[0:00] shortly] [0:00] [Orange county board of [0:00] supervisors- [0:00] meeting will begin [0:00] shortly] [0:00] [Orange county board of [0:00] supervisors- [0:16] shortly] [0:18] >>chair, doug chaffee: check [0:18] check. [0:19] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: check [0:19] check. [0:21] >>vincente sarmiento: check [0:21] check. [0:23] >>clerk, robin stieler: check check [0:31] >>chair, doug chaffee: this [0:31] morning I'm chair doug chaffee [0:33] and 4th district supervisor [0:36] and joined this morning with [0:37] vice-chair katrina foley. [0:41] National weights and measures [0:43] week is observed each year in [0:45] the first full week of MARCH. [0:47] We are in advance for a change, [0:50] recognition of PRESIDENT John [0:52] addams signing the first united [0:55] states weights and measures law [0:57] on MARCH 2, 1799. [0:58] . [1:01] Every day 3.2 million residents [1:04] and businesses as well as 59 [1:08] million-plus annual visitors [1:09] rely on accurate measurements [1:10] and pricing when purchasing [1:13] groceries, fuel, utilities, [1:15] consumer goods and services. [1:17] The orange county office of [1:19] weights and measures ensures [1:21] weighing and measuring devices [1:23] are accurate, protecting [1:25] millions of dollars in [1:26] transactions. With that, I'd [1:28] like to invite up jose air [1:31] yugoslav ga, the orange county [1:32] commissioner and also known as [1:35] the sealer of weights and [1:36] measures. Anthony lee, deputy [1:39] sealer of the weights measures, [1:41] and anna watts, our business [1:42] service analysts, hugo soto, [1:46] senior agricultural standards [1:47] inspector, marinda herr, [1:50] agricultural standards [1:51] inspector. Mark johnson, senior [1:56] agricultural standards [1:57] inspector, david scorski, [1:59] agricultural standards [2:06] inspector, and alicia barry, our [2:06] senior deputy D.A. So we do [2:09] have some oversight from the [2:11] D.A.'s office in here as well.. [2:14] Orange county ranks third [2:16] statewide in the number of [2:17] commercial weighing and [2:19] measuring device under our [2:21] jurisdiction, reflecting the [2:23] scale and complexity of the [2:24] local economy. Through the [2:27] diligent work, the office of [2:29] weights and measures' staff, [2:31] consumers are protected and [2:33] ensured that prices are fair. I [2:36] want to thank staff for their [2:37] work that often goes [2:38] unrecognized. We'd now like to [2:41] invite vice-chair foley with any [2:43] remarks she'd care to make. [2:44] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [2:48] you. Great to be here. Good [2:49] morning. Katrina foley, county [2:51] supervisor representing the [2:52] fabulous fifth district. And as [2:54] mentioned by our CHAIRMAN, we [2:56] are today recognizing weights [2:58] and measures week here in orange [2:59] county. And this rear's theme [3:01] is "we measure what matters." [3:05] and this reflects our commitment [3:06] to fairness, accountability, and [3:09] public protection. Every time [3:11] residents fill up at the gas [3:13] pump, buy groceries or receive a [3:15] delivery, they trust that they [3:17] receive exactly what they paid [3:19] for. Dedicated professionals [3:21] like these behind me inspect, [3:23] test, and verify these systems [3:25] every single day. Our weights [3:28] and measures team at oc public [3:29] works safeguards consumer [3:30] dollars, ensures a level playing [3:32] field for businesses and quietly [3:35] keeps our local economy running [3:38] fairly and efficiently. [3:40] Standard measurements are so [3:41] important, and they help us [3:42] perform even simple tasks like [3:45] purchasing carpet, laundry [3:47] detergent, fabric, any number of [3:50] things. And I do think it's so [3:52] important because before I [3:54] became a county supervise, I [3:56] didn't even know that we had [3:57] this group. And so it's very [4:00] important because it's all about [4:02] protecting our consumers and [4:04] making sure, like I said, that [4:06] we get what we pay for. So [4:07] thank you for all of the work [4:09] that you do. And sometimes it's [4:11] hard because people get mad at [4:12] you and they don't like you in [4:14] their business. But you're [4:15] there to protect the consumers. [4:17] So thank you. [4:26] >>speaker: CHAIRMAN Chaffee, [4:29] vice-chair foley, thank you so [4:30] much for being here, and thank [4:31] you for the opportunity to be [4:32] here and highlight a little bit [4:34] of the work of the weights and [4:36] measures professionals. My name [4:38] is jose arriaga, also known as [4:40] the county sealer of weights and [4:41] measures. I want to share a [4:45] little bit of information what [4:47] is weights and measures. As [4:48] mentioned, sometimes we don't [4:49] even know what weights and [4:51] measures is, it's quietly in our [4:52] communities, but I assure you [4:54] that by the end of the day today [4:57] the work of the individuals will [4:58] touch your life and every single [5:00] day for the rest of our days, [5:02] every single resident is touched [5:04] by the work of these [5:05] individuals. When you pump fuel [5:07] at that gas station and you see [5:08] that seal that says it was [5:10] accurate when tested, that [5:12] ensures that that device -- we [5:14] call them a device -- it meets [5:16] the conform plans. It is within [5:18] a tolerance that ensures that [5:19] you get what you pay for. It's [5:21] not just the 20,000 gas pumps in [5:23] orange county, it also includes [5:25] the 100,000 water submeters, [5:28] 20,000 electric watt meters, it [5:30] includes the thousands of scales [5:32] at grocery stores, and it's not [5:35] just devices, the work weights [5:37] and measures officials expands [5:38] beyond those devices. It also [5:42] applies to the price that you [5:43] pay. We do not set the price [5:46] but ensure that the price that [5:47] every consumer pays is the [5:49] lowest advertised price. We [5:51] have a team of secret shoppers, [5:53] some of them are here, where [5:54] they will go into thousands of [5:56] retail stores every year and [5:59] verify the accuracy of those [6:01] prices on the shelves against [6:02] the point of sales system. And [6:04] it's beyond pricing. When you [6:06] buy commodities by count, [6:08] weight, measure, when you pour a [6:10] gallon from a gallon of milk to [6:11] your 16 ounce box of cereal, [6:13] well, hopefully it's in a bowl, [6:16] how do you know there's a gallon [6:17] in there? When you buy items by [6:20] count, how do you know what's in [6:23] there by weight? The other [6:26] thing we do, one of the other [6:27] programs we play a critical role [6:29] here in our community is that [6:31] our officials respond to [6:32] hundreds of complaints of [6:34] residents where they buy canned [6:35] goods, packaged goods, and we're [6:37] verifying the accuracy of that [6:38] label and the content of those [6:40] containers. [6:41] We are protecting an $89 billion [6:44] retail economy, but more [6:46] importantly, we are protecting [6:47] an over$300 billion gdp economy [6:52] here in orange county. I do [6:55] want to thank the officials. I [6:56] want to thank the team here for [6:58] the work that they do every [6:59] single day. They are committed. [7:01] I also want to provide a [7:02] special thanks to our partners [7:04] with the district attorney's [7:05] office. A lot of our work [7:07] relies on compliance through [7:08] education, through awareness, [7:10] occasionally through [7:11] administrative actions, but [7:13] sometimes we have to go beyond [7:14] and do prosecutions and that is [7:16] where our district attorney's [7:17] office comes in. Alicia, thank [7:19] you so much for you and your [7:20] team for all of the help and [7:22] support. They help us achieve [7:23] our goals of protecting the [7:24] consumers hear in orange county. [7:27] With that, when we say thank [7:28] you. And if you ever feel that [7:29] anything you buy, the quantity, [7:32] the price, the weight is [7:33] inaccurate, please reach out to [7:34] our office. We are a very small [7:37] team. We do a lot of coverage, [7:39] but we actually need the help of [7:40] every single resident and every [7:41] single business in orange county [7:43] to help protect each other. So [7:45] please reach out to our office [7:46] if you have any questions, if he [7:47] ever want to learn about what we [7:48] do, if you want to come work [7:50] with us, it's an amazing job. [7:52] There's never a boring day here. [7:53] Thank you. [9:21] [Applause] [9:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: and that [9:23] concludes our presentations this [9:24] morning. We will begin our [9:28] regular meeting at 9:30. Thank [9:59] you. [10:19] [Orange county board of [10:19] supervisors- [10:20] meeting will begin [10:24] shortly] [10:25] [Orange county board of [10:25] supervisors- [10:26] meeting will begin [10:26] shortly] [10:27] [Orange county board of [10:27] supervisors- [10:28] meeting will begin [10:30] shortly] [10:31] [Orange county board of [10:31] supervisors- [10:32] meeting will begin [10:37] shortly] [10:37] [Orange county board of [10:38] supervisors- [10:38] meeting will begin [10:39] shortly] [10:40] [Orange county board of [10:40] supervisors- [10:40] meeting will begin [10:43] shortly] [10:44] [Orange county board of [10:44] supervisors- [10:45] meeting will begin [10:49] shortly] [10:50] [Orange county board of [10:50] supervisors- [10:51] meeting will begin [10:51] shortly] [10:52] [Orange county board of [10:53] supervisors- [10:53] meeting will begin [10:56] shortly] [10:56] [Orange county board of [10:57] supervisors- [10:57] meeting will begin [11:02] shortly] [11:03] [Orange county board of [11:03] supervisors- [11:04] meeting will begin [11:04] shortly] [11:05] [Orange county board of [11:05] supervisors- [11:06] meeting will begin [11:08] shortly] [11:09] [Orange county board of [11:09] supervisors- [11:10] meeting will begin [11:15] shortly] [11:15] [Orange county board of [11:16] supervisors- [11:16] meeting will begin [11:17] shortly] [11:18] [Orange county board of [11:18] supervisors- [11:18] meeting will begin [11:22] shortly] [11:22] [Orange county board of [11:22] supervisors- [11:23] meeting will begin [11:27] shortly] [11:28] [Orange county board of [11:28] supervisors- [11:29] meeting will begin [11:29] shortly] [11:30] [Orange county board of [11:31] supervisors- [11:31] meeting will begin [11:34] shortly] [11:34] [Orange county board of [11:35] supervisors- [11:35] meeting will begin [11:41] shortly] [11:41] [Orange county board of [11:41] supervisors- [11:42] meeting will begin [11:42] shortly] [11:43] [Orange county board of [11:43] supervisors- [11:44] meeting will begin [11:46] shortly] [11:47] [Orange county board of [11:47] supervisors- [11:48] meeting will begin [11:53] shortly] [11:53] [Orange county board of [11:54] supervisors- [11:54] meeting will begin [11:55] shortly] [11:56] [Orange county board of [11:56] supervisors- [11:56] meeting will begin [12:00] shortly] [12:00] [Orange county board of [12:00] supervisors- [12:01] meeting will begin [12:05] shortly] [12:07] [Orange county board of [12:07] supervisors- [12:07] meeting will begin [12:07] shortly] [12:08] [Orange county board of [12:09] supervisors- [12:09] meeting will begin [12:12] shortly] [12:12] [Orange county board of [12:13] supervisors- [12:13] meeting will begin [12:18] shortly] [12:19] [Orange county board of [12:19] supervisors- [12:20] meeting will begin [12:20] shortly] [12:21] [Orange county board of [12:21] supervisors- [12:22] meeting will begin [12:24] shortly] [12:25] [Orange county board of [12:25] supervisors- [12:26] meeting will begin [12:31] shortly] [12:31] [Orange county board of [12:32] supervisors- [12:32] meeting will begin [12:33] shortly] [12:34] [Orange county board of [12:34] supervisors- [12:34] meeting will begin [12:37] shortly] [12:38] [Orange county board of [12:39] supervisors- [12:39] meeting will begin [12:43] shortly] [12:45] [Orange county board of [12:45] supervisors- [12:45] meeting will begin [12:45] shortly] [12:46] [Orange county board of [12:47] supervisors- [12:47] meeting will begin [12:50] shortly] [12:50] [Orange county board of [12:51] supervisors- [12:51] meeting will begin [12:56] shortly] [12:57] [Orange county board of [12:58] supervisors- [12:58] meeting will begin [12:58] shortly] [12:59] [Orange county board of [12:59] supervisors- [13:00] meeting will begin [13:02] shortly] [13:04] [Orange county board of [13:04] supervisors- [13:04] meeting will begin [13:09] shortly] [13:09] [Orange county board of [13:10] supervisors- [13:10] meeting will begin [13:11] shortly] [13:12] [Orange county board of [13:12] supervisors- [13:12] meeting will begin [13:15] shortly] [13:16] [Orange county board of [13:17] supervisors- [13:17] meeting will begin [13:21] shortly] [13:22] [Orange county board of [13:22] supervisors- [13:23] meeting will begin [13:24] shortly] [13:24] [Orange county board of [13:25] supervisors- [13:25] meeting will begin [13:28] shortly] [13:29] [Orange county board of [13:29] supervisors- [13:29] meeting will begin [13:34] shortly] [13:35] [Orange county board of [13:35] supervisors- [13:35] meeting will begin [13:37] shortly] [13:37] [Orange county board of [13:37] supervisors- [13:38] meeting will begin [13:40] shortly] [13:41] [Orange county board of [13:41] supervisors- [13:42] meeting will begin [13:47] shortly] [13:47] [Orange county board of [13:48] supervisors- [13:48] meeting will begin [13:49] shortly] [13:50] [Orange county board of [13:50] supervisors- [13:50] meeting will begin [13:53] shortly] [13:54] [Orange county board of [13:54] supervisors- [13:55] meeting will begin [13:59] shortly] [14:00] [Orange county board of [14:00] supervisors- [14:01] meeting will begin [14:01] shortly] [14:02] [Orange county board of [14:03] supervisors- [14:03] meeting will begin [14:06] shortly] [14:06] [Orange county board of [14:07] supervisors- [14:08] meeting will begin [14:12] shortly] [14:13] [Orange county board of [14:13] supervisors- [14:13] meeting will begin [14:15] shortly] [14:15] [Orange county board of [14:15] supervisors- [14:16] meeting will begin [14:18] shortly] [14:19] [Orange county board of [14:19] supervisors- [14:20] meeting will begin [14:25] shortly] [14:25] [Orange county board of [14:26] supervisors- [14:27] meeting will begin [14:27] shortly] [14:28] [Orange county board of [14:28] supervisors- [14:29] meeting will begin [14:31] shortly] [14:32] [Orange county board of [14:32] supervisors- [14:33] meeting will begin [14:37] shortly] [14:38] [Orange county board of [14:38] supervisors- [14:39] meeting will begin [14:39] shortly] [14:41] [Orange county board of [14:41] supervisors- [14:41] meeting will begin [14:44] shortly] [14:44] [Orange county board of [14:45] supervisors- [14:46] meeting will begin [14:50] shortly] [14:51] [Orange county board of [14:51] supervisors- [14:52] meeting will begin [14:52] shortly] [14:53] [Orange county board of [14:53] supervisors- [14:54] meeting will begin [14:56] shortly] [14:57] [Orange county board of [14:57] supervisors- [14:58] meeting will begin [15:03] shortly] [15:03] [Orange county board of [15:04] supervisors- [15:05] meeting will begin [15:05] shortly] [15:06] [Orange county board of [15:06] supervisors- [15:06] meeting will begin [15:09] shortly] [15:10] [Orange county board of [15:10] supervisors- [15:11] meeting will begin [15:15] shortly] [15:16] [Orange county board of [15:16] supervisors- [15:17] meeting will begin [15:17] shortly] [15:19] [Orange county board of [15:19] supervisors- [15:19] meeting will begin [15:22] shortly] [15:22] [Orange county board of [15:23] supervisors- [15:23] meeting will begin [15:28] shortly] [15:29] [Orange county board of [15:29] supervisors- [15:30] meeting will begin [15:30] shortly] [15:31] [Orange county board of [15:32] supervisors- [15:32] meeting will begin [15:34] shortly] [15:35] [Orange county board of [15:35] supervisors- [15:36] meeting will begin [15:41] shortly] [15:41] [Orange county board of [15:42] supervisors- [15:42] meeting will begin [15:43] shortly] [15:44] [Orange county board of [15:44] supervisors- [15:44] meeting will begin [15:47] shortly] [15:48] [Orange county board of [15:49] supervisors- [15:49] meeting will begin [15:53] shortly] [15:54] [Orange county board of [15:54] supervisors- [15:55] meeting will begin [15:55] shortly] [15:56] [Orange county board of [15:57] supervisors- [15:57] meeting will begin [16:00] shortly] [16:00] [Orange county board of [16:01] supervisors- [16:01] meeting will begin [16:06] shortly] [16:07] [Orange county board of [16:07] supervisors- [16:08] meeting will begin [16:08] shortly] [16:09] [Orange county board of [16:09] supervisors- [16:10] meeting will begin [16:12] shortly] [16:13] [Orange county board of [16:13] supervisors- [16:14] meeting will begin [16:19] shortly] [16:19] [Orange county board of [16:20] supervisors- [16:20] meeting will begin [16:21] shortly] [16:22] [Orange county board of [16:22] supervisors- [16:23] meeting will begin [16:25] shortly] [16:26] [Orange county board of [16:26] supervisors- [16:27] meeting will begin [16:31] shortly] [16:32] [Orange county board of [16:32] supervisors- [16:33] meeting will begin [16:33] shortly] [16:34] [Orange county board of [16:35] supervisors- [16:35] meeting will begin [16:38] shortly] [16:38] [Orange county board of [16:39] supervisors- [16:39] meeting will begin [16:44] shortly] [16:45] [Orange county board of [16:45] supervisors- [16:46] meeting will begin [16:46] shortly] [16:47] [Orange county board of [16:47] supervisors- [16:48] meeting will begin [16:50] shortly] [16:51] [Orange county board of [16:51] supervisors- [16:52] meeting will begin [16:57] shortly] [16:57] [Orange county board of [16:58] supervisors- [16:58] meeting will begin [16:59] shortly] [17:00] [Orange county board of [17:00] supervisors- [17:01] meeting will begin [17:03] shortly] [17:04] [Orange county board of [17:04] supervisors- [17:05] meeting will begin [17:09] shortly] [17:10] [Orange county board of [17:10] supervisors- [17:11] meeting will begin [17:11] shortly] [17:13] [Orange county board of [17:13] supervisors- [17:13] meeting will begin [17:16] shortly] [17:16] [Orange county board of [17:17] supervisors- [17:17] meeting will begin [17:22] shortly] [17:23] [Orange county board of [17:23] supervisors- [17:24] meeting will begin [17:24] shortly] [17:25] [Orange county board of [17:25] supervisors- [17:26] meeting will begin [17:28] shortly] [17:29] [Orange county board of [17:29] supervisors- [17:30] meeting will begin [17:35] shortly] [17:35] [Orange county board of [17:36] supervisors- [17:36] meeting will begin [17:37] shortly] [17:38] [Orange county board of [17:38] supervisors- [17:39] meeting will begin [17:41] shortly] [17:42] [Orange county board of [17:42] supervisors- [17:43] meeting will begin [17:47] shortly] [17:48] [Orange county board of [17:49] supervisors- [17:49] meeting will begin [17:49] shortly] [17:50] [Orange county board of [17:51] supervisors- [17:51] meeting will begin [17:54] shortly] [17:54] [Orange county board of [17:55] supervisors- [17:55] meeting will begin [18:00] shortly] [18:01] [Orange county board of [18:01] supervisors- [18:02] meeting will begin [18:02] shortly] [18:03] [Orange county board of [18:03] supervisors- [18:04] meeting will begin [18:07] shortly] [18:07] [Orange county board of [18:07] supervisors- [18:08] meeting will begin [18:13] shortly] [18:13] [Orange county board of [18:14] supervisors- [18:14] meeting will begin [18:15] shortly] [18:16] [Orange county board of [18:16] supervisors- [18:16] meeting will begin [18:19] shortly] [18:20] [Orange county board of [18:20] supervisors- [18:21] meeting will begin [18:26] shortly] [18:26] [Orange county board of [18:26] supervisors- [18:27] meeting will begin [18:28] shortly] [18:28] [Orange county board of [18:29] supervisors- [18:29] meeting will begin [18:32] shortly] [18:32] [Orange county board of [18:33] supervisors- [18:33] meeting will begin [18:38] shortly] [18:39] [Orange county board of [18:39] supervisors- [18:40] meeting will begin [18:40] shortly] [18:41] [Orange county board of [18:41] supervisors- [18:42] meeting will begin [18:45] shortly] [18:45] [Orange county board of [18:45] supervisors- [18:46] meeting will begin [18:51] shortly] [18:51] [Orange county board of [18:52] supervisors- [18:52] meeting will begin [18:53] shortly] [18:54] [Orange county board of [18:54] supervisors- [18:54] meeting will begin [18:57] shortly] [18:58] [Orange county board of [18:58] supervisors- [18:59] meeting will begin [19:04] shortly] [19:04] [Orange county board of [19:05] supervisors- [19:05] meeting will begin [19:06] shortly] [19:06] [Orange county board of [19:07] supervisors- [19:07] meeting will begin [19:10] shortly] [19:11] [Orange county board of [19:11] supervisors- [19:11] meeting will begin [19:16] shortly] [19:17] [Orange county board of [19:17] supervisors- [19:18] meeting will begin [19:18] shortly] [19:19] [Orange county board of [19:19] supervisors- [19:20] meeting will begin [19:23] shortly] [19:23] [Orange county board of [19:23] supervisors- [19:24] meeting will begin [19:29] shortly] [19:30] [Orange county board of [19:30] supervisors- [19:30] meeting will begin [19:31] shortly] [19:32] [Orange county board of [19:32] supervisors- [19:32] meeting will begin [19:35] shortly] [19:36] [Orange county board of [19:36] supervisors- [19:37] meeting will begin [19:42] shortly] [19:42] [Orange county board of [19:43] supervisors- [19:43] meeting will begin [19:44] shortly] [19:44] [Orange county board of [19:45] supervisors- [19:45] meeting will begin [19:48] shortly] [19:49] [Orange county board of [19:49] supervisors- [19:50] meeting will begin [19:54] shortly] [19:55] [Orange county board of [19:55] supervisors- [19:56] meeting will begin [19:56] shortly] [19:57] [Orange county board of [19:57] supervisors- [19:58] meeting will begin [20:00] shortly] [20:01] [Orange county board of [20:02] supervisors- [20:02] meeting will begin [20:07] shortly] [20:08] [Orange county board of [20:08] supervisors- [20:08] meeting will begin [20:09] shortly] [20:10] [Orange county board of [20:10] supervisors- [20:10] meeting will begin [20:13] shortly] [20:14] [Orange county board of [20:14] supervisors- [20:15] meeting will begin [20:19] shortly] [20:20] [Orange county board of [20:21] supervisors- [20:21] meeting will begin [20:22] shortly] [20:22] [Orange county board of [20:23] supervisors- [20:23] meeting will begin [20:26] shortly] [20:27] [Orange county board of [20:27] supervisors- [20:27] meeting will begin [20:32] shortly] [20:33] [Orange county board of [20:33] supervisors- [20:34] meeting will begin [20:34] shortly] [20:35] [Orange county board of [20:35] supervisors- [20:36] meeting will begin [20:38] shortly] [20:39] [Orange county board of [20:40] supervisors- [20:40] meeting will begin [20:45] shortly] [20:46] [Orange county board of [20:46] supervisors- [20:47] meeting will begin [20:47] shortly] [20:48] [Orange county board of [20:48] supervisors- [20:48] meeting will begin [20:51] shortly] [20:52] [Orange county board of [20:52] supervisors- [20:53] meeting will begin [20:57] shortly] [20:58] [Orange county board of [20:58] supervisors- [20:59] meeting will begin [21:00] shortly] [21:00] [Orange county board of [21:01] supervisors- [21:01] meeting will begin [21:04] shortly] [21:05] [Orange county board of [21:05] supervisors- [21:05] meeting will begin [21:10] shortly] [21:11] [Orange county board of [21:11] supervisors- [21:12] meeting will begin [21:12] shortly] [21:13] [Orange county board of [21:13] supervisors- [21:14] meeting will begin [21:16] shortly] [21:17] [Orange county board of [21:18] supervisors- [21:18] meeting will begin [21:23] shortly] [21:23] [Orange county board of [21:24] supervisors- [21:24] meeting will begin [21:25] shortly] [21:26] [Orange county board of [21:26] supervisors- [21:26] meeting will begin [21:29] shortly] [21:30] [Orange county board of [21:30] supervisors- [21:31] meeting will begin [21:35] shortly] [21:36] [Orange county board of [21:36] supervisors- [21:37] meeting will begin [21:38] shortly] [21:38] [Orange county board of [21:39] supervisors- [21:39] meeting will begin [21:42] shortly] [21:42] [Orange county board of [21:43] supervisors- [21:43] meeting will begin [21:48] shortly] [21:49] [Orange county board of [21:49] supervisors- [21:50] meeting will begin [21:50] shortly] [21:51] [Orange county board of [21:51] supervisors- [21:52] meeting will begin [21:54] shortly] [21:55] [Orange county board of [21:55] supervisors- [21:56] meeting will begin [22:01] shortly] [22:01] [Orange county board of [22:02] supervisors- [22:02] meeting will begin [22:03] shortly] [22:04] [Orange county board of [22:04] supervisors- [22:04] meeting will begin [22:07] shortly] [22:08] [Orange county board of [22:08] supervisors- [22:09] meeting will begin [22:13] shortly] [22:14] [Orange county board of [22:14] supervisors- [22:15] meeting will begin [22:15] shortly] [22:16] [Orange county board of [22:17] supervisors- [22:17] meeting will begin [22:20] shortly] [22:20] [Orange county board of [22:21] supervisors- [22:21] meeting will begin [22:26] shortly] [22:27] [Orange county board of [22:27] supervisors- [22:28] meeting will begin [22:28] shortly] [22:29] [Orange county board of [22:29] supervisors- [22:30] meeting will begin [22:32] shortly] [22:33] [Orange county board of [22:33] supervisors- [22:34] meeting will begin [22:39] shortly] [22:39] [Orange county board of [22:40] supervisors- [22:40] meeting will begin [22:41] shortly] [22:42] [Orange county board of [22:42] supervisors- [22:42] meeting will begin [22:45] shortly] [22:46] [Orange county board of [22:46] supervisors- [22:47] meeting will begin [22:51] shortly] [22:52] [Orange county board of [22:52] supervisors- [22:53] meeting will begin [22:53] shortly] [22:54] [Orange county board of [22:55] supervisors- [22:55] meeting will begin [22:58] shortly] [22:58] [Orange county board of [22:59] supervisors- [22:59] meeting will begin [23:04] shortly] [23:05] [Orange county board of [23:05] supervisors- [23:06] meeting will begin [23:06] shortly] [23:07] [Orange county board of [23:07] supervisors- [23:09] meeting will begin [23:10] shortly] [23:11] [Orange county board of [23:11] supervisors- [23:12] meeting will begin [23:17] shortly] [23:17] [Orange county board of [23:18] supervisors- [23:18] meeting will begin [23:19] shortly] [23:20] [Orange county board of [23:20] supervisors- [23:20] meeting will begin [23:23] shortly] [23:24] [Orange county board of [23:24] supervisors- [23:25] meeting will begin [23:29] shortly] [23:30] [Orange county board of [23:30] supervisors- [23:31] meeting will begin [23:32] shortly] [23:32] [Orange county board of [23:33] supervisors- [23:33] meeting will begin [23:36] shortly] [23:36] [Orange county board of [23:37] supervisors- [23:37] meeting will begin [23:42] shortly] [23:43] [Orange county board of [23:43] supervisors- [23:44] meeting will begin [23:44] shortly] [23:45] [Orange county board of [23:45] supervisors- [23:46] meeting will begin [23:48] shortly] [23:49] [Orange county board of [23:49] supervisors- [23:50] meeting will begin [23:55] shortly] [23:56] [Orange county board of [23:56] supervisors- [23:56] meeting will begin [23:57] shortly] [23:58] [Orange county board of [23:58] supervisors- [23:58] meeting will begin [24:01] shortly] [24:02] [Orange county board of [24:02] supervisors- [24:03] meeting will begin [24:07] shortly] [24:08] [Orange county board of [24:08] supervisors- [24:09] meeting will begin [24:10] shortly] [24:10] [Orange county board of [24:11] supervisors- [24:11] meeting will begin [24:14] shortly] [24:14] [Orange county board of [24:15] supervisors- [24:15] meeting will begin [24:20] shortly] [24:21] [Orange county board of [24:21] supervisors- [24:22] meeting will begin [24:22] shortly] [24:23] [Orange county board of [24:23] supervisors- [24:24] meeting will begin [24:26] shortly] [24:27] [Orange county board of [24:27] supervisors- [24:28] meeting will begin [24:33] shortly] [24:33] [Orange county board of [24:34] supervisors- [24:34] meeting will begin [24:35] shortly] [24:36] [Orange county board of [24:36] supervisors- [24:36] meeting will begin [24:39] shortly] [24:40] [Orange county board of [24:40] supervisors- [24:41] meeting will begin [24:45] shortly] [24:46] [Orange county board of [24:46] supervisors- [24:47] meeting will begin [24:48] shortly] [24:48] [Orange county board of [24:49] supervisors- [24:49] meeting will begin [24:52] shortly] [24:52] [Orange county board of [24:53] supervisors- [24:53] meeting will begin [24:58] shortly] [24:59] [Orange county board of [24:59] supervisors- [25:00] meeting will begin [25:00] shortly] [25:01] [Orange county board of [25:01] supervisors- [25:02] meeting will begin [25:04] shortly] [25:05] [Orange county board of [25:05] supervisors- [25:06] meeting will begin [25:12] shortly] [25:12] [Orange county board of [25:12] supervisors- [25:12] meeting will begin [25:13] shortly] [25:14] [Orange county board of [25:14] supervisors- [25:14] meeting will begin [25:17] shortly] [25:18] [Orange county board of [25:18] supervisors- [25:19] meeting will begin [25:23] shortly] [25:24] [Orange county board of [25:24] supervisors- [25:25] meeting will begin [25:26] shortly] [25:26] [Orange county board of [25:27] supervisors- [25:27] meeting will begin [25:30] shortly] [25:30] [Orange county board of [25:31] supervisors- [25:31] meeting will begin [25:36] shortly] [25:37] [Orange county board of [25:37] supervisors- [25:38] meeting will begin [25:38] shortly] [25:39] [Orange county board of [25:39] supervisors- [25:40] meeting will begin [25:42] shortly] [25:43] [Orange county board of [25:45] supervisors- [25:45] meeting will begin [25:49] shortly] [25:49] [Orange county board of [25:51] supervisors- [25:51] meeting will begin [25:51] shortly] [25:52] [Orange county board of [25:52] supervisors- [25:52] meeting will begin [25:55] shortly] [25:57] [Orange county board of [25:57] supervisors- [25:57] meeting will begin [26:01] shortly] [26:02] [Orange county board of [26:02] supervisors- [26:03] meeting will begin [26:04] shortly] [26:04] [Orange county board of [26:05] supervisors- [26:05] meeting will begin [26:08] shortly] [26:08] [Orange county board of [26:09] supervisors- [26:09] meeting will begin [26:14] shortly] [26:16] [Orange county board of [26:16] supervisors- [26:16] meeting will begin [26:16] shortly] [26:17] [Orange county board of [26:17] supervisors- [26:18] meeting will begin [26:20] shortly] [26:21] [Orange county board of [26:21] supervisors- [26:22] meeting will begin [26:27] shortly] [26:27] [Orange county board of [26:28] supervisors- [26:28] meeting will begin [26:30] shortly] [26:30] [Orange county board of [26:30] supervisors- [26:30] meeting will begin [26:33] shortly] [26:34] [Orange county board of [26:34] supervisors- [26:35] meeting will begin [26:39] shortly] [26:40] [Orange county board of [26:40] supervisors- [26:41] meeting will begin [26:42] shortly] [26:42] [Orange county board of [26:43] supervisors- [26:43] meeting will begin [26:46] shortly] [26:46] [Orange county board of [26:48] supervisors- [26:48] meeting will begin [26:52] shortly] [26:53] [Orange county board of [26:53] supervisors- [26:54] meeting will begin [26:54] shortly] [26:55] [Orange county board of [26:55] supervisors- [26:56] meeting will begin [26:58] shortly] [26:59] [Orange county board of [26:59] supervisors- [27:00] meeting will begin [27:05] shortly] [27:05] [Orange county board of [27:06] supervisors- [27:06] meeting will begin [27:07] shortly] [27:08] [Orange county board of [27:08] supervisors- [27:08] meeting will begin [27:11] shortly] [27:12] [Orange county board of [27:12] supervisors- [27:13] meeting will begin [27:17] shortly] [27:18] [Orange county board of [27:18] supervisors- [27:20] meeting will begin [27:20] shortly] [27:20] [Orange county board of [27:21] supervisors- [27:21] meeting will begin [27:24] shortly] [27:24] [Orange county board of [27:25] supervisors- [27:25] meeting will begin [27:30] shortly] [27:31] [Orange county board of [27:31] supervisors- [27:32] meeting will begin [27:32] shortly] [27:33] [Orange county board of [27:33] supervisors- [27:34] meeting will begin [27:36] shortly] [27:37] [Orange county board of [27:37] supervisors- [27:38] meeting will begin [27:43] shortly] [27:43] [Orange county board of [27:44] supervisors- [27:44] meeting will begin [27:45] shortly] [27:46] [Orange county board of [27:46] supervisors- [27:46] meeting will begin [27:49] shortly] [27:50] [Orange county board of [27:50] supervisors- [27:51] meeting will begin [27:55] shortly] [27:56] [Orange county board of [27:56] supervisors- [27:57] meeting will begin [27:58] shortly] [27:58] [Orange county board of [27:59] supervisors- [27:59] meeting will begin [28:02] shortly] [28:02] [Orange county board of [28:03] supervisors- [28:03] meeting will begin [28:08] shortly] [28:09] [Orange county board of [28:09] supervisors- [28:10] meeting will begin [28:10] shortly] [28:11] [Orange county board of [28:11] supervisors- [28:12] meeting will begin [28:14] shortly] [28:15] [Orange county board of [28:15] supervisors- [28:16] meeting will begin [28:21] shortly] [28:21] [Orange county board of [28:22] supervisors- [28:22] meeting will begin [28:23] shortly] [28:24] [Orange county board of [28:25] supervisors- [28:25] meeting will begin [28:27] shortly] [28:28] [Orange county board of [28:28] supervisors- [28:29] meeting will begin [28:33] shortly] [28:34] [Orange county board of [28:34] supervisors- [28:35] meeting will begin [28:36] shortly] [28:36] [Orange county board of [28:37] supervisors- [28:37] meeting will begin [28:40] shortly] [28:40] [Orange county board of [28:41] supervisors- [28:41] meeting will begin [28:46] shortly] [28:47] [Orange county board of [28:47] supervisors- [28:48] meeting will begin [28:48] shortly] [28:50] [Orange county board of [28:50] supervisors- [28:50] meeting will begin [28:52] shortly] [28:53] [Orange county board of [28:53] supervisors- [28:54] meeting will begin [28:59] shortly] [28:59] [Orange county board of [29:00] supervisors- [29:00] meeting will begin [29:01] shortly] [29:02] [Orange county board of [29:02] supervisors- [29:02] meeting will begin [29:05] shortly] [29:06] [Orange county board of [29:06] supervisors- [29:07] meeting will begin [29:11] shortly] [29:12] [Orange county board of [29:12] supervisors- [29:13] meeting will begin [29:14] shortly] [29:14] [Orange county board of [29:15] supervisors- [29:15] meeting will begin [29:18] shortly] [29:18] [Orange county board of [29:19] supervisors- [29:19] meeting will begin [29:24] shortly] [29:25] [Orange county board of [29:25] supervisors- [29:26] meeting will begin [29:26] shortly] [29:27] [Orange county board of [29:27] supervisors- [29:28] meeting will begin [29:30] shortly] [29:31] [Orange county board of [29:32] supervisors- [29:32] meeting will begin [29:37] shortly] [29:37] [Orange county board of [29:38] supervisors- [29:38] meeting will begin [29:39] shortly] [29:40] [Orange county board of [29:40] supervisors- [29:40] meeting will begin [29:43] shortly] [29:44] [Orange county board of [29:44] supervisors- [29:45] meeting will begin [29:49] shortly] [29:50] [Orange county board of [29:50] supervisors- [29:51] meeting will begin [29:52] shortly] [29:52] [Orange county board of [29:53] supervisors- [29:54] meeting will begin [29:56] shortly] [29:56] [Orange county board of [29:57] supervisors- [29:57] meeting will begin [30:02] shortly] [30:03] [Orange county board of [30:03] supervisors- [30:04] meeting will begin [30:04] shortly] [30:05] [Orange county board of [30:05] supervisors- [30:06] meeting will begin [30:08] shortly] [30:09] [Orange county board of [30:10] supervisors- [30:10] meeting will begin [30:15] shortly] [30:15] [Orange county board of [30:16] supervisors- [30:16] meeting will begin [30:17] shortly] [30:18] [Orange county board of [30:18] supervisors- [30:18] meeting will begin [30:21] shortly] [30:22] [Orange county board of [30:22] supervisors- [30:23] meeting will begin [30:27] shortly] [30:28] [Orange county board of [30:28] supervisors- [30:29] meeting will begin [30:30] shortly] [30:30] [Orange county board of [30:31] supervisors- [30:31] meeting will begin [30:34] shortly] [30:34] [Orange county board of [30:35] supervisors- [30:35] meeting will begin [30:40] shortly] [30:41] [Orange county board of [30:41] supervisors- [30:42] meeting will begin [30:42] shortly] [30:43] [Orange county board of [30:43] supervisors- [30:44] meeting will begin [30:46] shortly] [30:47] [Orange county board of [30:47] supervisors- [30:48] meeting will begin [30:53] shortly] [30:53] [Orange county board of [30:54] supervisors- [30:54] meeting will begin [30:55] shortly] [30:56] [Orange county board of [30:56] supervisors- [30:56] meeting will begin [30:59] shortly] [31:00] [Orange county board of [31:00] supervisors- [31:01] meeting will begin [31:05] shortly] [31:06] [Orange county board of [31:06] supervisors- [31:07] meeting will begin [31:08] shortly] [31:08] [Orange county board of good morning, [31:09] supervisors- [31:09] meeting will begin everyone [31:10] shortly]. I'd like to welcome [31:15] you to this [31:16] >>speaker: good morning, [31:17] everyone. I'd like to welcome [31:19] you to this meeting FEBRUARY 24, [31:22] 2026. Today the invocations [31:25] will be offered by vice-chair [31:26] foley and pledge of allegiance [31:27] led by supervisor nguyen. If [31:36] you're able, please stand. [31:38] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: join [31:39] me today to pause for a moment [31:40] reflection before we begin the [31:41] work on behalf of our orange [31:42] county community. We join [31:44] together here with the shared [31:46] responsibility to serve every [31:50] constituent of our community [31:52] with speaking with grill and [31:53] purpose and moments when [31:55] disagreements grow MAY we [31:56] remember that public service [31:57] calls us to rise above division. [32:00] Let us all work harder and with [32:02] more intention to choose [32:04] collaboration over conflict and [32:06] solutions over spectacle. As [32:08] leaders we also have a duty to [32:10] protect and support the county [32:11] staff who carry out this work [32:14] for us every day. They look to [32:16] us for steadiness, [32:17] accountability and example. Our [32:20] conduct sets the tone. Ideally [32:23] we lead them and they help us [32:24] improve our county government by [32:26] trusting their commitment to [32:27] provide quality services and set [32:30] high standards for performance [32:31] and delivery of services. MAY [32:34] we remember that this work is [32:36] not about any one of us, it is [32:38] about all of us. We MAY not [32:40] always agree but we MAY disagree [32:42] with respect, work harder to [32:45] challenge ideas without [32:47] degrading one another and remain [32:49] productive rather than [32:51] interactive, when we falter or [32:52] slip up, MAY we also forgive and [32:55] commit to picking up another [32:56] plank to keep building the [32:58] bridges that keep us connected. [33:01] Our community benefits when we [33:02] build bridges, not barriers. [33:04] And when we focus on helping [33:06] lift up all segments of our [33:08] community.. As we watch bombs [33:10] bursting, builds blow up and [33:13] other chaos in other countries [33:14] and communities, let us [33:15] recognize the privilege we share [33:18] to live and serve here and the [33:20] duty to move forward together [33:22] for the entire county to protect [33:24] this paradise we call home. I [33:27] look forward a protective [33:28] meeting with you all. Thank [33:29] you. Please join me in the [33:37] pledge of allegiance. [33:39] I pledge allegiance to my flag [33:40] to the united states of america [33:41] and to the republic for which it [33:42] stands, one nation, under GOD, [33:44] indivisible, with liberty and [33:52] justice for all. [33:54] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank you [33:54] supervisors foley and nguyen. A [34:00] couple of reminders for today's [34:03] meeting, please use the main [34:04] entrance when entering and [34:06] leaving the room. All the other [34:08] doors are alarmed and for [34:09] emergency exit only. Please set [34:13] all cell phones to "mute" or [34:16] vibrate at this time for the [34:18] duration of the meeting. A list [34:20] of changes to today's agenda [34:22] along with the agenda requests [34:24] to speak are locate in the lobby [34:26] outside the boardroom. We'll be [34:29] breaking for lunch around the [34:31] noon hour during which time [34:32] we'll also recess to closed [34:33] sessions. [34:36] Feed the parking validation for [34:37] the p4 parking lot, please see [34:41] the deputy clerk next to the [34:42] podium and you'll see a parking [34:44] validation card. We now will [34:47] proceed to the agenda for this [34:49] morning's meeting. This agenda [34:52] contains a brief description of [34:54] each item to be considered [34:56] except as provided by law, no [34:58] action maybe taken to any item [35:00] not appearing in today's agenda. [35:03] The agenda is divide into [35:04] sections, all matters on the [35:06] scent calendar are proved by -- [35:07] a -- on the consent calendar are [35:08] approved by one motion, a board [35:10] member or member of the public [35:12] MAY have a separate action on a [35:13] specific item. If you wish to [35:15] address the board, please [35:17] complete a speaker request form. [35:22] To be heard on a consent [35:23] calendar item, the completed [35:25] form must be deposited in the [35:27] box next to the podium prior to [35:29] the beginning of the consent [35:30] calendar. As to all other items [35:33] to ensure smooth conduct in [35:35] meetings, speaker requests must [35:36] be turned in prior to the [35:38] reading of an individual item, [35:39] including public comments. [35:43] Speakers MAY address the board [35:44] up to three occasions for three [35:46] minutes allotted to the speaker [35:49] per occasion. When you're [35:51] called to special please step to [35:52] the podium, we request that you [35:54] state your name and city of [35:55] residence for the record. [35:57] Please note the light on the [35:58] podium. The green light means [36:00] you have three minutes. The [36:02] light changes to yellow when you [36:03] have 1 minute. The light turns [36:04] to red when your time has [36:06] expired. We ask that you [36:08] observe the time limit so that [36:09] all who wish to speak will have [36:11] an opportunity do so. [36:13] Addressing the board, we address [36:15] the board as a whole through the [36:16] chair.. We're moving to -- I'm [36:32] changing this around a little [36:34] built. Normally we have board [36:36] comments that the time. I'm [36:37] going to move that to the end of [36:38] the meeting instead. And so now [36:42] we'll move to our agenda items. [36:44] I ask the clerk to identify any [36:45] changes to the agenda, any [36:48] requests received from the [36:49] public to pull an item from the [36:51] consent calendar for separate [36:53] consideration. MADAM Clerk. [36:56] >>clerk, robin stieler: on [36:56] discussion calendar, item 22 has [36:58] been deleted. And closed [37:01] sessions cs-1 has also been [37:03] deleted. The public has [37:05] requested to pull item 4 from [37:06] the consent calendar. [37:11] >>chair, doug chaffee: I would [37:11] like to move item, I believe, [37:14] it's 28, to be heard after item [37:17] 17 since item 18 can be directed [37:21] by that item. That's the board [37:28] procurement item. [37:29] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: did [37:30] you say 22, grants committee [37:32] report -- [37:33] >>chair, doug chaffee: no. I [37:34] meant 28. [37:36] >>clerk, robin stieler: 22 was [37:37] deleted. Excuse me. 23. 23. [37:40] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay. [37:41] I thought so. Thank you. [37:51] >>chair, doug chaffee: okay. [37:52] I'd ask my colleague if there [37:54] are any items you'd like to hear [37:56] separately on the consent [37:57] calendar. We have requests from [38:00] the public that item 4 be heard [38:02] separately. Except for, that [38:04] MAY I have a motion -- [38:05] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [38:05] the balance. [38:06] >>don wagner: second. [38:06] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [38:07] objection? Seeing none, [38:10] carried. Item 4. [38:11] >>clerk, robin stieler: 4. [38:11] Under oc community resources, [38:12] Approve master agreement for oc [38:13] Animal Care services, 6/1/26- [38:15] 5/31/31; authorize Director [38:16] or designee to execute [38:17] individual agreements, make [38:18] minor changes and renew [38:20] agreements under certain conditions. [38:22] And we have one requests to [38:23] speak on agenda item 4. [38:25] >>chair, doug chaffee: please [38:25] call the speaker. [38:28] >>clerk, robin stieler: michael [38:29] m. [38:31] >>speaker: thank you. Michael m [38:34] from irvine. In the last year, [38:36] the animal shelter has made [38:37] significant strides, thanks to [38:40] this board. I am grateful to [38:45] those who led these positive [38:46] changes and as a proud resident [38:48] of the third district also to [38:50] supervisor wagner for his [38:51] support. To sustain the [38:54] progress we need to follow up on [38:56] the shelter's strategic plan, [38:58] which defines how the board, its [39:01] cities and community expect the [39:02] shelter to operate. We as a [39:05] county spent thousands of hours [39:07] and hundreds of thousands of [39:09] dollars to put this plan [39:10] together. The board voted for [39:13] the strategic plan as the [39:14] blueprint for shelter [39:15] operations. I urge the board [39:18] and the animal shelter to follow [39:20] up on last year's improvements [39:22] and put the shelter on a good [39:23] path that fixes persisting [39:26] promise and prevents [39:27] backsliding. The plan there, we [39:30] just need work on [39:31] implementation. Thank you. [39:33] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank you [39:34] for your comments. Back to the [39:37] board for consideration. Do we [39:38] have a motion. [39:39] >>janet nguyen: I'll move it [39:40] with comments, MR. CHAIRMAN. [39:41] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [39:41] second. [39:42] >>chair, doug chaffee: please go [39:43] ahead, prfers nguyen. [39:46] >>janet nguyen: I just want to [39:47] first thank monica, dillon and [39:51] the oc animal staff for putting [39:54] these contracts together. [39:56] Really thankful that there's no [39:59] increase in our rates as well, [40:01] because, you know, it's a tough [40:02] time for cities and -- but, yet, [40:05] you know, we are still providing [40:06] the services and making sure [40:08] that these contracts -- well, [40:11] making sure that we don't [40:12] increase the rates for the [40:13] cities. And so I appreciate all [40:16] that they've done. And I agree [40:18] with our speakers that, you [40:20] know, oc animal has made [40:21] significant changes last year, [40:26] you know, so please know that we [40:26] appreciate you, but there is [40:28] still some work to be done. And [40:31] I -- you know, I know that [40:32] you're working on a strategic [40:34] plan. Staff has told my office [40:37] that you're compiling a report [40:41] to, you know -- on the 2018 [40:43] strategic plan that would be [40:45] coming to the board. I'm hoping [40:47] maybe if you can give us a [40:49] report in the next 30 days on [40:51] where you're at with that and [40:53] when we will see it moving [40:56] forward, whether it's a board [40:58] hearing, then we will accept [40:59] your report or a report to the [41:01] board itself. So again, I'm [41:05] excited to support this item and [41:08] looking forward to more great [41:09] things and collaboration with oc [41:13] animal in the community. Thank [41:14] you. [41:16] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [41:16] you, supervisor nguyen. [41:17] Supervisor sarmiento. [41:19] >>vincente sarmiento: thank you, [41:19] MR. Chair, and thank you to the [41:21] speaker for his comments. I [41:23] certainly appreciate and agree [41:24] with them, and I want to [41:26] actually also thank the [41:29] community members that helped [41:30] influence the changes that were [41:33] made since, you know, I've been [41:35] on this board and thank the [41:37] staff at animal care, dillon and [41:39] monica and others that made [41:42] these changes that are very [41:43] reasonable. So I do think we [41:45] have a great outline of what we [41:47] need to do with the strategic [41:48] plan, and it was adopted in [41:50] 2018. I simply think that we [41:52] need to make sure that the [41:53] public gets to see [41:54] compliance, [41:56] implementation, and those [41:57] regular reports and making sure [42:01] that we're meeting the metrics, [42:02] the goals stated in that [42:04] strategic plan. So to the [42:06] extent that something is brought [42:08] back, I think we need to do [42:09] something on a periodic basis, [42:10] and make sure that we're able to [42:13] see almost as a dashboard, [42:14] right, to see how we're doing on [42:16] these different concerns that we [42:18] have, that are outlined in the [42:20] strategic plan. So I am [42:22] supportive of all that's been [42:24] said, and obviously on this [42:26] underlying item, which is sort [42:28] of unrelated to the strategic [42:29] plan implementation. But I do [42:31] think maybe we should bring [42:33] something back that's a little [42:34] bit more formal that will give [42:36] some guidance on how to make [42:38] sure we're complying with the [42:39] strategic plan periodically for [42:41] the public to see. So I am [42:43] supportive these -- of the [42:43] underlying item, as well. Thank [42:45] you. [42:46] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [42:47] you. Any more comment? [42:50] Seeing none, we have a motion. [42:53] Any objection? The item is [42:55] approved. Thank you. Item 7. [43:00] Is that where we're at? Item 7, [43:03] yes. That would conclude our [43:03] consent calendar. [43:05] >>clerk, robin stieler: 7. [43:06] Under Treasurer-Tax Collector- [43:08] Approve transfer of funds [43:09] ($62,669.16) From Probation Fund [43:10] to Probation Victim Restitution [43:12] Fund and transfer of escheated [43:14] funds ($74,056.03) From [43:15] Sheriff-Coroner Fund to County [43:16] General Fund. It does require a [43:17] vote. [43:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: an [43:29] all-district item. [43:29] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [43:29] the item. [43:30] >>chair, doug chaffee: I'll [43:30] second the item. [43:33] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: no [43:34] one wants to support this, I [43:35] guess. [43:38] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [43:39] objection? Seeing none, it [43:41] required a 4/5th vote. We [43:43] have unanimous approval of that [43:48] item. Item 8, please. [43:49] >>clerk, robin stieler: 8. [43:50] Under health care agency, [43:51] Approve amendment 2 to renew [43:52] contract ma-042-24010172 with [43:53] The Regents of the University of [43:54] California, on behalf of uc [43:56] Irvine School of Medicine, [43:57] Department of Psychiatry for [43:59] physician services, 7/1/26- [44:00] 6/30/28 ($1,210,000; cumulative [44:00] total $3,025,000); And [44:01] authorize County Procurement [44:03] Officer or Deputized designee to [44:05] execute amendment. We have no [44:08] requests to speak on agenda item [44:09] 8. [44:09] >>chair, doug chaffee: lgt a [44:11] district 2 item. [44:12] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [44:13] second. [44:13] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [44:15] objection? Item is approved. [44:16] Item 9, please. [44:16] >>clerk, robin stieler: 9. [44:17] Under health care agency, [44:19] Approve amendment 6 to renew [44:19] contract ma-042-23011035 with [44:20] ocy Management, llc for [44:21] non-emergency transportation [44:22] services, 7/1/26-6/30/28 [44:22] ($1,000,000; cumulative total [44:23] $4,650,000); and authorize [44:24] County Procurement Officer or [44:24] Deputized designee to execute [44:27] amendment. We have no requests [44:31] to speak on agenda item 9. [44:32] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [44:46] all-district item. [44:46] >>clerk, robin stieler: 10. [44:47] Under health care agency, [44:48] approve amendment 6 to renew [44:49] contract ma-042-20011621 with [44:49] anaheim global medical center, [44:50] inc. For inpatient hospital [44:51] services for correctional health [44:51] services, 7/1/26-6/30/28 [44:52] ($12,833,874; cumulative total [44:53] $49,855,154); and authorize [44:54] county procurement officer or [44:54] deputized designee to execute [44:57] amendment. S we have no [44:58] requests to speak. [44:59] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's a [45:00] district 3 item. [45:02] >>janet nguyen: thank you. I [45:03] received a contribution of over [45:06] $1,000 for ocy management back [45:09] in 2025. [45:10] Since the contribution exceeds [45:17] the 500 threshold set by the [45:19] management, I am recusing myself [45:22] from participating in this [45:22] discussion. [45:25] >>leon page: and that was item 9 [45:27] and 10, supervisor, correct? [45:29] Where you intend to recuse [45:30] yourself? If the board would [45:32] permit to reflect that [45:35] supervisor nguyen did not [45:36] participate in the board [45:37] deliberation vote on item 9, [45:38] which we already did, and now [45:40] we're on number 10. [45:41] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'll [45:47] move to re-open item 9 for -- [45:50] item no. 9 for a second vote. [45:51] >>vincente sarmiento: I'll move [45:52] the item. [45:53] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [45:53] second. [45:58] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [45:58] objection? [45:59] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: you [46:06] have to make the disclosure. [46:07] >>chair, doug chaffee: I'm not [46:08] sure where we are here. [46:09] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: now [46:10] we have to vote on item 9. [46:10] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [46:13] right. We had a motion, and [46:16] supervisor sarmiento would like [46:17] to make a comment. [46:19] >>vincente sarmiento: on item 10 [46:20] 10. [46:21] >>chair, doug chaffee: okay. [46:21] We're back to 9. [46:23] >>vincente sarmiento: I moved [46:24] item 9. [46:24] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: and I [46:24] seconded. [46:25] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [46:29] objection? Seeing none, item 9 [46:29] is approved. [46:32] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: with [46:32] one abstention. [46:33] >>chair, doug chaffee: okay. [46:34] With one abstention. Okay. [46:36] Sorry. All right. That gave us [46:42] a majority vote. Now we're on [46:44] item 10, that's a district 2 and [46:45] 3 item. [46:47] >>vincente sarmiento: that, [46:48] MR. Chair. I'd like to have [46:50] DR. Kelly, if she can, maybe [46:52] come and share some thoughts on [46:53] this. I want to make sure that [46:54] we are clear. I know this is [46:56] for services for our in-custody [47:01] population. So medical care and [47:04] hospital care. So to the [47:06] extent, DR. Kelly, if you could [47:07] just walk us through. [47:09] >>leon page: and I think [47:09] supervisor nguyen has been [47:10] announcement on this as well. [47:13] >>janet nguyen: I do. I would [47:13] like to also recuse myself from [47:15] this vote, as well. I received [47:17] a contribution of $2500 from [47:19] strategic global management, [47:20] inc. Which is affiliated with [47:22] anaheim global medical center [47:24] back on MAY 12th, 2025 for [47:27] this item. I'm recushion myself [47:28] from participating in any [47:29] discussion or vote on this [47:30] matter. Thank you. [47:34] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [47:34] right. Any more comments? [47:41] >>speaker: good morning, [47:41] CHAIRMAN Chaffee, honorable [47:43] board. DR. Kelly, director of [47:44] the orange county healthcare [47:48] agency. Were there specific [47:48] questions you had or you just [47:49] want an overview. [47:51] >>vincente sarmiento: I know we [47:52] went to procurement for this. [47:53] We had two responses. I know [47:55] that anaheim global is the [47:56] prevailing bidder on this. [47:59] Number one, explain what the [48:00] item is, it's an important one, [48:02] and number 2, what are your [48:04] thoughts going forward? Does [48:06] this benefit the county? I know [48:08] this is trying to include [48:11] cal-aim to be able to maybe [48:13] address some of the cost [48:15] concerns. But if you can, [48:16] please -- [48:18] >>speaker: this stem to renew [48:19] inpatient services for [48:20] correctional health. And so the [48:22] vendor is anaheim global medical [48:24] center. They provide medical [48:26] care for inmates who require [48:29] outpatient specialty care such [48:30] as dialysis that can't be done [48:32] in custody or inpatient care, if [48:35] someone is having a cardiac [48:36] issue, they're giving birth. So [48:38] they provide that medical care. [48:43] >>vincente sarmiento: who are we [48:43] billing for this? Who's paying [48:44] for this. [48:45] >>speaker: none of that is [48:46] billable to any insurance. That [48:48] is full net county cost. The [48:50] item you talked about cal-aim [48:52] jail in range is for a very [48:55] specific cost that would not [48:55] include these services. It [48:57] would include some services we [48:59] provide for correctional health, [49:01] evaluations, medical evaluations [49:03] of inmates, providing [49:05] medication. And we are going to [49:06] start that APRIL 1st, and we [49:09] can only provide that and bill [49:10] the state for those services, [49:13] for people who are eligible for [49:14] medi-cal, and that would be for [49:16] 90 days prior to their release. [49:19] Carnals so 83% of this is born [49:21] by the county, that county cost [49:23] 17% realignment dollars. Your [49:25] recommendation, we just went out [49:27] on an rfp, do you think we [49:28] should go out on one soon [49:30] after. [49:31] >>speaker: we are going to be [49:31] starting another rfp. Usually [49:33] they take 12 to 18 months. This [49:36] is harder service to find [49:38] appropriate vendors for because [49:40] of the population and the [49:41] custody, the hard custody [49:43] requirements. So change in the [49:44] actual building space itself. [49:47] So we will be shortly after -- [49:49] if this report approves, we will [49:51] go out for another rfp. [49:53] >>vincente sarmiento: I'm [49:53] supportive of that. That's what [49:54] I wanted to get on the the [49:56] record make sure that that's [49:57] understood, giving my support [50:00] for this item. I'll go ahead [50:02] and move this item based on [50:04] attempt that from your team. [50:06] Thanks. [50:06] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [50:08] seconded. Was there an [50:08] abstention? [50:09] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: yes. [50:09] >>chair, doug chaffee: noting [50:13] the abstention, the item is [50:14] approved, 4 votes. Item 11, [50:18] please. [50:19] >>clerk, robin stieler: 11. [50:20] Under health care agency, [50:21] approve amendment 2 to renew [50:21] contract ma-042-23011108 with [50:23] sdxray inc. For direct digital [50:25] radiology services for [50:26] correctional health services [50:27] programs, 7/1/26-6/30/28 [50:28] ($4,214,240; cumulative total [50:28] $10,535,600); and authorize [50:29] county procurement officer or [50:30] deputized designee to execute amendment. [50:32] We have no requests to speak on [50:33] agenda item 11. [50:33] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's a [50:34] district 2 and 3 item. Moved [50:38] and seconded. Any objection? [50:39] The item is approved. Item 12, [50:41] please. [50:41] >>clerk, robin stieler: 12. [50:42] Under health care agency, [50:43] approve amendment 2 to renew [50:43] contract ma-042-23011109 with [50:44] correctional managed care, [50:45] medical corporation, for [50:47] physician services for [50:48] correctional health services [50:49] programs, 7/1/26-6/30/28 [50:49] ($6,955,868; cumulative total [50:50] $16,410,125); and authorize [50:51] county procurement officer or [50:52] deputized designee to execute amendment. [50:54] We have no requests to speak on [50:56] agenda item 12. [50:56] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's a [50:59] district 2 and 3 item. Any [51:02] objection? Item is approved. [51:04] Item 13, please. [51:05] >>clerk, robin stieler: 13. [51:06] Under john wayne airport, [51:07] approve subordinate contract [51:08] ma-280-26010529 with siemens [51:09] industry, inc. For facility [51:10] security systems, equipment, and [51:12] software with related services, [51:13] 4/23/26-2/18/29 ($2,800,000); [51:14] renewable for one additional [51:14] two-year term; authorize county [51:16] procurement officer or deputized [51:17] designee to execute contract; [51:18] and make californi environmental [51:19] quality act (Ceqa) Exemption [51:19] findings under ceqa guidelines [51:21] section 15378. We have no [51:23] requests to speak on agenda item [51:24] 13. [51:25] >>chair, doug chaffee: item 13 a [51:27] district 5 item. [51:28] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [51:28] the item. [51:31] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [51:31] objection? Motion carries. [51:34] Unanimously. Next item is 14. [51:36] >>clerk, robin stieler: 14. [51:39] Under oc community resources, [51:40] approve amendment 1 to contract [51:41] ma-012-25011237 with citiguard, [51:42] inc. For unarmed security guard [51:43] services at various county [51:45] library branch locations, 4/1/26 [51:45] -3/31/30 ($2,050,000; [51:46] cumulative total $2,250,000); [51:47] and authorize county procurement [51:47] officer or deputized designee to [51:50] execute amendment and future [51:53] amendments under certain conditions. [51:54] Question have no requests to [51:55] speak on agenda item 14. [51:57] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [51:57] all-district item. [51:58] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [51:58] the item. [51:59] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [52:00] objection? Item is approved. [52:02] Item 15, please. [52:02] >>clerk, robin stieler: 15. [52:03] Under oc community resources, [52:05] approve amendment 7 to contract [52:06] ma-012-23011443 with council on [52:07] aging-southern california, [52:07] inc. For senior health insurance [52:09] counseling and advocacy program [52:11] services, 4/1/26-3/31/27 [52:12] ($601,668; cumulative total [52:12] $1,808,627); and authorize [52:13] county procurement officer or [52:14] deputized designee to execute [52:15] amendment and future amendments [52:15] under certain conditions. We [52:15] have no requests to speak. [52:15] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [52:23] all-district item. Any [52:23] objection? Item is approved. [52:26] Item 16. [52:30] >>clerk, robin stieler: 16. [52:31] Under oc public works, adopt [52:32] resolution initiating 2026 weed [52:35] abatement program and setting [52:36] public hearing for 4/14/26, 9:30 [52:40] A.M. To consider assessment to [52:42] private property for cost [52:43] removal of weeds by county or [52:45] contractor; and make california [52:45] environmental quality act (Ceqa) [52:47] Exemption findings under ceqa [52:48] guidelines section 15304. We [52:50] have no requests to speak on [52:51] agenda item 16. [52:53] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [52:55] all-district item. Moved and [52:57] seconded. Any objection? [52:58] Motion carries. Item 17, please [52:59] please. [53:00] >>clerk, robin stieler: 17. [53:01] Under oc public works, approve [53:02] aggregate contract [53:04] ma-080-26010053 with various [53:04] contractors for sanitation and [53:06] remediation removal & [53:07] decontamination services, 3/9/26 [53:08] -3/8/29 (Aggregate total [53:09] $1,800,000); renewable for one [53:09] additional two-year term; [53:10] authorize county procurement [53:11] officer or deputized designee to [53:13] execute contract; and make [53:13] california environmental [53:14] quality act (Ceqa) Exemption [53:15] findings under ceqa guidelines [53:16] sections 15301 and 15308 we have [53:20] no if to speak on agenda item [53:21] 17. [53:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [53:22] all-district item. [53:24] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [53:24] second. [53:25] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [53:26] seconded, any objection? Motion [53:27] approved. I'd like now to move [53:29] to item 28. [53:30] >>clerk, robin stieler: 28. [53:31] Under county executive office- [53:35] acting as the orange county [53:36] board of supervisors and orange [53:38] county flood control district- [53:39] adopt 2026 contract policy [53:42] manual, effective 2/24/26 [53:45] 2/24/26; authorize county [53:48] executive officer or designee to [53:48] make changes under certain [53:49] conditions; and adopt amended [53:51] resolution authorizing director [53:52] of oc public works, [53:55] sheriff-coroner or designees to [53:55] advertise bids in accordance [53:57] with public contract code [53:59] sections 22037, 22032(C) And 20128.5. [54:07] We have no if to speak on agenda [54:08] item 28. [54:08] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [54:09] all-district item. [54:12] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [54:12] the item. [54:15] >>janet nguyen: I have a [54:15] question, MR. CHAIRMAN [54:15] supervisor supervisor nguyen. [54:17] Go ahead. [54:21] >>janet nguyen: any staff here? [54:24] Maria, just, real quick, I [54:27] know -- first, thank you. You [54:32] did a phenomenal job in putting [54:34] all of our thoughts and comments [54:37] and questions from last week -- [54:38] or two weeks ago now. My only [54:40] question is, I know that you've [54:42] mentioned this, but I wanted to [54:43] make sure that the -- under the [54:47] board's approval on the power [54:48] presentation, it says -- where [54:51] it describes the changes to rfp [54:53] and rfq comes to the board for [54:54] selection and then staff [54:55] negotiates the contract and then [54:57] comes back to the board for [54:58] final approval. But on the [55:03] package itself, I don't see the [55:07] rfp. I only see rfq. Am I [55:11] missing somewhere? I just want [55:13] to make sure that it is [55:14] consistent and that it's in the [55:18] manual. [55:18] >>speaker: good morning, [55:19] CHAIRMAN, vice-chair, members of [55:21] the board. Yes, the change [55:26] applies to all ASRs for [55:28] contract award. [55:30] >>janet nguyen: so rfp and -- [55:31] >>speaker: any contracts coming [55:32] to the board. They will now [55:34] come one time for selection [55:35] earlier on in the process, [55:38] asking for authority to then [55:40] negotiate an award. But we will [55:42] be coming earlier in the [55:43] process. [55:44] >>janet nguyen: okay. So that's [55:45] not just an rfq for joc and a&e [55:48] contracts, but for all. [55:51] >>speaker: any contract coming [55:52] to the board for award. [55:54] >>janet nguyen: okay. Is it [55:54] somewhere here? Because I just [55:56] want to make sure that a year [55:58] from now when we're talking [55:59] about the manual, they're like, [56:01] we only did what the manual [56:01] says. [56:03] >>speaker: cpm is silent on that [56:04] procedural asr procedure. So [56:08] the change also be in the [56:09] procedures manual as well as the [56:11] asr guidance dewpoints. So cpm [56:15] is kind of silent on the process [56:17] to get board approval. [56:18] >>janet nguyen: why? [56:19] >>speaker: because we refer to [56:21] the asr guidance document and [56:22] our producers manual. [56:24] >>janet nguyen: when you have [56:25] that, can you send it up to us. [56:26] >>speaker: definitely. [56:27] >>janet nguyen: thank you. [56:28] >>chair, doug chaffee: [56:29] supervisor sarmiento. [56:31] >>vincente sarmiento: thank you, [56:31] MR. Chair, and thank you, marie [56:33] back for you and your team [56:35] making sure -- I think [56:36] everything that was discussed at [56:37] the last meeting was included. [56:39] Sounds like it was pretty [56:39] comprehensive. Just going back [56:41] to the question that supervisor [56:44] nguyen was asking, the one [56:44] change about having the items, [56:47] these contracts come to the [56:48] board first to give authority [56:51] for you and your team to [56:54] negotiate or for the contracts [56:56] to be negotiated, so we'll be [56:57] seeing these in advance of that. [57:00] Does it come back to us, or is [57:02] it pretty much once we give [57:03] authority for you to then [57:04] negotiate those contracts, are [57:06] you now delegated with that? [57:09] >>speaker: we will be asking for [57:09] that delegated authority. [57:10] However, the board has the [57:12] opportunity to ask us to come [57:13] back for an a -- back forward at [57:15] any gufn time. [57:15] >>vincente sarmiento: when you [57:17] bring back the results of, you [57:20] know, the rfp, rfq, it will come [57:25] with no staff recommendation. [57:26] It simply comes back with data? [57:28] >>speaker: he will come back [57:29] with the rank order of the [57:30] results of the evaluation. [57:33] >>vincente sarmiento: look, to [57:34] me -- and I understand, you [57:36] know, what we're doing. We want [57:38] to be more objective, maybe a [57:39] more open process for the board [57:42] to be able to make a decision. [57:43] I just want you to know, my [57:45] understanding of staff [57:47] recommending the way we have the [57:49] existing procedure now where [57:51] staff would come back and [57:52] recommend a vendor or vendors [57:55] based upon, you know, the [57:57] procurement process, I always [57:58] thought, was fair. That doesn't [58:00] mean that this board has to [58:01] follow staff's recommendation. [58:03] It could deviate for whatever [58:04] reason. We could just see [58:06] things a little differently. [58:07] But the guidance from an [58:10] unbiased, technical subject [58:12] matter, you know, a group of [58:14] people on panels, that are [58:16] taking a deeper dive on this has [58:17] always been instructive. Not [58:20] depositive, but, you know, [58:20] helpful. So, you know, I didn't [58:24] want that to be lost. But at [58:26] the same time I think maybe the [58:30] school board looking at having [58:31] an unvarnished, you know, no [58:34] preference from staff on this. [58:38] But I don't know if a hybrid [58:41] would be better where it comes [58:42] to us early and the staff gives [58:44] us their thoughts on, you know, [58:47] what they believe would be the [58:50] preferential vendor or the [58:52] vendor that, you know, seems to [58:54] be better suited, based on [58:55] costs, experience, business [58:56] plan, whatever criteria we have. [58:58] I just didn't want to dismiss [59:00] all our subject matter experts [59:02] that are able to, you know, take [59:04] a deeper dive than we would on [59:06] this. Again, just for guidance. [59:08] Not for any rubber stamping or [59:12] doing anything else. It's just [59:13] simply been helpful. So go [59:17] ahead, maria. [59:17] >>speaker: one suggestion is we [59:19] could put in the background [59:20] information of each asr based on [59:23] the information or evaluation -- [59:25] or information contained the [59:28] staff -- we could provide some [59:30] sort of recommendation based on [59:32] the information collected [59:33] through the evaluation process. [59:34] >>vincente sarmiento: right. [59:35] And that doesn't mean that's [59:36] going, to again, determine where [59:38] this board is going to go. We [59:39] could certainly take that into [59:40] consideration or not and just [59:42] simply, you know, go in a [59:43] different direction. I do think [59:44] having staff give us some idea [59:47] and some sense of the rationale [59:49] of how we arrived at ranking and [59:52] how these different applicants [59:55] did, I think, is fair. So to [59:58] the extent that would be [59:59] something that could be included [1:00:00] in the process, again, that [1:00:01] would be helpful, I think, as -- [1:00:03] you know, for the public as well [1:00:05] as for us. [1:00:05] >>speaker: there is procedural [1:00:06] language until background of [1:00:08] asr. We could put something in [1:00:09] there and draft it and extend to [1:00:11] the board's office for your [1:00:12] concurrence. [1:00:15] >>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN? [1:00:16] MAY I? [1:00:17] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:00:18] supervisor foley is next. [1:00:19] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [1:00:22] you. Mine will be quick. I [1:00:23] just want to thank your team in [1:00:26] procurement as well as all of [1:00:28] the department procurement team [1:00:30] members for helping us get [1:00:33] through this process. It's my [1:00:35] understanding that you all took [1:00:36] another look, and the $3 million [1:00:39] was gonna be okay in terms of [1:00:42] efficiencies, and so I think [1:00:45] this contract policy manual [1:00:47] helps us to accomplish two [1:00:48] things. It keeps us efficient [1:00:51] in our progression and prevents [1:00:54] us from having any delays in our [1:00:57] projects, but also, you another [1:00:59] a little bit more oversight and [1:01:01] accountability by the board. [1:01:04] And I'm hoping that if at all [1:01:07] you think that it's starting to [1:01:09] bog down, that you will alert [1:01:11] us, because we have a lot of [1:01:14] projects underway. We don't [1:01:16] want to get bogged down. And so [1:01:20] please do alert us. Thank you. [1:01:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:01:22] supervisor nguyen. [1:01:23] >>janet nguyen: thank you, [1:01:24] MR. CHAIRMAN. I want to follow [1:01:26] up on what supervisor sarmiento [1:01:28] mentioned. My understanding is [1:01:30] that staff would do your panel [1:01:33] interview and everything, and [1:01:35] then you would give us all that [1:01:36] data so we would know -- because [1:01:38] staff would usually take the [1:01:40] highest score. So we would know [1:01:41] that would be the selection of [1:01:43] staff, and then we would be up [1:01:44] here making that decision. And [1:01:46] the only reason is last year we [1:01:48] had so many of those came here [1:01:49] afterward, and staff was -- put [1:01:53] so much time in getting these [1:01:55] contracts and everything [1:01:57] negotiated, and then you had to [1:01:58] start over. And so that's why, [1:02:02] you know -- so it isn't that [1:02:04] we're just being handed, here, [1:02:05] have at it. You're going to [1:02:07] give us the data, the panel, [1:02:08] scoring, and all of that [1:02:11] information, and then we get to [1:02:12] make that -- we would then [1:02:14] deliberate and make that [1:02:15] decision. [1:02:16] >>speaker: correct. [1:02:17] >>janet nguyen: thank you. [1:02:18] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:02:18] you. I'd like to thank you for [1:02:21] the incredible line of work the [1:02:22] staff has put in. It's been a [1:02:24] long haul. And thank you for [1:02:26] helping us understand the [1:02:27] definition of "commodities" a [1:02:29] little better. It's more than [1:02:32] just gold and silver bars. And [1:02:35] with that, I think we have a [1:02:37] motion. Any objection? The [1:02:41] item is approved. Thank you for [1:02:43] your good work. [1:02:44] >>speaker: thank you. [1:02:45] >>chair, doug chaffee: and now [1:02:45] we come back to item 18. [1:02:50] 18. Approve job order contracts [1:02:51] with various contractors for [1:02:52] general contracting services, [1:02:53] oneyear term ($5,000,000 each); [1:02:53] and authorize director or [1:02:56] designee to execute contracts. [1:02:57] And we have no requests to speak [1:02:58] on item 18. [1:03:03] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [1:03:07] all-district item. Supervisor [1:03:07] wagner. [1:03:10] >>don wagner: before we do that, [1:03:11] though, I think this is an item [1:03:13] that's $5 million per contract, [1:03:16] and we just talked about and [1:03:19] voted on $3 million. How is [1:03:25] this going to work? Kevin, can [1:03:26] you live with $3 million? Or do [1:03:30] you want to add some other [1:03:31] companies to make up the [1:03:33] difference, or how -- help me [1:03:35] square these two. I just didn't [1:03:37] want this to fly past us. [1:03:40] >>michelle aguirre: kevin, [1:03:41] before you respond, I think as [1:03:45] part the policy, right, the ends [1:03:47] something for most types of [1:03:49] contracts, most types of work, [1:03:52] the $3 million will suffice. [1:03:54] But there are some areas like [1:03:56] the one that you see before you, [1:03:58] the general contracting, where [1:04:00] at least for this upcoming year, [1:04:02] based on the number of projects, [1:04:03] the analysis that staff has [1:04:05] done, a higher amount is [1:04:07] warranted, and departments would [1:04:11] bring those requests based on [1:04:13] their analysis. You MAY [1:04:15] occasionally see something that [1:04:16] deviates from the $3 million, [1:04:18] about you has to be justified by [1:04:20] the department, and then that's [1:04:21] why we've got kevin here, to [1:04:23] explain a little bit more [1:04:24] related to the general [1:04:25] contracting. [1:04:28] >>speaker: CHAIRMAN Chaffee, [1:04:29] members of the board, kevin [1:04:30] aloom know, oc public works. [1:04:32] The reason why we're [1:04:33] recommending a higher dollar [1:04:35] amount is joc contracts are low [1:04:38] bid. If we went with the $3 [1:04:40] million limit, we had 17 [1:04:43] responsive bids, we'd be using [1:04:46] the contractors with the highest [1:04:48] prices, so we'd be paying more [1:04:49] for the work. That why we're [1:04:51] recommending fewer contracts at [1:04:54] a higher dollar amount so we can [1:04:55] keep it at more of the low [1:04:57] bidders. [1:05:00] >>don wagner: is that true of [1:05:02] all joc contracts? [1:05:05] >>speaker: well, the joc [1:05:07] contracts for general [1:05:08] contracting as michelle said [1:05:10] tend to be a larger dollar [1:05:11] amount. The other joc contracts [1:05:13] when it's specific to a trade, [1:05:15] plumbing and so on, the need for [1:05:18] those are the project size and [1:05:20] total dollar amounts tending to [1:05:20] smaller. [1:05:22] >>don wagner: so despite our [1:05:23] policy and putting the $3 [1:05:25] million into the contract policy [1:05:27] manual you expect on general [1:05:29] contracting to keep coming back [1:05:32] to us for higher amounts? So we [1:05:35] should just be prepared for [1:05:36] that? [1:05:37] >>speaker: in general, yes. But [1:05:38] it depends on the capital [1:05:40] projects that are approved by [1:05:41] the board. If we have less, [1:05:43] maybe we can get by with the [1:05:45] smaller dollar amount. [1:05:46] >>don wagner: all right. Thank [1:05:47] you. I'll move the item. [1:05:49] >>chair, doug chaffee: if I MAY [1:05:53] comment, when we do the asr and [1:05:56] it exceeds the policy amount, [1:05:59] then we shrewed a paragraph in [1:06:01] there describing that and [1:06:03] justifying it, if we can have [1:06:04] that in the future ASRs, [1:06:06] that'd be helpful. [1:06:07] >>speaker: will do. [1:06:08] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:06:08] you. Supervisor sarmiento. [1:06:11] >>vincente sarmiento: and the [1:06:11] chair just kind of said exactly [1:06:13] weigh intended to say. Are we [1:06:14] calling this an exemption, an [1:06:16] exception, a justification? [1:06:18] What term of art are we going to [1:06:19] see in that additional [1:06:20] paragraph, just so we're clear [1:06:22] on the term? Maybe we should [1:06:26] and our county counsel, I'm not [1:06:26] sure if -- I've heard exemption, [1:06:34] i've heard exception. [1:06:36] >>speaker: we can develop that [1:06:37] language and alert the board. [1:06:42] >>vincente sarmiento: and I [1:06:42] appreciate the $3 million [1:06:43] because when I saw the data that [1:06:45] you sent our office, the bulk of [1:06:47] the contracts are $3 million and [1:06:49] below. So that's why we landed [1:06:51] on this amount. There are -- [1:06:52] there obviously were other [1:06:54] contracts outside of that [1:06:55] amount, but the bell curve, I [1:06:56] guess if you look at it, was the [1:06:59] median washed $3 million and [1:06:59] below. I just want to make sure [1:07:01] we have our terms correct. [1:07:03] >>speaker: we will get that out [1:07:03] to you. [1:07:04] >>vincente sarmiento: thank [1:07:04] you. [1:07:05] >>chair, doug [1:07:05] thank you [1:07:06] vice-chair foley. [1:07:07] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [1:07:07] you. I'm not sure what we're [1:07:14] going to get because that was [1:07:15] the language we voted on. We [1:07:17] specifically added that sentence [1:07:19] that said for anything above $3 [1:07:21] million we would come to the [1:07:23] board with a justification. [1:07:25] It's not an exemption. It's [1:07:26] just justification, for [1:07:28] exceeding the $3 million. So I [1:07:31] feel like we already have it in [1:07:32] there. If we're going to change [1:07:34] it, what do we need to change it [1:07:36] to? We've already said it. [1:07:39] >>vincente sarmiento: the only [1:07:39] reason why I mentioned it is [1:07:40] because I've heard exemption [1:07:41] from staff exceptions as well. [1:07:43] If we're not going to use [1:07:46] justification, I wanted to see [1:07:46] if there was any other language [1:07:48] besides that. But if it's [1:07:50] justification, then that's the [1:07:52] term. [1:07:54] >>michelle aguirre: departments [1:07:55] will be required, right, to [1:07:57] justify it within the background [1:08:00] exception of the asr. But what [1:08:02] the asr document does is provide [1:08:05] standard like template language [1:08:07] so that when you see, that we [1:08:08] have consistent language across [1:08:10] all ASRs for all departments [1:08:12] that kind of lead up to that [1:08:13] justification. So that's what [1:08:15] maria was referring to. We can [1:08:16] provide that standard language. [1:08:17] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: so it [1:08:19] will say "justification" and [1:08:21] then whatever it is. [1:08:22] >>michelle aguirre: exactly. [1:08:23] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay. [1:08:23] Thank you. [1:08:24] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:08:25] supervisor nguyen. [1:08:26] >>janet nguyen: thank you, [1:08:27] MR. CHAIRMAN. So kevin... [1:08:30] What are these projects? What's [1:08:34] the $5 million each company -- [1:08:36] what are they doing? [1:08:39] >>speaker: the projects are [1:08:40] listed in attachment m. So [1:08:43] they're the projects that have [1:08:44] been approved by the board as a [1:08:46] product of capital improvement [1:08:49] projects with the budget or with [1:08:50] the sfp. It includes projects [1:08:53] for fy25/26 and also projects [1:08:59] that were included in the sfp [1:09:02] for fy '26/27 and on. [1:09:05] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [1:09:11] libraries, public parks, -- [1:09:13] public works, the gas [1:09:16] compressors, probation, juvenile [1:09:18] hall, sprinkler system, it's on [1:09:22] page 18 of the staff report. [1:09:26] Orangewood children family [1:09:28] center rehab, the manchester [1:09:31] office building, several [1:09:32] different ada and fire panel [1:09:34] upgrades. A lot of parks, [1:09:40] libraries, town valley library [1:09:42] roof, hvac, westminster roof [1:09:45] hvac, interior refresh for the [1:09:47] library.. [1:09:54] >>janet nguyen: thank you. And [1:09:55] I think what would be helpful, [1:09:57] kevin, is maybe this page should [1:10:00] be part of it, asr, so we see [1:10:04] right away what these projects [1:10:06] are or what you're working on [1:10:08] versus having it in the back. [1:10:11] Because I think -- you know, I [1:10:13] want to also make sure that the [1:10:13] public knows that we are giving [1:10:16] you the $5 million outside the [1:10:18] manual. I mean, basically it's [1:10:19] your justification. [1:10:22] >>speaker: so put in the body of [1:10:22] the asr instead of the [1:10:23] attachment. [1:10:25] >>janet nguyen: yes, thank you. [1:10:26] >>speaker: okay. [1:10:27] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [1:10:31] right. We have a motion. Any [1:10:32] objection? Item is approved. [1:10:35] Thank you. Item 19, please. [1:10:38] >>clerk, robin stieler: 19. [1:10:41] Under oc public works, consider [1:10:42] second reading and adoption of [1:10:44] "an ordinance of the county of [1:10:45] orange, state of california, [1:10:47] amending sections 3-14-2 through [1:10:52] 3-14-16, 5-1-31, 5-1-33 and [1:10:59] 7-9-103 of the codified [1:11:00] ordinances of the county of [1:11:01] orange"; and adopt resolution [1:11:02] adopting zoning code amendment [1:11:06] ca 25-02 (County of orange [1:11:07] commercial cannabis activities [1:11:09] and outdoor personal cultivation [1:11:11] prohibition ordinance). Woe have [1:11:14] no requests to speak on agenda [1:11:15] item 19. [1:11:17] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [1:11:17] all-district item. [1:11:18] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [1:11:18] the item. [1:11:20] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [1:11:21] right. This is an interesting [1:11:22] item in that we catch property [1:11:24] owners who are profiting well [1:11:28] illegal cannabis trade. I think [1:11:30] it's a good ordinance. Any [1:11:32] objection? Motion carries. [1:11:34] thank you. Item 20 please. [1:11:36] >>clerk, robin stieler: 20. [1:11:38] Under oc waster & recycling, [1:11:41] approve amendment 1 to renew [1:11:41] contract ma-299-22011684 with [1:11:42] stearns, conrad and schmidt, [1:11:44] consulting engineers dba scs [1:11:47] field services for landfill gas [1:11:49] services, central region, [1:11:49] 4/10/26-4/9/28 ($11,000,000; [1:11:50] cumulative total $27,500,000); [1:11:51] authorize county procurement [1:11:51] officer or deputized designee to [1:11:53] make minor changes under certain [1:11:54] conditions and execute [1:11:55] amendment; and make california [1:11:56] environmental quality act (Ceqa) [1:11:57] Exemption findings under ceqa [1:11:58] guidelines sections 15301, [1:12:01] 15304, and 15308. We have no [1:12:04] requests to speak on agenda item [1:12:05] 20. [1:12:06] >>chair, doug chaffee: this is a [1:12:07] district 2, 3, and 5 item. [1:12:08] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [1:12:08] second. [1:12:10] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [1:12:11] seconded. Any objection? Item [1:12:12] is approved. Item 21, please. [1:12:13] >>clerk, robin stieler: 21. [1:12:14] Under oc waste & recycling, [1:12:16] adopt county of orange climate [1:12:17] action planning document; direct [1:12:19] staff to begin implementation [1:12:21] phase and analysis; and make [1:12:22] california environmental quality [1:12:23] act (Ceqa) Exemption findings [1:12:24] under ceqa guidelines section [1:12:25] 15262 and public resources code [1:12:29] sections 21083 and 21150. And [1:12:33] MR. Chair, we very received [1:12:34] three requests to speak on [1:12:36] agenda item 21. [1:12:37] >>chair, doug chaffee: please [1:12:37] call the speakers. [1:12:39] >>clerk, robin stieler: paulina [1:12:39] alvarez, anna gromas, and jeff [1:12:44] weaver. [1:12:51] >>speaker: good morning, chair [1:12:57] chaffee and members of the [1:12:57] board. My name is paulina [1:12:58] alvarez, and I'm the government [1:12:59] affairs manager for the orange [1:13:01] county business council. We [1:13:03] support thoughtful, [1:13:05] cost-effective, and achievable [1:13:06] climate policies and appreciates [1:13:09] the county's efforts to address [1:13:11] greenhouse gas emissions and [1:13:13] sustainability. Our concern is [1:13:15] chapter 4 community climate [1:13:17] action introduces measures that [1:13:19] could create uncertainty and [1:13:20] unintended consequences for [1:13:23] house production, economic [1:13:24] development and private [1:13:26] investment in un-incorporated [1:13:28] areas. Measure cm2 reduce [1:13:30] vehicles miles travels vmt [1:13:33] encourages reduction of vmt [1:13:35] through public outreach and [1:13:37] incentives. Our concern is vmt [1:13:39] is already regulated under state [1:13:41] law including sb-743 and ceqa. [1:13:44] Additional local measures could [1:13:45] duplicate standards and increase [1:13:47] entitlement uncertainty and ce1 [1:13:51] promotes building [1:13:54] decarbonization. The concern is [1:14:00] it could raise construction [1:14:02] costs, constrain housing supply [1:14:04] and complicate private [1:14:05] development particularly amid [1:14:07] california's housing [1:14:08] affordability crisis. [1:14:10] Incorporating the cap into the [1:14:11] general plan could [1:14:13] unintentionally turn [1:14:14] aspirational goals into binding [1:14:16] land use standards raising [1:14:18] secret disputes and feasibility [1:14:19] challenges. Ocbc recommends the [1:14:22] following, remove chapter 4 [1:14:24] community climate action from [1:14:26] phase 2, avoid incorporating [1:14:28] community cap measures into the [1:14:30] general plan in a way that [1:14:31] affects private development, and [1:14:33] focus the cap on county [1:14:34] operations and facilities to [1:14:36] ensure clarity and legal [1:14:38] defensibility and [1:14:39] economic competitiveness. Ocbc [1:14:42] remains committed to [1:14:43] collaborating with the county on [1:14:44] climate strategies that are [1:14:46] effective, achievable and [1:14:47] supportive of orange county's [1:14:49] economy. Thank you for your [1:14:50] time. [1:14:53] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:14:55] you. [1:14:58] >>speaker: good morning, chair [1:14:59] chaffee and supervisors. Anna [1:15:00] gromas here representing the [1:15:02] building industry association in [1:15:03] the orange county chapter. The [1:15:06] first outline was OCTOBER of [1:15:09] 2025 and the second one being in [1:15:12] JANUARY of 2026, we still have [1:15:14] concerns with the cap as it is [1:15:16] written in chapter 4 is still [1:15:17] problematic to us. There's a [1:15:19] lot of combyity that surrounds [1:15:20] the language on decarbon sayings [1:15:26] and vmt. We kindly ask that [1:15:26] that section be omitted from the [1:15:28] cap. In addition in the [1:15:29] JANUARY 2026 draft comprehensive [1:15:32] general plan update that is [1:15:33] currently out for public review, [1:15:35] implementation of the cap was [1:15:37] listed as an action item under [1:15:38] the resource management elements [1:15:40] section. The building industry [1:15:42] is justifiably concerned that [1:15:43] incorporating the climate action [1:15:45] plan into the general plan will [1:15:47] unintentionally turn advisory [1:15:49] climate objectives into binding [1:15:51] land use mandates. When goals [1:15:53] are elevated into the general [1:15:54] plan, they assume the same legal [1:15:56] bhait weight as other general [1:15:57] plan policies. That the county [1:16:00] must use when conditioning, [1:16:02] approving or denying development [1:16:05] complications. If the cap is [1:16:05] incorporated into the -- [1:16:06] development applications. If [1:16:07] the cap is incorporated, there's [1:16:08] a significant risk that the [1:16:10] broad, long-term community [1:16:11] greenhouse gas reduction goals [1:16:13] could be applied rigidly to [1:16:14] individual projects without [1:16:16] consideration or proportionality [1:16:18] or feasibility. It would switch [1:16:21] the cap from a planning guide [1:16:22] into a binding standard of [1:16:24] review. Developers could be [1:16:26] required to prove that their [1:16:27] projects meet community wide [1:16:29] goals. This creates entitlement [1:16:35] risks and the potential for ceqa [1:16:36] disputes over targets that were [1:16:37] originally meant to be [1:16:38] aspirational and not mandatory. [1:16:41] From the beginning the county [1:16:43] indicated that the cap would not [1:16:44] be applied to private [1:16:45] development and un-incorporated [1:16:47] areas. The cap goals should [1:16:49] remove references to private [1:16:50] development, should not be [1:16:51] incorporated into the general [1:16:53] plan as doing so could turn [1:16:55] community-wide aspirations into [1:16:57] inflexible and enforceable [1:16:59] mandates on individual prisons. [1:17:01] We thank you for your time and [1:17:02] consideration, and we look [1:17:03] forward to continuing our work [1:17:05] with the county on this [1:17:06] mattered. [1:17:07] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:17:07] you. Next speaker, please. [1:17:12] >>speaker: good afternoon, [1:17:12] board. I'm jeff weaver from san [1:17:14] juan capistrano, the home of the [1:17:16] prima desay sha landfill [1:17:19] problem. We talked last time [1:17:21] about the massive amount of [1:17:23] toxic gas that comes out of each [1:17:27] landfill. The prima landfill is [1:17:35] located about a mile from san [1:17:37] juan hills high school. At the [1:17:39] current status before the [1:17:40] expansion -- and I'd like to get [1:17:42] some definition. Expansion, we [1:17:44] talked last time -- or you [1:17:45] talked to tom petition troll [1:17:47] liss last time about expansion. [1:17:49] I think we spent $100 million on [1:17:51] to so-called expansion. This is [1:17:52] it. This is what they're [1:17:54] tearing apart right now. You [1:17:56] see this from miles away. The [1:18:00] problem is it's one mile from [1:18:01] our high school. And the high [1:18:02] school kids have no choice but [1:18:03] to breathe this toxic gas. Oc [1:18:07] waste and recycling and its [1:18:08] climate action plan calls it [1:18:10] odor. Well, the way they [1:18:12] control the odor, they drive [1:18:13] around and sniff and spray [1:18:16] febreze type stuff to decrease [1:18:18] the odor. And doesn't mean [1:18:20] you're not smelling it. But if [1:18:22] you're smelling it, it's really [1:18:23] bad. And these kids are out [1:18:25] there on the track team or the [1:18:27] football team, running as hard [1:18:28] as they can, they don't know [1:18:29] that they're breathing these [1:18:30] toxic fumes that are [1:18:32] consistently over 1 million [1:18:35] cubic feet per day that gets [1:18:37] released, uncontrolled release [1:18:38] from this landfill. So that's [1:18:42] our big concern. And in the [1:18:43] climate action plan they mandate [1:18:45] aggressive methane management. [1:18:50] And all I see in the climate [1:18:52] action plan are drones. $25 [1:18:53] million for drones. They have a [1:18:55] thing that says "drones are [1:18:56] tackling methane gas." I [1:18:59] watched the super bowl. I saw a [1:19:00] lot of tackling. I don't know [1:19:01] how it's even possible for a [1:19:03] drone to tackle an invisible [1:19:05] gas. But I like the definition [1:19:08] on how the drone tackles the [1:19:09] gas. I'd like the definition on [1:19:12] how older is a toxic gas and the [1:19:14] expansion. Is that an [1:19:15] expansion? It looks like an [1:19:16] expansion, and there's been over [1:19:18] $100 million on this expansion. [1:19:20] This be landfill will be in [1:19:21] operation for 75 years. It's [1:19:23] going to be producing this [1:19:24] methane for over 100 years. But [1:19:26] the problem is, this methane is [1:19:28] fuel. If we tap this methane, [1:19:30] our plan is to cap this [1:19:31] landfill, tap the landfill and [1:19:34] produce 20 megawatts of energy [1:19:36] that will power the desal plant [1:19:38] and the entire city of san juan [1:19:39] capistrano for the next 100 [1:19:41] years. We want to put an [1:19:43] amendment that you at least look [1:19:44] at our plan. I've talked to two [1:19:46] of the staff of the board [1:19:48] members here -- or the [1:19:49] supervisors. I've been waiting [1:19:51] to talk to katrina foley for [1:19:53] almost two years now, and I met [1:19:55] with alyssa. I was supposed to [1:19:57] have a meeting with her. I've [1:19:58] been waiting two years. But [1:19:59] until the climate action plan [1:20:01] came out and environmental [1:20:02] impact report came out just last [1:20:05] month, we didn't have a whole [1:20:06] lot of data to go on. The funny [1:20:07] thing is the data they're study [1:20:09] something from 2018 on the gas [1:20:11] that's released from these [1:20:12] landfills. 2018. That's the [1:20:14] current data. I'm sorry -- I'm [1:20:16] running a little long. [1:20:17] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:20:17] you, sir. [1:20:17] >>speaker: please someone talk [1:20:19] to us about this. We have a [1:20:20] plan, we have engineers. [1:20:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:20:22] you, sir. [1:20:23] >>speaker: we can have our own [1:20:23] financing and won't cost a dime [1:20:25] and we can save the kids from [1:20:29] the poisonous gas at san juan [1:20:29] hills high school. Please help [1:20:30] us. [1:20:31] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:20:33] supervisor wagner. [1:20:36] >>don wagner: real quick, we're [1:20:40] all at the octa board yesterday. [1:20:42] We had been in discussion about [1:20:45] one of these climate action [1:20:46] plans or a plan that carbon come [1:20:49] up with the ict, how it's [1:20:51] failing. A newspaper article [1:20:54] over the weekend, I want to say [1:20:56] wall street journal, it MAY have [1:20:58] been somewhere else. It [1:21:00] explained that the world has [1:21:03] spent $16 trillion with a "t" -- [1:21:06] trillion dollars on climate [1:21:08] action plans this and climate [1:21:11] environmental worries that and [1:21:13] climate the other thing. And [1:21:15] we're still spending that money, [1:21:16] and we aren't really achieving [1:21:18] anything close to what is [1:21:20] promised. With we are also not [1:21:22] seeing the ice melt in the artic [1:21:26] and the polar bears drowning [1:21:28] that al gore worried about in [1:21:31] the '90s when he said we only [1:21:32] have about 10 more years to fix [1:21:34] this problem. Anyway, it's a [1:21:35] long way of saying we've wasted [1:21:36] an enormous amount of time on [1:21:37] this. That said, as a realist [1:21:42] and being in california, I [1:21:44] recognize we need to have a [1:21:46] climate action plan in order to [1:21:48] get the funding that is [1:21:50] absolutely critical to this [1:21:53] government doing the basic [1:21:56] function it is needs to do. We [1:21:57] will not be eligible for grants [1:21:59] without it. And so I am not [1:22:02] prepared to vote against the [1:22:04] entire climate action plan. [1:22:06] Though, I believe it is a [1:22:07] grotesque waste of money, it is [1:22:09] the game the state forces us to [1:22:11] play. That said, I think [1:22:14] there's a lot to recommend the [1:22:17] views of our business champions [1:22:20] who are here, who recognize that [1:22:24] business and people being able [1:22:28] to do business for themselves [1:22:30] means the government needs to do [1:22:32] less. We can be smaller and be [1:22:34] more responsive. And that said, [1:22:37] that is a long way of saying we [1:22:40] ought to take them at their [1:22:41] word, we ought to do the minimum [1:22:43] that we need to do to play the [1:22:45] game the state forces us to [1:22:47] play, and with that, I move [1:22:50] approval the climate action plan [1:22:53] with the complete removal of [1:22:55] chapter 4, community climate [1:22:57] action. That's my motion. [1:22:58] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:23:03] supervisor nguyen. [1:23:05] >>janet nguyen: sorry. And I'll [1:23:07] second that. I agree. I mean, [1:23:10] we do -- I've been in [1:23:12] sacramento. I've heard all of [1:23:15] these arguments. I've been in [1:23:16] many, many hearings as well, [1:23:18] and, you know, I continue to ask [1:23:20] the question what has the [1:23:22] results been for us in [1:23:24] sacramento? And there's never [1:23:26] been an answer. The answer has [1:23:28] always been, well, we just gotta [1:23:29] set a very high bar and [1:23:33] hopefully we'll get there [1:23:34] eventually. So, I mean, but, [1:23:37] you know, in the end, we all [1:23:39] here want -- as a county, want [1:23:41] to reduce green house gas [1:23:42] emission. But the goals we [1:23:46] pursue needs to be in a way that [1:23:48] also preserves the economic [1:23:49] competitiveness, supports job [1:23:51] creation and also avoids any new [1:23:53] regulatory uncertainty. And so, [1:23:56] you know, as drafted, the [1:23:59] community section raise [1:24:03] significant concerns because it [1:24:05] focuses on an area where the [1:24:06] county has limited jurisdiction, [1:24:08] including private vehicles, [1:24:11] privately-owned buildings and [1:24:11] land use decisions overseen by [1:24:13] other agency. And I know that [1:24:16] it says volunteer and [1:24:18] non-bind -- voluntary and [1:24:21] non-binding, however, the [1:24:22] section establishes countywide [1:24:24] goals without clear [1:24:26] implementation parameters [1:24:27] creating risk of interpretation [1:24:29] beyond existing state law. And [1:24:33] so this action plan is intended [1:24:36] to outline aspirational goals, [1:24:40] not just create mandates. So [1:24:42] I'm concerned about that line [1:24:44] that's becoming very blurry. [1:24:46] And so, you know, is especially [1:24:47] if there's a lack of clarity, we [1:24:51] need -- I mean, what will end up [1:24:53] is that it will be duplicate, it [1:24:55] will be inconsistent went [1:24:56] requirements, increase [1:24:57] developmental costs, add [1:24:59] uncertainties for businesses and [1:25:01] housing providers in our [1:25:03] incorporated areas at a time [1:25:05] when we need housing to be [1:25:06] affordable in orange county. [1:25:08] And the cost of living is [1:25:10] unbearable. At this point for [1:25:13] anybody who lives in orange [1:25:15] county and so we as a county, [1:25:18] when we set our policy, when [1:25:20] it's countywide, yes we're [1:25:23] saying incorporate, but we're [1:25:25] also saying wink-wink, [1:25:28] countrywide, meaning cities and [1:25:29] everybody else also have to [1:25:31] adhere to our mandate, [1:25:39] countywide. So again, we can't [1:25:41] have duplicate, you know, areas [1:25:44] and unintended consequence asks [1:25:48] not really understanding [1:25:49] where -- what is mandate, what [1:25:51] is volunteer, as well. [1:25:52] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:25:54] vice-chair foley. [1:25:55] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [1:25:56] you, MR. CHAIRMAN. [1:26:01] You know, I'm not really seeing [1:26:03] these sections that have been [1:26:04] referred to in the climate [1:26:06] action plan itself. So there's [1:26:08] nothing in the climate action [1:26:10] plan that mandates anything on [1:26:11] any private developer. We had [1:26:15] representatives from the bi a [1:26:16] and the business council on our [1:26:19] task force. We've talked to [1:26:21] them multiple times about this, [1:26:23] and there's no mandates included [1:26:26] in this climate action plan. [1:26:29] And then respectfully we cannot [1:26:33] remove this section that they're [1:26:35] referring to because we will not [1:26:37] qualify for any grants. So [1:26:40] that's the critical component [1:26:42] here. And if for no other [1:26:45] reason the roadmap that has been [1:26:48] created here is to conserve [1:26:51] costs for the taxpayers, if for [1:26:54] know other reason, even if you [1:26:55] don't believe climate change is [1:26:57] real, the measures, the roadmap, [1:27:02] the landfill analysis is all [1:27:06] intended to reduce cost and so [1:27:08] make us competitive for grants. [1:27:10] So I will not be supporting the [1:27:12] motion. [1:27:14] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:27:15] you. Supervisor wagner. [1:27:17] >>don wagner: I want to respond [1:27:17] a little bit. The fact that bi [1:27:23] a and/or ocbc and/or any other [1:27:23] business groups were in the [1:27:26] discussions and at the table and [1:27:28] on the panels and involved here [1:27:29] doesn't mean that they were [1:27:32] listened to. And the resulting [1:27:34] document and their positions on [1:27:37] it suggest that they weren't [1:27:39] listened to. And I think we do [1:27:42] a disservice to -- not just to [1:27:44] those organizations but to the [1:27:46] vast business community in [1:27:48] orange county, that is so [1:27:51] important to us, that has been [1:27:53] so burdened by just trying to [1:27:56] exist in this state, that the [1:27:59] unaffordability issue supervisor [1:28:02] nguyen raised has come to the [1:28:03] forefront for so many people. [1:28:05] We aren't doing any favors to [1:28:07] everyone who is struggling with [1:28:09] unaffordability by rushing pell [1:28:13] mel into this and ignoring. [1:28:14] witness the leerings they sent [1:28:17] to us. They were at the table, [1:28:19] but they got ignored and felt [1:28:21] the need to do these letters. [1:28:23] And that's why, slow it down, [1:28:26] we'll still get the grants. [1:28:27] We've got what we need to do, [1:28:30] the bare minimum in what [1:28:32] survives my motion, the climate [1:28:35] action plan, just not this [1:28:39] unthought-through potentially [1:28:40] quite damaging section 4. I [1:28:42] urge support for the motion. [1:28:44] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:28:45] supervisor sarmiento. [1:28:46] >>vincente sarmiento: thank you, [1:28:46] MR. Chair. I see somebody from [1:28:49] waste and recycling. Is it tara [1:28:50] that's here? If you could come [1:28:53] up if you don't mind. And as [1:28:56] you're coming up, if you could [1:28:57] answer sort of the question [1:29:01] buffers, which is what would it [1:29:02] do -- what would the impact be [1:29:04] from removing this section from [1:29:06] the climate action plan. [1:29:08] >>speaker: good morning. I'm [1:29:09] tara, deputy director of [1:29:11] sustainability. What would it [1:29:14] do, to answer your question, [1:29:17] obviously we brought what we [1:29:18] thought was, you know, finished [1:29:20] product. I will say just to [1:29:22] answer some of the comments that [1:29:24] were raised, this is not being [1:29:26] included in the general plan. [1:29:27] There are no plans to put it in [1:29:29] the general plan at all. Any [1:29:31] document that's out on the [1:29:33] general plan right now through [1:29:34] public works I would encourage [1:29:36] them to comment on that, as [1:29:38] well, if there is a reference to [1:29:39] the cap. Beyond that, the part [1:29:43] that I would probably be worried [1:29:44] about losing is the references [1:29:46] to environmental justice. We [1:29:48] have a lot of mandates related [1:29:50] to environmental justice. I'm [1:29:52] so sorry. And with that said, [1:29:56] when we go back to tie the cap [1:29:57] into the ej sections, which you [1:30:00] know most of the prop 4, 40% of [1:30:03] that funding is going to ej [1:30:04] communities, and they literally [1:30:06] ask if you can tie it back into [1:30:08] an approved plan or motion. I'm [1:30:10] not saying this guarantees us [1:30:12] the money, but if it gives us a [1:30:13] leg up, I would obviously love [1:30:16] to keep it. With that said, [1:30:18] it's at your discretion. [1:30:21] >>vincente sarmiento: so I guess [1:30:22] the -- sort of the essence of [1:30:26] your response is that, keeping [1:30:28] it in will help for future [1:30:30] funding of projects that -- [1:30:33] >>speaker: I'm trying to just [1:30:34] gives any leg up that we can [1:30:35] get, and if there's an ab-39 [1:30:38] mandate that will also include [1:30:39] environmental justice, that I'm [1:30:40] hoping that when we bring this [1:30:42] back with the ceqa document we [1:30:44] will actually cover that report [1:30:46] that's due. I completely agree, [1:30:48] there are more mandates and laws [1:30:50] than we can keep track of at [1:30:51] this point. So the more we [1:30:52] could try to cover, like we put [1:30:54] the climate vulnerability [1:30:55] assessment in to try to cover [1:30:57] that state mandate. We are [1:30:59] trying to make this as [1:31:00] cost-effective as we can. [1:31:02] >>vincente sarmiento: is there a [1:31:03] net benefit from keeping this [1:31:04] section in for future funding. [1:31:07] >>speaker: I believe so. [1:31:09] >>vincente sarmiento: thank you. [1:31:09] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:31:09] supervisor nguyen. [1:31:10] >>janet nguyen: thank you. [1:31:14] Tara, can I just foul? -- follow [1:31:15] up? So it's not -- it's certain [1:31:21] that we would not get any [1:31:22] funding. [1:31:22] >>speaker: no. No. [1:31:24] >>janet nguyen: because that's [1:31:24] what was stated up here. I [1:31:26] wanted to make sure that we're [1:31:29] hearing there's a possibility, [1:31:30] right. But that's a possibility [1:31:31] all of our grants and every time [1:31:33] we apply for any grants through [1:31:37] the state or the federal, that [1:31:39] we -- it's competitive and it's, [1:31:41] you know, it can and cannot -- [1:31:44] we might or might not get it. [1:31:46] >>speaker: correct. There's no [1:31:47] guarantee. I think what we're [1:31:49] trying to do is be as [1:31:50] cost-effective as we could. But [1:31:52] if it has to cover ab-39 and has [1:31:54] to be a component of the general [1:31:56] plan and we could supply ands [1:31:58] dies and pull out of this [1:31:59] document -- slice and dice just [1:32:00] to pull out of this document to [1:32:00] save money on reports down the [1:32:02] road, that is also something we [1:32:05] would be trying to do. We were [1:32:10] not trying to mandate anything [1:32:12] on the community side. We [1:32:15] worked with bi a quite a bit, [1:32:16] with adam at the time. We [1:32:19] really just didn't want to be [1:32:22] preclueded from having to do [1:32:22] things like outreach, the mobile [1:32:24] home parks, projects of that [1:32:26] nature if an opportunity [1:32:28] presented itself. We're not [1:32:30] trying to mandate what type of [1:32:32] boiler, heater. And the nice [1:32:35] part is we do have to bring this [1:32:36] back to you with a ceqa document [1:32:39] if it's approved today so there [1:32:40] will be time to make adjustments [1:32:43] that nature, if you think that [1:32:44] the language implies, that I do [1:32:47] want to correct that. [1:32:48] >>janet nguyen: I just think it [1:32:50] makes everybody nervous when [1:32:52] you're not sure what is [1:32:54] mandated, what isn't. I mean, a [1:32:56] lot of times when government [1:32:57] says it's not mandated, but... [1:33:00] It is on here, and wink-wink, we [1:33:04] would really like to you follow [1:33:06] it. That's what makes everybody [1:33:07] nervous. [1:33:08] >>speaker: I agree with their [1:33:09] concerns on the general plan, [1:33:10] and the nice part of being one [1:33:11] of the last counties out of the [1:33:13] gate is that you get to see what [1:33:14] happened in other jurisdictions. [1:33:16] And san diego county, I know [1:33:18] and L.A. County, did have [1:33:19] litigation because it was part [1:33:21] of their general plan, which is [1:33:23] why I really hope that the board [1:33:26] does not put it in the general [1:33:27] plan and avoid that. And I [1:33:29] think that's where the concerns [1:33:30] are coming from, from bia. I [1:33:33] don't want to speak for them, [1:33:34] but I do not want to put it in [1:33:36] the general plan unless you feel [1:33:37] otherwise. [1:33:39] >>janet nguyen: and I don't want [1:33:40] to do anything L.A. Does. [1:33:42] >>speaker: I agree, but we're on [1:33:45] the record. [1:33:45] >>janet nguyen: thank you. [1:33:46] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:33:53] supervisor wagner. [1:33:55] >>don wagner: you're back. All [1:33:56] right. So for a brief shining [1:33:59] moment, I served on the south [1:34:02] coast air quality management [1:34:03] district board, and you and I [1:34:06] had numerous conversations when [1:34:08] I was wearing that hat. Now [1:34:10] supervisor nguyen is honored and [1:34:13] privileged and I'm sure thrilled [1:34:15] to serve on that board. In [1:34:18] those conversations, I remember [1:34:20] you telling me things like, [1:34:23] we've got all of these group ins [1:34:25] out there, but they're for [1:34:26] specific communities, and we [1:34:27] don't have those communities in [1:34:29] our county. So when you're [1:34:32] talking about, well, let's just [1:34:34] faint towards words [1:34:36] environmental justice [1:34:38] communities, et cetera, but at [1:34:39] the end of the day, most of that [1:34:42] by design is going to other [1:34:47] counties because we don't fit [1:34:48] the criteria. Correct? [1:34:50] >>speaker: right. I think when [1:34:51] we were having those [1:34:52] conversations, we were talking [1:34:53] about ab-61 exphiefnts. We do [1:34:56] not. We have no ab-617, which [1:34:59] are considered the most dire [1:35:02] under environmental justice, and [1:35:04] there's only six, and there is [1:35:05] one in L.A., yes. [1:35:09] >>don wagner: right. So the [1:35:09] statutes are written by folks [1:35:10] from L.A. To benefit L.A.. They [1:35:13] don't come to orange county. [1:35:15] And so to stand there and say, [1:35:16] well, we just need to make [1:35:17] this -- say these things doesn't [1:35:21] change the reality on the [1:35:22] ground. They write the statutes [1:35:24] to benefit themselves, and we [1:35:26] have been fighting for funding [1:35:28] equity. We have been fighting [1:35:29] for this, that, and the other [1:35:30] thing and getting nowhere. I [1:35:32] just lay that out there as maybe [1:35:33] one of the reasons that we have [1:35:35] to play the game, but we don't [1:35:36] have to damage our community's [1:35:39] wholesale to play that game, [1:35:41] which is what chapter 4 does. [1:35:44] MS. Walsh, is she in the [1:35:45] audience and if I MAY... [1:35:58] All right. You've been [1:35:59] listening to all of this, and [1:36:02] I'm going to kind of give -- and [1:36:05] law school 101, never ask a [1:36:07] question you don't know the [1:36:08] answer to. I don't know the [1:36:09] answer to this. We haven't [1:36:10] talked. What is your legal view [1:36:15] of this document, chapter 4. [1:36:19] What excising chapter 4 would do [1:36:22] to our availability to get these [1:36:24] grants under all of these [1:36:25] different programs. I know [1:36:27] you've worked on it. I'm hoping [1:36:29] you might be, if not the expert, [1:36:31] the sacrificial lamb -- [1:36:36] >>speaker: I think sacrificial [1:36:37] lamb helps us better at this [1:36:39] point. I have reviewed it. [1:36:42] There's a lot of things going on [1:36:43] here. Just so everybody knows, [1:36:44] with dough have a comprehensive [1:36:45] general plan update coming up. [1:36:48] It is out for public comment. I [1:36:50] spoke to the woman from the bia [1:36:51] in the back, and we do have a [1:36:55] mitigation measure in the [1:36:56] resource management chapter that [1:36:59] mentions the climate action [1:37:00] plan. That should be stricken. [1:37:03] Because we are not making the [1:37:05] climate action plan part of the [1:37:07] general plan. In addition our [1:37:10] comprehensive general plan [1:37:11] update has to have an [1:37:13] environmental justice chapter. [1:37:15] It is does. The chapt draft has [1:37:17] an environmental justice [1:37:17] chapter. That will be the [1:37:19] chapter that complies with state [1:37:22] law because the climate action [1:37:24] plan is not part of the general [1:37:26] plan and we are not making it [1:37:28] part of the general plan, any [1:37:30] environmental justice [1:37:31] conversation in the cap will not [1:37:35] qualify us for anything because [1:37:37] we are not the doing it as part [1:37:39] the general plan. The law [1:37:40] requires that an environmental [1:37:42] justice chapter be adopted as [1:37:46] part of the general plan. The [1:37:48] general plan requires multiple [1:37:49] hearings, as you all know, and [1:37:52] that's upcoming. Right now the [1:37:56] effect of today is that you [1:37:59] would be approving a plan. This [1:38:02] is just that you are approving [1:38:03] sort of the contents of what we [1:38:06] would move forward with in an [1:38:08] environmental document for the [1:38:10] cap. The cap right now as it [1:38:13] stands before you, even if [1:38:14] approved today, cannot be [1:38:15] implemented because there are no [1:38:17] ceqa findings. So we need to [1:38:20] move forward with an ier. It is [1:38:25] my understanding, and tara and I [1:38:28] haven't talked about this in a [1:38:30] while, and I was only involved [1:38:32] in the end just to be clear, [1:38:33] that the environmental document [1:38:37] will not cover chapter 4. Okay. [1:38:40] So that's correct. So what [1:38:42] that means is that even if you [1:38:45] adopt chapter 4 today, [1:38:48] quote/unquote, it is merely a [1:38:51] planning goal-oriented document. [1:38:53] It cannot be implemented, and [1:38:55] even after this when it is [1:38:56] brought back to you, because the [1:38:58] eir will not cover chapter 4. [1:39:00] It cannot be implemented. It [1:39:08] cannot be -- it's not binding. [1:39:11] We can't use it as a -- we can't [1:39:11] use it as a baseline for ceqa [1:39:15] documents for residential [1:39:16] developments. And we can't use [1:39:22] it to impose mitigation measures [1:39:25] because an eir will not have [1:39:29] covered that chapter. [1:39:33] >>don wagner: so is that a long [1:39:35] way of saying it won't matter if [1:39:37] we excise chapter 4, give us [1:39:40] more time then to have more [1:39:41] discussions with the [1:39:43] stakeholders and get something [1:39:45] that is not only agreeable to [1:39:48] them, but to the entire board, [1:39:49] and that we could then move [1:39:50] forward with? [1:39:51] >>speaker: I am not sure about [1:39:53] the funding on chapter 4. [1:39:55] That's what I'm not sure about. [1:39:57] In my conversations with the oc [1:40:00] waste and recycling, the fund [1:40:01] has been about municipal. So [1:40:04] that's not chapter 4. But there [1:40:06] could be funding that implicates [1:40:09] chapter 4. I honestly don't [1:40:11] know. I don't know what that [1:40:16] fund something, and I'm not [1:40:16] usually involved in that, I'll [1:40:18] be honest. [1:40:21] >>chair, doug chaffee: [1:40:26] vice-chair. Foals you're [1:40:26] getting everything mixed up [1:40:27] here. Sorry. But chapter 4 is [1:40:31] not an implementation strategy [1:40:33] section. [1:40:34] >>speaker: right. [1:40:35] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: it [1:40:35] talks about promoting -- it [1:40:43] talks about reducing building [1:40:45] energy, it talks about [1:40:47] promoting, building [1:40:49] decarbonization. It talks about [1:40:51] promoting solar installation. [1:40:54] It talks about accessible ev [1:40:59] charge infrastructure. It's [1:41:05] intend as a non-mandate section [1:41:06] that covers areas of support. [1:41:11] So the language in chapter 4 [1:41:14] says the community component of [1:41:17] the cap does not include binding [1:41:20] emissions, reductions, targets [1:41:22] or required implementation [1:41:25] measures. The community [1:41:27] component instead proposes [1:41:29] measures that could reduce [1:41:31] emissions if undertaken [1:41:32] voluntarily. [1:41:33] >>speaker: correct. [1:41:35] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: and [1:41:35] the reason for this chapter is [1:41:38] intended so that we could help [1:41:41] support cities and nonprofits [1:41:45] and communities like we did [1:41:47] recently with our trump [1:41:51] administration epa grant that [1:41:54] was for our mobile home park [1:41:56] project in supervisor [1:42:00] sarmiento's district to install [1:42:00] solar. So that is what it is [1:42:03] intended for, is to be [1:42:05] supportive so that we can help [1:42:09] those communities to achieve [1:42:11] grants. And so I think that [1:42:14] it's getting all confused [1:42:16] because there's an intentional [1:42:21] attempt to confuse it, and so [1:42:24] just to be clear, what I heard [1:42:27] you saying, that is correct is [1:42:30] that chapter 4 is not a mandate [1:42:33] that is being channeled into the [1:42:36] general plan into the [1:42:38] environmental documentation for [1:42:41] purpose of development in the [1:42:43] county un-incorporated area. We [1:42:45] are not mandating what is [1:42:47] contained in the section related [1:42:50] to chapter 4. Correct. [1:42:50] >>speaker: that's correct. [1:42:52] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay. [1:42:53] So the reason for chapter 4, [1:42:55] though is that if we don't have [1:42:58] chapter 4 we will not be able to [1:43:02] be as competitive for state [1:43:07] grants, especially prop 4. And [1:43:10] that is why we included chapter [1:43:14] 4. And just. [1:43:16] Ly, we didn't ignore anyone. [1:43:18] We've had many, many [1:43:19] conversations. The concern is [1:43:23] understood, and that's why I've [1:43:26] said every single meeting over [1:43:27] the past year and a half these [1:43:29] are not mandates; these are how [1:43:32] the county creates a roadmap for [1:43:33] how we manage our own buildings, [1:43:36] especially our landfills. We [1:43:37] have three landfills that are [1:43:38] creating the most carbon [1:43:39] emissions for -- you know, [1:43:41] that's our main carbon emitter, [1:43:43] is our landfills. The priority [1:43:45] will be focused on reducing the [1:43:47] landfill emissions and our own [1:43:49] county building, saving taxpayer [1:43:51] funds by reduce energy costs. [1:43:53] Thank you. [1:43:54] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [1:43:55] right. One more time, I'm going [1:43:57] to go around and make a comment [1:43:59] of my own and call for a vote if [1:44:00] I MAY. Supervisor wagner. [1:44:01] >>don wagner: I'll just be real [1:44:03] brief. Weigh heard was chapter [1:44:04] 4 -- what I heard was chapter 4 [1:44:06] is not about grants, from our [1:44:08] lawyer. That's in municipal. [1:44:14] And therefore the grants [1:44:16] argument is sort of a red [1:44:19] herring as it applies to chapter [1:44:22] 4. [1:44:24] >>speaker: I think I said -- I'm [1:44:27] not sure about all of the grants [1:44:28] that could result from chapter [1:44:30] 4. So we do have -- if it's an [1:44:32] environmental justice grant, [1:44:34] because there was discussion [1:44:35] about environmental justice, we [1:44:37] have a specified chapter hear [1:44:38] that will meet the requirements [1:44:40] of the general plan in our draft [1:44:42] general plan. There could be [1:44:44] other grants. I'm not an [1:44:44] expert. [1:44:46] >>don wagner: chapter 4 intnt [1:44:51] grants, correct? [1:44:53] >>speaker: I think you're asking [1:44:54] me a question -- I'm -- chapter [1:45:00] 4 is not about grants because [1:45:03] chapter 4 is a cap for [1:45:05] community, you know, ghg goals. [1:45:09] >>don wagner: thank you. [1:45:10] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [1:45:10] right. I'll make my own [1:45:12] comment. I dweebt to remove [1:45:14] chapter 4. The meeting is held [1:45:18] in my district. I saw [1:45:19] tremendous enthusiasm from my be [1:45:21] constituents. There was no [1:45:23] objection to these things being [1:45:26] objected to. I read the bia [1:45:28] letter. I kind of thought, how [1:45:32] does that even relate to the [1:45:33] document? It seemed like a [1:45:34] misfire. Because when I read [1:45:36] the document, there's nothing [1:45:37] binding that would even slightly [1:45:39] impact came a building trade. [1:45:42] So my -- I'm going to vote no on [1:45:45] the motion. And at this time, [1:45:46] I'd think I'd ask the clerk to [1:45:48] call the roll. [1:45:48] >>clerk, robin stieler: [1:45:51] supervisor wagner. Supervisor [1:45:54] nguyen. [1:45:55] >>janet nguyen: yes. [1:45:57] >>clerk, robin stieler: [1:45:58] supervisor sarmiento, vices [1:45:59] chair foley. [1:46:00] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: no. [1:46:01] >>clerk, robin stieler: and [1:46:01] chair chaffee. [1:46:02] >>chair, doug chaffee: no. I [1:46:04] think I will make a motion that [1:46:05] we approve the climate action [1:46:07] plan including chapter 4. [1:46:09] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'll [1:46:10] second. [1:46:11] >>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN, [1:46:12] MAY I -- [1:46:14] >>chair, doug chaffee: we have a [1:46:14] motion on the floor. Now we can [1:46:15] discuss it. Supervisor wagner. [1:46:17] >>don wagner: I was just going [1:46:19] to ask the chair, given the [1:46:21] natural division in the [1:46:22] question, to divide chapter 4 [1:46:25] out so that we can vote on the [1:46:27] bulk of the climate action plan [1:46:28] and chapter 4 separately. [1:46:31] >>chair, doug chaffee: I would [1:46:31] be agree tonight bifurcating if [1:46:33] that's agreeable -- I see a lot [1:46:35] of nodding. Let's -- let me [1:46:38] restate the motion, that we [1:46:40] consider the plan without [1:46:42] chapter 4, and we'll come back [1:46:44] and consider chapter 4 [1:46:47] separately. MAY I have a [1:46:48] second? [1:46:52] >>janet nguyen: I'll second it. [1:46:52] >>chair, doug chaffee: the [1:46:53] motion is everything but chapter [1:46:54] 4. [1:46:56] Is there any objection to [1:46:57] that. So the plan to chapter 4 [1:47:04] is now approved. I'll make a [1:47:06] motion that chapter 4 be [1:47:08] included in the plan. [1:47:08] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [1:47:09] second. [1:47:09] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [1:47:11] seconded. Now we can talk [1:47:11] separately about chapter 4 if [1:47:13] anyone cares. Supervisor [1:47:13] nguyen. [1:47:15] >>janet nguyen: thank you, [1:47:16] MR. CHAIRMAN. If you would [1:47:19] consider for chapter 4 is just [1:47:23] removing two sections of it. [1:47:25] Which is measure c, dash e-1, [1:47:29] which sets the building decarbon [1:47:32] sayings targets that while is [1:47:35] labor voluntary, it could be [1:47:37] interpreted as future policy [1:47:39] commitments and could contblict [1:47:41] state building codes and utility [1:47:42] programs. Building retrofit [1:47:46] expectation MAY increase costs [1:47:49] and operational challenges, [1:47:51] especially for small businesses [1:47:53] and older buildings. So [1:47:55] removing measure c-e1, and the [1:47:59] second one I'm asking you to [1:48:01] consider is removing measure [1:48:06] c-m2 which establishes the [1:48:08] vehicle mileage travel [1:48:12] reduction. That targets -- it's [1:48:16] largely outside the county's [1:48:19] direct control, and really could [1:48:22] negatively impact our business [1:48:23] access workforce mobility and [1:48:25] goods movement. So referencing [1:48:27] to come to this, it would [1:48:31] introduce land use policy [1:48:32] directions through a climate [1:48:33] plan rather than utilizing an [1:48:36] established plan in process. [1:48:39] Vmt has been in discussion in [1:48:41] sacramento since I was up there [1:48:43] for probably the full decade, [1:48:46] and so I think that we here at [1:48:49] county shouldn't be including [1:48:51] that in our section. And so if [1:48:55] you would consider removing [1:48:57] those two, I can support the [1:49:00] rest of chapter 4. [1:49:08] >>chair, doug chaffee: can I be [1:49:08] clear where that's in the plan. [1:49:15] >>janet nguyen: so c-e1, which [1:49:16] is -- [1:49:17] >>chair, doug chaffee: you can [1:49:18] give me a page number. [1:49:24] >>janet nguyen: page 95. [1:49:25] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [1:49:25] you. Vice change comments. [1:49:28] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [1:49:28] you, MR. CHAIRMAN. I need [1:49:32] change my vote on the prior [1:49:34] because I want to be against the [1:49:36] cap. The way that the vote got [1:49:38] set up, I voted against the [1:49:39] climate action plan, which [1:49:41] obviously I don't want to do [1:49:42] that because I spent two years [1:49:43] of my life helping to develop [1:49:45] it. So I need to change my vote [1:49:47] to a yes on the original motion. [1:49:50] I just was not in favor of [1:49:52] removing chapter 4. [1:49:54] >>vincente sarmiento: I'll move [1:49:55] to reconsider the initial vote [1:49:57] on the balance of the cap plan [1:50:00] without chapter 4. [1:50:02] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [1:50:03] you. Second. [1:50:04] >>chair, doug chaffee: wait a [1:50:04] minute. I got lost in all that. [1:50:08] We're talking separately about [1:50:10] the -- chapter 4. [1:50:12] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I [1:50:12] understand. But the original [1:50:14] motion was the climate action [1:50:17] plan without chapter 4, which I [1:50:19] voted against. But now because [1:50:21] of how it got set up, now I'm [1:50:24] against the cap as a result, [1:50:26] because you just added the [1:50:27] chapter 4 into the original [1:50:31] motion. So it made it so that I [1:50:34] voted against the cap, not [1:50:35] intentionally. [1:50:37] Unintentionally. [1:50:38] >>chair, doug chaffee: well, I [1:50:38] didn't interpret it that way. [1:50:40] We simply voted for the plan [1:50:43] itself. Clearly, I thought with [1:50:46] the understanding that we would [1:50:48] consider adding chapter 4 [1:50:51] separately. That's what we're [1:50:52] doing. [1:50:53] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: so [1:50:53] can I just re --- I would like [1:50:55] to vote in favor of the original [1:50:57] motion because I want to be in [1:50:58] favor of the cap. [1:51:00] >>chair, doug chaffee: of [1:51:00] chapter 4. [1:51:02] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I [1:51:02] support chapter 4. I support [1:51:04] the whole cap as presented. [1:51:07] >>chair, doug chaffee: so you [1:51:07] don't support the bifurcation; [1:51:09] is that what it is, where we [1:51:11] separated chapter 4 from the [1:51:13] plan? [1:51:16] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I [1:51:17] support -- I did not support [1:51:19] removing chapter 4. And I'm [1:51:23] just trying to make sure my vote [1:51:24] is in favor of the cap. I'm not [1:51:26] sure what we voted that the [1:51:26] point. [1:51:29] >>chair, doug chaffee: why don't [1:51:30] we restate the motion, if that's [1:51:34] where we're at, that we simply [1:51:38] approve the plan as presented, [1:51:40] including chapter 4. Is that [1:51:42] where you're at. [1:51:43] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: yes. [1:51:44] Second. [1:51:44] >>janet nguyen: we bifurcated [1:51:45] it. [1:51:46] >>chair, doug chaffee: I know. [1:51:47] But I think the result is the [1:51:48] same if we -- if you move [1:51:51] chapter 4 into the plan. [1:51:55] >>vincente sarmiento: I think [1:51:55] the vice-chair simply wants to [1:51:58] revote on the first part of the [1:52:00] bifurcation, which is on the [1:52:01] plan without chapter 4, because [1:52:03] she voted no and wants to vote [1:52:05] in favor of it. [1:52:06] >>janet nguyen: so in other [1:52:08] words, what I'm hearing, MADAM [1:52:12] Vice-chair, that we just need to [1:52:13] reconsider -- [1:52:14] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: is [1:52:14] there a way to clear the board? [1:52:15] >>chair, doug chaffee: we can [1:52:19] make a notion reconsider. Ask [1:52:20] counsel to clarify, if he can. [1:52:22] >>leon page: I think typically [1:52:26] the board is allowable of these [1:52:28] kinds of requests. And I think [1:52:30] there's just unanimous support [1:52:31] for the climate action plan [1:52:32] without chapter 4. [1:52:34] >>chair, doug chaffee: yes [1:52:35] paidgesz all of the members [1:52:35] support that. The controversy [1:52:37] concerns chapter 4, and I think [1:52:39] that's where the board had the [1:52:40] division of the vote, and now [1:52:43] there's been a request by [1:52:44] supervisor nguyen to remove two [1:52:46] action items in chapter 4. [1:52:47] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [1:52:48] that's not answering the [1:52:48] questions. [1:52:49] >>leon page: I think the clerk [1:52:51] can record that all five members [1:52:54] support the climate action plan [1:52:56] without chapter 4. And that's [1:52:58] what I think supervisor foley is [1:52:59] trying to get to. Supervisor [1:53:02] foley also supports chapter 4, [1:53:04] and that's where we will [1:53:05] eventually end up. [1:53:05] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [1:53:05] you. [1:53:08] >>chair, doug chaffee: okay. So [1:53:08] I'm going to stand by the [1:53:11] bifurcation, and we're now [1:53:13] considering chapter 4 as part [1:53:17] the climb ate -- climate action [1:53:18] plan. [1:53:19] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: yep. [1:53:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [1:53:23] right. Any further discussion [1:53:24] on that or shall we call another [1:53:25] roll at this point. [1:53:27] >>janet nguyen: I'm so confused. [1:53:30] I'm sorry. I'm confused. So [1:53:32] our original vote for 81, the [1:53:39] climate action plan without 4, [1:53:42] was 4/1. [1:53:43] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: it's [1:53:46] now 5-0. And then he added back [1:53:47] in chapter 4, and you've asked [1:53:49] for changes to chapter 4, which [1:53:51] there isn't support in the maker [1:53:53] of the motion for that. [1:53:54] >>janet nguyen: so the new vote [1:53:56] is just on chapter 4 then. [1:53:56] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [1:53:58] adding it in -- so it's page 65 [1:54:08] in also page 100.. I'm [1:54:12] asking -- [1:54:13] >>janet nguyen: also on page [1:54:13] 100, I'm asking you to consider [1:54:14] moving these two items off of [1:54:16] chapter 4 and I will be [1:54:29] supporting the rest. [1:54:29] >>chair, doug chaffee: are there [1:54:30] any other comments? I see the [1:54:32] point that you're making on e1. [1:54:37] I didn't read the next page, [1:54:37] but... [1:54:40] >>janet nguyen: page 100 is the [1:54:42] vehicles miles travel. [1:55:03] >>chair, doug chaffee: that one [1:55:04] I would be supportive of [1:55:08] removing, c-e3, but not the [1:55:13] other one, I think that has some [1:55:14] advantage. It's just a planning [1:55:16] consideration. That one. And I [1:55:19] think -- bifurcation to me is an [1:55:22] economic consideration. [1:55:24] >>janet nguyen: so c-e1 is [1:55:26] the -- [1:55:31] >>chair, doug chaffee: isn't [1:55:31] that on -- that's 97, sorry. [1:55:34] >>janet nguyen: 95. [1:55:34] >>chair, doug chaffee: I'm [1:55:38] sorry. E1 on page 95, I would [1:55:39] be agreeable that that be [1:55:42] removed. [1:55:43] >>janet nguyen: what about c-m2? [1:55:49] , which is page 100. [1:55:56] >>chair, doug chaffee: no. I [1:55:56] think that's okay. I would [1:56:01] leave that. But I think the [1:56:02] electrification goes with the [1:56:04] concept of all electric water [1:56:06] heaters and all that kind of [1:56:08] stuff that made no sense. [1:56:09] . [1:56:11] So I think electrification is [1:56:14] more of an economic concept to [1:56:17] me. Not necessarily a climate [1:56:19] one. You get there through [1:56:20] economics, I think. [1:56:20] >>janet nguyen: but remember, [1:56:22] MR. CHAIRMAN, the vehicles miles [1:56:24] travel is also economic. [1:56:29] Currently those who has gas car [1:56:34] paying gas taxes. While those [1:56:35] who has electric cars are not [1:56:36] paying the tax -- the gas tax. [1:56:41] And what you're going to end up [1:56:43] with is when we implement [1:56:45] statewide vehicles miles travel, [1:56:49] which means those whoa has gas [1:56:50] car would not only be paying [1:56:52] sales tax on the gasoline [1:56:56] they're pumping into their car, [1:56:58] but they're also now going to be [1:56:59] paying vehicles miles travel [1:57:01] while the electrical cars folks [1:57:03] are only paying for the vehicles [1:57:04] miles travel and not the gas [1:57:07] sales tax. So I think it's also [1:57:10] economic. And it does hit [1:57:12] individuals and families, you [1:57:15] know, very hard, and that's one [1:57:17] of my arguments in the last, you [1:57:19] know, several years in [1:57:21] sacramento when we talked about [1:57:23] the vehicles miles travel. And [1:57:25] so I think that removing both of [1:57:26] them would really -- I mean, it [1:57:31] also allows those -- I mean, for [1:57:35] us to continuing to watch that [1:57:37] sacramento is doing. They've [1:57:39] got hearings, talking about the [1:57:40] vehicle miles travel as well [1:57:42] this year. And watching what [1:57:45] they do and how it's going to be [1:57:47] implemented statewide would be [1:57:48] much more helpful to us than to [1:57:50] put it into our action. [1:57:53] >>chair, doug chaffee: I think [1:57:53] the vehicle miles plan can be [1:57:56] done different ways. Maybe a [1:57:58] different rate for electric cars [1:57:59] than gasoline cars for example. [1:58:01] I think that's a concept that [1:58:03] I'd like to see explored. [1:58:07] >>chair, doug chaffee: I would [1:58:11] demand the motion to approve by [1:58:15] 4 by deleting that first item on [1:58:21] page 95 that you're referring to [1:58:23] if the second is agreeable to [1:58:25] that. If the second is not [1:58:26] agreeable, then we don't move [1:58:28] forward. [1:58:30] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: can [1:58:30] someone clarify what section [1:58:32] we're deleting? I don't have [1:58:33] page numbers on mine. [1:58:36] >>chair, doug chaffee: page 95. [1:58:40] >>janet nguyen: c-e1. [1:58:42] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: c-e1 [1:58:43] as I understand it says provide [1:58:45] technical assistance to private [1:58:47] building owners and tenants [1:58:49] regarding building [1:58:50] decarbonization and explore [1:58:52] opportunities to connect [1:58:53] building owners with proficient [1:58:55] contractors. That's what you [1:58:56] want to remove? I don't [1:58:59] understand. [1:58:59] >>leon page: there are actually [1:59:00] three action items on page 95. [1:59:02] >>chair, doug chaffee: page 95. [1:59:06] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: c-e1 [1:59:07] says what I just read. Which [1:59:11] section are you asking to [1:59:12] remove? [1:59:17] >>janet nguyen: c-e1, e-1, dash [1:59:17] 2, and dash 3. [1:59:19] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: dash [1:59:20] 2 and 3 is what you want to [1:59:21] remove. [1:59:23] >>janet nguyen: all three of [1:59:23] them. At this point -- [1:59:25] MR. Chair, I appreciate -- [1:59:28] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: can I [1:59:28] finish? So c-e1.2, I just want [1:59:33] to make sure we're all on the [1:59:33] same page, says work with local [1:59:36] utilities and or the southern [1:59:39] california regional energy [1:59:41] network to promote replacement [1:59:43] of natural gas appliances [1:59:45] through education and financial [1:59:47] incentives. That's assuming [1:59:49] that those are required by the [1:59:51] state at some point. We're not [1:59:53] mandating it, we're just saying [1:59:55] if that's required, work with [1:59:57] locals to help them. So is that [2:00:00] what you want to remove? Is [2:00:02] that a yes or a no? I just want [2:00:04] to go through and make sure I [2:00:05] know what you want to remove. [2:00:06] >>janet nguyen: I said all of [2:00:07] e-1. [2:00:08] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: so [2:00:09] the next part of e-1.3 is launch [2:00:13] educational campaigns for [2:00:15] residents, businesses and [2:00:17] building owners and managers on [2:00:19] decarbon sayings and/or [2:00:21] electrification programs and [2:00:23] incentives offered by the local [2:00:25] utilities and or so cal rye n, [2:00:28] which is the regional -- [2:00:29] southern california regional [2:00:31] energy network. Is that what [2:00:33] else you want to remove. [2:00:34] >>janet nguyen: all of e-1. [2:00:36] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: and [2:00:39] the vehicle miles traveled, the [2:00:46] recommendation is to evaluate [2:00:48] opportunities to support and [2:00:50] expand active transportation [2:00:51] infrastructure to major [2:00:54] destinations within [2:00:55] un-incorporated areas, and the [2:00:58] second goal is to promote and/or [2:01:01] incentivize transit oriented, [2:01:03] mixed use, compact development [2:01:05] through permit streamlining and [2:01:07] incentives. That's not really [2:01:09] about vehicle miles traveled as [2:01:12] a tax, as it's been described. [2:01:14] It's more about how do we create [2:01:16] infrastructure. So I would not [2:01:18] support the motion. I would not [2:01:21] support the request to remove [2:01:23] those because -- [2:01:23] >>chair, doug chaffee: either of [2:01:24] them. [2:01:25] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: well, [2:01:25] I don't know what -- we're going [2:01:27] to remove the section -- I'd [2:01:29] like to hear why we need to [2:01:32] remove the section about [2:01:33] providing technical assistance [2:01:35] and working with the utility [2:01:37] companies. Don't we want to do [2:01:42] that. [2:01:43] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's [2:01:46] today to into this [2:01:47] electrification issue, so... [2:01:50] >>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN, [2:01:52] MAY I -- [2:01:54] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: it's [2:01:54] not requiring -- look, I have a [2:01:57] gas stove. I know people [2:01:59] have -- there's like a lot of [2:02:00] debate about that. And that's [2:02:04] why we did mandate anything like [2:02:05] that. And so I don't think this [2:02:09] section does what has been [2:02:11] described. [2:02:11] >>chair, doug chaffee: well, [2:02:11] it's strange, connecting a [2:02:14] building with proficient [2:02:16] contractors. That's almost like [2:02:18] an advertisement for who is [2:02:21] profession. [2:02:23] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: well, [2:02:23] I can understand why that would [2:02:24] be a concern. [2:02:26] >>chair, doug chaffee: yeah. I [2:02:26] don't want to vote a contractor [2:02:29] particularly. [2:02:29] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: can [2:02:29] we keep the provide technical [2:02:31] assistance to private building [2:02:33] owners. [2:02:34] >>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN, [2:02:35] can I say -- [2:02:35] >>chair, doug chaffee: well, [2:02:35] let's -- [2:02:36] >>janet nguyen: it might help [2:02:39] you to have not -- [2:02:42] >>chair, doug chaffee: okay. [2:02:48] Well, let's -- there is a [2:02:49] request now from removing two [2:02:52] items, and I don't see any [2:02:56] support for removing the one [2:02:57] concerning the vehicle miles [2:03:01] expiration. The first one, [2:03:02] though, building [2:03:03] decarbonization, I find that [2:03:06] difficult myself. All right. [2:03:10] Let's see if we can work through [2:03:11] this. Supervisor -- vice-chair, [2:03:15] any further comments? [2:03:17] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I [2:03:17] just would be open to hearing [2:03:19] how you might want to change [2:03:20] some of that because I think [2:03:21] what I hear you saying is that [2:03:23] you're concerned about the -- us [2:03:26] advertising. So I get that, and [2:03:28] that I can accept. But I guess [2:03:32] my concern is that most of the [2:03:34] rest of this is more sort of [2:03:37] educational, helping people to [2:03:39] find out what incentives are [2:03:41] offered by other utilities, [2:03:43] connecting residents, and [2:03:46] private businesses to utility [2:03:49] incentives. So if they have to [2:03:52] do something different in their [2:03:54] development or if they want to, [2:03:56] for that matter. So that would [2:03:58] be -- if we want to remove the [2:04:00] language, explore opportunities [2:04:03] to connect building owners with [2:04:05] proficient contractors, would [2:04:08] that satisfy your concerns? [2:04:10] >>chair, doug chaffee: well, I [2:04:11] think we're getting a little bit [2:04:12] into the weeds here a little too [2:04:14] much. [2:04:15] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [2:04:15] okay. [2:04:16] >>chair, doug chaffee: I think [2:04:17] if you want to come back later [2:04:18] with some rewording of this [2:04:21] whole section, that's possible. [2:04:25] It doesn't have to be the end of [2:04:26] it today. [2:04:27] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay. [2:04:28] >>chair, doug chaffee: but I [2:04:29] found the whole thrust of it is [2:04:32] leading to electrification when [2:04:35] there are other economic [2:04:36] opportunities that MAY need to [2:04:41] be considered. So -- and I'm [2:04:44] also going to try to find some [2:04:45] grounds to get this done. And I [2:04:47] find -- so, anyway... [2:04:51] We have a motion that so far is [2:04:55] just to add the section 4. [2:05:02] There's a suggestion for a [2:05:04] change from supervisor nguyen. [2:05:06] I'm agreeable to that. I did [2:05:08] not -- not to this mileage [2:05:10] thing, but to the other part. I [2:05:14] didn't hear an agreement from my [2:05:16] second. So I don't know where [2:05:17] we are. Right now we have a [2:05:20] motion to simply add section 4 [2:05:25] PRESIDENT Been moved and [2:05:25] seconded. That's where we're at [2:05:31] at. I guess we'll call -- and I [2:05:37] think we can address this other [2:05:38] thing later maybe? I don't [2:05:42] know. I'm troubled when I read [2:05:42] through that thing that [2:05:45] supervisor nguyen was pointing [2:05:46] out as not a good idea. [2:05:53] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'd [2:05:53] be happy to work with you on [2:05:54] some changes to the language if [2:05:56] we could just get it passed [2:05:56] today and then we could maybe [2:05:57] bring it back, if that's [2:05:58] agreeable. [2:05:58] >>chair, doug chaffee: the [2:05:59] alternative is simply to [2:06:01] continue consideration of [2:06:03] section 4 to the next meeting. [2:06:05] Would that be agreeable? [2:06:06] >>janet nguyen: I'll second [2:06:06] that. [2:06:07] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'd [2:06:10] rather just condition this one [2:06:12] page that is at issue if we're [2:06:14] going to continue anything. [2:06:16] >>chair, doug chaffee: so you'd [2:06:17] be agreeable at this time for [2:06:20] removing that item from -- [2:06:20] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [2:06:22] continuing this one item. [2:06:25] >>chair, doug chaffee: okay. So [2:06:29] that item c-e1 through 3 will [2:06:31] not be part of section 4 that [2:06:33] we're voting on now. [2:06:34] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: yeah. [2:06:35] And then we'll continue that to [2:06:36] the next meeting. [2:06:36] >>chair, doug chaffee: for [2:06:38] further discussion all right. [2:06:39] Got it. All right. Any [2:06:42] objection to that motion? [2:06:46] Clerk, please call the roll. [2:06:52] >>clerk, robin stieler: chair [2:06:52] chaffee. [2:06:55] >>chair, doug chaffee: aye. [2:06:58] >>clerk, robin stieler: [2:06:59] supervisor foley. [2:07:01] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [2:07:01] isle. [2:07:04] >>clerk, robin stieler: [2:07:06] supervisor nguyen. [2:07:08] >>janet nguyen: abstain. [2:07:09] >>clerk, robin stieler: [2:07:10] supervisor sarmiento. [2:07:11] >>vincente sarmiento: yes, but [2:07:30] it's c hi e1, ce-.2, c dash e1.3 [2:07:31] e1.3. [2:07:31] S. [2:07:33] >>janet nguyen: MADAM Clerk, you [2:07:40] can make mine no?. [2:07:42] >>chair, doug chaffee: so no, [2:07:45] three yeses and an abstention. [2:07:47] >>clerk, robin stieler: two [2:07:47] NOs. [2:07:48] >>chair, doug chaffee: so [2:07:53] section 4, absent the c-e.1, 2, [2:07:55] and 3 are now part of the [2:07:56] climate action plan and we'll [2:07:57] come back and further discuss [2:07:59] this and massage it a little bit [2:08:00] and see if we can make more [2:08:01] sense out of it. [2:08:02] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [2:08:02] you, MR. CHAIRMAN. [2:08:04] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [2:08:12] right. Now please go on to item [2:08:14] 22. [2:08:15] >>clerk, robin stieler: 22. [2:08:16] Under county executive office- [2:08:17] approve grant [2:08:18] applications/awards submitted by [2:08:19] health care agency, oc community [2:08:20] resources and oc waste & [2:08:24] recycling in 2/24/26 grant [2:08:24] report and other actions as [2:08:27] recommended; and adopt [2:08:27] resolution authorizing oc waste [2:08:29] & recycling director or designee [2:08:31] to negotiate, execute [2:08:33] agreements, related documents [2:08:34] and amendments with california [2:08:36] coastal commission for whale [2:08:38] tail grants program ($50,000) [2:08:39] And MR. Chair, we received one [2:08:41] request to speak on agenda item [2:08:42] 22. [2:08:43] >>chair, doug chaffee: please [2:08:43] call the speaker. [2:08:57] >>clerk, robin stieler: donora. [2:08:57] >>chair, doug chaffee: [2:08:59] apparently not present. [2:09:00] >>clerk, robin stieler: she's [2:09:01] right here. [2:09:02] >>chair, doug chaffee: come on [2:09:02] over then. Please come to the [2:09:04] podium. [2:09:13] >>speaker: good morning, [2:09:14] everyone. I guess you guys know [2:09:16] who I am, and I want to speak on [2:09:20] item 22, but I also -- since [2:09:22] english is my second language, I [2:09:25] want to stand a little bit that [2:09:27] I'm very disappointed that you [2:09:29] as federal government, who [2:09:31] brought me here as a kid, I was [2:09:34] 7 years old, supposed to be [2:09:35] protected under federal statute [2:09:37] because we were brought as [2:09:38] refugee, not escape from cuba. [2:09:41] Federal government brought us [2:09:43] here. And I've worked 40-plus [2:09:45] years and paid taxes to see [2:09:48] illegal aliens taken over [2:09:49] housing in orange county. I've [2:09:54] never drink, done drugs, neither [2:09:54] smoke. My family from florida [2:09:56] is very disappointed including [2:09:58] in cuba, so they're sending my [2:10:01] alien number to washington D.C. [2:10:03] To see what the heck went wrong [2:10:05] here. I should not be in my [2:10:12] cart, and illegal aliens have [2:10:14] taken over housing. I've been [2:10:15] coming to the board since 2019 [2:10:18] through the present, and a lot [2:10:20] of great officers are friends of [2:10:23] mine, including the chief [2:10:27] barnes. And it's an [2:10:28] embarrassment that you guys have [2:10:31] not done to anything about it to [2:10:33] tell the housing authority go [2:10:35] ahead and give her an emergency [2:10:36] voucher, run into church, taking [2:10:36] shower. [2:10:40] >>chair, doug chaffee: this has [2:10:40] nothing to do with that. [2:10:41] >>speaker: but I would like to [2:10:42] make an appointment with you. I [2:10:44] was told you are the chair. [2:10:46] >>chair, doug chaffee: you can [2:10:46] make an appointment through the [2:10:47] appropriate channels. But this [2:10:50] has nothing to do with that. [2:10:52] >>speaker: thank you. Very [2:10:54] stressed out. But on topping, [2:10:58] no. 22, since you say community [2:11:02] resource -- on topic... [2:11:03] Maybe the resource community [2:11:06] could focus on illegal immigrant [2:11:09] when they making housing and not [2:11:12] depriving me of housing [2:11:13] assistant, hopefully I can make [2:11:16] an I point with you, the chair, [2:11:22] because charles has refused to [2:11:22] make me an appointment with [2:11:24] supervisor janet nguyen, and I [2:11:28] was told that I have the right [2:11:30] to make an appointment with the [2:11:31] a supervisor because he have not [2:11:33] done anything for me, just ask [2:11:40] andrew do and chief crist. [2:11:41] >>chair, doug chaffee: you need [2:11:42] to address the item or sit down, [2:11:44] please. [2:11:45] >>speaker: thank you. This is [2:11:46] the item that -- like I say, [2:11:49] this is my first time being here [2:11:51] since I was a kid, and I had to [2:11:53] basically talk to you guys, [2:11:57] legislative policymakers, to see [2:11:58] why people that are illegal are [2:12:00] take over housing in orange [2:12:01] county. [2:12:02] >>chair, doug chaffee: again, [2:12:03] this item has nothing to do with [2:12:04] that. [2:12:05] >>speaker: so when it has [2:12:06] something to do, can you explain [2:12:07] this in english, is my second [2:12:08] language, community resource. [2:12:11] >>chair, doug chaffee: this has [2:12:11] to do with grant applications. [2:12:14] They're listed in the agenda. [2:12:17] >>speaker: well, I pulled out my [2:12:18] application for housing and [2:12:19] nothing happened yet. [2:12:20] >>chair, doug chaffee: that's [2:12:20] not this. Your time is up. [2:12:22] Thank you. [2:12:23] >>speaker: thank you. Have a [2:12:24] great day, and looking forward [2:12:25] to making an appointment with [2:12:26] you. [2:12:28] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [2:12:28] the item. [2:12:29] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [2:12:30] seconded. I would note there is [2:12:32] grant money here possibly for [2:12:35] prop 36 funding, something that [2:12:37] the people voted in, and they -- [2:12:39] and sacramento seems to ignore. [2:12:41] Here's a chance for some [2:12:43] funding, and we do take that [2:12:46] seriously. All right. It's [2:12:52] included PRESIDENT Been [2:12:52] approved. Item 23 has been [2:12:55] deleted. So item 24, please. [2:12:57] >>clerk, robin stieler: 24. [2:13:00] Under county executive office, [2:13:01] approve type 2 work order number [2:13:03] ncy7-009 under contract [2:13:05] ma-017-19010750 with science [2:13:06] applications international [2:13:07] corporation for managed services [2:13:09] network, voice and security [2:13:10] services to support firewall [2:13:12] system migration for john wayne [2:13:14] airport, 3/25/26-11/10/26 [2:13:16] ($225,200); and authorize county [2:13:16] chief information officer or [2:13:18] designee to execute work order. [2:13:19] We have no requests to speak on [2:13:21] agenda item 24. [2:13:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [2:13:23] all-district item. [2:13:23] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [2:13:24] the item. [2:13:26] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [2:13:26] objection? Item 24 is approved. [2:13:29] 25, please. [2:13:29] >>clerk, robin stieler: 25. [2:13:30] Under county executive office, [2:13:31] approve amendment 3 to renew [2:13:32] contract ma-017-22011093 with [2:13:33] southwest strategies, llc for [2:13:35] spent fuel solutions management [2:13:36] services at san onofre nuclear [2:13:39] generating station, 3/22/26- [2:13:39] 3/21/27 ($100,000; cumulative [2:13:40] total $500,000); and authorize [2:13:41] county procurement officer or [2:13:43] deputized designee to execute amendment. [2:13:44] We have no requests to speak on [2:13:49] agenda item 25. [2:13:49] >>chair, doug chaffee: is [2:13:50] district 5. [2:13:51] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [2:13:53] the item. [2:13:55] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [2:13:56] objection? Item 25 is approved. [2:14:00] 26, please. [2:14:00] >>clerk, robin stieler: 26. [2:14:00] Under county executive office, [2:14:01] approve 2026 federal community [2:14:03] project funding requests. And we [2:14:05] have no requests to speak on [2:14:06] agenda item 26. [2:14:08] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [2:14:09] all-district item. [2:14:10] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [2:14:11] the item. [2:14:12] >>chair, doug chaffee: seeing no [2:14:13] objection, item is approved. [2:14:16] 27, please. [2:14:16] >>clerk, robin stieler: 27. [2:14:17] Under county executive office, [2:14:18] approve amendment 3 to contract [2:14:19] ma-017-22010907 with network [2:14:20] television time inc. For board [2:14:21] hearing room hardware, software [2:14:22] and professional services, term [2:14:23] ending 3/8/31 ($1,793,655; [2:14:24] cumulative total $4,676,762); [2:14:24] and authorize county [2:14:25] procurement officer or deputized [2:14:26] designee to execute amendment. [2:14:27] And we have no if to speak on [2:14:29] agenda item 27. [2:14:30] >>chair, doug chaffee: it's an [2:14:33] all-district item. [2:14:34] >>don wagner: move the item. [2:14:36] >>chair, doug chaffee: I'll [2:14:37] second it. Any objection? [2:14:39] Motion carries. Item 28. We [2:14:41] dealt with earlier. Now we come [2:14:44] down to item 29. [2:14:45] >>clerk, robin stieler: 29. [2:14:47] Under registrar of voters- [2:14:47] approve retroactive amendment 2 [2:14:48] to contract ma-031-24010973 with [2:14:50] cathyjon enterprises, inc. Dba [2:14:52] hb staffing for temporary help [2:14:53] services, 1/31/25-1/30/26 [2:14:53] ($181,659; new total $500,000; [2:14:54] cumulative total $1,081,659); [2:14:55] and authorize county [2:14:55] procurement officer or deputized [2:14:57] designee to exercise cost [2:14:57] contingency increase not to [2:14:59] exceed 10% under certain [2:15:00] conditions and execute contract. [2:15:02] And we received one request to [2:15:05] speak on agenda item 29. [2:15:06] >>chair, doug chaffee: please [2:15:06] call the speaker. [2:15:08] >>clerk, robin stieler: paul [2:15:17] hayek. [2:15:23] >>speaker: I bet people -- my [2:15:25] question is, with this company, [2:15:27] are they gonna able to provide [2:15:29] the extra help when we have our [2:15:31] elections in JUNE and NOVEMBER [2:15:37] to staff? The facilities that [2:15:40] are needed. I'm very interested [2:15:43] in being one of those temps. [2:15:46] I'm a handicap. [2:15:48] >>clerk, robin stieler: no [2:15:50] further requests, MR. Chair. [2:15:51] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [2:15:52] right. This is an all-district [2:15:52] item. [2:15:54] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: move [2:15:55] the item. [2:15:55] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [2:15:56] second. Objection? Motion [2:15:58] carries. Next item is item 30. [2:16:01] >>clerk, robin stieler: 30. [2:16:03] Under office of campaign finance [2:16:05] and ethics commission-receive [2:16:06] and file 2025 campaign finance [2:16:09] and ethics commission's annual report. [2:16:12] And MR. Chair, we see one [2:16:13] request to speak on agenda item [2:16:15] 30. [2:16:15] >>chair, doug chaffee: please [2:16:15] call the speaker. [2:16:19] >>clerk, robin stieler: brian [2:16:30] kay. [2:16:34] >>speaker: happy day. So orange [2:16:35] county does have a campaign [2:16:37] ethics office. I've been to it. [2:16:43] I've been to a few of the [2:16:44] meetings, and it's somewhat of [2:16:48] an embarrassment. It's a vacant [2:16:50] building. There's no offices. [2:16:54] There's just a couple of tables. [2:16:57] They hold a meeting, which is [2:16:59] more a get-together for the four [2:17:01] or five board members. And poor [2:17:04] donna hoard isn't allowed to [2:17:07] actually communicate with the [2:17:08] public. So while our beloved [2:17:10] katrina foley sits there and [2:17:12] says that she's paying attention [2:17:14] to people and she wants to hear [2:17:16] what the public has to say, poor [2:17:19] donna hoard isn't capable of [2:17:21] listening to the public, and [2:17:24] then translating that to this [2:17:26] board of supervisors. And it is [2:17:30] a shame. It reminds me of james [2:17:33] armanderis. I'm sure that vince [2:17:34] remembers james. Do you not, [2:17:36] sir? He was a great man on the [2:17:39] human relations, and he met with [2:17:42] the members of the public, and [2:17:43] he communicated with members of [2:17:45] the public. And then he [2:17:47] communicated with members of the [2:17:48] board. And provided that [2:17:52] integral service of [2:17:54] communication between the public [2:17:57] and the board. And right now [2:18:00] donna doesn't have that ability. [2:18:03] She hasn't been given the [2:18:04] resources. She doesn't have the [2:18:06] office, and she's admitted to [2:18:10] being given orders to just [2:18:11] ignore the public and just keep [2:18:14] doing what she's doing. So you [2:18:18] would think that someone like [2:18:19] katrina foley, dressed to the [2:18:21] NINEs in that wonderful [2:18:23] bright, loud suit that she's [2:18:26] wearing today, matches the [2:18:28] lipstick, she looks sharp -- you [2:18:30] would think that she would want [2:18:31] to make sure that that board was [2:18:34] open to communication from the [2:18:36] public and able to communicate [2:18:39] with her. I mean, she's saying [2:18:41] that she doesn't want to ignore [2:18:42] people, yet, here she is [2:18:45] ordering a county employee to [2:18:47] ignore the public. So here I am [2:18:52] standing up for a county [2:18:54] employee, donna hoard, and even [2:18:56] for katrina foley, once again, [2:18:59] saying, katrina, this is what [2:19:00] you want. This is what you [2:19:02] believe in. This is the [2:19:04] standard that you are holding [2:19:06] out to the public as your own. [2:19:09] And we're not here to do [2:19:12] anything other than to help you, [2:19:13] to advise you and to warn you [2:19:15] that what you're doing is not [2:19:17] what you say you're doing. And [2:19:19] we're here giving you the [2:19:21] opportunity to live up to those [2:19:23] promises, live up to that bright [2:19:25] suit that you're wearing today [2:19:27] and follow the laws that you're [2:19:29] bragging about doing. Happy day [2:19:29] day. [2:19:31] >>clerk, robin stieler: no [2:19:32] further requests to speak, [2:19:34] MR. Chair. [2:19:34] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [2:19:35] right. This is actually a -- [2:19:40] this is a "receive and file". [2:19:46] Is there any discussion? Any [2:19:49] objection to receiving and [2:19:50] filing the report? The report [2:19:53] shall be received and filed. [2:19:56] All right. Now we come to item [2:19:57] 31. [2:19:58] >>clerk, robin stieler: 31. [2:19:59] Under vice chair foley- [2:20:00] consider second reading and [2:20:01] adoption of "an ordinance of the [2:20:03] county of orange, california, [2:20:04] adding division 22 to title 3, [2:20:08] sections 3-22-1 through 3-22-4, [2:20:10] relating to the unlawful [2:20:12] possession of catalytic [2:20:13] converters, to the codified [2:20:14] ordinances of the county of [2:20:15] orange." we have no requests to [2:20:17] speak on agenda item 31. [2:20:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: this [2:20:23] is -- it was continued before. [2:20:27] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [2:20:27] MR. CHAIRMAN. [2:20:29] >>chair, doug chaffee: [2:20:30] vice-chair, it's your item. [2:20:31] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [2:20:31] you. I'll move this item. This [2:20:34] ordinance, our second reading [2:20:35] makes it unlawful in [2:20:36] un-incorporated orange county to [2:20:38] possess even one detached [2:20:40] catalytic converter without [2:20:42] proof of ownership. This close [2:20:45] as loophole in state law which [2:20:47] actually allows you to have nine [2:20:48] or more detached catalytic [2:20:52] converters without proof [2:20:53] ownership. So the ordinance [2:20:54] shifts the burden to the [2:20:56] possessor, allows the [2:20:57] presumption of unlawful [2:20:58] possession and treats the [2:21:00] converter -- each converter as a [2:21:02] separate offense with civil [2:21:03] penalties. Thank you to the [2:21:05] sheriff's department and [2:21:06] district attorney for their [2:21:07] support of this ordinance. With [2:21:08] that, I move the item. [2:21:09] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [2:21:10] second. Thank you for bringing [2:21:12] this forward. There are no [2:21:14] objections. The item is [2:21:15] approved. [2:21:16] >>vincente sarmiento: I was a no [2:21:17] during the first reading but I [2:21:18] will be a no on this one too. [2:21:21] >>chair, doug chaffee: noting [2:21:22] the "no" vote. And supplement [2:21:25] 31a... [2:21:27] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31a. [2:21:27] Under health care agency- [2:21:27] approve amendment 1 to renew [2:21:28] master and individual contracts [2:21:30] ma042-25010884 for adult peer [2:21:31] support wellness and supported [2:21:33] employment centers with [2:21:34] college community services dba [2:21:37] clarvida, central and south, and [2:21:38] orange county association for [2:21:40] mental health dba mental health [2:21:42] association of orange county, [2:21:43] west, 7/1/26-6/30/28 [2:21:43] (Aggregate total $8,200,000; [2:21:43] cumulative aggregate total [2:21:43] $12,300,000); renewable for one [2:21:44] additional two-year term; and [2:21:44] authorize county procurement [2:21:45] officer or deputized designee to [2:21:46] execute amendments. We have no [2:21:48] requests to speak on s31a. [2:21:49] >>chair, doug chaffee: is a [2:21:51] district 1, 2, and 3 item. Any [2:21:54] objection? Motion carries. [2:21:55] Supplement 31b, please. [2:21:56] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31b. [2:21:57] Under supervisor sarmiento- [2:21:58] orange county behavioral health [2:22:00] advisory board-appoint cesilia [2:22:02] vega-gonzalez, laguna hills, for [2:22:07] ending 3/9/29. And we have no [2:22:10] requests to speak on s31b. [2:22:11] >>chair, doug chaffee: [2:22:12] supervisor sarmiento. [2:22:14] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: [2:22:14] second. [2:22:16] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [2:22:17] objection? The point is made. [2:22:18] Supplement 31c. [2:22:19] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31c. [2:22:20] Under supervisor sarmiento- [2:22:21] animal care community outreach [2:22:22] committee-appoint hollis [2:22:23] lenore, fountain valley, for [2:22:26] term ending 4/14/26. We have no [2:22:29] requests to speak on s31c. [2:22:29] >>chair, doug chaffee: [2:22:32] supervisor sarmiento? Second. [2:22:35] Any objection? There is none. [2:22:37] Next we have a series of items [2:22:39] being brought forward by the [2:22:42] vice-chair. If we could combine [2:22:44] d through m and also add q, r, [2:22:47] and s, I believe that's all of [2:22:48] them. And if the clerk would [2:23:28] read those items. [2:23:29] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31d. [2:23:31] Under vice chair foley-approve [2:23:32] allocation of $10,000 from fifth [2:23:34] district discretionary funds to [2:23:34] parkinson' [2:23:35] s exercise program for [2:23:40] you; make related findings under [2:23:42] government code section 26227; [2:23:43] authorize county executive [2:23:44] officer or designee to negotiate [2:23:45] and enter into agreement as [2:23:47] necessary; and authorize [2:23:48] auditor-controller or designee [2:23:58] to make related payments. [2:23:58] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31e. [2:23:59] Under vice chair foley-approve [2:24:00] allocation of $5,000 from fifth [2:24:01] district discretionary funds to [2:24:01] san clemente village; make [2:24:02] related findings under [2:24:03] government code section 26227; [2:24:04] authorize county executive [2:24:04] officer or designee to negotiate [2:24:05] and enter into agreement as [2:24:06] necessary; and authorize [2:24:07] auditor-controller or designee [2:24:09] to make related payments. Under [2:24:09] vice chair foley-approve [2:24:10] allocation of $5,000 from fifth [2:24:11] district discretionary funds to [2:24:11] families forward, inc.; make [2:24:12] related findings under [2:24:13] government code section 26227; [2:24:13] authorize county executive [2:24:14] officer or designee to negotiate [2:24:15] and enter into agreement as [2:24:16] necessary; and authorize [2:24:16] auditor-controller or designee [2:24:18] to make related payments. Under [2:24:19] vice chair foley-approve [2:24:20] allocation of $5,400 from fifth [2:24:21] district discretionary funds to [2:24:22] capistrano unified school [2:24:22] district: marco forster middle [2:24:23] school library; make related [2:24:23] findings under government code [2:24:24] section 26227; authorize county [2:24:25] executive officer or designee to [2:24:26] negotiate and enter into [2:24:27] agreement as necessary; and [2:24:27] authorize auditor-controller [2:24:31] or designee to make related payments. [2:24:31] under vice chair foley-approve [2:24:32] allocation of $103,633 from [2:24:33] fifth district discretionary [2:24:34] funds to south orange county [2:24:34] community theatre dba camino [2:24:35] real playhouse; make related [2:24:37] findings under government code [2:24:38] section 26227; authorize county [2:24:39] executive officer or designee to [2:24:40] negotiate and enter into [2:24:41] agreement as necessary; and [2:24:41] authorize auditor-controller [2:24:44] or designee to make related payments. [2:24:47] And we have no requests to speak [2:24:48] on any of these items. [2:24:49] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'll [2:25:13] move the items as described.? [2:25:14] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31n. [2:25:14] Under supervisor wagner- [2:25:15] approve sponsorship of various [2:25:16] nonprofit entities from third [2:25:17] district events funds; approve [2:25:18] addition or revision of events [2:25:18] to fy 2025-26 county events [2:25:19] calendar; make related findings [2:25:20] under government code section [2:25:21] 26227; and authorize [2:25:21] auditorcontroller to make [2:25:25] related payments. The we have no [2:25:26] requests to speak. [2:25:27] >>chair, doug chaffee: moved and [2:25:30] seconded. Motion is approved. [2:25:31] Supplement 31o. [2:25:32] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31o. [2:25:33] Under supervisor sarmiento- [2:25:34] approve sponsorship of various [2:25:35] nonprofit entities from second [2:25:35] district events funds; approve [2:25:37] addition or revision of events [2:25:37] to fy 2025-26 county events [2:25:38] calendar; make related findings [2:25:41] under government code section [2:25:42] 26227; and authorize [2:25:42] auditor-controller to make [2:25:48] related payments. And we have no [2:25:51] requests to speak on s31o. [2:25:52] >>chair, doug chaffee: [2:25:54] supervisor sarmiento? Moved and [2:25:56] seconded, any objections? [2:25:59] Seeing none. Approved. Now we [2:26:00] come to supplement 31p. [2:26:01] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31p. [2:26:02] Under chair chaffee-approve [2:26:03] sponsorship of nonprofit [2:26:03] ethiopian-american generational [2:26:04] bridge organization from fourth [2:26:06] district events funds; approve [2:26:08] addition or revision of events [2:26:09] to fy 2025-26 county events [2:26:11] calendar; make related findings [2:26:13] under government code section [2:26:14] 26227; and authorize [2:26:17] auditor-controller to make [2:26:17] related payments. And MR. Chair, [2:26:19] we have received one request to [2:26:20] speak on s31p. [2:26:22] >>chair, doug chaffee: please [2:26:22] call speaker. [2:26:31] >>clerk, robin stieler: donora. [2:26:32] >>speaker: a lot of problems in [2:26:45] the government. Thank GOD I'm [2:26:45] still here. What was that [2:26:49] again? That number, please? [2:26:52] >>clerk, robin stieler: 31p. [2:26:54] >>speaker: now, I trust the [2:26:57] chair, MR. Chaffee, you can [2:26:59] explain it to me that again, [2:27:02] that way I can translate into [2:27:04] spanish and english and then I [2:27:06] can be respond. Thank you. [2:27:10] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: this [2:27:10] item relates to support for [2:27:13] ethiopian american generational [2:27:15] bridge organization. [2:27:16] >>chair, doug chaffee: do you [2:27:17] want to speak on that. [2:27:20] >>speaker: well, I'm from cuba, [2:27:25] not ethiopia. So I pass, but I [2:27:25] would like to make an [2:27:26] appointment with the chair. [2:27:27] >>chair, doug chaffee: that's [2:27:27] not part of this item. So. [2:27:29] >>speaker: thank you. [2:27:31] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank you [2:27:35] you. Second. Any objection? [2:27:36] Motion carries. Now we come to [2:27:40] supplement 31t. [2:27:42] >>clerk, robin stieler: s31t. [2:27:43] Under supervisor sarmiento- [2:27:45] approve use of $75,000 from [2:27:48] second district, budget control [2:27:50] 007 to first five orange county [2:27:52] for childcare business incubator [2:27:54] program; make related findings [2:27:55] under government code section [2:27:57] 26227; authorize county [2:27:59] executive officer or designee to [2:28:01] negotiate and enter into [2:28:01] agreement as necessary; and [2:28:03] authorize auditor-controller or [2:28:04] designee to make related payments. [2:28:05] And we have no if to speak on [2:28:07] s31t. [2:28:11] >>chair, doug chaffee: any [2:28:11] objection? Motion carries. We [2:28:14] come to item 32, which is a [2:28:17] public hearing. [2:28:18] >>clerk, robin stieler: 32. [2:28:19] Under county executive office- [2:28:20] public hearing to consider [2:28:21] adopting resolutions of [2:28:22] necessity acquiring by eminent [2:28:23] domain easements for silverado [2:28:25] canyon road bridge replacement [2:28:27] project; authorizing county [2:28:29] counsel to retain outside [2:28:30] eminent domain counsel bdg law [2:28:32] group inc. And initiate [2:28:33] condemnation proceedings; and [2:28:35] directing and authorizing [2:28:36] auditorcontroller to encumber [2:28:38] and transfer compensation under [2:28:39] certain conditions and making [2:28:41] related findings. This item [2:28:42] does require a 2/3 vote of the [2:28:43] monopoly. [2:28:43] >>chair, doug chaffee: let me -- [2:28:43] vote of the membership. [2:28:45] >>chair, doug chaffee: all [2:28:48] right, do we have any members [2:28:49] who wish to speak. [2:28:54] >>clerk, robin stieler: no. [2:28:55] >>chair, doug chaffee: I'll [2:28:57] bring it back to the board for [2:28:58] consideration. This is a [2:28:59] district 3 item. Moved and [2:29:03] second. Any objection? We have [2:29:08] a unanimous vote, so the item is [2:29:09] approved. Now we could come at [2:29:15] this point to closed sessions. [2:29:17] was that -- would you like to do [2:29:18] that or -- do public comments? [2:29:21] All right. MADAM Clerk, how [2:29:22] many public comments do we [2:29:23] have. [2:29:27] >>clerk, robin stieler: nine. [2:29:30] >>chair, doug chaffee: nine. I [2:29:30] thought I heard "none." that [2:29:32] sounded intriguing, but it's [2:29:35] "nine." okay. Would you like [2:29:41] to do board comments before [2:29:43] closed sessions? We can do [2:29:44] that. Let's get to public [2:29:47] comments, and then we'll follow [2:29:49] with that, okay. Please call [2:29:51] the speakers. [2:29:52] >>clerk, robin stieler: I'll [2:29:52] call three names at a time. [2:29:53] Please line up at the center of [2:29:54] the room when your name is [2:29:56] called behind the podium, steve [2:29:57] rocco, paul hayek and greg [2:30:12] arrowsmith.. [2:30:14] >>speaker: if you see something, [2:30:16] say something. If you see [2:30:18] something, say something. That [2:30:22] was a calling cry at last [2:30:23] meeting that I spoke out on [2:30:25] JANUARY the 27th. Well, I did [2:30:28] say something. And I talked [2:30:30] about the home inveighs of my [2:30:32] home. And at the same time, my [2:30:36] home was being invaded. How [2:30:37] about that? And by pretty much [2:30:40] the same people. Let's see, my [2:30:44] grass is too high, I got bugs. [2:30:49] Plus, I owe the city over [2:30:52] $16,000 for a water bill. What [2:30:54] does that sound like to you? It [2:30:56] sounds like persecution, [2:30:57] prosecution. Sounds like [2:30:59] special prosecution. Sounds [2:31:01] like a special project. You [2:31:03] went to the fbi to get rid of [2:31:07] do. Why aren't you going to the [2:31:08] fbi to get rid of spitzer? [2:31:10] , [2:31:12] who's a sexual pervert. Prove [2:31:16] it. Hates christians. Hates [2:31:19] christians. Pulled a gun on [2:31:21] one. And yet that's okay with [2:31:24] you. Because criminal [2:31:26] politicians are okay with ooh [2:31:28] guys. You know, over the united [2:31:31] states supreme court in [2:31:32] washington D.C. There's a sign [2:31:35] which says "equal justice under [2:31:37] the law." this does not mean [2:31:40] equality in all things. It [2:31:42] doesn't mean you can go to the [2:31:44] same bathroom as me if you're [2:31:45] not the same gender. It means [2:31:48] equality under the law. You [2:31:50] have the same political rights. [2:31:53] Political rights is something [2:31:56] else, okay. Diversity and [2:32:00] equality are not the same thing. [2:32:04] Diversity gives an empire. [2:32:07] Washington D.C. Was built to [2:32:09] look like rome. Marvel -- [2:32:15] marble, columns, and the whole [2:32:15] shebang. And equality means [2:32:18] sameness. Similarity.. Nation [2:32:25] and empire are not the same [2:32:27] thing. Uncle sam loves [2:32:31] diversity because you're not [2:32:33] going to be a majority. And the [2:32:36] government will tell you what to [2:32:37] do, not vice-versa. You can't [2:32:41] have it both ways. You can't [2:32:44] have it both ways. They are [2:32:46] contradicter to. It's [2:32:49] either/or. Uncle sam's [2:32:50] diversity or sameness, a nation, [2:32:54] a real nation. And you know [2:32:57] what, it's people like me who [2:32:58] are being discriminated against [2:33:00] today. White christian males, [2:33:03] number one on the list. [2:33:05] Equality, take a look at the [2:33:06] sports. I couldn't find a white [2:33:09] face there for the entire last [2:33:20] week.S. [2:33:22] >>speaker: good afternoon. Good [2:33:25] morning, I mean. We need to [2:33:27] make sure these new operators [2:33:29] for these shelters are make them [2:33:36] wear they're -- where they are [2:33:40] walk in/walk out. Why don't we [2:33:41] hire those that have the trades [2:33:42] to help run the place? Because [2:33:46] they'd be glad to help run it [2:33:48] and make minimum wage. Let's [2:33:52] see them turn this place around. [2:33:55] Remember, back in '17 I was [2:34:00] advocating for the homeless [2:34:02] shelter in anaheim. I was there [2:34:05] when they dedicated it. I was [2:34:07] there for eight months, and [2:34:09] mercy house has to go. And the [2:34:12] one in santa ana is being run by [2:34:15] a foreign company. They're not [2:34:17] even a U.S.. And mercy house is [2:34:20] run by a hawaiian with hawaiian [2:34:23] security. [2:34:29] >>clerk, robin stieler: the next [2:34:29] three superiors are donora, l [2:34:32] uci daniel and nicole nguyen. [2:34:36] >>speaker: presentation z mailed [2:34:42] to the usdoj, california brown [2:34:42] act of 1953, forcing local [2:34:45] government agencies to be [2:34:46] transparent with the tax paying [2:34:47] citizens. Had an introduction [2:34:48] meeting with sheriff chad dee [2:34:52] bianco, government candidate and [2:34:53] michael gates, attorney general [2:34:54] candidate at the elks lodge in [2:34:56] santa ana last tuesday night. [2:34:58] They were both real, genuine and [2:34:59] approachable guys that have the [2:35:01] resume [2:35:02] and experience to make [2:35:03] california golden again. They [2:35:04] are eager to put their words [2:35:06] into action for the best [2:35:08] interest of californians. [2:35:09] Focus, offender recidivism and [2:35:12] re-entry in the united states, [2:35:15] crime in america net leonard [2:35:16] adam signs junior 2026, U.S. [2:35:18] Department of justice bureau of [2:35:20] justice statistics 68% of [2:35:23] prisoners were released with a [2:35:25] new arrest within three years [2:35:26] and 77% in five years. [2:35:31] California correctional [2:35:32] facilities issues from colleges [2:35:38] of law.Edu, overcrowding and [2:35:39] inadequate handling of [2:35:41] complaints and violence within [2:35:43] the system. California [2:35:44] correctional facilities remain [2:35:47] over capacity which affects [2:35:48] safety and rehabilitation [2:35:49] efforts. Overcrowding leads to [2:35:52] increased violence and undermine [2:35:53] security measures. Problem, [2:35:56] there are three hours of actual [2:35:57] work assignments and or [2:35:58] educational programs that an [2:36:00] inmate will accomplish in a [2:36:02] 15-hour day, according to the [2:36:03] typical daily schedule for [2:36:05] inmates in the california [2:36:06] correctional facilities. In [2:36:08] other words, the typical daily [2:36:09] schedule focuses more on a day [2:36:12] camp schedule for criminal [2:36:13] versus a work schedule to [2:36:15] prepare him or her to be [2:36:17] productive tax paying citizens [2:36:18] in society. The overcrowding [2:36:20] and violence in these facilities [2:36:21] makes sense due to these inmates [2:36:23] have too much time on their [2:36:25] hands for shenanigans. It [2:36:27] appears that the offenders' [2:36:29] behavior will accept returning [2:36:30] back to a correctional facility [2:36:32] knowing that he or she has a [2:36:33] criminal day camp waiting for [2:36:36] him or her. Solution, as a tax [2:36:38] paying citizens I'd like to have [2:36:39] the opportunity to revise a [2:36:41] typical daily schedule for [2:36:42] inmates. These inmates, [2:36:43] prisons, jails, juvenile [2:36:45] detentions should be working [2:36:46] eight hours a day for five days [2:36:47] a week. They will be allowed to [2:36:49] have a daily 30-minute lunch and [2:36:51] two 15-minute breaks to be [2:36:53] complying with california labor [2:36:54] laws. The inmates will execute [2:36:56] a self development and [2:36:57] educational class during day 6 [2:37:00] and 7 and after work. The goal [2:37:02] is to have the california [2:37:03] correctional facilities execute [2:37:05] a curriculum that will motivate [2:37:06] the inmates to not want to go [2:37:08] back to a correctional facility [2:37:10] ever again in a lifetime. [2:37:12] Temporary housing, dorms, [2:37:14] continued education and job [2:37:15] placement during the inmate [2:37:17] release program is crucial to [2:37:19] get him or her heading towards [2:37:22] the right direction for success. [2:37:27] >>chair, doug chaffee: MAY we [2:37:28] have the next speaker, please. [2:37:34] >>speaker: thank you, again. [2:37:36] Just want to say I still have [2:37:38] love for all you guys being a [2:37:40] christian pentecostal parent and [2:37:43] pastor be pentecostal and my [2:37:45] father was an architect. We [2:37:47] went to church seven days a week [2:37:49] to keep us focused from the [2:37:51] communists. I got sick from a [2:37:53] hearing, then it was government. [2:38:01] Not america. It was depraved [2:38:03] house, discriminated and I have [2:38:05] my alien number. This number [2:38:09] congress will now that they [2:38:09] brought me from cuba, supposed [2:38:11] to be protected under federal [2:38:14] statute and still today. So the [2:38:20] government has -- I'm praying [2:38:20] that they focus on illegal [2:38:23] immigrant U.S. Citizens that [2:38:25] work and pay taxes. Many [2:38:28] people, you see it in the media, [2:38:30] they are not legal. They are [2:38:32] aggressive against police [2:38:34] officer and I.C.E., and I'm [2:38:36] crying what the heck went wrong [2:38:38] in orange county that we grew up [2:38:40] in orange county, went to orange [2:38:42] high school where america taught [2:38:45] us how to speak english. There [2:38:47] was no one from mexico, with all [2:38:49] due respect, running orange [2:38:51] county back in 1969. So I'm [2:38:54] requesting our origin -- an [2:38:55] urgent appointment with the [2:38:57] chair doug chaffee as soon as [2:39:00] possible and, again, the chief [2:39:03] janet nguyen refuse to make me [2:39:06] an appointment. And you guys [2:39:08] have seen me since 2018 and 19. [2:39:11] And thank GOD I'm a great human [2:39:13] being to guiding other people [2:39:14] that are still standing. So [2:39:17] please it's urgent an [2:39:18] appointment with doug chaffee be [2:39:21] blessed in hoping to make [2:39:22] america great for all of us. If [2:39:24] you don't fix it, this will [2:39:25] never be the united states of [2:39:27] america anymore. My parents are [2:39:31] in heaven. They are the reason [2:39:33] why we are here, they prepare [2:39:35] possible under kennedy. We [2:39:38] waited, and thank GOD we here. [2:39:40] But this is not the country that [2:39:41] we grow up. But we still have [2:39:43] love for you guys. You. [2:39:47] >>chair, doug chaffee: the next [2:39:48] speaker, please. [2:39:48] >>clerk, robin stieler: l uci [2:39:49] daniel and nicole nguyen. [2:39:54] >>speaker: hello. I'm here to [2:40:01] explain that I am a home care [2:40:02] provider with ihss for 14 years. [2:40:05] I take care of my mom for 14 [2:40:07] years, and I do everything for [2:40:11] her. She cannot live by [2:40:12] herself. She's 92. And her [2:40:15] mind strong, but she is very [2:40:16] weak for her age. And she needs [2:40:21] help with everything. I cook [2:40:23] for her. I clean. I bathe her, [2:40:27] I MAY being sure she takes her [2:40:28] medication. I take her to the [2:40:31] doctor's, sometimes I take her [2:40:33] out to the store. That's what [2:40:35] she likes to do mostly, to go [2:40:36] shopping. And I'm just [2:40:40] explaining that because we don't [2:40:44] get paid very much, but it helps [2:40:46] us to stay with the people we [2:40:49] take care of. Like it helps me [2:40:50] to stay home with my mom because [2:40:53] of the ihss program because I [2:40:56] can be -- I'm a certified [2:40:59] paralegal. I could have a job [2:41:02] like I used to work with the [2:41:04] lawyers, and making a lot more [2:41:06] money. But I chose this because [2:41:08] I love my mom, and I have to [2:41:11] take care of her, or -- I don't [2:41:13] want to put her in a nursing [2:41:14] home because she gets very [2:41:16] depressed when she thinks about [2:41:17] what if she goes to a nursing [2:41:19] home. And that's not a good [2:41:22] thing for her, but she's healthy [2:41:25] and her mind is strong because [2:41:27] of my care. And I just want to [2:41:30] make sure that we try to keep [2:41:31] the ihss program for the [2:41:36] disabled and the elderly. [2:41:39] They're better off at home than [2:41:41] a nurse home. That's all I'm [2:41:42] saying. And when my mom's had [2:41:47] to go for therapy to a nursing [2:41:49] home, she just cried almost [2:41:51] every day. She was so [2:41:52] depressed. It's better if they [2:41:55] stay home. So thank you for [2:41:57] your time. [2:42:01] >>clerk, robin stieler: after [2:42:02] nicole, the last three speakers [2:42:04] are katherine louie, andrew and [2:42:06] brian kay. [2:42:07] >>speaker: good morning, board. [2:42:09] I am nicole nguyen, and I'm an [2:42:11] ihss provider. I live -- I have [2:42:17] been a provider for five years. [2:42:19] I care for my cousin, my first [2:42:21] cousin. I'm a resident of santa [2:42:24] ana and district 2. What I do [2:42:28] for my cousin -- and what I care [2:42:31] for my cousin, I MAY being sure [2:42:33] that she take her medication on [2:42:36] time and make sure she has her [2:42:39] refill medication on time too. [2:42:42] She is 83 years old. She's not [2:42:45] healthy, not physically and not [2:42:48] mentally. I care for her. I [2:42:51] MAY being sure she can eat. She [2:42:53] cannot eat likely, she can have [2:42:55] proper food, and I gotta help [2:42:59] her in and out of my car for [2:43:00] doctors, pharmacist or anywhere [2:43:03] she want to go. My work, my [2:43:06] helping her is very important, [2:43:09] that allow her to stay home and [2:43:12] be comfortable with respect. I [2:43:17] really appreciate the ihss [2:43:19] program to allow me to take care [2:43:23] of my cousin. And [2:43:39] >>speaker: I'd like to provide a [2:43:39] little help. My name is [2:43:47] katherine louie. I'm a proud [2:43:48] member of udw. And I'm an ihss [2:43:51] provider. I live in the city of [2:43:53] cota decause sarc I've been a [2:43:54] provider for 17 years, and I [2:43:56] take care of my beautiful boy, [2:43:58] as you can see. He is 19 years [2:44:01] old -- he is 19 years old, and [2:44:07] I've cared for him since the day [2:44:09] he was born. I just like to [2:44:11] share a little bit about my [2:44:12] story with you. I worked prior [2:44:15] in the corporate world for many [2:44:17] years doing everything -- [2:44:19] complete op assistant medical. [2:44:21] I never did anything like that. [2:44:22] My son was born with profound [2:44:24] needs requiring 24 hours care. [2:44:26] I knew nothing about this, so I [2:44:29] relied on the doctors and nurses [2:44:31] and therapists and everyone else [2:44:33] to tell me what to do and how to [2:44:35] take care of my son. I has [2:44:37] profound needs, like I said, [2:44:39] requiring 24 hours care. He is [2:44:42] blind. He's non-verbal. He is [2:44:45] fed through a tube. I take care [2:44:47] of all of his living activities [2:44:50] that he does. And as time went [2:44:53] on, I started questioning [2:44:55] things. And this program has [2:44:57] allowed me to -- was able to [2:45:00] allow me to stay home with him, [2:45:02] to do research, to find out what [2:45:06] I can better do. So the first [2:45:08] thing is -- one of the things is [2:45:09] my son -- they told me when he [2:45:11] was very young and he was in the [2:45:13] hospital for all of the time for [2:45:15] the first three years of his [2:45:16] life, that's all I did, was in [2:45:19] the hospital. He has a seizure [2:45:20] disorder. And he was on [2:45:22] multiple medications for that. [2:45:25] they just don't work, so they [2:45:26] would add another one, another [2:45:28] one. So I was okay with that. [2:45:30] He was fed through ag tube. [2:45:31] Every time offer stopped nursing [2:45:34] him, he would -- he had to [2:45:39] receive nutrition, medical-grade [2:45:42] nutrition. Every time I put it, [2:45:44] in he would throw it up. So one [2:45:47] day decided to start feeding him [2:45:48] with homemade food. I just [2:45:50] decided why don't I blend [2:45:51] something and put it. Heaven's [2:45:53] forbid, he started eating, he [2:45:55] was able to keep it down. Real [2:45:56] food kept it down. Then I said [2:45:59] why do you want me to keep [2:46:01] adding more seizure meds. They [2:46:02] don't work. I researched [2:46:04] alternative medications, seizure [2:46:07] medications. And they started [2:46:10] working. So I started taking [2:46:11] them away. And most of these [2:46:13] doctors you all know. Thomas is [2:46:15] a child of choc hospital and you [2:46:17] will of a the specialty there is [2:46:20] and they do great with him, but [2:46:22] he has thrived because I have [2:46:24] been allowed to stay home and [2:46:26] take care of him. They told me [2:46:27] he would never walk. After he [2:46:29] stopped throwing up and having [2:46:30] seizures, guess what, he walked. [2:46:32] We walked into the doctors, and [2:46:36] I would think they would run [2:46:37] down the hall going, oh, my GOD, [2:46:40] what did you do. He's in a much [2:46:41] better way because of this [2:46:42] program, and I'd like you to [2:46:44] consider doing what you can to [2:46:46] keep this program to allow [2:46:48] people to take care of their [2:46:49] loved ones. [2:46:51] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank you [2:46:52] you. [2:46:54] >>clerk, robin stieler: andrew [2:46:54] and brian kay. [2:47:09] >>speaker: hello. I'm andrew, [2:47:09] as you know. I just want to say [2:47:13] I was here at beginning, and [2:47:16] man, I give you guys props for [2:47:17] what you guys do. It can be [2:47:18] pretty intense. This is my [2:47:21] first public meeting. So I am [2:47:24] not as experienced as many of [2:47:27] you in this. So it is my first. [2:47:32] I'll do my best. I just have [2:47:36] three topics that I want to [2:47:38] start with. First off, one of [2:47:42] the gentleman before me had [2:47:45] mentioned shelters. There's a [2:47:50] few agenda ago. I just want to [2:47:53] go off of that because a lot of [2:47:55] times nonprofit organization try [2:47:57] to do their best to get their [2:47:58] grants, right, and make sure [2:48:02] that the community and everybody [2:48:04] within the community is able to [2:48:06] help set these places up. [2:48:13] What's point if you don't even [2:48:14] know what you're putting your [2:48:15] money into let alone at least go [2:48:19] and see it for yourself, right. [2:48:21] I know that if I'm going to go [2:48:22] to a donation center or [2:48:23] somewhere, I walk around and [2:48:25] view it and look at it, and then [2:48:27] I put my money down, and go, [2:48:28] hey, this program is helping [2:48:30] kids, right. Many of the [2:48:33] programs that I've been to [2:48:34] personally experiencing [2:48:36] homelessness and going to [2:48:38] shelters, they do a thing with [2:48:41] favoritism, and it's very, very [2:48:43] sad because if somebody is not [2:48:46] to your liking or they don't [2:48:48] like your attitude or they don't [2:48:49] like something about you, [2:48:53] basically you're screwed, and [2:48:54] it's back to the streets. And I [2:48:57] don't know if you guys are aware [2:48:58] of this, but a lot of these [2:48:59] shelter and a lot of these [2:49:00] places had a really long waiting [2:49:02] list just to get in, so it's [2:49:04] very sad on seeing that. And so [2:49:08] even the ones that are [2:49:15] non-shelters such as orangewood [2:49:16] donation foundation in santa [2:49:19] ana, they do good work, but, [2:49:21] again, it's a lot of favoritism, [2:49:25] and it's very, very sad. And we [2:49:27] need to seriously do something [2:49:28] about this, you guys. It's very [2:49:30] serious. We're not here to put [2:49:32] money in and go in a work place [2:49:35] and take every little thing that [2:49:38] we see as personal aspect, [2:49:42] because when you're in a [2:49:43] workplace, it requires and [2:49:45] involves professionalism. Not [2:49:48] how you feel, not how much of a [2:49:50] bad day you had at home. Please [2:49:52] don't bring what you have at [2:49:53] home into your workspace, [2:49:55] especially as shelters when [2:49:57] we're trying to help people not [2:49:59] break them back down and push [2:50:00] them back in the streets. All [2:50:02] right. Thank you guys. [2:50:03] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [2:50:04] you. [2:50:07] >>clerk, robin stieler: brian [2:50:20] kay. [2:50:27] >>speaker: happy day. Earlier [2:50:27] in the meeting katrina foley [2:50:29] realized that she had made a [2:50:30] mistake, and she wanted to go [2:50:32] back and correct her mistake. [2:50:35] And recast her vote. That's [2:50:38] basically the first amendment [2:50:39] right there. You redress the [2:50:42] grievance. So you would think [2:50:45] that in the criminal case she'd [2:50:47] look at it and go, hey, brian [2:50:48] cark doesn't know where I live, [2:50:50] so even if I think he really [2:50:51] threatened me, it doesn't rise [2:50:53] to the level of a crime. You'd [2:50:56] that I she'd be able to ask [2:50:57] vincent sarmiento, a defense [2:51:00] attorney, if that was the truth, [2:51:04] and that vince would be able to [2:51:05] stand up for the truth. You [2:51:07] don't have to stand up for me, [2:51:09] vince. You can hate me all the [2:51:10] want but I think that you would [2:51:13] stand up for the constitution [2:51:14] and the raw and that you would [2:51:18] help katrina foley not be [2:51:20] afraid. It's amazing, narsisco [2:51:25] ber rang oh, the gentleman who [2:51:26] fathered three children who were [2:51:28] marine veterans, you went to [2:51:30] court to get him -- get that [2:51:35] whole matter resolved. There's [2:51:37] a picture of you in the paper [2:51:38] walking out the courthouse right [2:51:40] there next to him. You [2:51:43] supported him. You endorsed [2:51:45] him. You worked to help get him [2:51:47] free. And it's a shame because [2:51:50] we have families right here to [2:51:53] petition you to not be forced [2:51:57] into family court without having [2:51:59] their petitions addressed. [2:51:59] Please realize you had to -- [2:52:00] their petitions redressed. [2:52:01] Please realize you had to stand [2:52:02] over julie, you had to step over [2:52:05] me, who's filed a petition to [2:52:10] help narsisco. I'm not saying [2:52:14] it's bad. As a matter of fact, [2:52:15] thank you for helping him, but [2:52:18] realize that you had to walk [2:52:20] over, you had to tread over your [2:52:23] own constituents. [2:52:25] You know, you're all complaining [2:52:26] about I.C.E.. You're doing the [2:52:28] same thing as I.C.E. You have [2:52:30] police who are undertrained, [2:52:33] overviolent, committing crimes [2:52:34] against the people. You ignore [2:52:36] the petitions from the people, [2:52:39] and then you allow the police to [2:52:40] do what they've done. Vince, [2:52:43] could you help me with my issue. [2:52:46] You have chosen not to. And [2:52:51] lastly, honorable spitzer, he [2:52:52] lost a second lawsuit. There's [2:52:55] about eight more. And the [2:52:57] really sad thing is that all of [2:52:59] you are implicated. You know, [2:53:01] probably the saddest one is, [2:53:02] again, katrina foley, who has a [2:53:04] law firm dedicated to protecting [2:53:06] employees from abusive employers [2:53:07] was found to be an abusive [2:53:10] employer. And rather than [2:53:12] stopping this abusive behavior, [2:53:14] she's gonna do it eight more [2:53:16] times. I wish better for you. [2:53:20] Happy day. [2:53:21] >>clerk, robin stieler: no [2:53:22] further requests to speak, [2:53:23] MR. Chair. [2:53:24] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [2:53:24] you. Now we'll go to board [2:53:26] comments. Would any board [2:53:27] member like to speak? [2:53:29] Supervisor nguyen. [2:53:29] >>janet nguyen: thank you. I [2:53:31] have a few items to make [2:53:34] comments on. One, I wanted to, [2:53:37] again, thank you, the ceo and [2:53:41] also doug from oc care, who [2:53:45] attended our hud senior [2:53:46] officials meeting last week. [2:53:50] This came about because of my [2:53:52] trip to washington D.C. And, you [2:53:55] know, it's -- we were inquiring [2:53:57] about receiving additional [2:53:58] funding for our homeless efforts [2:54:00] and, so last week they came out, [2:54:03] they originally were actually [2:54:05] just going to stop by L.A. And [2:54:07] san diego, but because of our [2:54:09] trip to D.C., they stopped by [2:54:12] orange county. I don't remember [2:54:14] the last time hud actually came [2:54:16] to orange county, at least not [2:54:18] at the time that I remembered, [2:54:20] my first two terms on this [2:54:22] board. And since I've been [2:54:24] back. So it actually was very [2:54:26] exciting that we were able to [2:54:27] get home to orange county to [2:54:29] visit us. We toured the oc [2:54:32] rescue mission, homeless shelter [2:54:33] in tustin. It is a private [2:54:36] state of the art facility with a [2:54:37] high successive rate of [2:54:39] rehabilitation. Hud was very [2:54:43] impressed what they saw and, you [2:54:45] know, what I gather and -- is [2:54:47] that they highly encourage us to [2:54:51] apply for the funding that's [2:54:52] coming up with the nofa, that's [2:54:55] coming up. You know, they're [2:54:56] refocusing on homeless policy on [2:54:59] treatment, recovery, and [2:55:01] self-sufficiency. And so it's [2:55:03] actually, you know, exciting, [2:55:05] and I really appreciate your [2:55:06] comments at the meeting, [2:55:07] MR. CHAIRMAN, and sharing your [2:55:08] prevention solutions. I think [2:55:11] they -- their eyes were really [2:55:13] wide open when they heard about [2:55:14] it and couldn't believe that, [2:55:15] you know, such a program exists. [2:55:17] And, you know, the ceo [2:55:19] mentioned about the encampment [2:55:23] of, you know, from -- in 2018, [2:55:25] the clearing of the encampment, [2:55:27] whether it's the santa ana river [2:55:28] trail or the plaza of the flags [2:55:31] and how the county has helped [2:55:35] assist hundreds of individuals. [2:55:36] And so we'll continue to [2:55:38] communicate with hud and, you [2:55:40] know, I want to continue to [2:55:41] offer that orange county can be [2:55:43] a statewide leader in solving [2:55:44] the homeless crisis unlike other [2:55:46] counties. And they did mention [2:55:49] that the nofa coming up will be [2:55:50] very competitive. It's not [2:55:52] gonna be, you know, just because [2:55:54] you received it in the past you [2:55:55] will get it, and that's why [2:55:56] there's a lot of angst all [2:55:58] across the country, because most [2:56:00] folks depend on these fundings. [2:56:01] But they want measures -- [2:56:07] measurements to be included. [2:56:08] And so I'm excited. And again, [2:56:10] thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN, and [2:56:11] thank you to the ceo and also [2:56:13] doug. It was friday evening. [2:56:15] Didn't finish to a little close [2:56:20] to 9:00 or past 9:00 P.M.. So I [2:56:21] really appreciate you being part [2:56:23] of it. The other -- couple of [2:56:26] other things is I want to thank [2:56:27] doug and his staff and the [2:56:31] thousand volunteers on the point [2:56:34] in time count. This past -- [2:56:37] couple of weeks ago now. This [2:56:39] is very important to us. So the [2:56:41] data is essential to access -- [2:56:43] assess our coach homelessness [2:56:45] and whether we as a county has [2:56:47] done well or not or what each [2:56:50] city has done, if it has worked [2:56:53] or not. As we know, in 2024, we [2:56:58] had 7,322 homeless individuals, [2:57:02] which, you know, was an increase [2:57:03] from 2022 by 37%, and we did not [2:57:09] do any count in '23 or '25. And [2:57:11] so this count something going to [2:57:13] be important for us to see what [2:57:14] has been done since '24. [2:57:16] Whether our programs or the [2:57:18] city's programs have worked or [2:57:20] not worked, and whether we [2:57:21] continue those programs or stop [2:57:24] those programs, and we look at [2:57:25] whether, you know, it's -- what [2:57:28] to do going forward. And so I [2:57:29] really appreciate the city of [2:57:31] fountain valley because I joined [2:57:32] them, the team of the officers, [2:57:34] at my square park, and we drove [2:57:36] around in fountain valley to [2:57:37] look and talk to a lot of [2:57:40] individuals. And it's very [2:57:42] eye-opening to see what's [2:57:43] happening there, especially in [2:57:45] the evening. And so, again, [2:57:48] thank you to doug, the oc cares [2:57:52] staff and also the thousand of [2:57:54] volunteers that came out to help [2:57:58] at that -- to help. And last, I [2:58:01] just also want to thank the [2:58:04] board for celebrating lunar new [2:58:06] year with us. We had a great [2:58:08] time at the board meeting, and [2:58:11] lots of comments and [2:58:13] conversations of folks. [2:58:16] Appreciate the board for [2:58:16] continuing to recognize lunar [2:58:19] new year, particularly in our [2:58:20] district, would be for tet. And [2:58:24] I was also able to participate [2:58:26] in a lot of lunar new year [2:58:28] events in the district. [2:58:31] And I can say that, you know, I [2:58:34] want to give a shout-out to my [2:58:34] staff that a whole week and a [2:58:37] half was exhausting for us. We, [2:58:40] you know, when new year's eve [2:58:42] events, temple run, which, you [2:58:44] know, a lot of us got back at [2:58:47] probably 1:30 in the morning. [2:58:49] And so really appreciate my [2:58:51] staff for hanging in there and, [2:58:53] even though it was raining on [2:58:55] us, as well, for being out [2:58:57] there, for being troopers and [2:58:58] then into -- being a part the [2:59:02] tet parade this past weekend in [2:59:03] westminster and appreciate all [2:59:09] of their support and all of the [2:59:10] volunteers that came out to help [2:59:11] us in the parade as well, and [2:59:13] thank you to this board for the [2:59:15] recognition of lunar new year [2:59:17] and tet in orange county. Thank [2:59:19] you, MR. CHAIRMAN. [2:59:20] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank [2:59:20] you, supervisor. Vice-chair. [2:59:26] >>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank [2:59:26] you, MR. CHAIRMAN. And, yes, [2:59:29] this -- I feel like this year [2:59:30] has been the most celebrated [2:59:32] lunar new year of anytime I've [2:59:35] ever seen in our whole county. [2:59:36] So it's wonderful, so many [2:59:38] colorful, joyful celebration, [2:59:41] and thanks for bringing all of [2:59:42] the decorations to the sixth [2:59:43] floor and the nice treats that [2:59:46] you shared with us at our lunch [2:59:49] meeting last time. So lots of [2:59:51] things to celebrate here in [2:59:52] orange county. One thing -- one [2:59:55] issue that has been percolating [2:59:57] in our district is the san juan [3:00:03] creek channels. I want to thank [3:00:03] orange county public works and [3:00:06] our agricultural commissioner [3:00:09] for the time expended and the [3:00:12] deep dive in briefing with my [3:00:14] time on all of the county's san [3:00:16] juan and trabuco creeks and [3:00:17] maintenance plans, the different [3:00:18] ways we manage our channels, the [3:00:20] history of managing our channels [3:00:22] and the use of herbicides [3:00:24] specifically in our flood [3:00:26] channels. So the community has [3:00:30] been communicating with us quite [3:00:31] a bit about the san juan and [3:00:34] trabuco creeks. And as our team [3:00:37] knows well, I'm very much [3:00:39] opposed to herbicides in our [3:00:40] public spaces and our waterways. [3:00:43] I share -- I've shared many of [3:00:44] these concerns and all of the [3:00:47] questions that we are receiving [3:00:48] with our orange county public [3:00:49] works team and I'll continue [3:00:51] engaging with our county staff [3:00:53] on different alternatives. We [3:00:56] want to assure the public that [3:01:02] round-up/gliff say the, has not [3:01:02] been applied to the tra bush oh [3:01:04] or san juan creek flued channels [3:01:06] eyewitness news since JANUARY of [3:01:09] 2025, the reason we know that is [3:01:14] because we received complaints [3:01:15] in JANUARY of 2025. Formal [3:01:17] complaints were made. An [3:01:19] investigation ensued. And [3:01:21] because we take these complaints [3:01:23] seriously, the investigation [3:01:25] found that the contractor was [3:01:27] not in compliance, and then our [3:01:30] county staff acted decisively. [3:01:34] Gliff say the has not been used [3:01:35] since then and not be applied [3:01:37] those channels again. [3:01:39] Glyfhosate. The county is only [3:01:41] approved to apply state water [3:01:42] board and epa approved [3:01:44] herbicides to vegetation and [3:01:48] flood control channels. And the [3:01:50] reason for that is so that [3:01:52] people don't experience flooding [3:01:53] in their homes. This channel [3:01:55] was developed and house built [3:01:58] and commercial retail built all [3:02:01] along it, and so it's a bagging [3:02:04] act to protect the homes from [3:02:07] flooding and keep the vegetation [3:02:09] out in a way that is respectful [3:02:12] of, you know, the humans and the [3:02:14] natural habitat that live in the [3:02:17] channel like fish. So we have [3:02:20] been following the protocols for [3:02:22] diluting the application to [3:02:24] ensure it remains as safe as [3:02:25] possible for humans, and we'll [3:02:28] continue to try to balance the [3:02:31] environmental needs, including [3:02:33] researching cost-effective [3:02:35] alternatives. I had a [3:02:38] discussion with county staff [3:02:40] yesterday about some [3:02:41] alternatives that I'm hoping [3:02:42] that we can research and pursue. [3:02:44] But also with the thought in [3:02:48] neighborhood we have to protect [3:02:49] the property and the people from [3:02:51] the threat of flooding. So if [3:02:53] you have questions for our [3:02:55] office or public works or the [3:02:57] healthcare agency, you can come [3:02:58] to our town hall. The town hall [3:03:00] is on monday MARCH 2nd at 6:00 [3:03:03] P.M.. Please rsvp, and you can [3:03:07] contact our office to do so. [3:03:09] And you can contact public works [3:03:11] for any additional inquiries at [3:03:17] 714-667-8800. And in the [3:03:18] interest of time, I want to just [3:03:20] focus quickly on travelers who [3:03:22] might be stuck in puerto [3:03:23] vallarta. In the fifth district [3:03:25] we have a lot of travelers that [3:03:26] go to puerto vallarta. The [3:03:29] country is pretty much on [3:03:31] lock-down in some areas, [3:03:34] tijuana, guadalajara, puerto [3:03:36] vallarta and the U.S. State [3:03:38] department is advising americans [3:03:41] as well as others that are [3:03:42] traveling to seek shelter, [3:03:44] minimize unnecessary movements, [3:03:46] remain in hotels or residences, [3:03:49] be aware of your surroundings. [3:03:51] Anyone needing assistance can [3:03:53] call from U.S. Or canada, [3:04:02] 1-888-407-4747. Or if you're in [3:04:03] mexico and you need call [3:04:11] 1-202-501-4444. Southwest [3:04:11] airlines, which travels direct [3:04:13] from jwa to mexico are advising [3:04:16] to check with [3:04:20] southwest.Com/traveladvisor for [3:04:21] information. And then the state [3:04:23] department has this american [3:04:24] citizens services task force for [3:04:26] U.S. Citizens in mexico, and you [3:04:29] can call a number to help get [3:04:31] returned travel 202-501-4444. [3:04:38] Or 1-888407-4747. [3:04:42] I already gave those numbers. [3:04:43] So with that, thank you to my [3:04:46] colleagues for a very productive [3:04:48] meeting today. And it's only [3:04:50] noon. [3:04:51] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank you [3:04:53] vice-chair. Supervisor [3:04:53] sarmiento. [3:04:55] >>vincente sarmiento: thank you, [3:04:55] MR. Chair. I have just a few [3:04:56] items, and if the board will [3:04:59] indulge me on these, I'll try go [3:05:00] rapid me. I -- rapidly. I want [3:05:01] to thank our partners who helped [3:05:04] us with the health and resource [3:05:07] fair this saturday the 21st. [3:05:09] We hosted at anaheim high [3:05:11] school. We want to thank their [3:05:12] board of trustees and the [3:05:14] principal there. Principal [3:05:16] rubin. [3:05:19] He and his team were just very [3:05:22] gracious and opening up the [3:05:24] campus. It's a beautiful [3:05:25] campus. It's a historic campus, [3:05:28] and our partners, who kind of [3:05:32] anchored this were social [3:05:33] service agency, ahn tran was [3:05:35] there and also caloptima. So we [3:05:38] want to thank our partners who [3:05:41] were there, notably lestinac, [3:05:44] cap oc, second harvest food [3:05:46] bank, choc, central city, [3:05:48] united, across borders and many, [3:05:51] many others. They were doing [3:05:53] medical screenings, reading [3:05:55] glasses on the spot and just a [3:06:02] lot of good stuff, groceries, [3:06:05] diapers, people who were just [3:06:07] trying to help their neighbors. [3:06:08] Unfortunately, attendance wasn't [3:06:10] as large as we would have [3:06:12] expected just because we know [3:06:14] there was a lot of fear, and it [3:06:15] was palpable in people who were [3:06:17] there. We saw it in their [3:06:19] faces, and they explained to us [3:06:21] that their neighbors would have [3:06:22] attended had conditions been [3:06:24] different. But they're still [3:06:25] fearful of immigration raids and [3:06:28] enforcement that has communities [3:06:30] really kind of closed off. So [3:06:33] that was one. And the other one [3:06:35] is our warm program. We just [3:06:37] wanted to update, we know it's [3:06:39] beautiful weather right now. [3:06:40] It's 80 degrees outside right [3:06:41] now. Last week we had a lot of [3:06:42] rain and previously, and I'm [3:06:44] sure we'll have more. The warm [3:06:46] program in its second year is [3:06:49] our effort to stand up what was [3:06:53] the cold weather shelter, and on [3:06:55] JANUARY 1st, the program [3:06:57] started providing motel stays to [3:07:02] elementary-age students and [3:07:02] their families during periods of [3:07:04] inclement weather. We partner [3:07:06] with all five school districts [3:07:07] in our area, and for families in [3:07:10] need. So if you know of [3:07:11] anybody, please have them [3:07:12] contact their school districts, [3:07:14] teachers, principals so they can [3:07:16] connect with their program. It [3:07:18] was able to support some [3:07:18] families through some very cold [3:07:20] nights and continue to activate [3:07:22] on nights when temperatures drop [3:07:24] below 45 degrees and during [3:07:26] rainy weather. Lastly, I wanted [3:07:29] to touch on the report that was [3:07:32] just released by caloptima, and [3:07:34] that is the audit on findings. [3:07:38] It disclosed in the expenditures [3:07:42] major in the period when former [3:07:43] supervisor andrew do served on [3:07:45] the caloptima board. You know, [3:07:47] there was an article written on [3:07:49] it. It's a little less than [3:07:52] accurate, but to the extent that [3:07:56] it captured what the board was [3:07:57] trying to do at came optima, [3:07:59] which was to look back and see [3:08:01] if there was any undue influence [3:08:02] by the former supervisor because [3:08:04] he served as chair and served on [3:08:05] that board as director for many [3:08:07] years. I know that they try to [3:08:09] budgets two reports. One that [3:08:11] was released late last year. [3:08:13] That was a completely separate [3:08:15] investigation. That was into [3:08:16] the proposed acquisition of a [3:08:21] tustin property, which [3:08:22] ultimately was not consummated. [3:08:25] That was not an investigation [3:08:26] into MR. Do. That was based [3:08:29] upon a whistle blower claim that [3:08:31] was made by an employee. He was [3:08:32] part of that. He was all over [3:08:34] that narrative. But it wasn't [3:08:36] focused in on him. This audit [3:08:38] in particular that was released [3:08:39] and done by ankura was [3:08:41] specifically focused in on his [3:08:43] possible influence on any [3:08:46] funding that MAY have gone [3:08:48] through the agency. So the [3:08:50] board initiated this. It was [3:08:52] not obligated to do this. But [3:08:54] it wanted to make sure that in [3:08:56] the effort and in the spirit of [3:08:57] transparency -- they wanted to [3:08:59] make sure that they looked back [3:09:00] and saw what his dealings were [3:09:03] there. And although it was [3:09:05] inclusive, that doesn't mean [3:09:06] that there weren't findings or [3:09:08] recommendations that we could [3:09:09] take and use going forward. And [3:09:11] that's where I use praise for [3:09:14] the report. It be wasn't really [3:09:15] for the findings. I know that [3:09:17] there was some difficulty by the [3:09:19] auditors to access information. [3:09:22] That, I'm certainly not [3:09:24] praising. I think there's some [3:09:26] work and improvements that could [3:09:27] be done, but to the extent that [3:09:28] the board took it upon itself to [3:09:30] initiate and complete these -- [3:09:33] both an investigation and an [3:09:36] audit -- I think are good steps [3:09:38] for public agencies that are [3:09:40] trying to make sure that there [3:09:42] is good governance, [3:09:43] transparency, oversight and [3:09:46] there is work to be done [3:09:47] obviously from the [3:09:48] recommendations that were cited. [3:09:49] So that's something that I'm [3:09:50] sure the board will undertake. [3:09:52] But there have been already [3:09:53] action taken by the board, [3:09:54] strengthening the grant's [3:09:56] management policy, [3:09:58] standardsizing processes and [3:09:59] improving oversight on every [3:10:01] grant and updating the conflict [3:10:02] of interest policy to clarify [3:10:04] when conflicts must be [3:10:05] disclosed. [3:10:06] That was done here at county [3:10:08] because we know that was abused [3:10:10] by a former supervisor do. So [3:10:13] to the extent that there is [3:10:14] continuing work to be done, [3:10:16] obviously there was -- you know, [3:10:18] there's some compliance and [3:10:19] improvements that need to be [3:10:20] made. We know there is work to [3:10:23] be done. But to the extent that [3:10:25] this health plan doesn't just [3:10:27] necessarily do medical care. We [3:10:30] know that at caloptima, what we [3:10:32] see is good healthcare means [3:10:35] house, to make sure people have [3:10:36] a roof over their head is an [3:10:39] india of how people can be [3:10:40] either healthy or ill, access, [3:10:43] which is why we stood up for [3:10:45] programs doing street medicine, [3:10:46] which is basically doctors' [3:10:49] offices on wheels, which helps [3:10:52] people on the street so they can [3:10:55] receive medical care and [3:10:56] eventually get housing. Also we [3:10:58] know that many of our members [3:10:59] suffer from swo substance abuse [3:11:05] and we had narcan that was [3:11:06] distributed throughout the [3:11:07] county to make sure people had [3:11:09] that who were addicted or use [3:11:15] fentanyl. We know many of our [3:11:16] members suffer from food [3:11:18] insecurity, which is why 1.2 [3:11:20] million was dedicated to second [3:11:22] harvest and cap oc to make sure [3:11:24] that we address those issues. [3:11:26] So the reason why I think that's [3:11:28] relevant is because this health [3:11:30] plan now, again, dispenses more [3:11:32] than just medical care. It does [3:11:35] grants. It works, community [3:11:36] partners and providers, and a [3:11:39] lot of times, you know, it is [3:11:40] not as familiar as maybe some of [3:11:42] the agencies that, you know, do [3:11:44] oversight compliance and [3:11:46] tracking of funds, you know, as [3:11:49] often as this health plan does. [3:11:51] We will certainly get into that, [3:11:55] you know, routine of making sure [3:11:59] that they track these things [3:12:00] better, and looking back, having [3:12:02] audits done, investigations [3:12:03] done, there are opportunities [3:12:05] for us to improve both here at [3:12:07] the county and at caloptima and [3:12:09] make sure that all public [3:12:10] dollars are accounted for, [3:12:13] there's responsibility and [3:12:14] oversight on those. So I just [3:12:15] wanted to make some clarity on, [3:12:17] that that I am very proud of our [3:12:19] board who undertook these things [3:12:20] voluntarily. Much work to be [3:12:22] done, and I believe a lot of [3:12:24] compliance training that, you [3:12:26] know, that plan could learn [3:12:28] from, you know, agencies that we [3:12:30] all sit on that do very good [3:12:31] work on track and oversight. So [3:12:33] with that, MR. Chair, those are [3:12:35] my comments for the day. [3:12:36] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank you [3:12:37] supervisor. I will make a few [3:12:39] of my own. First, I'd like to [3:12:40] thank supervisor nguyen for [3:12:43] setting up the little seance we [3:12:45] had with the hud people and the [3:12:46] staff that attend as well, and [3:12:49] particularly our ceo. It was, I [3:12:53] thought, a good rapport that was [3:12:56] established, something I don't [3:12:58] think we've had in the past. [3:12:59] You can look at all of the words [3:13:01] in your application, but when [3:13:02] you put it face to face, it [3:13:04] really helps. I think we'll [3:13:06] move forward successfully when [3:13:08] we get to those various [3:13:11] applications that they were [3:13:12] talking about. And I had my [3:13:16] usual good time on valentine's [3:13:18] day. My eighth year in a row [3:13:19] that I've spent in the clerk's [3:13:20] office officiating weddings. I [3:13:23] was able to do six of them this [3:13:26] last valentine's day at the [3:13:28] anaheim office. And that for me [3:13:30] is always fun, to see some happy [3:13:32] people and participate in their [3:13:35] joy. We have a couple events [3:13:40] coming up. We have our elder [3:13:43] fraud prevention. There it is. [3:13:47] Up, there coming up this [3:13:48] thursday. Elderly people are [3:13:52] probability most often scammed [3:13:54] group. So we want to give them [3:13:55] as much information so they can [3:13:57] protect themselves. So that's [3:13:59] coming up. The information is [3:14:00] up there. It is thursday at [3:14:03] noon. We'll have a little [3:14:05] something to eat, as well, being [3:14:07] noontime. And then more fun, on [3:14:11] MARCH 14, coming up, assuming no [3:14:14] rain, we will be holding another [3:14:17] fishing derby for kids. On [3:14:19] MARCH 14, beginning at 8:00, [3:14:23] ending at 11:00. We do have [3:14:24] fish rods and bait and all that [3:14:25] and the lake will be stocked. I [3:14:27] hope you like catfish because [3:14:28] that's what we have available at [3:14:31] this time. Always fun to see a [3:14:36] 5-year-old hold up a two-foot [3:14:38] catfish. Almost the same height [3:14:40] when they hold that up. If you [3:14:44] have a fishing license after 11, [3:14:46] there's still plenty of fish [3:14:47] there, you can join in, even [3:14:50] though you're not a kid. So [3:14:52] some fun things coming up for [3:14:54] me. We also at the end of the [3:14:55] day appreciate the orange county [3:14:58] employee association coming in [3:14:59] and providing lunch with their [3:15:02] hot dog machine that they have [3:15:03] there. So ceo agruye [3:15:04] rey, do you [3:15:06] have any -- ceo aguirre, do you [3:15:06] have any comments you'd like to [3:15:07] make. [3:15:11] >>michelle aguirre: I'll echo [3:15:12] the comments from yourself and [3:15:14] also from supervisor nguyen [3:15:15] related to our meeting with hud [3:15:16] on friday night. I think one of [3:15:18] the things that I found to be [3:15:19] most impactful was when we were [3:15:21] speaking about clearing the [3:15:23] riverbed, and a couple of the [3:15:24] graduates of the oc rescue [3:15:26] mission from actually on the [3:15:28] riverbed at that time. So it [3:15:30] was great to be able to [3:15:31] communicate with them and hear [3:15:33] their stories. [3:15:34] I thought it [3:15:35] was a great night also. So [3:15:37] thank you. And just one [3:15:39] shout-out, so this past friday, [3:15:41] the ceo government affairs and [3:15:44] communications team conducted an [3:15:46] oc cares photo shoot to dewpoint [3:15:49] the great work that our oc cares [3:15:51] initiative is doing. And it was [3:15:54] at craig regional park in [3:15:56] fullerton. We just want to give [3:15:59] kudos to the four parpght [3:16:02] probation officers, michael [3:16:04] castill, colleen burn, francisco [3:16:07] free was, and jorge cast none [3:16:09] for their time, professionalism [3:16:11] and their commitment to this [3:16:12] initiative and to our community [3:16:14] partner project kinship for [3:16:16] their participation. And then [3:16:18] this was right after the stormy [3:16:21] weather that we had last week. [3:16:23] And so a big thank you to the oc [3:16:26] parks crew who went above and [3:16:28] beyond to ensure that we had a [3:16:31] successful production at craig [3:16:33] park. Park ranger james kim, [3:16:36] supervising park ranger jason [3:16:37] arthur along with our [3:16:39] maintenance team of chavez, [3:16:42] caesar, alvarez and enrique [3:16:45] ororsco led a clean-up effort, [3:16:50] even repainting the hand ball [3:16:52] court before the photo shoot, [3:16:55] cleaning up debris, and just a [3:16:59] shout-out to you. Greatly [3:17:00] appreciate all of your efforts. [3:17:02] Thank you, chair. [3:17:03] >>chair, doug chaffee: thank you [3:17:04] MADAM Ceo. MADAM Clerk, you can [3:17:13] read the closed-session items. [3:17:15] >>clerk, robin stieler: cs-1 has [3:17:15] been deleted. [3:17:16] >>clerk, robin stieler: cs-2. [3:17:17] Public employee performance [3:17:20] evaluation-pursuant to [3:17:20] government code section 54957(B): [3:17:22] title:executive director of the [3:17:25] campaign finance and ethics commission. [3:17:26] (Continued from 2/10/26, item cs-2) [3:17:29] Scs3. County counsel- [3:17:29] conference with legal counsel- [3:17:30] existing litigation-pursuant [3:17:31] to government code section 54956.9(D)(1): [3:17:34] name of case: mind oc v. County [3:17:37] of orange, orange county [3:17:38] superior court case [3:17:38] no.: 30-2024-01442012-cu-co-cjc. [3:17:39] Scs4. County counsel- [3:17:40] conference with legal counsel- [3:17:41] existing litigation-pursuant [3:17:43] to government code section 54956.9(D)(1): [3:17:45] name of cases: clarisse magtoto [3:17:48] v. County of orange, orange [3:18:01] county superior court case no. 30-2022-01241335, [3:18:02] amy tallakson v. County of [3:18:02] orange, orange county superior [3:18:03] court case no. 30-2022-01241346, [3:18:04] shabnum azizi v. County of [3:18:05] orange, orange county superior [3:18:06] court case no. 30-2022-01232544, [3:18:06] mallory miller v. County of [3:18:07] orange, orange county superior [3:18:08] court case no. 30-2022-01252436, [3:18:09] bethel cope-vega v. County of [3:18:10] orange, orange county superior [3:18:10] court case no. 30-2022-01252452, [3:18:11] mohammad abuershaid v. County of [3:18:12] orange, orange county superior [3:18:13] court case no. 30-2022-01243989, [3:18:14] and tracy miller v. County of [3:18:15] orange et al., orange county [3:18:18] superior court case no. 30-2022-01262015. [3:18:19] >>chair, doug chaffee: we are [3:18:24] adjourned to closed sessions. [3:20:29] >>leon page: pursuant to [3:20:33] government code section 5 foifer [3:20:34] 5497b and section d the board [3:20:35] met in closed sessions to [3:20:37] discuss the items referenced on [3:20:40] today's agenda as cs2, cs3, and [3:20:44] scs4. Cs1 was actually deleted. [3:20:45] With respect to those three [3:20:47] items the board took no [3:20:48] reportable action in closed [3:20:49] sessions today. Thank you. [3:20:51] >>clerk, robin stieler: that [3:20:52] concludes today'sed a. The next [3:20:53] meeting is scheduled for tuesday [3:20:55] MARCH 10th at 9:30 A.M. [3:20:56] Today's meeting of the orange [3:21:00] county board of supervisors