[13:25] 888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 [15:16] and [16:24] and and I will answer. [16:25] All right. [16:25] Good morning. [16:26] I will now call the City [16:27] council meeting of Monday, JUNE [16:29] 22nd 2026 to order that [16:32] the clerk please call the Roll [16:34] Council member Campbell your [16:40] government Council member [16:40] Whitburn here Council Member [16:42] Foster Council Member Von [16:46] Wilpert Council Member Council [16:49] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee here [16:51] Council Member Can't be out [16:53] here Council Member Moreno [16:57] Council Member Julio Rivera and [16:59] Council PRESIDENT LaCava [17:01] present. [17:02] Also attending the meeting are [17:03] City Attorney Heather Ferber, [17:05] independent budget analyst [17:09] Jillian and Elina of Council [17:10] Affairs advisor in the mayor's [17:11] office. [17:12] But as I learned myself here [17:13] Deputy City Clerk Kevin Smith [17:16] All right, thank you Deputy [17:18] Clerk a quorum is now present. [17:20] We will begin this morning with [17:21] the invocation by Deputy Clerk [17:23] Smith followed with an [17:25] acknowledgment and the Pledge [17:26] of Allegiance let by council [17:27] member Campbell Brandt. [17:33] Those who hold office in [17:35] the city a spirit of wisdom, [17:37] charity and justice that were [17:38] steadfast purpose They MAY [17:40] faithfully serve in their [17:41] offices to promote [17:42] the well-being of all people. [17:48] We respectfully acknowledge [17:50] that the communication or [17:52] the original inhabitants of [17:54] the Unceded land now known as [17:57] San Diego Despite enduring [17:59] the horrors of genocide and [18:00] colonization, the community [18:02] spirit remains unbroken. [18:05] We honor the resilience of [18:06] their ancestors who fought to [18:08] protect their culture and land [18:10] and today they carry their [18:11] legacy forward ensuring that [18:14] their traditions continue to [18:16] thrive and gratitude and [18:17] strength We stand with Cooma, [18:20] our nation connected to our [18:22] past and committed to a [18:24] thriving future. [18:26] We place the flag, place your [18:28] hand over your heart and let's [18:30] begin by going to the flag [18:34] United States of America and to [18:36] the Republic for which it [18:37] stands one nation under GOD, [18:40] indivisible with liberty and [18:47] justice for all. [18:48] >> All right With that Deputy [18:49] clerk, please go over how [18:50] the public can offer their [18:51] testimony. [18:53] >> Thank you, Council [18:53] PRESIDENT. [18:54] I will now now highlight [18:55] the slide on the screen that [18:57] reviews how the public can [18:58] offer their public testimony [18:59] during today's meeting. [19:01] If you are in person please [19:03] complete a speaker slip located [19:05] at the entrance of chambers and [19:06] bring it to the front of [19:07] the room No further in-person [19:09] testimony will be taken once [19:11] the Council begins Virtual [19:13] testimony for better meeting [19:15] management purposes each [19:16] speaker will have one minute [19:17] per item per person. [19:19] If you would like to speak on [19:20] three or more items you will [19:22] have a maximum of three [19:23] minutes. [19:26] All right. [19:26] Thank you Deputy Clerk And as a [19:27] reminder non agenda public [19:29] comment which will be taken at [19:30] the end of the session with [19:31] the opportunity to speak freely [19:32] on items within city [19:34] jurisdiction items on [19:35] the docket we encourage [19:37] the public to offer their [19:38] testimony to inform the Council [19:40] members of their consideration [19:42] or deliberations on that docket [19:44] item. [19:45] So with that Deputy Clerk [19:47] please read the closed session [19:48] items into the record. [19:51] Conference with Legal Counsel [19:53] Existing litigation pursuant to [19:55] California Government Code [19:56] Section 5495 6.91 c. [20:00] S one Sandra Silva versus City [20:01] of San Diego at all the to [20:04] repeat versus city of San Diego [20:05] c. [20:09] S three Maria del Rosario Nunez [20:10] Munoz versus City of San Diego [20:10] c. [20:13] S four Jesse Torres versus [20:14] Civil Service Commission of [20:16] the city of San Diego c. [20:18] S five Denise Wadsworth at all [20:20] versus City of San Diego at [20:21] all. [20:23] All right. [20:24] >> With that please proceed [20:25] with public comment. [20:29] >> Thank you. [20:30] We will begin with in-person [20:31] public comment. [20:34] Jacob Lewis Edwards please come [20:36] forward. [20:38] You are requested to speak on c [20:40] us one c us two and see us [20:42] three. [20:42] >> You'll have three minutes to [20:43] speak. [20:49] Thank you members of our city [20:50] council and allow me to speak [20:52] in front of you. [20:54] I've spoken from you about many [20:56] things and these items include [20:59] lawsuits to the city of reading [21:01] slips and falls and such. [21:05] i'm going to speak upon myself [21:07] now. [21:08] I usually speak upon for what [21:09] is going on in a general sense. [21:13] I spoke to you about how our [21:14] cyber networks were hijacked [21:16] going around eight years ago. [21:19] My uncle his possession of [21:20] the dhs over our country [21:23] cybersecurity networks [21:23] hijacked. [21:24] I'm sorry to interrupt. [21:25] Can you speak to the closed [21:26] session items that you [21:27] identified as opposed to a now? [21:29] Yes, I am getting to that, sir. [21:31] I'm getting to that And that [21:33] handful of federal field agents [21:35] assisted the mob in hijacking [21:37] our federal government agencies [21:41] flooding terrorized along [21:41] the way by them pestered, [21:42] tormented, harassed, harassed [21:45] any trace of anything I've gone [21:46] through wiped out and it [21:50] continues to this day now is [21:53] prevented that until I get into [21:54] a shelter if I am able to get [21:57] into a shelter and that is here [21:59] in the city. [22:00] It's set up there on customer [22:02] tormented, harassed, terrorized [22:05] people, given assignments [22:06] within the shelter to hurt me. [22:08] And it all comes from federal [22:10] activity currently and [22:13] prevented from getting into a [22:14] shelter. [22:15] I sleep at the front door here [22:17] at the Civic Center to stay [22:18] safe under a camera. [22:21] But I go through even here I [22:23] wouldn't sue the city of San [22:25] Diego. [22:25] I love this city but I I'd like [22:26] to bring to your attention I [22:29] mean I could file a lawsuit but [22:32] I'm not but I'm going to bring [22:33] it to your attention. [22:34] Just two nights ago sleeping [22:36] right here at the front door. [22:38] Three guys nice designer jeans, [22:41] nice shoes And it was overnight [22:42] standing right over me loudly [22:45] conversating being rude. [22:47] It was very unruly over [22:49] somebody trying to sleep. [22:52] I mentioned that to them so [22:54] please have some consideration. [22:55] And I mentioned how federal [22:56] field agents who terrorize me [22:58] will set people up to do this. [23:00] I'm not saying that's the case [23:01] but it sure seems so. [23:04] They got very angry at me. [23:05] One of them pulls his belt off, [23:08] stands over me and says [23:09] Threaten to beat me in a very [23:12] aggressive threatening manner. [23:14] I said Now you're going to [23:15] threaten to beat a homeless guy [23:16] that you were standing over. [23:19] I said Really? [23:21] He got more abrasive cop bag [23:23] that he So I walked off and [23:24] called 911911 dispatchers will [23:28] not take a report from any of [23:30] the activity that I've gone [23:32] through in the past It struck [23:34] me from reporting anything [23:37] The dispatcher wanted me to [23:39] confirm my telephone number [23:40] before he would dispatch [23:42] anybody in an emergency call. [23:45] >> That's not normal protocol [23:47] in any city. [23:48] Usually it's a dispatch [23:49] immediately. [23:51] That's what I got. [23:51] Thank you for your comment that [23:51] that concludes the witness who [23:52] died. [23:55] And for the record you did not [23:56] speak to any of the closed [23:57] session items so thank you. [23:58] I'm a human being. [24:02] That does conclude in-person [24:03] public comment. [24:04] I've started the five minute [24:05] timer in council chambers. [24:07] We will now turn to the virtual [24:08] care in which there are [24:09] currently three participants [24:11] wishing to speak. [24:14] We will first go to original [24:14] draft. [24:18] Could you please indicate which [24:21] closed session item or items [24:22] you wish to speak to me? [24:26] I'm going to touch on all of [24:28] them. [24:28] Okay. [24:29] You have three minutes. [24:30] >> Please proceed. [24:30] Okay. [24:31] So with these continued trips [24:33] and fall incidents I mean it's [24:36] quite ridiculous how much money [24:38] we wind up spending to in [24:41] settlements when you know just [24:44] these problems can be fixed and [24:47] you know, knowing that someone [24:49] has tripped and fall fell in [24:51] these areas or had an incident [24:54] there, you know, have you gone [24:57] and mitigated that? [24:58] Is that something that you [25:00] know, was instantly put on [25:02] the list of things to do to [25:04] make sure that there won't be [25:06] other incidents that arise? [25:08] And I find it interesting as [25:10] well that some of you say this [25:12] case arises from a slip and [25:14] fall. [25:14] This case arises from a slip [25:15] and fall and then it's like [25:17] this matter arises from an [25:19] alleged trip and fall on [25:21] the sidewalk. [25:22] So I mean what leads you to [25:25] treat the case in that manner [25:27] And then for you you know [25:33] the case five in the Wadsworth [25:34] case, you know this one also it [25:36] says this case arises out of an [25:38] alleged scooter incident But [25:39] this is an actual death. [25:41] Somebody died and due to [25:45] dangerous condition. [25:46] So I feel like when you guys [25:48] want to, you know, go under [25:50] the Brown Act and say that [25:51] you're like providing just [25:53] enough information for a [25:55] summary I mean you're leaving [25:57] out some pretty significant [25:58] information and you know, for [26:01] the people to know and you know [26:04] to for someone to have died due [26:07] to this incident you know, and [26:09] you to to consider it alleged [26:11] in the other ones you know are [26:12] obviously true or whatever you [26:16] know it just kind of discredits [26:17] the person dying it feels like [26:20] And then with this Jesse Taurus [26:22] case and the Civil Service [26:24] Commission, you know, this [26:26] officer was engaged in [26:29] misconduct off duty. [26:31] And so, you know, officer [26:32] should be held to a, you know, [26:36] standard much like the people. [26:38] And I find that the people are [26:40] held to a higher standard than [26:41] law enforcement and or any kind [26:43] of public official. [26:44] And you know, when the people [26:46] engage in crimes, you know you [26:48] want to hold them accountable. [26:48] But then we have, you know, [26:50] officers whether it's on duty [26:52] or off duty and they're engaged [26:55] in misconduct abuse, you know, [27:00] abuse of power or different [27:01] things like that. [27:02] I mean. [27:02] Andrea Ebbing you know, within [27:04] Anthony Warner I mean he [27:06] brutally assaulted her and [27:07] she's sitting in jail right now [27:09] and they made her do a [27:10] competency evaluation and they [27:13] have deemed her incompetent [27:14] which is absolutely ridiculous [27:16] which means that stalls of [27:17] proceedings and all of this And [27:19] so it's like you guys wind up [27:22] criminal izing the people when [27:23] they've been abused by law [27:25] enforcement. [27:26] So I mean this man needs to be [27:29] held to a standard much like [27:31] the people and even higher I [27:33] would say thank you very [27:35] comment. [27:35] The caller did speak to all [27:37] the closed session items So [27:38] thank you very much. [27:41] Our next virtual commenter is [27:44] with the caller with the last [27:46] four digits 8700 please tell us [27:50] which items you wish to speak [27:51] to and begin your comments. [28:01] Excuse me. [28:02] Thank you. [28:03] Deputy Clerk Joy is Senator and [28:08] I would speak on all of them. [28:09] Okay. [28:10] Please proceed. [28:12] And number one which is a trip [28:14] and fall accident again I'm [28:18] going to speak to the public [28:20] deer public I really encourage [28:22] you to claim your own self [28:25] safety and be your own advocate [28:28] when you're out walking as I [28:30] try to do because it's [28:32] dangerous out there on [28:34] the sidewalks and we need to [28:36] watch out for ourselves. [28:37] So please consider that I'm [28:41] number two which is a slip and [28:45] fall incident and well I'll say [28:48] on that is incident versus an [28:50] accident doesn't seem as solid [28:53] a case for the plaintiff here. [28:55] I am not sure on that. [28:57] So on number three alleged trip [29:00] and fall on sidewalk so with [29:03] alleged I'm not clear again yet [29:07] what I'm not clear is what [29:10] happened and it doesn't seem [29:11] like you are either in what's [29:13] being presented and that [29:14] the evidence will need to be [29:16] presented so that you really [29:17] can move forward on it. [29:19] But best of luck on that. [29:21] So item number four which is [29:23] the Civil Service Commission [29:26] item a writ of mandamus which [29:31] in MARCH and it means we [29:33] command and also this really [29:36] struck me when I looked it up [29:38] it is an extraordinary remedy. [29:41] So I'm not clear what that [29:42] means but I did Google a civil [29:46] service commission and they [29:48] have a very positive [29:50] reputation. [29:50] So that was really wonderful to [29:53] read, You know, on [29:54] the settlements and judgments [29:55] which we looked at recently [29:57] mostly regarding speedy equal [30:01] rights within number one item [30:02] of the number of cases that [30:04] occur to I And they talked [30:08] about speeding up the process [30:09] because the costs are [30:11] escalating. [30:12] So please I don't know when [30:15] this termination in [30:16] the original added some [30:18] information which I didn't know [30:20] about so it sounds like a [30:21] pretty serious thing and then a [30:24] termination is involved So I'll [30:25] just send you blessings on that [30:27] and best of luck for all [30:29] parties In the Scooter incident [30:33] which was alleged excuse me [30:35] Same incident. [30:36] Alleged. [30:37] Oh yes. [30:38] So there is an incident alleged [30:40] e-scooter incident I learned a [30:42] lot during our e-scooter time [30:45] and when they were present in [30:47] San Diego mostly I learned that [30:49] we have many levels, many [30:52] layers of codes and regular [30:54] ations that can tie our hands [30:57] in litigation. [30:59] I think we learned a lot from [31:01] our e-scooter period and it's [31:06] it's just a learning lesson for [31:08] us and I certainly learned a [31:10] lot. [31:10] So we move forward and I thank [31:14] you very much for listening and [31:16] love to all have a beautiful [31:17] day and a beautiful week. [31:18] Thank you to the caller for [31:20] staying on topic. [31:21] Thank you for those comments. [31:23] Please note that the five [31:25] minute timer did conclude with [31:26] no additional speakers left in [31:27] the queue That does conclude [31:29] closed session Public comment [31:33] All right. [31:34] >> Thank you Deputy Clerk With [31:35] that we will now recess into [31:36] closed session and reconvene [31:38] council today at 2 P.M. Or [44:58] shortly thereafter [46:43] and then [46:49] All right started. [46:50] >> Good afternoon. [46:50] I will now reconvene the city [46:52] council meeting on Monday, JUNE [46:54] 22nd 2026 that the clerk please [46:57] call the Roll Council member [46:59] Campbell Council Member [47:01] Whitburn Council Member Foster [47:06] Council Member Von Wilpert [47:10] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem [47:10] The Council Member Campo [47:15] Council Member Moreno Council [47:18] Member Eli Rivera and Council [47:21] PRESIDENT LaCava Present. [47:23] Also attending the meeting are [47:25] Assistant City Attorney [47:26] Michelle Garland Jordan more [47:29] fiscal and policy analyst with [47:31] the Office of the Independent [47:32] Budget Analyst and myself here [47:36] Deputy City Clerk Kevin Smith. [47:40] All right, a quorum is now [47:41] present. [47:42] So first of all start off [47:43] whether there's any comments [47:44] from the mayor's office, [47:45] council members, city attorney, [47:47] independent budget analyst, our [47:49] city clerk and not seeing any [47:53] We'll go on Deputy Clerk Please [47:55] go over how the public can [47:56] offer their testimony. [47:59] I will not I don't know how I [48:00] like to slide on the screen [48:01] their reviews how the public [48:02] can offer their public [48:03] testimony during this [48:04] afternoon's meeting. [48:06] The order can be found on [48:07] the agenda Summary found online [48:08] or at the table in the back of [48:10] the room. [48:11] If you are in person please [48:12] complete the speaker slip [48:13] located at the entrance of [48:14] chambers and bring it to [48:15] the front of the room. [48:17] Council ambassadors are [48:18] available near the entrance of [48:20] chambers and can assist with [48:21] questions and speaker slips. [48:23] No further in-person testimony [48:25] will be taken once the council [48:26] begins Virtual testimony. [48:30] >> All right. [48:31] And as a friendly reminder non [48:34] agenda public comment which [48:35] will be taken at the end of [48:36] the day it's an opportunity to [48:37] speak on anything that's within [48:38] the broader city of San Diego [48:40] Purview docketed items We [48:43] request that you speak to [48:45] the item itself Inform [48:47] the Council about whether you [48:48] support an item or reject an [48:51] item and your reasons why So [48:53] focusing on the docket item [48:55] will be appreciated So with [48:57] that Deputy Clerk please [49:00] introduce item 200 item 200 [49:07] Public hour Feasibility study [49:09] Phase two report. [49:10] All right. [49:11] Thank you, sir. [49:12] And a reminder to everyone this [49:14] is an information item. [49:16] No motion will be taken And now [49:23] settle then please introduce [49:25] yourselves for the record and [49:26] let us know how much time [49:27] you'll need. [49:37] >> There we go. [49:37] Try again. [49:38] There we. [49:42] Keep on Heather Rider, deputy [49:42] director for energy in [49:44] the Department of General [49:45] Services. [49:45] We need about 15 minutes. [49:47] All right, Begin when you're [49:48] ready. [49:48] All right. [49:49] Thank you very much. [49:49] Thank you. [49:50] Council PRESIDENT, members of [49:51] council as many of you are [49:53] aware and as a corollary to [49:56] the award of the Genie [49:57] franchise, the city started [50:01] studying alternatives to a [50:03] franchise agreement for [50:05] the delivery of electricity [50:06] within the city boundary and as [50:08] public power feasibility that [50:10] study was split into two parts. [50:12] The Phase one report was [50:13] brought to council in [50:14] the summer of 2023. [50:17] It did find basic economic and [50:19] technical feasibility so we [50:21] moved into phase two which was [50:24] a much deeper dive into [50:26] the economic and technical [50:28] feasibility as well as [50:29] incorporating changes in [50:31] the regulatory space that have [50:33] happened between those periods. [50:35] We brought on new gen [50:37] strategies to act as our [50:41] subject matter expert and [50:42] technical consultant in [50:43] executing that study And so I'm [50:44] going to pass it over to Scott [50:46] to go over the findings. [50:48] Great. [50:49] Thank you Heather. [50:50] Good afternoon. [50:51] Council PRESIDENT Council [50:52] members Staff As I mentioned my [50:54] name is Scott Burnham. [50:55] I'm a partner and project [50:57] manager with New Data Strategy [50:59] Solutions. [51:00] I'm joined here today with DR. [51:02] Nelson Beck along with Siemens [51:04] Engineering, Andrew Atwater [51:05] with Beebe and a consultant [51:08] that assisted us with the study [51:08] . [51:14] Excellent. [51:15] >> All right. [51:15] The bottom line in terms of [51:17] the phase two study is that we [51:19] found that the analysis for [51:21] developing and creating an mcu [51:24] and municipal electric utility [51:25] from the San Diego Gas Electric [51:28] Genie assets was both [51:30] economically and technically [51:31] feasible. [51:33] The results depend on the value [51:35] of the assets that the city [51:37] pays to acquire them. [51:39] We conducted analysis using two [51:42] approaches to cost approaches [51:43] to value. [51:44] We'll talk more about that [51:45] The Oakland original costs less [51:47] depreciation at the low end and [51:49] replacement costs new less [51:51] depreciation on the high end. [51:53] This analysis focuses on [51:55] the delivery assets only [51:58] There's no generation assets to [51:59] be acquired from Genie [52:02] The generation power supply [52:04] portion of the mcu was assumed [52:07] to be supplied by sdp. [52:10] >> This data currently serves [52:10] the majority of the city Load [52:14] results suggest a range of [52:15] savings between 6 and 6% to 16% [52:20] depending on the assets paid to [52:22] be acquired between 7 billion [52:24] and $19 billion At the 30 year [52:27] conclusion of the 30 year study [52:28] . [52:31] More broadly, the analysis that [52:32] we conducted was what we call [52:34] an overnight analysis. [52:36] It's assuming that [52:39] the municipal utility would [52:40] essentially start within [52:43] the year. [52:44] That's not feasible. [52:45] We know that We realize that [52:47] will take at least 10 or 15 [52:48] years to establish a municipal [52:51] utility. [52:52] But the approach uses an [52:54] overnight analysis as a prudent [52:56] approach to understand the cost [52:58] and determine the feasibility. [53:05] We came before you [53:06] approximately three years ago [53:07] with the results of the Phase [53:08] one study. [53:09] >> There's been significant [53:10] changes since then. [53:12] The relative to the study we [53:15] had additional information and [53:17] detailed data provided by Jenny [53:20] and that informed a lot of [53:22] the results of the study. [53:23] We also recognize there have [53:25] been significant changes in [53:27] policy and the regulatory [53:28] environment that also impact [53:29] the study and the Phase two [53:31] report Phase two report In [53:35] terms of the changes in [53:36] the utility environment, [53:38] certainly a change in [53:39] the landscape relative to [53:40] the assets themselves. [53:42] Again, the information we got [53:43] from Jenny that information [53:46] helped improve the cost [53:48] analysis relative to [53:50] the physical separation of [53:52] the two systems. [53:53] If the mou is to be formed it [53:55] would be electrically isolated [53:56] from Jenny who have the ability [53:58] to do so and that would require [54:02] investment on behalf of [54:03] the city. [54:06] In terms of the regulatory [54:07] environment, the process [54:08] continues to evolve relative to [54:10] how the cpc would develop or [54:13] what would determine the cost [54:16] for the mcu to acquire these [54:18] assets. [54:19] As you're aware, the city of [54:20] San Francisco is going through [54:21] a similar exercise. [54:22] They're a little further ahead. [54:24] They've been to the cpc. [54:26] They have some preliminary [54:27] results relative to how the cpc [54:31] would then then look at [54:32] the acquisition costs. [54:34] But there are other policy and [54:36] risks to be considered in terms [54:38] of climate change, commodity [54:39] cost, wildfire mitigation as [54:41] you know that's a big ticket [54:43] item relative to costs and cost [54:46] recovery. [54:50] The Phase two approach focuses [54:52] on a 30 year cash needs. [54:54] It develops what we call a [54:56] revenue requirement for [54:57] the mcu. [54:58] That's the total dollars to [54:59] operate the mcu in comparison [55:01] to the total dollars paid to us [55:04] based on existing rates and [55:06] assumptions about future rates. [55:08] For Jenny, as I mentioned, it's [55:11] only acquiring assets within [55:13] the city primarily distribution [55:16] assets but some limited [55:17] transmission assets as dcp as [55:23] dcp sorry the cta will continue [55:23] to provide power supply to [55:24] everyone And it's this buildup [55:27] of the revenue requirement that [55:28] is the crux of the analysis. [55:30] So we're looking at the that [55:31] the system as mcu compared does [55:36] cost on an all in basis [55:38] compared to the system as I see [55:41] each unit continue and [55:42] the status quo the analysis [55:45] suggests the that there is [55:46] indeed savings it shows [55:48] the benefit of public power [55:50] there are but current [55:52] opportunity for efficiency [55:54] local control and cost savings. [55:57] Again this is done on what we [55:59] call an overnight analysis [56:01] recognizing that there would [56:02] still be a different time [56:04] component to this in terms of [56:09] the assets to be acquired. [56:11] As I mentioned, almost all [56:12] the assets almost all [56:14] the assets in the city would be [56:15] acquired approximately 800 [56:17] miles of secondary conductor [56:18] conductor line wires, [56:22] transformers meters and other [56:23] equipment. [56:24] The city would be responsible [56:26] for serving approximately six [56:29] 660,000 customers. [56:30] The city would also acquire 42 [56:33] electrical substations within [56:34] the municipal boundary and [56:36] the sub transmission conductor [56:37] between those substations [56:40] the city would not acquire [56:42] the high voltage system [56:44] the bulk transmission system or [56:45] any generation assets from a [56:52] genie. [56:53] As I mentioned, we conducted [56:54] what we call a cost based [56:55] purchase price analysis. [56:57] This cost based analysis begins [56:59] on a low end and with the only [57:03] older original cost less [57:03] depreciation and the high end [57:04] replacement cost new less [57:05] appreciation In reality [57:07] the cost would likely come in [57:09] between those two values. [57:10] But we developed these bookend [57:12] values at $2.4 billion for [57:15] original cost of depreciation [57:19] and $7.6 billion replacement [57:19] cost new less depreciation In a [57:23] transaction a prudent seller [57:24] likely would likely not accept [57:29] our original cost appreciation [57:29] . [57:29] That's a book value essentially [57:31] and a prudent buyer is unlikely [57:32] to accept replacement cost new [57:34] less depreciation which is why [57:36] would in all likelihood that [57:38] costs would come in between [57:39] those two values somewhere [57:41] The difference of that $5.2 [57:44] billion is significant and it [57:46] does in the age of the assets [57:48] certainly has an impact on that [57:49] valuation. [57:51] We also assumed that there [57:52] would be additional costs [57:53] upfront approximately $912 [57:55] million of upfront cost to fund [57:58] that separation analysis again [58:00] creating to electrically [58:02] ability to have two [58:03] electrically isolated systems [58:05] startup costs as well and as [58:07] well as $470 million in working [58:10] capital. [58:11] Startup costs include [58:12] the development of the utility [58:14] to create an operating utility [58:16] ,financial reserves, liquidity [58:18] measurements and the like. [58:22] This next slide shows a summary [58:23] of the key assumptions. [58:26] As I mentioned, the purchase [58:26] price is probably the most [58:28] dramatic key in terms of [58:30] the analysis that range between [58:34] 2.4 billion and 7.6 billion but [58:35] also the assumptions around [58:37] long term rate growth for ge we [58:40] assume 4% per year going [58:43] forward That was based on [58:44] information available at [58:45] the time From the general rate [58:46] case it's probably a little bit [58:49] lower than historic but we [58:52] believe there was a [58:52] conservative assumption other [58:55] elements include the payment in [58:56] lieu of franchise fees and [58:58] public benefits. [58:59] As I mentioned, the separation [59:00] costs, startup costs upfront [59:02] working and of course staffing [59:05] one of the critical elements [59:05] relative to difference between [59:07] the phase one and the phase two [59:07] analysis was there's a more [59:10] detailed analysis around [59:12] staffing. [59:13] The intent would be to to [59:15] address the concerns of ibew [59:17] and others and acquire [59:19] the workforce from any. [59:24] In summary of the results. [59:27] We've got two graphics here on [59:28] the left. [59:28] You can see there's selected [59:29] years between the oclc and [59:31] again on the low end the rca [59:33] and on the high end. [59:35] So you can see we're showing [59:37] your ten, your 20 and your 30 [59:38] for the ocd. [59:40] So significant savings of $19 [59:41] billion at the end of [59:43] cumulative savings in your 30 [59:45] the replacement costs new less [59:46] appreciation is slightly lower [59:48] at $7 billion There is a [59:51] crossover in the ocd case It's [59:54] year one in which mean you [59:55] would show cash positive for [59:58] the replacement cost you looked [59:59] at less depreciation the old [1:00:01] either higher asset that [1:00:02] crossover occurs and estimated [1:00:04] in year 12 so the city would [1:00:06] not recognize savings upfront [1:00:08] if indeed they purchased a [1:00:14] price at at rc an oldie [1:00:15] The next slide shows on an [1:00:17] annual basis looking out over [1:00:19] the 30 year forecast the period [1:00:21] of the study on the left we saw [1:00:23] the ocr and all the numbers You [1:00:24] can see showing cash positive [1:00:25] there in year one and [1:00:27] continuing to grow over time On [1:00:29] the right we show our you know [1:00:31] you can see that the blue bars [1:00:32] there are the city of San Diego [1:00:34] costs the mcu costs that would [1:00:37] be higher than any costs for [1:00:39] the first 12, 11, 12 years in [1:00:41] the study we did conduct a [1:00:48] sensitivity on the relative to [1:00:51] the assumptions about [1:00:53] the growth rate of the retail [1:00:55] rates. [1:00:56] As I mentioned, we use the 4% [1:00:57] approach annual approach for [1:01:00] city Jeanie retail rates We [1:01:02] believe that that was [1:01:03] reasonable based on recent rate [1:01:05] case information. [1:01:07] Historically that number is [1:01:08] probably closer to about 6% as [1:01:11] you can see in this analysis [1:01:12] here. [1:01:13] What we're trying to show in [1:01:14] this analysis I should say is [1:01:16] that at 3% at the lower end of [1:01:19] the range of growth rates, [1:01:22] the savings is significantly [1:01:23] less at 6% that that range goes [1:01:27] up to significant and [1:01:27] significant savings, a [1:01:31] difference of about $60 billion [1:01:32] between those. [1:01:33] Now this is based on the ocr [1:01:35] acquisition cost case but you [1:01:38] can see the sensitivity to [1:01:40] the results relative to [1:01:41] the assumption made for [1:01:42] the genie rates. [1:01:46] There are certainly several key [1:01:47] assumptions moving forward that [1:01:49] would impact future [1:01:50] feasibility. [1:01:52] Certainly policy direction [1:01:53] around climate change, consumer [1:01:55] preference, electrification and [1:01:56] the like relative to projected [1:01:58] low growth How it will impact [1:02:00] this analysis certainly [1:02:03] direction at the state level [1:02:05] looking at affordability, [1:02:07] looking at reliability in terms [1:02:09] of investment requirements for [1:02:11] systems such as energy needs [1:02:13] and the sensitivity to retail [1:02:15] rates is an important [1:02:16] consideration as well. [1:02:19] Looking out over what's [1:02:20] happening at the state at [1:02:22] the cpi you see relative to San [1:02:23] Francisco felt that [1:02:26] the precedents there in terms [1:02:26] of that court decision, [1:02:28] the preliminary court decision [1:02:30] looking at legislation, Senate [1:02:32] bill 875 looking at municipal [1:02:36] ization efforts across [1:02:37] the state as well as at the cpi [1:02:40] you see regarding wildfire [1:02:41] investments and the past in [1:02:43] the future is a major unknown [1:02:49] conclusion. [1:02:50] >> The Phase two analysis is [1:02:52] conducted has significantly [1:02:53] refined the financial [1:02:55] projections. [1:02:55] We have a lot more detailed [1:02:57] data relative to the asset [1:02:58] inventory relative to [1:03:00] the estimated costs. [1:03:02] The certainly the age of [1:03:03] the assets are materially older [1:03:04] than originally assumed [1:03:07] creating a different difference [1:03:08] disparity between the ocr and [1:03:11] replacement costs new less [1:03:12] depreciation values. [1:03:15] The Phase two does find [1:03:16] financial and technical [1:03:17] feasibility and the opportunity [1:03:19] to save dollars for the rate [1:03:20] over time for rate payers. [1:03:23] But the biggest drivers I [1:03:25] mentioned is the assumption [1:03:26] around sd g long term growth [1:03:28] rates and of course [1:03:30] the potential savings and [1:03:31] financial benefits are an [1:03:32] estimate At this point there's [1:03:34] no guarantees that these that [1:03:36] these savings would would would [1:03:36] come to fruition. [1:03:40] The legislative and regulatory [1:03:41] environment is indeed evolving [1:03:43] and fluid. [1:03:45] There are certainly costs [1:03:47] issues around costs recovery [1:03:48] cost reimbursement valuation [1:03:49] approaches as well as [1:03:51] the potential process all of [1:03:53] which could impact [1:03:53] the financial feasibility. [1:03:56] However, overall the results [1:03:57] are more refined and more more [1:04:00] defined than significant [1:04:00] unknowns and variables remain. [1:04:03] That's the conclusion of our [1:04:04] presentation. [1:04:05] I'd be happy to answer any [1:04:06] questions. [1:04:09] >> All right. [1:04:10] Thank you for the presentation. [1:04:11] The fire marshal has asked for [1:04:12] Those that are standing [1:04:14] the back are actually empty [1:04:15] seats out there. [1:04:16] So if you could take a seat [1:04:17] with make the fire marshal [1:04:19] happy which makes me feel more [1:04:21] comfortable. [1:04:22] So thank you. [1:04:24] So think again for [1:04:26] the presentation. [1:04:28] With that let's go to public [1:04:31] comment. [1:04:32] Thank you counsel Thank you. [1:04:35] Council PRESIDENT This item [1:04:35] received 15 comments in favor [1:04:37] and two comments in opposition [1:04:38] via our e comment form which [1:04:41] has been distributed to [1:04:42] the Council. [1:04:43] We will begin with in-person [1:04:44] public comment. [1:04:49] Anthony Stackhouse Please come [1:04:51] forward and and each speaker [1:04:55] will receive one minute after [1:04:59] Anthony Kevin Carroll, Matthew [1:05:02] Fish and Christina marquez [1:05:05] Please come sit in the front [1:05:06] row. [1:05:10] >> Please begin. [1:05:13] My name is Anthony Stackhouse. [1:05:15] I serve on the executive board [1:05:16] for ibew for 65. [1:05:19] I spent 14 years in the Army [1:05:22] with combat deployments [1:05:23] overseas and if you knew the I [1:05:25] went through to get to where [1:05:26] I'm at today you would not be [1:05:28] so steadfast to put my job and [1:05:30] my family's quality of life at [1:05:32] risk. [1:05:33] The people in this city don't [1:05:35] trust you Don't give them more [1:05:36] reasons. [1:05:37] Be honest with themselves. [1:05:39] You do not have the resources [1:05:40] or knowledge to do this. [1:05:43] Don't gamble with my job or [1:05:44] the job of my union brothers [1:05:46] and sisters because I promise [1:05:47] you one thing we will not go [1:05:49] down without a fight. [1:05:51] I urge this Cancel this council [1:05:52] to end this now Municipal [1:05:55] association is union busting. [1:06:01] Thank you for those comments. [1:06:02] Kevin Carroll Good afternoon [1:06:10] Council members My name is [1:06:11] Kevin Caroline, executive [1:06:12] Director of Tech San Diego [1:06:13] representing technology [1:06:14] companies across our region. [1:06:16] Our members care about reliable [1:06:17] service competitive rate and [1:06:19] the infrastructure needed to [1:06:20] support innovation, [1:06:21] manufacturing and economic [1:06:23] growth. [1:06:24] Based on this presentation we [1:06:25] have some concerns. [1:06:27] The question is not whether [1:06:28] minutes position is possible. [1:06:30] The question is whether [1:06:31] the risk caused are [1:06:33] sufficiently understood before [1:06:34] making a multibillion dollar [1:06:35] decision that could impact [1:06:36] businesses and residents for [1:06:38] decades before moving forward. [1:06:40] The city should have a high [1:06:41] degree of confidence that all [1:06:42] major cost liabilities, [1:06:44] regulatory requirements and [1:06:45] operational challenges are [1:06:47] fully understood and reflected [1:06:49] in the analysis. [1:06:51] If manipulation ultimately [1:06:52] proves to be the best path, [1:06:54] the business case could [1:06:55] withstand rigorous scrutiny if [1:06:56] significant uncertainties [1:06:57] remain as I think we saw in [1:06:59] the presentation, those [1:07:00] questions should be resolved [1:07:01] before ratepayers and [1:07:03] businesses assume the risk for [1:07:04] San Diego's innovation economy. [1:07:06] The goal is a reliable, [1:07:07] resilient and affordable energy [1:07:09] energy system that supports [1:07:09] job. [1:07:10] Thank you. [1:07:11] Thank you for your comment and [1:07:12] that does conclude your time. [1:07:15] Matthew Fish Good afternoon [1:07:21] Council members. [1:07:22] My name is Matthew Fish and I'm [1:07:23] the system business manager at [1:07:25] ibew Local 465. [1:07:27] I represent the workers [1:07:28] industry Jeannie speaking [1:07:32] against the Phase two study [1:07:32] because it offers no job [1:07:33] protections for my 700 gas [1:07:35] construction work members [1:07:37] workers will lose their jobs [1:07:39] and the retiree medical and [1:07:41] pensions will be affected. [1:07:43] Please in this once and for all [1:07:45] please invest the $9 million [1:07:46] Billion elsewhere such as [1:07:48] infrastructure backlog or [1:07:50] housing for the homeless. [1:07:51] Please do not gamble with our [1:07:53] union jobs and if the city has [1:07:55] bigger priorities like thank [1:08:03] you and Christina marquez and [1:08:05] while Christina speak incurred [1:08:08] Mark Fuentes, Krystal Gomez, [1:08:09] Monica Valdez and Cecilia [1:08:11] marquez please approach [1:08:12] the front row. [1:08:14] Hi good afternoon. [1:08:16] Christina marquez speaking on [1:08:18] behalf of ibew Local 569 San [1:08:21] Diego and Imperial County where [1:08:24] the inside wireman We're here [1:08:25] in solidarity with our union [1:08:27] sisters and brothers of 465. [1:08:30] The ibew stands against any [1:08:32] effort to municipalities [1:08:34] the power company the Nugent [1:08:37] study says nothing about worker [1:08:39] protections or job guarantee [1:08:42] Leaving our ibew five 569 [1:08:45] members in limbo ibew members [1:08:49] could lose jobs and benefits [1:08:53] and the city is already [1:08:54] billions behind in [1:08:55] infrastructure spending [1:08:57] infrastructure spending That [1:08:59] puts our building trades [1:09:00] members to work. [1:09:01] >> Please do not wage or gamble [1:09:05] with our jobs and our [1:09:07] livelihood. [1:09:08] Please end these efforts once [1:09:10] for all. [1:09:11] Thank you. [1:09:12] Thank you. [1:09:13] Mark wants Yeah Good afternoon. [1:09:20] Council members. [1:09:21] My name is Mark Fuentes. [1:09:23] I'm a gas working foreman for [1:09:23] our city. [1:09:26] Jeannie a shop steward Would I [1:09:28] be w Local 465 a proud U.S. [1:09:30] Army veteran and a San Diego [1:09:32] native. [1:09:33] I served this country because I [1:09:35] believe in protecting American [1:09:37] families, American workers and [1:09:39] communities. [1:09:40] But when I look at this [1:09:41] proposal I don't see any [1:09:42] protections for me, my [1:09:44] coworkers or our families. [1:09:45] I don't see a future for my [1:09:47] skilled gas workers who have [1:09:49] dedicated their entire careers [1:09:51] to serving this community. [1:09:53] I also don't see protection for [1:09:55] our communities especially when [1:09:56] the cost of living is at an all [1:09:58] time high. [1:10:00] This proposal will create [1:10:01] additional expenses for [1:10:03] citizens and taxpayers who are [1:10:04] already struggling to make ends [1:10:05] meet. [1:10:06] Please don't gamble with good [1:10:08] union jobs without clear worker [1:10:10] protections. [1:10:11] I urge you not to move forward [1:10:12] with this effort. [1:10:13] Thank you Cristo Gomez. [1:10:20] >> Good afternoon, Council [1:10:21] members. [1:10:22] My name is Cristo Gomez. [1:10:25] I am shop steward of ibew 465 [1:10:26] and equipment operator c [1:10:28] Jeannie I'm also a veteran of [1:10:29] the United States Marine Corps. [1:10:31] I operate equipment for gas and [1:10:32] electric emergency And this [1:10:34] feasibility study you only want [1:10:36] to take over electric. [1:10:37] What about gas jobs? [1:10:39] What about equipment operators [1:10:41] like myself and their families [1:10:44] when we lose our jobs? [1:10:46] What about our retirements? [1:10:48] There are over 700 gas workers [1:10:50] in our union. [1:10:51] What about them? [1:10:53] Where's our just transition And [1:10:55] what about job mobility? [1:10:57] Because in this proposal I [1:10:59] don't see a future for us in [1:11:01] our jobs Don't gamble with good [1:11:03] union jobs And I see Jeannie [1:11:05] with the city takeover I urge [1:11:06] the City Council not to proceed [1:11:08] any further with this effort [1:11:10] forcing the city to take on [1:11:11] billions in debt is wrong. [1:11:13] We have bigger priorities. [1:11:15] Thank you. [1:11:16] Thank you. [1:11:17] Monica Valdez Hello my name is [1:11:25] Monica Relative. [1:11:26] >> I'm a third generation ibew [1:11:28] member and emergency dispatcher [1:11:30] for sd Jeannie I'm a proud [1:11:32] resident of District four. [1:11:36] >> I am a very active and very [1:11:37] active in my union and my [1:11:39] community as part of local [1:11:41] social service clubs. [1:11:43] I'm here to express my absolute [1:11:45] opposition to the Phase two [1:11:46] study The proposal is costly, [1:11:49] will gamble what puts our union [1:11:51] contracts in the crosshairs? [1:11:53] There are zero protections and [1:11:55] zero guarantees for my members [1:11:56] . [1:11:57] There was zero current [1:12:00] consideration for my gas [1:12:00] members. [1:12:01] Our gas people They are left [1:12:03] behind in this proposal. [1:12:05] Where is the just the just [1:12:06] transition Please vote against [1:12:08] this risky measure. [1:12:10] Please don't gamble with our [1:12:11] livelihoods. [1:12:12] >> Please stop this once and [1:12:13] for all. [1:12:17] Thank you. [1:12:18] Cecilia marquez Well Cecilia [1:12:21] comes to the microphone could [1:12:21] Laurie Lips? [1:12:26] Lipson Noelia Carolyn Jason [1:12:28] Poggio, Chris Kate and Amy [1:12:30] Fossett please come to [1:12:30] the front row. [1:12:32] >> Please begin. [1:12:34] Thank you. [1:12:35] My name is Cecilia marquez. [1:12:37] I'm born and raised in San [1:12:38] Diego. [1:12:39] I'm a single mother, a [1:12:40] homeowner and a 24 year [1:12:42] employee at San Diego Gas and [1:12:43] Electric. [1:12:44] I'm also a proud union officer [1:12:46] and organizer at ibew Local [1:12:48] 465. [1:12:50] The city has been studying this [1:12:52] for decades and it's time to [1:12:53] stop. [1:12:53] San Diego is a beautiful city [1:12:56] but when I look around I see [1:12:57] bigger priorities that we [1:12:58] should be focusing on [1:13:00] the homelessness, affordable [1:13:02] housing, fixing our storm [1:13:03] drains, infrastructure, public [1:13:05] transit And in this study [1:13:08] there's no guarantee that our [1:13:09] jobs will carry over to a city [1:13:11] ran utility. [1:13:12] And even if they do, wages, [1:13:14] salaries and benefits could [1:13:16] change considerably. [1:13:17] So I urge the city council to [1:13:19] not proceed any further with [1:13:20] this effort. [1:13:21] Let's stop wasting our tax [1:13:22] dollars. [1:13:23] This is wrong and the city has [1:13:25] much bigger priorities. [1:13:28] Municipal association It is [1:13:28] union busting. [1:13:29] >> Thank you. [1:13:31] Thank you. [1:13:38] Laurie Lipman Hello Council [1:13:38] members. [1:13:39] I'm Laurie Litzman, a [1:13:40] constituent of District three [1:13:43] sd Jean e continues to put [1:13:45] profits before people. [1:13:46] For decades we've been we've [1:13:49] built an energy system that [1:13:51] transports power long distances [1:13:53] ,losing power along the way [1:13:55] while increasing costs and [1:13:57] vulnerability. [1:13:58] The Sunrise Powerlink destroyed [1:13:58] habitat impact and cultural [1:14:02] significance in significant [1:14:03] lands and disrupt its disrupted [1:14:05] communities. [1:14:08] Today those transmission [1:14:09] corridors are part of a system [1:14:11] that routinely shuts down power [1:14:13] to reduce wildfire risk. [1:14:15] This is not smart energy. [1:14:19] Sd g e customers pay among [1:14:21] the highest rates in California [1:14:23] while utility executives and [1:14:25] shareholders continue to profit [1:14:27] ,many residents are being [1:14:28] forced to choose between [1:14:29] necessities and keeping [1:14:31] the lights on. [1:14:32] Energy is an essential public [1:14:34] service. [1:14:35] It should be accountable to [1:14:36] the people not corporate [1:14:36] profit. [1:14:37] Basically that does conclude [1:14:37] your time. [1:14:38] Thank you. [1:14:43] Next speaker Noelia Collin Good [1:14:51] afternoon. [1:14:52] My name is Noelia Colon and I'm [1:14:53] a welder. [1:14:56] Jeannie I'm four and a proud [1:14:56] member of ibew for six five. [1:14:58] I'm proud to be the first woman [1:15:00] welder in our union's history [1:15:01] of over 100 years. [1:15:02] This career has changed My life [1:15:04] gave me opportunities financial [1:15:06] independence and a future I [1:15:08] never imagined for myself. [1:15:09] I understand that people are [1:15:10] frustrated with utility costs. [1:15:12] Those concerns are valid and do [1:15:14] deserve to be heard and [1:15:15] discussed. [1:15:15] We pay those too and we live [1:15:17] here as well. [1:15:18] But when I read the study I [1:15:19] didn't see enough discussion [1:15:21] about the workers who operate [1:15:22] maintain and respond to [1:15:23] emergencies on the system every [1:15:24] day. [1:15:25] I didn't see myself I didn't [1:15:26] see my union brothers and [1:15:27] sisters. [1:15:28] I didn't see the young women [1:15:29] who MAY 1st day follow the path [1:15:30] that I did part that I did. [1:15:32] I ask that you consider not [1:15:33] only the infrastructure but [1:15:34] the people behind it [1:15:35] the workforce, the training, [1:15:36] the experience, the careers, [1:15:38] the culture, all the hustlers [1:15:39] that serve that community for [1:15:41] generations. [1:15:41] I was born and raised here in [1:15:43] San Diego. [1:15:44] I love the city and that's [1:15:45] exactly why I'm asking you to [1:15:47] think carefully about [1:15:47] the people who serve and [1:15:48] sacrifice for it every day. [1:15:50] >> Thank you. [1:15:53] >> Jason Paglia, Jason Paglia. [1:15:59] Okay. [1:16:00] Moving on Chris Kate Good [1:16:06] afternoon. [1:16:06] Council PRESIDENT Members of [1:16:07] the council Chris Kate on [1:16:08] behalf of the San Diego [1:16:09] Regional Chamber of Commerce. [1:16:11] The Phase two study claims I [1:16:13] mean just what utility would [1:16:13] save San Diegans $130 billion? [1:16:16] Let's be direct When something [1:16:18] sounds too good to be true, it [1:16:19] usually is giving false hope to [1:16:22] San Diegans at a time when [1:16:23] affordability is top of mind. [1:16:25] The reality is that municipal [1:16:26] ization is a dangerous, costly [1:16:27] gamble. [1:16:29] Startup costs alone could reach [1:16:30] $9 billion a year or more. [1:16:32] Money the city simply does not [1:16:33] have nor residents can afford [1:16:35] to take on as debt. [1:16:36] This doesn't even account for [1:16:38] massive annual operating costs [1:16:40] wildfire insurance cost [1:16:41] overruns or litigation that [1:16:42] residents and businesses would [1:16:43] be forced to bankroll. [1:16:47] >> Pursuing a takeover of our [1:16:48] energy infrastructure is a [1:16:49] costly distraction that [1:16:50] undermines our economic [1:16:51] stability and risk our electric [1:16:53] reliability. [1:16:55] Past city councils have rightly [1:16:56] rejected this path time and [1:16:57] again because the risks [1:16:58] continue to far outweigh any [1:17:01] speculative benefits. [1:17:02] We urge you to reject this [1:17:03] proposal once and for all. [1:17:05] Thank you. [1:17:07] Amy Fossett. [1:17:12] >> Good afternoon. [1:17:13] Amy Fossett with the Building [1:17:14] Industry Association of San [1:17:16] Diego. [1:17:16] I'm here today to talk more [1:17:18] about from my personal and [1:17:19] professional experience working [1:17:21] here at the city. [1:17:22] I was had the honor of working [1:17:23] here over for over 20 years in [1:17:25] almost every branch of [1:17:27] government. [1:17:28] The city is not structured [1:17:29] organizationally nor does it [1:17:31] have the expertise or [1:17:32] the financial resources to take [1:17:34] on such an endeavor. [1:17:35] I too am concerned about energy [1:17:37] rates. [1:17:38] But the city of San Diego is [1:17:39] not the solution to that [1:17:40] problem. [1:17:41] So I ask you to please move on [1:17:43] from this endeavor and focus on [1:17:45] the priorities and issues that [1:17:46] you already have on your plate. [1:17:47] Thank you. [1:17:51] >> Thank you. [1:17:52] Our next speaker is Marcy [1:17:53] Weaver. [1:17:54] While Marcy approaches [1:17:55] the microphone, could Mark [1:17:58] Kersey. [1:18:01] Gene Wilder, Al Sanchez and [1:18:06] Matt Kaczynski Please come sit [1:18:08] in the front row. [1:18:10] Good afternoon, Council members [1:18:12] and city staff. [1:18:13] My name is Marcy Weaver, ceo [1:18:15] Controller MR. Chamber of [1:18:16] Commerce. [1:18:17] I'm here today on behalf of [1:18:18] the businesses we represent to [1:18:19] the throughout South County. [1:18:22] Our business community depends [1:18:23] on a reliable, affordable and [1:18:25] predictable energy to operate, [1:18:28] grow and create jobs in our [1:18:29] region. [1:18:30] While we appreciate the effort [1:18:32] that has gone into [1:18:33] the feasibility study, we are [1:18:34] concerned that there is still [1:18:36] not enough information [1:18:37] available to fully understand [1:18:39] financial, operational and long [1:18:42] term impacts of the municipal [1:18:42] politician accounts. [1:18:46] We also want to acknowledge [1:18:48] the significant wildfire [1:18:51] mitigation work and ongoing [1:18:53] investment that sgmd has made [1:18:56] across the region. [1:18:58] Chula Vista has had close calls [1:19:00] with five wildfires. [1:19:03] And this is critically [1:19:04] important issue for our [1:19:05] community. [1:19:05] We have seen firsthand the work [1:19:08] that fda has done to straighten [1:19:12] grid build reliability and [1:19:14] reduce fire risk being Thank [1:19:17] you for your comments. [1:19:17] That does conclude your time. [1:19:19] Next speaker is Mark Kersey. [1:19:24] Good afternoon council [1:19:25] PRESIDENT And members of [1:19:26] the council Mark Kersey [1:19:27] representing San Diego [1:19:27] Taxpayers. [1:19:29] Having said on your side of [1:19:30] the dais for eight years I'm [1:19:32] going to ask you a question Is [1:19:34] this really a headache that you [1:19:35] guys want to take on? [1:19:36] You guys already have a lot of [1:19:38] headaches and several of them [1:19:39] concern utilities. [1:19:41] You get thousands of complaints [1:19:42] about water rate increases. [1:19:45] You get browbeat over the cost [1:19:46] of pure water. [1:19:48] You get criticized for failed [1:19:49] stormwater channels and you [1:19:51] take errors over trash fees [1:19:52] particularly when third party [1:19:53] estimates don't match reality [1:19:56] Exactly like what could happen [1:19:57] with this issue. [1:19:59] Make no mistake running [1:20:00] the power grid will only make [1:20:02] these other headaches seem [1:20:03] minor by comparison. [1:20:05] The minute this ill fated [1:20:06] eminent domain takeover closes [1:20:08] ,people will expect you to [1:20:10] immediately lower their [1:20:11] electric rates. [1:20:12] But you won't be able to [1:20:13] because you have spent billions [1:20:15] to buy the system and might [1:20:16] actually need those rates to [1:20:17] increase to pay off the massive [1:20:19] bond debt and associated [1:20:20] integration costs. [1:20:23] You all have a tough job. [1:20:24] You have enough headaches. [1:20:25] Save yourself this one. [1:20:27] Thank you. [1:20:28] Thank you for your comments. [1:20:30] Next speaker is Jay Wilder. [1:20:33] If you're holding a sign, [1:20:34] remember there are people [1:20:35] behind you that might want to [1:20:36] see our smiling faces up here. [1:20:38] So use the back row if you want [1:20:40] to hold the signs up so we can [1:20:42] read them because you big fonts [1:20:43] but have a courtesy to [1:20:45] the people behind you. [1:20:46] Thank you. [1:20:47] Hello. [1:20:48] Thank you for your time. [1:20:48] My name is Jay Walder. [1:20:49] I'm PRESIDENT Of ibew Local 465 [1:20:52] and alignment during [1:20:52] the alignment. [1:20:54] I'm also a marine Corps veteran [1:20:56] husband father to two kids and [1:20:58] I'm and I've defended [1:21:00] the nation and our freedom. [1:21:02] Today I am speaking to defend [1:21:03] my union members and protect [1:21:05] their jobs. [1:21:06] Don't do this like I've trained [1:21:08] for 20 plus years under ibew [1:21:10] desk to learn this complex and [1:21:11] ever changing system and I'm [1:21:13] learning more every day. [1:21:15] This is not something you can [1:21:16] just learn overnight. [1:21:17] It will take you decades and [1:21:19] all the while my vw brothers [1:21:21] and sisters and I will fight [1:21:22] you every step of the way to [1:21:23] protect union jobs. [1:21:26] Let's not go to war. [1:21:27] Let's find a way to work [1:21:28] together to address real [1:21:29] priorities in San Diego like [1:21:31] homelessness especially veteran [1:21:33] homelessness, mental health and [1:21:37] addiction. [1:21:38] This is where we should be [1:21:39] spending valuable city [1:21:39] resources. [1:21:40] Thank you for your time. [1:21:42] >> Thank you. [1:21:44] Our next speaker is Al Sanchez [1:21:45] . [1:21:48] >> Thank you, council members. [1:21:49] My name's Al Sanchez and I'm [1:21:51] here on behalf of Local 89 and [1:21:54] my business manager Bella [1:21:54] Marcelo. [1:21:56] We're here today to communicate [1:21:58] our opposition to the efforts [1:22:00] of bringing the work union [1:22:02] contractors currently do [1:22:02] in-house. [1:22:05] We do not mean we do not [1:22:06] benefit the city taxpayers or [1:22:10] our employees. [1:22:11] The studies have shown [1:22:11] the studies have not proven you [1:22:15] with real opportunities costs [1:22:16] for what is needed to actually [1:22:20] manage this reliably utility [1:22:21] and keep it keep the lights on [1:22:23] 24 hours. [1:22:25] Nor does it address the costs [1:22:27] needed for worker safety [1:22:29] working in highly highly [1:22:30] skilled working workforce, [1:22:31] skilled workforce and [1:22:33] competitive wages and benefits [1:22:34] and construction expertise in [1:22:37] building and maintaining [1:22:38] the grid and pipelines in San [1:22:40] Diego. [1:22:41] We don't believe this business [1:22:42] is served in the cities. [1:22:46] >> Good interest of doing this [1:22:47] . [1:22:50] >> We asked the council to [1:22:51] direct their time and resources [1:22:53] in delivering the city [1:22:53] services. [1:22:55] >> Thank you Mayor Because [1:22:58] Greensky while Matt approaches [1:22:59] the microphone could make a [1:23:02] erroneous Britney says Rihanna [1:23:06] barrel Bill Powers and [1:23:08] allegedly Audra please come to [1:23:10] the front row. [1:23:11] Please begin. [1:23:13] Good afternoon council members. [1:23:15] My name is Max Stransky I'm [1:23:17] speaking We have today of acp [1:23:18] Local 127 the dedicated city [1:23:20] workers who keeps an you [1:23:22] running as you know local 127 [1:23:24] represents the hardworking [1:23:25] employees of our maintenance [1:23:27] labor skilled trades and [1:23:29] equipment operators and so [1:23:30] forth. [1:23:31] Our members are on the front [1:23:32] frontlines serving the city [1:23:33] every single day and their [1:23:35] stability is our top priority. [1:23:37] It is our concern that that's [1:23:39] stability and the fiscal health [1:23:41] of our city that local 127 must [1:23:43] express its continued objection [1:23:46] regarding public power. [1:23:47] We have met with the proponents [1:23:49] to express the same concerns to [1:23:51] them. [1:23:52] While we understand the desire [1:23:53] to explore alternative models, [1:23:54] we believe this current [1:23:55] proposal presents too many [1:23:57] unresolved risks. [1:23:58] One lack of consensus This [1:24:00] initiative has come before [1:24:01] the council multiple times and [1:24:04] has struggled to find viable [1:24:04] path forward Demonstrating [1:24:06] the community and leadership [1:24:07] remained deeply divided on this [1:24:09] issue. [1:24:11] Workforce uncertainty The Phase [1:24:12] two report does not provide [1:24:14] the concrete assurances. [1:24:15] >> Thank you. [1:24:16] That does conclude your time. [1:24:21] Mark o'Brien is Good afternoon [1:24:21] Council My name is Mark o'Brien [1:24:23] is political director of [1:24:24] the San Diego and Imperial [1:24:25] County Labor Council. [1:24:26] We're proud to represent over [1:24:26] 100 unions and 200,000 working [1:24:28] families including our brothers [1:24:30] and sisters in ibew 46 five and [1:24:32] we're here standing with them [1:24:34] in efforts to oppose them in [1:24:35] its opposition to this power [1:24:36] company. [1:24:36] We know the struggles of our [1:24:38] members to make it in San Diego [1:24:39] right now and we know that [1:24:40] consumers are paying the same [1:24:41] thing. [1:24:42] But we also know that right now [1:24:43] our city resources are [1:24:44] stretched very, very thin and [1:24:46] now is not the time to risk [1:24:47] those limited resources on [1:24:50] the utility take. [1:24:50] Workers could lose their [1:24:51] pensions and retirement and [1:24:52] the hard fought benefits. [1:24:54] We stand with the hundreds of [1:24:55] workers that could lose these [1:24:56] benefits. [1:24:56] Please don't gamble with their [1:24:57] jobs. [1:24:58] We have bigger priorities and [1:24:59] we thank you for your support. [1:25:03] >> Thank you. [1:25:03] Thank you. [1:25:07] Britney says hi. [1:25:07] Good afternoon council members. [1:25:08] Thank you so much for the time [1:25:09] to comment on this today. [1:25:11] Like many others here, we have [1:25:13] serious concerns with this [1:25:14] study in particular it doesn't [1:25:17] answer the critical question of [1:25:19] how much will it actually cost [1:25:21] to purchase the assets of [1:25:23] the utility. [1:25:24] First off, the report gives you [1:25:26] a range of between 2 and 2 and [1:25:27] a half and $7.5 billion a huge [1:25:30] range. [1:25:31] The cost to just purchase [1:25:33] the assets is $9.3 billion. [1:25:36] The study also omits some key [1:25:38] costs including the cost to [1:25:41] make our remaining customers [1:25:42] whole. [1:25:43] If the city were to leave [1:25:45] the surrounding cities and [1:25:46] unincorporated county would see [1:25:48] an increase in their rates. [1:25:50] There is precedent that says [1:25:52] that the city would need to [1:25:53] make sure that that does not [1:25:54] happen so there would be an [1:25:55] exit fee of billions of dollars [1:25:56] . [1:25:58] Finally the city this study [1:26:00] also isn't including [1:26:01] the significant wildfire risk [1:26:03] that is part of San Diego. [1:26:05] It doesn't include [1:26:06] the insurance costs or [1:26:07] mitigation. [1:26:08] Thank you very much. [1:26:10] Thank you. [1:26:12] Next speaker is Brianna Barrow. [1:26:13] >> Good afternoon, council [1:26:13] members. [1:26:16] My name is Brianna Berman and [1:26:18] local business owner and I also [1:26:19] run a local nonprofit. [1:26:20] So public power MAY be a good [1:26:22] idea and it MAY also be a [1:26:24] costly idea. [1:26:24] Both things can be true. [1:26:26] My concern is not about [1:26:27] protecting one institution over [1:26:28] the other. [1:26:29] My concern is about [1:26:29] workability, accountability and [1:26:31] integrity. [1:26:32] If the city is going to pursue [1:26:33] a public power model, [1:26:34] the process must be [1:26:34] transparent. [1:26:36] The numbers must be complete [1:26:37] and the public must understand [1:26:39] exactly what they're being [1:26:40] asked to carry as a ratepayer I [1:26:42] want relief as a taxpayer. [1:26:44] I want responsibility as a [1:26:45] contractor. [1:26:45] I want fair opportunity as a [1:26:47] community centered business [1:26:48] owner. [1:26:48] I want solutions that did not [1:26:50] leave the people with the least [1:26:52] margin carrying the most risk [1:26:54] at this time without a clear [1:26:55] and definitive understanding of [1:26:56] the full cost, the risk and [1:26:58] the impact on city communities [1:27:00] I cannot support moving forward [1:27:01] with the municipal ization and [1:27:02] I ask that you do not either. [1:27:04] Thank you. [1:27:05] Thank you. [1:27:07] Bill Powers While Bill [1:27:09] approaches the microphone could [1:27:11] I have Mike Miller okay all [1:27:15] the Monday Neil Winter John [1:27:18] Mattis and Barbara Pinto [1:27:21] approach the front row please [1:27:23] begin Bill Powers Board Member, [1:27:26] Public Power San Diego I'll [1:27:28] start with Labor. [1:27:29] The veteran utility workers [1:27:31] will be key to the new [1:27:32] utility's credibility Labor [1:27:34] does need to have a seat on [1:27:35] the utilities governing board. [1:27:37] Labor also needs to be a part [1:27:39] of the blue ribbon panel that [1:27:40] selects the critical initial [1:27:41] governing board with the die [1:27:43] gets cast. [1:27:45] New Jersey's first public power [1:27:47] study for the city was in 2020. [1:27:49] That study only looked at [1:27:50] distribution a distribution [1:27:51] only utility low voltage. [1:27:53] It did not look at transmission [1:27:54] and distribution phase one and [1:27:57] phase two that only at&t at&t [1:28:00] utility would be completely [1:28:01] contained within the city's [1:28:02] boundaries. [1:28:04] Crossing jurisdictional [1:28:05] boundaries would trigger Lasko [1:28:06] review that would occur six [1:28:08] years to the implementation [1:28:09] schedule That would be a [1:28:11] momentum killer for public [1:28:13] power. [1:28:13] In San Diego we obtained a [1:28:16] Phase two financial model [1:28:17] through a Public Records Act [1:28:18] request New Dennis set [1:28:20] the model up so you can click a [1:28:22] button and look at a [1:28:22] distribution only structure. [1:28:24] >> There is no more work to do [1:28:25] to assess distribution. [1:28:27] >> That is the way to go. [1:28:28] Thank you. [1:28:29] Thank you. [1:28:31] Next speakers allegedly Audra [1:28:42] Yeah so I mean as dg any roms [1:28:45] Peter to pay Paul but so do you [1:28:47] guys and so that's what's [1:28:49] concerning about this going [1:28:50] into your hands especially when [1:28:52] you talk about savings and that [1:28:54] not really being feasible of [1:28:55] course not because sd g and e [1:28:58] is aggressively opposed to you [1:29:01] guys doing this So this will [1:29:02] end up in litigation So it will [1:29:05] cost the people more than [1:29:07] the billions of dollars that [1:29:08] you are you know, talking about [1:29:10] here And I mean with the storm [1:29:12] infrastructure needing $5 [1:29:13] billion, it's like how many [1:29:15] billions of dollars do you guys [1:29:17] need in order to provide [1:29:19] the things? [1:29:19] But again, you can't be trusted [1:29:21] with this type of thing when [1:29:22] you are not good stewards of [1:29:25] our money and when this is [1:29:26] going to be something that is [1:29:28] San Diego community power is [1:29:30] engaged with when they're [1:29:31] talking about keeping data [1:29:33] centers on and having [1:29:34] the public in the community not [1:29:37] have power during that time [1:29:38] that is extremely egregious and [1:29:40] people need to pay attention to [1:29:41] that because there's meetings [1:29:42] that are talking about it. [1:29:43] >> Thank you. [1:29:46] Next speaker is Mike Miller. [1:29:52] >> Good afternoon counsel. [1:29:55] The more we learn about Jionni [1:29:57] the more appalled I am at [1:29:57] the amount of corporate greed [1:29:58] that goes on that organization. [1:30:00] Their average profit for [1:30:02] the last four years is over [1:30:04] $800 million and their parent [1:30:06] company also spends nearly $300 [1:30:08] million annually in campaign [1:30:10] donations and lobbying and [1:30:12] counting on $2,000 to Donald [1:30:13] Trump's inauguration last year [1:30:14] . [1:30:17] Obviously there are a lot of [1:30:19] questions and things that need [1:30:20] to be figured out before this [1:30:21] goes into place and it's [1:30:24] obviously an informational item [1:30:25] and I'm grateful you're taking [1:30:27] the time to consider it and I [1:30:28] hope that you consider to look [1:30:30] at it more because personally I [1:30:33] just can't imagine what I would [1:30:34] do with an excess amount of [1:30:37] even $1 million every year And [1:30:38] I'm sure there's a better way [1:30:39] that we can find to use that [1:30:42] money to help the people of San [1:30:43] Diego. [1:30:43] >> Thank you. [1:30:47] Thank you. [1:30:48] Gail via Marty Well Gail comes [1:30:50] to the microphone. [1:30:52] You do have time ceded to you [1:30:54] by Neil Winter. [1:30:56] Neil can you raise your hand? [1:30:57] Okay. [1:30:57] Thank you. [1:30:58] You will have two minutes. [1:30:59] Thank you. [1:31:00] My name is Gail b one time a [1:31:02] proud resident of District nine [1:31:03] and I'm also the chair of [1:31:05] the board of directors of [1:31:06] Public Power San Diego. [1:31:07] And I'd like to make an [1:31:09] important distinction here. [1:31:11] There's a difference between a [1:31:14] nonprofit public utility versus [1:31:16] a for profit investor owned [1:31:18] utility. [1:31:18] And the definition of municipal [1:31:23] as a nonprofit public utility [1:31:24] does not have to be quote run [1:31:26] by the city. [1:31:27] So you can all kind of public [1:31:29] thank GOD because there are [1:31:33] challenges but there are cities [1:31:36] this has been something that [1:31:37] has been done for 100 years. [1:31:39] All right. [1:31:40] And it's been done in over 40 [1:31:43] cities in California including [1:31:46] Sacramento, by the way they do [1:31:49] it And on the average they have [1:31:51] half the rates we do And better [1:31:54] reliability. [1:31:55] So I think that's one key [1:31:57] point. [1:31:57] I just like to leave you with [1:31:59] the other point is our union [1:32:01] brothers and sisters, they [1:32:03] deserve to have certainly their [1:32:05] benefits, their compensation, [1:32:07] their seniority, all of that [1:32:09] protected. [1:32:09] I don't think that was really [1:32:11] part of the study. [1:32:12] I mean I don't think it was [1:32:15] meant to be part of the study [1:32:16] but that's certainly part of [1:32:18] any conversation I have [1:32:20] personally been involved with. [1:32:22] They talked about the possible [1:32:24] future of a nonprofit utility. [1:32:26] In fact, public utilities have [1:32:28] 80 to 90% unionization rate [1:32:31] whereas private utilities have [1:32:34] I guess what, a 30% [1:32:37] unionization rate. [1:32:38] All right. [1:32:40] So there's a really big [1:32:41] difference. [1:32:41] So the unions would benefit And [1:32:43] I know that you know you have a [1:32:45] contract with sd g and that [1:32:47] precludes certain conversations [1:32:49] but you would benefit union [1:32:53] members would benefit both in [1:32:55] terms of their families and [1:32:56] their immediate costs and in [1:32:58] terms of their status. [1:32:59] No one is looking to change any [1:33:02] of that. [1:33:02] Thank you very much. [1:33:03] Thank you. [1:33:05] John Madison. [1:33:07] Next, while John approaches [1:33:09] the microphone, I would ask [1:33:10] that Patricia Mendoza [1:33:19] the ferryman, Adriana Cizik and [1:33:21] Kevin Machado please approach [1:33:23] the front row please me. [1:33:27] >> John matters here. [1:33:27] I'm here on the reality of [1:33:30] the crisis facing the city of [1:33:33] San Diego. [1:33:33] Proudly you took the first step [1:33:36] in a path forward. [1:33:38] The crisis is one quarter of [1:33:41] the people here in this city [1:33:43] can't afford their bills. [1:33:45] Wants to month they can't pay. [1:33:50] If you ask the question why [1:33:51] can't they? [1:33:52] Is it because they have [1:33:53] the highest rates in the state? [1:33:55] Is it because they want another [1:33:57] 8% rate increase? [1:34:00] That's the reality. [1:34:02] We have a powerful quote. [1:34:04] We have a plan. [1:34:06] We have a plan that saves your [1:34:09] constituents tens of thousands [1:34:11] of dollars. [1:34:13] Help us get out of this crisis [1:34:16] of unaffordability of a key [1:34:19] component of our life here in [1:34:21] San Diego. [1:34:21] And that is our outrageous g&a [1:34:23] rate. [1:34:25] >> Thank you. [1:34:26] Thank you. [1:34:28] >> Barbara Pinto. [1:34:31] Barbara, you do have time ceded [1:34:36] to you by Isidora Lopez Magali. [1:34:38] Can you raise your hand please? [1:34:39] Thank you. [1:34:40] And an okay. [1:34:44] Ana Thank you. [1:34:44] You have three minutes. [1:34:45] Thank you. [1:34:46] Good afternoon. [1:34:48] My name is Barbara Pinto and [1:34:50] I'm a resident of San Diego, [1:34:51] the District 11 Loganathan and [1:34:54] a member of eighth. [1:34:55] I have been a resident since [1:34:58] the 40s in San Diego and [1:35:01] selling gas and electric has [1:35:03] been our only utility company [1:35:04] So it is a monopoly on [1:35:07] utilities provided since then [1:35:09] and before Sandy Again we are [1:35:11] paying the highest prices for [1:35:14] homes rent, gas, food and [1:35:18] utilities more almost than [1:35:20] anyone in the nation. [1:35:21] Our utility provider dictates [1:35:24] cost increases services and [1:35:27] sets no limit on their profits. [1:35:29] Last year they made a whopping [1:35:35] $563 million in profits and [1:35:37] that figure was roughly one [1:35:39] third lower than it was [1:35:40] the previous year. [1:35:41] I'm a senior citizen living on [1:35:44] a fixed income of Social [1:35:46] Security and a modest [1:35:47] retirement. [1:35:48] I went back to work around 2018 [1:35:51] to keep up with the cost of [1:35:54] living and inflation. [1:35:55] i lost my job due to covid. [1:36:02] In 2021 I prioritize my rent [1:36:02] and I got behind in my water my [1:36:04] utility. [1:36:05] My current utility bill is over [1:36:06] $3,500. [1:36:09] I enlisted in a debt [1:36:11] forgiveness program and said [1:36:14] they would work with me to [1:36:15] forgive part of my debt. [1:36:16] I agreed to pay $111 a month [1:36:19] for 12 consecutive months but [1:36:23] that cost changes according to [1:36:26] my everyday usage. [1:36:28] I wasn't told that the average [1:36:31] monthly cost now is about $140 [1:36:33] a month. [1:36:33] This is difficult when you're [1:36:35] on a fixed income and you're [1:36:37] trying to do a budget. [1:36:38] Why is there no limit on what [1:36:41] these companies can make in [1:36:43] profits? [1:36:43] Even with my return to work I [1:36:47] am struggling. [1:36:48] We need services offered at [1:36:51] more affordable rates. [1:36:53] We need more competitive [1:36:55] companies putting people before [1:36:58] profits. [1:36:58] Thank you. [1:36:59] >> Thank you. [1:37:03] Next speaker is Patricia [1:37:04] Mendoza. [1:37:05] >> Hi, my name is Patrick and [1:37:12] I'm a member of Ace Energy as a [1:37:15] basic necessity that every [1:37:16] family depends on. [1:37:17] We need it to cook continue to [1:37:20] cut meals, keep the lights on [1:37:21] after dark, wash close to our [1:37:23] children and have clean clothes [1:37:24] to wear. [1:37:25] Yet these high utility rates [1:37:27] make everyday activities a [1:37:29] source of stress, often forcing [1:37:31] families to make difficult [1:37:32] choices about the bills to pay [1:37:34] and which bills to put off. [1:37:36] It is especially troubling now [1:37:37] that summer's here it's going [1:37:39] to be more hot. [1:37:40] People can't afford air [1:37:41] conditioner. [1:37:41] It's going to get colder [1:37:43] weather outside. [1:37:44] People can't afford adequate [1:37:47] heating. [1:37:48] But right now I also want to [1:37:50] acknowledge all our brothers [1:37:51] and sisters here in our union [1:37:54] brothers and sisters here I [1:37:55] heard it and I had another [1:37:56] speech written But I want to [1:37:58] hear you guys to I want to put [1:38:00] their voice out there too [1:38:01] because we need public power. [1:38:03] We really do. [1:38:04] But it concerns on your [1:38:07] concerns about job security. [1:38:08] We do need public power and we [1:38:11] need it not at the expense of [1:38:12] other working class people, [1:38:13] other working class jobs. [1:38:15] Thank you. [1:38:15] That does conclude your time. [1:38:16] >> We can work together. [1:38:19] We can Women I'm working. [1:38:21] We can work together. [1:38:22] We can work together. [1:38:22] We're still talking about So [1:38:25] they make their man work [1:38:26] together to make this [1:38:26] transition good. [1:38:26] Okay. [1:38:29] All all right. [1:38:38] >> She set the tone. [1:38:39] We're not going to do that [1:38:40] again. [1:38:40] Okay? [1:38:41] We're going to keep this [1:38:41] simple. [1:38:42] You guys have been fantastic. [1:38:43] So I'm passionate on both [1:38:45] sides. [1:38:46] I've been clear and unambiguous [1:38:48] but let's have a good civil [1:38:52] dialog Now you have three [1:38:53] people sitting your time When I [1:38:55] call your name please raise [1:38:56] your hand to confirm your year [1:39:01] And above all is honor. [1:39:07] Thank you Gary Carter. [1:39:08] Gary Clark. [1:39:08] Corey of Corey. [1:39:09] Sorry. [1:39:09] Thank you. [1:39:10] Oscar Gomez Junior. [1:39:11] Thank you. [1:39:14] Your four minutes please begin. [1:39:15] Good afternoon, Council members [1:39:17] and city staff. [1:39:18] My name is Nate Berryman, [1:39:19] business manager of [1:39:20] the International Brotherhood [1:39:21] of Electrical Workers Local [1:39:22] Union for 65 I represent 2900 [1:39:26] union utility workers here in [1:39:27] San Diego and several counties. [1:39:28] And look, I know why we're [1:39:31] really here. [1:39:31] People are not happy with [1:39:34] energy. [1:39:34] They're not happy with their [1:39:35] rates or their skyrocketing [1:39:37] profits. [1:39:38] People are mad at the never [1:39:39] ending corporate profits that [1:39:40] are pulled from our pockets and [1:39:42] funneled to separate [1:39:43] shareholders And to be 100% [1:39:45] honest my members are meant to [1:39:47] Our members have more in common [1:39:49] with you in this room than [1:39:50] utility CEOs or executives. [1:39:52] Working class people are [1:39:54] struggling. [1:39:54] They're struggling to get by [1:39:56] and something needs to be done [1:39:57] to provide support. [1:39:58] But I promise you brothers and [1:40:00] sisters, this ain't it. [1:40:02] Our union and our members share [1:40:03] a mutual interest in the city's [1:40:05] success and the success of our [1:40:06] communities success of our [1:40:08] mayor, our council and [1:40:10] the utility who's delivering [1:40:11] these essential services to San [1:40:14] Diego's municipal division is [1:40:15] bad for everyone. [1:40:16] It will not solve for [1:40:18] affordability. [1:40:19] It will destroy our union [1:40:20] contracts and force layoffs of [1:40:22] union workers. [1:40:23] Each phase of the new study [1:40:24] continues to diminish or ignore [1:40:26] addressing worker protections [1:40:27] and safety the fire risk and [1:40:29] liability the city would assume [1:40:31] under urban exploitation and [1:40:33] the occurred that the city [1:40:34] would force to be take on with [1:40:36] this effort High voltage [1:40:37] infrastructure demand [1:40:38] significant investment and [1:40:40] the operating continue [1:40:42] The operating costs continue to [1:40:43] be significantly [1:40:43] underestimated. [1:40:45] There's no guarantee that [1:40:46] the infrastructure the city [1:40:47] purchases will be maintained [1:40:48] sufficiently To keep my members [1:40:50] safe I was in these chambers [1:40:52] just weeks ago when you were [1:40:53] debating closing public [1:40:54] bathrooms in order to close a [1:40:56] $175 million budget deficit. [1:40:59] What happens when you have a [1:41:01] budget deficit but now you run [1:41:02] the power company. [1:41:03] You can't just shut down a [1:41:05] substation. [1:41:05] You can't just turn the lights [1:41:06] off to save money or limit [1:41:08] the hours that you provide. [1:41:09] Electric service like the grid [1:41:11] is a public library You can't [1:41:13] balance the budget by robbing [1:41:14] resources from grid maintenance [1:41:16] or pole replacement. [1:41:17] If you do that you might have [1:41:18] mass outages, blackouts and [1:41:20] wildfires. [1:41:21] So where's the real cost [1:41:22] associated with the fire risk [1:41:24] and liability? [1:41:25] Where's the real numbers on [1:41:26] the billions dollars of debt [1:41:27] the city and our taxpayers will [1:41:29] carry for decades? [1:41:31] Each phase of the Nugent study [1:41:32] has not provided you or our [1:41:34] taxpayers with an accurate [1:41:36] picture of that risk of [1:41:38] the cost of the liability and [1:41:40] the risk the city will be [1:41:41] undertaking to municipal lies. [1:41:44] It's a lot It's $9 billion, $9 [1:41:47] billion at a time where [1:41:48] the city is laying off workers [1:41:51] when the city is closing [1:41:52] bathrooms, the city is [1:41:54] defunding the bomb squad and [1:41:56] relying on donations to keep [1:41:57] your arts programs alive. [1:41:59] You just cut $7 million from [1:42:01] your own Climate Action Fund. [1:42:03] You don't have the money You [1:42:05] don't have the resources and [1:42:07] you don't have the expertise. [1:42:08] So we're asking you to please [1:42:10] not do this. [1:42:12] But I will end with this If [1:42:15] city genie doesn't offer [1:42:16] immediate rate relief to our [1:42:18] communities most at need, we [1:42:22] will be back here having [1:42:23] the same presentation with [1:42:25] the same advocacy and the same [1:42:26] level of frustration [1:42:28] The utility affordability [1:42:29] crisis isn't going away until [1:42:32] we sit down with honesty and [1:42:33] empathy for our communities [1:42:35] that are struggling. [1:42:36] I fear the cycle will continue [1:42:39] and the ibew stands ready and [1:42:40] willing to have that [1:42:41] conversation. [1:42:43] >> Thank you very much. [1:42:47] Thank you and Speaker lady And [1:42:51] if you think you could approach [1:42:51] the microphone, you have [1:42:54] several speakers seating time [1:42:55] to you. [1:42:56] Matthew Pendergrast, thank you [1:43:00] Randall and Driver thank you. [1:43:10] As an uncommon husband no, no. [1:43:10] Okay. [1:43:11] You will have a total of three [1:43:13] minutes then. [1:43:15] Okay. [1:43:16] Thank you so much for having [1:43:17] me. [1:43:17] I'm DR. Adrian Cusick. [1:43:19] I live in District three. [1:43:20] I served in the us Peace Corps [1:43:21] and I'm a member of cfa which [1:43:23] is a California faculty [1:43:24] association. [1:43:26] I teach environmental science [1:43:27] and sustainability sdsu My [1:43:29] students are bright, they're [1:43:31] motivated, they're innovative. [1:43:33] They get out there and gain [1:43:34] work experience. [1:43:35] Unfortunately they're learning [1:43:37] about the injustices that are [1:43:39] deeply embedded in our systems [1:43:41] and structures. [1:43:42] The sad reality that a utility [1:43:44] company is a monopoly [1:43:45] extracting wealth from [1:43:47] the community to transfer it to [1:43:49] its already wealthy CEOs and [1:43:51] shareholders is an example of [1:43:53] environmental and social [1:43:55] injustices that we've been [1:43:56] forced to live with This system [1:43:59] under the investor owned [1:44:00] utility makes life harder for [1:44:01] the average than Diegan and it [1:44:03] stifles innovation and [1:44:05] progress. [1:44:06] But there's a better way. [1:44:08] The Phase two public power [1:44:09] study clearly demonstrates that [1:44:11] it's financially, technically [1:44:12] and operationally feasible to [1:44:14] transition to a nonprofit [1:44:16] publicly owned utility. [1:44:18] The study focused on different [1:44:19] variations on one specific [1:44:22] scenario for acquiring [1:44:23] the grid. [1:44:24] It demonstrated that public [1:44:25] power will work in San Diego. [1:44:27] And it also demonstrated that [1:44:29] public power will be good for [1:44:31] San Diegans not only [1:44:32] financially but public power [1:44:34] would turn decision making over [1:44:35] to us the people who live here [1:44:37] and are impacted by local [1:44:39] energy decisions not [1:44:40] shareholders who probably [1:44:42] couldn't care less about [1:44:43] the struggles of everyday San [1:44:47] Diego's public power have been [1:44:47] successful in other cities So [1:44:48] it makes sense It would be [1:44:50] successful here where we pay [1:44:51] the highest electricity rates [1:44:53] in the continental United [1:44:54] States. [1:44:55] It's important to remember that [1:44:56] the phase two study is a [1:44:58] baseline and it shows that it's [1:45:00] possible We don't need to have [1:45:02] every single technical detail [1:45:03] worked out right now. [1:45:04] But what we do need to do is [1:45:06] commit to making action to [1:45:08] making it happen. [1:45:10] As local owners of the grid we [1:45:11] can determine what works best [1:45:13] for us. [1:45:14] We can ensure that Labor [1:45:15] remains whole and has agreement [1:45:17] agreements to ensure that [1:45:19] people operating the system are [1:45:21] involved in the decisions that [1:45:22] impact them. [1:45:23] We can tailor the scale of [1:45:24] the infrastructure and we can [1:45:26] explore different different [1:45:27] governance models. [1:45:29] We can trade the status quo for [1:45:31] low energy costs and local [1:45:33] control. [1:45:33] Imagine what that would do for [1:45:35] our city. [1:45:36] Lower energy costs are key to [1:45:37] economic growth Cutting [1:45:38] emissions, reducing [1:45:40] inequalities and spurring [1:45:41] innovation. [1:45:43] So once we're out from under [1:45:45] the thumb of Sempra we could be [1:45:46] a model of community [1:45:47] resilience. [1:45:48] We could have virtual power [1:45:50] plants bi directional charging, [1:45:52] microgrids, agile and proactive [1:45:54] technology to mitigate growing [1:45:56] climate risks. [1:45:57] We could decide if and where [1:45:59] data centers enter our city. [1:46:01] Ultimately we have the power [1:46:03] now to commit to transitioning [1:46:05] to public power. [1:46:06] And when we do, every aspect of [1:46:08] that transition will be under [1:46:10] our local control. [1:46:11] And like my students, we have [1:46:13] the imagination, the creativity [1:46:16] to create something really [1:46:18] wonderful that can serve us [1:46:19] all. [1:46:24] >> Thank you for your comments. [1:46:25] That does conclude your time. [1:46:25] Next speaker is Kevin Machado [1:46:25] or Kevin approaches [1:46:26] the microphone. [1:46:27] I would ask Will Smith, Kevin [1:46:30] Zavala Rachel Kiss Lane Range [1:46:31] shot Sharon. [1:46:40] Sorry if I said that in part [1:46:42] Troutman too. [1:46:42] Please come to the front row. [1:46:44] Kevin please begin. [1:46:45] Hello, my name is Kevin and I'm [1:46:47] a worker here in San Diego. [1:46:49] Working family The San Diego [1:46:50] are tired of the cost of living [1:46:51] going up as the union has [1:46:53] consistently raised rates in [1:46:54] the past decade as the union [1:46:56] has raised rates on average 7% [1:46:58] per year. [1:46:59] They're taking $1 billion from [1:47:00] us every year and doing nothing [1:47:02] for our communities. [1:47:03] That money could go to San [1:47:04] Diego schools and the library [1:47:05] San Diego workers and San Diego [1:47:07] infrastructure as the union [1:47:10] wants more more money for their [1:47:10] owners And Wall Street at [1:47:13] the city's profits this quarter [1:47:14] is $290 million and they're [1:47:17] likely to break a million in [1:47:18] profit this year. [1:47:18] And regardless of that, they [1:47:20] still are proposing another [1:47:21] $280 million more every year. [1:47:24] If we don't act now, another [1:47:26] decade will pass and San Diego [1:47:27] will still be struggling with [1:47:29] the cost of living. [1:47:30] We have the opportunity to [1:47:31] change that now la Power will [1:47:33] lower the cost of electricity [1:47:34] for generations. [1:47:35] The feasibility study will will [1:47:37] save money. [1:47:38] It will work here. [1:47:39] It's worked everywhere else [1:47:40] They've tried it. [1:47:43] The minimum the minimum [1:47:43] position in Sacramento has been [1:47:44] complete success. [1:47:45] They pay half of what we're [1:47:46] paying the council to be brave [1:47:48] and act And I thank you for [1:47:49] your time. [1:47:50] Thank you. [1:47:52] Well Smith you do have indoor [1:47:56] seating your time. [1:47:57] Andrew, could you raise your [1:47:58] hand, please? [1:47:59] Thank you. [1:48:00] You'll have two minutes. [1:48:01] Good afternoon, Council. [1:48:03] My name is Will and I live in [1:48:04] District five. [1:48:05] Over the last few years I have [1:48:07] moved around San Diego several [1:48:08] times. [1:48:09] Every neighborhood has been [1:48:10] different but in each one of [1:48:12] them life keeps getting more [1:48:13] expensive. [1:48:14] Like many people in my [1:48:15] generation I already worry [1:48:16] about the cost of rent, [1:48:18] groceries, gas and health care. [1:48:21] But when bills used to go up no [1:48:22] matter what I do. [1:48:23] Electricity. [1:48:24] Recently I was fortunate enough [1:48:26] to move somewhere with solar [1:48:27] panels. [1:48:28] I thought I would finally get [1:48:29] some relief. [1:48:30] Instead I watched as Jeannie [1:48:32] continued to make decisions [1:48:33] that made it harder for [1:48:34] ordinary people to lower their [1:48:36] bills. [1:48:37] It feels like no matter what we [1:48:38] do the system is designed so [1:48:40] that the shareholders win. [1:48:41] And working families pay [1:48:43] the price. [1:48:44] We don't want to keep having to [1:48:45] choose between keeping our [1:48:46] lights on and putting food on [1:48:48] the table. [1:48:50] Beyond affordability, I've also [1:48:51] seen the consequences of [1:48:53] failure to properly maintain [1:48:54] its infrastructure. [1:48:55] Wildfires fueled by neglected [1:48:57] infrastructure threaten our [1:48:58] communities, our environment [1:48:59] and the places that make San [1:49:00] Diego special. [1:49:02] I want future generations to be [1:49:03] able to enjoy our parks, open [1:49:05] spaces and beaches without [1:49:06] being under the constant threat [1:49:08] of very preventable disasters. [1:49:10] That is why I am here today in [1:49:11] support of public power. [1:49:13] I want a utility that answers [1:49:14] to the people of San Diego not [1:49:15] investors. [1:49:16] I want money we spend on [1:49:18] electricity to stay in our [1:49:19] community and be invested in [1:49:20] reliability, clean energy and [1:49:22] affordability. [1:49:23] Most of all, I want future [1:49:24] generations of San Diego owners [1:49:25] to be able to afford to live in [1:49:26] the city they call home. [1:49:28] Council These issues affect [1:49:30] real people, real families and [1:49:32] real voters. [1:49:33] Today you have a choice Stand [1:49:35] with San Diego and struggling [1:49:36] to afford an essential service [1:49:38] or stand with a monopoly that [1:49:40] continues to raise rates while [1:49:41] posting record profits off [1:49:43] the backs of working class [1:49:44] families. [1:49:45] The voters of the city will [1:49:46] remember that choice. [1:49:48] I urge you to move forward with [1:49:49] sd Public Power. [1:49:50] >> Thank you. [1:49:52] Thank you. [1:49:52] Kevin Zavala. [1:49:56] >> You have time ceded to you [1:49:57] by Robert Freedman Could you [1:49:59] raise your hand please? [1:49:59] >> Thank you. [1:50:00] You'll have two minutes. [1:50:02] Good afternoon. [1:50:03] My name is Kevin Zavala, Marine [1:50:05] Corps veteran and a District [1:50:06] four constituent. [1:50:07] Over the last decade, genius [1:50:09] driven electricity rates up by [1:50:11] more than 80% far outpacing [1:50:13] inflation and leaving San Diego [1:50:14] residents with the same with [1:50:16] some of the highest utility [1:50:17] bills in the nation. [1:50:18] We're told these increases are [1:50:19] unavoidable but what are [1:50:20] the facts? [1:50:21] After the devastating 2007 San [1:50:23] Diego wildfires, the us Supreme [1:50:25] Court ruled that the genie [1:50:27] could not pass $379 million in [1:50:29] fire related litigation costs [1:50:31] to ratepayers because [1:50:32] the damage was caused by [1:50:33] the utility's poor maintained [1:50:34] equipment. [1:50:35] Shareholders, not customers [1:50:36] were required to bear those [1:50:38] costs. [1:50:38] However, Genie later exploited [1:50:40] a legal loophole while barred [1:50:42] from charging customers for [1:50:43] past damages. [1:50:44] The company successfully [1:50:45] shifted 100% of its ongoing [1:50:47] wildfire mitigation and [1:50:48] infrastructure hardening costs [1:50:49] onto ratepayers. [1:50:50] As a result, customers are [1:50:52] paying billions to repair and [1:50:54] upgrade infrastructure that [1:50:55] the utility neglected for [1:50:56] years. [1:50:57] This is the consequence of a [1:50:58] private monopoly accountable to [1:51:00] investors rather than [1:51:01] the public it serves. [1:51:02] In response, public power San [1:51:04] Diego is working to establish a [1:51:05] publicly owned utility that [1:51:07] will prioritize affordability, [1:51:08] transparency and local control. [1:51:10] Public records show sgi has [1:51:12] spent millions on lobbying and [1:51:14] political influence efforts to [1:51:15] block public power proposals [1:51:17] and protect its monopoly. [1:51:18] The choice is clear continue [1:51:20] accepting more rate hikes or [1:51:22] support a public power future [1:51:23] that puts the people first. [1:51:24] >> Thank you Rachel Kiss. [1:51:29] You have time ceded to you by [1:51:32] Dale Holmberg. [1:51:32] Thank you. [1:51:34] Good afternoon. [1:51:35] My name is Rachel Kiss. [1:51:36] I'm a San Diego resident, a [1:51:38] mother of three young children, [1:51:39] a homeowner and a small [1:51:41] business owner. [1:51:41] Like many families, we've made [1:51:43] sacrifices over the last few [1:51:44] years as the cost of living [1:51:46] continues to rise. [1:51:47] We budget carefully. [1:51:48] We compare prices. [1:51:50] We make difficult decisions [1:51:51] about where our money goes. [1:51:52] What's frustrating is that [1:51:54] while families are expected to [1:51:55] tighten their belts as Jeannie [1:51:57] continues to come back asking [1:51:59] for more, how much is enough? [1:52:02] Electricity is not a luxury. [1:52:04] It's a necessity. [1:52:05] Families need to keep food cold [1:52:07] home safe and children [1:52:08] comfortable. [1:52:09] Small businesses need to [1:52:10] survive. [1:52:11] Yet we're paying some of [1:52:12] the highest energy rates in [1:52:13] the country with especially [1:52:15] concerning is that more and [1:52:17] more of these costs are being [1:52:18] shifted into fixed charges. [1:52:19] Whether someone lives in a [1:52:20] small apartment and edu or a [1:52:23] large home whether they can [1:52:24] serve energy or not, they're [1:52:26] being asked to pay more. [1:52:27] Families are being told to use [1:52:29] less energy while [1:52:30] simultaneously being charged [1:52:32] speeds that they cannot [1:52:32] control. [1:52:33] That undermines both [1:52:34] affordability and conservation. [1:52:36] Today isn't just about a [1:52:38] feasibility study. [1:52:39] It's about accountability. [1:52:41] It's about exploring whether [1:52:42] there's a better path forward [1:52:43] that puts residents before [1:52:44] profits. [1:52:46] I'm not here because I have all [1:52:47] the answers. [1:52:47] I'm here because I believe [1:52:48] the people of San Diego deserve [1:52:50] leaders who are willing to ask [1:52:52] hard questions and seriously [1:52:53] explore alternatives. [1:52:55] When sd Jenny asks for another [1:52:57] increase it's a line item on a [1:52:59] spreadsheet. [1:52:59] For families it's groceries, [1:53:01] kids activities, savings and a [1:53:04] peace of mind. [1:53:05] Those costs are real and we're [1:53:06] feeling them. [1:53:07] Please seriously evaluate every [1:53:09] option available to bring [1:53:11] affordability, transparency and [1:53:13] accountability back to our [1:53:14] energy system. [1:53:14] And please remember that behind [1:53:16] every rate increase is a family [1:53:18] trying to make their budget [1:53:19] work. [1:53:19] Thank you for your time. [1:53:21] Thank you. [1:53:22] Lane Sharman. [1:53:25] When you have time ceded to you [1:53:28] by Katherine Harrison and [1:53:29] Katherine, raise your hand. [1:53:30] Thank you. [1:53:30] You'll have two minutes. [1:53:38] Good afternoon, counsel. [1:53:39] My name is Lane Sharman. [1:53:41] I'm a fifth generation [1:53:43] Californian and I'm also [1:53:44] the proud founder and initiator [1:53:46] of community choice aggregation [1:53:48] in San Diego along with Bill [1:53:50] Powers. [1:53:51] We have public power in San [1:53:53] Diego, don't we? [1:53:55] We've had it since the Smart [1:53:57] Energy Alliance was founded by [1:53:59] Lisa hepner, your colleague. [1:54:00] She did that because it was [1:54:03] good for the city of Solana [1:54:05] Beach. [1:54:06] That tiny little city up north [1:54:06] . [1:54:09] >> And why was it good for it? [1:54:11] Because San Diego gas and [1:54:13] electric then as now was taking [1:54:16] advantage of every single [1:54:19] ratepayer then and now. [1:54:21] And I am asking you to please [1:54:24] look at the big picture here. [1:54:26] Your legacy, your future, your [1:54:30] ability to lead and do what's [1:54:33] good for this city is before [1:54:36] you. [1:54:36] And even though there is so [1:54:39] much opposition, much of it is [1:54:43] just fear. [1:54:44] It is. [1:54:45] And we all fear is the only [1:54:48] thing that we have to fear [1:54:50] right now. [1:54:50] This is going to be great for [1:54:53] unions. [1:54:53] It's going to be great for [1:54:55] the people of San Diego. [1:54:56] It's going to be good for our [1:54:59] future. [1:55:00] So I just beg you to do what [1:55:04] Lisa Huebner did in 2016. [1:55:07] She wrote why it was good and [1:55:11] she published it. [1:55:12] Each one of you could do that [1:55:14] and it would be an amazing way [1:55:17] of clearly stating why this is [1:55:20] good for San Diego because you [1:55:22] will work through all of [1:55:23] the issues including the fears [1:55:25] and I just want to thank each [1:55:28] and every one of you who takes [1:55:29] that action and and dedicates [1:55:33] themselves to the future of San [1:55:35] Diego. [1:55:35] Thank you. [1:55:37] >> Thank you. [1:55:39] Next speaker is Pak Troutman. [1:55:42] While you approach [1:55:43] the microphone I would ask that [1:55:44] James Ferguson Diego Sandoval, [1:55:47] Tyler Andre, Isaiah Glass and [1:55:51] Allison Miller please approach [1:55:53] the front row park. [1:55:55] You have five people sitting [1:55:57] time to you. [1:56:00] Angela Haynes Thank you. [1:56:01] Doris Wynn. [1:56:03] Thank you. [1:56:05] Michael Brack Me. [1:56:07] Thank you. [1:56:09] Janet o'Dea Thank you. [1:56:12] Five minutes please. [1:56:13] Please begin. [1:56:14] Thank you. [1:56:15] Good afternoon, Council members [1:56:17] and Council PRESIDENT My name [1:56:19] is Park Troutman. [1:56:20] I am with San Diego 350 Well, I [1:56:23] want to talk about is San Diego [1:56:25] Gas Electric general rate case [1:56:27] that was filed last week. [1:56:29] The general rate case is a huge [1:56:31] filing in which investor owned [1:56:33] utility tries to convince [1:56:35] the California Public Utilities [1:56:37] Commission that they should be [1:56:39] allowed to raise their rates [1:56:40] over a four year block for 2028 [1:56:43] the first year of the 40 years [1:56:46] of the rate increase request. [1:56:51] As the genie asked permission [1:56:52] to raise the residential [1:56:54] electricity rates by about $14 [1:56:56] per month which is a little bit [1:56:58] more than 7% and [1:57:00] the residential gas rates by a [1:57:03] little bit less than 850 per [1:57:05] month which is about a 13% [1:57:07] increase. [1:57:08] The California Public Advocacy [1:57:14] Office tracks acg genies rates [1:57:15] versus inflation. [1:57:16] They've done this since 2014. [1:57:17] The cumulative impact of their [1:57:21] increase in their rates more [1:57:22] than inflation is that they [1:57:23] have increased about triple [1:57:25] inflation. [1:57:28] This request for the general [1:57:30] rate increase or the general [1:57:32] rate case which is really [1:57:33] the window into how they're [1:57:34] thinking about the future is [1:57:37] actually a little bit more than [1:57:39] their average request for [1:57:40] the since 2014 and they make a [1:57:44] similar request in 2029 and in [1:57:47] 2030 and 2031 they only request [1:57:51] an increase of 5.5%. [1:57:54] And keep in mind that these [1:57:56] rate increases that are in [1:58:00] the general rate case are [1:58:03] merely the baseline of what [1:58:05] they're asking for. [1:58:07] Increasingly investor owned [1:58:08] utilities are asking for rate [1:58:10] increases outside of [1:58:12] the general rate case so we can [1:58:16] expect that they will keep [1:58:18] continue to ask for more And [1:58:19] these are through their [1:58:20] balancing in memorandum [1:58:22] accounts where they spend money [1:58:23] and then say oh we already [1:58:24] spent this money, could you get [1:58:27] reimbursed by paying or [1:58:29] charging rate payers more? [1:58:31] So this let the audacity and [1:58:34] compulsiveness of this sink in [1:58:36] public anger at investor owned [1:58:39] utilities has begun to affect [1:58:40] the outcomes of elections [1:58:43] nationwide and sd Genie which [1:58:46] in a J.D. Power study excuse me [1:58:50] a brand appeal of utilities in [1:58:52] the Western us that they did [1:58:53] last year sc Genie was 28 out [1:58:57] of 30th near the absolute [1:59:00] bottom because of their high [1:59:01] rates They are so out of touch [1:59:05] they are going to continue They [1:59:06] are continuing to ask for more. [1:59:10] The general rate case request [1:59:13] is higher than the 4% that was [1:59:15] the basis for the consultant's [1:59:19] study and that was the main [1:59:21] assumption for the phase two [1:59:23] feasibility study There are [1:59:23] consultants are constrained by [1:59:25] the need to be reasonable as [1:59:28] the genie apparently does not [1:59:29] feel the same. [1:59:31] This means that when we look at [1:59:34] the impacts of the cumulative [1:59:36] benefits I believe that Slide [1:59:38] 11 we should be concentrating [1:59:40] on the highest bar showing [1:59:42] the highest possible savings [1:59:48] because that is the most [1:59:50] likely. [1:59:50] We know this because Star Genie [1:59:52] is telling us so they are going [1:59:54] to continue to ask So what does [1:59:57] this mean going forward? [2:00:02] I was we are not going to if we [2:00:03] know they're going to continue [2:00:04] to ask for more rate increases. [2:00:06] We're not going to be having [2:00:06] the same conversation. [2:00:08] We're not always coming back [2:00:10] having the exact encounter. [2:00:11] It's going to be worse. [2:00:12] People will be more frustrated, [2:00:13] Rates are going to be higher. [2:00:15] We cannot sit our hands We [2:00:17] cannot say wait to see what [2:00:20] happens in San Francisco And [2:00:22] these are not options. [2:00:23] We need to keep moving forward. [2:00:28] Star Genie The company will not [2:00:29] stop itself. [2:00:30] >> Thank you. [2:00:33] Thank you. [2:00:34] Our next speaker is James [2:00:35] Ferguson. [2:00:37] James, you have Deborah [2:00:39] Winthrop or any time to you [2:00:41] Deborah, can you raise your [2:00:42] hand? [2:00:43] >> Thank you. [2:00:44] Two minutes. [2:00:46] Thank you. [2:00:48] My name is James and I live in [2:00:50] North Park and I have been an [2:00:54] advocate for climate issues and [2:00:55] our energy systems for my [2:00:57] entire adult life which is [2:00:58] actually pretty long. [2:00:59] I went to college in 1975 and [2:01:02] that's where I took [2:01:02] environmental science. [2:01:04] I'm a retired naval officer and [2:01:07] anesthesia provider and this [2:01:09] has been a passion of mine for [2:01:11] that long. [2:01:12] I'm now Senate liaison for [2:01:14] Citizens Climate Lobby and I [2:01:16] must tell you that we're [2:01:17] working on transmission issues [2:01:19] this year with the federal [2:01:21] government And I tell you that [2:01:23] dependency model of early [2:01:25] monopoly electronic electrical [2:01:26] systems no longer serves as [2:01:28] well as electrical demand will [2:01:31] double or triple in the next 20 [2:01:32] years because of data centers [2:01:34] electrification, reshoring of [2:01:36] business etc. Favoring big [2:01:40] distant production and long [2:01:42] wires with cpu c guaranteeing [2:01:45] double digit profits over [2:01:47] whatever costs are incurred And [2:01:52] it doesn't even have to try to [2:01:53] economize. [2:01:56] So they are incentivized to [2:01:58] spend as much as possible [2:01:59] because that's a percent above [2:02:01] the cost that they incur while [2:02:05] lack of profit incentives for [2:02:08] upgrades and maintenance of [2:02:09] the not very lucrative [2:02:10] capacities of the local [2:02:12] distribution grid is a failure [2:02:14] to accommodate local generation [2:02:16] and storage which we could do. [2:02:18] We have a lot of available [2:02:20] storage opportunities and in [2:02:22] solar opportunities. [2:02:23] But an sd Genie technician came [2:02:26] to my house to explain to me [2:02:27] why my 200 hour panel is crying [2:02:30] and it's because he just said [2:02:33] Well there's a lot of solar [2:02:34] systems around here These old [2:02:35] circuits just can't handle it. [2:02:38] So we pay the highest rates in [2:02:40] America in the continental [2:02:42] states two times California [2:02:44] average with three times [2:02:45] the national average. [2:02:47] Thank you. [2:02:48] Thank you. [2:02:50] Next speaker is D.A. Diego [2:02:54] Sandoval. [2:02:55] Do you have time to buy Ben [2:02:56] Owens? [2:02:58] Ben, could you raise your hand? [2:02:59] Thank you. [2:02:59] And Pamela Isaacs, thank you. [2:03:02] You have three minutes. [2:03:03] Please begin. [2:03:04] Thank you. [2:03:05] Good afternoon, City Council. [2:03:07] My name is Diego Sandoval. [2:03:08] I live in District eight and [2:03:09] I'm here today to ask you to [2:03:11] choose public power over [2:03:12] the greed and power hungry [2:03:16] genie as De Genie wants you to [2:03:16] think that there is serious [2:03:17] about what's doing best for our [2:03:19] environment and people when in [2:03:20] reality they're just doing [2:03:22] what's best for their pockets [2:03:23] so much so that they change [2:03:25] the g in their logo to Green. [2:03:28] Now it's green. [2:03:29] How nice is that? [2:03:32] And truth as the genie supports [2:03:32] fighting climate change insofar [2:03:34] as they can profit from it and [2:03:35] households across San Diego are [2:03:37] feeling that every month for a [2:03:39] company committed to net zero [2:03:41] they're still incredibly [2:03:41] enthusiastic about fossil [2:03:43] fuels. [2:03:44] Ac Genie is owned by Sempra [2:03:46] which has invested heavily in [2:03:47] the transportation of what they [2:03:49] euphemistically call natural [2:03:50] gas. [2:03:51] Natural gas is the most highly [2:03:53] potent greenhouse gas methane. [2:03:55] To quote the CHAIRMAN And ceo [2:03:56] of Sempra from last month, they [2:03:59] are very bullish on [2:04:01] the liquefied natural gas trade [2:04:02] long term This is not what you [2:04:05] say when you're serious about [2:04:06] net zero or what's doing best [2:04:08] for the people or the climate [2:04:10] that they depend on for a [2:04:11] livable future. [2:04:12] This corporations mentality of [2:04:14] grasping what every book they [2:04:16] can be seen is can be seen in [2:04:20] their filing for their general [2:04:21] rate case. [2:04:22] They claim that they need to [2:04:23] raise their rates for wildfire [2:04:25] mitigation in the case of [2:04:27] ongoing climate changes. [2:04:29] Yet on the very same page they [2:04:30] also say they want to raise [2:04:31] rates to support [2:04:33] the construction of new gas [2:04:34] facilities. [2:04:35] Does that make sense? [2:04:36] They want us to pay more so [2:04:38] that they can continue [2:04:39] contributing to climate change [2:04:41] then use climate change as [2:04:43] justification for us paying [2:04:45] more as the genie does not care [2:04:47] about people or the environment [2:04:49] they only care about profit not [2:04:51] progress. [2:04:52] San Diego can do better. [2:04:54] This is why I asked for you to [2:04:56] choose public power today but [2:04:57] also to work with our union [2:04:58] brothers and sisters to ensure [2:05:00] that they are considered during [2:05:01] this transition. [2:05:02] To echo the opinions of a [2:05:03] previous speaker we can do this [2:05:05] together. [2:05:05] >> Thank you. [2:05:05] Yeah. [2:05:08] Thank you. [2:05:09] Next speaker is Tyler Andre. [2:05:12] Tyler, you have several [2:05:13] individuals setting your time. [2:05:14] Cory Quite Lander. [2:05:20] Thank you, Jackie Smith. [2:05:21] Thank you, Fred And here. [2:05:26] Thank you. [2:05:28] Rhea Coleman. [2:05:30] Thank you. [2:05:31] You will have five minutes. [2:05:32] Please begin. [2:05:33] >> Good afternoon, Counsel. [2:05:34] My name is Dre. [2:05:35] I am a resident of District [2:05:37] one, a Navy veteran and a small [2:05:39] business owner as well as a [2:05:40] proud volunteer with San Diego [2:05:42] 350 and Public Power San Diego. [2:05:45] >> Now why are so many people [2:05:47] motivated to be here on a [2:05:48] Monday afternoon? [2:05:49] >> And why does Jeannie solicit [2:05:51] curses from every San Diego who [2:05:53] hears that name? [2:05:55] It's because every single one [2:05:56] of us has had that moment. [2:05:58] The one where you open [2:05:59] the billing up or the bill [2:06:00] lands on the counter and you [2:06:02] just stare at it. [2:06:03] Maybe you reread the number [2:06:05] like it'll change. [2:06:06] It won't. [2:06:07] In case you're wondering in [2:06:08] fact don't look at it too many [2:06:10] times because I'm going to [2:06:10] charge you extra for that. [2:06:12] >> And what's maddening is that [2:06:14] we live in one of the sunniest [2:06:15] city in the country. [2:06:16] Solar is now the cheapest [2:06:18] electricity on earth and we are [2:06:20] still paying some of [2:06:21] the highest electric rates in [2:06:22] the continental United States. [2:06:24] This is a broken arrangement [2:06:26] created by an investor owned [2:06:27] corporation. [2:06:29] In fact here are the numbers. [2:06:30] >> Straight from the cpu See? [2:06:32] Since 2014 sd genius [2:06:35] residential rates have gone up [2:06:36] about 117% Inflation over that [2:06:40] same period 39%. [2:06:43] Sd Genius rates have grown [2:06:44] three times faster than [2:06:46] the cost of everything three [2:06:48] times. [2:06:50] Right now nearly one in five sd [2:06:53] Genie households are behind on [2:06:55] their bill. [2:06:56] >> Owning an average owing an [2:06:56] average of over $500. [2:07:00] Those are our neighbors. [2:07:02] That's multiple people in this [2:07:03] room right now. [2:07:05] >> And this doesn't stop at our [2:07:06] electric bill. [2:07:08] Local businesses pay these same [2:07:09] rates and that cost gets built [2:07:11] into the price of your coffee, [2:07:13] your haircut, your kid's [2:07:14] daycare. [2:07:15] High electric rates are a [2:07:17] hidden cost on every [2:07:18] transaction in the city. [2:07:19] >> Our water rates mtf also [2:07:22] facing a deficit has to pay [2:07:23] them too. [2:07:24] So that's why we're here [2:07:26] because we're tired of [2:07:27] subsidizing a system that costs [2:07:29] us three times more than it [2:07:30] should in the one city in [2:07:32] America with the least excuse [2:07:34] for it. [2:07:35] But here's what I'd like you to [2:07:36] think about. [2:07:37] >> This is the business model [2:07:39] working exactly as designed. [2:07:42] Sd Jeannie is a government [2:07:43] granted monopoly. [2:07:44] You can't shop around for your [2:07:46] power and under California's [2:07:48] regulatory system it doesn't [2:07:49] make money by giving you [2:07:51] cheaper or better power. [2:07:52] It makes money by spending more [2:07:54] on infrastructure because [2:07:56] the state guarantees its [2:07:57] shareholders a return of nearly [2:07:59] 10% on every dollar that it [2:08:01] spends. [2:08:02] Not on outcomes but on [2:08:04] spending. [2:08:06] Sd Jeannie boasts up to $1 [2:08:07] billion in annual profits and [2:08:09] that money comes from [2:08:10] somewhere. [2:08:11] It came from us. [2:08:12] Yet they'll shut your power [2:08:14] off. [2:08:15] It is also why sd Jeannie [2:08:18] doesn't celebrate when your [2:08:18] neighbor puts solar panels on [2:08:19] the roof. [2:08:20] Solar that we the ratepayers [2:08:22] pay for Personally under this [2:08:25] business model your rooftop [2:08:26] solar is a loss of revenue to [2:08:28] them not a win for the grid. [2:08:30] >> And sd Genies parent company [2:08:32] Sempra is one of the largest [2:08:34] builders of fossil fuel export [2:08:35] infrastructure in the country. [2:08:37] >> So while we MAY be doing our [2:08:39] best to go green, the company [2:08:40] taking our power bill is in [2:08:43] other corners of its empire [2:08:45] building out more fossil fuel [2:08:46] infrastructure. [2:08:47] And they protect this [2:08:49] arrangement the same way every [2:08:50] entrenched monopoly does with [2:08:52] money in politics. [2:08:55] Sempra spendnds over $1 million a [2:08:56] year lobbying Sacramento and [2:08:58] the very commission that sets [2:08:59] its profit margin. [2:09:01] >> Take a look at where Sempra [2:09:03] Nest is. [2:09:03] You need to donate their money. [2:09:04] Our money. [2:09:06] This isn't just about a high [2:09:07] bill. [2:09:08] It's about a monopoly that [2:09:09] profits by spending more [2:09:12] vitally clean energy on our [2:09:13] roofs and spends our money [2:09:15] lobbying the people meant to [2:09:17] hold them accountable. [2:09:19] This is unacceptable. [2:09:20] This is nonpartisan and this is [2:09:22] wrong. [2:09:24] >> I want to end with a [2:09:25] question to the room and I [2:09:26] think you will actually might [2:09:27] know the answer. [2:09:28] How do you spell corporate [2:09:29] greed? [2:09:32] Sd Jeannie, thank you Counsel. [2:09:36] >> Thank you for your comments [2:09:36] . [2:09:40] Our next speaker is Isaiah [2:09:43] Glass of Isaiah. [2:09:43] You have several people sending [2:09:44] you time so I just need to [2:09:46] confirm they're here. [2:09:47] Robin Gill Burt thank you. [2:09:51] Mary Fifield Thank you. [2:09:54] Andrew Lund Steve Thank you. [2:09:57] So today Lopez Eugenio thank [2:09:58] you And Mike meaning All right, [2:10:02] Thank you. [2:10:03] You will have six minutes. [2:10:04] >> Please begin. [2:10:05] Good afternoon, Council [2:10:06] members. [2:10:07] My name is Isaiah Glasser and [2:10:08] I'm the program director for [2:10:10] Public Power San Diego. [2:10:12] I want to take a moment to [2:10:12] thank all the volunteers who [2:10:13] came out to support the Phase [2:10:15] two public power study and [2:10:16] public power in general. [2:10:17] I really do appreciate it from [2:10:18] the bottom of my heart. [2:10:20] This new gen study shows even [2:10:22] in the most conservative [2:10:23] modeling that public power is [2:10:26] good for San Diego and it's [2:10:27] good for San Diego is the key [2:10:29] number that determines this [2:10:30] amount of savings is [2:10:31] the revenue growth rate. [2:10:33] New Gen assumed 4% and admits [2:10:35] that 6% is more realistic and [2:10:38] it's a total slap in the face [2:10:39] that just a couple of days ago [2:10:41] you filed for an 8% increase in [2:10:42] 2028. [2:10:44] The second you take this model [2:10:46] it's the same You take this [2:10:47] model and use a revenue growth [2:10:48] rate that's anywhere near [2:10:49] reality. [2:10:50] The savings are absolutely mind [2:10:51] blowing and it seems to me that [2:10:53] we're actually pretty close to [2:10:54] consensus on that which makes [2:10:56] common sense because when you [2:10:58] cut Wall Street profit out of [2:10:59] our electricity bills you will [2:11:01] see savings. [2:11:02] Many of us here today knew this [2:11:04] back in 2020 during [2:11:05] the franchise agreement fight [2:11:06] and again in 2024 during [2:11:08] the power San Diego campaign. [2:11:10] Public power was the right [2:11:11] choice in 2020. [2:11:12] It was the right choice in [2:11:13] 2024. [2:11:15] It's the right choice in 2026 [2:11:17] and it will be the right choice [2:11:18] in 2023. [2:11:19] The question is not if public [2:11:21] power saves money. [2:11:23] The question is when will we [2:11:24] have a council that is brave [2:11:26] enough to take on the corporate [2:11:27] oligarchs that any all of us [2:11:30] here today are being ripped off [2:11:32] by our stage name including [2:11:34] the city of San Diego. [2:11:36] The city pays an sd Jeanie Bill [2:11:38] the water department pays [2:11:40] the nasty G.I. Bill. [2:11:41] The sewer department pays a [2:11:42] nasty G.I. Bill Electric rates [2:11:44] are a cost inflator on [2:11:46] the entire city budget. [2:11:48] Public power would help [2:11:49] the city's structural deficit, [2:11:51] t harm it. [2:11:52] We really truly are the council [2:11:54] and the people of San Diego on [2:11:56] the same side against sd Jenny [2:11:57] . [2:11:59] And moving forward we [2:12:00] absolutely must protect ibew [2:12:02] guarantee their fought hard, [2:12:04] hard fought labor contracts and [2:12:06] hard earned pension funds. [2:12:08] And that is absolutely doable [2:12:09] with public power. [2:12:11] Now I've got a message for [2:12:13] the bosses at e! [2:12:17] >> The public power movement is [2:12:19] only growing. [2:12:20] Your days are numbered. [2:12:21] Of pillaging our community. [2:12:23] Your for profit monopoly will [2:12:25] end. [2:12:26] >> Thank you. [2:12:30] >> Thank you. [2:12:31] Alison Miller Well Alison comes [2:12:33] to the microphone I will ask [2:12:35] Blaire Beekman, Jessica [2:12:36] Anderson Nicole Lilly Yeah and [2:12:40] Dori Bruggeman to please come [2:12:42] to the front room. [2:12:44] >> Alison, please begin. [2:12:45] Hello Council I am a resident [2:12:47] of District three and I am here [2:12:48] today because a quarter of your [2:12:50] voters and my neighbors are in [2:12:52] debt to corporate greed as any [2:12:56] at any given time. [2:12:58] >> They're on track to make $1 [2:13:00] billion in profits this year [2:13:01] yet they continue to ask for [2:13:02] more during the same time [2:13:04] period they've been [2:13:04] participating in union busting. [2:13:06] They've been turning to private [2:13:08] contractors that hurt our union [2:13:09] neighbors. [2:13:12] We the supporters of the public [2:13:14] power movement are committed to [2:13:15] working with our union [2:13:15] neighbors as we implement [2:13:17] public power And I ask you to [2:13:18] commit to the same. [2:13:19] Opponents today have argued [2:13:20] that there isn't enough [2:13:21] information to take the next [2:13:22] step. [2:13:23] But you have before you data [2:13:25] that is founded on good [2:13:27] information. [2:13:29] It's time today is the time to [2:13:32] take the next step. [2:13:33] There will never be enough [2:13:34] information for some people. [2:13:35] Today San Diego pays and see [2:13:37] Jeannie profits. [2:13:38] But San Diegans deserve to own [2:13:40] the goods and services that we [2:13:41] pay for. [2:13:42] So today I'm asking you to [2:13:43] reject corporate greed and act [2:13:45] in support of San Diegans by [2:13:47] supporting public good. [2:13:49] >> That doesn't include your [2:13:49] time. [2:13:50] Blair Beekman. [2:13:59] Hi. [2:14:00] I'm already here. [2:14:00] Shoot. [2:14:01] It's my time. [2:14:02] Thank you. [2:14:03] I'm not very knowledgeable [2:14:04] about these things, but I come [2:14:07] from the Bay Area. [2:14:08] They have a great tradition of [2:14:09] community energy and working [2:14:11] with unions I feel I have to [2:14:14] refresh myself on such [2:14:15] subjects. [2:14:16] I hope you guys are learning [2:14:17] that too that the municipal [2:14:20] things weren't offered here. [2:14:21] For union things I hope there [2:14:24] can be dialog between everyone [2:14:25] . [2:14:26] It sounds like people want to [2:14:27] have the dialog and we [2:14:29] definitely want to believe in [2:14:30] the future of what community [2:14:31] energy can offer. [2:14:34] Where you minister a municipal [2:14:36] system MAY not work. [2:14:37] We do have little small [2:14:39] programs you know like [2:14:41] the funding of neighborhood [2:14:42] infrastructure that can be [2:14:44] called a municipal program [2:14:46] possibly and work in those kind [2:14:48] of avenues. [2:14:49] But working towards the overall [2:14:51] goal of community energy I hope [2:14:53] we're all on board on that [2:14:54] subject matter and want to be [2:14:56] building such good things for [2:14:58] all of us in our future. [2:14:59] >> Thank you. [2:15:00] Thank you, Jessica Anderson. [2:15:05] >> Hello, Council. [2:15:07] Month after month over the past [2:15:08] year my utility bill has [2:15:09] continued to climb, reaching [2:15:11] nearly over $300 every single [2:15:13] month in my first apartment out [2:15:15] of college. [2:15:16] This is unaffordable. [2:15:17] It is ridiculous that City [2:15:17] Jionni profits nearly $1 [2:15:20] billion a year yet 1 in 5 San [2:15:22] Diegans cannot afford their [2:15:23] utility bills. [2:15:25] It is ridiculous that in that [2:15:28] stage you need claim that this [2:15:28] is not feasible when they are [2:15:29] asking for an 8.6% increase at [2:15:32] the cpu. [2:15:33] See it is absolutely ridiculous [2:15:35] when San Diegans are forced to [2:15:37] choose between food on their [2:15:38] table paying their rent and [2:15:40] paying their utility bills it [2:15:41] is clear the system is broken. [2:15:43] Public power is a real [2:15:44] opportunity to address this [2:15:45] crisis. [2:15:46] Public power presents us with [2:15:48] the opportunity for clean [2:15:50] affordable energy. [2:15:50] Public power presents us with [2:15:52] the opportunity for clean air [2:15:53] public health, the opportunity [2:15:55] to protect strong unions and to [2:15:58] protect people In San Diego who [2:15:59] cannot afford to live here any [2:16:00] longer. [2:16:01] Public power is a real viable [2:16:03] opportunity to build a more [2:16:05] affordable and thriving San [2:16:07] Diego. [2:16:07] >> Thank you. [2:16:08] That does conclude your time. [2:16:09] Nicole Lilly. [2:16:14] Nicole Lilly. [2:16:17] Okay. [2:16:17] Uh oh. [2:16:19] Here she comes. [2:16:20] All right. [2:16:32] >> Sorry. [2:16:34] Hello. [2:16:35] My name is Nicole Lilly. [2:16:36] I'm a 23 year old run turned [2:16:38] Golden Heel and the executive [2:16:39] director of our Time to Act a [2:16:41] youth led 523 nonprofit [2:16:42] organizing powerful youth for [2:16:44] an inclusive, equitable and [2:16:45] sustainable future. [2:16:47] As youth organizers we have [2:16:48] become all too familiar [2:16:49] tackling complicated and [2:16:51] nuanced issues and creating new [2:16:52] and innovative solutions [2:16:53] because it is what is necessary [2:16:54] . [2:16:56] I support the implementation of [2:16:58] public power without denying [2:17:00] the necessity of labor [2:17:01] considerations. [2:17:02] We need not be divided. [2:17:04] Dismantling monopolies like [2:17:06] Jeannie is an effort that we [2:17:07] must join together to pursue. [2:17:09] Utilities like housing and [2:17:10] health care are basic needs and [2:17:12] allowing it to be maintained as [2:17:13] a tool for profit because it is [2:17:15] complicated is unacceptable. [2:17:17] Every day San Diegans young [2:17:19] organizers like myself demand a [2:17:21] commitment from this council to [2:17:22] do what is complicated because [2:17:23] it is necessary. [2:17:25] My roommate and I figure out [2:17:26] how to make do with less and [2:17:27] less every month to survive in [2:17:29] San Diego. [2:17:30] I urge the city to do more to [2:17:31] make San Diego work for all [2:17:32] the people in this room not [2:17:33] the corporations that we [2:17:34] destroy. [2:17:35] >> Thank you. [2:17:36] Lori Saldana. [2:17:42] >> Good afternoon And I want to [2:17:44] just acknowledge and thank all [2:17:45] the people who have spoken [2:17:46] today because the perspectives [2:17:48] are important and I think [2:17:49] they've all raised some really [2:17:51] excellent points on both sides [2:17:53] for and against us. [2:17:54] There are a few certainties in [2:17:56] life We know a couple of them [2:17:58] death taxes and I'll add a [2:18:02] third sdg in asking to raise [2:18:03] their rates. [2:18:06] 300,000 people at least cannot [2:18:07] afford to pay their higher [2:18:08] rates here in San Diego. [2:18:10] We pay the highest rates in [2:18:12] the country. [2:18:13] So with certainty when I heard [2:18:14] the report on my way in today [2:18:15] and listen to the report saying [2:18:17] an estimated 3% rate increase [2:18:19] would even out over time i [2:18:22] think you're way [2:18:22] underestimating what us intends [2:18:25] to do. [2:18:26] So in the interest of time I [2:18:28] will just point out one more [2:18:29] thing. [2:18:29] Working against us is one [2:18:30] culprit. [2:18:31] You have received $5,000 as of [2:18:33] MARCH 31st from ibew for your [2:18:37] run for Congress. [2:18:38] I would ask that you please [2:18:39] recuse yourself from voting on [2:18:40] this. [2:18:41] >> I think you have a conflict [2:18:42] of interest and thank you for [2:18:46] your time. [2:18:46] >> Okay, take it easy. [2:18:47] This is an information item. [2:18:49] There is no voting. [2:18:54] Dori Brueggemann You do have [2:18:55] time ceded to you by Barbara I [2:19:00] have a rose Okay you have two [2:19:00] minutes. [2:19:00] Please begin. [2:19:02] >> Good afternoon Council I'm [2:19:04] Dory. [2:19:05] I'm an executive board member [2:19:06] of Public Power San Diego and [2:19:09] some of the points I had [2:19:10] written down here today have [2:19:11] already been said so I'll skip [2:19:12] those. [2:19:13] But I wanted to read a couple [2:19:15] of quotes from the feasibility [2:19:17] study phase two The first quote [2:19:20] that I have here is [2:19:22] the financial risks while real [2:19:24] are manageable through careful [2:19:25] planning and execution. [2:19:27] The municipal electric utility [2:19:29] remains viable even under [2:19:31] adverse scenarios. [2:19:33] The bottom line is that this [2:19:34] report shows that this is [2:19:35] feasible. [2:19:37] This quote also tells us that [2:19:38] when we build a public utility [2:19:40] we are building a domain where [2:19:42] success lies in our hands. [2:19:44] And I want to say there's been [2:19:45] a lot of fear mongering here [2:19:46] today. [2:19:48] I also just want to shout out [2:19:49] thank you. [2:19:52] Britney says for [2:19:52] the fearmongering directly from [2:19:53] sd Janey She did not identify [2:19:53] herself but she does work for [2:19:57] any. [2:19:58] I want to talk about the risk [2:20:00] of not making the choice to [2:20:02] switch to public power instead [2:20:03] making the choice to stay [2:20:05] the course where we are hoping [2:20:09] that legislative reform or cpc [2:20:11] reform will somehow fix this [2:20:12] problem. [2:20:13] The cbc is not going to save [2:20:16] us. [2:20:18] That's not our turf. [2:20:19] That's Sdrinis turf. [2:20:23] One of our allies over here had [2:20:26] a great example of the way that [2:20:27] they exploit loopholes. [2:20:28] Any any roadblock we put in [2:20:31] their way they will exploit. [2:20:33] We are not winning as much as [2:20:34] we need to be to fix [2:20:35] the problem at the state level. [2:20:39] But the point is that public [2:20:40] power is not uniquely risky And [2:20:42] also we're lucky that we have [2:20:44] this option that we are a city [2:20:45] and we can actually do [2:20:47] something significant to make a [2:20:49] change and get out under [2:20:51] the thumb of Jeannie. [2:20:52] So I want to echo what my ally [2:20:54] Patricia and Diego said. [2:20:56] We can do this. [2:20:57] >> We can work together. [2:20:59] This is a growing movement. [2:21:00] And don't let the fear [2:21:04] mongering get to you. [2:21:04] That does conclude your time. [2:21:06] Omar Walter Nadji. [2:21:25] One minute. [2:21:26] One minute. [2:21:26] Yes. [2:21:26] So you said you uniquely [2:21:27] positioned to chart a different [2:21:28] course with national [2:21:30] consequences. [2:21:31] Climate is one of the greatest [2:21:32] natural resources anywhere in [2:21:34] the world. [2:21:35] We have an abundant sunshine [2:21:36] growing clean energy sector, [2:21:38] world class research [2:21:39] institutions and the population [2:21:41] has consistently embraced [2:21:43] innovations. [2:21:44] We're not simply capable of [2:21:46] generating enough clean energy [2:21:48] to power our homes and [2:21:49] businesses. [2:21:50] We have potential to become a [2:21:52] net producer of energy creating [2:21:54] economic value that remains in [2:21:57] our region rather than leaving [2:21:58] it. [2:22:00] Decisions being made right now [2:22:01] will determine who benefits [2:22:03] from this growth. [2:22:05] This opportunity will the value [2:22:08] created by this transformation [2:22:09] of our system remain here in [2:22:13] San Diego reinvested in [2:22:15] affordability, reliability, [2:22:16] infrastructure and local [2:22:16] priorities? [2:22:19] Or will it continue to flow [2:22:20] primarily towards a system [2:22:21] designed around shareholder [2:22:23] returns? [2:22:25] We have every incentive to [2:22:27] preserve this model. [2:22:30] If we were part of this study [2:22:36] well we that's an investor [2:22:36] owned utility understand that. [2:22:37] But as you guys represent us [2:22:42] the citizens your [2:22:44] responsibility is about what [2:22:48] serves San Diego is best. [2:22:50] Sorry I'm not professional [2:22:51] speech. [2:22:53] Is my first speech in years. [2:22:54] But anyway I think this is a [2:22:56] test. [2:22:57] The biggest question is ask [2:22:59] whether the generation of [2:23:01] wealth created by the energy [2:23:03] economy should be captured [2:23:05] locally and used to benefit [2:23:07] communities that created it. [2:23:09] Or are we to continue to give [2:23:11] it to us to Junior? [2:23:15] This isn't their decision. [2:23:16] >> Thank you. [2:23:17] That does conclude [2:23:17] the development session but [2:23:26] please keep. [2:23:32] >> I just walk to the parking [2:23:33] structure with former [2:23:34] Councilmember Mark Kersey. [2:23:36] >> He was kind enough to listen [2:23:38] to my questions about why [2:23:41] the city can't do the simplest [2:23:42] things to oversee the many [2:23:46] businesses that operate [2:23:47] throughout this city. [2:23:50] Do you know what he said to me? [2:23:53] He said there was too much [2:23:54] going on in this city for [2:23:57] the council members to deal [2:23:58] with all the details in [2:24:00] the city. [2:24:02] Too much going on for you to [2:24:04] deal with. [2:24:06] Now I'm not an expert on energy [2:24:08] but I have become an expert on [2:24:11] business interests hijacking [2:24:13] the city government for their [2:24:15] own purposes. [2:24:17] If you have any doubt, look [2:24:19] into how the city That's you. [2:24:22] Joe Lacob and Todd Lauria have [2:24:24] mismanaged the Torrey Pines [2:24:24] Gloria port. [2:24:26] Thank you. [2:24:27] Thank you. [2:24:29] Our final in-person speaker [2:24:30] will be Anthony Ralphs. [2:24:39] >> Good afternoon City Council. [2:24:40] I want to remind everybody in [2:24:42] this room that we all share one [2:24:43] thing in common We're all [2:24:45] getting ripped off by Jionni [2:24:47] and it continues every day year [2:24:49] after year. [2:24:52] $1 billion in profits last year [2:24:54] Almost a billion the year [2:24:55] before. [2:24:56] I'm sick to my stomach. [2:24:57] I'm tired of not being able to [2:24:59] pay my energy bills. [2:25:00] I'm tired of the people in my [2:25:01] city not being able to pay [2:25:02] their energy bills. [2:25:03] I'm tired of one quarter to a [2:25:05] fifth of the people in this [2:25:06] city not being able to afford [2:25:08] meeting their energy bills at [2:25:10] the end of the month. [2:25:11] I'm tired of seeing a corporate [2:25:13] monopoly and its greed [2:25:15] prioritized over the people [2:25:17] that live in the city. [2:25:18] I am a union member. [2:25:20] I'm a member of iww, [2:25:21] the Industrial Workers of [2:25:22] the World so I understand [2:25:24] the priority that labor places [2:25:26] in our lives. [2:25:27] But I also understand that only [2:25:29] half of the people in this room [2:25:31] are getting paid handsomely to [2:25:32] be here And it's not those of [2:25:34] us who hate sd Jeanie for free. [2:25:36] >> Thank you. [2:25:41] >> Thank you. [2:25:42] We also received two speaker [2:25:44] slips from individuals wishing [2:25:46] to register their position in [2:25:48] favor but not speak from [2:25:49] Brandon Reynolds and Korina [2:25:51] Vega. [2:25:54] That concludes in-person public [2:25:55] comment. [2:25:56] I've started the five minute [2:25:57] timer and council chambers. [2:25:58] We will now turn to the virtual [2:26:00] queue in which there are [2:26:02] currently ten speakers [2:26:03] requesting to speak. [2:26:05] We will begin with Eric Revolt [2:26:09] Zachary. [2:26:20] Imagine every single family [2:26:23] house and duplex in San Diego [2:26:25] covered with twice the solar [2:26:28] panels there are now and [2:26:30] they're going to get paid three [2:26:31] times more for the energy. [2:26:33] Imagine Fashion Valley covered [2:26:36] in solar panels. [2:26:37] Mission Valley covered in solar [2:26:39] panels. [2:26:41] The parking drives all their [2:26:42] green power. [2:26:44] And imagine every trolley [2:26:46] station covered in providing [2:26:49] shade and solar energy to feed [2:26:52] the dc motors on the trolley [2:26:55] instead of using ac dropping [2:26:57] down to dc for them directly [2:27:00] with solar panels on [2:27:02] the trolley system Even [2:27:04] the tracks elevator from [2:27:05] the tracks. [2:27:06] We're now doing ac power and [2:27:09] turning that ac power into dc [2:27:12] causing energy when we can [2:27:15] generate it from solar panels [2:27:17] right there on the trolley [2:27:18] stations. [2:27:19] >> No all involved is solar. [2:27:23] Thank you. [2:27:24] That does conclude your time. [2:27:25] We will go next to Eric Proval, [2:27:28] Paul Jones Eric. [2:27:32] >> Perfect. [2:27:33] Thank you so much counsel. [2:27:34] My name is Eric Proval and I am [2:27:36] the ceo of the San Diego North [2:27:38] Economic Development Council [2:27:39] representing an area North of [2:27:42] that sa 56 with more than 1 [2:27:43] million residents and 500,000 [2:27:45] jobs. [2:27:46] I urge caution and ask that [2:27:48] the city pause this effort [2:27:49] until the regional implications [2:27:51] are better understood. [2:27:52] The reported self acknowledges [2:27:54] that the electric system was [2:27:55] not built around city [2:27:57] boundaries. [2:27:58] Numerous substations and other [2:27:59] assets serve customers both [2:28:01] inside and outside the city. [2:28:03] Yet the report appears to [2:28:05] assume that separating and [2:28:06] operating these assets can [2:28:08] occur smoothly and [2:28:09] cooperatively. [2:28:11] That is a significant [2:28:12] assumption with major [2:28:13] implications for reliability [2:28:14] costs in neighboring [2:28:15] communities. [2:28:16] But most importantly the report [2:28:18] does not adequately explain how [2:28:20] a municipal utility would [2:28:21] participate in regional [2:28:23] wildfire prevention, weather [2:28:25] monitoring and emergency [2:28:26] operations before moving [2:28:27] forward. [2:28:28] North County communities [2:28:29] deserve a clear understanding [2:28:31] of how municipal this action [2:28:32] would affect them. [2:28:36] Thank you for your comments. [2:28:40] Kathleen Levitt Thank you. [2:28:45] Good afternoon and thank you to [2:28:46] everybody who spoke. [2:28:48] Governor Newsom allowed [2:28:49] California companies to tax [2:28:51] taxpayer dollars from the state [2:28:53] $21 billion while fund wildfire [2:28:57] fund to pay for their damages, [2:28:59] fines and liabilities for fires [2:29:01] that were directly tied to it. [2:29:04] For every dollar the utility [2:29:06] spent building infrastructure [2:29:08] they were allowed to charge [2:29:09] customers an additional 10% in [2:29:12] profits for their shareholders. [2:29:14] They routinely their priority [2:29:16] is profit for their executives [2:29:18] and shareholders and they [2:29:19] routinely disregard public [2:29:21] priorities They disregard while [2:29:23] diverse habitats that support [2:29:25] migratory birds, reptiles, [2:29:28] pollinators and they're ignored [2:29:28] . [2:29:30] On behalf of permitting if [2:29:33] figure you need to put their [2:29:35] power lines they now want to [2:29:37] put their power lines directly [2:29:40] through the anza-borrego Park [2:29:43] that is a designated park in [2:29:45] perpetuity to protect Thank [2:29:48] you. [2:29:48] That does conclude your time. [2:29:56] Francis Yasmeen Matlala Hello. [2:29:57] So first it's I think it's [2:30:01] important for everyone to [2:30:02] realize that like the entire [2:30:04] state of Nebraska has municipal [2:30:06] run power is is not impossible [2:30:08] task any government can do it [2:30:10] if they just create the public [2:30:11] the political will to do it. [2:30:13] I think that every one of [2:30:16] the council members should [2:30:17] attend The American Public [2:30:20] Power Association's annual [2:30:21] conference and you can learn [2:30:23] about and meet cities of people [2:30:27] from cities all over [2:30:28] the country that enjoy [2:30:29] the benefits of public power [2:30:30] that we are only dreaming of. [2:30:33] I want to state that the sdg [2:30:35] business model it's not about [2:30:38] security or affordability. [2:30:42] It's about profit And even [2:30:43] the way they're designing [2:30:44] the future with long [2:30:45] transmission lines out to [2:30:47] the desert is the wrong way to [2:30:48] go. [2:30:49] It's not sensible unless you [2:30:51] try and exploit people for [2:30:52] money as he takes $1 million a [2:30:55] day out of the city and 3 [2:30:56] million a day out of [2:30:57] the county, it's got to stop [2:30:58] now. [2:30:59] >> Thank you, John Stump by [2:31:13] John Stone And DECEMBER 15th [2:31:15] 2025 I sent the council a nine [2:31:19] point program to get out of [2:31:23] this mess with me. [2:31:25] And the key thing in this nine [2:31:28] point program which I'm sending [2:31:29] you again today is that [2:31:32] the city should create its own [2:31:34] municipal utility for its own [2:31:36] use. [2:31:37] The city currently now [2:31:39] generates its own power and [2:31:41] spends a lot of money paying [2:31:45] Genny. [2:31:45] The city could easily set up [2:31:47] its own department and that [2:31:50] would be the initial step [2:31:51] the transitional step toward [2:31:54] public power. [2:31:56] City Council Start exploring [2:31:59] where you spend money and where [2:32:02] you generate electricity now [2:32:04] and set up a separate [2:32:06] department To watch that please [2:32:09] follow the direction of my [2:32:10] mother at DECEMBER 15th 2025. [2:32:13] >> Thank you very much. [2:32:17] Thank you. [2:32:18] And I please know that the five [2:32:19] minute timer has concluded with [2:32:21] eight speakers left in [2:32:23] the queue and the other [2:32:23] speakers will be taken after [2:32:27] this time The voices please [2:32:29] begin. [2:32:33] >> Hi my name is We try and set [2:32:34] the director for businesses. [2:32:37] I'm calling to support you know [2:32:39] public power. [2:32:40] I know that I also think it's [2:32:44] ironic that we need a study to [2:32:46] figure out where we should put [2:32:48] the power. [2:32:50] We all talk about the rising [2:32:53] costs of standing so much now I [2:32:57] you know, if you can find a [2:32:59] little will to make it happen, [2:33:02] it will really help a lot of us [2:33:03] reduce the cost of living here [2:33:05] and stay here And then I go it [2:33:07] is the no getting there now we [2:33:10] don't really need a study to do [2:33:11] it But now you have a study Can [2:33:13] you please move forward with [2:33:15] it? [2:33:15] That would be great. [2:33:16] Thank you. [2:33:22] Color with the last word Digits [2:33:22] 88213. [2:33:24] Please begin. [2:33:33] Okay so the goal here is [2:33:34] unbelievable to get people to [2:33:36] have confidence that this board [2:33:38] will do the right thing when [2:33:40] the record of ignoring [2:33:42] the people's wishes and needs [2:33:44] are like it's been proven in [2:33:47] putting people honestly to [2:33:49] the people who are awake to any [2:33:53] and all we have We have so much [2:33:53] of our money and keep asking [2:33:55] for more But you realize that [2:33:57] this board you're addressing [2:33:58] does the same exact thing [2:34:02] honestly from sandag to [2:34:03] the county to this board. [2:34:06] I mean all these corrupt [2:34:08] government agencies they'll [2:34:10] take for it They will take from [2:34:12] us and you know, whatever [2:34:15] benefits them. [2:34:16] But I just wish, you know, more [2:34:17] people were awake to that And [2:34:20] it's it's amazing You can't [2:34:22] address us without also [2:34:24] addressing the corruption of [2:34:24] the very board. [2:34:27] Well, I got to say that. [2:34:33] Thank you, Evan Burke, please [2:34:35] begin. [2:34:39] >> Hello. [2:34:39] I want to speak in favor of [2:34:41] public power first. [2:34:43] There is no benefit to a [2:34:44] private monopoly like Genie. [2:34:46] There's no need to even pretend [2:34:47] to little cost with no [2:34:49] competition. [2:34:50] Meanwhile, their insanely high [2:34:51] power costs make our cost of [2:34:52] living more expensive and [2:34:54] contribute to issues like [2:34:55] homelessness. [2:34:56] I found the fear mongering that [2:34:58] I've heard outrageous. [2:35:00] We hear that we don't have [2:35:01] enough data but what more data [2:35:02] do we need when dozens of other [2:35:04] cities have already done this [2:35:05] and succeeded, we were warned [2:35:08] that San Diego will have to pay [2:35:09] new costs like insurance [2:35:11] premiums. [2:35:12] But San Diegans are already [2:35:13] paying those costs and more [2:35:15] Whenever Janey turns a profit [2:35:18] the definition of madness is [2:35:19] doing the same thing over and [2:35:21] over again and expecting a [2:35:22] different result. [2:35:23] We've seen what I see Genie can [2:35:24] do and will do and now's [2:35:27] the time to try something [2:35:28] different or just a new form of [2:35:30] pop pop power. [2:35:31] >> Thank you. [2:35:33] Thank you. [2:35:34] Natalie Rashid, please begin. [2:35:42] Hi. [2:35:48] Natalie Rushdie Here I am [2:35:48] District seven. [2:35:48] I want to bring couple [2:35:50] attention to one number that [2:35:51] explains a lot of what's [2:35:52] happening with our electric [2:35:54] bills. [2:35:58] You see just authorized a [2:35:58] return on equity of nearly 10% [2:36:01] for 2026 to 2028. [2:36:03] That's the profit percentage [2:36:06] Sempra's shareholders earn not [2:36:07] on selling us electricity but [2:36:08] on infrastructure spending [2:36:10] itself. [2:36:11] The more he spends on poles [2:36:13] wires and upgrades the more [2:36:15] profit profit it earns because [2:36:17] that return is applied to [2:36:19] the entire faith based [2:36:21] independent economics at [2:36:23] the American Economic Liberties [2:36:25] Project testified that their [2:36:26] fair return based on current [2:36:27] market conditions would be [2:36:29] closer to 6% and the gap [2:36:30] between that and what was [2:36:32] actually authorized comes out [2:36:33] to 4.4 billion in overcharges [2:36:37] in 2026 alone across [2:36:39] California's immediate [2:36:40] utilities. [2:36:40] This is exactly why the cities [2:36:42] on Public Power study found [2:36:45] that most Thank you that does [2:36:48] conclude your tired electric [2:36:49] grid. [2:36:52] Next speaker is Jordan Lewis. [2:36:54] Please begin. [2:36:58] >> Hi, my name is Katherine [2:37:02] Mock. [2:37:02] I'm a resident of San San Diego [2:37:04] County in North County and I'm [2:37:06] an sd g and customer and I [2:37:08] support acquiring sd Janney [2:37:09] Infrastructure and could bring [2:37:11] it to a publicly owned power [2:37:12] utility particularly for [2:37:14] concerns like affordability and [2:37:16] transitioning to zero emission [2:37:18] utilities. [2:37:19] Well it's expensive to acquire [2:37:20] a managed utility and that cost [2:37:22] will be footed by us rate [2:37:22] payers. [2:37:23] We're already footing the bill [2:37:25] for sd duty and on top of that, [2:37:27] as others have pointed out, [2:37:29] we're paying the additional [2:37:29] cost of a for profit entity [2:37:32] including the hundreds of [2:37:33] millions of profits each year [2:37:35] that sd only makes as well as [2:37:36] the 22.2 million total [2:37:39] compensation for Jeffrey [2:37:40] Martin, Sempra ceo That was [2:37:42] last year's number. [2:37:44] So for these reasons I fully [2:37:45] support advancing a publicly [2:37:46] owned utility for San Diego. [2:37:48] Please continue this effort. [2:37:49] Do what you can to reduce [2:37:50] the uncertainty. [2:37:51] Incorporate the concerns of [2:37:53] some of the folks who spoken [2:37:53] opposition today and complete [2:37:55] the transition to public power. [2:37:57] >> Thank you. [2:37:57] Thank you. [2:38:00] Next speaker is a caller with [2:38:02] last four digits 8700. [2:38:06] Please begin. [2:38:13] Thank you. [2:38:14] Yes, I support public power [2:38:18] also known as Power of [2:38:20] the People. [2:38:21] Here are my reasons. [2:38:23] Number one, all of you using [2:38:26] the power of your voice today. [2:38:29] Number two, trusting that all [2:38:32] of us will do a full analysis [2:38:34] of this of its ability. [2:38:37] Number three keeping an eye on [2:38:40] San Francisco as a public power [2:38:42] model. [2:38:44] This is a golden opportunity [2:38:46] for creative action outside [2:38:49] the box of sd g and e! [2:38:53] It's been a great item. [2:38:55] Thank you everybody and love to [2:38:57] all. [2:39:00] Thank you. [2:39:00] Our next speaker is a caller [2:39:02] with the last four digits to [2:39:02] 265. [2:39:16] Please begin. [2:39:16] I am Diego. [2:39:17] I live in Kensington. [2:39:18] Over the last five years San [2:39:20] Diego Gas Electric has [2:39:22] appropriated an average more [2:39:23] than $800 million per year. [2:39:26] At the same time, nearly 1 in 5 [2:39:29] Centurions cannot afford to pay [2:39:30] their utility bills. [2:39:33] And greed knows no end. [2:39:35] And just last week they [2:39:36] requested the rate increase of [2:39:41] 8.6% at the puc. [2:39:43] This would mean an increase of [2:39:44] over $22,000,022 a month on top [2:39:47] of the already high utility [2:39:49] rates we are paying above [2:39:51] the public power Feasibility [2:39:53] study shows public power is [2:39:55] possible feasible and cheaper [2:39:57] for San Diego and the time for [2:39:59] public power is now. [2:40:01] My utility bill is like we live [2:40:04] in a 2000 square foot apartment [2:40:07] in utility bills like $250. [2:40:09] It's just ridiculous. [2:40:11] >> We need to do public art [2:40:11] now. [2:40:13] You. [2:40:16] >> Thank you. [2:40:17] Our final speakers and all of [2:40:17] Alaska. [2:40:19] Please begin. [2:40:23] Hi. [2:40:24] So I'm a resident of District [2:40:25] two. [2:40:27] Natural monopolies like [2:40:29] utilities should not be owned [2:40:30] by for profit entities because [2:40:32] without competition and [2:40:33] swimmers will always be [2:40:35] squeezed for profit. [2:40:36] It was a mistake to have ever [2:40:37] allowed power to be privately [2:40:38] owned. [2:40:39] If the power had been publicly [2:40:41] owned, the electrical expertise [2:40:43] and the good union jobs would [2:40:44] have always been available [2:40:45] through a public entity. [2:40:47] It will never be a good time to [2:40:48] unwind this mistake but it [2:40:50] needs to be done. [2:40:51] We understand the fear of [2:40:53] uncertainty facing union [2:40:54] members but there is no better [2:40:56] union employer than public [2:40:57] agencies. [2:40:58] As you have pointed out, your [2:40:59] expertise and skill will still [2:41:01] be needed. [2:41:02] And yes, there will be a [2:41:03] reshuffling of jobs but [2:41:04] the jobs would not go away. [2:41:06] We hear the argument we don't [2:41:07] have enough information But [2:41:08] isn't this what the council is [2:41:09] considering a feasibility study [2:41:12] to gather more information. [2:41:14] We want the council to have all [2:41:15] the information possible to [2:41:17] make a decision on this issue. [2:41:18] >> We cannot be afraid of this [2:41:20] knowledge. [2:41:20] Thank you. [2:41:22] Thank you. [2:41:23] That does conclude public [2:41:25] comment on item 200. [2:41:28] >> Thank you. [2:41:29] All right. [2:41:29] Thank you, Deputy Clerk. [2:41:30] Let's take a moment and thank [2:41:31] Kevin. [2:41:32] This is his first big meeting [2:41:33] sitting there in the chair. [2:41:35] So well done, sir. [2:41:38] And to your entire team because [2:41:40] the way that you organized all [2:41:42] the flips truly, truly [2:41:43] impressive. [2:41:44] I'll just give a personal [2:41:46] thanks to everybody that showed [2:41:47] up and the special shout out to [2:41:48] those who showed up just to [2:41:49] give time to somebody else to [2:41:51] speak. [2:41:52] Greatly appreciate that. [2:41:53] So with that we will turn it [2:41:55] over to the council members for [2:41:56] questions and comments. [2:41:58] And we'll start with the chair [2:41:59] of the Environment Committee. [2:42:01] >> Council member Ella Rivera. [2:42:03] All right. [2:42:04] Thank you. [2:42:04] Council PRESIDENT. [2:42:05] Thanks for the report. [2:42:07] Obviously we had this [2:42:09] conversation at Environment [2:42:10] Committee. [2:42:11] This is a continuation of that [2:42:15] And I think the additional [2:42:18] public participation is useful [2:42:20] because it highlighted to me [2:42:21] what I think is probably [2:42:23] the most important component of [2:42:25] this And with very few [2:42:28] exceptions almost every comment [2:42:30] we heard today came from one of [2:42:31] two groups either the blue [2:42:34] collar workers who who keep [2:42:35] the grid running or residents [2:42:37] who are breaking under [2:42:38] the weight of their bills. [2:42:41] It's working People fighting to [2:42:42] make rent, fighting to keep [2:42:44] the lights on and fighting each [2:42:46] other over scraps because [2:42:48] that's exactly what a rigged [2:42:50] economy does. [2:42:51] It doesn't just take people's [2:42:52] money. [2:42:53] It turns neighbors against each [2:42:55] other, workers against [2:42:56] ratepayers in a fight over who [2:43:00] absorbs the pain while [2:43:02] the people who actually rig [2:43:03] the game keep their feet up and [2:43:05] enjoy the show from the other [2:43:06] side of the table. [2:43:08] So who's doing that? [2:43:10] As Jeanie in Sempra the set of [2:43:13] millionaire executives who will [2:43:14] go home tonight to a financial [2:43:15] reality that no one who [2:43:17] testified here today can even [2:43:19] imagine let alone enjoy. [2:43:23] So our San Diego boys are [2:43:24] fighting each other over [2:43:25] scraps. [2:43:26] Executives sit fat and happy [2:43:29] enjoying the fruits of their [2:43:30] victories. [2:43:31] We should put some numbers to [2:43:32] that because I think that's [2:43:33] important. [2:43:34] Sempra ceo Jeff Martin took [2:43:36] home a compensation package [2:43:38] worth $22.2 million in 2025 [2:43:44] That made him the fourth [2:43:44] highest paid energy executive [2:43:46] in the country. [2:43:48] An average California worker [2:43:50] would have to work for 236 [2:43:52] years to earn what Martin made [2:43:55] in a single year 236 years. [2:44:00] That's not poor people. [2:44:02] That's the average California [2:44:03] worker. [2:44:05] And that's the gap between [2:44:07] the people who keep the grid [2:44:08] running and the man at the top [2:44:12] of the company who owns it. [2:44:15] And I think there's something [2:44:17] really important about why it's [2:44:19] so important to continue this [2:44:21] conversation. [2:44:21] I understand the anxiety that [2:44:24] it creates for the workers who [2:44:25] who are impacted by [2:44:27] the conversation. [2:44:28] But I want to explain why it's [2:44:30] been important to keep this [2:44:31] conversation going. [2:44:31] Because despite this [2:44:33] conversation going despite a [2:44:36] visibility report that says [2:44:38] that this is feasible despite a [2:44:41] growing movement of San Diegans [2:44:43] who are organizing to fire [2:44:47] Jeanie as Jeanie still filed [2:44:48] for another rate increase 8.6% [2:44:51] on the average monthly bill [2:44:53] That's an extra 20 to 50 a [2:44:54] month. [2:44:55] While all of that scrutiny is [2:44:57] happening, not pausing to read [2:44:59] the room, they're not [2:45:01] questioning whether or not they [2:45:02] should slow down. [2:45:04] They're just they just keep at [2:45:05] it. [2:45:06] Increase after increase after [2:45:08] increase. [2:45:09] And the message that that sends [2:45:11] to us is that they don't think [2:45:13] we have the nerve to have an [2:45:14] honest conversation about [2:45:15] alternatives. [2:45:16] So I think we have a [2:45:17] responsibility to know what our [2:45:19] options are and ensure [2:45:21] the public knows the pros and [2:45:22] cons of those options. [2:45:26] According to the most recent [2:45:28] electric rates report by [2:45:28] the California Public [2:45:30] Advocate's Office over the past [2:45:32] ten years as residential rates [2:45:33] have risen 98% and every single [2:45:39] cent that ibew Local 465 [2:45:42] members have earned in that [2:45:43] same period they've had to [2:45:45] fight for every contract [2:45:47] grievance after grievance. [2:45:48] Nothing handed to you earlier [2:45:52] this year or at the end of last [2:45:55] year as de went after a small [2:45:56] group of workers right to even [2:45:58] hold a union election. [2:46:00] Hiring the most notorious union [2:46:02] busting law firm in America and [2:46:06] tried to take advantage of a [2:46:08] paralyzed federal labor board [2:46:10] to run out the clock on that [2:46:11] vote. [2:46:12] And if it wasn't for the work [2:46:13] of the union they would have [2:46:16] been successful. [2:46:19] >> So when ratepayers see a 90% [2:46:21] or 98% rate increase and ask [2:46:23] for that money went I know it [2:46:26] didn't go to the workers. [2:46:29] It went to a company that will [2:46:30] spend resources fighting just a [2:46:33] handful of its own employees [2:46:34] rights to organize or asking [2:46:36] the rest of us for another 8.6% [2:46:39] . [2:46:39] So I want to make sure we're [2:46:43] really clear about what we're [2:46:44] up against and who we're [2:46:45] standing with. [2:46:47] MS. Mendoza I appreciated what [2:46:49] you said. [2:46:50] We can work together. [2:46:52] Nobody wants to fire [2:46:53] the workers who built the grid [2:46:54] and keep it running. [2:46:57] The conversation is about what [2:46:58] our options are instead of [2:47:00] the status quo Because [2:47:01] the status quo does not work. [2:47:02] The status quo allows a ceo to [2:47:05] earn 236 years worth an average [2:47:08] worker salary in a single year [2:47:09] ,fights its union over a [2:47:11] handful of jobs and squeezes [2:47:13] rate payers for a 98% rate [2:47:14] increase. [2:47:17] All while there's a [2:47:18] conversation happening about [2:47:19] what our options are. [2:47:25] So that context is incredibly [2:47:28] important. [2:47:29] I appreciate the conversation [2:47:30] here today and I again just [2:47:32] want to reiterate why I think [2:47:33] it's so important for us to [2:47:34] keep having it. [2:47:36] >> There were a lot of [2:47:38] important points made in [2:47:39] today's conversation about [2:47:41] the way that everyone feels [2:47:43] these impacts about the way [2:47:45] the city feels, the rising [2:47:47] costs, the way it has a a [2:47:52] domino effect in terms of cost [2:47:53] of living. [2:47:55] And we have this responsibility [2:47:55] . [2:47:59] I did have one one question [2:48:03] that I brought up last time and [2:48:05] I'm curious if there's any [2:48:06] updates. [2:48:06] Last time I asked about Long [2:48:08] Island and the hybrid model [2:48:11] that they pursued. [2:48:14] Have you done any additional [2:48:15] research on that? [2:48:18] Any additional analysis? [2:48:20] We did look into it generally. [2:48:24] Councilmember I think [2:48:24] the important thing to remember [2:48:25] about Long Island so you are [2:48:27] right that the Long Island [2:48:28] Power Authority lpa then has a [2:48:32] relationship with Shute I don't [2:48:35] remember actual utility [2:48:37] operator. [2:48:38] The issue is is that because [2:48:40] Long Island and New England and [2:48:42] most of the East Coast frankly [2:48:43] is in a deregulated [2:48:44] environment. [2:48:46] So it automatically splits kind [2:48:47] of commodity And then you've [2:48:48] got a lot of competing [2:48:50] distributors. [2:48:51] >> They are overseen still by [2:48:53] the state Department of Energy [2:48:55] and Electricity Resources. [2:48:57] And so you still have a state [2:48:59] level regulatory body that [2:49:01] oversees that specific contract [2:49:04] And there are conversations [2:49:05] going on on updates on that [2:49:07] contract that are coming up in [2:49:08] the next several years. [2:49:09] If there is continued interest [2:49:11] in deep diving in here we can [2:49:13] but there's no equivalent model [2:49:16] in a in what was a bundled or a [2:49:18] semi unregulated environment [2:49:20] like Calif in some of the other [2:49:22] larger states have got it. [2:49:24] >> Appreciate that. [2:49:26] General idea though is [2:49:29] the workers don't have to be [2:49:30] displaced from their current [2:49:32] place of work. [2:49:33] They continue to do the work [2:49:34] that they do for who they do [2:49:36] it. [2:49:37] What changes is that company is [2:49:39] now working for the city or [2:49:41] the municipality instead If I [2:49:44] understand the model correctly. [2:49:48] Yes. [2:49:48] Generally what I did not what [2:49:50] we did not necessarily have [2:49:51] time or resources to do was to [2:49:52] dig into the actual contracts [2:49:54] and compare what Long Island [2:49:57] Power Authority has negotiated [2:49:58] with the in this case. [2:50:00] And in that instance you're [2:50:01] talking about us contracting [2:50:02] out to sd Jenny so that that [2:50:05] and how different that is from [2:50:07] say either the workers contract [2:50:11] under that with that system [2:50:13] versus another and how [2:50:15] different say the revenue or [2:50:17] model is versus other areas [2:50:20] where that utility operates [2:50:22] separately? [2:50:24] Okay. [2:50:25] Again, just in terms of us [2:50:29] understanding options, the pros [2:50:30] and cons of those options [2:50:32] hearing what are the main [2:50:33] sources of anxiety that matter [2:50:34] to me here which is hardworking [2:50:37] people not being displaced in [2:50:38] their jobs, not having their [2:50:39] jobs place at risk And that's [2:50:43] seeming to be a thing that was [2:50:45] worked through in that model [2:50:47] While also significantly [2:50:49] reducing management costs. [2:50:51] It just seems like a thing that [2:50:54] we should know as a potential [2:50:55] tool in the tool belt. [2:50:57] I'll just end with this council [2:50:59] PRESIDENT. [2:51:00] I'm glad we're having this [2:51:01] conversation. [2:51:02] I think it's important and I [2:51:05] appreciate Nate your comments. [2:51:09] The reality is is that this is [2:51:11] I don't know that there's a [2:51:13] single issue where I heard have [2:51:14] heard more agreement amongst [2:51:18] folks from different sides of [2:51:19] the political spectrum. [2:51:20] We had some of the most [2:51:20] conservative folks who engage [2:51:22] with the council and some of [2:51:23] the furthest to the left who [2:51:25] are in complete agreement that [2:51:27] what is what we are currently [2:51:28] operating under is [2:51:29] unsustainable and unacceptable. [2:51:32] And if that doesn't show that [2:51:34] the dam is starting to break, [2:51:36] that San Diegans are sick and [2:51:37] tired of paying so much for [2:51:39] their utility bills I don't [2:51:41] know what will. [2:51:42] And it's that's why it's [2:51:43] incumbent upon us to continue [2:51:44] this conversation, continue to [2:51:45] work so that we know what [2:51:46] options we have to both protect [2:51:48] workers and protect ratepayers. [2:51:50] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT. [2:51:51] All right. [2:51:52] Well, thank you Council member [2:51:53] Eli Rivera. [2:51:54] And as a reminder this is an [2:51:55] information item and no motion [2:51:57] is required And I'm going to [2:52:00] jump in at this point. [2:52:02] So I want to start out by [2:52:02] thanking Heather General [2:52:04] Services Team Randy Wilde and [2:52:06] the mayor's office and [2:52:07] the teams that knew Jen and and [2:52:09] for this work And of course [2:52:11] thank you to every member of [2:52:12] the public who showed up [2:52:13] speaking on all sides of [2:52:15] the issue And those who called [2:52:17] in Phase two report was an [2:52:19] equally impressive undertaking [2:52:21] as phase one and provided [2:52:22] greater detail and clarity on a [2:52:24] proposal that is massive in [2:52:26] scale and as complex as [2:52:27] anything we would undertake at [2:52:28] the city. [2:52:29] That does not mean we should [2:52:31] shy away. [2:52:32] We can and will do big things [2:52:34] and win Financial impacts on [2:52:36] residents and businesses is on [2:52:37] the table. [2:52:38] We must be bold. [2:52:40] I will start by highlighting [2:52:41] the opening slide. [2:52:43] I mean it's simple Energy [2:52:44] utility is both economically [2:52:45] feasible and technically [2:52:47] feasible. [2:52:48] That is what the city set out [2:52:49] to determine and should we [2:52:51] decide to proceed there is a [2:52:52] path forward. [2:52:54] Of course that comes with risks [2:52:55] that must be weighed and [2:52:57] assumptions that must be tested [2:52:59] and we will have to find [2:53:01] the right balance. [2:53:02] And whether you feel the study [2:53:03] has been too conservative in [2:53:05] its projections or it MAY take [2:53:07] longer than initially [2:53:08] anticipated. [2:53:09] A municipal energy utility [2:53:10] remains feasible and since [2:53:12] the outset onset of exploring [2:53:14] public power and when I voted [2:53:16] against the current electric [2:53:18] and gas franchises in 2021 I [2:53:21] have talked about the limited [2:53:22] options we have as a city. [2:53:25] But just as we fought for in [2:53:27] the creation of the San Diego [2:53:28] community power in giving [2:53:30] customers options it would be [2:53:33] irresponsible of us not to [2:53:34] pursue pursue alternatives to [2:53:36] our energy distribution system [2:53:37] . [2:53:40] Today's presentation as we've [2:53:41] heard coincidentally perhaps [2:53:43] prophetically comes just days [2:53:45] after sd genius latest general [2:53:47] rate case submitted to the cpc. [2:53:50] And as we've heard from members [2:53:50] of the public sd Janey's own [2:53:53] projections are substantially [2:53:54] higher than the average annual [2:53:56] increase assumed by [2:53:57] the consultants in the study. [2:53:59] >> As an engineer I appreciate [2:54:00] that conservatism moving [2:54:03] forward with this process [2:54:04] demonstrates our commitment to [2:54:06] not sitting back not accepting [2:54:08] the status quo nor remaining [2:54:10] vulnerable to a monopoly but [2:54:12] rather exploring all options to [2:54:14] provide more affordable rates [2:54:17] keeping our options open and [2:54:19] continuing to pursue a [2:54:21] municipal energy utility is in [2:54:23] everyone's best interest. [2:54:25] So for those of you who opposed [2:54:28] this conversation, look into [2:54:31] the faces who can't afford but [2:54:34] don't qualify for subsidies on [2:54:35] their electric bill. [2:54:38] And for those of you who [2:54:39] support, look into the faces of [2:54:41] the workers who are wondering [2:54:43] whether they will still have a [2:54:46] long term career in their [2:54:48] chosen profession. [2:54:49] And a promise today is not [2:54:52] necessarily a promise that will [2:54:53] be kept. [2:54:55] The two sides of a conversation [2:54:58] And for those who oppose [2:55:01] municipal tell me the question [2:55:01] I ask you is what are you doing [2:55:03] to join the city in our efforts [2:55:06] to control rates, to control [2:55:09] the impact or reduce the impact [2:55:11] that is hitting so many San [2:55:13] Diegans? [2:55:15] And if those who spoke that [2:55:18] were prior here at City Hall [2:55:21] let me remind you you let a 50 [2:55:23] year franchise expire with no [2:55:26] game plan to give our city [2:55:28] options or help control rates. [2:55:31] We missed a golden opportunity [2:55:33] and 2021 became a very awkward [2:55:36] year to realize we had no place [2:55:39] to go and a franchise had to be [2:55:42] signed to keep the wheels [2:55:45] turning so to speak. [2:55:47] So this is a difficult [2:55:48] conversation. [2:55:49] I agree with Councilmember Eloy [2:55:50] Rivera. [2:55:51] We should keep our options [2:55:53] open. [2:55:53] We should continue to pursue a [2:55:55] municipal energy utility [2:55:56] because it's in everyone's best [2:55:58] interest. [2:55:59] And until we have sd Jeannie [2:56:01] come to the table, pull that [2:56:04] general rate increase and have [2:56:06] the conversation as one member [2:56:07] of the public I'm not going to [2:56:08] name. [2:56:09] He knows who he is and he [2:56:10] pleasantly surprised me today [2:56:12] and have a real conversation [2:56:14] about how we relook at rates [2:56:17] knowing as some of you have [2:56:19] said that the cpp is not going [2:56:21] to save us. [2:56:22] And as a reminder cpc doesn't [2:56:25] guarantee profits. [2:56:27] They set a profit rate to set [2:56:29] the rates. [2:56:30] And when I won and the investor [2:56:33] owned utility exceeds those [2:56:34] profit rates year after year [2:56:36] after year. [2:56:37] Something has to change. [2:56:39] We have to protect our most [2:56:41] vulnerable individuals who [2:56:42] can't afford what should be a [2:56:45] right of affordable electricity [2:56:47] going forward. [2:56:49] >> So that's where we stand [2:56:50] today. [2:56:51] I agree that we have to keep [2:56:53] this on the table going forward [2:56:53] . [2:56:55] And again, thank you for [2:56:56] the good work in this phase two [2:56:58] study. [2:56:59] With that again this is an [2:57:01] information item no motions [2:57:02] required. [2:57:03] We'll turn to council member [2:57:04] Campbell, the third member of [2:57:06] the Environment Committee. [2:57:08] >> Thank you so much. [2:57:09] Council PRESIDENT When first [2:57:12] elected and thank you for [2:57:15] the presentation and thanks to [2:57:16] the public for all of your [2:57:18] input. [2:57:19] It's a. [2:57:20] Agreed with and appreciated on [2:57:23] all sides. [2:57:24] This is a really complicated [2:57:25] issue and I want to say that [2:57:29] when I was first elected to [2:57:30] council I was appointed chair [2:57:31] of the Environment Committee [2:57:33] That was JANUARY 2019. [2:57:36] First thing I did was lead [2:57:37] the effort to create community [2:57:39] choice aggregation. [2:57:40] In other words, what became San [2:57:43] Diego community power does now [2:57:46] include six cities and our [2:57:48] county government which means [2:57:50] our unincorporated areas. [2:57:52] One of the goals was to provide [2:57:53] cleaner energy options to [2:57:55] reduce the effects of climate [2:57:56] change. [2:57:58] It also gave our communities [2:58:00] more local control over how we [2:58:02] purchase energy And at that [2:58:04] time the city commissioned [2:58:05] the first feasibility study on [2:58:09] municipal izing our energy [2:58:10] utilities, gas and electric. [2:58:13] And since then we have [2:58:14] completed two more studies and [2:58:16] spent millions of dollars on [2:58:19] consultants to tell us about [2:58:24] municipal ization millions of [2:58:25] dollars we could use this year [2:58:26] in our budget or in a year in [2:58:29] our budget. [2:58:31] The findings have always been [2:58:33] clear The estimated cost is at [2:58:37] least 8 billion. [2:58:38] That was the first study that [2:58:40] was seven years ago is probably [2:58:42] 16 billion now and that was [2:58:45] just for the infrastructure [2:58:46] needed. [2:58:47] The city cannot afford this. [2:58:51] That estimate does not include [2:58:53] additional cafs costs staffing [2:58:57] operations and onboarding. [2:58:59] The impact of exit fees on [2:59:01] the other 17 cities that rely [2:59:04] on sd Jeannie system and would [2:59:07] expect us to pay them [2:59:09] the difference or the fact that [2:59:13] we still would need to use sd g [2:59:16] and e for the gas component. [2:59:19] So this study was only about [2:59:21] electricity not the g. [2:59:23] Part of sd g After three [2:59:28] studies we do not need more [2:59:30] analysis. [2:59:31] We already have the information [2:59:33] we need to decide at this point [2:59:35] it is too expensive to continue [2:59:39] to spend billions of dollars on [2:59:41] consultants. [2:59:42] It is way too expensive for [2:59:45] the billions that the city [2:59:46] would have to spend to try to. [2:59:50] To provide this utility. [2:59:53] It is important to know that [2:59:56] the state of California public [2:59:58] utilities Commission, the puc [3:00:01] it says right there in the law [3:00:04] is main responsibility is to [3:00:06] protect ratepayers and also [3:00:10] decide utility rates In so [3:00:13] doing to protect ratepayers. [3:00:16] They're supposed to protect us [3:00:19] . [3:00:19] They don't. [3:00:20] It's supposed to decide utility [3:00:22] rates within mind us consumers [3:00:27] The puc needs to be reformed. [3:00:31] It needs to be held accountable [3:00:34] and I ask you to please [3:00:35] inundate them with emails and [3:00:38] phone calls and letters that [3:00:40] they need to lower sd any rates [3:00:43] not raise them. [3:00:47] Forming San Diego community [3:00:49] power was a good idea and sd [3:00:53] Jeannie was in favor and you [3:00:55] MAY be wondering why Why would [3:00:57] they have been in favor? [3:00:58] Because commercial utilities [3:01:01] are not allowed to make a [3:01:02] profit on what it costs them to [3:01:05] buy the power to make [3:01:06] electricity And so they handed [3:01:09] this off gladly to the San [3:01:12] Diego community power. [3:01:14] Do you know that 95% of [3:01:16] electric customers have signed [3:01:18] up for San Diego community [3:01:19] power? [3:01:21] It's a good thing It's been [3:01:24] very successful. [3:01:25] It has millions of dollars in [3:01:28] its reserve. [3:01:29] The question is why have they [3:01:32] not lowered their rates? [3:01:35] We need to have them come in [3:01:36] and answer that for us. [3:01:39] Meantime, we need to stop [3:01:41] spending on consultant reports [3:01:42] . [3:01:44] I think this last one was $3 [3:01:45] million. [3:01:47] It's ridiculous. [3:01:48] Is going to come out the same [3:01:49] every time. [3:01:50] It's very, very expensive And [3:01:53] the city has 100 and $100 [3:01:56] million deficit It can't even [3:01:57] meet And we're supposed to [3:02:01] spend 8,000,000,008 billion 60 [3:02:02] billion to become an electric [3:02:04] company? [3:02:05] No, no, no. [3:02:06] That doesn't make any sense at [3:02:08] all. [3:02:09] We cannot afford to be a power [3:02:11] company In the meantime, as dg [3:02:15] and his top executives and [3:02:16] those of many other [3:02:17] corporations in this nation [3:02:20] need to decide how many [3:02:22] millions of dollars a year do [3:02:24] they need to live on? [3:02:25] This is ridiculous. [3:02:27] Just as my my colleague [3:02:30] Councilmember Ella Rivera said, [3:02:32] the guy in 2025 made $25 [3:02:35] million a year. [3:02:37] It's ridiculous. [3:02:39] Think if you only made a couple [3:02:40] of million dollars a year how [3:02:42] many rates could be lowered? [3:02:45] Quite a few. [3:02:46] Quite a few. [3:02:47] And so I say to all the top [3:02:49] executives of the corporations [3:02:51] in this nation how much money [3:02:54] do you really need at the cost [3:02:59] of making your consumers poor? [3:03:03] Greed is evil. [3:03:05] Stop practicing it. [3:03:07] >> Thank you. [3:03:08] Council PRESIDENT All right. [3:03:10] Thank you, Council member [3:03:11] Campbell. [3:03:12] We'll go next to council member [3:03:13] Von Walbert. [3:03:14] Thank you very much for your [3:03:16] work today and for [3:03:17] the presentation. [3:03:17] Thank you for everyone who's [3:03:19] come in today to express a very [3:03:22] justified frustration over [3:03:24] the fact that effigy enables [3:03:25] continue to go up including our [3:03:27] own workers who also don't want [3:03:29] to pay that. [3:03:30] And I want to thank the workers [3:03:31] who came in, especially our [3:03:33] veterans who served in Iraq and [3:03:35] Afghanistan. [3:03:36] I can't imagine what you've [3:03:37] seen. [3:03:38] You know, this past Memorial [3:03:40] Day we just did a memorial [3:03:42] commemorations only for folks [3:03:44] who died in the Afghanistan and [3:03:46] Iraqi wars because they were [3:03:47] our generation. [3:03:50] And so just know that you have [3:03:51] sacrificed a lot in coming in [3:03:53] and getting training from ibew [3:03:54] which is one of the most [3:03:55] incredible veterans transition [3:03:57] employers in this country is [3:03:59] fantastic And I want to thank [3:04:01] you for continuing to do that [3:04:01] work. [3:04:02] So I know that we up here care [3:04:03] about you. [3:04:04] We care about union workers And [3:04:05] I'm going to show you why what [3:04:06] we're going to do. [3:04:08] I also want to thank [3:04:09] the environmentalist who came [3:04:10] in San Diego 350 and everyone [3:04:11] who's been trying to take away [3:04:13] the monopoly power of this [3:04:15] company as we should our our [3:04:18] public power should not be a [3:04:19] monopoly. [3:04:20] We should not be paying $22 [3:04:22] million alone To the ceo [3:04:25] Jeffrey Martin of Sempra last [3:04:27] year. [3:04:28] We just should none of us have [3:04:30] a choice about whether or not [3:04:31] we pay a fee. [3:04:32] You need to keep our power on [3:04:34] but I want everyone who's in [3:04:36] the room all the union workers [3:04:37] especially or anyone who works [3:04:38] at a job to pay attention to [3:04:39] this. [3:04:40] This is a public website from [3:04:42] the Office of Labor Management [3:04:43] Standards. [3:04:43] It's under the Department of [3:04:45] Labor. [3:04:46] You can check this website to [3:04:47] see if your employer is paying [3:04:49] union busters for the most [3:04:51] part. [3:04:52] We'll get to Jackson Lewis go [3:04:53] to the next slide please. [3:04:54] We did check this website when [3:04:56] we had to renew the franchise [3:04:58] agreement as council PRESIDENT [3:04:59] LaCava said and we all got [3:05:00] elected up here. [3:05:02] We were forced with this [3:05:04] renewal for stg and our [3:05:05] predecessors didn't do anything [3:05:06] about it and left it in our [3:05:08] laps This is a formal Clinton [3:05:09] report. [3:05:10] You can see it highlighted. [3:05:11] It's from c, g and e Studio gas [3:05:13] and electric from 2019. [3:05:14] Please go to the next slide. [3:05:16] This is a public report. [3:05:17] They have two to show if [3:05:19] they're going to hire union [3:05:19] busters they are public facing [3:05:22] in 2019 as you paid tens of [3:05:25] thousands of dollars of our [3:05:26] rate payer money to hire crews [3:05:28] and associates to be their [3:05:29] independent labor consultant [3:05:30] who is known nationwide to be [3:05:32] one of the biggest union [3:05:33] busters in the nation. [3:05:35] They were trying to rent steel [3:05:37] you need from hiring from [3:05:37] unionizing the coal center [3:05:39] workers And I know ibew came to [3:05:41] the call center Workers Aid and [3:05:42] made sure this didn't happen [3:05:43] before the next slide please. [3:05:45] This is the one from 2018 which [3:05:48] you can see Crews Associates [3:05:49] was paid This one I think was [3:05:50] signed by Scott Crider who is [3:05:52] now I believe the ceo of cgt. [3:05:55] They paid them $33,000 to hire [3:05:57] union busters to fight [3:05:59] The unionized work to cgt had [3:06:00] been hiring union busters And [3:06:02] when they came to this Dyess to [3:06:03] get a renewal I required cgt [3:06:06] their ceo to say they would not [3:06:08] hire union busters again with [3:06:09] our money And you agreed? [3:06:13] I think at the end of [3:06:13] the slides you do down And so [3:06:17] I'm really upset to see that [3:06:19] when ibew tried to get some of [3:06:21] their supervisor employees who [3:06:23] don't actually supervise anyone [3:06:24] into the union which is a [3:06:25] common union busting tactic for [3:06:26] an employer to say they have [3:06:29] supervisory responsibilities [3:06:30] which they don't You hired [3:06:32] Jackson Lewis but guess what? [3:06:34] You don't have to report that [3:06:35] because there's a loophole in [3:06:37] federal law that says if you [3:06:38] hire a lawyer to you your union [3:06:39] busting you can call it legal [3:06:41] services. [3:06:43] Congress can change this law [3:06:44] and I hope they do. [3:06:45] They haven't anyway, I am sick [3:06:47] and tired of seeing cgt crush [3:06:49] its workers at our expense and [3:06:51] I want you to know that [3:06:52] everyone on this diet is going [3:06:53] to work hard to make sure [3:06:54] whatever transition happens [3:06:56] union jobs are protected. [3:06:58] You do incredibly hard work at [3:07:00] a high voltage and none of us [3:07:01] are trying to do and we [3:07:02] respected value for that. [3:07:04] If you need me on a strike line [3:07:05] call me. [3:07:05] I'll be there. [3:07:07] That said, I'm questions First [3:07:13] of all what would taking over [3:07:16] the power structure look [3:07:19] the power infrastructure look [3:07:20] like Obviously you need is not [3:07:22] willing to sell their assets. [3:07:23] So legally what would the city [3:07:24] do if we were to do that? [3:07:28] >> So if we use the San [3:07:29] Francisco model as the current [3:07:32] Calif fornia template San [3:07:35] Francisco City County they're [3:07:36] all one thing did make an offer [3:07:39] to pge to purchase the wires in [3:07:42] their system and you kind of [3:07:44] didn't pick up the phone So San [3:07:45] Francisco petitioned to [3:07:46] the cpsc which regulates pge to [3:07:51] require pge to to establish a [3:07:54] purchase price. [3:07:55] >> So that is as Scott [3:07:57] mentioned, the biggest variable [3:07:58] about how all of this modeling [3:08:00] and economics really works [3:08:01] where feasible, where your cash [3:08:02] flow is, etc. That is now a [3:08:05] process that is ongoing. [3:08:06] The first decision came out in [3:08:08] the fall and that set [3:08:10] the framework of what has to [3:08:12] happen afterwards which [3:08:14] includes prey's appraisals of [3:08:16] the system by both parties, [3:08:17] multiple different valuations [3:08:19] and a basic set of principles [3:08:21] regarding things like just [3:08:23] compensation etc. So we know [3:08:26] that that step is in there. [3:08:30] >> There is our current [3:08:32] understanding and I will I am [3:08:33] not a lawyer so a grain of salt [3:08:36] a high probability that at some [3:08:38] point an action like this would [3:08:40] probably need to go to [3:08:41] the ballot. [3:08:43] And so one of the I would say [3:08:45] the next step that moves this [3:08:46] past feasibility if there is [3:08:48] interest in continuing this [3:08:49] effort is moves it into [3:08:52] the kind of political [3:08:54] regulatory legal area. [3:08:59] >> What that looks like really [3:09:01] frankly is a discussion and [3:09:03] guidance that will be given to [3:09:04] staff from discussions between [3:09:07] the mayor's office and council [3:09:09] Randi, I don't know if you have [3:09:09] anything to add. [3:09:14] I would say that there is not [3:09:16] currently allocated resources [3:09:17] to go hire more consultants or [3:09:20] staff resources to go do a lot [3:09:23] of that work in this current [3:09:24] fiscal year. [3:09:25] So our intention is to watch [3:09:26] closely what happens with [3:09:28] the San Francisco case. [3:09:29] Well not exactly the same [3:09:30] scenario as what would be [3:09:33] the case in San Diego for a [3:09:34] number of different reasons [3:09:35] would certainly set a lot of [3:09:37] precedents in terms of [3:09:38] the valuation methodology and [3:09:40] the process that the city of [3:09:42] San Diego would go through. [3:09:43] I think there's other decisions [3:09:44] that would need to be made if [3:09:46] the city were to move forward, [3:09:47] what would be the structure of [3:09:48] the new entity? [3:09:50] Would that be a special [3:09:51] district as recommended in [3:09:52] the report? [3:09:53] What type of a special district [3:09:54] would that be? [3:09:56] That MAY or MAY not require a [3:09:57] ballot measure or a vote of [3:09:59] the people depending on how [3:10:00] that structured MAY or MAY not [3:10:01] require less co component. [3:10:04] Again, I'm also not an attorney [3:10:05] so I would defer to them on [3:10:06] that. [3:10:07] But there's a number of [3:10:07] different decisions that need [3:10:08] to be made about the structure [3:10:10] and the process. [3:10:11] But I think that the highest [3:10:12] priority for us since this is [3:10:14] kind of the new process [3:10:16] established by the state is [3:10:17] through this cpc is to really [3:10:19] monitor closely what happens in [3:10:20] the San Francisco pge case. [3:10:23] Okay. [3:10:24] i have a question for a [3:10:24] question about the district. [3:10:25] So I, I, I do believe that [3:10:29] the power system should be [3:10:30] governed by a nonprofit. [3:10:32] I do not believe the city of [3:10:34] San Diego as a beautiful [3:10:35] corporation is ready to take [3:10:36] this on. [3:10:38] We can barely operate a water [3:10:39] department. [3:10:41] We are struggling to figure out [3:10:42] if we can deploy our own [3:10:43] ambulance system if we have to [3:10:44] bring that in-house. [3:10:45] But I do believe there's [3:10:47] another opportunity and that is [3:10:48] what Sacramento did with [3:10:50] the Sacramento Municipal [3:10:51] Utility District And this is [3:10:52] what I hope the advocates [3:10:53] listen to the city ceo you you [3:10:56] get a sales tax passed last [3:10:57] year because voters didn't [3:10:58] trust us. [3:10:59] I think the better option is [3:11:01] not to saddle this on the city [3:11:02] the better option is to create [3:11:04] a public utility district which [3:11:06] is run by experts And but [3:11:08] the only way anyone would vote [3:11:10] for this and I would vote for [3:11:11] this is if there was concrete [3:11:13] new protections for union [3:11:14] workers and they should have a [3:11:15] role in the ballot measure if [3:11:16] we're ever to get to that point [3:11:18] because there's no way I would [3:11:20] You're working with us and we [3:11:20] need our workers to provide [3:11:21] the power we need anyway. [3:11:24] So how would that process look [3:11:25] like? [3:11:27] >> As Randy mentioned, [3:11:29] the special district process [3:11:30] looks different depending on [3:11:32] one or multiple parties going [3:11:34] after it. [3:11:35] This is all kind of outlined in [3:11:37] California Public utilities [3:11:38] code so various structures [3:11:42] require votes by council and [3:11:47] then going to the ballot Some [3:11:48] of them it can be go to [3:11:49] the ballot directly. [3:11:50] So a lot of it is the structure [3:11:52] that is put in place and [3:11:53] therefore the special district [3:11:54] is defined by public utility [3:11:56] code. [3:11:56] I'm happy to follow up with you [3:11:58] with those specific areas of [3:11:59] law. [3:11:59] I do not want to even attempt [3:12:00] to quote them off the cuff yet. [3:12:03] >> Sounds like a lack of [3:12:03] question. [3:12:07] Understood that a question [3:12:07] about this valuation I have a [3:12:09] feeling it's going to be much [3:12:10] higher than what's even the $7 [3:12:11] billion just because you know I [3:12:14] don't think you do You wouldn't [3:12:16] willingly sell its assets which [3:12:18] means it would go to some kind [3:12:19] of eminent domain for closure. [3:12:22] I don't know. [3:12:22] And that would be litigated [3:12:23] every step of the way which [3:12:25] would increase the cost [3:12:26] exponentially. [3:12:26] So just I have a feeling that [3:12:29] what's going to happen in San [3:12:29] Francisco a wealthy the one [3:12:33] thing I do give you credit for [3:12:35] every time we're here is [3:12:37] the wildfire work they are [3:12:38] doing which the Witch Creek [3:12:40] Fire didn't have to happen to [3:12:41] have that led down that path by [3:12:43] the emergency operation center [3:12:45] to see if you need to start up [3:12:46] is state of the art. [3:12:47] It's incredible. [3:12:49] It's catching fires left and [3:12:50] right And I appreciate the fact [3:12:51] that they've also invested in [3:12:52] wildfire attack helicopters. [3:12:54] So does this study also [3:12:56] encapsulate the cost of taking [3:12:58] over the emergency operations [3:12:59] center Because we cannot take [3:13:01] over utility if we're not going [3:13:02] to protect us from wildfires. [3:13:05] It doesn't because the vast [3:13:06] majority of the area that [3:13:09] the eoc monitors is not within [3:13:13] the city of San Diego. [3:13:14] It does imagine a portion of [3:13:16] the costs that currently are [3:13:17] expended within wildfire [3:13:18] mitigation as a part of [3:13:20] the overall operating costs and [3:13:22] thus a revenue requirement for [3:13:24] the utility as well as pieces [3:13:27] of you know there's someone [3:13:29] mentioned liability so there's [3:13:30] liability insurance etc. So [3:13:32] that would need to be carried [3:13:33] for those areas that are [3:13:34] subject to it. [3:13:35] But again I think it's [3:13:37] remembering that if you're [3:13:38] separating out the system, what [3:13:40] now there also then would need [3:13:42] to be coordination between [3:13:43] the two and that kind of goes [3:13:45] to about just compensation [3:13:47] piece of how much has already [3:13:50] been paid for by San Diego [3:13:53] ratepayers how much would [3:13:55] therefore need to be And some [3:13:56] of that is also subject to you [3:14:00] know the cpc as was mentioned [3:14:01] as dgt makes a revenue request [3:14:02] specifically within [3:14:03] the wildfire mitigation fund [3:14:05] that includes the cost of [3:14:06] operation of the that's the cpc [3:14:07] then decides how much of that [3:14:08] can and cannot be rate based or [3:14:10] should or should not be [3:14:11] expended. [3:14:13] And so what role for [3:14:15] the municipal utility in an [3:14:19] area that is definitely at risk [3:14:22] because of fires in not its [3:14:23] territory pays and plays in [3:14:26] the operations to ensure that [3:14:28] those fires don't get anywhere [3:14:30] near the territory would all be [3:14:32] part of the negotiations [3:14:33] between the parties. [3:14:34] So the feasibility study [3:14:35] incorporates modeled costs for [3:14:39] that but it doesn't outline for [3:14:41] a whole bunch of reasons how [3:14:42] specifically those negotiations [3:14:44] would go because simply we [3:14:45] can't speak for the other side [3:14:46] of the table. [3:14:48] Okay, got it. [3:14:50] But that would be something [3:14:50] that's incredibly important [3:14:52] that needs to be thought about. [3:14:54] Absolutely. [3:14:56] Yeah, I was I suppose you would [3:14:58] require utility to do something [3:14:59] similar So we satellite involve [3:15:02] ours of another state but there [3:15:03] are many things I wish the cbc [3:15:04] would do. [3:15:06] Okay. [3:15:06] Okay. [3:15:07] My last my colleagues have [3:15:11] covered a lot of this. [3:15:12] I mean what about the fact that [3:15:14] there's an 8.6% request for a [3:15:16] rate hike and the feasibility [3:15:17] study had anticipated four per [3:15:19] year? [3:15:19] You know what is this large [3:15:20] hike that I see Judy want to [3:15:22] add to our bills once again due [3:15:24] to the feasibility study? [3:15:26] Sure. [3:15:26] So I think some of the thing to [3:15:28] remember is over a 30 year [3:15:29] horizon we specifically picked [3:15:30] 4% one because historically in [3:15:32] the past two grc that's [3:15:34] approximately been the end [3:15:36] decision. [3:15:37] So cgu usually asks for more [3:15:39] money and then it gets cut down [3:15:41] through the grc process. [3:15:44] So fundamentally if you look at [3:15:46] that sensitivity graph, [3:15:48] the higher the rate increase [3:15:50] annually for us, Jenny, [3:15:52] the more cumulative benefit [3:15:53] there would be for utility that [3:15:56] is only replacing its revenue [3:15:58] requirements, right? [3:16:00] And so you can kind of say if [3:16:02] their rates are significantly [3:16:03] higher than they're saying [3:16:04] their revenue requirement is [3:16:06] significantly higher than [3:16:07] the That's what that [3:16:08] distinction is because this is [3:16:12] just their proposal. [3:16:12] We don't know what the cpc is [3:16:14] going to decide And because it [3:16:15] is frankly only a four year [3:16:17] picture and we're trying to do [3:16:18] a 30 year model providing a [3:16:22] conservative estimate is gives [3:16:25] us and it's still feasible at [3:16:27] 4% then at 6% it is also [3:16:29] feasible from an economic [3:16:31] perspective at 8% it is still [3:16:33] feasible from an economic [3:16:34] perspective. [3:16:34] So it's 8% increase in 20 I'm [3:16:38] sorry it's overall in [3:16:40] the system it's actually a 5% [3:16:42] increase in f y 28 sorry in [3:16:44] 2028 from 2027 rates So we [3:16:47] haven't seen those yet. [3:16:49] 2028 is 8.5% and then 20 sorry [3:16:53] 2029 is 8.5% and then 2030 and [3:16:54] 2031 about 5.5%. [3:16:56] So again we're trying to blend [3:16:57] out a 30 year annual rate [3:17:00] increase in order to make those [3:17:02] numbers line up accurately and [3:17:05] ensure when we say it's [3:17:06] economically feasible you're [3:17:08] doing that with a responsibly [3:17:12] conservative number on [3:17:14] the Jenny side so you're not [3:17:17] overpromising savings that MAY [3:17:18] or MAY not manifest. [3:17:20] Okay. [3:17:21] Understood. [3:17:21] Thank you. [3:17:22] Thank you for the update. [3:17:24] Thank you for going down this [3:17:25] incredibly complex study and [3:17:28] what we're trying to do to at [3:17:29] least give the city and [3:17:31] the residents who live here [3:17:32] some kind of negotiating power [3:17:33] over city. [3:17:36] You know, it's very hard to do [3:17:38] that when did the monopoly but [3:17:40] it has to include protections [3:17:41] for our workers who work very [3:17:43] hard to make sure the lights [3:17:44] and the gas are literally [3:17:45] turned on every day And it [3:17:47] needs to account for [3:17:48] the catastrophic litigation [3:17:51] costs that are going to come [3:17:52] with trying to separate from [3:17:53] this. [3:17:54] But again, that's why I think [3:17:55] the utility district would be [3:17:56] better to take this on to [3:17:57] the city of San Diego itself [3:17:59] because that could be a fight [3:18:01] the good fight the city and I [3:18:02] don't think we can do this on [3:18:03] our own in a city needs to [3:18:08] charge lower rates. [3:18:10] We have no ability to handle [3:18:13] that here at the city of San [3:18:14] Diego We did Under California [3:18:15] state law it is Sacramento to [3:18:18] decide how and when a city [3:18:19] charges its rates. [3:18:20] However, in the next few years [3:18:22] in 20 2030 our franchise [3:18:25] agreement could be opened up [3:18:26] again by the future City [3:18:27] Council who sits here. [3:18:28] I will be termed out. [3:18:29] Many of us will be turned out [3:18:30] but we are trying to do is make [3:18:31] sure that 2030 if the future [3:18:33] Council wants to put [3:18:34] the pressure on cgt to lower [3:18:36] rates they will now be able to [3:18:37] do that because of the work [3:18:38] we're doing going down this [3:18:40] road with the public [3:18:41] marketability study and we need [3:18:42] to continue to strengthen our [3:18:43] hand to lower rates for our [3:18:44] state. [3:18:45] You need to they charge too [3:18:46] much. [3:18:47] Thank you. [3:18:48] All right. [3:18:49] Thank you, gentlemen. [3:18:50] Bonneville We'll go next to [3:18:50] Councilmember Flippen. [3:18:52] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT. [3:18:54] First of all, thank you to [3:18:55] everybody who provided public [3:18:58] comment this afternoon. [3:18:59] I took a lot of notes, very [3:19:00] interesting comments from [3:19:03] everybody here appreciated that [3:19:04] I have a few questions for our [3:19:06] consultant There is it says [3:19:09] the potential for average [3:19:11] customer savings of $500 a year [3:19:14] or which would equate to about [3:19:16] $42 about the end of the 30 [3:19:19] year study period is that in [3:19:22] today's dollars 30 years from [3:19:25] now $42 MAY not seem like that [3:19:29] much. [3:19:30] So if you say the potential [3:19:30] savings then would be [3:19:32] the equivalent of what $42 [3:19:34] about this today or would it be [3:19:37] $42.30 years from now to [3:19:39] the extent the analysis is [3:19:40] looking at a sort of average [3:19:41] bill, it would be in today's [3:19:42] dollars We're looking at [3:19:43] the percentage that were [3:19:45] proposed or was projected to be [3:19:47] relative to the savings. [3:19:50] And looking at the flip side, [3:19:52] you talk about the risk What [3:19:55] would be the worst case [3:19:56] scenario if things went south [3:20:00] in term in real terms what bad [3:20:02] things could happen to the city [3:20:07] in terms of what bad things I [3:20:09] mean, you know, who knows, [3:20:10] right? [3:20:11] I mean you could say that that [3:20:13] I mean I don't really know that [3:20:16] to tell you the truth. [3:20:17] But what bad things could [3:20:18] happen is that is that the you [3:20:20] know, the utility could incur [3:20:22] you know, costs like any other [3:20:24] utility incurred costs and have [3:20:26] to pass those costs on to a [3:20:27] ratepayer right Just in terms [3:20:29] of commodity cost, in terms of [3:20:33] all the costs that it takes [3:20:36] operating ability there's [3:20:37] there's always a potential [3:20:38] those costs could exceed beyond [3:20:40] what anybody could imagine and [3:20:43] then in which case those costs [3:20:44] would have to be recovered by [3:20:46] ratepayers. [3:20:46] Okay. [3:20:47] So essentially you're not [3:20:49] seeing a lot of financial risk [3:20:52] for the city as I mean it's a [3:20:55] poor entity in of itself. [3:20:56] You would see the financial [3:20:57] risk as being contained within [3:20:59] the utility structure. [3:21:02] Okay. [3:21:05] You've prepared a 200 page [3:21:07] report and analysis on [3:21:10] the feasibility Based on what [3:21:12] you know in your expertise, do [3:21:14] you think that San Diego should [3:21:15] go to a minimal utility? [3:21:17] I believe the report suggests [3:21:18] that it's financially feasible [3:21:20] to do so. [3:21:22] Okay. [3:21:24] I will turn now to the Office [3:21:26] of the Independent Budget [3:21:27] Analyst MR. Boer, your thoughts [3:21:31] on this? [3:21:35] My thoughts on this are many So [3:21:40] I will tell you what I've been [3:21:42] telling sort of leading up to [3:21:43] this meeting. [3:21:43] >> I've had many meetings I've [3:21:45] met with general Services, I've [3:21:46] met with Public power San [3:21:47] Diego, I've met with San Diego [3:21:49] Gas and Electric all three [3:21:51] entities the same thing. [3:21:52] We've had three studies. [3:21:54] They're all directionally [3:21:55] pointing the same direction [3:21:57] which is yeah, it's most likely [3:21:58] economically feasible. [3:22:00] The questions that are still [3:22:02] being raised how much is it [3:22:04] going to cost? [3:22:04] What's the revenue projections [3:22:06] going to look like? [3:22:07] Those types of things Another [3:22:09] study is not going to tell you [3:22:10] because there are things that [3:22:12] need to be worked out either [3:22:13] through the cpc proceeding or [3:22:16] somebody writing down on a [3:22:18] ballot measure What is this [3:22:20] thing going to look like? [3:22:21] What is structure going to be [3:22:22] and how is it going to operate [3:22:24] And then sending that ballot [3:22:25] measure to the people for a [3:22:26] decision. [3:22:27] So at this point I think [3:22:29] the study is sound. [3:22:31] It's a sound of the committee. [3:22:32] It's showing a path that could [3:22:34] be taken with known risks At [3:22:37] this point as Heather kind of [3:22:39] alluded to earlier, it's now a [3:22:41] policy decision on what [3:22:43] the people want to do. [3:22:44] How would you want to frame it [3:22:45] and how would you want to craft [3:22:46] If you want to craft a ballot [3:22:48] measure, how is that going to [3:22:49] look That will start answering [3:22:51] a lot of the questions that are [3:22:53] here today but it's kind of [3:22:56] going above the staff paper of [3:22:58] you know what they can answer [3:23:00] for you. [3:23:02] Okay. [3:23:05] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT. [3:23:06] All right. [3:23:07] Thank you, gentlemen. [3:23:08] Whitburn we'll go next to [3:23:09] Council member Campion Thank [3:23:11] you very much, Council [3:23:12] PRESIDENT And thank you to [3:23:13] the public for your [3:23:14] participation today. [3:23:18] Obviously a very big [3:23:19] conversation for our city [3:23:20] talking about over $10 billion [3:23:23] in one way or another in cost [3:23:26] and potentially more than that [3:23:27] in savings. [3:23:29] I want to get to the heart of [3:23:31] some key questions that keep [3:23:34] coming up in this is it's not [3:23:36] very often we have both sides [3:23:37] of the debate here to be able [3:23:39] to answer them. [3:23:40] I think the first thing I want [3:23:41] to point out is that we're not [3:23:42] going to get anywhere without [3:23:44] our workers who repair [3:23:47] the lines and make sure our [3:23:48] energy gets to our hospitals. [3:23:50] Schools and homes are taken [3:23:51] care of and that their jobs are [3:23:54] protected because they're just [3:23:55] too many livelihoods at risk to [3:23:57] make sure that they don't don't [3:24:00] get to continue their careers, [3:24:02] have their retirements [3:24:03] protected and their families [3:24:05] cared for. [3:24:08] The representative from sd [3:24:10] Eugenie would come to that [3:24:12] answer a few questions just [3:24:13] very directly. [3:24:20] Thank you. [3:24:20] MRS.. [3:24:22] Thank you for being here. [3:24:24] Given the report that's in [3:24:25] front of us very explicitly and [3:24:28] directly, what is the issue [3:24:30] that you believe makes whether [3:24:34] it's municipal ization or a [3:24:37] nonprofit utility which are [3:24:39] very close to the same in this [3:24:41] debate? [3:24:42] What's what do you think is [3:24:44] the most risky part of that [3:24:47] plan? [3:24:47] Sure. [3:24:48] I think the riskiest part of [3:24:49] the plan is the cost. [3:24:50] I don't think this report [3:24:52] captures the full cost to [3:24:54] acquire our assets And as I was [3:24:57] talking about the exit fee to [3:24:58] make other customers whole. [3:25:00] So if you even take the 9 [3:25:04] billion just to acquire [3:25:05] the assets, separate [3:25:06] the separate the system and [3:25:09] then ensure that the other [3:25:11] cities in our territory. [3:25:13] Chula Vista Imperial Beach [3:25:16] Alcohol and Carlsbad don't see [3:25:18] a significant rate increase [3:25:19] when the city leaves The city [3:25:21] of San Diego would have to pay [3:25:23] a significant fee to ensure [3:25:25] that that that doesn't happen. [3:25:26] That would be billions of [3:25:28] dollars. [3:25:28] So you're taking an asset to [3:25:31] purchase the assets of $9.3 [3:25:34] billion and then several [3:25:35] billion dollars on top of that. [3:25:37] The feasibility study itself [3:25:38] says that it's $7.5 billion. [3:25:41] There will be a rate increase [3:25:43] for the first 12 years. [3:25:44] Then at some point rates going [3:25:46] to flatten out And in 30 years [3:25:48] there's a very de minimus [3:25:50] decrease in rates. [3:25:51] I can just things that we can [3:25:53] be doing right now to reduce [3:25:54] rates that we'd love to work [3:25:56] with the City council on. [3:25:57] I think I've talked to many of [3:25:58] your officers about this Almost [3:26:00] 30% of our bills are made up of [3:26:03] state mandates and we would [3:26:04] love to work with the city [3:26:05] the city council. [3:26:06] We're happy to come in to talk [3:26:08] to you. [3:26:08] Let's work at this at [3:26:09] Sacramento and take these cost [3:26:12] ineffective things out of our [3:26:13] bills would immediately reduce [3:26:15] bills JANUARY first. [3:26:18] Okay. [3:26:18] Thank you. [3:26:18] Okay. [3:26:20] From public power San Diego [3:26:23] the issue of the cost. [3:26:26] But when I looked at [3:26:28] the spreadsheet realizing that [3:26:30] 4% was the 4%, was it assumed [3:26:34] increase in electrical rates [3:26:36] annually? [3:26:37] Right. [3:26:38] I think far higher than that in [3:26:39] the last ten years. [3:26:40] Right. [3:26:40] Almost a doubling in 13 years. [3:26:43] 14 years, something like that. [3:26:44] Correct? [3:26:45] Generally speaking, yes. [3:26:46] Okay. [3:26:47] So the cost of the system [3:26:49] relative to the cost to [3:26:51] the ratepayers that we're [3:26:53] seeing someone from San Diego, [3:26:56] what would you address that [3:26:57] issue related to [3:26:58] the disassociation cost that [3:27:00] we're going to have to pay to [3:27:02] the other municipalities [3:27:04] Because I know that one model [3:27:06] of this is to not take over [3:27:07] the transmission. [3:27:08] It's only to take over [3:27:10] the distribution. [3:27:12] What's your response to what [3:27:13] MRS. Just said about that fee [3:27:16] We'd have to pay other cities. [3:27:18] Well there is no fee yet that [3:27:21] we might pay. [3:27:21] I think I would side with I [3:27:24] think Heather's comment that [3:27:26] all of this would be a [3:27:27] negotiation. [3:27:29] We don't know where that's [3:27:30] going to land. [3:27:31] We talked about how much fire [3:27:34] exposure we have as a city That [3:27:36] would be it's partly in [3:27:37] the model already but this idea [3:27:40] that there are billions pending [3:27:43] that we would have to pay is [3:27:45] based on nothing at this point [3:27:48] That would be something we [3:27:50] would discuss. [3:27:50] But keep in mind the electrical [3:27:53] workers would stay. [3:27:55] They would be maintaining [3:27:56] the system. [3:27:56] I just wanted you to focus on [3:27:58] that part portion that she [3:27:59] brought up. [3:28:00] I know there's lots of [3:28:01] components that have been [3:28:01] brought up to date but you're [3:28:02] telling me we just don't know [3:28:04] what that true cost to [3:28:05] the associate would be here? [3:28:06] Would there be no cost if we [3:28:07] just did distribution instead [3:28:09] of taking over transmission [3:28:10] lines or the beauty of doing [3:28:12] distribution? [3:28:13] Not only is we would have no [3:28:16] lack of exposure so we have [3:28:18] years of delay to to look at [3:28:20] this but it's important to know [3:28:23] that those electrical workers [3:28:25] would be maintaining and [3:28:26] operating the system in San [3:28:28] Diego. [3:28:29] Those costs wouldn't be costs [3:28:31] that other cities would bear. [3:28:33] We would bear our own cost So [3:28:35] it's very much to be negotiated [3:28:37] what additional costs we might [3:28:39] have to bear as well. [3:28:40] Okay. [3:28:41] One second. [3:28:42] Given that our business manager [3:28:43] for these workers here in [3:28:45] the room, MR. Ferryman, can I [3:28:46] ask you a quick question [3:28:47] related to that component of [3:28:49] this potential model? [3:28:51] What impact on workers could [3:28:51] you guys work on all [3:28:52] the electrical lines We're [3:28:57] going to get some I'm here with [3:28:57] Nate. [3:28:58] Okay. [3:28:58] Thank you for being here. [3:29:02] The transmission versus [3:29:03] distribution concept here [3:29:06] the transmission lines cross [3:29:07] municipal boundaries that I [3:29:09] understand could open us up to [3:29:11] a price We have to pay other [3:29:13] municipalities but just a [3:29:13] distribution. [3:29:14] How many workers of that would [3:29:16] it impact that you represent? [3:29:20] I would say anywhere from 100 [3:29:22] to 200 directly but then you're [3:29:24] reducing the size of [3:29:26] the primary group at as many as [3:29:28] your lowering their bargaining [3:29:29] strength indirectly about 1800 [3:29:32] directly about 1 to 200. [3:29:34] Okay, understood. [3:29:35] So MRS. If we did a [3:29:39] distribution model as opposed [3:29:41] to taking over any transmission [3:29:43] lines, would we still be [3:29:45] exposed to those cut off fees [3:29:48] or or exit fees please? [3:29:51] Absolutely. [3:29:52] If you're taking out a portion [3:29:54] of our system and a portion of [3:29:55] our customers, those costs that [3:29:58] are fixed costs are still going [3:29:59] to need to be spread across [3:30:00] the remaining customers And now [3:30:02] you no longer have the city of [3:30:04] San Diego as part of that as [3:30:07] part of those customers paying [3:30:08] for those other costs. [3:30:09] So absolutely if you separate [3:30:11] the distribution cost out, [3:30:12] the remaining customers will [3:30:14] still see an increased cost. [3:30:16] Okay. [3:30:17] Transmission is where sd Genie [3:30:19] makes its profit. [3:30:20] Correct? [3:30:23] I don't understand. [3:30:24] So generation of the energy you [3:30:26] have to sell it at the value it [3:30:28] costs you to do it So there's [3:30:29] no profit on the actual [3:30:30] creation of it. [3:30:31] The profit margin comes from [3:30:33] the transmission cost from [3:30:35] where it's generated out to [3:30:36] the customers, correct? [3:30:38] Well, the profit comes from [3:30:39] both the distribute and [3:30:41] the transmission. [3:30:41] Okay. [3:30:42] So it's from our infrastructure [3:30:44] that we build everything from [3:30:46] that batteries, transmission [3:30:47] lines, distribution lines It's [3:30:49] the entire infrastructure [3:30:50] system. [3:30:51] Okay. [3:30:52] I guess a question as it [3:30:53] relates to the economics of [3:30:54] this is the transmission [3:31:00] crosses multiple cities, maybe [3:31:02] even multiple counties, right? [3:31:03] Absolutely. [3:31:03] Okay. [3:31:04] So there's a profit that's [3:31:05] built into that component that [3:31:07] goes to the entire system. [3:31:09] But after it gets to a [3:31:10] distribution hub say in Sierra [3:31:12] mesa in my district and down to [3:31:13] the homes, then there's a [3:31:15] different profit component [3:31:16] that's part of that correct? [3:31:20] Yes. [3:31:20] Okay. [3:31:20] It's the same concept though. [3:31:22] Okay. [3:31:22] When the infrastructure is [3:31:24] built we are making the profit [3:31:26] on building the infrastructure [3:31:27] whether it's transmission or [3:31:29] distribution. [3:31:29] Okay. [3:31:30] I guess I'm wondering is why [3:31:31] would why would we have to pay [3:31:34] an exit fee after the energy [3:31:36] already crosses into the city [3:31:38] of San Diego to a distribution [3:31:39] center And and then so we'd [3:31:43] have to pay to la Masons and [3:31:46] people from Poway and other [3:31:49] cities when it's crossed over [3:31:51] the line it's now in the city [3:31:52] And then the utility [3:31:53] the nonprofit utility would [3:31:55] ostensibly take control of it [3:31:56] at that point. [3:31:58] So Genie would still be making [3:31:59] a profit from the transmission [3:32:02] And at that point it's not [3:32:03] really affecting the Masons and [3:32:06] folks from power would it? [3:32:08] Right. [3:32:08] But there's fixed costs what [3:32:09] you just said. [3:32:09] Right. [3:32:10] Well I'm sorry. [3:32:12] Don't catch me. [3:32:14] I'll explain it. [3:32:16] There are fixed costs across [3:32:17] the entire system. [3:32:18] Don't build our system [3:32:19] including the distribution [3:32:20] system. [3:32:21] City boundaries only. [3:32:21] Okay? [3:32:23] You don't say We're building it [3:32:25] out for La mesa. [3:32:26] Done Now to do another foot in [3:32:28] San Diego. [3:32:29] So the distribution system also [3:32:31] crosses the borders So just [3:32:32] cutting it off there's still [3:32:34] fixed costs that go both ways [3:32:36] And so to serve the system as a [3:32:38] whole So you're taking our [3:32:40] customers out of the city of [3:32:42] San Diego out of the system and [3:32:44] there are still fixed costs [3:32:45] that will be part of [3:32:46] the distribution and [3:32:47] transmission system that would [3:32:49] then be shouldered by [3:32:50] the remaining customers no [3:32:52] longer the customers from [3:32:53] the city of San Diego. [3:32:55] But if a transmission line [3:32:56] crosses from some other county [3:32:58] or part of the part of [3:32:59] the county into our city and [3:33:02] we've disassociated from [3:33:03] the ecosystem as you're [3:33:05] pointing out, it doesn't seem [3:33:07] to me that la Masons would pay [3:33:10] for any component of it getting [3:33:12] to the distribution center and [3:33:14] on and we'd be buying [3:33:14] the distribution center from [3:33:16] you at that point. [3:33:18] So are we paying for la Masons [3:33:20] and people in power is I see [3:33:24] this one here You're nodding [3:33:25] your head clear this up for me [3:33:26] because it seems to me that [3:33:27] once it crosses into our city [3:33:29] gets to a place that the public [3:33:31] utility would have purchased it [3:33:32] . [3:33:34] I understand the fixed cost [3:33:35] component but if we bought it [3:33:37] from MR. Genie and it's being [3:33:39] owned publicly, why would there [3:33:40] be a further fixed cost to it? [3:33:42] Okay, so let me come at this [3:33:43] slightly differently in [3:33:45] the math so that it might be a [3:33:46] little clearer. [3:33:47] So the first thing to [3:33:48] understand is when we talk [3:33:49] about distribution assets in [3:33:50] the report, those include [3:33:52] specifically the vast majority [3:33:53] of the distribution sorry [3:33:56] the transmission assets that we [3:33:56] speak about are the substations [3:33:58] and that's the point of step [3:33:59] down. [3:34:00] Those are often and you want [3:34:02] those The reason they're [3:34:04] included in the study is [3:34:05] because you want them both for [3:34:07] the ability to manage [3:34:09] the system and then plan for [3:34:11] future growth so that [3:34:14] the oversimplified solute [3:34:14] example I can give here is [3:34:15] buying just the distribution [3:34:16] system is like buying the pipes [3:34:18] but not the pump station for [3:34:20] water. [3:34:21] So that's kind of the I just [3:34:23] want to address kind of [3:34:24] the there's a reason that we [3:34:25] didn't do a distribution only [3:34:26] kind of presentation in [3:34:28] the report from the just [3:34:30] compensation standpoint. [3:34:31] Yes. [3:34:32] So we know from the information [3:34:34] that's in the report that about [3:34:38] 10% give or take of [3:34:42] the physical assets of any [3:34:44] within the city of San Diego [3:34:45] are fully depreciated. [3:34:47] One of the reasons those cost [3:34:49] boundary is are so large [3:34:50] compared to phase one is [3:34:52] because there's a significantly [3:34:53] larger component of the assets [3:34:55] that are old And a lot of that [3:34:58] is because the vast majority of [3:35:01] ratepayer funds in the last 5 [3:35:04] to 10 years of all of city [3:35:07] genius territory have been [3:35:09] toward wildfire mitigation [3:35:10] that's been approved at the cpc [3:35:11] . [3:35:13] And to Councilmember Von [3:35:15] Wilpert point, we have [3:35:16] benefited from that as a city [3:35:18] but we're also paying for it. [3:35:20] >> We are ten and in every [3:35:23] other municipalities paying for [3:35:23] it. [3:35:23] So ten years ago the city of [3:35:26] San Diego ratepayers made up [3:35:28] approximately 40% of city [3:35:31] genies Total revenue Since [3:35:32] we've now seen growth in houses [3:35:34] and industry etc. In [3:35:35] the greater San Diego region [3:35:36] we're now down to about 35% of [3:35:40] their revenue. [3:35:42] So the issue of just [3:35:44] compensation in a hypothetical [3:35:46] simply says okay you are going [3:35:48] to remove 35% of revenue, [3:35:54] 660,000 customers from [3:35:55] the overall territory. [3:35:59] >> If you do that that means [3:36:01] that and again we don't put [3:36:04] this number in the feasibility [3:36:05] study because you can kind of [3:36:06] pick any number to put in that [3:36:09] whatever investments sdg any [3:36:11] continues to make from that [3:36:14] division from the point of that [3:36:16] division are only going to be [3:36:18] applied to the rest of excuse [3:36:21] me the rest of the system. [3:36:22] So right now yes, depending on [3:36:23] which year we're talking about [3:36:25] City of San Diego ratepayers [3:36:26] most of the urban ratepayers [3:36:28] frankly not just within [3:36:29] the city are subsidizing [3:36:31] investment in the physical [3:36:32] system outside the city If [3:36:37] those physical investments [3:36:38] continue to and are seen to be [3:36:41] beneficial to the whole area [3:36:44] including a new city I mean you [3:36:47] then there is a just [3:36:48] compensation problem that all [3:36:50] of those costs should not be [3:36:53] borne by the remaining sdg any [3:36:57] ratepayers If there is still [3:36:58] benefit out to the new city of [3:37:00] San Diego ratepayers And that's [3:37:02] the just compensation [3:37:03] conversation one and part of [3:37:05] the ongoing kind of proceeding [3:37:07] with San Francisco and ppg and [3:37:09] they have a very different [3:37:10] calculation both because of [3:37:12] Janie's lack of investment into [3:37:13] wildfire and the size of San [3:37:15] Francisco as it relates to [3:37:17] the larger any system but [3:37:18] the exit fee fees is kind of [3:37:21] like the cia when the ccr was [3:37:24] set up. [3:37:25] There are contracts and fixed [3:37:26] costs that Guinea pays or has [3:37:28] historically paid that the city [3:37:32] of San Diego ratepayers still [3:37:34] need to cover. [3:37:36] If you look back and say Well [3:37:37] we've done a whole bunch [3:37:38] outside the city you could [3:37:40] argue just compensation one way [3:37:42] If you say hey all this load [3:37:43] growth means that we're going [3:37:44] to have to do a whole bunch of [3:37:45] investment outside the city [3:37:47] boundaries but it benefits [3:37:48] the city than just compensation [3:37:50] is going to look another way [3:37:52] what that range looks like and [3:37:54] how the puc even determines [3:37:55] the correct way to calculate [3:37:57] that is a vastly open question. [3:37:59] Okay, So let me just go back to [3:38:02] one last material component of [3:38:04] this problem. [3:38:07] My understanding is if we did a [3:38:09] distribution only model that [3:38:11] would be the utility, the local [3:38:13] public utility that we'd pay a [3:38:16] portion of the bill too but we [3:38:17] wouldn't stop paying as genie [3:38:20] for the transmission component [3:38:22] would we Correct. [3:38:23] It would be like some type of [3:38:25] you would still have to use [3:38:26] the transmission system. [3:38:27] Yeah, okay. [3:38:28] We'd still have to use [3:38:28] the transmission system so we'd [3:38:31] still be bearing the cost of [3:38:34] the entire air transmission [3:38:35] system through that portion of [3:38:38] a potential hypothetical bill. [3:38:41] So why would there be an exit [3:38:42] fee if we'd still be paying [3:38:44] the transmission bill Because [3:38:46] of the fixed cost for [3:38:47] the entire distribution system [3:38:49] which again doesn't it wasn't [3:38:51] built city by city. [3:38:53] So even as you disconnect it, [3:38:55] our system is built as a [3:38:57] unified territory wide south [3:38:59] Orange County to the border and [3:39:01] there are fixed costs that run [3:39:03] through that that would still [3:39:05] need to be that are still being [3:39:07] paid by our customers. [3:39:08] And so if the city was to walk [3:39:10] away, those customers are still [3:39:12] paying those fixed costs that [3:39:13] have already been spent And so [3:39:15] the city can't just walk away [3:39:16] from those fixed costs across [3:39:18] the system. [3:39:19] They would still be [3:39:20] responsible. [3:39:21] That's what the case up in San [3:39:23] Francisco said is you have to [3:39:24] make the other customers whole [3:39:26] And what do you think the fixed [3:39:27] costs are We think it's in [3:39:28] the billions surely two $7 [3:39:32] billion That's a huge range [3:39:32] somewhere between 4 and $7 [3:39:33] billion for being very [3:39:37] concerned As I say, surely as [3:39:37] the investors in that [3:39:38] infrastructure you wouldn't [3:39:39] know the exact dollar amount [3:39:41] that it would cost, right? [3:39:42] Yeah. [3:39:43] Okay. [3:39:44] Can you not give me better than [3:39:45] 427 six 6 to $8 billion? [3:39:49] >> Okay But it's negotiable, [3:39:51] right? [3:39:52] >> We don't think so. [3:39:54] And the cpc did say that it's [3:39:56] absolutely part of the court [3:40:00] case as Heather just explained [3:40:00] ,the court will actually [3:40:01] determine it. [3:40:02] So you know, I don't know [3:40:04] exactly what that's going to [3:40:05] look like. [3:40:07] Yes, it could be some type of [3:40:08] settlement but ultimately [3:40:09] the court determines what [3:40:11] the just compensation would be [3:40:13] to the remaining customers So [3:40:14] they don't see a 20 to 30% rate [3:40:17] increase. [3:40:17] Okay. [3:40:18] Really quickly, you mentioned [3:40:20] that you didn't do an analysis [3:40:21] of distribution only model. [3:40:23] You said that right just a [3:40:24] minute ago. [3:40:25] This study doesn't provide its [3:40:28] kind of recommendations and [3:40:29] determination of feasibility [3:40:31] looking at just distribution [3:40:32] because it's not recommended [3:40:34] for the actual long term health [3:40:36] purpose and a capability of any [3:40:39] municipal utility. [3:40:41] But the other thing but there [3:40:42] is that distinction that's got [3:40:43] made of you're not talking high [3:40:45] voltage crossing line [3:40:46] transmissions. [3:40:47] We have transmission line is [3:40:48] just how big the line is. [3:40:50] There's a break point of what's [3:40:51] considered a distribution line [3:40:52] versus a transmission line. [3:40:53] We have transmission lines that [3:40:55] run between substations, both [3:40:56] of which are within the city. [3:40:57] You effectively want to own all [3:40:59] of the assets within the city [3:41:01] boundary in order to run [3:41:03] the system efficiently. [3:41:05] Sometimes you got to move power [3:41:06] really far and sometimes you [3:41:08] you know you can just run it [3:41:09] along the distribution lines. [3:41:11] That's an excellent point. [3:41:12] Power San Diego That's a [3:41:13] component that wasn't brought [3:41:14] up that I've heard before [3:41:16] The fact that within the city [3:41:17] you have the transmission lines [3:41:19] and if you're looking at if [3:41:20] you're suggesting just a [3:41:21] distribution only utility, a [3:41:23] public utility, how do you get [3:41:25] around that internal [3:41:26] transmission line? [3:41:30] What do you get around that is [3:41:30] those transmission and [3:41:32] distribution substations become [3:41:33] tollbooths. [3:41:35] You monitor how much power is [3:41:38] flowing off the transmission [3:41:39] system You pay for that. [3:41:41] We pay it through [3:41:42] the transmission access charges [3:41:44] and that is how the system [3:41:46] works. [3:41:47] Again, the first study that new [3:41:49] Gen did with distribution only [3:41:51] and so it's a choice. [3:41:56] Okay, understood. [3:41:59] Thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN, Quick [3:42:08] question for you. [3:42:09] I noticed you mentioned [3:42:10] leverage your workers would [3:42:13] have in negotiating a deal if a [3:42:14] significant proportion were [3:42:16] segregated off from the broader [3:42:19] body that you represent. [3:42:22] How would it materially change [3:42:24] the day to day work to have [3:42:28] Genie essentially handling [3:42:29] certain components that run [3:42:31] into the city of San Diego [3:42:32] versus a public utility [3:42:35] controlling inside the city? [3:42:37] I would say it's going to be a [3:42:39] substantial impact especially [3:42:41] when you start talking about [3:42:42] breaking out the transmission [3:42:43] and distribution infrastructure [3:42:43] . [3:42:45] As a lineman who worked on [3:42:46] these power lines in the city [3:42:47] of San Diego for ten years [3:42:48] before taking this job, a lot [3:42:50] of our transmission [3:42:51] infrastructure has distribution [3:42:53] under build so it's the same [3:42:55] exact pole, right? [3:42:57] So if a transmission pole has [3:43:00] 16 kbps on top 12 gave you [3:43:01] under build and then 120 to 40 [3:43:03] on the bottom and a drunk [3:43:04] driver runs into that pole and [3:43:06] everything's on the ground. [3:43:07] We struggle today having to put [3:43:09] up telecommunications lines, [3:43:11] having to rely on spectrum [3:43:14] at&t, Cox Communications to [3:43:15] come out and then we are [3:43:16] putting stuff up here Now [3:43:18] you're just adding another [3:43:19] layer of bureaucracy on who's [3:43:20] going to take the transmission. [3:43:22] We're going to do [3:43:22] the transmission, you're going [3:43:23] to do the distribution And then [3:43:25] three different telecom [3:43:25] telecommunications companies [3:43:27] are going to do these other [3:43:28] wires As a lineman I'm just [3:43:30] trying to get everything off [3:43:31] the ground and up safe and [3:43:33] power restored. [3:43:34] So you're going to add to [3:43:35] competing power companies [3:43:37] trying to restore service in an [3:43:38] emergency? [3:43:39] I think it would make it very [3:43:40] complicated. [3:43:41] Okay. [3:43:42] Appreciate that. [3:43:43] I'll wrap up my comments. [3:43:44] Council PRESIDENT I thank [3:43:45] the members of the public for [3:43:47] getting into the deep details [3:43:49] of just why this is so [3:43:50] complicated and being able to [3:43:52] stand side by side at [3:43:54] the microphone to answer [3:43:55] the questions very directly as [3:43:57] kind of transparent in fact [3:43:59] driven comparison I think [3:44:00] the public expects when we're [3:44:03] dealing with multibillion [3:44:04] dollar decisions and being able [3:44:07] to hear immediately what one [3:44:09] organization says and being [3:44:11] able to rebut it or supplement [3:44:13] it and ultimately hearing from [3:44:15] the workers about how that [3:44:16] impacts their lives. [3:44:17] I know we have another item [3:44:19] into a one where I'll have some [3:44:20] further comments but at the end [3:44:23] of the day I think that [3:44:25] the well I'll say my comments [3:44:27] about the 8% profit coming up [3:44:30] in a second. [3:44:30] Thank you Council PRESIDENT And [3:44:31] thank you to members of [3:44:32] the public for caring so much [3:44:33] about driving rates down for [3:44:35] electricity in San Diego. [3:44:36] All right. [3:44:37] Thank you. [3:44:39] And to member Campo, this is an [3:44:39] information item. [3:44:40] We have a lot more work to do [3:44:41] today but nevertheless [3:44:43] Councilmember Bond, welcome [3:44:44] one. [3:44:45] One more point. [3:44:48] First of all, the way that we [3:44:49] can lower bills today is by [3:44:50] making less profit for [3:44:51] shareholders. [3:44:53] Today any argument that we need [3:44:56] to get rid of the public [3:44:57] purpose programs in the state [3:44:59] but the mandates in our bills [3:45:01] is ridiculous. [3:45:01] You want us to take away [3:45:02] the low income assistance [3:45:03] program and state bills. [3:45:05] You want to take away [3:45:06] the wildfire safety mandates? [3:45:08] These are the state [3:45:08] requirements in the bills that [3:45:10] we pay. [3:45:11] That is ridiculous. [3:45:12] It should be said you need [3:45:14] shareholder profits that are [3:45:15] lower today to lower our bills, [3:45:16] not lowering help for low [3:45:17] income people And it shouldn't [3:45:18] be on the backs of cities to do [3:45:20] that. [3:45:20] Second, we already pay We [3:45:23] the city of San Diego already [3:45:24] pay for infrastructure we don't [3:45:25] use for city And I'm now [3:45:27] reading about the Golden [3:45:29] Pacific Power Line project that [3:45:30] could go entirely around [3:45:31] the city of San Diego. [3:45:32] Yet our ratepayers might have [3:45:34] to pay for it. [3:45:35] So I'm glad you're having a lot [3:45:37] of stakeholder engagement but [3:45:38] you need to engage the citizens [3:45:40] of City of San Diego who could [3:45:41] be paying for this. [3:45:42] And second of all you should be [3:45:43] doing more than just virtual [3:45:44] open houses. [3:45:46] If you're going to run this [3:45:47] through an unnatural state park [3:45:48] like Rego Springs, go to [3:45:50] Brigham Springs, talk to [3:45:51] the people in the communities [3:45:52] in in person about this before [3:45:54] you go to a natural preserve. [3:45:56] Thank you. [3:45:56] Council PRESIDENT. [3:45:57] All right. [3:45:58] Thank you. [3:45:59] So not seeing anybody else on [3:46:01] the lights. [3:46:01] This is an information item. [3:46:03] No motions required. [3:46:05] Thank you to Brittany, Nate [3:46:08] Bell and whoever else got in [3:46:10] the hot seat And we're willing [3:46:11] to take the questions from [3:46:12] the council members going [3:46:14] forward. [3:46:15] There was a lot of ground [3:46:16] covered. [3:46:16] There was a lot of ground not [3:46:17] covered for this discussion [3:46:19] because we weren't setting this [3:46:21] up for an action today because [3:46:23] there are still so many things. [3:46:25] But I'll reiterate what [3:46:27] the report said that it is [3:46:28] feasibly feasible from an [3:46:30] economic point of view and it's [3:46:31] feasible from a technical point [3:46:33] of view. [3:46:33] A lot more work would have to [3:46:35] be done And so you kind of [3:46:36] tried to summarize Heather and [3:46:37] I appreciate that. [3:46:39] So with that we will close item [3:46:41] 200. [3:46:42] Again, thank you to everyone [3:46:44] and Deputy Clerk please [3:46:46] introduce item 201 Thank you [3:46:50] Council PRESIDENT Item 2a1 sdg [3:46:52] any franchise independent audit [3:46:54] report and Franchise Compliance [3:46:55] Review Committee report 2023 [3:46:59] through 2025 Thank you for All [3:47:26] right As you start to settle in [3:47:28] introduce yourselves for [3:47:29] the record and let us know how [3:47:30] much time we need. [3:47:32] >> Hello. [3:47:32] Thank you. [3:47:33] Council PRESIDENT My name is [3:47:33] Matt. [3:47:35] We are We'll try to keep under [3:47:35] 20 minutes for That's for both [3:47:37] for the entire reading. [3:47:39] Okay. [3:47:39] Thank you. [3:47:41] >> Thank you. [3:47:42] My name is Megan Long, program [3:47:43] manager and department of [3:47:44] General Services. [3:47:45] I'm joined today by Eric Cohen, [3:47:46] Aaron Cohen and Eric Niland [3:47:49] from Crow Cody Human And to [3:47:50] tell me about Marshall Zeigler [3:47:52] from our franchise Compliance [3:47:53] Review committee today we'll be [3:47:54] presenting to you the results [3:47:55] of our second two year [3:47:56] compliance period of the Genie [3:48:00] franchise which will include a [3:48:00] presentation from our [3:48:01] independent auditor as well as [3:48:02] our presentation from [3:48:03] the Franchise Compliance Review [3:48:04] Committee. [3:48:06] By way of background in JULY of [3:48:08] 2021 the Council passed two [3:48:10] ordinances that awarded the gas [3:48:12] and electric franchises to San [3:48:14] Diego Gas and Electric [3:48:16] the franchise with a ten year [3:48:16] term with an automatic renewal [3:48:17] for a second ten years unless [3:48:19] there's action taken by council [3:48:21] as additional level of [3:48:22] oversight. [3:48:22] The franchise required two [3:48:23] things First, the city is [3:48:25] required to retain a third [3:48:26] party independent auditor every [3:48:27] two years to perform an audit [3:48:29] of each unit compliance with [3:48:30] the franchise. [3:48:31] And second, the franchise [3:48:32] requires the city to establish [3:48:33] the Franchise Compliance Review [3:48:34] Committee also known as the f [3:48:37] crc, a citizens committee [3:48:38] comprised of two mayoral [3:48:39] appointments and three council [3:48:40] appointments. [3:48:41] The icrc is charged with [3:48:42] receiving the independent [3:48:43] Auditors report and providing [3:48:44] its own report to Council with [3:48:46] a recommendation on [3:48:47] the automatic renewal on [3:48:48] the second ten year term. [3:48:49] Both of those reports will be [3:48:50] presented today in JULY of 2024 [3:48:53] we presented a similar item for [3:48:55] the first two year review [3:48:56] period and at the same meeting [3:48:58] council passed a resolution to [3:48:59] establish the second frc to [3:49:01] review the second compliance [3:49:02] period which covers JULY 8th [3:49:04] 2023 to JULY 7th of 2025. [3:49:07] I would like to take a moment [3:49:08] to thank the volunteer [3:49:09] committee members Matt Brennan, [3:49:10] Lydia Latimore, Cody Human So [3:49:14] tell me about Flagler and Corey [3:49:14] All right. [3:49:15] For their time and dedication [3:49:16] to this committee in regards to [3:49:20] the independent auditor in [3:49:21] OCTOBER of 2022 city staff [3:49:23] released an rfp for [3:49:24] the independent auditor and [3:49:25] after a competitive process [3:49:28] Crowell lp was elected as [3:49:28] the vendor cro will present [3:49:30] their audit findings for [3:49:31] the first two three for [3:49:32] the second two year Crowe [3:49:34] presented their audit findings [3:49:35] for the first two year [3:49:36] franchise period as part of [3:49:38] the hearing in JULY of 2024 and [3:49:40] the city chose to exercise its [3:49:42] option to extend Crowe's [3:49:43] contract for the second two [3:49:44] year compliance period. [3:49:46] I have with me today [3:49:47] representatives from the Crowe [3:49:48] team who will go into more [3:49:49] detail about their audit [3:49:50] procedures and findings in a [3:49:51] few minutes. [3:49:52] But at a high level the audit [3:49:53] covers the second two year of [3:49:55] the franchise scuse me [3:49:57] the second two years of [3:49:58] the franchise and includes [3:49:59] the financial, operational and [3:50:00] cooperative requirements under [3:50:02] the franchise ordinances and [3:50:03] their supporting documents [3:50:04] which include [3:50:05] the administrative mou, [3:50:06] the undergrounding mou and [3:50:07] the Energy Cooperation [3:50:08] Agreement. [3:50:09] At this point I will pass it [3:50:10] over to our independent under [3:50:12] Crowe who will provide an [3:50:12] overview of the audit findings [3:50:13] and recommendations. [3:50:17] Thank you Megan. [3:50:18] Next slide we'll go through [3:50:20] some brief introductions. [3:50:21] We'll talk about audit scope [3:50:22] and procedure and then our [3:50:24] findings and recommendations. [3:50:26] So next slide My name is Eric [3:50:27] Niland. [3:50:29] I'm a director with Crowe and [3:50:30] with me I have Erin Cohen who's [3:50:32] a senior manager with Crowe. [3:50:33] We don't have Burt with us but [3:50:35] he was the engagement partner [3:50:36] on this project. [3:50:40] >> I'll turn to Aaron to talk [3:50:41] about the scope here. [3:50:42] Thank you Eric So scope of [3:50:46] the audit was an independent [3:50:47] audit of Genie's gas and [3:50:49] electric franchise agreements [3:50:50] And as Megan mentioned the two [3:50:52] year period was JULY 8th, 2023 [3:50:54] through JULY 7th, 2025. [3:50:57] The audit covered Genie's [3:50:59] performance and complying with [3:51:00] the franchise agreements [3:51:02] Administrative mou, the utility [3:51:04] underwriting mou and the Energy [3:51:05] Cooperation agreement [3:51:06] associated with the franchises [3:51:06] . [3:51:09] Now our audit procedures [3:51:10] included conducting interviews [3:51:12] with Jenny and city staff. [3:51:14] We spoke with city staff [3:51:16] including finance, operational [3:51:17] and oversight personnel and [3:51:19] spoke with many city [3:51:20] departments the Development [3:51:21] Services Department and an [3:51:23] engineering and capital [3:51:24] projects utilities [3:51:25] undergrounding program and city [3:51:26] management. [3:51:28] We reviewed and documented [3:51:29] requirements of each agreement. [3:51:31] We submitted multiple data [3:51:32] requests to City Jenny and [3:51:34] the city. [3:51:35] These data requests were [3:51:36] requested for relevant [3:51:37] requirements for each of [3:51:38] the agreements for franchise [3:51:40] fees We obtained and reviewed [3:51:42] Genie Annual franchise fee [3:51:43] calculation documents, [3:51:45] quarterly franchise fee [3:51:46] statements, processed [3:51:47] documentation controls [3:51:49] information They are aging [3:51:51] reports, bad debt expense [3:51:52] support and collection [3:51:53] procedures and documentation of [3:51:55] payment to the city Exide For [3:52:01] the administrative mou we [3:52:03] selected a sample of 13 [3:52:05] projects to audit project [3:52:07] specific requirements things [3:52:08] like permitting inspections or [3:52:10] collaboration. [3:52:11] We also reviewed supporting [3:52:12] documentation for what we're [3:52:14] calling non project specific [3:52:15] requirements. [3:52:16] This is information sharing [3:52:17] protocols or communication [3:52:18] between Genie and the city. [3:52:21] Similarly for the utility [3:52:23] undergrounding mou we selected [3:52:24] eight in-process projects to [3:52:26] audit requirements that were [3:52:27] project specific and then [3:52:29] review review supporting [3:52:30] documentation for non project [3:52:31] specific requirements for [3:52:34] the Energy Cooperation [3:52:35] Agreement We reviewed [3:52:36] supporting documentation for [3:52:38] each requirement. [3:52:41] >> Now the results of these [3:52:42] tests indicated that we met [3:52:43] the four audit objectives in [3:52:45] all significant respects for [3:52:46] the audit period. [3:52:47] However we did include two [3:52:49] audit findings that were deemed [3:52:50] not to be significant [3:52:53] significant to the objectives [3:52:54] but warranted inclusion in [3:52:55] the report. [3:52:57] >> And now I'm going to turn it [3:52:58] to Eric to walk through [3:52:59] the findings. [3:53:01] You know, so the first of these [3:53:02] findings has to do with [3:53:03] compliance with [3:53:04] the undergrounding mou And [3:53:05] there were several sections of [3:53:07] the mou that we found [3:53:10] noncompliance and and they're [3:53:10] listed here on this slide and [3:53:12] I'll review those with you for [3:53:14] the first of those are six 11.2 [3:53:17] for a project titled block b r [3:53:24] a r c g You do not complete [3:53:24] internal processes on time [3:53:26] which caused a delay in [3:53:27] assigning and inspector to [3:53:29] the project and that's Palm [3:53:29] City. [3:53:32] Edgar Highlands project. [3:53:34] Secondly, sd g did not provide [3:53:36] a written schedule of days and [3:53:38] hours in which the c an [3:53:41] inspector would be available to [3:53:43] a project titled Blockade r sd [3:53:47] g ultimately was not able to [3:53:48] provide an inspector at [3:53:49] the time of that construction [3:53:51] as a consequence. [3:53:53] So in section 743g did not [3:53:56] comply by providing a [3:53:59] construction baseline which [3:54:00] includes both an estimate of [3:54:02] cost and a schedule for [3:54:05] trenching conduit work for [3:54:06] the project titled 2bb job two [3:54:06] That's a crown point one. [3:54:10] And finally in section 834cg [3:54:14] has not submitted detailed 90% [3:54:16] design estimates in [3:54:17] the supporting documentation [3:54:19] for invoices Did not clearly [3:54:20] differentiate projects that [3:54:22] have reached the 90% completion [3:54:24] threshold as required by [3:54:26] the franchise. [3:54:27] So we have a number of [3:54:28] recommendations to address [3:54:29] these these misses so to speak. [3:54:32] The first is to establish [3:54:33] stronger project management [3:54:35] controls by developing [3:54:37] standardized timelines and [3:54:38] checklists. [3:54:39] Secondly, to assign a dedicated [3:54:41] compliance liaison or project [3:54:43] coordinator within cdg and to [3:54:45] limit these misses. [3:54:47] Third, to revise invoicing [3:54:49] backup materials to more [3:54:52] clearly distinguish that 90% [3:54:53] design estimate. [3:54:55] Fourth to establish regular [3:54:56] joint review meetings with city [3:54:58] staff They've started doing [3:55:00] those and are doing more of [3:55:01] them As a consequence of this [3:55:06] trained personnel and mou [3:55:06] requirements by reinforcing [3:55:08] compliance standards And [3:55:09] finally link compliance to [3:55:11] performance metrics or [3:55:13] oversight reviews. [3:55:15] So those are recommendations [3:55:15] that are addressed first. [3:55:17] The first findings second [3:55:18] finding on the next slide has [3:55:20] to do with the admin mou [3:55:24] section ten point b of that mou [3:55:27] as you need to not schedule [3:55:30] pre-construction meeting with [3:55:30] the city as required as [3:55:33] Eugenie's Field crews [3:55:33] incorrectly assumed that was a [3:55:35] classic Category one project [3:55:37] winner which would not have [3:55:39] required this pre-construction [3:55:40] meeting and the project was [3:55:41] actually a Category two [3:55:43] project. [3:55:43] So there's a couple of things [3:55:44] that I can do to strengthen and [3:55:46] you know, respond accordingly. [3:55:49] First by just project project [3:55:52] classification work and review [3:55:54] processes so that this doesn't [3:55:56] happen again. [3:55:57] Developing a project checklist [3:55:58] to be reviewed by [3:55:59] the supervisor before [3:56:00] construction begins. [3:56:01] And perhaps most important to [3:56:03] train field crews and project [3:56:04] managers to clearly [3:56:05] differentiate between these two [3:56:07] category types. [3:56:09] So those are the two findings [3:56:11] the status of findings from [3:56:13] the first phase of the audit [3:56:14] and I'll go through those [3:56:15] briefly here. [3:56:16] There were four findings last [3:56:18] Two of these have been [3:56:19] remediating remediated. [3:56:21] Those are three and four. [3:56:23] Number three was remediated [3:56:25] because it's no longer a [3:56:27] compliance requirement And [3:56:27] the new admin mou number four [3:56:30] was remediated because [3:56:31] the finding related to a paint [3:56:32] plant completion timing which [3:56:34] they met although they delayed [3:56:37] in meeting and getting that [3:56:38] done both the city and in [3:56:40] the study ultimately got [3:56:41] the plan completed So it wasn't [3:56:43] a compliance matter in this [3:56:45] phase. [3:56:46] The other two relate to number [3:56:48] one they're inconsistent [3:56:49] undergrounding project cost [3:56:51] estimates. [3:56:51] And so this is sort of a to be [3:56:54] determined going forward. [3:56:55] In the past there were some [3:56:58] inconsistencies in the overhead [3:57:00] allocations to the cost [3:57:02] estimates and they've cleaned [3:57:03] those up to some degree. [3:57:04] But going forward I think [3:57:06] there's still as they get into [3:57:08] more construction projects [3:57:10] there's still a need to [3:57:11] reinforce consistent project [3:57:13] cost estimates There. [3:57:15] The second one is just in terms [3:57:17] of collaborating between [3:57:18] the city and sd Junior on [3:57:19] the mou for certain contracted [3:57:23] services, the Mhsaa hasn't been [3:57:25] solicited again So to [3:57:27] the degree that when that [3:57:28] happens there more coordination [3:57:30] between the city and sga and on [3:57:33] that is merited So we didn't [3:57:34] say that's remediated but it's [3:57:36] pending the next cycle of [3:57:37] the mhsaa. [3:57:39] So with that I will turn it [3:57:40] back to the Council for [3:57:43] questions. [3:57:44] At this time I would have to [3:57:45] revert to our franchise [3:57:46] compliance review committee. [3:57:50] Hi everybody. [3:57:50] Thank you. [3:57:50] My name is Cody Hoven. [3:57:52] I'm the chair of your franchise [3:57:54] Compliance Review committee. [3:57:55] Nice to be back in the seat I [3:57:56] think. [3:57:57] And here with the Tell me about [3:57:59] Siegler the vice chair of [3:58:00] the committee. [3:58:00] We're going to split up this [3:58:01] portion of the presentation. [3:58:05] Thanks. [3:58:06] So just to remind you [3:58:07] the purpose of Franchise [3:58:09] Compliance Review Committee was [3:58:12] it was assigned a very narrow [3:58:13] scope per the franchise [3:58:14] agreement and it's formed as [3:58:16] you see here every two years to [3:58:19] review franchise compliance and [3:58:21] recommend to the city council [3:58:22] whether the franchise should be [3:58:23] renewed for a secondary term. [3:58:24] So we're a function of [3:58:27] the Brown Act compliant [3:58:28] Committee and comply with all [3:58:30] of the rules of the Brown Act [3:58:31] in our meetings. [3:58:35] Additionally, our [3:58:36] responsibilities include [3:58:37] reviewing and discuss [3:58:38] discussing the franchise audit [3:58:41] what you just heard in [3:58:42] collaboration with the auditor [3:58:44] and preparing a comprehensive [3:58:46] written report for you all [3:58:48] which we provided And I quickly [3:58:52] went quickly through these and [3:58:54] then making a formal [3:58:55] recommendation to City Council [3:58:57] regarding whether to approve [3:58:58] automatic renewal of [3:59:00] the franchise for a secondary [3:59:06] ten year term. [3:59:12] Next on the committee found [3:59:13] that Junior demonstrated [3:59:15] overall compliance with all [3:59:16] four agreements The electric [3:59:17] and gas franchise agreements, [3:59:19] the administrative mou or [3:59:21] the utility utility [3:59:22] undergrounding mou and [3:59:23] the energy Cooperation [3:59:24] Agreement. [3:59:25] The audit identified only a few [3:59:27] minor issues mostly related to [3:59:28] documentation scheduling or [3:59:30] classification. [3:59:30] These were isolated and [3:59:33] technically and with no [3:59:35] evidence of systemic problems [3:59:37] financial harm or governance [3:59:38] breakdowns. [3:59:39] The committee recommends that [3:59:41] routine monitoring or franchise [3:59:42] compliance continue with a [3:59:44] focus on clarifying [3:59:45] expectations, standardizing [3:59:47] documentation and reinforcing [3:59:48] early coordination between [3:59:51] F.D.A. And city departments for [3:59:52] the administrative mou This [3:59:54] means strengthening internal [3:59:55] controls and aligning [3:59:57] renegotiate renegotiation [3:59:58] timelines with the committees [4:00:00] review cycle. [4:00:01] Right now there's a timing [4:00:03] mismatch mismatch between when [4:00:05] the agreements can be [4:00:06] renegotiated and when [4:00:07] the committee is actually doing [4:00:09] its review. [4:00:10] That means the committee's [4:00:11] input MAY come too late to [4:00:13] meaningful meaningfully [4:00:14] influence the process. [4:00:16] What we're proposing is to [4:00:17] better align those timelines so [4:00:19] when the renegotiation [4:00:20] opportunities arise they [4:00:22] coincide with the committee's [4:00:23] review cycle allowing their [4:00:25] work to directly inform city [4:00:26] decisions for [4:00:28] the undergrounding mou. [4:00:29] The committee recommends [4:00:30] providing detailed cost [4:00:31] breakdowns and establishing a [4:00:32] regular review mechanism. [4:00:34] Those costs are often shown as [4:00:36] big lump sums and not broken [4:00:38] into enough detail. [4:00:39] So you know x is for labor wise [4:00:42] for overhead, for construction. [4:00:43] Right now it's like getting a [4:00:44] restaurant bill that just says [4:00:46] a total of $200 with no [4:00:48] itemized itemization. [4:00:49] The committee is recommending [4:00:50] an itemized receipt and regular [4:00:52] check ins to make sure [4:00:53] everything looks reasonable for [4:00:55] the Energy Cooperation [4:00:56] Agreement. [4:00:56] The committee suggests setting [4:00:58] realistic timelines, [4:00:59] maintaining energy efficient [4:01:00] program commitments, improving [4:01:02] reporting and expanding public [4:01:04] engagement opportunities. [4:01:05] Next slide please. [4:01:07] While complaints are strong, [4:01:08] the committee noted several [4:01:09] areas where the processes could [4:01:11] be improved. [4:01:12] These include ensuring [4:01:13] pre-construction meetings are [4:01:14] consistently held clarifying [4:01:16] documentation practices, [4:01:17] increasing transparency and [4:01:19] project cost enhancing tracking [4:01:21] and reporting under the Energy [4:01:23] Cooperation Agreement and [4:01:24] creating additional [4:01:25] opportunities for public [4:01:26] engagement before agreements or [4:01:28] modifications are executed. [4:01:30] Next slide please. [4:01:32] The committee recommends [4:01:33] continuing to monitor prior [4:01:35] audit needs to ensure progress [4:01:36] is sustained. [4:01:37] Recognizing that some issues [4:01:38] require ongoing management [4:01:40] rather than one time fixes, it [4:01:42] also suggest creating plain [4:01:44] language summaries of all [4:01:45] agreements to help both [4:01:47] the committee and the public [4:01:48] understand the purpose process [4:01:51] and the timelines. [4:01:52] Renegotiation timelines once [4:01:54] again should be aligned should [4:01:55] align with biennial review [4:01:57] cycle to improve public [4:01:59] engagement and the Committee [4:02:00] should have access to draft [4:02:02] audit findings for early [4:02:03] review. [4:02:04] Oversight shouldn't just focus [4:02:05] on compliance though We also [4:02:07] need to look at financial [4:02:08] impacts and how these [4:02:09] agreements affect the community [4:02:11] creating structured [4:02:11] opportunities for Republican [4:02:13] input along with more [4:02:14] standardized reporting across [4:02:16] all franchise agreements would [4:02:17] improve transparency and make [4:02:19] it easier for the council and [4:02:20] the public to review and [4:02:21] understand what's happening [4:02:24] next Like this. [4:02:26] The committee observed that not [4:02:28] all franchise activities carry [4:02:30] the same level of risk or [4:02:31] public concern. [4:02:32] So oversight should focus on [4:02:33] areas of greatest impact For [4:02:35] example routine administrative [4:02:37] updates like minor contract [4:02:38] amendments or reporting changes [4:02:40] don't typically have major [4:02:42] community impacts and can be [4:02:43] reviewed more quickly. [4:02:45] But decisions involving [4:02:46] undergrounding projects rate [4:02:48] impacts or long term renewal [4:02:50] terms have significant [4:02:51] financial and public [4:02:53] implications So those should be [4:02:55] should receive deeper scrutiny [4:02:57] and more detailed oversight. [4:02:59] Some prior audit findings like [4:03:01] undergrounding cost variability [4:03:02] have improved while others [4:03:04] require ongoing management. [4:03:06] In this case continuous [4:03:07] improvement rather than [4:03:09] the complete absence of issues [4:03:10] is is a reasonable but [4:03:11] reasonable benchmark. [4:03:14] To strengthen oversight, [4:03:15] the committee recommends [4:03:16] establishing successful [4:03:17] criteria beyond compliance for [4:03:19] example instead of only [4:03:20] confirming compliance. [4:03:22] We would also look at look at [4:03:24] outcomes like whether [4:03:26] the project stayed on budget or [4:03:27] were delivered on schedule. [4:03:29] Sharing all public comments So [4:03:32] feedback from residents is [4:03:33] fully visible throughout [4:03:34] the process not just summarized [4:03:35] . [4:03:37] Expanding structured public [4:03:39] input early in the agreement [4:03:41] process for instance holding [4:03:42] engagement sessions before key [4:03:44] terms are finalized not after [4:03:46] decision decisions are largely [4:03:48] set. [4:03:49] Enhancing audit scope for cost [4:03:51] drivers. [4:03:51] So instead of just seeing total [4:03:54] project costs we can clearly [4:03:55] see the breakdowns you know [4:03:56] like earlier and itemized [4:04:00] receipt and standardizing [4:04:00] reporting across all franchise [4:04:01] agreements to improve [4:04:02] transparency, consistency and [4:04:04] accessibility for the committee [4:04:06] ,city council and the public [4:04:08] in general. [4:04:12] And so consider our [4:04:14] recommendations a bigger [4:04:15] picture. [4:04:16] We based on the information we [4:04:18] had in front of us and barring [4:04:19] any other decisions you all [4:04:20] might make. [4:04:21] The committee recommended [4:04:22] allowing the franchise to renew [4:04:24] with conditions. [4:04:29] So this Conditional Renewal [4:04:32] Council decision per our [4:04:33] recommendation should consider [4:04:34] both individual agreements and [4:04:36] among others as well as [4:04:36] the overall structure and long [4:04:38] term impact of the franchise. [4:04:40] So our recommendation for [4:04:41] renewals conditioned on [4:04:42] aligning renegotiation [4:04:43] timelines to ensure meaningful [4:04:45] public and council input before [4:04:46] agreements are finalized. [4:04:48] So we talked about some of our [4:04:50] key compliance. [4:04:52] i think the key findings as a [4:04:54] student is generally compliant [4:04:55] based on the scope of the audit [4:04:56] question posed with only minor [4:04:58] issues noted in the audit. [4:05:00] Underground costs are high and [4:05:01] overhead transparency could [4:05:02] improve. [4:05:04] And previous concerns have been [4:05:05] mostly addressed But climate [4:05:07] action progress has been [4:05:08] limited and public input was [4:05:10] considered in our meetings as [4:05:13] well. [4:05:14] And the three new one would [4:05:15] preserve flexibility for future [4:05:17] options like mineralization. [4:05:23] This conditional renewal is [4:05:25] the approach our committee [4:05:26] recommended because it supports [4:05:28] both San Diego ratepayers and [4:05:29] the city's broader policy [4:05:31] objectives. [4:05:32] But I would like to underscore [4:05:33] that it is important to [4:05:35] recognize that simply meeting [4:05:36] the terms of these agreements [4:05:38] the compliance alone doesn't [4:05:40] fully address the bigger [4:05:41] concerns of how you define [4:05:43] success As a lot of discussion [4:05:45] you've heard today. [4:05:46] Things like affordability, [4:05:47] potential rate impacts or how [4:05:48] these agreements align with [4:05:49] the city's long term energy and [4:05:51] climate goals. [4:05:52] This is why renewal is [4:05:53] ultimately a policy decision to [4:05:55] city council balancing [4:05:56] compliance with public value [4:05:57] and long term priorities. [4:06:01] >> Thank you. [4:06:02] We're happy to take any [4:06:03] questions I think. [4:06:04] All right. [4:06:04] Thank you for [4:06:05] the presentations. [4:06:06] Special shout out to Cody Soto [4:06:08] me and everybody on [4:06:09] the franchise compliance [4:06:10] agreement the volunteers. [4:06:13] You've got some fans out there [4:06:16] and all the work to do that. [4:06:18] So with that please proceed [4:06:21] with public comment. [4:06:23] Thank you. [4:06:24] Council PRESIDENT. [4:06:25] This item received one comment [4:06:26] in favor and one comment in [4:06:27] opposition via our e comment [4:06:29] form which had been distributed [4:06:31] to the Council. [4:06:32] We will begin with in-person [4:06:33] comment allegedly Audra please [4:06:35] come forward You'll have one [4:06:36] minute to speak or serve. [4:06:46] Feels like we're as de genies [4:06:49] really And it's just [4:06:51] interesting to have them here [4:06:52] and talking about like how much [4:06:55] is it really going to cost and [4:06:56] it's like 4 to 7 billion and [4:06:58] then it's like be honest and [4:07:00] it's like okay, 6 to 8. [4:07:03] So interesting how we just let [4:07:05] this go on and as long as we [4:07:06] make sure they're compliant [4:07:08] with these agreements But no [4:07:11] wonder why the cost is high for [4:07:13] undergrounding because they [4:07:14] make profit off of this [4:07:15] infrastructure. [4:07:17] And so I'm wondering if you're [4:07:18] conditional renewal can be like [4:07:21] any kind of profit you make you [4:07:23] give it to us or half of it so [4:07:25] that the people can start [4:07:26] getting their money back. [4:07:27] It's like I don't understand [4:07:29] why we just kind of bend over [4:07:31] and allow them to do these [4:07:32] things. [4:07:33] It's like you know it's [4:07:34] happening. [4:07:34] You know why their cost is high [4:07:36] and why they're profiting. [4:07:39] But yeah, we just continue to [4:07:40] let it happen. [4:07:41] How about you guys take some of [4:07:42] that back? [4:07:43] I mean you're the ones with [4:07:43] the agreements that should get [4:07:47] off the top. [4:07:48] >> Thank you, Blair Beckman And [4:07:52] while Blair comes to [4:07:53] the microphone, could we have [4:07:54] Anthony Ralphs or Seldon? [4:07:56] Yeah and Bob because these Can [4:07:57] you please come to the front [4:07:58] row? [4:08:03] Hi, we're Beekman. [4:08:04] Thanks for the report. [4:08:05] Thanks for the words on working [4:08:07] on undergrounding issues that [4:08:09] needs to be better specified. [4:08:12] I was trying to specify [4:08:14] previously that if we're going [4:08:15] to do undergrounding things [4:08:17] there is little neighborhoods [4:08:19] that have undergrounding you [4:08:21] know, funding sources and we [4:08:24] can consider that as a [4:08:25] municipality process. [4:08:26] I want to make that more clear. [4:08:29] Thank you for the ideas of [4:08:31] oversight. [4:08:34] Um yeah. [4:08:34] Basically what I was saying was [4:08:35] that we don't have to fully [4:08:36] rely on municipality. [4:08:38] We can rely on San Diego [4:08:39] community energy itself and [4:08:43] nothing in this capacity Those [4:08:43] are options. [4:08:44] Thank you for the oversight [4:08:45] process that you've offered [4:08:48] overall to do The big items on [4:08:52] public projects is good also to [4:08:54] offer you know what are [4:08:56] the little administrative [4:08:57] signatures Where's a little [4:08:59] space for that that can be [4:09:00] available to the public as [4:09:01] well? [4:09:02] I think that can be helpful and [4:09:03] important. [4:09:03] Thank you. [4:09:04] Thank you. [4:09:05] Thank you. [4:09:06] >> Anthony Ralphs followed by [4:09:08] Laurie Saldana City Council. [4:09:12] >> Thank you for [4:09:12] the presentation by the Audit [4:09:17] group. [4:09:18] I took a couple of notes on [4:09:19] the things that I heard. [4:09:20] I heard number one that they [4:09:21] didn't finished undergrounding [4:09:23] on time, that they didn't have [4:09:24] standardized timelines and that [4:09:26] the construction baseline for [4:09:28] cost and schedule are rather [4:09:29] that they didn't schedule [4:09:31] pre-construction meetings. [4:09:32] These are just the ways in [4:09:32] which you need $1 billion [4:09:35] profit in company every year [4:09:36] has been out of compliance just [4:09:38] some of the ways in which [4:09:40] they've been out of compliance [4:09:40] that I heard that I got to take [4:09:42] notes on which it was hard to [4:09:43] do because the representatives [4:09:44] from sd g are so loud and [4:09:47] they're talking right now when [4:09:48] I'm trying to give [4:09:49] the presentation and one of [4:09:50] them is eating your popcorn so [4:09:52] incredibly loudly that it's [4:09:53] really difficult for me and [4:09:55] it's really difficult for [4:09:56] the public to have trust in me [4:09:58] when they're talking in [4:09:59] the middle of someone giving a [4:10:00] presentation on how they're out [4:10:01] of compliance and eating so [4:10:03] loud that I can't even write [4:10:04] down the notes as to all [4:10:06] the ways in which they're out [4:10:07] of compliance yet they're [4:10:08] making $1 billion a year and [4:10:10] they're asking for their [4:10:11] franchise board renewal. [4:10:13] >> Thank you does conclude your [4:10:14] time. [4:10:15] Lori Saldana followed by Vikas [4:10:21] Whiskey Thank you. [4:10:22] So ultimately I think we need [4:10:23] to say is this meeting [4:10:24] the needs of utility rate [4:10:28] payers And there are many [4:10:29] things here that if you're [4:10:31] committed to improve customer [4:10:32] service they were delays. [4:10:34] We have a domino effect of [4:10:36] missed deadlines and other [4:10:37] things that delay the outcomes [4:10:38] . [4:10:39] So what are the consequences [4:10:41] for this? [4:10:42] That's my question When if you [4:10:44] do a customer service survey [4:10:46] and you find out that they're [4:10:48] not meeting the needs of your [4:10:49] customers, what are [4:10:50] the consequences? [4:10:51] What do you change? [4:10:52] And I think that's been missing [4:10:54] from these reports for the last [4:10:55] few cycles Are the meeting [4:10:58] formats available for people to [4:10:59] participate are accessible to [4:11:01] the public The ones that I [4:11:03] happen to have in the middle of [4:11:03] the day when most people are [4:11:05] not able to participate I think [4:11:06] that's problematic. [4:11:08] So in general talking about [4:11:10] undergrounding my family has [4:11:13] had the same house for 60 years [4:11:16] we've been paying into [4:11:16] undergrounding is delay, delay, [4:11:17] delay. [4:11:19] So what are the consequences [4:11:21] for delaying basic customer [4:11:23] service? [4:11:24] You know, there appeared to be [4:11:25] nothing but because it's been [4:11:35] followed by promises I'm not [4:11:36] deeply informed on this issue [4:11:38] and I'm mostly sympathetic to [4:11:40] ratepayers But it's my [4:11:42] understanding from city and [4:11:43] union representatives that they [4:11:45] are operating on their own land [4:11:47] or land that they have leased [4:11:50] or from their own funds over [4:11:53] many years Now that doesn't [4:11:55] mean that the city shouldn't [4:11:57] take a role in ensuring that [4:11:58] citizens are treated fairly. [4:12:01] You should but I find it [4:12:04] inexplicable that here you are [4:12:07] investigating and reporting and [4:12:09] auditing what sd, g and e does [4:12:12] as a private business on mostly [4:12:15] their own land. [4:12:17] While you have refused to do [4:12:18] any investigation or auditing [4:12:22] of a private business or [4:12:25] operating on our public [4:12:28] parkland at the Torrey Pines [4:12:30] Glider port, can any of you [4:12:32] explain that inconsistency? [4:12:36] >> Thank you. [4:12:36] That does conclude your time. [4:12:47] Says I thank you so much both [4:12:48] to the auditors and [4:12:49] the Franchise Compliance Review [4:12:50] Committee for spending the time [4:12:52] to evaluate our work Under [4:12:53] the franchise agreements we [4:12:55] knowledge of the independent [4:12:56] auditor for the second year or [4:12:58] the second time found no [4:13:00] significant findings or [4:13:01] deficiencies relating to [4:13:03] performance on the franchise [4:13:04] and related agreements. [4:13:06] This reflects our commitment to [4:13:07] meetings and to meeting [4:13:08] the several hundred [4:13:09] requirements under each of [4:13:11] these ancillary franchise [4:13:12] agreements. [4:13:13] Of course we know we always [4:13:14] have to improve. [4:13:16] We'll continue to work on our [4:13:17] processes and we take that [4:13:18] responsibility seriously. [4:13:20] We'd also like to recognize [4:13:21] the Franchise Compliance Review [4:13:22] Committee for the time and care [4:13:24] they dedicated to this process [4:13:26] After their extensive review [4:13:27] including presentations from [4:13:29] subject matter experts [4:13:31] including the cpa and other [4:13:33] stakeholders in the community. [4:13:35] Your evaluation of our [4:13:37] performance and your [4:13:38] consideration of all the public [4:13:39] input. [4:13:40] Importantly, the committee [4:13:41] found that we demonstrated [4:13:42] overall compliance with [4:13:44] the electric and gas franchise [4:13:45] agreements as well as an mou. [4:13:48] Thank you very much. [4:13:48] All of you. [4:13:49] Thank you. [4:13:50] That concludes in-person public [4:13:52] comment. [4:13:54] We will now go to virtual [4:13:55] public comment. [4:13:56] I've started the five minute [4:13:57] timer in council chambers and [4:14:00] we will turn to the virtual [4:14:01] queue in which there are [4:14:02] currently three participants [4:14:04] requesting to speak. [4:14:05] We'll begin with John Stott. [4:14:08] Please begin. [4:14:14] >> Wow. [4:14:15] Did they get it a a p a c, a d [4:14:20] or an f? [4:14:21] Can't tell you No. [4:14:24] For $1 billion company you'd [4:14:25] expect an a-plus. [4:14:27] Second thing that's missing [4:14:29] here is how much did the city [4:14:34] or residents of the city of San [4:14:37] Diego have to pay in litigation [4:14:41] with f, c, g and e? [4:14:43] How much damages did they do on [4:14:47] the undergrounding You know, in [4:14:52] the valuation that we had [4:14:53] before the undergrounding Seems [4:14:55] like we have to pay three times [4:14:58] for the same undergrounding. [4:15:00] And for the lawyers there [4:15:01] amongst you the law fixtures [4:15:04] should apply. [4:15:06] This is not like San Francisco [4:15:08] in any way. [4:15:10] San Francisco is a takeover. [4:15:12] Ours would be an end of a [4:15:14] franchise or at least that we [4:15:16] get the law for next year. [4:15:17] >> Thank you. [4:15:18] Thank you. [4:15:19] All right. [4:15:20] Our next speaker is John Lear. [4:15:27] Please begin. [4:15:28] >> Good afternoon. [4:15:28] This has been a long one. [4:15:29] I just really wish I could get [4:15:32] a contract where when I screw [4:15:34] up with a major installation [4:15:36] like a nuclear power plant I [4:15:38] get to build the customers for [4:15:39] it. [4:15:40] I don't even begin to [4:15:41] understand this cost plus [4:15:43] billing that we live under. [4:15:44] I will tell you this Six months [4:15:45] ago I had solar installed on [4:15:47] the on the unit that I live in. [4:15:50] Unfortunately I've not been [4:15:51] able to take advantage of it [4:15:52] until the last two months. [4:15:54] But I will say this I generate [4:15:56] twice as about twice the amount [4:15:58] of power that I need in this [4:16:02] household on that solar. [4:16:04] So the rest of it goes back to [4:16:05] my neighbors and the people [4:16:06] around me. [4:16:07] Unfortunately I'm not able to [4:16:09] take advantage of the benefit [4:16:10] of the reduced billing because [4:16:12] for 3 or 4 months as the genie [4:16:16] could get people out to inspect [4:16:18] and approve and turn it on [4:16:20] which is just outrageous. [4:16:22] Anyway, get solar, get away [4:16:24] from the grid and get rid as [4:16:24] the genie. [4:16:27] >> Thank you. [4:16:29] Thank you. [4:16:30] Our next speaker is caller with [4:16:33] the last four digits 8700. [4:16:36] Please begin. [4:16:41] >> Thank you, Joy. [4:16:41] It's turn. [4:16:44] I don't support the renewal of [4:16:48] the fda and the franchise [4:16:52] agreement. [4:16:53] My reasons are mostly in [4:16:57] the last paragraph of [4:16:59] the PowerPoint entitled [4:17:00] Conclusion and I quote [4:17:03] Conditional renewal supports [4:17:05] rate payers in the city's [4:17:08] objectives. [4:17:10] At the same time, complaints [4:17:12] alone doesn't solve concerns [4:17:14] about affordability rates or [4:17:16] long term value. [4:17:18] Ultimately the Council must [4:17:21] weigh both technical [4:17:22] performance in broader public [4:17:25] benefit in deciding whether to [4:17:27] renew Dear Council. [4:17:30] Dear Mayor do not renew It does [4:17:33] not support repairs. [4:17:35] It does not support the city [4:17:37] objectives. [4:17:38] We all know that. [4:17:40] So let's be bold. [4:17:42] Let's have the courage to say [4:17:45] no. [4:17:45] Thank you. [4:17:46] That concludes your time This [4:17:47] morning. [4:17:48] Thank you. [4:17:49] Thank you. [4:17:50] That concludes public testimony [4:17:52] on item 201. [4:17:55] >> All right. [4:17:55] Thank you, Deputy Clerk. [4:17:57] With that this is an [4:17:58] information item and no motions [4:18:00] required. [4:18:01] I'll turn it over to council [4:18:02] members and jump in if nobody [4:18:04] else wants to. [4:18:07] So I will jump in. [4:18:09] Again, thank you to the members [4:18:11] of the franchise compliance [4:18:12] agreement. [4:18:12] I mean it's committee excuse [4:18:14] me. [4:18:14] It's an interesting animal that [4:18:16] we've created and we appreciate [4:18:17] your two year stint. [4:18:19] You know, if I can make a pitch [4:18:20] for you to come back and do [4:18:21] another two years. [4:18:22] i would be remiss if I did not [4:18:24] do that. [4:18:26] I want to speak to some of [4:18:28] the things that were raised by [4:18:30] the public. [4:18:31] We have new faces doing utility [4:18:34] undergrounding and our [4:18:35] transportation department and [4:18:37] they've done some serious [4:18:39] changes to that that when we do [4:18:43] the next two year review I [4:18:44] don't think we're going to see [4:18:45] those same problems because [4:18:47] they've gotten much more [4:18:48] aggressive not only with Genie [4:18:50] but also with at&t and [4:18:51] Spectrum, [4:18:53] the telecommunications that [4:18:55] also have aboveground lines. [4:18:58] So I'm it didn't surprise me [4:19:00] that there were some instances [4:19:02] where there were problems going [4:19:04] forward But new crew internally [4:19:08] the city is doing a fantastic [4:19:09] job. [4:19:10] So I don't think we'll see it [4:19:11] in the next audit We go [4:19:13] forward. [4:19:14] And to MR. Kozinski or Bob [4:19:18] because I always pronounce your [4:19:19] name wrong I did reach out to [4:19:21] the city auditor to actually [4:19:22] look into the latter part. [4:19:24] You think I don't do anything? [4:19:26] And the city auditor reported [4:19:28] that they have heard these [4:19:30] allegations multiple times and [4:19:32] quote Our investigations [4:19:34] determined that the allegations [4:19:35] of fraud, waste and abuse were [4:19:38] unsubstantiated and that [4:19:39] the qualification requirements [4:19:40] for him claiming that the clerk [4:19:41] report were reasonable. [4:19:43] That comes from our independent [4:19:44] city auditor. [4:19:46] Take that for what it's worth. [4:19:48] But again thank you to [4:19:49] the auditors for the good work [4:19:51] that you do under the franchise [4:19:54] agreement. [4:19:55] Thank you again for the good [4:19:56] work that you do. [4:19:57] And then again the volunteers [4:19:58] who stepped up for [4:19:59] the committee very much [4:20:00] appreciate it. [4:20:01] With that we will go to council [4:20:03] member Eli Rivera. [4:20:06] >> All right. [4:20:07] Thank you. [4:20:07] Council PRESIDENT I just wanna [4:20:08] say thank you. [4:20:09] It's a ton of time and effort [4:20:11] that goes into this volunteer [4:20:13] work that you do and it is [4:20:15] important and is one of [4:20:17] the things that distinguishes [4:20:19] the way that we've approached [4:20:21] our our relationship ship with [4:20:26] Jeannie um and with this [4:20:26] franchise agreement in [4:20:27] comparison to what had been [4:20:29] done in the past. [4:20:30] I think that that positions us [4:20:31] better for the future and I'm [4:20:33] very grateful for the work that [4:20:34] you do to help us do that. [4:20:35] >> Thank you. [4:20:36] Council PRESIDENT. [4:20:37] All right. [4:20:38] Thank you. [4:20:38] Council Yellow Rivera Not [4:20:40] seeing anybody else in [4:20:41] the lights. [4:20:42] I will close this item up And [4:20:44] again thank you for the good [4:20:45] work and your patience on a [4:20:47] long afternoon. [4:20:54] Okay. [4:20:56] And with that deputy clerk [4:20:58] please introduce item 203 Thank [4:21:02] you, Council PRESIDENT Item 2 [4:21:03] or 3 approval of a Fifth [4:21:04] Amendment to the agreement with [4:21:05] Path of San Diego for [4:21:07] the Coordinated Street Outreach [4:21:09] Program. [4:21:11] >> All right. [4:21:11] Thank you for that. [4:21:12] This is a Fifth Amendment to an [4:21:14] agreement. [4:21:14] It's a little bit of a holdover [4:21:17] Would you guys be okay with [4:21:19] waiving the presentation given [4:21:21] that this is the Fifth [4:21:22] Amendment? [4:21:24] All right, So settle yourselves [4:21:27] in and Deputy clerk proceed [4:21:30] with public comment on item 203 [4:21:32] . [4:21:35] Thank you. [4:21:35] Council PRESIDENT We will begin [4:21:37] with an in-person comment [4:21:41] allegedly Order a please come [4:21:42] forward. [4:21:42] You'll have one minute to speak [4:21:54] And again you guys want to get [4:21:54] out of here. [4:21:54] But again the presentations [4:21:55] aren't for you guys. [4:21:57] It's also for the people. [4:21:59] All right. [4:22:00] So this is interesting because [4:22:02] you know, homelessness is [4:22:05] running rampant though It's [4:22:08] good for business when it is [4:22:10] it's fantastic. [4:22:11] There's so much money to be [4:22:12] made off of these people And [4:22:15] I'm wondering how good are they [4:22:16] doing if just right outside [4:22:19] the doors here there's homeless [4:22:20] people sleeping every night. [4:22:23] So I mean is that money well [4:22:24] spent And when there is no, you [4:22:26] know, path to another shelter [4:22:30] or you know, some kind of home [4:22:33] for like a hamster wheel and we [4:22:35] just keep going around. [4:22:36] It's like let's give more money [4:22:37] and maybe that will help fix [4:22:39] it. [4:22:39] No, we don't have anywhere for [4:22:40] them to go But we have these [4:22:42] people out there just telling [4:22:43] people, you know, that there's [4:22:46] nowhere for them to go but then [4:22:47] we're going to arrest them or [4:22:49] take their stuff, you know, [4:22:51] because they're out there. [4:22:52] So it seems like it's working [4:22:52] out. [4:22:54] Maybe you guys could get some [4:22:55] more money and throw it at it. [4:22:57] >> Thank you. [4:22:58] That concludes your time. [4:23:01] Our next speaker is Blair [4:23:02] Beekman followed by Anthony [4:23:04] Ralphs. [4:23:07] Hi, we're Beekman. [4:23:09] I'm filling improving today I [4:23:10] guess my my knowledge and depth [4:23:13] of community issues is pretty [4:23:16] feeble but gosh darn it this is [4:23:19] an item that I think really [4:23:21] needs a public presentation. [4:23:24] I'm the work that does for our [4:23:27] unhoused has been incredible [4:23:28] especially in the past few [4:23:29] years. [4:23:30] They've proven how much they [4:23:31] can house people and we don't [4:23:33] just talk about shelters we can [4:23:35] actually be talking about [4:23:36] housing issues. [4:23:38] I really ask the council to if [4:23:40] they can you know, be asking [4:23:42] questions after public [4:23:43] presentation and that they can [4:23:45] still make their presentation [4:23:47] that would be great too. [4:23:49] It's really important to be [4:23:51] hearing this item and I'm [4:23:52] really surprised we're avoiding [4:23:55] it out of efficiency and to get [4:23:58] home early. [4:24:00] This is an important step. [4:24:03] I hope we make this step more [4:24:05] open and clear in our public [4:24:06] future. [4:24:07] >> Thank you. [4:24:09] Anthony Ralphs Good afternoon [4:24:14] City Council Excuse me I [4:24:17] support the approval of [4:24:20] the Fifth Amendment to [4:24:21] the agreement with the path San [4:24:22] Diego Program for [4:24:23] the Coordinated Street Outreach [4:24:24] Program. [4:24:26] At a time when we've seen so [4:24:28] many of our homeless programs [4:24:29] and outreach programs cut [4:24:31] particularly the Alpha project [4:24:33] particularly I believe it was I [4:24:38] forget the good the good center [4:24:40] I'm blanking on the full name [4:24:41] of it. [4:24:42] But anyway we've had so many [4:24:43] homeless programs cut and this [4:24:46] is a matter of public safety [4:24:47] and I know how quick all are to [4:24:49] defend public safety. [4:24:51] So I would expect that we could [4:24:53] have that same approach with [4:24:56] our homeless, that same [4:24:57] compassion and empathy and that [4:24:59] these programs can pan out and [4:25:01] help the people that they are [4:25:02] intended to serve. [4:25:03] Thank you. [4:25:07] Thank you. [4:25:08] That concludes in-person public [4:25:09] comment. [4:25:10] I've started the five minute [4:25:11] timer and council chambers. [4:25:13] We will now turn to the virtual [4:25:14] queue in which there are [4:25:16] currently three participants [4:25:17] requesting to speak. [4:25:20] We will begin with color with [4:25:23] the last four digits 8700 [4:25:26] Please begin and thank you Joy [4:25:34] Senator Yes I support this item [4:25:37] passed. [4:25:38] It is absolutely fabulous. [4:25:40] I don't have personal [4:25:41] experience with them but I had [4:25:44] a wonderful experience with [4:25:45] the homeless couple years ago [4:25:47] when I moved here and I [4:25:49] followed their experience with [4:25:52] past and how they helped them [4:25:54] and it was very beautiful. [4:25:55] The only concern I have for [4:25:57] Path it seems like a few years [4:25:59] ago they were having trouble [4:26:01] with really paying their people [4:26:02] enough to work and perhaps they [4:26:06] were having trouble filling [4:26:07] positions that could have been [4:26:09] corrected And I MAY be way off [4:26:10] base on that but that just [4:26:12] popped up when I thought about [4:26:13] what I was going to say. [4:26:15] So love path just support them [4:26:18] wherever we can and love you [4:26:20] Path for what you do for [4:26:21] the homeless and that affects [4:26:23] all of San Diego Love to all [4:26:26] Thank you. [4:26:28] Next is Natalie Roski. [4:26:30] Please begin. [4:26:34] >> Hi Natalie. [4:26:36] Rush here District seven. [4:26:36] So I've been doing some [4:26:37] research and I'm really getting [4:26:39] good at my research I think so [4:26:41] I'm kind of confused on what [4:26:43] I'm researching and what this [4:26:45] path San Diego Fifth Amendment [4:26:47] means because it's telling me [4:26:51] that the resolution before it [4:26:54] describes this routine one year [4:26:55] extension flat funding at 13.6 [4:26:57] million and change. [4:27:00] But there's an underlining [4:27:02] amendment does something that [4:27:04] the resolution never mentions [4:27:05] It adds a new clause [4:27:10] acknowledge is that h m c. [4:27:11] S and c I e the data systems [4:27:12] used to track and house [4:27:15] residents are some surveillance [4:27:16] technology under the trust [4:27:18] ordinance. [4:27:20] So moving forward and improving [4:27:23] are these systems being used [4:27:25] currently? [4:27:28] Is there understanding [4:27:30] the grace period and is this [4:27:33] being acknowledged or is this [4:27:35] was known about is it [4:27:38] the question? [4:27:38] Thank you. [4:27:39] That does conclude your time. [4:27:42] Next speaker is John Leah. [4:27:44] Please begin. [4:27:49] Good afternoon. [4:27:50] Council members. [4:27:51] It's been a long one but I did [4:27:52] want to make time to update you [4:27:54] that I actually that [4:27:57] the individual that came out [4:27:58] front of city Council in my rv [4:28:00] for a period of time I'm not [4:28:04] sure where ultimately that [4:28:05] situation is resolved but I [4:28:07] will tell you that we've run [4:28:08] into these cases all the time. [4:28:11] I love that they're an amazing [4:28:12] provider. [4:28:13] We have had nothing but a high [4:28:15] regard for much of their [4:28:16] service. [4:28:17] So this is not necessarily [4:28:18] related to path but we do not [4:28:20] have a mechanism for people who [4:28:22] are struggling and falling [4:28:24] through the cracks to raise [4:28:26] their hand and go Hey, what's [4:28:28] going on? [4:28:29] And I don't think that we are [4:28:31] capturing the number of people [4:28:33] that are returning to our [4:28:35] system effectively because [4:28:36] after two years if you come [4:28:39] back into the system are hmas [4:28:42] recognize here is a brand new [4:28:43] person anyway we need to be [4:28:45] listening to our customers. [4:28:47] We're still not and I would [4:28:48] hope that we could take that [4:28:49] seriously. [4:28:50] Thank you. [4:28:52] Thank you. [4:28:53] That does conclude public [4:28:55] comment on item 203. [4:28:57] All right. [4:28:57] Thank you, Deputy Clerk. [4:28:59] This is an item for discussion [4:29:02] and we will need a motion. [4:29:04] So we'll turn over first to [4:29:05] Council member Whipper Thank [4:29:07] you Council PRESIDENT I will [4:29:09] make the motion to approve [4:29:11] the staff recommendation. [4:29:13] This presentation is online. [4:29:15] Both the PowerPoint and [4:29:17] the staff report are on line [4:29:20] for everybody to access and [4:29:22] they've been online for [4:29:23] everybody to access for several [4:29:24] days now. [4:29:26] This does not add more money to [4:29:30] the contract. [4:29:32] It extends the term of [4:29:34] the contract. [4:29:35] These response teams that I [4:29:38] have has out there assess [4:29:39] people who are experiencing [4:29:41] homelessness and have helped [4:29:44] hundreds of people not just get [4:29:46] into emergency shelters but [4:29:49] also into housing both [4:29:53] temporary and permanent [4:29:53] housing. [4:29:54] And that's very important [4:29:55] because I am deeply concerned [4:29:57] about the unavailability of [4:30:02] emergency shelter. [4:30:03] We need more shelter beds to be [4:30:05] available to people. [4:30:10] But the good news is that path [4:30:12] is also directing people to [4:30:13] housing And as long as we're [4:30:17] getting people off the streets [4:30:17] and directly into housing, [4:30:19] that's a good thing. [4:30:19] One of the most important [4:30:20] things we could be doing and I [4:30:22] will approve move the staff [4:30:25] recommendation. [4:30:26] All right. [4:30:27] Thank you, sir. [4:30:27] So we have a motion by council [4:30:28] member Whipper and we'll go [4:30:29] next to Council PRESIDENT Pro [4:30:31] Tem Lee. [4:30:32] Thank you Council PRESIDENT And [4:30:33] thank you to path for their [4:30:34] continued work as well. [4:30:35] I'll second this motion. [4:30:37] >> All right so we have a [4:30:38] motion by Councilmember Whipper [4:30:39] and a second by Council [4:30:40] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee to move [4:30:41] the staff recommendation. [4:30:43] I see Council member John [4:30:46] Wolpert sup Thank you very much [4:30:47] and thank you for all the work [4:30:49] that path does as well. [4:30:50] I appreciate it. [4:30:51] I know that does increase [4:30:53] the amount of the contract but [4:30:54] it is the Fifth Amendment. [4:30:55] So are we thinking about doing [4:30:56] another rfp at some point or a [4:30:58] new scope of services or what's [4:31:00] the plan? [4:31:00] We released the rfp in APRIL of [4:31:02] this year so we intend to [4:31:04] fulfill the awardees of the rfp [4:31:07] in this next fiscal year and [4:31:10] that will then supersede this [4:31:11] contract. [4:31:12] Okay. [4:31:12] All right. [4:31:12] Thank you very much. [4:31:14] And Sara, could you introduce [4:31:15] yourself for the record since [4:31:16] you did a response? [4:31:16] Sorry. [4:31:17] Third Dorman, director of [4:31:18] Homelessness Strategies and [4:31:19] Solutions Deanna would be very [4:31:21] mad at me if I didn't get that [4:31:22] done All right, I I don't see [4:31:24] anybody else in the light. [4:31:25] I'll just add my Thank you for [4:31:27] managing that And to the folks [4:31:30] at path we have a motion by [4:31:32] Councilmember Lipper and a [4:31:32] second by Council PRESIDENT Pro [4:31:34] Tem Lee to move the staff [4:31:35] recommendation please call [4:31:37] the roll Deputy Clerk I have [4:31:39] set up the voting system. [4:31:40] Please cast your vote. [4:31:53] The item passes unanimously [4:31:54] with District two and District [4:31:56] eight absent. [4:31:57] >> All right. [4:31:59] And for meeting management [4:32:00] the reason we did that was to [4:32:02] make sure that we have a quorum [4:32:03] when it comes to not agenda [4:32:05] public comment at the end. [4:32:07] So for those that might [4:32:08] participate remotely stay [4:32:11] tuned. [4:32:11] We MAY or MAY not have a quorum [4:32:13] to have remote not a agenda [4:32:15] public comment We will [4:32:16] definitely do it for in-person [4:32:18] non agenda Public comment [4:32:20] meeting Management All right [4:32:23] Deputy Clerk please introduce [4:32:24] item 202 Thank you Council [4:32:27] PRESIDENT Item 2o2 [4:32:29] Establishment of a cannabis [4:32:30] Delivery Services business [4:32:32] permit and enhanced commercial [4:32:34] cannabis enforcement mechanisms [4:32:38] . [4:32:38] All right. [4:32:38] I believe this is coming from [4:32:40] district seven. [4:32:41] So Councilmember Camp here do [4:32:42] you want to have some opening [4:32:42] remarks? [4:32:43] Thank you. [4:32:44] Counsel turn it over to your [4:32:44] staff. [4:32:45] Yes. [4:32:45] Council PRESIDENT, thank you [4:32:46] very much for that. [4:32:46] And before we begin with [4:32:47] the staff presentation, I'd [4:32:49] like to take a moment to [4:32:50] recognize the amount of work [4:32:51] that's gone in today's action [4:32:52] over the past two years not [4:32:54] only from my office but from [4:32:55] the mayor's office and cannabis [4:32:57] workers and businesses, members [4:32:59] of the public who've engaged [4:33:00] with us throughout this [4:33:01] process. [4:33:02] Cannabis delivery is a complex [4:33:03] policy issue and the item we [4:33:05] are putting forward for [4:33:06] consideration today is one that [4:33:08] puts accountability, safety and [4:33:09] workers first. [4:33:11] So with that I'll turn over to [4:33:12] Summer Patten, Deputy director [4:33:13] of policy for my office for [4:33:15] the presentation. [4:33:16] >> Thank you. [4:33:17] i need ten minutes for [4:33:18] the presentation when you're [4:33:20] ready. [4:33:21] >> Good afternoon. [4:33:22] Council PRESIDENT Lacob and [4:33:23] council members I'm presenting [4:33:25] here today on behalf of [4:33:26] Councilmember Campo [4:33:27] the establishment of a cannabis [4:33:28] delivery services business [4:33:30] permit and enhanced commercial [4:33:31] cannabis enforcement mechanisms [4:33:33] . [4:33:37] >> The proposed actions today [4:33:38] are to establish a cannabis [4:33:39] delivery business permit [4:33:41] category for commercial [4:33:42] cannabis operators entering [4:33:43] the city of San Diego to [4:33:45] conduct cannabis delivery. [4:33:46] I'm sorry, can you hold on? [4:33:48] We're not displaying. [4:33:49] There we go. [4:33:50] Okay. [4:33:50] Very nice. [4:33:50] My apologies for [4:33:52] the interruption. [4:33:53] Go ahead. [4:33:53] Good. [4:33:55] So that's the first action. [4:33:57] The second is to establish a [4:33:58] private right of action to [4:33:59] allow eligible entities to [4:34:01] pursue step one enforcement [4:34:02] against operators that violate [4:34:04] local commercial cannabis [4:34:05] regulations. [4:34:06] And third is to revise [4:34:08] penalties for noncompliance to [4:34:10] a maximum of $20,000 per day [4:34:12] for court imposed civil [4:34:13] penalties and $20,000 per [4:34:16] violation for administratively [4:34:17] imposed civil penalties not to [4:34:20] exceed $500,000 per parcel or [4:34:22] business and up to 10,000 per [4:34:25] violation for administrative [4:34:26] abatement penalties not to [4:34:28] exceed 500,000 per parcel or [4:34:30] structure. [4:34:32] And before we discuss [4:34:34] the proposed changes, it's [4:34:35] helpful to review the licensing [4:34:36] system around commercial [4:34:37] cannabis. [4:34:38] Cannabis in California is [4:34:40] regulated on a dual track [4:34:41] system meaning that cannabis is [4:34:43] regulated both by the state and [4:34:45] by a businesses, city or county [4:34:46] . [4:34:48] And at the state level there [4:34:49] are two types of retail [4:34:50] licenses. [4:34:51] There is a non storefront [4:34:53] retailer or delivery only [4:34:54] business which is what we're [4:34:55] talking about today. [4:34:57] And there are storefront [4:34:58] retailers or brick and mortar [4:34:59] businesses. [4:35:00] And while state law allows [4:35:04] cannabis delivery on public [4:35:05] roads, state law also [4:35:06] explicitly states that local [4:35:08] jurisdictions have authority to [4:35:09] regulate cannabis businesses [4:35:11] including through business [4:35:12] license requirements. [4:35:14] Cities and counties can [4:35:15] prohibit cannabis of all [4:35:18] business types some or [4:35:19] implement their own regulations [4:35:20] . [4:35:21] And as shown on the map, this [4:35:23] creates a patchwork of local [4:35:24] regulations throughout [4:35:25] the state. [4:35:29] >> So if a customer in San [4:35:30] Diego is ordering cannabis for [4:35:32] delivery, it can either come [4:35:34] from a permitted retailer in [4:35:35] the city a state licensed [4:35:37] business entering the city to [4:35:38] deliver or a business operating [4:35:41] outside of legal requirements. [4:35:43] Currently the city only permits [4:35:45] storefront or brick and mortar [4:35:46] cannabis retailers. [4:35:48] These are the ones that are [4:35:49] limited to four per council [4:35:50] district and they're required [4:35:51] to obtain a conditional use [4:35:52] permit. [4:35:54] They are allowed to deliver [4:35:55] direct to consumer as part of [4:35:56] that conditional use permit. [4:35:58] The city allows state licensed [4:36:00] delivery from outside of [4:36:01] the city If that business [4:36:02] registers for a business tax [4:36:04] certificate with [4:36:05] the Treasurer's office and [4:36:06] remits monthly business taxes. [4:36:08] The city's land use code does [4:36:10] not allow delivery only [4:36:11] non-food storefront retail [4:36:13] establishments within city [4:36:14] limits. [4:36:15] And this ordinance does not [4:36:16] change that. [4:36:16] And it does not propose any new [4:36:18] land uses. [4:36:21] Cannabis delivery is extremely [4:36:23] difficult to regulate because [4:36:24] the operations are mobile. [4:36:26] And cities can only regulate [4:36:27] what occurs within their [4:36:28] jurisdiction. [4:36:29] And cannabis businesses can [4:36:30] easily avoid those regulations. [4:36:32] And on the screen is an example [4:36:34] of a listing on weed maps for a [4:36:36] business advertising in North [4:36:37] Park. [4:36:39] That's based in Alameda County [4:36:40] and I'm looking at the license [4:36:43] on the Department of Cannabis [4:36:44] Control website. [4:36:45] It's expired but they currently [4:36:48] advertise 30 to 60 minute [4:36:49] deliveries in San Diego. [4:36:52] So here we can see [4:36:54] the difference between what's [4:36:55] advertised to consumers and [4:36:56] where the current the city [4:36:58] currently permits cannabis [4:36:59] retail. [4:37:00] The image on the left are [4:37:02] delivery only offerings listed [4:37:04] on weed maps in San Diego. [4:37:06] And some of these businesses [4:37:07] are advertising is based in San [4:37:09] Diego and are licensed to [4:37:10] the state. [4:37:11] Some are not licensed through [4:37:12] the state or operate on expired [4:37:14] permits or are not following [4:37:15] all state and local [4:37:16] requirements. [4:37:18] State licensing a strict and [4:37:19] requires those businesses to [4:37:21] return to a licensed premise [4:37:23] after a delivery route. [4:37:24] To use license facilities to [4:37:26] restock their product. [4:37:27] To dispatch deliveries only [4:37:29] after orders are received and [4:37:30] logged. [4:37:31] And it also requires delivery [4:37:32] of cannabis goods to be [4:37:33] performed by a driver employed [4:37:35] by that retailer. [4:37:37] >> For the retailers to [4:37:38] maintain an accurate list of [4:37:39] their delivery employees to [4:37:40] confirm ages and identities of [4:37:42] customers. [4:37:43] And for a delivery drivers to [4:37:44] carry copies of the retailers [4:37:46] license id and an employee [4:37:48] badge. [4:37:49] Which are just a few examples [4:37:50] of the numerous other state [4:37:51] requirements as part of [4:37:54] commercial cannabis delivery. [4:37:57] So with that the goals for this [4:37:59] ordinance are to create a [4:38:00] centralized regulatory check [4:38:02] point for cannabis delivery [4:38:03] services entering the city of [4:38:04] San Diego. [4:38:07] It's to increase the cost of [4:38:07] noncompliance through raise [4:38:10] penalties. [4:38:11] And third, it's to allow [4:38:12] private civil action where [4:38:14] the city currently lacks staff [4:38:15] capacity. [4:38:17] Next slide. [4:38:19] So with stronger civil [4:38:20] enforcement the goal is to [4:38:21] incentivize registration for a [4:38:23] cannabis delivery services [4:38:25] business permit and encourage [4:38:26] local compliance. [4:38:28] This requirement would be in [4:38:30] addition to the business tax [4:38:31] certificate and cannabis [4:38:32] business tax currently required [4:38:34] and administered through [4:38:35] the City Treasurer's office. [4:38:36] So all three of those processes [4:38:38] will be administered by [4:38:39] the city Treasurer's office. [4:38:42] Cannabis delivery businesses [4:38:44] entering into the city of San [4:38:45] Diego would be required to [4:38:46] obtain the permit. [4:38:48] This does not include current [4:38:49] cup holders as delivery [4:38:51] services are already permitted [4:38:53] and regulated through their [4:38:54] conditional use permit and they [4:38:56] are subject to an annual [4:38:57] cannabis fee at around $15,000 [4:38:59] a year. [4:39:00] The application requirements [4:39:02] are modeled off of the City of [4:39:03] Ventura which has a similar [4:39:04] license and would require a [4:39:06] copy of the business's state [4:39:07] retail license a copy of their [4:39:10] business tax certificate [4:39:11] information of all owners and [4:39:14] employees. [4:39:15] Proof that employees are direct [4:39:17] employees of the delivery [4:39:18] service as required by state [4:39:20] law. [4:39:21] And the fee amount would be [4:39:22] determined in a future action [4:39:24] to determine the exact costs [4:39:26] recoverable amounts related to [4:39:28] the registration or permit [4:39:28] expense. [4:39:36] So the proposed enforcement [4:39:37] changes are to increase civil [4:39:38] penalties in three categories [4:39:40] in the code regulating [4:39:41] commercial cannabis operations. [4:39:43] The first is to increase court [4:39:45] awarded civil penalties for [4:39:46] commercial cannabis violations [4:39:47] up to $20,000 per day for [4:39:50] cannabis business. [4:39:51] The second is to increase [4:39:52] administrative civil penalties [4:39:54] for violations up to $20,000 [4:39:55] per day not to exceed 500,000 [4:39:56] per business. [4:40:00] And third, this ordinance [4:40:01] defines cannabis violations as [4:40:03] a public nuisance which would [4:40:04] then allow the city to abate [4:40:05] violations if there's capacity. [4:40:08] The penalty amounts are aligned [4:40:09] with recent updates to land [4:40:10] development code which was [4:40:12] updated at $10,000 provi lation [4:40:14] not to exceed 500,000 per [4:40:16] parcel. [4:40:18] But the significant enforcement [4:40:19] change is to introduce a [4:40:21] private right of action for [4:40:22] cannabis related code [4:40:23] violations. [4:40:25] Private right of action are [4:40:26] more commonly used in labor law [4:40:27] but was implemented to allow [4:40:29] civil enforcement against [4:40:30] cannabis violations most [4:40:31] recently through ab 1171 which [4:40:34] was implemented in 2024. [4:40:36] The ordinance proposes [4:40:37] establishing the private right [4:40:39] of action to allow legal [4:40:40] cannabis businesses or labor [4:40:42] organizations representing [4:40:43] cannabis workers to file civil [4:40:45] actions to enforce compliance. [4:40:47] This means that a licensed [4:40:48] cannabis business could sue a [4:40:50] business if they can establish [4:40:51] that a violation of this [4:40:53] ordinance occurred within city [4:40:54] limits and any penalties [4:40:56] recovered would be distributed [4:40:58] between the city for [4:40:59] enforcement and the entity [4:41:00] bringing the civil action 65% [4:41:02] to 35%. [4:41:04] And this distribution was [4:41:05] modeled after the private [4:41:07] Attorney General's act or paga [4:41:08] which was updated in 2020 for. [4:41:12] So with that the recommended [4:41:14] action today is to approve [4:41:15] amendments to Chapter four [4:41:18] Article two Division 15 of [4:41:19] the San Diego Municipal Code to [4:41:21] establish a cannabis delivery [4:41:22] permit business permit category [4:41:24] for commercial cannabis [4:41:25] operators entering the city of [4:41:26] San Diego to conduct delivery [4:41:29] to create a private right of [4:41:30] action allowing eligible [4:41:31] entities including state [4:41:32] certified cannabis retailers [4:41:33] and labor unions representing [4:41:35] cannabis workers to pursue [4:41:37] civil enforcement against [4:41:38] operators that violate local [4:41:39] commercial cannabis regulations [4:41:42] and to revise penalties for [4:41:44] noncompliance to a maximum of [4:41:45] $20,000 per day for court [4:41:47] imposed civil penalties. [4:41:49] 20,000 per violation for [4:41:49] administratively imposed [4:41:50] penalties and up to $10,000 per [4:41:53] violation for administrative [4:41:55] abatement penalties. [4:41:58] And that concludes my [4:41:59] presentation. [4:42:00] Thank you. [4:42:01] All right. [4:42:01] Thank you very much for [4:42:02] the work and the presentation. [4:42:04] Now I'll turn it over to [4:42:04] the office of the rba for [4:42:07] comment. [4:42:07] >> Thank you. [4:42:07] Council PRESIDENT Sergio [4:42:08] Leclaire from the iab his [4:42:09] office as presented by staff [4:42:12] The this proposal would make [4:42:13] four main changes to [4:42:15] the municipal code. [4:42:16] First they would create a new [4:42:17] permit category specifically [4:42:19] for cannabis businesses that [4:42:20] are based outside the city but [4:42:23] deliver cannabis products to [4:42:24] customers within city limits. [4:42:26] Consistent with the status quo. [4:42:29] This proposal will not permit [4:42:30] delivery only businesses based [4:42:32] within the city. [4:42:34] Second, it would establish a [4:42:35] private right of action [4:42:36] allowing compliant cannabis [4:42:38] businesses and representative [4:42:41] labor organizations to pursue [4:42:42] civil action against operators [4:42:44] without a civil city permit [4:42:46] without a valid city permit. [4:42:48] Civil penalties recoverable in [4:42:50] this manner would be shared [4:42:51] with the city. [4:42:53] Third, it will classify [4:42:54] cannabis businesses without a [4:42:56] city permit as a public [4:42:57] nuisance. [4:42:58] And lastly it would separate. [4:42:59] It would update fines for those [4:43:01] that fail to comply with [4:43:03] the city's cannabis permitting [4:43:04] requirements. [4:43:06] Based on our conversations with [4:43:07] relevant departments. [4:43:08] The fiscal impact of this [4:43:10] proposal is uncertain but MAY [4:43:12] not be substantial. [4:43:13] There are three noteworthy [4:43:15] sources of potential revenue [4:43:17] outlined in the proposal. [4:43:18] First is permitting fees. [4:43:20] Second is city imposed fines. [4:43:22] And then third is the city's [4:43:24] share of civil penalties [4:43:25] recovered through private right [4:43:26] of action which would be one [4:43:28] time in nature. [4:43:30] Regarding permitting fees, [4:43:32] the number of businesses likely [4:43:33] to seek a new delivery permit [4:43:35] is limited currently to conduct [4:43:37] business including deliveries [4:43:39] within the city. [4:43:40] Cannabis businesses outside [4:43:41] city limits must obtain a [4:43:43] business tax certificate and [4:43:44] remit cannabis business tax. [4:43:47] The city Treasurer's office [4:43:48] indicated that there are five [4:43:49] of these compliant businesses. [4:43:51] Staff noted that if a new [4:43:53] permit is established these [4:43:54] five businesses are expected to [4:43:56] obtain the new permit in [4:43:58] addition to the business tax to [4:44:01] cannabis delivery services that [4:44:03] do not currently have business [4:44:03] . [4:44:05] Business tax ratification, [4:44:07] however, would likely not [4:44:08] comply with additional [4:44:10] permitting requirement given [4:44:12] the small number of affected [4:44:13] businesses Any permit fee [4:44:15] revenue as well as cannabis [4:44:16] business tax revenue would [4:44:17] likely be limited unless [4:44:19] private rights of action compel [4:44:21] enforcement. [4:44:23] Regarding fines we found that [4:44:25] the city currently does not [4:44:26] receive currently receives [4:44:27] minimal city issued penalty [4:44:29] revenue from delivery operators [4:44:31] that do not comply with [4:44:32] the city's current regulations. [4:44:34] Therefore, even with [4:44:35] adjustments to the fines city [4:44:37] issued penalty revenue would [4:44:39] likely remain minimal. [4:44:42] The private Right of action [4:44:43] provision offers an additional [4:44:44] enforcement tool for private [4:44:46] entities. [4:44:48] Though state law allows [4:44:49] licensed cannabis businesses [4:44:51] including those permitted by by [4:44:53] the city to pursue civil action [4:44:56] against operators without a [4:44:58] state license, cannabis [4:44:59] license. [4:45:00] The city's city attorney's [4:45:02] office has not found any [4:45:03] reported cases of such [4:45:04] lawsuits. [4:45:05] So it's unclear whether [4:45:06] eligible parties would choose [4:45:08] to pursue civil action under [4:45:10] this proposal. [4:45:12] As noted by the presentation, [4:45:13] however, the state's provision [4:45:14] has a higher burden of proof [4:45:16] and a more limited financial [4:45:17] incentive Compared to this [4:45:19] proposal. [4:45:20] Additionally, this proposal [4:45:21] would also allow compliant city [4:45:23] businesses to pursue civil [4:45:24] action against operators [4:45:25] without a city permit work [4:45:26] orders regardless of whether [4:45:29] they have a state issued [4:45:31] cannabis license or not or [4:45:34] the intent of this proposal is [4:45:35] to regulate state licensed [4:45:37] cannabis businesses not [4:45:38] complying with city regulations [4:45:40] or unregulated operators. [4:45:42] We note that the greater [4:45:43] compliance challenge lies [4:45:44] within with cannabis delivery [4:45:46] businesses that operate [4:45:48] illicitly without state issued [4:45:49] licenses or illicit operators [4:45:52] since again they're unlikely to [4:45:53] comply with the new additional [4:45:55] local permit requirement. [4:45:57] Additionally, since this [4:45:58] proposal doesn't increase [4:45:59] the city's enforcement levels, [4:46:02] the permit and fines provision [4:46:03] of this proposal MAY not [4:46:05] significantly improve [4:46:06] compliance among illicit or [4:46:08] unregulated operators and [4:46:09] materially increase the city's [4:46:11] revenues. [4:46:12] Unless a private right of [4:46:13] action compels enforcement [4:46:16] During our discussions with [4:46:18] the Development Services [4:46:20] Department and the Treasurer [4:46:22] they raise concerns regarding [4:46:23] implementation. [4:46:24] These operational concerns [4:46:25] include uncertainty over [4:46:26] whether which new which [4:46:28] department would enforce [4:46:30] the new perimeter permit or [4:46:32] what enforcement of the new [4:46:33] permit would look like from [4:46:34] the city's perspective. [4:46:36] Questions about the city's [4:46:37] authority to find businesses [4:46:39] located outside city boundaries [4:46:40] and whether additional [4:46:42] resources would be needed to [4:46:43] administer and enforce [4:46:44] the program. [4:46:46] We recommend that council [4:46:48] inquire further with [4:46:48] departments including the city [4:46:50] Attorney's office, city [4:46:51] treasurers, dsd and police [4:46:53] the police department regarding [4:46:55] the practical challenges of [4:46:56] implementing and enforcing [4:46:57] these provisions and whether [4:46:59] they are there are any [4:47:00] outstanding issues. [4:47:02] This concludes my comments and [4:47:04] are available for any [4:47:05] questions. [4:47:06] Then comes Council PRESIDENT. [4:47:06] All right, Thank you for your [4:47:07] always appreciate the input at [4:47:09] the office. [4:47:09] With that Deputy clerk please [4:47:11] proceed with public comment. [4:47:13] >> This item received five [4:47:15] comments in Opposition via our [4:47:17] economic forum which has been [4:47:18] distributed to the Council. [4:47:19] We'll begin with in-person [4:47:21] comment. [4:47:23] DeAndre Brooks please come [4:47:25] forward. [4:47:25] You'll have one minute to speak [4:47:27] while DeAndre walks to [4:47:28] the microphone I would ask Matt [4:47:28] Stransky. [4:47:32] Mark o'Brien as our man king [4:47:33] And Terry best to please come [4:47:35] to the front row Council [4:47:39] members My name is DeAndre [4:47:40] Brooks and I'm here tonight as [4:47:43] a concerned citizen with strong [4:47:45] opposition to this ordinance [4:47:47] for several reasons. [4:47:49] In a sense it creates a [4:47:51] monopoly on the delivery [4:47:52] services and that's also [4:47:54] counterproductive to [4:47:55] the county's cannabis equity [4:47:57] program that's been spearheaded [4:47:58] . [4:48:00] So for individuals who have [4:48:01] been harmed by the war on drugs [4:48:03] and then living out over [4:48:05] criminalized communities an [4:48:06] opportunity to get into [4:48:07] the cannabis industry so we end [4:48:10] up voting yes to things like [4:48:12] that. [4:48:13] It is super counterproductive [4:48:14] to what we're trying to do as a [4:48:16] county. [4:48:17] And if you recall this same [4:48:19] issue came before this city [4:48:20] council and you guys kind of [4:48:23] shut it down basically sort of [4:48:24] county had to come in to give [4:48:26] that demographic an opportunity [4:48:27] to thrive in this industry. [4:48:29] So again, I'm a strong [4:48:31] opposition to this and I urge [4:48:32] you to consider everything I [4:48:34] just said Thank you, MR. Ski. [4:48:40] I don't see you. [4:48:42] Okay. [4:48:42] We'll move on to Marco Briones [4:48:42] . [4:48:45] Thank you, council members. [4:48:46] But again we stand in [4:48:47] solidarity with the brothers [4:48:48] and sisters of 135 you if cw [4:48:51] and ask you to support this [4:48:52] ordinance today at a time [4:48:54] cannabis delivery businesses [4:48:55] are avoiding paying the city's [4:48:56] cannabis retail tax and harming [4:48:58] our local permitted cannabis [4:48:59] retailers like the ones I've [4:49:00] known since childhood that are [4:49:03] here today. [4:49:03] So our local cannabis workers [4:49:04] are really feeling these [4:49:05] effects of the unregulated [4:49:07] activity, seeing their hours of [4:49:09] layoffs and wages reduced [4:49:11] workers and taxpayers are [4:49:12] better. [4:49:13] >> We support this and we ask [4:49:14] you to do the same. [4:49:15] Thank you. [4:49:19] Thank you. [4:49:20] Our next speaker is Armand [4:49:21] King. [4:49:21] All right. [4:49:23] Do you have several speakers [4:49:25] reading time to you? [4:49:26] When I call your name please [4:49:27] raise your hand to confirm [4:49:29] you're here. [4:49:29] Justin Lewis going on. [4:49:30] Okay. [4:49:32] Anthony Hawkins. [4:49:34] Okay, Louis The waste business [4:49:38] gone. [4:49:38] Okay. [4:49:40] And tis one Let us Okay. [4:49:44] >> So that you'll have three [4:49:44] minutes. [4:49:45] Okay. [4:49:45] Sounds good. [4:49:47] Thank you. [4:49:48] So what was pointed out was [4:49:49] Alameda, right? [4:49:51] Alameda problem There are there [4:49:52] is a problem with dispensary [4:49:54] deliveries happening from [4:49:55] outside of San Diego County. [4:49:57] Very much so that should be [4:49:59] regulated. [4:50:00] What's not mentioned is our [4:50:01] neighbors La mesa, National [4:50:02] City, Chula Vista. [4:50:04] Let me grow now They cannot [4:50:05] deliver across the street [4:50:06] without going through this and [4:50:08] I'm not here to fight for them. [4:50:09] I doubt has been reach out to [4:50:11] these cities to let them know [4:50:12] that this is about to happen. [4:50:13] There has not been adequate [4:50:14] reach out to communities We [4:50:17] there hasn't been a time limit [4:50:20] right now The problem is and [4:50:21] what I'm here representing [4:50:22] those social equity applicants [4:50:25] I'm the program manager for [4:50:26] the County of San Diego Social [4:50:28] Equity Program. [4:50:29] The majority of our [4:50:31] participants are San Diego City [4:50:33] residents from your district, [4:50:34] your district or district in [4:50:36] your district the majority of [4:50:37] them. [4:50:38] Why are they in a county [4:50:39] program? [4:50:40] Because we all know I thought [4:50:42] we know we had it here and [4:50:44] the same entities that are [4:50:46] coming bringing that brought [4:50:47] this law because it didn't come [4:50:48] from your office, it came from [4:50:49] the same people, the same evil [4:50:51] people that stripped us from [4:50:55] having a social equity program [4:50:56] here are now back in this. [4:50:59] So what's behind the scenes [4:51:00] That private right to action [4:51:02] private right to action is [4:51:03] saying there now you all by [4:51:05] voting yes or giving them a [4:51:07] loaded gun to now attack [4:51:09] the very people that should be [4:51:11] in the city program right now [4:51:13] These people live in your city. [4:51:14] They live in Linda Vista. [4:51:16] They live in North Park. [4:51:17] They live in southeast San [4:51:18] Diego. [4:51:19] They live here. [4:51:20] And even if now they have to [4:51:21] locate because to have a [4:51:23] delivery service you have to [4:51:24] have a building somewhere to [4:51:26] deliver. [4:51:26] Forget outside. [4:51:28] Forget Oakland, forget L.A. San [4:51:29] Diego residents that you're [4:51:31] attacking here are people so [4:51:33] they have to have a break not a [4:51:35] brick and mortar but a building [4:51:36] where they store their their [4:51:39] stories that they live in San [4:51:39] Diego. [4:51:40] They pay rent in Central City. [4:51:42] They shop in San Diego City. [4:51:43] Where's the revenue coming back [4:51:45] to here? [4:51:46] So my only ask is is there a [4:51:48] way for us if we want to [4:51:50] register them because they're [4:51:51] going to be legal operators, [4:51:53] Can we set up a process to [4:51:56] where the city of San Diego [4:51:57] knows who they are but to add [4:51:59] an extra barrier to people who [4:52:00] have been buried and we stand [4:52:03] here marching on the ashes of a [4:52:05] program that we should have had [4:52:07] right Because certain people [4:52:09] are afraid to feel the wrath of [4:52:12] high paid lobbyists that are [4:52:14] pushing this forward. [4:52:16] >> I have represented [4:52:17] the people from your city. [4:52:19] Clean this up. [4:52:21] Yes, we need to regulate [4:52:22] outside people. [4:52:23] Yes, we do. [4:52:23] But this ain't it. [4:52:25] Let's do this right Because [4:52:26] once you sign this once you say [4:52:28] yes and this is put into place [4:52:29] you're giving You heard of a [4:52:30] Trojan horse, right? [4:52:32] It looks nice and shiny. [4:52:33] The way to deliver to your is [4:52:35] we're keeping out all these [4:52:36] outside folks But meanwhile [4:52:37] inside that Trojan horse is an [4:52:39] army ready to attack. [4:52:40] They can't wait to see all [4:52:41] these people out of business. [4:52:43] They couldn't stop the county [4:52:44] the same way they stopped [4:52:45] the city They couldn't And [4:52:47] we're about to have unlimited [4:52:48] delivery services. [4:52:51] Thank you for your time. [4:52:51] Thank you. [4:52:53] Next up Terry Bass. [4:52:54] Well, Terry walks to [4:52:54] the microphone. [4:52:56] I would like to ask Daniela [4:52:57] Nelson, Victoria Bush, James [4:53:00] Case, Nate Ferryman and [4:53:03] allegedly Otto to please come [4:53:03] to the front row please Again, [4:53:06] Terry. [4:53:06] Thank you. [4:53:07] I'm Terry Best, a voter in [4:53:08] District three. [4:53:10] This appears to be an [4:53:11] unnecessary law aimed at [4:53:13] the Social at the county social [4:53:15] equity program. [4:53:17] My suggestion would be to [4:53:18] please remove the private right [4:53:20] of action portion from [4:53:22] the proposal. [4:53:23] It is just wrong and shame on [4:53:26] you. [4:53:27] >> Shame on you too. [4:53:31] Please also modify the proposal [4:53:33] to only cover out of county [4:53:35] delivery services. [4:53:37] Please exclude all three within [4:53:39] San Diego County and San Diego [4:53:42] County itself from this law. [4:53:44] Each of our cities has a robust [4:53:46] cannabis permitting process. [4:53:48] It is not necessary to be [4:53:50] hostile to other cities [4:53:52] delivery operations. [4:53:54] Please do this so that at [4:53:56] the very least the one licensed [4:53:58] type where we struggling [4:54:01] entrepreneur could hope to get [4:54:02] into the industry is not [4:54:03] blocked by special interests. [4:54:10] Thank you that those who do not [4:54:11] want the competition [4:54:12] the current city operators [4:54:13] behind this proposal have [4:54:14] enjoyed additional [4:54:15] consideration. [4:54:15] Thank you. [4:54:17] No other industry enjoys. [4:54:19] Now the city is considering [4:54:20] whether that does conclude your [4:54:21] time on the board. [4:54:22] What would you do if you took [4:54:25] special interest along with a [4:54:26] rabbit for a profit and any [4:54:28] other. [4:54:34] >> Thank you. [4:54:35] Next speaker is Don Ellen [4:54:36] Nelson. [4:54:40] Hello, everybody. [4:54:41] Good evening. [4:54:42] My name is Donald Nelson. [4:54:43] I am a proud resident of San [4:54:45] Diego and live out to just [4:54:46] outside of City Heights. [4:54:47] I am actually here in support [4:54:50] of this measure. [4:54:51] Having worked on the license [4:54:52] cannabis delivery in San Diego. [4:54:54] I have firsthand seen [4:54:55] the impact of an illegal market [4:54:58] Continuing to have legitimate [4:54:58] business licenses are [4:54:59] legitimate businesses, [4:55:02] employees and consumers while [4:55:04] license operators invest [4:55:05] significant resources into [4:55:07] complying with state and local [4:55:08] regulations regulations. [4:55:10] Many unlicensed operators [4:55:11] continue to conduct business [4:55:13] without oversight [4:55:14] accountability and [4:55:16] consequences. [4:55:17] Licensed cannabis Licensed [4:55:18] cannabis is required to test [4:55:21] the products, verify customer [4:55:23] rage, maintain strict inventory [4:55:24] controls and pay taxes to [4:55:26] support our local community. [4:55:28] Illegal operators do not do [4:55:29] none of those things. [4:55:31] They undermine public safety, [4:55:32] avoid paying taxes and create [4:55:34] unfair competition for [4:55:35] businesses that are trying to [4:55:36] do things right. [4:55:38] I myself has been a part of [4:55:39] the cannabis industry for five [4:55:40] years and over the time I've [4:55:42] watched them do that does [4:55:43] conclude your time. [4:55:44] >> Thank you. [4:55:44] Thank you. [4:55:46] Next speaker is Victoria Bush. [4:55:48] Victoria. [4:55:48] Here. [4:55:51] Okay. [4:55:52] James Case Thank you Counsel My [4:55:56] time. [4:55:57] Thank you, Council members. [4:55:58] My name is James Case. [4:55:59] I'm a resident of District two [4:56:01] and I've lived and worked in [4:56:03] San Diego, the city of San [4:56:04] Diego for over 30 years since [4:56:06] SEPTEMBER of 2021. [4:56:08] I've been a proud member of [4:56:09] the United Food and Commercial [4:56:10] Workers Union as a delivery [4:56:12] driver for legal registered [4:56:14] cannabis dispensaries San [4:56:15] Diego. [4:56:16] I'm not evil. [4:56:17] I'm a 63 year old grandpa. [4:56:19] I do my job. [4:56:20] I love my job And that's four [4:56:23] and a half years I've been [4:56:24] doing this. [4:56:24] I've delivered I've driven over [4:56:27] 100,000 miles on the streets of [4:56:28] San Diego delivering cannabis. [4:56:30] And one thing I've learned to [4:56:32] be here today is it's about [4:56:33] the money The city needs [4:56:34] the money. [4:56:36] Unlicensed operators have no [4:56:38] incentive to pay business [4:56:39] taxes. [4:56:40] Those business taxes not only [4:56:41] fund the works of the city, [4:56:44] those operators also provide [4:56:46] good jobs like my union job [4:56:48] where the people who have those [4:56:50] jobs spend that money in [4:56:52] the county in the city. [4:56:54] So those dollars not only thank [4:56:59] that does the county help [4:57:00] the community? [4:57:01] Next speaker is Nate Furman. [4:57:03] Don't see Nate here. [4:57:06] I will go to allegedly order [4:57:08] next please smile. [4:57:09] Just coming to the microphone [4:57:11] Todd Walters grant Tom, Robert [4:57:14] Wood, Larry Beekman and Eduardo [4:57:17] Battista Please come to talk [4:57:20] about a war on drugs. [4:57:21] Did you guys ever think you'd [4:57:22] be micromanaging drug turf [4:57:24] competition and stuff like [4:57:26] that? [4:57:26] How cool is that? [4:57:27] Right? [4:57:27] It used to be illegal. [4:57:29] Now it's not. [4:57:30] I mean one day it could be [4:57:31] again. [4:57:31] Who knows? [4:57:32] It's like on the edge of your [4:57:34] seat which is so interesting [4:57:36] because people think it's still [4:57:37] profitable. [4:57:37] The government has taken like [4:57:39] $60 billion industry and it's [4:57:43] like governance. [4:57:45] >> We heard your daddy I mean [4:57:46] talk about being able to make [4:57:47] all the money and not have to [4:57:48] pay taxes. [4:57:49] Then you come here like listen, [4:57:50] we need you to regulate it and [4:57:52] I do not want these people [4:57:53] coming into my territory. [4:57:54] So you guys are going to need [4:57:55] to regulate that know But this [4:58:02] is what is so interesting New [4:58:04] permits you know what I mean? [4:58:06] It's like I'm sorry. [4:58:07] I just I don't understand why [4:58:09] people think it's cool for you [4:58:10] to come to the government and [4:58:12] be like what's going to take [4:58:14] billions of dollars out of my [4:58:17] pocket like I did? [4:58:19] >> But good for you guys, [4:58:20] right? [4:58:21] And it's supposed to go to city [4:58:22] services. [4:58:23] >> Looks like it's working. [4:58:26] Thank you. [4:58:26] That does conclude your time. [4:58:28] Our next speaker is Todd [4:58:29] Walters. [4:58:33] Good evening City council and [4:58:34] city staff and thank you very [4:58:35] much for your time. [4:58:36] It's very valuable and I [4:58:37] respect it. [4:58:39] Most people aren't aware of it. [4:58:42] The cannabis legal cannabis [4:58:42] industry is in trouble. [4:58:44] It's not doing well. [4:58:46] The unpermitted cannabis [4:58:47] delivery services are taking [4:58:48] business away from those [4:58:49] licensed retailers who are [4:58:51] paying taxes. [4:58:52] The illicit cannabis market can [4:58:53] treat contributes to a shadow [4:58:55] economy where wage theft, [4:58:57] unsafe working conditions and [4:58:59] labor exploitation are more [4:59:00] likely to occur. [4:59:01] Workers in legal cannabis [4:59:03] industry should not have to [4:59:04] compete against businesses that [4:59:05] ignore regulations and avoid [4:59:06] paying their fair share. [4:59:09] Stronger licensing requirements [4:59:10] help ensure that cannabis [4:59:11] businesses operating in San [4:59:13] Diego follow the same rules. [4:59:15] Ensuring operators contribute [4:59:16] to the cannabis business tax [4:59:18] helps generate revenue for our [4:59:20] city essential services which [4:59:21] we know we need. [4:59:23] Supporting this ordinance means [4:59:25] protecting workers responsible [4:59:27] business and the integrity of [4:59:29] Senegal's regulated cannabis [4:59:30] industry. [4:59:31] In conclusion I just ask you to [4:59:33] support this ordinance and [4:59:34] support the workers. [4:59:36] Thank you. [4:59:36] Thank you. [4:59:37] Our next speaker is Grant Tom. [4:59:44] >> Good evening. [4:59:45] I'm Grant Tom Secretary [4:59:48] Treasurer Jacobi Look at 135 I [4:59:48] represent about 12,000 members [4:59:50] throughout the county [4:59:52] everywhere including retail, [4:59:53] cannabis, medical, kiser [4:59:56] everything I know the out of [4:59:57] town companies and listed [5:00:00] operators of unpermitted [5:00:00] cannabis businesses that are [5:00:02] currently operating or harming [5:00:03] or illegal local cannabis [5:00:05] industry and operators and [5:00:07] they're undercutting taxpayers [5:00:08] but not paying their fair share [5:00:10] of the cannabis retail tax just [5:00:13] hurts the workers who are [5:00:15] causing reduce hours and we've [5:00:16] had tons of layoffs. [5:00:17] It's really sad. [5:00:19] It's important to maintain [5:00:20] the integrity of your San [5:00:22] Diego's regulated your cannabis [5:00:24] industry. [5:00:25] It's also important to protect [5:00:27] the workers and the taxpayer. [5:00:31] This ordinance creates enhanced [5:00:32] enforcement to protect those [5:00:34] workers and their families [5:00:37] including other local high road [5:00:38] cannabis businesses. [5:00:39] Please support this ordinance. [5:00:41] Thank you guys very much. [5:00:43] Thank you. [5:00:44] Robert Wood. [5:00:47] While Robert walks to [5:00:49] the microphone, I will ask for [5:00:51] the folks as needed in time to [5:00:53] please raise my hand when [5:00:54] called Eduardo Camacho Eduardo [5:01:02] Livio Marquez No. [5:01:06] Okay. [5:01:08] Ada Castaneda okay, So Ada is [5:01:11] here so you'll have to answer. [5:01:19] >> Okay? [5:01:20] >> Doug Okay. [5:01:21] Thank you. [5:01:21] First of all, my name is Robert [5:01:23] Wood. [5:01:23] I am a citizen of San Diego [5:01:26] County. [5:01:27] I was born and raised in [5:01:28] the city of San Diego. [5:01:30] I did prison time for selling [5:01:32] marijuana. [5:01:33] Now I go throughout [5:01:35] the community, try to improve [5:01:37] it in various ways and I'm a [5:01:40] social equity cannabis [5:01:40] advocate. [5:01:44] Would that be I'm one of [5:01:44] the people he helped build [5:01:45] the cannabis industry in [5:01:47] the county of San Diego at one [5:01:49] point and one of the people who [5:01:51] went to prison behind it And [5:01:53] now I'm out. [5:01:54] I'm ready to do things legally. [5:01:55] I told five different greens [5:01:55] one the nba. [5:01:58] I understand barriers to entry, [5:02:00] barriers to entry be it dealt [5:02:03] with Businesses want to keep [5:02:04] people out of something they [5:02:06] come up with ridiculous like [5:02:07] this ridiculousness like this. [5:02:09] They come up with things where [5:02:11] they say Oh you're probably [5:02:13] right too soon so you can just [5:02:15] personally sue me into oblivion [5:02:16] yourself. [5:02:17] You don't need anybody else to [5:02:19] do it for you. [5:02:20] This is this is this is [5:02:21] incredible to me. [5:02:23] The people in the San Diego [5:02:25] Social Equity Cannabis program [5:02:27] are people from San Diego. [5:02:29] We all arrested in San Diego [5:02:32] for cannabis at some point [5:02:35] Social equity cannabis. [5:02:38] It's just that is social [5:02:38] equity. [5:02:39] Do you think that any of these [5:02:41] businesses that got together it [5:02:44] concocted this that one time [5:02:45] about such work I can't see one [5:02:48] facing one of these owners in [5:02:49] here that came down to [5:02:50] the social equity program and [5:02:52] took the time to talk to us and [5:02:54] try in equities you would think [5:02:56] that they would be embracing [5:02:57] this, trying to work at it and [5:03:00] saying you got to try to get [5:03:00] into this Cool. [5:03:02] Let us see what we can do to [5:03:04] help you guys If they take [5:03:06] tooth and nail the whole time, [5:03:09] it's time that the game stop is [5:03:12] time that this gets torn up, [5:03:14] that the barriers to entry stop [5:03:16] and social equity is treated [5:03:17] like we're just supposed to be [5:03:20] sociable and equitable. [5:03:21] >> Thank you. [5:03:36] >> Thank you. [5:03:37] Blair Beekman. [5:03:37] All right. [5:03:37] Thank you. [5:03:37] Where we going? [5:03:38] I have not known much about [5:03:39] this item. [5:03:41] It was a learning process for [5:03:42] myself. [5:03:43] I really like hearing public [5:03:44] comment on it about the social [5:03:48] equity lack that seems to be a [5:03:50] part of this. [5:03:51] We try to make up rules and [5:03:53] laws sometimes that we feel is [5:03:55] just gosh darn good, you know [5:03:58] and we're doing a good thing. [5:03:59] It has a logic to it is a good [5:04:03] logic but that logic doesn't [5:04:05] take into account what maybe is [5:04:08] going on underneath. [5:04:10] This is a group that seems to [5:04:11] have some sort of real thing [5:04:13] going on in wanting to nail [5:04:15] social equity with marijuana [5:04:20] purchases and how that process [5:04:23] can work. [5:04:24] I mean Oakland has always [5:04:25] created really good examples of [5:04:27] social equity. [5:04:28] Perhaps you can talk to them at [5:04:30] this time at this needs a bit [5:04:33] of more review and work it [5:04:35] sounds like Thank you. [5:04:36] >> Thank you Eduardo Batista [5:04:40] followed by Anthony Ralphs and [5:04:45] more so Daniel. [5:04:46] Good evening Council members My [5:04:48] name is Eduardo Batista and I [5:04:49] respectfully oppose this [5:04:51] cannabis delivery proposal. [5:04:52] I support legal cannabis [5:04:53] businesses paying taxes [5:04:55] following the rules and [5:04:56] operating responsibly. [5:04:58] But this proposal goes beyond [5:04:59] fair regulation. [5:05:00] It creates new barriers for [5:05:02] licensed delivery operators and [5:05:03] gives existing cannabis [5:05:04] retailers the ability to use [5:05:06] private lawsuits against [5:05:08] competitors. [5:05:09] So weaponizing it This is [5:05:11] dangerous for small businesses, [5:05:12] county operators and future [5:05:14] social equity businesses that [5:05:15] MAY not have the resources to [5:05:17] fight expensive litigation. [5:05:19] Even a threat of lawsuit can [5:05:21] discourage competition and [5:05:22] limit access. [5:05:23] You can also look California [5:05:25] Motor Transport Company where [5:05:28] trucking Unlimited and I think [5:05:29] that covers kind of that If [5:05:31] the concern is tax compliance, [5:05:33] create a simple registration [5:05:34] and tax process. [5:05:36] If concern is illegal operators [5:05:37] focus enforcement on unlicensed [5:05:39] activity but do not create a [5:05:41] system that allows established [5:05:42] businesses to weaponize [5:05:43] enforcement against licensed [5:05:46] competitors. [5:05:46] I urge the Council to reject [5:05:48] this proposal. [5:05:49] >> Thank you. [5:05:50] That does conclude your time. [5:05:51] Anthony Ralphs Yes I had [5:05:56] submitted want to speak in [5:05:58] favor but after hearing [5:05:59] the deliberation I think I'm [5:06:00] going to change to speak in [5:06:02] opposition. [5:06:08] >> The reason why I am changing [5:06:10] my position from going in favor [5:06:12] to in opposition is because I [5:06:14] do think that regulation has [5:06:18] good intentions. [5:06:18] I do want to see delivery [5:06:20] drivers have the ability to [5:06:22] have some type of guidelines by [5:06:23] the city as to what they can do [5:06:25] and what they can't do. [5:06:26] However, I was really concerned [5:06:27] about the amount of [5:06:29] the penalties that would be [5:06:30] imposed The $20,000 a day just [5:06:33] like none of us are made out of [5:06:34] gold and we all make mistakes [5:06:35] and $20,000 to be out of [5:06:39] compliance or to have made a [5:06:42] mistake with the regulations [5:06:43] just seems really excessive to [5:06:47] me. [5:06:48] And also I think that if there [5:06:50] is a confliction a conflict [5:06:53] between the socially equitable [5:06:54] cannabis program and this one I [5:06:56] think I would rather go with [5:06:57] the socially equitable [5:06:58] community program. [5:06:58] Thank you. [5:06:58] Thank you. [5:07:03] Lori Saldana you actually cut [5:07:05] off some of his time but let me [5:07:06] just start out by saying what [5:07:08] Terry Bell said. [5:07:10] MR. Campos shame on you and [5:07:12] your committee members. [5:07:13] You were putting a loaded gun [5:07:14] in the hands of people to go [5:07:16] after folks who have been [5:07:17] historically disadvantaged in [5:07:19] this industry. [5:07:19] When I served the legislature I [5:07:21] wrote bills to do the exact [5:07:23] opposite to try and prevent [5:07:25] this kind of cherry picking and [5:07:27] I'm going to stick around for a [5:07:28] non agenda comment so I can [5:07:30] speak a little bit more about [5:07:31] what if other industries took [5:07:32] this approach What if other [5:07:35] indices were given a gun and [5:07:36] said you can do private action [5:07:37] and go after these opponents? [5:07:40] Are these competitors It would [5:07:42] be mayhem. [5:07:43] Shame on you. [5:07:45] Shame on you MR. Foster. [5:07:46] You know how this community has [5:07:48] been hurt so I just don't [5:07:51] understand why you're picking [5:07:51] winners and losers. [5:07:52] I wait. [5:07:53] I do. [5:07:53] Who has money? [5:07:54] Who gives money to [5:07:55] the Democratic Party? [5:07:56] Who gives money to the party [5:07:58] and then passes it on to [5:07:59] candidates? [5:08:00] >> The people that you are [5:08:02] favoring on this Shame on you. [5:08:05] >> Thank you. [5:08:06] That does conclude your time. [5:08:08] That concludes in-person public [5:08:10] comment. [5:08:11] We have started the five minute [5:08:13] timer and council chambers will [5:08:15] now turn to the virtual queue [5:08:17] in which there are ten [5:08:20] participants requesting to [5:08:21] speak. [5:08:21] We'll begin with Terry and [5:08:23] Skelly. [5:08:24] Please begin. [5:08:28] >> Good afternoon San Diego [5:08:29] City Council Chair LaCava My [5:08:31] name is Terrance Fili and I [5:08:33] work with my planning group on [5:08:35] good public health and safety [5:08:36] policies and land use [5:08:38] decisions. [5:08:39] I support this policy. [5:08:40] I appreciate the city's effort [5:08:42] to know who is selling pot in [5:08:43] our city and where the pot is [5:08:46] coming from since it doesn't [5:08:47] seem to have a physical [5:08:48] location within the city, this [5:08:50] is a very good thing We should [5:08:52] be aware of actual actually [5:08:54] being successful collecting [5:08:56] cannabis business tax and [5:08:58] perhaps also remember that [5:09:00] the comment by a physician [5:09:01] trained in emergency medicine [5:09:03] pediatrics and family practice [5:09:05] and I quote It's ridiculous to [5:09:07] think that any city or county [5:09:08] will make it will make excess [5:09:11] funds in tax revenue from [5:09:13] the selling of addictive [5:09:14] products. [5:09:15] The money being brought in does [5:09:17] not cover the costs of [5:09:18] addiction of addiction [5:09:20] treatment let alone any any [5:09:21] other harm psychosis, cannabis [5:09:25] hyperemesis pediatric exposures [5:09:27] and injuries while intoxicated. [5:09:29] Thank you for hearing my [5:09:31] concern. [5:09:32] Thank you. [5:09:33] Our next speakers and Albania's [5:09:35] please begin. [5:09:48] >> Andrew Ibanez I cannot [5:09:54] unmute for you must press on [5:09:54] Hear me? [5:09:57] Yup Go ahead please. [5:09:59] >> Thank you. [5:09:59] Good evening. [5:10:00] Presenter and council members. [5:10:02] My name is Andrew Ibanez. [5:10:03] I lived in District four for 39 [5:10:04] years and I'm a cannabis social [5:10:06] equity applicant. [5:10:07] I oppose the proposal. [5:10:08] I support maintaining expanded [5:10:10] access to cannabis delivery [5:10:12] services in the city of San [5:10:13] Diego. [5:10:14] Cannabis delivery provides a [5:10:16] safe, convenient and legal [5:10:17] option for adults, seniors, [5:10:18] people with disabilities, [5:10:20] veterans and patients and [5:10:22] residents who have difficulty [5:10:23] traveling to a dispensary or a [5:10:25] storefront. [5:10:26] Delivery services allows [5:10:28] consumers to receive product at [5:10:29] home rather than driving to a [5:10:31] retail location. [5:10:33] Licensed delivery operators are [5:10:34] regulated subject to testing [5:10:36] and tracking requirements and [5:10:37] contribute tax revenue to [5:10:39] the city. [5:10:39] Policy should encourage [5:10:41] consumers to the to use [5:10:42] the regulated market rather [5:10:44] than care or create barriers [5:10:46] that MAY unintentionally push [5:10:47] customers toward unlicensed [5:10:49] operators. [5:10:50] As the city considers new [5:10:51] regulations, I encourage you to [5:10:53] support a framework that [5:10:54] protects public safety while [5:10:56] preserving reasonable access to [5:10:58] legal cannabis delivery [5:10:59] services. [5:11:01] Regulation should be fair, [5:11:01] practical and designed to [5:11:02] promote compliance. [5:11:03] Thank you. [5:11:04] >> That does conclude your [5:11:05] time. [5:11:07] Madison please begin. [5:11:13] Hi. [5:11:14] Good evening. [5:11:15] Thank you for the chance to [5:11:15] speak. [5:11:16] I support this ordinance [5:11:18] because strong enforcement of [5:11:20] cannabis regulations is [5:11:21] essential to protecting young [5:11:22] people in our city. [5:11:24] We are not talking about [5:11:25] delivery of ice cream here. [5:11:27] When delivery of a drug like [5:11:29] cannabis is allowed it means [5:11:30] products are spreading [5:11:31] throughout our community that [5:11:33] contain extremely high levels [5:11:34] of thc and have been linked to [5:11:37] increased risks of psychosis [5:11:38] cannabis use disorder, cyclic [5:11:40] vomiting syndrome, impaired [5:11:42] driving and other serious [5:11:44] health concerns particularly [5:11:45] for adolescents. [5:11:47] That is why enforcement matters [5:11:48] . [5:11:50] Creating a local permit [5:11:51] requirement for cannabis [5:11:52] delivery businesses gives [5:11:54] the city a tool to identify [5:11:56] operators, monitor compliance [5:11:58] and take action When violation [5:12:00] occurs. [5:12:01] Strong penalties are also [5:12:02] important because regulations [5:12:04] without meaningful enforcement [5:12:05] are simply suggestions. [5:12:07] Every gap in enforcement [5:12:09] creates opportunities for [5:12:10] unlawful activity and increases [5:12:13] the risk that harmful cannabis [5:12:14] products will reach our youth. [5:12:16] >> Thank you. [5:12:17] Thank you. [5:12:19] Next is Becky Wrap. [5:12:20] Please begin. [5:12:35] My name is back. [5:12:40] You up and I'm very concerned. [5:12:40] The city is considering [5:12:41] expanding delivery regulations [5:12:44] before providing or proving [5:12:47] that existing regulations have [5:12:49] been effectively enforced. [5:12:50] For years residents have been [5:12:52] requesting a comprehensive [5:12:54] audit of San Diego's marijuana [5:12:56] program including the number of [5:12:57] businesses operating, [5:12:58] the amount of tax revenue being [5:12:59] collected and whether [5:13:01] businesses are complying with [5:13:02] local regulations. [5:13:04] This report repeatedly [5:13:05] references noncompliance but [5:13:07] does not include important [5:13:08] enforcement data to support [5:13:10] the need that this new permit [5:13:12] program is needed. [5:13:13] How many violations have been [5:13:15] identified? [5:13:15] How much unpaid tax has been [5:13:17] recovered? [5:13:18] And the delivery operators have [5:13:19] been investigating. [5:13:21] A report doesn't tell us that [5:13:23] before creating new permits and [5:13:25] expanding the city's marijuana [5:13:26] framework. [5:13:28] The city should first provide a [5:13:29] full accounting of the current [5:13:31] system. [5:13:32] If we don't know whether [5:13:33] existing businesses are [5:13:34] complying with the rules or [5:13:35] paying the taxes they owe. [5:13:37] >> How can we justify [5:13:38] expanding? [5:13:39] Thank you. [5:13:40] That is include your time. [5:13:41] >> Please note that the five [5:13:46] minute timer has concluded with [5:13:48] six speakers left in the queue. [5:13:50] No other speakers will be taken [5:13:51] . [5:13:54] Next up is Peggy Walker. [5:13:56] Please begin. [5:14:00] Oh, good evening, COUNCILMAN [5:14:01] Campo. [5:14:03] I represent parents and thank [5:14:04] you and support this. [5:14:06] Strict controls are needed [5:14:07] because bad players on both [5:14:09] the seller and consumer sides [5:14:11] ignore illegal delivery [5:14:13] requirements. [5:14:14] Delivery services Too often [5:14:16] cheat the city of taxes put [5:14:18] youth in jeopardy of harmful [5:14:20] underage use, fail to make I.D. [5:14:22] Checks and deliver quantities [5:14:24] not allowed by state [5:14:25] regulations. [5:14:26] A Bay Area delivery company was [5:14:29] recently exposed for leaking [5:14:31] their delivery databases [5:14:33] containing customer names, home [5:14:36] addresses, even medical data. [5:14:39] Consumers should be made aware [5:14:40] of these risks. [5:14:42] An official list posted online [5:14:44] of all future San Diego license [5:14:46] delivery services would be [5:14:48] helpful so that consumers can [5:14:50] know that their deliveries are [5:14:52] from permitted vendors. [5:14:54] Thank you. [5:14:58] >> Thank you. [5:15:04] Next up is Peggy Walker. [5:15:05] Please begin. [5:15:09] >> Hi. [5:15:10] That was me. [5:15:10] I just spoke. [5:15:11] Sorry. [5:15:12] I apologize. [5:15:16] Next up is Kathleen Leavitt. [5:15:18] Please begin. [5:15:22] >> Thank you. [5:15:22] Thank you. [5:15:23] To counsel Patrick Campo for [5:15:25] his good intentions a proactive [5:15:28] step that should be taken [5:15:29] before proposing any additional [5:15:32] programs like this would be to [5:15:34] do an analysis of [5:15:36] the businesses already [5:15:36] permitted. [5:15:37] Are they compliant? [5:15:39] Are they paying their taxes? [5:15:41] Many businesses already see [5:15:43] city codes and suggestions [5:15:44] rather than requirements. [5:15:47] They do not see meaningful [5:15:48] consequences to businesses [5:15:50] found to be out of compliance. [5:15:52] It is no surprise many [5:15:54] marijuana businesses have gone [5:15:56] out of business because [5:15:57] unpermitted marijuana [5:15:58] businesses always have and [5:16:01] always will take business from [5:16:03] permitted business. [5:16:04] This permanent undermines [5:16:06] the city's regulatory framework [5:16:08] and disadvantages compliant [5:16:10] businesses. [5:16:12] That being said, there is [5:16:13] nothing good about compliant or [5:16:16] permitted businesses any more [5:16:17] than unpermitted businesses. [5:16:19] The rent seeking revenues over [5:16:22] public safety is never going to [5:16:24] end well for the city. [5:16:26] >> That does conclude your [5:16:27] time. [5:16:27] Thank you. [5:16:28] Next up J.D. String Please [5:16:30] begin. [5:16:30] >> Good afternoon, San Diego [5:16:34] City Council. [5:16:36] Thank you to City Council [5:16:39] person Carpio for considering [5:16:39] this at his NOVEMBER adr [5:16:43] meeting. [5:16:44] I'm sorry Some of us maybe who [5:16:46] spoke didn't have an [5:16:47] opportunity to hear [5:16:48] the discussion then I think we [5:16:50] would have a better [5:16:51] understanding of what the goal [5:16:52] was behind this policy. [5:16:57] Some intent to level [5:16:58] the playing field for those who [5:17:01] actually have permits in [5:17:02] the city of San Diego to [5:17:03] deliver and those who do not [5:17:05] and are coming in and we don't [5:17:06] know who they are, where [5:17:08] they're from, what [5:17:09] the condition of the products [5:17:10] are And it looks like and [5:17:12] the example on the PowerPoint, [5:17:14] the one given it's not even [5:17:15] registered by the city, by [5:17:17] the state, by dcc. [5:17:20] So we need to really understand [5:17:22] who it is just driving around [5:17:24] our neighborhoods, dropping off [5:17:25] pot. [5:17:26] I must say, however, in doing a [5:17:28] search I found the city of [5:17:30] Oceanside tried to do the same [5:17:31] thing and get a registry of [5:17:34] deliveries and then when signed [5:17:35] out. [5:17:37] >> Thank you. [5:17:37] That does conclude your time. [5:17:39] Next is Cannabis Education [5:17:41] Project. [5:17:42] Please begin Cannabis Education [5:17:57] Project. [5:17:58] Please begin. [5:17:58] I see you're unmuted. [5:18:00] One more time Cannabis [5:18:12] Education Project. [5:18:17] Okay, we'll have to move on. [5:18:22] Next up Shelby Huffaker. [5:18:24] Please begin that evening. [5:18:29] My name is Shelby and I'm a [5:18:30] board member of the San Diego [5:18:31] chapter of Americans for Safe [5:18:33] Access, a national nonprofit [5:18:35] advancing Safe Access to [5:18:36] cannabis for therapeutic use [5:18:38] and research. [5:18:39] I urge you to reject this [5:18:40] proposed cannabis delivery [5:18:41] permit and enforcement [5:18:43] enforcement ordinance. [5:18:44] It is redundant with state law [5:18:46] and appearance designed to let [5:18:47] San Diego's existing cannabis [5:18:48] monopoly block competition from [5:18:51] the county social equity [5:18:52] program which is just weeks [5:18:53] away from an anticipated vote [5:18:55] on the code's needed to [5:18:56] implement it. [5:18:57] If you move forward please make [5:18:59] two changes. [5:19:01] First, eliminate the private [5:19:02] right of action which would let [5:19:03] anyone including monopoly [5:19:05] members and opponent opponents [5:19:06] of cannabis legalization sue [5:19:09] compliant operators and clog [5:19:11] our courts. [5:19:12] Second, please exempt operators [5:19:13] already licensed by the county [5:19:15] from this duplicative permitted [5:19:16] system. [5:19:18] Please reject this ordinance or [5:19:19] adopt these fixes. [5:19:20] >> Thank you. [5:19:21] Thank you. [5:19:23] >> Kelly Hayes. [5:19:24] Please begin. [5:19:24] >> Hi. [5:19:28] Good evening, Council members. [5:19:30] My name is Kelly Hayes. [5:19:31] i'm a resident of District two [5:19:33] and an attorney who specializes [5:19:35] in working with the cannabis [5:19:36] businesses. [5:19:37] I've been working with this [5:19:39] industry since 2014. [5:19:40] And I've seen a lot of issues [5:19:43] with this ordinance and I [5:19:45] strongly oppose it. [5:19:46] First requiring delivery [5:19:48] businesses to obtain a separate [5:19:50] San Diego permit is unworkable [5:19:53] in the city. [5:19:54] The city is going to have no [5:19:55] way to police and enforce this [5:19:57] requirement. [5:19:58] State regulations require [5:19:59] delivery vehicles to be in [5:20:01] unmarked and indistinguishable [5:20:03] from any other type of vehicle [5:20:04] . [5:20:06] The effect that this is going [5:20:07] to have on staff is going to be [5:20:09] burdensome and it's going to [5:20:10] accomplish absolutely nothing [5:20:11] nothing that you're trying to [5:20:13] achieve. [5:20:14] Additionally, the private right [5:20:15] to action is duplicative. [5:20:17] There's already state law that [5:20:18] allows for this type of private [5:20:21] action And what you're [5:20:23] proposing is going to create [5:20:25] meritless cases and clog our [5:20:28] court system. [5:20:29] >> So I strongly ask you to [5:20:31] oppose this. [5:20:32] Thank you. [5:20:32] That does conclude your time. [5:20:34] And that concludes the public [5:20:36] testimony on item 2o2. [5:20:38] All right. [5:20:39] Thank you, Deputy Clerk. [5:20:40] Thank you. [5:20:41] Everybody that spoke or called [5:20:42] in will now turn it over to [5:20:44] council members for questions, [5:20:46] comments and entertain a motion [5:20:47] and we'll start with [5:20:48] the proponent. [5:20:49] Council Member Campo Thank you [5:20:51] Council PRESIDENT And thank you [5:20:52] to my staff for the good work [5:20:53] on this. [5:20:53] Thank you to all the members of [5:20:54] the public for their [5:20:55] participation today. [5:20:56] I want to specifically thank [5:20:57] the cw workers who came to [5:20:59] speak directly. [5:21:00] Members of the Public Labor [5:21:01] Council and members of sounds [5:21:04] like almost every district for [5:21:06] explaining why today's action [5:21:07] is so important. [5:21:08] It's abundantly clear that [5:21:10] illicit cannabis delivery is a [5:21:12] problem in the city. [5:21:13] It's a problem that we haven't [5:21:15] had a solution to address [5:21:17] because it's difficult to [5:21:18] address. [5:21:19] It's layered with state and [5:21:21] local laws and enforcement [5:21:23] Actions span from the state to [5:21:24] city attorneys, local law [5:21:26] enforcement, the city [5:21:28] administrators and city [5:21:28] administrators involved. [5:21:30] Land use enforcement in some [5:21:31] cases. [5:21:32] So from a regulatory [5:21:33] perspective it is very [5:21:34] difficult to get this right. [5:21:36] But we're here. [5:21:39] The city regulates cannabis [5:21:40] delivery from businesses inside [5:21:41] city limits. [5:21:42] And if they don't follow [5:21:43] the rules, they don't get to [5:21:44] operate in the city. [5:21:46] They have a physical building [5:21:47] and a permit to operate it. [5:21:49] But what about the businesses [5:21:50] that come in, drive in, deliver [5:21:53] legally by state or local laws [5:21:55] and then leave? [5:21:56] To test if this is actually [5:21:58] happening you could right now [5:21:59] order cannabis to be delivered [5:22:01] to city hall particularly out [5:22:04] of city company is advertising [5:22:07] on Weed Maps an online platform [5:22:09] for marketing cannabis products [5:22:10] and has their location listed [5:22:12] as the Gaslamp District right [5:22:15] here in downtown Shouldn't [5:22:17] surprise anybody. [5:22:19] We don't have any licensed [5:22:20] cannabis outlets in [5:22:21] the Gaslamp. [5:22:23] This business is listed on [5:22:24] the state's Department of [5:22:25] Cannabis Control website as a [5:22:27] state licensed delivery [5:22:28] business but their licensed [5:22:30] operations is in Kern County. [5:22:34] That means in order to abide by [5:22:35] state law they would have to [5:22:36] wait until an order is made [5:22:38] before they dispatch to deliver [5:22:40] with a driver that delivery [5:22:42] driver has to be a direct [5:22:44] employee of that company. [5:22:46] They have to provide specific [5:22:47] details on every receipt with [5:22:49] information about that company [5:22:51] and they have to pay all [5:22:52] applicable taxes. [5:22:54] And they're definitely not [5:22:55] allowed to deliver to [5:22:56] government property. [5:22:57] You can place an order and have [5:22:59] a delivery within two hours [5:23:00] from this company. [5:23:01] No local taxes are applied on [5:23:03] their receipt. [5:23:05] No state license number is [5:23:06] listed on that receipt. [5:23:08] That means that someone is [5:23:10] either driving very fast from [5:23:11] Kern County, the nearest city [5:23:13] of which is 191 miles away or [5:23:16] they're storing cannabis [5:23:17] products illegally within our [5:23:19] city limits and that business [5:23:21] is clearly not abiding by [5:23:22] worker and consumer safety [5:23:24] protections. [5:23:24] So I understand we have a [5:23:26] current process for cannabis [5:23:27] delivery services entering city [5:23:29] limits. [5:23:30] They are required to register [5:23:31] for a business tax certificate [5:23:32] and pay applicable taxes but [5:23:34] they're not required to provide [5:23:35] any proof of their state [5:23:36] license. [5:23:36] So if we know that a business [5:23:38] is violating their state [5:23:39] license requirements, we can't [5:23:41] really do anything about it [5:23:42] yet. [5:23:43] And in this scenario let's say [5:23:45] we suspect that a facility is [5:23:46] within city limits is being [5:23:47] used to store cannabis products [5:23:49] for delivery. [5:23:50] It's not allowed under current [5:23:51] code. [5:23:52] We can provide notice and send [5:23:53] in code enforcement cpd to [5:23:55] investigate. [5:23:55] Apply penalties If they have [5:23:57] information on that business we [5:23:58] could file a complaint with [5:24:00] Department of Cannabis Control [5:24:01] to apply penalties or revoke a [5:24:03] permit if the business has one. [5:24:05] But we know that revoking a [5:24:06] permit or having an expired [5:24:07] permit does not stop that [5:24:09] business entity from continuing [5:24:10] to advertise and deliver [5:24:11] cannabis in the city of San [5:24:13] Diego. [5:24:14] So it's safe to say our current [5:24:15] resources are at capacity at [5:24:17] addressing this kind of illegal [5:24:18] commercial activity. [5:24:20] And when we've exhausted our [5:24:21] administrative options, [5:24:22] the city attorney's office can [5:24:23] still file a civil action in [5:24:24] court against the business. [5:24:26] But it would be a matter of [5:24:27] prioritizing this this issue [5:24:29] over others because our staff [5:24:31] capacity is limited. [5:24:33] And from what I've heard from [5:24:34] the workers and businesses and [5:24:35] members of the public is that [5:24:36] this activity goes on and on [5:24:38] and on. [5:24:39] >> While the government [5:24:41] agencies tasked with regulation [5:24:42] they're unable to enforce [5:24:43] the law. [5:24:44] My experience as a litigator [5:24:46] and prosecutor the private [5:24:47] right of action is a very [5:24:48] commonly used enforcement [5:24:49] mechanism. [5:24:50] It's primarily used in other [5:24:52] areas of law labor law for [5:24:53] example. [5:24:54] But the concept is very simple. [5:24:56] When a party is harmed by [5:24:58] the violation of a law they can [5:25:00] ask the court to enforce it. [5:25:01] This is not a unique remedy. [5:25:03] It's not a unique tool. [5:25:05] It's not just any member of [5:25:07] the public, by the way, a party [5:25:09] that's harmed by the violation [5:25:10] and in this case a legal [5:25:11] business. [5:25:12] Unions representing those [5:25:13] workers and those businesses [5:25:14] right here in San Diego. [5:25:16] So a court can evaluate that [5:25:18] evidence, determine penalties [5:25:20] if they determine the law was [5:25:22] not followed. [5:25:24] So what does this accomplish [5:25:24] and what does success look like [5:25:26] if we implement this? [5:25:27] First we incentivize legal [5:25:29] commercial activity by raising [5:25:31] the cost of noncompliance. [5:25:34] Registering for a business [5:25:36] permit means filling out a form [5:25:38] or you run The risk of high [5:25:42] penalties is not a high bar [5:25:43] that we are setting here [5:25:45] penalties that can actually [5:25:46] outweigh the financial benefit [5:25:47] to skip On hiring employees and [5:25:49] obtaining and renewing required [5:25:50] permits. [5:25:51] That's what we're looking at. [5:25:52] With this we intend to be clear [5:25:54] that any cannabis business [5:25:55] operating within our [5:25:56] jurisdiction must make [5:25:58] themselves known. [5:26:00] They must follow the laws. [5:26:02] As I pointed out earlier, a [5:26:04] receipt from a cannabis company [5:26:05] and current registered in Kern [5:26:07] County and delivering in [5:26:08] Gaslamp advertising Gaslamp as [5:26:09] violating multiple laws. [5:26:12] And if the business continues [5:26:13] to ignore local and state laws [5:26:15] they can then be held [5:26:16] accountable. [5:26:17] But I think we ought not reward [5:26:21] multimillion dollar companies [5:26:22] that decide it's more [5:26:23] profitable to ignore the law [5:26:25] which means ignoring worker [5:26:26] protections. [5:26:28] I think we should protect [5:26:29] workers. [5:26:32] These companies are ignoring [5:26:33] community protections where [5:26:34] around where cannabis can be [5:26:35] sold. [5:26:36] I think we should maintain [5:26:37] the system that we've put up in [5:26:39] San Diego that allow outside [5:26:40] entities to bring it down. [5:26:45] >> The public who voted to [5:26:46] allow commercial cannabis under [5:26:47] the expectation that tax [5:26:49] revenue would return back to [5:26:50] them. [5:26:51] That's what they wanted. [5:26:53] Right now it's not working. [5:26:55] So this proposal helps us [5:26:56] collect that as well. [5:26:59] So with that I understand that [5:27:01] to make this mechanism [5:27:01] successful we also need to [5:27:03] properly implement a permit or [5:27:06] a business registration [5:27:07] whichever way you want to [5:27:08] describe it. [5:27:09] We need to bring a fee study in [5:27:11] order to determine the cost [5:27:13] recoverable amount for [5:27:14] administering the permit. [5:27:16] And if we're asking businesses [5:27:17] to submit a copy of their state [5:27:18] license or business certificate [5:27:20] and information on their owners [5:27:21] employees I would imagine that [5:27:23] would align with the amount for [5:27:24] the business tax certificate [5:27:25] which is around $34 right now [5:27:27] for small businesses or $125 [5:27:29] for larger businesses. [5:27:31] I see Good is here from [5:27:32] the mayor's office. [5:27:34] I need the mayor's commitment [5:27:37] via you that we will that you [5:27:37] will work to bring back bring [5:27:41] forward the appropriate fee [5:27:42] study to determine the exact [5:27:43] amount of what this business [5:27:45] permit will cost. [5:27:46] Yes, Councilmember, thank you [5:27:47] for that. [5:27:48] You do have our commitment to [5:27:49] bring that forward post second [5:27:51] reading at this House is today. [5:27:53] City Treasurer's office will [5:27:54] initiate the process to conduct [5:27:56] the fee study and then bring [5:27:57] that forward for council [5:27:58] consideration later this fall. [5:27:59] >> Okay, very good. [5:28:01] Also with along those same [5:28:03] lines working with staff to [5:28:05] ensure that neighboring [5:28:06] jurisdictions and [5:28:07] the Department of Cannabis [5:28:08] Control are properly notified [5:28:09] of those changes to our [5:28:11] cannabis regulations and [5:28:12] understand how to register [5:28:13] through the mechanism that will [5:28:15] be created by our departments. [5:28:17] Yes and I think that be an all [5:28:18] hands effort for parties that [5:28:19] touch this including dsd, cpd, [5:28:21] our government affairs team. [5:28:22] So you have our full support [5:28:23] there as well. [5:28:24] Okay. [5:28:25] With that council PRESIDENT, [5:28:26] I'm happy to move approval of [5:28:28] staff's recommendation on this. [5:28:29] Thank you. [5:28:29] All right. [5:28:30] So we have a motion by Council [5:28:31] member Campo to move the staff [5:28:32] recommendation and we'll go [5:28:33] next to council member Von [5:28:34] Wolpert. [5:28:34] >> Thank you. [5:28:36] And thank you very much to [5:28:38] staff for bringing this forward [5:28:39] today and thank you for [5:28:40] the hard work you've done it [5:28:42] and thank you to the public for [5:28:43] commenting and thank you to our [5:28:43] hard working folks that you [5:28:44] have. [5:28:47] C.W. Who have negotiated some [5:28:49] of the very first labor [5:28:50] contracts in the cannabis [5:28:51] industry. [5:28:52] I mean things like a paid day [5:28:54] off to go to the doctor and [5:28:57] fair wages And if you're [5:28:58] injured at the job that your [5:29:00] employer actually has to pay [5:29:03] worker's comp these are [5:29:03] the things that these workers [5:29:04] are asking for. [5:29:05] And I think that that should be [5:29:06] the bare minimum And it really [5:29:09] is very hard for cannabis [5:29:11] businesses who are lawfully [5:29:13] operating including the new [5:29:14] cannabis businesses who will be [5:29:16] permitted under the county's [5:29:18] equity program. [5:29:19] You too can be undercut by [5:29:21] the folks who operate down [5:29:22] the gas gaslamp from Kern [5:29:23] County by folks operating [5:29:25] outside of our state. [5:29:27] Even once you're licensed by [5:29:29] the cannabis equity program in [5:29:30] the county you too can use this [5:29:32] law If you locate in San Diego [5:29:34] and with the private right of [5:29:35] action it grants attorney's [5:29:38] fees and costs to [5:29:40] the prevailing party So you [5:29:41] don't need to hire an attorney. [5:29:43] You can get one to do it On [5:29:44] contingency. [5:29:45] It will be available to any [5:29:46] licensed business provider here [5:29:48] and you all can take on these [5:29:49] guys here or girls whoever who [5:29:52] are clearly coming from outside [5:29:53] the city and the county to come [5:29:55] undercut our local businesses. [5:29:58] That said, anyone who delivers [5:30:01] a product for sale in the city [5:30:03] of San Diego needs to be paying [5:30:04] sales tax and in this case [5:30:07] cannabis tax in the city. [5:30:08] You know we have folks who [5:30:10] deliver for Amazon or Target or [5:30:12] Walmart And if the point of [5:30:13] sale is here in the city of San [5:30:14] Diego, they have to pay their [5:30:15] taxes here even if their [5:30:17] business is located outside of [5:30:18] it. [5:30:18] This is a basic tax revenue [5:30:21] requirement. [5:30:21] It's a licensure requirement [5:30:23] and we require all businesses [5:30:24] to do this. [5:30:25] So I will second the motion. [5:30:27] >> Thank you. [5:30:27] All right. [5:30:28] Thank you. [5:30:29] Council member Von Wilpert. [5:30:30] So we have a motion by [5:30:31] Councilmember Campos, second by [5:30:34] Council member Von Wolpert to [5:30:35] move the staff recommendation [5:30:36] and we'll go next to Council [5:30:39] member Foster and thank you [5:30:40] Council PRESIDENT And I guess I [5:30:48] just need to reiterate and just [5:30:52] state for the record that I [5:30:57] think the discourse that you [5:30:59] are hearing stems from one [5:31:03] problem and that is we move [5:31:06] forward with cannabis without [5:31:09] being inclusive on its onset [5:31:11] And I think that was the worst [5:31:14] thing that we could have done. [5:31:16] I appreciate the $20 million in [5:31:19] revenue or roughly thereof that [5:31:21] we have been receiving. [5:31:23] I appreciate the good jobs as [5:31:28] our partners have been working [5:31:30] to make sure that we have good [5:31:34] employee benefits and and [5:31:37] workers rights But we did a [5:31:40] disservice. [5:31:41] We excluded a community that [5:31:46] has and still to this day is [5:31:56] continuing to have challenges [5:31:57] as we look at um how folks can [5:32:08] have what we call a life in [5:32:10] this United States of America [5:32:13] and this is something that we [5:32:17] have to stop. [5:32:19] It sounds like just from [5:32:22] the line of I guess from my [5:32:24] colleague MR. Campo [5:32:27] Councilmember Campo that there [5:32:28] is work that needs to come back [5:32:29] as we talk about establishing [5:32:31] permit fees. [5:32:33] It sounds like it should not [5:32:35] exceed $125. [5:32:37] Is that what I'm understand on [5:32:40] the onset of this conversation? [5:32:41] That's correct. [5:32:44] Okay. [5:32:45] Um and I guess if you can help [5:32:49] me to understand what does this [5:32:52] mean as I hear the public [5:32:54] comment, what does this mean [5:32:55] for folks that are part of this [5:32:59] county's program? [5:33:01] Is this excluding those [5:33:03] individuals from being able to [5:33:06] participate in the cannabis [5:33:08] industry that would like to do [5:33:10] delivery? [5:33:12] Yeah. [5:33:13] Thank you for the question. [5:33:15] Um, as the ordinance is written [5:33:16] now the county social equity [5:33:18] operators or any operator [5:33:21] that's delivering from outside [5:33:22] the city would be required to [5:33:24] fill out the permit form which [5:33:26] would be an online [5:33:27] registration. [5:33:28] And I think the thing that [5:33:29] we're hearing and discussion is [5:33:31] the fee amount and does that [5:33:33] fee represent a barrier? [5:33:34] And so like you said, [5:33:36] the second part of this is to [5:33:38] bring that fee study forward [5:33:39] and to determine the cost of [5:33:42] service and also explore [5:33:44] options for whether that be [5:33:48] waivers, discounted rates and [5:33:53] explore the possibilities [5:33:54] there. [5:33:55] But we can't determine that [5:33:58] feasibility without [5:33:59] understanding the cost to begin [5:34:01] with. [5:34:01] So we benchmark it against [5:34:03] the current business tax [5:34:06] certificate because it's a [5:34:07] similar mechanism of [5:34:08] registering providing [5:34:09] the information online. [5:34:11] It's not a land use permit [5:34:12] where it's going to be [5:34:13] intensive. [5:34:14] So we're thinking ballpark [5:34:16] can't be more than 50 to $100 [5:34:18] but we have to be sure before [5:34:19] we present that information to [5:34:21] any other jurisdiction And also [5:34:23] to that we have met with [5:34:26] the county of San Diego over [5:34:28] this question and concern which [5:34:30] is how will the county social [5:34:33] equity businesses understand [5:34:35] the requirements when they're [5:34:37] navigating all of these hoops [5:34:39] through the county's program? [5:34:41] And we received their [5:34:43] commitment that they have a [5:34:44] list of the delivery operators [5:34:46] those Type nine licenses or [5:34:48] microbusinesses that will be [5:34:49] entering into the city and they [5:34:51] have a staff person ready to [5:34:52] assist filling out that form. [5:34:54] They're waiting on us to get [5:34:55] that information to them So we [5:34:58] will work extensively to make [5:35:00] sure that this ordinance [5:35:02] targets who is intended and is [5:35:05] not hurt, who it's not intended [5:35:06] to hurt. [5:35:10] Okay. [5:35:10] I appreciate that clarification [5:35:10] . [5:35:14] I mean I guess I will turn to [5:35:18] the city attorney as I am as my [5:35:22] office is working on a cannabis [5:35:25] equity policy as we speak. [5:35:30] And I will say that we have had [5:35:32] conversations with other [5:35:34] agencies and in one being Long [5:35:38] Beach on that we've had some [5:35:39] extensive conversations with as [5:35:41] we talk about the cannabis [5:35:43] industry and impacted folks and [5:35:45] barriers. [5:35:46] And one thing that did come [5:35:50] about that conversation as we [5:35:52] talk about cannabis equity is [5:35:54] the importance of delivery and [5:35:59] delivery services. [5:36:01] Um it is a lot different than [5:36:04] trying to enter the market just [5:36:08] establishing a brick and mortar [5:36:11] type process. [5:36:13] Um just evening I'm going to [5:36:15] take out what the cost of of of [5:36:18] building a building or some of [5:36:22] that but just the cost of what [5:36:24] we go through from a [5:36:26] development services position [5:36:28] and that added cost and time [5:36:31] frame and what it does to [5:36:33] someone that's trying to move [5:36:35] forward in this industry it is [5:36:37] daunting and it is a a [5:36:44] financial burden um the way [5:36:45] this process is moving right [5:36:48] now. [5:36:49] And so with that MADAM City [5:36:51] Attorney I will say um that um [5:36:57] I will my office will be [5:36:59] contacting you as I think as we [5:37:01] continue to move forward with [5:37:02] the cannabis equity policy that [5:37:05] we will have to potentially at [5:37:08] some point um relook at this [5:37:11] policy that we are discussing [5:37:12] today and to make some [5:37:14] provisions based on what we are [5:37:16] going to be bringing forward [5:37:18] because I cannot bring in a [5:37:22] cannabis equity policy without [5:37:24] a delivery provision and that [5:37:28] was directly a result of my [5:37:30] conversations with Long Beach [5:37:32] and what was brought to my [5:37:34] attention. [5:37:34] So it is a very, very important [5:37:37] and critical component of a of [5:37:39] an equity program. [5:37:40] So thank you Council member [5:37:45] We'll be happy to discuss those [5:37:46] issues with Office. [5:37:47] All right. [5:37:48] Thank you With that One last [5:37:50] question and just going to [5:37:52] the eBay's comments on that [5:37:56] they provided it seems like [5:37:58] there are as we as the main [5:38:00] purpose that we are doing this [5:38:02] is trying to get our arms [5:38:04] around the illicit market and [5:38:07] especially and I'm just going [5:38:08] to say out of town folks, right [5:38:10] I'm going to isolate those mean [5:38:12] those bad actors. [5:38:13] But clearly it looks like [5:38:14] there's concerns on just what [5:38:17] that enforcement entails, what [5:38:21] it looks like. [5:38:21] Can you fill us in on just what [5:38:25] those at least immediate [5:38:28] challenges have been or what is [5:38:31] police referring to? [5:38:33] As you know, we can pass a [5:38:35] policy but if we can't go out [5:38:36] and enforce then what are we [5:38:41] accomplishing? [5:38:41] Definitely I'll I'll start and [5:38:43] then I can pass it over to [5:38:45] the departments to get their [5:38:46] response. [5:38:47] But the concerns that were [5:38:49] mentioned on how to enforce [5:38:53] delivery is essentially [5:38:55] the reason why we're proposing [5:38:56] this with the private right of [5:38:58] action. [5:38:58] Our current enforcement [5:39:00] capacity is exhausted. [5:39:03] The fda has the authority to [5:39:04] issue notices and I'll let them [5:39:06] finish on their department of [5:39:08] their expertise. [5:39:09] But their staff is limited. [5:39:12] The information that they have [5:39:13] is limited So as is they're [5:39:16] unable to enforce against known [5:39:20] delivery services especially [5:39:21] because they don't have a [5:39:23] physical place in San Diego. [5:39:25] So how can dsd enforce [5:39:27] something that's not within [5:39:28] their limits? [5:39:29] And so that's where the city [5:39:31] treasurer's office comes in and [5:39:32] they're responsible for [5:39:35] administering the business tax [5:39:36] certificate and they would be [5:39:38] the entity that's responsible [5:39:39] for enforcing this so to speak [5:39:41] from an administrative [5:39:42] perspective they would be [5:39:43] administering the permit. [5:39:45] But the question then becomes [5:39:46] what happens if a business [5:39:48] decides not to register? [5:39:49] They only have five registrants [5:39:51] so far and like you heard in [5:39:54] comment Oceanside set up a [5:39:54] registry No one registered [5:39:56] because they don't have an [5:39:57] incentive to and so that's [5:40:01] where the private right of [5:40:02] action comes into play where [5:40:05] the current enforcement [5:40:07] mechanisms aren't working. [5:40:08] So there wouldn't be [5:40:10] necessarily additional [5:40:11] enforcement capacity to address [5:40:13] that even though it repeat some [5:40:16] of the available improvement [5:40:19] mechanisms. [5:40:19] I would say So with that I can [5:40:23] turn it over to coda if you [5:40:24] have anything else to add. [5:40:24] >> Yeah. [5:40:25] Thanks so much. [5:40:26] I think that captures it pretty [5:40:28] accurately. [5:40:28] It's really to supplement and [5:40:30] support the current enforcement [5:40:33] landscape they're adding in [5:40:35] the Treasurer piece of it and [5:40:36] having essentially a checkpoint [5:40:37] for what we know is out there [5:40:40] not out there That's helpful to [5:40:41] support these efforts [5:40:43] separately from that. [5:40:44] But really the private right of [5:40:46] action is is that in the big [5:40:47] shiny thing through this new [5:40:49] proposed policy But staff is [5:40:51] ready to enforce this to [5:40:53] implement this I do have at [5:40:57] least open to as well as [5:40:57] Ricardo Ramos from city [5:41:00] treasurer all mine if have [5:41:00] really any specific questions [5:41:01] there But we are all on [5:41:03] the same page and ready to [5:41:04] enforce. [5:41:04] Okay. [5:41:07] Is there any I guess anything [5:41:09] covered in the current statutes [5:41:11] in regards to reporting or how [5:41:13] are we going to monitor Is [5:41:15] there any monitoring associated [5:41:16] with this? [5:41:16] How are we going to determine [5:41:18] how this is progressing? [5:41:20] There's no monitoring [5:41:22] requirements that are explicit [5:41:23] in the ordinance but because of [5:41:26] that it's flexible to determine [5:41:28] that administratively our goal [5:41:30] would be to have something like [5:41:32] the Department of Cannabis [5:41:33] Control They have a registry [5:41:37] that's available for public [5:41:38] viewing so you're not [5:41:39] contacting that staff person [5:41:41] and asking for that [5:41:42] information. [5:41:42] It's a readily available list [5:41:45] and active registry. [5:41:46] So in terms of records [5:41:48] maintenance and managing of [5:41:50] that we would envision an [5:41:53] annual updated process. [5:41:54] But again it's up to [5:41:55] the administration and [5:41:57] department to determine what [5:41:58] makes the most sense and what [5:42:00] would be feasible on their end. [5:42:03] Okay. [5:42:05] All right. [5:42:06] Thank you for that. [5:42:07] I guess I will fall back coda [5:42:10] and have some additional [5:42:12] conversation so I can make sure [5:42:13] I just understand just from a [5:42:15] practical perspective what this [5:42:17] enforcement process looks like. [5:42:19] It sounds like we are going to [5:42:21] leave it in the hands of [5:42:22] the public to come in and try [5:42:24] and do some things which is a [5:42:30] little concerning based on how [5:42:33] the commentary and the feedback [5:42:35] you get within the industry as [5:42:38] competitive as it is and [5:42:40] the issues that that everyone's [5:42:42] encountering I will support [5:42:47] this today as we continue to [5:42:50] move forward. [5:42:51] But again and that's what [5:42:55] the understanding the intent [5:42:55] that I will be bringing forward [5:42:57] the cannabis equity program [5:42:58] I'll be it will have a delivery [5:43:01] component to it And so we'll be [5:43:04] looking to make sure that any [5:43:06] necessary provisions to make [5:43:07] sure we are as inclusive as we [5:43:09] can be as we continue to move [5:43:11] forward and further progress [5:43:14] with the cannabis or cannabis [5:43:18] program. [5:43:20] And again I'm just going to [5:43:21] close with I am still very [5:43:24] disappointed that we move [5:43:26] forward without the cannabis [5:43:27] equity program. [5:43:28] I hate that we gave almost $1 [5:43:31] million back which I think was [5:43:32] a horrible decision and really [5:43:35] an injustice to those folks who [5:43:37] have been impacted. [5:43:38] And just to turn this over to [5:43:42] what I guess I would call [5:43:43] corporate type folks to take [5:43:47] over this industry I think was [5:43:48] just a horrific and horrible [5:43:51] move by the by the city [5:43:52] council. [5:43:53] And so I'll conclude there. [5:43:56] Council PRESIDENT And me for [5:44:02] your comments. [5:44:02] All right. [5:44:03] Thank you Council my boss for [5:44:04] not seeing anybody Council [5:44:06] member Yellow River Thank you [5:44:09] Council PRESIDENT Thank you so [5:44:11] much for the presentation and [5:44:12] for your help Customer come to [5:44:14] you for bringing us forward [5:44:15] kind of at a high level you [5:44:22] know groups and businesses that [5:44:25] are taking advantage of San [5:44:28] Diego that are operating here [5:44:31] benefiting from the city but [5:44:33] not paying their fair share. [5:44:35] I always have a problem with [5:44:36] that And so I appreciate [5:44:39] the part of this that that aims [5:44:41] to address that. [5:44:42] I'm certainly sympathetic to [5:44:44] the concerns that the high [5:44:49] standard that you C.W., has [5:44:53] helped establish for what work [5:44:55] place conditions and wages look [5:44:57] like for those folks who work [5:44:59] in the industry that operate [5:45:02] outside the city. [5:45:04] There's operators who work or [5:45:06] not not only not meeting that [5:45:07] standard that employers [5:45:09] generally and we certainly do [5:45:11] want to reward that All of [5:45:13] those concerns I am very [5:45:15] sympathetic to I appreciate [5:45:17] the questions and comments from [5:45:17] Councilmember Foster. [5:45:22] I could I'm not sure I fully [5:45:25] understood the answer to [5:45:26] the question raised about input [5:45:28] raised about implementation [5:45:29] because in terms I appreciate [5:45:34] your your response but I will [5:45:38] note that dsd and Treasurer [5:45:40] raise concerns regarding [5:45:41] implementation of Proposal co [5:45:42] two. [5:45:43] You said you guys are ready to [5:45:45] enforce. [5:45:47] What's the gap there between [5:45:48] what the department's told [5:45:50] the ipa and the readiness to [5:45:53] enforce? [5:45:53] And I think there's been an [5:45:54] acknowledgment by the length [5:45:56] within the language of [5:45:57] the ordinance that there's a [5:46:00] gap between what the city can [5:46:03] do and what the expectation is [5:46:05] as far as what needs to be [5:46:06] done. [5:46:08] I think and certainly I'm not [5:46:11] tried to speak on your behalf I [5:46:12] think there was a [5:46:14] misunderstanding that MAY be [5:46:14] played out last week during one [5:46:16] of the public briefings that [5:46:18] has since been resolved where [5:46:20] dsd does know their role here [5:46:22] within this proposed ordinance [5:46:23] as does the city treasurer. [5:46:24] I think maybe there was an [5:46:26] assumption that more was going [5:46:27] to be added to their plate in [5:46:28] terms of something that would [5:46:29] require additional staff time [5:46:30] or budget which again wouldn't [5:46:33] be maybe wasn't something that [5:46:36] was going to be ready for [5:46:36] consideration today that then [5:46:38] resolved We do have a path [5:46:40] forward here that we can do [5:46:41] within our current capacity. [5:46:43] We do have a game plan moving [5:46:45] forward on returning with [5:46:47] the fee study and so we do feel [5:46:48] confident that our timeline and [5:46:52] path forward is solidified and [5:46:54] agreed upon by all parties and [5:46:56] city departments. [5:46:58] So if you can I ask you I mean [5:46:59] you put this here for a reason [5:47:00] . [5:47:02] Are there specific concerns [5:47:04] that you continue to have just [5:47:09] not have the information that [5:47:11] code is referencing here? [5:47:13] I'm trying to reconcile what I [5:47:16] know what's put here in good [5:47:18] faith and what we're hearing on [5:47:20] the dais. [5:47:23] I think Yes. [5:47:24] So so while we're discussing [5:47:24] with the departments both dsd [5:47:28] and seato just have questions [5:47:30] on how to enforce once we have [5:47:33] this registered or some [5:47:35] information that they might [5:47:36] require that it's not provided [5:47:38] and I defer back to the city or [5:47:40] what specific those are For [5:47:41] example type nine licenses [5:47:43] information that is collected [5:47:46] in the state That's not [5:47:47] something they're able to [5:47:48] receive as of my understanding [5:47:51] now But I would defer back to [5:47:53] the cto for specifics. [5:48:01] I don't have anyone we do [5:48:03] believe we had a deputy [5:48:04] director Ricardo Ramos from [5:48:06] city treasurer only this [5:48:08] recording of the see that's [5:48:10] what concern was just [5:48:11] the enforcement as referenced [5:48:14] earlier this is basically just [5:48:16] a registry So we're collecting [5:48:17] the data and we can actually do [5:48:20] that piece. [5:48:20] But it's the question is just [5:48:22] the enforcement. [5:48:27] So that's what the answer if [5:48:33] that's the question as well as [5:48:34] what was presented today, there [5:48:35] is no enforcement enforcement [5:48:38] that would be performed by [5:48:38] the city just because we have a [5:48:40] lack of resources to The answer [5:48:43] is a private right of action. [5:48:45] Correct. [5:48:46] Okay. [5:48:52] So okay So concerns about [5:48:59] the city's ability to enforce [5:49:02] or I should say implement [5:49:04] through enforcement those [5:49:06] remain what is solved through [5:49:10] salt Fourth through [5:49:10] the ordinance is [5:49:12] the expectation that that gap [5:49:14] will be closed through private [5:49:16] right of action. [5:49:18] That's okay. [5:49:22] There's like I like a consensus [5:49:23] of had nothing going on okay I [5:49:29] recognize that type of action [5:49:30] are a common tool and an [5:49:34] important tool And I just from [5:49:36] a general public policy [5:49:37] perspective I have concerns and [5:49:41] don't like the idea that we've [5:49:43] basically written off [5:49:44] the city's ability to to [5:49:46] perform a function that we [5:49:47] think is worth writing the law [5:49:48] for to the to private industry. [5:49:54] But that's just as a general [5:49:57] sense of public policy that [5:49:59] doesn't seem like the direction [5:50:02] we should head but that's a [5:50:03] resource issue and that will [5:50:05] continue to be a resource issue [5:50:06] until the city is properly is [5:50:08] properly resourced which is a [5:50:17] little bit of a separate issue [5:50:18] but not completely because as [5:50:20] we like we are adding things to [5:50:22] the city's plate while we're [5:50:23] also removing resources at [5:50:25] times and I will continue to be [5:50:27] frustrated by that But that's [5:50:29] not the decision that's in [5:50:30] front of us. [5:50:34] One other question and [5:50:36] COUNCILMAN Foster was going to [5:50:37] get to this There's four cities [5:50:39] referenced in the ordinance [5:50:41] L.A., Oakland, Long Beach and [5:50:42] Ventura. [5:50:46] Three of those four, as I [5:50:47] understand it have equity [5:50:48] programs and as I think either [5:50:50] of us were saying, the delivery [5:50:53] piece is the onramp to [5:50:55] the equity program in Long [5:50:56] Beach. [5:51:00] So what are and I trust [5:51:02] COUNCILMAN Foster to do [5:51:03] the work here But what what are [5:51:04] we kind of doing more broadly [5:51:08] to include the equity piece [5:51:10] since we're using their [5:51:11] regulatory framework that you [5:51:17] you'll have you don't have to [5:51:19] That's all right if you want it [5:51:20] by all means. [5:51:20] But it's also a question for [5:51:23] COUNCILMAN Foster and our [5:51:24] office has been working on [5:51:25] the cannabis social equity [5:51:26] program and proposed policy for [5:51:29] you know been working closely [5:51:30] together on that. [5:51:31] That was one of the first [5:51:31] questions asked when this [5:51:33] initial proposal came forward [5:51:34] was how it MAY incorporate an [5:51:34] impact Councilmember Foster's [5:51:35] effort. [5:51:38] And so as we get closer to [5:51:39] the finish line with that [5:51:40] proposed policy as this one [5:51:42] gets legs under it and starts [5:51:43] to be implemented, those are [5:51:44] two conversations that [5:51:45] absolutely have to happen [5:51:46] concurrently to ensure that [5:51:48] both are essentially feeding [5:51:49] into each other. [5:51:51] >> So okay, I appreciate that. [5:51:55] The last thing I will say is I [5:51:57] just will echo the comments [5:51:59] from Catherine Foster that [5:52:01] the further we allow those who [5:52:08] got their foot in the door for [5:52:10] the regulated industry to to to [5:52:17] sprint ahead, the more [5:52:19] difficult it is to make it [5:52:21] equity to eventually have an [5:52:23] equity program that will [5:52:24] actually be meaningful and we [5:52:29] have folks who were shut out [5:52:32] who were targeted just as much [5:52:36] for who they are and where they [5:52:38] were as as to what they were [5:52:41] actually doing. [5:52:43] We know the disproportionality [5:52:45] of the war on drugs and what [5:52:47] that has meant for generational [5:52:49] poverty, the disruption of [5:52:51] families and long term harm [5:52:53] that will take generations to [5:52:57] undo And it the cities the city [5:53:01] has made it a intentional [5:53:05] decision to start a race and [5:53:07] not even allow those folks to [5:53:10] not only not have their shoes [5:53:11] on yet they're not even at [5:53:12] the track yet And I think that [5:53:14] continues to be a concern And [5:53:16] my trust in Councilmember [5:53:19] Foster's commitment to making [5:53:22] sure that we get that piece up [5:53:25] and running in a meaningful way [5:53:28] is is significant. [5:53:30] But I understand [5:53:33] the frustration And so again, [5:53:35] the intent here I think is [5:53:38] there's a lot that we are [5:53:39] aiming to curb that I think [5:53:40] needs to be curbed. [5:53:41] I will never support the idea [5:53:43] of businesses operating in [5:53:44] the city without contributing [5:53:47] back to the city. [5:53:48] I'll never support the idea of [5:53:50] businesses operating in [5:53:51] the city and selling their [5:53:53] workers short and I want to [5:53:56] make sure that we do right by [5:53:57] those who were most harmed by a [5:54:01] war on drugs that has been [5:54:04] proven in every way imaginable [5:54:08] to have been extremely, [5:54:10] extremely harmful in a very [5:54:13] disproportionate way. [5:54:14] So with that I say thank you [5:54:16] again to Catherine Pompeo and [5:54:18] his team for bringing this [5:54:20] forward and look forward to [5:54:21] having the questions answered [5:54:22] that have been raised today. [5:54:24] Thank you. [5:54:25] >> All right. [5:54:26] Thank you. [5:54:26] Council member Eli Rivera. [5:54:27] We'll go back to Councilmember [5:54:28] Foster. [5:54:29] Thank you. [5:54:30] Just one last question [5:54:33] Hopefully I guess just process [5:54:36] wise as there is more work to [5:54:40] do Right. [5:54:42] We have this passes today I'm [5:54:44] assuming that's the first read [5:54:46] comes back for the second read. [5:54:49] I guess my question is timeline [5:54:53] wise and as we talk about cost [5:54:59] of service right our fee study [5:55:02] those types of things So what [5:55:05] happens when we are still going [5:55:07] through that process and [5:55:08] understanding just how this [5:55:09] will be operationalized? [5:55:11] I guess I will say And what [5:55:13] does that leave to [5:55:14] the individuals who MAY be [5:55:16] going through whatever they are [5:55:18] going through? [5:55:19] Let's say there is a county [5:55:22] equity individual who wants to [5:55:29] come in and sign up or do [5:55:32] something. [5:55:32] What does that do to their [5:55:33] business and their ability to [5:55:35] engage as we are trying to [5:55:38] figure out the operational side [5:55:39] of this and to where we are [5:55:41] able to function and understand [5:55:45] who you know because I'm [5:55:45] assuming if they go to court [5:55:46] who would be the legal not [5:55:48] legal not legal business entity [5:55:51] or what comes first, how does [5:55:54] that play out in terms of [5:55:56] the process of the ordinance [5:55:57] and its implementation? [5:55:59] Well, first this would be first [5:56:01] reading second reading 30 days [5:56:04] pass that implementation date [5:56:06] and we're asking for commitment [5:56:07] from the mayor's office to be [5:56:08] able to bring that fee study in [5:56:11] alignment with that timeline so [5:56:13] that we have certainty before [5:56:15] this ordinance becomes [5:56:16] effective because you can't [5:56:20] have an effective ordinance [5:56:21] with this tool without [5:56:22] the implementation and it can't [5:56:26] work. [5:56:28] So correct And I think it would [5:56:29] if that did happen it would [5:56:31] just become chaos. [5:56:33] So what I guess how are you [5:56:35] going to manage that? [5:56:36] What's the plan for that? [5:56:37] So as we go through the second [5:56:39] reading and if that passes [5:56:41] through council city treasurer [5:56:43] initiates the fee study item We [5:56:46] are up against legislative [5:56:47] recess at that time as well [5:56:48] too. [5:56:48] So there's a little bit of time [5:56:50] here after initial passage and [5:56:51] actual implementation. [5:56:53] I think during that portion as [5:56:54] you do have the commitment from [5:56:55] our office that this does not [5:56:57] go live until that fee is [5:56:58] obviously there. [5:57:00] And so it's a it's a [5:57:01] communication piece really. [5:57:03] And so I think the second part [5:57:04] of the request from [5:57:06] Councilmember Campo was for our [5:57:07] assistance in coordinating with [5:57:08] other regional entities as [5:57:10] Summer mentioned earlier [5:57:11] incorporating equity pieces [5:57:13] that the county already has in [5:57:14] place into that fee study I [5:57:16] think is is a good step forward [5:57:18] And so there's quite a bit of [5:57:20] work here after initial passage [5:57:22] but we got to get this passed [5:57:24] to initiate that work And so [5:57:26] it's really going to be a [5:57:27] communication piece from both [5:57:28] of our offices on this council [5:57:30] to educate folks on what to [5:57:32] expect and then have a clear [5:57:34] runway as the fee actually gets [5:57:35] adopted by this council. [5:57:37] We have a firm implementation [5:57:38] date in mind. [5:57:39] Okay. [5:57:40] So what I'm hearing is if for [5:57:42] some reason that commitment in [5:57:45] regards to operationalizing [5:57:47] this is not stood up in time as [5:57:52] we go through this second read [5:57:53] then are we going to pause or [5:57:58] timeline that correctly so that [5:58:00] we are not so we don't have an [5:58:02] ordinance that has passed and [5:58:03] made it through and then we are [5:58:07] in trouble trying to scramble [5:58:09] and you have this clause in [5:58:13] here where folks can just start [5:58:15] filing. [5:58:18] So how are we managing that? [5:58:21] >> You understand what I'm [5:58:22] asking? [5:58:23] I totally get what you're [5:58:24] saying. [5:58:24] So I think I think there need [5:58:27] to be a discussion maybe with [5:58:28] city attorney's office here on [5:58:30] if we push out a second reading [5:58:31] and initiate to basically take [5:58:33] this as the direction of [5:58:34] the council saying yes, proceed [5:58:35] with establishing the fee and [5:58:37] then going through that process [5:58:38] to conduct the study and have [5:58:41] the conversations I described [5:58:42] earlier before returning for [5:58:43] the second reading Similar to [5:58:45] how we do things if it's a [5:58:46] meeting confer approach or [5:58:47] anything like that that way we [5:58:49] can have a clear and clean [5:58:50] implementation date. [5:58:52] I think both options work here [5:58:54] but I completely understand [5:58:55] where your concerns are of [5:58:56] basically creating a [5:58:57] opportunity for predatory [5:58:59] litigation to come through and [5:58:59] in place. [5:59:01] So get that. [5:59:02] Okay. [5:59:03] Well I think that's something [5:59:04] that we need to make sure we [5:59:06] have a clear understanding and [5:59:10] don't get ahead of ourselves [5:59:14] and create other issues And [5:59:17] then I'm sure creating more [5:59:20] barriers for folks who have [5:59:21] already been impacted from [5:59:23] the war on drugs right. [5:59:26] So so MADAM City Attorney, I [5:59:28] guess I will in the city [5:59:31] attorney's office We'll add [5:59:32] that to our conversation. [5:59:35] Um, as we are preparing and [5:59:37] continuing to move this item [5:59:39] forward I just want to make [5:59:40] sure that we are not getting [5:59:41] ahead of ourselves and doing [5:59:43] more of a disservice and that [5:59:44] what we are trying to [5:59:46] accomplish with this. [5:59:48] Okay. [5:59:49] Thank you. [5:59:49] Council PRESIDENT All right. [5:59:51] Thank you Councilmember Foster [5:59:54] Not see anybody else and light [5:59:56] I'll ask a few questions of my [5:59:58] own one Thank you Councilmember [6:00:03] Camp you and your d seven team [6:00:03] on This is something we've [6:00:05] talked about. [6:00:06] We have acknowledged it and it [6:00:07] never went anywhere even though [6:00:09] we recognize the delivery [6:00:11] services were happening there [6:00:13] And as I think we've all kind [6:00:15] of landed on the inability to [6:00:18] enforce by city staff was [6:00:21] probably one of the reasons [6:00:22] that we were just kind of stuck [6:00:25] and acknowledging there was a [6:00:26] problem without any kind of [6:00:27] solution And the private right [6:00:28] of action is that missing piece [6:00:30] that allows us to actually that [6:00:34] will be brought forward. [6:00:35] So thank you for working [6:00:36] through it. [6:00:38] So the questions that go [6:00:39] through my mind are unlike most [6:00:42] ordinances and implementations [6:00:45] that follow afterwards, it's [6:00:48] the city that's doing [6:00:49] the enforcement. [6:00:50] This ordinance actually has a [6:00:52] private right of action. [6:00:53] Is there language in today's [6:00:56] motion that says this does not [6:00:59] go into effect until we [6:01:01] actually have a permit process [6:01:03] in place That's not in [6:01:07] the motion language but if [6:01:09] the maker would like to we go [6:01:11] to the first reading, we go to [6:01:12] the second reading we have an [6:01:13] ordinance and somebody named [6:01:16] Lady Named says I just found [6:01:18] somebody who doesn't have a [6:01:19] permit and compliance. [6:01:21] I'm going to initiate a private [6:01:22] right of action Go to my be [6:01:25] bound with operations side. [6:01:28] Is it a crazy idea? [6:01:29] I know there's some big money [6:01:31] there that council PRESIDENT [6:01:39] Are you are you asking if [6:01:41] the private right of action can [6:01:43] be a force enforced if the city [6:01:45] hasn't City Treasurer's office [6:01:46] hasn't created the license [6:01:48] structure or the permit [6:01:49] structure for an outside of [6:01:52] the city cannabis delivery [6:01:53] program or a business to [6:01:55] actually get and therefore [6:01:58] follow the law. [6:01:59] >> I guess that's that's [6:02:01] the question. [6:02:02] I think that it would Okay Well [6:02:05] first to even prove it you'd [6:02:05] have to prove harm or you'd [6:02:08] have to show that you're, you [6:02:08] know, harmed economically But I [6:02:13] guess strictly speaking it [6:02:14] doesn't elucidate that exactly [6:02:15] . [6:02:20] I mean code is committed to [6:02:22] the operation cited dft or city [6:02:25] treasurers would enforce that. [6:02:26] We actually had it in place [6:02:28] certainly Well to be very to be [6:02:29] very clear, there is an [6:02:31] enforcement mechanism for [6:02:32] the city that says a city [6:02:33] manager shall promulgate rules [6:02:34] and regulations to do that. [6:02:36] So it's not as if we're not [6:02:39] able to create a system for [6:02:41] internal administrative [6:02:42] enforcement. [6:02:47] So I would say it's almost [6:02:49] nonsensical to think that a [6:02:51] private right of action could [6:02:51] come forward if the city [6:02:55] manager, the mayor's office [6:02:57] through the departments hasn't [6:02:58] created an actual license to [6:02:59] apply for because how could you [6:03:01] possibly go forward and try to [6:03:02] follow the law as an outside [6:03:04] delivery company if it doesn't [6:03:06] exist? [6:03:08] Yeah but the city attorney [6:03:10] agree with him Either one of [6:03:12] you And as Deputy City attorney [6:03:16] David Carlin to respond to [6:03:17] that? [6:03:18] >> Yes, I would agree with that [6:03:19] proposition that's been [6:03:21] discussed by Councilmember You [6:03:22] . [6:03:24] It's a private right of action [6:03:25] could not be initiated until [6:03:26] there actually is a permit [6:03:27] process in place That I guess [6:03:30] to answer that question [6:03:31] specifically, there's nothing [6:03:32] ever to stop somebody from [6:03:34] filing a lawsuit as I think we [6:03:35] all know. [6:03:35] But to succeed in that lawsuit [6:03:38] is you'd have to have a permit [6:03:40] process in place to show that [6:03:42] somebody is in violation of it [6:03:43] . [6:03:43] >> That's right. [6:03:45] Okay. [6:03:45] I got three lawyers saying yes [6:03:50] so I'm going to back off at [6:03:51] the engineer the for those of [6:03:57] us that are not steeped in this [6:03:58] whole ordinance, there's no [6:04:02] limit on the number of permits [6:04:03] that can be issued. [6:04:04] Is that correct? [6:04:06] >> That's correct. [6:04:06] As long as it's state licensed [6:04:09] there was an assumption made [6:04:11] that you have to have both a I [6:04:14] think a business tax [6:04:15] certificate and the permit and [6:04:19] that the expectation is that [6:04:22] that permit we know what [6:04:23] the business tax certificate [6:04:24] amounts are. [6:04:25] It's kind of a throwaway It's [6:04:27] probably the cheapest fee that [6:04:29] we have on the books. [6:04:30] But if what if survey the fee [6:04:37] analysis comes back and said [6:04:39] well yeah, we're not going to [6:04:40] do anything for 75 bucks or 150 [6:04:42] bucks. [6:04:42] I don't even know what permit [6:04:43] you could get for that. [6:04:44] And it comes back of 300 bucks [6:04:46] and 500 bucks. [6:04:48] We're just going to we could [6:04:50] subsidize it. [6:04:51] We don't have to have full cost [6:04:52] recovery but I just want to set [6:04:56] expectations that in fact it [6:04:58] MAY not come in that an [6:05:00] expensive so and then we can [6:05:02] deal with it because we can [6:05:03] subsidize it. [6:05:04] We don't have to charge full [6:05:05] cost recovery and we can do as [6:05:07] I think it was suggested [6:05:08] waivers or carve out I've done [6:05:12] some of those and some of [6:05:13] the fees. [6:05:14] The other question is I think [6:05:16] every time that we've gone and [6:05:18] done update our fees and [6:05:20] penalties, a lot of us have [6:05:23] grumbled that we don't think [6:05:24] those rates are high enough to [6:05:26] actually be a disincentive to [6:05:28] someone breaking the law. [6:05:30] I can think lots and lots of [6:05:31] examples of that. [6:05:33] This sets a whole new bar of [6:05:35] jacking up 10,000 per violation [6:05:39] for abatement $20,000 a day for [6:05:41] a civil penalty That opens up [6:05:44] the universe in terms of what [6:05:46] those can be. [6:05:47] Why is this okay? [6:05:48] And when we don't do that with [6:05:49] any other fee and penalty, was [6:05:52] that just a policy call or was [6:05:55] there actually something that [6:05:56] limited how much we could [6:05:57] charge? [6:05:58] I don't know Who wants to [6:05:59] answer that. [6:06:00] I can start with the policy [6:06:02] direction the fee establishment [6:06:04] amount at $20,000 was a policy [6:06:07] decision based off of the city [6:06:08] of L.A. Is a penalty structure. [6:06:12] The $10,000 value comes from [6:06:15] what is existing in the land [6:06:17] development code that was [6:06:19] recently updated as part of [6:06:20] the JUNE 8th action. [6:06:22] So that is the baseline figure [6:06:24] that we were operating off of. [6:06:29] I'll leave it there. [6:06:29] MR.. [6:06:32] So legally again this literally [6:06:35] goes to the United States [6:06:36] Constitution and the Eighth [6:06:38] Amendment and the excessive [6:06:38] fine clause It would have to be [6:06:40] to be unlawful to be grossly [6:06:43] disproportionate to the actual [6:06:43] fence. [6:06:45] Again, this is a fee that's up [6:06:47] to $20,000 per day that a [6:06:50] violation exists. [6:06:51] And this would be I guess I [6:06:55] should say this is the judicial [6:06:56] civil penalty portion of this. [6:06:58] So a judge would have to factor [6:07:01] in what he or she would decide [6:07:03] would be judicially imposed. [6:07:04] Right. [6:07:09] I mean so it's not it's not a [6:07:10] guarantee $20,000 if we put a [6:07:13] ceiling on it. [6:07:15] Okay. [6:07:15] Fair enough Because again, we [6:07:18] have private right of action. [6:07:21] The city's policy generally has [6:07:22] a ban. [6:07:23] We're not looking for revenue. [6:07:25] We're looking for compliance by [6:07:27] private right of action [6:07:28] probably assume has no such [6:07:30] strings. [6:07:32] They don't have to say Did you [6:07:34] not know that there was a new [6:07:35] law that you have to comply [6:07:37] with that they can just drag [6:07:39] them into court, is that [6:07:41] correct? [6:07:43] Again, once the permit process [6:07:44] is up and running, yes, that [6:07:46] that is correct. [6:07:47] Okay. [6:07:49] And as I think others said, [6:07:52] communications are going to be [6:07:52] a big part of this to try to [6:07:53] spread the word that not only [6:07:56] is there a requirement but it [6:07:57] could be enforced immediately [6:07:58] unlike how the city typically [6:08:00] acts. [6:08:03] I think the one question that I [6:08:04] didn't hear from my colleagues [6:08:07] was we got a number of folks [6:08:10] who apparently operate under [6:08:12] the county cannabis equity [6:08:15] program. [6:08:18] I'm not familiar what are [6:08:20] the requirements that they had [6:08:21] to go through to qualify or get [6:08:24] a permit or whatever the county [6:08:25] does versus what this ordinance [6:08:27] will require? [6:08:29] Is there any differences or any [6:08:31] added obligations or [6:08:33] differences between [6:08:35] the county's permit and this [6:08:36] proposed permit The counties [6:08:38] permit? [6:08:38] From our conversations they [6:08:40] have four categories and [6:08:42] they're all land use based So [6:08:44] their delivery permit also [6:08:46] include is the facility itself [6:08:49] and they have a flat fee [6:08:50] assessed And I know we have [6:08:52] some county operators here they [6:08:54] can give the specifics on fees [6:08:55] but it's in the thousands of [6:08:56] dollars That's for the license [6:09:00] for the counties program. [6:09:01] An operator that's operating [6:09:04] social equity or not still has [6:09:06] to obtain their state license [6:09:07] both at the same time. [6:09:09] So they would have to obtain [6:09:11] their state license their [6:09:13] license to the county as a [6:09:14] separate licensing process [6:09:16] application fee And that's [6:09:20] the county what the city is [6:09:22] proposing in this ordinance is [6:09:25] the registration, [6:09:26] the commercial business [6:09:28] registration to do business and [6:09:30] conduct business in the city. [6:09:31] So it's not a land use permit [6:09:33] in that sense It's a business [6:09:35] registration that it's intended [6:09:36] to complement the existing [6:09:38] cannabis non cannabis business [6:09:41] tax certificate. [6:09:43] So if I understand correctly [6:09:45] the only new requirement for [6:09:47] anybody who has a permit or [6:09:49] license through the county is [6:09:51] to fill out an online form. [6:09:54] That's correct. [6:09:55] That's it. [6:09:56] So and the tax certificate and [6:10:00] then the permit fee which we [6:10:01] hope is $150 range. [6:10:08] >> Okay. [6:10:08] And I think that answers all [6:10:11] the questions. [6:10:12] So thank you very much for [6:10:13] answering the questions. [6:10:15] Thank you for working through [6:10:17] this. [6:10:17] I know some of the folks that [6:10:19] were in opposition to this are [6:10:20] not going to be satisfied with [6:10:22] the dialog here going forward [6:10:26] but I will be in support of [6:10:30] this. [6:10:31] So Councilmember Hemphill Thank [6:10:31] you, counselors. [6:10:33] I'll just be very brief. [6:10:34] MR. Carlin mentioned [6:10:34] constitutional protections that [6:10:36] clicked in my mind The Doctor [6:10:38] There would be a due process [6:10:40] problem for the city to create [6:10:42] a law but not create the permit [6:10:44] to enforce the law and then go [6:10:46] someone from a private reaction [6:10:47] go to a court to say this [6:10:48] person doesn't have the permit [6:10:50] that is required by law. [6:10:51] So I think it's a I think we [6:10:54] can say with a high degree of [6:10:56] certainty that no court would [6:10:57] allow a private private right [6:10:59] of action lawsuit if we haven't [6:11:01] taken the steps. [6:11:02] There's also equitable remedies [6:11:04] under the law to save. [6:11:05] How could I know I was [6:11:07] violating the law if I never [6:11:08] had the ability to follow [6:11:10] the law itself? [6:11:11] So I appreciate MR. Carlin [6:11:13] bringing up that phrase so it [6:11:15] would trigger that history [6:11:16] lesson. [6:11:17] Well, we all learned a little [6:11:18] bit about the Constitution. [6:11:21] Okay. [6:11:22] I think I've gotten all my [6:11:24] questions answered about again [6:11:27] thank you, Councilmember Campo, [6:11:29] for finally solving the missing [6:11:31] piece to regulate something [6:11:32] that we've talked about for a [6:11:33] very long time. [6:11:35] I look forward to Councilmember [6:11:36] Foster and his work at the city [6:11:39] level. [6:11:40] Thank you to staff for [6:11:41] navigating this and [6:11:42] the research that you did to [6:11:44] bring bring this forward. [6:11:46] So with that I don't see [6:11:48] anybody else on the lights. [6:11:49] We have a motion by [6:11:49] Councilmember Campo and [6:11:52] the second by council member [6:11:53] Von Wilbert that we can't [6:11:55] please call the roll. [6:11:57] I have set up the voting [6:11:58] system. [6:11:59] Please cast your vote. [6:12:10] The motion passes unanimously [6:12:11] with District two and district [6:12:13] date absent. [6:12:15] All right. [6:12:16] Thank you again. [6:12:18] Okay. [6:12:18] I need to do a little bit of a [6:12:19] time check. [6:12:20] This is the point in [6:12:21] the afternoon session where we [6:12:23] do not agenda public comment [6:12:25] Everybody willing to stick [6:12:26] around for both in-person and [6:12:29] remote because I hope we got [6:12:33] six So we're in good shape. [6:12:36] Thank you because I know I [6:12:37] don't want to roll over till [6:12:38] tomorrow. [6:12:38] It can be done so we will now [6:12:42] take up non agenda public [6:12:43] comment We'll take both [6:12:45] in-person and those [6:12:46] participating remotely. [6:12:48] Council members respect and [6:12:49] appreciate the public input and [6:12:50] are fully committed to [6:12:51] protecting every participant's [6:12:53] free speech rights at council [6:12:54] and committee meetings. [6:12:55] Deputy Clerk Please proceed [6:12:57] with public comment Pearl 2.7 [6:13:00] Known Agenda Public comment is [6:13:01] an opportunity for members of [6:13:02] the public to comment on items [6:13:03] that are not on the agenda but [6:13:05] within the subject matter [6:13:06] jurisdiction of the City [6:13:08] Council. [6:13:08] Each speaker will have two [6:13:10] minutes. [6:13:10] Please note if there are eight [6:13:12] or more speakers on a single [6:13:13] topic the maximum time for [6:13:14] the topic will be 16 minutes. [6:13:16] If you are in chambers please [6:13:18] submit your speaker slip If you [6:13:19] are joining us virtually please [6:13:20] raise your hand to speak by [6:13:22] tapping the raise your hand [6:13:23] icon or if you are a call in [6:13:25] participant start nine We will [6:13:27] begin with in-person knowledge [6:13:30] and public comment. [6:13:34] Jacob Lewis Edwards I don't [6:13:36] think he's still here so I'll [6:13:39] go to the next person allegedly [6:13:44] Order Please come forward. [6:13:45] You have two minutes to speak. [6:13:45] Okay. [6:13:58] We we go. [6:14:01] Can you start my time over? [6:14:03] Thanks. [6:14:04] Yeah. [6:14:04] You guys are funny with this [6:14:05] drug stuff. [6:14:06] You're like we're going to [6:14:07] fight the war on drugs by [6:14:08] heavily regulating the drugs [6:14:12] make an extremely difficult for [6:14:13] all those people. [6:14:14] Who were you know wrongly [6:14:17] charged any who And it's funny [6:14:18] to be talking about drugs while [6:14:19] we have people who are [6:14:22] whistleblowing against [6:14:23] the government like some are [6:14:26] Stephan And the things that are [6:14:27] going on in the jails at Las [6:14:31] Colinas and their brutal [6:14:33] assault from that Andrea Ebbing [6:14:35] with Anthony Warner totally [6:14:37] slammed her face into [6:14:38] the ground and he's playing [6:14:40] the victim. [6:14:40] He's like six, six three and [6:14:44] 260 pounds said she was really [6:14:46] posturing any who So they have [6:14:49] done a competency evaluation [6:14:52] because you know in order to [6:14:53] silence somebody you got to [6:14:54] really question their [6:14:56] competency. [6:14:57] So then as long as you ask them [6:14:59] some political questions and [6:15:00] the person doing the evaluation [6:15:02] things that you're I don't know [6:15:05] maybe a conspiracy theorist [6:15:06] then they'll say that your [6:15:07] incompetent So how cool is [6:15:10] that? [6:15:10] I mean she's got felony charges [6:15:12] from you know, supposedly [6:15:14] barring Anthony Warner who you [6:15:15] know, can still shoot his [6:15:16] firearm but has to take time [6:15:19] off of work because his hand is [6:15:20] so injured. [6:15:22] But it's just interesting to [6:15:24] see the lengths that people [6:15:25] will go to silence people. [6:15:27] So I mean imagine she might go [6:15:29] into a mental hospital for like [6:15:31] two years. [6:15:32] Who knows? [6:15:33] And then eventually, you know, [6:15:34] if somebody deems her competent [6:15:35] she might be able to face these [6:15:37] charges. [6:15:39] Right. [6:15:39] And right now she's in on two [6:15:41] misdemeanors. [6:15:42] She's out on a felony. [6:15:43] You know, she had her brain [6:15:44] aneurysm. [6:15:45] No worries there. [6:15:47] She might need some more [6:15:48] surgery while she's in there. [6:15:49] She already had to go to [6:15:50] the hospital because they can't [6:15:52] take care of her. [6:15:53] >> But good job isn't that cool [6:15:55] when you're exposing stuff and [6:15:57] they say you're incompetent [6:15:58] should be really exciting. [6:16:01] >> The job. [6:16:02] Thank you. [6:16:03] Blair Beekman followed by Bob [6:16:05] Kozinski, Anthony Ralphs, Lori [6:16:11] Saldana, Marco Espinosa and [6:16:11] Terry Best High by Beekman [6:16:14] Thanks. [6:16:20] A report back on Andrea's which [6:16:23] is that where she's at? [6:16:24] I think she's passing her [6:16:25] competency test so Oh I'm not [6:16:29] hearing the story right If [6:16:30] she's going down again she was [6:16:31] up before and now it's down and [6:16:33] it's just amazing she has to go [6:16:35] through all of this. [6:16:37] I mean I really hope that can [6:16:38] be a real effort to be working [6:16:41] on this issue And overall [6:16:44] issues of how our police work, [6:16:45] how our immune systems are [6:16:47] working. [6:16:48] Good luck in those efforts. [6:16:49] I wanted to ask also how [6:16:52] the just I made a point You [6:16:57] know, I was I was late to learn [6:16:59] that the new Good Day Centers [6:17:01] is probably going to be closing [6:17:02] in six months time And I think [6:17:05] we have to make a concerted [6:17:06] effort to talk about our [6:17:09] homeless issues more in [6:17:10] the coming year, how we do that [6:17:12] and a more sensitivity in that [6:17:14] department. [6:17:15] And so I was really hurt in [6:17:17] the presentation being [6:17:19] dismissed today. [6:17:20] I think we have to make that [6:17:22] extra effort at this time and I [6:17:24] hope we can. [6:17:25] So good luck how we can. [6:17:27] I also wanted to offer at this [6:17:30] time I'm giving my tech academy [6:17:33] a bit of a break tonight and [6:17:35] just consider you know [6:17:36] the ideas I brought up before [6:17:39] about budget issues that we can [6:17:41] still work on budget issues at [6:17:43] this time And the idea of as a [6:17:47] very small cut in pay to our [6:17:49] city government staff if that's [6:17:53] 3000 people at least if they [6:17:56] take a cut of say $600 a year [6:18:00] that's 50 bucks a month. [6:18:01] I think that's over almost $2 [6:18:03] million in savings that can go [6:18:06] to the budget and that's not [6:18:07] including our city council And [6:18:09] Mayor, what they can take on [6:18:12] that's a lot of money and I [6:18:14] hope we want to consider such [6:18:16] things. [6:18:17] >> Good luck You can Thank you. [6:18:19] Thank you. [6:18:20] Bob Kozinski So video okay. [6:18:43] Okay Bob because there's a week [6:18:43] ago today I was hang gliding at [6:18:45] Dockweiler State Beach in Los [6:18:46] Angeles under the Dockweiler [6:18:48] waiver that has been in place [6:18:49] since 2017 the public has been [6:18:52] able to hang glider at [6:18:53] Dockweiler Beach for nearly ten [6:18:54] years under that waiver a [6:18:56] decade ago. [6:18:57] However, hang gliding at [6:18:58] Dockweiler was not allowed by [6:18:59] the county of Los Angeles [6:19:01] without use of a membership. [6:19:03] Fortunately that all changed [6:19:04] due to a sequence of events [6:19:06] that started right here in San [6:19:08] Diego On JULY 24th, 2011. [6:19:11] A female student named Shannon [6:19:12] Hamby was taking lessons at [6:19:14] Tori through the city where she [6:19:19] was under radio supervision [6:19:21] when she was flown directly [6:19:22] into the path of another [6:19:23] student. [6:19:24] She crashed and was badly [6:19:26] injured. [6:19:26] I was contacted by Shannon's [6:19:28] lawyer and asked to testify as [6:19:30] an expert witness and I did. [6:19:32] My testimony in SEPTEMBER of [6:19:33] 2014 was solid and the case was [6:19:36] quickly settled in Shannon's [6:19:37] favor for an undisclosed [6:19:39] amount. [6:19:40] Yeshivah ended up losing their [6:19:41] insurance coverage by NOVEMBER [6:19:43] of 2014. [6:19:44] I was retaliated against by [6:19:46] your concessionaire who [6:19:48] conspired with you spend [6:19:49] the spring of 2015 to have me [6:19:51] expelled for my testimony which [6:19:53] ended my ability to fly at all [6:19:55] use for sites including Torrey [6:19:57] Pines and Dockweiler In early [6:19:59] 2017 we met with newly elected [6:20:01] Barbara Bree for help. [6:20:03] Barbara Bree suggested a flight [6:20:04] waiver to solve the problem but [6:20:06] she never followed through. [6:20:09] Joe Foust and I also spoke to [6:20:10] the Los Angeles County Board of [6:20:12] Supervisors while Barbara Bree [6:20:14] did nothing here in San Diego, [6:20:16] Los Angeles Supervisor Janice [6:20:18] Hahn stepped up and actually [6:20:20] instituted a waiver. [6:20:21] The first DR. Weiler waivers [6:20:23] were issued to Joe Foust, Frank [6:20:25] Culver and myself on JULY 26th, [6:20:28] 2017 and we have flown under [6:20:31] those waivers without incident [6:20:32] ever since Barbara Bree dodged [6:20:34] the issue for the rest of her [6:20:35] term until her failed mayoral [6:20:37] bid in 2020. [6:20:38] Joe LaCava has followed her [6:20:40] lead throughout his entire term [6:20:42] reactivate the Torrey Pines [6:20:44] City Park Advisory Board and [6:20:45] Institute a Torrey Pines flight [6:20:47] waiver now Thank you. [6:20:49] >> Thank you. [6:20:49] >> Our next speaker is Anthony [6:20:57] Ralphs. [6:21:05] Good afternoon City Council. [6:21:07] I just wanted to speak about [6:21:09] the concern that I have and [6:21:10] hearing the expressed financial [6:21:12] concerns earlier today. [6:21:14] Miss Campbell who is no longer [6:21:15] here expressed the $3 million [6:21:17] concern that she had with [6:21:19] the study that was done for [6:21:21] the Phase two project for sdi [6:21:25] And she thought that the $3 [6:21:26] million was too much, that [6:21:27] these studies are costing [6:21:28] the city too much. [6:21:31] I have a real difficulty in [6:21:33] understanding how she can on [6:21:35] one hand have fine problems [6:21:37] with the costs of the studies [6:21:39] that cost $3 million to help us [6:21:42] potentially get off of a [6:21:43] monopoly that's making $1 [6:21:46] billion of profit every year. [6:21:47] But she doesn't raise a single [6:21:49] point with the fact that [6:21:52] the police budget the public [6:21:54] liability fund has exceeded [6:21:56] over $116 million in the last [6:22:00] ten years or that this year [6:22:02] alone it's already exceeded $42 [6:22:04] million and we're not even [6:22:06] finished with all [6:22:07] the settlements. [6:22:07] I have not heard the side of [6:22:11] the city that does not address [6:22:12] these issues as as Henry Foster [6:22:14] has expressed before and [6:22:16] multiple times in this chambers [6:22:17] he said this is the tale of two [6:22:19] cities And he's right. [6:22:20] We do have one half of this [6:22:22] city council that understands [6:22:24] and respects our privacy [6:22:25] concerns, that understands and [6:22:27] respects that we are not [6:22:30] property of the state to be [6:22:32] tracked in our whereabouts of [6:22:34] where we go that understands in [6:22:37] the Supreme Court's recent [6:22:38] ruling that we have freedom in [6:22:42] the whole totality of our [6:22:43] movement Although the roads are [6:22:46] owned yes by the city and [6:22:49] therefore yes y'all do have [6:22:51] jurisdiction over the city's [6:22:53] roads. [6:22:54] We own our own personal [6:22:56] sovereignty over our own bodies [6:22:58] And there are cities that are [6:23:01] being sued including I believe [6:23:05] it is Santa Monica No Santa [6:23:05] Clara. [6:23:07] >> Thank you for your time. [6:23:09] Thank you. [6:23:10] We're next. [6:23:10] Lori Saldana. [6:23:19] >> Good evening and thank you [6:23:20] to those of you who are [6:23:22] actually still here and some of [6:23:23] you are maybe even paying [6:23:25] attention. [6:23:25] I just got off of a Zoom [6:23:28] meeting with the Democratic [6:23:29] Club and one of the council [6:23:31] members who's not here tonight [6:23:33] was in that meeting. [6:23:34] So I'm not sure where [6:23:35] the priorities are but it's a [6:23:37] little concerning to me when [6:23:38] you have discussions on issues [6:23:40] that are important to this body [6:23:42] and people leave early and then [6:23:44] end up at another engagement [6:23:45] elsewhere. [6:23:46] You're you're concerned about [6:23:48] the impacts on public health [6:23:50] and safety and giving [6:23:51] the private right of action to [6:23:52] others in certain industry. [6:23:55] And I just want to suggest that [6:23:56] there's another industry in [6:23:57] town that has serious impacts [6:23:59] on public health and safety. [6:24:02] Is it just me or is there [6:24:03] feedback on this tonight? [6:24:05] There's feedback. [6:24:07] >> And if you were to give a [6:24:09] private right of action to [6:24:10] people I think you would go a [6:24:12] long way to closing of several [6:24:14] problems in our city budget and [6:24:16] also our housing. [6:24:17] And of course I'm talking about [6:24:18] short term vacation rentals. [6:24:20] They also lack enforcement. [6:24:22] They also have people operating [6:24:24] without permits. [6:24:25] They also have people putting [6:24:26] lives and safety at risk. [6:24:28] Around the corner from my [6:24:30] house. [6:24:30] There's a short term rental [6:24:32] that has caught on fire that [6:24:34] has flooded raw sewage into [6:24:35] the streets. [6:24:36] And it took me over a year to [6:24:38] get someone to respond. [6:24:40] If I had a private right of [6:24:41] action I could have gone at [6:24:42] them as a property owner [6:24:44] nearby. [6:24:45] Also they don't pay commercial [6:24:46] trash hauling fees. [6:24:48] They pay residential fees and [6:24:49] they're businesses operating in [6:24:51] our neighborhoods. [6:24:52] If you are serious about [6:24:53] private right of action, give [6:24:56] residents who are next door to [6:24:58] short term rentals that are [6:24:59] violating the permitting, [6:25:01] violating health and safety. [6:25:03] And let us go after them [6:25:04] because I promise you they are [6:25:06] not disadvantaged. [6:25:08] They have people that owned [6:25:09] multiple properties that form [6:25:10] consortiums that buy our [6:25:12] properties in Ocean Beach and [6:25:14] elsewhere and push out full [6:25:15] time residential rent renters [6:25:18] and homeowners. [6:25:19] If you want a right of action [6:25:21] apply it to short term rent. [6:25:22] Thank you. [6:25:23] That does conclude your time. [6:25:25] >> Marco Espinosa. [6:25:32] >> Good evening. [6:25:35] My question goes a Boston [6:25:35] Avenue park ideas. [6:25:42] Um the it's not helpful if I [6:25:43] don't have a map for you. [6:25:46] Sorry. [6:25:47] Um, I know we already iterated [6:25:47] the coming onto the freeway [6:25:50] The bollards that first section [6:25:53] of park between the freeway [6:25:55] onramp and the bridge that goes [6:25:57] over the freeway. [6:25:58] I think that could be [6:25:58] the section in the diagram [6:26:03] shows how it's owned. [6:26:05] It doesn't include actually [6:26:07] the walkway. [6:26:08] Um, and the bridge. [6:26:11] Um, so when I got to the park I [6:26:12] was like oh that's something to [6:26:13] consider on Google Maps. [6:26:15] The park actually looks really [6:26:16] small. [6:26:18] Doesn't seem like there's a lot [6:26:18] space but once you get there [6:26:20] quite a lot of space for a park [6:26:22] If it does end up being the um [6:26:23] tennis courts or soccer fields [6:26:27] um in the portion that's like a [6:26:33] longer portion Nothing could [6:26:33] fit there. [6:26:34] That doesn't need to be like a [6:26:35] net or something that goes [6:26:37] along that nice new barrier [6:26:38] wall for the freeway so [6:26:40] eyeballs don't go into [6:26:41] the freeway as cars are going. [6:26:43] And then the second portion of [6:26:47] land use available for park [6:26:52] Right now it's a cycle center. [6:26:54] I remember I heard that [6:26:55] possibly So we chose one second [6:26:59] over which then we left like a [6:27:00] little strip on the side along [6:27:03] Charles Creek and at the creek [6:27:04] was a lot cleaner, a lot nicer. [6:27:05] I mean you can make that into [6:27:06] some kind of little beach kind [6:27:08] of thing but it's a really [6:27:10] dirty water so. [6:27:10] And if the recycle center does [6:27:13] move out and the so be chosen [6:27:16] to move in, that's a huge whole [6:27:19] plot of land for a park that [6:27:21] had a nice and everything. [6:27:22] That would be a lot of fun. [6:27:24] And couple of more that you [6:27:27] measured did not pass but I saw [6:27:29] advertised as 5000 to 5000 but [6:27:31] on the values 8000. [6:27:34] Thank you. [6:27:34] That does conclude your time. [6:27:37] Terry Best Terry Best District [6:27:37] three. [6:27:44] Please stop allowing special [6:27:47] interest to write laws that [6:27:49] create and strengthen [6:27:50] monopolies. [6:27:52] Stop doing the bidding of rich [6:27:54] white men to fund your future [6:27:56] political endeavors. [6:27:58] Stop allowing special interests [6:28:00] using labor to attack those [6:28:03] less fortunate. [6:28:04] This nonsense theme here is [6:28:07] precursory support for your [6:28:09] 2028 mayor campaign and it [6:28:12] looks ugly. [6:28:13] Is that the look you want [6:28:14] further marginalize vulnerable [6:28:16] people? [6:28:18] Again, shame on you MR. Trump. [6:28:23] You. [6:28:24] >> Thank you. [6:28:25] That does conclude in-person [6:28:28] public comment. [6:28:28] I have started the five minute [6:28:29] timer in council chambers. [6:28:31] We will now turn to the virtual [6:28:33] queue in which there are seven [6:28:35] participants requesting to [6:28:37] speak. [6:28:37] We'll begin with Tyrion Skelly. [6:28:39] Please begin. [6:28:44] Good evening San Diego City [6:28:45] Council Chair. [6:28:46] My name is Scully and I work [6:28:49] with my planning group on good [6:28:50] public health and safety [6:28:51] policies and land use [6:28:53] decisions. [6:28:53] Where I live has windy [6:28:56] sometimes rocky roads, [6:28:57] overgrown foliage and some [6:28:59] roads reported that at times [6:29:01] and dangerous when it rains or [6:29:03] is windy as it's been in [6:29:05] the last couple of days. [6:29:07] JUNE is Brain Awareness Month [6:29:09] and I'd like to talk about [6:29:10] the dangers of marijuana and [6:29:12] alcohol impaired drivers. [6:29:14] This is a situation we know [6:29:15] well in our family oriented [6:29:17] neighborhoods with our perilous [6:29:18] roadways. [6:29:19] Recently the Journal of [6:29:21] Adolescent Health article wrote [6:29:23] that marijuana policies [6:29:25] decisions must acknowledge that [6:29:28] access access to an [6:29:29] intoxicating substance that [6:29:31] appeals to young people will [6:29:33] end up causing harm No more. [6:29:35] So then when we drive [6:29:37] the tribute again describe [6:29:38] the conditions of our roadways [6:29:40] and the delays to fix them. [6:29:42] I would like to respectfully [6:29:44] suggest that damaged roadways [6:29:46] combined with drug impaired [6:29:48] driving is one more lawsuit [6:29:51] about to happen? [6:29:53] At least there is one thing you [6:29:55] could do to mitigate that has [6:29:56] been contributing to [6:29:57] the dangerous the dangerous use [6:30:00] of can and cannabis removing [6:30:02] enticing and distracting [6:30:04] marijuana billboards from our [6:30:06] roadways. [6:30:07] Summer 26 would be the perfect [6:30:10] time for policies to happen [6:30:11] that would ban marijuana from [6:30:13] our neighborhood roadways. [6:30:15] Thank you for hearing my [6:30:16] concerns this evening. [6:30:19] Thank you. [6:30:20] Next up Peggy Walker. [6:30:21] Please begin. [6:30:25] Thank you. [6:30:26] Council members Food and gas [6:30:29] prices MAY be high today but [6:30:32] drugs like high potency [6:30:33] marijuana have never been more [6:30:35] affordable or available And [6:30:37] that's reflected in today's [6:30:39] marijuana delivery item [6:30:40] addressed earlier. [6:30:43] In a society seeking [6:30:44] the convenience of home [6:30:46] delivery for just about [6:30:47] everything that item shows [6:30:50] psychotropic drug consumers are [6:30:52] no exception. [6:30:52] And the upshot of that is that [6:30:55] a society where people can get [6:30:57] high so easily it's also less [6:31:00] healthy and that's reasonable. [6:31:02] That truth was put forth in a [6:31:04] recent New York Times article [6:31:06] headlined It Shouldn't Be This [6:31:08] Easy to Get High And so many of [6:31:11] us parents agree. [6:31:13] Citing the fact that 48 million [6:31:14] Americans are addicted to an [6:31:16] intoxicant like marijuana, [6:31:18] the Times suggests we should be [6:31:20] making it easier for people to [6:31:22] get help rather than get high. [6:31:25] A straightforward way to curb a [6:31:29] particularly uptick in use and [6:31:30] its outcomes of poor physical [6:31:32] and mental health and [6:31:33] addiction. [6:31:36] The proposals it's higher [6:31:37] taxation on marijuana reasoning [6:31:40] that people sicker less when [6:31:41] something's more costly. [6:31:44] With that in mind I ask your [6:31:46] consideration of increased [6:31:48] taxes for all marijuana [6:31:49] products. [6:31:50] However results are delivered [6:31:53] and more transparent reporting [6:31:55] of how much in taxes for [6:31:58] marijuana is being collected [6:32:01] and transfer nc and how they're [6:32:02] being used by the city. [6:32:04] Thank you for that [6:32:05] consideration. [6:32:09] Thank you. [6:32:10] Next up is Judith Strain. [6:32:12] Please begin. [6:32:15] >> Good evening San Diego City [6:32:16] Council. [6:32:17] I appreciate that you've stated [6:32:18] that doesn't go unnoticed by [6:32:20] the public when you make those [6:32:21] sorts of sacrifices. [6:32:23] I want to speak to a [6:32:24] terminology that we're seeing [6:32:25] in public health more and more [6:32:27] and that is called gas station [6:32:30] heroin. [6:32:31] It's kind of used as a catchall [6:32:32] terminology for gas station [6:32:35] intoxicants but we now see [6:32:36] those products still available [6:32:38] to our young people. [6:32:40] They include in their often [6:32:42] sort of spotlight kratom. [6:32:44] They're also including what's [6:32:46] called magic mushrooms not I'm [6:32:48] sorry nitrous oxide and other [6:32:52] products that contain high thc [6:32:56] in hiding under cbd products. [6:32:58] I just mention it because [6:33:00] the terminology is getting used [6:33:03] more and more about where our [6:33:05] children buy these items at gas [6:33:08] stations which right at the top [6:33:08] of the list and the number of [6:33:10] gas stations in the city of San [6:33:12] Diego. [6:33:12] One can only guess And if we [6:33:14] were to enforce the laws [6:33:16] against these products here in [6:33:18] our city, just think of [6:33:19] the amount of money that we [6:33:20] could bring in. [6:33:22] So as you hear the terminology [6:33:23] gas station heroin and realize [6:33:26] that they're talking about all [6:33:27] the intoxicants that are now [6:33:29] portable at gas stations, I [6:33:31] think what we could do to at [6:33:33] least stop it by enforcement [6:33:35] and gather up from them they [6:33:39] find that come with it. [6:33:40] Boy, it could be a double win [6:33:42] for everybody. [6:33:43] >> Thank you. [6:33:46] >> Please note that the five [6:33:47] minute timer has concluded with [6:33:49] four speakers left in [6:33:51] the queue. [6:33:51] No other speakers will be taken [6:33:52] at this time. [6:33:55] Next up Phyllis. [6:33:57] Please begin. [6:34:04] Phyllis, please On the air. [6:34:14] I can assure you Phyllis I can [6:34:26] on mute for you. [6:34:26] We're going to move on. [6:34:32] Okay. [6:34:33] Next up, Becky Wrap. [6:34:45] Please begin. [6:34:45] Good evening. [6:34:46] I need a second rapid increase [6:34:50] in my concerns about [6:34:51] transparency and [6:34:52] accountability. [6:34:53] In San Diego, the marijuana [6:34:54] marijuana permitting program [6:34:57] almost seven years ago, [6:34:58] the rich Bernardo community [6:35:00] engaged extensively in [6:35:02] the public process for [6:35:03] the original marijuana [6:35:05] application. [6:35:06] Residents attended hearings, [6:35:07] submitted written comments and [6:35:09] with strong concern about this [6:35:11] being a pot shop in their [6:35:13] neighborhood. [6:35:14] But what has happened since [6:35:15] that approval is basically [6:35:17] invisible to the public. [6:35:19] That original permit has now [6:35:21] changed hands multiple times. [6:35:22] The operator that the community [6:35:24] initially evaluated is no [6:35:26] longer the operator today. [6:35:28] Ownership has shifted through [6:35:29] acquisitions and corporate [6:35:30] transactions and now [6:35:32] the business is associated with [6:35:33] a brand called Lake House. [6:35:36] Residents were never notified [6:35:37] of these changes. [6:35:38] There were no public hearings, [6:35:39] no neighborhood notices and no [6:35:41] requirement for the city to [6:35:42] explain who ultimately controls [6:35:43] these permits. [6:35:45] The community was fully engaged [6:35:46] in the original decision but it [6:35:49] has been in the dark for years [6:35:51] since. [6:35:51] That raises a transparency [6:35:53] question. [6:35:54] If public input is required to [6:35:56] approve a pot shop, why is [6:35:58] there no transparency when that [6:36:00] same permit is sold or [6:36:01] transferred to an entirely [6:36:03] different company multiple [6:36:05] times? [6:36:06] The operator behind the permit [6:36:08] is not a minor detail. [6:36:10] It speaks to accountability, [6:36:12] business practices and [6:36:13] the enforcement history. [6:36:14] It also raises concerns about [6:36:16] branding and public perception [6:36:19] and the like. [6:36:20] The House does not communicate [6:36:22] to the public that this [6:36:23] business will be selling highly [6:36:25] intoxicating products. [6:36:27] Rather the message it sends is [6:36:29] that our being now has a new [6:36:30] bakery in town. [6:36:32] This is unacceptable and [6:36:33] communities deserve to know who [6:36:35] is operating in their [6:36:36] neighborhoods not just at [6:36:38] the moment of approval but [6:36:39] throughout the entire life of a [6:36:41] permit. [6:36:42] Thank you. [6:36:44] Thank you. [6:36:46] Next, John Elway. [6:36:48] Please begin. [6:36:53] Hi John. [6:36:54] You have lived experience [6:36:55] advisors so my team and I went [6:36:57] through all the press articles [6:36:59] and were in attendance or [6:37:02] listening to the majority of [6:37:04] the budget meetings and we [6:37:08] started to find out that [6:37:09] the city is not only funding [6:37:12] the partial operation over at [6:37:15] the new Good data center but [6:37:18] that you are licensing it [6:37:20] meaning that nobody could go [6:37:21] ahead and or and fill in [6:37:23] the money or or move in and [6:37:27] operate that separately from [6:37:29] the existing provider. [6:37:31] I can't believe after all [6:37:34] the work we've done building [6:37:35] relationships that nobody had [6:37:36] the courtesy to say that Well [6:37:39] actually I probably should [6:37:40] believe it because obviously it [6:37:43] was hidden from the public. [6:37:45] The fact that you were taking [6:37:46] away the only place that [6:37:48] homeless people could go in [6:37:50] the entire city and not be [6:37:53] addressed at least from 9 to 5 [6:37:55] for a few days a week. [6:37:57] I'd like to understand how this [6:38:00] decision occurred and was that [6:38:02] included in the budget [6:38:03] resolution? [6:38:05] >> Thank you. [6:38:08] Thank you. [6:38:09] Next our last caller is caller [6:38:12] with the last four digits 8700 [6:38:15] please begin. [6:38:20] Thank you. [6:38:22] First of all, Joy Senator a [6:38:24] first of all, a big thank you [6:38:26] and five stars for [6:38:28] the performance by our deputy [6:38:31] city clerk. [6:38:33] Thank you so much And the next [6:38:39] PRESIDENT For your humor was [6:38:40] present today. [6:38:42] Thank you. [6:38:43] Thank you. [6:38:43] I really enjoyed that. [6:38:45] And then a request from MR. [6:38:48] Stump. [6:38:49] I'm wondering if you could [6:38:51] during the public comment give [6:38:53] the public his nine step plan [6:38:56] for fda and that sounds [6:38:59] interesting. [6:39:01] Next I want to speak to [6:39:03] the gentleman who used the word [6:39:07] union bust and I felt his anger [6:39:10] in those words. [6:39:14] I respect that anger. [6:39:18] Next, I love the boldness and [6:39:21] the fight that was present in [6:39:23] the chamber today. [6:39:24] Did you feel the beautiful [6:39:27] tapestry of all the people to [6:39:31] be There was a little bit like [6:39:36] what we feel when we say one [6:39:38] people, one family, one San [6:39:41] Diego I'm going to get to this [6:39:42] tomorrow. [6:39:43] Look forward to that. [6:39:45] But to all. [6:39:48] Thank you. [6:39:48] This concludes lunch and [6:39:49] the public comment. [6:39:51] All right. [6:39:51] You can catch me at The Late [6:39:53] Show at the Comedy Club later [6:39:54] tonight. [6:39:54] With that, does the city [6:39:56] attorney have anything to [6:39:58] report out in closed session? [6:40:02] There is nothing to report. [6:40:03] All right. [6:40:03] Thank you. [6:40:05] With that we will now turn [6:40:05] counsel to the regularly [6:40:07] scheduled council meeting [6:40:07] tomorrow, Tuesday, JUNE 23rd, [6:40:08] 2026 at 10 A.M. Or shortly [6:40:08] thereafter.