220
00:28:46,440 --> 00:28:51,320
And I think we're still, yeah, I don't think anyone else will join.

221
00:28:51,760 --> 00:28:52,660
Okay, thanks.

222
00:28:52,880 --> 00:28:53,120
Go ahead.

223
00:28:53,360 --> 00:28:54,160
Thank you.

224
00:28:54,700 --> 00:28:59,080
So thanks so much for the opportunity to share information with you

225
00:28:59,080 --> 00:29:00,820
on the Pittsburgh Fair Share Tax.

226
00:29:00,940 --> 00:29:02,940
Again, my name's Diana Polson.

227
00:29:03,200 --> 00:29:05,720
I'm a senior policy analyst at the Keystone Research Center.

228
00:29:07,100 --> 00:29:09,400
We're a Pennsylvania based nonprofit research

229
00:29:09,400 --> 00:29:14,500
and policy organization focused on building shared prosperity in the state.

230
00:29:15,020 --> 00:29:20,900
In the first part of my PowerPoint, I'm going to describe what a fair share tax is, how it

231
00:29:20,900 --> 00:29:25,060
can raise revenue for the city and who would be most impacted, then I'll turn it over

232
00:29:25,060 --> 00:29:30,180
to Richie Fedor, municipal lawyer who has written and advised us on legal matters related

233
00:29:30,180 --> 00:29:31,880
to the Pittsburgh Fair Share Tax.

234
00:29:41,220 --> 00:29:47,240
So Pittsburgh's current tax system is unfair, meaning that working people, both low and middle

235
00:29:47,240 --> 00:29:52,480
come people pay a greater share of their incomes in Pittsburgh taxes than the wealthy do.

236
00:29:53,100 --> 00:29:58,420
In general, sales tax and property taxes are considered regressive, meaning that lower

237
00:29:59,040 --> 00:29:59,740
people's income.

238
00:30:00,000 --> 00:30:04,420
The lower people's income is the higher assure of their income they pay in taxes.

239
00:30:06,360 --> 00:30:13,600
Some other states and cities offset the regressive character of these taxes with graduated income

240
00:30:13,600 --> 00:30:17,400
taxes, but the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled that our constitution prohibits

241
00:30:17,400 --> 00:30:24,020
graduated income taxes. The cities income tax currently only taxes wages and salaries

242
00:30:24,020 --> 00:30:29,580
plus net profits from the operation of a business. But the city and school district do not

243
00:30:29,580 --> 00:30:34,900
tax other kinds of income that mostly go to wealthy people, such as dividends, capital gains and

244
00:30:34,900 --> 00:30:40,720
interest, and I'll get into what's included in these categories, rather along in my presentation.

245
00:30:42,140 --> 00:30:48,020
This figure divides up what share of income each income group in Pittsburgh from the richest

246
00:30:48,020 --> 00:30:55,060
1% to the poorest fifth currently pays on local income taxes, on the left you can see the average

247
00:30:55,060 --> 00:31:01,600
income of the bottom fifth of income earners and pitsburg is only about $15,000 per year.

248
00:31:02,120 --> 00:31:07,520
The middle fifth has an average wage of $67,000 per year and the bar all the way to the

249
00:31:07,520 --> 00:31:15,120
rate is the top 1% richest pitsburgers with an average of 2.1 million per year. You can also see

250
00:31:15,120 --> 00:31:19,920
that the richest 1% pays the lowest share of its income in city income taxes.

251
00:31:23,160 --> 00:31:23,740
So now I'm going to

252
00:31:23,740 --> 00:31:27,040
There are some more information about a Pittsburgh fair share tax.

253
00:31:34,340 --> 00:31:40,640
While Pittsburgh has a revenue problem, we don't believe that a broad-based tax increase

254
00:31:40,640 --> 00:31:45,960
is the best answer since lower-end middle income tax fares already pay an outsize share

255
00:31:45,960 --> 00:31:47,840
of their income on local taxes.

256
00:31:48,300 --> 00:31:52,380
As I mentioned earlier, most of Pittsburgh's income tax comes from wages, salaries,

257
00:31:59,240 --> 00:31:59,260
and

258
00:31:59,260 --> 00:32:01,280
The fair share tax solves this problem.

259
00:32:01,620 --> 00:32:04,260
It would raise a significant amount of additional revenue

260
00:32:05,000 --> 00:32:06,980
and make Pittsburgh's tax system more fair

261
00:32:06,980 --> 00:32:08,720
by taxing income from wealth.

262
00:32:09,720 --> 00:32:11,760
So let me get into the details.

263
00:32:13,340 --> 00:32:15,300
The state of Pennsylvania currently taxes eight

264
00:32:15,300 --> 00:32:17,520
crosses of income all of which are taxed

265
00:32:17,520 --> 00:32:20,880
at the same rate of 3.07% by the current Pennsylvania

266
00:32:20,880 --> 00:32:22,140
state income tax.

267
00:32:22,620 --> 00:32:24,340
I'm going to briefly go through these categories

268
00:32:24,340 --> 00:32:26,140
so we're all in the same page.

269
00:32:26,700 --> 00:32:28,920
The first two categories on the left are actively

270
00:32:28,920 --> 00:32:33,780
earned income, meaning it's money earned and exchange for active work, including compensation,

271
00:32:35,000 --> 00:32:40,740
which is payment received for services rendered, including wages, salaries, and it also includes

272
00:32:40,740 --> 00:32:43,860
the net income from the operational of business profession or farm.

273
00:32:44,640 --> 00:32:51,540
The next five categories in the middle column are forms of what is sometimes called unearnd

274
00:32:51,540 --> 00:32:57,740
income or passive income, and this is income that maybe requires investment of time or money,

275
00:32:57,740 --> 00:33:00,720
but has the potential to generate money over time with minimal effort.

276
00:33:01,360 --> 00:33:06,380
So this includes interest, which is generated by savings, money market accounts, bonds,

277
00:33:06,560 --> 00:33:11,620
and those kind of things, dividends, which are periodic payments by a company to its shareholders

278
00:33:11,620 --> 00:33:17,880
as a reward for their investment, neck gains or income from the sale exchange or other

279
00:33:17,880 --> 00:33:19,660
disposition of any kind of property.

280
00:33:20,060 --> 00:33:24,080
And you'll see this on feature slides referred to as capital gains.

281
00:33:24,080 --> 00:33:27,200
This includes real estate, tangible, personal property,

282
00:33:27,460 --> 00:33:29,200
intangible, personal property, investments,

283
00:33:29,520 --> 00:33:31,580
like stocks, and bonds.

284
00:33:33,040 --> 00:33:36,820
That gains from rents, royalties, patents, and copyrights,

285
00:33:37,060 --> 00:33:38,920
and income from estates or trusts.

286
00:33:42,560 --> 00:33:45,260
So Pittsburgh only taxes two of these classes of income,

287
00:33:45,840 --> 00:33:49,080
compensation, and net profits from the operation of business.

288
00:33:50,740 --> 00:33:54,760
The categories in red, however, are not currently tax

289
00:33:54,760 --> 00:33:56,420
in Pittsburgh, and these are the categories.

290
00:33:57,020 --> 00:33:58,900
You could include in a fair share tax.

291
00:33:59,960 --> 00:34:01,940
But before you present estimates of the increases

292
00:34:01,940 --> 00:34:04,960
in revenues from Pittsburgh share tax and data

293
00:34:04,960 --> 00:34:09,660
on who pays those increases, I just want to mention two things.

294
00:34:10,180 --> 00:34:12,120
First, I just want to note that a fair share tax

295
00:34:12,120 --> 00:34:15,200
would not tax retirement income, social security,

296
00:34:15,320 --> 00:34:17,360
unemployment benefits, federal active duty

297
00:34:17,360 --> 00:34:18,840
pay for military service.

298
00:34:19,440 --> 00:34:21,780
And secondly, for those who want to know more

299
00:34:21,780 --> 00:34:23,880
about the methodology behind these estimates,

300
00:34:23,880 --> 00:34:30,620
that's we're lucky to have Kamalika Daz, who's going to testify later from the Institute

301
00:34:30,620 --> 00:34:35,560
on Taxation and Economic Policy, who generated these estimates for us.

302
00:34:36,000 --> 00:34:42,260
In brief, the I-TEP model uses state level IRS tax data matched to Pittsburgh using American

303
00:34:42,260 --> 00:34:43,760
community survey data.

304
00:34:44,800 --> 00:34:47,120
I-TEP's modeling has a really great reputation.

305
00:34:47,960 --> 00:34:52,420
In the case of Pittsburgh, the Pittsburgh fair share tax, we have the added reassurance

306
00:34:52,420 --> 00:34:59,980
that comes from the fact that last time, I tap ran numbers in 2023, the pencil.

307
00:35:00,000 --> 00:35:10,500
We need a department of revenue corroborated those item estimates, both modellers came essentially to the same conclusion about revenues and who pays the increase.

308
00:35:11,140 --> 00:35:18,800
If the council wants a new round of item estimates validated, the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue told us last week that they're happy to do them.

309
00:35:22,380 --> 00:35:27,580
So there's many different ways if it's structure of fair share tax and Pittsburgh, which would tax income from wealth.

310
00:35:27,580 --> 00:35:33,060
I'm going to be mainly talking about option one, but I just wanted to share some options

311
00:35:33,060 --> 00:35:36,380
about how you could potentially structure it.

312
00:35:36,580 --> 00:35:43,180
Option one, you could tax income that goes mostly to the wealthiest Pittsburghs at the

313
00:35:43,180 --> 00:35:47,900
same current rate as the current Pittsburgh income tax, which is 1 percent that would generate

314
00:35:47,900 --> 00:35:53,660
between 20 and 27 million depending on what categories of income are taxed.

315
00:35:53,660 --> 00:36:00,160
2 would be taxing income from wealth at 2% and keeping the tax on income from wages at 1%

316
00:36:00,160 --> 00:36:07,200
this would bring in an additional 63 to 78 million more annually and option 3 you could decide

317
00:36:07,200 --> 00:36:12,140
down the road that you like to tax income from wealth at 2% but decrease income from wages and

318
00:36:12,140 --> 00:36:17,860
salaries to give lower and middle income earners a break. We've modeled this decrease in earned income

319
00:36:17,860 --> 00:36:26,680
tax to drop from 1% to 0.95%, it's a small amount, but enough where most Pittsburghers would

320
00:36:26,680 --> 00:36:31,960
see a decrease in their city income tax. This would bring in 55 to 69 million.

321
00:36:35,620 --> 00:36:35,920
So I'm going

322
00:36:35,920 --> 00:36:41,720
to spend the rest of my time diving into option one, tax income from wealth at the same rate

323
00:36:41,720 --> 00:36:48,280
as the current income tax. So on the slide with the three options, you could see that the

324
00:36:48,280 --> 00:36:53,880
potential revenues spans a range, the range is there because we modeled two options, depending

325
00:36:53,880 --> 00:36:58,540
on what you want to include in a fair share tax, and these aren't the only options.

326
00:36:58,740 --> 00:37:01,920
You could also decide to include or exclude some of the categories.

327
00:37:03,400 --> 00:37:08,120
But by just taxing interest dividends in capital gains at 1% of fair share tax would raise

328
00:37:08,120 --> 00:37:14,160
an additional $20 million annually, if you tax interest dividends capital gains, and incomes

329
00:37:14,160 --> 00:37:19,280
from rents, royalties, patents, copyrights, the states, and trust that 1% Pittsburgh could

330
00:37:19,280 --> 00:37:22,180
raise an additional 27 million annually.

331
00:37:24,860 --> 00:37:28,160
So I'm going to show some of the data and figures for the latter example.

332
00:37:28,760 --> 00:37:32,280
Here's a breakdown of where the 27 million would come from.

333
00:37:32,420 --> 00:37:34,400
This is how it breaks down by category.

334
00:37:35,500 --> 00:37:40,640
Capital gains would bring in 13.2 million rents, royalties, patents, copyrights,

335
00:37:40,640 --> 00:37:50,860
and trust labeled here as specialized income would raise an additional 7 million dividends would raise 5.2 million at interest 1.6 million.

336
00:37:53,500 --> 00:38:01,860
So who would pay for the tax increase? The pieces of the pie that are shades of blue are the top 20% of income earners in Pittsburgh.

337
00:38:02,620 --> 00:38:08,940
All together they would pay over 90% of the additional revenue raised by this version of the Fair Tax.

338
00:38:08,940 --> 00:38:17,660
The top 1% of income earners earning an average of 2.1 million a year would pay 51% of the total tax increase.

339
00:38:18,180 --> 00:38:24,480
The next 4% with an average wage was about $500,000 a year would pay 25% of the tax.

340
00:38:25,300 --> 00:38:35,460
And the bottom 80% of income earners, the small slice in yellow, those earning less than $113,000 a year would only pay for 8% of the tax increase.

341
00:38:36,620 --> 00:38:43,700
Some examples of this just to kind of make this more tangible, you know, wealthy Pittsburgher receives

342
00:38:43,700 --> 00:38:49,040
$100,000 in dividends this year, a 1% tax on that would be $1,000.

343
00:38:49,980 --> 00:38:54,820
A Pittsburgh resident owned some investment property purchased a property 10 years ago and

344
00:38:54,820 --> 00:38:55,700
is selling it.

345
00:38:55,960 --> 00:39:01,160
The property sells for $200,000, but once she subtracts what she owes and closing cost and fees

346
00:39:01,160 --> 00:39:03,240
her net gain is $50,000.

347
00:39:03,240 --> 00:39:06,820
a 1% local fair share tax would cost her a $500.

348
00:39:08,400 --> 00:39:14,500
Another example, a woman holds $25,000 in a savings account that pays 3% in annual interest,

349
00:39:14,740 --> 00:39:21,840
so she earned $750 in interest income, she would owe the cities $7.50 in a fair share tax.

350
00:39:24,570 --> 00:39:30,310
So this figure breaks down what percent of Pittsburghers in each income bracket that would see a tax increase.

351
00:39:30,310 --> 00:39:47,270
If you look at the bottom of the chart, only 11% of Pittsburghers at the bottom, 20% of income earners would see an increase, 35% of the middle income category would earn an average of 67,000 year would see an increase.

352
00:39:48,150 --> 00:39:51,070
But most people at the top income brackets would see an increase.

353
00:39:51,510 --> 00:39:57,410
But it's important to see how much of an increase these different categories of earners would see.

354
00:39:58,610 --> 00:39:59,970
This figure shows the app.

355
00:40:00,000 --> 00:40:15,160
Average tax increases by income distribution. So the dark blue shows the dark blue bars show the average tax change for the whole category of earners and the later blue bars shows the average tax change for those with a tax increase.

356
00:40:16,500 --> 00:40:27,420
As you can see, the average increase for the bottom 20% of income earners is $2 for the 11% that actually would see and increase their increase is an average of $16 in taxes.

357
00:40:28,300 --> 00:40:35,420
Increases very low for most Pittsburghers, and you start to see those bars get more substantial only in the top 5% of income earners.

358
00:40:36,480 --> 00:40:47,000
The real substantial increase occurs at the top of income distribution. The top 1% would see their taxes increase by about $5700 annually.

359
00:40:47,520 --> 00:40:51,980
And remember, these are individuals who have an average income of over $2 million.

360
00:40:53,100 --> 00:40:58,440
And with that, I'm going to pass it to Richie.

361
00:40:59,600 --> 00:41:00,560
Thanks, Diana.

362
00:41:01,360 --> 00:41:10,080
Just so you appreciate Diana asked me to talk about, since this is a new and novel way to raise money.

363
00:41:10,080 --> 00:41:19,020
She asked me to talk about the legal background to reassure you that this is to enact a tax like this would be well within city councils legal authority.

364
00:41:19,020 --> 00:41:24,240
and it will primarily derive from the same act of 511 that the Finance Director has talked about.

365
00:41:25,160 --> 00:41:27,780
Just 30 seconds of background on who I am.

366
00:41:28,160 --> 00:41:30,680
I'm a private municipal lawyer in Philadelphia.

367
00:41:31,100 --> 00:41:33,800
I also teach at Penn and Temple Law Schools.

368
00:41:33,960 --> 00:41:35,140
I teach local government law.

369
00:41:35,500 --> 00:41:38,400
But I spent most of my career working for the city of Philadelphia.

370
00:41:39,260 --> 00:41:42,780
And for 20 years I was the head of the city law department's legislation unit.

371
00:41:42,860 --> 00:41:46,540
And what I did for a living is exactly what I'm about to do here,

372
00:41:46,540 --> 00:41:51,320
which is analyzed legislative proposals on determined whether or not what is the legal authority

373
00:41:51,320 --> 00:41:56,760
and whether or not it is legal. And this one I feel very comfortable for as well within city councils

374
00:41:56,760 --> 00:42:03,340
authority. As the finest director mentioned, most of your taxing authority comes from at 511,

375
00:42:03,620 --> 00:42:08,160
the local tax enabling act. And the local tax enabling act initially says that Pittsburgh

376
00:42:08,160 --> 00:42:14,900
contacts anything it wishes. And then it lists the series of exceptions. And unless you can find

377
00:42:14,900 --> 00:42:20,780
exception, and there's a lot of exceptions, but unless you can find an exception, the baseline rule

378
00:42:20,780 --> 00:42:25,540
is Pittsburgh attacks anything it wishes. So I've looked through all those exceptions, and there

379
00:42:25,540 --> 00:42:31,440
is only one exception that even remotely relevant, most of the exceptions deal with all kind of

380
00:42:31,440 --> 00:42:37,120
specialty taxes, amusement taxes, business privilege taxes, they're just not relevant to an

381
00:42:37,120 --> 00:42:42,780
unarmed income tax. The only potentially relevant exception is the one that says Pittsburgh

382
00:42:42,780 --> 00:42:46,800
can not tax anything if the Commonwealth already taxes it.

383
00:42:47,000 --> 00:42:49,860
You can't generally have double taxation.

384
00:42:53,880 --> 00:43:03,080
And as you know, the Commonwealth does impose a personal income tax, and that personal income tax does cover all of the classes have income that Diana has talked about today.

385
00:43:03,080 --> 00:43:06,980
Interest dividends, capital gains income from royalties, patents, etc.

386
00:43:06,980 --> 00:43:11,900
So, at first question, it would seem that Pittsburgh doesn't have the authority to duplicate

387
00:43:11,900 --> 00:43:18,360
Pennsylvania's tax, but there's a critically important exception to this exception.

388
00:43:19,340 --> 00:43:24,420
And that is, that's the personal income tax statute itself says, and I'll just quote it,

389
00:43:24,420 --> 00:43:28,020
nothing, notwithstanding anything contained in any load of the contrary.

390
00:43:28,720 --> 00:43:36,960
The validity of any ordinance adopted by any political subdivision relating to the

391
00:43:36,960 --> 00:43:40,440
by anything contained in the personal income tax.

392
00:43:41,080 --> 00:43:47,100
So in other words, although Pittsburgh cannot duplicate any Pennsylvania tax, there's an

393
00:43:47,100 --> 00:43:47,920
important exception.

394
00:43:48,640 --> 00:43:51,740
You can duplicate anything that's in the personal income tax.

395
00:43:52,140 --> 00:43:55,760
You can't duplicate numerous other Pennsylvania tax.

396
00:43:55,760 --> 00:44:00,940
You can't duplicate inheritance taxes, fuel taxes, the corporate net income tax.

397
00:44:01,140 --> 00:44:05,060
Those all are outside of the personal income tax.

398
00:44:05,060 --> 00:44:12,880
But if it's in the personal income tax statute, there is nothing to put, it is not included in this prohibition on double taxation.

399
00:44:14,300 --> 00:44:23,140
So just reading that exception, applying it to this particular situation, notwithstanding the X5111 van on double taxation,

400
00:44:23,940 --> 00:44:32,300
the validity of the proposed fairshat share tax would not be affected or impaired by the Commonwealth tax on interest dividends, capital gains, etc.

401
00:44:32,300 --> 00:44:39,800
contained in the Pennsylvania personal income tax, the ban on double taxation simply does not apply here.

402
00:44:41,080 --> 00:44:47,700
Now, whenever that concludes the statutory analysis, the baseline rule has to protect anything.

403
00:44:47,940 --> 00:44:52,320
It wishes, unless there's an exception, and there is no relevant exception.

404
00:44:52,320 --> 00:44:58,980
critically, there also is nothing in the F5-1111 that addresses the maximum

405
00:44:58,980 --> 00:44:59,980
amount that you can take.

406
00:45:00,000 --> 00:45:29,980
Tax on an income, because it doesn't specifically discuss that on an income tax at all. And so there's no cap on on an income tax. You could, as the, as the, as the appropriate number, whenever you look at Pennsylvania taxes, you always have to at least look to see if it, if it raises a concern under the Pennsylvania uniformity clause under the Pennsylvania constitution for uniformity clause. And it, it does not raise a constitution.

407
00:45:29,980 --> 00:45:36,280
certain, the uniformity clause says that similar subjects must be taxed similarly and dissimilar

408
00:45:36,280 --> 00:45:43,800
subjects may be taxed similarly differently, earned income and earned income are very different

409
00:45:43,800 --> 00:45:50,320
categories and that's why, currently, you are allowed to tax earned income at 1% and not tax

410
00:45:50,320 --> 00:45:56,260
earned income at all. They have different categories, they can be taxed differently. But similarly,

411
00:45:56,260 --> 00:46:01,800
It is nothing to prohibit you from taxing the two of them at the same rate and moreover,

412
00:46:01,900 --> 00:46:05,320
there's nothing to prohibit you under the uniformity clause from treating them differently

413
00:46:05,320 --> 00:46:09,880
taxing, on-earned income, at a higher rate than earned income.

414
00:46:10,780 --> 00:46:16,320
And similarly, all of the subcategories of on-earned income, interest dividends, capital gains,

415
00:46:16,520 --> 00:46:24,000
net income from rents, royalties, each of those is clearly considered a separate class of

416
00:46:24,000 --> 00:46:25,940
income under Pennsylvania law.

417
00:46:26,120 --> 00:46:32,660
And we know that from the PA40 that we all fill out, hopefully, each line represents a different

418
00:46:32,660 --> 00:46:33,760
class of income.

419
00:46:34,260 --> 00:46:38,600
And therefore, the uniformity clause would give you complete freedom, constitutionally,

420
00:46:39,040 --> 00:46:44,560
to pick and choose from the manual of honor and income that Diana has talked about.

421
00:46:44,580 --> 00:46:49,120
If you want it to only tax dividends and capital gains and net income for royalty, you

422
00:46:49,120 --> 00:46:52,460
would be free to pick and choose and there's nothing in the uniformity clause that would

423
00:46:52,460 --> 00:46:53,160
preclude that.

424
00:46:53,160 --> 00:46:58,880
So given that there's no statutory exception, that's on point, and there's no uniformity close problem.

425
00:46:59,260 --> 00:47:04,380
There's no legal impediment to the Pittsburgh City Council adopting a fair share tax.

426
00:47:06,000 --> 00:47:07,320
That concludes my presentation.

427
00:47:13,940 --> 00:47:14,200
Great.

428
00:47:14,360 --> 00:47:15,140
Thank you very much.

429
00:47:15,200 --> 00:47:23,980
I also want to say Councilwoman Gross has joined us, and so now, so we have talked about millaging

430
00:47:23,980 --> 00:47:24,380
increase.

431
00:47:24,520 --> 00:47:29,580
We have talked about a fair share tax, and now we are going to move to the Institute

432
00:47:29,580 --> 00:47:35,640
on taxation and economic policy as well as the controllers office to talk a bit about

433
00:47:35,640 --> 00:47:40,820
pilot programs, payment and lieu of taxes where we are, you know, we're our large non-profits

434
00:47:40,820 --> 00:47:43,740
would be helping to contribute to our revenue.

435
00:47:44,720 --> 00:47:47,580
So with that, Kamalika, are you?

436
00:47:48,340 --> 00:47:49,300
Yes, I'm here.

437
00:47:49,620 --> 00:47:49,660
Okay.

438
00:47:50,220 --> 00:47:51,460
I don't have slides.

439
00:47:51,780 --> 00:47:52,820
Those all just talk to folks.

440
00:47:53,000 --> 00:47:53,120
Okay.

441
00:47:53,160 --> 00:47:53,600
That's fine.

442
00:47:53,800 --> 00:47:53,980
That's fine.

443
00:47:54,320 --> 00:47:59,600
Okay, so everybody, thank you for this opportunity to seek and for what we could ask.

444
00:47:59,880 --> 00:48:06,460
I live in Philadelphia and the Liberal Tax Policy Director at the Institute of Taxation

445
00:48:06,460 --> 00:48:12,400
Economic Policy, or ITO, to non-profit, non-partisan tax policy organization,

446
00:48:13,000 --> 00:48:16,740
conduct rigorous analyses of tax and economic proposals.

447
00:48:18,060 --> 00:48:23,160
So before I go into everything else, I realize that we all understand how pressing the local

448
00:48:23,160 --> 00:48:28,960
revenue challenges are nationwide, especially just given the massive federal cuts to

449
00:48:28,960 --> 00:48:33,660
help care through distance and other supports, but I just want to mention one

450
00:48:33,660 --> 00:48:38,660
other last reported on issue that will certainly affect local budgets going forward

451
00:48:39,320 --> 00:48:43,960
that I took with me have been really honed in on and let's speak conformity.

452
00:48:46,020 --> 00:48:51,300
You know that unfortunately a lot of the costly regressive policies of OBE,

453
00:48:51,300 --> 00:48:58,980
A, O, B, B, B, A could flow through to states, for the local governments too, and that since

454
00:48:58,980 --> 00:49:03,640
the states will just have a lot less money available for revenue sharing, so it's a bit

455
00:49:03,640 --> 00:49:04,320
of a double way.

456
00:49:04,440 --> 00:49:09,760
I mean, the states and localities can pick up the slack of slashed federal support and plus

457
00:49:09,760 --> 00:49:15,580
the impacts of subsidies either automatically or deliberately adopting the same provisions.

458
00:49:15,580 --> 00:49:21,700
So, the ones to keep an eye out for impulse will be in the end to really encourage sea

459
00:49:21,700 --> 00:49:28,260
policy makers to put that on to not limit or decouple from the permanent exception

460
00:49:28,260 --> 00:49:36,460
of opportunity zones, the restoration and expansion of the provision, notice the 100% bonus

461
00:49:36,460 --> 00:49:42,540
depreciation and the drastic exception of 529 accounts that have been pretty much hijacked

462
00:49:42,540 --> 00:49:44,460
by a lot of private school boosters.

463
00:49:45,060 --> 00:49:47,420
We have more details on all of that on our website,

464
00:49:47,620 --> 00:49:50,500
but I just wanted to mention that as another example,

465
00:49:50,780 --> 00:49:52,640
I look how do you say to focus on revenue

466
00:49:52,640 --> 00:49:56,520
and just the dominant effects of these federal decisions.

467
00:49:58,320 --> 00:49:59,980
So all of that said, one of those.

468
00:50:00,340 --> 00:50:10,420
Really comment some decisions, so cities can take to call back to the revenue, the city's state, you know, as in that's not profits to contribute more to city revenues.

469
00:50:11,920 --> 00:50:19,120
And pay the record, you know, our own research shows that Pennsylvania has the fourth most regressive state local tax system in the nation.

470
00:50:19,780 --> 00:50:26,700
So the last of these large nonprofit institutions pay the more taxes fall to lowest paid households.

471
00:50:26,700 --> 00:50:32,520
So, the research is clear that many of these organizations need to contribute more.

472
00:50:32,760 --> 00:50:37,620
There is a 2021 on public study that found the nonprofit hospitals, actually some

473
00:50:37,620 --> 00:50:43,800
blasts on charity care, then for profit hospitals and the amount of sending uncovering

474
00:50:43,800 --> 00:50:48,760
that a key shortfall is actually pretty similar for profit and nonprofit hospitals.

475
00:50:49,720 --> 00:50:51,600
There is also a 2024 study.

476
00:50:51,600 --> 00:50:59,220
the moment to, from about 80% of hospitals and last Ontario care and community investment,

477
00:51:00,160 --> 00:51:03,000
then the estimated value of their tax rates.

478
00:51:04,240 --> 00:51:07,680
So, the bulk of what I'm talking about, what are other cities doing about this.

479
00:51:08,680 --> 00:51:11,480
This one is mostly, so this will start there.

480
00:51:11,920 --> 00:51:14,780
So, it's like field, not so too safe.

481
00:51:15,120 --> 00:51:18,180
The pretty recently took a pretty huge step forward.

482
00:51:18,180 --> 00:51:23,960
They had an internal audit that found that the city recorded pretty modest pilot receipts,

483
00:51:24,400 --> 00:51:29,940
while the exact property volumes pretty much ran into civilians, and so their local council

484
00:51:29,940 --> 00:51:36,480
subcommittee recommended developing a formal pilot program, just to push all these colleges, hospitals,

485
00:51:36,620 --> 00:51:42,660
and charities to contribute more to the tax base. The subcommittee recommended standardized

486
00:51:42,660 --> 00:51:51,440
and legislation that would lots of the use require up to 25% of the amount that you assessed

487
00:51:51,440 --> 00:51:54,100
in taxes if they were regular businesses.

488
00:51:55,440 --> 00:51:59,700
So this agreement still in the works that it seems like something for Pittsburgh to

489
00:51:59,700 --> 00:52:11,110
floor as a lot all, you know, I think the thing that feels probably most important for Pittsburgh

490
00:52:11,110 --> 00:52:14,670
I'm really just kind of pushing for that seat in New England legislation.

491
00:52:16,350 --> 00:52:19,410
Boston is often cited as precedent here.

492
00:52:20,750 --> 00:52:24,190
It's very, it's a public formulaic, high-level cost.

493
00:52:24,710 --> 00:52:31,810
It's 25 percent, again, a hypothetical tax liability with credits for verified community benefits

494
00:52:31,810 --> 00:52:35,630
and public disclosure for cost and receipts.

495
00:52:36,410 --> 00:52:42,890
That's six cents the is a solid for self, so Boston in a annually post, the requested

496
00:52:42,890 --> 00:52:49,270
pilot amounts in the share of the institution's actually the E. This program, because

497
00:52:49,270 --> 00:52:55,590
it's voluntary institutions, routinely pay a lot below the city's asked and participation

498
00:52:55,590 --> 00:53:03,470
varies quite a bit by structure. This is an example in fiscal year 2023, the city requested,

499
00:53:03,470 --> 00:53:08,390
It gives like over a hundred million, or over a hundred, twenty million, hundred

500
00:53:08,390 --> 00:53:12,110
of California, and then received maybe about 30 to 40.

501
00:53:13,210 --> 00:53:16,790
And so it's a solid model for public accounting and transparency,

502
00:53:17,550 --> 00:53:22,150
but not guaranteed compliance, not for accountability, not necessarily.

503
00:53:23,350 --> 00:53:27,390
The other place where this has been a huge topic of conversation is in Chicago.

504
00:53:27,930 --> 00:53:30,470
There's a huge grassroots push going on right there.

505
00:53:30,470 --> 00:53:38,230
among various deeper groups and coalitions and even among older men in asking for a university

506
00:53:38,230 --> 00:53:42,490
use for piloting payments that are tied to institutional law.

507
00:53:43,350 --> 00:53:46,750
And so, this is, you know, very much in the beginning stages.

508
00:53:46,790 --> 00:53:51,990
But organizers have produced some concrete estimates showing how much to be raised.

509
00:53:52,210 --> 00:53:55,210
If they were held accountable, and in some of those estimates,

510
00:53:55,210 --> 00:54:04,870
They're saying it's up to 250 annually, if the largest universities are included, again, that's very much in the beginning stages.

511
00:54:06,270 --> 00:54:13,970
Baltimore, that's another big one. Again, this is all happening. There's a lot going on right now.

512
00:54:13,970 --> 00:54:19,510
So they present some pretty, they have some, they give a lot of conflict steps recently.

513
00:54:20,450 --> 00:54:26,210
Just about a month ago, Baltimore announced a new non-profit assessment deal with 14

514
00:54:26,210 --> 00:54:32,110
Ingrid's institutions there for fiscal year 2020-2031.

515
00:54:33,030 --> 00:54:38,710
So under that deal, the pilot payments are going to double over that time.

516
00:54:38,710 --> 00:54:45,230
So this started up about 620,000 and 20,000 and increased to 12,000 and by 2030.

517
00:54:46,570 --> 00:54:50,450
I will say there's been sort of a mixed reaction to these negotiations.

518
00:54:51,450 --> 00:54:53,470
No, the plus side, it's a huge stuff forward.

519
00:54:54,510 --> 00:54:59,590
They're having some critics that have pointed out that the decision itself didn't have a lot of transparency that wasn't.

520
00:55:00,000 --> 00:55:10,840
A public participatory process and the amounts are so pretty small compared to the top straight from just those institutions use of cities or surveys.

521
00:55:11,840 --> 00:55:28,140
So I think there was one estimate that even after doubling the payment, they would only be about 10% of the full tax liability, which you can see compared to the Boston model, again, of some fault, hearing the best more like 25.

522
00:55:29,440 --> 00:55:36,020
And so what are we going to do about it, strong economy, accountability measures, it's not mandated by statute.

523
00:55:38,320 --> 00:55:46,580
I think I wanted to end with Providence Rhode Island. It feels like a really good example of a city that's finally gotten some traction on this.

524
00:55:46,580 --> 00:55:52,960
One has heard, I'm sorry, one of the providence who is facing potential bankruptcy,

525
00:55:53,500 --> 00:55:57,740
doctorate and great recession. That's why some universities like Brown,

526
00:55:57,880 --> 00:56:05,120
they start making voluntary contributions, but it wasn't until 2023 that a lot of the city leaders

527
00:56:05,120 --> 00:56:10,580
who's free negotiated that deal because they're just not paying enough. There's continued financial

528
00:56:10,580 --> 00:56:15,120
pressure so that agreement more than doubled with the schools have been contributing

529
00:56:15,120 --> 00:56:23,820
to nearly like a hundred million over 20 years and then Brown signed a separate agreement with

530
00:56:23,820 --> 00:56:30,860
providence to provide an additional almost 50 million involuntary payments on top of what

531
00:56:30,860 --> 00:56:37,620
was outlined in the MOU. So in terms of lessons for Pittsburgh, I think one of the big things

532
00:56:37,620 --> 00:56:42,340
to take away from providence is just how long-term this is, just having this predictable

533
00:56:42,340 --> 00:56:49,300
long-term payments for 20 years. That's a great idea. The agreements are pretty clear. They're

534
00:56:49,300 --> 00:56:55,700
public, you can find them online. They are so technically voluntary. They're not

535
00:56:55,700 --> 00:57:00,800
right in the statute, but it would be, they would get pretty huge public backlogs of pages

536
00:57:00,800 --> 00:57:06,140
locked away from those agreements. So there are still some lessons to be taken away from

537
00:57:07,200 --> 00:57:14,760
Yeah, and I think in Toronto, I'm just saying it's an issue that lots of cities are grappling with and giving the expected revenue and stability,

538
00:57:15,960 --> 00:57:21,140
hiring costs, picking up a stock for the federal cuts, makes them explore some of these options,

539
00:57:21,920 --> 00:57:27,120
and, you know, as you all know, I'm realized, potential and Pittsburgh is just pretty massive.

540
00:57:29,540 --> 00:57:35,740
And now feel free to email me at Kamalika.com.org and I have to provide some more details.

541
00:57:36,180 --> 00:57:36,900
Thank you.

542
00:57:37,780 --> 00:57:39,320
Thank you very much Kamalika.

543
00:57:40,000 --> 00:57:41,080
Can you control her?

544
00:57:44,520 --> 00:57:50,100
We also don't have a slide deck, but I just wanted to, again, thank Councilperson Warwick

545
00:57:50,100 --> 00:57:53,420
for convening this conversation from our perspective.

546
00:57:53,540 --> 00:57:57,600
We believe that this should be part of the dialogue as the budget process moves forward.

547
00:57:58,180 --> 00:58:05,120
As we flagged in response to the initial 246 budget proposal, our perspective is that some

548
00:58:05,120 --> 00:58:10,740
of those city expenditures have been deflated to get to balance on paper and we do not

549
00:58:10,740 --> 00:58:16,820
believe that this budget or word of crisis point that does not need to be a crisis, but we

550
00:58:16,820 --> 00:58:19,440
don't think that we should not be waiting.

551
00:58:21,000 --> 00:58:28,460
And as the conversation with voluntary payments or pilots unfolds, we did wait in 2024.

552
00:58:29,180 --> 00:58:32,380
We waited until we were in Act 47 to have a conversation with pilots.

553
00:58:33,500 --> 00:58:37,700
And we had a 10-year agreement, and a lot of that was shrouded in secrecy.

554
00:58:38,200 --> 00:58:43,240
We did a report in 2022, which was written primarily by my colleague Mark Patak.

555
00:58:43,740 --> 00:58:49,420
And as you can see, it was, again, it's a three-year-old report, but only 18.2 million

556
00:58:49,420 --> 00:58:58,500
of the 121 million actually came through and a lot of it was unable to be deciphered, we don't

557
00:58:58,500 --> 00:59:07,560
know who paid white. The highest amount that came in was 5.8 million and 2026. And the total revenue

558
00:59:07,560 --> 00:59:13,860
that year was 437 million, which is about 1.8% of revenue came from that pilot agreement.

559
00:59:15,680 --> 00:59:19,960
From our perspective, the Pittsburgh Public Service Fund, which was created in 2004,

560
00:59:20,780 --> 00:59:26,040
I didn't help bui city revenue, but it was not a sustainable revenue source.

561
00:59:27,180 --> 00:59:34,300
It peaked, like I said in 2006, it was unpredictable, and it was not handled for my perspective.

562
00:59:34,640 --> 00:59:39,060
Again, in retrospect, I'm Monday morning quarterbacking, but it was not handled in a way that

563
00:59:39,060 --> 00:59:42,320
I think best serve taxpayers, because there was just no predictability with it.

564
00:59:42,320 --> 00:59:47,460
So, as the conversation unfolds with voluntary payments from our non-profits, I think that

565
00:59:47,460 --> 00:59:52,380
we just need to remember that city taxpayers are paying their textiles every year and

566
00:59:52,380 --> 00:59:57,520
we need to make sure that the conversation with the non-large non-profits, you know,

567
00:59:57,960 --> 00:59:59,980
remembers that our taxpayers are affected.

568
01:00:00,000 --> 01:00:29,980
Today that they'll every year, and there needs to be some transparency in the process that, you know, if we're having those conversations that there's some level of transparency that, you know, ex, ex, non-profit is paying, ex-dollar a year. And this is what the money is going towards. Our office is actually releasing a report, I think next week, on the status of the fleet and a recommendation in that, is that the city established a frontline fleet trust fund and that some dedicated revenue from the

569
01:00:30,740 --> 01:00:37,360
voluntary payment go towards that because we believe that the status of the fleet right now is the public safety issue.

570
01:00:38,040 --> 01:00:41,780
So, again, I'm happy to have a conversation.

571
01:00:42,400 --> 01:00:43,260
We don't have a slide deck.

572
01:00:43,380 --> 01:00:46,920
I'm like I said the reports from 2022 and Mark, I don't know if you've anything to add.

573
01:00:47,840 --> 01:00:52,240
But my hope is that as the conversation around voluntary payments unfolds that A.

574
01:00:52,620 --> 01:00:54,480
It is a voluntary payment.

575
01:00:54,960 --> 01:00:56,200
And we recognize that.

576
01:00:56,200 --> 01:01:10,980
But at the same time, we do well when they do well and they do well when we do well, and I think that we need to engage in a good faith conversation with all of the nonprofit partners in Western Pennsylvania, and you know, we have nonprofit employers.

577
01:01:11,660 --> 01:01:19,260
There are a lot of foundations who have made a lot of money off of people who have worked and lived in Western Pennsylvania for 150 years.

578
01:01:19,260 --> 01:01:35,020
And those folks need also be part of the conversation as well, but I think in 2005, when the public service fund was created, we waited too long to have that conversation, and now is the time that we need to start this conversation with the large nonprofits.

579
01:01:36,240 --> 01:01:38,460
So with that, Mark, do anything you want to end.

580
01:01:39,480 --> 01:01:43,660
So I'm happy to have a conversation, but again, thank you for convening this conversation. It needs to happen.

581
01:01:43,660 --> 01:01:50,760
Yeah, absolutely. Okay. Well, thank you all, everyone, so much for coming and I guess I want to quickly

582
01:01:50,760 --> 01:01:55,880
are there any members who have a time commitment that they need? Anyone?

583
01:01:58,240 --> 01:01:58,600
I know.

584
01:02:00,720 --> 01:02:06,640
There's folks online. So I will start then in that case with Councilwoman Strauss Berger.

585
01:02:12,380 --> 01:02:13,060
Thank you all.

586
01:02:13,060 --> 01:02:21,240
And thank you, Councilmember Warwick, for convening this apologies for staying out camera

587
01:02:21,240 --> 01:02:27,140
for the time being, but I very much was tuning in listening in on all of these presentations.

588
01:02:28,860 --> 01:02:37,420
And in the spirit of creating a dialogue, which I hope this is, and very much not putting anyone

589
01:02:37,420 --> 01:02:39,580
on the side, so I'll just open it up more generally.

590
01:02:41,680 --> 01:02:45,620
The THAN SHAN TACS is something that I've heard of before

591
01:02:46,360 --> 01:02:48,820
from some of the folks who presented it today.

592
01:02:50,040 --> 01:02:53,000
And it's not something that's brought up in other symbols

593
01:02:54,660 --> 01:03:00,070
when we're discussing opportunities for a balanced budget.

594
01:03:01,400 --> 01:03:06,040
And I would, again, in the series of a dialogue,

595
01:03:06,040 --> 01:03:24,730
I'm not putting it in on the spot. I'm about to hear other folks' reaction to the extent you feel comfortable and what the upsides and the downsides might be of this in the city.

596
01:03:25,550 --> 01:03:34,570
Of course, first thought that comes to mind is the legality that that was actually handled in the conversation, but I would like to hear some of the action.

597
01:03:39,110 --> 01:03:47,510
So, I can weigh in on that a little bit, I think, and I think from finance standpoint, less

598
01:03:47,510 --> 01:03:57,130
of a legality issue is more of how do we actually collect and institute the tax should

599
01:03:57,130 --> 01:03:59,410
this be the path that we go on?

600
01:03:59,690 --> 01:04:02,890
I mean, this is not something that could happen for us overnight.

601
01:04:02,890 --> 01:04:16,090
So it would take a lot of planning, it may take resources like employees in order to process or even hiring a third party vendor to collect.

602
01:04:16,730 --> 01:04:26,190
It could also mean like changing tax systems to accommodate bringing in a new tax type and form generation.

603
01:04:26,190 --> 01:04:33,310
And as well as like rules and regs that we would absolutely have to allow the public to inspect

604
01:04:33,310 --> 01:04:38,530
and weigh on for certain amounts of time should like we start down the legislation path.

605
01:04:39,190 --> 01:04:43,450
So it's not something that's an immediate fix.

606
01:04:43,970 --> 01:04:50,330
I mean we definitely could if it's you know the will of council to entertain something like this.

607
01:04:50,470 --> 01:04:55,310
We could definitely head down that path but it's not going to be something that's going to happen overnight.

608
01:04:55,310 --> 01:04:59,830
So time constraints and maybe resources.

609
01:05:00,000 --> 01:05:05,320
This is an order to institute it, it would be a constraint for my department, like currently.

610
01:05:08,480 --> 01:05:14,480
I mean, I would say something that we could move forward with cautious optimism and not to

611
01:05:14,480 --> 01:05:18,440
second guess anything. You guys know this way better than I do, so I don't mean to

612
01:05:18,440 --> 01:05:22,640
second guess you, but we have sat at tables with lawyers that told us, yeah, you can collect

613
01:05:22,640 --> 01:05:28,780
this tax. It's no problem. And then it turns out we can't. So it's something that should

614
01:05:28,780 --> 01:05:33,680
we looked into further but to echo what Jen said. Finance is the one area in the city that you

615
01:05:33,680 --> 01:05:39,400
got to spend money to make money. It's actually incredible the amount of work that Jen and Ian

616
01:05:39,400 --> 01:05:44,140
and their entire staff does to bring in as much money as possible for the city of Pittsburgh.

617
01:05:45,020 --> 01:05:50,080
And we can't commend them enough but they can only do so much. So if we want to explore something new,

618
01:05:50,680 --> 01:05:55,840
we should take it very slowly and be very methodical but also make sure that they have the resources

619
01:05:55,840 --> 01:06:00,680
So we don't set to high-of-expectations and then come back in three years and we dug ourselves

620
01:06:00,680 --> 01:06:02,560
the giant hole without making any progress.

621
01:06:03,560 --> 01:06:06,220
So it's definitely something that we should look into.

622
01:06:06,900 --> 01:06:10,720
We should get every penny that we possibly could because we'd want to provide good services

623
01:06:10,720 --> 01:06:13,280
to the city of Pittsburgh and its residents.

624
01:06:14,500 --> 01:06:19,440
But we have to make sure that we're not putting ourselves in a compromise position.

625
01:06:20,100 --> 01:06:33,040
And to add to Pete's comments, I mean, we did institute like a Billboard exercise tax, which we did many years ago, and we're still not collecting because it's tied up in litigation.

626
01:06:35,300 --> 01:06:43,460
So these are concerns, you know, for us, just because we head down that road, it doesn't mean that we'll actually get there.

627
01:06:44,020 --> 01:06:47,520
So, and it will take resources from us in order to be able to do it.

628
01:06:53,180 --> 01:07:00,000
Thank you, appreciate that answer, all of just a one-on-one question, and then I'll wrap up with a comment.

629
01:07:01,960 --> 01:07:10,040
When, this might, I believe this is for a comma week of primarily, but others can try to, when we discussed pilot agreements.

630
01:07:11,280 --> 01:07:20,940
There was cynicism of the one-PGH plan that made a video put into place because it was a third party nonprofit that would collect the funds,

631
01:07:20,940 --> 01:07:31,900
than work-decented on city priorities there as not that an agreement reached system, but it's

632
01:07:31,900 --> 01:07:38,820
my understanding that any agreement probably would not go straight to city conferences because

633
01:07:38,820 --> 01:07:48,000
of the tax benefits that the institutions would realize by contributing to a non-profit

634
01:07:48,000 --> 01:07:51,340
rather than to a droplet to the city, to government.

635
01:07:52,040 --> 01:07:57,820
Is this a challenge that you find elsewhere and how is it handled elsewhere and how

636
01:07:57,820 --> 01:07:58,640
is public perception?

637
01:07:58,960 --> 01:08:04,660
I think one of the big downfalls of the things that I was put into place was public perception

638
01:08:04,660 --> 01:08:11,390
of that being, you know, called a slosh song or being called something else, but if it

639
01:08:11,390 --> 01:08:21,890
is the most the only way that institutions will want to increase this but coming to the city

640
01:08:21,890 --> 01:08:26,930
ultimately because they're then receiving that tax benefit or two it's only way that a deal

641
01:08:26,930 --> 01:08:34,810
gets on how our other state grappling with that aspect of it. Yeah I know what that at least in

642
01:08:34,810 --> 01:08:41,390
Providence and Baltimore a lot of like and Providence those payments from the universities and hospitals

643
01:08:41,390 --> 01:08:47,970
go directly into the city's general fund or they're like earmarks, you know, these long-term

644
01:08:47,970 --> 01:08:54,090
hello use. And so I guess, you know, I guess the short answer there is, at least I

645
01:08:54,090 --> 01:09:01,730
know that in Providence and Baltimore they're not grappling with it. In the same way, I

646
01:09:01,730 --> 01:09:08,930
don't know exactly about Boston to be honest, but I think the fact that they have just

647
01:09:08,930 --> 01:09:13,770
like very clear formula based system and, you know, the fact that, you know, they have like

648
01:09:13,770 --> 01:09:19,790
a lot of public reporting, some states, like I think that probably helps a little bit.

649
01:09:20,930 --> 01:09:25,530
You know, I will say, you know, I type usually is on the kind of policy side, less so when

650
01:09:25,530 --> 01:09:31,250
the administrative side, so apologies if I don't have a lot of a detailed first ones.

651
01:09:31,250 --> 01:09:37,990
No, it's helpful, even knowing that if you'd be able to point to a few other cities that can

652
01:09:38,790 --> 01:09:45,450
the understanding it's not always an apples to apples compare us and understanding that there are few of the cities to point to

653
01:09:45,450 --> 01:09:49,730
could be helpful in future negotiations that are cities entering into.

654
01:09:50,290 --> 01:09:51,130
So, that's great.

655
01:09:52,330 --> 01:09:57,910
Okay, lastly, I'll turn it over to my back to the non-chair to the council colleagues.

656
01:10:00,000 --> 01:10:15,220
The general stance here is, yes, we should be collective or revenue. No, we don't want to have to move into an austerity mode. No one wants that. It's painful for everyone.

657
01:10:15,220 --> 01:10:21,280
We're going to do a vast majority of what we're sending our funds on is vast, that's the

658
01:10:21,280 --> 01:10:26,780
majority is positive and is exactly where we should be spending our money, I think.

659
01:10:28,760 --> 01:10:34,480
And any kind of revenue generation involves trade-offs and involves some level of pain

660
01:10:34,480 --> 01:10:43,780
for some partners for not even partners, institutions, individuals, residents, etc.

661
01:10:45,280 --> 01:10:50,160
So there's no easy answer, but I appreciate the panoply options that we're offered today

662
01:10:50,160 --> 01:10:52,860
and look forward to future budget decisions.

663
01:10:53,720 --> 01:10:54,060
Thank you.

664
01:10:54,360 --> 01:10:54,860
Madam Chair.

665
01:10:58,270 --> 01:10:58,770
Great.

666
01:10:58,930 --> 01:10:59,770
Thank you.

667
01:11:00,430 --> 01:11:04,190
With that, I believe Councilman Sharland

668
01:11:11,420 --> 01:11:14,300
may actually be under the weather today, so he

669
01:11:14,300 --> 01:11:19,060
may not be up for, and I'm very appreciative that he joined.

670
01:11:29,040 --> 01:11:29,120
Great.

671
01:11:30,280 --> 01:11:33,020
I don't think I have a whole question.

672
01:11:33,300 --> 01:11:34,540
This was a lot to digest.

673
01:11:35,560 --> 01:11:38,660
And I really thank you for putting together this.

674
01:11:41,460 --> 01:11:44,840
You're kind of an immediate opportunity for us.

675
01:11:46,380 --> 01:11:49,480
And I'm actually very excited to have for the discussion topics,

676
01:11:50,280 --> 01:11:51,840
but I don't really have questions right now.

677
01:11:51,840 --> 01:11:55,840
because I'm a good candidate, just a big thank you.

678
01:11:56,500 --> 01:11:56,740
Thanks.

679
01:11:56,860 --> 01:11:57,620
Thanks, thank you.

680
01:11:57,960 --> 01:11:58,180
Thank you.

681
01:11:59,300 --> 01:12:01,960
And then Councilwoman Smith.

682
01:12:03,940 --> 01:12:04,960
Thank you, and thank you all.

683
01:12:05,380 --> 01:12:07,540
And thank you, Councilwoman, for organizing this.

684
01:12:10,200 --> 01:12:15,460
I'm going to be honest, I have said very vocally that I would vote for a tax increase.

685
01:12:15,600 --> 01:12:19,260
I think our residents are going struggling for so much right now.

686
01:12:19,260 --> 01:12:31,420
And especially when we're talking about food justice and making sure that we're giving away funding for food justice, making sure we're giving funding away for housing, making sure we're giving funding away for grants, and then we're talking about

687
01:12:31,420 --> 01:12:34,600
now tax increasing their tax to pay for all those things.

688
01:12:34,780 --> 01:12:35,960
And yet they need those things.

689
01:12:36,280 --> 01:12:38,420
And so to me, it's just, it's hypocritical.

690
01:12:38,540 --> 01:12:41,120
We're talking, I think we need to start looking at our finances.

691
01:12:41,300 --> 01:12:47,400
I don't hear us talking a lot about cutting and holding the line ourselves, including in our council offices.

692
01:12:47,400 --> 01:12:52,320
And I can do a better job myself, and I know that many of us can, but I also know we give

693
01:12:52,320 --> 01:12:53,760
away a lot of grant money.

694
01:12:55,280 --> 01:13:01,680
And could you talk a little bit about in total between housing and opportunity, food justice,

695
01:13:02,600 --> 01:13:06,480
stop the violence, it used to be echo, I can't remember what they're called, it's called

696
01:13:06,940 --> 01:13:07,300
now.

697
01:13:07,800 --> 01:13:08,160
That funny.

698
01:13:08,220 --> 01:13:11,280
Do you know that a total amount of what we give away in, in, in, in?

699
01:13:11,280 --> 01:13:16,840
I know housing opportunity and stop the violence are both about 10 million a year.

700
01:13:16,840 --> 01:13:21,920
I don't know the other amounts to off the top of my head, this is 20, okay.

701
01:13:22,480 --> 01:13:24,940
I also had the least half of the stock of violence going on.

702
01:13:24,940 --> 01:13:25,900
I'll close that one.

703
01:13:26,080 --> 01:13:26,740
We just wanted to do that.

704
01:13:27,140 --> 01:13:27,400
Thank you.

705
01:13:28,580 --> 01:13:34,740
When we have, have we spent the housing up to any fund funding that you know,

706
01:13:35,560 --> 01:13:36,400
off the top of my head?

707
01:13:36,540 --> 01:13:37,540
I know that you are.

708
01:13:37,560 --> 01:13:40,180
I know that you are.

709
01:13:40,240 --> 01:13:43,980
I know that the URA did issue the bond and we have a bond repayment that we make annually too.

710
01:13:43,980 --> 01:13:48,320
So, I don't know what the URA is sitting on at the moment of the top of my head.

711
01:13:49,560 --> 01:13:58,700
And have you seen any increases in the salaries across and what we're spending in personnel and salaries in the increase in services?

712
01:13:58,900 --> 01:14:00,960
Have you looked at that at all?

713
01:14:01,620 --> 01:14:02,080
If the URA?

714
01:14:02,580 --> 01:14:03,760
Just in general for the city.

715
01:14:04,680 --> 01:14:06,420
I know we've hired a lot of people.

716
01:14:06,500 --> 01:14:08,880
Yes, so we've seen results from that as one wondering.

717
01:14:10,620 --> 01:14:12,060
I mean, is there audits done to that?

718
01:14:12,060 --> 01:14:18,240
No, I mean, that's something we are really difficult to measure, but we have hired, we

719
01:14:18,240 --> 01:14:21,400
have hired added 250 positions in the last two years.

720
01:14:22,240 --> 01:14:23,860
And do you know where they are?

721
01:14:23,860 --> 01:14:25,000
Off the top of my head, I don't.

722
01:14:25,200 --> 01:14:27,520
That's in the back of our annual comprehensive financial report.

723
01:14:27,740 --> 01:14:28,560
Could you get that to us?

724
01:14:29,040 --> 01:14:29,540
I'm curious.

725
01:14:30,380 --> 01:14:35,960
And we are talking and I do know we're talking about new council member or new mayor coming in

726
01:14:35,960 --> 01:14:40,600
in a new council member and my seat, which I'm excited for.

727
01:14:40,600 --> 01:14:46,600
So, but I will say that there's talks of having a pilot program.

728
01:14:46,800 --> 01:14:50,760
And I think before we talk about raising taxes or doing things to our residents, we need

729
01:14:50,760 --> 01:14:51,640
to have those conversations.

730
01:14:52,120 --> 01:14:59,940
Where we're cutting back, what we can to cut back, how we're going to freeze hiring in.

731
01:15:02,170 --> 01:15:28,550
I understand you have to have a new staff coming in. You have to have that. I understand that you're just your transition. I understand that there's a need for additional police and some public safety. I understand the emergency positions. But I think that we're hiring in a lot of places that we're not seeing exactly a lot of results. And my concern is what we're doing. And we have a comprehensive plan. How much have we spent of the comprehensive plan so far? Do you know, director?

732
01:15:30,370 --> 01:15:34,970
I've taught my head, I know it's over 4 million at this point, I think.

733
01:15:35,210 --> 01:15:38,590
So we spent over 4 million, and do you know how we spent it?

734
01:15:40,730 --> 01:15:44,370
There are two separate contracts, and one to put play in it.

735
01:15:44,370 --> 01:15:47,150
But we've given a lot of money away to people, because I've saw that.

736
01:15:47,650 --> 01:15:53,330
Yeah, for like the outreach, you would hope they would do very robust hours.

737
01:15:53,330 --> 01:15:56,510
We should come up with a comprehensive plan, but I haven't been a party to any of that.

738
01:15:56,510 --> 01:15:57,730
That's what I can't speak to it.

739
01:15:57,730 --> 01:16:06,530
I mean, it's things like that that I think that I could never have voted for, I didn't vote for the comprehensive land because we weren't in such a financial, you know, it's not an initial difficult situation.

740
01:16:07,090 --> 01:16:10,270
And when you said that we're not in a crisis, do you say we're not in a crisis?

741
01:16:10,710 --> 01:16:21,630
I think we are not at a point where it is a crisis. It's very, we're in a very precarious position, but we can avoid being in a crisis, which to me is entering into Act 47.

742
01:16:21,630 --> 01:16:27,850
that's a crisis, but we're in a very delicate financial position right now for my perspective,

743
01:16:28,250 --> 01:16:34,170
you know, a lot of municipalities are in this place right now, down towns across the country and

744
01:16:34,170 --> 01:16:40,330
candidly around the world are dealing with a post pandemic, real estate landscape that no one

745
01:16:40,330 --> 01:16:45,790
could have anticipated. And I have been very clear about that since I started in this position,

746
01:16:45,790 --> 01:16:49,790
like no one anticipated what COVID would have done to

747
01:16:50,550 --> 01:16:55,010
downtown the right where downtown is going to look different forever.

748
01:16:56,330 --> 01:17:00,730
That said, what will make her break any city is how we respond to this and what

749
01:17:00,730 --> 01:17:05,650
we do to make sure our real estate portfolio bounces back.

750
01:17:06,050 --> 01:17:09,750
I mean, kind of the I do think we need a countywide reassessment.

751
01:17:10,790 --> 01:17:14,770
I have said that for a year and a half or however long I've been here.

752
01:17:14,770 --> 01:17:21,230
But I do think we need to, when you look, we need revenue.

753
01:17:21,930 --> 01:17:25,110
I think that when you accurately look at the budget

754
01:17:25,110 --> 01:17:27,750
and what things were really going to end up costing over the course

755
01:17:27,750 --> 01:17:31,730
of the next five years, we to get to balance we need revenue.

756
01:17:32,890 --> 01:17:35,710
And that conversation's going to unfold over the course

757
01:17:35,710 --> 01:17:39,370
of the next six weeks or eight weeks, some weeks.

758
01:17:40,610 --> 01:17:41,710
But we need revenue.

759
01:17:41,710 --> 01:17:49,490
That is an honest assessment from me and I do think pilots or voluntary payments or whatever

760
01:17:49,490 --> 01:17:53,250
you want to call them are going to have to be a part of that conversation and I agree

761
01:17:53,250 --> 01:17:53,510
with you.

762
01:17:53,550 --> 01:17:57,350
I mean we need to figure out some cost containment measures and what is a nice to have versus

763
01:17:57,350 --> 01:18:03,390
what is a must have and I've always been an agreement with you that public safety and public

764
01:18:03,390 --> 01:18:07,870
work so those must have and what are things that are nice to have that we maybe don't need

765
01:18:07,870 --> 01:18:12,850
the next couple years. Next year's bond repayment is budgeted to be $75 million dollars and

766
01:18:12,850 --> 01:18:17,030
so there are some things that are probably nice to have so that we aren't going to spend

767
01:18:17,030 --> 01:18:22,570
money on next year and we need to make sure that the nice to have are not in the budget next year

768
01:18:22,570 --> 01:18:29,350
maybe and we're prioritizing the must-have and we are going to make sure that we should we're not

769
01:18:29,350 --> 01:18:37,010
a budgeting office but the prioritizing police officers we need to make sure that we are

770
01:18:37,010 --> 01:18:42,130
We have police on the streets because we are severely short staffed and put up a lot of

771
01:18:42,130 --> 01:18:42,770
to be honest.

772
01:18:43,470 --> 01:18:47,510
I think we need more police but I also think that we need to allow the police to do

773
01:18:47,510 --> 01:18:47,750
the job.

774
01:18:47,850 --> 01:18:52,550
If you have two police officers doing their job or two hundred not doing anything, we're wasting

775
01:18:52,550 --> 01:18:52,970
our money.

776
01:18:53,130 --> 01:18:56,250
So we need officers to be able to do their job to do law enforcement.

777
01:18:57,310 --> 01:19:04,230
And I made that clear before I did any kind of endorsements or anything in this past

778
01:19:04,230 --> 01:19:09,090
election, that to me that's a priority because we have people struggling every single day in

779
01:19:09,090 --> 01:19:13,510
the communities that need it the most. And they're the ones reaching out to me, not, you know,

780
01:19:13,730 --> 01:19:18,730
a lot of elitist of areas that moved into the city or people who have never experienced crime,

781
01:19:19,050 --> 01:19:23,810
but actually people in neighborhoods that are high crime areas, they're asking for some help. And so

782
01:19:23,810 --> 01:19:27,550
it's great when a lot of white kids come down and sit here and talk about how we need to do something

783
01:19:27,550 --> 01:19:30,270
about crime in the black community, you mean where the black community is saying the total opposite.

784
01:19:30,270 --> 01:19:37,490
So it's nice to hear from the people that actually are affected and I have I've heard a lot from them

785
01:19:38,030 --> 01:19:44,390
So with that said I will also say when we talk about trash and I heard you mentioned about trash and charging for you

786
01:19:44,390 --> 01:19:47,290
We don't charge for trash we don't offer a lot in the city of Pittsburgh

787
01:19:47,290 --> 01:19:49,310
That's one of the things we offer that people do appreciate

788
01:19:50,070 --> 01:19:56,370
And I think we also need to make sure that when we're hiring all these extra people that were picking up after the trash when they leave behind

789
01:19:56,370 --> 01:19:59,390
That's left behind because people are also frustrated with that

790
01:19:59,390 --> 01:19:59,970
Um...

791
01:20:00,110 --> 01:20:29,910
But for me, I would never vote for an increase in tax, especially if we're not doing cutting back on our own spending. Watching our own increases and watching the grand funding. And I think with the grand funding that we give out, it's a lot of money. And we're handing out money at the same time, we're saying people are so poor, they need help, but then we're going to increase through the tax. I mean, I mean, get our priorities straight. And let's stop talking hypocritical out of both sides of our mouths. We either want to help people or we don't.

792
01:20:29,910 --> 01:20:35,070
If we want to help people, we're looking at what are spending, we're cutting back what we need to, and we're doing what we have to do.

793
01:20:35,370 --> 01:20:36,910
That's it for me. Thank you.

794
01:20:38,270 --> 01:20:39,910
Thank you, council president.

795
01:20:40,990 --> 01:20:41,630
Thank you so much.

796
01:20:42,550 --> 01:20:43,170
No, okay.

797
01:20:43,590 --> 01:20:45,710
All right, then I'll move on to council on grass.

798
01:20:50,660 --> 01:20:56,920
I really appreciate the panel and the thoughtful kind of diverse ideas here.

799
01:20:56,920 --> 01:21:06,200
Um, I took a lot of notes that is a lot to, to digest, um, but what I heard from the

800
01:21:07,420 --> 01:21:13,980
presentation, it is about taxing him, who pays more in who pays less in taxes. And so what I heard,

801
01:21:15,060 --> 01:21:19,560
very distinctly, and I think very clearly presented in the charts and in the very nice bar charts

802
01:21:19,560 --> 01:21:26,980
graphs is that we're talking about texting people who are definitely not hungry and are

803
01:21:26,980 --> 01:21:31,300
definitely not housing insecure and are definitely not the people complaining about

804
01:21:31,300 --> 01:21:37,140
crime in the streets. Right, we're talking about the 1% is what it looked to me in your

805
01:21:37,140 --> 01:21:42,100
chart pays significantly. Would you like to review that for us? Yeah, definitely.

806
01:21:45,070 --> 01:21:45,530
I'm going

807
01:21:45,530 --> 01:21:51,370
I jumped to some of the notes that I scribbled down, and we're talking about not a

808
01:21:51,370 --> 01:21:57,210
millaging crease, which is what usually we're talking about, which I think is

809
01:21:57,210 --> 01:22:02,770
regressive in the city, that kind of regressively affects renters and home owners.

810
01:22:04,110 --> 01:22:12,390
But here on one of the charts, it says something like looking at the wrong person.

811
01:22:12,390 --> 01:22:13,970
It's something like,

812
01:22:20,820 --> 01:22:23,820
oh, who, it's one, the top 1%.

813
01:22:23,820 --> 01:22:27,440
So I just want to increase that halfway down the packet, right?

814
01:22:27,760 --> 01:22:29,560
Who pays for a tax increase?

815
01:22:30,980 --> 01:22:36,340
Yeah, so the top 1% will pay 51% of the taxes in that group

816
01:22:36,340 --> 01:22:39,740
of people, or I'll see this because the camera, once again,

817
01:22:39,980 --> 01:22:41,940
is not on me while I'm speaking, hello.

818
01:22:43,380 --> 01:22:46,640
So if you can show me on the screen,

819
01:22:47,920 --> 01:22:51,360
You would be really, there we go, you can see a little bit of things feet.

820
01:22:52,940 --> 01:23:00,040
This pie charts is meant to be the 300,000 people of the city Pittsburgh, right?

821
01:23:01,220 --> 01:23:05,100
And so this half is one, the one percent.

822
01:23:05,980 --> 01:23:06,320
That's right.

823
01:23:06,780 --> 01:23:16,180
And so this pie charts as it 3,000 people have income that they didn't earn from a job.

824
01:23:16,880 --> 01:23:23,960
of an average of $2 million, so 3,000 people in the city of Pittsburgh, some of them have

825
01:23:23,960 --> 01:23:31,800
a tremendously high annual income from money that they didn't earn through a job, because

826
01:23:31,800 --> 01:23:33,360
that's 2,000, this is the average.

827
01:23:33,960 --> 01:23:34,380
Am I reading that?

828
01:23:34,640 --> 01:23:35,080
Yeah, that's right.

829
01:23:35,260 --> 01:23:42,680
Okay, so again, this is how much revenue the city would earn, but only 3,000 people are

830
01:23:42,680 --> 01:23:51,360
that. And those 3,000 people may have a job that has a salary, but on top of that. That's right.

831
01:23:51,500 --> 01:23:58,500
In addition to whatever job they may have, they're asset just magically give them $2 million

832
01:23:58,500 --> 01:24:07,720
a year on average. Okay, so I just wanted to re-emphasize that point. So there's 297,000 other people

833
01:24:07,720 --> 01:24:18,880
who are over here, and then of those 297,000 other people, about 25%, so I'm going to do

834
01:24:18,880 --> 01:24:19,360
that off for you.

835
01:24:20,360 --> 01:24:27,920
That's like 80,000 people or so, less than any, like 75,000 people, may also may have a job,

836
01:24:28,580 --> 01:24:32,200
and we don't know how much the job pays them, may pay them a dollar a year, may pay them

837
01:24:32,200 --> 01:24:33,140
a million dollars a year.

838
01:24:33,140 --> 01:24:41,320
But on top of that job, about 75,000 people have unarmed revenue,

839
01:24:41,840 --> 01:24:43,960
does the magically appearing money in their lives

840
01:24:43,960 --> 01:24:46,160
of $500,000 a year on average?

841
01:24:46,880 --> 01:24:49,560
Yeah, that's their total income, so it would include.

842
01:24:49,960 --> 01:24:53,520
Okay, that's total income, so not magically appearing in addition to a job.

843
01:24:53,900 --> 01:24:55,340
Some of it would be from a job.

844
01:24:55,340 --> 01:24:57,040
Okay, yeah. Okay, good.

845
01:24:57,380 --> 01:24:59,960
And so it says that, so that's the next 4%.

846
01:25:00,000 --> 01:25:21,700
So, this, like, this big blue half, yeah, where am I? Good. And then this dark blue quarter is the top 5% of people. So, this is a total of 6,000 people. I doing that math right. No, can't be. Somebody help me out.

847
01:25:23,890 --> 01:25:31,870
Right. 4% of the people would be 12,000 people in the city Pittsburgh. Right? And 1% of the people's 3,000 people in the city.

848
01:25:31,870 --> 01:25:36,610
people the city puts brick. So this whole three quarters of this part chart is being paid by only

849
01:25:36,610 --> 01:25:42,190
7,000 people. They just did the math rate. 15,000. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I come

850
01:25:42,190 --> 01:25:51,040
not to your right. All right. So it's not too many. It's really just a few.

851
01:25:53,070 --> 01:25:54,710
And they're very, very,

852
01:25:54,710 --> 01:26:02,630
very high incomes. And they're not the people who are receiving a

853
01:26:05,130 --> 01:26:05,790
food assistance.

854
01:26:08,400 --> 01:26:08,540
And they're

855
01:26:08,540 --> 01:26:17,200
people who would qualify for rental assistance. And so it's a very, you know, we are trying

856
01:26:17,200 --> 01:26:24,860
your proposal where we to attempt this fair, would we going it again?

857
01:26:25,260 --> 01:26:35,360
Fair share tax. Fair share tax would definitely decrease the tax burden on the people

858
01:26:35,960 --> 01:26:40,720
if you do need our assistance, and that who are our grant programs are aimed at.

859
01:26:41,180 --> 01:26:47,820
So I just wanted to make sure I understood what the proposal that we just were presented

860
01:26:47,820 --> 01:26:58,700
was. So we don't know if it will work. That's debatable. And then we need to figure out what

861
01:26:58,700 --> 01:27:04,400
we just heard is how would we do it? And really like how many people in the organizational

862
01:27:04,400 --> 01:27:06,180
chart would it take?

863
01:27:06,820 --> 01:27:10,160
God knows what would need another million dollar technology package that we're

864
01:27:10,160 --> 01:27:11,980
constantly needing to be faced with, right?

865
01:27:12,000 --> 01:27:12,140
Right.

866
01:27:12,700 --> 01:27:13,820
Those are expensive.

867
01:27:15,340 --> 01:27:15,640
They don't.

868
01:27:15,880 --> 01:27:18,240
They've taken years to debug.

869
01:27:18,780 --> 01:27:21,100
JDEs, taking 20, it's still not working right?

870
01:27:22,320 --> 01:27:23,420
So there's that.

871
01:27:23,760 --> 01:27:30,520
That was forced on us by the Act 47 committee, but you know, we are still having to undo

872
01:27:31,020 --> 01:27:32,700
the problems that that created.

873
01:27:35,120 --> 01:27:42,400
So, I want to ask a couple of questions, but I think so I think I move on to our next speaker, Mr. Fetter.

874
01:27:43,740 --> 01:28:01,250
Possibly, in your presentation, you say that there's an exception to the exception so that we clearly can tax what the state already taxes.

875
01:28:01,250 --> 01:28:04,150
That's from this red shirt.

876
01:28:06,580 --> 01:28:10,000
But you also said that the state kind of treats these all separately.

877
01:28:11,260 --> 01:28:18,460
And so when this box where there's a bunch lumped together, are those treated separately?

878
01:28:19,320 --> 01:28:21,100
So here's why I ask, right?

879
01:28:21,340 --> 01:28:25,980
So it says net income from rents, royalties, patents, and copyrights.

880
01:28:29,190 --> 01:28:32,950
Where we need to consider a fair share tax?

881
01:28:32,950 --> 01:28:35,070
Is it

882
01:28:37,280 --> 01:28:38,760
can we Terry pick?

883
01:28:39,940 --> 01:28:42,400
The short answer to that question council member is yes.

884
01:28:42,720 --> 01:28:42,820
Okay.

885
01:28:43,160 --> 01:28:48,140
It's easy to read answers that if you pick that entire category,

886
01:28:48,360 --> 01:28:49,820
or you exclude that entire category,

887
01:28:50,140 --> 01:28:52,900
because the state already treats that as one lump sum category.

888
01:28:54,480 --> 01:28:57,520
But as long as there's a material difference

889
01:28:57,520 --> 01:29:01,740
between income from rent and income from patents,

890
01:29:02,540 --> 01:29:03,780
which there surely is.

891
01:29:03,780 --> 01:29:06,560
It's itemized on some other text form somewhere.

892
01:29:06,780 --> 01:29:09,560
The uniformity clause would certainly allow you to

893
01:29:09,560 --> 01:29:11,200
cherry-peck to use your words.

894
01:29:11,320 --> 01:29:15,260
They would have to be a rational basis for why you would choose in one or the other,

895
01:29:15,360 --> 01:29:18,700
but I don't think you would have any difficulty coming up with those rational basis.

896
01:29:19,020 --> 01:29:22,320
And so the same is true for each of the red boxes as a lump.

897
01:29:23,720 --> 01:29:30,940
So the city of Pittsburgh could consider taxing interest and dividends or interest or dividends.

898
01:29:30,940 --> 01:29:38,760
that interests and gains from disposing dispositions of property or one of the other, et cetera.

899
01:29:39,220 --> 01:29:46,380
So we could do all of these or we could attempt to do some of these. Correct. Thank you.

900
01:29:46,860 --> 01:29:53,100
I think that's also interesting. So there might follow up question would be, which we don't probably know right now.

901
01:29:54,280 --> 01:29:58,680
In other cities in Pennsylvania, which ones are easier to collect?

902
01:30:00,000 --> 01:30:28,760
We take the least amount of people and the least complicated software, so if we're attempting to balance the capacity that we need in personal and in technical expertise and in literally the mechanics of the collections, right? Sometimes we have to do hard mail and it's expensive, sometimes we don't. That should be part of our consideration.

903
01:30:30,000 --> 01:30:34,620
I don't know the answer, but I will say that is the exact question that I wanted someone to ask

904
01:30:34,620 --> 01:30:40,840
because like, one of the keys to doing this successfully is to like, not make it harder than it needs to be.

905
01:30:41,060 --> 01:30:43,540
Like if somebody else is already doing it, let's just do it how they do it.

906
01:30:43,540 --> 01:30:44,160
Let's do it.

907
01:30:44,760 --> 01:30:47,820
If it's a step forward for us, let's take that first step forward.

908
01:30:48,280 --> 01:30:49,300
Don't make it too hard.

909
01:30:50,100 --> 01:30:52,620
Does anyone know the answer to our heavy hands?

910
01:30:52,640 --> 01:30:54,240
Help for hints on how to figure that out?

911
01:30:54,540 --> 01:30:56,500
I can answer your question in part.

912
01:30:56,500 --> 01:31:04,020
The city of Philadelphia currently taxes interest dividends and capital gains, and I can tell you that administratively

913
01:31:04,760 --> 01:31:16,680
They get good cooperation from the Commonwealth Department of Revenue and given that the Commonwealth Department of Revenue already has information from everybody's PA 40 about each of those seven categories

914
01:31:16,680 --> 01:31:22,700
Separate like the Commonwealth can share with you if you were to break up one of those categories into subcategories

915
01:31:22,700 --> 01:31:29,980
I would imagine that would get a little more difficult, but as long as you're sticking to any one or two or three of those red boxes

916
01:31:29,980 --> 01:31:33,020
The Commonwealth shares that data with the city of Philadelphia

917
01:31:33,840 --> 01:31:38,040
I can't speak for the Commonwealth, but I don't see why they wouldn't share that information

918
01:31:38,040 --> 01:31:41,720
It doesn't mean there isn't ramp up costs and administrative costs

919
01:31:41,720 --> 01:31:44,340
I'm not disagreeing with the fire director at all

920
01:31:44,340 --> 01:31:50,080
But the Commonwealth can share a lot of that information with you to make administration significantly easier

921
01:31:50,080 --> 01:31:51,500
which is the way we do it in Philadelphia.

922
01:31:51,680 --> 01:31:53,620
I say, I used to work for the city of Philadelphia.

923
01:31:55,020 --> 01:31:59,460
So if you're one of those people in the big blue part

924
01:31:59,460 --> 01:32:02,260
of the pie chart with the $2 million income

925
01:32:02,260 --> 01:32:03,500
and you live in the state of Pennsylvania,

926
01:32:03,500 --> 01:32:04,760
you live in the state of Pittsburgh,

927
01:32:07,130 --> 01:32:07,490
you already

928
01:32:07,490 --> 01:32:11,390
have itemized on your state's Pennsylvania tax return

929
01:32:11,390 --> 01:32:14,570
every year, you've already got a number here

930
01:32:14,570 --> 01:32:16,430
and the state's already sharing that with Philadelphia.

931
01:32:18,530 --> 01:32:20,470
Yes, you already have that number there.

932
01:32:20,470 --> 01:32:24,310
the state is already sharing that with Philadelphia for the categories that Philadelphia taxes.

933
01:32:24,730 --> 01:32:28,970
Right, and so hypothetically for the categories that Pittsburgh might consider taxing,

934
01:32:28,970 --> 01:32:31,930
it might also be easy information to get.

935
01:32:32,510 --> 01:32:33,170
Good to know.

936
01:32:33,750 --> 01:32:35,270
I think that wraps it up. Thank you, Memphier.

937
01:32:37,210 --> 01:32:38,490
Great, thank you.

938
01:32:40,430 --> 01:32:45,810
I know, well, before I get to my comments, I'm happy to do a round two.

939
01:32:48,970 --> 01:32:52,710
Councilman Straussberger, did you have a round two?

940
01:32:57,110 --> 01:33:00,110
Now that we're talking based off of that last conversation,

941
01:33:02,350 --> 01:33:04,270
I'm curious, since you all know

942
01:33:04,270 --> 01:33:05,530
how to do we know

943
01:33:09,180 --> 01:33:19,610
and how many people, like what percentage of people continue to pay the tax?

944
01:33:23,610 --> 01:33:36,330
I can only speak to that the cities had on the books for decades and so I can't I can't speak to the revenue impact, although it's very easily accessible from the city's financial reports.

945
01:33:37,310 --> 01:33:37,330
Okay.

946
01:33:40,030 --> 01:33:45,670
Did the states say, well, if it's decreased over time, that's not the interesting to me.

947
01:33:45,970 --> 01:33:47,070
So we'll look after them.

948
01:33:47,410 --> 01:33:48,090
Thank you.

949
01:33:50,740 --> 01:33:57,240
I noticed when I was looking at the website yesterday in Philadelphia that they also used this tax to tax short-term rentals.

950
01:33:57,980 --> 01:34:01,760
Is that anything that you're familiar with or can speak to?

951
01:34:02,760 --> 01:34:05,480
I think that's probably a different text.

952
01:34:05,520 --> 01:34:06,720
Okay, all right, sorry.

953
01:34:06,980 --> 01:34:09,300
I think that's probably from our hotel tax.

954
01:34:26,280 --> 01:34:26,900
I do.

955
01:34:27,700 --> 01:34:28,440
I do.

956
01:34:30,210 --> 01:34:30,810
Yeah, I do.

957
01:34:30,990 --> 01:34:34,530
I just want to know a couple things.

958
01:34:35,470 --> 01:34:37,310
Let me just check something real quick, I'm sorry.

959
01:34:38,830 --> 01:34:43,890
I just want to know when you talk about this higher percentage paying the tax that they would be.

960
01:34:43,890 --> 01:34:49,650
What did you base that off of? I mean, what is there? What's the income? The household income? How many people living in the household?

961
01:34:49,950 --> 01:34:52,430
What's the debt? Do you know? I mean, what do you base that off of?

962
01:34:52,490 --> 01:34:56,210
Do you think you need that? It's tax, you know, based on tax units. Okay.

963
01:34:56,450 --> 01:34:59,970
In Pittsburgh. And so I'm just wondering, because, you know, my son and his...

964
01:35:00,000 --> 01:35:10,460
This is a girl for they look great on paper financially, but they're student debt and the things that they have, they couldn't afford any more increases either.

965
01:35:10,920 --> 01:35:18,420
So I know a lot of people that make a decent pay and decent salary and have a home and cars and all those things on paper looks great.

966
01:35:18,540 --> 01:35:25,300
But in reality, they're saddled with student debt and just childhood, every day childhood care.

967
01:35:25,300 --> 01:35:29,580
Those types of things are really a drain on people's budget, so I don't like to hear

968
01:35:29,580 --> 01:35:33,580
us talking about, you know, as if we know what some of these struggles are because we

969
01:35:34,020 --> 01:35:36,900
don't, you know, and you don't know, you know what you see on paper, you don't know what's

970
01:35:36,900 --> 01:35:40,240
going on in their house, you know, and who they're taking care of, who they're helping, and

971
01:35:40,240 --> 01:35:43,440
so those kinds of things make me worry about people in general, and that's not saying that

972
01:35:43,440 --> 01:35:47,740
these people, other people that aren't wealthy aren't going to pay tax, they're still going

973
01:35:47,740 --> 01:35:51,300
to pay a tax, and so they're still struggling, and we have people that are not paying,

974
01:35:51,300 --> 01:35:52,380
what they need to pay.

975
01:35:53,760 --> 01:35:58,360
And we know that there's a lot that we had back when we had fewer in tax service, they recommended

976
01:35:58,360 --> 01:36:02,760
that we collect taxes from people who weren't paying because it was in the millions that

977
01:36:02,760 --> 01:36:03,480
we could have collected.

978
01:36:03,980 --> 01:36:04,880
And we don't.

979
01:36:05,660 --> 01:36:09,380
So, you know, I think there's a lot to be said here and there's a lot of discussion that

980
01:36:09,380 --> 01:36:13,780
needs to happen internally before we start talking too much externally and we start saying

981
01:36:13,780 --> 01:36:18,980
things that maybe people don't want necessarily want to have a discussion about, but I'm

982
01:36:18,980 --> 01:36:19,660
ready to have it.

983
01:36:20,000 --> 01:36:20,600
Thank you.

984
01:36:21,940 --> 01:36:23,420
Thank you, Councillor.

985
01:36:24,920 --> 01:36:36,800
Thank you. I think I have a question I forgot to ask is the notion that a non-profit corporation, like

986
01:36:36,800 --> 01:36:38,720
UPMC, Kernany University,

987
01:36:42,810 --> 01:36:48,030
would not agree to a payment in lieu of taxes

988
01:36:51,580 --> 01:36:53,660
because they don't pay taxes.

989
01:36:53,660 --> 01:36:57,200
So, the pilot is a payment and lieu of those taxes

990
01:37:00,300 --> 01:37:07,060
because they want to donate to a non-profit to lower their taxes.

991
01:37:08,500 --> 01:37:12,000
Which I think was posited here.

992
01:37:12,600 --> 01:37:14,440
But it seems to be mutually exclusive.

993
01:37:17,320 --> 01:37:23,780
So, if you donate to a non-profit, if you're corporation and you donate to a non-profit to lower your taxes,

994
01:37:23,780 --> 01:37:31,420
it's because you pay taxes. You pay taxes. You're not a non-profit exempt from taxes.

995
01:37:33,730 --> 01:37:33,950
And so

996
01:37:33,950 --> 01:37:40,250
if you were going to pay a payment in lieu, it's because so if you were paying taxes, and

997
01:37:40,250 --> 01:37:48,630
can benefit from a non-profit contribution, then you should be paying city-pizper taxes. I wouldn't

998
01:37:48,630 --> 01:38:02,290
I, I guess I don't know this, I wouldn't imagine that there's a tax benefit, at least under a federal law, to paying to one P.G.H. if you're like a nonprofit again.

999
01:38:02,510 --> 01:38:09,570
But like big brother big sisters wouldn't donate to the greater Pittsburgh community food bank.

1000
01:38:10,250 --> 01:38:15,550
I mean, they, maybe they wouldn't, there's no tax benefit to them.

1001
01:38:15,550 --> 01:38:22,110
Right. So, so we can't be like, well, I'm not giving you City of Pittsburgh a payment

1002
01:38:22,110 --> 01:38:27,210
and live because I have some other tax benefit because it makes sense. Yeah. I will say

1003
01:38:27,210 --> 01:38:34,630
that I do think that there is a benefit for City residents to demonstrate where a voluntary

1004
01:38:34,630 --> 01:38:43,250
payment is going because I think from the Pittsburgh Public Service Fund in 2004, those payment,

1005
01:38:43,250 --> 01:38:49,290
like there was no transparency in that process and the money from what we can tell when

1006
01:38:49,290 --> 01:38:54,990
into the general fund, literally what you see here is what we have access to and I can

1007
01:38:54,990 --> 01:39:01,450
get you all copies of what we have in terms of the agreement. It's a six-page letter between

1008
01:39:01,450 --> 01:39:07,570
the city and the diocese which also doesn't make any sense, but there was no transparency

1009
01:39:08,150 --> 01:39:09,830
from the city side whatsoever.

1010
01:39:10,410 --> 01:39:14,430
So from my perspective, I believe that we all would benefit

1011
01:39:14,430 --> 01:39:17,630
with some degree of, this is what the money is going

1012
01:39:17,630 --> 01:39:18,090
toward.

1013
01:39:20,450 --> 01:39:24,510
So I think it should go toward the operation of city government,

1014
01:39:24,610 --> 01:39:25,410
whatever that looks like.

1015
01:39:25,410 --> 01:39:28,310
And if it's towards the free fund, if it's towards something

1016
01:39:28,870 --> 01:39:30,750
that's towards the beautification of downtown,

1017
01:39:31,330 --> 01:39:32,670
or what have you.

1018
01:39:33,490 --> 01:39:41,850
But I, the argument that, because of the tax exempt from my perspective, I, at least as it relates to federal tax law.

1019
01:39:42,050 --> 01:39:47,250
If there's some tax benefit you get from donating to an nonprofit, then you should be paying your city for different taxes.

1020
01:39:47,930 --> 01:39:52,730
I'm not a tax professional, but in my simple mind, it kind of makes sense to me.

1021
01:39:53,030 --> 01:39:59,310
If you pay taxes somewhere, then you need an exemption for donating to an unprofit, then you should also be paying your city for different taxes also.

1022
01:40:00,000 --> 01:40:03,280
All right. Okay. I think that is awesome. I thought it was. Thank you, men.

1023
01:40:04,680 --> 01:40:24,040
Can I just ask one question more? So, you know, so, you know, so, Dean Freeson, who's in the attorney behind, who works in our office, or for, you know, consulting with our office. Also said that he thinks that, um, P.A. law requires a flat tax on income, not tiered, um, and that a change of state law may be required for the fair share plan. Do you know if that's accurate?

1024
01:40:25,640 --> 01:40:30,680
I'm fairly confident what the lawyer meant is that you can't have different tax amounts

1025
01:40:30,680 --> 01:40:31,940
for different amounts of income.

1026
01:40:32,060 --> 01:40:33,440
You can't have a graduated tax.

1027
01:40:33,600 --> 01:40:38,400
You can't say someone who earns 100,000 pays more than someone who earns 50,000.

1028
01:40:38,640 --> 01:40:41,200
But nothing in the fair share tax deals with it.

1029
01:40:41,200 --> 01:40:42,620
It's not a tiered tax.

1030
01:40:42,980 --> 01:40:48,480
It's by lump sum categories and I don't think there's any constitution, a confident there's

1031
01:40:48,480 --> 01:40:52,860
no constitutional prohibition if you're categorizing it the way is being proposed in the

1032
01:40:52,860 --> 01:40:57,480
share tax, what you can't do is have higher rates for higher incomes.

1033
01:40:59,000 --> 01:41:00,320
I just want to make sure.

1034
01:41:00,720 --> 01:41:02,800
Thank you.

1035
01:41:02,940 --> 01:41:03,860
Yeah, thank you.

1036
01:41:04,920 --> 01:41:05,120
Thank you.

1037
01:41:05,120 --> 01:41:05,360
Yeah, please.

1038
01:41:05,760 --> 01:41:06,640
Yeah, go ahead, please.

1039
01:41:06,980 --> 01:41:07,300
Thank you.

1040
01:41:07,540 --> 01:41:07,720
Thank you.

1041
01:41:08,560 --> 01:41:22,560
I just wanted to see that this idea that I introduced about a separate fund rather than directly to the city and any kind of payment and lieu program.

1042
01:41:22,560 --> 01:41:30,800
was introduced to me by a budget director, Jake Pollock, and so he's someone I'd like to talk

1043
01:41:30,800 --> 01:41:37,580
to about this or anyone has thought and to ask him what that information exactly was and

1044
01:41:38,340 --> 01:41:44,980
a drill done for other. I'd like to understand it as well. I'm certainly not a proponent of that scheme.

1045
01:41:45,460 --> 01:41:51,800
I'd rather come directly to the city, but that was my understanding from a meeting we had about a year ago

1046
01:41:51,800 --> 01:41:58,840
you're going to have to go with the mayor's office that that was likely going to be the

1047
01:41:58,840 --> 01:42:05,880
condition that had to be met were any agreement to be reached during this administration.

1048
01:42:07,340 --> 01:42:10,380
So he would be the one to ask and that certainly can follow up with him.

1049
01:42:14,480 --> 01:42:15,740
Thank you.

1050
01:42:16,900 --> 01:42:24,780
So just, you know, obviously, just a few questions, just to kind of clarify.

1051
01:42:25,240 --> 01:42:29,840
So when we were talking about the village, it could also,

1052
01:42:30,560 --> 01:42:35,140
Maybe I'll take a step back and sort of say, I agree with Councilman Smith, right?

1053
01:42:35,360 --> 01:42:37,600
That we should not wait.

1054
01:42:39,140 --> 01:42:40,980
Nobody wants to raise taxes.

1055
01:42:41,480 --> 01:42:43,200
Certainly, no elected official wants to raise taxes.

1056
01:42:43,460 --> 01:42:46,280
But we don't want to raise taxes on our residents.

1057
01:42:48,580 --> 01:42:55,680
But the issue that I see it today, right, where we are right now, like going into next year,

1058
01:42:56,540 --> 01:43:02,180
is that I firmly believe that in the city of Pittsburgh.

1059
01:43:03,200 --> 01:43:11,720
So, well, let me just say, so, director Goli, you had said, for taking this sort of mean person,

1060
01:43:11,720 --> 01:43:18,260
of $72,000 a year, like I earned $72,000 a year and my property is valued at $100,000.

1061
01:43:18,720 --> 01:43:25,780
So that's sort of like the person that we're just sort of like generic Pittsburgher that we're taking.

1062
01:43:25,780 --> 01:43:32,980
The total city tax is 1,535,

1063
01:43:35,560 --> 01:43:36,700
that's for the city.

1064
01:43:37,160 --> 01:43:38,940
Just for the city.

1065
01:43:42,500 --> 01:43:45,600
And what is the, yeah, what is the month, I'm just curious,

1066
01:43:45,800 --> 01:43:51,200
like for that, what is the monthly contribution that that person makes?

1067
01:43:51,200 --> 01:43:53,180
the monthly contribution.

1068
01:43:55,910 --> 01:44:11,010
Yeah. It would be, well, we'd be $127 a month. So I just want to make that, I mean, I understand we talk about it, but I want to make that clear. So if you're, if this sort of average person,

1069
01:44:11,010 --> 01:44:20,280
$72,000 a year. Their property is valued at $100,000. They are paying $127 a month.

1070
01:44:21,070 --> 01:44:22,650
$127 a month.

1071
01:44:24,880 --> 01:44:31,100
For parks, for pools, for fields, and sports, I mean, is this the right number?

1072
01:44:32,040 --> 01:44:41,860
So let's say that's just the moment. So, right. So for city, okay, so if you're $100,000 worth of assessment, your tax bill is

1073
01:44:42,580 --> 01:44:49,260
$806 a year. Okay. Okay. Your income, if you make, that's just for the city. That's not

1074
01:44:49,260 --> 01:44:55,260
including library parks. Right. And that's not including school district. Right. I'm looking at

1075
01:44:55,260 --> 01:44:59,960
just business. So what do I pay? If I'm 70, if I make 72,000 a year and my-

1076
01:45:00,000 --> 01:45:07,920
My property is valued at $100,000. What do I do in total? Income would be another $729.35.

1077
01:45:08,380 --> 01:45:10,660
So what's the total that I pay a year?

1078
01:45:19,060 --> 01:45:19,620
1535.

1079
01:45:21,200 --> 01:45:24,780
So 1535 is what I pay per year.

1080
01:45:25,480 --> 01:45:28,920
And this is one thing I really need the residents to understand.

1081
01:45:28,920 --> 01:45:35,020
right is at the city we're not talking and we I get it you're also paying county you're also paying

1082
01:45:35,020 --> 01:45:42,980
school but you know for us at the city we are really talking about the services so so divide that by 12

1083
01:45:43,790 --> 01:45:56,700
and that is $127.9 a month so for $127 or you know $128 a month that is your garbage pick up your

1084
01:45:56,700 --> 01:46:08,400
you know, paved your your pools, your wreck centers, your senior centers, you're like, you know, I mean, the police, the fire, the EMS PLA, all of it, right?

1085
01:46:08,740 --> 01:46:13,940
Right, and I guess if you relate to what Keate showed earlier was $300 and some dollars.

1086
01:46:13,940 --> 01:46:15,400
Yeah, it's $400, so much.

1087
01:46:15,740 --> 01:46:17,960
Yeah, you pay it on $2,000, but you get $4,400.

1088
01:46:18,020 --> 01:46:23,860
Right, so like, $1,000, but like, you get almost $400 a month in service.

1089
01:46:23,860 --> 01:46:33,400
So I just want to put it into context for what, and when we talk about, so there's that,

1090
01:46:33,500 --> 01:46:38,880
I just want to make that clear, and I think that one thing that I want is it's about living

1091
01:46:38,880 --> 01:46:40,640
in Pittsburgh, right?

1092
01:46:40,860 --> 01:46:44,460
Like the thing, I was speaking for myself, right?

1093
01:46:44,460 --> 01:46:47,040
But I live in Greenfield, right?

1094
01:46:47,040 --> 01:46:54,520
But the thing that makes Pittsburgh so amazing to live in is that we have, I mean, my

1095
01:46:54,520 --> 01:47:00,820
kid, my youngest goes to after school, he gets free after school care, right, free at the

1096
01:47:00,820 --> 01:47:01,440
rest center.

1097
01:47:02,800 --> 01:47:07,780
You know, you know, there's summer camps at the rest centers that are free, we have pools that

1098
01:47:07,780 --> 01:47:15,470
are free, the parks, the fields, the oval, the ice drink, like if it's not free, it's

1099
01:47:15,470 --> 01:47:22,490
It's very affordable to use all these things and then fire EMS and all these other things you hope you don't need, but they're there.

1100
01:47:23,450 --> 01:47:36,090
So I just, you know, and we are at this major crunch in budget and I don't think whether it's for a residence now, who live here now or for attracting new residents,

1101
01:47:36,090 --> 01:47:43,730
cutting those things is not where it's at for me right cutting those things and there are

1102
01:47:43,730 --> 01:47:49,570
things that we struggle with right we struggle with snow we struggle with litter we struggle

1103
01:47:49,570 --> 01:47:54,210
with with tearing down vacant and abandoned properties right we those are things that we struggle

1104
01:47:54,210 --> 01:48:00,630
with right and and in some of our most neglected neighborhoods as well and we need to do better

1105
01:48:00,630 --> 01:48:06,350
So I think that's the conversation that we should be having because when we talk about like belt tightening

1106
01:48:06,350 --> 01:48:14,670
That's talking about reducing services and I think the way that anyway, so so you know for for that average Pittsburgh or that

1107
01:48:14,670 --> 01:48:17,030
$127 a month

1108
01:48:17,730 --> 01:48:20,670
That you're paying in city taxes, right that's

1109
01:48:24,360 --> 01:48:28,840
You're you're getting quite a bit, right the taxpayer is getting quite a bit now

1110
01:48:29,240 --> 01:48:34,040
When we get to a village, you know, we talk about village, because that's the tool that we have,

1111
01:48:34,180 --> 01:48:34,920
a council, right?

1112
01:48:35,060 --> 01:48:36,020
It's up the village.

1113
01:48:36,720 --> 01:48:37,720
That's what we can do.

1114
01:48:37,800 --> 01:48:38,960
That's what we can do in the budget.

1115
01:48:39,960 --> 01:48:45,740
However, we have on the other hand, these giant nonprofits, right?

1116
01:48:46,840 --> 01:48:52,400
That are making, I mean, I don't, like, what would the, what, if you PMC were not a non-profit?

1117
01:48:52,460 --> 01:48:56,560
Do we have an idea of how much they would be paying in taxes a year?

1118
01:48:59,160 --> 01:49:11,060
It's like 30 million or, yeah, it's a report, yeah, it's in the report, but what I will say is the federal government is cutting Medicare and Medicaid, which is 70% of their clients, and that is a real thing.

1119
01:49:11,320 --> 01:49:14,380
Well, that made me today, but I'm just talking, you know, right.

1120
01:49:14,780 --> 01:49:16,880
It's not, right or so.

1121
01:49:19,740 --> 01:49:24,600
And we don't have the ability as a city to determine tax service.

1122
01:49:24,600 --> 01:49:32,180
I understand, but I'm just saying if they were, right, what is the report say that they would be paying?

1123
01:49:32,580 --> 01:49:37,520
So you can see if they were not tax exempt, they would be paying 58.3 million.

1124
01:49:37,640 --> 01:49:42,840
Okay, so they'd be paying 58.3 million dollars a year to the City of Pittsburgh.

1125
01:49:43,600 --> 01:49:44,620
No, that's all.

1126
01:49:45,820 --> 01:49:50,600
Sorry, that's the amount of property that would be exempt from taxes.

1127
01:49:51,280 --> 01:49:52,240
In all three governments.

1128
01:49:52,660 --> 01:49:56,240
Hey y'all three, I'm sorry, so county, all governments and school districts.

1129
01:49:56,340 --> 01:49:59,640
Okay, so do we know like what they would be paying in taxes if they were paying?

1130
01:50:00,430 --> 01:50:02,270
Or if they, if they, you know, we're not.

1131
01:50:02,270 --> 01:50:09,250
Collectively, the top five, we can trade you $127.5 million, so that's the big top five non-profits.

1132
01:50:10,070 --> 01:50:13,590
$127.5 million a year?

1133
01:50:13,970 --> 01:50:14,090
Yes.

1134
01:50:14,350 --> 01:50:14,750
A year.

1135
01:50:16,370 --> 01:50:19,570
$127.5 million a year.

1136
01:50:20,750 --> 01:50:25,870
The top five non-profits attributed to real estate, correct?

1137
01:50:26,770 --> 01:50:26,970
Yes.

1138
01:50:26,970 --> 01:50:32,850
So they do pay, so they do pay some payroll expense and parking.

1139
01:50:33,210 --> 01:50:35,470
But I payles and compare them to the real estate.

1140
01:50:35,970 --> 01:50:37,510
And that's the all three, sorry.

1141
01:50:38,050 --> 01:50:39,550
The city of Pittsburgh is 34 million.

1142
01:50:39,890 --> 01:50:41,530
34 million, okay, that's sort of what, okay.

1143
01:50:41,950 --> 01:50:45,930
But nonetheless, so when we're balancing

1144
01:50:45,930 --> 01:50:48,090
Millage increase, that's, you know,

1145
01:50:48,230 --> 01:50:50,430
Millage increase versus this pilots, right?

1146
01:50:50,510 --> 01:50:51,810
That's what we're talking about.

1147
01:50:51,990 --> 01:50:53,410
It's property taxes, right?

1148
01:50:53,970 --> 01:51:01,110
So, you know, I mean, I sort of looked up, so UPM feels like a 100,000 employees HN has about

1149
01:51:01,110 --> 01:51:04,090
22,000 CMU, 11,000 pit 15,000.

1150
01:51:04,230 --> 01:51:09,750
So, I mean, if right out of the gate, if UPMC would just commit to 20 million a year for

1151
01:51:09,750 --> 01:51:15,350
10 years, an A HN would commit to 10 million year for, you know, and maybe PIT and CMU,

1152
01:51:15,370 --> 01:51:19,470
5 million each, just that, right, just throw those numbers out there.

1153
01:51:20,070 --> 01:51:24,550
that would be $40 million dollars that we would have as a city

1154
01:51:24,550 --> 01:51:26,390
Pittsburgh and we wouldn't even need to be talking about these

1155
01:51:26,390 --> 01:51:34,700
milligen creases, right? But there's just, I mean, I, you know, I would

1156
01:51:34,700 --> 01:51:38,560
love to see that happen tomorrow. I'd love to, I'd love for, for the mayor

1157
01:51:38,560 --> 01:51:42,560
elect to get a phone call tomorrow saying, yeah, we're doing it. You don't need to

1158
01:51:42,560 --> 01:51:46,880
have this convict. You don't need to worry about this. We're gonna do it today. So

1159
01:51:46,880 --> 01:51:50,120
that when we do our budget come up here in December,

1160
01:51:51,320 --> 01:51:54,580
that we know that I know that we can just do a $10 million

1161
01:51:54,580 --> 01:51:59,740
a year fund for fleet, that I know that I can give pay

1162
01:51:59,740 --> 01:52:04,620
increases to all the DPW supervisors, right,

1163
01:52:04,780 --> 01:52:08,260
who like have, you know, whatever, that we know that we

1164
01:52:08,260 --> 01:52:10,940
can, you know, whatever this worker who's like literally

1165
01:52:10,940 --> 01:52:14,140
looking around and talking about quitting like these workers who

1166
01:52:14,140 --> 01:52:17,540
you just desperately need to do the work that we do.

1167
01:52:18,100 --> 01:52:23,340
That PLI could get the whatever 10 million they need to actually make some serious progress

1168
01:52:23,340 --> 01:52:26,780
on tearing down some of these awful properties, all over our city.

1169
01:52:27,480 --> 01:52:29,660
These nonprofits could step up today.

1170
01:52:30,620 --> 01:52:32,100
They could pick up the phone today.

1171
01:52:37,350 --> 01:52:41,150
But since we don't know if they're going to do that, right?

1172
01:52:41,350 --> 01:52:46,030
Like since we don't know, that's what I want to come back to the village, just to clarify

1173
01:52:46,030 --> 01:52:47,210
some of these numbers.

1174
01:52:48,410 --> 01:52:54,830
So, director Gula, so hypothetically, right?

1175
01:52:55,030 --> 01:53:01,430
So, we're saying like 127 a month is what your average Pittsburghers paying for city services,

1176
01:53:02,810 --> 01:53:13,390
If we were to increase the mileage by 20%, that would be an additional $161 for that person, right?

1177
01:53:13,410 --> 01:53:15,150
That would be an additional $161.

1178
01:53:15,150 --> 01:53:25,590
And if we did that, that would bring the city $34 million.6 Dollars, right, for with a 20%

1179
01:53:25,590 --> 01:53:26,130
knowledge increase.

1180
01:53:26,730 --> 01:53:34,230
If you go down to 10%, 10% knowledge increase, that would be an additional $81 for that

1181
01:53:34,850 --> 01:53:35,290
Pittsburgher.

1182
01:53:35,650 --> 01:53:40,430
Now, that would bring us just 17 million.4, right?

1183
01:53:41,030 --> 01:53:44,550
So, you know, if you look at the 10%, that would, you know, that would bring you just

1184
01:53:44,550 --> 01:53:52,510
over $200 a month in taxes, which you're paying for city services.

1185
01:53:53,130 --> 01:53:58,810
I just want those numbers to be clear, like for the press and for the public, right?

1186
01:53:59,770 --> 01:54:03,890
And again, please, to underscore, we are talking about the taxes that you pay to the city

1187
01:54:03,890 --> 01:54:07,670
and we do understand that you pay taxes to the county and you pay taxes to the school district.

1188
01:54:07,670 --> 01:54:09,770
we do. We understand that.

1189
01:54:12,610 --> 01:54:17,130
And then, you know, with regards to the, um, to the fair share

1190
01:54:17,570 --> 01:54:23,090
tax, you know, I think it was, we said, this is not something that's going to happen this

1191
01:54:23,090 --> 01:54:27,350
budget season, right? This is just a broader conversation that I think all Pittsburghers

1192
01:54:27,350 --> 01:54:32,450
should be having, right? This is a broader conversation about, and when we talk about interest

1193
01:54:32,450 --> 01:54:39,650
dividends capital gains that's like on your you know like that's that's the money that you have in the bank that's like

1194
01:54:39,650 --> 01:54:45,170
you know that's like your stock you know like your and it does not include we're not talking about retirement funds

1195
01:54:45,170 --> 01:54:52,230
we're not talking about pensions right we're talking about your your stocks and bonds right like the

1196
01:54:52,230 --> 01:54:59,570
you know and and we're talking about people who the the lines share of that tax would be paid by people who make

1197
01:55:00,000 --> 01:55:21,260
Around $2 million a year. And I think it's important to talk about that because in Pittsburgh in the past 10 years, and I say that because I'm new to Pittsburgh, right? And I would actually, I would be, I would be a person who would be paying this fair share tax and maybe not the highest, but you know what I mean, I definitely would be paying it.

1198
01:55:24,400 --> 01:55:31,960
We have lots of higher earners who are moving into the city. That's a fact. I think that's part of the reason that our earned income tax is going up a bit, right?

1199
01:55:31,980 --> 01:55:38,740
We do have higher earners and sadly some of our lower income earners are being pushed out of the city, right?

1200
01:55:41,080 --> 01:55:47,080
But you know, all those folks who have all that money are benefiting from all these same things.

1201
01:55:47,280 --> 01:55:52,900
They come to Pittsburgh because of these things because of the parks and the pools and the restaurants and all the cool stuff.

1202
01:55:53,120 --> 01:55:55,760
And it is safe, right, that this is a safe city.

1203
01:55:55,760 --> 01:56:02,940
It's an urban area, but you can let your kids kind of walk to the library and go here and there.

1204
01:56:04,600 --> 01:56:06,820
I think we need to have a serious conversation.

1205
01:56:07,060 --> 01:56:09,400
We're talking about building, you know what I mean?

1206
01:56:09,400 --> 01:56:13,800
We've got to build housing and that's expensive, that's $3,000 a month,

1207
01:56:14,100 --> 01:56:18,000
because we've got to have housing for all these wealthy people who are coming to Pittsburgh

1208
01:56:18,000 --> 01:56:19,800
and can pay all this money for rent.

1209
01:56:19,900 --> 01:56:23,340
Well, we need to be paying their fair share.

1210
01:56:23,340 --> 01:56:38,280
So, you know, I'm really grateful to you all for coming and for bringing this right and for presenting this idea because it is an idea and I know that it takes some time right like I mean how how how long do you happen to remember how long it kind of took Philly

1211
01:56:38,800 --> 01:56:44,360
To get this in place from like the first conversation it was well before my time okay

1212
01:56:46,600 --> 01:56:57,600
And it is important to know that this is something that other Philadelphia has already figured out, right, is that the high earners need to be paying their fair share, right?

1213
01:56:57,600 --> 01:57:02,460
Because it shouldn't be on the back of average Pittsburghers.

1214
01:57:04,580 --> 01:57:08,960
I don't think I have any other question

1215
01:57:14,470 --> 01:57:16,010
in having this kind

1216
01:57:28,460 --> 01:57:30,040
of the

1217
01:58:17,110 --> 01:58:18,510
residents.

1218
01:59:14,290 --> 01:59:15,730
because the cost of

1219
01:59:33,110 --> 01:59:34,810
it would be the closest thing we would get.

1220
01:59:48,380 --> 01:59:49,880
It needs to do a regular read.

1221
02:00:00,000 --> 02:00:02,320
But it's their job and

1222
02:00:09,230 --> 02:00:10,290
because

1223
02:00:14,360 --> 02:00:16,800
you're paying your fair share,

1224
02:00:19,800 --> 02:00:22,660
investing their house and they're

1225
02:00:22,660 --> 02:00:26,160
getting overtaxed and until there's a reassessment done, they're going to be paying more

1226
02:00:26,160 --> 02:00:30,080
than their fair share. So that's the closest thing we can get to equity, but we have no control

1227
02:00:30,080 --> 02:00:32,840
over that. So that's why I always talk about the military.

1228
02:00:33,560 --> 02:00:40,760
And I agree with that, Pete. I feel like it's always hard for, and I want to, like, it is always

1229
02:00:40,760 --> 02:00:45,080
hard for elected officials to raise taxes, because nobody wants taxes, right?

1230
02:00:45,280 --> 02:00:54,480
That is often feels like a one-way ticket out of your job, but I think too that it would

1231
02:00:54,480 --> 02:00:59,060
be who counsel, and again, we don't have control over what the county does, but if there

1232
02:00:59,060 --> 02:01:04,140
was a way for us to kind of implement like a base increase every two or three years or

1233
02:01:04,140 --> 02:01:06,720
something like that, where we didn't have to have this conversation, right?

1234
02:01:06,720 --> 02:01:11,800
were just sort of, it was just very gradually going up so that it didn't hurt quite so much.

1235
02:01:12,360 --> 02:01:16,840
The other thing I just want to flag is last year we collected less than $400,000 in

1236
02:01:16,840 --> 02:01:22,420
voluntary payments from non-profits so right now the bar is quite low and I do think that

1237
02:01:22,420 --> 02:01:27,480
the conversation needs to start like yesterday and don't let perfectly the enemy of the good.

1238
02:01:27,780 --> 02:01:35,340
I appreciate the work that has been done in other municipalities that we can learn from, but

1239
02:01:35,340 --> 02:01:36,740
we need to have the conversation.

1240
02:01:37,420 --> 02:01:40,900
And I think, you know, I've said from the beginning,

1241
02:01:41,660 --> 02:01:42,760
ever since I started this job, whatever,

1242
02:01:44,180 --> 02:01:48,200
that you can't have a, you can't go to your next door neighbor

1243
02:01:48,200 --> 02:01:51,340
and ask for a couple of sugar if you're in a land dispute

1244
02:01:51,340 --> 02:01:51,940
with your neighbor.

1245
02:01:52,400 --> 02:01:55,940
And we need to put the disagreements aside with that

1246
02:01:55,940 --> 02:01:59,520
and actually ask and have a good faith conversation

1247
02:01:59,520 --> 02:02:03,040
with our nonprofit partners in the city of Pittsburgh.

1248
02:02:03,040 --> 02:02:17,400
We are in a position where we need additional revenue period and other municipalities they've been able to negotiate long-term agreements to bring in additional revenue through voluntary payments.

1249
02:02:17,980 --> 02:02:28,880
And I believe it's my perspective that city residents are owed that good faith discussion from city leaders and we haven't engaged in that conversation in the last few years.

1250
02:02:28,880 --> 02:02:34,760
And at a minimum, I think that the residents are owed that conversation, so I hope that

1251
02:02:34,760 --> 02:02:39,880
that conversation will commence because I think that revenue needs to come in to at least

1252
02:02:39,880 --> 02:02:45,820
alleviate part of the burden, because I think that, you know, we need that money, we need

1253
02:02:45,820 --> 02:02:52,560
that money. So that's my two cents. And hopefully, we'll the next time we do an updated report

1254
02:02:52,560 --> 02:02:57,980
on voluntary payments, it will reflect a digital revenue. Thank you. Thank you for

1255
02:02:57,980 --> 02:03:00,160
meeting this conversation. Yeah, great. Anyone?

1256
02:03:02,230 --> 02:03:06,110
Okay. Well, with that, having exhausted the

1257
02:03:06,110 --> 02:03:09,050
business of this post agenda, this meeting is adjourned.