City Council Meetings — Special Agenda Revised Added 614-615

San Diego, CA · · More San Diego, CA meetings · More California meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT ·
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT

This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.

The times in this transcript were moved to match the video, using the meeting's own audio. The text is the source's captions, unchanged; the source times are kept in the "sourced" version.
[0:00] Okay.
[0:00] Good morning.
[0:00] I will now call the special
[0:00] City Council meeting of Monday,
[0:00] JUNE 9th, 2025 to order Deputy
[0:02] clerk please call the roll.
[0:04] >> Councilmember Campbell.
[0:06] Councilmember Whitburn here.
[0:07] Councilmember Foster here
[0:07] Council Member John Wolpert
[0:11] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee
[0:12] here.
[0:13] Councilmember Campo here
[0:14] Councilmember Moreno Present
[0:17] Council member Eli Rivera and
[0:19] Council PRESIDENT Lee Carver
[0:20] present also attending
[0:21] the meeting are Assistant City
[0:23] Attorney Michelle Garland,
[0:24] independent budget analyst
[0:25] Charles Monica Council Affairs
[0:27] Advisor in the Mayor's office
[0:29] Curtis Iser and myself your
[0:30] Deputy City Clerk Jennifer
[0:31] Barry.
[0:32] All right.
[0:32] Thank you Deputy Clerk.
[0:33] A quorum is now present.
[0:35] We will begin this morning with
[0:36] the land acknowledgment and
[0:38] the Pledge of Allegiance led by
[0:46] Council member Campo.
[0:47] >> We respectfully acknowledge
[0:48] that the culmination are
[0:50] the original inhabitants of
[0:51] the Unceded land now known as
[0:53] San Diego.
[0:54] Despite enduring the horrors of
[0:56] colonization and genocide,
[0:58] the ice spirit remains
[0:59] unbroken.
[1:00] We honor the resilience of
[1:02] their ancestors who fought to
[1:03] protect their culture and land
[1:03] .
[1:05] Today they carry their legacy
[1:07] forward ensuring that their
[1:09] traditions continue to thrive
[1:10] in gratitude and strength.
[1:12] We stand with the Cuzmy nation
[1:14] connected to our past and
[1:17] committed to a thriving future.
[1:18] Please face the flag.
[1:22] Ready?
[1:22] Begin.
[1:23] I pledge allegiance to the flag
[1:25] of the United States of America
[1:27] and to the Republic for which
[1:29] it stands One nation under GOD,
[1:33] indivisible with liberty and
[1:34] justice for all.
[1:40] >> With that Deputy clerk
[1:41] please go over how the public
[1:42] can offer their public
[1:43] testimony.
[1:44] I would now highlight the slide
[1:46] on the screen that reveals how
[1:47] the public can offer their
[1:48] public testimony during today's
[1:49] meeting.
[1:50] Please note that the time
[1:51] allocations for proclamations
[1:52] consent items for meeting
[1:53] management purposes the order
[1:55] can be found on the agenda
[1:56] Summary found online or at
[1:57] the table in the back of
[1:58] the room.
[1:59] If you're in person please
[1:59] complete a speaker slip located
[2:01] at the entrance of chambers and
[2:02] bring it to the front of
[2:03] the room.
[2:04] Council ambassadors are
[2:05] available near the entrance of
[2:06] chambers and can assist with
[2:07] questions and speaker slips.
[2:09] No further in-person testimony
[2:10] will be taken once the council
[2:11] begins Virtual testimony.
[2:15] All right.
[2:16] With that we will now dispense
[2:17] with the approval of
[2:18] the proclamation item.
[2:20] Deputy Clerk Please proceed
[2:21] with public comment.
[2:22] The public comment period for
[2:23] the proclamation item is now
[2:24] open.
[2:25] Each speaker will have one
[2:26] minute per item per person.
[2:28] The proclamation item being
[2:30] approved is item 600.
[2:33] Uh, we've got a few folks here
[2:36] in council chambers.
[2:38] If allegedly Audra would go
[2:40] ahead and come up because it's
[2:52] not loud at all.
[2:54] >> Um, so as far as this
[2:56] proclamation goes I think
[2:57] what's happening as far as all
[3:00] of the ice stuff is going on
[3:02] because you guys incentivize
[3:03] people to come and have incited
[3:06] these things to happen.
[3:08] I think it is a disservice to
[3:09] immigrants who came here.
[3:11] The legal way and did the right
[3:14] thing went through the process
[3:15] of coming here And you know, it
[3:18] does them a disservice to see
[3:20] that you're you think and just
[3:22] let everybody come in whatever
[3:24] manner that they want.
[3:25] We're going to incentivize Is
[3:27] it they're going to cause chaos
[3:28] in our communities.
[3:29] They're going to rape children
[3:30] in their home.
[3:31] They're going to murder people
[3:32] out on a run.
[3:36] They're going to do a lot of
[3:37] different things and nobody
[3:37] seems to care.
[3:39] You seem to care about ice
[3:41] coming down the pipe when you
[3:43] knew that the federal
[3:44] government was going to come in
[3:46] and do its job.
[3:47] You kept asking for them to.
[3:49] This is their job.
[3:50] This is not our job.
[3:51] That's their job.
[3:52] And now that they're doing it,
[3:54] you guys are setting yourselves
[3:55] up for ice to come into these
[3:56] chambers and hold you
[3:58] accountable for the aiding and
[4:00] abetting and harboring of
[4:01] illegal aliens that you've been
[4:02] doing for years And you wonder
[4:05] why this stuff is happening.
[4:06] You're saying that what Trump
[4:07] does is illegal.
[4:09] No.
[4:09] What you guys have done is
[4:10] illegal and you're setting
[4:11] yourself up and San Diego for
[4:14] some really dire times And it's
[4:16] not fair because nobody asked
[4:19] for that.
[4:19] You wouldn't You guys were so
[4:20] trying to hide the information
[4:23] of them just being here.
[4:24] It was never even something
[4:26] that was talked about like
[4:27] there is an invasion happening
[4:28] on our border Like I
[4:29] continually was telling all of
[4:31] the politicians here in San
[4:33] Diego because I was down at
[4:35] the border collecting their
[4:36] documents, collecting their IDs
[4:38] that they ripped apart even
[4:39] money birth certificates from
[4:42] children who disappeared into
[4:44] our county and the nation
[4:46] The convention center 3200
[4:48] children have gone missing
[4:49] because of you guys.
[4:51] So when ice comes here to these
[4:53] chambers don't question why it
[4:56] happened.
[4:56] Don't question why you're in a
[4:58] jail cell.
[4:59] No, it's because of the choices
[5:00] that you have made and
[5:02] the sodas It's seeds that you
[5:03] have sown.
[5:04] >> Thank you.
[5:05] Seeing no hands in our virtual
[5:07] queue, that concludes public
[5:08] comment on the proclamation
[5:09] items.
[5:10] >> All right.
[5:11] Thank you, Deputy Clerk We'll
[5:12] turn it over to my council
[5:13] colleagues for any questions
[5:15] and entertain a motion and
[5:16] we'll start out with Council
[5:17] President Pro Tem Lee.
[5:20] >> I think Council PRESIDENT
[5:21] I'll speak to item 600 which
[5:23] essentially allow Food festival
[5:24] day proud to bring forward this
[5:25] proclamation alongside council
[5:27] members Campo Foster and Isla
[5:29] Rivera.
[5:29] Recognizing the Lao community
[5:31] and culture and celebrating
[5:32] the upcoming Santa Allow Food
[5:34] Festival which will be
[5:36] the third iteration of this
[5:37] event from JUNE 20th 1st to
[5:39] JUNE 22nd.
[5:41] Lao San Diego will host this
[5:42] third annual Food Festival this
[5:45] year in District seven And
[5:47] the reason behind that for
[5:48] folks who might be curious is
[5:49] because Miramar Community Park
[5:51] is undergoing its Phase two
[5:52] upgrades and renovations And so
[5:55] we think my colleague from
[5:57] District seven as they'll be
[5:59] hosting the event this year
[6:00] it's a two day family friendly
[6:01] event, a celebration of Lao
[6:03] cuisine and culture.
[6:05] It also helps to recognize
[6:06] World Refugee Day an
[6:09] international day to honor
[6:09] the resilience of refugee
[6:11] communities that have made San
[6:12] Diego their home.
[6:14] San Diego happens to be one of
[6:16] the largest populations for Lao
[6:17] Americans and we are a more
[6:19] stronger and vibrant, vibrant
[6:21] because of their culture, their
[6:22] history and the traditions that
[6:24] they've brought here.
[6:25] I think often when we talk
[6:26] about the history of
[6:27] the Vietnam War, one of
[6:30] the discussions that we often
[6:31] don't touch upon is
[6:32] the forgotten war that impacted
[6:34] several neighboring countries
[6:35] and resulted in
[6:37] the displacement of many
[6:38] immigrants from last Cambodia
[6:40] and more attendees who do
[6:43] choose to attend.
[6:44] They'll get to enjoy a variety
[6:45] of Lao food traditional music
[6:47] and dance arts and crafts even
[6:49] some competitions.
[6:50] I understand the spicy papaya
[6:52] salad eating contest is a big
[6:54] hit at this event as well and
[6:57] it brings folks together not
[6:58] just from our region but
[6:59] throughout California and more
[6:59] .
[7:01] This was really heralded in its
[7:03] first year as a significant
[7:04] event across the country So
[7:05] we're certainly proud to honor
[7:07] the contributions of the Lao
[7:08] American community and to help
[7:09] recognize JUNE 21st, 2025 a
[7:13] single Lao food Festival day
[7:14] and thank you again to left San
[7:15] Diego for hosting this
[7:16] incredible celebration and we
[7:18] look forward to seeing them
[7:19] this weekend.
[7:20] >> With that I'll move
[7:21] the proclamation agenda.
[7:22] All right.
[7:23] We have a motion by PRESIDENT
[7:24] Pro Tem Lee.
[7:24] We'll go next to council member
[7:25] Campo.
[7:27] Thank you.
[7:27] Council PRESIDENT I'm honored
[7:28] to join my fellow council
[7:29] members in proclaiming
[7:30] Saturday, JUNE 21st as San
[7:33] Diego Lao Festival Day.
[7:35] The Laotian community has been
[7:36] part of San Diego since
[7:37] the 1970s and before enriching
[7:40] our city with their culture,
[7:41] resilience and deep community
[7:42] roots.
[7:43] And even in my district within
[7:45] the neighborhood of Linda
[7:45] Vista, the Lao Novarum Temple
[7:48] stands as a cultural and
[7:49] spiritual anchor reflecting
[7:50] decades of Lao heritage
[7:52] presence and resilience across
[7:53] San Diego.
[7:55] The Lao Food Festival on
[7:56] the 21st celebrates that legacy
[7:58] and showcases traditional
[7:59] cuisine and music, dance and
[8:01] local entrepreneurs.
[8:02] In honor of World Refugee Day
[8:04] And I'm honored that we'll be
[8:05] able to host it and my
[8:06] community of Allied Gardens and
[8:07] District seven.
[8:09] And with that I will second
[8:10] the proclamations.
[8:11] Thank you.
[8:11] All right.
[8:12] Thank you.
[8:12] Council member will have now a
[8:14] motion by Council PRESIDENT Pro
[8:16] Tem Lee and the second by
[8:19] COUNCILMAN Peel to move
[8:19] the proclamation will go next
[8:20] to council member Whitburn.
[8:22] Thank you Council PRESIDENT I
[8:24] what I thank Council PRESIDENT
[8:25] Pro Tem Lee and Council members
[8:28] Carpio Foster and Isla Rivera
[8:28] for bringing forward San Diego
[8:31] Lao Food Festival de San Diego
[8:31] has such a vibrant Laotian
[8:34] community with organizations
[8:35] like the Lao Community Cultural
[8:37] Center, San Diego Lao heritage
[8:39] working to preserve and promote
[8:42] the culture.
[8:43] And it is a pleasure to join my
[8:45] colleagues at honoring this
[8:46] community.
[8:47] Thank you.
[8:47] Council PRESIDENT All right.
[8:48] Thank you.
[8:49] Council member Whitburn.
[8:49] We'll go next to Councilmember
[8:50] Foster Yes, Thank you.
[8:53] Council PRESIDENT.
[8:54] First I'd like to thank Council
[8:57] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Kent Lee,
[9:02] Councilmember Isla Rivera and
[9:02] Councilmember Campo for
[9:02] bringing forward this
[9:03] proclamation to honor San Diego
[9:05] Lao Food Festival Day.
[9:06] It's important that we take
[9:07] time to recognize the cultural,
[9:11] economic and civic
[9:12] contributions of our Lao
[9:13] community both here in San
[9:14] Diego and across the country.
[9:16] What else?
[9:17] Donate example of this is a Lao
[9:18] food festival itself which not
[9:21] only showcases traditional
[9:22] cuisine but brings people
[9:23] together, drive small business
[9:25] visibility and strengthens
[9:26] community bonds.
[9:27] I've had the privilege of
[9:28] attending Lao cultural events
[9:30] with the Lao community and
[9:31] district for including the Lao
[9:33] New Year celebration.
[9:34] These gatherings reflect
[9:35] the heart of what makes not
[9:37] only District four but the city
[9:38] of San Diego great shared
[9:40] culture community pride and
[9:41] connection across generations.
[9:43] I want to give a special
[9:45] acknowledgment and thank you to
[9:49] Peter Po Town who supports
[9:50] community matters in District
[9:51] four and serves as a board
[9:52] member and public relations
[9:54] director for Lao sd and special
[9:56] thanks to the local community
[9:57] for their contributions, mutual
[9:59] support and commitment to
[10:00] family and neighborhood.
[10:01] >> And that concludes my
[10:02] comments.
[10:03] All right.
[10:04] Thank you.
[10:04] Council member Foster Not
[10:06] seeing anyone else Lights We do
[10:07] have a motion by Council
[10:08] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee and a
[10:09] second by Council member Campo
[10:11] to move the proclamation.
[10:12] Deputy Clerk Please call
[10:13] the roll.
[10:16] I have now started the voting
[10:18] system and you'll go ahead and
[10:19] enter your vote.
[10:25] >> Council member Whitburn
[10:28] There you go.
[10:30] Okay, that passes unanimously.
[10:35] >> All right.
[10:36] Thank you.
[10:37] We will now proceed with
[10:39] the approval of the consent
[10:40] items First, are there any
[10:41] requests to pull an item by
[10:43] the council members not seeing
[10:45] any requests?
[10:46] >> Deputy Clerk Please proceed
[10:47] with public comment on
[10:49] the consent items.
[10:50] Please note each person will
[10:52] have one minute per item per
[10:54] person.
[10:54] If you would like to speak on
[10:55] three or more items you have a
[10:56] maximum of three minutes.
[10:58] The consent agenda includes
[11:03] item 60126 14.
[11:04] I'd also like to note for
[11:05] the record that the potential
[11:06] appointments that are on
[11:07] the agenda this morning are
[11:08] item 6 to 12 is the potential
[11:11] appointment of Michael
[11:12] Singleton to the Balboa Park
[11:14] Committee and item 613 as
[11:16] the potential appointment of
[11:17] Daniel Reeves to the Planning
[11:19] Commission.
[11:20] We have one person here in
[11:22] chambers for public comment You
[11:24] have allegedly Audra if you
[11:26] want to go ahead and come up
[11:27] you have four items So I'm
[11:29] going to put three minutes on
[11:31] the timer, give you a check.
[11:38] You MAY proceed.
[11:40] I MAY not proceed.
[11:43] Sorry.
[11:43] I was like one.
[11:43] Yes.
[11:45] So for this as needed agreement
[11:48] with the two entities regarding
[11:51] services to the water main
[11:53] breaks and sewer backups you
[11:56] know you guys need to make sure
[11:57] that you're taking care of
[11:58] things when it needs to happen
[12:01] instead of, you know, allowing
[12:01] people to lose everything
[12:03] because of your, you know,
[12:04] unwillingness to do what needs
[12:07] to be done.
[12:07] It's funny you guys are so
[12:08] smug.
[12:09] It's like and you act like you
[12:11] do these really great things
[12:13] for the community and you
[12:15] really don't especially when
[12:16] you try and hide all the things
[12:18] that you're doing You can't be
[12:19] transparent And that just shows
[12:21] that when you can't be
[12:22] transparent there's some wrong
[12:24] there And that's that's what's
[12:27] taken place with this entire
[12:29] thing that you guys are dealing
[12:31] with with ice and it's just sad
[12:34] And then we spend money like
[12:36] $6.6 million for rental of you
[12:39] know, traffic and street
[12:41] warning devices Like you spend
[12:43] a lot of money, you waste a lot
[12:45] of money of the people's money
[12:46] They work really hard and you
[12:48] guys get to sit up here on a
[12:50] dias, go home to a beautiful
[12:51] home.
[12:51] There's people suffering on
[12:52] the streets.
[12:53] I've been telling you about
[12:54] Tent City And that brings me to
[12:56] Balboa Park Committee because
[12:57] it's like Steven, when are you
[12:59] going to go and mitigate what's
[13:01] happening at Tent City?
[13:03] Do people deserve to be raped
[13:05] in like have employees sit
[13:07] there and you know, get people
[13:09] drunk and high and then take
[13:11] them into the bathroom and make
[13:12] them on their?
[13:14] Is that acceptable?
[13:16] Is it acceptable to die there
[13:17] because there's no staff for
[13:19] the people to access the Narcan
[13:21] that they need?
[13:22] Is it acceptable for there to
[13:24] be flooding there for tends to
[13:26] be infested with bugs for them
[13:29] to be given Not even anything
[13:31] that is like anything that you
[13:33] would eat as far as food goes
[13:34] yet we spend millions of
[13:36] dollars You upped down Dreams
[13:38] for Change contract just under
[13:44] $500,000 and the racketeering
[13:45] with that like people are being
[13:46] abused in tent city and you
[13:50] don't care It's really sad but
[13:52] you care about giving Theresa
[13:54] Smith dreams for change some
[13:55] money, right?
[13:56] That doesn't matter.
[13:57] We don't mind giving people
[13:58] money but we don't really need
[14:00] to worry about whether or not
[14:02] they're going to provide
[14:02] the services.
[14:06] I mean because nobody's leaving
[14:07] that place.
[14:09] They're just sitting there
[14:10] sitting and maggots and flies
[14:14] right now You do you want me?
[14:16] I have video of it, dude.
[14:18] And you're sitting here
[14:19] laughing.
[14:19] That's what such a disservice
[14:21] it is.
[14:21] It's a slap in the face And
[14:23] then yeah, do your eyebrows
[14:24] like that, bro, Because it's
[14:26] like that's just like when I
[14:27] came to you and asked you what
[14:29] was going on at the school
[14:31] Elementary school during
[14:32] the count for homeless and you
[14:34] know we're counting
[14:35] the homeless.
[14:35] Yeah.
[14:35] I'm wondering why I came across
[14:37] 50 military age men behind a
[14:39] fence that conclude your time.
[14:43] Thank you.
[14:44] I'm going to go ahead and set
[14:45] our five minute timer here in
[14:46] chambers.
[14:47] We have no more speakers in
[14:48] chambers and take our online
[14:50] folks.
[14:52] We have one person in
[14:53] the online q color ending an
[14:57] 8700 If you could go ahead and
[14:58] unmute.
[15:03] >> There you go.
[15:04] Can you let me know which item,
[15:05] which item or items you'll be
[15:07] speaking to?
[15:09] >> Yes.
[15:09] Thank you.
[15:10] I will be speaking to five
[15:12] items six all four, five, six,
[15:16] eight and 11.
[15:20] >> Okay.
[15:21] We'll put three minutes on
[15:22] the timer for you.
[15:23] >> You can go ahead and proceed
[15:24] Thank you so much.
[15:27] Deputy City Clerk Barry on all
[15:31] or six of four actually six
[15:37] four 6 or 5 and 6 or 6 104 is a
[15:38] landscape contract with West
[15:40] Turf five is landscape tree
[15:44] beard six is Landscape usa for
[15:48] Scripps Miramar I mostly looked
[15:51] at the contract and there's a
[15:54] continuing thing that's
[15:57] happening where the under
[16:02] served under representative
[16:03] tend to be African-American,
[16:07] Asian and so well not female so
[16:08] much but female is included
[16:10] this time around in these
[16:12] contracts And I just am
[16:16] concerned about that And I look
[16:18] at the workforce report
[16:20] sometimes there's a workforce
[16:21] report there, sometimes there's
[16:23] not If it's 15 and under
[16:26] they're exempt from them.
[16:28] So there's so many different
[16:30] things to look at.
[16:31] I'm stunned just when I think I
[16:33] understand them I don't And
[16:36] because of a lack of
[16:37] information or protocol that I
[16:39] don't understand for how they
[16:40] fill out these reports.
[16:42] But in any case, I don't know
[16:44] how the play is really
[16:46] enforcing all of this and I
[16:47] don't fully understand the play
[16:49] either but I understand it's
[16:51] mostly good So I'm just
[16:53] concerned that this ongoing
[16:55] representation continues and I
[16:58] don't know how it's being
[16:59] addressed.
[17:00] So on 608 the water main Briggs
[17:06] and sewer back up No on this
[17:06] there was an eoc report again
[17:09] unrepresented in those areas I
[17:11] just mentioned with a little
[17:13] addition of female in
[17:15] management and financial I
[17:17] couldn't find a workforce there
[17:19] report there but there's 114
[17:22] admin workforce And one of
[17:25] the things I don't understand
[17:26] in landscape is how why do we
[17:29] need that many admin and
[17:31] the laborers are really much
[17:33] lower So I don't really fully
[17:35] understand that yet.
[17:36] I'll be looking into it on 611
[17:39] I felt really really sad about
[17:41] this when I read about
[17:42] the $80,000 paid to an alleged
[17:45] excessive force during arrest
[17:48] for a dui.
[17:49] So I'll just say this mostly
[17:51] from my heart Anybody who's
[17:54] driving the eye we know how
[17:56] dangerous this is Joy that
[18:07] we're going to set 30 minute or
[18:14] 30s back on your timer.
[18:16] I apologize, sweetie.
[18:18] How much are you giving me And
[18:21] we stopped about 30s so we'll
[18:24] go ahead and put 30s back on.
[18:27] >> That's no problem here.
[18:28] This is a new set for you up
[18:31] there.
[18:31] So anyway, in some ways here
[18:34] you know a lot of it already So
[18:36] good luck with that.
[18:38] Yes.
[18:38] So just finishing up on 611
[18:41] which is the dui $80,000
[18:44] payment to the person that
[18:46] actually was driving under
[18:47] the influence which shocked me
[18:49] and also saddened me.
[18:51] So I love to see pd Anytime you
[18:55] get involved with these scenes,
[18:57] anything it's so subjective.
[19:00] It's so amazing how in a split
[19:02] second or less you have to make
[19:05] a decision for so much that
[19:09] affects you personally in
[19:10] the city.
[19:11] So love all of that very much
[19:13] and thank you.
[19:14] That concludes your time.
[19:15] Apologies for the technical
[19:16] difficulties that as our only
[19:18] virtual caller.
[19:19] So that concludes public
[19:20] testimony on the consent items
[19:23] All right.
[19:23] Thank you, Deputy Clerk.
[19:24] With that we'll turn over to my
[19:26] council colleagues for any
[19:27] questions and comments and then
[19:29] entertain a motion and we'll
[19:30] start with Council member
[19:31] Whitburn.
[19:32] Thank you.
[19:32] Council PRESIDENT Happy to move
[19:33] the consent agenda.
[19:34] I just want to congratulate
[19:35] District three Michael
[19:37] Singleton at his appointment to
[19:37] the Balboa Park Committee as
[19:39] well as District three is
[19:39] Daniel Reeves on his
[19:41] appointment to the planning
[19:42] Commission.
[19:42] Both MR. Singleton and MR.
[19:44] Reeves have been active in
[19:45] civic affairs for years and I
[19:47] just want to thank them for
[19:48] their continued service to our
[19:49] city.
[19:50] Thank you.
[19:51] All right.
[19:51] So we do have that motion by
[19:52] Council member Whitburn to move
[19:53] the consent items all second,
[19:56] not seeing anybody else on
[19:58] the lights And with that deputy
[20:00] clerk please call the roll.
[20:03] I have turned on the voting
[20:04] system If you can please record
[20:06] your vote If you could try one
[20:11] more time Council member
[20:12] Whitburn and Moreno thank you
[20:14] very much.
[20:15] And that passes unanimously.
[20:21] >> All right.
[20:21] I just will take a yes from
[20:25] Councilmember Moreno and one
[20:25] absent So So with that we will
[20:30] now take up our morning
[20:31] discussion agenda.
[20:32] >> Deputy Clerk please
[20:33] introduce item 6156 15 Item 615
[20:38] is the approval of a request
[20:39] for a conflict of interest
[20:41] waiver from Colleen Tuna
[20:43] Highsmith and Whitely Peachey
[20:44] Citywide.
[20:45] >> Okay.
[20:46] All right.
[20:47] I noticed that two of our
[20:48] colleagues are recusing from
[20:50] this particular item.
[20:52] Do we need a presentation on
[20:54] this one that we have five
[20:57] minutes presentation Five
[21:00] minutes will go at once.
[21:01] You go ahead and do
[21:02] the presentation just to dot
[21:04] the I's and cross the t's.
[21:06] >> Good morning.
[21:07] City Council Senior Deputy City
[21:09] Attorney Ben Seats I'm here
[21:11] today on item 615 which is a
[21:14] request for a conflict of
[21:15] interest waiver by the content
[21:16] of law firm The law firm
[21:18] currently represents us is San
[21:19] Diego in two ongoing lawsuits
[21:22] and they're requesting
[21:23] the waiver to allow them to
[21:25] continue to represent the city
[21:27] and to also represent Lasco in
[21:29] the city's anticipated lawsuit
[21:30] against Lafc related to the La
[21:32] Hoya and Corporation
[21:33] proceedings.
[21:34] The conflict waiver does not
[21:36] pose a risk of any detrimental
[21:38] impact to the city In the city
[21:40] Attorney's office recommends
[21:41] granting the request.
[21:43] >> Please let me know if you
[21:44] have any questions.
[21:44] All right.
[21:44] >> And your name for the record
[21:46] I forgot to ask Senor Deputy
[21:48] City Attorney Ben Seats all
[21:50] right.
[21:50] Thank you for that.
[21:52] With that Deputy clerk please
[21:54] proceed with public comment.
[21:56] >> We have one public commenter
[21:57] here in chambers of allegedly
[22:00] order what come up?
[22:09] >> You MAY proceed.
[22:10] Too bad Steven's gone.
[22:13] Yeah.
[22:13] It's interesting that you guys
[22:14] want to deal with conflicts of
[22:15] interest codes when there's
[22:18] conflicts of interest going on
[22:19] across the board with you guys
[22:21] yet you sit here and you're
[22:22] like This isn't going to affect
[22:23] anything.
[22:24] You can't be trusted because
[22:26] the choices that you guys make
[22:28] lead to really bad things like
[22:30] little girls being raped in
[22:31] their home five years old or
[22:34] the 21 year old her.
[22:36] How cool is that, right?
[22:38] But yeah, let's just keep keep
[22:40] pretending that what we've done
[22:42] is good.
[22:43] Right?
[22:43] And it's interesting that
[22:45] Steven doesn't think that
[22:46] anything that's going on in
[22:48] Tent City is actually happening
[22:49] but yet when I'm exposing it
[22:50] they tend to be asking all of
[22:52] the employees who's giving out
[22:54] the information we need to keep
[22:55] this confidential.
[22:57] We can't be having people talk
[22:58] about what's going on outside
[23:00] of Tent City.
[23:01] You know what?
[23:01] You're fired.
[23:02] So they fire people and then
[23:04] they do You know what else
[23:05] Because they live there too.
[23:07] Then they file complaints
[23:08] against them so that they can
[23:10] set to basically kick them out
[23:12] onto the streets.
[23:13] But I'm sure you'll offer up
[23:14] another solution right?
[23:17] It's disgusting the things that
[23:19] takes place with our money and
[23:22] the abuse of people And you
[23:25] guys sit up there and you're
[23:25] just like horizontal Great.
[23:27] We're just so great going to
[23:28] pat myself on the back.
[23:31] We're going to give ourselves
[23:32] raises, ignore the suffering of
[23:34] people that is going on in
[23:35] the community And exactly for
[23:38] that reason I cannot weigh in
[23:41] until I is in these chambers
[23:43] And you guys are the ones
[23:45] begging and pleading Oh my
[23:46] gosh.
[23:47] >> Oh no we didn't do anything.
[23:51] Yeah you did And you've been
[23:53] warned and you had been for
[23:55] years yet you don't care but
[23:59] perhaps you will when you're in
[24:01] a jail cell and you're just
[24:03] trying to get something to eat
[24:05] and maybe call one of your
[24:06] loved ones And when you're
[24:08] separated from your family
[24:09] because of your choices that
[24:12] concludes your time.
[24:13] We have no more speakers here
[24:15] in chambers so I'm going to set
[24:16] our five minute timer and go to
[24:18] our virtual queue.
[24:19] We have one hand raised and
[24:20] the virtual queue caller ending
[24:23] and 8700 You can go ahead and
[24:25] unmute If you have two minutes
[24:30] you MAY proceed.
[24:32] >> Thank you so much.
[24:34] Joining me out of District 30I
[24:38] don't quite quite know how to
[24:40] speak on this.
[24:41] I'm really coming from
[24:42] the heart and the mind.
[24:44] Hopefully that's a good
[24:45] combination this morning.
[24:48] I respect the office of
[24:50] the City attorney so very very
[24:52] much Yet I know that things can
[24:55] be ministerial and very
[24:56] subjective often in life but
[24:59] I'm I just feel not good about
[25:01] this item.
[25:03] I just think it's almost a
[25:04] conflict of interest to bring
[25:06] it in as an agenda item And
[25:08] then we have the other conflict
[25:10] of interest is to really allow
[25:12] these attorneys to handle this
[25:13] and PRESIDENT LaCava I love a
[25:13] lawyer.
[25:22] It's it's some things I don't
[25:24] like about it but in general
[25:26] it's a wonderful place.
[25:28] And so this is involving whole
[25:33] situation was so high and
[25:34] they're wanting to become a new
[25:35] city and it's going to be a
[25:37] long process.
[25:38] So I just don't feel good about
[25:40] them being represented in other
[25:43] cases for the city and then
[25:46] going sort of with this other
[25:48] firm that really is against us.
[25:51] So I just wish I understood I
[25:54] tried to read all the back up.
[25:56] It was late and I just don't
[25:59] understand risk not involved
[26:02] here.
[26:02] I think there is a risk and and
[26:04] these things might just come up
[26:07] to really haunt So make sure
[26:09] that you really want to do
[26:11] this.
[26:11] I would go on the no side but I
[26:14] respect all of you and thank
[26:16] you for listening.
[26:16] Love to all.
[26:19] Thank you so much.
[26:21] That concludes public testimony
[26:23] on item 615.
[26:24] All right.
[26:25] Thank you, Deputy Clerk.
[26:26] With that we'll turn over to
[26:28] the council for questions.
[26:29] Entertain a motion not seen in
[26:31] the lights.
[26:31] I'll go ahead and move
[26:32] the staff recommendation and I
[26:35] get a second.
[26:38] Okay.
[26:38] We have a second by council
[26:40] member Isla Rivera and Council
[26:43] member Campo.
[26:44] >> Thank you.
[26:44] Just a quick question for MR.
[26:45] Seats.
[26:46] So it's my understanding that
[26:47] the particular law firm in
[26:51] question they're kind of caught
[26:52] between a rock and a hard place
[26:53] because there the general
[26:55] counsel for Lascaux but
[26:56] represent us in two particular
[26:57] cases.
[26:58] So it seems to me that if we
[26:59] didn't waive or didn't have a
[27:02] waiver of the potential
[27:03] conflict of interest, we'd lose
[27:05] them as a lawyer, not laugh, go
[27:07] lose them as a lawyer in
[27:09] the potential proceedings that
[27:10] it might come.
[27:12] I think well, I believe, you
[27:16] know, deference on the law firm
[27:17] but that is a potential outcome
[27:19] that we understood.
[27:21] Well, it's part of your
[27:22] comments earlier were that
[27:23] there's nothing you don't
[27:24] foresee any detriment to
[27:27] the city.
[27:27] It seems to me that there would
[27:29] be a detriment to the city.
[27:30] Is it We've hired a law firm to
[27:31] represent us in two cases and
[27:33] then well after the fact it
[27:36] turns out that they're
[27:37] representing a potential
[27:38] opposing party to us.
[27:39] There would be no there would
[27:41] be no detriment if we granted
[27:42] the waiver or representation in
[27:45] either matter would or in
[27:46] the existing matter would not
[27:48] be impacted by their
[27:49] representation of
[27:50] the anticipated new matter.
[27:52] Understood.
[27:53] Okay.
[27:55] Of no further questions.
[27:55] Thank you Counsel PRESIDENT All
[27:56] right.
[27:57] Thank you, Council Member
[27:58] Campbell So we have a motion by
[27:59] myself and a second by council
[28:01] member Eli Rivera not seeing
[28:03] anyone else in the lights
[28:03] Please call the roll.
[28:06] I have started the voting
[28:07] system If you'll go ahead and
[28:08] put in your vote you MAY have
[28:11] to press the button twice.
[28:15] >> Council member Whitburn is
[28:18] as absent okay Council Member
[28:20] Foster Thank you very much.
[28:27] That passes with a five votes
[28:29] and four council members
[28:30] absent.
[28:32] >> All right, Thank you very
[28:33] much and thank you for your
[28:34] good work on that.
[28:35] With that we will now adjourn
[28:37] the PRESIDENT My my apologies
[28:39] but I think on the earlier vote
[28:41] the screen isn't registering
[28:42] correctly because I think it
[28:44] missed my vote on the item,
[28:46] the consent agenda and then
[28:47] just on this one council member
[28:48] Ellen Rivera should she was
[28:50] absent I apologize for
[28:54] the record.
[28:54] Council member Ella Ribeiro Yes
[28:56] on item 615 And just to be
[28:59] clear Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem
[29:02] voted yes on the consent
[29:03] agenda.
[29:04] Thank you.
[29:04] Council PRESIDENT Apologies if
[29:06] I MAY I just for the record
[29:07] also I think it I think we
[29:10] typically distinguish between a
[29:11] recusal in an absence when
[29:13] we're setting the record on
[29:14] the vote.
[29:16] >> That's a very good point.
[29:18] So a type network.
[29:22] Okay.
[29:23] >> Okay, go ahead.
[29:24] Well I can go ahead and Sorry
[29:26] it's not my everyday job That
[29:29] was five votes to Council
[29:32] member Whitburn and Council
[29:34] member Von Wilpert recused and
[29:37] and one absence and it's two
[29:43] Yes yes six plus two plus one
[29:44] equals nine.
[29:45] >> Okay.
[29:46] >> Apologies.
[29:46] Thank you, Council member
[29:49] Rivera for that reminder.
[29:51] With that we will now adjourn
[29:53] the special council meeting for
[29:55] the noon recess and convene
[29:56] the regular council meeting at
[29:58] 2 P.M. Or shortly thereafter