1 00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:08,299 2 00:00:08,299 --> 00:00:24,302 3 00:00:24,302 --> 00:00:40,220 4 00:00:40,220 --> 00:00:56,290 5 00:00:56,290 --> 00:01:12,224 6 00:01:12,224 --> 00:01:25,208 7 00:01:25,208 --> 00:01:41,181 8 00:01:41,181 --> 00:01:57,197 9 00:01:57,197 --> 00:02:13,142 10 00:02:13,142 --> 00:02:29,179 11 00:02:29,179 --> 00:02:45,128 12 00:02:45,128 --> 00:03:01,150 13 00:03:01,150 --> 00:03:17,134 14 00:03:17,134 --> 00:03:17,134 15 00:03:17,134 --> 00:03:25,993 >> mayor: good morning, 16 00:03:25,993 --> 00:03:25,993 everyone. 17 00:03:25,993 --> 00:03:27,797 welcome to the gainesville cit 18 00:03:27,797 --> 00:03:28,029 y 19 00:03:28,029 --> 00:03:28,029 commission. 20 00:03:28,029 --> 00:03:30,477 as we speak, there are three 21 00:03:30,477 --> 00:03:32,600 americans and a canadian on 22 00:03:32,600 --> 00:03:36,968 their way to the moon from 23 00:03:36,968 --> 00:03:36,968 florida. 24 00:03:36,968 --> 00:03:38,677 from right here in the sunshine 25 00:03:38,677 --> 00:03:38,875 26 00:03:38,875 --> 00:03:38,875 state. 27 00:03:38,875 --> 00:03:41,645 one of those americans is a 28 00:03:41,645 --> 00:03:43,242 black man piloting the ship. 29 00:03:43,242 --> 00:03:46,415 one is a woman for the first 30 00:03:46,415 --> 00:03:48,461 time, it's the first time a 31 00:03:48,461 --> 00:03:50,057 black man or a woman have gone 32 00:03:50,057 --> 00:03:50,351 33 00:03:50,351 --> 00:03:50,646 to the moon. 34 00:03:50,646 --> 00:03:52,387 we should take note of this, and 35 00:03:52,387 --> 00:03:52,387 36 00:03:52,387 --> 00:03:55,789 it gives me hope that if we as 37 00:03:55,789 --> 00:03:56,063 a 38 00:03:56,063 --> 00:03:58,197 nation and a world are able to 39 00:03:58,197 --> 00:03:59,124 40 00:03:59,124 --> 00:04:00,730 send people to the moon -- 41 00:04:00,730 --> 00:04:01,965 again, from the sunshine state, 42 00:04:01,965 --> 00:04:02,444 43 00:04:02,444 --> 00:04:04,273 not anywhere else, that we can 44 00:04:04,273 --> 00:04:04,629 45 00:04:04,629 --> 00:04:07,232 do some great things for our 46 00:04:07,232 --> 00:04:08,933 folks right here in this room 47 00:04:08,933 --> 00:04:08,933 48 00:04:08,933 --> 00:04:08,933 today. 49 00:04:08,933 --> 00:04:10,033 madam clerk? 50 00:04:10,033 --> 00:04:12,303 >> mr. Mayor, we have the 51 00:04:12,303 --> 00:04:22,922 invocation, given by reverend 52 00:04:22,922 --> 00:04:22,922 53 00:04:22,922 --> 00:04:23,282 katherine dearlove. 54 00:04:23,282 --> 00:04:24,867 >> thank you. 55 00:04:24,867 --> 00:04:28,201 I invite you to pray or reflect 56 00:04:28,201 --> 00:04:28,489 57 00:04:28,489 --> 00:04:28,893 with me. 58 00:04:28,893 --> 00:04:30,305 let's pause for a moment of 59 00:04:30,305 --> 00:04:30,305 reflection. 60 00:04:30,305 --> 00:04:37,730 grounding ourselves in the 61 00:04:37,730 --> 00:04:39,399 shared reason that brings us 62 00:04:39,399 --> 00:04:39,399 today. 63 00:04:39,399 --> 00:04:43,161 we come from many shared 64 00:04:43,161 --> 00:04:44,303 experiences, some of us name t 65 00:04:44,303 --> 00:04:44,303 he 66 00:04:44,303 --> 00:04:46,608 sacred as god, the spirit, 67 00:04:46,608 --> 00:04:47,578 creator or source of life. 68 00:04:47,578 --> 00:04:50,091 some of us find meaning in hum 69 00:04:50,091 --> 00:04:50,091 an 70 00:04:50,091 --> 00:04:52,513 connection and justice and 71 00:04:52,513 --> 00:04:52,513 compassion. 72 00:04:52,513 --> 00:04:55,781 or in the quiet wisdom of 73 00:04:55,781 --> 00:04:55,781 conscience. 74 00:04:55,781 --> 00:04:58,375 whatever our path, we are united 75 00:04:58,375 --> 00:04:58,375 76 00:04:58,375 --> 00:04:59,455 in the responsibility serving 77 00:04:59,455 --> 00:04:59,455 78 00:04:59,455 --> 00:04:59,766 the common good. 79 00:04:59,766 --> 00:05:05,934 may this gathering be guided b 80 00:05:05,934 --> 00:05:06,257 y 81 00:05:06,257 --> 00:05:06,257 wisdom. 82 00:05:06,257 --> 00:05:10,806 the wisdom to weigh decisions 83 00:05:10,806 --> 00:05:10,806 84 00:05:10,806 --> 00:05:11,632 carefully, and seek 85 00:05:11,632 --> 00:05:12,123 understanding even in 86 00:05:12,123 --> 00:05:12,123 disagreement. 87 00:05:12,123 --> 00:05:18,022 may we be guided by courage, t 88 00:05:18,022 --> 00:05:18,022 he 89 00:05:18,022 --> 00:05:20,249 courage to act with integrity. 90 00:05:20,249 --> 00:05:20,249 91 00:05:20,249 --> 00:05:22,215 to stand for what is right and 92 00:05:22,215 --> 00:05:22,581 93 00:05:22,581 --> 00:05:22,581 just. 94 00:05:22,581 --> 00:05:24,999 and to make decisions that ser 95 00:05:24,999 --> 00:05:24,999 ve 96 00:05:24,999 --> 00:05:25,983 not only the present but the 97 00:05:25,983 --> 00:05:25,983 future. 98 00:05:25,983 --> 00:05:34,118 may we be guided by compassion 99 00:05:34,118 --> 00:05:35,189 , 100 00:05:35,189 --> 00:05:36,957 that every policy, every 101 00:05:36,957 --> 00:05:38,199 discussion, every vote touches 102 00:05:38,199 --> 00:05:38,426 103 00:05:38,426 --> 00:05:40,134 the lives of the real people I 104 00:05:40,134 --> 00:05:40,261 n 105 00:05:40,261 --> 00:05:40,594 our community. 106 00:05:40,594 --> 00:05:43,695 especially those whose voices 107 00:05:43,695 --> 00:05:43,695 108 00:05:43,695 --> 00:05:44,461 are too often unheard. 109 00:05:44,461 --> 00:05:47,465 and may we be guided by 110 00:05:47,465 --> 00:05:48,485 humility, recognizing that non 111 00:05:48,485 --> 00:05:48,650 e 112 00:05:48,650 --> 00:05:56,320 of us holds all the answers, b 113 00:05:56,320 --> 00:05:56,320 ut 114 00:05:56,320 --> 00:05:58,325 together we can move through a 115 00:05:58,325 --> 00:05:58,582 116 00:05:58,582 --> 00:06:00,747 more just and inclusive and 117 00:06:00,747 --> 00:06:01,179 thriving community. 118 00:06:01,179 --> 00:06:04,169 in this spirit, let the work 119 00:06:04,169 --> 00:06:07,351 begin today with open minds, 120 00:06:07,351 --> 00:06:09,729 steady hearts and a dedication 121 00:06:09,729 --> 00:06:09,951 122 00:06:09,951 --> 00:06:10,633 to the well being of all. 123 00:06:10,633 --> 00:06:10,633 amen. 124 00:06:10,633 --> 00:06:19,586 >> mayor: thank you, pastor. 125 00:06:19,586 --> 00:06:23,172 >> we are on to the agenda, we 126 00:06:23,172 --> 00:06:23,607 127 00:06:23,607 --> 00:06:24,378 have the update list on the 128 00:06:24,378 --> 00:06:24,378 screen. 129 00:06:24,378 --> 00:06:33,435 >> mayor: commissioner willit 130 00:06:33,435 --> 00:06:33,435 s? 131 00:06:33,435 --> 00:06:46,265 >> I'd like to pull 2026-024 - 132 00:06:46,265 --> 00:06:46,429 - 133 00:06:46,429 --> 00:06:47,730 >> what number? 134 00:06:47,730 --> 00:06:50,666 >> number ten on the consent. 135 00:06:50,666 --> 00:06:52,802 >> let's move that to item one 136 00:06:52,802 --> 00:06:52,929 137 00:06:52,929 --> 00:06:53,369 on the morning. 138 00:06:53,369 --> 00:06:54,599 >> that sounds good. 139 00:06:54,599 --> 00:06:55,233 >> s 140 00:06:55,233 --> 00:06:55,233 changes. 141 00:06:55,233 --> 00:07:04,505 >> mayor: before we move on. 142 00:07:04,505 --> 00:07:05,586 is there public comment? 143 00:07:05,586 --> 00:07:07,909 >> there is no public comment. 144 00:07:07,909 --> 00:07:07,909 145 00:07:07,909 --> 00:07:09,124 >> I would point out to you tha 146 00:07:09,124 --> 00:07:09,124 t 147 00:07:09,124 --> 00:07:15,895 on the consent agenda, are a 148 00:07:15,895 --> 00:07:17,599 multiplicity of items that the 149 00:07:17,599 --> 00:07:18,761 150 00:07:18,761 --> 00:07:21,701 audit committee considered and 151 00:07:21,701 --> 00:07:22,026 152 00:07:22,026 --> 00:07:23,569 passed on to us, if anyone has 153 00:07:23,569 --> 00:07:23,836 154 00:07:23,836 --> 00:07:24,795 any questions about those, our 155 00:07:24,795 --> 00:07:25,317 156 00:07:25,317 --> 00:07:26,811 city auditor is here, and I 157 00:07:26,811 --> 00:07:28,584 would encourage you to make tim 158 00:07:28,584 --> 00:07:28,584 e 159 00:07:28,584 --> 00:07:29,285 to speak with him offline. 160 00:07:29,285 --> 00:07:37,243 about that, they all received 161 00:07:37,243 --> 00:07:37,243 162 00:07:37,243 --> 00:07:38,779 unanimous vote, all two of us, 163 00:07:38,779 --> 00:07:40,115 164 00:07:40,115 --> 00:07:40,981 from the audit committee. 165 00:07:40,981 --> 00:07:43,189 I don't want those to go 166 00:07:43,189 --> 00:07:43,189 unnoticed. 167 00:07:43,189 --> 00:07:45,588 but I'm glad we can keep them 168 00:07:45,588 --> 00:07:49,605 the consent agenda to receive. 169 00:07:49,605 --> 00:07:49,605 170 00:07:49,605 --> 00:07:51,836 that said, madam clerk, all in 171 00:07:51,836 --> 00:07:52,159 172 00:07:52,159 --> 00:07:52,159 favor? 173 00:07:52,159 --> 00:07:53,563 >> aye. 174 00:07:53,563 --> 00:07:54,561 >> mayor: any opposed? 175 00:07:54,561 --> 00:07:55,022 that passes unanimously. 176 00:07:55,022 --> 00:08:03,674 >> mr. Mayor, 2026-234, oak par 177 00:08:03,674 --> 00:08:03,674 k 178 00:08:03,674 --> 00:08:11,013 public housing development 179 00:08:11,013 --> 00:08:11,480 disposition letter of support. 180 00:08:11,480 --> 00:08:11,480 181 00:08:11,480 --> 00:08:22,317 for rehabilitation of oak park 182 00:08:22,317 --> 00:08:22,317 183 00:08:22,317 --> 00:08:22,883 development in gainesville, 184 00:08:22,883 --> 00:08:22,883 florida. 185 00:08:22,883 --> 00:08:26,127 >> mayor: commissioner willits, 186 00:08:26,127 --> 00:08:26,461 187 00:08:26,461 --> 00:08:27,531 you had the question? 188 00:08:27,531 --> 00:08:31,102 >> mr. Harris remind us abo 189 00:08:31,102 --> 00:08:33,146 what support we've provided to 190 00:08:33,146 --> 00:08:33,239 191 00:08:33,239 --> 00:08:33,901 this project in particular, 192 00:08:33,901 --> 00:08:41,193 through gainesville housing. 193 00:08:41,193 --> 00:08:41,893 >> mayor: certainly. 194 00:08:41,893 --> 00:08:42,543 mr. Manager? 195 00:08:42,543 --> 00:08:44,982 >> good morning, mr. Mayor, to 196 00:08:44,982 --> 00:08:45,145 197 00:08:45,145 --> 00:08:45,735 the commission. 198 00:08:45,735 --> 00:08:49,487 our support has been related t 199 00:08:49,487 --> 00:08:49,820 o 200 00:08:49,820 --> 00:08:52,357 our connect free funds as a par 201 00:08:52,357 --> 00:08:52,357 t 202 00:08:52,357 --> 00:08:53,155 of the sale applications. 203 00:08:53,155 --> 00:08:57,598 so it's a grant for 37,500, so 204 00:08:57,598 --> 00:08:57,857 205 00:08:57,857 --> 00:08:59,927 they can apply for the sale 206 00:08:59,927 --> 00:08:59,927 program. 207 00:08:59,927 --> 00:09:02,461 >> okay, and this is a park 208 00:09:02,461 --> 00:09:04,165 which is going to be -- these 209 00:09:04,165 --> 00:09:04,165 210 00:09:04,165 --> 00:09:06,567 are all single units. 211 00:09:06,567 --> 00:09:08,971 my understanding of, it's not 212 00:09:08,971 --> 00:09:08,971 213 00:09:08,971 --> 00:09:11,007 our project, it's the 214 00:09:11,007 --> 00:09:12,673 gainesville housing authority' 215 00:09:12,673 --> 00:09:15,408 s 216 00:09:15,408 --> 00:09:15,408 product. 217 00:09:15,408 --> 00:09:18,074 >> if you don't mind, the 218 00:09:18,074 --> 00:09:20,676 developer is here, gha is here 219 00:09:20,676 --> 00:09:20,676 . 220 00:09:20,676 --> 00:09:22,787 I'm going to allow him to talk 221 00:09:22,787 --> 00:09:23,078 222 00:09:23,078 --> 00:09:23,673 about the project. 223 00:09:23,673 --> 00:09:26,451 >> that was who I was looking 224 00:09:26,451 --> 00:09:26,451 225 00:09:26,451 --> 00:09:26,813 for real quick. 226 00:09:26,813 --> 00:09:30,445 if you can give us the 30 second 227 00:09:30,445 --> 00:09:30,445 228 00:09:30,445 --> 00:09:30,445 reminder. 229 00:09:30,445 --> 00:09:39,541 >> malcolm kynes. 230 00:09:39,541 --> 00:09:43,767 oak park is a six story 231 00:09:43,767 --> 00:09:47,321 development, off main street a 232 00:09:47,321 --> 00:09:47,321 nd 233 00:09:47,321 --> 00:09:48,505 8th avenue. 234 00:09:48,505 --> 00:09:53,345 we have 1 two bedroom, 60 235 00:09:53,345 --> 00:09:56,597 studios and 401 bedroom units. 236 00:09:56,597 --> 00:09:56,597 237 00:09:56,597 --> 00:09:58,953 this is a total redevelopment o 238 00:09:58,953 --> 00:09:58,953 f 239 00:09:58,953 --> 00:09:59,789 the oak park building. 240 00:09:59,789 --> 00:10:01,235 it needs a lot of love. 241 00:10:01,235 --> 00:10:03,569 it was -- I think it opened in 242 00:10:03,569 --> 00:10:03,893 243 00:10:03,893 --> 00:10:05,095 1968 or '69. 244 00:10:05,095 --> 00:10:07,089 and so you can imagine how many 245 00:10:07,089 --> 00:10:07,413 246 00:10:07,413 --> 00:10:10,501 individuals and families that 247 00:10:10,501 --> 00:10:10,501 248 00:10:10,501 --> 00:10:12,605 building has serviced over it' 249 00:10:12,605 --> 00:10:13,840 s 250 00:10:13,840 --> 00:10:15,073 56 or so year life. 251 00:10:15,073 --> 00:10:16,843 total development costs are in 252 00:10:16,843 --> 00:10:16,969 253 00:10:16,969 --> 00:10:19,405 the range, I don't want to 254 00:10:19,405 --> 00:10:22,695 misspeak, in the range of 38 t 255 00:10:22,695 --> 00:10:22,810 o 256 00:10:22,810 --> 00:10:23,941 $39 million of this developmen 257 00:10:23,941 --> 00:10:23,941 t. 258 00:10:23,941 --> 00:10:26,248 we have hired a relocation 259 00:10:26,248 --> 00:10:28,361 specialist, similar to our 260 00:10:28,361 --> 00:10:29,319 woodland park project, which 261 00:10:29,319 --> 00:10:31,183 will help enable those 262 00:10:31,183 --> 00:10:31,785 individuals to relocate. 263 00:10:31,785 --> 00:10:33,617 they will walk them through it 264 00:10:33,617 --> 00:10:34,121 , 265 00:10:34,121 --> 00:10:35,653 they have certain rights 266 00:10:35,653 --> 00:10:36,495 assigned by the federal 267 00:10:36,495 --> 00:10:38,255 government, we ensure those 268 00:10:38,255 --> 00:10:39,941 folks are taken care of. 269 00:10:39,941 --> 00:10:41,783 once the building has been 270 00:10:41,783 --> 00:10:42,133 totally redeveloped. 271 00:10:42,133 --> 00:10:45,549 this letter is basically a 272 00:10:45,549 --> 00:10:47,865 letter saying that the city of 273 00:10:47,865 --> 00:10:48,301 274 00:10:48,301 --> 00:10:49,499 gainesville supports us in 275 00:10:49,499 --> 00:10:51,241 redeveloping the property, and 276 00:10:51,241 --> 00:10:51,537 277 00:10:51,537 --> 00:10:53,282 it's provided to hud, it's a 278 00:10:53,282 --> 00:10:54,100 form letter we sent over to th 279 00:10:54,100 --> 00:10:54,148 e 280 00:10:54,148 --> 00:10:54,393 manager's office. 281 00:10:54,393 --> 00:10:55,851 >> thanks. 282 00:10:55,851 --> 00:11:00,031 a few comments on this before w 283 00:11:00,031 --> 00:11:00,031 e 284 00:11:00,031 --> 00:11:00,849 move forward. 285 00:11:00,849 --> 00:11:02,953 we support gainesville housing 286 00:11:02,953 --> 00:11:03,183 287 00:11:03,183 --> 00:11:04,786 authority in different ways, 288 00:11:04,786 --> 00:11:06,516 sometimes big chunks, sometimes 289 00:11:06,516 --> 00:11:06,692 290 00:11:06,692 --> 00:11:07,024 small chunks. 291 00:11:07,024 --> 00:11:08,525 this is something that app 292 00:11:08,525 --> 00:11:12,312 for our larger chunk, affordabl 293 00:11:12,312 --> 00:11:12,312 e 294 00:11:12,312 --> 00:11:14,496 development housing funds that 295 00:11:14,496 --> 00:11:14,804 296 00:11:14,804 --> 00:11:17,337 were leftover from arpa and to 297 00:11:17,337 --> 00:11:17,564 298 00:11:17,564 --> 00:11:18,002 general fund. 299 00:11:18,002 --> 00:11:19,938 did not receive, but we did hav 300 00:11:19,938 --> 00:11:19,938 e 301 00:11:19,938 --> 00:11:22,167 at least the small amount. 302 00:11:22,167 --> 00:11:24,205 our community has a lot of 303 00:11:24,205 --> 00:11:26,238 expectations on how we spend o 304 00:11:26,238 --> 00:11:26,238 ur 305 00:11:26,238 --> 00:11:28,441 affordable housing dollars, 306 00:11:28,441 --> 00:11:29,382 there's currently some concerns 307 00:11:29,382 --> 00:11:29,382 , 308 00:11:29,382 --> 00:11:31,649 I know that commissioner dunca 309 00:11:31,649 --> 00:11:32,382 n 310 00:11:32,382 --> 00:11:36,480 walker, speak of the devil -- 311 00:11:36,480 --> 00:11:36,480 312 00:11:36,480 --> 00:11:37,064 speak of the commissioner, 313 00:11:37,064 --> 00:11:38,957 excuse me. 314 00:11:38,957 --> 00:11:44,660 some on going concerns, maybe 315 00:11:44,660 --> 00:11:44,660 316 00:11:44,660 --> 00:11:46,690 this is out of frustration, 317 00:11:46,690 --> 00:11:48,364 general housing crisis or at 318 00:11:48,364 --> 00:11:50,906 least tightness in the market, 319 00:11:50,906 --> 00:11:50,906 320 00:11:50,906 --> 00:11:53,634 where below 100% of ami, we 321 00:11:53,634 --> 00:11:55,876 really need more units, more 322 00:11:55,876 --> 00:11:57,003 affordability, so that -- I 323 00:11:57,003 --> 00:12:00,840 think it's part of our -- 324 00:12:00,840 --> 00:12:02,084 tension we're feeling, we're 325 00:12:02,084 --> 00:12:03,386 looking at all of our partners 326 00:12:03,386 --> 00:12:03,563 327 00:12:03,563 --> 00:12:05,950 to achieve at their highest and 328 00:12:05,950 --> 00:12:06,375 329 00:12:06,375 --> 00:12:06,375 best. 330 00:12:06,375 --> 00:12:08,390 but that also means not just 331 00:12:08,390 --> 00:12:11,082 the -- I'm a big fan of new 332 00:12:11,082 --> 00:12:12,777 units, existing units about the 333 00:12:12,777 --> 00:12:12,884 334 00:12:12,884 --> 00:12:14,461 quality of them, and how peopl 335 00:12:14,461 --> 00:12:14,852 e 336 00:12:14,852 --> 00:12:16,697 live in those -- how our 337 00:12:16,697 --> 00:12:17,690 neighbors live in those homes, 338 00:12:17,690 --> 00:12:17,957 I 339 00:12:17,957 --> 00:12:20,534 want to bring it up as a conce 340 00:12:20,534 --> 00:12:20,534 rn 341 00:12:20,534 --> 00:12:21,026 of mine. 342 00:12:21,026 --> 00:12:24,074 and when we put our stamp of 343 00:12:24,074 --> 00:12:25,406 approval on the letter and cas 344 00:12:25,406 --> 00:12:26,464 h 345 00:12:26,464 --> 00:12:29,019 funds, the auditor, I spoke to 346 00:12:29,019 --> 00:12:29,019 347 00:12:29,019 --> 00:12:30,605 the auditor recently about, how 348 00:12:30,605 --> 00:12:30,837 349 00:12:30,837 --> 00:12:32,680 on some of our grant funding, w 350 00:12:32,680 --> 00:12:32,680 e 351 00:12:32,680 --> 00:12:34,542 don't have a strict policy abo 352 00:12:34,542 --> 00:12:34,542 ut 353 00:12:34,542 --> 00:12:36,289 the ability to audit, at least 354 00:12:36,289 --> 00:12:36,443 355 00:12:36,443 --> 00:12:38,411 the funds we give of our 356 00:12:38,411 --> 00:12:40,443 nonprofit partners, that is 357 00:12:40,443 --> 00:12:41,816 something suggested by the 358 00:12:41,816 --> 00:12:43,330 auditors, something we need in 359 00:12:43,330 --> 00:12:44,516 360 00:12:44,516 --> 00:12:47,223 every time we give money. 361 00:12:47,223 --> 00:12:48,679 because we are responsible for 362 00:12:48,679 --> 00:12:49,094 363 00:12:49,094 --> 00:12:49,692 the money we give. 364 00:12:49,692 --> 00:12:52,392 to our taxpayers, to our 365 00:12:52,392 --> 00:12:53,596 residents, to our neighbors, I 366 00:12:53,596 --> 00:12:53,761 367 00:12:53,761 --> 00:12:55,144 bring this up as a concern I'm 368 00:12:55,144 --> 00:12:55,806 369 00:12:55,806 --> 00:12:57,065 hearing in the community about 370 00:12:57,065 --> 00:12:57,434 371 00:12:57,434 --> 00:12:58,657 the long term relationship 372 00:12:58,657 --> 00:13:00,164 between the city and gainesvil 373 00:13:00,164 --> 00:13:00,164 le 374 00:13:00,164 --> 00:13:02,702 housing authority and that it 375 00:13:02,702 --> 00:13:02,702 376 00:13:02,702 --> 00:13:02,936 goes forward. 377 00:13:02,936 --> 00:13:05,274 again, I say some of this to m 378 00:13:05,274 --> 00:13:05,669 y 379 00:13:05,669 --> 00:13:06,780 colleagues is about the tension 380 00:13:06,780 --> 00:13:06,958 381 00:13:06,958 --> 00:13:10,177 we feel, the angst we feel, 382 00:13:10,177 --> 00:13:11,382 we're trying to figure out eve 383 00:13:11,382 --> 00:13:11,382 ry 384 00:13:11,382 --> 00:13:13,176 last thing we do, limited 385 00:13:13,176 --> 00:13:15,581 budget, but how we spend it wit 386 00:13:15,581 --> 00:13:15,581 h 387 00:13:15,581 --> 00:13:17,820 whom, which partners, we have 388 00:13:17,820 --> 00:13:17,820 389 00:13:17,820 --> 00:13:22,395 several partners, some of them 390 00:13:22,395 --> 00:13:22,651 391 00:13:22,651 --> 00:13:26,427 are private developers who we 392 00:13:26,427 --> 00:13:26,427 393 00:13:26,427 --> 00:13:31,769 provide a substitute and it's a 394 00:13:31,769 --> 00:13:33,205 395 00:13:33,205 --> 00:13:34,219 subsidy per door that brings t 396 00:13:34,219 --> 00:13:34,219 he 397 00:13:34,219 --> 00:13:36,347 prices down, even up to 120% of 398 00:13:36,347 --> 00:13:36,347 399 00:13:36,347 --> 00:13:36,347 ami. 400 00:13:36,347 --> 00:13:41,641 mr. Kiner thank you for being 401 00:13:41,641 --> 00:13:41,641 402 00:13:41,641 --> 00:13:41,641 here. 403 00:13:41,641 --> 00:13:44,141 it's a comment to my fellow 404 00:13:44,141 --> 00:13:44,850 commissioners how we spend our 405 00:13:44,850 --> 00:13:45,356 406 00:13:45,356 --> 00:13:45,356 money. 407 00:13:45,356 --> 00:13:51,357 there's some concerns about the 408 00:13:51,357 --> 00:13:51,641 409 00:13:51,641 --> 00:13:53,616 balance between having to keep 410 00:13:53,616 --> 00:13:53,877 411 00:13:53,877 --> 00:13:56,124 enough money in all of our 412 00:13:56,124 --> 00:13:57,826 partners pockets so they can 413 00:13:57,826 --> 00:14:00,390 build new housing or do 414 00:14:00,390 --> 00:14:01,470 renovations, what happens in th 415 00:14:01,470 --> 00:14:01,470 e 416 00:14:01,470 --> 00:14:02,766 meantime between now and then. 417 00:14:02,766 --> 00:14:02,766 418 00:14:02,766 --> 00:14:04,373 how our neighbors have to live 419 00:14:04,373 --> 00:14:04,876 420 00:14:04,876 --> 00:14:10,706 w they're being serviced by who 421 00:14:10,706 --> 00:14:10,791 by whohey pay thr rent to. 422 00:14:10,791 --> 00:14:11,164 that's all I got. 423 00:14:11,164 --> 00:14:17,887 [ inaudible ] 424 00:14:17,887 --> 00:14:19,146 >> our board has challenged us 425 00:14:19,146 --> 00:14:19,556 , 426 00:14:19,556 --> 00:14:21,490 we just completed a new 427 00:14:21,490 --> 00:14:23,153 strategic plan that will take u 428 00:14:23,153 --> 00:14:23,153 s 429 00:14:23,153 --> 00:14:25,120 from 2025 to 2030. 430 00:14:25,120 --> 00:14:27,795 has challenged us to bring bac 431 00:14:27,795 --> 00:14:27,924 k 432 00:14:27,924 --> 00:14:30,127 on line 600 housing 433 00:14:30,127 --> 00:14:30,127 opportunities. 434 00:14:30,127 --> 00:14:33,156 and an additional 100 through 435 00:14:33,156 --> 00:14:33,156 436 00:14:33,156 --> 00:14:34,090 our instrumentality. 437 00:14:34,090 --> 00:14:35,864 that's our goal, we're 438 00:14:35,864 --> 00:14:36,994 aggressive pursuing that, 439 00:14:36,994 --> 00:14:38,212 through things like the choice 440 00:14:38,212 --> 00:14:38,664 441 00:14:38,664 --> 00:14:40,264 program, and also through rfa' 442 00:14:40,264 --> 00:14:42,040 s 443 00:14:42,040 --> 00:14:46,869 at the state level 444 00:14:46,869 --> 00:14:47,323 >> mayor: very good. 445 00:14:47,323 --> 00:14:50,306 we have multiple lights, 446 00:14:50,306 --> 00:14:50,733 commissioner chestnut. 447 00:14:50,733 --> 00:14:55,287 >> this facility is in my 448 00:14:55,287 --> 00:14:56,480 neighborhood, and as I recall, 449 00:14:56,480 --> 00:14:56,948 450 00:14:56,948 --> 00:14:58,550 the only thing that's been 451 00:14:58,550 --> 00:14:59,180 renovated there has been the 452 00:14:59,180 --> 00:14:59,422 parking lot. 453 00:14:59,422 --> 00:15:05,386 but it is in very dire need of 454 00:15:05,386 --> 00:15:05,861 455 00:15:05,861 --> 00:15:07,800 renovation, and I think that t 456 00:15:07,800 --> 00:15:07,800 he 457 00:15:07,800 --> 00:15:11,162 residents totally welcome this 458 00:15:11,162 --> 00:15:11,162 . 459 00:15:11,162 --> 00:15:13,134 and it's the facility that has 460 00:15:13,134 --> 00:15:13,306 a 461 00:15:13,306 --> 00:15:15,672 mixture of residents, and I 462 00:15:15,672 --> 00:15:16,444 think that's what's very good 463 00:15:16,444 --> 00:15:16,444 464 00:15:16,444 --> 00:15:16,758 about it as well. 465 00:15:16,758 --> 00:15:23,779 >> mayor: thank you, 466 00:15:23,779 --> 00:15:25,459 commissioner chestnut. 467 00:15:25,459 --> 00:15:26,448 >> how many units? 468 00:15:26,448 --> 00:15:32,092 >> it's 101 units. 469 00:15:32,092 --> 00:15:35,896 it's a 60/40 split between one 470 00:15:35,896 --> 00:15:35,987 471 00:15:35,987 --> 00:15:36,320 bedrooms and studios. 472 00:15:36,320 --> 00:15:38,560 >> thank you. 473 00:15:38,560 --> 00:15:40,474 I missed your initial comments 474 00:15:40,474 --> 00:15:41,351 , 475 00:15:41,351 --> 00:15:43,131 but I can certainly prern what 476 00:15:43,131 --> 00:15:43,665 I' 477 00:15:43,665 --> 00:15:44,994 I've heard thus far from my 478 00:15:44,994 --> 00:15:47,006 colleagues, I would like to ask 479 00:15:47,006 --> 00:15:47,230 480 00:15:47,230 --> 00:15:47,230 this. 481 00:15:47,230 --> 00:15:49,375 when was the last time that we 482 00:15:49,375 --> 00:15:49,537 483 00:15:49,537 --> 00:15:52,342 had a meeting with gha? 484 00:15:52,342 --> 00:15:55,676 was it about two years ago, 485 00:15:55,676 --> 00:15:55,676 three? 486 00:15:55,676 --> 00:15:58,346 >> spring of '23? 487 00:15:58,346 --> 00:16:02,233 >> it was april 4, 2023. 488 00:16:02,233 --> 00:16:04,329 >> april 4 of 2023. 489 00:16:04,329 --> 00:16:06,857 >> that was the date the 490 00:16:06,857 --> 00:16:07,544 decision came out for the 491 00:16:07,544 --> 00:16:07,544 choice. 492 00:16:07,544 --> 00:16:09,820 >> I would like to see us meet 493 00:16:09,820 --> 00:16:09,962 a 494 00:16:09,962 --> 00:16:10,991 little more frequently. 495 00:16:10,991 --> 00:16:11,722 >> no problem. 496 00:16:11,722 --> 00:16:13,694 >> I think there is -- clearly 497 00:16:13,694 --> 00:16:13,896 498 00:16:13,896 --> 00:16:15,298 we field a lot of questions tha 499 00:16:15,298 --> 00:16:15,298 t 500 00:16:15,298 --> 00:16:17,196 we can't or shouldn't even 501 00:16:17,196 --> 00:16:18,450 attempt to answer, but also, I 502 00:16:18,450 --> 00:16:18,834 n 503 00:16:18,834 --> 00:16:21,704 light of our partnership, how I 504 00:16:21,704 --> 00:16:21,704 t 505 00:16:21,704 --> 00:16:23,508 may be expanding or what your 506 00:16:23,508 --> 00:16:23,508 507 00:16:23,508 --> 00:16:25,976 desires are, I feel the need t 508 00:16:25,976 --> 00:16:26,103 o 509 00:16:26,103 --> 00:16:26,988 expand our opportunities to 510 00:16:26,988 --> 00:16:29,945 speak with you, so I am curious 511 00:16:29,945 --> 00:16:30,252 512 00:16:30,252 --> 00:16:31,846 about my colleagues and what 513 00:16:31,846 --> 00:16:35,554 your thoughts are on maybe 514 00:16:35,554 --> 00:16:37,127 literally slid fig an annual 515 00:16:37,127 --> 00:16:37,762 meeting at least. 516 00:16:37,762 --> 00:16:40,016 maybe something in -- with roo 517 00:16:40,016 --> 00:16:40,331 m 518 00:16:40,331 --> 00:16:41,796 to do something every six month 519 00:16:41,796 --> 00:16:41,796 s 520 00:16:41,796 --> 00:16:43,230 or quarterly, if you want to. 521 00:16:43,230 --> 00:16:45,664 but I certainly would like to 522 00:16:45,664 --> 00:16:45,664 523 00:16:45,664 --> 00:16:49,797 touch bases with gha on an 524 00:16:49,797 --> 00:16:51,303 annual basis. 525 00:16:51,303 --> 00:16:53,062 >> beginning as soon as 526 00:16:53,062 --> 00:16:53,062 possible? 527 00:16:53,062 --> 00:16:53,812 >> absolutely. 528 00:16:53,812 --> 00:16:55,442 and that will be a motion. 529 00:16:55,442 --> 00:16:56,866 >> mayor: would you like to 530 00:16:56,866 --> 00:16:58,208 include that with a motion for 531 00:16:58,208 --> 00:16:58,537 532 00:16:58,537 --> 00:16:59,904 staff recommendation or -- 533 00:16:59,904 --> 00:17:02,238 >> sure, let me refresh my 534 00:17:02,238 --> 00:17:02,724 memory on that. 535 00:17:02,724 --> 00:17:05,804 and as you see I'm just sittin 536 00:17:05,804 --> 00:17:05,804 g. 537 00:17:05,804 --> 00:17:06,138 thank you. 538 00:17:06,138 --> 00:17:15,755 so I move that the city 539 00:17:15,755 --> 00:17:16,764 commission authorize the mayor 540 00:17:16,764 --> 00:17:17,057 541 00:17:17,057 --> 00:17:18,696 to send a letter supporting the 542 00:17:18,696 --> 00:17:19,126 543 00:17:19,126 --> 00:17:20,103 gainesville housing authority' 544 00:17:20,103 --> 00:17:20,723 s 545 00:17:20,723 --> 00:17:21,303 application to the u.s. 546 00:17:21,303 --> 00:17:23,079 department of housing and urban 547 00:17:23,079 --> 00:17:23,460 548 00:17:23,460 --> 00:17:24,631 development for the dispositio 549 00:17:24,631 --> 00:17:25,183 n 550 00:17:25,183 --> 00:17:30,871 and rehabilitation of the oak 551 00:17:30,871 --> 00:17:30,871 552 00:17:30,871 --> 00:17:32,385 park development, and arrange 553 00:17:32,385 --> 00:17:32,385 554 00:17:32,385 --> 00:17:34,243 for a meeting to take place at 555 00:17:34,243 --> 00:17:34,441 556 00:17:34,441 --> 00:17:37,419 least annually with the gha to 557 00:17:37,419 --> 00:17:37,681 558 00:17:37,681 --> 00:17:38,042 check in. 559 00:17:38,042 --> 00:17:38,962 >> second. 560 00:17:38,962 --> 00:17:40,489 >> mayor: we have a motion and 561 00:17:40,489 --> 00:17:40,575 a 562 00:17:40,575 --> 00:17:40,575 second. 563 00:17:40,575 --> 00:17:43,845 we have one more light, then 564 00:17:43,845 --> 00:17:44,281 we'll go to public comment. 565 00:17:44,281 --> 00:17:47,193 >> I support the development. 566 00:17:47,193 --> 00:17:51,462 clearly for oak park, it's in 567 00:17:51,462 --> 00:17:51,462 568 00:17:51,462 --> 00:17:53,401 dire need as you said, mr. 569 00:17:53,401 --> 00:17:55,569 manager, I don't know who 570 00:17:55,569 --> 00:17:57,169 executes the letter, but the 571 00:17:57,169 --> 00:17:59,263 letter itself, very minor, it 572 00:17:59,263 --> 00:17:59,263 573 00:17:59,263 --> 00:18:00,695 doesn't have language, it 574 00:18:00,695 --> 00:18:02,167 doesn't bring the full city 575 00:18:02,167 --> 00:18:03,175 commission behind it, just the 576 00:18:03,175 --> 00:18:03,439 577 00:18:03,439 --> 00:18:04,677 mayor at this point. 578 00:18:04,677 --> 00:18:06,353 so whoever executes the letter 579 00:18:06,353 --> 00:18:06,609 , 580 00:18:06,609 --> 00:18:09,313 make sure that will benefit gh 581 00:18:09,313 --> 00:18:10,443 a 582 00:18:10,443 --> 00:18:12,779 for an amendment to the 583 00:18:12,779 --> 00:18:12,779 template. 584 00:18:12,779 --> 00:18:13,591 thank you, mr. Mayor. 585 00:18:13,591 --> 00:18:15,338 >> thank you, commissioner book. 586 00:18:15,338 --> 00:18:15,338 587 00:18:15,338 --> 00:18:18,654 >> I did too want to be specific 588 00:18:18,654 --> 00:18:18,654 589 00:18:18,654 --> 00:18:20,581 in my comments about this 590 00:18:20,581 --> 00:18:21,551 particular development, thank 591 00:18:21,551 --> 00:18:21,551 592 00:18:21,551 --> 00:18:22,328 you for your attention to it. 593 00:18:22,328 --> 00:18:27,055 I believe, and I said this 594 00:18:27,055 --> 00:18:28,476 before from the dais, that it 595 00:18:28,476 --> 00:18:28,476 is 596 00:18:28,476 --> 00:18:28,802 a beautiful facility. 597 00:18:28,802 --> 00:18:34,000 that needs some shining up, the 598 00:18:34,000 --> 00:18:34,713 599 00:18:34,713 --> 00:18:36,173 atrium at the bottom is such a 600 00:18:36,173 --> 00:18:36,803 n 601 00:18:36,803 --> 00:18:36,803 asset. 602 00:18:36,803 --> 00:18:38,800 I can't wait to see what you a 603 00:18:38,800 --> 00:18:38,800 ll 604 00:18:38,800 --> 00:18:40,509 do with the greenery down ther 605 00:18:40,509 --> 00:18:40,509 e. 606 00:18:40,509 --> 00:18:43,980 I have obviously been through, 607 00:18:43,980 --> 00:18:44,327 608 00:18:44,327 --> 00:18:46,079 and I've seen the severe need 609 00:18:46,079 --> 00:18:46,079 610 00:18:46,079 --> 00:18:48,078 for the renovation, so I'm 611 00:18:48,078 --> 00:18:49,095 looking forward to that. 612 00:18:49,095 --> 00:18:52,581 mr. Kiner, can you speak to wha 613 00:18:52,581 --> 00:18:52,581 t 614 00:18:52,581 --> 00:18:53,987 we should expect. 615 00:18:53,987 --> 00:18:56,131 can you speak to what we should 616 00:18:56,131 --> 00:18:56,271 617 00:18:56,271 --> 00:18:57,628 expect in terms of the overall 618 00:18:57,628 --> 00:18:58,269 619 00:18:58,269 --> 00:18:58,269 renovation? 620 00:18:58,269 --> 00:18:59,905 >> we're taking down to the 621 00:18:59,905 --> 00:18:59,905 studs. 622 00:18:59,905 --> 00:19:00,567 >> okay, thank you. 623 00:19:00,567 --> 00:19:08,335 >> oak park needs love, it needs a lot 624 00:19:08,335 --> 00:19:08,373 a lot of love. 625 00:19:08,373 --> 00:19:09,968 we've dealt with a lot of 626 00:19:09,968 --> 00:19:10,875 systems issues. 627 00:19:10,875 --> 00:19:14,137 and it's hoard to keep up on 628 00:19:14,137 --> 00:19:15,273 sustaining maintenance on a 629 00:19:15,273 --> 00:19:15,901 property like that. 630 00:19:15,901 --> 00:19:18,379 we redid the parking lot, we p 631 00:19:18,379 --> 00:19:18,379 ut 632 00:19:18,379 --> 00:19:20,786 a new roof on it about 10 years 633 00:19:20,786 --> 00:19:21,180 634 00:19:21,180 --> 00:19:23,618 ago, some exterior coating, but 635 00:19:23,618 --> 00:19:23,781 636 00:19:23,781 --> 00:19:26,151 down to the studs, new elevator, 637 00:19:26,151 --> 00:19:26,151 638 00:19:26,151 --> 00:19:28,223 every apartment, every community 639 00:19:28,223 --> 00:19:28,223 640 00:19:28,223 --> 00:19:30,123 amenity will be redone. 641 00:19:30,123 --> 00:19:32,857 somewhere in the area of -- 642 00:19:32,857 --> 00:19:35,459 between 39 and $40 so million o 643 00:19:35,459 --> 00:19:35,459 f 644 00:19:35,459 --> 00:19:37,429 redevelopment on oak park. 645 00:19:37,429 --> 00:19:39,433 new building, but good bones. 646 00:19:39,433 --> 00:19:41,395 just like you love the building, 647 00:19:41,395 --> 00:19:41,395 648 00:19:41,395 --> 00:19:45,914 lovitz design, it just needs 649 00:19:45,914 --> 00:19:46,167 some love. 650 00:19:46,167 --> 00:19:47,171 >> every unit? 651 00:19:47,171 --> 00:19:48,142 >> every unit. 652 00:19:48,142 --> 00:19:51,044 >> I will say that you probabl 653 00:19:51,044 --> 00:19:51,447 y 654 00:19:51,447 --> 00:19:53,182 faced an issue with some water 655 00:19:53,182 --> 00:19:54,277 656 00:19:54,277 --> 00:19:55,660 intrusion in there. 657 00:19:55,660 --> 00:19:56,008 >> we face many issues. 658 00:19:56,008 --> 00:20:01,988 >> I'm glad to hear we're going 659 00:20:01,988 --> 00:20:02,155 660 00:20:02,155 --> 00:20:02,685 down to the studs. 661 00:20:02,685 --> 00:20:03,082 >> total redevelopment. 662 00:20:03,082 --> 00:20:05,359 >> thank you. 663 00:20:05,359 --> 00:20:08,032 >> mayor: commissioner eastman 664 00:20:08,032 --> 00:20:08,032 . 665 00:20:08,032 --> 00:20:12,961 >> it's in district 4, it's a 666 00:20:12,961 --> 00:20:12,961 667 00:20:12,961 --> 00:20:17,600 great society era, '50s, '60s 668 00:20:17,600 --> 00:20:17,600 669 00:20:17,600 --> 00:20:17,600 era. 670 00:20:17,600 --> 00:20:20,150 >> whatever, mid modern. 671 00:20:20,150 --> 00:20:22,674 >> '68 I believe it was built. 672 00:20:22,674 --> 00:20:22,674 673 00:20:22,674 --> 00:20:24,880 >> it definitely needs some 674 00:20:24,880 --> 00:20:24,880 love. 675 00:20:24,880 --> 00:20:28,480 I'm glad to see you guys put 676 00:20:28,480 --> 00:20:29,111 some work into that. 677 00:20:29,111 --> 00:20:31,288 can we get a reread of what the 678 00:20:31,288 --> 00:20:31,521 679 00:20:31,521 --> 00:20:32,015 motion was? 680 00:20:32,015 --> 00:20:33,991 I'm always happy to have joint 681 00:20:33,991 --> 00:20:35,007 682 00:20:35,007 --> 00:20:36,385 conversations with other 683 00:20:36,385 --> 00:20:39,361 governmental bodies, I want to 684 00:20:39,361 --> 00:20:39,958 685 00:20:39,958 --> 00:20:40,546 know what we're committing to. 686 00:20:40,546 --> 00:20:40,546 687 00:20:40,546 --> 00:20:44,737 >> I can reread it, approve -- 688 00:20:44,737 --> 00:20:45,139 689 00:20:45,139 --> 00:20:46,707 as recommended and set a joint 690 00:20:46,707 --> 00:20:47,834 691 00:20:47,834 --> 00:20:48,722 meeting for both boards to recu 692 00:20:48,722 --> 00:20:48,722 r 693 00:20:48,722 --> 00:20:48,722 annually. 694 00:20:48,722 --> 00:20:55,572 >> I am happy to have a joint 695 00:20:55,572 --> 00:20:55,572 696 00:20:55,572 --> 00:20:55,572 meeting. 697 00:20:55,572 --> 00:20:59,002 I am more receipt sent to set u 698 00:20:59,002 --> 00:20:59,002 s 699 00:20:59,002 --> 00:21:00,756 up for something that we're now 700 00:21:00,756 --> 00:21:01,308 701 00:21:01,308 --> 00:21:03,378 structuring for an annual 702 00:21:03,378 --> 00:21:06,138 amount, if there's something 703 00:21:06,138 --> 00:21:08,982 that's more ad-hoc if we have 704 00:21:08,982 --> 00:21:08,982 705 00:21:08,982 --> 00:21:09,451 something to discuss. 706 00:21:09,451 --> 00:21:11,759 I don't think we really -- 707 00:21:11,759 --> 00:21:13,492 setting this up for an annual 708 00:21:13,492 --> 00:21:13,492 709 00:21:13,492 --> 00:21:15,752 meeting, I think might be a bit 710 00:21:15,752 --> 00:21:16,328 711 00:21:16,328 --> 00:21:17,428 much at this particular time, a 712 00:21:17,428 --> 00:21:17,428 s 713 00:21:17,428 --> 00:21:21,872 opposed to scheduling a meeting 714 00:21:21,872 --> 00:21:21,872 715 00:21:21,872 --> 00:21:24,352 in the future, is my only 716 00:21:24,352 --> 00:21:24,738 reticence about it. 717 00:21:24,738 --> 00:21:28,306 >> mayor: thank you. 718 00:21:28,306 --> 00:21:31,340 >> the gainesville housing 719 00:21:31,340 --> 00:21:34,946 authority has a number of 720 00:21:34,946 --> 00:21:36,042 facilities within its portfolio, 721 00:21:36,042 --> 00:21:36,042 722 00:21:36,042 --> 00:21:38,358 and I think we would have a lot 723 00:21:38,358 --> 00:21:38,398 724 00:21:38,398 --> 00:21:38,948 to talk about. 725 00:21:38,948 --> 00:21:40,893 they have a lot of new projects 726 00:21:40,893 --> 00:21:41,148 727 00:21:41,148 --> 00:21:42,752 they're bringing online, I thi 728 00:21:42,752 --> 00:21:42,752 nk 729 00:21:42,752 --> 00:21:44,114 there's always one meeting per 730 00:21:44,114 --> 00:21:44,662 731 00:21:44,662 --> 00:21:44,662 year. 732 00:21:44,662 --> 00:21:48,044 I don't think we'll struggle 733 00:21:48,044 --> 00:21:48,300 with an agenda. 734 00:21:48,300 --> 00:21:48,610 thank you. 735 00:21:48,610 --> 00:21:51,458 >> mayor: thank you. 736 00:21:51,458 --> 00:21:53,131 mr. Duncan walker? 737 00:21:53,131 --> 00:21:56,504 are there any public comment? 738 00:21:56,504 --> 00:21:56,994 >> no public comment. 739 00:21:56,994 --> 00:21:59,434 >> mayor: all in favor? 740 00:21:59,434 --> 00:22:02,286 >> aye. 741 00:22:02,286 --> 00:22:02,286 ma 742 00:22:02,286 --> 00:22:04,238 >> mayor: that passed 743 00:22:04,238 --> 00:22:04,238 unanimously. 744 00:22:04,238 --> 00:22:05,976 we will get that letter 745 00:22:05,976 --> 00:22:06,574 procsed as quily as 746 00:22:06,574 --> 00:22:06,574 possible. 747 00:22:06,574 --> 00:22:15,206 >> mr. Mayor, I did neglect to 748 00:22:15,206 --> 00:22:15,988 749 00:22:15,988 --> 00:22:17,120 call for early public comment, 750 00:22:17,120 --> 00:22:18,392 751 00:22:18,392 --> 00:22:21,362 but there is none, so we're mov 752 00:22:21,362 --> 00:22:21,362 e 753 00:22:21,362 --> 00:22:24,867 on to f1, 2026-164 discuss cit 754 00:22:24,867 --> 00:22:26,231 y 755 00:22:26,231 --> 00:22:28,162 manager recruitment time line. 756 00:22:28,162 --> 00:22:28,162 757 00:22:28,162 --> 00:22:30,268 >> mayor: let me preface real 758 00:22:30,268 --> 00:22:30,268 759 00:22:30,268 --> 00:22:30,268 quick. 760 00:22:30,268 --> 00:22:31,572 I appreciate you bringing this 761 00:22:31,572 --> 00:22:31,968 762 00:22:31,968 --> 00:22:33,674 forward and look forward to my 763 00:22:33,674 --> 00:22:34,106 764 00:22:34,106 --> 00:22:34,956 colleagues comments. 765 00:22:34,956 --> 00:22:40,544 I will say, as I have said 766 00:22:40,544 --> 00:22:43,078 before, it's going to cost us 767 00:22:43,078 --> 00:22:43,078 768 00:22:43,078 --> 00:22:45,378 between 50,000 and $100,000 to 769 00:22:45,378 --> 00:22:46,418 770 00:22:46,418 --> 00:22:49,082 do a search. 771 00:22:49,082 --> 00:22:58,999 and given the free state of 772 00:22:58,999 --> 00:23:03,106 florida, given lots and lots o 773 00:23:03,106 --> 00:23:03,498 f 774 00:23:03,498 --> 00:23:06,034 things, have a hard time 775 00:23:06,034 --> 00:23:07,090 believing we're going to spend 776 00:23:07,090 --> 00:23:07,438 777 00:23:07,438 --> 00:23:09,602 $100,000 and come out with a 778 00:23:09,602 --> 00:23:11,078 different product than what we 779 00:23:11,078 --> 00:23:11,276 780 00:23:11,276 --> 00:23:12,582 have in front of us right now. 781 00:23:12,582 --> 00:23:12,582 782 00:23:12,582 --> 00:23:16,719 I do not believe this process I 783 00:23:16,719 --> 00:23:16,719 s 784 00:23:16,719 --> 00:23:16,719 necessary. 785 00:23:16,719 --> 00:23:18,685 I think we should stick with 786 00:23:18,685 --> 00:23:19,883 what we have, frankly. 787 00:23:19,883 --> 00:23:22,288 that's my thought, I wanted to 788 00:23:22,288 --> 00:23:22,654 789 00:23:22,654 --> 00:23:22,950 preface that. 790 00:23:22,950 --> 00:23:27,494 >> good morning, laura gretz, 791 00:23:27,494 --> 00:23:27,494 792 00:23:27,494 --> 00:23:29,326 human resources director of 793 00:23:29,326 --> 00:23:29,326 gainesville. 794 00:23:29,326 --> 00:23:33,536 happy to be before you today, a 795 00:23:33,536 --> 00:23:33,536 s 796 00:23:33,536 --> 00:23:34,035 you'll recall. 797 00:23:34,035 --> 00:23:36,407 sorry, let me grab this real 798 00:23:36,407 --> 00:23:36,407 quick. 799 00:23:36,407 --> 00:23:38,954 just a bit of background on 800 00:23:38,954 --> 00:23:42,125 october 20, 2025, mr. Andrew 801 00:23:42,125 --> 00:23:43,818 persons was named as the interim 802 00:23:43,818 --> 00:23:43,818 803 00:23:43,818 --> 00:23:45,411 city manager by the commission 804 00:23:45,411 --> 00:23:45,411 . 805 00:23:45,411 --> 00:23:50,658 we met on october 23 of 2025 t 806 00:23:50,658 --> 00:23:50,951 o 807 00:23:50,951 --> 00:23:53,246 discuss what a recruitment 808 00:23:53,246 --> 00:23:54,854 search would like like if the 809 00:23:54,854 --> 00:23:54,854 810 00:23:54,854 --> 00:23:56,456 commission opted to go in that 811 00:23:56,456 --> 00:23:57,002 812 00:23:57,002 --> 00:23:57,002 direction. 813 00:23:57,002 --> 00:23:59,053 and during that meeting, we 814 00:23:59,053 --> 00:23:59,652 agreed to come back. 815 00:23:59,652 --> 00:24:03,142 it was in march, but we shifted 816 00:24:03,142 --> 00:24:03,276 817 00:24:03,276 --> 00:24:06,009 it to this meeting, here we ar 818 00:24:06,009 --> 00:24:06,138 e 819 00:24:06,138 --> 00:24:07,196 april 2nd to discuss it. 820 00:24:07,196 --> 00:24:09,734 just a brief refresher on how w 821 00:24:09,734 --> 00:24:09,734 e 822 00:24:09,734 --> 00:24:10,142 got here. 823 00:24:10,142 --> 00:24:12,280 this is a reiteration of some o 824 00:24:12,280 --> 00:24:12,280 f 825 00:24:12,280 --> 00:24:14,537 the talking points that we 826 00:24:14,537 --> 00:24:15,167 discussed back in october. 827 00:24:15,167 --> 00:24:20,164 some of which -- some of the 828 00:24:20,164 --> 00:24:22,413 uncertainties may be a bit 829 00:24:22,413 --> 00:24:23,452 clearer is my best way to say 830 00:24:23,452 --> 00:24:28,524 that, but at the time, we had 831 00:24:28,524 --> 00:24:28,524 832 00:24:28,524 --> 00:24:31,836 not received from the state of 833 00:24:31,836 --> 00:24:31,836 834 00:24:31,836 --> 00:24:32,172 florida -- 835 00:24:32,172 --> 00:24:32,461 [ inaudible ] 836 00:24:32,461 --> 00:24:34,127 and have some more insight fro 837 00:24:34,127 --> 00:24:34,300 m 838 00:24:34,300 --> 00:24:35,228 what their findings were. 839 00:24:35,228 --> 00:24:38,631 there was a gru referendum tha 840 00:24:38,631 --> 00:24:38,716 t 841 00:24:38,716 --> 00:24:40,259 was currently in litigation, I 842 00:24:40,259 --> 00:24:40,868 t 843 00:24:40,868 --> 00:24:41,967 remains in litigation, in 844 00:24:41,967 --> 00:24:43,089 addition to what we discussed I 845 00:24:43,089 --> 00:24:43,089 n 846 00:24:43,089 --> 00:24:44,899 october, as we're all well 847 00:24:44,899 --> 00:24:49,059 aware, there was some actual 848 00:24:49,059 --> 00:24:49,877 state legislation that has bee 849 00:24:49,877 --> 00:24:50,304 n 850 00:24:50,304 --> 00:24:51,552 passed by house and senate, but 851 00:24:51,552 --> 00:24:52,116 852 00:24:52,116 --> 00:24:53,652 remains at the desk of the 853 00:24:53,652 --> 00:24:54,045 governor currently. 854 00:24:54,045 --> 00:24:57,182 we talked about the need for 855 00:24:57,182 --> 00:24:57,655 momentum and stability. 856 00:24:57,655 --> 00:25:00,456 and I think I heard a series o 857 00:25:00,456 --> 00:25:01,429 f 858 00:25:01,429 --> 00:25:02,642 meetings since mr. Persons too 859 00:25:02,642 --> 00:25:02,950 k 860 00:25:02,950 --> 00:25:04,800 on this role that that is 861 00:25:04,800 --> 00:25:05,993 something we've been able to s 862 00:25:05,993 --> 00:25:05,993 ee 863 00:25:05,993 --> 00:25:05,993 materialize. 864 00:25:05,993 --> 00:25:08,757 and as a reminder, and the may 865 00:25:08,757 --> 00:25:08,757 or 866 00:25:08,757 --> 00:25:10,331 just discussed that, there is a 867 00:25:10,331 --> 00:25:10,707 868 00:25:10,707 --> 00:25:12,670 cost associated if you chose t 869 00:25:12,670 --> 00:25:12,925 o 870 00:25:12,925 --> 00:25:14,331 move forward with the 871 00:25:14,331 --> 00:25:15,727 recruitment, and could range 872 00:25:15,727 --> 00:25:17,432 anywhere from 22 to just shy o 873 00:25:17,432 --> 00:25:17,781 f 874 00:25:17,781 --> 00:25:17,781 $100,000. 875 00:25:17,781 --> 00:25:21,839 as a reminder, the process tak 876 00:25:21,839 --> 00:25:21,839 es 877 00:25:21,839 --> 00:25:22,975 16 to 20 months. 878 00:25:22,975 --> 00:25:25,139 and when we had met back in 879 00:25:25,139 --> 00:25:29,008 october, we talked about 880 00:25:29,008 --> 00:25:29,937 consideration the budget 881 00:25:29,937 --> 00:25:31,514 preparation we do here at the 882 00:25:31,514 --> 00:25:31,514 883 00:25:31,514 --> 00:25:33,157 city as well as upcoming 884 00:25:33,157 --> 00:25:34,216 commission elections in august 885 00:25:34,216 --> 00:25:34,216 . 886 00:25:34,216 --> 00:25:37,484 so I did not share this 887 00:25:37,484 --> 00:25:38,699 information at the last meetin 888 00:25:38,699 --> 00:25:38,699 g. 889 00:25:38,699 --> 00:25:40,829 and it's just a reminder to kin 890 00:25:40,829 --> 00:25:40,829 d 891 00:25:40,829 --> 00:25:43,192 of walk you through the 892 00:25:43,192 --> 00:25:44,416 different steps in the process, 893 00:25:44,416 --> 00:25:44,416 894 00:25:44,416 --> 00:25:46,761 I think it will help in our nex 895 00:25:46,761 --> 00:25:46,761 t 896 00:25:46,761 --> 00:25:47,502 slide of discussion. 897 00:25:47,502 --> 00:25:52,602 the key point to remember is, 898 00:25:52,602 --> 00:25:52,602 899 00:25:52,602 --> 00:25:56,047 it's about in the 3rd or 4th 900 00:25:56,047 --> 00:25:57,447 month when the commission would 901 00:25:57,447 --> 00:25:57,709 902 00:25:57,709 --> 00:25:59,278 select candidates to bring 903 00:25:59,278 --> 00:26:01,369 forward and interview those 904 00:26:01,369 --> 00:26:01,369 candidates. 905 00:26:01,369 --> 00:26:05,046 I think that's relevant as we 906 00:26:05,046 --> 00:26:05,046 907 00:26:05,046 --> 00:26:06,161 talk about the options. 908 00:26:06,161 --> 00:26:07,217 so in october. 909 00:26:07,217 --> 00:26:10,493 I just brought one visual for 910 00:26:10,493 --> 00:26:10,493 911 00:26:10,493 --> 00:26:11,157 you all to consider. 912 00:26:11,157 --> 00:26:13,758 based on the discussions and 913 00:26:13,758 --> 00:26:14,639 comments from the commission 914 00:26:14,639 --> 00:26:17,239 october, I brought forth 915 00:26:17,239 --> 00:26:19,763 two options based on the 916 00:26:19,763 --> 00:26:21,397 feedback we were hearing when w 917 00:26:21,397 --> 00:26:21,397 e 918 00:26:21,397 --> 00:26:22,131 last met. 919 00:26:22,131 --> 00:26:25,475 option one looks at starting t 920 00:26:25,475 --> 00:26:25,475 he 921 00:26:25,475 --> 00:26:26,171 search in august. 922 00:26:26,171 --> 00:26:28,540 you can see our fiscal year for 923 00:26:28,540 --> 00:26:28,874 924 00:26:28,874 --> 00:26:31,949 october, for fiscal year 27 925 00:26:31,949 --> 00:26:32,441 begins in october. 926 00:26:32,441 --> 00:26:35,154 and if there were runoff 927 00:26:35,154 --> 00:26:36,409 elections that would be needed 928 00:26:36,409 --> 00:26:36,610 929 00:26:36,610 --> 00:26:40,420 that occur in november, it giv 930 00:26:40,420 --> 00:26:40,420 es 931 00:26:40,420 --> 00:26:45,085 a smidge of time for any 932 00:26:45,085 --> 00:26:46,621 commissioners to be part of th 933 00:26:46,621 --> 00:26:46,621 at 934 00:26:46,621 --> 00:26:47,425 final selection process. 935 00:26:47,425 --> 00:26:50,532 the second option is below, 936 00:26:50,532 --> 00:26:54,465 where commission elections occ 937 00:26:54,465 --> 00:26:54,465 ur 938 00:26:54,465 --> 00:26:54,934 in august. 939 00:26:54,934 --> 00:26:57,641 at that point if the comment 940 00:26:57,641 --> 00:26:59,510 commissioners are re-elected a 941 00:26:59,510 --> 00:26:59,510 nd 942 00:26:59,510 --> 00:27:02,303 there's no runoff needed we kno 943 00:27:02,303 --> 00:27:02,303 w 944 00:27:02,303 --> 00:27:04,079 who they are, and they can be 945 00:27:04,079 --> 00:27:04,079 946 00:27:04,079 --> 00:27:06,077 part of the process from the 947 00:27:06,077 --> 00:27:07,073 beginning, if there are runoff 948 00:27:07,073 --> 00:27:07,073 s, 949 00:27:07,073 --> 00:27:11,816 they're able to be candidates a 950 00:27:11,816 --> 00:27:11,816 s 951 00:27:11,816 --> 00:27:12,749 part of the selection. 952 00:27:12,749 --> 00:27:14,863 so I will leave it to you all 953 00:27:14,863 --> 00:27:14,863 to 954 00:27:14,863 --> 00:27:15,293 discuss at this time. 955 00:27:15,293 --> 00:27:17,191 >> mayor: very good. 956 00:27:17,191 --> 00:27:17,443 thank you. 957 00:27:17,443 --> 00:27:19,673 commission eastman? 958 00:27:19,673 --> 00:27:20,066 >> thank you. 959 00:27:20,066 --> 00:27:22,185 mr. Mayor. 960 00:27:22,185 --> 00:27:31,473 so the -- so it -- the last cit 961 00:27:31,473 --> 00:27:31,473 y 962 00:27:31,473 --> 00:27:34,683 manager, we did a public search 963 00:27:34,683 --> 00:27:34,683 964 00:27:34,683 --> 00:27:36,069 around 2020 -- 965 00:27:36,069 --> 00:27:37,602 >> I believe it was for the 966 00:27:37,602 --> 00:27:38,409 acting city manager. 967 00:27:38,409 --> 00:27:41,183 >> yes, I'm just a little bit - 968 00:27:41,183 --> 00:27:41,183 - 969 00:27:41,183 --> 00:27:46,615 >> for the -- so cynthia curry 970 00:27:46,615 --> 00:27:46,798 971 00:27:46,798 --> 00:27:48,521 came in, she had come in, I 972 00:27:48,521 --> 00:27:49,943 think we selected her, there w 973 00:27:49,943 --> 00:27:49,943 as 974 00:27:49,943 --> 00:27:51,591 not an active search for that, 975 00:27:51,591 --> 00:27:51,953 976 00:27:51,953 --> 00:27:51,953 correct? 977 00:27:51,953 --> 00:27:54,825 >> yes, mayor and commissioner, 978 00:27:54,825 --> 00:27:56,689 I wasn't in this role at the 979 00:27:56,689 --> 00:27:58,123 time, I recall there was a 980 00:27:58,123 --> 00:27:59,769 search, I believe it was for t 981 00:27:59,769 --> 00:27:59,769 he 982 00:27:59,769 --> 00:28:02,598 acting position, and then miss 983 00:28:02,598 --> 00:28:02,995 984 00:28:02,995 --> 00:28:04,777 curry was selected as the actin 985 00:28:04,777 --> 00:28:04,777 g 986 00:28:04,777 --> 00:28:06,901 city manager and was 987 00:28:06,901 --> 00:28:07,547 subsequently appointed after a 988 00:28:07,547 --> 00:28:07,661 989 00:28:07,661 --> 00:28:07,833 period of time. 990 00:28:07,833 --> 00:28:10,873 >> okay, and then prior to that 991 00:28:10,873 --> 00:28:10,873 , 992 00:28:10,873 --> 00:28:14,639 we did, we had an acting, but 993 00:28:14,639 --> 00:28:14,639 994 00:28:14,639 --> 00:28:22,105 then we had a public search, I 995 00:28:22,105 --> 00:28:22,151 s 996 00:28:22,151 --> 00:28:22,412 that correct? 997 00:28:22,412 --> 00:28:23,291 >> I believe that's correct, 998 00:28:23,291 --> 00:28:23,291 yes. 999 00:28:23,291 --> 00:28:26,187 >> we ask all of our employees, 1000 00:28:26,187 --> 00:28:26,551 1001 00:28:26,551 --> 00:28:28,197 I guess we have hr here. 1002 00:28:28,197 --> 00:28:30,065 generally speaking for our 1003 00:28:30,065 --> 00:28:31,717 employees, we do panels, public 1004 00:28:31,717 --> 00:28:32,126 1005 00:28:32,126 --> 00:28:33,637 services, I'm sure there are 1006 00:28:33,637 --> 00:28:34,729 instances where you may select 1007 00:28:34,729 --> 00:28:34,909 1008 00:28:34,909 --> 00:28:36,263 someone to come into the city 1009 00:28:36,263 --> 00:28:36,263 1010 00:28:36,263 --> 00:28:37,941 that is not through that 1011 00:28:37,941 --> 00:28:40,469 process, that's generally the 1012 00:28:40,469 --> 00:28:40,469 1013 00:28:40,469 --> 00:28:40,740 process, correct? 1014 00:28:40,740 --> 00:28:41,137 >> correct. 1015 00:28:41,137 --> 00:28:43,135 our employee process says 1016 00:28:43,135 --> 00:28:45,141 generally, we will conduct a 1017 00:28:45,141 --> 00:28:46,571 search for our positions. 1018 00:28:46,571 --> 00:28:50,977 there are circ umstances in whi 1019 00:28:50,977 --> 00:28:50,977 ch 1020 00:28:50,977 --> 00:28:54,279 we elect direct hires, it's 1021 00:28:54,279 --> 00:28:56,250 usually based on the can dwi 1022 00:28:56,250 --> 00:28:56,985 date's specific experiences. 1023 00:28:56,985 --> 00:28:58,489 what the needs are of the 1024 00:28:58,489 --> 00:28:59,561 organization at the time, if I 1025 00:28:59,561 --> 00:28:59,925 t 1026 00:28:59,925 --> 00:29:01,347 seems to be a good match, 1027 00:29:01,347 --> 00:29:02,443 sometimes a decision is made t 1028 00:29:02,443 --> 00:29:03,129 o 1029 00:29:03,129 --> 00:29:03,533 conduct a direct hire. 1030 00:29:03,533 --> 00:29:07,287 >> I think our system of 1031 00:29:07,287 --> 00:29:09,865 government is a funny one, the 1032 00:29:09,865 --> 00:29:09,865 re 1033 00:29:09,865 --> 00:29:12,671 are seven of us here, we're the 1034 00:29:12,671 --> 00:29:13,107 1035 00:29:13,107 --> 00:29:15,569 legislative branch, we don't 1036 00:29:15,569 --> 00:29:16,303 communicate with one another. 1037 00:29:16,303 --> 00:29:19,237 so the city manager ends up 1038 00:29:19,237 --> 00:29:20,907 being a strong mayor type role 1039 00:29:20,907 --> 00:29:21,077 , 1040 00:29:21,077 --> 00:29:23,821 but working for the seven of u 1041 00:29:23,821 --> 00:29:24,077 s 1042 00:29:24,077 --> 00:29:24,711 as it goes forward. 1043 00:29:24,711 --> 00:29:27,949 it is far and away the most 1044 00:29:27,949 --> 00:29:28,581 important decision we make as a 1045 00:29:28,581 --> 00:29:28,625 1046 00:29:28,625 --> 00:29:28,625 city. 1047 00:29:28,625 --> 00:29:32,085 it -- I would say our city is 1048 00:29:32,085 --> 00:29:32,085 1049 00:29:32,085 --> 00:29:33,993 more defined even by which cit 1050 00:29:33,993 --> 00:29:34,591 y 1051 00:29:34,591 --> 00:29:36,389 managers we had at various tim 1052 00:29:36,389 --> 00:29:36,389 es 1053 00:29:36,389 --> 00:29:38,225 and who we have sitting in the 1054 00:29:38,225 --> 00:29:38,225 se 1055 00:29:38,225 --> 00:29:38,225 seats. 1056 00:29:38,225 --> 00:29:41,967 I think having a public search 1057 00:29:41,967 --> 00:29:42,251 1058 00:29:42,251 --> 00:29:43,989 for something as important as 1059 00:29:43,989 --> 00:29:43,989 1060 00:29:43,989 --> 00:29:45,667 this makes a lot of sense for 1061 00:29:45,667 --> 00:29:45,667 1062 00:29:45,667 --> 00:29:48,881 our employees otherwise, I lik 1063 00:29:48,881 --> 00:29:50,540 e 1064 00:29:50,540 --> 00:29:52,037 the idea of looking around 1065 00:29:52,037 --> 00:29:54,478 the -- and I think it ends up 1066 00:29:54,478 --> 00:29:54,478 1067 00:29:54,478 --> 00:29:55,353 coming into that role, whether 1068 00:29:55,353 --> 00:29:55,578 1069 00:29:55,578 --> 00:29:57,577 it be our acting or not our 1070 00:29:57,577 --> 00:29:58,477 acting, however it goes. 1071 00:29:58,477 --> 00:30:01,005 it gives legitimacy that they 1072 00:30:01,005 --> 00:30:01,005 1073 00:30:01,005 --> 00:30:03,127 went through the same process 1074 00:30:03,127 --> 00:30:03,127 1075 00:30:03,127 --> 00:30:04,709 every other city did. 1076 00:30:04,709 --> 00:30:06,519 they've been selected by the 1077 00:30:06,519 --> 00:30:08,293 city commission, and meeting t 1078 00:30:08,293 --> 00:30:08,293 he 1079 00:30:08,293 --> 00:30:09,833 community, introducing 1080 00:30:09,833 --> 00:30:11,001 themselves, I think that's a 1081 00:30:11,001 --> 00:30:14,332 good process, I don't -- I thi 1082 00:30:14,332 --> 00:30:14,332 nk 1083 00:30:14,332 --> 00:30:16,607 when cynthia curry was coming I 1084 00:30:16,607 --> 00:30:16,607 n 1085 00:30:16,607 --> 00:30:17,679 before us acting. 1086 00:30:17,679 --> 00:30:19,443 we're going through a period 1087 00:30:19,443 --> 00:30:20,765 where we needed someone to com 1088 00:30:20,765 --> 00:30:21,103 e 1089 00:30:21,103 --> 00:30:23,021 in, step into the role, we are 1090 00:30:23,021 --> 00:30:23,501 1091 00:30:23,501 --> 00:30:26,549 now in a place where -- there's 1092 00:30:26,549 --> 00:30:26,783 1093 00:30:26,783 --> 00:30:28,510 always uncertainties, this 1094 00:30:28,510 --> 00:30:29,643 question as to what the future 1095 00:30:29,643 --> 00:30:30,043 1096 00:30:30,043 --> 00:30:30,043 holds. 1097 00:30:30,043 --> 00:30:32,717 where we stand now, I don't see 1098 00:30:32,717 --> 00:30:32,843 1099 00:30:32,843 --> 00:30:33,611 this getting any better. 1100 00:30:33,611 --> 00:30:35,320 I think the process is what the 1101 00:30:35,320 --> 00:30:35,587 1102 00:30:35,587 --> 00:30:37,052 process is, and we should 1103 00:30:37,052 --> 00:30:37,825 probably go forward with our 1104 00:30:37,825 --> 00:30:38,091 standard process. 1105 00:30:38,091 --> 00:30:41,085 >> thank you, commissioner 1106 00:30:41,085 --> 00:30:41,085 eastman. 1107 00:30:41,085 --> 00:30:43,595 commissioner chestnut? 1108 00:30:43,595 --> 00:30:46,838 >> and I think we owe it to the 1109 00:30:46,838 --> 00:30:46,967 1110 00:30:46,967 --> 00:30:50,902 public to do a search, a 1111 00:30:50,902 --> 00:30:51,199 thorough search. 1112 00:30:51,199 --> 00:30:55,675 so that they can see the 1113 00:30:55,675 --> 00:30:56,721 competition, whose available o 1114 00:30:56,721 --> 00:30:56,721 ut 1115 00:30:56,721 --> 00:31:00,183 there, but a public search is 1116 00:31:00,183 --> 00:31:00,183 1117 00:31:00,183 --> 00:31:01,911 something that I totally 1118 00:31:01,911 --> 00:31:01,911 support. 1119 00:31:01,911 --> 00:31:04,217 and I would look at option one 1120 00:31:04,217 --> 00:31:04,349 1121 00:31:04,349 --> 00:31:07,747 in terms of time. 1122 00:31:07,747 --> 00:31:08,416 time line. 1123 00:31:08,416 --> 00:31:10,983 I just don't see delaying the 1124 00:31:10,983 --> 00:31:10,983 1125 00:31:10,983 --> 00:31:12,273 beginning of the process to 1126 00:31:12,273 --> 00:31:12,273 october. 1127 00:31:12,273 --> 00:31:23,099 I'll be happy to place that as 1128 00:31:23,099 --> 00:31:23,214 a 1129 00:31:23,214 --> 00:31:25,865 motion later on if others wish 1130 00:31:25,865 --> 00:31:25,865 1131 00:31:25,865 --> 00:31:26,019 to comment. 1132 00:31:26,019 --> 00:31:28,147 >> mayor: thank you. 1133 00:31:28,147 --> 00:31:28,531 commissioner willits? 1134 00:31:28,531 --> 00:31:30,187 >> there's always uncertainty, 1135 00:31:30,187 --> 00:31:35,907 1136 00:31:35,907 --> 00:31:37,417 and I was looking at option 2. 1137 00:31:37,417 --> 00:31:37,417 1138 00:31:37,417 --> 00:31:43,225 if the legislature passes a 1139 00:31:43,225 --> 00:31:44,083 constitutional amendment on 1140 00:31:44,083 --> 00:31:45,453 taxes, people who have applied 1141 00:31:45,453 --> 00:31:46,355 1142 00:31:46,355 --> 00:31:48,293 may be like, no, that's not a 1143 00:31:48,293 --> 00:31:48,293 1144 00:31:48,293 --> 00:31:50,005 battle I want to fight, about 1145 00:31:50,005 --> 00:31:50,005 1146 00:31:50,005 --> 00:31:52,457 how you completely refigure 1147 00:31:52,457 --> 00:31:53,035 local government while everyon 1148 00:31:53,035 --> 00:31:53,665 e 1149 00:31:53,665 --> 00:31:58,031 in the state is also doing it. 1150 00:31:58,031 --> 00:31:58,031 1151 00:31:58,031 --> 00:32:04,225 we have a little more recent 1152 00:32:04,225 --> 00:32:07,709 knowledge of communities not 1153 00:32:07,709 --> 00:32:08,817 having to make these decisions 1154 00:32:08,817 --> 00:32:09,214 1155 00:32:09,214 --> 00:32:09,214 recently. 1156 00:32:09,214 --> 00:32:13,259 I think elections should have 1157 00:32:13,259 --> 00:32:13,259 1158 00:32:13,259 --> 00:32:13,259 consequences. 1159 00:32:13,259 --> 00:32:14,899 that like voters should be abl 1160 00:32:14,899 --> 00:32:15,181 e 1161 00:32:15,181 --> 00:32:19,122 to vote for things, and every 1162 00:32:19,122 --> 00:32:19,122 1163 00:32:19,122 --> 00:32:20,791 decision a city makes should n 1164 00:32:20,791 --> 00:32:20,791 ot 1165 00:32:20,791 --> 00:32:22,931 be shielded from democracy, in 1166 00:32:22,931 --> 00:32:23,262 a 1167 00:32:23,262 --> 00:32:25,257 way that's like, we're going t 1168 00:32:25,257 --> 00:32:25,535 o 1169 00:32:25,535 --> 00:32:26,547 make all these decisions right 1170 00:32:26,547 --> 00:32:26,730 1171 00:32:26,730 --> 00:32:28,171 before an election, as opposed 1172 00:32:28,171 --> 00:32:28,361 1173 00:32:28,361 --> 00:32:30,065 to, okay, since we're already in 1174 00:32:30,065 --> 00:32:30,065 1175 00:32:30,065 --> 00:32:31,641 this range, where it's like, o 1176 00:32:31,641 --> 00:32:31,641 h, 1177 00:32:31,641 --> 00:32:33,375 maybe it could be done after, 1178 00:32:33,375 --> 00:32:33,375 1179 00:32:33,375 --> 00:32:34,633 decisions could be made 1180 00:32:34,633 --> 00:32:36,270 afterwards, so if this is a big 1181 00:32:36,270 --> 00:32:37,269 1182 00:32:37,269 --> 00:32:39,605 issue, then elections can 1183 00:32:39,605 --> 00:32:41,353 matter -- you know, people 1184 00:32:41,353 --> 00:32:42,855 that -- our voters can talk 1185 00:32:42,855 --> 00:32:44,151 about like, this is what we wan 1186 00:32:44,151 --> 00:32:44,151 t 1187 00:32:44,151 --> 00:32:46,793 in a city manager or city staf 1188 00:32:46,793 --> 00:32:46,793 f, 1189 00:32:46,793 --> 00:32:49,449 city charters in general. 1190 00:32:49,449 --> 00:32:51,889 we ran two elections here, whe 1191 00:32:51,889 --> 00:32:51,889 re 1192 00:32:51,889 --> 00:32:53,691 we wanted the elections to 1193 00:32:53,691 --> 00:32:55,299 matter, where the voters wante 1194 00:32:55,299 --> 00:32:55,527 d 1195 00:32:55,527 --> 00:32:57,459 to bring gru back under us. 1196 00:32:57,459 --> 00:32:59,139 someone's changing the rules a 1197 00:32:59,139 --> 00:32:59,139 nd 1198 00:32:59,139 --> 00:33:02,867 making it this impenetrable, 1199 00:33:02,867 --> 00:33:03,463 nothing can happen. 1200 00:33:03,463 --> 00:33:06,165 doesn't matter how you vote, w 1201 00:33:06,165 --> 00:33:06,165 ho 1202 00:33:06,165 --> 00:33:07,599 you elect, nothing can happen. 1203 00:33:07,599 --> 00:33:07,599 1204 00:33:07,599 --> 00:33:09,499 I like option 2 just for the 1205 00:33:09,499 --> 00:33:12,079 sake of, if this is something 1206 00:33:12,079 --> 00:33:12,079 1207 00:33:12,079 --> 00:33:13,917 that is so important or off, 1208 00:33:13,917 --> 00:33:16,391 that people need an election, t 1209 00:33:16,391 --> 00:33:16,391 o 1210 00:33:16,391 --> 00:33:18,849 say, no, no, we really want mor 1211 00:33:18,849 --> 00:33:18,849 e 1212 00:33:18,849 --> 00:33:21,706 candidates, x candidate or just 1213 00:33:21,706 --> 00:33:22,051 1214 00:33:22,051 --> 00:33:24,753 generally, we want a city 1215 00:33:24,753 --> 00:33:27,161 manager, the whole process, I 1216 00:33:27,161 --> 00:33:27,161 1217 00:33:27,161 --> 00:33:27,983 lean toward option 2. 1218 00:33:27,983 --> 00:33:30,527 I like this idea of having thi 1219 00:33:30,527 --> 00:33:30,527 1220 00:33:30,527 --> 00:33:32,895 public search, I'll remind us 1221 00:33:32,895 --> 00:33:32,895 1222 00:33:32,895 --> 00:33:35,429 the budget is $466 million 1223 00:33:35,429 --> 00:33:35,429 total. 1224 00:33:35,429 --> 00:33:37,765 the idea of spending 22 or 1225 00:33:37,765 --> 00:33:40,367 99,000 on a search for -- as 1226 00:33:40,367 --> 00:33:42,845 eastman said, it's our most 1227 00:33:42,845 --> 00:33:45,047 consequential decision. 1228 00:33:45,047 --> 00:33:48,381 and sometimes we make it quick 1229 00:33:48,381 --> 00:33:48,523 1230 00:33:48,523 --> 00:33:50,859 and fill in the gap of what we 1231 00:33:50,859 --> 00:33:50,908 1232 00:33:50,908 --> 00:33:52,149 need immediately, and sometimes 1233 00:33:52,149 --> 00:33:52,345 1234 00:33:52,345 --> 00:33:53,558 we can make it looking forward 1235 00:33:53,558 --> 00:33:56,617 1236 00:33:56,617 --> 00:33:57,056 into the unknown. 1237 00:33:57,056 --> 00:34:01,666 I like option 2 particularly 1238 00:34:01,666 --> 00:34:02,791 because of the opportunity to - 1239 00:34:02,791 --> 00:34:02,791 - 1240 00:34:02,791 --> 00:34:04,401 if the voters, the legislature 1241 00:34:04,401 --> 00:34:04,619 1242 00:34:04,619 --> 00:34:08,061 and the voters pass a ballot 1243 00:34:08,061 --> 00:34:09,973 measure or to a very large 1244 00:34:09,973 --> 00:34:09,973 degree. 1245 00:34:09,973 --> 00:34:14,207 I would hate to be in option o 1246 00:34:14,207 --> 00:34:14,207 ne 1247 00:34:14,207 --> 00:34:16,378 and then all our candidates dro 1248 00:34:16,378 --> 00:34:16,378 p 1249 00:34:16,378 --> 00:34:18,146 out right at the end, as oppos 1250 00:34:18,146 --> 00:34:18,146 ed 1251 00:34:18,146 --> 00:34:20,015 to, they may drop out in 1252 00:34:20,015 --> 00:34:21,517 november, and then we know a 1253 00:34:21,517 --> 00:34:23,444 little more of where we're at. 1254 00:34:23,444 --> 00:34:23,444 1255 00:34:23,444 --> 00:34:26,927 I lean toward option 2. 1256 00:34:26,927 --> 00:34:29,357 and also to commissioner 1257 00:34:29,357 --> 00:34:31,330 chestnut's point, we owe it to 1258 00:34:31,330 --> 00:34:31,330 1259 00:34:31,330 --> 00:34:33,854 the public, it may very well be 1260 00:34:33,854 --> 00:34:33,854 , 1261 00:34:33,854 --> 00:34:36,789 I you is suspect if the 1262 00:34:36,789 --> 00:34:39,024 candidates say, their current 1263 00:34:39,024 --> 00:34:39,024 1264 00:34:39,024 --> 00:34:40,126 interim is about taking names, 1265 00:34:40,126 --> 00:34:40,435 1266 00:34:40,435 --> 00:34:41,878 they themselves probably won't 1267 00:34:41,878 --> 00:34:42,398 1268 00:34:42,398 --> 00:34:42,398 apply. 1269 00:34:42,398 --> 00:34:45,803 why am I going to apply for 1270 00:34:45,803 --> 00:34:46,997 something where it looks like 1271 00:34:46,997 --> 00:34:46,997 1272 00:34:46,997 --> 00:34:47,527 it's going well. 1273 00:34:47,527 --> 00:34:54,044 they will be able to see the 1274 00:34:54,044 --> 00:34:54,675 names we can't see. 1275 00:34:54,675 --> 00:34:56,748 other city managers mand 1276 00:34:56,748 --> 00:34:58,943 say, no, no, no this is 1277 00:34:58,943 --> 00:35:00,589 something I offer, that -- 1278 00:35:00,589 --> 00:35:01,685 >> I support option 2. 1279 00:35:01,685 --> 00:35:03,764 because of both elections, and 1280 00:35:03,764 --> 00:35:03,985 1281 00:35:03,985 --> 00:35:05,191 then also the consequence of 1282 00:35:05,191 --> 00:35:08,220 knowing a little bit about 1283 00:35:08,220 --> 00:35:09,689 whether there's going to be a 1284 00:35:09,689 --> 00:35:09,689 measure. 1285 00:35:09,689 --> 00:35:12,727 I suspect there may be a ballo 1286 00:35:12,727 --> 00:35:13,329 t 1287 00:35:13,329 --> 00:35:14,663 measure of some sort, which one 1288 00:35:14,663 --> 00:35:14,863 1289 00:35:14,863 --> 00:35:15,139 it is. 1290 00:35:15,139 --> 00:35:16,395 in a month or two. 1291 00:35:16,395 --> 00:35:17,929 thank you, mr. Mayor. 1292 00:35:17,929 --> 00:35:21,507 >> thank you, commissioner 1293 00:35:21,507 --> 00:35:24,643 willits, commissioner ingle? 1294 00:35:24,643 --> 00:35:26,383 >> I would say, in general the 1295 00:35:26,383 --> 00:35:26,514 1296 00:35:26,514 --> 00:35:31,453 idea of doing a search -- I 1297 00:35:31,453 --> 00:35:34,881 think the last time we did a 1298 00:35:34,881 --> 00:35:36,958 public search for a city 1299 00:35:36,958 --> 00:35:39,259 manager, the city was in prett 1300 00:35:39,259 --> 00:35:39,388 y 1301 00:35:39,388 --> 00:35:41,564 rough shape, we've been cycling 1302 00:35:41,564 --> 00:35:41,729 1303 00:35:41,729 --> 00:35:42,869 through a lot of people, we we 1304 00:35:42,869 --> 00:35:42,869 re 1305 00:35:42,869 --> 00:35:44,759 looking for someone who could 1306 00:35:44,759 --> 00:35:44,759 1307 00:35:44,759 --> 00:35:45,628 change the direction things wer 1308 00:35:45,628 --> 00:35:45,628 e 1309 00:35:45,628 --> 00:35:45,628 going. 1310 00:35:45,628 --> 00:35:48,462 and it worked pretty well. We 1311 00:35:48,462 --> 00:35:50,965 we found someone that did an 1312 00:35:50,965 --> 00:35:51,271 amazing job. 1313 00:35:51,271 --> 00:35:53,188 I don't think we're in that sam 1314 00:35:53,188 --> 00:35:53,188 e 1315 00:35:53,188 --> 00:35:53,188 situation. 1316 00:35:53,188 --> 00:35:55,880 right now, things have been 1317 00:35:55,880 --> 00:35:58,276 steady, I think we kind of bui 1318 00:35:58,276 --> 00:35:58,276 lt 1319 00:35:58,276 --> 00:35:59,838 on that stability. 1320 00:35:59,838 --> 00:36:02,680 so I feel like we're in a 1321 00:36:02,680 --> 00:36:03,877 different situation, and I'm n 1322 00:36:03,877 --> 00:36:03,877 ot 1323 00:36:03,877 --> 00:36:06,381 entirely sure we need to do a 1324 00:36:06,381 --> 00:36:06,381 1325 00:36:06,381 --> 00:36:08,221 search, if we have a qualified 1326 00:36:08,221 --> 00:36:08,513 1327 00:36:08,513 --> 00:36:09,621 person that's already doing tha 1328 00:36:09,621 --> 00:36:09,621 t 1329 00:36:09,621 --> 00:36:09,621 job. 1330 00:36:09,621 --> 00:36:12,224 I'm not 100% on that one way o 1331 00:36:12,224 --> 00:36:12,518 r 1332 00:36:12,518 --> 00:36:12,518 another. 1333 00:36:12,518 --> 00:36:14,727 I could see the advantage of 1334 00:36:14,727 --> 00:36:16,091 putting that out there, and 1335 00:36:16,091 --> 00:36:18,102 looking at, that's not a hill 1336 00:36:18,102 --> 00:36:19,907 I'm going to die on. 1337 00:36:19,907 --> 00:36:22,363 I can see both sides of it. 1338 00:36:22,363 --> 00:36:25,071 I would say, I am a bigger fan 1339 00:36:25,071 --> 00:36:25,770 1340 00:36:25,770 --> 00:36:27,747 of option number two. 1341 00:36:27,747 --> 00:36:30,607 mostly because as we said, thi 1342 00:36:30,607 --> 00:36:30,853 s 1343 00:36:30,853 --> 00:36:37,719 is going to be a very 1344 00:36:37,719 --> 00:36:38,081 consequential decision. 1345 00:36:38,081 --> 00:36:39,651 starting the first part of 1346 00:36:39,651 --> 00:36:41,087 january, we're going to have a 1347 00:36:41,087 --> 00:36:41,791 t 1348 00:36:41,791 --> 00:36:43,055 least one new commissioner and 1349 00:36:43,055 --> 00:36:43,551 1350 00:36:43,551 --> 00:36:44,453 potentially four new 1351 00:36:44,453 --> 00:36:44,453 commissioners. 1352 00:36:44,453 --> 00:36:46,411 so I would think if we're 1353 00:36:46,411 --> 00:36:50,623 looking at a long term -- 1354 00:36:50,623 --> 00:36:51,562 something that's going to have 1355 00:36:51,562 --> 00:36:51,823 1356 00:36:51,823 --> 00:36:53,327 that big of an impact, I think 1357 00:36:53,327 --> 00:36:55,778 1358 00:36:55,778 --> 00:36:58,904 it makes sense to wait until 1359 00:36:58,904 --> 00:37:00,587 we've got the new commission 1360 00:37:00,587 --> 00:37:01,801 seated and those people that are 1361 00:37:01,801 --> 00:37:01,801 goin 1362 00:37:01,801 --> 00:37:03,106 goin to be dealing with this 1363 00:37:03,106 --> 00:37:04,933 new city manager potentially n 1364 00:37:04,933 --> 00:37:04,933 ew 1365 00:37:04,933 --> 00:37:05,164 city manager. 1366 00:37:05,164 --> 00:37:13,251 have the ability to weigh-in o 1367 00:37:13,251 --> 00:37:13,476 n 1368 00:37:13,476 --> 00:37:13,476 that. 1369 00:37:13,476 --> 00:37:15,117 regardless of whether there's a 1370 00:37:15,117 --> 00:37:15,348 1371 00:37:15,348 --> 00:37:17,519 runoff or not, those new 1372 00:37:17,519 --> 00:37:19,519 commissioners will not be part 1373 00:37:19,519 --> 00:37:19,968 1374 00:37:19,968 --> 00:37:20,951 of this board until january. 1375 00:37:20,951 --> 00:37:23,565 so that option 2 makes a lot o 1376 00:37:23,565 --> 00:37:23,660 f 1377 00:37:23,660 --> 00:37:25,727 sense to me, and I think 1378 00:37:25,727 --> 00:37:27,024 commissioner willits makes a 1379 00:37:27,024 --> 00:37:28,758 good point, a whole lot of 1380 00:37:28,758 --> 00:37:30,204 things change in november, 1381 00:37:30,204 --> 00:37:32,401 depending on what goes on on t 1382 00:37:32,401 --> 00:37:32,401 he 1383 00:37:32,401 --> 00:37:33,197 state level. 1384 00:37:33,197 --> 00:37:34,877 I'm sorry, I said that option 2 1385 00:37:34,877 --> 00:37:35,232 1386 00:37:35,232 --> 00:37:39,944 makes more sense, plus, we're 1387 00:37:39,944 --> 00:37:39,944 1388 00:37:39,944 --> 00:37:41,040 pushed past budget season. 1389 00:37:41,040 --> 00:37:42,276 that's where I am. 1390 00:37:42,276 --> 00:37:44,583 >> thank you, commissioner 1391 00:37:44,583 --> 00:37:44,583 ingle. 1392 00:37:44,583 --> 00:37:45,918 commissioner book? 1393 00:37:45,918 --> 00:37:46,567 >> thank you. 1394 00:37:46,567 --> 00:37:49,452 hr manager, I'm in agreement 1395 00:37:49,452 --> 00:37:50,689 with several of my colleagues, 1396 00:37:50,689 --> 00:37:51,263 1397 00:37:51,263 --> 00:37:53,088 as it relates to legitimacy and 1398 00:37:53,088 --> 00:37:53,223 1399 00:37:53,223 --> 00:37:54,822 trust, you follow process, and 1400 00:37:54,822 --> 00:37:54,922 1401 00:37:54,922 --> 00:37:56,620 you've had to do that for many 1402 00:37:56,620 --> 00:37:56,620 1403 00:37:56,620 --> 00:37:59,397 other employees across all 1404 00:37:59,397 --> 00:38:00,305 ranges in an organization, 1405 00:38:00,305 --> 00:38:01,899 that's how you instill to them 1406 00:38:01,899 --> 00:38:02,260 1407 00:38:02,260 --> 00:38:03,735 we follow the same rules at the 1408 00:38:03,735 --> 00:38:03,827 1409 00:38:03,827 --> 00:38:05,372 same time for the same group, I 1410 00:38:05,372 --> 00:38:05,630 1411 00:38:05,630 --> 00:38:06,463 think that's really important. 1412 00:38:06,463 --> 00:38:06,463 1413 00:38:06,463 --> 00:38:08,568 this is notwithstanding the fac 1414 00:38:08,568 --> 00:38:08,568 t 1415 00:38:08,568 --> 00:38:11,103 that the interim city manager I 1416 00:38:11,103 --> 00:38:11,103 s 1417 00:38:11,103 --> 00:38:12,068 doing an excellent job. 1418 00:38:12,068 --> 00:38:12,804 that's a fact. 1419 00:38:12,804 --> 00:38:15,138 I think that's not arguable 1420 00:38:15,138 --> 00:38:18,182 but that's different from when 1421 00:38:18,182 --> 00:38:18,319 1422 00:38:18,319 --> 00:38:19,611 we follow process. 1423 00:38:19,611 --> 00:38:23,226 miss manager, if you were to 1424 00:38:23,226 --> 00:38:25,072 pursue a process in hire, do yo 1425 00:38:25,072 --> 00:38:25,072 u 1426 00:38:25,072 --> 00:38:29,277 have a preference for one of 1427 00:38:29,277 --> 00:38:29,757 these options? 1428 00:38:29,757 --> 00:38:31,788 >> mayor and commissioner, we 1429 00:38:31,788 --> 00:38:31,788 1430 00:38:31,788 --> 00:38:33,170 could make either of those work 1431 00:38:33,170 --> 00:38:33,170 . 1432 00:38:33,170 --> 00:38:34,691 because we're in april right 1433 00:38:34,691 --> 00:38:37,455 now, we have ample time to 1434 00:38:37,455 --> 00:38:38,843 prepare for that, we should be 1435 00:38:38,843 --> 00:38:39,032 1436 00:38:39,032 --> 00:38:39,032 fine. 1437 00:38:39,032 --> 00:38:41,566 I appreciate the consideration. 1438 00:38:41,566 --> 00:38:41,929 1439 00:38:41,929 --> 00:38:43,641 >> well, I was thinking about 1440 00:38:43,641 --> 00:38:43,641 1441 00:38:43,641 --> 00:38:45,304 that, and also the last two 1442 00:38:45,304 --> 00:38:46,811 processes we did for charter 1443 00:38:46,811 --> 00:38:49,134 officers, our city leaders, we 1444 00:38:49,134 --> 00:38:49,134 1445 00:38:49,134 --> 00:38:49,626 did go through the process. 1446 00:38:49,626 --> 00:38:53,683 we followed process, and we had 1447 00:38:53,683 --> 00:38:54,352 1448 00:38:54,352 --> 00:38:55,389 internal candidate, and here's 1449 00:38:55,389 --> 00:38:55,862 1450 00:38:55,862 --> 00:38:57,153 the internal candidate. 1451 00:38:57,153 --> 00:38:59,482 and we had an external 1452 00:38:59,482 --> 00:39:01,786 candidate, and there he is 1453 00:39:01,786 --> 00:39:02,989 sitting at the back. 1454 00:39:02,989 --> 00:39:05,955 we had tremendous skill and 1455 00:39:05,955 --> 00:39:07,127 continuity, as commissioner 1456 00:39:07,127 --> 00:39:09,326 engle was talking about very 1457 00:39:09,326 --> 00:39:10,426 different than we were in 2022 1458 00:39:10,426 --> 00:39:11,031 , 1459 00:39:11,031 --> 00:39:13,297 and I like what you said, 1460 00:39:13,297 --> 00:39:14,168 commissioner eastman. 1461 00:39:14,168 --> 00:39:15,768 you want to make sure that 1462 00:39:15,768 --> 00:39:16,739 employees feel that we're doing 1463 00:39:16,739 --> 00:39:18,449 1464 00:39:18,449 --> 00:39:20,083 the same thing. 1465 00:39:20,083 --> 00:39:22,582 so I do favor a process, I thi 1466 00:39:22,582 --> 00:39:22,582 nk 1467 00:39:22,582 --> 00:39:26,243 it's probably the best way to 1468 00:39:26,243 --> 00:39:26,243 1469 00:39:26,243 --> 00:39:27,757 instill the legitimacy and 1470 00:39:27,757 --> 00:39:29,919 trust, and I hope the candidates 1471 00:39:29,919 --> 00:39:29,919 1472 00:39:29,919 --> 00:39:31,783 rise to the top, that's what you 1473 00:39:31,783 --> 00:39:31,783 1474 00:39:31,783 --> 00:39:31,783 want. 1475 00:39:31,783 --> 00:39:34,290 internal or external. 1476 00:39:34,290 --> 00:39:37,758 I don't have a preference for 1477 00:39:37,758 --> 00:39:37,758 1478 00:39:37,758 --> 00:39:39,360 option, but doi o support the 1479 00:39:39,360 --> 00:39:39,360 1480 00:39:39,360 --> 00:39:40,231 external process. 1481 00:39:40,231 --> 00:39:42,020 >> mayor: thank you, 1482 00:39:42,020 --> 00:39:42,345 commissioner book. 1483 00:39:42,345 --> 00:39:45,631 is there any public comment? 1484 00:39:45,631 --> 00:39:48,406 >> yes, ron rawles. 1485 00:39:48,406 --> 00:39:51,857 >> mayor: welcome, pastor 1486 00:39:51,857 --> 00:39:51,857 rawles. 1487 00:39:51,857 --> 00:39:55,413 >> I think we should definitel 1488 00:39:55,413 --> 00:39:56,543 y 1489 00:39:56,543 --> 00:39:57,445 have a search. 1490 00:39:57,445 --> 00:40:00,330 I think communication is 1491 00:40:00,330 --> 00:40:01,998 extremely important from our 1492 00:40:01,998 --> 00:40:02,861 side when we're dealing with th 1493 00:40:02,861 --> 00:40:02,861 e 1494 00:40:02,861 --> 00:40:06,421 city, and so sometimes what you 1495 00:40:06,421 --> 00:40:06,670 1496 00:40:06,670 --> 00:40:08,119 feel you have, the relationshi 1497 00:40:08,119 --> 00:40:08,119 ps 1498 00:40:08,119 --> 00:40:10,728 you feel you have, you may not 1499 00:40:10,728 --> 00:40:11,023 1500 00:40:11,023 --> 00:40:12,495 find you have those 1501 00:40:12,495 --> 00:40:13,992 relationships until you need 1502 00:40:13,992 --> 00:40:13,992 something. 1503 00:40:13,992 --> 00:40:16,992 and so recently, we tried to 1504 00:40:16,992 --> 00:40:19,871 assist one of our senior 1505 00:40:19,871 --> 00:40:19,871 citizens. 1506 00:40:19,871 --> 00:40:23,468 I had a horrible experience 1507 00:40:23,468 --> 00:40:25,553 trying to deal with a person I 1508 00:40:25,553 --> 00:40:26,874 n 1509 00:40:26,874 --> 00:40:28,919 permitting, and so I walked it 1510 00:40:28,919 --> 00:40:28,959 1511 00:40:28,959 --> 00:40:32,322 up the ladder, didn't get 1512 00:40:32,322 --> 00:40:33,734 response from the director ove 1513 00:40:33,734 --> 00:40:33,862 r 1514 00:40:33,862 --> 00:40:36,633 in permitting, tried to walk it 1515 00:40:36,633 --> 00:40:36,722 1516 00:40:36,722 --> 00:40:38,427 up the ladder, couldn't get a 1517 00:40:38,427 --> 00:40:38,427 1518 00:40:38,427 --> 00:40:40,557 response from the city manager' 1519 00:40:40,557 --> 00:40:40,557 s 1520 00:40:40,557 --> 00:40:40,557 office. 1521 00:40:40,557 --> 00:40:45,856 and so we need more than a 1522 00:40:45,856 --> 00:40:45,856 smile. 1523 00:40:45,856 --> 00:40:49,003 I need to know if we need to communic 1524 00:40:49,003 --> 00:40:50,273 communicate with you to get som 1525 00:40:50,273 --> 00:40:50,273 e 1526 00:40:50,273 --> 00:40:53,936 clarification that we have tha 1527 00:40:53,936 --> 00:40:54,264 t 1528 00:40:54,264 --> 00:40:54,264 ability. 1529 00:40:54,264 --> 00:40:56,098 not your previous city manager, 1530 00:40:56,098 --> 00:40:56,775 1531 00:40:56,775 --> 00:40:58,273 but the one before that that w 1532 00:40:58,273 --> 00:40:58,273 as 1533 00:40:58,273 --> 00:41:00,046 a horrible experience. Th 1534 00:41:00,046 --> 00:41:07,043 the previous manager was a goo 1535 00:41:07,043 --> 00:41:07,447 d 1536 00:41:07,447 --> 00:41:07,447 experience. 1537 00:41:07,447 --> 00:41:09,160 you could communicate, walk it 1538 00:41:09,160 --> 00:41:09,345 1539 00:41:09,345 --> 00:41:10,817 up the ladder and follow the 1540 00:41:10,817 --> 00:41:10,817 process. 1541 00:41:10,817 --> 00:41:15,387 as citizens, we need to have a 1542 00:41:15,387 --> 00:41:16,756 n 1543 00:41:16,756 --> 00:41:22,764 input to see who it is that 1544 00:41:22,764 --> 00:41:25,278 applies, the credentials and 1545 00:41:25,278 --> 00:41:27,798 have a feel that we're heard 1546 00:41:27,798 --> 00:41:28,136 from our side. 1547 00:41:28,136 --> 00:41:30,153 this is no complaint against mr. 1548 00:41:30,153 --> 00:41:30,153 1549 00:41:30,153 --> 00:41:31,808 persons, but I do feel that we 1550 00:41:31,808 --> 00:41:33,143 1551 00:41:33,143 --> 00:41:35,542 need to have a -- for our 1552 00:41:35,542 --> 00:41:40,776 comfort and our ease, to make 1553 00:41:40,776 --> 00:41:40,776 1554 00:41:40,776 --> 00:41:41,952 sure that it's nothing you get 1555 00:41:41,952 --> 00:41:42,091 1556 00:41:42,091 --> 00:41:44,055 from entitlement or a few peopl 1557 00:41:44,055 --> 00:41:44,055 e 1558 00:41:44,055 --> 00:41:44,685 like you. 1559 00:41:44,685 --> 00:41:46,224 it's because the community 1560 00:41:46,224 --> 00:41:47,588 trusts the leadership that we' 1561 00:41:47,588 --> 00:41:47,588 re 1562 00:41:47,588 --> 00:41:53,864 about to spend $55,000 on a 1563 00:41:53,864 --> 00:41:55,259 private company to make sure 1564 00:41:55,259 --> 00:42:02,568 that they can be sustained. 1565 00:42:02,568 --> 00:42:04,942 we're about to give away $55,000 1566 00:42:04,942 --> 00:42:04,942 1567 00:42:04,942 --> 00:42:07,931 to a private entity that's for 1568 00:42:07,931 --> 00:42:08,405 1569 00:42:08,405 --> 00:42:10,382 profit, definitely we could 1570 00:42:10,382 --> 00:42:12,516 spend $100,000 to make sure we 1571 00:42:12,516 --> 00:42:13,046 1572 00:42:13,046 --> 00:42:13,406 have a great leader. 1573 00:42:13,406 --> 00:42:18,797 >> mayor: thank you, pastor 1574 00:42:18,797 --> 00:42:18,797 rawles. 1575 00:42:18,797 --> 00:42:22,395 >> that was our last speaker. 1576 00:42:22,395 --> 00:42:26,722 >> mayor: commissioner duncan 1577 00:42:26,722 --> 00:42:26,722 1578 00:42:26,722 --> 00:42:26,722 walker? 1579 00:42:26,722 --> 00:42:28,294 >> my comments are brief. 1580 00:42:28,294 --> 00:42:30,601 I support the public process fo 1581 00:42:30,601 --> 00:42:30,601 r 1582 00:42:30,601 --> 00:42:31,839 most of the reasons most of us 1583 00:42:31,839 --> 00:42:31,964 1584 00:42:31,964 --> 00:42:32,909 have stated up here today. 1585 00:42:32,909 --> 00:42:35,301 I have had the opportunity to 1586 00:42:35,301 --> 00:42:35,301 1587 00:42:35,301 --> 00:42:36,838 watch the community really 1588 00:42:36,838 --> 00:42:38,104 enjoy, and not just get 1589 00:42:38,104 --> 00:42:40,068 something out of, but be able t 1590 00:42:40,068 --> 00:42:40,068 o 1591 00:42:40,068 --> 00:42:41,979 provide what I consider valuable 1592 00:42:41,979 --> 00:42:41,979 1593 00:42:41,979 --> 00:42:43,946 input to us, when they've had 1594 00:42:43,946 --> 00:42:43,946 1595 00:42:43,946 --> 00:42:45,590 the opportunity to interact wit 1596 00:42:45,590 --> 00:42:45,590 h 1597 00:42:45,590 --> 00:42:47,044 those individuals who were 1598 00:42:47,044 --> 00:42:48,260 applying for this position in 1599 00:42:48,260 --> 00:42:48,260 1600 00:42:48,260 --> 00:42:55,260 the meet and greets and in the 1601 00:42:55,260 --> 00:42:56,842 1602 00:42:56,842 --> 00:42:58,528 varying ways they can when the 1603 00:42:58,528 --> 00:42:58,528 1604 00:42:58,528 --> 00:42:58,815 process is public. 1605 00:42:58,815 --> 00:43:04,668 it's accessibility, it's 1606 00:43:04,668 --> 00:43:05,905 transparency, and it's the kin 1607 00:43:05,905 --> 00:43:06,140 d 1608 00:43:06,140 --> 00:43:07,443 of trust we need to continue t 1609 00:43:07,443 --> 00:43:07,546 o 1610 00:43:07,546 --> 00:43:11,172 build with the public, so 1611 00:43:11,172 --> 00:43:11,972 certainly I support that. 1612 00:43:11,972 --> 00:43:13,503 I'm on the fence about the tim 1613 00:43:13,503 --> 00:43:14,973 e 1614 00:43:14,973 --> 00:43:16,311 frames, because while part of m 1615 00:43:16,311 --> 00:43:16,311 e 1616 00:43:16,311 --> 00:43:19,512 would like to jump into it. 1617 00:43:19,512 --> 00:43:20,724 another part of me thinks from 1618 00:43:20,724 --> 00:43:20,852 1619 00:43:20,852 --> 00:43:22,950 the perspective of where we may 1620 00:43:22,950 --> 00:43:23,093 1621 00:43:23,093 --> 00:43:26,055 be down the line, and that lev 1622 00:43:26,055 --> 00:43:26,055 el 1623 00:43:26,055 --> 00:43:27,527 of just not knowing who will b 1624 00:43:27,527 --> 00:43:27,867 e 1625 00:43:27,867 --> 00:43:30,291 here, and I remember some 1626 00:43:30,291 --> 00:43:31,790 comments by some of my 1627 00:43:31,790 --> 00:43:32,807 colleagues who are here with u 1628 00:43:32,807 --> 00:43:32,926 s 1629 00:43:32,926 --> 00:43:34,465 now about wishing they had had 1630 00:43:34,465 --> 00:43:34,594 1631 00:43:34,594 --> 00:43:37,839 the desire to be a part of the 1632 00:43:37,839 --> 00:43:38,640 1633 00:43:38,640 --> 00:43:40,440 process n making a selection 1634 00:43:40,440 --> 00:43:41,470 that occurred just before they 1635 00:43:41,470 --> 00:43:41,816 1636 00:43:41,816 --> 00:43:42,198 got here. 1637 00:43:42,198 --> 00:43:44,042 I'm sensitive to throws types o 1638 00:43:44,042 --> 00:43:44,042 f 1639 00:43:44,042 --> 00:43:46,332 things, if I put myself in that 1640 00:43:46,332 --> 00:43:46,510 1641 00:43:46,510 --> 00:43:48,242 situation, where I had just 1642 00:43:48,242 --> 00:43:49,615 missed that opportunity and 1643 00:43:49,615 --> 00:43:50,431 literally the individuals who 1644 00:43:50,431 --> 00:43:50,431 1645 00:43:50,431 --> 00:43:52,018 were a port of that process, 1646 00:43:52,018 --> 00:43:53,953 were no longer at the dais, tha 1647 00:43:53,953 --> 00:43:53,953 t 1648 00:43:53,953 --> 00:43:56,885 would really be something. 1649 00:43:56,885 --> 00:43:58,747 I'd like to get down to 1650 00:43:58,747 --> 00:44:00,786 business, absolutely, but I als 1651 00:44:00,786 --> 00:44:00,786 o 1652 00:44:00,786 --> 00:44:03,427 am sensitive to the fact that 1653 00:44:03,427 --> 00:44:03,427 1654 00:44:03,427 --> 00:44:05,499 whoever is sitting at this dai 1655 00:44:05,499 --> 00:44:05,692 s 1656 00:44:05,692 --> 00:44:10,136 should be a part of making tha 1657 00:44:10,136 --> 00:44:10,400 t 1658 00:44:10,400 --> 00:44:11,928 decision in who they will have 1659 00:44:11,928 --> 00:44:12,237 1660 00:44:12,237 --> 00:44:13,611 the opportunity to work with, 1661 00:44:13,611 --> 00:44:13,611 1662 00:44:13,611 --> 00:44:14,700 when they're seated here. 1663 00:44:14,700 --> 00:44:16,932 I'll conclude my comments with 1664 00:44:16,932 --> 00:44:17,138 1665 00:44:17,138 --> 00:44:18,546 that but the public being 1666 00:44:18,546 --> 00:44:20,936 involved in this process is 1667 00:44:20,936 --> 00:44:21,479 really my most important piece 1668 00:44:21,479 --> 00:44:21,479 . 1669 00:44:21,479 --> 00:44:25,187 >> thank you, commissioner 1670 00:44:25,187 --> 00:44:26,090 duncan walker. 1671 00:44:26,090 --> 00:44:27,045 commissioner eastman? 1672 00:44:27,045 --> 00:44:27,842 >> thank you. 1673 00:44:27,842 --> 00:44:29,479 before I spoke on doing the 1674 00:44:29,479 --> 00:44:30,680 public process, before I do 1675 00:44:30,680 --> 00:44:33,228 that, I want to say, mr. Mayor 1676 00:44:33,228 --> 00:44:33,423 1677 00:44:33,423 --> 00:44:35,956 in the last process that we ha 1678 00:44:35,956 --> 00:44:35,956 d, 1679 00:44:35,956 --> 00:44:37,898 where we were deciding about - 1680 00:44:37,898 --> 00:44:38,162 - 1681 00:44:38,162 --> 00:44:39,226 when you first came into office 1682 00:44:39,226 --> 00:44:39,226 , 1683 00:44:39,226 --> 00:44:41,696 there was a slew of -- everyon 1684 00:44:41,696 --> 00:44:42,358 e 1685 00:44:42,358 --> 00:44:43,905 was interim at that point. 1686 00:44:43,905 --> 00:44:45,733 one permanent. 1687 00:44:45,733 --> 00:44:47,970 you made the recommendation to 1688 00:44:47,970 --> 00:44:47,970 ma 1689 00:44:47,970 --> 00:44:48,947 make all of those -- to move 1690 00:44:48,947 --> 00:44:53,706 from interim to the permanent 1691 00:44:53,706 --> 00:44:53,706 1692 00:44:53,706 --> 00:44:53,706 positions. 1693 00:44:53,706 --> 00:44:54,671 that was brand new in the role. 1694 00:44:54,671 --> 00:44:54,671 1695 00:44:54,671 --> 00:44:57,264 I would say you were 100% right 1696 00:44:57,264 --> 00:44:57,500 abou 1697 00:44:57,500 --> 00:44:57,766 about that. We 1698 00:44:57,766 --> 00:44:59,566 we had no idea what we were 1699 00:44:59,566 --> 00:45:00,449 about to go through. 1700 00:45:00,449 --> 00:45:02,062 there's no way we could have 1701 00:45:02,062 --> 00:45:04,355 told the future, I was thankful 1702 00:45:04,355 --> 00:45:04,583 1703 00:45:04,583 --> 00:45:05,880 for you for taking that kind o 1704 00:45:05,880 --> 00:45:05,976 f 1705 00:45:05,976 --> 00:45:07,420 a stance, and in this instance 1706 00:45:07,420 --> 00:45:08,257 , 1707 00:45:08,257 --> 00:45:10,664 I -- I still feel now as I do 1708 00:45:10,664 --> 00:45:10,664 1709 00:45:10,664 --> 00:45:12,361 then, that this is an important 1710 00:45:12,361 --> 00:45:13,044 1711 00:45:13,044 --> 00:45:15,058 process to go through. 1712 00:45:15,058 --> 00:45:17,268 but just to give some credence 1713 00:45:17,268 --> 00:45:17,738 1714 00:45:17,738 --> 00:45:24,873 to what your point was at the 1715 00:45:24,873 --> 00:45:24,873 1716 00:45:24,873 --> 00:45:24,873 time. 1717 00:45:24,873 --> 00:45:27,536 I am in favor, but I didn't get 1718 00:45:27,536 --> 00:45:27,780 1719 00:45:27,780 --> 00:45:29,793 into option one or option two, 1720 00:45:29,793 --> 00:45:30,339 I 1721 00:45:30,339 --> 00:45:32,084 support commissioner chestnut's, 1722 00:45:32,084 --> 00:45:33,579 what you said about option one, 1723 00:45:33,579 --> 00:45:34,047 1724 00:45:34,047 --> 00:45:35,328 I think there's always going t 1725 00:45:35,328 --> 00:45:35,418 o be 1726 00:45:35,418 --> 00:45:36,490 be more questions, more thought 1727 00:45:36,490 --> 00:45:36,490 s 1728 00:45:36,490 --> 00:45:39,941 as to where we -- you know, that 1729 00:45:39,941 --> 00:45:39,941 1730 00:45:39,941 --> 00:45:41,450 we could hold this off for 1731 00:45:41,450 --> 00:45:42,651 longer, I think it's important 1732 00:45:42,651 --> 00:45:42,831 1733 00:45:42,831 --> 00:45:44,630 to get someone in that is 1734 00:45:44,630 --> 00:45:45,583 permanent and get this done as 1735 00:45:45,583 --> 00:45:46,023 1736 00:45:46,023 --> 00:45:47,494 opposed to have this holdout for 1737 00:45:47,494 --> 00:45:47,494 1738 00:45:47,494 --> 00:45:47,932 a while. 1739 00:45:47,932 --> 00:45:49,730 regardless of what we do, I'll 1740 00:45:49,730 --> 00:45:50,700 1741 00:45:50,700 --> 00:45:51,662 point out this ends. 1742 00:45:51,662 --> 00:45:54,560 if you look at the time line, we 1743 00:45:54,560 --> 00:45:54,560 1744 00:45:54,560 --> 00:45:55,867 are interviewing folks, and this 1745 00:45:55,867 --> 00:45:55,867 1746 00:45:55,867 --> 00:45:59,980 comes to a decision point in 1747 00:45:59,980 --> 00:45:59,980 december. 1748 00:45:59,980 --> 00:46:03,439 we do the final employment 1749 00:46:03,439 --> 00:46:04,784 agreement in week 16, we selec 1750 00:46:04,784 --> 00:46:05,910 t 1751 00:46:05,910 --> 00:46:08,116 the charter officer week 14 and 1752 00:46:08,116 --> 00:46:08,444 1753 00:46:08,444 --> 00:46:08,444 15. 1754 00:46:08,444 --> 00:46:10,498 there's ample opportunity for 1755 00:46:10,498 --> 00:46:10,498 1756 00:46:10,498 --> 00:46:12,497 whoever runs and wins, which m 1757 00:46:12,497 --> 00:46:12,497 ay 1758 00:46:12,497 --> 00:46:15,435 end in august, aas opposed to 1759 00:46:15,435 --> 00:46:15,435 1760 00:46:15,435 --> 00:46:16,412 november and december. 1761 00:46:16,412 --> 00:46:19,560 even if there is a runoff for 1762 00:46:19,560 --> 00:46:19,560 1763 00:46:19,560 --> 00:46:20,139 that person to come in and hav 1764 00:46:20,139 --> 00:46:20,226 e 1765 00:46:20,226 --> 00:46:20,824 a say in that. 1766 00:46:20,824 --> 00:46:22,390 I would rather just have this. 1767 00:46:22,390 --> 00:46:22,390 1768 00:46:22,390 --> 00:46:24,600 I would rather get this done, 1769 00:46:24,600 --> 00:46:24,600 1770 00:46:24,600 --> 00:46:26,300 have this off the table and be 1771 00:46:26,300 --> 00:46:26,496 1772 00:46:26,496 --> 00:46:28,304 able to move through to other 1773 00:46:28,304 --> 00:46:28,304 1774 00:46:28,304 --> 00:46:28,304 priorities. 1775 00:46:28,304 --> 00:46:30,062 I would support option one. 1776 00:46:30,062 --> 00:46:30,328 thank you. 1777 00:46:30,328 --> 00:46:33,539 >> mayor: thank you, 1778 00:46:33,539 --> 00:46:34,706 commissioner eastman, 1779 00:46:34,706 --> 00:46:38,480 commissioner willits? 1780 00:46:38,480 --> 00:46:39,607 >> thank you, mayor. 1781 00:46:39,607 --> 00:46:41,012 new commissioners may have a 1782 00:46:41,012 --> 00:46:43,486 say, which I like input, but a 1783 00:46:43,486 --> 00:46:43,686 1784 00:46:43,686 --> 00:46:45,214 say is a vote, you know, and t 1785 00:46:45,214 --> 00:46:45,214 he 1786 00:46:45,214 --> 00:46:47,562 thing is, we go with option 1, 1787 00:46:47,562 --> 00:46:47,987 1788 00:46:47,987 --> 00:46:50,024 you can literally have a 1789 00:46:50,024 --> 00:46:51,019 majority of this commission 1790 00:46:51,019 --> 00:46:52,996 that's not going to work with 1791 00:46:52,996 --> 00:46:52,996 1792 00:46:52,996 --> 00:46:54,296 this new manager. 1793 00:46:54,296 --> 00:46:56,770 not people who lose an electio 1794 00:46:56,770 --> 00:46:56,953 n 1795 00:46:56,953 --> 00:46:58,868 are going to say -- oh, I'm 1796 00:46:58,868 --> 00:47:00,016 going to stick you with the dud 1797 00:47:00,016 --> 00:47:00,988 1798 00:47:00,988 --> 00:47:02,972 or something, but they won't 1799 00:47:02,972 --> 00:47:04,246 have to face the consequences of 1800 00:47:04,246 --> 00:47:04,246 1801 00:47:04,246 --> 00:47:06,714 working with the next manager. 1802 00:47:06,714 --> 00:47:06,714 1803 00:47:06,714 --> 00:47:08,656 and I have a lot of trust in m 1804 00:47:08,656 --> 00:47:09,106 y 1805 00:47:09,106 --> 00:47:10,946 colleagues, we try to do what' 1806 00:47:10,946 --> 00:47:11,141 s 1807 00:47:11,141 --> 00:47:13,110 right, kind of for the long 1808 00:47:13,110 --> 00:47:14,854 term, not necessarily what an 1809 00:47:14,854 --> 00:47:14,854 1810 00:47:14,854 --> 00:47:16,720 individual needs or wants, wha 1811 00:47:16,720 --> 00:47:16,882 t 1812 00:47:16,882 --> 00:47:18,182 the community needs or wants. 1813 00:47:18,182 --> 00:47:20,096 that's why I lean toward optio 1814 00:47:20,096 --> 00:47:20,320 n 1815 00:47:20,320 --> 00:47:22,023 two, I get a -- I don't always 1816 00:47:22,023 --> 00:47:22,658 1817 00:47:22,658 --> 00:47:24,763 think that we should have to 1818 00:47:24,763 --> 00:47:25,858 like -- there's always going t 1819 00:47:25,858 --> 00:47:25,896 o 1820 00:47:25,896 --> 00:47:29,375 be an election, an issue, if w 1821 00:47:29,375 --> 00:47:29,418 e 1822 00:47:29,418 --> 00:47:30,830 were doing this last fall, wou 1823 00:47:30,830 --> 00:47:30,830 ld 1824 00:47:30,830 --> 00:47:32,602 I have said yeah, let's get it 1825 00:47:32,602 --> 00:47:32,835 1826 00:47:32,835 --> 00:47:33,697 done right there. 1827 00:47:33,697 --> 00:47:35,697 in my mind, we're close enough 1828 00:47:35,697 --> 00:47:36,203 , 1829 00:47:36,203 --> 00:47:37,900 looking out that, okay, make 1830 00:47:37,900 --> 00:47:39,576 this that process, and the new 1831 00:47:39,576 --> 00:47:40,040 1832 00:47:40,040 --> 00:47:41,943 commissioners would be able to 1833 00:47:41,943 --> 00:47:42,256 1834 00:47:42,256 --> 00:47:43,356 in january -- even in october, 1835 00:47:43,356 --> 00:47:44,454 1836 00:47:44,454 --> 00:47:48,447 they will know who applicants 1837 00:47:48,447 --> 00:47:48,447 1838 00:47:48,447 --> 00:47:48,447 are. 1839 00:47:48,447 --> 00:47:51,312 by december, know who the 1840 00:47:51,312 --> 00:47:52,464 finalists are, there's a 1841 00:47:52,464 --> 00:47:54,252 process, and they can hit the 1842 00:47:54,252 --> 00:47:54,252 1843 00:47:54,252 --> 00:47:58,725 ground in january, having 1844 00:47:58,725 --> 00:48:00,292 conversations and be able to 1845 00:48:00,292 --> 00:48:01,659 vote, that's what I lean toward 1846 00:48:01,659 --> 00:48:01,786 1847 00:48:01,786 --> 00:48:01,786 too. 1848 00:48:01,786 --> 00:48:01,786 thanks. 1849 00:48:01,786 --> 00:48:06,531 >> mayor: thank you, 1850 00:48:06,531 --> 00:48:08,150 commissioner chestnut? 1851 00:48:08,150 --> 00:48:10,444 >> yes, I just want to add, 1852 00:48:10,444 --> 00:48:12,846 commissioner eastman was elected 1853 00:48:12,846 --> 00:48:12,846 1854 00:48:12,846 --> 00:48:16,546 in august and could not be 1855 00:48:16,546 --> 00:48:17,284 seated until january. 1856 00:48:17,284 --> 00:48:19,788 we involved him in each -- he 1857 00:48:19,788 --> 00:48:19,788 1858 00:48:19,788 --> 00:48:21,757 was invited to sit at the table 1859 00:48:21,757 --> 00:48:22,044 1860 00:48:22,044 --> 00:48:23,160 in each discussion, so that he 1861 00:48:23,160 --> 00:48:23,160 1862 00:48:23,160 --> 00:48:25,295 was involved in the process. 1863 00:48:25,295 --> 00:48:29,128 while he did not have a vote, h 1864 00:48:29,128 --> 00:48:29,128 e 1865 00:48:29,128 --> 00:48:29,886 had a voice. 1866 00:48:29,886 --> 00:48:32,056 and we heard his voice. 1867 00:48:32,056 --> 00:48:34,465 so that's why I was going with 1868 00:48:34,465 --> 00:48:34,597 1869 00:48:34,597 --> 00:48:38,365 option one, because I think -- 1870 00:48:38,365 --> 00:48:38,635 I 1871 00:48:38,635 --> 00:48:41,175 suspect all of you will be 1872 00:48:41,175 --> 00:48:45,443 re-elected in august, except f 1873 00:48:45,443 --> 00:48:45,443 or 1874 00:48:45,443 --> 00:48:47,568 one -- 1875 00:48:47,568 --> 00:48:48,180 [ inaudible ] 1876 00:48:48,180 --> 00:48:49,277 and you'll be at the table unt 1877 00:48:49,277 --> 00:48:49,277 il 1878 00:48:49,277 --> 00:48:51,395 we begin that process in 1879 00:48:51,395 --> 00:48:51,395 january. 1880 00:48:51,395 --> 00:48:51,834 thank you. 1881 00:48:51,834 --> 00:48:54,758 >> mayor: thank you. 1882 00:48:54,758 --> 00:48:56,628 commissioner chestnut, I 1883 00:48:56,628 --> 00:49:00,120 appreciate your optimism, but I 1884 00:49:00,120 --> 00:49:00,822 1885 00:49:00,822 --> 00:49:04,088 do want us to be mindful that 1886 00:49:04,088 --> 00:49:04,088 1887 00:49:04,088 --> 00:49:06,192 because of what we've said, thi 1888 00:49:06,192 --> 00:49:06,192 s 1889 00:49:06,192 --> 00:49:08,594 is likely -- or at least 1890 00:49:08,594 --> 00:49:10,862 potentially to become a campaig 1891 00:49:10,862 --> 00:49:10,862 n 1892 00:49:10,862 --> 00:49:14,599 issue if we do it with option 1893 00:49:14,599 --> 00:49:14,599 1894 00:49:14,599 --> 00:49:14,599 one. 1895 00:49:14,599 --> 00:49:20,308 I don't think you want to chose 1896 00:49:20,308 --> 00:49:20,436 1897 00:49:20,436 --> 00:49:25,412 a city manager by ballot, that' 1898 00:49:25,412 --> 00:49:25,412 s 1899 00:49:25,412 --> 00:49:26,168 not our system. 1900 00:49:26,168 --> 00:49:28,617 I'm not saying it's a bad 1901 00:49:28,617 --> 00:49:29,952 system, but that's not what our 1902 00:49:29,952 --> 00:49:30,220 1903 00:49:30,220 --> 00:49:34,234 system is supposed to be. 1904 00:49:34,234 --> 00:49:37,046 I for that reason would be more 1905 00:49:37,046 --> 00:49:37,681 1906 00:49:37,681 --> 00:49:38,958 comfortable with making it 1907 00:49:38,958 --> 00:49:39,224 option two. 1908 00:49:39,224 --> 00:49:41,368 if there are four new people 1909 00:49:41,368 --> 00:49:42,696 here, I want to make sure they 1910 00:49:42,696 --> 00:49:42,834 1911 00:49:42,834 --> 00:49:43,262 get a vote. 1912 00:49:43,262 --> 00:49:45,712 the one we know is going to be 1913 00:49:45,712 --> 00:49:45,960 1914 00:49:45,960 --> 00:49:50,400 different, gets a vote on who 1915 00:49:50,400 --> 00:49:50,400 1916 00:49:50,400 --> 00:49:51,607 they're going to be working wit 1917 00:49:51,607 --> 00:49:51,607 h 1918 00:49:51,607 --> 00:49:52,648 as city manager. 1919 00:49:52,648 --> 00:49:54,214 I'm generally open to the other 1920 00:49:54,214 --> 00:49:55,006 1921 00:49:55,006 --> 00:49:58,424 one, but the politicization of 1922 00:49:58,424 --> 00:49:58,510 1923 00:49:58,510 --> 00:50:01,882 it leads me to option 2. 1924 00:50:01,882 --> 00:50:05,418 and I want to say, also, 1925 00:50:05,418 --> 00:50:06,916 commissioner willits, I hear 1926 00:50:06,916 --> 00:50:08,360 what you're saying about the 1927 00:50:08,360 --> 00:50:09,924 property tax vote and that sor 1928 00:50:09,924 --> 00:50:10,486 t 1929 00:50:10,486 --> 00:50:14,403 of thing, anyone who might app 1930 00:50:14,403 --> 00:50:14,403 ly 1931 00:50:14,403 --> 00:50:16,626 who is anyone we want to hire 1932 00:50:16,626 --> 00:50:16,626 is 1933 00:50:16,626 --> 00:50:17,938 already watching that they're 1934 00:50:17,938 --> 00:50:17,938 1935 00:50:17,938 --> 00:50:18,478 already on it. 1936 00:50:18,478 --> 00:50:20,736 and if they're not again, 1937 00:50:20,736 --> 00:50:23,614 they're probably not someone w 1938 00:50:23,614 --> 00:50:25,575 e 1939 00:50:25,575 --> 00:50:27,771 want to hire. 1940 00:50:27,771 --> 00:50:30,274 everything that we take for 1941 00:50:30,274 --> 00:50:31,111 granted because we're in the 1942 00:50:31,111 --> 00:50:32,786 middle of it, people from the 1943 00:50:32,786 --> 00:50:32,786 1944 00:50:32,786 --> 00:50:35,582 outside are saying, is that 1945 00:50:35,582 --> 00:50:37,248 something I want? 1946 00:50:37,248 --> 00:50:40,486 but I would just caution us wit 1947 00:50:40,486 --> 00:50:40,486 h 1948 00:50:40,486 --> 00:50:40,486 that. 1949 00:50:40,486 --> 00:50:42,890 and again, that probably seeks 1950 00:50:42,890 --> 00:50:43,194 1951 00:50:43,194 --> 00:50:44,296 better to option two. 1952 00:50:44,296 --> 00:50:51,795 I'm open to option 2. 1953 00:50:51,795 --> 00:50:54,604 >> I'll try not to say the sam 1954 00:50:54,604 --> 00:50:54,738 e 1955 00:50:54,738 --> 00:50:55,041 thing twice. 1956 00:50:55,041 --> 00:51:00,085 I would like to throw another 1957 00:51:00,085 --> 00:51:00,085 1958 00:51:00,085 --> 00:51:02,748 reason on why I'm in favor of 1959 00:51:02,748 --> 00:51:02,748 1960 00:51:02,748 --> 00:51:04,706 option 2. 1961 00:51:04,706 --> 00:51:06,882 is that, just the other things 1962 00:51:06,882 --> 00:51:06,882 1963 00:51:06,882 --> 00:51:07,842 going on at the time. 1964 00:51:07,842 --> 00:51:09,536 in august you were looking at 1965 00:51:09,536 --> 00:51:09,536 1966 00:51:09,536 --> 00:51:10,968 elections that I think a lot o 1967 00:51:10,968 --> 00:51:11,316 f 1968 00:51:11,316 --> 00:51:13,290 us would be focused on, and the 1969 00:51:13,290 --> 00:51:13,290 n 1970 00:51:13,290 --> 00:51:14,342 september you were going to be 1971 00:51:14,342 --> 00:51:14,722 1972 00:51:14,722 --> 00:51:16,190 looking at the middle of budge 1973 00:51:16,190 --> 00:51:16,394 t 1974 00:51:16,394 --> 00:51:19,229 season, which is probably one o 1975 00:51:19,229 --> 00:51:19,229 f 1976 00:51:19,229 --> 00:51:21,427 the most intense things we do. 1977 00:51:21,427 --> 00:51:21,427 1978 00:51:21,427 --> 00:51:23,758 and it seems like a lot of 1979 00:51:23,758 --> 00:51:26,343 overlap to start this process I 1980 00:51:26,343 --> 00:51:26,343 n 1981 00:51:26,343 --> 00:51:27,939 the middle of. 1982 00:51:27,939 --> 00:51:30,598 if this is going to be a long 1983 00:51:30,598 --> 00:51:30,598 1984 00:51:30,598 --> 00:51:31,944 process, I just assume it be t 1985 00:51:31,944 --> 00:51:31,944 he 1986 00:51:31,944 --> 00:51:34,206 focus of what we're doing, I 1987 00:51:34,206 --> 00:51:35,610 think option two puts the bulk 1988 00:51:35,610 --> 00:51:35,824 of 1989 00:51:35,824 --> 00:51:37,326 of that work into a time that w 1990 00:51:37,326 --> 00:51:37,326 e 1991 00:51:37,326 --> 00:51:39,878 usually got the ability to foc 1992 00:51:39,878 --> 00:51:39,878 us 1993 00:51:39,878 --> 00:51:42,120 on that issue, instead of 1994 00:51:42,120 --> 00:51:44,299 looking at the budget, looking 1995 00:51:44,299 --> 00:51:44,583 1996 00:51:44,583 --> 00:51:46,219 at all these other things that 1997 00:51:46,219 --> 00:51:46,219 1998 00:51:46,219 --> 00:51:46,615 are going on. 1999 00:51:46,615 --> 00:51:48,317 I'm an option 2 fan, but that' 2000 00:51:48,317 --> 00:51:48,409 s 2001 00:51:48,409 --> 00:51:48,799 where I stand on that. 2002 00:51:48,799 --> 00:51:52,875 >> mayor: thank you, 2003 00:51:52,875 --> 00:51:53,232 commissioner ingle. 2004 00:51:53,232 --> 00:51:53,925 commissioner book. 2005 00:51:53,925 --> 00:51:56,260 >> just hearing so many comment 2006 00:51:56,260 --> 00:51:56,260 s 2007 00:51:56,260 --> 00:51:58,407 makes me lean toward the first 2008 00:51:58,407 --> 00:51:58,670 2009 00:51:58,670 --> 00:51:58,670 option. 2010 00:51:58,670 --> 00:52:00,749 and the reason for that, I 2011 00:52:00,749 --> 00:52:08,512 always like to depoliticize 2012 00:52:08,512 --> 00:52:09,574 anything we're doing. 2013 00:52:09,574 --> 00:52:13,713 I know people will know we're 2014 00:52:13,713 --> 00:52:13,713 2015 00:52:13,713 --> 00:52:15,517 looking at decisions, whether I 2016 00:52:15,517 --> 00:52:15,517 t 2017 00:52:15,517 --> 00:52:16,925 benefits us or doesn't benefit 2018 00:52:16,925 --> 00:52:16,925 2019 00:52:16,925 --> 00:52:16,925 us. 2020 00:52:16,925 --> 00:52:22,524 the least political decision w 2021 00:52:22,524 --> 00:52:22,625 e 2022 00:52:22,625 --> 00:52:24,134 can make, we always have 2023 00:52:24,134 --> 00:52:25,529 tremendous amounts of other big 2024 00:52:25,529 --> 00:52:25,861 2025 00:52:25,861 --> 00:52:26,325 things going on. 2026 00:52:26,325 --> 00:52:28,225 I think the fact that anybody, 2027 00:52:28,225 --> 00:52:28,683 2028 00:52:28,683 --> 00:52:31,400 even if I'm not rerunning, for 2029 00:52:31,400 --> 00:52:31,485 2030 00:52:31,485 --> 00:52:33,600 example, you -- I feel like I 2031 00:52:33,600 --> 00:52:33,600 2032 00:52:33,600 --> 00:52:34,697 will have a voice regardless. 2033 00:52:34,697 --> 00:52:36,536 I'm going to support either 2034 00:52:36,536 --> 00:52:38,116 option, I think the process is 2035 00:52:38,116 --> 00:52:38,379 2036 00:52:38,379 --> 00:52:40,610 much more important than any o 2037 00:52:40,610 --> 00:52:40,610 ne 2038 00:52:40,610 --> 00:52:41,181 of us. 2039 00:52:41,181 --> 00:52:43,027 but I think taking any of the, 2040 00:52:43,027 --> 00:52:43,442 2041 00:52:43,442 --> 00:52:45,341 who's going to be elected and 2042 00:52:45,341 --> 00:52:45,341 2043 00:52:45,341 --> 00:52:46,849 who's going to be sitting up 2044 00:52:46,849 --> 00:52:49,152 here out of the equation is 2045 00:52:49,152 --> 00:52:50,211 possible, even though people 2046 00:52:50,211 --> 00:52:52,285 will give, they will think tha 2047 00:52:52,285 --> 00:52:53,128 t 2048 00:52:53,128 --> 00:52:54,517 we may have explanations that 2049 00:52:54,517 --> 00:52:54,517 2050 00:52:54,517 --> 00:52:57,394 lean toward one or the other I 2051 00:52:57,394 --> 00:52:58,152 s 2052 00:52:58,152 --> 00:52:58,152 important. 2053 00:52:58,152 --> 00:53:00,292 that's just me. 2054 00:53:00,292 --> 00:53:00,883 >> mayor: thank you, 2055 00:53:00,883 --> 00:53:01,215 commissioner book. 2056 00:53:01,215 --> 00:53:07,028 does someone want to make a 2057 00:53:07,028 --> 00:53:08,662 motion, commissioner chestnut? 2058 00:53:08,662 --> 00:53:08,662 2059 00:53:08,662 --> 00:53:13,079 >> it looks like we would have 2060 00:53:13,079 --> 00:53:13,217 2061 00:53:13,217 --> 00:53:14,881 support, total support for 2062 00:53:14,881 --> 00:53:17,979 option two, so I will move tha 2063 00:53:17,979 --> 00:53:18,243 t 2064 00:53:18,243 --> 00:53:21,945 we begin the search process and 2065 00:53:21,945 --> 00:53:22,395 2066 00:53:22,395 --> 00:53:26,052 start that process beginning I 2067 00:53:26,052 --> 00:53:26,381 n 2068 00:53:26,381 --> 00:53:26,381 october. 2069 00:53:26,381 --> 00:53:28,253 hopefully to conclude in 2070 00:53:28,253 --> 00:53:28,253 february. 2071 00:53:28,253 --> 00:53:29,119 >> second. 2072 00:53:29,119 --> 00:53:30,527 >> mayor: we have a motion and 2073 00:53:30,527 --> 00:53:31,057 a 2074 00:53:31,057 --> 00:53:31,057 second. 2075 00:53:31,057 --> 00:53:32,023 all in favor? 2076 00:53:32,023 --> 00:53:33,021 >> aye. 2077 00:53:33,021 --> 00:53:34,431 >> mayor: any opposed? 2078 00:53:34,431 --> 00:53:34,867 that passes unanimously. 2079 00:53:34,867 --> 00:53:38,963 thank you all for the excellent 2080 00:53:38,963 --> 00:53:39,227 2081 00:53:39,227 --> 00:53:42,743 conversation on that. 2082 00:53:42,743 --> 00:53:46,873 and miss gretz you have your 2083 00:53:46,873 --> 00:53:47,231 work ahead of you. 2084 00:53:47,231 --> 00:53:55,578 >> we're on to 2026-225 public 2085 00:53:55,578 --> 00:53:56,181 2086 00:53:56,181 --> 00:53:58,925 works department update. 2087 00:53:58,925 --> 00:53:59,801 >> mayor: welcome. 2088 00:53:59,801 --> 00:54:02,668 >> good morning mr. Mayor, 2089 00:54:02,668 --> 00:54:02,668 commissioners. 2090 00:54:02,668 --> 00:54:06,077 this is our very first public 2091 00:54:06,077 --> 00:54:06,077 2092 00:54:06,077 --> 00:54:06,698 works departmentwide update. 2093 00:54:06,698 --> 00:54:08,556 and I know there are a lot of 2094 00:54:08,556 --> 00:54:08,556 2095 00:54:08,556 --> 00:54:10,496 slides -- it will be a longer 2096 00:54:10,496 --> 00:54:10,496 2097 00:54:10,496 --> 00:54:11,473 presentation than what we'll d 2098 00:54:11,473 --> 00:54:11,633 o 2099 00:54:11,633 --> 00:54:13,491 in the future, but we'll try to 2100 00:54:13,491 --> 00:54:13,491 2101 00:54:13,491 --> 00:54:14,795 keep it rolling through. 2102 00:54:14,795 --> 00:54:24,341 I want to talk about the 2103 00:54:24,341 --> 00:54:26,735 origination of public works, 2104 00:54:26,735 --> 00:54:29,983 started in 1933, with the new 2105 00:54:29,983 --> 00:54:29,983 2106 00:54:29,983 --> 00:54:31,625 deal and the public works 2107 00:54:31,625 --> 00:54:35,751 administration, and the civil 2108 00:54:35,751 --> 00:54:35,751 2109 00:54:35,751 --> 00:54:36,118 conservation core. 2110 00:54:36,118 --> 00:54:41,125 streets, highways, bridges, 2111 00:54:41,125 --> 00:54:42,238 hospitals, even though the pwa 2112 00:54:42,238 --> 00:54:42,965 2113 00:54:42,965 --> 00:54:44,427 was short lived it shut down in 2114 00:54:44,427 --> 00:54:44,612 2115 00:54:44,612 --> 00:54:46,701 1944, it created a lot of 2116 00:54:46,701 --> 00:54:49,081 infrastructure, including the 2117 00:54:49,081 --> 00:54:49,081 2118 00:54:49,081 --> 00:54:50,811 hoover dam, which I think I hav 2119 00:54:50,811 --> 00:54:50,811 e 2120 00:54:50,811 --> 00:54:51,869 the right pointer. 2121 00:54:51,869 --> 00:54:53,281 >> mayor: I was going to ask you 2122 00:54:53,281 --> 00:54:53,281 2123 00:54:53,281 --> 00:54:53,811 what district that was in. 2124 00:54:53,811 --> 00:54:59,855 >> and the reason why I -- the 2125 00:54:59,855 --> 00:54:59,855 2126 00:54:59,855 --> 00:55:01,949 hoover dam started in 1931, so 2127 00:55:01,949 --> 00:55:02,323 2128 00:55:02,323 --> 00:55:03,448 before the public works 2129 00:55:03,448 --> 00:55:04,987 administration, it was finished 2130 00:55:04,987 --> 00:55:05,285 2131 00:55:05,285 --> 00:55:08,057 with the help of pwa. 2132 00:55:08,057 --> 00:55:17,841 I chose to use that photo, 2133 00:55:17,841 --> 00:55:20,937 because it was named after 2134 00:55:20,937 --> 00:55:21,639 herbert hoover. 2135 00:55:21,639 --> 00:55:24,813 we also have some gainesville 2136 00:55:24,813 --> 00:55:24,813 2137 00:55:24,813 --> 00:55:27,177 area, early public works, and 2138 00:55:27,177 --> 00:55:27,177 2139 00:55:27,177 --> 00:55:32,611 that includes the bullwart 2140 00:55:32,611 --> 00:55:34,346 springs, it started in 1891, a 2141 00:55:34,346 --> 00:55:34,346 nd 2142 00:55:34,346 --> 00:55:36,986 it was part of the city's first 2143 00:55:36,986 --> 00:55:37,589 2144 00:55:37,589 --> 00:55:40,321 municipal water utility, until 2145 00:55:40,321 --> 00:55:40,527 2146 00:55:40,527 --> 00:55:43,027 1913, and then it later 2147 00:55:43,027 --> 00:55:45,263 functioned as an auxiliary wat 2148 00:55:45,263 --> 00:55:45,263 er 2149 00:55:45,263 --> 00:55:45,263 source. 2150 00:55:45,263 --> 00:55:47,909 now it's an historic place. 2151 00:55:47,909 --> 00:55:50,727 I included in a smaller level, 2152 00:55:50,727 --> 00:55:57,891 the apwa acronym, so we 2153 00:55:57,891 --> 00:55:58,499 are -- 2154 00:55:58,499 --> 00:55:58,823 [ inaudible ] 2155 00:55:58,823 --> 00:56:00,509 it was founded originally in 2156 00:56:00,509 --> 00:56:02,809 1937, and we've been a long 2157 00:56:02,809 --> 00:56:04,273 accredited member, what does 2158 00:56:04,273 --> 00:56:05,351 that mean in short terms? 2159 00:56:05,351 --> 00:56:07,442 it means we follow a certain 2160 00:56:07,442 --> 00:56:08,779 standard of policies and 2161 00:56:08,779 --> 00:56:11,316 procedures, and we implement a 2162 00:56:11,316 --> 00:56:11,378 2163 00:56:11,378 --> 00:56:13,184 best management, standard 2164 00:56:13,184 --> 00:56:16,092 practice of work that meets the 2165 00:56:16,092 --> 00:56:16,659 2166 00:56:16,659 --> 00:56:18,763 pwa standards. 2167 00:56:18,763 --> 00:56:22,435 we go through an accreditation 2168 00:56:22,435 --> 00:56:22,921 2169 00:56:22,921 --> 00:56:23,667 process for years. 2170 00:56:23,667 --> 00:56:28,433 we're one of 172 agencies in 2171 00:56:28,433 --> 00:56:29,666 north america and canada that 2172 00:56:29,666 --> 00:56:29,666 2173 00:56:29,666 --> 00:56:30,438 are credited. 2174 00:56:30,438 --> 00:56:32,848 and 27 in florida. 2175 00:56:32,848 --> 00:56:34,577 we're currently going through 2176 00:56:34,577 --> 00:56:34,577 2177 00:56:34,577 --> 00:56:38,242 the reaccreditation process no 2178 00:56:38,242 --> 00:56:38,242 w. 2179 00:56:38,242 --> 00:56:41,614 just real quick on our public 2180 00:56:41,614 --> 00:56:41,614 2181 00:56:41,614 --> 00:56:43,619 works mission, it's to basically 2182 00:56:43,619 --> 00:56:43,619 2183 00:56:43,619 --> 00:56:46,786 enhance the quality life for 2184 00:56:46,786 --> 00:56:48,295 gainesville community by 2185 00:56:48,295 --> 00:56:52,080 maintaining and managing our 2186 00:56:52,080 --> 00:56:54,767 infrastructure and solid waste 2187 00:56:54,767 --> 00:56:55,293 2188 00:56:55,293 --> 00:56:55,293 services. 2189 00:56:55,293 --> 00:56:58,028 we do have a lot of assets tha 2190 00:56:58,028 --> 00:56:58,302 t 2191 00:56:58,302 --> 00:57:02,108 we manage, that includes 401 2192 00:57:02,108 --> 00:57:04,868 center line miles of road. 2193 00:57:04,868 --> 00:57:08,181 sidewalks, 205 miles, we hav 2194 00:57:08,181 --> 00:57:09,934 some significant assets out 2195 00:57:09,934 --> 00:57:09,934 there. 2196 00:57:09,934 --> 00:57:13,812 traffic infrastructure, we hav 2197 00:57:13,812 --> 00:57:14,177 e 2198 00:57:14,177 --> 00:57:16,586 251 interconnected traffic 2199 00:57:16,586 --> 00:57:18,348 signals, we maintain the entire 2200 00:57:18,348 --> 00:57:18,655 2201 00:57:18,655 --> 00:57:19,722 traffic signals for the county 2202 00:57:19,722 --> 00:57:19,956 , 2203 00:57:19,956 --> 00:57:22,186 that includes ourselves, dot, 2204 00:57:22,186 --> 00:57:22,186 2205 00:57:22,186 --> 00:57:23,989 alachua county, and what we cal 2206 00:57:23,989 --> 00:57:23,989 l 2207 00:57:23,989 --> 00:57:24,963 the seven cities. 2208 00:57:24,963 --> 00:57:27,526 if I can remember them all, 2209 00:57:27,526 --> 00:57:30,270 archer, alatch way, high 2210 00:57:30,270 --> 00:57:33,351 springs, micanopy, waldo, and I 2211 00:57:33,351 --> 00:57:33,391 2212 00:57:33,391 --> 00:57:34,236 think I hit them all, newberry. 2213 00:57:34,236 --> 00:57:34,236 2214 00:57:34,236 --> 00:57:43,211 and that's a large revenue 2215 00:57:43,211 --> 00:57:43,744 source for us too. 2216 00:57:43,744 --> 00:57:45,676 over a million dollars, I think 2217 00:57:45,676 --> 00:57:45,917 2218 00:57:45,917 --> 00:57:49,547 it's over 1.3 or $4 million tha 2219 00:57:49,547 --> 00:57:49,547 t 2220 00:57:49,547 --> 00:57:53,525 we get from seven cities, from 2221 00:57:53,525 --> 00:57:53,734 2222 00:57:53,734 --> 00:57:55,260 the dot in alachua county. 2223 00:57:55,260 --> 00:57:57,983 we are a city of creeks, some 2224 00:57:57,983 --> 00:57:57,983 of 2225 00:57:57,983 --> 00:58:00,572 our major creeks being hog tow 2226 00:58:00,572 --> 00:58:01,124 n 2227 00:58:01,124 --> 00:58:02,571 possum creek, sweetwater branch 2228 00:58:02,571 --> 00:58:02,571 , 2229 00:58:02,571 --> 00:58:05,794 and we have other little creek 2230 00:58:05,794 --> 00:58:06,012 s 2231 00:58:06,012 --> 00:58:07,728 that are tributaries to the 2232 00:58:07,728 --> 00:58:08,162 larger creeks. 2233 00:58:08,162 --> 00:58:10,533 so a lot of water quality 2234 00:58:10,533 --> 00:58:12,712 concerns and issues, a lot of 2235 00:58:12,712 --> 00:58:12,712 2236 00:58:12,712 --> 00:58:16,172 water quality and flood plain 2237 00:58:16,172 --> 00:58:16,172 2238 00:58:16,172 --> 00:58:17,519 type concerns and issues. 2239 00:58:17,519 --> 00:58:19,780 we manage all of this on a $57 2240 00:58:19,780 --> 00:58:19,915 2241 00:58:19,915 --> 00:58:21,520 million budget, and this is kin 2242 00:58:21,520 --> 00:58:21,520 d 2243 00:58:21,520 --> 00:58:24,984 of a breakdown of the budget, 2244 00:58:24,984 --> 00:58:24,984 2245 00:58:24,984 --> 00:58:27,551 solid waste being our largest 2246 00:58:27,551 --> 00:58:27,551 2247 00:58:27,551 --> 00:58:27,551 component. 2248 00:58:27,551 --> 00:58:30,006 but then general fund, storm 2249 00:58:30,006 --> 00:58:35,160 water fund and we go down from 2250 00:58:35,160 --> 00:58:35,503 2251 00:58:35,503 --> 00:58:35,503 there. 2252 00:58:35,503 --> 00:58:39,355 public works does come in lots 2253 00:58:39,355 --> 00:58:39,599 2254 00:58:39,599 --> 00:58:41,669 of sizes, right? 2255 00:58:41,669 --> 00:58:44,004 some public works might only 2256 00:58:44,004 --> 00:58:44,905 have an operation section. 2257 00:58:44,905 --> 00:58:46,775 some might have an engineering 2258 00:58:46,775 --> 00:58:47,145 2259 00:58:47,145 --> 00:58:49,606 section, some might have 2260 00:58:49,606 --> 00:58:50,674 utilities, we are five 2261 00:58:50,674 --> 00:58:53,416 divisions, we have our 2262 00:58:53,416 --> 00:58:54,748 operations team led by mr. Jar 2263 00:58:54,748 --> 00:58:54,748 ed 2264 00:58:54,748 --> 00:58:56,787 lloyd, we have our engineering 2265 00:58:56,787 --> 00:58:57,112 2266 00:58:57,112 --> 00:58:59,383 team led by dr. Chase knight, w 2267 00:58:59,383 --> 00:58:59,383 e 2268 00:58:59,383 --> 00:59:03,591 have facilities management, led 2269 00:59:03,591 --> 00:59:03,853 2270 00:59:03,853 --> 00:59:04,931 by mr. Derry kaufmann. 2271 00:59:04,931 --> 00:59:09,699 our administrative team is led 2272 00:59:09,699 --> 00:59:09,788 2273 00:59:09,788 --> 00:59:13,713 by miss anissa booth who was 2274 00:59:13,713 --> 00:59:14,911 unable to be here today. 2275 00:59:14,911 --> 00:59:18,580 and our technology team is led 2276 00:59:18,580 --> 00:59:18,704 2277 00:59:18,704 --> 00:59:19,300 by steve rossi. 2278 00:59:19,300 --> 00:59:21,302 I wanted to include slides on 2279 00:59:21,302 --> 00:59:21,302 2280 00:59:21,302 --> 00:59:21,812 overall performance for us. 2281 00:59:21,812 --> 00:59:29,946 we have -- these are some raw 2282 00:59:29,946 --> 00:59:29,946 2283 00:59:29,946 --> 00:59:32,314 overall scores -- raw overall 2284 00:59:32,314 --> 00:59:32,314 2285 00:59:32,314 --> 00:59:35,317 numbers for the entire 2286 00:59:35,317 --> 00:59:35,968 department that represent 2287 00:59:35,968 --> 00:59:37,419 service requests that come in, 2288 00:59:37,419 --> 00:59:37,886 2289 00:59:37,886 --> 00:59:41,392 service requests that are close 2290 00:59:41,392 --> 00:59:41,392 d 2291 00:59:41,392 --> 00:59:43,510 and work order centers that ar 2292 00:59:43,510 --> 00:59:43,911 e 2293 00:59:43,911 --> 00:59:45,279 open, work orders that are 2294 00:59:45,279 --> 00:59:45,279 closed. 2295 00:59:45,279 --> 00:59:47,268 one of the things that I want t 2296 00:59:47,268 --> 00:59:47,268 o 2297 00:59:47,268 --> 00:59:49,363 make sure I note, the reason why 2298 00:59:49,363 --> 00:59:49,363 2299 00:59:49,363 --> 00:59:50,450 the service request here in th 2300 00:59:50,450 --> 00:59:51,666 e 2301 00:59:51,666 --> 00:59:54,241 blue and the orange seem low I 2302 00:59:54,241 --> 00:59:54,471 s 2303 00:59:54,471 --> 00:59:55,875 because there was a period of 2304 00:59:55,875 --> 00:59:55,875 2305 00:59:55,875 --> 00:59:57,745 time where solid waste was onl 2306 00:59:57,745 --> 00:59:57,915 y 2307 00:59:57,915 --> 01:00:02,249 going into gru's utility 2308 01:00:02,249 --> 01:00:03,751 software, then they changed int 2309 01:00:03,751 --> 01:00:03,751 o 2310 01:00:03,751 --> 01:00:04,697 a different platform. 2311 01:00:04,697 --> 01:00:06,121 we don't have those numbers 2312 01:00:06,121 --> 01:00:06,962 available to us right now. 2313 01:00:06,962 --> 01:00:10,993 you'll see that we have a sudde 2314 01:00:10,993 --> 01:00:10,993 n 2315 01:00:10,993 --> 01:00:12,690 increase in the service reques 2316 01:00:12,690 --> 01:00:12,690 t, 2317 01:00:12,690 --> 01:00:15,064 but that just reflects what 2318 01:00:15,064 --> 01:00:16,835 we're doing in city works, whi 2319 01:00:16,835 --> 01:00:16,835 ch 2320 01:00:16,835 --> 01:00:18,361 is where we track everything. 2321 01:00:18,361 --> 01:00:24,935 and the overall trend for us, 2322 01:00:24,935 --> 01:00:24,935 2323 01:00:24,935 --> 01:00:27,277 for service request is up, we 2324 01:00:27,277 --> 01:00:27,277 2325 01:00:27,277 --> 01:00:29,848 basically averaged in fiscal 2326 01:00:29,848 --> 01:00:32,459 '24, an average of 53 service 2327 01:00:32,459 --> 01:00:32,459 2328 01:00:32,459 --> 01:00:33,987 requests a day, we're currently 2329 01:00:33,987 --> 01:00:34,243 2330 01:00:34,243 --> 01:00:35,449 up to 76 a day. 2331 01:00:35,449 --> 01:00:37,955 those are basically every singl 2332 01:00:37,955 --> 01:00:37,955 e 2333 01:00:37,955 --> 01:00:40,289 day we get approximately that 2334 01:00:40,289 --> 01:00:40,289 2335 01:00:40,289 --> 01:00:41,419 many service request calls. 2336 01:00:41,419 --> 01:00:43,597 that's basically called -- it 2337 01:00:43,597 --> 01:00:43,597 2338 01:00:43,597 --> 01:00:45,209 doesn't mean we do any work 2339 01:00:45,209 --> 01:00:46,541 associated with it, that's 2340 01:00:46,541 --> 01:00:47,894 different than the work orders 2341 01:00:47,894 --> 01:00:48,128 2342 01:00:48,128 --> 01:00:49,505 which is the green and lighter 2343 01:00:49,505 --> 01:00:49,505 2344 01:00:49,505 --> 01:00:50,196 blue on the top. 2345 01:00:50,196 --> 01:00:51,896 in general, with those, those 2346 01:00:51,896 --> 01:00:51,896 2347 01:00:51,896 --> 01:00:53,639 are accurate for all of the 2348 01:00:53,639 --> 01:00:57,107 departments, all the groups, 2349 01:00:57,107 --> 01:00:59,607 from fiscal '21, we started wit 2350 01:00:59,607 --> 01:00:59,607 h 2351 01:00:59,607 --> 01:01:02,846 42.6 work orders a day, and now 2352 01:01:02,846 --> 01:01:03,147 2353 01:01:03,147 --> 01:01:05,147 we're at 51, we've gotten as 2354 01:01:05,147 --> 01:01:08,045 high as 58 per day. 2355 01:01:08,045 --> 01:01:11,918 so a lot of work going through 2356 01:01:11,918 --> 01:01:12,321 2357 01:01:12,321 --> 01:01:12,625 the department. 2358 01:01:12,625 --> 01:01:14,695 these ended up a little smaller 2359 01:01:14,695 --> 01:01:14,695 2360 01:01:14,695 --> 01:01:16,659 than I anticipated, but I wante 2361 01:01:16,659 --> 01:01:16,659 d 2362 01:01:16,659 --> 01:01:18,762 to kind of also reflect the 2363 01:01:18,762 --> 01:01:19,898 total cost of the work orders. 2364 01:01:19,898 --> 01:01:19,898 2365 01:01:19,898 --> 01:01:22,634 you'll see we have a steady 2366 01:01:22,634 --> 01:01:24,231 trend up, that's something to d 2367 01:01:24,231 --> 01:01:24,231 o 2368 01:01:24,231 --> 01:01:26,175 with -- we also have increasing 2369 01:01:26,175 --> 01:01:26,426 2370 01:01:26,426 --> 01:01:28,411 number of work orders, it also 2371 01:01:28,411 --> 01:01:28,537 2372 01:01:28,537 --> 01:01:30,074 has to do with the cost of 2373 01:01:30,074 --> 01:01:32,143 things going up, asphalt, 2374 01:01:32,143 --> 01:01:33,769 concrete, supplies, thing wez 2375 01:01:33,769 --> 01:01:33,769 2376 01:01:33,769 --> 01:01:34,720 need to do the actual work. 2377 01:01:34,720 --> 01:01:42,026 and then the last slide really 2378 01:01:42,026 --> 01:01:42,026 2379 01:01:42,026 --> 01:01:43,713 just speaks to more of the 2380 01:01:43,713 --> 01:01:44,857 service request and work order 2381 01:01:44,857 --> 01:01:45,218 s 2382 01:01:45,218 --> 01:01:46,921 and where we are in terms of 2383 01:01:46,921 --> 01:01:48,761 efficiency, what I call 2384 01:01:48,761 --> 01:01:50,131 efficiency, how many are we 2385 01:01:50,131 --> 01:01:53,759 closing through the fiscal year 2386 01:01:53,759 --> 01:01:53,759 . 2387 01:01:53,759 --> 01:01:56,471 so we're going from -- the blu 2388 01:01:56,471 --> 01:01:56,661 e 2389 01:01:56,661 --> 01:01:58,230 line is service requests, and 2390 01:01:58,230 --> 01:01:58,230 2391 01:01:58,230 --> 01:01:59,269 how many we're closing, but you 2392 01:01:59,269 --> 01:01:59,407 2393 01:01:59,407 --> 01:02:01,493 can see, if you remember, the 2394 01:02:01,493 --> 01:02:01,493 2395 01:02:01,493 --> 01:02:02,749 numbers were going up a lot for 2396 01:02:02,749 --> 01:02:02,868 2397 01:02:02,868 --> 01:02:04,671 service requests, we were 2398 01:02:04,671 --> 01:02:05,771 averaging 76 per day right now, 2399 01:02:05,771 --> 01:02:06,210 2400 01:02:06,210 --> 01:02:08,180 you can see our efficiency is 2401 01:02:08,180 --> 01:02:08,180 2402 01:02:08,180 --> 01:02:09,441 kind of decreased a little bit. 2403 01:02:09,441 --> 01:02:09,441 2404 01:02:09,441 --> 01:02:11,539 because our staff is the same 2405 01:02:11,539 --> 01:02:11,539 2406 01:02:11,539 --> 01:02:12,842 number, so it's harder to get to ever 2407 01:02:12,842 --> 01:02:12,842 everybody. 2408 01:02:12,842 --> 01:02:13,387 as quickly. 2409 01:02:13,387 --> 01:02:26,291 as we go through, as the 2410 01:02:26,291 --> 01:02:27,249 division manager goes through, 2411 01:02:27,249 --> 01:02:27,762 2412 01:02:27,762 --> 01:02:28,667 there are individual groups and 2413 01:02:28,667 --> 01:02:29,160 2414 01:02:29,160 --> 01:02:31,667 teams and what they're doing, 2415 01:02:31,667 --> 01:02:31,667 2416 01:02:31,667 --> 01:02:32,667 they'll be touching on the 2417 01:02:32,667 --> 01:02:34,067 strategic goals as we go along 2418 01:02:34,067 --> 01:02:34,445 2419 01:02:34,445 --> 01:02:34,764 through there. 2420 01:02:34,764 --> 01:02:37,543 and I'm going to turn it over, 2421 01:02:37,543 --> 01:02:38,013 2422 01:02:38,013 --> 01:02:41,064 first to garrett kaufmann our 2423 01:02:41,064 --> 01:02:41,064 2424 01:02:41,064 --> 01:02:41,345 facilities manager. 2425 01:02:41,345 --> 01:02:46,059 >> mayor: welcome. 2426 01:02:46,059 --> 01:02:47,343 >> good morning. 2427 01:02:47,343 --> 01:02:50,851 I'm gary kaufmann, the 2428 01:02:50,851 --> 01:02:52,616 facilities manager, and 2429 01:02:52,616 --> 01:02:53,743 facilities division of public 2430 01:02:53,743 --> 01:02:53,743 2431 01:02:53,743 --> 01:02:55,331 works, I'm here to give you a 2432 01:02:55,331 --> 01:02:55,331 2433 01:02:55,331 --> 01:02:56,617 brief overview of what we're 2434 01:02:56,617 --> 01:02:57,971 doing in the facilities 2435 01:02:57,971 --> 01:02:57,971 division. 2436 01:02:57,971 --> 01:03:01,897 first of all, I want to give y 2437 01:03:01,897 --> 01:03:01,897 ou 2438 01:03:01,897 --> 01:03:04,396 guys a rundown of what our 2439 01:03:04,396 --> 01:03:06,334 department looks like, we have 2440 01:03:06,334 --> 01:03:06,670 2441 01:03:06,670 --> 01:03:08,711 24 1/2 fte in our department, 2442 01:03:08,711 --> 01:03:08,711 2443 01:03:08,711 --> 01:03:09,036 including myself. 2444 01:03:09,036 --> 01:03:11,809 I am the manager, we have an 2445 01:03:11,809 --> 01:03:13,171 assistant manager, we have two 2446 01:03:13,171 --> 01:03:14,075 2447 01:03:14,075 --> 01:03:16,612 supervisors, we have seven 2448 01:03:16,612 --> 01:03:18,587 mechanical staff covers, 2449 01:03:18,587 --> 01:03:19,377 mechanical electrical plumbing, 2450 01:03:19,377 --> 01:03:20,065 2451 01:03:20,065 --> 01:03:26,721 which is hvac and firearms, we 2452 01:03:26,721 --> 01:03:26,853 2453 01:03:26,853 --> 01:03:28,155 have three structural personnel. 2454 01:03:28,155 --> 01:03:28,155 2455 01:03:28,155 --> 01:03:30,915 it's a very lean subdivision o 2456 01:03:30,915 --> 01:03:31,031 f 2457 01:03:31,031 --> 01:03:31,352 our department. 2458 01:03:31,352 --> 01:03:34,035 we have two carpenters and one 2459 01:03:34,035 --> 01:03:34,697 2460 01:03:34,697 --> 01:03:34,697 painter. 2461 01:03:34,697 --> 01:03:37,397 we have nine custodial staff I 2462 01:03:37,397 --> 01:03:37,525 n 2463 01:03:37,525 --> 01:03:39,432 our department, and one capital 2464 01:03:39,432 --> 01:03:39,794 2465 01:03:39,794 --> 01:03:42,069 projects manager, and then the 2466 01:03:42,069 --> 01:03:42,383 2467 01:03:42,383 --> 01:03:44,333 second part time -- temporary 2468 01:03:44,333 --> 01:03:44,333 2469 01:03:44,333 --> 01:03:44,907 part time capital projects 2470 01:03:44,907 --> 01:03:44,907 manager. 2471 01:03:44,907 --> 01:03:55,051 our department is broken down 2472 01:03:55,051 --> 01:03:55,051 2473 01:03:55,051 --> 01:03:56,390 into several different 2474 01:03:56,390 --> 01:03:58,287 categories, operations and 2475 01:03:58,287 --> 01:04:00,889 maintenance, which basically 2476 01:04:00,889 --> 01:04:02,495 covers a wide variety of 2477 01:04:02,495 --> 01:04:06,257 maintenance on roofs and walls, 2478 01:04:06,257 --> 01:04:07,089 2479 01:04:07,089 --> 01:04:10,195 operations, that's for 2480 01:04:10,195 --> 01:04:14,099 structural, and we do 2481 01:04:14,099 --> 01:04:15,061 mechanical, we do a lot with 2482 01:04:15,061 --> 01:04:15,061 firearms. 2483 01:04:15,061 --> 01:04:18,371 operations and maintenance and 2484 01:04:18,371 --> 01:04:18,982 2485 01:04:18,982 --> 01:04:20,849 custodial, we do custodial wor 2486 01:04:20,849 --> 01:04:21,037 k 2487 01:04:21,037 --> 01:04:22,243 for a few of the buildings in 2488 01:04:22,243 --> 01:04:22,243 2489 01:04:22,243 --> 01:04:24,473 the city's portfolio, we do not 2490 01:04:24,473 --> 01:04:24,639 2491 01:04:24,639 --> 01:04:26,079 take all of them, we take care 2492 01:04:26,079 --> 01:04:26,309 2493 01:04:26,309 --> 01:04:28,351 of all the major ones, I think 2494 01:04:28,351 --> 01:04:29,616 I 2495 01:04:29,616 --> 01:04:33,257 shared this with you guys 2496 01:04:33,257 --> 01:04:33,257 previously. 2497 01:04:33,257 --> 01:04:35,583 the police department, the fir 2498 01:04:35,583 --> 01:04:35,672 e 2499 01:04:35,672 --> 01:04:37,395 department, parks takes care o 2500 01:04:37,395 --> 01:04:37,789 f 2501 01:04:37,789 --> 01:04:40,527 most of themselves. 2502 01:04:40,527 --> 01:04:43,201 operations and maintenance 2503 01:04:43,201 --> 01:04:44,631 administration, we take care, 2504 01:04:44,631 --> 01:04:44,631 2505 01:04:44,631 --> 01:04:47,935 make sure that we watch after 2506 01:04:47,935 --> 01:04:47,935 2507 01:04:47,935 --> 01:04:50,239 our budget and prepare for 2508 01:04:50,239 --> 01:04:52,507 purchase orders, do a lot of 2509 01:04:52,507 --> 01:04:53,473 administrative work that way. 2510 01:04:53,473 --> 01:04:56,681 capital preservation, do a lot 2511 01:04:56,681 --> 01:04:56,817 2512 01:04:56,817 --> 01:04:58,347 of small projects for 2513 01:04:58,347 --> 01:05:00,483 replacement of structural 2514 01:05:00,483 --> 01:05:00,483 components. 2515 01:05:00,483 --> 01:05:03,549 replacing doors, rollout doors, 2516 01:05:03,549 --> 01:05:04,413 2517 01:05:04,413 --> 01:05:04,625 fire departments. 2518 01:05:04,625 --> 01:05:07,987 hvac systems, we go a lot of 2519 01:05:07,987 --> 01:05:09,591 replacements, fire alarms, fir 2520 01:05:09,591 --> 01:05:09,921 e 2521 01:05:09,921 --> 01:05:11,393 alarm panels, different things 2522 01:05:11,393 --> 01:05:11,634 2523 01:05:11,634 --> 01:05:11,957 like that. 2524 01:05:11,957 --> 01:05:15,223 I'll say we do facilities 2525 01:05:15,223 --> 01:05:15,741 restoration and expansion. 2526 01:05:15,741 --> 01:05:19,171 we do some remodeling work. 2527 01:05:19,171 --> 01:05:21,559 we did the lobby out here with 2528 01:05:21,559 --> 01:05:21,559 2529 01:05:21,559 --> 01:05:23,305 the security improvements, stu 2530 01:05:23,305 --> 01:05:23,305 ff 2531 01:05:23,305 --> 01:05:24,440 like that. 2532 01:05:24,440 --> 01:05:27,265 we do large projects, involve in 2533 01:05:27,265 --> 01:05:27,265 2534 01:05:27,265 --> 01:05:30,312 the new construction of fire 2535 01:05:30,312 --> 01:05:32,145 station number three, number 9 2536 01:05:32,145 --> 01:05:32,375 2537 01:05:32,375 --> 01:05:34,053 and the eoc, all the projects 2538 01:05:34,053 --> 01:05:34,053 2539 01:05:34,053 --> 01:05:35,287 that falls on our department t 2540 01:05:35,287 --> 01:05:35,330 o 2541 01:05:35,330 --> 01:05:35,853 take care of those things. 2542 01:05:35,853 --> 01:05:46,659 >> as far as our portfolio of 2543 01:05:46,659 --> 01:05:46,659 2544 01:05:46,659 --> 01:05:48,597 buildings, we eliminated some 2545 01:05:48,597 --> 01:05:48,597 2546 01:05:48,597 --> 01:05:50,593 buildings, touch on that you I 2547 01:05:50,593 --> 01:05:50,639 n 2548 01:05:50,639 --> 01:05:51,099 a minute. 2549 01:05:51,099 --> 01:06:04,213 we have greater than 135 2550 01:06:04,213 --> 01:06:05,713 buildings, we have over 200,00 2551 01:06:05,713 --> 01:06:06,343 0 2552 01:06:06,343 --> 01:06:07,475 square feet of buildings that 2553 01:06:07,475 --> 01:06:07,475 2554 01:06:07,475 --> 01:06:09,885 are older than 50 years old, w 2555 01:06:09,885 --> 01:06:10,010 e 2556 01:06:10,010 --> 01:06:12,121 have a lot of very old 2557 01:06:12,121 --> 01:06:13,821 buildings, and a lot of old 2558 01:06:13,821 --> 01:06:13,821 equipment. 2559 01:06:13,821 --> 01:06:16,735 so our staff stays quite busy 2560 01:06:16,735 --> 01:06:16,735 2561 01:06:16,735 --> 01:06:18,323 trying to keep up with it. 2562 01:06:18,323 --> 01:06:30,537 this is the list of buildings. 2563 01:06:30,537 --> 01:06:30,537 2564 01:06:30,537 --> 01:06:33,681 we reduced it last year, we hav 2565 01:06:33,681 --> 01:06:33,681 e 2566 01:06:33,681 --> 01:06:36,713 taken away the boltin building 2567 01:06:36,713 --> 01:06:36,973 2568 01:06:36,973 --> 01:06:41,949 in the northeast complex. 2569 01:06:41,949 --> 01:06:43,981 that should help our department 2570 01:06:43,981 --> 01:06:43,981 2571 01:06:43,981 --> 01:06:45,625 get a little more efficient. 2572 01:06:45,625 --> 01:06:48,457 we have quite a bit to do with 2573 01:06:48,457 --> 01:06:48,583 2574 01:06:48,583 --> 01:06:51,231 these buildings, keeping up wi 2575 01:06:51,231 --> 01:06:51,231 th 2576 01:06:51,231 --> 01:06:51,735 the maintenance on them. 2577 01:06:51,735 --> 01:06:55,647 facilities capital projects, o 2578 01:06:55,647 --> 01:06:56,093 n 2579 01:06:56,093 --> 01:06:58,323 the left we have 21 projects 2580 01:06:58,323 --> 01:07:00,131 that our staff is currently 2581 01:07:00,131 --> 01:07:02,543 working on, and I'll break tho 2582 01:07:02,543 --> 01:07:02,543 se 2583 01:07:02,543 --> 01:07:04,131 down a little more in a minute 2584 01:07:04,131 --> 01:07:04,131 . 2585 01:07:04,131 --> 01:07:06,471 those are small projects, but 2586 01:07:06,471 --> 01:07:06,471 2587 01:07:06,471 --> 01:07:07,707 are very important, they inclu 2588 01:07:07,707 --> 01:07:07,707 de 2589 01:07:07,707 --> 01:07:10,673 things like hvac systems, fire 2590 01:07:10,673 --> 01:07:10,977 2591 01:07:10,977 --> 01:07:12,475 alarm replacements. 2592 01:07:12,475 --> 01:07:15,509 this building specifically is 2593 01:07:15,509 --> 01:07:15,509 2594 01:07:15,509 --> 01:07:16,805 getting two new chillers. 2595 01:07:16,805 --> 01:07:18,425 we're also working in the next 2596 01:07:18,425 --> 01:07:18,615 2597 01:07:18,615 --> 01:07:20,453 couple weeks to start replacing 2598 01:07:20,453 --> 01:07:20,691 2599 01:07:20,691 --> 01:07:22,325 the fire alarm, so we're reall 2600 01:07:22,325 --> 01:07:22,718 y 2601 01:07:22,718 --> 01:07:23,129 excited about that. 2602 01:07:23,129 --> 01:07:25,825 >> that will be fun. 2603 01:07:25,825 --> 01:07:28,321 >> let's hope not, let's hope 2604 01:07:28,321 --> 01:07:28,321 we 2605 01:07:28,321 --> 01:07:29,659 can keep that uneventful. 2606 01:07:29,659 --> 01:07:32,478 >> on the right, we have the 2607 01:07:32,478 --> 01:07:34,267 large projects shown again, the 2608 01:07:34,267 --> 01:07:34,563 2609 01:07:34,563 --> 01:07:38,399 gpd property and evidence 2610 01:07:38,399 --> 01:07:40,277 building, public works, 2611 01:07:40,277 --> 01:07:43,847 safety -- southwest safety 2612 01:07:43,847 --> 01:07:45,815 annex, and hurricane hardening 2613 01:07:45,815 --> 01:07:46,477 2614 01:07:46,477 --> 01:07:48,049 for the hurricane works comple 2615 01:07:48,049 --> 01:07:48,049 x. 2616 01:07:48,049 --> 01:07:50,455 of the capital preservation 2617 01:07:50,455 --> 01:07:51,479 projects that were on the bigge 2618 01:07:51,479 --> 01:07:51,479 r 2619 01:07:51,479 --> 01:07:52,657 list on the page prior. 2620 01:07:52,657 --> 01:07:54,719 six of those currently are 2621 01:07:54,719 --> 01:07:54,719 completed. 2622 01:07:54,719 --> 01:07:58,155 300 in construction, we have 1 2623 01:07:58,155 --> 01:07:58,323 0 2624 01:07:58,323 --> 01:08:00,023 with equipment, including the 2625 01:08:00,023 --> 01:08:00,023 2626 01:08:00,023 --> 01:08:01,843 chillers, we're hoping to get 2627 01:08:01,843 --> 01:08:01,843 2628 01:08:01,843 --> 01:08:03,127 those shipped to us late april, 2629 01:08:03,127 --> 01:08:03,489 2630 01:08:03,489 --> 01:08:05,077 so we should be starting work o 2631 01:08:05,077 --> 01:08:05,077 n 2632 01:08:05,077 --> 01:08:07,541 that, hopefully may, june, we' 2633 01:08:07,541 --> 01:08:07,541 ll 2634 01:08:07,541 --> 01:08:08,275 have those completed. 2635 01:08:08,275 --> 01:08:10,744 once we get the equipment in, 2636 01:08:10,744 --> 01:08:10,744 2637 01:08:10,744 --> 01:08:11,357 that stuff should move really 2638 01:08:11,357 --> 01:08:11,357 2639 01:08:11,357 --> 01:08:11,357 fast. 2640 01:08:11,357 --> 01:08:14,845 we were finalizing, the time w 2641 01:08:14,845 --> 01:08:15,137 e 2642 01:08:15,137 --> 01:08:17,807 create the slide, we were 2643 01:08:17,807 --> 01:08:19,193 finalizing procurement on the 2644 01:08:19,193 --> 01:08:19,193 2645 01:08:19,193 --> 01:08:19,193 project. 2646 01:08:19,193 --> 01:08:21,047 one of them is a phased project 2647 01:08:21,047 --> 01:08:21,279 2648 01:08:21,279 --> 01:08:22,315 where we're doing some further 2649 01:08:22,315 --> 01:08:22,497 2650 01:08:22,497 --> 01:08:25,527 stud byes, we're waiting on 2651 01:08:25,527 --> 01:08:26,153 finalizing the report on that, 2652 01:08:26,153 --> 01:08:26,553 2653 01:08:26,553 --> 01:08:27,389 so we can continue on with that 2654 01:08:27,389 --> 01:08:27,389 2655 01:08:27,389 --> 01:08:27,389 process. 2656 01:08:27,389 --> 01:08:31,287 not included in that last slid 2657 01:08:31,287 --> 01:08:31,287 e, 2658 01:08:31,287 --> 01:08:33,591 we're also working on four 2659 01:08:33,591 --> 01:08:34,965 different roof projects, one o 2660 01:08:34,965 --> 01:08:35,095 f 2661 01:08:35,095 --> 01:08:36,665 them is completed, one of them 2662 01:08:36,665 --> 01:08:37,363 2663 01:08:37,363 --> 01:08:40,899 is completed today. 2664 01:08:40,899 --> 01:08:44,201 we were doing the flat roof 2665 01:08:44,201 --> 01:08:44,697 portion of that. 2666 01:08:44,697 --> 01:08:46,867 this week we're supposed to 2667 01:08:46,867 --> 01:08:48,809 start the td mcpherson roof. 2668 01:08:48,809 --> 01:08:51,519 we're waiting for the insulatio 2669 01:08:51,519 --> 01:08:51,519 n 2670 01:08:51,519 --> 01:08:54,189 to come n that's being torn off 2671 01:08:54,189 --> 01:08:54,415 2672 01:08:54,415 --> 01:08:57,651 and getting ready to get 2673 01:08:57,651 --> 01:08:57,651 started. 2674 01:08:57,651 --> 01:08:57,651 . 2675 01:08:57,651 --> 01:09:01,009 that was not on the list, but I 2676 01:09:01,009 --> 01:09:01,053 2677 01:09:01,053 --> 01:09:02,855 just want to point that out, w 2678 01:09:02,855 --> 01:09:02,899 e 2679 01:09:02,899 --> 01:09:03,403 have quite a bit going on. 2680 01:09:03,403 --> 01:09:09,695 street stations -- 2681 01:09:09,695 --> 01:09:10,791 >> mayor: commissioner chestnut 2682 01:09:10,791 --> 01:09:10,791 ? 2683 01:09:10,791 --> 01:09:11,365 >> yes. 2684 01:09:11,365 --> 01:09:14,261 in replacing the roof, are we 2685 01:09:14,261 --> 01:09:14,261 2686 01:09:14,261 --> 01:09:15,863 using our own team or are you 2687 01:09:15,863 --> 01:09:15,863 2688 01:09:15,863 --> 01:09:16,501 contracting that out? 2689 01:09:16,501 --> 01:09:18,441 >> we're contracting it out, 2690 01:09:18,441 --> 01:09:23,553 these are relatively small 2691 01:09:23,553 --> 01:09:25,253 roofs, you probably haven't see 2692 01:09:25,253 --> 01:09:25,253 n 2693 01:09:25,253 --> 01:09:27,723 these, they fall within our 2694 01:09:27,723 --> 01:09:28,015 purchasing guidelines. 2695 01:09:28,015 --> 01:09:32,463 they're small roofs. 2696 01:09:32,463 --> 01:09:35,312 they fall under our agreement t 2697 01:09:35,312 --> 01:09:35,312 o 2698 01:09:35,312 --> 01:09:36,459 make things happen quickly. 2699 01:09:36,459 --> 01:09:38,597 street stations and strong 2700 01:09:38,597 --> 01:09:40,699 foundations, the gpd property 2701 01:09:40,699 --> 01:09:43,723 business building, we should s 2702 01:09:43,723 --> 01:09:43,723 ee 2703 01:09:43,723 --> 01:09:45,593 the walls of the old building 2704 01:09:45,593 --> 01:09:45,593 2705 01:09:45,593 --> 01:09:47,429 start falling down. 2706 01:09:47,429 --> 01:09:49,909 construction should start 2707 01:09:49,909 --> 01:09:51,235 beginning -- it should be in 2708 01:09:51,235 --> 01:09:55,179 may, actually, for the gfr 2709 01:09:55,179 --> 01:09:57,683 administration, the eoc parking 2710 01:09:57,683 --> 01:09:58,487 2711 01:09:58,487 --> 01:10:01,283 lot, the fire station number 9, 2712 01:10:01,283 --> 01:10:01,521 2713 01:10:01,521 --> 01:10:03,619 number 3, we should start site 2714 01:10:03,619 --> 01:10:04,293 2715 01:10:04,293 --> 01:10:05,447 work on that early in may. 2716 01:10:05,447 --> 01:10:08,127 public works hardening, we have 2717 01:10:08,127 --> 01:10:08,349 2718 01:10:08,349 --> 01:10:09,628 design completed, and that 2719 01:10:09,628 --> 01:10:11,326 project is pretty much on hold 2720 01:10:11,326 --> 01:10:11,454 2721 01:10:11,454 --> 01:10:14,192 at the moment, but we are 2722 01:10:14,192 --> 01:10:16,940 anxious to get that one going 2723 01:10:16,940 --> 01:10:16,940 2724 01:10:16,940 --> 01:10:16,940 to. 2725 01:10:16,940 --> 01:10:20,278 kpi's, primarily on kpi's, we 2726 01:10:20,278 --> 01:10:20,278 2727 01:10:20,278 --> 01:10:22,072 are looking at how many work 2728 01:10:22,072 --> 01:10:23,606 orders we received, and how fas 2729 01:10:23,606 --> 01:10:23,606 t 2730 01:10:23,606 --> 01:10:26,103 we can get them done, our 2731 01:10:26,103 --> 01:10:27,334 efficiency in getting them done 2732 01:10:27,334 --> 01:10:27,334 . 2733 01:10:27,334 --> 01:10:30,672 you see in 25, we had almost 2734 01:10:30,672 --> 01:10:30,672 5600. 2735 01:10:30,672 --> 01:10:33,316 and we set a goal for 55 00 thi 2736 01:10:33,316 --> 01:10:33,316 s 2737 01:10:33,316 --> 01:10:35,816 year, for a total number of wor 2738 01:10:35,816 --> 01:10:35,816 k 2739 01:10:35,816 --> 01:10:37,552 orders, right now at the end o 2740 01:10:37,552 --> 01:10:39,324 f 2741 01:10:39,324 --> 01:10:41,395 fiscal year 56 quarter one, 2742 01:10:41,395 --> 01:10:43,191 we're at 11 00, we're on track 2743 01:10:43,191 --> 01:10:43,518 2744 01:10:43,518 --> 01:10:44,947 with what our goals are, and a 2745 01:10:44,947 --> 01:10:45,787 s 2746 01:10:45,787 --> 01:10:48,460 far as the actual numbers 2747 01:10:48,460 --> 01:10:49,564 completed, we're probably just 2748 01:10:49,564 --> 01:10:49,833 a 2749 01:10:49,833 --> 01:10:52,704 little bit behind on that our 2750 01:10:52,704 --> 01:10:52,704 2751 01:10:52,704 --> 01:10:54,264 completion rates, you see on 2752 01:10:54,264 --> 01:10:58,538 this slide are at 89.5% at the 2753 01:10:58,538 --> 01:10:59,039 2754 01:10:59,039 --> 01:11:01,050 end of our first quarter, and 2755 01:11:01,050 --> 01:11:01,050 2756 01:11:01,050 --> 01:11:03,956 our goal was 95% at the end of 2757 01:11:03,956 --> 01:11:03,956 2758 01:11:03,956 --> 01:11:04,210 the year. 2759 01:11:04,210 --> 01:11:06,508 we should be a little better off 2760 01:11:06,508 --> 01:11:06,508 2761 01:11:06,508 --> 01:11:08,196 on that, a lot of the 2762 01:11:08,196 --> 01:11:12,164 incompletion rates have to do 2763 01:11:12,164 --> 01:11:12,164 2764 01:11:12,164 --> 01:11:17,562 with things like that. 2765 01:11:17,562 --> 01:11:20,288 average days of getting work 2766 01:11:20,288 --> 01:11:20,558 orders done. 2767 01:11:20,558 --> 01:11:21,926 this is something we're trying 2768 01:11:21,926 --> 01:11:22,098 2769 01:11:22,098 --> 01:11:23,596 to speed up in getting work 2770 01:11:23,596 --> 01:11:25,342 orders addressed, and get them 2771 01:11:25,342 --> 01:11:25,606 2772 01:11:25,606 --> 01:11:25,606 completedagain. 2773 01:11:25,606 --> 01:11:28,134 this has to do a lot with 2774 01:11:28,134 --> 01:11:29,371 waiting on parts and materials, 2775 01:11:29,371 --> 01:11:29,796 2776 01:11:29,796 --> 01:11:31,708 that kind of thing holds us up. 2777 01:11:31,708 --> 01:11:31,708 2778 01:11:31,708 --> 01:11:37,816 I think we've done a pretty goo 2779 01:11:37,816 --> 01:11:37,816 d 2780 01:11:37,816 --> 01:11:39,514 job of improving this, and you 2781 01:11:39,514 --> 01:11:39,746 2782 01:11:39,746 --> 01:11:41,680 can see that our goal was for 2783 01:11:41,680 --> 01:11:41,680 2784 01:11:41,680 --> 01:11:47,050 ten days and we're at about 18 2785 01:11:47,050 --> 01:11:47,614 2786 01:11:47,614 --> 01:11:48,853 for the first quarter. 2787 01:11:48,853 --> 01:11:51,902 and we're moving in the right 2788 01:11:51,902 --> 01:11:51,902 2789 01:11:51,902 --> 01:11:53,528 direction, we're much better 2790 01:11:53,528 --> 01:11:54,804 than what our actuals were 2791 01:11:54,804 --> 01:11:55,832 showing last year, but we have 2792 01:11:55,832 --> 01:11:55,958 a 2793 01:11:55,958 --> 01:11:58,900 little bit of work to do on 2794 01:11:58,900 --> 01:11:58,900 that. 2795 01:11:58,900 --> 01:12:00,230 that completes everything that 2796 01:12:00,230 --> 01:12:00,397 I 2797 01:12:00,397 --> 01:12:02,002 have to share with you guys, I 2798 01:12:02,002 --> 01:12:02,396 2799 01:12:02,396 --> 01:12:04,146 want to hand this over to jared 2800 01:12:04,146 --> 01:12:04,314 2801 01:12:04,314 --> 01:12:05,940 lloyd, the operations manager 2802 01:12:05,940 --> 01:12:05,940 2803 01:12:05,940 --> 01:12:06,359 for public works. 2804 01:12:06,359 --> 01:12:07,003 >> mayor: thank you. 2805 01:12:07,003 --> 01:12:07,003 welcome. 2806 01:12:07,003 --> 01:12:08,148 >> thank you. 2807 01:12:08,148 --> 01:12:12,242 good morning mr. Mayor, 2808 01:12:12,242 --> 01:12:13,058 commissioners, jared lloyd, 2809 01:12:13,058 --> 01:12:13,339 operations manager. 2810 01:12:13,339 --> 01:12:18,068 with the operations division, 2811 01:12:18,068 --> 01:12:18,068 2812 01:12:18,068 --> 01:12:21,226 there's 7 of us on the 2813 01:12:21,226 --> 01:12:24,540 administrative team that runs 2814 01:12:24,540 --> 01:12:24,540 2815 01:12:24,540 --> 01:12:24,540 operations. 2816 01:12:24,540 --> 01:12:26,259 two of which are currently 2817 01:12:26,259 --> 01:12:27,598 vacant working on fixing that. 2818 01:12:27,598 --> 01:12:27,598 2819 01:12:27,598 --> 01:12:29,498 I would love to have a full tea 2820 01:12:29,498 --> 01:12:29,498 m 2821 01:12:29,498 --> 01:12:34,116 to assist. 2822 01:12:34,116 --> 01:12:35,846 in the operations team, there's 2823 01:12:35,846 --> 01:12:36,238 2824 01:12:36,238 --> 01:12:39,248 129fte's, we're currently 2825 01:12:39,248 --> 01:12:42,208 sitting at roughly 20 1/2% 2826 01:12:42,208 --> 01:12:43,730 vacancy, but in operations, I 2827 01:12:43,730 --> 01:12:43,730 2828 01:12:43,730 --> 01:12:45,446 know I've been up here a lot 2829 01:12:45,446 --> 01:12:48,910 about solid waste, but I also 2830 01:12:48,910 --> 01:12:48,910 2831 01:12:48,910 --> 01:12:50,124 oversee construction, drainage, 2832 01:12:50,124 --> 01:12:50,826 2833 01:12:50,826 --> 01:12:53,286 right-of-way,ing urban forestry 2834 01:12:53,286 --> 01:12:53,286 , 2835 01:12:53,286 --> 01:12:56,022 mosquito control as well as 2836 01:12:56,022 --> 01:12:57,647 solid waste, and a small engine 2837 01:12:57,647 --> 01:12:58,052 2838 01:12:58,052 --> 01:12:58,918 mechanic that we have at our 2839 01:12:58,918 --> 01:12:58,918 warehouse. 2840 01:12:58,918 --> 01:13:04,026 >> mayor: apology there, in 2841 01:13:04,026 --> 01:13:05,710 your -- maybe you'll address 2842 01:13:05,710 --> 01:13:08,536 this going-forward, of that 2843 01:13:08,536 --> 01:13:11,830 20.5%, is there a particular 2844 01:13:11,830 --> 01:13:12,808 department that's heavier with 2845 01:13:12,808 --> 01:13:12,938 2846 01:13:12,938 --> 01:13:13,307 vacancies than others. 2847 01:13:13,307 --> 01:13:17,309 >> no, not necessarily, it's a 2848 01:13:17,309 --> 01:13:17,828 2849 01:13:17,828 --> 01:13:22,625 lot of your workforce, grounds 2850 01:13:22,625 --> 01:13:23,418 2851 01:13:23,418 --> 01:13:25,414 workers, it's a high turnover 2852 01:13:25,414 --> 01:13:25,414 2853 01:13:25,414 --> 01:13:27,028 position, we're constantly 2854 01:13:27,028 --> 01:13:29,150 restocking employees in those 2855 01:13:29,150 --> 01:13:29,150 2856 01:13:29,150 --> 01:13:29,150 positions. 2857 01:13:29,150 --> 01:13:29,920 >> mayor: okay, thank you. 2858 01:13:29,920 --> 01:13:34,974 >> we'll start with our 2859 01:13:34,974 --> 01:13:35,326 construction section. 2860 01:13:35,326 --> 01:13:37,329 my slides are going to be a 2861 01:13:37,329 --> 01:13:38,372 little different than the 2862 01:13:38,372 --> 01:13:39,903 previous ones you've seen, on 2863 01:13:39,903 --> 01:13:39,903 2864 01:13:39,903 --> 01:13:41,930 the left, you're going to see 2865 01:13:41,930 --> 01:13:41,930 2866 01:13:41,930 --> 01:13:43,108 numbers, they're strictly for 2867 01:13:43,108 --> 01:13:43,108 2868 01:13:43,108 --> 01:13:43,862 quarter one of this year. 2869 01:13:43,862 --> 01:13:48,078 and then I'm providing a pictu 2870 01:13:48,078 --> 01:13:48,078 re 2871 01:13:48,078 --> 01:13:51,286 that I feel like best describes 2872 01:13:51,286 --> 01:13:52,080 2873 01:13:52,080 --> 01:13:53,122 the section I'm discussing. 2874 01:13:53,122 --> 01:13:54,957 and then I'm really not going t 2875 01:13:54,957 --> 01:13:54,957 o 2876 01:13:54,957 --> 01:13:56,520 speak to the numbers, I'm going 2877 01:13:56,520 --> 01:13:56,658 2878 01:13:56,658 --> 01:13:58,482 to talk about the sections 2879 01:13:58,482 --> 01:13:58,482 themselves. 2880 01:13:58,482 --> 01:14:00,352 and then this picture, this is 2881 01:14:00,352 --> 01:14:01,254 2882 01:14:01,254 --> 01:14:04,070 really a great representation o 2883 01:14:04,070 --> 01:14:04,070 f 2884 01:14:04,070 --> 01:14:04,493 the construction team. 2885 01:14:04,493 --> 01:14:07,098 you have your sidewalks, you 2886 01:14:07,098 --> 01:14:08,858 have your curb inlets, your 2887 01:14:08,858 --> 01:14:11,062 curbs themselves, your roadways 2888 01:14:11,062 --> 01:14:11,062 , 2889 01:14:11,062 --> 01:14:13,554 your signs, your markings, all 2890 01:14:13,554 --> 01:14:13,769 2891 01:14:13,769 --> 01:14:17,671 of this is done by our 2892 01:14:17,671 --> 01:14:18,136 construction team. 2893 01:14:18,136 --> 01:14:21,012 so asphalt is one of the 2894 01:14:21,012 --> 01:14:22,504 subsections of construction, 2895 01:14:22,504 --> 01:14:23,900 it's a 12 person crew, they ar 2896 01:14:23,900 --> 01:14:23,992 e 2897 01:14:23,992 --> 01:14:26,184 in charge of all the potholes, 2898 01:14:26,184 --> 01:14:26,610 2899 01:14:26,610 --> 01:14:27,718 all of the full reconstruction 2900 01:14:27,718 --> 01:14:28,080 2901 01:14:28,080 --> 01:14:32,580 of roadways, that essentially 2902 01:14:32,580 --> 01:14:32,580 2903 01:14:32,580 --> 01:14:33,450 saves us money from contracting 2904 01:14:33,450 --> 01:14:33,680 2905 01:14:33,680 --> 01:14:39,526 it out, we do it in house. 2906 01:14:39,526 --> 01:14:44,010 and we've got our concrete 2907 01:14:44,010 --> 01:14:44,559 subsection which are responsible 2908 01:14:44,559 --> 01:14:44,559 2909 01:14:44,559 --> 01:14:48,006 for all the pedestrians 2910 01:14:48,006 --> 01:14:51,436 pathways, ada compliance for 2911 01:14:51,436 --> 01:14:52,774 ramps, sidewalks and curbs 2912 01:14:52,774 --> 01:14:53,096 themselves on the roadways. 2913 01:14:53,096 --> 01:15:00,711 the pavement preservation 2914 01:15:00,711 --> 01:15:03,150 program is done at the 2915 01:15:03,150 --> 01:15:04,518 administrative level, but we've 2916 01:15:04,518 --> 01:15:04,982 2917 01:15:04,982 --> 01:15:07,052 just recently introduced the d 2918 01:15:07,052 --> 01:15:07,052 ot 2919 01:15:07,052 --> 01:15:09,388 software, which uses the new sb 2920 01:15:09,388 --> 01:15:09,388 I 2921 01:15:09,388 --> 01:15:12,824 indexes to weight in and 2922 01:15:12,824 --> 01:15:18,634 prioritize the roadways with t 2923 01:15:18,634 --> 01:15:18,634 he 2924 01:15:18,634 --> 01:15:20,190 sbi in mind. 2925 01:15:20,190 --> 01:15:28,824 this is a picture putting down 2926 01:15:28,824 --> 01:15:28,964 a 2927 01:15:28,964 --> 01:15:30,908 binder on the roadway. 2928 01:15:30,908 --> 01:15:40,423 it's getting rolled in, two, 2929 01:15:40,423 --> 01:15:42,320 three weeks after this, they'll 2930 01:15:42,320 --> 01:15:42,622 2931 01:15:42,622 --> 01:15:44,830 top it with a micro surface, I 2932 01:15:44,830 --> 01:15:45,686 t 2933 01:15:45,686 --> 01:15:47,526 gives you a much loaninger lif 2934 01:15:47,526 --> 01:15:47,657 e 2935 01:15:47,657 --> 01:15:49,064 out of your roadways. 2936 01:15:49,064 --> 01:15:50,538 pavement preservation is 2937 01:15:50,538 --> 01:15:51,980 important to maintain our good 2938 01:15:51,980 --> 01:15:52,626 2939 01:15:52,626 --> 01:15:55,906 roadways so that we don't fail 2940 01:15:55,906 --> 01:15:56,134 2941 01:15:56,134 --> 01:15:57,670 and get to a point where we're 2942 01:15:57,670 --> 01:15:58,066 2943 01:15:58,066 --> 01:15:59,302 spending a bunch of money. 2944 01:15:59,302 --> 01:16:04,006 a lot cheaper to do it this wa 2945 01:16:04,006 --> 01:16:04,006 y. 2946 01:16:04,006 --> 01:16:06,615 our drainage section, we have a 2947 01:16:06,615 --> 01:16:06,615 n 2948 01:16:06,615 --> 01:16:09,646 open water course and closed 2949 01:16:09,646 --> 01:16:10,277 water course subsection. 2950 01:16:10,277 --> 01:16:12,486 the open water course is simpl 2951 01:16:12,486 --> 01:16:13,146 y 2952 01:16:13,146 --> 01:16:14,786 ditches, retention ponds, 2953 01:16:14,786 --> 01:16:15,721 anything that's open to the ai 2954 01:16:15,721 --> 01:16:15,721 r, 2955 01:16:15,721 --> 01:16:17,628 closed water course is going t 2956 01:16:17,628 --> 01:16:17,670 o 2957 01:16:17,670 --> 01:16:20,222 be all of your pipes, boxes, 2958 01:16:20,222 --> 01:16:25,262 stuff that's buried that you 2959 01:16:25,262 --> 01:16:25,854 ca't see. 2960 01:16:25,854 --> 01:16:29,936 so this is our open water 2961 01:16:29,936 --> 01:16:32,285 course, crew correcting a bridg 2962 01:16:32,285 --> 01:16:32,285 e 2963 01:16:32,285 --> 01:16:35,675 deficiency that was found by t 2964 01:16:35,675 --> 01:16:35,675 he 2965 01:16:35,675 --> 01:16:37,818 contractor that inspects our 2966 01:16:37,818 --> 01:16:37,818 bridges. 2967 01:16:37,818 --> 01:16:40,126 so we have to go in, divert 2968 01:16:40,126 --> 01:16:44,752 water, and come in and fix the defi 2969 01:16:44,752 --> 01:16:51,230 deficiency so we can pass 2970 01:16:51,230 --> 01:16:51,230 inspection. 2971 01:16:51,230 --> 01:16:53,488 and then this is a great pictu 2972 01:16:53,488 --> 01:16:53,488 re 2973 01:16:53,488 --> 01:16:55,162 showing what the closed water 2974 01:16:55,162 --> 01:16:55,162 2975 01:16:55,162 --> 01:16:56,358 course team does, this is a 2976 01:16:56,358 --> 01:16:59,969 project, this is when we put I 2977 01:16:59,969 --> 01:17:00,328 n 2978 01:17:00,328 --> 01:17:03,068 the new northeast 9th avenue 2979 01:17:03,068 --> 01:17:03,068 roadway. 2980 01:17:03,068 --> 01:17:07,102 this pipe system was placed, 2981 01:17:07,102 --> 01:17:09,474 that's 8th avenue, so we built 2982 01:17:09,474 --> 01:17:09,944 2983 01:17:09,944 --> 01:17:11,642 9th just behind this, this is 2984 01:17:11,642 --> 01:17:11,642 2985 01:17:11,642 --> 01:17:13,007 exactly what they do, this is a 2986 01:17:13,007 --> 01:17:13,582 2987 01:17:13,582 --> 01:17:14,818 smaller team of about 5. 2988 01:17:14,818 --> 01:17:18,782 and they just come in, and 2989 01:17:18,782 --> 01:17:20,856 really have a ton of pipes. 2990 01:17:20,856 --> 01:17:23,324 miles and miles in pipes to 2991 01:17:23,324 --> 01:17:24,790 maintain, they do a great job. 2992 01:17:24,790 --> 01:17:24,790 2993 01:17:24,790 --> 01:17:25,378 very good at their jobs. 2994 01:17:25,378 --> 01:17:31,326 so we'll move on to our 2995 01:17:31,326 --> 01:17:32,272 right-of-way section, the 2996 01:17:32,272 --> 01:17:36,335 picture on the right, you see 2997 01:17:36,335 --> 01:17:36,335 2998 01:17:36,335 --> 01:17:39,273 this is the mad vac mini-that w 2999 01:17:39,273 --> 01:17:39,273 e 3000 01:17:39,273 --> 01:17:42,570 had to buy when we started 3001 01:17:42,570 --> 01:17:44,350 putting in the one way pavers, 3002 01:17:44,350 --> 01:17:45,342 3003 01:17:45,342 --> 01:17:46,810 it's been a phenomenal machine. 3004 01:17:46,810 --> 01:17:46,810 3005 01:17:46,810 --> 01:17:50,110 and then we've got our full 3006 01:17:50,110 --> 01:17:53,526 sized street sweepers that run 3007 01:17:53,526 --> 01:17:53,848 3008 01:17:53,848 --> 01:17:55,088 just curbed roadways. 3009 01:17:55,088 --> 01:17:57,757 so the only roadways that will 3010 01:17:57,757 --> 01:17:58,323 3011 01:17:58,323 --> 01:17:59,122 get swept are curbed. 3012 01:17:59,122 --> 01:18:01,816 a lot of people think the street 3013 01:18:01,816 --> 01:18:01,816 3014 01:18:01,816 --> 01:18:03,726 sweeper is here to clean the 3015 01:18:03,726 --> 01:18:05,394 roadways, and they do that. 3016 01:18:05,394 --> 01:18:07,036 the main purpose is to pull the 3017 01:18:07,036 --> 01:18:07,534 3018 01:18:07,534 --> 01:18:09,538 debris out of the roadway, so I 3019 01:18:09,538 --> 01:18:09,538 t 3020 01:18:09,538 --> 01:18:10,866 doesn't get flushed down into 3021 01:18:10,866 --> 01:18:10,866 3022 01:18:10,866 --> 01:18:13,140 the pipes and waterways, so it' 3023 01:18:13,140 --> 01:18:13,140 s 3024 01:18:13,140 --> 01:18:15,386 actually a water quality thing 3025 01:18:15,386 --> 01:18:15,638 3026 01:18:15,638 --> 01:18:19,372 more than it is a street 3027 01:18:19,372 --> 01:18:20,110 cleaning thing. 3028 01:18:20,110 --> 01:18:21,646 >> I'll pause you there and pas 3029 01:18:21,646 --> 01:18:21,646 s 3030 01:18:21,646 --> 01:18:23,377 on something that we heard in a 3031 01:18:23,377 --> 01:18:23,562 3032 01:18:23,562 --> 01:18:24,550 presentation many years ago, 3033 01:18:24,550 --> 01:18:26,416 that was an eye opener for me. 3034 01:18:26,416 --> 01:18:26,416 3035 01:18:26,416 --> 01:18:29,562 that if you -- if your street I 3036 01:18:29,562 --> 01:18:29,562 s 3037 01:18:29,562 --> 01:18:31,358 a curb and gutter street, that 3038 01:18:31,358 --> 01:18:31,492 3039 01:18:31,492 --> 01:18:33,991 is -- if you have a curb, that' 3040 01:18:33,991 --> 01:18:33,991 s 3041 01:18:33,991 --> 01:18:36,092 part of our storm water 3042 01:18:36,092 --> 01:18:36,494 management system. 3043 01:18:36,494 --> 01:18:38,258 not every street is part of our 3044 01:18:38,258 --> 01:18:38,538 3045 01:18:38,538 --> 01:18:39,520 storm water management system, 3046 01:18:39,520 --> 01:18:39,896 3047 01:18:39,896 --> 01:18:40,892 if you have curb and gutter, 3048 01:18:40,892 --> 01:18:41,262 that's part of it. 3049 01:18:41,262 --> 01:18:48,340 >> it's very important. 3050 01:18:48,340 --> 01:18:52,206 and then the maintenance and 3051 01:18:52,206 --> 01:18:53,712 mowing section of our 3052 01:18:53,712 --> 01:18:54,580 right-of-way team is extremely 3053 01:18:54,580 --> 01:18:56,118 3054 01:18:56,118 --> 01:18:57,416 important, they handle the 3055 01:18:57,416 --> 01:18:59,356 medians, keeping the medians 3056 01:18:59,356 --> 01:18:59,783 nice and clean. 3057 01:18:59,783 --> 01:19:01,485 they make sure our sidewalks a 3058 01:19:01,485 --> 01:19:01,485 re 3059 01:19:01,485 --> 01:19:04,658 edged, cut back to keep our 3060 01:19:04,658 --> 01:19:05,496 clearances for the pedestrians 3061 01:19:05,496 --> 01:19:05,894 3062 01:19:05,894 --> 01:19:06,654 walking the sidewalks. 3063 01:19:06,654 --> 01:19:09,862 make sure we got our 7 foot 3064 01:19:09,862 --> 01:19:11,390 height on everything, so peopl 3065 01:19:11,390 --> 01:19:11,554 e 3066 01:19:11,554 --> 01:19:12,672 aren't bumping heads walking 3067 01:19:12,672 --> 01:19:16,234 down sidewalks. 3068 01:19:16,234 --> 01:19:21,174 this is the downtown detail 3069 01:19:21,174 --> 01:19:23,023 crew, we have the mad vac in t 3070 01:19:23,023 --> 01:19:23,023 he 3071 01:19:23,023 --> 01:19:25,110 streeterry area, they spend 10 3072 01:19:25,110 --> 01:19:25,110 0% 3073 01:19:25,110 --> 01:19:27,342 of their time in core downtown 3074 01:19:27,342 --> 01:19:28,051 , 3075 01:19:28,051 --> 01:19:29,498 really cleaning, making sure 3076 01:19:29,498 --> 01:19:31,778 they're keeping up with 3077 01:19:31,778 --> 01:19:33,498 graffiti, and garbage, any 3078 01:19:33,498 --> 01:19:36,592 spills, they're fully dedicated 3079 01:19:36,592 --> 01:19:36,770 3080 01:19:36,770 --> 01:19:37,664 to downtown, they do a great 3081 01:19:37,664 --> 01:19:37,664 job. 3082 01:19:37,664 --> 01:19:45,267 we'll move into solid waste. 3083 01:19:45,267 --> 01:19:47,646 I want to touch on a couple of 3084 01:19:47,646 --> 01:19:47,646 3085 01:19:47,646 --> 01:19:49,134 the key strategic goals before 3086 01:19:49,134 --> 01:19:49,378 I 3087 01:19:49,378 --> 01:19:50,236 get into it. 3088 01:19:50,236 --> 01:19:53,199 we're currently in the final 3089 01:19:53,199 --> 01:19:58,479 phases of our I.t. Negotiations 3090 01:19:58,479 --> 01:19:58,479 . 3091 01:19:58,479 --> 01:20:01,212 and we're in the scoring phase 3092 01:20:01,212 --> 01:20:01,442 3093 01:20:01,442 --> 01:20:02,782 for the food waste rfp. 3094 01:20:02,782 --> 01:20:05,814 I can't get too much into it, 3095 01:20:05,814 --> 01:20:05,814 3096 01:20:05,814 --> 01:20:08,454 just wanted to give you an 3097 01:20:08,454 --> 01:20:09,418 update on where we're at with 3098 01:20:09,418 --> 01:20:09,418 3099 01:20:09,418 --> 01:20:09,418 it. 3100 01:20:09,418 --> 01:20:11,192 we'll go ahead and start with 3101 01:20:11,192 --> 01:20:11,192 3102 01:20:11,192 --> 01:20:12,490 solid waste, as you can see, 3103 01:20:12,490 --> 01:20:18,296 this is an issue here with mov 3104 01:20:18,296 --> 01:20:18,594 e 3105 01:20:18,594 --> 01:20:19,933 n someone didn't plan for the 3106 01:20:19,933 --> 01:20:19,933 3107 01:20:19,933 --> 01:20:19,933 boxes. 3108 01:20:19,933 --> 01:20:22,434 our inspector team is a team o 3109 01:20:22,434 --> 01:20:22,762 f 3110 01:20:22,762 --> 01:20:22,762 four. 3111 01:20:22,762 --> 01:20:27,200 their entire job is to go out 3112 01:20:27,200 --> 01:20:27,200 3113 01:20:27,200 --> 01:20:29,938 and enforce our ordinances. 3114 01:20:29,938 --> 01:20:32,116 and they do a phenomenal job. 3115 01:20:32,116 --> 01:20:35,044 this one will I point at the 3116 01:20:35,044 --> 01:20:35,044 numbers. 3117 01:20:35,044 --> 01:20:36,416 this is impressive. 3118 01:20:36,416 --> 01:20:38,214 just in the first quarter of 3119 01:20:38,214 --> 01:20:40,484 this year, they've made contact 3120 01:20:40,484 --> 01:20:40,781 3121 01:20:40,781 --> 01:20:44,383 with 2700 residential and 3122 01:20:44,383 --> 01:20:44,865 commercial properties. 3123 01:20:44,865 --> 01:20:48,895 out of all of those only 4 wou 3124 01:20:48,895 --> 01:20:48,895 nd 3125 01:20:48,895 --> 01:20:51,396 up with a civil citation, it 3126 01:20:51,396 --> 01:20:53,432 means they're doing a very goo 3127 01:20:53,432 --> 01:20:53,566 d 3128 01:20:53,566 --> 01:20:56,128 job educating people on the 3129 01:20:56,128 --> 01:20:57,136 ordinance, what's required and 3130 01:20:57,136 --> 01:20:57,318 3131 01:20:57,318 --> 01:20:58,598 the residential and commercial 3132 01:20:58,598 --> 01:20:58,902 3133 01:20:58,902 --> 01:21:02,504 properties are following them. 3134 01:21:02,504 --> 01:21:02,504 3135 01:21:02,504 --> 01:21:04,186 our litter crew are up and dow 3136 01:21:04,186 --> 01:21:04,314 n 3137 01:21:04,314 --> 01:21:07,208 the sides of the roadways, 3138 01:21:07,208 --> 01:21:09,412 cleaning up encampments that 3139 01:21:09,412 --> 01:21:11,509 have been abandoned, they're 3140 01:21:11,509 --> 01:21:14,654 constantly out running, picking 3141 01:21:14,654 --> 01:21:14,850 3142 01:21:14,850 --> 01:21:16,784 garbage cans up, a very 3143 01:21:16,784 --> 01:21:18,226 important part to keeping all of 3144 01:21:18,226 --> 01:21:18,226 3145 01:21:18,226 --> 01:21:22,840 the city of gainesville clean 3146 01:21:22,840 --> 01:21:22,840 3147 01:21:22,840 --> 01:21:24,496 our surplus department, this, I 3148 01:21:24,496 --> 01:21:24,760 3149 01:21:24,760 --> 01:21:26,835 know this -- anyone who's a 3150 01:21:26,835 --> 01:21:28,360 fleet freak, this picture may 3151 01:21:28,360 --> 01:21:28,360 3152 01:21:28,360 --> 01:21:29,633 freak you out, but essentially 3153 01:21:29,633 --> 01:21:30,831 3154 01:21:30,831 --> 01:21:33,541 this is the storage building f 3155 01:21:33,541 --> 01:21:33,541 or 3156 01:21:33,541 --> 01:21:36,080 all of the city's no longer 3157 01:21:36,080 --> 01:21:36,341 needed items. 3158 01:21:36,341 --> 01:21:41,308 so what we do, we turn the 3159 01:21:41,308 --> 01:21:45,388 city's trash into treasure with 3160 01:21:45,388 --> 01:21:46,914 3161 01:21:46,914 --> 01:21:46,914 surplus. 3162 01:21:46,914 --> 01:21:49,472 they made, I believe, right at 3163 01:21:49,472 --> 01:21:50,423 a 3164 01:21:50,423 --> 01:21:52,592 quarter million dollars last 3165 01:21:52,592 --> 01:21:54,363 year out of disposed items and 3166 01:21:54,363 --> 01:21:54,588 3167 01:21:54,588 --> 01:21:55,934 kept them out of the land year 3168 01:21:55,934 --> 01:21:55,934 . 3169 01:21:55,934 --> 01:21:58,931 quarter one, they turned $57,0 3170 01:21:58,931 --> 01:21:58,931 00 3171 01:21:58,931 --> 01:22:01,267 out of unwanted city items. 3172 01:22:01,267 --> 01:22:02,672 they're very good at what they 3173 01:22:02,672 --> 01:22:03,162 3174 01:22:03,162 --> 01:22:03,940 do, very passionate. 3175 01:22:03,940 --> 01:22:05,740 a lot of times my construction 3176 01:22:05,740 --> 01:22:06,784 3177 01:22:06,784 --> 01:22:09,244 crews will take a bent form fro 3178 01:22:09,244 --> 01:22:09,244 m 3179 01:22:09,244 --> 01:22:11,252 a concrete team, throw it in th 3180 01:22:11,252 --> 01:22:11,252 e 3181 01:22:11,252 --> 01:22:13,374 dumpster, recover it and sell, 3182 01:22:13,374 --> 01:22:13,784 3183 01:22:13,784 --> 01:22:14,358 and very good at what they do. 3184 01:22:14,358 --> 01:22:14,358 3185 01:22:14,358 --> 01:22:19,152 zero waste team, we're in a 3186 01:22:19,152 --> 01:22:20,950 rebuilding phase on the zero 3187 01:22:20,950 --> 01:22:22,352 waste team, we had some 3188 01:22:22,352 --> 01:22:23,814 turnover, we just -- we're in 3189 01:22:23,814 --> 01:22:23,814 3190 01:22:23,814 --> 01:22:28,688 the process of getting our 3191 01:22:28,688 --> 01:22:32,968 second and final zero waste 3192 01:22:32,968 --> 01:22:34,865 specialist, this team is very 3193 01:22:34,865 --> 01:22:34,865 3194 01:22:34,865 --> 01:22:36,600 important when it comes to 3195 01:22:36,600 --> 01:22:37,569 presenting to the community, 3196 01:22:37,569 --> 01:22:52,114 getting out to the community a 3197 01:22:52,114 --> 01:22:52,114 nd 3198 01:22:52,114 --> 01:22:54,256 let them know what is expected 3199 01:22:54,256 --> 01:22:54,256 3200 01:22:54,256 --> 01:22:54,521 from our ordinances. 3201 01:22:54,521 --> 01:22:59,056 >> how do organizations and 3202 01:22:59,056 --> 01:23:02,305 nonprofits and citizens access 3203 01:23:02,305 --> 01:23:02,491 3204 01:23:02,491 --> 01:23:03,558 that and purchase things? 3205 01:23:03,558 --> 01:23:05,358 can you tell us things about 3206 01:23:05,358 --> 01:23:05,358 that? 3207 01:23:05,358 --> 01:23:07,844 >> how dony purchase -- 3208 01:23:07,844 --> 01:23:08,604 >> our surplus goods. 3209 01:23:08,604 --> 01:23:08,935 >> oh, okay. 3210 01:23:08,935 --> 01:23:13,802 our surplus team will post the 3211 01:23:13,802 --> 01:23:14,370 3212 01:23:14,370 --> 01:23:14,370 goods. 3213 01:23:14,370 --> 01:23:16,612 they first will put it back out 3214 01:23:16,612 --> 01:23:16,902 3215 01:23:16,902 --> 01:23:21,092 to city blo employees and say, 3216 01:23:21,092 --> 01:23:21,726 is 3217 01:23:21,726 --> 01:23:23,619 there anything here you're 3218 01:23:23,619 --> 01:23:24,028 interested in? 3219 01:23:24,028 --> 01:23:25,914 and when people come and get 3220 01:23:25,914 --> 01:23:27,786 what they want, they'll turn 3221 01:23:27,786 --> 01:23:29,418 around, take pictures of it, 3222 01:23:29,418 --> 01:23:30,742 they inventory everything, and 3223 01:23:30,742 --> 01:23:30,828 3224 01:23:30,828 --> 01:23:35,188 put it on a go deals website, 3225 01:23:35,188 --> 01:23:35,188 3226 01:23:35,188 --> 01:23:36,366 either as a batch, if they hav 3227 01:23:36,366 --> 01:23:36,575 e 3228 01:23:36,575 --> 01:23:38,969 a bunch of matching chairs or 3229 01:23:38,969 --> 01:23:38,969 3230 01:23:38,969 --> 01:23:39,907 they have something special, a 3231 01:23:39,907 --> 01:23:40,231 3232 01:23:40,231 --> 01:23:41,567 computer unit, they'll put it o 3233 01:23:41,567 --> 01:23:41,567 n 3234 01:23:41,567 --> 01:23:42,769 there, people will bid on, and 3235 01:23:42,769 --> 01:23:42,769 3236 01:23:42,769 --> 01:23:42,910 buy it. 3237 01:23:42,910 --> 01:23:48,489 >> very good, thank you. 3238 01:23:48,489 --> 01:23:57,175 >> so then we have urban 3239 01:23:57,175 --> 01:23:57,175 forestry. 3240 01:23:57,175 --> 01:24:01,490 our tree crew, very important 3241 01:24:01,490 --> 01:24:01,490 3242 01:24:01,490 --> 01:24:05,626 crew, they're actually -- their 3243 01:24:05,626 --> 01:24:05,762 3244 01:24:05,762 --> 01:24:07,824 actual title is tree surgeons, 3245 01:24:07,824 --> 01:24:08,170 I 3246 01:24:08,170 --> 01:24:09,723 thought that was funny until I 3247 01:24:09,723 --> 01:24:09,864 3248 01:24:09,864 --> 01:24:13,001 saw them with a chain saw and 3249 01:24:13,001 --> 01:24:13,001 3250 01:24:13,001 --> 01:24:14,064 realized they are true 3251 01:24:14,064 --> 01:24:14,064 craftsman. 3252 01:24:14,064 --> 01:24:16,332 they can take a tree like this 3253 01:24:16,332 --> 01:24:16,870 , 3254 01:24:16,870 --> 01:24:18,602 I wouldn't know what to do, the 3255 01:24:18,602 --> 01:24:18,602 y 3256 01:24:18,602 --> 01:24:20,474 have it cut, pushed, out of 3257 01:24:20,474 --> 01:24:21,674 there, before you know it. 3258 01:24:21,674 --> 01:24:23,415 they're phenomenal, very 3259 01:24:23,415 --> 01:24:25,347 important to keeping the city o 3260 01:24:25,347 --> 01:24:25,347 f 3261 01:24:25,347 --> 01:24:26,286 gainesville roadways open and 3262 01:24:26,286 --> 01:24:26,286 3263 01:24:26,286 --> 01:24:26,286 running. 3264 01:24:26,286 --> 01:24:32,486 our horticulturalist team loves 3265 01:24:32,486 --> 01:24:32,616 3266 01:24:32,616 --> 01:24:33,119 to plant trees. 3267 01:24:33,119 --> 01:24:35,759 on the right, that's our edibl 3268 01:24:35,759 --> 01:24:36,138 e 3269 01:24:36,138 --> 01:24:38,652 grove that's in smokey bear 3270 01:24:38,652 --> 01:24:38,652 park. 3271 01:24:38,652 --> 01:24:40,222 off in the distance, you can't 3272 01:24:40,222 --> 01:24:40,424 3273 01:24:40,424 --> 01:24:41,624 see, there's one of our 3274 01:24:41,624 --> 01:24:42,955 neighbors who picked some fruit 3275 01:24:42,955 --> 01:24:43,524 3276 01:24:43,524 --> 01:24:44,589 an was eating on the way out. 3277 01:24:44,589 --> 01:24:47,233 this team's very passionate, 3278 01:24:47,233 --> 01:24:49,058 they would plant a tree where 3279 01:24:49,058 --> 01:24:49,058 3280 01:24:49,058 --> 01:24:50,169 I'm standing if you would let 3281 01:24:50,169 --> 01:24:50,169 3282 01:24:50,169 --> 01:24:50,169 them. 3283 01:24:50,169 --> 01:24:52,241 they're amazing. 3284 01:24:52,241 --> 01:24:54,350 we have the program coordinator 3285 01:24:54,350 --> 01:24:56,244 3286 01:24:56,244 --> 01:24:59,044 who is the lead liaison to our 3287 01:24:59,044 --> 01:24:59,476 3288 01:24:59,476 --> 01:25:01,578 tree advisory board, also deals 3289 01:25:01,578 --> 01:25:03,318 3290 01:25:03,318 --> 01:25:04,794 directly with the public, 3291 01:25:04,794 --> 01:25:07,182 sponsoring trees and really is 3292 01:25:07,182 --> 01:25:07,496 3293 01:25:07,496 --> 01:25:09,818 the -- kind of the outreach 3294 01:25:09,818 --> 01:25:13,388 voice for urban forestry. 3295 01:25:13,388 --> 01:25:17,232 and then we have mosquito 3296 01:25:17,232 --> 01:25:19,267 control, so mosquito control 3297 01:25:19,267 --> 01:25:20,977 kind of holds a special place I 3298 01:25:20,977 --> 01:25:20,977 n 3299 01:25:20,977 --> 01:25:23,909 my heart, this is where I 3300 01:25:23,909 --> 01:25:29,344 started my journey with the 3301 01:25:29,344 --> 01:25:29,344 city. 3302 01:25:29,344 --> 01:25:32,614 so you may or may not know, 3303 01:25:32,614 --> 01:25:34,374 mosquitos are the deadliest 3304 01:25:34,374 --> 01:25:38,450 animal on the planet, they kil 3305 01:25:38,450 --> 01:25:38,746 l 3306 01:25:38,746 --> 01:25:42,660 700,000 to a million people 3307 01:25:42,660 --> 01:25:43,238 every year. 3308 01:25:43,238 --> 01:25:45,648 in my opinion, mosquito control 3309 01:25:45,648 --> 01:25:46,057 3310 01:25:46,057 --> 01:25:48,159 is one of the best bangs for 3311 01:25:48,159 --> 01:25:49,192 your puck that the city has. 3312 01:25:49,192 --> 01:25:53,203 in 2016, we had some zeka cases 3313 01:25:53,203 --> 01:25:53,487 3314 01:25:53,487 --> 01:25:55,232 that came in with transient 3315 01:25:55,232 --> 01:25:55,232 students. 3316 01:25:55,232 --> 01:25:58,102 and the mosquito control team 3317 01:25:58,102 --> 01:25:58,102 3318 01:25:58,102 --> 01:26:01,244 had to go out and actually 3319 01:26:01,244 --> 01:26:02,534 spray, treat and really make 3320 01:26:02,534 --> 01:26:04,171 sure that we didn't take 3321 01:26:04,171 --> 01:26:05,944 imported cases and make them 3322 01:26:05,944 --> 01:26:08,612 locally acquired cases. 3323 01:26:08,612 --> 01:26:11,691 very important part of the cit 3324 01:26:11,691 --> 01:26:11,994 y 3325 01:26:11,994 --> 01:26:12,458 of gainesville. 3326 01:26:12,458 --> 01:26:16,490 the city of gainesville has a 3327 01:26:16,490 --> 01:26:16,490 3328 01:26:16,490 --> 01:26:19,288 very, very good integrated pes 3329 01:26:19,288 --> 01:26:19,590 t 3330 01:26:19,590 --> 01:26:20,857 management program, part of tha 3331 01:26:20,857 --> 01:26:20,857 t 3332 01:26:20,857 --> 01:26:26,872 is biological control, so thes 3333 01:26:26,872 --> 01:26:27,066 e 3334 01:26:27,066 --> 01:26:29,502 six ponds are on the public 3335 01:26:29,502 --> 01:26:33,138 works compound. 3336 01:26:33,138 --> 01:26:37,309 we raise fish that are native 3337 01:26:37,309 --> 01:26:37,309 3338 01:26:37,309 --> 01:26:39,474 species, they're ferocious 3339 01:26:39,474 --> 01:26:39,474 eaters. 3340 01:26:39,474 --> 01:26:42,390 any time a pond fills up, or w 3341 01:26:42,390 --> 01:26:42,886 e 3342 01:26:42,886 --> 01:26:44,253 have a new wet area that fills 3343 01:26:44,253 --> 01:26:44,392 3344 01:26:44,392 --> 01:26:47,092 after the rain, these fish go t 3345 01:26:47,092 --> 01:26:47,092 o 3346 01:26:47,092 --> 01:26:50,325 work, and they keep the 3347 01:26:50,325 --> 01:26:50,630 population down. 3348 01:26:50,630 --> 01:26:53,519 proactive treatment is done with 3349 01:26:53,519 --> 01:26:53,519 3350 01:26:53,519 --> 01:26:58,031 the vectomax, a dual active 3351 01:26:58,031 --> 01:27:00,766 bacteria, that focuses on 3352 01:27:00,766 --> 01:27:02,102 mosquito larvae, and when they 3353 01:27:02,102 --> 01:27:02,334 3354 01:27:02,334 --> 01:27:03,842 eat, they are unable to turn 3355 01:27:03,842 --> 01:27:04,028 into adults. 3356 01:27:04,028 --> 01:27:12,508 this is kind of a really short 3357 01:27:12,508 --> 01:27:12,789 3358 01:27:12,789 --> 01:27:14,616 sweet breakdown of a really goo 3359 01:27:14,616 --> 01:27:14,616 d 3360 01:27:14,616 --> 01:27:16,520 integrated pest management 3361 01:27:16,520 --> 01:27:16,520 program. 3362 01:27:16,520 --> 01:27:18,654 you have your surveillance whe 3363 01:27:18,654 --> 01:27:18,654 re 3364 01:27:18,654 --> 01:27:21,092 you're really going out there 3365 01:27:21,092 --> 01:27:21,092 3366 01:27:21,092 --> 01:27:23,021 and looking at what mosquitos 3367 01:27:23,021 --> 01:27:23,021 3368 01:27:23,021 --> 01:27:23,580 are popping off. 3369 01:27:23,580 --> 01:27:25,874 you identify that mosquito, you 3370 01:27:25,874 --> 01:27:26,052 3371 01:27:26,052 --> 01:27:28,542 say, that's a swamp mosquito, a 3372 01:27:28,542 --> 01:27:29,256 3373 01:27:29,256 --> 01:27:32,906 container brieeder. 3374 01:27:32,906 --> 01:27:34,828 our guys are doing that 3375 01:27:34,828 --> 01:27:36,362 continuously, they're removing 3376 01:27:36,362 --> 01:27:37,230 3377 01:27:37,230 --> 01:27:38,966 tires, buckets they find on the 3378 01:27:38,966 --> 01:27:39,156 3379 01:27:39,156 --> 01:27:40,938 side of the road or a swamp, 3380 01:27:40,938 --> 01:27:43,270 they're picking that stuff up 3381 01:27:43,270 --> 01:27:43,270 3382 01:27:43,270 --> 01:27:45,566 and physically removing the 3383 01:27:45,566 --> 01:27:45,566 environment. 3384 01:27:45,566 --> 01:27:47,872 they're treating proactively 3385 01:27:47,872 --> 01:27:52,112 with the vectamax granules I w 3386 01:27:52,112 --> 01:27:52,112 as 3387 01:27:52,112 --> 01:27:54,332 previously speaking of. 3388 01:27:54,332 --> 01:27:56,972 on the cattails you see, there's 3389 01:27:56,972 --> 01:27:56,972 3390 01:27:56,972 --> 01:27:58,856 two different types of mosquitos 3391 01:27:58,856 --> 01:27:58,856 3392 01:27:58,856 --> 01:28:00,844 that don't have to comment to 3393 01:28:00,844 --> 01:28:00,844 3394 01:28:00,844 --> 01:28:02,330 the surface for air. 3395 01:28:02,330 --> 01:28:05,830 they tap into the roots of 3396 01:28:05,830 --> 01:28:13,276 cattails so you can get what 3397 01:28:13,276 --> 01:28:13,894 they're eating. 3398 01:28:13,894 --> 01:28:15,936 with that, I will turn it over 3399 01:28:15,936 --> 01:28:16,236 3400 01:28:16,236 --> 01:28:17,537 to dr. Chase knight. 3401 01:28:17,537 --> 01:28:18,278 >> mayor: thank you. 3402 01:28:18,278 --> 01:28:20,788 I would recommend anyone who h 3403 01:28:20,788 --> 01:28:20,788 as 3404 01:28:20,788 --> 01:28:23,112 not spent any time with the 3405 01:28:23,112 --> 01:28:24,149 mosquito control team, I would 3406 01:28:24,149 --> 01:28:25,534 3407 01:28:25,534 --> 01:28:26,522 strongly recommend that, we do 3408 01:28:26,522 --> 01:28:26,982 3409 01:28:26,982 --> 01:28:28,130 some really cool work with tha 3410 01:28:28,130 --> 01:28:30,168 t 3411 01:28:30,168 --> 01:28:31,708 and it was -- I haven't been o 3412 01:28:31,708 --> 01:28:31,708 ut 3413 01:28:31,708 --> 01:28:34,162 in a few years, I have to go 3414 01:28:34,162 --> 01:28:35,264 back out and take a look. 3415 01:28:35,264 --> 01:28:39,054 it's a high-tech use to this, 3416 01:28:39,054 --> 01:28:39,054 3417 01:28:39,054 --> 01:28:39,226 it's functional. 3418 01:28:39,226 --> 01:28:41,912 spend a little time in our 3419 01:28:41,912 --> 01:28:42,792 neighbors and one further out I 3420 01:28:42,792 --> 01:28:42,792 n 3421 01:28:42,792 --> 01:28:43,382 the county, you'll see a 3422 01:28:43,382 --> 01:28:43,382 difference. 3423 01:28:43,382 --> 01:28:46,444 >> good morning, I'm chase 3424 01:28:46,444 --> 01:28:48,370 knight, the city engineer, I 3425 01:28:48,370 --> 01:28:51,107 have the honor of leading the 3426 01:28:51,107 --> 01:28:51,107 3427 01:28:51,107 --> 01:28:52,282 engineering division with the 3428 01:28:52,282 --> 01:28:52,282 3429 01:28:52,282 --> 01:28:52,944 public works department. 3430 01:28:52,944 --> 01:28:55,716 as with everybody else, I start 3431 01:28:55,716 --> 01:28:55,847 3432 01:28:55,847 --> 01:28:59,411 by reviewing the team. 3433 01:28:59,411 --> 01:29:01,686 and I want to pause and make 3434 01:29:01,686 --> 01:29:02,892 sure that I recognize the heart 3435 01:29:02,892 --> 01:29:02,892 s 3436 01:29:02,892 --> 01:29:05,150 and brains of the engineering 3437 01:29:05,150 --> 01:29:05,150 3438 01:29:05,150 --> 01:29:05,150 division. 3439 01:29:05,150 --> 01:29:08,759 our greatest asset, our people 3440 01:29:08,759 --> 01:29:08,759 . 3441 01:29:08,759 --> 01:29:10,334 because without them, none of 3442 01:29:10,334 --> 01:29:10,334 3443 01:29:10,334 --> 01:29:11,628 the work or numbers that I'm 3444 01:29:11,628 --> 01:29:13,292 about to go through will be 3445 01:29:13,292 --> 01:29:13,292 possible. 3446 01:29:13,292 --> 01:29:18,802 so the team here consists of 3447 01:29:18,802 --> 01:29:23,376 40.5fte's, we're divided into 5 3448 01:29:23,376 --> 01:29:23,546 3449 01:29:23,546 --> 01:29:25,408 sub teams, it's the capital 3450 01:29:25,408 --> 01:29:26,176 projects and development review 3451 01:29:26,176 --> 01:29:26,176 , 3452 01:29:26,176 --> 01:29:28,584 right-of-way permitting and 3453 01:29:28,584 --> 01:29:30,348 inspections, storm water 3454 01:29:30,348 --> 01:29:31,150 engineering, survey and traffi 3455 01:29:31,150 --> 01:29:31,321 c 3456 01:29:31,321 --> 01:29:31,321 management. 3457 01:29:31,321 --> 01:29:37,720 so in terms of the high level 3458 01:29:37,720 --> 01:29:37,720 3459 01:29:37,720 --> 01:29:39,690 overview of some of the more 3460 01:29:39,690 --> 01:29:43,134 important kpi's that we have, 3461 01:29:43,134 --> 01:29:43,134 3462 01:29:43,134 --> 01:29:46,306 and starting with the number o 3463 01:29:46,306 --> 01:29:46,698 f 3464 01:29:46,698 --> 01:29:48,134 design projects completed for 3465 01:29:48,134 --> 01:29:48,134 3466 01:29:48,134 --> 01:29:49,898 both roadway and storm water 3467 01:29:49,898 --> 01:29:52,332 projects, we're right on track 3468 01:29:52,332 --> 01:29:52,606 3469 01:29:52,606 --> 01:29:54,206 through quarter one for fy '26, 3470 01:29:54,206 --> 01:29:54,728 3471 01:29:54,728 --> 01:29:55,986 and one thing I wanted to 3472 01:29:55,986 --> 01:29:59,814 highlight here is, the majority 3473 01:29:59,814 --> 01:29:59,994 3474 01:29:59,994 --> 01:30:01,520 of projects that we're designing 3475 01:30:01,520 --> 01:30:01,520 3476 01:30:01,520 --> 01:30:03,382 are in house, that's been a key 3477 01:30:03,382 --> 01:30:03,718 3478 01:30:03,718 --> 01:30:05,416 focus for us, just to be able t 3479 01:30:05,416 --> 01:30:05,416 o 3480 01:30:05,416 --> 01:30:06,890 build up that expertise in 3481 01:30:06,890 --> 01:30:09,420 house, so we can begin to 3482 01:30:09,420 --> 01:30:13,190 balance our dependency. 3483 01:30:13,190 --> 01:30:15,896 in terms of construction 3484 01:30:15,896 --> 01:30:18,956 projects completed, we're on 3485 01:30:18,956 --> 01:30:22,096 track with our goal for this 3486 01:30:22,096 --> 01:30:23,733 fiscal year through quarter 1, 3487 01:30:23,733 --> 01:30:24,396 3488 01:30:24,396 --> 01:30:25,604 and just there are two examples 3489 01:30:25,604 --> 01:30:25,776 3490 01:30:25,776 --> 01:30:28,574 of projects that were completed 3491 01:30:28,574 --> 01:30:29,100 during that 3492 01:30:29,100 --> 01:30:30,474 during that quarter. 3493 01:30:30,474 --> 01:30:39,125 and moving on to review tasks for 3494 01:30:39,125 --> 01:30:40,926 for developments, this is really a 3495 01:30:40,926 --> 01:30:42,720 a cross function of kpi's, so w 3496 01:30:42,720 --> 01:30:42,720 e 3497 01:30:42,720 --> 01:30:45,124 have multiple team members tha 3498 01:30:45,124 --> 01:30:47,058 t 3499 01:30:47,058 --> 01:30:48,444 review plans for development a 3500 01:30:48,444 --> 01:30:48,444 nd 3501 01:30:48,444 --> 01:30:50,902 building permits, along with 3502 01:30:50,902 --> 01:30:52,406 other city departments in 3503 01:30:52,406 --> 01:30:53,464 conjunction with the city 3504 01:30:53,464 --> 01:30:53,464 departments. 3505 01:30:53,464 --> 01:30:56,910 so again, for this one, we are 3506 01:30:56,910 --> 01:30:56,910 3507 01:30:56,910 --> 01:30:58,469 on track looking at our quarter 3508 01:30:58,469 --> 01:30:58,642 3509 01:30:58,642 --> 01:31:01,268 one numbers to meet our 3510 01:31:01,268 --> 01:31:05,119 expectations for this fiscal 3511 01:31:05,119 --> 01:31:05,119 year. 3512 01:31:05,119 --> 01:31:08,828 and switching to traffic 3513 01:31:08,828 --> 01:31:11,750 operations, again, we are on 3514 01:31:11,750 --> 01:31:13,646 track for this particular kpi 3515 01:31:13,646 --> 01:31:13,646 3516 01:31:13,646 --> 01:31:16,752 looking at the number of traffic 3517 01:31:16,752 --> 01:31:16,752 3518 01:31:16,752 --> 01:31:19,989 engineers and related service 3519 01:31:19,989 --> 01:31:19,989 3520 01:31:19,989 --> 01:31:19,989 requests. 3521 01:31:19,989 --> 01:31:24,959 our goal for this year is 100 3522 01:31:24,959 --> 01:31:24,959 3523 01:31:24,959 --> 01:31:25,506 through quarter one. 3524 01:31:25,506 --> 01:31:28,666 we're just about on track to 3525 01:31:28,666 --> 01:31:29,816 meet that expectation. 3526 01:31:29,816 --> 01:31:32,204 we are slightly off our goal o 3527 01:31:32,204 --> 01:31:32,766 f 3528 01:31:32,766 --> 01:31:39,116 having 100% response time, les 3529 01:31:39,116 --> 01:31:39,252 s 3530 01:31:39,252 --> 01:31:41,411 than 40 hours, and that 3531 01:31:41,411 --> 01:31:42,512 certainly is something that 3532 01:31:42,512 --> 01:31:43,152 we'll continue to focus on 3533 01:31:43,152 --> 01:31:43,152 improving. 3534 01:31:43,152 --> 01:31:47,866 and then just to take a break 3535 01:31:47,866 --> 01:31:47,866 3536 01:31:47,866 --> 01:31:50,448 from the numbers for a little 3537 01:31:50,448 --> 01:31:50,448 3538 01:31:50,448 --> 01:31:54,230 bit, I do want to highlight som 3539 01:31:54,230 --> 01:31:54,230 e 3540 01:31:54,230 --> 01:31:55,894 general collaborations and key 3541 01:31:55,894 --> 01:31:57,230 3542 01:31:57,230 --> 01:32:00,109 initiatives that we've been 3543 01:32:00,109 --> 01:32:00,732 working with other departments 3544 01:32:00,732 --> 01:32:00,992 3545 01:32:00,992 --> 01:32:03,066 and agencies, with the traffic 3546 01:32:03,066 --> 01:32:05,142 3547 01:32:05,142 --> 01:32:06,272 engineering side. 3548 01:32:06,272 --> 01:32:07,974 so we've continued collaborati 3549 01:32:07,974 --> 01:32:07,974 on 3550 01:32:07,974 --> 01:32:09,708 with law enforcement partners, 3551 01:32:09,708 --> 01:32:10,121 3552 01:32:10,121 --> 01:32:13,280 on cctv integration, so we can 3553 01:32:13,280 --> 01:32:13,478 3554 01:32:13,478 --> 01:32:15,384 get realtime feeds, also, 3555 01:32:15,384 --> 01:32:17,482 working with the sheriff's 3556 01:32:17,482 --> 01:32:18,644 office as they explore buildin 3557 01:32:18,644 --> 01:32:18,858 g 3558 01:32:18,858 --> 01:32:21,236 a realtime intelligence center 3559 01:32:21,236 --> 01:32:21,236 . 3560 01:32:21,236 --> 01:32:25,128 and then we just continue with 3561 01:32:25,128 --> 01:32:25,957 3562 01:32:25,957 --> 01:32:27,386 preventative maintenance on all 3563 01:32:27,386 --> 01:32:28,152 3564 01:32:28,152 --> 01:32:29,072 251 traffic signals. 3565 01:32:29,072 --> 01:32:31,266 and the number is growing, tha 3566 01:32:31,266 --> 01:32:31,412 t 3567 01:32:31,412 --> 01:32:32,732 are maintained by the city. 3568 01:32:32,732 --> 01:32:36,200 so that helps us to reduce 3569 01:32:36,200 --> 01:32:39,772 calls, which saves time and 3570 01:32:39,772 --> 01:32:39,772 money. 3571 01:32:39,772 --> 01:32:44,418 moving to some numbers for a 3572 01:32:44,418 --> 01:32:44,742 survey team. 3573 01:32:44,742 --> 01:32:46,540 number of surveys completed. 3574 01:32:46,540 --> 01:32:51,748 we're on track here for goal 3575 01:32:51,748 --> 01:32:52,592 this fiscal year. 3576 01:32:52,592 --> 01:32:54,890 number of right-of-way 3577 01:32:54,890 --> 01:32:55,850 determinations, in support of 3578 01:32:55,850 --> 01:32:59,289 reactive services for 3579 01:32:59,289 --> 01:33:02,166 operations, gpd, code 3580 01:33:02,166 --> 01:33:02,166 enforcement. 3581 01:33:02,166 --> 01:33:07,772 also on track to meet our 3582 01:33:07,772 --> 01:33:09,502 expectation for this year. 3583 01:33:09,502 --> 01:33:12,343 likewise on track 4, the numbe 3584 01:33:12,343 --> 01:33:12,600 r 3585 01:33:12,600 --> 01:33:14,034 of legal descriptions complete 3586 01:33:14,034 --> 01:33:14,034 d. 3587 01:33:14,034 --> 01:33:17,912 one thing to highlight here tha 3588 01:33:17,912 --> 01:33:17,912 t 3589 01:33:17,912 --> 01:33:19,737 I show on the slide, basically, 3590 01:33:19,737 --> 01:33:20,976 3591 01:33:20,976 --> 01:33:23,735 it's not eligible, the picture 3592 01:33:23,735 --> 01:33:23,866 s 3593 01:33:23,866 --> 01:33:26,082 is an expert from the 42 page 3594 01:33:26,082 --> 01:33:26,082 3595 01:33:26,082 --> 01:33:27,514 legal description of the city 3596 01:33:27,514 --> 01:33:27,514 3597 01:33:27,514 --> 01:33:27,924 that our surveyor completed. 3598 01:33:27,924 --> 01:33:33,998 I find it hard sometimes to kee 3599 01:33:33,998 --> 01:33:33,998 p 3600 01:33:33,998 --> 01:33:36,497 up with a half page legal 3601 01:33:36,497 --> 01:33:37,896 description, not to mention one 3602 01:33:37,896 --> 01:33:38,264 3603 01:33:38,264 --> 01:33:39,532 that's 42 pages long. 3604 01:33:39,532 --> 01:33:39,830 that's impressive. 3605 01:33:39,830 --> 01:33:44,502 moving on to our right-of-way 3606 01:33:44,502 --> 01:33:44,502 3607 01:33:44,502 --> 01:33:46,068 permitting and inspections 3608 01:33:46,068 --> 01:33:47,176 group, so looking at the numbe 3609 01:33:47,176 --> 01:33:47,370 r 3610 01:33:47,370 --> 01:33:51,612 of permits that I've been 3611 01:33:51,612 --> 01:33:52,946 issued, for work in the 3612 01:33:52,946 --> 01:33:52,946 right-of-way. 3613 01:33:52,946 --> 01:33:56,716 again, right there on track for 3614 01:33:56,716 --> 01:33:57,142 3615 01:33:57,142 --> 01:33:59,514 what we expect this year. 3616 01:33:59,514 --> 01:34:02,952 and then finally, looking at t 3617 01:34:02,952 --> 01:34:02,952 he 3618 01:34:02,952 --> 01:34:06,386 number of inspections that tha 3619 01:34:06,386 --> 01:34:06,556 t 3620 01:34:06,556 --> 01:34:07,822 team has completed per month, 3621 01:34:07,822 --> 01:34:07,822 3622 01:34:07,822 --> 01:34:10,934 and I do want to apologize, 3623 01:34:10,934 --> 01:34:13,102 there's an update for this 3624 01:34:13,102 --> 01:34:13,102 slide. 3625 01:34:13,102 --> 01:34:16,542 so for the quarter one, the fy 3626 01:34:16,542 --> 01:34:17,002 3627 01:34:17,002 --> 01:34:19,053 '26 quarter one numbers, it is 3628 01:34:19,053 --> 01:34:19,053 a 3629 01:34:19,053 --> 01:34:22,948 total of 538 on average for 3630 01:34:22,948 --> 01:34:23,934 those first three months of the 3631 01:34:23,934 --> 01:34:24,174 3632 01:34:24,174 --> 01:34:24,174 year. 3633 01:34:24,174 --> 01:34:28,912 and that broke down to 173 for 3634 01:34:28,912 --> 01:34:29,292 3635 01:34:29,292 --> 01:34:30,423 building inspections, building 3636 01:34:30,423 --> 01:34:30,848 3637 01:34:30,848 --> 01:34:32,684 related inspections and building 3638 01:34:32,684 --> 01:34:32,684 3639 01:34:32,684 --> 01:34:35,416 permit related inspections. 3640 01:34:35,416 --> 01:34:41,024 and 365 right-of-way permit 3641 01:34:41,024 --> 01:34:41,024 inspections. 3642 01:34:41,024 --> 01:34:46,866 and that concludes what I have 3643 01:34:46,866 --> 01:34:47,072 3644 01:34:47,072 --> 01:34:48,228 >> mayor: very good, thank I. 3645 01:34:48,228 --> 01:34:50,338 I'll pass it on to mr. Rossi. 3646 01:34:50,338 --> 01:34:51,142 >> mayor: welcome. 3647 01:34:51,142 --> 01:34:55,844 >> steve rossi, computer syste 3648 01:34:55,844 --> 01:34:55,844 ms 3649 01:34:55,844 --> 01:34:57,134 analyst for public works. 3650 01:34:57,134 --> 01:34:59,142 we're one of the smaller 3651 01:34:59,142 --> 01:34:59,890 divisions of public works with 3652 01:34:59,890 --> 01:35:00,660 3653 01:35:00,660 --> 01:35:01,900 only two full time employees, 3654 01:35:01,900 --> 01:35:01,900 3655 01:35:01,900 --> 01:35:03,592 one of which is standing before 3656 01:35:03,592 --> 01:35:04,294 3657 01:35:04,294 --> 01:35:04,294 you. 3658 01:35:04,294 --> 01:35:05,976 as such, we wear many, many 3659 01:35:05,976 --> 01:35:06,222 different hats. 3660 01:35:06,222 --> 01:35:11,866 anything from helping staff 3661 01:35:11,866 --> 01:35:15,566 provide reportreports, procurem 3662 01:35:15,566 --> 01:35:15,912 ent, 3663 01:35:15,912 --> 01:35:17,284 how tos, training, anything that 3664 01:35:17,284 --> 01:35:17,284 3665 01:35:17,284 --> 01:35:20,180 happens to involve technology. 3666 01:35:20,180 --> 01:35:20,180 3667 01:35:20,180 --> 01:35:21,938 or as we like to think of it, 3668 01:35:21,938 --> 01:35:21,938 3669 01:35:21,938 --> 01:35:22,544 anything that plugs into the 3670 01:35:22,544 --> 01:35:22,544 wall. 3671 01:35:22,544 --> 01:35:26,368 the bulk of our workforce in 3672 01:35:26,368 --> 01:35:27,632 public works is mobile. 3673 01:35:27,632 --> 01:35:30,360 they're in the field all day 3674 01:35:30,360 --> 01:35:30,360 long. 3675 01:35:30,360 --> 01:35:32,504 they need mobile devices and 3676 01:35:32,504 --> 01:35:32,504 communications. 3677 01:35:32,504 --> 01:35:34,776 we keep track of almost 300 3678 01:35:34,776 --> 01:35:35,154 devices for our staff. 3679 01:35:35,154 --> 01:35:46,854 we also manage systems for the 3680 01:35:46,854 --> 01:35:47,330 3681 01:35:47,330 --> 01:35:49,966 gis system, some are shared by 3682 01:35:49,966 --> 01:35:50,008 3683 01:35:50,008 --> 01:35:51,233 public works and parks. 3684 01:35:51,233 --> 01:35:54,762 and we also maintain our own 3685 01:35:54,762 --> 01:35:56,234 cloud environment, where we run 3686 01:35:56,234 --> 01:35:56,560 3687 01:35:56,560 --> 01:35:57,742 and host these applications, 3688 01:35:57,742 --> 01:35:58,800 most of the stuff that our 3689 01:35:58,800 --> 01:36:00,504 department is using, we're 3690 01:36:00,504 --> 01:36:01,589 providing the front line suppo 3691 01:36:01,589 --> 01:36:01,589 rt 3692 01:36:01,589 --> 01:36:03,150 and the back end infrastructure 3693 01:36:03,150 --> 01:36:03,150 3694 01:36:03,150 --> 01:36:03,446 support of it. 3695 01:36:03,446 --> 01:36:08,516 our goals with having that man 3696 01:36:08,516 --> 01:36:08,844 y 3697 01:36:08,844 --> 01:36:11,246 mobile devices is to try to 3698 01:36:11,246 --> 01:36:12,356 replace them every four years. 3699 01:36:12,356 --> 01:36:12,356 3700 01:36:12,356 --> 01:36:13,888 this helps ensure that we have 3701 01:36:13,888 --> 01:36:14,046 3702 01:36:14,046 --> 01:36:15,254 the latest technology in front 3703 01:36:15,254 --> 01:36:15,458 3704 01:36:15,458 --> 01:36:18,154 of them, and they also have the 3705 01:36:18,154 --> 01:36:18,238 3706 01:36:18,238 --> 01:36:19,290 most recent can communications 3707 01:36:19,290 --> 01:36:19,562 3708 01:36:19,562 --> 01:36:20,992 and good battery life, since 3709 01:36:20,992 --> 01:36:22,060 they're going to be in the fie 3710 01:36:22,060 --> 01:36:22,060 ld 3711 01:36:22,060 --> 01:36:22,488 all day. 3712 01:36:22,488 --> 01:36:24,428 we try to make the most use of 3713 01:36:24,428 --> 01:36:24,684 3714 01:36:24,684 --> 01:36:26,562 our technology assets, we 3715 01:36:26,562 --> 01:36:27,872 promote the use of technology, 3716 01:36:27,872 --> 01:36:28,398 3717 01:36:28,398 --> 01:36:30,732 try to find efficiencies, 3718 01:36:30,732 --> 01:36:31,872 anything to help the departmen 3719 01:36:31,872 --> 01:36:32,084 t 3720 01:36:32,084 --> 01:36:33,798 reach their goals, and we 3721 01:36:33,798 --> 01:36:36,342 provide the front line support 3722 01:36:36,342 --> 01:36:36,342 3723 01:36:36,342 --> 01:36:37,228 for all of our staff, anything 3724 01:36:37,228 --> 01:36:37,374 3725 01:36:37,374 --> 01:36:39,587 that doesn't get covered by 3726 01:36:39,587 --> 01:36:42,718 gru I.t. Is what falls back to 3727 01:36:42,718 --> 01:36:42,912 3728 01:36:42,912 --> 01:36:46,186 us, most of that is department 3729 01:36:46,186 --> 01:36:46,467 3730 01:36:46,467 --> 01:36:48,188 specific things are specialized 3731 01:36:48,188 --> 01:36:48,448 3732 01:36:48,448 --> 01:36:49,290 that only public works would be 3733 01:36:49,290 --> 01:36:49,290 3734 01:36:49,290 --> 01:36:49,290 utilizing. 3735 01:36:49,290 --> 01:36:54,427 and our performance indicators 3736 01:36:54,427 --> 01:36:54,894 , 3737 01:36:54,894 --> 01:36:57,120 we try to keep our systems 3738 01:36:57,120 --> 01:36:57,120 available. 3739 01:36:57,120 --> 01:36:59,768 99.9% up time. 3740 01:36:59,768 --> 01:37:02,230 that leads to less than 45 3741 01:37:02,230 --> 01:37:05,842 minutes of downtown every month 3742 01:37:05,842 --> 01:37:05,982 3743 01:37:05,982 --> 01:37:06,506 for these systems. 3744 01:37:06,506 --> 01:37:08,288 as we refresh the mobile phone 3745 01:37:08,288 --> 01:37:08,510 s 3746 01:37:08,510 --> 01:37:10,478 with the volume we have,s 25% o 3747 01:37:10,478 --> 01:37:10,478 f 3748 01:37:10,478 --> 01:37:12,416 them each year, that equates t 3749 01:37:12,416 --> 01:37:12,640 o 3750 01:37:12,640 --> 01:37:14,784 about 6 devices every month tha 3751 01:37:14,784 --> 01:37:14,784 t 3752 01:37:14,784 --> 01:37:15,342 we swap out. 3753 01:37:15,342 --> 01:37:18,090 and we try to pride ourselves o 3754 01:37:18,090 --> 01:37:18,090 n 3755 01:37:18,090 --> 01:37:20,026 resolving all of these issues 3756 01:37:20,026 --> 01:37:20,026 3757 01:37:20,026 --> 01:37:21,316 the first time that staff 3758 01:37:21,316 --> 01:37:22,998 reaches out to us, we want to 3759 01:37:22,998 --> 01:37:22,998 3760 01:37:22,998 --> 01:37:25,092 make sure that they can complete 3761 01:37:25,092 --> 01:37:25,092 3762 01:37:25,092 --> 01:37:26,991 whatever task they needed, and 3763 01:37:26,991 --> 01:37:27,262 3764 01:37:27,262 --> 01:37:31,468 not have to defer it or circle 3765 01:37:31,468 --> 01:37:31,664 3766 01:37:31,664 --> 01:37:32,254 back around. 3767 01:37:32,254 --> 01:37:34,574 our success in trying to make 3768 01:37:34,574 --> 01:37:34,574 3769 01:37:34,574 --> 01:37:36,700 sure that our staff can do the 3770 01:37:36,700 --> 01:37:36,700 ir 3771 01:37:36,700 --> 01:37:38,620 duties is what helps lead to th 3772 01:37:38,620 --> 01:37:38,620 e 3773 01:37:38,620 --> 01:37:42,084 kpi's for the rest of the 3774 01:37:42,084 --> 01:37:42,084 department. 3775 01:37:42,084 --> 01:37:44,650 and that is all I have. 3776 01:37:44,650 --> 01:37:47,144 >> mayor: very good. 3777 01:37:47,144 --> 01:37:47,519 hold on a second. 3778 01:37:47,519 --> 01:37:49,648 commissioner willits? 3779 01:37:49,648 --> 01:37:51,344 >> a question about how your 3780 01:37:51,344 --> 01:37:55,656 team interacts or fitz into the 3781 01:37:55,656 --> 01:37:59,724 3782 01:37:59,724 --> 01:38:00,884 burgeoning department under 3783 01:38:00,884 --> 01:38:01,356 director nagy. 3784 01:38:01,356 --> 01:38:04,724 I know lots of different 3785 01:38:04,724 --> 01:38:05,356 departments operate technology. 3786 01:38:05,356 --> 01:38:05,356 3787 01:38:05,356 --> 01:38:07,140 a little insight on how that's 3788 01:38:07,140 --> 01:38:07,284 3789 01:38:07,284 --> 01:38:08,631 been working or what our plans 3790 01:38:08,631 --> 01:38:08,898 3791 01:38:08,898 --> 01:38:09,394 for the future? 3792 01:38:09,394 --> 01:38:11,532 >> we've been sharing some of 3793 01:38:11,532 --> 01:38:11,532 3794 01:38:11,532 --> 01:38:13,100 the efforts that we do within 3795 01:38:13,100 --> 01:38:13,100 3796 01:38:13,100 --> 01:38:15,070 the department, a couple things 3797 01:38:15,070 --> 01:38:15,070 3798 01:38:15,070 --> 01:38:18,402 like the enterprise wide 3799 01:38:18,402 --> 01:38:18,942 software before the department 3800 01:38:18,942 --> 01:38:19,584 3801 01:38:19,584 --> 01:38:19,584 existed. 3802 01:38:19,584 --> 01:38:21,298 there wasn't anyone else to 3803 01:38:21,298 --> 01:38:22,309 maintain and carry it forward. 3804 01:38:22,309 --> 01:38:22,309 3805 01:38:22,309 --> 01:38:24,050 we've been holding the torch f 3806 01:38:24,050 --> 01:38:24,050 or 3807 01:38:24,050 --> 01:38:26,175 a couple of the enterprise 3808 01:38:26,175 --> 01:38:26,175 contracts. 3809 01:38:26,175 --> 01:38:28,417 hoping to eventually be able t 3810 01:38:28,417 --> 01:38:28,686 o 3811 01:38:28,686 --> 01:38:30,192 turn them over to them, once 3812 01:38:30,192 --> 01:38:34,316 they start picking up on that we 3813 01:38:34,316 --> 01:38:34,316 3814 01:38:34,316 --> 01:38:39,358 don't overlap with what gru I. 3815 01:38:39,358 --> 01:38:39,358 t. 3816 01:38:39,358 --> 01:38:42,030 does, it may not be on the 3817 01:38:42,030 --> 01:38:43,774 horizon for that group yet, 3818 01:38:43,774 --> 01:38:45,147 until they take over all of 3819 01:38:45,147 --> 01:38:45,842 those duties. 3820 01:38:45,842 --> 01:38:47,569 >> that is kind of where I was 3821 01:38:47,569 --> 01:38:47,937 3822 01:38:47,937 --> 01:38:48,208 getting at. 3823 01:38:48,208 --> 01:38:51,550 the gru things, very clearly w 3824 01:38:51,550 --> 01:38:51,840 e 3825 01:38:51,840 --> 01:38:54,010 think a plan or it's the scope 3826 01:38:54,010 --> 01:38:54,542 3827 01:38:54,542 --> 01:38:58,012 of director nagy, the nongri, I 3828 01:38:58,012 --> 01:38:58,526 3829 01:38:58,526 --> 01:39:00,582 was a little less aware of wha 3830 01:39:00,582 --> 01:39:00,723 t 3831 01:39:00,723 --> 01:39:03,382 our plans are for the non-gru 3832 01:39:03,382 --> 01:39:03,382 3833 01:39:03,382 --> 01:39:04,902 items, you've been holding dow 3834 01:39:04,902 --> 01:39:05,033 n 3835 01:39:05,033 --> 01:39:06,304 our other departments where 3836 01:39:06,304 --> 01:39:07,400 there's some opportunities, 3837 01:39:07,400 --> 01:39:08,796 perhaps where it's easier or 3838 01:39:08,796 --> 01:39:10,588 more efficient to house them 3839 01:39:10,588 --> 01:39:13,798 under the I. Dd. Department, a 3840 01:39:13,798 --> 01:39:14,562 n 3841 01:39:14,562 --> 01:39:15,770 enterprise software that needs 3842 01:39:15,770 --> 01:39:15,898 3843 01:39:15,898 --> 01:39:16,764 to be maintained there, because 3844 01:39:16,764 --> 01:39:16,944 3845 01:39:16,944 --> 01:39:19,070 he this can be the expert on 3846 01:39:19,070 --> 01:39:19,827 maintaining, we can do the work 3847 01:39:19,827 --> 01:39:19,914 3848 01:39:19,914 --> 01:39:20,222 we need to do. 3849 01:39:20,222 --> 01:39:23,488 >> thank you. 3850 01:39:23,488 --> 01:39:26,240 >> mayor: thank you. 3851 01:39:26,240 --> 01:39:26,651 welcome back. 3852 01:39:26,651 --> 01:39:28,986 >> thank you, we're on to the 3853 01:39:28,986 --> 01:39:28,986 3854 01:39:28,986 --> 01:39:31,610 last division of our team, the 3855 01:39:31,610 --> 01:39:31,889 3856 01:39:31,889 --> 01:39:33,148 administrative team division. 3857 01:39:33,148 --> 01:39:35,288 I think of steve's team and the 3858 01:39:35,288 --> 01:39:36,438 3859 01:39:36,438 --> 01:39:40,096 demonstrative team as being the 3860 01:39:40,096 --> 01:39:40,138 3861 01:39:40,138 --> 01:39:41,064 glue that holds us all together. 3862 01:39:41,064 --> 01:39:41,064 3863 01:39:41,064 --> 01:39:43,656 the administrative team is led 3864 01:39:43,656 --> 01:39:44,138 3865 01:39:44,138 --> 01:39:45,662 by abeesag walken booth. 3866 01:39:45,662 --> 01:39:50,772 she has 18 fte's, they're 3867 01:39:50,772 --> 01:39:53,918 helping us with budget prep for 3868 01:39:53,918 --> 01:39:53,918 the 3869 01:39:53,918 --> 01:40:00,508 the 3870 01:40:00,508 --> 01:40:01,912 grant coordinator coming in 3871 01:40:01,912 --> 01:40:05,210 soon, I hope, crossing our 3872 01:40:05,210 --> 01:40:05,210 fingers. 3873 01:40:05,210 --> 01:40:07,281 grants can be challenging to 3874 01:40:07,281 --> 01:40:09,351 make sure you check all the -- 3875 01:40:09,351 --> 01:40:11,754 all the -- cross all the 3876 01:40:11,754 --> 01:40:15,620 t's, so -- and then they help 3877 01:40:15,620 --> 01:40:15,620 3878 01:40:15,620 --> 01:40:16,825 out with the supply chain. 3879 01:40:16,825 --> 01:40:19,226 they oversee one of the 3880 01:40:19,226 --> 01:40:21,114 warehouse staff helps us with 3881 01:40:21,114 --> 01:40:21,114 3882 01:40:21,114 --> 01:40:23,444 that, and then solid waste 3883 01:40:23,444 --> 01:40:24,531 customer service, which gets a 3884 01:40:24,531 --> 01:40:24,531 3885 01:40:24,531 --> 01:40:24,901 huge amount of calls. 3886 01:40:24,901 --> 01:40:32,155 their key performance 3887 01:40:32,155 --> 01:40:33,506 indicator -- I should have take 3888 01:40:33,506 --> 01:40:33,506 n 3889 01:40:33,506 --> 01:40:34,612 a drink of water before I came 3890 01:40:34,612 --> 01:40:34,838 3891 01:40:34,838 --> 01:40:35,198 back up. 3892 01:40:35,198 --> 01:40:37,056 for them, largely, we're looking 3893 01:40:37,056 --> 01:40:37,056 3894 01:40:37,056 --> 01:40:38,953 at a large number of 3895 01:40:38,953 --> 01:40:40,212 acquisitions that get processe 3896 01:40:40,212 --> 01:40:40,212 d, 3897 01:40:40,212 --> 01:40:42,752 purchase orders, around 600 per 3898 01:40:42,752 --> 01:40:43,124 3899 01:40:43,124 --> 01:40:43,124 year. 3900 01:40:43,124 --> 01:40:45,788 last year was a little low, but 3901 01:40:45,788 --> 01:40:46,019 3902 01:40:46,019 --> 01:40:46,998 we're already up for the 3903 01:40:46,998 --> 01:40:48,460 quarter, you can see we're 3904 01:40:48,460 --> 01:40:51,156 around 300 for both requisition 3905 01:40:51,156 --> 01:40:51,156 s 3906 01:40:51,156 --> 01:40:53,634 requested, and the purchase 3907 01:40:53,634 --> 01:40:55,670 orders generated. 3908 01:40:55,670 --> 01:40:57,864 they do a variety of finance 3909 01:40:57,864 --> 01:40:59,808 reports for us, and then proce 3910 01:40:59,808 --> 01:40:59,808 ss 3911 01:40:59,808 --> 01:41:04,377 thousands of invoices every 3912 01:41:04,377 --> 01:41:04,377 year. 3913 01:41:04,377 --> 01:41:06,006 and then jared and I are going 3914 01:41:06,006 --> 01:41:06,314 3915 01:41:06,314 --> 01:41:08,548 to move on to -- just some of 3916 01:41:08,548 --> 01:41:08,548 3917 01:41:08,548 --> 01:41:10,875 our emergency response 3918 01:41:10,875 --> 01:41:12,518 activities, I'll let jared -- 3919 01:41:12,518 --> 01:41:12,518 3920 01:41:12,518 --> 01:41:15,894 he's going to start first. 3921 01:41:15,894 --> 01:41:16,386 >> thank you. 3922 01:41:16,386 --> 01:41:18,789 hello again, I want to 3923 01:41:18,789 --> 01:41:20,060 apologize, I forgot to mention 3924 01:41:20,060 --> 01:41:20,358 3925 01:41:20,358 --> 01:41:22,626 one of our key strategic goals 3926 01:41:22,626 --> 01:41:22,824 3927 01:41:22,824 --> 01:41:23,856 for the land ranking. 3928 01:41:23,856 --> 01:41:24,738 we're working on. 3929 01:41:24,738 --> 01:41:26,604 we've been in collaboration wit 3930 01:41:26,604 --> 01:41:26,604 h 3931 01:41:26,604 --> 01:41:26,604 prca. 3932 01:41:26,604 --> 01:41:32,040 we come to what we feel is a 3933 01:41:32,040 --> 01:41:33,468 good place for ranking land for 3934 01:41:33,468 --> 01:41:33,706 3935 01:41:33,706 --> 01:41:33,706 purchase. 3936 01:41:33,706 --> 01:41:36,394 and we will be bringing that t 3937 01:41:36,394 --> 01:41:36,672 o 3938 01:41:36,672 --> 01:41:37,512 you for discussion and hopefull 3939 01:41:37,512 --> 01:41:37,512 y 3940 01:41:37,512 --> 01:41:37,512 approval. 3941 01:41:37,512 --> 01:41:39,998 >> mayor: very good. 3942 01:41:39,998 --> 01:41:41,340 >> on may 7th. 3943 01:41:41,340 --> 01:41:48,749 police, fire and public works 3944 01:41:48,749 --> 01:41:48,749 3945 01:41:48,749 --> 01:41:53,292 are all first responders. 3946 01:41:53,292 --> 01:41:58,230 so what kind of kicks off the 3947 01:41:58,230 --> 01:41:58,230 3948 01:41:58,230 --> 01:42:00,066 operations -- kind of kicks off 3949 01:42:00,066 --> 01:42:00,242 3950 01:42:00,242 --> 01:42:02,730 the operations, emergency 3951 01:42:02,730 --> 01:42:03,636 response here, in the may time 3952 01:42:03,636 --> 01:42:03,967 3953 01:42:03,967 --> 01:42:05,534 frame, will start doing 3954 01:42:05,534 --> 01:42:07,044 preparations where we test out 3955 01:42:07,044 --> 01:42:07,300 3956 01:42:07,300 --> 01:42:09,174 our equipment by making 10,000 3957 01:42:09,174 --> 01:42:09,812 3958 01:42:09,812 --> 01:42:12,714 sandbags, and we make 10,000 3959 01:42:12,714 --> 01:42:14,010 sandbags, we store them so tha 3960 01:42:14,010 --> 01:42:14,243 t 3961 01:42:14,243 --> 01:42:16,347 if we do get a declaration of a 3962 01:42:16,347 --> 01:42:16,347 n 3963 01:42:16,347 --> 01:42:18,116 emergency, we're not starting 3964 01:42:18,116 --> 01:42:18,116 3965 01:42:18,116 --> 01:42:20,252 from 0, because when those car 3966 01:42:20,252 --> 01:42:20,420 s 3967 01:42:20,420 --> 01:42:22,314 start lining up, if you're 3968 01:42:22,314 --> 01:42:24,156 starting from 0, you're never 3969 01:42:24,156 --> 01:42:24,156 3970 01:42:24,156 --> 01:42:25,618 ever ever going to give 3971 01:42:25,618 --> 01:42:26,288 everybody a sandbag. 3972 01:42:26,288 --> 01:42:27,964 that's what you see here on the 3973 01:42:27,964 --> 01:42:29,560 3974 01:42:29,560 --> 01:42:32,142 left, early preparations on th 3975 01:42:32,142 --> 01:42:32,324 e 3976 01:42:32,324 --> 01:42:32,632 far right. 3977 01:42:32,632 --> 01:42:34,112 those cars are coming through, 3978 01:42:34,112 --> 01:42:34,462 3979 01:42:34,462 --> 01:42:35,998 we're able to go ahead and sta 3980 01:42:35,998 --> 01:42:35,998 rt 3981 01:42:35,998 --> 01:42:37,362 handing out those bags. 3982 01:42:37,362 --> 01:42:39,666 this is also the handsout phas 3983 01:42:39,666 --> 01:42:39,666 e, 3984 01:42:39,666 --> 01:42:43,425 but with the addition of the ml 3985 01:42:43,425 --> 01:42:43,425 k 3986 01:42:43,425 --> 01:42:46,008 property where we have the 3987 01:42:46,008 --> 01:42:48,083 self-serve and we have our ski 3988 01:42:48,083 --> 01:42:48,242 d 3989 01:42:48,242 --> 01:42:49,973 steer on site, make bags as 3990 01:42:49,973 --> 01:42:49,973 well. 3991 01:42:49,973 --> 01:42:51,677 so people, if they don't feel 3992 01:42:51,677 --> 01:42:51,677 3993 01:42:51,677 --> 01:42:53,216 like waiting, they can go ahead 3994 01:42:53,216 --> 01:42:53,623 3995 01:42:53,623 --> 01:42:55,210 and fill their sandbags and we 3996 01:42:55,210 --> 01:42:55,394 3997 01:42:55,394 --> 01:42:56,212 have folks on site to assist. 3998 01:42:56,212 --> 01:43:05,092 storm rolls through, winds die 3999 01:43:05,092 --> 01:43:05,225 4000 01:43:05,225 --> 01:43:05,961 down, this is the norm. 4001 01:43:05,961 --> 01:43:08,090 you have a roadblock with the 4002 01:43:08,090 --> 01:43:08,090 4003 01:43:08,090 --> 01:43:09,652 tree in the middle of it, what 4004 01:43:09,652 --> 01:43:09,652 4005 01:43:09,652 --> 01:43:11,440 you can't see, there's power 4006 01:43:11,440 --> 01:43:12,061 lines all through that. 4007 01:43:12,061 --> 01:43:14,544 we have to wait for gru to giv 4008 01:43:14,544 --> 01:43:15,280 e 4009 01:43:15,280 --> 01:43:17,736 us the all clear, and our tree 4010 01:43:17,736 --> 01:43:17,860 4011 01:43:17,860 --> 01:43:19,346 crew strike teams will move n 4012 01:43:19,346 --> 01:43:19,346 4013 01:43:19,346 --> 01:43:21,796 take that out of the roadway, s 4014 01:43:21,796 --> 01:43:21,796 o 4015 01:43:21,796 --> 01:43:25,645 people can traverse the featur 4016 01:43:25,645 --> 01:43:25,645 e. 4017 01:43:25,645 --> 01:43:27,615 the top right picture is one 4018 01:43:27,615 --> 01:43:29,618 that took out a light pole. 4019 01:43:29,618 --> 01:43:42,633 >> we had to wait under the 4020 01:43:42,633 --> 01:43:44,769 daytime comes n we have to wai 4021 01:43:44,769 --> 01:43:45,036 t 4022 01:43:45,036 --> 01:43:47,032 for gru to clear it. 4023 01:43:47,032 --> 01:43:49,772 our nighttime crews will go out 4024 01:43:49,772 --> 01:43:49,772 4025 01:43:49,772 --> 01:43:54,282 to a tree downcall. 4026 01:43:54,282 --> 01:43:55,027 if there's no wires in it, the 4027 01:43:55,027 --> 01:43:55,241 y 4028 01:43:55,241 --> 01:43:57,494 will cut it, push it out of th 4029 01:43:57,494 --> 01:43:57,875 e 4030 01:43:57,875 --> 01:43:58,747 roadway and leave. 4031 01:43:58,747 --> 01:44:01,493 they have to get to another 4032 01:44:01,493 --> 01:44:01,493 call. 4033 01:44:01,493 --> 01:44:03,946 our alpha team or daytime team 4034 01:44:03,946 --> 01:44:04,152 4035 01:44:04,152 --> 01:44:05,886 will come in and collect the 4036 01:44:05,886 --> 01:44:08,956 tree debris they left on the 4037 01:44:08,956 --> 01:44:11,263 side of the road, and move on t 4038 01:44:11,263 --> 01:44:11,263 o 4039 01:44:11,263 --> 01:44:15,133 the next location. 4040 01:44:15,133 --> 01:44:16,671 this is one where a tree fell o 4041 01:44:16,671 --> 01:44:16,671 n 4042 01:44:16,671 --> 01:44:17,131 to a car. 4043 01:44:17,131 --> 01:44:19,934 we had to get the tree off the 4044 01:44:19,934 --> 01:44:20,234 4045 01:44:20,234 --> 01:44:22,579 car and out of the roadway, so 4046 01:44:22,579 --> 01:44:22,663 4047 01:44:22,663 --> 01:44:23,299 traffic could continue to flow 4048 01:44:23,299 --> 01:44:23,299 4049 01:44:23,299 --> 01:44:23,544 on that road. 4050 01:44:23,544 --> 01:44:31,780 >> another part of our emergency 4051 01:44:31,780 --> 01:44:31,780 4052 01:44:31,780 --> 01:44:35,692 response investigation is the 4053 01:44:35,692 --> 01:44:35,692 4054 01:44:35,692 --> 01:44:36,284 flood investigation team. 4055 01:44:36,284 --> 01:44:38,248 as I mentioned earlier, we hav 4056 01:44:38,248 --> 01:44:38,539 e 4057 01:44:38,539 --> 01:44:39,713 several creeks in the city, what 4058 01:44:39,713 --> 01:44:39,713 4059 01:44:39,713 --> 01:44:42,256 we do, as they rise, we will 4060 01:44:42,256 --> 01:44:44,169 send teams out to do what we 4061 01:44:44,169 --> 01:44:47,826 call measure downs. 4062 01:44:47,826 --> 01:44:54,096 we can later use that data to 4063 01:44:54,096 --> 01:44:55,976 terpret what storm did we 4064 01:44:55,976 --> 01:44:55,976 have. 4065 01:44:55,976 --> 01:44:57,237 is there something different w 4066 01:44:57,237 --> 01:44:57,400 e 4067 01:44:57,400 --> 01:44:59,086 should be looking at in terms o 4068 01:44:59,086 --> 01:44:59,086 f 4069 01:44:59,086 --> 01:45:01,711 storm water measures. 4070 01:45:01,711 --> 01:45:05,879 so very big effort from that 4071 01:45:05,879 --> 01:45:05,879 team. 4072 01:45:05,879 --> 01:45:09,293 I want to mention to the 4073 01:45:09,293 --> 01:45:10,584 administration efforts, as wit 4074 01:45:10,584 --> 01:45:10,921 h 4075 01:45:10,921 --> 01:45:12,529 any storm event there's a lot o 4076 01:45:12,529 --> 01:45:12,529 f 4077 01:45:12,529 --> 01:45:14,377 paperwork so we can be 4078 01:45:14,377 --> 01:45:16,224 reimbursed by fema. 4079 01:45:16,224 --> 01:45:22,450 it's a huge effort to track all 4080 01:45:22,450 --> 01:45:24,532 4081 01:45:24,532 --> 01:45:26,041 the 211s that we make during th 4082 01:45:26,041 --> 01:45:26,041 e 4083 01:45:26,041 --> 01:45:26,041 event. 4084 01:45:26,041 --> 01:45:28,614 it's a big administrative 4085 01:45:28,614 --> 01:45:31,181 effort, and they do a great job 4086 01:45:31,181 --> 01:45:31,644 4087 01:45:31,644 --> 01:45:31,830 with that. 4088 01:45:31,830 --> 01:45:34,371 the last thing we wanted to 4089 01:45:34,371 --> 01:45:36,225 mention, our special events, w 4090 01:45:36,225 --> 01:45:36,394 e 4091 01:45:36,394 --> 01:45:38,116 have a lot of special events we 4092 01:45:38,116 --> 01:45:38,162 4093 01:45:38,162 --> 01:45:40,441 part in. 4094 01:45:40,441 --> 01:45:45,551 we're currently working on 4095 01:45:45,551 --> 01:45:48,092 something with uaa and uaf for 4096 01:45:48,092 --> 01:45:48,254 4097 01:45:48,254 --> 01:45:49,356 live event assistance. 4098 01:45:49,356 --> 01:45:54,758 that may be coming through 4099 01:45:54,758 --> 01:45:55,117 pretty soon. 4100 01:45:55,117 --> 01:46:02,304 the parade efforts are very coo 4101 01:46:02,304 --> 01:46:02,304 l 4102 01:46:02,304 --> 01:46:03,345 to see. 4103 01:46:03,345 --> 01:46:05,306 and motifs, I can't forget the 4104 01:46:05,306 --> 01:46:05,608 4105 01:46:05,608 --> 01:46:06,277 guys that set it up at the 4106 01:46:06,277 --> 01:46:06,277 beginning. 4107 01:46:06,277 --> 01:46:11,809 it's really interesting to lea 4108 01:46:11,809 --> 01:46:11,809 rn 4109 01:46:11,809 --> 01:46:15,896 about some of the groups or the 4110 01:46:15,896 --> 01:46:16,191 4111 01:46:16,191 --> 01:46:18,382 people that get named for the 4112 01:46:18,382 --> 01:46:18,382 4113 01:46:18,382 --> 01:46:18,928 street naming. 4114 01:46:18,928 --> 01:46:23,096 that's been a super fun part o 4115 01:46:23,096 --> 01:46:23,140 f 4116 01:46:23,140 --> 01:46:24,464 the experience of public works. 4117 01:46:24,464 --> 01:46:24,464 4118 01:46:24,464 --> 01:46:26,059 and that is the end. 4119 01:46:26,059 --> 01:46:28,712 I would like to give a special 4120 01:46:28,712 --> 01:46:28,842 4121 01:46:28,842 --> 01:46:30,787 thank you for the leadership 4122 01:46:30,787 --> 01:46:32,226 team that support me, they are 4123 01:46:32,226 --> 01:46:32,437 a 4124 01:46:32,437 --> 01:46:34,441 fabulous group as you just 4125 01:46:34,441 --> 01:46:34,441 heard. 4126 01:46:34,441 --> 01:46:37,203 there's a lot going onon any 4127 01:46:37,203 --> 01:46:40,172 given day withteam, 4128 01:46:40,172 --> 01:46:40,694 they're always up for the 4129 01:46:40,694 --> 01:46:41,249 challenge, looking to make 4130 01:46:41,249 --> 01:46:41,770 things better in the city. 4131 01:46:41,770 --> 01:46:42,254 >> mayor: thank you. 4132 01:46:42,254 --> 01:46:53,137 >> I have several slides, the 4133 01:46:53,137 --> 01:46:53,137 4134 01:46:53,137 --> 01:46:54,488 budget for tree mitigation, 4135 01:46:54,488 --> 01:46:55,723 that's something, that's just 4136 01:46:55,723 --> 01:46:55,723 4137 01:46:55,723 --> 01:46:57,426 the full amount of the fund, a 4138 01:46:57,426 --> 01:46:57,426 nd 4139 01:46:57,426 --> 01:47:00,030 every year we roll it over as w 4140 01:47:00,030 --> 01:47:00,030 e 4141 01:47:00,030 --> 01:47:02,396 don't spend, correct? 4142 01:47:02,396 --> 01:47:06,100 or is that what we're spending 4143 01:47:06,100 --> 01:47:06,482 4144 01:47:06,482 --> 01:47:10,099 in fy '26? 4145 01:47:10,099 --> 01:47:13,392 >> I'm not sure how to get to I 4146 01:47:13,392 --> 01:47:13,392 t 4147 01:47:13,392 --> 01:47:13,392 quickly. 4148 01:47:13,392 --> 01:47:17,456 >> a budget number of 16 4149 01:47:17,456 --> 01:47:17,456 million? 4150 01:47:17,456 --> 01:47:20,980 >> 6.3 is what it said under 4151 01:47:20,980 --> 01:47:20,980 premitigation. 4152 01:47:20,980 --> 01:47:24,287 it said fund at the top, so I 4153 01:47:24,287 --> 01:47:24,287 4154 01:47:24,287 --> 01:47:25,253 imagine it's the whole fund. 4155 01:47:25,253 --> 01:47:32,178 >> I pulled that straight off 4156 01:47:32,178 --> 01:47:32,178 4157 01:47:32,178 --> 01:47:37,060 the adopted budget number 4158 01:47:37,060 --> 01:47:38,474 current fund total is higher 4159 01:47:38,474 --> 01:47:40,660 than the -- what is that current 4160 01:47:40,660 --> 01:47:40,660 4161 01:47:40,660 --> 01:47:44,903 total, 15, 16? 4162 01:47:44,903 --> 01:47:45,657 >> it's going to be, I would 4163 01:47:45,657 --> 01:47:46,375 have to double check, it would 4164 01:47:46,375 --> 01:47:46,941 4165 01:47:46,941 --> 01:47:48,679 have to be over 12 at this 4166 01:47:48,679 --> 01:47:51,876 point, I would have to double 4167 01:47:51,876 --> 01:47:51,876 4168 01:47:51,876 --> 01:47:51,876 check. 4169 01:47:51,876 --> 01:47:53,583 >> is that what we're planning 4170 01:47:53,583 --> 01:47:55,513 4171 01:47:55,513 --> 01:47:56,318 to -- 4172 01:47:56,318 --> 01:47:58,152 >> budget expenditure for this 4173 01:47:58,152 --> 01:47:58,422 4174 01:47:58,422 --> 01:48:00,228 fiscal year, I believe fund 4175 01:48:00,228 --> 01:48:03,588 balance at the end of last 4176 01:48:03,588 --> 01:48:06,563 fiscal year was in the 15 dolla 4177 01:48:06,563 --> 01:48:06,563 r 4178 01:48:06,563 --> 01:48:06,563 range. 4179 01:48:06,563 --> 01:48:09,028 >> it's a big number, I was 4180 01:48:09,028 --> 01:48:10,132 remembering a bigger number, I 4181 01:48:10,132 --> 01:48:10,429 4182 01:48:10,429 --> 01:48:11,707 was trying to remember if 4183 01:48:11,707 --> 01:48:13,279 that -- if we don't close on a 4184 01:48:13,279 --> 01:48:13,667 4185 01:48:13,667 --> 01:48:15,237 property, we didn't manage it, 4186 01:48:15,237 --> 01:48:16,067 4187 01:48:16,067 --> 01:48:17,819 rollover to the next year, 4188 01:48:17,819 --> 01:48:19,774 hopefully, that's just one 4189 01:48:19,774 --> 01:48:21,152 where -- I just wanted to have 4190 01:48:21,152 --> 01:48:21,152 4191 01:48:21,152 --> 01:48:21,884 the understanding. 4192 01:48:21,884 --> 01:48:22,339 thank you. 4193 01:48:22,339 --> 01:48:26,190 and then a deeper question abo 4194 01:48:26,190 --> 01:48:26,190 ut 4195 01:48:26,190 --> 01:48:27,694 under facilities manager, they 4196 01:48:27,694 --> 01:48:28,346 4197 01:48:28,346 --> 01:48:29,851 talked about custodial, we had 4198 01:48:29,851 --> 01:48:30,058 4199 01:48:30,058 --> 01:48:32,715 the conversation last week, 4200 01:48:32,715 --> 01:48:33,527 about who cleans what 4201 01:48:33,527 --> 01:48:34,931 facilities, and because the -- 4202 01:48:34,931 --> 01:48:35,121 4203 01:48:35,121 --> 01:48:37,969 one of the potential bills for 4204 01:48:37,969 --> 01:48:38,058 4205 01:48:38,058 --> 01:48:41,730 property tax amendment propose 4206 01:48:41,730 --> 01:48:44,434 d 4207 01:48:44,434 --> 01:48:47,340 wouldn't let us -- first 4208 01:48:47,340 --> 01:48:48,824 responders or police -- is that 4209 01:48:48,824 --> 01:48:49,139 4210 01:48:49,139 --> 01:48:50,534 something where even custodial 4211 01:48:50,534 --> 01:48:50,871 4212 01:48:50,871 --> 01:48:52,206 service should come back under 4213 01:48:52,206 --> 01:48:52,840 4214 01:48:52,840 --> 01:48:54,146 public works? 4215 01:48:54,146 --> 01:48:57,752 because then we have more 4216 01:48:57,752 --> 01:48:59,382 flexibility -- if it's at all 4217 01:48:59,382 --> 01:48:59,382 4218 01:48:59,382 --> 01:49:01,910 being paid for under fire. 4219 01:49:01,910 --> 01:49:03,867 an amendment says you can't 4220 01:49:03,867 --> 01:49:05,293 touch fire's budget, well, you 4221 01:49:05,293 --> 01:49:05,525 4222 01:49:05,525 --> 01:49:07,993 know, and I don't know what the 4223 01:49:07,993 --> 01:49:08,253 4224 01:49:08,253 --> 01:49:09,655 full amendment will envision, 4225 01:49:09,655 --> 01:49:09,655 4226 01:49:09,655 --> 01:49:13,899 but just that kind of looking 4227 01:49:13,899 --> 01:49:13,899 4228 01:49:13,899 --> 01:49:15,695 ahead like do we need to plan 4229 01:49:15,695 --> 01:49:15,695 4230 01:49:15,695 --> 01:49:17,089 now to have flexibility, becau 4231 01:49:17,089 --> 01:49:17,089 se 4232 01:49:17,089 --> 01:49:18,697 the voters may pass something 4233 01:49:18,697 --> 01:49:18,697 4234 01:49:18,697 --> 01:49:22,041 that is quite restrictive in o 4235 01:49:22,041 --> 01:49:22,041 ur 4236 01:49:22,041 --> 01:49:25,397 ability to build the budget.>> 4237 01:49:25,397 --> 01:49:26,146 we're still reviewing the 4238 01:49:26,146 --> 01:49:30,250 bills, the way I read them, 4239 01:49:30,250 --> 01:49:30,986 there's -- 4240 01:49:30,986 --> 01:49:31,252 [ inaudible ] 4241 01:49:31,252 --> 01:49:32,362 firefighter in accordance with 4242 01:49:32,362 --> 01:49:32,546 4243 01:49:32,546 --> 01:49:34,611 the definition of state statut 4244 01:49:34,611 --> 01:49:34,611 e. 4245 01:49:34,611 --> 01:49:37,744 emt in coordination with the 4246 01:49:37,744 --> 01:49:38,348 state statute. 4247 01:49:38,348 --> 01:49:40,285 my initial read of it is, no, 4248 01:49:40,285 --> 01:49:40,285 4249 01:49:40,285 --> 01:49:41,624 these employees would not fall 4250 01:49:41,624 --> 01:49:41,624 4251 01:49:41,624 --> 01:49:41,910 under those definitions. 4252 01:49:41,910 --> 01:49:42,599 >> thank you. 4253 01:49:42,599 --> 01:49:48,814 >> good job on in house for 4254 01:49:48,814 --> 01:49:50,059 roadway, and storm water 4255 01:49:50,059 --> 01:49:51,241 projects engineering, it's goo 4256 01:49:51,241 --> 01:49:51,618 d 4257 01:49:51,618 --> 01:49:53,069 to have capacity within the 4258 01:49:53,069 --> 01:49:55,236 city, that's great to hear. 4259 01:49:55,236 --> 01:49:56,805 and then technology. 4260 01:49:56,805 --> 01:49:59,301 and then on page 68 there's som 4261 01:49:59,301 --> 01:49:59,301 e 4262 01:49:59,301 --> 01:50:02,372 budget numbers for, I think, fy 4263 01:50:02,372 --> 01:50:02,776 4264 01:50:02,776 --> 01:50:05,548 '24 that ended in 0, numbers 4265 01:50:05,548 --> 01:50:06,852 that end in 0 aren't real. 4266 01:50:06,852 --> 01:50:09,496 I will follow up on that 4267 01:50:09,496 --> 01:50:09,496 privately. 4268 01:50:09,496 --> 01:50:11,490 >> mayor: thank you so much. 4269 01:50:11,490 --> 01:50:14,016 commissioner chestnut? 4270 01:50:14,016 --> 01:50:16,561 >> I want to compliment you and 4271 01:50:16,561 --> 01:50:16,756 4272 01:50:16,756 --> 01:50:17,966 your staff on the excellent and 4273 01:50:17,966 --> 01:50:18,425 4274 01:50:18,425 --> 01:50:18,965 efficient job you do, in 4275 01:50:18,965 --> 01:50:20,507 delivering service. 4276 01:50:20,507 --> 01:50:22,561 you are a very good face for t 4277 01:50:22,561 --> 01:50:22,561 he 4278 01:50:22,561 --> 01:50:26,273 city, very friendly face, your 4279 01:50:26,273 --> 01:50:26,402 4280 01:50:26,402 --> 01:50:27,830 sidewalk people, your streets 4281 01:50:27,830 --> 01:50:27,830 4282 01:50:27,830 --> 01:50:29,108 people are out there, and peopl 4283 01:50:29,108 --> 01:50:29,108 e 4284 01:50:29,108 --> 01:50:30,055 really appreciate the work tha 4285 01:50:30,055 --> 01:50:30,149 t 4286 01:50:30,149 --> 01:50:30,287 is done. 4287 01:50:30,287 --> 01:50:35,777 and I can't believe 76 request 4288 01:50:35,777 --> 01:50:37,072 s 4289 01:50:37,072 --> 01:50:37,276 per day. 4290 01:50:37,276 --> 01:50:37,595 that's a lot. 4291 01:50:37,595 --> 01:50:38,461 so thank you. 4292 01:50:38,461 --> 01:50:39,031 thank you for your service. 4293 01:50:39,031 --> 01:50:39,419 >> thank you. 4294 01:50:39,419 --> 01:50:43,684 >> mayor: commissioner chestnut, 4295 01:50:43,684 --> 01:50:43,684 4296 01:50:43,684 --> 01:50:45,213 commissioner duncan walker? 4297 01:50:45,213 --> 01:50:46,956 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 4298 01:50:46,956 --> 01:50:49,422 and thank you, miss mowry and 4299 01:50:49,422 --> 01:50:49,422 4300 01:50:49,422 --> 01:50:50,936 staff for really good and 4301 01:50:50,936 --> 01:50:52,513 informative presentation. 4302 01:50:52,513 --> 01:50:57,028 I want to start off with a 4303 01:50:57,028 --> 01:50:57,028 compliment. 4304 01:50:57,028 --> 01:51:01,876 a group from public works was 4305 01:51:01,876 --> 01:51:01,876 4306 01:51:01,876 --> 01:51:06,440 traveling down a particular roa 4307 01:51:06,440 --> 01:51:06,440 d 4308 01:51:06,440 --> 01:51:07,326 where my mother engaged with 4309 01:51:07,326 --> 01:51:07,326 them. 4310 01:51:07,326 --> 01:51:10,343 she shared this with me. 4311 01:51:10,343 --> 01:51:12,242 she had a wonderful experience 4312 01:51:12,242 --> 01:51:16,446 4313 01:51:16,446 --> 01:51:17,955 with the tree crew I want to 4314 01:51:17,955 --> 01:51:19,752 shout them out and say what a 4315 01:51:19,752 --> 01:51:19,752 4316 01:51:19,752 --> 01:51:20,690 great service they provided. 4317 01:51:20,690 --> 01:51:22,489 tree limbs were over into a 4318 01:51:22,489 --> 01:51:25,481 particular yard. 4319 01:51:25,481 --> 01:51:27,100 and that's not what they were 4320 01:51:27,100 --> 01:51:27,100 4321 01:51:27,100 --> 01:51:27,761 out there to do. 4322 01:51:27,761 --> 01:51:30,808 but they responded in the mom 4323 01:51:30,808 --> 01:51:34,154 to the neighbors, and took car 4324 01:51:34,154 --> 01:51:34,238 e 4325 01:51:34,238 --> 01:51:36,103 of some tree limbs and some 4326 01:51:36,103 --> 01:51:37,984 debris that had fallen into 4327 01:51:37,984 --> 01:51:39,336 neighboring yards, thank you 4328 01:51:39,336 --> 01:51:41,469 very much for a responsive, 4329 01:51:41,469 --> 01:51:42,116 professional and kind team. 4330 01:51:42,116 --> 01:51:42,529 thank you. 4331 01:51:42,529 --> 01:51:44,716 I have maybe two questions, I 4332 01:51:44,716 --> 01:51:44,716 4333 01:51:44,716 --> 01:51:44,716 believe. 4334 01:51:44,716 --> 01:51:53,322 back to page 7 where your slide 4335 01:51:53,322 --> 01:51:53,506 4336 01:51:53,506 --> 01:51:57,924 is with regards to the budget. 4337 01:51:57,924 --> 01:51:57,924 4338 01:51:57,924 --> 01:52:00,095 I believe there was a number o 4339 01:52:00,095 --> 01:52:00,463 f 4340 01:52:00,463 --> 01:52:02,104 $2 million that's allotted for 4341 01:52:02,104 --> 01:52:03,933 4342 01:52:03,933 --> 01:52:03,933 resurfacing. 4343 01:52:03,933 --> 01:52:05,904 and my question is just this, I 4344 01:52:05,904 --> 01:52:06,040 4345 01:52:06,040 --> 01:52:08,370 know we do the resurfacing out 4346 01:52:08,370 --> 01:52:08,598 4347 01:52:08,598 --> 01:52:09,699 at the gas tax as well. 4348 01:52:09,699 --> 01:52:11,173 that number is different from 4349 01:52:11,173 --> 01:52:11,173 4350 01:52:11,173 --> 01:52:11,173 this. 4351 01:52:11,173 --> 01:52:15,260 these are two separate pots of 4352 01:52:15,260 --> 01:52:15,260 4353 01:52:15,260 --> 01:52:16,740 money we chose, where we do our 4354 01:52:16,740 --> 01:52:17,579 4355 01:52:17,579 --> 01:52:17,931 resurfacing from? 4356 01:52:17,931 --> 01:52:21,498 >> yes, we have a pavement 4357 01:52:21,498 --> 01:52:22,304 preservation program, every 4358 01:52:22,304 --> 01:52:24,525 year, the plan is for us to -- 4359 01:52:24,525 --> 01:52:24,614 4360 01:52:24,614 --> 01:52:24,886 on newer roads. 4361 01:52:24,886 --> 01:52:31,546 we'll use rejuvenator product. 4362 01:52:31,546 --> 01:52:31,546 4363 01:52:31,546 --> 01:52:35,023 that helps extend the life of 4364 01:52:35,023 --> 01:52:35,023 4365 01:52:35,023 --> 01:52:35,996 that newer section of road. 4366 01:52:35,996 --> 01:52:37,902 we'll look at other roads, 4367 01:52:37,902 --> 01:52:39,406 that's where he mentioned the 4368 01:52:39,406 --> 01:52:39,406 4369 01:52:39,406 --> 01:52:42,470 dot software, which we're now 4370 01:52:42,470 --> 01:52:42,470 4371 01:52:42,470 --> 01:52:44,205 using, it will predict out wha 4372 01:52:44,205 --> 01:52:44,378 t 4373 01:52:44,378 --> 01:52:48,971 we need to do in terms of road 4374 01:52:48,971 --> 01:52:48,971 4375 01:52:48,971 --> 01:52:48,971 maintenance. 4376 01:52:48,971 --> 01:52:52,614 which roads do we need to look 4377 01:52:52,614 --> 01:52:53,121 4378 01:52:53,121 --> 01:52:53,512 at -- 4379 01:52:53,512 --> 01:52:53,826 [ inaudible ] 4380 01:52:53,826 --> 01:52:56,411 and we set aside a certain 4381 01:52:56,411 --> 01:52:57,952 amount of money for that, which 4382 01:52:57,952 --> 01:52:58,279 4383 01:52:58,279 --> 01:52:59,390 will involve some sort of 4384 01:52:59,390 --> 01:53:01,150 repaving, and we also have par 4385 01:53:01,150 --> 01:53:01,440 t 4386 01:53:01,440 --> 01:53:04,128 of that 2 million, we'll have 4387 01:53:04,128 --> 01:53:04,128 4388 01:53:04,128 --> 01:53:05,630 associated concrete work, 4389 01:53:05,630 --> 01:53:06,597 whether it's curb or ada ramp 4390 01:53:06,597 --> 01:53:06,597 4391 01:53:06,597 --> 01:53:06,597 maybe. 4392 01:53:06,597 --> 01:53:16,105 >> yes, that's correct, exactly 4393 01:53:16,105 --> 01:53:16,321 4394 01:53:16,321 --> 01:53:16,932 what we were saying. 4395 01:53:16,932 --> 01:53:19,176 the $2 million here for roadway 4396 01:53:19,176 --> 01:53:19,956 4397 01:53:19,956 --> 01:53:21,143 resurfacing, is a transfer fro 4398 01:53:21,143 --> 01:53:21,945 m 4399 01:53:21,945 --> 01:53:26,010 solid waste for damage done by 4400 01:53:26,010 --> 01:53:26,253 4401 01:53:26,253 --> 01:53:26,847 the trash trucks. 4402 01:53:26,847 --> 01:53:28,553 this comes from the solid waste 4403 01:53:28,553 --> 01:53:28,718 4404 01:53:28,718 --> 01:53:32,226 and transfers to the roadways. 4405 01:53:32,226 --> 01:53:32,226 4406 01:53:32,226 --> 01:53:35,017 >> thank you very much for that 4407 01:53:35,017 --> 01:53:35,017 . 4408 01:53:35,017 --> 01:53:36,627 this software that we have, am 4409 01:53:36,627 --> 01:53:36,894 I 4410 01:53:36,894 --> 01:53:38,561 hearing that the software is 4411 01:53:38,561 --> 01:53:40,798 doing the prioritization of th 4412 01:53:40,798 --> 01:53:41,327 e 4413 01:53:41,327 --> 01:53:41,327 streets? 4414 01:53:41,327 --> 01:53:43,233 or how are we prioritizing? 4415 01:53:43,233 --> 01:53:46,501 >> yes, so we -- basically, the 4416 01:53:46,501 --> 01:53:46,639 4417 01:53:46,639 --> 01:53:49,233 first cut at it, our pavement 4418 01:53:49,233 --> 01:53:49,233 4419 01:53:49,233 --> 01:53:49,839 condition index. 4420 01:53:49,839 --> 01:53:52,015 the pci, what's the rating of 4421 01:53:52,015 --> 01:53:52,015 4422 01:53:52,015 --> 01:53:52,303 the road. 4423 01:53:52,303 --> 01:53:57,343 we also have the sbi, the socia 4424 01:53:57,343 --> 01:53:57,343 l 4425 01:53:57,343 --> 01:53:59,745 vulnerability index is also put 4426 01:53:59,745 --> 01:54:00,102 4427 01:54:00,102 --> 01:54:03,823 into that scenario, so it's a - 4428 01:54:03,823 --> 01:54:03,823 - 4429 01:54:03,823 --> 01:54:06,587 in the end, it's 80% functional 4430 01:54:06,587 --> 01:54:06,927 4431 01:54:06,927 --> 01:54:09,365 class, and pci is factored int 4432 01:54:09,365 --> 01:54:09,829 o 4433 01:54:09,829 --> 01:54:12,112 that and 20% sbi to determine 4434 01:54:12,112 --> 01:54:12,112 4435 01:54:12,112 --> 01:54:14,558 what we call the krit kalety 4436 01:54:14,558 --> 01:54:14,558 score. 4437 01:54:14,558 --> 01:54:17,705 and then what the team will do 4438 01:54:17,705 --> 01:54:17,885 4439 01:54:17,885 --> 01:54:18,162 from there. 4440 01:54:18,162 --> 01:54:20,669 we look at it on a map, and loo 4441 01:54:20,669 --> 01:54:20,669 k 4442 01:54:20,669 --> 01:54:22,832 at it in the field to assess, 4443 01:54:22,832 --> 01:54:22,832 4444 01:54:22,832 --> 01:54:24,112 and make sure that what's being 4445 01:54:24,112 --> 01:54:25,305 4446 01:54:25,305 --> 01:54:26,346 predicted by the program is wha 4447 01:54:26,346 --> 01:54:26,346 t 4448 01:54:26,346 --> 01:54:29,109 we should be doing, and so 4449 01:54:29,109 --> 01:54:31,949 generally speaking, as we use 4450 01:54:31,949 --> 01:54:31,949 4451 01:54:31,949 --> 01:54:33,517 this program multiple years in 4452 01:54:33,517 --> 01:54:33,648 a 4453 01:54:33,648 --> 01:54:36,151 row, it will become more 4454 01:54:36,151 --> 01:54:37,679 predictable, we will be able to 4455 01:54:37,679 --> 01:54:37,816 4456 01:54:37,816 --> 01:54:39,991 better set or just, where we s 4457 01:54:39,991 --> 01:54:39,991 ee 4458 01:54:39,991 --> 01:54:42,284 there may be an error in the 4459 01:54:42,284 --> 01:54:42,284 program. 4460 01:54:42,284 --> 01:54:43,992 it's brand program for us, and 4461 01:54:43,992 --> 01:54:44,120 4462 01:54:44,120 --> 01:54:45,362 we're still working out some o 4463 01:54:45,362 --> 01:54:45,407 f 4464 01:54:45,407 --> 01:54:45,766 the bugs. 4465 01:54:45,766 --> 01:54:48,587 that is the plan. 4466 01:54:48,587 --> 01:54:50,699 >> is it safe for me or this 4467 01:54:50,699 --> 01:54:51,640 commission to assume that -- I 4468 01:54:51,640 --> 01:54:51,738 4469 01:54:51,738 --> 01:54:53,801 mean, obviously, your 4470 01:54:53,801 --> 01:54:55,135 professional expertise will 4471 01:54:55,135 --> 01:54:56,573 override any glitches that you 4472 01:54:56,573 --> 01:54:56,737 4473 01:54:56,737 --> 01:54:57,299 see in the system. 4474 01:54:57,299 --> 01:54:59,724 because I mean, I -- software I 4475 01:54:59,724 --> 01:54:59,724 s 4476 01:54:59,724 --> 01:55:01,769 wonderful and it's helpful, but 4477 01:55:01,769 --> 01:55:01,975 4478 01:55:01,975 --> 01:55:05,145 there is nothing in my mind tha 4479 01:55:05,145 --> 01:55:05,145 t 4480 01:55:05,145 --> 01:55:08,093 can substitute for a human eye 4481 01:55:08,093 --> 01:55:08,211 4482 01:55:08,211 --> 01:55:12,455 on a lot of these situations 4483 01:55:12,455 --> 01:55:13,596 that hear from community et 4484 01:55:13,596 --> 01:55:13,596 cetera. 4485 01:55:13,596 --> 01:55:15,571 you all will be making final 4486 01:55:15,571 --> 01:55:16,987 decisions, and especially since 4487 01:55:16,987 --> 01:55:16,987 4488 01:55:16,987 --> 01:55:19,161 this is new, we will be relying 4489 01:55:19,161 --> 01:55:19,363 4490 01:55:19,363 --> 01:55:19,923 on you now? 4491 01:55:19,923 --> 01:55:22,069 >> what will be relying on me 4492 01:55:22,069 --> 01:55:22,069 4493 01:55:22,069 --> 01:55:22,069 now? 4494 01:55:22,069 --> 01:55:23,634 >> in other words, you're not 4495 01:55:23,634 --> 01:55:23,634 4496 01:55:23,634 --> 01:55:25,227 solely relying on the software 4497 01:55:25,227 --> 01:55:25,227 . 4498 01:55:25,227 --> 01:55:26,501 you're going to be making these 4499 01:55:26,501 --> 01:55:26,731 4500 01:55:26,731 --> 01:55:28,395 egs doeses as human beings 4501 01:55:28,395 --> 01:55:28,395 first? 4502 01:55:28,395 --> 01:55:29,503 >> that is correct. 4503 01:55:29,503 --> 01:55:32,071 we will definitely be taking 4504 01:55:32,071 --> 01:55:33,609 what the software gives us, and 4505 01:55:33,609 --> 01:55:33,871 4506 01:55:33,871 --> 01:55:35,913 then, does that make sense, and 4507 01:55:35,913 --> 01:55:36,043 4508 01:55:36,043 --> 01:55:36,371 ground truth. 4509 01:55:36,371 --> 01:55:39,185 and also look at mapping? 4510 01:55:39,185 --> 01:55:40,618 where are the numbers hitting, 4511 01:55:40,618 --> 01:55:41,084 4512 01:55:41,084 --> 01:55:43,993 and trying to make sure we stay 4513 01:55:43,993 --> 01:55:43,993 4514 01:55:43,993 --> 01:55:43,993 distributed. 4515 01:55:43,993 --> 01:55:46,081 but also, incorporating in the 4516 01:55:46,081 --> 01:55:46,081 4517 01:55:46,081 --> 01:55:46,081 sbi. 4518 01:55:46,081 --> 01:55:47,987 >> thank you. 4519 01:55:47,987 --> 01:55:50,387 >> you're welcome. 4520 01:55:50,387 --> 01:55:53,167 >> mayor: thank you, 4521 01:55:53,167 --> 01:55:53,991 commissioner duncan walker. 4522 01:55:53,991 --> 01:55:56,398 madam clerk, do we have any 4523 01:55:56,398 --> 01:55:59,343 public commeon this? 4524 01:55:59,343 --> 01:56:00,689 >> no public comment on this. 4525 01:56:00,689 --> 01:56:01,968 >> mayor: thank you all for wha 4526 01:56:01,968 --> 01:56:01,968 t 4527 01:56:01,968 --> 01:56:02,399 you do. 4528 01:56:02,399 --> 01:56:03,572 we appreciate you spending the 4529 01:56:03,572 --> 01:56:03,572 4530 01:56:03,572 --> 01:56:03,920 time with us today. 4531 01:56:03,920 --> 01:56:07,278 >> thank you. 4532 01:56:07,278 --> 01:56:08,341 >> mayor: madam clerk. 4533 01:56:08,341 --> 01:56:13,485 >> we're on to our next item, 4534 01:56:13,485 --> 01:56:13,485 4535 01:56:13,485 --> 01:56:19,857 2026-235 request to amend budge 4536 01:56:19,857 --> 01:56:19,857 t 4537 01:56:19,857 --> 01:56:23,921 for office of city auditor, to 4538 01:56:23,921 --> 01:56:24,357 4539 01:56:24,357 --> 01:56:25,657 authorize the office of 4540 01:56:25,657 --> 01:56:26,928 management and budget to amend 4541 01:56:26,928 --> 01:56:27,206 4542 01:56:27,206 --> 01:56:28,974 the city auditor's office 4543 01:56:28,974 --> 01:56:28,974 budget. 4544 01:56:28,974 --> 01:56:31,833 >> mayor: welcome mr. Auditor. 4545 01:56:31,833 --> 01:56:31,833 4546 01:56:31,833 --> 01:56:35,680 >> good morning, mr. Mayor, 4547 01:56:35,680 --> 01:56:36,709 members of the city commission 4548 01:56:36,709 --> 01:56:36,709 . 4549 01:56:36,709 --> 01:56:38,181 I'm the city auditor. 4550 01:56:38,181 --> 01:56:40,769 I do not have any presentation 4551 01:56:40,769 --> 01:56:41,371 4552 01:56:41,371 --> 01:56:44,377 slides, I don't intend for thi 4553 01:56:44,377 --> 01:56:44,643 s 4554 01:56:44,643 --> 01:56:45,075 to be long. 4555 01:56:45,075 --> 01:56:46,623 and also, prior to this meeting, 4556 01:56:46,623 --> 01:56:46,623 4557 01:56:46,623 --> 01:56:49,452 I have held one on one decisio 4558 01:56:49,452 --> 01:56:49,452 ns 4559 01:56:49,452 --> 01:56:51,891 with each and every member of 4560 01:56:51,891 --> 01:56:51,891 4561 01:56:51,891 --> 01:56:53,755 the city commission and each a 4562 01:56:53,755 --> 01:56:53,755 nd 4563 01:56:53,755 --> 01:56:55,227 every member of the city 4564 01:56:55,227 --> 01:56:57,421 commission knows my request. 4565 01:56:57,421 --> 01:57:01,937 the office of the city is 4566 01:57:01,937 --> 01:57:02,915 helping us better carry out the 4567 01:57:02,915 --> 01:57:03,003 4568 01:57:03,003 --> 01:57:03,003 office. 4569 01:57:03,003 --> 01:57:08,657 we're asking for an amount of 4570 01:57:08,657 --> 01:57:08,657 4571 01:57:08,657 --> 01:57:10,202 $45,000 to do two things. 4572 01:57:10,202 --> 01:57:11,943 we would like to be able to use 4573 01:57:11,943 --> 01:57:12,071 4574 01:57:12,071 --> 01:57:14,273 the services of private internal 4575 01:57:14,273 --> 01:57:14,273 4576 01:57:14,273 --> 01:57:15,475 audit consulting firms. 4577 01:57:15,475 --> 01:57:20,323 in this process, we go out to 4578 01:57:20,323 --> 01:57:20,323 4579 01:57:20,323 --> 01:57:23,985 ask external auditors to come I 4580 01:57:23,985 --> 01:57:23,985 n 4581 01:57:23,985 --> 01:57:26,189 and work with us on projects n 4582 01:57:26,189 --> 01:57:26,455 4583 01:57:26,455 --> 01:57:33,893 an approach we call cost 4584 01:57:33,893 --> 01:57:33,893 servicing. 4585 01:57:33,893 --> 01:57:36,585 this helps us to move along in 4586 01:57:36,585 --> 01:57:37,563 4587 01:57:37,563 --> 01:57:38,891 our -- in the incorporation of 4588 01:57:38,891 --> 01:57:38,891 4589 01:57:38,891 --> 01:57:39,383 the audit plan. 4590 01:57:39,383 --> 01:57:41,263 the other thing we'd like to be 4591 01:57:41,263 --> 01:57:41,347 4592 01:57:41,347 --> 01:57:43,171 able to do with this amendment 4593 01:57:43,171 --> 01:57:44,369 4594 01:57:44,369 --> 01:57:47,035 is to promote a member in our 4595 01:57:47,035 --> 01:57:47,035 4596 01:57:47,035 --> 01:57:48,842 office who is now a staff 4597 01:57:48,842 --> 01:57:51,445 auditor to the position of 4598 01:57:51,445 --> 01:57:53,211 senior internal auditor. 4599 01:57:53,211 --> 01:57:56,849 let me pull this up for you to 4600 01:57:56,849 --> 01:57:56,849 4601 01:57:56,849 --> 01:57:56,849 see. 4602 01:57:56,849 --> 01:58:03,465 this is the organizational cha 4603 01:58:03,465 --> 01:58:03,465 rt 4604 01:58:03,465 --> 01:58:07,321 of the city office. 4605 01:58:07,321 --> 01:58:09,805 the red that you see is the 4606 01:58:09,805 --> 01:58:11,927 senior auditor position, at thi 4607 01:58:11,927 --> 01:58:11,927 s 4608 01:58:11,927 --> 01:58:13,401 time it is not funded. 4609 01:58:13,401 --> 01:58:15,701 we have it, but it's frozen. 4610 01:58:15,701 --> 01:58:17,701 on this side -- what I'm tryin 4611 01:58:17,701 --> 01:58:17,970 g 4612 01:58:17,970 --> 01:58:21,045 to do is to move the staff 4613 01:58:21,045 --> 01:58:22,899 auditor from being staff audit 4614 01:58:22,899 --> 01:58:22,899 or 4615 01:58:22,899 --> 01:58:24,623 from the position to the 4616 01:58:24,623 --> 01:58:25,741 position of senior auditor. 4617 01:58:25,741 --> 01:58:27,386 he's been with us for close to 4618 01:58:27,386 --> 01:58:27,479 4619 01:58:27,479 --> 01:58:32,817 four years now. 4620 01:58:32,817 --> 01:58:34,691 he's a good auditor. 4621 01:58:34,691 --> 01:58:36,158 during the time he's been with 4622 01:58:36,158 --> 01:58:36,488 4623 01:58:36,488 --> 01:58:39,869 us, he's been able to get his 4624 01:58:39,869 --> 01:58:39,869 4625 01:58:39,869 --> 01:58:40,198 auditor qualification. 4626 01:58:40,198 --> 01:58:42,419 he's a cia internal auditor. 4627 01:58:42,419 --> 01:58:46,831 the qualification is an 4628 01:58:46,831 --> 01:58:48,519 international qualification. 4629 01:58:48,519 --> 01:58:49,801 international credential. 4630 01:58:49,801 --> 01:58:52,167 that means, wherever he goes, 4631 01:58:52,167 --> 01:58:52,167 4632 01:58:52,167 --> 01:58:53,702 he's recognized as a competent 4633 01:58:53,702 --> 01:58:54,034 4634 01:58:54,034 --> 01:58:54,034 auditor. 4635 01:58:54,034 --> 01:58:58,483 I would like to ask you to 4636 01:58:58,483 --> 01:59:00,056 unfreeze the senior auditor 4637 01:59:00,056 --> 01:59:05,749 position, to enable me to move 4638 01:59:05,749 --> 01:59:06,818 4639 01:59:06,818 --> 01:59:10,719 the stuff into that, I would a 4640 01:59:10,719 --> 01:59:10,719 sk 4641 01:59:10,719 --> 01:59:13,693 you to freeze the staff auditor 4642 01:59:13,693 --> 01:59:13,993 4643 01:59:13,993 --> 01:59:15,967 position that we continue to 4644 01:59:15,967 --> 01:59:15,967 have. 4645 01:59:15,967 --> 01:59:17,755 one that is not funded but 4646 01:59:17,755 --> 01:59:18,279 available to us at any time. 4647 01:59:18,279 --> 01:59:25,599 I would like to mention, again, 4648 01:59:25,599 --> 01:59:25,985 4649 01:59:25,985 --> 01:59:27,343 I mention that we're asking for 4650 01:59:27,343 --> 01:59:29,678 4651 01:59:29,678 --> 01:59:29,678 $45,000. 4652 01:59:29,678 --> 01:59:36,551 this year, fiscal fy '26, my 4653 01:59:36,551 --> 01:59:39,456 office absorbed a 6% reduction 4654 01:59:39,456 --> 01:59:39,759 4655 01:59:39,759 --> 01:59:40,396 in its budget. 4656 01:59:40,396 --> 01:59:44,803 if you approve this request I'm 4657 01:59:44,803 --> 01:59:45,361 4658 01:59:45,361 --> 01:59:49,131 making now, my office will sti 4659 01:59:49,131 --> 01:59:49,131 ll 4660 01:59:49,131 --> 01:59:54,039 have absorbed 11.6% in the 4661 01:59:54,039 --> 01:59:56,599 reduction of budget from last 4662 01:59:56,599 --> 01:59:56,599 4663 01:59:56,599 --> 02:00:01,271 year, so we are still in 4664 02:00:01,271 --> 02:00:02,386 difficult budgetary times. 4665 02:00:02,386 --> 02:00:06,647 but still, 45,000 does does not 4666 02:00:06,647 --> 02:00:06,776 4667 02:00:06,776 --> 02:00:08,653 mean all of a sudden, we're not 4668 02:00:08,653 --> 02:00:12,016 4669 02:00:12,016 --> 02:00:13,617 contributing to trying to 4670 02:00:13,617 --> 02:00:14,863 ameliorate the problems we're 4671 02:00:14,863 --> 02:00:14,863 4672 02:00:14,863 --> 02:00:16,326 having in our city budgets. 4673 02:00:16,326 --> 02:00:17,656 that is the position we am be, 4674 02:00:17,656 --> 02:00:18,032 4675 02:00:18,032 --> 02:00:23,198 if you approve this 4676 02:00:23,198 --> 02:00:23,198 recommendation. 4677 02:00:23,198 --> 02:00:24,980 in the document o taking that I 4678 02:00:24,980 --> 02:00:24,980 4679 02:00:24,980 --> 02:00:26,016 have, you will find all of this 4680 02:00:26,016 --> 02:00:26,016 , 4681 02:00:26,016 --> 02:00:31,200 you will find a little bit of 4682 02:00:31,200 --> 02:00:31,200 4683 02:00:31,200 --> 02:00:35,569 some numbers that we have 4684 02:00:35,569 --> 02:00:36,943 alongside our budget office, t 4685 02:00:36,943 --> 02:00:37,243 o 4686 02:00:37,243 --> 02:00:39,449 show you how much will go towar 4687 02:00:39,449 --> 02:00:39,449 d 4688 02:00:39,449 --> 02:00:41,850 funding the senior auditor 4689 02:00:41,850 --> 02:00:42,579 position if it happens. 4690 02:00:42,579 --> 02:00:46,856 you will also find that I 4691 02:00:46,856 --> 02:00:48,197 provided some descriptions of 4692 02:00:48,197 --> 02:00:48,197 4693 02:00:48,197 --> 02:00:52,658 the jobs of senior auditor. 4694 02:00:52,658 --> 02:00:53,018 staff auditor. 4695 02:00:53,018 --> 02:01:01,436 you have it with you, other tha 4696 02:01:01,436 --> 02:01:01,436 n 4697 02:01:01,436 --> 02:01:01,436 that. 4698 02:01:01,436 --> 02:01:03,404 unless you have any questions, 4699 02:01:03,404 --> 02:01:04,017 I 4700 02:01:04,017 --> 02:01:06,436 would like to ask for you to 4701 02:01:06,436 --> 02:01:07,472 approve my request. 4702 02:01:07,472 --> 02:01:08,859 >> mayor okay, any questions o 4703 02:01:08,859 --> 02:01:08,859 r 4704 02:01:08,859 --> 02:01:13,577 a motion or anything? 4705 02:01:13,577 --> 02:01:14,872 commissioner eastman? 4706 02:01:14,872 --> 02:01:16,916 >> yes, thank you. 4707 02:01:16,916 --> 02:01:20,258 it seems to me like we -- that 4708 02:01:20,258 --> 02:01:20,538 4709 02:01:20,538 --> 02:01:22,052 this is -- as you said, you've 4710 02:01:22,052 --> 02:01:22,425 4711 02:01:22,425 --> 02:01:23,652 split this up into two, right? 4712 02:01:23,652 --> 02:01:23,652 4713 02:01:23,652 --> 02:01:26,351 one of which is about fte's and 4714 02:01:26,351 --> 02:01:26,571 4715 02:01:26,571 --> 02:01:28,265 how you would like to structure 4716 02:01:28,265 --> 02:01:28,661 4717 02:01:28,661 --> 02:01:30,971 your fte's internally, which I 4718 02:01:30,971 --> 02:01:31,129 4719 02:01:31,129 --> 02:01:33,501 think is a conversation that - 4720 02:01:33,501 --> 02:01:34,033 - 4721 02:01:34,033 --> 02:01:35,964 we froze about 30 positions las 4722 02:01:35,964 --> 02:01:35,964 t 4723 02:01:35,964 --> 02:01:35,964 time. 4724 02:01:35,964 --> 02:01:38,267 do we want to continue to have 4725 02:01:38,267 --> 02:01:38,398 4726 02:01:38,398 --> 02:01:40,819 those frozen, do we eliminate 4727 02:01:40,819 --> 02:01:40,819 4728 02:01:40,819 --> 02:01:43,139 these positions, how do we rig 4729 02:01:43,139 --> 02:01:43,139 ht 4730 02:01:43,139 --> 02:01:43,961 size departments. 4731 02:01:43,961 --> 02:01:45,810 having a stock of frozen 4732 02:01:45,810 --> 02:01:46,778 positions that are held year 4733 02:01:46,778 --> 02:01:48,180 over year, doesn't make a lot o 4734 02:01:48,180 --> 02:01:48,180 f 4735 02:01:48,180 --> 02:01:49,749 sense, and it would make sense 4736 02:01:49,749 --> 02:01:50,129 4737 02:01:50,129 --> 02:01:52,050 in the budget cycle to look at 4738 02:01:52,050 --> 02:01:52,282 , 4739 02:01:52,282 --> 02:01:55,528 what positions do we want 4740 02:01:55,528 --> 02:01:55,528 going-forward. 4741 02:01:55,528 --> 02:01:58,556 because we're looking at a 4742 02:01:58,556 --> 02:01:59,853 budget gap, does it make sense. 4743 02:01:59,853 --> 02:01:59,853 4744 02:01:59,853 --> 02:02:01,561 setting that to the side, the 4745 02:02:01,561 --> 02:02:01,561 4746 02:02:01,561 --> 02:02:04,512 other one is the expansion of 4747 02:02:04,512 --> 02:02:04,512 4748 02:02:04,512 --> 02:02:06,635 the auditor's ability to do mor 4749 02:02:06,635 --> 02:02:06,635 e 4750 02:02:06,635 --> 02:02:08,842 of the audits, I'll say that - 4751 02:02:08,842 --> 02:02:09,237 - 4752 02:02:09,237 --> 02:02:11,144 you have a very aggressive aud 4753 02:02:11,144 --> 02:02:11,144 it 4754 02:02:11,144 --> 02:02:13,205 plan that you guys were looking 4755 02:02:13,205 --> 02:02:13,608 4756 02:02:13,608 --> 02:02:14,410 at in increasing the 4757 02:02:14,410 --> 02:02:19,005 >> that is correct. 4758 02:02:19,005 --> 02:02:20,652 we have 10 audit topics on the 4759 02:02:20,652 --> 02:02:20,844 4760 02:02:20,844 --> 02:02:21,620 awed it the plan. 4761 02:02:21,620 --> 02:02:23,913 this time the mayor already 4762 02:02:23,913 --> 02:02:24,811 mentioned the fact that we have 4763 02:02:24,811 --> 02:02:24,811 4764 02:02:24,811 --> 02:02:26,252 some items on the consent 4765 02:02:26,252 --> 02:02:26,252 agenda. 4766 02:02:26,252 --> 02:02:28,260 two of these items are audits 4767 02:02:28,260 --> 02:02:28,260 4768 02:02:28,260 --> 02:02:28,535 that we completed. 4769 02:02:28,535 --> 02:02:29,091 >> right. 4770 02:02:29,091 --> 02:02:29,091 4771 02:02:29,091 --> 02:02:34,496 >> we are currently working on 4772 02:02:34,496 --> 02:02:34,631 4773 02:02:34,631 --> 02:02:36,725 two audits that we hope to 4774 02:02:36,725 --> 02:02:38,292 complete by june in the next 4775 02:02:38,292 --> 02:02:38,984 audit committee meeting. 4776 02:02:38,984 --> 02:02:40,899 we would like to do more. 4777 02:02:40,899 --> 02:02:42,273 we have an internal performance 4778 02:02:42,273 --> 02:02:43,070 4779 02:02:43,070 --> 02:02:45,071 metric of 85% completion of our 4780 02:02:45,071 --> 02:02:47,582 4781 02:02:47,582 --> 02:02:47,842 audit plan. 4782 02:02:47,842 --> 02:02:50,743 that is very aggressive. 4783 02:02:50,743 --> 02:02:52,314 we might not be able to hit 4784 02:02:52,314 --> 02:02:54,259 that, but we want to be able to 4785 02:02:54,259 --> 02:02:54,416 4786 02:02:54,416 --> 02:02:54,771 move towards it. 4787 02:02:54,771 --> 02:03:00,752 there are certain performance 4788 02:03:00,752 --> 02:03:00,752 4789 02:03:00,752 --> 02:03:03,920 levels that cause people to 4790 02:03:03,920 --> 02:03:04,682 wonder what's going on. 4791 02:03:04,682 --> 02:03:08,233 I'll just put it that way. 4792 02:03:08,233 --> 02:03:10,798 if you, say, complete only 50% 4793 02:03:10,798 --> 02:03:11,725 4794 02:03:11,725 --> 02:03:13,996 of your audit plan, this is jus 4795 02:03:13,996 --> 02:03:13,996 t 4796 02:03:13,996 --> 02:03:16,263 a number I'm just throwing, 4797 02:03:16,263 --> 02:03:19,108 compared to, say, 80% of the 4798 02:03:19,108 --> 02:03:20,475 audit plan, people might begin 4799 02:03:20,475 --> 02:03:20,837 4800 02:03:20,837 --> 02:03:22,838 to think -- and by people, I 4801 02:03:22,838 --> 02:03:24,475 mean industry experts, people 4802 02:03:24,475 --> 02:03:24,475 4803 02:03:24,475 --> 02:03:25,646 might think, there has to be 4804 02:03:25,646 --> 02:03:26,608 some reason why this is the 4805 02:03:26,608 --> 02:03:26,608 case. 4806 02:03:26,608 --> 02:03:30,043 when they do that and whethey 4807 02:03:30,043 --> 02:03:30,043 4808 02:03:30,043 --> 02:03:30,560 have those thoughts, when tito 4809 02:03:30,560 --> 02:03:32,518 be audited like 4810 02:03:32,518 --> 02:03:35,120 we are here, late last year, w 4811 02:03:35,120 --> 02:03:35,552 e 4812 02:03:35,552 --> 02:03:37,192 begin to look into that to fin 4813 02:03:37,192 --> 02:03:37,420 d 4814 02:03:37,420 --> 02:03:38,559 out exactly why that is the 4815 02:03:38,559 --> 02:03:38,559 case. 4816 02:03:38,559 --> 02:03:40,838 and we don't want that to 4817 02:03:40,838 --> 02:03:40,838 happen. 4818 02:03:40,838 --> 02:03:42,232 that is why we want to move as 4819 02:03:42,232 --> 02:03:43,091 4820 02:03:43,091 --> 02:03:43,964 aggressively as we can, as muc 4821 02:03:43,964 --> 02:03:44,328 h 4822 02:03:44,328 --> 02:03:44,593 as we can. 4823 02:03:44,593 --> 02:03:46,800 >> why does a gap between what 4824 02:03:46,800 --> 02:03:46,932 4825 02:03:46,932 --> 02:03:49,235 we had our audit plan versus 4826 02:03:49,235 --> 02:03:50,208 what we were able to accomplis 4827 02:03:50,208 --> 02:03:50,598 h 4828 02:03:50,598 --> 02:03:51,247 in the audit plan? 4829 02:03:51,247 --> 02:03:52,240 is that what you are saying? 4830 02:03:52,240 --> 02:03:53,138 >> that is right. 4831 02:03:53,138 --> 02:03:54,620 when auditors come, one of the 4832 02:03:54,620 --> 02:03:54,940 4833 02:03:54,940 --> 02:03:55,936 things they look at is they loo 4834 02:03:55,936 --> 02:03:55,936 k 4835 02:03:55,936 --> 02:03:57,780 at the audit plan, and they loo 4836 02:03:57,780 --> 02:03:57,780 k 4837 02:03:57,780 --> 02:03:58,748 at what you have accomplished. 4838 02:03:58,748 --> 02:03:58,748 4839 02:03:58,748 --> 02:04:02,182 they want to know if you are t 4840 02:04:02,182 --> 02:04:02,182 oo 4841 02:04:02,182 --> 02:04:04,918 far away from completing your 4842 02:04:04,918 --> 02:04:04,918 4843 02:04:04,918 --> 02:04:06,562 audit plan, they don't expect 4844 02:04:06,562 --> 02:04:06,562 4845 02:04:06,562 --> 02:04:07,324 that you complete it. 4846 02:04:07,324 --> 02:04:10,264 it's not easy, but they expect 4847 02:04:10,264 --> 02:04:10,444 4848 02:04:10,444 --> 02:04:12,190 that you heed a benchmark is 4849 02:04:12,190 --> 02:04:12,190 85%. 4850 02:04:12,190 --> 02:04:17,244 so if you are far from that 85%, 4851 02:04:17,244 --> 02:04:17,244 4852 02:04:17,244 --> 02:04:19,032 you might begin to wonder, why 4853 02:04:19,032 --> 02:04:19,200 4854 02:04:19,200 --> 02:04:20,170 is that the case? 4855 02:04:20,170 --> 02:04:22,079 and then we don't want to be I 4856 02:04:22,079 --> 02:04:22,300 n 4857 02:04:22,300 --> 02:04:22,732 such position. 4858 02:04:22,732 --> 02:04:24,336 >> right, right. 4859 02:04:24,336 --> 02:04:26,929 and so I'll just say, I mean - 4860 02:04:26,929 --> 02:04:27,105 - 4861 02:04:27,105 --> 02:04:30,245 so we had a reduction overall I 4862 02:04:30,245 --> 02:04:30,245 n 4863 02:04:30,245 --> 02:04:31,550 the administrative oversight o 4864 02:04:31,550 --> 02:04:32,147 f 4865 02:04:32,147 --> 02:04:32,844 multiple departments within the 4866 02:04:32,844 --> 02:04:33,709 4867 02:04:33,709 --> 02:04:34,983 city, right? 4868 02:04:34,983 --> 02:04:36,180 because gainesville utilities 4869 02:04:36,180 --> 02:04:36,180 4870 02:04:36,180 --> 02:04:36,844 moved out from under there. 4871 02:04:36,844 --> 02:04:39,422 so a number of departments wer 4872 02:04:39,422 --> 02:04:39,622 e 4873 02:04:39,622 --> 02:04:40,858 reduced at that time. 4874 02:04:40,858 --> 02:04:43,590 we now, I would say that gener 4875 02:04:43,590 --> 02:04:43,590 al 4876 02:04:43,590 --> 02:04:45,224 government is probably being 4877 02:04:45,224 --> 02:04:46,836 audited more so than it had in 4878 02:04:46,836 --> 02:04:46,836 4879 02:04:46,836 --> 02:04:47,922 the past because it is about 1 4880 02:04:47,922 --> 02:04:47,922 /3 4881 02:04:47,922 --> 02:04:50,226 of your overall auditing was a 4882 02:04:50,226 --> 02:04:50,349 t 4883 02:04:50,349 --> 02:04:51,526 the g.r.u. Side. 4884 02:04:51,526 --> 02:04:52,844 and then there was a reduction 4885 02:04:52,844 --> 02:04:53,028 4886 02:04:53,028 --> 02:04:54,838 in overall, but there's still, 4887 02:04:54,838 --> 02:04:54,838 4888 02:04:54,838 --> 02:04:55,451 you know, a significant amount 4889 02:04:55,451 --> 02:04:55,663 4890 02:04:55,663 --> 02:04:57,502 of resources going over the 4891 02:04:57,502 --> 02:04:57,763 general government. 4892 02:04:57,763 --> 02:04:59,841 I guess my point is, as of 4893 02:04:59,841 --> 02:05:00,904 yesterday we were six months 4894 02:05:00,904 --> 02:05:01,781 into our overall budget. 4895 02:05:01,781 --> 02:05:03,408 october 1 was when the budget 4896 02:05:03,408 --> 02:05:03,408 4897 02:05:03,408 --> 02:05:03,408 started. 4898 02:05:03,408 --> 02:05:07,508 april 1 is our six-month time. 4899 02:05:07,508 --> 02:05:07,508 4900 02:05:07,508 --> 02:05:12,320 and I could consider freezing 4901 02:05:12,320 --> 02:05:12,320 4902 02:05:12,320 --> 02:05:14,736 the one position, unfreezing 4903 02:05:14,736 --> 02:05:15,886 that position, which would put 4904 02:05:15,886 --> 02:05:16,137 4905 02:05:16,137 --> 02:05:17,530 -- it's 11,000 for the rest of 4906 02:05:17,530 --> 02:05:17,530 4907 02:05:17,530 --> 02:05:17,931 the year. 4908 02:05:17,931 --> 02:05:20,780 it's 22,000 going forward, plus 4909 02:05:20,780 --> 02:05:20,780 , 4910 02:05:20,780 --> 02:05:23,664 I'd imagine, some amount of 4911 02:05:23,664 --> 02:05:24,527 increase that would come from 4912 02:05:24,527 --> 02:05:24,527 4913 02:05:24,527 --> 02:05:25,629 cost of living. 4914 02:05:25,629 --> 02:05:27,212 but I think all of our 4915 02:05:27,212 --> 02:05:28,298 departments across the board w 4916 02:05:28,298 --> 02:05:28,346 e 4917 02:05:28,346 --> 02:05:29,370 have froze a number of 4918 02:05:29,370 --> 02:05:30,836 departments and eliminated -- 4919 02:05:30,836 --> 02:05:30,836 4920 02:05:30,836 --> 02:05:31,874 frozen a lot of positions. 4921 02:05:31,874 --> 02:05:33,338 I think everyone, we need to 4922 02:05:33,338 --> 02:05:34,810 really hold the line on trying 4923 02:05:34,810 --> 02:05:34,810 4924 02:05:34,810 --> 02:05:35,776 to say the level of service and 4925 02:05:35,776 --> 02:05:35,942 4926 02:05:35,942 --> 02:05:37,346 what we have agreed to is what 4927 02:05:37,346 --> 02:05:37,872 4928 02:05:37,872 --> 02:05:38,746 we're going to accomplish withi 4929 02:05:38,746 --> 02:05:38,746 n 4930 02:05:38,746 --> 02:05:40,142 the budget is what we're 4931 02:05:40,142 --> 02:05:41,243 agreeing to, and roll the rest 4932 02:05:41,243 --> 02:05:41,748 4933 02:05:41,748 --> 02:05:42,667 of that over into the next 4934 02:05:42,667 --> 02:05:43,124 budget year. 4935 02:05:43,124 --> 02:05:45,650 and so those are my thoughts, 4936 02:05:45,650 --> 02:05:45,650 4937 02:05:45,650 --> 02:05:46,175 mr. Mayor. 4938 02:05:46,175 --> 02:05:46,856 >> mayor: thank you. 4939 02:05:46,856 --> 02:05:47,782 commissioner eastman. 4940 02:05:47,782 --> 02:05:48,664 and commissioner book. 4941 02:05:48,664 --> 02:05:50,262 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 4942 02:05:50,262 --> 02:05:52,093 just a few questions. 4943 02:05:52,093 --> 02:05:54,892 do you know, what was the 4944 02:05:54,892 --> 02:05:56,116 position levelling that we have 4945 02:05:56,116 --> 02:05:56,462 4946 02:05:56,462 --> 02:05:57,576 this in some previous documents 4947 02:05:57,576 --> 02:05:57,933 4948 02:05:57,933 --> 02:05:59,162 of the auditor's office pre-gr 4949 02:05:59,162 --> 02:06:00,965 u 4950 02:06:00,965 --> 02:06:00,965 split? 4951 02:06:00,965 --> 02:06:02,118 how many positions was that? 4952 02:06:02,118 --> 02:06:05,679 >> so it would be 2022 and back 4953 02:06:05,679 --> 02:06:05,679 . 4954 02:06:05,679 --> 02:06:08,142 >> I believe it was seven. 4955 02:06:08,142 --> 02:06:08,910 I might be wrong. 4956 02:06:08,910 --> 02:06:10,048 maybe six. 4957 02:06:10,048 --> 02:06:12,544 but it was maybe an intention t 4958 02:06:12,544 --> 02:06:12,544 o 4959 02:06:12,544 --> 02:06:12,910 have a seventh. 4960 02:06:12,910 --> 02:06:15,314 >> I see. 4961 02:06:15,314 --> 02:06:16,020 I see. 4962 02:06:16,020 --> 02:06:17,454 I see your staff nodding their 4963 02:06:17,454 --> 02:06:17,760 4964 02:06:17,760 --> 02:06:17,760 head. 4965 02:06:17,760 --> 02:06:19,028 that is really important becau 4966 02:06:19,028 --> 02:06:19,028 se 4967 02:06:19,028 --> 02:06:20,048 what commissioner eastman is 4968 02:06:20,048 --> 02:06:21,188 talking about is when you move 4969 02:06:21,188 --> 02:06:21,316 4970 02:06:21,316 --> 02:06:23,018 different pieces away from a 4971 02:06:23,018 --> 02:06:23,928 city, we should have appropria 4972 02:06:23,928 --> 02:06:23,928 te 4973 02:06:23,928 --> 02:06:27,064 reductions to deal with the -- 4974 02:06:27,064 --> 02:06:27,342 4975 02:06:27,342 --> 02:06:28,054 but that was already done in th 4976 02:06:28,054 --> 02:06:28,054 e 4977 02:06:28,054 --> 02:06:28,960 auditor's office. 4978 02:06:28,960 --> 02:06:30,859 and as it relates to the total 4979 02:06:30,859 --> 02:06:31,280 4980 02:06:31,280 --> 02:06:33,026 figure, we're talking about 4981 02:06:33,026 --> 02:06:34,978 $45,000 across these two 4982 02:06:34,978 --> 02:06:35,604 different aspects. 4983 02:06:35,604 --> 02:06:37,942 one is for services and one is 4984 02:06:37,942 --> 02:06:38,272 a 4985 02:06:38,272 --> 02:06:40,708 percentage of a year for a 4986 02:06:40,708 --> 02:06:42,774 position upgrade is what I loo 4987 02:06:42,774 --> 02:06:43,172 k 4988 02:06:43,172 --> 02:06:43,172 at. 4989 02:06:43,172 --> 02:06:45,348 is that -- has that, the piece 4990 02:06:45,348 --> 02:06:45,610 4991 02:06:45,610 --> 02:06:47,144 related to the position, been 4992 02:06:47,144 --> 02:06:47,144 4993 02:06:47,144 --> 02:06:47,944 run through h.r.? 4994 02:06:47,944 --> 02:06:48,976 because you have already kind o 4995 02:06:48,976 --> 02:06:48,976 f 4996 02:06:48,976 --> 02:06:50,832 focused on a specific process 4997 02:06:50,832 --> 02:06:50,832 4998 02:06:50,832 --> 02:06:52,452 and upgrading a position. 4999 02:06:52,452 --> 02:06:54,006 just want to make sure, as 5000 02:06:54,006 --> 02:06:55,260 always, are we following the 5001 02:06:55,260 --> 02:06:55,684 process there? 5002 02:06:55,684 --> 02:06:58,079 and what is h.r.'s thoughts 5003 02:06:58,079 --> 02:06:58,357 about that? 5004 02:06:58,357 --> 02:07:01,898 >> yeah, and before we can sta 5005 02:07:01,898 --> 02:07:01,898 rt 5006 02:07:01,898 --> 02:07:03,412 with all this, I consulted wit 5007 02:07:03,412 --> 02:07:03,504 h 5008 02:07:03,504 --> 02:07:04,132 the h.r. Director. 5009 02:07:04,132 --> 02:07:06,959 I also consulted with the budge 5010 02:07:06,959 --> 02:07:06,959 t 5011 02:07:06,959 --> 02:07:08,532 office, and we made sure that w 5012 02:07:08,532 --> 02:07:08,532 e 5013 02:07:08,532 --> 02:07:11,200 followed the proper process. 5014 02:07:11,200 --> 02:07:13,676 and the process we are following 5015 02:07:13,676 --> 02:07:13,676 5016 02:07:13,676 --> 02:07:15,472 is within policy. 5017 02:07:15,472 --> 02:07:18,308 >> and so if this were to move 5018 02:07:18,308 --> 02:07:18,572 5019 02:07:18,572 --> 02:07:20,117 forward, there would be no iss 5020 02:07:20,117 --> 02:07:20,117 ue 5021 02:07:20,117 --> 02:07:22,490 with pre-identifying a person 5022 02:07:22,490 --> 02:07:22,490 5023 02:07:22,490 --> 02:07:23,454 who was in a position that bas 5024 02:07:23,454 --> 02:07:23,454 ed 5025 02:07:23,454 --> 02:07:26,700 on their skills and abilities 5026 02:07:26,700 --> 02:07:26,700 5027 02:07:26,700 --> 02:07:27,514 and probably the job 5028 02:07:27,514 --> 02:07:28,973 description, where the job aud 5029 02:07:28,973 --> 02:07:28,973 it 5030 02:07:28,973 --> 02:07:30,394 itself, and they would, in fact 5031 02:07:30,394 --> 02:07:30,394 , 5032 02:07:30,394 --> 02:07:32,188 be able to ascend to that 5033 02:07:32,188 --> 02:07:33,226 position and creates no problem 5034 02:07:33,226 --> 02:07:33,395 5035 02:07:33,395 --> 02:07:33,792 in the process. 5036 02:07:33,792 --> 02:07:36,014 >> absolutely. 5037 02:07:36,014 --> 02:07:36,424 >> okay. 5038 02:07:36,424 --> 02:07:40,120 well, I just -- mr. Manager, I 5039 02:07:40,120 --> 02:07:40,160 5040 02:07:40,160 --> 02:07:40,842 don't know if you want to weigh 5041 02:07:40,842 --> 02:07:41,000 5042 02:07:41,000 --> 02:07:42,670 in or should weigh in, but fro 5043 02:07:42,670 --> 02:07:42,796 m 5044 02:07:42,796 --> 02:07:44,800 a standpoint of the 45,000 rig 5045 02:07:44,800 --> 02:07:44,800 ht 5046 02:07:44,800 --> 02:07:46,472 now at the middle of the budge 5047 02:07:46,472 --> 02:07:46,706 t 5048 02:07:46,706 --> 02:07:49,481 year, and any thoughts about 5049 02:07:49,481 --> 02:07:50,973 where that would come from? 5050 02:07:50,973 --> 02:07:54,422 or what that means for us moving 5051 02:07:54,422 --> 02:07:54,422 5052 02:07:54,422 --> 02:07:56,352 on our potential finances 5053 02:07:56,352 --> 02:07:57,616 through the fiscal year? 5054 02:07:57,616 --> 02:08:01,294 >> mr. Mayor, I don't have 5055 02:08:01,294 --> 02:08:03,140 anything, I guess, specific in 5056 02:08:03,140 --> 02:08:03,418 5057 02:08:03,418 --> 02:08:06,415 terms of weighing in. 5058 02:08:06,415 --> 02:08:11,594 I do -- as the auditor 5059 02:08:11,594 --> 02:08:12,436 indicated, he has been meeting 5060 02:08:12,436 --> 02:08:12,740 5061 02:08:12,740 --> 02:08:13,234 about the budget. 5062 02:08:13,234 --> 02:08:14,686 I haven't received anything fro 5063 02:08:14,686 --> 02:08:14,686 m 5064 02:08:14,686 --> 02:08:18,318 the budget office in terms of 5065 02:08:18,318 --> 02:08:18,318 5066 02:08:18,318 --> 02:08:18,936 concern about the $45,000, and 5067 02:08:18,936 --> 02:08:19,138 I 5068 02:08:19,138 --> 02:08:20,574 think that's largely in part d 5069 02:08:20,574 --> 02:08:20,574 ue 5070 02:08:20,574 --> 02:08:23,070 to the auditor's willingness t 5071 02:08:23,070 --> 02:08:23,160 o 5072 02:08:23,160 --> 02:08:24,188 swap essentially one position 5073 02:08:24,188 --> 02:08:24,188 5074 02:08:24,188 --> 02:08:26,012 for the other in terms of 5075 02:08:26,012 --> 02:08:26,012 frozen. 5076 02:08:26,012 --> 02:08:29,180 >> just the fact we have over 5077 02:08:29,180 --> 02:08:29,180 5078 02:08:29,180 --> 02:08:31,552 1,200 employees and we've been 5079 02:08:31,552 --> 02:08:32,150 5080 02:08:32,150 --> 02:08:32,932 scrutinizing them basically 5081 02:08:32,932 --> 02:08:35,326 position by position is a reall 5082 02:08:35,326 --> 02:08:35,326 y 5083 02:08:35,326 --> 02:08:37,724 good thing in different, you 5084 02:08:37,724 --> 02:08:38,655 know, in difficult financal 5085 02:08:38,655 --> 02:08:40,102 times, that is what we've done 5086 02:08:40,102 --> 02:08:40,102 . 5087 02:08:40,102 --> 02:08:41,956 that is what has led us to 5088 02:08:41,956 --> 02:08:42,694 freeze essentially 30 positions 5089 02:08:42,694 --> 02:08:42,872 5090 02:08:42,872 --> 02:08:44,500 through the fiscal year that 5091 02:08:44,500 --> 02:08:45,636 will probably come up in other 5092 02:08:45,636 --> 02:08:46,097 5093 02:08:46,097 --> 02:08:48,738 agenda items, but just would 5094 02:08:48,738 --> 02:08:50,170 like when equal opportunity cam 5095 02:08:50,170 --> 02:08:50,170 e 5096 02:08:50,170 --> 02:08:52,938 to forest to mrak slight 5097 02:08:52,938 --> 02:08:56,196 adjustment, and we supported it 5098 02:08:56,196 --> 02:08:56,196 . 5099 02:08:56,196 --> 02:08:58,376 I'm always -- I'm hesitant to 5100 02:08:58,376 --> 02:08:58,376 5101 02:08:58,376 --> 02:09:00,277 increase things through the 5102 02:09:00,277 --> 02:09:03,252 budget year during the budget 5103 02:09:03,252 --> 02:09:03,252 5104 02:09:03,252 --> 02:09:03,252 year. 5105 02:09:03,252 --> 02:09:04,700 on the other hand, our city 5106 02:09:04,700 --> 02:09:05,881 leaders should have the ability 5107 02:09:05,881 --> 02:09:06,048 5108 02:09:06,048 --> 02:09:08,564 to make small and incremental 5109 02:09:08,564 --> 02:09:08,564 5110 02:09:08,564 --> 02:09:10,024 additions, subtractions that 5111 02:09:10,024 --> 02:09:10,905 allow them to be efficient and 5112 02:09:10,905 --> 02:09:11,120 5113 02:09:11,120 --> 02:09:12,416 tell us what they need, and I 5114 02:09:12,416 --> 02:09:12,416 5115 02:09:12,416 --> 02:09:15,624 think this is one of those 5116 02:09:15,624 --> 02:09:15,624 cases. 5117 02:09:15,624 --> 02:09:18,076 as the money comes through 5118 02:09:18,076 --> 02:09:20,204 general revenue, I would suppo 5119 02:09:20,204 --> 02:09:20,204 rt 5120 02:09:20,204 --> 02:09:20,204 it. 5121 02:09:20,204 --> 02:09:21,934 but again, we have to be looki 5122 02:09:21,934 --> 02:09:21,934 ng 5123 02:09:21,934 --> 02:09:24,468 across all positions and across 5124 02:09:24,468 --> 02:09:25,234 5125 02:09:25,234 --> 02:09:26,416 all charters actually when the 5126 02:09:26,416 --> 02:09:27,150 y 5127 02:09:27,150 --> 02:09:28,132 come before us. 5128 02:09:28,132 --> 02:09:29,304 so thank you for that 5129 02:09:29,304 --> 02:09:29,304 information. 5130 02:09:29,304 --> 02:09:32,942 >> thank you, commissioner book 5131 02:09:32,942 --> 02:09:32,942 . 5132 02:09:32,942 --> 02:09:34,278 commissioner duncan-walker. 5133 02:09:34,278 --> 02:09:36,352 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 5134 02:09:36,352 --> 02:09:37,686 thank you for being very, very 5135 02:09:37,686 --> 02:09:38,006 5136 02:09:38,006 --> 02:09:39,916 thorough and making sure you 5137 02:09:39,916 --> 02:09:41,163 covered many, if not all, of th 5138 02:09:41,163 --> 02:09:41,163 e 5139 02:09:41,163 --> 02:09:42,656 bases in regards to speaking 5140 02:09:42,656 --> 02:09:43,920 with h.r., speaking to budgeting 5141 02:09:43,920 --> 02:09:43,920 5142 02:09:43,920 --> 02:09:45,587 so that you could come to us 5143 02:09:45,587 --> 02:09:46,401 with something that was not hal 5144 02:09:46,401 --> 02:09:46,401 f 5145 02:09:46,401 --> 02:09:48,836 baked but very well thought ou 5146 02:09:48,836 --> 02:09:48,836 t. 5147 02:09:48,836 --> 02:09:53,632 I do remember our conversation 5148 02:09:53,632 --> 02:09:54,192 , 5149 02:09:54,192 --> 02:09:54,900 and I could appreciate your 5150 02:09:54,900 --> 02:09:56,234 level of thoroughness then jus 5151 02:09:56,234 --> 02:09:56,436 t 5152 02:09:56,436 --> 02:09:57,202 as I appreciate it today. 5153 02:09:57,202 --> 02:10:00,070 I think this is a reasonable 5154 02:10:00,070 --> 02:10:00,070 request. 5155 02:10:00,070 --> 02:10:02,678 and I think the ability of you 5156 02:10:02,678 --> 02:10:02,838 5157 02:10:02,838 --> 02:10:04,340 to be having to trade off a 5158 02:10:04,340 --> 02:10:06,518 position is something that I 5159 02:10:06,518 --> 02:10:08,852 consider very, very important. 5160 02:10:08,852 --> 02:10:08,852 5161 02:10:08,852 --> 02:10:10,516 I think that the request is 5162 02:10:10,516 --> 02:10:11,242 small. 5163 02:10:11,242 --> 02:10:12,576 it's reasonable considering what 5164 02:10:12,576 --> 02:10:12,576 5165 02:10:12,576 --> 02:10:13,798 it is that your office has to 5166 02:10:13,798 --> 02:10:13,798 5167 02:10:13,798 --> 02:10:15,422 do, and I support it. 5168 02:10:15,422 --> 02:10:15,806 thank you. 5169 02:10:15,806 --> 02:10:17,288 >> mayor: thank you, 5170 02:10:17,288 --> 02:10:17,966 commissioner duncan-walker. 5171 02:10:17,966 --> 02:10:19,326 commissioner chestnut. 5172 02:10:19,326 --> 02:10:24,866 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 5173 02:10:24,866 --> 02:10:27,128 I support the $11,000 towards 5174 02:10:27,128 --> 02:10:27,128 5175 02:10:27,128 --> 02:10:30,935 your staff, your senior staff 5176 02:10:30,935 --> 02:10:30,935 5177 02:10:30,935 --> 02:10:30,935 auditor. 5178 02:10:30,935 --> 02:10:32,420 where I have the concern is wit 5179 02:10:32,420 --> 02:10:32,420 h 5180 02:10:32,420 --> 02:10:38,067 the, I guess the overall $33,00 5181 02:10:38,067 --> 02:10:38,067 0 5182 02:10:38,067 --> 02:10:38,067 increase. 5183 02:10:38,067 --> 02:10:46,882 now, prior to this year, this 5184 02:10:46,882 --> 02:10:46,882 5185 02:10:46,882 --> 02:10:48,860 year I'll say, for average 5186 02:10:48,860 --> 02:10:50,186 number of audits was at six? 5187 02:10:50,186 --> 02:10:53,594 >> I would say we moved from 5188 02:10:53,594 --> 02:10:54,390 five, six, sometimes four. 5189 02:10:54,390 --> 02:10:55,860 >> but it wasn't 10. 5190 02:10:55,860 --> 02:10:56,692 it wasn't 10. 5191 02:10:56,692 --> 02:10:58,326 >> I don't remember it ever 5192 02:10:58,326 --> 02:10:58,690 being 10. 5193 02:10:58,690 --> 02:10:59,761 >> no. 5194 02:10:59,761 --> 02:11:01,014 it was not 10. 5195 02:11:01,014 --> 02:11:04,973 I think we had a reduction whe 5196 02:11:04,973 --> 02:11:05,098 n 5197 02:11:05,098 --> 02:11:07,419 we moved from having g.r.u. Plu 5198 02:11:07,419 --> 02:11:07,419 s 5199 02:11:07,419 --> 02:11:09,277 general government, and then I 5200 02:11:09,277 --> 02:11:09,320 5201 02:11:09,320 --> 02:11:13,886 think you went up from six to 5202 02:11:13,886 --> 02:11:13,886 5203 02:11:13,886 --> 02:11:13,886 10. 5204 02:11:13,886 --> 02:11:17,916 while that's very ambitious and 5205 02:11:17,916 --> 02:11:18,138 5206 02:11:18,138 --> 02:11:20,221 I appreciate that, I think tha 5207 02:11:20,221 --> 02:11:20,498 t 5208 02:11:20,498 --> 02:11:23,860 that's what's causing the 5209 02:11:23,860 --> 02:11:24,375 increase here. 5210 02:11:24,375 --> 02:11:30,396 so I would support the 11,000. 5211 02:11:30,396 --> 02:11:30,396 5212 02:11:30,396 --> 02:11:32,596 I can't support 44,000. 5213 02:11:32,596 --> 02:11:35,506 >> thank you, commissioner 5214 02:11:35,506 --> 02:11:35,506 willits. 5215 02:11:35,506 --> 02:11:38,068 >> mayor: thank you, mr. Mayor. 5216 02:11:38,068 --> 02:11:38,068 5217 02:11:38,068 --> 02:11:42,290 I think the fte kind of swap I 5218 02:11:42,290 --> 02:11:42,809 s 5219 02:11:42,809 --> 02:11:42,809 great. 5220 02:11:42,809 --> 02:11:45,592 I think it makes sense partial 5221 02:11:45,592 --> 02:11:45,592 ly 5222 02:11:45,592 --> 02:11:47,680 because through some budgeting 5223 02:11:47,680 --> 02:11:48,408 5224 02:11:48,408 --> 02:11:50,354 cuts, we were -- I think as I 5225 02:11:50,354 --> 02:11:50,354 5226 02:11:50,354 --> 02:11:52,956 remember, some of the practice 5227 02:11:52,956 --> 02:11:53,401 5228 02:11:53,401 --> 02:11:55,250 was that sometimes an open 5229 02:11:55,250 --> 02:11:58,364 position is what we kept froze 5230 02:11:58,364 --> 02:11:58,890 5231 02:11:58,890 --> 02:11:59,566 or it was cut. 5232 02:11:59,566 --> 02:12:02,967 as opposed to firing someone 5233 02:12:02,967 --> 02:12:04,524 from a lower position and then 5234 02:12:04,524 --> 02:12:05,258 5235 02:12:05,258 --> 02:12:06,032 having to go through a process 5236 02:12:06,032 --> 02:12:06,334 5237 02:12:06,334 --> 02:12:09,170 of hiring an open position. 5238 02:12:09,170 --> 02:12:13,826 and so this just seems like, yo 5239 02:12:13,826 --> 02:12:13,826 u 5240 02:12:13,826 --> 02:12:16,043 know -- this makes a lot of 5241 02:12:16,043 --> 02:12:16,578 sense to me. 5242 02:12:16,578 --> 02:12:19,311 to structure your office and 5243 02:12:19,311 --> 02:12:20,811 because we just have to do it 5244 02:12:20,811 --> 02:12:20,811 5245 02:12:20,811 --> 02:12:24,022 through the fte budget process, 5246 02:12:24,022 --> 02:12:24,022 5247 02:12:24,022 --> 02:12:24,704 that makes sense. 5248 02:12:24,704 --> 02:12:26,518 partially because you've got t 5249 02:12:26,518 --> 02:12:26,805 o 5250 02:12:26,805 --> 02:12:27,491 keep your people. 5251 02:12:27,491 --> 02:12:29,262 and sometimes you really have t 5252 02:12:29,262 --> 02:12:29,262 o 5253 02:12:29,262 --> 02:12:31,131 -- as they progress in their 5254 02:12:31,131 --> 02:12:32,721 career, it makes a lot of sens 5255 02:12:32,721 --> 02:12:32,721 e. 5256 02:12:32,721 --> 02:12:33,522 that makes sense. 5257 02:12:33,522 --> 02:12:35,501 the other issue, I can 5258 02:12:35,501 --> 02:12:36,560 understand the concerns, but I 5259 02:12:36,560 --> 02:12:36,757 5260 02:12:36,757 --> 02:12:38,152 do encourage my colleagues to g 5261 02:12:38,152 --> 02:12:38,152 o 5262 02:12:38,152 --> 02:12:40,129 back and if you didn't read 5263 02:12:40,129 --> 02:12:42,507 consent agenda item 7 and 8, t 5264 02:12:42,507 --> 02:12:42,507 he 5265 02:12:42,507 --> 02:12:45,304 reports from audit, and 5266 02:12:45,304 --> 02:12:46,610 particularly some of them are 5267 02:12:46,610 --> 02:12:46,610 5268 02:12:46,610 --> 02:12:47,225 confidential because they 5269 02:12:47,225 --> 02:12:48,042 contain security issues. 5270 02:12:48,042 --> 02:12:51,949 I was very impressed by just t 5271 02:12:51,949 --> 02:12:51,949 he 5272 02:12:51,949 --> 02:12:53,934 past, those two, and one 5273 02:12:53,934 --> 02:12:54,414 previously this spring. 5274 02:12:54,414 --> 02:12:56,622 the ones I've seen this spring 5275 02:12:56,622 --> 02:12:56,622 5276 02:12:56,622 --> 02:13:00,785 and maybe it was a culminati 5277 02:13:00,785 --> 02:13:03,288 of a lot of work and the 5278 02:13:03,288 --> 02:13:05,538 findings about where managemen 5279 02:13:05,538 --> 02:13:05,718 t 5280 02:13:05,718 --> 02:13:06,301 and the office has worked with 5281 02:13:06,301 --> 02:13:06,391 5282 02:13:06,391 --> 02:13:07,506 you and identified several 5283 02:13:07,506 --> 02:13:09,925 concerns to make sure that we 5284 02:13:09,925 --> 02:13:09,925 5285 02:13:09,925 --> 02:13:14,818 can prevent future fraud or any 5286 02:13:14,818 --> 02:13:15,100 5287 02:13:15,100 --> 02:13:15,739 kind of security threat. 5288 02:13:15,739 --> 02:13:18,937 and so I just -- it reminded m 5289 02:13:18,937 --> 02:13:19,771 e 5290 02:13:19,771 --> 02:13:22,243 why you have to do these becau 5291 02:13:22,243 --> 02:13:22,243 se 5292 02:13:22,243 --> 02:13:23,677 all of our departments are bus 5293 02:13:23,677 --> 02:13:24,039 y 5294 02:13:24,039 --> 02:13:26,281 getting all their work done and 5295 02:13:26,281 --> 02:13:26,617 5296 02:13:26,617 --> 02:13:28,851 maybe that level of reflection 5297 02:13:28,851 --> 02:13:29,078 5298 02:13:29,078 --> 02:13:30,645 of process is not the first 5299 02:13:30,645 --> 02:13:32,086 thing they do, but our auditor, 5300 02:13:32,086 --> 02:13:32,448 5301 02:13:32,448 --> 02:13:33,391 that is the first thing you do 5302 02:13:33,391 --> 02:13:33,391 . 5303 02:13:33,391 --> 02:13:35,233 that's your first concern. 5304 02:13:35,233 --> 02:13:37,207 and so I want to pose a questio 5305 02:13:37,207 --> 02:13:37,627 n to m 5306 02:13:37,627 --> 02:13:39,861 to m colleagues is, was the 5307 02:13:39,861 --> 02:13:42,531 level of general government 5308 02:13:42,531 --> 02:13:43,693 audit appropriate before 2024? 5309 02:13:43,693 --> 02:13:43,693 5310 02:13:43,693 --> 02:13:45,167 we can reference the past, but 5311 02:13:45,167 --> 02:13:45,565 5312 02:13:45,565 --> 02:13:48,970 were we getting enough done? 5313 02:13:48,970 --> 02:13:52,575 and we know before fy24 going 5314 02:13:52,575 --> 02:13:52,575 5315 02:13:52,575 --> 02:13:54,209 back a few years before that, 5316 02:13:54,209 --> 02:13:54,209 5317 02:13:54,209 --> 02:13:55,141 there were issues with certain 5318 02:13:55,141 --> 02:13:55,555 5319 02:13:55,555 --> 02:13:57,619 parts of our government that l 5320 02:13:57,619 --> 02:13:57,619 ed 5321 02:13:57,619 --> 02:13:58,411 to staff transition. 5322 02:13:58,411 --> 02:14:01,787 that led to us devolving part o 5323 02:14:01,787 --> 02:14:01,787 f 5324 02:14:01,787 --> 02:14:03,313 your government away and I'm 5325 02:14:03,313 --> 02:14:05,087 talkin 5326 02:14:05,087 --> 02:14:05,087 tal 5327 02:14:05,087 --> 02:14:11,959 talking about riker house, lik 5328 02:14:11,959 --> 02:14:12,253 e 5329 02:14:12,253 --> 02:14:12,472 real concerns. 5330 02:14:12,472 --> 02:14:14,427 and more of our contracts when 5331 02:14:14,427 --> 02:14:14,627 5332 02:14:14,627 --> 02:14:16,528 we give money to a nonprofit 5333 02:14:16,528 --> 02:14:17,389 partner, that we have some 5334 02:14:17,389 --> 02:14:18,694 ability to audit a portion of 5335 02:14:18,694 --> 02:14:18,694 5336 02:14:18,694 --> 02:14:20,943 what we give to bee to kind 5337 02:14:20,943 --> 02:14:21,787 of peel back the onion and loo 5338 02:14:21,787 --> 02:14:21,917 k 5339 02:14:21,917 --> 02:14:22,877 a little bit. 5340 02:14:22,877 --> 02:14:24,573 so that is if -- if we want to 5341 02:14:24,573 --> 02:14:24,573 5342 02:14:24,573 --> 02:14:26,649 do that, but we don't want to 5343 02:14:26,649 --> 02:14:26,649 5344 02:14:26,649 --> 02:14:27,940 have a little more budget wiggl 5345 02:14:27,940 --> 02:14:27,940 e 5346 02:14:27,940 --> 02:14:29,739 room so that the auditor can 5347 02:14:29,739 --> 02:14:32,711 hire outside, we need to know 5348 02:14:32,711 --> 02:14:32,711 5349 02:14:32,711 --> 02:14:34,879 that before we even propose or 5350 02:14:34,879 --> 02:14:36,011 5351 02:14:36,011 --> 02:14:38,123 put that policy in because we 5352 02:14:38,123 --> 02:14:38,123 5353 02:14:38,123 --> 02:14:39,079 can't give them more work 5354 02:14:39,079 --> 02:14:40,851 without some more resources. 5355 02:14:40,851 --> 02:14:44,491 because we have an item coming 5356 02:14:44,491 --> 02:14:44,491 5357 02:14:44,491 --> 02:14:45,953 up in the afternoon, similar 5358 02:14:45,953 --> 02:14:47,157 dollar amount coming out of 5359 02:14:47,157 --> 02:14:49,527 proposed to be spent out of 5360 02:14:49,527 --> 02:14:50,690 excess fund balance where we 5361 02:14:50,690 --> 02:14:52,199 will talk about the ability to 5362 02:14:52,199 --> 02:14:52,525 5363 02:14:52,525 --> 02:14:55,631 audit the money we give them. 5364 02:14:55,631 --> 02:14:58,539 so I will -- it will be hard t 5365 02:14:58,539 --> 02:14:58,539 o 5366 02:14:58,539 --> 02:15:00,971 understand someone voting yes 5367 02:15:00,971 --> 02:15:00,971 5368 02:15:00,971 --> 02:15:01,579 and we want oversight over the 5369 02:15:01,579 --> 02:15:03,343 5370 02:15:03,343 --> 02:15:03,343 5371 02:15:03,343 --> 02:15:10,451 $55,000 for heartwood, but not 5372 02:15:10,451 --> 02:15:10,859 5373 02:15:10,859 --> 02:15:13,119 the money to go track and the 5374 02:15:13,119 --> 02:15:13,119 5375 02:15:13,119 --> 02:15:13,949 person potentially being part o 5376 02:15:13,949 --> 02:15:13,949 f 5377 02:15:13,949 --> 02:15:14,683 that audit process. 5378 02:15:14,683 --> 02:15:15,687 I don't know where we're going 5379 02:15:15,687 --> 02:15:15,825 5380 02:15:15,825 --> 02:15:17,225 to land on both of those, but I 5381 02:15:17,225 --> 02:15:17,473 5382 02:15:17,473 --> 02:15:18,857 just wanted to bring that up. 5383 02:15:18,857 --> 02:15:20,583 I have similar concerns about 5384 02:15:20,583 --> 02:15:20,583 5385 02:15:20,583 --> 02:15:22,395 understanding, commissioner 5386 02:15:22,395 --> 02:15:23,595 eastman, about is this 5387 02:15:23,595 --> 02:15:23,595 necessary? 5388 02:15:23,595 --> 02:15:24,640 is the volume? 5389 02:15:24,640 --> 02:15:26,880 but I will say it is hard for m 5390 02:15:26,880 --> 02:15:26,880 e 5391 02:15:26,880 --> 02:15:28,397 to make that decision right now 5392 02:15:28,397 --> 02:15:28,551 5393 02:15:28,551 --> 02:15:30,777 without using part of the trust 5394 02:15:30,777 --> 02:15:30,907 5395 02:15:30,907 --> 02:15:32,246 of the auditor to say this is 5396 02:15:32,246 --> 02:15:32,246 5397 02:15:32,246 --> 02:15:33,367 what we've been working on. 5398 02:15:33,367 --> 02:15:35,313 this is how much gamed out. 5399 02:15:35,313 --> 02:15:37,109 this is how many hours of help 5400 02:15:37,109 --> 02:15:37,273 I 5401 02:15:37,273 --> 02:15:41,213 need as opposed to I need an 5402 02:15:41,213 --> 02:15:42,715 extra position mid year. 5403 02:15:42,715 --> 02:15:43,555 thank you, colleagues. 5404 02:15:43,555 --> 02:15:45,251 thank you, mr. Mayor. 5405 02:15:45,251 --> 02:15:47,249 >> mayor: thank you, 5406 02:15:47,249 --> 02:15:47,842 commissioner willits. 5407 02:15:47,842 --> 02:15:49,017 commissioner ingle. 5408 02:15:49,017 --> 02:15:50,893 >> looking at your overall 5409 02:15:50,893 --> 02:15:54,393 chart, it looked like a pretty 5410 02:15:54,393 --> 02:15:54,861 5411 02:15:54,861 --> 02:15:55,255 tight organization. 5412 02:15:55,255 --> 02:15:58,397 so I'm assuming the work of a 5413 02:15:58,397 --> 02:15:58,397 5414 02:15:58,397 --> 02:16:01,003 senior auditor is being done 5415 02:16:01,003 --> 02:16:01,003 now. 5416 02:16:01,003 --> 02:16:03,465 it's being done by an auditor w 5417 02:16:03,465 --> 02:16:03,465 e 5418 02:16:03,465 --> 02:16:05,301 are not calling a senior 5419 02:16:05,301 --> 02:16:05,893 auditor, is that correct? 5420 02:16:05,893 --> 02:16:07,535 >> you could say that pretty 5421 02:16:07,535 --> 02:16:07,535 much. 5422 02:16:07,535 --> 02:16:09,515 our staff auditor has been 5423 02:16:09,515 --> 02:16:10,841 working very hard under the 5424 02:16:10,841 --> 02:16:13,317 supervision of our senior 5425 02:16:13,317 --> 02:16:14,480 auditor and yourself and our 5426 02:16:14,480 --> 02:16:15,679 I.t. Audit monitor. 5427 02:16:15,679 --> 02:16:18,231 we do cooperate on every audit 5428 02:16:18,231 --> 02:16:18,370 5429 02:16:18,370 --> 02:16:20,719 and we do provide that kind of 5430 02:16:20,719 --> 02:16:21,051 5431 02:16:21,051 --> 02:16:21,051 supervision. 5432 02:16:21,051 --> 02:16:23,533 when somebody becomes a senior 5433 02:16:23,533 --> 02:16:23,785 5434 02:16:23,785 --> 02:16:25,019 auditor moving from staff 5435 02:16:25,019 --> 02:16:26,057 auditor position, they need -- 5436 02:16:26,057 --> 02:16:26,221 5437 02:16:26,221 --> 02:16:28,422 they will require less 5438 02:16:28,422 --> 02:16:29,697 supervision, thereby kind of 5439 02:16:29,697 --> 02:16:32,601 allowing the other auditors to 5440 02:16:32,601 --> 02:16:32,960 5441 02:16:32,960 --> 02:16:34,061 regulate more time to other 5442 02:16:34,061 --> 02:16:34,061 projects. 5443 02:16:34,061 --> 02:16:38,315 >> that makes a lot of sense t 5444 02:16:38,315 --> 02:16:38,359 o 5445 02:16:38,359 --> 02:16:38,359 me. 5446 02:16:38,359 --> 02:16:42,214 if that will free up the other 5447 02:16:42,214 --> 02:16:42,214 5448 02:16:42,214 --> 02:16:42,842 time because this person issed 5449 02:16:42,842 --> 02:16:43,051 a 5450 02:16:43,051 --> 02:16:45,483 vanced enough in their -- is 5451 02:16:45,483 --> 02:16:46,520 advanced enough in their caree 5452 02:16:46,520 --> 02:16:47,073 r 5453 02:16:47,073 --> 02:16:48,641 they don't have to have that 5454 02:16:48,641 --> 02:16:50,294 constant oversight, then I thi 5455 02:16:50,294 --> 02:16:50,294 nk 5456 02:16:50,294 --> 02:16:51,979 if everybody was given that type 5457 02:16:51,979 --> 02:16:51,979 5458 02:16:51,979 --> 02:16:53,309 of responsibility, they would b 5459 02:16:53,309 --> 02:16:53,309 e 5460 02:16:53,309 --> 02:16:54,321 given the pay commensurate wit 5461 02:16:54,321 --> 02:16:54,451 h 5462 02:16:54,451 --> 02:16:54,451 that. 5463 02:16:54,451 --> 02:16:56,151 otherwise, we are just saving 5464 02:16:56,151 --> 02:16:56,151 5465 02:16:56,151 --> 02:16:57,897 money off the back of one 5466 02:16:57,897 --> 02:16:59,703 worker, and I am in no way in 5467 02:16:59,703 --> 02:16:59,703 5468 02:16:59,703 --> 02:17:00,009 favor of that. 5469 02:17:00,009 --> 02:17:04,465 I'm okay with this. 5470 02:17:04,465 --> 02:17:06,633 I think it's a relatively small 5471 02:17:06,633 --> 02:17:06,833 5472 02:17:06,833 --> 02:17:07,968 about of money and the charter 5473 02:17:07,968 --> 02:17:08,299 5474 02:17:08,299 --> 02:17:10,301 office coming and telling me 5475 02:17:10,301 --> 02:17:11,364 this small amount of money is 5476 02:17:11,364 --> 02:17:11,364 5477 02:17:11,364 --> 02:17:12,345 what it will take to correctly 5478 02:17:12,345 --> 02:17:12,345 5479 02:17:12,345 --> 02:17:13,541 do it, I am all right with thi 5480 02:17:13,541 --> 02:17:13,665 s 5481 02:17:13,665 --> 02:17:14,281 for myself. 5482 02:17:14,281 --> 02:17:14,281 thanks. 5483 02:17:14,281 --> 02:17:16,145 >> mayor: all right. 5484 02:17:16,145 --> 02:17:17,040 thank you, commissioner ingle. 5485 02:17:17,040 --> 02:17:17,040 5486 02:17:17,040 --> 02:17:19,575 is there any public comment, 5487 02:17:19,575 --> 02:17:19,842 madam clerk? 5488 02:17:19,842 --> 02:17:21,857 >> mr. Mayor, there is no publi 5489 02:17:21,857 --> 02:17:21,857 c 5490 02:17:21,857 --> 02:17:21,857 comment. 5491 02:17:21,857 --> 02:17:23,453 >> mayor: anyone else? 5492 02:17:23,453 --> 02:17:24,205 commissioner eastman? 5493 02:17:24,205 --> 02:17:26,451 >> I'm make a motion and if 5494 02:17:26,451 --> 02:17:27,555 someone wants to make a motion 5495 02:17:27,555 --> 02:17:27,787 5496 02:17:27,787 --> 02:17:28,133 about the seconart. 5497 02:17:28,133 --> 02:17:32,149 as I mention, I support th firspart 5498 02:17:32,149 --> 02:17:33,388 firspart that the city 5499 02:17:33,388 --> 02:17:34,659 commission authorize the [audio 5500 02:17:34,659 --> 02:17:37,363 5501 02:17:37,363 --> 02:17:37,363 disruption] 5502 02:17:37,363 --> 02:17:38,967 and authorize to amend the cit 5503 02:17:38,967 --> 02:17:39,597 y 5504 02:17:39,597 --> 02:17:42,357 auditor's budget in the amount 5505 02:17:42,357 --> 02:17:42,483 5506 02:17:42,483 --> 02:17:42,645 of $11,488. 5507 02:17:42,645 --> 02:17:44,273 >> mayor: motion and a second. 5508 02:17:44,273 --> 02:17:44,273 5509 02:17:44,273 --> 02:17:46,179 all in favor say aye. 5510 02:17:46,179 --> 02:17:46,936 any opposed? 5511 02:17:46,936 --> 02:17:47,583 all right. 5512 02:17:47,583 --> 02:17:48,803 that passes unanimously. 5513 02:17:48,803 --> 02:17:51,509 anyone want to approach the 5514 02:17:51,509 --> 02:17:51,989 other issue? 5515 02:17:51,989 --> 02:17:55,109 commissioner duncan-walker. 5516 02:17:55,109 --> 02:18:01,496 >> I vote that we apply the 5517 02:18:01,496 --> 02:18:03,453 $33,600 towards the co-sourcin 5518 02:18:03,453 --> 02:18:03,981 g 5519 02:18:03,981 --> 02:18:06,433 of a selected audit project wit 5520 02:18:06,433 --> 02:18:06,433 h 5521 02:18:06,433 --> 02:18:09,596 qualified external audit 5522 02:18:09,596 --> 02:18:10,175 consulting firms. 5523 02:18:10,175 --> 02:18:10,591 >> second. 5524 02:18:10,591 --> 02:18:11,863 >> mayor: we have a motion and 5525 02:18:11,863 --> 02:18:12,033 a 5526 02:18:12,033 --> 02:18:12,033 second. 5527 02:18:12,033 --> 02:18:13,019 any discussion? 5528 02:18:13,019 --> 02:18:13,895 commissioner eastman? 5529 02:18:13,895 --> 02:18:16,873 >> I think that any kind of 5530 02:18:16,873 --> 02:18:17,801 change in budgeting that would 5531 02:18:17,801 --> 02:18:17,926 5532 02:18:17,926 --> 02:18:19,240 change the oversaul scope, I 5533 02:18:19,240 --> 02:18:21,435 mean, I'm not a blanket opposed 5534 02:18:21,435 --> 02:18:21,565 5535 02:18:21,565 --> 02:18:21,879 to it. 5536 02:18:21,879 --> 02:18:23,181 obviously we did it in the las 5537 02:18:23,181 --> 02:18:23,403 t 5538 02:18:23,403 --> 02:18:25,629 one, but I think that is the 5539 02:18:25,629 --> 02:18:26,693 purpose of the budget process 5540 02:18:26,693 --> 02:18:26,693 5541 02:18:26,693 --> 02:18:28,713 that we do starting -- that 5542 02:18:28,713 --> 02:18:30,020 we've already started and goes 5543 02:18:30,020 --> 02:18:30,411 5544 02:18:30,411 --> 02:18:31,679 through the end of october 5545 02:18:31,679 --> 02:18:32,758 figuring out where our 5546 02:18:32,758 --> 02:18:34,571 priorities are, how that 5547 02:18:34,571 --> 02:18:35,621 balances out with other 5548 02:18:35,621 --> 02:18:37,355 positions we have frozen or not 5549 02:18:37,355 --> 02:18:37,502 5550 02:18:37,502 --> 02:18:38,723 kept frozen. 5551 02:18:38,723 --> 02:18:40,998 I am not opposed, commissioner 5552 02:18:40,998 --> 02:18:41,791 5553 02:18:41,791 --> 02:18:42,855 willits, what overall level of 5554 02:18:42,855 --> 02:18:43,025 5555 02:18:43,025 --> 02:18:45,359 service we want from our 5556 02:18:45,359 --> 02:18:46,369 administrative departments 5557 02:18:46,369 --> 02:18:49,380 versus public works, versus 5558 02:18:49,380 --> 02:18:51,199 parks, and that is what that 5559 02:18:51,199 --> 02:18:52,581 overall budget process would be 5560 02:18:52,581 --> 02:18:52,581 . 5561 02:18:52,581 --> 02:18:54,273 I am comfortable looking at the 5562 02:18:54,273 --> 02:18:54,467 5563 02:18:54,467 --> 02:18:57,545 overall scope of the audit 5564 02:18:57,545 --> 02:18:58,779 department just like I am 5565 02:18:58,779 --> 02:18:59,683 looking at everyone else durin 5566 02:18:59,683 --> 02:18:59,819 g 5567 02:18:59,819 --> 02:19:00,846 that process, not necessarily 5568 02:19:00,846 --> 02:19:00,846 5569 02:19:00,846 --> 02:19:01,217 during this one. 5570 02:19:01,217 --> 02:19:02,731 so I'll vote no on it. 5571 02:19:02,731 --> 02:19:04,711 >> mayor: thank you, 5572 02:19:04,711 --> 02:19:05,293 commissioner eastman. 5573 02:19:05,293 --> 02:19:07,055 any other comments? 5574 02:19:07,055 --> 02:19:09,033 commissioner book? 5575 02:19:09,033 --> 02:19:11,135 >> yeah, I'm similarly situated, 5576 02:19:11,135 --> 02:19:11,135 5577 02:19:11,135 --> 02:19:14,033 mr. Mayor, commissioner eastma 5578 02:19:14,033 --> 02:19:14,033 n, 5579 02:19:14,033 --> 02:19:15,241 that I think we can address tha 5580 02:19:15,241 --> 02:19:15,241 t 5581 02:19:15,241 --> 02:19:16,405 and I think that would be 5582 02:19:16,405 --> 02:19:17,105 appropriate to put that in the 5583 02:19:17,105 --> 02:19:17,398 5584 02:19:17,398 --> 02:19:20,005 middle of the fiscal year in th 5585 02:19:20,005 --> 02:19:20,005 e 5586 02:19:20,005 --> 02:19:20,998 budget process. 5587 02:19:20,998 --> 02:19:21,901 I think it would be supported. 5588 02:19:21,901 --> 02:19:21,901 5589 02:19:21,901 --> 02:19:23,097 it's reasonable. 5590 02:19:23,097 --> 02:19:24,575 it's incremental. 5591 02:19:24,575 --> 02:19:25,811 I think probably merely because 5592 02:19:25,811 --> 02:19:25,811 5593 02:19:25,811 --> 02:19:27,371 we're six months in and we nee 5594 02:19:27,371 --> 02:19:27,575 d 5595 02:19:27,575 --> 02:19:29,041 a little more clarity, we 5596 02:19:29,041 --> 02:19:30,141 probably shouldn't do that at 5597 02:19:30,141 --> 02:19:30,141 5598 02:19:30,141 --> 02:19:30,713 this point. 5599 02:19:30,713 --> 02:19:31,665 I think we have another -- jus 5600 02:19:31,665 --> 02:19:31,843 t 5601 02:19:31,843 --> 02:19:33,147 the fact I look ahead as we all 5602 02:19:33,147 --> 02:19:33,275 5603 02:19:33,275 --> 02:19:36,118 do and look at the other budge 5604 02:19:36,118 --> 02:19:36,321 t 5605 02:19:36,321 --> 02:19:37,666 requests that are coming, and w 5606 02:19:37,666 --> 02:19:37,666 e 5607 02:19:37,666 --> 02:19:39,331 kind of have to weigh them all 5608 02:19:39,331 --> 02:19:39,964 5609 02:19:39,964 --> 02:19:41,416 collectively and kind of at a 5610 02:19:41,416 --> 02:19:41,416 5611 02:19:41,416 --> 02:19:43,138 30,000-foot level from what's 5612 02:19:43,138 --> 02:19:43,138 5613 02:19:43,138 --> 02:19:43,138 best. 5614 02:19:43,138 --> 02:19:44,631 so I support it. 5615 02:19:44,631 --> 02:19:46,056 I just don't support it today. 5616 02:19:46,056 --> 02:19:46,056 5617 02:19:46,056 --> 02:19:47,687 and that's because we need to 5618 02:19:47,687 --> 02:19:47,687 5619 02:19:47,687 --> 02:19:49,535 see what our total financial 5620 02:19:49,535 --> 02:19:49,805 picture is. 5621 02:19:49,805 --> 02:19:50,414 thank you. 5622 02:19:50,414 --> 02:19:52,227 >> mayor: thank you, 5623 02:19:52,227 --> 02:19:53,235 commissioner book. M 5624 02:19:53,235 --> 02:19:53,235 m sorry. 5625 02:19:53,235 --> 02:19:55,207 commissioner willits. 5626 02:19:55,207 --> 02:19:56,733 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 5627 02:19:56,733 --> 02:19:58,473 so I have similar concerns abo 5628 02:19:58,473 --> 02:19:58,473 ut 5629 02:19:58,473 --> 02:20:00,071 the full, how we build out 5630 02:20:00,071 --> 02:20:02,337 budget and the level of servic 5631 02:20:02,337 --> 02:20:02,337 e, 5632 02:20:02,337 --> 02:20:04,109 but I just want to remind folk 5633 02:20:04,109 --> 02:20:04,109 s, 5634 02:20:04,109 --> 02:20:06,079 when we talk about the core 5635 02:20:06,079 --> 02:20:07,315 functions of the city. 5636 02:20:07,315 --> 02:20:09,079 this is in our charter. 5637 02:20:09,079 --> 02:20:11,130 public safety is in a lot of 5638 02:20:11,130 --> 02:20:13,319 different places throughout the 5639 02:20:13,319 --> 02:20:13,601 5640 02:20:13,601 --> 02:20:15,216 state charter, ordinances, but 5641 02:20:15,216 --> 02:20:15,353 5642 02:20:15,353 --> 02:20:17,589 the office of auditor and the 5643 02:20:17,589 --> 02:20:17,589 5644 02:20:17,589 --> 02:20:19,753 job to be done is a core servic 5645 02:20:19,753 --> 02:20:19,753 e 5646 02:20:19,753 --> 02:20:21,300 of the city. 5647 02:20:21,300 --> 02:20:23,077 it is a service to ourselves o 5648 02:20:23,077 --> 02:20:23,223 n 5649 02:20:23,223 --> 02:20:24,640 behalf of our residents. 5650 02:20:24,640 --> 02:20:28,743 and so it is -- it is tough 5651 02:20:28,743 --> 02:20:29,728 because, you know, there's a 5652 02:20:29,728 --> 02:20:30,473 charter office for a reason. 5653 02:20:30,473 --> 02:20:33,943 the voters put it there. 5654 02:20:33,943 --> 02:20:36,107 and so yeah, it is tough. 5655 02:20:36,107 --> 02:20:38,473 I know it's an amount of money 5656 02:20:38,473 --> 02:20:38,657 5657 02:20:38,657 --> 02:20:39,547 that doesn't seem like it is t 5658 02:20:39,547 --> 02:20:39,547 he 5659 02:20:39,547 --> 02:20:40,580 toughest decision in the world, 5660 02:20:40,580 --> 02:20:40,895 5661 02:20:40,895 --> 02:20:43,113 but I fully understand the 5662 02:20:43,113 --> 02:20:45,349 weight of the decision about 5663 02:20:45,349 --> 02:20:45,349 this. 5664 02:20:45,349 --> 02:20:46,983 thank you, mr. Mayor. 5665 02:20:46,983 --> 02:20:49,455 >> mayor: thank you, 5666 02:20:49,455 --> 02:20:50,607 commissioner willits. 5667 02:20:50,607 --> 02:20:51,771 madam clerk, since this is goi 5668 02:20:51,771 --> 02:20:51,771 ng 5669 02:20:51,771 --> 02:20:54,397 to be a close vote, call the 5670 02:20:54,397 --> 02:20:55,329 roll please so I don't miss t I 5671 02:20:55,329 --> 02:20:55,329 . 5672 02:20:55,329 --> 02:20:57,097 >> yes, mr. Mayor. 5673 02:20:57,097 --> 02:20:57,853 commissioner book. 5674 02:20:57,853 --> 02:20:58,193 >> nay. 5675 02:20:58,193 --> 02:20:59,575 >> a commissioner chestnut 5676 02:20:59,575 --> 02:21:00,845 >> no. 5677 02:21:00,845 --> 02:21:02,137 >> commissioner duncan-walker. 5678 02:21:02,137 --> 02:21:02,137 5679 02:21:02,137 --> 02:21:03,003 >> aye. 5680 02:21:03,003 --> 02:21:04,379 >> commissioner eastman. 5681 02:21:04,379 --> 02:21:05,001 >> nay. 5682 02:21:05,001 --> 02:21:06,565 >> commissioner ingle. 5683 02:21:06,565 --> 02:21:09,775 >> aye. 5684 02:21:09,775 --> 02:21:11,915 >> mayor pro tem willits. 5685 02:21:11,915 --> 02:21:13,081 >> aye. 5686 02:21:13,081 --> 02:21:13,841 >> mayor ward. 5687 02:21:13,841 --> 02:21:14,757 >> aye. 5688 02:21:14,757 --> 02:21:18,615 >> that passes 4-3 with book, 5689 02:21:18,615 --> 02:21:18,615 5690 02:21:18,615 --> 02:21:20,221 eastman and chestnut in dissent. 5691 02:21:20,221 --> 02:21:20,221 5692 02:21:20,221 --> 02:21:23,253 madam clerk? 5693 02:21:23,253 --> 02:21:24,163 >> all right. 5694 02:21:24,163 --> 02:21:29,693 mr. Mayor, we're on to our 5695 02:21:29,693 --> 02:21:31,533 2026-235 request to amend budge 5696 02:21:31,533 --> 02:21:31,533 t 5697 02:21:31,533 --> 02:21:33,631 for office of the city auditor 5698 02:21:33,631 --> 02:21:34,165 5699 02:21:34,165 --> 02:21:35,447 with recommendation the city 5700 02:21:35,447 --> 02:21:37,531 commission authorize human 5701 02:21:37,531 --> 02:21:38,199 resources to unfreeze -- 5702 02:21:38,199 --> 02:21:38,681 >> mayor: no. 5703 02:21:38,681 --> 02:21:40,375 >> an I apologize. 5704 02:21:40,375 --> 02:21:40,375 sorry. 5705 02:21:40,375 --> 02:21:42,834 I'll get there. 5706 02:21:42,834 --> 02:21:43,883 hold on one minute. 5707 02:21:43,883 --> 02:21:45,442 >> mayor: we're going to 5708 02:21:45,442 --> 02:21:46,633 reconsider the whole thing? 5709 02:21:46,633 --> 02:21:47,245 >> no. 5710 02:21:47,245 --> 02:21:48,383 we are moving on. 5711 02:21:48,383 --> 02:21:48,383 sorry. 5712 02:21:48,383 --> 02:21:53,588 2025-170, contract for red lig 5713 02:21:53,588 --> 02:21:53,588 ht 5714 02:21:53,588 --> 02:21:55,632 detection camera enforcement 5715 02:21:55,632 --> 02:21:56,345 system between redspeed florida 5716 02:21:56,345 --> 02:21:56,525 5717 02:21:56,525 --> 02:21:59,395 llc and the city of gainesvill 5718 02:21:59,395 --> 02:21:59,395 e. 5719 02:21:59,395 --> 02:22:00,856 the recommendation the city 5720 02:22:00,856 --> 02:22:01,793 commission approve the contrac 5721 02:22:01,793 --> 02:22:02,023 t 5722 02:22:02,023 --> 02:22:04,099 with redspeed florida llc and 5723 02:22:04,099 --> 02:22:04,099 5724 02:22:04,099 --> 02:22:07,135 authorize the city manager or 5725 02:22:07,135 --> 02:22:07,135 5726 02:22:07,135 --> 02:22:08,771 designee to take up the redspee 5727 02:22:08,771 --> 02:22:08,771 d 5728 02:22:08,771 --> 02:22:09,685 florida contract and execute a 5729 02:22:09,685 --> 02:22:09,685 ll 5730 02:22:09,685 --> 02:22:11,338 documents and contracts related 5731 02:22:11,338 --> 02:22:11,338 5732 02:22:11,338 --> 02:22:13,041 subject to approval of the cit 5733 02:22:13,041 --> 02:22:13,509 y 5734 02:22:13,509 --> 02:22:14,947 attorney as to form and 5735 02:22:14,947 --> 02:22:14,947 legality. 5736 02:22:14,947 --> 02:22:16,139 >> mayor: welcome. 5737 02:22:16,139 --> 02:22:18,244 >> good afternoon, mayor, city 5738 02:22:18,244 --> 02:22:18,841 5739 02:22:18,841 --> 02:22:19,507 commissioners, mr. Manager. 5740 02:22:19,507 --> 02:22:22,953 thank you for having me today. 5741 02:22:22,953 --> 02:22:22,953 5742 02:22:22,953 --> 02:22:25,817 this is part of our florida 5743 02:22:25,817 --> 02:22:27,057 state statute requirement, whi 5744 02:22:27,057 --> 02:22:27,057 ch 5745 02:22:27,057 --> 02:22:29,351 mandates that we bring this 5746 02:22:29,351 --> 02:22:30,024 contract back to you. 5747 02:22:30,024 --> 02:22:32,391 allow it to not go on a consent 5748 02:22:32,391 --> 02:22:32,565 5749 02:22:32,565 --> 02:22:35,021 agenda so if the public had a 5750 02:22:35,021 --> 02:22:35,021 5751 02:22:35,021 --> 02:22:35,775 comment about it that they could 5752 02:22:35,775 --> 02:22:35,775 5753 02:22:35,775 --> 02:22:36,830 make a comment about it. 5754 02:22:36,830 --> 02:22:40,675 we did on may 15 adopt the 5755 02:22:40,675 --> 02:22:43,700 ordinance 2025-170, and it's 5756 02:22:43,700 --> 02:22:45,265 related to, of course, the 5757 02:22:45,265 --> 02:22:47,441 contract for the red light 5758 02:22:47,441 --> 02:22:47,441 cameras. 5759 02:22:47,441 --> 02:22:48,131 this is the contract. 5760 02:22:48,131 --> 02:22:49,949 this is the backup items of th 5761 02:22:49,949 --> 02:22:50,153 e 5762 02:22:50,153 --> 02:22:52,589 scope of services and how we 5763 02:22:52,589 --> 02:22:56,405 will move forward, and so we 5764 02:22:56,405 --> 02:22:58,215 have been in contact both with 5765 02:22:58,215 --> 02:22:58,517 5766 02:22:58,517 --> 02:23:00,883 the vendor and lee libby has 5767 02:23:00,883 --> 02:23:02,451 helped us all the way through 5768 02:23:02,451 --> 02:23:02,451 5769 02:23:02,451 --> 02:23:03,555 this because it is new for us a 5770 02:23:03,555 --> 02:23:03,555 t 5771 02:23:03,555 --> 02:23:04,605 the gainesville police 5772 02:23:04,605 --> 02:23:04,605 department. 5773 02:23:04,605 --> 02:23:06,588 I'm here for any questions or 5774 02:23:06,588 --> 02:23:06,588 5775 02:23:06,588 --> 02:23:09,325 any of that, and to allow for 5776 02:23:09,325 --> 02:23:09,325 5777 02:23:09,325 --> 02:23:09,962 public comment. 5778 02:23:09,962 --> 02:23:10,469 >> mayor: very good. 5779 02:23:10,469 --> 02:23:10,921 thank you. 5780 02:23:10,921 --> 02:23:12,560 >> and I would remind everyone, 5781 02:23:12,560 --> 02:23:12,993 5782 02:23:12,993 --> 02:23:14,369 this is about the red light 5783 02:23:14,369 --> 02:23:16,129 cameras, not about school zone 5784 02:23:16,129 --> 02:23:16,533 5785 02:23:16,533 --> 02:23:17,031 cameras to be specific. 5786 02:23:17,031 --> 02:23:18,797 I know that is easy to conflate 5787 02:23:18,797 --> 02:23:19,935 5788 02:23:19,935 --> 02:23:20,147 the two. 5789 02:23:20,147 --> 02:23:22,911 we're not on school zones 5790 02:23:22,911 --> 02:23:23,293 contract just yet. 5791 02:23:23,293 --> 02:23:25,054 is there any public comment? 5792 02:23:25,054 --> 02:23:27,243 >> there is no public comment. 5793 02:23:27,243 --> 02:23:27,243 5794 02:23:27,243 --> 02:23:28,209 >> mayor: okay. 5795 02:23:28,209 --> 02:23:28,785 all right. 5796 02:23:28,785 --> 02:23:29,943 commissioner book. 5797 02:23:29,943 --> 02:23:32,215 >> I remain fully in support. 5798 02:23:32,215 --> 02:23:33,853 we have taken several votes for 5799 02:23:33,853 --> 02:23:33,915 5800 02:23:33,915 --> 02:23:35,481 both of these forms of 5801 02:23:35,481 --> 02:23:35,481 technology. 5802 02:23:35,481 --> 02:23:36,851 it is all about public safety, 5803 02:23:36,851 --> 02:23:37,165 5804 02:23:37,165 --> 02:23:38,487 and it's definitely not about 5805 02:23:38,487 --> 02:23:38,487 5806 02:23:38,487 --> 02:23:38,487 revenue. 5807 02:23:38,487 --> 02:23:40,237 if anything, it appears that o 5808 02:23:40,237 --> 02:23:40,237 ur 5809 02:23:40,237 --> 02:23:42,407 analysis shows that it will be 5810 02:23:42,407 --> 02:23:42,663 5811 02:23:42,663 --> 02:23:43,165 revenue neutral. 5812 02:23:43,165 --> 02:23:46,561 I suspect it will probably be 5813 02:23:46,561 --> 02:23:46,561 5814 02:23:46,561 --> 02:23:47,707 revenue negative for plan 5815 02:23:47,707 --> 02:23:48,633 implementation, at least for a 5816 02:23:48,633 --> 02:23:48,633 5817 02:23:48,633 --> 02:23:48,633 while. 5818 02:23:48,633 --> 02:23:51,805 definitely has nothing to do 5819 02:23:51,805 --> 02:23:52,837 with fees and definitely has 5820 02:23:52,837 --> 02:23:54,235 nothing to do with leveraging 5821 02:23:54,235 --> 02:23:54,235 5822 02:23:54,235 --> 02:23:56,479 safety and the fact that we 5823 02:23:56,479 --> 02:23:57,671 identified some of our most 5824 02:23:57,671 --> 02:23:59,205 dangerous areas to pilot it 5825 02:23:59,205 --> 02:24:01,015 means that maybe a year down t 5826 02:24:01,015 --> 02:24:01,015 he 5827 02:24:01,015 --> 02:24:02,480 road if we've not done it well 5828 02:24:02,480 --> 02:24:02,919 , 5829 02:24:02,919 --> 02:24:03,931 it is not implemented in a way 5830 02:24:03,931 --> 02:24:04,326 5831 02:24:04,326 --> 02:24:05,921 that gives trust to the 5832 02:24:05,921 --> 02:24:07,521 community, then the commission 5833 02:24:07,521 --> 02:24:07,751 5834 02:24:07,751 --> 02:24:08,960 has the ability to ramp it back 5835 02:24:08,960 --> 02:24:08,960 . 5836 02:24:08,960 --> 02:24:10,778 that is the whole point of the 5837 02:24:10,778 --> 02:24:10,925 5838 02:24:10,925 --> 02:24:10,925 pilot. 5839 02:24:10,925 --> 02:24:14,756 I say this just as another 5840 02:24:14,756 --> 02:24:16,017 bureaucratic step in support, 5841 02:24:16,017 --> 02:24:16,017 5842 02:24:16,017 --> 02:24:18,437 and so with that, I recommend 5843 02:24:18,437 --> 02:24:18,437 5844 02:24:18,437 --> 02:24:20,833 approval of 2025-170, approve 5845 02:24:20,833 --> 02:24:20,833 5846 02:24:20,833 --> 02:24:22,202 the contract with redspeed, 5847 02:24:22,202 --> 02:24:25,531 authorize the city manage 5848 02:24:25,531 --> 02:24:26,153 areer and 5849 02:24:26,153 --> 02:24:27,377 designee to accept the contrac 5850 02:24:27,377 --> 02:24:27,377 t, 5851 02:24:27,377 --> 02:24:29,615 execute the documents and 5852 02:24:29,615 --> 02:24:30,509 contracts subject to the 5853 02:24:30,509 --> 02:24:31,076 approval of the city attorney. 5854 02:24:31,076 --> 02:24:31,076 5855 02:24:31,076 --> 02:24:32,217 >> second. 5856 02:24:32,217 --> 02:24:34,056 >> mayor: thank you, 5857 02:24:34,056 --> 02:24:34,395 commissioner book. 5858 02:24:34,395 --> 02:24:35,511 commissioner willits? 5859 02:24:35,511 --> 02:24:36,615 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 5860 02:24:36,615 --> 02:24:38,016 my understanding it is a 5861 02:24:38,016 --> 02:24:39,721 three-year contract with two 5862 02:24:39,721 --> 02:24:41,219 potential extensions of a year 5863 02:24:41,219 --> 02:24:41,219 . 5864 02:24:41,219 --> 02:24:44,827 but it can be terminated early? 5865 02:24:44,827 --> 02:24:44,827 5866 02:24:44,827 --> 02:24:46,301 pursuant to the contract. 5867 02:24:46,301 --> 02:24:49,189 how -- what are the terms for 5868 02:24:49,189 --> 02:24:49,189 5869 02:24:49,189 --> 02:24:49,897 terminating early? 5870 02:24:49,897 --> 02:24:51,803 if we only -- if we got a year 5871 02:24:51,803 --> 02:24:52,025 5872 02:24:52,025 --> 02:24:53,398 into it and we don't like it o 5873 02:24:53,398 --> 02:24:53,533 r 5874 02:24:53,533 --> 02:24:54,363 a future commission doesn't like 5875 02:24:54,363 --> 02:24:54,363 5876 02:24:54,363 --> 02:24:54,363 it. 5877 02:24:54,363 --> 02:24:59,137 >> so if for some reason we -- 5878 02:24:59,137 --> 02:24:59,245 5879 02:24:59,245 --> 02:25:00,635 if legality in the state level 5880 02:25:00,635 --> 02:25:01,107 5881 02:25:01,107 --> 02:25:02,667 like the statute went away that 5882 02:25:02,667 --> 02:25:02,937 5883 02:25:02,937 --> 02:25:04,208 allows us to have them, at any 5884 02:25:04,208 --> 02:25:04,504 5885 02:25:04,504 --> 02:25:06,975 time we wanted to be able to 5886 02:25:06,975 --> 02:25:07,844 negate that contract. 5887 02:25:07,844 --> 02:25:10,057 we also put a stipulation in 5888 02:25:10,057 --> 02:25:10,057 there. 5889 02:25:10,057 --> 02:25:11,680 I think it's 30 days. 5890 02:25:11,680 --> 02:25:13,532 letting each other know if for 5891 02:25:13,532 --> 02:25:13,681 5892 02:25:13,681 --> 02:25:15,261 some reason, maybe the camera I 5893 02:25:15,261 --> 02:25:15,261 s 5894 02:25:15,261 --> 02:25:16,250 not functional. 5895 02:25:16,250 --> 02:25:19,497 maybe we are not getting enoug 5896 02:25:19,497 --> 02:25:19,809 h 5897 02:25:19,809 --> 02:25:20,894 -- the decision has changed and 5898 02:25:20,894 --> 02:25:21,023 5899 02:25:21,023 --> 02:25:23,537 is not supported by the 5900 02:25:23,537 --> 02:25:26,071 legislative body at that time, 5901 02:25:26,071 --> 02:25:26,266 5902 02:25:26,266 --> 02:25:27,200 we could ask -- 5903 02:25:27,200 --> 02:25:27,200 yes. 5904 02:25:27,200 --> 02:25:30,331 >> with a simple majority vote 5905 02:25:30,331 --> 02:25:30,331 5906 02:25:30,331 --> 02:25:32,371 of the commission, this contract 5907 02:25:32,371 --> 02:25:32,371 5908 02:25:32,371 --> 02:25:34,266 can be and -- and sorry I did 5909 02:25:34,266 --> 02:25:34,266 5910 02:25:34,266 --> 02:25:35,373 not go look through for 5911 02:25:35,373 --> 02:25:35,373 penalties. 5912 02:25:35,373 --> 02:25:40,137 just so that I understand, you 5913 02:25:40,137 --> 02:25:40,137 5914 02:25:40,137 --> 02:25:40,943 know, cancellation, terminatio 5915 02:25:40,943 --> 02:25:40,943 n, 5916 02:25:40,943 --> 02:25:44,631 for cause, without cause, loss 5917 02:25:44,631 --> 02:25:44,781 5918 02:25:44,781 --> 02:25:45,415 of funding. 5919 02:25:45,415 --> 02:25:47,735 so I just want and maybe this 5920 02:25:47,735 --> 02:25:47,735 is 5921 02:25:47,735 --> 02:25:49,341 deeper, so it's an attorney 5922 02:25:49,341 --> 02:25:49,341 question. 5923 02:25:49,341 --> 02:25:51,777 I just want to fully understand 5924 02:25:51,777 --> 02:25:51,777 . 5925 02:25:51,777 --> 02:25:54,091 if we end up just hating it f 5926 02:25:54,091 --> 02:25:54,091 5927 02:25:54,091 --> 02:25:56,169 the public hates it, everybody 5928 02:25:56,169 --> 02:25:57,395 5929 02:25:57,395 --> 02:26:00,601 hates it, whatever, can we jus 5930 02:26:00,601 --> 02:26:01,133 t 5931 02:26:01,133 --> 02:26:03,333 make a -- for no cause, besides 5932 02:26:03,333 --> 02:26:03,531 5933 02:26:03,531 --> 02:26:06,139 it is unpopular decision to 5934 02:26:06,139 --> 02:26:07,157 terminate what kind of -- I use 5935 02:26:07,157 --> 02:26:07,677 5936 02:26:07,677 --> 02:26:09,417 the term penalty because I don 5937 02:26:09,417 --> 02:26:09,417 't 5938 02:26:09,417 --> 02:26:10,137 know any better word. 5939 02:26:10,137 --> 02:26:11,978 can we get out of it at some 5940 02:26:11,978 --> 02:26:12,939 point before the three years? 5941 02:26:12,939 --> 02:26:15,137 >> so all of our contracts with 5942 02:26:15,137 --> 02:26:15,341 5943 02:26:15,341 --> 02:26:18,255 the city say the vast majority 5944 02:26:18,255 --> 02:26:18,687 5945 02:26:18,687 --> 02:26:20,883 have a termination for 5946 02:26:20,883 --> 02:26:20,883 conveyance. 5947 02:26:20,883 --> 02:26:22,591 this one says after ayear. 5948 02:26:22,591 --> 02:26:24,717 with 30 days notice, we can 5949 02:26:24,717 --> 02:26:25,453 cancel the agreement. 5950 02:26:25,453 --> 02:26:26,253 >> a year. 5951 02:26:26,253 --> 02:26:27,660 >> and give it a year. 5952 02:26:27,660 --> 02:26:31,230 and then if it's just, like, 5953 02:26:31,230 --> 02:26:32,817 outside -- now, obviously, les 5954 02:26:32,817 --> 02:26:33,927 s 5955 02:26:33,927 --> 02:26:35,009 than a year for cause, there's 5956 02:26:35,009 --> 02:26:35,369 5957 02:26:35,369 --> 02:26:36,279 some listed in the contract. 5958 02:26:36,279 --> 02:26:37,307 that makes sense. 5959 02:26:37,307 --> 02:26:38,905 if it's really not working and 5960 02:26:38,905 --> 02:26:39,067 5961 02:26:39,067 --> 02:26:40,385 they really failed and if 5962 02:26:40,385 --> 02:26:41,403 there's cause that we can prov 5963 02:26:41,403 --> 02:26:41,403 e. 5964 02:26:41,403 --> 02:26:43,307 but I'm thinking of the no 5965 02:26:43,307 --> 02:26:44,385 cause, merely convenience, giv 5966 02:26:44,385 --> 02:26:44,675 e 5967 02:26:44,675 --> 02:26:47,473 it a year, and then 30 day, 5968 02:26:47,473 --> 02:26:49,226 which makes me feel a little 5969 02:26:49,226 --> 02:26:51,845 more comfortable with it so try 5970 02:26:51,845 --> 02:26:53,017 5971 02:26:53,017 --> 02:26:54,151 it out on just two. 5972 02:26:54,151 --> 02:26:56,649 does this contract allow 5973 02:26:56,649 --> 02:26:58,255 expansion of the two to more 5974 02:26:58,255 --> 02:26:59,891 than two should we want within 5975 02:26:59,891 --> 02:27:00,065 5976 02:27:00,065 --> 02:27:03,263 this three-year period? 5977 02:27:03,263 --> 02:27:05,797 >> it is my understanding from 5978 02:27:05,797 --> 02:27:06,329 5979 02:27:06,329 --> 02:27:08,203 lee that we would have to enter 5980 02:27:08,203 --> 02:27:08,563 5981 02:27:08,563 --> 02:27:09,899 into an addendum to the contract 5982 02:27:09,899 --> 02:27:09,899 5983 02:27:09,899 --> 02:27:11,865 if we were going to do that. 5984 02:27:11,865 --> 02:27:14,177 it does allow for some leeway 5985 02:27:14,177 --> 02:27:14,177 5986 02:27:14,177 --> 02:27:14,513 for that. 5987 02:27:14,513 --> 02:27:16,973 >> it would involve the same 5988 02:27:16,973 --> 02:27:17,827 steps of, you know, it's got t 5989 02:27:17,827 --> 02:27:18,009 o 5990 02:27:18,009 --> 02:27:18,406 come before it. 5991 02:27:18,406 --> 02:27:21,411 it can't be on continue sent I 5992 02:27:21,411 --> 02:27:21,581 f 5993 02:27:21,581 --> 02:27:22,614 we do an addendum. 5994 02:27:22,614 --> 02:27:24,247 >> I apologize. 5995 02:27:24,247 --> 02:27:25,859 that is a legal question I don 5996 02:27:25,859 --> 02:27:25,859 't 5997 02:27:25,859 --> 02:27:27,085 have the answer to. 5998 02:27:27,085 --> 02:27:28,133 >> mr. City attorney? 5999 02:27:28,133 --> 02:27:30,887 >> mr. Mayor, this contract, I 6000 02:27:30,887 --> 02:27:30,927 6001 02:27:30,927 --> 02:27:32,087 think, is for the two 6002 02:27:32,087 --> 02:27:34,903 intersections that were 6003 02:27:34,903 --> 02:27:34,903 identified. 6004 02:27:34,903 --> 02:27:37,195 and I'm not aware of any reaso 6005 02:27:37,195 --> 02:27:38,225 n 6006 02:27:38,225 --> 02:27:39,601 why they wouldn't be willing t 6007 02:27:39,601 --> 02:27:39,861 o 6008 02:27:39,861 --> 02:27:44,541 expand fit it if we wanted to 6009 02:27:44,541 --> 02:27:44,585 6010 02:27:44,585 --> 02:27:44,827 add -- 6011 02:27:44,827 --> 02:27:47,443 >> my question is, would this 6012 02:27:47,443 --> 02:27:47,443 6013 02:27:47,443 --> 02:27:50,113 return to us in a similar 6014 02:27:50,113 --> 02:27:50,113 fashion? 6015 02:27:50,113 --> 02:27:52,209 would it go through the same 6016 02:27:52,209 --> 02:27:52,209 process? 6017 02:27:52,209 --> 02:27:54,209 >> if you add additional 6018 02:27:54,209 --> 02:27:55,710 intersections, it would come 6019 02:27:55,710 --> 02:27:56,137 back before you. 6020 02:27:56,137 --> 02:27:58,448 >> a yes, statute requires all 6021 02:27:58,448 --> 02:27:58,848 6022 02:27:58,848 --> 02:28:00,887 approvals from the governing 6023 02:28:00,887 --> 02:28:02,211 body to be done on a regular 6024 02:28:02,211 --> 02:28:03,686 agenda item for all these 6025 02:28:03,686 --> 02:28:05,951 automated enforcement efforts. 6026 02:28:05,951 --> 02:28:05,951 6027 02:28:05,951 --> 02:28:07,457 the ordinance you adopted liste 6028 02:28:07,457 --> 02:28:07,457 d 6029 02:28:07,457 --> 02:28:09,362 additional intersections as an 6030 02:28:09,362 --> 02:28:10,324 6031 02:28:10,324 --> 02:28:11,166 authorization, but the 6032 02:28:11,166 --> 02:28:12,663 contracts, yes, would have to 6033 02:28:12,663 --> 02:28:12,663 6034 02:28:12,663 --> 02:28:13,461 come back and that is for schoo 6035 02:28:13,461 --> 02:28:13,461 l 6036 02:28:13,461 --> 02:28:14,703 zones and for the red lights. 6037 02:28:14,703 --> 02:28:15,733 >> perfect. 6038 02:28:15,733 --> 02:28:17,329 I do remember a list. 6039 02:28:17,329 --> 02:28:18,825 and the contract comes back. 6040 02:28:18,825 --> 02:28:19,738 that's wonderful. 6041 02:28:19,738 --> 02:28:21,485 I would just say, I think I'm 6042 02:28:21,485 --> 02:28:21,485 6043 02:28:21,485 --> 02:28:23,105 going to support this, and 6044 02:28:23,105 --> 02:28:23,770 because we are down the road. 6045 02:28:23,770 --> 02:28:25,539 we're getting down on this. 6046 02:28:25,539 --> 02:28:27,995 but I do like the idea, and my 6047 02:28:27,995 --> 02:28:28,945 6048 02:28:28,945 --> 02:28:30,115 colleagues agree, that I want a 6049 02:28:30,115 --> 02:28:30,348 6050 02:28:30,348 --> 02:28:31,479 real one-year deadline that we 6051 02:28:31,479 --> 02:28:31,653 6052 02:28:31,653 --> 02:28:33,081 bring back and look at it so 6053 02:28:33,081 --> 02:28:34,386 that we know and if it's 6054 02:28:34,386 --> 02:28:36,369 something we don't like, that w 6055 02:28:36,369 --> 02:28:36,369 e 6056 02:28:36,369 --> 02:28:38,885 look at data, hear community 6057 02:28:38,885 --> 02:28:40,323 feedback, you know, that kind o 6058 02:28:40,323 --> 02:28:40,323 f 6059 02:28:40,323 --> 02:28:41,495 set in stone that ewith're goi 6060 02:28:41,495 --> 02:28:41,495 ng 6061 02:28:41,495 --> 02:28:42,455 to do in a year. 6062 02:28:42,455 --> 02:28:44,837 >> statute actually requires a 6063 02:28:44,837 --> 02:28:45,807 n 6064 02:28:45,807 --> 02:28:46,558 annual report with a regular 6065 02:28:46,558 --> 02:28:47,827 agenda item on the regular 6066 02:28:47,827 --> 02:28:49,229 meeting, not on consent as well 6067 02:28:49,229 --> 02:28:49,229 . 6068 02:28:49,229 --> 02:28:52,139 >> not everything we do is 6069 02:28:52,139 --> 02:28:52,873 mandated by the state 6070 02:28:52,873 --> 02:28:54,261 government, but in this case, I 6071 02:28:54,261 --> 02:28:54,303 6072 02:28:54,303 --> 02:28:54,851 think -- 6073 02:28:54,851 --> 02:28:56,437 it shows that there is an 6074 02:28:56,437 --> 02:28:56,437 interest. 6075 02:28:56,437 --> 02:28:58,041 and so I think I can support 6076 02:28:58,041 --> 02:28:58,041 this. 6077 02:28:58,041 --> 02:28:58,531 thank you. 6078 02:28:58,531 --> 02:29:00,006 >> mayor: thank you, 6079 02:29:00,006 --> 02:29:01,077 commissioner willits. 6080 02:29:01,077 --> 02:29:04,971 xhing commissionerening I I 6081 02:29:04,971 --> 02:29:04,971 think? 6082 02:29:04,971 --> 02:29:08,287 >> this is an issue I really 6083 02:29:08,287 --> 02:29:21,648 have beencommissioner ingle? 6084 02:29:21,648 --> 02:29:22,358 >> this is an issue I really is 6085 02:29:22,358 --> 02:29:23,989 sue 6086 02:29:23,989 --> 02:29:25,916 of folks who don't get mail and 6087 02:29:25,916 --> 02:29:26,001 6088 02:29:26,001 --> 02:29:27,579 move a lot and missing something 6089 02:29:27,579 --> 02:29:27,579 6090 02:29:27,579 --> 02:29:28,925 like this and turning from a 6091 02:29:28,925 --> 02:29:29,882 fine they didn't know they had 6092 02:29:29,882 --> 02:29:30,175 6093 02:29:30,175 --> 02:29:32,410 into a suspended license and a 6094 02:29:32,410 --> 02:29:32,646 6095 02:29:32,646 --> 02:29:33,449 bench warrant and all the thing 6096 02:29:33,449 --> 02:29:33,449 s 6097 02:29:33,449 --> 02:29:34,310 that go along with that. 6098 02:29:34,310 --> 02:29:36,014 I really wrestled back and for 6099 02:29:36,014 --> 02:29:36,014 th 6100 02:29:36,014 --> 02:29:38,777 with those things. 6101 02:29:38,777 --> 02:29:41,041 in addition to that, there was 6102 02:29:41,041 --> 02:29:41,242 6103 02:29:41,242 --> 02:29:42,818 recently a case in south flori 6104 02:29:42,818 --> 02:29:42,818 da 6105 02:29:42,818 --> 02:29:46,819 where these cameras were 6106 02:29:46,819 --> 02:29:47,235 declared unconstitutional. 6107 02:29:47,235 --> 02:29:54,395 between those two things, I 6108 02:29:54,395 --> 02:29:56,405 would be more comfortable 6109 02:29:56,405 --> 02:29:57,573 waiting on actually executing 6110 02:29:57,573 --> 02:29:57,573 6111 02:29:57,573 --> 02:30:00,245 this contract until we had som 6112 02:30:00,245 --> 02:30:00,335 e 6113 02:30:00,335 --> 02:30:01,680 word back from the appeal that' 6114 02:30:01,680 --> 02:30:01,680 s 6115 02:30:01,680 --> 02:30:03,442 going on to that as to whether 6116 02:30:03,442 --> 02:30:03,605 6117 02:30:03,605 --> 02:30:05,019 or not these are going to 6118 02:30:05,019 --> 02:30:05,384 continue to be legal. 6119 02:30:05,384 --> 02:30:07,250 I don't want to go into putting 6120 02:30:07,250 --> 02:30:07,426 6121 02:30:07,426 --> 02:30:09,755 in the expense of getting 6122 02:30:09,755 --> 02:30:11,120 special magistrate, getting the 6123 02:30:11,120 --> 02:30:11,170 6124 02:30:11,170 --> 02:30:12,643 equipment to, or hiring someon 6125 02:30:12,643 --> 02:30:12,773 e 6126 02:30:12,773 --> 02:30:14,150 to review all the tickets, doi 6127 02:30:14,150 --> 02:30:14,150 ng 6128 02:30:14,150 --> 02:30:15,437 all the things that we would 6129 02:30:15,437 --> 02:30:17,057 have to do to make this 6130 02:30:17,057 --> 02:30:19,156 functional, only to find out a 6131 02:30:19,156 --> 02:30:19,286 6132 02:30:19,286 --> 02:30:21,389 few months from now that it's 6133 02:30:21,389 --> 02:30:21,389 6134 02:30:21,389 --> 02:30:24,264 not considered constitutional I 6135 02:30:24,264 --> 02:30:24,264 n 6136 02:30:24,264 --> 02:30:25,705 florida anymore. 6137 02:30:25,705 --> 02:30:30,598 I'm also a little, not 6138 02:30:30,598 --> 02:30:32,264 concerned, but curious, as to 6139 02:30:32,264 --> 02:30:32,264 6140 02:30:32,264 --> 02:30:33,140 whether or not the traffic 6141 02:30:33,140 --> 02:30:34,837 patterns that we used to make 6142 02:30:34,837 --> 02:30:34,837 6143 02:30:34,837 --> 02:30:37,305 this decision would hold up if 6144 02:30:37,305 --> 02:30:37,469 6145 02:30:37,469 --> 02:30:39,125 now that they're talking about 6146 02:30:39,125 --> 02:30:39,807 6147 02:30:39,807 --> 02:30:43,080 closing stephen foster and one 6148 02:30:43,080 --> 02:30:43,080 6149 02:30:43,080 --> 02:30:43,843 of the intersections we have 6150 02:30:43,843 --> 02:30:45,185 been looking at was the corner 6151 02:30:45,185 --> 02:30:45,626 6152 02:30:45,626 --> 02:30:47,150 of 6th and 23rd. 6153 02:30:47,150 --> 02:30:50,020 I would imagine a good deal of 6154 02:30:50,020 --> 02:30:50,417 6155 02:30:50,417 --> 02:30:51,309 that traffic was some school 6156 02:30:51,309 --> 02:30:51,687 traffic for that. 6157 02:30:51,687 --> 02:30:53,922 so I'm a no on this today. 6158 02:30:53,922 --> 02:30:55,190 and I would say I would be jus 6159 02:30:55,190 --> 02:30:55,391 t 6160 02:30:55,391 --> 02:30:56,694 as happy pushing this off until 6161 02:30:56,694 --> 02:30:57,524 6162 02:30:57,524 --> 02:30:59,028 we've got some real answer as t 6163 02:30:59,028 --> 02:30:59,028 o 6164 02:30:59,028 --> 02:31:02,134 whether or not this is going t 6165 02:31:02,134 --> 02:31:02,254 o 6166 02:31:02,254 --> 02:31:04,802 continue to be found 6167 02:31:04,802 --> 02:31:07,238 unconstitutional and not barri 6168 02:31:07,238 --> 02:31:07,238 ng 6169 02:31:07,238 --> 02:31:08,168 the appeal in south florida. 6170 02:31:08,168 --> 02:31:09,850 that's where I am on it. 6171 02:31:09,850 --> 02:31:11,448 >> mayor: thank you, 6172 02:31:11,448 --> 02:31:12,567 commissioner ingle. 6173 02:31:12,567 --> 02:31:16,216 I will continue to be a yes on 6174 02:31:16,216 --> 02:31:16,613 6175 02:31:16,613 --> 02:31:16,613 this. 6176 02:31:16,613 --> 02:31:17,545 I have been through. 6177 02:31:17,545 --> 02:31:18,649 I understand the concerns. 6178 02:31:18,649 --> 02:31:22,264 the thing that we have not 6179 02:31:22,264 --> 02:31:23,288 talked about is the tremendous 6180 02:31:23,288 --> 02:31:23,894 6181 02:31:23,894 --> 02:31:25,643 danger, and I would almost -- I 6182 02:31:25,643 --> 02:31:25,984 6183 02:31:25,984 --> 02:31:28,389 won't call it an epidemic, but 6184 02:31:28,389 --> 02:31:28,484 6185 02:31:28,484 --> 02:31:29,726 close to that, of people runni 6186 02:31:29,726 --> 02:31:29,726 ng 6187 02:31:29,726 --> 02:31:30,201 red lights. 6188 02:31:30,201 --> 02:31:32,063 I watched three of them 6189 02:31:32,063 --> 02:31:34,855 yesterday in the space of half 6190 02:31:34,855 --> 02:31:35,099 6191 02:31:35,099 --> 02:31:35,444 an hour. 6192 02:31:35,444 --> 02:31:37,730 they weren't at these two 6193 02:31:37,730 --> 02:31:37,730 intersections. 6194 02:31:37,730 --> 02:31:39,587 these two intersections are the 6195 02:31:39,587 --> 02:31:39,587 6196 02:31:39,587 --> 02:31:43,175 ones that the data show us hav 6197 02:31:43,175 --> 02:31:43,340 e 6198 02:31:43,340 --> 02:31:45,347 the most trouble. 6199 02:31:45,347 --> 02:31:47,710 and some weren't even in the t 6200 02:31:47,710 --> 02:31:47,710 op 6201 02:31:47,710 --> 02:31:47,710 two. 6202 02:31:47,710 --> 02:31:50,073 public safety is a thing we ar 6203 02:31:50,073 --> 02:31:50,251 e 6204 02:31:50,251 --> 02:31:51,452 100%, as you mentioned earlier, 6205 02:31:51,452 --> 02:31:54,883 6206 02:31:54,883 --> 02:31:55,282 responsible for. 6207 02:31:55,282 --> 02:31:55,884 no question about that. 6208 02:31:55,884 --> 02:31:58,700 if we are committed to vision 6209 02:31:58,700 --> 02:31:58,700 6210 02:31:58,700 --> 02:32:00,515 zero, we've got to do something 6211 02:32:00,515 --> 02:32:00,686 6212 02:32:00,686 --> 02:32:04,827 to lower the number of people 6213 02:32:04,827 --> 02:32:04,827 6214 02:32:04,827 --> 02:32:05,266 running red lights. 6215 02:32:05,266 --> 02:32:06,472 if somebody's got a better idea 6216 02:32:06,472 --> 02:32:06,472 , 6217 02:32:06,472 --> 02:32:07,705 I'm all ears. 6218 02:32:07,705 --> 02:32:09,264 but until a better idea comes 6219 02:32:09,264 --> 02:32:09,264 6220 02:32:09,264 --> 02:32:11,443 along, I'm a yes on this. 6221 02:32:11,443 --> 02:32:14,245 is there any public comment, 6222 02:32:14,245 --> 02:32:15,073 madam clerk? 6223 02:32:15,073 --> 02:32:16,539 >> no public comment. 6224 02:32:16,539 --> 02:32:18,873 >> mayor: we have a motion on 6225 02:32:18,873 --> 02:32:18,873 6226 02:32:18,873 --> 02:32:19,124 the floor. 6227 02:32:19,124 --> 02:32:21,939 all in favor vote aye. 6228 02:32:21,939 --> 02:32:22,941 opposed nay. 6229 02:32:22,941 --> 02:32:24,676 that passes 6-1 with 6230 02:32:24,676 --> 02:32:25,455 commissioner ingle in dissent. 6231 02:32:25,455 --> 02:32:25,455 6232 02:32:25,455 --> 02:32:26,712 madam clerk? 6233 02:32:26,712 --> 02:32:30,220 >> mr. Mayor, that is our 6234 02:32:30,220 --> 02:32:30,618 morning agenda. 6235 02:32:30,618 --> 02:32:31,280 >> mayor: thank you. 6236 02:32:31,280 --> 02:32:32,208 commissioner duncan-walker? 6237 02:32:32,208 --> 02:32:34,222 >> mr. Mayor, I do have a quick 6238 02:32:34,222 --> 02:32:34,692 6239 02:32:34,692 --> 02:32:36,791 question with regards to the 6240 02:32:36,791 --> 02:32:37,328 previous agenda item. 6241 02:32:37,328 --> 02:32:39,058 thank you, commissioner ingle, 6242 02:32:39,058 --> 02:32:40,863 6243 02:32:40,863 --> 02:32:41,465 for your concerns. 6244 02:32:41,465 --> 02:32:44,514 the police advisory council tha 6245 02:32:44,514 --> 02:32:44,514 t 6246 02:32:44,514 --> 02:32:45,065 is seated. 6247 02:32:45,065 --> 02:32:46,571 is it possible to utilize them 6248 02:32:46,571 --> 02:32:46,768 6249 02:32:46,768 --> 02:32:48,874 in review of some of these cas 6250 02:32:48,874 --> 02:32:48,874 es 6251 02:32:48,874 --> 02:32:51,640 as they come through? 6252 02:32:51,640 --> 02:32:53,448 because what commissioner ingl 6253 02:32:53,448 --> 02:32:53,642 e 6254 02:32:53,642 --> 02:32:55,083 was stating is certainly not 6255 02:32:55,083 --> 02:32:56,044 anything that's lost on me. 6256 02:32:56,044 --> 02:33:00,549 and I wonder if there is a way 6257 02:33:00,549 --> 02:33:00,759 6258 02:33:00,759 --> 02:33:02,656 for us in an ongoing way as 6259 02:33:02,656 --> 02:33:03,820 opposed to at this year point 6260 02:33:03,820 --> 02:33:03,820 6261 02:33:03,820 --> 02:33:05,485 where we will have to review 6262 02:33:05,485 --> 02:33:07,262 this, that if we could kind of 6263 02:33:07,262 --> 02:33:08,054 6264 02:33:08,054 --> 02:33:09,090 have probably a more consistent 6265 02:33:09,090 --> 02:33:09,526 6266 02:33:09,526 --> 02:33:12,136 review and/or analysis of the 6267 02:33:12,136 --> 02:33:12,136 6268 02:33:12,136 --> 02:33:14,035 data that we're collecting, so 6269 02:33:14,035 --> 02:33:16,241 e can be more apprised of 6270 02:33:16,241 --> 02:33:16,900 what's actually happening. 6271 02:33:16,900 --> 02:33:20,207 is that a way it could be used 6272 02:33:20,207 --> 02:33:20,207 ? 6273 02:33:20,207 --> 02:33:24,608 >> commission, sergeant lynn 6274 02:33:24,608 --> 02:33:26,978 valdez, traffic unit. 6275 02:33:26,978 --> 02:33:28,741 with the statutory requirement, 6276 02:33:28,741 --> 02:33:29,171 6277 02:33:29,171 --> 02:33:29,975 part of it is they would like 6278 02:33:29,975 --> 02:33:29,975 6279 02:33:29,975 --> 02:33:31,819 the public forum, but the vendo 6280 02:33:31,819 --> 02:33:31,819 r 6281 02:33:31,819 --> 02:33:34,259 actually produces reports and 6282 02:33:34,259 --> 02:33:34,259 6283 02:33:34,259 --> 02:33:35,625 statistical analysis that is 6284 02:33:35,625 --> 02:33:36,356 easily available to everybody. 6285 02:33:36,356 --> 02:33:36,356 6286 02:33:36,356 --> 02:33:39,025 so we could also present to the 6287 02:33:39,025 --> 02:33:39,183 6288 02:33:39,183 --> 02:33:40,128 police advisory commission. 6289 02:33:40,128 --> 02:33:41,761 but part of the formality is, I 6290 02:33:41,761 --> 02:33:41,761 6291 02:33:41,761 --> 02:33:44,961 believe, they want it in this 6292 02:33:44,961 --> 02:33:44,961 6293 02:33:44,961 --> 02:33:47,043 public setting on record to be 6294 02:33:47,043 --> 02:33:47,043 6295 02:33:47,043 --> 02:33:48,066 able to comment about what has 6296 02:33:48,066 --> 02:33:48,435 6297 02:33:48,435 --> 02:33:50,032 gone on in the previous year. 6298 02:33:50,032 --> 02:33:52,930 >> so that happens once per yea 6299 02:33:52,930 --> 02:33:52,930 r 6300 02:33:52,930 --> 02:33:53,913 is what you are talking about. 6301 02:33:53,913 --> 02:33:53,913 6302 02:33:53,913 --> 02:33:54,598 >> yes, ma'am. 6303 02:33:54,598 --> 02:33:56,576 >> what I am talking about is 6304 02:33:56,576 --> 02:33:56,576 6305 02:33:56,576 --> 02:33:58,306 the police advisory council tha 6306 02:33:58,306 --> 02:33:58,306 t 6307 02:33:58,306 --> 02:33:59,291 meets how often? 6308 02:33:59,291 --> 02:34:00,816 >> good morning, commissioner. 6309 02:34:00,816 --> 02:34:00,816 6310 02:34:00,816 --> 02:34:02,309 good morning, mr. City manager, 6311 02:34:02,309 --> 02:34:03,541 6312 02:34:03,541 --> 02:34:03,998 mr. Mayor. 6313 02:34:03,998 --> 02:34:08,017 absolutely. That council is th 6314 02:34:08,017 --> 02:34:08,615 ere for 6315 02:34:08,615 --> 02:34:10,291 several reasons, one of which I 6316 02:34:10,291 --> 02:34:10,291 s 6317 02:34:10,291 --> 02:34:11,583 to give us advice. 6318 02:34:11,583 --> 02:34:12,851 to have some degree of oversigh 6319 02:34:12,851 --> 02:34:12,851 t 6320 02:34:12,851 --> 02:34:14,376 to our processes. 6321 02:34:14,376 --> 02:34:17,476 I see this as just that. 6322 02:34:17,476 --> 02:34:19,145 so if the commission wanted to 6323 02:34:19,145 --> 02:34:19,337 6324 02:34:19,337 --> 02:34:20,705 give direction to that council, 6325 02:34:20,705 --> 02:34:21,402 6326 02:34:21,402 --> 02:34:22,203 certainly that would be within 6327 02:34:22,203 --> 02:34:22,342 6328 02:34:22,342 --> 02:34:23,048 the purview. 6329 02:34:23,048 --> 02:34:27,265 and we would make whatever 6330 02:34:27,265 --> 02:34:29,270 reported timeline, so on a 6331 02:34:29,270 --> 02:34:30,774 monthly, ongoing, status repor 6332 02:34:30,774 --> 02:34:31,005 t 6333 02:34:31,005 --> 02:34:32,414 because we meet with council 6334 02:34:32,414 --> 02:34:33,813 every month, then that is what 6335 02:34:33,813 --> 02:34:34,144 6336 02:34:34,144 --> 02:34:34,580 we would do. 6337 02:34:34,580 --> 02:34:37,590 despite the annual reported 6338 02:34:37,590 --> 02:34:38,382 mandate statutorily. 6339 02:34:38,382 --> 02:34:39,803 >> I would be interested in 6340 02:34:39,803 --> 02:34:39,803 that. 6341 02:34:39,803 --> 02:34:42,093 I wonder if it's the appetite 6342 02:34:42,093 --> 02:34:42,093 of 6343 02:34:42,093 --> 02:34:44,491 my colleagues, but I will make 6344 02:34:44,491 --> 02:34:44,653 6345 02:34:44,653 --> 02:34:47,592 that motion because I think to 6346 02:34:47,592 --> 02:34:47,818 6347 02:34:47,818 --> 02:34:49,328 put us at ease, to put the 6348 02:34:49,328 --> 02:34:50,327 community at ease, and to make 6349 02:34:50,327 --> 02:34:50,530 6350 02:34:50,530 --> 02:34:52,032 sure we are staying on top of 6351 02:34:52,032 --> 02:34:52,032 6352 02:34:52,032 --> 02:34:53,172 what's happening with our 6353 02:34:53,172 --> 02:34:54,539 neighbors, I definitely, 6354 02:34:54,539 --> 02:34:55,668 especially if it's going to not 6355 02:34:55,668 --> 02:34:55,839 6356 02:34:55,839 --> 02:34:57,636 be that much of an impact, we d 6357 02:34:57,636 --> 02:34:57,636 o 6358 02:34:57,636 --> 02:34:59,976 have a board that sits there for 6359 02:34:59,976 --> 02:34:59,976 6360 02:34:59,976 --> 02:35:01,846 this particular reason, and I 6361 02:35:01,846 --> 02:35:01,846 6362 02:35:01,846 --> 02:35:03,578 think that a lot of them might 6363 02:35:03,578 --> 02:35:03,708 6364 02:35:03,708 --> 02:35:06,070 be interested in this as well. 6365 02:35:06,070 --> 02:35:06,070 6366 02:35:06,070 --> 02:35:09,250 but I move that we enlist the 6367 02:35:09,250 --> 02:35:09,250 6368 02:35:09,250 --> 02:35:12,542 police advisory council to 6369 02:35:12,542 --> 02:35:15,290 provide a monthly, ongoing -- 6370 02:35:15,290 --> 02:35:15,290 6371 02:35:15,290 --> 02:35:15,290 commissioner? 6372 02:35:15,290 --> 02:35:16,150 >> sorry. 6373 02:35:16,150 --> 02:35:17,334 the only thing that is still 6374 02:35:17,334 --> 02:35:17,784 unknown to us. 6375 02:35:17,784 --> 02:35:18,422 >> yes. 6376 02:35:18,422 --> 02:35:20,552 >> is the impact on how we're 6377 02:35:20,552 --> 02:35:20,552 6378 02:35:20,552 --> 02:35:22,754 going to capture the data, 6379 02:35:22,754 --> 02:35:22,754 right? 6380 02:35:22,754 --> 02:35:24,830 the instrument to capture data 6381 02:35:24,830 --> 02:35:25,436 6382 02:35:25,436 --> 02:35:26,026 is yet unknown. 6383 02:35:26,026 --> 02:35:29,028 so a lot of this will be all 6384 02:35:29,028 --> 02:35:30,398 hands on deck using our 6385 02:35:30,398 --> 02:35:32,900 analysts, using our traffic 6386 02:35:32,900 --> 02:35:33,884 personnel, so I don't have a 6387 02:35:33,884 --> 02:35:35,268 clear picture yet as to how eas 6388 02:35:35,268 --> 02:35:35,268 y 6389 02:35:35,268 --> 02:35:36,045 it is going to be. 6390 02:35:36,045 --> 02:35:36,542 >> right. 6391 02:35:36,542 --> 02:35:38,559 >> so maybe we can have further 6392 02:35:38,559 --> 02:35:38,840 6393 02:35:38,840 --> 02:35:39,672 dialogue whether it's monthly, 6394 02:35:39,672 --> 02:35:40,002 6395 02:35:40,002 --> 02:35:41,646 whether it's quarterly, not 6396 02:35:41,646 --> 02:35:41,646 sure. 6397 02:35:41,646 --> 02:35:43,106 but whatever the commission 6398 02:35:43,106 --> 02:35:44,580 arrives at at a reasonable 6399 02:35:44,580 --> 02:35:45,600 timeline, I think we can deliver 6400 02:35:45,600 --> 02:35:45,600 6401 02:35:45,600 --> 02:35:45,600 that. 6402 02:35:45,600 --> 02:35:47,654 >> okay. 6403 02:35:47,654 --> 02:35:50,652 so let me take the monthly out 6404 02:35:50,652 --> 02:35:50,960 6405 02:35:50,960 --> 02:35:50,960 now. 6406 02:35:50,960 --> 02:35:53,190 I'll take the monthly out. 6407 02:35:53,190 --> 02:35:57,628 let me just say it like this. 6408 02:35:57,628 --> 02:36:02,562 in response to community need, 6409 02:36:02,562 --> 02:36:02,994 6410 02:36:02,994 --> 02:36:07,164 in response to a level of 6411 02:36:07,164 --> 02:36:09,187 transparency, I'm interested I 6412 02:36:09,187 --> 02:36:09,400 n 6413 02:36:09,400 --> 02:36:11,538 us being able to provide 6414 02:36:11,538 --> 02:36:11,847 additional information. 6415 02:36:11,847 --> 02:36:15,150 I'm interested in additional 6416 02:36:15,150 --> 02:36:17,416 analysis, okay, that can 6417 02:36:17,416 --> 02:36:18,270 apparently be done through our 6418 02:36:18,270 --> 02:36:18,448 6419 02:36:18,448 --> 02:36:19,385 police advisory council. 6420 02:36:19,385 --> 02:36:21,881 now, if that's not done on a 6421 02:36:21,881 --> 02:36:23,890 monthly basis, maybe that's 6422 02:36:23,890 --> 02:36:23,890 fine. 6423 02:36:23,890 --> 02:36:26,319 but maybe a quarterly basis. 6424 02:36:26,319 --> 02:36:27,426 because I hear you. 6425 02:36:27,426 --> 02:36:30,547 ther are still a number of 6426 02:36:30,547 --> 02:36:30,828 unknowns here. 6427 02:36:30,828 --> 02:36:34,733 >> commissioner, we can always 6428 02:36:34,733 --> 02:36:34,964 6429 02:36:34,964 --> 02:36:36,408 as we go along adjust that. 6430 02:36:36,408 --> 02:36:38,144 >> yeah, that's what I'm 6431 02:36:38,144 --> 02:36:38,144 thinking. 6432 02:36:38,144 --> 02:36:41,300 right now let's do quarterly 6433 02:36:41,300 --> 02:36:42,506 because maybe that's the lowes 6434 02:36:42,506 --> 02:36:42,938 t 6435 02:36:42,938 --> 02:36:42,938 burden. 6436 02:36:42,938 --> 02:36:47,146 and it allows you a chance to 6437 02:36:47,146 --> 02:36:47,146 6438 02:36:47,146 --> 02:36:48,144 figure things out. 6439 02:36:48,144 --> 02:36:49,675 give your advisory council a 6440 02:36:49,675 --> 02:36:51,426 chance to figure things out an 6441 02:36:51,426 --> 02:36:51,515 d 6442 02:36:51,515 --> 02:36:53,112 you all speaking with them and 6443 02:36:53,112 --> 02:36:53,681 6444 02:36:53,681 --> 02:36:55,213 as developments arise in terms 6445 02:36:55,213 --> 02:36:55,614 6446 02:36:55,614 --> 02:36:57,196 of how the data will be 6447 02:36:57,196 --> 02:36:58,321 captured, all of that can come 6448 02:36:58,321 --> 02:36:58,496 6449 02:36:58,496 --> 02:36:58,496 in. 6450 02:36:58,496 --> 02:36:59,320 you hear my concern. 6451 02:36:59,320 --> 02:37:02,200 I'm trying to cobble this 6452 02:37:02,200 --> 02:37:04,860 together on the fly here. 6453 02:37:04,860 --> 02:37:07,211 but the motion is essentially t 6454 02:37:07,211 --> 02:37:07,211 o 6455 02:37:07,211 --> 02:37:09,896 involve the police advisory 6456 02:37:09,896 --> 02:37:12,506 council in an ongoing way to b 6457 02:37:12,506 --> 02:37:14,302 e 6458 02:37:14,302 --> 02:37:15,774 able to analyze this -- the dat 6459 02:37:15,774 --> 02:37:15,774 a 6460 02:37:15,774 --> 02:37:17,044 that has been captured from the 6461 02:37:17,044 --> 02:37:18,851 6462 02:37:18,851 --> 02:37:19,515 red light cameras. 6463 02:37:19,515 --> 02:37:21,709 >> got it. 6464 02:37:21,709 --> 02:37:22,772 >> mayor: is there a second? 6465 02:37:22,772 --> 02:37:24,373 we have a motion and a second. 6466 02:37:24,373 --> 02:37:24,373 6467 02:37:24,373 --> 02:37:27,250 commissioner ingle? 6468 02:37:27,250 --> 02:37:29,582 >> I will get it after this 6469 02:37:29,582 --> 02:37:29,582 motion. 6470 02:37:29,582 --> 02:37:30,419 >> mayor: gotcha. 6471 02:37:30,419 --> 02:37:30,419 okay. 6472 02:37:30,419 --> 02:37:32,369 mr. Manager? 6473 02:37:32,369 --> 02:37:33,817 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 6474 02:37:33,817 --> 02:37:35,219 I was going to point out, too, 6475 02:37:35,219 --> 02:37:35,513 6476 02:37:35,513 --> 02:37:36,525 we can certainly include this 6477 02:37:36,525 --> 02:37:36,525 6478 02:37:36,525 --> 02:37:37,493 information as we collect it I 6479 02:37:37,493 --> 02:37:37,542 n 6480 02:37:37,542 --> 02:37:39,794 the quarterly reports and 6481 02:37:39,794 --> 02:37:40,731 presentations that g.d.p. Gives 6482 02:37:40,731 --> 02:37:40,970 6483 02:37:40,970 --> 02:37:41,461 you all, too. 6484 02:37:41,461 --> 02:37:42,576 >> excellent. 6485 02:37:42,576 --> 02:37:43,471 >> mayor: very good. 6486 02:37:43,471 --> 02:37:44,154 commissioner book? 6487 02:37:44,154 --> 02:37:46,704 >> yeah, commissioner 6488 02:37:46,704 --> 02:37:47,499 duncan-walker, more community 6489 02:37:47,499 --> 02:37:47,499 6490 02:37:47,499 --> 02:37:49,147 sentiment and evaluation does 6491 02:37:49,147 --> 02:37:49,147 6492 02:37:49,147 --> 02:37:51,367 not hurt is us in any way. 6493 02:37:51,367 --> 02:37:52,820 it is a good thing, and I think 6494 02:37:52,820 --> 02:37:52,820 6495 02:37:52,820 --> 02:37:54,641 the mayor pro tem was eluding t 6496 02:37:54,641 --> 02:37:54,641 o 6497 02:37:54,641 --> 02:37:55,165 that, too. 6498 02:37:55,165 --> 02:37:57,075 any way we get that and as 6499 02:37:57,075 --> 02:37:58,548 things go on, I think is a goo 6500 02:37:58,548 --> 02:37:58,813 d 6501 02:37:58,813 --> 02:37:58,813 idea. 6502 02:37:58,813 --> 02:37:59,340 thank you. 6503 02:37:59,340 --> 02:38:00,178 >> mayor: thank you, 6504 02:38:00,178 --> 02:38:01,119 commissioner book. 6505 02:38:01,119 --> 02:38:02,546 all in favor please say aye. 6506 02:38:02,546 --> 02:38:03,182 any opposed? 6507 02:38:03,182 --> 02:38:03,666 all right. 6508 02:38:03,666 --> 02:38:04,855 that passes unanimously. 6509 02:38:04,855 --> 02:38:06,509 commissioner ingle, did you hav 6510 02:38:06,509 --> 02:38:06,509 e 6511 02:38:06,509 --> 02:38:06,977 something to add? 6512 02:38:06,977 --> 02:38:09,929 >> yeah, just to throw onto 6513 02:38:09,929 --> 02:38:09,929 that. 6514 02:38:09,929 --> 02:38:11,292 I think we have talked about I 6515 02:38:11,292 --> 02:38:11,410 t 6516 02:38:11,410 --> 02:38:12,696 every time this has come up, a 6517 02:38:12,696 --> 02:38:13,366 n 6518 02:38:13,366 --> 02:38:14,907 issue and the concerns as part 6519 02:38:14,907 --> 02:38:14,989 6520 02:38:14,989 --> 02:38:16,930 of the report and as part of the 6521 02:38:16,930 --> 02:38:16,930 6522 02:38:16,930 --> 02:38:17,954 feedback and everything else, I 6523 02:38:17,954 --> 02:38:18,132 6524 02:38:18,132 --> 02:38:20,114 really want to get some answer 6525 02:38:20,114 --> 02:38:20,463 6526 02:38:20,463 --> 02:38:21,332 on how many of those red light 6527 02:38:21,332 --> 02:38:23,679 6528 02:38:23,679 --> 02:38:25,569 tickets are rolling over into 6529 02:38:25,569 --> 02:38:25,569 6530 02:38:25,569 --> 02:38:27,673 traffic tickets and not just a 6531 02:38:27,673 --> 02:38:27,775 6532 02:38:27,775 --> 02:38:28,741 civil violation, but actually 6533 02:38:28,741 --> 02:38:28,741 6534 02:38:28,741 --> 02:38:29,353 rolled over to that. 6535 02:38:29,353 --> 02:38:32,007 and I know you said there was 6536 02:38:32,007 --> 02:38:32,007 6537 02:38:32,007 --> 02:38:33,247 complications in figuring out 6538 02:38:33,247 --> 02:38:33,247 6539 02:38:33,247 --> 02:38:34,039 where that information was hel 6540 02:38:34,039 --> 02:38:34,177 d 6541 02:38:34,177 --> 02:38:35,629 and all that, but I want to mak 6542 02:38:35,629 --> 02:38:35,629 e 6543 02:38:35,629 --> 02:38:36,916 sure as part of the report we 6544 02:38:36,916 --> 02:38:38,910 are getting an update of how 6545 02:38:38,910 --> 02:38:40,017 many of these civil violations 6546 02:38:40,017 --> 02:38:40,283 6547 02:38:40,283 --> 02:38:43,857 end up rolling over into the 6548 02:38:43,857 --> 02:38:44,725 standard traffic violations. 6549 02:38:44,725 --> 02:38:45,279 thank you. 6550 02:38:45,279 --> 02:38:46,083 >> mayor: all right. 6551 02:38:46,083 --> 02:38:47,375 thank you, commissioner ingle. 6552 02:38:47,375 --> 02:38:47,375 6553 02:38:47,375 --> 02:38:48,281 all right. 6554 02:38:48,281 --> 02:38:51,114 I see no no further lights. 6555 02:38:51,114 --> 02:38:53,168 we will reconvene at 1:00. 6556 00:00:00,000 --> 23:48:52,298 . 6557 23:48:52,298 --> 00:03:42,279 >> mayor: good afternoon, 6558 00:03:42,279 --> 00:03:42,279 everyone. 6559 00:03:42,279 --> 00:03:43,716 welcome to the afternoon 6560 00:03:43,716 --> 00:03:47,027 association of this april 2nd, 6561 00:03:47,027 --> 00:03:47,027 6562 00:03:47,027 --> 00:03:47,895 2026, city commission meeting. 6563 00:03:47,895 --> 00:03:47,895 6564 00:03:47,895 --> 00:03:49,431 the afternoon will be just as 6565 00:03:49,431 --> 00:03:51,365 packed as the morning was. 6566 00:03:51,365 --> 00:03:52,829 madam clerk. 6567 00:03:52,829 --> 00:03:57,269 >> mr. Mayor, we have the 6568 00:03:57,269 --> 00:03:58,657 gainesville history moment to b 6569 00:03:58,657 --> 00:03:58,657 e 6570 00:03:58,657 --> 00:04:00,003 presented by ms. Donna waller. 6571 00:04:00,003 --> 00:04:00,003 6572 00:04:00,003 --> 00:04:04,145 >> mayor: welcome. 6573 00:04:04,145 --> 00:04:06,712 good to see you. 6574 00:04:06,712 --> 00:04:09,211 >> always nice to see you 6575 00:04:09,211 --> 00:04:09,211 folks. 6576 00:04:09,211 --> 00:04:15,017 today some of you may remember 6577 00:04:15,017 --> 00:04:15,017 6578 00:04:15,017 --> 00:04:17,057 that I was, that last time I was 6579 00:04:17,057 --> 00:04:17,057 6580 00:04:17,057 --> 00:04:22,991 here, I talked about essential 6581 00:04:22,991 --> 00:04:22,991 ly 6582 00:04:22,991 --> 00:04:26,293 the african american background 6583 00:04:26,293 --> 00:04:26,293 6584 00:04:26,293 --> 00:04:30,576 of gainesville and own one of 6585 00:04:30,576 --> 00:04:31,775 the things I pointed out was t 6586 00:04:31,775 --> 00:04:31,775 he 6587 00:04:31,775 --> 00:04:34,713 pleasant striet plez -- 6588 00:04:34,713 --> 00:04:34,933 pleasant 6589 00:04:34,933 --> 00:04:36,051 street neighborhood wasn't jus 6590 00:04:36,051 --> 00:04:36,051 t 6591 00:04:36,051 --> 00:04:36,863 gainesville's first african 6592 00:04:36,863 --> 00:04:37,591 american neighborhood but it wa 6593 00:04:37,591 --> 00:04:37,591 s 6594 00:04:37,591 --> 00:04:42,076 really gainesville's first real 6595 00:04:42,076 --> 00:04:42,076 6596 00:04:42,076 --> 00:04:45,879 neighborhood, and so today wha 6597 00:04:45,879 --> 00:04:45,879 t 6598 00:04:45,879 --> 00:04:49,851 I want to talk about is what w 6599 00:04:49,851 --> 00:04:49,851 as 6600 00:04:49,851 --> 00:04:54,125 actually the first real white 6601 00:04:54,125 --> 00:04:56,523 neighborhood in gainesville. 6602 00:04:56,523 --> 00:05:00,131 and I want to start and ask you 6603 00:05:00,131 --> 00:05:00,131 6604 00:05:00,131 --> 00:05:04,869 to sort of consider this fact, 6605 00:05:04,869 --> 00:05:04,869 6606 00:05:04,869 --> 00:05:06,661 which plays off something else 6607 00:05:06,661 --> 00:05:06,661 I 6608 00:05:06,661 --> 00:05:08,110 said last month. 6609 00:05:08,110 --> 00:05:12,145 which is that in 1860, which I 6610 00:05:12,145 --> 00:05:12,145 s 6611 00:05:12,145 --> 00:05:14,105 the year when the civil war 6612 00:05:14,105 --> 00:05:21,121 broke out, gainesville had 223 6613 00:05:21,121 --> 00:05:21,121 6614 00:05:21,121 --> 00:05:25,229 white residents according to th 6615 00:05:25,229 --> 00:05:25,229 e 6616 00:05:25,229 --> 00:05:26,609 1860 census. 6617 00:05:26,609 --> 00:05:29,997 so when you think about the 6618 00:05:29,997 --> 00:05:32,303 development of gainesville, yo 6619 00:05:32,303 --> 00:05:32,303 u 6620 00:05:32,303 --> 00:05:39,405 want to recognize that at, sor 6621 00:05:39,405 --> 00:05:39,405 t 6622 00:05:39,405 --> 00:05:41,377 of the moment of chartering in 6623 00:05:41,377 --> 00:05:41,377 6624 00:05:41,377 --> 00:05:45,541 many ways, gainesville really 6625 00:05:45,541 --> 00:05:48,913 only had what we would think o 6626 00:05:48,913 --> 00:05:48,913 f 6627 00:05:48,913 --> 00:05:53,289 as a block of permanent white 6628 00:05:53,289 --> 00:05:53,289 residents. 6629 00:05:53,289 --> 00:05:58,989 and just like pleasant street 6630 00:05:58,989 --> 00:06:00,857 and the african american 6631 00:06:00,857 --> 00:06:04,173 population grew because of the 6632 00:06:04,173 --> 00:06:04,173 6633 00:06:04,173 --> 00:06:08,069 war and the railroads, so did 6634 00:06:08,069 --> 00:06:10,265 the white population, and you 6635 00:06:10,265 --> 00:06:14,974 might recall that I said that 6636 00:06:14,974 --> 00:06:16,272 african americans and people o 6637 00:06:16,272 --> 00:06:16,272 f 6638 00:06:16,272 --> 00:06:18,369 color were majority of this 6639 00:06:18,369 --> 00:06:18,369 county. 6640 00:06:18,369 --> 00:06:24,381 up through the 1880s. 6641 00:06:24,381 --> 00:06:27,219 and it was, it was the railroads 6642 00:06:27,219 --> 00:06:27,219 6643 00:06:27,219 --> 00:06:30,522 that changed all that. 6644 00:06:30,522 --> 00:06:32,085 gainesville was very lucky tha 6645 00:06:32,085 --> 00:06:32,085 t 6646 00:06:32,085 --> 00:06:34,565 the union armies did not pull u 6647 00:06:34,565 --> 00:06:34,565 p 6648 00:06:34,565 --> 00:06:37,689 the railroad tracks during the 6649 00:06:37,689 --> 00:06:37,689 6650 00:06:37,689 --> 00:06:37,689 war. 6651 00:06:37,689 --> 00:06:39,894 and by the 1880s, the 6652 00:06:39,894 --> 00:06:43,469 railroads had expanded greatly 6653 00:06:43,469 --> 00:06:43,469 6654 00:06:43,469 --> 00:06:46,734 in florida, but I'm always 6655 00:06:46,734 --> 00:06:49,065 learning new stuff, and this I 6656 00:06:49,065 --> 00:06:49,065 s 6657 00:06:49,065 --> 00:06:51,341 the new one for this time. 6658 00:06:51,341 --> 00:06:53,615 I did not properly understand 6659 00:06:53,615 --> 00:06:57,149 until last week that gainesvil 6660 00:06:57,149 --> 00:06:57,149 le 6661 00:06:57,149 --> 00:07:00,648 was essentially the last 6662 00:07:00,648 --> 00:07:05,601 railroad stop in central flori 6663 00:07:05,601 --> 00:07:05,601 da 6664 00:07:05,601 --> 00:07:10,828 until after 1900. 6665 00:07:10,828 --> 00:07:12,480 if you wanted to come to florida 6666 00:07:12,480 --> 00:07:12,480 6667 00:07:12,480 --> 00:07:16,196 and go further south, you had t 6668 00:07:16,196 --> 00:07:16,196 o 6669 00:07:16,196 --> 00:07:19,932 take a wagon train or some oth 6670 00:07:19,932 --> 00:07:19,932 er 6671 00:07:19,932 --> 00:07:23,636 kind of vehicle. 6672 00:07:23,636 --> 00:07:25,290 so when you think about why we 6673 00:07:25,290 --> 00:07:25,290 6674 00:07:25,290 --> 00:07:29,216 have that train on our seal up 6675 00:07:29,216 --> 00:07:29,216 6676 00:07:29,216 --> 00:07:32,210 above the mayor's head, it's 6677 00:07:32,210 --> 00:07:34,518 because this town was really 6678 00:07:34,518 --> 00:07:37,589 made by the railroads in a ver 6679 00:07:37,589 --> 00:07:37,589 y 6680 00:07:37,589 --> 00:07:39,225 real sense. 6681 00:07:39,225 --> 00:07:43,160 and by the 1880s, what, what 6682 00:07:43,160 --> 00:07:45,893 that railroad had done was to 6683 00:07:45,893 --> 00:07:49,266 make this area the single 6684 00:07:49,266 --> 00:07:54,100 largest producer of sea island 6685 00:07:54,100 --> 00:07:54,100 6686 00:07:54,100 --> 00:07:56,134 cotton in the entire state of 6687 00:07:56,134 --> 00:07:56,134 florida. 6688 00:07:56,134 --> 00:08:02,652 and two-thirds of the state's 6689 00:08:02,652 --> 00:08:04,456 agricultural products were 6690 00:08:04,456 --> 00:08:09,220 shipped out of gainesville. 6691 00:08:09,220 --> 00:08:16,096 and so what you kind of have t 6692 00:08:16,096 --> 00:08:16,096 o 6693 00:08:16,096 --> 00:08:20,784 understand is that after the w 6694 00:08:20,784 --> 00:08:20,784 ar 6695 00:08:20,784 --> 00:08:22,968 and by the 1880s, people were 6696 00:08:22,968 --> 00:08:24,972 moving into the area and movin 6697 00:08:24,972 --> 00:08:24,972 g 6698 00:08:24,972 --> 00:08:28,166 into gainesville for economic 6699 00:08:28,166 --> 00:08:28,166 reasons. 6700 00:08:28,166 --> 00:08:31,802 it was really boom time here. 6701 00:08:31,802 --> 00:08:34,241 there hadn't been a lot of 6702 00:08:34,241 --> 00:08:37,176 damage during the war, and it 6703 00:08:37,176 --> 00:08:40,355 was all about cotton and 6704 00:08:40,355 --> 00:08:42,891 oranges, and then in the 6705 00:08:42,891 --> 00:08:46,057 1890s, there were series of 6706 00:08:46,057 --> 00:08:50,894 big freezes that simply wiped 6707 00:08:50,894 --> 00:08:53,492 out agriculture, but lucky for 6708 00:08:53,492 --> 00:08:53,492 6709 00:08:53,492 --> 00:08:59,284 us, by the time that occurred, 6710 00:08:59,284 --> 00:08:59,284 6711 00:08:59,284 --> 00:09:02,469 florida had begun to be a 6712 00:09:02,469 --> 00:09:04,678 tourist attraction. 6713 00:09:04,678 --> 00:09:09,681 and again, the railroads broug 6714 00:09:09,681 --> 00:09:09,681 ht 6715 00:09:09,681 --> 00:09:12,223 the tourists down here. 6716 00:09:12,223 --> 00:09:17,719 and what happened around 1900 6717 00:09:17,719 --> 00:09:21,155 was the first of the florida 6718 00:09:21,155 --> 00:09:24,803 great real estate booms, and 6719 00:09:24,803 --> 00:09:28,533 gainesville really benefited 6720 00:09:28,533 --> 00:09:34,343 from that, and the specific 6721 00:09:34,343 --> 00:09:35,639 neighborhood I want to talk 6722 00:09:35,639 --> 00:09:39,779 about today is actually the duc 6723 00:09:39,779 --> 00:09:39,779 k 6724 00:09:39,779 --> 00:09:39,779 pond. 6725 00:09:39,779 --> 00:09:44,385 if you think about the growth o 6726 00:09:44,385 --> 00:09:44,385 f 6727 00:09:44,385 --> 00:09:49,083 gainesville and those 223 6728 00:09:49,083 --> 00:09:50,089 people, most of them lived on 6729 00:09:50,089 --> 00:09:52,556 warlz or plantation houses. 6730 00:09:52,556 --> 00:09:54,585 if you look at that little hou 6731 00:09:54,585 --> 00:09:54,585 se 6732 00:09:54,585 --> 00:09:57,291 over on the math eosin propert 6733 00:09:57,291 --> 00:09:57,291 y, 6734 00:09:57,291 --> 00:09:59,831 that was the original farm 6735 00:09:59,831 --> 00:10:02,747 house, and it was up on a hill, 6736 00:10:02,747 --> 00:10:02,747 6737 00:10:02,747 --> 00:10:04,533 and there was nothing around I 6738 00:10:04,533 --> 00:10:04,533 t 6739 00:10:04,533 --> 00:10:11,723 until the math matheson's b 6740 00:10:11,723 --> 00:10:11,723 uilt 6741 00:10:11,723 --> 00:10:12,743 the better house where the muse 6742 00:10:12,743 --> 00:10:12,743 6743 00:10:12,743 --> 00:10:13,949 ement is and that did not happe 6744 00:10:13,949 --> 00:10:13,949 n 6745 00:10:13,949 --> 00:10:16,349 until the 1890s. 6746 00:10:16,349 --> 00:10:19,851 so beginning in the early 6747 00:10:19,851 --> 00:10:23,457 1900s, there was a real estate 6748 00:10:23,457 --> 00:10:23,457 6749 00:10:23,457 --> 00:10:25,761 boom, and one of the developer 6750 00:10:25,761 --> 00:10:25,761 s 6751 00:10:25,761 --> 00:10:27,861 is a name that you've heard a 6752 00:10:27,861 --> 00:10:33,966 lot from me, mr. William ruben 6753 00:10:33,966 --> 00:10:33,966 6754 00:10:33,966 --> 00:10:36,370 thomas of the thomas center. 6755 00:10:36,370 --> 00:10:39,341 and you'll recall that someone 6756 00:10:39,341 --> 00:10:39,341 6757 00:10:39,341 --> 00:10:41,611 else started his house, which 6758 00:10:41,611 --> 00:10:45,773 was called sun kissed villa, a 6759 00:10:45,773 --> 00:10:45,773 nd 6760 00:10:45,773 --> 00:10:47,945 he took it over and finished I 6761 00:10:47,945 --> 00:10:47,945 t 6762 00:10:47,945 --> 00:10:51,351 in 1910 and while that was goi 6763 00:10:51,351 --> 00:10:51,351 ng 6764 00:10:51,351 --> 00:10:55,851 on, he started developing an 6765 00:10:55,851 --> 00:10:58,891 adjacent area to his house, 6766 00:10:58,891 --> 00:11:01,864 which is now the thomas center, 6767 00:11:01,864 --> 00:11:01,864 6768 00:11:01,864 --> 00:11:07,433 and it was called sun sunkist 6769 00:11:07,433 --> 00:11:07,433 6770 00:11:07,433 --> 00:11:09,481 like the sun kissed villa, and 6771 00:11:09,481 --> 00:11:09,969 a 6772 00:11:09,969 --> 00:11:11,719 number of the houses in the duc 6773 00:11:11,719 --> 00:11:11,719 k 6774 00:11:11,719 --> 00:11:14,338 pond that are built in the 6775 00:11:14,338 --> 00:11:19,150 1890s are part of the original 6776 00:11:19,150 --> 00:11:19,150 6777 00:11:19,150 --> 00:11:24,089 sun kissed development which w 6778 00:11:24,089 --> 00:11:24,089 as 6779 00:11:24,089 --> 00:11:26,909 around thomas' house, but the 6780 00:11:26,909 --> 00:11:29,417 real story of the duck pond is 6781 00:11:29,417 --> 00:11:29,417 6782 00:11:29,417 --> 00:11:32,590 one of his neighbors. 6783 00:11:32,590 --> 00:11:36,895 in 1910a man named james 6784 00:11:36,895 --> 00:11:40,597 videl -- vidal moved into a 6785 00:11:40,597 --> 00:11:43,432 house pretty close to where 6786 00:11:43,432 --> 00:11:46,974 thomas lived about a block awa 6787 00:11:46,974 --> 00:11:46,974 y 6788 00:11:46,974 --> 00:11:50,344 from the thomas estate. 6789 00:11:50,344 --> 00:11:56,910 and in 1922, he talked william 6790 00:11:56,910 --> 00:11:56,910 6791 00:11:56,910 --> 00:12:00,373 ruben thomas into selling him a 6792 00:12:00,373 --> 00:12:00,373 6793 00:12:00,373 --> 00:12:03,687 lot of the acreage around the 6794 00:12:03,687 --> 00:12:07,830 thomas center, and it was to 6795 00:12:07,830 --> 00:12:09,971 become a development that came 6796 00:12:09,971 --> 00:12:09,971 6797 00:12:09,971 --> 00:12:14,306 to be called the highlands 6798 00:12:14,306 --> 00:12:14,306 neighborhood. 6799 00:12:14,306 --> 00:12:20,547 and in 1926, vidal who was 6800 00:12:20,547 --> 00:12:22,611 actually a kind of a sybil 6801 00:12:22,611 --> 00:12:27,452 engineer and a city planner 6802 00:12:27,452 --> 00:12:29,084 dammed a part of sweetwater 6803 00:12:29,084 --> 00:12:34,560 creek and created what was 6804 00:12:34,560 --> 00:12:38,724 maybe, there's a contending, 6805 00:12:38,724 --> 00:12:42,664 another contender here, but in 6806 00:12:42,664 --> 00:12:42,664 6807 00:12:42,664 --> 00:12:46,132 1926 what vidal did was to 6808 00:12:46,132 --> 00:12:50,636 create the first public park I 6809 00:12:50,636 --> 00:12:50,636 n 6810 00:12:50,636 --> 00:12:50,636 gainesville. 6811 00:12:50,636 --> 00:12:52,936 inside the city of gainesville. 6812 00:12:52,936 --> 00:12:52,936 6813 00:12:52,936 --> 00:12:56,208 and that was the duck pond. 6814 00:12:56,208 --> 00:12:59,378 and if you walk around the duc 6815 00:12:59,378 --> 00:12:59,378 k 6816 00:12:59,378 --> 00:13:04,184 pond area, you'll see that man 6817 00:13:04,184 --> 00:13:04,184 y 6818 00:13:04,184 --> 00:13:07,786 of the houses are from the 6819 00:13:07,786 --> 00:13:10,657 1920s in the northeast 6820 00:13:10,657 --> 00:13:11,770 historic area. 6821 00:13:11,770 --> 00:13:14,724 some of them date from the fir 6822 00:13:14,724 --> 00:13:14,724 st 6823 00:13:14,724 --> 00:13:16,694 wave, the sun kissed 6824 00:13:16,694 --> 00:13:19,130 development, but a lot of the 6825 00:13:19,130 --> 00:13:20,398 houses in the duck pond were 6826 00:13:20,398 --> 00:13:23,566 built in the 1920s as part of 6827 00:13:23,566 --> 00:13:27,958 the highland neighborhood. 6828 00:13:27,958 --> 00:13:32,976 and it really was in many ways 6829 00:13:32,976 --> 00:13:32,976 6830 00:13:32,976 --> 00:13:36,684 the first downtown white 6831 00:13:36,684 --> 00:13:39,658 neighborhood in gainesville 6832 00:13:39,658 --> 00:13:42,958 starting in the -- around 1900 6833 00:13:42,958 --> 00:13:42,958 6834 00:13:42,958 --> 00:13:46,688 and then with a big growth spu 6835 00:13:46,688 --> 00:13:46,688 rt 6836 00:13:46,688 --> 00:13:48,306 in the 1920s. 6837 00:13:48,306 --> 00:13:50,058 and that was when the duck pon 6838 00:13:50,058 --> 00:13:50,058 d 6839 00:13:50,058 --> 00:13:56,638 appeared, and in 1980, the 6840 00:13:56,638 --> 00:14:00,472 entire northeast historic 6841 00:14:00,472 --> 00:14:03,550 district was put on the nationa 6842 00:14:03,550 --> 00:14:03,550 l 6843 00:14:03,550 --> 00:14:07,588 register of historic places, a 6844 00:14:07,588 --> 00:14:07,588 nd 6845 00:14:07,588 --> 00:14:09,244 if you walk around the duck 6846 00:14:09,244 --> 00:14:12,965 pond, you see a huge range of 6847 00:14:12,965 --> 00:14:15,722 architectural styles in these 6848 00:14:15,722 --> 00:14:17,424 houses that were essentially 6849 00:14:17,424 --> 00:14:23,328 built from 1900 through about 6850 00:14:23,328 --> 00:14:25,560 1927 or so. 6851 00:14:25,560 --> 00:14:26,210 >> mayor: thank you so much. 6852 00:14:26,210 --> 00:14:28,468 appreciate it. 6853 00:14:28,468 --> 00:14:28,933 all right. 6854 00:14:28,933 --> 00:14:30,070 madam clerk. 6855 00:14:30,070 --> 00:14:32,469 >> mr. Mayor, we have early 6856 00:14:32,469 --> 00:14:33,672 public comment, but we don't 6857 00:14:33,672 --> 00:14:35,102 have anyone signed up there. 6858 00:14:35,102 --> 00:14:36,974 we currently have six speakers 6859 00:14:36,974 --> 00:14:36,974 6860 00:14:36,974 --> 00:14:39,148 for general public comment. 6861 00:14:39,148 --> 00:14:40,682 I'm going to say the person 6862 00:14:40,682 --> 00:14:42,120 speaking and then a couple of 6863 00:14:42,120 --> 00:14:43,223 after so people know who's 6864 00:14:43,223 --> 00:14:45,148 coming up next. 6865 00:14:45,148 --> 00:14:46,720 margaret delisle followed by 6866 00:14:46,720 --> 00:14:49,460 billy rohan and then ryan 6867 00:14:49,460 --> 00:14:49,460 bornet. 6868 00:14:49,460 --> 00:14:51,291 >> mayor: okay, so before anyon 6869 00:14:51,291 --> 00:14:51,291 e 6870 00:14:51,291 --> 00:14:53,158 starts let me just give a quick 6871 00:14:53,158 --> 00:14:53,158 6872 00:14:53,158 --> 00:14:54,614 primer because I know there are 6873 00:14:54,614 --> 00:14:54,614 6874 00:14:54,614 --> 00:14:56,510 some folks here who are going t 6875 00:14:56,510 --> 00:14:56,510 o 6876 00:14:56,510 --> 00:14:57,695 want to speak who have not bee 6877 00:14:57,695 --> 00:14:57,695 n 6878 00:14:57,695 --> 00:14:58,994 regulars here so just as a 6879 00:14:58,994 --> 00:15:03,364 reminder, when we call you up t 6880 00:15:03,364 --> 00:15:03,364 o 6881 00:15:03,364 --> 00:15:06,474 lectern, first of all, let me 6882 00:15:06,474 --> 00:15:08,838 say we've had am some folks 6883 00:15:08,838 --> 00:15:10,570 soo-- had some folks sign up f 6884 00:15:10,570 --> 00:15:10,570 or 6885 00:15:10,570 --> 00:15:11,342 general public comment and 6886 00:15:11,342 --> 00:15:11,708 that's great. 6887 00:15:11,708 --> 00:15:12,876 if you're here to speak to an 6888 00:15:12,876 --> 00:15:14,642 item that's on the agenda later 6889 00:15:14,642 --> 00:15:14,642 6890 00:15:14,642 --> 00:15:16,624 on, we'll call you for that ite 6891 00:15:16,624 --> 00:15:16,624 m 6892 00:15:16,624 --> 00:15:17,482 as well just please make sure 6893 00:15:17,482 --> 00:15:18,588 you fill a form out so the 6894 00:15:18,588 --> 00:15:20,856 clerk's office can do that 6895 00:15:20,856 --> 00:15:20,856 effectively. 6896 00:15:20,856 --> 00:15:23,388 when you come up, there is thr 6897 00:15:23,388 --> 00:15:23,388 ee 6898 00:15:23,388 --> 00:15:25,700 little lights on the lectern a 6899 00:15:25,700 --> 00:15:25,700 nd 6900 00:15:25,700 --> 00:15:28,098 a light is green, you have the 6901 00:15:28,098 --> 00:15:28,098 , 6902 00:15:28,098 --> 00:15:29,766 you'll start off with three ful 6903 00:15:29,766 --> 00:15:29,766 l 6904 00:15:29,766 --> 00:15:30,827 minutes to talk and I'm not 6905 00:15:30,827 --> 00:15:35,632 going to court cut you off 6906 00:15:35,632 --> 00:15:36,738 midsentence but if the light I 6907 00:15:36,738 --> 00:15:36,738 s 6908 00:15:36,738 --> 00:15:37,902 green, you've got plenty of 6909 00:15:37,902 --> 00:15:37,902 time. 6910 00:15:37,902 --> 00:15:39,566 light turns yellow you want to 6911 00:15:39,566 --> 00:15:39,566 6912 00:15:39,566 --> 00:15:40,058 start winding down. 6913 00:15:40,058 --> 00:15:41,604 when the light turn reds when 6914 00:15:41,604 --> 00:15:42,672 you get to the end of a thought 6915 00:15:42,672 --> 00:15:42,672 6916 00:15:42,672 --> 00:15:43,754 I'm going to ask you to please 6917 00:15:43,754 --> 00:15:43,754 6918 00:15:43,754 --> 00:15:44,939 wrap up so that's just the 6919 00:15:44,939 --> 00:15:47,684 general way of how we do it. 6920 00:15:47,684 --> 00:15:47,684 so. 6921 00:15:47,684 --> 00:15:48,982 >> so our first speaker is 6922 00:15:48,982 --> 00:15:51,532 margaret delisle, also to let 6923 00:15:51,532 --> 00:15:53,352 you know room 16 has been opene 6924 00:15:53,352 --> 00:15:53,352 d 6925 00:15:53,352 --> 00:15:55,684 because we are packed full in 6926 00:15:55,684 --> 00:15:56,834 here so we may need to have som 6927 00:15:56,834 --> 00:15:56,834 e 6928 00:15:56,834 --> 00:15:59,794 time to get people from there. 6929 00:15:59,794 --> 00:15:59,794 6930 00:15:59,794 --> 00:16:01,393 followed by billy rohan and the 6931 00:16:01,393 --> 00:16:01,393 n 6932 00:16:01,393 --> 00:16:04,862 prien ryan burnette are on 6933 00:16:04,862 --> 00:16:04,862 6934 00:16:04,862 --> 00:16:04,862 deck. 6935 00:16:04,862 --> 00:16:06,136 >> mayor: all right, 6936 00:16:06,136 --> 00:16:08,409 ms. Delisle. 6937 00:16:08,409 --> 00:16:10,242 hello, I'm margaret. 6938 00:16:10,242 --> 00:16:13,179 I have cept many e-mails of 6939 00:16:13,179 --> 00:16:15,245 various topics, but today I cam 6940 00:16:15,245 --> 00:16:15,245 e 6941 00:16:15,245 --> 00:16:17,007 to talk about the traffic 6942 00:16:17,007 --> 00:16:17,007 lights. 6943 00:16:17,007 --> 00:16:18,573 I didn't know the first session 6944 00:16:18,573 --> 00:16:18,573 6945 00:16:18,573 --> 00:16:21,282 was going to be about traffic 6946 00:16:21,282 --> 00:16:22,712 lights, so it's a fun 6947 00:16:22,712 --> 00:16:25,659 coincidence but as I've driven 6948 00:16:25,659 --> 00:16:25,659 6949 00:16:25,659 --> 00:16:27,416 around this town and I came her 6950 00:16:27,416 --> 00:16:27,416 e 6951 00:16:27,416 --> 00:16:28,829 from atlanta and so I've drive 6952 00:16:28,829 --> 00:16:28,829 n 6953 00:16:28,829 --> 00:16:30,588 through atlanta, I've noticed 6954 00:16:30,588 --> 00:16:33,130 how much an impact improperly 6955 00:16:33,130 --> 00:16:34,634 timed lights have on pretty muc 6956 00:16:34,634 --> 00:16:34,634 h 6957 00:16:34,634 --> 00:16:37,262 every aspect of our day to day 6958 00:16:37,262 --> 00:16:37,262 6959 00:16:37,262 --> 00:16:37,262 lives. 6960 00:16:37,262 --> 00:16:40,097 and how strange it is that we' 6961 00:16:40,097 --> 00:16:40,097 re 6962 00:16:40,097 --> 00:16:44,138 still relying on such as stati 6963 00:16:44,138 --> 00:16:44,138 c 6964 00:16:44,138 --> 00:16:45,802 way of viewing traffic, which I 6965 00:16:45,802 --> 00:16:45,802 s 6966 00:16:45,802 --> 00:16:47,971 inherently adaptable and ever 6967 00:16:47,971 --> 00:16:50,274 shifting according to condition 6968 00:16:50,274 --> 00:16:50,274 s 6969 00:16:50,274 --> 00:16:53,112 that include both just how you 6970 00:16:53,112 --> 00:16:53,112 r 6971 00:16:53,112 --> 00:16:54,917 populous is doing mentally, the 6972 00:16:54,917 --> 00:16:54,917 6973 00:16:54,917 --> 00:16:57,719 weather, the things that happe 6974 00:16:57,719 --> 00:16:57,719 n 6975 00:16:57,719 --> 00:17:00,520 on I-75, and so I really came 6976 00:17:00,520 --> 00:17:03,162 down here just today to bring u 6977 00:17:03,162 --> 00:17:03,162 p 6978 00:17:03,162 --> 00:17:06,961 the topic of finding new ways t 6979 00:17:06,961 --> 00:17:06,961 o 6980 00:17:06,961 --> 00:17:09,138 direct traffic that have more t 6981 00:17:09,138 --> 00:17:09,138 o 6982 00:17:09,138 --> 00:17:11,866 do with how life actually works 6983 00:17:11,866 --> 00:17:11,866 6984 00:17:11,866 --> 00:17:14,439 and how we want liev to be 6985 00:17:14,439 --> 00:17:16,566 because I understand you know, 6986 00:17:16,566 --> 00:17:16,566 6987 00:17:16,566 --> 00:17:17,748 the routines that we have 6988 00:17:17,748 --> 00:17:19,197 throughout the day are what 6989 00:17:19,197 --> 00:17:21,613 causes congestion in the morni 6990 00:17:21,613 --> 00:17:21,613 ng 6991 00:17:21,613 --> 00:17:23,775 and the evening, but when I was 6992 00:17:23,775 --> 00:17:23,775 6993 00:17:23,775 --> 00:17:26,719 driving here, today even, I was 6994 00:17:26,719 --> 00:17:26,719 6995 00:17:26,719 --> 00:17:29,747 stopped at a stoplight on main 6996 00:17:29,747 --> 00:17:29,747 6997 00:17:29,747 --> 00:17:32,303 street, next to southwest 16 6998 00:17:32,303 --> 00:17:34,421 ave., and there were no cars 6999 00:17:34,421 --> 00:17:35,284 coming from the other direction 7000 00:17:35,284 --> 00:17:35,284 s 7001 00:17:35,284 --> 00:17:36,963 but we just sat there for like 7002 00:17:36,963 --> 00:17:36,963 7003 00:17:36,963 --> 00:17:40,051 about a minute, maybe two, and 7004 00:17:40,051 --> 00:17:40,051 7005 00:17:40,051 --> 00:17:43,626 that's just not the way that y 7006 00:17:43,626 --> 00:17:43,626 ou 7007 00:17:43,626 --> 00:17:45,534 most efficiently direct people. 7008 00:17:45,534 --> 00:17:45,534 7009 00:17:45,534 --> 00:17:47,462 so you asked the question of 7010 00:17:47,462 --> 00:17:49,435 what can you do to make people 7011 00:17:49,435 --> 00:17:49,435 7012 00:17:49,435 --> 00:17:51,399 stop for stoplights, for publi 7013 00:17:51,399 --> 00:17:51,399 c 7014 00:17:51,399 --> 00:17:53,908 safety, and one of those thing 7015 00:17:53,908 --> 00:17:53,908 s 7016 00:17:53,908 --> 00:17:55,537 is that you need to build up 7017 00:17:55,537 --> 00:17:57,739 that trust between the 7018 00:17:57,739 --> 00:17:59,340 individual driving and the 7019 00:17:59,340 --> 00:18:00,656 infrastructure itself because a 7020 00:18:00,656 --> 00:18:00,656 s 7021 00:18:00,656 --> 00:18:03,409 it currently is, I've lost tru 7022 00:18:03,409 --> 00:18:03,409 st 7023 00:18:03,409 --> 00:18:04,464 in it. 7024 00:18:04,464 --> 00:18:05,519 I'm willing to respect the 7025 00:18:05,519 --> 00:18:07,922 government because I enjoy thi 7026 00:18:07,922 --> 00:18:07,922 s 7027 00:18:07,922 --> 00:18:07,922 town. 7028 00:18:07,922 --> 00:18:09,987 I enjoy the commissioners. 7029 00:18:09,987 --> 00:18:11,426 I love that they have put up 7030 00:18:11,426 --> 00:18:12,855 with, you know, some of my 7031 00:18:12,855 --> 00:18:16,973 shenanigans, but just because I 7032 00:18:16,973 --> 00:18:16,973 7033 00:18:16,973 --> 00:18:17,658 have that trust does not mean 7034 00:18:17,658 --> 00:18:19,067 that everyone else in the 7035 00:18:19,067 --> 00:18:20,065 community is going to maintain 7036 00:18:20,065 --> 00:18:20,065 7037 00:18:20,065 --> 00:18:21,463 that trust. 7038 00:18:21,463 --> 00:18:23,433 whether we're constantly being 7039 00:18:23,433 --> 00:18:23,433 7040 00:18:23,433 --> 00:18:28,271 left to sit on university and 7041 00:18:28,271 --> 00:18:31,047 441 and just not be able to mov 7042 00:18:31,047 --> 00:18:31,047 e 7043 00:18:31,047 --> 00:18:32,156 when there is nobody on the 7044 00:18:32,156 --> 00:18:32,156 way. 7045 00:18:32,156 --> 00:18:34,515 so if you really, really truly 7046 00:18:34,515 --> 00:18:34,515 7047 00:18:34,515 --> 00:18:36,715 do want to address the issue 7048 00:18:36,715 --> 00:18:38,766 with the red lights, then we 7049 00:18:38,766 --> 00:18:40,851 need to find a better solution 7050 00:18:40,851 --> 00:18:40,851 7051 00:18:40,851 --> 00:18:42,286 instead of tying every single 7052 00:18:42,286 --> 00:18:44,127 aspectf our infrastructure to 7053 00:18:44,127 --> 00:18:46,855 three badly timed lights light 7054 00:18:46,855 --> 00:18:46,855 s 7055 00:18:46,855 --> 00:18:47,425 on 441. 7056 00:18:47,425 --> 00:18:48,525 thank you. 7057 00:18:48,525 --> 00:18:49,192 >> mayor: thank you. 7058 00:18:49,192 --> 00:18:51,364 >> billy rohan followed by rya 7059 00:18:51,364 --> 00:18:51,364 n 7060 00:18:51,364 --> 00:18:55,131 bornet and annie rochelle. 7061 00:18:55,131 --> 00:18:56,623 >> mayor: welcome, mr. Rohan. 7062 00:18:56,623 --> 00:18:58,257 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 7063 00:18:58,257 --> 00:19:01,629 [off mic] 7064 00:19:01,629 --> 00:19:04,105 greetings and good afternoon, 7065 00:19:04,105 --> 00:19:05,777 mayor ward, commissioners 7066 00:19:05,777 --> 00:19:09,388 eastman, commissioner ingle, 7067 00:19:09,388 --> 00:19:11,122 commissioner desmon walker and 7068 00:19:11,122 --> 00:19:11,122 7069 00:19:11,122 --> 00:19:12,652 commissioner books and 7070 00:19:12,652 --> 00:19:14,733 commissioner willits. 7071 00:19:14,733 --> 00:19:16,251 thank you for your time. 7072 00:19:16,251 --> 00:19:17,691 my name is billy rohan. 7073 00:19:17,691 --> 00:19:19,125 for years I have stood at this 7074 00:19:19,125 --> 00:19:19,125 7075 00:19:19,125 --> 00:19:21,827 podium in the city hall to 7076 00:19:21,827 --> 00:19:24,532 ensure the voices of district 3 7077 00:19:24,532 --> 00:19:24,532 7078 00:19:24,532 --> 00:19:25,567 are heard. 7079 00:19:25,567 --> 00:19:27,099 now I am asking for the 7080 00:19:27,099 --> 00:19:28,738 opportunity to bring that same 7081 00:19:28,738 --> 00:19:28,738 7082 00:19:28,738 --> 00:19:30,813 dedication to the dais. 7083 00:19:30,813 --> 00:19:32,241 our neighbors in southwest 7084 00:19:32,241 --> 00:19:33,976 gainesville deserve a 7085 00:19:33,976 --> 00:19:35,843 representative who prioritizes 7086 00:19:35,843 --> 00:19:35,843 7087 00:19:35,843 --> 00:19:37,619 fiscal accountability and commo 7088 00:19:37,619 --> 00:19:37,619 n 7089 00:19:37,619 --> 00:19:39,907 sense solutions. 7090 00:19:39,907 --> 00:19:40,861 citizens' concerns about 7091 00:19:40,861 --> 00:19:42,959 addressing utility 7092 00:19:42,959 --> 00:19:46,253 accountability, addressing the 7093 00:19:46,253 --> 00:19:46,253 7094 00:19:46,253 --> 00:19:48,313 $1.7 billion gru debt, and 7095 00:19:48,313 --> 00:19:49,953 stabilizing rates for residents 7096 00:19:49,953 --> 00:19:49,953 7097 00:19:49,953 --> 00:19:51,336 of gainesville. 7098 00:19:51,336 --> 00:19:53,799 a smart infrastructure, by 7099 00:19:53,799 --> 00:19:55,696 fixing traffic, the bottlenecks 7100 00:19:55,696 --> 00:19:55,696 7101 00:19:55,696 --> 00:19:57,757 along the archer road corridor, 7102 00:19:57,757 --> 00:19:57,757 7103 00:19:57,757 --> 00:20:00,169 and ensuring pedestrian safety 7104 00:20:00,169 --> 00:20:00,169 7105 00:20:00,169 --> 00:20:03,063 near haile plantation and tower 7106 00:20:03,063 --> 00:20:03,063 7107 00:20:03,063 --> 00:20:04,871 road, and finally, through 7108 00:20:04,871 --> 00:20:07,371 community investment, protecting 7109 00:20:07,371 --> 00:20:11,443 the public spaces and parks 7110 00:20:11,443 --> 00:20:12,908 deaght life here in gainesville 7111 00:20:12,908 --> 00:20:12,908 , 7112 00:20:12,908 --> 00:20:14,979 florida, that we all enjoy. 7113 00:20:14,979 --> 00:20:17,153 and gainesville in general. 7114 00:20:17,153 --> 00:20:18,783 thank you for your time. 7115 00:20:18,783 --> 00:20:20,556 I look forward to serving the 7116 00:20:20,556 --> 00:20:23,723 community of gainesville. 7117 00:20:23,723 --> 00:20:25,353 thanks for giving me so much 7118 00:20:25,353 --> 00:20:27,355 this city has in the last 45 7119 00:20:27,355 --> 00:20:29,293 years growing up here from goin 7120 00:20:29,293 --> 00:20:29,293 g 7121 00:20:29,293 --> 00:20:31,365 to school at duval elementary 7122 00:20:31,365 --> 00:20:33,134 school to gainesville high 7123 00:20:33,134 --> 00:20:35,867 school to new pathways and 7124 00:20:35,867 --> 00:20:37,699 horizons, everything that the 7125 00:20:37,699 --> 00:20:39,033 city has offered me, I really 7126 00:20:39,033 --> 00:20:40,207 appreciate it. 7127 00:20:40,207 --> 00:20:41,333 I hope y'all have a great rest 7128 00:20:41,333 --> 00:20:41,333 7129 00:20:41,333 --> 00:20:43,401 of your day, and a wonderful a 7130 00:20:43,401 --> 00:20:43,401 nd 7131 00:20:43,401 --> 00:20:44,367 happy easter. 7132 00:20:44,367 --> 00:20:45,575 thank you for your time agod 7133 00:20:45,575 --> 00:20:50,481 bless you. 7134 00:20:50,481 --> 00:20:50,951 >> mayor: thank you. 7135 00:20:50,951 --> 00:20:51,596 >> we have ryan bornet followed 7136 00:20:51,596 --> 00:20:51,596 7137 00:20:51,596 --> 00:20:52,615 by -- and jim konish. 7138 00:20:52,615 --> 00:20:52,615 to. 7139 00:20:52,615 --> 00:20:53,693 >> mayor: very good. 7140 00:20:53,693 --> 00:20:53,693 welcome. 7141 00:20:53,693 --> 00:20:55,559 >> hi. 7142 00:20:55,559 --> 00:20:56,757 mr. Mayor and commissione 7143 00:20:56,757 --> 00:20:59,486 appreciate your time and 7144 00:20:59,486 --> 00:20:59,486 attention. 7145 00:20:59,486 --> 00:21:02,023 -- on behalf of multiple 7146 00:21:02,023 --> 00:21:03,769 stakeholders when it comes to 7147 00:21:03,769 --> 00:21:04,961 the business community, and I 7148 00:21:04,961 --> 00:21:06,977 wanted to readdress something, 7149 00:21:06,977 --> 00:21:06,977 a 7150 00:21:06,977 --> 00:21:09,273 change that took place in 7151 00:21:09,273 --> 00:21:11,205 december and in january with 7152 00:21:11,205 --> 00:21:13,406 one-way pairs. 7153 00:21:13,406 --> 00:21:15,914 I speak on behalf of bagels 7154 00:21:15,914 --> 00:21:17,011 company gator beverage which I 7155 00:21:17,011 --> 00:21:17,011 s 7156 00:21:17,011 --> 00:21:18,339 my business, it's been our 7157 00:21:18,339 --> 00:21:20,601 family business in town for 35 7158 00:21:20,601 --> 00:21:20,601 7159 00:21:20,601 --> 00:21:22,643 years, the sweetwater coffee 7160 00:21:22,643 --> 00:21:25,415 company, jungle boys and then 7161 00:21:25,415 --> 00:21:25,415 smokeville. 7162 00:21:25,415 --> 00:21:29,489 since this change has taken 7163 00:21:29,489 --> 00:21:32,893 place, we've seen a significant 7164 00:21:32,893 --> 00:21:32,893 7165 00:21:32,893 --> 00:21:34,963 impact financially to all of o 7166 00:21:34,963 --> 00:21:34,963 ur 7167 00:21:34,963 --> 00:21:36,489 businesses in a very negative 7168 00:21:36,489 --> 00:21:39,711 way, and it, it certainly has 7169 00:21:39,711 --> 00:21:41,301 been a struggle to keep up 7170 00:21:41,301 --> 00:21:41,301 with. 7171 00:21:41,301 --> 00:21:44,271 access for businesses is very 7172 00:21:44,271 --> 00:21:44,271 important. 7173 00:21:44,271 --> 00:21:46,010 when I grew up I grew up in a 7174 00:21:46,010 --> 00:21:47,067 divorced household. 7175 00:21:47,067 --> 00:21:48,407 my mother and father both ran 7176 00:21:48,407 --> 00:21:51,145 their own businesses, and they 7177 00:21:51,145 --> 00:21:51,145 7178 00:21:51,145 --> 00:21:53,343 instilled a philosophy in me 7179 00:21:53,343 --> 00:21:55,515 that I carry and credit a lot o 7180 00:21:55,515 --> 00:21:55,515 f 7181 00:21:55,515 --> 00:21:58,159 our success in the business 7182 00:21:58,159 --> 00:22:00,979 scope, which is competition 7183 00:22:00,979 --> 00:22:02,087 makes you better. 7184 00:22:02,087 --> 00:22:04,045 if it's bad, you turn it into 7185 00:22:04,045 --> 00:22:04,045 a 7186 00:22:04,045 --> 00:22:04,045 good. 7187 00:22:04,045 --> 00:22:06,255 and the reason I'm standing up 7188 00:22:06,255 --> 00:22:06,255 7189 00:22:06,255 --> 00:22:08,326 here today is I'm struggling 7190 00:22:08,326 --> 00:22:11,966 deeply along with everyone in 7191 00:22:11,966 --> 00:22:12,681 the business community I 7192 00:22:12,681 --> 00:22:14,931 mentioned, with finding the 7193 00:22:14,931 --> 00:22:15,967 positive with the changes that 7194 00:22:15,967 --> 00:22:15,967 7195 00:22:15,967 --> 00:22:17,341 have taken place. 7196 00:22:17,341 --> 00:22:19,423 what we've experienced is worse 7197 00:22:19,423 --> 00:22:19,423 7198 00:22:19,423 --> 00:22:19,423 traffic. 7199 00:22:19,423 --> 00:22:21,953 we've experienced the financial 7200 00:22:21,953 --> 00:22:21,953 7201 00:22:21,953 --> 00:22:24,107 impact, our roadways are now 7202 00:22:24,107 --> 00:22:25,215 worse than they were previousl 7203 00:22:25,215 --> 00:22:25,215 y 7204 00:22:25,215 --> 00:22:28,386 as far as the condition of the 7205 00:22:28,386 --> 00:22:28,386 7206 00:22:28,386 --> 00:22:28,386 roads. 7207 00:22:28,386 --> 00:22:30,113 the neighborhood is suffering. 7208 00:22:30,113 --> 00:22:30,113 7209 00:22:30,113 --> 00:22:31,729 back in the december 4th 7210 00:22:31,729 --> 00:22:34,410 meeting that the community spo 7211 00:22:34,410 --> 00:22:34,410 ke 7212 00:22:34,410 --> 00:22:35,485 in in a prominent business 7213 00:22:35,485 --> 00:22:38,227 leader spoke, everyone spoke I 7214 00:22:38,227 --> 00:22:38,227 n 7215 00:22:38,227 --> 00:22:40,425 opposition of the changes, and 7216 00:22:40,425 --> 00:22:40,425 7217 00:22:40,425 --> 00:22:42,305 becauseof this arpa money, it 7218 00:22:42,305 --> 00:22:45,567 really came off after the fact 7219 00:22:45,567 --> 00:22:45,567 7220 00:22:45,567 --> 00:22:46,693 that this was a railroad 7221 00:22:46,693 --> 00:22:46,693 project. 7222 00:22:46,693 --> 00:22:50,605 this was just shoved down our 7223 00:22:50,605 --> 00:22:53,107 throats, and I would love to 7224 00:22:53,107 --> 00:22:54,541 find the optimistic side of 7225 00:22:54,541 --> 00:22:54,871 these changes. 7226 00:22:54,871 --> 00:22:57,141 I watch public safety as a maj 7227 00:22:57,141 --> 00:22:57,141 or 7228 00:22:57,141 --> 00:22:57,141 issue. 7229 00:22:57,141 --> 00:22:59,279 I had a police officer running 7230 00:22:59,279 --> 00:22:59,279 7231 00:22:59,279 --> 00:23:00,747 down the one way -- wrong way 7232 00:23:00,747 --> 00:23:02,143 two days ago because there was 7233 00:23:02,143 --> 00:23:02,318 a 7234 00:23:02,318 --> 00:23:04,149 criminal on the loose. 7235 00:23:04,149 --> 00:23:05,685 and what does that tell me? 7236 00:23:05,685 --> 00:23:06,889 that tells me that access to 7237 00:23:06,889 --> 00:23:08,418 emergency response is worse. 7238 00:23:08,418 --> 00:23:10,543 I'm a bicyclist. 7239 00:23:10,543 --> 00:23:13,251 I am the definition of vision 7240 00:23:13,251 --> 00:23:15,949 zero, I ride my bike four days 7241 00:23:15,949 --> 00:23:16,085 a 7242 00:23:16,085 --> 00:23:17,667 week 30 minutes both ways to 7243 00:23:17,667 --> 00:23:17,667 work. 7244 00:23:17,667 --> 00:23:21,897 and not one time when we had t 7245 00:23:21,897 --> 00:23:21,897 he 7246 00:23:21,897 --> 00:23:22,639 bike boulevard before the 7247 00:23:22,639 --> 00:23:23,637 changes did I ever think that I 7248 00:23:23,637 --> 00:23:23,637 7249 00:23:23,637 --> 00:23:24,741 needed more bike lanes. 7250 00:23:24,741 --> 00:23:27,273 or mike changes to the 7251 00:23:27,273 --> 00:23:27,273 infrastructure. 7252 00:23:27,273 --> 00:23:29,439 this is a transient community. 7253 00:23:29,439 --> 00:23:29,439 7254 00:23:29,439 --> 00:23:30,747 we train everyone on the one 7255 00:23:30,747 --> 00:23:32,140 ways, wait until august. 7256 00:23:32,140 --> 00:23:33,479 we have to train everyone all 7257 00:23:33,479 --> 00:23:34,247 over again. 7258 00:23:34,247 --> 00:23:36,457 it's -- everyone goes the wrong 7259 00:23:36,457 --> 00:23:36,457 7260 00:23:36,457 --> 00:23:37,649 way on the one ways. 7261 00:23:37,649 --> 00:23:40,294 it's dangerouses, and no one's 7262 00:23:40,294 --> 00:23:40,294 , 7263 00:23:40,294 --> 00:23:41,585 we're not slowing down drivers 7264 00:23:41,585 --> 00:23:41,585 . 7265 00:23:41,585 --> 00:23:42,447 we're not changing drivers. 7266 00:23:42,447 --> 00:23:44,852 and frankly I think it's very 7267 00:23:44,852 --> 00:23:46,391 biased towards all the people 7268 00:23:46,391 --> 00:23:47,559 that deserve the right to 7269 00:23:47,559 --> 00:23:47,559 drive. 7270 00:23:47,559 --> 00:23:50,660 I talk to neighborhood people 7271 00:23:50,660 --> 00:23:51,429 all the time and now they're 7272 00:23:51,429 --> 00:23:52,869 more inconvenienced than ever. 7273 00:23:52,869 --> 00:23:52,869 7274 00:23:52,869 --> 00:23:54,267 they can't ride a bike. 7275 00:23:54,267 --> 00:23:55,601 they have to drive. 7276 00:23:55,601 --> 00:23:58,117 and now they're circling back 7277 00:23:58,117 --> 00:23:59,103 five different ways to 7278 00:23:59,103 --> 00:23:59,534 accomplish something. 7279 00:23:59,534 --> 00:24:00,503 I know I've spoken withyou 7280 00:24:00,503 --> 00:24:00,503 individually. 7281 00:24:00,503 --> 00:24:04,773 and we've talked about -- 7282 00:24:04,773 --> 00:24:05,683 obviously that's something tha 7283 00:24:05,683 --> 00:24:05,683 t 7284 00:24:05,683 --> 00:24:07,855 I would like to continue to mov 7285 00:24:07,855 --> 00:24:07,855 e 7286 00:24:07,855 --> 00:24:09,496 towards with the commission, but 7287 00:24:09,496 --> 00:24:09,496 7288 00:24:09,496 --> 00:24:11,119 I just want to be on the recor 7289 00:24:11,119 --> 00:24:11,119 d 7290 00:24:11,119 --> 00:24:17,031 and open that the two-way was a 7291 00:24:17,031 --> 00:24:17,031 7292 00:24:17,031 --> 00:24:18,357 successful model and this chang 7293 00:24:18,357 --> 00:24:18,357 e 7294 00:24:18,357 --> 00:24:19,993 has been very, very harmful to 7295 00:24:19,993 --> 00:24:19,993 7296 00:24:19,993 --> 00:24:22,068 the businesses in the community 7297 00:24:22,068 --> 00:24:22,068 , 7298 00:24:22,068 --> 00:24:23,699 and you know at the commission 7299 00:24:23,699 --> 00:24:23,699 7300 00:24:23,699 --> 00:24:25,463 meeting that you voted against 7301 00:24:25,463 --> 00:24:25,463 7302 00:24:25,463 --> 00:24:26,665 everyone in the community, tha 7303 00:24:26,665 --> 00:24:26,665 t 7304 00:24:26,665 --> 00:24:29,507 was also said and now the 7305 00:24:29,507 --> 00:24:30,599 businesses are here trying to 7306 00:24:30,599 --> 00:24:31,602 also acknowledge that. 7307 00:24:31,602 --> 00:24:32,785 thank you. 7308 00:24:32,785 --> 00:24:34,881 >> mayor: thank you. 7309 00:24:34,881 --> 00:24:36,414 so I will ask that we, we 7310 00:24:36,414 --> 00:24:38,277 generally try not to clap or 7311 00:24:38,277 --> 00:24:41,547 cheer or jeer because the side 7312 00:24:41,547 --> 00:24:41,547 7313 00:24:41,547 --> 00:24:42,690 you're on right now might not b 7314 00:24:42,690 --> 00:24:42,690 e 7315 00:24:42,690 --> 00:24:43,613 the side that you're on next 7316 00:24:43,613 --> 00:24:44,857 time it happens so please try t 7317 00:24:44,857 --> 00:24:44,857 o 7318 00:24:44,857 --> 00:24:48,067 keep that from doing that. 7319 00:24:48,067 --> 00:24:49,457 >> annie rochelle followed by 7320 00:24:49,457 --> 00:24:52,057 jim konish and justin smith. 7321 00:24:52,057 --> 00:24:53,433 >> mayor: welcome. 7322 00:24:53,433 --> 00:24:56,364 >> thank you all. 7323 00:24:56,364 --> 00:24:57,891 unfortunately but fortunately 7324 00:24:57,891 --> 00:24:58,995 I'll sorry I have to be here 7325 00:24:58,995 --> 00:25:01,567 with this but fortunately I'm 7326 00:25:01,567 --> 00:25:03,569 glad I can bring it to you guy 7327 00:25:03,569 --> 00:25:03,569 s' 7328 00:25:03,569 --> 00:25:03,569 attention. 7329 00:25:03,569 --> 00:25:12,775 on 3/9 I was concerned with my 7330 00:25:12,775 --> 00:25:12,775 7331 00:25:12,775 --> 00:25:14,073 electric bill being so high, s 7332 00:25:14,073 --> 00:25:14,073 o 7333 00:25:14,073 --> 00:25:15,282 I with gan to research over 7334 00:25:15,282 --> 00:25:17,242 maybe -- began to research ove 7335 00:25:17,242 --> 00:25:17,242 7336 00:25:17,242 --> 00:25:19,457 maybe what could cause it to go 7337 00:25:19,457 --> 00:25:19,457 7338 00:25:19,457 --> 00:25:19,952 to that level and I realized 7339 00:25:19,952 --> 00:25:25,695 that my, the container garbage 7340 00:25:25,695 --> 00:25:25,695 7341 00:25:25,695 --> 00:25:27,757 container fee on there was not 7342 00:25:27,757 --> 00:25:27,757 7343 00:25:27,757 --> 00:25:30,595 what I thought it should be. 7344 00:25:30,595 --> 00:25:32,031 that I was supposed to be payin 7345 00:25:32,031 --> 00:25:32,031 g 7346 00:25:32,031 --> 00:25:32,031 for. 7347 00:25:32,031 --> 00:25:37,063 so I rirched my bill for march 7348 00:25:37,063 --> 00:25:37,063 7349 00:25:37,063 --> 00:25:40,335 it was consistent of this year. 7350 00:25:40,335 --> 00:25:40,335 7351 00:25:40,335 --> 00:25:43,319 for '25 I had four different 7352 00:25:43,319 --> 00:25:45,474 fees for that. 7353 00:25:45,474 --> 00:25:50,944 20.56, 31.80, 33.50, 41.52. 7354 00:25:50,944 --> 00:25:53,118 so I called. 7355 00:25:53,118 --> 00:25:55,127 I said that can't be. 7356 00:25:55,127 --> 00:25:57,091 and I've had that problem 7357 00:25:57,091 --> 00:25:59,259 before, so I called, and I 7358 00:25:59,259 --> 00:26:01,566 talked with the young lady. 7359 00:26:01,566 --> 00:26:03,855 she said yes, ms. Rochelle. 7360 00:26:03,855 --> 00:26:03,855 inconsistency. 7361 00:26:03,855 --> 00:26:07,565 let me get back, let me get bac 7362 00:26:07,565 --> 00:26:07,565 k 7363 00:26:07,565 --> 00:26:12,069 with you so she put me on hold 7364 00:26:12,069 --> 00:26:12,069 7365 00:26:12,069 --> 00:26:13,805 and said so she said well, som 7366 00:26:13,805 --> 00:26:13,805 e 7367 00:26:13,805 --> 00:26:15,673 of the prices changed. 7368 00:26:15,673 --> 00:26:19,076 something, I could have maybe 7369 00:26:19,076 --> 00:26:19,076 overlooked. 7370 00:26:19,076 --> 00:26:21,247 so we go on that was on a 7371 00:26:21,247 --> 00:26:21,247 monday. 7372 00:26:21,247 --> 00:26:24,694 so I said well, I don't need a 7373 00:26:24,694 --> 00:26:24,694 7374 00:26:24,694 --> 00:26:25,984 bigger container. 7375 00:26:25,984 --> 00:26:27,719 I want what I initially started 7376 00:26:27,719 --> 00:26:27,719 7377 00:26:27,719 --> 00:26:27,719 with. 7378 00:26:27,719 --> 00:26:32,084 I moved there 2020. 7379 00:26:32,084 --> 00:26:36,897 and so therefore it wasn't the 7380 00:26:36,897 --> 00:26:36,897 7381 00:26:36,897 --> 00:26:39,193 price that for that retainer. 7382 00:26:39,193 --> 00:26:40,099 and -- container. 7383 00:26:40,099 --> 00:26:42,293 and so therefore, I said no, 7384 00:26:42,293 --> 00:26:43,472 this is not right. 7385 00:26:43,472 --> 00:26:44,946 this is just not good. 7386 00:26:44,946 --> 00:26:47,848 and so she said okay well I'll 7387 00:26:47,848 --> 00:26:47,848 7388 00:26:47,848 --> 00:26:49,504 forward it forward. 7389 00:26:49,504 --> 00:26:51,051 that was that monday. 7390 00:26:51,051 --> 00:26:52,712 tuesday, wednesday, they came 7391 00:26:52,712 --> 00:26:55,311 and changed out the garbage can 7392 00:26:55,311 --> 00:26:55,311 7393 00:26:55,311 --> 00:26:58,250 to what I really wanted. 7394 00:26:58,250 --> 00:27:01,218 and so thursday go by, friday 7395 00:27:01,218 --> 00:27:03,887 come, I never heard anything 7396 00:27:03,887 --> 00:27:03,887 back. 7397 00:27:03,887 --> 00:27:05,371 I pick up the phone, I called 7398 00:27:05,371 --> 00:27:05,371 them. 7399 00:27:05,371 --> 00:27:08,561 and I asked them. 7400 00:27:08,561 --> 00:27:10,739 I said hey, what was the deal o 7401 00:27:10,739 --> 00:27:10,739 n 7402 00:27:10,739 --> 00:27:10,739 this? 7403 00:27:10,739 --> 00:27:12,163 what what happened? 7404 00:27:12,163 --> 00:27:15,697 they said well ms. Rochelle, I 7405 00:27:15,697 --> 00:27:15,697 'm 7406 00:27:15,697 --> 00:27:16,614 sorry, there is nothing we can 7407 00:27:16,614 --> 00:27:16,614 7408 00:27:16,614 --> 00:27:17,432 do because you called before. 7409 00:27:17,432 --> 00:27:19,076 I said I did. 7410 00:27:19,076 --> 00:27:21,472 and they say, I said yes, about 7411 00:27:21,472 --> 00:27:21,472 7412 00:27:21,472 --> 00:27:23,677 my, about the rates not being 7413 00:27:23,677 --> 00:27:24,646 the same before, consistent 7414 00:27:24,646 --> 00:27:24,646 before. 7415 00:27:24,646 --> 00:27:28,281 she said no, that was gru 7416 00:27:28,281 --> 00:27:28,281 fault. 7417 00:27:28,281 --> 00:27:31,656 and so therefore they say I sa 7418 00:27:31,656 --> 00:27:31,656 id 7419 00:27:31,656 --> 00:27:34,419 well that was warranted then. 7420 00:27:34,419 --> 00:27:38,060 and so, and so she said no, you 7421 00:27:38,060 --> 00:27:38,060 7422 00:27:38,060 --> 00:27:42,330 call before, and I said yeah, I 7423 00:27:42,330 --> 00:27:42,330 7424 00:27:42,330 --> 00:27:43,410 said I did. 7425 00:27:43,410 --> 00:27:45,400 I called back about debris bei 7426 00:27:45,400 --> 00:27:45,400 ng 7427 00:27:45,400 --> 00:27:47,229 put in my yard, by the city 7428 00:27:47,229 --> 00:27:47,229 workers. 7429 00:27:47,229 --> 00:27:49,565 and so she said yes, that is 7430 00:27:49,565 --> 00:27:52,939 what I'm talking about. 7431 00:27:52,939 --> 00:27:55,065 I said, she said because of that 7432 00:27:55,065 --> 00:27:55,065 7433 00:27:55,065 --> 00:27:56,337 and you did not bring that to 7434 00:27:56,337 --> 00:27:58,877 our attention then, we can't 7435 00:27:58,877 --> 00:28:01,103 help you now basically. 7436 00:28:01,103 --> 00:28:04,372 and I said but that was then a 7437 00:28:04,372 --> 00:28:04,372 nd 7438 00:28:04,372 --> 00:28:05,622 that was about something else 7439 00:28:05,622 --> 00:28:07,183 and this is now. 7440 00:28:07,183 --> 00:28:10,823 when I did that, that was in ' 7441 00:28:10,823 --> 00:28:10,823 23 7442 00:28:10,823 --> 00:28:14,457 and '24, october -- 7443 00:28:14,457 --> 00:28:16,184 >> mayor: I'm going to ask you 7444 00:28:16,184 --> 00:28:16,184 7445 00:28:16,184 --> 00:28:17,059 to wrap up if you will. 7446 00:28:17,059 --> 00:28:18,489 -- manager's office -- 7447 00:28:18,489 --> 00:28:19,008 >> okay. 7448 00:28:19,008 --> 00:28:21,135 well nevertheless, I was told 7449 00:28:21,135 --> 00:28:22,634 that there was nothing -- I 7450 00:28:22,634 --> 00:28:23,832 don't feel that I should or 7451 00:28:23,832 --> 00:28:25,037 anybody else should be 7452 00:28:25,037 --> 00:28:26,919 retaliated against for making a 7453 00:28:26,919 --> 00:28:26,919 7454 00:28:26,919 --> 00:28:26,919 complaint. 7455 00:28:26,919 --> 00:28:28,433 I pay my taxes. 7456 00:28:28,433 --> 00:28:30,403 I pay my utility fees. 7457 00:28:30,403 --> 00:28:32,281 I pay my state taxes. 7458 00:28:32,281 --> 00:28:34,907 I do what I'm supposed to, and 7459 00:28:34,907 --> 00:28:34,996 I 7460 00:28:34,996 --> 00:28:36,595 have a right I did not know that 7461 00:28:36,595 --> 00:28:36,595 7462 00:28:36,595 --> 00:28:40,096 the city had a limit on the 7463 00:28:40,096 --> 00:28:42,117 complaints or a timeline. 7464 00:28:42,117 --> 00:28:43,063 >> mayor: so there is clearly a 7465 00:28:43,063 --> 00:28:43,063 7466 00:28:43,063 --> 00:28:43,063 misunderstanding. 7467 00:28:43,063 --> 00:28:45,395 we'll have someone from the 7468 00:28:45,395 --> 00:28:46,393 manager's office talk with you 7469 00:28:46,393 --> 00:28:46,393 , 7470 00:28:46,393 --> 00:28:46,393 okay? 7471 00:28:46,393 --> 00:28:47,631 all right. 7472 00:28:47,631 --> 00:28:48,989 thank you. 7473 00:28:48,989 --> 00:28:49,326 >> thank you. 7474 00:28:49,326 --> 00:28:50,231 thank you all. 7475 00:28:50,231 --> 00:28:51,768 no that was for them to see. 7476 00:28:51,768 --> 00:28:51,768 [laughter] 7477 00:28:51,768 --> 00:28:55,566 >> we have jim konish followed 7478 00:28:55,566 --> 00:28:55,566 7479 00:28:55,566 --> 00:28:58,438 by justin smith and kali 7480 00:28:58,438 --> 00:28:58,438 blount. 7481 00:28:58,438 --> 00:29:00,543 >> mayor: welcome, mr. Konish. 7482 00:29:00,543 --> 00:29:00,543 7483 00:29:00,543 --> 00:29:01,477 >> mr. Mayor, jim konish, good 7484 00:29:01,477 --> 00:29:01,477 7485 00:29:01,477 --> 00:29:01,477 afternoon. 7486 00:29:01,477 --> 00:29:04,342 like the overhead, please. 7487 00:29:04,342 --> 00:29:09,002 in 1997, alachua county rolled 7488 00:29:09,002 --> 00:29:09,002 7489 00:29:09,002 --> 00:29:10,950 out a, what was called a 7490 00:29:10,950 --> 00:29:12,720 privilege fee. 7491 00:29:12,720 --> 00:29:16,874 and everyone that was anyone I 7492 00:29:16,874 --> 00:29:16,874 n 7493 00:29:16,874 --> 00:29:20,130 intervened, and the honorable 7494 00:29:20,130 --> 00:29:22,093 frederick smith an iconic judge 7495 00:29:22,093 --> 00:29:22,093 7496 00:29:22,093 --> 00:29:29,542 concluded that this was an 7497 00:29:29,542 --> 00:29:30,277 unconstitutional tax and that' 7498 00:29:30,277 --> 00:29:30,277 s 7499 00:29:30,277 --> 00:29:31,742 because when you let a utility 7500 00:29:31,742 --> 00:29:31,742 7501 00:29:31,742 --> 00:29:33,799 into your right-of-way for fre 7502 00:29:33,799 --> 00:29:33,799 e 7503 00:29:33,799 --> 00:29:36,407 for 100 years, and they get 7504 00:29:36,407 --> 00:29:38,845 comfortable in there, you can't 7505 00:29:38,845 --> 00:29:38,845 7506 00:29:38,845 --> 00:29:41,444 like have second thoughts about 7507 00:29:41,444 --> 00:29:41,444 7508 00:29:41,444 --> 00:29:43,976 it and sap a franchise fee 7509 00:29:43,976 --> 00:29:45,143 because a franchise fee has to 7510 00:29:45,143 --> 00:29:45,143 7511 00:29:45,143 --> 00:29:48,122 be negotiated in a contract. 7512 00:29:48,122 --> 00:29:51,188 so the city of gainesville and 7513 00:29:51,188 --> 00:29:51,188 7514 00:29:51,188 --> 00:29:53,287 alachua county commission let 7515 00:29:53,287 --> 00:29:55,226 gru enter their rights-of-way 7516 00:29:55,226 --> 00:29:58,078 without any kind of contract a 7517 00:29:58,078 --> 00:29:58,078 nd 7518 00:29:58,078 --> 00:30:00,164 they're going to stay there 7519 00:30:00,164 --> 00:30:01,067 forever without any kind of 7520 00:30:01,067 --> 00:30:02,981 contract and your franchise fee 7521 00:30:02,981 --> 00:30:02,981 7522 00:30:02,981 --> 00:30:03,899 that you're discussing is 7523 00:30:03,899 --> 00:30:05,981 illegal, sir. 7524 00:30:05,981 --> 00:30:09,540 it's a tax, and mr.-- knows 7525 00:30:09,540 --> 00:30:09,540 this. 7526 00:30:09,540 --> 00:30:11,004 in terms of you meeting your 7527 00:30:11,004 --> 00:30:12,337 budget, the first thing you 7528 00:30:12,337 --> 00:30:13,945 should do is stop paying for t 7529 00:30:13,945 --> 00:30:13,945 he 7530 00:30:13,945 --> 00:30:15,718 county street lights. 7531 00:30:15,718 --> 00:30:17,116 they're not entitled to any 7532 00:30:17,116 --> 00:30:21,289 compensation for gru's use of 7533 00:30:21,289 --> 00:30:22,066 their right-of-way and in fact 7534 00:30:22,066 --> 00:30:22,066 7535 00:30:22,066 --> 00:30:23,454 they have to get on their knees 7536 00:30:23,454 --> 00:30:23,454 7537 00:30:23,454 --> 00:30:25,024 and beg to save a few live oak 7538 00:30:25,024 --> 00:30:25,024 7539 00:30:25,024 --> 00:30:27,660 trees because they cannot even 7540 00:30:27,660 --> 00:30:27,660 7541 00:30:27,660 --> 00:30:28,630 regulate the use of right-of-wa 7542 00:30:28,630 --> 00:30:28,630 y 7543 00:30:28,630 --> 00:30:30,196 and I want to remind you you'v 7544 00:30:30,196 --> 00:30:30,196 e 7545 00:30:30,196 --> 00:30:32,062 passed an ordinance purporting 7546 00:30:32,062 --> 00:30:32,062 7547 00:30:32,062 --> 00:30:34,136 to require gru permits in your 7548 00:30:34,136 --> 00:30:34,136 7549 00:30:34,136 --> 00:30:35,667 right-of-ways, and they have 7550 00:30:35,667 --> 00:30:36,539 ignored it because it's 7551 00:30:36,539 --> 00:30:36,539 illegal. 7552 00:30:36,539 --> 00:30:41,340 not that they can't impose 7553 00:30:41,340 --> 00:30:41,888 franchise fees. 7554 00:30:41,888 --> 00:30:44,903 you can't impose conditions on 7555 00:30:44,903 --> 00:30:44,903 7556 00:30:44,903 --> 00:30:45,945 their occupancy of 7557 00:30:45,945 --> 00:30:47,372 rights-of-way, sir, and I'm 7558 00:30:47,372 --> 00:30:49,571 abhaized like you're eving -- 7559 00:30:49,571 --> 00:30:50,922 amazed you're even talking abo 7560 00:30:50,922 --> 00:30:50,922 ut 7561 00:30:50,922 --> 00:30:50,922 this. 7562 00:30:50,922 --> 00:30:52,802 it's settled law, that's just 7563 00:30:52,802 --> 00:30:53,414 the way it is. 7564 00:30:53,414 --> 00:30:56,220 but the ult of gru to -- abili 7565 00:30:56,220 --> 00:30:56,220 ty 7566 00:30:56,220 --> 00:30:58,888 of gru to pay you any money is 7567 00:30:58,888 --> 00:30:58,888 7568 00:30:58,888 --> 00:31:02,498 limited by the legacy costs of 7569 00:31:02,498 --> 00:31:02,498 7570 00:31:02,498 --> 00:31:04,165 this commission's mismanagement 7571 00:31:04,165 --> 00:31:04,165 7572 00:31:04,165 --> 00:31:06,564 of gru. 7573 00:31:06,564 --> 00:31:09,844 gru loses $46 million a year o 7574 00:31:09,844 --> 00:31:09,844 n 7575 00:31:09,844 --> 00:31:12,910 european style solar feeder 7576 00:31:12,910 --> 00:31:14,543 tariff enjoyed by a former may 7577 00:31:14,543 --> 00:31:14,543 or 7578 00:31:14,543 --> 00:31:15,942 and her cronies. 7579 00:31:15,942 --> 00:31:17,840 four to $6 million a year we're 7580 00:31:17,840 --> 00:31:17,840 7581 00:31:17,840 --> 00:31:19,148 in year 17 of a 20-year 7582 00:31:19,148 --> 00:31:26,349 agreement, sir: gru pays 7583 00:31:26,349 --> 00:31:28,228 $1.2 million to -- pollution a 7584 00:31:28,228 --> 00:31:28,228 t 7585 00:31:28,228 --> 00:31:30,064 depot park, sir, after spending 7586 00:31:30,064 --> 00:31:30,064 7587 00:31:30,064 --> 00:31:32,264 tens of millions. 7588 00:31:32,264 --> 00:31:33,558 gru provides the county with 7589 00:31:33,558 --> 00:31:35,428 free fire hydrants. 7590 00:31:35,428 --> 00:31:36,566 costs them about a million a 7591 00:31:36,566 --> 00:31:36,566 year. 7592 00:31:36,566 --> 00:31:40,182 no justification for thithere 7593 00:31:40,182 --> 00:31:40,586 is no recognition of it 7594 00:31:40,586 --> 00:31:40,586 either. 7595 00:31:40,586 --> 00:31:43,013 group -- $2 million a year 7596 00:31:43,013 --> 00:31:45,072 because the services they 7597 00:31:45,072 --> 00:31:46,389 provide to the city, the county, 7598 00:31:46,389 --> 00:31:46,389 7599 00:31:46,389 --> 00:31:47,470 and school board do not cover 7600 00:31:47,470 --> 00:31:50,970 the costs so you're freeloading 7601 00:31:50,970 --> 00:31:50,970 7602 00:31:50,970 --> 00:31:53,946 on that level. 7603 00:31:53,946 --> 00:31:55,464 private developer got gru to 7604 00:31:55,464 --> 00:31:58,090 install a package plant in cro 7605 00:31:58,090 --> 00:31:58,090 ss 7606 00:31:58,090 --> 00:32:02,322 creek 16 miles from gru -- lin 7607 00:32:02,322 --> 00:32:02,322 es 7608 00:32:02,322 --> 00:32:03,694 it's failed gru is trucking the 7609 00:32:03,694 --> 00:32:03,694 7610 00:32:03,694 --> 00:32:05,456 sewage out of there. 7611 00:32:05,456 --> 00:32:07,964 weekly at a loss of a third of 7612 00:32:07,964 --> 00:32:08,289 a 7613 00:32:08,289 --> 00:32:09,405 million dollars and I could go 7614 00:32:09,405 --> 00:32:09,405 7615 00:32:09,405 --> 00:32:10,460 but I'm out of time. 7616 00:32:10,460 --> 00:32:11,560 thank you, sir. 7617 00:32:11,560 --> 00:32:12,123 >> mayor: thank you, 7618 00:32:12,123 --> 00:32:12,836 mr. Konish. 7619 00:32:12,836 --> 00:32:14,863 I would remind everyone that t 7620 00:32:14,863 --> 00:32:14,863 he 7621 00:32:14,863 --> 00:32:15,905 city commission doesn't run 7622 00:32:15,905 --> 00:32:15,905 gru. 7623 00:32:15,905 --> 00:32:18,081 >> mr. Mayor, we're onto justin 7624 00:32:18,081 --> 00:32:18,081 7625 00:32:18,081 --> 00:32:21,038 smith, followed by kali blount 7626 00:32:21,038 --> 00:32:21,038 7627 00:32:21,038 --> 00:32:22,642 and andrew miles. 7628 00:32:22,642 --> 00:32:28,204 >> mayor: welcome, mr. Smith. 7629 00:32:28,204 --> 00:32:30,503 >> good afternoon, mr. Chair. 7630 00:32:30,503 --> 00:32:32,188 I'm here today on behalf of th 7631 00:32:32,188 --> 00:32:32,188 e 7632 00:32:32,188 --> 00:32:33,270 community of individuals who 7633 00:32:33,270 --> 00:32:35,620 live here downtown. 7634 00:32:35,620 --> 00:32:37,792 they have many struggles. 7635 00:32:37,792 --> 00:32:39,364 many suffer varying degrees of 7636 00:32:39,364 --> 00:32:39,364 7637 00:32:39,364 --> 00:32:41,724 mental health challenges, many 7638 00:32:41,724 --> 00:32:41,724 7639 00:32:41,724 --> 00:32:43,600 are victims of severe trauma a 7640 00:32:43,600 --> 00:32:43,600 nd 7641 00:32:43,600 --> 00:32:46,992 abuse, sometimes as children, 7642 00:32:46,992 --> 00:32:48,833 sometimes in service of our 7643 00:32:48,833 --> 00:32:48,833 country. 7644 00:32:48,833 --> 00:32:51,087 sometimes both. 7645 00:32:51,087 --> 00:32:52,338 often these friends of mine are 7646 00:32:52,338 --> 00:32:52,338 7647 00:32:52,338 --> 00:32:53,004 struggling to overcome 7648 00:32:53,004 --> 00:32:53,004 addictions. 7649 00:32:53,004 --> 00:32:56,378 many of them have spent 7650 00:32:56,378 --> 00:32:59,118 significant time in prison. 7651 00:32:59,118 --> 00:33:01,412 for a host of reasons, most hav 7652 00:33:01,412 --> 00:33:01,412 e 7653 00:33:01,412 --> 00:33:04,821 no support from family or 7654 00:33:04,821 --> 00:33:06,020 friends, and now they are 7655 00:33:06,020 --> 00:33:08,030 trapped and living a life on th 7656 00:33:08,030 --> 00:33:08,030 e 7657 00:33:08,030 --> 00:33:08,030 street. 7658 00:33:08,030 --> 00:33:11,762 they are commonly lonely, 7659 00:33:11,762 --> 00:33:15,858 afraid, anxious, angry, 7660 00:33:15,858 --> 00:33:17,829 depressed, cold. 7661 00:33:17,829 --> 00:33:20,440 and hungry. 7662 00:33:20,440 --> 00:33:22,198 but there is one message that 7663 00:33:22,198 --> 00:33:24,070 nearly all of these folks are 7664 00:33:24,070 --> 00:33:27,274 given day in and day out; one 7665 00:33:27,274 --> 00:33:28,871 lie that these image bearers o 7666 00:33:28,871 --> 00:33:28,871 f 7667 00:33:28,871 --> 00:33:32,410 god are constantly told. 7668 00:33:32,410 --> 00:33:33,160 they are told that they are 7669 00:33:33,160 --> 00:33:33,160 worthless. 7670 00:33:33,160 --> 00:33:37,890 that tay don't matter. 7671 00:33:37,890 --> 00:33:39,815 that it is the same lie that 7672 00:33:39,815 --> 00:33:40,922 many of them have been told for 7673 00:33:40,922 --> 00:33:40,922 7674 00:33:40,922 --> 00:33:44,100 so long that they've come to 7675 00:33:44,100 --> 00:33:44,856 believe it. 7676 00:33:44,856 --> 00:33:46,262 mr. Chair, I don't think you 7677 00:33:46,262 --> 00:33:47,660 believe this lie anymore than I 7678 00:33:47,660 --> 00:33:47,660 7679 00:33:47,660 --> 00:33:47,660 do. 7680 00:33:47,660 --> 00:33:50,224 and I would like to thank you 7681 00:33:50,224 --> 00:33:52,200 and our city for the many 7682 00:33:52,200 --> 00:33:53,730 efforts made to support this 7683 00:33:53,730 --> 00:33:55,136 vulnerable portion of our 7684 00:33:55,136 --> 00:33:55,136 population. 7685 00:33:55,136 --> 00:33:55,136 however. 7686 00:33:55,136 --> 00:34:00,166 as you are aware, our community 7687 00:34:00,166 --> 00:34:00,166 7688 00:34:00,166 --> 00:34:01,606 has recently suffered an 7689 00:34:01,606 --> 00:34:04,107 incredible loss in services due 7690 00:34:04,107 --> 00:34:04,107 7691 00:34:04,107 --> 00:34:06,594 to the closure of st. Francis 7692 00:34:06,594 --> 00:34:06,594 house. 7693 00:34:06,594 --> 00:34:09,918 it is impossible to overstate 7694 00:34:09,918 --> 00:34:12,748 the importance of providing 7695 00:34:12,748 --> 00:34:15,096 daily hot meals and a shower t 7696 00:34:15,096 --> 00:34:15,096 o 7697 00:34:15,096 --> 00:34:18,264 people in need. 7698 00:34:18,264 --> 00:34:21,473 therefore, I encourage you to 7699 00:34:21,473 --> 00:34:23,860 look for and doggedly pursue 7700 00:34:23,860 --> 00:34:25,594 future partnerships to help fil 7701 00:34:25,594 --> 00:34:25,594 l 7702 00:34:25,594 --> 00:34:29,327 this gap as opportunities 7703 00:34:29,327 --> 00:34:29,327 arise. 7704 00:34:29,327 --> 00:34:31,434 please continue the work of 7705 00:34:31,434 --> 00:34:33,040 serving these members of our 7706 00:34:33,040 --> 00:34:33,040 community. 7707 00:34:33,040 --> 00:34:36,676 my friends on the street. 7708 00:34:36,676 --> 00:34:38,544 thank you for your time. 7709 00:34:38,544 --> 00:34:40,445 >> mayor: thank you. 7710 00:34:40,445 --> 00:34:43,450 >> mr. Mayor, we have kali 7711 00:34:43,450 --> 00:34:44,837 blount and then mr. Andrew 7712 00:34:44,837 --> 00:34:44,837 miles. 7713 00:34:44,837 --> 00:34:49,882 >> mayor: welcome, mr. Blount. 7714 00:34:49,882 --> 00:34:49,882 7715 00:34:49,882 --> 00:34:50,264 >> thank you. 7716 00:34:50,264 --> 00:34:53,188 I attended an event about net 7717 00:34:53,188 --> 00:34:56,154 zero the other day at the bloun 7718 00:34:56,154 --> 00:34:56,154 t 7719 00:34:56,154 --> 00:35:00,864 center, and as is too ovthe cas 7720 00:35:00,864 --> 00:35:00,864 e 7721 00:35:00,864 --> 00:35:03,386 in -- often the case in the cit 7722 00:35:03,386 --> 00:35:03,386 y 7723 00:35:03,386 --> 00:35:04,554 outreach events we the public 7724 00:35:04,554 --> 00:35:05,536 got to sit and hear 7725 00:35:05,536 --> 00:35:07,220 presentations from staffs of 7726 00:35:07,220 --> 00:35:10,410 several departments and the we 7727 00:35:10,410 --> 00:35:10,410 7728 00:35:10,410 --> 00:35:12,814 the public did not get to give 7729 00:35:12,814 --> 00:35:12,814 7730 00:35:12,814 --> 00:35:14,916 our questions and statements to 7731 00:35:14,916 --> 00:35:14,916 7732 00:35:14,916 --> 00:35:17,044 the whole room to all staff and 7733 00:35:17,044 --> 00:35:17,044 7734 00:35:17,044 --> 00:35:17,614 public present. 7735 00:35:17,614 --> 00:35:20,352 that is, we were told well vis 7736 00:35:20,352 --> 00:35:20,352 it 7737 00:35:20,352 --> 00:35:22,114 each table and but that's not 7738 00:35:22,114 --> 00:35:24,190 speaking to the room and to 7739 00:35:24,190 --> 00:35:24,190 everybody. 7740 00:35:24,190 --> 00:35:28,994 so about these, about net zero. 7741 00:35:28,994 --> 00:35:28,994 7742 00:35:28,994 --> 00:35:30,226 I'm going to rattle off as lis 7743 00:35:30,226 --> 00:35:30,226 t 7744 00:35:30,226 --> 00:35:31,530 as quick as I can in this time 7745 00:35:31,530 --> 00:35:31,530 7746 00:35:31,530 --> 00:35:31,530 frame. 7747 00:35:31,530 --> 00:35:35,561 all offender ignition interlock 7748 00:35:35,561 --> 00:35:35,561 7749 00:35:35,561 --> 00:35:38,066 laws, has to do with d.u.I., 7750 00:35:38,066 --> 00:35:40,285 .05% blood alcohol content and 7751 00:35:40,285 --> 00:35:40,285 7752 00:35:40,285 --> 00:35:41,813 strict penalty laws as far as 7753 00:35:41,813 --> 00:35:42,674 revocation for repeat 7754 00:35:42,674 --> 00:35:42,674 offenders. 7755 00:35:42,674 --> 00:35:45,640 primary front seat belt laws. 7756 00:35:45,640 --> 00:35:50,049 primary rear seat belt laws. 7757 00:35:50,049 --> 00:35:50,927 speed cameras. 7758 00:35:50,927 --> 00:35:52,213 reduced speed limits where 7759 00:35:52,213 --> 00:35:52,213 appropriate. 7760 00:35:52,213 --> 00:35:55,930 all driver handheld devices 7761 00:35:55,930 --> 00:35:55,930 banned. 7762 00:35:55,930 --> 00:36:00,276 graduated driver licensing for 7763 00:36:00,276 --> 00:36:00,276 7764 00:36:00,276 --> 00:36:01,728 teens including younger permit 7765 00:36:01,728 --> 00:36:01,728 7766 00:36:01,728 --> 00:36:01,728 age. 7767 00:36:01,728 --> 00:36:05,045 not younger license but a longer 7768 00:36:05,045 --> 00:36:05,045 7769 00:36:05,045 --> 00:36:06,668 supervised learning period. 7770 00:36:06,668 --> 00:36:10,271 mandatory supervised hours fra 7771 00:36:10,271 --> 00:36:10,271 t 7772 00:36:10,271 --> 00:36:10,271 learning. 7773 00:36:10,271 --> 00:36:12,434 nighttime driving restrictions, 7774 00:36:12,434 --> 00:36:12,434 7775 00:36:12,434 --> 00:36:13,893 passenger restrictions, this I 7776 00:36:13,893 --> 00:36:13,893 s 7777 00:36:13,893 --> 00:36:14,977 again with young people. 7778 00:36:14,977 --> 00:36:17,910 intermediate license age. 7779 00:36:17,910 --> 00:36:19,447 other safety laws. 7780 00:36:19,447 --> 00:36:21,015 rear facing carseat law for 7781 00:36:21,015 --> 00:36:21,593 small children. 7782 00:36:21,593 --> 00:36:24,190 booster seat law. 7783 00:36:24,190 --> 00:36:25,488 motorcycle helmet laws. 7784 00:36:25,488 --> 00:36:27,045 that one stands out to me havin 7785 00:36:27,045 --> 00:36:27,045 g 7786 00:36:27,045 --> 00:36:28,885 seen many scrambled 7787 00:36:28,885 --> 00:36:31,953 motorcyclistsbrains in the e.r 7788 00:36:31,953 --> 00:36:31,953 . 7789 00:36:31,953 --> 00:36:33,293 all driver alcohol open 7790 00:36:33,293 --> 00:36:34,358 container law. 7791 00:36:34,358 --> 00:36:36,225 slow down move over laws. 7792 00:36:36,225 --> 00:36:40,558 this list of laws is done in 7793 00:36:40,558 --> 00:36:41,366 those states that have the 7794 00:36:41,366 --> 00:36:45,744 lowest traffic accident deaths. 7795 00:36:45,744 --> 00:36:45,744 7796 00:36:45,744 --> 00:36:49,342 so I favor your net zero effor 7797 00:36:49,342 --> 00:36:49,342 ts 7798 00:36:49,342 --> 00:36:51,278 here but your problem is in 7799 00:36:51,278 --> 00:36:51,278 tallahassee. 7800 00:36:51,278 --> 00:36:55,283 florida has three of these 17 7801 00:36:55,283 --> 00:36:55,283 laws. 7802 00:36:55,283 --> 00:36:58,447 and if they care about the 7803 00:36:58,447 --> 00:37:00,750 public, in tallahassee, they 7804 00:37:00,750 --> 00:37:04,120 ought to be passing these laws. 7805 00:37:04,120 --> 00:37:04,120 7806 00:37:04,120 --> 00:37:07,110 instead of listening to private 7807 00:37:07,110 --> 00:37:07,110 7808 00:37:07,110 --> 00:37:10,260 interests that want to limit 7809 00:37:10,260 --> 00:37:10,990 these laws. 7810 00:37:10,990 --> 00:37:13,431 for instance, motorcycle helme 7811 00:37:13,431 --> 00:37:13,431 ts 7812 00:37:13,431 --> 00:37:15,732 used to be the law. 7813 00:37:15,732 --> 00:37:17,899 and some people put on a 7814 00:37:17,899 --> 00:37:19,635 powerful lobbying effort to get 7815 00:37:19,635 --> 00:37:19,635 7816 00:37:19,635 --> 00:37:22,175 rid of that and in fact the lea 7817 00:37:22,175 --> 00:37:22,175 d 7818 00:37:22,175 --> 00:37:23,739 lobbyist died of head injuries 7819 00:37:23,739 --> 00:37:23,739 7820 00:37:23,739 --> 00:37:27,082 in a motorcycle crash. 7821 00:37:27,082 --> 00:37:28,848 so these laws are needed to 7822 00:37:28,848 --> 00:37:31,686 really reach your goal. 7823 00:37:31,686 --> 00:37:32,324 >> mayor: I don't think anybody 7824 00:37:32,324 --> 00:37:32,324 7825 00:37:32,324 --> 00:37:32,997 here disagrees with you, 7826 00:37:32,997 --> 00:37:34,673 mr. Blount. 7827 00:37:34,673 --> 00:37:36,394 >> andrew miles. 7828 00:37:36,394 --> 00:37:37,524 >> mayor: welcome, mr. Miles. 7829 00:37:37,524 --> 00:37:42,390 >> our last speaker. 7830 00:37:42,390 --> 00:37:45,022 >> good afternoon, y'all. 7831 00:37:45,022 --> 00:37:46,199 I'm here at this particular 7832 00:37:46,199 --> 00:37:48,530 point to talk to y'all about 7833 00:37:48,530 --> 00:37:50,010 property boundaries on the 7834 00:37:50,010 --> 00:37:52,705 northeast side of town. 7835 00:37:52,705 --> 00:37:54,872 the properties on the west, 7836 00:37:54,872 --> 00:37:57,293 east, south and north side of 7837 00:37:57,293 --> 00:37:59,381 all the properties in east 7838 00:37:59,381 --> 00:38:02,314 gainesville, it's all by about 7839 00:38:02,314 --> 00:38:02,314 7840 00:38:02,314 --> 00:38:06,629 five feet. 7841 00:38:06,629 --> 00:38:09,913 and on all the sides now, it's 7842 00:38:09,913 --> 00:38:09,913 7843 00:38:09,913 --> 00:38:12,183 started to affect the residents 7844 00:38:12,183 --> 00:38:12,183 7845 00:38:12,183 --> 00:38:13,390 because we got lot of new homes 7846 00:38:13,390 --> 00:38:13,390 7847 00:38:13,390 --> 00:38:15,130 that are being built on the eas 7848 00:38:15,130 --> 00:38:15,130 t 7849 00:38:15,130 --> 00:38:17,233 side now. 7850 00:38:17,233 --> 00:38:18,965 all before when people rur 7851 00:38:18,965 --> 00:38:21,028 building their most of it was 7852 00:38:21,028 --> 00:38:23,439 residents that was living there 7853 00:38:23,439 --> 00:38:23,439 7854 00:38:23,439 --> 00:38:24,943 before, and so they didn't arg 7855 00:38:24,943 --> 00:38:24,943 ue 7856 00:38:24,943 --> 00:38:26,438 with each other and they kind o 7857 00:38:26,438 --> 00:38:26,438 f 7858 00:38:26,438 --> 00:38:28,641 let people kept their fences up 7859 00:38:28,641 --> 00:38:28,641 7860 00:38:28,641 --> 00:38:29,708 and stuff like that. 7861 00:38:29,708 --> 00:38:31,908 but now there's a lot of new 7862 00:38:31,908 --> 00:38:32,806 properties that have been built 7863 00:38:32,806 --> 00:38:32,806 7864 00:38:32,806 --> 00:38:36,613 by homeowners and they're 7865 00:38:36,613 --> 00:38:38,151 measuring the property, and 7866 00:38:38,151 --> 00:38:39,549 they're finding that it's five 7867 00:38:39,549 --> 00:38:39,549 7868 00:38:39,549 --> 00:38:41,501 feet off on all sides all the 7869 00:38:41,501 --> 00:38:43,189 way around in fact my property 7870 00:38:43,189 --> 00:38:43,189 7871 00:38:43,189 --> 00:38:46,124 my front yard goes five feet 7872 00:38:46,124 --> 00:38:49,603 into a roadway so half of the 7873 00:38:49,603 --> 00:38:51,490 roadway is part of my property. 7874 00:38:51,490 --> 00:38:51,490 7875 00:38:51,490 --> 00:38:53,369 and I found out that in my 7876 00:38:53,369 --> 00:38:55,903 backyard where I had got a 7877 00:38:55,903 --> 00:38:59,374 permit to build a garage stora 7878 00:38:59,374 --> 00:38:59,374 ge 7879 00:38:59,374 --> 00:39:03,003 unit back there, that four fee 7880 00:39:03,003 --> 00:39:03,003 tf 7881 00:39:03,003 --> 00:39:03,984 that property does not belong t 7882 00:39:03,984 --> 00:39:03,984 o 7883 00:39:03,984 --> 00:39:03,984 me. 7884 00:39:03,984 --> 00:39:07,607 and so it's some problems that 7885 00:39:07,607 --> 00:39:07,607 7886 00:39:07,607 --> 00:39:09,150 are occurring right now and the 7887 00:39:09,150 --> 00:39:09,150 n 7888 00:39:09,150 --> 00:39:11,765 find out that property on the 7889 00:39:11,765 --> 00:39:13,754 other side of me is right up to 7890 00:39:13,754 --> 00:39:13,754 7891 00:39:13,754 --> 00:39:16,590 the sliding door glass of a 7892 00:39:16,590 --> 00:39:18,226 homeowner and their porch and 7893 00:39:18,226 --> 00:39:22,157 all is actually on my property. 7894 00:39:22,157 --> 00:39:22,157 7895 00:39:22,157 --> 00:39:23,459 so that really needs to be 7896 00:39:23,459 --> 00:39:26,036 looked at and see how we can 7897 00:39:26,036 --> 00:39:26,996 work some of this out because 7898 00:39:26,996 --> 00:39:28,737 it's going to be lot more 7899 00:39:28,737 --> 00:39:31,042 problems very soon about this 7900 00:39:31,042 --> 00:39:33,064 because in the pas 7901 00:39:33,064 --> 00:39:36,181 built the home in '82 after 7902 00:39:36,181 --> 00:39:37,578 realizing -- say something abo 7903 00:39:37,578 --> 00:39:37,578 ut 7904 00:39:37,578 --> 00:39:40,311 it, I came a couple years ago 7905 00:39:40,311 --> 00:39:41,381 about it and say something to 7906 00:39:41,381 --> 00:39:41,642 the commission. 7907 00:39:41,642 --> 00:39:42,520 I talked to the property 7908 00:39:42,520 --> 00:39:43,948 appraiser office a couple times 7909 00:39:43,948 --> 00:39:43,948 7910 00:39:43,948 --> 00:39:46,581 and reported it and ask them 7911 00:39:46,581 --> 00:39:48,421 could they look at it. 7912 00:39:48,421 --> 00:39:49,521 they came out and did 7913 00:39:49,521 --> 00:39:50,424 measurements and now recently 7914 00:39:50,424 --> 00:39:51,184 they are doing lot of 7915 00:39:51,184 --> 00:39:53,177 measurements but it really nee 7916 00:39:53,177 --> 00:39:53,177 ds 7917 00:39:53,177 --> 00:39:54,200 to be looked into because it's 7918 00:39:54,200 --> 00:39:54,200 7919 00:39:54,200 --> 00:39:56,955 going to be a lot of fights and 7920 00:39:56,955 --> 00:39:56,955 7921 00:39:56,955 --> 00:39:59,630 pushes about who owns what 7922 00:39:59,630 --> 00:40:01,076 property and I don't know if 7923 00:40:01,076 --> 00:40:02,369 you've been taking care of tha 7924 00:40:02,369 --> 00:40:02,369 t 7925 00:40:02,369 --> 00:40:03,936 property for 40, 50 years if 7926 00:40:03,936 --> 00:40:04,893 that going to give you the right 7927 00:40:04,893 --> 00:40:04,893 7928 00:40:04,893 --> 00:40:06,871 to still keep that property or 7929 00:40:06,871 --> 00:40:06,871 7930 00:40:06,871 --> 00:40:09,604 not, but I know this is about t 7931 00:40:09,604 --> 00:40:09,604 o 7932 00:40:09,604 --> 00:40:12,009 come up real soon because like 7933 00:40:12,009 --> 00:40:12,158 I 7934 00:40:12,158 --> 00:40:13,976 said four feet of my backyard 7935 00:40:13,976 --> 00:40:15,645 has been pointed out to me tha 7936 00:40:15,645 --> 00:40:15,645 t 7937 00:40:15,645 --> 00:40:17,613 it don't belong to me. 7938 00:40:17,613 --> 00:40:18,914 and according to when they com 7939 00:40:18,914 --> 00:40:18,914 e 7940 00:40:18,914 --> 00:40:20,702 out and shoot the property line 7941 00:40:20,702 --> 00:40:20,702 7942 00:40:20,702 --> 00:40:23,753 now, it's pretty much actual 7943 00:40:23,753 --> 00:40:24,620 what they're saying. 7944 00:40:24,620 --> 00:40:26,391 but when they shot it before, 7945 00:40:26,391 --> 00:40:28,456 when we got the permit, to bui 7946 00:40:28,456 --> 00:40:28,456 ld 7947 00:40:28,456 --> 00:40:30,418 a shed there they said 7948 00:40:30,418 --> 00:40:31,762 everything was aligned. 7949 00:40:31,762 --> 00:40:32,698 so it's going talqestamab a lot 7950 00:40:32,698 --> 00:40:32,698 7951 00:40:32,698 --> 00:40:33,755 of confusion. 7952 00:40:33,755 --> 00:40:35,032 I hope that y'all try to get 7953 00:40:35,032 --> 00:40:36,913 this addressed real soon instead 7954 00:40:36,913 --> 00:40:36,913 7955 00:40:36,913 --> 00:40:38,433 of later because a lot of new 7956 00:40:38,433 --> 00:40:40,508 homes been built out on the eas 7957 00:40:40,508 --> 00:40:40,508 t 7958 00:40:40,508 --> 00:40:41,438 side right now at this present 7959 00:40:41,438 --> 00:40:41,438 7960 00:40:41,438 --> 00:40:41,438 time. 7961 00:40:41,438 --> 00:40:50,846 new that was our last speaker, 7962 00:40:50,846 --> 00:40:50,846 7963 00:40:50,846 --> 00:40:52,124 mr. Mayor. 7964 00:40:52,124 --> 00:40:52,654 >> mayor: very good. 7965 00:40:52,654 --> 00:40:53,348 >> we are onto our discussion 7966 00:40:53,348 --> 00:40:54,260 items for the afternoon. 7967 00:40:54,260 --> 00:40:54,260 2026-92. 7968 00:40:54,260 --> 00:40:57,542 heartwood soundstage funding 7969 00:40:57,542 --> 00:40:58,520 with the recommendation the cit 7970 00:40:58,520 --> 00:40:58,520 y 7971 00:40:58,520 --> 00:41:01,892 commission approve allocating 7972 00:41:01,892 --> 00:41:03,176 $55,000 from excess fund balance 7973 00:41:03,176 --> 00:41:03,176 7974 00:41:03,176 --> 00:41:04,094 in the general fund for 7975 00:41:04,094 --> 00:41:05,760 heartwood sound' stage funding 7976 00:41:05,760 --> 00:41:05,760 7977 00:41:05,760 --> 00:41:07,342 request and provide direction o 7978 00:41:07,342 --> 00:41:09,482 npreferred option for 7979 00:41:09,482 --> 00:41:09,482 disbursement. 7980 00:41:09,482 --> 00:41:10,210 >> mayor: all right, 7981 00:41:10,210 --> 00:41:10,916 mr. Manager, did you want to -- 7982 00:41:10,916 --> 00:41:10,916 7983 00:41:10,916 --> 00:41:13,142 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 7984 00:41:13,142 --> 00:41:14,604 the march 5th meeting you all 7985 00:41:14,604 --> 00:41:16,670 asked for us to come back with 7986 00:41:16,670 --> 00:41:16,670 7987 00:41:16,670 --> 00:41:18,740 options for y'all to consider 7988 00:41:18,740 --> 00:41:23,675 about how to accommodate the 7989 00:41:23,675 --> 00:41:27,282 heartwood soundstage's request 7990 00:41:27,282 --> 00:41:27,282 . 7991 00:41:27,282 --> 00:41:28,981 we are recommending that if the 7992 00:41:28,981 --> 00:41:28,981 7993 00:41:28,981 --> 00:41:30,320 commission did decide to move 7994 00:41:30,320 --> 00:41:33,724 forward with, with funding, it 7995 00:41:33,724 --> 00:41:33,724 7996 00:41:33,724 --> 00:41:35,162 would come from excess fund 7997 00:41:35,162 --> 00:41:35,162 balance. 7998 00:41:35,162 --> 00:41:37,808 we provided three options for 7999 00:41:37,808 --> 00:41:42,808 your consideration, a loan 8000 00:41:42,808 --> 00:41:45,542 format, importantly we don't 8001 00:41:45,542 --> 00:41:49,174 have terms to discuss and that 8002 00:41:49,174 --> 00:41:49,174 8003 00:41:49,174 --> 00:41:51,013 may be something that y'all 8004 00:41:51,013 --> 00:41:53,108 could discuss if that was a 8005 00:41:53,108 --> 00:41:55,078 desired option. 8006 00:41:55,078 --> 00:41:56,418 in advance the grant with 8007 00:41:56,418 --> 00:41:59,016 required backup documentation 8008 00:41:59,016 --> 00:42:01,743 for expended funds and city 8009 00:42:01,743 --> 00:42:04,355 audit right to, audit right 8010 00:42:04,355 --> 00:42:05,592 languageige there. 8011 00:42:05,592 --> 00:42:08,877 that would be a similar to wha 8012 00:42:08,877 --> 00:42:08,877 t 8013 00:42:08,877 --> 00:42:11,671 the city commission did for the 8014 00:42:11,671 --> 00:42:11,671 8015 00:42:11,671 --> 00:42:13,105 hippodrome, and then a 8016 00:42:13,105 --> 00:42:15,302 reimbursable grant with required 8017 00:42:15,302 --> 00:42:15,302 8018 00:42:15,302 --> 00:42:16,736 backup documentation right to 8019 00:42:16,736 --> 00:42:19,131 audit requirements. 8020 00:42:19,131 --> 00:42:24,432 I think importantly, there are 8021 00:42:24,432 --> 00:42:24,432 8022 00:42:24,432 --> 00:42:27,241 the soundstage I think during 8023 00:42:27,241 --> 00:42:28,441 the last presentation gave you 8024 00:42:28,441 --> 00:42:28,441 8025 00:42:28,441 --> 00:42:31,311 some, some items by which I 8026 00:42:31,311 --> 00:42:33,350 think they have some outstanding 8027 00:42:33,350 --> 00:42:33,350 8028 00:42:33,350 --> 00:42:34,488 debt, some operational 8029 00:42:34,488 --> 00:42:34,488 expenses,. 8030 00:42:34,488 --> 00:42:40,537 I think for purposes of the 8031 00:42:40,537 --> 00:42:45,525 commission's decision we would 8032 00:42:45,525 --> 00:42:45,525 8033 00:42:45,525 --> 00:42:47,749 want to at least put it on the 8034 00:42:47,749 --> 00:42:47,749 8035 00:42:47,749 --> 00:42:50,006 record that we would need to v 8036 00:42:50,006 --> 00:42:50,006 et 8037 00:42:50,006 --> 00:42:54,803 any potential expenditures wit 8038 00:42:54,803 --> 00:42:54,803 h 8039 00:42:54,803 --> 00:42:57,200 in conjunction with financial 8040 00:42:57,200 --> 00:42:57,968 services and the attorney's 8041 00:42:57,968 --> 00:43:00,939 office to make sure that any 8042 00:43:00,939 --> 00:43:04,109 expenses were sort of public 8043 00:43:04,109 --> 00:43:07,054 interest meaning if, if there 8044 00:43:07,054 --> 00:43:09,049 was old debt as a private 8045 00:43:09,049 --> 00:43:10,591 institution or a private 8046 00:43:10,591 --> 00:43:12,223 company, those things would nee 8047 00:43:12,223 --> 00:43:12,223 d 8048 00:43:12,223 --> 00:43:13,853 to be vetted to make sure that 8049 00:43:13,853 --> 00:43:13,853 8050 00:43:13,853 --> 00:43:15,229 we could actually expend publi 8051 00:43:15,229 --> 00:43:15,229 c 8052 00:43:15,229 --> 00:43:17,732 dollars on it versus ongoing 8053 00:43:17,732 --> 00:43:18,845 operational expenses, which 8054 00:43:18,845 --> 00:43:21,137 would be certainly I think a 8055 00:43:21,137 --> 00:43:23,835 more allowable use than paying 8056 00:43:23,835 --> 00:43:23,835 8057 00:43:23,835 --> 00:43:25,367 for old private debt if that 8058 00:43:25,367 --> 00:43:27,970 makes sense. 8059 00:43:27,970 --> 00:43:28,845 >> mayor: okay, thank you, 8060 00:43:28,845 --> 00:43:30,893 mr. Manager. 8061 00:43:30,893 --> 00:43:32,811 did anyone from heartwood want 8062 00:43:32,811 --> 00:43:32,811 8063 00:43:32,811 --> 00:43:34,315 to make any further 8064 00:43:34,315 --> 00:43:34,315 presentation? 8065 00:43:34,315 --> 00:43:37,209 or did we want to go straight t 8066 00:43:37,209 --> 00:43:37,209 o 8067 00:43:37,209 --> 00:43:37,209 discussion? 8068 00:43:37,209 --> 00:43:38,521 you don't have to. 8069 00:43:38,521 --> 00:43:39,879 I mean, we were all here last 8070 00:43:39,879 --> 00:43:39,879 time? 8071 00:43:39,879 --> 00:43:39,879 okay. 8072 00:43:39,879 --> 00:43:42,111 very good. 8073 00:43:42,111 --> 00:43:42,689 all right. 8074 00:43:42,689 --> 00:43:43,461 any thoughts from the 8075 00:43:43,461 --> 00:43:43,461 commission? 8076 00:43:43,461 --> 00:43:52,559 commissioner willits. 8077 00:43:52,559 --> 00:43:53,415 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 8078 00:43:53,415 --> 00:43:57,537 I agree that if, that future 8079 00:43:57,537 --> 00:43:59,039 facing needs under the current 8080 00:43:59,039 --> 00:43:59,039 8081 00:43:59,039 --> 00:44:01,473 structure of the 501(c)3 that 8082 00:44:01,473 --> 00:44:03,929 is heartwood now makes the most 8083 00:44:03,929 --> 00:44:03,929 8084 00:44:03,929 --> 00:44:05,705 sense if that's what it is, it' 8085 00:44:05,705 --> 00:44:05,705 s 8086 00:44:05,705 --> 00:44:06,943 about what they need now to 8087 00:44:06,943 --> 00:44:09,447 continue being, you know, 8088 00:44:09,447 --> 00:44:09,447 successful. 8089 00:44:09,447 --> 00:44:13,749 but I also understand that the 8090 00:44:13,749 --> 00:44:13,749 ir 8091 00:44:13,749 --> 00:44:15,488 business model is their rapidly 8092 00:44:15,488 --> 00:44:15,488 8093 00:44:15,488 --> 00:44:17,113 switching from their for profi 8094 00:44:17,113 --> 00:44:17,113 t 8095 00:44:17,113 --> 00:44:20,719 to nonprofit structure and 8096 00:44:20,719 --> 00:44:22,267 rebuilding kind of rebuilding 8097 00:44:22,267 --> 00:44:24,057 the airplane as it's flying to 8098 00:44:24,057 --> 00:44:24,057 8099 00:44:24,057 --> 00:44:25,223 go off into the future 8100 00:44:25,223 --> 00:44:27,967 successful as possible as a, a 8101 00:44:27,967 --> 00:44:27,967 n 8102 00:44:27,967 --> 00:44:30,705 arts presenting institution in 8103 00:44:30,705 --> 00:44:30,705 8104 00:44:30,705 --> 00:44:30,705 downtown. 8105 00:44:30,705 --> 00:44:33,433 so some of this is a little 8106 00:44:33,433 --> 00:44:36,606 confusing to me just about lik 8107 00:44:36,606 --> 00:44:36,606 e 8108 00:44:36,606 --> 00:44:37,995 because I know the sport is -- 8109 00:44:37,995 --> 00:44:37,995 8110 00:44:37,995 --> 00:44:39,274 it's kind of a general support 8111 00:44:39,274 --> 00:44:39,274 8112 00:44:39,274 --> 00:44:41,895 kind of a bridge to get to the 8113 00:44:41,895 --> 00:44:41,895 8114 00:44:41,895 --> 00:44:43,001 future, but at the same time I 8115 00:44:43,001 --> 00:44:43,001 8116 00:44:43,001 --> 00:44:44,477 do see that we have some 8117 00:44:44,477 --> 00:44:46,681 instances of, you know, some 8118 00:44:46,681 --> 00:44:49,285 transparency about, you know, 8119 00:44:49,285 --> 00:44:51,053 the expenses they have. 8120 00:44:51,053 --> 00:44:53,227 I don't feel good about retiring 8121 00:44:53,227 --> 00:44:53,227 8122 00:44:53,227 --> 00:44:53,227 debt. 8123 00:44:53,227 --> 00:44:55,993 I feel much better about, 8124 00:44:55,993 --> 00:44:59,331 know, basically paying people' 8125 00:44:59,331 --> 00:44:59,331 s 8126 00:44:59,331 --> 00:45:01,071 salaries who have been -- and 8127 00:45:01,071 --> 00:45:03,671 I'm still a little not sure tha 8128 00:45:03,671 --> 00:45:03,671 t 8129 00:45:03,671 --> 00:45:05,699 I will support this because of 8130 00:45:05,699 --> 00:45:05,699 8131 00:45:05,699 --> 00:45:08,671 this midyear, I don't know, it' 8132 00:45:08,671 --> 00:45:08,671 s 8133 00:45:08,671 --> 00:45:10,470 tough because it is a really 8134 00:45:10,470 --> 00:45:12,173 good chunk of entertainment 8135 00:45:12,173 --> 00:45:13,171 downtown, and it does make a l 8136 00:45:13,171 --> 00:45:13,171 ot 8137 00:45:13,171 --> 00:45:15,160 of sense I would prefer it be 8138 00:45:15,160 --> 00:45:17,361 normal budget process with 8139 00:45:17,361 --> 00:45:21,581 changes to our other program 8140 00:45:21,581 --> 00:45:21,581 eligibility. 8141 00:45:21,581 --> 00:45:22,879 thank you, mr. Mayor. 8142 00:45:22,879 --> 00:45:23,393 >> mayor: thank you, 8143 00:45:23,393 --> 00:45:23,825 commissioner willits. 8144 00:45:23,825 --> 00:45:25,142 to be clear, this is a 8145 00:45:25,142 --> 00:45:31,025 nonprofit, and as they provide 8146 00:45:31,025 --> 00:45:31,025 8147 00:45:31,025 --> 00:45:35,095 a, an opportunity for a variety 8148 00:45:35,095 --> 00:45:35,095 8149 00:45:35,095 --> 00:45:40,905 of arts for the community, som 8150 00:45:40,905 --> 00:45:40,905 e 8151 00:45:40,905 --> 00:45:42,335 of it open to the community, 8152 00:45:42,335 --> 00:45:45,842 some of it ticketed talso is a 8153 00:45:45,842 --> 00:45:45,842 n 8154 00:45:45,842 --> 00:45:47,478 economic development issue, and 8155 00:45:47,478 --> 00:45:47,478 8156 00:45:47,478 --> 00:45:49,393 that's the way I look at this 8157 00:45:49,393 --> 00:45:49,393 100%. 8158 00:45:49,393 --> 00:45:52,177 there are businesses surrounding 8159 00:45:52,177 --> 00:45:52,177 8160 00:45:52,177 --> 00:45:54,149 it that are there because 8161 00:45:54,149 --> 00:45:56,013 heartwood is there. 8162 00:45:56,013 --> 00:46:00,091 and that is an important 8163 00:46:00,091 --> 00:46:01,389 consideration as we move forwa 8164 00:46:01,389 --> 00:46:01,389 rd 8165 00:46:01,389 --> 00:46:02,924 with this thought. 8166 00:46:02,924 --> 00:46:04,458 but commissioner book. 8167 00:46:04,458 --> 00:46:05,513 >> yeah, thank you, mr. Mayor. 8168 00:46:05,513 --> 00:46:05,513 8169 00:46:05,513 --> 00:46:07,731 so when we kind of spoke about 8170 00:46:07,731 --> 00:46:07,731 8171 00:46:07,731 --> 00:46:09,155 this at length on march 5th 8172 00:46:09,155 --> 00:46:11,047 almost a month ago, we were 8173 00:46:11,047 --> 00:46:12,078 talking -- what's the current 8174 00:46:12,078 --> 00:46:14,539 financial picture? 8175 00:46:14,539 --> 00:46:17,609 maybe -- this is a unique one. 8176 00:46:17,609 --> 00:46:17,609 8177 00:46:17,609 --> 00:46:18,284 I don't think in the time that 8178 00:46:18,284 --> 00:46:18,284 8179 00:46:18,284 --> 00:46:19,673 I've been on the commission tha 8180 00:46:19,673 --> 00:46:19,673 t 8181 00:46:19,673 --> 00:46:22,405 we've had a situation for a for 8182 00:46:22,405 --> 00:46:22,405 8183 00:46:22,405 --> 00:46:24,149 profit converted to a nonprofit 8184 00:46:24,149 --> 00:46:24,149 8185 00:46:24,149 --> 00:46:25,405 and then we provided them money 8186 00:46:25,405 --> 00:46:25,405 8187 00:46:25,405 --> 00:46:27,486 to get up and running. 8188 00:46:27,486 --> 00:46:29,031 if there is, I'm unfamiliar wit 8189 00:46:29,031 --> 00:46:29,031 h 8190 00:46:29,031 --> 00:46:31,719 it and so it's really difficult 8191 00:46:31,719 --> 00:46:31,719 8192 00:46:31,719 --> 00:46:33,427 to consider but I thought what' 8193 00:46:33,427 --> 00:46:33,427 s 8194 00:46:33,427 --> 00:46:34,485 the current financial picture 8195 00:46:34,485 --> 00:46:35,931 for heartwood? 8196 00:46:35,931 --> 00:46:37,455 we've had about a month to get 8197 00:46:37,455 --> 00:46:37,455 8198 00:46:37,455 --> 00:46:37,455 that. 8199 00:46:37,455 --> 00:46:39,108 I wonder if any of the heartwo 8200 00:46:39,108 --> 00:46:39,108 od 8201 00:46:39,108 --> 00:46:40,039 staff would be willing to 8202 00:46:40,039 --> 00:46:47,302 provide some updates. 8203 00:46:47,302 --> 00:46:48,602 >> thank you, my name is chels 8204 00:46:48,602 --> 00:46:48,602 y 8205 00:46:48,602 --> 00:46:50,151 karns I'm the executive directo 8206 00:46:50,151 --> 00:46:50,151 r 8207 00:46:50,151 --> 00:46:52,534 of heartwood sound stage. 8208 00:46:52,534 --> 00:47:00,580 so financial picture, I give t 8209 00:47:00,580 --> 00:47:00,580 he 8210 00:47:00,580 --> 00:47:02,652 full spiel last time but minor 8211 00:47:02,652 --> 00:47:02,652 8212 00:47:02,652 --> 00:47:03,747 updates since then. 8213 00:47:03,747 --> 00:47:05,112 just to repeat for the folks I 8214 00:47:05,112 --> 00:47:05,112 n 8215 00:47:05,112 --> 00:47:05,862 the audience who weren't here 8216 00:47:05,862 --> 00:47:06,604 last time, some of those 8217 00:47:06,604 --> 00:47:10,032 numbers, you know, we brought I 8218 00:47:10,032 --> 00:47:10,032 n 8219 00:47:10,032 --> 00:47:11,604 23,0 concert goers last year, 8220 00:47:11,604 --> 00:47:15,059 across 160 events, generated 8221 00:47:15,059 --> 00:47:16,902 $864,000 in ticket revenue. 8222 00:47:16,902 --> 00:47:18,107 there's a lot of studies that 8223 00:47:18,107 --> 00:47:20,124 show that performing arts 8224 00:47:20,124 --> 00:47:22,736 centers like ours, the amount o 8225 00:47:22,736 --> 00:47:22,736 f 8226 00:47:22,736 --> 00:47:23,944 economic activity that happens 8227 00:47:23,944 --> 00:47:23,944 8228 00:47:23,944 --> 00:47:25,344 around those events that's 8229 00:47:25,344 --> 00:47:26,640 people eating downtown, getting 8230 00:47:26,640 --> 00:47:26,640 8231 00:47:26,640 --> 00:47:28,978 hotel rooms, even the bands who 8232 00:47:28,978 --> 00:47:28,978 8233 00:47:28,978 --> 00:47:30,820 come in I shop their writers 8234 00:47:30,820 --> 00:47:32,583 which are often $1,000 writers 8235 00:47:32,583 --> 00:47:32,583 8236 00:47:32,583 --> 00:47:33,642 where I'm going to local, you 8237 00:47:33,642 --> 00:47:35,513 know, I just put in a $200 orde 8238 00:47:35,513 --> 00:47:35,513 r 8239 00:47:35,513 --> 00:47:37,380 at paper bag last week for 8240 00:47:37,380 --> 00:47:39,656 sandwiches for our, for a big 8241 00:47:39,656 --> 00:47:40,621 band that was touring through. 8242 00:47:40,621 --> 00:47:40,621 you 8243 00:47:40,621 --> 00:47:42,097 you know, so the economic 8244 00:47:42,097 --> 00:47:42,956 activity that happens around 8245 00:47:42,956 --> 00:47:44,824 these events is like five times 8246 00:47:44,824 --> 00:47:44,824 8247 00:47:44,824 --> 00:47:46,464 what we're generating internally 8248 00:47:46,464 --> 00:47:46,464 8249 00:47:46,464 --> 00:47:48,088 not to mention we're providing 8250 00:47:48,088 --> 00:47:48,088 8251 00:47:48,088 --> 00:47:51,738 jobs for 40-plus local 8252 00:47:51,738 --> 00:47:53,502 individuals who work in the art 8253 00:47:53,502 --> 00:47:53,502 s 8254 00:47:53,502 --> 00:47:54,904 that's steam jobs like sound 8255 00:47:54,904 --> 00:47:58,084 engineering and audio teching, 8256 00:47:58,084 --> 00:47:58,084 8257 00:47:58,084 --> 00:48:00,711 light design, and also 8258 00:48:00,711 --> 00:48:02,111 hospitality and event managemen 8259 00:48:02,111 --> 00:48:02,111 t 8260 00:48:02,111 --> 00:48:02,111 positions. 8261 00:48:02,111 --> 00:48:04,417 we have close relationships 8262 00:48:04,417 --> 00:48:05,979 with, I don't know how far to g 8263 00:48:05,979 --> 00:48:05,979 o 8264 00:48:05,979 --> 00:48:07,919 into the spiel but we have clo 8265 00:48:07,919 --> 00:48:07,919 se 8266 00:48:07,919 --> 00:48:10,168 relationships with uf, santa f 8267 00:48:10,168 --> 00:48:10,168 e 8268 00:48:10,168 --> 00:48:10,933 college, there is a university 8269 00:48:10,933 --> 00:48:10,933 8270 00:48:10,933 --> 00:48:13,616 of florida class base a 8271 00:48:13,616 --> 00:48:15,849 videoraphy class based on our 8272 00:48:15,849 --> 00:48:20,094 campuses, teaching viddography 8273 00:48:20,094 --> 00:48:20,094 . 8274 00:48:20,094 --> 00:48:23,164 they can go on to do live event 8275 00:48:23,164 --> 00:48:23,164 8276 00:48:23,164 --> 00:48:25,038 photography and videography, a 8277 00:48:25,038 --> 00:48:25,038 nd 8278 00:48:25,038 --> 00:48:27,296 you know financially one thing 8279 00:48:27,296 --> 00:48:28,076 I 8280 00:48:28,076 --> 00:48:28,976 said last time that I was here 8281 00:48:28,976 --> 00:48:28,976 8282 00:48:28,976 --> 00:48:32,048 and that I'll reiterate is tha 8283 00:48:32,048 --> 00:48:32,048 t 8284 00:48:32,048 --> 00:48:33,440 this isn't a story of a busines 8285 00:48:33,440 --> 00:48:33,440 s 8286 00:48:33,440 --> 00:48:35,608 that failed or a project that 8287 00:48:35,608 --> 00:48:36,508 you know failed to meet goals. 8288 00:48:36,508 --> 00:48:36,508 8289 00:48:36,508 --> 00:48:38,252 it's actually the opposite. 8290 00:48:38,252 --> 00:48:39,679 we've been incredibly 8291 00:48:39,679 --> 00:48:39,679 successful. 8292 00:48:39,679 --> 00:48:41,982 the people who founded this 8293 00:48:41,982 --> 00:48:43,818 institution four years ago nev 8294 00:48:43,818 --> 00:48:43,818 er 8295 00:48:43,818 --> 00:48:45,610 imagined that it would grow into 8296 00:48:45,610 --> 00:48:45,610 8297 00:48:45,610 --> 00:48:47,223 this thing that it is today. 8298 00:48:47,223 --> 00:48:48,092 it was a small listening room 8299 00:48:48,092 --> 00:48:50,530 for videography and for 100 8300 00:48:50,530 --> 00:48:51,896 people to sit and quietly liste 8301 00:48:51,896 --> 00:48:51,896 n 8302 00:48:51,896 --> 00:48:52,712 to sconsert and now it's a 8303 00:48:52,712 --> 00:48:53,926 festival and event space a 8304 00:48:53,926 --> 00:48:56,346 performing arts center, a campu 8305 00:48:56,346 --> 00:48:56,346 s for 8306 00:48:56,346 --> 00:48:58,860 for learning, and a place that 8307 00:48:58,860 --> 00:48:58,860 8308 00:48:58,860 --> 00:49:01,344 employs again over 40 local 8309 00:49:01,344 --> 00:49:01,344 professionals. 8310 00:49:01,344 --> 00:49:07,349 so you know, with that growth 8311 00:49:07,349 --> 00:49:10,706 comes a need for you know, 8312 00:49:10,706 --> 00:49:12,022 better supplies, better 8313 00:49:12,022 --> 00:49:14,218 equipment, we're also hitting 8314 00:49:14,218 --> 00:49:15,704 our 10-year anniversary so a l 8315 00:49:15,704 --> 00:49:15,704 ot 8316 00:49:15,704 --> 00:49:16,980 of things were purchased 10 8317 00:49:16,980 --> 00:49:18,866 years ago and we need -- we put 8318 00:49:18,866 --> 00:49:18,866 8319 00:49:18,866 --> 00:49:19,500 $4,000 into lights. 8320 00:49:19,500 --> 00:49:20,778 we needed new lights on the top 8321 00:49:20,778 --> 00:49:20,778 8322 00:49:20,778 --> 00:49:22,899 of our stage so this request 8323 00:49:22,899 --> 00:49:23,800 comes from a place of we're 8324 00:49:23,800 --> 00:49:25,822 really growing we're really 8325 00:49:25,822 --> 00:49:27,082 expanding we're doing our part 8326 00:49:27,082 --> 00:49:27,082 8327 00:49:27,082 --> 00:49:28,600 to bring people downtown to 8328 00:49:28,600 --> 00:49:30,032 support arts and community, 8329 00:49:30,032 --> 00:49:31,247 community resilience through t 8330 00:49:31,247 --> 00:49:31,247 he 8331 00:49:31,247 --> 00:49:32,962 arts, and downtown gainesville 8332 00:49:32,962 --> 00:49:32,962 . 8333 00:49:32,962 --> 00:49:35,167 making it a place for people's 8334 00:49:35,167 --> 00:49:35,167 8335 00:49:35,167 --> 00:49:36,484 to feel safe and comfortable a 8336 00:49:36,484 --> 00:49:36,484 nd 8337 00:49:36,484 --> 00:49:38,771 bring their families. 8338 00:49:38,771 --> 00:49:39,637 and supporting the local 8339 00:49:39,637 --> 00:49:42,078 businesses around us with our 8340 00:49:42,078 --> 00:49:42,078 activities. 8341 00:49:42,078 --> 00:49:44,246 so this request is, you know, t 8342 00:49:44,246 --> 00:49:44,246 o 8343 00:49:44,246 --> 00:49:47,218 so we can continue doing that. 8344 00:49:47,218 --> 00:49:47,218 8345 00:49:47,218 --> 00:49:49,718 those are kind of a lot but I 8346 00:49:49,718 --> 00:49:50,452 don't know specifically if you 8347 00:49:50,452 --> 00:49:50,452 8348 00:49:50,452 --> 00:49:51,165 want a certain number let me 8349 00:49:51,165 --> 00:49:51,165 know. 8350 00:49:51,165 --> 00:49:53,800 >> yeah, I think we had -- than 8351 00:49:53,800 --> 00:49:53,800 k 8352 00:49:53,800 --> 00:49:54,592 you very much for that 8353 00:49:54,592 --> 00:49:54,592 synopsis. 8354 00:49:54,592 --> 00:49:56,860 I think that probably my thoug 8355 00:49:56,860 --> 00:49:56,860 ht 8356 00:49:56,860 --> 00:49:57,757 about optimism for 8357 00:49:57,757 --> 00:49:59,262 heartwoodicize an economic 8358 00:49:59,262 --> 00:50:00,929 driver clearly it is that, 8359 00:50:00,929 --> 00:50:03,462 mr. Mayor is that you have 8360 00:50:03,462 --> 00:50:04,795 somebody who's come in and the 8361 00:50:04,795 --> 00:50:04,795 8362 00:50:04,795 --> 00:50:06,431 executive director who has 8363 00:50:06,431 --> 00:50:08,161 extensive knowledge about how t 8364 00:50:08,161 --> 00:50:08,161 o 8365 00:50:08,161 --> 00:50:09,166 manage things just like this. 8366 00:50:09,166 --> 00:50:11,476 so that's why I feel good about 8367 00:50:11,476 --> 00:50:11,476 8368 00:50:11,476 --> 00:50:13,306 heartwood going forward. 8369 00:50:13,306 --> 00:50:14,432 what have we raised as a 8370 00:50:14,432 --> 00:50:14,432 nonprofit? 8371 00:50:14,432 --> 00:50:16,655 we've been a nonprofit for about 8372 00:50:16,655 --> 00:50:16,655 8373 00:50:16,655 --> 00:50:18,347 seven months? 8374 00:50:18,347 --> 00:50:20,368 >> yes, so let me pull those 8375 00:50:20,368 --> 00:50:31,862 numbers for you. 8376 00:50:31,862 --> 00:50:35,729 so yeah, we've raised over 8377 00:50:35,729 --> 00:50:37,134 $5,416 in friends of heartwood 8378 00:50:37,134 --> 00:50:37,134 s 8379 00:50:37,134 --> 00:50:38,034 donations that's our membershi 8380 00:50:38,034 --> 00:50:38,034 p 8381 00:50:38,034 --> 00:50:40,433 program since becoming a 8382 00:50:40,433 --> 00:50:40,433 nonprofit. 8383 00:50:40,433 --> 00:50:44,634 we've raised over 5,000 -- we 8384 00:50:44,634 --> 00:50:47,040 have over $5,000 incoming just 8385 00:50:47,040 --> 00:50:47,040 8386 00:50:47,040 --> 00:50:48,906 in the past few weeks of peopl 8387 00:50:48,906 --> 00:50:48,906 e 8388 00:50:48,906 --> 00:50:50,244 supporting us, supporting our 8389 00:50:50,244 --> 00:50:51,775 upcoming events, mostly like 8390 00:50:51,775 --> 00:50:53,116 sponsorship corporate 8391 00:50:53,116 --> 00:50:55,284 sponsorship type donations. 8392 00:50:55,284 --> 00:50:56,581 from our online giving platform 8393 00:50:56,581 --> 00:50:56,581 8394 00:50:56,581 --> 00:50:58,220 that we launched when we became 8395 00:50:58,220 --> 00:50:58,220 8396 00:50:58,220 --> 00:51:00,426 a nonprofit in september we've 8397 00:51:00,426 --> 00:51:00,426 8398 00:51:00,426 --> 00:51:03,229 raised $3,815 that's just from 8399 00:51:03,229 --> 00:51:03,485 a 8400 00:51:03,485 --> 00:51:06,036 donate now button on our web 8401 00:51:06,036 --> 00:51:06,036 site. 8402 00:51:06,036 --> 00:51:08,473 from event sponsors, this is a 8403 00:51:08,473 --> 00:51:08,473 8404 00:51:08,473 --> 00:51:10,396 lot of this came from our at th 8405 00:51:10,396 --> 00:51:10,396 e 8406 00:51:10,396 --> 00:51:11,496 end of the year tom petty 8407 00:51:11,496 --> 00:51:15,954 weekend last year, we had 25,785 8408 00:51:15,954 --> 00:51:15,954 8409 00:51:15,954 --> 00:51:17,174 corporate sponsors that was the 8410 00:51:17,174 --> 00:51:17,174 8411 00:51:17,174 --> 00:51:18,636 very tail end of last year for 8412 00:51:18,636 --> 00:51:18,636 8413 00:51:18,636 --> 00:51:20,573 tom petty, one of our signature 8414 00:51:20,573 --> 00:51:20,573 8415 00:51:20,573 --> 00:51:20,573 events. 8416 00:51:20,573 --> 00:51:26,447 we received over $4,000 actual 8417 00:51:26,447 --> 00:51:26,447 ly 8418 00:51:26,447 --> 00:51:28,285 $6,000 total in ira disbursemen 8419 00:51:28,285 --> 00:51:28,285 t 8420 00:51:28,285 --> 00:51:29,917 since becoming a nonprofit so 8421 00:51:29,917 --> 00:51:31,455 that's where you can use your 8422 00:51:31,455 --> 00:51:32,770 retirement funds there's a way 8423 00:51:32,770 --> 00:51:32,770 8424 00:51:32,770 --> 00:51:34,327 to kind of reduce your taxes o 8425 00:51:34,327 --> 00:51:34,327 n 8426 00:51:34,327 --> 00:51:36,757 your retirement plan by doing a 8427 00:51:36,757 --> 00:51:36,757 n 8428 00:51:36,757 --> 00:51:39,387 ira disbursement, so yeah, 8429 00:51:39,387 --> 00:51:41,022 $6,000 from that. 8430 00:51:41,022 --> 00:51:43,033 and then from a single donor, w 8431 00:51:43,033 --> 00:51:43,033 e 8432 00:51:43,033 --> 00:51:47,302 received $58,000 at the end of 8433 00:51:47,302 --> 00:51:47,302 8434 00:51:47,302 --> 00:51:50,177 last year, and this kind of ti 8435 00:51:50,177 --> 00:51:50,177 es 8436 00:51:50,177 --> 00:51:51,215 into you know that donor was o 8437 00:51:51,215 --> 00:51:51,215 ne 8438 00:51:51,215 --> 00:51:53,309 of the founders of heartwood. 8439 00:51:53,309 --> 00:51:54,637 that was kind of where we were 8440 00:51:54,637 --> 00:51:54,637 8441 00:51:54,637 --> 00:51:56,277 at with this one donor pitching 8442 00:51:56,277 --> 00:51:56,277 8443 00:51:56,277 --> 00:51:57,802 in heavenally to pick up the - 8444 00:51:57,802 --> 00:51:57,802 - 8445 00:51:57,802 --> 00:51:59,981 heavily to pick up on slack whe 8446 00:51:59,981 --> 00:51:59,981 n 8447 00:51:59,981 --> 00:52:02,417 we fell low on things. 8448 00:52:02,417 --> 00:52:04,853 this is since september when w 8449 00:52:04,853 --> 00:52:04,853 e 8450 00:52:04,853 --> 00:52:05,519 became a nonprofit. 8451 00:52:05,519 --> 00:52:07,687 that adds up in total to 8452 00:52:07,687 --> 00:52:07,687 $94,016. 8453 00:52:07,687 --> 00:52:10,426 so we're doing quite well with 8454 00:52:10,426 --> 00:52:10,426 8455 00:52:10,426 --> 00:52:10,426 sponsorships. 8456 00:52:10,426 --> 00:52:12,627 this is another reason that I 8457 00:52:12,627 --> 00:52:17,218 say I don't expect to be back here n 8458 00:52:17,218 --> 00:52:17,541 here next year asking for this 8459 00:52:17,541 --> 00:52:17,541 8460 00:52:17,541 --> 00:52:18,506 kind of money, so -- really wel 8461 00:52:18,506 --> 00:52:18,506 l 8462 00:52:18,506 --> 00:52:20,937 it's just I've inherited some 8463 00:52:20,937 --> 00:52:23,711 problems, you know, some debt. 8464 00:52:23,711 --> 00:52:23,711 8465 00:52:23,711 --> 00:52:24,870 and to address the conversatio 8466 00:52:24,870 --> 00:52:24,870 n 8467 00:52:24,870 --> 00:52:26,105 about whether it should go 8468 00:52:26,105 --> 00:52:27,977 towards debt or future expenses, 8469 00:52:27,977 --> 00:52:27,977 8470 00:52:27,977 --> 00:52:30,815 either one would do the trick. 8471 00:52:30,815 --> 00:52:30,815 8472 00:52:30,815 --> 00:52:33,341 it's, I'm we're amenable to, y 8473 00:52:33,341 --> 00:52:33,341 ou 8474 00:52:33,341 --> 00:52:36,388 know, aplooiing the money where 8475 00:52:36,388 --> 00:52:36,388 8476 00:52:36,388 --> 00:52:38,250 it's, where it feels best 8477 00:52:38,250 --> 00:52:41,540 applies by the commission. 8478 00:52:41,540 --> 00:52:42,029 >> thank you. 8479 00:52:42,029 --> 00:52:43,925 the figures that you just 8480 00:52:43,925 --> 00:52:45,439 provided for what's being raise 8481 00:52:45,439 --> 00:52:45,439 d 8482 00:52:45,439 --> 00:52:47,489 is another source of optimism 8483 00:52:47,489 --> 00:52:48,259 going forward. 8484 00:52:48,259 --> 00:52:51,677 that for me, where I struggle I 8485 00:52:51,677 --> 00:52:51,677 s 8486 00:52:51,677 --> 00:52:53,737 just this morning we stopped 8487 00:52:53,737 --> 00:52:55,013 providing money internally at 8488 00:52:55,013 --> 00:52:57,597 the city for our own staff 8489 00:52:57,597 --> 00:52:58,576 because we said we're in the 8490 00:52:58,576 --> 00:53:00,861 middle of a budget process, and 8491 00:53:00,861 --> 00:53:00,861 8492 00:53:00,861 --> 00:53:02,311 you know, where we can't provi 8493 00:53:02,311 --> 00:53:02,311 de 8494 00:53:02,311 --> 00:53:04,813 money internally, I really 8495 00:53:04,813 --> 00:53:06,014 struggle even though the fundi 8496 00:53:06,014 --> 00:53:06,014 ng 8497 00:53:06,014 --> 00:53:07,589 sources are different, to 8498 00:53:07,589 --> 00:53:08,548 provide those monies 8499 00:53:08,548 --> 00:53:08,548 externally. 8500 00:53:08,548 --> 00:53:11,603 we have 30 frozen positions at 8501 00:53:11,603 --> 00:53:11,603 8502 00:53:11,603 --> 00:53:11,847 the city. 8503 00:53:11,847 --> 00:53:12,943 these are 30 people that we're 8504 00:53:12,943 --> 00:53:12,943 8505 00:53:12,943 --> 00:53:15,351 not hiring across various 8506 00:53:15,351 --> 00:53:18,423 divisions because we ourselves 8507 00:53:18,423 --> 00:53:18,423 8508 00:53:18,423 --> 00:53:19,725 are holding the line on some 8509 00:53:19,725 --> 00:53:22,377 fiscal restraint, and then I, 8510 00:53:22,377 --> 00:53:23,993 what worries me is we just got 8511 00:53:23,993 --> 00:53:23,993 8512 00:53:23,993 --> 00:53:25,731 another email this week from 8513 00:53:25,731 --> 00:53:27,503 another nonprofit that wants t 8514 00:53:27,503 --> 00:53:27,503 o 8515 00:53:27,503 --> 00:53:29,138 increase their funding. 8516 00:53:29,138 --> 00:53:30,435 they may be within one of our 8517 00:53:30,435 --> 00:53:32,073 existing processes, but they 8518 00:53:32,073 --> 00:53:34,082 want between 50 -- instead of 8519 00:53:34,082 --> 00:53:35,989 what they got is $65,000 they 8520 00:53:35,989 --> 00:53:36,783 want double that at least 8521 00:53:36,783 --> 00:53:37,809 they're hoping that we'll 8522 00:53:37,809 --> 00:53:38,621 provide double. 8523 00:53:38,621 --> 00:53:40,575 and it's another worthwhile 8524 00:53:40,575 --> 00:53:41,775 nonprofit organization. 8525 00:53:41,775 --> 00:53:43,863 so these are the things I 8526 00:53:43,863 --> 00:53:45,157 struggle with which is funding 8527 00:53:45,157 --> 00:53:45,157 8528 00:53:45,157 --> 00:53:46,720 internally that we have versus 8529 00:53:46,720 --> 00:53:46,720 8530 00:53:46,720 --> 00:53:48,353 funding externally even though 8531 00:53:48,353 --> 00:53:48,353 8532 00:53:48,353 --> 00:53:50,523 again I know the funding strea 8533 00:53:50,523 --> 00:53:50,523 ms 8534 00:53:50,523 --> 00:53:51,734 are different. 8535 00:53:51,734 --> 00:53:54,055 so thank you, mr. Mayor. 8536 00:53:54,055 --> 00:53:57,328 >> mayor: thank you,. 8537 00:53:57,328 --> 00:53:59,228 commissioner chestnut. 8538 00:53:59,228 --> 00:54:00,181 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 8539 00:54:00,181 --> 00:54:01,129 if you could just very 8540 00:54:01,129 --> 00:54:05,305 succinctly tell us again what 8541 00:54:05,305 --> 00:54:08,773 the 55, what the 55,000 would b 8542 00:54:08,773 --> 00:54:08,773 e 8543 00:54:08,773 --> 00:54:10,207 used for. 8544 00:54:10,207 --> 00:54:12,441 is it your retired debt or 8545 00:54:12,441 --> 00:54:13,321 exactly what? 8546 00:54:13,321 --> 00:54:13,855 >> sure. 8547 00:54:13,855 --> 00:54:15,409 so initially I thought the bes 8548 00:54:15,409 --> 00:54:15,409 t 8549 00:54:15,409 --> 00:54:17,381 thing to use it for -- well 8550 00:54:17,381 --> 00:54:19,159 first I'll say where the numbe 8551 00:54:19,159 --> 00:54:19,159 r 8552 00:54:19,159 --> 00:54:19,623 55,000 came from. 8553 00:54:19,623 --> 00:54:22,325 so the past two years in a row 8554 00:54:22,325 --> 00:54:22,325 , 8555 00:54:22,325 --> 00:54:24,489 bate end of the budget year, 8556 00:54:24,489 --> 00:54:26,166 we've been $250,000 -- we've 8557 00:54:26,166 --> 00:54:28,439 needed $250,000 from our 8558 00:54:28,439 --> 00:54:31,931 founder'spitched in to keep the 8559 00:54:31,931 --> 00:54:31,931 8560 00:54:31,931 --> 00:54:32,973 thing going so I have no reason 8561 00:54:32,973 --> 00:54:32,973 8562 00:54:32,973 --> 00:54:34,263 to suspect that number is going 8563 00:54:34,263 --> 00:54:34,263 8564 00:54:34,263 --> 00:54:35,136 to be any different this year. 8565 00:54:35,136 --> 00:54:35,136 8566 00:54:35,136 --> 00:54:38,303 that number will be different 8567 00:54:38,303 --> 00:54:39,501 from this year moving forward 8568 00:54:39,501 --> 00:54:42,907 because we have reduced expensed 8569 00:54:42,907 --> 00:54:42,907 8570 00:54:42,907 --> 00:54:44,113 by $100,000. 8571 00:54:44,113 --> 00:54:46,079 I got the nature and culture 8572 00:54:46,079 --> 00:54:47,803 enhancement grantwhich I 8573 00:54:47,803 --> 00:54:48,381 believe we will get a grant 8574 00:54:48,381 --> 00:54:50,285 every year through the county's 8575 00:54:50,285 --> 00:54:50,285 8576 00:54:50,285 --> 00:54:51,883 ed tax so not local taxpayers 8577 00:54:51,883 --> 00:54:52,919 paying that money. 8578 00:54:52,919 --> 00:54:54,885 it's for events and services 8579 00:54:54,885 --> 00:54:56,317 like ours that bring in tourist 8580 00:54:56,317 --> 00:54:56,317 s 8581 00:54:56,317 --> 00:54:58,088 and fill hotel beds. 8582 00:54:58,088 --> 00:55:01,787 so we got $100,000 from that s 8583 00:55:01,787 --> 00:55:01,787 o 8584 00:55:01,787 --> 00:55:03,099 between the cost that I've 8585 00:55:03,099 --> 00:55:05,857 reduced about $100,000 and the 8586 00:55:05,857 --> 00:55:05,857 8587 00:55:05,857 --> 00:55:08,695 grant that we received of 8588 00:55:08,695 --> 00:55:09,899 100,000 that leaves me with the 8589 00:55:09,899 --> 00:55:09,899 8590 00:55:09,899 --> 00:55:10,719 55,000 that where suspect we're 8591 00:55:10,719 --> 00:55:10,719 8592 00:55:10,719 --> 00:55:12,007 going to be short this year tha 8593 00:55:12,007 --> 00:55:12,007 t 8594 00:55:12,007 --> 00:55:13,639 we're tracking to be short on s 8595 00:55:13,639 --> 00:55:13,639 o 8596 00:55:13,639 --> 00:55:14,569 before we get to the part of 8597 00:55:14,569 --> 00:55:15,705 like closing doors or laying 8598 00:55:15,705 --> 00:55:18,041 people off or reducing services, 8599 00:55:18,041 --> 00:55:18,041 8600 00:55:18,041 --> 00:55:19,981 I came to you all to say can y 8601 00:55:19,981 --> 00:55:19,981 ou 8602 00:55:19,981 --> 00:55:21,585 help me with this 55,000. 8603 00:55:21,585 --> 00:55:23,309 and as far as what it will be 8604 00:55:23,309 --> 00:55:24,167 spent on? 8605 00:55:24,167 --> 00:55:27,051 I thought it made the most sen 8606 00:55:27,051 --> 00:55:27,051 se 8607 00:55:27,051 --> 00:55:29,359 to spend it on past debts eso 8608 00:55:29,359 --> 00:55:30,657 then our monthly expenses payin 8609 00:55:30,657 --> 00:55:30,657 g 8610 00:55:30,657 --> 00:55:32,621 off of those debts are reduced 8611 00:55:32,621 --> 00:55:32,621 8612 00:55:32,621 --> 00:55:34,332 and that sets us up month to 8613 00:55:34,332 --> 00:55:35,739 month to be saving money on the 8614 00:55:35,739 --> 00:55:36,293 z 8615 00:55:36,293 --> 00:55:37,925 those debts and interest but I 8616 00:55:37,925 --> 00:55:37,925 8617 00:55:37,925 --> 00:55:39,799 mean we have single shows comin 8618 00:55:39,799 --> 00:55:39,799 g 8619 00:55:39,799 --> 00:55:40,957 up where the artist fees are 8620 00:55:40,957 --> 00:55:41,763 about $50,000. 8621 00:55:41,763 --> 00:55:43,171 so like one, I could use this t 8622 00:55:43,171 --> 00:55:43,171 o 8623 00:55:43,171 --> 00:55:44,413 pay one artist fee and it would 8624 00:55:44,413 --> 00:55:44,413 8625 00:55:44,413 --> 00:55:46,277 save us $50,000 that I could u 8626 00:55:46,277 --> 00:55:46,277 se 8627 00:55:46,277 --> 00:55:48,575 to address other issues. 8628 00:55:48,575 --> 00:55:50,671 that's the kind of how the 8629 00:55:50,671 --> 00:55:52,981 business works, there's major 8630 00:55:52,981 --> 00:55:55,913 expenses, so so whether the 8631 00:55:55,913 --> 00:55:56,677 55,000 is spent on past 8632 00:55:56,677 --> 00:55:58,215 expenses, whether we applied 8633 00:55:58,215 --> 00:55:59,821 donor fees to past expenses and 8634 00:55:59,821 --> 00:55:59,821 8635 00:55:59,821 --> 00:56:01,723 applied this to labor for the 8636 00:56:01,723 --> 00:56:03,179 next calendar year, apply it t 8637 00:56:03,179 --> 00:56:03,179 o 8638 00:56:03,179 --> 00:56:05,537 artist fees or apply it to we 8639 00:56:05,537 --> 00:56:08,233 have some major -- I'll name a 8640 00:56:08,233 --> 00:56:08,233 8641 00:56:08,233 --> 00:56:09,777 few things I'd love to apply I 8642 00:56:09,777 --> 00:56:09,777 t 8643 00:56:09,777 --> 00:56:09,777 to. 8644 00:56:09,777 --> 00:56:11,419 I mentioned production upgrade 8645 00:56:11,419 --> 00:56:11,419 s 8646 00:56:11,419 --> 00:56:13,363 so 10 years old with most of o 8647 00:56:13,363 --> 00:56:13,363 ur 8648 00:56:13,363 --> 00:56:14,935 production equipment and you 8649 00:56:14,935 --> 00:56:15,891 know we need computer upgrades 8650 00:56:15,891 --> 00:56:15,891 8651 00:56:15,891 --> 00:56:18,433 software upgrades, systems 8652 00:56:18,433 --> 00:56:19,406 upgrades, we've already begun 8653 00:56:19,406 --> 00:56:19,406 that. 8654 00:56:19,406 --> 00:56:21,275 like replacing the lights like 8655 00:56:21,275 --> 00:56:21,275 8656 00:56:21,275 --> 00:56:22,945 we did last week but you know 8657 00:56:22,945 --> 00:56:24,813 lighting, seating, electrical 8658 00:56:24,813 --> 00:56:28,083 upgrades, our outdoor sound 8659 00:56:28,083 --> 00:56:29,517 system, and maintenance to our 8660 00:56:29,517 --> 00:56:29,517 8661 00:56:29,517 --> 00:56:32,122 current production equipment. 8662 00:56:32,122 --> 00:56:33,977 >> so it could be considered a 8663 00:56:33,977 --> 00:56:33,977 8664 00:56:33,977 --> 00:56:33,977 windfall. 8665 00:56:33,977 --> 00:56:36,459 >> a wind -- I'm not sure what 8666 00:56:36,459 --> 00:56:36,459 8667 00:56:36,459 --> 00:56:41,169 that means. 8668 00:56:41,169 --> 00:56:41,827 >> I don't know how to explain 8669 00:56:41,827 --> 00:56:41,827 8670 00:56:41,827 --> 00:56:41,827 it. 8671 00:56:41,827 --> 00:56:47,695 >> mayor: okay. 8672 00:56:47,695 --> 00:56:48,399 anything else? 8673 00:56:48,399 --> 00:56:48,399 okay. 8674 00:56:48,399 --> 00:56:49,927 anyone else? 8675 00:56:49,927 --> 00:56:50,369 all right. 8676 00:56:50,369 --> 00:56:51,670 is there any public comment on 8677 00:56:51,670 --> 00:56:51,670 8678 00:56:51,670 --> 00:56:52,667 this, madam clerk? 8679 00:56:52,667 --> 00:56:53,781 >> I do not have public comment 8680 00:56:53,781 --> 00:56:53,781 8681 00:56:53,781 --> 00:56:56,073 on this item. 8682 00:56:56,073 --> 00:56:57,009 >> mayor: okay. 8683 00:56:57,009 --> 00:56:57,853 would anyone like to make any 8684 00:56:57,853 --> 00:56:59,517 sort of recommendation? 8685 00:56:59,517 --> 00:57:01,011 commissioner duncan-walker. 8686 00:57:01,011 --> 00:57:02,105 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 8687 00:57:02,105 --> 00:57:03,552 I just have some questions and 8688 00:57:03,552 --> 00:57:03,552 8689 00:57:03,552 --> 00:57:06,715 then I want to make the comments 8690 00:57:06,715 --> 00:57:06,715 8691 00:57:06,715 --> 00:57:08,074 because clearly I think so men 8692 00:57:08,074 --> 00:57:08,252 a 8693 00:57:08,252 --> 00:57:09,435 of us are appreciative of the 8694 00:57:09,435 --> 00:57:10,855 work that is done out of 8695 00:57:10,855 --> 00:57:11,894 heartwood and I know that when 8696 00:57:11,894 --> 00:57:11,894 8697 00:57:11,894 --> 00:57:14,731 we spoke, I had a subsequent 8698 00:57:14,731 --> 00:57:17,229 conversation with our arts 8699 00:57:17,229 --> 00:57:21,165 grants programs, prca. 8700 00:57:21,165 --> 00:57:23,397 and of course the question was 8701 00:57:23,397 --> 00:57:23,397 8702 00:57:23,397 --> 00:57:25,805 you know what is existing there 8703 00:57:25,805 --> 00:57:25,805 8704 00:57:25,805 --> 00:57:27,771 and what we found was 8705 00:57:27,771 --> 00:57:29,737 unfortunately that heartwood d 8706 00:57:29,737 --> 00:57:29,737 id 8707 00:57:29,737 --> 00:57:31,840 not fit into the neat boxes tha 8708 00:57:31,840 --> 00:57:31,840 t 8709 00:57:31,840 --> 00:57:34,373 we currently have prescribed a 8710 00:57:34,373 --> 00:57:34,373 s 8711 00:57:34,373 --> 00:57:35,873 arts presenters and for me tha 8712 00:57:35,873 --> 00:57:35,873 t 8713 00:57:35,873 --> 00:57:36,920 was a bit of a challenge. 8714 00:57:36,920 --> 00:57:38,179 so what I want to say to my 8715 00:57:38,179 --> 00:57:40,225 colleagues here is we have I 8716 00:57:40,225 --> 00:57:42,989 think a case where we have an 8717 00:57:42,989 --> 00:57:44,255 arts presenter that is not 8718 00:57:44,255 --> 00:57:45,710 fitting within our definition o 8719 00:57:45,710 --> 00:57:45,710 f 8720 00:57:45,710 --> 00:57:48,761 arts presenter, and I'm 8721 00:57:48,761 --> 00:57:50,526 interested as a board to figur 8722 00:57:50,526 --> 00:57:50,526 e 8723 00:57:50,526 --> 00:57:52,397 out a way how we might be able 8724 00:57:52,397 --> 00:57:52,397 8725 00:57:52,397 --> 00:57:53,495 to reconcile that. 8726 00:57:53,495 --> 00:57:55,465 now I clearly understand that 8727 00:57:55,465 --> 00:57:57,127 those arts organizations that 8728 00:57:57,127 --> 00:57:58,859 we're currently funding out of 8729 00:57:58,859 --> 00:57:58,859 8730 00:57:58,859 --> 00:58:00,453 those buckets of monies fit 8731 00:58:00,453 --> 00:58:01,603 within a particular description 8732 00:58:01,603 --> 00:58:01,603 8733 00:58:01,603 --> 00:58:03,813 but I think that we have to be 8734 00:58:03,813 --> 00:58:03,813 8735 00:58:03,813 --> 00:58:07,121 mindful and we have to be 8736 00:58:07,121 --> 00:58:08,285 responsive when we know that 8737 00:58:08,285 --> 00:58:09,209 there are organizations that a 8738 00:58:09,209 --> 00:58:09,209 re 8739 00:58:09,209 --> 00:58:10,593 doing that thing that we just 8740 00:58:10,593 --> 00:58:12,879 haven't considered how we, we 8741 00:58:12,879 --> 00:58:15,723 are able to address that, okay 8742 00:58:15,723 --> 00:58:15,723 8743 00:58:15,723 --> 00:58:19,655 in terms of money so what we 8744 00:58:19,655 --> 00:58:23,833 hear is an organization that 8745 00:58:23,833 --> 00:58:25,803 needs some help. 8746 00:58:25,803 --> 00:58:27,233 and there are a lot of 8747 00:58:27,233 --> 00:58:31,607 organizations that need help. 8748 00:58:31,607 --> 00:58:33,039 so I'm struggling now with 8749 00:58:33,039 --> 00:58:36,677 making sure that there is a fai 8750 00:58:36,677 --> 00:58:36,677 r 8751 00:58:36,677 --> 00:58:43,727 way as we move forward that 8752 00:58:43,727 --> 00:58:44,905 we'll be able to do this in the 8753 00:58:44,905 --> 00:58:44,905 8754 00:58:44,905 --> 00:58:45,428 future because we're already 8755 00:58:45,428 --> 00:58:46,051 getting e-mails. 8756 00:58:46,051 --> 00:58:47,316 should we do this, there will 8757 00:58:47,316 --> 00:58:47,316 be 8758 00:58:47,316 --> 00:58:48,571 more and there will be the 8759 00:58:48,571 --> 00:58:50,287 question of well, the city 8760 00:58:50,287 --> 00:58:52,595 funded heartwood why won't you 8761 00:58:52,595 --> 00:58:52,595 8762 00:58:52,595 --> 00:58:53,355 fund us. 8763 00:58:53,355 --> 00:58:54,285 and nobody's going to be 8764 00:58:54,285 --> 00:58:54,285 concerned. 8765 00:58:54,285 --> 00:59:00,165 nobody's concerned with our 8766 00:59:00,165 --> 00:59:02,243 budget or bottom line is, 8767 00:59:02,243 --> 00:59:03,211 they're just going to say you 8768 00:59:03,211 --> 00:59:04,153 funded heartwood. 8769 00:59:04,153 --> 00:59:05,581 so for me it's a matter of 8770 00:59:05,581 --> 00:59:06,767 making sure our processes can 8771 00:59:06,767 --> 00:59:08,174 accommodate what the needs are 8772 00:59:08,174 --> 00:59:08,174 8773 00:59:08,174 --> 00:59:09,713 artistically here, and I want t 8774 00:59:09,713 --> 00:59:09,713 o 8775 00:59:09,713 --> 00:59:11,609 have another conversation and 8776 00:59:11,609 --> 00:59:12,811 intertain and she's not in her 8777 00:59:12,811 --> 00:59:12,811 e 8778 00:59:12,811 --> 00:59:14,580 so I don't want to do it right 8779 00:59:14,580 --> 00:59:14,580 8780 00:59:14,580 --> 00:59:16,465 now, but I think that I'm 8781 00:59:16,465 --> 00:59:18,331 interested in coming back to t 8782 00:59:18,331 --> 00:59:18,331 he 8783 00:59:18,331 --> 00:59:21,957 table with parks, rec and 8784 00:59:21,957 --> 00:59:23,253 cultural affairs or the cultura 8785 00:59:23,253 --> 00:59:23,253 l 8786 00:59:23,253 --> 00:59:25,753 affairs board, whichever entit 8787 00:59:25,753 --> 00:59:25,753 y 8788 00:59:25,753 --> 00:59:27,425 it is, it's our cultural affai 8789 00:59:27,425 --> 00:59:27,425 rs 8790 00:59:27,425 --> 00:59:29,446 department is who it is, to ha 8791 00:59:29,446 --> 00:59:29,446 ve 8792 00:59:29,446 --> 00:59:35,409 a conversation around what we 8793 00:59:35,409 --> 00:59:37,098 would need to do to address the 8794 00:59:37,098 --> 00:59:37,098 8795 00:59:37,098 --> 00:59:39,843 organization's like heartwood. 8796 00:59:39,843 --> 00:59:39,843 8797 00:59:39,843 --> 00:59:40,859 heartwood is not the only one 8798 00:59:40,859 --> 00:59:41,942 but it's the one that's in 8799 00:59:41,942 --> 00:59:43,507 downtown that's doing a large 8800 00:59:43,507 --> 00:59:46,352 volime of business -- volume o 8801 00:59:46,352 --> 00:59:46,352 f 8802 00:59:46,352 --> 00:59:47,443 business that is feeding into 8803 00:59:47,443 --> 00:59:48,647 the economic development piece 8804 00:59:48,647 --> 00:59:48,647 8805 00:59:48,647 --> 00:59:50,745 that is important and vital to 8806 00:59:50,745 --> 00:59:50,745 8807 00:59:50,745 --> 00:59:52,830 the city. 8808 00:59:52,830 --> 00:59:57,487 it's just a shame that we da wa 8809 00:59:57,487 --> 00:59:57,889 y to fund it right now 8810 00:59:57,889 --> 00:59:58,258 through the city. 8811 00:59:58,258 --> 01:00:00,296 and flow have to look -- now 8812 01:00:00,296 --> 01:00:02,689 have to look at doing this an 8813 01:00:02,689 --> 01:00:04,265 alternate way that will be a b 8814 01:00:04,265 --> 01:00:04,265 it 8815 01:00:04,265 --> 01:00:04,265 controversial. 8816 01:00:04,265 --> 01:00:06,331 so I want to say before I make 8817 01:00:06,331 --> 01:00:06,331 8818 01:00:06,331 --> 01:00:07,672 any comment about the current 8819 01:00:07,672 --> 01:00:09,667 request that I'd like for us t 8820 01:00:09,667 --> 01:00:09,667 o 8821 01:00:09,667 --> 01:00:11,304 look internally at our process 8822 01:00:11,304 --> 01:00:11,304 8823 01:00:11,304 --> 01:00:15,007 and ask the cultural affairs 8824 01:00:15,007 --> 01:00:16,443 council what they would need I 8825 01:00:16,443 --> 01:00:16,443 n 8826 01:00:16,443 --> 01:00:19,380 order to move this forward, a 8827 01:00:19,380 --> 01:00:25,038 definition or grant program that 8828 01:00:25,038 --> 01:00:25,038 8829 01:00:25,038 --> 01:00:29,390 would include organizations li 8830 01:00:29,390 --> 01:00:29,390 ke 8831 01:00:29,390 --> 01:00:32,226 what are the financial needs. 8832 01:00:32,226 --> 01:00:33,696 who do we need to reach out to? 8833 01:00:33,696 --> 01:00:33,696 8834 01:00:33,696 --> 01:00:38,064 I did want to ask you this. 8835 01:00:38,064 --> 01:00:39,772 have you in any way engaged wit 8836 01:00:39,772 --> 01:00:39,772 h 8837 01:00:39,772 --> 01:00:40,382 the gainesville community 8838 01:00:40,382 --> 01:00:40,382 foundation? 8839 01:00:40,382 --> 01:00:43,500 >> gainesville community 8840 01:00:43,500 --> 01:00:43,500 foundation? 8841 01:00:43,500 --> 01:00:44,712 >> yes. 8842 01:00:44,712 --> 01:00:45,892 >> is that the center for 8843 01:00:45,892 --> 01:00:48,388 nonprofit excellence? 8844 01:00:48,388 --> 01:00:49,710 >> they're a part of that. 8845 01:00:49,710 --> 01:00:50,322 >> okay. 8846 01:00:50,322 --> 01:00:51,142 >> the center for nonprofit 8847 01:00:51,142 --> 01:00:52,108 excellence is a part. 8848 01:00:52,108 --> 01:00:53,050 >> we have been in touch with 8849 01:00:53,050 --> 01:00:54,446 the center for nonprofit 8850 01:00:54,446 --> 01:00:54,446 excellence. 8851 01:00:54,446 --> 01:00:56,650 I don't know specifically about 8852 01:00:56,650 --> 01:00:56,650 8853 01:00:56,650 --> 01:00:57,854 the foundation that you speak o 8854 01:00:57,854 --> 01:00:57,854 f 8855 01:00:57,854 --> 01:00:57,854 though. 8856 01:00:57,854 --> 01:00:58,924 >> mm-hmm. 8857 01:00:58,924 --> 01:01:00,871 so what was the outcome of tha 8858 01:01:00,871 --> 01:01:00,871 t 8859 01:01:00,871 --> 01:01:00,871 interaction? 8860 01:01:00,871 --> 01:01:03,816 >> they've been supportive and 8861 01:01:03,816 --> 01:01:03,816 8862 01:01:03,816 --> 01:01:07,224 you know, they reached out 8863 01:01:07,224 --> 01:01:08,888 actually one of the leaders of 8864 01:01:08,888 --> 01:01:08,888 8865 01:01:08,888 --> 01:01:09,770 our organization reached out 8866 01:01:09,770 --> 01:01:10,724 right when we became a nonprof 8867 01:01:10,724 --> 01:01:10,724 it 8868 01:01:10,724 --> 01:01:12,294 and said hey, you know, we're 8869 01:01:12,294 --> 01:01:13,136 here if you need resources and 8870 01:01:13,136 --> 01:01:13,136 8871 01:01:13,136 --> 01:01:14,274 we reached out back to her to 8872 01:01:14,274 --> 01:01:15,368 connect her with our developme 8873 01:01:15,368 --> 01:01:15,368 nt 8874 01:01:15,368 --> 01:01:17,232 director when we hired him, so 8875 01:01:17,232 --> 01:01:17,232 8876 01:01:17,232 --> 01:01:18,534 we've been in contact but there 8877 01:01:18,534 --> 01:01:18,534 8878 01:01:18,534 --> 01:01:20,174 has been no discussion of here' 8879 01:01:20,174 --> 01:01:20,174 s 8880 01:01:20,174 --> 01:01:21,506 some money we have for you or 8881 01:01:21,506 --> 01:01:23,710 anything like that. 8882 01:01:23,710 --> 01:01:24,914 >> mayor: so to be clear they' 8883 01:01:24,914 --> 01:01:24,914 re 8884 01:01:24,914 --> 01:01:28,416 no longer with the north centr 8885 01:01:28,416 --> 01:01:28,416 al 8886 01:01:28,416 --> 01:01:29,414 florida community foundation? 8887 01:01:29,414 --> 01:01:30,058 >> okay. 8888 01:01:30,058 --> 01:01:31,684 >> mayor: and their missionis 8889 01:01:31,684 --> 01:01:34,290 to help train nonprofits be goo 8890 01:01:34,290 --> 01:01:34,290 d 8891 01:01:34,290 --> 01:01:37,106 nonprofits -- 8892 01:01:37,106 --> 01:01:37,564 >> correct I'm definitely 8893 01:01:37,564 --> 01:01:39,422 familiar with what the nonprof 8894 01:01:39,422 --> 01:01:39,422 it 8895 01:01:39,422 --> 01:01:42,470 center for nonprofit excellence 8896 01:01:42,470 --> 01:01:42,470 8897 01:01:42,470 --> 01:01:43,732 does but I also know that the 8898 01:01:43,732 --> 01:01:45,707 gainesville community foundation 8899 01:01:45,707 --> 01:01:45,707 8900 01:01:45,707 --> 01:01:46,762 has been a grant making 8901 01:01:46,762 --> 01:01:47,574 organization so I was wondering 8902 01:01:47,574 --> 01:01:47,574 8903 01:01:47,574 --> 01:01:49,802 if there was any conversation o 8904 01:01:49,802 --> 01:01:49,802 r 8905 01:01:49,802 --> 01:01:51,208 any movement in that way. 8906 01:01:51,208 --> 01:01:52,536 >> I'll write it down. 8907 01:01:52,536 --> 01:01:55,270 I'll definitely reach out. 8908 01:01:55,270 --> 01:01:58,543 >> I'll conclude for now. 8909 01:01:58,543 --> 01:01:59,040 >> mayor: thank you. 8910 01:01:59,040 --> 01:02:02,506 commissioner ingle. 8911 01:02:02,506 --> 01:02:04,075 >> so I was not present for the 8912 01:02:04,075 --> 01:02:04,075 8913 01:02:04,075 --> 01:02:09,430 previous discussion on this, b 8914 01:02:09,430 --> 01:02:09,430 ut 8915 01:02:09,430 --> 01:02:10,454 I was I can certainly see the 8916 01:02:10,454 --> 01:02:17,304 concerns about we strike a che 8917 01:02:17,304 --> 01:02:17,304 ck 8918 01:02:17,304 --> 01:02:18,802 when the first nonprofit comes 8919 01:02:18,802 --> 01:02:18,802 8920 01:02:18,802 --> 01:02:20,025 and asks us for money. 8921 01:02:20,025 --> 01:02:20,796 there are certainly going to be 8922 01:02:20,796 --> 01:02:20,796 8923 01:02:20,796 --> 01:02:21,943 a lot of people asking for mon 8924 01:02:21,943 --> 01:02:21,943 ey 8925 01:02:21,943 --> 01:02:22,498 like this. 8926 01:02:22,498 --> 01:02:25,532 I will say heartwood to me, I 8927 01:02:25,532 --> 01:02:26,740 greatly enjoy the place. 8928 01:02:26,740 --> 01:02:31,281 it's -- but more than that, if 8929 01:02:31,281 --> 01:02:31,281 8930 01:02:31,281 --> 01:02:33,207 you remember the baird center 8931 01:02:33,207 --> 01:02:36,126 prior to heartwood, there was 8932 01:02:36,126 --> 01:02:37,584 nothing there. 8933 01:02:37,584 --> 01:02:39,824 I mean, there was a one bla 8934 01:02:39,824 --> 01:02:42,556 box theater and the old 8935 01:02:42,556 --> 01:02:43,652 crosstown was there. 8936 01:02:43,652 --> 01:02:45,603 but I'll say it was pretty muc 8937 01:02:45,603 --> 01:02:45,603 h 8938 01:02:45,603 --> 01:02:47,496 a derelict building so I reall 8939 01:02:47,496 --> 01:02:47,496 y 8940 01:02:47,496 --> 01:02:50,670 do think that this is an ancho 8941 01:02:50,670 --> 01:02:50,670 r 8942 01:02:50,670 --> 01:02:54,186 business that is keeping I mea 8943 01:02:54,186 --> 01:02:54,186 n 8944 01:02:54,186 --> 01:02:56,064 just another half dozen 8945 01:02:56,064 --> 01:02:57,560 businesses going and then just 8946 01:02:57,560 --> 01:02:57,560 8947 01:02:57,560 --> 01:03:02,172 in general adding an awful lot 8948 01:03:02,172 --> 01:03:02,172 8949 01:03:02,172 --> 01:03:05,052 to the economy of kind of south 8950 01:03:05,052 --> 01:03:05,052 8951 01:03:05,052 --> 01:03:06,712 main and it's been a kind of a 8952 01:03:06,712 --> 01:03:06,712 n 8953 01:03:06,712 --> 01:03:08,186 anchor that I feel has drawn l 8954 01:03:08,186 --> 01:03:08,186 ot 8955 01:03:08,186 --> 01:03:10,418 of things down that way. 8956 01:03:10,418 --> 01:03:12,182 it's kind of dove tailed very 8957 01:03:12,182 --> 01:03:14,585 nicely with depot park and 8958 01:03:14,585 --> 01:03:17,455 really turning that into a muc 8959 01:03:17,455 --> 01:03:17,455 h 8960 01:03:17,455 --> 01:03:18,970 different economic area than it 8961 01:03:18,970 --> 01:03:18,970 8962 01:03:18,970 --> 01:03:20,036 was prior to heartwood being 8963 01:03:20,036 --> 01:03:20,036 there. 8964 01:03:20,036 --> 01:03:25,335 I don't know the best way of 8965 01:03:25,335 --> 01:03:27,106 going about supporting them but 8966 01:03:27,106 --> 01:03:27,106 8967 01:03:27,106 --> 01:03:28,667 I know we've done plenty of 8968 01:03:28,667 --> 01:03:30,302 grants for other organizations 8969 01:03:30,302 --> 01:03:30,302 8970 01:03:30,302 --> 01:03:32,826 that were everything from 8971 01:03:32,826 --> 01:03:34,248 picking an area of town that we 8972 01:03:34,248 --> 01:03:34,248 8973 01:03:34,248 --> 01:03:35,476 want to put some money into mak 8974 01:03:35,476 --> 01:03:35,476 e 8975 01:03:35,476 --> 01:03:38,014 sure that their, there's options 8976 01:03:38,014 --> 01:03:38,014 8977 01:03:38,014 --> 01:03:39,730 there for businesses to get -- 8978 01:03:39,730 --> 01:03:39,730 8979 01:03:39,730 --> 01:03:42,810 built up and facades of 8980 01:03:42,810 --> 01:03:44,024 buildings to get cleaned to 8981 01:03:44,024 --> 01:03:45,268 those types of things to helping 8982 01:03:45,268 --> 01:03:45,268 8983 01:03:45,268 --> 01:03:46,650 out the hippodrome. 8984 01:03:46,650 --> 01:03:48,166 so I would really like to find 8985 01:03:48,166 --> 01:03:48,166 8986 01:03:48,166 --> 01:03:49,162 some way to move forward with 8987 01:03:49,162 --> 01:03:49,162 this. 8988 01:03:49,162 --> 01:03:51,665 I think it's, it's important n 8989 01:03:51,665 --> 01:03:51,665 ot 8990 01:03:51,665 --> 01:03:53,104 only to heartwood but also to 8991 01:03:53,104 --> 01:03:53,104 a 8992 01:03:53,104 --> 01:03:54,048 lot of other businesses around 8993 01:03:54,048 --> 01:03:54,048 8994 01:03:54,048 --> 01:03:55,554 there and generally the economi 8995 01:03:55,554 --> 01:03:55,554 c 8996 01:03:55,554 --> 01:03:56,790 health of the area but whether 8997 01:03:56,790 --> 01:03:56,790 8998 01:03:56,790 --> 01:04:01,070 that looks like, like a low or 8999 01:04:01,070 --> 01:04:01,070 9000 01:04:01,070 --> 01:04:02,364 no interest loan, whether that 9001 01:04:02,364 --> 01:04:02,364 9002 01:04:02,364 --> 01:04:03,554 looks like a grant, whether tha 9003 01:04:03,554 --> 01:04:03,554 t 9004 01:04:03,554 --> 01:04:05,190 looks like whatever, I think 9005 01:04:05,190 --> 01:04:07,293 it's a very important driver f 9006 01:04:07,293 --> 01:04:07,293 or 9007 01:04:07,293 --> 01:04:11,180 the area that I think it would 9008 01:04:11,180 --> 01:04:11,180 9009 01:04:11,180 --> 01:04:12,778 be very detrimental if we let 9010 01:04:12,778 --> 01:04:12,778 fail. 9011 01:04:12,778 --> 01:04:16,084 more than that, like I also 9012 01:04:16,084 --> 01:04:19,786 think it is very unique in the 9013 01:04:19,786 --> 01:04:19,786 9014 01:04:19,786 --> 01:04:21,348 arts community in town that it's 9015 01:04:21,348 --> 01:04:21,348 9016 01:04:21,348 --> 01:04:24,418 one of the few kind of regiona 9017 01:04:24,418 --> 01:04:24,418 l 9018 01:04:24,418 --> 01:04:27,354 draws for music in the area. 9019 01:04:27,354 --> 01:04:28,694 you know it's not national act 9020 01:04:28,694 --> 01:04:28,694 s 9021 01:04:28,694 --> 01:04:31,098 but it's larger than local act 9022 01:04:31,098 --> 01:04:31,098 s, 9023 01:04:31,098 --> 01:04:35,066 and it really does pull in, it' 9024 01:04:35,066 --> 01:04:35,066 s 9025 01:04:35,066 --> 01:04:39,102 kind of well known I don't kno 9026 01:04:39,102 --> 01:04:39,102 w 9027 01:04:39,102 --> 01:04:40,106 what you would call it, second 9028 01:04:40,106 --> 01:04:40,106 9029 01:04:40,106 --> 01:04:41,856 tier stars or whatever, there 9030 01:04:41,856 --> 01:04:43,022 aren't quite national touring 9031 01:04:43,022 --> 01:04:44,178 acts but are that kind of level 9032 01:04:44,178 --> 01:04:44,178 9033 01:04:44,178 --> 01:04:45,642 that pulls a lot of people int 9034 01:04:45,642 --> 01:04:45,642 o 9035 01:04:45,642 --> 01:04:45,642 gainesville. 9036 01:04:45,642 --> 01:04:47,952 like I know a lot of people tha 9037 01:04:47,952 --> 01:04:47,952 t 9038 01:04:47,952 --> 01:04:49,044 are familiar with gainesville 9039 01:04:49,044 --> 01:04:50,010 because of heartwood. 9040 01:04:50,010 --> 01:04:51,513 they came here to see shows 9041 01:04:51,513 --> 01:04:51,513 there. 9042 01:04:51,513 --> 01:04:54,808 and that's why they're coming t 9043 01:04:54,808 --> 01:04:54,808 o 9044 01:04:54,808 --> 01:04:54,808 town. 9045 01:04:54,808 --> 01:04:58,488 so I don't know the best way t 9046 01:04:58,488 --> 01:04:58,488 o 9047 01:04:58,488 --> 01:04:59,806 move forward with it but I thi 9048 01:04:59,806 --> 01:04:59,806 nk 9049 01:04:59,806 --> 01:05:00,900 it's important we find some way 9050 01:05:00,900 --> 01:05:00,900 9051 01:05:00,900 --> 01:05:01,926 to move forward with it. 9052 01:05:01,926 --> 01:05:02,690 >> mayor: all right. 9053 01:05:02,690 --> 01:05:04,572 thank you, commissioner ingle. 9054 01:05:04,572 --> 01:05:04,572 9055 01:05:04,572 --> 01:05:05,708 commissional willits. 9056 01:05:05,708 --> 01:05:07,290 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 9057 01:05:07,290 --> 01:05:08,814 you know, it's not lost on me 9058 01:05:08,814 --> 01:05:09,864 that about a block away we're 9059 01:05:09,864 --> 01:05:12,512 trying to sell a property, an 9060 01:05:12,512 --> 01:05:13,936 old fire station location. 9061 01:05:13,936 --> 01:05:15,842 $55,000 could be the 9062 01:05:15,842 --> 01:05:17,610 difference -- I mean a good 9063 01:05:17,610 --> 01:05:18,428 functioning business community 9064 01:05:18,428 --> 01:05:18,428 9065 01:05:18,428 --> 01:05:20,744 on south main street versus one 9066 01:05:20,744 --> 01:05:20,744 9067 01:05:20,744 --> 01:05:22,412 with a you know a big hole in 9068 01:05:22,412 --> 01:05:24,086 it, could be the difference in 9069 01:05:24,086 --> 01:05:24,086 9070 01:05:24,086 --> 01:05:25,152 how -- how much we sell that 9071 01:05:25,152 --> 01:05:26,280 property for. 9072 01:05:26,280 --> 01:05:27,450 you know? 9073 01:05:27,450 --> 01:05:30,808 so that's, to me it's economic 9074 01:05:30,808 --> 01:05:30,808 9075 01:05:30,808 --> 01:05:32,188 development and arts. 9076 01:05:32,188 --> 01:05:33,292 these are the two things kind o 9077 01:05:33,292 --> 01:05:33,292 f 9078 01:05:33,292 --> 01:05:33,292 combined. 9079 01:05:33,292 --> 01:05:36,264 and so the fact that the count 9080 01:05:36,264 --> 01:05:36,264 y 9081 01:05:36,264 --> 01:05:37,888 tourism bed tax is being 9082 01:05:37,888 --> 01:05:38,993 supported that leads me more 9083 01:05:38,993 --> 01:05:40,510 towards hey this is the county 9084 01:05:40,510 --> 01:05:40,510 9085 01:05:40,510 --> 01:05:43,540 has done their part, can we do 9086 01:05:43,540 --> 01:05:43,540 9087 01:05:43,540 --> 01:05:45,734 part, and ms. Karns can you 9088 01:05:45,734 --> 01:05:47,042 remind me did the full county 9089 01:05:47,042 --> 01:05:48,192 commission have to vote on tha 9090 01:05:48,192 --> 01:05:48,192 t 9091 01:05:48,192 --> 01:05:48,192 grant? 9092 01:05:48,192 --> 01:05:50,426 does it go through them or is 9093 01:05:50,426 --> 01:05:50,426 it 9094 01:05:50,426 --> 01:05:52,008 part of a committee or an 9095 01:05:52,008 --> 01:05:54,212 administrative decision? 9096 01:05:54,212 --> 01:05:55,912 >> the alachua county arts 9097 01:05:55,912 --> 01:05:58,786 council I want to say decides on 9098 01:05:58,786 --> 01:05:58,786 9099 01:05:58,786 --> 01:06:00,150 the grant, and then they send 9100 01:06:00,150 --> 01:06:01,020 that to the county commissione 9101 01:06:01,020 --> 01:06:01,020 rs 9102 01:06:01,020 --> 01:06:02,652 to approve. 9103 01:06:02,652 --> 01:06:03,162 >> okay. 9104 01:06:03,162 --> 01:06:04,382 so in the end it is -- 9105 01:06:04,382 --> 01:06:05,592 >> it was vetted both by the 9106 01:06:05,592 --> 01:06:06,622 council and by the commission. 9107 01:06:06,622 --> 01:06:06,622 9108 01:06:06,622 --> 01:06:08,768 >> okay. 9109 01:06:08,768 --> 01:06:09,624 county commission's kind of done 9110 01:06:09,624 --> 01:06:09,624 9111 01:06:09,624 --> 01:06:10,596 part of their part. 9112 01:06:10,596 --> 01:06:12,364 this leads me more towards -- 9113 01:06:12,364 --> 01:06:13,962 I'm very in the middle. 9114 01:06:13,962 --> 01:06:14,658 I don't know. 9115 01:06:14,658 --> 01:06:16,434 because it is, it's so importa 9116 01:06:16,434 --> 01:06:16,434 nt 9117 01:06:16,434 --> 01:06:17,630 to the business development. 9118 01:06:17,630 --> 01:06:21,904 if this was ngcra in a different 9119 01:06:21,904 --> 01:06:21,904 9120 01:06:21,904 --> 01:06:25,148 way or in our arts programs mor 9121 01:06:25,148 --> 01:06:25,148 e 9122 01:06:25,148 --> 01:06:26,378 aligned out I would feel more 9123 01:06:26,378 --> 01:06:27,316 comfortable but I'm looking at 9124 01:06:27,316 --> 01:06:27,316 9125 01:06:27,316 --> 01:06:29,214 your calendar just through jul 9126 01:06:29,214 --> 01:06:29,214 y 9127 01:06:29,214 --> 01:06:30,412 and there's all kinds of stuff 9128 01:06:30,412 --> 01:06:30,412 9129 01:06:30,412 --> 01:06:31,146 on here. 9130 01:06:31,146 --> 01:06:33,719 all kinds of great stuff. 9131 01:06:33,719 --> 01:06:36,356 ani defranko and juvenile are 9132 01:06:36,356 --> 01:06:37,090 definitely national acts. 9133 01:06:37,090 --> 01:06:38,318 and rightly so some of the act 9134 01:06:38,318 --> 01:06:38,318 s 9135 01:06:38,318 --> 01:06:39,652 on here that I'm sure the 9136 01:06:39,652 --> 01:06:40,466 florida legislature does about 9137 01:06:40,466 --> 01:06:40,466 9138 01:06:40,466 --> 01:06:42,058 want to talk about. 9139 01:06:42,058 --> 01:06:43,752 blues society presents women I 9140 01:06:43,752 --> 01:06:43,752 n 9141 01:06:43,752 --> 01:06:45,792 blues showcase if we're allowed 9142 01:06:45,792 --> 01:06:45,792 9143 01:06:45,792 --> 01:06:47,798 to showcase women in music. 9144 01:06:47,798 --> 01:06:50,768 or black -- there is just whole 9145 01:06:50,768 --> 01:06:50,768 9146 01:06:50,768 --> 01:06:50,768 list. 9147 01:06:50,768 --> 01:06:53,326 I do it for my city festival I 9148 01:06:53,326 --> 01:06:53,326 n 9149 01:06:53,326 --> 01:06:54,500 master class these are things 9150 01:06:54,500 --> 01:06:55,502 people in the state legislature 9151 01:06:55,502 --> 01:06:55,502 9152 01:06:55,502 --> 01:06:56,472 probably don't want us to 9153 01:06:56,472 --> 01:06:58,240 participate, but we're free to 9154 01:06:58,240 --> 01:06:58,240 9155 01:06:58,240 --> 01:07:01,316 do it for now. 9156 01:07:01,316 --> 01:07:03,416 so I'm leaning more towards 9157 01:07:03,416 --> 01:07:05,716 let's find this 55,000 but in 9158 01:07:05,716 --> 01:07:07,015 the best I don't have a 9159 01:07:07,015 --> 01:07:09,986 preference on the format or 9160 01:07:09,986 --> 01:07:09,986 version. 9161 01:07:09,986 --> 01:07:12,846 a zero interest loan is where I 9162 01:07:12,846 --> 01:07:12,846 9163 01:07:12,846 --> 01:07:15,062 lean towards if we're capable o 9164 01:07:15,062 --> 01:07:15,062 f 9165 01:07:15,062 --> 01:07:15,490 doing that. 9166 01:07:15,490 --> 01:07:16,728 a zero interest loan. 9167 01:07:16,728 --> 01:07:19,906 that way they figure out what 9168 01:07:19,906 --> 01:07:20,900 they need to do, whether it's 9169 01:07:20,900 --> 01:07:22,102 pay off debt or whatever, and 9170 01:07:22,102 --> 01:07:25,634 they have less in their monthly 9171 01:07:25,634 --> 01:07:25,634 9172 01:07:25,634 --> 01:07:26,844 you know costs and they can pay 9173 01:07:26,844 --> 01:07:26,844 9174 01:07:26,844 --> 01:07:28,904 us back over a period of time. 9175 01:07:28,904 --> 01:07:28,904 9176 01:07:28,904 --> 01:07:30,708 city manager, I would need a 9177 01:07:30,708 --> 01:07:33,984 little more guidance on -- I 9178 01:07:33,984 --> 01:07:34,844 know loans are not impossible. 9179 01:07:34,844 --> 01:07:34,844 9180 01:07:34,844 --> 01:07:37,382 we do it in certain formats, b 9181 01:07:37,382 --> 01:07:37,382 ut 9182 01:07:37,382 --> 01:07:38,384 this is one where it's a littl 9183 01:07:38,384 --> 01:07:38,384 e 9184 01:07:38,384 --> 01:07:39,712 out of my -- I was not prepped 9185 01:07:39,712 --> 01:07:39,712 9186 01:07:39,712 --> 01:07:42,261 for that portion of this today 9187 01:07:42,261 --> 01:07:42,261 , 9188 01:07:42,261 --> 01:07:43,456 so can you answer a little bit 9189 01:07:43,456 --> 01:07:43,456 9190 01:07:43,456 --> 01:07:47,058 about loans or somebody? 9191 01:07:47,058 --> 01:07:48,508 >> to be honest, this is kind o 9192 01:07:48,508 --> 01:07:48,508 f 9193 01:07:48,508 --> 01:07:52,864 new territory for the city wit 9194 01:07:52,864 --> 01:07:52,864 h 9195 01:07:52,864 --> 01:07:56,298 respect to this, the examples o 9196 01:07:56,298 --> 01:07:56,298 f 9197 01:07:56,298 --> 01:07:57,284 loans that I can give you that 9198 01:07:57,284 --> 01:07:57,284 9199 01:07:57,284 --> 01:08:01,804 we do do are the connect three 9200 01:08:01,804 --> 01:08:01,804 9201 01:08:01,804 --> 01:08:03,872 funds are typically structured 9202 01:08:03,872 --> 01:08:03,872 9203 01:08:03,872 --> 01:08:09,514 as a very low interest loan. 9204 01:08:09,514 --> 01:08:11,950 we have certain aspects of our 9205 01:08:11,950 --> 01:08:11,950 9206 01:08:11,950 --> 01:08:15,214 housing programs. 9207 01:08:15,214 --> 01:08:17,524 we are technically a forgivabl 9208 01:08:17,524 --> 01:08:17,524 e 9209 01:08:17,524 --> 01:08:19,827 loan with a sort of soft side 9210 01:08:19,827 --> 01:08:21,685 mortgage that gets forgiven yea 9211 01:08:21,685 --> 01:08:21,685 r 9212 01:08:21,685 --> 01:08:25,798 after year in a prorated sense 9213 01:08:25,798 --> 01:08:25,798 . 9214 01:08:25,798 --> 01:08:26,930 I think as I mentioned like we 9215 01:08:26,930 --> 01:08:26,930 9216 01:08:26,930 --> 01:08:28,762 don't have terms if for this f 9217 01:08:28,762 --> 01:08:28,762 or 9218 01:08:28,762 --> 01:08:30,633 the, for the loan. 9219 01:08:30,633 --> 01:08:31,840 we would look for the commissio 9220 01:08:31,840 --> 01:08:31,840 n 9221 01:08:31,840 --> 01:08:34,108 if they wanted to be forgivabl 9222 01:08:34,108 --> 01:08:34,108 e 9223 01:08:34,108 --> 01:08:35,334 or zero interest. 9224 01:08:35,334 --> 01:08:36,972 like we could work with them a 9225 01:08:36,972 --> 01:08:36,972 nd 9226 01:08:36,972 --> 01:08:39,076 then come up with terms. 9227 01:08:39,076 --> 01:08:39,924 >> okay. 9228 01:08:39,924 --> 01:08:42,378 I mean, by all means, if we giv 9229 01:08:42,378 --> 01:08:42,378 e 9230 01:08:42,378 --> 01:08:43,180 $55,000 loan with zero interes 9231 01:08:43,180 --> 01:08:43,180 t 9232 01:08:43,180 --> 01:08:44,654 and forgivable and they're ali 9233 01:08:44,654 --> 01:08:44,654 ve 9234 01:08:44,654 --> 01:08:46,488 and kicking in three or four 9235 01:08:46,488 --> 01:08:47,478 years, great. 9236 01:08:47,478 --> 01:08:49,122 we've achieved, you know, the 9237 01:08:49,122 --> 01:08:49,122 goal. 9238 01:08:49,122 --> 01:08:50,955 so that's, I just ask that but 9239 01:08:50,955 --> 01:08:50,955 9240 01:08:50,955 --> 01:08:52,160 I'm leaning more towards let's 9241 01:08:52,160 --> 01:08:52,160 9242 01:08:52,160 --> 01:08:54,200 figure this out and find it as 9243 01:08:54,200 --> 01:08:54,200 9244 01:08:54,200 --> 01:08:55,292 an economic development piece 9245 01:08:55,292 --> 01:08:56,206 with the county already having 9246 01:08:56,206 --> 01:08:56,206 9247 01:08:56,206 --> 01:08:59,326 put in their portion and then 9248 01:08:59,326 --> 01:09:00,756 you know an opportunity. 9249 01:09:00,756 --> 01:09:01,862 it is out on the edge of what 9250 01:09:01,862 --> 01:09:02,530 I'm comfortable with. 9251 01:09:02,530 --> 01:09:05,598 it's a bit of leap of faith not 9252 01:09:05,598 --> 01:09:05,598 9253 01:09:05,598 --> 01:09:07,840 in you ms. Karns or the 9254 01:09:07,840 --> 01:09:09,572 soundstage but a leap of faith 9255 01:09:09,572 --> 01:09:09,572 9256 01:09:09,572 --> 01:09:10,872 of what the community does and 9257 01:09:10,872 --> 01:09:10,872 9258 01:09:10,872 --> 01:09:13,746 doesn't support as an entire 9259 01:09:13,746 --> 01:09:13,746 whole. 9260 01:09:13,746 --> 01:09:15,174 I think that's all I got for 9261 01:09:15,174 --> 01:09:15,174 now. 9262 01:09:15,174 --> 01:09:17,022 >> mayor: thank you, 9263 01:09:17,022 --> 01:09:17,750 commissioner willits and let m 9264 01:09:17,750 --> 01:09:17,750 e 9265 01:09:17,750 --> 01:09:18,876 throw an idea out there and the 9266 01:09:18,876 --> 01:09:18,876 n 9267 01:09:18,876 --> 01:09:20,516 we'll go back around to the res 9268 01:09:20,516 --> 01:09:20,516 t 9269 01:09:20,516 --> 01:09:21,948 of the lights. 9270 01:09:21,948 --> 01:09:24,784 what if we thought of this and 9271 01:09:24,784 --> 01:09:25,452 I 9272 01:09:25,452 --> 01:09:26,356 am, I don't have a proposal 9273 01:09:26,356 --> 01:09:29,904 ready I'm just putting this ide 9274 01:09:29,904 --> 01:09:29,904 a 9275 01:09:29,904 --> 01:09:30,762 out there. 9276 01:09:30,762 --> 01:09:31,628 what if we went in the direction 9277 01:09:31,628 --> 01:09:31,628 9278 01:09:31,628 --> 01:09:34,828 of a loan very low interest loa 9279 01:09:34,828 --> 01:09:34,828 n 9280 01:09:34,828 --> 01:09:41,272 that we could then turn into a 9281 01:09:41,272 --> 01:09:41,272 9282 01:09:41,272 --> 01:09:44,010 revolving loan opportunity for 9283 01:09:44,010 --> 01:09:44,010 9284 01:09:44,010 --> 01:09:45,576 arts presenting organizations? 9285 01:09:45,576 --> 01:09:45,576 9286 01:09:45,576 --> 01:09:48,020 so as that is paid back, we the 9287 01:09:48,020 --> 01:09:48,020 n 9288 01:09:48,020 --> 01:09:50,512 make that available to other 9289 01:09:50,512 --> 01:09:53,180 arts presenting organizations on 9290 01:09:53,180 --> 01:09:56,052 same sort of basis. 9291 01:09:56,052 --> 01:09:57,592 just that's a thought. 9292 01:09:57,592 --> 01:09:59,750 that's a way for us to honestl 9293 01:09:59,750 --> 01:09:59,750 y 9294 01:09:59,750 --> 01:10:01,124 put our money where our mouth is 9295 01:10:01,124 --> 01:10:01,124 9296 01:10:01,124 --> 01:10:02,016 when we talk about supporting 9297 01:10:02,016 --> 01:10:03,962 the arts for arts presenting 9298 01:10:03,962 --> 01:10:06,698 organizations and see if maybe 9299 01:10:06,698 --> 01:10:06,698 9300 01:10:06,698 --> 01:10:09,696 there's an opportunity to use 9301 01:10:09,696 --> 01:10:11,908 that as seed money for other 9302 01:10:11,908 --> 01:10:14,506 arts presenting organizations. 9303 01:10:14,506 --> 01:10:14,506 9304 01:10:14,506 --> 01:10:15,374 then we could do that 9305 01:10:15,374 --> 01:10:15,374 geographically. 9306 01:10:15,374 --> 01:10:17,502 we could -- there are any numbe 9307 01:10:17,502 --> 01:10:17,502 r 9308 01:10:17,502 --> 01:10:19,225 of ways that we could think 9309 01:10:19,225 --> 01:10:20,673 about that. 9310 01:10:20,673 --> 01:10:22,778 consider that as we do this. 9311 01:10:22,778 --> 01:10:24,916 it would be good to have you 9312 01:10:24,916 --> 01:10:28,420 know, options a, b, and c for u 9313 01:10:28,420 --> 01:10:28,420 s 9314 01:10:28,420 --> 01:10:29,492 to choose from up here rather 9315 01:10:29,492 --> 01:10:33,724 than us trying to create a loa 9316 01:10:33,724 --> 01:10:33,724 n 9317 01:10:33,724 --> 01:10:34,822 package as we go. 9318 01:10:34,822 --> 01:10:37,859 but I would like to have that a 9319 01:10:37,859 --> 01:10:37,859 s 9320 01:10:37,859 --> 01:10:39,090 a, an option. 9321 01:10:39,090 --> 01:10:42,002 I would also like us to consider 9322 01:10:42,002 --> 01:10:42,002 9323 01:10:42,002 --> 01:10:43,681 that there are a bit of a 9324 01:10:43,681 --> 01:10:43,681 timeline. 9325 01:10:43,681 --> 01:10:45,636 I mean they know there is a 9326 01:10:45,636 --> 01:10:46,640 money crunch coming down the 9327 01:10:46,640 --> 01:10:47,741 road in summer. 9328 01:10:47,741 --> 01:10:48,704 I mean they indicated to us 9329 01:10:48,704 --> 01:10:49,606 whether they were here last 9330 01:10:49,606 --> 01:10:49,606 time. 9331 01:10:49,606 --> 01:10:51,006 -- when they were here last time 9332 01:10:51,006 --> 01:10:51,006 9333 01:10:51,006 --> 01:10:52,840 so we need to keep that in min 9334 01:10:52,840 --> 01:10:52,840 d 9335 01:10:52,840 --> 01:10:53,652 as well. 9336 01:10:53,652 --> 01:10:54,018 all right, commissioner 9337 01:10:54,018 --> 01:10:54,018 duncan-walker. 9338 01:10:54,018 --> 01:10:57,462 >> thank you, mr. Mayor.to ask 9339 01:10:57,462 --> 01:10:57,598 the city 9340 01:10:57,598 --> 01:11:02,666 manager, did the city provide, 9341 01:11:02,666 --> 01:11:02,666 9342 01:11:02,666 --> 01:11:05,882 was what we did with the reggae 9343 01:11:05,882 --> 01:11:05,882 9344 01:11:05,882 --> 01:11:07,497 shack, was that a loan through 9345 01:11:07,497 --> 01:11:07,497 9346 01:11:07,497 --> 01:11:07,497 gcra? 9347 01:11:07,497 --> 01:11:16,293 >> the related to the -- are y 9348 01:11:16,293 --> 01:11:16,293 ou 9349 01:11:16,293 --> 01:11:17,163 talking -- 9350 01:11:17,163 --> 01:11:17,552 >> I know it particular 9351 01:11:17,552 --> 01:11:20,069 owner and there were ways the 9352 01:11:20,069 --> 01:11:22,333 city interfaced and worked wit 9353 01:11:22,333 --> 01:11:22,333 h 9354 01:11:22,333 --> 01:11:23,839 this person on I believe a few 9355 01:11:23,839 --> 01:11:23,839 9356 01:11:23,839 --> 01:11:24,973 different projects. 9357 01:11:24,973 --> 01:11:26,669 I don't recall whether it was, 9358 01:11:26,669 --> 01:11:26,807 I 9359 01:11:26,807 --> 01:11:28,987 do believe it was southern char 9360 01:11:28,987 --> 01:11:28,987 m 9361 01:11:28,987 --> 01:11:30,681 but I thought it was also regga 9362 01:11:30,681 --> 01:11:30,681 e 9363 01:11:30,681 --> 01:11:32,116 shack and another one of the 9364 01:11:32,116 --> 01:11:33,631 restaurants that they were 9365 01:11:33,631 --> 01:11:35,181 trying to do. 9366 01:11:35,181 --> 01:11:37,399 the twisted peacock I believe 9367 01:11:37,399 --> 01:11:39,809 >> that would've been outside o 9368 01:11:39,809 --> 01:11:39,809 f 9369 01:11:39,809 --> 01:11:40,787 cra area. 9370 01:11:40,787 --> 01:11:44,463 the twisted peacock.I believe w 9371 01:11:44,463 --> 01:11:45,547 ithout you know 9372 01:11:45,547 --> 01:11:46,329 without having to do some 9373 01:11:46,329 --> 01:11:49,615 research, I believe reggae sha 9374 01:11:49,615 --> 01:11:49,615 ck 9375 01:11:49,615 --> 01:11:52,967 receive received a facade g 9376 01:11:52,967 --> 01:11:52,967 rant 9377 01:11:52,967 --> 01:11:54,173 for the front of the building 9378 01:11:54,173 --> 01:11:56,071 and then the southern charm was 9379 01:11:56,071 --> 01:11:56,071 9380 01:11:56,071 --> 01:11:58,887 a, you know, was a complete yo 9381 01:11:58,887 --> 01:11:58,887 u 9382 01:11:58,887 --> 01:12:01,049 know we built a restaurant 9383 01:12:01,049 --> 01:12:02,452 essentially for that. 9384 01:12:02,452 --> 01:12:03,573 but I don't think that it's an 9385 01:12:03,573 --> 01:12:03,573 9386 01:12:03,573 --> 01:12:05,747 equivalent in this case. 9387 01:12:05,747 --> 01:12:07,185 >> not a loan that the city 9388 01:12:07,185 --> 01:12:09,483 created for that. 9389 01:12:09,483 --> 01:12:10,561 >> correct. 9390 01:12:10,561 --> 01:12:12,507 I would, I just want -- the 9391 01:12:12,507 --> 01:12:12,507 opportunity. 9392 01:12:12,507 --> 01:12:16,087 I would suggest that the 9393 01:12:16,087 --> 01:12:17,752 commission separate creation o 9394 01:12:17,752 --> 01:12:17,752 f 9395 01:12:17,752 --> 01:12:22,271 a new loan program from this 9396 01:12:22,271 --> 01:12:24,384 discussion like because I think 9397 01:12:24,384 --> 01:12:24,384 9398 01:12:24,384 --> 01:12:26,969 if you all give direction that 9399 01:12:26,969 --> 01:12:26,969 9400 01:12:26,969 --> 01:12:27,881 that's something you want to d 9401 01:12:27,881 --> 01:12:27,881 o 9402 01:12:27,881 --> 01:12:30,045 then we would work that into t 9403 01:12:30,045 --> 01:12:30,045 he 9404 01:12:30,045 --> 01:12:31,371 budget but I think for all the 9405 01:12:31,371 --> 01:12:31,371 9406 01:12:31,371 --> 01:12:32,915 reasons that you know that have 9407 01:12:32,915 --> 01:12:32,915 9408 01:12:32,915 --> 01:12:35,015 been listed both in terms of 9409 01:12:35,015 --> 01:12:37,385 the, the timing for heartwood, 9410 01:12:37,385 --> 01:12:37,385 9411 01:12:37,385 --> 01:12:39,281 and then not coming up with 9412 01:12:39,281 --> 01:12:41,713 something on a daises separatin 9413 01:12:41,713 --> 01:12:41,713 g 9414 01:12:41,713 --> 01:12:43,241 the two -- dais, separating the 9415 01:12:43,241 --> 01:12:43,241 9416 01:12:43,241 --> 01:12:45,077 two, they may both have the 9417 01:12:45,077 --> 01:12:48,391 reasons would probably be the 9418 01:12:48,391 --> 01:12:51,924 best course in this case. 9419 01:12:51,924 --> 01:12:53,008 >> mm-hmm. 9420 01:12:53,008 --> 01:12:54,563 andrew, can I ask you this. 9421 01:12:54,563 --> 01:12:56,665 you see no reason it can't be 9422 01:12:56,665 --> 01:12:57,573 arts specific though, the 9423 01:12:57,573 --> 01:13:00,039 discussion you come back with, 9424 01:13:00,039 --> 01:13:00,039 9425 01:13:00,039 --> 01:13:00,039 correct? 9426 01:13:00,039 --> 01:13:01,306 >> from a loan program? 9427 01:13:01,306 --> 01:13:01,937 yeah, of course. 9428 01:13:01,937 --> 01:13:07,111 I think that would be the focus 9429 01:13:07,111 --> 01:13:07,111 9430 01:13:07,111 --> 01:13:09,213 based on y'all discussion. 9431 01:13:09,213 --> 01:13:09,725 >> okay. 9432 01:13:09,725 --> 01:13:10,849 thank you. 9433 01:13:10,849 --> 01:13:12,513 I conclude for now, mr. Mayor. 9434 01:13:12,513 --> 01:13:12,513 9435 01:13:12,513 --> 01:13:13,045 >> mayor: thank you, 9436 01:13:13,045 --> 01:13:13,045 commissioner. 9437 01:13:13,045 --> 01:13:15,207 so for all of you wondering why 9438 01:13:15,207 --> 01:13:15,207 9439 01:13:15,207 --> 01:13:16,853 didn't they just talk about thi 9440 01:13:16,853 --> 01:13:16,853 s 9441 01:13:16,853 --> 01:13:16,853 beforehand. 9442 01:13:16,853 --> 01:13:18,387 because we can't. 9443 01:13:18,387 --> 01:13:21,025 the sunshine law says if we're 9444 01:13:21,025 --> 01:13:21,025 9445 01:13:21,025 --> 01:13:22,259 going to talk about things tha 9446 01:13:22,259 --> 01:13:22,259 t 9447 01:13:22,259 --> 01:13:23,347 we're going to vote on, this is 9448 01:13:23,347 --> 01:13:23,347 9449 01:13:23,347 --> 01:13:25,661 the way that we do that. 9450 01:13:25,661 --> 01:13:28,599 and it is, it is uncomfortable 9451 01:13:28,599 --> 01:13:28,599 9452 01:13:28,599 --> 01:13:30,299 watching the sausage get made I 9453 01:13:30,299 --> 01:13:30,299 n 9454 01:13:30,299 --> 01:13:31,503 public but this is how it 9455 01:13:31,503 --> 01:13:31,503 works. 9456 01:13:31,503 --> 01:13:35,537 so commissioner eastman. 9457 01:13:35,537 --> 01:13:36,357 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 9458 01:13:36,357 --> 01:13:37,455 I agree with everything that 9459 01:13:37,455 --> 01:13:38,603 commissioner ingle said from 9460 01:13:38,603 --> 01:13:38,603 before. 9461 01:13:38,603 --> 01:13:40,717 I think that losing heartwood 9462 01:13:40,717 --> 01:13:43,447 sound stage would be, I mean, 9463 01:13:43,447 --> 01:13:44,981 devastating for south main which 9464 01:13:44,981 --> 01:13:44,981 9465 01:13:44,981 --> 01:13:46,683 we have invested lot of money I 9466 01:13:46,683 --> 01:13:46,683 n 9467 01:13:46,683 --> 01:13:48,647 over time to we're seeing the 9468 01:13:48,647 --> 01:13:50,229 fruits of that and it is truly 9469 01:13:50,229 --> 01:13:50,229 9470 01:13:50,229 --> 01:13:52,854 an anchor business that is dow 9471 01:13:52,854 --> 01:13:52,854 n 9472 01:13:52,854 --> 01:13:52,854 there. 9473 01:13:52,854 --> 01:13:55,853 it would be a loss to our music 9474 01:13:55,853 --> 01:13:55,853 9475 01:13:55,853 --> 01:13:57,398 community which has lost a lot 9476 01:13:57,398 --> 01:13:57,398 9477 01:13:57,398 --> 01:13:59,363 of its medium sized venue over 9478 01:13:59,363 --> 01:13:59,363 9479 01:13:59,363 --> 01:14:00,161 the last couple of years. 9480 01:14:00,161 --> 01:14:01,797 there are very, very few place 9481 01:14:01,797 --> 01:14:01,797 s 9482 01:14:01,797 --> 01:14:03,977 that medium sized band or group 9483 01:14:03,977 --> 01:14:03,977 9484 01:14:03,977 --> 01:14:06,339 would be able to play in here 9485 01:14:06,339 --> 01:14:07,455 just in our entire city and 9486 01:14:07,455 --> 01:14:09,499 heartwood really serves that 9487 01:14:09,499 --> 01:14:11,462 purpose and it's why -- 9488 01:14:11,462 --> 01:14:12,108 potentially the only one that 9489 01:14:12,108 --> 01:14:14,375 serves that purpose right now 9490 01:14:14,375 --> 01:14:16,043 within the city of gainesville 9491 01:14:16,043 --> 01:14:16,043 . 9492 01:14:16,043 --> 01:14:17,343 but I also I mean I agree 9493 01:14:17,343 --> 01:14:18,245 withition comer willits and som 9494 01:14:18,245 --> 01:14:18,245 e 9495 01:14:18,245 --> 01:14:18,899 of the other folks that have 9496 01:14:18,899 --> 01:14:20,661 spoken that said, you know, you 9497 01:14:20,661 --> 01:14:20,661 9498 01:14:20,661 --> 01:14:22,161 also -- because I spent the rest of t 9499 01:14:22,161 --> 01:14:22,831 of this time up here on the 9500 01:14:22,831 --> 01:14:24,221 commission today arguing about 9501 01:14:24,221 --> 01:14:24,221 9502 01:14:24,221 --> 01:14:27,159 following processes and that 9503 01:14:27,159 --> 01:14:28,731 making one -- when you start 9504 01:14:28,731 --> 01:14:30,559 making one off decisions here, 9505 01:14:30,559 --> 01:14:30,559 9506 01:14:30,559 --> 01:14:32,931 that ends up bek-78ing bec 9507 01:14:32,931 --> 01:14:32,931 oming 9508 01:14:32,931 --> 01:14:34,799 the process in and of itself. 9509 01:14:34,799 --> 01:14:36,897 if people come and ask you mon 9510 01:14:36,897 --> 01:14:36,897 ey 9511 01:14:36,897 --> 01:14:37,930 and you make an exception, 9512 01:14:37,930 --> 01:14:38,807 eventually there is not a rule, 9513 01:14:38,807 --> 01:14:38,807 9514 01:14:38,807 --> 01:14:38,807 right? 9515 01:14:38,807 --> 01:14:41,125 you're now the exception to the 9516 01:14:41,125 --> 01:14:41,125 9517 01:14:41,125 --> 01:14:41,125 rule. 9518 01:14:41,125 --> 01:14:43,968 and so yeah I've struggled wit 9519 01:14:43,968 --> 01:14:43,968 h 9520 01:14:43,968 --> 01:14:46,471 it in exactly the same way. 9521 01:14:46,471 --> 01:14:48,378 so we're now talking about the 9522 01:14:48,378 --> 01:14:48,378 9523 01:14:48,378 --> 01:14:51,640 needs of heartwood that have 9524 01:14:51,640 --> 01:14:52,839 been up until this point kind o 9525 01:14:52,839 --> 01:14:52,839 f 9526 01:14:52,839 --> 01:14:56,725 spoken about as a, some way tha 9527 01:14:56,725 --> 01:14:56,725 t 9528 01:14:56,725 --> 01:14:57,762 funding would go straight to 9529 01:14:57,762 --> 01:14:59,866 heartwood that would then, tha 9530 01:14:59,866 --> 01:14:59,866 t 9531 01:14:59,866 --> 01:15:00,850 would work in some way. 9532 01:15:00,850 --> 01:15:02,058 and I said at the last meeting 9533 01:15:02,058 --> 01:15:02,058 9534 01:15:02,058 --> 01:15:03,029 I'll say it this one that 9535 01:15:03,029 --> 01:15:04,095 anything like this I think it 9536 01:15:04,095 --> 01:15:05,926 has to be focused on what the 9537 01:15:05,926 --> 01:15:07,126 community gets from it, what t 9538 01:15:07,126 --> 01:15:07,126 he 9539 01:15:07,126 --> 01:15:08,966 benefits are, that would to me 9540 01:15:08,966 --> 01:15:08,966 9541 01:15:08,966 --> 01:15:11,095 mean open community events, 9542 01:15:11,095 --> 01:15:13,342 community gatherings that, tha 9543 01:15:13,342 --> 01:15:13,342 t 9544 01:15:13,342 --> 01:15:14,406 you guys are either doing 9545 01:15:14,406 --> 01:15:16,082 currently or that you would be 9546 01:15:16,082 --> 01:15:16,082 9547 01:15:16,082 --> 01:15:18,260 putting into place that, that 9548 01:15:18,260 --> 01:15:18,260 I 9549 01:15:18,260 --> 01:15:19,375 mean that is what our taxpayers 9550 01:15:19,375 --> 01:15:19,375 9551 01:15:19,375 --> 01:15:19,375 expect. 9552 01:15:19,375 --> 01:15:21,232 is they expect that our funding 9553 01:15:21,232 --> 01:15:21,232 9554 01:15:21,232 --> 01:15:23,803 is going to supporting overall 9555 01:15:23,803 --> 01:15:23,803 9556 01:15:23,803 --> 01:15:24,580 something that benefits the 9557 01:15:24,580 --> 01:15:26,148 community, but as someone had 9558 01:15:26,148 --> 01:15:30,313 mentioned a, just a regular, n 9559 01:15:30,313 --> 01:15:30,313 o 9560 01:15:30,313 --> 01:15:31,034 interest loan. 9561 01:15:31,034 --> 01:15:33,163 I don't know if that,and you 9562 01:15:33,163 --> 01:15:33,797 mentioned, I mean you had a 9563 01:15:33,797 --> 01:15:35,958 couple of -- trying to fill a 9564 01:15:35,958 --> 01:15:37,724 gap, right, but then too, you'r 9565 01:15:37,724 --> 01:15:37,724 e 9566 01:15:37,724 --> 01:15:39,758 trying to pay off old debts, a 9567 01:15:39,758 --> 01:15:39,758 nd 9568 01:15:39,758 --> 01:15:42,432 get rid of the, the interest 9569 01:15:42,432 --> 01:15:42,979 that's on that. 9570 01:15:42,979 --> 01:15:45,298 I mean, what -- I know just cam 9571 01:15:45,298 --> 01:15:45,298 e 9572 01:15:45,298 --> 01:15:47,401 up here today, but what are you 9573 01:15:47,401 --> 01:15:47,401 r 9574 01:15:47,401 --> 01:15:48,404 thoughts overall about it? 9575 01:15:48,404 --> 01:15:49,502 a no interest loan for that 9576 01:15:49,502 --> 01:15:49,502 amount? 9577 01:15:49,502 --> 01:15:51,841 >> I think any of those three 9578 01:15:51,841 --> 01:15:53,508 you said the loan, the advanced 9579 01:15:53,508 --> 01:15:53,508 9580 01:15:53,508 --> 01:15:54,945 grant, or the reimbursable 9581 01:15:54,945 --> 01:15:57,079 grant, we could work within the 9582 01:15:57,079 --> 01:15:57,079 9583 01:15:57,079 --> 01:15:58,286 measures of any of those three 9584 01:15:58,286 --> 01:15:58,286 , 9585 01:15:58,286 --> 01:16:00,095 and I would want as much as yo 9586 01:16:00,095 --> 01:16:00,095 u 9587 01:16:00,095 --> 01:16:01,784 all for it to be completely 9588 01:16:01,784 --> 01:16:03,254 transparent completely reported 9589 01:16:03,254 --> 01:16:03,254 9590 01:16:03,254 --> 01:16:05,221 on like I want no, you know, I 9591 01:16:05,221 --> 01:16:05,221 'm 9592 01:16:05,221 --> 01:16:06,580 not interested in negative press 9593 01:16:06,580 --> 01:16:06,580 9594 01:16:06,580 --> 01:16:07,088 for heartwood. 9595 01:16:07,088 --> 01:16:08,622 I want to be completely 9596 01:16:08,622 --> 01:16:09,442 transparent in everything we're 9597 01:16:09,442 --> 01:16:09,442 9598 01:16:09,442 --> 01:16:13,198 is happy to provide whatever 9599 01:16:13,198 --> 01:16:15,668 receipts are needed and you kno 9600 01:16:15,668 --> 01:16:15,668 w 9601 01:16:15,668 --> 01:16:16,867 to make sure that it's all don 9602 01:16:16,867 --> 01:16:16,867 e 9603 01:16:16,867 --> 01:16:18,236 above board and nothing's 9604 01:16:18,236 --> 01:16:18,236 seedy. 9605 01:16:18,236 --> 01:16:20,560 >> right but there is -- one's 9606 01:16:20,560 --> 01:16:20,769 a 9607 01:16:20,769 --> 01:16:22,820 forgivable loan which would be 9608 01:16:22,820 --> 01:16:22,820 I 9609 01:16:22,820 --> 01:16:23,852 mean similar to a grant in tha 9610 01:16:23,852 --> 01:16:23,852 t 9611 01:16:23,852 --> 01:16:24,944 we would give you the up front 9612 01:16:24,944 --> 01:16:24,944 9613 01:16:24,944 --> 01:16:26,874 money and then over time when 9614 01:16:26,874 --> 01:16:26,874 it 9615 01:16:26,874 --> 01:16:28,610 could be certain provisions are 9616 01:16:28,610 --> 01:16:28,610 9617 01:16:28,610 --> 01:16:30,587 met then that is, that gets 9618 01:16:30,587 --> 01:16:32,148 taken off of the total amount o 9619 01:16:32,148 --> 01:16:32,148 r 9620 01:16:32,148 --> 01:16:33,584 it could be just a grant that' 9621 01:16:33,584 --> 01:16:33,584 s 9622 01:16:33,584 --> 01:16:35,122 on the front end or I guess a 9623 01:16:35,122 --> 01:16:38,718 rerebimersable grant doesn't f 9624 01:16:38,718 --> 01:16:38,718 ix 9625 01:16:38,718 --> 01:16:39,964 the cash crunch in the 9626 01:16:39,964 --> 01:16:40,964 short-term because as you said 9627 01:16:40,964 --> 01:16:40,964 9628 01:16:40,964 --> 01:16:43,594 at the last one, the summer is 9629 01:16:43,594 --> 01:16:43,594 9630 01:16:43,594 --> 01:16:44,760 where the cash crunch is comin 9631 01:16:44,760 --> 01:16:44,760 g 9632 01:16:44,760 --> 01:16:45,926 in but the other one would be a 9633 01:16:45,926 --> 01:16:45,926 9634 01:16:45,926 --> 01:16:48,665 no interest lane loan. 9635 01:16:48,665 --> 01:16:50,900 cash eventually that would be 9636 01:16:50,900 --> 01:16:52,413 paid back over a point of time 9637 01:16:52,413 --> 01:16:52,413 9638 01:16:52,413 --> 01:16:53,746 so it's really a loan at that 9639 01:16:53,746 --> 01:16:53,746 point. 9640 01:16:53,746 --> 01:16:54,804 it's not a grant or some amoun 9641 01:16:54,804 --> 01:16:54,804 t 9642 01:16:54,804 --> 01:16:56,436 that is spent. 9643 01:16:56,436 --> 01:16:59,716 >> that's, less helpful than t 9644 01:16:59,716 --> 01:16:59,716 he 9645 01:16:59,716 --> 01:17:01,782 other options maybe a band aid 9646 01:17:01,782 --> 01:17:01,782 9647 01:17:01,782 --> 01:17:03,286 but then we owe you a money in 9648 01:17:03,286 --> 01:17:03,286 9649 01:17:03,286 --> 01:17:04,680 the year or two so it's just a 9650 01:17:04,680 --> 01:17:04,680 s 9651 01:17:04,680 --> 01:17:07,816 we're kind of breaking even and 9652 01:17:07,816 --> 01:17:07,816 9653 01:17:07,816 --> 01:17:09,818 so yeah not -- I would favor t 9654 01:17:09,818 --> 01:17:09,818 he 9655 01:17:09,818 --> 01:17:13,087 options of a forgivable loan o 9656 01:17:13,087 --> 01:17:13,087 r 9657 01:17:13,087 --> 01:17:17,096 an advanced grant. 9658 01:17:17,096 --> 01:17:18,296 >> I mean, that is what I walke 9659 01:17:18,296 --> 01:17:18,296 d 9660 01:17:18,296 --> 01:17:19,166 into this discussion with the 9661 01:17:19,166 --> 01:17:21,834 idea of the with a forgivable 9662 01:17:21,834 --> 01:17:24,052 loan of some amount that would 9663 01:17:24,052 --> 01:17:24,052 9664 01:17:24,052 --> 01:17:28,636 be forgiven upon the contingen 9665 01:17:28,636 --> 01:17:28,636 t 9666 01:17:28,636 --> 01:17:30,436 upon having publicly accessible 9667 01:17:30,436 --> 01:17:30,436 9668 01:17:30,436 --> 01:17:31,576 community events throughout th 9669 01:17:31,576 --> 01:17:31,576 e 9670 01:17:31,576 --> 01:17:33,710 year at some number that would 9671 01:17:33,710 --> 01:17:33,710 9672 01:17:33,710 --> 01:17:36,014 be, the over three-year period 9673 01:17:36,014 --> 01:17:36,014 9674 01:17:36,014 --> 01:17:36,986 is what I had written down her 9675 01:17:36,986 --> 01:17:36,986 e 9676 01:17:36,986 --> 01:17:39,883 that would just to ensure that 9677 01:17:39,883 --> 01:17:39,883 9678 01:17:39,883 --> 01:17:41,216 which I think is the best thing 9679 01:17:41,216 --> 01:17:41,216 9680 01:17:41,216 --> 01:17:43,420 that solves the cash crunch on 9681 01:17:43,420 --> 01:17:43,420 9682 01:17:43,420 --> 01:17:44,782 the front end and then ensures 9683 01:17:44,782 --> 01:17:44,782 9684 01:17:44,782 --> 01:17:45,796 that there is some community 9685 01:17:45,796 --> 01:17:46,658 benefit to this on the back 9686 01:17:46,658 --> 01:17:46,658 end. 9687 01:17:46,658 --> 01:17:50,332 but does not solve the overall 9688 01:17:50,332 --> 01:17:50,332 9689 01:17:50,332 --> 01:17:52,540 question of, of how do you 9690 01:17:52,540 --> 01:17:53,506 ensure that this is done 9691 01:17:53,506 --> 01:17:53,506 fairly. 9692 01:17:53,506 --> 01:17:56,732 we just don't I mean if we're, 9693 01:17:56,732 --> 01:17:56,732 9694 01:17:56,732 --> 01:17:58,850 if we believe, if we believe 9695 01:17:58,850 --> 01:17:59,692 that this is something that 9696 01:17:59,692 --> 01:18:00,870 needs to happen immediately, 9697 01:18:00,870 --> 01:18:03,804 this has to happen before the 9698 01:18:03,804 --> 01:18:04,569 summer, then we don't have 9699 01:18:04,569 --> 01:18:06,016 time -- to the mayor's point I 9700 01:18:06,016 --> 01:18:06,016 9701 01:18:06,016 --> 01:18:06,982 like the idea of having 9702 01:18:06,982 --> 01:18:08,757 revolving loans, mr. Mayor, 9703 01:18:08,757 --> 01:18:10,517 making sure that we have that I 9704 01:18:10,517 --> 01:18:10,517 n 9705 01:18:10,517 --> 01:18:12,516 place, you know, to city 9706 01:18:12,516 --> 01:18:13,692 manager's point we just don't 9707 01:18:13,692 --> 01:18:14,528 have the time for that at the 9708 01:18:14,528 --> 01:18:14,528 moment. 9709 01:18:14,528 --> 01:18:16,758 but I do think that there is 9710 01:18:16,758 --> 01:18:18,193 some kind of a solution we cou 9711 01:18:18,193 --> 01:18:18,193 ld 9712 01:18:18,193 --> 01:18:18,689 find here. 9713 01:18:18,689 --> 01:18:19,553 thank you, mr. Mayor. 9714 01:18:19,553 --> 01:18:20,095 >> mayor: thank you, 9715 01:18:20,095 --> 01:18:20,525 commissioner eastman. 9716 01:18:20,525 --> 01:18:22,065 I do want to point out that 9717 01:18:22,065 --> 01:18:23,531 speaking of process, speaking to 9718 01:18:23,531 --> 01:18:23,531 9719 01:18:23,531 --> 01:18:26,436 process, we have off the top o 9720 01:18:26,436 --> 01:18:26,436 f 9721 01:18:26,436 --> 01:18:28,191 my head I can name three times 9722 01:18:28,191 --> 01:18:28,191 9723 01:18:28,191 --> 01:18:29,834 in the last few years when we' 9724 01:18:29,834 --> 01:18:29,834 ve 9725 01:18:29,834 --> 01:18:30,966 done almost exactly the same 9726 01:18:30,966 --> 01:18:33,888 thing for more money. And 9727 01:18:33,888 --> 01:18:41,282 and that is got a $75,000 grant 9728 01:18:41,282 --> 01:18:41,282 , 9729 01:18:41,282 --> 01:18:43,324 came and made a proposal, we 9730 01:18:43,324 --> 01:18:44,883 said okay, here is your money. 9731 01:18:44,883 --> 01:18:44,883 9732 01:18:44,883 --> 01:18:46,903 the hippodrome didn't even make 9733 01:18:46,903 --> 01:18:46,903 9734 01:18:46,903 --> 01:18:49,546 a proposal just walked up and 9735 01:18:49,546 --> 01:18:51,959 said we need $250,000. 9736 01:18:51,959 --> 01:18:53,142 we said how about 150 I think 9737 01:18:53,142 --> 01:18:54,429 was the number. 9738 01:18:54,429 --> 01:18:55,437 and by the way, I voted for 9739 01:18:55,437 --> 01:18:56,396 every one of these and I'm 9740 01:18:56,396 --> 01:18:58,390 pretty sure that they were all 9741 01:18:58,390 --> 01:18:58,390 9742 01:18:58,390 --> 01:19:00,602 unanimous so I'm not casting a 9743 01:19:00,602 --> 01:19:00,602 ny 9744 01:19:00,602 --> 01:19:03,071 apirations -- aspersions here. 9745 01:19:03,071 --> 01:19:03,071 9746 01:19:03,071 --> 01:19:05,367 and last year we gave bread of 9747 01:19:05,367 --> 01:19:05,367 9748 01:19:05,367 --> 01:19:06,535 the m$100,000. 9749 01:19:06,535 --> 01:19:08,787 now that waserary specifically 9750 01:19:08,787 --> 01:19:08,787 9751 01:19:08,787 --> 01:19:11,115 to go feed -- not saying that 9752 01:19:11,115 --> 01:19:11,945 they're all the same. 9753 01:19:11,945 --> 01:19:13,042 they're not. 9754 01:19:13,042 --> 01:19:16,518 but I am saying that this is n 9755 01:19:16,518 --> 01:19:16,518 ot 9756 01:19:16,518 --> 01:19:18,993 out of the ordinary in the 9757 01:19:18,993 --> 01:19:23,452 greater scheme of things, and I 9758 01:19:23,452 --> 01:19:23,452 9759 01:19:23,452 --> 01:19:24,786 think the lesson is that we nee 9760 01:19:24,786 --> 01:19:24,786 d 9761 01:19:24,786 --> 01:19:25,926 to find a way to make it less 9762 01:19:25,926 --> 01:19:26,816 out of the ordinary and find a 9763 01:19:26,816 --> 01:19:26,816 9764 01:19:26,816 --> 01:19:30,858 way to create actual process s 9765 01:19:30,858 --> 01:19:30,858 o 9766 01:19:30,858 --> 01:19:32,560 that when people come say hey, 9767 01:19:32,560 --> 01:19:32,560 9768 01:19:32,560 --> 01:19:34,211 we need money, we say well 9769 01:19:34,211 --> 01:19:36,928 there's a process for that ther 9770 01:19:36,928 --> 01:19:36,928 e 9771 01:19:36,928 --> 01:19:41,039 are right now processes that a 9772 01:19:41,039 --> 01:19:41,039 re 9773 01:19:41,039 --> 01:19:43,771 very much boxes that are built 9774 01:19:43,771 --> 01:19:43,771 9775 01:19:43,771 --> 01:19:45,467 and if you don't fit one -- if 9776 01:19:45,467 --> 01:19:45,467 9777 01:19:45,467 --> 01:19:47,484 you fit one of the boxes you 9778 01:19:47,484 --> 01:19:48,439 probably don't need the money I 9779 01:19:48,439 --> 01:19:48,439 n 9780 01:19:48,439 --> 01:19:48,955 the first place. 9781 01:19:48,955 --> 01:19:49,962 but if you don't, then there I 9782 01:19:49,962 --> 01:19:49,962 s 9783 01:19:49,962 --> 01:19:51,687 really nowhere where we can say 9784 01:19:51,687 --> 01:19:51,687 9785 01:19:51,687 --> 01:19:53,852 here, go there and do this and 9786 01:19:53,852 --> 01:19:53,852 9787 01:19:53,852 --> 01:19:56,683 we'll work through it with you 9788 01:19:56,683 --> 01:19:56,683 . 9789 01:19:56,683 --> 01:19:57,871 so but it is not out of the 9790 01:19:57,871 --> 01:19:59,394 ordinary for this to happen a 9791 01:19:59,394 --> 01:20:01,557 thing that we are asked of and 9792 01:20:01,557 --> 01:20:01,557 9793 01:20:01,557 --> 01:20:03,189 that we respond affirmatively 9794 01:20:03,189 --> 01:20:03,189 to. 9795 01:20:03,189 --> 01:20:10,337 commissioner ingle. 9796 01:20:10,337 --> 01:20:12,344 >> I want to say I like the ide 9797 01:20:12,344 --> 01:20:12,344 a 9798 01:20:12,344 --> 01:20:13,208 that commissioner eastman 9799 01:20:13,208 --> 01:20:14,934 floated about having some actua 9800 01:20:14,934 --> 01:20:14,934 l 9801 01:20:14,934 --> 01:20:17,904 deliverables for the community 9802 01:20:17,904 --> 01:20:17,904 9803 01:20:17,904 --> 01:20:18,845 that this would be going towar 9804 01:20:18,845 --> 01:20:18,845 ds 9805 01:20:18,845 --> 01:20:20,044 so there was some accountable 9806 01:20:20,044 --> 01:20:22,102 for what that money was -- 9807 01:20:22,102 --> 01:20:22,905 accountability for what that 9808 01:20:22,905 --> 01:20:23,823 money was for. 9809 01:20:23,823 --> 01:20:24,923 but then also I would really 9810 01:20:24,923 --> 01:20:27,353 like to take a look at what we 9811 01:20:27,353 --> 01:20:27,353 9812 01:20:27,353 --> 01:20:30,023 could do to establish a kind o 9813 01:20:30,023 --> 01:20:30,023 f 9814 01:20:30,023 --> 01:20:30,878 long-term program on making som 9815 01:20:30,878 --> 01:20:30,878 e 9816 01:20:30,878 --> 01:20:32,291 of these loans available both 9817 01:20:32,291 --> 01:20:36,792 for economic development and 9818 01:20:36,792 --> 01:20:41,531 arts programs and that, it's a 9819 01:20:41,531 --> 01:20:41,531 9820 01:20:41,531 --> 01:20:43,501 little bit of a cost on the up 9821 01:20:43,501 --> 01:20:43,501 9822 01:20:43,501 --> 01:20:45,371 front but it should be coming 9823 01:20:45,371 --> 01:20:47,339 back and about break even, the 9824 01:20:47,339 --> 01:20:47,339 9825 01:20:47,339 --> 01:20:48,405 type of thing I talked to a lot 9826 01:20:48,405 --> 01:20:48,405 9827 01:20:48,405 --> 01:20:49,379 of businesses and developers 9828 01:20:49,379 --> 01:20:50,881 that are like well I would rea 9829 01:20:50,881 --> 01:20:50,881 l 9830 01:20:50,881 --> 01:20:53,183 ay like to be able to do x but 9831 01:20:53,183 --> 01:20:53,183 9832 01:20:53,183 --> 01:20:55,481 money is 6.5% right now so it' 9833 01:20:55,481 --> 01:20:55,481 s 9834 01:20:55,481 --> 01:20:57,909 not even necessarily need, not 9835 01:20:57,909 --> 01:20:57,909 9836 01:20:57,909 --> 01:21:00,656 necessarily that everybody jus 9837 01:21:00,656 --> 01:21:00,656 t 9838 01:21:00,656 --> 01:21:01,475 needs a check but like the 9839 01:21:01,475 --> 01:21:04,115 ability to get some pay backabl 9840 01:21:04,115 --> 01:21:04,115 e 9841 01:21:04,115 --> 01:21:05,321 money at a reasonable price tha 9842 01:21:05,321 --> 01:21:05,321 t 9843 01:21:05,321 --> 01:21:07,189 could keep economic development 9844 01:21:07,189 --> 01:21:07,189 9845 01:21:07,189 --> 01:21:11,033 going in the town if interest 9846 01:21:11,033 --> 01:21:13,412 rates continue to explode and 9847 01:21:13,412 --> 01:21:14,701 the economy in general slows 9848 01:21:14,701 --> 01:21:14,701 down. 9849 01:21:14,701 --> 01:21:16,769 so I think it might be a timely 9850 01:21:16,769 --> 01:21:16,769 9851 01:21:16,769 --> 01:21:18,607 thing for us to take a look at 9852 01:21:18,607 --> 01:21:18,607 9853 01:21:18,607 --> 01:21:20,237 in general. 9854 01:21:20,237 --> 01:21:22,537 like I said as manager mentioned 9855 01:21:22,537 --> 01:21:22,537 9856 01:21:22,537 --> 01:21:23,339 I don't think you're going to 9857 01:21:23,339 --> 01:21:23,339 be 9858 01:21:23,339 --> 01:21:25,373 able to put that together to 9859 01:21:25,373 --> 01:21:27,026 address this, but I think those 9860 01:21:27,026 --> 01:21:27,026 9861 01:21:27,026 --> 01:21:29,273 two things in tandem are 9862 01:21:29,273 --> 01:21:30,175 something I can probably get 9863 01:21:30,175 --> 01:21:30,175 behind. 9864 01:21:30,175 --> 01:21:31,923 >> mayor: okay. 9865 01:21:31,923 --> 01:21:33,883 thank you, commissioner ingle. 9866 01:21:33,883 --> 01:21:33,883 9867 01:21:33,883 --> 01:21:35,527 commissioner chestnut. 9868 01:21:35,527 --> 01:21:36,465 >> okay. 9869 01:21:36,465 --> 01:21:39,123 my question was going to be on 9870 01:21:39,123 --> 01:21:39,123 9871 01:21:39,123 --> 01:21:39,123 process. 9872 01:21:39,123 --> 01:21:42,559 last year for the hippodrome. 9873 01:21:42,559 --> 01:21:44,434 the hippodrome was in dire 9874 01:21:44,434 --> 01:21:44,434 straits. 9875 01:21:44,434 --> 01:21:45,888 they couldn't meet their 9876 01:21:45,888 --> 01:21:45,888 payroll. 9877 01:21:45,888 --> 01:21:50,071 and we stepped in to help them. 9878 01:21:50,071 --> 01:21:50,071 9879 01:21:50,071 --> 01:21:56,105 bread of the mighty -- food 9880 01:21:56,105 --> 01:21:56,105 stamps. 9881 01:21:56,105 --> 01:21:57,871 we had to meet that need 9882 01:21:57,871 --> 01:22:01,147 immediately for our community. 9883 01:22:01,147 --> 01:22:01,147 9884 01:22:01,147 --> 01:22:02,043 trying to think of the other 9885 01:22:02,043 --> 01:22:02,043 one. 9886 01:22:02,043 --> 01:22:07,185 so that's the one thought. 9887 01:22:07,185 --> 01:22:10,689 then I do not like reimbursabl 9888 01:22:10,689 --> 01:22:10,689 e 9889 01:22:10,689 --> 01:22:12,461 loans or payments because that 9890 01:22:12,461 --> 01:22:12,461 9891 01:22:12,461 --> 01:22:14,693 really doesn't help the 9892 01:22:14,693 --> 01:22:15,657 organization you're trying to. 9893 01:22:15,657 --> 01:22:15,657 9894 01:22:15,657 --> 01:22:17,321 if they have to put up the money 9895 01:22:17,321 --> 01:22:17,321 9896 01:22:17,321 --> 01:22:20,869 first, then submit papers to y 9897 01:22:20,869 --> 01:22:20,869 ou 9898 01:22:20,869 --> 01:22:24,073 to be reimbursed it really 9899 01:22:24,073 --> 01:22:30,314 doesn't serve their purpose. 9900 01:22:30,314 --> 01:22:31,514 I don't think we can create the 9901 01:22:31,514 --> 01:22:31,514 9902 01:22:31,514 --> 01:22:33,474 program sitting up here today, 9903 01:22:33,474 --> 01:22:33,474 9904 01:22:33,474 --> 01:22:35,908 but just -- I'm just thinking 9905 01:22:35,908 --> 01:22:37,718 that of course we have the 9906 01:22:37,718 --> 01:22:39,034 tourist development council, and 9907 01:22:39,034 --> 01:22:39,034 9908 01:22:39,034 --> 01:22:39,968 I think that's probably where 9909 01:22:39,968 --> 01:22:41,648 you got the money from from the 9910 01:22:41,648 --> 01:22:41,648 9911 01:22:41,648 --> 01:22:42,986 county was the tourist 9912 01:22:42,986 --> 01:22:44,664 development council. 9913 01:22:44,664 --> 01:22:47,496 then we have the north central 9914 01:22:47,496 --> 01:22:47,496 9915 01:22:47,496 --> 01:22:52,198 florida -- community 9916 01:22:52,198 --> 01:22:52,198 foundation. 9917 01:22:52,198 --> 01:22:54,864 I'm trying to think if there I 9918 01:22:54,864 --> 01:22:54,864 s 9919 01:22:54,864 --> 01:22:56,109 some kind of program we could 9920 01:22:56,109 --> 01:22:57,938 create with them where we could 9921 01:22:57,938 --> 01:22:57,938 9922 01:22:57,938 --> 01:23:01,108 deposit funds and then let the 9923 01:23:01,108 --> 01:23:01,108 m 9924 01:23:01,108 --> 01:23:08,216 be the distributor. 9925 01:23:08,216 --> 01:23:09,348 I don't know I'm just having, 9926 01:23:09,348 --> 01:23:10,550 I'm just having a problem with 9927 01:23:10,550 --> 01:23:10,550 9928 01:23:10,550 --> 01:23:11,890 this one right here today. 9929 01:23:11,890 --> 01:23:13,483 I'm having a -- I'm having a 9930 01:23:13,483 --> 01:23:15,852 real problem with it. 9931 01:23:15,852 --> 01:23:17,716 maybe something we need to sen 9932 01:23:17,716 --> 01:23:17,716 d 9933 01:23:17,716 --> 01:23:18,868 back to the manager. 9934 01:23:18,868 --> 01:23:20,264 I thought we would -- with som 9935 01:23:20,264 --> 01:23:20,264 e 9936 01:23:20,264 --> 01:23:22,058 more direction, with some more 9937 01:23:22,058 --> 01:23:22,058 9938 01:23:22,058 --> 01:23:22,058 direction. 9939 01:23:22,058 --> 01:23:27,830 but in the end they really may 9940 01:23:27,830 --> 01:23:27,830 9941 01:23:27,830 --> 01:23:29,966 generate the $50,000 they need 9942 01:23:29,966 --> 01:23:29,966 9943 01:23:29,966 --> 01:23:32,302 anyway by summer. 9944 01:23:32,302 --> 01:23:36,416 she's gotten part of it. 9945 01:23:36,416 --> 01:23:38,910 so I'm just having a problem 9946 01:23:38,910 --> 01:23:41,777 with signing off on it today. 9947 01:23:41,777 --> 01:23:44,326 I did not support giving money 9948 01:23:44,326 --> 01:23:44,326 9949 01:23:44,326 --> 01:23:47,546 for an auditor this morning. 9950 01:23:47,546 --> 01:23:49,318 for our city program so I reall 9951 01:23:49,318 --> 01:23:49,318 y 9952 01:23:49,318 --> 01:23:51,048 have a problem trying to fund 9953 01:23:51,048 --> 01:23:52,889 this now. 9954 01:23:52,889 --> 01:23:54,326 so I probably would not vote t 9955 01:23:54,326 --> 01:23:54,326 o 9956 01:23:54,326 --> 01:23:58,266 fund it. 9957 01:23:58,266 --> 01:23:58,902 >> mayor: thank you, 9958 01:23:58,902 --> 01:23:59,394 commissioner chestnut. 9959 01:23:59,394 --> 01:24:02,044 commissioner book. 9960 01:24:02,044 --> 01:24:02,902 >> yes, mr. Mayor. 9961 01:24:02,902 --> 01:24:03,994 so I'm in a similar place, 9962 01:24:03,994 --> 01:24:03,994 right? 9963 01:24:03,994 --> 01:24:06,416 I want to stay consistent with 9964 01:24:06,416 --> 01:24:06,416 9965 01:24:06,416 --> 01:24:07,672 the way that we fund 9966 01:24:07,672 --> 01:24:09,446 organizations even those that 9967 01:24:09,446 --> 01:24:10,808 have great potential and are 9968 01:24:10,808 --> 01:24:12,068 greatly worthwhile, which is 9969 01:24:12,068 --> 01:24:13,172 this one. 9970 01:24:13,172 --> 01:24:14,408 but it's been a nonprofit for 9971 01:24:14,408 --> 01:24:16,182 seven months, and it ran a 9972 01:24:16,182 --> 01:24:17,746 deficit for several years, and 9973 01:24:17,746 --> 01:24:17,746 9974 01:24:17,746 --> 01:24:19,518 the only way I know that is 9975 01:24:19,518 --> 01:24:20,418 because their own staff and the 9976 01:24:20,418 --> 01:24:20,418 9977 01:24:20,418 --> 01:24:22,048 folks who've funded it told us 9978 01:24:22,048 --> 01:24:22,048 9979 01:24:22,048 --> 01:24:22,048 that. 9980 01:24:22,048 --> 01:24:24,556 that it run at deficit for 9981 01:24:24,556 --> 01:24:26,392 several years, and it's only 9982 01:24:26,392 --> 01:24:27,370 because they've moved to a 9983 01:24:27,370 --> 01:24:29,694 nonprofit model and you have 9984 01:24:29,694 --> 01:24:31,362 really proactive aggressive 9985 01:24:31,362 --> 01:24:32,357 staff that they're in a positio 9986 01:24:32,357 --> 01:24:32,357 n 9987 01:24:32,357 --> 01:24:34,236 that they're far more 9988 01:24:34,236 --> 01:24:36,038 financially solvent now. 9989 01:24:36,038 --> 01:24:37,714 so that's a testament to the 9990 01:24:37,714 --> 01:24:40,096 folks who are working there, a 9991 01:24:40,096 --> 01:24:40,096 nd 9992 01:24:40,096 --> 01:24:41,634 the director. 9993 01:24:41,634 --> 01:24:43,272 kind of on the back end, 9994 01:24:43,272 --> 01:24:44,488 commissioner duncan-walker was 9995 01:24:44,488 --> 01:24:44,488 9996 01:24:44,488 --> 01:24:45,790 talking about a process that's 9997 01:24:45,790 --> 01:24:45,790 9998 01:24:45,790 --> 01:24:47,482 more inclusive for arts and 9999 01:24:47,482 --> 01:24:48,246 cultural affairs. 10000 01:24:48,246 --> 01:24:49,082 I support that. 10001 01:24:49,082 --> 01:24:50,180 that might be on the back end 10002 01:24:50,180 --> 01:24:51,486 something that comes out. 10003 01:24:51,486 --> 01:24:52,394 I think you have a little more 10004 01:24:52,394 --> 01:24:52,394 10005 01:24:52,394 --> 01:24:53,822 knowledge than I do in that. 10006 01:24:53,822 --> 01:24:55,927 that we should in fact move 10007 01:24:55,927 --> 01:24:57,418 forward a process to research 10008 01:24:57,418 --> 01:24:57,418 that. 10009 01:24:57,418 --> 01:25:01,764 because I think is it mayor pr 10010 01:25:01,764 --> 01:25:01,764 o 10011 01:25:01,764 --> 01:25:07,354 tem is the papi grant that is 10012 01:25:07,354 --> 01:25:08,764 the one that is very narrowly 10013 01:25:08,764 --> 01:25:11,000 tayered taylered. 10014 01:25:11,000 --> 01:25:12,630 well it probably shouldn't be s 10015 01:25:12,630 --> 01:25:12,630 o 10016 01:25:12,630 --> 01:25:14,510 narrowly tailored at this point 10017 01:25:14,510 --> 01:25:14,510 10018 01:25:14,510 --> 01:25:16,402 with the, with the plethora of 10019 01:25:16,402 --> 01:25:16,402 10020 01:25:16,402 --> 01:25:16,402 organizations. 10021 01:25:16,402 --> 01:25:19,611 >> you may eat those words. 10022 01:25:19,611 --> 01:25:19,611 [laughter] 10023 01:25:19,611 --> 01:25:21,190 >> I don't think so. 10024 01:25:21,190 --> 01:25:23,452 I won't. 10025 01:25:23,452 --> 01:25:25,584 I just think there should be a 10026 01:25:25,584 --> 01:25:25,584 10027 01:25:25,584 --> 01:25:26,682 second motion that comes out 10028 01:25:26,682 --> 01:25:29,955 that deals with allowing the 10029 01:25:29,955 --> 01:25:31,921 city to determine better ways 10030 01:25:31,921 --> 01:25:34,821 for potentially -- and it may 10031 01:25:34,821 --> 01:25:35,720 not even be that grant. 10032 01:25:35,720 --> 01:25:37,154 I'm pretty broad thinking in 10033 01:25:37,154 --> 01:25:37,561 this regard. 10034 01:25:37,561 --> 01:25:39,818 but I do think we need mike sur 10035 01:25:39,818 --> 01:25:39,818 e 10036 01:25:39,818 --> 01:25:41,164 that we're looking and -- make 10037 01:25:41,164 --> 01:25:41,164 10038 01:25:41,164 --> 01:25:42,011 sure that we're looking up and 10039 01:25:42,011 --> 01:25:42,011 10040 01:25:42,011 --> 01:25:43,239 staying up with times and 10041 01:25:43,239 --> 01:25:46,063 friends for the way the -- 10042 01:25:46,063 --> 01:25:46,836 trends for the way those 10043 01:25:46,836 --> 01:25:47,885 organizations provide those 10044 01:25:47,885 --> 01:25:48,842 types of events and cultural 10045 01:25:48,842 --> 01:25:49,610 development to the city. 10046 01:25:49,610 --> 01:25:51,717 so that's second. 10047 01:25:51,717 --> 01:25:53,010 as it relates to this money 10048 01:25:53,010 --> 01:25:54,277 again I voted against providing 10049 01:25:54,277 --> 01:25:54,277 10050 01:25:54,277 --> 01:25:56,116 money to our own city this 10051 01:25:56,116 --> 01:25:56,116 morning. 10052 01:25:56,116 --> 01:25:57,649 and I know it's a different 10053 01:25:57,649 --> 01:25:59,485 funding source. 10054 01:25:59,485 --> 01:26:01,384 but there's no mechanism that 10055 01:26:01,384 --> 01:26:02,182 after seven months as a 10056 01:26:02,182 --> 01:26:03,255 nonprofit I could say that 10057 01:26:03,255 --> 01:26:05,625 that's enough runway to see tha 10058 01:26:05,625 --> 01:26:05,625 t 10059 01:26:05,625 --> 01:26:06,728 we've done everything, and the 10060 01:26:06,728 --> 01:26:06,728 re 10061 01:26:06,728 --> 01:26:09,229 are some other options to look 10062 01:26:09,229 --> 01:26:09,229 10063 01:26:09,229 --> 01:26:09,229 at. 10064 01:26:09,229 --> 01:26:10,761 it sounds to me like you 10065 01:26:10,761 --> 01:26:13,532 director have actually you're 10066 01:26:13,532 --> 01:26:14,537 uncovering quite a few options 10067 01:26:14,537 --> 01:26:14,537 10068 01:26:14,537 --> 01:26:15,731 and pursuing all those. 10069 01:26:15,731 --> 01:26:16,413 couple others have been 10070 01:26:16,413 --> 01:26:18,543 mentioned here. 10071 01:26:18,543 --> 01:26:20,544 surplus equipment, and I think 10072 01:26:20,544 --> 01:26:20,544 10073 01:26:20,544 --> 01:26:21,985 we should see what happens in 10074 01:26:21,985 --> 01:26:23,672 the coming months, and perhaps 10075 01:26:23,672 --> 01:26:23,672 10076 01:26:23,672 --> 01:26:27,615 after a year as a nonprofit tha 10077 01:26:27,615 --> 01:26:27,615 t 10078 01:26:27,615 --> 01:26:29,011 puts us on equal footing with 10079 01:26:29,011 --> 01:26:31,483 other nonprofits asking us for 10080 01:26:31,483 --> 01:26:31,483 10081 01:26:31,483 --> 01:26:32,424 money and other existing fundi 10082 01:26:32,424 --> 01:26:32,424 ng 10083 01:26:32,424 --> 01:26:33,477 sources and then there are, and 10084 01:26:33,477 --> 01:26:33,477 10085 01:26:33,477 --> 01:26:35,079 then we're considering them 10086 01:26:35,079 --> 01:26:36,392 amongst the other competition 10087 01:26:36,392 --> 01:26:37,923 for such good work. 10088 01:26:37,923 --> 01:26:40,355 so it is, this is merely about 10089 01:26:40,355 --> 01:26:40,355 10090 01:26:40,355 --> 01:26:41,694 the same process we are talkin 10091 01:26:41,694 --> 01:26:41,694 g 10092 01:26:41,694 --> 01:26:42,797 about this morning for me. 10093 01:26:42,797 --> 01:26:44,263 thank you. 10094 01:26:44,263 --> 01:26:45,731 >> mayor: all right, thank you 10095 01:26:45,731 --> 01:26:45,731 10096 01:26:45,731 --> 01:26:46,574 commissioner book. 10097 01:26:46,574 --> 01:26:47,663 commissioner duncan-walker. 10098 01:26:47,663 --> 01:26:49,087 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 10099 01:26:49,087 --> 01:26:50,169 just a really quick question t 10100 01:26:50,169 --> 01:26:50,169 o 10101 01:26:50,169 --> 01:26:50,169 staff. 10102 01:26:50,169 --> 01:26:53,896 mr. Manager, how quickly, I know 10103 01:26:53,896 --> 01:26:53,896 10104 01:26:53,896 --> 01:26:55,624 we have a gpc coming up next 10105 01:26:55,624 --> 01:26:57,574 week, but how quickly probably 10106 01:26:57,574 --> 01:26:57,574 10107 01:26:57,574 --> 01:26:59,175 not at that one do you think 10108 01:26:59,175 --> 01:27:00,613 staff might be able to come bac 10109 01:27:00,613 --> 01:27:00,613 k 10110 01:27:00,613 --> 01:27:03,219 with some options for a process 10111 01:27:03,219 --> 01:27:03,219 10112 01:27:03,219 --> 01:27:04,389 to the commission based on wha 10113 01:27:04,389 --> 01:27:04,389 t 10114 01:27:04,389 --> 01:27:09,553 you've heard here today? 10115 01:27:09,553 --> 01:27:10,527 >> can you be more specific? 10116 01:27:10,527 --> 01:27:11,963 like what kind of process? 10117 01:27:11,963 --> 01:27:14,025 >> so you've heard us today tal 10118 01:27:14,025 --> 01:27:14,025 k 10119 01:27:14,025 --> 01:27:15,455 about the, you've heard us talk 10120 01:27:15,455 --> 01:27:15,455 10121 01:27:15,455 --> 01:27:16,395 about a few things. 10122 01:27:16,395 --> 01:27:17,430 you've heard us talk about 10123 01:27:17,430 --> 01:27:18,602 grants but you've also heard u 10124 01:27:18,602 --> 01:27:18,602 s 10125 01:27:18,602 --> 01:27:20,026 talk about loans. 10126 01:27:20,026 --> 01:27:21,969 you've heard us talk about pap 10127 01:27:21,969 --> 01:27:21,969 I 10128 01:27:21,969 --> 01:27:23,074 and I would personally be 10129 01:27:23,074 --> 01:27:24,663 interested in entertaining all 10130 01:27:24,663 --> 01:27:24,663 10131 01:27:24,663 --> 01:27:25,030 of the options. 10132 01:27:25,030 --> 01:27:26,099 now what I do understand about 10133 01:27:26,099 --> 01:27:26,099 10134 01:27:26,099 --> 01:27:30,345 papi is there was a little bit 10135 01:27:30,345 --> 01:27:30,345 10136 01:27:30,345 --> 01:27:34,047 of 3ugsback -- pushback by sta 10137 01:27:34,047 --> 01:27:34,047 ff 10138 01:27:34,047 --> 01:27:35,215 of altering that because there 10139 01:27:35,215 --> 01:27:35,215 10140 01:27:35,215 --> 01:27:37,047 are already major institutions 10141 01:27:37,047 --> 01:27:37,047 10142 01:27:37,047 --> 01:27:38,451 getting money out of the pot 10143 01:27:38,451 --> 01:27:39,505 that max out with that grant 10144 01:27:39,505 --> 01:27:41,485 which is why we -- none of us 10145 01:27:41,485 --> 01:27:43,523 are the professionals up here 10146 01:27:43,523 --> 01:27:45,291 that understand of the financing 10147 01:27:45,291 --> 01:27:45,291 10148 01:27:45,291 --> 01:27:46,305 behind that, et cetera, 10149 01:27:46,305 --> 01:27:48,291 et cetera, so I'm curious if 10150 01:27:48,291 --> 01:27:50,320 based on everything you've heard 10151 01:27:50,320 --> 01:27:50,320 10152 01:27:50,320 --> 01:27:53,699 us say here today from loans t 10153 01:27:53,699 --> 01:27:53,699 o 10154 01:27:53,699 --> 01:27:55,696 grants and to specifically the 10155 01:27:55,696 --> 01:27:57,369 p 10156 01:27:57,369 --> 01:27:59,073 api grant so we can be reminded 10157 01:27:59,073 --> 01:27:59,073 10158 01:27:59,073 --> 01:28:00,069 or informed about what the 10159 01:28:00,069 --> 01:28:03,806 restrictions are or what our 10160 01:28:03,806 --> 01:28:05,448 options are if we did decide we 10161 01:28:05,448 --> 01:28:05,448 10162 01:28:05,448 --> 01:28:08,476 wanted tosee staff kind of 10163 01:28:08,476 --> 01:28:09,885 revisit and reformat that. 10164 01:28:09,885 --> 01:28:11,957 those options and anymore that 10165 01:28:11,957 --> 01:28:11,957 10166 01:28:11,957 --> 01:28:14,119 staff could come back with, how 10167 01:28:14,119 --> 01:28:14,119 10168 01:28:14,119 --> 01:28:15,515 quickly do you think we could 10169 01:28:15,515 --> 01:28:16,203 have that conversation or an 10170 01:28:16,203 --> 01:28:17,919 agenda item? 10171 01:28:17,919 --> 01:28:21,293 >> so I guess couple things. 10172 01:28:21,293 --> 01:28:26,269 for the papi grants, those are 10173 01:28:26,269 --> 01:28:26,269 10174 01:28:26,269 --> 01:28:27,596 grants but they're essentially 10175 01:28:27,596 --> 01:28:27,596 10176 01:28:27,596 --> 01:28:28,999 sort of more baked into your 10177 01:28:28,999 --> 01:28:28,999 budget. 10178 01:28:28,999 --> 01:28:31,863 there is less of a competitive 10179 01:28:31,863 --> 01:28:31,863 10180 01:28:31,863 --> 01:28:34,301 process that goes into it. 10181 01:28:34,301 --> 01:28:38,073 and my understanding is the 10182 01:28:38,073 --> 01:28:40,374 issue that we discussed last 10183 01:28:40,374 --> 01:28:44,679 time was that there are for art 10184 01:28:44,679 --> 01:28:44,679 s 10185 01:28:44,679 --> 01:28:46,385 producing organizations not art 10186 01:28:46,385 --> 01:28:46,385 s 10187 01:28:46,385 --> 01:28:46,385 presenting. 10188 01:28:46,385 --> 01:28:51,390 so there is, so in one sense 10189 01:28:51,390 --> 01:28:53,302 it's very easy because we can 10190 01:28:53,302 --> 01:28:55,095 just change that to include art 10191 01:28:55,095 --> 01:28:55,095 s 10192 01:28:55,095 --> 01:28:57,725 presenting organizations as 10193 01:28:57,725 --> 01:28:59,025 eligible as well, but then the 10194 01:28:59,025 --> 01:28:59,025 re 10195 01:28:59,025 --> 01:29:01,004 is the money piece and the 10196 01:29:01,004 --> 01:29:03,601 existing organizations that are 10197 01:29:03,601 --> 01:29:03,601 10198 01:29:03,601 --> 01:29:05,705 already funded, and I think we 10199 01:29:05,705 --> 01:29:05,705 10200 01:29:05,705 --> 01:29:06,537 would, what we had talked about 10201 01:29:06,537 --> 01:29:06,537 10202 01:29:06,537 --> 01:29:07,567 last time was potentially if 10203 01:29:07,567 --> 01:29:08,843 that was direction from the 10204 01:29:08,843 --> 01:29:10,707 commission, we would bring tha 10205 01:29:10,707 --> 01:29:10,707 t 10206 01:29:10,707 --> 01:29:13,105 any recommendations back throu 10207 01:29:13,105 --> 01:29:13,105 gh 10208 01:29:13,105 --> 01:29:15,481 your budget process this year. 10209 01:29:15,481 --> 01:29:15,481 10210 01:29:15,481 --> 01:29:18,115 there is also the outside agenc 10211 01:29:18,115 --> 01:29:18,115 y 10212 01:29:18,115 --> 01:29:20,619 grant which is more competitive 10213 01:29:20,619 --> 01:29:20,619 , 10214 01:29:20,619 --> 01:29:21,915 and it has like a larger 10215 01:29:21,915 --> 01:29:25,317 diversity of nonprofits that 10216 01:29:25,317 --> 01:29:25,317 apply. 10217 01:29:25,317 --> 01:29:27,591 of which I believe heartwood I 10218 01:29:27,591 --> 01:29:27,591 s 10219 01:29:27,591 --> 01:29:28,691 eligible for but that's a 10220 01:29:28,691 --> 01:29:31,927 smaller pot of money than papi. 10221 01:29:31,927 --> 01:29:31,927 10222 01:29:31,927 --> 01:29:39,619 similarly, I think that would b 10223 01:29:39,619 --> 01:29:39,619 e 10224 01:29:39,619 --> 01:29:42,149 something less of a programmati 10225 01:29:42,149 --> 01:29:42,149 c 10226 01:29:42,149 --> 01:29:43,102 change and more of a discussio 10227 01:29:43,102 --> 01:29:43,102 n 10228 01:29:43,102 --> 01:29:45,145 that you would all probably wan 10229 01:29:45,145 --> 01:29:45,145 t 10230 01:29:45,145 --> 01:29:50,891 to have around the actual total 10231 01:29:50,891 --> 01:29:50,891 10232 01:29:50,891 --> 01:29:50,891 amount. 10233 01:29:50,891 --> 01:29:52,085 I think commissioner willits y 10234 01:29:52,085 --> 01:29:52,085 ou 10235 01:29:52,085 --> 01:29:53,345 brought up last time that both 10236 01:29:53,345 --> 01:29:53,345 10237 01:29:53,345 --> 01:29:54,181 of those funding sources have 10238 01:29:54,181 --> 01:29:55,851 not been increased in a long 10239 01:29:55,851 --> 01:29:59,049 time, so I'm not sure it's 10240 01:29:59,049 --> 01:30:02,709 like -- we can come back for 10241 01:30:02,709 --> 01:30:04,049 options for programmatic chang 10242 01:30:04,049 --> 01:30:04,049 es 10243 01:30:04,049 --> 01:30:05,631 that are relatively short but I 10244 01:30:05,631 --> 01:30:05,631 10245 01:30:05,631 --> 01:30:06,256 don't think that gets to the 10246 01:30:06,256 --> 01:30:07,715 commission's point about if yo 10247 01:30:07,715 --> 01:30:07,715 u 10248 01:30:07,715 --> 01:30:09,731 all want to make room for a 10249 01:30:09,731 --> 01:30:12,937 fourth organization to fund, 10250 01:30:12,937 --> 01:30:13,801 that's going to be a budget 10251 01:30:13,801 --> 01:30:14,737 discussion through your budget 10252 01:30:14,737 --> 01:30:14,737 10253 01:30:14,737 --> 01:30:14,737 process. 10254 01:30:14,737 --> 01:30:19,811 I'm not worried about staff 10255 01:30:19,811 --> 01:30:22,739 being able to come up with 10256 01:30:22,739 --> 01:30:24,279 something in that sense, but I 10257 01:30:24,279 --> 01:30:24,279 10258 01:30:24,279 --> 01:30:25,183 don't want it to be a situation 10259 01:30:25,183 --> 01:30:25,183 10260 01:30:25,183 --> 01:30:27,187 where we rush staff forward and 10261 01:30:27,187 --> 01:30:27,187 10262 01:30:27,187 --> 01:30:28,588 we're still in the middle of 10263 01:30:28,588 --> 01:30:29,671 this existing budget, in the 10264 01:30:29,671 --> 01:30:30,619 middle of your budget process. 10265 01:30:30,619 --> 01:30:30,619 10266 01:30:30,619 --> 01:30:32,355 I would want to wrap that up 10267 01:30:32,355 --> 01:30:33,441 with the discussion of 10268 01:30:33,441 --> 01:30:34,191 everything else that we're going 10269 01:30:34,191 --> 01:30:34,191 10270 01:30:34,191 --> 01:30:36,221 to talk about with budget 10271 01:30:36,221 --> 01:30:37,375 process this year. 10272 01:30:37,375 --> 01:30:40,117 but we can certainly I think 10273 01:30:40,117 --> 01:30:43,401 come back with some programmati 10274 01:30:43,401 --> 01:30:43,401 c 10275 01:30:43,401 --> 01:30:46,928 recommendations through that 10276 01:30:46,928 --> 01:30:47,933 budget process and make sure 10277 01:30:47,933 --> 01:30:49,379 that that, if that's the 10278 01:30:49,379 --> 01:30:50,239 direction of the commission, 10279 01:30:50,239 --> 01:30:52,143 that could be something that w 10280 01:30:52,143 --> 01:30:52,143 e 10281 01:30:52,143 --> 01:30:53,717 discuss during when parks comes 10282 01:30:53,717 --> 01:30:53,717 10283 01:30:53,717 --> 01:30:54,823 and presents the budget or I 10284 01:30:54,823 --> 01:30:56,351 think those are maybe a 10285 01:30:56,351 --> 01:30:57,395 nondepartmental right now so w 10286 01:30:57,395 --> 01:30:57,395 e 10287 01:30:57,395 --> 01:30:57,639 can have 10288 01:30:57,639 --> 01:31:06,291 >> thank you. 10289 01:31:06,291 --> 01:31:07,725 >> thank you. 10290 01:31:07,725 --> 01:31:08,635 >> mayor: that leaves us at 10291 01:31:08,635 --> 01:31:08,635 zero. 10292 01:31:08,635 --> 01:31:12,969 I don't make motions as chair. 10293 01:31:12,969 --> 01:31:12,969 10294 01:31:12,969 --> 01:31:21,065 I would think what we would -- 10295 01:31:21,065 --> 01:31:21,307 I 10296 01:31:21,307 --> 01:31:26,281 think what we would probably 10297 01:31:26,281 --> 01:31:27,909 like is for the manager's offic 10298 01:31:27,909 --> 01:31:27,909 e 10299 01:31:27,909 --> 01:31:30,211 to come back to us with an ide 10300 01:31:30,211 --> 01:31:30,878 a 10301 01:31:30,878 --> 01:31:33,015 of what a loan might look like 10302 01:31:33,015 --> 01:31:33,356 10303 01:31:33,356 --> 01:31:34,923 and what a grant might look 10304 01:31:34,923 --> 01:31:41,589 like, and how that would be 10305 01:31:41,589 --> 01:31:42,959 possible and if nobody wants t 10306 01:31:42,959 --> 01:31:43,121 o 10307 01:31:43,121 --> 01:31:44,525 make that motion, that means we 10308 01:31:44,525 --> 01:31:44,569 10309 01:31:44,569 --> 01:31:45,744 don't want to do this, and 10310 01:31:45,744 --> 01:31:46,135 that's okay as well. 10311 01:31:46,135 --> 01:31:48,217 commissioner willits? 10312 01:31:48,217 --> 01:31:50,161 >> I think I'm getting closer t 10313 01:31:50,161 --> 01:31:50,161 o 10314 01:31:50,161 --> 01:31:50,807 a motion. 10315 01:31:50,807 --> 01:31:57,285 I know delay is not great, but 10316 01:31:57,285 --> 01:32:00,143 10317 01:32:00,143 --> 01:32:08,897 we do have -- the potential 10318 01:32:08,897 --> 01:32:10,291 option to advance was for city 10319 01:32:10,291 --> 01:32:10,687 10320 01:32:10,687 --> 01:32:11,987 funds and audit rights. 10321 01:32:11,987 --> 01:32:14,659 that's where I'm leaning right 10322 01:32:14,659 --> 01:32:14,919 10323 01:32:14,919 --> 01:32:15,333 now with 55,000. 10324 01:32:15,333 --> 01:32:17,595 with some sort of option for - 10325 01:32:17,595 --> 01:32:18,687 - 10326 01:32:18,687 --> 01:32:20,159 I'm sure you'll open to lots o 10327 01:32:20,159 --> 01:32:20,263 f 10328 01:32:20,263 --> 01:32:21,973 public things when a nonprofit 10329 01:32:21,973 --> 01:32:21,973 10330 01:32:21,973 --> 01:32:22,599 is hosting this, that or the 10331 01:32:22,599 --> 01:32:22,599 other. 10332 01:32:22,599 --> 01:32:29,777 some sort of build in about 10333 01:32:29,777 --> 01:32:30,967 public access. 10334 01:32:30,967 --> 01:32:32,709 the grant suggests the public 10335 01:32:32,709 --> 01:32:32,709 10336 01:32:32,709 --> 01:32:34,153 has to be involved somehow, 10337 01:32:34,153 --> 01:32:34,575 there has to be an option. 10338 01:32:34,575 --> 01:32:43,449 some sort of -- I don't know 10339 01:32:43,449 --> 01:32:44,583 what city staff would envision 10340 01:32:44,583 --> 01:32:44,583 ,s 10341 01:32:44,583 --> 01:32:46,887 maybe between now and next week 10342 01:32:46,887 --> 01:32:46,887 , 10343 01:32:46,887 --> 01:32:50,835 come up with -- yeah, we do hav 10344 01:32:50,835 --> 01:32:50,835 e 10345 01:32:50,835 --> 01:32:53,999 a need for a location. 10346 01:32:53,999 --> 01:32:55,093 we're going to record somethin 10347 01:32:55,093 --> 01:32:55,093 g. 10348 01:32:55,093 --> 01:32:59,899 commissioner eastman plays 10349 01:32:59,899 --> 01:32:59,899 guitar? 10350 01:32:59,899 --> 01:33:02,739 banjo, maybe he's going to hav 10351 01:33:02,739 --> 01:33:03,339 e 10352 01:33:03,339 --> 01:33:05,007 a city commission band who wan 10353 01:33:05,007 --> 01:33:05,007 ts 10354 01:33:05,007 --> 01:33:05,007 to. 10355 01:33:05,007 --> 01:33:07,779 I say that as a joke, but if 10356 01:33:07,779 --> 01:33:09,409 there's something we could be 10357 01:33:09,409 --> 01:33:09,409 10358 01:33:09,409 --> 01:33:11,059 useful for us, it could be 10359 01:33:11,059 --> 01:33:12,857 slotted in, public access, 10360 01:33:12,857 --> 01:33:15,687 benefiting the city directly o 10361 01:33:15,687 --> 01:33:15,957 r 10362 01:33:15,957 --> 01:33:16,779 just the public. 10363 01:33:16,779 --> 01:33:18,553 I'm leaning toward that secon 10364 01:33:18,553 --> 01:33:21,121 option to bring it back next 10365 01:33:21,121 --> 01:33:21,121 week. 10366 01:33:21,121 --> 01:33:23,553 which I know is a further dela 10367 01:33:23,553 --> 01:33:24,384 y, none wants thear. 10368 01:33:24,384 --> 01:33:24,384 none wants thear. 10369 01:33:24,384 --> 01:33:30,547 my motion is that we look at t 10370 01:33:30,547 --> 01:33:30,547 he 10371 01:33:30,547 --> 01:33:32,905 next gpc, staff brings back the 10372 01:33:32,905 --> 01:33:33,131 10373 01:33:33,131 --> 01:33:35,277 option of an advanced grant wit 10374 01:33:35,277 --> 01:33:35,277 h 10375 01:33:35,277 --> 01:33:38,311 required backup documentation, 10376 01:33:38,311 --> 01:33:38,311 10377 01:33:38,311 --> 01:33:43,239 with specific funds and 10378 01:33:43,239 --> 01:33:45,081 public -- some sort of 10379 01:33:45,081 --> 01:33:47,713 expectation of public access 10380 01:33:47,713 --> 01:33:49,251 events for a time period or in 10381 01:33:49,251 --> 01:33:49,555 a 10382 01:33:49,555 --> 01:33:51,691 time period for the full 10383 01:33:51,691 --> 01:33:51,691 $55,000. 10384 01:33:51,691 --> 01:33:57,771 >> mayor: how about the 23rd 10385 01:33:57,771 --> 01:33:58,175 instead of next week. 10386 01:33:58,175 --> 01:34:05,111 >> let's do the 23rd. 10387 01:34:05,111 --> 01:34:12,949 >> second. 10388 01:34:12,949 --> 01:34:13,877 >> mayor: thank you. 10389 01:34:13,877 --> 01:34:16,639 >> I did want to hear. 10390 01:34:16,639 --> 01:34:18,563 I was going to -- I thought we 10391 01:34:18,563 --> 01:34:18,819 10392 01:34:18,819 --> 01:34:20,414 needed to make a call on it, I 10393 01:34:20,414 --> 01:34:20,755 10394 01:34:20,755 --> 01:34:22,259 would be curious what the city 10395 01:34:22,259 --> 01:34:22,782 10396 01:34:22,782 --> 01:34:23,691 manager had to say. 10397 01:34:23,691 --> 01:34:25,659 from my understanding of this 10398 01:34:25,659 --> 01:34:25,659 10399 01:34:25,659 --> 01:34:26,885 conversation, I don't think 10400 01:34:26,885 --> 01:34:28,521 staff thought this was a 10401 01:34:28,521 --> 01:34:30,429 complicated thing that it neede 10402 01:34:30,429 --> 01:34:30,429 d 10403 01:34:30,429 --> 01:34:33,293 to be written, prewritten, we 10404 01:34:33,293 --> 01:34:33,293 10405 01:34:33,293 --> 01:34:35,285 could have that direction here 10406 01:34:35,285 --> 01:34:35,285 10407 01:34:35,285 --> 01:34:35,285 today. 10408 01:34:35,285 --> 01:34:36,602 you have your light on, is that 10409 01:34:36,602 --> 01:34:36,739 10410 01:34:36,739 --> 01:34:36,739 right? 10411 01:34:36,739 --> 01:34:38,047 >> yeah. 10412 01:34:38,047 --> 01:34:47,676 >> I think commissioner willits 10413 01:34:47,676 --> 01:34:47,974 10414 01:34:47,974 --> 01:34:48,339 motion is clear. 10415 01:34:48,339 --> 01:34:50,186 we can take that, what I would 10416 01:34:50,186 --> 01:34:50,465 10417 01:34:50,465 --> 01:35:01,487 say in terms of the public 10418 01:35:01,487 --> 01:35:03,691 facing, if it's open to the 10419 01:35:03,691 --> 01:35:05,805 public, that's something that 10420 01:35:05,805 --> 01:35:05,805 10421 01:35:05,805 --> 01:35:07,292 hartwood is amenable to. 10422 01:35:07,292 --> 01:35:12,217 that gives us action, we make 10423 01:35:12,217 --> 01:35:12,217 10424 01:35:12,217 --> 01:35:12,905 that session here today. 10425 01:35:12,905 --> 01:35:14,449 I don't think we need to bring 10426 01:35:14,449 --> 01:35:14,581 10427 01:35:14,581 --> 01:35:16,735 it back, the only complicated 10428 01:35:16,735 --> 01:35:16,735 10429 01:35:16,735 --> 01:35:19,847 factor would be if there was - 10430 01:35:19,847 --> 01:35:20,105 - 10431 01:35:20,105 --> 01:35:23,773 if there was a desire to walk 10432 01:35:23,773 --> 01:35:23,773 10433 01:35:23,773 --> 01:35:24,544 down the loan front. 10434 01:35:24,544 --> 01:35:27,113 then we would need to come up 10435 01:35:27,113 --> 01:35:27,113 10436 01:35:27,113 --> 01:35:28,569 with repayment terms, et cetera 10437 01:35:28,569 --> 01:35:28,569 , 10438 01:35:28,569 --> 01:35:29,599 et cetera. 10439 01:35:29,599 --> 01:35:32,553 if the commission wants to do 10440 01:35:32,553 --> 01:35:32,553 10441 01:35:32,553 --> 01:35:35,860 the advance grant with those 10442 01:35:35,860 --> 01:35:36,861 stipulations, and the discussio 10443 01:35:36,861 --> 01:35:36,861 n 10444 01:35:36,861 --> 01:35:40,728 that we had about making sure 10445 01:35:40,728 --> 01:35:40,728 10446 01:35:40,728 --> 01:35:42,327 that it is for eligible 10447 01:35:42,327 --> 01:35:46,733 expenses, on going eligible 10448 01:35:46,733 --> 01:35:48,207 expenses, not past debt, I thi 10449 01:35:48,207 --> 01:35:48,207 nk 10450 01:35:48,207 --> 01:35:51,301 it's -- our preference would 10451 01:35:51,301 --> 01:35:53,479 probably be, as miss carnes 10452 01:35:53,479 --> 01:35:55,011 indicated, some of the equipment 10453 01:35:55,011 --> 01:35:55,011 10454 01:35:55,011 --> 01:35:57,841 costs because those are long 10455 01:35:57,841 --> 01:35:59,917 term capital investment that I 10456 01:35:59,917 --> 01:36:00,315 10457 01:36:00,315 --> 01:36:03,420 think would have benefit beyon 10458 01:36:03,420 --> 01:36:04,387 d 10459 01:36:04,387 --> 01:36:06,555 just necessarily paying for 10460 01:36:06,555 --> 01:36:08,021 staffing or salaries or things 10461 01:36:08,021 --> 01:36:08,201 10462 01:36:08,201 --> 01:36:18,025 like that, that would be our 10463 01:36:18,025 --> 01:36:18,025 10464 01:36:18,025 --> 01:36:21,868 if that's the will of the 10465 01:36:21,868 --> 01:36:23,203 commission, we could decide tha 10466 01:36:23,203 --> 01:36:23,203 t 10467 01:36:23,203 --> 01:36:24,809 today and give staff enough to 10468 01:36:24,809 --> 01:36:24,979 10469 01:36:24,979 --> 01:36:25,199 move forward. 10470 01:36:25,199 --> 01:36:28,411 >> to me, it's important that I 10471 01:36:28,411 --> 01:36:28,411 t 10472 01:36:28,411 --> 01:36:33,189 have -- it doesn't feel right 10473 01:36:33,189 --> 01:36:33,189 10474 01:36:33,189 --> 01:36:33,613 paying for equipment. 10475 01:36:33,613 --> 01:36:36,427 it's for a multiprivate 10476 01:36:36,427 --> 01:36:36,427 organization. 10477 01:36:36,427 --> 01:36:38,665 I think structuring -- whether 10478 01:36:38,665 --> 01:36:38,919 10479 01:36:38,919 --> 01:36:41,615 it's a grant or forgivable loan 10480 01:36:41,615 --> 01:36:41,759 10481 01:36:41,759 --> 01:36:43,519 that is based on a certain 10482 01:36:43,519 --> 01:36:45,219 number of events that get done 10483 01:36:45,219 --> 01:36:45,219 10484 01:36:45,219 --> 01:36:45,681 over the course of time. 10485 01:36:45,681 --> 01:36:50,563 15 years seems like a bit. 10486 01:36:50,563 --> 01:36:53,193 a three-year forgivable loan 10487 01:36:53,193 --> 01:36:54,197 that were open to the public, 10488 01:36:54,197 --> 01:36:54,197 10489 01:36:54,197 --> 01:36:55,704 which I think are pretty much I 10490 01:36:55,704 --> 01:36:55,704 n 10491 01:36:55,704 --> 01:36:57,879 there, I'm happy to defer that 10492 01:36:57,879 --> 01:36:58,011 10493 01:36:58,011 --> 01:36:59,838 to staff to kick that over, wha 10494 01:36:59,838 --> 01:36:59,838 t 10495 01:36:59,838 --> 01:37:01,099 the community expects and what 10496 01:37:01,099 --> 01:37:01,099 10497 01:37:01,099 --> 01:37:02,781 the city already does, we have 10498 01:37:02,781 --> 01:37:03,409 10499 01:37:03,409 --> 01:37:04,641 events that are open to the 10500 01:37:04,641 --> 01:37:06,796 public that people can come to 10501 01:37:06,796 --> 01:37:06,796 . 10502 01:37:06,796 --> 01:37:08,590 we -- that is a part of what w 10503 01:37:08,590 --> 01:37:08,877 e 10504 01:37:08,877 --> 01:37:09,414 do as a community. 10505 01:37:09,414 --> 01:37:12,353 this is an extension of that t 10506 01:37:12,353 --> 01:37:12,617 o 10507 01:37:12,617 --> 01:37:14,591 an organization that does that 10508 01:37:14,591 --> 01:37:14,855 10509 01:37:14,855 --> 01:37:15,543 very well. 10510 01:37:15,543 --> 01:37:17,675 I guess I'm comfortable with 10511 01:37:17,675 --> 01:37:18,153 what you have. 10512 01:37:18,153 --> 01:37:19,393 I think that gets in the same 10513 01:37:19,393 --> 01:37:19,393 10514 01:37:19,393 --> 01:37:19,393 direction. 10515 01:37:19,393 --> 01:37:23,500 >> mayor: thank you, 10516 01:37:23,500 --> 01:37:23,947 commissioner eastman. 10517 01:37:23,947 --> 01:37:25,629 I like the idea of a three-year 10518 01:37:25,629 --> 01:37:28,734 10519 01:37:28,734 --> 01:37:29,223 forgivable loan. 10520 01:37:29,223 --> 01:37:29,847 as opposed to straight out. 10521 01:37:29,847 --> 01:37:32,165 >> my original. 10522 01:37:32,165 --> 01:37:35,653 >> mayor: commissioner duncan 10523 01:37:35,653 --> 01:37:35,653 10524 01:37:35,653 --> 01:37:35,653 walker? 10525 01:37:35,653 --> 01:37:38,045 >> I was going to ask if the 10526 01:37:38,045 --> 01:37:39,010 maker of the motion would be 10527 01:37:39,010 --> 01:37:41,725 willing to add that to the 10528 01:37:41,725 --> 01:37:41,725 motion? 10529 01:37:41,725 --> 01:37:44,532 >> my preference is, it is 10530 01:37:44,532 --> 01:37:44,532 forgivable. 10531 01:37:44,532 --> 01:37:45,698 we give the money now. 10532 01:37:45,698 --> 01:37:48,389 >> to have staff to bring back 10533 01:37:48,389 --> 01:37:48,555 10534 01:37:48,555 --> 01:37:49,093 loan options so we can see. 10535 01:37:49,093 --> 01:37:52,795 >> I side more with commissione 10536 01:37:52,795 --> 01:37:52,795 r 10537 01:37:52,795 --> 01:37:54,967 eastman, let's get this done 10538 01:37:54,967 --> 01:37:55,216 right now. 10539 01:37:55,216 --> 01:37:57,063 if it didn't need to come back 10540 01:37:57,063 --> 01:37:57,529 , 10541 01:37:57,529 --> 01:37:58,911 the motion was clear enough, I 10542 01:37:58,911 --> 01:37:59,830 10543 01:37:59,830 --> 01:38:00,675 would prefer today. 10544 01:38:00,675 --> 01:38:02,603 in my heart of hearts, I like 10545 01:38:02,603 --> 01:38:02,603 10546 01:38:02,603 --> 01:38:04,571 the had idea of a forgivable 10547 01:38:04,571 --> 01:38:04,571 loan. 10548 01:38:04,571 --> 01:38:06,619 we get some documentation at 10549 01:38:06,619 --> 01:38:08,410 some point and we see some -- I 10550 01:38:08,410 --> 01:38:08,410 f 10551 01:38:08,410 --> 01:38:12,245 it's four events a year, you 10552 01:38:12,245 --> 01:38:13,983 know, then they say yeah, we d 10553 01:38:13,983 --> 01:38:13,983 id 10554 01:38:13,983 --> 01:38:16,447 this, it was great, it was fun, 10555 01:38:16,447 --> 01:38:16,953 10556 01:38:16,953 --> 01:38:19,355 at the end, it's a forgivable 10557 01:38:19,355 --> 01:38:19,355 10558 01:38:19,355 --> 01:38:19,355 loan. 10559 01:38:19,355 --> 01:38:22,285 a forgivable loan is less of ou 10560 01:38:22,285 --> 01:38:22,285 r 10561 01:38:22,285 --> 01:38:24,965 knowledge base, that's why I 10562 01:38:24,965 --> 01:38:26,263 lean more toward getting 10563 01:38:26,263 --> 01:38:26,789 something done today. 10564 01:38:26,789 --> 01:38:29,255 just to be clear, you know what, 10565 01:38:29,255 --> 01:38:29,255 10566 01:38:29,255 --> 01:38:31,879 I withdraw my motion and we wi 10567 01:38:31,879 --> 01:38:31,879 ll 10568 01:38:31,879 --> 01:38:32,245 start a new motion. 10569 01:38:32,245 --> 01:38:34,811 this is literally how the 10570 01:38:34,811 --> 01:38:35,084 sausage is made. 10571 01:38:35,084 --> 01:38:43,445 >> that is why I said that, I 10572 01:38:43,445 --> 01:38:43,445 10573 01:38:43,445 --> 01:38:44,303 like something the mayor 10574 01:38:44,303 --> 01:38:46,111 brought up, it would take us I 10575 01:38:46,111 --> 01:38:46,413 n 10576 01:38:46,413 --> 01:38:47,211 a different direction in terms 10577 01:38:47,211 --> 01:38:47,495 10578 01:38:47,495 --> 01:38:49,185 of giving us the ability to be 10579 01:38:49,185 --> 01:38:49,611 10580 01:38:49,611 --> 01:38:53,291 able to regenerate the pot of 10581 01:38:53,291 --> 01:38:53,291 10582 01:38:53,291 --> 01:38:53,291 money. 10583 01:38:53,291 --> 01:38:56,148 so a loan, whatever the options 10584 01:38:56,148 --> 01:38:56,148 are 10585 01:38:56,148 --> 01:39:02,597 are from all of us. 10586 01:39:02,597 --> 01:39:04,371 we're still able to provide a 10587 01:39:04,371 --> 01:39:04,371 10588 01:39:04,371 --> 01:39:06,010 service, now we don't have the 10589 01:39:06,010 --> 01:39:06,567 10590 01:39:06,567 --> 01:39:07,835 responsibility of, here we hav 10591 01:39:07,835 --> 01:39:07,967 e 10592 01:39:07,967 --> 01:39:09,304 to carve this out in the budget 10593 01:39:09,304 --> 01:39:09,304 . 10594 01:39:09,304 --> 01:39:10,857 I think that's very important 10595 01:39:10,857 --> 01:39:10,857 10596 01:39:10,857 --> 01:39:14,812 for us, it's part of our 10597 01:39:14,812 --> 01:39:16,207 responsibility for the people 10598 01:39:16,207 --> 01:39:16,207 10599 01:39:16,207 --> 01:39:19,711 who expect us to be able to 10600 01:39:19,711 --> 01:39:21,681 support the arts, but also in 10601 01:39:21,681 --> 01:39:21,681 10602 01:39:21,681 --> 01:39:24,293 these lean times, do it as 10603 01:39:24,293 --> 01:39:25,825 fiscally responsible as we can 10604 01:39:25,825 --> 01:39:25,825 . 10605 01:39:25,825 --> 01:39:28,701 >> we can make the motion. 10606 01:39:28,701 --> 01:39:31,458 >> I can definitely make the 10607 01:39:31,458 --> 01:39:31,458 motion. 10608 01:39:31,458 --> 01:39:33,885 let's see. 10609 01:39:33,885 --> 01:39:41,209 I move that staff come back wit 10610 01:39:41,209 --> 01:39:41,209 h 10611 01:39:41,209 --> 01:39:44,407 options for a loan program tha 10612 01:39:44,407 --> 01:39:44,563 t 10613 01:39:44,563 --> 01:39:46,031 will support arts organization 10614 01:39:46,031 --> 01:39:46,031 s, 10615 01:39:46,031 --> 01:39:49,973 not currently served. 10616 01:39:49,973 --> 01:39:52,079 and I guess I could put the 10617 01:39:52,079 --> 01:39:52,435 period there. 10618 01:39:52,435 --> 01:39:53,558 does that cover what we need? 10619 01:39:53,558 --> 01:39:53,763 >> second. 10620 01:39:53,763 --> 01:39:57,051 >> mayor: we have a motion and 10621 01:39:57,051 --> 01:39:57,455 a 10622 01:39:57,455 --> 01:39:57,455 second. 10623 01:39:57,455 --> 01:39:58,629 anything snels. 10624 01:39:58,629 --> 01:40:00,252 >> no, I think that's it. 10625 01:40:00,252 --> 01:40:01,922 >> mayor: commissioner eastman? 10626 01:40:01,922 --> 01:40:01,922 10627 01:40:01,922 --> 01:40:03,332 >> that's fine, we can move on 10628 01:40:03,332 --> 01:40:03,332 10629 01:40:03,332 --> 01:40:06,005 the current motion. 10630 01:40:06,005 --> 01:40:07,002 >> mayor: okay. 10631 01:40:07,002 --> 01:40:08,669 we need to ask for public 10632 01:40:08,669 --> 01:40:08,669 comment. 10633 01:40:08,669 --> 01:40:10,021 we don't have any. 10634 01:40:10,021 --> 01:40:12,465 >> I would like to see what the 10635 01:40:12,465 --> 01:40:12,555 10636 01:40:12,555 --> 01:40:13,742 motion is that we're voting on. 10637 01:40:13,742 --> 01:40:13,742 10638 01:40:13,742 --> 01:40:15,672 there have been several. 10639 01:40:15,672 --> 01:40:18,953 >> mayor: it will take us a 10640 01:40:18,953 --> 01:40:19,385 moment to get it on screen. 10641 01:40:19,385 --> 01:40:22,578 >> broadcast, I have it up. 10642 01:40:22,578 --> 01:40:24,855 there we go. 10643 01:40:24,855 --> 01:40:33,756 >> mayor: do you want to put a 10644 01:40:33,756 --> 01:40:33,917 n 10645 01:40:33,917 --> 01:40:34,425 amount on there? 10646 01:40:34,425 --> 01:40:37,283 >> no, I don't want to put an 10647 01:40:37,283 --> 01:40:37,283 10648 01:40:37,283 --> 01:40:37,528 amount on there. 10649 01:40:37,528 --> 01:40:43,433 I want staff to. 10650 01:40:43,433 --> 01:40:44,731 >> mayor: do you want to put a 10651 01:40:44,731 --> 01:40:45,027 10652 01:40:45,027 --> 01:40:45,705 date on there? 10653 01:40:45,705 --> 01:40:47,737 >> can you bring it back to gp 10654 01:40:47,737 --> 01:40:48,837 c 10655 01:40:48,837 --> 01:40:49,439 on the 23rd? 10656 01:40:49,439 --> 01:40:51,721 I'm trying to take a little 10657 01:40:51,721 --> 01:40:52,165 pressure off from you. 10658 01:40:52,165 --> 01:40:58,525 >> that's the second gpc of th 10659 01:40:58,525 --> 01:41:00,083 e 10660 01:41:00,083 --> 01:41:00,083 month. 10661 01:41:00,083 --> 01:41:01,419 we can, yes. 10662 01:41:01,419 --> 01:41:12,790 is this to serve heartwood or? 10663 01:41:12,790 --> 01:41:12,790 10664 01:41:12,790 --> 01:41:16,299 I'm confused. 10665 01:41:16,299 --> 01:41:18,133 does this need to be done for 10666 01:41:18,133 --> 01:41:18,133 10667 01:41:18,133 --> 01:41:18,699 her to apply? 10668 01:41:18,699 --> 01:41:20,697 >> well, this is great for the 10669 01:41:20,697 --> 01:41:21,166 10670 01:41:21,166 --> 01:41:22,375 community, it's not actually 10671 01:41:22,375 --> 01:41:22,767 what hartwood was requesting. 10672 01:41:22,767 --> 01:41:26,905 we were requesting money we won 10673 01:41:26,905 --> 01:41:27,125 10674 01:41:27,125 --> 01:41:29,776 the owe you to kind of -- I'm 10675 01:41:29,776 --> 01:41:29,776 10676 01:41:29,776 --> 01:41:31,679 trying to avoid being back her 10677 01:41:31,679 --> 01:41:32,513 e 10678 01:41:32,513 --> 01:41:33,209 next year asking again. 10679 01:41:33,209 --> 01:41:40,119 so a loan we would have to pay 10680 01:41:40,119 --> 01:41:40,119 10681 01:41:40,119 --> 01:41:42,611 off doesn't fix that need. 10682 01:41:42,611 --> 01:41:44,491 it won't be ready for us in tim 10683 01:41:44,491 --> 01:41:44,491 e 10684 01:41:44,491 --> 01:41:45,824 for summer. 10685 01:41:45,824 --> 01:41:45,981 >> understood. 10686 01:41:45,981 --> 01:41:50,172 >> I think it's a great motion 10687 01:41:50,172 --> 01:41:50,172 . 10688 01:41:50,172 --> 01:41:54,202 >> I think if this is the 10689 01:41:54,202 --> 01:41:55,643 direction that the commission 10690 01:41:55,643 --> 01:41:55,643 10691 01:41:55,643 --> 01:41:58,183 wants to do from a programmati 10692 01:41:58,183 --> 01:41:58,707 c 10693 01:41:58,707 --> 01:42:00,219 standpoint, then I think that' 10694 01:42:00,219 --> 01:42:00,475 s 10695 01:42:00,475 --> 01:42:03,215 a separate motion than dealing 10696 01:42:03,215 --> 01:42:03,649 10697 01:42:03,649 --> 01:42:04,943 with heart wood. 10698 01:42:04,943 --> 01:42:08,413 we can do this, we don't need 10699 01:42:08,413 --> 01:42:08,413 10700 01:42:08,413 --> 01:42:09,518 necessarily, if you all want I 10701 01:42:09,518 --> 01:42:09,679 t 10702 01:42:09,679 --> 01:42:11,819 on the 23rd for initial 10703 01:42:11,819 --> 01:42:11,819 discussion. 10704 01:42:11,819 --> 01:42:14,053 I think part of the budget 10705 01:42:14,053 --> 01:42:15,464 process, we wouldn't need to 10706 01:42:15,464 --> 01:42:17,926 actually put some money in to 10707 01:42:17,926 --> 01:42:17,926 10708 01:42:17,926 --> 01:42:18,854 the initial loan amount. 10709 01:42:18,854 --> 01:42:20,897 and my recommendation would 10710 01:42:20,897 --> 01:42:23,203 again be let's do that as part 10711 01:42:23,203 --> 01:42:23,461 10712 01:42:23,461 --> 01:42:24,326 of the budget process. 10713 01:42:24,326 --> 01:42:26,503 but I think if the commission 10714 01:42:26,503 --> 01:42:26,503 10715 01:42:26,503 --> 01:42:34,605 wants to deal with hartwood, 10716 01:42:34,605 --> 01:42:35,062 they're two separate things. 10717 01:42:35,062 --> 01:42:38,395 does that make sense? 10718 01:42:38,395 --> 01:42:38,712 >> it does. 10719 01:42:38,712 --> 01:42:45,343 >> and again n a competitive 10720 01:42:45,343 --> 01:42:45,879 way. 10721 01:42:45,879 --> 01:42:47,279 >> in a competitive process, 10722 01:42:47,279 --> 01:42:49,893 where the city is able to recou 10723 01:42:49,893 --> 01:42:49,893 p 10724 01:42:49,893 --> 01:42:50,656 their funds. 10725 01:42:50,656 --> 01:42:52,575 I have no problem with that 10726 01:42:52,575 --> 01:42:54,964 being a part of the budgetary 10727 01:42:54,964 --> 01:42:54,964 10728 01:42:54,964 --> 01:42:54,964 solution. 10729 01:42:54,964 --> 01:42:56,634 we have this one on the table. 10730 01:42:56,634 --> 01:42:56,634 10731 01:42:56,634 --> 01:43:00,865 but it's not applied to 10732 01:43:00,865 --> 01:43:01,374 heart wood. 10733 01:43:01,374 --> 01:43:04,706 we need another one going to 10734 01:43:04,706 --> 01:43:07,362 heart wood. 10735 01:43:07,362 --> 01:43:07,975 >> am I taking the 23rd off? 10736 01:43:07,975 --> 01:43:08,191 >> yes. 10737 01:43:08,191 --> 01:43:19,133 >> thank you. 10738 01:43:19,133 --> 01:43:21,429 >> okay. That is something 10739 01:43:21,429 --> 01:43:22,820 that is something we can handl 10740 01:43:22,820 --> 01:43:23,025 e 10741 01:43:23,025 --> 01:43:25,625 during the -- should we vote 10742 01:43:25,625 --> 01:43:26,825 affirmatively on this, that's 10743 01:43:26,825 --> 01:43:26,825 10744 01:43:26,825 --> 01:43:27,942 something we can do during the 10745 01:43:27,942 --> 01:43:28,363 10746 01:43:28,363 --> 01:43:28,847 budget process. 10747 01:43:28,847 --> 01:43:31,101 we still have the question to 10748 01:43:31,101 --> 01:43:31,101 10749 01:43:31,101 --> 01:43:32,895 deal with, but is there any 10750 01:43:32,895 --> 01:43:36,067 other question about this 10751 01:43:36,067 --> 01:43:36,386 particular motion? 10752 01:43:36,386 --> 01:43:39,777 all in favor? 10753 01:43:39,777 --> 01:43:40,805 any opposed? 10754 01:43:40,805 --> 01:43:43,416 that passes unanimously, as par 10755 01:43:43,416 --> 01:43:43,416 t 10756 01:43:43,416 --> 01:43:45,145 of the on going process. 10757 01:43:45,145 --> 01:43:45,938 at some number. 10758 01:43:45,938 --> 01:43:48,073 now, that's not a definite 10759 01:43:48,073 --> 01:43:49,546 number, and we can work that o 10760 01:43:49,546 --> 01:43:49,546 ut 10761 01:43:49,546 --> 01:43:50,447 as we go. 10762 01:43:50,447 --> 01:43:54,093 I do think that has tremendous 10763 01:43:54,093 --> 01:43:54,307 10764 01:43:54,307 --> 01:43:55,989 long term potential, even at a 10765 01:43:55,989 --> 01:43:56,036 10766 01:43:56,036 --> 01:43:56,353 low number. 10767 01:43:56,353 --> 01:43:58,438 I think it gets a lot of 10768 01:43:58,438 --> 01:44:00,524 organizations over a hump, 10769 01:44:00,524 --> 01:44:02,167 without having to put it on 10770 01:44:02,167 --> 01:44:02,961 someone's credit card. 10771 01:44:02,961 --> 01:44:07,706 the truth,that's what arts 10772 01:44:07,706 --> 01:44:08,510 organizations get funded with, 10773 01:44:08,510 --> 01:44:09,173 10774 01:44:09,173 --> 01:44:11,705 someone's high interest credit 10775 01:44:11,705 --> 01:44:11,705 10776 01:44:11,705 --> 01:44:11,705 card. 10777 01:44:11,705 --> 01:44:14,541 it's rarely a situation with 10778 01:44:14,541 --> 01:44:16,512 nonprofits and particularly art 10779 01:44:16,512 --> 01:44:16,512 s 10780 01:44:16,512 --> 01:44:18,814 nonprofits and for profit, to 10781 01:44:18,814 --> 01:44:18,814 10782 01:44:18,814 --> 01:44:19,446 make a profit. 10783 01:44:19,446 --> 01:44:22,916 and it's harder to be stable 10784 01:44:22,916 --> 01:44:24,759 without the community's suppor 10785 01:44:24,759 --> 01:44:24,759 t. 10786 01:44:24,759 --> 01:44:26,425 that still leaves us with the 10787 01:44:26,425 --> 01:44:26,425 10788 01:44:26,425 --> 01:44:28,759 question we have on the agenda 10789 01:44:28,759 --> 01:44:29,525 10790 01:44:29,525 --> 01:44:29,525 today. 10791 01:44:29,525 --> 01:44:31,454 commissioner eastman? 10792 01:44:31,454 --> 01:44:33,791 >> for the point of this, I'm 10793 01:44:33,791 --> 01:44:33,791 10794 01:44:33,791 --> 01:44:35,491 happy to review it, I think 10795 01:44:35,491 --> 01:44:37,539 there's a lot that need -- how 10796 01:44:37,539 --> 01:44:37,765 10797 01:44:37,765 --> 01:44:40,048 we're going to make up our 10798 01:44:40,048 --> 01:44:41,943 budget gap that we have, I 10799 01:44:41,943 --> 01:44:42,871 consider this part of the 10800 01:44:42,871 --> 01:44:44,941 overall policy process, and I'l 10801 01:44:44,941 --> 01:44:44,941 l 10802 01:44:44,941 --> 01:44:46,654 be curious what staff comes bac 10803 01:44:46,654 --> 01:44:46,654 k 10804 01:44:46,654 --> 01:44:46,654 with. 10805 01:44:46,654 --> 01:44:49,879 I hope just to be on the up 10806 01:44:49,879 --> 01:44:52,611 front about it, in the same vie 10807 01:44:52,611 --> 01:44:52,611 w 10808 01:44:52,611 --> 01:44:55,761 as the hippo drome came out for 10809 01:44:55,761 --> 01:44:56,650 10810 01:44:56,650 --> 01:44:57,893 $250,000 initially? 10811 01:44:57,893 --> 01:44:59,343 >> mayor: that's what think 10812 01:44:59,343 --> 01:45:01,604 asked, I don't think we gave 10813 01:45:01,604 --> 01:45:02,021 them 250. 10814 01:45:02,021 --> 01:45:04,193 >> I think in that same spirit 10815 01:45:04,193 --> 01:45:04,625 , 10816 01:45:04,625 --> 01:45:06,128 I hear what you're saying about 10817 01:45:06,128 --> 01:45:06,439 10818 01:45:06,439 --> 01:45:06,703 the 55,000. 10819 01:45:06,703 --> 01:45:10,397 I move to approve $45,000 to b 10820 01:45:10,397 --> 01:45:11,231 e 10821 01:45:11,231 --> 01:45:13,766 taken out of excess fund balan 10822 01:45:13,766 --> 01:45:13,766 ce 10823 01:45:13,766 --> 01:45:15,645 to be forgiven over three year 10824 01:45:15,645 --> 01:45:15,645 s, 10825 01:45:15,645 --> 01:45:17,908 contingent on continued 10826 01:45:17,908 --> 01:45:19,975 operations, and hosting at lea 10827 01:45:19,975 --> 01:45:19,975 st 10828 01:45:19,975 --> 01:45:23,285 four free community accessible 10829 01:45:23,285 --> 01:45:23,715 10830 01:45:23,715 --> 01:45:24,041 events per year. 10831 01:45:24,041 --> 01:45:24,583 >> second. 10832 01:45:24,583 --> 01:45:28,697 >> mayor: okay. 10833 01:45:28,697 --> 01:45:32,094 we have a motion and a second. 10834 01:45:32,094 --> 01:45:32,094 10835 01:45:32,094 --> 01:45:34,001 is there any conversation or 10836 01:45:34,001 --> 01:45:35,686 misunderstanding about that. 10837 01:45:35,686 --> 01:45:36,992 >> what we're doing right now, 10838 01:45:36,992 --> 01:45:37,664 10839 01:45:37,664 --> 01:45:39,875 events downtown, about $5,000 10840 01:45:39,875 --> 01:45:39,875 10841 01:45:39,875 --> 01:45:39,875 per. 10842 01:45:39,875 --> 01:45:42,495 so events over a three-year 10843 01:45:42,495 --> 01:45:44,569 period, it would be $60,000 for 10844 01:45:44,569 --> 01:45:44,765 10845 01:45:44,765 --> 01:45:45,440 what we're currently putting o 10846 01:45:45,440 --> 01:45:45,440 ut 10847 01:45:45,440 --> 01:45:45,440 there. 10848 01:45:45,440 --> 01:45:47,548 >> this is less than that. 10849 01:45:47,548 --> 01:45:49,911 >> yeah, this is less than that 10850 01:45:49,911 --> 01:45:49,911 . 10851 01:45:49,911 --> 01:45:55,141 >> mayor: any questions about 10852 01:45:55,141 --> 01:45:55,141 10853 01:45:55,141 --> 01:45:55,614 the current motion? 10854 01:45:55,614 --> 01:45:56,396 all in favor, please say aye. 10855 01:45:56,396 --> 01:45:59,064 >> aye. 10856 01:45:59,064 --> 01:46:00,479 >> mayor: any opposed? 10857 01:46:00,479 --> 01:46:03,397 >> nay. 10858 01:46:03,397 --> 01:46:05,870 >> 45,000? 10859 01:46:05,870 --> 01:46:06,134 >> yes. 10860 01:46:06,134 --> 01:46:12,462 so you were -- 10861 01:46:12,462 --> 01:46:14,094 >> yes, I just want to make sur 10862 01:46:14,094 --> 01:46:14,094 e 10863 01:46:14,094 --> 01:46:15,730 we're talking about 45 instead 10864 01:46:15,730 --> 01:46:16,174 10865 01:46:16,174 --> 01:46:16,511 of 55. 10866 01:46:16,511 --> 01:46:17,039 >> yes. 10867 01:46:17,039 --> 01:46:20,168 >> and commissioner duncan 10868 01:46:20,168 --> 01:46:21,815 walker you were nay? 10869 01:46:21,815 --> 01:46:23,055 >> nay. 10870 01:46:23,055 --> 01:46:27,574 >> mayor: I'm yea. 10871 01:46:27,574 --> 01:46:30,341 that passes 4-3, with book, 10872 01:46:30,341 --> 01:46:32,781 chestnut and duncan walker in 10873 01:46:32,781 --> 01:46:32,781 10874 01:46:32,781 --> 01:46:32,781 dissent. 10875 01:46:32,781 --> 01:46:33,648 is that accurate? 10876 01:46:33,648 --> 01:46:33,969 >> correct. 10877 01:46:33,969 --> 01:46:37,881 >> mayor: all right. 10878 01:46:37,881 --> 01:46:38,482 there you go. 10879 01:46:38,482 --> 01:46:41,053 >> I want to thank you all for 10880 01:46:41,053 --> 01:46:41,758 10881 01:46:41,758 --> 01:46:43,691 taking the time to discuss thi 10882 01:46:43,691 --> 01:46:43,997 s 10883 01:46:43,997 --> 01:46:45,774 in multiple meetings. 10884 01:46:45,774 --> 01:46:48,428 we're thankful for your su 10885 01:46:48,428 --> 01:46:51,876 heart wood and the arts. 10886 01:46:51,876 --> 01:47:00,678 mr. Manager and mr. Attorneys 10887 01:47:00,678 --> 01:47:00,678 10888 01:47:00,678 --> 01:47:00,993 [ inaudible ] 10889 01:47:00,993 --> 01:47:03,587 >> mayor: madam clerk. 10890 01:47:03,587 --> 01:47:07,527 >> madam mayor, 2026-226, 10891 01:47:07,527 --> 01:47:08,501 northeast 8th avenue corridor 10892 01:47:08,501 --> 01:47:08,501 10893 01:47:08,501 --> 01:47:08,501 improvements. 10894 01:47:08,501 --> 01:47:12,607 the city commission authorize 10895 01:47:12,607 --> 01:47:12,607 10896 01:47:12,607 --> 01:47:14,823 the city manager to proceed wit 10897 01:47:14,823 --> 01:47:14,823 h 10898 01:47:14,823 --> 01:47:17,605 the redesign of northeast 8th 10899 01:47:17,605 --> 01:47:17,605 10900 01:47:17,605 --> 01:47:22,695 avenue from waldo road to loft 10901 01:47:22,695 --> 01:47:22,695 en 10902 01:47:22,695 --> 01:47:24,229 high school. 10903 01:47:24,229 --> 01:47:26,355 return to the city commission 10904 01:47:26,355 --> 01:47:26,355 10905 01:47:26,355 --> 01:47:28,768 with a construction agreement 10906 01:47:28,768 --> 01:47:28,768 10907 01:47:28,768 --> 01:47:36,149 with the northeast 8th avenue. 10908 01:47:36,149 --> 01:47:36,149 10909 01:47:36,149 --> 01:47:36,987 >> mayor: welcome back. 10910 01:47:36,987 --> 01:47:38,871 >> we have a presentation today 10911 01:47:38,871 --> 01:47:39,046 10912 01:47:39,046 --> 01:47:42,046 to show you some proposed 10913 01:47:42,046 --> 01:47:43,735 concept you'll concepts of the 10914 01:47:43,735 --> 01:47:44,225 10915 01:47:44,225 --> 01:47:47,626 northeast 8th avenue corridor 10916 01:47:47,626 --> 01:47:47,626 10917 01:47:47,626 --> 01:47:47,626 improvements. 10918 01:47:47,626 --> 01:47:49,283 this presentation is going to 10919 01:47:49,283 --> 01:47:49,283 10920 01:47:49,283 --> 01:47:50,659 provide some options, and then 10921 01:47:50,659 --> 01:47:50,838 10922 01:47:50,838 --> 01:47:54,563 what our recommendations are 10923 01:47:54,563 --> 01:47:54,563 currently. 10924 01:47:54,563 --> 01:47:59,737 the portion of the road -- I'm 10925 01:47:59,737 --> 01:47:59,827 10926 01:47:59,827 --> 01:48:07,639 sorry, there's two parts. 10927 01:48:07,639 --> 01:48:10,081 dr. Chase and I will be 10928 01:48:10,081 --> 01:48:11,596 presenting on the portion of th 10929 01:48:11,596 --> 01:48:11,596 e 10930 01:48:11,596 --> 01:48:13,212 road that we are designing. 10931 01:48:13,212 --> 01:48:15,443 ultimately, we're just looking 10932 01:48:15,443 --> 01:48:15,641 10933 01:48:15,641 --> 01:48:17,815 for some recommendations for 10934 01:48:17,815 --> 01:48:18,916 approval to move forward with 10935 01:48:18,916 --> 01:48:18,916 10936 01:48:18,916 --> 01:48:22,316 some recommendations that we 10937 01:48:22,316 --> 01:48:22,316 have. 10938 01:48:22,316 --> 01:48:28,742 >> mayor: good. 10939 01:48:28,742 --> 01:48:32,428 >> good afternoon, mona konach 10940 01:48:32,428 --> 01:48:32,428 et 10941 01:48:32,428 --> 01:48:35,570 with nb5. 10942 01:48:35,570 --> 01:48:41,008 I'm going to go through what 10943 01:48:41,008 --> 01:48:42,688 informed our options and design 10944 01:48:42,688 --> 01:48:43,010 10945 01:48:43,010 --> 01:48:43,010 decisions. 10946 01:48:43,010 --> 01:48:44,544 for the corridor. 10947 01:48:44,544 --> 01:48:46,189 we'll talk about public 10948 01:48:46,189 --> 01:48:47,778 involvement, how we got citizen 10949 01:48:47,778 --> 01:48:47,778 s 10950 01:48:47,778 --> 01:48:50,056 involveds in neighborhood 10951 01:48:50,056 --> 01:48:50,056 residents. 10952 01:48:50,056 --> 01:48:52,096 I'll go through a general 10953 01:48:52,096 --> 01:48:53,100 project overview, where we are, 10954 01:48:53,100 --> 01:48:53,450 10955 01:48:53,450 --> 01:48:54,788 what we're doing, go through t 10956 01:48:54,788 --> 01:48:54,788 he 10957 01:48:54,788 --> 01:48:56,190 existing conditions. 10958 01:48:56,190 --> 01:48:58,356 some data, traffic and 10959 01:48:58,356 --> 01:48:58,872 transportation data. 10960 01:48:58,872 --> 01:49:00,995 the options we came up with, a 10961 01:49:00,995 --> 01:49:00,995 nd 10962 01:49:00,995 --> 01:49:06,476 then our recommendations. 10963 01:49:06,476 --> 01:49:08,896 so that's the title. 10964 01:49:08,896 --> 01:49:11,252 last year on the 29th of may. 10965 01:49:11,252 --> 01:49:14,172 we held a public workshop. 10966 01:49:14,172 --> 01:49:16,180 this was an opportunity for us 10967 01:49:16,180 --> 01:49:16,613 10968 01:49:16,613 --> 01:49:19,212 to present not only the citizens 10969 01:49:19,212 --> 01:49:19,212 10970 01:49:19,212 --> 01:49:21,382 field revitalization plan for 10971 01:49:21,382 --> 01:49:21,382 10972 01:49:21,382 --> 01:49:23,584 the site, but as well as our 10973 01:49:23,584 --> 01:49:24,278 street scapes plan. 10974 01:49:24,278 --> 01:49:27,722 we had about 60 attendees, and 10975 01:49:27,722 --> 01:49:28,124 10976 01:49:28,124 --> 01:49:29,983 we set up stations so that 10977 01:49:29,983 --> 01:49:30,626 residents could come and speak 10978 01:49:30,626 --> 01:49:30,788 10979 01:49:30,788 --> 01:49:32,720 with us, ask us questions and 10980 01:49:32,720 --> 01:49:32,720 10981 01:49:32,720 --> 01:49:33,964 tell us their concerns or thing 10982 01:49:33,964 --> 01:49:33,964 s 10983 01:49:33,964 --> 01:49:37,290 they want to see in their 10984 01:49:37,290 --> 01:49:37,290 neighborhood. 10985 01:49:37,290 --> 01:49:40,298 some feedback we got on that, 10986 01:49:40,298 --> 01:49:40,298 10987 01:49:40,298 --> 01:49:41,806 definitely speed was an issue 10988 01:49:41,806 --> 01:49:41,806 10989 01:49:41,806 --> 01:49:43,677 through some segments of eight 10990 01:49:43,677 --> 01:49:44,035 h 10991 01:49:44,035 --> 01:49:44,035 avenue. 10992 01:49:44,035 --> 01:49:47,908 they wanted bike lanes with the 10993 01:49:47,908 --> 01:49:47,995 10994 01:49:47,995 --> 01:49:50,578 green pavement markings, some 10995 01:49:50,578 --> 01:49:50,578 10996 01:49:50,578 --> 01:49:51,854 enhanced pedestrians crossings, 10997 01:49:51,854 --> 01:49:52,212 10998 01:49:52,212 --> 01:49:54,717 whether that's the raised 10999 01:49:54,717 --> 01:49:56,918 intersections and spied humps o 11000 01:49:56,918 --> 01:49:56,918 r 11001 01:49:56,918 --> 01:49:59,184 flashing beacons and fluorescent 11002 01:49:59,184 --> 01:49:59,184 11003 01:49:59,184 --> 01:49:59,184 signage. 11004 01:49:59,184 --> 01:50:02,991 some landscape medians, 11005 01:50:02,991 --> 01:50:04,422 especially west of waldo. 11006 01:50:04,422 --> 01:50:06,480 some had concerns with the 11007 01:50:06,480 --> 01:50:08,721 median openings along eighth 11008 01:50:08,721 --> 01:50:08,721 avenue. 11009 01:50:08,721 --> 01:50:11,232 and we also requested -- spoke 11010 01:50:11,232 --> 01:50:11,731 11011 01:50:11,731 --> 01:50:14,134 about a pedestrians bridge ove 11012 01:50:14,134 --> 01:50:16,102 r 11013 01:50:16,102 --> 01:50:16,466 waldo road. 11014 01:50:16,466 --> 01:50:18,572 >> good afternoon, chase knigh 11015 01:50:18,572 --> 01:50:19,034 t 11016 01:50:19,034 --> 01:50:22,005 city engineer, based on their 11017 01:50:22,005 --> 01:50:22,005 11018 01:50:22,005 --> 01:50:24,143 review and analysis of the 11019 01:50:24,143 --> 01:50:27,312 corridor, like lana said, and 11020 01:50:27,312 --> 01:50:27,312 11021 01:50:27,312 --> 01:50:29,414 incorporating some of the 11022 01:50:29,414 --> 01:50:30,387 feedback they just spoke about, 11023 01:50:30,387 --> 01:50:30,816 11024 01:50:30,816 --> 01:50:33,424 they came up with options and 11025 01:50:33,424 --> 01:50:33,424 11026 01:50:33,424 --> 01:50:35,816 recommendations, staff 11027 01:50:35,816 --> 01:50:37,060 subsequently took those 11028 01:50:37,060 --> 01:50:39,829 recommended options to provide 11029 01:50:39,829 --> 01:50:44,892 11030 01:50:44,892 --> 01:50:46,035 information and feedback to the 11031 01:50:46,035 --> 01:50:46,194 11032 01:50:46,194 --> 01:50:46,194 community. 11033 01:50:46,194 --> 01:50:48,705 I do apologize, there's a typo 11034 01:50:48,705 --> 01:50:49,216 11035 01:50:49,216 --> 01:50:51,171 on the date for the last one, I 11036 01:50:51,171 --> 01:50:51,171 s 11037 01:50:51,171 --> 01:50:51,171 2026. 11038 01:50:51,171 --> 01:50:55,140 so I'll circle back later on I 11039 01:50:55,140 --> 01:50:55,183 n 11040 01:50:55,183 --> 01:50:56,407 the presentation, after you've 11041 01:50:56,407 --> 01:50:56,407 11042 01:50:56,407 --> 01:50:58,541 had a chance to see those 11043 01:50:58,541 --> 01:50:59,987 recommendations and summarize 11044 01:50:59,987 --> 01:50:59,987 11045 01:50:59,987 --> 01:51:00,984 what the feedback was at these 11046 01:51:00,984 --> 01:51:00,984 11047 01:51:00,984 --> 01:51:00,984 events. 11048 01:51:00,984 --> 01:51:08,991 >> so project overview, where w 11049 01:51:08,991 --> 01:51:08,991 e 11050 01:51:08,991 --> 01:51:11,287 are, what we're doing. 11051 01:51:11,287 --> 01:51:14,764 so part of our citizens field 11052 01:51:14,764 --> 01:51:14,764 11053 01:51:14,764 --> 01:51:15,986 site plan, we were tasked with 11054 01:51:15,986 --> 01:51:17,167 11055 01:51:17,167 --> 01:51:18,732 reviewing the street scapes 11056 01:51:18,732 --> 01:51:20,531 along eighth avenue and waldo 11057 01:51:20,531 --> 01:51:20,531 11058 01:51:20,531 --> 01:51:20,531 road. 11059 01:51:20,531 --> 01:51:22,530 our approach to this was using 11060 01:51:22,530 --> 01:51:23,068 11061 01:51:23,068 --> 01:51:24,105 something called complete 11062 01:51:24,105 --> 01:51:26,069 streets and a multimodal 11063 01:51:26,069 --> 01:51:26,069 approach. 11064 01:51:26,069 --> 01:51:27,703 that's a mouthful. 11065 01:51:27,703 --> 01:51:30,411 this approach focuses on makin 11066 01:51:30,411 --> 01:51:30,679 g 11067 01:51:30,679 --> 01:51:33,813 drive ways -- driving and 11068 01:51:33,813 --> 01:51:35,714 roadways safe for not only 11069 01:51:35,714 --> 01:51:38,023 drivers, but pedestrians, 11070 01:51:38,023 --> 01:51:41,799 cyclists, motorcyclists, and 11071 01:51:41,799 --> 01:51:43,031 even people using public 11072 01:51:43,031 --> 01:51:43,031 transit. 11073 01:51:43,031 --> 01:51:45,595 some examples of street scapes, 11074 01:51:45,595 --> 01:51:46,223 11075 01:51:46,223 --> 01:51:48,623 you'll see those zippers, green 11076 01:51:48,623 --> 01:51:48,763 11077 01:51:48,763 --> 01:51:51,565 bike line markings, adding bik 11078 01:51:51,565 --> 01:51:51,734 e 11079 01:51:51,734 --> 01:51:53,039 lanes, planting trees on 11080 01:51:53,039 --> 01:51:53,407 sidewalks for protection. 11081 01:51:53,407 --> 01:51:56,935 and shade. 11082 01:51:56,935 --> 01:51:59,732 you'll see flashing pedestrians 11083 01:51:59,732 --> 01:52:00,482 11084 01:52:00,482 --> 01:52:00,482 signs. 11085 01:52:00,482 --> 01:52:03,043 updating bus stops with those 11086 01:52:03,043 --> 01:52:03,043 11087 01:52:03,043 --> 01:52:05,885 shelters, so people are more 11088 01:52:05,885 --> 01:52:06,979 comfortable while they're 11089 01:52:06,979 --> 01:52:06,979 waiting. 11090 01:52:06,979 --> 01:52:09,983 we broke up the corridor. 11091 01:52:09,983 --> 01:52:12,619 our focus was really eighth 11092 01:52:12,619 --> 01:52:12,619 avenue. 11093 01:52:12,619 --> 01:52:15,325 that will be west of waldo and 11094 01:52:15,325 --> 01:52:15,655 11095 01:52:15,655 --> 01:52:16,549 east of waldo. 11096 01:52:16,549 --> 01:52:19,683 so west of waldo, we went from 11097 01:52:19,683 --> 01:52:19,683 11098 01:52:19,683 --> 01:52:22,762 the round about on 9th to waldo 11099 01:52:22,762 --> 01:52:23,075 11100 01:52:23,075 --> 01:52:23,075 road. 11101 01:52:23,075 --> 01:52:25,227 we shifted gears east of waldo, 11102 01:52:25,227 --> 01:52:26,027 11103 01:52:26,027 --> 01:52:29,173 we have from waldo road to 11104 01:52:29,173 --> 01:52:30,819 northeast 22nd street, that's 11105 01:52:30,819 --> 01:52:30,819 11106 01:52:30,819 --> 01:52:32,367 where our limits stopped. 11107 01:52:32,367 --> 01:52:34,689 and then city of gainesville 11108 01:52:34,689 --> 01:52:37,089 staff picked up on northeast 11109 01:52:37,089 --> 01:52:39,781 22nd all the way to lofton hig 11110 01:52:39,781 --> 01:52:40,135 h 11111 01:52:40,135 --> 01:52:40,135 school. 11112 01:52:40,135 --> 01:52:42,853 some existing conditions, what' 11113 01:52:42,853 --> 01:52:42,853 s 11114 01:52:42,853 --> 01:52:43,777 out there now. 11115 01:52:43,777 --> 01:52:47,583 west of waldo, you got a curb 11116 01:52:47,583 --> 01:52:47,583 11117 01:52:47,583 --> 01:52:49,525 and gutter section, have you 11118 01:52:49,525 --> 01:52:51,147 landscape medians throughout, 11119 01:52:51,147 --> 01:52:51,147 11120 01:52:51,147 --> 01:52:53,057 with nice planted trees and lef 11121 01:52:53,057 --> 01:52:53,057 t 11122 01:52:53,057 --> 01:52:55,265 turn lane openings, there's a 3 11123 01:52:55,265 --> 01:52:55,265 5 11124 01:52:55,265 --> 01:52:57,991 mile per hour speed limit, the 11125 01:52:57,991 --> 01:52:58,085 11126 01:52:58,085 --> 01:52:59,064 sidewalks are five feet on bot 11127 01:52:59,064 --> 01:52:59,695 h 11128 01:52:59,695 --> 01:53:03,599 sides, there are no bike lanes. 11129 01:53:03,599 --> 01:53:03,599 11130 01:53:03,599 --> 01:53:06,511 east of waldo, so for a segment 11131 01:53:06,511 --> 01:53:06,901 11132 01:53:06,901 --> 01:53:09,980 of it, waldo road to 22nd, hav 11133 01:53:09,980 --> 01:53:10,069 e 11134 01:53:10,069 --> 01:53:11,977 you a 30 mile per hour design 11135 01:53:11,977 --> 01:53:11,977 11136 01:53:11,977 --> 01:53:14,417 speed, it's a little lower, you 11137 01:53:14,417 --> 01:53:15,355 11138 01:53:15,355 --> 01:53:16,521 have five foot sidewalks as 11139 01:53:16,521 --> 01:53:19,317 well, no bike lanes, you have 11140 01:53:19,317 --> 01:53:19,317 11141 01:53:19,317 --> 01:53:21,191 really wide travel lanes, so 11142 01:53:21,191 --> 01:53:23,263 it's about 34 feet of total 11143 01:53:23,263 --> 01:53:27,761 pavement width, so 17 -- 16 1/2 11144 01:53:27,761 --> 01:53:27,897 11145 01:53:27,897 --> 01:53:28,662 foot travel lanes. 11146 01:53:28,662 --> 01:53:30,829 and then the segment that city 11147 01:53:30,829 --> 01:53:31,131 11148 01:53:31,131 --> 01:53:32,197 of gainesville staff worked on 11149 01:53:32,197 --> 01:53:32,897 , 11150 01:53:32,897 --> 01:53:37,835 that was northeast 22nd to 11151 01:53:37,835 --> 01:53:38,765 lofton high school. 11152 01:53:38,765 --> 01:53:40,708 the pavement varies, you have 11153 01:53:40,708 --> 01:53:40,708 11154 01:53:40,708 --> 01:53:43,005 curb and gutter for the first 11155 01:53:43,005 --> 01:53:43,005 11156 01:53:43,005 --> 01:53:45,217 segment, from 22nd street to 11157 01:53:45,217 --> 01:53:48,041 22nd terrace, and then you hav 11158 01:53:48,041 --> 01:53:48,295 e 11159 01:53:48,295 --> 01:53:49,681 those 34 feet of pavement. 11160 01:53:49,681 --> 01:53:52,043 from 22nd terrace to 25th 11161 01:53:52,043 --> 01:53:54,021 street, it narrows down to abo 11162 01:53:54,021 --> 01:53:54,021 ut 11163 01:53:54,021 --> 01:53:55,092 23 feet of pavement. 11164 01:53:55,092 --> 01:53:57,855 and then from 25th to lofton I 11165 01:53:57,855 --> 01:53:58,023 t 11166 01:53:58,023 --> 01:53:59,261 kind of widens a little bit, to 11167 01:53:59,261 --> 01:53:59,261 11168 01:53:59,261 --> 01:53:59,389 a foot. 11169 01:53:59,389 --> 01:54:03,799 also through here, 30 miles per 11170 01:54:03,799 --> 01:54:03,997 11171 01:54:03,997 --> 01:54:06,597 hour, with your five foot 11172 01:54:06,597 --> 01:54:06,597 sidewalk. 11173 01:54:06,597 --> 01:54:09,519 I'm an engineer, I like data t 11174 01:54:09,519 --> 01:54:10,367 o 11175 01:54:10,367 --> 01:54:11,464 inform my design decisions. 11176 01:54:11,464 --> 01:54:13,437 we pulled # some traffic data, 11177 01:54:13,437 --> 01:54:14,176 11178 01:54:14,176 --> 01:54:14,789 looked at how many cars were o 11179 01:54:14,789 --> 01:54:14,789 ut 11180 01:54:14,789 --> 01:54:14,789 there. 11181 01:54:14,789 --> 01:54:20,281 we had counts west of waldo, 11182 01:54:20,281 --> 01:54:22,479 east of waldo, we also had som 11183 01:54:22,479 --> 01:54:23,345 e 11184 01:54:23,345 --> 01:54:25,985 estimated geospatial data that 11185 01:54:25,985 --> 01:54:26,117 11186 01:54:26,117 --> 01:54:27,688 we worked with the traffic gro 11187 01:54:27,688 --> 01:54:27,688 up 11188 01:54:27,688 --> 01:54:29,459 to get those numbers, as you can 11189 01:54:29,459 --> 01:54:29,459 11190 01:54:29,459 --> 01:54:31,929 see for a local road that is 11191 01:54:31,929 --> 01:54:32,659 really truly a neighborhood. 11192 01:54:32,659 --> 01:54:34,559 there is a lot of traffic out 11193 01:54:34,559 --> 01:54:34,559 11194 01:54:34,559 --> 01:54:36,489 there, especially around 11195 01:54:36,489 --> 01:54:38,505 citizens field which was our 11196 01:54:38,505 --> 01:54:39,123 focus area. 11197 01:54:39,123 --> 01:54:41,729 you've got cyclists, so again 11198 01:54:41,729 --> 01:54:41,729 11199 01:54:41,729 --> 01:54:43,734 our focus area was around 11200 01:54:43,734 --> 01:54:44,939 citizens field, you have block 11201 01:54:44,939 --> 01:54:45,937 s 11202 01:54:45,937 --> 01:54:47,672 right there on eighth avenue 11203 01:54:47,672 --> 01:54:49,239 west of waldo, a lot of bikes, 11204 01:54:49,239 --> 01:54:49,840 a 11205 01:54:49,840 --> 01:54:53,245 lot of pedestrians going throu 11206 01:54:53,245 --> 01:54:53,245 gh 11207 01:54:53,245 --> 01:54:53,245 there. 11208 01:54:53,245 --> 01:54:55,749 like I mentioned, 35 miles per 11209 01:54:55,749 --> 01:54:56,016 11210 01:54:56,016 --> 01:54:59,556 hour west of waldo, 35 miles p 11211 01:54:59,556 --> 01:54:59,556 er 11212 01:54:59,556 --> 01:55:00,481 hour east of waldo. 11213 01:55:00,481 --> 01:55:03,185 you can see west of waldo, 11214 01:55:03,185 --> 01:55:07,020 people pretty go at 32.5 miles 11215 01:55:07,020 --> 01:55:07,112 11216 01:55:07,112 --> 01:55:08,157 an hour, they're following the 11217 01:55:08,157 --> 01:55:08,325 11218 01:55:08,325 --> 01:55:08,596 speed limit. 11219 01:55:08,596 --> 01:55:11,834 east of waldo is where we 11220 01:55:11,834 --> 01:55:14,027 noticed -- we start to see an 11221 01:55:14,027 --> 01:55:14,027 11222 01:55:14,027 --> 01:55:15,600 uptick in speed, they're going 11223 01:55:15,600 --> 01:55:15,828 11224 01:55:15,828 --> 01:55:16,763 about 38 miles per hour. 11225 01:55:16,763 --> 01:55:19,040 and then the city of gainesvil 11226 01:55:19,040 --> 01:55:19,040 le 11227 01:55:19,040 --> 01:55:26,110 segment, which is 22nd to 11228 01:55:26,110 --> 01:55:28,666 loften, it drops to 26, what 11229 01:55:28,666 --> 01:55:29,428 people are driving out there 11230 01:55:29,428 --> 01:55:29,711 where it narrows. 11231 01:55:29,711 --> 01:55:36,184 my least favorite part of the 11232 01:55:36,184 --> 01:55:36,184 11233 01:55:36,184 --> 01:55:37,719 data is the crash history, so w 11234 01:55:37,719 --> 01:55:37,719 e 11235 01:55:37,719 --> 01:55:40,634 did a five-year crash analysis. 11236 01:55:40,634 --> 01:55:40,634 11237 01:55:40,634 --> 01:55:44,640 this is from january 2020 to 11238 01:55:44,640 --> 01:55:45,230 december 24. 11239 01:55:45,230 --> 01:55:48,507 75 crashes, which may not seem 11240 01:55:48,507 --> 01:55:48,670 11241 01:55:48,670 --> 01:55:50,434 like a lot in five years, but I 11242 01:55:50,434 --> 01:55:50,434 t 11243 01:55:50,434 --> 01:55:50,434 is. 11244 01:55:50,434 --> 01:55:52,480 you're going through a local 11245 01:55:52,480 --> 01:55:53,268 road, a neighborhood. 11246 01:55:53,268 --> 01:55:56,742 that's about one crash a month. 11247 01:55:56,742 --> 01:55:56,742 11248 01:55:56,742 --> 01:55:59,124 there were no fatalities which 11249 01:55:59,124 --> 01:55:59,272 11250 01:55:59,272 --> 01:56:00,706 was great, but there were four 11251 01:56:00,706 --> 01:56:00,706 11252 01:56:00,706 --> 01:56:02,510 that resulted in a serious 11253 01:56:02,510 --> 01:56:05,248 injury, and six that included 11254 01:56:05,248 --> 01:56:05,248 11255 01:56:05,248 --> 01:56:07,420 bicyclists, pedestrians or 11256 01:56:07,420 --> 01:56:07,420 motorcycles. 11257 01:56:07,420 --> 01:56:09,262 ultimately our goal is to make 11258 01:56:09,262 --> 01:56:09,554 11259 01:56:09,554 --> 01:56:11,522 the streets safe, especially f 11260 01:56:11,522 --> 01:56:11,522 or 11261 01:56:11,522 --> 01:56:13,852 vulnerable users like 11262 01:56:13,852 --> 01:56:14,251 pedestrians and cyclists. 11263 01:56:14,251 --> 01:56:17,848 so using this data, we came up 11264 01:56:17,848 --> 01:56:17,948 11265 01:56:17,948 --> 01:56:18,164 with some options. 11266 01:56:18,164 --> 01:56:25,276 our first option here, this is 11267 01:56:25,276 --> 01:56:25,572 11268 01:56:25,572 --> 01:56:27,536 going to be west of waldo road. 11269 01:56:27,536 --> 01:56:27,536 11270 01:56:27,536 --> 01:56:30,876 the curb and gutter position 11271 01:56:30,876 --> 01:56:31,640 with the medians. 11272 01:56:31,640 --> 01:56:34,294 we're proposing maintaining the 11273 01:56:34,294 --> 01:56:35,114 11274 01:56:35,114 --> 01:56:36,487 existing curbline, maybe 11275 01:56:36,487 --> 01:56:37,846 enhancing them a little bit. 11276 01:56:37,846 --> 01:56:41,158 but we'd like to say let's add 11277 01:56:41,158 --> 01:56:41,658 a 11278 01:56:41,658 --> 01:56:44,124 10-foot shared use path on the 11279 01:56:44,124 --> 01:56:44,354 11280 01:56:44,354 --> 01:56:45,494 north side of the road, and kee 11281 01:56:45,494 --> 01:56:45,494 p 11282 01:56:45,494 --> 01:56:47,191 the existing sidewalk on the 11283 01:56:47,191 --> 01:56:47,191 other. 11284 01:56:47,191 --> 01:56:52,026 this gives an option for maybe 11285 01:56:52,026 --> 01:56:53,760 11286 01:56:53,760 --> 01:56:54,835 cyclists like maybe families o 11287 01:56:54,835 --> 01:56:55,402 n 11288 01:56:55,402 --> 01:56:56,892 bikes that don't necessarily 11289 01:56:56,892 --> 01:56:58,242 feel comfortable riding on the 11290 01:56:58,242 --> 01:56:58,570 11291 01:56:58,570 --> 01:56:58,570 road. 11292 01:56:58,570 --> 01:57:01,486 this makes room for two-way 11293 01:57:01,486 --> 01:57:02,846 traffic on bikes, and it reall 11294 01:57:02,846 --> 01:57:03,272 y 11295 01:57:03,272 --> 01:57:05,003 makes it a gateway to citizens 11296 01:57:05,003 --> 01:57:05,336 11297 01:57:05,336 --> 01:57:05,336 field. 11298 01:57:05,336 --> 01:57:07,640 total estimated cost for just 11299 01:57:07,640 --> 01:57:07,640 11300 01:57:07,640 --> 01:57:09,184 the resurfacing, and restriping 11301 01:57:09,184 --> 01:57:09,184 , 11302 01:57:09,184 --> 01:57:12,114 no path, came out to about 11303 01:57:12,114 --> 01:57:12,114 $900,000. 11304 01:57:12,114 --> 01:57:14,718 and to add the path on the nor 11305 01:57:14,718 --> 01:57:14,718 th 11306 01:57:14,718 --> 01:57:18,356 was an additional 800,000. 11307 01:57:18,356 --> 01:57:22,492 option 2 for west of waldo, thi 11308 01:57:22,492 --> 01:57:22,492 s 11309 01:57:22,492 --> 01:57:24,236 is complete redesign of the 11310 01:57:24,236 --> 01:57:26,096 typical section, you have your 11311 01:57:26,096 --> 01:57:26,362 11312 01:57:26,362 --> 01:57:27,504 curb and gutter section, you'r 11313 01:57:27,504 --> 01:57:28,362 e 11314 01:57:28,362 --> 01:57:29,933 taking out those land scape 11315 01:57:29,933 --> 01:57:32,230 medians and putting in bike 11316 01:57:32,230 --> 01:57:32,230 lanes. 11317 01:57:32,230 --> 01:57:34,190 you would have to reconstruct 11318 01:57:34,190 --> 01:57:34,190 11319 01:57:34,190 --> 01:57:36,774 the road under the medians, you 11320 01:57:36,774 --> 01:57:36,968 11321 01:57:36,968 --> 01:57:37,606 would add striping. 11322 01:57:37,606 --> 01:57:39,944 we do like the idea of the 11323 01:57:39,944 --> 01:57:41,348 protected bike lanes, whether 11324 01:57:41,348 --> 01:57:41,348 11325 01:57:41,348 --> 01:57:42,776 that's with zippers or striping, 11326 01:57:42,776 --> 01:57:42,776 11327 01:57:42,776 --> 01:57:45,386 and particularly using that 11328 01:57:45,386 --> 01:57:46,594 green pavement marking. 11329 01:57:46,594 --> 01:57:49,600 that bike lane would be 4 1/2 11330 01:57:49,600 --> 01:57:49,600 11331 01:57:49,600 --> 01:57:49,600 feet. 11332 01:57:49,600 --> 01:57:52,624 and we would propose that share 11333 01:57:52,624 --> 01:57:52,624 d 11334 01:57:52,624 --> 01:57:53,096 use path. 11335 01:57:53,096 --> 01:57:55,422 total cost without the path 11336 01:57:55,422 --> 01:57:58,266 would be 1.6 million. 11337 01:57:58,266 --> 01:58:00,708 with the path with be an 11338 01:58:00,708 --> 01:58:01,048 additional 100,000. 11339 01:58:01,048 --> 01:58:03,676 now we're shifting gears, we're 11340 01:58:03,676 --> 01:58:03,939 11341 01:58:03,939 --> 01:58:07,808 on the other side of waldo roa 11342 01:58:07,808 --> 01:58:08,004 d 11343 01:58:08,004 --> 01:58:08,004 now. 11344 01:58:08,004 --> 01:58:13,280 still a curb and gutter section 11345 01:58:13,280 --> 01:58:13,502 11346 01:58:13,502 --> 01:58:14,138 with the stripings. 11347 01:58:14,138 --> 01:58:17,282 we're going to restripe it to 11348 01:58:17,282 --> 01:58:17,282 11349 01:58:17,282 --> 01:58:19,090 add the protected bike lanes 11350 01:58:19,090 --> 01:58:20,618 with the zippers and potential 11351 01:58:20,618 --> 01:58:20,618 ly 11352 01:58:20,618 --> 01:58:23,355 add a shared use path on the 11353 01:58:23,355 --> 01:58:25,084 north or south side of the road 11354 01:58:25,084 --> 01:58:25,084 . 11355 01:58:25,084 --> 01:58:27,158 currently there's no shared use 11356 01:58:27,158 --> 01:58:27,486 11357 01:58:27,486 --> 01:58:29,588 path, it's just sidewalks. 11358 01:58:29,588 --> 01:58:31,328 so some challenges with that. 11359 01:58:31,328 --> 01:58:34,436 right now on this portion of 11360 01:58:34,436 --> 01:58:37,104 eighth, we have really mature, 11361 01:58:37,104 --> 01:58:37,432 11362 01:58:37,432 --> 01:58:38,934 beautiful large trees on the 11363 01:58:38,934 --> 01:58:39,608 north side of the road. 11364 01:58:39,608 --> 01:58:41,742 and on the south side of the 11365 01:58:41,742 --> 01:58:43,712 road, you have a lot of overhe 11366 01:58:43,712 --> 01:58:43,712 ad 11367 01:58:43,712 --> 01:58:48,213 utilities, so if you were to 11368 01:58:48,213 --> 01:58:49,782 just do the path -- if you were 11369 01:58:49,782 --> 01:58:49,974 11370 01:58:49,974 --> 01:58:51,754 just to do the road, resurface 11371 01:58:51,754 --> 01:58:51,952 11372 01:58:51,952 --> 01:58:54,422 the road, restripe it and add 11373 01:58:54,422 --> 01:58:54,422 11374 01:58:54,422 --> 01:58:56,492 the bike lanes, that would be 11375 01:58:56,492 --> 01:58:56,492 11376 01:58:56,492 --> 01:58:57,100 1.9 million. 11377 01:58:57,100 --> 01:58:59,420 for the traffic calming, you 11378 01:58:59,420 --> 01:59:00,662 have your raised intersections 11379 01:59:00,662 --> 01:59:00,915 11380 01:59:00,915 --> 01:59:02,938 and enhanced crosswalks, that 11381 01:59:02,938 --> 01:59:02,938 11382 01:59:02,938 --> 01:59:04,768 would be an additional 1.7 11383 01:59:04,768 --> 01:59:04,768 million. 11384 01:59:04,768 --> 01:59:07,514 if you were to take out those 11385 01:59:07,514 --> 01:59:07,514 11386 01:59:07,514 --> 01:59:08,995 trees which add a lot of 11387 01:59:08,995 --> 01:59:09,964 character to the neighborhood. 11388 01:59:09,964 --> 01:59:09,964 11389 01:59:09,964 --> 01:59:11,478 add shading and protection to 11390 01:59:11,478 --> 01:59:11,478 11391 01:59:11,478 --> 01:59:12,426 the sidewalk, that's going to 11392 01:59:12,426 --> 01:59:12,426 be 11393 01:59:12,426 --> 01:59:15,340 an additional 1.3 million. 11394 01:59:15,340 --> 01:59:17,414 on the other side, in order to 11395 01:59:17,414 --> 01:59:17,658 11396 01:59:17,658 --> 01:59:19,028 underground the utilities, add 11397 01:59:19,028 --> 01:59:19,604 11398 01:59:19,604 --> 01:59:21,339 lighting and add other 11399 01:59:21,339 --> 01:59:22,810 utilities, that would be an 11400 01:59:22,810 --> 01:59:23,374 additional $3 million. 11401 01:59:23,374 --> 01:59:25,562 some of these, you start to -- 11402 01:59:25,562 --> 01:59:25,758 I 11403 01:59:25,758 --> 01:59:27,750 tried to make it modular, so w 11404 01:59:27,750 --> 01:59:27,886 e 11405 01:59:27,886 --> 01:59:31,488 could look at it in sections. 11406 01:59:31,488 --> 01:59:34,523 here's option two. 11407 01:59:34,523 --> 01:59:37,222 we would still maintain the 11408 01:59:37,222 --> 01:59:37,844 existing curbline. 11409 01:59:37,844 --> 01:59:39,858 we don't want to widen the road 11410 01:59:39,858 --> 01:59:39,858 , 11411 01:59:39,858 --> 01:59:41,635 there's not a lot of room out 11412 01:59:41,635 --> 01:59:41,635 11413 01:59:41,635 --> 01:59:41,635 there. 11414 01:59:41,635 --> 01:59:43,944 we don't want to reconstruct 11415 01:59:43,944 --> 01:59:43,944 things. 11416 01:59:43,944 --> 01:59:46,202 we're trying to use what we 11417 01:59:46,202 --> 01:59:46,202 have. 11418 01:59:46,202 --> 01:59:48,836 here we're proposing two new 11419 01:59:48,836 --> 01:59:50,276 landscape medians, there's onl 11420 01:59:50,276 --> 01:59:50,506 y 11421 01:59:50,506 --> 01:59:51,714 two locations along the projec 11422 01:59:51,714 --> 01:59:51,714 t. 11423 01:59:51,714 --> 01:59:54,244 I have a slide later so becan 11424 01:59:54,244 --> 01:59:54,244 11425 01:59:54,244 --> 01:59:55,420 talk about the openings. 11426 01:59:55,420 --> 01:59:56,893 there's only two locations whe 11427 01:59:56,893 --> 01:59:56,893 re 11428 01:59:56,893 --> 01:59:59,183 we can add some landscape 11429 01:59:59,183 --> 02:00:00,622 medians and a center turn lane 11430 02:00:00,622 --> 02:00:00,622 . 11431 02:00:00,622 --> 02:00:02,988 we can add a shared use path o 11432 02:00:02,988 --> 02:00:03,220 n 11433 02:00:03,220 --> 02:00:04,919 the north, south or no path at 11434 02:00:04,919 --> 02:00:05,320 11435 02:00:05,320 --> 02:00:05,320 all. 11436 02:00:05,320 --> 02:00:07,955 that breakdown kind of 11437 02:00:07,955 --> 02:00:08,856 discussing those mature trees, 11438 02:00:08,856 --> 02:00:09,257 11439 02:00:09,257 --> 02:00:11,256 the utilities and how that's 11440 02:00:11,256 --> 02:00:11,769 broken down with the additional 11441 02:00:11,769 --> 02:00:11,950 11442 02:00:11,950 --> 02:00:11,950 cost 11443 02:00:11,950 --> 02:00:19,200 so northeast 22nd. 11444 02:00:19,200 --> 02:00:22,272 waldo to northeast 22nd, we hav 11445 02:00:22,272 --> 02:00:22,272 e 11446 02:00:22,272 --> 02:00:23,710 our proposed option 3. 11447 02:00:23,710 --> 02:00:24,534 this is everything. 11448 02:00:24,534 --> 02:00:27,470 how do we go through and add 11449 02:00:27,470 --> 02:00:28,086 everything we can. 11450 02:00:28,086 --> 02:00:32,950 we started with maintaining the 11451 02:00:32,950 --> 02:00:33,382 11452 02:00:33,382 --> 02:00:33,737 existing sidewalks. 11453 02:00:33,737 --> 02:00:37,616 providing two more narrow 11454 02:00:37,616 --> 02:00:39,220 medians, it wouldn't necessarily 11455 02:00:39,220 --> 02:00:39,220 11456 02:00:39,220 --> 02:00:41,124 meet that turn lane width, it 11457 02:00:41,124 --> 02:00:41,124 11458 02:00:41,124 --> 02:00:42,455 would be a little more narrow. 11459 02:00:42,455 --> 02:00:42,455 11460 02:00:42,455 --> 02:00:44,292 and then you have -- you would 11461 02:00:44,292 --> 02:00:44,822 11462 02:00:44,822 --> 02:00:46,128 utilize the curb and gutter to 11463 02:00:46,128 --> 02:00:46,662 11464 02:00:46,662 --> 02:00:48,567 get a five foot bike lane, and 11465 02:00:48,567 --> 02:00:48,694 11466 02:00:48,694 --> 02:00:50,432 the travel lanes would be more 11467 02:00:50,432 --> 02:00:51,164 11468 02:00:51,164 --> 02:00:52,867 narrow, 10 feet instead of 11 11469 02:00:52,867 --> 02:00:52,867 11470 02:00:52,867 --> 02:00:54,580 feet, like on the other side o 11471 02:00:54,580 --> 02:00:55,473 f 11472 02:00:55,473 --> 02:00:55,928 waldo road. 11473 02:00:55,928 --> 02:01:00,026 same thing here, we broke it 11474 02:01:00,026 --> 02:01:00,026 down. 11475 02:01:00,026 --> 02:01:01,914 without the path, that would b 11476 02:01:01,914 --> 02:01:02,296 e 11477 02:01:02,296 --> 02:01:04,914 2.1 million, to add in those 11478 02:01:04,914 --> 02:01:07,452 landscape medians, add in those 11479 02:01:07,452 --> 02:01:07,610 11480 02:01:07,610 --> 02:01:08,486 raised intersections, and 11481 02:01:08,486 --> 02:01:09,850 whether we put the path on the 11482 02:01:09,850 --> 02:01:09,982 11483 02:01:09,982 --> 02:01:11,019 north or south, or whether we 11484 02:01:11,019 --> 02:01:11,019 11485 02:01:11,019 --> 02:01:11,302 don't at all. 11486 02:01:11,302 --> 02:01:14,188 so this was that breakdown I w 11487 02:01:14,188 --> 02:01:14,188 as 11488 02:01:14,188 --> 02:01:17,458 talking about earlier with the 11489 02:01:17,458 --> 02:01:18,530 11490 02:01:18,530 --> 02:01:20,632 median openings, so when we 11491 02:01:20,632 --> 02:01:22,298 looked at the -- all the drive 11492 02:01:22,298 --> 02:01:22,435 11493 02:01:22,435 --> 02:01:24,638 way entrances and side street 11494 02:01:24,638 --> 02:01:24,638 11495 02:01:24,638 --> 02:01:25,834 entrances, you can see there's 11496 02:01:25,834 --> 02:01:26,006 a 11497 02:01:26,006 --> 02:01:27,570 ton along that road. 11498 02:01:27,570 --> 02:01:30,510 it's a lot of -- there's not a 11499 02:01:30,510 --> 02:01:30,778 11500 02:01:30,778 --> 02:01:32,576 lot of opportunity to put in n 11501 02:01:32,576 --> 02:01:32,576 ew 11502 02:01:32,576 --> 02:01:35,138 medians without blocking 11503 02:01:35,138 --> 02:01:37,214 someone's access, and our goal 11504 02:01:37,214 --> 02:01:37,354 11505 02:01:37,354 --> 02:01:39,178 was to not impact any access for 11506 02:01:39,178 --> 02:01:39,178 11507 02:01:39,178 --> 02:01:41,122 homes, churches, businesses, 11508 02:01:41,122 --> 02:01:49,086 anything along this road. 11509 02:01:49,086 --> 02:01:51,880 >> it looks like we may have a 11510 02:01:51,880 --> 02:01:52,022 11511 02:01:52,022 --> 02:01:53,250 little formatting issue here. 11512 02:01:53,250 --> 02:01:55,096 I apologize for that. 11513 02:01:55,096 --> 02:01:59,004 these next three slides really 11514 02:01:59,004 --> 02:01:59,432 11515 02:01:59,432 --> 02:02:02,272 represent one overall option 11516 02:02:02,272 --> 02:02:03,276 broken into three mini-segment 11517 02:02:03,276 --> 02:02:03,276 s. 11518 02:02:03,276 --> 02:02:06,714 overall, we're looking at 11519 02:02:06,714 --> 02:02:08,638 northeast 22nd street to the 11520 02:02:08,638 --> 02:02:09,776 school property line or the end 11521 02:02:09,776 --> 02:02:09,874 11522 02:02:09,874 --> 02:02:11,746 of the road, as I call it. 11523 02:02:11,746 --> 02:02:14,402 so that total estimated cost I 11524 02:02:14,402 --> 02:02:14,746 s 11525 02:02:14,746 --> 02:02:17,090 $2.1 million, so that 11526 02:02:17,090 --> 02:02:18,400 encompasses all three here, not 11527 02:02:18,400 --> 02:02:18,634 11528 02:02:18,634 --> 02:02:20,316 each slide that we're looking 11529 02:02:20,316 --> 02:02:20,316 11530 02:02:20,316 --> 02:02:20,316 at. 11531 02:02:20,316 --> 02:02:23,556 the first portion here continu 11532 02:02:23,556 --> 02:02:23,556 es 11533 02:02:23,556 --> 02:02:27,094 from northeast 22nd street to 11534 02:02:27,094 --> 02:02:27,094 11535 02:02:27,094 --> 02:02:30,262 22nd terrace, where there is t 11536 02:02:30,262 --> 02:02:30,262 he 11537 02:02:30,262 --> 02:02:32,732 section that continues from tha 11538 02:02:32,732 --> 02:02:32,732 t 11539 02:02:32,732 --> 02:02:34,618 previous section. 11540 02:02:34,618 --> 02:02:36,770 really, this one would just be 11541 02:02:36,770 --> 02:02:37,172 11542 02:02:37,172 --> 02:02:39,347 matching the proposed option 11543 02:02:39,347 --> 02:02:41,446 one, and continuing the 11544 02:02:41,446 --> 02:02:43,444 protected bike lanes, through 11545 02:02:43,444 --> 02:02:43,444 11546 02:02:43,444 --> 02:02:44,920 the end of the curb section at 11547 02:02:44,920 --> 02:02:44,920 11548 02:02:44,920 --> 02:02:45,912 22nd terrace. 11549 02:02:45,912 --> 02:02:50,060 once we get past 22nd terrace, 11550 02:02:50,060 --> 02:02:51,127 11551 02:02:51,127 --> 02:02:53,232 we move into a narrower, overal 11552 02:02:53,232 --> 02:02:53,232 l 11553 02:02:53,232 --> 02:02:55,826 narrower pavement with no curb 11554 02:02:55,826 --> 02:02:55,992 11555 02:02:55,992 --> 02:02:56,892 and gutter. 11556 02:02:56,892 --> 02:03:01,602 and the proposal here is to kee 11557 02:03:01,602 --> 02:03:01,602 11558 02:03:01,602 --> 02:03:03,760 that pavement and add a multiu 11559 02:03:03,760 --> 02:03:03,760 se 11560 02:03:03,760 --> 02:03:09,402 path on the north side of the 11561 02:03:09,402 --> 02:03:09,402 11562 02:03:09,402 --> 02:03:09,402 road. 11563 02:03:09,402 --> 02:03:11,816 as we move past northeast 25th 11564 02:03:11,816 --> 02:03:12,408 11565 02:03:12,408 --> 02:03:13,810 street, going toward the end o 11566 02:03:13,810 --> 02:03:13,854 f 11567 02:03:13,854 --> 02:03:18,614 the road, similarly, the 11568 02:03:18,614 --> 02:03:20,344 pavement would remain in 11569 02:03:20,344 --> 02:03:22,011 existence, and be resurfaced. 11570 02:03:22,011 --> 02:03:27,358 and then the ten foot multiuse 11571 02:03:27,358 --> 02:03:27,864 11572 02:03:27,864 --> 02:03:29,997 path would switch over to the 11573 02:03:29,997 --> 02:03:29,997 11574 02:03:29,997 --> 02:03:33,510 south side of the road due to 11575 02:03:33,510 --> 02:03:33,510 11576 02:03:33,510 --> 02:03:36,631 the alignment of the ditch which 11577 02:03:36,631 --> 02:03:36,631 11578 02:03:36,631 --> 02:03:38,255 is part of the creek system on 11579 02:03:38,255 --> 02:03:38,255 11580 02:03:38,255 --> 02:03:38,726 the north side of the roadway. 11581 02:03:38,726 --> 02:03:38,726 11582 02:03:38,726 --> 02:03:48,482 >> based on all that, we have 11583 02:03:48,482 --> 02:03:48,482 11584 02:03:48,482 --> 02:03:53,119 our proposed recommendations, s 11585 02:03:53,119 --> 02:03:53,119 o 11586 02:03:53,119 --> 02:03:55,820 we propose option 1 for west o 11587 02:03:55,820 --> 02:03:56,288 f 11588 02:03:56,288 --> 02:03:58,182 waldo, so this would be 11589 02:03:58,182 --> 02:03:59,888 maintaining that existing 11590 02:03:59,888 --> 02:04:01,190 curbline in the landscape 11591 02:04:01,190 --> 02:04:04,369 medians, and adding a 10-foot 11592 02:04:04,369 --> 02:04:04,369 11593 02:04:04,369 --> 02:04:05,698 shared use path on the north 11594 02:04:05,698 --> 02:04:08,140 side of the road and keep the 11595 02:04:08,140 --> 02:04:08,140 11596 02:04:08,140 --> 02:04:08,948 existing sidewalk on the other. 11597 02:04:08,948 --> 02:04:08,948 11598 02:04:08,948 --> 02:04:12,430 this will be a total existing 11599 02:04:12,430 --> 02:04:12,430 11600 02:04:12,430 --> 02:04:15,804 cost of 1.7 million. 11601 02:04:15,804 --> 02:04:19,408 for waldo road to 27th street, 11602 02:04:19,408 --> 02:04:19,912 11603 02:04:19,912 --> 02:04:24,077 we recommend maintaining 11604 02:04:24,077 --> 02:04:26,725 existing curbline and we do not 11605 02:04:26,725 --> 02:04:27,076 11606 02:04:27,076 --> 02:04:29,383 propose put youing in a shared 11607 02:04:29,383 --> 02:04:29,765 11608 02:04:29,765 --> 02:04:31,492 use path because of those trees 11609 02:04:31,492 --> 02:04:31,653 11610 02:04:31,653 --> 02:04:32,896 and overhead utilities. 11611 02:04:32,896 --> 02:04:35,023 that would come to an estimated 11612 02:04:35,023 --> 02:04:35,336 11613 02:04:35,336 --> 02:04:36,558 cost of 3.6 million. 11614 02:04:36,558 --> 02:04:40,323 >> going back to the section 11615 02:04:40,323 --> 02:04:42,866 east of 22nd street to the 11616 02:04:42,866 --> 02:04:45,863 school to losten school, the 11617 02:04:45,863 --> 02:04:48,305 property line, that is the sam 11618 02:04:48,305 --> 02:04:48,738 e 11619 02:04:48,738 --> 02:04:50,011 recommended option broken into 11620 02:04:50,011 --> 02:04:50,410 11621 02:04:50,410 --> 02:04:52,407 the three sections at a total 11622 02:04:52,407 --> 02:04:52,407 11623 02:04:52,407 --> 02:04:56,993 cost of 2.1 million. 11624 02:04:56,993 --> 02:04:58,986 >> some other recommendations 11625 02:04:58,986 --> 02:04:58,986 11626 02:04:58,986 --> 02:05:00,248 are some pedestrians 11627 02:05:00,248 --> 02:05:02,652 improvements, especially at som 11628 02:05:02,652 --> 02:05:02,652 e 11629 02:05:02,652 --> 02:05:04,000 mid block crossings. 11630 02:05:04,000 --> 02:05:06,116 >> mayor: commissioner duncan 11631 02:05:06,116 --> 02:05:06,116 11632 02:05:06,116 --> 02:05:07,691 walker, did you want to ask now 11633 02:05:07,691 --> 02:05:07,691 11634 02:05:07,691 --> 02:05:08,088 or later? 11635 02:05:08,088 --> 02:05:09,169 >> no. 11636 02:05:09,169 --> 02:05:09,785 >> mayor: go ahead. 11637 02:05:09,785 --> 02:05:13,056 >> some examples of that are 11638 02:05:13,056 --> 02:05:16,325 going to be your rectangular 11639 02:05:16,325 --> 02:05:18,154 flashing beacons. 11640 02:05:18,154 --> 02:05:20,482 your fluorescent crosswalksign 11641 02:05:20,482 --> 02:05:20,482 s 11642 02:05:20,482 --> 02:05:26,244 with flashing beacons. 11643 02:05:26,244 --> 02:05:27,972 they flash, people stop, you can 11644 02:05:27,972 --> 02:05:27,972 11645 02:05:27,972 --> 02:05:27,972 cross. 11646 02:05:27,972 --> 02:05:35,918 we're suggesting raised median 11647 02:05:35,918 --> 02:05:35,918 s. 11648 02:05:35,918 --> 02:05:38,561 it provides extra safety for 11649 02:05:38,561 --> 02:05:40,058 pedestrians, and traffic calmi 11650 02:05:40,058 --> 02:05:40,058 ng 11651 02:05:40,058 --> 02:05:41,919 for those people that are 11652 02:05:41,919 --> 02:05:41,919 speeding. 11653 02:05:41,919 --> 02:05:47,862 >> there are two designs alrea 11654 02:05:47,862 --> 02:05:47,862 dy 11655 02:05:47,862 --> 02:05:49,912 in progress, at northeast 11th 11656 02:05:49,912 --> 02:05:51,436 11657 02:05:51,436 --> 02:05:53,770 terrace, and in between 13th a 11658 02:05:53,770 --> 02:05:53,770 nd 11659 02:05:53,770 --> 02:05:56,153 14th which is right around 11660 02:05:56,153 --> 02:06:00,337 citizens field and the fire 11661 02:06:00,337 --> 02:06:00,847 station location. 11662 02:06:00,847 --> 02:06:04,206 east of waldo road, we have a 11663 02:06:04,206 --> 02:06:04,206 11664 02:06:04,206 --> 02:06:05,408 couple mid block crossings, 11665 02:06:05,408 --> 02:06:07,211 which will be your rapid 11666 02:06:07,211 --> 02:06:08,784 flashing beacons, and we have a 11667 02:06:08,784 --> 02:06:09,247 11668 02:06:09,247 --> 02:06:10,083 couple raised intersections. 11669 02:06:10,083 --> 02:06:16,691 this would be at 15th, 17th 11670 02:06:16,691 --> 02:06:18,131 street, 19th terrace, which wil 11671 02:06:18,131 --> 02:06:18,131 l 11672 02:06:18,131 --> 02:06:19,629 be a raised intersection. 11673 02:06:19,629 --> 02:06:21,331 and 22nd street, which be a 11674 02:06:21,331 --> 02:06:21,592 raised intersection. 11675 02:06:21,592 --> 02:06:26,534 and then two mid block 11676 02:06:26,534 --> 02:06:27,740 crossings, which already exist 11677 02:06:27,740 --> 02:06:28,145 11678 02:06:28,145 --> 02:06:31,472 would be your rapid beacons. 11679 02:06:31,472 --> 02:06:34,585 we also coordinated with rts t 11680 02:06:34,585 --> 02:06:34,881 o 11681 02:06:34,881 --> 02:06:36,618 see if they were doing any 11682 02:06:36,618 --> 02:06:37,382 improvements through here based 11683 02:06:37,382 --> 02:06:37,646 11684 02:06:37,646 --> 02:06:38,825 on ridership. 11685 02:06:38,825 --> 02:06:41,581 they are planning ada 11686 02:06:41,581 --> 02:06:44,161 improvements at six bus stops o 11687 02:06:44,161 --> 02:06:44,161 n 11688 02:06:44,161 --> 02:06:45,963 eighth avenue, these costs wer 11689 02:06:45,963 --> 02:06:46,115 e 11690 02:06:46,115 --> 02:06:47,951 not included add part of our 11691 02:06:47,951 --> 02:06:47,951 scope. 11692 02:06:47,951 --> 02:06:51,167 they are also doing an 11693 02:06:51,167 --> 02:06:51,967 improvement to the mid block 11694 02:06:51,967 --> 02:06:52,326 crossing at waldo road. 11695 02:06:52,326 --> 02:06:59,635 >> so we've looked at the 11696 02:06:59,635 --> 02:07:01,399 recommended options and what 11697 02:07:01,399 --> 02:07:05,637 this slide does is total those 11698 02:07:05,637 --> 02:07:06,345 11699 02:07:06,345 --> 02:07:08,014 recommendations for the portion 11700 02:07:08,014 --> 02:07:08,195 11701 02:07:08,195 --> 02:07:13,511 between waldo road and loften 11702 02:07:13,511 --> 02:07:13,511 11703 02:07:13,511 --> 02:07:13,511 school. 11704 02:07:13,511 --> 02:07:15,482 that estimate is $5.7 million, 11705 02:07:15,482 --> 02:07:15,827 11706 02:07:15,827 --> 02:07:17,686 that would be the resurfacing 11707 02:07:17,686 --> 02:07:17,686 11708 02:07:17,686 --> 02:07:20,725 project, plus the recommended 11709 02:07:20,725 --> 02:07:20,725 11710 02:07:20,725 --> 02:07:22,923 improvements that we are 11711 02:07:22,923 --> 02:07:23,833 proposing to move forward with 11712 02:07:23,833 --> 02:07:23,833 . 11713 02:07:23,833 --> 02:07:26,395 and as promised, I wanted to g 11714 02:07:26,395 --> 02:07:26,529 o 11715 02:07:26,529 --> 02:07:28,826 back to this slide while I 11716 02:07:28,826 --> 02:07:30,081 discuss some of the feedback 11717 02:07:30,081 --> 02:07:31,677 that we got on the recommended 11718 02:07:31,677 --> 02:07:34,197 11719 02:07:34,197 --> 02:07:34,197 options. 11720 02:07:34,197 --> 02:07:36,209 so first was discussion on 11721 02:07:36,209 --> 02:07:36,209 speeding. 11722 02:07:36,209 --> 02:07:38,437 there were neighbors present a 11723 02:07:38,437 --> 02:07:39,639 t 11724 02:07:39,639 --> 02:07:41,381 the meetings that didn't 11725 02:07:41,381 --> 02:07:42,041 necessarily feel that speeding 11726 02:07:42,041 --> 02:07:42,309 11727 02:07:42,309 --> 02:07:42,838 was a concern. 11728 02:07:42,838 --> 02:07:45,544 we did reiterate the data that 11729 02:07:45,544 --> 02:07:45,813 11730 02:07:45,813 --> 02:07:49,349 we have, that shows that there 11731 02:07:49,349 --> 02:07:49,483 11732 02:07:49,483 --> 02:07:51,451 is an increase speed along tha 11733 02:07:51,451 --> 02:07:51,585 t 11734 02:07:51,585 --> 02:07:53,825 section of the roadway. 11735 02:07:53,825 --> 02:07:55,560 there was also concern about t 11736 02:07:55,560 --> 02:07:55,560 he 11737 02:07:55,560 --> 02:07:59,572 installation of the raised 11738 02:07:59,572 --> 02:08:01,363 intersection, traffic calming 11739 02:08:01,363 --> 02:08:01,363 11740 02:08:01,363 --> 02:08:02,713 measures, and we did provide t 11741 02:08:02,713 --> 02:08:02,713 he 11742 02:08:02,713 --> 02:08:05,441 examples of -- and provide the 11743 02:08:05,441 --> 02:08:06,167 11744 02:08:06,167 --> 02:08:07,563 clarification that these aren' 11745 02:08:07,563 --> 02:08:07,768 t 11746 02:08:07,768 --> 02:08:09,743 the speed humps, but they're 11747 02:08:09,743 --> 02:08:11,911 raised intersections, which are 11748 02:08:11,911 --> 02:08:13,619 11749 02:08:13,619 --> 02:08:15,271 more gentle than what you 11750 02:08:15,271 --> 02:08:16,813 experienced driving over a spe 11751 02:08:16,813 --> 02:08:16,813 ed 11752 02:08:16,813 --> 02:08:18,959 bump or a speed hump. 11753 02:08:18,959 --> 02:08:23,491 the second discussion was 11754 02:08:23,491 --> 02:08:24,347 surrounding the bike lanes. 11755 02:08:24,347 --> 02:08:25,719 there were neighbors concerned 11756 02:08:25,719 --> 02:08:25,924 11757 02:08:25,924 --> 02:08:28,156 about the installation of 11758 02:08:28,156 --> 02:08:31,459 zippers, and staff did express 11759 02:08:31,459 --> 02:08:32,838 11760 02:08:32,838 --> 02:08:33,865 that during the design phase. 11761 02:08:33,865 --> 02:08:36,303 if we do more forward with the 11762 02:08:36,303 --> 02:08:36,963 11763 02:08:36,963 --> 02:08:40,641 zippers, the placement of the 11764 02:08:40,641 --> 02:08:40,641 11765 02:08:40,641 --> 02:08:43,781 zippers would be thoroughly 11766 02:08:43,781 --> 02:08:44,519 thought out in consideration o 11767 02:08:44,519 --> 02:08:44,637 f 11768 02:08:44,637 --> 02:08:45,703 drive ways and access points. 11769 02:08:45,703 --> 02:08:49,621 and turning radius. 11770 02:08:49,621 --> 02:08:55,409 third there was a discussion o 11771 02:08:55,409 --> 02:08:55,848 n 11772 02:08:55,848 --> 02:08:55,848 trees. 11773 02:08:55,848 --> 02:08:58,850 there were neighbors concerned 11774 02:08:58,850 --> 02:08:59,169 11775 02:08:59,169 --> 02:09:00,883 about trees causing damage to 11776 02:09:00,883 --> 02:09:00,883 11777 02:09:00,883 --> 02:09:03,353 the roadway, and falling 11778 02:09:03,353 --> 02:09:04,929 branches, and we did express 11779 02:09:04,929 --> 02:09:07,637 that would be a consideration 11780 02:09:07,637 --> 02:09:07,637 11781 02:09:07,637 --> 02:09:08,227 during the design phase. 11782 02:09:08,227 --> 02:09:10,681 we could evaluate trees and see 11783 02:09:10,681 --> 02:09:10,759 11784 02:09:10,759 --> 02:09:12,182 if any of that would need to be 11785 02:09:12,182 --> 02:09:13,073 11786 02:09:13,073 --> 02:09:13,776 removed, and potentially 11787 02:09:13,776 --> 02:09:13,776 replanted. 11788 02:09:13,776 --> 02:09:18,567 and then there were drainage 11789 02:09:18,567 --> 02:09:19,919 concerns in some specific area 11790 02:09:19,919 --> 02:09:19,919 s, 11791 02:09:19,919 --> 02:09:21,849 and again those are items that 11792 02:09:21,849 --> 02:09:21,972 11793 02:09:21,972 --> 02:09:23,577 we would definitely be able to 11794 02:09:23,577 --> 02:09:24,283 11795 02:09:24,283 --> 02:09:25,346 review during the design phase 11796 02:09:25,346 --> 02:09:25,647 11797 02:09:25,647 --> 02:09:27,769 and look at ways to mitigate 11798 02:09:27,769 --> 02:09:27,977 those concerns. 11799 02:09:27,977 --> 02:09:40,462 >> I just want to add a few mor 11800 02:09:40,462 --> 02:09:40,462 e 11801 02:09:40,462 --> 02:09:40,462 things. 11802 02:09:40,462 --> 02:09:42,929 there were some concerns about 11803 02:09:42,929 --> 02:09:43,063 11804 02:09:43,063 --> 02:09:46,701 the usage of the road through 11805 02:09:46,701 --> 02:09:46,701 11806 02:09:46,701 --> 02:09:48,100 the corridor and in are a lot o 11807 02:09:48,100 --> 02:09:48,100 f 11808 02:09:48,100 --> 02:09:49,610 churches along that stretch of 11809 02:09:49,610 --> 02:09:49,804 11810 02:09:49,804 --> 02:09:51,537 road, that utilize the roadway 11811 02:09:51,537 --> 02:09:51,707 11812 02:09:51,707 --> 02:09:54,513 for funerals, church events, 11813 02:09:54,513 --> 02:09:55,945 things like that, that was one 11814 02:09:55,945 --> 02:09:56,109 11815 02:09:56,109 --> 02:09:57,173 of the asks from the community. 11816 02:09:57,173 --> 02:09:57,173 11817 02:09:57,173 --> 02:09:59,011 I know we're going to set up a 11818 02:09:59,011 --> 02:09:59,175 11819 02:09:59,175 --> 02:10:01,224 second meeting with a couple o 11820 02:10:01,224 --> 02:10:01,267 f 11821 02:10:01,267 --> 02:10:03,146 the different pastors to talk 11822 02:10:03,146 --> 02:10:03,146 11823 02:10:03,146 --> 02:10:05,017 about how they generally have 11824 02:10:05,017 --> 02:10:05,017 11825 02:10:05,017 --> 02:10:06,853 events, and where people park, 11826 02:10:06,853 --> 02:10:07,585 11827 02:10:07,585 --> 02:10:09,265 because with cycle lanes, you 11828 02:10:09,265 --> 02:10:09,265 11829 02:10:09,265 --> 02:10:11,933 know, obviously there may be 11830 02:10:11,933 --> 02:10:14,262 somewhat of a, do we need to 11831 02:10:14,262 --> 02:10:18,179 move people off on to a path o 11832 02:10:18,179 --> 02:10:18,501 r 11833 02:10:18,501 --> 02:10:18,501 sidewalk. 11834 02:10:18,501 --> 02:10:20,767 we're going to be paying 11835 02:10:20,767 --> 02:10:22,465 particular attention to and 11836 02:10:22,465 --> 02:10:23,680 visiting some of the usages of 11837 02:10:23,680 --> 02:10:23,680 11838 02:10:23,680 --> 02:10:24,078 the road. 11839 02:10:24,078 --> 02:10:27,143 we do have some more meetings 11840 02:10:27,143 --> 02:10:27,143 11841 02:10:27,143 --> 02:10:30,073 that we have promised to set u 11842 02:10:30,073 --> 02:10:30,341 p 11843 02:10:30,341 --> 02:10:34,151 to get with folks about what 11844 02:10:34,151 --> 02:10:35,915 they see, because as chase 11845 02:10:35,915 --> 02:10:37,069 mentioned, there's a differenc 11846 02:10:37,069 --> 02:10:37,245 e 11847 02:10:37,245 --> 02:10:38,961 of opinion on speeding. 11848 02:10:38,961 --> 02:10:41,159 there were some drainage 11849 02:10:41,159 --> 02:10:42,493 concerns that we can address, 11850 02:10:42,493 --> 02:10:42,493 11851 02:10:42,493 --> 02:10:44,255 based on what I saw with my 11852 02:10:44,255 --> 02:10:46,281 initial assessment. 11853 02:10:46,281 --> 02:10:49,063 and just overall usages, bike 11854 02:10:49,063 --> 02:10:49,063 11855 02:10:49,063 --> 02:10:49,063 pass. 11856 02:10:49,063 --> 02:10:52,427 the general consensus on the 11857 02:10:52,427 --> 02:10:52,783 bike pass. 11858 02:10:52,783 --> 02:10:55,201 a lot of folks weren't sure if 11859 02:10:55,201 --> 02:10:55,663 11860 02:10:55,663 --> 02:10:57,205 folks would use a cycle lane, I 11861 02:10:57,205 --> 02:10:57,205 f 11862 02:10:57,205 --> 02:10:59,438 you don't have one, there's not 11863 02:10:59,438 --> 02:10:59,675 11864 02:10:59,675 --> 02:11:00,774 an opportunity for that, there 11865 02:11:00,774 --> 02:11:00,774 's 11866 02:11:00,774 --> 02:11:02,411 only the sidewalk, the zippers 11867 02:11:02,411 --> 02:11:02,673 11868 02:11:02,673 --> 02:11:03,549 were the big concern. 11869 02:11:03,549 --> 02:11:06,513 that was a big note for them. 11870 02:11:06,513 --> 02:11:08,657 a big note for a lot of folks. 11871 02:11:08,657 --> 02:11:08,657 11872 02:11:08,657 --> 02:11:12,391 I think there's -- there's no 11873 02:11:12,391 --> 02:11:12,391 11874 02:11:12,391 --> 02:11:13,219 design that's been done. 11875 02:11:13,219 --> 02:11:16,192 there's no survey, we just nee 11876 02:11:16,192 --> 02:11:16,192 d 11877 02:11:16,192 --> 02:11:17,817 the general direction of, we're 11878 02:11:17,817 --> 02:11:18,359 11879 02:11:18,359 --> 02:11:19,923 resurfacing the road with the 11880 02:11:19,923 --> 02:11:19,923 11881 02:11:19,923 --> 02:11:23,109 comp plan and edcm engineering 11882 02:11:23,109 --> 02:11:23,340 11883 02:11:23,340 --> 02:11:25,039 design and construction manual 11884 02:11:25,039 --> 02:11:25,265 , 11885 02:11:25,265 --> 02:11:27,235 we are required to consider 11886 02:11:27,235 --> 02:11:29,007 multimodal facilities, that's 11887 02:11:29,007 --> 02:11:29,007 11888 02:11:29,007 --> 02:11:30,065 prt of our overall requirement, 11889 02:11:30,065 --> 02:11:30,065 11890 02:11:30,065 --> 02:11:31,640 which is one of the reasons why 11891 02:11:31,640 --> 02:11:31,805 11892 02:11:31,805 --> 02:11:32,905 you're seeing the bike lanes 11893 02:11:32,905 --> 02:11:32,905 proposed. 11894 02:11:32,905 --> 02:11:42,301 the last thing I wanteto 11895 02:11:42,301 --> 02:11:42,813 mention was, there are medians 11896 02:11:42,813 --> 02:11:42,955 11897 02:11:42,955 --> 02:11:43,539 on the west side of waldo, and 11898 02:11:43,539 --> 02:11:43,583 11899 02:11:43,583 --> 02:11:47,485 that was at that community's 11900 02:11:47,485 --> 02:11:47,485 request. 11901 02:11:47,485 --> 02:11:49,458 I think I may have covered all 11902 02:11:49,458 --> 02:11:49,699 11903 02:11:49,699 --> 02:11:49,699 that. 11904 02:11:49,699 --> 02:11:50,927 and you guys can move on to th 11905 02:11:50,927 --> 02:11:50,973 e 11906 02:11:50,973 --> 02:11:51,176 next slide. 11907 02:11:51,176 --> 02:12:03,607 >> so the recommendation at han 11908 02:12:03,607 --> 02:12:03,607 d 11909 02:12:03,607 --> 02:12:05,471 is the city commission 11910 02:12:05,471 --> 02:12:07,109 authorized the city manager to 11911 02:12:07,109 --> 02:12:07,277 11912 02:12:07,277 --> 02:12:09,381 proceed with the design and 11913 02:12:09,381 --> 02:12:11,083 permitting of the northeast 11914 02:12:11,083 --> 02:12:13,013 eighth avenue project from wal 11915 02:12:13,013 --> 02:12:13,013 do 11916 02:12:13,013 --> 02:12:16,043 road to the western property 11917 02:12:16,043 --> 02:12:18,755 line of loften high school, and 11918 02:12:18,755 --> 02:12:19,053 11919 02:12:19,053 --> 02:12:20,335 return to the city commission 11920 02:12:20,335 --> 02:12:20,335 11921 02:12:20,335 --> 02:12:21,685 with a construction agreement 11922 02:12:21,685 --> 02:12:21,685 11923 02:12:21,685 --> 02:12:26,189 for the northeast eighth avenu 11924 02:12:26,189 --> 02:12:26,361 e 11925 02:12:26,361 --> 02:12:27,929 construction project to the 11926 02:12:27,929 --> 02:12:28,831 property line of the loften hig 11927 02:12:28,831 --> 02:12:28,831 h 11928 02:12:28,831 --> 02:12:28,831 school. 11929 02:12:28,831 --> 02:12:30,109 >> mayor: okay. 11930 02:12:30,109 --> 02:12:31,011 thank you. 11931 02:12:31,011 --> 02:12:34,247 commissioner duncan walker. 11932 02:12:34,247 --> 02:12:36,105 >> thank you, mr. Mayor, and 11933 02:12:36,105 --> 02:12:37,471 thank you, staff for that 11934 02:12:37,471 --> 02:12:37,471 presentation. 11935 02:12:37,471 --> 02:12:42,283 I have a couple questions to 11936 02:12:42,283 --> 02:12:42,807 begin with. 11937 02:12:42,807 --> 02:12:45,441 I'll be very forthcoming in 11938 02:12:45,441 --> 02:12:46,951 saying I'm interested in hearing 11939 02:12:46,951 --> 02:12:46,951 11940 02:12:46,951 --> 02:12:47,855 what the community members who 11941 02:12:47,855 --> 02:12:48,115 11942 02:12:48,115 --> 02:12:50,051 have shown up here today have t 11943 02:12:50,051 --> 02:12:50,051 o 11944 02:12:50,051 --> 02:12:50,051 say. 11945 02:12:50,051 --> 02:12:52,553 because what has become clear 11946 02:12:52,553 --> 02:12:52,553 11947 02:12:52,553 --> 02:12:54,151 is, they have not had an 11948 02:12:54,151 --> 02:12:55,853 opportunity to weigh-in on his. 11949 02:12:55,853 --> 02:12:55,853 11950 02:12:55,853 --> 02:12:57,980 my first question is, what types 11951 02:12:57,980 --> 02:12:57,980 11952 02:12:57,980 --> 02:12:59,503 of notices did you all send ou 11953 02:12:59,503 --> 02:12:59,547 t 11954 02:12:59,547 --> 02:12:59,791 to the community? 11955 02:12:59,791 --> 02:13:07,501 >> for the public workshop? 11956 02:13:07,501 --> 02:13:09,778 >> any types of notices that 11957 02:13:09,778 --> 02:13:11,606 would have let anyone who's 11958 02:13:11,606 --> 02:13:13,133 impacted by this project know 11959 02:13:13,133 --> 02:13:13,133 11960 02:13:13,133 --> 02:13:13,421 what you're proposing. 11961 02:13:13,421 --> 02:13:18,140 >> I can't speak for the may 11962 02:13:18,140 --> 02:13:20,178 2025 one, but in terms of the 11963 02:13:20,178 --> 02:13:20,178 11964 02:13:20,178 --> 02:13:23,183 most recent event, so we first 11965 02:13:23,183 --> 02:13:23,447 11966 02:13:23,447 --> 02:13:25,017 heard about some concerns with 11967 02:13:25,017 --> 02:13:25,615 11968 02:13:25,615 --> 02:13:26,453 northeast eighth back in 11969 02:13:26,453 --> 02:13:28,123 december at one of our greater 11970 02:13:28,123 --> 02:13:28,417 11971 02:13:28,417 --> 02:13:30,887 duvall meetings, public works 11972 02:13:30,887 --> 02:13:30,887 11973 02:13:30,887 --> 02:13:33,166 does participate in a monthly 11974 02:13:33,166 --> 02:13:33,166 11975 02:13:33,166 --> 02:13:34,661 meeting on the second monday o 11976 02:13:34,661 --> 02:13:35,457 f 11977 02:13:35,457 --> 02:13:37,395 every month from 12:00 to 1:00 11978 02:13:37,395 --> 02:13:37,871 , 11979 02:13:37,871 --> 02:13:39,531 it's just a free come and go, 11980 02:13:39,531 --> 02:13:39,531 11981 02:13:39,531 --> 02:13:41,067 and we chat with whoever's 11982 02:13:41,067 --> 02:13:42,401 there, and find out what their 11983 02:13:42,401 --> 02:13:43,237 11984 02:13:43,237 --> 02:13:43,869 concerns are. 11985 02:13:43,869 --> 02:13:46,469 there's also a greater duvall 11986 02:13:46,469 --> 02:13:46,469 11987 02:13:46,469 --> 02:13:47,109 neighborhood association meeti 11988 02:13:47,109 --> 02:13:47,109 ng 11989 02:13:47,109 --> 02:13:49,379 on the 3rd monday night of eve 11990 02:13:49,379 --> 02:13:49,379 ry 11991 02:13:49,379 --> 02:13:53,681 month and we participate in 11992 02:13:53,681 --> 02:13:53,681 that. 11993 02:13:53,681 --> 02:13:54,583 we had been talking with all 11994 02:13:54,583 --> 02:13:56,009 those folks who attended. 11995 02:13:56,009 --> 02:13:57,348 we were going to have a 11996 02:13:57,348 --> 02:14:01,291 particular meeting, and that w 11997 02:14:01,291 --> 02:14:01,291 as 11998 02:14:01,291 --> 02:14:04,429 three mondays ago -- maybe thr 11999 02:14:04,429 --> 02:14:04,429 ee 12000 02:14:04,429 --> 02:14:04,699 mondays ago. 12001 02:14:04,699 --> 02:14:10,563 we went ahead -- and had a 12002 02:14:10,563 --> 02:14:11,009 meeting on march 25th. 12003 02:14:11,009 --> 02:14:14,363 we did not send out flyers or 12004 02:14:14,363 --> 02:14:14,363 12005 02:14:14,363 --> 02:14:15,501 anything like that we sent out 12006 02:14:15,501 --> 02:14:16,067 12007 02:14:16,067 --> 02:14:20,201 emails tough the greater 12008 02:14:20,201 --> 02:14:20,549 duvall exchange. 12009 02:14:20,549 --> 02:14:23,041 we have more work to do with 12010 02:14:23,041 --> 02:14:23,787 communication and meeting with 12011 02:14:23,787 --> 02:14:23,979 12012 02:14:23,979 --> 02:14:25,944 people, and a lot of it has bee 12013 02:14:25,944 --> 02:14:25,944 n 12014 02:14:25,944 --> 02:14:26,643 word of mouth. 12015 02:14:26,643 --> 02:14:28,567 >> so let me -- in the interest 12016 02:14:28,567 --> 02:14:28,808 12017 02:14:28,808 --> 02:14:31,453 of saving a little bit of time 12018 02:14:31,453 --> 02:14:31,917 12019 02:14:31,917 --> 02:14:33,117 and being very forthright. 12020 02:14:33,117 --> 02:14:35,921 I did share this with you, tha 12021 02:14:35,921 --> 02:14:36,469 t 12022 02:14:36,469 --> 02:14:38,889 is a hot button issue and a 12023 02:14:38,889 --> 02:14:39,487 problem for me. 12024 02:14:39,487 --> 02:14:41,627 right now, one of the reasons 12025 02:14:41,627 --> 02:14:41,627 12026 02:14:41,627 --> 02:14:43,629 that this room is full of peopl 12027 02:14:43,629 --> 02:14:43,629 e 12028 02:14:43,629 --> 02:14:46,241 from east gainesville, and I 12029 02:14:46,241 --> 02:14:47,335 believe a few are also 12030 02:14:47,335 --> 02:14:49,389 downstairs, is because they 12031 02:14:49,389 --> 02:14:50,449 received no notification. 12032 02:14:50,449 --> 02:14:53,317 I'm looking at at least four 12033 02:14:53,317 --> 02:14:55,177 people that live directly on 12034 02:14:55,177 --> 02:14:56,981 northeast 8th avenue west of 12035 02:14:56,981 --> 02:14:59,849 waldo road, who received no 12036 02:14:59,849 --> 02:14:59,849 notification. 12037 02:14:59,849 --> 02:15:02,753 I know the duncans received no 12038 02:15:02,753 --> 02:15:03,083 12039 02:15:03,083 --> 02:15:05,141 notification, I know my next 12040 02:15:05,141 --> 02:15:06,471 door neighbor received no 12041 02:15:06,471 --> 02:15:06,471 notification. 12042 02:15:06,471 --> 02:15:09,753 you hear from this commission 12043 02:15:09,753 --> 02:15:09,753 12044 02:15:09,753 --> 02:15:10,622 just about every commission 12045 02:15:10,622 --> 02:15:12,267 meeting now, when we have these 12046 02:15:12,267 --> 02:15:12,555 12047 02:15:12,555 --> 02:15:14,964 major projects, that 12048 02:15:14,964 --> 02:15:17,701 notification is something that 12049 02:15:17,701 --> 02:15:18,205 the communi 12050 02:15:18,205 --> 02:15:19,727 the community expects, and 12051 02:15:19,727 --> 02:15:20,728 something that we expect. 12052 02:15:20,728 --> 02:15:24,337 I'm not prepared to make any 12053 02:15:24,337 --> 02:15:25,431 kind of decision today on those 12054 02:15:25,431 --> 02:15:25,772 12055 02:15:25,772 --> 02:15:26,205 grounds alone. 12056 02:15:26,205 --> 02:15:29,975 at the end of the day, we've n 12057 02:15:29,975 --> 02:15:29,975 ot 12058 02:15:29,975 --> 02:15:32,645 had the opportunity to engage 12059 02:15:32,645 --> 02:15:32,645 12060 02:15:32,645 --> 02:15:33,814 with the people in the way tha 12061 02:15:33,814 --> 02:15:34,232 t 12062 02:15:34,232 --> 02:15:37,685 we have said we are going to. 12063 02:15:37,685 --> 02:15:39,693 and frankly, we can take a loo 12064 02:15:39,693 --> 02:15:39,951 k 12065 02:15:39,951 --> 02:15:41,717 at what a lot of people have 12066 02:15:41,717 --> 02:15:45,161 serious issues with on northwest 12067 02:15:45,161 --> 02:15:45,161 12068 02:15:45,161 --> 02:15:46,760 eighth avenue, and see why the 12069 02:15:46,760 --> 02:15:46,760 re 12070 02:15:46,760 --> 02:15:47,921 are a lot of concerns. 12071 02:15:47,921 --> 02:15:51,234 I call it the 3c's, what 12072 02:15:51,234 --> 02:15:53,477 happened with northwest 8th 12073 02:15:53,477 --> 02:15:54,897 avenue, that's brought about 12074 02:15:54,897 --> 02:15:58,745 contention, confusion and 12075 02:15:58,745 --> 02:15:58,745 congestion. 12076 02:15:58,745 --> 02:16:02,141 and the individuals on the 12077 02:16:02,141 --> 02:16:03,745 eastside of waldo road and 12078 02:16:03,745 --> 02:16:04,871 probably a little bit before 12079 02:16:04,871 --> 02:16:06,379 that, but certainly, I've had a 12080 02:16:06,379 --> 02:16:06,781 12081 02:16:06,781 --> 02:16:08,283 chance to hear from the 12082 02:16:08,283 --> 02:16:09,749 individuals on the eastside of 12083 02:16:09,749 --> 02:16:10,321 12084 02:16:10,321 --> 02:16:11,997 waldo road who do not want to 12085 02:16:11,997 --> 02:16:11,997 12086 02:16:11,997 --> 02:16:13,413 see that happen, but you have 12087 02:16:13,413 --> 02:16:13,413 12088 02:16:13,413 --> 02:16:14,551 not engaged with them. 12089 02:16:14,551 --> 02:16:17,227 so you cannot properly provide 12090 02:16:17,227 --> 02:16:17,421 12091 02:16:17,421 --> 02:16:19,137 this commission with any type o 12092 02:16:19,137 --> 02:16:19,137 f 12093 02:16:19,137 --> 02:16:19,795 information regarding that. 12094 02:16:19,795 --> 02:16:21,694 I understand there were some 12095 02:16:21,694 --> 02:16:23,169 meetings that were convened, I 12096 02:16:23,169 --> 02:16:23,169 'm 12097 02:16:23,169 --> 02:16:24,263 glad you went to them. 12098 02:16:24,263 --> 02:16:27,173 but a lot of the people in thi 12099 02:16:27,173 --> 02:16:27,264 s 12100 02:16:27,264 --> 02:16:28,634 room, don't go to those 12101 02:16:28,634 --> 02:16:28,634 meetings. 12102 02:16:28,634 --> 02:16:30,477 there are people in this room 12103 02:16:30,477 --> 02:16:30,477 12104 02:16:30,477 --> 02:16:33,565 who didn't receive the emails. 12105 02:16:33,565 --> 02:16:33,565 12106 02:16:33,565 --> 02:16:35,919 so I am suggesting that until a 12107 02:16:35,919 --> 02:16:36,314 12108 02:16:36,314 --> 02:16:40,145 much more robust community 12109 02:16:40,145 --> 02:16:41,749 engagement experience is had, 12110 02:16:41,749 --> 02:16:43,845 this commission is not in 12111 02:16:43,845 --> 02:16:47,992 anyway prepared to have this 12112 02:16:47,992 --> 02:16:47,992 discussion. 12113 02:16:47,992 --> 02:16:50,661 I have engaged with a number o 12114 02:16:50,661 --> 02:16:50,791 f 12115 02:16:50,791 --> 02:16:52,793 people who are using multimodal 12116 02:16:52,793 --> 02:16:53,531 12117 02:16:53,531 --> 02:16:53,531 transport. 12118 02:16:53,531 --> 02:16:56,122 some of them want bike lanes, 12119 02:16:56,122 --> 02:16:56,122 12120 02:16:56,122 --> 02:16:57,524 and some of them don't for a 12121 02:16:57,524 --> 02:16:58,741 number of reasons. 12122 02:16:58,741 --> 02:17:02,665 but you won't know that unless 12123 02:17:02,665 --> 02:17:03,066 12124 02:17:03,066 --> 02:17:04,173 the table is prepared for them 12125 02:17:04,173 --> 02:17:04,369 12126 02:17:04,369 --> 02:17:05,185 to come sit with us, and have 12127 02:17:05,185 --> 02:17:05,185 12128 02:17:05,185 --> 02:17:05,397 that conversation. 12129 02:17:05,397 --> 02:17:13,641 I'm going to conclude for now, 12130 02:17:13,641 --> 02:17:14,231 12131 02:17:14,231 --> 02:17:15,181 because I'm very interested in 12132 02:17:15,181 --> 02:17:15,381 12133 02:17:15,381 --> 02:17:16,689 hearing what the people who cam 12134 02:17:16,689 --> 02:17:16,689 e 12135 02:17:16,689 --> 02:17:18,491 to speak to this issue have to 12136 02:17:18,491 --> 02:17:18,683 12137 02:17:18,683 --> 02:17:18,683 say. 12138 02:17:18,683 --> 02:17:21,587 I want to hear what my 12139 02:17:21,587 --> 02:17:22,549 colleagues have to say. 12140 02:17:22,549 --> 02:17:24,328 but I'm a little more intereste 12141 02:17:24,328 --> 02:17:24,328 d 12142 02:17:24,328 --> 02:17:26,987 in hearing from them today, 12143 02:17:26,987 --> 02:17:29,161 because they've been cheated o 12144 02:17:29,161 --> 02:17:29,161 ut 12145 02:17:29,161 --> 02:17:31,605 of an opportunity to speak. 12146 02:17:31,605 --> 02:17:34,937 I'm not interests in a decision, 12147 02:17:34,937 --> 02:17:34,937 12148 02:17:34,937 --> 02:17:36,771 I'm interested in a conversatio 12149 02:17:36,771 --> 02:17:36,771 n 12150 02:17:36,771 --> 02:17:40,639 today that will lead to the 12151 02:17:40,639 --> 02:17:42,273 broader discussion that is rea 12152 02:17:42,273 --> 02:17:42,537 l 12153 02:17:42,537 --> 02:17:45,817 community engagement, and 12154 02:17:45,817 --> 02:17:47,421 frankly that I'll probably put 12155 02:17:47,421 --> 02:17:47,509 12156 02:17:47,509 --> 02:17:49,029 out there, it will probably be 12157 02:17:49,029 --> 02:17:49,188 a 12158 02:17:49,188 --> 02:17:50,679 meeting that I'll convene. 12159 02:17:50,679 --> 02:17:52,955 I'm going to stop talking, mr. 12160 02:17:52,955 --> 02:17:53,348 12161 02:17:53,348 --> 02:17:54,287 mayor, for now. 12162 02:17:54,287 --> 02:17:56,452 I'm happy to hear from my 12163 02:17:56,452 --> 02:17:58,939 colleagues, and I'm certainly 12164 02:17:58,939 --> 02:17:58,939 12165 02:17:58,939 --> 02:18:00,661 happy to hear from the 12166 02:18:00,661 --> 02:18:00,661 community. 12167 02:18:00,661 --> 02:18:01,937 I'm sorry this has been the 12168 02:18:01,937 --> 02:18:01,937 experience. 12169 02:18:01,937 --> 02:18:04,099 this is is what we said we would 12170 02:18:04,099 --> 02:18:04,099 12171 02:18:04,099 --> 02:18:06,927 not do, and I do have this 12172 02:18:06,927 --> 02:18:11,011 question, before I release wit 12173 02:18:11,011 --> 02:18:11,165 h 12174 02:18:11,165 --> 02:18:11,600 my comments. 12175 02:18:11,600 --> 02:18:14,163 did we in anyway engage with the 12176 02:18:14,163 --> 02:18:14,163 12177 02:18:14,163 --> 02:18:16,275 office of governmental 12178 02:18:16,275 --> 02:18:17,113 affairs -- government relations 12179 02:18:17,113 --> 02:18:17,339 12180 02:18:17,339 --> 02:18:18,457 and community affairs, I believe 12181 02:18:18,457 --> 02:18:18,457 12182 02:18:18,457 --> 02:18:21,424 it is, aren't they now a part o 12183 02:18:21,424 --> 02:18:21,424 f 12184 02:18:21,424 --> 02:18:22,213 our process? 12185 02:18:22,213 --> 02:18:24,413 did we engage with them? 12186 02:18:24,413 --> 02:18:25,951 >> they were at the same 12187 02:18:25,951 --> 02:18:26,351 meetings as us, yes. 12188 02:18:26,351 --> 02:18:29,791 >> no, did we engage with them 12189 02:18:29,791 --> 02:18:30,017 12190 02:18:30,017 --> 02:18:30,825 to ask them -- 12191 02:18:30,825 --> 02:18:33,022 >> not to coordinate any 12192 02:18:33,022 --> 02:18:33,623 additional meetings. 12193 02:18:33,623 --> 02:18:35,355 >> correct. 12194 02:18:35,355 --> 02:18:38,027 andrew, let me ask you this 12195 02:18:38,027 --> 02:18:38,027 question. 12196 02:18:38,027 --> 02:18:42,645 help me understand what our 12197 02:18:42,645 --> 02:18:43,345 community engagement process I 12198 02:18:43,345 --> 02:18:43,571 s 12199 02:18:43,571 --> 02:18:44,117 now with that office? 12200 02:18:44,117 --> 02:18:48,185 >> yes, to your point, we are 12201 02:18:48,185 --> 02:18:48,185 12202 02:18:48,185 --> 02:18:50,948 working on a community 12203 02:18:50,948 --> 02:18:51,672 engagement guide going-forward, 12204 02:18:51,672 --> 02:18:52,627 12205 02:18:52,627 --> 02:18:53,579 that's still in draft form, we 12206 02:18:53,579 --> 02:18:53,691 12207 02:18:53,691 --> 02:18:55,785 will be finalizing it,ing and 12208 02:18:55,785 --> 02:18:55,785 12209 02:18:55,785 --> 02:18:57,054 sending it on to the commission 12210 02:18:57,054 --> 02:18:57,054 . 12211 02:18:57,054 --> 02:18:59,650 it talks about how the 12212 02:18:59,650 --> 02:19:04,527 departments do engagement with 12213 02:19:04,527 --> 02:19:05,087 12214 02:19:05,087 --> 02:19:06,230 my office through the governmen 12215 02:19:06,230 --> 02:19:06,230 t 12216 02:19:06,230 --> 02:19:08,227 affairs community relations 12217 02:19:08,227 --> 02:19:08,227 team. 12218 02:19:08,227 --> 02:19:10,529 I do want to -- I think gail m 12219 02:19:10,529 --> 02:19:10,529 ay 12220 02:19:10,529 --> 02:19:13,265 have touched on this, but I 12221 02:19:13,265 --> 02:19:14,933 do -- miss mowry may have 12222 02:19:14,933 --> 02:19:18,209 touched on this, this was 12223 02:19:18,209 --> 02:19:19,671 originally part of that -- the 12224 02:19:19,671 --> 02:19:19,898 12225 02:19:19,898 --> 02:19:21,777 overall 8th and waldo process. 12226 02:19:21,777 --> 02:19:21,777 12227 02:19:21,777 --> 02:19:25,279 the overall engagement. 12228 02:19:25,279 --> 02:19:28,225 during that process, there had 12229 02:19:28,225 --> 02:19:28,549 12230 02:19:28,549 --> 02:19:32,995 been, I think programmed an 12231 02:19:32,995 --> 02:19:34,257 engagement workshop just about 12232 02:19:34,257 --> 02:19:34,458 12233 02:19:34,458 --> 02:19:35,320 the street scapes. 12234 02:19:35,320 --> 02:19:37,123 but because of all the changes 12235 02:19:37,123 --> 02:19:37,304 12236 02:19:37,304 --> 02:19:40,155 that we went through with the 12237 02:19:40,155 --> 02:19:40,155 12238 02:19:40,155 --> 02:19:45,427 scope and changing the design, 12239 02:19:45,427 --> 02:19:45,995 12240 02:19:45,995 --> 02:19:48,799 the streetscape portion got 12241 02:19:48,799 --> 02:19:51,082 broken out as a separate 12242 02:19:51,082 --> 02:19:52,833 project, and it didn't have a 12243 02:19:52,833 --> 02:19:52,833 12244 02:19:52,833 --> 02:19:54,578 specific engage thamt was part 12245 02:19:54,578 --> 02:19:54,711 12246 02:19:54,711 --> 02:19:56,093 of the original scope with the 12247 02:19:56,093 --> 02:19:56,306 12248 02:19:56,306 --> 02:19:59,243 eighth and waldo overall 12249 02:19:59,243 --> 02:19:59,243 project. 12250 02:19:59,243 --> 02:20:02,821 I do want to mention a couple 12251 02:20:02,821 --> 02:20:02,821 12252 02:20:02,821 --> 02:20:04,351 things that I think are -- wou 12253 02:20:04,351 --> 02:20:04,351 ld 12254 02:20:04,351 --> 02:20:06,217 probably be relevant now. 12255 02:20:06,217 --> 02:20:09,717 this is still very early on. 12256 02:20:09,717 --> 02:20:14,099 so I think the -- to your poin 12257 02:20:14,099 --> 02:20:14,099 t, 12258 02:20:14,099 --> 02:20:20,369 if there's -- I know staff has 12259 02:20:20,369 --> 02:20:20,601 12260 02:20:20,601 --> 02:20:22,140 already had additional engage a 12261 02:20:22,140 --> 02:20:22,140 m 12262 02:20:22,140 --> 02:20:23,664 coming up with community. 12263 02:20:23,664 --> 02:20:30,508 certainly, if the commission 12264 02:20:30,508 --> 02:20:31,913 provides that direction and 12265 02:20:31,913 --> 02:20:34,089 decides to delay any sort of 12266 02:20:34,089 --> 02:20:36,846 design vote, that's certainly 12267 02:20:36,846 --> 02:20:36,846 12268 02:20:36,846 --> 02:20:39,513 the commission's prerogative, 12269 02:20:39,513 --> 02:20:39,513 12270 02:20:39,513 --> 02:20:40,433 and we would understand that. 12271 02:20:40,433 --> 02:20:42,286 importantly too, I do not 12272 02:20:42,286 --> 02:20:44,485 believe we actually have 12273 02:20:44,485 --> 02:20:45,298 construction funding lined up 12274 02:20:45,298 --> 02:20:45,298 12275 02:20:45,298 --> 02:20:46,026 for any of this. 12276 02:20:46,026 --> 02:20:48,165 right now, all we're talking 12277 02:20:48,165 --> 02:20:50,658 about is the $500,000 roughly 12278 02:20:50,658 --> 02:20:50,658 12279 02:20:50,658 --> 02:20:50,958 for design. 12280 02:20:50,958 --> 02:20:53,417 so we would need to identify h 12281 02:20:53,417 --> 02:20:53,417 ow 12282 02:20:53,417 --> 02:20:54,679 to actually fund construction. 12283 02:20:54,679 --> 02:20:54,679 12284 02:20:54,679 --> 02:20:58,602 so I do want to make sure, 12285 02:20:58,602 --> 02:20:59,983 because we've had a couple roa 12286 02:20:59,983 --> 02:21:00,605 d 12287 02:21:00,605 --> 02:21:01,740 projects that have been designe 12288 02:21:01,740 --> 02:21:01,740 d 12289 02:21:01,740 --> 02:21:04,143 a long time ago, and then 12290 02:21:04,143 --> 02:21:04,605 finally funded. 12291 02:21:04,605 --> 02:21:06,055 I don't want the commission to 12292 02:21:06,055 --> 02:21:06,306 12293 02:21:06,306 --> 02:21:10,244 think this is one of those 12294 02:21:10,244 --> 02:21:11,714 processes where the community 12295 02:21:11,714 --> 02:21:11,714 12296 02:21:11,714 --> 02:21:13,380 that construction is imminent. 12297 02:21:13,380 --> 02:21:13,380 12298 02:21:13,380 --> 02:21:15,236 you can make a vote, two months 12299 02:21:15,236 --> 02:21:15,460 12300 02:21:15,460 --> 02:21:16,492 from now we're going to be out 12301 02:21:16,492 --> 02:21:16,685 12302 02:21:16,685 --> 02:21:17,771 there doing the work, that's n 12303 02:21:17,771 --> 02:21:17,771 ot 12304 02:21:17,771 --> 02:21:19,691 the case, we don't have the 12305 02:21:19,691 --> 02:21:21,091 funding lined up for it yet. 12306 02:21:21,091 --> 02:21:24,167 I do think there's still time t 12307 02:21:24,167 --> 02:21:24,167 o 12308 02:21:24,167 --> 02:21:26,963 have additional dialogue, and I 12309 02:21:26,963 --> 02:21:26,963 f 12310 02:21:26,963 --> 02:21:28,505 that's the will of the 12311 02:21:28,505 --> 02:21:29,965 commission, in terms of design 12312 02:21:29,965 --> 02:21:30,369 12313 02:21:30,369 --> 02:21:31,749 on any of the segments and the 12314 02:21:31,749 --> 02:21:31,749 12315 02:21:31,749 --> 02:21:32,173 options presented today. 12316 02:21:32,173 --> 02:21:34,401 >> I'm glad to hear that. 12317 02:21:34,401 --> 02:21:36,676 I do not believe that staff 12318 02:21:36,676 --> 02:21:37,905 should ever make any 12319 02:21:37,905 --> 02:21:39,107 recommendations that have not 12320 02:21:39,107 --> 02:21:39,107 12321 02:21:39,107 --> 02:21:41,421 been fully vetted through a 12322 02:21:41,421 --> 02:21:42,781 process with the community. 12323 02:21:42,781 --> 02:21:45,248 somehow that was circumvented, 12324 02:21:45,248 --> 02:21:46,489 12325 02:21:46,489 --> 02:21:47,312 we missed it. 12326 02:21:47,312 --> 02:21:49,563 and we shouldn't be making any 12327 02:21:49,563 --> 02:21:50,194 12328 02:21:50,194 --> 02:21:50,774 recommendations today at all. 12329 02:21:50,774 --> 02:21:51,225 I'll conclude for now. 12330 02:21:51,225 --> 02:21:56,023 >> thank you, commissioner 12331 02:21:56,023 --> 02:21:57,626 duncan walker, commissioner 12332 02:21:57,626 --> 02:21:57,626 chestnut? 12333 02:21:57,626 --> 02:22:01,671 >> thank you, I think the 12334 02:22:01,671 --> 02:22:02,914 community is still reeling fro 12335 02:22:02,914 --> 02:22:03,003 m 12336 02:22:03,003 --> 02:22:05,501 the changes that were made on 12337 02:22:05,501 --> 02:22:05,501 12338 02:22:05,501 --> 02:22:06,933 northwest eighth avenue from 12339 02:22:06,933 --> 02:22:08,707 main street to sixth street, t 12340 02:22:08,707 --> 02:22:08,707 he 12341 02:22:08,707 --> 02:22:10,241 community has not gotten over 12342 02:22:10,241 --> 02:22:10,241 12343 02:22:10,241 --> 02:22:11,711 that, they don't like it, and I 12344 02:22:11,711 --> 02:22:12,007 12345 02:22:12,007 --> 02:22:17,313 don't think they want to see 12346 02:22:17,313 --> 02:22:18,644 this extended any further. 12347 02:22:18,644 --> 02:22:21,285 now, how many bike lanes are 12348 02:22:21,285 --> 02:22:27,257 from waldo road to mt. Carmel 12349 02:22:27,257 --> 02:22:27,257 12350 02:22:27,257 --> 02:22:27,257 church. 12351 02:22:27,257 --> 02:22:29,943 we have bike lanes on both sid 12352 02:22:29,943 --> 02:22:29,943 es 12353 02:22:29,943 --> 02:22:30,493 now currently? 12354 02:22:30,493 --> 02:22:32,351 >> no, there's just sidewalks. 12355 02:22:32,351 --> 02:22:32,351 12356 02:22:32,351 --> 02:22:32,877 >> just two sidewalks. 12357 02:22:32,877 --> 02:22:36,707 all right. 12358 02:22:36,707 --> 02:22:37,467 that's one. 12359 02:22:37,467 --> 02:22:41,440 how many bikers do you have fro 12360 02:22:41,440 --> 02:22:41,440 12361 02:22:41,440 --> 02:22:45,071 waldo road to mt. Carmel church 12362 02:22:45,071 --> 02:22:45,071 ? 12363 02:22:45,071 --> 02:22:48,213 what do you -- 12364 02:22:48,213 --> 02:22:51,384 >> there was data past a certa 12365 02:22:51,384 --> 02:22:51,384 in 12366 02:22:51,384 --> 02:22:53,117 road point for bike traffic. 12367 02:22:53,117 --> 02:22:54,325 that there's no count. 12368 02:22:54,325 --> 02:22:56,391 I'm not sure what the 12369 02:22:56,391 --> 02:22:56,739 intersection was. 12370 02:22:56,739 --> 02:23:00,371 >> well, I don't think people 12371 02:23:00,371 --> 02:23:00,371 12372 02:23:00,371 --> 02:23:05,461 want to see eighth avenue 12373 02:23:05,461 --> 02:23:06,111 enter -- how many? 12374 02:23:06,111 --> 02:23:09,297 >> no data east of waldo, and 12375 02:23:09,297 --> 02:23:09,297 12376 02:23:09,297 --> 02:23:10,704 that was a question from many o 12377 02:23:10,704 --> 02:23:10,704 f 12378 02:23:10,704 --> 02:23:12,817 the folks we talked, to they 12379 02:23:12,817 --> 02:23:13,486 weren't sure the bike lanes 12380 02:23:13,486 --> 02:23:13,739 would be utilized. >> 12381 02:23:13,739 --> 02:23:18,961 >> had now, there are lots of 12382 02:23:18,961 --> 02:23:18,961 12383 02:23:18,961 --> 02:23:19,941 churches on that stretch. 12384 02:23:19,941 --> 02:23:22,251 there are lots of -- I guess y 12385 02:23:22,251 --> 02:23:22,251 ou 12386 02:23:22,251 --> 02:23:24,287 would call them curb cuts, but 12387 02:23:24,287 --> 02:23:24,422 12388 02:23:24,422 --> 02:23:26,757 there are lots of drive ways 12389 02:23:26,757 --> 02:23:27,981 turning into people's street. 12390 02:23:27,981 --> 02:23:30,363 turning into the streets, which 12391 02:23:30,363 --> 02:23:30,517 12392 02:23:30,517 --> 02:23:36,701 this would just really disrupt. 12393 02:23:36,701 --> 02:23:36,701 12394 02:23:36,701 --> 02:23:39,596 and just the thought of taking 12395 02:23:39,596 --> 02:23:39,861 12396 02:23:39,861 --> 02:23:42,105 out trees, as much as 12397 02:23:42,105 --> 02:23:43,034 gainesville talks about trees, 12398 02:23:43,034 --> 02:23:43,402 12399 02:23:43,402 --> 02:23:46,104 you would have to remove trees 12400 02:23:46,104 --> 02:23:46,243 12401 02:23:46,243 --> 02:23:46,577 here at some point. 12402 02:23:46,577 --> 02:23:52,428 the raised intersections, are 12403 02:23:52,428 --> 02:23:52,428 12404 02:23:52,428 --> 02:23:54,409 you talking about raised 12405 02:23:54,409 --> 02:23:55,386 intersection similar to what y 12406 02:23:55,386 --> 02:23:55,386 ou 12407 02:23:55,386 --> 02:23:57,478 have over on university avenue 12408 02:23:57,478 --> 02:23:58,586 , 12409 02:23:58,586 --> 02:24:01,859 as you go into target copy? 12410 02:24:01,859 --> 02:24:03,459 what would the raised 12411 02:24:03,459 --> 02:24:03,921 intersection look like? 12412 02:24:03,921 --> 02:24:09,759 >> a couple good use of them, 12413 02:24:09,759 --> 02:24:09,759 12414 02:24:09,759 --> 02:24:11,762 there's one on northwest 5th a 12415 02:24:11,762 --> 02:24:11,762 nd 12416 02:24:11,762 --> 02:24:11,762 22nd. 12417 02:24:11,762 --> 02:24:13,944 >> okay. 12418 02:24:13,944 --> 02:24:14,566 I got it. 12419 02:24:14,566 --> 02:24:15,170 I know. 12420 02:24:15,170 --> 02:24:17,898 >> so it's a -- 12421 02:24:17,898 --> 02:24:19,543 >> okay. 12422 02:24:19,543 --> 02:24:21,034 >> so the intersection is 12423 02:24:21,034 --> 02:24:21,034 elevated. 12424 02:24:21,034 --> 02:24:28,470 it's not the increase you get 12425 02:24:28,470 --> 02:24:28,470 12426 02:24:28,470 --> 02:24:29,250 with a speed bump, it's the 12427 02:24:29,250 --> 02:24:29,442 whole thing. 12428 02:24:29,442 --> 02:24:32,730 >> I am interested in hearing 12429 02:24:32,730 --> 02:24:32,730 12430 02:24:32,730 --> 02:24:33,158 from the community. 12431 02:24:33,158 --> 02:24:34,854 particularly since what we've 12432 02:24:34,854 --> 02:24:34,854 12433 02:24:34,854 --> 02:24:36,556 gone through with northwest 12434 02:24:36,556 --> 02:24:39,960 eighth avenue to sixth street, 12435 02:24:39,960 --> 02:24:40,488 12436 02:24:40,488 --> 02:24:41,102 the community has not gotten 12437 02:24:41,102 --> 02:24:41,894 over that. 12438 02:24:41,894 --> 02:24:45,598 we did not have any input in 12439 02:24:45,598 --> 02:24:45,598 that. 12440 02:24:45,598 --> 02:24:48,071 and the next thing we knew, our 12441 02:24:48,071 --> 02:24:48,498 12442 02:24:48,498 --> 02:24:50,468 street was being torn up, bike 12443 02:24:50,468 --> 02:24:51,110 12444 02:24:51,110 --> 02:24:52,574 lanes were being put in, zippe 12445 02:24:52,574 --> 02:24:52,574 rs 12446 02:24:52,574 --> 02:24:54,780 were being put in, we had no 12447 02:24:54,780 --> 02:24:54,780 input. 12448 02:24:54,780 --> 02:24:57,233 now, what we were told is that 12449 02:24:57,233 --> 02:24:57,344 12450 02:24:57,344 --> 02:24:58,906 the input was several years ag 12451 02:24:58,906 --> 02:24:58,906 o, 12452 02:24:58,906 --> 02:25:01,048 we did not have input on that. 12453 02:25:01,048 --> 02:25:01,048 12454 02:25:01,048 --> 02:25:04,186 just as I think these people a 12455 02:25:04,186 --> 02:25:04,186 re 12456 02:25:04,186 --> 02:25:04,856 here today to tell you they've 12457 02:25:04,856 --> 02:25:05,888 12458 02:25:05,888 --> 02:25:06,552 had no input. 12459 02:25:06,552 --> 02:25:09,403 I would not want to see what 12460 02:25:09,403 --> 02:25:13,034 happened to us on northwest 12461 02:25:13,034 --> 02:25:15,664 eighth avenue, when we're told 12462 02:25:15,664 --> 02:25:15,958 12463 02:25:15,958 --> 02:25:17,835 that the public engagement was 12464 02:25:17,835 --> 02:25:17,927 12465 02:25:17,927 --> 02:25:19,626 held years before, but we did 12466 02:25:19,626 --> 02:25:19,626 12467 02:25:19,626 --> 02:25:21,198 not have an opportunity to 12468 02:25:21,198 --> 02:25:23,509 participate there. 12469 02:25:23,509 --> 02:25:25,300 so I have some concerns about 12470 02:25:25,300 --> 02:25:25,300 12471 02:25:25,300 --> 02:25:25,300 this. 12472 02:25:25,300 --> 02:25:29,106 concerns of how this would 12473 02:25:29,106 --> 02:25:29,529 disrupt our community. 12474 02:25:29,529 --> 02:25:31,925 I have concerns about putting I 12475 02:25:31,925 --> 02:25:31,925 n 12476 02:25:31,925 --> 02:25:33,920 these bike lanes, and people 12477 02:25:33,920 --> 02:25:35,644 have not requested those. 12478 02:25:35,644 --> 02:25:39,246 and taking out trees. 12479 02:25:39,246 --> 02:25:41,826 so I'll wait to hear what the 12480 02:25:41,826 --> 02:25:41,826 12481 02:25:41,826 --> 02:25:42,433 community has to say, thank yo 12482 02:25:42,433 --> 02:25:42,433 u. 12483 02:25:42,433 --> 02:25:45,264 >> thank you, commissioner 12484 02:25:45,264 --> 02:25:45,264 chestnut. 12485 02:25:45,264 --> 02:25:46,322 commissioner eastman. 12486 02:25:46,322 --> 02:25:48,270 >> taking a step back here, what 12487 02:25:48,270 --> 02:25:48,270 12488 02:25:48,270 --> 02:25:50,060 we're talking about now is, 12489 02:25:50,060 --> 02:25:52,667 we -- this road is due for 12490 02:25:52,667 --> 02:25:53,512 resurfacing, correct? 12491 02:25:53,512 --> 02:25:55,231 >> what we're talking about 12492 02:25:55,231 --> 02:25:57,687 doing, is taking a road, and 12493 02:25:57,687 --> 02:25:59,973 I'll say, I've tried to ride m 12494 02:25:59,973 --> 02:26:00,402 y 12495 02:26:00,402 --> 02:26:01,678 bike on every street in the cit 12496 02:26:01,678 --> 02:26:01,678 y 12497 02:26:01,678 --> 02:26:02,381 of ga 12498 02:26:02,381 --> 02:26:07,050 this needs help, I will hear 12499 02:26:07,050 --> 02:26:09,253 from the community, but the -- 12500 02:26:09,253 --> 02:26:09,446 12501 02:26:09,446 --> 02:26:09,771 [ inaudible ] 12502 02:26:09,771 --> 02:26:11,148 this is a road that has cracks 12503 02:26:11,148 --> 02:26:11,335 12504 02:26:11,335 --> 02:26:14,759 in it, it is clearly has not 12505 02:26:14,759 --> 02:26:16,659 gotten the love that it 12506 02:26:16,659 --> 02:26:16,659 deserves. 12507 02:26:16,659 --> 02:26:19,874 and that's true with -- just t 12508 02:26:19,874 --> 02:26:19,921 o 12509 02:26:19,921 --> 02:26:22,062 be candid, a lot of east 12510 02:26:22,062 --> 02:26:23,277 gainesville infrastructure, whe 12511 02:26:23,277 --> 02:26:23,277 n 12512 02:26:23,277 --> 02:26:24,331 we're going through that 12513 02:26:24,331 --> 02:26:25,527 process, naturally what happen 12514 02:26:25,527 --> 02:26:25,527 s, 12515 02:26:25,527 --> 02:26:27,405 how should this be designed in 12516 02:26:27,405 --> 02:26:27,448 12517 02:26:27,448 --> 02:26:31,401 the future, whether it was has 12518 02:26:31,401 --> 02:26:31,401 ty 12519 02:26:31,401 --> 02:26:33,643 to come out with recommendatio 12520 02:26:33,643 --> 02:26:33,643 ns 12521 02:26:33,643 --> 02:26:35,744 or -- this is the process of h 12522 02:26:35,744 --> 02:26:35,744 ow 12523 02:26:35,744 --> 02:26:38,909 we decide what wire going to d 12524 02:26:38,909 --> 02:26:39,041 o 12525 02:26:39,041 --> 02:26:40,645 when we're making large 12526 02:26:40,645 --> 02:26:41,867 investments, I think it's great 12527 02:26:41,867 --> 02:26:42,059 12528 02:26:42,059 --> 02:26:43,649 we're making large investments. 12529 02:26:43,649 --> 02:26:43,649 12530 02:26:43,649 --> 02:26:45,451 this road clearly needs it, you 12531 02:26:45,451 --> 02:26:45,855 12532 02:26:45,855 --> 02:26:47,151 guys are asking for right now, 12533 02:26:47,151 --> 02:26:47,451 12534 02:26:47,451 --> 02:26:48,987 I'm hearing -- I know that roa 12535 02:26:48,987 --> 02:26:48,987 ds 12536 02:26:48,987 --> 02:26:51,121 are the sort of funny thing, y 12537 02:26:51,121 --> 02:26:51,121 ou 12538 02:26:51,121 --> 02:26:52,963 make plans in the beginning, y 12539 02:26:52,963 --> 02:26:52,963 ou 12540 02:26:52,963 --> 02:26:54,634 go to the state for grants and 12541 02:26:54,634 --> 02:26:55,063 12542 02:26:55,063 --> 02:26:57,063 you try to get gas tax out of, 12543 02:26:57,063 --> 02:26:59,165 12544 02:26:59,165 --> 02:27:00,797 or whatever the pop of funding 12545 02:27:00,797 --> 02:27:01,031 12546 02:27:01,031 --> 02:27:01,031 is. 12547 02:27:01,031 --> 02:27:02,953 you mentioned briefly, what are 12548 02:27:02,953 --> 02:27:03,041 12549 02:27:03,041 --> 02:27:04,007 you guys looking for? 12550 02:27:04,007 --> 02:27:07,007 you wouldn't be coming and 12551 02:27:07,007 --> 02:27:08,911 asking us if you didn't want 12552 02:27:08,911 --> 02:27:10,756 some sort of direction to move 12553 02:27:10,756 --> 02:27:10,953 12554 02:27:10,953 --> 02:27:12,255 forward to this investment. 12555 02:27:12,255 --> 02:27:13,497 what kind of direction are you 12556 02:27:13,497 --> 02:27:13,645 12557 02:27:13,645 --> 02:27:15,679 looking for, aside from the -- 12558 02:27:15,679 --> 02:27:16,049 12559 02:27:16,049 --> 02:27:17,317 just overall design you 12560 02:27:17,317 --> 02:27:18,033 mentioned, can you repeat that 12561 02:27:18,033 --> 02:27:18,171 12562 02:27:18,171 --> 02:27:18,171 again? 12563 02:27:18,171 --> 02:27:21,957 >> I think in general, the 12564 02:27:21,957 --> 02:27:23,991 recommendations are to look at 12565 02:27:23,991 --> 02:27:24,257 12566 02:27:24,257 --> 02:27:25,719 speed control and do we need t 12567 02:27:25,719 --> 02:27:25,989 o 12568 02:27:25,989 --> 02:27:26,721 have raised intersections. 12569 02:27:26,721 --> 02:27:29,461 I know the graphic proposes 12570 02:27:29,461 --> 02:27:29,461 three. 12571 02:27:29,461 --> 02:27:33,505 it may not be three, we may not 12572 02:27:33,505 --> 02:27:34,075 12573 02:27:34,075 --> 02:27:35,573 need three when we start looki 12574 02:27:35,573 --> 02:27:35,573 ng 12575 02:27:35,573 --> 02:27:35,934 at design. 12576 02:27:35,934 --> 02:27:38,173 I don't think anyone had issue 12577 02:27:38,173 --> 02:27:38,399 s 12578 02:27:38,399 --> 02:27:42,371 with the rfp's or pedestrians 12579 02:27:42,371 --> 02:27:42,371 12580 02:27:42,371 --> 02:27:42,371 crossings. 12581 02:27:42,371 --> 02:27:45,177 bike lanes are tricky, not 12582 02:27:45,177 --> 02:27:46,649 everyone thinks those will be 12583 02:27:46,649 --> 02:27:46,649 12584 02:27:46,649 --> 02:27:49,013 used, do we look at trying to 12585 02:27:49,013 --> 02:27:49,013 12586 02:27:49,013 --> 02:27:50,880 offer a wider sidewalk you for 12587 02:27:50,880 --> 02:27:51,091 12588 02:27:51,091 --> 02:27:52,255 certain stretches so folks can 12589 02:27:52,255 --> 02:27:52,549 12590 02:27:52,549 --> 02:27:54,935 stay on a multiuse trail of som 12591 02:27:54,935 --> 02:27:54,935 e 12592 02:27:54,935 --> 02:27:54,935 sort. 12593 02:27:54,935 --> 02:27:58,559 we do have a multiuse trail fro 12594 02:27:58,559 --> 02:27:58,559 m 12595 02:27:58,559 --> 02:28:00,627 the end, like 25th terrace on, 12596 02:28:00,627 --> 02:28:01,531 12597 02:28:01,531 --> 02:28:02,665 there's multiuse trails. 12598 02:28:02,665 --> 02:28:04,367 we're looking for simple 12599 02:28:04,367 --> 02:28:06,364 guidance in terms of -- 12600 02:28:06,364 --> 02:28:07,863 obviously, everybody's on board 12601 02:28:07,863 --> 02:28:07,991 12602 02:28:07,991 --> 02:28:09,369 with the road paving, what do 12603 02:28:09,369 --> 02:28:09,369 12604 02:28:09,369 --> 02:28:12,669 the bike lanes look like, and d 12605 02:28:12,669 --> 02:28:12,669 o 12606 02:28:12,669 --> 02:28:14,420 we offer bike lanes or do we 12607 02:28:14,420 --> 02:28:16,777 more focus on a sidewalk or 12608 02:28:16,777 --> 02:28:17,411 multiuse situation. 12609 02:28:17,411 --> 02:28:19,516 I don't know if we have enough 12610 02:28:19,516 --> 02:28:20,649 12611 02:28:20,649 --> 02:28:23,479 right-of-way to do that. 12612 02:28:23,479 --> 02:28:25,655 generally speaking that's what 12613 02:28:25,655 --> 02:28:26,151 12614 02:28:26,151 --> 02:28:29,825 we're looking for, comp plan 12615 02:28:29,825 --> 02:28:31,219 indicates we're looking for 12616 02:28:31,219 --> 02:28:31,675 those multimodal opportunities. 12617 02:28:31,675 --> 02:28:31,675 12618 02:28:31,675 --> 02:28:40,333 when it comes to trees, it 12619 02:28:40,333 --> 02:28:41,717 depends if it's a healthy tree 12620 02:28:41,717 --> 02:28:41,999 12621 02:28:41,999 --> 02:28:42,449 or not. 12622 02:28:42,449 --> 02:28:44,470 some of the oaks may be dying 12623 02:28:44,470 --> 02:28:44,470 12624 02:28:44,470 --> 02:28:45,449 inside, and they were dropping 12625 02:28:45,449 --> 02:28:45,902 12626 02:28:45,902 --> 02:28:46,873 logs every time it rained. 12627 02:28:46,873 --> 02:28:48,545 that was one of the reasons the 12628 02:28:48,545 --> 02:28:48,977 12629 02:28:48,977 --> 02:28:49,383 trees came up. 12630 02:28:49,383 --> 02:28:52,041 we would look at that. 12631 02:28:52,041 --> 02:28:54,543 we want long term safety, the 12632 02:28:54,543 --> 02:28:54,543 12633 02:28:54,543 --> 02:28:56,591 trees are providing shade, 12634 02:28:56,591 --> 02:28:58,222 they're dropping limbs, is that 12635 02:28:58,222 --> 02:28:58,261 12636 02:28:58,261 --> 02:28:58,581 a problem? 12637 02:28:58,581 --> 02:28:59,448 >> right. 12638 02:28:59,448 --> 02:29:03,462 >> to that point, when we tal 12639 02:29:03,462 --> 02:29:06,365 about tearing down the trees a 12640 02:29:06,365 --> 02:29:06,365 nd 12641 02:29:06,365 --> 02:29:06,688 the bike lanes. 12642 02:29:06,688 --> 02:29:09,596 in most of these, we had bike 12643 02:29:09,596 --> 02:29:09,596 12644 02:29:09,596 --> 02:29:09,596 lanes. 12645 02:29:09,596 --> 02:29:13,735 what are you referring to. 12646 02:29:13,735 --> 02:29:15,274 those there, that is a question 12647 02:29:15,274 --> 02:29:15,471 12648 02:29:15,471 --> 02:29:16,914 that is there, whether or not w 12649 02:29:16,914 --> 02:29:16,914 e 12650 02:29:16,914 --> 02:29:20,137 want to extend that one side, 12651 02:29:20,137 --> 02:29:20,137 12652 02:29:20,137 --> 02:29:21,378 which for folks that walk, wha 12653 02:29:21,378 --> 02:29:21,551 t 12654 02:29:21,551 --> 02:29:23,717 we're talking about is a large 12655 02:29:23,717 --> 02:29:23,852 r 12656 02:29:23,852 --> 02:29:30,773 sidewalk in a lot of ways, of 12657 02:29:30,773 --> 02:29:30,773 12658 02:29:30,773 --> 02:29:31,343 course it's nice. 12659 02:29:31,343 --> 02:29:33,523 yeah, I mean, so when you were 12660 02:29:33,523 --> 02:29:33,785 12661 02:29:33,785 --> 02:29:36,329 telling us about the time line 12662 02:29:36,329 --> 02:29:36,794 , 12663 02:29:36,794 --> 02:29:38,888 you said you wanted some kind o 12664 02:29:38,888 --> 02:29:38,888 f 12665 02:29:38,888 --> 02:29:40,461 direction related to -- I mean 12666 02:29:40,461 --> 02:29:41,161 , 12667 02:29:41,161 --> 02:29:43,699 kind of the broad swaths, 12668 02:29:43,699 --> 02:29:45,096 specifically east of waldo, the 12669 02:29:45,096 --> 02:29:45,433 12670 02:29:45,433 --> 02:29:47,334 9th to waldo, I don't see as 12671 02:29:47,334 --> 02:29:48,586 part of the motion in here. 12672 02:29:48,586 --> 02:29:51,096 >> no, we're specifically 12673 02:29:51,096 --> 02:29:51,672 looking for more east. 12674 02:29:51,672 --> 02:29:55,512 I don't know -- it was a median 12675 02:29:55,512 --> 02:29:55,512 , 12676 02:29:55,512 --> 02:29:58,046 10 foot wide on -- 12677 02:29:58,046 --> 02:29:59,811 >> it was conceptual 12678 02:29:59,811 --> 02:30:00,657 recommendation for what we wou 12679 02:30:00,657 --> 02:30:00,657 ld 12680 02:30:00,657 --> 02:30:02,679 say, this is what we would 12681 02:30:02,679 --> 02:30:05,022 propose to put out here, if 12682 02:30:05,022 --> 02:30:06,526 we're going to do west waldo. 12683 02:30:06,526 --> 02:30:08,940 that would be resurfacing and 12684 02:30:08,940 --> 02:30:08,940 12685 02:30:08,940 --> 02:30:08,940 restriping. 12686 02:30:08,940 --> 02:30:11,410 adding a 10 foot top. 12687 02:30:11,410 --> 02:30:13,823 >> that's not in the 12688 02:30:13,823 --> 02:30:14,600 recommendation I saw in the 12689 02:30:14,600 --> 02:30:14,600 back? 12690 02:30:14,600 --> 02:30:16,860 >> 00, the last part, no. 12691 02:30:16,860 --> 02:30:18,210 >> yeah, for the direction, 12692 02:30:18,210 --> 02:30:19,874 which I think would be nice to 12693 02:30:19,874 --> 02:30:20,734 12694 02:30:20,734 --> 02:30:22,616 gear us in on which portion of 12695 02:30:22,616 --> 02:30:22,616 12696 02:30:22,616 --> 02:30:23,278 the direction. 12697 02:30:23,278 --> 02:30:25,510 that western portion is my 12698 02:30:25,510 --> 02:30:28,074 district, be and it's also whe 12699 02:30:28,074 --> 02:30:28,074 re 12700 02:30:28,074 --> 02:30:30,278 we're about to build citizens 12701 02:30:30,278 --> 02:30:30,278 12702 02:30:30,278 --> 02:30:31,722 field, and there's a lot of 12703 02:30:31,722 --> 02:30:32,338 questions within there. 12704 02:30:32,338 --> 02:30:33,876 yeah, I mean, I do think -- you 12705 02:30:33,876 --> 02:30:34,172 12706 02:30:34,172 --> 02:30:37,050 know, you have duvall, which I 12707 02:30:37,050 --> 02:30:37,094 s 12708 02:30:37,094 --> 02:30:38,796 now going to remain open it 12709 02:30:38,796 --> 02:30:40,327 seems, so this is a place where 12710 02:30:40,327 --> 02:30:40,588 12711 02:30:40,588 --> 02:30:42,720 kids are riding their bikes fro 12712 02:30:42,720 --> 02:30:42,720 m 12713 02:30:42,720 --> 02:30:46,761 the surroundi ing neighborhoods 12714 02:30:46,761 --> 02:30:47,498 to 12715 02:30:47,498 --> 02:30:47,498 [laughter] 12716 02:30:47,498 --> 02:30:52,077 >> I think there is lot of 12717 02:30:52,077 --> 02:30:52,574 benefit to having these 12718 02:30:52,574 --> 02:30:53,202 discussions about this, figurin 12719 02:30:53,202 --> 02:30:53,202 g 12720 02:30:53,202 --> 02:30:54,330 out what makes sense here and 12721 02:30:54,330 --> 02:30:55,634 where that makes sense, and so 12722 02:30:55,634 --> 02:30:55,634 12723 02:30:55,634 --> 02:30:57,468 yeah, I'm interested in seeing 12724 02:30:57,468 --> 02:30:57,468 12725 02:30:57,468 --> 02:30:58,634 how we can move forward this. 12726 02:30:58,634 --> 02:30:58,914 all right. 12727 02:30:58,914 --> 02:30:59,472 thank you. 12728 02:30:59,472 --> 02:31:00,008 >> mayor: thank you, 12729 02:31:00,008 --> 02:31:00,538 commissioner eastman. 12730 02:31:00,538 --> 02:31:03,612 commissioner willits. 12731 02:31:03,612 --> 02:31:05,494 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 12732 02:31:05,494 --> 02:31:07,228 so just remind me, so our comp 12733 02:31:07,228 --> 02:31:07,228 12734 02:31:07,228 --> 02:31:08,746 plan says when we go to 12735 02:31:08,746 --> 02:31:11,486 resurface, this type of, you 12736 02:31:11,486 --> 02:31:13,376 know, road, we have to 12737 02:31:13,376 --> 02:31:13,376 consider. 12738 02:31:13,376 --> 02:31:14,559 that's why we're here today, 12739 02:31:14,559 --> 02:31:14,559 right? 12740 02:31:14,559 --> 02:31:16,621 because our comp plan says, hey 12741 02:31:16,621 --> 02:31:16,621 , 12742 02:31:16,621 --> 02:31:17,720 if you're going to spend a but 12743 02:31:17,720 --> 02:31:17,720 ch 12744 02:31:17,720 --> 02:31:19,588 of money on asphalt, is it tim 12745 02:31:19,588 --> 02:31:19,588 e 12746 02:31:19,588 --> 02:31:21,126 for something that we didn't 12747 02:31:21,126 --> 02:31:22,524 envision 30 years ago or 20 12748 02:31:22,524 --> 02:31:24,731 years ago or 15 when we last, s 12749 02:31:24,731 --> 02:31:24,731 o 12750 02:31:24,731 --> 02:31:26,914 this process is not because 12751 02:31:26,914 --> 02:31:27,908 someone on staff said hey this 12752 02:31:27,908 --> 02:31:27,908 12753 02:31:27,908 --> 02:31:29,003 is a good idea or anyone on the 12754 02:31:29,003 --> 02:31:29,003 12755 02:31:29,003 --> 02:31:29,003 commission. 12756 02:31:29,003 --> 02:31:31,616 it's just is that our process 12757 02:31:31,616 --> 02:31:32,788 from the comp plan which is, y 12758 02:31:32,788 --> 02:31:32,788 ou 12759 02:31:32,788 --> 02:31:35,008 know, like the plan for the cit 12760 02:31:35,008 --> 02:31:35,008 y 12761 02:31:35,008 --> 02:31:37,214 just, it says hey you're about 12762 02:31:37,214 --> 02:31:37,214 12763 02:31:37,214 --> 02:31:39,474 to resurface, go look at some 12764 02:31:39,474 --> 02:31:40,478 other options. 12765 02:31:40,478 --> 02:31:42,448 >> yes, our comp plan says tha 12766 02:31:42,448 --> 02:31:42,448 t 12767 02:31:42,448 --> 02:31:44,850 also our edcm, our engineering 12768 02:31:44,850 --> 02:31:44,850 12769 02:31:44,850 --> 02:31:46,290 design and construction manual. 12770 02:31:46,290 --> 02:31:46,290 12771 02:31:46,290 --> 02:31:48,120 the same as you would also 12772 02:31:48,120 --> 02:31:49,684 provide ada ramps you know, if 12773 02:31:49,684 --> 02:31:49,684 12774 02:31:49,684 --> 02:31:51,194 we're doing work like that we 12775 02:31:51,194 --> 02:31:53,690 would also upgrade the ramps 12776 02:31:53,690 --> 02:31:54,590 along the roadway. 12777 02:31:54,590 --> 02:31:55,794 >> right, okay, so I just want 12778 02:31:55,794 --> 02:31:55,794 12779 02:31:55,794 --> 02:31:57,226 to make sure I understand 12780 02:31:57,226 --> 02:31:58,530 because it's been asphalt, are 12781 02:31:58,530 --> 02:31:58,530 12782 02:31:58,530 --> 02:32:00,364 there safety improvements that 12783 02:32:00,364 --> 02:32:00,364 12784 02:32:00,364 --> 02:32:01,600 can be done, safety, ada 12785 02:32:01,600 --> 02:32:03,470 accessibility, issues. 12786 02:32:03,470 --> 02:32:05,681 while we're there. 12787 02:32:05,681 --> 02:32:08,854 while we're laying asphalts. 12788 02:32:08,854 --> 02:32:09,518 while that makes sense to look 12789 02:32:09,518 --> 02:32:09,518 12790 02:32:09,518 --> 02:32:09,754 at it. 12791 02:32:09,754 --> 02:32:11,478 questions and part of this is 12792 02:32:11,478 --> 02:32:13,844 because 8th avenue is this 12793 02:32:13,844 --> 02:32:15,278 weer beast because it's got all 12794 02:32:15,278 --> 02:32:15,278 12795 02:32:15,278 --> 02:32:16,250 these different sections. 12796 02:32:16,250 --> 02:32:18,244 just what we're talking about I 12797 02:32:18,244 --> 02:32:18,244 s 12798 02:32:18,244 --> 02:32:19,422 three different sections. 12799 02:32:19,422 --> 02:32:20,496 every section is a little bit 12800 02:32:20,496 --> 02:32:21,390 different and it's been cobbled 12801 02:32:21,390 --> 02:32:21,390 12802 02:32:21,390 --> 02:32:23,288 together over decades, some of 12803 02:32:23,288 --> 02:32:23,288 12804 02:32:23,288 --> 02:32:25,864 it's disjointed about biking 12805 02:32:25,864 --> 02:32:25,996 12806 02:32:25,996 --> 02:32:26,896 biking and walking and where 12807 02:32:26,896 --> 02:32:28,862 it's easy for buses and where 12808 02:32:28,862 --> 02:32:29,928 it's easy for cars and we're 12809 02:32:29,928 --> 02:32:30,598 going to continue to struggle 12810 02:32:30,598 --> 02:32:34,002 with this because city road and 12811 02:32:34,002 --> 02:32:34,002 12812 02:32:34,002 --> 02:32:36,198 state road in some sections, 12813 02:32:36,198 --> 02:32:36,198 unfortunately. 12814 02:32:36,198 --> 02:32:41,439 the thing that stuck out to me 12815 02:32:41,439 --> 02:32:41,439 12816 02:32:41,439 --> 02:32:42,677 was the traffic data on the 12817 02:32:42,677 --> 02:32:42,677 speed. 12818 02:32:42,677 --> 02:32:45,575 northeast 9th to waldo so the 12819 02:32:45,575 --> 02:32:48,084 western portion, posted at 12820 02:32:48,084 --> 02:32:50,523 35 miles an hour, and 8th 12821 02:32:50,523 --> 02:32:55,091 percentile is less than that. 12822 02:32:55,091 --> 02:32:57,621 yet from waldo to 22nd, posted 12823 02:32:57,621 --> 02:32:57,621 12824 02:32:57,621 --> 02:32:59,883 35 miles per hour, 38.3 miles 12825 02:32:59,883 --> 02:33:00,469 per hour. 12826 02:33:00,469 --> 02:33:01,920 that tells me the story of 12827 02:33:01,920 --> 02:33:03,634 engineering absolutely matters 12828 02:33:03,634 --> 02:33:03,634 12829 02:33:03,634 --> 02:33:05,665 because there is -- little 12830 02:33:05,665 --> 02:33:06,597 fundamental difference between 12831 02:33:06,597 --> 02:33:06,597 12832 02:33:06,597 --> 02:33:07,365 the people who are driving eas 12833 02:33:07,365 --> 02:33:07,365 t 12834 02:33:07,365 --> 02:33:09,471 and west to waldo. 12835 02:33:09,471 --> 02:33:11,103 they're people, they're 12836 02:33:11,103 --> 02:33:11,103 neighbors. 12837 02:33:11,103 --> 02:33:13,944 some of them are going the who 12838 02:33:13,944 --> 02:33:13,944 le 12839 02:33:13,944 --> 02:33:15,239 route, some of them are turning 12840 02:33:15,239 --> 02:33:15,239 12841 02:33:15,239 --> 02:33:15,778 at some point. 12842 02:33:15,778 --> 02:33:17,107 that tells me the engineering, 12843 02:33:17,107 --> 02:33:17,107 12844 02:33:17,107 --> 02:33:20,281 and why the people on the the 12845 02:33:20,281 --> 02:33:21,583 west side get the benefit of a 12846 02:33:21,583 --> 02:33:21,583 12847 02:33:21,583 --> 02:33:22,401 slower road. 12848 02:33:22,401 --> 02:33:23,517 you can say it's only 6 miles 12849 02:33:23,517 --> 02:33:24,039 per hour. 12850 02:33:24,039 --> 02:33:25,251 averaged out, that 85th 12851 02:33:25,251 --> 02:33:28,823 percentile, there are plenty o 12852 02:33:28,823 --> 02:33:28,823 f 12853 02:33:28,823 --> 02:33:29,817 people flying down the road, 12854 02:33:29,817 --> 02:33:31,231 particularly the section, you 12855 02:33:31,231 --> 02:33:33,967 know, between wawltdo and -- so 12856 02:33:33,967 --> 02:33:33,967 12857 02:33:33,967 --> 02:33:35,047 I think there is some sort of 12858 02:33:35,047 --> 02:33:35,764 infrastructure that needs to 12859 02:33:35,764 --> 02:33:37,093 happen that slows that down and 12860 02:33:37,093 --> 02:33:37,093 12861 02:33:37,093 --> 02:33:37,862 makes it safer. 12862 02:33:37,862 --> 02:33:38,399 what exactly? 12863 02:33:38,399 --> 02:33:39,765 we're going to have lot -- lots 12864 02:33:39,765 --> 02:33:39,765 12865 02:33:39,765 --> 02:33:40,757 of opinion in the community is 12866 02:33:40,757 --> 02:33:40,757 12867 02:33:40,757 --> 02:33:42,669 going to give us some. 12868 02:33:42,669 --> 02:33:45,874 but it's, you see 34 feet wide? 12869 02:33:45,874 --> 02:33:45,874 12870 02:33:45,874 --> 02:33:47,269 between wawltdo and 22nd? 12871 02:33:47,269 --> 02:33:49,217 waldo and 22nd? 12872 02:33:49,217 --> 02:33:50,847 like basically 17-foot travel 12873 02:33:50,847 --> 02:33:50,847 lanes. 12874 02:33:50,847 --> 02:33:52,513 >> there are segments where it' 12875 02:33:52,513 --> 02:33:52,513 s 12876 02:33:52,513 --> 02:33:53,181 35 even wider. 12877 02:33:53,181 --> 02:33:55,006 >> what did we just agree to 12878 02:33:55,006 --> 02:33:59,649 northeast 9th and mr.-- 12879 02:33:59,649 --> 02:34:02,060 northeast, is it 9th where we 12880 02:34:02,060 --> 02:34:03,361 had, we're doing work on that, 12881 02:34:03,361 --> 02:34:03,361 12882 02:34:03,361 --> 02:34:05,321 9th street, and there was an 12883 02:34:05,321 --> 02:34:07,145 argument whether it was 11 1/2 12884 02:34:07,145 --> 02:34:07,145 12885 02:34:07,145 --> 02:34:09,391 foot lanes versus, do we end u 12886 02:34:09,391 --> 02:34:09,391 p 12887 02:34:09,391 --> 02:34:10,205 on 11 1/2? 12888 02:34:10,205 --> 02:34:13,341 >> 10 1/2 foot lanes. 12889 02:34:13,341 --> 02:34:15,777 >> did we end up on 10 10 1/ 12890 02:34:15,777 --> 02:34:15,777 2? 12891 02:34:15,777 --> 02:34:17,273 I thought we ended up on 12892 02:34:17,273 --> 02:34:17,743 11 1/2. 12893 02:34:17,743 --> 02:34:21,439 so just for some example like I 12894 02:34:21,439 --> 02:34:21,439 12895 02:34:21,439 --> 02:34:23,809 think those lanes need to be 12896 02:34:23,809 --> 02:34:24,601 narrowed some way. 12897 02:34:24,601 --> 02:34:27,357 the quick quick easy is you 12898 02:34:27,357 --> 02:34:29,417 put 12899 02:34:29,417 --> 02:34:30,407 a lane of parking in on the 12900 02:34:30,407 --> 02:34:32,683 south side so it's still 12901 02:34:32,683 --> 02:34:33,689 available for parking, church, 12902 02:34:33,689 --> 02:34:33,689 12903 02:34:33,689 --> 02:34:36,653 you know, events, something 12904 02:34:36,653 --> 02:34:37,447 needs to happen on that 12905 02:34:37,447 --> 02:34:37,447 section. 12906 02:34:37,447 --> 02:34:40,159 and and the crash data seem to 12907 02:34:40,159 --> 02:34:40,159 12908 02:34:40,159 --> 02:34:41,759 suggest that. 12909 02:34:41,759 --> 02:34:43,867 what exactly, the idea of a 12910 02:34:43,867 --> 02:34:46,503 10-foot path from 22nd and 12911 02:34:46,503 --> 02:34:48,703 that street not terrace, right 12912 02:34:48,703 --> 02:34:48,703 ? 12913 02:34:48,703 --> 02:34:50,787 northwest 22nd street. 12914 02:34:50,787 --> 02:34:51,173 >> yes. 12915 02:34:51,173 --> 02:34:53,097 >> 26th street, yes. 12916 02:34:53,097 --> 02:34:53,981 >> there are two houses on that 12917 02:34:53,981 --> 02:34:53,981 12918 02:34:53,981 --> 02:34:54,939 corner right there on the corne 12919 02:34:54,939 --> 02:34:54,939 r 12920 02:34:54,939 --> 02:34:56,141 that are, that abut the 12921 02:34:56,141 --> 02:34:56,141 sidewalk. 12922 02:34:56,141 --> 02:34:59,847 I mean, I don't know, their 12923 02:34:59,847 --> 02:35:01,635 stoop is two feet from the 12924 02:35:01,635 --> 02:35:02,681 sidewalk, and then there's you 12925 02:35:02,681 --> 02:35:02,681 12926 02:35:02,681 --> 02:35:05,093 know there's a grass strip 12927 02:35:05,093 --> 02:35:05,887 between the sidewalk and the 12928 02:35:05,887 --> 02:35:07,197 street but a 10-foot path there 12929 02:35:07,197 --> 02:35:07,197 12930 02:35:07,197 --> 02:35:10,692 eats up from their front door 12931 02:35:10,692 --> 02:35:11,991 it's nothing but sidewalk. 12932 02:35:11,991 --> 02:35:14,503 plus 34th feet of or however 12933 02:35:14,503 --> 02:35:18,137 many feet of section of asphalt 12934 02:35:18,137 --> 02:35:18,137 12935 02:35:18,137 --> 02:35:18,785 on the other side so that 12936 02:35:18,785 --> 02:35:19,765 doesn't sound pleasant. 12937 02:35:19,765 --> 02:35:24,140 so, and what -- so there's no 12938 02:35:24,140 --> 02:35:27,639 discussion of maybe we just, 12939 02:35:27,639 --> 02:35:31,477 what if you had a two-way cycle 12940 02:35:31,477 --> 02:35:31,477 12941 02:35:31,477 --> 02:35:32,994 lane on the north side of the 12942 02:35:32,994 --> 02:35:33,784 road where you took out the 12943 02:35:33,784 --> 02:35:35,194 medians from northeast 9th to 12944 02:35:35,194 --> 02:35:37,541 waldo, so that you don't have t 12945 02:35:37,541 --> 02:35:37,541 o 12946 02:35:37,541 --> 02:35:38,727 create a 10-foot path on the 12947 02:35:38,727 --> 02:35:39,786 north side. 12948 02:35:39,786 --> 02:35:40,864 I'm trying to think of lots of 12949 02:35:40,864 --> 02:35:40,864 12950 02:35:40,864 --> 02:35:42,849 different ways, things that we 12951 02:35:42,849 --> 02:35:42,849 12952 02:35:42,849 --> 02:35:49,205 find in the nack nacto 12953 02:35:49,205 --> 02:35:49,205 standards. 12954 02:35:49,205 --> 02:35:50,168 that's not a question. 12955 02:35:50,168 --> 02:35:51,398 I'm going to keep on moving on 12956 02:35:51,398 --> 02:35:51,398 12957 02:35:51,398 --> 02:35:52,501 with maybe some more comments 12958 02:35:52,501 --> 02:35:55,633 about is there any way that we 12959 02:35:55,633 --> 02:35:55,633 12960 02:35:55,633 --> 02:35:58,641 could do more envisioning where 12961 02:35:58,641 --> 02:35:58,641 12962 02:35:58,641 --> 02:36:00,003 we you know go out and put the 12963 02:36:00,003 --> 02:36:00,003 12964 02:36:00,003 --> 02:36:02,052 cones and show what it would 12965 02:36:02,052 --> 02:36:03,843 look like, particularly in wal 12966 02:36:03,843 --> 02:36:03,843 do 12967 02:36:03,843 --> 02:36:06,041 to 22nd, so what a potential 12968 02:36:06,041 --> 02:36:07,954 could look at. 12969 02:36:07,954 --> 02:36:08,709 you put out the cones and you 12970 02:36:08,709 --> 02:36:10,319 tell the neighborhood, hey, we 12971 02:36:10,319 --> 02:36:10,319 12972 02:36:10,319 --> 02:36:11,025 just seeing what it would look 12973 02:36:11,025 --> 02:36:11,025 12974 02:36:11,025 --> 02:36:12,517 like and then people go, oh, I 12975 02:36:12,517 --> 02:36:12,517 12976 02:36:12,517 --> 02:36:14,359 would like the lane to be 12977 02:36:14,359 --> 02:36:18,196 narrower or whatever. 12978 02:36:18,196 --> 02:36:19,495 so it's just a thought. 12979 02:36:19,495 --> 02:36:21,119 I know this is early in the 12980 02:36:21,119 --> 02:36:21,119 process. 12981 02:36:21,119 --> 02:36:25,563 when I saw the work of the, the 12982 02:36:25,563 --> 02:36:25,563 12983 02:36:25,563 --> 02:36:27,611 outreach, I even thought this I 12984 02:36:27,611 --> 02:36:27,611 s 12985 02:36:27,611 --> 02:36:27,611 rushed. 12986 02:36:27,611 --> 02:36:29,678 normally we get outreach and 12987 02:36:29,678 --> 02:36:31,534 couple months later, you know, 12988 02:36:31,534 --> 02:36:31,534 12989 02:36:31,534 --> 02:36:34,512 things have trickled up to us 12990 02:36:34,512 --> 02:36:37,260 and we hear some and we go oh 12991 02:36:37,260 --> 02:36:39,552 yeah, we're going to drive and 12992 02:36:39,552 --> 02:36:39,552 12993 02:36:39,552 --> 02:36:41,417 see what people were talking 12994 02:36:41,417 --> 02:36:41,417 about. 12995 02:36:41,417 --> 02:36:43,146 this feels a little fast. 12996 02:36:43,146 --> 02:36:44,118 I don't understand why it's so 12997 02:36:44,118 --> 02:36:44,118 12998 02:36:44,118 --> 02:36:45,118 compressed getting back to us 12999 02:36:45,118 --> 02:36:47,760 after that amount of feedback. 13000 02:36:47,760 --> 02:36:47,760 13001 02:36:47,760 --> 02:36:48,832 let me see if there is anything 13002 02:36:48,832 --> 02:36:48,832 13003 02:36:48,832 --> 02:36:51,598 else like a specific. 13004 02:36:51,598 --> 02:36:52,830 where they said, you said there 13005 02:36:52,830 --> 02:36:52,830 13006 02:36:52,830 --> 02:36:53,698 was a lot of trees on one of th 13007 02:36:53,698 --> 02:36:53,698 e 13008 02:36:53,698 --> 02:36:53,698 sides. 13009 02:36:53,698 --> 02:36:55,404 I think they said north side 13010 02:36:55,404 --> 02:36:56,930 with the 10-foot path is that 13011 02:36:56,930 --> 02:36:57,933 the eastern portion or the 13012 02:36:57,933 --> 02:36:58,910 western portion? 13013 02:36:58,910 --> 02:37:00,313 >> eastern portion. 13014 02:37:00,313 --> 02:37:03,504 >> eastern, oi got that 13015 02:37:03,504 --> 02:37:03,504 confused. 13016 02:37:03,504 --> 02:37:05,068 thanks for -- and -- 13017 02:37:05,068 --> 02:37:07,784 >> [off mic] 13018 02:37:07,784 --> 02:37:08,684 bullet we would go out there 13019 02:37:08,684 --> 02:37:09,882 with an arborist to make sure 13020 02:37:09,882 --> 02:37:11,196 they're healthy and not -- 13021 02:37:11,196 --> 02:37:11,769 >> thank you and the concern 13022 02:37:11,769 --> 02:37:13,484 over median opens, again, was 13023 02:37:13,484 --> 02:37:16,882 that the section west of waldo 13024 02:37:16,882 --> 02:37:16,882 ? 13025 02:37:16,882 --> 02:37:19,746 so potential median. 13026 02:37:19,746 --> 02:37:20,920 okay it was concerns. 13027 02:37:20,920 --> 02:37:24,896 it wasn't over existing -- 13028 02:37:24,896 --> 02:37:26,510 sorry, we are talking about lot 13029 02:37:26,510 --> 02:37:26,510 s 13030 02:37:26,510 --> 02:37:27,364 of different sections. 13031 02:37:27,364 --> 02:37:27,983 >> mm-hmm. 13032 02:37:27,983 --> 02:37:28,332 it's a lot. 13033 02:37:28,332 --> 02:37:32,076 so each of those little diamond 13034 02:37:32,076 --> 02:37:32,076 13035 02:37:32,076 --> 02:37:33,274 stick points, that's a driveway 13036 02:37:33,274 --> 02:37:33,274 13037 02:37:33,274 --> 02:37:33,274 access. 13038 02:37:33,274 --> 02:37:36,992 >> right. 13039 02:37:36,992 --> 02:37:37,766 >> so nose are all the 13040 02:37:37,766 --> 02:37:38,958 openings -- those are all the 13041 02:37:38,958 --> 02:37:38,958 openings. 13042 02:37:38,958 --> 02:37:40,704 so the medians, those would be 13043 02:37:40,704 --> 02:37:40,704 13044 02:37:40,704 --> 02:37:41,710 the two options. 13045 02:37:41,710 --> 02:37:44,288 in terms of the concerns with 13046 02:37:44,288 --> 02:37:46,288 median openings, is that what 13047 02:37:46,288 --> 02:37:46,812 you're asking? 13048 02:37:46,812 --> 02:37:47,810 >> yeah, I thought -- I that 13049 02:37:47,810 --> 02:37:49,354 thought was coming from I think 13050 02:37:49,354 --> 02:37:49,354 13051 02:37:49,354 --> 02:37:50,206 the neighbors. 13052 02:37:50,206 --> 02:37:50,893 >> west waldo. 13053 02:37:50,893 --> 02:37:51,250 I'm sorry. 13054 02:37:51,250 --> 02:37:51,790 I misunderstood. 13055 02:37:51,790 --> 02:37:52,888 >> yeah, so that was the west o 13056 02:37:52,888 --> 02:37:52,888 f 13057 02:37:52,888 --> 02:37:53,577 waldo section. 13058 02:37:53,577 --> 02:37:54,850 is that there weren't enough? 13059 02:37:54,850 --> 02:37:57,255 or there -- too many -- I don't 13060 02:37:57,255 --> 02:37:57,255 , 13061 02:37:57,255 --> 02:37:57,706 what was the concern. 13062 02:37:57,706 --> 02:37:59,023 >> some of the median, like the 13063 02:37:59,023 --> 02:37:59,023 13064 02:37:59,023 --> 02:38:00,524 actual turn lane lengths they 13065 02:38:00,524 --> 02:38:01,866 felt were short. 13066 02:38:01,866 --> 02:38:03,062 when we did look at the crash 13067 02:38:03,062 --> 02:38:05,360 data nothing stuck out to 13068 02:38:05,360 --> 02:38:06,576 indicate that they were a 13069 02:38:06,576 --> 02:38:06,576 problem. 13070 02:38:06,576 --> 02:38:10,317 but I guess as, when I was 13071 02:38:10,317 --> 02:38:11,451 driving through there doing sit 13072 02:38:11,451 --> 02:38:11,451 e 13073 02:38:11,451 --> 02:38:13,406 visits taking pictures, things 13074 02:38:13,406 --> 02:38:13,406 13075 02:38:13,406 --> 02:38:14,472 like that even just driving 13076 02:38:14,472 --> 02:38:15,348 along I could see where someone 13077 02:38:15,348 --> 02:38:15,348 13078 02:38:15,348 --> 02:38:16,741 would be up comfortable with the 13079 02:38:16,741 --> 02:38:16,741 13080 02:38:16,741 --> 02:38:19,244 rush to get into a shorter tur 13081 02:38:19,244 --> 02:38:19,244 n 13082 02:38:19,244 --> 02:38:19,244 lane. 13083 02:38:19,244 --> 02:38:20,906 >> well if they were going 38 13084 02:38:20,906 --> 02:38:22,248 instead of 32 I can imagine it 13085 02:38:22,248 --> 02:38:22,248 13086 02:38:22,248 --> 02:38:22,490 felt -- 13087 02:38:22,490 --> 02:38:22,490 [laughter] 13088 02:38:22,490 --> 02:38:24,901 >> so. 13089 02:38:24,901 --> 02:38:25,430 >> okay, that helps me 13090 02:38:25,430 --> 02:38:26,366 understand a little bit about 13091 02:38:26,366 --> 02:38:28,206 that concern because just the 13092 02:38:28,206 --> 02:38:29,684 fact that it's so much slower, 13093 02:38:29,684 --> 02:38:29,684 13094 02:38:29,684 --> 02:38:31,332 six miles an hour on average 13095 02:38:31,332 --> 02:38:34,200 slower, on a street that is 13096 02:38:34,200 --> 02:38:36,658 signaled higher you know or yit 13097 02:38:36,658 --> 02:38:39,998 tells me we did maybe 13098 02:38:39,998 --> 02:38:41,551 some -- on that section -- the 13099 02:38:41,551 --> 02:38:41,551 13100 02:38:41,551 --> 02:38:45,705 other section needs something. 13101 02:38:45,705 --> 02:38:45,705 13102 02:38:45,705 --> 02:38:46,918 I think that's, I think that's 13103 02:38:46,918 --> 02:38:46,918 13104 02:38:46,918 --> 02:38:48,775 all I got for -- oh, and just, 13105 02:38:48,775 --> 02:38:48,775 13106 02:38:48,775 --> 02:38:50,272 oh, just the idea is also like, 13107 02:38:50,272 --> 02:38:50,272 13108 02:38:50,272 --> 02:38:51,510 is there any opportunity for 13109 02:38:51,510 --> 02:38:52,582 quick build things where we, 13110 02:38:52,582 --> 02:38:55,596 where we don't spend 3 or 13111 02:38:55,596 --> 02:38:56,517 $5 million where we do put in 13112 02:38:56,517 --> 02:38:59,918 things that are much more quick 13113 02:38:59,918 --> 02:38:59,918 , 13114 02:38:59,918 --> 02:39:02,458 temporary, try for six months, 13115 02:39:02,458 --> 02:39:03,654 I 13116 02:39:03,654 --> 02:39:05,830 just had that, and then, sorry 13117 02:39:05,830 --> 02:39:05,830 , 13118 02:39:05,830 --> 02:39:07,558 that's -- maybe this is just 13119 02:39:07,558 --> 02:39:08,425 conversation for my colleagues 13120 02:39:08,425 --> 02:39:08,425 13121 02:39:08,425 --> 02:39:09,430 to hear. 13122 02:39:09,430 --> 02:39:12,381 and then can you, this is one 13123 02:39:12,381 --> 02:39:13,296 you may be able to answer. 13124 02:39:13,296 --> 02:39:15,973 why is there hashing on the 13125 02:39:15,973 --> 02:39:17,103 eastern portion in front of the 13126 02:39:17,103 --> 02:39:17,103 13127 02:39:17,103 --> 02:39:19,511 slab basically at 17th. 13128 02:39:19,511 --> 02:39:20,636 there is some hashing s. That t 13129 02:39:20,636 --> 02:39:20,636 o 13130 02:39:20,636 --> 02:39:21,799 keep people from parking there 13131 02:39:21,799 --> 02:39:21,799 13132 02:39:21,799 --> 02:39:23,007 on the north side? 13133 02:39:23,007 --> 02:39:24,016 it's kind of marked off. 13134 02:39:24,016 --> 02:39:25,542 it's not parking, but it -- lik 13135 02:39:25,542 --> 02:39:25,542 e 13136 02:39:25,542 --> 02:39:26,516 I said it's got a hash mark. 13137 02:39:26,516 --> 02:39:28,370 is that to keep people from 13138 02:39:28,370 --> 02:39:29,520 parking there. 13139 02:39:29,520 --> 02:39:30,480 >> because the lane is 17-foot 13140 02:39:30,480 --> 02:39:30,480 13141 02:39:30,480 --> 02:39:30,480 wide? 13142 02:39:30,480 --> 02:39:34,224 >> it's right there by steven 13143 02:39:34,224 --> 02:39:34,224 kelly. 13144 02:39:34,224 --> 02:39:35,302 >> that was part of an 13145 02:39:35,302 --> 02:39:36,837 initiative a few years back to 13146 02:39:36,837 --> 02:39:36,837 13147 02:39:36,837 --> 02:39:38,024 prevent people from parking 13148 02:39:38,024 --> 02:39:38,024 there. 13149 02:39:38,024 --> 02:39:39,899 there are no parking signs and 13150 02:39:39,899 --> 02:39:39,899 13151 02:39:39,899 --> 02:39:43,296 the hatching is just to enforce 13152 02:39:43,296 --> 02:39:43,296 13153 02:39:43,296 --> 02:39:43,296 that. 13154 02:39:43,296 --> 02:39:44,275 >> I think that's my example o 13155 02:39:44,275 --> 02:39:44,275 f 13156 02:39:44,275 --> 02:39:45,369 that kind of quick build to see 13157 02:39:45,369 --> 02:39:45,369 13158 02:39:45,369 --> 02:39:47,538 how it goes, does it help, not 13159 02:39:47,538 --> 02:39:47,538 13160 02:39:47,538 --> 02:39:49,867 the millions of dollars where - 13161 02:39:49,867 --> 02:39:49,867 - 13162 02:39:49,867 --> 02:39:51,508 where there is -- because that 13163 02:39:51,508 --> 02:39:51,508 13164 02:39:51,508 --> 02:39:52,187 came I believe from community 13165 02:39:52,187 --> 02:39:53,283 feedback originally, right? 13166 02:39:53,283 --> 02:39:54,019 >> it came from the community 13167 02:39:54,019 --> 02:39:56,110 and gpd it was a request that 13168 02:39:56,110 --> 02:39:58,179 was facilitated from them to 13169 02:39:58,179 --> 02:39:59,910 public works to facilitate. 13170 02:39:59,910 --> 02:40:00,365 >> okay. 13171 02:40:00,365 --> 02:40:02,993 I just, I bring that out as an 13172 02:40:02,993 --> 02:40:02,993 13173 02:40:02,993 --> 02:40:04,955 example where we did a small 13174 02:40:04,955 --> 02:40:05,962 intervention to see if it 13175 02:40:05,962 --> 02:40:07,541 helped, and I don't know about 13176 02:40:07,541 --> 02:40:07,541 13177 02:40:07,541 --> 02:40:10,365 the feedback since then, but 13178 02:40:10,365 --> 02:40:12,098 because it's 17-foot wide lane 13179 02:40:12,098 --> 02:40:12,098 13180 02:40:12,098 --> 02:40:13,059 you could do that. 13181 02:40:13,059 --> 02:40:14,834 those lanes are way too wide. 13182 02:40:14,834 --> 02:40:19,671 one-way or another they need to 13183 02:40:19,671 --> 02:40:19,671 13184 02:40:19,671 --> 02:40:20,918 be narrowed pee people street I 13185 02:40:20,918 --> 02:40:20,918 t 13186 02:40:20,918 --> 02:40:22,757 like the -- so that people 13187 02:40:22,757 --> 02:40:25,010 street it treat it like the 13188 02:40:25,010 --> 02:40:26,447 neighborhood street it is. 13189 02:40:26,447 --> 02:40:27,395 thank you, mr. Mayor. 13190 02:40:27,395 --> 02:40:28,074 >> mayor: I would encourage 13191 02:40:28,074 --> 02:40:29,081 everybody let's not try to 13192 02:40:29,081 --> 02:40:30,275 design the road today because 13193 02:40:30,275 --> 02:40:31,219 that's not where we are in the 13194 02:40:31,219 --> 02:40:31,219 13195 02:40:31,219 --> 02:40:33,647 process at all. 13196 02:40:33,647 --> 02:40:42,119 there is. 13197 02:40:42,119 --> 02:40:43,393 we have three lights and we ar 13198 02:40:43,393 --> 02:40:43,393 e 13199 02:40:43,393 --> 02:40:45,088 trying to hear from the public, 13200 02:40:45,088 --> 02:40:45,088 13201 02:40:45,088 --> 02:40:46,833 but we are not in that phase. 13202 02:40:46,833 --> 02:40:48,328 >> yes, mayor, I'm not in the 13203 02:40:48,328 --> 02:40:49,232 design phase, either, so thank 13204 02:40:49,232 --> 02:40:49,232 13205 02:40:49,232 --> 02:40:50,660 you to staff and thank you to 13206 02:40:50,660 --> 02:40:52,836 nv5 for providing some 13207 02:40:52,836 --> 02:40:56,400 conceptual plans and ideas. 13208 02:40:56,400 --> 02:40:57,339 it's a great start. 13209 02:40:57,339 --> 02:40:59,768 commissioner dunker walker sai 13210 02:40:59,768 --> 02:40:59,768 d 13211 02:40:59,768 --> 02:41:03,640 that -- duncan-walker. 13212 02:41:03,640 --> 02:41:05,579 2700 block of northeast 8th 13213 02:41:05,579 --> 02:41:07,521 avenue wants to do all the way 13214 02:41:07,521 --> 02:41:07,521 13215 02:41:07,521 --> 02:41:09,915 to 9th street, the 900 block, 13216 02:41:09,915 --> 02:41:12,557 and so the designs are great. 13217 02:41:12,557 --> 02:41:14,267 but there is a number of 13218 02:41:14,267 --> 02:41:15,734 faith-based and community and 13219 02:41:15,734 --> 02:41:18,619 resident leaders here, and, and 13220 02:41:18,619 --> 02:41:18,619 13221 02:41:18,619 --> 02:41:20,253 they'll be great opportunity t 13222 02:41:20,253 --> 02:41:20,253 o 13223 02:41:20,253 --> 02:41:21,234 reach out through those 13224 02:41:21,234 --> 02:41:22,334 networks, especially the 13225 02:41:22,334 --> 02:41:23,365 churches because there's five 13226 02:41:23,365 --> 02:41:25,133 churches right there on the 13227 02:41:25,133 --> 02:41:26,926 northeast 8th avenue -- 13228 02:41:26,926 --> 02:41:31,709 >> northeast 8th avenue. 13229 02:41:31,709 --> 02:41:32,319 >> 808. 13230 02:41:32,319 --> 02:41:33,477 >> what she said. 13231 02:41:33,477 --> 02:41:33,477 8. 13232 02:41:33,477 --> 02:41:36,009 so, I was thinking from 13233 02:41:36,009 --> 02:41:38,841 northeast from 15th street to 13234 02:41:38,841 --> 02:41:39,735 25th street there were five 13235 02:41:39,735 --> 02:41:40,242 right there. 13236 02:41:40,242 --> 02:41:41,285 did I miss -- there are three 13237 02:41:41,285 --> 02:41:41,285 more? 13238 02:41:41,285 --> 02:41:41,285 okay. 13239 02:41:41,285 --> 02:41:44,880 so to those other three churche 13240 02:41:44,880 --> 02:41:44,880 s 13241 02:41:44,880 --> 02:41:48,124 sorry because I know there are 13242 02:41:48,124 --> 02:41:48,124 13243 02:41:48,124 --> 02:41:48,383 five at least. 13244 02:41:48,383 --> 02:41:48,843 at least that many. 13245 02:41:48,843 --> 02:41:51,099 but -- to get information so I'm 13246 02:41:51,099 --> 02:41:51,099 13247 02:41:51,099 --> 02:41:53,225 very interested in hearing wha 13248 02:41:53,225 --> 02:41:53,225 t 13249 02:41:53,225 --> 02:41:54,427 the people who are here have t 13250 02:41:54,427 --> 02:41:54,427 o 13251 02:41:54,427 --> 02:41:57,263 say about the designs, what the 13252 02:41:57,263 --> 02:41:57,263 y 13253 02:41:57,263 --> 02:41:58,337 may be interested in and the 13254 02:41:58,337 --> 02:41:59,386 mechanisms that we're going to 13255 02:41:59,386 --> 02:41:59,386 13256 02:41:59,386 --> 02:42:00,243 do to find out more. 13257 02:42:00,243 --> 02:42:01,096 at one question for you, 13258 02:42:01,096 --> 02:42:03,839 mr. Manager, before we hear fro 13259 02:42:03,839 --> 02:42:03,839 m 13260 02:42:03,839 --> 02:42:05,371 I hope we go right to public. 13261 02:42:05,371 --> 02:42:07,880 they've been waiting for a lon 13262 02:42:07,880 --> 02:42:07,880 g 13263 02:42:07,880 --> 02:42:07,880 time. 13264 02:42:07,880 --> 02:42:10,985 is if all we did today, I felt 13265 02:42:10,985 --> 02:42:10,985 13266 02:42:10,985 --> 02:42:11,815 no pressure to make a decision 13267 02:42:11,815 --> 02:42:11,815 13268 02:42:11,815 --> 02:42:13,145 today, none at all, especially 13269 02:42:13,145 --> 02:42:13,145 13270 02:42:13,145 --> 02:42:15,422 the folks showing up, 13271 02:42:15,422 --> 02:42:16,516 if all w did was say okay, 13272 02:42:16,516 --> 02:42:19,649 let's get some more robust 13273 02:42:19,649 --> 02:42:20,463 information, that would not 13274 02:42:20,463 --> 02:42:21,455 require a motion because that' 13275 02:42:21,455 --> 02:42:21,455 s 13276 02:42:21,455 --> 02:42:23,171 something you would do on in th 13277 02:42:23,171 --> 02:42:23,171 e 13278 02:42:23,171 --> 02:42:24,627 diseme of things or would you b 13279 02:42:24,627 --> 02:42:24,627 e 13280 02:42:24,627 --> 02:42:25,428 looking for something from 13281 02:42:25,428 --> 02:42:27,497 someone on the dais? 13282 02:42:27,497 --> 02:42:28,259 >> I think a motion would be 13283 02:42:28,259 --> 02:42:28,259 appropriate. 13284 02:42:28,259 --> 02:42:30,335 >> okay. 13285 02:42:30,335 --> 02:42:30,589 all right. 13286 02:42:30,589 --> 02:42:31,493 well that's something to 13287 02:42:31,493 --> 02:42:31,493 consider. 13288 02:42:31,493 --> 02:42:34,797 I'd love to hear from all the 13289 02:42:34,797 --> 02:42:36,586 people who've probably been 13290 02:42:36,586 --> 02:42:37,848 waiting for a while, mr. Mayor. 13291 02:42:37,848 --> 02:42:37,848 13292 02:42:37,848 --> 02:42:38,369 >> mayor: thank you, 13293 02:42:38,369 --> 02:42:38,793 commissioner book. 13294 02:42:38,793 --> 02:42:41,611 commissioner ingle. 13295 02:42:41,611 --> 02:42:42,608 >> just kind of short and sweet 13296 02:42:42,608 --> 02:42:42,608 13297 02:42:42,608 --> 02:42:42,911 on this. 13298 02:42:42,911 --> 02:42:44,065 it certainly sounds like the 13299 02:42:44,065 --> 02:42:45,114 community doesn't feel like it' 13300 02:42:45,114 --> 02:42:45,114 s 13301 02:42:45,114 --> 02:42:47,185 been heard. 13302 02:42:47,185 --> 02:42:48,811 look forward to hearing public 13303 02:42:48,811 --> 02:42:48,811 13304 02:42:48,811 --> 02:42:50,917 comment on this, but in general 13305 02:42:50,917 --> 02:42:50,917 13306 02:42:50,917 --> 02:42:53,083 my first kind of reaction is 13307 02:42:53,083 --> 02:42:54,533 just the inclination to table 13308 02:42:54,533 --> 02:42:56,393 this until we've got some bette 13309 02:42:56,393 --> 02:42:56,393 r 13310 02:42:56,393 --> 02:42:58,566 community feedback. 13311 02:42:58,566 --> 02:42:59,939 we don't have construction fun 13312 02:42:59,939 --> 02:42:59,939 ds 13313 02:42:59,939 --> 02:43:00,323 for it. 13314 02:43:00,323 --> 02:43:01,222 there is nothing pressing. 13315 02:43:01,222 --> 02:43:03,407 there is no thing going on so 13316 02:43:03,407 --> 02:43:03,407 as 13317 02:43:03,407 --> 02:43:04,247 far as I can see there is no 13318 02:43:04,247 --> 02:43:08,663 downside to tabling this and 13319 02:43:08,663 --> 02:43:09,835 getting some better community 13320 02:43:09,835 --> 02:43:11,938 feedback on that. 13321 02:43:11,938 --> 02:43:13,043 that being said, I'm sure there 13322 02:43:13,043 --> 02:43:13,043 13323 02:43:13,043 --> 02:43:13,927 are a lot of people here to tal 13324 02:43:13,927 --> 02:43:13,927 k 13325 02:43:13,927 --> 02:43:17,305 so I will be happy to hear fro 13326 02:43:17,305 --> 02:43:17,305 m 13327 02:43:17,305 --> 02:43:18,074 them now. 13328 02:43:18,074 --> 02:43:18,790 >> mayor: commissioner duncan 13329 02:43:18,790 --> 02:43:20,493 and then I've gut a brief 13330 02:43:20,493 --> 02:43:21,349 comment and then we will go to 13331 02:43:21,349 --> 02:43:21,349 13332 02:43:21,349 --> 02:43:21,787 the public. 13333 02:43:21,787 --> 02:43:22,883 >> thank you, mr. Mayor, and I 13334 02:43:22,883 --> 02:43:22,883 13335 02:43:22,883 --> 02:43:23,923 know I said y wasn't going to 13336 02:43:23,923 --> 02:43:25,287 say anything until after the 13337 02:43:25,287 --> 02:43:25,287 public. 13338 02:43:25,287 --> 02:43:27,592 I lied. 13339 02:43:27,592 --> 02:43:29,222 but only to say this. 13340 02:43:29,222 --> 02:43:30,435 it is important to consider the 13341 02:43:30,435 --> 02:43:30,435 13342 02:43:30,435 --> 02:43:33,067 functionality of this street. 13343 02:43:33,067 --> 02:43:35,995 not just the street where peopl 13344 02:43:35,995 --> 02:43:35,995 e 13345 02:43:35,995 --> 02:43:36,998 just drive past. 13346 02:43:36,998 --> 02:43:38,199 there are a number of activitie 13347 02:43:38,199 --> 02:43:38,199 s 13348 02:43:38,199 --> 02:43:39,832 that take place on this street, 13349 02:43:39,832 --> 02:43:39,832 13350 02:43:39,832 --> 02:43:40,928 and what I would've been 13351 02:43:40,928 --> 02:43:43,101 interested in hearing in today 13352 02:43:43,101 --> 02:43:43,101 's 13353 02:43:43,101 --> 02:43:44,735 conversation since your 13354 02:43:44,735 --> 02:43:46,183 recommendation is to get us to 13355 02:43:46,183 --> 02:43:46,183 13356 02:43:46,183 --> 02:43:49,015 do something today that I'm not 13357 02:43:49,015 --> 02:43:49,015 13358 02:43:49,015 --> 02:43:50,458 interested in doing, I would'v 13359 02:43:50,458 --> 02:43:50,458 e 13360 02:43:50,458 --> 02:43:52,517 been interested in you telling 13361 02:43:52,517 --> 02:43:52,517 13362 02:43:52,517 --> 02:43:53,817 us how much on-street parking 13363 02:43:53,817 --> 02:43:55,150 there currently is. 13364 02:43:55,150 --> 02:43:56,996 because many of the eight 13365 02:43:56,996 --> 02:43:58,656 churches that I just told you 13366 02:43:58,656 --> 02:44:00,093 there were on northeast 8th 13367 02:44:00,093 --> 02:44:01,485 avenue take advantage of that 13368 02:44:01,485 --> 02:44:02,500 onstreit parking. 13369 02:44:02,500 --> 02:44:04,895 not just for sunday services o 13370 02:44:04,895 --> 02:44:04,895 r 13371 02:44:04,895 --> 02:44:05,997 saturday services at the 7th 13372 02:44:05,997 --> 02:44:07,965 day adventant church but for t 13373 02:44:07,965 --> 02:44:07,965 he 13374 02:44:07,965 --> 02:44:09,595 mere yatd of services that -- 13375 02:44:09,595 --> 02:44:10,211 myriad of services they 13376 02:44:10,211 --> 02:44:10,211 provide. 13377 02:44:10,211 --> 02:44:11,806 many of the residents in that 13378 02:44:11,806 --> 02:44:18,685 community utilize thrking -- p 13379 02:44:18,685 --> 02:44:18,685 ark 13380 02:44:18,685 --> 02:44:25,287 there -- there was a slide in 13381 02:44:25,287 --> 02:44:26,913 the public works presentation a 13382 02:44:26,913 --> 02:44:26,913 13383 02:44:26,913 --> 02:44:28,805 little bit earlier today, and I 13384 02:44:28,805 --> 02:44:28,805 13385 02:44:28,805 --> 02:44:29,737 don't -- you don't have to pul 13386 02:44:29,737 --> 02:44:29,737 l 13387 02:44:29,737 --> 02:44:31,557 it up right now, but it was on 13388 02:44:31,557 --> 02:44:31,557 13389 02:44:31,557 --> 02:44:32,597 page 53. 13390 02:44:32,597 --> 02:44:33,959 I wrote it down during your 13391 02:44:33,959 --> 02:44:36,217 presentation bots because I 13392 02:44:36,217 --> 02:44:37,102 thought about asking the 13393 02:44:37,102 --> 02:44:38,363 question then, but I said no 13394 02:44:38,363 --> 02:44:39,049 we're going to have this 13395 02:44:39,049 --> 02:44:39,871 conversation a little bit later 13396 02:44:39,871 --> 02:44:39,871 13397 02:44:39,871 --> 02:44:41,049 on today and perhaps I'll be 13398 02:44:41,049 --> 02:44:43,467 able to get that information 13399 02:44:43,467 --> 02:44:43,467 then. 13400 02:44:43,467 --> 02:44:45,239 don't find it now but just kno 13401 02:44:45,239 --> 02:44:45,239 w 13402 02:44:45,239 --> 02:44:47,305 on page 53 of the previous 13403 02:44:47,305 --> 02:44:49,401 public works conversation you 13404 02:44:49,401 --> 02:44:51,335 told us about the northwest 13405 02:44:51,335 --> 02:44:55,105 1st avenue resurfacing, and 13406 02:44:55,105 --> 02:44:56,713 I'm very curious to know how y 13407 02:44:56,713 --> 02:44:56,713 ou 13408 02:44:56,713 --> 02:44:58,916 incorporated or how you're 13409 02:44:58,916 --> 02:45:00,101 looking at a completed so how 13410 02:45:00,101 --> 02:45:02,945 did you incorporate multimodal 13411 02:45:02,945 --> 02:45:02,945 13412 02:45:02,945 --> 02:45:02,945 there. 13413 02:45:02,945 --> 02:45:04,811 because don't tell me right 13414 02:45:04,811 --> 02:45:04,811 now. 13415 02:45:04,811 --> 02:45:07,518 don't tell me right now. 13416 02:45:07,518 --> 02:45:09,477 but I want you to show me. 13417 02:45:09,477 --> 02:45:10,200 don't tell me. 13418 02:45:10,200 --> 02:45:13,770 show me. 13419 02:45:13,770 --> 02:45:14,877 northwest 1st avenue is a 13420 02:45:14,877 --> 02:45:16,737 tiny street. 13421 02:45:16,737 --> 02:45:19,671 northeast 8th avenue east of 13422 02:45:19,671 --> 02:45:22,337 waldo road is strange. 13423 02:45:22,337 --> 02:45:24,115 and the reason that it expands 13424 02:45:24,115 --> 02:45:24,115 13425 02:45:24,115 --> 02:45:25,676 is to accommodate traffic -- I 13426 02:45:25,676 --> 02:45:25,676 13427 02:45:25,676 --> 02:45:27,084 think the engineering there 13428 02:45:27,084 --> 02:45:28,989 waserary wise, and I think it 13429 02:45:28,989 --> 02:45:29,755 should remain exactly how it is 13430 02:45:29,755 --> 02:45:29,755 13431 02:45:29,755 --> 02:45:30,780 right now. 13432 02:45:30,780 --> 02:45:34,292 because it helps to facilitate 13433 02:45:34,292 --> 02:45:34,292 13434 02:45:34,292 --> 02:45:35,160 everything that goes on in tha 13435 02:45:35,160 --> 02:45:35,160 t 13436 02:45:35,160 --> 02:45:35,160 community. 13437 02:45:35,160 --> 02:45:37,448 where there is church activity, 13438 02:45:37,448 --> 02:45:37,448 13439 02:45:37,448 --> 02:45:39,326 the road expands, and where 13440 02:45:39,326 --> 02:45:40,430 there are buses, the road 13441 02:45:40,430 --> 02:45:41,492 expands to allow for on-street 13442 02:45:41,492 --> 02:45:41,492 13443 02:45:41,492 --> 02:45:41,492 parking. 13444 02:45:41,492 --> 02:45:44,793 and the traffic can continue t 13445 02:45:44,793 --> 02:45:44,793 o 13446 02:45:44,793 --> 02:45:45,657 move through without 13447 02:45:45,657 --> 02:45:45,657 congestion. 13448 02:45:45,657 --> 02:45:48,159 and without problems. 13449 02:45:48,159 --> 02:45:49,495 keeping safety in mind. 13450 02:45:49,495 --> 02:45:51,483 it then narrows again after 13451 02:45:51,483 --> 02:45:53,023 duval and I'm glad that it was 13452 02:45:53,023 --> 02:45:53,023 13453 02:45:53,023 --> 02:45:55,835 noted that yes, duval is still 13454 02:45:55,835 --> 02:45:55,835 13455 02:45:55,835 --> 02:45:56,507 in play. 13456 02:45:56,507 --> 02:45:58,571 it is not closing. 13457 02:45:58,571 --> 02:45:59,777 and I don't believe a 13458 02:45:59,777 --> 02:46:00,511 conversation with the school 13459 02:46:00,511 --> 02:46:02,948 board has been had to learn wha 13460 02:46:02,948 --> 02:46:02,948 t 13461 02:46:02,948 --> 02:46:04,375 their plans are. 13462 02:46:04,375 --> 02:46:05,883 and how we need to incorporate 13463 02:46:05,883 --> 02:46:05,883 13464 02:46:05,883 --> 02:46:07,653 what those plans are in our 13465 02:46:07,653 --> 02:46:09,701 transportation plans for the 13466 02:46:09,701 --> 02:46:09,701 street. 13467 02:46:09,701 --> 02:46:11,159 I'm going to close my mouth 13468 02:46:11,159 --> 02:46:11,159 now. 13469 02:46:11,159 --> 02:46:13,833 I have a lot mthat I could 13470 02:46:13,833 --> 02:46:15,099 say, but I felt the need to 13471 02:46:15,099 --> 02:46:17,433 bring those things before my 13472 02:46:17,433 --> 02:46:18,059 constituents had the opportuni 13473 02:46:18,059 --> 02:46:18,059 ty 13474 02:46:18,059 --> 02:46:18,873 to speak and anybody else who 13475 02:46:18,873 --> 02:46:23,526 wants to speak on this because 13476 02:46:23,526 --> 02:46:23,526 13477 02:46:23,526 --> 02:46:28,672 this is a major issue. 13478 02:46:28,672 --> 02:46:30,206 nobody needs to talk about 8th 13479 02:46:30,206 --> 02:46:30,206 13480 02:46:30,206 --> 02:46:31,071 avenue needing to be 13481 02:46:31,071 --> 02:46:31,071 resurfaced. 13482 02:46:31,071 --> 02:46:33,995 I think I asked you in our 13483 02:46:33,995 --> 02:46:35,095 meeting the other day how long 13484 02:46:35,095 --> 02:46:35,095 13485 02:46:35,095 --> 02:46:37,691 it's been. 13486 02:46:37,691 --> 02:46:39,153 20 years? 13487 02:46:39,153 --> 02:46:41,066 it's been a very, very long tim 13488 02:46:41,066 --> 02:46:41,066 e 13489 02:46:41,066 --> 02:46:41,949 since that road has been 13490 02:46:41,949 --> 02:46:41,949 addressed. 13491 02:46:41,949 --> 02:46:46,757 if I had a dime for every time 13492 02:46:46,757 --> 02:46:46,757 13493 02:46:46,757 --> 02:46:50,139 am faal family asked me abo 13494 02:46:50,139 --> 02:46:50,139 ut 13495 02:46:50,139 --> 02:46:51,287 when that road was going to be 13496 02:46:51,287 --> 02:46:51,287 13497 02:46:51,287 --> 02:46:55,963 resurfaced, I would be rich. 13498 02:46:55,963 --> 02:46:56,829 I'm glad we're going to do 13499 02:46:56,829 --> 02:46:56,829 that. 13500 02:46:56,829 --> 02:46:59,203 I think that's a given. 13501 02:46:59,203 --> 02:47:00,673 that's the no-brainer part. 13502 02:47:00,673 --> 02:47:02,303 it's everything else that 13503 02:47:02,303 --> 02:47:03,642 everyone else has questions 13504 02:47:03,642 --> 02:47:03,642 about. 13505 02:47:03,642 --> 02:47:05,173 everyone else even has 13506 02:47:05,173 --> 02:47:06,009 questions -- there are a numbe 13507 02:47:06,009 --> 02:47:06,009 r 13508 02:47:06,009 --> 02:47:07,197 of people who don't want to se 13509 02:47:07,197 --> 02:47:07,197 e 13510 02:47:07,197 --> 02:47:08,912 the street narrowed. 13511 02:47:08,912 --> 02:47:11,613 and we need to hear that. 13512 02:47:11,613 --> 02:47:12,718 I understand that there is a 13513 02:47:12,718 --> 02:47:14,383 belief that narrowing a road 13514 02:47:14,383 --> 02:47:15,882 would control speed. 13515 02:47:15,882 --> 02:47:17,658 maybe, maybe not. 13516 02:47:17,658 --> 02:47:18,619 but those are the conversations 13517 02:47:18,619 --> 02:47:18,619 13518 02:47:18,619 --> 02:47:20,058 that you need to have the 13519 02:47:20,058 --> 02:47:21,152 opportunity to have with the 13520 02:47:21,152 --> 02:47:21,152 people. 13521 02:47:21,152 --> 02:47:23,659 I'll conclude for now and then 13522 02:47:23,659 --> 02:47:23,659 13523 02:47:23,659 --> 02:47:25,089 I'll come back afterwards. 13524 02:47:25,089 --> 02:47:25,724 thank you, commissioner 13525 02:47:25,724 --> 02:47:25,724 duncan-walker. 13526 02:47:25,724 --> 02:47:27,910 so I just have a couple of 13527 02:47:27,910 --> 02:47:28,693 comments and then we'll hear 13528 02:47:28,693 --> 02:47:34,742 from you all. 13529 02:47:34,742 --> 02:47:35,821 so the two things that are dea 13530 02:47:35,821 --> 02:47:35,821 l 13531 02:47:35,821 --> 02:47:36,877 breakers for me when we finally 13532 02:47:36,877 --> 02:47:36,877 13533 02:47:36,877 --> 02:47:38,439 get around to voting on 13534 02:47:38,439 --> 02:47:40,221 something about actual design, 13535 02:47:40,221 --> 02:47:40,221 13536 02:47:40,221 --> 02:47:41,913 which is not today, it's a goo 13537 02:47:41,913 --> 02:47:41,913 d 13538 02:47:41,913 --> 02:47:44,151 way ways off, the two things 13539 02:47:44,151 --> 02:47:45,882 that are deal breakers for me 13540 02:47:45,882 --> 02:47:48,218 are number one, safety, it has 13541 02:47:48,218 --> 02:47:48,218 13542 02:47:48,218 --> 02:47:49,851 to be a safer street. 13543 02:47:49,851 --> 02:47:50,920 fewer people have to git 13544 02:47:50,920 --> 02:47:53,983 has to be the sort of thing th 13545 02:47:53,983 --> 02:47:53,983 at 13546 02:47:53,983 --> 02:47:54,761 people are less likely to get 13547 02:47:54,761 --> 02:47:55,969 hurt on. 13548 02:47:55,969 --> 02:47:59,265 I don't have data to corroborate 13549 02:47:59,265 --> 02:47:59,265 13550 02:47:59,265 --> 02:48:01,329 this but I would bet 41 injurie 13551 02:48:01,329 --> 02:48:01,329 s 13552 02:48:01,329 --> 02:48:02,529 is more than we would normally 13553 02:48:02,529 --> 02:48:02,529 13554 02:48:02,529 --> 02:48:04,267 expect on a two-lane street. 13555 02:48:04,267 --> 02:48:06,229 over a five-year period. 13556 02:48:06,229 --> 02:48:11,273 I want a safer street. 13557 02:48:11,273 --> 02:48:12,809 safe dozen always feel like 13558 02:48:12,809 --> 02:48:15,341 what -- safe doesn't always fee 13559 02:48:15,341 --> 02:48:15,341 l 13560 02:48:15,341 --> 02:48:16,885 like what the data tell us, tha 13561 02:48:16,885 --> 02:48:16,885 t 13562 02:48:16,885 --> 02:48:18,107 safe doesn't always feel like 13563 02:48:18,107 --> 02:48:19,309 what we want it to feel like. 13564 02:48:19,309 --> 02:48:20,917 slower is safer. 13565 02:48:20,917 --> 02:48:22,935 there's no way to argue with th 13566 02:48:22,935 --> 02:48:22,935 e 13567 02:48:22,935 --> 02:48:23,779 physics of that. 13568 02:48:23,779 --> 02:48:25,985 slower is safer. 13569 02:48:25,985 --> 02:48:27,453 and talking about a relatively 13570 02:48:27,453 --> 02:48:27,453 13571 02:48:27,453 --> 02:48:30,939 short road, if it's, if it tak 13572 02:48:30,939 --> 02:48:30,939 es 13573 02:48:30,939 --> 02:48:33,325 you, takes anybody a shorter a 13574 02:48:33,325 --> 02:48:33,325 13575 02:48:33,325 --> 02:48:34,427 little bit longer to get where 13576 02:48:34,427 --> 02:48:34,427 13577 02:48:34,427 --> 02:48:35,407 we're going, a minute or so 13578 02:48:35,407 --> 02:48:36,933 longer to get where we're going 13579 02:48:36,933 --> 02:48:36,933 , 13580 02:48:36,933 --> 02:48:38,249 and people don't die as a 13581 02:48:38,249 --> 02:48:39,421 result, twel that's a good 13582 02:48:39,421 --> 02:48:39,421 thing. 13583 02:48:39,421 --> 02:48:43,941 safer is the number one thing. 13584 02:48:43,941 --> 02:48:43,941 13585 02:48:43,941 --> 02:48:45,135 I also want to make sure that 13586 02:48:45,135 --> 02:48:48,407 whatever gets done adds to the 13587 02:48:48,407 --> 02:48:48,407 13588 02:48:48,407 --> 02:48:50,912 value of the neighborhoods. 13589 02:48:50,912 --> 02:48:52,181 that it does not detract from 13590 02:48:52,181 --> 02:48:53,551 the value of the neighborhoods 13591 02:48:53,551 --> 02:48:53,551 . 13592 02:48:53,551 --> 02:48:54,645 that means we need to save as 13593 02:48:54,645 --> 02:48:57,757 many trees as possible because 13594 02:48:57,757 --> 02:48:57,927 I 13595 02:48:57,927 --> 02:48:59,193 know we have a few realtors in 13596 02:48:59,193 --> 02:48:59,193 13597 02:48:59,193 --> 02:49:01,229 the room, there is no realtor 13598 02:49:01,229 --> 02:49:03,628 that will tell you fewer trees 13599 02:49:03,628 --> 02:49:03,628 13600 02:49:03,628 --> 02:49:05,691 makes property more valuable. 13601 02:49:05,691 --> 02:49:08,787 mature trees add to the value o 13602 02:49:08,787 --> 02:49:08,787 f 13603 02:49:08,787 --> 02:49:09,737 property so we don't want to 13604 02:49:09,737 --> 02:49:11,696 reduce the value of anybody's 13605 02:49:11,696 --> 02:49:11,696 property. 13606 02:49:11,696 --> 02:49:13,703 we want to increase it, but 13607 02:49:13,703 --> 02:49:16,006 mostly we want to be sure that 13608 02:49:16,006 --> 02:49:16,006 13609 02:49:16,006 --> 02:49:18,170 people don't get hurt on the 13610 02:49:18,170 --> 02:49:19,985 road if we can possibly avoid 13611 02:49:19,985 --> 02:49:19,985 it. 13612 02:49:19,985 --> 02:49:22,103 those are the two deal breaker 13613 02:49:22,103 --> 02:49:22,103 s 13614 02:49:22,103 --> 02:49:23,745 for me when we finally get 13615 02:49:23,745 --> 02:49:27,045 around to voting for something. 13616 02:49:27,045 --> 02:49:27,045 13617 02:49:27,045 --> 02:49:28,018 that's a long way off. 13618 02:49:28,018 --> 02:49:32,287 we need to hear from the 13619 02:49:32,287 --> 02:49:32,287 public. 13620 02:49:32,287 --> 02:49:38,289 we do have years of data and o 13621 02:49:38,289 --> 02:49:38,289 f, 13622 02:49:38,289 --> 02:49:40,727 you know, ability to check wit 13623 02:49:40,727 --> 02:49:40,727 h 13624 02:49:40,727 --> 02:49:43,226 other cities because we're not 13625 02:49:43,226 --> 02:49:43,226 13626 02:49:43,226 --> 02:49:44,141 all that special. 13627 02:49:44,141 --> 02:49:45,093 there are other cities just lik 13628 02:49:45,093 --> 02:49:45,093 e 13629 02:49:45,093 --> 02:49:45,093 us. 13630 02:49:45,093 --> 02:49:47,499 and we can tell what works in 13631 02:49:47,499 --> 02:49:49,167 other cities to make them safe. 13632 02:49:49,167 --> 02:49:49,167 13633 02:49:49,167 --> 02:49:51,037 and what keeps people alive, 13634 02:49:51,037 --> 02:49:53,133 what keeps people not hurt on 13635 02:49:53,133 --> 02:49:54,637 our streets. 13636 02:49:54,637 --> 02:49:55,843 we have plenty of time for all 13637 02:49:55,843 --> 02:49:55,843 13638 02:49:55,843 --> 02:49:59,141 of that, and I want to make sure 13639 02:49:59,141 --> 02:49:59,141 13640 02:49:59,141 --> 02:50:01,047 that we include all of that wit 13641 02:50:01,047 --> 02:50:01,047 h 13642 02:50:01,047 --> 02:50:04,352 also the idea that the longer w 13643 02:50:04,352 --> 02:50:04,352 e 13644 02:50:04,352 --> 02:50:06,250 take to make it a safer street 13645 02:50:06,250 --> 02:50:06,250 13646 02:50:06,250 --> 02:50:08,081 the more people get hurt on tha 13647 02:50:08,081 --> 02:50:08,081 t 13648 02:50:08,081 --> 02:50:08,081 street. 13649 02:50:08,081 --> 02:50:11,263 and is it is a street that has 13650 02:50:11,263 --> 02:50:11,263 13651 02:50:11,263 --> 02:50:14,661 lots of kids on it. 13652 02:50:14,661 --> 02:50:18,760 I mean there are just lots of 13653 02:50:18,760 --> 02:50:18,760 kids. 13654 02:50:18,760 --> 02:50:19,877 we want lots of kids on the 13655 02:50:19,877 --> 02:50:19,877 street. 13656 02:50:19,877 --> 02:50:21,365 I'm very familiar with 8th 13657 02:50:21,365 --> 02:50:21,365 avenue. 13658 02:50:21,365 --> 02:50:24,301 and no, they're not all riding 13659 02:50:24,301 --> 02:50:24,301 13660 02:50:24,301 --> 02:50:25,509 their bike to duval. 13661 02:50:25,509 --> 02:50:26,703 we all understand that. 13662 02:50:26,703 --> 02:50:29,107 but there are a lot of kids in 13663 02:50:29,107 --> 02:50:29,107 13664 02:50:29,107 --> 02:50:29,791 the neighborhood, a lot of kid 13665 02:50:29,791 --> 02:50:29,791 s 13666 02:50:29,791 --> 02:50:32,177 on the street, and we want the 13667 02:50:32,177 --> 02:50:32,177 m 13668 02:50:32,177 --> 02:50:33,550 to grow up to be adults who can 13669 02:50:33,550 --> 02:50:33,550 13670 02:50:33,550 --> 02:50:34,481 come to a city commission 13671 02:50:34,481 --> 02:50:34,481 meeting. 13672 02:50:34,481 --> 02:50:38,363 so those are the things that a 13673 02:50:38,363 --> 02:50:38,363 re 13674 02:50:38,363 --> 02:50:40,103 foremost in my mind as we move 13675 02:50:40,103 --> 02:50:40,103 13676 02:50:40,103 --> 02:50:40,103 forward. 13677 02:50:40,103 --> 02:50:43,353 so I'm asking you all to step 13678 02:50:43,353 --> 02:50:44,131 out of the way and let's hear 13679 02:50:44,131 --> 02:50:44,787 from the public. 13680 02:50:44,787 --> 02:50:47,199 >> yes, mr. Mayor, and y us 13681 02:50:47,199 --> 02:50:47,241 I 13682 02:50:47,241 --> 02:50:49,000 just wanted to let every bn 13683 02:50:49,000 --> 02:50:49,673 13684 02:50:49,673 --> 02:50:50,999 everyone know that everyone who 13685 02:50:50,999 --> 02:50:50,999 13686 02:50:50,999 --> 02:50:52,783 was down in room 16 has been 13687 02:50:52,783 --> 02:50:54,841 able to come up and find seats. 13688 02:50:54,841 --> 02:50:54,841 13689 02:50:54,841 --> 02:50:59,335 room 16 is empty. 13690 02:50:59,335 --> 02:51:00,065 I'm going to say a few names - 13691 02:51:00,065 --> 02:51:00,065 - 13692 02:51:00,065 --> 02:51:00,914 people who signed up on deck t 13693 02:51:00,914 --> 02:51:00,914 o 13694 02:51:00,914 --> 02:51:02,789 come up to the podium. 13695 02:51:02,789 --> 02:51:04,297 pamela anderson followed by 13696 02:51:04,297 --> 02:51:11,749 carolyn eason and then juanita 13697 02:51:11,749 --> 02:51:11,749 13698 02:51:11,749 --> 02:51:13,721 miles hamilton. 13699 02:51:13,721 --> 02:51:19,923 is pamela here? 13700 02:51:19,923 --> 02:51:22,321 >> mayor: welcome. 13701 02:51:22,321 --> 02:51:24,099 >> afternoon, commissioners. 13702 02:51:24,099 --> 02:51:27,601 my respect to all of you. 13703 02:51:27,601 --> 02:51:30,913 whether when I first heard a 13704 02:51:30,913 --> 02:51:30,913 bout 13705 02:51:30,913 --> 02:51:32,113 the plan for the improvements o 13706 02:51:32,113 --> 02:51:32,113 f 13707 02:51:32,113 --> 02:51:34,675 8th avenue, I just happened to 13708 02:51:34,675 --> 02:51:34,675 13709 02:51:34,675 --> 02:51:37,681 be there at the time that they 13710 02:51:37,681 --> 02:51:37,681 13711 02:51:37,681 --> 02:51:39,217 were at the, when the city com 13712 02:51:39,217 --> 02:51:39,217 es 13713 02:51:39,217 --> 02:51:41,723 out on the second monday at the 13714 02:51:41,723 --> 02:51:41,723 13715 02:51:41,723 --> 02:51:43,255 clarence kelly center. 13716 02:51:43,255 --> 02:51:44,594 I said well, why don't you com 13717 02:51:44,594 --> 02:51:44,594 e 13718 02:51:44,594 --> 02:51:46,853 to the seniors on the move at 13719 02:51:46,853 --> 02:51:48,957 clarence kelly center and 13720 02:51:48,957 --> 02:51:50,839 present that to them because 13721 02:51:50,839 --> 02:51:51,723 there are so many people that 13722 02:51:51,723 --> 02:51:53,657 don't know about this. 13723 02:51:53,657 --> 02:51:55,293 so from there we had those two 13724 02:51:55,293 --> 02:51:55,293 13725 02:51:55,293 --> 02:51:57,907 meetings, and with them, and I 13726 02:51:57,907 --> 02:51:57,907 13727 02:51:57,907 --> 02:52:00,369 saw some improvements over wha 13728 02:52:00,369 --> 02:52:00,369 t 13729 02:52:00,369 --> 02:52:03,767 was presented back then as 13730 02:52:03,767 --> 02:52:03,767 well. 13731 02:52:03,767 --> 02:52:05,836 I was against it, and still am 13732 02:52:05,836 --> 02:52:05,836 13733 02:52:05,836 --> 02:52:10,039 against the zippers, and the 13734 02:52:10,039 --> 02:52:14,217 bike lanes on this eastern 13735 02:52:14,217 --> 02:52:16,257 portion of 8th avenue because 13736 02:52:16,257 --> 02:52:19,119 seeing it every day and 13737 02:52:19,119 --> 02:52:21,907 traveling that corridor and 13738 02:52:21,907 --> 02:52:26,121 seeing how it was done over by 13739 02:52:26,121 --> 02:52:26,121 13740 02:52:26,121 --> 02:52:28,759 chestnut as far as the zippers 13741 02:52:28,759 --> 02:52:28,759 13742 02:52:28,759 --> 02:52:30,633 and the turn lane, the bike 13743 02:52:30,633 --> 02:52:33,031 lanes rather, and I'm going to 13744 02:52:33,031 --> 02:52:33,031 c 13745 02:52:33,031 --> 02:52:33,967 church twice a week over there 13746 02:52:33,967 --> 02:52:33,967 13747 02:52:33,967 --> 02:52:35,279 and seeing how dangerous this I 13748 02:52:35,279 --> 02:52:35,279 s 13749 02:52:35,279 --> 02:52:37,485 so I thought, we can't just -- 13750 02:52:37,485 --> 02:52:37,485 13751 02:52:37,485 --> 02:52:38,538 we got to find out what's going 13752 02:52:38,538 --> 02:52:38,538 13753 02:52:38,538 --> 02:52:41,037 on and why and we just wile 13754 02:52:41,037 --> 02:52:42,577 we're just hearing about this 13755 02:52:42,577 --> 02:52:42,577 plan. 13756 02:52:42,577 --> 02:52:49,901 I understand safety and the 13757 02:52:49,901 --> 02:52:50,855 children, I'm all for children 13758 02:52:50,855 --> 02:52:50,855 13759 02:52:50,855 --> 02:52:51,949 and everybody being safe 13760 02:52:51,949 --> 02:52:53,617 certainly, but I don't think 13761 02:52:53,617 --> 02:52:55,731 that when it comes down to thi 13762 02:52:55,731 --> 02:52:55,731 s 13763 02:52:55,731 --> 02:52:59,623 portion of 8th avenue, I have 13764 02:52:59,623 --> 02:53:01,347 my sayings about the other 13765 02:53:01,347 --> 02:53:03,465 portion as well that I wouldn' 13766 02:53:03,465 --> 02:53:03,465 t 13767 02:53:03,465 --> 02:53:05,207 care to be talking about right 13768 02:53:05,207 --> 02:53:05,207 13769 02:53:05,207 --> 02:53:06,735 now but going threw thet 13770 02:53:06,735 --> 02:53:08,603 roundabout at -- through that 13771 02:53:08,603 --> 02:53:10,345 roundabout at night, but I'm 13772 02:53:10,345 --> 02:53:12,845 just saying as far as the east 13773 02:53:12,845 --> 02:53:12,845 13774 02:53:12,845 --> 02:53:14,374 8th avenue corridor, and it is 13775 02:53:14,374 --> 02:53:14,374 13776 02:53:14,374 --> 02:53:16,489 special and yes, there are a l 13777 02:53:16,489 --> 02:53:16,489 ot 13778 02:53:16,489 --> 02:53:18,227 of things that happen down the 13779 02:53:18,227 --> 02:53:18,227 re 13780 02:53:18,227 --> 02:53:20,111 on that street that people 13781 02:53:20,111 --> 02:53:21,647 didn't take into consideration 13782 02:53:21,647 --> 02:53:21,647 13783 02:53:21,647 --> 02:53:23,283 and maybe they've looked into I 13784 02:53:23,283 --> 02:53:23,283 t 13785 02:53:23,283 --> 02:53:23,283 now. 13786 02:53:23,283 --> 02:53:25,585 I didn't see that data before 13787 02:53:25,585 --> 02:53:27,356 about the accidents and not tha 13788 02:53:27,356 --> 02:53:27,356 t 13789 02:53:27,356 --> 02:53:30,429 I've heard about that many 13790 02:53:30,429 --> 02:53:31,724 accidents on that part of 8th 13791 02:53:31,724 --> 02:53:31,724 avenue. 13792 02:53:31,724 --> 02:53:34,359 safety is a goal, and it's my 13793 02:53:34,359 --> 02:53:34,359 goal. 13794 02:53:34,359 --> 02:53:36,659 and there'll be other comments. 13795 02:53:36,659 --> 02:53:36,659 13796 02:53:36,659 --> 02:53:38,867 I don't want to be redundant b 13797 02:53:38,867 --> 02:53:38,867 ut 13798 02:53:38,867 --> 02:53:43,473 I was opposed to the bike lanes 13799 02:53:43,473 --> 02:53:45,111 , . 13800 02:53:45,111 --> 02:53:46,641 the traffic calming what they 13801 02:53:46,641 --> 02:53:48,837 talked about, those tables, 13802 02:53:48,837 --> 02:53:49,816 first when I saw the first pla 13803 02:53:49,816 --> 02:53:49,816 n 13804 02:53:49,816 --> 02:53:50,577 it was three of them. 13805 02:53:50,577 --> 02:53:53,311 I see it's been cut down to two 13806 02:53:53,311 --> 02:53:53,311 13807 02:53:53,311 --> 02:53:55,152 proposed median locations. 13808 02:53:55,152 --> 02:53:56,715 I am for the flashing lights. 13809 02:53:56,715 --> 02:53:59,683 the beacons for crossing the 13810 02:53:59,683 --> 02:54:02,270 roadway, put as many as you can 13811 02:54:02,270 --> 02:54:02,270 13812 02:54:02,270 --> 02:54:02,933 down there. 13813 02:54:02,933 --> 02:54:04,927 I am all for that. 13814 02:54:04,927 --> 02:54:06,791 but there's those few other 13815 02:54:06,791 --> 02:54:09,393 things that pertains to as far 13816 02:54:09,393 --> 02:54:09,393 13817 02:54:09,393 --> 02:54:12,095 as the traffic flow, that's a 13818 02:54:12,095 --> 02:54:13,577 different thing. 13819 02:54:13,577 --> 02:54:16,823 as far as those are my, what I 13820 02:54:16,823 --> 02:54:16,823 13821 02:54:16,823 --> 02:54:18,071 see after 50 years of living 13822 02:54:18,071 --> 02:54:20,471 down there in cedar grove, whi 13823 02:54:20,471 --> 02:54:20,471 ch 13824 02:54:20,471 --> 02:54:23,310 they say duval, my neighborhood 13825 02:54:23,310 --> 02:54:23,310 13826 02:54:23,310 --> 02:54:26,717 is cedar grove part 1, but wha 13827 02:54:26,717 --> 02:54:26,717 t 13828 02:54:26,717 --> 02:54:29,449 I see for 50 years of going bac 13829 02:54:29,449 --> 02:54:29,449 k 13830 02:54:29,449 --> 02:54:31,419 and forth, I've not heard of 13831 02:54:31,419 --> 02:54:32,721 that many people getting reall 13832 02:54:32,721 --> 02:54:32,721 y 13833 02:54:32,721 --> 02:54:32,721 hurt. 13834 02:54:32,721 --> 02:54:36,099 that, on that portion of 8th 13835 02:54:36,099 --> 02:54:36,099 avenue. 13836 02:54:36,099 --> 02:54:37,921 thank you. 13837 02:54:37,921 --> 02:54:39,597 >> mayor: thank you. 13838 02:54:39,597 --> 02:54:43,331 >> carolyn eason followed by 13839 02:54:43,331 --> 02:54:47,832 juanita miles -- I apologize. 13840 02:54:47,832 --> 02:54:49,698 juanita miles hamilton. 13841 02:54:49,698 --> 02:54:50,805 thank you for the correction. 13842 02:54:50,805 --> 02:54:51,536 >> mayor: welcome. 13843 02:54:51,536 --> 02:54:53,109 >> and kali blount. 13844 02:54:53,109 --> 02:54:54,639 >> thank you, juanita miles 13845 02:54:54,639 --> 02:54:54,639 hamilton. 13846 02:54:54,639 --> 02:55:01,219 and I'm standing today in 13847 02:55:01,219 --> 02:55:04,321 support, I hope it was a motio 13848 02:55:04,321 --> 02:55:04,321 n, 13849 02:55:04,321 --> 02:55:06,381 that there was not proper 13850 02:55:06,381 --> 02:55:08,965 community input from the staff 13851 02:55:08,965 --> 02:55:08,965 13852 02:55:08,965 --> 02:55:12,960 regarding this issue. 13853 02:55:12,960 --> 02:55:14,297 transparency, accountability, 13854 02:55:14,297 --> 02:55:16,939 and public involvement are 13855 02:55:16,939 --> 02:55:19,762 critical in decision making 13856 02:55:19,762 --> 02:55:19,762 processes. 13857 02:55:19,762 --> 02:55:25,491 gentrification at best, at 13858 02:55:25,491 --> 02:55:25,491 best. 13859 02:55:25,491 --> 02:55:30,843 I'm standing because of the fac 13860 02:55:30,843 --> 02:55:30,843 t 13861 02:55:30,843 --> 02:55:33,680 that the northwest 8th avenue 13862 02:55:33,680 --> 02:55:35,313 just yesterday I was traveling 13863 02:55:35,313 --> 02:55:35,513 a 13864 02:55:35,513 --> 02:55:35,513 sloppy. 13865 02:55:35,513 --> 02:55:41,319 and it creates a problem I've 13866 02:55:41,319 --> 02:55:42,659 sat and monitored the traffic 13867 02:55:42,659 --> 02:55:45,923 for several hours several times 13868 02:55:45,923 --> 02:55:45,923 13869 02:55:45,923 --> 02:55:47,934 a day different times of day 13870 02:55:47,934 --> 02:55:50,433 morning, noon, and evening and 13871 02:55:50,433 --> 02:55:50,433 13872 02:55:50,433 --> 02:55:52,619 pretty much I have yet to see a 13873 02:55:52,619 --> 02:55:52,619 13874 02:55:52,619 --> 02:55:57,669 bicycle on the bike lane. 13875 02:55:57,669 --> 02:55:59,977 and but yet it imposes a 13876 02:55:59,977 --> 02:55:59,977 problem. 13877 02:55:59,977 --> 02:56:02,508 just yesterday I was coming fro 13878 02:56:02,508 --> 02:56:02,508 m 13879 02:56:02,508 --> 02:56:06,447 therapy, and the traffic was 13880 02:56:06,447 --> 02:56:06,982 flowing good. 13881 02:56:06,982 --> 02:56:08,083 it was right at 5:00. 13882 02:56:08,083 --> 02:56:09,945 a lot of traffic. 13883 02:56:09,945 --> 02:56:14,914 and I was stuck headeeast on 13884 02:56:14,914 --> 02:56:17,494 8th avenue at northwest -- the 13885 02:56:17,494 --> 02:56:17,494 13886 02:56:17,494 --> 02:56:21,997 traffic suddenly stopped bec folk were cr 13887 02:56:21,997 --> 02:56:22,220 folk were crossing the lane -- 13888 02:56:22,220 --> 02:56:22,220 13889 02:56:22,220 --> 02:56:23,599 down the street. 13890 02:56:23,599 --> 02:56:25,467 stopped abruptly. 13891 02:56:25,467 --> 02:56:27,899 several other cars and myself 13892 02:56:27,899 --> 02:56:30,410 had to hit the bike lane to 13893 02:56:30,410 --> 02:56:33,043 get -- to stop from getting hit 13894 02:56:33,043 --> 02:56:33,043 13895 02:56:33,043 --> 02:56:35,437 with cars headed north on 6th 13896 02:56:35,437 --> 02:56:35,437 street. 13897 02:56:35,437 --> 02:56:39,685 the police department. 13898 02:56:39,685 --> 02:56:42,781 we were stuck out if the I 13899 02:56:42,781 --> 02:56:42,883 n the 13900 02:56:42,883 --> 02:56:42,883 lane. 13901 02:56:42,883 --> 02:56:44,723 the traffic light changed on u 13902 02:56:44,723 --> 02:56:44,723 s 13903 02:56:44,723 --> 02:56:45,828 because the traffic had abruptly 13904 02:56:45,828 --> 02:56:45,828 13905 02:56:45,828 --> 02:56:45,828 stopped. 13906 02:56:45,828 --> 02:56:47,153 it's a problem. 13907 02:56:47,153 --> 02:56:49,699 it is a problem. 13908 02:56:49,699 --> 02:56:51,199 I think that we need to revisit 13909 02:56:51,199 --> 02:56:51,199 13910 02:56:51,199 --> 02:56:53,255 our comp plan because in that 13911 02:56:53,255 --> 02:56:56,763 comp plan it clearly states tha 13912 02:56:56,763 --> 02:56:56,763 t 13913 02:56:56,763 --> 02:56:59,165 you need to make other changes 13914 02:56:59,165 --> 02:56:59,165 13915 02:56:59,165 --> 02:57:02,136 to roads when you resurface a 13916 02:57:02,136 --> 02:57:04,203 street or do the sidewalks. 13917 02:57:04,203 --> 02:57:06,071 we don't, I ride. 13918 02:57:06,071 --> 02:57:08,041 I see the children walking, 13919 02:57:08,041 --> 02:57:09,778 parents walking, we don't walk 13920 02:57:09,778 --> 02:57:09,778 13921 02:57:09,778 --> 02:57:11,410 in the streets. 13922 02:57:11,410 --> 02:57:12,758 we don't ride our bikes in the 13923 02:57:12,758 --> 02:57:12,758 13924 02:57:12,758 --> 02:57:12,758 street. 13925 02:57:12,758 --> 02:57:15,389 we ride on the sidewalk. 13926 02:57:15,389 --> 02:57:19,441 because we were taught not to 13927 02:57:19,441 --> 02:57:19,441 be 13928 02:57:19,441 --> 02:57:21,293 in the streets and compete wit 13929 02:57:21,293 --> 02:57:21,293 h 13930 02:57:21,293 --> 02:57:21,823 a car or truck. 13931 02:57:21,823 --> 02:57:23,583 this is a community, a 13932 02:57:23,583 --> 02:57:23,583 neighborhood. 13933 02:57:23,583 --> 02:57:25,991 a neighborhood. 13934 02:57:25,991 --> 02:57:29,839 and bike lanes doesn't apply to 13935 02:57:29,839 --> 02:57:29,839 13936 02:57:29,839 --> 02:57:33,535 the concept that we we will 13937 02:57:33,535 --> 02:57:34,251 build it now and they will 13938 02:57:34,251 --> 02:57:34,251 come. 13939 02:57:34,251 --> 02:57:37,474 this is an existing community 13940 02:57:37,474 --> 02:57:39,005 and we need to respect it as 13941 02:57:39,005 --> 02:57:42,678 such: there are several projects 13942 02:57:42,678 --> 02:57:42,678 13943 02:57:42,678 --> 02:57:43,707 if you are looking for project 13944 02:57:43,707 --> 02:57:43,707 s 13945 02:57:43,707 --> 02:57:47,413 that can be beneficial to us. 13946 02:57:47,413 --> 02:57:50,584 one is getting rid of that 13947 02:57:50,584 --> 02:57:52,551 recycling plant right on waldo 13948 02:57:52,551 --> 02:57:52,551 13949 02:57:52,551 --> 02:57:56,596 and 8th avenue that provides 13950 02:57:56,596 --> 02:57:59,354 dust to residents of us living 13951 02:57:59,354 --> 02:57:59,354 13952 02:57:59,354 --> 02:58:01,295 in the community creating healt 13953 02:58:01,295 --> 02:58:01,295 h 13954 02:58:01,295 --> 02:58:01,295 issues. 13955 02:58:01,295 --> 02:58:04,827 folk can't open their windows 13956 02:58:04,827 --> 02:58:06,569 boss of because of the noi 13957 02:58:06,569 --> 02:58:06,704 se and 13958 02:58:06,704 --> 02:58:07,566 air pollution. 13959 02:58:07,566 --> 02:58:12,833 that you can relocate that 13960 02:58:12,833 --> 02:58:15,141 convenience store on 8th 13961 02:58:15,141 --> 02:58:17,212 avenue that you gave permissio 13962 02:58:17,212 --> 02:58:17,212 n 13963 02:58:17,212 --> 02:58:19,480 to sell beer and wine or 13964 02:58:19,480 --> 02:58:21,914 whatever else out of it, and 13965 02:58:21,914 --> 02:58:24,659 plaster the signs all over the 13966 02:58:24,659 --> 02:58:24,659 13967 02:58:24,659 --> 02:58:26,314 window right in front of a 13968 02:58:26,314 --> 02:58:28,588 recreation center and a 13969 02:58:28,588 --> 02:58:28,588 nursery. 13970 02:58:28,588 --> 02:58:31,994 >> mayor: I am a going to ask 13971 02:58:31,994 --> 02:58:34,832 you to wrap up. 13972 02:58:34,832 --> 02:58:36,538 that's not how we do it. 13973 02:58:36,538 --> 02:58:37,894 you know that. 13974 02:58:37,894 --> 02:58:39,440 >> and the same thing happens o 13975 02:58:39,440 --> 02:58:39,440 n 13976 02:58:39,440 --> 02:58:41,398 southeast 4th avenue. 13977 02:58:41,398 --> 02:58:42,808 this is, this is not good for 13978 02:58:42,808 --> 02:58:46,206 our community. 13979 02:58:46,206 --> 02:58:47,777 it creates all kind of problem 13980 02:58:47,777 --> 02:58:47,777 s 13981 02:58:47,777 --> 02:58:50,518 for our children at they young 13982 02:58:50,518 --> 02:58:50,518 13983 02:58:50,518 --> 02:58:52,115 age and now you have come in 13984 02:58:52,115 --> 02:58:53,212 talking about bicycles putting 13985 02:58:53,212 --> 02:58:53,212 13986 02:58:53,212 --> 02:58:54,548 them in the streets. 13987 02:58:54,548 --> 02:58:56,050 trying to kill them. 13988 02:58:56,050 --> 02:58:57,420 >> mayor: ms. Miles hamilton I'm 13989 02:58:57,420 --> 02:58:57,420 13990 02:58:57,420 --> 02:58:58,355 going to ask you to wrap up. 13991 02:58:58,355 --> 02:58:59,221 you're at four minutes. 13992 02:58:59,221 --> 02:59:00,226 >> okay, I will, thank you, 13993 02:59:00,226 --> 02:59:00,226 sir. 13994 02:59:00,226 --> 02:59:05,358 and another thing we can do is 13995 02:59:05,358 --> 02:59:05,358 13996 02:59:05,358 --> 02:59:08,426 to provide avenues for economic 13997 02:59:08,426 --> 02:59:08,426 13998 02:59:08,426 --> 02:59:09,724 development, provide 13999 02:59:09,724 --> 02:59:11,602 recreational after-school 14000 02:59:11,602 --> 02:59:14,200 programs for our kids so that 14001 02:59:14,200 --> 02:59:15,864 they can continue to do -- the 14002 02:59:15,864 --> 02:59:15,864 14003 02:59:15,864 --> 02:59:17,206 city used to do that. 14004 02:59:17,206 --> 02:59:18,272 >> mayor: I'm going to ask you 14005 02:59:18,272 --> 02:59:18,272 14006 02:59:18,272 --> 02:59:19,135 to wrap up, please. 14007 02:59:19,135 --> 02:59:20,014 >> we appreciate it and I would 14008 02:59:20,014 --> 02:59:20,014 14009 02:59:20,014 --> 02:59:22,686 like to say that if you continue 14010 02:59:22,686 --> 02:59:22,686 14011 02:59:22,686 --> 02:59:25,208 to ignore our safety, our 14012 02:59:25,208 --> 02:59:26,912 children, our peace, and our 14013 02:59:26,912 --> 02:59:28,712 survival, we will target your 14014 02:59:28,712 --> 02:59:28,712 seats. 14015 02:59:28,712 --> 02:59:33,826 >> amen. 14016 02:59:33,826 --> 02:59:34,590 >> mayor: ms. Miles hamilton, I 14017 02:59:34,590 --> 02:59:34,590 14018 02:59:34,590 --> 02:59:35,260 would love to schedule a meeti 14019 02:59:35,260 --> 02:59:35,260 ng 14020 02:59:35,260 --> 02:59:35,779 with you. 14021 02:59:35,779 --> 02:59:35,779 please. 14022 02:59:35,779 --> 02:59:36,773 >> okay. 14023 02:59:36,773 --> 02:59:37,664 thank you. 14024 02:59:37,664 --> 02:59:40,096 >> we have kali blount followed 14025 02:59:40,096 --> 02:59:40,096 14026 02:59:40,096 --> 02:59:42,990 by andrew miles and dejohn 14027 02:59:42,990 --> 02:59:48,266 dijon 14028 02:59:48,266 --> 02:59:48,266 cane. 14029 02:59:48,266 --> 02:59:50,800 >> they brought up removing 14030 02:59:50,800 --> 02:59:50,800 trees. 14031 02:59:50,800 --> 02:59:53,217 it should be part of the study. 14032 02:59:53,217 --> 02:59:53,217 14033 02:59:53,217 --> 02:59:54,642 trees really are removable, 14034 02:59:54,642 --> 02:59:56,378 which ones are alien. 14035 02:59:56,378 --> 02:59:57,946 if you remove the only more 14036 02:59:57,946 --> 03:00:00,643 a3w-7bdant abundant trees 14037 03:00:00,643 --> 03:00:00,962 will 14038 03:00:00,962 --> 03:00:02,084 that clear a path on either sid 14039 03:00:02,084 --> 03:00:02,084 e 14040 03:00:02,084 --> 03:00:02,532 of the street. 14041 03:00:02,532 --> 03:00:03,913 we don't want to expand heat 14042 03:00:03,913 --> 03:00:05,776 islands, so you should be 14043 03:00:05,776 --> 03:00:10,630 preserving the trees. 14044 03:00:10,630 --> 03:00:12,153 and with these street changes 14045 03:00:12,153 --> 03:00:13,698 and you're talking later about 14046 03:00:13,698 --> 03:00:13,698 14047 03:00:13,698 --> 03:00:17,192 utility changes, even if you 14048 03:00:17,192 --> 03:00:18,670 weren't putting utilities under 14049 03:00:18,670 --> 03:00:18,670 14050 03:00:18,670 --> 03:00:21,906 ground, you're dealing with the 14051 03:00:21,906 --> 03:00:21,906 14052 03:00:21,906 --> 03:00:25,150 surface water drainage, which, 14053 03:00:25,150 --> 03:00:25,150 14054 03:00:25,150 --> 03:00:26,604 and there's a couple areas whe 14055 03:00:26,604 --> 03:00:26,604 re 14056 03:00:26,604 --> 03:00:27,672 you have swales on the 14057 03:00:27,672 --> 03:00:27,672 roadside. 14058 03:00:27,672 --> 03:00:29,438 it would be great to turn that 14059 03:00:29,438 --> 03:00:29,438 14060 03:00:29,438 --> 03:00:30,873 into level ground over pipe and 14061 03:00:30,873 --> 03:00:30,873 14062 03:00:30,873 --> 03:00:32,073 no longer have swales. 14063 03:00:32,073 --> 03:00:34,176 but that's going to involve the 14064 03:00:34,176 --> 03:00:34,176 14065 03:00:34,176 --> 03:00:37,116 utilities cooperation. 14066 03:00:37,116 --> 03:00:39,515 and since you and gru are now 14067 03:00:39,515 --> 03:00:41,092 frien-emies, you need to know 14068 03:00:41,092 --> 03:00:43,354 well ahead of time what are the 14069 03:00:43,354 --> 03:00:43,354 y 14070 03:00:43,354 --> 03:00:44,556 going to participate, what wil 14071 03:00:44,556 --> 03:00:44,556 l 14072 03:00:44,556 --> 03:00:46,995 be their participation. 14073 03:00:46,995 --> 03:00:49,446 and I mentioned earlier when I 14074 03:00:49,446 --> 03:00:49,446 14075 03:00:49,446 --> 03:00:52,272 talked about the zero project -- 14076 03:00:52,272 --> 03:00:52,272 14077 03:00:52,272 --> 03:00:53,628 the project zero event the oth 14078 03:00:53,628 --> 03:00:53,628 er 14079 03:00:53,628 --> 03:00:55,500 day, what I think of the quali 14080 03:00:55,500 --> 03:00:55,500 ty 14081 03:00:55,500 --> 03:00:57,844 of outreach. 14082 03:00:57,844 --> 03:00:59,452 too often the outreach is bring 14083 03:00:59,452 --> 03:00:59,452 14084 03:00:59,452 --> 03:01:01,844 a citizens in, let them hear a 14085 03:01:01,844 --> 03:01:01,844 14086 03:01:01,844 --> 03:01:03,383 presentations, and they don't 14087 03:01:03,383 --> 03:01:05,155 get to speak back to the room 14088 03:01:05,155 --> 03:01:07,417 and each other and the staff. 14089 03:01:07,417 --> 03:01:09,423 or they just get to take two 14090 03:01:09,423 --> 03:01:11,278 cookies and go home or they're 14091 03:01:11,278 --> 03:01:11,278 14092 03:01:11,278 --> 03:01:12,916 told write your question on an 14093 03:01:12,916 --> 03:01:12,916 14094 03:01:12,916 --> 03:01:13,586 index card. 14095 03:01:13,586 --> 03:01:16,953 that's not good enough. 14096 03:01:16,953 --> 03:01:20,625 and that feeds into one giant 14097 03:01:20,625 --> 03:01:21,325 apprehension for this 14098 03:01:21,325 --> 03:01:21,325 neighborhood. 14099 03:01:21,325 --> 03:01:23,561 they've seen what happened in 14100 03:01:23,561 --> 03:01:26,734 5th avenue and pleasant street 14101 03:01:26,734 --> 03:01:26,734 14102 03:01:26,734 --> 03:01:27,932 and porters. 14103 03:01:27,932 --> 03:01:30,580 is this a prequell to 14104 03:01:30,580 --> 03:01:30,580 gentrification? 14105 03:01:30,580 --> 03:01:33,739 they need some reassurance. 14106 03:01:33,739 --> 03:01:38,216 and for $500,000, do we get 14107 03:01:38,216 --> 03:01:39,986 anywhere into the kinetic part 14108 03:01:39,986 --> 03:01:39,986 14109 03:01:39,986 --> 03:01:41,077 of this work? 14110 03:01:41,077 --> 03:01:42,527 you know, since I've been in 14111 03:01:42,527 --> 03:01:44,361 town in '87 I'm sure there's 14112 03:01:44,361 --> 03:01:46,045 been 6 or $7 million spent on 14113 03:01:46,045 --> 03:01:47,652 consultants and studies that 14114 03:01:47,652 --> 03:01:49,518 have given you lots of paper t 14115 03:01:49,518 --> 03:01:49,518 o 14116 03:01:49,518 --> 03:01:53,323 protect your shelves from d 14117 03:01:53,323 --> 03:01:53,323 ust, 14118 03:01:53,323 --> 03:01:54,526 but we want to see it become 14119 03:01:54,526 --> 03:01:56,731 actual action so does this get 14120 03:01:56,731 --> 03:01:56,731 14121 03:01:56,731 --> 03:01:58,897 us into -- even if it's just a 14122 03:01:58,897 --> 03:01:58,897 14123 03:01:58,897 --> 03:02:01,262 coordination with d.o.t., I 14124 03:02:01,262 --> 03:02:02,771 think the park west of waldo 14125 03:02:02,771 --> 03:02:05,938 might be d.o.t. Concern, or 14126 03:02:05,938 --> 03:02:09,677 required testing, maybe a test 14127 03:02:09,677 --> 03:02:09,677 14128 03:02:09,677 --> 03:02:10,687 soil on where you're going to 14129 03:02:10,687 --> 03:02:13,029 pay new, put new pavement make 14130 03:02:13,029 --> 03:02:13,029 14131 03:02:13,029 --> 03:02:15,455 sure it's good. 14132 03:02:15,455 --> 03:02:17,513 so for $500,000, I hope we're 14133 03:02:17,513 --> 03:02:20,655 getting into some part of the 14134 03:02:20,655 --> 03:02:22,789 kinetic part of this work. 14135 03:02:22,789 --> 03:02:24,796 a shovel in the dirt, somewhere 14136 03:02:24,796 --> 03:02:24,796 14137 03:02:24,796 --> 03:02:26,871 for that $500,000 and not just 14138 03:02:26,871 --> 03:02:27,525 a 14139 03:02:27,525 --> 03:02:29,698 new pile of paper. 14140 03:02:29,698 --> 03:02:30,266 >> mayor: thank you, 14141 03:02:30,266 --> 03:02:32,910 mr. Blount. 14142 03:02:32,910 --> 03:02:35,641 >> andrew miles followed by 14143 03:02:35,641 --> 03:02:43,376 dijon cane and pastor earnestee 14144 03:02:43,376 --> 03:02:43,376 n 14145 03:02:43,376 --> 03:02:43,376 butler. 14146 03:02:43,376 --> 03:02:45,279 >> welcome, how are you doing 14147 03:02:45,279 --> 03:02:45,279 again. 14148 03:02:45,279 --> 03:02:48,417 I'm coming to talk to you about 14149 03:02:48,417 --> 03:02:48,417 14150 03:02:48,417 --> 03:02:50,085 the road construction as well. 14151 03:02:50,085 --> 03:02:50,085 14152 03:02:50,085 --> 03:02:51,465 and I want to go straight to th 14153 03:02:51,465 --> 03:02:51,465 e 14154 03:02:51,465 --> 03:02:53,453 crash data because the crash 14155 03:02:53,453 --> 03:02:54,591 data that they're talking is 14156 03:02:54,591 --> 03:02:56,109 about for the safety and so 14157 03:02:56,109 --> 03:02:59,156 forth, is somewhat inconclusiv 14158 03:02:59,156 --> 03:02:59,156 e 14159 03:02:59,156 --> 03:03:01,693 andit don't really related to 14160 03:03:01,693 --> 03:03:04,090 speed or to any particular thi 14161 03:03:04,090 --> 03:03:04,090 ng 14162 03:03:04,090 --> 03:03:05,791 that's why they have all the 14163 03:03:05,791 --> 03:03:05,791 incidents. 14164 03:03:05,791 --> 03:03:10,510 so we can't exactly say that al 14165 03:03:10,510 --> 03:03:10,510 l 14166 03:03:10,510 --> 03:03:11,877 of those incidents is because o 14167 03:03:11,877 --> 03:03:11,877 f 14168 03:03:11,877 --> 03:03:11,877 speed. 14169 03:03:11,877 --> 03:03:13,447 first of all. 14170 03:03:13,447 --> 03:03:14,623 so that's kind of screwed a 14171 03:03:14,623 --> 03:03:17,891 little bit. 14172 03:03:17,891 --> 03:03:22,249 the speed tables and the zippe 14173 03:03:22,249 --> 03:03:22,249 rs 14174 03:03:22,249 --> 03:03:23,881 along for the bike path and so 14175 03:03:23,881 --> 03:03:23,881 14176 03:03:23,881 --> 03:03:26,851 forth is by biggest objection. 14177 03:03:26,851 --> 03:03:26,851 14178 03:03:26,851 --> 03:03:27,917 8th avenue definitely, 14179 03:03:27,917 --> 03:03:29,449 definitely need to have some 14180 03:03:29,449 --> 03:03:31,487 renovation done to so forth but 14181 03:03:31,487 --> 03:03:31,487 14182 03:03:31,487 --> 03:03:34,533 the speed tables I think is an 14183 03:03:34,533 --> 03:03:34,533 14184 03:03:34,533 --> 03:03:35,589 unnecessary, little bit 14185 03:03:35,589 --> 03:03:37,895 overkill, and we don't have 14186 03:03:37,895 --> 03:03:40,199 enough data that directly 14187 03:03:40,199 --> 03:03:43,219 relates it to speeding, and so 14188 03:03:43,219 --> 03:03:43,219 14189 03:03:43,219 --> 03:03:45,283 forth because as far as we know, 14190 03:03:45,283 --> 03:03:45,283 14191 03:03:45,283 --> 03:03:47,909 it could be from people texting, 14192 03:03:47,909 --> 03:03:47,909 14193 03:03:47,909 --> 03:03:49,462 it could be from folks talking 14194 03:03:49,462 --> 03:03:49,462 14195 03:03:49,462 --> 03:03:51,078 on the phone or just not payin 14196 03:03:51,078 --> 03:03:51,078 g attent 14197 03:03:51,078 --> 03:03:51,078 attentn. So 14198 03:03:51,078 --> 03:03:53,815 soforth so a lot of that is the 14199 03:03:53,815 --> 03:03:53,815 14200 03:03:53,815 --> 03:03:55,355 reason why we have lot of 14201 03:03:55,355 --> 03:03:56,691 accidents in the first place 14202 03:03:56,691 --> 03:03:59,391 more so than speeding. 14203 03:03:59,391 --> 03:04:05,149 the other thing is that some of 14204 03:04:05,149 --> 03:04:05,149 14205 03:04:05,149 --> 03:04:06,523 the causes that you do have 14206 03:04:06,523 --> 03:04:08,621 superspeeding is somewhat could 14207 03:04:08,621 --> 03:04:08,621 14208 03:04:08,621 --> 03:04:11,431 be related to that on the west 14209 03:04:11,431 --> 03:04:11,431 14210 03:04:11,431 --> 03:04:13,433 side of 8th avenue before you 14211 03:04:13,433 --> 03:04:15,045 cross waldo, the speed limit I 14212 03:04:15,045 --> 03:04:15,045 s 14213 03:04:15,045 --> 03:04:16,703 35 miles an hour. 14214 03:04:16,703 --> 03:04:20,007 so coming across waldo road it' 14215 03:04:20,007 --> 03:04:20,007 s 14216 03:04:20,007 --> 03:04:21,075 kind of hard transitioning 14217 03:04:21,075 --> 03:04:21,075 there. 14218 03:04:21,075 --> 03:04:22,937 I drive that way quite a bit a 14219 03:04:22,937 --> 03:04:22,937 nd 14220 03:04:22,937 --> 03:04:27,215 so forth myself coming back and 14221 03:04:27,215 --> 03:04:27,215 14222 03:04:27,215 --> 03:04:27,837 forth every day. 14223 03:04:27,837 --> 03:04:28,957 a little speed transition coming 14224 03:04:28,957 --> 03:04:28,957 14225 03:04:28,957 --> 03:04:30,179 through there, but having the 14226 03:04:30,179 --> 03:04:31,781 speed tables up on 8th avenue 14227 03:04:31,781 --> 03:04:34,122 is going to slow down traffic, 14228 03:04:34,122 --> 03:04:34,122 14229 03:04:34,122 --> 03:04:35,212 it's going to slow down traffic 14230 03:04:35,212 --> 03:04:35,212 14231 03:04:35,212 --> 03:04:36,987 so much until I think it's 14232 03:04:36,987 --> 03:04:38,289 possibly even make it dangerous 14233 03:04:38,289 --> 03:04:38,289 14234 03:04:38,289 --> 03:04:40,123 for us that are living there 14235 03:04:40,123 --> 03:04:41,156 because we have a lot of traff 14236 03:04:41,156 --> 03:04:41,156 ic 14237 03:04:41,156 --> 03:04:44,563 that's flowing through that 14238 03:04:44,563 --> 03:04:48,038 little -- there and we and 14239 03:04:48,038 --> 03:04:48,235 so 14240 03:04:48,235 --> 03:04:48,235 forth. 14241 03:04:48,235 --> 03:04:52,341 we do want the road to be fixed 14242 03:04:52,341 --> 03:04:52,341 14243 03:04:52,341 --> 03:04:54,972 and so forth, and some other 14244 03:04:54,972 --> 03:04:57,142 ated stuff, and some bike paths 14245 03:04:57,142 --> 03:04:57,142 14246 03:04:57,142 --> 03:04:58,702 could be some additional stuff 14247 03:04:58,702 --> 03:04:58,702 14248 03:04:58,702 --> 03:05:00,109 that could be help it a little 14249 03:05:00,109 --> 03:05:00,109 14250 03:05:00,109 --> 03:05:01,151 bit, but like I said, the 14251 03:05:01,151 --> 03:05:02,816 zipper's going to impede a who 14252 03:05:02,816 --> 03:05:02,816 le 14253 03:05:02,816 --> 03:05:02,816 lot. 14254 03:05:02,816 --> 03:05:04,581 even widening the sidwould 14255 03:05:04,581 --> 03:05:07,548 make it a little bit better. 14256 03:05:07,548 --> 03:05:08,733 some folks don't want -- but I 14257 03:05:08,733 --> 03:05:08,733 14258 03:05:08,733 --> 03:05:10,617 don't know who if the world 14259 03:05:10,617 --> 03:05:11,055 in 14260 03:05:11,055 --> 03:05:12,589 the world decided to put large 14261 03:05:12,589 --> 03:05:12,589 14262 03:05:12,589 --> 03:05:13,735 oak trees in the middle of a 14263 03:05:13,735 --> 03:05:15,440 sidewalk that's going to grow 14264 03:05:15,440 --> 03:05:17,167 this big around as this table, 14265 03:05:17,167 --> 03:05:17,167 14266 03:05:17,167 --> 03:05:18,490 and it's going to tear up the 14267 03:05:18,490 --> 03:05:20,662 roads, it's going to tear up t 14268 03:05:20,662 --> 03:05:20,662 he 14269 03:05:20,662 --> 03:05:21,493 sidewalk as soon as you fix the 14270 03:05:21,493 --> 03:05:21,493 14271 03:05:21,493 --> 03:05:23,539 roads, five, six years from now 14272 03:05:23,539 --> 03:05:23,539 , 14273 03:05:23,539 --> 03:05:24,571 we have to resurface the road 14274 03:05:24,571 --> 03:05:25,940 again because of all of the 14275 03:05:25,940 --> 03:05:25,940 roots. 14276 03:05:25,940 --> 03:05:28,071 I don't care how you trim the 14277 03:05:28,071 --> 03:05:31,208 trees, it's going -- some 14278 03:05:31,208 --> 03:05:32,310 consideration or replacing tho 14279 03:05:32,310 --> 03:05:32,310 se 14280 03:05:32,310 --> 03:05:35,754 oaks with some more manageable 14281 03:05:35,754 --> 03:05:35,754 14282 03:05:35,754 --> 03:05:37,609 trees, possibly would be 14283 03:05:37,609 --> 03:05:37,609 better. 14284 03:05:37,609 --> 03:05:42,727 but again, my biggest objection 14285 03:05:42,727 --> 03:05:42,727 14286 03:05:42,727 --> 03:05:46,225 is the speed tables and zipper 14287 03:05:46,225 --> 03:05:46,225 14288 03:05:46,225 --> 03:05:48,959 ties, but having a path for 14289 03:05:48,959 --> 03:05:50,611 bikes, that would be okay 14290 03:05:50,611 --> 03:05:52,022 because I ride a bike quite a 14291 03:05:52,022 --> 03:05:54,295 bit but I don't have any probl 14292 03:05:54,295 --> 03:05:54,295 em 14293 03:05:54,295 --> 03:05:56,779 riding bikes over on the east 14294 03:05:56,779 --> 03:05:58,034 side of town and so forth and I 14295 03:05:58,034 --> 03:05:58,034 14296 03:05:58,034 --> 03:05:59,115 have been riding for over 67 14297 03:05:59,115 --> 03:05:59,115 years. 14298 03:05:59,115 --> 03:06:02,220 over there haven't had any 14299 03:06:02,220 --> 03:06:04,407 problems and as I said the 14300 03:06:04,407 --> 03:06:05,466 speeding and so forth the data 14301 03:06:05,466 --> 03:06:05,466 14302 03:06:05,466 --> 03:06:09,079 is too inconclusive and not too 14303 03:06:09,079 --> 03:06:09,079 14304 03:06:09,079 --> 03:06:10,319 much to say it's directly 14305 03:06:10,319 --> 03:06:13,145 related to a speed problem and 14306 03:06:13,145 --> 03:06:13,145 14307 03:06:13,145 --> 03:06:13,581 so forth. 14308 03:06:13,581 --> 03:06:16,027 but I hope you consider making 14309 03:06:16,027 --> 03:06:16,027 14310 03:06:16,027 --> 03:06:18,328 the changes but some of the 14311 03:06:18,328 --> 03:06:22,542 stuff which is zippers and the 14312 03:06:22,542 --> 03:06:22,542 14313 03:06:22,542 --> 03:06:23,924 speed humps like I said that's 14314 03:06:23,924 --> 03:06:23,924 14315 03:06:23,924 --> 03:06:25,633 my biggest complaint and so 14316 03:06:25,633 --> 03:06:26,970 forth because if an emergency 14317 03:06:26,970 --> 03:06:27,741 happened on the east side of 14318 03:06:27,741 --> 03:06:30,732 town, it's going to be a probl 14319 03:06:30,732 --> 03:06:30,732 em 14320 03:06:30,732 --> 03:06:31,598 with all those people trying t 14321 03:06:31,598 --> 03:06:31,598 o 14322 03:06:31,598 --> 03:06:34,204 get out because it's only so 14323 03:06:34,204 --> 03:06:36,946 many exits coming from the eas 14324 03:06:36,946 --> 03:06:36,946 t 14325 03:06:36,946 --> 03:06:37,968 side of town. 14326 03:06:37,968 --> 03:06:40,576 8th avenue, university avenue, 14327 03:06:40,576 --> 03:06:40,576 14328 03:06:40,576 --> 03:06:41,011 12th avenue. 14329 03:06:41,011 --> 03:06:42,111 we used to have 10th avenue 14330 03:06:42,111 --> 03:06:43,118 but it was closed off when the 14331 03:06:43,118 --> 03:06:43,118 y 14332 03:06:43,118 --> 03:06:44,116 put that little place down 14333 03:06:44,116 --> 03:06:44,116 there. 14334 03:06:44,116 --> 03:06:49,924 so a lot of people coming out o 14335 03:06:49,924 --> 03:06:49,924 f 14336 03:06:49,924 --> 03:06:51,324 east side of town -- not reall 14337 03:06:51,324 --> 03:06:51,324 y 14338 03:06:51,324 --> 03:06:52,222 going to benefit -- 14339 03:06:52,222 --> 03:06:52,714 >> mayor: thank you. 14340 03:06:52,714 --> 03:06:54,390 >> we have dijon cane followed 14341 03:06:54,390 --> 03:06:54,390 14342 03:06:54,390 --> 03:06:56,596 by pastor earnesteen butler and 14343 03:06:56,596 --> 03:06:56,596 14344 03:06:56,596 --> 03:06:58,094 then corey brunson. 14345 03:06:58,094 --> 03:06:58,826 >> mayor: welcome. 14346 03:06:58,826 --> 03:06:59,473 >> all right, good afternoon, 14347 03:06:59,473 --> 03:06:59,473 commission. 14348 03:06:59,473 --> 03:07:02,296 I grew up on the east side. 14349 03:07:02,296 --> 03:07:03,264 I'm running for commission in 14350 03:07:03,264 --> 03:07:04,802 district 3, which is all of 14351 03:07:04,802 --> 03:07:04,802 southwest. 14352 03:07:04,802 --> 03:07:06,871 and I preach this all the time 14353 03:07:06,871 --> 03:07:06,871 14354 03:07:06,871 --> 03:07:08,511 when you're from gainesville y 14355 03:07:08,511 --> 03:07:08,511 ou 14356 03:07:08,511 --> 03:07:09,278 know gainesville. 14357 03:07:09,278 --> 03:07:10,716 and when I heard about this,I 14358 03:07:10,716 --> 03:07:12,472 looked it up I was like wow 14359 03:07:12,472 --> 03:07:12,908 that's crazy. 14360 03:07:12,908 --> 03:07:15,180 I thought about the fune rlt 14361 03:07:15,180 --> 03:07:17,832 best thing about -- funerals. 14362 03:07:17,832 --> 03:07:18,685 let's think about how those 14363 03:07:18,685 --> 03:07:21,462 funerals go -- you're going it 14364 03:07:21,462 --> 03:07:21,462 14365 03:07:21,462 --> 03:07:24,725 take going to take tha 14366 03:07:24,725 --> 03:07:25,306 t away. 14367 03:07:25,306 --> 03:07:27,101 they ain't going to have 14368 03:07:27,101 --> 03:07:28,220 anywhere to do the funerals an 14369 03:07:28,220 --> 03:07:28,220 d 14370 03:07:28,220 --> 03:07:29,991 the cars will not know where t 14371 03:07:29,991 --> 03:07:29,991 o 14372 03:07:29,991 --> 03:07:29,991 park. 14373 03:07:29,991 --> 03:07:31,194 the other thing is the amount o 14374 03:07:31,194 --> 03:07:31,194 f 14375 03:07:31,194 --> 03:07:31,950 money you want to spend on this 14376 03:07:31,950 --> 03:07:31,950 14377 03:07:31,950 --> 03:07:33,256 when we really don't need it, 14378 03:07:33,256 --> 03:07:34,902 you could just do the 14379 03:07:34,902 --> 03:07:36,188 reconstruction, we need a 14380 03:07:36,188 --> 03:07:37,942 grocery store. 14381 03:07:37,942 --> 03:07:40,736 we need better development. 14382 03:07:40,736 --> 03:07:41,726 we need better things for the 14383 03:07:41,726 --> 03:07:43,307 kids.we have programs called the 14384 03:07:43,307 --> 03:07:43,307 14385 03:07:43,307 --> 03:07:43,307 outlet. 14386 03:07:43,307 --> 03:07:45,559 all that stuff, the city did 14387 03:07:45,559 --> 03:07:49,030 post-917 gainesville police 14388 03:07:49,030 --> 03:07:50,022 explorers, other programs in 14389 03:07:50,022 --> 03:07:50,974 this community, that's what we 14390 03:07:50,974 --> 03:07:50,974 14391 03:07:50,974 --> 03:07:50,974 need. 14392 03:07:50,974 --> 03:07:53,768 but if we going -- it amaze me 14393 03:07:53,768 --> 03:07:53,768 14394 03:07:53,768 --> 03:07:57,953 that -- amazes me nat we that w 14395 03:07:57,953 --> 03:07:57,953 e 14396 03:07:57,953 --> 03:07:59,018 spend this kind of money hon 14397 03:07:59,018 --> 03:08:00,553 this but we can't get a growsy 14398 03:08:00,553 --> 03:08:00,553 14399 03:08:00,553 --> 03:08:00,553 store. 14400 03:08:00,553 --> 03:08:03,096 that's a problem. 14401 03:08:03,096 --> 03:08:04,526 many of you are like wow. 14402 03:08:04,526 --> 03:08:05,348 no, it's the truth. 14403 03:08:05,348 --> 03:08:06,243 when we say we want economic 14404 03:08:06,243 --> 03:08:07,572 development, what do you reall 14405 03:08:07,572 --> 03:08:07,572 y 14406 03:08:07,572 --> 03:08:07,572 want? 14407 03:08:07,572 --> 03:08:09,336 why are you really here? 14408 03:08:09,336 --> 03:08:11,200 I know one commissioner can't d 14409 03:08:11,200 --> 03:08:11,200 o 14410 03:08:11,200 --> 03:08:11,200 it. 14411 03:08:11,200 --> 03:08:12,736 because that's her district. 14412 03:08:12,736 --> 03:08:14,802 but we got to work together to 14413 03:08:14,802 --> 03:08:14,802 14414 03:08:14,802 --> 03:08:15,269 do it. 14415 03:08:15,269 --> 03:08:16,240 because I'm going to tell you, 14416 03:08:16,240 --> 03:08:16,240 14417 03:08:16,240 --> 03:08:17,436 this is a mess. 14418 03:08:17,436 --> 03:08:18,842 but it's funny to me how we wan 14419 03:08:18,842 --> 03:08:18,842 t 14420 03:08:18,842 --> 03:08:20,801 to put this infrastructure in 14421 03:08:20,801 --> 03:08:21,951 right now when we didn't care 14422 03:08:21,951 --> 03:08:25,115 about it 20 years ago. 14423 03:08:25,115 --> 03:08:26,988 time comes about change. 14424 03:08:26,988 --> 03:08:28,126 but we got to be careful when 14425 03:08:28,126 --> 03:08:29,758 we're spending this kind of 14426 03:08:29,758 --> 03:08:31,716 money on this. 14427 03:08:31,716 --> 03:08:34,228 when we need so much more in 14428 03:08:34,228 --> 03:08:35,567 that community. 14429 03:08:35,567 --> 03:08:37,468 and it's lacking because guess 14430 03:08:37,468 --> 03:08:37,468 14431 03:08:37,468 --> 03:08:37,468 what? 14432 03:08:37,468 --> 03:08:39,500 we have not made the investmen 14433 03:08:39,500 --> 03:08:39,500 ts 14434 03:08:39,500 --> 03:08:40,901 over the years. 14435 03:08:40,901 --> 03:08:42,237 it ain't just this commission. 14436 03:08:42,237 --> 03:08:44,222 blame you. 14437 03:08:44,222 --> 03:08:46,438 it's past commissions, past 14438 03:08:46,438 --> 03:08:46,438 problems. 14439 03:08:46,438 --> 03:08:49,570 it is piled on top of each oth 14440 03:08:49,570 --> 03:08:49,570 er 14441 03:08:49,570 --> 03:08:51,314 and on top of each other and 14442 03:08:51,314 --> 03:08:52,622 people are tired. 14443 03:08:52,622 --> 03:08:54,822 these folks are tired. 14444 03:08:54,822 --> 03:08:56,040 when is things going to change? 14445 03:08:56,040 --> 03:08:56,040 14446 03:08:56,040 --> 03:08:58,758 when is it going to get better? 14447 03:08:58,758 --> 03:08:58,758 14448 03:08:58,758 --> 03:09:01,084 I remember being, you know, in 14449 03:09:01,084 --> 03:09:01,518 a 14450 03:09:01,518 --> 03:09:02,384 black on black crime task force 14451 03:09:02,384 --> 03:09:02,384 14452 03:09:02,384 --> 03:09:05,552 at 14, and we had this plan eas 14453 03:09:05,552 --> 03:09:05,552 t 14454 03:09:05,552 --> 03:09:06,318 gainesville they lied. 14455 03:09:06,318 --> 03:09:07,626 we keep lying. 14456 03:09:07,626 --> 03:09:09,042 when are we going to do what we 14457 03:09:09,042 --> 03:09:09,042 14458 03:09:09,042 --> 03:09:09,386 need to do? 14459 03:09:09,386 --> 03:09:10,634 when are we going to hear the 14460 03:09:10,634 --> 03:09:10,634 need? 14461 03:09:10,634 --> 03:09:13,046 when are we going to spark the 14462 03:09:13,046 --> 03:09:13,046 14463 03:09:13,046 --> 03:09:14,428 change, and whether are we 14464 03:09:14,428 --> 03:09:16,734 really -- when are we really 14465 03:09:16,734 --> 03:09:17,967 going to serve the people and 14466 03:09:17,967 --> 03:09:19,940 I'm going to tell you it is a 14467 03:09:19,940 --> 03:09:20,982 big problem we haven't heard 14468 03:09:20,982 --> 03:09:21,338 from the community. 14469 03:09:21,338 --> 03:09:23,642 that won't happen on any other 14470 03:09:23,642 --> 03:09:23,642 14471 03:09:23,642 --> 03:09:24,882 side of the town, so why is it 14472 03:09:24,882 --> 03:09:24,882 14473 03:09:24,882 --> 03:09:25,412 happening with us? 14474 03:09:25,412 --> 03:09:26,508 and I think that every 14475 03:09:26,508 --> 03:09:27,476 commissioner up there should 14476 03:09:27,476 --> 03:09:28,678 listen to what I'm saying. 14477 03:09:28,678 --> 03:09:30,007 it don't happen on no other sid 14478 03:09:30,007 --> 03:09:30,007 e 14479 03:09:30,007 --> 03:09:32,852 of town. 14480 03:09:32,852 --> 03:09:34,792 why is it happening on the 14481 03:09:34,792 --> 03:09:34,792 east? 14482 03:09:34,792 --> 03:09:35,998 so if you're really wanting to 14483 03:09:35,998 --> 03:09:35,998 14484 03:09:35,998 --> 03:09:37,500 do your job, for the people and 14485 03:09:37,500 --> 03:09:37,500 14486 03:09:37,500 --> 03:09:39,562 serve the people, vote this dow 14487 03:09:39,562 --> 03:09:39,562 n 14488 03:09:39,562 --> 03:09:39,562 today. 14489 03:09:39,562 --> 03:09:43,162 and when they do the right job 14490 03:09:43,162 --> 03:09:43,162 14491 03:09:43,162 --> 03:09:45,228 then we can come back and have a 14492 03:09:45,228 --> 03:09:45,228 14493 03:09:45,228 --> 03:09:45,228 conversation. 14494 03:09:45,228 --> 03:09:46,570 we're here for the people. 14495 03:09:46,570 --> 03:09:47,656 you're not getting paid to get 14496 03:09:47,656 --> 03:09:47,656 14497 03:09:47,656 --> 03:09:47,656 paid. 14498 03:09:47,656 --> 03:09:48,978 you're working for the people. 14499 03:09:48,978 --> 03:09:48,978 14500 03:09:48,978 --> 03:09:49,636 let's do it. 14501 03:09:49,636 --> 03:09:50,732 it's not hard. 14502 03:09:50,732 --> 03:09:52,140 so thank you very much. 14503 03:09:52,140 --> 03:09:53,674 I look forward to you hearing 14504 03:09:53,674 --> 03:09:55,438 the needs, serving the people, 14505 03:09:55,438 --> 03:09:55,438 14506 03:09:55,438 --> 03:09:56,836 and sparking the change. 14507 03:09:56,836 --> 03:09:57,938 something we're missing in thu 14508 03:09:57,938 --> 03:09:57,938 s 14509 03:09:57,938 --> 03:09:57,938 community. 14510 03:09:57,938 --> 03:10:00,236 thank you very much. 14511 03:10:00,236 --> 03:10:00,716 >> mayor: thank you. 14512 03:10:00,716 --> 03:10:01,658 I do want to before anybody els 14513 03:10:01,658 --> 03:10:01,658 e 14514 03:10:01,658 --> 03:10:03,408 comes up I want to point out 14515 03:10:03,408 --> 03:10:04,816 that it is right now a 14516 03:10:04,816 --> 03:10:06,110 $2 million grant out to help 14517 03:10:06,110 --> 03:10:07,826 folks who live in the community 14518 03:10:07,826 --> 03:10:07,826 , 14519 03:10:07,826 --> 03:10:08,686 invest in that community. 14520 03:10:08,686 --> 03:10:10,118 >> yes, mr. Mayor, I tote sale 14521 03:10:10,118 --> 03:10:10,118 14522 03:10:10,118 --> 03:10:10,782 understand that and respect 14523 03:10:10,782 --> 03:10:10,782 that. 14524 03:10:10,782 --> 03:10:13,062 my only thing with that is gue 14525 03:10:13,062 --> 03:10:13,062 ss 14526 03:10:13,062 --> 03:10:13,062 what? 14527 03:10:13,062 --> 03:10:14,390 it's a little late. 14528 03:10:14,390 --> 03:10:15,873 we need more, I get you -- 14529 03:10:15,873 --> 03:10:18,326 >> mayor: if not now, when? 14530 03:10:18,326 --> 03:10:19,322 >> I been asking you that 14531 03:10:19,322 --> 03:10:20,250 question since I have 14 years 14532 03:10:20,250 --> 03:10:20,250 14533 03:10:20,250 --> 03:10:20,250 old. 14534 03:10:20,250 --> 03:10:22,500 >> if not now, when. 14535 03:10:22,500 --> 03:10:24,162 >> mr. Mayor, with all due 14536 03:10:24,162 --> 03:10:25,109 respect I have been asking tha 14537 03:10:25,109 --> 03:10:25,109 t 14538 03:10:25,109 --> 03:10:27,630 since I was 14, and -- 14539 03:10:27,630 --> 03:10:28,308 >> mayor: we're trying, for 14540 03:10:28,308 --> 03:10:29,040 goodness sake. 14541 03:10:29,040 --> 03:10:29,802 that's what we're doing. 14542 03:10:29,802 --> 03:10:30,667 >> let's work together, 14543 03:10:30,667 --> 03:10:31,384 mr. Mayor. 14544 03:10:31,384 --> 03:10:32,078 >> mayor: come on. 14545 03:10:32,078 --> 03:10:33,208 let's get some more folks 14546 03:10:33,208 --> 03:10:33,208 talking. 14547 03:10:33,208 --> 03:10:35,520 >> all right, we have pastor 14548 03:10:35,520 --> 03:10:37,385 ernesteen butler followed by 14549 03:10:37,385 --> 03:10:39,306 corey brunson and then mr. Kip 14550 03:10:39,306 --> 03:10:39,306 14551 03:10:39,306 --> 03:10:40,014 hayes senior. 14552 03:10:40,014 --> 03:10:41,318 >> mayor: welcome, pastor. 14553 03:10:41,318 --> 03:10:44,022 >> hello. 14554 03:10:44,022 --> 03:10:45,924 I've been sitting there for 14555 03:10:45,924 --> 03:10:49,394 awhile little stiff. 14556 03:10:49,394 --> 03:10:52,690 but the things that they're 14557 03:10:52,690 --> 03:10:54,468 asking and talking about on 14558 03:10:54,468 --> 03:10:58,506 8th avenue as far as I too can 14559 03:10:58,506 --> 03:10:58,506 14560 03:10:58,506 --> 03:11:01,316 talk about lots more that we 14561 03:11:01,316 --> 03:11:02,534 need on 8th avenue. 14562 03:11:02,534 --> 03:11:08,640 but right now I will focus on 14563 03:11:08,640 --> 03:11:09,977 the transportation, the streets, 14564 03:11:09,977 --> 03:11:09,977 14565 03:11:09,977 --> 03:11:11,614 the things that are happening 14566 03:11:11,614 --> 03:11:13,243 right now. 14567 03:11:13,243 --> 03:11:15,168 and right now one of the thing 14568 03:11:15,168 --> 03:11:15,168 s 14569 03:11:15,168 --> 03:11:18,557 that I'm seriously against is 14570 03:11:18,557 --> 03:11:20,193 the bicycle lane. 14571 03:11:20,193 --> 03:11:23,458 yes, we ride our bicycle. 14572 03:11:23,458 --> 03:11:26,832 I have a tricycle, and y ride I 14573 03:11:26,832 --> 03:11:26,832 t 14574 03:11:26,832 --> 03:11:27,731 on the -- I ride it on the 14575 03:11:27,731 --> 03:11:27,731 sidewalk. 14576 03:11:27,731 --> 03:11:32,536 so yes, that's what we do. 14577 03:11:32,536 --> 03:11:36,512 I did sit no one else have any 14578 03:11:36,512 --> 03:11:36,512 14579 03:11:36,512 --> 03:11:38,608 data on how many bicycles that 14580 03:11:38,608 --> 03:11:38,608 14581 03:11:38,608 --> 03:11:40,575 go from 8th avenue down. 14582 03:11:40,575 --> 03:11:41,220 well guess what? 14583 03:11:41,220 --> 03:11:45,516 I was sitting there and every 14584 03:11:45,516 --> 03:11:46,948 night then at antioch where 14585 03:11:46,948 --> 03:11:48,156 they're talking about, I sat 14586 03:11:48,156 --> 03:11:50,451 there and every now and then I 14587 03:11:50,451 --> 03:11:50,451 14588 03:11:50,451 --> 03:11:51,656 would say there is a bicycle. 14589 03:11:51,656 --> 03:11:54,826 there is a bicycle. 14590 03:11:54,826 --> 03:11:58,759 I think I counted about two, 14591 03:11:58,759 --> 03:12:03,398 ipabout a in about a wee 14592 03:12:03,398 --> 03:12:03,598 k's time 14593 03:12:03,598 --> 03:12:07,368 of people riding their bicycle 14594 03:12:07,368 --> 03:12:07,368 s 14595 03:12:07,368 --> 03:12:08,008 out there. 14596 03:12:08,008 --> 03:12:09,204 other than that, there was n 14597 03:12:09,204 --> 03:12:11,172 and as far as the trees are 14598 03:12:11,172 --> 03:12:14,250 concerned -- I love trees. 14599 03:12:14,250 --> 03:12:15,621 I garden. 14600 03:12:15,621 --> 03:12:17,878 I love trees. 14601 03:12:17,878 --> 03:12:23,222 but a water oak is different. 14602 03:12:23,222 --> 03:12:25,489 the leaves are slippery when 14603 03:12:25,489 --> 03:12:25,489 wet. 14604 03:12:25,489 --> 03:12:29,496 how many times I've almost 14605 03:12:29,496 --> 03:12:32,290 slipped down just walking acros 14606 03:12:32,290 --> 03:12:32,290 s 14607 03:12:32,290 --> 03:12:34,502 the street because of the leave 14608 03:12:34,502 --> 03:12:34,502 s 14609 03:12:34,502 --> 03:12:36,466 and no, we don't have them 14610 03:12:36,466 --> 03:12:39,138 coming cleaning as often. 14611 03:12:39,138 --> 03:12:43,273 so those oak trees, now they're 14612 03:12:43,273 --> 03:12:43,273 14613 03:12:43,273 --> 03:12:46,118 water oaks, plant something 14614 03:12:46,118 --> 03:12:46,118 else. 14615 03:12:46,118 --> 03:12:49,410 some other kind of trees like 14616 03:12:49,410 --> 03:12:52,682 they have on the other side on 14617 03:12:52,682 --> 03:12:52,682 14618 03:12:52,682 --> 03:12:53,214 west side. 14619 03:12:53,214 --> 03:12:53,898 they have different types of 14620 03:12:53,898 --> 03:12:53,898 trees. 14621 03:12:53,898 --> 03:12:56,452 they don't have water oaks. 14622 03:12:56,452 --> 03:12:58,083 we do. 14623 03:12:58,083 --> 03:13:00,822 and yes, I was sitting there, 14624 03:13:00,822 --> 03:13:03,594 and all of a sudden this limb 14625 03:13:03,594 --> 03:13:07,194 big limb green fell. 14626 03:13:07,194 --> 03:13:11,200 it was like, why? 14627 03:13:11,200 --> 03:13:13,399 limb was still green but it 14628 03:13:13,399 --> 03:13:13,399 fell. 14629 03:13:13,399 --> 03:13:15,558 big limb. 14630 03:13:15,558 --> 03:13:16,676 I'm not talking about a little 14631 03:13:16,676 --> 03:13:16,676 14632 03:13:16,676 --> 03:13:16,676 twig. 14633 03:13:16,676 --> 03:13:20,892 so therefore, yeah, there is a 14634 03:13:20,892 --> 03:13:20,892 14635 03:13:20,892 --> 03:13:22,710 lot of things that are 14636 03:13:22,710 --> 03:13:22,710 happening. 14637 03:13:22,710 --> 03:13:27,216 no one here would disagree tha 14638 03:13:27,216 --> 03:13:27,216 t 14639 03:13:27,216 --> 03:13:29,458 it need to be paved or 14640 03:13:29,458 --> 03:13:29,458 surfaced. 14641 03:13:29,458 --> 03:13:35,127 no one because I'm trying to 14642 03:13:35,127 --> 03:13:38,199 dodge potholes as I drive along 14643 03:13:38,199 --> 03:13:38,199 , 14644 03:13:38,199 --> 03:13:40,166 and to come and just patch one 14645 03:13:40,166 --> 03:13:40,166 14646 03:13:40,166 --> 03:13:43,129 here and patch one there is a 14647 03:13:43,129 --> 03:13:43,129 mess. 14648 03:13:43,129 --> 03:13:45,336 and since I am a pastor and I d 14649 03:13:45,336 --> 03:13:45,336 o 14650 03:13:45,336 --> 03:13:48,368 go to church not that -- is not 14651 03:13:48,368 --> 03:13:48,368 14652 03:13:48,368 --> 03:13:50,472 my church, but I've had to do 14653 03:13:50,472 --> 03:13:53,740 funerals there, can you imagine 14654 03:13:53,740 --> 03:13:53,740 14655 03:13:53,740 --> 03:13:56,274 if we had to bring the body 14656 03:13:56,274 --> 03:13:57,810 around the back because of tho 14657 03:13:57,810 --> 03:13:57,810 se 14658 03:13:57,810 --> 03:14:00,434 big ugly zippers? 14659 03:14:00,434 --> 03:14:03,150 parked out front of the church, 14660 03:14:03,150 --> 03:14:03,150 14661 03:14:03,150 --> 03:14:06,030 and by the way, I was born and 14662 03:14:06,030 --> 03:14:06,030 14663 03:14:06,030 --> 03:14:09,087 raised on off of 5th avenue. 14664 03:14:09,087 --> 03:14:12,035 I literally got lost the other 14665 03:14:12,035 --> 03:14:12,035 14666 03:14:12,035 --> 03:14:14,566 day, and I was riding in a 14667 03:14:14,566 --> 03:14:18,405 bicycle lane, didn't, it was 14668 03:14:18,405 --> 03:14:22,139 like my god, then I had to go 14669 03:14:22,139 --> 03:14:24,640 down the wrong road, turn, and 14670 03:14:24,640 --> 03:14:25,220 I 14671 03:14:25,220 --> 03:14:27,377 literally didn't know how to g 14672 03:14:27,377 --> 03:14:27,377 et 14673 03:14:27,377 --> 03:14:28,905 back to the new restaurant 14674 03:14:28,905 --> 03:14:31,116 that's down 5th avenue. 14675 03:14:31,116 --> 03:14:33,180 I didn't know how to get back. 14676 03:14:33,180 --> 03:14:33,180 14677 03:14:33,180 --> 03:14:36,252 it was like it's too many littl 14678 03:14:36,252 --> 03:14:36,252 e 14679 03:14:36,252 --> 03:14:38,819 one-way little things, and I w 14680 03:14:38,819 --> 03:14:38,819 as 14681 03:14:38,819 --> 03:14:40,661 like, but I was born and raise 14682 03:14:40,661 --> 03:14:40,661 d 14683 03:14:40,661 --> 03:14:40,661 here. 14684 03:14:40,661 --> 03:14:45,134 no one told me, no one did 14685 03:14:45,134 --> 03:14:46,794 anything, and yes we're still 14686 03:14:46,794 --> 03:14:51,603 going through that shock of 14687 03:14:51,603 --> 03:14:56,637 having the street redone from 14688 03:14:56,637 --> 03:14:58,738 west of main street. 14689 03:14:58,738 --> 03:15:00,481 >> mayor: I'm going to ask you 14690 03:15:00,481 --> 03:15:00,481 14691 03:15:00,481 --> 03:15:01,341 to wrap up, please. 14692 03:15:01,341 --> 03:15:02,007 >> west of main street. 14693 03:15:02,007 --> 03:15:04,763 so no, I disagree with them 14694 03:15:04,763 --> 03:15:10,668 changing things on east -- 14695 03:15:10,668 --> 03:15:11,912 >> mayor: so again, I'm going to 14696 03:15:11,912 --> 03:15:11,912 14697 03:15:11,912 --> 03:15:13,358 be clear that we're not voting 14698 03:15:13,358 --> 03:15:13,358 14699 03:15:13,358 --> 03:15:14,555 to -- there won't be a vote 14700 03:15:14,555 --> 03:15:20,838 today to do anything. 14701 03:15:20,838 --> 03:15:21,793 >> [off mic] 14702 03:15:21,793 --> 03:15:23,769 we don't like it. 14703 03:15:23,769 --> 03:15:24,350 >> mayor: yes, ma'am, that's 14704 03:15:24,350 --> 03:15:27,161 what we're here to hear, not t 14705 03:15:27,161 --> 03:15:27,161 o 14706 03:15:27,161 --> 03:15:29,174 decide how to vote on it because there's 14707 03:15:29,174 --> 03:15:30,667 there's no vote today on pavin 14708 03:15:30,667 --> 03:15:30,667 g 14709 03:15:30,667 --> 03:15:33,101 it or on adding speed bumps or 14710 03:15:33,101 --> 03:15:33,101 14711 03:15:33,101 --> 03:15:33,839 anything else. 14712 03:15:33,839 --> 03:15:34,602 who's next. 14713 03:15:34,602 --> 03:15:36,273 >> we have corey brunson 14714 03:15:36,273 --> 03:15:38,380 followed by kip hayes and ryan 14715 03:15:38,380 --> 03:15:38,380 14716 03:15:38,380 --> 03:15:40,539 undine who is the last one on 14717 03:15:40,539 --> 03:15:41,115 the list. 14718 03:15:41,115 --> 03:15:42,688 >> mayor: welcome. 14719 03:15:42,688 --> 03:15:43,262 >> hi. 14720 03:15:43,262 --> 03:15:44,727 corey brunson, and just speaking 14721 03:15:44,727 --> 03:15:44,727 14722 03:15:44,727 --> 03:15:51,829 for myself, I also was confused 14723 03:15:51,829 --> 03:15:51,829 14724 03:15:51,829 --> 03:15:53,697 when reading the item on the 14725 03:15:53,697 --> 03:15:55,227 agenda a couple of days ago or 14726 03:15:55,227 --> 03:15:55,371 a 14727 03:15:55,371 --> 03:15:57,369 few days ago in that it looked 14728 03:15:57,369 --> 03:15:57,369 14729 03:15:57,369 --> 03:15:58,304 like something was about to be 14730 03:15:58,304 --> 03:15:58,304 14731 03:15:58,304 --> 03:15:59,576 decided that I had not been 14732 03:15:59,576 --> 03:16:01,418 aware of for quite sometime, a 14733 03:16:01,418 --> 03:16:01,418 nd 14734 03:16:01,418 --> 03:16:02,837 sent a kind of frantic email 14735 03:16:02,837 --> 03:16:04,881 suggesting this needs to be 14736 03:16:04,881 --> 03:16:06,022 considered alongside the options 14737 03:16:06,022 --> 03:16:06,022 14738 03:16:06,022 --> 03:16:08,541 that are proposed in this 14739 03:16:08,541 --> 03:16:08,541 report. 14740 03:16:08,541 --> 03:16:11,167 and so I want to apologize for 14741 03:16:11,167 --> 03:16:11,167 14742 03:16:11,167 --> 03:16:12,611 acting like I was trying to mak 14743 03:16:12,611 --> 03:16:12,611 e 14744 03:16:12,611 --> 03:16:14,052 a recommendation to do this 14745 03:16:14,052 --> 03:16:15,599 instead of that. 14746 03:16:15,599 --> 03:16:17,117 I am glad that this is an 14747 03:16:17,117 --> 03:16:19,419 ongoing conversation. 14748 03:16:19,419 --> 03:16:22,353 and so I want to emphasize tha 14749 03:16:22,353 --> 03:16:22,353 t 14750 03:16:22,353 --> 03:16:23,691 I think what I'm going to speak 14751 03:16:23,691 --> 03:16:23,691 , 14752 03:16:23,691 --> 03:16:25,660 what I'm going to say is more 14753 03:16:25,660 --> 03:16:27,705 towards the procedural than 14754 03:16:27,705 --> 03:16:30,369 towards the infrastructural. 14755 03:16:30,369 --> 03:16:32,369 the community needs to exert the 14756 03:16:32,369 --> 03:16:32,369 14757 03:16:32,369 --> 03:16:33,334 greatest influence on how this 14758 03:16:33,334 --> 03:16:33,334 14759 03:16:33,334 --> 03:16:35,845 resurfacing is done. 14760 03:16:35,845 --> 03:16:37,940 but the -- but the procedure 14761 03:16:37,940 --> 03:16:39,812 sets a precedent that the whole 14762 03:16:39,812 --> 03:16:39,812 14763 03:16:39,812 --> 03:16:41,263 city is eventually going to fee 14764 03:16:41,263 --> 03:16:41,263 l 14765 03:16:41,263 --> 03:16:43,757 the impact of. 14766 03:16:43,757 --> 03:16:46,615 one thing to be aware of is tha 14767 03:16:46,615 --> 03:16:46,615 t 14768 03:16:46,615 --> 03:16:48,223 narrowing car lanes from 11 to 14769 03:16:48,223 --> 03:16:48,223 14770 03:16:48,223 --> 03:16:50,315 10 feet, from 10 to 9 feet, 14771 03:16:50,315 --> 03:16:53,423 reduces speeds, which prevents 14772 03:16:53,423 --> 03:16:53,423 14773 03:16:53,423 --> 03:16:55,407 injury, reduces injury, even if 14774 03:16:55,407 --> 03:16:55,407 14775 03:16:55,407 --> 03:16:56,359 it doesn't reduce number of 14776 03:16:56,359 --> 03:16:56,359 crashes. 14777 03:16:56,359 --> 03:17:01,993 motorists can be spect expecte 14778 03:17:01,993 --> 03:17:01,993 d 14779 03:17:01,993 --> 03:17:04,067 to drive the streets facilitat 14780 03:17:04,067 --> 03:17:04,067 ed 14781 03:17:04,067 --> 03:17:05,556 by the street and road design, 14782 03:17:05,556 --> 03:17:05,556 14783 03:17:05,556 --> 03:17:06,706 more lively than the posted 14784 03:17:06,706 --> 03:17:07,181 speed limits. 14785 03:17:07,181 --> 03:17:08,908 we've seen evidence of that. 14786 03:17:08,908 --> 03:17:10,783 and I would say the city stree 14787 03:17:10,783 --> 03:17:10,783 ts 14788 03:17:10,783 --> 03:17:13,075 nee to be appropriately narrowed 14789 03:17:13,075 --> 03:17:13,075 14790 03:17:13,075 --> 03:17:15,774 if they are wider than necessa 14791 03:17:15,774 --> 03:17:15,774 ry 14792 03:17:15,774 --> 03:17:17,583 in general regardless of the 14793 03:17:17,583 --> 03:17:18,943 impacts of pedestrian -- on 14794 03:17:18,943 --> 03:17:21,279 pedestrians and cyclists. 14795 03:17:21,279 --> 03:17:23,587 speaking as a cyclist, bicycli 14796 03:17:23,587 --> 03:17:23,587 ng 14797 03:17:23,587 --> 03:17:28,519 may not be may not expand at a 14798 03:17:28,519 --> 03:17:28,519 14799 03:17:28,519 --> 03:17:31,263 appreciable rate unless or unt 14800 03:17:31,263 --> 03:17:31,263 il 14801 03:17:31,263 --> 03:17:34,765 the infrastructure is improved. 14802 03:17:34,765 --> 03:17:34,765 14803 03:17:34,765 --> 03:17:37,329 but e-cycling, microtransits, 14804 03:17:37,329 --> 03:17:39,203 are going to expand regardless 14805 03:17:39,203 --> 03:17:39,203 14806 03:17:39,203 --> 03:17:41,077 because they are convenient for 14807 03:17:41,077 --> 03:17:41,077 14808 03:17:41,077 --> 03:17:42,907 people who can't or won't put 14809 03:17:42,907 --> 03:17:44,569 themselves in traffic at a 14810 03:17:44,569 --> 03:17:47,743 relatively low speed bicycle. 14811 03:17:47,743 --> 03:17:49,811 and so infrastructure 14812 03:17:49,811 --> 03:17:50,809 redevelopment needs to 14813 03:17:50,809 --> 03:17:54,559 accommodate at least these thr 14814 03:17:54,559 --> 03:17:54,559 ee 14815 03:17:54,559 --> 03:17:54,559 tiers. 14816 03:17:54,559 --> 03:17:56,559 when you separate at the very 14817 03:17:56,559 --> 03:17:57,917 least we need to separate 14818 03:17:57,917 --> 03:17:59,819 pedestrians from e-bikes. 14819 03:17:59,819 --> 03:18:01,824 and that can't be safely done b 14820 03:18:01,824 --> 03:18:01,824 y 14821 03:18:01,824 --> 03:18:03,426 forcing e-bikes and cyclists 14822 03:18:03,426 --> 03:18:04,959 into the same lanes as traffic 14823 03:18:04,959 --> 03:18:04,959 . 14824 03:18:04,959 --> 03:18:08,064 as car traffic. 14825 03:18:08,064 --> 03:18:10,027 my suggestions were just to 14826 03:18:10,027 --> 03:18:11,669 narrow the lanes by a foot or 14827 03:18:11,669 --> 03:18:13,865 two in each direction, which 14828 03:18:13,865 --> 03:18:15,872 would admit plenty of buffers 14829 03:18:15,872 --> 03:18:19,475 separating a two-way bike path 14830 03:18:19,475 --> 03:18:19,475 14831 03:18:19,475 --> 03:18:20,973 which would then reduce the 14832 03:18:20,973 --> 03:18:22,541 number of zippers by about hal 14833 03:18:22,541 --> 03:18:22,541 f, 14834 03:18:22,541 --> 03:18:29,492 the number of -- and cyclists b 14835 03:18:29,492 --> 03:18:29,492 y 14836 03:18:29,492 --> 03:18:30,749 half by putting all the bike 14837 03:18:30,749 --> 03:18:32,193 infrastructure on one side of 14838 03:18:32,193 --> 03:18:35,887 the road. 14839 03:18:35,887 --> 03:18:37,860 and make it more inviting to 14840 03:18:37,860 --> 03:18:40,195 people riding together. 14841 03:18:40,195 --> 03:18:46,194 ideally incre use. 14842 03:18:46,194 --> 03:18:46,967 >> mayor: ask you to wrap up, 14843 03:18:46,967 --> 03:18:46,967 please. 14844 03:18:46,967 --> 03:18:48,201 >> that'll be fine. 14845 03:18:48,201 --> 03:18:49,415 I'll wrap up there. 14846 03:18:49,415 --> 03:18:49,838 thank you. 14847 03:18:49,838 --> 03:18:51,579 >> mayor: thank you. 14848 03:18:51,579 --> 03:18:53,345 >> mr. Kip hayes senior, 14849 03:18:53,345 --> 03:18:55,438 followed by ryan undine. 14850 03:18:55,438 --> 03:18:56,969 >> mayor: welcome, mr. Hayes. 14851 03:18:56,969 --> 03:18:58,943 >> thank you. 14852 03:18:58,943 --> 03:19:01,581 thank you for having me. 14853 03:19:01,581 --> 03:19:02,685 make this brief. 14854 03:19:02,685 --> 03:19:05,891 I'm a property owner of 14855 03:19:05,891 --> 03:19:07,863 property, I have property on the 14856 03:19:07,863 --> 03:19:07,863 14857 03:19:07,863 --> 03:19:09,695 corridor of east gainesville 14858 03:19:09,695 --> 03:19:10,453 duval area. 14859 03:19:10,453 --> 03:19:12,861 and I own what's called the 14860 03:19:12,861 --> 03:19:12,861 slab. 14861 03:19:12,861 --> 03:19:15,437 I own the two-story building 14862 03:19:15,437 --> 03:19:17,235 that used to be russell henry's 14863 03:19:17,235 --> 03:19:17,235 14864 03:19:17,235 --> 03:19:18,799 barber shop. 14865 03:19:18,799 --> 03:19:21,207 I own the property between the 14866 03:19:21,207 --> 03:19:21,207 14867 03:19:21,207 --> 03:19:23,067 me and the church of unity. 14868 03:19:23,067 --> 03:19:23,943 we split the lot. 14869 03:19:23,943 --> 03:19:26,043 I own 10 other slots behind the 14870 03:19:26,043 --> 03:19:26,043 14871 03:19:26,043 --> 03:19:27,811 slab and behind the other 14872 03:19:27,811 --> 03:19:31,745 building itself. 14873 03:19:31,745 --> 03:19:34,815 I just got my permits to build 14874 03:19:34,815 --> 03:19:34,815 , 14875 03:19:34,815 --> 03:19:37,452 to build out the russell henry 14876 03:19:37,452 --> 03:19:37,452 14877 03:19:37,452 --> 03:19:40,615 building to a restaurant to a 14878 03:19:40,615 --> 03:19:43,234 food downstairs. 14879 03:19:43,234 --> 03:19:46,655 also applying for the grant to 14880 03:19:46,655 --> 03:19:46,655 14881 03:19:46,655 --> 03:19:48,816 redo the slab and some of the 14882 03:19:48,816 --> 03:19:51,031 parcels behind the slap to put 14883 03:19:51,031 --> 03:19:51,803 a 14884 03:19:51,803 --> 03:19:53,867 small convenient grocery store 14885 03:19:53,867 --> 03:19:53,867 14886 03:19:53,867 --> 03:19:53,867 there. 14887 03:19:53,867 --> 03:19:53,867 right? 14888 03:19:53,867 --> 03:19:56,565 with a pharmacy because we got 14889 03:19:56,565 --> 03:19:56,733 a 14890 03:19:56,733 --> 03:19:58,541 lot of people in duval, you 14891 03:19:58,541 --> 03:20:00,477 know, that need to get to a 14892 03:20:00,477 --> 03:20:01,675 pharmacy that's not I think it' 14893 03:20:01,675 --> 03:20:01,675 s 14894 03:20:01,675 --> 03:20:03,745 either wal-mart or cvs. 14895 03:20:03,745 --> 03:20:05,649 so we also need to do something 14896 03:20:05,649 --> 03:20:05,649 14897 03:20:05,649 --> 03:20:07,931 about the store that's next do 14898 03:20:07,931 --> 03:20:07,931 or 14899 03:20:07,931 --> 03:20:10,145 to the slab, it's on that 14900 03:20:10,145 --> 03:20:12,788 corridor as well. 14901 03:20:12,788 --> 03:20:16,163 and I figure if we put a bette 14902 03:20:16,163 --> 03:20:16,163 r 14903 03:20:16,163 --> 03:20:20,128 product on 8th avenue, better 14904 03:20:20,128 --> 03:20:23,233 services, better sort of a 14905 03:20:23,233 --> 03:20:24,263 better convenience store but a 14906 03:20:24,263 --> 03:20:24,263 14907 03:20:24,263 --> 03:20:27,445 small grocery store, it will 14908 03:20:27,445 --> 03:20:28,137 eliminate a lot of the things 14909 03:20:28,137 --> 03:20:29,173 going on at that store. 14910 03:20:29,173 --> 03:20:30,801 I'm saying all that because the 14911 03:20:30,801 --> 03:20:30,801 14912 03:20:30,801 --> 03:20:34,110 bike lanes even in the future 14913 03:20:34,110 --> 03:20:35,411 with the traffic that this 14914 03:20:35,411 --> 03:20:36,275 particular project that I'm 14915 03:20:36,275 --> 03:20:37,273 working on is, that I'm 14916 03:20:37,273 --> 03:20:40,091 developing, there would be no 14917 03:20:40,091 --> 03:20:42,419 need, there would be no room for 14918 03:20:42,419 --> 03:20:42,419 14919 03:20:42,419 --> 03:20:43,679 a bike lane with the traffic 14920 03:20:43,679 --> 03:20:45,781 that's going to increase with 14921 03:20:45,781 --> 03:20:46,821 the businesses that I'm trying 14922 03:20:46,821 --> 03:20:46,821 14923 03:20:46,821 --> 03:20:48,497 to set up there. 14924 03:20:48,497 --> 03:20:48,497 right? 14925 03:20:48,497 --> 03:20:52,088 I agree with the resurfacing. 14926 03:20:52,088 --> 03:20:53,629 and I agree with that 14927 03:20:53,629 --> 03:20:53,629 wholeheartedly. 14928 03:20:53,629 --> 03:20:55,263 we been needing that. 14929 03:20:55,263 --> 03:20:59,427 but as far as adding bike lanes 14930 03:20:59,427 --> 03:20:59,427 , 14931 03:20:59,427 --> 03:21:01,677 now or in the future, to what I 14932 03:21:01,677 --> 03:21:01,677 14933 03:21:01,677 --> 03:21:04,001 plan on doing, over there as fa 14934 03:21:04,001 --> 03:21:04,001 r 14935 03:21:04,001 --> 03:21:06,577 as enhancing that community, 14936 03:21:06,577 --> 03:21:07,673 putting a better product out 14937 03:21:07,673 --> 03:21:10,539 there, having a better service 14938 03:21:10,539 --> 03:21:10,539 14939 03:21:10,539 --> 03:21:14,323 for the community itself, I 14940 03:21:14,323 --> 03:21:15,309 don't see how that's going to 14941 03:21:15,309 --> 03:21:15,309 work. 14942 03:21:15,309 --> 03:21:17,425 I'm from that area. 14943 03:21:17,425 --> 03:21:18,227 I grew up in that area. 14944 03:21:18,227 --> 03:21:20,321 I grew up in duval. 14945 03:21:20,321 --> 03:21:21,857 my mom still lives over there. 14946 03:21:21,857 --> 03:21:21,857 14947 03:21:21,857 --> 03:21:23,523 I'm -- the people in the -- 14948 03:21:23,523 --> 03:21:24,929 sitting behind me they see me 14949 03:21:24,929 --> 03:21:26,147 over there every day cleaning u 14950 03:21:26,147 --> 03:21:26,147 p 14951 03:21:26,147 --> 03:21:26,901 that property. 14952 03:21:26,901 --> 03:21:29,690 cleared those lots, those, the 14953 03:21:29,690 --> 03:21:29,690 14954 03:21:29,690 --> 03:21:32,103 trees, the bushes, overbrush, 14955 03:21:32,103 --> 03:21:32,706 all that stuff. 14956 03:21:32,706 --> 03:21:33,983 I did all that with my own dim 14957 03:21:33,983 --> 03:21:33,983 e, 14958 03:21:33,983 --> 03:21:34,940 I bought this property with my 14959 03:21:34,940 --> 03:21:34,940 14960 03:21:34,940 --> 03:21:35,647 own money. 14961 03:21:35,647 --> 03:21:37,938 so I invested my own money int 14962 03:21:37,938 --> 03:21:37,938 o 14963 03:21:37,938 --> 03:21:39,472 this area because this is my 14964 03:21:39,472 --> 03:21:39,472 area. 14965 03:21:39,472 --> 03:21:41,009 this is my property. 14966 03:21:41,009 --> 03:21:42,206 I hate to see what's going on 14967 03:21:42,206 --> 03:21:45,188 over there, but I'm one man. 14968 03:21:45,188 --> 03:21:46,003 if the city really wants to 14969 03:21:46,003 --> 03:21:47,419 help, help me put a grocery 14970 03:21:47,419 --> 03:21:48,181 store on my property. 14971 03:21:48,181 --> 03:21:49,382 help me develop it. 14972 03:21:49,382 --> 03:21:51,453 help me hire -- you know, 14973 03:21:51,453 --> 03:21:53,007 whatever you want to do, as fa 14974 03:21:53,007 --> 03:21:53,007 r 14975 03:21:53,007 --> 03:21:54,649 as developing that area, getti 14976 03:21:54,649 --> 03:21:54,649 ng 14977 03:21:54,649 --> 03:21:56,957 rid of the slab, and running 14978 03:21:56,957 --> 03:21:57,897 that convenience store out of 14979 03:21:57,897 --> 03:21:58,661 business because I don't think 14980 03:21:58,661 --> 03:21:58,661 14981 03:21:58,661 --> 03:22:01,229 they can be bought out, so let 14982 03:22:01,229 --> 03:22:01,229 's 14983 03:22:01,229 --> 03:22:02,011 do that. 14984 03:22:02,011 --> 03:22:04,589 thank you. 14985 03:22:04,589 --> 03:22:05,725 >> mayor: thank you. 14986 03:22:05,725 --> 03:22:08,365 >> brian undine. 14987 03:22:08,365 --> 03:22:09,071 >> question for him. 14988 03:22:09,071 --> 03:22:09,547 >> mayor: hold on. 14989 03:22:09,547 --> 03:22:10,524 just a minute, mr. Hayes. 14990 03:22:10,524 --> 03:22:11,639 come back up. 14991 03:22:11,639 --> 03:22:14,443 we have a question for you. 14992 03:22:14,443 --> 03:22:14,874 commissioner chestnut. 14993 03:22:14,874 --> 03:22:15,307 >> thank you. 14994 03:22:15,307 --> 03:22:16,592 thank you, mr. Hayes. 14995 03:22:16,592 --> 03:22:17,685 it sounds like you are taking 14996 03:22:17,685 --> 03:22:20,059 advantage of the grant that the 14997 03:22:20,059 --> 03:22:20,059 14998 03:22:20,059 --> 03:22:20,563 city -- 14999 03:22:20,563 --> 03:22:22,052 >> yes, ma'am, I have a -- 15000 03:22:22,052 --> 03:22:23,059 >> made available -- 15001 03:22:23,059 --> 03:22:24,094 >> yes, ma'am, I have a grant 15002 03:22:24,094 --> 03:22:24,923 writer on it right now. 15003 03:22:24,923 --> 03:22:25,919 we're going to submit it in the 15004 03:22:25,919 --> 03:22:25,919 15005 03:22:25,919 --> 03:22:27,427 next couple of days hopefully t 15006 03:22:27,427 --> 03:22:27,427 o 15007 03:22:27,427 --> 03:22:31,235 help with the slab part and some 15008 03:22:31,235 --> 03:22:31,235 15009 03:22:31,235 --> 03:22:32,925 facade work on the russell hen 15010 03:22:32,925 --> 03:22:32,925 ry 15011 03:22:32,925 --> 03:22:34,135 building as well. 15012 03:22:34,135 --> 03:22:37,103 I just was permitted, thanks t 15013 03:22:37,103 --> 03:22:37,103 o 15014 03:22:37,103 --> 03:22:38,529 the andrew persons in the offic 15015 03:22:38,529 --> 03:22:38,529 e 15016 03:22:38,529 --> 03:22:40,167 really helping me get my permi 15017 03:22:40,167 --> 03:22:40,167 ts 15018 03:22:40,167 --> 03:22:42,941 and stuff going through and 15019 03:22:42,941 --> 03:22:43,911 commissioner desmon. 15020 03:22:43,911 --> 03:22:45,701 they really helped me because 15021 03:22:45,701 --> 03:22:47,445 this permit with the building 15022 03:22:47,445 --> 03:22:50,177 department took a year. 15023 03:22:50,177 --> 03:22:51,239 and then gun violence helped m 15024 03:22:51,239 --> 03:22:51,239 e 15025 03:22:51,239 --> 03:22:53,553 up a year on the wastewater -- 15026 03:22:53,553 --> 03:22:53,553 15027 03:22:53,553 --> 03:22:55,715 gru helped help held me up 15028 03:22:55,715 --> 03:22:55,831 a 15029 03:22:55,831 --> 03:22:56,613 year on the wastewater. 15030 03:22:56,613 --> 03:22:58,041 when I got them involved, when 15031 03:22:58,041 --> 03:22:58,041 I 15032 03:22:58,041 --> 03:23:06,631 got mr. Persons involved and 15033 03:23:06,631 --> 03:23:07,825 commissioner duncan-walker 15034 03:23:07,825 --> 03:23:09,395 involved, I got my permits. 15035 03:23:09,395 --> 03:23:11,163 I got my permits last month and 15036 03:23:11,163 --> 03:23:11,163 15037 03:23:11,163 --> 03:23:13,135 now they comup with the grant, 15038 03:23:13,135 --> 03:23:13,135 15039 03:23:13,135 --> 03:23:15,105 so I slowed down on what I was 15040 03:23:15,105 --> 03:23:15,105 15041 03:23:15,105 --> 03:23:16,049 doing because I'm spending my 15042 03:23:16,049 --> 03:23:17,873 own money like I say to apply 15043 03:23:17,873 --> 03:23:19,651 for some of that money as well 15044 03:23:19,651 --> 03:23:19,651 15045 03:23:19,651 --> 03:23:20,847 because I believe if we put a 15046 03:23:20,847 --> 03:23:22,711 pharmacy over there with a nic 15047 03:23:22,711 --> 03:23:22,711 e 15048 03:23:22,711 --> 03:23:24,449 little grocery store, it doesn 15049 03:23:24,449 --> 03:23:24,449 't 15050 03:23:24,449 --> 03:23:25,153 have to be really big. 15051 03:23:25,153 --> 03:23:26,201 it just has to be what the 15052 03:23:26,201 --> 03:23:27,079 community needs and a pharmacy 15053 03:23:27,079 --> 03:23:27,079 15054 03:23:27,079 --> 03:23:29,483 in that put it over there, man 15055 03:23:29,483 --> 03:23:29,483 , 15056 03:23:29,483 --> 03:23:30,912 and I think we'll do real well. 15057 03:23:30,912 --> 03:23:30,912 15058 03:23:30,912 --> 03:23:32,687 I think that it'll change the 15059 03:23:32,687 --> 03:23:33,889 way it looks. 15060 03:23:33,889 --> 03:23:35,465 and the way it feels walking 15061 03:23:35,465 --> 03:23:36,525 down the street of east 15062 03:23:36,525 --> 03:23:36,525 gainesville. 15063 03:23:36,525 --> 03:23:39,525 it doesn't feel good, doesn't 15064 03:23:39,525 --> 03:23:39,826 feel safe. 15065 03:23:39,826 --> 03:23:41,113 you know, I'm over there all t 15066 03:23:41,113 --> 03:23:41,113 he 15067 03:23:41,113 --> 03:23:43,166 time and I'm like it's just 15068 03:23:43,166 --> 03:23:44,337 don't feel right, don't feel 15069 03:23:44,337 --> 03:23:47,109 like home and it's supposed to 15070 03:23:47,109 --> 03:23:47,109 15071 03:23:47,109 --> 03:23:48,174 be my home, you know? 15072 03:23:48,174 --> 03:23:50,042 >> well, I want to thank you f 15073 03:23:50,042 --> 03:23:50,042 or 15074 03:23:50,042 --> 03:23:53,413 your due diligence and being 15075 03:23:53,413 --> 03:23:54,433 steady and applying for the 15076 03:23:54,433 --> 03:23:54,433 grant. 15077 03:23:54,433 --> 03:23:55,273 >> thank you. 15078 03:23:55,273 --> 03:23:55,981 >> so thank you. 15079 03:23:55,981 --> 03:23:56,847 >> thank you too. 15080 03:23:56,847 --> 03:23:57,907 >> mayor: thank you. 15081 03:23:57,907 --> 03:23:59,206 commissioner chestnut, and the 15082 03:23:59,206 --> 03:23:59,206 n 15083 03:23:59,206 --> 03:24:01,215 commissioner duncan-walker. 15084 03:24:01,215 --> 03:24:02,222 >> mr. Mayor, mine is just 15085 03:24:02,222 --> 03:24:03,383 simply a comment. 15086 03:24:03,383 --> 03:24:05,582 I wanted to also thank you, 15087 03:24:05,582 --> 03:24:06,561 mr. Hayes. 15088 03:24:06,561 --> 03:24:08,123 we've had numerous conversatio 15089 03:24:08,123 --> 03:24:08,123 ns 15090 03:24:08,123 --> 03:24:10,232 over quite sometime now with 15091 03:24:10,232 --> 03:24:12,596 regards to the type of 15092 03:24:12,596 --> 03:24:13,368 innovation that you want to 15093 03:24:13,368 --> 03:24:16,295 bring to that area that is, tha 15094 03:24:16,295 --> 03:24:16,295 t 15095 03:24:16,295 --> 03:24:18,541 is different, and I think 15096 03:24:18,541 --> 03:24:20,467 colleagues expect to hear from 15097 03:24:20,467 --> 03:24:20,467 15098 03:24:20,467 --> 03:24:23,467 him based on a much more recen 15099 03:24:23,467 --> 03:24:23,467 t 15100 03:24:23,467 --> 03:24:25,000 conversation and a more formal 15101 03:24:25,000 --> 03:24:25,000 15102 03:24:25,000 --> 03:24:25,925 way in terms of a different typ 15103 03:24:25,925 --> 03:24:25,925 e 15104 03:24:25,925 --> 03:24:28,109 of proposal that will also 15105 03:24:28,109 --> 03:24:29,517 impact that area, and so that' 15106 03:24:29,517 --> 03:24:29,517 s 15107 03:24:29,517 --> 03:24:30,726 why this conversation is so 15108 03:24:30,726 --> 03:24:30,726 important. 15109 03:24:30,726 --> 03:24:33,682 I'll conclude right here but 15110 03:24:33,682 --> 03:24:34,813 just to be on the look out for 15111 03:24:34,813 --> 03:24:34,813 15112 03:24:34,813 --> 03:24:35,879 something that I believe is 15113 03:24:35,879 --> 03:24:37,195 coming forward. 15114 03:24:37,195 --> 03:24:38,849 I think andrew I mentioned it t 15115 03:24:38,849 --> 03:24:38,849 o 15116 03:24:38,849 --> 03:24:41,825 you as well, so thank you once 15117 03:24:41,825 --> 03:24:41,825 15118 03:24:41,825 --> 03:24:44,825 again, mr. Hayes, for trying to 15119 03:24:44,825 --> 03:24:44,825 15120 03:24:44,825 --> 03:24:46,325 be a part of the solution with 15121 03:24:46,325 --> 03:24:46,325 15122 03:24:46,325 --> 03:24:49,165 regards toic economic 15123 03:24:49,165 --> 03:24:50,067 development on 8th avenue.you. 15124 03:24:50,067 --> 03:24:50,067 15125 03:24:50,067 --> 03:24:51,897 >> mayor: thank you, 15126 03:24:51,897 --> 03:24:55,475 commissioner duncan-walker -- 15127 03:24:55,475 --> 03:24:56,931 >> I d't have a lot to say. 15128 03:24:56,931 --> 03:24:59,081 so thank you for resurfacing 15129 03:24:59,081 --> 03:25:01,675 that road that is fan fastic, 15130 03:25:01,675 --> 03:25:02,911 well needed, fixing the 15131 03:25:02,911 --> 03:25:04,213 sidewalk, that will be great. 15132 03:25:04,213 --> 03:25:05,651 I would like to point out that 15133 03:25:05,651 --> 03:25:05,651 15134 03:25:05,651 --> 03:25:06,723 you're seeing differences in 15135 03:25:06,723 --> 03:25:09,153 speeding from west of waldo, 15136 03:25:09,153 --> 03:25:10,256 they're totally different. 15137 03:25:10,256 --> 03:25:11,783 totally different neighbors and 15138 03:25:11,783 --> 03:25:11,783 15139 03:25:11,783 --> 03:25:13,551 smrkt east of waldo is totally 15140 03:25:13,551 --> 03:25:13,551 15141 03:25:13,551 --> 03:25:15,319 different than any other secti 15142 03:25:15,319 --> 03:25:15,319 on 15143 03:25:15,319 --> 03:25:17,059 of 8th avenue because it's a 15144 03:25:17,059 --> 03:25:17,059 neighborhood. 15145 03:25:17,059 --> 03:25:19,407 that's a neighborhood street. 15146 03:25:19,407 --> 03:25:21,021 the reason you're seeing those 15147 03:25:21,021 --> 03:25:21,021 15148 03:25:21,021 --> 03:25:22,131 speeds is because people are 15149 03:25:22,131 --> 03:25:23,690 coming down waldo road and 15150 03:25:23,690 --> 03:25:25,297 trying to dodge that 15151 03:25:25,297 --> 03:25:26,295 intersection and they come dow 15152 03:25:26,295 --> 03:25:26,295 n, 15153 03:25:26,295 --> 03:25:27,765 they turn right, and they fly 15154 03:25:27,765 --> 03:25:29,643 down that road. 15155 03:25:29,643 --> 03:25:31,841 I live on the corner, I own my 15156 03:25:31,841 --> 03:25:31,841 15157 03:25:31,841 --> 03:25:33,575 home on the corner of 23rd 15158 03:25:33,575 --> 03:25:34,575 street and 8th avenue. 15159 03:25:34,575 --> 03:25:35,372 that's where I live. 15160 03:25:35,372 --> 03:25:37,256 we don't have a sidewalk there 15161 03:25:37,256 --> 03:25:37,256 . 15162 03:25:37,256 --> 03:25:37,906 don't care. 15163 03:25:37,906 --> 03:25:40,344 it can come in and not come in, 15164 03:25:40,344 --> 03:25:40,344 15165 03:25:40,344 --> 03:25:40,755 I don't care. 15166 03:25:40,755 --> 03:25:42,215 the crosswalks is a great idea, 15167 03:25:42,215 --> 03:25:42,215 15168 03:25:42,215 --> 03:25:43,277 as long as you're not ticketing 15169 03:25:43,277 --> 03:25:43,277 15170 03:25:43,277 --> 03:25:44,735 people that don't use them 15171 03:25:44,735 --> 03:25:45,321 because it's a neighborhood 15172 03:25:45,321 --> 03:25:45,321 street. 15173 03:25:45,321 --> 03:25:47,711 people are going to want to go 15174 03:25:47,711 --> 03:25:47,711 15175 03:25:47,711 --> 03:25:48,586 back and forth, right? 15176 03:25:48,586 --> 03:25:49,290 it is a neighborhood. 15177 03:25:49,290 --> 03:25:52,560 having no intralines telling u 15178 03:25:52,560 --> 03:25:52,560 s 15179 03:25:52,560 --> 03:25:55,060 how -- extra lines telling us 15180 03:25:55,060 --> 03:25:56,202 how we have to use the road is 15181 03:25:56,202 --> 03:25:56,202 15182 03:25:56,202 --> 03:25:57,063 okay with us. 15183 03:25:57,063 --> 03:25:59,247 if you want to cut down the 15184 03:25:59,247 --> 03:26:01,033 speed, you have to deter peopl 15185 03:26:01,033 --> 03:26:01,033 e 15186 03:26:01,033 --> 03:26:03,207 from trying to use that as a c 15187 03:26:03,207 --> 03:26:03,207 ut 15188 03:26:03,207 --> 03:26:03,207 through. 15189 03:26:03,207 --> 03:26:05,534 as far as those trees go, those 15190 03:26:05,534 --> 03:26:05,534 15191 03:26:05,534 --> 03:26:06,841 trees can be beautiful healthy 15192 03:26:06,841 --> 03:26:06,841 15193 03:26:06,841 --> 03:26:08,501 trees water oak or not. 15194 03:26:08,501 --> 03:26:09,991 they are designed to get heavy 15195 03:26:09,991 --> 03:26:09,991 15196 03:26:09,991 --> 03:26:11,917 with acorns, load up and break 15197 03:26:11,917 --> 03:26:11,917 , 15198 03:26:11,917 --> 03:26:13,445 and fall down. 15199 03:26:13,445 --> 03:26:15,647 that's how they're evolved and 15200 03:26:15,647 --> 03:26:15,647 15201 03:26:15,647 --> 03:26:18,082 if we're cutting these close t 15202 03:26:18,082 --> 03:26:18,082 o 15203 03:26:18,082 --> 03:26:18,930 the trunk they are going to hav 15204 03:26:18,930 --> 03:26:18,930 e 15205 03:26:18,930 --> 03:26:19,233 rot problems. 15206 03:26:19,233 --> 03:26:21,681 and that's the problem we have 15207 03:26:21,681 --> 03:26:21,681 . 15208 03:26:21,681 --> 03:26:23,441 you send in city crews and 15209 03:26:23,441 --> 03:26:24,521 they're destroying the trees. 15210 03:26:24,521 --> 03:26:25,991 they get unhealthy and are goi 15211 03:26:25,991 --> 03:26:25,991 ng 15212 03:26:25,991 --> 03:26:27,863 to fall. 15213 03:26:27,863 --> 03:26:29,291 I think I said everything. 15214 03:26:29,291 --> 03:26:32,798 oh it food store, yeah. 15215 03:26:32,798 --> 03:26:33,590 if we have accidents on the 15216 03:26:33,590 --> 03:26:35,139 street people getting hit and 15217 03:26:35,139 --> 03:26:36,336 killed that's because they're 15218 03:26:36,336 --> 03:26:37,234 coming from across the street 15219 03:26:37,234 --> 03:26:37,234 of 15220 03:26:37,234 --> 03:26:38,979 the food store stumbling to th 15221 03:26:38,979 --> 03:26:38,979 e 15222 03:26:38,979 --> 03:26:41,971 clarence thomas center and sit 15223 03:26:41,971 --> 03:26:41,971 15224 03:26:41,971 --> 03:26:42,640 down and do whatever. 15225 03:26:42,640 --> 03:26:43,834 I can't even go to that park no 15226 03:26:43,834 --> 03:26:43,834 15227 03:26:43,834 --> 03:26:44,946 more, right wmy daughter. 15228 03:26:44,946 --> 03:26:46,041 I have a 6-year-old daughter. 15229 03:26:46,041 --> 03:26:46,746 that's another thing. 15230 03:26:46,746 --> 03:26:48,517 kids on the street, that's whe 15231 03:26:48,517 --> 03:26:48,517 re 15232 03:26:48,517 --> 03:26:50,151 I taught her to ride her bike. 15233 03:26:50,151 --> 03:26:50,151 15234 03:26:50,151 --> 03:26:50,913 not on that street. 15235 03:26:50,913 --> 03:26:52,048 we don't go on 8th avenue to 15236 03:26:52,048 --> 03:26:53,224 go on that street, all right? 15237 03:26:53,224 --> 03:26:55,255 if we start putting lines on 15238 03:26:55,255 --> 03:26:56,895 there, we got extra laws and 15239 03:26:56,895 --> 03:26:57,987 extra enforcement and we alrea 15240 03:26:57,987 --> 03:26:57,987 dy 15241 03:26:57,987 --> 03:26:59,201 have predatory police trying t 15242 03:26:59,201 --> 03:26:59,201 o 15243 03:26:59,201 --> 03:27:01,262 fill quotas watching for 15244 03:27:01,262 --> 03:27:02,061 teenagers driving slow. 15245 03:27:02,061 --> 03:27:03,747 so please, like we don't need a 15246 03:27:03,747 --> 03:27:03,747 15247 03:27:03,747 --> 03:27:04,728 bunch of extra lines. 15248 03:27:04,728 --> 03:27:06,371 it's just a neighborhood. 15249 03:27:06,371 --> 03:27:07,994 do you want extra lines on the 15250 03:27:07,994 --> 03:27:07,994 15251 03:27:07,994 --> 03:27:09,568 road outside of your house? 15252 03:27:09,568 --> 03:27:10,535 probably not. 15253 03:27:10,535 --> 03:27:11,074 probably not. 15254 03:27:11,074 --> 03:27:12,148 so I hope y'all have a great 15255 03:27:12,148 --> 03:27:12,148 day. 15256 03:27:12,148 --> 03:27:13,203 god bless. 15257 03:27:13,203 --> 03:27:14,303 thank you. 15258 03:27:14,303 --> 03:27:15,930 for fixing it and next time I 15259 03:27:15,930 --> 03:27:16,590 see you I'll probably be angry 15260 03:27:16,590 --> 03:27:16,590 , 15261 03:27:16,590 --> 03:27:18,282 who knows, I'm crazy, right? 15262 03:27:18,282 --> 03:27:18,852 >> mayor: thank you. 15263 03:27:18,852 --> 03:27:21,254 >> we did have another sign up, 15264 03:27:21,254 --> 03:27:21,254 15265 03:27:21,254 --> 03:27:24,118 arb armando grundy gomez. 15266 03:27:24,118 --> 03:27:25,200 >> welcome, mr. Gundy. 15267 03:27:25,200 --> 03:27:26,297 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 15268 03:27:26,297 --> 03:27:27,688 armando grundy gomez. 15269 03:27:27,688 --> 03:27:29,652 I guess I want to do a contrac 15270 03:27:29,652 --> 03:27:29,652 ts 15271 03:27:29,652 --> 03:27:31,808 when it comes -- contrast when 15272 03:27:31,808 --> 03:27:31,808 15273 03:27:31,808 --> 03:27:32,760 it comes to public works 15274 03:27:32,760 --> 03:27:33,844 projects of this nature when I 15275 03:27:33,844 --> 03:27:33,844 t 15276 03:27:33,844 --> 03:27:35,160 comes to quote, unquote, 15277 03:27:35,160 --> 03:27:35,580 complete streets. 15278 03:27:35,580 --> 03:27:37,068 I remember the last time a few 15279 03:27:37,068 --> 03:27:37,068 15280 03:27:37,068 --> 03:27:38,166 iterations ago a few years ago 15281 03:27:38,166 --> 03:27:38,166 15282 03:27:38,166 --> 03:27:39,662 when we talk about complete 15283 03:27:39,662 --> 03:27:40,900 streets, we talk about 15284 03:27:40,900 --> 03:27:42,106 university avenue which also 15285 03:27:42,106 --> 03:27:43,846 goes also into our community a 15286 03:27:43,846 --> 03:27:43,846 nd 15287 03:27:43,846 --> 03:27:44,912 district 1. 15288 03:27:44,912 --> 03:27:46,282 and in that during that 15289 03:27:46,282 --> 03:27:48,072 conversation and that time, the 15290 03:27:48,072 --> 03:27:48,072 15291 03:27:48,072 --> 03:27:49,170 only real section of university 15292 03:27:49,170 --> 03:27:49,170 15293 03:27:49,170 --> 03:27:51,014 avenue that's really a complete 15294 03:27:51,014 --> 03:27:51,014 15295 03:27:51,014 --> 03:27:53,119 street is in and around and by 15296 03:27:53,119 --> 03:27:53,119 15297 03:27:53,119 --> 03:27:54,020 the definition of a complete 15298 03:27:54,020 --> 03:27:55,976 street, I'm talking about for 15299 03:27:55,976 --> 03:27:56,856 the department of transportatio 15300 03:27:56,856 --> 03:27:56,856 n 15301 03:27:56,856 --> 03:27:58,726 and what civil engineers will 15302 03:27:58,726 --> 03:27:59,922 recognize as you having a mu 15303 03:27:59,922 --> 03:28:02,184 multimodal pedestrian friendly 15304 03:28:02,184 --> 03:28:02,184 15305 03:28:02,184 --> 03:28:03,458 slowing down of traffic, 15306 03:28:03,458 --> 03:28:05,110 et cetera, you have that in and 15307 03:28:05,110 --> 03:28:05,110 15308 03:28:05,110 --> 03:28:06,334 around the university but if yo 15309 03:28:06,334 --> 03:28:06,334 u 15310 03:28:06,334 --> 03:28:09,059 have it down in district 1, pas 15311 03:28:09,059 --> 03:28:09,059 t 15312 03:28:09,059 --> 03:28:10,898 waldo road you don't pretty muc 15313 03:28:10,898 --> 03:28:10,898 h 15314 03:28:10,898 --> 03:28:12,697 you don't see that too much. 15315 03:28:12,697 --> 03:28:14,196 you don't see it slowing down. 15316 03:28:14,196 --> 03:28:14,196 15317 03:28:14,196 --> 03:28:15,634 of course we have traffic death 15318 03:28:15,634 --> 03:28:15,634 s 15319 03:28:15,634 --> 03:28:17,214 but we also have traffic deaths 15320 03:28:17,214 --> 03:28:17,214 15321 03:28:17,214 --> 03:28:18,406 in district 1 too. 15322 03:28:18,406 --> 03:28:19,498 so I just find it interesting 15323 03:28:19,498 --> 03:28:22,982 that we're having the tale of 15324 03:28:22,982 --> 03:28:24,015 two streets. 15325 03:28:24,015 --> 03:28:26,488 so it I guess I want to 15326 03:28:26,488 --> 03:28:27,986 understand where all this energ 15327 03:28:27,986 --> 03:28:27,986 15328 03:28:27,986 --> 03:28:32,136 is coming from to want to have 15329 03:28:32,136 --> 03:28:32,136 15330 03:28:32,136 --> 03:28:34,450 this -- one person would say 15331 03:28:34,450 --> 03:28:35,984 we're resurfacing it. 15332 03:28:35,984 --> 03:28:37,858 is that really the reiteration 15333 03:28:37,858 --> 03:28:37,858 15334 03:28:37,858 --> 03:28:39,826 of why we're doing this? 15335 03:28:39,826 --> 03:28:40,566 of course we want to have bike 15336 03:28:40,566 --> 03:28:40,566 15337 03:28:40,566 --> 03:28:41,602 lanes and they're good, but if 15338 03:28:41,602 --> 03:28:41,602 15339 03:28:41,602 --> 03:28:44,662 that was the case why didn't w 15340 03:28:44,662 --> 03:28:44,662 e 15341 03:28:44,662 --> 03:28:45,694 complete university avenue all 15342 03:28:45,694 --> 03:28:45,694 15343 03:28:45,694 --> 03:28:47,036 the way down too and make it a 15344 03:28:47,036 --> 03:28:47,036 15345 03:28:47,036 --> 03:28:47,696 real complete street? 15346 03:28:47,696 --> 03:28:48,670 because it is the same 15347 03:28:48,670 --> 03:28:49,644 university avenue if I turn off 15348 03:28:49,644 --> 03:28:49,644 15349 03:28:49,644 --> 03:28:51,633 of williston road and turn lef 15350 03:28:51,633 --> 03:28:51,633 t, 15351 03:28:51,633 --> 03:28:53,076 and go toward university of 15352 03:28:53,076 --> 03:28:54,634 florida, it's not a complete 15353 03:28:54,634 --> 03:28:58,577 street when you come off 15354 03:28:58,577 --> 03:29:01,512 williston road. 15355 03:29:01,512 --> 03:29:04,964 oh urmy, my my god it slo 15356 03:29:04,964 --> 03:29:05,058 ws down 15357 03:29:05,058 --> 03:29:06,154 and is beautiful and wonderful 15358 03:29:06,154 --> 03:29:06,154 15359 03:29:06,154 --> 03:29:07,720 and gorgeous. 15360 03:29:07,720 --> 03:29:09,048 so that would be my question why 15361 03:29:09,048 --> 03:29:09,048 15362 03:29:09,048 --> 03:29:09,048 now. 15363 03:29:09,048 --> 03:29:10,887 where is all this and it's not 15364 03:29:10,887 --> 03:29:10,887 15365 03:29:10,887 --> 03:29:13,761 simply because we're resurfacing 15366 03:29:13,761 --> 03:29:13,761 15367 03:29:13,761 --> 03:29:13,761 it. 15368 03:29:13,761 --> 03:29:19,906 make it make sense. 15369 03:29:19,906 --> 03:29:21,330 and what's the total cost of 15370 03:29:21,330 --> 03:29:21,330 this? 15371 03:29:21,330 --> 03:29:24,658 so but what we would be great I 15372 03:29:24,658 --> 03:29:24,658 s 15373 03:29:24,658 --> 03:29:25,381 when we're having the 15374 03:29:25,381 --> 03:29:27,058 conversation about the 8th and 15375 03:29:27,058 --> 03:29:27,058 15376 03:29:27,058 --> 03:29:28,680 waldo road project is why is 15377 03:29:28,680 --> 03:29:29,952 waldo road looking the same as 15378 03:29:29,952 --> 03:29:29,952 15379 03:29:29,952 --> 03:29:31,896 it has for 40 years, why are w 15380 03:29:31,896 --> 03:29:31,896 e 15381 03:29:31,896 --> 03:29:33,496 not having real economic 15382 03:29:33,496 --> 03:29:35,458 investment in economic in that 15383 03:29:35,458 --> 03:29:35,458 15384 03:29:35,458 --> 03:29:36,912 corridor, real economic 15385 03:29:36,912 --> 03:29:36,912 investment. 15386 03:29:36,912 --> 03:29:38,620 I'm not talking about parts and 15387 03:29:38,620 --> 03:29:38,620 15388 03:29:38,620 --> 03:29:40,484 piece3450e8ing we're doing 15389 03:29:40,484 --> 03:29:44,556 street cafes with gcra money. 15390 03:29:44,556 --> 03:29:45,328 I want to have real 15391 03:29:45,328 --> 03:29:46,138 conversations about what we ca 15392 03:29:46,138 --> 03:29:46,138 n 15393 03:29:46,138 --> 03:29:49,338 do to have meaningful impact in 15394 03:29:49,338 --> 03:29:49,338 15395 03:29:49,338 --> 03:29:51,701 the community that sees 15396 03:29:51,701 --> 03:29:52,466 disinvestment from you and not 15397 03:29:52,466 --> 03:29:52,466 15398 03:29:52,466 --> 03:29:52,879 real investment. 15399 03:29:52,879 --> 03:29:53,932 thank you so much. 15400 03:29:53,932 --> 03:29:54,466 >> mayor: thank you, 15401 03:29:54,466 --> 03:29:55,856 mr. Grundy. 15402 03:29:55,856 --> 03:29:56,724 I do want to point out we have 15403 03:29:56,724 --> 03:29:56,724 15404 03:29:56,724 --> 03:29:58,341 been trying to get the funds 15405 03:29:58,341 --> 03:30:00,514 released to do the similar wor 15406 03:30:00,514 --> 03:30:00,514 k 15407 03:30:00,514 --> 03:30:03,376 on the east end of university 15408 03:30:03,376 --> 03:30:06,213 avenue that fdot released to d 15409 03:30:06,213 --> 03:30:06,213 o 15410 03:30:06,213 --> 03:30:07,780 in front of the university of 15411 03:30:07,780 --> 03:30:09,546 florida for a number of years, 15412 03:30:09,546 --> 03:30:09,546 15413 03:30:09,546 --> 03:30:10,415 some of those times while you 15414 03:30:10,415 --> 03:30:11,914 were sitting in the room, 15415 03:30:11,914 --> 03:30:13,230 mr. Grundy. 15416 03:30:13,230 --> 03:30:15,822 but I would love to be able to 15417 03:30:15,822 --> 03:30:15,822 15418 03:30:15,822 --> 03:30:17,590 get a safer east university 15419 03:30:17,590 --> 03:30:19,126 avenue as I'm on the record 15420 03:30:19,126 --> 03:30:20,598 voting for a number of times. 15421 03:30:20,598 --> 03:30:22,236 so thank you for that. 15422 03:30:22,236 --> 03:30:23,858 anyone else? 15423 03:30:23,858 --> 03:30:25,530 >> [off mic] 15424 03:30:25,530 --> 03:30:26,470 >> mayor: okay. 15425 03:30:26,470 --> 03:30:28,300 as we move forward, I want to 15426 03:30:28,300 --> 03:30:31,934 let everybody know that unless 15427 03:30:31,934 --> 03:30:31,934 15428 03:30:31,934 --> 03:30:34,240 there is a objection we're goi 15429 03:30:34,240 --> 03:30:34,240 ng 15430 03:30:34,240 --> 03:30:36,318 to move the two land use -- th 15431 03:30:36,318 --> 03:30:36,318 e 15432 03:30:36,318 --> 03:30:38,316 land use and zoning item forwa 15433 03:30:38,316 --> 03:30:38,316 rd 15434 03:30:38,316 --> 03:30:39,650 to the end of the agenda becau 15435 03:30:39,650 --> 03:30:39,650 se 15436 03:30:39,650 --> 03:30:40,848 we clearly don't have time for 15437 03:30:40,848 --> 03:30:40,848 15438 03:30:40,848 --> 03:30:44,560 them this afternoon. 15439 03:30:44,560 --> 03:30:45,554 and again, what we're talking 15440 03:30:45,554 --> 03:30:49,202 about here is where do we go 15441 03:30:49,202 --> 03:30:51,992 forward as far as more, more 15442 03:30:51,992 --> 03:30:54,610 engagement and more planning, w 15443 03:30:54,610 --> 03:30:54,610 e 15444 03:30:54,610 --> 03:30:57,706 have not had the opportunity t 15445 03:30:57,706 --> 03:30:57,706 o 15446 03:30:57,706 --> 03:31:00,466 have funding available to do 15447 03:31:00,466 --> 03:31:01,702 anything yet as we've said fro 15448 03:31:01,702 --> 03:31:01,702 m 15449 03:31:01,702 --> 03:31:03,369 the beginning of this item. 15450 03:31:03,369 --> 03:31:05,042 so I don't want anybody to thin 15451 03:31:05,042 --> 03:31:05,042 k 15452 03:31:05,042 --> 03:31:06,005 once again that we are in the 15453 03:31:06,005 --> 03:31:10,817 process of rolling out 15454 03:31:10,817 --> 03:31:11,799 crosswalks and all that sort o 15455 03:31:11,799 --> 03:31:11,799 f 15456 03:31:11,799 --> 03:31:13,482 thing right now because it's n 15457 03:31:13,482 --> 03:31:13,482 ot 15458 03:31:13,482 --> 03:31:16,950 funded at this point. 15459 03:31:16,950 --> 03:31:17,950 many, many lights. 15460 03:31:17,950 --> 03:31:19,281 before we move on from this 15461 03:31:19,281 --> 03:31:23,456 item, so commissioner ingle. 15462 03:31:23,456 --> 03:31:24,268 >> I would like to make a motio 15463 03:31:24,268 --> 03:31:24,268 n 15464 03:31:24,268 --> 03:31:26,854 his item until there 15465 03:31:26,854 --> 03:31:29,295 has been community input. 15466 03:31:29,295 --> 03:31:30,806 >> second. 15467 03:31:30,806 --> 03:31:31,458 >> mayor: would 15468 03:31:31,458 --> 03:31:33,466 >> would the maker of the 15469 03:31:33,466 --> 03:31:35,093 motion -- well, let me just say 15470 03:31:35,093 --> 03:31:35,093 15471 03:31:35,093 --> 03:31:35,093 this. 15472 03:31:35,093 --> 03:31:36,332 I'm speaking out of turn. 15473 03:31:36,332 --> 03:31:37,699 >> mayor: go ahead, it's all 15474 03:31:37,699 --> 03:31:37,699 right. 15475 03:31:37,699 --> 03:31:40,738 >> in the interest of clarity 15476 03:31:40,738 --> 03:31:44,347 I'm going to convene a meeting 15477 03:31:44,347 --> 03:31:44,347 15478 03:31:44,347 --> 03:31:45,787 as the district 1 commissioner. 15479 03:31:45,787 --> 03:31:45,787 15480 03:31:45,787 --> 03:31:47,451 I I am going to convene a 15481 03:31:47,451 --> 03:31:47,451 meeting. 15482 03:31:47,451 --> 03:31:49,195 it is something that I've 15483 03:31:49,195 --> 03:31:52,017 already mentioned to staff. 15484 03:31:52,017 --> 03:31:53,487 because there is a certain way 15485 03:31:53,487 --> 03:31:53,487 15486 03:31:53,487 --> 03:31:55,163 that I know that I can convene 15487 03:31:55,163 --> 03:31:55,353 a 15488 03:31:55,353 --> 03:31:55,353 meeting. 15489 03:31:55,353 --> 03:31:56,498 there are certain things that 15490 03:31:56,498 --> 03:31:57,362 are important to me about the 15491 03:31:57,362 --> 03:31:58,931 way that these meetings should 15492 03:31:58,931 --> 03:31:58,931 15493 03:31:58,931 --> 03:32:02,867 go but also it's important to m 15494 03:32:02,867 --> 03:32:02,867 e 15495 03:32:02,867 --> 03:32:04,365 that I can convene this. 15496 03:32:04,365 --> 03:32:05,631 understand that when I say I'm 15497 03:32:05,631 --> 03:32:05,631 15498 03:32:05,631 --> 03:32:06,883 going to convene the meeting t 15499 03:32:06,883 --> 03:32:06,883 he 15500 03:32:06,883 --> 03:32:07,831 meeting that I'm talking about 15501 03:32:07,831 --> 03:32:07,831 15502 03:32:07,831 --> 03:32:10,541 is going to be very similar to 15503 03:32:10,541 --> 03:32:10,541 15504 03:32:10,541 --> 03:32:12,054 what we did over at cone park a 15505 03:32:12,054 --> 03:32:12,054 15506 03:32:12,054 --> 03:32:13,723 couple of weeks ago and it will 15507 03:32:13,723 --> 03:32:13,723 15508 03:32:13,723 --> 03:32:16,115 be a robust experience, not jus 15509 03:32:16,115 --> 03:32:16,115 t 15510 03:32:16,115 --> 03:32:18,423 where you're being provided 15511 03:32:18,423 --> 03:32:20,125 information, but where you wil 15512 03:32:20,125 --> 03:32:20,125 l 15513 03:32:20,125 --> 03:32:21,343 have the opportunity to speak 15514 03:32:21,343 --> 03:32:23,979 because that's the whole point 15515 03:32:23,979 --> 03:32:23,979 . 15516 03:32:23,979 --> 03:32:26,515 so I'm sorry I was going to ask 15517 03:32:26,515 --> 03:32:26,515 15518 03:32:26,515 --> 03:32:28,291 you to add something to that a 15519 03:32:28,291 --> 03:32:28,291 nd 15520 03:32:28,291 --> 03:32:29,051 I don't think I need to in lig 15521 03:32:29,051 --> 03:32:29,051 ht 15522 03:32:29,051 --> 03:32:29,659 of that. 15523 03:32:29,659 --> 03:32:30,863 >> all right. 15524 03:32:30,863 --> 03:32:31,497 >> mayor: all right. 15525 03:32:31,497 --> 03:32:32,593 you good, commissioner 15526 03:32:32,593 --> 03:32:32,593 duncan-walker? 15527 03:32:32,593 --> 03:32:33,695 >> I think so. 15528 03:32:33,695 --> 03:32:34,801 >> mayor: all right. 15529 03:32:34,801 --> 03:32:37,101 commissioner willits. 15530 03:32:37,101 --> 03:32:37,707 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 15531 03:32:37,707 --> 03:32:39,869 can staff just read from our 15532 03:32:39,869 --> 03:32:40,867 comp plan why it is that we're 15533 03:32:40,867 --> 03:32:40,867 15534 03:32:40,867 --> 03:32:43,139 doing this? 15535 03:32:43,139 --> 03:32:44,601 can it be read just so it's 15536 03:32:44,601 --> 03:32:44,601 clear? 15537 03:32:44,601 --> 03:32:46,171 I can't find it searching comp 15538 03:32:46,171 --> 03:32:46,171 15539 03:32:46,171 --> 03:32:46,171 plan. 15540 03:32:46,171 --> 03:32:48,304 or comp plan specifically says 15541 03:32:48,304 --> 03:32:48,304 15542 03:32:48,304 --> 03:32:51,777 when we resurface, I'm trying t 15543 03:32:51,777 --> 03:32:51,777 o 15544 03:32:51,777 --> 03:32:53,443 remember the type of road, but 15545 03:32:53,443 --> 03:32:53,443 15546 03:32:53,443 --> 03:32:54,749 there's a specific type of roa 15547 03:32:54,749 --> 03:32:54,749 d 15548 03:32:54,749 --> 03:32:56,978 that when we go to resurface I 15549 03:32:56,978 --> 03:32:56,978 t, 15550 03:32:56,978 --> 03:32:59,049 we must begin this process of 15551 03:32:59,049 --> 03:33:02,019 considering, correct? 15552 03:33:02,019 --> 03:33:03,755 bike lanes, safety improvement 15553 03:33:03,755 --> 03:33:03,755 15554 03:33:03,755 --> 03:33:08,101 whether that's I think it's the 15555 03:33:08,101 --> 03:33:08,101 15556 03:33:08,101 --> 03:33:10,033 whole that's why it's here 15557 03:33:10,033 --> 03:33:11,377 because if we weren't 15558 03:33:11,377 --> 03:33:12,407 resurfacing this would never 15559 03:33:12,407 --> 03:33:15,134 come up, right? 15560 03:33:15,134 --> 03:33:15,134 so-- 15561 03:33:15,134 --> 03:33:18,417 >> chase -- city engineer. 15562 03:33:18,417 --> 03:33:19,643 I apologize I don't have the 15563 03:33:19,643 --> 03:33:20,405 specific comp plan right here. 15564 03:33:20,405 --> 03:33:20,405 15565 03:33:20,405 --> 03:33:22,637 I do have the engineering desig 15566 03:33:22,637 --> 03:33:22,637 n 15567 03:33:22,637 --> 03:33:25,009 and construction manual. 15568 03:33:25,009 --> 03:33:26,153 >> forget -- I typically say 15569 03:33:26,153 --> 03:33:27,575 comp plan because comp plan 15570 03:33:27,575 --> 03:33:29,981 references a, does it not 15571 03:33:29,981 --> 03:33:31,446 reference the design and 15572 03:33:31,446 --> 03:33:35,121 construction manual, the edm? 15573 03:33:35,121 --> 03:33:36,198 roughly that's how I 15574 03:33:36,198 --> 03:33:37,373 understand -- I said comp plan 15575 03:33:37,373 --> 03:33:37,373 15576 03:33:37,373 --> 03:33:38,297 so it references. 15577 03:33:38,297 --> 03:33:39,105 somewhere there is written 15578 03:33:39,105 --> 03:33:41,767 policy that says when we go 15579 03:33:41,767 --> 03:33:44,169 forward before we go spending a 15580 03:33:44,169 --> 03:33:44,169 15581 03:33:44,169 --> 03:33:45,331 bunch of money on paving let's 15582 03:33:45,331 --> 03:33:45,331 15583 03:33:45,331 --> 03:33:47,027 look and see if the thing we 15584 03:33:47,027 --> 03:33:48,509 missed 20 years ago needs to be 15585 03:33:48,509 --> 03:33:48,509 15586 03:33:48,509 --> 03:33:51,639 done today. 15587 03:33:51,639 --> 03:33:53,886 >> yes, in general so 15588 03:33:53,886 --> 03:33:55,238 transportation element 15589 03:33:55,238 --> 03:33:55,802 underneath the comprehensive 15590 03:33:55,802 --> 03:33:57,447 plan, and then the bicycle 15591 03:33:57,447 --> 03:33:59,753 facilities underneath our edcm 15592 03:33:59,753 --> 03:33:59,753 15593 03:33:59,753 --> 03:34:01,985 references pretty close to the 15594 03:34:01,985 --> 03:34:01,985 15595 03:34:01,985 --> 03:34:03,114 same language but it's bicycle 15596 03:34:03,114 --> 03:34:03,114 15597 03:34:03,114 --> 03:34:04,717 facilities shall be provided o 15598 03:34:04,717 --> 03:34:04,717 n 15599 03:34:04,717 --> 03:34:05,658 resurfacing projects if 15600 03:34:05,658 --> 03:34:07,622 sufficient right-of-way and/or 15601 03:34:07,622 --> 03:34:07,622 15602 03:34:07,622 --> 03:34:10,889 pavement with width exists a 15603 03:34:10,889 --> 03:34:10,889 nd 15604 03:34:10,889 --> 03:34:12,426 on all new roadways and then I 15605 03:34:12,426 --> 03:34:12,426 t 15606 03:34:12,426 --> 03:34:16,761 references nacto or bike way 15607 03:34:16,761 --> 03:34:17,471 standards, et cetera, 15608 03:34:17,471 --> 03:34:18,341 et cetera. 15609 03:34:18,341 --> 03:34:20,922 and it goes into a little bit 15610 03:34:20,922 --> 03:34:22,405 more detail from there. 15611 03:34:22,405 --> 03:34:22,844 >> thank you. 15612 03:34:22,844 --> 03:34:23,851 I wanted to clarify that's why 15613 03:34:23,851 --> 03:34:23,851 15614 03:34:23,851 --> 03:34:24,158 we're here. 15615 03:34:24,158 --> 03:34:25,172 I agree there is way more 15616 03:34:25,172 --> 03:34:25,172 conversation. 15617 03:34:25,172 --> 03:34:26,874 I'm still a little confused by 15618 03:34:26,874 --> 03:34:26,874 15619 03:34:26,874 --> 03:34:29,482 the motion often because it's 15620 03:34:29,482 --> 03:34:30,476 sometimes we're doing contracts, 15621 03:34:30,476 --> 03:34:30,476 15622 03:34:30,476 --> 03:34:33,782 sometimes we're doing, whateve 15623 03:34:33,782 --> 03:34:33,782 r, 15624 03:34:33,782 --> 03:34:34,544 90% plans. 15625 03:34:34,544 --> 03:34:35,972 what does proceed with the 15626 03:34:35,972 --> 03:34:36,978 design and permitting of 15627 03:34:36,978 --> 03:34:37,850 northeast 8th avenue 15628 03:34:37,850 --> 03:34:39,500 resurfacing project from waldo 15629 03:34:39,500 --> 03:34:39,500 15630 03:34:39,500 --> 03:34:41,698 to the western property line o 15631 03:34:41,698 --> 03:34:41,698 f 15632 03:34:41,698 --> 03:34:42,531 loftin high school with the 15633 03:34:42,531 --> 03:34:44,656 scope as recommended mean? 15634 03:34:44,656 --> 03:34:46,888 >> mayor: we're not doing it 15635 03:34:46,888 --> 03:34:46,888 anyway. 15636 03:34:46,888 --> 03:34:49,396 it's not a motion -- 15637 03:34:49,396 --> 03:34:50,474 >> okay, because I want to know 15638 03:34:50,474 --> 03:34:50,474 15639 03:34:50,474 --> 03:34:51,402 the original motion. 15640 03:34:51,402 --> 03:34:53,038 that's right. 15641 03:34:53,038 --> 03:34:54,036 >> only one motion. 15642 03:34:54,036 --> 03:34:55,234 >> you're right. 15643 03:34:55,234 --> 03:34:57,002 forgive me. 15644 03:34:57,002 --> 03:34:58,258 and so the last thing I will s 15645 03:34:58,258 --> 03:34:58,258 ay 15646 03:34:58,258 --> 03:35:01,976 is like, just in the future lik 15647 03:35:01,976 --> 03:35:01,976 e 15648 03:35:01,976 --> 03:35:04,011 I said the easy cheap option I 15649 03:35:04,011 --> 03:35:04,011 s 15650 03:35:04,011 --> 03:35:05,584 literally a line of parking 15651 03:35:05,584 --> 03:35:06,922 either on the north or the sou 15652 03:35:06,922 --> 03:35:06,922 th 15653 03:35:06,922 --> 03:35:09,418 side of 8th from waldo out 15654 03:35:09,418 --> 03:35:10,384 however far. 15655 03:35:10,384 --> 03:35:13,500 which does allow churches to d 15656 03:35:13,500 --> 03:35:13,500 o 15657 03:35:13,500 --> 03:35:14,924 what they need to do with more 15658 03:35:14,924 --> 03:35:14,924 15659 03:35:14,924 --> 03:35:15,994 flexible street and would allow 15660 03:35:15,994 --> 03:35:15,994 15661 03:35:15,994 --> 03:35:17,454 potential businesses. 15662 03:35:17,454 --> 03:35:18,472 I always envision that corner 15663 03:35:18,472 --> 03:35:20,422 anywhere between 15, 17th, 15664 03:35:20,422 --> 03:35:22,763 18th as being an idea of our 15665 03:35:22,763 --> 03:35:24,966 grant program was it's mixed u 15666 03:35:24,966 --> 03:35:24,966 se 15667 03:35:24,966 --> 03:35:27,815 sort of commercial maybe theywa 15668 03:35:27,815 --> 03:35:28,312 nt, maybe they could use 15669 03:35:28,312 --> 03:35:30,248 on-street parking on side 15670 03:35:30,248 --> 03:35:31,104 streets so they can actually 15671 03:35:31,104 --> 03:35:33,228 have commercial activity becau 15672 03:35:33,228 --> 03:35:33,228 se 15673 03:35:33,228 --> 03:35:35,208 you need a couple parks spaces. 15674 03:35:35,208 --> 03:35:35,208 15675 03:35:35,208 --> 03:35:36,504 so the quick and easy cheap is 15676 03:35:36,504 --> 03:35:36,504 15677 03:35:36,504 --> 03:35:37,850 resurface, repaint your normal 15678 03:35:37,850 --> 03:35:37,850 15679 03:35:37,850 --> 03:35:39,942 lines, put in a row of parking 15680 03:35:39,942 --> 03:35:39,942 , 15681 03:35:39,942 --> 03:35:41,950 that gets you now lanes that a 15682 03:35:41,950 --> 03:35:41,950 re 15683 03:35:41,950 --> 03:35:44,926 somewhere less than 17 feet 15684 03:35:44,926 --> 03:35:44,926 wide. 15685 03:35:44,926 --> 03:35:47,122 but I want to make sure I'm 15686 03:35:47,122 --> 03:35:48,760 adamant that the reason why 15687 03:35:48,760 --> 03:35:50,286 people speed there is not 15688 03:35:50,286 --> 03:35:51,926 because of magic cut through. 15689 03:35:51,926 --> 03:35:54,428 it's because it is a 17-foot 15690 03:35:54,428 --> 03:35:56,420 wide lane cut through because 15691 03:35:56,420 --> 03:35:58,052 8th on the other side is just 15692 03:35:58,052 --> 03:35:59,574 as much of a cut through, but 15693 03:35:59,574 --> 03:36:00,804 those lanes are much narrower 15694 03:36:00,804 --> 03:36:03,364 with a median, you know curves 15695 03:36:03,364 --> 03:36:03,364 15696 03:36:03,364 --> 03:36:04,436 that were done however many 15697 03:36:04,436 --> 03:36:07,272 years ago. 15698 03:36:07,272 --> 03:36:08,839 I just, the people, the east 15699 03:36:08,839 --> 03:36:11,348 side deserves frankly they 15700 03:36:11,348 --> 03:36:13,007 deserve 32 miles an hour avera 15701 03:36:13,007 --> 03:36:13,007 ge 15702 03:36:13,007 --> 03:36:14,812 or not average but 85th 15703 03:36:14,812 --> 03:36:16,787 percentile instead of 38. 15704 03:36:16,787 --> 03:36:18,650 I think they deserve the same 15705 03:36:18,650 --> 03:36:19,522 speeds running through their 15706 03:36:19,522 --> 03:36:20,192 neighborhood because it is a 15707 03:36:20,192 --> 03:36:20,192 neighborhood. 15708 03:36:20,192 --> 03:36:23,256 it's a mixed use, you know, old 15709 03:36:23,256 --> 03:36:23,256 15710 03:36:23,256 --> 03:36:25,394 kind of older school tradition 15711 03:36:25,394 --> 03:36:25,394 al 15712 03:36:25,394 --> 03:36:26,472 neighborhood format, and it doe 15713 03:36:26,472 --> 03:36:26,472 s 15714 03:36:26,472 --> 03:36:29,160 not deserve 38 miles an hour a 15715 03:36:29,160 --> 03:36:29,160 t 15716 03:36:29,160 --> 03:36:30,702 the 85th percentile. 15717 03:36:30,702 --> 03:36:33,200 I want to to figure out how w 15718 03:36:33,200 --> 03:36:33,200 e 15719 03:36:33,200 --> 03:36:35,400 can get it down to 32. 15720 03:36:35,400 --> 03:36:35,740 thank you. 15721 03:36:35,740 --> 03:36:36,698 >> mayor: thank you, 15722 03:36:36,698 --> 03:36:37,236 commissioner willits. 15723 03:36:37,236 --> 03:36:38,506 thank . 15724 03:36:38,506 --> 03:36:40,484 commissioner chestnut. 15725 03:36:40,484 --> 03:36:41,997 >> commissioner willits, I think 15726 03:36:41,997 --> 03:36:41,997 15727 03:36:41,997 --> 03:36:43,511 the key word you keep saying 15728 03:36:43,511 --> 03:36:44,555 regarding the comp plan is 15729 03:36:44,555 --> 03:36:44,555 consideration. 15730 03:36:44,555 --> 03:36:49,848 consideration. Not 15731 03:36:49,848 --> 03:36:50,690 not a mandate to do anything. It 15732 03:36:50,690 --> 03:36:53,782 it's just to consider it. 15733 03:36:53,782 --> 03:36:54,556 and that is the key word. 15734 03:36:54,556 --> 03:36:56,093 thank you. 15735 03:36:56,093 --> 03:36:56,628 >> mayor: thank you, 15736 03:36:56,628 --> 03:36:56,628 commissioner. 15737 03:36:56,628 --> 03:37:02,332 commissioner duncan-walker. 15738 03:37:02,332 --> 03:37:04,007 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 15739 03:37:04,007 --> 03:37:05,572 what I wanted to say has alrea 15740 03:37:05,572 --> 03:37:05,572 dy 15741 03:37:05,572 --> 03:37:05,998 been said. 15742 03:37:05,998 --> 03:37:06,903 hopefully this motion will 15743 03:37:06,903 --> 03:37:07,611 carry, and hopefully we are 15744 03:37:07,611 --> 03:37:09,665 sending the message to the 15745 03:37:09,665 --> 03:37:11,004 people that we won't miss these 15746 03:37:11,004 --> 03:37:11,004 15747 03:37:11,004 --> 03:37:12,392 critical steps to pull them in 15748 03:37:12,392 --> 03:37:12,392 to 15749 03:37:12,392 --> 03:37:14,340 the process in a meaningful way 15750 03:37:14,340 --> 03:37:14,340 15751 03:37:14,340 --> 03:37:15,746 on something that is so critical 15752 03:37:15,746 --> 03:37:15,746 15753 03:37:15,746 --> 03:37:17,177 in the future. 15754 03:37:17,177 --> 03:37:17,610 thank you. 15755 03:37:17,610 --> 03:37:18,145 >> mayor: thank you, 15756 03:37:18,145 --> 03:37:20,178 commissioner dunk 15757 03:37:20,178 --> 03:37:20,178 duncan-walker. 15758 03:37:20,178 --> 03:37:21,764 mr. Manager. 15759 03:37:21,764 --> 03:37:22,348 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 15760 03:37:22,348 --> 03:37:24,250 I do have the comp plan policie 15761 03:37:24,250 --> 03:37:24,250 s 15762 03:37:24,250 --> 03:37:28,092 if you all want to hear them. 15763 03:37:28,092 --> 03:37:29,540 so is that a yes or -- 15764 03:37:29,540 --> 03:37:29,540 [laughter] 15765 03:37:29,540 --> 03:37:35,033 I'm getting mixed like faces. Al 15766 03:37:35,033 --> 03:37:35,900 all right. 15767 03:37:35,900 --> 03:37:37,429 >> mayor: thank you. 15768 03:37:37,429 --> 03:37:37,868 commissioner chestnut? 15769 03:37:37,868 --> 03:37:39,588 >> yeah, again, I just want to 15770 03:37:39,588 --> 03:37:39,588 15771 03:37:39,588 --> 03:37:41,710 be sure that the key word in the 15772 03:37:41,710 --> 03:37:41,710 15773 03:37:41,710 --> 03:37:46,679 comp plan is consider. 15774 03:37:46,679 --> 03:37:47,219 >> it is not. 15775 03:37:47,219 --> 03:37:48,508 >> it is not? 15776 03:37:48,508 --> 03:37:49,509 what is it then? 15777 03:37:49,509 --> 03:37:52,220 >> yeah, there's three policies 15778 03:37:52,220 --> 03:37:52,220 15779 03:37:52,220 --> 03:37:55,181 in your transportation element 15780 03:37:55,181 --> 03:37:55,181 . 15781 03:37:55,181 --> 03:38:00,119 the first is policy 3.1.5 which 15782 03:38:00,119 --> 03:38:00,119 15783 03:38:00,119 --> 03:38:02,682 says essentially street 15784 03:38:02,682 --> 03:38:05,571 modifications including 15785 03:38:05,571 --> 03:38:06,961 restriping or resurfacing shall 15786 03:38:06,961 --> 03:38:06,961 15787 03:38:06,961 --> 03:38:08,525 not increase the difficulty of 15788 03:38:08,525 --> 03:38:08,525 15789 03:38:08,525 --> 03:38:10,768 bike transit or pedestrian 15790 03:38:10,768 --> 03:38:12,200 travel such changes shall 15791 03:38:12,200 --> 03:38:13,726 include safety features for 15792 03:38:13,726 --> 03:38:15,764 bicycle, transit and pedestrians 15793 03:38:15,764 --> 03:38:15,764 15794 03:38:15,764 --> 03:38:17,802 to offset any negative impact 15795 03:38:17,802 --> 03:38:20,441 and modification might otherwise 15796 03:38:20,441 --> 03:38:20,441 15797 03:38:20,441 --> 03:38:22,574 create then policy 4.1.7 says 15798 03:38:22,574 --> 03:38:24,779 new cluks, reconstruction, 15799 03:38:24,779 --> 03:38:25,691 and -- construction, 15800 03:38:25,691 --> 03:38:26,554 reconstruction, and resurfacing 15801 03:38:26,554 --> 03:38:26,554 15802 03:38:26,554 --> 03:38:27,976 of arterials and collectors 15803 03:38:27,976 --> 03:38:29,655 shall be designed using complet 15804 03:38:29,655 --> 03:38:29,655 e 15805 03:38:29,655 --> 03:38:30,886 streets and context sensitive 15806 03:38:30,886 --> 03:38:33,256 street design principles. 15807 03:38:33,256 --> 03:38:35,854 and then policy 6.1.4 says the 15808 03:38:35,854 --> 03:38:35,854 15809 03:38:35,854 --> 03:38:37,188 city shall use street 15810 03:38:37,188 --> 03:38:39,625 resurfacing projects as an 15811 03:38:39,625 --> 03:38:40,832 opportunity to install or 15812 03:38:40,832 --> 03:38:43,135 enhance sidewalks, bike lanes, 15813 03:38:43,135 --> 03:38:43,135 15814 03:38:43,135 --> 03:38:45,038 raised medians, brick or brick 15815 03:38:45,038 --> 03:38:45,038 15816 03:38:45,038 --> 03:38:46,461 and printed paver or painted 15817 03:38:46,461 --> 03:38:48,567 croswalks where feasible if not 15818 03:38:48,567 --> 03:38:48,567 15819 03:38:48,567 --> 03:38:50,573 a city project the city shall 15820 03:38:50,573 --> 03:38:53,114 recommend to the state or county 15821 03:38:53,114 --> 03:38:53,114 15822 03:38:53,114 --> 03:38:55,075 make such enhancements. 15823 03:38:55,075 --> 03:38:55,743 >> mayor: all right. 15824 03:38:55,743 --> 03:38:58,737 thank you, mr. Manager. 15825 03:38:58,737 --> 03:39:01,349 commissioner book. 15826 03:39:01,349 --> 03:39:02,643 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 15827 03:39:02,643 --> 03:39:03,549 coincidentally when we did the 15828 03:39:03,549 --> 03:39:03,549 15829 03:39:03,549 --> 03:39:04,447 comp plan and we needed to get 15830 03:39:04,447 --> 03:39:04,447 15831 03:39:04,447 --> 03:39:05,223 out information, we had a 15832 03:39:05,223 --> 03:39:05,223 flier. 15833 03:39:05,223 --> 03:39:07,433 we had a qr code. 15834 03:39:07,433 --> 03:39:09,601 we had a couple of forums that 15835 03:39:09,601 --> 03:39:09,601 15836 03:39:09,601 --> 03:39:10,693 were hosted by two of the 15837 03:39:10,693 --> 03:39:12,927 commissioners on the dais here. 15838 03:39:12,927 --> 03:39:12,927 15839 03:39:12,927 --> 03:39:14,721 and we got tremendous amounts o 15840 03:39:14,721 --> 03:39:14,721 f 15841 03:39:14,721 --> 03:39:16,597 feedback so it's easy to do and 15842 03:39:16,597 --> 03:39:16,597 15843 03:39:16,597 --> 03:39:18,129 in this northeast 8th avenue 15844 03:39:18,129 --> 03:39:19,769 corridor no matter what segment, 15845 03:39:19,769 --> 03:39:19,769 15846 03:39:19,769 --> 03:39:21,999 you're talking about, eight 15847 03:39:21,999 --> 03:39:23,539 churches, was we said, I learn 15848 03:39:23,539 --> 03:39:23,539 ed 15849 03:39:23,539 --> 03:39:24,735 it was even more than I thought 15850 03:39:24,735 --> 03:39:24,735 , 15851 03:39:24,735 --> 03:39:26,075 but you got the school board. 15852 03:39:26,075 --> 03:39:28,417 we asked them to come for us f 15853 03:39:28,417 --> 03:39:28,417 or 15854 03:39:28,417 --> 03:39:29,515 listen we sent out information 15855 03:39:29,515 --> 03:39:29,515 15856 03:39:29,515 --> 03:39:30,388 to the school board and say it' 15857 03:39:30,388 --> 03:39:30,388 s 15858 03:39:30,388 --> 03:39:32,281 going to impact them, you got a 15859 03:39:32,281 --> 03:39:32,281 15860 03:39:32,281 --> 03:39:34,679 number of residents on that 15861 03:39:34,679 --> 03:39:34,679 thing. 15862 03:39:34,679 --> 03:39:35,429 you have a number of 15863 03:39:35,429 --> 03:39:35,429 businesses. 15864 03:39:35,429 --> 03:39:37,487 you have the high aff right 15865 03:39:37,487 --> 03:39:37,487 there. 15866 03:39:37,487 --> 03:39:40,333 so there is plenty of 15867 03:39:40,333 --> 03:39:41,421 opportunity for people to come 15868 03:39:41,421 --> 03:39:41,421 15869 03:39:41,421 --> 03:39:43,760 to any forum hosted by anyone 15870 03:39:43,760 --> 03:39:46,023 here through the city manager's 15871 03:39:46,023 --> 03:39:46,023 15872 03:39:46,023 --> 03:39:48,459 office and when we -- and we a 15873 03:39:48,459 --> 03:39:48,459 15874 03:39:48,459 --> 03:39:50,325 large multifamily housing 15875 03:39:50,325 --> 03:39:51,287 complex right there in northea 15876 03:39:51,287 --> 03:39:51,287 st 15877 03:39:51,287 --> 03:39:53,899 8th avenue and 17th street. 15878 03:39:53,899 --> 03:39:54,731 so I think we're going to get 15879 03:39:54,731 --> 03:39:55,931 plenty of feedback, and we'll 15880 03:39:55,931 --> 03:39:57,475 all be better for it. 15881 03:39:57,475 --> 03:40:00,823 whatever comes, if out, if it 15882 03:40:00,823 --> 03:40:00,823 's 15883 03:40:00,823 --> 03:40:01,975 merely resurfacing down the 15884 03:40:01,975 --> 03:40:03,213 road, that's fine, or if it's 15885 03:40:03,213 --> 03:40:05,013 resurfacing plus enhancements, 15886 03:40:05,013 --> 03:40:05,013 15887 03:40:05,013 --> 03:40:06,016 well we'll know that we have 15888 03:40:06,016 --> 03:40:07,851 community backing to do it. 15889 03:40:07,851 --> 03:40:09,163 so thank you. 15890 03:40:09,163 --> 03:40:09,751 I appreciate the fact that 15891 03:40:09,751 --> 03:40:11,089 you're going to host a forum, 15892 03:40:11,089 --> 03:40:13,589 and if it comes time to go and 15893 03:40:13,589 --> 03:40:13,589 15894 03:40:13,589 --> 03:40:15,141 maybe walk or distribute some 15895 03:40:15,141 --> 03:40:16,398 information, I'd be happy to 15896 03:40:16,398 --> 03:40:18,491 assist in a public way. 15897 03:40:18,491 --> 03:40:19,363 thank you. 15898 03:40:19,363 --> 03:40:19,909 >> mayor: thank you, 15899 03:40:19,909 --> 03:40:20,340 commissioner book. 15900 03:40:20,340 --> 03:40:22,031 commissioner duncan-walker. 15901 03:40:22,031 --> 03:40:22,795 >> thank you, mr. Book. 15902 03:40:22,795 --> 03:40:23,463 thank you, mr. Mayor. 15903 03:40:23,463 --> 03:40:25,069 I did want to just mention tha 15904 03:40:25,069 --> 03:40:25,069 t 15905 03:40:25,069 --> 03:40:27,271 as a part of this discussion, 15906 03:40:27,271 --> 03:40:29,005 the comp plan will be 15907 03:40:29,005 --> 03:40:29,005 discussed. 15908 03:40:29,005 --> 03:40:31,516 because we're still within the 15909 03:40:31,516 --> 03:40:31,516 15910 03:40:31,516 --> 03:40:33,275 time frame where any necessary 15911 03:40:33,275 --> 03:40:33,275 15912 03:40:33,275 --> 03:40:35,761 tweaks can be made. 15913 03:40:35,761 --> 03:40:36,026 thank you. 15914 03:40:36,026 --> 03:40:36,559 >> mayor: thank you, 15915 03:40:36,559 --> 03:40:38,143 commissioner duncan-walker. 15916 03:40:38,143 --> 03:40:40,549 so the short answer to the thi 15917 03:40:40,549 --> 03:40:40,549 ng 15918 03:40:40,549 --> 03:40:42,385 that I heard several people ask 15919 03:40:42,385 --> 03:40:42,385 15920 03:40:42,385 --> 03:40:46,223 as to why now is because we're 15921 03:40:46,223 --> 03:40:46,223 15922 03:40:46,223 --> 03:40:48,657 at a point where we need to 15923 03:40:48,657 --> 03:40:49,619 spend money on that road. 15924 03:40:49,619 --> 03:40:50,525 on that stretch of road. 15925 03:40:50,525 --> 03:40:51,859 so if we're going to spend it 15926 03:40:51,859 --> 03:40:53,257 money, let's have a conversatio 15927 03:40:53,257 --> 03:40:53,257 n 15928 03:40:53,257 --> 03:40:54,529 about exactly what it ought to 15929 03:40:54,529 --> 03:40:54,529 15930 03:40:54,529 --> 03:40:54,529 be. 15931 03:40:54,529 --> 03:41:00,799 a place we need to get to as a 15932 03:41:00,799 --> 03:41:00,799 15933 03:41:00,799 --> 03:41:03,435 city is when we say, hey, what 15934 03:41:03,435 --> 03:41:03,435 15935 03:41:03,435 --> 03:41:07,524 should we do, is not have folks 15936 03:41:07,524 --> 03:41:07,524 15937 03:41:07,524 --> 03:41:10,047 understand -- it's a catch-22. 15938 03:41:10,047 --> 03:41:10,047 15939 03:41:10,047 --> 03:41:12,401 if folks understand it as we 15940 03:41:12,401 --> 03:41:14,723 need to do a thing, here's wha 15941 03:41:14,723 --> 03:41:14,723 t 15942 03:41:14,723 --> 03:41:16,980 we're going to do out front, 15943 03:41:16,980 --> 03:41:18,012 then of course people push back 15944 03:41:18,012 --> 03:41:18,012 15945 03:41:18,012 --> 03:41:19,417 on that. 15946 03:41:19,417 --> 03:41:22,139 but usually what it is is when 15947 03:41:22,139 --> 03:41:22,139 15948 03:41:22,139 --> 03:41:23,391 we put something out, is here' 15949 03:41:23,391 --> 03:41:23,391 s 15950 03:41:23,391 --> 03:41:25,059 a discussion item. 15951 03:41:25,059 --> 03:41:26,469 here's something to get a 15952 03:41:26,469 --> 03:41:27,539 conversation started. 15953 03:41:27,539 --> 03:41:30,695 because if we just have a, a 15954 03:41:30,695 --> 03:41:31,772 meeting and say what should we 15955 03:41:31,772 --> 03:41:31,772 15956 03:41:31,772 --> 03:41:34,899 do, there will be every from 15957 03:41:34,899 --> 03:41:37,203 well, we ought to put an 15958 03:41:37,203 --> 03:41:41,179 interstate there to we shouldn 15959 03:41:41,179 --> 03:41:41,179 't 15960 03:41:41,179 --> 03:41:41,838 do anything. 15961 03:41:41,838 --> 03:41:43,513 so the idea is you got to put 15962 03:41:43,513 --> 03:41:44,118 something on the table to have 15963 03:41:44,118 --> 03:41:44,251 a 15964 03:41:44,251 --> 03:41:44,645 discussion about. 15965 03:41:44,645 --> 03:41:47,813 if you don't, experience in thi 15966 03:41:47,813 --> 03:41:47,813 s 15967 03:41:47,813 --> 03:41:49,237 building has taught me you don 15968 03:41:49,237 --> 03:41:49,237 't 15969 03:41:49,237 --> 03:41:50,721 get anywhere at all and then y 15970 03:41:50,721 --> 03:41:50,721 ou 15971 03:41:50,721 --> 03:41:52,060 get ten years down the road and 15972 03:41:52,060 --> 03:41:52,060 15973 03:41:52,060 --> 03:41:53,592 somebody says how come you nev 15974 03:41:53,592 --> 03:41:53,592 er 15975 03:41:53,592 --> 03:41:55,492 spent any money on this. 15976 03:41:55,492 --> 03:41:57,351 we can't be there either. 15977 03:41:57,351 --> 03:41:59,225 so when we get to this point, 15978 03:41:59,225 --> 03:42:03,059 this is the opportunity to 15979 03:42:03,059 --> 03:42:04,702 figure out what it is that oug 15980 03:42:04,702 --> 03:42:04,702 ht 15981 03:42:04,702 --> 03:42:07,595 to be done, and that vote is n 15982 03:42:07,595 --> 03:42:07,595 ot 15983 03:42:07,595 --> 03:42:07,595 today. 15984 03:42:07,595 --> 03:42:10,233 it never was supposed to be par 15985 03:42:10,233 --> 03:42:10,233 t 15986 03:42:10,233 --> 03:42:11,545 of today. 15987 03:42:11,545 --> 03:42:13,141 we need to have more opportunity 15988 03:42:13,141 --> 03:42:13,141 15989 03:42:13,141 --> 03:42:15,641 for everybody to weigh in that 15990 03:42:15,641 --> 03:42:15,641 15991 03:42:15,641 --> 03:42:17,417 uses the road or that lives on 15992 03:42:17,417 --> 03:42:17,417 15993 03:42:17,417 --> 03:42:19,480 the road for what it ought to 15994 03:42:19,480 --> 03:42:19,480 be. 15995 03:42:19,480 --> 03:42:21,283 that's where we are. 15996 03:42:21,283 --> 03:42:23,053 and that's why now. 15997 03:42:23,053 --> 03:42:26,557 that's the answer to why now. 15998 03:42:26,557 --> 03:42:29,157 yeah, and I know we're a coupl 15999 03:42:29,157 --> 03:42:29,157 e 16000 03:42:29,157 --> 03:42:30,557 folks are going with it. 16001 03:42:30,557 --> 03:42:32,393 it's always election year. 16002 03:42:32,393 --> 03:42:34,599 it's always election year so I 16003 03:42:34,599 --> 03:42:34,599 t 16004 03:42:34,599 --> 03:42:37,563 ain't that. 16005 03:42:37,563 --> 03:42:38,696 this is the opportunity to 16006 03:42:38,696 --> 03:42:40,699 figure out what's, what we do 16007 03:42:40,699 --> 03:42:42,097 because we're going to spend 16008 03:42:42,097 --> 03:42:42,635 some money. 16009 03:42:42,635 --> 03:42:43,573 we're fought going to come back 16010 03:42:43,573 --> 03:42:44,685 d spend the money again 16011 03:42:44,685 --> 03:42:44,685 later. 16012 03:42:44,685 --> 03:42:47,231 we need to figure out what the 16013 03:42:47,231 --> 03:42:47,231 16014 03:42:47,231 --> 03:42:48,573 right way to do it now is. 16015 03:42:48,573 --> 03:42:50,720 that's why now. 16016 03:42:50,720 --> 03:42:50,995 all right. 16017 03:42:50,995 --> 03:42:51,728 so we have a motion on the 16018 03:42:51,728 --> 03:42:53,309 table, all in favor, please say 16019 03:42:53,309 --> 03:42:53,309 16020 03:42:53,309 --> 03:42:53,309 aye. 16021 03:42:53,309 --> 03:42:55,685 any opposed? 16022 03:42:55,685 --> 03:42:56,261 all right that passes 16023 03:42:56,261 --> 03:42:56,261 unanimously. 16024 03:42:56,261 --> 03:42:59,184 madam clerk. 16025 03:42:59,184 --> 03:43:02,755 >> mr. Mayor, pause just a 16026 03:43:02,755 --> 03:43:02,755 moment. 16027 03:43:02,755 --> 03:43:13,269 we have 2026-171, appointments 16028 03:43:13,269 --> 03:43:13,269 16029 03:43:13,269 --> 03:43:14,461 to the city plan board and the 16030 03:43:14,461 --> 03:43:14,461 16031 03:43:14,461 --> 03:43:15,567 gainesville human rights board 16032 03:43:15,567 --> 03:43:15,567 16033 03:43:15,567 --> 03:43:17,061 with recommendation the city 16034 03:43:17,061 --> 03:43:18,675 commission review and discuss 16035 03:43:18,675 --> 03:43:20,608 the applications received for 16036 03:43:20,608 --> 03:43:21,306 the appointments to the city 16037 03:43:21,306 --> 03:43:23,085 plan board and gainesville hum 16038 03:43:23,085 --> 03:43:23,085 an 16039 03:43:23,085 --> 03:43:24,787 rights board and take action 16040 03:43:24,787 --> 03:43:28,820 deemed necessary. 16041 03:43:28,820 --> 03:43:30,130 and mr. Mayor I did want to let 16042 03:43:30,130 --> 03:43:30,130 16043 03:43:30,130 --> 03:43:35,657 you know one of the application 16044 03:43:35,657 --> 03:43:35,657 s 16045 03:43:35,657 --> 03:43:36,813 for the city plan board has bee 16046 03:43:36,813 --> 03:43:36,813 n 16047 03:43:36,813 --> 03:43:37,863 updated and printed and you wil 16048 03:43:37,863 --> 03:43:37,863 l 16049 03:43:37,863 --> 03:43:39,159 find it in the file folders in 16050 03:43:39,159 --> 03:43:39,159 16051 03:43:39,159 --> 03:43:40,108 front of you. 16052 03:43:40,108 --> 03:43:41,340 essentially there was a questio 16053 03:43:41,340 --> 03:43:41,340 n 16054 03:43:41,340 --> 03:43:43,373 about a financial disclosure, 16055 03:43:43,373 --> 03:43:45,803 and that answer was changed fro 16056 03:43:45,803 --> 03:43:45,803 m 16057 03:43:45,803 --> 03:43:48,370 no to yes. 16058 03:43:48,370 --> 03:43:49,219 >> mayor: very good, thank you 16059 03:43:49,219 --> 03:43:49,219 , 16060 03:43:49,219 --> 03:43:50,439 and before we move any farther 16061 03:43:50,439 --> 03:43:50,439 16062 03:43:50,439 --> 03:43:52,013 forward I want to remind 16063 03:43:52,013 --> 03:43:52,839 everyone here for the land use 16064 03:43:52,839 --> 03:43:52,839 16065 03:43:52,839 --> 03:43:54,040 and zoning items that we've 16066 03:43:54,040 --> 03:43:55,335 pushed those forward to the end 16067 03:43:55,335 --> 03:43:55,335 16068 03:43:55,335 --> 03:43:57,446 of the meeting. 16069 03:43:57,446 --> 03:43:59,448 so we're not going to do that 16070 03:43:59,448 --> 03:44:01,224 before dinner. 16071 03:44:01,224 --> 03:44:01,224 okay. 16072 03:44:01,224 --> 03:44:10,167 all right. 16073 03:44:10,167 --> 03:44:11,355 so we have two folks here for 16074 03:44:11,355 --> 03:44:12,497 the city plan board 16075 03:44:12,497 --> 03:44:12,497 appointment. 16076 03:44:12,497 --> 03:44:14,240 would y'all like to speak? 16077 03:44:14,240 --> 03:44:14,696 all right. 16078 03:44:14,696 --> 03:44:16,403 so I'm going to ask -- to go 16079 03:44:16,403 --> 03:44:18,607 first because we'll do the 16080 03:44:18,607 --> 03:44:18,607 alphabetically. 16081 03:44:18,607 --> 03:44:18,607 welcome. 16082 03:44:18,607 --> 03:44:25,512 >> thank you. 16083 03:44:25,512 --> 03:44:27,475 and thank you, mr. Mayor and 16084 03:44:27,475 --> 03:44:27,475 commissioners. 16085 03:44:27,475 --> 03:44:38,153 my name is jayne moras ki. 16086 03:44:38,153 --> 03:44:39,354 prior to my time in gainesville 16087 03:44:39,354 --> 03:44:39,354 16088 03:44:39,354 --> 03:44:40,623 I complete admasters in urban 16089 03:44:40,623 --> 03:44:42,885 and regional planning where I 16090 03:44:42,885 --> 03:44:44,422 did comp plan review for iowa 16091 03:44:44,422 --> 03:44:45,797 city another university town. 16092 03:44:45,797 --> 03:44:47,509 dollar I was a commercial -- 16093 03:44:47,509 --> 03:44:48,423 there was a commercial real 16094 03:44:48,423 --> 03:44:49,867 estate appraiser, actually the 16095 03:44:49,867 --> 03:44:49,867 16096 03:44:49,867 --> 03:44:50,793 only commercial real estate 16097 03:44:50,793 --> 03:44:52,333 appraiser that was a woman in 16098 03:44:52,333 --> 03:44:52,985 the state of iowa for men a 16099 03:44:52,985 --> 03:44:52,985 years. 16100 03:44:52,985 --> 03:44:54,501 >> mayor: in the whole state? 16101 03:44:54,501 --> 03:44:55,498 >> in the whole state, yeah. 16102 03:44:55,498 --> 03:44:56,039 at the time. 16103 03:44:56,039 --> 03:44:58,537 it's changed since then. 16104 03:44:58,537 --> 03:45:00,070 but my specialty was low-income 16105 03:45:00,070 --> 03:45:00,070 16106 03:45:00,070 --> 03:45:02,442 housing tax credits. 16107 03:45:02,442 --> 03:45:04,713 since then moving here, I know 16108 03:45:04,713 --> 03:45:04,713 16109 03:45:04,713 --> 03:45:07,720 many of you in my work as the 16110 03:45:07,720 --> 03:45:08,959 director of the homeless shelt 16111 03:45:08,959 --> 03:45:08,959 er 16112 03:45:08,959 --> 03:45:10,593 called family promise of 16113 03:45:10,593 --> 03:45:10,593 gainesville. 16114 03:45:10,593 --> 03:45:16,765 I've worked in nonprofits for 16115 03:45:16,765 --> 03:45:17,963 the last two decades here. 16116 03:45:17,963 --> 03:45:20,851 my specialty was housing and n 16117 03:45:20,851 --> 03:45:20,851 ow 16118 03:45:20,851 --> 03:45:21,769 it's education as well. 16119 03:45:21,769 --> 03:45:25,698 it took a -- gainesville is my 16120 03:45:25,698 --> 03:45:25,698 16121 03:45:25,698 --> 03:45:25,698 home. 16122 03:45:25,698 --> 03:45:26,903 my children grew up here. 16123 03:45:26,903 --> 03:45:29,027 went to gainesville high 16124 03:45:29,027 --> 03:45:29,027 school. 16125 03:45:29,027 --> 03:45:30,436 went to glen springs 16126 03:45:30,436 --> 03:45:30,436 elementary. 16127 03:45:30,436 --> 03:45:35,907 and I want to be part of the 16128 03:45:35,907 --> 03:45:36,873 planning board because one, a 16129 03:45:36,873 --> 03:45:37,939 friend asked me to do this 16130 03:45:37,939 --> 03:45:38,849 because they knew of my 16131 03:45:38,849 --> 03:45:40,681 experience in it, but because 16132 03:45:40,681 --> 03:45:41,513 this is my home. 16133 03:45:41,513 --> 03:45:45,797 it will continue to be my home 16134 03:45:45,797 --> 03:45:45,797 16135 03:45:45,797 --> 03:45:48,256 and it's where my family has 16136 03:45:48,256 --> 03:45:49,045 chosen to be. 16137 03:45:49,045 --> 03:45:49,703 I'm happy to answer any 16138 03:45:49,703 --> 03:45:50,509 questions you have about my 16139 03:45:50,509 --> 03:45:52,324 background or experience. 16140 03:45:52,324 --> 03:45:55,100 and I believe that the sum tot 16141 03:45:55,100 --> 03:45:55,100 al 16142 03:45:55,100 --> 03:45:58,167 of that experience would make m 16143 03:45:58,167 --> 03:45:58,167 e 16144 03:45:58,167 --> 03:45:59,558 a good part of the planning 16145 03:45:59,558 --> 03:45:59,558 board. 16146 03:45:59,558 --> 03:46:00,539 thank you. 16147 03:46:00,539 --> 03:46:00,967 >> mayor: very good. 16148 03:46:00,967 --> 03:46:03,169 thank you. 16149 03:46:03,169 --> 03:46:11,019 mr. Willis. 16150 03:46:11,019 --> 03:46:11,941 >> good afternoon, it's a 16151 03:46:11,941 --> 03:46:13,245 pleasure to be here today. 16152 03:46:13,245 --> 03:46:15,081 little bit about me is I'm 16153 03:46:15,081 --> 03:46:17,157 currently civil engineering 16154 03:46:17,157 --> 03:46:18,489 student at university of 16155 03:46:18,489 --> 03:46:18,489 florida. 16156 03:46:18,489 --> 03:46:20,123 I'm a senior. 16157 03:46:20,123 --> 03:46:22,303 I currently have a year left, 16158 03:46:22,303 --> 03:46:24,071 and I really discovered a 16159 03:46:24,071 --> 03:46:25,223 passion for sustainable 16160 03:46:25,223 --> 03:46:26,759 development which is why I 16161 03:46:26,759 --> 03:46:27,793 applied to be on the city 16162 03:46:27,793 --> 03:46:30,295 planning board after the lovel 16163 03:46:30,295 --> 03:46:30,295 y 16164 03:46:30,295 --> 03:46:32,296 city clerk came to our class a 16165 03:46:32,296 --> 03:46:32,296 nd 16166 03:46:32,296 --> 03:46:33,362 made me aware that it was an 16167 03:46:33,362 --> 03:46:33,362 opportunity. 16168 03:46:33,362 --> 03:46:36,255 and which I believe mayor ward 16169 03:46:36,255 --> 03:46:36,255 16170 03:46:36,255 --> 03:46:37,265 you will be speaking at in a 16171 03:46:37,265 --> 03:46:38,143 couple weeks. 16172 03:46:38,143 --> 03:46:40,745 so I'm excited for that. 16173 03:46:40,745 --> 03:46:43,386 but yes, I want to serve my 16174 03:46:43,386 --> 03:46:43,386 community. 16175 03:46:43,386 --> 03:46:44,913 I've only been in gainesville 16176 03:46:44,913 --> 03:46:48,015 since august, but I really gro 16177 03:46:48,015 --> 03:46:48,015 wn 16178 03:46:48,015 --> 03:46:48,379 to love it. 16179 03:46:48,379 --> 03:46:50,680 been a lifelong gator fan so I 16180 03:46:50,680 --> 03:46:50,680 16181 03:46:50,680 --> 03:46:51,799 hope to stay here for a long 16182 03:46:51,799 --> 03:46:54,021 period of time, and I hope wit 16183 03:46:54,021 --> 03:46:54,021 h 16184 03:46:54,021 --> 03:46:57,286 this opportunity I can initiat 16185 03:46:57,286 --> 03:46:57,286 e 16186 03:46:57,286 --> 03:46:58,321 some resilience and 16187 03:46:58,321 --> 03:47:01,199 sustainable -- sustainability I 16188 03:47:01,199 --> 03:47:01,199 n 16189 03:47:01,199 --> 03:47:03,711 this community, and serve as a 16190 03:47:03,711 --> 03:47:03,711 16191 03:47:03,711 --> 03:47:05,196 lifelong commitment to the 16192 03:47:05,196 --> 03:47:05,196 people. 16193 03:47:05,196 --> 03:47:08,143 and as we've seen today, it is 16194 03:47:08,143 --> 03:47:08,143 16195 03:47:08,143 --> 03:47:09,407 important to listen to the 16196 03:47:09,407 --> 03:47:11,235 people, so I hope to bring tha 16197 03:47:11,235 --> 03:47:11,235 t 16198 03:47:11,235 --> 03:47:11,967 along too. 16199 03:47:11,967 --> 03:47:12,577 thank you. 16200 03:47:12,577 --> 03:47:13,069 >> mayor: very good. 16201 03:47:13,069 --> 03:47:14,578 thank you. 16202 03:47:14,578 --> 03:47:16,307 all right. 16203 03:47:16,307 --> 03:47:17,839 commissioner willits. 16204 03:47:17,839 --> 03:47:18,605 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 16205 03:47:18,605 --> 03:47:19,943 a quick question. 16206 03:47:19,943 --> 03:47:22,427 so for, for the clerk first. 16207 03:47:22,427 --> 03:47:25,795 for ms. Moraski application I 16208 03:47:25,795 --> 03:47:27,625 don't see the, the address has 16209 03:47:27,625 --> 03:47:27,625 16210 03:47:27,625 --> 03:47:28,671 been blacked out. 16211 03:47:28,671 --> 03:47:29,557 I know there are lots of 16212 03:47:29,557 --> 03:47:30,489 potential reasons why, but I 16213 03:47:30,489 --> 03:47:32,327 just want to really confirm tha 16214 03:47:32,327 --> 03:47:32,327 t 16215 03:47:32,327 --> 03:47:35,831 ms. Moraski lives inside the 16216 03:47:35,831 --> 03:47:37,216 incorporated gainesville city 16217 03:47:37,216 --> 03:47:37,216 limits. 16218 03:47:37,216 --> 03:47:37,709 >> yes. 16219 03:47:37,709 --> 03:47:38,389 I have the map if you would like 16220 03:47:38,389 --> 03:47:38,389 16221 03:47:38,389 --> 03:47:40,179 to see. 16222 03:47:40,179 --> 03:47:41,433 >> I'm a map person. 16223 03:47:41,433 --> 03:47:42,381 you already knew where I was 16224 03:47:42,381 --> 03:47:42,381 going. 16225 03:47:42,381 --> 03:47:43,733 thank you. 16226 03:47:43,733 --> 03:47:45,507 and then so then just outside 16227 03:47:45,507 --> 03:47:47,527 this I would make a pitch if n 16228 03:47:47,527 --> 03:47:47,527 ot 16229 03:47:47,527 --> 03:47:49,067 in this vote but into the futur 16230 03:47:49,067 --> 03:47:49,067 e 16231 03:47:49,067 --> 03:47:50,111 for all of our boards but 16232 03:47:50,111 --> 03:47:51,321 particularly even this one 16233 03:47:51,321 --> 03:47:53,659 board, we are a community of 6 16234 03:47:53,659 --> 03:47:53,659 0% 16235 03:47:53,659 --> 03:47:53,659 renters. 16236 03:47:53,659 --> 03:47:55,615 I don't know that we have any 16237 03:47:55,615 --> 03:47:56,725 renters on the city plan board 16238 03:47:56,725 --> 03:47:56,725 16239 03:47:56,725 --> 03:47:58,115 right now. 16240 03:47:58,115 --> 03:48:02,264 I would have to double check. 16241 03:48:02,264 --> 03:48:03,796 but mr. Willis lives in my 16242 03:48:03,796 --> 03:48:05,230 district and I'm a little 16243 03:48:05,230 --> 03:48:06,062 partial to my district because 16244 03:48:06,062 --> 03:48:06,062 16245 03:48:06,062 --> 03:48:07,828 my district is 90% multifamily 16246 03:48:07,828 --> 03:48:07,828 , 16247 03:48:07,828 --> 03:48:11,297 and we're, and in a city that' 16248 03:48:11,297 --> 03:48:11,297 s 16249 03:48:11,297 --> 03:48:12,569 60% renters, renters and 16250 03:48:12,569 --> 03:48:14,002 multifamily are part of whatwe 16251 03:48:14,002 --> 03:48:14,002 16252 03:48:14,002 --> 03:48:15,249 have to plan for, what we were 16253 03:48:15,249 --> 03:48:15,249 16254 03:48:15,249 --> 03:48:16,558 gifted from the county in the 16255 03:48:16,558 --> 03:48:17,944 case of southwest gainesville, 16256 03:48:17,944 --> 03:48:17,944 16257 03:48:17,944 --> 03:48:18,969 moving forward so I actually 16258 03:48:18,969 --> 03:48:20,542 want to make a pitch that we 16259 03:48:20,542 --> 03:48:21,662 need more diversity on some of 16260 03:48:21,662 --> 03:48:21,662 16261 03:48:21,662 --> 03:48:23,876 our boards, and that includes 16262 03:48:23,876 --> 03:48:25,115 income, age, where you live in 16263 03:48:25,115 --> 03:48:25,115 16264 03:48:25,115 --> 03:48:27,682 this city, and whether you are 16265 03:48:27,682 --> 03:48:27,682 16266 03:48:27,682 --> 03:48:31,060 an incumbent property owner, you 16267 03:48:31,060 --> 03:48:31,060 16268 03:48:31,060 --> 03:48:32,838 know or you're a renter so I 16269 03:48:32,838 --> 03:48:35,728 just want to make that pitch 16270 03:48:35,728 --> 03:48:37,586 because, because we have a 16271 03:48:37,586 --> 03:48:39,892 community that is 60% renters 16272 03:48:39,892 --> 03:48:41,902 and when all of our policymaker 16273 03:48:41,902 --> 03:48:41,902 s 16274 03:48:41,902 --> 03:48:42,894 are homeowners and when everyon 16275 03:48:42,894 --> 03:48:42,894 e 16276 03:48:42,894 --> 03:48:44,346 on our boards are homeowners, o 16277 03:48:44,346 --> 03:48:44,346 r 16278 03:48:44,346 --> 03:48:47,800 live in a, a family -- a home 16279 03:48:47,800 --> 03:48:49,232 owned by their family, where y 16280 03:48:49,232 --> 03:48:49,232 ou 16281 03:48:49,232 --> 03:48:50,812 don't pay rent, because that's 16282 03:48:50,812 --> 03:48:50,812 16283 03:48:50,812 --> 03:48:52,881 how homeownership is typically 16284 03:48:52,881 --> 03:48:52,881 16285 03:48:52,881 --> 03:48:54,543 measured, if you're not paying 16286 03:48:54,543 --> 03:48:54,543 16287 03:48:54,543 --> 03:48:56,614 rent, you live in a owned home, 16288 03:48:56,614 --> 03:48:56,614 16289 03:48:56,614 --> 03:48:58,216 a family owned home of some 16290 03:48:58,216 --> 03:48:58,216 sort. 16291 03:48:58,216 --> 03:49:00,178 anies with just want to make 16292 03:49:00,178 --> 03:49:01,082 that pitch out there. 16293 03:49:01,082 --> 03:49:02,478 but also understand that 16294 03:49:02,478 --> 03:49:05,556 ms. Moraski is pretty well 16295 03:49:05,556 --> 03:49:06,437 qualified both with the 16296 03:49:06,437 --> 03:49:07,463 knowledge of our community but 16297 03:49:07,463 --> 03:49:07,463 16298 03:49:07,463 --> 03:49:09,131 also the basics of urban 16299 03:49:09,131 --> 03:49:09,131 planning. 16300 03:49:09,131 --> 03:49:10,690 though I will say some people 16301 03:49:10,690 --> 03:49:13,490 think that we have plenty of 16302 03:49:13,490 --> 03:49:14,797 urban planner in the city. 16303 03:49:14,797 --> 03:49:15,462 they're called staff. 16304 03:49:15,462 --> 03:49:17,103 they're everywhere. 16305 03:49:17,103 --> 03:49:20,010 and they guide us a lot so to 16306 03:49:20,010 --> 03:49:21,973 some degree that plan board is 16307 03:49:21,973 --> 03:49:21,973 16308 03:49:21,973 --> 03:49:23,942 still just our neighbors' 16309 03:49:23,942 --> 03:49:25,272 knowledge, not necessarily. 16310 03:49:25,272 --> 03:49:26,871 we can hire, even more city 16311 03:49:26,871 --> 03:49:28,415 planners we could just have a comm 16312 03:49:28,415 --> 03:49:29,522 commtee of city planners that 16313 03:49:29,522 --> 03:49:29,947 we hire. 16314 03:49:29,947 --> 03:49:31,712 so just putting that out there 16315 03:49:31,712 --> 03:49:31,712 16316 03:49:31,712 --> 03:49:32,211 as conversation. 16317 03:49:32,211 --> 03:49:34,004 we've had interesting, deep 16318 03:49:34,004 --> 03:49:34,844 conversations today so I just 16319 03:49:34,844 --> 03:49:36,620 wanted to throw it out there. 16320 03:49:36,620 --> 03:49:38,314 and just to be clear we have a 16321 03:49:38,314 --> 03:49:38,314 n 16322 03:49:38,314 --> 03:49:39,718 urban planner as our interim 16323 03:49:39,718 --> 03:49:42,794 city manager as well, so thank 16324 03:49:42,794 --> 03:49:42,794 16325 03:49:42,794 --> 03:49:44,526 you, madam clerk, for answering 16326 03:49:44,526 --> 03:49:44,526 16327 03:49:44,526 --> 03:49:45,202 that question. 16328 03:49:45,202 --> 03:49:46,059 thank you. 16329 03:49:46,059 --> 03:49:48,165 >> mayor: thank you. 16330 03:49:48,165 --> 03:49:49,891 commissioner duncan-walker. 16331 03:49:49,891 --> 03:49:50,683 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 16332 03:49:50,683 --> 03:49:51,427 I have a question and it's kin 16333 03:49:51,427 --> 03:49:51,427 d 16334 03:49:51,427 --> 03:49:53,338 of to your point, commissioner 16335 03:49:53,338 --> 03:49:53,338 16336 03:49:53,338 --> 03:49:55,549 willits in terms of the 16337 03:49:55,549 --> 03:49:57,236 composition but do we currently 16338 03:49:57,236 --> 03:49:57,236 16339 03:49:57,236 --> 03:49:59,648 have -- we don't have a student 16340 03:49:59,648 --> 03:49:59,648 16341 03:49:59,648 --> 03:50:02,112 seat on this board, do we? 16342 03:50:02,112 --> 03:50:03,543 I don't see one indicated here? 16343 03:50:03,543 --> 03:50:03,543 16344 03:50:03,543 --> 03:50:04,974 >> we -- the staff liaison 16345 03:50:04,974 --> 03:50:06,049 hasn't requested for us to fil 16346 03:50:06,049 --> 03:50:06,049 l 16347 03:50:06,049 --> 03:50:07,776 it but I do believe that this 16348 03:50:07,776 --> 03:50:07,776 is 16349 03:50:07,776 --> 03:50:09,701 one of our boards that does ha 16350 03:50:09,701 --> 03:50:09,701 ve 16351 03:50:09,701 --> 03:50:10,417 a student seat. 16352 03:50:10,417 --> 03:50:12,560 we typically don't advertise f 16353 03:50:12,560 --> 03:50:12,560 or 16354 03:50:12,560 --> 03:50:13,885 those until september or octob 16355 03:50:13,885 --> 03:50:13,885 er 16356 03:50:13,885 --> 03:50:16,765 when students are back in 16357 03:50:16,765 --> 03:50:19,122 session because everyone sort o 16358 03:50:19,122 --> 03:50:19,122 f 16359 03:50:19,122 --> 03:50:21,934 gearing now towards finals and 16360 03:50:21,934 --> 03:50:21,934 16361 03:50:21,934 --> 03:50:22,931 graduation and all of those 16362 03:50:22,931 --> 03:50:25,233 types of things, so we typically 16363 03:50:25,233 --> 03:50:25,233 16364 03:50:25,233 --> 03:50:27,998 don't advertise for student 16365 03:50:27,998 --> 03:50:32,272 seats until usually it's aroun 16366 03:50:32,272 --> 03:50:32,272 d 16367 03:50:32,272 --> 03:50:34,038 the homecoming time frame gives 16368 03:50:34,038 --> 03:50:34,038 16369 03:50:34,038 --> 03:50:35,245 them a chance to get their foo 16370 03:50:35,245 --> 03:50:35,245 t 16371 03:50:35,245 --> 03:50:37,838 in the door, for the semester, 16372 03:50:37,838 --> 03:50:37,838 16373 03:50:37,838 --> 03:50:39,055 get their head on their 16374 03:50:39,055 --> 03:50:40,234 shoulders about what they want 16375 03:50:40,234 --> 03:50:40,234 16376 03:50:40,234 --> 03:50:42,856 to do for professional, you 16377 03:50:42,856 --> 03:50:45,588 know, experience, and we send 16378 03:50:45,588 --> 03:50:48,522 that out to the schools and our 16379 03:50:48,522 --> 03:50:48,522 16380 03:50:48,522 --> 03:50:51,354 different contacts to get 16381 03:50:51,354 --> 03:50:53,041 student applications, and as y 16382 03:50:53,041 --> 03:50:53,041 ou 16383 03:50:53,041 --> 03:50:56,040 heard, I do speak to college 16384 03:50:56,040 --> 03:51:00,404 classes, and wave the flag for 16385 03:51:00,404 --> 03:51:00,404 16386 03:51:00,404 --> 03:51:02,133 our advisory boards. 16387 03:51:02,133 --> 03:51:03,110 >> that's good. 16388 03:51:03,110 --> 03:51:05,112 that's good. 16389 03:51:05,112 --> 03:51:07,281 because I appreciate 16390 03:51:07,281 --> 03:51:09,925 mr. Brantley coming to us today 16391 03:51:09,925 --> 03:51:09,925 , 16392 03:51:09,925 --> 03:51:11,212 and he clearly is making all 16393 03:51:11,212 --> 03:51:13,412 sorts of efforts to educate 16394 03:51:13,412 --> 03:51:15,605 himself in this way, and what 16395 03:51:15,605 --> 03:51:15,605 I 16396 03:51:15,605 --> 03:51:17,787 would say based on how I'm 16397 03:51:17,787 --> 03:51:19,355 probably going to vote today, I 16398 03:51:19,355 --> 03:51:19,355 s 16399 03:51:19,355 --> 03:51:20,927 mr. Willis, I hope you will com 16400 03:51:20,927 --> 03:51:20,927 e 16401 03:51:20,927 --> 03:51:22,790 back around the time that we 16402 03:51:22,790 --> 03:51:23,895 open that application for the 16403 03:51:23,895 --> 03:51:27,659 student seat because what when 16404 03:51:27,659 --> 03:51:27,855 I 16405 03:51:27,855 --> 03:51:31,596 take a look at the experience 16406 03:51:31,596 --> 03:51:35,203 that ms. Jayne moraski brings t 16407 03:51:35,203 --> 03:51:35,203 o 16408 03:51:35,203 --> 03:51:35,967 the board, I have to lean in 16409 03:51:35,967 --> 03:51:36,738 that direction. 16410 03:51:36,738 --> 03:51:38,007 and you'll get there. 16411 03:51:38,007 --> 03:51:40,204 you will get there. 16412 03:51:40,204 --> 03:51:41,278 >> [off mic] 16413 03:51:41,278 --> 03:51:41,278 [laughter] 16414 03:51:41,278 --> 03:51:41,278 good. 16415 03:51:41,278 --> 03:51:41,278 good. 16416 03:51:41,278 --> 03:51:41,278 good. 16417 03:51:41,278 --> 03:51:41,278 good. 16418 03:51:41,278 --> 03:51:41,278 good. 16419 03:51:41,278 --> 03:51:51,018 and I mean, for me, it is the 16420 03:51:51,018 --> 03:51:52,417 diverse wealth of experience 16421 03:51:52,417 --> 03:51:54,952 that she brings to this. 16422 03:51:54,952 --> 03:51:59,392 and how that can just make tha 16423 03:51:59,392 --> 03:51:59,392 t 16424 03:51:59,392 --> 03:52:00,463 board so much more robust. 16425 03:52:00,463 --> 03:52:01,277 commissioner willits, I am 16426 03:52:01,277 --> 03:52:02,327 certainly willing to entertain 16427 03:52:02,327 --> 03:52:02,729 a 16428 03:52:02,729 --> 03:52:04,062 conversation about the ways tha 16429 03:52:04,062 --> 03:52:04,062 t 16430 03:52:04,062 --> 03:52:06,617 we can continue to diversify t 16431 03:52:06,617 --> 03:52:06,617 he 16432 03:52:06,617 --> 03:52:06,617 board. 16433 03:52:06,617 --> 03:52:10,259 but I certainly, mr. Willis, 16434 03:52:10,259 --> 03:52:11,045 please come back in september or 16435 03:52:11,045 --> 03:52:11,045 16436 03:52:11,045 --> 03:52:13,774 whenever it is that that we 16437 03:52:13,774 --> 03:52:14,976 advertise this again because I 16438 03:52:14,976 --> 03:52:14,976 16439 03:52:14,976 --> 03:52:16,109 certainly appreciate your 16440 03:52:16,109 --> 03:52:18,215 application as well. 16441 03:52:18,215 --> 03:52:18,745 >> mayor: thank you, 16442 03:52:18,745 --> 03:52:19,692 commissioner duncan-walker. 16443 03:52:19,692 --> 03:52:21,713 so madam clerk, I have a concern 16444 03:52:21,713 --> 03:52:21,713 16445 03:52:21,713 --> 03:52:24,656 that if we're waiting until 16446 03:52:24,656 --> 03:52:28,701 october or sod to aert adverti 16447 03:52:28,701 --> 03:52:28,701 se 16448 03:52:28,701 --> 03:52:29,597 for a student position, that 16449 03:52:29,597 --> 03:52:30,420 means they don't really start 16450 03:52:30,420 --> 03:52:34,463 until january, and we may end u 16451 03:52:34,463 --> 03:52:34,463 p 16452 03:52:34,463 --> 03:52:36,390 putting somebody on the board 16453 03:52:36,390 --> 03:52:37,280 that's only here for one 16454 03:52:37,280 --> 03:52:37,280 semester. 16455 03:52:37,280 --> 03:52:39,037 >> mr. Mayor, it's a point wel 16456 03:52:39,037 --> 03:52:39,037 l 16457 03:52:39,037 --> 03:52:39,037 taken. 16458 03:52:39,037 --> 03:52:41,202 most of the student seats we d 16459 03:52:41,202 --> 03:52:41,202 o 16460 03:52:41,202 --> 03:52:43,684 with you all in camera in your 16461 03:52:43,684 --> 03:52:43,684 16462 03:52:43,684 --> 03:52:49,577 chambers, and so we get them o 16463 03:52:49,577 --> 03:52:49,577 n 16464 03:52:49,577 --> 03:52:50,805 the appointment and on the 16465 03:52:50,805 --> 03:52:51,473 consent agenda much more 16466 03:52:51,473 --> 03:52:51,473 quickly. 16467 03:52:51,473 --> 03:52:55,763 we usually have them on there 16468 03:52:55,763 --> 03:52:58,083 with by the end of october ear 16469 03:52:58,083 --> 03:52:58,083 ly 16470 03:52:58,083 --> 03:52:58,083 november. 16471 03:52:58,083 --> 03:53:01,988 it does eat into -- it's just 16472 03:53:01,988 --> 03:53:03,592 our experience when we've done 16473 03:53:03,592 --> 03:53:03,592 16474 03:53:03,592 --> 03:53:06,107 applications for students we 16475 03:53:06,107 --> 03:53:07,732 don't get the pool that you all 16476 03:53:07,732 --> 03:53:07,732 16477 03:53:07,732 --> 03:53:09,247 want to see. 16478 03:53:09,247 --> 03:53:09,763 >> mayor: okay. 16479 03:53:09,763 --> 03:53:10,096 all right. 16480 03:53:10,096 --> 03:53:11,432 thank you. 16481 03:53:11,432 --> 03:53:13,431 commissioner ingle. 16482 03:53:13,431 --> 03:53:15,673 >> make a motion to appoint 16483 03:53:15,673 --> 03:53:18,701 jayne moraski to the city plan 16484 03:53:18,701 --> 03:53:18,701 16485 03:53:18,701 --> 03:53:25,381 board -- [off mic] 16486 03:53:25,381 --> 03:53:29,193 >> sentiments that we you jus 16487 03:53:29,193 --> 03:53:29,193 t 16488 03:53:29,193 --> 03:53:29,877 stay involved. 16489 03:53:29,877 --> 03:53:31,950 more opportunities for you. 16490 03:53:31,950 --> 03:53:33,443 >> second. 16491 03:53:33,443 --> 03:53:34,122 >> mayor: all right we have a 16492 03:53:34,122 --> 03:53:34,122 second. 16493 03:53:34,122 --> 03:53:37,050 we did not sahave the giv 16494 03:53:37,050 --> 03:53:37,261 e the 16495 03:53:37,261 --> 03:53:38,028 other folks an opportunity. 16496 03:53:38,028 --> 03:53:40,227 >> oh, whoops, sorry. 16497 03:53:40,227 --> 03:53:40,833 >> mayor: that's okay. 16498 03:53:40,833 --> 03:53:41,897 I can do that before we vote. 16499 03:53:41,897 --> 03:53:43,235 >> neither of those folks 16500 03:53:43,235 --> 03:53:45,305 indicate -- they let us know 16501 03:53:45,305 --> 03:53:46,208 they weren't going to be able t 16502 03:53:46,208 --> 03:53:46,208 o 16503 03:53:46,208 --> 03:53:46,208 attend. 16504 03:53:46,208 --> 03:53:47,317 >> mayor: all right, well that 16505 03:53:47,317 --> 03:53:47,317 16506 03:53:47,317 --> 03:53:48,265 makes it easier, doesn't it. 16507 03:53:48,265 --> 03:53:49,005 all right. 16508 03:53:49,005 --> 03:53:49,875 commissioner eastman, did you 16509 03:53:49,875 --> 03:53:50,276 have anything else? 16510 03:53:50,276 --> 03:53:51,167 >> I was going do do exactly 16511 03:53:51,167 --> 03:53:57,591 what commissioner ingle did. 16512 03:53:57,591 --> 03:53:58,645 >> there is no public comment. 16513 03:53:58,645 --> 03:53:58,645 16514 03:53:58,645 --> 03:53:59,848 >> mayor: all in favor, I rirya 16515 03:53:59,848 --> 03:54:00,240 n 16516 03:54:00,240 --> 03:54:00,240 aye. 16517 03:54:00,240 --> 03:54:02,422 any opposed? 16518 03:54:02,422 --> 03:54:05,784 congratulations ms. Moraski. 16519 03:54:05,784 --> 03:54:06,689 thank you for being willing. 16520 03:54:06,689 --> 03:54:08,627 and mr. Willis, please do stay 16521 03:54:08,627 --> 03:54:08,627 16522 03:54:08,627 --> 03:54:08,627 involved. 16523 03:54:08,627 --> 03:54:09,989 there are many other boards out 16524 03:54:09,989 --> 03:54:09,989 16525 03:54:09,989 --> 03:54:09,989 there. 16526 03:54:09,989 --> 03:54:11,139 okay, madam clerk. 16527 03:54:11,139 --> 03:54:13,505 >> mr. Mayor, 2026-203, 16528 03:54:13,505 --> 03:54:14,727 application to the audit 16529 03:54:14,727 --> 03:54:15,495 committee with recommendation 16530 03:54:15,495 --> 03:54:17,102 the city commission review the 16531 03:54:17,102 --> 03:54:17,102 16532 03:54:17,102 --> 03:54:18,193 application received for 16533 03:54:18,193 --> 03:54:19,117 appointment to the audit 16534 03:54:19,117 --> 03:54:21,935 committee and take action deeme 16535 03:54:21,935 --> 03:54:21,935 d 16536 03:54:21,935 --> 03:54:21,935 necessary. 16537 03:54:21,935 --> 03:54:24,539 we did have only one applicant 16538 03:54:24,539 --> 03:54:24,539 , 16539 03:54:24,539 --> 03:54:27,912 who is here with us today, and 16540 03:54:27,912 --> 03:54:27,912 16541 03:54:27,912 --> 03:54:30,012 he did also attend the audit 16542 03:54:30,012 --> 03:54:31,345 committee meeting. 16543 03:54:31,345 --> 03:54:33,147 >> mayor: all right, would you 16544 03:54:33,147 --> 03:54:33,147 16545 03:54:33,147 --> 03:54:35,545 like to speak? 16546 03:54:35,545 --> 03:54:43,023 >> just want to say happy frida 16547 03:54:43,023 --> 03:54:43,023 y 16548 03:54:43,023 --> 03:54:43,023 eve. 16549 03:54:43,023 --> 03:54:45,112 I used to travel a lot when I 16550 03:54:45,112 --> 03:54:46,764 was down in the rider systems 16551 03:54:46,764 --> 03:54:48,193 always rider trucks always 16552 03:54:48,193 --> 03:54:49,466 traveled sunday night hated 16553 03:54:49,466 --> 03:54:51,000 being away from my family so I 16554 03:54:51,000 --> 03:54:51,000 16555 03:54:51,000 --> 03:54:52,337 always counted down to fried s 16556 03:54:52,337 --> 03:54:52,337 o 16557 03:54:52,337 --> 03:54:53,739 I do want to -- friday. 16558 03:54:53,739 --> 03:54:54,702 so I do want to appreciate you 16559 03:54:54,702 --> 03:54:54,702 16560 03:54:54,702 --> 03:54:55,799 all as far as inviting me here 16561 03:54:55,799 --> 03:54:55,799 16562 03:54:55,799 --> 03:54:55,799 today. 16563 03:54:55,799 --> 03:54:57,350 just give you a background of 16564 03:54:57,350 --> 03:54:57,350 myself. 16565 03:54:57,350 --> 03:54:59,743 my name is mark modus. 16566 03:54:59,743 --> 03:55:01,465 I have my cpa license I have a 16567 03:55:01,465 --> 03:55:01,465 16568 03:55:01,465 --> 03:55:02,443 masters in taxation I'm a 16569 03:55:02,443 --> 03:55:05,135 professor over at santa fe 16570 03:55:05,135 --> 03:55:08,815 college teach as far as -- 16571 03:55:08,815 --> 03:55:09,978 courses over there and also 16572 03:55:09,978 --> 03:55:11,092 created and put together the 16573 03:55:11,092 --> 03:55:12,708 advanced government accounting 16574 03:55:12,708 --> 03:55:12,708 16575 03:55:12,708 --> 03:55:12,708 course. 16576 03:55:12,708 --> 03:55:14,599 prior to coming up here, I was 16577 03:55:14,599 --> 03:55:14,599 16578 03:55:14,599 --> 03:55:18,495 the head of a accounting -- for 16579 03:55:18,495 --> 03:55:18,495 16580 03:55:18,495 --> 03:55:19,900 broward county school board, s 16581 03:55:19,900 --> 03:55:19,900 o 16582 03:55:19,900 --> 03:55:21,302 we were the sixth largest schoo 16583 03:55:21,302 --> 03:55:21,302 l 16584 03:55:21,302 --> 03:55:23,063 system in the nation, and prior 16585 03:55:23,063 --> 03:55:23,063 16586 03:55:23,063 --> 03:55:28,132 to that I was over at rider 16587 03:55:28,132 --> 03:55:28,132 systems. 16588 03:55:28,132 --> 03:55:29,786 my wife asked me why are you 16589 03:55:29,786 --> 03:55:31,769 interested in doing this? 16590 03:55:31,769 --> 03:55:32,840 because as far as you know 16591 03:55:32,840 --> 03:55:34,361 volunteering, and I would say 16592 03:55:34,361 --> 03:55:35,249 well two things. 16593 03:55:35,249 --> 03:55:37,981 I said as far as being head ove 16594 03:55:37,981 --> 03:55:37,981 r 16595 03:55:37,981 --> 03:55:39,149 broward county for financial 16596 03:55:39,149 --> 03:55:43,089 reporting, was I was conductin 16597 03:55:43,089 --> 03:55:43,089 g 16598 03:55:43,089 --> 03:55:43,929 meetings with the audit 16599 03:55:43,929 --> 03:55:43,929 committee. 16600 03:55:43,929 --> 03:55:46,258 conducting meetings with the 16601 03:55:46,258 --> 03:55:46,258 board. 16602 03:55:46,258 --> 03:55:50,765 every month and with rider 16603 03:55:50,765 --> 03:55:51,703 systems it was pretty much the 16604 03:55:51,703 --> 03:55:51,703 16605 03:55:51,703 --> 03:55:52,317 same thing. 16606 03:55:52,317 --> 03:55:53,759 you know what? 16607 03:55:53,759 --> 03:55:54,921 this gives me the opportunity t 16608 03:55:54,921 --> 03:55:54,921 o 16609 03:55:54,921 --> 03:55:55,845 see how it's done on the other 16610 03:55:55,845 --> 03:55:56,957 16611 03:55:56,957 --> 03:55:57,561 on the other side. 16612 03:55:57,561 --> 03:55:59,205 on the flip being professor ove 16613 03:55:59,205 --> 03:55:59,205 r 16614 03:55:59,205 --> 03:56:03,004 santa fe college, I'm also on 16615 03:56:03,004 --> 03:56:04,111 the community connect and 16616 03:56:04,111 --> 03:56:04,981 community connect board what 16617 03:56:04,981 --> 03:56:07,485 we're doing is reaching inside 16618 03:56:07,485 --> 03:56:07,485 16619 03:56:07,485 --> 03:56:08,670 alachua county, outside the 16620 03:56:08,670 --> 03:56:10,981 county as well, and looking for, 16621 03:56:10,981 --> 03:56:10,981 16622 03:56:10,981 --> 03:56:13,049 to get that connection, 16623 03:56:13,049 --> 03:56:13,663 opportunities for business, 16624 03:56:13,663 --> 03:56:15,585 opportunities for governments. 16625 03:56:15,585 --> 03:56:15,585 16626 03:56:15,585 --> 03:56:18,019 not only for to extend santa f 16627 03:56:18,019 --> 03:56:18,019 e 16628 03:56:18,019 --> 03:56:20,289 college out more, but also to 16629 03:56:20,289 --> 03:56:21,813 help our students as far as we 16630 03:56:21,813 --> 03:56:21,813 16631 03:56:21,813 --> 03:56:23,594 got a lot of different 16632 03:56:23,594 --> 03:56:24,601 apprenticeships that are going 16633 03:56:24,601 --> 03:56:24,601 16634 03:56:24,601 --> 03:56:26,287 on, and I figured you know 16635 03:56:26,287 --> 03:56:26,287 what? 16636 03:56:26,287 --> 03:56:28,291 what's a better way to learn 16637 03:56:28,291 --> 03:56:30,145 about such a good size city as 16638 03:56:30,145 --> 03:56:30,145 16639 03:56:30,145 --> 03:56:31,201 gainesville, what the 16640 03:56:31,201 --> 03:56:35,064 opportunities are there, and 16641 03:56:35,064 --> 03:56:37,768 just -- as you can tell, as I 16642 03:56:37,768 --> 03:56:39,778 tell my students and my class, I 16643 03:56:39,778 --> 03:56:39,778 16644 03:56:39,778 --> 03:56:40,836 talk and never shut up, so the 16645 03:56:40,836 --> 03:56:40,836 re 16646 03:56:40,836 --> 03:56:41,603 we go. 16647 03:56:41,603 --> 03:56:42,575 appreciate the time. 16648 03:56:42,575 --> 03:56:44,317 >> mayor: all right, thank you. 16649 03:56:44,317 --> 03:56:44,317 16650 03:56:44,317 --> 03:56:47,180 commissioner book? 16651 03:56:47,180 --> 03:56:49,020 >> this is so easy. 16652 03:56:49,020 --> 03:56:51,925 mr. Mayor, so professor modus 16653 03:56:51,925 --> 03:56:52,719 has the knowledge, the skills, 16654 03:56:52,719 --> 03:56:52,719 16655 03:56:52,719 --> 03:56:54,365 the abilities, he's a current 16656 03:56:54,365 --> 03:56:56,626 educator so he is going to be u 16657 03:56:56,626 --> 03:56:56,626 p 16658 03:56:56,626 --> 03:56:59,273 on trends related to auditing 16659 03:56:59,273 --> 03:56:59,273 in 16660 03:56:59,273 --> 03:57:01,701 the field so under 2026-203 I 16661 03:57:01,701 --> 03:57:02,971 recommend approval of professor 16662 03:57:02,971 --> 03:57:02,971 16663 03:57:02,971 --> 03:57:03,989 mark modus to the audit 16664 03:57:03,989 --> 03:57:03,989 committee. 16665 03:57:03,989 --> 03:57:07,741 >> second. 16666 03:57:07,741 --> 03:57:08,481 >> mayor: we have a motion and 16667 03:57:08,481 --> 03:57:08,571 a 16668 03:57:08,571 --> 03:57:08,571 second. 16669 03:57:08,571 --> 03:57:10,636 commissioner duncan-walker. 16670 03:57:10,636 --> 03:57:13,601 >> I was going to simply 16671 03:57:13,601 --> 03:57:13,601 support. 16672 03:57:13,601 --> 03:57:15,207 that's it. 16673 03:57:15,207 --> 03:57:15,636 >> mayor: all right. 16674 03:57:15,636 --> 03:57:21,093 commissioner eastman? 16675 03:57:21,093 --> 03:57:21,849 >> I called around to some 16676 03:57:21,849 --> 03:57:23,364 friends in the city of newberr 16677 03:57:23,364 --> 03:57:23,364 y 16678 03:57:23,364 --> 03:57:25,354 who -- mr. Modus here has a 16679 03:57:25,354 --> 03:57:25,883 great reputation. 16680 03:57:25,883 --> 03:57:27,454 you're very involved within you 16681 03:57:27,454 --> 03:57:27,454 r 16682 03:57:27,454 --> 03:57:30,463 community from what I've heard 16683 03:57:30,463 --> 03:57:30,463 . 16684 03:57:30,463 --> 03:57:31,991 yob ryan undine been helpful I 16685 03:57:31,991 --> 03:57:31,991 n 16686 03:57:31,991 --> 03:57:32,963 the -- you've been helpful in 16687 03:57:32,963 --> 03:57:34,691 the city of newberry in trying 16688 03:57:34,691 --> 03:57:34,691 16689 03:57:34,691 --> 03:57:35,499 to work through the of the 16690 03:57:35,499 --> 03:57:37,597 financials there so I think 16691 03:57:37,597 --> 03:57:38,811 you'll be a great addition to 16692 03:57:38,811 --> 03:57:39,915 our audit committee and this I 16693 03:57:39,915 --> 03:57:39,915 s 16694 03:57:39,915 --> 03:57:41,177 great for your record, we how 16695 03:57:41,177 --> 03:57:44,331 long was our last board member 16696 03:57:44,331 --> 03:57:44,331 16697 03:57:44,331 --> 03:57:44,331 there? 16698 03:57:44,331 --> 03:57:45,973 >> several years. 16699 03:57:45,973 --> 03:57:48,575 >> several years. 16700 03:57:48,575 --> 03:57:51,317 I'm looking forward have to 16701 03:57:51,317 --> 03:57:52,844 having you in there, have a 16702 03:57:52,844 --> 03:57:54,381 fresh pair of eyes on 16703 03:57:54,381 --> 03:57:54,381 everything. 16704 03:57:54,381 --> 03:57:56,577 >> appreciate you. 16705 03:57:56,577 --> 03:57:57,221 >> I think he's already attended 16706 03:57:57,221 --> 03:57:57,221 16707 03:57:57,221 --> 03:57:57,557 a meeting. 16708 03:57:57,557 --> 03:57:59,041 >> yeah, last week, yes, ma'am. 16709 03:57:59,041 --> 03:57:59,041 16710 03:57:59,041 --> 03:57:59,637 >> yes, yes. 16711 03:57:59,637 --> 03:58:00,283 >> yes, ma'am. 16712 03:58:00,283 --> 03:58:00,924 >> mayor: very good. 16713 03:58:00,924 --> 03:58:01,182 all right. 16714 03:58:01,182 --> 03:58:01,961 thank you, commissioner 16715 03:58:01,961 --> 03:58:01,961 eastman. 16716 03:58:01,961 --> 03:58:03,959 seeing no further lights, is 16717 03:58:03,959 --> 03:58:06,054 there any public comment? 16718 03:58:06,054 --> 03:58:07,059 >> there is no public comment. 16719 03:58:07,059 --> 03:58:07,059 16720 03:58:07,059 --> 03:58:07,801 >> mayor: all right, all in 16721 03:58:07,801 --> 03:58:09,093 favor, please say aye. 16722 03:58:09,093 --> 03:58:10,099 any opposed? 16723 03:58:10,099 --> 03:58:10,963 all righty, that passes 16724 03:58:10,963 --> 03:58:10,963 unanimously. 16725 03:58:10,963 --> 03:58:12,803 madam clerk. 16726 03:58:12,803 --> 03:58:14,067 >> mr. Mayor, we're onto 16727 03:58:14,067 --> 03:58:15,996 commission comment. 16728 03:58:15,996 --> 03:58:16,537 >> mayor: all right. 16729 03:58:16,537 --> 03:58:17,671 I have multiple commission 16730 03:58:17,671 --> 03:58:18,811 comments, but I'll save those 16731 03:58:18,811 --> 03:58:20,007 for, for the end of the 16732 03:58:20,007 --> 03:58:20,007 meeting. 16733 03:58:20,007 --> 03:58:22,611 anyone else? 16734 03:58:22,611 --> 03:58:22,913 anyone else? 16735 03:58:22,913 --> 03:58:25,743 we will be back here at 5:45 o 16736 03:58:25,743 --> 03:58:25,743 r 16737 03:58:25,743 --> 03:58:37,481 yeah, 5:45. 16738 03:58:37,481 --> 03:59:03,605 16739 00:00:00,000 --> 23:49:32,609 16740 23:49:32,609 --> 00:03:07,044 >> mayor: good evening, 16741 00:03:07,044 --> 00:03:07,044 everyone. 16742 00:03:07,044 --> 00:03:08,700 welcome to the evening session 16743 00:03:08,700 --> 00:03:08,700 16744 00:03:08,700 --> 00:03:11,337 for this thursday april 2nd 16745 00:03:11,337 --> 00:03:13,070 meeting of the gainesville city 16746 00:03:13,070 --> 00:03:13,070 16747 00:03:13,070 --> 00:03:13,070 commission. 16748 00:03:13,070 --> 00:03:16,875 we are lucky to have with us a 16749 00:03:16,875 --> 00:03:16,875 16750 00:03:16,875 --> 00:03:18,541 great group of cub scouts and 16751 00:03:18,541 --> 00:03:20,282 I'm going to invite you all to 16752 00:03:20,282 --> 00:03:20,282 16753 00:03:20,282 --> 00:03:22,443 come forward and lead us in the 16754 00:03:22,443 --> 00:03:22,443 16755 00:03:22,443 --> 00:03:24,320 pledge please. 16756 00:03:24,320 --> 00:03:25,952 come on up. 16757 00:03:25,952 --> 00:03:33,059 good marching. 16758 00:03:33,059 --> 00:03:39,930 so we're going to follow your 16759 00:03:39,930 --> 00:03:39,930 lead. 16760 00:03:39,930 --> 00:03:41,534 >> start it off. 16761 00:03:41,534 --> 00:03:47,044 >> group: I pledge allegiance to 16762 00:03:47,044 --> 00:03:47,044 16763 00:03:47,044 --> 00:03:47,679 the flag of the united states of 16764 00:03:47,679 --> 00:03:47,679 16765 00:03:47,679 --> 00:03:49,333 america and to the republic for 16766 00:03:49,333 --> 00:03:49,333 16767 00:03:49,333 --> 00:03:49,923 which it stands one nation und 16768 00:03:49,923 --> 00:03:49,923 er 16769 00:03:49,923 --> 00:03:51,400 god indivisible with liberty a 16770 00:03:51,400 --> 00:03:51,400 nd 16771 00:03:51,400 --> 00:03:55,012 justice for all. 16772 00:03:55,012 --> 00:03:57,981 >> mayor: very, very good. 16773 00:03:57,981 --> 00:03:59,311 y'all turn around and let's get 16774 00:03:59,311 --> 00:03:59,311 16775 00:03:59,311 --> 00:04:01,365 some photos. 16776 00:04:01,365 --> 00:04:03,667 >> you want to take a picture? 16777 00:04:03,667 --> 00:04:03,667 16778 00:04:03,667 --> 00:04:06,166 >> get in here. 16779 00:04:06,166 --> 00:04:22,158 [indistinct conversation] 16780 00:04:22,158 --> 00:04:24,908 >> mayor: between that and the 16781 00:04:24,908 --> 00:04:24,908 16782 00:04:24,908 --> 00:04:26,443 rocket launch last night, I'm 16783 00:04:26,443 --> 00:04:28,380 feeling all kinds of patriotic 16784 00:04:28,380 --> 00:04:28,380 . 16785 00:04:28,380 --> 00:04:29,684 good work. 16786 00:04:29,684 --> 00:04:29,684 [applause] 16787 00:04:29,684 --> 00:04:36,687 madam clerk. 16788 00:04:36,687 --> 00:04:38,763 >> mr. Mayor, oh, my goodness. 16789 00:04:38,763 --> 00:04:38,763 16790 00:04:38,763 --> 00:04:39,892 it's a hard act to follow. 16791 00:04:39,892 --> 00:04:43,234 >> mayor: yes. 16792 00:04:43,234 --> 00:04:45,135 >> oh, my gosh. 16793 00:04:45,135 --> 00:04:45,554 [indistinct conversation] 16794 00:04:45,554 --> 00:04:52,368 >> give them a minute. 16795 00:04:52,368 --> 00:04:57,188 >> they may need just a sec. 16796 00:04:57,188 --> 00:05:07,226 mr. Mayor, we have 2026-251, 16797 00:05:07,226 --> 00:05:08,424 national public safety 16798 00:05:08,424 --> 00:05:27,299 telecommunications week. 16799 00:05:27,299 --> 00:05:38,212 >> mayor: whereas the professio 16800 00:05:38,212 --> 00:05:38,212 n 16801 00:05:38,212 --> 00:05:39,821 of public safety 16802 00:05:39,821 --> 00:05:40,925 telecommunicator in alachua 16803 00:05:40,925 --> 00:05:42,005 county plays a crucial role in 16804 00:05:42,005 --> 00:05:42,005 16805 00:05:42,005 --> 00:05:43,333 the protection of life, propert 16806 00:05:43,333 --> 00:05:43,333 y 16807 00:05:43,333 --> 00:05:44,622 and delivery of public safety 16808 00:05:44,622 --> 00:05:44,622 services. 16809 00:05:44,622 --> 00:05:47,625 and whereas, each day hundreds 16810 00:05:47,625 --> 00:05:47,625 16811 00:05:47,625 --> 00:05:50,092 of neighbors dial 911 for help 16812 00:05:50,092 --> 00:05:50,092 16813 00:05:50,092 --> 00:05:51,962 in emergencies and the 16814 00:05:51,962 --> 00:05:53,704 telecommunicators who answer 16815 00:05:53,704 --> 00:05:55,583 these calls gather essential 16816 00:05:55,583 --> 00:05:56,696 information and dispatch the 16817 00:05:56,696 --> 00:05:58,636 appropriate assistance which c 16818 00:05:58,636 --> 00:05:58,636 an 16819 00:05:58,636 --> 00:05:59,835 often make the difference 16820 00:05:59,835 --> 00:06:00,834 between life and death for 16821 00:06:00,834 --> 00:06:01,714 persons in need. 16822 00:06:01,714 --> 00:06:04,495 and whereas, these well trained 16823 00:06:04,495 --> 00:06:04,495 , 16824 00:06:04,495 --> 00:06:05,679 highly dedicated and deeply 16825 00:06:05,679 --> 00:06:07,512 motivated individuals proudly 16826 00:06:07,512 --> 00:06:08,812 and selflessly serve the 16827 00:06:08,812 --> 00:06:10,787 neighbors of gainesville 24 16828 00:06:10,787 --> 00:06:12,897 hours a day, seven days a week 16829 00:06:12,897 --> 00:06:12,897 , 16830 00:06:12,897 --> 00:06:14,483 and sometimes during extreme 16831 00:06:14,483 --> 00:06:16,487 situations such as hurricanes, 16832 00:06:16,487 --> 00:06:16,487 16833 00:06:16,487 --> 00:06:17,924 making them unable to be with 16834 00:06:17,924 --> 00:06:19,454 their own families or protect 16835 00:06:19,454 --> 00:06:20,423 their personal homes and 16836 00:06:20,423 --> 00:06:20,423 property. 16837 00:06:20,423 --> 00:06:23,205 and whereas, telecommunicators 16838 00:06:23,205 --> 00:06:23,205 16839 00:06:23,205 --> 00:06:24,701 who are the original first 16840 00:06:24,701 --> 00:06:26,532 responders are honored to 16841 00:06:26,532 --> 00:06:27,417 receive recognition by the 16842 00:06:27,417 --> 00:06:28,698 neighbors and agencies who 16843 00:06:28,698 --> 00:06:30,567 depend on them and benefit fro 16844 00:06:30,567 --> 00:06:30,567 m 16845 00:06:30,567 --> 00:06:31,569 their services. 16846 00:06:31,569 --> 00:06:33,435 and whereas, the congress of t 16847 00:06:33,435 --> 00:06:33,435 he 16848 00:06:33,435 --> 00:06:35,540 united states has proclaimed I 16849 00:06:35,540 --> 00:06:35,540 n 16850 00:06:35,540 --> 00:06:37,342 support and recognition to the 16851 00:06:37,342 --> 00:06:37,342 se 16852 00:06:37,342 --> 00:06:38,507 employees and their profession 16853 00:06:38,507 --> 00:06:38,507 16854 00:06:38,507 --> 00:06:39,451 and the city commission wishes 16855 00:06:39,451 --> 00:06:39,451 16856 00:06:39,451 --> 00:06:42,414 to publicly recognize the local 16857 00:06:42,414 --> 00:06:42,414 16858 00:06:42,414 --> 00:06:43,451 telecommunicators who serve the 16859 00:06:43,451 --> 00:06:43,451 16860 00:06:43,451 --> 00:06:46,348 neighbors of gainesville in suc 16861 00:06:46,348 --> 00:06:46,348 hmanner. 16862 00:06:46,348 --> 00:06:50,111 now, therefore, I harvey l. Ward 16863 00:06:50,111 --> 00:06:50,111 16864 00:06:50,111 --> 00:06:51,062 jr. By the authority vested in 16865 00:06:51,062 --> 00:06:51,062 16866 00:06:51,062 --> 00:06:52,258 me by the city of gainesville d 16867 00:06:52,258 --> 00:06:52,258 o 16868 00:06:52,258 --> 00:06:57,493 hereby proclaim april 12 throu 16869 00:06:57,493 --> 00:06:57,493 gh 16870 00:06:57,493 --> 00:07:00,662 18, 2026 as national 16871 00:07:00,662 --> 00:07:02,105 telecommunicators week and 16872 00:07:02,105 --> 00:07:04,165 invite our neighbors to 16873 00:07:04,165 --> 00:07:05,804 recognize our heroes in witness 16874 00:07:05,804 --> 00:07:05,804 16875 00:07:05,804 --> 00:07:09,486 whereof, I have caused to be 16876 00:07:09,486 --> 00:07:12,295 affixed the official seal of t 16877 00:07:12,295 --> 00:07:12,295 he 16878 00:07:12,295 --> 00:07:13,483 city of gainesville, florida 16879 00:07:13,483 --> 00:07:15,680 this 31st day of march, 2026. 16880 00:07:15,680 --> 00:07:17,021 thank you, all. 16881 00:07:17,021 --> 00:07:17,021 [applause] 16882 00:07:17,021 --> 00:07:21,118 and I want to tell you, this o 16883 00:07:21,118 --> 00:07:21,118 ne 16884 00:07:21,118 --> 00:07:22,455 is special to me. 16885 00:07:22,455 --> 00:07:24,764 when I was a kid, my dad was a 16886 00:07:24,764 --> 00:07:24,764 16887 00:07:24,764 --> 00:07:28,032 radio operator/early 16888 00:07:28,032 --> 00:07:30,202 telecommunicator at gpd. 16889 00:07:30,202 --> 00:07:34,360 and so I grew up when we had a 16890 00:07:34,360 --> 00:07:34,360 n 16891 00:07:34,360 --> 00:07:36,178 emergency, my dad was -- it was 16892 00:07:36,178 --> 00:07:36,178 16893 00:07:36,178 --> 00:07:37,765 a hurricane or whatever, dad w 16894 00:07:37,765 --> 00:07:37,765 as 16895 00:07:37,765 --> 00:07:38,555 at gpd. 16896 00:07:38,555 --> 00:07:44,585 and so I respect what youall do 16897 00:07:44,585 --> 00:07:44,585 16898 00:07:44,585 --> 00:07:45,155 very much and what your families 16899 00:07:45,155 --> 00:07:45,155 16900 00:07:45,155 --> 00:07:45,510 offer as well. 16901 00:07:45,510 --> 00:07:51,576 >> hello, my name is kristoffer 16902 00:07:51,576 --> 00:07:51,576 16903 00:07:51,576 --> 00:07:55,610 orwig, I'm at the alachua count 16904 00:07:55,610 --> 00:07:55,610 y 16905 00:07:55,610 --> 00:07:56,127 training center. 16906 00:07:56,127 --> 00:07:58,332 on behalf of my co-workers, I'd 16907 00:07:58,332 --> 00:07:58,332 16908 00:07:58,332 --> 00:08:00,225 like to thank the chair and 16909 00:08:00,225 --> 00:08:01,257 citizens of alachua county for 16910 00:08:01,257 --> 00:08:01,257 16911 00:08:01,257 --> 00:08:05,001 taking the time to recognize 16912 00:08:05,001 --> 00:08:06,659 telecommunicators safety week 16913 00:08:06,659 --> 00:08:06,659 2026. 16914 00:08:06,659 --> 00:08:07,499 thank you. 16915 00:08:07,499 --> 00:08:23,451 [applause] 16916 00:08:23,451 --> 00:08:38,479 >> mr. Mayor, we have 2026-197, 16917 00:08:38,479 --> 00:08:38,479 16918 00:08:38,479 --> 00:08:42,097 child abuse prevention month. 16919 00:08:42,097 --> 00:08:42,633 >> mayor: all right. 16920 00:08:42,633 --> 00:08:43,535 who is receiving this? 16921 00:08:43,535 --> 00:08:45,715 there we go. 16922 00:08:45,715 --> 00:08:51,819 whereas, prevention is possible. 16923 00:08:51,819 --> 00:08:51,819 16924 00:08:51,819 --> 00:08:52,685 every family and child are 16925 00:08:52,685 --> 00:08:54,877 filled with tremendous promise. 16926 00:08:54,877 --> 00:08:54,877 16927 00:08:54,877 --> 00:08:56,518 we all have a collective 16928 00:08:56,518 --> 00:08:58,814 responsibility to prevent 16929 00:08:58,814 --> 00:09:00,630 adverse childhood experiences, 16930 00:09:00,630 --> 00:09:00,630 16931 00:09:00,630 --> 00:09:02,119 foster the potential of every 16932 00:09:02,119 --> 00:09:03,423 child and promote positive 16933 00:09:03,423 --> 00:09:04,289 childhood experiences. 16934 00:09:04,289 --> 00:09:05,951 and whereas, families who 16935 00:09:05,951 --> 00:09:08,025 receive the support they need 16936 00:09:08,025 --> 00:09:09,337 before a crisis occurs are 16937 00:09:09,337 --> 00:09:11,199 better equipped to provide saf 16938 00:09:11,199 --> 00:09:11,199 e, 16939 00:09:11,199 --> 00:09:13,591 healthy and nurturing 16940 00:09:13,591 --> 00:09:14,805 environments leading to children 16941 00:09:14,805 --> 00:09:14,805 16942 00:09:14,805 --> 00:09:16,265 who are safer, healthier and 16943 00:09:16,265 --> 00:09:17,905 more hopeful about their 16944 00:09:17,905 --> 00:09:17,905 futures. 16945 00:09:17,905 --> 00:09:19,935 whereas childhood trauma 16946 00:09:19,935 --> 00:09:22,041 including abuse and neglect can 16947 00:09:22,041 --> 00:09:22,041 16948 00:09:22,041 --> 00:09:23,778 have long-term psychological, 16949 00:09:23,778 --> 00:09:26,009 emotional and physical effects 16950 00:09:26,009 --> 00:09:26,009 16951 00:09:26,009 --> 00:09:27,039 throughout an individual's 16952 00:09:27,039 --> 00:09:28,479 lifetime and impact future 16953 00:09:28,479 --> 00:09:28,479 generations. 16954 00:09:28,479 --> 00:09:31,777 and whereas, we acknowledge that 16955 00:09:31,777 --> 00:09:31,777 16956 00:09:31,777 --> 00:09:33,619 we must work together as a 16957 00:09:33,619 --> 00:09:35,715 community to increase awareness 16958 00:09:35,715 --> 00:09:35,715 16959 00:09:35,715 --> 00:09:37,263 about child abuse and contribut 16960 00:09:37,263 --> 00:09:37,263 e 16961 00:09:37,263 --> 00:09:38,753 to promoting the social and 16962 00:09:38,753 --> 00:09:40,300 emotional well-being of children 16963 00:09:40,300 --> 00:09:40,300 16964 00:09:40,300 --> 00:09:43,159 and families in a safe, stable 16965 00:09:43,159 --> 00:09:43,159 16966 00:09:43,159 --> 00:09:45,096 and nurturing environment. 16967 00:09:45,096 --> 00:09:47,199 and whereas, investments in 16968 00:09:47,199 --> 00:09:48,269 prevention initiatives are 16969 00:09:48,269 --> 00:09:49,701 essential to building safer and 16970 00:09:49,701 --> 00:09:49,701 16971 00:09:49,701 --> 00:09:52,673 healthier communities for all. 16972 00:09:52,673 --> 00:09:52,673 16973 00:09:52,673 --> 00:09:55,271 therefore, I harvey l. Ward jr. 16974 00:09:55,271 --> 00:09:55,271 16975 00:09:55,271 --> 00:09:57,237 as the mayor of the city of 16976 00:09:57,237 --> 00:09:58,575 gainesville harborby proclaim 16977 00:09:58,575 --> 00:10:00,081 april 2026 as child abuse 16978 00:10:00,081 --> 00:10:02,029 prevention month in the city of 16979 00:10:02,029 --> 00:10:02,029 16980 00:10:02,029 --> 00:10:03,053 gainesville and invite all our 16981 00:10:03,053 --> 00:10:03,053 16982 00:10:03,053 --> 00:10:04,352 neighbors to join me in 16983 00:10:04,352 --> 00:10:05,551 recognizing this month by 16984 00:10:05,551 --> 00:10:07,120 dedicating ourselves to the tas 16985 00:10:07,120 --> 00:10:07,120 k 16986 00:10:07,120 --> 00:10:08,343 of improving the quality of life 16987 00:10:08,343 --> 00:10:08,343 16988 00:10:08,343 --> 00:10:10,723 for all children and families. 16989 00:10:10,723 --> 00:10:10,723 16990 00:10:10,723 --> 00:10:12,569 in witness whereof, I have 16991 00:10:12,569 --> 00:10:14,523 hereunto set my hand and cause 16992 00:10:14,523 --> 00:10:14,523 d 16993 00:10:14,523 --> 00:10:15,765 to be affixed the official sea 16994 00:10:15,765 --> 00:10:15,765 l 16995 00:10:15,765 --> 00:10:17,009 of the city of gainesville, 16996 00:10:17,009 --> 00:10:17,836 florida this 11th day of 16997 00:10:17,836 --> 00:10:20,237 march, 2026. 16998 00:10:20,237 --> 00:10:21,667 harvey ward jr. Mayor. 16999 00:10:21,667 --> 00:10:21,667 congratulations. 17000 00:10:21,667 --> 00:10:21,667 [applause] 17001 00:10:21,667 --> 00:10:27,537 >> thank you, thank you. 17002 00:10:27,537 --> 00:10:29,521 on behalf of the alachua count 17003 00:10:29,521 --> 00:10:29,521 y 17004 00:10:29,521 --> 00:10:31,241 child abuse prevention task 17005 00:10:31,241 --> 00:10:33,781 force in partnership for stron 17006 00:10:33,781 --> 00:10:33,781 g 17007 00:10:33,781 --> 00:10:35,835 families, I want to thank you s 17008 00:10:35,835 --> 00:10:35,835 o 17009 00:10:35,835 --> 00:10:36,679 much for standing with us in 17010 00:10:36,679 --> 00:10:38,521 recognizing april as child abu 17011 00:10:38,521 --> 00:10:38,521 se 17012 00:10:38,521 --> 00:10:39,349 prevention month. 17013 00:10:39,349 --> 00:10:40,885 child abuse prevention needs t 17014 00:10:40,885 --> 00:10:40,885 o 17015 00:10:40,885 --> 00:10:42,785 happen all year long, but we'd 17016 00:10:42,785 --> 00:10:42,785 17017 00:10:42,785 --> 00:10:44,623 like to set aside this month t 17018 00:10:44,623 --> 00:10:44,623 o 17019 00:10:44,623 --> 00:10:45,823 especially recognize it. 17020 00:10:45,823 --> 00:10:48,521 and with that, I'm going to han 17021 00:10:48,521 --> 00:10:48,521 d 17022 00:10:48,521 --> 00:10:50,999 it over to sherry kitchens with 17023 00:10:50,999 --> 00:10:50,999 17024 00:10:50,999 --> 00:10:52,739 the child advocacy center. 17025 00:10:52,739 --> 00:10:54,401 >> good afternoon. 17026 00:10:54,401 --> 00:10:55,333 mayor, thank you so much for 17027 00:10:55,333 --> 00:10:57,615 this acknowledgment. 17028 00:10:57,615 --> 00:10:58,693 city commissioners, thank you 17029 00:10:58,693 --> 00:10:59,699 for all you do for children 17030 00:10:59,699 --> 00:11:00,504 throughout the year. 17031 00:11:00,504 --> 00:11:03,017 my name is sherry kitchens,the 17032 00:11:03,017 --> 00:11:03,017 17033 00:11:03,017 --> 00:11:04,307 director of the child advocacy 17034 00:11:04,307 --> 00:11:04,307 17035 00:11:04,307 --> 00:11:06,241 center and the chair of the 17036 00:11:06,241 --> 00:11:07,017 alachua county child abuse 17037 00:11:07,017 --> 00:11:07,680 prevention task force. 17038 00:11:07,680 --> 00:11:09,297 you may have noticed if you hav 17039 00:11:09,297 --> 00:11:09,297 e 17040 00:11:09,297 --> 00:11:12,081 been by u.f. Health children's 17041 00:11:12,081 --> 00:11:12,081 17042 00:11:12,081 --> 00:11:13,667 hospital since yesterday, there 17043 00:11:13,667 --> 00:11:13,667 17044 00:11:13,667 --> 00:11:15,687 is a beautiful display of 17045 00:11:15,687 --> 00:11:16,655 pinwheels out front. 17046 00:11:16,655 --> 00:11:19,457 that is due to the support and 17047 00:11:19,457 --> 00:11:19,457 17048 00:11:19,457 --> 00:11:21,291 effort of the children's trust 17049 00:11:21,291 --> 00:11:21,291 17050 00:11:21,291 --> 00:11:23,655 of alachua county and 12 17051 00:11:23,655 --> 00:11:26,763 organizations that make up the 17052 00:11:26,763 --> 00:11:30,513 abuse prevention task 17053 00:11:30,513 --> 00:11:31,021 force, got out there yesterday 17054 00:11:31,021 --> 00:11:31,021 . 17055 00:11:31,021 --> 00:11:31,709 there were over 50 of us 17056 00:11:31,709 --> 00:11:34,405 planting those pinwheels, over 17057 00:11:34,405 --> 00:11:34,405 17058 00:11:34,405 --> 00:11:35,211 200 pinwheels. 17059 00:11:35,211 --> 00:11:36,581 you'll also see them throughou 17060 00:11:36,581 --> 00:11:36,581 t 17061 00:11:36,581 --> 00:11:37,855 the community. 17062 00:11:37,855 --> 00:11:39,503 everywhere where prevention is 17063 00:11:39,503 --> 00:11:39,503 17064 00:11:39,503 --> 00:11:40,213 happening in the community wit 17065 00:11:40,213 --> 00:11:40,213 h 17066 00:11:40,213 --> 00:11:41,189 our agencies. 17067 00:11:41,189 --> 00:11:43,480 so we really appreciate this 17068 00:11:43,480 --> 00:11:46,022 acknowledgment and your focus 17069 00:11:46,022 --> 00:11:47,753 and support in taking care of 17070 00:11:47,753 --> 00:11:49,722 chinch in our community. 17071 00:11:49,722 --> 00:11:53,994 >> and I'm emily mccauley with 17072 00:11:53,994 --> 00:11:53,994 17073 00:11:53,994 --> 00:11:55,830 the children's trust of alachua 17074 00:11:55,830 --> 00:11:55,830 17075 00:11:55,830 --> 00:11:55,830 county. 17076 00:11:55,830 --> 00:11:57,745 I will echo what has been said 17077 00:11:57,745 --> 00:11:57,745 17078 00:11:57,745 --> 00:11:58,928 here in that we are proud to 17079 00:11:58,928 --> 00:12:00,325 fund and support efforts all 17080 00:12:00,325 --> 00:12:02,990 around our community to make 17081 00:12:02,990 --> 00:12:03,796 alachua county safer for 17082 00:12:03,796 --> 00:12:05,134 children and families. 17083 00:12:05,134 --> 00:12:06,674 the pinwheels are a visual 17084 00:12:06,674 --> 00:12:08,100 reminder of that role that we 17085 00:12:08,100 --> 00:12:09,840 all collectively play. 17086 00:12:09,840 --> 00:12:11,474 I'll give a shout-out to the 17087 00:12:11,474 --> 00:12:13,356 students at the u.f. Center for 17088 00:12:13,356 --> 00:12:13,356 17089 00:12:13,356 --> 00:12:14,544 autism and related disabilitie 17090 00:12:14,544 --> 00:12:14,544 s 17091 00:12:14,544 --> 00:12:16,548 who helped us assemble about 600 17092 00:12:16,548 --> 00:12:16,548 17093 00:12:16,548 --> 00:12:18,280 of those pinwheels in our offic 17094 00:12:18,280 --> 00:12:18,280 e 17095 00:12:18,280 --> 00:12:19,012 last week. 17096 00:12:19,012 --> 00:12:21,894 and we have 10 different ctac 17097 00:12:21,894 --> 00:12:23,556 funded partners who will also b 17098 00:12:23,556 --> 00:12:23,556 e 17099 00:12:23,556 --> 00:12:25,828 planting pinwheels and it reall 17100 00:12:25,828 --> 00:12:25,828 y 17101 00:12:25,828 --> 00:12:27,898 is a community wide collective 17102 00:12:27,898 --> 00:12:27,898 17103 00:12:27,898 --> 00:12:29,094 effort because we all play a 17104 00:12:29,094 --> 00:12:35,698 role, wis providing a 17105 00:12:35,698 --> 00:12:35,742 sa and supportive 17106 00:12:35,742 --> 00:12:37,032 out-of-school time provider to 17107 00:12:37,032 --> 00:12:37,032 17108 00:12:37,032 --> 00:12:39,072 an individual and the children' 17109 00:12:39,072 --> 00:12:39,072 s 17110 00:12:39,072 --> 00:12:40,580 trust of alachua county in 17111 00:12:40,580 --> 00:12:41,804 supporting our children and 17112 00:12:41,804 --> 00:12:58,649 families absolute the county. 17113 00:12:58,649 --> 00:13:19,182 >> mr. Mayor, we have 2026-198, 17114 00:13:19,182 --> 00:13:19,182 17115 00:13:19,182 --> 00:13:27,147 pray then play day. 17116 00:13:27,147 --> 00:13:28,950 >> mayor: okay. 17117 00:13:28,950 --> 00:13:30,110 mr. Sweger, do you have this 17118 00:13:30,110 --> 00:13:30,110 one? 17119 00:13:30,110 --> 00:13:33,161 I'm sorry. 17120 00:13:33,161 --> 00:13:34,159 all right. 17121 00:13:34,159 --> 00:13:35,792 whereas, individuals and 17122 00:13:35,792 --> 00:13:36,890 families thrive when think com 17123 00:13:36,890 --> 00:13:36,890 e 17124 00:13:36,890 --> 00:13:38,862 together in unity, community a 17125 00:13:38,862 --> 00:13:38,862 nd 17126 00:13:38,862 --> 00:13:41,266 harmony to engage in wholesome 17127 00:13:41,266 --> 00:13:41,266 17128 00:13:41,266 --> 00:13:41,266 fellowship. 17129 00:13:41,266 --> 00:13:43,178 whereas the strength of a city 17130 00:13:43,178 --> 00:13:43,178 17131 00:13:43,178 --> 00:13:45,404 lies in how well the residents 17132 00:13:45,404 --> 00:13:45,404 17133 00:13:45,404 --> 00:13:46,538 collaborate and share positive 17134 00:13:46,538 --> 00:13:46,538 17135 00:13:46,538 --> 00:13:48,068 interactions, commonalities and 17136 00:13:48,068 --> 00:13:48,068 17137 00:13:48,068 --> 00:13:48,068 bonds. 17138 00:13:48,068 --> 00:13:51,208 whereas, pray, then play day I 17139 00:13:51,208 --> 00:13:51,208 s 17140 00:13:51,208 --> 00:13:52,776 a significant occasion dedicated 17141 00:13:52,776 --> 00:13:52,776 17142 00:13:52,776 --> 00:13:54,508 to encouraging godly reflectio 17143 00:13:54,508 --> 00:13:54,508 n 17144 00:13:54,508 --> 00:13:56,142 followed by joyful community 17145 00:13:56,142 --> 00:13:56,142 engagement. 17146 00:13:56,142 --> 00:13:58,756 whereas, this event promotes 17147 00:13:58,756 --> 00:14:00,424 peace, togetherness and holistic 17148 00:14:00,424 --> 00:14:00,424 17149 00:14:00,424 --> 00:14:01,125 well-being through 17150 00:14:01,125 --> 00:14:02,586 christ-centered prayer and 17151 00:14:02,586 --> 00:14:03,894 recreational activities to bring 17152 00:14:03,894 --> 00:14:03,894 17153 00:14:03,894 --> 00:14:05,520 different people of all races, 17154 00:14:05,520 --> 00:14:05,520 17155 00:14:05,520 --> 00:14:08,156 genders and socioeconomic 17156 00:14:08,156 --> 00:14:09,621 statuses to one accord. 17157 00:14:09,621 --> 00:14:11,222 whereas the observance of pray 17158 00:14:11,222 --> 00:14:11,222 17159 00:14:11,222 --> 00:14:12,965 then play day serves as a 17160 00:14:12,965 --> 00:14:14,971 purposeful opportunity for 17161 00:14:14,971 --> 00:14:16,466 individual families to connect 17162 00:14:16,466 --> 00:14:16,466 17163 00:14:16,466 --> 00:14:17,702 and celebrate their shared 17164 00:14:17,702 --> 00:14:20,206 values, beliefs and ideologies. 17165 00:14:20,206 --> 00:14:20,206 17166 00:14:20,206 --> 00:14:22,272 I harvey l. Ward jr. By the 17167 00:14:22,272 --> 00:14:25,688 authority vested in me as the 17168 00:14:25,688 --> 00:14:28,210 mayor of city of gainesville, 17169 00:14:28,210 --> 00:14:29,948 florida as pray then play day 17170 00:14:29,948 --> 00:14:31,929 and invite all our neighbors t 17171 00:14:31,929 --> 00:14:31,929 o 17172 00:14:31,929 --> 00:14:34,090 join me in recognizing this 17173 00:14:34,090 --> 00:14:34,848 special day. 17174 00:14:34,848 --> 00:14:36,824 I have where unto set my hand 17175 00:14:36,824 --> 00:14:40,222 and cause to be affixed this t 17176 00:14:40,222 --> 00:14:40,222 he 17177 00:14:40,222 --> 00:14:43,351 official seal of the city of 17178 00:14:43,351 --> 00:14:44,058 gainesville, florida, the 11th 17179 00:14:44,058 --> 00:14:44,058 17180 00:14:44,058 --> 00:14:45,566 day of march, 2026. 17181 00:14:45,566 --> 00:14:49,195 set that aside. 17182 00:14:49,195 --> 00:14:52,268 >> mr. Mayor, we have 2026-200. 17183 00:14:52,268 --> 00:14:52,268 17184 00:14:52,268 --> 00:14:54,870 spring migration season. 17185 00:14:54,870 --> 00:14:55,568 >> mayor: all right. 17186 00:14:55,568 --> 00:14:56,634 who's got this one? 17187 00:14:56,634 --> 00:15:09,937 come on up. 17188 00:15:09,937 --> 00:15:16,228 whereas each spring, millions o 17189 00:15:16,228 --> 00:15:16,228 f 17190 00:15:16,228 --> 00:15:18,534 migratory birds travel thousan 17191 00:15:18,534 --> 00:15:18,534 ds 17192 00:15:18,534 --> 00:15:20,266 of miles publish flashes of 17193 00:15:20,266 --> 00:15:21,702 color and song through 17194 00:15:21,702 --> 00:15:23,238 gainesville as they journey 17195 00:15:23,238 --> 00:15:24,333 between wintering and breeding 17196 00:15:24,333 --> 00:15:24,333 17197 00:15:24,333 --> 00:15:24,333 grounds. 17198 00:15:24,333 --> 00:15:27,408 whereas gainesville's birding 17199 00:15:27,408 --> 00:15:29,642 community and parks, forests a 17200 00:15:29,642 --> 00:15:29,642 nd 17201 00:15:29,642 --> 00:15:32,550 wetlands make palm point, 17202 00:15:32,550 --> 00:15:35,624 sweetwater park and l loblolly 17203 00:15:35,624 --> 00:15:35,624 17204 00:15:35,624 --> 00:15:37,411 among some of the best birding 17205 00:15:37,411 --> 00:15:37,411 17206 00:15:37,411 --> 00:15:38,353 locations in florida. 17207 00:15:38,353 --> 00:15:41,004 whereas, an observant may catch 17208 00:15:41,004 --> 00:15:41,004 17209 00:15:41,004 --> 00:15:50,095 the yellow of a prothontory, t 17210 00:15:50,095 --> 00:15:50,095 he 17211 00:15:50,095 --> 00:15:56,004 inindigo bunting or standigger 17212 00:15:56,004 --> 00:15:56,766 as 17213 00:15:56,766 --> 00:15:58,102 they because in trees and 17214 00:15:58,102 --> 00:15:58,102 wetlands. 17215 00:15:58,102 --> 00:16:00,974 students and nature lovers 17216 00:16:00,974 --> 00:16:01,808 throughout gainesville celebrate 17217 00:16:01,808 --> 00:16:01,808 17218 00:16:01,808 --> 00:16:04,342 the fleeting season stepping 17219 00:16:04,342 --> 00:16:05,642 outdoors to listen for bird 17220 00:16:05,642 --> 00:16:07,048 association arn watch the tree 17221 00:16:07,048 --> 00:16:07,048 17222 00:16:07,048 --> 00:16:08,950 tops for passing migrants. 17223 00:16:08,950 --> 00:16:12,618 whereas, as a city known for 17224 00:16:12,618 --> 00:16:14,330 welcoming new neighbors around 17225 00:16:14,330 --> 00:16:14,330 17226 00:16:14,330 --> 00:16:15,092 the world, gainesville also 17227 00:16:15,092 --> 00:16:16,686 welcomes the arrival of these 17228 00:16:16,686 --> 00:16:18,097 seasonal migrants who briefly 17229 00:16:18,097 --> 00:16:19,426 call our parks, wetlands and 17230 00:16:19,426 --> 00:16:21,422 forests home each spring. 17231 00:16:21,422 --> 00:16:23,390 therefore, I harvey l. Ward jr. 17232 00:16:23,390 --> 00:16:24,803 y the authority vested in me a 17233 00:16:24,803 --> 00:16:24,803 s 17234 00:16:24,803 --> 00:16:26,822 mayor of the city of gainesville 17235 00:16:26,822 --> 00:16:26,822 17236 00:16:26,822 --> 00:16:29,169 hereby appoint march 15 through 17237 00:16:29,169 --> 00:16:29,169 17238 00:16:29,169 --> 00:16:31,731 april 15, 2026 as spring 17239 00:16:31,731 --> 00:16:32,564 migration season in the city of 17240 00:16:32,564 --> 00:16:32,564 17241 00:16:32,564 --> 00:16:33,773 gainesville and invite all our 17242 00:16:33,773 --> 00:16:33,773 17243 00:16:33,773 --> 00:16:36,406 neighbors to inveto me in 17244 00:16:36,406 --> 00:16:37,407 stepping outside and watching 17245 00:16:37,407 --> 00:16:39,171 for the flashes of red, yellow, 17246 00:16:39,171 --> 00:16:39,171 17247 00:16:39,171 --> 00:16:41,349 blue and black that mark this 17248 00:16:41,349 --> 00:16:43,088 remarkable season of migration. 17249 00:16:43,088 --> 00:16:43,088 17250 00:16:43,088 --> 00:16:44,649 I have hereunto set my hand and 17251 00:16:44,649 --> 00:16:44,649 17252 00:16:44,649 --> 00:16:49,119 cause to be affixed the officia 17253 00:16:49,119 --> 00:16:49,119 l 17254 00:16:49,119 --> 00:16:52,723 seal of the city of gainesville 17255 00:16:52,723 --> 00:16:52,723 , 17256 00:16:52,723 --> 00:16:52,723 florida. 17257 00:16:52,723 --> 00:16:54,122 if you want to say a few words 17258 00:16:54,122 --> 00:16:54,122 . 17259 00:16:54,122 --> 00:16:55,052 >> thank you,mayor, 17260 00:16:55,052 --> 00:16:55,994 commissioner, for recognizing 17261 00:16:55,994 --> 00:16:57,428 birds and nature and 17262 00:16:57,428 --> 00:17:01,898 conservation here in alachua g 17263 00:17:01,898 --> 00:17:01,898 ainesville. 17264 00:17:01,898 --> 00:17:04,058 we are so lucky to have so man 17265 00:17:04,058 --> 00:17:04,058 y 17266 00:17:04,058 --> 00:17:05,154 preserves, so many parks 17267 00:17:05,154 --> 00:17:07,068 throughout the area. 17268 00:17:07,068 --> 00:17:09,339 and it's really drawn attention 17269 00:17:09,339 --> 00:17:09,339 17270 00:17:09,339 --> 00:17:10,304 to the value that we place in 17271 00:17:10,304 --> 00:17:12,410 nature here in this community. 17272 00:17:12,410 --> 00:17:12,410 17273 00:17:12,410 --> 00:17:14,274 I want to give a shout-out to 17274 00:17:14,274 --> 00:17:17,985 sweetwater wetlands park and t 17275 00:17:17,985 --> 00:17:17,985 he 17276 00:17:17,985 --> 00:17:18,844 wonderful habitat that it 17277 00:17:18,844 --> 00:17:21,682 provides to wildlife, but also 17278 00:17:21,682 --> 00:17:21,919 a 17279 00:17:21,919 --> 00:17:25,189 great venue for environmental 17280 00:17:25,189 --> 00:17:27,728 education and passive 17281 00:17:27,728 --> 00:17:27,728 recreation. 17282 00:17:27,728 --> 00:17:29,970 and your may be surprised to 17283 00:17:29,970 --> 00:17:32,966 know that sweetwater just in I 17284 00:17:32,966 --> 00:17:32,966 ts 17285 00:17:32,966 --> 00:17:34,434 short 10 years being open to t 17286 00:17:34,434 --> 00:17:34,434 he 17287 00:17:34,434 --> 00:17:36,127 public has risen to the very t 17288 00:17:36,127 --> 00:17:36,127 op 17289 00:17:36,127 --> 00:17:39,634 in popularity of birding hot 17290 00:17:39,634 --> 00:17:41,242 spots in the state of florida. 17291 00:17:41,242 --> 00:17:41,242 17292 00:17:41,242 --> 00:17:44,284 out of over 5,000 it's in the 17293 00:17:44,284 --> 00:17:46,444 top 10 now which is phenomenal. 17294 00:17:46,444 --> 00:17:46,444 17295 00:17:46,444 --> 00:17:47,542 something even more phenomenal 17296 00:17:47,542 --> 00:17:47,542 17297 00:17:47,542 --> 00:17:50,043 about sweetwater, last year the 17298 00:17:50,043 --> 00:17:50,043 17299 00:17:50,043 --> 00:17:52,042 bird conservancy just added 17300 00:17:52,042 --> 00:17:53,493 sweetwater to its list of the 17301 00:17:53,493 --> 00:17:55,955 top 15 most recommended birding 17302 00:17:55,955 --> 00:17:55,955 17303 00:17:55,955 --> 00:17:58,483 places to go in the entire 17304 00:17:58,483 --> 00:17:59,560 united states. 17305 00:17:59,560 --> 00:18:00,569 so that's amazing. 17306 00:18:00,569 --> 00:18:02,674 and so what that translates int 17307 00:18:02,674 --> 00:18:02,674 o 17308 00:18:02,674 --> 00:18:04,401 is it shows that gainesville, 17309 00:18:04,401 --> 00:18:06,068 alachua county is a place where 17310 00:18:06,068 --> 00:18:06,068 17311 00:18:06,068 --> 00:18:08,338 we value our nature, where we 17312 00:18:08,338 --> 00:18:09,399 value conservation and wildlif 17313 00:18:09,399 --> 00:18:09,399 e 17314 00:18:09,399 --> 00:18:12,570 and it also translates into an 17315 00:18:12,570 --> 00:18:12,570 17316 00:18:12,570 --> 00:18:14,671 untold amount of ecotourism 17317 00:18:14,671 --> 00:18:16,080 dollars for the things that we 17318 00:18:16,080 --> 00:18:16,080 17319 00:18:16,080 --> 00:18:16,080 value. 17320 00:18:16,080 --> 00:18:18,711 so thank you very much for thi 17321 00:18:18,711 --> 00:18:18,711 s. 17322 00:18:18,711 --> 00:18:33,154 >> mayor: thank you. 17323 00:18:33,154 --> 00:18:50,141 >> mr. Mayor, we are on to 17324 00:18:50,141 --> 00:18:53,574 2026-201, national public heal 17325 00:18:53,574 --> 00:18:53,574 th 17326 00:18:53,574 --> 00:19:03,246 week -- 17327 00:19:03,246 --> 00:19:03,246 [inaudible] 17328 00:19:03,246 --> 00:19:06,504 >> mayor: all right. 17329 00:19:06,504 --> 00:19:08,161 this is national public health 17330 00:19:08,161 --> 00:19:08,161 17331 00:19:08,161 --> 00:19:08,161 week. 17332 00:19:08,161 --> 00:19:27,715 pwhereas the week of april 6th 17333 00:19:27,715 --> 00:19:27,715 , 17334 00:19:27,715 --> 00:19:28,777 2026 is national public health 17335 00:19:28,777 --> 00:19:28,777 17336 00:19:28,777 --> 00:19:30,219 week and the theme is ready, 17337 00:19:30,219 --> 00:19:31,446 set, action. 17338 00:19:31,446 --> 00:19:32,972 highlighting that public health 17339 00:19:32,972 --> 00:19:32,972 17340 00:19:32,972 --> 00:19:34,319 actions occurring through 17341 00:19:34,319 --> 00:19:35,817 scientific conferees, 17342 00:19:35,817 --> 00:19:37,261 legislation and community 17343 00:19:37,261 --> 00:19:39,218 initiatives have significantly 17344 00:19:39,218 --> 00:19:39,218 17345 00:19:39,218 --> 00:19:40,890 improved the health of all 17346 00:19:40,890 --> 00:19:43,628 americans since its inception I 17347 00:19:43,628 --> 00:19:43,628 n 17348 00:19:43,628 --> 00:19:43,628 1994. 17349 00:19:43,628 --> 00:19:46,229 and whereas, racial and ethnic 17350 00:19:46,229 --> 00:19:46,229 17351 00:19:46,229 --> 00:19:47,273 minority populations of the 17352 00:19:47,273 --> 00:19:48,336 united states continue to 17353 00:19:48,336 --> 00:19:50,038 experience disparities in the 17354 00:19:50,038 --> 00:19:51,673 burden of illness and deaths a 17355 00:19:51,673 --> 00:19:51,673 s 17356 00:19:51,673 --> 00:19:52,603 compared with the entire 17357 00:19:52,603 --> 00:19:54,940 population of the united states 17358 00:19:54,940 --> 00:19:54,940 . 17359 00:19:54,940 --> 00:19:56,401 and whereas, a person's health 17360 00:19:56,401 --> 00:19:56,401 17361 00:19:56,401 --> 00:19:58,949 status can differ drastically b 17362 00:19:58,949 --> 00:19:58,949 y 17363 00:19:58,949 --> 00:20:00,443 zip code due to differences in 17364 00:20:00,443 --> 00:20:00,443 17365 00:20:00,443 --> 00:20:02,118 environment quality, community 17366 00:20:02,118 --> 00:20:02,118 17367 00:20:02,118 --> 00:20:04,081 context, access to healthy foo 17368 00:20:04,081 --> 00:20:04,081 d, 17369 00:20:04,081 --> 00:20:05,714 access to education, and acces 17370 00:20:05,714 --> 00:20:05,714 s 17371 00:20:05,714 --> 00:20:07,061 to healthcare. 17372 00:20:07,061 --> 00:20:08,457 and whereas, efforts to 17373 00:20:08,457 --> 00:20:10,121 adequately support public 17374 00:20:10,121 --> 00:20:10,921 health, the prevention of 17375 00:20:10,921 --> 00:20:13,863 disease and the injury continue 17376 00:20:13,863 --> 00:20:13,863 17377 00:20:13,863 --> 00:20:15,330 to transform a health system 17378 00:20:15,330 --> 00:20:17,124 focused on treating illness and 17379 00:20:17,124 --> 00:20:17,124 17380 00:20:17,124 --> 00:20:19,343 to a health system focused on 17381 00:20:19,343 --> 00:20:21,554 preventing disease, injury and 17382 00:20:21,554 --> 00:20:21,554 17383 00:20:21,554 --> 00:20:23,596 promoting wellness. 17384 00:20:23,596 --> 00:20:25,773 therefore, I harvey l. Ward jr. 17385 00:20:25,773 --> 00:20:25,773 17386 00:20:25,773 --> 00:20:26,847 as mayor of the city of 17387 00:20:26,847 --> 00:20:28,504 gainesville proclaim april 6th 17388 00:20:28,504 --> 00:20:28,504 17389 00:20:28,504 --> 00:20:29,907 through 12th at national 17390 00:20:29,907 --> 00:20:31,007 public health week in the city 17391 00:20:31,007 --> 00:20:31,007 17392 00:20:31,007 --> 00:20:31,812 of gainesville and invite all 17393 00:20:31,812 --> 00:20:33,448 our neighbors to join me in 17394 00:20:33,448 --> 00:20:34,744 observing this week by helping 17395 00:20:34,744 --> 00:20:34,744 17396 00:20:34,744 --> 00:20:36,709 our families, friends, neighbo 17397 00:20:36,709 --> 00:20:36,709 rs 17398 00:20:36,709 --> 00:20:39,488 and co-workers and leaders to 17399 00:20:39,488 --> 00:20:42,115 recognize the contribution of 17400 00:20:42,115 --> 00:20:44,049 scientists, loyal city and 17401 00:20:44,049 --> 00:20:45,121 community activists including 17402 00:20:45,121 --> 00:20:46,455 the public health workers as t 17403 00:20:46,455 --> 00:20:46,455 he 17404 00:20:46,455 --> 00:20:48,762 theme states ready, set, actio 17405 00:20:48,762 --> 00:20:48,762 n. 17406 00:20:48,762 --> 00:20:51,194 in witness whereafter I have 17407 00:20:51,194 --> 00:20:54,531 here unto caused to be affixed 17408 00:20:54,531 --> 00:20:54,531 17409 00:20:54,531 --> 00:20:57,397 the official seal of the city 17410 00:20:57,397 --> 00:20:57,397 of 17411 00:20:57,397 --> 00:21:00,933 gainesville, florida. 17412 00:21:00,933 --> 00:21:11,079 >> on behalf of the beta for 17413 00:21:11,079 --> 00:21:13,318 recognizing public health and 17414 00:21:13,318 --> 00:21:16,551 what it has on our communities 17415 00:21:16,551 --> 00:21:16,551 . 17416 00:21:16,551 --> 00:21:19,220 and thank you for proclaiming 17417 00:21:19,220 --> 00:21:20,828 national public health week. 17418 00:21:20,828 --> 00:21:34,545 thank you. 17419 00:21:34,545 --> 00:21:42,409 >> mr. Mayor, we have 2026-204. 17420 00:21:42,409 --> 00:21:42,409 17421 00:21:42,409 --> 00:21:44,811 s landscape architecture 17422 00:21:44,811 --> 00:21:44,811 month. 17423 00:21:44,811 --> 00:21:46,518 >> mayor: all right. 17424 00:21:46,518 --> 00:21:52,953 who's got this wurp? 17425 00:21:52,953 --> 00:21:54,589 whereas landscape architecture 17426 00:21:54,589 --> 00:21:54,589 17427 00:21:54,589 --> 00:21:56,006 encompasses the analysis, 17428 00:21:56,006 --> 00:21:58,526 planning, design and stewardship 17429 00:21:58,526 --> 00:21:58,526 17430 00:21:58,526 --> 00:21:59,857 of the natural and built 17431 00:21:59,857 --> 00:22:01,191 environment, translating visio 17432 00:22:01,191 --> 00:22:01,191 n 17433 00:22:01,191 --> 00:22:03,029 into action to shape places that 17434 00:22:03,029 --> 00:22:03,029 17435 00:22:03,029 --> 00:22:05,655 are healthy, safe and resilient 17436 00:22:05,655 --> 00:22:05,655 . 17437 00:22:05,655 --> 00:22:06,549 landscape architecture is a 17438 00:22:06,549 --> 00:22:08,553 regulated profession in all 50 17439 00:22:08,553 --> 00:22:08,553 17440 00:22:08,553 --> 00:22:09,570 states and the department of 17441 00:22:09,570 --> 00:22:10,675 business and professional 17442 00:22:10,675 --> 00:22:11,975 regulation ensures the highest 17443 00:22:11,975 --> 00:22:11,975 17444 00:22:11,975 --> 00:22:14,808 standards of professional 17445 00:22:14,808 --> 00:22:16,046 competence through education, 17446 00:22:16,046 --> 00:22:17,877 experience and examination 17447 00:22:17,877 --> 00:22:17,877 requirements. 17448 00:22:17,877 --> 00:22:20,180 whereas, during april, landsca 17449 00:22:20,180 --> 00:22:20,180 pe 17450 00:22:20,180 --> 00:22:21,387 architecture month is celebrated 17451 00:22:21,387 --> 00:22:21,387 17452 00:22:21,387 --> 00:22:23,469 under the theme landscape 17453 00:22:23,469 --> 00:22:25,558 architecture in action, where w 17454 00:22:25,558 --> 00:22:25,558 e 17455 00:22:25,558 --> 00:22:27,433 recognize the tangible impact 17456 00:22:27,433 --> 00:22:30,459 this has on parks, streetscape 17457 00:22:30,459 --> 00:22:30,459 s, 17458 00:22:30,459 --> 00:22:32,227 campuses across urban, suburba 17459 00:22:32,227 --> 00:22:32,227 n 17460 00:22:32,227 --> 00:22:33,329 and rural communities. 17461 00:22:33,329 --> 00:22:35,601 and whereas, the license to 17462 00:22:35,601 --> 00:22:37,427 practice landscape architecture 17463 00:22:37,427 --> 00:22:37,427 17464 00:22:37,427 --> 00:22:39,336 is a critical safeguard for 17465 00:22:39,336 --> 00:22:40,662 public health, safety and 17466 00:22:40,662 --> 00:22:44,810 welfare ensuring outdoor 17467 00:22:44,810 --> 00:22:48,544 environments are designed with 17468 00:22:48,544 --> 00:22:48,544 17469 00:22:48,544 --> 00:22:50,281 technical rigor and ethical 17470 00:22:50,281 --> 00:22:50,281 responsibility. 17471 00:22:50,281 --> 00:22:53,395 whereas landscape architects a 17472 00:22:53,395 --> 00:22:53,395 re 17473 00:22:53,395 --> 00:22:57,011 nuniquely qualified through 17474 00:22:57,011 --> 00:22:58,293 resilient green infrastructure 17475 00:22:58,293 --> 00:22:58,293 17476 00:22:58,293 --> 00:23:00,495 design strategies that restore 17477 00:23:00,495 --> 00:23:00,495 17478 00:23:00,495 --> 00:23:02,163 ecosystems and mitigate 17479 00:23:02,163 --> 00:23:03,688 environmental hazards and 17480 00:23:03,688 --> 00:23:05,271 decrease the long-term disaste 17481 00:23:05,271 --> 00:23:05,271 r 17482 00:23:05,271 --> 00:23:06,871 recovery on state and local 17483 00:23:06,871 --> 00:23:06,871 governments. 17484 00:23:06,871 --> 00:23:08,630 whereas the economy of the city 17485 00:23:08,630 --> 00:23:08,630 17486 00:23:08,630 --> 00:23:10,205 of gainesville is strengthened 17487 00:23:10,205 --> 00:23:10,205 17488 00:23:10,205 --> 00:23:11,577 by the work of these landscape 17489 00:23:11,577 --> 00:23:11,577 17490 00:23:11,577 --> 00:23:14,969 architects and the accredited a 17491 00:23:14,969 --> 00:23:14,969 t 17492 00:23:14,969 --> 00:23:16,536 florida international universit 17493 00:23:16,536 --> 00:23:16,536 y 17494 00:23:16,536 --> 00:23:17,193 and the university of florida 17495 00:23:17,193 --> 00:23:18,907 who together foster tourism, 17496 00:23:18,907 --> 00:23:19,874 economic development and 17497 00:23:19,874 --> 00:23:20,637 environmental protection. 17498 00:23:20,637 --> 00:23:23,854 I harvey l. Ward jr. As 17499 00:23:23,854 --> 00:23:30,100 authority of the mayor of 17500 00:23:30,100 --> 00:23:30,964 gainesville, florida and invite 17501 00:23:30,964 --> 00:23:30,964 17502 00:23:30,964 --> 00:23:32,821 all our neighbors to join me I 17503 00:23:32,821 --> 00:23:32,821 n 17504 00:23:32,821 --> 00:23:33,765 celebrating landscape 17505 00:23:33,765 --> 00:23:35,280 architecture in action and the 17506 00:23:35,280 --> 00:23:35,280 17507 00:23:35,280 --> 00:23:39,027 essential role landscape architects 17508 00:23:39,027 --> 00:23:39,651 architects play in the shaping 17509 00:23:39,651 --> 00:23:39,651 17510 00:23:39,651 --> 00:23:41,029 of resilient, safe environment 17511 00:23:41,029 --> 00:23:41,029 s. 17512 00:23:41,029 --> 00:23:42,963 I have hereunto set my hand and 17513 00:23:42,963 --> 00:23:42,963 17514 00:23:42,963 --> 00:23:44,401 caused to be affixed the 17515 00:23:44,401 --> 00:23:46,808 official seal of gainesville, 17516 00:23:46,808 --> 00:23:47,675 florida this 26th day of 17517 00:23:47,675 --> 00:23:50,734 march, 2026, harvey ward jr., 17518 00:23:50,734 --> 00:23:50,734 mayor. 17519 00:23:50,734 --> 00:23:50,734 welcome. 17520 00:23:50,734 --> 00:23:54,144 >> you're all set. 17521 00:23:54,144 --> 00:23:56,663 if you want to hand those to 17522 00:23:56,663 --> 00:23:56,663 francisco. 17523 00:23:56,663 --> 00:24:01,887 >> mayor: I'll do that. 17524 00:24:01,887 --> 00:24:03,217 >> we'll make sure those get 17525 00:24:03,217 --> 00:24:11,757 where they need to go. 17526 00:24:11,757 --> 00:24:14,157 next mr. Mayor is the early 17527 00:24:14,157 --> 00:24:14,735 public comment. 17528 00:24:14,735 --> 00:24:15,943 and I don't believe -- no, we 17529 00:24:15,943 --> 00:24:15,943 do 17530 00:24:15,943 --> 00:24:17,231 not have anyone signed up for 17531 00:24:17,231 --> 00:24:19,027 early public comment. 17532 00:24:19,027 --> 00:24:21,479 so we are going to go on to our 17533 00:24:21,479 --> 00:24:21,479 17534 00:24:21,479 --> 00:24:23,273 first discussion item -- I'm 17535 00:24:23,273 --> 00:24:25,877 sorry, not discussion item, the 17536 00:24:25,877 --> 00:24:25,877 17537 00:24:25,877 --> 00:24:28,719 ordinance for the evening. 17538 00:24:28,719 --> 00:24:30,683 we have ordinance number 17539 00:24:30,683 --> 00:24:33,134 2025-998, an ordinance of the 17540 00:24:33,134 --> 00:24:33,679 city of gainesville, florida 17541 00:24:33,679 --> 00:24:35,623 amending the future land use m 17542 00:24:35,623 --> 00:24:35,623 ap 17543 00:24:35,623 --> 00:24:36,533 of the comprehensive plan by 17544 00:24:36,533 --> 00:24:37,887 changing the land use category 17545 00:24:37,887 --> 00:24:37,887 17546 00:24:37,887 --> 00:24:40,657 of approximately .64 acres of 17547 00:24:40,657 --> 00:24:42,626 property generally located at 17548 00:24:42,626 --> 00:24:45,031 the 800 block of east universit 17549 00:24:45,031 --> 00:24:45,031 y 17550 00:24:45,031 --> 00:24:46,459 avenue as more specifically 17551 00:24:46,459 --> 00:24:48,132 described in this ordinance fro 17552 00:24:48,132 --> 00:24:48,132 m 17553 00:24:48,132 --> 00:24:50,626 planned use district and mixed 17554 00:24:50,626 --> 00:24:50,626 17555 00:24:50,626 --> 00:24:53,269 use low intensity to mixed use 17556 00:24:53,269 --> 00:24:53,269 17557 00:24:53,269 --> 00:24:54,875 office residential, providing 17558 00:24:54,875 --> 00:24:56,071 directions to the city manager, 17559 00:24:56,071 --> 00:24:56,071 17560 00:24:56,071 --> 00:24:58,076 providing severability clause, 17561 00:24:58,076 --> 00:24:58,076 17562 00:24:58,076 --> 00:24:59,549 providing repealing clause and 17563 00:24:59,549 --> 00:24:59,549 17564 00:24:59,549 --> 00:25:02,880 providing an effective date. 17565 00:25:02,880 --> 00:25:03,526 >> mayor: very good. 17566 00:25:03,526 --> 00:25:06,283 thank you for your patience. 17567 00:25:06,283 --> 00:25:07,231 >> good evening, mr. Mayor and 17568 00:25:07,231 --> 00:25:07,231 17569 00:25:07,231 --> 00:25:07,231 commission. 17570 00:25:07,231 --> 00:25:14,279 my name is ari rabbinvich, thi 17571 00:25:14,279 --> 00:25:14,279 s 17572 00:25:14,279 --> 00:25:16,703 is the 800 block east universit 17573 00:25:16,703 --> 00:25:16,703 y 17574 00:25:16,703 --> 00:25:22,613 project item ld25-000143. 17575 00:25:22,613 --> 00:25:30,004 so the parcel seen here located 17576 00:25:30,004 --> 00:25:33,017 n the 800 block of east 17577 00:25:33,017 --> 00:25:35,735 university avenue, the current 17578 00:25:35,735 --> 00:25:35,735 17579 00:25:35,735 --> 00:25:37,683 land use designation is planned 17580 00:25:37,683 --> 00:25:37,683 17581 00:25:37,683 --> 00:25:39,983 use district and mixed use low 17582 00:25:39,983 --> 00:25:39,983 17583 00:25:39,983 --> 00:25:41,387 intensity with a proposed 17584 00:25:41,387 --> 00:25:43,021 designation of mixed use offic 17585 00:25:43,021 --> 00:25:43,021 e 17586 00:25:43,021 --> 00:25:43,021 residential. 17587 00:25:43,021 --> 00:25:45,990 the planned use district land 17588 00:25:45,990 --> 00:25:49,353 use designation corresponded t 17589 00:25:49,353 --> 00:25:49,353 o 17590 00:25:49,353 --> 00:25:51,055 planned ordinance which existed 17591 00:25:51,055 --> 00:25:51,055 17592 00:25:51,055 --> 00:25:52,692 to enable the restoration and 17593 00:25:52,692 --> 00:25:54,323 rehabilitation of the former b 17594 00:25:54,323 --> 00:25:54,323 ed 17595 00:25:54,323 --> 00:25:55,397 and breakfast use that was at 17596 00:25:55,397 --> 00:25:57,033 the property and allowed for 17597 00:25:57,033 --> 00:25:58,805 uses that were consistent with 17598 00:25:58,805 --> 00:25:58,805 17599 00:25:58,805 --> 00:26:02,573 those enabled by the former 02 17600 00:26:02,573 --> 00:26:02,573 17601 00:26:02,573 --> 00:26:03,534 general office zoning 17602 00:26:03,534 --> 00:26:03,534 designation. 17603 00:26:03,534 --> 00:26:08,107 the requested designation ofmor 17604 00:26:08,107 --> 00:26:10,813 e of mor 17605 00:26:10,813 --> 00:26:11,915 would establish a range of 17606 00:26:11,915 --> 00:26:14,317 allowable uses and development 17607 00:26:14,317 --> 00:26:14,317 17608 00:26:14,317 --> 00:26:15,210 consistent with the surrounding 17609 00:26:15,210 --> 00:26:15,210 17610 00:26:15,210 --> 00:26:17,059 area which is a mix of uses 17611 00:26:17,059 --> 00:26:19,323 including offices, residences, 17612 00:26:19,323 --> 00:26:19,323 17613 00:26:19,323 --> 00:26:20,864 retail, commercial and civic 17614 00:26:20,864 --> 00:26:20,864 uses. 17615 00:26:20,864 --> 00:26:25,256 so here's a map just showing t 17616 00:26:25,256 --> 00:26:25,256 he 17617 00:26:25,256 --> 00:26:27,561 current land uses for the 17618 00:26:27,561 --> 00:26:28,577 subject parcel as compared to 17619 00:26:28,577 --> 00:26:30,263 the surrounding area. 17620 00:26:30,263 --> 00:26:36,167 you see largely mor. 17621 00:26:36,167 --> 00:26:38,045 versus the proposed land use a 17622 00:26:38,045 --> 00:26:38,045 s 17623 00:26:38,045 --> 00:26:40,245 requested under the application 17624 00:26:40,245 --> 00:26:40,245 . 17625 00:26:40,245 --> 00:26:43,851 so looking at the surrounding 17626 00:26:43,851 --> 00:26:46,145 uses and land use designations 17627 00:26:46,145 --> 00:26:46,145 17628 00:26:46,145 --> 00:26:48,301 for the parcels nearby, you can 17629 00:26:48,301 --> 00:26:48,301 17630 00:26:48,301 --> 00:26:51,086 see that the majority of the -- 17631 00:26:51,086 --> 00:26:51,086 17632 00:26:51,086 --> 00:26:53,121 or all of the abutting parcels 17633 00:26:53,121 --> 00:26:53,121 17634 00:26:53,121 --> 00:26:56,095 are designated mixed use offic 17635 00:26:56,095 --> 00:26:56,095 e 17636 00:26:56,095 --> 00:26:58,835 residential with existing uses 17637 00:26:58,835 --> 00:26:58,835 17638 00:26:58,835 --> 00:26:59,815 that are primarily residential 17639 00:26:59,815 --> 00:26:59,815 17640 00:26:59,815 --> 00:27:00,934 and multi-family and 17641 00:27:00,934 --> 00:27:00,934 single-family. 17642 00:27:00,934 --> 00:27:08,671 and so here is an image that 17643 00:27:08,671 --> 00:27:11,607 illustrates what the area looks 17644 00:27:11,607 --> 00:27:11,607 17645 00:27:11,607 --> 00:27:11,607 like. 17646 00:27:11,607 --> 00:27:14,219 it's a total of approximately 73 17647 00:27:14,219 --> 00:27:16,115 acres of land designated mor 17648 00:27:16,115 --> 00:27:19,183 in this area before you hit 17649 00:27:19,183 --> 00:27:24,655 waldo road to the east. 17650 00:27:24,655 --> 00:27:28,051 so this is a property that is 17651 00:27:28,051 --> 00:27:30,031 within an historic district. 17652 00:27:30,031 --> 00:27:33,110 the designation pud existed to 17653 00:27:33,110 --> 00:27:33,110 17654 00:27:33,110 --> 00:27:39,303 restore a former bed & 17655 00:27:39,303 --> 00:27:39,303 breakfast. 17656 00:27:39,303 --> 00:27:42,602 today it lies in the southeast 17657 00:27:42,602 --> 00:27:42,602 17658 00:27:42,602 --> 00:27:44,041 district and has one 17659 00:27:44,041 --> 00:27:45,243 contributing historic 17660 00:27:45,243 --> 00:27:46,443 distributing which is the 17661 00:27:46,443 --> 00:27:47,342 mccreary house. 17662 00:27:47,342 --> 00:27:48,979 the allowable uses per the pd 17663 00:27:48,979 --> 00:27:50,751 were those that were consistent 17664 00:27:50,751 --> 00:27:50,751 17665 00:27:50,751 --> 00:27:54,335 with the former 02 general 17666 00:27:54,335 --> 00:27:55,657 designation with factors like 17667 00:27:55,657 --> 00:27:56,755 setbacks and parking determine 17668 00:27:56,755 --> 00:27:56,755 d 17669 00:27:56,755 --> 00:27:58,253 by the requirements of that 17670 00:27:58,253 --> 00:28:04,827 former use category. 17671 00:28:04,827 --> 00:28:07,979 so regarding historic 17672 00:28:07,979 --> 00:28:09,275 preservation, the historic 17673 00:28:09,275 --> 00:28:09,891 preservation officer has 17674 00:28:09,891 --> 00:28:10,733 provided some comments on this 17675 00:28:10,733 --> 00:28:10,733 17676 00:28:10,733 --> 00:28:10,733 project. 17677 00:28:10,733 --> 00:28:13,037 she left the comment that land 17678 00:28:13,037 --> 00:28:13,037 17679 00:28:13,037 --> 00:28:14,567 uses which would allow for 17680 00:28:14,567 --> 00:28:15,971 additional infill that adds to 17681 00:28:15,971 --> 00:28:15,971 17682 00:28:15,971 --> 00:28:17,304 the character of the district I 17683 00:28:17,304 --> 00:28:17,304 s 17684 00:28:17,304 --> 00:28:17,304 appropriate. 17685 00:28:17,304 --> 00:28:19,941 additionally, any new 17686 00:28:19,941 --> 00:28:21,575 development that would occur 17687 00:28:21,575 --> 00:28:23,445 within any historic district 17688 00:28:23,445 --> 00:28:24,615 would be subject to review for 17689 00:28:24,615 --> 00:28:24,615 17690 00:28:24,615 --> 00:28:26,918 certificates of appropriateness 17691 00:28:26,918 --> 00:28:26,918 17692 00:28:26,918 --> 00:28:28,049 per land development code 17693 00:28:28,049 --> 00:28:34,153 section 30-4.28 which regulate 17694 00:28:34,153 --> 00:28:34,153 17695 00:28:34,153 --> 00:28:35,965 design and the subject 17696 00:28:35,965 --> 00:28:37,760 properties in the surrounding 17697 00:28:37,760 --> 00:28:37,760 area. 17698 00:28:37,760 --> 00:28:39,491 this is a land use change which 17699 00:28:39,491 --> 00:28:39,491 17700 00:28:39,491 --> 00:28:41,469 is subject to review against 17701 00:28:41,469 --> 00:28:43,235 the set of criteria defined by 17702 00:28:43,235 --> 00:28:43,235 17703 00:28:43,235 --> 00:28:44,273 the land development code. 17704 00:28:44,273 --> 00:28:45,534 we have conducted this review 17705 00:28:45,534 --> 00:28:46,939 and conclude that the criteria 17706 00:28:46,939 --> 00:28:46,939 17707 00:28:46,939 --> 00:28:48,705 of the code are met including 17708 00:28:48,705 --> 00:28:50,209 consistency with comprehensive 17709 00:28:50,209 --> 00:28:50,209 17710 00:28:50,209 --> 00:28:51,315 plan goals, policies and 17711 00:28:51,315 --> 00:28:52,873 objectives surrounding the 17712 00:28:52,873 --> 00:28:55,812 diversity of housing, retail a 17713 00:28:55,812 --> 00:28:55,812 nd 17714 00:28:55,812 --> 00:28:57,377 workplace choices encouraging a 17715 00:28:57,377 --> 00:28:57,377 17716 00:28:57,377 --> 00:28:59,981 mix of uses and discouraging 17717 00:28:59,981 --> 00:29:01,596 sprawl towards the periphery o 17718 00:29:01,596 --> 00:29:01,596 f 17719 00:29:01,596 --> 00:29:02,983 the city and compatibility with 17720 00:29:02,983 --> 00:29:02,983 17721 00:29:02,983 --> 00:29:04,125 scrownding land uses. 17722 00:29:04,125 --> 00:29:05,787 this would encourage a diverse 17723 00:29:05,787 --> 00:29:05,787 17724 00:29:05,787 --> 00:29:07,128 range ever uses consistent wit 17725 00:29:07,128 --> 00:29:07,128 h 17726 00:29:07,128 --> 00:29:08,422 what exists in the area today 17727 00:29:08,422 --> 00:29:10,457 and impacts on affordable 17728 00:29:10,457 --> 00:29:10,457 housing. 17729 00:29:10,457 --> 00:29:12,029 this project would enable 17730 00:29:12,029 --> 00:29:13,961 residential uses at the site 17731 00:29:13,961 --> 00:29:15,500 which is currently prohibited 17732 00:29:15,500 --> 00:29:17,266 under the planned development 17733 00:29:17,266 --> 00:29:18,766 and pud designation today. 17734 00:29:18,766 --> 00:29:20,637 so there may be impacts to 17735 00:29:20,637 --> 00:29:21,908 affordable housing in that thi 17736 00:29:21,908 --> 00:29:21,908 s 17737 00:29:21,908 --> 00:29:22,940 change would allow housing at 17738 00:29:22,940 --> 00:29:23,906 that site. 17739 00:29:23,906 --> 00:29:26,206 so with that, staff recommends 17740 00:29:26,206 --> 00:29:26,206 17741 00:29:26,206 --> 00:29:33,111 approval of ld25-000143. 17742 00:29:33,111 --> 00:29:35,100 we have a rezoning to follow I 17743 00:29:35,100 --> 00:29:35,100 f 17744 00:29:35,100 --> 00:29:35,714 you have any questions. 17745 00:29:35,714 --> 00:29:36,777 I don't know if the applicant I 17746 00:29:36,777 --> 00:29:36,777 s 17747 00:29:36,777 --> 00:29:39,457 here to speak on this item. 17748 00:29:39,457 --> 00:29:41,423 you can if you'd like to. 17749 00:29:41,423 --> 00:29:46,066 >> mayor: ocome on up, 17750 00:29:46,066 --> 00:29:48,737 mr. Sweger. 17751 00:29:48,737 --> 00:29:48,737 welcome. 17752 00:29:48,737 --> 00:29:49,675 >> good afternoon or evening, 17753 00:29:49,675 --> 00:29:51,070 mr. Mayor and commissioners. 17754 00:29:51,070 --> 00:29:52,701 I'm clay sweger. 17755 00:29:52,701 --> 00:29:53,909 glad to be here tonight. 17756 00:29:53,909 --> 00:29:55,433 this is a relative 17757 00:29:55,433 --> 00:29:56,399 administrative type of 17758 00:29:56,399 --> 00:29:57,405 consideration for you all 17759 00:29:57,405 --> 00:29:57,405 tonight. 17760 00:29:57,405 --> 00:30:00,688 the owners of this property 17761 00:30:00,688 --> 00:30:02,351 which includes the mccreary 17762 00:30:02,351 --> 00:30:04,715 house, one of the old victorian 17763 00:30:04,715 --> 00:30:04,715 17764 00:30:04,715 --> 00:30:06,929 homes on east university heavy 17765 00:30:06,929 --> 00:30:06,929 17766 00:30:06,929 --> 00:30:08,459 has purchased the property and 17767 00:30:08,459 --> 00:30:08,459 17768 00:30:08,459 --> 00:30:11,955 is putting significant into 17769 00:30:11,955 --> 00:30:13,301 revitalizing and bringing it 17770 00:30:13,301 --> 00:30:14,383 back to a bread of the mighty 17771 00:30:14,383 --> 00:30:15,691 which is very exciting. 17772 00:30:15,691 --> 00:30:16,995 but in the weeds on the planning 17773 00:30:16,995 --> 00:30:16,995 17774 00:30:16,995 --> 00:30:21,801 side it's an expired from the 17775 00:30:21,801 --> 00:30:23,669 1980s, that era of pds 17776 00:30:23,669 --> 00:30:26,733 doesn't have a reverter clause 17777 00:30:26,733 --> 00:30:26,733 17778 00:30:26,733 --> 00:30:29,269 so the pd expired and it doesn 17779 00:30:29,269 --> 00:30:29,269 't 17780 00:30:29,269 --> 00:30:30,737 go back to the office zoning 17781 00:30:30,737 --> 00:30:31,671 that it was before. 17782 00:30:31,671 --> 00:30:33,077 the action before you is to 17783 00:30:33,077 --> 00:30:34,509 address that issue on the land 17784 00:30:34,509 --> 00:30:34,509 17785 00:30:34,509 --> 00:30:36,811 use map to go to mor in the 17786 00:30:36,811 --> 00:30:39,653 zoning to u-4 which would allow 17787 00:30:39,653 --> 00:30:39,653 17788 00:30:39,653 --> 00:30:41,113 that bed & breakfast use. 17789 00:30:41,113 --> 00:30:42,697 but, of course, the analysis by 17790 00:30:42,697 --> 00:30:42,697 17791 00:30:42,697 --> 00:30:44,255 your staff was to consider all 17792 00:30:44,255 --> 00:30:44,255 17793 00:30:44,255 --> 00:30:46,787 uses in that area. 17794 00:30:46,787 --> 00:30:48,253 properties in essentially every 17795 00:30:48,253 --> 00:30:48,253 17796 00:30:48,253 --> 00:30:49,879 direction are u-4 for a block o 17797 00:30:49,879 --> 00:30:49,879 r 17798 00:30:49,879 --> 00:30:51,256 two, so it's very consistent 17799 00:30:51,256 --> 00:30:52,593 with the pattern. 17800 00:30:52,593 --> 00:30:54,231 this would allow that 17801 00:30:54,231 --> 00:30:56,299 revitalization of the historic 17802 00:30:56,299 --> 00:30:56,299 17803 00:30:56,299 --> 00:30:57,601 structure, which happy to say 17804 00:30:57,601 --> 00:30:58,865 that your historic preservatio 17805 00:30:58,865 --> 00:30:58,865 n 17806 00:30:58,865 --> 00:31:00,579 planner has been involved and 17807 00:31:00,579 --> 00:31:02,319 she's integral in the design a 17808 00:31:02,319 --> 00:31:02,319 nd 17809 00:31:02,319 --> 00:31:04,976 permitting of the improvements. 17810 00:31:04,976 --> 00:31:04,976 17811 00:31:04,976 --> 00:31:06,269 as you drive by there, you can 17812 00:31:06,269 --> 00:31:06,269 17813 00:31:06,269 --> 00:31:07,343 see them happening. 17814 00:31:07,343 --> 00:31:08,440 so thank you for consideration 17815 00:31:08,440 --> 00:31:08,440 17816 00:31:08,440 --> 00:31:09,053 on this. 17817 00:31:09,053 --> 00:31:10,187 if you have any questions for m 17818 00:31:10,187 --> 00:31:10,187 e 17819 00:31:10,187 --> 00:31:11,613 tonight, please let me know. 17820 00:31:11,613 --> 00:31:11,613 thank 17821 00:31:11,613 --> 00:31:13,338 >> mayor: very good. 17822 00:31:13,338 --> 00:31:15,448 thank you. 17823 00:31:15,448 --> 00:31:18,763 commissioner ingle. 17824 00:31:18,763 --> 00:31:20,385 >> so looking quickly at the 17825 00:31:20,385 --> 00:31:23,135 map, there's two old victorian 17826 00:31:23,135 --> 00:31:23,135 17827 00:31:23,135 --> 00:31:24,997 houses there, the mccreary 17828 00:31:24,997 --> 00:31:25,964 house and another one right 17829 00:31:25,964 --> 00:31:26,731 beside it. 17830 00:31:26,731 --> 00:31:27,595 >> yes, sir. 17831 00:31:27,595 --> 00:31:28,599 >> is this considering both of 17832 00:31:28,599 --> 00:31:28,599 17833 00:31:28,599 --> 00:31:28,599 those? 17834 00:31:28,599 --> 00:31:30,732 >> no, mr. Mayor. 17835 00:31:30,732 --> 00:31:32,871 it's just the one to the east. 17836 00:31:32,871 --> 00:31:32,871 17837 00:31:32,871 --> 00:31:34,313 >> okay. 17838 00:31:34,313 --> 00:31:35,077 >> the owner of the property to 17839 00:31:35,077 --> 00:31:35,077 17840 00:31:35,077 --> 00:31:36,709 the west, the other home was n 17841 00:31:36,709 --> 00:31:36,709 ot 17842 00:31:36,709 --> 00:31:38,818 interested in participating in 17843 00:31:38,818 --> 00:31:38,818 17844 00:31:38,818 --> 00:31:41,514 the application. 17845 00:31:41,514 --> 00:31:44,017 >> mayor: very good. 17846 00:31:44,017 --> 00:31:44,916 commissioner willits. 17847 00:31:44,916 --> 00:31:46,405 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 17848 00:31:46,405 --> 00:31:47,987 staff, we heard this back in 17849 00:31:47,987 --> 00:31:47,987 october. 17850 00:31:47,987 --> 00:31:49,583 is there a reason why there's 17851 00:31:49,583 --> 00:31:51,025 such a long period between fir 17852 00:31:51,025 --> 00:31:51,025 st 17853 00:31:51,025 --> 00:31:55,161 and second reading? 17854 00:31:55,161 --> 00:31:56,291 >> which item did you hear bac 17855 00:31:56,291 --> 00:31:56,291 k 17856 00:31:56,291 --> 00:31:58,357 in october? 17857 00:31:58,357 --> 00:31:59,583 >> it said we heard the petitio 17858 00:31:59,583 --> 00:31:59,583 n 17859 00:31:59,583 --> 00:32:00,680 in october. 17860 00:32:00,680 --> 00:32:03,404 is that accurate? 17861 00:32:03,404 --> 00:32:04,383 >> is this not first reading f 17862 00:32:04,383 --> 00:32:04,383 or 17863 00:32:04,383 --> 00:32:07,343 this item? 17864 00:32:07,343 --> 00:32:08,902 >> this is on for first reading 17865 00:32:08,902 --> 00:32:08,902 . 17866 00:32:08,902 --> 00:32:10,109 >> mayor: this is first reading. 17867 00:32:10,109 --> 00:32:10,109 17868 00:32:10,109 --> 00:32:11,372 >> why did I just see a chart 17869 00:32:11,372 --> 00:32:12,610 that said we had already heard 17870 00:32:12,610 --> 00:32:12,610 17871 00:32:12,610 --> 00:32:12,610 it? 17872 00:32:12,610 --> 00:32:15,780 >> that may be for the sheriff's 17873 00:32:15,780 --> 00:32:15,780 17874 00:32:15,780 --> 00:32:17,082 office rezoning that's later. 17875 00:32:17,082 --> 00:32:18,679 >> mayor: maybe. 17876 00:32:18,679 --> 00:32:19,814 >> I'm looking at the wrong one 17877 00:32:19,814 --> 00:32:19,814 . 17878 00:32:19,814 --> 00:32:27,826 no, no. 17879 00:32:27,826 --> 00:32:28,789 maybe there's a chart 17880 00:32:28,789 --> 00:32:32,854 accidentally on the historic 17881 00:32:32,854 --> 00:32:33,344 preservation one. 17882 00:32:33,344 --> 00:32:35,000 if you tell me it's not, but o 17883 00:32:35,000 --> 00:32:35,000 n 17884 00:32:35,000 --> 00:32:37,596 one of those slides it says 17885 00:32:37,596 --> 00:32:41,782 10/ 16/25. 17886 00:32:41,782 --> 00:32:42,731 >> that was an error. 17887 00:32:42,731 --> 00:32:44,815 >> in our backup, perfect. 17888 00:32:44,815 --> 00:32:46,006 we are looking at different 17889 00:32:46,006 --> 00:32:46,006 documents. 17890 00:32:46,006 --> 00:32:48,838 >> sorry about that. 17891 00:32:48,838 --> 00:32:50,212 >> I didn't think I was -- 17892 00:32:50,212 --> 00:32:51,483 that's why I was wondering. 17893 00:32:51,483 --> 00:32:52,554 but I remember we heard 17894 00:32:52,554 --> 00:32:53,459 somewhere in the back of my 17895 00:32:53,459 --> 00:32:54,588 brain, we heard something about 17896 00:32:54,588 --> 00:32:54,588 17897 00:32:54,588 --> 00:32:54,588 this. 17898 00:32:54,588 --> 00:32:57,046 but maybe there was conversatio 17899 00:32:57,046 --> 00:32:57,046 n 17900 00:32:57,046 --> 00:32:58,482 about what's going on and then 17901 00:32:58,482 --> 00:32:58,682 I 17902 00:32:58,682 --> 00:32:59,824 think staff said something is 17903 00:32:59,824 --> 00:33:00,884 coming down the pike. 17904 00:33:00,884 --> 00:33:01,851 >> that sounds like it could be 17905 00:33:01,851 --> 00:33:01,851 17906 00:33:01,851 --> 00:33:02,522 it, yeah. 17907 00:33:02,522 --> 00:33:03,128 >> perfect. 17908 00:33:03,128 --> 00:33:06,025 so is there -- but all three o 17909 00:33:06,025 --> 00:33:06,025 f 17910 00:33:06,025 --> 00:33:07,428 the -- well, not parcels, but 17911 00:33:07,428 --> 00:33:07,428 lots. 17912 00:33:07,428 --> 00:33:09,299 it's basically three lots in a 17913 00:33:09,299 --> 00:33:09,299 17914 00:33:09,299 --> 00:33:09,299 row. 17915 00:33:09,299 --> 00:33:12,370 but it's the middle and eastern 17916 00:33:12,370 --> 00:33:12,370 17917 00:33:12,370 --> 00:33:12,370 one. 17918 00:33:12,370 --> 00:33:14,184 >> right. 17919 00:33:14,184 --> 00:33:16,306 >> are we splitting up the pud 17920 00:33:16,306 --> 00:33:16,306 17921 00:33:16,306 --> 00:33:16,306 then? 17922 00:33:16,306 --> 00:33:19,146 are we leaving a remnant? 17923 00:33:19,146 --> 00:33:21,771 for the land use, that pud, is 17924 00:33:21,771 --> 00:33:21,771 17925 00:33:21,771 --> 00:33:24,310 it one pud originally that we 17926 00:33:24,310 --> 00:33:25,976 are then splitting and leaving? 17927 00:33:25,976 --> 00:33:25,976 17928 00:33:25,976 --> 00:33:29,754 >> so the pud that you're 17929 00:33:29,754 --> 00:33:31,960 referencing, I think I have som 17930 00:33:31,960 --> 00:33:31,960 e 17931 00:33:31,960 --> 00:33:32,822 images here. 17932 00:33:32,822 --> 00:33:35,662 I believe it counts for both o 17933 00:33:35,662 --> 00:33:35,662 f 17934 00:33:35,662 --> 00:33:36,994 these properties. 17935 00:33:36,994 --> 00:33:38,724 but this proposal is just to 17936 00:33:38,724 --> 00:33:43,996 apply to the lot, like you sai 17937 00:33:43,996 --> 00:33:43,996 d, 17938 00:33:43,996 --> 00:33:48,302 east of the other historic sit 17939 00:33:48,302 --> 00:33:48,302 e. 17940 00:33:48,302 --> 00:33:50,370 so the pud would still be in 17941 00:33:50,370 --> 00:33:51,344 effect for that. 17942 00:33:51,344 --> 00:33:52,570 >> that's the land use. 17943 00:33:52,570 --> 00:33:53,286 >> right. 17944 00:33:53,286 --> 00:33:55,084 >> that's a land use and then 17945 00:33:55,084 --> 00:33:57,046 even later on the zoning. 17946 00:33:57,046 --> 00:33:58,478 >> the pud would also still 17947 00:33:58,478 --> 00:34:00,318 apply to that other piece of 17948 00:34:00,318 --> 00:34:00,318 property. 17949 00:34:00,318 --> 00:34:02,088 >> even though it is kind of an 17950 00:34:02,088 --> 00:34:02,088 17951 00:34:02,088 --> 00:34:02,754 old -- 17952 00:34:02,754 --> 00:34:03,488 >> even still, yeah. 17953 00:34:03,488 --> 00:34:04,546 >> all right. 17954 00:34:04,546 --> 00:34:05,882 it feels a little weird, but I 17955 00:34:05,882 --> 00:34:05,882 t 17956 00:34:05,882 --> 00:34:06,656 does make sense. 17957 00:34:06,656 --> 00:34:08,519 if everything else is mor aarou 17958 00:34:08,519 --> 00:34:12,976 nd it, this is just 17959 00:34:12,976 --> 00:34:16,292 returning potential [inaudible] 17960 00:34:16,292 --> 00:34:16,292 . 17961 00:34:16,292 --> 00:34:18,202 airbnbs have probably taken a 17962 00:34:18,202 --> 00:34:21,972 lot of wind out of the sail of 17963 00:34:21,972 --> 00:34:21,972 17964 00:34:21,972 --> 00:34:25,946 actual b&bs, there could be 17965 00:34:25,946 --> 00:34:27,140 somebody living on the site to 17966 00:34:27,140 --> 00:34:27,140 17967 00:34:27,140 --> 00:34:28,553 help the east side and downtown 17968 00:34:28,553 --> 00:34:28,553 17969 00:34:28,553 --> 00:34:30,883 have more people living there to 17970 00:34:30,883 --> 00:34:30,883 17971 00:34:30,883 --> 00:34:32,812 do everything that we want to d 17972 00:34:32,812 --> 00:34:32,812 o 17973 00:34:32,812 --> 00:34:34,148 in getting more people to live 17974 00:34:34,148 --> 00:34:34,148 17975 00:34:34,148 --> 00:34:35,876 downtown or close to downtown. 17976 00:34:35,876 --> 00:34:35,876 17977 00:34:35,876 --> 00:34:39,088 so I just want to be in support 17978 00:34:39,088 --> 00:34:39,088 17979 00:34:39,088 --> 00:34:41,790 and I'll make the motion. 17980 00:34:41,790 --> 00:34:42,563 >> mayor: thank you. 17981 00:34:42,563 --> 00:34:43,382 commissioner eastman. 17982 00:34:43,382 --> 00:34:44,121 >> yeah, thank you. 17983 00:34:44,121 --> 00:34:45,732 I mean this seems like a 17984 00:34:45,732 --> 00:34:45,732 no-brainer. 17985 00:34:45,732 --> 00:34:48,262 there's mixed use office 17986 00:34:48,262 --> 00:34:52,064 residential all around it. 17987 00:34:52,064 --> 00:34:53,266 you know, for years, the 17988 00:34:53,266 --> 00:34:54,072 community has been asking what' 17989 00:34:54,072 --> 00:34:54,072 s 17990 00:34:54,072 --> 00:34:56,575 going to happen with this house 17991 00:34:56,575 --> 00:34:56,575 . 17992 00:34:56,575 --> 00:34:58,210 it is a very stark house. 17993 00:34:58,210 --> 00:35:00,448 I believe it is on bo diddley 17994 00:35:00,448 --> 00:35:00,448 plaza. 17995 00:35:00,448 --> 00:35:02,856 it was originally in downtown, 17996 00:35:02,856 --> 00:35:02,856 17997 00:35:02,856 --> 00:35:02,856 correct? 17998 00:35:02,856 --> 00:35:05,240 it was originally on bo diddley 17999 00:35:05,240 --> 00:35:05,240 18000 00:35:05,240 --> 00:35:05,240 plaza. 18001 00:35:05,240 --> 00:35:09,864 the city had a bit of history, 18002 00:35:09,864 --> 00:35:09,864 18003 00:35:09,864 --> 00:35:11,647 eminent domain this entire 18004 00:35:11,647 --> 00:35:13,310 section of our downtown to 18005 00:35:13,310 --> 00:35:14,959 create city hall, bo diddley 18006 00:35:14,959 --> 00:35:16,563 plaza and what should have bee 18007 00:35:16,563 --> 00:35:16,563 n 18008 00:35:16,563 --> 00:35:19,064 a civic center from there. 18009 00:35:19,064 --> 00:35:22,471 it was high historic 18010 00:35:22,471 --> 00:35:24,231 preservation and moved it to 18011 00:35:24,231 --> 00:35:24,764 university avenue. 18012 00:35:24,764 --> 00:35:25,867 and people have been curious 18013 00:35:25,867 --> 00:35:27,197 what is going to happen to it. 18014 00:35:27,197 --> 00:35:27,197 18015 00:35:27,197 --> 00:35:28,467 it is a beautiful stately house 18016 00:35:28,467 --> 00:35:28,467 18017 00:35:28,467 --> 00:35:30,236 that now looks sort of ghostly 18018 00:35:30,236 --> 00:35:30,236 18019 00:35:30,236 --> 00:35:32,303 and wasn't entirely clear. 18020 00:35:32,303 --> 00:35:35,042 I'm glad someone wanted to ste 18021 00:35:35,042 --> 00:35:35,042 p 18022 00:35:35,042 --> 00:35:36,055 up and do something good with 18023 00:35:36,055 --> 00:35:36,055 it. 18024 00:35:36,055 --> 00:35:38,237 I'm very happy they came forwa 18025 00:35:38,237 --> 00:35:38,237 rd 18026 00:35:38,237 --> 00:35:38,877 with it. 18027 00:35:38,877 --> 00:35:40,654 it's a really good reminder to 18028 00:35:40,654 --> 00:35:40,654 18029 00:35:40,654 --> 00:35:41,951 everyone why we should be tryin 18030 00:35:41,951 --> 00:35:41,951 g 18031 00:35:41,951 --> 00:35:43,851 not to approve pds. 18032 00:35:43,851 --> 00:35:45,449 I understand there's reverters 18033 00:35:45,449 --> 00:35:45,449 18034 00:35:45,449 --> 00:35:45,449 nowadays. 18035 00:35:45,449 --> 00:35:48,434 we have learned some thingover 18036 00:35:48,434 --> 00:35:48,434 18037 00:35:48,434 --> 00:35:48,434 time. 18038 00:35:48,434 --> 00:35:52,231 what happens with planned 18039 00:35:52,231 --> 00:35:52,856 developments which are these 18040 00:35:52,856 --> 00:35:54,862 kind of costly parcels, they 18041 00:35:54,862 --> 00:35:56,166 just linger there. 18042 00:35:56,166 --> 00:35:57,625 and then the whole code changes 18043 00:35:57,625 --> 00:35:57,625 18044 00:35:57,625 --> 00:35:58,271 all around it. 18045 00:35:58,271 --> 00:36:00,619 and then eventually somebody is 18046 00:36:00,619 --> 00:36:00,619 18047 00:36:00,619 --> 00:36:02,001 just trying to already put in 18048 00:36:02,001 --> 00:36:03,306 enough time and effort to make 18049 00:36:03,306 --> 00:36:03,306 18050 00:36:03,306 --> 00:36:04,645 the house look nice and hires 18051 00:36:04,645 --> 00:36:07,275 eda to come and go for the pla 18052 00:36:07,275 --> 00:36:07,275 n 18053 00:36:07,275 --> 00:36:09,041 board and I think I saw july 18054 00:36:09,041 --> 00:36:10,447 when this first came forward. 18055 00:36:10,447 --> 00:36:12,117 just a lot of work for people to 18056 00:36:12,117 --> 00:36:12,117 18057 00:36:12,117 --> 00:36:12,549 go through. 18058 00:36:12,549 --> 00:36:14,145 so it's nice for it to just be 18059 00:36:14,145 --> 00:36:14,145 18060 00:36:14,145 --> 00:36:15,157 part of the rest of the process 18061 00:36:15,157 --> 00:36:15,157 18062 00:36:15,157 --> 00:36:17,553 as the code changes. 18063 00:36:17,553 --> 00:36:19,079 so I'm very happy to support I 18064 00:36:19,079 --> 00:36:19,079 t. 18065 00:36:19,079 --> 00:36:20,489 with that, I'd like to approve 18066 00:36:20,489 --> 00:36:20,489 18067 00:36:20,489 --> 00:36:23,893 ordinance number 2025-998. 18068 00:36:23,893 --> 00:36:24,495 >> second. 18069 00:36:24,495 --> 00:36:25,291 >> mayor: we have a motion and 18070 00:36:25,291 --> 00:36:25,373 a 18071 00:36:25,373 --> 00:36:25,373 second. 18072 00:36:25,373 --> 00:36:27,751 madam clerk, is there any public 18073 00:36:27,751 --> 00:36:27,751 18074 00:36:27,751 --> 00:36:27,751 comment? 18075 00:36:27,751 --> 00:36:30,029 >> there's no public comment. 18076 00:36:30,029 --> 00:36:31,767 >> mayor: anything either staff 18077 00:36:31,767 --> 00:36:31,767 18078 00:36:31,767 --> 00:36:33,769 or the applicant want to add t 18079 00:36:33,769 --> 00:36:33,769 o 18080 00:36:33,769 --> 00:36:34,949 the land use? 18081 00:36:34,949 --> 00:36:35,366 all right. 18082 00:36:35,366 --> 00:36:36,659 seeing no further lights, madam 18083 00:36:36,659 --> 00:36:36,659 18084 00:36:36,659 --> 00:36:38,674 clerk, please call the roll. 18085 00:36:38,674 --> 00:36:39,417 >> commissioner ingle. 18086 00:36:39,417 --> 00:36:39,952 >> aye. 18087 00:36:39,952 --> 00:36:40,599 >> commissioner chestnut. 18088 00:36:40,599 --> 00:36:41,053 >> aye. 18089 00:36:41,053 --> 00:36:41,537 >> commissioner duncan-walker. 18090 00:36:41,537 --> 00:36:41,537 18091 00:36:41,537 --> 00:36:41,991 >> aye. 18092 00:36:41,991 --> 00:36:42,511 >> commissioner book. 18093 00:36:42,511 --> 00:36:43,149 >> aye. 18094 00:36:43,149 --> 00:36:43,645 >> commissioner willits. 18095 00:36:43,645 --> 00:36:44,115 >> aye. 18096 00:36:44,115 --> 00:36:44,620 >> commissioner eastman. 18097 00:36:44,620 --> 00:36:45,183 >> aye. 18098 00:36:45,183 --> 00:36:45,613 >> mayor ward. 18099 00:36:45,613 --> 00:36:46,627 >> mayor: aye. 18100 00:36:46,627 --> 00:36:47,391 that passes unanimously. 18101 00:36:47,391 --> 00:36:50,183 madam clerk. 18102 00:36:50,183 --> 00:36:52,648 >> mr. Mayor, ordinance number 18103 00:36:52,648 --> 00:36:52,648 18104 00:36:52,648 --> 00:36:55,619 2025-997, an ordinance of the 18105 00:36:55,619 --> 00:36:56,151 city of gainesville, florida 18106 00:36:56,151 --> 00:36:58,791 amending the zoning map atlas b 18107 00:36:58,791 --> 00:36:58,791 y 18108 00:36:58,791 --> 00:37:00,423 rezoning approximately .64 acr 18109 00:37:00,423 --> 00:37:00,423 es 18110 00:37:00,423 --> 00:37:02,761 of property generally located a 18111 00:37:02,761 --> 00:37:02,761 t 18112 00:37:02,761 --> 00:37:04,562 the 800 block of east universi 18113 00:37:04,562 --> 00:37:04,562 ty 18114 00:37:04,562 --> 00:37:05,503 avenue as more specifically 18115 00:37:05,503 --> 00:37:07,137 described in this ordinance fro 18116 00:37:07,137 --> 00:37:07,137 m 18117 00:37:07,137 --> 00:37:08,329 planned development to urban 4 18118 00:37:08,329 --> 00:37:08,329 , 18119 00:37:08,329 --> 00:37:09,827 providing directions to the city 18120 00:37:09,827 --> 00:37:09,827 18121 00:37:09,827 --> 00:37:11,307 manager, providing severabilit 18122 00:37:11,307 --> 00:37:11,307 y 18123 00:37:11,307 --> 00:37:13,577 clause, prov providing repeali 18124 00:37:13,577 --> 00:37:13,577 ng 18125 00:37:13,577 --> 00:37:16,185 clause and providing effective 18126 00:37:16,185 --> 00:37:16,185 18127 00:37:16,185 --> 00:37:16,185 date. 18128 00:37:16,185 --> 00:37:26,815 >> ari rabinovich, this is the 18129 00:37:26,815 --> 00:37:26,815 18130 00:37:26,815 --> 00:37:28,019 800 block of east university 18131 00:37:28,019 --> 00:37:28,019 avenue. 18132 00:37:28,019 --> 00:37:32,186 so the requested zoning 18133 00:37:32,186 --> 00:37:34,624 designation is urban zoned 4 18134 00:37:34,624 --> 00:37:36,497 which is transect. 18135 00:37:36,497 --> 00:37:38,531 this is a zoning designation 18136 00:37:38,531 --> 00:37:40,197 that would establish a range o 18137 00:37:40,197 --> 00:37:40,197 f 18138 00:37:40,197 --> 00:37:45,665 allowable uses and allowable 18139 00:37:45,665 --> 00:37:46,869 development which is a mix of 18140 00:37:46,869 --> 00:37:47,970 uses including offices, 18141 00:37:47,970 --> 00:37:49,277 residences, retail, commercial 18142 00:37:49,277 --> 00:37:49,277 18143 00:37:49,277 --> 00:37:53,010 and civic uses. 18144 00:37:53,010 --> 00:37:55,717 so a map of the current zoning 18145 00:37:55,717 --> 00:37:55,717 18146 00:37:55,717 --> 00:37:58,591 designations which are both pd. 18147 00:37:58,591 --> 00:37:58,591 18148 00:37:58,591 --> 00:38:03,823 and the requested u4. 18149 00:38:03,823 --> 00:38:06,333 same set of surrounding active 18150 00:38:06,333 --> 00:38:06,333 18151 00:38:06,333 --> 00:38:08,093 uses, surrounding zoning 18152 00:38:08,093 --> 00:38:13,997 designations are both u4 and u 18153 00:38:13,997 --> 00:38:13,997 3. 18154 00:38:13,997 --> 00:38:16,932 and rooking at that same clust 18155 00:38:16,932 --> 00:38:16,932 er 18156 00:38:16,932 --> 00:38:19,080 of land it's about 73 acres 18157 00:38:19,080 --> 00:38:21,033 that are zoned either u3 or u4 18158 00:38:21,033 --> 00:38:21,033 18159 00:38:21,033 --> 00:38:25,394 in this area. 18160 00:38:25,394 --> 00:38:28,877 same historic considerations. 18161 00:38:28,877 --> 00:38:33,057 and same set of review criteri 18162 00:38:33,057 --> 00:38:33,057 a 18163 00:38:33,057 --> 00:38:37,555 that historic preservation wou 18164 00:38:37,555 --> 00:38:37,555 ld 18165 00:38:37,555 --> 00:38:37,555 conduct. 18166 00:38:37,555 --> 00:38:42,126 and just real quick synopsis o 18167 00:38:42,126 --> 00:38:42,126 f 18168 00:38:42,126 --> 00:38:45,063 the transect zone. 18169 00:38:45,063 --> 00:38:49,235 this is being -- u4 falls withi 18170 00:38:49,235 --> 00:38:49,235 n 18171 00:38:49,235 --> 00:38:50,614 the designation that consists 18172 00:38:50,614 --> 00:38:50,614 of 18173 00:38:50,614 --> 00:38:51,979 a wide range of residential 18174 00:38:51,979 --> 00:38:53,838 building types with the higher 18175 00:38:53,838 --> 00:38:53,838 18176 00:38:53,838 --> 00:38:55,669 numbered zones providing for t 18177 00:38:55,669 --> 00:38:55,669 he 18178 00:38:55,669 --> 00:38:57,346 integration of offices and 18179 00:38:57,346 --> 00:38:58,977 neighborhood services within a 18180 00:38:58,977 --> 00:38:58,977 n 18181 00:38:58,977 --> 00:39:01,279 increasingly urban fabric, 18182 00:39:01,279 --> 00:39:03,385 setbacks that vary and streets 18183 00:39:03,385 --> 00:39:03,385 18184 00:39:03,385 --> 00:39:05,082 with curbs and sidewalks that 18185 00:39:05,082 --> 00:39:07,083 define medium-sized blocks. 18186 00:39:07,083 --> 00:39:08,418 and the intent of the transect 18187 00:39:08,418 --> 00:39:08,418 18188 00:39:08,418 --> 00:39:09,518 zoning is to establish 18189 00:39:09,518 --> 00:39:10,291 development standards that 18190 00:39:10,291 --> 00:39:12,361 encourage a more efficient and 18191 00:39:12,361 --> 00:39:12,361 18192 00:39:12,361 --> 00:39:13,563 sustainable forum by allowing a 18193 00:39:13,563 --> 00:39:13,563 18194 00:39:13,563 --> 00:39:15,629 range of housing, employment, 18195 00:39:15,629 --> 00:39:17,394 shopping and recreation choices 18196 00:39:17,394 --> 00:39:17,394 18197 00:39:17,394 --> 00:39:19,597 within a compact and 18198 00:39:19,597 --> 00:39:23,575 pedestrian-friendly environmen 18199 00:39:23,575 --> 00:39:23,575 t. 18200 00:39:23,575 --> 00:39:25,499 comparing the u4 designation 18201 00:39:25,499 --> 00:39:27,377 against what was basically 18202 00:39:27,377 --> 00:39:29,689 applied within the pd which was 18203 00:39:29,689 --> 00:39:29,689 18204 00:39:29,689 --> 00:39:31,904 o2 back then, we see that 18205 00:39:31,904 --> 00:39:33,951 there's some outdated standards 18206 00:39:33,951 --> 00:39:33,951 18207 00:39:33,951 --> 00:39:37,051 for things like setbacks where 18208 00:39:37,051 --> 00:39:37,051 18209 00:39:37,051 --> 00:39:41,389 the o2 require setbacks relative 18210 00:39:41,389 --> 00:39:41,389 18211 00:39:41,389 --> 00:39:42,265 to the angle of light 18212 00:39:42,265 --> 00:39:42,265 obstruction. 18213 00:39:42,265 --> 00:39:46,409 o2 disallowed residential uses 18214 00:39:46,409 --> 00:39:46,409 18215 00:39:46,409 --> 00:39:48,065 so this request would introduce 18216 00:39:48,065 --> 00:39:48,065 18217 00:39:48,065 --> 00:39:49,565 residential uses and modernize 18218 00:39:49,565 --> 00:39:49,565 18219 00:39:49,565 --> 00:39:50,745 code requirements to meet the 18220 00:39:50,745 --> 00:39:51,664 design and development standards 18221 00:39:51,664 --> 00:39:51,664 18222 00:39:51,664 --> 00:39:53,633 that are set by our transect 18223 00:39:53,633 --> 00:39:55,035 code relating to density, 18224 00:39:55,035 --> 00:40:00,071 height, setback, sidewalks. 18225 00:40:00,071 --> 00:40:03,041 so staff are required by code t 18226 00:40:03,041 --> 00:40:03,041 o 18227 00:40:03,041 --> 00:40:04,877 review rezoning against a set o 18228 00:40:04,877 --> 00:40:04,877 f 18229 00:40:04,877 --> 00:40:05,982 criteria and have found that 18230 00:40:05,982 --> 00:40:07,814 this request does meet the 18231 00:40:07,814 --> 00:40:09,597 requirements of the land 18232 00:40:09,597 --> 00:40:10,249 development code. 18233 00:40:10,249 --> 00:40:12,521 this involves compatibility wit 18234 00:40:12,521 --> 00:40:12,521 h 18235 00:40:12,521 --> 00:40:13,913 the surrounding development, a 18236 00:40:13,913 --> 00:40:13,913 ny 18237 00:40:13,913 --> 00:40:15,648 changes to the character of the 18238 00:40:15,648 --> 00:40:15,648 18239 00:40:15,648 --> 00:40:16,920 area that warrant the requested 18240 00:40:16,920 --> 00:40:16,920 18241 00:40:16,920 --> 00:40:19,225 change and the goals, policies 18242 00:40:19,225 --> 00:40:19,225 18243 00:40:19,225 --> 00:40:20,290 and objectives of the 18244 00:40:20,290 --> 00:40:20,992 comprehensive plan, specificall 18245 00:40:20,992 --> 00:40:20,992 y 18246 00:40:20,992 --> 00:40:22,298 foes surrounding the 18247 00:40:22,298 --> 00:40:23,498 encouragement of diverse 18248 00:40:23,498 --> 00:40:25,597 housing, office, retail and 18249 00:40:25,597 --> 00:40:26,739 workplace choices as well as the 18250 00:40:26,739 --> 00:40:26,739 18251 00:40:26,739 --> 00:40:28,344 discouraging of sprawl through 18252 00:40:28,344 --> 00:40:28,344 18253 00:40:28,344 --> 00:40:28,967 infill development. 18254 00:40:28,967 --> 00:40:30,298 so with that, staff does 18255 00:40:30,298 --> 00:40:31,507 recommend approval of 18256 00:40:31,507 --> 00:40:31,507 ld25-000141. 18257 00:40:31,507 --> 00:40:35,508 thank you very much for your 18258 00:40:35,508 --> 00:40:37,177 time and I'm here for any 18259 00:40:37,177 --> 00:40:38,413 further questions. 18260 00:40:38,413 --> 00:40:38,955 >> mayor: very good. 18261 00:40:38,955 --> 00:40:39,912 thank you. 18262 00:40:39,912 --> 00:40:43,117 I see no questions. 18263 00:40:43,117 --> 00:40:44,281 mr. Sweger, did you want to 18264 00:40:44,281 --> 00:40:45,086 offer anything? 18265 00:40:45,086 --> 00:40:46,455 all right. 18266 00:40:46,455 --> 00:40:48,554 very good. 18267 00:40:48,554 --> 00:40:49,755 commissioner willits. 18268 00:40:49,755 --> 00:40:51,522 >> mr. Mayor, seeing as the 18269 00:40:51,522 --> 00:40:53,049 property is immediately across 18270 00:40:53,049 --> 00:40:53,049 18271 00:40:53,049 --> 00:40:54,591 the street and then to the two 18272 00:40:54,591 --> 00:40:54,591 18273 00:40:54,591 --> 00:40:55,802 blocks towards downtown are all 18274 00:40:55,802 --> 00:40:55,802 18275 00:40:55,802 --> 00:41:00,432 that u4, on that kind of half 18276 00:41:00,432 --> 00:41:01,470 block abutting the university. 18277 00:41:01,470 --> 00:41:01,470 18278 00:41:01,470 --> 00:41:02,808 it seems to make sense. 18279 00:41:02,808 --> 00:41:05,973 it's a little bit of corridor o 18280 00:41:05,973 --> 00:41:05,973 f 18281 00:41:05,973 --> 00:41:07,382 u4 that makes sense. 18282 00:41:07,382 --> 00:41:08,721 I move the city commission ado 18283 00:41:08,721 --> 00:41:08,721 18284 00:41:08,721 --> 00:41:14,048 the proposed ordinance 2025-995 18285 00:41:14,048 --> 00:41:14,048 18286 00:41:14,048 --> 00:41:16,018 quasi-judicial the 800 block 18287 00:41:16,018 --> 00:41:17,918 east university rezoning. 18288 00:41:17,918 --> 00:41:19,158 >> second. 18289 00:41:19,158 --> 00:41:19,813 >> mayor: is there any public 18290 00:41:19,813 --> 00:41:20,951 comment on this, madam clerk? 18291 00:41:20,951 --> 00:41:22,192 >> no public comment. 18292 00:41:22,192 --> 00:41:22,932 >> mayor: would you call the 18293 00:41:22,932 --> 00:41:23,688 roll, please. 18294 00:41:23,688 --> 00:41:24,855 >> commissioner chestnut. 18295 00:41:24,855 --> 00:41:25,499 >> aye. 18296 00:41:25,499 --> 00:41:25,990 >> commissioner duncan-walker. 18297 00:41:25,990 --> 00:41:25,990 18298 00:41:25,990 --> 00:41:26,500 >> aye. 18299 00:41:26,500 --> 00:41:27,122 >> commissioner book. 18300 00:41:27,122 --> 00:41:27,833 >> aye. 18301 00:41:27,833 --> 00:41:28,362 >> commissioner willits. 18302 00:41:28,362 --> 00:41:28,804 >> aye. 18303 00:41:28,804 --> 00:41:29,382 >> commissioner eastman. 18304 00:41:29,382 --> 00:41:29,895 >> aye. 18305 00:41:29,895 --> 00:41:30,478 >> commissioner ingle. 18306 00:41:30,478 --> 00:41:31,140 >> aye. 18307 00:41:31,140 --> 00:41:31,502 >> mayor ward. 18308 00:41:31,502 --> 00:41:32,463 >> mayor: aye. 18309 00:41:32,463 --> 00:41:34,194 that passes unanimously. 18310 00:41:34,194 --> 00:41:35,131 nice work. 18311 00:41:35,131 --> 00:41:36,736 >> mr. Mayor, ordinance number 18312 00:41:36,736 --> 00:41:36,736 18313 00:41:36,736 --> 00:41:38,837 2025-992, an ordinance of the 18314 00:41:38,837 --> 00:41:39,352 city of gainesville, florida 18315 00:41:39,352 --> 00:41:40,712 amending the future land use m 18316 00:41:40,712 --> 00:41:40,712 ap 18317 00:41:40,712 --> 00:41:41,606 of the comprehensive plan by 18318 00:41:41,606 --> 00:41:43,212 changing the land use category 18319 00:41:43,212 --> 00:41:43,212 18320 00:41:43,212 --> 00:41:45,704 of approximately 25.55 acres o 18321 00:41:45,704 --> 00:41:45,704 f 18322 00:41:45,704 --> 00:41:47,078 property generally located wes 18323 00:41:47,078 --> 00:41:47,078 t 18324 00:41:47,078 --> 00:41:48,710 of southwest 13th street, 18325 00:41:48,710 --> 00:41:51,050 south of southwest archer road, 18326 00:41:51,050 --> 00:41:51,050 18327 00:41:51,050 --> 00:41:53,020 east of southwest 16th street 18328 00:41:53,020 --> 00:41:54,721 and north of southwest 16th 18329 00:41:54,721 --> 00:41:56,620 avenue as more specifically 18330 00:41:56,620 --> 00:41:58,152 described in this ordinance fro 18331 00:41:58,152 --> 00:41:58,152 m 18332 00:41:58,152 --> 00:42:01,225 urban mixed use high intensity 18333 00:42:01,225 --> 00:42:01,225 18334 00:42:01,225 --> 00:42:03,422 to office, providing directions 18335 00:42:03,422 --> 00:42:03,422 18336 00:42:03,422 --> 00:42:05,097 to the city manager, providing 18337 00:42:05,097 --> 00:42:05,097 18338 00:42:05,097 --> 00:42:06,733 severability clause, providing 18339 00:42:06,733 --> 00:42:06,733 18340 00:42:06,733 --> 00:42:08,311 repealing clause and providing 18341 00:42:08,311 --> 00:42:08,311 18342 00:42:08,311 --> 00:42:09,034 an effective date. 18343 00:42:09,034 --> 00:42:09,942 >> mayor: very good. 18344 00:42:09,942 --> 00:42:09,942 welcome. 18345 00:42:09,942 --> 00:42:11,160 >> hello, good evening, mayor 18346 00:42:11,160 --> 00:42:11,775 and commissioners. 18347 00:42:11,775 --> 00:42:12,868 thank you for having me this 18348 00:42:12,868 --> 00:42:12,868 evening. 18349 00:42:12,868 --> 00:42:16,610 my name is allison payinger. 18350 00:42:16,610 --> 00:42:20,514 I'm a in the department of 18351 00:42:20,514 --> 00:42:21,748 sustainable development. 18352 00:42:21,748 --> 00:42:24,420 u.f. South campus will consist 18353 00:42:24,420 --> 00:42:24,420 18354 00:42:24,420 --> 00:42:26,260 of two applications, one for t 18355 00:42:26,260 --> 00:42:26,260 he 18356 00:42:26,260 --> 00:42:28,319 land use that is legislative a 18357 00:42:28,319 --> 00:42:28,319 nd 18358 00:42:28,319 --> 00:42:30,390 one for the map change which I 18359 00:42:30,390 --> 00:42:30,390 s 18360 00:42:30,390 --> 00:42:30,390 quasi-judicial. 18361 00:42:30,390 --> 00:42:31,792 this presentation is 18362 00:42:31,792 --> 00:42:32,693 specifically for the land use 18363 00:42:32,693 --> 00:42:34,852 amendment identified by petitio 18364 00:42:34,852 --> 00:42:34,852 n 18365 00:42:34,852 --> 00:42:34,852 number. 18366 00:42:34,852 --> 00:42:40,954 the applicant is in attendance 18367 00:42:40,954 --> 00:42:40,954 18368 00:42:40,954 --> 00:42:42,540 and will have a presentation 18369 00:42:42,540 --> 00:42:44,166 after the conclusion of staff's 18370 00:42:44,166 --> 00:42:44,166 18371 00:42:44,166 --> 00:42:44,166 presentation. 18372 00:42:44,166 --> 00:42:50,504 this petition is for three 18373 00:42:50,504 --> 00:42:52,614 subject parcels equaling in 18374 00:42:52,614 --> 00:42:55,748 total approximately 25.55 acres 18375 00:42:55,748 --> 00:42:55,748 . 18376 00:42:55,748 --> 00:42:56,448 for the record identified as 18377 00:42:56,448 --> 00:43:09,261 parcels 1548200000145490000 and 18378 00:43:09,261 --> 00:43:09,261 18379 00:43:09,261 --> 00:43:09,261 154-60-0000. 18380 00:43:09,261 --> 00:43:11,670 the three parcels are south of 18381 00:43:11,670 --> 00:43:11,670 18382 00:43:11,670 --> 00:43:12,994 the university of florida xuts 18383 00:43:12,994 --> 00:43:12,994 18384 00:43:12,994 --> 00:43:15,400 and bounded by archer road, 18385 00:43:15,400 --> 00:43:17,605 southwest 16th ave. 18386 00:43:17,605 --> 00:43:18,902 southwest 13th street and 18387 00:43:18,902 --> 00:43:19,871 southwest 16th street. 18388 00:43:19,871 --> 00:43:23,205 the current land use category I 18389 00:43:23,205 --> 00:43:23,205 s 18390 00:43:23,205 --> 00:43:24,740 umuh urban mixed use high 18391 00:43:24,740 --> 00:43:24,740 intensity. 18392 00:43:24,740 --> 00:43:27,144 the proposed change is for 18393 00:43:27,144 --> 00:43:27,144 office. 18394 00:43:27,144 --> 00:43:28,946 the subject parcels are 18395 00:43:28,946 --> 00:43:30,008 currently developed. 18396 00:43:30,008 --> 00:43:32,448 this area is referred to as u.f 18397 00:43:32,448 --> 00:43:32,448 . 18398 00:43:32,448 --> 00:43:34,028 healthsouth campus. 18399 00:43:34,028 --> 00:43:35,180 please note that the three 18400 00:43:35,180 --> 00:43:37,464 parcels are not within the u.f 18401 00:43:37,464 --> 00:43:37,464 . 18402 00:43:37,464 --> 00:43:38,436 campus development agreement 18403 00:43:38,436 --> 00:43:38,436 this. 18404 00:43:38,436 --> 00:43:40,766 however it is part of the u.f. 18405 00:43:40,766 --> 00:43:40,766 18406 00:43:40,766 --> 00:43:42,052 master plan and largely part o 18407 00:43:42,052 --> 00:43:42,052 f 18408 00:43:42,052 --> 00:43:44,900 the u.f. Health shands complex. 18409 00:43:44,900 --> 00:43:44,900 18410 00:43:44,900 --> 00:43:46,230 the parcels are currently home 18411 00:43:46,230 --> 00:43:46,230 18412 00:43:46,230 --> 00:43:50,370 to u.f. Health heart and 18413 00:43:50,370 --> 00:43:52,246 vascular hospital and u.f. 18414 00:43:52,246 --> 00:43:54,777 health shands, and trauma 18415 00:43:54,777 --> 00:43:54,777 center. 18416 00:43:54,777 --> 00:43:57,513 the purpose of the request is I 18417 00:43:57,513 --> 00:43:57,513 n 18418 00:43:57,513 --> 00:43:58,100 two parts. 18419 00:43:58,100 --> 00:43:59,046 to have the property be 18420 00:43:59,046 --> 00:44:00,548 consistent in land use and 18421 00:44:00,548 --> 00:44:01,984 zoning designation with other 18422 00:44:01,984 --> 00:44:03,080 hospital complexes throughout 18423 00:44:03,080 --> 00:44:04,290 the city. 18424 00:44:04,290 --> 00:44:05,482 and to bring the existing 18425 00:44:05,482 --> 00:44:07,456 hospital facility structures 18426 00:44:07,456 --> 00:44:08,894 into conformance and provide 18427 00:44:08,894 --> 00:44:10,502 land use and zoning that is 18428 00:44:10,502 --> 00:44:12,694 needed for any future 18429 00:44:12,694 --> 00:44:13,794 redevelopment and site 18430 00:44:13,794 --> 00:44:15,962 improvements as needed. 18431 00:44:15,962 --> 00:44:18,164 for additional context, this 18432 00:44:18,164 --> 00:44:20,374 area of the city was part of t 18433 00:44:20,374 --> 00:44:20,374 he 18434 00:44:20,374 --> 00:44:22,566 form-based city initiated land 18435 00:44:22,566 --> 00:44:22,566 18436 00:44:22,566 --> 00:44:24,500 use change and rezoning efforts 18437 00:44:24,500 --> 00:44:24,500 18438 00:44:24,500 --> 00:44:29,436 in 2017 with transect zoning. 18439 00:44:29,436 --> 00:44:31,074 in this case, it was near the 18440 00:44:31,074 --> 00:44:32,901 u.f. Campus in the periphery o 18441 00:44:32,901 --> 00:44:32,901 f 18442 00:44:32,901 --> 00:44:32,901 downtown. 18443 00:44:32,901 --> 00:44:35,362 and the next few slides are jus 18444 00:44:35,362 --> 00:44:35,362 t 18445 00:44:35,362 --> 00:44:36,618 going to provide some context to 18446 00:44:36,618 --> 00:44:36,618 18447 00:44:36,618 --> 00:44:37,752 the area before we get into the 18448 00:44:37,752 --> 00:44:37,752 18449 00:44:37,752 --> 00:44:39,858 criteria of the land use chang 18450 00:44:39,858 --> 00:44:39,858 e. 18451 00:44:39,858 --> 00:44:42,018 so this is an overhead imagery 18452 00:44:42,018 --> 00:44:42,018 18453 00:44:42,018 --> 00:44:43,122 showing the area and the 18454 00:44:43,122 --> 00:44:43,122 structures. 18455 00:44:43,122 --> 00:44:51,200 hihere is showing the u.f. Cam 18456 00:44:51,200 --> 00:44:51,200 pus 18457 00:44:51,200 --> 00:44:51,730 master plan agreement. 18458 00:44:51,730 --> 00:44:53,926 so it's outside of it, but it I 18459 00:44:53,926 --> 00:44:53,926 s 18460 00:44:53,926 --> 00:44:57,236 directly north of the parcels. 18461 00:44:57,236 --> 00:44:57,236 18462 00:44:57,236 --> 00:44:58,878 here is just a quick location 18463 00:44:58,878 --> 00:45:00,270 map for reference. 18464 00:45:00,270 --> 00:45:02,906 so north of the subject area I 18465 00:45:02,906 --> 00:45:02,906 s 18466 00:45:02,906 --> 00:45:05,208 archer road and then the main 18467 00:45:05,208 --> 00:45:07,746 u.f. Health shands facilities. 18468 00:45:07,746 --> 00:45:07,746 18469 00:45:07,746 --> 00:45:10,016 south is southwest 16th ave 18470 00:45:10,016 --> 00:45:12,988 and kind of a mixture of 18471 00:45:12,988 --> 00:45:14,852 apartments and restaurants, 18472 00:45:14,852 --> 00:45:15,580 office uses. 18473 00:45:15,580 --> 00:45:17,088 east is southwest 13th street 18474 00:45:17,088 --> 00:45:18,553 and then some multi-family and 18475 00:45:18,553 --> 00:45:18,553 18476 00:45:18,553 --> 00:45:19,762 restaurant uses. 18477 00:45:19,762 --> 00:45:23,026 and west of the subject area I 18478 00:45:23,026 --> 00:45:23,026 s 18479 00:45:23,026 --> 00:45:24,698 southwest 16th street and then 18480 00:45:24,698 --> 00:45:24,698 18481 00:45:24,698 --> 00:45:26,562 additional medical facilities 18482 00:45:26,562 --> 00:45:28,832 and the v.a. Hospital. 18483 00:45:28,832 --> 00:45:30,714 this is just a summary of those, 18484 00:45:30,714 --> 00:45:30,714 18485 00:45:30,714 --> 00:45:33,641 of what was just described. 18486 00:45:33,641 --> 00:45:36,171 and just to kind of give a 18487 00:45:36,171 --> 00:45:38,042 visual, so this would be if you we 18488 00:45:38,042 --> 00:45:40,246 were on archer road where it 18489 00:45:40,246 --> 00:45:42,110 intersects with southwest 16th 18490 00:45:42,110 --> 00:45:42,110 18491 00:45:42,110 --> 00:45:45,216 street looking towards southwest 18492 00:45:45,216 --> 00:45:45,216 18493 00:45:45,216 --> 00:45:45,216 13th. 18494 00:45:45,216 --> 00:45:46,712 so like the grass and trees 18495 00:45:46,712 --> 00:45:48,372 area, that's like the v.a. Are 18496 00:45:48,372 --> 00:45:48,372 a. 18497 00:45:48,372 --> 00:45:50,224 and then you're staring directly 18498 00:45:50,224 --> 00:45:50,224 18499 00:45:50,224 --> 00:45:51,658 at the emergency room building. 18500 00:45:51,658 --> 00:45:51,658 18501 00:45:51,658 --> 00:45:53,258 just to kind of show how large 18502 00:45:53,258 --> 00:45:53,258 18503 00:45:53,258 --> 00:45:55,258 this area is. 18504 00:45:55,258 --> 00:45:56,992 this is at the intersection of 18505 00:45:56,992 --> 00:45:56,992 18506 00:45:56,992 --> 00:45:58,556 southwest 16th ave and 18507 00:45:58,556 --> 00:46:01,032 southwest 13th street looking 18508 00:46:01,032 --> 00:46:03,128 at northwest at the u.f. 18509 00:46:03,128 --> 00:46:05,008 healthsouth campus and seeing 18510 00:46:05,008 --> 00:46:06,003 the majority of the structures. 18511 00:46:06,003 --> 00:46:06,003 18512 00:46:06,003 --> 00:46:08,872 and lastly, if you are on 18513 00:46:08,872 --> 00:46:10,578 southwest 13th street looking 18514 00:46:10,578 --> 00:46:11,778 towards archer road which is 18515 00:46:11,778 --> 00:46:15,712 past the dna bridge, the trees 18516 00:46:15,712 --> 00:46:15,712 18517 00:46:15,712 --> 00:46:17,580 on the left are the smaller 18518 00:46:17,580 --> 00:46:20,950 parcels that are part of this. 18519 00:46:20,950 --> 00:46:20,950 18520 00:46:20,950 --> 00:46:23,288 and then just a quick recap of 18521 00:46:23,288 --> 00:46:23,288 18522 00:46:23,288 --> 00:46:25,153 the petition timeline, so there 18523 00:46:25,153 --> 00:46:25,153 18524 00:46:25,153 --> 00:46:26,687 was a pre-application meeting, 18525 00:46:26,687 --> 00:46:26,890 a 18526 00:46:26,890 --> 00:46:28,523 neighborhood workshop, the cit 18527 00:46:28,523 --> 00:46:28,523 y 18528 00:46:28,523 --> 00:46:30,055 staff review and then it went 18529 00:46:30,055 --> 00:46:31,960 before the plan board on 18530 00:46:31,960 --> 00:46:33,107 september 18th. 18531 00:46:33,107 --> 00:46:33,808 now it's before you today for 18532 00:46:33,808 --> 00:46:34,776 the first reading. 18533 00:46:34,776 --> 00:46:36,435 and this is just a quick recap 18534 00:46:36,435 --> 00:46:36,435 18535 00:46:36,435 --> 00:46:37,774 of all the public notice for 18536 00:46:37,774 --> 00:46:40,504 those meetings being held 18537 00:46:40,504 --> 00:46:41,444 including the neighborhood 18538 00:46:41,444 --> 00:46:41,444 workshop. 18539 00:46:41,444 --> 00:46:44,118 the plan board meeting and the 18540 00:46:44,118 --> 00:46:44,118 18541 00:46:44,118 --> 00:46:45,878 city commission meeting 18542 00:46:45,878 --> 00:46:47,088 including property signs, 18543 00:46:47,088 --> 00:46:51,934 postcards and the newspaper ads 18544 00:46:51,934 --> 00:46:51,934 . 18545 00:46:51,934 --> 00:46:53,226 so this petition was reviewed 18546 00:46:53,226 --> 00:46:55,086 using the criteria outlined in 18547 00:46:55,086 --> 00:46:55,086 18548 00:46:55,086 --> 00:46:58,556 section 30-3.13 of the land 18549 00:46:58,556 --> 00:46:59,030 development code and 18550 00:46:59,030 --> 00:47:00,223 corresponding sections of the 18551 00:47:00,223 --> 00:47:01,128 comp plan for the city of 18552 00:47:01,128 --> 00:47:01,128 gainesville. 18553 00:47:01,128 --> 00:47:03,561 the criteria shown on this sli 18554 00:47:03,561 --> 00:47:03,561 de 18555 00:47:03,561 --> 00:47:04,928 are explored in more detail in 18556 00:47:04,928 --> 00:47:04,928 18557 00:47:04,928 --> 00:47:06,929 the backup and staff report. 18558 00:47:06,929 --> 00:47:08,512 I just have a few quick points 18559 00:47:08,512 --> 00:47:08,662 I 18560 00:47:08,662 --> 00:47:09,736 wanted to expand on. 18561 00:47:09,736 --> 00:47:11,506 just to recap, the proposed 18562 00:47:11,506 --> 00:47:15,542 changes to go from umuh to o f 18563 00:47:15,542 --> 00:47:15,542 or 18564 00:47:15,542 --> 00:47:18,712 office, to hit on redevelopment, 18565 00:47:18,712 --> 00:47:18,712 18566 00:47:18,712 --> 00:47:20,240 the site is already developed 18567 00:47:20,240 --> 00:47:22,326 and has established 18568 00:47:22,326 --> 00:47:24,134 streetscapes, multimodal forms 18569 00:47:24,134 --> 00:47:24,134 18570 00:47:24,134 --> 00:47:26,052 of transportation, vehicular a 18571 00:47:26,052 --> 00:47:26,052 nd 18572 00:47:26,052 --> 00:47:27,485 pedestrian circulation and 18573 00:47:27,485 --> 00:47:28,694 building frontage. 18574 00:47:28,694 --> 00:47:29,556 any future development would 18575 00:47:29,556 --> 00:47:31,619 retain the pattern per the 18576 00:47:31,619 --> 00:47:33,401 submittal by the applicant but 18577 00:47:33,401 --> 00:47:33,401 18578 00:47:33,401 --> 00:47:36,464 would still be held to office 18579 00:47:36,464 --> 00:47:39,395 and the proposed md zoning if 18580 00:47:39,395 --> 00:47:40,496 approved in the companion 18581 00:47:40,496 --> 00:47:40,496 application. 18582 00:47:40,496 --> 00:47:45,334 for compatibility, on this map, 18583 00:47:45,334 --> 00:47:45,334 w 18584 00:47:45,334 --> 00:47:48,270 we can see directly to the wes 18585 00:47:48,270 --> 00:47:48,270 t 18586 00:47:48,270 --> 00:47:50,772 where the v.a. Hospital is, tha 18587 00:47:50,772 --> 00:47:50,772 t 18588 00:47:50,772 --> 00:47:52,076 has the office land use. 18589 00:47:52,076 --> 00:47:57,684 so this would let it extend on 18590 00:47:57,684 --> 00:47:57,684 18591 00:47:57,684 --> 00:48:00,620 to the u.f. Health south campu 18592 00:48:00,620 --> 00:48:00,620 s. 18593 00:48:00,620 --> 00:48:02,056 on that compatibility, here is 18594 00:48:02,056 --> 00:48:02,283 a 18595 00:48:02,283 --> 00:48:05,464 table showing other hospital 18596 00:48:05,464 --> 00:48:06,300 complex properties in the city 18597 00:48:06,300 --> 00:48:06,300 18598 00:48:06,300 --> 00:48:08,292 just to kind of show how those 18599 00:48:08,292 --> 00:48:08,292 18600 00:48:08,292 --> 00:48:10,827 have similar land use and zonin 18601 00:48:10,827 --> 00:48:10,827 g 18602 00:48:10,827 --> 00:48:12,028 districts of what the purpose o 18603 00:48:12,028 --> 00:48:12,028 f 18604 00:48:12,028 --> 00:48:14,471 this application is for to have 18605 00:48:14,471 --> 00:48:14,471 18606 00:48:14,471 --> 00:48:16,067 consistency in that. 18607 00:48:16,067 --> 00:48:18,477 so a couple are listed here, 18608 00:48:18,477 --> 00:48:19,801 including like north florida, 18609 00:48:19,801 --> 00:48:23,408 the v.a. Hospital, hca archer, 18610 00:48:23,408 --> 00:48:23,408 18611 00:48:23,408 --> 00:48:24,374 showing they also have that 18612 00:48:24,374 --> 00:48:25,812 office land use designation. 18613 00:48:25,812 --> 00:48:28,681 and with the companion rezoning 18614 00:48:28,681 --> 00:48:28,681 18615 00:48:28,681 --> 00:48:29,877 application, the medical 18616 00:48:29,877 --> 00:48:29,877 services. 18617 00:48:29,877 --> 00:48:38,553 and then to touch on conformance 18618 00:48:38,553 --> 00:48:38,553 18619 00:48:38,553 --> 00:48:40,422 with the land use categories, 18620 00:48:40,422 --> 00:48:42,292 this is just a brief summary o 18621 00:48:42,292 --> 00:48:42,292 f 18622 00:48:42,292 --> 00:48:43,499 some of the differences between 18623 00:48:43,499 --> 00:48:43,499 18624 00:48:43,499 --> 00:48:45,036 the current land use category 18625 00:48:45,036 --> 00:48:46,000 and the proposed one. 18626 00:48:46,000 --> 00:48:47,713 this is taken from the future 18627 00:48:47,713 --> 00:48:48,477 land use element of the 18628 00:48:48,477 --> 00:48:49,828 comprehensive plan. 18629 00:48:49,828 --> 00:48:55,310 policy. 18630 00:48:55,310 --> 00:48:57,039 so when comparing them with 18631 00:48:57,039 --> 00:48:58,712 highlight, umuh which is the 18632 00:48:58,712 --> 00:49:00,982 current one has a six-story 18633 00:49:00,982 --> 00:49:03,414 maximum, eight stories with 18634 00:49:03,414 --> 00:49:03,414 bonus. 18635 00:49:03,414 --> 00:49:05,610 office has a five-story maximum 18636 00:49:05,610 --> 00:49:05,610 18637 00:49:05,610 --> 00:49:07,819 and then it also has the 18638 00:49:07,819 --> 00:49:09,861 addition of specifically for 18639 00:49:09,861 --> 00:49:11,156 large scale medical facilities 18640 00:49:11,156 --> 00:49:11,156 18641 00:49:11,156 --> 00:49:13,691 that are located in medical 18642 00:49:13,691 --> 00:49:17,061 services zoning, they can go u 18643 00:49:17,061 --> 00:49:17,061 p 18644 00:49:17,061 --> 00:49:17,900 to 14 stories but they have to 18645 00:49:17,900 --> 00:49:17,900 18646 00:49:17,900 --> 00:49:19,499 have a special use permit whic 18647 00:49:19,499 --> 00:49:19,499 h 18648 00:49:19,499 --> 00:49:21,766 is a special review process. 18649 00:49:21,766 --> 00:49:23,431 those also go before the city 18650 00:49:23,431 --> 00:49:24,399 plan board. 18651 00:49:24,399 --> 00:49:25,497 just something to keep in m 18652 00:49:25,497 --> 00:49:28,340 with that. 18653 00:49:28,340 --> 00:49:31,499 and in addition, this petition 18654 00:49:31,499 --> 00:49:31,499 18655 00:49:31,499 --> 00:49:32,477 specifically is just for the 18656 00:49:32,477 --> 00:49:34,058 land use but I did want to 18657 00:49:34,058 --> 00:49:36,849 provide context that the next 18658 00:49:36,849 --> 00:49:38,614 petition will be for the zonin 18659 00:49:38,614 --> 00:49:38,614 g. 18660 00:49:38,614 --> 00:49:39,584 per our land development code 18661 00:49:39,584 --> 00:49:41,685 and comprehensive plan, the onl 18662 00:49:41,685 --> 00:49:41,685 y 18663 00:49:41,685 --> 00:49:42,785 future land use category that 18664 00:49:42,785 --> 00:49:45,383 allows for the proposed medical 18665 00:49:45,383 --> 00:49:45,383 18666 00:49:45,383 --> 00:49:46,726 services zoning is the office 18667 00:49:46,726 --> 00:49:47,260 land use. 18668 00:49:47,260 --> 00:49:48,912 so just important to keep in 18669 00:49:48,912 --> 00:49:52,297 mind for compatibility purpose 18670 00:49:52,297 --> 00:49:52,297 s. 18671 00:49:52,297 --> 00:49:53,860 and my last point on this is t 18672 00:49:53,860 --> 00:49:53,860 he 18673 00:49:53,860 --> 00:49:55,363 office land use in our 18674 00:49:55,363 --> 00:49:56,333 comprehensive plan does 18675 00:49:56,333 --> 00:50:00,500 highlight that it is for like 18676 00:50:00,500 --> 00:50:02,078 hospital uses, as one of the 18677 00:50:02,078 --> 00:50:04,537 parts that it's for. 18678 00:50:04,537 --> 00:50:05,538 in addition to that, the 18679 00:50:05,538 --> 00:50:08,042 specific use of hospital is onl 18680 00:50:08,042 --> 00:50:08,042 y 18681 00:50:08,042 --> 00:50:10,241 permitted in that medical 18682 00:50:10,241 --> 00:50:11,781 services zoning which is only 18683 00:50:11,781 --> 00:50:13,318 allowed in the office land use 18684 00:50:13,318 --> 00:50:13,318 . 18685 00:50:13,318 --> 00:50:14,817 so just to connect all the dot 18686 00:50:14,817 --> 00:50:14,817 s 18687 00:50:14,817 --> 00:50:18,125 on that. 18688 00:50:18,125 --> 00:50:20,424 this was just a broader map to 18689 00:50:20,424 --> 00:50:20,424 18690 00:50:20,424 --> 00:50:22,738 use if needed. 18691 00:50:22,738 --> 00:50:24,259 and that brings us to the end, 18692 00:50:24,259 --> 00:50:24,259 18693 00:50:24,259 --> 00:50:25,898 so based on the review of this 18694 00:50:25,898 --> 00:50:25,898 18695 00:50:25,898 --> 00:50:26,862 criteria, staff recommends 18696 00:50:26,862 --> 00:50:28,965 approval of this petition. 18697 00:50:28,965 --> 00:50:30,635 and the city plan board on 18698 00:50:30,635 --> 00:50:33,618 december 18th, 2025 voted 6-0 18699 00:50:33,618 --> 00:50:35,072 to recommend approval of 18700 00:50:35,072 --> 00:50:39,775 petition ld 25-000104 as well. 18701 00:50:39,775 --> 00:50:39,775 18702 00:50:39,775 --> 00:50:40,875 we are available for any 18703 00:50:40,875 --> 00:50:40,875 questions. 18704 00:50:40,875 --> 00:50:42,850 and the applicant also has a 18705 00:50:42,850 --> 00:50:42,850 presentation. 18706 00:50:42,850 --> 00:50:44,747 >> mayor: okay. 18707 00:50:44,747 --> 00:50:45,280 >> thank you. 18708 00:50:45,280 --> 00:50:46,315 >> mayor: thank you. 18709 00:50:46,315 --> 00:50:48,185 the applicant want to come up 18710 00:50:48,185 --> 00:50:53,221 and walk us through it? 18711 00:50:53,221 --> 00:50:54,847 >> good evening, mr. Mayor, 18712 00:50:54,847 --> 00:50:54,847 commissioners. 18713 00:50:54,847 --> 00:51:00,661 ryan thompson, mv5, the agency 18714 00:51:00,661 --> 00:51:00,661 18715 00:51:00,661 --> 00:51:03,434 agent for the applicant. 18716 00:51:03,434 --> 00:51:06,134 essentially we're here to allow 18717 00:51:06,134 --> 00:51:06,134 18718 00:51:06,134 --> 00:51:07,418 this property to develop like 18719 00:51:07,418 --> 00:51:09,109 all of their hospital campuses 18720 00:51:09,109 --> 00:51:09,109 18721 00:51:09,109 --> 00:51:10,339 in the city of gainesville. 18722 00:51:10,339 --> 00:51:15,907 when the city went through the 18723 00:51:15,907 --> 00:51:15,907 18724 00:51:15,907 --> 00:51:23,023 transect zone it was the u9. 18725 00:51:23,023 --> 00:51:25,091 the previous zoning district 18726 00:51:25,091 --> 00:51:26,825 standards, there's a concern 18727 00:51:26,825 --> 00:51:32,336 that there may be some 18728 00:51:32,336 --> 00:51:35,512 conformance challenges with th 18729 00:51:35,512 --> 00:51:35,512 e 18730 00:51:35,512 --> 00:51:35,512 property. 18731 00:51:35,512 --> 00:51:37,274 and we just want to make sure 18732 00:51:37,274 --> 00:51:38,906 that none of that is the case. 18733 00:51:38,906 --> 00:51:38,906 18734 00:51:38,906 --> 00:51:41,775 then we also want to maximize 18735 00:51:41,775 --> 00:51:45,507 the opportunities on this site 18736 00:51:45,507 --> 00:51:45,507 18737 00:51:45,507 --> 00:51:47,118 for u.f. Health and our 18738 00:51:47,118 --> 00:51:47,118 community. 18739 00:51:47,118 --> 00:51:54,688 the first application is -- and 18740 00:51:54,688 --> 00:51:54,688 18741 00:51:54,688 --> 00:51:56,425 by the way, I do have a combine 18742 00:51:56,425 --> 00:51:56,425 d 18743 00:51:56,425 --> 00:51:57,964 presentation if that's okay wit 18744 00:51:57,964 --> 00:51:57,964 h 18745 00:51:57,964 --> 00:51:58,713 this commission. 18746 00:51:58,713 --> 00:51:58,713 okay. 18747 00:51:58,713 --> 00:52:03,556 the first application is for 18748 00:52:03,556 --> 00:52:04,194 comprehensive plan amendment 18749 00:52:04,194 --> 00:52:07,159 from umuh to office. 18750 00:52:07,159 --> 00:52:09,112 and a rezoning from u9 to 18751 00:52:09,112 --> 00:52:10,538 medical services. 18752 00:52:10,538 --> 00:52:13,039 and again, we're just looking 18753 00:52:13,039 --> 00:52:14,305 for what all other hospital 18754 00:52:14,305 --> 00:52:18,321 campuses have within the city o 18755 00:52:18,321 --> 00:52:18,321 f 18756 00:52:18,321 --> 00:52:18,321 gainesville. 18757 00:52:18,321 --> 00:52:21,041 we did properly notice the 18758 00:52:21,041 --> 00:52:22,950 public for our neighborhood 18759 00:52:22,950 --> 00:52:22,950 workshop. 18760 00:52:22,950 --> 00:52:25,649 we had four attendees, 18761 00:52:25,649 --> 00:52:27,951 discussions about the zoning 18762 00:52:27,951 --> 00:52:29,160 change and what is most 18763 00:52:29,160 --> 00:52:31,787 appropriate for this site given 18764 00:52:31,787 --> 00:52:31,787 18765 00:52:31,787 --> 00:52:32,656 the context of development 18766 00:52:32,656 --> 00:52:34,959 that's already occurred. 18767 00:52:34,959 --> 00:52:36,393 we have followed the city's 18768 00:52:36,393 --> 00:52:39,357 process for small scale 18769 00:52:39,357 --> 00:52:40,580 comprehensive plan amendment a 18770 00:52:40,580 --> 00:52:40,580 nd 18771 00:52:40,580 --> 00:52:45,127 rezoning applications. 18772 00:52:45,127 --> 00:52:47,040 the justification for the 18773 00:52:47,040 --> 00:52:48,873 request, there's multiple point 18774 00:52:48,873 --> 00:52:48,873 s 18775 00:52:48,873 --> 00:52:50,510 here that should be made. 18776 00:52:50,510 --> 00:52:52,709 one that's not on here is the 18777 00:52:52,709 --> 00:52:54,149 demand for hospital beds is 18778 00:52:54,149 --> 00:52:57,095 going up as our population age 18779 00:52:57,095 --> 00:52:57,095 s. 18780 00:52:57,095 --> 00:53:00,048 and they desire -- and industry 18781 00:53:00,048 --> 00:53:00,048 18782 00:53:00,048 --> 00:53:02,119 trends that are going towards 18783 00:53:02,119 --> 00:53:03,228 single occupancy rooms. 18784 00:53:03,228 --> 00:53:04,755 so the amount of square footag 18785 00:53:04,755 --> 00:53:04,755 e 18786 00:53:04,755 --> 00:53:06,157 in the facilities that u.f. 18787 00:53:06,157 --> 00:53:08,791 health has currently will reduc 18788 00:53:08,791 --> 00:53:08,791 e 18789 00:53:08,791 --> 00:53:11,867 the number of people that they 18790 00:53:11,867 --> 00:53:11,867 18791 00:53:11,867 --> 00:53:14,271 will be able to treat, switching 18792 00:53:14,271 --> 00:53:14,271 18793 00:53:14,271 --> 00:53:16,665 from multiple occupant rooms t 18794 00:53:16,665 --> 00:53:16,665 o 18795 00:53:16,665 --> 00:53:21,273 single occupant rooms. 18796 00:53:21,273 --> 00:53:22,580 and they are obviously 18797 00:53:22,580 --> 00:53:24,109 constrained in their capacity 18798 00:53:24,109 --> 00:53:26,417 with their existing facilities. 18799 00:53:26,417 --> 00:53:26,417 18800 00:53:26,417 --> 00:53:28,181 the south campus is 18801 00:53:28,181 --> 00:53:29,579 substantially built and site 18802 00:53:29,579 --> 00:53:29,579 constrained. 18803 00:53:29,579 --> 00:53:32,049 redevelopment on this site nee 18804 00:53:32,049 --> 00:53:32,049 ds 18805 00:53:32,049 --> 00:53:35,545 to occur vertically. 18806 00:53:35,545 --> 00:53:37,853 and on site hospitals were 18807 00:53:37,853 --> 00:53:40,790 permitted under umu2 standards 18808 00:53:40,790 --> 00:53:40,790 18809 00:53:40,790 --> 00:53:42,459 as I mentioned before. 18810 00:53:42,459 --> 00:53:43,763 and this is the only hospita 18811 00:53:43,763 --> 00:53:47,133 campus in the city of 18812 00:53:47,133 --> 00:53:47,695 gainesville that does not have 18813 00:53:47,695 --> 00:53:47,695 18814 00:53:47,695 --> 00:53:50,331 the offic land use designation 18815 00:53:50,331 --> 00:53:50,331 18816 00:53:50,331 --> 00:53:53,266 of medical services district. 18817 00:53:53,266 --> 00:53:55,131 and the md zoning district was 18818 00:53:55,131 --> 00:53:55,131 18819 00:53:55,131 --> 00:53:56,877 specifically intended for these 18820 00:53:56,877 --> 00:53:56,877 18821 00:53:56,877 --> 00:54:02,353 types of facilities. 18822 00:54:02,353 --> 00:54:03,823 this is a context map of the 18823 00:54:03,823 --> 00:54:03,823 site. 18824 00:54:03,823 --> 00:54:06,713 I will work through these 18825 00:54:06,713 --> 00:54:08,919 quickly due to staff's thorough 18826 00:54:08,919 --> 00:54:08,919 18827 00:54:08,919 --> 00:54:08,919 presentation. 18828 00:54:08,919 --> 00:54:12,358 we're bound to the north by 18829 00:54:12,358 --> 00:54:14,390 archer road and to the east by 18830 00:54:14,390 --> 00:54:14,390 18831 00:54:14,390 --> 00:54:16,907 13th street. 18832 00:54:16,907 --> 00:54:19,860 and immediately south of the 18833 00:54:19,860 --> 00:54:21,163 university of florida main 18834 00:54:21,163 --> 00:54:21,163 campus. 18835 00:54:21,163 --> 00:54:24,115 it's effectively an extension o 18836 00:54:24,115 --> 00:54:24,115 f 18837 00:54:24,115 --> 00:54:27,065 u.f. Health facilities there. 18838 00:54:27,065 --> 00:54:29,371 this is a close-up of the site. 18839 00:54:29,371 --> 00:54:29,371 18840 00:54:29,371 --> 00:54:31,877 again, the adjacent roadways. 18841 00:54:31,877 --> 00:54:35,281 u.f. Health shands to the north 18842 00:54:35,281 --> 00:54:35,281 , 18843 00:54:35,281 --> 00:54:37,011 the v.a. Hospital which has the 18844 00:54:37,011 --> 00:54:37,011 18845 00:54:37,011 --> 00:54:39,748 office land use and medical 18846 00:54:39,748 --> 00:54:41,949 services zoning to the west. 18847 00:54:41,949 --> 00:54:46,253 and typically, apartments or 18848 00:54:46,253 --> 00:54:48,083 auto-oriented retail type uses 18849 00:54:48,083 --> 00:54:48,083 18850 00:54:48,083 --> 00:54:52,270 to the east and to the south. 18851 00:54:52,270 --> 00:54:54,123 we did a little bit of site 18852 00:54:54,123 --> 00:54:55,201 assessment on the property. 18853 00:54:55,201 --> 00:54:57,105 there are two primary areas tha 18854 00:54:57,105 --> 00:54:57,105 t 18855 00:54:57,105 --> 00:54:58,427 would develop on this site. 18856 00:54:58,427 --> 00:55:00,403 there's a surface parking lot 18857 00:55:00,403 --> 00:55:02,673 along 16th to the west and 18858 00:55:02,673 --> 00:55:04,537 then a surface parking lot and 18859 00:55:04,537 --> 00:55:04,537 18860 00:55:04,537 --> 00:55:08,607 one story building along 13th 18861 00:55:08,607 --> 00:55:08,607 street. 18862 00:55:08,607 --> 00:55:11,979 you can see that this site is 18863 00:55:11,979 --> 00:55:13,121 substantially developed. 18864 00:55:13,121 --> 00:55:16,585 it's already established. 18865 00:55:16,585 --> 00:55:17,991 the frontage and streetscape 18866 00:55:17,991 --> 00:55:19,287 along archer road and 13th 18867 00:55:19,287 --> 00:55:20,497 street and redevelopment on the 18868 00:55:20,497 --> 00:55:20,497 18869 00:55:20,497 --> 00:55:21,632 site would continue in that 18870 00:55:21,632 --> 00:55:21,632 pattern. 18871 00:55:21,632 --> 00:55:25,974 there is substantial pedestria 18872 00:55:25,974 --> 00:55:25,974 n 18873 00:55:25,974 --> 00:55:29,029 facilities enter into the site 18874 00:55:29,029 --> 00:55:29,029 18875 00:55:29,029 --> 00:55:30,476 with wide sidewalks, some of 18876 00:55:30,476 --> 00:55:32,439 which are even covered and 18877 00:55:32,439 --> 00:55:34,635 amenities around the stormwate 18878 00:55:34,635 --> 00:55:34,635 r 18879 00:55:34,635 --> 00:55:37,905 ponds as well. 18880 00:55:37,905 --> 00:55:39,411 u.f. Health has done a 18881 00:55:39,411 --> 00:55:41,642 conceptual master plan as 18882 00:55:41,642 --> 00:55:42,894 identified these two areas for 18883 00:55:42,894 --> 00:55:42,894 18884 00:55:42,894 --> 00:55:42,894 development. 18885 00:55:42,894 --> 00:55:50,626 this is the existing land use of 18886 00:55:50,626 --> 00:55:50,626 18887 00:55:50,626 --> 00:55:51,622 the property. 18888 00:55:51,622 --> 00:55:55,211 it's umuh high as described in 18889 00:55:55,211 --> 00:55:55,211 18890 00:55:55,211 --> 00:55:56,307 the comprehensive plan. 18891 00:55:56,307 --> 00:55:57,553 it's aligned with multi-family 18892 00:55:57,553 --> 00:55:57,553 18893 00:55:57,553 --> 00:56:00,366 and commercial uses which 18894 00:56:00,366 --> 00:56:02,509 typically abut the university of 18895 00:56:02,509 --> 00:56:02,509 18896 00:56:02,509 --> 00:56:05,099 florida except in this case. 18897 00:56:05,099 --> 00:56:08,037 and the proposed is office whi 18898 00:56:08,037 --> 00:56:08,037 ch 18899 00:56:08,037 --> 00:56:13,141 is specifically allows hospita 18900 00:56:13,141 --> 00:56:13,141 ls 18901 00:56:13,141 --> 00:56:14,749 and medical uses. 18902 00:56:14,749 --> 00:56:17,481 the existing zoning is u9 which 18903 00:56:17,481 --> 00:56:17,481 18904 00:56:17,481 --> 00:56:19,541 is characterized in the land 18905 00:56:19,541 --> 00:56:20,851 development code for high 18906 00:56:20,851 --> 00:56:21,553 density residential and 18907 00:56:21,553 --> 00:56:23,157 commercial uses. 18908 00:56:23,157 --> 00:56:24,935 and the proposed md zoning 18909 00:56:24,935 --> 00:56:26,593 district is the only zoning 18910 00:56:26,593 --> 00:56:30,259 district specific for hospitals 18911 00:56:30,259 --> 00:56:30,259 . 18912 00:56:30,259 --> 00:56:31,587 and it's consistent with all 18913 00:56:31,587 --> 00:56:34,528 others in the city. 18914 00:56:34,528 --> 00:56:37,273 this is a step back from that 18915 00:56:37,273 --> 00:56:37,933 zoning map. 18916 00:56:37,933 --> 00:56:40,241 you can see that there are 18917 00:56:40,241 --> 00:56:41,670 medical facilities including t 18918 00:56:41,670 --> 00:56:41,670 he 18919 00:56:41,670 --> 00:56:43,407 v.a. Hospital that are along 18920 00:56:43,407 --> 00:56:45,275 this segment of archer road tha 18921 00:56:45,275 --> 00:56:45,275 t 18922 00:56:45,275 --> 00:56:47,381 share our requested land use a 18923 00:56:47,381 --> 00:56:47,381 nd 18924 00:56:47,381 --> 00:56:47,381 zoning. 18925 00:56:47,381 --> 00:56:50,412 and then looking at the other 18926 00:56:50,412 --> 00:56:53,281 facilities, we have north 18927 00:56:53,281 --> 00:56:55,049 florida to the north. 18928 00:56:55,049 --> 00:56:56,888 we have the v.a. Hospital to o 18929 00:56:56,888 --> 00:56:56,888 ur 18930 00:56:56,888 --> 00:56:56,888 west. 18931 00:56:56,888 --> 00:57:01,391 and we have the new hca facilit 18932 00:57:01,391 --> 00:57:01,391 y 18933 00:57:01,391 --> 00:57:03,195 on archer road and I-75 all 18934 00:57:03,195 --> 00:57:05,329 sharing the office land use and 18935 00:57:05,329 --> 00:57:05,329 18936 00:57:05,329 --> 00:57:07,527 md zoning. 18937 00:57:07,527 --> 00:57:09,393 staff has reviewed the 18938 00:57:09,393 --> 00:57:10,493 applications and found them 18939 00:57:10,493 --> 00:57:11,215 consistent with the 18940 00:57:11,215 --> 00:57:15,405 comprehensive plan. 18941 00:57:15,405 --> 00:57:17,275 this, in fact, would discourag 18942 00:57:17,275 --> 00:57:17,275 e 18943 00:57:17,275 --> 00:57:21,111 urban sprawl being that bewould 18944 00:57:21,111 --> 00:57:21,111 18945 00:57:21,111 --> 00:57:23,285 redevelop an infill and focus o 18946 00:57:23,285 --> 00:57:23,285 n 18947 00:57:23,285 --> 00:57:26,143 maximizing this campus. 18948 00:57:26,143 --> 00:57:29,213 and staff has also found the 18949 00:57:29,213 --> 00:57:30,821 code compliant -- or the 18950 00:57:30,821 --> 00:57:32,287 application compliant with the 18951 00:57:32,287 --> 00:57:32,287 18952 00:57:32,287 --> 00:57:35,285 land development code. 18953 00:57:35,285 --> 00:57:36,321 staff has recommended approval 18954 00:57:36,321 --> 00:57:36,321 18955 00:57:36,321 --> 00:57:37,961 for both the small scale 18956 00:57:37,961 --> 00:57:39,075 comprehensive plan amendment a 18957 00:57:39,075 --> 00:57:39,075 nd 18958 00:57:39,075 --> 00:57:41,167 rezoning applications. 18959 00:57:41,167 --> 00:57:42,131 and the city plan board 18960 00:57:42,131 --> 00:57:43,791 unanimously recommended approva 18961 00:57:43,791 --> 00:57:43,791 l 18962 00:57:43,791 --> 00:57:45,249 in december. 18963 00:57:45,249 --> 00:57:46,503 so with that, I'm happy to 18964 00:57:46,503 --> 00:57:47,272 answer any questions. 18965 00:57:47,272 --> 00:57:48,977 I hope I didn't belabor it too 18966 00:57:48,977 --> 00:57:48,977 18967 00:57:48,977 --> 00:57:48,977 much. 18968 00:57:48,977 --> 00:57:51,139 I know staff's presentation was 18969 00:57:51,139 --> 00:57:51,139 18970 00:57:51,139 --> 00:57:52,667 very thorough. 18971 00:57:52,667 --> 00:57:53,391 thank you very much. 18972 00:57:53,391 --> 00:57:55,251 >> mayor: thank you. 18973 00:57:55,251 --> 00:57:57,339 all right. 18974 00:57:57,339 --> 00:57:58,987 commissioner willits. 18975 00:57:58,987 --> 00:57:59,849 >> some quick questions for 18976 00:57:59,849 --> 00:57:59,849 staff. 18977 00:57:59,849 --> 00:58:03,905 would changing this land use - 18978 00:58:03,905 --> 00:58:03,905 - 18979 00:58:03,905 --> 00:58:06,563 and I guess potentially the 18980 00:58:06,563 --> 00:58:06,563 zoning. 18981 00:58:06,563 --> 00:58:09,866 I have a couple of specific -- 18982 00:58:09,866 --> 00:58:09,866 18983 00:58:09,866 --> 00:58:12,665 >> mayor: hold on a second. 18984 00:58:12,665 --> 00:58:13,995 >> broadcast, we have a screen 18985 00:58:13,995 --> 00:58:13,995 18986 00:58:13,995 --> 00:58:18,701 that shows we are in recess. 18987 00:58:18,701 --> 00:58:21,099 >> the broadcast light is still 18988 00:58:21,099 --> 00:58:21,099 18989 00:58:21,099 --> 00:58:21,099 on. 18990 00:58:21,099 --> 00:58:25,613 >> mayor: yes. 18991 00:58:25,613 --> 00:58:26,675 we just need confirmation that 18992 00:58:26,675 --> 00:58:26,675 18993 00:58:26,675 --> 00:58:28,313 we are definitely broadcasting. 18994 00:58:28,313 --> 00:58:28,313 18995 00:58:28,313 --> 00:58:34,159 >> there's a thumb's up back 18996 00:58:34,159 --> 00:58:34,159 there. 18997 00:58:34,159 --> 00:58:36,117 >> I saw the light on. 18998 00:58:36,117 --> 00:58:36,590 >> mayor: all right. 18999 00:58:36,590 --> 00:58:37,645 if we're comfortable that we 19000 00:58:37,645 --> 00:58:39,485 have a thumb's up, go ahead. 19001 00:58:39,485 --> 00:58:40,329 >> sorry. 19002 00:58:40,329 --> 00:58:43,457 so the changing this to the 19003 00:58:43,457 --> 00:58:45,097 office, potential redevelopment 19004 00:58:45,097 --> 00:58:45,097 , 19005 00:58:45,097 --> 00:58:47,829 would this require -- the answe 19006 00:58:47,829 --> 00:58:47,829 r 19007 00:58:47,829 --> 00:58:49,600 is probably both the current a 19008 00:58:49,600 --> 00:58:49,600 nd 19009 00:58:49,600 --> 00:58:51,333 the proposed. 19010 00:58:51,333 --> 00:58:53,431 putting an additional sidewalk 19011 00:58:53,431 --> 00:58:53,431 19012 00:58:53,431 --> 00:58:54,969 on southwest 14th street on 19013 00:58:54,969 --> 00:58:56,039 the east side of that? 19014 00:58:56,039 --> 00:58:57,325 because right now there's one o 19015 00:58:57,325 --> 00:58:57,325 n 19016 00:58:57,325 --> 00:58:59,203 the west side closer to hotel 19017 00:58:59,203 --> 00:58:59,203 ellio. 19018 00:58:59,203 --> 00:59:03,673 but in the undeveloped one, 19019 00:59:03,673 --> 00:59:05,549 single story building and 19020 00:59:05,549 --> 00:59:06,451 parking lot, there's not a 19021 00:59:06,451 --> 00:59:07,415 sidewalk on that side. 19022 00:59:07,415 --> 00:59:09,626 I would assume both of these 19023 00:59:09,626 --> 00:59:11,819 zonings if redeveloped, they 19024 00:59:11,819 --> 00:59:13,323 would have to build a sidewalk 19025 00:59:13,323 --> 00:59:13,323 19026 00:59:13,323 --> 00:59:14,325 internal to the whole project 19027 00:59:14,325 --> 00:59:16,395 but along 14th street. 19028 00:59:16,395 --> 00:59:18,611 >> yeah, potentially. 19029 00:59:18,611 --> 00:59:21,197 it would come down to the land 19030 00:59:21,197 --> 00:59:21,197 19031 00:59:21,197 --> 00:59:22,431 development review and the sta 19032 00:59:22,431 --> 00:59:22,431 ff 19033 00:59:22,431 --> 00:59:23,291 analysis of that. 19034 00:59:23,291 --> 00:59:25,027 we'd work with transportation 19035 00:59:25,027 --> 00:59:26,233 and evaluate the code 19036 00:59:26,233 --> 00:59:30,252 requirements to verify like wh 19037 00:59:30,252 --> 00:59:30,252 at 19038 00:59:30,252 --> 00:59:32,043 is needed based on the scale a 19039 00:59:32,043 --> 00:59:32,043 nd 19040 00:59:32,043 --> 00:59:34,340 intensity of what is proposed 19041 00:59:34,340 --> 00:59:35,778 for redevelopment. 19042 00:59:35,778 --> 00:59:37,740 >> everything that was already 19043 00:59:37,740 --> 00:59:37,740 19044 00:59:37,740 --> 00:59:41,047 there under the current, you 19045 00:59:41,047 --> 00:59:41,930 know, development, there's a 19046 00:59:41,930 --> 00:59:43,550 sidewalk on every street 19047 00:59:43,550 --> 00:59:45,856 fronting face I believe 19048 00:59:45,856 --> 00:59:48,366 almost -- besides a little pie 19049 00:59:48,366 --> 00:59:48,366 ce 19050 00:59:48,366 --> 00:59:50,798 of 14th ave does not have a 19051 00:59:50,798 --> 00:59:51,525 sidewalk next to it. 19052 00:59:51,525 --> 00:59:53,494 so I just wondered what will 19053 00:59:53,494 --> 00:59:55,796 force -- will that force chang 19054 00:59:55,796 --> 00:59:55,796 es 19055 00:59:55,796 --> 00:59:56,894 on the opposite side. 19056 00:59:56,894 --> 01:00:00,986 so this -- why did we move it t 19057 01:00:00,986 --> 01:00:00,986 o 19058 01:00:00,986 --> 01:00:00,986 this? 19059 01:00:00,986 --> 01:00:04,238 well, we moved to transect 19060 01:00:04,238 --> 01:00:04,238 zones. 19061 01:00:04,238 --> 01:00:05,646 why that parcel? 19062 01:00:05,646 --> 01:00:07,178 how did it kind of get there 19063 01:00:07,178 --> 01:00:10,142 instead of being -- I know 19064 01:00:10,142 --> 01:00:12,020 decades ago or not that long 19065 01:00:12,020 --> 01:00:13,788 ago, there was an old hotel on 19066 01:00:13,788 --> 01:00:13,788 19067 01:00:13,788 --> 01:00:17,686 the site, which is much more a 19068 01:00:17,686 --> 01:00:17,686 n 19069 01:00:17,686 --> 01:00:20,948 ofurban use than office. 19070 01:00:20,948 --> 01:00:21,468 >> yes. 19071 01:00:21,468 --> 01:00:22,376 from my understanding from the 19072 01:00:22,376 --> 01:00:22,376 19073 01:00:22,376 --> 01:00:23,928 research for this staff report, 19074 01:00:23,928 --> 01:00:23,928 19075 01:00:23,928 --> 01:00:27,438 we looked back so prior to 2017 19076 01:00:27,438 --> 01:00:27,438 19077 01:00:27,438 --> 01:00:29,832 it was the umu-2. 19078 01:00:29,832 --> 01:00:33,638 and in 2017 when the transect 19079 01:00:33,638 --> 01:00:34,832 zoning and associated land use 19080 01:00:34,832 --> 01:00:34,832 19081 01:00:34,832 --> 01:00:37,042 categories were implemented, 19082 01:00:37,042 --> 01:00:40,980 with the comprehensive plan, t 19083 01:00:40,980 --> 01:00:40,980 he 19084 01:00:40,980 --> 01:00:42,608 umuh written in that category I 19085 01:00:42,608 --> 01:00:42,608 s 19086 01:00:42,608 --> 01:00:45,576 to use it for research and 19087 01:00:45,576 --> 01:00:47,016 development along the periphery 19088 01:00:47,016 --> 01:00:47,016 19089 01:00:47,016 --> 01:00:48,322 of u.f. Campus along the east 19090 01:00:48,322 --> 01:00:48,910 and west. 19091 01:00:48,910 --> 01:00:50,552 and I think that's where it ki 19092 01:00:50,552 --> 01:00:50,552 nd 19093 01:00:50,552 --> 01:00:52,616 of fell looking that way in 19094 01:00:52,616 --> 01:00:55,467 terms of the analysis of where 19095 01:00:55,467 --> 01:00:55,467 19096 01:00:55,467 --> 01:00:56,994 the campus was. 19097 01:00:56,994 --> 01:00:58,830 so I think that's why it was 19098 01:00:58,830 --> 01:01:02,096 rezoned that way. 19099 01:01:02,096 --> 01:01:03,772 that's what we found in the 19100 01:01:03,772 --> 01:01:03,772 analysis. 19101 01:01:03,772 --> 01:01:05,628 >> mayor: that rezoning, did I 19102 01:01:05,628 --> 01:01:05,628 t 19103 01:01:05,628 --> 01:01:08,934 happen in between the building 19104 01:01:08,934 --> 01:01:08,934 19105 01:01:08,934 --> 01:01:10,172 of the cancer center and the 19106 01:01:10,172 --> 01:01:13,412 heart and vascular hvn? 19107 01:01:13,412 --> 01:01:14,944 I'm trying to remember the 19108 01:01:14,944 --> 01:01:14,944 order. 19109 01:01:14,944 --> 01:01:18,382 I'm trying to remember when th 19110 01:01:18,382 --> 01:01:18,382 at 19111 01:01:18,382 --> 01:01:19,414 was done? 19112 01:01:19,414 --> 01:01:20,982 are they eight story hospitals 19113 01:01:20,982 --> 01:01:20,982 19114 01:01:20,982 --> 01:01:29,060 and this opens up to a 14 story 19115 01:01:29,060 --> 01:01:29,060 ? 19116 01:01:29,060 --> 01:01:31,828 >> I'm dial trying to remember. 19117 01:01:31,828 --> 01:01:31,828 19118 01:01:31,828 --> 01:01:33,164 the built environment is 19119 01:01:33,164 --> 01:01:34,063 determined by the rules. 19120 01:01:34,063 --> 01:01:35,088 >> certainly, mr. Mayor, thank 19121 01:01:35,088 --> 01:01:35,088 19122 01:01:35,088 --> 01:01:35,088 you. 19123 01:01:35,088 --> 01:01:43,604 so the cancer hospital and the 19124 01:01:43,604 --> 01:01:43,604 19125 01:01:43,604 --> 01:01:45,676 13th garage were in 2009. 19126 01:01:45,676 --> 01:01:51,768 the hvn hospital was -- 19127 01:01:51,768 --> 01:01:53,018 >> it was before that. 19128 01:01:53,018 --> 01:01:56,090 >> they were both under the umu 19129 01:01:56,090 --> 01:01:56,090 19130 01:01:56,090 --> 01:01:56,548 2 standards. 19131 01:01:56,548 --> 01:01:58,252 >> and now looking to the next. 19132 01:01:58,252 --> 01:01:58,252 19133 01:01:58,252 --> 01:01:59,688 >> mr. Mayor, if I may opine o 19134 01:01:59,688 --> 01:01:59,688 n 19135 01:01:59,688 --> 01:02:01,762 your previous question. 19136 01:02:01,762 --> 01:02:03,160 certainly, they would put 19137 01:02:03,160 --> 01:02:04,060 sidewalks there when that 19138 01:02:04,060 --> 01:02:04,826 portion of the site is 19139 01:02:04,826 --> 01:02:09,308 redeveloped regardless of what 19140 01:02:09,308 --> 01:02:09,308 19141 01:02:09,308 --> 01:02:12,922 the uldc or land development 19142 01:02:12,922 --> 01:02:13,354 code requires. 19143 01:02:13,354 --> 01:02:15,138 >> I was wondering because 19144 01:02:15,138 --> 01:02:16,419 southwest 14th ave swimming 19145 01:02:16,419 --> 01:02:18,512 pools to 14th street doesn't 19146 01:02:18,512 --> 01:02:19,642 have sidewalks. 19147 01:02:19,642 --> 01:02:21,150 as someone who has walked that 19148 01:02:21,150 --> 01:02:21,150 19149 01:02:21,150 --> 01:02:23,342 site many, many times as it's 19150 01:02:23,342 --> 01:02:24,684 between work and home, it is 19151 01:02:24,684 --> 01:02:26,016 frustrating there is not a 19152 01:02:26,016 --> 01:02:27,280 sidewalk on southwest 14th. 19153 01:02:27,280 --> 01:02:28,482 I understand maybe that's not 19154 01:02:28,482 --> 01:02:29,720 where you want people to walk 19155 01:02:29,720 --> 01:02:30,542 because that's where the 19156 01:02:30,542 --> 01:02:31,652 ambulances are coming in and 19157 01:02:31,652 --> 01:02:31,652 out. 19158 01:02:31,652 --> 01:02:33,885 but the truth is, you know -- 19159 01:02:33,885 --> 01:02:34,784 >> I understand. 19160 01:02:34,784 --> 01:02:35,820 >> people would prefer to walk 19161 01:02:35,820 --> 01:02:35,820 19162 01:02:35,820 --> 01:02:36,930 through the middle of a 19163 01:02:36,930 --> 01:02:37,794 beautiful campus than down on 19164 01:02:37,794 --> 01:02:39,858 some of the arterial roads. 19165 01:02:39,858 --> 01:02:40,468 >> certainly. 19166 01:02:40,468 --> 01:02:41,598 >> that's why I asked about the 19167 01:02:41,598 --> 01:02:41,598 19168 01:02:41,598 --> 01:02:45,666 internal because I know I use I 19169 01:02:45,666 --> 01:02:45,666 t 19170 01:02:45,666 --> 01:02:47,401 to cut through. 19171 01:02:47,401 --> 01:02:48,402 it's very pleasant. 19172 01:02:48,402 --> 01:02:51,134 fountains and ponds and ducks o 19173 01:02:51,134 --> 01:02:51,134 r 19174 01:02:51,134 --> 01:02:51,134 whatever. 19175 01:02:51,134 --> 01:02:52,780 >> certainly. 19176 01:02:52,780 --> 01:02:53,380 thank you, mr. Mayor. 19177 01:02:53,380 --> 01:02:54,690 >> and then so I think that's 19178 01:02:54,690 --> 01:02:54,690 it. 19179 01:02:54,690 --> 01:02:57,386 this could potentially be a muc 19180 01:02:57,386 --> 01:02:57,386 h 19181 01:02:57,386 --> 01:02:58,572 larger tower on that southeast 19182 01:02:58,572 --> 01:02:58,572 19183 01:02:58,572 --> 01:02:58,572 corner. 19184 01:02:58,572 --> 01:03:00,605 like it could be a 14 story 19185 01:03:00,605 --> 01:03:05,486 hospital or support office for 19186 01:03:05,486 --> 01:03:05,584 a 19187 01:03:05,584 --> 01:03:08,698 hospital in the future. 19188 01:03:08,698 --> 01:03:08,998 >> yes. 19189 01:03:08,998 --> 01:03:12,459 and just as confirmation, with 19190 01:03:12,459 --> 01:03:12,459 19191 01:03:12,459 --> 01:03:14,866 the office land use if approve 19192 01:03:14,866 --> 01:03:14,866 d, 19193 01:03:14,866 --> 01:03:16,410 they would have to apply for a 19194 01:03:16,410 --> 01:03:16,410 19195 01:03:16,410 --> 01:03:18,694 special use permit. 19196 01:03:18,694 --> 01:03:19,804 that would have to go through 19197 01:03:19,804 --> 01:03:20,542 staff review. 19198 01:03:20,542 --> 01:03:22,978 there would be public engagemen 19199 01:03:22,978 --> 01:03:22,978 t 19200 01:03:22,978 --> 01:03:24,042 associated with that, a 19201 01:03:24,042 --> 01:03:25,168 neighborhood workshop. 19202 01:03:25,168 --> 01:03:27,444 and it would go before the cit 19203 01:03:27,444 --> 01:03:27,444 y 19204 01:03:27,444 --> 01:03:27,902 plan board. 19205 01:03:27,902 --> 01:03:29,302 >> but not before the city 19206 01:03:29,302 --> 01:03:30,414 commission because special use 19207 01:03:30,414 --> 01:03:30,414 19208 01:03:30,414 --> 01:03:32,476 permits are only done -- 19209 01:03:32,476 --> 01:03:33,696 >> correct, yeah. 19210 01:03:33,696 --> 01:03:34,408 >> through the plan board. 19211 01:03:34,408 --> 01:03:35,850 well, this all makes sense. 19212 01:03:35,850 --> 01:03:37,386 I did see when the sign got 19213 01:03:37,386 --> 01:03:38,592 stakeholder and asked city sta 19214 01:03:38,592 --> 01:03:38,592 ff 19215 01:03:38,592 --> 01:03:40,560 so I got a little head's up 19216 01:03:40,560 --> 01:03:41,790 about some of this internal. 19217 01:03:41,790 --> 01:03:45,234 I'm glad some members of the 19218 01:03:45,234 --> 01:03:46,204 public went to the meeting at 19219 01:03:46,204 --> 01:03:49,534 least through zoom or teams. 19220 01:03:49,534 --> 01:03:50,730 it is a little weird, but it 19221 01:03:50,730 --> 01:03:52,602 does make sense that if office 19222 01:03:52,602 --> 01:03:52,602 19223 01:03:52,602 --> 01:03:53,934 is more appropriate, like the 19224 01:03:53,934 --> 01:03:57,206 other ones. 19225 01:03:57,206 --> 01:03:58,146 do you know this personally in 19226 01:03:58,146 --> 01:03:58,146 19227 01:03:58,146 --> 01:03:58,872 your district? 19228 01:03:58,872 --> 01:04:00,184 >> uh-huh. 19229 01:04:00,184 --> 01:04:01,410 >> that very little corner. 19230 01:04:01,410 --> 01:04:02,280 I don't think they are going t 19231 01:04:02,280 --> 01:04:02,280 o 19232 01:04:02,280 --> 01:04:03,038 build anything on it. 19233 01:04:03,038 --> 01:04:05,348 on my corner, they might. 19234 01:04:05,348 --> 01:04:10,391 with that, I would like to mov 19235 01:04:10,391 --> 01:04:10,391 e 19236 01:04:10,391 --> 01:04:13,686 adoption of 2025-992, u.f. 19237 01:04:13,686 --> 01:04:15,458 health south campus land use 19238 01:04:15,458 --> 01:04:15,458 change. 19239 01:04:15,458 --> 01:04:17,537 >> second. 19240 01:04:17,537 --> 01:04:18,390 >> mayor: motion and second. 19241 01:04:18,390 --> 01:04:19,600 commissioner -- excuse me, 19242 01:04:19,600 --> 01:04:23,809 mr. Manager. 19243 01:04:23,809 --> 01:04:24,524 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 19244 01:04:24,524 --> 01:04:27,602 mr. Thompson answered the 19245 01:04:27,602 --> 01:04:27,602 question. 19246 01:04:27,602 --> 01:04:29,473 I think I wrote the staff repor 19247 01:04:29,473 --> 01:04:29,473 t 19248 01:04:29,473 --> 01:04:31,331 back in the day but mr. Thompso 19249 01:04:31,331 --> 01:04:31,331 n 19250 01:04:31,331 --> 01:04:32,008 answered it. 19251 01:04:32,008 --> 01:04:32,837 >> mayor: commissioner eastman. 19252 01:04:32,837 --> 01:04:32,837 19253 01:04:32,837 --> 01:04:33,605 >> you answered a lot of my 19254 01:04:33,605 --> 01:04:33,605 questions. 19255 01:04:33,605 --> 01:04:36,808 I was confused similarly why we 19256 01:04:36,808 --> 01:04:36,808 19257 01:04:36,808 --> 01:04:41,818 would be going down in intense 19258 01:04:41,818 --> 01:04:41,818 19259 01:04:41,818 --> 01:04:42,390 to medical. 19260 01:04:42,390 --> 01:04:44,793 first it says here in permitted 19261 01:04:44,793 --> 01:04:44,793 19262 01:04:44,793 --> 01:04:46,453 use, hospital not listed. 19263 01:04:46,453 --> 01:04:47,860 health services permitted. 19264 01:04:47,860 --> 01:04:49,156 I was looking through our code. 19265 01:04:49,156 --> 01:04:49,156 19266 01:04:49,156 --> 01:04:51,042 is a hospital considered health 19267 01:04:51,042 --> 01:04:51,042 19268 01:04:51,042 --> 01:04:52,358 services because it's two 19269 01:04:52,358 --> 01:04:53,626 different sections of our code. 19270 01:04:53,626 --> 01:04:53,626 19271 01:04:53,626 --> 01:04:54,265 >> yeah. 19272 01:04:54,265 --> 01:04:55,626 that's a great question that w 19273 01:04:55,626 --> 01:04:55,626 e 19274 01:04:55,626 --> 01:04:58,370 looked into as well. 19275 01:04:58,370 --> 01:05:00,966 so for context, urban 9, the 19276 01:05:00,966 --> 01:05:02,064 current zoning district allows 19277 01:05:02,064 --> 01:05:02,064 19278 01:05:02,064 --> 01:05:03,042 for health services. 19279 01:05:03,042 --> 01:05:04,130 health services in our land 19280 01:05:04,130 --> 01:05:06,670 development code is defined as 19281 01:05:06,670 --> 01:05:06,670 19282 01:05:06,670 --> 01:05:08,740 establishments primarily engag 19283 01:05:08,740 --> 01:05:08,740 ed 19284 01:05:08,740 --> 01:05:10,516 in furnishing medical, surgical 19285 01:05:10,516 --> 01:05:10,516 19286 01:05:10,516 --> 01:05:12,146 and other health services to 19287 01:05:12,146 --> 01:05:14,644 persons and pets. 19288 01:05:14,644 --> 01:05:15,667 hospitals specifically does no 19289 01:05:15,667 --> 01:05:15,667 t 19290 01:05:15,667 --> 01:05:17,055 have a definition in our 19291 01:05:17,055 --> 01:05:18,920 definition section. 19292 01:05:18,920 --> 01:05:21,130 medical services is the only 19293 01:05:21,130 --> 01:05:23,626 zoning district that allows by 19294 01:05:23,626 --> 01:05:23,626 19295 01:05:23,626 --> 01:05:27,232 right the hospital use. 19296 01:05:27,232 --> 01:05:29,057 we differentiate the two uses 19297 01:05:29,057 --> 01:05:31,342 when it comes down to intensity 19298 01:05:31,342 --> 01:05:31,342 19299 01:05:31,342 --> 01:05:31,342 mostly. 19300 01:05:31,342 --> 01:05:34,906 so we consider like hospitals t 19301 01:05:34,906 --> 01:05:34,906 o 19302 01:05:34,906 --> 01:05:37,004 have a higher intensity in ter 19303 01:05:37,004 --> 01:05:37,004 ms 19304 01:05:37,004 --> 01:05:38,840 of use, size, types of health 19305 01:05:38,840 --> 01:05:40,942 services that they are offering. 19306 01:05:40,942 --> 01:05:40,942 19307 01:05:40,942 --> 01:05:41,816 especially when we start 19308 01:05:41,816 --> 01:05:43,906 considering like number of bed 19309 01:05:43,906 --> 01:05:43,906 s 19310 01:05:43,906 --> 01:05:46,986 and patient/outpatient hours o 19311 01:05:46,986 --> 01:05:46,986 f 19312 01:05:46,986 --> 01:05:46,986 service. 19313 01:05:46,986 --> 01:05:49,622 so we mainly scale it down to 19314 01:05:49,622 --> 01:05:51,480 intensity for what that 19315 01:05:51,480 --> 01:05:52,666 difference is. 19316 01:05:52,666 --> 01:05:53,492 >> okay. 19317 01:05:53,492 --> 01:05:54,468 because I mean one of the 19318 01:05:54,468 --> 01:05:57,400 benefits of u9 is when you hav 19319 01:05:57,400 --> 01:05:57,400 e 19320 01:05:57,400 --> 01:05:59,122 that flexibility of uses, you d 19321 01:05:59,122 --> 01:05:59,122 o 19322 01:05:59,122 --> 01:06:01,094 things like you can build a 19323 01:06:01,094 --> 01:06:01,094 hotel. 19324 01:06:01,094 --> 01:06:02,967 if you are in that zoning 19325 01:06:02,967 --> 01:06:05,098 district, hotel ellio, would 19326 01:06:05,098 --> 01:06:06,966 that be considered conforming 19327 01:06:06,966 --> 01:06:13,678 under the new zoning district? 19328 01:06:13,678 --> 01:06:13,678 19329 01:06:13,678 --> 01:06:14,184 >> yes. 19330 01:06:14,184 --> 01:06:15,688 hotel is also permitted in the 19331 01:06:15,688 --> 01:06:15,688 19332 01:06:15,688 --> 01:06:17,075 md zoning district. 19333 01:06:17,075 --> 01:06:19,576 >> then I guess md is more 19334 01:06:19,576 --> 01:06:21,014 flexibility than the title may 19335 01:06:21,014 --> 01:06:21,014 19336 01:06:21,014 --> 01:06:21,014 suggest. 19337 01:06:21,014 --> 01:06:22,664 I'm comfortable with it. 19338 01:06:22,664 --> 01:06:23,520 it makes sense. 19339 01:06:23,520 --> 01:06:25,518 yeah, those are my questions. 19340 01:06:25,518 --> 01:06:26,354 thank you, mr. Mayor. 19341 01:06:26,354 --> 01:06:27,601 >> mayor: thank you. 19342 01:06:27,601 --> 01:06:28,444 madam clerk, there any public 19343 01:06:28,444 --> 01:06:29,927 comment on this? 19344 01:06:29,927 --> 01:06:30,655 >> there is no public comment, 19345 01:06:30,655 --> 01:06:30,655 19346 01:06:30,655 --> 01:06:31,030 mr. Mayor. 19347 01:06:31,030 --> 01:06:31,930 >> mayor: I so he no further 19348 01:06:31,930 --> 01:06:37,433 lights, let's call the roll. 19349 01:06:37,433 --> 01:06:38,102 >> commissioner duncan-walker. 19350 01:06:38,102 --> 01:06:38,102 19351 01:06:38,102 --> 01:06:38,513 >> aye. 19352 01:06:38,513 --> 01:06:39,041 >> commissioner book. 19353 01:06:39,041 --> 01:06:39,348 >> aye. 19354 01:06:39,348 --> 01:06:39,876 >> commissioner willits. 19355 01:06:39,876 --> 01:06:40,266 >> aye. 19356 01:06:40,266 --> 01:06:40,922 >> commissioner eastman. 19357 01:06:40,922 --> 01:06:41,677 >> aye. 19358 01:06:41,677 --> 01:06:42,337 >> commissioner ingle. 19359 01:06:42,337 --> 01:06:42,975 >> aye. 19360 01:06:42,975 --> 01:06:43,498 >> commissioner chestnut. 19361 01:06:43,498 --> 01:06:44,085 >> aye. 19362 01:06:44,085 --> 01:06:44,440 >> mayor ward. 19363 01:06:44,440 --> 01:06:44,952 >> mayor: aye. 19364 01:06:44,952 --> 01:06:46,245 that passes unanimously. 19365 01:06:46,245 --> 01:06:47,577 madam clerk, before we go on, I 19366 01:06:47,577 --> 01:06:47,577 19367 01:06:47,577 --> 01:06:49,177 don't want to let this pass 19368 01:06:49,177 --> 01:06:53,515 without mentions this when you 19369 01:06:53,515 --> 01:06:53,515 19370 01:06:53,515 --> 01:06:55,996 look at the map of the 10 bloc 19371 01:06:55,996 --> 01:06:55,996 ks 19372 01:06:55,996 --> 01:06:57,067 between basically southwest 19373 01:06:57,067 --> 01:06:59,455 23rd street to southwest 19374 01:06:59,455 --> 01:07:01,743 13th street along archer road 19375 01:07:01,743 --> 01:07:05,029 and southwest 16th avenue, it 19376 01:07:05,029 --> 01:07:08,907 repeating that this is 19377 01:07:08,907 --> 01:07:10,092 among the most, ifot the most 19378 01:07:10,092 --> 01:07:12,653 dense employment area. 19379 01:07:12,653 --> 01:07:14,404 it probably in florida, maybe 19380 01:07:14,404 --> 01:07:15,239 throughout the southeast 19381 01:07:15,239 --> 01:07:16,959 consistently because it is 19382 01:07:16,959 --> 01:07:19,775 almost all 24/7 employment. 19383 01:07:19,775 --> 01:07:22,183 and it includes everything fro 19384 01:07:22,183 --> 01:07:22,183 m, 19385 01:07:22,183 --> 01:07:25,117 you know, world-class medical 19386 01:07:25,117 --> 01:07:32,488 college to to the associated 19387 01:07:32,488 --> 01:07:33,555 hospitals with that and all the 19388 01:07:33,555 --> 01:07:33,555 19389 01:07:33,555 --> 01:07:35,296 offices that support u.f. Healt 19390 01:07:35,296 --> 01:07:35,296 h 19391 01:07:35,296 --> 01:07:42,313 throughout and the largest v.a 19392 01:07:42,313 --> 01:07:42,313 . 19393 01:07:42,313 --> 01:07:50,311 hospital headquarters. 19394 01:07:50,311 --> 01:07:52,175 all that is something you don't 19395 01:07:52,175 --> 01:07:52,175 19396 01:07:52,175 --> 01:07:53,313 encounter in most communities. 19397 01:07:53,313 --> 01:07:53,313 19398 01:07:53,313 --> 01:07:54,777 we take it for granted but 19399 01:07:54,777 --> 01:07:56,339 should not take it for granted 19400 01:07:56,339 --> 01:07:56,339 , 19401 01:07:56,339 --> 01:07:58,275 not only for the jobs, the ver 19402 01:07:58,275 --> 01:07:58,275 y 19403 01:07:58,275 --> 01:07:59,363 good jobs that it provides 19404 01:07:59,363 --> 01:08:02,655 throughout that sector, but the 19405 01:08:02,655 --> 01:08:02,655 19406 01:08:02,655 --> 01:08:03,889 opportunity for people to come 19407 01:08:03,889 --> 01:08:03,889 19408 01:08:03,889 --> 01:08:06,299 and be healed in our community 19409 01:08:06,299 --> 01:08:06,299 19410 01:08:06,299 --> 01:08:07,686 in a way that other communities 19411 01:08:07,686 --> 01:08:07,686 19412 01:08:07,686 --> 01:08:09,121 are envious of. 19413 01:08:09,121 --> 01:08:11,098 it's important when we have any 19414 01:08:11,098 --> 01:08:11,098 19415 01:08:11,098 --> 01:08:13,501 opportunity to repeat all that, 19416 01:08:13,501 --> 01:08:13,501 19417 01:08:13,501 --> 01:08:15,367 so that we don't ever forget I 19418 01:08:15,367 --> 01:08:15,367 t. 19419 01:08:15,367 --> 01:08:16,863 it's something we should walk 19420 01:08:16,863 --> 01:08:18,345 out of here feeling pretty dar 19421 01:08:18,345 --> 01:08:18,345 n 19422 01:08:18,345 --> 01:08:19,071 good about. 19423 01:08:19,071 --> 01:08:25,403 madam clerk. 19424 01:08:25,403 --> 01:08:25,403 [inaudible] 19425 01:08:25,403 --> 01:08:27,974 >> mayor: that's the theory. 19426 01:08:27,974 --> 01:08:27,974 [laughter] 19427 01:08:27,974 --> 01:08:30,343 >> mr. Mayor. 19428 01:08:30,343 --> 01:08:31,057 >> mayor: yes, we are very 19429 01:08:31,057 --> 01:08:32,191 grateful for that. >> 19430 01:08:32,191 --> 01:08:32,914 >> we are very grateful. 19431 01:08:32,914 --> 01:08:34,547 mr. Mayor, we are on to 19432 01:08:34,547 --> 01:08:36,855 ordinance number 2025-993, an 19433 01:08:36,855 --> 01:08:38,097 ordinance of the city of 19434 01:08:38,097 --> 01:08:40,193 gainesville, florida amending 19435 01:08:40,193 --> 01:08:41,981 the zoning map atlas by rezoning 19436 01:08:41,981 --> 01:08:41,981 19437 01:08:41,981 --> 01:08:44,698 approximately 25.55 acres of 19438 01:08:44,698 --> 01:08:45,760 property generally located wes 19439 01:08:45,760 --> 01:08:45,760 t 19440 01:08:45,760 --> 01:08:47,353 of southwest 13th street, 19441 01:08:47,353 --> 01:08:48,929 south of southwest archer road, 19442 01:08:48,929 --> 01:08:48,929 19443 01:08:48,929 --> 01:08:51,344 east of southwest 16th street 19444 01:08:51,344 --> 01:08:53,071 and north of southwest 16th 19445 01:08:53,071 --> 01:08:53,968 avenue as more specifically 19446 01:08:53,968 --> 01:08:56,088 described in this ordinance fro 19447 01:08:56,088 --> 01:08:56,088 m 19448 01:08:56,088 --> 01:08:59,875 urban 9 to medical services 19449 01:08:59,875 --> 01:09:02,911 providing directions, providing 19450 01:09:02,911 --> 01:09:02,911 19451 01:09:02,911 --> 01:09:04,912 severability clause, providing 19452 01:09:04,912 --> 01:09:04,912 19453 01:09:04,912 --> 01:09:06,546 repealing clause and providing 19454 01:09:06,546 --> 01:09:06,546 19455 01:09:06,546 --> 01:09:07,455 an effective date. 19456 01:09:07,455 --> 01:09:08,686 >> mayor: welcome back. 19457 01:09:08,686 --> 01:09:09,059 >> thank you. 19458 01:09:09,059 --> 01:09:12,355 good evening again. 19459 01:09:12,355 --> 01:09:16,481 allison pedder, to preface in 19460 01:09:16,481 --> 01:09:17,423 this presentation will be 19461 01:09:17,423 --> 01:09:18,471 identical to the previous item 19462 01:09:18,471 --> 01:09:18,471 19463 01:09:18,471 --> 01:09:20,928 so I'll skip past those and 19464 01:09:20,928 --> 01:09:22,212 briefly summarize them. 19465 01:09:22,212 --> 01:09:23,801 feel free to stop me if you'd 19466 01:09:23,801 --> 01:09:25,769 like me to go more in-depth. 19467 01:09:25,769 --> 01:09:27,197 so for the record, this is the 19468 01:09:27,197 --> 01:09:27,197 19469 01:09:27,197 --> 01:09:28,935 presentation before you now for 19470 01:09:28,935 --> 01:09:28,935 19471 01:09:28,935 --> 01:09:30,581 the zoning map change which is 19472 01:09:30,581 --> 01:09:30,581 19473 01:09:30,581 --> 01:09:32,440 quasi-judicial for petition 19474 01:09:32,440 --> 01:09:37,621 number ld 25-000106 for u.f. 19475 01:09:37,621 --> 01:09:39,163 health south campus. 19476 01:09:39,163 --> 01:09:40,883 for this request, the current 19477 01:09:40,883 --> 01:09:42,641 zoning designation is urban 9 19478 01:09:42,641 --> 01:09:43,618 and the proposed change 19479 01:09:43,618 --> 01:09:44,816 requested is for medical 19480 01:09:44,816 --> 01:09:56,531 services md. 19481 01:09:56,531 --> 01:10:01,138 but nothing has changed in the 19482 01:10:01,138 --> 01:10:01,138 m. 19483 01:10:01,138 --> 01:10:02,575 this petition was reviewed usi 19484 01:10:02,575 --> 01:10:02,575 ng 19485 01:10:02,575 --> 01:10:05,075 the criteria outlined in secti 19486 01:10:05,075 --> 01:10:05,075 on 19487 01:10:05,075 --> 01:10:07,276 30-3.14 of the land development 19488 01:10:07,276 --> 01:10:07,276 19489 01:10:07,276 --> 01:10:09,583 code and the corresponding 19490 01:10:09,583 --> 01:10:10,915 sections of the comprehensive 19491 01:10:10,915 --> 01:10:12,289 plan for the city of 19492 01:10:12,289 --> 01:10:12,289 gainesville. 19493 01:10:12,289 --> 01:10:13,745 the criteria shown on this sli 19494 01:10:13,745 --> 01:10:13,745 de 19495 01:10:13,745 --> 01:10:15,618 are explored in the backup and 19496 01:10:15,618 --> 01:10:15,618 19497 01:10:15,618 --> 01:10:16,147 staff report. 19498 01:10:16,147 --> 01:10:17,359 I have a couple of quick point 19499 01:10:17,359 --> 01:10:17,359 s 19500 01:10:17,359 --> 01:10:19,321 I wanted to expand in more 19501 01:10:19,321 --> 01:10:19,321 detail. 19502 01:10:19,321 --> 01:10:22,191 so this proposal is to change 19503 01:10:22,191 --> 01:10:23,942 from urban 9 which is a transec 19504 01:10:23,942 --> 01:10:23,942 t 19505 01:10:23,942 --> 01:10:25,125 zone to medical services which 19506 01:10:25,125 --> 01:10:25,125 19507 01:10:25,125 --> 01:10:26,671 is one of the special zoning 19508 01:10:26,671 --> 01:10:26,671 districts. 19509 01:10:26,671 --> 01:10:30,265 and then as a quick reminder a 19510 01:10:30,265 --> 01:10:30,265 nd 19511 01:10:30,265 --> 01:10:31,917 recap with the last item being 19512 01:10:31,917 --> 01:10:31,917 19513 01:10:31,917 --> 01:10:33,201 approved for the change in lan 19514 01:10:33,201 --> 01:10:33,201 d 19515 01:10:33,201 --> 01:10:36,069 use to office, our land 19516 01:10:36,069 --> 01:10:37,275 development code and 19517 01:10:37,275 --> 01:10:38,614 comprehensive plan do state tha 19518 01:10:38,614 --> 01:10:38,614 t 19519 01:10:38,614 --> 01:10:39,816 the only future land use 19520 01:10:39,816 --> 01:10:42,205 category that allows for the m 19521 01:10:42,205 --> 01:10:42,205 d 19522 01:10:42,205 --> 01:10:45,929 zoning is office. 19523 01:10:45,929 --> 01:10:47,458 and some other things to keep I 19524 01:10:47,458 --> 01:10:47,458 n 19525 01:10:47,458 --> 01:10:49,321 mind in terms of permitted use 19526 01:10:49,321 --> 01:10:49,321 s, 19527 01:10:49,321 --> 01:10:50,631 the use of hospitals only 19528 01:10:50,631 --> 01:10:52,721 permitted in medical services 19529 01:10:52,721 --> 01:10:52,721 md. 19530 01:10:52,721 --> 01:10:59,697 this is a reminder of the 19531 01:10:59,697 --> 01:11:00,893 compatibility element of this t 19532 01:11:00,893 --> 01:11:00,893 o 19533 01:11:00,893 --> 01:11:02,743 bring it into consistency with 19534 01:11:02,743 --> 01:11:02,743 19535 01:11:02,743 --> 01:11:04,601 the other hospital campuses see 19536 01:11:04,601 --> 01:11:04,601 n 19537 01:11:04,601 --> 01:11:06,174 around the city that also have 19538 01:11:06,174 --> 01:11:06,174 19539 01:11:06,174 --> 01:11:09,098 that md zoning. 19540 01:11:09,098 --> 01:11:10,499 and this is just a quick 19541 01:11:10,499 --> 01:11:11,995 comparison table of the two 19542 01:11:11,995 --> 01:11:13,714 zoning districts. 19543 01:11:13,714 --> 01:11:15,642 so u9 which is a transect zone 19544 01:11:15,642 --> 01:11:15,642 19545 01:11:15,642 --> 01:11:17,174 and medical services which is a 19546 01:11:17,174 --> 01:11:17,174 19547 01:11:17,174 --> 01:11:19,247 special district, a lot of the 19548 01:11:19,247 --> 01:11:19,247 se 19549 01:11:19,247 --> 01:11:21,871 have already been kind of talked ab 19550 01:11:21,871 --> 01:11:23,199 about but the main ones being 19551 01:11:23,199 --> 01:11:25,416 the permitted uses, the height. 19552 01:11:25,416 --> 01:11:25,416 19553 01:11:25,416 --> 01:11:28,664 just a quick glance over that 19554 01:11:28,664 --> 01:11:29,991 with the special district 19555 01:11:29,991 --> 01:11:32,294 medical services, it's five 19556 01:11:32,294 --> 01:11:34,981 stories by right, 14 with a 19557 01:11:34,981 --> 01:11:38,101 special use permit for those 19558 01:11:38,101 --> 01:11:39,995 larger medical facilities. 19559 01:11:39,995 --> 01:11:40,869 other than that, medical 19560 01:11:40,869 --> 01:11:42,206 services is a special district 19561 01:11:42,206 --> 01:11:42,206 19562 01:11:42,206 --> 01:11:48,313 hathat has its own section. 19563 01:11:48,313 --> 01:11:50,459 and this is just a broader map 19564 01:11:50,459 --> 01:11:50,459 19565 01:11:50,459 --> 01:11:54,551 showing the zoning of the area. 19566 01:11:54,551 --> 01:11:54,551 19567 01:11:54,551 --> 01:11:56,719 and lastly, based on the revie 19568 01:11:56,719 --> 01:11:56,719 w 19569 01:11:56,719 --> 01:11:57,820 of this criteria, staff 19570 01:11:57,820 --> 01:11:59,224 recommends approval of petition 19571 01:11:59,224 --> 01:11:59,224 19572 01:11:59,224 --> 01:12:02,937 ld 25-000106 and the city plan 19573 01:12:02,937 --> 01:12:02,937 19574 01:12:02,937 --> 01:12:05,145 board on december 18th of 2025 19575 01:12:05,145 --> 01:12:05,145 19576 01:12:05,145 --> 01:12:06,718 voted 6-0 to recommend approva 19577 01:12:06,718 --> 01:12:06,718 l 19578 01:12:06,718 --> 01:12:10,962 of the petition as well. 19579 01:12:10,962 --> 01:12:15,044 we are available for questions 19580 01:12:15,044 --> 01:12:15,044 19581 01:12:15,044 --> 01:12:16,669 and mv5 is also here. 19582 01:12:16,669 --> 01:12:17,593 >> mayor: would the applicant 19583 01:12:17,593 --> 01:12:21,249 like to add anything to this? 19584 01:12:21,249 --> 01:12:23,622 >> not other than having my 19585 01:12:23,622 --> 01:12:24,747 presentation from the previous 19586 01:12:24,747 --> 01:12:24,747 19587 01:12:24,747 --> 01:12:26,077 item reflected in the record. 19588 01:12:26,077 --> 01:12:27,579 thank you, mr. Mayor. 19589 01:12:27,579 --> 01:12:29,581 >> mayor: absolutely, yes. 19590 01:12:29,581 --> 01:12:30,316 thank you. 19591 01:12:30,316 --> 01:12:31,379 commissioner ingle. 19592 01:12:31,379 --> 01:12:34,293 >> move staff recommendation o 19593 01:12:34,293 --> 01:12:34,293 f 19594 01:12:34,293 --> 01:12:34,293 2025-993. 19595 01:12:34,293 --> 01:12:36,268 >> second. 19596 01:12:36,268 --> 01:12:37,325 >> mayor: motion and second. 19597 01:12:37,325 --> 01:12:39,187 and commissioner book. 19598 01:12:39,187 --> 01:12:39,793 >> yeah, thank you. 19599 01:12:39,793 --> 01:12:41,294 this is precisely the type of 19600 01:12:41,294 --> 01:12:43,435 presentation that helps us be 19601 01:12:43,435 --> 01:12:44,335 prepared to make something lik 19602 01:12:44,335 --> 01:12:44,335 e 19603 01:12:44,335 --> 01:12:44,335 this. The 19604 01:12:44,335 --> 01:12:47,503 the nuances of something like a 19605 01:12:47,503 --> 01:12:47,503 19606 01:12:47,503 --> 01:12:49,314 health use versus a hospital an 19607 01:12:49,314 --> 01:12:49,314 d 19608 01:12:49,314 --> 01:12:50,869 the fact that it has different 19609 01:12:50,869 --> 01:12:50,869 19610 01:12:50,869 --> 01:12:52,972 densities in the same area and 19611 01:12:52,972 --> 01:12:52,972 19612 01:12:52,972 --> 01:12:54,720 really doesn't change the 19613 01:12:54,720 --> 01:12:55,811 overall character of the area I 19614 01:12:55,811 --> 01:12:55,811 s 19615 01:12:55,811 --> 01:12:57,684 very helpful for this. 19616 01:12:57,684 --> 01:12:59,653 so this is very, very good 19617 01:12:59,653 --> 01:13:00,783 preparation by staff. 19618 01:13:00,783 --> 01:13:02,185 and this was a really -- I 19619 01:13:02,185 --> 01:13:03,385 didn't even know why this was 19620 01:13:03,385 --> 01:13:04,158 coming before us. 19621 01:13:04,158 --> 01:13:06,454 seemed like I would have thoug 19622 01:13:06,454 --> 01:13:06,454 ht 19623 01:13:06,454 --> 01:13:07,651 that this was a use that could 19624 01:13:07,651 --> 01:13:07,651 19625 01:13:07,651 --> 01:13:09,728 have been done in that area, b 19626 01:13:09,728 --> 01:13:09,728 ut 19627 01:13:09,728 --> 01:13:11,060 for the fact that we have very, 19628 01:13:11,060 --> 01:13:11,060 19629 01:13:11,060 --> 01:13:13,127 very precise land use and zonin 19630 01:13:13,127 --> 01:13:13,127 g 19631 01:13:13,127 --> 01:13:13,127 standards. 19632 01:13:13,127 --> 01:13:19,039 I appreciate staff in this 19633 01:13:19,039 --> 01:13:20,669 particular case and support the 19634 01:13:20,669 --> 01:13:20,669 19635 01:13:20,669 --> 01:13:20,669 motion. 19636 01:13:20,669 --> 01:13:22,435 >> mayor: commissioner willits 19637 01:13:22,435 --> 01:13:22,435 . 19638 01:13:22,435 --> 01:13:24,981 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. Yo 19639 01:13:24,981 --> 01:13:26,376 you know, it's like -- it feels 19640 01:13:26,376 --> 01:13:26,376 19641 01:13:26,376 --> 01:13:27,572 like a small change but in 19642 01:13:27,572 --> 01:13:28,880 essence it is also saying 19643 01:13:28,880 --> 01:13:30,512 there's less land. 19644 01:13:30,512 --> 01:13:37,216 we have just dezoned a chunk of 19645 01:13:37,216 --> 01:13:37,216 19646 01:13:37,216 --> 01:13:43,903 land that could be -- 19647 01:13:43,903 --> 01:13:47,333 [inaudible] if u.f. Said let's 19648 01:13:47,333 --> 01:13:47,333 19649 01:13:47,333 --> 01:13:48,905 build a dorm for nursing 19650 01:13:48,905 --> 01:13:50,772 students and now 20 per acre, w 19651 01:13:50,772 --> 01:13:50,772 e 19652 01:13:50,772 --> 01:13:53,271 do remove some -- the changes 19653 01:13:53,271 --> 01:13:54,617 aren't completely minimal. 19654 01:13:54,617 --> 01:13:56,668 it does change with the future. 19655 01:13:56,668 --> 01:13:56,668 19656 01:13:56,668 --> 01:13:58,285 but I think this is more in line 19657 01:13:58,285 --> 01:13:58,285 19658 01:13:58,285 --> 01:14:00,380 with what u.f. Health is looki 19659 01:14:00,380 --> 01:14:00,380 ng 19660 01:14:00,380 --> 01:14:00,380 at. 19661 01:14:00,380 --> 01:14:02,256 people can't say we never do 19662 01:14:02,256 --> 01:14:03,344 anything for u.f. Health. 19663 01:14:03,344 --> 01:14:05,425 like this is, you know, a help 19664 01:14:05,425 --> 01:14:05,425 19665 01:14:05,425 --> 01:14:06,521 for them to build that. 19666 01:14:06,521 --> 01:14:08,480 and I just want to also give 19667 01:14:08,480 --> 01:14:20,726 thanks to ms. Pager. 19668 01:14:20,726 --> 01:14:22,544 I'm glad you're the person here 19669 01:14:22,544 --> 01:14:22,544 19670 01:14:22,544 --> 01:14:24,332 to do all the research to answe 19671 01:14:24,332 --> 01:14:24,332 19672 01:14:24,332 --> 01:14:25,648 my questions. 19673 01:14:25,648 --> 01:14:26,028 thank you. 19674 01:14:26,028 --> 01:14:27,765 >> happy to help. 19675 01:14:27,765 --> 01:14:28,316 >> mayor: thank you, 19676 01:14:28,316 --> 01:14:28,970 commissioner willits. 19677 01:14:28,970 --> 01:14:30,319 commissioner eastman. 19678 01:14:30,319 --> 01:14:31,176 >> thank you. 19679 01:14:31,176 --> 01:14:33,572 since I got on my soapbox last 19680 01:14:33,572 --> 01:14:33,572 19681 01:14:33,572 --> 01:14:35,451 time about pds when making the 19682 01:14:35,451 --> 01:14:35,451 19683 01:14:35,451 --> 01:14:37,550 change, another thing that is on 19684 01:14:37,550 --> 01:14:37,550 19685 01:14:37,550 --> 01:14:39,154 that staff looking at that 19686 01:14:39,154 --> 01:14:40,128 spreadsheet of all the work th 19687 01:14:40,128 --> 01:14:40,128 at 19688 01:14:40,128 --> 01:14:41,880 you guys are doing is to look a 19689 01:14:41,880 --> 01:14:41,880 t 19690 01:14:41,880 --> 01:14:43,320 our allowed use tables. 19691 01:14:43,320 --> 01:14:45,386 I have not asked this directly 19692 01:14:45,386 --> 01:14:45,386 19693 01:14:45,386 --> 01:14:46,688 but I'm guessing the differenc 19694 01:14:46,688 --> 01:14:46,688 e 19695 01:14:46,688 --> 01:14:47,588 between medical services and 19696 01:14:47,588 --> 01:14:48,801 hospitals is the main purpose o 19697 01:14:48,801 --> 01:14:48,801 f 19698 01:14:48,801 --> 01:14:51,935 this changeover. And 19699 01:14:51,935 --> 01:14:53,727 and well, regardless, I think it 19700 01:14:53,727 --> 01:14:53,727 19701 01:14:53,727 --> 01:14:55,806 is important that we have that, 19702 01:14:55,806 --> 01:14:55,806 19703 01:14:55,806 --> 01:14:57,226 you know, if there are 19704 01:14:57,226 --> 01:14:58,534 allowances that make sense 19705 01:14:58,534 --> 01:14:59,639 within certain zoning districts 19706 01:14:59,639 --> 01:14:59,639 19707 01:14:59,639 --> 01:15:01,040 that we simply make those 19708 01:15:01,040 --> 01:15:07,520 updates, we might not have tak 19709 01:15:07,520 --> 01:15:07,520 en 19710 01:15:07,520 --> 01:15:09,574 a different look since we made 19711 01:15:09,574 --> 01:15:09,574 19712 01:15:09,574 --> 01:15:09,574 transects. 19713 01:15:09,574 --> 01:15:11,467 now we have lots of time and 19714 01:15:11,467 --> 01:15:12,786 experience under our belt as t 19715 01:15:12,786 --> 01:15:12,786 o 19716 01:15:12,786 --> 01:15:14,314 what makes sense where and wha 19717 01:15:14,314 --> 01:15:14,314 t 19718 01:15:14,314 --> 01:15:16,291 applicants are coming and askin 19719 01:15:16,291 --> 01:15:16,291 g 19720 01:15:16,291 --> 01:15:16,722 us for. 19721 01:15:16,722 --> 01:15:18,024 I'm looking forward to getting 19722 01:15:18,024 --> 01:15:18,024 19723 01:15:18,024 --> 01:15:19,850 that back whenever the plan 19724 01:15:19,850 --> 01:15:21,549 board gets done with that. 19725 01:15:21,549 --> 01:15:24,094 I think it's well overdue to 19726 01:15:24,094 --> 01:15:26,495 take a second set of eyes. 19727 01:15:26,495 --> 01:15:27,239 >> mayor: thank you, 19728 01:15:27,239 --> 01:15:28,098 commissioner eastman. 19729 01:15:28,098 --> 01:15:29,905 is there any public comment, 19730 01:15:29,905 --> 01:15:31,182 madam clerk? 19731 01:15:31,182 --> 01:15:32,086 >> no public comment. 19732 01:15:32,086 --> 01:15:32,708 >> mayor: let's call the roll. 19733 01:15:32,708 --> 01:15:32,708 19734 01:15:32,708 --> 01:15:33,245 >> commissioner book. 19735 01:15:33,245 --> 01:15:33,944 >> aye. 19736 01:15:33,944 --> 01:15:34,440 >> commissioner willits. 19737 01:15:34,440 --> 01:15:34,979 >> aye. 19738 01:15:34,979 --> 01:15:35,578 >> commissioner eastman. 19739 01:15:35,578 --> 01:15:36,214 >> aye. 19740 01:15:36,214 --> 01:15:36,801 >> commissioner ingle. 19741 01:15:36,801 --> 01:15:37,175 >> aye. 19742 01:15:37,175 --> 01:15:37,720 >> commissioner chestnut. 19743 01:15:37,720 --> 01:15:38,376 >> aye. 19744 01:15:38,376 --> 01:15:38,922 >> commissioner duncan-walker. 19745 01:15:38,922 --> 01:15:38,922 19746 01:15:38,922 --> 01:15:40,384 >> aye. 19747 01:15:40,384 --> 01:15:40,785 >> mayor ward. 19748 01:15:40,785 --> 01:15:41,960 >> mayor: aye. That 19749 01:15:41,960 --> 01:15:42,308 that passes unanimously. 19750 01:15:42,308 --> 01:15:42,751 madam clerk. 19751 01:15:42,751 --> 01:15:44,792 >> mr. Mayor, we are on to 19752 01:15:44,792 --> 01:15:49,768 ordinance number 2025-994, an 19753 01:15:49,768 --> 01:15:50,778 ordinance of the city of 19754 01:15:50,778 --> 01:15:51,266 gainesville, florida amending 19755 01:15:51,266 --> 01:15:53,488 the future land use map of the 19756 01:15:53,488 --> 01:15:53,488 19757 01:15:53,488 --> 01:15:54,356 comprehensive plan by changing 19758 01:15:54,356 --> 01:15:54,356 19759 01:15:54,356 --> 01:15:56,164 the land use category of 19760 01:15:56,164 --> 01:15:58,472 approximately 1.38 acres of 19761 01:15:58,472 --> 01:15:59,844 property generally located at 19762 01:15:59,844 --> 01:16:01,980 the 1200 block of northeast 19763 01:16:01,980 --> 01:16:04,069 8th avenue as more 19764 01:16:04,069 --> 01:16:05,034 specifically described in this 19765 01:16:05,034 --> 01:16:05,034 19766 01:16:05,034 --> 01:16:07,534 ordinance from mixed use 19767 01:16:07,534 --> 01:16:09,442 office/residential to urban 19768 01:16:09,442 --> 01:16:09,882 mixed use. 19769 01:16:09,882 --> 01:16:11,280 providing directions to the cit 19770 01:16:11,280 --> 01:16:11,280 y 19771 01:16:11,280 --> 01:16:12,314 manager, providing a 19772 01:16:12,314 --> 01:16:13,710 severability clause, providing 19773 01:16:13,710 --> 01:16:13,942 a 19774 01:16:13,942 --> 01:16:15,477 repealing clause and providing 19775 01:16:15,477 --> 01:16:15,477 19776 01:16:15,477 --> 01:16:16,848 an effective date. 19777 01:16:16,848 --> 01:16:19,516 >> mayor: very good. 19778 01:16:19,516 --> 01:16:20,250 commissioner chestnut. 19779 01:16:20,250 --> 01:16:22,896 >> thank you. 19780 01:16:22,896 --> 01:16:23,774 thank you, mr. Mayor. 19781 01:16:23,774 --> 01:16:26,856 I will be abstaining on this 19782 01:16:26,856 --> 01:16:29,124 vote on ordinance number 19783 01:16:29,124 --> 01:16:32,626 2025-994 as well as ordinance 19784 01:16:32,626 --> 01:16:34,974 number 2025-995. 19785 01:16:34,974 --> 01:16:37,190 I have a conflict of interest, 19786 01:16:37,190 --> 01:16:37,190 19787 01:16:37,190 --> 01:16:38,572 both forms have been filed wit 19788 01:16:38,572 --> 01:16:38,572 h 19789 01:16:38,572 --> 01:16:40,172 the clerk's office. 19790 01:16:40,172 --> 01:16:40,822 >> mayor: very good. 19791 01:16:40,822 --> 01:16:41,182 thank you, commissioner 19792 01:16:41,182 --> 01:16:41,182 chestnut. 19793 01:16:41,182 --> 01:16:43,540 mr. Chen. 19794 01:16:43,540 --> 01:16:43,946 >> thank you. 19795 01:16:43,946 --> 01:16:44,670 good evening, mayor and 19796 01:16:44,670 --> 01:16:44,670 commissioners. 19797 01:16:44,670 --> 01:16:53,452 nathan iel chen. 19798 01:16:53,452 --> 01:16:54,858 this is the chestnut northeast 19799 01:16:54,858 --> 01:16:54,858 19800 01:16:54,858 --> 01:16:59,788 8th avenue land use change. 19801 01:16:59,788 --> 01:17:02,655 so this is the 1200 block of 19802 01:17:02,655 --> 01:17:04,594 northeast 8th avenue with 19803 01:17:04,594 --> 01:17:06,800 those four parcels listed. 19804 01:17:06,800 --> 01:17:08,867 the existing land use and zonin 19805 01:17:08,867 --> 01:17:08,867 g 19806 01:17:08,867 --> 01:17:10,434 district allow for mixed use 19807 01:17:10,434 --> 01:17:10,434 development. 19808 01:17:10,434 --> 01:17:13,610 so it is currently mixed use 19809 01:17:13,610 --> 01:17:16,238 office residential or mor and 19810 01:17:16,238 --> 01:17:19,617 currently urban 4 or u4 zoning. 19811 01:17:19,617 --> 01:17:19,617 19812 01:17:19,617 --> 01:17:20,716 as I said, it allows 19813 01:17:20,716 --> 01:17:26,712 it is bounded on four sides by 19814 01:17:26,712 --> 01:17:26,712 19815 01:17:26,712 --> 01:17:30,014 streets, so northeast 8th avenu 19816 01:17:30,014 --> 01:17:30,014 e 19817 01:17:30,014 --> 01:17:31,187 to the north. 19818 01:17:31,187 --> 01:17:35,387 northeast 12th street, northea 19819 01:17:35,387 --> 01:17:35,387 st 19820 01:17:35,387 --> 01:17:37,098 place to the south, and 19821 01:17:37,098 --> 01:17:38,290 northeast to the east. 19822 01:17:38,290 --> 01:17:42,852 as I said, it's the 1200 block 19823 01:17:42,852 --> 01:17:42,852 19824 01:17:42,852 --> 01:17:44,488 of northeast 8th avenue. 19825 01:17:44,488 --> 01:17:46,794 approximately 1.38 acres, and 19826 01:17:46,794 --> 01:17:49,236 the proposed land use and zonin 19827 01:17:49,236 --> 01:17:49,236 g 19828 01:17:49,236 --> 01:17:53,854 is mixed use and urban 6. 19829 01:17:53,854 --> 01:17:55,790 the site is currently vacant. 19830 01:17:55,790 --> 01:17:58,318 here's the subject property on 19831 01:17:58,318 --> 01:17:58,318 19832 01:17:58,318 --> 01:17:59,114 northeast 8th avenue. 19833 01:17:59,114 --> 01:18:03,351 as I said, charles chestnut iii 19834 01:18:03,351 --> 01:18:03,351 19835 01:18:03,351 --> 01:18:03,351 avenue. 19836 01:18:03,351 --> 01:18:04,967 the subject property is in 19837 01:18:04,967 --> 01:18:06,624 orange, and the surrounding 19838 01:18:06,624 --> 01:18:08,254 developments are called out in 19839 01:18:08,254 --> 01:18:08,254 19840 01:18:08,254 --> 01:18:08,254 blue. 19841 01:18:08,254 --> 01:18:11,083 mainly of course the 8th and 19842 01:18:11,083 --> 01:18:15,702 waldo road, located within 19843 01:18:15,702 --> 01:18:17,667 walking distance of the subject 19844 01:18:17,667 --> 01:18:17,667 19845 01:18:17,667 --> 01:18:17,667 property. 19846 01:18:17,667 --> 01:18:20,531 and that of course proposes 19847 01:18:20,531 --> 01:18:22,107 reutilization of the site, 19848 01:18:22,107 --> 01:18:24,885 including improved facilities 19849 01:18:24,885 --> 01:18:27,437 and other improvements, and also 19850 01:18:27,437 --> 01:18:27,437 19851 01:18:27,437 --> 01:18:29,609 note I wanted to point out tha 19852 01:18:29,609 --> 01:18:29,609 t 19853 01:18:29,609 --> 01:18:32,116 the city-approved rezoning 19854 01:18:32,116 --> 01:18:35,149 petitions of this office complex 19855 01:18:35,149 --> 01:18:35,149 19856 01:18:35,149 --> 01:18:37,487 on the southwest corner of wal 19857 01:18:37,487 --> 01:18:37,487 do 19858 01:18:37,487 --> 01:18:39,518 and northeast 8th avenue. 19859 01:18:39,518 --> 01:18:42,577 that was removing old pud and 19860 01:18:42,577 --> 01:18:44,285 going to mixed use, which is 19861 01:18:44,285 --> 01:18:45,469 proposed on this site as well. 19862 01:18:45,469 --> 01:18:45,469 19863 01:18:45,469 --> 01:18:56,295 mixed use office residential f 19864 01:18:56,295 --> 01:18:56,295 or 19865 01:18:56,295 --> 01:18:58,037 the blue and outlined in orang 19866 01:18:58,037 --> 01:18:58,037 e. 19867 01:18:58,037 --> 01:19:00,117 the mixed use exists o to the 19868 01:19:00,117 --> 01:19:00,680 east of the site. 19869 01:19:00,680 --> 01:19:02,571 to the north is of course 19870 01:19:02,571 --> 01:19:05,005 citizen's field, and the army 19871 01:19:05,005 --> 01:19:06,687 reserve parcel that has public 19872 01:19:06,687 --> 01:19:06,687 19873 01:19:06,687 --> 01:19:09,319 facilities, pf future land use 19874 01:19:09,319 --> 01:19:09,319 , 19875 01:19:09,319 --> 01:19:13,353 and to the west is more mixed 19876 01:19:13,353 --> 01:19:16,762 use residential use. 19877 01:19:16,762 --> 01:19:19,925 and the proposed future use is 19878 01:19:19,925 --> 01:19:19,925 19879 01:19:19,925 --> 01:19:21,236 urban mixed use. 19880 01:19:21,236 --> 01:19:23,198 just comparing a little bit 19881 01:19:23,198 --> 01:19:26,167 between the descriptions in the 19882 01:19:26,167 --> 01:19:26,167 19883 01:19:26,167 --> 01:19:27,805 comprehensive plan for urban 19884 01:19:27,805 --> 01:19:30,573 mixed use and the mixed use 19885 01:19:30,573 --> 01:19:32,897 office residential category. 19886 01:19:32,897 --> 01:19:36,675 here is the mixed use office 19887 01:19:36,675 --> 01:19:38,279 residential description. 19888 01:19:38,279 --> 01:19:55,560 allowing for more development. 19889 01:19:55,560 --> 01:19:55,560 19890 01:19:55,560 --> 01:20:00,580 you'll see in the re-zoning 19891 01:20:00,580 --> 01:20:02,440 petition, the u6 zoning allows 19892 01:20:02,440 --> 01:20:02,440 19893 01:20:02,440 --> 01:20:05,080 up to 50 units per acre, which 19894 01:20:05,080 --> 01:20:05,080 19895 01:20:05,080 --> 01:20:07,109 is requested for the rezoning. 19896 01:20:07,109 --> 01:20:07,109 19897 01:20:07,109 --> 01:20:09,073 for height, mixed use is limit 19898 01:20:09,073 --> 01:20:09,073 ed 19899 01:20:09,073 --> 01:20:11,949 to three stories max yum, and 19900 01:20:11,949 --> 01:20:13,784 urban mixed use allows four 19901 01:20:13,784 --> 01:20:16,179 stories by rate, and five if 19902 01:20:16,179 --> 01:20:18,528 granted with a high bonus for 19903 01:20:18,528 --> 01:20:20,057 affordable housing or other 19904 01:20:20,057 --> 01:20:20,057 bonuses. 19905 01:20:20,057 --> 01:20:22,123 here's the description for urb 19906 01:20:22,123 --> 01:20:22,123 an 19907 01:20:22,123 --> 01:20:22,845 mixed use. 19908 01:20:22,845 --> 01:20:24,899 as I said, up to 60 units per 19909 01:20:24,899 --> 01:20:24,899 acre. 19910 01:20:24,899 --> 01:20:28,585 allows for residential office 19911 01:20:28,585 --> 01:20:30,311 retail, essentially more 19912 01:20:30,311 --> 01:20:32,267 commercial uses at the site wit 19913 01:20:32,267 --> 01:20:32,267 h 19914 01:20:32,267 --> 01:20:45,917 urban mixed use. 19915 01:20:45,917 --> 01:20:54,821 mor compatibility buffers or 19916 01:20:54,821 --> 01:20:57,987 land-use buffers, that identify 19917 01:20:57,987 --> 01:20:57,987 19918 01:20:57,987 --> 01:21:00,187 minimum requirements for the 19919 01:21:00,187 --> 01:21:01,400 separation of land uses, so the 19920 01:21:01,400 --> 01:21:01,400 19921 01:21:01,400 --> 01:21:04,702 table is read with the a-- or 19922 01:21:04,702 --> 01:21:05,971 the subject property on the lef 19923 01:21:05,971 --> 01:21:05,971 t 19924 01:21:05,971 --> 01:21:07,603 x then the abutting property o 19925 01:21:07,603 --> 01:21:07,603 n 19926 01:21:07,603 --> 01:21:10,140 the top, so, you'll see that 19927 01:21:10,140 --> 01:21:12,974 with the subject property, if I 19928 01:21:12,974 --> 01:21:12,974 t 19929 01:21:12,974 --> 01:21:14,618 were to be changed to urban 19930 01:21:14,618 --> 01:21:17,583 mixed use and the abutting 19931 01:21:17,583 --> 01:21:19,749 property having mixed-use 19932 01:21:19,749 --> 01:21:22,920 residential, a type-a buffer 19933 01:21:22,920 --> 01:21:24,055 would be applied to the 19934 01:21:24,055 --> 01:21:25,323 remaining portion. 19935 01:21:25,323 --> 01:21:27,629 currently, of course, no come 19936 01:21:27,629 --> 01:21:29,053 bability buffers are required 19937 01:21:29,053 --> 01:21:31,230 because the whole block is mix 19938 01:21:31,230 --> 01:21:31,230 ed 19939 01:21:31,230 --> 01:21:34,135 use residential, but with this 19940 01:21:34,135 --> 01:21:34,135 19941 01:21:34,135 --> 01:21:35,838 change a type a buffer would b 19942 01:21:35,838 --> 01:21:35,838 e 19943 01:21:35,838 --> 01:21:37,366 applied, and I'm showing some o 19944 01:21:37,366 --> 01:21:37,366 f 19945 01:21:37,366 --> 01:21:39,339 the detailed language for what 19946 01:21:39,339 --> 01:21:39,339 19947 01:21:39,339 --> 01:21:41,746 the buffer would entail, which 19948 01:21:41,746 --> 01:21:41,746 19949 01:21:41,746 --> 01:21:43,529 includes landscaping, shade 19950 01:21:43,529 --> 01:21:44,602 trees and an additional 19951 01:21:44,602 --> 01:21:50,286 distance, if you will. 19952 01:21:50,286 --> 01:21:52,295 staff reviewed and pound it 19953 01:21:52,295 --> 01:21:56,753 meets the criteria for future 19954 01:21:56,753 --> 01:21:59,585 land use change outlined in the 19955 01:21:59,585 --> 01:21:59,585 19956 01:21:59,585 --> 01:22:05,499 comprehensive plan, and of the 19957 01:22:05,499 --> 01:22:05,499 19958 01:22:05,499 --> 01:22:06,487 land development code. 19959 01:22:06,487 --> 01:22:08,761 it allows a mix of uses and 19960 01:22:08,761 --> 01:22:10,097 supports infill and 19961 01:22:10,097 --> 01:22:11,214 redevelopment of the vacant 19962 01:22:11,214 --> 01:22:11,214 site. 19963 01:22:11,214 --> 01:22:13,968 it is a site that's well 19964 01:22:13,968 --> 01:22:15,668 connected to existing facilitie 19965 01:22:15,668 --> 01:22:15,668 s 19966 01:22:15,668 --> 01:22:17,107 and services, including 19967 01:22:17,107 --> 01:22:18,662 sidewalks on both sides o 19968 01:22:18,662 --> 01:22:26,475 northeast 8th avenue, and land uses -- 19969 01:22:26,475 --> 01:22:26,475 19970 01:22:26,475 --> 01:22:26,956 mixed use and mixed use office 19971 01:22:26,956 --> 01:22:26,956 19972 01:22:26,956 --> 01:22:26,956 residential. 19973 01:22:26,956 --> 01:22:28,821 [indistinct] there are no 19974 01:22:28,821 --> 01:22:30,577 significant environmental 19975 01:22:30,577 --> 01:22:32,986 resources or wetlands on the 19976 01:22:32,986 --> 01:22:34,290 property as well. 19977 01:22:34,290 --> 01:22:36,260 more details on the petition 19978 01:22:36,260 --> 01:22:38,204 meeting review criteria found I 19979 01:22:38,204 --> 01:22:38,204 n 19980 01:22:38,204 --> 01:22:39,963 the staff report. 19981 01:22:39,963 --> 01:22:42,833 staff recommends based on the 19982 01:22:42,833 --> 01:22:44,264 analysis that we recommend 19983 01:22:44,264 --> 01:22:46,435 approval of the petition 19984 01:22:46,435 --> 01:22:53,497 ld25-000124, the chestnut ne 8t 19985 01:22:53,497 --> 01:22:55,078 h land use change, and at 19986 01:22:55,078 --> 01:22:56,282 the city plan board meeting, t 19987 01:22:56,282 --> 01:22:56,282 he 19988 01:22:56,282 --> 01:22:57,913 plan board recommended approval 19989 01:22:57,913 --> 01:22:57,913 19990 01:22:57,913 --> 01:23:00,245 of the petition. 19991 01:23:00,245 --> 01:23:02,522 the applicant is here and has a 19992 01:23:02,522 --> 01:23:02,522 19993 01:23:02,522 --> 01:23:03,859 presentation if you'd like, but 19994 01:23:03,859 --> 01:23:03,859 19995 01:23:03,859 --> 01:23:04,818 I'm here to answer any 19996 01:23:04,818 --> 01:23:04,818 questions. 19997 01:23:04,818 --> 01:23:08,991 >> mayor: very good, thank 19998 01:23:08,991 --> 01:23:08,991 you. 19999 01:23:08,991 --> 01:23:11,593 would the applicant want to giv 20000 01:23:11,593 --> 01:23:11,593 e 20001 01:23:11,593 --> 01:23:12,267 us a presentation? 20002 01:23:12,267 --> 01:23:19,127 >> good evening, mr. Mayor, and 20003 01:23:19,127 --> 01:23:19,127 20004 01:23:19,127 --> 01:23:19,127 commissioners. 20005 01:23:19,127 --> 01:23:24,941 I'm clay swayinger representin 20006 01:23:24,941 --> 01:23:24,941 g 20007 01:23:24,941 --> 01:23:25,724 the property tonight. 20008 01:23:25,724 --> 01:23:29,139 I'd like to make com comments a 20009 01:23:29,139 --> 01:23:29,139 bout 20010 01:23:29,139 --> 01:23:30,747 the land use and zoning, and 20011 01:23:30,747 --> 01:23:32,286 answer questions you may have. 20012 01:23:32,286 --> 01:23:32,286 20013 01:23:32,286 --> 01:23:35,161 this is obviously an area of a 20014 01:23:35,161 --> 01:23:35,161 20015 01:23:35,161 --> 01:23:35,551 lot of interest. 20016 01:23:35,551 --> 01:23:38,433 I was with you in the other room 20017 01:23:38,433 --> 01:23:38,433 20018 01:23:38,433 --> 01:23:39,323 this afternoon, but it's an 20019 01:23:39,323 --> 01:23:41,256 exciting area, and it's an are 20020 01:23:41,256 --> 01:23:41,256 a 20021 01:23:41,256 --> 01:23:43,432 where revitalization and 20022 01:23:43,432 --> 01:23:46,161 investment is a city priority. 20023 01:23:46,161 --> 01:23:46,161 20024 01:23:46,161 --> 01:23:48,125 see the chestnut family's owned 20025 01:23:48,125 --> 01:23:48,125 20026 01:23:48,125 --> 01:23:49,333 this property for quite some 20027 01:23:49,333 --> 01:23:52,836 time, and we have been engaged 20028 01:23:52,836 --> 01:23:52,836 20029 01:23:52,836 --> 01:23:54,599 to bring to the city a land-use 20030 01:23:54,599 --> 01:23:58,979 map change from mor to umu, and 20031 01:23:58,979 --> 01:23:58,979 20032 01:23:58,979 --> 01:24:01,382 the change from zoning from u4 20033 01:24:01,382 --> 01:24:01,382 20034 01:24:01,382 --> 01:24:02,149 to u6. 20035 01:24:02,149 --> 01:24:05,156 it's sort of a step up on the 20036 01:24:05,156 --> 01:24:05,156 ladder. 20037 01:24:05,156 --> 01:24:07,811 this is very consistent with t 20038 01:24:07,811 --> 01:24:07,811 he 20039 01:24:07,811 --> 01:24:09,861 approval by the commission for 20040 01:24:09,861 --> 01:24:09,861 20041 01:24:09,861 --> 01:24:11,889 the, what's commonly known as 20042 01:24:11,889 --> 01:24:15,829 the former jones edmonds 20043 01:24:15,829 --> 01:24:15,829 property. 20044 01:24:15,829 --> 01:24:18,087 I'm not sure if the guys in the 20045 01:24:18,087 --> 01:24:18,087 20046 01:24:18,087 --> 01:24:19,365 back could put this overhead o 20047 01:24:19,365 --> 01:24:19,365 n. 20048 01:24:19,365 --> 01:24:22,163 I think this helps describe the 20049 01:24:22,163 --> 01:24:22,163 20050 01:24:22,163 --> 01:24:22,811 area a little bit better. 20051 01:24:22,811 --> 01:24:30,137 it's about 1.4 acres in size 20052 01:24:30,137 --> 01:24:32,987 outlined in red, so in this are 20053 01:24:32,987 --> 01:24:32,987 a 20054 01:24:32,987 --> 01:24:35,948 you have jones edmonds property, 20055 01:24:35,948 --> 01:24:35,948 20056 01:24:35,948 --> 01:24:39,083 changed to umu and u6. 20057 01:24:39,083 --> 01:24:40,717 you have city properties to the 20058 01:24:40,717 --> 01:24:40,717 20059 01:24:40,717 --> 01:24:40,717 north. 20060 01:24:40,717 --> 01:24:45,119 the armory, east end eatery, t 20061 01:24:45,119 --> 01:24:45,119 he 20062 01:24:45,119 --> 01:24:49,033 firefighter union, baptist 20063 01:24:49,033 --> 01:24:52,026 church west, and a mix of 20064 01:24:52,026 --> 01:24:53,361 residential use to the south. 20065 01:24:53,361 --> 01:24:55,058 you have a lot of different 20066 01:24:55,058 --> 01:24:56,536 mixed uses. 20067 01:24:56,536 --> 01:24:59,000 the properties to the north mul 20068 01:24:59,000 --> 01:24:59,000 , 20069 01:24:59,000 --> 01:25:00,963 that's one of the older 20070 01:25:00,963 --> 01:25:02,639 designations and the zoning tha 20071 01:25:02,639 --> 01:25:02,639 t 20072 01:25:02,639 --> 01:25:06,673 is mu1, and so obviously back I 20073 01:25:06,673 --> 01:25:06,673 n 20074 01:25:06,673 --> 01:25:08,848 2017 the city approved the 20075 01:25:08,848 --> 01:25:11,049 zonings for properties around 20076 01:25:11,049 --> 01:25:11,049 town. 20077 01:25:11,049 --> 01:25:17,423 u4 was placed on the property 20078 01:25:17,423 --> 01:25:19,633 with the land use designation. 20079 01:25:19,633 --> 01:25:19,633 20080 01:25:19,633 --> 01:25:23,193 this used to be an mu1 property 20081 01:25:23,193 --> 01:25:23,193 20082 01:25:23,193 --> 01:25:26,698 and mul property. 20083 01:25:26,698 --> 01:25:35,474 some of the older ant ain't ant 20084 01:25:35,474 --> 01:25:35,474 iquated 20085 01:25:35,474 --> 01:25:35,474 designations. 20086 01:25:35,474 --> 01:25:37,858 the owner held back on that 20087 01:25:37,858 --> 01:25:37,858 idea. 20088 01:25:37,858 --> 01:25:39,810 that was a permitted use for 20089 01:25:39,810 --> 01:25:41,343 decades on this property. 20090 01:25:41,343 --> 01:25:44,521 the u4 and mor does not allow 20091 01:25:44,521 --> 01:25:45,541 that permitted use. 20092 01:25:45,541 --> 01:25:46,846 that's something that the 20093 01:25:46,846 --> 01:25:48,349 property owner is considering, 20094 01:25:48,349 --> 01:25:48,349 20095 01:25:48,349 --> 01:25:50,416 just wanted to mention sort of 20096 01:25:50,416 --> 01:25:50,649 a 20097 01:25:50,649 --> 01:25:51,726 little history and why we're here. 20098 01:25:51,726 --> 01:25:51,726 here. 20099 01:25:51,726 --> 01:25:53,532 there's a reason why someone's 20100 01:25:53,532 --> 01:25:53,532 20101 01:25:53,532 --> 01:25:54,062 here before you. 20102 01:25:54,062 --> 01:26:08,282 all this area has been chartered 20103 01:26:08,282 --> 01:26:08,282 20104 01:26:08,282 --> 01:26:10,018 out for a mix of uses for highe 20105 01:26:10,018 --> 01:26:10,018 r 20106 01:26:10,018 --> 01:26:12,124 density, so we feel like this 20107 01:26:12,124 --> 01:26:13,134 increase and change would be 20108 01:26:13,134 --> 01:26:14,810 appropriate with the land use 20109 01:26:14,810 --> 01:26:18,110 map that you have on the books 20110 01:26:18,110 --> 01:26:18,110 , 20111 01:26:18,110 --> 01:26:20,090 along with its location along 20112 01:26:20,090 --> 01:26:22,167 collector city treat. 20113 01:26:22,167 --> 01:26:25,457 so I feel it's very compatible 20114 01:26:25,457 --> 01:26:25,457 20115 01:26:25,457 --> 01:26:27,421 with that pattern. 20116 01:26:27,421 --> 01:26:28,864 as far as building height, lan 20117 01:26:28,864 --> 01:26:28,864 d 20118 01:26:28,864 --> 01:26:30,298 use and zoning would allow 20119 01:26:30,298 --> 01:26:32,262 three-story buildings. 20120 01:26:32,262 --> 01:26:35,930 this would allow four-story 20121 01:26:35,930 --> 01:26:36,906 buildings by right. 20122 01:26:36,906 --> 01:26:38,699 we did hold a neighborhood 20123 01:26:38,699 --> 01:26:39,713 workshop in the fall. 20124 01:26:39,713 --> 01:26:41,434 we had one community attendee, 20125 01:26:41,434 --> 01:26:43,971 and they did not have any 20126 01:26:43,971 --> 01:26:46,137 objection to the application. 20127 01:26:46,137 --> 01:26:48,680 we sent out notification to the 20128 01:26:48,680 --> 01:26:48,680 20129 01:26:48,680 --> 01:26:50,514 nearby property owners and the 20130 01:26:50,514 --> 01:26:50,514 20131 01:26:50,514 --> 01:26:52,918 notification radius, along wit 20132 01:26:52,918 --> 01:26:52,918 h 20133 01:26:52,918 --> 01:26:54,147 registered neighborhood 20134 01:26:54,147 --> 01:26:54,147 associations. 20135 01:26:54,147 --> 01:27:00,731 you're plan back in december 20136 01:27:00,731 --> 01:27:02,082 recommended approval unanimously 20137 01:27:02,082 --> 01:27:02,082 20138 01:27:02,082 --> 01:27:04,586 of the change, and your staff I 20139 01:27:04,586 --> 01:27:04,586 s 20140 01:27:04,586 --> 01:27:05,982 recommending approval. 20141 01:27:05,982 --> 01:27:06,631 I preernght that. 20142 01:27:06,631 --> 01:27:08,605 I -- I appreciate that. 20143 01:27:08,605 --> 01:27:10,276 we've got something put together 20144 01:27:10,276 --> 01:27:10,276 20145 01:27:10,276 --> 01:27:12,220 that will benefit the community, 20146 01:27:12,220 --> 01:27:12,220 20147 01:27:12,220 --> 01:27:13,234 benefit the property, and 20148 01:27:13,234 --> 01:27:14,452 hopefully bring something 20149 01:27:14,452 --> 01:27:15,704 positive to area and continue t 20150 01:27:15,704 --> 01:27:15,704 o 20151 01:27:15,704 --> 01:27:17,042 build on that momentum. 20152 01:27:17,042 --> 01:27:20,944 so, I think with that, I'll 20153 01:27:20,944 --> 01:27:22,277 conclude and answer any 20154 01:27:22,277 --> 01:27:23,476 questions y'all have tonight. 20155 01:27:23,476 --> 01:27:24,378 >> mayor: thank you. 20156 01:27:24,378 --> 01:27:25,546 all right! 20157 01:27:25,546 --> 01:27:27,425 any questions? 20158 01:27:27,425 --> 01:27:29,087 any comments? 20159 01:27:29,087 --> 01:27:32,008 is there any public comment? 20160 01:27:32,008 --> 01:27:33,856 >> yes, mr. Mayor. 20161 01:27:33,856 --> 01:27:36,603 first, we have petria davis. 20162 01:27:36,603 --> 01:27:36,603 20163 01:27:36,603 --> 01:27:39,460 >> mayor: welcome. 20164 01:27:39,460 --> 01:27:50,380 >> good afternoon, mayor, and 20165 01:27:50,380 --> 01:27:50,380 commissioners. 20166 01:27:50,380 --> 01:27:53,050 I live 30 feet from the parcel 20167 01:27:53,050 --> 01:27:53,050 20168 01:27:53,050 --> 01:27:54,969 being considered for the futur 20169 01:27:54,969 --> 01:27:54,969 e 20170 01:27:54,969 --> 01:27:57,917 land use changed from 4 unit p 20171 01:27:57,917 --> 01:27:57,917 er 20172 01:27:57,917 --> 01:28:00,012 acre to 6 unit per acre. 20173 01:28:00,012 --> 01:28:02,428 I am here today to respectfull 20174 01:28:02,428 --> 01:28:02,428 y 20175 01:28:02,428 --> 01:28:03,717 oppose this change. 20176 01:28:03,717 --> 01:28:11,061 increasing the k density open t 20177 01:28:11,061 --> 01:28:11,061 he 20178 01:28:11,061 --> 01:28:12,926 development far more intense 20179 01:28:12,926 --> 01:28:14,768 than currently exists in our 20180 01:28:14,768 --> 01:28:14,768 neighborhood. 20181 01:28:14,768 --> 01:28:17,099 although the request is tied t 20182 01:28:17,099 --> 01:28:17,099 o 20183 01:28:17,099 --> 01:28:19,605 a funeral home, this could wou 20184 01:28:19,605 --> 01:28:19,605 ld 20185 01:28:19,605 --> 01:28:21,274 allow much larger structure, 20186 01:28:21,274 --> 01:28:23,004 including the possibility of a 20187 01:28:23,004 --> 01:28:23,004 20188 01:28:23,004 --> 01:28:26,574 multi-story building extremely 20189 01:28:26,574 --> 01:28:26,574 20190 01:28:26,574 --> 01:28:28,342 close to my home that would 20191 01:28:28,342 --> 01:28:30,072 significantly affect my privacy 20192 01:28:30,072 --> 01:28:30,072 , 20193 01:28:30,072 --> 01:28:31,972 sunlight, and overall quality of 20194 01:28:31,972 --> 01:28:31,972 20195 01:28:31,972 --> 01:28:31,972 life. 20196 01:28:31,972 --> 01:28:34,916 this area is a family-oriented 20197 01:28:34,916 --> 01:28:34,916 20198 01:28:34,916 --> 01:28:34,916 neighborhood. 20199 01:28:34,916 --> 01:28:37,414 we have children under the age 20200 01:28:37,414 --> 01:28:37,414 20201 01:28:37,414 --> 01:28:40,485 of 10 who regularly play 20202 01:28:40,485 --> 01:28:42,136 outside, riding bicycle, playi 20203 01:28:42,136 --> 01:28:42,136 ng 20204 01:28:42,136 --> 01:28:43,858 basketball, and kicking soccer 20205 01:28:43,858 --> 01:28:43,858 20206 01:28:43,858 --> 01:28:45,288 balls in the yard. 20207 01:28:45,288 --> 01:28:48,570 introducing a commercial-scale 20208 01:28:48,570 --> 01:28:48,570 20209 01:28:48,570 --> 01:28:51,100 facility with increased traffic 20210 01:28:51,100 --> 01:28:51,100 20211 01:28:51,100 --> 01:28:53,158 and frequent visitation would 20212 01:28:53,158 --> 01:28:55,374 create safety risks for these 20213 01:28:55,374 --> 01:28:57,437 children who use the street and 20214 01:28:57,437 --> 01:28:57,437 20215 01:28:57,437 --> 01:28:58,548 surrounding area daily. 20216 01:28:58,548 --> 01:29:01,148 a funeral home will also be 20217 01:29:01,148 --> 01:29:03,006 additional vehicle trips, 20218 01:29:03,006 --> 01:29:07,847 deliveries of peak time 20219 01:29:07,847 --> 01:29:14,150 congestion within a short time 20220 01:29:14,150 --> 01:29:14,150 20221 01:29:14,150 --> 01:29:15,288 conflict of our home. 20222 01:29:15,288 --> 01:29:17,660 beyond safety, placing a 20223 01:29:17,660 --> 01:29:18,960 commercial building so close t 20224 01:29:18,960 --> 01:29:18,960 o 20225 01:29:18,960 --> 01:29:21,930 my property would negatively 20226 01:29:21,930 --> 01:29:23,732 impact my home expral primarily 20227 01:29:23,732 --> 01:29:23,732 20228 01:29:23,732 --> 01:29:25,232 change the character of the 20229 01:29:25,232 --> 01:29:25,232 neighborhood. 20230 01:29:25,232 --> 01:29:27,406 for these reasons I respectfull 20231 01:29:27,406 --> 01:29:27,406 y 20232 01:29:27,406 --> 01:29:31,676 ask you not to approve the land 20233 01:29:31,676 --> 01:29:31,676 20234 01:29:31,676 --> 01:29:33,642 use change from 4 units to 6 20235 01:29:33,642 --> 01:29:33,642 units. 20236 01:29:33,642 --> 01:29:34,957 thank you for your time and 20237 01:29:34,957 --> 01:29:34,957 consideration. 20238 01:29:34,957 --> 01:29:35,648 >> thank you. 20239 01:29:35,648 --> 01:29:41,999 >> sharon bower. 20240 01:29:41,999 --> 01:29:45,390 >> I have a graphic I'd like t 20241 01:29:45,390 --> 01:29:45,390 o 20242 01:29:45,390 --> 01:29:45,390 project. 20243 01:29:45,390 --> 01:29:56,864 this shows not the zoning, but 20244 01:29:56,864 --> 01:29:56,864 20245 01:29:56,864 --> 01:29:57,638 the actual land use. 20246 01:29:57,638 --> 01:30:00,236 here are the chestnut propertie 20247 01:30:00,236 --> 01:30:00,236 s 20248 01:30:00,236 --> 01:30:00,236 here. 20249 01:30:00,236 --> 01:30:07,346 [indistinct] it's surrounded b 20250 01:30:07,346 --> 01:30:07,346 y 20251 01:30:07,346 --> 01:30:10,510 all sides by residential, singl 20252 01:30:10,510 --> 01:30:10,510 e 20253 01:30:10,510 --> 01:30:12,284 family and duplexes. 20254 01:30:12,284 --> 01:30:15,216 most of them, or many of them 20255 01:30:15,216 --> 01:30:16,722 like 40 feet away. 20256 01:30:16,722 --> 01:30:18,552 after december 18th plan board 20257 01:30:18,552 --> 01:30:18,552 20258 01:30:18,552 --> 01:30:20,280 meeting, our neighborhood 20259 01:30:20,280 --> 01:30:21,224 association northeast neighbors 20260 01:30:21,224 --> 01:30:21,224 20261 01:30:21,224 --> 01:30:24,986 asked why the chestnut familie 20262 01:30:24,986 --> 01:30:24,986 s 20263 01:30:24,986 --> 01:30:28,328 needed to use 6 zoning instead 20264 01:30:28,328 --> 01:30:28,328 20265 01:30:28,328 --> 01:30:30,585 of the current 3, and 50 acres 20266 01:30:30,585 --> 01:30:30,585 20267 01:30:30,585 --> 01:30:33,264 instead of 20 for their 20268 01:30:33,264 --> 01:30:33,928 northeast avenue property. 20269 01:30:33,928 --> 01:30:35,238 what they were planning that 20270 01:30:35,238 --> 01:30:36,812 they couldn't do under the 20271 01:30:36,812 --> 01:30:37,170 current zoning. 20272 01:30:37,170 --> 01:30:38,842 we got no answer. 20273 01:30:38,842 --> 01:30:41,044 then we saw the table of 20274 01:30:41,044 --> 01:30:43,781 permitted uses in the code of 20275 01:30:43,781 --> 01:30:48,150 ordinances and saw that a 20276 01:30:48,150 --> 01:30:52,755 funeral home, which a sign on 20277 01:30:52,755 --> 01:30:56,330 the site had announced isn't 20278 01:30:56,330 --> 01:30:58,462 allowed in the u4, even with a 20279 01:30:58,462 --> 01:30:58,462 20280 01:30:58,462 --> 01:31:00,460 special-use permit. 20281 01:31:00,460 --> 01:31:02,062 it would be allowed by right I 20282 01:31:02,062 --> 01:31:02,062 n 20283 01:31:02,062 --> 01:31:04,470 the proposed u6. 20284 01:31:04,470 --> 01:31:07,068 now that the land use is being 20285 01:31:07,068 --> 01:31:07,068 20286 01:31:07,068 --> 01:31:09,578 used to 20 units per acre to 20287 01:31:09,578 --> 01:31:11,474 urban mixed use, 50 units with 20288 01:31:11,474 --> 01:31:11,920 a 20289 01:31:11,920 --> 01:31:14,982 possible 50% density bonus for 20290 01:31:14,982 --> 01:31:14,982 20291 01:31:14,982 --> 01:31:17,014 things like tree preservation 20292 01:31:17,014 --> 01:31:19,785 and an extra two stories for 20293 01:31:19,785 --> 01:31:21,080 landscaping and pedestrian 20294 01:31:21,080 --> 01:31:21,080 access. 20295 01:31:21,080 --> 01:31:23,588 instead of the two units and 20296 01:31:23,588 --> 01:31:25,347 three stories allowed, there 20297 01:31:25,347 --> 01:31:27,686 would be 90 units -- there cou 20298 01:31:27,686 --> 01:31:27,686 ld 20299 01:31:27,686 --> 01:31:30,022 be 90 units and seven stories. 20300 01:31:30,022 --> 01:31:30,022 20301 01:31:30,022 --> 01:31:34,198 the chestnut property's next a 20302 01:31:34,198 --> 01:31:34,198 20303 01:31:34,198 --> 01:31:36,052 church on northeast 8th avenue, 20304 01:31:36,052 --> 01:31:36,052 20305 01:31:36,052 --> 01:31:38,047 and it's surrounded on three 20306 01:31:38,047 --> 01:31:40,469 side by residences, 14 20307 01:31:40,469 --> 01:31:42,406 single-family homes, and three 20308 01:31:42,406 --> 01:31:42,406 20309 01:31:42,406 --> 01:31:42,406 duplexes. 20310 01:31:42,406 --> 01:31:47,648 the people most likely to suffe 20311 01:31:47,648 --> 01:31:47,648 r 20312 01:31:47,648 --> 01:31:50,278 the most negative impact on 20313 01:31:50,278 --> 01:31:51,960 their property values, if a 20314 01:31:51,960 --> 01:31:54,880 funeral home or a seven-story, 20315 01:31:54,880 --> 01:31:54,880 20316 01:31:54,880 --> 01:31:57,122 90-unit apartment building is 20317 01:31:57,122 --> 01:32:00,051 built, or the owners of the 20318 01:32:00,051 --> 01:32:05,060 single-family homes that were 20319 01:32:05,060 --> 01:32:09,572 built in 200 #9 by the housing 20320 01:32:09,572 --> 01:32:09,572 20321 01:32:09,572 --> 01:32:10,631 and neighborhood corporation. 20322 01:32:10,631 --> 01:32:12,208 the only one that has changed 20323 01:32:12,208 --> 01:32:14,910 hands was sold in 2024. 20324 01:32:14,910 --> 01:32:17,614 I'm sure that you if you lived 20325 01:32:17,614 --> 01:32:17,614 20326 01:32:17,614 --> 01:32:19,712 in a residential neighborhood, 20327 01:32:19,712 --> 01:32:19,712 20328 01:32:19,712 --> 01:32:23,080 just single family and d duple 20329 01:32:23,080 --> 01:32:23,080 xes, 20330 01:32:23,080 --> 01:32:27,584 would you not be happy having a 20331 01:32:27,584 --> 01:32:27,584 20332 01:32:27,584 --> 01:32:28,386 funeral home there. 20333 01:32:28,386 --> 01:32:30,192 that is why we are requesting 20334 01:32:30,192 --> 01:32:32,488 that you delay action on this 20335 01:32:32,488 --> 01:32:34,120 and hold a neighborhood 20336 01:32:34,120 --> 01:32:34,120 workshop. 20337 01:32:34,120 --> 01:32:37,100 there's been some confusion. 20338 01:32:37,100 --> 01:32:38,734 people didn't understand the 20339 01:32:38,734 --> 01:32:40,832 implications and the postcard 20340 01:32:40,832 --> 01:32:43,230 they got about today said it 20341 01:32:43,230 --> 01:32:45,440 would be voted on as early as 20342 01:32:45,440 --> 01:32:47,402 10:00 a.m., so people thought 20343 01:32:47,402 --> 01:32:48,468 they were supposed to come thi 20344 01:32:48,468 --> 01:32:48,468 s 20345 01:32:48,468 --> 01:32:49,999 morning and they couldn't, 20346 01:32:49,999 --> 01:32:51,308 because they're working, so 20347 01:32:51,308 --> 01:32:52,638 please, please listen to the 20348 01:32:52,638 --> 01:32:53,938 people in this neighborhood 20349 01:32:53,938 --> 01:32:55,162 because this is going -- you 20350 01:32:55,162 --> 01:32:56,408 would not want this across the 20351 01:32:56,408 --> 01:32:56,408 20352 01:32:56,408 --> 01:32:57,382 street from you. 20353 01:32:57,382 --> 01:33:04,450 >> that was our last speaker, 20354 01:33:04,450 --> 01:33:06,472 mr. Mayor. 20355 01:33:06,472 --> 01:33:07,984 >> mayor: commissioner book. 20356 01:33:07,984 --> 01:33:09,816 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 20357 01:33:09,816 --> 01:33:12,530 such an interesting avenue 20358 01:33:12,530 --> 01:33:13,740 because we have so many 20359 01:33:13,740 --> 01:33:14,830 components going on, we 20360 01:33:14,830 --> 01:33:16,156 discussed it today. 20361 01:33:16,156 --> 01:33:19,214 we talking about mlk and the 20362 01:33:19,214 --> 01:33:20,650 citizen's field. 20363 01:33:20,650 --> 01:33:22,478 the way we develop the roadway 20364 01:33:22,478 --> 01:33:22,478 20365 01:33:22,478 --> 01:33:25,974 and the resurfacing, and land 20366 01:33:25,974 --> 01:33:27,742 use and zoning right in there. 20367 01:33:27,742 --> 01:33:27,742 20368 01:33:27,742 --> 01:33:29,846 I wish sometimes we were able t 20369 01:33:29,846 --> 01:33:29,846 o 20370 01:33:29,846 --> 01:33:32,069 consider them all together, and 20371 01:33:32,069 --> 01:33:32,069 20372 01:33:32,069 --> 01:33:33,356 it's very difficult to do that 20373 01:33:33,356 --> 01:33:33,356 20374 01:33:33,356 --> 01:33:35,214 because one piece holds up 20375 01:33:35,214 --> 01:33:36,504 another piece, and there's a lot 20376 01:33:36,504 --> 01:33:36,504 20377 01:33:36,504 --> 01:33:38,132 of dominoes in that regard. 20378 01:33:38,132 --> 01:33:39,988 I had a couple questions. 20379 01:33:39,988 --> 01:33:43,288 this is probably for city staff 20380 01:33:43,288 --> 01:33:43,288 , 20381 01:33:43,288 --> 01:33:45,450 but in driving down the 20382 01:33:45,450 --> 01:33:47,348 ne 8th avenue and looking at t 20383 01:33:47,348 --> 01:33:47,348 he 20384 01:33:47,348 --> 01:33:49,196 map there are two large parcels, 20385 01:33:49,196 --> 01:33:49,196 20386 01:33:49,196 --> 01:33:50,826 and it does not affect the 20387 01:33:50,826 --> 01:33:54,006 second parcel, and they're 20388 01:33:54,006 --> 01:33:54,006 identical. 20389 01:33:54,006 --> 01:33:57,368 this is one parcel that's about 20390 01:33:57,368 --> 01:33:57,368 20391 01:33:57,368 --> 01:33:58,650 1.5 acres plus. 20392 01:33:58,650 --> 01:34:00,474 is that right? 20393 01:34:00,474 --> 01:34:06,850 >> that's right. 20394 01:34:06,850 --> 01:34:09,954 so, there's four parcels in 20395 01:34:09,954 --> 01:34:11,384 consideration for the future 20396 01:34:11,384 --> 01:34:14,056 land use change in the rezoning. 20397 01:34:14,056 --> 01:34:14,056 20398 01:34:14,056 --> 01:34:18,288 I'll go back to the map that 20399 01:34:18,288 --> 01:34:22,020 shows the parcels, but 20400 01:34:22,020 --> 01:34:23,472 generally, it's considered -- 20401 01:34:23,472 --> 01:34:25,504 there's three parcels actually, 20402 01:34:25,504 --> 01:34:25,504 20403 01:34:25,504 --> 01:34:29,536 sort of fronting northeast 20404 01:34:29,536 --> 01:34:29,919 8th avenue. 20405 01:34:29,919 --> 01:34:32,440 >> so the land use clang in this 20406 01:34:32,440 --> 01:34:32,440 20407 01:34:32,440 --> 01:34:33,808 particular case, as it's 20408 01:34:33,808 --> 01:34:35,552 currently situated, could not 20409 01:34:35,552 --> 01:34:36,880 have a funeral home and has to 20410 01:34:36,880 --> 01:34:36,880 20411 01:34:36,880 --> 01:34:38,372 change if that was a potential 20412 01:34:38,372 --> 01:34:38,372 20413 01:34:38,372 --> 01:34:40,044 use that the applicant was 20414 01:34:40,044 --> 01:34:41,184 interested in. 20415 01:34:41,184 --> 01:34:41,528 >> that's correct. 20416 01:34:41,528 --> 01:34:46,016 so with the current urban 4 20417 01:34:46,016 --> 01:34:47,284 district does not allow funeral 20418 01:34:47,284 --> 01:34:47,284 20419 01:34:47,284 --> 01:34:48,094 homes by right. 20420 01:34:48,094 --> 01:34:51,900 it's not a permitted use in u4. 20421 01:34:51,900 --> 01:34:54,862 the u6 zoning district does I 20422 01:34:54,862 --> 01:34:55,792 law for funeral homes. 20423 01:34:55,792 --> 01:34:57,630 >> my last question is more jus 20424 01:34:57,630 --> 01:34:57,630 t 20425 01:34:57,630 --> 01:34:57,898 a comment. 20426 01:34:57,898 --> 01:34:59,294 we talked about engagement. 20427 01:34:59,294 --> 01:35:01,302 there's always a big differenc 20428 01:35:01,302 --> 01:35:01,302 e 20429 01:35:01,302 --> 01:35:05,904 between engagement in the 20430 01:35:05,904 --> 01:35:07,775 business area because there's 20431 01:35:07,775 --> 01:35:08,880 not a lot of homes around there 20432 01:35:08,880 --> 01:35:08,880 . 20433 01:35:08,880 --> 01:35:10,711 so the people we get more 20434 01:35:10,711 --> 01:35:13,022 feedback in are more intereste 20435 01:35:13,022 --> 01:35:13,022 d 20436 01:35:13,022 --> 01:35:15,016 in the commercial enterprise, 20437 01:35:15,016 --> 01:35:17,413 but the northeast 8th avenue h 20438 01:35:17,413 --> 01:35:17,413 as 20439 01:35:17,413 --> 01:35:19,292 residents all the way down fro 20440 01:35:19,292 --> 01:35:19,292 m 20441 01:35:19,292 --> 01:35:23,190 really from here all the way t 20442 01:35:23,190 --> 01:35:23,190 o 20443 01:35:23,190 --> 01:35:24,984 horizon and to our school there 20444 01:35:24,984 --> 01:35:24,984 . 20445 01:35:24,984 --> 01:35:26,734 so always want to make sure we 20446 01:35:26,734 --> 01:35:26,734 20447 01:35:26,734 --> 01:35:29,162 have a really good feedback fro 20448 01:35:29,162 --> 01:35:29,162 m 20449 01:35:29,162 --> 01:35:33,030 the folks who are most impacte 20450 01:35:33,030 --> 01:35:33,030 d. 20451 01:35:33,030 --> 01:35:34,972 we had one person attend the 20452 01:35:34,972 --> 01:35:34,972 feedback. 20453 01:35:34,972 --> 01:35:37,082 we talked about having 20454 01:35:37,082 --> 01:35:39,134 engagement related to the 20455 01:35:39,134 --> 01:35:39,134 roadway. 20456 01:35:39,134 --> 01:35:42,312 I don't want to complicate 20457 01:35:42,312 --> 01:35:42,312 things. 20458 01:35:42,312 --> 01:35:44,415 it's always good to have that 20459 01:35:44,415 --> 01:35:46,784 type of engagement, as far as 20460 01:35:46,784 --> 01:35:48,980 people impacted, and this abuts 20461 01:35:48,980 --> 01:35:48,980 20462 01:35:48,980 --> 01:35:50,376 business and single family. 20463 01:35:50,376 --> 01:35:51,232 that's just my comment. 20464 01:35:51,232 --> 01:35:52,688 thank you for the work. 20465 01:35:52,688 --> 01:35:54,312 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 20466 01:35:54,312 --> 01:35:55,094 >> mayor: thank you. 20467 01:35:55,094 --> 01:35:56,260 commission willis? 20468 01:35:56,260 --> 01:35:57,820 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 20469 01:35:57,820 --> 01:36:01,464 so this is -- I'm a little 20470 01:36:01,464 --> 01:36:03,766 shocked that a funeral home is 20471 01:36:03,766 --> 01:36:03,766 20472 01:36:03,766 --> 01:36:06,802 not allowed in u4 but allowed I 20473 01:36:06,802 --> 01:36:06,802 n 20474 01:36:06,802 --> 01:36:06,802 u6. 20475 01:36:06,802 --> 01:36:09,466 I would imagine funeral home I 20476 01:36:09,466 --> 01:36:09,466 s 20477 01:36:09,466 --> 01:36:14,142 almost a very suburban-ish in 20478 01:36:14,142 --> 01:36:14,142 20479 01:36:14,142 --> 01:36:14,142 nature. 20480 01:36:14,142 --> 01:36:19,611 it is not really urban use, in 20481 01:36:19,611 --> 01:36:19,611 20482 01:36:19,611 --> 01:36:20,052 my mind. 20483 01:36:20,052 --> 01:36:23,888 so why is it -- can you chart a 20484 01:36:23,888 --> 01:36:23,888 20485 01:36:23,888 --> 01:36:24,990 little bit more -- that's later 20486 01:36:24,990 --> 01:36:24,990 . 20487 01:36:24,990 --> 01:36:27,054 I'll wait for my zoning until 20488 01:36:27,054 --> 01:36:28,250 the actual zoning. 20489 01:36:28,250 --> 01:36:28,250 20490 01:36:28,250 --> 01:36:30,428 so I know that there was 20491 01:36:30,428 --> 01:36:33,197 reference that we did change t 20492 01:36:33,197 --> 01:36:33,197 he 20493 01:36:33,197 --> 01:36:34,828 land use of some of the parcels 20494 01:36:34,828 --> 01:36:34,828 20495 01:36:34,828 --> 01:36:36,272 or I think a couple of the 20496 01:36:36,272 --> 01:36:38,333 parcels in the very far 20497 01:36:38,333 --> 01:36:39,538 northeast of this intersection 20498 01:36:39,538 --> 01:36:39,538 20499 01:36:39,538 --> 01:36:43,030 with waldo and 8th very 20500 01:36:43,030 --> 01:36:46,074 recently, but this does feel a 20501 01:36:46,074 --> 01:36:46,074 20502 01:36:46,074 --> 01:36:47,110 little bit like putting the 20503 01:36:47,110 --> 01:36:48,477 carpet before the horse. 20504 01:36:48,477 --> 01:36:50,242 everything next door is zoned, 20505 01:36:50,242 --> 01:36:50,242 20506 01:36:50,242 --> 01:36:52,212 but it's also a big, huge, 20507 01:36:52,212 --> 01:36:55,279 mostly vacant parcels, right, t 20508 01:36:55,279 --> 01:36:55,279 o 20509 01:36:55,279 --> 01:36:57,593 the east right now. 20510 01:36:57,593 --> 01:36:58,748 largely vacant? 20511 01:36:58,748 --> 01:37:02,486 >> to the east, I believe -- I 20512 01:37:02,486 --> 01:37:02,486 20513 01:37:02,486 --> 01:37:03,688 can't speak to the current 20514 01:37:03,688 --> 01:37:07,168 status of whether they're -- 20515 01:37:07,168 --> 01:37:11,696 whether they're in use actively 20516 01:37:11,696 --> 01:37:11,696 20517 01:37:11,696 --> 01:37:12,862 or not, but you're correct tha 20518 01:37:12,862 --> 01:37:12,862 t 20519 01:37:12,862 --> 01:37:15,600 the land use and zoning did 20520 01:37:15,600 --> 01:37:19,670 change from a pud over to the 20521 01:37:19,670 --> 01:37:20,663 zones on that corner. 20522 01:37:20,663 --> 01:37:22,848 >> I'm sure if the future, to 20523 01:37:22,848 --> 01:37:24,988 commissioner book's point, whe 20524 01:37:24,988 --> 01:37:24,988 n 20525 01:37:24,988 --> 01:37:26,337 we're looking at 8th avenue, 20526 01:37:26,337 --> 01:37:28,076 we're looking at some traffic 20527 01:37:28,076 --> 01:37:28,076 numbers. 20528 01:37:28,076 --> 01:37:30,554 it's not nearly as much as one 20529 01:37:30,554 --> 01:37:30,554 20530 01:37:30,554 --> 01:37:33,022 of the other sections, but all 20531 01:37:33,022 --> 01:37:33,022 20532 01:37:33,022 --> 01:37:34,086 of that corner, outside of wha 20533 01:37:34,086 --> 01:37:34,086 t 20534 01:37:34,086 --> 01:37:34,913 we're talking about today. 20535 01:37:34,913 --> 01:37:36,635 if all that developed in a way 20536 01:37:36,635 --> 01:37:36,635 20537 01:37:36,635 --> 01:37:37,958 that would perhaps have more 20538 01:37:37,958 --> 01:37:40,239 housing or commerce or mix, muc 20539 01:37:40,239 --> 01:37:40,239 h 20540 01:37:40,239 --> 01:37:41,467 more intense, that would chang 20541 01:37:41,467 --> 01:37:41,859 e some of 20542 01:37:41,859 --> 01:37:42,907 some of the traffic on 8th. 20543 01:37:42,907 --> 01:37:46,334 so, I understand this is right 20544 01:37:46,334 --> 01:37:46,334 20545 01:37:46,334 --> 01:37:50,666 next to it, which that's kind o 20546 01:37:50,666 --> 01:37:50,666 f 20547 01:37:50,666 --> 01:37:51,890 that sequential. 20548 01:37:51,890 --> 01:37:54,678 we did one of these up on 20549 01:37:54,678 --> 01:37:56,138 northwest 16th, I believe, 20550 01:37:56,138 --> 01:37:59,374 behind the cvs, just one small 20551 01:37:59,374 --> 01:37:59,374 20552 01:37:59,374 --> 01:38:01,904 parcel, and we barely increased 20553 01:38:01,904 --> 01:38:01,904 the 20554 01:38:01,904 --> 01:38:03,064 the intensity, and that was 20555 01:38:03,064 --> 01:38:05,168 quite a conversation. 20556 01:38:05,168 --> 01:38:07,790 that was right next to something 20557 01:38:07,790 --> 01:38:07,790 20558 01:38:07,790 --> 01:38:09,318 that had been zoned for decades 20559 01:38:09,318 --> 01:38:09,318 , 20560 01:38:09,318 --> 01:38:12,130 at least two decades, and just 20561 01:38:12,130 --> 01:38:12,130 20562 01:38:12,130 --> 01:38:15,562 the one next parcel, about hal 20563 01:38:15,562 --> 01:38:15,562 f 20564 01:38:15,562 --> 01:38:16,668 an acre. 20565 01:38:16,668 --> 01:38:19,596 so, seems -- it makes sense if 20566 01:38:19,596 --> 01:38:19,596 20567 01:38:19,596 --> 01:38:20,704 you're talking about developing 20568 01:38:20,704 --> 01:38:20,704 20569 01:38:20,704 --> 01:38:24,438 the whole corner, but, I 20570 01:38:24,438 --> 01:38:25,976 appreciate that the larger map 20571 01:38:25,976 --> 01:38:25,976 20572 01:38:25,976 --> 01:38:31,240 that mr. Swageer shows, where I 20573 01:38:31,240 --> 01:38:31,240 t 20574 01:38:31,240 --> 01:38:33,280 transitions to -- if we could 20575 01:38:33,280 --> 01:38:36,822 show that, broadcast that 20576 01:38:36,822 --> 01:38:36,822 overhead. 20577 01:38:36,822 --> 01:38:39,224 we are the oldest single famil 20578 01:38:39,224 --> 01:38:39,224 y 20579 01:38:39,224 --> 01:38:40,894 is on the farther west and sou 20580 01:38:40,894 --> 01:38:40,894 th 20581 01:38:40,894 --> 01:38:40,894 side. 20582 01:38:40,894 --> 01:38:43,470 the section, the middle that I 20583 01:38:43,470 --> 01:38:43,470 s 20584 01:38:43,470 --> 01:38:47,956 mixed office resident -- mor I 20585 01:38:47,956 --> 01:38:47,956 s 20586 01:38:47,956 --> 01:38:50,360 not -- mixed use office 20587 01:38:50,360 --> 01:38:50,360 residential. 20588 01:38:50,360 --> 01:38:52,106 that's where it lies. 20589 01:38:52,106 --> 01:38:54,734 this helps give me a little mor 20590 01:38:54,734 --> 01:38:54,734 e 20591 01:38:54,734 --> 01:38:55,374 context for it. 20592 01:38:55,374 --> 01:38:55,374 20593 01:38:55,374 --> 01:39:04,218 seems like it's a little -- I 20594 01:39:04,218 --> 01:39:05,344 would wait until the other 20595 01:39:05,344 --> 01:39:07,614 properties got developed to see 20596 01:39:07,614 --> 01:39:07,614 20597 01:39:07,614 --> 01:39:10,048 what the demand is in the area 20598 01:39:10,048 --> 01:39:10,048 20599 01:39:10,048 --> 01:39:12,236 for land use because that mixed 20600 01:39:12,236 --> 01:39:12,236 20601 01:39:12,236 --> 01:39:14,754 op is clearly we're allowed to 20602 01:39:14,754 --> 01:39:14,754 20603 01:39:14,754 --> 01:39:17,720 have single family in the mixed 20604 01:39:17,720 --> 01:39:17,720 20605 01:39:17,720 --> 01:39:19,030 use office residential? 20606 01:39:19,030 --> 01:39:24,600 >> in urban 4 and urban 6 do 20607 01:39:24,600 --> 01:39:25,922 allow dominate. 20608 01:39:25,922 --> 01:39:28,260 >> in the mixed use office, 20609 01:39:28,260 --> 01:39:30,336 that's why we have some of the 20610 01:39:30,336 --> 01:39:30,336 20611 01:39:30,336 --> 01:39:34,766 homes in southeast 12th street 20612 01:39:34,766 --> 01:39:34,766 . 20613 01:39:34,766 --> 01:39:35,974 that's all I got for now. 20614 01:39:35,974 --> 01:39:36,642 thank you. 20615 01:39:36,642 --> 01:39:37,758 >> mayor: thank you, 20616 01:39:37,758 --> 01:39:38,814 commissioner willis. 20617 01:39:38,814 --> 01:39:40,340 would anyone like to make a 20618 01:39:40,340 --> 01:39:40,340 motion? 20619 01:39:40,340 --> 01:39:40,340 20620 01:39:40,340 --> 01:39:45,188 commissioner book. 20621 01:39:45,188 --> 01:39:47,068 >> I'd like to ask one more 20622 01:39:47,068 --> 01:39:47,068 question. 20623 01:39:47,068 --> 01:39:48,354 this is really for the city 20624 01:39:48,354 --> 01:39:48,354 manager. 20625 01:39:48,354 --> 01:39:52,258 I hate to complicate things. 20626 01:39:52,258 --> 01:39:54,498 is there any benefit in us not 20627 01:39:54,498 --> 01:39:54,498 20628 01:39:54,498 --> 01:39:56,768 kicking the can down the road, 20629 01:39:56,768 --> 01:39:56,768 20630 01:39:56,768 --> 01:39:58,298 but getting the same feedback 20631 01:39:58,298 --> 01:40:00,738 we're about to get from probabl 20632 01:40:00,738 --> 01:40:00,738 y 20633 01:40:00,738 --> 01:40:01,372 a lot of people for that 20634 01:40:01,372 --> 01:40:02,906 corridor because this is the 20635 01:40:02,906 --> 01:40:05,432 exact same stretch of road we're 20636 01:40:05,432 --> 01:40:05,432 20637 01:40:05,432 --> 01:40:07,612 about to get feedback on befor 20638 01:40:07,612 --> 01:40:07,612 e 20639 01:40:07,612 --> 01:40:09,239 or from your perspective, 20640 01:40:09,239 --> 01:40:13,316 mr. Manager -- [indistinct] two 20641 01:40:13,316 --> 01:40:13,316 20642 01:40:13,316 --> 01:40:14,518 very different situations, but 20643 01:40:14,518 --> 01:40:14,518 20644 01:40:14,518 --> 01:40:18,554 they're in the same geography. 20645 01:40:18,554 --> 01:40:18,554 20646 01:40:18,554 --> 01:40:20,620 >> mr. Mayor, I would say that 20647 01:40:20,620 --> 01:40:20,620 20648 01:40:20,620 --> 01:40:22,222 really kind of separate, two 20649 01:40:22,222 --> 01:40:23,628 separate issues. 20650 01:40:23,628 --> 01:40:27,198 I did also kind of want to 20651 01:40:27,198 --> 01:40:30,412 clarify one, somewhat wonky 20652 01:40:30,412 --> 01:40:32,766 aspect, of the discussion about 20653 01:40:32,766 --> 01:40:32,766 20654 01:40:32,766 --> 01:40:35,944 the allowance for a funeral 20655 01:40:35,944 --> 01:40:35,944 home. 20656 01:40:35,944 --> 01:40:38,574 urban 4 zoning in the list of 20657 01:40:38,574 --> 01:40:40,350 permitted uses allows for 20658 01:40:40,350 --> 01:40:42,374 personal services, which that 20659 01:40:42,374 --> 01:40:44,250 definition includes funeral 20660 01:40:44,250 --> 01:40:47,564 homes, so actually that urban 4 20661 01:40:47,564 --> 01:40:47,564 20662 01:40:47,564 --> 01:40:52,032 does allow funeral homes, just 20663 01:40:52,032 --> 01:40:53,549 not specific called-out use. 20664 01:40:53,549 --> 01:41:04,172 it's a little bit in the weeds 20665 01:41:04,172 --> 01:41:04,172 . 20666 01:41:04,172 --> 01:41:05,798 not something that jumps out 20667 01:41:05,798 --> 01:41:07,370 unless you're reading through 20668 01:41:07,370 --> 01:41:07,370 definition. 20669 01:41:07,370 --> 01:41:09,942 >> so why do we need the land 20670 01:41:09,942 --> 01:41:10,314 use change? 20671 01:41:10,314 --> 01:41:29,852 >> -- [indistinct] # 20672 01:41:29,852 --> 01:41:29,852 20673 01:41:29,852 --> 01:41:34,580 >> mayor: ms. Bower -- you had 20674 01:41:34,580 --> 01:41:34,580 20675 01:41:34,580 --> 01:41:35,544 your opportunities. 20676 01:41:35,544 --> 01:41:39,696 >> the question was important 20677 01:41:39,696 --> 01:41:40,486 since you brought it up. 20678 01:41:40,486 --> 01:41:42,208 why do we need the land use 20679 01:41:42,208 --> 01:41:42,208 change? 20680 01:41:42,208 --> 01:41:42,208 20681 01:41:42,208 --> 01:41:50,132 >> I'll take a swipe at it. 20682 01:41:50,132 --> 01:41:52,508 >> the manager's correct in tha 20683 01:41:52,508 --> 01:41:52,508 t 20684 01:41:52,508 --> 01:41:54,342 embedded in the definition 20685 01:41:54,342 --> 01:41:55,618 personal services, but then 20686 01:41:55,618 --> 01:41:57,614 there's the use table that 20687 01:41:57,614 --> 01:42:00,914 doesn't have funeral home as a 20688 01:42:00,914 --> 01:42:00,914 20689 01:42:00,914 --> 01:42:03,690 permitted use in u4, so there's 20690 01:42:03,690 --> 01:42:03,690 20691 01:42:03,690 --> 01:42:04,702 conflicted information. 20692 01:42:04,702 --> 01:42:07,600 so, I'll let the city planning 20693 01:42:07,600 --> 01:42:07,600 20694 01:42:07,600 --> 01:42:09,226 director say more, but that was 20695 01:42:09,226 --> 01:42:09,226 20696 01:42:09,226 --> 01:42:10,866 the response I wanted to give t 20697 01:42:10,866 --> 01:42:10,866 o 20698 01:42:10,866 --> 01:42:12,070 you all. 20699 01:42:12,070 --> 01:42:12,564 >> good evening. 20700 01:42:12,564 --> 01:42:13,266 thank you all. 20701 01:42:13,266 --> 01:42:14,802 director of sustainable 20702 01:42:14,802 --> 01:42:14,802 development. 20703 01:42:14,802 --> 01:42:19,404 the u6 designation also include 20704 01:42:19,404 --> 01:42:19,404 s 20705 01:42:19,404 --> 01:42:21,382 crematory, which is an important 20706 01:42:21,382 --> 01:42:21,382 20707 01:42:21,382 --> 01:42:23,670 adoition that funeral home and 20708 01:42:23,670 --> 01:42:23,670 20709 01:42:23,670 --> 01:42:25,556 the personal services definitio 20710 01:42:25,556 --> 01:42:25,556 n 20711 01:42:25,556 --> 01:42:25,556 there. 20712 01:42:25,556 --> 01:42:31,746 >> so really largely that u6 I 20713 01:42:31,746 --> 01:42:31,746 s 20714 01:42:31,746 --> 01:42:32,852 again additional options or 20715 01:42:32,852 --> 01:42:34,454 opportunities for those 20716 01:42:34,454 --> 01:42:35,792 commercial practices. 20717 01:42:35,792 --> 01:42:38,990 >> very good. 20718 01:42:38,990 --> 01:42:40,659 >> mayor: commissioner book. 20719 01:42:40,659 --> 01:42:43,930 >> I know this merely because w 20720 01:42:43,930 --> 01:42:43,930 e 20721 01:42:43,930 --> 01:42:46,388 have someone on the dais -- 20722 01:42:46,388 --> 01:42:48,104 makes us feel a little bit 20723 01:42:48,104 --> 01:42:51,242 awkward, but we apply the same 20724 01:42:51,242 --> 01:42:51,242 20725 01:42:51,242 --> 01:42:52,642 standards regardless of who's 20726 01:42:52,642 --> 01:42:53,736 involved, and those standards 20727 01:42:53,736 --> 01:42:55,608 are related to the comprehensi 20728 01:42:55,608 --> 01:42:55,608 ve 20729 01:42:55,608 --> 01:42:55,608 plan. 20730 01:42:55,608 --> 01:42:58,410 and if it's substantially in 20731 01:42:58,410 --> 01:42:59,544 compliance with the conference 20732 01:42:59,544 --> 01:42:59,544 20733 01:42:59,544 --> 01:43:01,212 of plan, then by law, not even 20734 01:43:01,212 --> 01:43:01,212 20735 01:43:01,212 --> 01:43:05,982 by opinion, by law we have to 20736 01:43:05,982 --> 01:43:07,030 move forward at least one of 20737 01:43:07,030 --> 01:43:07,030 these. 20738 01:43:07,030 --> 01:43:10,024 so, with that, I move approval 20739 01:43:10,024 --> 01:43:10,024 20740 01:43:10,024 --> 01:43:13,432 of 202-5994 and adopt the 20741 01:43:13,432 --> 01:43:14,862 proposed land use change. 20742 01:43:14,862 --> 01:43:16,434 >> second. 20743 01:43:16,434 --> 01:43:17,368 >> mayor: motion and a second. 20744 01:43:17,368 --> 01:43:17,368 20745 01:43:17,368 --> 01:43:18,914 commissioner willis. 20746 01:43:18,914 --> 01:43:21,054 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 20747 01:43:21,054 --> 01:43:23,366 I know we're getting to zoning 20748 01:43:23,366 --> 01:43:23,366 20749 01:43:23,366 --> 01:43:25,502 in a minute, but some of this I 20750 01:43:25,502 --> 01:43:25,502 s 20751 01:43:25,502 --> 01:43:26,678 helping us understand what is 20752 01:43:26,678 --> 01:43:28,976 allowed in different land uses. 20753 01:43:28,976 --> 01:43:28,976 20754 01:43:28,976 --> 01:43:30,812 I will say I think it's crazy 20755 01:43:30,812 --> 01:43:33,782 that a crematory's allowed in u 20756 01:43:33,782 --> 01:43:33,782 6 20757 01:43:33,782 --> 01:43:36,510 and not u4 because higher up t 20758 01:43:36,510 --> 01:43:36,510 he 20759 01:43:36,510 --> 01:43:38,264 sect is more urban in nature. 20760 01:43:38,264 --> 01:43:39,856 does not make a lot of sense to 20761 01:43:39,856 --> 01:43:39,856 20762 01:43:39,856 --> 01:43:41,225 me, but thank you between the 20763 01:43:41,225 --> 01:43:45,460 manager and mr. [indistinct] 20764 01:43:45,460 --> 01:43:46,034 clarifying it. 20765 01:43:46,034 --> 01:43:47,672 same way talking about hospita 20766 01:43:47,672 --> 01:43:47,672 ls 20767 01:43:47,672 --> 01:43:48,662 and medical services. 20768 01:43:48,662 --> 01:43:50,731 sometimes it's -- the details 20769 01:43:50,731 --> 01:43:52,708 are lost in there somewhere wha 20770 01:43:52,708 --> 01:43:52,708 t 20771 01:43:52,708 --> 01:43:54,234 allowed and what isn't allowed. 20772 01:43:54,234 --> 01:43:54,234 20773 01:43:54,234 --> 01:43:56,206 thank you for clarifying that. 20774 01:43:56,206 --> 01:43:56,206 20775 01:43:56,206 --> 01:44:00,241 so, yeah, that is -- I'm still 20776 01:44:00,241 --> 01:44:00,774 a 20777 01:44:00,774 --> 01:44:04,184 little shocked that we allow I 20778 01:44:04,184 --> 01:44:04,184 t, 20779 01:44:04,184 --> 01:44:08,052 that our zoning code crematory 20780 01:44:08,052 --> 01:44:08,052 20781 01:44:08,052 --> 01:44:11,986 in u6 when I was hearing in a 20782 01:44:11,986 --> 01:44:13,484 different county, union county, 20783 01:44:13,484 --> 01:44:13,484 20784 01:44:13,484 --> 01:44:15,552 the conversation was in a rural 20785 01:44:15,552 --> 01:44:15,552 20786 01:44:15,552 --> 01:44:17,366 area, people thought it was too 20787 01:44:17,366 --> 01:44:17,366 20788 01:44:17,366 --> 01:44:19,058 close to homes, let alone close 20789 01:44:19,058 --> 01:44:19,058 20790 01:44:19,058 --> 01:44:21,910 to what -- the rest of u6 is 20791 01:44:21,910 --> 01:44:25,544 zoned up to 60 verses or 50 20792 01:44:25,544 --> 01:44:27,265 units per acre plus with 20793 01:44:27,265 --> 01:44:30,005 potential bonuses, putting a 20794 01:44:30,005 --> 01:44:31,205 crematory that close to even 20795 01:44:31,205 --> 01:44:32,068 more people. 20796 01:44:32,068 --> 01:44:33,107 I'm having a hard time 20797 01:44:33,107 --> 01:44:35,054 understanding how this got int 20798 01:44:35,054 --> 01:44:35,054 o 20799 01:44:35,054 --> 01:44:39,074 that portion of our comp plan, 20800 01:44:39,074 --> 01:44:39,074 20801 01:44:39,074 --> 01:44:40,176 unless it was completely 20802 01:44:40,176 --> 01:44:40,176 ignored. 20803 01:44:40,176 --> 01:44:43,454 I would think crematories and 20804 01:44:43,454 --> 01:44:44,436 stuff in general should be in 20805 01:44:44,436 --> 01:44:45,757 the more rural area you can 20806 01:44:45,757 --> 01:44:48,288 make, or industrial areas, chi 20807 01:44:48,288 --> 01:44:49,256 which 20808 01:44:49,256 --> 01:44:50,460 I know that's common. 20809 01:44:50,460 --> 01:44:51,324 thank you. 20810 01:44:51,324 --> 01:44:52,332 that's all I have. 20811 01:44:52,332 --> 01:44:54,054 >> mayor: thank you, 20812 01:44:54,054 --> 01:44:57,460 commissioner will is. 20813 01:44:57,460 --> 01:44:58,358 please call the roll. 20814 01:44:58,358 --> 01:45:12,621 20815 01:45:12,621 --> 01:45:20,026 >> mayor: that passes 20816 01:45:20,026 --> 01:45:21,952 unanimously with commissioner 20817 01:45:21,952 --> 01:45:23,852 chestnut abstaining. 20818 01:45:23,852 --> 01:45:26,229 good, commissioner book. 20819 01:45:26,229 --> 01:45:28,336 >> I want a statement released. 20820 01:45:28,336 --> 01:45:28,336 20821 01:45:28,336 --> 01:45:30,102 this first half is since we wi 20822 01:45:30,102 --> 01:45:30,102 ll 20823 01:45:30,102 --> 01:45:31,168 be doing some community 20824 01:45:31,168 --> 01:45:33,475 engagement, we already have the 20825 01:45:33,475 --> 01:45:33,475 20826 01:45:33,475 --> 01:45:35,138 week we've done extensive types 20827 01:45:35,138 --> 01:45:35,138 20828 01:45:35,138 --> 01:45:38,100 of engagement related to the 20829 01:45:38,100 --> 01:45:40,710 northeast 8th avenue, the mlk 20830 01:45:40,710 --> 01:45:42,394 center, citizen's field. 20831 01:45:42,394 --> 01:45:44,846 when we end up sending out mor 20832 01:45:44,846 --> 01:45:44,846 e 20833 01:45:44,846 --> 01:45:46,379 information about the northeast 20834 01:45:46,379 --> 01:45:46,379 20835 01:45:46,379 --> 01:45:50,754 avenue corridor. 20836 01:45:50,754 --> 01:45:52,290 certainly not complicating the 20837 01:45:52,290 --> 01:45:52,290 20838 01:45:52,290 --> 01:45:54,590 matter, providing additional 20839 01:45:54,590 --> 01:45:55,890 information about all the 20840 01:45:55,890 --> 01:45:58,196 components going on so all the 20841 01:45:58,196 --> 01:45:58,196 20842 01:45:58,196 --> 01:45:59,528 people want to weigh in. 20843 01:45:59,528 --> 01:46:01,092 would that be problematic? 20844 01:46:01,092 --> 01:46:05,394 >> I guess, can you clarify wha 20845 01:46:05,394 --> 01:46:05,394 t 20846 01:46:05,394 --> 01:46:06,601 you're asking that we would 20847 01:46:06,601 --> 01:46:06,962 notify about? 20848 01:46:06,962 --> 01:46:13,824 >> sure, for the last two years 20849 01:46:13,824 --> 01:46:13,824 , 20850 01:46:13,824 --> 01:46:14,808 we've been talking about 20851 01:46:14,808 --> 01:46:16,394 citizen's field, and we've got 20852 01:46:16,394 --> 01:46:16,394 20853 01:46:16,394 --> 01:46:17,594 information out many, many times 20854 01:46:17,594 --> 01:46:17,594 20855 01:46:17,594 --> 01:46:18,520 in many different ways. 20856 01:46:18,520 --> 01:46:19,844 earlier today we had the 20857 01:46:19,844 --> 01:46:21,747 northeast 8th avenue, the 20858 01:46:21,747 --> 01:46:22,782 roadway, and everything we're 20859 01:46:22,782 --> 01:46:24,557 doing, and clearly we're going 20860 01:46:24,557 --> 01:46:24,557 20861 01:46:24,557 --> 01:46:26,286 to focus on what neighbors and 20862 01:46:26,286 --> 01:46:26,286 20863 01:46:26,286 --> 01:46:27,926 businesses feel like around 20864 01:46:27,926 --> 01:46:29,857 there and our faith-based 20865 01:46:29,857 --> 01:46:31,581 community, and here we have a 20866 01:46:31,581 --> 01:46:32,592 third component right there in 20867 01:46:32,592 --> 01:46:32,592 20868 01:46:32,592 --> 01:46:35,328 the same area, and it seem to m 20869 01:46:35,328 --> 01:46:35,328 e 20870 01:46:35,328 --> 01:46:36,471 it would be to our benefit, eve 20871 01:46:36,471 --> 01:46:36,471 n 20872 01:46:36,471 --> 01:46:38,563 if we're not asking for input t 20873 01:46:38,563 --> 01:46:38,563 o 20874 01:46:38,563 --> 01:46:39,426 provide as much information 20875 01:46:39,426 --> 01:46:40,639 about all the things we know 20876 01:46:40,639 --> 01:46:57,079 that are going on in an area. 20877 01:46:57,079 --> 01:47:01,590 does that clarify a little bit? 20878 01:47:01,590 --> 01:47:01,590 20879 01:47:01,590 --> 01:47:02,970 >> yes, I believe so. 20880 01:47:02,970 --> 01:47:02,970 20881 01:47:02,970 --> 01:47:05,794 >> mayor: thank you, 20882 01:47:05,794 --> 01:47:09,844 commissioner book. 20883 01:47:09,844 --> 01:47:13,900 >> mr. Mayor, we're on to 20884 01:47:13,900 --> 01:47:16,306 ordinance 2025-995, ordinance o 20885 01:47:16,306 --> 01:47:16,306 f 20886 01:47:16,306 --> 01:47:17,502 the city of gainesville, 20887 01:47:17,502 --> 01:47:19,708 florida, amending the zoning 20888 01:47:19,708 --> 01:47:22,392 atlas by rezoning 1.3 acres of 20889 01:47:22,392 --> 01:47:22,392 20890 01:47:22,392 --> 01:47:24,078 property generally located at 20891 01:47:24,078 --> 01:47:27,010 the 1200 block of northeast 20892 01:47:27,010 --> 01:47:38,469 8th avenue. 20893 01:47:38,469 --> 01:47:49,775 >> this is the rezoning of the 20894 01:47:49,775 --> 01:47:49,775 20895 01:47:49,775 --> 01:47:53,846 chestnut petition. 20896 01:47:53,846 --> 01:47:55,956 so this is the same area we wer 20897 01:47:55,956 --> 01:47:55,956 e 20898 01:47:55,956 --> 01:47:57,098 just discussing. 20899 01:47:57,098 --> 01:47:58,003 the portion that we're 20900 01:47:58,003 --> 01:48:03,286 discussing now is the urban 6 20901 01:48:03,286 --> 01:48:05,787 area going from u4 to u6, and 20902 01:48:05,787 --> 01:48:07,988 same area we are discussing. 20903 01:48:07,988 --> 01:48:10,558 here you can see -- I'll pause 20904 01:48:10,558 --> 01:48:10,558 20905 01:48:10,558 --> 01:48:12,428 for a second to talk about the 20906 01:48:12,428 --> 01:48:12,428 20907 01:48:12,428 --> 01:48:14,329 zoning districts, so as you can 20908 01:48:14,329 --> 01:48:14,329 20909 01:48:14,329 --> 01:48:17,308 see in the blue urban 4 being 20910 01:48:17,308 --> 01:48:20,564 the subject property and u6 20911 01:48:20,564 --> 01:48:25,044 existing on the east side, so 20912 01:48:25,044 --> 01:48:26,107 east of the subject properties 20913 01:48:26,107 --> 01:48:26,107 20914 01:48:26,107 --> 01:48:28,180 to the south, there's more urb 20915 01:48:28,180 --> 01:48:28,180 an 20916 01:48:28,180 --> 01:48:30,810 4 zoning and to the west is 20917 01:48:30,810 --> 01:48:33,551 urban 3 zoning. 20918 01:48:33,551 --> 01:48:36,076 to the north with citizen's 20919 01:48:36,076 --> 01:48:40,220 field being public service, and 20920 01:48:40,220 --> 01:48:40,220 20921 01:48:40,220 --> 01:48:41,988 mu1 being to the north as well. 20922 01:48:41,988 --> 01:48:41,988 20923 01:48:41,988 --> 01:48:45,954 and urban 6 is the proposed 20924 01:48:45,954 --> 01:48:47,558 zoning district for this, and 20925 01:48:47,558 --> 01:48:49,788 I'll get a little bit into the 20926 01:48:49,788 --> 01:48:49,788 20927 01:48:49,788 --> 01:48:53,174 table with the permitted uses t 20928 01:48:53,174 --> 01:48:53,174 o 20929 01:48:53,174 --> 01:48:54,720 explain a little bit more 20930 01:48:54,720 --> 01:48:58,288 between u4 and u6, so, for thi 20931 01:48:58,288 --> 01:48:58,288 s 20932 01:48:58,288 --> 01:49:00,370 table you can see the uses 20933 01:49:00,370 --> 01:49:01,904 listed on the left. 20934 01:49:01,904 --> 01:49:03,442 those are uses just directly 20935 01:49:03,442 --> 01:49:04,972 from the land development code 20936 01:49:04,972 --> 01:49:04,972 20937 01:49:04,972 --> 01:49:07,168 of what is permitted, not 20938 01:49:07,168 --> 01:49:08,782 permitted, or allowed by 20939 01:49:08,782 --> 01:49:10,582 accessory, or allowed with a 20940 01:49:10,582 --> 01:49:12,230 special-use permit. 20941 01:49:12,230 --> 01:49:13,926 you can see the columns with u 20942 01:49:13,926 --> 01:49:13,926 20943 01:49:13,926 --> 01:49:16,994 u4 -- what's allowed is p with 20944 01:49:16,994 --> 01:49:17,858 a 20945 01:49:17,858 --> 01:49:20,296 permitted, allowed by accessory 20946 01:49:20,296 --> 01:49:20,296 20947 01:49:20,296 --> 01:49:23,129 a, and also the column for u6. 20948 01:49:23,129 --> 01:49:23,129 20949 01:49:23,129 --> 01:49:24,861 so I'll click through some of 20950 01:49:24,861 --> 01:49:24,861 these. 20951 01:49:24,861 --> 01:49:28,618 I've also highlighted in blue 20952 01:49:28,618 --> 01:49:30,768 where with the rezoning going 20953 01:49:30,768 --> 01:49:32,302 from u4 to u6. 20954 01:49:32,302 --> 01:49:35,352 if it's blue that means it is 20955 01:49:35,352 --> 01:49:36,714 now permitted in u6. 20956 01:49:36,714 --> 01:49:39,599 if they're rezoning carries 20957 01:49:39,599 --> 01:49:39,599 forward. 20958 01:49:39,599 --> 01:49:42,892 in the orange it would no longer 20959 01:49:42,892 --> 01:49:42,892 20960 01:49:42,892 --> 01:49:44,156 be permitted in u6. 20961 01:49:44,156 --> 01:49:46,322 you'll see there's all blues a 20962 01:49:46,322 --> 01:49:46,322 s 20963 01:49:46,322 --> 01:49:49,094 far as the change from u4 to u 20964 01:49:49,094 --> 01:49:49,094 6 20965 01:49:49,094 --> 01:49:49,632 is considered. 20966 01:49:49,632 --> 01:49:53,272 so there would be no, I guess, 20967 01:49:53,272 --> 01:49:53,272 20968 01:49:53,272 --> 01:49:55,194 loss of a permitted use if you 20969 01:49:55,194 --> 01:49:55,194 20970 01:49:55,194 --> 01:49:56,938 will, and this just captures t 20971 01:49:56,938 --> 01:49:56,938 he 20972 01:49:56,938 --> 01:49:58,167 non-residential uses. 20973 01:49:58,167 --> 01:50:01,104 I have another table going ove 20974 01:50:01,104 --> 01:50:01,104 r 20975 01:50:01,104 --> 01:50:02,636 density in the residential 20976 01:50:02,636 --> 01:50:02,636 component. 20977 01:50:02,636 --> 01:50:05,692 just clicking through. 20978 01:50:05,692 --> 01:50:07,790 as I explained previously, u6 20979 01:50:07,790 --> 01:50:09,409 zoning allows for more 20980 01:50:09,409 --> 01:50:11,046 non-residential uses, including 20981 01:50:11,046 --> 01:50:11,046 20982 01:50:11,046 --> 01:50:13,012 commercial and retail uses by 20983 01:50:13,012 --> 01:50:13,012 right. 20984 01:50:13,012 --> 01:50:14,986 so you can see as I click 20985 01:50:14,986 --> 01:50:16,674 through things like restaurant 20986 01:50:16,674 --> 01:50:16,674 20987 01:50:16,674 --> 01:50:17,940 and retail sales would be al 20988 01:50:17,940 --> 01:50:22,856 allowed by right with the p? 20989 01:50:22,856 --> 01:50:25,152 in 20990 01:50:25,152 --> 01:50:25,860 u6 zoning. 20991 01:50:25,860 --> 01:50:40,909 20992 01:50:40,909 --> 01:50:45,048 going from u4 to u6, that would 20993 01:50:45,048 --> 01:50:45,048 20994 01:50:45,048 --> 01:50:47,316 be changing from 20 to 50 units 20995 01:50:47,316 --> 01:50:47,316 20996 01:50:47,316 --> 01:50:47,752 per acre. 20997 01:50:47,752 --> 01:50:50,112 just to note that the subject 20998 01:50:50,112 --> 01:50:51,190 area that is being considered 20999 01:50:51,190 --> 01:50:54,886 for rezoning is 1.38 acres, so, 21000 01:50:54,886 --> 01:50:54,886 21001 01:50:54,886 --> 01:50:57,890 at 50 units per acre, that's 69 21002 01:50:57,890 --> 01:50:57,890 21003 01:50:57,890 --> 01:50:59,848 units maximum. 21004 01:50:59,848 --> 01:51:02,032 we've discussed the maximum 21005 01:51:02,032 --> 01:51:05,098 stories going from u4 allows 21006 01:51:05,098 --> 01:51:06,936 three stories by right. 21007 01:51:06,936 --> 01:51:11,772 u6 allows four stories by right 21008 01:51:11,772 --> 01:51:11,772 , 21009 01:51:11,772 --> 01:51:14,144 and five with a bonus for tree 21010 01:51:14,144 --> 01:51:14,144 21011 01:51:14,144 --> 01:51:16,776 preservation or things like 21012 01:51:16,776 --> 01:51:17,647 affordable housing. 21013 01:51:17,647 --> 01:51:19,488 maximum height is listed there 21014 01:51:19,488 --> 01:51:19,488 21015 01:51:19,488 --> 01:51:22,656 as well, and there would be an 21016 01:51:22,656 --> 01:51:22,656 21017 01:51:22,656 --> 01:51:24,224 increased in required glazing. 21018 01:51:24,224 --> 01:51:24,224 21019 01:51:24,224 --> 01:51:27,186 changing from u4 to u6 dependi 21020 01:51:27,186 --> 01:51:27,186 ng 21021 01:51:27,186 --> 01:51:28,352 on the type of project that's 21022 01:51:28,352 --> 01:51:29,988 proposed, additional treatments 21023 01:51:29,988 --> 01:51:29,988 21024 01:51:29,988 --> 01:51:33,862 to the urban forum, like 21025 01:51:33,862 --> 01:51:36,708 sidewalk improvements or 21026 01:51:36,708 --> 01:51:38,026 material improvements, dependi 21027 01:51:38,026 --> 01:51:38,026 ng 21028 01:51:38,026 --> 01:51:39,532 on the project, may also be 21029 01:51:39,532 --> 01:51:42,070 imposed with different uses 21030 01:51:42,070 --> 01:51:43,468 being allowed at the site. 21031 01:51:43,468 --> 01:51:47,172 but generally, setbacks, 21032 01:51:47,172 --> 01:51:49,714 building placement and buildin 21033 01:51:49,714 --> 01:51:49,714 g 21034 01:51:49,714 --> 01:51:51,552 frontage, all would remain the 21035 01:51:51,552 --> 01:51:51,552 21036 01:51:51,552 --> 01:51:54,312 same between u4 and u6, and tha 21037 01:51:54,312 --> 01:51:54,312 t 21038 01:51:54,312 --> 01:51:55,316 should remain the same. 21039 01:51:55,316 --> 01:51:58,017 I can also talk about urban fiv 21040 01:51:58,017 --> 01:51:58,017 e 21041 01:51:58,017 --> 01:52:00,518 should you have any questions, 21042 01:52:00,518 --> 01:52:00,518 21043 01:52:00,518 --> 01:52:02,206 have some notes for that, if y 21044 01:52:02,206 --> 01:52:02,206 ou 21045 01:52:02,206 --> 01:52:02,820 are interested. 21046 01:52:02,820 --> 01:52:06,326 so, with the proposed zoning 21047 01:52:06,326 --> 01:52:11,362 staff reviewed the petition 21048 01:52:11,362 --> 01:52:14,106 based on the criteria in the 21049 01:52:14,106 --> 01:52:15,200 land development code. 21050 01:52:15,200 --> 01:52:18,072 the u6 zoning district is 21051 01:52:18,072 --> 01:52:19,036 compatible with the sownding 21052 01:52:19,036 --> 01:52:21,238 uses, and allowed intensity and 21053 01:52:21,238 --> 01:52:21,238 21054 01:52:21,238 --> 01:52:21,238 density. 21055 01:52:21,238 --> 01:52:23,836 u6 zoning exists to the east o 21056 01:52:23,836 --> 01:52:23,836 f 21057 01:52:23,836 --> 01:52:25,476 the subject property and many o 21058 01:52:25,476 --> 01:52:25,476 f 21059 01:52:25,476 --> 01:52:27,252 the u6 permitted uses are 21060 01:52:27,252 --> 01:52:29,076 similar to those in the u4 21061 01:52:29,076 --> 01:52:31,316 zoning district, with some of 21062 01:52:31,316 --> 01:52:33,252 those additional non-residenti 21063 01:52:33,252 --> 01:52:33,252 al 21064 01:52:33,252 --> 01:52:34,686 allowances I mentioned. 21065 01:52:34,686 --> 01:52:36,624 the proposed rezoning also 21066 01:52:36,624 --> 01:52:38,490 conformed to an additional set 21067 01:52:38,490 --> 01:52:38,490 21068 01:52:38,490 --> 01:52:43,962 of criteria, the transect zone 21069 01:52:43,962 --> 01:52:43,962 21070 01:52:43,962 --> 01:52:43,962 criteria. 21071 01:52:43,962 --> 01:52:48,141 it establishes a logical 21072 01:52:48,141 --> 01:52:49,781 extension of the existing u6 t 21073 01:52:49,781 --> 01:52:49,781 o 21074 01:52:49,781 --> 01:52:50,108 the exist. 21075 01:52:50,108 --> 01:52:54,140 a more urban transect zone is 21076 01:52:54,140 --> 01:52:55,668 appropriate considering the 21077 01:52:55,668 --> 01:52:57,304 interest in development in thi 21078 01:52:57,304 --> 01:52:57,304 s 21079 01:52:57,304 --> 01:52:58,744 area, and the improvements the 21080 01:52:58,744 --> 01:52:58,744 21081 01:52:58,744 --> 01:53:01,948 city's making to the corridor. 21082 01:53:01,948 --> 01:53:01,948 21083 01:53:01,948 --> 01:53:05,084 if development at the property 21084 01:53:05,084 --> 01:53:05,084 21085 01:53:05,084 --> 01:53:08,324 occurs the urban transect zone 21086 01:53:08,324 --> 01:53:08,324 21087 01:53:08,324 --> 01:53:09,634 standards would require 21088 01:53:09,634 --> 01:53:10,892 additional glazing, and 21089 01:53:10,892 --> 01:53:14,160 depending on the type of proje 21090 01:53:14,160 --> 01:53:14,160 ct 21091 01:53:14,160 --> 01:53:15,797 more material standards or oth 21092 01:53:15,797 --> 01:53:15,797 er 21093 01:53:15,797 --> 01:53:17,668 things may also be applied. 21094 01:53:17,668 --> 01:53:23,136 I also wanted to mention the u 21095 01:53:23,136 --> 01:53:23,136 6 21096 01:53:23,136 --> 01:53:25,872 zoning district would come int 21097 01:53:25,872 --> 01:53:25,872 o 21098 01:53:25,872 --> 01:53:28,612 play with the inclusionary 21099 01:53:28,612 --> 01:53:29,952 zoning requirement, so going 21100 01:53:29,952 --> 01:53:31,876 from u4 to u6. 21101 01:53:31,876 --> 01:53:34,176 u6 is one of the zoning distric 21102 01:53:34,176 --> 01:53:34,176 t 21103 01:53:34,176 --> 01:53:35,752 that is would require 21104 01:53:35,752 --> 01:53:37,216 inclusionary zoning if the 21105 01:53:37,216 --> 01:53:38,320 property were developed with 21106 01:53:38,320 --> 01:53:40,188 over 50 units. 21107 01:53:40,188 --> 01:53:41,286 and I think that is all that I 21108 01:53:41,286 --> 01:53:41,286 21109 01:53:41,286 --> 01:53:42,496 have to say. 21110 01:53:42,496 --> 01:53:45,677 staff recommends approval of 21111 01:53:45,677 --> 01:53:53,212 ld25- 000125, and the plan boa 21112 01:53:53,212 --> 01:53:53,212 rd 21113 01:53:53,212 --> 01:53:54,296 recommended approval of the 21114 01:53:54,296 --> 01:53:54,296 petition. 21115 01:53:54,296 --> 01:53:56,482 here for any questions you hav 21116 01:53:56,482 --> 01:53:56,482 e. 21117 01:53:56,482 --> 01:53:57,571 >> mayor: very good. 21118 01:53:57,571 --> 01:53:58,424 thank you. 21119 01:53:58,424 --> 01:53:59,874 applicant have anything to add 21120 01:53:59,874 --> 01:54:10,363 ? 21121 01:54:10,363 --> 01:54:13,380 if you have questions for me, I' 21122 01:54:13,380 --> 01:54:13,924 I'm glad to answer them. 21123 01:54:13,924 --> 01:54:16,432 with the umu land use, you nee 21124 01:54:16,432 --> 01:54:16,432 d 21125 01:54:16,432 --> 01:54:18,592 to consider a new zoning, and u 21126 01:54:18,592 --> 01:54:18,592 6 21127 01:54:18,592 --> 01:54:20,866 is one of the lower tier, 21128 01:54:20,866 --> 01:54:23,538 less-intense zoning options tha 21129 01:54:23,538 --> 01:54:23,538 t 21130 01:54:23,538 --> 01:54:23,936 you have. 21131 01:54:23,936 --> 01:54:28,082 I did want to mention too, in 21132 01:54:28,082 --> 01:54:29,538 the back to our previous 21133 01:54:29,538 --> 01:54:31,910 conversation a few minutes ago 21134 01:54:31,910 --> 01:54:31,910 21135 01:54:31,910 --> 01:54:33,840 at our neighborhood workshop, w 21136 01:54:33,840 --> 01:54:33,840 e 21137 01:54:33,840 --> 01:54:35,974 did make an extra effort to lay 21138 01:54:35,974 --> 01:54:35,974 21139 01:54:35,974 --> 01:54:37,879 out the table to show what use 21140 01:54:37,879 --> 01:54:37,879 s 21141 01:54:37,879 --> 01:54:40,914 are allowed, what's not allowed, 21142 01:54:40,914 --> 01:54:40,914 21143 01:54:40,914 --> 01:54:42,312 what are the changes. 21144 01:54:42,312 --> 01:54:44,082 we were clear and announced tha 21145 01:54:44,082 --> 01:54:44,082 t 21146 01:54:44,082 --> 01:54:47,359 the funeral home is a 21147 01:54:47,359 --> 01:54:47,359 possibility. 21148 01:54:47,359 --> 01:54:49,026 we're trying to be transparent 21149 01:54:49,026 --> 01:54:49,026 21150 01:54:49,026 --> 01:54:50,468 about this, but, of course, you 21151 01:54:50,468 --> 01:54:50,468 21152 01:54:50,468 --> 01:54:51,696 all have to consider all the 21153 01:54:51,696 --> 01:54:53,488 uses that are allowed in u6, a 21154 01:54:53,488 --> 01:54:53,488 nd 21155 01:54:53,488 --> 01:54:55,364 we really think it's compatibl 21156 01:54:55,364 --> 01:54:55,364 e 21157 01:54:55,364 --> 01:54:58,370 with that overall map pattern w 21158 01:54:58,370 --> 01:54:58,370 e 21159 01:54:58,370 --> 01:54:59,658 had discussed a few minutes ago 21160 01:54:59,658 --> 01:54:59,658 . 21161 01:54:59,658 --> 01:55:00,838 if you have any questions for 21162 01:55:00,838 --> 01:55:03,942 me, I would be glad to answer 21163 01:55:03,942 --> 01:55:03,942 -- 21164 01:55:03,942 --> 01:55:04,836 one last thing too. 21165 01:55:04,836 --> 01:55:07,752 I think the neighbor who was 21166 01:55:07,752 --> 01:55:10,152 here and left, if a project 21167 01:55:10,152 --> 01:55:11,862 comes sphward they'll have to 21168 01:55:11,862 --> 01:55:11,862 -- 21169 01:55:11,862 --> 01:55:15,882 forward, stl they'll have to d 21170 01:55:15,882 --> 01:55:16,048 o a 21171 01:55:16,048 --> 01:55:17,822 site plan review, and most 21172 01:55:17,822 --> 01:55:18,653 likely neighborhood workshop. 21173 01:55:18,653 --> 01:55:20,852 I'm sure this project would tak 21174 01:55:20,852 --> 01:55:20,852 e 21175 01:55:20,852 --> 01:55:21,726 into consideration local stree 21176 01:55:21,726 --> 01:55:21,726 ts 21177 01:55:21,726 --> 01:55:24,020 and neighbors and zoning code 21178 01:55:24,020 --> 01:55:26,624 allows -- I'm sorry, it require 21179 01:55:26,624 --> 01:55:26,624 s 21180 01:55:26,624 --> 01:55:28,728 buildings to be fronting the 21181 01:55:28,728 --> 01:55:29,910 primary street, addressing the 21182 01:55:29,910 --> 01:55:29,910 21183 01:55:29,910 --> 01:55:32,430 street, which is 8th avenue, a 21184 01:55:32,430 --> 01:55:32,430 nd 21185 01:55:32,430 --> 01:55:34,294 so the concentration of any 21186 01:55:34,294 --> 01:55:35,635 development on this property I 21187 01:55:35,635 --> 01:55:35,635 s 21188 01:55:35,635 --> 01:55:37,174 going to be towards the more 21189 01:55:37,174 --> 01:55:39,444 primary street and away from t 21190 01:55:39,444 --> 01:55:39,444 he 21191 01:55:39,444 --> 01:55:42,949 residential area to the south. 21192 01:55:42,949 --> 01:55:42,949 21193 01:55:42,949 --> 01:55:43,914 certainly aware of that issue. 21194 01:55:43,914 --> 01:55:43,914 21195 01:55:43,914 --> 01:55:44,274 thank you. 21196 01:55:44,274 --> 01:55:45,574 >> mayor: thank you, 21197 01:55:45,574 --> 01:55:47,360 mr. Swager. 21198 01:55:47,360 --> 01:55:51,804 I would point out also that ha 21199 01:55:51,804 --> 01:55:51,804 s 21200 01:55:51,804 --> 01:55:58,270 been alluded, it's our decision 21201 01:55:58,270 --> 01:55:58,270 21202 01:55:58,270 --> 01:55:59,630 tonight to allow a particular 21203 01:55:59,630 --> 01:55:59,630 use. 21204 01:55:59,630 --> 01:56:01,222 whether to allow the different 21205 01:56:01,222 --> 01:56:01,222 21206 01:56:01,222 --> 01:56:01,222 zoning. 21207 01:56:01,222 --> 01:56:06,370 not what will go in that, on 21208 01:56:06,370 --> 01:56:07,226 these lots. 21209 01:56:07,226 --> 01:56:10,102 that is for a future question. 21210 01:56:10,102 --> 01:56:10,102 21211 01:56:10,102 --> 01:56:12,500 tonight's question is, will we 21212 01:56:12,500 --> 01:56:12,500 21213 01:56:12,500 --> 01:56:14,072 allow the zoning to move forwa 21214 01:56:14,072 --> 01:56:14,072 rd 21215 01:56:14,072 --> 01:56:15,774 as requested? 21216 01:56:15,774 --> 01:56:20,956 commissioner willits. 21217 01:56:20,956 --> 01:56:24,124 >> questions about u5 instead o 21218 01:56:24,124 --> 01:56:24,124 f 21219 01:56:24,124 --> 01:56:24,124 u6. 21220 01:56:24,124 --> 01:56:28,460 u5 is allow inside thi 21221 01:56:28,460 --> 01:56:32,668 >> it's actually not. 21222 01:56:32,668 --> 01:56:41,465 skipping to 6, what about 5. D 21223 01:56:41,465 --> 01:56:41,730 on't have my laptop. 21224 01:56:41,730 --> 01:56:44,578 it's at it, but I have my 21225 01:56:44,578 --> 01:56:46,108 phone -- the better question. 21226 01:56:46,108 --> 01:56:47,840 what are the other zonings 21227 01:56:47,840 --> 01:56:47,840 allowed? 21228 01:56:47,840 --> 01:56:50,210 that's kind of what I was 21229 01:56:50,210 --> 01:56:51,779 looking at. 21230 01:56:51,779 --> 01:56:55,181 in the urban mixed use zoning 21231 01:56:55,181 --> 01:56:57,786 district -- sorry, future land 21232 01:56:57,786 --> 01:56:57,786 21233 01:56:57,786 --> 01:56:59,654 use category, there are three 21234 01:56:59,654 --> 01:57:01,390 sort of allowable zoning 21235 01:57:01,390 --> 01:57:03,392 districts to choose from that 21236 01:57:03,392 --> 01:57:05,390 would be permitted in that 21237 01:57:05,390 --> 01:57:05,390 category. 21238 01:57:05,390 --> 01:57:09,160 it would be u6, u7, or u8. 21239 01:57:09,160 --> 01:57:11,872 the u5 zoning district is only 21240 01:57:11,872 --> 01:57:11,872 21241 01:57:11,872 --> 01:57:14,804 allowed in the mixed-use 21242 01:57:14,804 --> 01:57:16,440 residential future land use 21243 01:57:16,440 --> 01:57:18,144 category, which is primarily 21244 01:57:18,144 --> 01:57:24,882 areas like sorority row 21245 01:57:24,882 --> 01:57:26,192 surrounding the university tha 21246 01:57:26,192 --> 01:57:26,192 t 21247 01:57:26,192 --> 01:57:27,878 have a unique set of 21248 01:57:27,878 --> 01:57:28,850 circumstances that have 21249 01:57:28,850 --> 01:57:30,278 descriptions of the u5 zoning 21250 01:57:30,278 --> 01:57:32,224 district if you're curious, but 21251 01:57:32,224 --> 01:57:32,224 21252 01:57:32,224 --> 01:57:33,374 that is not something that cou 21253 01:57:33,374 --> 01:57:33,374 ld 21254 01:57:33,374 --> 01:57:35,890 be placed in the urban mixed u 21255 01:57:35,890 --> 01:57:35,890 se 21256 01:57:35,890 --> 01:57:36,458 future land category. 21257 01:57:36,458 --> 01:57:38,794 >> I want to remind -- which 21258 01:57:38,794 --> 01:57:40,892 runs are available? 21259 01:57:40,892 --> 01:57:42,792 so then, can you tell me the 21260 01:57:42,792 --> 01:57:44,002 difference between u6. 21261 01:57:44,002 --> 01:57:46,694 typically as you go up, more a 21262 01:57:46,694 --> 01:57:46,694 nd 21263 01:57:46,694 --> 01:57:48,468 more things are allowed and 21264 01:57:48,468 --> 01:57:49,910 permitted, but I wanted to 21265 01:57:49,910 --> 01:57:51,543 double check on a few things. 21266 01:57:51,543 --> 01:57:55,912 drive-through facility is 21267 01:57:55,912 --> 01:57:57,572 allowed and permitted in u6. 21268 01:57:57,572 --> 01:58:00,478 is it permitted in u7 and u8? 21269 01:58:00,478 --> 01:58:02,178 >> I can check that. 21270 01:58:02,178 --> 01:58:02,178 21271 01:58:02,178 --> 01:58:06,518 table is limited in its 21272 01:58:06,518 --> 01:58:06,518 research. 21273 01:58:06,518 --> 01:58:12,306 >> it's one that wasn't allowed 21274 01:58:12,306 --> 01:58:12,306 21275 01:58:12,306 --> 01:58:14,966 in u4, but it is permitted in 21276 01:58:14,966 --> 01:58:14,966 u6. 21277 01:58:14,966 --> 01:58:18,460 so I'm trying -- in general, I 21278 01:58:18,460 --> 01:58:18,460 21279 01:58:18,460 --> 01:58:20,510 know that usually as you go up 21280 01:58:20,510 --> 01:58:20,510 21281 01:58:20,510 --> 01:58:21,700 more and more things are 21282 01:58:21,700 --> 01:58:24,010 permitted, but I think some 21283 01:58:24,010 --> 01:58:25,964 things drop out as you get 21284 01:58:25,964 --> 01:58:27,204 closer to u9. 21285 01:58:27,204 --> 01:58:28,150 >> that's correct. 21286 01:58:28,150 --> 01:58:29,732 some uses do drop off as you g 21287 01:58:29,732 --> 01:58:29,732 et 21288 01:58:29,732 --> 01:58:34,182 to the more intensive united d 21289 01:58:34,182 --> 01:58:34,182 t 21290 01:58:34,182 --> 01:58:35,926 zoning districts, but 21291 01:58:35,926 --> 01:58:37,690 drive-through facilities are 21292 01:58:37,690 --> 01:58:39,882 allowed in u6 and through u8. 21293 01:58:39,882 --> 01:58:41,860 >> this is where I get to -- t 21294 01:58:41,860 --> 01:58:41,860 he 21295 01:58:41,860 --> 01:58:45,258 idea of permitting, and I know 21296 01:58:45,258 --> 01:58:45,258 21297 01:58:45,258 --> 01:58:47,590 we, on the legislative, somewha 21298 01:58:47,590 --> 01:58:47,590 t 21299 01:58:47,590 --> 01:58:49,536 optional side land use, we 21300 01:58:49,536 --> 01:58:50,930 already at least one time 21301 01:58:50,930 --> 01:58:53,964 around, made that decision, but 21302 01:58:53,964 --> 01:58:53,964 21303 01:58:53,964 --> 01:58:55,842 zoning it for that one in 21304 01:58:55,842 --> 01:59:01,284 particular in this specific are 21305 01:59:01,284 --> 01:59:01,284 a 21306 01:59:01,284 --> 01:59:03,528 seems a little crazy that you'd 21307 01:59:03,528 --> 01:59:03,528 21308 01:59:03,528 --> 01:59:05,238 have a drive-through facility 21309 01:59:05,238 --> 01:59:06,812 there, and like a lot of these 21310 01:59:06,812 --> 01:59:06,812 21311 01:59:06,812 --> 01:59:09,216 other ones, things that don't 21312 01:59:09,216 --> 01:59:14,886 make a lot of sense right there 21313 01:59:14,886 --> 01:59:14,886 . 21314 01:59:14,886 --> 01:59:16,522 so anyways, that's the one tha 21315 01:59:16,522 --> 01:59:16,522 t 21316 01:59:16,522 --> 01:59:20,890 stuck out to me on the list of 21317 01:59:20,890 --> 01:59:20,890 21318 01:59:20,890 --> 01:59:24,062 just because it is still jamme 21319 01:59:24,062 --> 01:59:24,062 d 21320 01:59:24,062 --> 01:59:26,136 in next to not very far away 21321 01:59:26,136 --> 01:59:29,532 single-family homes, out of the 21322 01:59:29,532 --> 01:59:29,532 21323 01:59:29,532 --> 01:59:30,026 quiet corner. 21324 01:59:30,026 --> 01:59:31,776 up on 8th avenue it's a little 21325 01:59:31,776 --> 01:59:31,776 21326 01:59:31,776 --> 01:59:34,138 bit a little more busy and 21327 01:59:34,138 --> 01:59:34,138 denser. 21328 01:59:34,138 --> 01:59:34,138 makessense. 21329 01:59:34,138 --> 01:59:38,514 if you want to build 30 units a 21330 01:59:38,514 --> 01:59:38,514 n 21331 01:59:38,514 --> 01:59:38,514 acre. 21332 01:59:38,514 --> 01:59:41,482 that makes sense to me, put 21333 01:59:41,482 --> 01:59:43,192 people close to what's going t 21334 01:59:43,192 --> 01:59:43,192 o 21335 01:59:43,192 --> 01:59:44,183 be a great park, you know. 21336 01:59:44,183 --> 01:59:46,466 anyways, that's just -- that 21337 01:59:46,466 --> 01:59:47,920 stuck o out to me. 21338 01:59:47,920 --> 01:59:53,582 thank you, mr. Chan. 21339 01:59:53,582 --> 01:59:55,526 >> mayor: any public comment? 21340 01:59:55,526 --> 01:59:57,864 >> yes, ms. Sharon bower. 21341 01:59:57,864 --> 02:00:00,096 >> mayor: welcome, ms. Bower. 21342 02:00:00,096 --> 02:00:02,332 >> I know I'm wasting my breat 21343 02:00:02,332 --> 02:00:02,332 h, 21344 02:00:02,332 --> 02:00:06,738 but I do want to point out tha 21345 02:00:06,738 --> 02:00:06,738 t 21346 02:00:06,738 --> 02:00:08,471 irrespective of how you have 21347 02:00:08,471 --> 02:00:10,682 changed the land use, there is 21348 02:00:10,682 --> 02:00:10,682 21349 02:00:10,682 --> 02:00:13,978 this parcel where john phlegmi 21350 02:00:13,978 --> 02:00:13,978 ng 21351 02:00:13,978 --> 02:00:17,593 has put together 7 acres 21352 02:00:17,593 --> 02:00:19,316 fronting a highway to put a 21353 02:00:19,316 --> 02:00:19,844 development there. 21354 02:00:19,844 --> 02:00:22,526 other than the sunny food m 21355 02:00:22,526 --> 02:00:25,478 the east end eatery, and the 21356 02:00:25,478 --> 02:00:27,740 union hall [indistinct] on the 21357 02:00:27,740 --> 02:00:27,740 21358 02:00:27,740 --> 02:00:30,600 highway, there is no commercia 21359 02:00:30,600 --> 02:00:30,600 l 21360 02:00:30,600 --> 02:00:32,624 from here all the way to main 21361 02:00:32,624 --> 02:00:32,624 street. 21362 02:00:32,624 --> 02:00:32,624 none. 21363 02:00:32,624 --> 02:00:36,834 so, the use is residential. 21364 02:00:36,834 --> 02:00:40,936 it's all single family and 21365 02:00:40,936 --> 02:00:44,479 duplexes, except for -- santos. 21366 02:00:44,479 --> 02:00:44,479 21367 02:00:44,479 --> 02:00:46,210 he had a duplex and built a 21368 02:00:46,210 --> 02:00:46,974 single family. 21369 02:00:46,974 --> 02:00:48,620 that's the highest-density 21370 02:00:48,620 --> 02:00:50,014 thing, other than the housing 21371 02:00:50,014 --> 02:00:51,676 authority down by main street. 21372 02:00:51,676 --> 02:00:51,676 21373 02:00:51,676 --> 02:00:55,486 you're destroying neighborhoods 21374 02:00:55,486 --> 02:00:55,486 . 21375 02:00:55,486 --> 02:00:56,497 these are established 21376 02:00:56,497 --> 02:00:56,497 neighborhoods. 21377 02:00:56,497 --> 02:00:59,234 these are duck pond area. 21378 02:00:59,234 --> 02:01:03,994 the appraiser's office calls o 21379 02:01:03,994 --> 02:01:03,994 ur 21380 02:01:03,994 --> 02:01:05,264 neighborhood duck pond area or 21381 02:01:05,264 --> 02:01:05,264 21382 02:01:05,264 --> 02:01:06,678 east of duck pond. 21383 02:01:06,678 --> 02:01:11,405 so, I just don't understand why 21384 02:01:11,405 --> 02:01:11,405 21385 02:01:11,405 --> 02:01:13,006 iowa would allow -- you would 21386 02:01:13,006 --> 02:01:13,986 allow t 21387 02:01:13,986 --> 02:01:17,078 why you would allow these poor 21388 02:01:17,078 --> 02:01:17,078 21389 02:01:17,078 --> 02:01:18,576 people who dreamed of buying a 21390 02:01:18,576 --> 02:01:18,576 21391 02:01:18,576 --> 02:01:20,210 home and bought the homes from 21392 02:01:20,210 --> 02:01:20,210 21393 02:01:20,210 --> 02:01:22,082 the national -- I mean, from t 21394 02:01:22,082 --> 02:01:22,082 he 21395 02:01:22,082 --> 02:01:23,282 neighborhood housing development 21396 02:01:23,282 --> 02:01:23,282 21397 02:01:23,282 --> 02:01:23,282 corporation. 21398 02:01:23,282 --> 02:01:25,579 these five beautiful homes 21399 02:01:25,579 --> 02:01:28,928 there, and single family all 21400 02:01:28,928 --> 02:01:30,368 there, and I don't know, a 21401 02:01:30,368 --> 02:01:30,766 funeral home. 21402 02:01:30,766 --> 02:01:38,830 the table s says you four no, u 21403 02:01:38,830 --> 02:01:38,830 6 21404 02:01:38,830 --> 02:01:41,332 yes for a funeral home or 21405 02:01:41,332 --> 02:01:41,332 crematorium. 21406 02:01:41,332 --> 02:01:43,834 you don't care about these 21407 02:01:43,834 --> 02:01:44,994 single-family homes. 21408 02:01:44,994 --> 02:01:46,308 they're going to have this 21409 02:01:46,308 --> 02:01:47,373 40 feet away from them. 21410 02:01:47,373 --> 02:01:48,044 it baffles me. 21411 02:01:48,044 --> 02:01:55,016 >> mayor: thank you, 21412 02:01:55,016 --> 02:01:56,827 ms. Bower. 21413 02:01:56,827 --> 02:01:58,176 commissioner eastman. 21414 02:01:58,176 --> 02:02:09,330 >> whenever these things come 21415 02:02:09,330 --> 02:02:10,428 up, people look at the most 21416 02:02:10,428 --> 02:02:12,230 intensive uses one step above. 21417 02:02:12,230 --> 02:02:12,230 21418 02:02:12,230 --> 02:02:13,530 I think about that as we're 21419 02:02:13,530 --> 02:02:15,578 trying to potentially increase 21420 02:02:15,578 --> 02:02:15,578 21421 02:02:15,578 --> 02:02:15,578 uses. 21422 02:02:15,578 --> 02:02:20,776 this allows an alcoholic 21423 02:02:20,776 --> 02:02:22,687 beverage establishment. 21424 02:02:22,687 --> 02:02:24,473 the highest use. 21425 02:02:24,473 --> 02:02:27,347 we have u4 4 across the street 21426 02:02:27,347 --> 02:02:27,347 21427 02:02:27,347 --> 02:02:28,076 from my house. 21428 02:02:28,076 --> 02:02:29,944 I have u6 in the neighborhoods 21429 02:02:29,944 --> 02:02:29,944 21430 02:02:29,944 --> 02:02:31,820 north of mine right behind the 21431 02:02:31,820 --> 02:02:31,820 se 21432 02:02:31,820 --> 02:02:31,820 houses. 21433 02:02:31,820 --> 02:02:36,385 these more-intensive zoning 21434 02:02:36,385 --> 02:02:38,035 districts exist in the very old 21435 02:02:38,035 --> 02:02:38,035 21436 02:02:38,035 --> 02:02:39,498 neighborhoods, and this is one 21437 02:02:39,498 --> 02:02:39,498 21438 02:02:39,498 --> 02:02:39,750 of those. 21439 02:02:39,750 --> 02:02:42,323 like I said, u6 right next doo 21440 02:02:42,323 --> 02:02:42,323 r 21441 02:02:42,323 --> 02:02:44,503 to it, which is why I feel 21442 02:02:44,503 --> 02:02:46,562 fairly comfortable with where w 21443 02:02:46,562 --> 02:02:46,562 e 21444 02:02:46,562 --> 02:02:46,901 are with it. 21445 02:02:46,901 --> 02:02:49,834 it's a -- there's shops 21446 02:02:49,834 --> 02:02:54,565 nearby, and there's no single -- 21447 02:02:54,565 --> 02:02:54,565 21448 02:02:54,565 --> 02:02:57,487 [indistinct] single family ove 21449 02:02:57,487 --> 02:02:57,487 r 21450 02:02:57,487 --> 02:02:58,274 to where this would be. 21451 02:02:58,274 --> 02:02:59,905 so there's a bit of a buffer 21452 02:02:59,905 --> 02:02:59,905 there. 21453 02:02:59,905 --> 02:03:03,083 and so I feel very comfortable 21454 02:03:03,083 --> 02:03:03,083 21455 02:03:03,083 --> 02:03:05,826 making a motion for ordinance 21456 02:03:05,826 --> 02:03:08,803 no. 2025-995. 21457 02:03:08,803 --> 02:03:15,468 >> mayor: madam clerk, please 21458 02:03:15,468 --> 02:03:16,658 call the role. 21459 02:03:16,658 --> 02:03:18,655 >> commissioner eastman. 21460 02:03:18,655 --> 02:03:22,139 commissioner ingle. 21461 02:03:22,139 --> 02:03:24,840 commissioner duncan-walker. 21462 02:03:24,840 --> 02:03:26,128 mayor ward. 21463 02:03:26,128 --> 02:03:27,970 >> mayor: that passes 21464 02:03:27,970 --> 02:03:29,440 unanimously with commissioner 21465 02:03:29,440 --> 02:03:30,440 chestnut abstaining. 21466 02:03:30,440 --> 02:03:31,771 madam clerk. 21467 02:03:31,771 --> 02:03:31,771 21468 02:03:31,771 --> 02:03:39,957 >> mr. Mayor, we're going back 21469 02:03:39,957 --> 02:03:39,957 21470 02:03:39,957 --> 02:03:41,783 to ordinances for second 21471 02:03:41,783 --> 02:03:49,362 reading, ordinance no. 2025-60. 21472 02:03:49,362 --> 02:04:00,962 21473 02:04:00,962 --> 02:04:06,191 providing directions to the cit 21474 02:04:06,191 --> 02:04:06,191 y 21475 02:04:06,191 --> 02:04:08,473 manager, providing severabilit 21476 02:04:08,473 --> 02:04:08,473 y 21477 02:04:08,473 --> 02:04:10,182 clause, providing a repealing 21478 02:04:10,182 --> 02:04:11,086 clause, and providing an 21479 02:04:11,086 --> 02:04:11,882 effective date. 21480 02:04:11,882 --> 02:04:13,846 >> mayor: thank you, madam 21481 02:04:13,846 --> 02:04:13,846 clerk. 21482 02:04:13,846 --> 02:04:17,783 commissioner willits. 21483 02:04:17,783 --> 02:04:21,191 >> no further questions from m 21484 02:04:21,191 --> 02:04:21,191 y 21485 02:04:21,191 --> 02:04:21,191 colleagues. 21486 02:04:21,191 --> 02:04:22,926 I move adoption on second 21487 02:04:22,926 --> 02:04:26,345 reading 2025-760. 21488 02:04:26,345 --> 02:04:27,305 >> aye. 21489 02:04:27,305 --> 02:04:27,774 >> second. 21490 02:04:27,774 --> 02:04:28,643 >> mayor: motion and a second. 21491 02:04:28,643 --> 02:04:28,643 21492 02:04:28,643 --> 02:04:29,668 any public comment? 21493 02:04:29,668 --> 02:04:31,913 >> no public comment. 21494 02:04:31,913 --> 02:04:33,298 >> mayor: no for the lights. 21495 02:04:33,298 --> 02:04:34,773 let's call the role and give 21496 02:04:34,773 --> 02:04:35,942 commissioner walker another shot 21497 02:04:35,942 --> 02:04:35,942 21498 02:04:35,942 --> 02:04:48,363 here. 21499 02:04:48,363 --> 02:04:51,431 >> mayor: that passes 21500 02:04:51,431 --> 02:04:51,431 unanimously. 21501 02:04:51,431 --> 02:04:53,480 madam clerk. 21502 02:04:53,480 --> 02:04:57,433 >> mr. Mayor, we are on to 21503 02:04:57,433 --> 02:05:00,348 ordinance 2025-873, ordinance o 21504 02:05:00,348 --> 02:05:00,348 f 21505 02:05:00,348 --> 02:05:01,503 the city of gainesville, 21506 02:05:01,503 --> 02:05:07,643 florida, annexing approximately 21507 02:05:07,643 --> 02:05:07,643 21508 02:05:07,643 --> 02:05:09,928 26.897 acres, privately-owned 21509 02:05:09,928 --> 02:05:11,377 property generally located sou 21510 02:05:11,377 --> 02:05:11,377 th 21511 02:05:11,377 --> 02:05:14,780 of state road 24, archer road, 21512 02:05:14,780 --> 02:05:14,780 21513 02:05:14,780 --> 02:05:18,852 west of sw 51st drive, north o 21514 02:05:18,852 --> 02:05:18,852 f 21515 02:05:18,852 --> 02:05:22,858 oaks, preserved, phase ii, eas 21516 02:05:22,858 --> 02:05:22,858 t 21517 02:05:22,858 --> 02:05:27,062 of county road sw 24c, as more 21518 02:05:27,062 --> 02:05:27,062 21519 02:05:27,062 --> 02:05:28,693 specifically describing in thi 21520 02:05:28,693 --> 02:05:28,693 s 21521 02:05:28,693 --> 02:05:30,901 ordinance as petitioned for by 21522 02:05:30,901 --> 02:05:30,901 21523 02:05:30,901 --> 02:05:32,967 the property owners pursuant to 21524 02:05:32,967 --> 02:05:32,967 21525 02:05:32,967 --> 02:05:34,992 chapter 171. 21526 02:05:34,992 --> 02:05:36,802 providing for persons engaged I 21527 02:05:36,802 --> 02:05:36,802 n 21528 02:05:36,802 --> 02:05:39,434 any occupation, business, trade 21529 02:05:39,434 --> 02:05:39,434 , 21530 02:05:39,434 --> 02:05:40,771 or profession, providing 21531 02:05:40,771 --> 02:05:42,204 directions to the city clerk, 21532 02:05:42,204 --> 02:05:43,942 providing severability clause, 21533 02:05:43,942 --> 02:05:43,942 21534 02:05:43,942 --> 02:05:45,181 providing a repealing clause, 21535 02:05:45,181 --> 02:05:46,471 and providing an immediate 21536 02:05:46,471 --> 02:05:47,878 effective date. 21537 02:05:47,878 --> 02:05:48,823 >> mayor: thank you, madam 21538 02:05:48,823 --> 02:05:48,823 clerk. 21539 02:05:48,823 --> 02:05:52,480 before we roll into this, I wan 21540 02:05:52,480 --> 02:05:52,480 t 21541 02:05:52,480 --> 02:05:57,313 to apologize for folks who wer 21542 02:05:57,313 --> 02:05:57,313 e 21543 02:05:57,313 --> 02:05:57,773 here for the entire afternoon 21544 02:05:57,773 --> 02:05:58,991 and had to wait for this. 21545 02:05:58,991 --> 02:06:00,391 we obviously have a lot going 21546 02:06:00,391 --> 02:06:01,930 on, and I appreciate your 21547 02:06:01,930 --> 02:06:01,930 patience. 21548 02:06:01,930 --> 02:06:04,662 so thank you. 21549 02:06:04,662 --> 02:06:08,500 >> thank you, good evening, 21550 02:06:08,500 --> 02:06:09,263 mayor, and commissioners. 21551 02:06:09,263 --> 02:06:12,712 the item before you is a request 21552 02:06:12,712 --> 02:06:12,712 21553 02:06:12,712 --> 02:06:15,505 for voluntary annexation 21554 02:06:15,505 --> 02:06:19,585 submitted by dogwood acquisiti 21555 02:06:19,585 --> 02:06:19,585 on 21556 02:06:19,585 --> 02:06:19,585 llc. 21557 02:06:19,585 --> 02:06:19,585 21558 02:06:19,585 --> 02:06:26,693 >> so this annexation request is 21559 02:06:26,693 --> 02:06:26,693 21560 02:06:26,693 --> 02:06:29,389 for a total of eight contiguou 21561 02:06:29,389 --> 02:06:29,389 s 21562 02:06:29,389 --> 02:06:36,494 tax parcels totaling 21563 02:06:36,494 --> 02:06:38,942 26.25 acres, and due sw of 21564 02:06:38,942 --> 02:06:42,535 butler plaza and I-75. 21565 02:06:42,535 --> 02:06:46,565 currently under alachua county, 21566 02:06:46,565 --> 02:06:46,565 21567 02:06:46,565 --> 02:06:48,674 zoned single family residential 21568 02:06:48,674 --> 02:06:48,674 , 21569 02:06:48,674 --> 02:06:51,037 and residential estate re1. 21570 02:06:51,037 --> 02:06:55,219 staff prepared an urban services 21571 02:06:55,219 --> 02:06:55,219 21572 02:06:55,219 --> 02:06:57,315 report as attached to the 21573 02:06:57,315 --> 02:06:59,519 backup, which detail the city 21574 02:06:59,519 --> 02:07:01,791 services provided following 21575 02:07:01,791 --> 02:07:03,456 annexation, so the parcels wou 21576 02:07:03,456 --> 02:07:03,456 ld 21577 02:07:03,456 --> 02:07:05,186 fall under city commission 21578 02:07:05,186 --> 02:07:06,657 district 3, with the closest 21579 02:07:06,657 --> 02:07:09,142 fire station being station 9, 21580 02:07:09,142 --> 02:07:10,225 and would fall under the 21581 02:07:10,225 --> 02:07:12,364 gainesville police department 21582 02:07:12,364 --> 02:07:12,859 zone papa. 21583 02:07:12,859 --> 02:07:15,927 rts route 75 would service the 21584 02:07:15,927 --> 02:07:15,927 se 21585 02:07:15,927 --> 02:07:18,774 parcels and gru would provide 21586 02:07:18,774 --> 02:07:21,301 utility services like electric, 21587 02:07:21,301 --> 02:07:21,301 21588 02:07:21,301 --> 02:07:22,836 wastewater and gas, and 21589 02:07:22,836 --> 02:07:26,646 additionally, public works wou 21590 02:07:26,646 --> 02:07:26,646 ld 21591 02:07:26,646 --> 02:07:28,489 provide solid waste services, a 21592 02:07:28,489 --> 02:07:28,489 s 21593 02:07:28,489 --> 02:07:32,152 well as basic maintenance and 21594 02:07:32,152 --> 02:07:33,988 repair any building streets. 21595 02:07:33,988 --> 02:07:37,061 however, there are no current 21596 02:07:37,061 --> 02:07:38,543 street city streets that would 21597 02:07:38,543 --> 02:07:38,543 21598 02:07:38,543 --> 02:07:40,328 be involved in this annexation 21599 02:07:40,328 --> 02:07:40,328 21600 02:07:40,328 --> 02:07:41,866 upon approval. 21601 02:07:41,866 --> 02:07:43,192 the details of all of the 21602 02:07:43,192 --> 02:07:44,382 services that are available in 21603 02:07:44,382 --> 02:07:44,382 21604 02:07:44,382 --> 02:07:46,900 that urban services report wer 21605 02:07:46,900 --> 02:07:46,900 e 21606 02:07:46,900 --> 02:07:48,330 provided or were created with 21607 02:07:48,330 --> 02:07:50,130 feedback that were provided by 21608 02:07:50,130 --> 02:07:50,130 21609 02:07:50,130 --> 02:07:51,839 each relevant department as we 21610 02:07:51,839 --> 02:07:51,839 ll 21611 02:07:51,839 --> 02:07:53,239 as some additional maps that 21612 02:07:53,239 --> 02:07:55,211 highlight the locations of 21613 02:07:55,211 --> 02:07:56,746 utilities and emergency response 21614 02:07:56,746 --> 02:07:56,746 21615 02:07:56,746 --> 02:07:56,746 facilities. 21616 02:07:56,746 --> 02:08:04,261 according to florida stawlt 21617 02:08:04,261 --> 02:08:07,787 chapter 171 -- statute chapter 21618 02:08:07,787 --> 02:08:07,787 21619 02:08:07,787 --> 02:08:09,690 171, required to meet certain 21620 02:08:09,690 --> 02:08:09,690 criteria. 21621 02:08:09,690 --> 02:08:12,400 so the parcels must be 21622 02:08:12,400 --> 02:08:14,133 contiguous with existing city 21623 02:08:14,133 --> 02:08:14,133 boundaries. 21624 02:08:14,133 --> 02:08:17,200 they must be reasonably compact 21625 02:08:17,200 --> 02:08:17,200 21626 02:08:17,200 --> 02:08:18,761 and close together, and must n 21627 02:08:18,761 --> 02:08:18,761 ot 21628 02:08:18,761 --> 02:08:21,031 create any enclaves or a 21629 02:08:21,031 --> 02:08:22,937 non-city parcel would be bound 21630 02:08:22,937 --> 02:08:22,937 21631 02:08:22,937 --> 02:08:25,534 on all sides by city boundarie 21632 02:08:25,534 --> 02:08:25,534 s. 21633 02:08:25,534 --> 02:08:27,508 illustrated by this map, 21634 02:08:27,508 --> 02:08:31,076 provided by the applicant, the 21635 02:08:31,076 --> 02:08:31,076 se 21636 02:08:31,076 --> 02:08:32,482 criteria are met allowing the 21637 02:08:32,482 --> 02:08:34,475 city to move forward toward 21638 02:08:34,475 --> 02:08:36,448 adopting the ordinance. 21639 02:08:36,448 --> 02:08:37,977 with that, staff does recommend 21640 02:08:37,977 --> 02:08:37,977 21641 02:08:37,977 --> 02:08:41,391 approval of agenda item 21642 02:08:41,391 --> 02:08:41,391 2025-873. 21643 02:08:41,391 --> 02:08:44,685 if you approve today, we would 21644 02:08:44,685 --> 02:08:44,685 21645 02:08:44,685 --> 02:08:46,094 aim to have the second reading 21646 02:08:46,094 --> 02:08:46,094 21647 02:08:46,094 --> 02:08:48,188 before you by april 16th, which 21648 02:08:48,188 --> 02:08:48,188 21649 02:08:48,188 --> 02:08:49,827 would be the effective date of 21650 02:08:49,827 --> 02:08:49,827 21651 02:08:49,827 --> 02:08:50,791 the annexation. 21652 02:08:50,791 --> 02:08:52,629 I am near you have further 21653 02:08:52,629 --> 02:08:52,629 questions. 21654 02:08:52,629 --> 02:08:54,612 the applicant is also here. 21655 02:08:54,612 --> 02:08:55,795 >> mayor: very good. 21656 02:08:55,795 --> 02:08:58,006 would the applicant like to mak 21657 02:08:58,006 --> 02:08:58,006 e 21658 02:08:58,006 --> 02:08:58,483 any presentation? 21659 02:08:58,483 --> 02:08:58,483 21660 02:08:58,483 --> 02:09:02,044 >> hi, good evening, mayor, 21661 02:09:02,044 --> 02:09:02,044 commission. 21662 02:09:02,044 --> 02:09:03,373 I don't have much to add. 21663 02:09:03,373 --> 02:09:05,548 staff did a great job 21664 02:09:05,548 --> 02:09:06,423 illustrating everything. 21665 02:09:06,423 --> 02:09:10,014 I wanted to say thank you for 21666 02:09:10,014 --> 02:09:10,906 your time. 21667 02:09:10,906 --> 02:09:13,508 I'm here with -- to answer any 21668 02:09:13,508 --> 02:09:13,508 21669 02:09:13,508 --> 02:09:14,385 questions you might have. 21670 02:09:14,385 --> 02:09:15,329 >> mayor: thank you so much. 21671 02:09:15,329 --> 02:09:16,261 I appreciate it. 21672 02:09:16,261 --> 02:09:18,495 commissioners, anything? 21673 02:09:18,495 --> 02:09:23,447 commissioner willits? 21674 02:09:23,447 --> 02:09:25,991 >> a question for staff about I 21675 02:09:25,991 --> 02:09:27,265 f -- when we bring in, this is 21676 02:09:27,265 --> 02:09:27,265 21677 02:09:27,265 --> 02:09:30,467 one of the bigger chunks, I 21678 02:09:30,467 --> 02:09:31,475 think, it's one of the bigger 21679 02:09:31,475 --> 02:09:33,385 chunks we've done recently, tha 21680 02:09:33,385 --> 02:09:33,385 t 21681 02:09:33,385 --> 02:09:35,067 does not have an existing road 21682 02:09:35,067 --> 02:09:35,067 21683 02:09:35,067 --> 02:09:36,608 network like through it 21684 02:09:36,608 --> 02:09:38,841 necessarily, I don't think. 21685 02:09:38,841 --> 02:09:41,911 what's the difference between - 21686 02:09:41,911 --> 02:09:41,911 - 21687 02:09:41,911 --> 02:09:43,613 if this was developed in the 21688 02:09:43,613 --> 02:09:45,017 future but still under the 21689 02:09:45,017 --> 02:09:47,169 county, would they -- is there 21690 02:09:47,169 --> 02:09:47,169 21691 02:09:47,169 --> 02:09:48,218 an agreement with the county 21692 02:09:48,218 --> 02:09:50,058 that they would have to design 21693 02:09:50,058 --> 02:09:50,058 21694 02:09:50,058 --> 02:09:54,529 the roads for the existing roa 21695 02:09:54,529 --> 02:09:54,529 d 21696 02:09:54,529 --> 02:09:56,855 network, any connections to the 21697 02:09:56,855 --> 02:09:56,855 21698 02:09:56,855 --> 02:09:58,397 part that's already in the cit 21699 02:09:58,397 --> 02:09:58,397 y 21700 02:09:58,397 --> 02:09:59,291 that's being developed? 21701 02:09:59,291 --> 02:10:02,429 I cannot remember if that oak 21702 02:10:02,429 --> 02:10:04,834 whatever neighborhood has a stu 21703 02:10:04,834 --> 02:10:04,834 b 21704 02:10:04,834 --> 02:10:07,601 anticipating out there, but if 21705 02:10:07,601 --> 02:10:07,601 21706 02:10:07,601 --> 02:10:10,213 it remains in the county do the 21707 02:10:10,213 --> 02:10:10,213 y 21708 02:10:10,213 --> 02:10:11,769 have to connect that stub or 21709 02:10:11,769 --> 02:10:14,047 only by coming into the city a 21710 02:10:14,047 --> 02:10:14,047 nd 21711 02:10:14,047 --> 02:10:16,121 then they would have the connect 21712 02:10:16,121 --> 02:10:16,121 21713 02:10:16,121 --> 02:10:17,747 a stub according to our comp 21714 02:10:17,747 --> 02:10:17,747 plan? 21715 02:10:17,747 --> 02:10:20,391 >> so I don't think I can speak 21716 02:10:20,391 --> 02:10:20,391 21717 02:10:20,391 --> 02:10:22,549 to if there are any county 21718 02:10:22,549 --> 02:10:25,189 requirements that they build o 21719 02:10:25,189 --> 02:10:25,189 ut 21720 02:10:25,189 --> 02:10:27,625 those roads prior to annexation. 21721 02:10:27,625 --> 02:10:27,625 21722 02:10:27,625 --> 02:10:29,005 we -- 21723 02:10:29,005 --> 02:10:29,287 >> no prior. 21724 02:10:29,287 --> 02:10:36,128 if it stays in the county and w 21725 02:10:36,128 --> 02:10:36,128 e 21726 02:10:36,128 --> 02:10:38,871 don't approve annexation, and 21727 02:10:38,871 --> 02:10:39,974 someone wants to build and hav 21728 02:10:39,974 --> 02:10:39,974 e 21729 02:10:39,974 --> 02:10:41,071 a small street networks. 21730 02:10:41,071 --> 02:10:43,277 because it's in the county, is 21731 02:10:43,277 --> 02:10:43,277 21732 02:10:43,277 --> 02:10:44,881 there any agreement with the 21733 02:10:44,881 --> 02:10:46,009 county -- will you please 21734 02:10:46,009 --> 02:10:47,313 connect to, across the border 21735 02:10:47,313 --> 02:10:50,280 line, if wehave a stub on the 21736 02:10:50,280 --> 02:10:52,247 city side, will these connect? 21737 02:10:52,247 --> 02:10:52,247 21738 02:10:52,247 --> 02:10:54,648 have more of -- a comp plan 21739 02:10:54,648 --> 02:10:56,814 envisions a grid with a lot of 21740 02:10:56,814 --> 02:10:56,814 21741 02:10:56,814 --> 02:10:56,814 connectivity? 21742 02:10:56,814 --> 02:10:59,704 >> after annexation they would 21743 02:10:59,704 --> 02:10:59,704 21744 02:10:59,704 --> 02:11:00,971 be required to build out that 21745 02:11:00,971 --> 02:11:03,160 road network to meet the lot 21746 02:11:03,160 --> 02:11:05,416 requirements for development I 21747 02:11:05,416 --> 02:11:05,416 n 21748 02:11:05,416 --> 02:11:07,000 the city of gainesville. 21749 02:11:07,000 --> 02:11:09,738 if you're asking whether count 21750 02:11:09,738 --> 02:11:09,738 y 21751 02:11:09,738 --> 02:11:12,740 parcels are required to connect 21752 02:11:12,740 --> 02:11:12,740 21753 02:11:12,740 --> 02:11:13,259 to city roads. 21754 02:11:13,259 --> 02:11:15,244 that I'm not entirely sure of. 21755 02:11:15,244 --> 02:11:15,244 21756 02:11:15,244 --> 02:11:19,376 >> mr. Singleton. 21757 02:11:19,376 --> 02:11:20,679 >> I do want to answer this. 21758 02:11:20,679 --> 02:11:23,484 so I can fully understand. 21759 02:11:23,484 --> 02:11:28,614 >> chief operating officer, I 21760 02:11:28,614 --> 02:11:30,682 used to be employed by the 21761 02:11:30,682 --> 02:11:31,422 county -- 21762 02:11:31,422 --> 02:11:32,778 >> hold that against you. 21763 02:11:32,778 --> 02:11:34,588 >> review these type of 21764 02:11:34,588 --> 02:11:36,732 applications, networks, county 21765 02:11:36,732 --> 02:11:36,732 21766 02:11:36,732 --> 02:11:38,759 has a very similar land 21767 02:11:38,759 --> 02:11:40,302 development regulations and com 21768 02:11:40,302 --> 02:11:40,302 p 21769 02:11:40,302 --> 02:11:43,399 plan reg regulations similar to 21770 02:11:43,399 --> 02:11:43,566 the 21771 02:11:43,566 --> 02:11:43,566 city. 21772 02:11:43,566 --> 02:11:46,372 they would connect to the 21773 02:11:46,372 --> 02:11:48,373 existing s stubs. 21774 02:11:48,373 --> 02:11:51,541 looking at the plat, I don't s 21775 02:11:51,541 --> 02:11:51,541 ee 21776 02:11:51,541 --> 02:11:53,416 that stub to these parcels, but 21777 02:11:53,416 --> 02:11:53,416 21778 02:11:53,416 --> 02:11:57,250 we do collaboraten and sure we 21779 02:11:57,250 --> 02:11:57,250 21780 02:11:57,250 --> 02:11:58,684 have -- and ensure we have 21781 02:11:58,684 --> 02:11:59,981 interconnected roadway network. 21782 02:11:59,981 --> 02:11:59,981 21783 02:11:59,981 --> 02:12:01,566 >> I bring it up partially as 21784 02:12:01,566 --> 02:12:02,923 part of the conversation on the 21785 02:12:02,923 --> 02:12:02,923 21786 02:12:02,923 --> 02:12:04,458 outside edge of the city when w 21787 02:12:04,458 --> 02:12:04,458 e 21788 02:12:04,458 --> 02:12:06,252 potentially annex, particularl 21789 02:12:06,252 --> 02:12:06,252 y 21790 02:12:06,252 --> 02:12:08,726 right next to a new development 21791 02:12:08,726 --> 02:12:08,726 , 21792 02:12:08,726 --> 02:12:12,031 how they interact, the current, 21793 02:12:12,031 --> 02:12:12,031 21794 02:12:12,031 --> 02:12:13,797 new development, and potential 21795 02:12:13,797 --> 02:12:13,797 ly 21796 02:12:13,797 --> 02:12:15,966 new annexation. 21797 02:12:15,966 --> 02:12:18,810 mr. Singleton, I appreciate 21798 02:12:18,810 --> 02:12:18,810 that. 21799 02:12:18,810 --> 02:12:23,406 I've had some skepticism in the 21800 02:12:23,406 --> 02:12:23,406 21801 02:12:23,406 --> 02:12:26,015 southwest largely because of 21802 02:12:26,015 --> 02:12:27,341 annexations and changing of 21803 02:12:27,341 --> 02:12:28,448 densities because of the amoun 21804 02:12:28,448 --> 02:12:28,448 t 21805 02:12:28,448 --> 02:12:31,058 of park services in southwest. 21806 02:12:31,058 --> 02:12:31,058 21807 02:12:31,058 --> 02:12:33,453 I would say we almost bought, w 21808 02:12:33,453 --> 02:12:33,453 e 21809 02:12:33,453 --> 02:12:34,877 haven't -- I don't know if we 21810 02:12:34,877 --> 02:12:37,189 signed the contract yet, rough 21811 02:12:37,189 --> 02:12:37,189 ly 21812 02:12:37,189 --> 02:12:38,720 14 acres in southwest 21813 02:12:38,720 --> 02:12:40,457 gainesville for future park and 21814 02:12:40,457 --> 02:12:40,457 21815 02:12:40,457 --> 02:12:41,096 reservation land. 21816 02:12:41,096 --> 02:12:42,471 that makes me a little more 21817 02:12:42,471 --> 02:12:43,503 confident in the future we'll b 21818 02:12:43,503 --> 02:12:43,503 e 21819 02:12:43,503 --> 02:12:47,131 able to ride that, but that lan 21820 02:12:47,131 --> 02:12:47,131 d 21821 02:12:47,131 --> 02:12:51,011 is -- of 75, and past 75 there's 21822 02:12:51,011 --> 02:12:51,011 21823 02:12:51,011 --> 02:12:52,431 continued conversation. 21824 02:12:52,431 --> 02:12:53,434 firefighter infrastructure's 21825 02:12:53,434 --> 02:12:55,243 gointo go in, great, but in 21826 02:12:55,243 --> 02:12:56,649 the end the city or the county 21827 02:12:56,649 --> 02:12:56,649 21828 02:12:56,649 --> 02:12:59,279 or us combined we need to build 21829 02:12:59,279 --> 02:12:59,279 21830 02:12:59,279 --> 02:13:02,105 another -- we need to be looki 21831 02:13:02,105 --> 02:13:02,105 ng 21832 02:13:02,105 --> 02:13:05,511 at longer, 10-15-year plan 21833 02:13:05,511 --> 02:13:08,483 larger park, south that is 21834 02:13:08,483 --> 02:13:10,564 serves that chunk -- in the end 21835 02:13:10,564 --> 02:13:10,564 21836 02:13:10,564 --> 02:13:14,158 it's going to serve county and 21837 02:13:14,158 --> 02:13:14,158 21838 02:13:14,158 --> 02:13:14,158 city. 21839 02:13:14,158 --> 02:13:16,363 that's another conversation wit 21840 02:13:16,363 --> 02:13:16,363 h 21841 02:13:16,363 --> 02:13:19,595 the county: so with that, I'v 21842 02:13:19,595 --> 02:13:19,595 e 21843 02:13:19,595 --> 02:13:21,263 been skeptical, but I'm very 21844 02:13:21,263 --> 02:13:21,263 happy. 21845 02:13:21,263 --> 02:13:22,865 I will be supporting this 21846 02:13:22,865 --> 02:13:24,299 voluntary annexation. 21847 02:13:24,299 --> 02:13:25,498 thank you, mr. Mayor. 21848 02:13:25,498 --> 02:13:27,267 >> mayor: thank you, 21849 02:13:27,267 --> 02:13:30,117 mr. Willits. 21850 02:13:30,117 --> 02:13:31,979 >> if there are no further 21851 02:13:31,979 --> 02:13:34,147 questions, I move ordinance 21852 02:13:34,147 --> 02:13:34,147 2025-873. 21853 02:13:34,147 --> 02:13:35,589 >> second. 21854 02:13:35,589 --> 02:13:36,573 >> mayor: we have a motion and 21855 02:13:36,573 --> 02:13:36,573 21856 02:13:36,573 --> 02:13:36,819 a second. 21857 02:13:36,819 --> 02:13:37,961 any public comment? 21858 02:13:37,961 --> 02:13:40,311 >> there's no public comment. 21859 02:13:40,311 --> 02:13:42,120 >> mayor: okay! 21860 02:13:42,120 --> 02:13:45,556 >> I'm here. 21861 02:13:45,556 --> 02:13:47,922 our firm worked on the oaks 21862 02:13:47,922 --> 02:13:49,027 preserve project with the city, 21863 02:13:49,027 --> 02:13:49,027 21864 02:13:49,027 --> 02:13:52,667 and I can tell you there is a 21865 02:13:52,667 --> 02:13:53,559 stub out to this property. 21866 02:13:53,559 --> 02:13:54,929 I had to look at it too. 21867 02:13:54,929 --> 02:13:56,599 it's in a future phase, but, 21868 02:13:56,599 --> 02:13:58,335 yeah, just kind of the very 21869 02:13:58,335 --> 02:14:01,937 bottom corner makes a 90-degree 21870 02:14:01,937 --> 02:14:01,937 21871 02:14:01,937 --> 02:14:01,937 turn. 21872 02:14:01,937 --> 02:14:04,405 if this property's built in the 21873 02:14:04,405 --> 02:14:04,405 21874 02:14:04,405 --> 02:14:06,144 city, lit connect to that 21875 02:14:06,144 --> 02:14:06,144 neighborhood. 21876 02:14:06,144 --> 02:14:07,281 >> mayor: thank you. 21877 02:14:07,281 --> 02:14:10,293 I remembered that discussion. 21878 02:14:10,293 --> 02:14:11,243 that was the whole point of 21879 02:14:11,243 --> 02:14:16,203 discussion about that issue was 21880 02:14:16,203 --> 02:14:16,203 21881 02:14:16,203 --> 02:14:16,975 whether or not people came to 21882 02:14:16,975 --> 02:14:19,145 talk to us about whether or not 21883 02:14:19,145 --> 02:14:19,145 21884 02:14:19,145 --> 02:14:19,999 there was going to be 21885 02:14:19,999 --> 02:14:21,001 [indistinct] there. 21886 02:14:21,001 --> 02:14:21,954 I remember that. 21887 02:14:21,954 --> 02:14:22,525 all right! 21888 02:14:22,525 --> 02:14:24,591 madam clerk, let's call the 21889 02:14:24,591 --> 02:14:24,591 roll. 21890 02:14:24,591 --> 02:14:24,591 21891 02:14:24,591 --> 02:14:28,785 [roll call] 21892 02:14:28,785 --> 02:14:28,785 21893 02:14:28,785 --> 02:14:37,472 >> mayor: all right, that 21894 02:14:37,472 --> 02:14:39,475 passes unanimously. 21895 02:14:39,475 --> 02:14:39,475 yes. 21896 02:14:39,475 --> 02:14:41,503 madam clerk. 21897 02:14:41,503 --> 02:14:49,521 commissioner willits. 21898 02:14:49,521 --> 02:14:51,626 >> I'm not going to go into the 21899 02:14:51,626 --> 02:14:51,626 21900 02:14:51,626 --> 02:14:52,928 full because it's been a long 21901 02:14:52,928 --> 02:14:52,928 day. 21902 02:14:52,928 --> 02:14:56,291 I wanted to poke at the 21903 02:14:56,291 --> 02:14:58,727 on-street neighborhood parking 21904 02:14:58,727 --> 02:14:58,727 21905 02:14:58,727 --> 02:15:00,024 permit and some of the zonings 21906 02:15:00,024 --> 02:15:00,024 21907 02:15:00,024 --> 02:15:00,659 around campus. 21908 02:15:00,659 --> 02:15:04,633 we currently charge people hav 21909 02:15:04,633 --> 02:15:04,633 e 21910 02:15:04,633 --> 02:15:06,836 the privilege of owning a home 21911 02:15:06,836 --> 02:15:06,836 21912 02:15:06,836 --> 02:15:08,131 far less than we do for people 21913 02:15:08,131 --> 02:15:08,131 21914 02:15:08,131 --> 02:15:10,437 paying rent. 21915 02:15:10,437 --> 02:15:14,811 it looks like we charge $119.25 21916 02:15:14,811 --> 02:15:14,811 21917 02:15:14,811 --> 02:15:16,307 to homesteaders, people who hav 21918 02:15:16,307 --> 02:15:16,307 e 21919 02:15:16,307 --> 02:15:18,041 a homesteaded property, verses 21920 02:15:18,041 --> 02:15:18,041 21921 02:15:18,041 --> 02:15:20,849 looks like $238 for 21922 02:15:20,849 --> 02:15:20,849 non-homestead. 21923 02:15:20,849 --> 02:15:23,306 I know there's not a lot of 21924 02:15:23,306 --> 02:15:25,145 properties that necessarily 21925 02:15:25,145 --> 02:15:25,621 applies to. 21926 02:15:25,621 --> 02:15:27,360 some of the larger complexes y 21927 02:15:27,360 --> 02:15:27,360 ou 21928 02:15:27,360 --> 02:15:29,025 may think of around campus are 21929 02:15:29,025 --> 02:15:29,025 21930 02:15:29,025 --> 02:15:32,623 not eligible for 21931 02:15:32,623 --> 02:15:34,487 neighborhood-zoned parking 21932 02:15:34,487 --> 02:15:36,900 because those were developed a 21933 02:15:36,900 --> 02:15:36,900 s 21934 02:15:36,900 --> 02:15:39,901 a denser parking on site and/o 21935 02:15:39,901 --> 02:15:39,901 r 21936 02:15:39,901 --> 02:15:42,036 it is envisioned not every 21937 02:15:42,036 --> 02:15:43,763 person brings their car for some 21938 02:15:43,763 --> 02:15:43,763 21939 02:15:43,763 --> 02:15:45,203 of the on-street parking on 21940 02:15:45,203 --> 02:15:47,646 campus there's always going to 21941 02:15:47,646 --> 02:15:47,646 21942 02:15:47,646 --> 02:15:47,857 be tension. 21943 02:15:47,857 --> 02:15:49,608 the fact we charge renters mor 21944 02:15:49,608 --> 02:15:49,608 e 21945 02:15:49,608 --> 02:15:51,118 than people who own their home. 21946 02:15:51,118 --> 02:15:51,118 21947 02:15:51,118 --> 02:15:53,667 I'm sure there's going to be a 21948 02:15:53,667 --> 02:15:53,667 21949 02:15:53,667 --> 02:15:55,550 lot of arguments why that is t 21950 02:15:55,550 --> 02:15:55,550 o 21951 02:15:55,550 --> 02:15:57,554 protect homeowners, giving the 21952 02:15:57,554 --> 02:15:57,554 m 21953 02:15:57,554 --> 02:15:59,184 a space, but a person who rents 21954 02:15:59,184 --> 02:15:59,184 21955 02:15:59,184 --> 02:16:02,212 that close to there may also -- 21956 02:16:02,212 --> 02:16:02,212 21957 02:16:02,212 --> 02:16:04,027 I feel like they should probably 21958 02:16:04,027 --> 02:16:04,027 21959 02:16:04,027 --> 02:16:06,089 be more similar, that they 21960 02:16:06,089 --> 02:16:09,331 should pay the same amount to 21961 02:16:09,331 --> 02:16:10,764 park on the street whether the 21962 02:16:10,764 --> 02:16:10,764 y 21963 02:16:10,764 --> 02:16:14,401 own the home there or whether 21964 02:16:14,401 --> 02:16:15,082 they are renting. 21965 02:16:15,082 --> 02:16:16,409 so that's something I'm going t 21966 02:16:16,409 --> 02:16:16,409 o 21967 02:16:16,409 --> 02:16:18,803 bring in forward in the future 21968 02:16:18,803 --> 02:16:19,012 as 21969 02:16:19,012 --> 02:16:20,214 fairness to the renters in our 21970 02:16:20,214 --> 02:16:20,214 21971 02:16:20,214 --> 02:16:20,214 community. 21972 02:16:20,214 --> 02:16:22,340 it's only in a couple 21973 02:16:22,340 --> 02:16:23,376 neighborhoods that it applies. 21974 02:16:23,376 --> 02:16:23,376 21975 02:16:23,376 --> 02:16:25,091 I'm going to be asking staff I 21976 02:16:25,091 --> 02:16:25,091 f 21977 02:16:25,091 --> 02:16:27,327 I can get a -- peer into the 21978 02:16:27,327 --> 02:16:29,379 data on the number of people w 21979 02:16:29,379 --> 02:16:29,379 ho 21980 02:16:29,379 --> 02:16:31,348 have those permits, but at lea 21981 02:16:31,348 --> 02:16:31,348 st 21982 02:16:31,348 --> 02:16:32,614 digging to understand the cost 21983 02:16:32,614 --> 02:16:32,614 21984 02:16:32,614 --> 02:16:33,458 of the permits. 21985 02:16:33,458 --> 02:16:38,690 that's something I'll bring up 21986 02:16:38,690 --> 02:16:38,690 21987 02:16:38,690 --> 02:16:38,690 later. 21988 02:16:38,690 --> 02:16:39,900 >> mayor: thank you. 21989 02:16:39,900 --> 02:16:42,064 commissioner ingle. 21990 02:16:42,064 --> 02:16:47,392 >> so there's a zoning issue I 21991 02:16:47,392 --> 02:16:47,392 21992 02:16:47,392 --> 02:16:51,142 wanted to bring up, actually 21993 02:16:51,142 --> 02:16:51,142 21994 02:16:51,142 --> 02:16:53,974 some drive-through businesses 21995 02:16:53,974 --> 02:16:56,950 have caused some real traffic 21996 02:16:56,950 --> 02:16:57,842 snarls in town. 21997 02:16:57,842 --> 02:17:00,411 starbucks on 13th street, reall 21998 02:17:00,411 --> 02:17:00,411 y 21999 02:17:00,411 --> 02:17:02,550 kind of backs some stuff up, a 22000 02:17:02,550 --> 02:17:02,550 nd 22001 02:17:02,550 --> 02:17:04,590 I know it's the new coffee sho 22002 02:17:04,590 --> 02:17:04,590 p 22003 02:17:04,590 --> 02:17:09,620 down on 16th, I forget the nam 22004 02:17:09,620 --> 02:17:09,620 e 22005 02:17:09,620 --> 02:17:13,302 of it, 7 brew, also caused a l 22006 02:17:13,302 --> 02:17:13,302 ot 22007 02:17:13,302 --> 02:17:14,324 of snarls around there and 22008 02:17:14,324 --> 02:17:16,000 people trying to get in a 22009 02:17:16,000 --> 02:17:17,662 drive-through line, backing all 22010 02:17:17,662 --> 02:17:17,662 22011 02:17:17,662 --> 02:17:19,162 the way out into traffic. 22012 02:17:19,162 --> 02:17:21,686 I would really like to see wha 22013 02:17:21,686 --> 02:17:21,686 t 22014 02:17:21,686 --> 02:17:23,540 options we've got on tweaking 22015 02:17:23,540 --> 02:17:29,776 our zoning to either prohibit 22016 02:17:29,776 --> 02:17:31,844 drive-through things on major 22017 02:17:31,844 --> 02:17:33,580 thoroughfares like that or wha 22018 02:17:33,580 --> 02:17:33,580 t 22019 02:17:33,580 --> 02:17:35,779 options we've got to kind of 22020 02:17:35,779 --> 02:17:37,088 regulate some of that to make 22021 02:17:37,088 --> 02:17:39,323 those more compatible to those 22022 02:17:39,323 --> 02:17:39,323 22023 02:17:39,323 --> 02:17:39,323 areas. 22024 02:17:39,323 --> 02:17:43,885 just plopping them down I've 22025 02:17:43,885 --> 02:17:45,492 seen them cause real traffic 22026 02:17:45,492 --> 02:17:47,422 problems with just a line of 22027 02:17:47,422 --> 02:17:48,752 people out in the street waiti 22028 02:17:48,752 --> 02:17:48,752 ng 22029 02:17:48,752 --> 02:17:49,902 to get into a business. 22030 02:17:49,902 --> 02:17:51,664 and I think there's got to be 22031 02:17:51,664 --> 02:17:53,416 some way we can avoid doing tha 22032 02:17:53,416 --> 02:17:53,416 t 22033 02:17:53,416 --> 02:17:55,076 in the future. 22034 02:17:55,076 --> 02:17:56,772 so talked a little bit to the 22035 02:17:56,772 --> 02:17:58,306 city manager, but I'd really 22036 02:17:58,306 --> 02:17:59,608 like to have some options 22037 02:17:59,608 --> 02:18:02,172 brought back on what it is we 22038 02:18:02,172 --> 02:18:04,044 can do in those areas. 22039 02:18:04,044 --> 02:18:06,766 >> it looks like the director I 22040 02:18:06,766 --> 02:18:06,766 s 22041 02:18:06,766 --> 02:18:08,642 chomping at the bit to come talk 22042 02:18:08,642 --> 02:18:08,642 22043 02:18:08,642 --> 02:18:08,952 about this. 22044 02:18:08,952 --> 02:18:08,952 [laughter] 22045 02:18:08,952 --> 02:18:10,912 >> thank you, mr. Mayor, 22046 02:18:10,912 --> 02:18:12,396 commissioners, halfway there. 22047 02:18:12,396 --> 02:18:14,622 I realized I had a little bit o 22048 02:18:14,622 --> 02:18:14,622 f 22049 02:18:14,622 --> 02:18:15,828 regret that maybe I should 22050 02:18:15,828 --> 02:18:19,092 probably not start walking, but 22051 02:18:19,092 --> 02:18:19,092 22052 02:18:19,092 --> 02:18:21,720 anyhow, certainly any time it's 22053 02:18:21,720 --> 02:18:21,720 22054 02:18:21,720 --> 02:18:23,934 a use in the way that a use is 22055 02:18:23,934 --> 02:18:23,934 22056 02:18:23,934 --> 02:18:24,938 really playing out is something 22057 02:18:24,938 --> 02:18:24,938 22058 02:18:24,938 --> 02:18:27,206 that we can look at through 22059 02:18:27,206 --> 02:18:27,800 zoning code. 22060 02:18:27,800 --> 02:18:29,610 what we had done to date for 22061 02:18:29,610 --> 02:18:30,670 those uses. 22062 02:18:30,670 --> 02:18:32,815 the starbucks on 13th has 22063 02:18:32,815 --> 02:18:37,280 been -- has had issues for qui 22064 02:18:37,280 --> 02:18:37,280 te 22065 02:18:37,280 --> 02:18:37,848 some time. 22066 02:18:37,848 --> 02:18:39,780 the 7 brew you're speaking of, 22067 02:18:39,780 --> 02:18:39,780 22068 02:18:39,780 --> 02:18:41,116 but we've had them in a couple 22069 02:18:41,116 --> 02:18:41,116 22070 02:18:41,116 --> 02:18:43,086 other locations that are drive 22071 02:18:43,086 --> 02:18:43,086 22072 02:18:43,086 --> 02:18:43,086 throughs. 22073 02:18:43,086 --> 02:18:51,194 the zaxby's, popeyes when they 22074 02:18:51,194 --> 02:18:51,194 22075 02:18:51,194 --> 02:18:52,392 had their fried chicken 22076 02:18:52,392 --> 02:18:54,660 sandwich, that was an issue, a 22077 02:18:54,660 --> 02:18:54,660 s 22078 02:18:54,660 --> 02:18:55,862 you might understand, but what 22079 02:18:55,862 --> 02:18:55,862 22080 02:18:55,862 --> 02:18:57,192 we've done for the code 22081 02:18:57,192 --> 02:18:59,402 enforcement side of sit gone o 22082 02:18:59,402 --> 02:18:59,402 ut 22083 02:18:59,402 --> 02:19:00,566 and worked directly with the 22084 02:19:00,566 --> 02:19:01,964 businesses to adjust their 22085 02:19:01,964 --> 02:19:03,206 business model to make sure the 22086 02:19:03,206 --> 02:19:03,206 y 22087 02:19:03,206 --> 02:19:06,802 can or if they could actually 22088 02:19:06,802 --> 02:19:07,902 fit these uses on their 22089 02:19:07,902 --> 02:19:09,410 property, which is required by 22090 02:19:09,410 --> 02:19:09,410 22091 02:19:09,410 --> 02:19:09,410 code. 22092 02:19:09,410 --> 02:19:10,750 we've worked with them to be 22093 02:19:10,750 --> 02:19:11,238 able to do that. 22094 02:19:11,238 --> 02:19:13,046 some of you may have seen at t 22095 02:19:13,046 --> 02:19:13,046 he 22096 02:19:13,046 --> 02:19:14,822 starbucks or the chick-fil-a 22097 02:19:14,822 --> 02:19:16,286 where some of the staff started 22098 02:19:16,286 --> 02:19:16,286 22099 02:19:16,286 --> 02:19:17,988 getting tablets and walk to you 22100 02:19:17,988 --> 02:19:17,988 r 22101 02:19:17,988 --> 02:19:18,650 car and order. 22102 02:19:18,650 --> 02:19:22,024 and they direct you through tha 22103 02:19:22,024 --> 02:19:22,024 t 22104 02:19:22,024 --> 02:19:22,024 area. 22105 02:19:22,024 --> 02:19:24,258 that allowed them to both have 22106 02:19:24,258 --> 02:19:24,258 22107 02:19:24,258 --> 02:19:26,538 more users on site, but process 22108 02:19:26,538 --> 02:19:26,538 22109 02:19:26,538 --> 02:19:28,006 them quickly and really we 22110 02:19:28,006 --> 02:19:29,400 helped them with their own 22111 02:19:29,400 --> 02:19:29,400 businessodel. 22112 02:19:29,400 --> 02:19:32,104 now, of course if that -- in 22113 02:19:32,104 --> 02:19:34,438 some cases, continues to spill 22114 02:19:34,438 --> 02:19:34,438 22115 02:19:34,438 --> 02:19:37,359 out in the roadway, then we've 22116 02:19:37,359 --> 02:19:37,359 22117 02:19:37,359 --> 02:19:38,971 started to go down the code 22118 02:19:38,971 --> 02:19:40,406 enforcement path. 22119 02:19:40,406 --> 02:19:42,482 gpd is engaged in some of these 22120 02:19:42,482 --> 02:19:42,482 22121 02:19:42,482 --> 02:19:42,482 businesses. 22122 02:19:42,482 --> 02:19:45,113 I cannot speak in detail for 22123 02:19:45,113 --> 02:19:48,818 what gpd has doan done, but 22124 02:19:48,818 --> 02:19:49,533 they've been involved in the 22125 02:19:49,533 --> 02:19:50,192 conversation and working with 22126 02:19:50,192 --> 02:19:51,256 the businesses. 22127 02:19:51,256 --> 02:19:52,984 in several cases we've seen vas 22128 02:19:52,984 --> 02:19:52,984 t 22129 02:19:52,984 --> 02:19:54,290 improvements just by working 22130 02:19:54,290 --> 02:19:55,922 with the practices 22131 02:19:55,922 --> 02:19:55,922 22132 02:19:55,922 --> 02:19:58,407 >> I appreciate that, and I 22133 02:19:58,407 --> 02:20:00,630 think it's a good way to addre 22134 02:20:00,630 --> 02:20:00,630 ss 22135 02:20:00,630 --> 02:20:02,204 the issue in places that alrea 22136 02:20:02,204 --> 02:20:02,204 dy 22137 02:20:02,204 --> 02:20:03,696 exist, but I don't want to 22138 02:20:03,696 --> 02:20:08,197 continue making more work for 22139 02:20:08,197 --> 02:20:10,144 code enforcement and gpd, 22140 02:20:10,144 --> 02:20:12,004 clearly we're setting ourselves 22141 02:20:12,004 --> 02:20:12,004 22142 02:20:12,004 --> 02:20:14,105 up for a problem and trying to 22143 02:20:14,105 --> 02:20:14,105 22144 02:20:14,105 --> 02:20:16,072 fix it instead of seeing if we 22145 02:20:16,072 --> 02:20:16,072 22146 02:20:16,072 --> 02:20:18,137 can't find ways to eliminate t 22147 02:20:18,137 --> 02:20:18,137 he 22148 02:20:18,137 --> 02:20:18,137 problems. 22149 02:20:18,137 --> 02:20:20,248 it's frustrated me. 22150 02:20:20,248 --> 02:20:21,985 I talked to a lot of people who 22151 02:20:21,985 --> 02:20:21,985 22152 02:20:21,985 --> 02:20:23,147 get frustrated with it, 22153 02:20:23,147 --> 02:20:25,484 especially on major 22154 02:20:25,484 --> 02:20:25,484 thoroughfares. 22155 02:20:25,484 --> 02:20:33,663 when we look at major 22156 02:20:33,663 --> 02:20:35,007 thoroughfares through places, 22157 02:20:35,007 --> 02:20:36,398 I'm very concerned about 22158 02:20:36,398 --> 02:20:37,732 continuing to set up the type o 22159 02:20:37,732 --> 02:20:37,732 f 22160 02:20:37,732 --> 02:20:40,566 businesses that are going to 22161 02:20:40,566 --> 02:20:42,202 limit themselves to have code 22162 02:20:42,202 --> 02:20:43,731 enforcement involved or have 22163 02:20:43,731 --> 02:20:45,401 work around to make them 22164 02:20:45,401 --> 02:20:46,716 function well as neighbors. 22165 02:20:46,716 --> 02:20:53,158 >> add to what -- was saying o 22166 02:20:53,158 --> 02:20:53,158 ur 22167 02:20:53,158 --> 02:20:53,664 code requirements. 22168 02:20:53,664 --> 02:20:55,134 during the process as we're 22169 02:20:55,134 --> 02:20:56,844 seeing the newer drive through 22170 02:20:56,844 --> 02:20:56,844 s 22171 02:20:56,844 --> 02:21:00,788 come in, we request a queuing 22172 02:21:00,788 --> 02:21:02,021 analysis from the applicant. 22173 02:21:02,021 --> 02:21:03,226 we do look at that. 22174 02:21:03,226 --> 02:21:04,967 I would say the 7 brew was a 22175 02:21:04,967 --> 02:21:06,632 surprise to all of us. 22176 02:21:06,632 --> 02:21:08,696 we didn't expect that to queue 22177 02:21:08,696 --> 02:21:08,696 22178 02:21:08,696 --> 02:21:10,187 up and backup that far. 22179 02:21:10,187 --> 02:21:12,631 I'm not aware of that trying t 22180 02:21:12,631 --> 02:21:12,631 o 22181 02:21:12,631 --> 02:21:14,605 do that, but I'm not down in 22182 02:21:14,605 --> 02:21:18,331 that area regularly, so -- so 22183 02:21:18,331 --> 02:21:20,512 codes has been monitoring it. 22184 02:21:20,512 --> 02:21:24,671 but the drive throughs that hav 22185 02:21:24,671 --> 02:21:24,671 e 22186 02:21:24,671 --> 02:21:26,847 gone in recently, we've not bee 22187 02:21:26,847 --> 02:21:26,847 n 22188 02:21:26,847 --> 02:21:29,249 seeing on that anymore, like 22189 02:21:29,249 --> 02:21:31,056 what the exception of 7 brew 22190 02:21:31,056 --> 02:21:32,854 first opened, but we are 22191 02:21:32,854 --> 02:21:34,454 actively working with developers 22192 02:21:34,454 --> 02:21:34,454 22193 02:21:34,454 --> 02:21:36,293 and doing a queuing analysis a 22194 02:21:36,293 --> 02:21:36,293 s 22195 02:21:36,293 --> 02:21:39,029 the drive throughs come through, 22196 02:21:39,029 --> 02:21:39,029 22197 02:21:39,029 --> 02:21:40,030 as required by code. 22198 02:21:40,030 --> 02:21:46,551 >> mayor: anything else? 22199 02:21:46,551 --> 02:21:48,867 very good. 22200 02:21:48,867 --> 02:21:51,753 mr. Manager, was that toward 22201 02:21:51,753 --> 02:21:51,753 this? 22202 02:21:51,753 --> 02:21:55,108 >> it was towards this? 22203 02:21:55,108 --> 02:21:56,917 >> we would want a motion and 22204 02:21:56,917 --> 02:21:58,277 add it to the list and send you 22205 02:21:58,277 --> 02:21:58,277 22206 02:21:58,277 --> 02:22:03,245 a new list of code pieces. 22207 02:22:03,245 --> 02:22:04,987 >> I'd like to make a motion w 22208 02:22:04,987 --> 02:22:04,987 e 22209 02:22:04,987 --> 02:22:05,950 add to that the list. 22210 02:22:05,950 --> 02:22:06,532 >> second. 22211 02:22:06,532 --> 02:22:08,323 >> adding it to the list. 22212 02:22:08,323 --> 02:22:09,479 >> mayor: all right. 22213 02:22:09,479 --> 02:22:11,094 is there any public comment on 22214 02:22:11,094 --> 02:22:11,094 22215 02:22:11,094 --> 02:22:11,094 that? 22216 02:22:11,094 --> 02:22:11,094 22217 02:22:11,094 --> 02:22:15,739 >> mr. Mayor, is there like a - 22218 02:22:15,739 --> 02:22:15,739 - 22219 02:22:15,739 --> 02:22:15,739 [indistinct] 22220 02:22:15,739 --> 02:22:15,739 [laughter] 22221 02:22:15,739 --> 02:22:15,739 [laughter] 22222 02:22:15,739 --> 02:22:20,500 emotion added to the list? 22223 02:22:20,500 --> 02:22:23,205 >> mayor: definitely. 22224 02:22:23,205 --> 02:22:24,434 >> I'll get with the city 22225 02:22:24,434 --> 02:22:25,407 manager and find out the 22226 02:22:25,407 --> 02:22:27,973 specific terms. 22227 02:22:27,973 --> 02:22:29,406 >> mayor: very good. 22228 02:22:29,406 --> 02:22:32,207 all in favor please say aye. 22229 02:22:32,207 --> 02:22:33,225 any opposed. 22230 02:22:33,225 --> 02:22:34,645 that passes unanimously. 22231 02:22:34,645 --> 02:22:35,559 mr. Manager. 22232 02:22:35,559 --> 02:22:37,771 >> thank you, mr. Mayor. 22233 02:22:37,771 --> 02:22:39,125 this is unrelated to drive 22234 02:22:39,125 --> 02:22:40,987 throughs or zoning for that 22235 02:22:40,987 --> 02:22:40,987 matter. 22236 02:22:40,987 --> 02:22:42,957 I did want to give you all an 22237 02:22:42,957 --> 02:22:42,957 update. 22238 02:22:42,957 --> 02:22:46,041 we had an individual come at 22239 02:22:46,041 --> 02:22:47,557 public comment and talk a litt 22240 02:22:47,557 --> 02:22:47,557 le 22241 02:22:47,557 --> 02:22:53,536 bit about the st. Francis 22242 02:22:53,536 --> 02:22:53,536 closure. 22243 02:22:53,536 --> 02:22:55,893 I did get an update this 22244 02:22:55,893 --> 02:22:57,838 afternoon from mr. Mann who's 22245 02:22:57,838 --> 02:23:02,141 the city's liaison and coc. 22246 02:23:02,141 --> 02:23:05,587 to date, th there three remaining 22247 02:23:05,587 --> 02:23:05,587 22248 02:23:05,587 --> 02:23:06,915 families in sherlt at 22249 02:23:06,915 --> 02:23:09,279 st. Francis that we have not 22250 02:23:09,279 --> 02:23:09,279 connected. 22251 02:23:09,279 --> 02:23:14,463 we, being the city, the cnd the 22252 02:23:14,463 --> 02:23:14,777 coc, connected with 22253 02:23:14,777 --> 02:23:14,777 housing. 22254 02:23:14,777 --> 02:23:19,228 believe will be connected with 22255 02:23:19,228 --> 02:23:19,228 22256 02:23:19,228 --> 02:23:20,921 housing as early as tomorrow, 22257 02:23:20,921 --> 02:23:22,431 leaving two remaining families 22258 02:23:22,431 --> 02:23:22,431 22259 02:23:22,431 --> 02:23:23,627 and one individual. 22260 02:23:23,627 --> 02:23:25,735 those are the only remaining 22261 02:23:25,735 --> 02:23:27,902 folks that were in shelter tha 22262 02:23:27,902 --> 02:23:27,902 t 22263 02:23:27,902 --> 02:23:31,743 have not been able to find new 22264 02:23:31,743 --> 02:23:31,743 22265 02:23:31,743 --> 02:23:31,743 housing. 22266 02:23:31,743 --> 02:23:36,807 so, we're continuing to work o 22267 02:23:36,807 --> 02:23:36,807 n 22268 02:23:36,807 --> 02:23:38,115 the list and be able to 22269 02:23:38,115 --> 02:23:39,879 successfully place everybody I 22270 02:23:39,879 --> 02:23:39,879 n 22271 02:23:39,879 --> 02:23:41,589 shelter that was in shelter 22272 02:23:41,589 --> 02:23:44,219 before the closure of 22273 02:23:44,219 --> 02:23:45,591 st. Francis hospital. 22274 02:23:45,591 --> 02:23:46,162 >> mayor: excellent. 22275 02:23:46,162 --> 02:23:47,723 I appreciate that. 22276 02:23:47,723 --> 02:23:49,555 I don't see any other lights, 22277 02:23:49,555 --> 02:23:51,465 but I have a few items try to g 22278 02:23:51,465 --> 02:23:51,465 o 22279 02:23:51,465 --> 02:23:52,455 through as quickly as possible 22280 02:23:52,455 --> 02:23:52,455 22281 02:23:52,455 --> 02:23:52,455 here. 22282 02:23:52,455 --> 02:23:56,746 first of all, on a somber note, 22283 02:23:56,746 --> 02:23:56,746 22284 02:23:56,746 --> 02:24:00,838 yesterday's news we learned tha 22285 02:24:00,838 --> 02:24:00,838 t 22286 02:24:00,838 --> 02:24:02,721 coral springs commissioner and 22287 02:24:02,721 --> 02:24:02,721 22288 02:24:02,721 --> 02:24:07,305 vice mayor, nancy bowen, was 22289 02:24:07,305 --> 02:24:08,977 murdered, and what appears to 22290 02:24:08,977 --> 02:24:13,646 have been a domestic violence 22291 02:24:13,646 --> 02:24:13,646 attack. 22292 02:24:13,646 --> 02:24:17,051 I mentioned that not only 22293 02:24:17,051 --> 02:24:19,787 because she is one of our own, 22294 02:24:19,787 --> 02:24:19,787 22295 02:24:19,787 --> 02:24:24,707 but to remind everyone that 22296 02:24:24,707 --> 02:24:26,125 the -- we don't know what's 22297 02:24:26,125 --> 02:24:27,763 happening in somebody else's 22298 02:24:27,763 --> 02:24:27,763 house. 22299 02:24:27,763 --> 02:24:30,613 we don't know, and domestic 22300 02:24:30,613 --> 02:24:36,219 violence can happen anywhere I 22301 02:24:36,219 --> 02:24:36,219 n 22302 02:24:36,219 --> 02:24:38,502 any home, and I have talked 22303 02:24:38,502 --> 02:24:40,239 about this a couple of times 22304 02:24:40,239 --> 02:24:41,039 this year. 22305 02:24:41,039 --> 02:24:43,445 it is something that I want us 22306 02:24:43,445 --> 02:24:43,445 22307 02:24:43,445 --> 02:24:47,087 to, as a city, as an entity, 22308 02:24:47,087 --> 02:24:48,717 find ways that we can be more 22309 02:24:48,717 --> 02:24:51,987 supportive of organizations 22310 02:24:51,987 --> 02:24:52,591 fighting domestic violence. 22311 02:24:52,591 --> 02:24:55,452 and sometimes that is as simpl 22312 02:24:55,452 --> 02:24:55,452 e 22313 02:24:55,452 --> 02:24:59,069 as talking about it. 22314 02:24:59,069 --> 02:25:01,173 that's why I wanted to bring I 22315 02:25:01,173 --> 02:25:01,173 t 22316 02:25:01,173 --> 02:25:01,173 up. 22317 02:25:01,173 --> 02:25:02,847 not for action, but I want to 22318 02:25:02,847 --> 02:25:04,651 think about how we might 22319 02:25:04,651 --> 02:25:08,567 approach the issue differently, 22320 02:25:08,567 --> 02:25:08,567 d 22321 02:25:08,567 --> 02:25:10,785 d nigd we can all -- anything 22322 02:25:10,785 --> 02:25:12,971 we can all do is talk about 22323 02:25:12,971 --> 02:25:13,715 domestic violence more 22324 02:25:13,715 --> 02:25:19,186 frequently and let folks know 22325 02:25:19,186 --> 02:25:21,147 who we may not realize are in a 22326 02:25:21,147 --> 02:25:21,147 22327 02:25:21,147 --> 02:25:22,469 difficult situation, that we a 22328 02:25:22,469 --> 02:25:22,469 re 22329 02:25:22,469 --> 02:25:23,157 here for them. 22330 02:25:23,157 --> 02:25:24,825 the city is here for them. 22331 02:25:24,825 --> 02:25:29,053 we as individuals are here for 22332 02:25:29,053 --> 02:25:29,053 22333 02:25:29,053 --> 02:25:29,053 them. 22334 02:25:29,053 --> 02:25:31,027 and all we can do for this 22335 02:25:31,027 --> 02:25:32,329 commissioner and vice mayor is 22336 02:25:32,329 --> 02:25:32,329 22337 02:25:32,329 --> 02:25:34,102 offer prayers and thoughts, 22338 02:25:34,102 --> 02:25:35,634 which is a hollow thing right 22339 02:25:35,634 --> 02:25:38,775 now, but it was important to 22340 02:25:38,775 --> 02:25:39,203 mention that. 22341 02:25:39,203 --> 02:25:41,935 try to get less somber as I go 22342 02:25:41,935 --> 02:25:41,935 22343 02:25:41,935 --> 02:25:42,434 down the list here. 22344 02:25:42,434 --> 02:25:47,195 I have heard recently that there 22345 02:25:47,195 --> 02:25:47,195 22346 02:25:47,195 --> 02:25:48,843 is potential of the northwest 22347 02:25:48,843 --> 02:25:50,845 boy's club, the existing 22348 02:25:50,845 --> 02:25:54,453 northwest boy's and girl's clu 22349 02:25:54,453 --> 02:25:54,453 b. 22350 02:25:54,453 --> 02:25:57,492 that property being up for sal 22351 02:25:57,492 --> 02:25:57,492 e 22352 02:25:57,492 --> 02:25:59,257 and all sorts of things there. 22353 02:25:59,257 --> 02:25:59,257 22354 02:25:59,257 --> 02:26:00,883 it is in the county. 22355 02:26:00,883 --> 02:26:03,833 it's not in the city, but it I 22356 02:26:03,833 --> 02:26:03,833 s 22357 02:26:03,833 --> 02:26:05,798 important to me, and I think t 22358 02:26:05,798 --> 02:26:05,798 o 22359 02:26:05,798 --> 02:26:08,329 this community, that that 22360 02:26:08,329 --> 02:26:10,197 remain, if it can't be boy's and 22361 02:26:10,197 --> 02:26:10,197 22362 02:26:10,197 --> 02:26:12,169 girl's club, then at least 22363 02:26:12,169 --> 02:26:13,607 remain athletic fields for tho 22364 02:26:13,607 --> 02:26:13,607 se 22365 02:26:13,607 --> 02:26:13,607 purposes 22366 02:26:13,607 --> 02:26:13,607 22367 02:26:13,607 --> 02:26:16,535 that matters a lot to this 22368 02:26:16,535 --> 02:26:22,113 community, I think. 22369 02:26:22,113 --> 02:26:23,871 not only from historical 22370 02:26:23,871 --> 02:26:25,261 perspective, but that kind of 22371 02:26:25,261 --> 02:26:26,415 use is dwindling. 22372 02:26:26,415 --> 02:26:31,083 I am normally 100%, 150% for m 22373 02:26:31,083 --> 02:26:32,589 u new 22374 02:26:32,589 --> 02:26:35,027 places to live, but that is a 22375 02:26:35,027 --> 02:26:36,790 place that's dwindling rapidly 22376 02:26:36,790 --> 02:26:36,790 22377 02:26:36,790 --> 02:26:38,289 when it is not a school use, a 22378 02:26:38,289 --> 02:26:38,289 nd 22379 02:26:38,289 --> 02:26:39,063 that one is not. 22380 02:26:39,063 --> 02:26:40,090 I would like to put that messa 22381 02:26:40,090 --> 02:26:40,090 ge 22382 02:26:40,090 --> 02:26:40,391 out there. 22383 02:26:40,391 --> 02:26:41,691 it is in the county. 22384 02:26:41,691 --> 02:26:42,994 were it to be in the city, I 22385 02:26:42,994 --> 02:26:45,107 don't think my mind would change 22386 02:26:45,107 --> 02:26:45,107 22387 02:26:45,107 --> 02:26:45,421 own that. 22388 02:26:45,421 --> 02:26:46,296 just put that out there. 22389 02:26:46,296 --> 02:26:51,702 a thing that I would like us to 22390 02:26:51,702 --> 02:26:51,702 22391 02:26:51,702 --> 02:26:54,639 be thinking about, we don't nee 22392 02:26:54,639 --> 02:26:54,639 d 22393 02:26:54,639 --> 02:26:55,841 to take action on it tonight, 22394 02:26:55,841 --> 02:26:57,813 but if you would think about 22395 02:26:57,813 --> 02:26:57,813 this. 22396 02:26:57,813 --> 02:27:00,520 I am interested in us getting 22397 02:27:00,520 --> 02:27:01,947 into the community and out of 22398 02:27:01,947 --> 02:27:06,325 the building more as a body. 22399 02:27:06,325 --> 02:27:09,289 I was talking with city clerk 22400 02:27:09,289 --> 02:27:12,457 yesterday about the idea of 22401 02:27:12,457 --> 02:27:15,067 doing one gpc meeting a quarter 22402 02:27:15,067 --> 02:27:15,067 22403 02:27:15,067 --> 02:27:18,899 off site somewhere, in an ada 22404 02:27:18,899 --> 02:27:20,431 accessible city facility, 22405 02:27:20,431 --> 02:27:21,819 wherever possible, certainly a 22406 02:27:21,819 --> 02:27:21,819 n 22407 02:27:21,819 --> 02:27:23,669 ada-accessible facility 22408 02:27:23,669 --> 02:27:25,139 regardless, whether it's city o 22409 02:27:25,139 --> 02:27:25,139 r 22410 02:27:25,139 --> 02:27:27,243 not, and get into each district 22411 02:27:27,243 --> 02:27:27,243 22412 02:27:27,243 --> 02:27:28,745 once a year. 22413 02:27:28,745 --> 02:27:32,391 there's -- I'm sure there's 22414 02:27:32,391 --> 02:27:34,237 reasons to be uncomfortable with 22415 02:27:34,237 --> 02:27:34,237 22416 02:27:34,237 --> 02:27:36,307 that, but I think it's good for 22417 02:27:36,307 --> 02:27:36,307 22418 02:27:36,307 --> 02:27:37,851 the community and the city as a 22419 02:27:37,851 --> 02:27:37,851 n 22420 02:27:37,851 --> 02:27:39,828 organization and us as a 22421 02:27:39,828 --> 02:27:41,015 commission to be out of the 22422 02:27:41,015 --> 02:27:42,218 building when we can. 22423 02:27:42,218 --> 02:27:47,928 I fully respect the idea we've 22424 02:27:47,928 --> 02:27:47,928 22425 02:27:47,928 --> 02:27:49,863 got to be not only personally 22426 02:27:49,863 --> 02:27:53,165 accessible with ada compliance, 22427 02:27:53,165 --> 02:27:53,165 22428 02:27:53,165 --> 02:27:55,839 but also available for people to 22429 02:27:55,839 --> 02:27:55,839 22430 02:27:55,839 --> 02:27:58,002 be able to watch and hear the 22431 02:27:58,002 --> 02:28:00,515 meetings, and that is something 22432 02:28:00,515 --> 02:28:00,515 22433 02:28:00,515 --> 02:28:02,051 that matters that we will 22434 02:28:02,051 --> 02:28:04,209 follow, but I would like to us 22435 02:28:04,209 --> 02:28:04,209 22436 02:28:04,209 --> 02:28:05,411 think about that as we move 22437 02:28:05,411 --> 02:28:06,785 forward, please. 22438 02:28:06,785 --> 02:28:10,587 last thing, I want to thank you 22439 02:28:10,587 --> 02:28:10,587 22440 02:28:10,587 --> 02:28:12,749 all for your wisdom and patienc 22441 02:28:12,749 --> 02:28:12,749 e 22442 02:28:12,749 --> 02:28:14,557 and good humor over the course 22443 02:28:14,557 --> 02:28:14,557 22444 02:28:14,557 --> 02:28:16,271 of this very long day, and I 22445 02:28:16,271 --> 02:28:18,593 hope to see many of you at the 22446 02:28:18,593 --> 02:28:18,593 22447 02:28:18,593 --> 02:28:22,135 mlk prayer breakfast tomorrow 22448 02:28:22,135 --> 02:28:23,523 morning, bright and early. 22449 02:28:23,523 --> 02:28:24,266 commissioner ingle. 22450 02:28:24,266 --> 02:28:26,697 >> I just wanted to throw some 22451 02:28:26,697 --> 02:28:26,697 22452 02:28:26,697 --> 02:28:27,996 support behind that idea of 22453 02:28:27,996 --> 02:28:29,633 maybe having meetings off site, 22454 02:28:29,633 --> 02:28:29,633 22455 02:28:29,633 --> 02:28:31,169 not only because it might be 22456 02:28:31,169 --> 02:28:33,875 interesting to be in all the 22457 02:28:33,875 --> 02:28:36,545 areas of the city, but the ide 22458 02:28:36,545 --> 02:28:36,545 a 22459 02:28:36,545 --> 02:28:38,482 of gpc is a little easier to 22460 02:28:38,482 --> 02:28:38,803 hash out. 22461 02:28:38,803 --> 02:28:40,240 I don't think this is the 22462 02:28:40,240 --> 02:28:41,750 easiest format to have 22463 02:28:41,750 --> 02:28:42,980 conversations about things. 22464 02:28:42,980 --> 02:28:46,051 so, being able to get around a 22465 02:28:46,051 --> 02:28:46,051 22466 02:28:46,051 --> 02:28:48,026 table somewhere or a little bit 22467 02:28:48,026 --> 02:28:48,026 22468 02:28:48,026 --> 02:28:51,912 different format where -- I like 22469 02:28:51,912 --> 02:28:51,912 22470 02:28:51,912 --> 02:28:55,446 to have a look at somebody whe 22471 02:28:55,446 --> 02:28:55,446 n 22472 02:28:55,446 --> 02:28:57,298 I'm talking to them. 22473 02:28:57,298 --> 02:29:00,802 a round table may be conducive 22474 02:29:00,802 --> 02:29:00,802 22475 02:29:00,802 --> 02:29:02,009 to have better conversations a 22476 02:29:02,009 --> 02:29:02,009 nd 22477 02:29:02,009 --> 02:29:03,671 see if we can't get those type 22478 02:29:03,671 --> 02:29:03,671 22479 02:29:03,671 --> 02:29:07,036 of topics on the agenda for whe 22480 02:29:07,036 --> 02:29:07,036 n 22481 02:29:07,036 --> 02:29:09,482 we might be in a format more 22482 02:29:09,482 --> 02:29:10,542 conducive to the conversations 22483 02:29:10,542 --> 02:29:10,542 . 22484 02:29:10,542 --> 02:29:13,174 >> I noticed there's a workshop 22485 02:29:13,174 --> 02:29:13,174 . 22486 02:29:13,174 --> 02:29:15,480 >> mayor: thank you, 22487 02:29:15,480 --> 02:29:16,572 commissioner ingle. 22488 02:29:16,572 --> 02:29:18,086 no further lights. 22489 02:29:18,086 --> 02:29:18,956 we are adjourned. 22490 02:29:18,956 --> 02:29:18,956