[3:04] the. [3:04] >> All right. [3:05] Good morning And I will now [3:05] call the city council meeting [3:06] on Monday, JUNE 29th, 2026 to [3:09] order Clerk please call [3:10] the roll. [3:10] Thank you. [3:11] Council PRESIDENT Council [3:12] member Campbell Council Member [3:14] Whitburn Council Member Foster [3:17] Council Member Von Wilpert [3:20] Council PRESIDENT Pro Timely I [3:27] Apologies Council Member [3:27] Campion here Council Member [3:28] Moreno Council Member Ellen [3:31] Rivera and Council PRESIDENT [3:32] LaCava present also attending [3:36] the meeting our city Attorney [3:37] Heather Ferber, independent [3:38] budget analyst Charles Monaco [3:40] and myself your city Clerk [3:41] Diana Fuentes. [3:42] Thank you Council PRESIDENT All [3:43] right, thank you. [3:44] A quorum is now present. [3:45] We will begin this morning with [3:46] an invocation by Clark Winters [3:48] followed with [3:49] the acknowledgment and [3:50] the Pledge of Allegiance led by [3:51] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee [3:57] Grant. [3:57] Those who hold office in this [3:59] city, the spirit of wisdom, [4:01] charity and justice that was [4:03] steadfast purpose. [4:04] They MAY faithfully serve in [4:05] their offices to promote [4:06] the well-being of all people. [4:09] >> We respectfully acknowledge [4:11] the nation or the original [4:12] inhabitants of the Unceded land [4:14] Now known as San Diego. [4:15] Despite enduring the horrors of [4:17] genocide and colonization, [4:17] the community spirit remains [4:18] and broken. [4:20] We honor the resilience of [4:21] their ancestors who fought to [4:22] protect their culture and land. [4:24] Today they carry their legacy [4:25] forward ensuring that their [4:27] traditions continue to thrive [4:28] in gratitude and strength. [4:30] We stand with committed nation [4:31] connected to our past and [4:33] committed to a thriving future. [4:35] Please raise a flag and join me [4:37] in the Pledge of Allegiance But [4:38] begin I pledge allegiance to [4:41] the flag of the United States [4:43] of America and to the Republic [4:45] for which it stands one nation [4:47] under GOD, indivisible with [4:56] liberty and justice for all. [4:56] >> And with that, Clark, please [4:58] go over how the public can [4:59] offer their testimony. [5:00] Thank you. [5:00] Council PRESIDENT I'd like to [5:01] highlight the slide on [5:02] the screen that reviews how [5:03] the public can offer their [5:04] public testimony during today's [5:05] meeting. [5:06] If you are located in person [5:07] please complete the speaker [5:08] slip. [5:09] Please note that no further [5:11] in-person testimony will be [5:11] taken once the Council begins [5:12] virtual testimony for a better [5:14] meeting management purposes [5:15] each speaker will have one [5:16] minute per item per person. [5:18] If you're joining us remotely [5:19] please be sure to raise your [5:20] hand now for closed session [5:21] items by pressing Star nine or [5:23] the raise your hand icon. [5:24] >> Thank you Council PRESIDENT. [5:25] All right. [5:26] Thank you. [5:26] With that please read [5:27] the closed session item into [5:28] the record. [5:29] Conference with Labor [5:30] Negotiators pursuant to [5:31] California Government Code [5:32] Section 54957.661 City [5:36] Designated Management Team [5:37] representatives. [5:39] >> All right. [5:40] And with that please proceed [5:41] with public comment. [5:42] There is no public comment here [5:45] in council chambers going to [5:45] those participating remotely. [5:47] Blair Beckman, if you can [5:48] please limit. [5:49] There is one item in the closed [5:53] session so you'll have one [5:54] minute. [5:54] >> Please proceed. [5:56] Hi. [5:56] Thank you. [5:57] Blair Bateman. [5:58] At the end of JUNE everyone I [6:03] speak to is a JUNE. [6:04] I wanted to comment with this [6:05] kind of item and the many Union [6:08] City government union worker [6:10] groups involved with this item [6:10] . [6:12] It usually signifies some sort [6:14] of labor talk but I mean I [6:16] guess for this item you're [6:17] going to speak specifically to [6:18] police actions working with [6:20] the police review Commission. [6:23] Thanks and good luck. [6:24] What You can be decided [6:25] together. [6:25] We are really trying to build a [6:27] future of the police review [6:30] body as cold and we keep [6:34] sputtering a bit. [6:35] I keep praying that the powers [6:38] that be in San Diego can be of [6:42] some help that you know, I [6:43] think we're trying to reach out [6:44] and develop a relationship with [6:47] esdp. [6:48] Good luck with that can mean [6:49] and what you talk about and how [6:51] it can be an accountable [6:52] process for all of us and that [6:54] we want to trust each other and [6:56] what we talk and work on and [6:57] work towards in the street. [7:01] That does conclude your time. [7:03] 8700 If you can please unmute. [7:06] There's one item on the agenda [7:07] You'll have a minute. [7:08] Please proceed. [7:11] Oh excuse me Joy. [7:12] It's an item. [7:14] This is my opinion. [7:16] I find it interesting that [7:19] the sd pd wants less [7:21] surveillance use of [7:23] miscellaneous and the public c [7:26] p p wants more surveillance use [7:29] of investigations. [7:31] Therefore in labor negotiations [7:34] on proposed operating [7:36] procedures the balance [7:39] the sweet spot will be what is [7:42] enough Investigating and more [7:45] is enough Miscellaneous This [7:47] will build more trust on [7:50] the public officer definition I [7:53] am guided by Article b of [7:56] the Charter Section 41.2 So [8:00] I'll say this It's City Council [8:03] call. [8:04] Thank you for listening. [8:05] It's going to be a beautiful [8:06] day and a beautiful week. [8:07] Love you all. [8:08] >> Thank you. [8:09] That does conclude public [8:10] comment on this closed session [8:12] agenda. [8:13] >> All right. [8:13] Thank you, city Clerk. [8:14] And with that we will now [8:15] recess in the closed session [8:16] and reconvene council today at [14:43] the. [14:43] >> All right. [14:43] Good afternoon. [14:44] I will now reconvene the city [14:45] council meeting on Monday, JUNE [14:46] 29th, 2026. [14:48] Clerk Please call the roll. [14:50] Thank you. [14:50] Council PRESIDENT Council [14:51] Member Campbell Council Member [14:54] Whitburn Council Member Foster [14:59] Council Member Von Millburn [15:01] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee. [15:02] Council Member Can you hear [15:07] Council Member present Council [15:08] Member Ella Rivera and Council [15:11] PRESIDENT Look I also thank [15:14] the meeting our Assistant City [15:14] Attorney Leslie Fitzgerald, [15:16] independent budget analyst [15:17] Charles Monica and myself your [15:19] city Clerk Diana Fuentes. [15:20] Thank you Council PRESIDENT All [15:22] right, thank you. [15:22] A quorum is now present. [15:24] So let's start off by asking is [15:26] there any comments from [15:27] the mayor's office? [15:30] Council members So the attorney [15:30] independent journalist or city [15:31] clerk I don't see anything. [15:33] We'll move right along. [15:34] So please go over how [15:35] the public can offer their [15:37] testimony. [15:38] Thank you. [15:38] Council PRESIDENT I'd like to [15:39] highlight the slide on [15:40] the screen that reviews how [15:41] the public can offer their [15:41] public testimony during this [15:43] afternoon's meeting. [15:45] The order can be found on [15:46] the agenda summary found online [15:47] or at the table in the back of [15:49] the room. [15:49] If you are in person please [15:50] complete the speaker slip [15:51] located at the entrance of [15:52] chambers and bring it to [15:54] the front of the room into [15:55] the clear box. [15:56] Council ambassadors are [15:57] available near the entrance of [15:59] chambers and can assist with [16:00] questions and speakers Lips No [16:02] for the person No further [16:04] in-person testimony will be [16:05] taken once the council begins [16:07] Virtual testimony. [16:08] Thank you Council PRESIDENT All [16:09] right. [16:10] Thank you for that. [16:10] And as you slowly make your way [16:13] down we'll have our deputy [16:15] clerk Please introduce item or [16:17] one item As for one. [16:20] Information guide on group [16:21] participation updates and [16:23] council determination of [16:24] community engagement efforts. [16:27] >> All right. [16:30] So it looks like you're settled [16:30] in. [16:31] Please enter your yourself for [16:32] the record and let us know what [16:33] time you need for your [16:34] presentation. [16:35] Thank you. [16:35] Council PRESIDENT. [16:36] Good afternoon Council [16:37] PRESIDENT And members of [16:38] the city council as well as [16:40] those joining me here in-person [16:42] and online. [16:43] My name is Deanna Fuentes and I [16:44] am your city clerk. [16:46] I will need ten minutes for my [16:48] presentation. [16:49] All right. [16:49] When you're ready. [16:50] I'm pleased to present an [16:52] overview of the recent [16:53] initiatives aimed at expanding [16:54] access to local government and [16:56] compliance with sb 7o7 which [16:59] we've all heard a lot about [17:01] today We are reviewing ongoing [17:02] proactive efforts to engage [17:04] communities that do not [17:06] traditionally participate in [17:07] our public meetings. [17:08] And our core goal is to remove [17:11] barriers so that every San [17:13] Diego feels empowered to have [17:14] their voice heard in this [17:16] chamber. [17:17] At the heart of this initiative [17:19] is our department's mission to [17:21] provide accurate information [17:22] and maximize public access to [17:24] municipal government. [17:26] But we know traditional [17:27] notification methods don't work [17:29] for everyone, especially [17:30] historically underserved [17:32] populations. [17:33] To break those barriers down we [17:35] didn't just push information [17:36] out. [17:36] We went out into the community [17:38] to listen. [17:39] We conducted four public [17:40] listening sessions across [17:42] districts one, seven and eight [17:44] alongside a citywide survey [17:45] that ran from OCTOBER 2025 [17:47] through MARCH 2026. [17:50] We also engage with residents [17:51] at community events and [17:53] meetings in districts three, [17:54] four, eight and nine. [17:56] Now what did our residents tell [17:57] us? [17:58] Their feedback fell into clear [18:00] themes They want simpler [18:01] website navigation more visible [18:03] public comment links plain [18:06] language summaries of our [18:07] complex agendas and expanded [18:09] translation services. [18:12] They also noted that a simple [18:13] lack of awareness and [18:14] scheduling conflicts often [18:16] stand in their way. [18:18] The direct community feedback [18:19] is what helped shape some of [18:21] the operational improvements we [18:22] are presenting today. [18:25] So we took that feedback and [18:27] immediately translated it into [18:29] action on the language and [18:30] digital access front. [18:32] Thanks to Panda's web team we [18:34] have updated our website to be [18:37] week 2.1 compliant for better [18:38] ada accessibility. [18:40] We also revamped our How to [18:42] Participate web page making [18:43] critical information available [18:46] and not just our primary [18:47] alternative languages but [18:49] thanks to our city's new auto [18:52] translation 22 languages [18:53] overall. [18:54] You will now see the English [18:56] and Spanish language agendas [18:57] featured prominently on the San [18:59] Diego Doc website as well. [19:01] Near the top we have [19:03] streamlined our agenda [19:05] formatting using plain language [19:07] principles and even added a [19:08] dedicated legislative glossary [19:10] directly onto the council [19:12] agenda. [19:12] So government jargon isn't a [19:14] barrier to participation. [19:16] Physically we've distributed [19:18] education materials to nearly [19:20] 200 neighborhood locations over [19:23] 200 neighborhood locations [19:25] including libraries or [19:27] recreation centers, cultural [19:29] markets and faith based [19:30] organizations and other [19:32] community hubs such as [19:33] laundromats and latrines across [19:35] all nine districts. [19:38] And looking ahead to JULY or [19:39] just next week's agenda, [19:41] the council PRESIDENT Is [19:42] launching anticipated time [19:43] allotments on the agenda to [19:45] help residents better plan [19:47] their participated around their [19:47] participation around busy [19:50] schedules. [19:51] And we are officially launching [19:53] our new organized presentation [19:55] process on JULY 1st as adopted [19:57] by the city Council. [20:00] So what is an organized [20:01] presentation? [20:02] Let's dive into that new tool. [20:04] This is an equity improvement [20:06] adopted by the City Council to [20:08] empower community groups to be [20:10] income and to be in compliance [20:11] with sb 707. [20:13] Essentially an organized [20:14] presentation allows a [20:16] coordinated group of two or [20:17] more individuals to share a [20:19] unified position to speak [20:21] collectively or choose a lead [20:23] speaker for an allocated block [20:25] of time during a meeting. [20:26] This applies especially [20:28] specifically to discussion or [20:30] informational items listed on [20:33] our agenda. [20:34] This replaces the old [20:35] traditional practice of seating [20:37] time which was restricted [20:39] exclusively to those who could [20:41] show up in person. [20:42] This new format equitably [20:46] extends the exact same [20:47] collective presentation [20:49] opportunity and the ability to [20:51] share PowerPoint presentations [20:52] or other ab two hour online and [20:56] virtual participants. [20:57] Leveling the playing field for [20:59] working families or homebound [21:01] residents. [21:03] We've designed the digital [21:05] submission framework to be as [21:06] intuitive and streamlined as [21:08] possible. [21:08] It breaks down into three [21:10] simple steps for the community. [21:12] Step one is to review [21:14] the agenda. [21:14] Groups must identify [21:16] the specific item number or [21:17] numbers that matter to them and [21:19] look over the accompanying [21:20] staff reports and allocated [21:22] time per person for that item [21:25] that is listed on the agenda. [21:26] Step two is to submit [21:28] the online sign up web form. [21:30] The group's designated lead [21:32] presenter can fill out the form [21:34] at San diego.Gov/presentation. [21:37] This must be done at least 24 [21:39] hours in advance of [21:40] the scheduled meeting so our [21:42] staff can verify the details. [21:44] Step three is to submit [21:46] materials if the group wants to [21:48] use visual or audio aids like a [21:50] PowerPoint presentation. [21:51] They can upload them right [21:52] along with the sign up form or [21:54] use a follow up link emailed to [21:56] them at sign up. [21:57] They must submit them no later [21:59] than two hours before [22:01] the meeting starts. [22:02] So for city council meetings [22:03] that would be Monday and [22:06] Tuesday depending on when [22:08] the item is scheduled for. [22:11] To ensure that a seamless user [22:15] experience there is a seamless [22:17] user experience we've [22:18] integrated these tools right [22:20] into the active areas of [22:22] the city's existing web portal. [22:23] When residents visit the main [22:25] page San diego.Gov the Council [22:28] Agenda portal or the City [22:30] Clerk's Web page such as are [22:32] main San Diego slash City Clerk [22:34] or San Diego slash L.A. Or [22:37] the legislative calendar you'll [22:39] be able to see it prominently [22:40] displayed and updated headers [22:42] with direct links to public [22:45] comment and organize [22:46] presentations. [22:47] We have also placed comment [22:48] button public comment buttons [22:51] and clear links to [22:52] the dedicated group [22:53] presentations portal. [22:54] Right alongside the standard [22:56] individual comment options this [22:58] means the community member [22:59] doesn't have to hunt their [23:00] pages of text just to figure [23:02] out how to participate. [23:04] The link is also going to be on [23:06] the agenda just as public [23:07] comment is today when the lead [23:11] presenter clicks through to San [23:13] Diego Taco presentation. [23:14] They are brought to this [23:16] dedicated sign up interface. [23:17] The system prompts them to [23:20] select the meet the specific [23:22] meeting body which can be [23:24] the city council meeting or any [23:26] of the committee agendas. [23:28] The system then prompts them to [23:30] select the specific meeting [23:33] date which I'll just give Kevin [23:36] a moment to bring up the actual [23:38] website. [23:39] Here it is. [23:39] So you would see meeting body [23:43] then click the calendar date [23:45] and then input the exact agenda [23:49] item number. [23:49] You can also input the agenda [23:52] item name so that they can give [23:54] us a clue as to what item you [23:56] are. [23:56] If sometimes the item number [23:58] gets missed input and it [24:01] further has them read and check [24:03] the acknowledgments to ensure [24:05] everyone understands the rules [24:06] of the road and we are managing [24:09] expectations. [24:10] Most importantly this is where [24:12] they enter their participant [24:13] roster and upload their slides [24:16] behind the scenes. [24:17] The entire web interface [24:18] features full in translations [24:21] appear to match our city's [24:22] language access goal ensuring [24:24] that language is never a [24:26] barrier to organizing a group [24:27] presentation. [24:30] If you can go up to the top up [24:31] Kevin and then just show [24:33] the language in the language [24:42] translation I can choose any [24:43] language and it will change [24:45] the form to be in any of the 22 [24:47] languages there. [24:48] Thank you. [24:50] We'll go back to our PowerPoint [24:52] presentation to keep our [24:57] council meetings moving [24:58] efficiently. [24:59] The program relies on the lead [25:01] presenter. [25:01] This individual serves as [25:03] the primary operational link [25:05] between the community group or [25:07] a group that wishes to present [25:08] and the clerk's office. [25:09] The lead presenter handles [25:11] the logistics. [25:12] They make sure everyone in [25:13] their group understands [25:14] the rules and they sign off on [25:16] the formal ignore [25:17] acknowledgments during [25:18] registration. [25:18] When the agenda item is finally [25:21] called in the council chambers [25:22] it's the lead presenters job to [25:24] verify that all listed members [25:27] are present and know how to [25:29] raise their hands either [25:30] physically here in the room or [25:32] digitally on the virtual [25:33] meeting platform so that [25:35] the clerk can accurately verify [25:37] attendance just as we do today [25:39] with seating time. [25:40] Now to ensure fairness and [25:42] transparency for all speakers. [25:43] There are established clear [25:45] structure time rules. [25:47] First a group must have a [25:49] minimum of two individuals and [25:51] the total speaking time for any [25:52] single organized presentation [25:54] is capped at 15 minutes to [25:56] ensure proper meeting [25:57] management. [25:58] How do we calculate the time? [26:00] We multiply the number of [26:02] verified present group speakers [26:04] by the standard time allocated [26:06] per person for that specific [26:08] item on the agenda. [26:09] For example, if the item allows [26:12] two minutes per person and a [26:14] group has four members present [26:15] they get an eight minute block [26:18] to present. [26:20] However there is an attendance [26:21] rule Every person listed on [26:24] the roster must all be present [26:25] either physically or virtually [26:26] . [26:27] When the item is called if a [26:29] registered member is missing [26:31] that portion of the time is [26:32] forfeited and the group's total [26:34] speaking block is reduced [26:36] accordingly. [26:37] Currently all members of a [26:39] group must be present in one [26:40] attendance format. [26:41] If they are present in a mix [26:43] format, the way that the lead [26:45] presenter is attending is how [26:47] the group's time will be [26:48] calculated. [26:49] For example if there is a group [26:51] before but only two are present [26:53] in chambers with the lead [26:54] presenter the group will only [26:56] get three minutes. [26:57] The virtual attendee will not [26:59] count towards that time [27:01] allocation vice versa if [27:03] the lead presenter is virtual [27:04] and everyone else is present in [27:06] chambers none of their time [27:08] will go to them unless they [27:10] attend virtually. [27:13] We do hope to continue to work [27:15] through our rfp process for a [27:16] new agenda system and zoom to [27:18] find a technology solution to [27:20] allow for mixed attendance [27:22] without meeting disruption in [27:23] the future. [27:25] Now equity means meeting our [27:27] residents in the language they [27:29] are most comfortable using as [27:30] well. [27:31] In strict alignment our equity [27:32] objectives all in structures [27:34] and win forms from [27:35] the organized presentation [27:36] process. [27:36] Are fully available in [27:38] the cities. [27:39] Eight Primary Alternative [27:40] Languages of Spanish Chinese [27:42] Tagalog Vietnamese Arabic, [27:43] Korean, Japanese and Laotian. [27:46] I will note that the only [27:47] required language per sb 707 is [27:50] Spanish Such a bad card. [27:52] >> We provide full language [27:54] support and if anyone [27:55] experiences technical glitches [27:57] or has a question while [27:59] navigating the portal they can [28:00] call or email our staff [28:01] directly for real time [28:03] assistance. [28:04] A new program is only effective [28:07] if people actually know it [28:08] exists. [28:08] To get the word out ahead of [28:11] the JULY roll out we are [28:12] executing a multichannel [28:13] outreach campaign. [28:14] This includes distributing [28:16] physical fliers to community [28:18] homes, pushing targeted notices [28:19] through diversity email [28:21] listservs and launching a [28:22] dedicated social media campaign [28:24] across all of the city [28:25] channels. [28:26] We want to ensure that [28:27] the community organization [28:29] planning groups and grassroot [28:30] coalitions is fully informed [28:32] and ready to leverage this [28:34] tool. [28:34] In conclusion, these actions [28:38] represent a sustained, [28:39] proactive and good faith [28:41] commitment to lowering barriers [28:42] and ensuring equitable civic [28:44] access. [28:46] Perfectly aligning with our [28:47] city's strategic core principle [28:49] of equity and inclusion based [28:51] on the extensive community [28:52] listening, the technological [28:54] and language upgrades and [28:55] the deployment of the new [28:56] organized presentation tool [28:58] staff confidently believe that [29:01] city that the city has made [29:02] reasonable efforts to efforts [29:04] to invite public participation. [29:06] Therefore we respectfully [29:07] request that the Council adopt [29:08] a resolution finding that [29:10] the city of San Diego has made [29:11] reasonable efforts to encourage [29:12] participation from communities [29:14] that do not traditionally [29:15] engage in public meetings and [29:17] direct our office to continue [29:19] implementing these vital [29:21] outreach initiatives. [29:22] I thank you for your time, your [29:24] leadership and your partnership [29:26] in making local government more [29:28] accessible to all San Diegans. [29:29] And a special thank you to [29:31] the Panda Web team to the Park [29:33] and Rec services director Andy [29:35] Field and Misty Jones as well [29:37] as Christina Beyeler from adb [29:39] who have all been engaging with [29:41] me to ensure that we get [29:42] the word out as well as each [29:44] one of your offices as much as [29:46] possible. [29:46] I'm happy to answer any [29:47] questions you MAY have [29:48] regarding the report or [29:50] the upcoming rollout of [29:51] the organized presentation [29:52] process. [29:52] Thank you Counsel PRESIDENT And [29:54] apologies for the overrun. [29:55] All right. [29:56] Thank you. [29:57] City Clerk 20th for [29:59] the presentation. [30:00] Deputy Clerk Please proceed [30:01] with public comment. [30:02] Thank you. [30:03] Council PRESIDENT We received [30:04] one request to speak from an [30:06] individual in chambers. [30:08] Paul Kruger please come [30:10] forward. [30:11] You'll have two minutes. [30:19] I want to thank you And I had [30:19] the time seated by Yvonne [30:22] Jones. [30:23] >> Yvonne Jones Okay. [30:25] You'll have four minutes. [30:29] Which one? [30:30] >> Uh, thank you. [30:34] Um, first let me express my and [30:36] other people's appreciation for [30:39] all the work that the city [30:40] clerk did in making sure that [30:42] the council is compliant with [30:43] seven seven. [30:47] I can tell it was a lot of work [30:49] And those of us who participate [30:52] in this project appreciate it. [30:56] Um, but I wanted to use an [30:58] opportunity here to focus again [31:01] your attention on [31:02] the importance of community [31:03] planning groups. [31:05] And I do understand why we're [31:09] moving forward with this But [31:11] you'll hear today on the phone [31:13] from Victoria Lou Brousseau [31:16] who's chair of the cpc and [31:17] she's going to speak with you [31:19] again about how crucial a role [31:23] community planning groups can [31:25] play in this process. [31:26] Because one thing we know for [31:29] sure is that these new rules [31:30] are going to be very [31:31] complicated for people to [31:33] follow. [31:33] And that we have already or you [31:37] have already at hand a time [31:40] tested five decade old process [31:42] of community planning groups [31:44] that are prepared, shared and [31:47] more than able to give you [31:50] information about how members [31:52] of that community who you don't [31:54] hear from often because [31:56] unfortunately they don't have [31:58] access to a lot of counsel [32:00] offices and are not connected [32:02] financially and politically. [32:05] I have to say about important [32:07] things that are happening in [32:08] their neighborhoods. [32:11] I know that there has been for [32:13] the last five years criticism [32:15] of community planning groups [32:17] and I would like to just urge [32:19] you what I think planning group [32:22] members urged from [32:23] the beginning which is that way [32:27] to improve the process is not [32:29] to silence or minimize [32:30] community planning groups but [32:33] to continue to expand their [32:35] representation within [32:37] communities by making each [32:40] council office responsible or [32:44] encouraged to work with [32:47] community planning groups to [32:48] expand notification of [32:51] vacancies, to expand [32:54] notification of elections so [32:56] that more people participate [32:59] and to ensure as we have done [33:02] and in several planning groups [33:04] that these planning groups [33:06] represent the community. [33:09] The biggest split of course [33:10] would be from those who want to [33:13] see pretty much unbridled [33:15] development in our in our [33:17] residential areas and how they [33:21] are contrasted with those who [33:24] want to take a more measured [33:26] and realistic approach. [33:28] And we can encourage those who [33:32] are underrepresented if they [33:34] are to run for election, to win [33:37] election and to give a very [33:40] Democratic voice to these [33:42] meetings. [33:44] So in closing, I would just [33:45] urge you to please not forgo [33:48] the opportunity to embrace [33:51] the constructive work that [33:53] community planning groups can [33:54] do. [33:56] And excuse me to listen to [33:59] Victoria when she calls in. [34:01] She couldn't be here in person [34:03] and I know that coming here in [34:06] person and speaking to you and [34:08] looking at you does have a bit [34:10] more of an impact than a [34:12] telephone call. [34:13] But hers will only be two [34:15] minutes and I appreciate your [34:18] attention. [34:18] Thank you very much. [34:20] >> Thank you. [34:21] That does conclude the public [34:22] comment hearing Council chamber [34:23] is going to those participating [34:24] remotely currently have seven [34:26] people in the queue. [34:27] Kate Callaghan If you can [34:30] please unmute. [34:33] >> Good afternoon. [34:35] When this item came before [34:37] the rules Committee several of [34:38] us urged that community [34:39] planning groups be given a seat [34:41] at the table. [34:42] Council PRESIDENT LaCava [34:43] responded that we were [34:45] misunderstood. [34:45] Why the council was discussing [34:48] community outreach. [34:49] There was no misunderstanding. [34:51] We rarely have the chance to [34:53] point out publicly that [34:55] the city has failed a genuine [34:56] community engagement. [34:58] That's where planning groups [35:00] come in. [35:01] There are members who are [35:01] elected to serve the public [35:03] just as all of you were. [35:05] For 50 years they have carried [35:07] out their mandate to speak for [35:08] their communities. [35:10] They survived an ugly campaign [35:12] by special interest that [35:14] questioned their integrity and [35:15] their competence. [35:16] They emerged stronger. [35:19] They continue to represent San [35:20] Diegans who are too often [35:22] ignored. [35:23] If you care about community [35:25] engagement please adopt a seat [35:27] at the table proposal that [35:29] Victoria Brousseau has put [35:30] before you. [35:32] It is the best way to make sure [35:33] that people and communities are [35:35] represented and heard and [35:38] respected. [35:39] Thank you. [35:41] Thank you. [35:41] Next is 8700 If you can please [35:43] unmute. [35:50] >> Thank you so much. [35:52] I support this resolution on [35:55] group participation and [35:56] community engagement efforts. [35:58] Well there were 15 items in [36:00] the backup and the staff report [36:02] itself was 12 pages. [36:04] What does that tell you? [36:05] Great job. [36:07] I especially appreciate [36:09] the office of the city clerk [36:11] Fuentes and the rest of [36:13] the team for encouraging [36:15] participative participation of [36:18] individuals and groups that do [36:21] not traditionally participate [36:23] in public meetings. [36:26] Please speak up and let us hear [36:29] your voice. [36:30] Is that for me? [36:31] I enjoyed hearing your [36:33] presentation. [36:34] City Clerk 20 For the second [36:36] time This is a stellar [36:38] initiative and so is your [36:40] implementation of it. [36:42] I'm so excited about it being [36:45] rolled out by the rolling out [36:47] on JULY 1st, 2026 with [36:51] the first real City Council [36:54] meeting on JULY 6th, 2026. [36:58] I love the inclusion Inclusion [37:01] Public Engagement Guide. [37:05] That was a great idea. [37:07] Now this is kind of a finishing [37:09] paragraph with something else [37:11] came up just a few minutes ago [37:12] that I want to add to it So [37:13] I'll say this first. [37:15] Please keep on top of any [37:17] additional funding that is [37:19] needed over the 2027 budget. [37:24] Let's keep this fire burning. [37:26] So on the community planning [37:29] groups I really haven't looked [37:32] at that but I can tell there's [37:34] an issue in this passion around [37:35] the item including them. [37:38] What I just wanted to say is [37:40] that I know there's been some [37:43] bumpy moments with [37:44] the community planning groups [37:46] yet I really respect PRESIDENT [37:51] Carver's participation you [37:51] know, leadership. [37:52] He's been very involved with [37:54] those groups and he really is [37:56] on top of of kind of what's [37:58] going on in the future and all [38:00] of that. [38:00] >> So what I just want your [38:02] time has concluded. [38:03] John, if you can please unmute [38:03] . [38:10] >> Hi. [38:10] Good afternoon. [38:11] Council members. [38:13] MISS Congratulations. [38:14] This is really amazing work. [38:16] It shows a lot of thought. [38:18] A lot of the changes that we've [38:20] been hoping might be included [38:21] in this are really love [38:24] the ability to have a group [38:25] participate particularly for [38:27] those with disabilities who [38:29] cannot show up in person. [38:32] >> And speaking of which, I was [38:33] wondering if there was any [38:35] accommodation provided. [38:36] I know we give extra time for [38:38] folks that have language [38:40] barriers or need translation. [38:43] I feel that the same courtesy [38:44] might want to be extended to [38:46] those who have challenges with [38:48] speech or speech impediments [38:50] that cause them to not be able [38:53] to articulate effectively or as [38:56] quickly as others. [38:59] The other thing I do I'm not [39:00] sure if I heard but I would be [39:02] nice to read to be able to read [39:04] this during neutral position as [39:05] opposed to for or against as we [39:08] sign in for these things. [39:10] I do have one other suggestion [39:12] for you but that will take more [39:14] time so I'll reach out to you [39:15] independently but really great [39:16] work. [39:17] They're very supportive of [39:18] this. [39:20] I agree that Thank you Francine [39:21] Maxwell if you can please [39:22] unmute. [39:23] >> There was also the five [39:24] minute time where we have five [39:25] speakers in the queue. [39:25] No additional speakers will be [39:27] taken. [39:28] >> Francine Maxwell if you can [39:29] please. [39:31] >> Francine Maxwell [39:33] Southeastern San Diego resident [39:34] Thank you so much for [39:35] the presentation and for [39:37] support. [39:38] Really want the Council to pay [39:40] attention to what the clerk's [39:41] office staff does. [39:43] You get a glimpse of it but [39:45] literally they're not supposed [39:46] to work on the weekends with [39:48] some of them, do their due [39:49] diligence and go ahead and [39:50] answer a quick question on [39:52] the weekend unlike many of your [39:53] offices. [39:54] So want to make sure that you [39:56] look at the diversity of when [39:59] the meetings were very [40:01] inclusive. [40:03] You did not have to send for [40:06] council for someone to consult [40:07] from Colorado. [40:09] I think we were doing a parking [40:11] rack or we were doing something [40:12] in water area and we had a [40:14] consultant from Colorado. [40:16] So I mean literally you have [40:18] stars right there in [40:19] the building. [40:20] I mean some stars are getting [40:22] stuck in elevators but they're [40:23] still a star. [40:25] And again, we want to make sure [40:27] that everyone is educated in [40:30] and if hopefully the council [40:32] people that have newsletters [40:35] maybe you'll put a corner [40:37] clerk's corner in your [40:38] newsletter so that while you're [40:40] showing the wonderful events [40:41] that you go to the handouts of [40:44] resolution and certificates [40:46] proclamations that you can help [40:48] educate. [40:49] Again, education is the key to [40:52] everything. [40:53] And a Clerks Corner and [40:55] everybody's newsletter could [40:57] give people insight on how to [40:59] work the system, how to [41:01] participate more in their city [41:03] government because they know [41:05] that their voice really counts [41:07] and it counts more than just [41:09] election season. [41:10] So again, thanks to every [41:12] person in that works for [41:14] the clerk's office. [41:16] You are absolutely seen we are [41:19] listening to you and we [41:20] appreciate your time and your [41:22] talent. [41:23] Thank you for allowing me to [41:24] speak. [41:25] Thank you. [41:26] Blair Beckman if you can please [41:27] unmute. [41:30] >> Hi. [41:32] Where Beckman are San Diego [41:33] Civic Center. [41:33] Elevators are starting to [41:35] become infamous. [41:36] Good luck. [41:37] We can fix them elevators soon. [41:40] Thanks a lot for this item. [41:41] i'm in full agreement with [41:42] the public comment. [41:44] Stellar was used as a word. [41:47] The concept that you are [41:48] allowing over 20 plus languages [41:51] so people can attend city [41:53] council meetings now I was [41:56] living in San Diego in 1986 [41:58] when they created English only [42:00] laws that I feel were just [42:02] learning to work through San [42:02] Diego. [42:04] San Jose made really [42:06] significant strides in these [42:08] sort of efforts in the mid and [42:09] the 2015. [42:11] You guys are coming through now [42:13] San Diego San Jose's practicing [42:15] what you're offering now and [42:16] thank you immensely. [42:18] That means everyone can [42:19] participate. [42:20] That's an amazing concept we [42:22] haven't grasped fully yet. [42:23] Good luck. [42:24] We can continue to do that. [42:25] Thank you for the idea of a [42:27] neutral voice to vote to to put [42:31] in your speaker card on issues. [42:32] I'm totally in favor of that [42:33] idea. [42:35] I was a bit surprised that, you [42:37] know, in working with community [42:38] groups a very nice speech [42:40] earlier that upon the beginning [42:42] public speaker that really [42:44] described the importance of [42:45] community groups and what our [42:46] current community groups are [42:48] working towards. [42:49] I mean it's a really [42:50] participatory process. [42:52] It's in our decency while [42:53] others have money to accomplish [42:55] things, a group of community is [42:58] trying to offer ways that [42:59] people who don't have [43:00] advantages can be a part of [43:02] the process and help create our [43:04] process. [43:05] >> I really hope that can be [43:06] better expressed. [43:08] It seems like you cut things [43:09] short a bit on the Zoom [43:11] comments on how to do that Even [43:12] better. [43:13] Good luck. [43:14] You can continue that work and [43:15] effort on that on those issues [43:17] and San Diego County government [43:20] is working on a subcommittee [43:22] process They've taken notes [43:24] from 707 like the close agenda [43:26] item things but they need a bit [43:29] of help in how to better [43:30] understand its future that [43:32] respects privacy. [43:33] >> Good luck on those efforts [43:34] too. [43:35] Thank you Victoria Lorenzo Hey [43:46] good afternoon. [43:46] Council members Victoria [43:48] Brousseau, Chair of the cpc. [43:49] First I want to thank Paul for [43:51] showing up and giving this [43:52] comment since afternoon. [43:53] I also want to thank the city [43:54] Clerk office for all the great [43:57] advancements with [43:57] the distributing distributing [44:00] information but continue to [44:01] encourage the city clerk and [44:02] the City council to continue [44:04] refining public participation [44:05] allowing time to be seated [44:07] virtually is a great step [44:08] forward. [44:09] However, I remain concerned [44:10] about the organized [44:11] presentation process. [44:13] Under the new rules volunteers [44:14] must identify speakers gather [44:16] commitments to cede time, [44:18] collect names and submit those [44:19] names in advance. [44:20] That adds another level of [44:22] coordination for volunteers [44:23] that already donate time to [44:25] participate. [44:26] As for robust public [44:28] engagement, I continue to [44:29] advocate that the city already [44:31] has an established network of [44:33] community planning groups made [44:34] up of more than 600 elected [44:36] volunteers serving San Diego. [44:38] If you truly want to strengthen [44:40] public engagement, the answer [44:42] is to provide with the cpses a [44:44] seat at the table and [44:45] empowering and promoting [44:47] the community elected voices. [44:48] This would complement public [44:50] comment, not replace it and [44:53] provide a predictable way for [44:54] organized community voices to [44:56] be heard. [44:57] As the Planning Department [44:58] continues to reduce the role of [45:01] CPGs, I urge the City Council [45:02] to move in the opposite [45:03] direction, strengthen not [45:06] diminish the role by formally [45:08] providing CPGs and cpc a seat [45:10] at the table. [45:12] If the city wants stronger [45:13] public engagement it should [45:15] actively promote community [45:16] planning groups as the local [45:18] connection between residents [45:20] and City Hall. [45:21] Not leave each cpg to create [45:23] its own public awareness Bpg [45:26] and the cpc should be [45:28] the city's front door to civic [45:30] participation. [45:32] Thank you again and I [45:33] appreciate the time to speak [45:35] with you guys and wish I could [45:36] have come down there. [45:37] But Scripps Ranches is further [45:39] out and takes a lot more time [45:41] and a lot more money. [45:42] So I speak when I can and I [45:44] appreciate you all giving [45:45] attention to this matter. [45:46] Thanks. [45:47] Thank you. [45:49] Next is Peggy Walker and then [45:50] our final speaker is Natalie [45:51] asking Peggy please. [45:51] And you. [45:53] Thank you. [45:54] Good afternoon And thank you [45:56] for explaining this process. [45:58] All efforts to increase public [45:59] participation in the governing [46:01] process are good and in [46:02] particular allowance for [46:05] seeding time for virtual [46:06] participants as well as [46:10] in-person events. [46:11] Solid equity improve allowing [46:11] organized virtual presentations [46:13] levels the playing field for [46:15] all constituents especially [46:17] those like myself who observe [46:19] and participate in these [46:21] meetings from an office finding [46:23] it hard to make regular trips [46:25] to council chambers and our [46:27] mobile society. [46:28] Virtual participation deserves [46:30] to be recognized as important [46:32] as in-person participation. [46:35] It has enabled me, for example [46:37] and I'm sure others to speak to [46:39] issues when I'm not in town or [46:41] able to drive downtown. [46:43] And finally I attend my [46:45] planning group and strongly [46:46] support the suggestions earlier [46:49] of giving planning groups a [46:50] greater seat at the table [46:52] including expanding council [46:54] member or staff communication [46:57] with pages in their districts. [47:00] Planning groups are the best [47:02] way to strengthen a community [47:03] link to the council and they [47:06] should be recognized for their [47:07] importance. [47:08] Thank you. [47:10] Thank you. [47:11] And our final speaker is [47:12] Natalie Raskin. [47:12] If you can please unmute and [47:13] thank you. [47:19] Another thing that I think is [47:20] an amazing idea having more [47:24] involved and having the ability [47:24] . [47:29] I think that you're a little [47:29] jumbled up here. [47:30] You sound a little bit Can you [47:33] hear me now? [47:34] Yes, that's better. [47:35] >> Please proceed. [47:36] I'm multitasking. [47:39] I think it's it's amazing. [47:40] I think having the opportunity [47:41] for the community support [47:45] involved is the best thing [47:47] moving forward in this case. [47:51] Feel a little sympathy stomach [47:51] for what? [47:56] That's what I'm on. [47:59] We have to curb that and help [48:02] People are also a part of how [48:05] we best when we go. [48:06] People that forget they are [48:09] part of it. [48:14] You're cutting out again Not [48:20] hear me? [48:21] >> You are cutting out again [48:23] and we no longer hear you. [48:31] I'm sorry. [48:34] You can definitely submit [48:35] comments to City clerk at San [48:37] diego.Gov and those will be [48:38] distributed to the council. [48:40] But we have lost you. [48:43] That does include public [48:44] comment here in council [48:46] chambers And regarding this [48:47] item. [48:48] >> All right. [48:50] Thank you City Clerk. [48:52] This now goes back to [48:53] the Council to ratify [48:55] the community engagement [48:56] process and whether it met [48:57] the standards of the 707 In [49:01] addition to the extraordinary [49:03] training session that the city [49:04] clerk gave us on how this new [49:07] process will move forward. [49:09] So I'll kick things off. [49:11] So again, thank you to Clark [49:13] Francis and your team for [49:14] the work and as well as [49:15] the office of the City Attorney [49:16] and everybody else that engaged [49:18] in this process. [49:20] And as a reminder sb 707 [49:21] requires us to put this in [49:23] place by JULY 1st and our very [49:26] first council meeting where [49:27] we'll be using this new system [49:28] will be Monday, JULY sixth. [49:33] Sb 7 or 7 has many elements but [49:34] for the public the most obvious [49:35] will be the changes to [49:36] the agenda to comply with [49:38] translation requirements and [49:41] changes to the public comment [49:42] procedures to ensure equal [49:43] treatment of in-person and [49:45] virtual public commenters. [49:47] Virtual public commerce will [49:48] now allow seeding of time a [49:51] first for the City of San Diego [49:53] Sacramento path sb 707 with [49:56] good intentions but provided a [49:58] very short timeline for [49:59] implementation and no [50:00] additional resources. [50:02] Nevertheless, the City clerk [50:03] remain undaunted and was ready [50:05] to take up the charge. [50:07] And with our current staffing [50:08] levels and with technology [50:09] currently available in [50:10] the marketplace it became clear [50:12] that we could not fully [50:13] replicate our existing [50:15] in-person processes for virtual [50:17] participation. [50:19] So council had a choice either [50:20] eliminate long standing option [50:22] of city time during in-person [50:24] public comment or reimagine [50:25] the process And some [50:26] jurisdictions like Encinitas [50:28] opted to discontinue seeding [50:30] time. [50:31] Everyone has limited their own [50:32] time and own presentation. [50:34] Under my work as Council [50:36] PRESIDENT And with [50:37] collaboration from City Clerk, [50:38] council administration and City [50:39] Attorney's Office, we proposed [50:41] changes to protect public [50:42] participation by reimagining [50:44] the process of seeding time. [50:47] The changes were tested and [50:48] revisited numerous times. [50:50] I first brought in Information [50:52] Item two Rules Committee in [50:53] FEBRUARY with a framework for [50:54] these changes. [50:55] We listened to feedback from [50:56] the public and committee [50:57] members and adjusted. [50:59] We had originally had different [51:01] ideas. [51:01] We proposed process only [51:03] applying to groups of 5 to 10. [51:05] Due to the administrative [51:06] burden on the clerk's team [51:08] however, with feedback from [51:09] Rules Committee and the public [51:11] I propose and Council adopted [51:13] organize presentation groups [51:14] for just two or more people. [51:17] Additionally we reduced [51:18] the signup time based on public [51:20] feedback and I really have to [51:21] give thanks to the city clerk [51:22] and her team for willingness to [51:24] do that. [51:24] As you heard in [51:25] the presentation, groups can [51:27] now sign up 24 hours in advance [51:29] of the meeting and provide [51:30] their slides or presentation [51:31] material if any as late as two [51:34] hours before the meeting. [51:36] That's a lot of scrambling by [51:37] the city clerk's office to [51:38] accommodate this further. [51:41] Again, based on public feedback [51:43] we are keeping the virtual [51:44] comment period open for up to [51:46] five minutes. [51:47] Once in-person comment has [51:49] ended in MARCH, Rules Committee [51:52] unanimously voted on [51:53] the revised proposal and [51:54] forwarded to Council [51:56] unanimously voted in forwarded [51:58] to the Council in APRIL. [51:59] Council heard this item on [52:00] discussion and also voted [52:02] unanimously to support [52:03] the changes modifications to [52:05] our publicic comment procedures [52:07] were done out of a requirement [52:08] to comply with state law and [52:10] our commitment to preserving [52:12] public participation. [52:14] This proposal strikes a good [52:15] balance between what was [52:17] possible with our current [52:18] resources and expanding this to [52:20] virtual participants. [52:22] Under these new procedures [52:24] virtual participants can can [52:25] now give presentations and as I [52:29] mentioned at the onset we will [52:31] now put this into practice [52:32] after a lot of talk and a lot [52:34] of discussion. [52:35] Council's JULY 6th hearing will [52:37] be the first time we will roll [52:38] this out. [52:40] >> It MAY all sound a bit [52:41] complicated and as you saw [52:42] the clerk has put out [52:43] information guides and their [52:44] office stands ready to help [52:46] the public navigate the new [52:47] processes. [52:49] In closing the council and city [52:49] clerk has been a statewide [52:51] leader in hosting public [52:53] comment both in-person and [52:55] virtually And now we're [52:56] stepping up to meet the intent [52:58] of sb 77 with the resources. [53:01] Bottom line we're expanding [53:02] opportunities for public [53:03] comment and input at our public [53:06] hearings. [53:07] There MAY be some bumps in [53:08] the road but I have no doubt [53:09] the clerk's team and council [53:10] administration will be up to [53:12] the challenge to help us all [53:13] through it. [53:14] Note They often do as they [53:16] always do I should say in every [53:18] council and committee hearing. [53:20] And so to the comments of a [53:22] members of the public, I [53:23] certainly appreciate that And [53:25] it's important to know that a [53:27] seat at the table was not about [53:28] public comment. [53:29] It was a proposal to have [53:31] dedicated time during a council [53:33] action. [53:34] I think that's a big change [53:36] from what our past practices [53:39] have been and I wonder about [53:41] who we actually limited to. [53:43] I was a big believer in [53:45] community planning groups. [53:46] I'm still a big, big believer [53:48] and planning groups as well as [53:49] the Community Planners [53:50] committee. [53:51] But there are so many other [53:52] voices that we need to hear [53:55] from when we make a decision [53:57] and the variety of things that [53:58] come across our diocese. [54:01] And so we can continue [54:02] the conversation about how we [54:03] do that. [54:04] But I think this is an [54:05] important step because I used [54:07] to be on the other side of [54:08] the dice and I remember how [54:10] much time was and how tricky it [54:12] was to get people to cede time. [54:13] But we see it time and time [54:15] again about how it is possible [54:18] we're going to roll this out on [54:20] JULY 1st for an experience in [54:22] JULY 6th and the four meetings [54:24] we have in JULY and then we'll [54:27] react and possibly pivot. [54:29] This is brand new and we know [54:31] there MAY be bumps as I said [54:33] going forward. [54:34] We do appreciate the planning [54:36] groups. [54:36] I know my colleagues appreciate [54:38] the planning groups. [54:39] I think we all appreciate [54:41] the community planners [54:41] committee as well. [54:43] Going forward And we want to [54:45] hear from them and we want to [54:46] hear from every organized group [54:49] whether it's neighbors for a [54:49] better San Diego live [54:50] experience advisors Alliance, [54:53] Summit City can you name it [54:54] They all have important voices [54:56] to contribute to our decision [54:57] making process. [54:59] And with that I will move [55:00] the staff recommendation and [55:02] turn it over to my colleagues [55:05] for either a second or a [55:05] permit. [55:10] Councilmember Marino have [55:12] second and not seen any other [55:14] councilmember mpo. [55:14] >> Thank you Council PRESIDENT [55:15] Just briefly appreciate [55:16] the members of the public who [55:17] came in and spoke as they did [55:18] in Rules Committee a couple of [55:19] days ago and just reiterate my [55:20] comments from rules out [55:22] continually looking for ways to [55:24] improve and increase public [55:25] participation. [55:26] There's no better person in our [55:27] city government who does that [55:28] than our city clerk. [55:28] They want this. [55:30] And I just want to say hearing [55:32] them loud and clear and [55:34] appreciating the role that [55:36] species play and finding a [55:37] bigger role for them moving [55:38] forward continued Well I'm [55:41] committed to doing that further [55:42] into the future but I am in [55:43] support today of the motion. [55:45] >> Thank you. [55:45] All right. [55:46] Thank you, sir. [55:47] And I forgot to mention with [55:48] handy field in the background [55:49] the councils are also another [55:50] voice in a lot of these [55:52] conversations. [55:53] So see no one else on [55:54] the lights a motion by myself [55:56] and a second by COUNCILMAN [55:57] Marino to move the staff [55:58] recommendation Call the roll [56:01] I'm sorry the voting system [56:02] Please cast your vote and that [56:06] passes unanimously 7 to 0 with [56:06] Councilmember Foster and [56:07] Councilmember Yvonne Wilbert [56:11] Absent. [56:11] Thank you, council PRESIDENT [56:12] And thank you again. [56:14] Thank you city Clerk, for all [56:15] the good work you and your [56:16] entire team and everyone who [56:17] participated in that process. [56:19] >> So with that please [56:20] introduce item 400 items 400 as [56:24] the proposed fiscal year 2027 [56:26] Recreation Center Fund Budget [56:28] Opportunity Fund budget and [56:30] 2025 complete outside report If [56:33] you're here in council chambers [56:34] I would like to speak on this [56:35] item. [56:35] Please be sure to submit your [56:37] speakers live to the front of [56:38] the room in the clear box And [56:39] if you're participating online [56:41] or via phone now's the time to [56:43] raise your hand by pressing [56:44] Star nine or the Raise your [56:46] hand I can't thank you Council [56:47] for that. [56:48] >> All right. [56:48] Thank you. [56:48] I see a staff is settling in [56:51] When you're ready, introduce [56:54] yourselves for the record and [56:56] let us know how much time you [56:57] need. [57:03] >> Good afternoon. [57:05] Sara Erato, deputy director for [57:05] the Parks and Recreation [57:06] Department. [57:07] With me today is Salome [57:08] Martinez, program equity [57:10] manager as well as Andy Field [57:12] Department director. [57:13] Today we have returned to [57:14] present updates to the proposed [57:16] fiscal year 2027 Recreation [57:18] Center Fund and Opportunity [57:19] Fund Budget. [57:20] We are requesting eight minutes [57:21] for the presentation. [57:22] All right. [57:23] When you're ready. [57:26] On JUNE 16th the department [57:27] presented the proposed fiscal [57:29] year 2027 Recreation Center [57:31] Fund an opportunity fund [57:32] budgets to council resulting in [57:34] concerns raised over how [57:36] the Opportunity fund was being [57:37] allocated and unspent [57:39] Recreation Center fund dances [57:41] without the Recreation Council. [57:43] The Council returned this item [57:44] to staff requesting that [57:45] the opportunity fund allocation [57:46] for Council District eight [57:48] recreation centers be increased [57:48] . [57:50] The Allocation for Opportunity [57:52] Fund be reevaluated using [57:53] the assumption that fiscal year [57:55] 26 budgets were fully expended [57:57] to develop a plan for [57:59] the expenditure of fund [58:00] balances and to evaluate [58:02] improvements to the Recreation [58:03] Center Fund Budget and [58:04] Opportunity Fund allocation [58:06] process in the future. [58:08] The next few slides we will [58:09] review each of these [58:10] recommendations. [58:13] Recreation centers are [58:14] supported through a combination [58:16] of funding sources beginning [58:17] with the general fund which [58:18] provides core operating support [58:20] needed to maintain services and [58:22] facilities. [58:23] In addition to general fund [58:24] support we have recreation [58:26] center funds that capture [58:27] revenues generated through [58:29] recreation center operations [58:30] and reinvest those funds back [58:31] into recreation services. [58:33] Opportunity funds provide [58:35] additional resources that are [58:36] allocated to recreation centers [58:38] and underserved communities for [58:39] local priorities programs, [58:41] equipment and minor maintenance [58:42] projects. [58:43] We also have actively we [58:44] actively pursue grants from [58:46] state, federal and private [58:47] organizations to support [58:49] specific projects, expand [58:51] programing and improve [58:52] facilities. [58:53] Finally, donations from [58:54] community members, [58:55] organizations and partners help [58:57] support programs and projects [58:58] beyond what traditional funding [58:59] sources MAY provide. [59:01] Taking a closer look at [59:03] recreation Center funds, there [59:04] are several revenue sources [59:06] that make up fund balance [59:07] program registration fees from [59:09] classes, camps, sports leagues [59:11] and other recreational [59:12] activities. [59:13] Our primary source of revenue [59:14] for the Recreation Center Fund [59:17] revenue is also generated [59:18] through permits for use of [59:19] recreation buildings, athletic [59:21] fields and park facilities for [59:22] community events, leagues and [59:24] private rentals. [59:25] Annually Opportunity Fund [59:27] allocations are deposited into [59:28] recreation center funds to [59:30] support underserved communities [59:30] . [59:32] Expanding programs, events and [59:34] projects identified at [59:35] the local level. [59:37] Donations made specifically to [59:38] a recreation center can also be [59:40] deposited into a fund and used [59:42] in accordance with the donor [59:43] intent. [59:44] Together these funding sources [59:45] create a diversified funding [59:47] model that allows recreation [59:48] centers to maintain daily [59:50] operations while also investing [59:52] in programs, equipment and [59:53] facility improvements. [59:56] After running the analysis [59:58] recommended in item two, [1:00:00] the results remained similar in [1:00:01] the original allocation [1:00:02] disbursement resulting in even [1:00:04] less item Council District [1:00:05] eight receiving an allocation. [1:00:07] With that the Department makes [1:00:09] the following recommendation to [1:00:10] move the budgets forward for f [1:00:12] y 27 expenditure maintain [1:00:14] the previously proposed [1:00:15] opportunity Fund allocations of [1:00:19] 555,000 to the 14 recreation [1:00:20] centers originally identified [1:00:22] in the staff report and [1:00:23] Attachment b. [1:00:25] In addition, utilize $100,000 [1:00:27] of Future Opportunity Fund [1:00:29] revenue to support expanding [1:00:31] opportunity fund allocations in [1:00:33] the fiscal year 27 budget to [1:00:35] all eight recreation centers in [1:00:36] Council District eight. [1:00:38] This would provide each site an [1:00:39] additional $12,500 for [1:00:41] the fiscal year 27 Recreation [1:00:43] Center Fund budget. [1:00:45] This would be a one time [1:00:46] allocation of future revenues. [1:00:48] Future allocations will follow [1:00:50] a policy methodology at [1:00:52] the time as it existed at [1:00:54] the time of that year's [1:00:55] allocation. [1:00:57] As previously mentioned, staff [1:00:59] assessed the Opportunity Fund [1:01:01] scoring methodology assuming [1:01:02] fiscal year 26 recreation [1:01:03] center fund budgets had been [1:01:05] fully expended. [1:01:07] The analysis found similar [1:01:08] results to the original scores [1:01:10] with Council District eight [1:01:11] allocations changing from two [1:01:12] eligible sites to one. [1:01:14] The findings suggest that [1:01:15] broader elements of [1:01:16] the Opportunity Fund scoring [1:01:17] matrix and methodology work [1:01:20] further evaluation to ensure [1:01:22] the program effectively [1:01:23] advances equity objectives [1:01:25] which the Department is [1:01:26] committed to evaluating prior [1:01:27] to the fy 28 budget cycle. [1:01:31] The third request of a plan to [1:01:34] expend recreation center fund [1:01:35] balances requires a broader [1:01:36] discussion on why fund balance [1:01:38] does exist for the immediate [1:01:40] fiscal year 27 budget proposal. [1:01:42] The Department updated all [1:01:43] eight recreation center fund [1:01:44] budgets in Council District [1:01:47] eight to fully expend fund [1:01:48] balances less $5,000 to support [1:01:50] expanding programs and [1:01:52] maintenance projects. [1:01:53] As for the history of [1:01:54] Recreation Center fund [1:01:56] balances, these were created in [1:01:57] 2018 with many balances [1:02:00] starting with funds turned over [1:02:01] by recreation councils who had [1:02:03] been generating balances since [1:02:05] their inception. [1:02:07] To date community recreation [1:02:08] groups continue to provide [1:02:10] recommendations for recreation [1:02:11] center fund expenditures and [1:02:13] often include a reserve of [1:02:15] funds over multiple years to [1:02:16] support larger projects. [1:02:18] In addition, recreation centers [1:02:19] require sufficient fund [1:02:21] balances at the start of [1:02:22] the fiscal year to continue [1:02:23] operating busy summer month [1:02:25] programing and events. [1:02:27] Also being annual revenues and [1:02:28] expenditures can fluctuate [1:02:30] throughout the year. [1:02:31] Having fund balance does [1:02:32] provide a safeguard against [1:02:33] revenue shortfalls preventing [1:02:35] spending and program freezes. [1:02:38] In addition, fund balances MAY [1:02:40] exist as a result of changes to [1:02:42] procurement processes. [1:02:43] Specifically the implementation [1:02:44] of 8339 which requires a more [1:02:47] robust contracting out review [1:02:49] process for example contracting [1:02:51] out review process previously [1:02:52] took 14 to 45 days to process [1:02:55] or as currently underway since [1:02:58] FEBRUARY. [1:02:59] The process takes 90 or more [1:03:00] days depending on [1:03:01] the procurement type. [1:03:03] Also the department continues [1:03:04] to face ongoing challenges [1:03:05] primarily due to staffing [1:03:07] capacity as it relates to [1:03:08] navigating public works and [1:03:10] maintenance contract process [1:03:11] for facility repairs and [1:03:12] improvements as well as [1:03:14] recreation program contracts. [1:03:16] While we have experienced [1:03:17] delays in getting contracts in [1:03:18] place in a timely manner to [1:03:20] support these activities, [1:03:21] the Department continues to [1:03:23] work closely with various city [1:03:24] departments to ensure [1:03:25] compliance with these [1:03:26] requirements and processes. [1:03:30] Lastly, fund balances continue [1:03:31] to grow as the department [1:03:32] continues to leverage nonprofit [1:03:34] partners and grants to fund [1:03:36] specific programs events and [1:03:37] projects. [1:03:39] The supplemental funding [1:03:40] sources have reduced our [1:03:41] reliance on recreation center [1:03:42] funds which allows fund [1:03:44] balances to be preserved for [1:03:45] future community priorities [1:03:46] programs and investments. [1:03:48] A couple of examples include [1:03:50] the Padres Foundation donating [1:03:54] $40,000 to Montgomery Lawler to [1:03:54] cover field renovations that [1:03:55] were previously budgeted for [1:03:57] recreation center fund [1:03:58] expenditure as well as [1:04:00] the ongoing collaboration with [1:04:01] Saanich Parks Foundation, [1:04:02] the County Press Philanthropies [1:04:04] and the private foundation to [1:04:06] support the Parks After Dark [1:04:07] program. [1:04:10] Moving on to the last [1:04:11] recommendation a possible [1:04:12] recreation center Fund and [1:04:14] Opportunity Fund reforms. [1:04:15] The Department is committed [1:04:17] over the upcoming year to work [1:04:18] with eBay office of Race and [1:04:20] Equity to analyze the policy [1:04:22] and allocation process for [1:04:23] improvements and to participate [1:04:25] in the Allocation Process [1:04:26] Committee to achieve a more [1:04:28] equitable distribution of [1:04:30] funding. [1:04:31] We will meet with [1:04:31] the Department of Finance to [1:04:33] evaluate if the funds and both [1:04:35] funds can be folded into [1:04:36] the annual budget development [1:04:38] and monitoring process. [1:04:40] We will improve our [1:04:41] communication efforts with [1:04:42] the Council on the process for [1:04:43] developing Budgets for [1:04:45] Recreation Center Funds and [1:04:46] Opportunity Fund. [1:04:48] And lastly we will boost our [1:04:49] efforts to work closely with [1:04:50] operational staff and [1:04:52] the Council to ensure unspent [1:04:54] fund balances are prioritized [1:04:55] and spent on community [1:04:57] priorities. [1:04:59] The Department updated [1:05:00] attachments to the Recreation [1:05:02] Center Fund budget proposals as [1:05:03] well as Attachment b [1:05:05] Opportunity Fund allocations to [1:05:07] reflect the Increase [1:05:08] Opportunity fund allocations as [1:05:10] increased and increased budgets [1:05:12] for Council District eight. [1:05:14] Without the only changes to [1:05:15] the proposed actions includes [1:05:16] the addition of action for [1:05:18] which authorizes [1:05:19] the appropriation and [1:05:20] expenditure of future revenue [1:05:21] which was intended for fiscal [1:05:23] year 28 allocations as part of [1:05:25] the fiscal year 27 budget and [1:05:27] expenditures specifically [1:05:28] across all eight recreation [1:05:30] center funds in Council [1:05:31] District eight. [1:05:32] The Department recommends [1:05:33] approval of all actions as [1:05:35] proposed to ensure [1:05:35] the Recreation Center Fund [1:05:37] budgets are approved in a [1:05:38] timely manner and are available [1:05:40] for use beginning JULY 1st to [1:05:43] ensure constant continuity of [1:05:43] summer programing. [1:05:45] That concludes my presentation [1:05:47] . [1:05:47] >> Happy to take questions. [1:05:48] All right. [1:05:48] Thanks for the work and thank [1:05:49] you for the presentation. [1:05:50] Clerk Please go to Excuse me [1:05:53] Officer The idea to have some [1:05:53] comments. [1:05:54] >> Thank you. [1:05:54] Council PRESIDENT Kim Desmond [1:05:56] from our Division of Race and [1:05:57] Equitable provide our comments [1:05:58] . [1:05:59] Good afternoon to your local [1:06:01] members of council. [1:06:02] Our team wanted to outline some [1:06:05] equity implications for this [1:06:07] item including the upcoming [1:06:08] fund budget. [1:06:10] So our team has identified a [1:06:12] couple of equity implications [1:06:14] in the following categories. [1:06:16] One some that were mentioned by [1:06:18] Parks and Rec but one I want to [1:06:19] highlight is the Opportunity [1:06:21] Fund evaluation Committee [1:06:23] scoring matrix process. [1:06:25] We've had several conversations [1:06:26] with Sara and team around this [1:06:28] process in our team is [1:06:31] committed to looking at [1:06:32] the process in ways that we can [1:06:33] make sure that it's more [1:06:34] equitable. [1:06:35] And we plan to work with staff [1:06:37] to look at those improvements [1:06:38] in the 2020 budget cycle. [1:06:41] Some of the preliminary things [1:06:42] that we saw regarding this item [1:06:44] is improvement include [1:06:46] increasing transparency so that [1:06:50] we the recreation fund we can [1:06:51] make sure that the money is [1:06:53] being set aside in retained in [1:06:55] the fund balance for [1:06:56] the improve to other areas is [1:07:00] that it's clear that those [1:07:01] items are being used for and [1:07:03] why it's set aside. [1:07:05] Other opportunities includes [1:07:06] looking at the actual [1:07:07] opportunity fund scoring matrix [1:07:09] to explore ways in which [1:07:12] the matrix can be changed and [1:07:14] we can examine and critique [1:07:15] those factors. [1:07:17] Factors of 21 include if [1:07:20] the location is in a community [1:07:21] concern and or it is adjacent [1:07:23] to a pool. [1:07:24] So our team is committed to [1:07:26] looking at those factors in [1:07:27] partnership with Parks and Rec. [1:07:30] Last but not least in this [1:07:31] particular category we [1:07:33] recommended the department [1:07:34] determine which individuals to [1:07:37] be present to evaluate [1:07:38] the Allocation of Opportunity [1:07:40] Fund which is also charged with [1:07:42] providing recommendations. [1:07:44] Parks and Rec have invited our [1:07:46] team to sit on this committee [1:07:47] and so we wanted to just [1:07:49] highlight that part as looking [1:07:50] at who should be on [1:07:51] the committee and we accept [1:07:53] the invite from Parks and Rec [1:07:57] to the consideration of them. [1:07:57] I'll say this really quickly is [1:07:58] that we know that not all rec [1:07:59] centers are created equally so [1:08:02] council MAY want to consider [1:08:03] how facility limitations [1:08:06] including side and upper upper [1:08:07] recent offers of operational [1:08:07] hours impact access to activity [1:08:13] for stakeholders. [1:08:15] So we recommend that Parks and [1:08:16] Rec could identify a process to [1:08:18] provide stakeholders with [1:08:20] access information if their [1:08:22] service is not provided at [1:08:23] their location. [1:08:25] So essentially if it's not [1:08:26] provided there where else can [1:08:27] they go? [1:08:28] Last but not least regarding [1:08:29] the subsidized contracts [1:08:31] council MAY want to consider [1:08:32] and monitor the increase in [1:08:35] programs and activities in [1:08:38] septa as it pertains to working [1:08:40] with those provider to offer [1:08:41] more activity and services. [1:08:43] This includes the number of [1:08:44] clear tangible programs and [1:08:46] activities. [1:08:48] The call from our team is [1:08:49] aligned to address any [1:08:50] questions as well as Celina is [1:08:51] behind me. [1:08:52] We look forward to answering [1:08:54] any other questions regarding [1:08:55] our suggestions for this fund. [1:08:59] >> All right. [1:09:00] Thank you for those comments. [1:09:02] Always helpful in [1:09:03] the conversation. [1:09:04] >> Now let's go to public [1:09:06] comment. [1:09:06] Thank you. [1:09:07] Council PRESIDENT Evelyn Smith [1:09:10] if you can please come forward [1:09:11] after that is allegedly under. [1:09:17] >> You will have two minutes [1:09:25] and Smith representative day [1:09:26] four on the City Parks and Rec [1:09:28] board and I'm just here [1:09:31] requesting that these funds [1:09:33] remain in the hands of [1:09:36] the parks and Rec department [1:09:37] because the parks and rec [1:09:40] groups and the owners are [1:09:43] committed to do really need [1:09:44] these funds. [1:09:46] Thank you. [1:09:48] Thank you for the comments [1:09:49] Allegedly Audra, you you guys [1:09:58] thought I wasn't going to show [1:09:59] up today. [1:10:00] I bet would have been good. [1:10:03] I think you are right. [1:10:03] Yes. [1:10:04] So my concern is what's [1:10:06] happening at these rec centers [1:10:07] and the parks and the safety of [1:10:10] the children and really anybody [1:10:13] that participates in engaging [1:10:16] in those activities. [1:10:18] >> And as you're talking about [1:10:20] Parks after Dark program like [1:10:22] that's a little scary. [1:10:23] We don't have lights at parks [1:10:23] rubble. [1:10:25] People have been dying in your [1:10:27] parks. [1:10:29] I mean murdered it you know [1:10:29] Linda Vista skate park or being [1:10:31] brutally assaulted by officers [1:10:33] I mean you don't really care [1:10:35] because it doesn't really [1:10:37] affect you but it's very [1:10:39] detrimental what's happening at [1:10:42] these places And these funds [1:10:43] should be spent for safety and [1:10:45] things like that to make sure [1:10:47] there's lighting because people [1:10:48] are getting raped. [1:10:49] These are like perfect places [1:10:51] when you're a rapist or [1:10:53] something like that. [1:10:54] If they're dark and there's [1:10:56] secluded areas to go and take [1:10:58] advantage of somebody and it's [1:11:00] like you know we can sit here [1:11:02] and virtue signal like what [1:11:03] we're really doing is bringing [1:11:05] forward something in [1:11:06] the community which you are But [1:11:08] if you're not ensuring that [1:11:09] it's a safe place to go to then [1:11:11] it's like where's our money [1:11:12] really being spent? [1:11:13] I mean you could sit there and [1:11:14] have swings all day long but if [1:11:16] children are being raped under [1:11:17] the swings I mean how does that [1:11:20] help? [1:11:20] So I just feel like you guys [1:11:22] need to be more you know, [1:11:26] concerned about people's public [1:11:28] safety and you know, the fact [1:11:30] that, you know, you can just be [1:11:32] going and enjoying the park and [1:11:34] you know, an officer from [1:11:36] the San Diego Police Department [1:11:37] can just come up and like [1:11:39] basically slam your face into [1:11:41] the ground. [1:11:42] You know, and brutally assault [1:11:45] you and then you get charged [1:11:47] with something. [1:11:48] So it's just interesting [1:11:49] the things that take place that [1:11:51] isn't really of concern to [1:11:53] people who you know, those are [1:11:55] your constituents like Raul [1:11:57] Campo. [1:11:58] But you know, that's just [1:11:58] the way the business goes. [1:12:05] Good job involved Suzy or [1:12:05] Gonzalez Walden people you [1:12:09] can't read the person Sage [1:12:12] Thank you. [1:12:13] You'll have two minutes. [1:12:14] Please proceed. [1:12:15] Hi, my name is Sage Consultant. [1:12:17] Well, I am the chair of Choice [1:12:20] Valley Community Planning [1:12:21] Group. [1:12:22] I'm speaking to this in favor [1:12:24] because obviously we all need [1:12:26] more money for Parks and Rec. [1:12:29] One of the issues that our [1:12:31] community has is that finding [1:12:33] what the metric is for each [1:12:36] district for parks has been [1:12:39] difficult to figure out. [1:12:41] So I have brought you each [1:12:44] something to look at. [1:12:45] This is called the Trust for [1:12:47] Public Land. [1:12:49] This is a nationwide [1:12:50] organization that that really [1:12:53] just does a metric And in San [1:12:55] Diego we rate pretty low for [1:12:57] equity. [1:12:58] So you know, the other piece is [1:13:02] next week we're speaking over [1:13:03] radio towers and this is a 31 [1:13:05] acre park. [1:13:06] I know this is not on [1:13:07] the agenda but I am And I [1:13:09] really all the things that are [1:13:12] happening with the presentation [1:13:15] is this is going to be a really [1:13:15] big deal for our community. [1:13:17] So I would like you all to look [1:13:19] at this Public safety is [1:13:24] imperative in our community And [1:13:26] if you consider public safety [1:13:27] being clean air places to play, [1:13:31] things for children to do and [1:13:34] ways to invest in our children [1:13:35] in our community this is this [1:13:39] is for for our community really [1:13:41] important. [1:13:42] I find it interesting my [1:13:43] council member isn't here today [1:13:45] and this is what we're talking [1:13:46] about. [1:13:47] >> So thank you. [1:13:50] >> Shut up here. [1:13:52] Thank you. [1:13:52] We'll pick that up. [1:13:54] Paul, are you speaking to this [1:13:55] item? [1:13:57] Paul Kruger Are you speaking to [1:13:58] this item? [1:13:59] Okay. [1:13:59] Just wanted to make sure before [1:14:00] I went to virtual public [1:14:02] comment I'm sorry the five [1:14:03] minute timer going to those [1:14:04] participating virtually we have [1:14:06] six speakers in the queue 9885 [1:14:09] If you can please unmute line [1:14:17] 85I can't imagine for you. [1:14:18] >> There you go. [1:14:18] Hi. [1:14:19] Hi there I am. [1:14:20] My name is Joanne Paquette. [1:14:22] I am the secretary and you [1:14:24] officer for Lucky Waller our [1:14:25] Little League that is located [1:14:27] at Montgomery Water Park. [1:14:29] I have to just say that we're [1:14:30] really sad to hear that our [1:14:34] district is being passed up [1:14:34] again this year for the second [1:14:36] time And it's really important [1:14:37] for us not to leave money on [1:14:39] the table especially when a [1:14:40] park with McMurry Waller has so [1:14:42] many things that it needs fix [1:14:44] and we have a playground that [1:14:45] is not ada compliant. [1:14:46] We have parking lots that have [1:14:48] no lights to them or people [1:14:49] can't get broken into them. [1:14:50] We had the Padres come out last [1:14:52] year and yes they donated [1:14:54] $40,000 to have our fields [1:14:55] flattened and modeled so that [1:14:57] our kids could play on this [1:14:57] field. [1:14:58] And this is the first time [1:14:59] since 1969 that these bills are [1:15:01] fixed and we cannot depend on [1:15:04] the charity of organizations to [1:15:06] come in and step in to take [1:15:07] care of what being neglected. [1:15:09] And on top of that, yes, they [1:15:10] came in and they fix those [1:15:11] fields for us but then Parks [1:15:13] and Rec allowed football and [1:15:15] soccer to play on those fields [1:15:16] and so we had to spend [1:15:17] thousands of dollars this year [1:15:18] to fix them again so that they [1:15:20] can be playable for our players [1:15:21] this spring And the season is [1:15:23] almost over and we're going to [1:15:24] have to hand it back over to [1:15:25] football and soccer again. [1:15:27] It is just going to happen [1:15:27] again. [1:15:30] The community has been stepping [1:15:31] up to make sure that our parks [1:15:32] look good but it's not enough [1:15:34] and our kids deserve better and [1:15:36] we deserve the funding and [1:15:37] the funding that's left over [1:15:39] the 300,000 is not even enough [1:15:41] to start working to bring [1:15:43] Montgomery Waller into [1:15:44] compliance. [1:15:45] The playgrounds need to be [1:15:46] fixed. [1:15:47] The lights need to be fixed. [1:15:48] We don't have a scoreboard for [1:15:50] our kids. [1:15:50] We don't have a dog park. [1:15:52] It's not safe. [1:15:53] Our bathrooms are not great. [1:15:55] It's just it's not okay that [1:15:56] every year we get passed up and [1:15:58] our families deserve better. [1:16:00] This is something that I live [1:16:01] in the community, something I [1:16:02] was born there and this is [1:16:04] something that we've been [1:16:04] fighting for every year that I [1:16:06] can remember. [1:16:06] My parents fought for life in [1:16:08] the parking lot. [1:16:08] I'm almost 40 years old and we [1:16:10] still don't have them. [1:16:11] We cannot leave money on [1:16:12] the table anymore and we need [1:16:13] to look at these parks and [1:16:15] these organized actions and [1:16:17] these would be places that kids [1:16:18] can go and have fun in a safe [1:16:20] manner and give them [1:16:22] the opportunity to improve and [1:16:23] to grow because your time has [1:16:25] concluded Becky Rapp is [1:16:27] the next speaker. [1:16:28] >> If you can please unmute. [1:16:31] >> Yes, good afternoon. [1:16:33] My name is Becky Rapp and it's [1:16:35] unfortunate that we are to [1:16:37] the point that we have to [1:16:38] utilize opportunity funds to [1:16:40] help fund parks and rec [1:16:41] centers. [1:16:42] Our communities are being asked [1:16:43] to do more with limited [1:16:44] resources while families [1:16:46] continue to rely on these types [1:16:49] of recreation programs [1:16:50] especially now I do appreciate [1:16:53] the city's commitment to [1:16:54] expanding the recreational [1:16:55] opportunities but we also need [1:16:57] to look at opportunities to [1:16:59] generate additional revenue [1:17:01] without asking taxpayers to pay [1:17:03] more. [1:17:04] One opportunity is stronger [1:17:05] enforcement of laws that [1:17:07] already exist across San Diego [1:17:10] illegal flavored tobacco [1:17:11] products, intoxicating hemp [1:17:12] products and other prohibited [1:17:13] items continue to be sold [1:17:15] openly, often and often in [1:17:19] storefront windows near [1:17:20] neighborhoods and recreation [1:17:22] centers. [1:17:23] These illegal sales undermine [1:17:24] public health, increase youth [1:17:26] exposure and create unnecessary [1:17:28] burdens on our communities. [1:17:30] Stronger enforcement will not [1:17:32] only protect children and [1:17:33] families, it could also [1:17:34] generate substantial revenue [1:17:36] through penalties, fines and [1:17:37] enforcement actions. [1:17:39] >> Those funds could be [1:17:40] reinvested directly into our [1:17:42] recreation system. [1:17:44] Imagine what that could mean. [1:17:47] Recreation centers could expand [1:17:49] afterschool and summer programs [1:17:50] parks that currently lack [1:17:52] adequate lighting could finally [1:17:53] be lit up making them safer and [1:17:56] more accessible during [1:17:57] the evening hours. [1:17:58] Facilities could receive long [1:18:00] overdue maintenance and [1:18:02] neighborhoods with the greatest [1:18:03] needs could benefit from [1:18:05] additional recreational [1:18:06] activities without relying [1:18:08] solely on limited general fund [1:18:11] dollars. [1:18:13] I just encourage the city to [1:18:15] make stronger enforcement of [1:18:17] existing laws as part of its [1:18:19] long term funding strategy for [1:18:21] parks and Rec. [1:18:23] >> Let's put it back into [1:18:24] the community. [1:18:25] Thank you. [1:18:26] Thank you Blair Beakman If you [1:18:27] can please unmute. [1:18:28] >> All right. [1:18:29] Thank you. [1:18:29] We're Beakman. [1:18:34] I think this is about the third [1:18:35] time this item has been here at [1:18:37] Council in committee in [1:18:38] the past month and a half. [1:18:40] Thank you. [1:18:41] It's interesting for items to [1:18:43] come back. [1:18:44] I thought additional funding it [1:18:46] was described today that [1:18:47] additional funding is going to [1:18:48] be going to District eight. [1:18:50] So good luck how that can go to [1:18:51] the park that was described as [1:18:54] needing help. [1:18:57] >> And you know as this is [1:18:58] the third time with this item, [1:19:00] I hope my ideas can be very [1:19:03] much a part of this process in [1:19:04] how we talk about the future of [1:19:06] our tech accountability for [1:19:08] the future of these rec centers [1:19:09] and park systems in San Diego. [1:19:14] It sounds like there's going to [1:19:15] be a lot of new aspects of [1:19:16] surveillance tech coming up and [1:19:19] I think we should be well [1:19:20] prepared that we not only ask [1:19:21] for good surveillance tech but [1:19:23] that we ask for good policies [1:19:24] with the tech. [1:19:26] I think I think we have to [1:19:28] start moving past [1:19:29] the euphemisms of sports [1:19:31] utility lighting and learn to [1:19:33] speak directly to the concept [1:19:35] of biometric technology as an [1:19:37] example and that we're not [1:19:39] afraid to have that subject be [1:19:40] a regular talking point in our [1:19:42] community dialog. [1:19:44] We don't know how to do that [1:19:45] yet but yet biometric tech was [1:19:46] all around us during the era of [1:19:48] covid and in our post-covid era [1:19:51] and yet we don't know how to [1:19:52] practice having that [1:19:53] conversation openly yet. [1:19:55] It's really important to say [1:19:57] that instead of sports utility [1:19:58] lighting and I hope we make [1:19:59] the efforts to do that. [1:20:01] And for all the clamor to [1:20:03] create new tech we have to have [1:20:06] we have that has to be equally [1:20:08] balanced with the concepts of [1:20:09] good policy practices. [1:20:11] And that's all I ask for. [1:20:12] You know, in this sort of [1:20:14] instance, you know how we can [1:20:16] limit our tech is important and [1:20:18] it can do that serve the same [1:20:19] purposes. [1:20:20] But having the good policies in [1:20:22] place just adds that we're [1:20:24] doing things well. [1:20:25] We're doing it responsibly and [1:20:27] holistically. [1:20:29] I mean that's how you build [1:20:30] the park community future and I [1:20:32] hope you take to heart. [1:20:34] Creating good tech policies [1:20:35] with our future tech in our [1:20:37] parks Your time has concluded [1:20:39] and so has the five minute [1:20:40] timer. [1:20:40] We have three speakers in [1:20:41] the queue with their hands [1:20:42] raised. [1:20:43] No additional speakers will be [1:20:44] taken at 700 If you can please [1:20:46] unmute. [1:20:46] Thank you Joy. [1:20:54] Assume that I support this [1:20:56] movement of funds to see [1:20:57] the eight Councilmember Moreno [1:21:01] Ward I think it was just a week [1:21:03] or two ago and I listened so I [1:21:07] strongly support it. [1:21:09] I really liked under the in [1:21:11] the staff report under equal [1:21:14] opportunity contracting info [1:21:17] the way they spelled it out [1:21:20] the whole the steps in [1:21:21] the unfoldment of the process [1:21:23] it just got me to a big yes [1:21:26] real fast. [1:21:27] So if you haven't read that [1:21:29] section I highly recommend send [1:21:30] it. [1:21:33] So and then my next comment is [1:21:35] on the c r g the community [1:21:38] recreation groups Do we know [1:21:42] this is not a judgment? [1:21:43] I'm a little bit in the past [1:21:45] with the recreation councils It [1:21:47] was very bumpy the way it ended [1:21:50] up but do we have enough [1:21:52] transparency monitoring and [1:21:56] oversight of the influence on [1:21:59] funds and so forth The movement [1:22:02] to influence [1:22:02] the recommendations from the c [1:22:05] r g groups and how that is all [1:22:07] handled. [1:22:08] Thank you Kim Desmond because [1:22:12] I'm really excited about you [1:22:14] being called to do work on [1:22:17] the spend down and the scoring [1:22:19] metrics. [1:22:21] Recent Equity Department is [1:22:23] really really needed on that [1:22:26] and you're just going to come [1:22:28] forward with your greatness and [1:22:29] you're going to make it happen. [1:22:31] So I love the Race and Equity [1:22:33] Department. [1:22:34] I was against it sort of it [1:22:36] first being part of the idea. [1:22:39] But you began beginning to be [1:22:40] even better and better and [1:22:41] greater and greater heroes for [1:22:43] me on this important item. [1:22:46] And then of course you MAY have [1:22:47] to cut me off, sweetie. [1:22:49] No grants in a nine, no grants [1:22:55] and your time is concluded. [1:22:56] Francine Maxwell if you can [1:22:58] please unmute Francine Maxwell [1:23:01] Southeastern San Diego resident [1:23:03] Thank you so much for [1:23:04] the presentation and full [1:23:06] support of their request [1:23:09] wanting to make sure that [1:23:11] people go and make sure that [1:23:13] the studies that were done in [1:23:16] earlier years are pulled off [1:23:18] the shelf before we decide to [1:23:19] do another one because [1:23:21] the things that were found [1:23:22] remain the same. [1:23:24] So before we spend more money [1:23:25] on disparities steady let's [1:23:27] make sure that we go to [1:23:28] the shelves and pull off [1:23:29] the programing equity study [1:23:31] within the parking rec desist [1:23:36] system and we MAY need to [1:23:37] expand his board another seat [1:23:41] at the table where it comes [1:23:42] from the community Voice Not [1:23:45] people that are paid where [1:23:47] they're going to check a box [1:23:48] and pretty much be able to pull [1:23:50] out what the community has been [1:23:52] knowing for years. [1:23:54] We knew that there were issues [1:23:55] with the hiring that our panels [1:23:58] had relatives on it and so [1:24:01] given that the department knows [1:24:03] it we don't need to sit and [1:24:05] continue to put committees [1:24:07] together and put people that [1:24:08] are going to sit there and talk [1:24:09] about it and not change [1:24:11] the narrative. [1:24:12] So again, looking forward to [1:24:15] more transparency and oversight [1:24:17] within our parking rec. [1:24:19] The system making sure that [1:24:21] when people are turned out they [1:24:22] are thoughtfully removed so [1:24:25] that things can grow. [1:24:27] Also remember that it's [1:24:28] the council office that directs [1:24:29] things that they want to as [1:24:31] well and people that are in [1:24:33] the areas of concern sometimes [1:24:34] you remain the areas of concern [1:24:36] because you need to look at [1:24:38] what's going on behind [1:24:39] the doors in the council office [1:24:40] because our park was stacked to [1:24:43] get a a plaza when we could [1:24:46] have pushed harder and got a [1:24:48] whole skate park across [1:24:49] the street on some land that we [1:24:51] own, all those people are gone. [1:24:53] They attended the meeting and [1:24:55] the park system knew that they [1:24:56] were going to do it and so did [1:24:57] the council office and that [1:24:59] doesn't bode well. [1:25:03] That concludes your time and [1:25:05] our final speakers Peggy Walker [1:25:08] Thank you again As a youth [1:25:10] mentor I support this with a [1:25:12] focus on safety and oversight. [1:25:15] It's important to provide [1:25:16] greater availability of healthy [1:25:18] recreational choices in a safe [1:25:21] place for children, especially [1:25:22] in underserved communities. [1:25:24] This is important at a time [1:25:26] when youth are bombarded with [1:25:28] so many diverse and not always [1:25:30] healthy way to spend their time [1:25:32] when case in point [1:25:34] the overwhelming draft So some [1:25:35] media another scores of studies [1:25:38] have shown that when kids live [1:25:39] near dispensaries for example [1:25:41] they are more likely to use [1:25:42] marijuana and as a result have [1:25:45] higher rates of psychosis. [1:25:47] There is a greater prevalence [1:25:48] of dispensary dispensaries and [1:25:51] higher rates of underage use [1:25:53] marijuana use in underserved [1:25:54] communities. [1:25:55] So we need to counterbalance [1:25:57] that with safe and equitable [1:25:59] year round recreational [1:26:00] opportunities for healthy youth [1:26:00] activities. [1:26:04] The interaction and engagement [1:26:07] Thank you again. [1:26:08] Thank you. [1:26:09] And that concludes public [1:26:10] comment on this item. [1:26:11] >> All right. [1:26:12] Thank you. [1:26:12] City Clerk. [1:26:13] An item like this I would [1:26:14] normally go to the chair of [1:26:15] the Community Neighborhood [1:26:16] services but we're here a [1:26:17] second time because of issues [1:26:19] raised by District eight So I'm [1:26:20] going to start out with council [1:26:21] member Moreno. [1:26:22] >> Thank you. [1:26:24] I want to thank our Parks and [1:26:26] Rec staff and [1:26:27] the administration for your [1:26:29] work on this revision and also [1:26:31] to my colleagues for [1:26:32] understanding my concerns on [1:26:34] this item. [1:26:35] When it was heard last week at [1:26:36] Council the opportunity Fund is [1:26:39] a special revenue fund created [1:26:41] by the Parks and Rec Department [1:26:43] to reduce historical [1:26:44] disparities in recreation [1:26:47] programing a goal that I [1:26:48] strongly support In 2021 [1:26:50] the City of San Diego released [1:26:53] their Park Master Plan and [1:26:55] the Performance Audit of Equity [1:26:59] and Recreation programing both [1:26:59] identified inequities related [1:27:01] to park access and recreation [1:27:04] programing across the city. [1:27:06] The performance audit [1:27:10] recommendation recommendations [1:27:11] six states that the Park and [1:27:12] Rec Department should a [1:27:15] developed document and [1:27:16] implement a plan for directing [1:27:18] resources including any equity [1:27:21] based funding towards specific [1:27:23] steps to eliminate identified [1:27:25] disparities. [1:27:28] The Opportunity Fund was [1:27:29] created in direct response to [1:27:33] that recommendation and it's [1:27:35] deeply troubling that the fund [1:27:36] itself is now reproducing [1:27:39] the disparities it was designed [1:27:40] to fix sit Since its inception [1:27:44] in fiscal year 24, District [1:27:46] eight has consistently received [1:27:48] a disproportionately low share [1:27:50] of opportunity fund allocations [1:27:53] compared to other historically [1:27:55] underserved districts. [1:27:57] The numbers speak for [1:27:58] themselves in fiscal year 24, [1:28:01] District eight received 9% of [1:28:03] the total opportunity Fund [1:28:05] allocation In fiscal year 25, [1:28:08] District eight got 24% in [1:28:10] fiscal year 26 District eight [1:28:13] got 12% Fiscal year 27 we're [1:28:18] getting 26% and this is only [1:28:20] after this revision and only [1:28:23] with additional funds Over four [1:28:26] years District eight has [1:28:28] averaged roughly 18% of a fund [1:28:32] explicitly designed to address [1:28:34] underserved communities. [1:28:37] To me that's a continuation of [1:28:39] the same neglect these funds [1:28:41] were created for and it's [1:28:44] unacceptable. [1:28:47] >> I also want to address [1:28:48] the issue of unspent rec center [1:28:51] funds. [1:28:52] When this item was first [1:28:53] brought forward, District eight [1:28:57] had $1.2 million in funds and [1:29:00] it was these exact funds that [1:29:02] are obstructing my park and [1:29:04] RECs from being considered for [1:29:06] the opportunity fund Yet [1:29:08] the money has not been spent. [1:29:11] It was those unspent funds that [1:29:13] disqualified our parks from [1:29:15] being considered for [1:29:16] opportunity fund dollars. [1:29:19] I stated last time and I still [1:29:21] have it I have an invoice for [1:29:23] $34,000 for a scoreboard that [1:29:26] Little League families have [1:29:27] advocated for years. [1:29:29] Montgomery Waller Park has [1:29:33] $302,000 in identified needs [1:29:35] with funds that have not been [1:29:38] spent. [1:29:39] The San Diego American Memorial [1:29:41] Park Little League plays on [1:29:43] baseball fields that need laser [1:29:45] leveling clay for the bases [1:29:48] proper fencing to allow for [1:29:49] landscape maintenance and [1:29:51] additional shading In this [1:29:53] revision memorial park will not [1:29:55] will now receive some funds but [1:29:58] absolutely not enough to [1:30:00] address the full scope of what [1:30:02] the fields need. [1:30:04] My residents deserve the same [1:30:05] quality of parks and recreation [1:30:07] programs that other that other [1:30:11] communities across this city [1:30:12] take for granted. [1:30:13] The opportunity funds exist [1:30:15] precisely to close the gap and [1:30:18] right now it's falling short of [1:30:19] that promise for District [1:30:20] eight. [1:30:22] I disagree with the historical [1:30:24] trajectory of priority [1:30:25] prioritization that has been [1:30:28] presented because District [1:30:30] eight deserves more. [1:30:33] I do want to thank our Chief of [1:30:36] race and equity Can Kim Desmond [1:30:38] and I look forward I look [1:30:38] forward to looking into [1:30:42] the process that these [1:30:44] opportunity funds get allocated [1:30:45] . [1:30:47] The committee members that are [1:30:49] sitting on the committee that [1:30:52] gets to decide how these funds [1:30:54] are being spent which were to [1:30:56] items that I brought up at [1:30:58] the last meeting. [1:30:59] When are you proposing to come [1:31:01] back to this Council with your [1:31:03] findings? [1:31:06] >> So I think we can sketch out [1:31:07] a timeline what Parks and Rec [1:31:09] for f y 28 as looking at some [1:31:12] of these factors I think it [1:31:13] deserves some critique to make [1:31:15] sure we're getting it right so [1:31:17] we can come back with a [1:31:18] timeline when we get with Parks [1:31:19] and Rec If that suffices. [1:31:21] Okay so we don't know yet. [1:31:22] It could be a month. [1:31:24] It could be seven months. [1:31:25] That's right. [1:31:28] It's up to the administration. [1:31:32] >> Councilmember I think that's [1:31:33] fair. [1:31:34] The timeline is somewhat [1:31:34] indeterminate right now. [1:31:35] However, we anticipate that an [1:31:38] updated process including [1:31:39] members of the Opportunity Fund [1:31:42] kind of committee would be in [1:31:44] place in time for development [1:31:45] of the fy 28 budget. [1:31:47] So I know that you will not be [1:31:49] sitting here next year but [1:31:50] whoever succeeds you should [1:31:52] have the benefit of having some [1:31:55] folks from the draft team [1:31:56] sitting on that committee when [1:31:58] they see their fy 28 numbers [1:31:59] presented to you. [1:32:00] >> Wonderful. [1:32:00] And so I would just like to [1:32:01] read into the record [1:32:02] the committee member titles We [1:32:05] and these are all city of San [1:32:06] Diego associate manager analyst [1:32:09] a district manager, an area [1:32:11] manager, a senior management [1:32:12] analyst supervising rec [1:32:15] specialist, a senior park [1:32:17] ranger and I think recently [1:32:18] added a philanthropic public [1:32:21] partner into that. [1:32:23] These are the folks that get to [1:32:25] decide how much funding is [1:32:26] being disbursed And obviously [1:32:28] the city council puts [1:32:30] the parameters as to what is [1:32:33] puts the approves [1:32:35] the parameters So definitely [1:32:37] something that needs to be [1:32:38] looked at with a finer lens. [1:32:42] Also Council Councilmember [1:32:44] Foster at the last meeting [1:32:46] brought up the fact that he [1:32:47] would wanted to see a funding [1:32:50] allocations for these park and [1:32:52] RECs at during the budget [1:32:54] process which I very much [1:32:56] welcome. [1:32:58] So with that I would like to [1:33:03] make an amendment to [1:33:04] the staff's recommendation if I [1:33:07] could find it here. [1:33:09] So in section four and I'll [1:33:12] read this authorize the chief [1:33:14] financial Officer to [1:33:15] appropriate and expend 100,000 [1:33:18] from the surf cubs Ports llc [1:33:20] percentage ground lease [1:33:22] payments scheduled for delivery [1:33:24] into the Opportunity Fund for [1:33:26] fiscal year 2028 Disbursement [1:33:28] and redirect it to the fiscal [1:33:31] year 2027 opportunity budget to [1:33:34] be allocated to Montgomery [1:33:37] Waller Little League for their [1:33:39] scoreboard at $34,000 and [1:33:42] allocate the remainder all [1:33:47] across District eight. [1:33:52] >> Let me see Scuse me Sorry [1:33:58] once again to allocate to [1:33:59] Montgomery Waller Little League [1:34:03] for their scoreboard at $34,000 [1:34:08] and allocate evenly. [1:34:17] >> Sorry can't even read my own [1:34:19] notes to allocate evenly across [1:34:21] all eight city rec centers and [1:34:25] Council District eight at [1:34:26] the amount of 8250 each and [1:34:29] that will be my modification to [1:34:32] the motion And I was I and I [1:34:34] apologize I do want to thank my [1:34:37] colleague Council member Shani [1:34:40] Leo Rivera for proposing [1:34:40] the $100,000 from the Surf Club [1:34:44] Boards llc percentage ground [1:34:46] lease payment. [1:34:47] Thank you for that [1:34:48] recommendation. [1:34:49] I will note that District four [1:34:52] and District nine are receiving [1:34:56] $250,000 of opportunity funds [1:34:58] which they 1,000% deserve. [1:35:01] District eight is only getting [1:35:04] $150,000 this year and that's [1:35:05] because of the $100,000 that my [1:35:08] colleague was able to identify. [1:35:10] If not, we would only be [1:35:12] getting $54,000. [1:35:15] It's my district, my community, [1:35:17] very underserved community and [1:35:18] I will always fight tooth and [1:35:20] nail to make sure that we get [1:35:22] our fair share. [1:35:22] So I hope to see if I I'll [1:35:25] finish up next year as a member [1:35:28] of the public I hope to see [1:35:30] the opportunity funds being [1:35:31] dispersed across all very much [1:35:34] needed communities evenly and [1:35:38] proportionately as well [1:35:39] including Linda Vista. [1:35:42] I will out of that one So thank [1:35:43] you all right. [1:35:46] Thank you, Councilmember [1:35:46] Moreno. [1:35:47] So we have a motion as amended [1:35:49] and we'll get that up on [1:35:50] the screen. [1:35:51] >> I don't maybe hard copies We [1:35:54] didn't get an email so yeah [1:35:55] we'll get through All council [1:35:57] members know what the amended [1:35:58] motion is. [1:36:01] >> So with that we'll go to [1:36:02] Council Member Campbell. [1:36:03] The Chair Thank you so much. [1:36:05] Thank you so much. [1:36:06] Council PRESIDENT There's [1:36:10] 34,000 for the scoreboard. [1:36:11] Is that part of the 12,500 each [1:36:15] for the eight rec center areas [1:36:18] in District eight or is that an [1:36:21] additional funding from [1:36:23] somewhere else? [1:36:26] Thank you for the question. [1:36:27] I do want to clarify since you [1:36:28] made the motion that as part of [1:36:30] the budget revision that we did [1:36:32] for Montgomery Waller we did [1:36:33] incorporate the repairs to [1:36:36] the scoreboard as part of their [1:36:38] budget So it has already [1:36:38] included utilize in their [1:36:40] recreation center fund budgets [1:36:41] just in case that helps with [1:36:43] your amendment. [1:36:45] But the 34,000 is separate than [1:36:48] the 12,500 that we originally [1:36:50] recommended for each of the rec [1:36:52] centers and Council District [1:36:54] eight That is incorrect. [1:36:57] Councilmember Campbell our [1:36:58] colleague Shani Lowe Rivera [1:36:59] discovered that we could [1:37:01] potentially put $100,000 of [1:37:03] surf club funding So out of [1:37:05] those $100,000 the staff is [1:37:07] proposing to divide up evenly [1:37:09] into eight council into eight [1:37:12] Council District eight parking [1:37:15] Rex Right for a total of about [1:37:15] 12,500. [1:37:17] What I'm proposing is we take [1:37:19] that 100,000 we fund the 34,000 [1:37:20] for that. [1:37:24] So I'm not taking money out of [1:37:26] anywhere else than what is [1:37:28] already being proposed Out of [1:37:30] the 100,000 we take 34 and we [1:37:33] put it towards the scoreboard [1:37:35] at Montgomery Waller and [1:37:36] the remainder which is roughly [1:37:39] 64,000 which equates to about [1:37:42] 8250 divided up to the eight. [1:37:44] So nothing there's no extra [1:37:45] money coming out of anywhere. [1:37:46] It's the 100,000 that clarifies [1:37:51] it for me. [1:37:52] Is that your understanding? [1:37:54] Good afternoon Andy Field Parks [1:37:55] and Recreation Director Yes, we [1:37:57] understand we take the first [1:37:59] portion of 100,000 towards [1:38:01] the scoreboard then divide [1:38:02] the remainder across the eight [1:38:04] sites We got you. [1:38:05] No problem. [1:38:06] Thank you. [1:38:07] Okay, Thanks you guys. [1:38:08] I understand completely and I'm [1:38:09] happy to second the motion. [1:38:11] >> All right. [1:38:12] We have a motion by council [1:38:13] member Moreno Marina which was [1:38:15] an amendment amended to [1:38:17] the staff recommendation and a [1:38:18] second by Councilmember [1:38:19] Campbell. [1:38:20] We'll go next to council member [1:38:21] Eli Rivera. [1:38:22] All right. [1:38:23] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT [1:38:25] Vic Sayre for the presentation [1:38:26] and all that work for Parks and [1:38:28] Rec. [1:38:28] I appreciate the work that [1:38:30] Councilmember Moreno did [1:38:32] between last evening and this [1:38:33] meeting in partnership with [1:38:35] Parks and Rec and the Mayor's [1:38:36] office to get to where we are [1:38:39] today. [1:38:41] I think this is an important [1:38:42] conversation about the way that [1:38:44] the Opportunity Fund is working [1:38:45] in practice Now the idea behind [1:38:47] it is incredibly important and [1:38:49] that it starts with recognizing [1:38:51] that there are rec centers in [1:38:53] San Diego that have not been [1:38:55] given the opportunity to [1:38:57] succeed and that we have a [1:38:59] system in place that made it [1:39:00] more and more difficult for [1:39:01] them to ever catch up. [1:39:04] It's that that is reminiscent [1:39:06] of the way many things work in [1:39:08] our city and opportunity And i [1:39:11] think is it is a really smart [1:39:13] idea And now it's about making [1:39:15] sure that the idea aligns with [1:39:17] the vision that we have for our [1:39:19] our rec centers and the goals [1:39:22] of this specific program. [1:39:26] So if I really do believe that [1:39:30] if we properly frame [1:39:31] the opportunity fund we can [1:39:32] figure out the ways to to [1:39:34] modify it in a way that [1:39:36] achieves those goals. [1:39:38] There's going to need to be [1:39:39] some rightsizing and some [1:39:40] improvements, some recognition [1:39:41] that the way that things are [1:39:44] being operationalized on [1:39:45] the ground impacts ability for [1:39:49] this fund to up to to work as [1:39:52] intended. [1:39:54] But all of that doesn't mean [1:39:57] that the opportunity in itself [1:40:00] it isn't important. [1:40:00] I think it's important for [1:40:01] members of the public to [1:40:02] recognize I also did want to [1:40:03] just make note that [1:40:06] Councilmember Foster is on [1:40:07] official business right now. [1:40:09] He is not shy about ensuring [1:40:12] that District four gets its [1:40:14] fair share and was an important [1:40:19] part of the conversation to [1:40:20] ensure that District four [1:40:21] wasn't left out of [1:40:24] the conversation as this [1:40:25] opportunity fund as [1:40:26] the decisions were being made [1:40:28] and that they didn't get any [1:40:30] less than what they were [1:40:30] deserving of just because we [1:40:33] heard some some comments and I [1:40:34] want to make sure that was on [1:40:35] the record as well. [1:40:36] The last thing I wanted to say [1:40:38] is that I think the $100,000 [1:40:40] that we were able to to deploy [1:40:42] here to address some of [1:40:45] Councilmember Moreno's concerns [1:40:46] and the direct result of this [1:40:47] this council demanding more and [1:40:50] demanding better from those who [1:40:51] have the ability to pay more [1:40:53] and treat the city better. [1:40:55] It's an example of us leaning [1:40:57] into that and then deploying [1:41:00] that additional revenue in a [1:41:02] way that serves a part of [1:41:03] the city that's been the most [1:41:05] left behind over the years. [1:41:07] And you know in this case it's [1:41:09] just $100,000. [1:41:11] So not transformational from a [1:41:13] city budget perspective but it [1:41:15] also demonstrates that every [1:41:16] single dollar that we get in [1:41:17] that sort of way matters that [1:41:21] the $34,000 that'll be deployed [1:41:21] for the scoreboard is going to [1:41:23] make a margin. [1:41:24] A very big difference for [1:41:25] the families who are at [1:41:28] Montgomery Waller and we can't [1:41:32] lose sight of that. [1:41:32] That's just my way of saying [1:41:34] that when we are entering into [1:41:35] negotiations with any party [1:41:38] with the city we need to [1:41:39] squeeze as much out as possible [1:41:43] because on the other end of [1:41:44] that equation are families who [1:41:46] will benefit from that And in [1:41:49] this case it's $100,000 It'll [1:41:50] feed into the opportunity fund [1:41:51] and those hundred thousand [1:41:52] dollars are being deployed to [1:41:53] benefit the residents of [1:41:54] District eight And in other [1:41:56] circumstances there are similar [1:41:59] positive outcomes that can be [1:42:02] derived from us simply [1:42:03] demanding more when we are in [1:42:06] negotiations especially with [1:42:08] very wealthy entities that are [1:42:10] making a lot of money from [1:42:11] their from from the agreements [1:42:14] that they have from the city. [1:42:15] So I'm glad that this is being [1:42:18] this is being able to be [1:42:19] deployed in this way But we're [1:42:21] in a better place than we were [1:42:22] a couple of weeks ago. [1:42:22] I appreciate the work that was [1:42:24] done to get to this place and [1:42:26] look forward to more [1:42:27] opportunities to make sure that [1:42:29] we're that we're doing right by [1:42:30] residents who were not done [1:42:32] right by in the past. [1:42:36] >> And that will conclude my [1:42:37] comments. [1:42:38] Council PRESIDENT Thank you. [1:42:39] All right. [1:42:40] Thank you, Councilmember Rivera [1:42:42] I'll just out of course be [1:42:44] supportive of this and I [1:42:45] appreciate Park and Rec in [1:42:48] everyone who pivoted after [1:42:50] the input from the first [1:42:53] meeting of this. [1:42:55] You did an awful lot of work on [1:42:57] that and have reevaluated a lot [1:42:59] of your processes. [1:43:00] There's more work to be done as [1:43:02] you gain this And what I want [1:43:05] to focus on something that I [1:43:06] think Councilmember Foster [1:43:07] pointed out about having this [1:43:11] information not as a separate [1:43:12] item after the budget is [1:43:14] already approved but part and [1:43:16] parcel of the budget because [1:43:18] today we have very little room. [1:43:20] The opportunity fund is x [1:43:21] dollars and the question is how [1:43:22] are you going to divvy up those [1:43:23] x dollars if count if [1:43:24] Councilmember El Overhead [1:43:29] secured that hundred thousand [1:43:29] it would have been a much [1:43:30] different very painful [1:43:31] conversation today. [1:43:33] So having that information [1:43:34] about even if it's only draft [1:43:36] in terms of the rec center fund [1:43:39] the opportunity fund during [1:43:41] the budget conversations [1:43:42] because a few dollars every [1:43:45] dollar is painful that we don't [1:43:47] give to Parks and Rec given how [1:43:48] much you have to do and how [1:43:49] much is on your plate but a few [1:43:51] dollars taken from that [1:43:52] operating budget for dedicated [1:43:54] funds for individual rec [1:43:56] centers and under resourced [1:43:57] communities could have made a [1:43:59] heck of a lot of difference. [1:44:00] But we didn't know we didn't [1:44:02] have those tools available to [1:44:03] us. [1:44:03] So one more thing to add to [1:44:06] your list of how we do f y 28 [1:44:08] differently and maybe have you [1:44:10] at least give us [1:44:11] the opportunity or council [1:44:13] the opportunity that more [1:44:14] flexibility and weigh the pros [1:44:17] and cons to benefits and [1:44:19] the cost of any of those [1:44:21] decisions going forward. [1:44:23] So thank you for your good work [1:44:23] . [1:44:24] Thank you for that And again [1:44:26] I'll throw in a to rec centers [1:44:29] rec councils in district one [1:44:31] through in money towards that [1:44:32] opportunity fund beyond [1:44:33] the regular process and oh that [1:44:39] you created the opportunity to [1:44:40] find out of scratch and maybe [1:44:42] this is a good chance to kind [1:44:43] of revisit the thinking that [1:44:45] went into the opportunity funds [1:44:46] now that we've got a few years [1:44:49] under our belt. [1:44:50] So anyway, thank you. [1:44:52] Thank you to COUNCILMAN Moreno [1:44:53] and everybody who weighed in [1:44:55] last time and weighed in this [1:44:57] afternoon and so that we do [1:44:59] have the motion that is now up [1:45:01] on the screen I think you heard [1:45:03] it said out loud a couple of [1:45:04] times. [1:45:07] So the key being directing [1:45:11] 34,000 directly to [1:45:12] the Montgomery Recreation [1:45:13] Center for the scoreboard and [1:45:15] spreading the remainder of that [1:45:17] 100,000 evenly across all eight [1:45:19] recreation centers and council [1:45:21] district in the $8,250 each. [1:45:25] So with that not to anybody [1:45:27] else in life, please call [1:45:28] the roll. [1:45:29] >> That's right the voting [1:45:30] system Please cast your vote [1:45:34] That passes unanimously 7 to 0 [1:45:36] with Councilmember Foster and [1:45:36] Councilmember a little bit [1:45:38] absent. [1:45:39] >> Thank you, Council [1:45:39] PRESIDENT. [1:45:40] All right. [1:45:41] Thank you, Clerk. [1:45:43] So with that for the next two [1:45:44] items we're going to update [1:45:46] the order. [1:45:47] We will first hear the item two [1:45:50] establish the Affordable [1:45:51] Housing Preservation Fund which [1:45:53] is item one as the housing [1:45:56] authority. [1:45:56] Then we will hear item 402 from [1:46:01] the city Planning Department as [1:46:03] the City Council upon inclusion [1:46:05] of those two items we will [1:46:07] Return of Housing Authority to [1:46:09] continue with today's business [1:46:10] . [1:46:11] So with that we will now [1:46:12] adjourn as the City Council and [1:46:14] convene as a special housing [1:46:16] Authority meeting Clerk Please [1:46:18] introduce Housing Authority [1:46:19] Item ha1 of you council [1:46:22] PRESIDENT Item one is to [1:46:25] establish an affordable housing [1:46:26] preservation Fund and amend [1:46:28] the San Diego Housing [1:46:29] Commission and Fiscal Year 2026 [1:46:31] budget to accept City of San [1:46:33] Diego Neighborhood Enhancement [1:46:34] fee funds for affordable [1:46:36] housing preservation. [1:46:37] If you'd like to speak on this [1:46:38] item please be sure to submit [1:46:40] the speaker up to the front of [1:46:41] the room in the clear box Or if [1:46:42] you're participating remotely [1:46:44] please be sure to raise your [1:46:45] hand by pressing Star nine or [1:46:46] the raise your hand icon. [1:46:48] Thank you. [1:46:49] All right. [1:46:50] Thank you so staff, please [1:46:51] introduce yourself for [1:46:52] the record and let us know how [1:46:54] much time you need. [1:46:55] >> Good afternoon, Councilor [1:46:56] Senior Vice PRESIDENT, Real [1:46:57] estate for Senior Housing [1:46:59] Commission minutes, please. [1:47:00] >> All right, When you're ready [1:47:05] you staff is recommending that [1:47:06] the housing authority of [1:47:07] the city of San Diego authorize [1:47:08] a senior housing commission to [1:47:09] establish an affordable housing [1:47:10] preservation fund and amend [1:47:12] the Housing Commission's fiscal [1:47:13] year 2026 budget to accept [1:47:21] $5,913,554 instead of sending [1:47:21] only renouncing funds that will [1:47:21] be transferred from the city of [1:47:22] San Diego to the Housing [1:47:23] Commission to be deposited into [1:47:25] the Housing Commission's [1:47:25] Affordable Housing Preservation [1:47:27] Fund. [1:47:28] These are crucial, crucial next [1:47:29] steps to help preserve [1:47:30] the affordable rental homes [1:47:31] citywide. [1:47:33] We also support the City [1:47:34] Council approved Affordable [1:47:34] housing preservation strategy [1:47:39] that was a commission study [1:47:39] preserving affordable housing [1:47:40] in the city of San Diego [1:47:41] released MAY 2020 estimated [1:47:43] that more than 13,000 units [1:47:45] could become unaffordable by [1:47:49] 2040 4200 restricted units MAY [1:47:49] lose protections and up to [1:47:50] 9250. [1:47:52] Naturally, affordable homes [1:47:54] will become unaffordable due to [1:47:56] market pressures without [1:48:00] without intervention 35% of all [1:48:01] new production or simply [1:48:03] replacing have lost [1:48:03] affordability. [1:48:06] On FEBRUARY 3rd, 2025 City [1:48:07] Council approved a deed [1:48:08] restricted Affordable Housing [1:48:10] Preservation Ordinance [1:48:10] spearheaded by Councilmember [1:48:12] Fabian Moreno. [1:48:13] Then on APRIL 10th 2025 at [1:48:15] the request of City Council [1:48:17] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee, chair of [1:48:20] the Land Use and Housing [1:48:20] Committee staff presented an [1:48:22] informational report about [1:48:23] the potential for the creation [1:48:24] of an Affordable Housing [1:48:25] Preservation fund Along with [1:48:27] the options for its [1:48:28] implementation, the committee [1:48:30] asked us to return with [1:48:31] recommendations and funding [1:48:32] models going forward On [1:48:34] SEPTEMBER 4th, 2025 staff [1:48:36] returned to eliminate with a [1:48:37] range of preservation [1:48:38] strategies to create and [1:48:39] implement an affordable housing [1:48:40] preservation fund. [1:48:42] The committee unanimously [1:48:43] unanimously approved [1:48:44] recommending that the City [1:48:45] Council take the staff [1:48:46] recommended actions to [1:48:47] establish an affordable housing [1:48:48] preservation fund. [1:48:51] The committee requested [1:48:52] the staff take the actions [1:48:53] shown on the slide start of [1:48:56] research to various funding [1:48:57] models available to create and [1:48:58] preserve affordable housing and [1:48:59] naturally occurring housing In [1:49:01] San Diego we spoke with [1:49:03] industry professionals and [1:49:04] consulted with other localities [1:49:05] Determine the best options for [1:49:06] the city of San Diego. [1:49:08] We return to City Council to [1:49:09] request the approvals needed to [1:49:10] establish the fund and transfer [1:49:12] the neighborhood enhancement [1:49:13] funds to the Housing Commission [1:49:18] in its approval of the City of [1:49:19] San Diego's fiscal year 2026 [1:49:21] budget, the City Council [1:49:22] allocated $5 million for [1:49:24] the Neighborhood Enhancement [1:49:25] Fund to the Affordable Housing [1:49:26] Preservation Fund since that [1:49:29] council action, [1:49:30] the Neighborhood announcement [1:49:31] Fund has grown to $5,913,544 as [1:49:35] new as additional new [1:49:36] developers paid for the Bond [1:49:38] Housing Commission staff have [1:49:39] worked with City of San Diego [1:49:40] staff to bring a companion item [1:49:41] to the city council to approve [1:49:43] a transfer of funds from [1:49:44] the city of San Diego Fund 2000 [1:49:48] Commission for the fiscal year [1:49:48] 2026 Sources and uses of funds [1:49:50] proposed for approval were not [1:49:52] included in the Housing [1:49:53] Commission's housing. [1:49:53] The Housing Commission's [1:49:54] Housing authority approved [1:49:57] fiscal year 2026 budget. [1:50:00] The Housing Commission is [1:50:00] requesting approval from [1:50:01] the Housing Authority to amend [1:50:02] the Housing Commission's fiscal [1:50:04] Year 2026 budget to authorize [1:50:06] the Housing Commission to [1:50:07] accept 5,000,913 $1,154 from [1:50:11] any fund for Affordable Housing [1:50:12] Preservation Fund activities to [1:50:14] acquire and preserve both deed [1:50:15] restricted and naturally [1:50:16] occurring affordable housing [1:50:17] properties. [1:50:21] The Housing Commission's [1:50:23] proposal for 26 Budget [1:50:23] Amendment does not commit any [1:50:25] funds to any specific strategy [1:50:28] program or acquisition or [1:50:30] individual property [1:50:31] acquisitions, Bond [1:50:32] authorizations and Preservation [1:50:34] Fund program approvals will be [1:50:36] brought back to the housing [1:50:37] Commission Board of [1:50:38] Commissioners, the Housing [1:50:39] Authority and or City Council [1:50:41] for separate approval before [1:50:42] any funds are expended on a [1:50:44] specific project. [1:50:46] The Housing Authority and or [1:50:47] City Council will set the final [1:50:48] policy strategies for [1:50:50] the Preservation Fund at a [1:50:51] later date as the fund grows [1:50:53] and additional types of [1:50:54] investments are sought, Those [1:50:56] proposals and any changes to [1:50:58] preservation fund activities [1:50:59] will be brought to the Housing [1:51:00] Authority or City Council for [1:51:02] approval. [1:51:04] Staff recommend that [1:51:05] the Housing authority of [1:51:06] the City of San Diego take [1:51:07] the actions detailed in staff [1:51:08] report and shown on the slide. [1:51:14] Thank you for your time. [1:51:15] Francis Barros and I are able [1:51:16] to answer any questions and [1:51:18] that concludes our [1:51:19] presentation. [1:51:20] All right. [1:51:20] Thank you for the work and [1:51:21] thank you for the presentation. [1:51:22] Please proceed with public [1:51:23] comment. [1:51:25] Thank you. [1:51:25] Council PRESIDENT If I can have [1:51:26] Paul Krueger please come [1:51:27] forward after that as allegedly [1:51:30] Adrienne and then Anthony Ross [1:51:32] you can please come forward to [1:51:33] the other reserved seats at [1:51:34] the front. [1:51:34] Anthony That would be greatly [1:51:35] appreciated as well as Agenda [1:51:38] You will have two minutes. [1:51:40] >> Please proceed. [1:51:41] I put in a slip for this and a [1:51:43] slip for the next one that i [1:51:44] would like almost the same. [1:51:46] Would it be easier if I just [1:51:47] made one presentation for four [1:51:50] minutes and not on the next? [1:51:51] The items are being taken [1:51:52] separately so then your [1:51:54] comments on Disappear. [1:51:55] Thank you. [1:51:55] Thank you. [1:51:56] I just wanted to call your [1:51:58] attention to how significant [1:52:00] this is in terms of unintended [1:52:02] consequences of programs. [1:52:04] The city council has approved [1:52:06] and refused to modify over [1:52:10] years of concern. [1:52:11] The bonus idea program [1:52:13] specifically removed from our [1:52:15] housing stock Affordable [1:52:17] starter housing at 750,000 or [1:52:21] more. [1:52:22] These homes are considered very [1:52:25] affordable and they're in [1:52:26] neighborhoods where housing is [1:52:28] affordable. [1:52:29] This policy allowed developers [1:52:32] to turn these homes into rental [1:52:35] units and build multiple units [1:52:37] in the backyards where these [1:52:38] bonus adu units affordable. [1:52:41] No they were not. [1:52:43] For every market rate unit [1:52:45] the developer got they were [1:52:47] allowed or required to build a [1:52:52] quote unquote affordable unit. [1:52:54] Those affordable units include [1:52:56] moderate rate housing that [1:52:58] rents for up to people who make [1:53:01] more than 110% of the average [1:53:05] median income for five years. [1:53:08] We urge this council to revisit [1:53:10] these rules and require [1:53:12] developers to build truly low [1:53:14] income housing and this council [1:53:16] did not do that. [1:53:18] The other issue here is what [1:53:20] could lead communities has done [1:53:22] to existing apartment buildings [1:53:25] that because they're older or [1:53:29] more affordable those those [1:53:30] units examples in utc and [1:53:34] Golden Hill were demolished to [1:53:36] make room for developments that [1:53:38] charge $2,700 for a one bedroom [1:53:43] unit with quote unquote [1:53:44] affordable units costing more [1:53:47] than $2,500. [1:53:49] We wouldn't be here if you [1:53:51] would Please take time to [1:53:53] review the consequences of [1:53:55] these programs They are pointed [1:53:57] out to you. [1:53:58] >> Thank you. [1:54:00] Thank you. [1:54:01] Allegedly under course they [1:54:08] didn't do it. [1:54:08] They need to squeeze out as [1:54:10] much as possible. [1:54:11] Right. [1:54:11] Sean, it's so interesting [1:54:13] because you guys sit here and [1:54:15] you do bring forward items like [1:54:17] this like you're really going [1:54:18] to preserve affordability. [1:54:19] You can't preserve something [1:54:20] that doesn't exist. [1:54:22] So you guys sit here and act [1:54:24] like we're providing affordable [1:54:25] housing. [1:54:27] Is it I mean is it really [1:54:28] affordable even if you need [1:54:29] some kind of voucher, does that [1:54:31] mean it's still affordable? [1:54:33] I mean would that mean it's not [1:54:35] that you make more money to go [1:54:36] in there? [1:54:37] I mean it's like the way you [1:54:39] guys pull wool over people's [1:54:40] eyes to make it seem like what [1:54:41] you're doing is beneficial to [1:54:43] them. [1:54:43] It's so sad because it's like [1:54:44] this $5 million. [1:54:45] >> I mean really what's going [1:54:46] to do your time on acquiring [1:54:47] and preserving like I mean you [1:54:51] guys sit up there with a [1:54:52] straight face. [1:54:53] >> It's so sad because people [1:54:56] are suffering. [1:54:56] You sit up on your dais and you [1:55:00] guys act like you know what [1:55:01] that's like to try and figure [1:55:03] out how you're going to pay [1:55:04] your rent and what's actually [1:55:06] affordable Like when you have [1:55:08] people that are making hundreds [1:55:10] of thousands of dollars and [1:55:12] talking about affordability [1:55:13] until you guys get paid 20 [1:55:15] bucks an hour and you're trying [1:55:17] to make ends meet, I don't [1:55:18] think that you have a right to [1:55:19] talk about that because you [1:55:21] don't have that kind of lived [1:55:22] experience where you would [1:55:23] understand what it's like to [1:55:25] stretch a dollar Instead you [1:55:27] guys come out to the people [1:55:28] time and talk know Sean Do you [1:55:30] know what that's like? [1:55:31] Have you been homeless? [1:55:32] You have for how long? [1:55:36] Right? [1:55:36] And look at you now right? [1:55:39] Do you care about the people [1:55:40] you walk over at night? [1:55:42] You don't. [1:55:43] So I mean you want to sit here [1:55:44] and act like you've been [1:55:45] homeless? [1:55:45] I've been homeless too, but I [1:55:47] actually give a about [1:55:48] the people. [1:55:48] I don't just walk over them and [1:55:50] like Oh my gosh you're such an [1:55:51] eyesore. [1:55:52] Let's move you down the road. [1:55:53] That's what's so sad. [1:55:54] Yes, that's what you guys do. [1:55:57] You don't go in and personally [1:55:59] like encounter these people but [1:56:03] yet you sit up here and decide [1:56:05] what they can and what they [1:56:07] can't afford and that is so [1:56:09] egregious. [1:56:10] >> Anthony please confirm. [1:56:16] Well good afternoon City [1:56:17] Council. [1:56:17] I thought that this I mean it [1:56:22] appeared to be cut and dry to [1:56:23] me but after hearing some of [1:56:25] the testimonies, some of [1:56:26] the members of the public I'm [1:56:28] not exactly sure. [1:56:29] And I think that with regard to [1:56:31] what one of the gentlemen said [1:56:33] earlier with regard to [1:56:34] the unintended consequences, I [1:56:36] think that we should look into [1:56:37] that. [1:56:37] I think that I'm in support of [1:56:40] this item on the contingency [1:56:42] that we look into some of [1:56:44] the unintended consequences [1:56:46] that could happen as a result [1:56:48] of this proposal. [1:56:50] Thank you. [1:56:52] Sorry I'm going to time are [1:56:54] going to those participating [1:56:55] remotely starting with Francine [1:56:57] Maxwell If you can please [1:56:58] unmute Francine that's all [1:57:02] southeastern San Diego any of [1:57:04] these required paragraph two in [1:57:06] our dash 2021 dash 22 to be [1:57:08] used solely to fund recreation [1:57:10] amenities, active [1:57:11] transportation and transit [1:57:13] infrastructure projects. [1:57:15] So 100% no amenities were or [1:57:19] ever will be constructed with [1:57:21] any benefit. [1:57:22] Any money was not spent in any [1:57:24] amenity in communities of [1:57:26] concern or any infrastructure. [1:57:29] 100% of money is now being [1:57:30] proposed to be transferred into [1:57:32] preserving the concentration of [1:57:34] poverty in communities of [1:57:36] concern without needed [1:57:37] infrastructure. [1:57:38] I could have sworn that my [1:57:40] neighbors won their lawsuit [1:57:42] against the city of San Diego [1:57:44] in reference to [1:57:45] the concentration of poverty. [1:57:48] So again we're going to have to [1:57:51] revisit this because it seems [1:57:53] like people have forgotten [1:57:55] about the win that my neighbors [1:57:58] received building projects [1:58:00] without amenities then using [1:58:02] the money meant to improve [1:58:03] the lives of the most [1:58:04] vulnerable but instead ensuring [1:58:07] they are without amenities. [1:58:10] I think that there's something [1:58:11] wrong unless I have just [1:58:14] completely misread this. [1:58:16] So I look forward to [1:58:18] the education that I MAY [1:58:20] receive from the diocese today [1:58:20] . [1:58:22] >> And again let's not forget [1:58:27] about 100% is now being [1:58:28] transferred preserving [1:58:30] the concentration of poverty [1:58:31] because District four is an [1:58:35] area of concern and their [1:58:37] neighbors get together and they [1:58:39] win lawsuits. [1:58:41] >> Thank you for allowing me to [1:58:42] speak. [1:58:43] Thank you. [1:58:44] Next is 8700 If you can please [1:58:46] unmute a joyful two Oh gosh I [1:58:57] thought I was preparing for [1:59:00] this in an unexpected items but [1:59:00] that's not what I need to whine [1:59:03] about or even cry. [1:59:05] Thank you Paul Krueger Thank [1:59:08] you Allegedly Audra Thank you. [1:59:10] Francine Maxwell They all are [1:59:13] telling us things You need to [1:59:15] listen to those statistics [1:59:18] about what's going to happen to [1:59:21] you know, these covenants these [1:59:23] these homes that are a year ago [1:59:27] we looked at this We have a [1:59:29] list of these things, these [1:59:31] restrictive covenant properties [1:59:32] that really didn't go under. [1:59:34] I don't think we've really done [1:59:36] anything dramatically to stop [1:59:37] that. [1:59:42] I really don't But I don't have [1:59:42] the time So I'm just worried. [1:59:47] I was very I love the word [1:59:48] preservation. [1:59:49] You all know that And I really [1:59:53] was all for this whole new I [1:59:54] still am. [1:59:56] But are we missing something? [1:59:59] I think we are and I don't know [2:00:01] what it is so please help me [2:00:04] with that, will you? [2:00:05] So we can do better. [2:00:06] >> Thank you for listening to. [2:00:10] Next is John If you can play [2:00:16] some you Good afternoon City [2:00:17] council It's interesting [2:00:18] the direction it's taken It's [2:00:20] the same direction that I was [2:00:22] going to go which is the most [2:00:24] underserved community and most [2:00:27] struggling is those that are [2:00:28] living on our streets right now [2:00:30] And we have decided to close [2:00:35] the facility that represents [2:00:37] over half of the bathrooms [2:00:39] the only place where you can [2:00:41] wash your personal items and [2:00:44] get your clothes done and [2:00:46] the only place where you can [2:00:47] take a break even a park for [2:00:50] homeless people to go to. [2:00:52] So if this funding is for that [2:00:55] for the purpose of meeting [2:00:56] the needs of underserved [2:00:57] communities I suggest we start [2:00:59] there and then we should go [2:01:01] over to the lot and talk about [2:01:03] what's going on there because [2:01:05] when we envision that we did [2:01:06] not envision it at the density [2:01:08] that it currently is operating [2:01:09] at, we did not envision it [2:01:11] without any ground cover to [2:01:13] relieve you of just any point [2:01:16] or when it rains. [2:01:17] We do not agree to a place that [2:01:19] has no shade and no community [2:01:21] gathering places to relax. [2:01:23] There is and it is divisible [2:01:26] and dense beyond what we ever [2:01:29] imagined were 2 to 300 tents in [2:01:32] one location. [2:01:34] We have zero adult shelters [2:01:37] that are built for purpose or [2:01:39] for that matter that are in [2:01:40] place for anyone who is a [2:01:43] single adult On our streets [2:01:44] right now we've got four [2:01:46] specialty groups. [2:01:46] We've got it for families. [2:01:48] We've got for people with [2:01:49] disabilities people gay, [2:01:50] lesbian. [2:01:51] But if you're a single adult [2:01:52] you get to live in a tent [2:01:54] whether it's a group tent on [2:01:55] asphalt or a tent and then a [2:02:00] lot So I think we need to [2:02:02] rethink our priorities here [2:02:04] because honestly we're kind of [2:02:06] make it some break up ranch [2:02:07] look like a good idea and you [2:02:10] know how I feel about that. [2:02:13] Thank you. [2:02:15] Thank you. [2:02:16] The five minute timer has been [2:02:16] clear. [2:02:17] We have two speakers in [2:02:18] the can. [2:02:18] No additional speakers will be [2:02:19] taken. [2:02:20] That was Blair Beekman and [2:02:21] Natalie Raasch. [2:02:22] Gabler if you can please unmute [2:02:23] I thank you for Beakman Thank [2:02:28] you Public comment today [2:02:29] the previous public comment or [2:02:32] as a lot of words and ideas on [2:02:34] the concept of the future of [2:02:35] the New York Day Center and he [2:02:38] is just the best strongest [2:02:40] voice to really talk about any [2:02:42] possible future for the day [2:02:43] center. [2:02:44] I hope his voice is really [2:02:46] listened to and realize what [2:02:49] we're losing and giving that [2:02:49] up. [2:02:51] I think we understand its [2:02:52] efficiency in giving it up. [2:02:55] He's stating the practicalities [2:02:57] why we need to keep it and work [2:02:59] on concepts like it If we if it [2:03:02] is depended where else are we [2:03:02] going to go All Kruger also [2:03:06] offered really interesting [2:03:07] comments that was seconded by [2:03:10] Anthony Thank you very much I [2:03:13] would like to third that [2:03:14] concept and and the idea that [2:03:17] you're hearing good public [2:03:19] voices on this matter and that [2:03:21] help and I guess to thank our [2:03:23] council persons you know I've [2:03:25] been learning important lessons [2:03:27] from our council person [2:03:28] the Carver that I understand [2:03:30] you guys do care about [2:03:32] affordable housing at this time [2:03:34] I'm better understanding that [2:03:35] what you can be doing towards [2:03:37] that subject towards truly [2:03:39] affordable housing and with [2:03:41] what the groups like path can [2:03:43] do the work that they do has [2:03:46] been nothing short of [2:03:48] miraculous And we really have [2:03:50] to be I hope those [2:03:52] conversations become more and [2:03:54] more clear. [2:03:54] I mean it's more than just [2:03:55] shelters that they offer and [2:03:58] how we build that future is [2:03:59] important from that how do we [2:04:02] again talk about the future of [2:04:03] places like New graduate center [2:04:05] and services for people who [2:04:07] really need it And look how [2:04:10] this funding can be used to for [2:04:14] a truly affordable end and that [2:04:14] you guys have conversations [2:04:15] here on the dsa in those good [2:04:18] terms and good luck in [2:04:19] listening to the public to all [2:04:21] of us who've offered really [2:04:22] interesting comment here today. [2:04:24] >> Thank you. [2:04:25] Thank you, Natalie Rush here [2:04:26] last speaker please on media Hi [2:04:31] Natalie Rashi a lot a lot of [2:04:33] this is kind of confusing [2:04:34] understanding the language [2:04:37] that's being used as a [2:04:40] stakeholder elder And I was you [2:04:43] know, looking at the definition [2:04:44] I consider myself a stakeholder [2:04:46] and I don't know that we are [2:04:49] considered a stakeholder. [2:04:51] Some of us the voices that we [2:04:52] have I think that moving [2:04:56] forward we have to really be [2:04:58] intentional and conscious of [2:05:00] what we choose and how we [2:05:02] choose to build buildings or [2:05:05] build anything that we're [2:05:06] doing. [2:05:07] I was offered a apartment at [2:05:12] Quattro for City Heights. [2:05:13] I drove by there that whoever [2:05:16] designed that that building it [2:05:19] looks like a jail cell. [2:05:20] The side window would be [2:05:23] the freeway of the 15 I [2:05:26] understood in that when we have [2:05:26] to build affordable housing in [2:05:28] areas where there's transits [2:05:31] and such things but I don't [2:05:34] know of anybody who's looked at [2:05:35] that building or some of [2:05:37] the other buildings that are [2:05:38] built. [2:05:38] It really stands out as you're [2:05:42] in affordable housing. [2:05:43] So if we're creating these I [2:05:47] don't know it almost puts a tag [2:05:49] on you again and I don't know [2:05:52] whose intentions are or what [2:05:54] they are when they're building [2:05:55] these places that are supposed [2:05:57] to include or be inclusive to [2:06:01] our community. [2:06:03] And I think that there is there [2:06:09] is definitely we need to re [2:06:11] approach how we move forward in [2:06:15] this new day and age. [2:06:17] Thank you. [2:06:18] >> Thank you. [2:06:19] That does conclude public [2:06:20] comment on this item. [2:06:21] All right. [2:06:22] Thank you City Clerk. [2:06:22] With that we'll turn over to [2:06:24] council members questions, [2:06:25] comments entertain a motion. [2:06:26] We'll start with the chair of [2:06:28] Land Use and Housing Council [2:06:29] PRESIDENT Pro tem I think I was [2:06:31] PRESIDENT And I want to start [2:06:33] off by thanking my colleague [2:06:35] Councilmember Renaud for her [2:06:35] years of leadership and [2:06:36] advocacy as the former chair of [2:06:38] Planning and Housing Committee [2:06:39] in bringing forward [2:06:40] the Preservation Ordinance that [2:06:42] was passed by this council [2:06:44] earlier last year. [2:06:45] This item came before the Land [2:06:48] Use and Housing Committee in [2:06:49] the fall and where we are doing [2:06:52] is taking the next step in [2:06:54] actually putting together a [2:06:55] fund that supports our [2:06:57] affordable housing preservation [2:06:59] ordinance as we acknowledge at [2:07:01] the time the ordinance was [2:07:02] really just one initial step to [2:07:05] move the city's affordable [2:07:06] housing preservation strategy [2:07:07] forward allowing for [2:07:09] opportunities so that as [2:07:10] affordable housing covenants [2:07:11] expired, the city whether [2:07:14] through the Housing Commission [2:07:15] or through partners within [2:07:16] the community who could [2:07:18] participate in this fund could [2:07:20] help and have the opportunity [2:07:22] to preserve existing affordable [2:07:24] housing and to renew their [2:07:26] covenants in the years ahead. [2:07:28] As you've heard from [2:07:29] the presentation, there's been [2:07:30] over 13,000 units that have [2:07:32] been identified with covenants [2:07:34] that would be expiring other [2:07:36] nationally affordable housing [2:07:37] occurring affordable housing [2:07:38] that has been at risk And for [2:07:41] much time the city has focused [2:07:43] heavily primarily on producing [2:07:46] new housing units. [2:07:47] But at the same time we [2:07:48] recognize that just producing [2:07:50] new units doesn't necessarily [2:07:51] ensure that the existing units [2:07:53] with expirations on their [2:07:55] covenants would actually be [2:07:57] protected. [2:07:57] And that's why we're here today [2:07:59] working with the Housing [2:08:00] Commission and Planning [2:08:01] Department, the Neighborhood [2:08:03] Enhancement fee was established [2:08:05] specifically with housing [2:08:07] preservation as one of its [2:08:09] primary areas of emphasis And [2:08:12] today we're looking not just at [2:08:13] allocating the $5.9 million to [2:08:17] start this fund but recognizing [2:08:18] that the funds that were [2:08:20] collected in that now have [2:08:21] the opportunity actually be [2:08:22] utilized for the purpose they [2:08:23] were intended which is to [2:08:25] provide for additional [2:08:26] affordable housing [2:08:27] opportunities specifically by [2:08:29] protecting the ones that [2:08:30] already exist. [2:08:32] I do want to ask both Colin and [2:08:35] Francis something that has been [2:08:37] identified is that the staff [2:08:39] report and the materials here [2:08:40] talk about the $5.9 million as [2:08:42] a part of f by 26. [2:08:45] We're of course headed into [2:08:46] that for 27 budget as well. [2:08:46] And so we've been talking about [2:08:48] a higher number of what's [2:08:49] anticipated to ultimately go [2:08:50] into this fund. [2:08:51] >> Can you share about that? [2:08:52] Yeah. [2:08:52] Thank you for the question. [2:08:53] So yes, this is strictly for [2:08:56] fiscal year 2026 for the 5.9 [2:08:58] million in fiscal year 27 [2:09:00] there's an additional 2.7 [2:09:02] million to get bring us to a [2:09:03] total of $8.5 million. [2:09:05] That budget was already [2:09:07] approved by city council. [2:09:08] >> That's why we did not [2:09:08] mention it in this report. [2:09:09] Thank you. [2:09:11] And let me just note that as [2:09:13] much as we talked about [2:09:14] the ordinance being a first [2:09:15] step and the establishment of [2:09:17] this fund being another step, [2:09:19] there's a lot of work to do [2:09:21] still $8.5 million is not a lot [2:09:24] at the end of the day in terms [2:09:25] of the number of housing units [2:09:26] that can be impacted. [2:09:28] We look at some of [2:09:28] the developments that we've or [2:09:31] some of the properties in [2:09:32] the past where on the national [2:09:34] affordable naturally occurring [2:09:35] affordable side we've seen [2:09:37] thousands of units shift hands [2:09:39] to become market rate and we've [2:09:41] lost that affordability to [2:09:43] those who had the ability to [2:09:45] act upon that. [2:09:46] What this establishing this [2:09:48] fund allows the city to do is [2:09:49] to also look at other resources [2:09:52] whether it's philanthropic [2:09:53] partners, whether it's [2:09:55] corporate and workforce [2:09:56] partners within the region to [2:09:58] think about how we can work [2:10:00] collectively to have funding [2:10:01] available so that as housing [2:10:03] units either lose their [2:10:05] covenants or naturally [2:10:06] affordable occurring affordable [2:10:07] units are identified where [2:10:10] there's an opportunity for us [2:10:11] to step in and preserve their [2:10:13] existing cost so that [2:10:15] homeowners renters etc. Can [2:10:18] stay within the housing units [2:10:19] that they're in. [2:10:21] This fund is just the first [2:10:22] step in allowing us to better [2:10:24] be prepared to act upon that [2:10:25] front. [2:10:26] So again, we're just taking one [2:10:29] step today We're opening a door [2:10:30] inviting the opportunity to [2:10:32] partner with others to expand [2:10:34] upon our ability as a city to [2:10:37] preserve affordable housing. [2:10:38] Again, where this really [2:10:39] focuses just as a starting [2:10:41] point are the thousands of [2:10:42] units that we have identified [2:10:43] that are 55 year covenants for [2:10:46] affordable housing that are [2:10:47] expiring and the decade ahead. [2:10:49] There's nothing else we can do [2:10:52] for those units if we're not [2:10:54] ready to act upon them and to [2:10:56] encourage others to do so. [2:10:58] The ordinance that was [2:10:59] established that Councilmember [2:11:01] Moreno helped to champion help [2:11:02] provide the first right of [2:11:03] refusal so that affordable [2:11:04] housing developers and others [2:11:06] could act before someone could [2:11:07] come in. [2:11:08] From a market rate standpoint [2:11:10] this is a next step that allows [2:11:11] the city to partner with folks [2:11:13] to actually put funding and [2:11:14] capital into doing just that. [2:11:15] So with that I'm proud to move [2:11:18] the staff recommendation on [2:11:19] this item and look forward to [2:11:21] the comments from my [2:11:21] colleagues. [2:11:22] Thank you. [2:11:22] All right. [2:11:22] Thank you. [2:11:23] So we have a motion by Council [2:11:24] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee to move [2:11:25] the staff recommendation and [2:11:26] we'll go next to council member [2:11:28] Moreno. [2:11:30] Thank you to the San Diego [2:11:31] Housing Commission and city [2:11:32] staff for bringing this item [2:11:34] forward. [2:11:35] I am pleased to support [2:11:36] the final establishment of [2:11:38] the Affordable Housing [2:11:39] Preservation Fund and [2:11:41] the transfer of [2:11:42] the Neighborhood Enhancement [2:11:43] Funds to build this important [2:11:45] resource for San Diego. [2:11:49] The reality is simple San Diego [2:11:52] doesn't have enough affordable [2:11:53] housing and while we must [2:11:55] continue building more [2:11:57] construction, it alone is not [2:11:58] keeping up with the need. [2:12:01] This is why preserving [2:12:02] the Affordable homes we already [2:12:04] have is just as important as [2:12:07] building new ones. [2:12:09] When an affordable housing [2:12:10] property is put up for sale [2:12:13] after the 55 year covenant it [2:12:16] simply could be before it could [2:12:18] be sold from an affordable [2:12:21] housing developer to a private [2:12:22] developer without the city ever [2:12:25] having the opportunity to step [2:12:26] in and preserve its [2:12:28] affordability. [2:12:30] To be clear, these are [2:12:31] affordable homes that were [2:12:32] built using public subsidies [2:12:34] and it's critical that we keep [2:12:37] them affordable. [2:12:38] The Affordable Housing [2:12:40] Preservation Ordinance that was [2:12:42] mentioned by our pro tem is an [2:12:45] ordinance that I worked very [2:12:47] closely with with the San Diego [2:12:48] Housing Commission in 2023 As a [2:12:52] former chair of the Land Use [2:12:53] and Housing Committee, I [2:12:55] requested that the San Diego [2:12:56] Housing Commission bring [2:12:58] the committee information on [2:13:00] what we could do to preserve [2:13:01] affordable homes in San Diego [2:13:04] in NOVEMBER 2024, the Land Use [2:13:06] and Housing Committee [2:13:07] unanimously recommended that [2:13:09] the City Council adopt this or [2:13:11] the order the previous [2:13:12] ordinance which provides a [2:13:14] right of first offer and right [2:13:17] of first refusal to qualified [2:13:19] entities including nonprofits [2:13:21] and for profit organization or [2:13:26] for profit organizations. [2:13:27] And I do want to take this [2:13:28] opportunity to thank the San [2:13:29] Diego Housing Commission for [2:13:31] how many meetings did you guys [2:13:33] have during that? [2:13:34] >> I know we're not talking [2:13:35] about this but it's good to to [2:13:36] put on record how many meetings [2:13:38] you had. [2:13:39] >> I've lost count. [2:13:41] >> It was a lot was a lot. [2:13:42] It was a lot of meetings But in [2:13:45] 20 in 20 in FEBRUARY of 2025 [2:13:49] the Affordable Housing [2:13:50] Preservation Ordinance was [2:13:52] unanimously approved by [2:13:54] the city council. [2:13:56] This ordinance applies when [2:13:58] the owner of an assisted [2:13:59] housing development intends to [2:14:01] sell the property. [2:14:03] It requires the property owner [2:14:05] to provide a notice of intent [2:14:07] to sell to government and [2:14:09] affordable housing entities [2:14:10] three months before any [2:14:12] offering to sell or listing [2:14:14] with any real estate agent [2:14:17] the Affordable Housing [2:14:17] Preservation Ordinance prevents [2:14:20] deed restricted affordable [2:14:22] homes from being redeveloped [2:14:25] into market rate or luxury [2:14:27] housing. [2:14:29] Now when a building with deed [2:14:31] restricted affordable housing [2:14:32] goes on the market we will have [2:14:34] the opportunity to preserve [2:14:36] that The those houses that pass [2:14:40] ordinance I thought was very [2:14:41] reasonable and it was an [2:14:43] effective tool to keep deed [2:14:44] restricted affordable units in [2:14:46] place across San Diego [2:14:49] basically keeping San Diego [2:14:51] from losing affordable homes [2:14:53] that they live in today We are [2:14:56] now we're taking the next [2:14:58] critical step the neighborhood [2:15:00] enhancement for dollars JANUARY [2:15:02] aided by new development are [2:15:04] now being reinvested to [2:15:06] preserve affordable housing and [2:15:09] establishing the Affordable [2:15:10] Housing Preservation Ordinance [2:15:12] Fund which we are doing today [2:15:14] will ensure we have [2:15:16] the resources also known as [2:15:18] money needed to act when these [2:15:21] opportunities arise. [2:15:23] So the first ordinance gave us [2:15:24] the right to do it. [2:15:26] Now this is providing us [2:15:27] the money to do it. [2:15:29] So having the Affordable [2:15:30] Housing Preservation Ordinance [2:15:32] Fund in place is an essential [2:15:34] tool to ensure that we continue [2:15:37] preserving exist existing [2:15:39] affordable homes in San Diego. [2:15:42] >> Do we need more housing? [2:15:43] Yes. [2:15:44] Do we need more parks? [2:15:45] Yes. [2:15:46] Do we need to make our parks [2:15:48] and keep them up to speed? [2:15:49] Absolutely yes. [2:15:51] But we absolutely need need [2:15:52] these funds And I want to take [2:15:54] this opportunity to thank [2:15:56] Council Pro Tem Lee and his [2:15:58] staff for your continuous work [2:15:59] on this very important effort. [2:16:02] Could have just left it sitting [2:16:04] on the shelf and we would have [2:16:05] never had money to actually put [2:16:07] our money where our mouth is. [2:16:09] And I also want to take an [2:16:11] opportunity to thank our I'm [2:16:14] going to call you guys housing [2:16:15] heroes to call in to Frances to [2:16:18] Lisa. [2:16:19] You guys are absolutely our [2:16:20] housing heroes. [2:16:22] We could have had that [2:16:23] informational item and you [2:16:24] could have, you know, told me [2:16:26] everything I wanted to hear and [2:16:28] we could have walked away and [2:16:29] not had I want to say it was [2:16:31] like it was a crazy amount of [2:16:33] meeting like 15 or 33 meetings [2:16:35] You could have never you didn't [2:16:36] have you you didn't have to do [2:16:38] it and you did it. [2:16:39] >> And now we are seeing [2:16:40] the fruits of your hard labor [2:16:42] And I want to thank you for [2:16:43] that And second the motion. [2:16:44] >> Thank you. [2:16:45] All right. [2:16:46] Thank you. [2:16:46] Council member Moreno So we do [2:16:48] have a motion by Council [2:16:49] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee and [2:16:50] second by council member Marina [2:16:51] on move the staff [2:16:52] recommendation will go next to [2:16:54] council member Eli Rivera. [2:16:55] Thank you Council PRESIDENT [2:16:58] Thank you Colin and Frances and [2:17:01] Lisa and the whole Housing [2:17:03] Commission team. [2:17:07] >> Sometimes things are good. [2:17:10] That's it. [2:17:11] They're just good. [2:17:13] This is good If we care about [2:17:16] people being able to live in [2:17:18] this city and stay in [2:17:20] the communities that they live [2:17:21] in they love and they're [2:17:22] pouring their hearts into this [2:17:24] is good period. [2:17:28] >> This is making it easier for [2:17:32] the city to actually do [2:17:35] the things we say we want to [2:17:36] do. [2:17:38] So I think some of [2:17:39] the confusion is coming from a [2:17:42] a genuine place of not [2:17:44] understanding exactly what [2:17:46] the action is here in front of [2:17:47] us. [2:17:48] But I also think there's some [2:17:49] folks who just will always find [2:17:55] an opportunity to criticize [2:17:59] everything that happens here to [2:18:02] relitigate completely separate [2:18:05] issues And what's in front of [2:18:08] us right now is the result of [2:18:11] one council member working hand [2:18:15] in hand with the housing [2:18:16] Commission to put a law on [2:18:20] the books to to ensure that [2:18:22] every single affordable housing [2:18:25] naturally occurring affordable [2:18:26] housing complex in San Diego [2:18:31] isn't seen as fresh meat from [2:18:35] Wall Street investors and [2:18:38] people who want to flip homes [2:18:41] regardless of what the impact [2:18:42] is on community gives San Diego [2:18:45] an actual chance to to compete [2:18:47] and then council PRESIDENT Pro [2:18:49] Tem Lee in partnership with [2:18:50] the Housing Commission is [2:18:51] making sure that the city has a [2:18:52] vehicle to have the funding [2:18:54] necessary to actually act on [2:18:56] that law. [2:18:57] >> This is good. [2:19:01] >> So I'm appreciative of [2:19:02] the effort that's gone into [2:19:03] this. [2:19:04] I am glad to see that we are [2:19:07] taking actions to ensure that [2:19:09] we can do the things that we [2:19:10] say we want to do And there are [2:19:16] plenty of reasons to be [2:19:20] dissatisfied with the state of [2:19:21] housing in San Diego. [2:19:22] There are plenty of reasons to [2:19:23] be dissatisfied with [2:19:25] the progress we've made to make [2:19:27] San Diego more affordable and [2:19:31] this is good. [2:19:33] So the last thing I will add [2:19:37] and I had a chance to talk [2:19:38] about this a little bit earlier [2:19:40] alongside my colleagues [2:19:43] Councilmember Moreno and [2:19:43] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee. [2:19:44] But communities like City [2:19:47] Heights and other parts of [2:19:48] the city that were naturally [2:19:49] occurring affordable housing [2:19:50] exists and just to make sure [2:19:52] that's a technical term so we [2:19:54] can like define what we're [2:19:55] talking about there Those are [2:19:56] typically older homes that have [2:20:00] have become more affordable [2:20:04] over time or there's a deed [2:20:06] restricted affordable housing [2:20:08] that is about to where the deed [2:20:12] restrictions are about to [2:20:12] expire And that is the reason [2:20:15] why investors are seeing it as [2:20:18] chum in the water. [2:20:18] And if we don't do this, what [2:20:23] happens is a Wall Street [2:20:27] investor or local developer who [2:20:30] doesn't care about people comes [2:20:32] in, buys a property, kicks [2:20:33] the people out who are [2:20:34] currently there, flips those [2:20:36] units into air quote luxury [2:20:38] apartments cause they're not [2:20:39] really luxury and that [2:20:43] the cycle continues. [2:20:46] So some of the folks who've [2:20:48] spoken kind of in opposition to [2:20:51] this are the same people who [2:20:53] talk about caring about [2:20:54] community character and [2:20:55] the community character that I [2:20:56] care about comes from [2:20:57] the people who live in those [2:20:58] homes And this helps us protect [2:21:01] those people. [2:21:02] So thank you again everyone who [2:21:03] worked on this who put effort [2:21:05] in I'm glad we're doing this. [2:21:07] This is good. [2:21:07] That's why I'm supporting it [2:21:09] And we'll vote yes. [2:21:09] Thank you. [2:21:10] Council PRESIDENT. [2:21:10] All right. [2:21:11] Thank you. [2:21:11] Got Somerville or Rivera We'll [2:21:12] go next to council member [2:21:13] Whitburn Thank you. [2:21:14] Council PRESIDENT Yes this is a [2:21:15] great step forward. [2:21:16] Thank you to the Housing [2:21:17] commission, the planning [2:21:18] department for all the work [2:21:19] that's gone into it. [2:21:20] So many people are struggling [2:21:21] with the cost of living in San [2:21:22] Diego. [2:21:23] The biggest part of that is [2:21:24] the cost of housing. [2:21:25] We need more housing that is [2:21:28] truly affordable And obviously [2:21:30] one way to address that is to [2:21:31] build more affordable housing. [2:21:33] We're doing that. [2:21:35] We're doing quite a bit of that [2:21:36] in the district I represent [2:21:38] here downtown Harrington [2:21:39] Heights and the East Village [2:21:41] opened up late last year. [2:21:43] Jacaranda died in Cortez Hill [2:21:46] opened up last month. [2:21:47] We got another deed restricted [2:21:49] affordable housing project [2:21:50] going in up here on six between [2:21:53] Cedar and Beach That will be [2:21:55] opening before too long. [2:21:56] All of those have or will have [2:21:58] rents that are restricted based [2:22:00] on the renter's income. [2:22:02] But as we produce that new [2:22:04] affordable housing we can't [2:22:05] afford to lose the affordable [2:22:07] housing that we already have [2:22:10] Lose it because [2:22:11] the department's rent [2:22:12] restriction expires or because [2:22:16] that apartment that simply has [2:22:17] a low rent because of [2:22:18] the market goes away or is [2:22:20] replaced by something more [2:22:21] expensive. [2:22:22] Otherwise we're just spinning [2:22:23] our wheels and we're not [2:22:25] actually adding to the overall [2:22:27] supply of affordable housing [2:22:29] that we so desperately need. [2:22:30] That is why this fund is such a [2:22:32] big deal. [2:22:32] The city dedicating funding [2:22:35] specifically for preserving [2:22:36] affordable housing is not [2:22:37] something that very many cities [2:22:38] are doing. [2:22:39] This fund as has been [2:22:41] discussed, could be used to [2:22:42] acquire naturally occurring [2:22:44] affordable housing before a [2:22:46] private investor snaps it up [2:22:47] could be used to preserve deed [2:22:49] restricted affordable housing [2:22:51] and with the city committing [2:22:53] neighborhood enhancement for [2:22:55] dollars year over year this is [2:22:57] a sustained investment in [2:22:59] keeping San Diego affordable. [2:23:00] It's not just a one time [2:23:01] effort. [2:23:02] That's part of the beauty of [2:23:04] this. [2:23:04] This is going to help renters [2:23:05] in my district who currently [2:23:07] live in affordable housing and [2:23:09] depend on their apartment to [2:23:12] remain affordable. [2:23:14] It means that when a landlord [2:23:15] decides to sell that apartment [2:23:17] building in North Park or [2:23:19] Hillcrest or Golden Hill a [2:23:21] building where people have [2:23:22] lived for years and where rents [2:23:24] are still affordable, [2:23:24] the Housing Commission could [2:23:26] have an opportunity to step in [2:23:27] and buy it before a private [2:23:29] investor does Before Redd's go [2:23:31] up, before people get pushed [2:23:32] out of their homes and out of [2:23:34] their neighborhoods, it'll [2:23:36] protect the affordable rents [2:23:38] that exist right now and keep [2:23:39] them affordable going forward. [2:23:41] Every unit that we preserve is [2:23:43] a family that doesn't have to [2:23:45] move, a family that could stay [2:23:47] in the neighborhood. [2:23:47] A senior at fixed income who [2:23:50] gets to stay in [2:23:50] the neighborhood that they have [2:23:51] called home for decades a [2:23:53] worker who could still afford [2:23:55] to live close to where they [2:23:57] work. [2:23:57] >> We lose thousands thousands [2:24:00] of affordable units in this [2:24:02] city every year that because [2:24:04] they're necessarily tore down [2:24:06] but because they're sold and [2:24:07] the rents are raised this fund [2:24:09] is how we start to fight back [2:24:10] against that. [2:24:11] So San Diego is doing something [2:24:13] genuinely innovative here. [2:24:14] I am proud to support it and I [2:24:16] will join my colleagues [2:24:17] colleagues in thanking all of [2:24:20] you who have been involved in [2:24:21] this incredibly important work. [2:24:23] Thank you. [2:24:23] Thank you. [2:24:23] Council PRESIDENT All right. [2:24:24] >> Thank you Council member [2:24:26] Whitburn. [2:24:26] And we'll go next to Council [2:24:27] member Campbell. [2:24:28] Thank you so much for all [2:24:31] the comments from all my [2:24:32] colleagues that are absolutely [2:24:33] correct. [2:24:34] I remember gosh back just [2:24:37] before I ran for council we [2:24:39] lost a large affordable housing [2:24:44] complex because the 55 years [2:24:47] had run out and it was really [2:24:50] difficult to get them to agree [2:24:53] with the fact that please help [2:24:55] us figure out a way to help [2:24:56] these folks who are now elderly [2:24:58] and can't move And they got [2:25:00] they've been in this thing for [2:25:01] 55 years So at any rate those [2:25:06] times that's the history that [2:25:07] led to ideas like this. [2:25:10] This is an excellent idea and [2:25:12] I'm definitely in favor and I [2:25:14] want to thank all my colleagues [2:25:15] for this as well as the Housing [2:25:17] Commission. [2:25:18] Again for your brilliance in [2:25:20] trying to help us with our [2:25:21] housing situation. [2:25:22] Thank you. [2:25:23] Thank you, Councilmember [2:25:24] Campbell. [2:25:26] Not anybody else on the lights [2:25:26] . [2:25:28] I'll add my thank you to member [2:25:32] Maureen out Council PRESIDENT [2:25:32] Pro Tom Lee the Housing [2:25:34] commission excuse me city staff [2:25:37] that has done the very good [2:25:38] work here going forward and [2:25:42] the one thing I want to really [2:25:43] emphasize is that nobody is [2:25:45] standing up and cheering and [2:25:46] saying mission accomplished. [2:25:47] This is a huge step towards [2:25:51] solving a huge problem and we [2:25:54] can't build fast enough. [2:25:56] And as my colleagues have said [2:25:57] ,this is an opportunity to [2:25:58] preserve what we have and there [2:26:01] is nothing more efficient, more [2:26:02] green, more climate action plan [2:26:04] friendly than simply preserving [2:26:06] the development and buildings [2:26:08] that we have already. [2:26:09] So this is a huge step. [2:26:11] I appreciate the emphasis in [2:26:14] getting this place locked into [2:26:16] place and then begin to think [2:26:18] about what do we do next? [2:26:19] Can we leverage this together [2:26:22] and are funding other grants [2:26:24] philanthropic philanthropy. [2:26:26] As council PRESIDENT Pro Tem we [2:26:29] talked about so we look forward [2:26:32] to once you start getting into [2:26:34] the weeds and where you go and [2:26:38] this is a good day. [2:26:40] It is a a step in the right [2:26:42] direction So I'll be supporting [2:26:44] as well. [2:26:44] So we have a motion by Council [2:26:46] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee and a [2:26:48] second by Councilmember Moreno. [2:26:49] Clerk Please call the roll I'm [2:26:54] sorry the voting system Please [2:26:55] cast your vote That passes [2:27:00] unanimously unanimously 6 to 0 [2:27:03] with Council Member Campo, [2:27:04] Councilmember Yvonne Wolpert [2:27:07] and Councilmember Foster [2:27:07] absent. [2:27:08] >> Thank you Council PRESIDENT. [2:27:09] All right. [2:27:09] Thank you And again thank you [2:27:10] to staff for the good work. [2:27:11] We will now adjourn as [2:27:13] the housing authority and [2:27:14] reconvene as the City council [2:27:15] clerk please introduce item 402 [2:27:19] items for a Tuesday agreement [2:27:19] between the city of San Diego [2:27:21] and the San Diego Housing [2:27:22] Commission as the agency for [2:27:24] the Transfer of Neighborhood [2:27:25] Enhancement Fund fees to chc to [2:27:27] support the Affordable Housing [2:27:29] Preservation Fund. [2:27:30] Thank you Council PRESIDENT All [2:27:32] right. [2:27:32] And staff as you're settling in [2:27:34] when you're ready please [2:27:36] introduce yourselves for [2:27:37] the record and let us know how [2:27:38] much time you need. [2:27:41] We should only need five [2:27:42] minutes. [2:27:42] All right. [2:27:43] When you're ready. [2:27:43] All right. [2:27:44] >> Good afternoon, council [2:27:46] members. [2:27:47] My name is Melissa Garcia and [2:27:48] I'm a senior planner with [2:27:49] the city planning Department. [2:27:50] Today I'm joined by Marlin [2:27:52] Pangilinan, program manager [2:27:54] with the City Planning [2:27:54] Department. [2:27:55] We are here to present [2:27:56] the agreement between the city [2:27:58] of San Diego and the San Diego [2:27:59] Housing Commission for [2:28:00] the Transfer of Neighborhood [2:28:01] Enhancement Fund fees to [2:28:04] the San Diego Housing [2:28:05] Commission to support [2:28:06] the Affordable Housing [2:28:07] Preservation Fund. [2:28:09] The item proposes the following [2:28:11] actions Authorize the mayor or [2:28:13] designee to enter an agreement [2:28:15] between the city of San Diego [2:28:16] and the San Diego Housing [2:28:18] Commission to transfer City [2:28:20] Neighborhood Enhancement Fund [2:28:21] fees to support the Affordable [2:28:23] Housing Preservation Fund. [2:28:25] And authorize the Chief [2:28:27] Financial Officer or designee [2:28:29] to appropriate and expend an [2:28:31] amount not to exceed 8.5 [2:28:33] million from the city's [2:28:34] Neighborhood Enhancement Fund [2:28:36] to the San Diego Housing [2:28:37] Commission for the purpose of [2:28:39] supporting the Affordable [2:28:40] Housing Preservation Fund. [2:28:43] The Neighborhood Enhancement [2:28:45] Fund consists of fees collected [2:28:47] from developers participating [2:28:48] in the Complete Community's [2:28:50] Housing Solutions program which [2:28:52] was adopted in 2020 and is a [2:28:54] program that incentivizes [2:28:56] housing production here transit [2:28:58] while funding neighborhood [2:28:59] amenities to be eligible to [2:29:01] receive benefits under [2:29:02] the Complete Community's [2:29:03] Housing Solutions regulations. [2:29:05] Applicants must either [2:29:07] construct on site public [2:29:08] amenities or pay a neighborhood [2:29:11] enhancement in lieu fee. [2:29:12] 50% of the net funds collected [2:29:16] are to be used to fund [2:29:17] recreation amenities, active [2:29:19] transportation and transit [2:29:21] infrastructure projects and [2:29:23] the remaining 50% of the nef is [2:29:25] to be used for affordable [2:29:26] housing preservation. [2:29:30] >> This action proposes to [2:29:32] transfer a neighborhood [2:29:32] enhancement fees to the San [2:29:34] Diego Housing Commission's [2:29:35] Affordable Housing Preservation [2:29:37] Fund which is being established [2:29:39] under a separate action by [2:29:40] the Housing Authority. [2:29:42] The Affordable Housing [2:29:43] Preservation Fund will acquire [2:29:45] and preserve deed restriction [2:29:46] deed restricted, restricted and [2:29:48] naturally occurring affordable [2:29:49] housing for households earning [2:29:51] between 30% and 150% of area [2:29:55] median income. [2:29:56] The fund will also preserve at [2:29:58] risk deed restricted affordable [2:30:00] housing that is nearing the end [2:30:02] of its affordability term. [2:30:04] It will also prevent [2:30:05] displacement and leverage [2:30:07] public and private investment. [2:30:11] The staff recommendation is to [2:30:12] authorize the mayor or designee [2:30:14] to enter into an agreement [2:30:15] between the city of San Diego [2:30:17] and the San Diego Housing [2:30:18] Commission to transfer a city [2:30:20] neighborhood Enhancement Fund [2:30:21] fees to support the Affordable [2:30:23] Housing Preservation Fund and [2:30:25] authorize the Chief financial [2:30:27] officer or designee to [2:30:28] appropriate and expend an [2:30:30] amount not to exceed 8.5 [2:30:32] million from the city's [2:30:34] Neighborhood Enhancement Fund [2:30:35] to the San Diego Housing [2:30:36] Commission for the purpose of [2:30:38] supporting the Affordable [2:30:39] Housing Preservation Fund. [2:30:41] >> That concludes staff [2:30:42] presentation. [2:30:43] We're available for questions. [2:30:44] All right. [2:30:45] Thank you for the presentation [2:30:47] ,Clark Please proceed with [2:30:48] public comment. [2:30:49] >> Paul Krueger if you can [2:30:50] please come forward after that [2:30:50] will be allegedly older than [2:30:57] Anthony Ramos If you can please [2:30:57] come to the front of the room. [2:31:02] >> Oh, thank you. [2:31:03] First I'd like to clarify that [2:31:04] I don't oppose this nor [2:31:06] the prior motion I spoke [2:31:08] neutrally about them. [2:31:10] Secondly, I want to stress that [2:31:12] our concerns are as you [2:31:15] yourselves have pointed out, [2:31:17] the loss of quote unquote [2:31:19] naturally occurring affordable [2:31:21] housing could be and could have [2:31:24] been prevented. [2:31:25] I'm not here to relitigate [2:31:27] anything. [2:31:27] I'm here to stress to you and [2:31:31] ask you to please moving [2:31:33] forward listen to those who [2:31:35] bring a wealth of knowledge and [2:31:38] research. [2:31:39] Six years ago we told you that [2:31:42] commune complete communities [2:31:43] and more than that the bonus [2:31:46] edu program were destroying [2:31:48] naturally occurring affordable [2:31:50] housing They were destroying. [2:31:52] Market level entry purchase [2:31:56] housing by turning those homes [2:31:58] into rentals and they were [2:32:00] destroying opportunities for [2:32:02] truly affordable housing by [2:32:04] allowing developers to always [2:32:07] choose the moderate income [2:32:09] option for their bonus. [2:32:12] The moderate income option was [2:32:14] 100 and is 110% of the area [2:32:18] Median income or more than [2:32:21] $100,000 a year and resulted in [2:32:23] rents of $2,500 for a 417 [2:32:27] square foot apartment. [2:32:30] If you had only listened to us [2:32:32] six years ago and simply took a [2:32:35] critical look at these two [2:32:37] programs, you would have saved [2:32:39] a significant number of [2:32:42] affordable homes moving [2:32:44] forward. [2:32:45] You have the opportunity to [2:32:47] look critically at with our [2:32:51] upcoming neighborhood homes for [2:32:53] All of Us program to ask [2:32:56] yourself for a viewpoint that [2:32:58] do not reflect those with money [2:33:01] and lobbying connections who [2:33:04] speak with your. [2:33:06] >> Thank you for including [2:33:12] sentence at the allegedly ultra [2:33:12] . [2:33:17] >> Do you guys smell that It [2:33:18] smells like gas all [2:33:20] the gaslighting that you guys [2:33:21] have done hopefully nobody [2:33:24] likes imaginative plays will go [2:33:24] up in flames It's so sad [2:33:26] because it's like I still [2:33:27] understand how you're literally [2:33:29] pretending to preserve anything [2:33:30] when $8.5 million even if you [2:33:33] wanted to preserve those 13,000 [2:33:35] units it's like 650 bucks. [2:33:38] I mean and then you're talking [2:33:39] about buying these these [2:33:40] affordable housing units that [2:33:42] the deed restrictions have gone [2:33:44] and how you can afford that And [2:33:45] then who's going to take care [2:33:46] of it? [2:33:46] Dreams for change And then [2:33:48] people will die just like they [2:33:50] have a tent city to 17 in your [2:33:51] district Stephen to last week [2:33:54] How cool is that? [2:33:55] Thursday and Friday. [2:33:55] That's so exciting that it's [2:33:58] just 17 and six months. [2:33:59] Goodness good thing they're [2:34:00] open But yeah they would be a [2:34:01] good people to you know go in [2:34:03] and take over one of these deed [2:34:05] restricted units. [2:34:06] I mean how about you guys [2:34:07] What's with the 55 years? [2:34:09] >> Why do we only do it 55 [2:34:09] years? [2:34:10] So we come to a place like this [2:34:11] and like oh my gosh, what are [2:34:12] we going to do? [2:34:13] Oh dang it, these people are [2:34:14] going to sell this unit but [2:34:16] we're going to put in an [2:34:17] ordinance, We're going to get [2:34:18] this money and tell people that [2:34:19] if you pay a fee you don't have [2:34:20] to create affordable housing [2:34:22] even when we need it and there [2:34:24] isn't anything affordable Like [2:34:26] again you guys sit here and you [2:34:27] say it's affordable. [2:34:28] How can it be affordable if you [2:34:30] have to have a subsidy for it? [2:34:34] >> Just wondering are we [2:34:36] redefining this just like we [2:34:37] did with a woman? [2:34:38] So now affordable means that as [2:34:40] long as you have to get all of [2:34:42] these things to help you pay [2:34:43] for that means it's affordable [2:34:45] to you. [2:34:46] Like you literally get in [2:34:48] the way of people being able to [2:34:50] thrive in life. [2:34:51] It's disgusting because you [2:34:53] gaslight the people sitting [2:34:54] here saying like This is good. [2:34:57] Trust us. [2:34:57] This is good right? [2:34:58] This is this is so good. [2:35:01] So good. [2:35:02] It's good. [2:35:02] That's all I can say is that [2:35:04] it's good. [2:35:04] Just trust us. [2:35:09] It's bad for real. [2:35:11] People are dying at 1030 and [2:35:13] you guys won't even shut it [2:35:14] down. [2:35:15] >> You won't even do anything. [2:35:16] But yet you're in litigation [2:35:17] with Anthony Robles. [2:35:25] Good afternoon, City Council. [2:35:26] I wanted to start by thinking [2:35:29] Vivian Moreno for explaining [2:35:31] exactly what the ordinance does [2:35:33] and how one of them establishes [2:35:35] the procedure and one of them [2:35:36] helps fund the procedure. [2:35:39] I want to thank Kent Lee for [2:35:41] explaining that as well to add [2:35:42] that both of your explanations [2:35:44] made a really what was what it [2:35:45] was a complicated issue that I [2:35:49] didn't understand really helped [2:35:50] It really helps break it down [2:35:52] so that I could understand it [2:35:54] in terms that were more [2:35:55] palpable And now it is [2:35:57] something that I fully support [2:35:57] . [2:35:59] I am thankful, MISS Campbell [2:36:01] for your input, your historical [2:36:03] input. [2:36:04] I really appreciate you sharing [2:36:05] that expertise with regard to [2:36:08] the context of the governance [2:36:10] of the 55 year lease and how [2:36:12] any expire We have to renew [2:36:13] them and we have to have [2:36:14] the funds to renew them. [2:36:16] Every time I come to city [2:36:17] council it's always humbling. [2:36:19] There's always stuff that I [2:36:20] learn. [2:36:21] I show up wanting to oppose [2:36:23] block and then I learn about [2:36:24] tons more issues that I had no [2:36:27] idea existed and had no idea [2:36:29] how to even interpret. [2:36:31] So I'm grateful for the work [2:36:33] that's done here. [2:36:34] And I also want to acknowledge [2:36:38] the cynicism and the lack of [2:36:44] trust that comes from repeated [2:36:48] public engagement and feeling [2:36:50] like there is a what's the word [2:36:56] I'm looking for It was in [2:37:00] packet It was left behind [2:37:00] somebody they were talking [2:37:02] about a planning group and they [2:37:03] were talking about how [2:37:03] the planning groups don't feel [2:37:04] like they have an adequate seat [2:37:05] at the table. [2:37:06] It was the first agenda item [2:37:08] unfortunately I was not here [2:37:10] for it for that discussion But [2:37:11] the point that was raised they [2:37:14] mentioned it in the letter that [2:37:15] was left behind I feel like it [2:37:17] probably got a copy of it but [2:37:18] it was mentioning how sometimes [2:37:20] it feels like we don't have [2:37:22] enough of a seat at the table [2:37:24] to really have the input [2:37:25] necessary to be qualified. [2:37:29] >> Honestly thank you for [2:37:30] completing that either by going [2:37:32] to time or going to those [2:37:32] participating remotely Starting [2:37:34] with Hector If you can please [2:37:35] unmute. [2:37:38] All right. [2:37:39] This one is probably going to [2:37:42] be the Supreme Court Supreme [2:37:43] Court ruling just came down [2:37:46] with temporary legal status has [2:37:48] been revoked for a million [2:37:50] people. [2:37:51] So anybody that's got their [2:37:54] legal status revoked and send [2:37:56] your county has got to leave. [2:37:58] So make sure that the roles [2:38:02] the roles of the buildings [2:38:03] don't have any illegals in them [2:38:05] to have to leave. [2:38:06] So that would that would clear [2:38:08] up housing problem but that [2:38:10] would put in more spaces for [2:38:12] rent like even 100,000 people [2:38:15] are living here illegally work [2:38:17] on that problem to deport them [2:38:17] . [2:38:20] That will open up a lot of [2:38:21] housing, affordable housing and [2:38:23] even some millionaire guys who [2:38:25] are here illegally. [2:38:26] So that'd be a good reason to [2:38:28] do. [2:38:29] And then about I'm all for [2:38:32] the mayor of Barrio Logan for [2:38:35] the new mayor to get some Tesla [2:38:38] charging stations down there by [2:38:41] the railroad tracks and get [2:38:43] the banana company to get those [2:38:45] Tesla trucks, the electric [2:38:48] trucks are flying off [2:38:49] the shelves the time companies [2:38:52] are buying them And the Dow guy [2:38:54] could set up a thing down there [2:38:56] to charge these trucks and give [2:38:57] the revenue to Barrio [2:38:59] the Barrio Logan Don't let [2:39:01] the city get the revenue Have [2:39:03] the barrio get that revenue [2:39:05] Like maybe it'd be like 500,000 [2:39:08] a month doing the charging [2:39:10] station down there in battery [2:39:12] thing that would be and guys [2:39:15] could live there and watch it [2:39:17] The barrio could I mention it [2:39:18] doesn't get tagged They could [2:39:20] provide security but no one [2:39:23] ever tags the girls under [2:39:26] the bridge right where they're [2:39:28] tagging their neighborhood in [2:39:30] District four but not in [2:39:32] the barrio. [2:39:32] Logan Nobody tags the murals [2:39:35] because they provide security [2:39:37] for their own stuff so that [2:39:39] would be cool. [2:39:40] Okay But thank you. [2:39:43] Next is Jonathan please on you [2:39:45] . [2:39:45] Hi. [2:39:49] I just wanted to make sure that [2:39:50] it was understood with my prior [2:39:52] comments that we do support [2:39:54] the effort to retain affordable [2:39:56] housing. [2:39:57] The frustration that we're [2:39:58] having is whether or not you [2:40:01] know, there's 320 households [2:40:03] that were on a used that are [2:40:05] going to see those vouchers go [2:40:07] away and they will not at this [2:40:09] point as we understand it, have [2:40:11] a place for them or their [2:40:13] families to go. [2:40:14] So that's almost 2000 people I [2:40:19] you've got that You've got [2:40:20] the loss of food stamps where [2:40:22] people who are living on [2:40:23] the streets there's some sort [2:40:24] of insanity that people are [2:40:26] going to be believe that those [2:40:27] folks are going to be able to [2:40:28] get a job or are volunteer for [2:40:31] 20 hours a week. [2:40:33] Clearly this is something [2:40:34] designed by people that have no [2:40:35] idea and now on top of it in [2:40:39] the city where we've had [2:40:39] multiple outbreaks amongst this [2:40:41] population because of a lack of [2:40:43] sanitation, we're taking half [2:40:46] or more of the toilets offline [2:40:48] that are available to them at a [2:40:51] time where they're needed most [2:40:52] on top of a place to clean [2:40:55] their stuff, to relax and not [2:40:58] be harassed. [2:40:58] >> Remember we just talked [2:41:00] about people investing in [2:41:01] parks. [2:41:03] People who are experiencing [2:41:04] homelessness can't even go to a [2:41:05] park without being harassed [2:41:07] here And I'll say that And now [2:41:09] that I've experienced it I will [2:41:11] never again allow to stand up [2:41:13] and help somebody who the city [2:41:15] cannot help when they've been [2:41:16] evicted because now my rv has [2:41:20] been targeted and I got one [2:41:23] morning and now I have $175 [2:41:25] ticket and I have left that rv [2:41:27] as needed out on the overpass [2:41:29] nearby my home for years But [2:41:33] since it got tagged now we're [2:41:35] targeting So why don't we take [2:41:36] some of those resources and [2:41:38] target people that are oh I [2:41:40] don't know in illegally renting [2:41:41] vacation homes so we can free [2:41:43] up some housing. [2:41:44] >> Thank you. [2:41:44] Next is 8700 and then our final [2:41:49] speaker is Blair Beekman. [2:41:58] Joy Senator, first of all, [2:42:00] Councilmember Rivera and [2:42:01] Councilmember Moreno, I'm [2:42:03] really I can't believe the two [2:42:06] of you are just chatting. [2:42:10] Councilmember Moreno, this is [2:42:11] your big baby. [2:42:14] You did get it rolling yet [2:42:16] You're sitting there with [2:42:19] Councilmember Rivera and you're [2:42:23] talking while people are [2:42:24] talking and telling you how [2:42:26] they feel and what they care [2:42:28] about What what you I it's [2:42:29] beyond it's beyond me. [2:42:31] It's beyond me What I need to [2:42:41] believe you are the one thing [2:42:49] to which you're my hero You're [2:42:51] the one of those 20 or 30 [2:42:53] meetings You were just here [2:42:57] beyond beyond your five star [2:42:59] plus into the universe And [2:43:02] the presentation tax [2:43:03] exemptions. [2:43:04] And I wish I could talk to you [2:43:07] about which projects are exempt [2:43:08] from those we don't qualify [2:43:11] for. [2:43:11] The ordinance said that it's [2:43:14] brilliant These financial [2:43:15] solutions are brilliant and why [2:43:17] can't I understand the movement [2:43:19] of the funds on both of these [2:43:23] items? [2:43:23] Why can't I? [2:43:27] I look at I look at I look at [2:43:28] it I'm not good at it. [2:43:28] I'll say that. [2:43:29] But why can't we understand [2:43:31] what you're doing with these [2:43:33] funds in the past and now And [2:43:36] what was the companion item? [2:43:38] I thought they were called a [2:43:40] companion item. [2:43:41] I'm just lost in the shuffle [2:43:43] and I'm doing the best I can. [2:43:45] >> Please listen to us. [2:43:48] Love to all our next because [2:43:53] Blair between please I mean [2:44:01] what are we going academy for [2:44:01] you I will need to move on If [2:44:03] you are having technical [2:44:04] difficulties there could be [2:44:07] between. [2:44:08] Yes, we can hear you. [2:44:09] Please proceed. [2:44:11] I just got a new phone, so [2:44:12] thank you. [2:44:13] It's working now. [2:44:14] Yeah. [2:44:15] I wanted to comment that I [2:44:17] enjoyed watching Councilperson [2:44:20] Moreno and and their [2:44:22] conversations over the past few [2:44:24] months Now it's been really [2:44:26] engaging I think what they're [2:44:28] talking about it seems like But [2:44:30] hopefully they can make [2:44:31] the arrangements to to listen [2:44:32] more to public comment during [2:44:33] public comment time as well. [2:44:36] I wanted to comment that yeah [2:44:42] this item as it can work with [2:44:44] the baby asylum I thought of [2:44:47] ideas I thought of a community [2:44:50] land trust ideas and how well [2:44:51] that can be working these items [2:44:53] and what the future of that can [2:44:55] be. [2:44:57] I've always been a really [2:44:59] important point that within [2:45:02] this if we have a consistent [2:45:03] pattern in how we fund our in [2:45:08] movies developers then know [2:45:09] what to expect and we can be [2:45:11] very very clear in the concepts [2:45:13] of what truly affordable [2:45:14] housing can be about and they [2:45:17] can be clear as well And they [2:45:18] all understand the rules of [2:45:19] the road a lot easier and be [2:45:22] more giving I think to be more [2:45:24] understanding of what is good [2:45:26] policy and good practices [2:45:27] instead of the continual casino [2:45:30] that we usually practice that I [2:45:32] agree work sometimes but other [2:45:34] times we just get really really [2:45:36] confused and everybody gets [2:45:37] lost and hate each other from [2:45:39] it, you know And then they say [2:45:40] I don't want to ever support [2:45:41] for affordable housing again, [2:45:44] you know And when you go [2:45:44] through that whole pattern and [2:45:45] trip instead of just having a [2:45:47] nice steady way or just [2:45:51] consistently, you know, doing [2:45:51] the best practices and I hope [2:45:53] you can be working towards that [2:45:55] To conclude. [2:45:56] Thank you a lot for the words [2:45:57] of John Again you mentioned [2:45:58] affordable housing. [2:46:00] It's really it's importance And [2:46:01] can I mention mixed income [2:46:03] ideas and ideas? [2:46:04] How can we work towards new [2:46:05] ideas of mixed income that [2:46:08] offers a lot of flexibility and [2:46:09] choices in our efforts? [2:46:11] >> Thank you. [2:46:12] That doesn't appear to comment [2:46:13] on this item. [2:46:16] >> All right. [2:46:17] Thank you. [2:46:17] City Clerk Without turning over [2:46:19] to colleagues for questions [2:46:21] Comments entertain a motion [2:46:22] We'll start with the chair of [2:46:23] the Land and Housing Committee [2:46:24] council PRESIDENT Pro tem we [2:46:27] think as a PRESIDENT Whereas [2:46:28] the last item helped to [2:46:29] establish the Affordable [2:46:29] Housing Preservation Fund [2:46:31] Outstanding Housing Commission. [2:46:32] This item helps to allocate [2:46:34] the funding from [2:46:35] the Neighborhood Advancement [2:46:36] Fund fees to the Housing [2:46:38] Commission to complete [2:46:39] the other side of it. [2:46:40] >> So with that I will move [2:46:41] the staff's recommendation. [2:46:43] All right. [2:46:44] Thank you. [2:46:44] So we do have that motion [2:46:46] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee [2:46:47] and with the staff [2:46:47] recommendation I'll go next to [2:46:49] Councilmember Moreno. [2:46:50] Happy to second item. [2:46:52] All right. [2:46:53] So we have motion by Council [2:46:54] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee, a second [2:46:55] by Councilmember Moreno to move [2:46:57] the staff recommendation. [2:46:58] We'll go to my way to say thank [2:47:02] you. [2:47:03] How did we get dropped? [2:47:05] Do you want okay I'll just add [2:47:09] my thanks for the good work to [2:47:11] do this and I appreciate that [2:47:13] brief explanation. [2:47:14] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Maybe [2:47:15] that helps one of the public [2:47:16] commenters with that clerk [2:47:19] Please call the roll So [2:47:23] the voting system please cast [2:47:24] your vote That passes [2:47:29] unanimously 6 to 0 with [2:47:30] Councilmember Campo [2:47:32] Councilmember Opening [2:47:33] Councilmember Foster Absent. [2:47:34] Thank you. [2:47:35] Council PRESIDENT All right [2:47:36] Again thank you to staff for [2:47:37] the item. [2:47:38] We will now adjourn as the city [2:47:39] council and reconvene [2:47:41] the special Housing Authority [2:47:42] meeting Clerk Please introduce [2:47:44] Housing Authority Item two [2:47:48] Authority Item two is [2:47:49] the Federal Housing Commission [2:47:51] Semiannual Grant Report JULY [2:47:52] 1st, 2025 through DECEMBER 31st [2:47:55] 2025. [2:47:56] If you'd like to speak to this [2:47:57] item please be sure to raise [2:47:58] your hand by pressing Star nine [2:48:00] or the raise your hand icon Or [2:48:02] if you are hearing council [2:48:03] chambers please be sure to [2:48:04] submit your speakers to the box [2:48:07] in the front of the room. [2:48:08] Thank you. [2:48:10] All right. [2:48:11] As you said all yourself in [2:48:12] please indicate or scuse me [2:48:12] please state your name for [2:48:15] the record and let us know how [2:48:16] much time you need. [2:48:19] Okay? [2:48:20] There we go. [2:48:21] Good afternoon. [2:48:21] I'm Deborah Fishel for [2:48:23] the senior vice PRESIDENT Of [2:48:24] Community and Strategic [2:48:25] Initiatives for the Housing [2:48:26] Commission. [2:48:27] With me is Polly Toledo, [2:48:29] the housing programs manager [2:48:31] Are presentation will be six [2:48:34] minutes or less. [2:48:36] All right. [2:48:36] Well hang on the left. [2:48:38] All right. [2:48:39] We're getting ready. [2:48:40] Okay. [2:48:41] Let's go to the folks. [2:48:44] That's all I did here But I'm [2:48:45] going to stop there. [2:48:47] I'm going to go there. [2:48:48] There we go. [2:48:51] So this informational report is [2:48:53] being provided in accordance [2:48:54] with the resolution number [2:48:56] eight 1569 which granted [2:48:59] the Housing Commission [2:49:00] authority for a number of grant [2:49:02] related activities. [2:49:04] The report provides information [2:49:06] on grant activities for [2:49:08] the period of JULY 1st 2025 [2:49:10] through DECEMBER 31st, 2025. [2:49:14] It covers competitive grants, [2:49:17] noncompetitive grants and [2:49:17] allocations grant funds passed [2:49:19] through to the Housing [2:49:20] Commission and agreements and [2:49:22] contracts executed as a result [2:49:24] of these sources of funds. [2:49:27] During this reporting period [2:49:29] there was activity on 13 [2:49:31] competitive funding [2:49:32] opportunities. [2:49:33] This included nine new and four [2:49:36] renewal applications. [2:49:38] We were notified of seven [2:49:40] awards totaling more than $40 [2:49:42] million. [2:49:44] There was one grant request for [2:49:46] more than 490,000 that didn't [2:49:49] unfortunately didn't advance to [2:49:50] the next step in [2:49:51] the application process. [2:49:53] Finally, five applications for [2:49:55] approximately $6.5 million were [2:49:58] pending decisions as of [2:50:00] DECEMBER 31st 2025. [2:50:03] I will now provide you with [2:50:04] the remaining grant activity [2:50:05] details for this report. [2:50:10] The nearly 40.1 million in [2:50:13] grant awards came from three [2:50:14] sources The California Housing [2:50:16] and Community Development [2:50:17] Department, the us Department [2:50:19] of Housing and Urban [2:50:20] Development and the County of [2:50:22] San Diego. [2:50:24] Please note that this total [2:50:25] does not reflect the value of a [2:50:27] grant that was awarded but for [2:50:28] which the dollar amount was [2:50:29] unknown as of DECEMBER 31st, [2:50:32] 2025 and this total includes [2:50:35] only the first year award [2:50:37] amount for a grant that has two [2:50:39] more one year options [2:50:44] approximately 39.2 million in [2:50:47] grant awards came from three [2:50:49] separate programs administered [2:50:51] by the California Housing and [2:50:53] Community Development [2:50:54] Department, also known as hpd. [2:50:57] The programs include Hongqi [2:50:59] plus Cal Home and the Local [2:51:01] Housing Trust Fund. [2:51:03] These awards will help create [2:51:04] 205 affordable rental [2:51:06] apartments including permanent [2:51:08] supportive housing units for [2:51:10] households experiencing [2:51:11] homelessness. [2:51:13] Additionally, they will support [2:51:14] up to 19 households to be [2:51:16] assisted through the housing [2:51:17] commissions for first time [2:51:19] homebuyer low income program [2:51:21] and up to five households [2:51:23] through the Accessory Dwelling [2:51:24] Unit Finance program. [2:51:28] The Commission received more [2:51:30] than 727,000 in renewal funding [2:51:34] from the federal family [2:51:36] Self-sufficiency Program. [2:51:37] This money pays for staff to [2:51:38] provide families receiving [2:51:40] federal rental assistance with [2:51:42] financial literacy, employment [2:51:44] and similar services to help [2:51:46] them become more self-reliant. [2:51:48] The Commission also was [2:51:49] selected to continue its [2:51:51] administration of the county of [2:51:52] San Diego's as needed [2:51:53] Downpayment and Closing Costs [2:51:56] Assistance program. [2:51:58] The program offers low interest [2:52:00] deferred payment loans for [2:52:01] first time homebuyers with low [2:52:03] income and makes funds [2:52:04] available to moderate income [2:52:06] first time homebuyers in [2:52:07] designated areas. [2:52:12] The final two awards during [2:52:13] this reporting period include a [2:52:16] $10,000 from the banking [2:52:17] institution City Community [2:52:19] Investing and Development to [2:52:20] support programs of the San [2:52:22] Diego City County Reinvestment [2:52:23] Task Force. [2:52:25] Additionally, we were notified [2:52:26] about a first time award of a [2:52:28] federal youth homeless [2:52:30] demonstration program funds [2:52:32] which was granted to [2:52:33] the Housing Commission by [2:52:34] the San Diego Regional Task [2:52:36] Force on Homelessness. [2:52:38] The exact amount of the award [2:52:39] was unknown at the end of this [2:52:41] reporting period but we have [2:52:42] since been notified that it is [2:52:44] for more than 1.5 million. [2:52:50] >> The Commission submitted a [2:52:52] letter of interest to [2:52:53] the California Wellness [2:52:54] Foundation's Economic Safety [2:52:56] Net program which unfortunately [2:52:59] did not advance to the next [2:53:01] stage though our request for [2:53:03] approximately 490,000 to [2:53:06] provide homelessness prevention [2:53:07] assistance did fit within [2:53:10] the foundation's strategies. [2:53:12] There were limited funds to [2:53:13] accommodate all the submissions [2:53:17] as the Housing Commission had [2:53:18] five submissions to three [2:53:20] separate funding opportunities [2:53:21] that were pending decision as [2:53:23] of DECEMBER 31st 2025. [2:53:26] Requests for funding for three [2:53:27] separate projects were [2:53:29] submitted to [2:53:29] the congressionally directed [2:53:30] economic development Initiative [2:53:32] Community Project Funding [2:53:34] through hud. [2:53:36] Two of the project requests [2:53:37] totaling approximately 4.4 [2:53:39] million were submitted via [2:53:40] the Office of Congressman Scott [2:53:42] Peters to support an affordable [2:53:44] housing prevention program as [2:53:46] well as an integrated recovery [2:53:48] support program. [2:53:50] Another request for 2 million [2:53:52] to support the Velasco [2:53:53] redevelopment project was [2:53:55] submitted via the Office of [2:53:57] Congresswoman Sara Jacobs and [2:54:00] application was submitted to [2:54:01] the County of San Diego's [2:54:03] Community Development Block [2:54:04] Grant requesting annual support [2:54:06] for the Reinvestment Task Force [2:54:08] for more than $121,000. [2:54:11] The last pending request at [2:54:13] the end of this reporting [2:54:14] period was to head for Veterans [2:54:16] Affairs supportive housing [2:54:17] vouchers not including [2:54:20] the budget authority for [2:54:21] the rental housing vouchers [2:54:23] which is unknown until [2:54:24] the vouchers are awarded. [2:54:26] The total for these pending [2:54:27] grant request was more than 6.5 [2:54:29] million. [2:54:34] The Housing Commission [2:54:35] submitted six eligible renewal [2:54:37] projects worth a combined total [2:54:39] of more than 11.7 million That [2:54:42] provided rapid rehousing and [2:54:43] permanent supportive housing [2:54:45] surface services through [2:54:47] the continuum of care. [2:54:53] No formal application for [2:54:57] the Housing Commission also [2:54:58] received two awards of grant [2:55:00] funding totaling more than 18.5 [2:55:02] million. [2:55:03] That was passed through from [2:55:04] other entities. [2:55:06] These awards will be leveraged [2:55:07] with the housing Commission's [2:55:08] Grant Award from the Homekey [2:55:10] Plus program for Starline Place [2:55:12] Affordable housing development. [2:55:14] >> The funding includes more [2:55:16] than 11.5 million in federal [2:55:20] community development block [2:55:22] grant fundraising passed [2:55:23] the pass through by the city of [2:55:25] San Diego and 7 million and [2:55:27] Federal American Rescue Plan [2:55:28] Act general purpose revenue [2:55:30] passed through by the county of [2:55:32] San Diego. [2:55:37] Next up grant funding to [2:55:38] the Housing Commission also is [2:55:39] reinvested into the community [2:55:40] and positively impact the local [2:55:42] economy. [2:55:43] During the first half of f y 20 [2:55:47] 2623 sub recipient agreements [2:55:48] utilized approximately 28.7 [2:55:51] million in whole or in part [2:55:53] from grant funding were [2:55:55] executed. [2:55:56] Additionally three contracts [2:55:58] totaling approximately $122,000 [2:56:02] and hud Capital Fund program [2:56:03] funding were also executed. [2:56:06] That concludes our [2:56:08] informational report and we're [2:56:09] happy to answer any questions [2:56:10] you MAY have. [2:56:11] All right. [2:56:11] Thank you for the work. [2:56:12] Thank you for the presentation. [2:56:15] Clark, please proceed with [2:56:16] public comment. [2:56:17] >> If you can please come [2:56:18] forward to the microphone And [2:56:19] after that is Anthony Ralphs. [2:56:34] >> Just because I wish that you [2:56:34] guys did all these things that [2:56:37] you talk about like you do good [2:56:39] presentations and whatnot But I [2:56:43] mean it's scary to think about [2:56:44] where this youth homeless [2:56:45] funding is going to go When you [2:56:50] give out money you you don't [2:56:51] ensure that it's being used [2:56:53] properly, that people aren't [2:56:54] being abused. [2:56:55] I mean, again, I'm going to [2:56:56] bring up Tent City and Lot and [2:56:59] the fact that like I don't know [2:57:04] the exact number but it's close [2:57:06] to 40 people have died at Tent [2:57:08] City since it's in session. [2:57:11] And Sean, you said you were [2:57:14] even going to look into it. [2:57:15] You said you care about [2:57:16] homeless, that you've been [2:57:17] homeless. [2:57:19] Why doesn't it matter that [2:57:20] those people are dying? [2:57:21] Why does it matter that Ciara [2:57:23] died on Friday? [2:57:26] Why does it matter that people [2:57:27] are being raped there? [2:57:29] They're like there's rats and [2:57:30] infestations but people are [2:57:32] losing their lives there. [2:57:33] And I just I really don't [2:57:35] understand why someone like [2:57:37] Steven will I get why he would [2:57:39] Because he's an arrogant son of [2:57:40] a And that's why he laughed in [2:57:42] my face when Tammy died and why [2:57:46] he doesn't give a that this [2:57:48] older woman died on Thursday [2:57:50] and a woman named Sierra died [2:57:52] on Friday. [2:57:54] How many more? [2:57:55] I've asked you guys this for [2:57:57] years now. [2:57:57] How many people is enough that [2:58:01] you will do something about [2:58:03] tent City Bro What's the number [2:58:06] Is 100 Is it You know like what [2:58:09] What is is that threshold where [2:58:11] it's like oh that death really [2:58:12] matters Where we really should [2:58:14] do something about that. [2:58:16] I mean you're in litigation [2:58:17] federal court for it and you [2:58:20] guys were supposed to bring a [2:58:21] response today and we'll see [2:58:23] what what you've said. [2:58:24] But how many is enough I guess [2:58:32] if it's not your child it [2:58:34] doesn't matter. [2:58:36] >> Anthony Robles. [2:58:43] >> Afternoon City Council I [2:58:46] like to think our city [2:58:49] employees for the presentation [2:58:51] was a good presentation. [2:58:54] Thankful for all [2:58:54] the information that's been [2:58:55] brought forth today. [2:58:58] Um I do have concerns as a [2:58:59] member of the public with some [2:59:01] of the oversight with regard to [2:59:03] some of these facilities has as [2:59:05] has been mentioned by Audra. [2:59:07] I would hope that we could look [2:59:08] into that. [2:59:09] I'd hope that we could be more [2:59:11] accountable with the funds, how [2:59:13] these funds are spent and [2:59:14] ultimately how these services [2:59:16] are delivered to the people. [2:59:17] I have no problem with these [2:59:18] funds going to these programs [2:59:21] and helping people that need [2:59:22] help. [2:59:23] I would just hope that we could [2:59:24] follow up on the oversight and [2:59:27] the supervision and make sure [2:59:28] that these programs are as [2:59:30] effective in helping people as [2:59:32] possible. [2:59:33] With regard to the point that I [2:59:34] was trying to make earlier, [2:59:35] there's a San Diego community [2:59:37] planner's committee letter [2:59:39] probably was left for all of [2:59:39] y'all. [2:59:40] And it says these organization [2:59:42] organizations exist and provide [2:59:45] a meaningful pathway into local [2:59:46] government talking about [2:59:47] the importance of having [2:59:48] members of planning groups [2:59:50] participate in the discussions [2:59:52] and how we serve as liaison [2:59:54] between some of the policies [2:59:55] that are implemented here and [2:59:57] members of the general public [2:59:58] understanding some of [2:59:59] the policies that you all [3:00:00] implement. [3:00:01] I know that this was already [3:00:02] discussed in Item se for a one [3:00:04] but I just wanted to address it [3:00:06] now within the context of [3:00:07] saying we can provide that [3:00:11] opportunity to help some of [3:00:12] these issues become more better [3:00:14] known to the public especially [3:00:15] with regard to the Housing [3:00:17] Commission. [3:00:17] The grants, the agreements that [3:00:19] are made. [3:00:20] But it's in our best interest [3:00:22] to have you all support with [3:00:25] regard to the human rights [3:00:29] issues, the privacy issues, [3:00:30] the constitutional amendment [3:00:32] issues this morning the Supreme [3:00:33] Court handed down a decision [3:00:37] with regard to all of our [3:00:38] privacy concerns with regard to [3:00:40] our location database tracking. [3:00:43] I will mention that and non [3:00:44] agenda public comment thank you [3:00:47] started the five minute time [3:00:48] are going to those [3:00:49] participating remotely Hector [3:00:51] if you can please unmute after [3:00:53] that is 8700 and then Blair [3:00:55] Beekman. [3:00:56] >> It's great for you guys [3:00:57] pursue all the grants it's [3:00:59] great man Just get on some more [3:01:01] grants It also throughout [3:01:02] the city but there's also like [3:01:05] been talk about taxing the rich [3:01:08] so if you want to tax I'm all [3:01:09] for taxing the rich politicians [3:01:12] like Scott Peters has got $600 [3:01:14] Million on Google and Sarah [3:01:17] Jacobs got 60 million But she's [3:01:20] related to MR. Jacobs who's got [3:01:23] like a trillion I wouldn't tax [3:01:26] him. [3:01:27] Let's just put a tax on [3:01:28] the wealthy politicians that [3:01:31] are in our purview. [3:01:32] You and maybe just that million [3:01:34] dollars a year to go to [3:01:36] the housing fund and see how [3:01:38] they like it will set the rich [3:01:41] politician as $10 Million So if [3:01:45] you got 10 million you should [3:01:47] be able to afford not counting [3:01:49] your house like you other house [3:01:53] and the lawyer that is down But [3:01:53] if you got 10 million somewhere [3:01:55] that's called rich and we'll [3:01:57] just put $1 million a year tax [3:01:59] on the politicians and even [3:02:02] some of your cronies below you, [3:02:04] they might be sitting there [3:02:06] talking to people. [3:02:08] They might be loaded no kind of [3:02:10] trust fund kids or something. [3:02:12] But anyway that's what [3:02:16] the Housing Commission just one [3:02:17] house set a time target one [3:02:19] house and try to make it work. [3:02:21] However the grants flow or [3:02:24] the people that live there see [3:02:26] what happens and just one house [3:02:29] at a time. [3:02:29] It's it's going to be hard to [3:02:31] compete with guys with billions [3:02:33] of dollars and to them it's [3:02:35] just a candy store. [3:02:36] They're looking at that [3:02:37] property and it's going to be [3:02:39] hard for the city to match [3:02:41] the funds or it's going to be a [3:02:43] kind of it's going to be hard [3:02:47] to do. [3:02:47] The guys are paying them double [3:02:48] What you guys are paying [3:02:50] Anyway, good luck. [3:02:53] >> 8700 If you can please [3:02:55] unmute Joy Senator thank you. [3:03:05] San Diego Housing Commission I [3:03:08] love grants and I have been [3:03:10] concerned about grants due to [3:03:13] the way things have been [3:03:14] unfolding the last few years So [3:03:18] it looks like you're doing [3:03:19] better with the competitive [3:03:21] grants because at one point I [3:03:24] thought we were going to form a [3:03:25] working group and analyze what [3:03:28] was happening on our not [3:03:30] getting competitive grants and [3:03:32] that never did happen. [3:03:33] I don't know what happened to [3:03:34] that working group But anyway [3:03:37] it looks like things are really [3:03:40] so that applied in a very good [3:03:41] way. [3:03:42] So thank you very much San [3:03:44] Diego Housing Commission for [3:03:45] that and keep up the work when [3:03:49] we have that other item today [3:03:51] on on the Opportunity Fund I [3:03:54] was surprised to see that list [3:03:57] Nine of the people on that list [3:04:01] had zero grant money come in. [3:04:05] So you know, I think it is it's [3:04:09] much less and that's sad. [3:04:11] So hopefully that will change [3:04:13] and philanthropists to me are [3:04:16] definitely invited to the table [3:04:18] as all income levels are [3:04:20] invited to our table and we can [3:04:23] have a conversation of working [3:04:24] together. [3:04:25] So thank you Congressman Scott [3:04:29] Peters so very much for your [3:04:31] work for California and for San [3:04:33] Diego And thank you [3:04:35] Congresswoman Sarah Jacobs also [3:04:38] for your help with the grants. [3:04:40] You are very appreciated as are [3:04:42] all people that work together [3:04:44] to to make our city work and to [3:04:48] make all levels of people work [3:04:51] together. [3:04:51] That is so appreciated. [3:04:53] I love to all of you That [3:04:58] completes your comments. [3:05:00] Yes. [3:05:00] Thank you. [3:05:01] >> Thank you. [3:05:02] Blair Bateman If you can please [3:05:03] unmute. [3:05:04] >> All right. [3:05:06] Thank you Big Ben. [3:05:08] Really nice to have a comment [3:05:09] from Joy. [3:05:10] Thank you. [3:05:10] >> I learned a lot from what [3:05:12] you just said Grants is a is a [3:05:15] new process to me. [3:05:16] >> I find it an interesting [3:05:17] process to be learning about [3:05:19] how our government can function [3:05:20] and find ways of funding and so [3:05:25] thank you for this item and [3:05:27] good luck how this can develop [3:05:27] . [3:05:30] >> Thank you. [3:05:31] Thank you John If you can [3:05:34] please on you. [3:05:39] Yes Thank you for all Thank you [3:05:41] again. [3:05:42] Hello. [3:05:42] Hello John Brady with [3:05:44] Experience Advisors Thank you [3:05:44] again for this update. [3:05:47] I you know I think as we are [3:05:49] looking forward to another [3:05:52] three years we need to be [3:05:54] planning for even more cuts and [3:06:02] and and really I guess where my [3:06:04] frustrations are as I see [3:06:05] the country and therefore our [3:06:09] own city heading in a very dark [3:06:11] direction when it comes to our [3:06:13] support for people in need, our [3:06:16] compassion and for people that [3:06:17] have been impacted by any [3:06:19] number of life struggles and a [3:06:22] seemingly comfortable I guess [3:06:27] they comfortable way that they [3:06:28] society at large wants to [3:06:30] accept that it's okay to blame [3:06:34] the victim And I don't know how [3:06:38] we reverse that but I do know [3:06:40] that it does need a unified [3:06:42] political voice locally here [3:06:46] that is clearly saying we can't [3:06:48] do this to our own people. [3:06:50] We can't do this to our [3:06:51] neighbors, we can't do this to [3:06:53] our grandparents. [3:06:54] We can't do this to our family [3:06:55] members. [3:06:56] We can't do this to even those [3:06:57] strangers. [3:06:57] We don't have. [3:07:01] But we've got more belt [3:07:03] tightening folks And these [3:07:05] decisions are going to get even [3:07:07] harder as we move forward. [3:07:08] >> Thank you. [3:07:10] That does include public [3:07:12] comment for this item. [3:07:13] All right. [3:07:13] Thank you, city clerk. [3:07:14] And with that I'll turn it over [3:07:15] to my colleagues. [3:07:17] This is an information item so [3:07:18] no motion is required. [3:07:19] >> I'll go to Council member [3:07:21] Whitburn. [3:07:22] Thank you. [3:07:23] Council PRESIDENT Thank you for [3:07:24] this report. [3:07:25] Applying for these grants is [3:07:27] critical work. [3:07:28] It's a lot of work and [3:07:29] the effort that you put into it [3:07:31] is very much appreciated. [3:07:33] Understanding that this report [3:07:34] gives us the status as of [3:07:36] the end of last year DECEMBER [3:07:37] 31st that there were six [3:07:39] pending grants at that time. [3:07:42] Do you know if we've heard of [3:07:44] any of those pending six grants [3:07:45] since then? [3:07:46] I fear that at your fingertips [3:07:48] if you don't we can follow up. [3:07:49] But I'm curious if you've heard [3:07:51] one way or the other. [3:07:53] >> Yeah, I don't have that [3:07:54] information in my fingertips [3:07:55] right now but we have heard [3:07:56] back on probably most of them. [3:07:58] Yeah. [3:07:58] And we can certainly provide [3:08:00] you with that information. [3:08:01] Thank you. [3:08:02] We did get some good news late [3:08:04] on Friday. [3:08:05] Not part of this program but [3:08:07] that the state's hap program is [3:08:10] going to be fully funded during [3:08:13] the last budget And this MAY be [3:08:16] a question for Lisa. [3:08:18] We were forced to cut 50 beds [3:08:21] at the 60 Newton shelter [3:08:24] because there wasn't enough [3:08:26] money to fund them all. [3:08:27] Understanding that we got this [3:08:29] news late Friday and you know [3:08:30] it's the middle of the day on [3:08:32] Monday. [3:08:33] Do you have any idea yet [3:08:35] whether the full funding will [3:08:37] enable us to keep those 50 [3:08:38] beds? [3:08:40] >> No, I don't. [3:08:41] It's wonderful to see [3:08:42] the amount of funding that has [3:08:43] come through and for the state [3:08:44] to really step up And I think a [3:08:46] lot of the advocacy that [3:08:47] happened with this council and [3:08:48] with this mayor MAY have to [3:08:50] make that happen. [3:08:52] And shelter is definitely an [3:08:53] eligible use for those funds. [3:08:55] But we'll need to meet with [3:08:57] the city's Homeless Strategies [3:08:59] and Solutions department [3:09:00] obviously have conversations [3:09:01] with Council and the mayor [3:09:02] about where that funding can [3:09:05] go. [3:09:05] >> Okay. [3:09:06] Thank you very much. [3:09:07] Appreciate that And thank you [3:09:09] again for all the work to bring [3:09:10] in funding and thank you [3:09:12] Council PRESIDENT. [3:09:13] All right. [3:09:14] Thank you Council member [3:09:14] whitburn. [3:09:16] I don't see anybody else lights [3:09:17] I'll just have my thank you for [3:09:18] the good work and clearly you [3:09:20] have the secret sauce of going [3:09:22] after grants and securing [3:09:23] the wins on that. [3:09:25] So when there's too little [3:09:26] resources it's incredibly [3:09:28] important to do that. [3:09:29] Good work. [3:09:30] So thank you. [3:09:32] >> Thank you. [3:09:33] With that we will now proceed [3:09:34] with the approval of [3:09:35] the Housing Authority minutes. [3:09:37] >> clerk Please proceed with [3:09:39] public comment. [3:09:40] >> Thank you. [3:09:41] The public comment period for [3:09:42] the housing authority minutes [3:09:43] is now open and please note [3:09:44] each speaker will have three [3:09:46] will have one minute per item [3:09:47] per person up to a maximum of 3 [3:09:50] minutes or 3 minutes on [3:09:51] the agenda. [3:09:51] Tuesday, MAY 12th, 2026 Regular [3:09:54] Meeting Tuesday, JUNE 9th, 2026 [3:09:56] Regular meeting and Monday, [3:09:57] JUNE 15th, 2026 Special meeting [3:10:01] and allegedly order if you can [3:10:03] please come forward. [3:10:10] >> You'll have three minutes to [3:10:12] speak on all three dates. [3:10:17] >> So you're talking about [3:10:18] bonds for housing homeless [3:10:19] programs, litigation and these [3:10:22] three meetings and you know [3:10:23] we're getting in debt to [3:10:27] pretend to provide housing. [3:10:32] I just find it extremely [3:10:33] difficult to like proceed when [3:10:39] you guys hear people have died [3:10:42] in your programs and it doesn't [3:10:44] bother you enough to go, We [3:10:47] should really look into that. [3:10:48] >> We should figure out why [3:10:52] this is happening. [3:10:52] >> I mean, Steven why why [3:10:53] aren't you doing that? [3:10:54] Why is it funny to you? [3:11:03] >> Everything done in the dark [3:11:05] will come to the light And it [3:11:07] does And it's sad because it's [3:11:09] like I mean these people are [3:11:14] put in like a prison there. [3:11:15] You guys spend money at Tent [3:11:17] City to put up a fence that is [3:11:20] a wired like the ones that [3:11:22] usually have the spikes going [3:11:23] out. [3:11:24] Like you go to a hotel and you [3:11:25] see it because you don't want [3:11:26] someone coming in But it tent [3:11:29] city they're facing in like [3:11:30] these people can't get out and [3:11:32] you put them in fire danger by [3:11:34] continuing to add tents and [3:11:37] it's like you can't even see [3:11:38] your way out of there and [3:11:40] there's no fireworks Seeing [3:11:41] wishers if there was a fire in [3:11:44] Fenton, all is being dealt [3:11:44] there and people are dying on [3:11:48] it on a regular basis And yet [3:11:51] Dreams for Change continues to [3:11:53] get more funding because that's [3:11:57] your friend Stephen and that's [3:12:00] why you don't give a that [3:12:03] these people are dying. [3:12:04] That's like three people a [3:12:05] month so far this year and [3:12:13] everybody just sits there like [3:12:15] who cares? [3:12:21] And you wonder why people don't [3:12:23] trust you. [3:12:25] I'm not talking about someone [3:12:27] taking a out on the sidewalk [3:12:29] which happens all the time to [3:12:31] allow people to come and clean [3:12:32] it up. [3:12:32] I'm talking about a life lost [3:12:36] and you guys sit up here and [3:12:38] act like you care about people [3:12:39] But this falls upon deaf ears [3:12:42] and we just keep giving them [3:12:44] more money. [3:12:47] Make it make sense. [3:12:50] Why don't their lives matter [3:12:52] enough to like question what's [3:12:57] going on to go? [3:12:59] Maybe we should look into this [3:13:00] funding, make sure it's really [3:13:02] going somewhere that is [3:13:04] beneficial to people. [3:13:05] I mean if Theresa Smiths wants [3:13:07] people to stay there as long as [3:13:09] possible I mean that's [3:13:12] terrifying and literally they [3:13:14] die before they'll ever get [3:13:15] into housing. [3:13:16] >> How sad going to those [3:13:20] participating online. [3:13:21] John Stump if you can please [3:13:23] unmute and let me know which [3:13:25] item or items of minutes you [3:13:27] wish to speak to. [3:13:29] Oh excuse me. [3:13:30] I thought this was public [3:13:31] comment. [3:13:32] They'll be next. [3:13:33] I'll come back to you John [3:13:36] Please let me know which item [3:13:38] or items you wish to speak to [3:13:39] on the minutes. [3:13:44] I'm sorry at that. [3:13:44] This public comment goes well. [3:13:47] I have you We'll come back to [3:13:48] you right now Blair Beekman on [3:13:50] the minutes Well where do you [3:13:53] know where Big Ben I'm going to [3:13:55] wait to for public comment [3:13:57] Sorry about sorry. [3:14:00] >> Okay. [3:14:00] That does conclude the public [3:14:01] comment on the minutes or I [3:14:06] think you said sorry or I think [3:14:07] you city Clerk And with that [3:14:08] I'm going to make a motion to [3:14:09] approve the minutes. [3:14:09] Can I get a second [3:14:11] Councilmember Marina Beach out [3:14:13] Not anybody else seeking to [3:14:15] speak So motion by myself and [3:14:15] the second by Councilmember [3:14:19] Moreno. [3:14:20] Clerk please call the roll. [3:14:22] >> I'm sorry The voting system [3:14:23] Please cast your vote That [3:14:32] passes unanimously 6 to 0 with [3:14:34] Council member Campo, [3:14:35] Councilmember Yvonne Wolpert [3:14:37] and Councilmember Foster [3:14:37] absent. [3:14:37] Thank you Council PRESIDENT. [3:14:39] All right. [3:14:39] We will now adjourn as a [3:14:40] housing authority and reconvene [3:14:41] as the City council and take up [3:14:44] non agenda public comment. [3:14:45] Council members respect and [3:14:46] appreciate the public's input. [3:14:48] I fully committed to protecting [3:14:49] every participant's free speech [3:14:50] rights at council and committee [3:14:51] meetings. [3:14:52] >> Clerk Please proceed with [3:14:53] public comment. [3:14:55] >> Thank you. [3:14:55] Council PRESIDENT Per rule 2.7 [3:14:57] on agenda Public comment is an [3:14:58] opportunity for members of [3:14:59] the public to comment on items [3:15:00] that are not on the agenda but [3:15:02] within the subject matter [3:15:03] jurisdiction of the City [3:15:04] Council. [3:15:04] Each speaker will have two [3:15:05] minutes. [3:15:06] Please note if there are eight [3:15:07] or more speakers on a single [3:15:08] topic the maximum time for [3:15:09] the topic will be 16 minutes. [3:15:11] If you're in chambers please [3:15:12] submit your speaker slip If [3:15:13] you're joining us virtually [3:15:14] please raise your hand to speak [3:15:15] by tapping the raise your hand [3:15:16] icon or if you are calling on [3:15:18] Participant Star nine allegedly [3:15:22] Audrey if you can please come [3:15:22] forward And then Anthony Ralph [3:15:25] so he can please come to [3:15:26] the yellow reserved seats at [3:15:27] the front of the room. [3:15:31] It's interesting I wasn't here [3:15:32] earlier because I was in care [3:15:34] court now for myself. [3:15:36] But hearing what they're going [3:15:37] to do with Andrea being and [3:15:39] it's such an educational [3:15:41] experience just observing [3:15:44] things like a board like this [3:15:46] being in court and seeing how [3:15:48] they use competency And then I [3:15:51] think about how I'm telling you [3:15:52] guys about people dying that [3:15:54] are part of your community and [3:15:56] that involve really people [3:15:59] don't care. [3:15:59] So I would think I mean you [3:16:01] guys should be evaluated for [3:16:02] competency to see I mean are [3:16:05] you you you know if you don't [3:16:07] really care about human life [3:16:08] but you're saying that you do I [3:16:09] mean perhaps you're incompetent [3:16:11] and perhaps you guys should be [3:16:13] sent to one of the psychiatric [3:16:15] facilities and medicated until [3:16:17] you can be deemed competent. [3:16:19] Right. [3:16:19] And somebody like me because [3:16:21] this is how it goes Like [3:16:22] someone like you guys would [3:16:23] deem me incompetent because I [3:16:25] don't go along with your [3:16:26] ideologies. [3:16:27] So imagine someone like me [3:16:29] doing that to you and saying [3:16:31] that the way that you feel is [3:16:34] means that you are incompetent [3:16:35] . [3:16:37] It's interesting the way [3:16:38] the world works and if you [3:16:39] don't just kind of capitulate [3:16:41] and go along and conform then [3:16:44] you're seen as somebody who [3:16:46] needs their behavior changed [3:16:48] And it's like I literally could [3:16:49] say that about you guys seeing [3:16:51] that you don't care that people [3:16:52] are dying all while professing [3:16:55] that you do. [3:16:57] >> But it's interesting the way [3:16:59] that it's used to silence [3:17:00] people And sure there's people [3:17:03] that are incompetent [3:17:04] potentially and need help and [3:17:06] wouldn't be able to, you know, [3:17:07] go through trial. [3:17:09] >> But when it's literally [3:17:10] being used to silence the truth [3:17:12] about the people that are [3:17:13] actually engaged in this care [3:17:15] court and whatnot, what a smart [3:17:19] weapon to use. [3:17:20] You know what I'm saying? [3:17:22] But imagine being that person. [3:17:23] Thank GOD it's not you guys. [3:17:25] Right? [3:17:26] Right. [3:17:28] Maybe it'll be one of your [3:17:29] children. [3:17:29] >> Who knows? [3:17:30] We'll see who's in charge. [3:17:35] Anthony Rose Yes, I will read [3:17:41] today's reading from [3:17:42] the Supreme Court. [3:17:44] But first I just want to [3:17:44] acknowledge that there is an [3:17:46] inherent conflict of interest [3:17:47] between those that want to [3:17:48] leave work early and can do so [3:17:50] with a short workday with which [3:17:53] is facilitated by minimal [3:17:55] public engagement and those [3:17:57] members of the public that wish [3:17:58] to have a robust, engaged, [3:18:00] fully informed discussion that [3:18:02] often requires extended hours [3:18:03] of additional city council [3:18:04] participation. [3:18:06] So when the vast majority of [3:18:07] your constituents demand you [3:18:09] respect our concept of our [3:18:11] constitutional protected [3:18:11] privacy rights over your own [3:18:14] esdp sponsored perception of [3:18:16] public safety, it sends us [3:18:18] the message that you prioritize [3:18:20] getting off work early over [3:18:22] doing your job. [3:18:25] So here's the article You've [3:18:27] probably had a chance to read [3:18:28] it But this morning the Supreme [3:18:29] Court ruled that when law [3:18:30] enforcement officials used a [3:18:32] geofence warrant a warrant that [3:18:33] instructed Google to provide [3:18:34] location data for cell phone [3:18:36] users who were near a [3:18:37] particular place during a [3:18:39] specified time period to obtain [3:18:41] evidence used to convict a [3:18:42] Virginia man of a 2019 bank [3:18:44] robbery. [3:18:44] They conducted a quote search [3:18:46] for the purposes of the Fourth [3:18:47] Amendment By a vote of 6 to 3 [3:18:50] the justices sent Okello [3:18:53] Patrice's case back to [3:18:53] the lower court for it to [3:18:54] consider whether his Fourth [3:18:55] Amendment requires the search [3:18:57] was quote reasonable. [3:18:58] Writing for the majority, [3:19:00] Justice Elena Kagan emphasized [3:19:01] that quote An individual has a [3:19:03] reasonable expectation of [3:19:05] privacy in records about his [3:19:07] cell phone's location and [3:19:08] police intrude on that [3:19:10] constitutionally protected [3:19:12] interest when they demand [3:19:13] the information even though for [3:19:14] only a limited time and from a [3:19:16] third party tech company there [3:19:22] we have it the Supreme Court [3:19:23] decided this morning that our [3:19:26] location data on our on our [3:19:28] cell phones is not fair game [3:19:30] for third party applications to [3:19:33] be utilized to track us. [3:19:36] That should be a clear cut case [3:19:37] . [3:19:39] >> There are lawsuits all over [3:19:40] the state of California against [3:19:43] Floc Thank you for that [3:19:44] concluding remark Five minute [3:19:45] time We're going to those [3:19:46] participating online. [3:19:48] We currently have nine speakers [3:19:49] in the queue starting with [3:19:50] John. [3:19:50] >> If you can please unmute. [3:19:54] >> Good evening City Council. [3:19:55] My first comment is that public [3:20:00] comment should be at [3:20:01] the beginning of the meeting or [3:20:02] you should at least provide [3:20:03] the opportunity for a number of [3:20:05] people to speak at [3:20:06] the beginning of the meeting. [3:20:07] Because in part public comment [3:20:08] is so that our voices are heard [3:20:10] not only by us, not only by you [3:20:12] but other members of [3:20:13] the community. [3:20:16] Secondly, I want to explain to [3:20:17] you what it's like to be a [3:20:18] target. [3:20:19] I have had my rb now for two [3:20:22] years. [3:20:23] I have regularly parked it on [3:20:24] the nearby overpass where semi [3:20:27] tractor trailers parked [3:20:28] limousines, other commercial [3:20:30] businesses, vehicles got junk [3:20:34] trailers. [3:20:35] >> But for the moment until [3:20:38] the moment somebody was [3:20:39] identified as living in there [3:20:41] And then I became a marked [3:20:43] vehicle. [3:20:45] So now 17 members of [3:20:47] the community policing [3:20:48] department are out and actively [3:20:51] aware of where my vehicle is [3:20:53] And now I've got 275 to $75 [3:20:57] ticket with no warning for [3:20:59] trying to help. [3:21:00] That's my office. [3:21:01] That's the place we used to do [3:21:03] surveys. [3:21:04] That's the place I've never [3:21:05] allowed anybody to live on it [3:21:07] at least while I was out in a [3:21:08] public space. [3:21:09] So I'm a little in shock here [3:21:11] how quickly we're able to act [3:21:12] on that. [3:21:13] >> But we can't pick up a911 [3:21:14] call. [3:21:17] We've got to figure out where [3:21:18] our priorities are. [3:21:20] And right now going into this [3:21:22] whole budget negotiation, I [3:21:24] thought homelessness was off [3:21:26] the table. [3:21:27] And then I thought well, we're [3:21:29] going to cut the new center not [3:21:30] one member of the Community [3:21:32] Budget Alliance or any of [3:21:33] the other people that I know [3:21:34] that advocate for homeless [3:21:36] individuals had any clue when [3:21:38] that went through that it was [3:21:39] going to permanently close [3:21:40] the neon good day center. [3:21:42] We've been your close partner [3:21:44] on this and I'll tell you I [3:21:45] feel violated. [3:21:48] Our trust is gone. [3:21:51] And that's a sad place to be. [3:21:54] >> Thank you, Blair Beckman If [3:21:57] you can place on you. [3:22:00] All right. [3:22:01] Thank you. [3:22:02] Plan b friends? [3:22:02] Yeah. [3:22:02] I thought we were working on a [3:22:04] six day plan for the future of [3:22:07] New York State Center. [3:22:07] I was pretty shocked in what [3:22:08] you've decided. [3:22:09] I understand your decision and [3:22:11] how it can be working. [3:22:13] But the previous speaker is [3:22:15] offering a lot of good public [3:22:17] comment What we actually need [3:22:20] within the data center and we [3:22:20] have to be having that [3:22:21] conversation more openly and [3:22:24] regularly. [3:22:25] As I've been mentioning myself [3:22:26] I've been trying to mention [3:22:27] John is up in the actual words [3:22:29] Good luck in that effort. [3:22:31] So what we can be talking about [3:22:32] openly and I also wanted to [3:22:35] mention there's been a lot of [3:22:37] talk about encampment issues [3:22:40] You know, or the government [3:22:41] sponsored camp I heard before [3:22:44] here you know that instead of [3:22:47] you know, the 2 to 300 person [3:22:49] site in San Diego, San Jose's [3:22:52] model, they work, you know, in [3:22:54] a much smaller frame you know, [3:22:56] 35 to 50, 25 to 35 spaces for [3:23:00] people. [3:23:00] We can have one space in San [3:23:02] Diego to say 100 people and [3:23:04] then you know, create 3 or 4 [3:23:06] little smaller spaces that I [3:23:09] think we can much better manage [3:23:10] people and people will just be [3:23:12] dying the way they currently [3:23:14] are. [3:23:15] This large encampment is [3:23:16] creating a lot of again and we [3:23:19] got to really consider our [3:23:20] different options from that. [3:23:22] So good luck on those efforts. [3:23:23] Good luck that we can be [3:23:25] listening to Andrea Evans case [3:23:26] what she can be doing, what we [3:23:29] can be doing for her so she can [3:23:30] be free and regular She [3:23:33] deserves it. [3:23:35] I thank you for the words of [3:23:36] Anthony. [3:23:38] She actually mentioned concepts [3:23:39] that we're working on in 2018 [3:23:41] We stopped something in 2018. [3:23:44] Good work. [3:23:45] We can continue what he's [3:23:46] talking about and from that [3:23:47] really address your issues in [3:23:49] real time. [3:23:50] There's a lot of subtlety in [3:23:52] what he said and how he can and [3:23:55] can't work that we need to more [3:23:57] openly address And I'll talk [3:23:58] about more tomorrow a lot more [3:24:02] I need to say good luck with [3:24:04] our public process right now, [3:24:05] concluded Francine Maxwell. [3:24:07] >> If you can please on your [3:24:13] Nancy Maxwell Southeastern San [3:24:14] Diego resident I want to thank [3:24:16] the council for the education [3:24:18] that came when I was [3:24:20] misdirected. [3:24:22] Really appreciate that. [3:24:24] Now let's parlay that since [3:24:26] there are so many upcoming [3:24:28] legislative breaks, let's do it [3:24:30] Educational series. [3:24:31] Let's go to some parking risks [3:24:33] and let's make sure that we try [3:24:36] to educate the community all [3:24:38] year long. [3:24:39] I would like your first thing [3:24:40] to be educational wise How can [3:24:44] Steve Cushman be an advisor to [3:24:47] the city, to the mayor's office [3:24:48] and be on the Housing [3:24:50] Commission? [3:24:52] So it would seem like that [3:24:53] would be a conflict to me. [3:24:55] I completely understand that [3:24:56] everybody is looking for their [3:24:58] next gig and so Steve Cushman [3:25:01] is not looking for his next gig [3:25:02] because he's pretty much [3:25:03] running our city. [3:25:04] But the mayor is absolutely [3:25:07] parlaying his dc trips and so [3:25:10] maybe he's looking to get a [3:25:11] position in hud or something. [3:25:14] >> We don't have all [3:25:15] the receipts but it seems like [3:25:17] elected officials continue to [3:25:20] hold things close to the vest [3:25:22] And when somebody needs a good [3:25:24] piece of press things come out [3:25:27] very appreciative of District [3:25:29] nine sharing with my neighbors [3:25:30] that our elected official is on [3:25:33] official business Love our [3:25:35] neighbor National City Council [3:25:36] member markets took a picture [3:25:38] of our council member on a bus [3:25:41] with our Board of Supervisors [3:25:43] vice chair just wonderful [3:25:46] communication through social [3:25:47] media. [3:25:48] So we're hoping that in [3:25:50] the newsletter there will be a [3:25:51] report in reference to [3:25:53] the Baltimore official trip. [3:25:55] >> Again, all city officials [3:25:57] take all of these official [3:25:59] trips. [3:26:00] You sit on other boards and [3:26:02] commissions, some of them are [3:26:04] paid, some of them are not. [3:26:05] But there never an educational [3:26:08] component or a component to [3:26:09] the constituents. [3:26:11] So let's do better. [3:26:12] Let's begin to educate the next [3:26:14] generation. [3:26:15] Thank you. [3:26:16] Thank you. [3:26:16] 8700 If you can please unmute [3:26:18] 8700 city for committees so I [3:26:27] can shape my comments is this [3:26:31] each day this is not agenda [3:26:32] public comment for the whole [3:26:36] meeting for the for the city [3:26:38] council meeting yes but there [3:26:41] was no agenda Public comment No [3:26:44] because it was a special [3:26:45] meeting for you. [3:26:51] Okay Thank you. [3:26:52] We just catch my breath here a [3:26:54] minute. [3:26:56] Had two plans so we will need [3:26:59] to start your time out. [3:27:05] I think you I need to finish on [3:27:06] this because I. [3:27:07] I don't know. [3:27:09] I'm coming strictly from [3:27:11] extemporaneous and then I think [3:27:14] I need to begin to get it out [3:27:20] of joy to I voted yes for this [3:27:22] week since we think [3:27:29] the ordinance a small minority [3:27:32] voted yes I'm never forget that [3:27:33] day and here we are That's what [3:27:38] we to where we are now And let [3:27:40] me tell you that I still [3:27:42] believe in our case. [3:27:50] We think of and pivot away from [3:27:52] that. [3:27:54] I'm using a lens to look at [3:27:57] the world. [3:27:59] It's different for each of us [3:28:01] that's proven scientifically [3:28:03] and to my lens I can't see all [3:28:07] the ugliness I'm hearing. [3:28:10] I don't I've never witnessed it [3:28:12] yet. [3:28:13] I respect the people that are [3:28:15] sharing their truth So I'm I to [3:28:18] become sort of a rock and a [3:28:19] hard place. [3:28:21] I worked with the homeless for [3:28:23] 20 years. [3:28:24] David lost both my hair [3:28:28] the water man He lived in [3:28:30] the trenches Not really that he [3:28:32] lived there as a hero and he [3:28:34] told me a lot And these people [3:28:42] they have stories that are [3:28:43] beyond belief So we transition [3:28:46] them from the streets into an [3:28:49] enclosed space. [3:28:50] He could save sleeping sight, [3:28:55] make it safe and comfortable [3:28:56] and take care of them. [3:28:58] I don't know. [3:29:00] It's a big transition. [3:29:01] Let's talk more later with Joel [3:29:01] . [3:29:04] Thank you, Kathleen Lippert. [3:29:10] Thank you. [3:29:11] Good afternoon. [3:29:12] Council and the public drug [3:29:14] policy researcher. [3:29:16] I follow drug research and best [3:29:18] practices for decades. [3:29:20] The year to year data is [3:29:21] important but it is the long [3:29:24] term trend of drug use that are [3:29:27] that are the best indicators of [3:29:30] a city's policies Whether or [3:29:32] not they're preventing harms or [3:29:34] contributing to collateral [3:29:36] damage. [3:29:37] The report I want to share [3:29:39] today with Council is from [3:29:41] the American Society of [3:29:43] Addiction Medicine, which [3:29:44] followed cannabis policy [3:29:46] changes from 2009 to 2018. [3:29:50] The researchers studied [3:29:51] pediatric exposures of children [3:29:55] under six years old to [3:29:57] marijuana which were stable [3:29:59] between 2000 and 2009. [3:30:02] But beginning in 2010 [3:30:05] the increase of more than [3:30:08] 6,000% in pediatric exposures [3:30:10] to marijuana it was found oral [3:30:13] ingestion was found to be [3:30:15] responsible for the majority of [3:30:18] exposures in young children. [3:30:21] A concurrent prospective cohort [3:30:23] found that virtually all of [3:30:26] the of the effects were from [3:30:29] hospital admissions in the U.S. [3:30:34] And Canada For those under ten [3:30:35] years old for severe toxicity [3:30:38] from marijuana was from [3:30:40] ingestions of edible [3:30:42] preparations. [3:30:45] The negative effects on [3:30:47] children's health public health [3:30:48] policy adjustments are [3:30:50] warranted. [3:30:52] Please the city should consider [3:30:55] the manufacturers that it [3:30:57] allows the small shops that [3:30:59] continue to sell such broad [3:31:01] edible products without any [3:31:04] oversight or regulations And [3:31:07] these are the products that are [3:31:08] getting into the hands of [3:31:10] children They need to be [3:31:13] protected. [3:31:13] >> I hope you will do that. [3:31:15] Thank you. [3:31:15] Your time has concluded. [3:31:17] The five minute time are also [3:31:18] concluded and there are eight [3:31:19] speakers in the queue. [3:31:21] No additional speakers will be [3:31:22] taken. [3:31:23] >> Barbara Gordon If you can [3:31:24] please unmute Thank you. [3:31:28] As a public health educator [3:31:30] concerned about the lack of [3:31:32] Smokefree policies, I wanted to [3:31:33] share with you a peer review [3:31:36] study regarding comprehensive [3:31:39] Smokefree laws and [3:31:40] cardiovascular disease [3:31:41] mortality in U.S. Counties. [3:31:44] This was published in [3:31:46] the Journal of American Medical [3:31:48] Association just JUNE of 2026. [3:31:52] The research examined [3:31:53] comprehensive Smokefree Laws [3:31:56] Associate it with long term [3:31:58] changes in cardiovascular [3:32:00] disease mortality at the county [3:32:03] level in the us. [3:32:04] The 2026 county level study [3:32:07] found that counties adopting [3:32:09] comprehensive smokefree laws [3:32:11] were associated with lower [3:32:13] cardiovascular mortality over [3:32:15] roughly a decade compared to [3:32:17] similar counties that did not [3:32:19] adopt such law. [3:32:21] These findings are consistent [3:32:22] with decades of research [3:32:24] showing that comprehensive [3:32:26] Smokefree policies reduce [3:32:27] exposure to secondhand smoke [3:32:30] and are associated with [3:32:32] improvement of cardiovascular [3:32:34] health. [3:32:35] The strongest evidence supports [3:32:38] Smokefree laws of any kind [3:32:40] tobacco or marijuana indoors or [3:32:42] outdoor public places without [3:32:44] exception showed an average [3:32:46] reduction of about 12 [3:32:47] cardiovascular death per 100 [3:32:50] people in this year. [3:32:52] I think for city councils and [3:32:53] local health departments that [3:32:56] we can reduce exposure tobacco [3:32:58] and marijuana secondhand smoke [3:33:00] by enacting comprehensive well [3:33:03] enforced smokefree ordinances [3:33:05] along with it doing public [3:33:08] health education and it will [3:33:10] improve the lives of all San [3:33:10] Diego. [3:33:13] Thank you for letting me speak [3:33:16] Ernie Casco If you can please [3:33:18] unmute Brant Colorado Ernie [3:33:26] Casco Lawyer Resident Attention [3:33:28] District Attorney The end [3:33:31] concern of Torrey Pines Dog [3:33:34] Park Ongoing dispute The Dear [3:33:35] Ernie email I received from cp [3:33:37] p is completely unacceptable [3:33:40] unacceptable It fails to [3:33:43] address serious allegations [3:33:44] made to City Council John [3:33:47] LaCava and San Diego Police [3:33:48] Department itself. [3:33:50] It it completely ignores [3:33:51] the victims and witnesses and [3:33:53] the ongoing criminal activity [3:33:54] and public safety concerns that [3:33:57] tweet my slide report My first [3:33:58] question is is where are [3:34:00] the police reports addressing [3:34:02] the victim and witnesses? [3:34:03] Residents should not be forced [3:34:06] to sign an access pass waiver [3:34:08] under the threat of violence. [3:34:10] I receive unanimous letters of [3:34:12] support from the town council, [3:34:15] the Hoyt Shores Association and [3:34:16] the University Community [3:34:17] Planning Group to stop this [3:34:20] crime. [3:34:20] Yet the court issues remain [3:34:22] ignored while problems continue [3:34:23] . [3:34:25] I have experienced retaliation [3:34:27] myself Serious injuries and [3:34:32] assaults devastating personal [3:34:33] loss to me and my family [3:34:35] poisoned with a biohazard over [3:34:37] the commercialization of Torrey [3:34:41] Pines Glider part died with [3:34:41] stage four cancer. [3:34:43] I want to see this public park [3:34:45] returned to the people and [3:34:46] protected from future abuse. [3:34:49] I'm asking City Council for [3:34:50] three things. [3:34:51] First, where are the police [3:34:53] reports involving victim and [3:34:55] witnesses? [3:34:56] Let's see them. [3:34:57] Second stop the illegal [3:34:59] collection of public funding in [3:35:01] the private accounts with a [3:35:03] full city audit Until we find [3:35:05] Sly report Where is the money [3:35:06] going? [3:35:07] Third, restore lawful public [3:35:09] access and ensure that no one [3:35:12] is forced into signing waivers. [3:35:14] Time to address the victim and [3:35:16] witnesses and force American [3:35:18] law not administrative law and [3:35:20] stand up for a constitutional [3:35:22] recreational rights and [3:35:24] freedoms. [3:35:25] Thank you. [3:35:28] Ready Casco You kid. [3:35:28] My apologies, Ernie. [3:35:31] Did you want to make any final [3:35:34] comment? [3:35:37] I didn't mean you. [3:35:39] I thought you were dead. [3:35:40] My apologies. [3:35:44] Okay. [3:35:45] You're not a meeting so we will [3:35:46] proceed. [3:35:48] Madison, if you can please. [3:35:52] On. [3:35:53] >> Hello. [3:35:53] Good evening. [3:35:54] City council members with [3:35:56] the 4th of JULY holiday [3:35:57] approaching, I want to briefly [3:35:59] highlight an important public [3:36:00] safety concern drug impaired [3:36:02] driving especially when it [3:36:04] comes to marijuana because [3:36:06] while many people think of [3:36:07] impaired driving primarily in [3:36:08] terms of alcohol, marijuana can [3:36:10] also significantly affect a [3:36:12] person's ability to drive [3:36:13] safely. [3:36:14] It can slow down reaction time [3:36:16] ,impair coordination, distort [3:36:18] perception of distance and [3:36:20] speed and reduce overall [3:36:22] attention. [3:36:23] These effects can make it much [3:36:25] more difficult to respond [3:36:26] quickly to changing road [3:36:27] conditions, pedestrians or [3:36:29] other drivers. [3:36:31] One of the challenges with [3:36:32] marijuana impairment is that [3:36:33] people often underestimate it [3:36:36] Unlike alcohol where there are [3:36:38] well-known guidelines and [3:36:39] widespread public messaging, [3:36:41] many individuals do not fully [3:36:42] recognize how long marijuana [3:36:44] can impair judgment or how it [3:36:46] can affect driving even hours [3:36:48] after use. [3:36:49] This can lead to risky [3:36:51] decisions such as driving too [3:36:53] soon after consumption or [3:36:55] assuming they are fine to drive [3:36:56] when they are not during [3:36:58] holiday periods like the 4th of [3:37:00] JULY when there is increased [3:37:01] travel, social gatherings and [3:37:03] celebrations the risks become [3:37:05] even more significant. [3:37:07] More cars on the road combined [3:37:08] with impaired driving increased [3:37:10] the higher potential for [3:37:11] preventable accidents and [3:37:12] injuries. [3:37:14] I encourage our community to [3:37:15] prioritize planning ahead this [3:37:17] holiday using designated [3:37:19] drivers, rancher services or [3:37:21] other safe transportation [3:37:22] options If substances are being [3:37:24] used, public awareness and [3:37:26] personal responsibility can go [3:37:28] a long way in preventing [3:37:29] tragedies. [3:37:30] Thank you and I wish everyone a [3:37:31] safe and happy holiday. [3:37:33] Thank you. [3:37:34] John Stump Oh John Stump Want [3:37:45] to talk about three things [3:37:48] the recent election I don't [3:37:51] think the results in District [3:37:55] four or in the controversial [3:37:59] districts in New York City is a [3:38:03] reflection that people want [3:38:04] socialism. [3:38:06] I think it's more reflection. [3:38:08] They want change and they're [3:38:10] not They're dissatisfied with [3:38:13] the return they're getting in [3:38:15] response are getting from [3:38:15] elected officials They want [3:38:18] change. [3:38:20] Secondly, in today's newspaper [3:38:22] there was a report about [3:38:24] the separation or retirement of [3:38:30] the ceo of Community Power. [3:38:36] Community power is very fat. [3:38:40] There's 150 employees who make [3:38:43] salaries much greater than [3:38:45] the city of San Diego and [3:38:48] community power doesn't do [3:38:50] anything. [3:38:51] It's just an aggregator. [3:38:52] It doesn't generate or [3:38:54] distribute the council members [3:38:57] that are in community power [3:38:59] should be looking at the wages [3:39:01] paid. [3:39:02] Their third I need the city [3:39:05] clerk to call me concerning [3:39:06] the notice of appeals there's [3:39:10] an appeal scheduled for next [3:39:12] week the seventh and completely [3:39:18] misunderstands what is being [3:39:21] done in an appeal. [3:39:23] The City Council is acting as a [3:39:26] hearing body as judges and yet [3:39:29] the mayor and the staff who are [3:39:32] the group being appealed [3:39:35] against are being given status [3:39:39] in that appeal different than [3:39:41] the appellant So that process [3:39:44] either needs to be re noticed [3:39:49] or changed and concluded Hector [3:39:50] he complains on you. [3:39:54] >> All right thanks. [3:39:55] I'm just so disappointed and [3:39:58] I'm not surprised at [3:40:00] the outcome of the California [3:40:03] budget how we didn't get [3:40:05] millions of dollars to fix our [3:40:07] sewer plant. [3:40:09] Where's our 3 or 400 million to [3:40:11] have a state of the art sewer [3:40:13] plant at the border? [3:40:15] It's a joke. [3:40:16] It's the blind leading [3:40:17] the blind. [3:40:19] You end up smelling Mexican [3:40:21] for another decade. [3:40:23] Come on, man. [3:40:25] We need we need a railroad high [3:40:27] speed from Fresno to [3:40:29] Bakersfield funded another [3:40:31] couple billion. [3:40:33] Where's our money? [3:40:35] But come on, you guys, you got [3:40:36] to be embarrassed. [3:40:38] How could you have your kids [3:40:39] that sewer gas growing up? [3:40:43] You know? [3:40:43] Come on. [3:40:44] What are you going to tell [3:40:44] them? [3:40:45] Why don't they ask the dad? [3:40:48] How do you smell that? [3:40:49] How come we live here? [3:40:51] How What's going on? [3:40:51] Blame. [3:40:53] Blame the Democratic Party. [3:40:56] You can't blame Mexico. [3:40:58] They don't got their together [3:40:58] . [3:41:00] They're only like building $1 [3:41:02] billion highway above Tijuana. [3:41:06] Yeah, which is if you live [3:41:07] below that today, you better be [3:41:09] heavily into the Catholic [3:41:11] Church with their rosary beads [3:41:13] at night when they earthquake [3:41:15] comes, that thing's going down [3:41:19] bad And then there's going to [3:41:20] be a flood, a sewer gas even [3:41:21] more when that sewer breaks [3:41:24] again over there it's it's [3:41:26] frankly it's embarrassing And [3:41:29] don't use the expression [3:41:30] America's finest city until we [3:41:33] have it all areas of the city [3:41:35] and county until we have a [3:41:37] sewer plant that can handle [3:41:39] Tijuana's sewage. [3:41:42] It's just disgusting that it's [3:41:45] just it's totally disgusting. [3:41:48] So anyway, the next time I'm [3:41:50] I'm looking forward to next [3:41:52] year when everyone gets [3:41:53] deported is that'd be great. [3:41:57] Round them up, man. [3:41:58] Your time is concluded. [3:42:00] Jodi Strang, if you can please [3:42:00] unmute. [3:42:05] >> Good afternoon City Council [3:42:07] Thank you for this opportunity [3:42:08] to share some thoughts. [3:42:10] Perhaps you saw as I did [3:42:12] the press conference on Friday [3:42:15] regarding legislation that's [3:42:17] been supported by our Senator [3:42:20] Catherine Blake or as well as [3:42:23] assembly person Lori Davis. [3:42:24] It's sb 936 that would prohibit [3:42:27] the sale of natural nitrous [3:42:29] oxide canisters that are larger [3:42:31] than eight grams. [3:42:35] Noxious oxide joins a group of [3:42:36] other products being sold at [3:42:38] gas stations, Vape stores smoke [3:42:41] shops across our city that are [3:42:45] being purchased by our young [3:42:46] people in particular they join [3:42:49] Create Them which is another [3:42:49] product that's illegal to sell [3:42:51] that we're selling it in our [3:42:53] city Nevertheless as well as [3:42:55] magic mushrooms and hemp [3:42:57] products that contain over [3:43:00] limit And thus we get these [3:43:03] high concentrated thc products [3:43:06] hiding under hemp products. [3:43:10] Sb 936 nitrogen oxide can cause [3:43:12] serious damage to people who [3:43:14] are inhaling them which tend to [3:43:16] be our young people [3:43:17] particularly brain damage. [3:43:18] It seems to have its main [3:43:20] effect neurologically and in [3:43:22] many instances it has caused [3:43:24] death. [3:43:25] If you have an opportunity as a [3:43:27] city council to support [3:43:28] legislation and I know that you [3:43:30] do and you have a lobbyist I [3:43:32] would suggest you add sb 936 to [3:43:35] your list Be a wonderful thing [3:43:37] for our city council to [3:43:38] recognize the role of these [3:43:40] drugs primarily sold in our [3:43:44] city at gas stations, [3:43:45] convenience stores, vape stores [3:43:48] and change the course of [3:43:49] the young people's lives who [3:43:51] are using them. [3:43:52] Thank you. [3:43:54] Thank you. [3:43:55] Natalie Raskin If you can [3:43:56] please unmute them after that [3:43:59] is backing up. [3:44:04] >> Hi Natalie Rush key here I [3:44:05] agree with I think her name was [3:44:07] Maxine There should be more [3:44:10] education within the public in [3:44:12] educating on how the system [3:44:15] works and how the items work [3:44:18] and being informed so that when [3:44:20] they do have the opportunity to [3:44:21] come speak they understand what [3:44:23] they're speaking on and about [3:44:27] and not just calling in and [3:44:29] making random random [3:44:30] statements. [3:44:33] >> I'm also concerned with this [3:44:36] possibility of a sun break [3:44:40] ranch with all the things that [3:44:42] are going on and these cuts no [3:44:45] backup plan. [3:44:46] >> I'm really doing some [3:44:47] research as Maxine stated with [3:44:50] Steve Cushman Now I'm starting [3:44:52] to go down a rabbit hole [3:44:56] because if it's not Sun Break [3:44:58] ranch then what is it? [3:45:01] Transparency I think is [3:45:03] necessary for me and my family. [3:45:06] >> And it also seems that [3:45:08] the county is starting to go [3:45:11] this direction as in now [3:45:14] reframing homelessness as [3:45:15] mental illness and addiction [3:45:18] which I have neither of those [3:45:20] but yet I will still be in this [3:45:23] possible homeless category. [3:45:27] Also what's concerning to me is [3:45:30] that I was reading our tfa [3:45:34] teachers data and how many [3:45:36] people have entered [3:45:36] homelessness and how many [3:45:37] people exited. [3:45:38] I have came to learn that they [3:45:40] do not do statistics past 18 [3:45:44] months of a person staying [3:45:46] housed or unhoused And these [3:45:49] are certain things that I think [3:45:51] we should be keeping track of [3:45:53] because if we're not keeping [3:45:55] people housed then we're just [3:45:57] doing this vicious cycle and [3:46:00] it's causing distrust amongst [3:46:02] our community and the unhoused [3:46:04] people and they don't want to [3:46:05] have any. [3:46:07] Sir, your time has come. [3:46:07] Thank you. [3:46:09] Becky Rapp, if you can please [3:46:11] unmute. [3:46:15] >> Good evening. [3:46:16] My name is Becky Rapp and [3:46:17] tonight I would like to share [3:46:19] with the council what I shared [3:46:21] with the active transportation [3:46:23] and Infrastructure Committee [3:46:24] last week. [3:46:25] As I am concerned for road [3:46:26] safety and the real [3:46:28] consequences of reducing [3:46:29] staffing in program that [3:46:31] support Vision Zero. [3:46:33] >> Traffic deaths continue to [3:46:35] be a serious public safety [3:46:36] issue and nationally about one [3:46:39] third of fatal crashes involved [3:46:41] in per driver. [3:46:43] That includes not only alcohol [3:46:45] but also drugs including [3:46:48] marijuana. [3:46:49] Federal data proves that many [3:46:51] drivers involved in fatal [3:46:52] crashes test positive for [3:46:54] marijuana. [3:46:55] When we reduce staffing for say [3:46:56] for traffic safety, we're not [3:46:58] simply cutting back on [3:46:59] positions, we're weakening [3:47:00] education planning and [3:47:02] enforcement efforts that help [3:47:04] prevent crashes before they [3:47:05] happen. [3:47:06] At the same time, California is [3:47:09] advancing assembly Bill 2697 [3:47:12] which would allow local [3:47:13] governments to authorize drive [3:47:15] thru marijuana sales at [3:47:17] licensed pot shops. [3:47:19] The bill has already passed [3:47:20] the Assembly and continues to [3:47:22] move through the Senate. [3:47:23] This proposal moves us in [3:47:25] the opposite direction of [3:47:26] Vision Zero. [3:47:27] It's also important to know [3:47:29] that there's nothing in [3:47:30] the bill prohibiting adults [3:47:31] from purchasing pot products [3:47:32] while children are sitting in [3:47:34] the back seat of the car. [3:47:35] That sends the wrong message to [3:47:37] families and undermines our [3:47:39] efforts to protect public [3:47:41] the young people. [3:47:43] If we're serious about [3:47:44] eliminating traffic deaths, we [3:47:47] should not be reducing vision [3:47:48] zero resources Why Policies are [3:47:51] being advanced that could [3:47:52] increase the convene instead of [3:47:54] purchasing intoxicating [3:47:55] products. [3:47:56] So I urge this council to [3:47:58] consider the importance of [3:47:59] transportation, transportation [3:48:00] safety. [3:48:02] Continue investing and Vision [3:48:04] zero and publicly oppose ab [3:48:06] 2697. [3:48:09] >> Thank you. [3:48:09] Thank you. [3:48:10] That does conclude public [3:48:11] knowledge and a public comment [3:48:12] on today's meeting. [3:48:13] All right. [3:48:14] Thank you, City Clerk. [3:48:15] And with that does the office [3:48:16] of the city attorney have [3:48:17] anything to report out from [3:48:18] closed session? [3:48:19] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT. [3:48:20] There's no report out from [3:48:21] closed session. [3:48:22] >> All right. [3:48:23] Thank you. [3:48:24] We have one adjournment in [3:48:26] memory by council member [3:48:27] Moreno. [3:48:28] >> I respectfully request that [3:48:31] the council adjourn today's [3:48:33] meeting in memory of MISS [3:48:34] Veronica Medina, a committed [3:48:37] and influential member of [3:48:39] the San Isidro community. [3:48:41] MISS Medina peacefully passed [3:48:43] away on JUNE 19th, 2026. [3:48:46] MISS Benita was a natural [3:48:48] leader with a kind heart. [3:48:50] Her dedication, compassion and [3:48:52] humility were evident in her [3:48:54] work with the San Isidro Youth [3:48:56] and Families. [3:48:57] As the coordinator of Pupil [3:48:59] Services ses at the San Ysidro [3:49:01] School District during the many [3:49:04] years I had the privilege of [3:49:05] knowing her through her [3:49:07] community work and our time [3:49:08] together in the San Isidro [3:49:10] Women's Club. [3:49:11] MISS Medina's presence was [3:49:12] unfair unforgettable. [3:49:15] Her laughter alone would have [3:49:16] let you know she was in [3:49:17] the room. [3:49:19] The same warmth, grace and joy [3:49:21] guided the way she served [3:49:22] others and reflected the hope [3:49:24] she carried for the San Isidro [3:49:26] community. [3:49:27] She made it her mission to [3:49:29] improve the lives of students [3:49:30] outside of the classroom. [3:49:32] In doing this she provided [3:49:33] students with the external [3:49:35] foundation needed to be able to [3:49:37] learn. [3:49:38] This commitment was reflected [3:49:40] in her development of [3:49:41] the Primero homeless program [3:49:43] which aimed to eliminate [3:49:45] barriers to education for [3:49:47] students and families [3:49:48] experiencing homelessness. [3:49:51] Through her work, MS. Medina [3:49:52] built a strong network of [3:49:55] community partnerships that [3:49:56] connected students families to [3:50:00] mental health services, housing [3:50:01] assistance, food resources and [3:50:04] other essential support for [3:50:06] daily life. [3:50:08] MS. Medina cultivated a safe [3:50:09] and welcoming environment where [3:50:11] she was known as a trusted [3:50:13] colleague, advocate, mentor and [3:50:15] friend. [3:50:16] Throughout her life MS. Medina [3:50:18] was recognized many times for [3:50:20] her service and dedication And [3:50:23] today we honor her [3:50:24] contributions and ensure that [3:50:26] her impact on the San Isidro [3:50:28] youth families and the broader [3:50:29] community will never be [3:50:31] forgotten. [3:50:32] My deepest condolences to her [3:50:34] son Nathaniel, whom she loved. [3:50:36] Dearly and MAY she rest in [3:50:38] peace. [3:50:39] >> Thank you, Councilmember [3:50:40] Moreno. [3:50:42] And with that we will now [3:50:43] adjourn Council to [3:50:44] the regularly scheduled council [3:50:45] meeting on Tuesday, JUNE 30th,