1 00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:11,980 And welcome to the City of Hayward Planning Commission meeting for May 22, 2025. We're holding a hybrid meeting with some participants in the council chambers and others who have joined virtually via Zoom. 2 00:00:12,520 --> 00:00:25,660 This meeting is being webcast on Comcast TV, Channel 15, and live streamed on the city's YouTube channel and on the city's website. This meeting is called to order at 704PM. Please rise for the pledge of allegiance. 3 00:00:47,090 --> 00:00:49,330 Ms. Allen, could you please call roll? 4 00:00:51,990 --> 00:00:53,310 Good afternoon. 5 00:00:54,290 --> 00:00:56,110 Commissioner Franco Cawson absent. 6 00:00:56,770 --> 00:00:57,510 Commissioner Goodbody. 7 00:00:58,150 --> 00:00:58,190 Here. 8 00:00:58,810 --> 00:00:59,950 Commissioner Hammond. 9 00:01:00,370 --> 00:01:00,510 Here. 10 00:01:01,090 --> 00:01:01,870 Commissioner Low. 11 00:01:02,510 --> 00:01:02,570 Here. 12 00:01:02,990 --> 00:01:03,870 Commissioner Myers. 13 00:01:04,670 --> 00:01:04,690 Here. 14 00:01:05,050 --> 00:01:05,910 Commissioner Stevens. 15 00:01:06,530 --> 00:01:06,550 Here. 16 00:01:06,830 --> 00:01:07,390 Chair Hardy. 17 00:01:08,130 --> 00:01:08,270 Present. 18 00:01:10,650 --> 00:01:14,070 We will now open public comments on non agenda items. 19 00:01:14,710 --> 00:01:20,430 The public comment section provides an opportunity to address the planning commission on items not listed on the agenda. 20 00:01:20,430 --> 00:01:33,550 The Commission welcomes comments and requests that speakers present their remarks in a respectful manner with in-established time limits and focused on issues which directly affect the city or within the jurisdiction of the city. 21 00:01:34,550 --> 00:01:44,390 As the Commission is prohibited by state law from discussing items not listed on the agenda, your item will be taken into consideration and may be referred to staff for further action. 22 00:01:44,390 --> 00:01:50,590 Speaker, shall not use threatening profane, abusive or abusive language, which disrupts, disturbs 23 00:01:50,590 --> 00:01:53,710 or otherwise impedes the orderly conduct of a commission meeting. 24 00:01:54,670 --> 00:01:59,430 The city is committed to maintaining a workplace free of unlawful harassment, and is mindful 25 00:01:59,430 --> 00:02:02,590 that city staff regularly attend commission meetings. 26 00:02:03,450 --> 00:02:08,470 Discriminatory statements are conduct that is hostile, intimidating, oppressive, or abusive, 27 00:02:08,990 --> 00:02:12,090 or per se, disruptive to a meeting will not be tolerated. 28 00:02:12,870 --> 00:02:16,250 Ms. Allen, do we have any public comments at this time? 29 00:02:20,320 --> 00:02:21,200 There are not online. 30 00:02:22,560 --> 00:02:23,520 Thank you. 31 00:02:23,980 --> 00:02:28,860 I will now close public comments and we will move on to our action items. 32 00:02:30,680 --> 00:02:35,980 The Commission will permit comments on each item that is called for public hearing. 33 00:02:36,640 --> 00:02:38,840 Please submit a speaker card if you haven't already. 34 00:02:39,020 --> 00:02:41,320 If you wish to speak on a public hearing item. 35 00:02:41,320 --> 00:02:46,840 For agenda item number one, the decision of the Planning Commission is final unless appealed. 36 00:02:47,460 --> 00:02:50,500 The appeal period is 10 days from the date of the decision. 37 00:02:51,160 --> 00:02:55,500 If appealed, a public hearing will be scheduled before the City Council for final decision. 38 00:02:57,720 --> 00:03:03,720 Item number one, P-H-2502 is a public hearing for the Stack Data Center, 39 00:03:04,000 --> 00:03:07,400 a major site plan review and administrative use permit application 40 00:03:07,400 --> 00:03:11,400 to construct a three-story data center, generator yard, 41 00:03:11,880 --> 00:03:15,540 substation, switching yard, and related accessory structures, 42 00:03:16,320 --> 00:03:20,140 in-site improvements on an approximately 11 acre site, 43 00:03:20,320 --> 00:03:24,440 located at 26062, Eden Landing Road, 44 00:03:24,980 --> 00:03:27,900 and review and certify the project's initial study, 45 00:03:28,200 --> 00:03:31,220 mitigated negative declaration, and mitigation monitoring, 46 00:03:31,820 --> 00:03:35,640 and reporting program, prepared by the California Energy Commission. 47 00:03:36,660 --> 00:03:39,400 staff have a presentation for this item. 48 00:03:40,380 --> 00:03:41,060 Yes, we do. 49 00:03:41,720 --> 00:03:45,800 I'm joining online so first just want to make sure that you are seeing the title slide before 50 00:03:45,800 --> 00:03:48,020 you and that you can hear me okay. 51 00:03:49,340 --> 00:03:51,780 We can hear you, but we do not see the slides yet. 52 00:03:52,380 --> 00:03:53,060 Oh, okay. 53 00:03:53,100 --> 00:03:54,140 Let's try sharing again. 54 00:03:54,260 --> 00:03:55,100 Hang on one second. 55 00:03:55,460 --> 00:03:56,480 And Jeremy, please stand by. 56 00:03:56,520 --> 00:03:57,760 I might have you share instead. 57 00:03:59,080 --> 00:03:59,520 Let's see. 58 00:03:59,580 --> 00:04:00,340 I try again. 59 00:04:09,000 --> 00:04:09,100 Okay. 60 00:04:09,220 --> 00:04:09,680 And my screen. 61 00:04:09,860 --> 00:04:10,640 It looks like it's sharing. 62 00:04:10,680 --> 00:04:11,880 How does it look on everybody else? 63 00:04:12,020 --> 00:04:12,240 It's green. 64 00:04:12,240 --> 00:04:14,600 It looks great if you see it on Monday. 65 00:04:16,800 --> 00:04:20,860 Well, a good evening commissioner is Elizabeth Lantin, senior planner. 66 00:04:21,360 --> 00:04:27,740 I'm joining you all virtually this evening because I'm actually currently on vacation in Pennsylvania, visiting my sisters family. 67 00:04:28,460 --> 00:04:38,020 So from afar, I'm here to present the Stacked Data Center project, which is requesting approval of a major site plan review and administrative use permit application. 68 00:04:38,020 --> 00:04:44,380 You may recall that this project was previously brought before the commission at a work session back in November. 69 00:04:45,160 --> 00:04:52,460 Since then, the project application has been deemed complete by staff and the environmental analysis process has concluded. 70 00:04:52,960 --> 00:04:57,580 So as a result, tonight, we'll be asking the commission to make a decision on this application. 71 00:05:05,430 --> 00:05:26,370 There we go. The project site is located just south of Highway 92 on Eden Landing Road in the middle of the city's industrial area, and as you can see on this map, it's fairly close to the shoreline interpretive center, which is indicated by the yellow dot, as well as sections of the Bay Trail, which are indicated by the dotted line green lines. 72 00:05:28,540 --> 00:05:34,440 As zooming in on our map, the site itself is approximately 11 acres and has frontages on 73 00:05:34,440 --> 00:05:38,700 Eden Landing Road, Production Avenue, and Investment Boulevard. 74 00:05:39,300 --> 00:05:44,680 It has a general plan land use designation of industrial corridor and is zoned in industrial 75 00:05:44,680 --> 00:05:50,500 park, which allows for data centers by right along with a range of other industrial and office 76 00:05:50,500 --> 00:05:51,080 uses. 77 00:05:51,980 --> 00:05:57,080 Currently, there's a vacant, light industrial office park with nine single-story buildings on 78 00:05:57,080 --> 00:06:03,080 site, which would be demolished in order to accommodate the proposed project. Staff has heard 79 00:06:03,080 --> 00:06:07,500 from one of the now former tenants of this office park that they were concerned that they 80 00:06:07,500 --> 00:06:12,760 would be unable to find affordable office space elsewhere in the area. But in response to the 81 00:06:12,760 --> 00:06:17,540 applicant team provided some financial relief to support this tenant's relocation efforts. 82 00:06:18,540 --> 00:06:27,060 I'll also note here while we're looking at this map that staff has also heard from a couple of 83 00:06:27,060 --> 00:06:31,920 landing road, who are concerned about the potential impacts that the construction of the project 84 00:06:31,920 --> 00:06:37,680 and that the limited number of future employees would have on their businesses and we'll address 85 00:06:37,680 --> 00:06:45,200 that more in just a bit. So this site plan rotates our orientation slightly so that north and highway 86 00:06:45,200 --> 00:06:51,440 92 are now toward the left of this image. The main building on site here shown in orange would 87 00:06:51,440 --> 00:06:58,620 a three-story 310 square foot data center that is about 100 feet tall. To support the project 88 00:06:58,620 --> 00:07:03,560 significant power needs there would also be an on-site substation and switching station 89 00:07:03,560 --> 00:07:10,420 along inlanding road and a large generator yard with 28 emergency diesel generators facing 90 00:07:10,420 --> 00:07:16,560 production avenue. Additional site improvements would include a guard station, security fencing, 91 00:07:16,560 --> 00:07:21,800 new landscaping and buyer retention basins and outdoor seating for employees. 92 00:07:24,180 --> 00:07:29,280 The design of the primary building includes a mix of concrete, metal, and textured elements. 93 00:07:29,820 --> 00:07:34,780 This rendering is a view from the corner of investment, boulevard, and production avenue, 94 00:07:35,280 --> 00:07:40,160 and as you can see the building incorporates a number of elements from the city's industrial design 95 00:07:40,160 --> 00:07:46,160 guidelines, including varied wallplanes and projections that help to visually break up the overall 96 00:07:46,160 --> 00:07:51,460 of the building. In this render, you can also see some of the screening that will help 97 00:07:51,460 --> 00:07:56,960 mask the view of that large generator yard facing production avenue. And in addition, 98 00:07:58,140 --> 00:08:03,980 the on-site substation, which will be visible from Eden Landing Road in Highway 92, will also be 99 00:08:03,980 --> 00:08:09,360 screened. As shown in this rendering, the screening design has evolved since the last time you saw 100 00:08:09,360 --> 00:08:14,980 in November, but the curved blue slats remain. And again, there meant to be a bucket of of the 101 00:08:14,980 --> 00:08:16,520 by Hayward Shoreline. 102 00:08:19,140 --> 00:08:22,040 Now, while this project is proposed, meets most of the requirements 103 00:08:22,040 --> 00:08:26,580 of the industrial park zoning district, as you might recall, there are two exceptions 104 00:08:26,580 --> 00:08:32,500 that the applicant is requesting. The first is a reduction in parking. Data centers are defined 105 00:08:32,500 --> 00:08:37,840 as an office use in our zoning ordinance, which means that they're required to provide one parking space 106 00:08:37,840 --> 00:08:43,340 for every 250 square feet of building. Given the square footage of the proposed project, 107 00:08:43,340 --> 00:08:46,380 this would require over 1200 parking spaces. 108 00:08:47,140 --> 00:08:49,480 Now, however, the city's parking regulations 109 00:08:49,480 --> 00:08:53,380 do allow for exceptions in cases when a uses parking demand 110 00:08:53,380 --> 00:08:55,200 would be significantly lower 111 00:08:55,200 --> 00:08:57,000 than the required number of spaces. 112 00:08:57,780 --> 00:08:59,640 So it's illustrated in the parking memo 113 00:08:59,640 --> 00:09:01,220 that's attached to the staff report. 114 00:09:01,620 --> 00:09:05,560 The proposed data center would have a maximum of 33 employees 115 00:09:05,560 --> 00:09:07,960 and up to 12 visitors per day. 116 00:09:08,600 --> 00:09:10,760 So that's the 68 parking spaces 117 00:09:10,760 --> 00:09:15,320 that the application proposals would be more than enough to accommodate the project's 118 00:09:15,320 --> 00:09:16,580 daily parking demand. 119 00:09:18,960 --> 00:09:22,720 The applicant team is also requesting a second exception related to 120 00:09:22,720 --> 00:09:29,020 building height. The building's main building, I should say, is proposed 100 foot height is taller 121 00:09:29,020 --> 00:09:35,180 than the 75 foot maximum height allowed by the industrial part zoning district. Now that said, 122 00:09:35,520 --> 00:09:40,760 the city's code does allow decision makers to approve taller buildings in the zoning district 123 00:09:40,760 --> 00:09:49,700 if the project includes significant and sufficient public benefits or amenities to warrant that increase in height. 124 00:09:51,340 --> 00:09:56,980 So the applicant team has met with staff, the Council Economic Development Committee, the HASPA Board of Directors, 125 00:09:56,980 --> 00:09:59,960 and this commission over the past two years, she just got... 126 00:10:00,000 --> 00:10:06,520 What should be included in the project's public benefit package to justify that requested height increase? 127 00:10:07,440 --> 00:10:14,400 As a result of these discussions, the public benefits package has increased from $900,000 in the initial application 128 00:10:14,740 --> 00:10:22,860 to the $2 million that you see today. Now, this is an increase from the $1.5 million public benefits package 129 00:10:22,860 --> 00:10:28,700 that was described in the staff report as just this week, the applicant team elected to increase 130 00:10:28,700 --> 00:10:33,600 their proposed contributions further in response to a letter from the HASPA Board of Trustees, 131 00:10:33,880 --> 00:10:40,420 which was also included as an attachment to the staff report. So this latest proposed $2 million 132 00:10:40,860 --> 00:10:46,780 public benefits package would be divided among various city and regional projects and funds, 133 00:10:46,780 --> 00:10:56,940 including $500,000 to HASPA, $300,000 each to the city's gateway marker project and a small business grant program, 134 00:10:57,400 --> 00:11:06,280 $200,000 each to Levista Park, the school district, and a CIP solar project at the city's water resource recovery facility, 135 00:11:06,280 --> 00:11:15,920 $150,000 for nearby bike and pedestrian projects, $100,000 for the CIP Stack Community Center 136 00:11:15,920 --> 00:11:22,640 project, and $50,000 for new signage for that adjacent Eden Landing shopping center 137 00:11:22,640 --> 00:11:23,900 that I was mentioning earlier. 138 00:11:25,140 --> 00:11:36,260 The revised conditions of approval that were distributed earlier this afternoon in the 139 00:11:36,260 --> 00:11:43,280 Again, this proposed public benefits package is based on feedback that the applicant team has received to date. 140 00:11:44,040 --> 00:11:52,640 At their June meeting last year, the Council Economic Development Committee recommended that the public benefits package include hosting an ongoing food truck court nearby, 141 00:11:53,360 --> 00:11:57,240 a contribution for the staff community center and support for small businesses. 142 00:11:58,020 --> 00:12:05,640 All of these are included in the latest public benefits package, with the exception of the food truck court as staff from the East Bay Regional Park District, 143 00:12:05,640 --> 00:12:09,840 recommended against that idea of based on where we are talking about putting it. 144 00:12:10,440 --> 00:12:16,060 In addition to CDC, we wanted to see further enhancement of the project's architectural 145 00:12:16,060 --> 00:12:21,580 elements and artistic screening, especially where they would be visible from Highway 92. 146 00:12:23,260 --> 00:12:27,940 On the behalf of Board of Trustees meetings in February and October of last year, 147 00:12:28,200 --> 00:12:33,800 the Board recommended a significant increase to the public benefits budget to cover a wider variety 148 00:12:33,800 --> 00:12:39,560 of green and sustainable projects, including contributions toward the renovation of the nearby shoreline 149 00:12:39,560 --> 00:12:45,260 interpretive center and towards bike and pedestrian infrastructure, city parks, tree plantings, 150 00:12:45,400 --> 00:12:51,040 and educational programs. Again, contributions for all of these items are included in the latest 151 00:12:51,040 --> 00:12:55,640 public benefits package and in direct response to a recent letter by the House of the Board, 152 00:12:56,060 --> 00:13:01,420 the applicant team increased the overall package to the low from $1.5 million to $2 million, 153 00:13:01,420 --> 00:13:06,500 which now includes a half million dollar contribution directly to HASPA to be used at their 154 00:13:06,500 --> 00:13:10,880 discretion towards their projects aimed at shoreline resiliency and education. 155 00:13:13,410 --> 00:13:17,650 And a work session with this body last year, the Commission again was generally supportive of 156 00:13:17,650 --> 00:13:22,230 the project, but recommended increased funding for the shoreline interpreted center, 157 00:13:22,410 --> 00:13:26,230 even landing ecological reserve, Hayward Unified School District, 158 00:13:26,750 --> 00:13:31,950 Russell City Art Project, and the Hayward Fire Department. In addition, the Commission recommended 159 00:13:31,950 --> 00:13:36,870 ongoing funding for the small business grant program to ensure its long-term success. 160 00:13:37,810 --> 00:13:42,050 And then finally, the Commission asked the applicant to incorporate more public art and EV charging 161 00:13:42,050 --> 00:13:47,690 stations. So again, many of these items are represented in the applicant's final proposal 162 00:13:48,230 --> 00:13:53,950 for the public benefits package and in the project design itself in the case of public art and EV charging 163 00:13:53,950 --> 00:13:54,670 stations. 164 00:13:57,180 --> 00:14:01,900 Now, this project is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act or CWA and 165 00:14:01,900 --> 00:14:06,520 initial study in mitigated negative declaration with the mitigation monitoring and reporting 166 00:14:06,520 --> 00:14:13,440 program was prepared. Per State requirements for projects that qualify as a small thermal power 167 00:14:13,440 --> 00:14:19,300 plant, as this one does, the California Energy Commission served as the lead agency in 168 00:14:19,300 --> 00:14:25,880 charge of preparing the ISM and D. The city, on the other hand, served as a responsible agency 169 00:14:25,880 --> 00:14:29,080 under SIGWA, assisting in the review of draft chapters. 170 00:14:30,160 --> 00:14:35,740 The ISM&D was available for public review from March 21st through April 21st, and the 171 00:14:35,740 --> 00:14:41,180 final document was certified by the CEC earlier this month on May 8th. 172 00:14:41,440 --> 00:14:45,980 Tonight, if the Planning Commission decides to approve this project, you will also be required 173 00:14:45,980 --> 00:14:52,080 to certify and accept the ISM&D that the CEC prepared, which is attached to the staff report. 174 00:14:53,180 --> 00:14:59,580 So, in conclusion, staff finds a project is consistent with all applicable city-cosm requirements. 175 00:15:00,000 --> 00:15:21,700 Including the general plan, zoning ordinance and industrial district design guidelines. We further find that by increasing the overall public benefits package from $900,000 to $2 million, and adjusting the contributions contained within, the proposal has adequately responded to the feedback provided to date, including from this body. 176 00:15:21,700 --> 00:15:42,240 While there were some comments received an opposition to the project, citing general concerns about the environment related to a data center and concern about impacts to nearby small businesses, the proposed project includes a number of sustainability measures and public benefits aimed at addressing these concerns. 177 00:15:43,300 --> 00:15:47,880 Moreover, staff also received several letters and correspondence in support of the project. 178 00:15:47,880 --> 00:15:55,360 On staff supports the requested parking reduction given the uniquely low staffing needs of a data center. 179 00:15:56,100 --> 00:16:06,500 And finally, staff appreciates the unique architectural design of this structure, especially the creative artistic screening of the substation facing Highway 92 and Eglanting Road. 180 00:16:08,220 --> 00:16:15,640 So as a result, staff recommends that the Planning Commission approves the proposed major site plan review and administrative use permit application 181 00:16:15,640 --> 00:16:18,320 and certify the project's Secret Document. 182 00:16:19,340 --> 00:16:20,960 This concludes staff's presentation, 183 00:16:21,420 --> 00:16:23,500 but if the chair will allow the applicant 184 00:16:23,500 --> 00:16:26,040 team has also prepared a short presentation 185 00:16:26,540 --> 00:16:28,540 that they'd like to share before we open it 186 00:16:28,540 --> 00:16:30,140 for questions and discussion. 187 00:16:32,460 --> 00:16:33,460 Thank you, senior planner, 188 00:16:33,840 --> 00:16:34,020 Blanson. 189 00:16:34,620 --> 00:16:36,580 Yes, if the developer would like to go ahead 190 00:16:36,580 --> 00:16:38,940 and make their presentation that would be great. 191 00:17:33,300 --> 00:17:34,100 Thank you so much. 192 00:17:34,320 --> 00:17:35,340 Great to be here this evening. 193 00:17:35,540 --> 00:17:36,620 Thank you so much for having us. 194 00:17:36,640 --> 00:17:38,820 Very exciting night for us and all of our partners. 195 00:17:38,820 --> 00:17:44,840 I have a lot of stakeholders, partners, consultants with us and some on the phone, so questions come up, I may be phoning a friend later. 196 00:17:45,340 --> 00:17:46,240 Thank you so much. 197 00:17:46,840 --> 00:17:47,480 Stack infrastructure. 198 00:17:48,200 --> 00:17:51,220 To review a bit, we are a data center developer. 199 00:17:51,500 --> 00:17:53,560 We specialize in building data centers globally. 200 00:17:54,120 --> 00:17:58,400 And data centers really help to power the internet, you know, the brick and mortar of the cloud. 201 00:17:59,000 --> 00:18:01,800 This is the nice to have, like the virtual presentation, 202 00:18:02,440 --> 00:18:04,700 Retreat even the documents from the internet that we're all using. 203 00:18:05,020 --> 00:18:08,380 It's also the need to have such as air control, such as police dispatch, 204 00:18:08,380 --> 00:18:10,520 such as our medical records in the event of emergency. 205 00:18:11,640 --> 00:18:12,240 Next slide, please. 206 00:18:14,660 --> 00:18:17,160 Stack is a global data center group. 207 00:18:17,320 --> 00:18:20,800 We focus here today in the Bay Area in Hayward, 208 00:18:21,020 --> 00:18:22,540 but we have a presence across the globe. 209 00:18:25,600 --> 00:18:27,640 This is where the internet crisscrosses the world 210 00:18:27,640 --> 00:18:28,780 and creates the cloud. 211 00:18:29,640 --> 00:18:30,040 Next slide, please. 212 00:18:32,730 --> 00:18:35,610 As I mentioned, Stack has a significant Bay Area presence here. 213 00:18:36,150 --> 00:18:37,610 We intend to grow in Hayward. 214 00:18:38,210 --> 00:18:40,590 We're also in Santa Clara in San Jose 215 00:18:40,590 --> 00:18:42,790 with two sister projects as well. 216 00:18:42,790 --> 00:18:43,890 Next slide, please. 217 00:18:46,120 --> 00:18:50,260 As Elizabeth was mentioning, and with great partnership, very proud working with Elizabeth staff 218 00:18:50,260 --> 00:18:53,740 who has been tremendous to the process as much as all of you have in continuing to refine 219 00:18:53,740 --> 00:18:54,320 the project. 220 00:18:54,880 --> 00:18:59,280 We really found ourselves a great home and 10-day grow here in the industrial technology 221 00:18:59,280 --> 00:19:05,240 corridor to really help to bring a healthy blend of information and technology jobs to the manufacturing 222 00:19:05,240 --> 00:19:06,140 jobs that are there. 223 00:19:06,660 --> 00:19:12,260 This is to really move an alignment with Hayward's 2040 general plan and really help to bring 224 00:19:12,260 --> 00:19:16,580 that healthy blend and to continue to attract additional corporate development in the area. 225 00:19:17,200 --> 00:19:17,660 Next slide, please. 226 00:19:19,840 --> 00:19:23,360 Here we see an updated rendering that you may be seeing for the first time, but this is just 227 00:19:23,360 --> 00:19:26,720 a visual to see how we really integrate into the neighborhood. 228 00:19:27,360 --> 00:19:30,580 You can see right in the middle, this is our SBY03A project. 229 00:19:30,980 --> 00:19:31,640 Thank you so much. 230 00:19:32,360 --> 00:19:34,100 It's hard to see too, because it blends in. 231 00:19:34,360 --> 00:19:38,520 You know, although we are asking for a height modification, we are relative to some of the other buildings, 232 00:19:38,860 --> 00:19:42,540 especially across the highway, and it really looked to integrate into the neighborhood. 233 00:19:42,540 --> 00:19:48,540 I think the biggest part that helps us to stand out is our enhanced architectural and science that we're really proud of. 234 00:19:48,840 --> 00:19:50,160 I'd also like to call out here. 235 00:19:51,080 --> 00:19:53,340 It's hard to see, you might be able to see it easier on your visuals. 236 00:19:54,120 --> 00:19:58,020 But we will be building a switching station in this sub-station on site. 237 00:19:58,320 --> 00:19:59,860 This is really to help enhance. 238 00:20:00,000 --> 00:20:05,300 The electrical infrastructure of the network, as well as help to provide our facility with electricity. 239 00:20:06,000 --> 00:20:14,540 This switching station will also enhance the robustness of the already PG&E network switching station network to help provide another breaker point. 240 00:20:14,840 --> 00:20:25,480 To help in case of an outage upstream or downstream, this allows other networks inside of this distribution and transmission network to stay online in the event of an emergency. 241 00:20:25,480 --> 00:20:27,700 see this provides that additional breaker position. 242 00:20:28,400 --> 00:20:31,260 What you can't see here is additional infrastructure that's underground. 243 00:20:31,640 --> 00:20:35,020 Some upgrades to the water infrastructure that we'll be making as part of our project. 244 00:20:36,020 --> 00:20:40,380 In collaboration with our civil engineering team, we're actually going to be doing some 245 00:20:40,920 --> 00:20:47,060 ride-along trenching for our water improvements to not disrupt any of the neighbors and make 246 00:20:47,060 --> 00:20:51,060 sure that this is actually an up-sized, you know, our upgrade actually calls for a 10-inch 247 00:20:51,060 --> 00:20:55,740 and this will be a 12 inch main to provide for future expansion in the area as well for future 248 00:20:55,740 --> 00:20:58,600 businesses or for future water usage. 249 00:20:59,680 --> 00:21:00,240 Next slide, please. 250 00:21:01,860 --> 00:21:07,560 Just to hit on a few of the benefits that we bring to the table, really excited to be creating 251 00:21:07,560 --> 00:21:11,960 approximately 380 union jobs for our construction site. 252 00:21:12,600 --> 00:21:17,380 We also anticipate having around 41 on-site jobs throughout the project and we have a job 253 00:21:17,380 --> 00:21:21,480 to apply here with about 200 indirect jobs that will be supporting in the data center. 254 00:21:22,560 --> 00:21:26,260 To go down some of the conformance and consistency that Elizabeth mentioned, this is truly 255 00:21:26,260 --> 00:21:31,400 in the line with a 2040 general plan as well as some of the green building ordinances and revenue 256 00:21:31,400 --> 00:21:37,080 creation that Hayward has really outlined. Some of our off-site improvements include pedestrian network 257 00:21:37,080 --> 00:21:41,480 improvements, traffic calming measures, and we also do work with alternative work schedules. 258 00:21:41,680 --> 00:21:46,760 This is a 24 hour facility, so not everyone is coming all at one time to reduce the amount of traffic 259 00:21:46,760 --> 00:21:47,880 that we bring to the area. 260 00:21:48,580 --> 00:21:52,560 With our mitigative negative declaration that was led by the CEC, 261 00:21:52,880 --> 00:21:54,700 we were able to complete our secret process 262 00:21:54,700 --> 00:21:56,720 and also be granted our small part planning exemption. 263 00:21:57,260 --> 00:21:59,220 This also includes our mitigation, 264 00:21:59,820 --> 00:22:02,140 monitoring and reporting program to help establish 265 00:22:02,140 --> 00:22:04,160 best practices through the course of development, 266 00:22:04,920 --> 00:22:06,020 what to do in each scenario, 267 00:22:06,340 --> 00:22:08,780 and really mitigate all concerns there. 268 00:22:09,660 --> 00:22:12,500 We will be 100% renewable and this goes towards 269 00:22:12,500 --> 00:22:14,120 stacks global and net zero program. 270 00:22:14,120 --> 00:22:20,580 for landscaping will be replanting 55 of the trees will be starting off with our 18EV 271 00:22:20,580 --> 00:22:25,400 chargers right off the bat and will be reducing our parking stalls to about 71 or less. 272 00:22:25,940 --> 00:22:29,600 Just to hit on some of the infrastructure that I was talking about that switching station, 273 00:22:30,200 --> 00:22:35,740 the water infrastructure upgrades, approximately you know $70 million worth of infrastructure 274 00:22:35,740 --> 00:22:38,300 upgrades that will be coming here to the city of Hatewood. 275 00:22:38,960 --> 00:22:39,700 Next slide please. 276 00:22:41,960 --> 00:22:44,900 Additionally, just a chat on some of the additional public benefits here. 277 00:22:44,900 --> 00:22:49,540 This is a letter from Dustin to the City Council identifying some of the key areas to help 278 00:22:49,540 --> 00:22:53,300 city close some of the funding gaps that we have in the general plan. 279 00:22:53,480 --> 00:22:57,240 The areas that we highlighted here with property tax sales tax and utility user tax. 280 00:22:57,380 --> 00:22:57,900 Next slide, please. 281 00:22:59,420 --> 00:23:05,520 When we look at the property taxes, for example, each one dollar that goes into property taxes, 282 00:23:06,100 --> 00:23:08,380 Hayward gets 16 cents on that dollar. 283 00:23:08,520 --> 00:23:12,400 Last time we were here, we were discussing how we believe Hayward has a pretty significant 284 00:23:12,400 --> 00:23:15,020 and deal relative to some of the neighboring jurisdictions. 285 00:23:15,840 --> 00:23:17,300 And we'd like to do a little comparison. 286 00:23:17,680 --> 00:23:18,340 So next slide, please. 287 00:23:19,900 --> 00:23:22,360 This is just some help on kind of by the numbers. 288 00:23:22,540 --> 00:23:26,160 And what we did here was try to bring through one of the questions 289 00:23:26,160 --> 00:23:28,020 that we had during our work session of, 290 00:23:28,040 --> 00:23:29,720 what if this project was in San Jose? 291 00:23:30,440 --> 00:23:32,980 Do we really have a better deal than other jurisdictions? 292 00:23:33,500 --> 00:23:35,240 And what we did here with one of our consultants 293 00:23:35,240 --> 00:23:37,260 and I'm going to really showcase that. 294 00:23:37,260 --> 00:23:40,960 If this project was dropped down in the exact same acreage, 295 00:23:40,960 --> 00:23:44,320 the exact same project, the difference is quite significant. 296 00:23:44,560 --> 00:23:46,020 And we'll just walk through some of these 297 00:23:46,020 --> 00:23:47,820 the tax revenue streams that we're looking at here 298 00:23:47,820 --> 00:23:48,560 from left to right. 299 00:23:49,100 --> 00:23:52,680 From left to right, we have the secured real estate property taxes. 300 00:23:52,680 --> 00:23:55,480 This is the traditional property tax that we all think of. 301 00:23:55,760 --> 00:24:00,040 As we go to the right here, the next one is the unsecured property taxes. 302 00:24:00,100 --> 00:24:01,960 Not as typical for a lot of projects, 303 00:24:02,140 --> 00:24:03,200 but these are the computers. 304 00:24:04,180 --> 00:24:06,740 The mechanical equipment to help cool the facility. 305 00:24:07,200 --> 00:24:08,800 These are also taxes as well. 306 00:24:08,800 --> 00:24:14,460 These are, this is equipment that is inside the building and consider personal property or unsecured property. 307 00:24:15,320 --> 00:24:18,840 As we continue to the right, all of that equipment that we're buying is coming to Hayward. 308 00:24:19,300 --> 00:24:21,400 And Hayward gets a piece of that sales tax. 309 00:24:22,180 --> 00:24:24,820 The computers that are in the facility are also refreshed. 310 00:24:25,000 --> 00:24:28,520 Just like the computers here, just like the computers that we had at home or in our work lives. 311 00:24:28,920 --> 00:24:31,240 You know, every one to five years will need to refresh these computers. 312 00:24:31,620 --> 00:24:34,100 So the sales tax revenue continues to regenerate. 313 00:24:34,220 --> 00:24:37,900 About 20% of the facility will be replaced every year on a rolling base. 314 00:24:37,900 --> 00:24:39,780 So it's just as we continue to update and refresh, 315 00:24:40,260 --> 00:24:43,220 and that produces a huge tax revenue center 316 00:24:43,220 --> 00:24:45,340 for hayward for sales tax. 317 00:24:45,800 --> 00:24:48,060 The last one, which is one that we don't always think about, 318 00:24:48,140 --> 00:24:49,960 but this is for the utility usage tax. 319 00:24:50,060 --> 00:24:52,600 This is the tax on electricity. 320 00:24:53,320 --> 00:24:56,780 And so again, as we go across all of these brackets here, 321 00:24:57,020 --> 00:24:59,620 we can see how if this project was in San Jose. 322 00:24:59,620 --> 00:24:59,760 Okay. 323 00:25:00,000 --> 00:25:15,260 Hayward does have a significant higher figure across the board to where we look at. When the project is fully stabilized, we can anticipate Hayward to anticipate about $9 million per year in direct revenue. 324 00:25:15,860 --> 00:25:20,960 And by the numbers, that's about an increase of 2% on the total revenue for the city of Hayward. 325 00:25:20,960 --> 00:25:24,560 as we look down at San Jose, it's about $7 million. 326 00:25:25,080 --> 00:25:27,680 So significantly about a million and a half higher per year 327 00:25:27,680 --> 00:25:30,300 that Hayward can anticipate to receive instead 328 00:25:30,300 --> 00:25:32,220 of if this project was in San Jose. 329 00:25:32,820 --> 00:25:33,560 Next slide, please. 330 00:25:35,260 --> 00:25:35,920 You've seen this one. 331 00:25:35,920 --> 00:25:38,620 This is again, we're just showing off how beautiful this project is. 332 00:25:38,800 --> 00:25:40,360 I'm really proud of our architectural team. 333 00:25:40,620 --> 00:25:41,940 And again, challenge for Mayor Mark Solene 334 00:25:41,940 --> 00:25:43,740 is during the Cdc meeting and from you all 335 00:25:43,740 --> 00:25:45,720 to continue to improve the design. 336 00:25:46,260 --> 00:25:48,420 I can say without a doubt, this is the most attractive data 337 00:25:48,420 --> 00:25:51,320 that I personally entitled, and that we've stood up here 338 00:25:51,320 --> 00:25:53,320 on the West Coast, or in the Americas. 339 00:25:54,280 --> 00:25:54,700 Very impressive. 340 00:25:54,820 --> 00:25:58,020 This is breaking up the facade using different architectural features. 341 00:25:59,020 --> 00:26:01,480 Some tricks that our architects have implemented, 342 00:26:01,620 --> 00:26:03,800 so not only at Louvers, but fake windows 343 00:26:03,800 --> 00:26:05,980 to help disguise the building, not as a data center, 344 00:26:06,660 --> 00:26:09,600 but as a office building next slide, please. 345 00:26:10,800 --> 00:26:11,400 And then the screening. 346 00:26:11,780 --> 00:26:13,400 Again, from you all continuing to iterate, 347 00:26:13,480 --> 00:26:15,260 this is the concept design that you all saw 348 00:26:15,260 --> 00:26:17,440 during the working session and really 349 00:26:17,440 --> 00:26:21,680 providing some feedback. We continue to enhance that and to great on the wave in next 350 00:26:21,680 --> 00:26:26,720 slide, please. And brought us to reality of what we anticipate to build and what we anticipate 351 00:26:26,720 --> 00:26:31,880 to submit a building permit on. Again, this is the integration of a wave into the screen. 352 00:26:32,320 --> 00:26:35,940 And as we see here, it does have a straight line at the top, but as we continue our designs 353 00:26:35,940 --> 00:26:40,900 with PG&E, we hope to be able to create some more undulation on the top of that to make the 354 00:26:40,900 --> 00:26:44,460 interpretation of a wave more evocative. We wanted to show, you know, no pun intended 355 00:26:44,460 --> 00:26:46,420 with the high water mark of how it could be, 356 00:26:46,520 --> 00:26:48,880 what it could look like, but we continue to work 357 00:26:48,880 --> 00:26:51,160 to improve our design even after this meeting tonight. 358 00:26:51,860 --> 00:26:54,220 In this screen, it's something that we're really proud of 359 00:26:54,220 --> 00:26:57,660 in an area for us to really bring our artistic expression to. 360 00:26:57,880 --> 00:27:00,700 This could have been corrugated metal paneling. 361 00:27:00,920 --> 00:27:02,880 We wanted this to be something that we could all be proud of 362 00:27:02,880 --> 00:27:03,800 every time we look by. 363 00:27:03,960 --> 00:27:05,600 This is a project that we all worked on together. 364 00:27:06,480 --> 00:27:07,020 Next slide, please. 365 00:27:08,120 --> 00:27:10,200 And then again, we'll continue on looking at this screen. 366 00:27:10,780 --> 00:27:12,240 This is a different screen this time, 367 00:27:12,300 --> 00:27:13,260 as Elizabeth was mentioning. 368 00:27:13,260 --> 00:27:19,000 this is for our generators. So not only are our generators, these are the cleanest generators 369 00:27:19,000 --> 00:27:25,620 that exist, these are tier 4 generators using biodiesel, reduced emissions, and scrubbers, 370 00:27:25,660 --> 00:27:31,200 basically Catholic inverters on these diesel generators. These have enclosures. So each of these 371 00:27:31,200 --> 00:27:36,400 generators are within their own little room. So even before we put the screen on, if you're walking 372 00:27:36,400 --> 00:27:40,880 along that fence line, if you hear testing or anything like that, it's going to be like a vacuum, 373 00:27:40,880 --> 00:27:45,740 You know less than 70 decibels less than noisy less than on the noise or conversation 374 00:27:45,740 --> 00:27:49,400 You know someone in the next room over having a loud conversation. That's what it's going to sound like 375 00:27:49,400 --> 00:27:52,440 Good driving by in a car. You're not going to hear it 376 00:27:52,440 --> 00:27:56,940 And to enhance that we also hide these so that someone driving by wouldn't even know that they were there 377 00:27:56,940 --> 00:28:01,760 We have we have these screenings all the way up to the top of the stack so you can't even tell you're going to see the screen 378 00:28:02,200 --> 00:28:05,340 And we went in to also make this just not a standard screen, but again 379 00:28:06,000 --> 00:28:09,260 different colors to break up these facades, you know, these were longer areas. 380 00:28:09,440 --> 00:28:13,020 So we use the checker, we use different colors to help to break this up, to help distract the eye. 381 00:28:13,160 --> 00:28:14,740 So it's not just one monolith of the color. 382 00:28:15,760 --> 00:28:16,340 Next slide, please. 383 00:28:17,600 --> 00:28:20,020 And here's just a view of the entrances control facility. 384 00:28:20,660 --> 00:28:25,800 24, 7, only people that are supposed to be there will be there to make sure that we have that. 385 00:28:25,860 --> 00:28:28,620 We have a controlled access to access control building. 386 00:28:29,120 --> 00:28:32,640 And again, just another view from another perspective to show that, you know, 387 00:28:32,640 --> 00:28:34,440 So there's really no kind of backside of the building. 388 00:28:34,700 --> 00:28:37,300 A lot of buildings nowadays will have the front facade that's enhanced, 389 00:28:37,740 --> 00:28:40,320 but the backside, the side neighbors, they don't get a pretty view. 390 00:28:40,700 --> 00:28:42,440 We want to make sure that from every angle, 391 00:28:42,540 --> 00:28:44,240 this is truly the gorgeous building. 392 00:28:45,260 --> 00:28:45,760 Next slide, please. 393 00:28:47,140 --> 00:28:48,480 Coming back to the public benefits. 394 00:28:48,920 --> 00:28:51,520 As Elizabeth was mentioning, I won't go through them all again, 395 00:28:51,640 --> 00:28:55,460 but really an iterative process that we're really proud to be a part of. 396 00:28:55,860 --> 00:28:58,260 Stack is always active in our communities. 397 00:28:58,260 --> 00:29:08,380 down in San Jose, we just helped out with the Buries are festival down there, and so we are proud to be members of the communities that we operate in across the Americas and across the globe. 398 00:29:08,520 --> 00:29:18,660 This provided us with really a unique opportunity where earlier we were kind of talking about some of the apples, you know, the infrastructure, the taxes. 399 00:29:19,220 --> 00:29:26,600 We didn't talk about the impact fees, the schedules that we all have as each city does that will be contributing to, but that's really the apples that we look to other cities at. 400 00:29:26,600 --> 00:29:32,340 This is the orange. This is where we have the opportunity to create an enhanced package for 401 00:29:32,340 --> 00:29:37,100 Hayward and really bring something that no other city has. Santa Santa Santa's A doesn't 402 00:29:37,100 --> 00:29:41,080 have the opportunity to receive these type of public benefits. They have a different 403 00:29:41,080 --> 00:29:45,040 system. They have higher height limits which don't provide the opportunity for us to engage 404 00:29:45,040 --> 00:29:49,960 with the community for all of these causes. The way that we look at this is this is really 405 00:29:49,960 --> 00:29:54,240 the start of the conversation for us to get together with these organizations, begin the 406 00:29:54,240 --> 00:29:59,980 discussions and then as the years go on and as we continue to work with our neighborhoods and work with our state. 407 00:30:10,580 --> 00:30:25,900 Thank you all for helping us along the way, from the project that we started with to the project that we are today. Truly an interim process that we're so proud of and excited to be a member of this community. Thank you so much. 408 00:30:33,520 --> 00:30:36,920 So, now we will move on to a commissioner questions. 409 00:30:38,060 --> 00:30:42,080 This is a time for us to ask staff and the developer and any questions and we'll 410 00:30:42,080 --> 00:30:43,520 reserve our comments for later. 411 00:30:44,120 --> 00:30:46,780 Do any of my fellow commissioners have any questions? 412 00:30:51,170 --> 00:30:51,610 Commissioner. 413 00:30:52,590 --> 00:30:53,110 Good body. 414 00:30:55,130 --> 00:30:55,570 Thank you, Chair. 415 00:30:55,690 --> 00:30:57,390 I have a question for the applicant. 416 00:30:59,880 --> 00:31:06,960 So, there were comments about the concern about making it a little more sustainable. 417 00:31:07,760 --> 00:31:15,080 And I was wondering if it was possible to phase in or do a hybrid with battery storage 418 00:31:15,080 --> 00:31:17,540 or if, because I understand that it's all diesel. 419 00:31:18,520 --> 00:31:18,840 Correct. 420 00:31:18,960 --> 00:31:22,900 Yeah, these are all tier four diesel generators using renewable fuel. 421 00:31:23,420 --> 00:31:26,060 Batteries are something that we did explore. 422 00:31:26,660 --> 00:31:33,300 Unfortunately, we do not have a lot of space on site and to ride our redundancy for power. 423 00:31:33,880 --> 00:31:38,000 This is the only time the generators come on is when we test them, just like an old car 424 00:31:38,000 --> 00:31:41,520 to make sure they work when it turns on or if the grade goes out. 425 00:31:42,220 --> 00:31:46,500 So again, the only time those generators are coming on is in the event of the grid going out. 426 00:31:46,720 --> 00:31:51,520 Talking with our printers about PG&E or adjacent substations have had zero downtime in the past decade. 427 00:31:51,520 --> 00:31:57,780 So these are only just in case, unfortunately, we're not able to integrate batteries into our 428 00:31:57,780 --> 00:32:02,980 building program here, just given the site constraints, the batteries that would be required 429 00:32:02,980 --> 00:32:07,200 to provide this amount of electricity would take up significantly more space than we're afforded 430 00:32:07,200 --> 00:32:08,280 on this site. 431 00:32:15,700 --> 00:32:17,160 Commissioner Stevens? 432 00:32:19,910 --> 00:32:20,190 Thank you. 433 00:32:20,250 --> 00:32:21,330 I just have a quick question. 434 00:32:23,410 --> 00:32:25,530 Why three floors and not four? 435 00:32:25,790 --> 00:32:26,650 Why not make a taller? 436 00:32:26,650 --> 00:32:31,690 Is there like an economic sweet spot between size and height? 437 00:32:32,190 --> 00:32:32,610 Great question. 438 00:32:32,970 --> 00:32:36,070 Yeah, for us, as we were working through this project, 439 00:32:36,570 --> 00:32:39,350 a two-story project was not economically feasible. 440 00:32:39,730 --> 00:32:43,450 And so we came forth with the plan to go with the three-story project, 441 00:32:44,030 --> 00:32:47,350 looking at the incremental increase from 75 feet to 100 feet. 442 00:32:47,590 --> 00:32:51,930 We felt like that was an area that we could be approachable with this public benefit package 443 00:32:51,930 --> 00:32:55,690 and with precedent from the project across the street, across Highway 92, 444 00:32:56,230 --> 00:32:59,950 at about 91 feet, we felt the relative height would be achievable. 445 00:33:00,590 --> 00:33:03,470 We actually have built projects that we have won in Santa Clara. 446 00:33:03,490 --> 00:33:04,670 That's a four-story project. 447 00:33:05,310 --> 00:33:08,890 And so we, at the time, came forth with a three-story project, 448 00:33:09,590 --> 00:33:12,210 but given the relative size to some of the other projects in the neighborhood, 449 00:33:12,670 --> 00:33:14,670 I felt like a three-story project was more appropriate, 450 00:33:15,090 --> 00:33:16,630 and that's where we came forth with our project. 451 00:33:16,630 --> 00:33:24,330 But if you looked at market forces, something much taller would be a reasonable thing for your firm to tackle. 452 00:33:25,390 --> 00:33:30,290 And then just can you summarize the benefits this project makes? 453 00:33:30,550 --> 00:33:34,130 I understand it has a huge tax benefit to the city. 454 00:33:35,070 --> 00:33:37,030 There's impact fees paid, which are standard. 455 00:33:39,110 --> 00:33:46,610 You are also making a lot of infrastructure improvements that go beyond the value of what your project is. 456 00:33:46,630 --> 00:33:47,590 is that correct? 457 00:33:47,750 --> 00:33:48,090 That's correct. 458 00:33:48,210 --> 00:33:49,730 Can you estimate what that value is? 459 00:33:49,790 --> 00:33:49,950 Yeah. 460 00:33:50,010 --> 00:33:53,010 We think about $70 million for the infrastructure improvements. 461 00:33:53,510 --> 00:33:57,710 That's between the electrical grid infrastructure improvements for the switching station 462 00:33:57,710 --> 00:34:02,430 as well as the water infrastructure that I was mentioning earlier, and really upsizing that beyond 463 00:34:02,430 --> 00:34:03,930 our project itself. 464 00:34:04,450 --> 00:34:12,210 And then finally, I think you mentioned this last time you were here in the event of a power issue in California. 465 00:34:12,210 --> 00:34:18,450 Does data centers like this and the one across the highway provide auxiliary power to the grid? 466 00:34:20,250 --> 00:34:23,270 Our company has never participated in it. 467 00:34:23,650 --> 00:34:33,390 But a few years ago Gavin knew some during a major power shortage did call around to data centers in the area to ask them to shed load off of the grid. 468 00:34:34,210 --> 00:34:35,990 Santa Clara has also done this itself again. 469 00:34:36,190 --> 00:34:38,010 Our company has never participated in that. 470 00:34:38,010 --> 00:34:41,590 That's something that has happened historically to help prevent issues. 471 00:34:42,090 --> 00:34:49,310 Our project is actually on what's considered the transmission network as opposed to the distribution network. 472 00:34:50,010 --> 00:34:54,690 So our electricity isn't necessarily competing with local businesses or local homes. 473 00:34:55,050 --> 00:34:56,570 And so that program is a little bit separate. 474 00:34:57,130 --> 00:34:59,970 And we actually help to enhance the transmission network through our switch. 475 00:35:00,560 --> 00:35:04,660 We also provide for enhanced grid reliability down at the distribution level. 476 00:35:05,040 --> 00:35:11,360 But conceivably, that could be another benefit, should it ever come to pass? We can't promise it today, but it potentially could be in the future. 477 00:35:11,920 --> 00:35:17,860 If Governor Newsom wants to call in us and need us to help out, that's something that we would of course consider. 478 00:35:17,860 --> 00:35:37,680 So finally, you own the data center, you least space in the data center, so many, many users are going to come in and develop many different resources and applications that are going to serve us as we occupy the area that could be AI, it could be everything, correct? 479 00:35:37,680 --> 00:35:45,840 That's correct. The abstract infrastructure purchases property actually back in 2020, and we'll continue to be a long-term owner of this facility in landlord. 480 00:35:46,500 --> 00:35:53,560 We are ourselves a developer of the building itself, just like an office building would have a developer that builds the shell itself. 481 00:35:53,840 --> 00:35:58,420 And then meets us, leases out different space inside for for users. Very similar. 482 00:35:58,420 --> 00:36:03,360 And then just to confirm, when these type of resources, 483 00:36:04,060 --> 00:36:07,260 these availability centers are located near the centroid 484 00:36:07,260 --> 00:36:10,880 of populations, it improves the reliability of our digital experience. 485 00:36:12,160 --> 00:36:14,260 Yes, this helps to reduce latency. 486 00:36:14,960 --> 00:36:16,640 That's one of the biggest things that we'll experience 487 00:36:16,640 --> 00:36:20,000 is faster internet, as well as reliant internet 488 00:36:20,000 --> 00:36:23,060 to other areas within our community, 489 00:36:23,840 --> 00:36:27,000 faster ability to reach that, as well as having that locally 490 00:36:27,000 --> 00:36:29,020 in the event of a course of a natural disaster. 491 00:36:32,690 --> 00:36:32,890 Thank you. 492 00:36:32,990 --> 00:36:33,590 Commissioner Low? 493 00:36:35,470 --> 00:36:35,690 Hi. 494 00:36:35,850 --> 00:36:38,330 Thank you very much for your presentation. 495 00:36:38,650 --> 00:36:40,410 And also for the presentation of staff. 496 00:36:41,330 --> 00:36:42,430 I said a couple of questions. 497 00:36:42,670 --> 00:36:44,590 I wanted to find out. 498 00:36:46,050 --> 00:36:50,570 The diesel generators is natural gas. 499 00:36:50,810 --> 00:36:55,230 Would that be less pollutant and was that explored as an option? 500 00:36:56,350 --> 00:37:00,110 We did look at different options for this specifically. 501 00:37:00,110 --> 00:37:07,830 We do not have natural gas transmission nearby, and natural gas is also used for a lot of 502 00:37:07,830 --> 00:37:13,430 facilities to help bridge the gap to the grid when grid electricity is not available. 503 00:37:14,210 --> 00:37:18,090 So people will have a natural gas essentially power plant in their backyard. 504 00:37:18,830 --> 00:37:24,010 We wanted to lead, and of course start with electrical power from the grid to reduce our 505 00:37:24,010 --> 00:37:24,350 emissions. 506 00:37:24,350 --> 00:37:31,070 And again, these generators are only there for an emergency, and also do help to provide that 507 00:37:31,070 --> 00:37:33,290 resiliency in the event of an emergency. 508 00:37:34,010 --> 00:37:40,550 So we're not using any natural gas on site for power generation or redundancy and our generators 509 00:37:40,550 --> 00:37:45,350 are state of the art as clean as it gets and using renewable fuel. 510 00:37:47,130 --> 00:37:52,440 And I know there's a red a little bit about the issue that I'm going to bring up, but I 511 00:37:52,440 --> 00:38:00,300 see if you could talk a little bit more about it. I was just wondering about the generators again 512 00:38:00,300 --> 00:38:08,080 they're tested several times a month. Is that correct? And then my question to that is 513 00:38:09,040 --> 00:38:16,680 how much noise pollution would there be with those? I might actually phone a friend on this one. 514 00:38:16,680 --> 00:38:22,220 I have Scott Deloddy, my RCEC consultant. 515 00:38:22,600 --> 00:38:24,520 Scott, are you available to answer that one? 516 00:38:25,900 --> 00:38:26,400 Yes, I am. 517 00:38:28,910 --> 00:38:30,730 Can you hear me? 518 00:38:31,450 --> 00:38:32,710 Yes, we can hear you. 519 00:38:32,910 --> 00:38:34,170 OK, thank you very much. 520 00:38:34,370 --> 00:38:36,550 Thanks for the opportunity to speak in front of you. 521 00:38:36,930 --> 00:38:39,510 A couple of things, a typical testing schedule 522 00:38:39,510 --> 00:38:43,230 for these kinds of generators are to our, 523 00:38:44,210 --> 00:38:47,470 we test them at no load, meaning they're tested 524 00:38:47,470 --> 00:38:55,030 very low load, usually 15 minutes a month for each generator. We also don't really test them 525 00:38:55,430 --> 00:39:03,190 that more than one at a time. So as as Miles said, it is presentation, these generators are inside 526 00:39:03,190 --> 00:39:09,570 an enclosure already. So all of the noise is already mitigated by the enclosure to make sure 527 00:39:09,570 --> 00:39:14,890 that we meet the standards as well as the additional screening that's provided. 528 00:39:15,750 --> 00:39:27,550 Towards the end of the year, sometimes you run the machine from instead of 15 minutes, you run it for an hour to four hours, and again, we do those at one at a time. 529 00:39:29,170 --> 00:39:44,810 The last thing I'd like to say is, as far as the diesel is concerned when it comes to emissions, again, we're talking about the possibility of maybe 10, 12 times a year for about 15 minutes each. 530 00:39:46,490 --> 00:39:50,170 And it's our intention is to never have to run them. 531 00:39:50,990 --> 00:39:55,910 And so far, the data from PG&E shows that in the last 10 years, we would have never had to run them 532 00:39:55,910 --> 00:39:57,450 except for this testing protocol. 533 00:39:58,270 --> 00:39:59,970 So the commission looked at the testing protocol. 534 00:40:00,000 --> 00:40:15,680 And look at what the noise would be, and look at what the emissions would be, and we're below every threshold, the thresholds that the Bay Area sets and the Bay Area Quality Management District, excuse me, sets, and we're also below below the city standards. 535 00:40:16,920 --> 00:40:30,680 Thank you very much for that answer. I appreciate that. You committed to 100% renewable but it wasn't clear. 536 00:40:30,960 --> 00:40:39,340 It said you could either go with PG&E or Ava and Hayward has chosen Ava as our renewable energy source. 537 00:40:39,820 --> 00:40:43,000 What is preventing you from just committing to Ava? 538 00:40:44,250 --> 00:40:50,830 We did have a great discussion with Eva about three, four months ago just learning about the program. 539 00:40:51,410 --> 00:40:54,190 Very looking much forward to continuing the discussion with Eva. 540 00:40:56,580 --> 00:40:59,640 But what is preventing you from just committing to Eva? 541 00:41:00,400 --> 00:41:01,740 What is holding you back? 542 00:41:01,780 --> 00:41:03,340 What are your thoughts about it? 543 00:41:03,480 --> 00:41:07,740 I was looking for a little bit more of an in-depth answer. 544 00:41:10,070 --> 00:41:15,530 Just learning about Eva very much so in the last couple of months and working with our energy procurement team 545 00:41:15,530 --> 00:41:18,610 and our potential clients to learn more about Ava. 546 00:41:19,230 --> 00:41:20,590 Ava sounds like a great community partner 547 00:41:20,590 --> 00:41:23,890 that I know has been a partner with Hayward, 548 00:41:24,030 --> 00:41:25,010 I believe since 2001. 549 00:41:25,750 --> 00:41:27,150 And so a great community partner 550 00:41:27,150 --> 00:41:30,090 and one that I know a lot of the profits from Ava 551 00:41:30,090 --> 00:41:31,250 do stay within the community. 552 00:41:31,690 --> 00:41:33,770 So a great partner here in the community. 553 00:41:34,290 --> 00:41:35,670 Something that we're just learning about 554 00:41:35,670 --> 00:41:37,630 and just beginning to discussions with Ava. 555 00:41:37,930 --> 00:41:39,090 So very much again, looking forward 556 00:41:39,090 --> 00:41:40,990 to continuing discussions with Ava 557 00:41:40,990 --> 00:41:42,990 and learning more from Ava. 558 00:41:44,130 --> 00:41:52,470 I'll also jump in here quickly, Commissioner Low, to add as conditioned and as is reflected in the mitigation monitoring and reporting program for the project. 559 00:41:53,050 --> 00:41:57,130 The project is required to use an 100% renewable option. 560 00:41:57,370 --> 00:42:06,430 Eva is kind of the typical option that we see here in Hayward, but PG&E, if you buy power from them directly, they also have a 100% renewable option. 561 00:42:06,430 --> 00:42:20,750 So from a sustainability standpoint, from an environmental standpoint, the project will be using 100% energy from 100% renewable sources in either case, whether they go with Eva or with PG&E. 562 00:42:23,340 --> 00:42:23,780 Thank you. 563 00:42:24,080 --> 00:42:25,620 Thank you very much, Ms. Blanton. 564 00:42:25,620 --> 00:42:27,800 And then, lastly, 565 00:42:29,840 --> 00:42:35,260 I wanted to ask, I believe, and now I don't have it exactly in my notes 566 00:42:35,260 --> 00:42:43,220 where, but I believe initially when the project was brought to one of the committees I 567 00:42:43,220 --> 00:42:50,660 don't remember, Phil, as Hesper or who, but the discussion was around a $3 million that 568 00:42:50,660 --> 00:42:59,240 public benefits package and I'm wondering why did you settle on 2 million instead of 3 million? 569 00:43:01,880 --> 00:43:07,260 Yeah, we originally started at about $900,000 looking at the data center project across 570 00:43:07,940 --> 00:43:16,160 the highway at exchange at 92. That project was about $730,000 equivalent. Through discussions 571 00:43:16,160 --> 00:43:21,100 with you all and through community discussions with stakeholders, we had I've been able to identify 572 00:43:21,100 --> 00:43:24,540 areas of most impact and continuously improve that package. 573 00:43:25,840 --> 00:43:31,360 With our package coming out of the study session, we're about $1.3 million and increase that 574 00:43:31,360 --> 00:43:37,400 up to $1.5 and then in discussions with other community stakeholders as well as the request 575 00:43:37,400 --> 00:43:40,460 from Hasbud to increase their specifically to $500,000. 576 00:43:40,900 --> 00:43:45,400 We're able to revisit our budget, really dig deep, and bring that up to the $2 million figure. 577 00:43:46,880 --> 00:43:50,860 That's where we started digging deep and cutting into bone a little bit. 578 00:43:50,860 --> 00:43:56,740 and really the public benefit packages the one time these really gave us an opportunity 579 00:43:57,340 --> 00:44:03,600 to help with some of these really key opportunities and we ended up leveling out at about 580 00:44:03,600 --> 00:44:04,000 $2 million. 581 00:44:06,720 --> 00:44:15,020 Thank you and I did also want to ask the jobs that you are generating specifically like 582 00:44:15,020 --> 00:44:17,600 I think you said 41 jobs, 583 00:44:19,940 --> 00:44:24,540 41 employees, and then all of the other jobs that you listed. 584 00:44:25,460 --> 00:44:27,880 Will there, is there a preference for a Haywood residence? 585 00:44:29,000 --> 00:44:29,860 For those jobs? 586 00:44:30,980 --> 00:44:34,840 We don't set any restrictions on any of our employment. 587 00:44:35,100 --> 00:44:39,860 We welcome all and encourage everyone from Haywood to come down and apply. 588 00:44:40,740 --> 00:44:41,700 We don't set any preference. 589 00:44:41,700 --> 00:44:46,220 We want to turn any one away from a great job and excited to work with everyone, but of course 590 00:44:46,220 --> 00:44:50,340 encourage, especially people nearby, especially people in Hayward, to minimize commute 591 00:44:50,340 --> 00:44:54,220 times, to work in their own communities, to come work on a great data center. 592 00:44:56,020 --> 00:44:56,660 Thank you very much. 593 00:44:56,920 --> 00:44:58,580 Again, thank you to staff as well. 594 00:45:00,460 --> 00:45:04,820 Commissioner Myers? Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Miles. 595 00:45:05,720 --> 00:45:17,680 Excuse me. So, one of my, my, my two questions for you. The first one is kind of been touched upon briefly, regarding kind of the decision to opt into a hundred percent renewable energies. 596 00:45:19,680 --> 00:45:23,620 Is it true that a lot of those will come from renewable credits? 597 00:45:25,200 --> 00:45:31,640 That's correct, we're afraid of fortunate here in California to have a very clean electrical grid. 598 00:45:31,960 --> 00:45:37,700 However, some of that power is still imported, and to reach a 100% renewable level, 599 00:45:37,700 --> 00:45:43,760 especially with 24-7 power. The sun isn't always shining at night time, and the wind isn't always blowing. 600 00:45:44,620 --> 00:45:53,160 We do use carbon credit offsets to achieve a 100% renewable level. These credits are typically used to help 601 00:45:53,760 --> 00:45:57,860 subsidize some of those new solar projects, some of those new wind projects, and to help 602 00:45:58,620 --> 00:46:04,940 by large acreages of trees to help deforestation prevent deforestation and to also replant 603 00:46:04,940 --> 00:46:08,940 trees and areas that have been logged and to help subsidize that. And so a lot of these 604 00:46:08,940 --> 00:46:13,000 credits in our national programs and a lot of our clients, national programs, helped to 605 00:46:13,000 --> 00:46:17,420 focus a lot of those credits on a national level and focus those as local as possible. 606 00:46:17,420 --> 00:46:24,840 Okay, and one of the things I've heard over the past decade pushed back against the carbon credit program. 607 00:46:25,600 --> 00:46:33,340 If is there a possibility that it may be expire and if so, what would be your recourse? 608 00:46:35,580 --> 00:46:36,580 That's a great question. 609 00:46:37,600 --> 00:46:41,180 That's one that I'm not personally able to answer. 610 00:46:41,360 --> 00:46:45,000 I think Sharon, are you available to answer that? 611 00:46:45,000 --> 00:46:48,600 We have one of our sustainability consultants that was able to 612 00:46:48,600 --> 00:46:50,060 participate in the program? 613 00:46:50,840 --> 00:46:51,300 Yes, hello. 614 00:46:52,320 --> 00:46:57,140 Thank you again for giving me the opportunity to present to the committee today. 615 00:46:57,580 --> 00:47:05,100 So for the carbon program, if it was canceled, then we will focus more on the energy part 616 00:47:05,100 --> 00:47:13,720 of the, so usually, again, these things are not guaranteed, but with carbon credits and things 617 00:47:13,720 --> 00:47:19,500 like that, since the building also look into embodied carbon and other stuff. 618 00:47:20,640 --> 00:47:23,320 So these are things that will be explored. 619 00:47:23,940 --> 00:47:29,300 So one of the things, majorly the things that we looked into was the energy aspect of 620 00:47:29,300 --> 00:47:34,060 the project and the water consumption of the project cool things that will resume and continue 621 00:47:34,060 --> 00:47:38,860 to be a factor into continuing the project. 622 00:47:38,860 --> 00:47:46,180 While the carbon credit part is more concerned of, so carbon is the embodied carbon can be 623 00:47:46,180 --> 00:47:49,160 operational carbon, which is also related to energy. 624 00:47:49,760 --> 00:47:55,640 So this also consolidates the idea that if we continue with the carbon, even if the carbon 625 00:47:55,640 --> 00:48:01,800 is cancelled, then looking into the energy and operating energy of the building, that will 626 00:48:01,800 --> 00:48:07,840 help us also to consolidate and confirm that the energy efficiency of the building is going 627 00:48:07,840 --> 00:48:14,900 who was all the resonating of all the ideas that we can put into making sure that the building 628 00:48:14,900 --> 00:48:21,460 is energy efficient. And again, all of this also goes with the enmanagement, with the Calgary 629 00:48:22,260 --> 00:48:26,680 requirements, and all of the California Energy Commission requirements as well. 630 00:48:27,960 --> 00:48:33,660 Okay, thank you. I don't anticipate it growing away except with the new administration 631 00:48:33,660 --> 00:48:37,820 and stuff, a lot of things are happening that we don't anticipate, or haven't anticipated. 632 00:48:38,640 --> 00:48:45,240 And if we had to, based on the footprint, I know we're limited on space, but would any, 633 00:48:45,700 --> 00:48:50,960 do you know of any size megawatt system, or a proportion of that, would fit on the footprint of the property, 634 00:48:51,440 --> 00:48:58,560 that maybe you could charge during non-rush hour, let's say, at night and then use harness in the day? 635 00:48:58,560 --> 00:49:03,680 So, right now, on the open space that we have, we are on the non-building space for really 636 00:49:03,680 --> 00:49:08,820 prohibited, given our open space requirements to provide green space about 15 percent 637 00:49:08,820 --> 00:49:13,660 of our site plan is required and we're excited to comply with that. 638 00:49:13,820 --> 00:49:17,820 For open space requirements and green space, this provides break areas for our employees 639 00:49:17,820 --> 00:49:20,820 as well as areas for wildlife to come. 640 00:49:21,480 --> 00:49:23,240 We are solar ready on the roof. 641 00:49:23,300 --> 00:49:27,260 We are a little bit prohibited with the space that we have on our roof given the equipment. 642 00:49:27,260 --> 00:49:34,540 However, as that space and that equipment continues to reduce in footprint, it's an opportunity for us to perhaps install 643 00:49:34,540 --> 00:49:36,340 scale solar arrays. 644 00:49:36,860 --> 00:49:38,640 Right now we're a little bit prevented on space. 645 00:49:38,820 --> 00:49:40,700 However, the building is solar ready. 646 00:49:42,140 --> 00:49:45,100 Yeah, and hopefully the efficiencies will grow up on those solar as well. 647 00:49:46,300 --> 00:49:53,800 And then my second question for you is, I see a few of the restaurant owners that are in the area. 648 00:49:54,500 --> 00:49:59,220 I asked about this in November, but I was wondering if maybe you could talk a little bit more about the 649 00:50:00,000 --> 00:50:11,460 The construction limitations that you're going to impose or not impose on the company, the local restaurants, it's a tough location to have any kind of food service. 650 00:50:12,040 --> 00:50:18,940 So any impact that I know over the last few weeks, PG&E was just redoing wires and it really, really affected the business there. 651 00:50:18,940 --> 00:50:29,940 Yeah, so you already, you know, have a tough situation with the location and now we're building this, can you talk about how to mitigate those disruptions? 652 00:50:30,400 --> 00:50:36,180 Absolutely. Yeah, we're blessed to have three street frontages on our project with Eden Landing production and investment. 653 00:50:36,740 --> 00:50:44,380 And with our general contractor hit, we've really been able to focus that logistics plan to leverage investment and production to stay away from Eden Landing. 654 00:50:44,380 --> 00:51:14,360 There's a, there's a bike lane there. We have our restaurant to cross the street. And so for all of our site logistics, we're really focused on not using e-dolanding to limit that interaction between some of our larger vehicles, some of our, some of our, some of our other trucks, some of our dump trucks from bicycles from pedestrians from other cars. And this will also help with reducing any street closures. So that those retailers are not interrupted. In the event that there's any time that we do need to interrupt any type of traffic on e-dolanding. 655 00:51:14,380 --> 00:51:27,600 It would be done with the help of traffic control measures such as flaggers to make sure that we keep the street open so that people are able to access all the commercial tenants across the street and again really focusing on leveraging production and investment. 656 00:51:30,120 --> 00:51:34,840 Okay, yeah, that's appreciated because I mean just one day of everybody driving by saying, 657 00:51:34,840 --> 00:51:39,340 It's too much trouble. I'll go somewhere else. That's really painful for the restaurant owners. 658 00:51:40,000 --> 00:51:44,100 So if there's anything you can do to really minimize that, that's appreciate it. 659 00:51:44,540 --> 00:51:47,700 Okay, that's all I had. I have one for staff, one question for staff. 660 00:51:49,640 --> 00:51:55,360 So I was reading today and I know we've all had our comments about the food court, food truck court. 661 00:51:55,840 --> 00:52:01,460 And is it my understanding that that will not be part of this situation now? 662 00:52:01,460 --> 00:52:10,240 Correct. When this idea originally came up at the CDC, we were envisioning where that might be in the nearby area. 663 00:52:10,440 --> 00:52:15,820 We talked about the inlanding ecological reserve parking lot, which is a couple blocks away. 664 00:52:16,300 --> 00:52:20,100 Where all the shoreline trails are without that might be a good spot for it. 665 00:52:20,860 --> 00:52:31,160 When talking though to East Bay Regional Park staff directly, they thought that that would be a more difficult thing to accommodate. 666 00:52:31,160 --> 00:52:37,200 especially because we're so close to the shoreline and there's sensitive species, sensitive habitat. 667 00:52:37,480 --> 00:52:43,620 So having an event that comes in and trash and all of that sort of stuff, they were concerned about that. 668 00:52:44,860 --> 00:52:51,400 So in response to that feedback from them, that's when some of the contributions shifted towards other things in the area. 669 00:52:51,400 --> 00:52:59,560 by pedestrian improvements, additional trees, additional improvements to signage and things like 670 00:52:59,560 --> 00:53:00,320 that instead. 671 00:53:01,940 --> 00:53:02,540 Okay, thank you. 672 00:53:02,600 --> 00:53:08,680 Evan, I've worked a lot of job sites, and I never thought about it, but it must be just 673 00:53:08,680 --> 00:53:10,860 an organic thing where food trucks appear. 674 00:53:11,060 --> 00:53:17,700 Is there a process where food trucks show up, do they have to get permits, or is it just organically 675 00:53:17,700 --> 00:53:18,620 showing up? 676 00:53:18,620 --> 00:53:24,260 Good question for any food truck operators listening. We do have a process and hey, word 677 00:53:24,260 --> 00:53:29,300 You have to get an annual permit to operate your food trucks so we can make sure that you're 678 00:53:29,860 --> 00:53:38,300 Operating in a legal way you have all of your trash pick up and everything contained and but we do allow food trucks to operate in the 679 00:53:38,300 --> 00:53:46,080 Industrial area in parking lots and things like that. So if there were food trucks that wanted to come and operate nearby 680 00:53:46,680 --> 00:53:51,080 They would just have to fill out an application with the city and then renew that every year. 681 00:53:53,120 --> 00:54:02,660 Is there a way to kind of make our restaurant owners a priority over the food trucks? 682 00:54:02,840 --> 00:54:07,480 Because if we're flooded with a bunch of food trucks and all of a sudden our restaurant owners are struggling, 683 00:54:07,700 --> 00:54:10,440 and we lose that business, I think that would be a total negative. 684 00:54:11,220 --> 00:54:23,220 Yeah, honestly, like our food truck permitting program has been in effect since I've worked for the city, so I started working here in 2018 and it was revamped a little bit when we updated our industrial regulations in 2019. 685 00:54:23,960 --> 00:54:29,260 We do have some folks in different places around town that every year get their food truck permit. 686 00:54:29,260 --> 00:54:36,160 However, it has not been a pervasive program where we would be having significant competition 687 00:54:36,160 --> 00:54:40,240 for this brick and mortar businesses, like we have in that inlanding shopping center. 688 00:54:40,940 --> 00:54:45,740 So to date, it hasn't really been much of an issue, but I'll say another long-range planning 689 00:54:45,740 --> 00:54:49,800 project I'm working on is a business-friendly update where we're looking at some of our commercial 690 00:54:49,800 --> 00:54:53,740 code updates, so this could certainly be something that we revisit and discuss as part 691 00:54:53,740 --> 00:54:55,040 of that project moving forward. 692 00:54:55,680 --> 00:54:59,960 Okay, and is there anything we should say to the restaurant owners if all of a sudden 693 00:55:01,320 --> 00:55:09,340 We are inundated with trucks, and it should affect them negatively. Is there a recourse or somebody they could talk to? 694 00:55:09,860 --> 00:55:16,060 They can always come to planning again that this is friendly. It's called Business Friendly Hate Word. It's the name of the project. 695 00:55:16,380 --> 00:55:26,520 It's aimed at making sure that our regulations, our processes, our permitting, our fairer to businesses. They are supporting businesses in Hate Word. 696 00:55:26,520 --> 00:55:29,080 So that's a project that's going on right now. 697 00:55:29,180 --> 00:55:32,980 Anyone that has concerns about this and he businesses please reach out to me. 698 00:55:33,080 --> 00:55:37,520 I'm the head planner on that project and we can certainly address your concerns as part 699 00:55:37,520 --> 00:55:38,440 of that effort. 700 00:55:38,960 --> 00:55:39,440 Excellent. 701 00:55:39,640 --> 00:55:40,240 Thank you. 702 00:55:40,460 --> 00:55:40,520 Planner. 703 00:55:40,980 --> 00:55:41,700 And that's all. 704 00:55:41,720 --> 00:55:42,660 Thank you. 705 00:55:45,540 --> 00:55:46,940 Mr. Hammond. 706 00:55:48,300 --> 00:55:48,480 Hello. 707 00:55:50,220 --> 00:55:53,960 First, I want to thank everyone for the hard work and putting together the staff report, it's 708 00:55:53,960 --> 00:55:54,480 attachments. 709 00:55:54,480 --> 00:55:57,520 and to the staff team for bringing us this project, 710 00:55:58,240 --> 00:56:01,340 your presentation was very informative and encouraging. 711 00:56:02,820 --> 00:56:03,620 I have a few questions. 712 00:56:04,200 --> 00:56:08,600 My full commissioners have already answered quite a few of them. 713 00:56:09,800 --> 00:56:15,820 What was the most significant concern in the mitigated negative declaration 714 00:56:15,820 --> 00:56:20,660 that you had to mitigate and that we should be aware of? 715 00:56:22,600 --> 00:56:24,880 Scott, are you able to feel that one? 716 00:56:27,790 --> 00:56:38,750 Yes, Mr. Nice to meet you. Thank you for letting me answer that question. Surprisingly, not much. We were not surprised. 717 00:56:39,130 --> 00:56:48,870 We proposed many of those mitigation measures. This applicant is the one that proposed to do 100% renewable and proposed to use renewable diesel. 718 00:56:48,870 --> 00:56:52,610 and proposed to do the mitigation that you see there. 719 00:56:53,510 --> 00:56:56,690 So there were certainly tweaks to the language 720 00:56:56,690 --> 00:57:01,130 that the Energy Commission in consultation with the city worked on. 721 00:57:01,290 --> 00:57:03,910 And none of that was unacceptable to us. 722 00:57:04,030 --> 00:57:05,250 We didn't make a single comment. 723 00:57:05,490 --> 00:57:08,670 We accepted the ISM&D because we weren't surprised. 724 00:57:09,210 --> 00:57:11,350 And I must tell you, I represent a lot of applicants. 725 00:57:12,010 --> 00:57:15,450 This applicant came to the table to work in such a way 726 00:57:15,450 --> 00:57:18,170 as to prepare in their application two years ago 727 00:57:18,170 --> 00:57:25,290 to the Energy Commission, a hired all of the technical consultants to do the studies, necessary 728 00:57:25,290 --> 00:57:29,130 to develop a full mitigation package with their application. 729 00:57:30,090 --> 00:57:35,010 I think that that should be acknowledged, that's why we weren't surprised because most of 730 00:57:35,010 --> 00:57:38,470 the mitigation was the things we were committing to do because we're good neighbors. 731 00:57:39,630 --> 00:57:44,350 I can also add to that as the city is a, we weren't the lead agency, but we're a responsible 732 00:57:44,350 --> 00:57:51,170 agency. So within a mitigated negative declaration, basically that means that you've reduced 733 00:57:51,170 --> 00:57:58,270 any identified potential impact to less than significant level. So Sequa has specific thresholds 734 00:57:58,270 --> 00:58:01,930 that says, you know, for example, for greenhouse gases, you have to be under these various 735 00:58:01,930 --> 00:58:08,690 specific thresholds that the city has adopted and that backman has adopted. And then the project 736 00:58:08,690 --> 00:58:11,670 test I would identify ways to get below those thresholds. 737 00:58:11,790 --> 00:58:15,750 Some of the things were, as Scott was saying, from the design of the project itself, 738 00:58:16,010 --> 00:58:20,550 and other things are those items that are listed in the mitigation monitoring and reporting 739 00:58:20,550 --> 00:58:27,090 program to ensure that on every topic that's equal to covers, if the project will be below those thresholds. 740 00:58:27,170 --> 00:58:29,330 So, sequence and end of itself doesn't weigh. 741 00:58:29,390 --> 00:58:32,090 It's a one topic more than others are all equally important. 742 00:58:32,130 --> 00:58:36,850 You have to get below levels of significance in all of them in order to use mitigated 743 00:58:36,850 --> 00:58:44,250 I get a declaration rather than an EIR, but for myself, when I've reviewed data center projects, 744 00:58:44,570 --> 00:58:49,370 the things that you tend to look at are air quality impacts, greenhouse gas impacts. 745 00:58:50,250 --> 00:58:54,470 Those are the types of things that rice is service, but again, this project mitigated them 746 00:58:54,470 --> 00:58:59,930 below the identified threshold, so there are no significant impacts identified with the mitigation 747 00:58:59,930 --> 00:59:01,170 that are incorporated. 748 00:59:02,410 --> 00:59:03,730 All right, thank you. 749 00:59:04,290 --> 00:59:12,870 Next question in the conditions of approval numbers 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, cover everything from Native American artifacts to fossils. 750 00:59:13,730 --> 00:59:16,470 Is anything of this sort ever been found in the general vicinity? 751 00:59:16,930 --> 00:59:20,610 And what do you think the likelihood of us finding something there would be? 752 00:59:21,790 --> 00:59:23,610 I think Scott, if you could address that one as well. 753 00:59:29,600 --> 00:59:32,440 I think when it comes to those things, we don't think it's a high likelihood, 754 00:59:32,440 --> 00:59:40,540 But because it could happen, we want to be prepared and again, as Elizabeth said, to meet 755 00:59:40,540 --> 00:59:46,020 the thresholds to ensure that there would not be no significant impacts, we proposed the monitoring. 756 00:59:46,420 --> 00:59:47,480 We proposed those things. 757 00:59:47,540 --> 00:59:50,620 They did turn into mitigation measures so that they would be enforceable. 758 00:59:51,180 --> 00:59:56,500 But we proposed those in our application for the sole purpose of just making sure. 759 00:59:56,680 --> 00:59:59,980 So I don't think it's going to happen, but we're prepared in case. 760 01:00:02,360 --> 01:00:13,740 And that's what those mitigation measures I think prevent. Correct. And I'll add here that this project did have an ISM&D, so you saw those in the form of mitigation measures in the conditions of approval. 761 01:00:14,280 --> 01:00:28,420 But even for projects that don't require the city has standard conditions of approval. They get it that same thing. Basically, if you find anything, they could be an artifact, or something of cultural significance, there's a process that you need to follow to make sure that we're not destroying any of that. 762 01:00:28,420 --> 01:00:31,200 So that's that's something that you would see in any project in the city. 763 01:00:31,620 --> 01:00:34,980 Sure, but historically there have ever been anything found in that vicinity. 764 01:00:35,620 --> 01:00:43,160 I know that the coastline was popular by the Lonees and the ISM&D has some more detail about 765 01:00:43,160 --> 01:00:49,720 that in the cultural resources chapter it talks about it, not a ton in the exact immediate 766 01:00:49,720 --> 01:00:50,280 vicinity. 767 01:00:50,540 --> 01:00:55,540 There is stuff culturally that's been found in our area and we do have tribes that requested 768 01:00:55,540 --> 01:01:00,980 consultation as a result. No tribe requests a consultation as part of this project. So again, 769 01:01:01,940 --> 01:01:07,460 I agree with Scott, it's probably unlikely, but it's not impossible that something would be found. 770 01:01:08,260 --> 01:01:13,820 All right, thank you very much. The last, at the last meeting, you stated that you'd be using 771 01:01:13,820 --> 01:01:20,720 local union labor and local suppliers to help construct the data center. It appears from the audience 772 01:01:21,680 --> 01:01:23,120 that's still in the plan. 773 01:01:23,520 --> 01:01:26,020 Have you reached out to any other local unions besides 774 01:01:26,020 --> 01:01:29,420 the Carpenter's Union, which quite a few letters 775 01:01:30,020 --> 01:01:31,640 in the presentation this evening? 776 01:01:32,120 --> 01:01:32,460 That's correct. 777 01:01:32,600 --> 01:01:34,580 We're excited to be proceeding forward 778 01:01:34,580 --> 01:01:36,880 with 100% Union for our construction project. 779 01:01:37,220 --> 01:01:38,240 So across all the trades. 780 01:01:39,940 --> 01:01:40,800 OK, very good. 781 01:01:41,320 --> 01:01:44,040 What is your contingency in your site plan 782 01:01:44,040 --> 01:01:45,240 for rising sea levels? 783 01:01:45,900 --> 01:01:48,420 I didn't see anything in that. 784 01:01:48,420 --> 01:01:57,430 and the report about sea level. Right now, I believe our site plan is built up, I believe, 785 01:01:58,290 --> 01:02:02,310 maybe Bernie, if you can address this one, or I believe we have our civil engineer. If you said 786 01:02:02,310 --> 01:02:09,070 you had a lower level, if I saw it. I can actually jump in here. So HASPA has a shoreline mitigation plan 787 01:02:09,070 --> 01:02:16,170 that anticipates different levels of sea level rise depending on the severity of what happens in 788 01:02:16,170 --> 01:02:21,710 future. So they have actual maps that identify which properties in our largely for us in 789 01:02:21,710 --> 01:02:26,250 a word. It's in our industrial area that might be subject to inundation, depending on what 790 01:02:26,250 --> 01:02:33,950 the levels of sea level rise are. This property is just outside of that. So the base elevations 791 01:02:33,950 --> 01:02:39,310 of the property are high enough that it's not anticipated even if there was a sea level rise event 792 01:02:40,010 --> 01:02:45,570 that it would be impacted at this property. Some of the properties to the west closer to the shoreline, 793 01:02:45,570 --> 01:02:50,970 certainly would face impacts, but not this property based on our latest data. 794 01:02:51,690 --> 01:02:52,790 Okay, thank you. 795 01:02:53,330 --> 01:02:58,730 In the staff report, it was said that EV stations were mentioned for use by the public. 796 01:02:59,950 --> 01:03:03,670 How are the EV stations incorporated in this new plan? 797 01:03:04,430 --> 01:03:05,250 Where are they? 798 01:03:05,670 --> 01:03:06,050 We have eight. 799 01:03:06,050 --> 01:03:13,390 There are EV charging stations that are incorporated for the workers and for visitors to the site itself. 800 01:03:13,390 --> 01:03:16,970 but since it's a secure site, those would not be available to the public. 801 01:03:17,030 --> 01:03:20,610 It would just be available to visitors or employees of the site. 802 01:03:20,750 --> 01:03:23,870 Okay, so there wouldn't be any room for any destination, maybe, chargers? 803 01:03:25,070 --> 01:03:29,610 No, one of the reasons that the public benefits package included all financial contributions 804 01:03:29,610 --> 01:03:34,950 was because this site was so constrained at 11 acres that there was just was not space 805 01:03:34,950 --> 01:03:38,650 for any sort of public amenity to be built on site. 806 01:03:38,750 --> 01:03:42,130 We'll still accommodate all of the needs of the project itself. 807 01:03:42,130 --> 01:03:49,790 Okay, thank you. And then in the conditions approval, number 46, and in the public benefit package, 808 01:03:50,110 --> 01:03:56,150 I'll just be clear are the funds for the LaVista Park and the in-lu fees for the treatment mitigation separate? 809 01:03:57,810 --> 01:04:06,070 Good question. So yeah, this project will have park impact fee requirements as all industrial projects in the city do. 810 01:04:06,070 --> 01:04:12,910 that's based on what the building permit issuance date is and we have a fee that goes up with an 811 01:04:12,910 --> 01:04:19,210 annual inflator every year. So that the project is subject to that in addition because there were 812 01:04:19,210 --> 01:04:23,870 trees that were removed on site that couldn't the value of those trees could not be fully mitigated 813 01:04:23,870 --> 01:04:30,050 on site. There is an obligation to pay the city into a tree fund for those additional trees that 814 01:04:30,050 --> 01:04:32,690 to be planted elsewhere, likely to live as to park. 815 01:04:33,190 --> 01:04:36,590 So this contribution in the public benefits package 816 01:04:36,590 --> 01:04:38,810 is in addition to both of those things. 817 01:04:38,930 --> 01:04:41,230 So it's an extra thing that they would not 818 01:04:41,230 --> 01:04:42,530 be required to do otherwise. 819 01:04:42,770 --> 01:04:45,030 The park impact fee, they're required to do. 820 01:04:45,170 --> 01:04:46,810 The inluffee for the tree medication, 821 01:04:46,890 --> 01:04:48,450 they're required to do. 822 01:04:48,670 --> 01:04:50,850 The public benefits package, that is something 823 01:04:50,850 --> 01:04:51,690 that they're proposing. 824 01:04:51,730 --> 01:04:54,430 It's above and beyond what is required of them. 825 01:04:54,850 --> 01:04:55,410 OK, very good. 826 01:04:55,730 --> 01:04:57,830 And so can some of that money be used to plant trees 827 01:04:57,830 --> 01:04:59,210 in those neighborhoods where 828 01:04:59,210 --> 01:04:59,970 They're most needed. 829 01:05:00,000 --> 01:05:11,800 For to reduce carbon like the Jackson corridor and our neighborhoods that are under planted with trees, in lieu of or in addition to love this to park? 830 01:05:12,780 --> 01:05:28,360 Yeah, I think my, in my husband correct me if I'm wrong. The applicant team has been very clear with staff to say that they want to make these contributions as general is possible and really trust staff to know where best to spend these funds. 831 01:05:28,360 --> 01:05:33,460 that's why, for example, the HASPA contributions says HASPA and then HASPA could elect us, you 832 01:05:33,460 --> 01:05:38,820 know, spend it on the shoreline, Interimative Center upgrade, or on other projects that 833 01:05:38,820 --> 01:05:44,760 they're pursuing. I'm so similarly with the tree donation to live this department, they 834 01:05:44,760 --> 01:05:49,280 heard that from city staff, they heard that city staff thinks that's where it would most be needed, 835 01:05:50,180 --> 01:05:53,740 but that could certainly be direction that the planning commission gives staff that they want that 836 01:05:53,740 --> 01:05:58,480 we use more generally towards trees and different locations around the city. 837 01:05:59,000 --> 01:06:00,200 Okay, thank you very much. 838 01:06:00,760 --> 01:06:05,360 And for my last question, besides your generous public benefits package, have you considered 839 01:06:05,360 --> 01:06:11,200 community involvement such as volunteering for a adoptive block program or joining in on community 840 01:06:11,200 --> 01:06:19,480 cleanup events or tabling a Hayward event to show the public with the stack centers all 841 01:06:19,480 --> 01:06:28,460 Absolutely. Yeah, we are very involved in the communities that we are members of as I was mentioning earlier just a recent example in San Jose 842 01:06:28,460 --> 01:06:36,200 But we had participated in cleanups in San Jose and looked to participate in ongoing activities here in Hayward as well 843 01:06:36,200 --> 01:06:44,260 One of the examples of the school district contribution was potentially to help out with the scholarship for the steam competition 844 01:06:44,260 --> 01:06:48,360 That's held each year to help grow the minds of the future of tomorrow children 845 01:06:48,360 --> 01:06:53,780 And so just another example of one of the areas that we are really excited to help contribute in. 846 01:06:54,320 --> 01:06:56,100 And again, that's a starting place. 847 01:06:56,400 --> 01:06:58,620 We are continued members of our community. 848 01:06:59,080 --> 01:07:00,540 And that's one of the fun parts of our job. 849 01:07:01,140 --> 01:07:02,500 We get to engage with the community. 850 01:07:02,720 --> 01:07:03,840 We get to help out. 851 01:07:04,060 --> 01:07:05,860 And all of our employees, our future employees, 852 01:07:06,060 --> 01:07:08,140 we're always excited to help out as well. 853 01:07:08,380 --> 01:07:09,160 It's very good to hear. 854 01:07:09,380 --> 01:07:09,960 Thank you very much. 855 01:07:10,140 --> 01:07:10,620 That's my questions. 856 01:07:12,580 --> 01:07:13,380 Thank you. 857 01:07:13,760 --> 01:07:15,500 I have just a few questions. 858 01:07:16,140 --> 01:07:24,020 The first one is what is the expected lifespan of the generators and how will they be disposed of or replaced at the end of their life cycle? 859 01:07:26,340 --> 01:07:27,980 Scott, can you address that one? 860 01:07:33,480 --> 01:07:37,120 Yeah, I'll do my best here. This is more of a commercial and more of an environmental guy. 861 01:07:37,640 --> 01:07:43,740 But I can tell you that most of the warranties that I've seen, they go for many years. 862 01:07:43,740 --> 01:07:51,340 I have worked on projects where I know that the generators are still operating and functioning 863 01:07:51,340 --> 01:07:56,360 appropriately 15 years into their life. 864 01:07:57,600 --> 01:08:02,740 These generators are modules, so they're easy to pick up and send back to the manufacturer 865 01:08:02,740 --> 01:08:03,860 and get a new one. 866 01:08:04,380 --> 01:08:07,520 So I think the disposal would be to the manufacturer. 867 01:08:08,560 --> 01:08:11,300 What the manufacturer does at that point, I don't know. 868 01:08:11,300 --> 01:08:18,320 So that's, I'm not really sure on being able to answer your full question, sorry about that. 869 01:08:19,180 --> 01:08:20,880 Okay, thank you. 870 01:08:23,540 --> 01:08:30,800 So, is there any scenario where a diesel spill from a generator could actually present a hazard to the public? 871 01:08:34,020 --> 01:08:36,300 We do have, go ahead Scott, yep. 872 01:08:36,460 --> 01:08:41,540 Sorry, that you're going to call on me and I was going to say maybe the time, but you want to answer it. 873 01:08:41,540 --> 01:08:43,400 we're probably going to say the same thing, 874 01:08:43,560 --> 01:08:44,220 go ahead and head Scott. 875 01:08:44,640 --> 01:08:46,220 Yeah, we have still prevention and protection. 876 01:08:46,460 --> 01:08:50,120 We have a hazard and materials plan that we prepare. 877 01:08:52,380 --> 01:08:55,560 We only use licensed delivers. 878 01:08:56,580 --> 01:09:00,300 And so they're not filling this very often. 879 01:09:00,640 --> 01:09:04,840 As you know, we only test them about 15 minutes a month. 880 01:09:05,680 --> 01:09:07,220 So we have thought about that 881 01:09:07,220 --> 01:09:09,320 and we have the appropriate catch basins 882 01:09:09,320 --> 01:09:17,600 and the appropriate materials that have to be on site during filling, and I think that's 883 01:09:17,600 --> 01:09:23,440 all required in one of the proposed conditions that we had proposed to the Energy Commission 884 01:09:23,440 --> 01:09:26,600 showing that exactly how we prepared those plans and what we do. 885 01:09:27,020 --> 01:09:32,680 So it is always possible to have a spill that it's not going to be a spill that isn't more 886 01:09:32,680 --> 01:09:34,240 like ounces rather than gallons. 887 01:09:34,240 --> 01:09:38,800 I can also add to this just to clarify and process. 888 01:09:39,340 --> 01:09:44,460 So in addition to this entitlement application that the applicant is required to get 889 01:09:44,460 --> 01:09:50,060 for this project, they're also required to apply for a separate fire permit, where they submit 890 01:09:50,060 --> 01:09:55,740 a fire protection engineer report and what's called an alternate means of protection or 891 01:09:55,740 --> 01:09:59,000 related to exactly the decil that's on site. 892 01:09:59,000 --> 01:09:59,980 that that's actually why this 893 01:10:00,000 --> 01:10:05,200 This project is not just a major site plan review, but it's a major site plan review and a administrative 894 01:10:05,200 --> 01:10:10,240 use permit. It's because of the amount of diesel on site. So basically, it means that they have 895 01:10:10,240 --> 01:10:17,740 fire technical experts and engineers submit all this documentation to show how things will be stored 896 01:10:17,740 --> 01:10:23,500 on site, how the diesel will be handled when being brought to the site to make sure that there's 897 01:10:23,500 --> 01:10:29,880 adequate fire access and then our team of technical experts reviews that make sure that it meets 898 01:10:29,880 --> 01:10:35,980 fire code or meets the intent to fire code in the sense of an AMP and our fire marshal 899 01:10:35,980 --> 01:10:41,340 signs off on that before anything is installed. So we're through the conditions of approval 900 01:10:41,340 --> 01:10:47,240 of this project. We're kind of enforcing that that is double triple check to make sure that 901 01:10:47,240 --> 01:10:51,600 it's safe and meets the intent to fire code and it's something we're to happen that our teams 902 01:10:51,600 --> 01:10:59,650 could safely access the site. Thank you. So as a part of that fire protection report, 903 01:10:59,650 --> 01:11:06,050 community warning system at all? Is there any plan right now for if there were, I hear 904 01:11:06,050 --> 01:11:09,710 that there's a lot being done to prevent it from happening? But if something were to happen, 905 01:11:09,950 --> 01:11:13,750 is there a plan for how, just yeah, it would be communicated? 906 01:11:15,090 --> 01:11:19,390 That wouldn't be in the technical fire report, but that would be something that we as a city, 907 01:11:19,470 --> 01:11:25,890 our PIO and in coordination with the fire chief would handle. As we've seen that first, there's 908 01:11:25,890 --> 01:11:30,650 some like refineries and different projects around the Bay Area that have had 909 01:11:31,010 --> 01:11:35,390 emergency events. We're that's coordinated that communication about that is 910 01:11:35,390 --> 01:11:38,230 coordinated through the cities official channel so it would be similar here in 911 01:11:38,230 --> 01:11:38,730 Hayward. 912 01:11:41,650 --> 01:11:45,270 So then just for my understanding so it wouldn't be a part of this 913 01:11:45,270 --> 01:11:50,090 actual plan but it's something separate that the city would exactly 914 01:11:50,090 --> 01:11:55,290 rather and it's more like rather than having like a thousand different plans about 915 01:11:55,290 --> 01:12:01,830 how that would be communicated to the community in event of a disaster, our fire chief would 916 01:12:01,830 --> 01:12:06,370 just be coordinating with our public information team to get that information out as quickly 917 01:12:06,370 --> 01:12:06,870 as possible. 918 01:12:07,110 --> 01:12:11,630 So when it be specific to this site, that's just what would happen in the event of any major 919 01:12:11,630 --> 01:12:15,210 emergency that the community need to be made aware of immediately. 920 01:12:16,750 --> 01:12:17,830 Thank you. 921 01:12:18,950 --> 01:12:24,490 So, I saw that the diesel fuel would be delivered as needed and you already spoke to how 922 01:12:24,490 --> 01:12:29,230 infrequently you would even run the generators really, they're only there for an emergency, 923 01:12:30,610 --> 01:12:35,570 but is there an estimate of how often like as needed could be like with some of the other 924 01:12:35,570 --> 01:12:41,470 stack centers that you've developed, like how often does diesel actually have to be brought in? 925 01:12:43,090 --> 01:12:47,710 It's infrequent. Scott, if you could provide any specifics from our maintenance program 926 01:12:47,710 --> 01:12:48,610 that we have. 927 01:12:56,660 --> 01:13:00,440 Sorry about that. Yeah, I'm trying to look it up here and I think that when we 928 01:13:00,440 --> 01:13:07,140 evaluated the number of trips, I think we thought we were going to have maybe two trucks a quarter 929 01:13:08,840 --> 01:13:09,800 at most. 930 01:13:13,340 --> 01:13:19,720 So is that typically because you just need to replace the diesel or is it really being 931 01:13:19,720 --> 01:13:25,940 used in the testing and it's getting empty and has to be refilled? What we like to do is keep 932 01:13:25,940 --> 01:13:32,360 the tank all the way full, so we don't use a full tank and then so we top off the tank. 933 01:13:32,820 --> 01:13:39,640 In case there is emergency we want to have 24 hours of run time available to us. 934 01:13:40,080 --> 01:13:46,040 So we generally do a schedule and if I remember correctly I think it's once a quarter we top up the tank. 935 01:13:46,300 --> 01:13:49,060 So it's not filling it from the bottom of the tank. 936 01:13:49,060 --> 01:13:56,060 And when I say tank, each generator has its own tank, that is enclosed and it is double walled. 937 01:13:57,320 --> 01:14:05,820 And so, yeah, I think that's the best I can find right now. I'm happy to keep looking and see if I can find the exact number. 938 01:14:06,720 --> 01:14:14,080 But my memory fits good. I think it was a couple of trucks in a quarter, once a quarter we usually do that. 939 01:14:14,520 --> 01:14:18,520 Great. Thank you. That's sufficient for what I wanted to know. Thank you. 940 01:14:18,520 --> 01:14:25,320 Thank you. Sorry. So I had a question about the Gateway Market Project, so this might be more for staff. 941 01:14:26,060 --> 01:14:32,800 It says with community, can you speak to what that project is and does it potentially include anything 942 01:14:32,800 --> 01:14:35,120 have to do with a Russell City Art Project? 943 01:14:36,500 --> 01:14:41,220 That's a good question. I don't know if Jeremy LeCurgo or Planning Manager knows more than I do, 944 01:14:41,300 --> 01:14:47,460 but my understanding is the Gateway Market Project has been something that's been on the city's road map for quite some time now. 945 01:14:47,460 --> 01:14:51,980 It's about incorporating signage or public art components, 946 01:14:52,940 --> 01:14:55,420 specifically that welcome people into the city, 947 01:14:55,540 --> 01:14:58,140 for example, on Highway 92, coming into the city, 948 01:14:58,500 --> 01:14:59,980 to kind of announce, hey, word. 949 01:15:00,000 --> 01:15:12,840 I'm in all the great new things that we have here. There has been talks about including like artists from our community into helping to develop some of the schemes of this. 950 01:15:13,260 --> 01:15:19,940 But I don't know the particulars of the project well enough to know if that also includes a connection to the Russell City Art Project. 951 01:15:20,420 --> 01:15:23,920 Jeremy Sardy put you on the spot, but do you happen to know more about this than I do? 952 01:15:23,920 --> 01:15:31,220 I actually don't know much more than you just mentioned, although I do understand that one of the reasons why it hasn't happened 953 01:15:31,220 --> 01:15:37,280 Seniors because there hasn't been enough sufficient funding available to be able to provide that. 954 01:15:37,660 --> 01:15:44,620 But certainly, I mean, obviously community input is going to be hugely valuable as we're entering a gateway to the community. 955 01:15:44,860 --> 01:15:50,380 And so obviously, you would want to make sure that that does reflect a word in a positive way. 956 01:15:50,380 --> 01:15:55,380 But in terms of timeline or when that actually happens, I think I'm not quite sure on that yet. 957 01:15:56,620 --> 01:15:57,140 And I can ask that. 958 01:15:57,140 --> 01:16:09,240 You can, sorry, just to interject here. Again, if the commission wanted to make recommendations to, you know, shift some of the conditions of approval to maybe make sure that incorporates the rest of the city art project. 959 01:16:09,440 --> 01:16:12,800 It would certainly be within your purview to do that. 960 01:16:12,800 --> 01:16:25,740 And originally, this was a program commissioned by the CEDC and so when we visited the CEDC almost a year ago now this was one of the programs that we were very excited to present to the CEDC. 961 01:16:26,040 --> 01:16:33,480 Originally it was commissioned for a budget of about $250,000 and just given that was back in 2017 when originally envisioned. 962 01:16:33,480 --> 01:16:37,880 We wanted to bring that forward to hopefully today's dollars bringing that up to $300,000. 963 01:16:38,480 --> 01:16:43,800 And based on feedback from the CDC, we thought this would be a great opportunity to involve the community, 964 01:16:44,240 --> 01:16:47,140 or deploy the program that staff had already helped to develop. 965 01:16:47,600 --> 01:16:51,480 And so we wanted to again leave that up to the discretion of decision makers like you, 966 01:16:51,660 --> 01:16:53,680 that could best integrate that into the community. 967 01:16:56,340 --> 01:16:57,060 Thank you. 968 01:16:57,240 --> 01:17:01,980 So my last question is, if this were approved tonight, 969 01:17:01,980 --> 01:17:05,160 When do you think you might break ground on this project? 970 01:17:06,440 --> 01:17:07,540 It's a great question. 971 01:17:08,180 --> 01:17:09,020 We hope it's possible. 972 01:17:09,620 --> 01:17:12,680 But we likely anticipate around October, November. 973 01:17:13,400 --> 01:17:16,000 We would be submitting our building permits. 974 01:17:16,380 --> 01:17:18,040 We're submitting them as we speak. 975 01:17:18,720 --> 01:17:21,560 And so planning to commence as soon as possible. 976 01:17:22,460 --> 01:17:26,760 We are, you know, of course, facing economic pressures over the last year and 977 01:17:26,760 --> 01:17:30,840 have two years since we began this planning process, we've been facing inflation, which directly 978 01:17:30,840 --> 01:17:34,540 hits all of the equipment and construction that we're facing, as well as increase 979 01:17:34,540 --> 01:17:37,980 tariff risk for all of the steel and other equipment that we're purchasing. 980 01:17:38,640 --> 01:17:41,740 And so, no time to waste, we're very excited to start construction. 981 01:17:44,230 --> 01:17:44,970 Thank you. 982 01:17:45,610 --> 01:17:46,350 Commissioner Myers. 983 01:17:47,410 --> 01:17:47,690 Thank you. 984 01:17:47,770 --> 01:17:49,810 I just have a couple of quick ones I hope. 985 01:17:50,190 --> 01:17:52,350 My first one was going to be that same one. 986 01:17:52,630 --> 01:17:58,050 From start to finish, what do you expect the construction duration to be and what is the overall 987 01:17:58,050 --> 01:18:00,050 build package price of this? 988 01:18:02,110 --> 01:18:07,910 It's about 20 months, 20 months from start to finish involving all of the site and horizontal 989 01:18:07,910 --> 01:18:13,010 work. The development costs have been evolving, and so I don't want to anchor 20 990 01:18:13,010 --> 01:18:17,610 figure or any number. But again, that day by day is continuing to grow, unfortunately. 991 01:18:18,450 --> 01:18:22,930 But so I don't want to presume to anchor on any number as that figure is continuing to evolve. 992 01:18:24,110 --> 01:18:25,130 Okay, fair enough. 993 01:18:25,370 --> 01:18:38,350 And then my other one is, I think for staff, just for due diligence purposes, not that I don't believe the numbers, but do we, are we finding the same numbers approximately 8.8 million that revenue that we'll receive? 994 01:18:39,430 --> 01:18:43,770 Yeah, I can start to speak to this and Jeremy can jump in if there's anything that I'm missing. 995 01:18:44,670 --> 01:18:46,790 We received a question from you. 996 01:18:47,210 --> 01:18:50,910 We spoke with Eric Pearson, who's on our sustainability team. 997 01:18:51,530 --> 01:18:55,330 He vetted that the utility tax number seem about right, 998 01:18:55,450 --> 01:18:57,290 if anything, they seem a little bit conservative, 999 01:18:57,650 --> 01:19:00,330 because they assume a flat rate for the utility tax 1000 01:19:00,330 --> 01:19:02,930 when often that will increase slightly over time. 1001 01:19:03,530 --> 01:19:05,850 And that's over half, I believe, 1002 01:19:06,010 --> 01:19:06,870 if I'm remembering correctly, 1003 01:19:06,870 --> 01:19:10,290 from the table of the tax benefit to the city. 1004 01:19:10,750 --> 01:19:11,870 For the other numbers, 1005 01:19:11,870 --> 01:19:18,750 we weren't able to verify with our finance team specifically to do the same 1006 01:19:18,750 --> 01:19:23,310 sorts of calculations that generally speaking the information that's conveyed 1007 01:19:23,310 --> 01:19:30,030 in those reports is accurate. Super. Okay, my last thing is senior planner 1008 01:19:30,030 --> 01:19:34,470 Blanton is on vacation. I want to nominate her for a huge raise this year. 1009 01:19:35,090 --> 01:19:35,770 Thank you. 1010 01:19:35,770 --> 01:19:35,970 Thank you. 1011 01:19:39,360 --> 01:19:42,140 There are any other commissioner questions? 1012 01:19:43,520 --> 01:19:44,240 Not seeing any. 1013 01:19:44,320 --> 01:19:46,960 I will close this section of our agenda. 1014 01:19:47,120 --> 01:19:48,040 Thank you. 1015 01:19:48,400 --> 01:19:50,580 And we will now move on to public comment. 1016 01:19:51,580 --> 01:19:55,600 So I know I have I believe 11 speaker cards for this item. 1017 01:19:55,780 --> 01:19:58,320 Are there any public comments on Zoom? 1018 01:20:01,140 --> 01:20:04,220 Yes, we have rainjada. 1019 01:20:04,620 --> 01:20:12,980 Just one, okay. Let's do the online comment first. Each person will have three minutes for comments. 1020 01:20:13,780 --> 01:20:16,460 So, I'm sorry if you could please set a timer for our public speakers. 1021 01:20:29,030 --> 01:20:30,190 Hello, you can go ahead. 1022 01:20:31,290 --> 01:20:38,010 Hi, so I'm one of the owners in that blog that the gentleman announced earlier. 1023 01:20:38,010 --> 01:20:45,030 And our concern is that we have been suffering for the past year, year and a half. 1024 01:20:45,750 --> 01:20:53,890 What is the city of Hayward besides the 50,000 that you guys are going to honor for everyone at the Plaza? 1025 01:20:54,530 --> 01:20:59,990 But what else are you guys willing to do to help us as business owners? 1026 01:21:00,070 --> 01:21:05,770 Because the landlord for that Plaza, he's not willing to help us with anything. 1027 01:21:05,770 --> 01:21:13,430 In fact, he actually raised the rent on us rather than lowering it, knowing that we've been 1028 01:21:13,430 --> 01:21:13,850 suffering. 1029 01:21:15,350 --> 01:21:19,510 So, and the city of Hayward, I have to mention, has been such a big help. 1030 01:21:20,210 --> 01:21:22,210 We just opened a place in San Francisco. 1031 01:21:22,630 --> 01:21:28,090 I have never met a city that is actually on top of it. 1032 01:21:28,130 --> 01:21:33,530 I want to thank Paul and Miles for always being so consistent with us. 1033 01:21:33,530 --> 01:21:40,550 but now our concern is that we're barely making it. I'm hearing that if there's going to be 1034 01:21:40,550 --> 01:21:47,530 a food truck, you guys are going to be okay with it. You know, we want to get as much benefit 1035 01:21:47,530 --> 01:21:53,110 out of the construction you guys are doing and I'm speaking upon all the owners in that 1036 01:21:53,110 --> 01:21:53,450 club. 1037 01:22:00,160 --> 01:22:06,460 Thank you. Okay, we will move on to our in-person comments. So again, if anyone would like to 1038 01:22:06,460 --> 01:22:12,320 Coming on this item who didn't already, please submit a speaker card, but I'll begin by calling 1039 01:22:12,960 --> 01:22:13,740 from the script. 1040 01:22:14,100 --> 01:22:15,300 So, Luis and Draude. 1041 01:22:22,870 --> 01:22:23,590 Thank you. 1042 01:22:24,210 --> 01:22:26,090 Commissioner, my name is Luis Andrade. 1043 01:22:27,450 --> 01:22:31,590 I'm President of the Hayward Integration and Park District, but tonight I come to you as 1044 01:22:32,290 --> 01:22:40,370 Trustee for the Haspa, and we are satisfied with the increased, 1045 01:22:42,930 --> 01:22:43,350 how do you want 1046 01:22:43,350 --> 01:22:47,610 call it the increased amount that they're offering as mitigation. 1047 01:22:48,430 --> 01:22:54,410 I do want to say that the purpose of the haspah is to mitigate climate change. 1048 01:22:55,010 --> 01:23:00,030 And even though this project is slightly out of their boundaries, it will benefit eventually 1049 01:23:00,030 --> 01:23:05,010 or all the projects in the area will benefit from our mitigation efforts. 1050 01:23:05,010 --> 01:23:15,250 So, I think it's an appropriate nexus between this project and what's happening and what 1051 01:23:15,250 --> 01:23:16,090 has been doing. 1052 01:23:17,030 --> 01:23:21,170 We plan to improve the offshore line center. 1053 01:23:21,330 --> 01:23:32,590 It'll be not just for help and space and natural values there, but also for we're going 1054 01:23:32,590 --> 01:23:38,070 to repurpose it or refogus it on sea level rise, 1055 01:23:38,350 --> 01:23:40,610 which is will affect the area. 1056 01:23:40,890 --> 01:23:42,230 It definitely will affect the area. 1057 01:23:43,230 --> 01:23:46,470 So it'll, and we should know that that center, 1058 01:23:46,550 --> 01:23:49,850 you know, pose several thousand school children 1059 01:23:49,850 --> 01:23:51,790 every year in field trips, 1060 01:23:51,930 --> 01:23:53,250 and we'll probably get, 1061 01:23:53,650 --> 01:23:55,270 including from this local area, 1062 01:23:55,330 --> 01:23:56,410 but also the entire area. 1063 01:23:56,850 --> 01:23:59,790 And I believe that we'll be able to accommodate more 1064 01:23:59,790 --> 01:24:05,950 have a program that will be a great interest to not only school children with a general public. 1065 01:24:07,170 --> 01:24:14,550 So, just when I say we approve the mitigation that's been offered and that's full of good 1066 01:24:14,550 --> 01:24:20,390 say right now. So thank you. Thank you, Lewis. I apologize for mispronouncing your name and 1067 01:24:20,390 --> 01:24:24,830 anyone else who's named my mispronouns. Next is Oligario, Guzman. 1068 01:24:34,100 --> 01:24:35,260 Good evening members of this committee. 1069 01:24:35,260 --> 01:24:39,720 my names when they got to use them and I'm a member of Lionel Labor's Local 304 right here in 1070 01:24:39,720 --> 01:24:44,160 Hayward and I've been a member for two years. I'm here to express support for this project. 1071 01:24:44,580 --> 01:24:49,280 A project like this offers this community, the chances start and or further a union construction 1072 01:24:49,280 --> 01:24:54,500 career in their local area. Much like I have and like my brother's decisions behind me have. 1073 01:24:54,800 --> 01:24:59,700 And since I joined the Zine, my life has improved dramatically because I'm certified. 1074 01:25:00,000 --> 01:25:29,160 I train and working. I once felt like I had no options for employment, but the labor's and local 304 were there when I needed a career to start providing for my family. There are hundreds of thousands more in my position. As a resident of this area, this project allows me to work within the community where I live, where my family attends school and attends church, and when we spend our money. All while I contribute towards my pension and provide health care benefits from my immediate family. 1075 01:25:31,020 --> 01:25:34,780 Projects like these show that the labor in our community are proven and trusted partners. 1076 01:25:35,760 --> 01:25:38,160 It's a project built by this community for the same community. 1077 01:25:38,760 --> 01:25:42,120 The exact partnership we need to move Hayward and its residents forward. 1078 01:25:43,060 --> 01:25:47,760 I urge you all to approve this project, grant the permits and break ground so that this community 1079 01:25:47,760 --> 01:25:51,020 are our members and your constituents can begin working. 1080 01:25:51,600 --> 01:25:53,000 Thank you. 1081 01:25:53,720 --> 01:25:54,380 Thank you. 1082 01:25:55,080 --> 01:25:56,820 Next is Alejandro Martinez. 1083 01:26:01,020 --> 01:26:06,380 Good afternoon, chair and commissioners. My name is Alejandro Martinez and I've been a member 1084 01:26:06,380 --> 01:26:13,200 of the labor's union for the past 10 years. I'm here tonight on behalf of the 4,363 members 1085 01:26:13,200 --> 01:26:20,620 in Elamita County and the 1,058 members that live here in Hayward. I'm here tonight to voice my strong 1086 01:26:20,620 --> 01:26:26,460 support for the proposed stack data center and ask you to grant the permits to get construction 1087 01:26:26,460 --> 01:26:31,560 started as soon as possible. This project will bring more jobs and better opportunities to our 1088 01:26:31,560 --> 01:26:36,280 community. It will provide great jobs and opportunities especially for young adults. 1089 01:26:37,180 --> 01:26:41,600 And anyone looking for a fresh start, it also allows skill training through our apprenticeship 1090 01:26:41,600 --> 01:26:46,900 program. When I was younger I had big dreams we're going to college starting a career and have a family. 1091 01:26:47,420 --> 01:26:57,940 Unfortunately it didn't go as planned. I found myself struggling making ends meet while trying to 1092 01:26:57,940 --> 01:27:04,660 Ohio. One of the largest cause next to housing is the expense of owning a vehicle associated 1093 01:27:04,660 --> 01:27:09,640 with the fuel and computing. After years of hardship, the labor's union gave me an opportunity 1094 01:27:09,640 --> 01:27:15,100 for a second chance and I was able to start a career as a skill labor. This general contractor 1095 01:27:15,100 --> 01:27:20,640 has been a proven partner in the past and believes in equitable benefits to all workers in their 1096 01:27:20,640 --> 01:27:26,100 under projects. This long-term project, so close to home, we'll create opportunities for others 1097 01:27:26,100 --> 01:27:30,920 like me who are looking for a way to build a better future for themselves and their families 1098 01:27:30,920 --> 01:27:36,260 providing a livable wages, health benefits, an entire family and a pension so they can 1099 01:27:36,260 --> 01:27:43,220 retire with dignity. We will also appreciate the opportunity to work here close to home and 1100 01:27:43,220 --> 01:27:48,080 maybe I can catch a soccer game for my daughter. It will be my honor and privilege to work with 1101 01:27:48,080 --> 01:27:52,240 my brothers and sisters in this project. I urge you to please support and grant the permits 1102 01:27:52,240 --> 01:27:54,760 So we can get to work. Thank you for your time. 1103 01:27:56,980 --> 01:27:57,540 Thank you. 1104 01:27:57,960 --> 01:28:00,100 Next is Jason Guematato. 1105 01:28:12,780 --> 01:28:14,660 All right, greetings chair and commissioners. 1106 01:28:14,740 --> 01:28:17,100 Thank you for allowing me to speak. 1107 01:28:17,760 --> 01:28:19,120 My name is Jason Guematato. 1108 01:28:19,280 --> 01:28:22,840 I'm a member and organizer with IBW Local 595. 1109 01:28:24,000 --> 01:28:27,980 I'm also a delegate with the Alameda County Building and Construction Trade Council. 1110 01:28:28,400 --> 01:28:34,620 Speaking on behalf of our local as well as the BTC and a number of the other affiliated locals in the room. 1111 01:28:36,020 --> 01:28:43,040 We are here to urge you to approve the staff recommendation of the proposed major site plan review. 1112 01:28:45,120 --> 01:28:49,580 You know, some of the things that we talked about tonight, I was going to try and address, 1113 01:28:49,820 --> 01:28:53,280 but it sounded like there was one thing that was really important to the committee. 1114 01:28:54,200 --> 01:28:58,360 The public, the benefits, the community benefits portion. 1115 01:28:58,360 --> 01:29:05,200 And so while the developer and the team maybe didn't hit the three million as, as it probably could have been viewed, 1116 01:29:06,000 --> 01:29:10,140 what I would offer is that a project like this, maybe there's 400 construction workers, 1117 01:29:10,840 --> 01:29:14,960 you know, the state requires about 20% be performed by apprentices. 1118 01:29:15,680 --> 01:29:19,960 That's about 40 apprentices on this job over the duration of the 20 months. 1119 01:29:20,600 --> 01:29:25,420 If those 40 apprentices works for approximately six months, about 1000 hours, 1120 01:29:26,060 --> 01:29:31,760 They're hovering around $30 an hour when you look at entry level apprentices, that's over, that's north of a million dollars. 1121 01:29:32,260 --> 01:29:37,720 That's a million dollars for apprentices that are from Hayward that can spend it at these restaurants. 1122 01:29:37,980 --> 01:29:44,780 They can spend it at Buffalo Bills, they can go down to Costco, they go down to Target or whoever, you know, they're, however they're spending their money. 1123 01:29:45,720 --> 01:29:55,360 And so while it wasn't sort of explicitly listed, if you would, if you would consider that part, that part of it, as it relates to the workforce in Hayward that 1124 01:29:55,360 --> 01:29:59,980 that will be working on this project. Maybe Miles was unable to sort of communicate it. 1125 01:30:12,220 --> 01:30:18,390 Thank you, thank you. Next is Victor de la Torre, 1126 01:30:24,870 --> 01:30:29,410 and thank you all for allowing me to 1127 01:30:29,410 --> 01:30:33,830 didn't speak this this evening. I am a third generation Lyona that is the labor 1128 01:30:33,830 --> 01:30:37,410 International Union of North America and I've been a resident of this area 1129 01:30:37,410 --> 01:30:41,950 for over 20 years. Thanks to the construction traits and the opportunity that 1130 01:30:41,950 --> 01:30:45,770 they have to offer, I will say what to start a career off as a friend when I was 1131 01:30:45,770 --> 01:30:51,910 18 years old. Learning the skill says that will help me build a career. This is why I'm 1132 01:30:51,910 --> 01:30:57,270 here this evening in support of the Stack Data Center. Projects that will bring 1133 01:30:57,270 --> 01:31:03,910 much needed, good paying jobs that benefits our brothers and sisters, where careers opportunities 1134 01:31:03,910 --> 01:31:09,370 will be offered to the youth and those facing hardships in this difficult times we are facing 1135 01:31:09,370 --> 01:31:15,390 due to inflation. I am a single father of four and I can't stress enough the importance of being 1136 01:31:15,390 --> 01:31:21,490 able to work close to home instead of driving multiple hours committing. Projects like this will 1137 01:31:21,490 --> 01:31:27,250 bring will allow us to balance home and work. I am extremely grateful to be able to provide 1138 01:31:27,250 --> 01:31:29,210 of a roof over my family's head, 1139 01:31:29,570 --> 01:31:31,910 and fortunate to be able to send my kids off to college 1140 01:31:31,910 --> 01:31:35,050 and watching grow up in the community that I grew up in. 1141 01:31:35,070 --> 01:31:37,150 I will not have been able to do this 1142 01:31:37,150 --> 01:31:38,370 if it wasn't for the construction 1143 01:31:38,370 --> 01:31:42,330 or opportunities provided to me through projects like this one. 1144 01:31:42,850 --> 01:31:46,350 No, I know many believe that this construction jobs 1145 01:31:46,350 --> 01:31:49,590 are only temporary, but I'm here to tell you, 1146 01:31:49,850 --> 01:31:50,970 this jobs are not temporary. 1147 01:31:51,170 --> 01:31:52,650 Construction jobs build America 1148 01:31:52,650 --> 01:31:54,970 and maintain the communities that we live in. 1149 01:31:54,970 --> 01:32:01,130 It's not just a job. It's a career. I am in full support of this project. You have a decision 1150 01:32:01,130 --> 01:32:06,670 to make. And I trust that you will make the right one and get us working once again. Thank you 1151 01:32:06,670 --> 01:32:12,810 for your time. Thank you. Oscar Masari Eagles. 1152 01:32:20,290 --> 01:32:22,030 Good evening. Steve members of the Planet Commission. 1153 01:32:22,250 --> 01:32:31,830 My name is Oscar Masari Eagles. I am here before you, not only as a field representative for the 1154 01:32:31,830 --> 01:32:35,450 but also as a Hayward resident myself in the last 15-plus years. 1155 01:32:36,230 --> 01:32:37,510 The developer, stacking infrastructure, 1156 01:32:37,810 --> 01:32:39,590 has shows a responsible contractor 1157 01:32:39,590 --> 01:32:41,430 in Hayth Constructing, 1158 01:32:41,990 --> 01:32:43,710 which is signatory to the Carpenter's Union. 1159 01:32:44,630 --> 01:32:46,910 Currently, construction in general has been very slow. 1160 01:32:47,770 --> 01:32:50,230 So residents and all members from the surrounding areas 1161 01:32:50,230 --> 01:32:51,670 could benefit from a work opportunity 1162 01:32:51,670 --> 01:32:54,450 that a project of this size can offer. 1163 01:32:55,750 --> 01:32:56,830 Not only during construction, 1164 01:32:57,010 --> 01:32:58,690 but opportunities after as well. 1165 01:32:58,690 --> 01:33:02,490 Also, by contracting being signatory to the carpenters, 1166 01:33:02,930 --> 01:33:04,950 they are part of a state-approved apprenticeship program, 1167 01:33:05,370 --> 01:33:08,690 though bringing many new next generation carpenters 1168 01:33:09,310 --> 01:33:11,990 to start a new career and many to finish their apprenticeship 1169 01:33:11,990 --> 01:33:15,970 by becoming a gentleman with a career that they could be proud of. 1170 01:33:16,130 --> 01:33:19,590 In conclusion, I want to thank you for the time to talk tonight. 1171 01:33:20,470 --> 01:33:23,970 And also, myself and the rest of our carpenters over here, 1172 01:33:24,230 --> 01:33:26,330 we urge you to please support this project and continue 1173 01:33:26,330 --> 01:33:29,110 investing on a workforce, our future, and local economy. 1174 01:33:30,690 --> 01:33:31,570 Thank you. 1175 01:33:31,830 --> 01:33:32,830 Thank you. 1176 01:33:34,250 --> 01:33:35,130 Michelle Swin. 1177 01:33:45,760 --> 01:33:46,480 Commissioner Sincere. 1178 01:33:46,840 --> 01:33:47,720 My name is Michelle. 1179 01:33:48,160 --> 01:33:51,280 I'm here today as a third-year apprentice in the local 1180 01:33:51,280 --> 01:33:54,720 Carpenter's Union here at 713 as well as being a 1181 01:33:54,720 --> 01:33:55,320 Hebrew resident. 1182 01:33:55,460 --> 01:33:56,900 I'm here today in support of this 1183 01:33:56,900 --> 01:33:58,100 Data Center project. 1184 01:33:58,820 --> 01:34:00,200 My union has done a lot more than a 1185 01:34:00,200 --> 01:34:01,740 specific variety job. 1186 01:34:02,560 --> 01:34:04,200 It's built a foundation for a stable and 1187 01:34:04,200 --> 01:34:08,300 to fight life, not only for me, but my family, but for hundreds of 1188 01:34:08,300 --> 01:34:10,780 apprentices across Alameda County in Northern California. 1189 01:34:11,680 --> 01:34:14,540 As a union apprentice, I've had the privilege of working alongside 1190 01:34:14,540 --> 01:34:17,400 highly skilled professionals, learning trade specific skills and 1191 01:34:17,400 --> 01:34:20,480 contributing to the growth of my community and those around me. 1192 01:34:20,820 --> 01:34:24,620 The benefits of large-scale projects like this go beyond just the 1193 01:34:24,620 --> 01:34:27,980 workers that are directly involved, they extend to the local business 1194 01:34:28,660 --> 01:34:31,560 businesses, families, and the entire region. 1195 01:34:31,560 --> 01:34:35,940 So once again I ask you to please support this project. Thank you. 1196 01:34:36,020 --> 01:34:37,220 Thank you. 1197 01:34:39,240 --> 01:34:40,280 Rosalie Aheda. 1198 01:35:05,040 --> 01:35:09,660 Hello, good afternoon. Members of the Planning Commission. 1199 01:35:11,940 --> 01:35:14,320 Thank you for allowing me to speak today. 1200 01:35:15,940 --> 01:35:30,380 My name is Rosalio Heda. I have been a carpenter at North Cal Carpenter's Local 713 in Alameda County for 20 years, and a Hayward resident for 40 plus years. 1201 01:35:31,260 --> 01:35:40,760 I am here today to ask for the approve of the Stack Center General Projects. 1202 01:35:40,760 --> 01:35:43,520 I'm very excited about it. 1203 01:35:44,020 --> 01:35:47,460 I already asked my nephew to join the union. He's a welder. 1204 01:35:49,460 --> 01:35:57,020 The HITT contracting has made a commitment to pay area standard wages, benefits, and retirement 1205 01:35:57,020 --> 01:36:02,880 to all construction workers working on their job site. 1206 01:36:03,800 --> 01:36:09,700 This job will also create opportunities for many residents from Hayward 1207 01:36:11,020 --> 01:36:13,180 and surrounding areas. 1208 01:36:14,980 --> 01:36:16,420 Thank you for your time. 1209 01:36:18,390 --> 01:36:20,030 Thank you. 1210 01:36:20,350 --> 01:36:22,890 Is Hedardo Rios? 1211 01:36:29,760 --> 01:36:30,200 Good evening. 1212 01:36:33,040 --> 01:36:34,200 Good evening. 1213 01:36:35,620 --> 01:36:41,080 I'm a member of Dr. Wal-Local 968 for the last 10 years. 1214 01:36:41,460 --> 01:36:44,660 I'm also a Hayward resident for the last year. 1215 01:36:45,400 --> 01:36:49,240 I'm here today to ask for the opportunity for a stack status center project. 1216 01:36:49,460 --> 01:36:53,560 This project will create a lot of necessary jobs for the residents of Hayward 1217 01:36:53,560 --> 01:36:59,460 and surrounding area, help a lot, and keep a lot of people working during these critical times 1218 01:36:59,460 --> 01:37:00,740 where jobs are scarce. 1219 01:37:00,740 --> 01:37:06,800 These workers can also benefit not only from liable wages, but benefits for ourselves and our families 1220 01:37:08,590 --> 01:37:12,670 So once again, I ask you to please approve this project. Thank you 1221 01:37:13,850 --> 01:37:16,470 Thank you 1222 01:37:16,470 --> 01:37:17,590 David Calderon. 1223 01:37:28,460 --> 01:37:31,120 Good evening planning commission. My name's David Calderon 1224 01:37:31,660 --> 01:37:36,280 I'm a field representative for brick layers now like craft workers local three of Northern California 1225 01:37:36,880 --> 01:37:39,440 I was born and raised in Hayward 1226 01:37:39,440 --> 01:37:41,640 Hayward is close to my heart. 1227 01:37:44,040 --> 01:37:44,600 I 1228 01:37:44,600 --> 01:37:54,540 I look forward to having the opportunity to give a local resident an opportunity to have an apprenticeship program and a middle-class career. 1229 01:37:54,800 --> 01:37:55,980 Thank you. 1230 01:37:55,980 --> 01:37:56,700 Thank you. 1231 01:37:59,000 --> 01:38:00,120 Julian Dodge. 1232 01:38:06,940 --> 01:38:07,740 Good evening, Commissioner. 1233 01:38:08,140 --> 01:38:08,600 Commissioner. 1234 01:38:09,000 --> 01:38:10,480 I am Julian Dodge. 1235 01:38:10,840 --> 01:38:13,620 Project Manager with Revital Electric Group. 1236 01:38:13,620 --> 01:38:21,600 signatory with I.B.W. Local 595, I've been planning on working on this project for a while now, 1237 01:38:21,740 --> 01:38:26,420 and I'm very excited to get some, get some guys hired and get out there and get after it. 1238 01:38:26,540 --> 01:38:30,980 So I just urge you guys to please support this project and improve it tonight. Thank you so much. 1239 01:38:32,640 --> 01:38:35,620 Thank you. Robert Downs. 1240 01:38:44,540 --> 01:38:48,980 Thanks, commissioners. Good evening. My name is Robert Downs. I'm a 1241 01:38:48,980 --> 01:38:53,880 decision with local 342, the Pummers and Pifters, I just want to say you guys had some amazing 1242 01:38:53,880 --> 01:39:00,560 questions tonight with the project. Just address a couple of with some of the issues about fuel 1243 01:39:00,560 --> 01:39:07,340 spills, 25 years in the heavy industrial industry, my self working refineries. All fuel containment 1244 01:39:07,340 --> 01:39:13,660 systems are double contained. So if there is a spill within side generating system in the fuel 1245 01:39:13,660 --> 01:39:19,300 management, it leaks into the first containment system that is the outer 1246 01:39:19,300 --> 01:39:24,160 containment. There's moisture sensors that would trigger all on-site alarm. That 1247 01:39:24,160 --> 01:39:29,920 basically the on-site maintenance guys that are working the buildings, it 1248 01:39:29,920 --> 01:39:33,460 triggers them to obviously respond in those scenarios. So I just wanted to 1249 01:39:33,460 --> 01:39:37,700 kind of point that out, that is something that's a valuable system that's, you know, 1250 01:39:37,880 --> 01:39:43,380 obviously moving fuel oil around a facility like that. So hopefully that kind of 1251 01:39:43,380 --> 01:39:48,620 is that question with the fire code prevention to with that stuff. Looking at their generator 1252 01:39:48,620 --> 01:39:54,960 run times that they were proposing only 15 minutes a month was that correct? Okay. So if you 1253 01:39:54,960 --> 01:39:59,980 look at that, that's only three hours a year. The average commercial generator runs about 40,000. 1254 01:40:00,000 --> 01:40:14,000 On its lifetime span. So if you do the math there, I mean, that three hours a year, that thing will last a long time. So you're probably looking to probably make missing it from not using it enough, more so than having to replace it. I would think in that scenario. 1255 01:40:15,480 --> 01:40:28,940 And then to all the business owners around, I promise you guys, we are tired of eating on the same food trucks all the time. Every job site we go to the food truck is always the same. It doesn't matter who owns the food truck. 1256 01:40:28,940 --> 01:40:33,020 I promise you, we will be eating at your businesses during this project. 1257 01:40:34,120 --> 01:40:38,280 Just, you know, it's refreshing to see that there's businesses right across the street from the project. 1258 01:40:38,960 --> 01:40:44,040 Not including all of the business that you're going to see in the future from the data center itself. 1259 01:40:45,420 --> 01:40:49,600 So the UA, we cover spring critters, plumbers, pipe critters, welders. 1260 01:40:50,160 --> 01:40:53,040 So we will bring a lot of business to this with the job site itself. 1261 01:40:53,540 --> 01:40:57,740 And we urge you to move forward with the project, also along with my constituents and the unions. 1262 01:40:57,740 --> 01:41:00,220 Thank you. 1263 01:41:00,540 --> 01:41:01,360 Thank you. 1264 01:41:02,100 --> 01:41:04,300 And that was our last public comment. 1265 01:41:04,660 --> 01:41:09,340 So I will close public comments and we will move on to Commissioner comments. 1266 01:41:10,780 --> 01:41:11,420 Commissioner low. 1267 01:41:15,490 --> 01:41:16,090 Thank you, Chair. 1268 01:41:24,150 --> 01:41:32,290 So I definitely hope that the applicant will consider using Ava. 1269 01:41:32,870 --> 01:41:38,410 And I hope that you will continue with the talks with them and getting to know them so that you will be comfortable doing this. 1270 01:41:38,410 --> 01:41:47,990 that. But I am grateful that you are committing to 100% renewable. I still hold out hope 1271 01:41:47,990 --> 01:41:54,730 and would love to see the 3 million. However, I definitely feel better about it after hearing 1272 01:41:54,730 --> 01:42:03,050 from Mr. Guamatautel. So I feel a lot better about that. And also, I just want to say, it's 1273 01:42:03,050 --> 01:42:09,710 very, very refreshing to see so many people here passionate about a topic, usually we don't have 1274 01:42:09,710 --> 01:42:15,750 anyone here, and it's great to see you not only here, but the fact that you were brave enough 1275 01:42:15,750 --> 01:42:24,210 to come up and speak, you didn't just say words that were persuasive which you did, but you also 1276 01:42:24,210 --> 01:42:31,830 educated us in ways that all these experts hadn't educated us. So I just really appreciated and 1277 01:42:31,830 --> 01:42:34,690 and encourage you to do that for topics like this 1278 01:42:34,690 --> 01:42:36,750 that you are very concerned about. 1279 01:42:37,310 --> 01:42:39,930 And I would encourage other groups to do the same. 1280 01:42:40,690 --> 01:42:47,090 What I like most about this project 1281 01:42:47,090 --> 01:42:52,110 is that our residents will have jobs. 1282 01:42:52,410 --> 01:42:54,830 That it's jobs, it's revenue, generating, 1283 01:42:56,010 --> 01:43:00,130 and also my favorite thing besides the jobs, which is huge, 1284 01:43:00,130 --> 01:43:01,870 is the design. 1285 01:43:02,010 --> 01:43:03,450 I really like the design. 1286 01:43:03,650 --> 01:43:10,290 I like the fact that the applicant takes pride in the architecture, and didn't just give 1287 01:43:10,290 --> 01:43:18,230 us a square box or a rectangle that is especially with it being something that people will 1288 01:43:18,230 --> 01:43:19,910 see when they come off of the bridge. 1289 01:43:20,170 --> 01:43:28,910 I really like that design that water sort of design that they have on the, I think that's 1290 01:43:28,910 --> 01:43:35,530 third, three story building. So thank you for that. When this project, when we had a 1291 01:43:35,530 --> 01:43:40,130 work session back in November, I supported the project. I just wanted to get more money 1292 01:43:40,130 --> 01:43:46,910 for Hayward. And I think Hayward deserves the best. I think Hayward deserves to have all 1293 01:43:46,910 --> 01:43:52,630 the public benefits that we could possibly get. And so that's why I've been pushing for that. 1294 01:43:52,850 --> 01:43:58,410 But I was in support of the project in November. I'm supportive of the project today. And you guys 1295 01:43:58,410 --> 01:44:01,890 being here just as made me even more excited about it. 1296 01:44:02,230 --> 01:44:03,030 Thank you. 1297 01:44:04,310 --> 01:44:05,590 Thank you, Commissioner Lowe. 1298 01:44:05,670 --> 01:44:06,710 Commissioner Stephens. 1299 01:44:09,580 --> 01:44:10,140 Thank you. 1300 01:44:10,760 --> 01:44:13,220 So first off, thank you, Stacks, for being here. 1301 01:44:13,240 --> 01:44:14,860 Again, this is an awesome project. 1302 01:44:15,120 --> 01:44:18,700 I'm so glad you chose Hayward to make this your home. 1303 01:44:19,020 --> 01:44:23,880 And I feel a little bad that all you folks 1304 01:44:23,880 --> 01:44:25,920 have to be here to advocate for this project. 1305 01:44:26,980 --> 01:44:27,500 I agree. 1306 01:44:27,740 --> 01:44:30,840 It's nice to have people here, but this shouldn't be 1307 01:44:30,840 --> 01:44:34,500 you should be your advocating. This should be a no brain or this should be stamped approved, 1308 01:44:35,040 --> 01:44:39,720 right, there should be, there shouldn't be even an issue with this. I don't think the policy 1309 01:44:39,720 --> 01:44:45,800 makers are understand that there is like an AI race right now and it's really about the economic 1310 01:44:45,800 --> 01:44:53,540 interest of the country and us as individuals. And hyper scale data centers like this make this 1311 01:44:53,540 --> 01:44:59,520 like realistically possible. Hyper scale data center needs two things, cheap power, or really cheap 1312 01:44:59,520 --> 01:44:59,820 hour. 1313 01:45:00,110 --> 01:45:08,790 And space. I don't know why they chose Hayward. I can think of a lot of other places the United States. It make a heck of a lot better space, but thank you for being here. 1314 01:45:09,610 --> 01:45:19,090 I feel frustrated that there is any payment made for a special benefit. I think that sets a really bad precedent. 1315 01:45:19,470 --> 01:45:29,930 I mean, we want the best, the highest quality data center equipment located in the San Francisco Bay Area that provides us the interest to support our future. 1316 01:45:30,110 --> 01:45:43,850 And $2 million is too much to spend given all the other benefits that are coming here, and I think there needs to be a realistic discussion at the state level about how much power is actually consumed by a 50-megawatt data center. 1317 01:45:44,310 --> 01:45:49,970 It's laughable to think that this is going to be supported by any type of renewable energy. 1318 01:45:50,470 --> 01:46:00,090 I mean, that's not realistic unless the state and the country get on the ball and come up with a plan here really quickly because there's a lot of other places in the world that are surpassing this country. 1319 01:46:00,090 --> 01:46:06,830 So thank you for being here. I fully support this. I'd like to make a motion to approve this this item. 1320 01:46:10,500 --> 01:46:10,940 Second. 1321 01:46:13,110 --> 01:46:16,270 So we have a motion and a second. Do we have other commissioner comments? 1322 01:46:17,730 --> 01:46:18,350 Mr. Goodbody. 1323 01:46:19,610 --> 01:46:28,950 Thank you chair. I also want to thank the staff center for coming out and working with our staff on on this very innovative project. I think it's going to be a wonderful gateway. 1324 01:46:28,950 --> 01:46:36,190 way. You know, as you come off the 92 to welcome people into, into Hayward Residence and Visitors, 1325 01:46:37,230 --> 01:46:44,210 alike to the development services. I also want to thank you for the robust work session 1326 01:46:44,210 --> 01:46:55,290 and everything that has gone into planning this to our citizens and our workers. You have shared 1327 01:46:55,290 --> 01:47:02,990 a journey about, that's common here in the Hayward and Common in California, and what struck 1328 01:47:02,990 --> 01:47:09,770 me is that while I am appreciative of the increase in the community benefit program, it struck 1329 01:47:09,770 --> 01:47:18,070 me that, you know, there is perhaps a missed opportunity in that I felt the, it wasn't an open 1330 01:47:18,070 --> 01:47:24,650 process, it wasn't necessarily, there was definitely some partners that were missing here, 1331 01:47:24,650 --> 01:47:30,750 I didn't see St. Rose, I didn't see Cal State Hayward, I didn't see Shabou, Fesco, some of the 1332 01:47:31,470 --> 01:47:40,090 organizations of our very city that provide lifelines to our community. And I, through 1333 01:47:40,090 --> 01:47:45,490 your conversations and through your public comments this evening, workforce development is very 1334 01:47:45,490 --> 01:47:52,930 much a part of our fabric here in Hayward. And I think the missed opportunity is a way that we 1335 01:47:52,930 --> 01:47:59,750 could work the city of Hayward and perhaps St. Rose or Cal State Hayward to some of our 1336 01:47:59,750 --> 01:48:07,410 education institutions to work with some of the future clients and snacks center on AI technology, 1337 01:48:07,890 --> 01:48:16,250 on getting our, you know, working with teachers and educators on AI curriculum or at St. Rose 1338 01:48:16,250 --> 01:48:22,070 with our medical professionals on how to use AI in medicine. 1339 01:48:22,750 --> 01:48:26,590 And so I am supportive of this project, 1340 01:48:26,810 --> 01:48:30,530 but I would like to see our policymakers take another look, 1341 01:48:30,810 --> 01:48:35,390 and maybe perhaps invite some of our other stakeholders 1342 01:48:35,390 --> 01:48:39,630 here in Hayward to build something that's sustainable 1343 01:48:39,630 --> 01:48:43,170 and can grow year after year after year, instead 1344 01:48:43,170 --> 01:48:45,810 of just a one-time funding opportunity. 1345 01:48:45,810 --> 01:48:53,290 I know that we have leverage with leverage funds from other sources and that's what I would 1346 01:48:53,290 --> 01:48:58,270 like to see with this community benefit program. I would like to see it grow. I would like 1347 01:48:58,270 --> 01:49:03,970 to see it expand and include more people to really grow our economy, not just for one budget 1348 01:49:03,970 --> 01:49:06,830 cycle or two budget cycles, but for many budget cycles. 1349 01:49:09,830 --> 01:49:11,990 Thank you Commissioner Myers. 1350 01:49:13,050 --> 01:49:14,010 Thank you, Chair. 1351 01:49:14,990 --> 01:49:15,870 Okay, a few comments. 1352 01:49:16,430 --> 01:49:21,190 First off, to all the brothers out there, one of my biggest fears is public speaking. 1353 01:49:22,010 --> 01:49:24,810 They probably have paid me to come up and do what you guys did. 1354 01:49:25,270 --> 01:49:26,570 And I really appreciate it. 1355 01:49:26,790 --> 01:49:29,170 I know it's not comfortable for a lot of you. 1356 01:49:29,450 --> 01:49:31,330 And you guys really rocked it. 1357 01:49:31,470 --> 01:49:32,750 So thank you for coming out, do that. 1358 01:49:32,750 --> 01:49:34,010 Apologize for the long meeting. 1359 01:49:34,390 --> 01:49:37,930 It doesn't happen all the time, but it's very nice of you guys to come out. 1360 01:49:37,930 --> 01:49:44,990 I'm a card-caring I.B.W. Most of my friends are 595 and I even work for Redwood City Electric 1361 01:49:44,990 --> 01:49:51,830 before it was Redwood Group. It's a very cool. Also, primarily wanted to thank Miles and Dave 1362 01:49:51,830 --> 01:49:59,430 and the whole stack center team for your collaboration with staff and with us and the neighbors. 1363 01:50:01,320 --> 01:50:15,320 I just think it's a phenomenal precedent to set for maybe future builds. So thank you for that. That's really excellent. And staff, obviously, amazing. Amazing work. I'm really excited about this project. 1364 01:50:15,320 --> 01:50:19,240 for the work it's bringing and also for what you guys will provide. 1365 01:50:19,860 --> 01:50:26,660 I appreciate the benefits package and the increased package that recently came out means a lot. 1366 01:50:28,760 --> 01:50:36,020 And also, putting the EV charges, I think that's really, really appreciated from my standpoint. 1367 01:50:37,220 --> 01:50:43,720 I will definitely be supporting this and I still believe that senior Blanton should get a race. 1368 01:50:44,060 --> 01:50:44,500 Thank you. 1369 01:50:46,130 --> 01:50:49,210 Thank you, Mr. Hammond. 1370 01:50:50,950 --> 01:50:59,030 Yes, I like this project and I'm excited to see all the benefits little bring to this community. 1371 01:51:00,270 --> 01:51:06,170 The benefits package is generous and will go a long way to help different aspects of the city. 1372 01:51:08,670 --> 01:51:15,710 The project will replace a property in the industrial park that's struggling with lease vacancies. 1373 01:51:16,330 --> 01:51:23,230 With a project will be a future benefit to the city of Hayward, technology, revenue, and community commitment. 1374 01:51:24,330 --> 01:51:31,850 In general, I'm pleased with the design and I appreciate the different architectural elements incorporated in the design as seen from every side. 1375 01:51:32,630 --> 01:51:43,790 I maybe I'm not 100% on board with the screening and I'd like to see potential mural opportunities for local artists in combination with the proposed screen wall as a condition of approval. 1376 01:51:44,970 --> 01:51:50,870 Being this, this will be the tallest building in the industrial park and that will be viewed from a distance from all directions. 1377 01:51:51,390 --> 01:51:58,350 I hope that every effort has been made in developing the final design that would create a building that the city of Haywood can be proud of. 1378 01:51:58,350 --> 01:52:02,330 It will serve as an example for future similar developments. 1379 01:52:03,610 --> 01:52:05,210 I'm very excited about this project. 1380 01:52:06,670 --> 01:52:07,330 Thank you. 1381 01:52:09,630 --> 01:52:10,770 Thank you. 1382 01:52:11,690 --> 01:52:15,010 So I just also wanted to echo Commissioner Lowe's comments, 1383 01:52:15,250 --> 01:52:17,710 thanking everyone who made a public comment. 1384 01:52:19,030 --> 01:52:22,170 Just the amount of information that we all got from you, 1385 01:52:22,250 --> 01:52:24,810 that was not the same information that we already received. 1386 01:52:24,810 --> 01:52:26,290 It's just very appreciate it. 1387 01:52:26,310 --> 01:52:27,550 Thank you all for being here. 1388 01:52:27,750 --> 01:52:32,250 It is so exciting to see people involved and engaged. 1389 01:52:33,050 --> 01:52:35,110 So yes, hope that we do see more of that. 1390 01:52:36,290 --> 01:52:39,110 And then, one is to thank the applicant. 1391 01:52:39,810 --> 01:52:43,370 I really do think that the amount of engagement 1392 01:52:43,370 --> 01:52:45,310 that I feel like we had with you and just 1393 01:52:45,310 --> 01:52:48,050 seeing the responsiveness that you had. 1394 01:52:48,330 --> 01:52:50,070 So the community and even the way that you answer 1395 01:52:50,070 --> 01:52:52,670 our questions, I just really appreciate that. 1396 01:52:52,710 --> 01:52:54,370 I do appreciate what I thought 1397 01:52:54,370 --> 01:52:59,010 was a significant increase in the public benefits package, even though I may have been one of 1398 01:52:59,010 --> 01:53:03,690 the people who suggested it even higher amount previously with that negotiation, right? 1399 01:53:04,210 --> 01:53:08,070 So I appreciate where you ended up with it and all the things that you added. 1400 01:53:08,830 --> 01:53:13,070 I appreciate your investment in Union Labor and then here in that's going to be 100% Union 1401 01:53:13,070 --> 01:53:14,530 Labor is really exciting. 1402 01:53:15,030 --> 01:53:19,910 I appreciate that you like name that the design will be on all sides of the building, not just 1403 01:53:19,910 --> 01:53:25,170 front facing portion. That's really great too. And then finally appreciation to staff 1404 01:53:25,170 --> 01:53:32,510 and senior planner. Senior planner, Blanton, especially for being here. And so I do 1405 01:53:32,510 --> 01:53:37,850 want to see if there could be maybe a friendly amendment to the motion. I do really want 1406 01:53:37,850 --> 01:53:43,370 to make sure that the Russell City Art Project is a part of that Gateway Marker project. 1407 01:53:43,470 --> 01:53:48,290 And so just adding in some language around that is a condition is that something that we 1408 01:53:48,290 --> 01:53:53,890 potentially do and so I'm asking you commissioner Stevens if that's something that you would be 1409 01:53:53,890 --> 01:54:01,630 I'm in a little too. I am with the caveat that I don't accept and appreciate the use of funds, 1410 01:54:01,810 --> 01:54:06,830 which is always clear that on the record I do not believe that staff should have to pay any special 1411 01:54:06,830 --> 01:54:17,450 benefit that I recognize your comment. Thank you. I appreciate that. Do we can we have a second on the 1412 01:54:21,090 --> 01:54:32,650 And then just to check, Commissioner Hammond, you actually mentioned something about a mural, were you suggesting that as a friendly amendment, as well, or you just, I'm saying that something that you usually want on the record. 1413 01:54:34,530 --> 01:54:37,710 So then that would be directed to. 1414 01:54:37,710 --> 01:54:39,410 Mr. Stephens, as well. 1415 01:54:40,710 --> 01:54:43,770 So I appreciate the intent of that. 1416 01:54:43,970 --> 01:54:46,150 I do not agree with that, because as I previously 1417 01:54:46,150 --> 01:54:49,530 said in November, that a data center 1418 01:54:49,530 --> 01:54:52,630 is part of the base infrastructure of our society 1419 01:54:53,150 --> 01:54:56,450 and the electrical generation is a key component of that. 1420 01:54:56,450 --> 01:54:58,810 I don't think it should be screened. 1421 01:54:59,230 --> 01:54:59,930 I understand. 1422 01:55:00,000 --> 01:55:07,060 I understand the benefit of any aesthetic quality of what you've created, but I fundamentally disagree 1423 01:55:07,060 --> 01:55:11,540 that it should be screened. I don't know how you handle that. I appreciate what your comment is, 1424 01:55:11,660 --> 01:55:20,640 but for this purpose and what we're trying to achieve and the fundamental basis that our society 1425 01:55:21,200 --> 01:55:28,120 and the economic success of all of us thrive on the future of AI. I think we have to get real about things 1426 01:55:28,120 --> 01:55:29,720 and we can't cover things up. 1427 01:55:31,380 --> 01:55:31,860 Thank you. 1428 01:55:31,860 --> 01:55:33,320 So I think how we've received from that 1429 01:55:33,320 --> 01:55:34,860 is that we do have a motion on the floor 1430 01:55:34,860 --> 01:55:38,420 with a second, so it stands as you have stated it 1431 01:55:38,420 --> 01:55:40,380 and we can vote and if the vote doesn't pass 1432 01:55:40,380 --> 01:55:42,100 and you could propose a new motion 1433 01:55:42,100 --> 01:55:44,180 that includes your piece. 1434 01:55:44,980 --> 01:55:49,140 So with that, Ms. Allen, could we have a vote on the motion? 1435 01:55:50,900 --> 01:55:52,860 Commissioner Franco Cawson, absent. 1436 01:55:53,480 --> 01:55:53,920 Commissioner's good. 1437 01:55:53,920 --> 01:55:57,820 Can we have more discussion? 1438 01:55:59,300 --> 01:56:00,300 What is the motion? 1439 01:56:02,860 --> 01:56:04,540 So the motion and amendment. 1440 01:56:05,620 --> 01:56:08,860 So commissioner Stevens originally just motion for approval. 1441 01:56:09,580 --> 01:56:13,640 The amendment that I gave was that I would like to see Russell city art project 1442 01:56:13,640 --> 01:56:17,100 included in the gateway marker funding specifically. 1443 01:56:18,020 --> 01:56:20,860 It's because it's something that I actually talked about in the last meeting 1444 01:56:20,860 --> 01:56:23,920 and so staff was unclear whether that is a part of it or not. 1445 01:56:23,920 --> 01:56:25,580 So I would definitely like to see it there. 1446 01:56:25,780 --> 01:56:27,380 So that is the motion on the floor. 1447 01:56:31,310 --> 01:56:32,590 Are we okay to vote or do? 1448 01:56:33,050 --> 01:56:33,570 Okay, sorry. 1449 01:56:33,730 --> 01:56:34,150 It's a commissioner. 1450 01:56:34,490 --> 01:56:34,990 I'm sorry. 1451 01:56:35,670 --> 01:56:36,130 Ms. Allen. 1452 01:56:36,430 --> 01:56:37,870 Could you please call roll. 1453 01:56:38,550 --> 01:56:40,350 Commissioner Franco Cawson, absent. 1454 01:56:41,170 --> 01:56:41,730 Commissioner Goodbody. 1455 01:56:42,510 --> 01:56:42,590 Yes. 1456 01:56:43,750 --> 01:56:44,430 Commissioner Hammond? 1457 01:56:45,270 --> 01:56:45,670 Yes. 1458 01:56:46,770 --> 01:56:47,510 Commissioner Low. 1459 01:56:48,030 --> 01:56:48,250 Yes. 1460 01:56:49,670 --> 01:56:50,430 Commissioner Myers. 1461 01:56:51,450 --> 01:56:51,810 Yes. 1462 01:56:51,870 --> 01:56:52,630 And one quick thing. 1463 01:56:52,790 --> 01:56:54,890 When I said brothers, I met brothers and sisters 1464 01:56:54,890 --> 01:56:56,570 because I remember there was a couple out there. 1465 01:56:56,710 --> 01:56:57,270 So thank you. 1466 01:56:58,410 --> 01:56:59,690 Commissioner Stevens? 1467 01:57:00,090 --> 01:57:00,250 Yes. 1468 01:57:01,070 --> 01:57:01,650 Chair Hardy. 1469 01:57:02,430 --> 01:57:02,550 Yes. 1470 01:57:03,190 --> 01:57:04,150 The motion passes. 1471 01:57:05,490 --> 01:57:06,270 Thank you all. 1472 01:57:11,690 --> 01:57:12,210 All right. 1473 01:57:24,580 --> 01:57:29,700 We would like to take like a one-minute break if that's okay before we move on. 1474 01:57:29,880 --> 01:57:30,220 Two minutes. 1475 01:57:31,240 --> 01:57:31,660 The break. 1476 01:57:32,340 --> 01:57:36,260 And we are moving on to agenda item number two. 1477 01:57:37,220 --> 01:57:41,360 For this item, the planning commission may make a recommendation to city council. 1478 01:57:42,320 --> 01:57:50,740 Item number 2, PH-25-020, it's a public hearing for a proposed zoning text amendment, conditional 1479 01:57:50,740 --> 01:57:56,300 use permit and site plan review, so allow drive-thru's and the air terminal commercial 1480 01:57:56,300 --> 01:58:02,040 district, and construction of a Starbucks coffee shop with drive-thru as part of a new 1481 01:58:02,040 --> 01:58:09,480 two-story mixed use development on a vacant portion of the property located at 22101, 1482 01:58:09,480 --> 01:58:15,240 This very embole of art adjacent to the home to sweets by Hilton Hotel and the finding that 1483 01:58:15,240 --> 01:58:20,520 the proposed zoning text amendment and mixed use development are exempt from the California 1484 01:58:20,520 --> 01:58:23,000 Environmental Quality Act or Sequa. 1485 01:58:23,640 --> 01:58:25,720 The staff have a presentation for this item. 1486 01:58:26,280 --> 01:58:26,960 I do, yes. 1487 01:58:26,980 --> 01:58:28,480 Thank you, Chair Hardy. 1488 01:58:29,060 --> 01:58:30,480 Steve Koalski, senior planner. 1489 01:58:31,840 --> 01:58:38,560 And this is an application for a small number of amendments to the zoning ordinance along with 1490 01:58:38,560 --> 01:58:43,140 a company and conditional use permit, which I'm going to say I'm going to refer to as a 1491 01:58:43,140 --> 01:58:48,820 CUP from here on out, and site plan review application for a new mixed use development 1492 01:58:48,820 --> 01:58:54,560 featuring a Starbucks drive-through coffee shop on a vacant portion of the property at 1493 01:58:54,560 --> 01:58:57,420 221-01 has barium boulevard. 1494 01:58:58,960 --> 01:59:04,780 All zoning ordinance text amendments require review by the Planning Commission and final 1495 01:59:04,780 --> 01:59:07,080 approval or denial by the city council. 1496 01:59:07,080 --> 01:59:19,920 The CUP and Site Plan review hinge upon the approval of the zoning text amendments, so if the amendments are not ultimately approved by the council, then the Starbucks drive through would not be allowed to be built. 1497 01:59:23,110 --> 01:59:35,550 In January 2019, the applicants who are here in the audience site obtained Site Plan review approval to construct the home to suites by Hilton Hotel on the subject property. 1498 01:59:35,550 --> 01:59:41,550 Along with a small multi-tenant commercial building where the mixed use development is now being proposed. 1499 01:59:42,310 --> 01:59:48,430 In early 2022, while getting ready to build the hotel project, the applicant informed staff 1500 01:59:48,430 --> 01:59:53,070 that the multi-tenant building was no longer economically viable at the site, 1501 01:59:53,510 --> 01:59:57,310 and asked if it could be replaced with a new Starbucks drive-through. 1502 01:59:57,310 --> 01:59:59,890 staff presented this idea to the council. 1503 02:00:00,000 --> 02:00:13,360 Economic Development Committee in April 2022, at which time the committee expressed support for the idea, but with the caveat that it'd be part of a mixed use development to make better, more efficient use of the site. 1504 02:00:14,440 --> 02:00:29,980 So, in March of 2024, the applicant submitted the application to amend the zoning ordinance, and obtain approval of a CUP and site plan review for a mixed use project with the Starbucks on the ground floor, and for small office suites on the site. 1505 02:00:33,970 --> 02:00:43,030 This is an aerial photo of the site as you can see the subject property is the part that is kind of highlighted in a yellow color outlined in red. 1506 02:00:43,770 --> 02:00:56,630 As you can see, when the applicant completed the construction of the hotel, he constructed all the necessary parking landscaping and utility connection improvements for the site in anticipation of its eventual development. 1507 02:00:56,630 --> 02:00:59,330 And this was all just done a couple of years, a couple of years ago. 1508 02:00:59,830 --> 02:01:07,990 The site is 1.76 acres in size and has the vehicular access via existing driveways along 1509 02:01:07,990 --> 02:01:10,450 hasperian Boulevard and SkyWest Drive. 1510 02:01:11,250 --> 02:01:17,650 It shares parking with both the hotel to the south, and this large rectangular white building 1511 02:01:17,650 --> 02:01:24,570 is the hotel that we're talking about, and the adjacent business park to the north via reciprocal 1512 02:01:24,570 --> 02:01:31,430 access and parking easements, and this kind of saw-toothed building to the north is the office 1513 02:01:31,430 --> 02:01:39,050 business park that we're talking about. The site is zoned air terminal commercial or ATC for 1514 02:01:39,050 --> 02:01:43,430 short and is designated retail and office commercial in the general plan. 1515 02:01:46,850 --> 02:01:48,810 The proposed mixed use project 1516 02:01:48,810 --> 02:01:57,870 features a 2,345 square foot Starbucks on the ground floor and a 1,912 square foot 1517 02:01:57,870 --> 02:02:04,090 second floor that would contain four small east office suites ranging in size from a little 1518 02:02:04,090 --> 02:02:11,330 less than 400 square feet to a little more than 400 square feet. 16 new additional parking spaces 1519 02:02:11,330 --> 02:02:17,810 would be built directly outside of this building. But as I said before the site also has access to 1520 02:02:17,810 --> 02:02:22,870 the other existing parking spaces around the hotel and the adjacent hotel and business 1521 02:02:22,870 --> 02:02:23,290 park. 1522 02:02:23,870 --> 02:02:30,350 Two outdoor patios will also be provided and furnished with Starbucks standard cafe tables, 1523 02:02:30,750 --> 02:02:36,170 chairs and sunshades for use by the cafe's customers and the building's office tenants. 1524 02:02:39,000 --> 02:02:42,900 This slide shows the proposed site plan layout. 1525 02:02:43,620 --> 02:02:50,220 Hesperium Boulevard is the street at the top of the graphic, while Sky West is the street at the bottom. 1526 02:02:50,980 --> 02:02:56,980 The entrance to the drive through Lane, rather is directly inside of the Sky West driveway. 1527 02:02:57,620 --> 02:02:59,060 You can see it here. 1528 02:03:00,660 --> 02:03:06,420 And this is to make sure that in a worst case scenario, if there were overflow, 1529 02:03:06,420 --> 02:03:12,780 So, cueing of vehicles, those vehicles would not spill out into the much, obviously, much 1530 02:03:12,780 --> 02:03:16,920 busier, hasperium, boulevard ride away and pose a traffic safety hazard. 1531 02:03:20,780 --> 02:03:25,920 This slide lists the small number of amendments to the zoning ordinance that need be made 1532 02:03:25,920 --> 02:03:31,320 to enable the proposed mixed use project with the Starbucks drive through to move forward. 1533 02:03:32,200 --> 02:03:35,060 There's five sections of the code that need to be amended. 1534 02:03:36,200 --> 02:03:39,980 The first one is just kind of a clean up item here. 1535 02:03:39,980 --> 02:03:41,180 I don't need to go into that. 1536 02:03:41,380 --> 02:03:43,560 But the second one is that is one of the key ones. 1537 02:03:44,160 --> 02:03:47,040 It's an amendment to the list of permitted uses 1538 02:03:47,040 --> 02:03:49,720 in the ATC zoning district 1539 02:03:50,460 --> 02:03:53,900 to amend that the list to allow drive-through restaurants 1540 02:03:53,900 --> 02:03:57,060 and coffee shops like Starbucks and Peats. 1541 02:03:59,600 --> 02:04:03,520 With a drive-through subject to approval of a conditional use permit, 1542 02:04:03,520 --> 02:04:06,920 which would be an approval that would require planned commission review. 1543 02:04:08,280 --> 02:04:15,060 And then the other three are amendments to the general regulations governing all drive through restaurants throughout the city. 1544 02:04:15,660 --> 02:04:19,660 And I don't need to go and these are all described in detail in your staff reports. 1545 02:04:22,050 --> 02:04:31,490 Staff reviewed the proposal for conformance to the general plan and for compliance with the applicable standards for a new mixed use project with the drive through 1546 02:04:31,490 --> 02:04:42,410 and found that it complies with the standards of the zoning ordinance and is consistent with a number of goals and policies of the land use and economic development elements of the general plan. 1547 02:04:43,390 --> 02:04:51,810 Again, I won't read each of these verbatim here on the slide, but here are four goals and policies which the proposal does conform to. 1548 02:04:53,120 --> 02:04:59,760 So, finally, if the Planning Commission agrees with staff and supports the project, then staff 1549 02:04:59,760 --> 02:04:59,960 wrecked. 1550 02:05:00,000 --> 02:05:16,380 Commence it forward the proposed text amendments and accompanying CUP and site plan review to the city council with a recommendation for approval, based on the findings in attachment to your staff reports and subject to the conditions in attachment three. 1551 02:05:16,960 --> 02:05:29,920 If the commission does not wish to support this project, which is an option available to you, then it can forward the matter to the council with a recommendation for denial instead and direct staff to prepare recommended findings. 1552 02:05:30,000 --> 02:05:34,000 for that denial. And that concludes staff's presentation. Thank you. 1553 02:05:35,500 --> 02:05:45,920 Thank you senior planner Kowalski. So at this time we will actually, is there a presentation from the developer the applicant for this project? 1554 02:05:46,840 --> 02:05:52,340 I believe the developer is just here to answer any questions that the commission may have. 1555 02:05:52,460 --> 02:05:53,760 I don't think has a presentation prepared. 1556 02:05:54,760 --> 02:05:56,060 Okay. Thank you for being here. 1557 02:05:56,660 --> 02:06:05,320 Okay, so at this time we'll open it up for our commissioner questions, do any commissioners have questions? 1558 02:06:07,730 --> 02:06:08,390 Commissioner Hammond? 1559 02:06:11,500 --> 02:06:12,020 Yes. 1560 02:06:14,380 --> 02:06:19,220 Can this building be used for another type of business that needs to drive through in the future? 1561 02:06:19,560 --> 02:06:22,360 And will they also need to apply for a conditionally use permit? 1562 02:06:23,620 --> 02:06:24,800 That's an easy one. 1563 02:06:24,800 --> 02:06:31,420 Once the conditional use permit is approved for a drive-through, whether it's a Starbucks or a McDonald's or a Taco Bell, 1564 02:06:32,940 --> 02:06:41,960 if the Starbucks were to close down after a year later after it's constructed, and a McDonald's asked to move in, they would be able to move in. 1565 02:06:42,220 --> 02:06:49,480 There is a sunset period of six months for another drive-through operator to move into the space. 1566 02:06:49,480 --> 02:06:56,720 If more than six months elapsed, then that McDonald's or that Taco Bell would have to re-apply for a new conditional use permit. 1567 02:06:57,140 --> 02:06:58,200 Well, you thank you. 1568 02:06:58,580 --> 02:07:05,420 On the zoning map attachment five, how many of the nine ATC parcels are considering a drive through at this time? 1569 02:07:07,160 --> 02:07:07,260 No. 1570 02:07:08,260 --> 02:07:18,300 And some of those parcels are probably two that would be capable of accommodating a new drive through that's built from the ground up. 1571 02:07:18,300 --> 02:07:23,620 but they're all occupied by existing buildings so something would have to be demolished, 1572 02:07:23,880 --> 02:07:28,140 some parking spaces would have to be removed and replaced. So there's not, 1573 02:07:28,200 --> 02:07:34,800 none of those lots are vacant and ready for a corporation like McDonald's or a talk about 1574 02:07:34,800 --> 02:07:39,880 them to move on to them. Okay, and then would each one of those parcels be required to 1575 02:07:39,880 --> 02:07:45,220 attend its own conditionly use permit for a drive-through or would this be, if approval tonight 1576 02:07:45,220 --> 02:07:49,340 would this be a blanket approval for all future ATC parcels? 1577 02:07:50,020 --> 02:07:55,740 No. This approval is changing the rules for those parcels. It's only approving. It would only 1578 02:07:56,360 --> 02:08:02,380 approve a drive through at this property next to the home to sweet hotel. If any other corporations 1579 02:08:02,380 --> 02:08:07,980 wanted to try to build a drive through on those other parcels that are zoned ATC, they would have 1580 02:08:07,980 --> 02:08:12,400 to come back. We would have to take them back before you further own conditional use permits. 1581 02:08:15,220 --> 02:08:21,360 of the 10% plus tax at the city charges, what does the tax revenue percentage going directly 1582 02:08:21,360 --> 02:08:29,400 the city of Hayward? Economic development director Paul Nguyen, it's probably best suited to 1583 02:08:29,400 --> 02:08:35,120 you. I think I'm kind of quoting you for the previous. Hi. Good evening. Commissioner Paul Nguyen, 1584 02:08:35,300 --> 02:08:40,240 Chief Economic Development Officer. So I understand the question is of the sales tax that a consumer 1585 02:08:40,240 --> 02:08:46,500 pays at a business in here or this use what percent of that goes to the Hayward General Fund? 1586 02:08:46,880 --> 02:08:51,460 Yes. About 1 percent of the sales tax that you pay as a consumer when purchasing a good 1587 02:08:51,460 --> 02:08:57,160 or having a transaction in Hayward goes to the General Fund. So who's the big beneficiary? 1588 02:08:57,680 --> 02:09:02,440 Well, it's a pretty complicated formula, but the majority of it is state sales tax, so the states get 1589 02:09:02,440 --> 02:09:07,720 their cut and then there's an apartment portion of a formula where that dollar, where that 10 percent 1590 02:09:07,720 --> 02:09:13,720 10.75% tax gets dvd up from the state to the counties and then to the cities. 1591 02:09:14,660 --> 02:09:15,220 Thank you. 1592 02:09:18,740 --> 02:09:24,700 Then what is the maximum I can see for the office spaces on the second floor and with this 1593 02:09:24,700 --> 02:09:29,820 impact parking or pedestrian traffic for employees or visitors visiting the office spaces? 1594 02:09:32,440 --> 02:09:38,300 I don't know the answer to the question, is the maximum occupancy of an office space? 1595 02:09:38,300 --> 02:09:48,680 But we did do a parking analysis to make sure that there is sufficient parking for the parking requirement for an office is one for every 200 square feet. 1596 02:09:49,120 --> 02:09:52,620 And so each of those offices is about 400 square feet. 1597 02:09:52,940 --> 02:09:56,900 So if you do the math they need a little less than 10 parking spaces for the office. 1598 02:09:57,160 --> 02:09:59,800 But there's a sea of parking around the hotel. 1599 02:10:00,000 --> 02:10:10,740 And the business park that is largely available nearly all the time. And this property would have the rights to use that parking. 1600 02:10:11,620 --> 02:10:19,020 Okay. Are any of these office spaces exclusive to Starbucks activities? Are there going to be Starbucks offices? Or are these going to be these to? 1601 02:10:19,840 --> 02:10:25,440 No, I perhaps the developer is better equipped to answer that question, but I don't believe so. 1602 02:10:25,440 --> 02:10:30,260 These are just going to be leaseable, small spaces, probably flex spaces, I'm not sure. 1603 02:10:30,940 --> 02:10:36,640 Jay, do you want to address the commissioner's question about the office spaces? 1604 02:10:45,060 --> 02:10:46,340 Jay push the green button, yes please. 1605 02:10:46,720 --> 02:10:47,280 Thank you. 1606 02:10:47,440 --> 02:10:48,220 Good afternoon. 1607 02:10:49,000 --> 02:10:50,620 All the members of the Blowing Commission. 1608 02:10:51,880 --> 02:10:59,300 I made me Javansai and we are the part of the developer ownership of this site development with the Hilton Hotel. 1609 02:10:59,300 --> 02:11:09,840 And as you know that this is a complimentary to my hotel also, we can have the more gas service. 1610 02:11:10,240 --> 02:11:17,280 We can bring more people from the San Mateo side or these by adding the coffee in our parcel. 1611 02:11:18,500 --> 02:11:24,100 And regarding the parking, I think that is the question, right? 1612 02:11:24,100 --> 02:11:31,700 Well, I guess the question is the office faces up above are these going to be used for star 1613 02:11:31,700 --> 02:11:32,500 buck? 1614 02:11:32,780 --> 02:11:39,260 Oh no, obviously for the other tenant, we have already negotiating the lease with them, 1615 02:11:39,440 --> 02:11:44,820 but once in the report we will sign the lease on that, so it is not for the Starbucks. 1616 02:11:46,540 --> 02:11:52,320 Okay, so another question, another question on the condition of approval number 11 for a separate 1617 02:11:52,320 --> 02:11:54,800 building permit should be required for all signage. 1618 02:11:55,440 --> 02:11:59,140 Well, these spaces will they get their own signage? 1619 02:11:59,700 --> 02:12:03,700 I didn't see anything on the drawings that would advertise their business 1620 02:12:05,120 --> 02:12:05,680 or... 1621 02:12:05,680 --> 02:12:11,100 No, we will not allow them to put the signage on our... on this person. 1622 02:12:11,880 --> 02:12:13,320 So they wouldn't be able to advertise their business. 1623 02:12:14,840 --> 02:12:15,180 Okay. 1624 02:12:18,120 --> 02:12:25,180 And then the condition of approval number 28, the trash and closers, they were required to 1625 02:12:25,180 --> 02:12:32,260 be self-contained with a sanitary sewer connection, but the approved clean-up method includes 1626 02:12:32,260 --> 02:12:40,780 a dry clean-up method with no hose bib, I'm guessing that's so you can't wash the trash. 1627 02:12:40,780 --> 02:12:45,440 that's correct. That's more of a question for us over here in staff. And that is correct. 1628 02:12:45,500 --> 02:12:51,480 That's a clean water regulation nowadays. And back in the old days people were just washed 1629 02:12:51,480 --> 02:12:57,300 and then the leechate from the dumpsters would seat down into that and then it ends up in, 1630 02:12:57,300 --> 02:13:01,660 you know, also in the internet. Yeah, I think we all kind of know. Inclosure is getting kind of 1631 02:13:01,660 --> 02:13:07,360 gritty and grimy. How is it? I'm just curious how you're going to clean that without 1632 02:13:07,360 --> 02:13:15,260 but given some mental extra washing, I don't actually know that condition is a standard condition 1633 02:13:15,260 --> 02:13:20,380 from our environmental services division, but it's, everybody has to do it nowadays, 1634 02:13:20,720 --> 02:13:24,240 not just here in Hayward, but all throughout the Bay Area, probably throughout the state of 1635 02:13:24,240 --> 02:13:24,300 California. 1636 02:13:26,020 --> 02:13:31,840 Okay, just say that we can reach out to an inspector for inquiries, just curious how you might 1637 02:13:31,840 --> 02:13:38,280 to clean that. And then it's said in the conditional approval number 36 all businesses are required 1638 02:13:38,280 --> 02:13:45,540 to arrange for separate collection of recyclables in organics. Does this mean that each business 1639 02:13:45,540 --> 02:13:49,980 will need to secure their own trash service? Or does this mean that each business must comply 1640 02:13:49,980 --> 02:13:57,560 with the three-way separation? The latter. So each little office will have to have its own 1641 02:13:57,560 --> 02:14:01,820 garbage can recycling bin and green waste bin. And then of course Starbucks which generates 1642 02:14:01,820 --> 02:14:07,640 a great deal of organic waste and, but they all use on the same trash enclosure. 1643 02:14:08,460 --> 02:14:11,400 Yeah, they'll still, they'll share the same trash enclosure, so they'll have to be some 1644 02:14:11,400 --> 02:14:16,360 large dumpsters, but each business has to have its own three-can stream like you see here 1645 02:14:16,360 --> 02:14:17,720 in City Hall at the common areas. 1646 02:14:18,780 --> 02:14:25,620 And then, for the conditional proof, for the hours of operation, it says that the hours of operation 1647 02:14:25,620 --> 02:14:33,660 can be between 6.30 a.m. in 11 p.m. a weekdays and 7 to 1 a.m. on weekends. What are the proposed 1648 02:14:33,660 --> 02:14:34,880 hours for this establishment? 1649 02:14:38,260 --> 02:14:40,220 Jay, would you like to answer that? I'm not sure what the 1650 02:14:40,220 --> 02:14:42,440 Starbucks is saying. 1651 02:14:42,800 --> 02:14:52,820 So, requirement of the tenant and the leases, we proposed these timings on that and the other 1652 02:14:52,820 --> 02:14:58,940 mainly business working time to be accommodated them. 1653 02:14:59,520 --> 02:14:59,980 So if I want to... 1654 02:15:00,000 --> 02:15:04,120 We're going to get a drive-through cup of coffee at 11 o'clock at night, would I be able to? 1655 02:15:04,140 --> 02:15:05,920 Mr. Speaker. 1656 02:15:05,920 --> 02:15:07,640 And how late would I be able to get a cup of coffee? 1657 02:15:11,570 --> 02:15:15,730 I think when Jay is saying here is that I'm sorry. I'm our key to be an architect. 1658 02:15:18,810 --> 02:15:22,830 Lieutenant themselves, Starbucks will probably dictate, you know, the hours of operation. 1659 02:15:23,790 --> 02:15:26,310 You know, it's going to be least to Starbucks, right? 1660 02:15:27,010 --> 02:15:32,210 I just was wondering if it's going to be open later tonight or early in the morning. 1661 02:15:32,330 --> 02:15:39,430 I think that's really up to the franchise e Starbucks, what they're going to actually the 1662 02:15:39,430 --> 02:15:41,750 hours of operation, but I can't see Starbucks open. 1663 02:15:42,210 --> 02:15:43,090 There aren't too many of them open. 1664 02:15:43,310 --> 02:15:44,310 There's a little bit of a clock at night. 1665 02:15:45,710 --> 02:15:47,310 It's a drive through. 1666 02:15:48,390 --> 02:15:50,570 It might serve those people. 1667 02:15:50,930 --> 02:15:51,430 Possibly. 1668 02:15:51,950 --> 02:15:56,870 Yeah, there is the hotel there, the hotel, the good thing about the hotel is that it has the 1669 02:15:56,870 --> 02:16:04,930 extra reserve parking, so during the daytime where Starbucks is popular, the hotel has a 1670 02:16:04,930 --> 02:16:10,170 sea of empty parking spaces, so there's plenty of parking, same thing for the office spaces on 1671 02:16:10,170 --> 02:16:16,910 the second floor, I think Jay has one tenant, even though it's divided up into four spaces, 1672 02:16:16,910 --> 02:16:22,830 it's my understanding, but there's excess parking during the daytime office spaces used, 1673 02:16:22,830 --> 02:16:27,650 parking in the parking lot when the most hotel guests are gone. So there shouldn't be an issue 1674 02:16:27,650 --> 02:16:33,290 with parking and as far as the hours of operation for the office space usually even those are 1675 02:16:33,290 --> 02:16:39,650 based on the tenant that's occupying the space of what they may occupy there to meet the office 1676 02:16:39,650 --> 02:16:44,850 spaces open 24 hours, but maybe this might be, I don't know. Sure, no, I realize that for the office 1677 02:16:44,850 --> 02:16:48,990 I guess I'm more concerned about with hours I can get a cup of coffee. 1678 02:16:49,410 --> 02:16:56,430 Being in a main corridor, people are going to be wanting their coffee early in the morning. 1679 02:16:57,170 --> 02:17:04,330 And this certainly offers that opportunity for people to get a cup of coffee early in the morning or late at night. 1680 02:17:04,510 --> 02:17:10,010 If they close up at five o'clock, it seems like it would be. 1681 02:17:12,250 --> 02:17:17,230 I believe if it's profitable for them, they'll be open, you know, and that's really the key here. 1682 02:17:17,410 --> 02:17:21,410 And if the demographics dictate to be open and five in the morning, for instance, 1683 02:17:21,550 --> 02:17:23,350 they'll probably be open and five in the morning. 1684 02:17:24,230 --> 02:17:32,390 Okay, but because, again, with the condition of approval, it does say that the hours should be considered between 630 and 11. 1685 02:17:33,610 --> 02:17:36,830 So we make that's what's already written in there. 1686 02:17:37,130 --> 02:17:38,550 That's what we're going to comply by. 1687 02:17:38,550 --> 02:17:39,270 Okay. 1688 02:17:40,750 --> 02:17:43,030 Anyway, that's my questions. 1689 02:17:43,330 --> 02:17:44,090 Thank you. 1690 02:17:45,530 --> 02:17:46,090 Thank you. 1691 02:17:46,230 --> 02:17:47,250 Are there other commissioner? 1692 02:17:47,470 --> 02:17:48,410 Commissioner Myers. 1693 02:17:49,490 --> 02:17:50,230 Thank you, chair. 1694 02:17:50,410 --> 02:17:51,250 Thank you. 1695 02:17:51,510 --> 02:17:51,630 Staff. 1696 02:17:54,510 --> 02:17:56,830 So, a few questions. 1697 02:17:57,270 --> 02:17:58,690 Maybe for staff first. 1698 02:17:59,170 --> 02:18:02,030 I think I read that the adjacent street. 1699 02:18:02,050 --> 02:18:02,750 I believe Southwest. 1700 02:18:03,550 --> 02:18:05,750 We were going to change that with no parking signs. 1701 02:18:06,150 --> 02:18:07,910 Am I correct in that? 1702 02:18:08,690 --> 02:18:09,070 Yes. 1703 02:18:09,070 --> 02:18:13,730 And that was a mitigation measure that came out of the traffic study. 1704 02:18:14,930 --> 02:18:19,850 As you know, Starbucks drives you can get pretty crowded at morning rush hour, typically 1705 02:18:19,850 --> 02:18:22,230 when everybody wants to get their coffee on the way to work. 1706 02:18:22,850 --> 02:18:29,470 And what the traffic study recommended was to prevent people from just backing out on the 1707 02:18:29,470 --> 02:18:35,590 sky west drive to red curb, like something like 100, I forget what it is exactly, but maybe 1708 02:18:35,590 --> 02:18:43,410 But a big segment of curb right before the entrance driveway from SkyWest into the drive-through site. 1709 02:18:43,910 --> 02:18:47,950 So that people won't just wait on SkyWest drive for their turn to enter the queue. 1710 02:18:48,450 --> 02:18:52,130 Now that means that the queueing is going to have to occur within the site. 1711 02:18:52,310 --> 02:18:56,470 But there's a lot of drive-iles here there everywhere kind of around the back of the hotel. 1712 02:18:56,830 --> 02:18:59,690 There's like a fire lane separating the hotel from the Starbucks. 1713 02:18:59,690 --> 02:19:05,250 If worst case scenario, there's, you know, dozens of cars waiting to, their turn to get in 1714 02:19:05,250 --> 02:19:09,690 that drive, they're going to have to negotiate it within the property. 1715 02:19:10,430 --> 02:19:18,950 That's the reason for that no parking signage and red curving along that segment of Skyways 1716 02:19:18,950 --> 02:19:20,030 drive right before the driveway. 1717 02:19:21,470 --> 02:19:21,990 Thank you. 1718 02:19:22,690 --> 02:19:26,530 It appears like there's not a heck of a lot of traffic there, there's a lot of space there. 1719 02:19:26,530 --> 02:19:34,270 I was concerned maybe the worry was having a long term parking people with RVs maybe that wasn't it at all 1720 02:19:34,270 --> 02:19:41,150 I was just to make sure that people don't wait on Sky West drive and block traffic. Okay, and I think even with the sign 1721 02:19:41,150 --> 02:19:46,930 They're probably not going to listen, but at least it's the sign, right. Okay, and then the other thing is so I use Google 1722 02:19:48,830 --> 02:19:55,750 Let me let me back up. So I am I've flown with friends for years and recently started flying 1723 02:19:55,750 --> 02:19:59,970 for my own license out of the Hayward Airport, and there's a thing called, you may have heard of it. 1724 02:20:00,000 --> 02:20:06,340 The $100 hamburger, which means it's just that's how much it costs to fly to a fun airport and get a burger. 1725 02:20:06,500 --> 02:20:23,200 I think nowadays, it's like a $300 burger. So it's kind of fun to think that we would have something for a destination, for our pilots to come to Hayward, and I don't foresee them coming for a Starbucks. 1726 02:20:23,200 --> 02:20:28,640 So what I did was I did Google Maps and this is a question. 1727 02:20:29,700 --> 02:20:35,560 I used Google Maps and I used their measuring tool and it's a little over I think 10,000 square feet that property. 1728 02:20:36,380 --> 02:20:47,520 Is it possible and does the code allow for a restaurant possibly to take up that space in the future if this was not approved? 1729 02:20:48,680 --> 02:20:48,920 Yes. 1730 02:20:48,920 --> 02:20:52,120 But a restaurant is a permitted use in the ATC district. 1731 02:20:52,880 --> 02:20:57,360 Full service sit down style restaurant would not require a CUB. 1732 02:20:58,620 --> 02:20:59,680 I was thinking the same thing. 1733 02:20:59,680 --> 02:21:01,620 And it appears that the parking would accommodate 1734 02:21:01,620 --> 02:21:03,760 that are ready based on the hotels pre-planning. 1735 02:21:03,980 --> 02:21:04,880 Is that right? 1736 02:21:05,780 --> 02:21:06,020 Okay. 1737 02:21:06,280 --> 02:21:06,560 Yes, sir. 1738 02:21:08,700 --> 02:21:14,700 Can I ask, what is of the Indian cuisine at the Winton corridor? 1739 02:21:15,680 --> 02:21:18,220 Is there a plan for a restaurant there? 1740 02:21:18,220 --> 02:21:19,880 What's happening there? 1741 02:21:21,200 --> 02:21:24,000 Director Nguyen, do you know that? 1742 02:21:24,120 --> 02:21:25,740 It's been shuddered for a while, hasn't it? 1743 02:21:26,020 --> 02:21:26,880 I haven't heard anything. 1744 02:21:27,000 --> 02:21:30,240 I don't know if planning director Lekirko has heard anything. 1745 02:21:30,900 --> 02:21:33,760 Paul would probably, Mr. Nguyen would be the one who would know, best. 1746 02:21:36,750 --> 02:21:40,690 I hadn't heard anything either, but so that's one site where this could, another drive 1747 02:21:40,690 --> 02:21:44,730 through could get built, but they'd probably have to tear down that building or do I 1748 02:21:44,730 --> 02:21:45,750 significant remodel of it. 1749 02:21:45,970 --> 02:21:47,070 Okay, that makes sense. 1750 02:21:47,070 --> 02:21:48,310 And then, 1751 02:21:51,000 --> 02:21:54,120 so do we know how many Starbucks we have in Hayward already? 1752 02:21:55,060 --> 02:21:57,740 I think you figured that question was going to come up? 1753 02:22:00,680 --> 02:22:01,620 I said I don't know. 1754 02:22:03,300 --> 02:22:07,500 So, I went on their website and I counted this would be the 16th. 1755 02:22:07,580 --> 02:22:08,580 Sound about right? 1756 02:22:11,210 --> 02:22:13,270 That sounds a little high, but that might be right. 1757 02:22:13,630 --> 02:22:14,910 They were the answer I don't know if Paul. 1758 02:22:14,930 --> 02:22:16,310 They were the ones with the Hayward address. 1759 02:22:17,310 --> 02:22:21,250 And then I went to the site and I did a map from my truck 1760 02:22:21,250 --> 02:22:28,790 And it showed, this would be the six, I mean, the ninth one within a two mile radius. 1761 02:22:29,790 --> 02:22:33,150 I'm just wondering, is there's a number of sounds about right, because that was my question. 1762 02:22:34,450 --> 02:22:40,370 I know there's like three or four within like a mile, in either direction on his 1763 02:22:40,370 --> 02:22:45,470 barium, boulevard. But just so the commission knows, staff is in the one going out and 1764 02:22:45,470 --> 02:22:51,070 trying to attract a Starbucks, right? Mr. Shaw is, he was approached by the Starbucks 1765 02:22:51,070 --> 02:22:58,150 corporation. It's his idea so to speak, but we're not going to discriminate against the Starbucks 1766 02:22:58,150 --> 02:23:04,070 versus McDonald's versus an in and out or something like that. Okay, very good. That was all my 1767 02:23:04,070 --> 02:23:05,430 question. Thank you. 1768 02:23:07,760 --> 02:23:15,200 Thank you for that presentation. Steve, I have a question for the applicant 1769 02:23:15,200 --> 02:23:22,380 following up on Commissioner Myers. So if a proof this would be the fourth drive through Starbucks 1770 02:23:22,380 --> 02:23:33,160 in Hayward, and at this location there are two Starbucks, two blocks to the north, so it 1771 02:23:33,160 --> 02:23:40,200 would be in the target, there's one target, and then there's one next to the Duggetia. 1772 02:23:41,240 --> 02:23:50,420 And then three blocks to the south of this location, there is one at the Walgreens, right 1773 02:23:50,420 --> 02:23:51,480 next to the Walgreens. 1774 02:23:51,480 --> 02:24:05,520 And so I wanted to ask the applicant what was the, what drove the decision to put a, a Starbucks, a Starbucks drive through rather than just a free standing restaurant. 1775 02:24:06,720 --> 02:24:17,880 Yeah, we went through this visibility and we are the owner of another five-quartered by 1776 02:24:17,880 --> 02:24:27,580 myriad and we have Starbucks inside the bistro and that helps helping the guest service 1777 02:24:27,580 --> 02:24:29,940 in good ways. 1778 02:24:29,940 --> 02:24:36,720 So we were thinking to put some coffee shop near the Hilton and we discussed with the Hilton 1779 02:24:36,720 --> 02:24:43,600 franchise and they have the support of our ideas, yeah, just go ahead with the Starbucks 1780 02:24:43,600 --> 02:24:49,880 and it will be the complementary supplementary to the to the Hilton hotel nearby. 1781 02:24:50,940 --> 02:24:58,260 So the parcel available right next to the Hilton and we approached the Starbucks and they 1782 02:24:58,260 --> 02:24:59,860 really accepted idea. 1783 02:25:08,700 --> 02:25:09,440 Thank 1784 02:25:11,680 --> 02:25:17,700 you. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Obama. Thank you chair. 1785 02:25:18,840 --> 02:25:19,680 I could have a moment. 1786 02:25:31,420 --> 02:25:33,460 So at one point, 1787 02:25:36,970 --> 02:25:41,650 we talked earlier about the parking issue. 1788 02:25:42,110 --> 02:25:47,910 The parking spaces and you were saying staff, this is to staff that there are plenty of parking. 1789 02:25:47,910 --> 02:25:56,530 I'm wondering though, I assume, just like the owner or applicant want to have lots of people 1790 02:25:56,530 --> 02:26:03,930 going to Starbucks and that business to thrive, they expect their hotels to also fill 1791 02:26:03,930 --> 02:26:04,390 up. 1792 02:26:04,670 --> 02:26:14,310 If the hotel is full, and the Starbucks is full, will there actually be the extra 40 parking 1793 02:26:14,310 --> 02:26:20,250 spaces at the hotel and business park if they're if the hotel is in use and the business 1794 02:26:20,250 --> 02:26:21,850 park is also in use. 1795 02:26:26,850 --> 02:26:28,890 I'm the architect you want me to answer that 1796 02:26:31,670 --> 02:26:33,450 if you'd like to. I'm looking 1797 02:26:33,450 --> 02:26:38,590 yeah I guess I can jump in there you know because I I design hotels across the United States 1798 02:26:38,590 --> 02:26:44,650 and we we always talk about parking you know from the 70s and 80s and you know when hotels 1799 02:26:45,250 --> 02:26:50,130 you have to look at the Drogaster leave it in the morning and during the daytime they're fairly 1800 02:26:50,130 --> 02:26:56,990 empty parking lots. So the idea is not to actually create more paved surface area in the world, 1801 02:26:57,130 --> 02:27:03,210 but actually to have a little less of it, right? So during the daytime, you look at your typical 1802 02:27:03,210 --> 02:27:07,750 office user. They're going to be there for me in the morning to five o'clock if you can get people 1803 02:27:07,750 --> 02:27:14,250 to come to an office nowadays right during that time period. And the Starbucks user, I would say from 1804 02:27:14,250 --> 02:27:20,030 earlier in the morning until the evening. But, you know, I think the key attribute to this particular 1805 02:27:20,030 --> 02:27:23,990 Starbucks that's different than, you know, the other Starbucks is that are down around the corner. 1806 02:27:24,510 --> 02:27:30,770 The one you had mentioned that was in the target. Not a lot of people want to stop to actually go 1807 02:27:30,770 --> 02:27:35,690 inside Target to grab a Starbucks as you probably know. The convenience of driving through with your 1808 02:27:35,690 --> 02:27:43,290 car is a huge convenience. So if you look at how many people are actually going to park to go into 1809 02:27:43,290 --> 02:27:48,830 Starbucks, you know, for a meeting space, it's probably not going to equate out to, I can't 1810 02:27:48,830 --> 02:27:54,410 see more than the parking that's already provided for the Starbucks by itself. That's in 1811 02:27:54,410 --> 02:28:00,270 addition to the hotel parking. So, because this is what they call a convenience Starbucks, 1812 02:28:01,030 --> 02:28:12,990 it's kind of a third portion or third type of Starbucks that they talk about where you have the 1813 02:28:12,990 --> 02:28:18,390 So, if the line is extra long, people will park and then leave, of course, right? 1814 02:28:19,130 --> 02:28:25,250 But, you know, when you look at the majority of traffic, time periods, and there was a 1815 02:28:25,250 --> 02:28:27,090 traffic state done, I believe, on this anyways. 1816 02:28:28,070 --> 02:28:33,630 But the parking that's already available in the parking lot will be absorbing amount of extra 1817 02:28:33,630 --> 02:28:35,630 parking during those hours. 1818 02:28:36,610 --> 02:28:40,950 So, thank you very much, transferring my question, I appreciate it. 1819 02:28:41,630 --> 02:28:52,190 In the CD draft minutes on page three, Mayor Salinas expressed concerns that changing the zoning 1820 02:28:53,750 --> 02:28:59,530 here would open the floodgates to too many drive-thrues where we do not want them in our city. 1821 02:29:00,310 --> 02:29:06,070 And my question to staff is, is there any reason why this should no longer be a concern for us? 1822 02:29:09,710 --> 02:29:23,930 So, as I mentioned in the staff report there, I think there are nine parcels total that have this zoning that we're talking about tonight, and they're all developed none of them are vacant right now. 1823 02:29:24,310 --> 02:29:32,170 So if somebody like McDonald's wanted to come in, they would have to tear down an existing building and start from scratch. 1824 02:29:32,170 --> 02:29:39,870 And we're well aware that a lot of the city leaders have expressed. 1825 02:29:40,390 --> 02:29:44,630 Concerning about the number of drive-thru's, we're just processing Mr. Shaw's application. 1826 02:29:45,430 --> 02:29:47,170 It seems... 1827 02:29:49,660 --> 02:29:51,220 What am I trying to say? 1828 02:29:52,880 --> 02:29:58,260 I guess it's kind of up to you guys if you feel that the community benefit is there to recommend 1829 02:29:58,260 --> 02:29:59,980 to prove all of these zoning text amendments are in. 1830 02:30:00,000 --> 02:30:14,200 Not all in the name of, you know, supporting another, another construction, another drive through and relaxing some zoning standards that might enable one or two more drive through sometime in the distant future to get built around the airport. 1831 02:30:15,060 --> 02:30:28,120 If I could just add onto that, I would just say, you know, that was a discussion that we had internally about the potential of maybe just creating a pathway more broadly with commercial districts, but that was not the direction that we received from CEDC. 1832 02:30:28,120 --> 02:30:35,120 We were trying to really tailor this request to this specific zoning district, which is very small. 1833 02:30:36,540 --> 02:30:41,240 So that way to your point, Commissioner, we're not proposing to broaden it. 1834 02:30:42,060 --> 02:30:50,300 And, you know, obviously if we're going to change that city wide, we will need some additional direction from city council on how they would like to approach that. 1835 02:30:50,300 --> 02:30:56,320 And I know we did make a couple of minor amendments to that several years ago when it was really intended to encourage 1836 02:30:56,320 --> 02:31:03,740 what you would typically find along auto thoroughfares, like 880, that's auto oriented, and so 1837 02:31:03,740 --> 02:31:08,780 a drive-through was completely appropriate, but a drive-through may not be appropriate in 1838 02:31:08,780 --> 02:31:13,360 downtown where we're trying to create more pedestrian environment. So again, it's trying 1839 02:31:13,360 --> 02:31:18,380 to take not only look at the policy, but also trying to understand why was the policy invented 1840 02:31:18,380 --> 02:31:22,380 in the first place or why were those prohibitions established in the first place. And 1841 02:31:22,380 --> 02:31:27,340 location off of his sparian. Obviously you have the airport there. You have a very number of very 1842 02:31:27,340 --> 02:31:33,760 low number of parcels that would be even, that would even qualify to do this. And even those 1843 02:31:33,760 --> 02:31:39,620 if one became available as Steve had pointed out, they would be subject to the same discretionary 1844 02:31:39,620 --> 02:31:43,440 of reprocess that this applicant would be going through in front of coming front of the commission. 1845 02:31:43,640 --> 02:31:48,600 And so you would have, ultimately, you would continue to have that discretion on a case by case 1846 02:31:48,600 --> 02:31:54,700 But we did have that conversation, and we thought that this was the best way to accommodate his 1847 02:31:54,700 --> 02:32:04,540 sparian, which also is a major thoroughfare through the community, as well as catering to some of the businesses and the air traffic that come in from the airport. 1848 02:32:09,350 --> 02:32:10,390 Thank you. 1849 02:32:11,690 --> 02:32:19,890 And then I noticed in the same report, the mayor said he would consider his position if the applicant built a second story with offices, 1850 02:32:19,890 --> 02:32:26,910 which the applicant has done and provide a rooftop seating and I didn't see that in the 1851 02:32:26,910 --> 02:32:32,570 plans. Is that in the plan somewhere? I don't believe that is there does need to be room for 1852 02:32:33,150 --> 02:32:37,910 solar panels on the rooftop and I think the building frankly is probably too small to accommodate 1853 02:32:37,910 --> 02:32:43,670 a rooftop deck but we do have the two nice and it's a nicely landscaped project if you look 1854 02:32:43,670 --> 02:32:48,110 at the landscape plans. There are going to be those two outdoor patio areas that are furnished 1855 02:32:48,110 --> 02:32:52,070 with cafe table and chair, but I don't think the roof top deck made it into the 1856 02:32:52,070 --> 02:32:52,330 plans. 1857 02:32:52,890 --> 02:32:55,410 Just wondering, because I didn't see it, I just wanted to know. 1858 02:32:55,470 --> 02:32:56,150 It's a good cop. 1859 02:32:56,450 --> 02:32:57,810 Just wanted to know. 1860 02:32:58,470 --> 02:33:10,210 And then does the planning commission have any BTO power, say so, or suggestability power 1861 02:33:10,210 --> 02:33:20,030 as it relates to the architecture of the Starbucks, wondering that, because I'm trying to 1862 02:33:20,030 --> 02:33:23,430 make sure I don't make a comment because I'm supposed to just ask questions. 1863 02:33:26,730 --> 02:33:32,370 But I guess that's my question because when I look at it and as I'm trying to evaluate 1864 02:33:32,370 --> 02:33:39,730 whether or not it creates a benefit to the city, that is one of the things that we generally 1865 02:33:39,730 --> 02:33:44,730 look at and there's no buddy here from Starbucks to talk about that. 1866 02:33:44,890 --> 02:33:47,970 I assume there's a reason for that and I just want to hear what that is. 1867 02:33:47,970 --> 02:34:03,050 I would just say is a recommendation to Council if you want to recommend further architectural enhancements that the Council consider those when they're reviewing the text amendment and the use permit which ultimately would be now pushed to them. 1868 02:34:03,130 --> 02:34:07,050 That could be something that would be made as part of your part of your recommendation. 1869 02:34:07,050 --> 02:34:07,850 Yeah, 1870 02:34:10,710 --> 02:34:24,330 this is a housing project, you guys are probably accustomed to not being able to say very much about the design of housing projects anymore, but this is different, you can definitely request our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our cultural improvements if you if you deem that. 1871 02:34:24,550 --> 02:34:26,370 That's very great. I will. 1872 02:34:27,350 --> 02:34:32,090 Um, I think it's the last thing I wanted to ask about was security. 1873 02:34:32,890 --> 02:34:36,990 Um, I wanted to find out from the applicant. 1874 02:34:36,990 --> 02:34:45,630 But if you know or staff, if you know what the security measures will be at this particular 1875 02:34:45,630 --> 02:34:46,250 Starbucks. 1876 02:34:46,250 --> 02:34:47,150 It 1877 02:34:52,340 --> 02:34:58,700 is present also, we have a hundred and thirty-one room hotel and we have twenty-four 1878 02:34:58,700 --> 02:34:59,740 why so and security? 1879 02:35:00,300 --> 02:35:13,000 In the parking area. So we have the full our in-house security people for all days and all hours. 1880 02:35:13,060 --> 02:35:20,240 Will Starbucks have their own security in addition, that's patrolling Starbucks as well, or will this be relying on your security? 1881 02:35:20,620 --> 02:35:21,400 Starbucks, actually. 1882 02:35:22,320 --> 02:35:24,680 And do you know anything more about their security? 1883 02:35:24,680 --> 02:35:54,140 Oh no, we don't require it, because our, for the hotel for the Hilton requirement, we are putting the, and we are also thinking to put the friends around and we are just discussing with their port authority and everybody to how much height we can do for the friends and that also we are thinking on that and planning to put the friends at around whole hotel and the Starbucks whole whole bus. 1884 02:35:54,760 --> 02:35:57,760 So the fence would go around the Starbucks and the hotel 1885 02:35:57,760 --> 02:36:00,740 And the Starbucks should be the part of that person 1886 02:36:00,740 --> 02:36:03,200 Where we will put the fence 1887 02:36:03,200 --> 02:36:06,960 So the fence would just go around your hotel 1888 02:36:06,960 --> 02:36:14,840 No, no, it would be a whole parcel parcel contained the hotel and the Starbucks vote. Oh, that's what I was asked. Okay, so the fence will go around 1889 02:36:14,840 --> 02:36:16,640 And what does the fence look like? 1890 02:36:18,320 --> 02:36:21,880 We are just planning and thinking to put the fence 1891 02:36:22,960 --> 02:36:24,980 with the dancers from the start of the box. 1892 02:36:25,920 --> 02:36:28,080 Oh, okay, thank you. 1893 02:36:29,540 --> 02:36:33,140 If I could just interject, a fence would have to be. 1894 02:36:33,280 --> 02:36:35,540 This is the first we've heard of any such fence. 1895 02:36:35,800 --> 02:36:38,140 So the plane would have to, in the building, 1896 02:36:38,360 --> 02:36:40,720 the vision would have to review that, the design of that fence. 1897 02:36:41,120 --> 02:36:42,640 So this is news to us. 1898 02:36:43,780 --> 02:36:46,460 But Mr. Shaw, did you understand, you, 1899 02:36:46,520 --> 02:36:49,660 you have your own private security around the hotel property? 1900 02:36:49,660 --> 02:36:53,200 Do they also extend their service to the Starbucks? 1901 02:36:54,220 --> 02:36:54,460 Yes. 1902 02:36:54,940 --> 02:36:57,360 We have our private security. 1903 02:36:57,980 --> 02:36:59,560 We will take care of the Starbucks also. 1904 02:36:59,740 --> 02:37:00,620 It's a one parcel. 1905 02:37:02,260 --> 02:37:02,300 Yeah. 1906 02:37:07,960 --> 02:37:09,400 Make sure I got all my questions. 1907 02:37:09,920 --> 02:37:11,060 I'm done. 1908 02:37:11,260 --> 02:37:11,720 Thank you again. 1909 02:37:11,860 --> 02:37:13,440 Thank you again for your presentation. 1910 02:37:16,950 --> 02:37:18,690 Yeah, there are commissioner questions. 1911 02:37:19,730 --> 02:37:22,270 I have just three. 1912 02:37:23,330 --> 02:37:32,430 Has Starbucks indicated that they're thinking about opening this location and closing one of those other ones that is very close by that is not a drive through? 1913 02:37:34,970 --> 02:37:40,130 I have not had any discussions with Starbucks representatives. I don't know if Mr. Shaw has or Paul. 1914 02:37:41,010 --> 02:37:41,750 Mr. Nguyen. 1915 02:37:42,490 --> 02:37:43,650 Thank you. 1916 02:37:47,390 --> 02:37:49,390 Good evening, Paul Cohen, Chief Economic Development Officer. 1917 02:37:50,410 --> 02:37:54,150 No, in fact, we've received a number of inquiries. 1918 02:37:54,370 --> 02:37:56,670 Starbucks is in a pretty aggressive growth mode, 1919 02:37:56,890 --> 02:38:00,170 and they're looking to open more and more given consumer demand. 1920 02:38:01,950 --> 02:38:02,870 Thank you. 1921 02:38:04,310 --> 02:38:08,590 Will the Starbucks have a say in what tenants are permitted 1922 02:38:09,450 --> 02:38:11,090 in the upstairs offices? 1923 02:38:11,230 --> 02:38:14,350 Is that totally going to be at the discretion of the applicant? 1924 02:38:15,820 --> 02:38:19,760 That would be the discretion of the, the lessy of the building. 1925 02:38:20,220 --> 02:38:32,800 The city owns the property, but the developer, whoever the landlord is, of those tenent office tenent spaces would, I don't think Starbucks would have, that's just between them. Sorry, we're not a party to that. 1926 02:38:35,920 --> 02:38:45,600 It does seem that this is a unique design, which was, I'm not aware of any other, like at least standalone Starbucks that have a drive through like this. 1927 02:38:45,600 --> 02:38:49,660 I think, of course, there's some that are just commercial storefronts that have something 1928 02:38:49,660 --> 02:38:50,200 above. 1929 02:38:50,760 --> 02:38:56,080 Are you all aware of a model like this, and just the types of tenants that may even want 1930 02:38:56,080 --> 02:38:57,360 to be above a drive through? 1931 02:38:57,560 --> 02:39:03,800 I imagine that could be an annoying thing, or just, is there been any research into that yet? 1932 02:39:04,120 --> 02:39:07,420 There hasn't, perhaps, the architect could attempt anything. 1933 02:39:07,420 --> 02:39:12,120 I think Mr. Shaw has a potential tenant already that wants to be in the above location 1934 02:39:12,120 --> 02:39:12,960 of all the Starbucks. 1935 02:39:12,960 --> 02:39:17,320 And I think it's really, when you really look at the square footage of it, it's a very 1936 02:39:17,320 --> 02:39:23,920 small, 1912 square feet, that's a very small tenant space, even as a single tenant. 1937 02:39:24,660 --> 02:39:30,460 To the best of my knowledge, I believe that the lease for that tenant space has nothing to do 1938 02:39:30,460 --> 02:39:32,980 with the Starbucks, the other individual tenants, right? 1939 02:39:34,900 --> 02:39:41,820 But I don't really see any multiple tenants going in there, because it would be too small, 1940 02:39:41,820 --> 02:39:48,780 the office we'd so, and I think Mr. Shaw had conveyed tonight even that he has a tenant 1941 02:39:48,780 --> 02:39:51,820 that he's in negotiations with with a full space home. 1942 02:39:53,580 --> 02:39:59,040 Yeah, Mr. Shaw would use mind-speaking to maybe that tenant, is it look like they're going to be 1943 02:39:59,040 --> 02:39:59,960 leasing that end. 1944 02:40:00,000 --> 02:40:03,200 Tire space, potentially, and then what kind of business it is? 1945 02:40:03,520 --> 02:40:09,020 No, he's all he sees, and they're separate in, and non-one, one-dominant. 1946 02:40:11,150 --> 02:40:15,350 Okay, and so it's just someone's personal use office space that they're considering. 1947 02:40:16,190 --> 02:40:18,150 Okay, thank you. 1948 02:40:19,370 --> 02:40:22,290 Not seeing any other commissioner questions. 1949 02:40:22,810 --> 02:40:25,350 Do we have any public comments on this item? 1950 02:40:26,870 --> 02:40:27,450 There are none. 1951 02:40:27,450 --> 02:40:29,490 Thank you. 1952 02:40:29,570 --> 02:40:33,950 We will close public comments, do any commissioners have comments? 1953 02:40:35,590 --> 02:40:36,130 Commissioner Goodbody. 1954 02:40:37,230 --> 02:40:37,550 Thank you, Chief. 1955 02:40:37,610 --> 02:40:41,010 This is actually a question for staff. 1956 02:40:42,310 --> 02:40:50,630 I'm concerned about the over the proximity of all these Starbucks near each other. 1957 02:40:50,690 --> 02:40:55,990 Does the commission have any way to recommend if it's going to be a coffee shop? 1958 02:40:55,990 --> 02:41:06,010 can we make a room recommendation that the applicant look at other coffee establishments like 1959 02:41:06,010 --> 02:41:13,290 peats or blue bottle or Dutch bros, which is popular with the younger crowd? 1960 02:41:14,910 --> 02:41:23,630 We don't really have the ability to select particular tenants, I think, as the applicant, 1961 02:41:23,630 --> 02:41:26,190 and I think is the architect pointed out. 1962 02:41:26,750 --> 02:41:30,390 The clarification I thought that he made was pretty accurate 1963 02:41:30,390 --> 02:41:32,550 in that there are other Starbucks nearby, 1964 02:41:33,070 --> 02:41:34,430 but they cater to different users. 1965 02:41:35,050 --> 02:41:36,110 And so if you're going into Target, 1966 02:41:36,210 --> 02:41:38,510 you would typically pick that up as you're going there. 1967 02:41:38,610 --> 02:41:42,270 But Starbucks like this with a drive-thru is mainly catering 1968 02:41:42,270 --> 02:41:44,330 to those that are in their car and passing by, 1969 02:41:44,490 --> 02:41:46,510 or maybe potentially that are staying at the hotel 1970 02:41:46,510 --> 02:41:49,730 and just want to walk a couple steps without having to get 1971 02:41:49,730 --> 02:41:53,050 in their car to drive down the street to get that cup of coffee. 1972 02:41:53,970 --> 02:42:01,870 So, you know, similar to a lot of businesses, obviously, but, yeah, I'd love to see Blue 1973 02:42:01,870 --> 02:42:06,590 Bottles, but I don't know that we have an option to pick and choose what tenants are. 1974 02:42:06,770 --> 02:42:10,810 I would also say to that what we're really evaluating, even though it's a coffee shop, 1975 02:42:10,910 --> 02:42:12,370 as we're looking at an individual use. 1976 02:42:13,030 --> 02:42:18,790 So, just as we're looking at a restaurant use, we don't, the planning commission and the 1977 02:42:18,790 --> 02:42:25,130 the ability to select what kind of restaurant, if it just falls into that category, it would 1978 02:42:25,130 --> 02:42:25,450 qualify. 1979 02:42:25,670 --> 02:42:30,490 In this case, it's a drive through, and so as Steve had pointed out, this could be specific 1980 02:42:30,490 --> 02:42:36,250 to drive through for a coffee shop, but if there's a, if this happened to close, and there 1981 02:42:36,250 --> 02:42:40,010 was another operator that wanted to go in there, an operator either a coffee shop or another 1982 02:42:40,010 --> 02:42:43,970 restaurant within six months, they could easily do that without having to come back, or 1983 02:42:43,970 --> 02:42:46,550 they would need to come back to the commission if it would be on that six month period. 1984 02:42:47,770 --> 02:42:53,510 My family has stayed at the home two suites and I will say that we had to get in a car 1985 02:42:53,510 --> 02:42:59,410 to go either to restaurant at Southland or a restaurant further down towards the San Lorenzo 1986 02:42:59,410 --> 02:43:05,990 area and it seems that a standalone restaurant would be a better use of the space next 1987 02:43:05,990 --> 02:43:12,590 to a next hotel and you have people coming from out of town. It's nice to just be able 1988 02:43:12,590 --> 02:43:18,230 for hotel room and go have dinner rather than getting your car and drive somewhere and go 1989 02:43:18,230 --> 02:43:18,930 to dinner. 1990 02:43:22,070 --> 02:43:22,650 Commissioner Myers. 1991 02:43:24,610 --> 02:43:25,070 Thank you, Chair. 1992 02:43:25,930 --> 02:43:29,070 Thank you for your presentation and for staff's work on this. 1993 02:43:29,430 --> 02:43:31,530 She's been able to apologize for my coughing. 1994 02:43:32,870 --> 02:43:38,090 So right now there's nothing there and what's proposed is mixed juice. 1995 02:43:38,350 --> 02:43:39,790 I think mixed juice is wonderful. 1996 02:43:40,650 --> 02:43:43,030 I'm a big advocate for mixed juice projects. 1997 02:43:43,030 --> 02:43:47,470 There's currently no real trees there, so we're gonna be adding trees. I think that's a positive and 1998 02:43:48,250 --> 02:43:49,690 Looking at the architectural 1999 02:43:50,550 --> 02:44:01,240 Layout and the design. I have to say I'm pretty impressed with the way it looks. I particularly like the layout and I know the city needs 2000 02:44:01,240 --> 02:44:04,520 Revenue or I know that this would help the city with revenue 2001 02:44:05,880 --> 02:44:08,180 with all that said I 2002 02:44:08,180 --> 02:44:10,080 look at it as 2003 02:44:10,080 --> 02:44:17,040 And analogous, if you're a single person in a home, a small home, and you're looking for a roommate, 2004 02:44:17,900 --> 02:44:23,320 you need that money to pay your rent. It would be great to have a tenant there for the income. 2005 02:44:23,800 --> 02:44:32,340 But what you do as a roommate is you really find the best use or the best person that would fit the characteristics of who you are, your environment, 2006 02:44:32,860 --> 02:44:35,840 and the same which should be said with the city as well. 2007 02:44:40,180 --> 02:44:48,640 With it's possibly being maybe the 16th Starbucks, I know that Starbucks in the past has had mass closings. 2008 02:44:49,160 --> 02:44:52,240 I would hate to have all of our eggs, that many eggs in one basket. 2009 02:44:53,780 --> 02:44:59,960 If they should have some mass closings, you know, who knows what's going to happen, then I foresee a potential. 2010 02:45:00,000 --> 02:45:07,980 I'm sure for boarded up buildings here and there. As I mentioned, the $300 hamburger, I think a restaurant 2011 02:45:07,980 --> 02:45:18,160 would better suit the airport, would also better suit the hotel. And based on the dimensions, it appears 2012 02:45:18,160 --> 02:45:24,380 that there's enough space. I know we don't have anybody wanting it right now, but that's like a roommate thing. 2013 02:45:24,860 --> 02:45:29,320 You know, I wouldn't jump at the first person offering to pay half my rent if they weren't a good fit. 2014 02:45:31,980 --> 02:45:37,380 I know, Starbucks has kind of a business plan of having a lot of Starbucks, and they claim 2015 02:45:37,380 --> 02:45:41,800 it's probably partially true that it helps with climate because you're not parking 2016 02:45:41,800 --> 02:45:43,760 in a bunch of places, you're in and out faster. 2017 02:45:44,360 --> 02:45:50,180 But I also think that they have a overall plan to stifle competition, and I know that for 2018 02:45:50,180 --> 02:45:52,600 our local businesses, I don't want to see that. 2019 02:45:53,500 --> 02:45:58,700 I do appreciate the design in the space, just I will not be supporting this today. 2020 02:45:59,340 --> 02:46:01,000 Thank you. 2021 02:46:01,700 --> 02:46:02,520 Commissioner Lowe. 2022 02:46:06,150 --> 02:46:08,270 16 Starbucks is a lot of Starbucks. 2023 02:46:08,970 --> 02:46:16,310 It's a lot of Starbucks and to have so many in such a short space, I know that one of our neighboring cities, 2024 02:46:17,290 --> 02:46:22,230 my daughter is saying the other day, a good lord that holds cities just one gigantic Starbucks. 2025 02:46:22,230 --> 02:46:29,850 And I would prefer that Hayward not become one gigantic Starbucks, that's just my personal 2026 02:46:29,850 --> 02:46:30,390 preferences. 2027 02:46:30,690 --> 02:46:38,050 Somebody who lives here and who pays taxes here, I prefer not to just be in a giant Starbucks. 2028 02:46:39,950 --> 02:46:46,030 And so when I look at the public benefit, I see I understand that people would prefer not 2029 02:46:46,030 --> 02:46:50,870 to get out of their cars and have that benefit of being able to drive up and I think that 2030 02:46:50,870 --> 02:46:58,050 a benefit for sure to be able to not get out of your car and just pull up and get your coffee 2031 02:46:58,050 --> 02:47:07,990 and go. I'm concerned though if it's enough of a value add to the city overall because to 2032 02:47:07,990 --> 02:47:16,170 me a value add to the city should be something fresh, new, different, exciting, something that 2033 02:47:16,170 --> 02:47:21,870 draws people. I don't see it as a draw. I just see it as anybody going to work. We'll 2034 02:47:21,870 --> 02:47:26,710 just stop there because it's convenient, which is very different than a draw to the city 2035 02:47:26,710 --> 02:47:35,290 or a value add to the city. I'm really not overwhelmingly excited about it, but I also don't hate 2036 02:47:35,290 --> 02:47:42,050 it. I get the point that people, some people will benefit from it. I just, I'm struggling with 2037 02:47:42,050 --> 02:47:45,330 whether or not there's enough value add to the city. 2038 02:47:46,270 --> 02:47:46,690 In addition, 2039 02:47:48,990 --> 02:47:49,770 I, unlike my colleague, 2040 02:47:49,830 --> 02:47:51,590 I actually do not like the design. 2041 02:47:51,770 --> 02:47:53,350 I think it looks like all the others. 2042 02:47:53,770 --> 02:47:56,350 There's nothing new about this one. 2043 02:47:56,690 --> 02:47:58,450 Like if there's so, I understand the newness 2044 02:47:58,450 --> 02:48:01,590 is that it's a drive through, but there's nothing new unique 2045 02:48:01,590 --> 02:48:05,110 about this one in this company has so much money. 2046 02:48:05,570 --> 02:48:08,610 They can bring something really new, unique, 2047 02:48:08,790 --> 02:48:11,330 and exciting to the city if they really want it to. 2048 02:48:12,110 --> 02:48:16,510 There's the Starbucks Reserve in Chicago that is gorgeous. 2049 02:48:16,970 --> 02:48:22,190 And I'm not talking about, I know we wouldn't build it on that scale here. 2050 02:48:22,910 --> 02:48:29,990 But gosh, it shows how, if a city really, let's say, 2051 02:48:30,170 --> 02:48:34,530 gently encourages Starbucks to make something unique, different, 2052 02:48:34,990 --> 02:48:39,570 something that's attractive, they will do it because they've done it. 2053 02:48:39,570 --> 02:48:51,030 And it worries me or kind of upsets me a little that I am more impressed with the architecture of a data center than I am with the architecture of the Starbucks. 2054 02:48:52,070 --> 02:49:00,730 So from my standpoint, I'm just not 100% convinced of the value add to the city. 2055 02:49:04,670 --> 02:49:06,070 Commissioner Stevens. 2056 02:49:08,500 --> 02:49:21,980 Thank you. So when when we started this exercise because there were some questions, I thought I would run a little AI test and I thought I'd ask my friends and AI about 2057 02:49:21,980 --> 02:49:28,040 about Starbucks in Hayward, and this is not the free version, this is the paid version, 2058 02:49:28,280 --> 02:49:33,740 and this is the deep research version. So it took about 15 minutes to come up with this 2059 02:49:33,740 --> 02:49:40,460 market research analysis. So there are 10 Starbucks that are company owned, and there are 2060 02:49:40,460 --> 02:49:48,880 four that are part of a grocery store or something else. There's 14 Starbucks in Hayward. 2061 02:49:48,880 --> 02:49:59,840 And if you look at the national averages, right now, if another Starbucks goes in, they'll probably be a higher concentrate. 2062 02:50:04,960 --> 02:50:13,500 I think this makes a really good point about Starbucks's strategy about concentrating in high traffic areas of high commute areas. 2063 02:50:15,100 --> 02:50:29,480 And if we think about how this site is in the city, and we think about his very mobile part as a principal commute corridor, and it is near the Hayward Airport, to me, the concentration of Starbucks in this location makes reasonable business sense. 2064 02:50:29,480 --> 02:50:39,880 This is a free economy that we live in, if Starbucks wants to make the investment here, I think it makes perfect sense, so I complete support of this initiative. 2065 02:50:43,410 --> 02:50:44,970 Thank you. 2066 02:50:45,210 --> 02:50:46,090 Commissioner Hammond? 2067 02:50:48,030 --> 02:50:48,130 Yes. 2068 02:50:49,190 --> 02:50:50,850 So it's a very interesting conversation. 2069 02:50:50,850 --> 02:51:01,650 And so in general, I am all for approving changes in the tax amendments and in the 2070 02:51:01,650 --> 02:51:06,710 conditionally use permit and changing for the zoning. 2071 02:51:07,830 --> 02:51:14,630 Maybe I'm a little bit concerned about having a star buck, but again, it is a free market 2072 02:51:14,630 --> 02:51:23,250 economy and if Starbucks, things that they can make and go at it in another location, I guess 2073 02:51:23,250 --> 02:51:30,230 that's all they're right, if I can tell, nobody else has come up forward to do something 2074 02:51:30,230 --> 02:51:35,410 with that piece of property. I do like that piece of property or the fact that they would 2075 02:51:35,410 --> 02:51:42,930 be putting something like this on that piece of property. I like that it's a mixed use. It's 2076 02:51:42,930 --> 02:51:48,470 good use for the site. Even though there are already two other Starbucks in the vicinity, 2077 02:51:48,850 --> 02:51:54,010 I believe that this location probably serves the community a little bit better than the one 2078 02:51:54,010 --> 02:52:03,630 that's located at Target or the one on, close to it on Winton, in that it would have a better 2079 02:52:03,630 --> 02:52:11,330 seating capacity, maybe a little bit more of an atmosphere, to have your coffee and also I think that 2080 02:52:11,330 --> 02:52:14,650 drive through is, is a good idea for that, for the corridor. 2081 02:52:18,510 --> 02:52:26,370 So I would have to say that I'm probably in favor of it, even though I would maybe 2082 02:52:26,970 --> 02:52:33,430 like to see perhaps some other competition come in and make a go at it. 2083 02:52:33,430 --> 02:52:41,530 But nobody that I've talked you so far has given me any reason to think that they wouldn't 2084 02:52:41,530 --> 02:52:42,490 want another Starbucks. 2085 02:52:43,730 --> 02:52:45,950 So anyway, those are my comments. 2086 02:52:48,400 --> 02:52:49,500 Thank you. 2087 02:52:49,840 --> 02:52:52,160 And I will just add my comments as well. 2088 02:52:53,820 --> 02:52:57,420 So I want to see the hotel be successful. 2089 02:52:57,940 --> 02:53:04,060 This is something that the hotel owner feels is going to keep that business thriving. 2090 02:53:04,060 --> 02:53:10,160 and we won't see that shut down. I feel like that is a consideration also for public benefit. 2091 02:53:10,880 --> 02:53:15,900 I see this as a model similar to the Fairfield and in sweet Starbucks drive through that's down 2092 02:53:15,900 --> 02:53:21,360 on industrial boulevard seems to always be busy. It's near a hotel, it's near the freeway. 2093 02:53:22,020 --> 02:53:28,580 So I could see how these would work being next to each other, not just a necessarily a sit-down 2094 02:53:28,580 --> 02:53:33,780 restaurant. I also just want to point out that there are two vacant restaurants really close by. 2095 02:53:33,780 --> 02:53:37,780 we talked about the Raja Indian cuisine on Witten, 2096 02:53:38,060 --> 02:53:40,300 which seems that it's not open anymore. 2097 02:53:40,500 --> 02:53:41,760 It says it's temporarily closed, 2098 02:53:41,840 --> 02:53:43,940 but I haven't seen it open in a very long time. 2099 02:53:44,240 --> 02:53:45,900 And then the elephant bar at Southland Mall, 2100 02:53:45,920 --> 02:53:47,940 that building has been there vacant for, 2101 02:53:47,960 --> 02:53:49,220 I believe, years now. 2102 02:53:50,100 --> 02:53:52,120 So I'm concerned that if we don't do this 2103 02:53:52,120 --> 02:53:54,920 because we're holding out for a sit-down restaurant 2104 02:53:54,920 --> 02:53:58,540 that we may just end up having nothing there with the hotel 2105 02:53:58,540 --> 02:54:01,120 and that could impact the hotel. 2106 02:54:01,220 --> 02:54:02,600 And we want to keep the hotel 2107 02:54:02,600 --> 02:54:07,700 have that be thriving as well. I do agree that that's a lot of Starbucks. I actually do 2108 02:54:07,700 --> 02:54:14,540 think that this is a better location. Also, Mr. Hammond said, then definitely, I mean, 2109 02:54:14,600 --> 02:54:18,000 the one in the target, that serves a different purpose with the standalone one next to the 2110 02:54:18,000 --> 02:54:22,900 Walgreens. I suspect many people who currently go to that one maybe going to this one if it's 2111 02:54:22,900 --> 02:54:27,860 approved. And then we would have to see if Starbucks actually keeps that open as well. So that 2112 02:54:27,860 --> 02:54:32,240 maybe something more to think about, like, the potential of, even though they're in a growth 2113 02:54:32,240 --> 02:54:37,100 model, like, is there really supply in the man that necessitates another one? 2114 02:54:37,180 --> 02:54:40,980 If there is, then it'll be fine, but that's yet to be seen. 2115 02:54:42,360 --> 02:54:47,220 So, the one other point I mean, I wanted to make was that I really did like the signage that 2116 02:54:47,220 --> 02:54:51,760 they were going to add, even though I don't necessarily think the architectural design is anything 2117 02:54:51,760 --> 02:54:57,240 special, but I did think that the sign that was specific to Hayward was a nice touch. 2118 02:54:57,240 --> 02:54:59,120 And those are my comments. 2119 02:55:00,000 --> 02:55:02,720 Are there any other commissioner comments? 2120 02:55:03,520 --> 02:55:04,040 Commissioner Myers? 2121 02:55:04,600 --> 02:55:05,240 Well, thank you. 2122 02:55:05,560 --> 02:55:14,680 The only things I hadn't mentioned earlier were, I'm concerned with a small square footage of the four units on top if it's not taken by one person. 2123 02:55:15,240 --> 02:55:19,220 You're probably looking at somebody with little capital, maybe start up starting the wrong little business. 2124 02:55:19,480 --> 02:55:23,900 And there's probably going to be a lot of turnaround, I fear, and maybe possibly some boarded up windows. 2125 02:55:24,060 --> 02:55:29,980 And if it does overtake this Starbucks, if it does overtake one of the other Walgreens, now we have that vacancy there. 2126 02:55:30,000 --> 02:55:33,040 So that was the other trepidations that I had. 2127 02:55:33,280 --> 02:55:34,040 Thank you. 2128 02:55:35,550 --> 02:55:36,470 Commissioner Hammond? 2129 02:55:37,030 --> 02:55:37,310 Yes. 2130 02:55:37,370 --> 02:55:38,410 Just a couple more comments. 2131 02:55:39,430 --> 02:55:45,750 I did want to say that I appreciate the thought given to the landscaping and the trees and to the separation of the trash. 2132 02:55:46,370 --> 02:55:53,990 But to echo the concerns of previous meetings, I'm concerned about the traffic and the litter generated around a drive-through restaurant. 2133 02:55:53,990 --> 02:56:00,750 And that means any of them, although they're included in the condition of approval, I hope that 2134 02:56:00,750 --> 02:56:05,110 after the certificate of occupancy has been issued, that it won't become a forgotten item. 2135 02:56:09,110 --> 02:56:10,030 Thank you. 2136 02:56:11,170 --> 02:56:13,010 Are there any other commissioner comments? 2137 02:56:13,210 --> 02:56:15,110 Do we have a motion on this item? 2138 02:56:18,870 --> 02:56:27,260 I would make a motion to approve this item, and I guess I'm struggling, when I look at 2139 02:56:27,260 --> 02:56:33,180 architecture of it. I think it's well balanced. I think it's integrated with this side, I guess. 2140 02:56:34,420 --> 02:56:39,700 I don't understand. I mean, I'd love to hear what the concerns are with the architecture of it. 2141 02:56:39,740 --> 02:56:44,380 I mean, it seems, it almost seems natural. I mean, maybe I'm totally missing something. 2142 02:56:44,400 --> 02:56:49,200 And I'm usually the critic. So I'd love to hear more feedback about it. 2143 02:56:52,930 --> 02:56:54,650 I think you're directing that at me. 2144 02:56:54,650 --> 02:57:01,010 I've heard two folks say that they had concerns about the architectural feel of the building 2145 02:57:01,010 --> 02:57:04,610 and I just thought that we should put it on the record what our issue is. 2146 02:57:05,010 --> 02:57:12,530 Yeah, I just said what I think I said what I believe which is there are when I looked at the 2147 02:57:12,530 --> 02:57:18,590 for example, just as an example, the one in Chicago, it is unique, it is different, it is 2148 02:57:18,590 --> 02:57:28,090 interesting and it brings some sort of, it's just, it's different and interesting. And I feel 2149 02:57:28,090 --> 02:57:33,830 like this, it looks like it's just trying to look like the hotel to me. And I understand 2150 02:57:33,830 --> 02:57:37,930 maybe that is the goal because it's next to the hotel and it's a part of the whole hotel, 2151 02:57:38,050 --> 02:57:43,530 maybe that is the goal. I'm just saying for me, I don't really think it's the sort of thing 2152 02:57:43,530 --> 02:57:47,190 that you can quantify because it's a personal preference 2153 02:57:47,190 --> 02:57:51,530 based upon what I think would add value. 2154 02:57:52,130 --> 02:57:53,810 So that's just my personal opinion. 2155 02:57:55,090 --> 02:57:56,330 Can I make a suggestion? 2156 02:57:56,550 --> 02:57:58,250 When I look at 2157 02:58:00,560 --> 02:58:02,240 the, I think it's the south facade, 2158 02:58:03,340 --> 02:58:06,620 there's a funny little sign on it. 2159 02:58:09,570 --> 02:58:14,110 And the sign scale seems incorrect. 2160 02:58:14,110 --> 02:58:14,890 It 2161 02:58:18,190 --> 02:58:24,070 says Hayward Aviation on it, is that really, I'm sorry, is that a logo that is 2162 02:58:24,070 --> 02:58:25,890 readily used? 2163 02:58:30,110 --> 02:58:32,910 If the architect could answer that question, I was wondering this thing. 2164 02:58:32,910 --> 02:58:34,510 Yeah, it just says Hayward on it. 2165 02:58:34,750 --> 02:58:39,450 I think there's an airplane flying through it, but I don't know if that's your logo or 2166 02:58:39,450 --> 02:58:41,010 how that came about. 2167 02:58:41,650 --> 02:58:47,870 But, you know, the massing on this is much more proportion to scale to human scale, 2168 02:58:47,970 --> 02:58:50,930 unlike the call center or whatever you got going there. 2169 02:58:50,930 --> 02:58:54,030 of the other good building. 2170 02:58:54,290 --> 02:58:56,710 I mean, this scale on this is only 20-something tall. 2171 02:58:56,890 --> 02:59:00,850 It's almost like a couple ADA residential units put together. 2172 02:59:01,570 --> 02:59:06,930 I think the architecture, too, is not like any other Starbucks that the facade's broken 2173 02:59:06,930 --> 02:59:07,230 up. 2174 02:59:07,310 --> 02:59:11,510 The two-story section, which makes it more of a mixed use look, is broken up. 2175 02:59:11,750 --> 02:59:14,330 The color scheme, these are the ink colors. 2176 02:59:14,590 --> 02:59:16,170 I do a lot of work with Miran Hotels. 2177 02:59:16,410 --> 02:59:20,130 They spend, you know, I don't think three or four million dollars a year in color schemes. 2178 02:59:20,130 --> 02:59:25,870 these are the primary colors that people like and enjoy and they're very long lasting. 2179 02:59:26,330 --> 02:59:31,210 So I think just looking at this as a Starbucks like a one in the mill versus the one in Chicago, 2180 02:59:31,470 --> 02:59:37,190 which I've been to too. This has this has outdoor seating area with, you know, 2181 02:59:37,370 --> 02:59:42,490 umbrellas and things like that. So it's, I think, you know, I appeal with the landscaping, 2182 02:59:42,490 --> 02:59:47,440 the facade broken off so much. I don't think you get any developer to actually 2183 02:59:48,240 --> 02:59:54,660 You invest so much in such a small little building here, and it's basically, you know, 2184 02:59:54,700 --> 02:59:58,500 a 2,000-square footprint, and I think the second floor is 2,000, roughly 2. 2185 02:59:58,880 --> 02:59:59,980 So it's such a small footprint. 2186 03:00:00,700 --> 03:00:28,820 It's a blink of an eye as you drive by, right? So say at the end of the day, you know, between the color schemes and the architectural facade, it's not anything like, well, the color schemes are probably very close to other Starbucks stores, but ideally here, I think the architecture went above and beyond what your typical developer would do. And the cost per square foot is probably, you know, higher than your call center, you're doing down the road. 2187 03:00:28,820 --> 03:00:34,740 because the amount of small scale that this is at the cost for construction is very high. 2188 03:00:34,920 --> 03:00:42,360 So I think, you know, Mr. Shaw, of course, put in a lot of extra effort here and money into this design to get it to be appealing. 2189 03:00:44,060 --> 03:00:50,420 So I kind of disagree with the architecture thoughts here, but everybody does have their own opinions which is good. 2190 03:00:52,100 --> 03:00:54,480 So I would continue to make my motion. 2191 03:00:54,480 --> 03:00:59,280 And I'm still unclear about this sign that's on the side of this building. 2192 03:00:59,660 --> 03:01:02,280 I think this sign and architect can correct me if I'm wrong. 2193 03:01:02,680 --> 03:01:04,300 I think it was just a gesture. 2194 03:01:05,520 --> 03:01:07,980 They are required to do a sign on the building. 2195 03:01:08,240 --> 03:01:13,380 And if this is not what the logo of the Hayward Executive Airport, if this is not the airports logo, 2196 03:01:13,920 --> 03:01:18,880 then our airport staff will inform the architect what the proper logo is. 2197 03:01:18,900 --> 03:01:23,140 And they'll have to put that sign on the exterior. 2198 03:01:23,140 --> 03:01:28,660 sort of clarify that the building is to be branded with the Hayward Air Force logo. 2199 03:01:29,080 --> 03:01:35,460 That's correct. Okay. Then I would continue my motion to recommend this. 2200 03:01:38,030 --> 03:01:39,590 Do we have the second? 2201 03:01:41,790 --> 03:01:42,950 Mr. Hammond. All second. 2202 03:01:44,190 --> 03:01:50,010 Thank you. So we have a motion on the floor in the second. Ms. Allen, can you please call roll? 2203 03:01:52,850 --> 03:01:57,510 Commissioner Franco Clauston, absent. Commissioner Goodbody? No. 2204 03:01:58,390 --> 03:02:00,150 Commissioner Hammond? 2205 03:02:00,470 --> 03:02:01,190 Yes. 2206 03:02:01,790 --> 03:02:02,770 Commissioner low? 2207 03:02:04,110 --> 03:02:04,890 Commissioner Myers? 2208 03:02:05,930 --> 03:02:06,370 No. 2209 03:02:06,890 --> 03:02:07,550 Commissioner Stevens? 2210 03:02:08,230 --> 03:02:08,510 Yes. 2211 03:02:08,990 --> 03:02:09,530 Chair Hardy. 2212 03:02:10,230 --> 03:02:10,510 Yes. 2213 03:02:13,320 --> 03:02:19,900 So I am going to look to our city staff to see what we do with the tie. 2214 03:02:20,540 --> 03:02:24,600 So if it's a tie then it would just be a neutral recommendation to council. 2215 03:02:26,340 --> 03:02:26,360 Great. 2216 03:02:26,700 --> 03:02:28,360 No recommendation actually. 2217 03:02:29,060 --> 03:02:30,260 No recommendation. 2218 03:02:31,500 --> 03:02:31,660 Okay. 2219 03:02:32,740 --> 03:02:34,080 So thank you to staff. 2220 03:02:34,180 --> 03:02:36,300 Thank you, applicant for being here. 2221 03:02:36,860 --> 03:02:37,720 Thank you very much. 2222 03:02:42,120 --> 03:02:42,360 Right. 2223 03:02:45,320 --> 03:02:50,400 So we will move on to approval of the Planning Commission meeting minutes from November 14th, 2224 03:02:51,160 --> 03:02:52,940 2020-4. 2225 03:02:55,470 --> 03:02:56,990 I'm moved to approve the minutes. 2226 03:02:58,670 --> 03:02:59,050 All second. 2227 03:03:01,440 --> 03:03:02,480 Can we have a vote? 2228 03:03:04,740 --> 03:03:07,840 Commissioner Franco Kwasen, Absent, Commissioner Goodbody. 2229 03:03:08,400 --> 03:03:08,480 Yes. 2230 03:03:08,480 --> 03:03:10,320 Commissioner Hammond. 2231 03:03:10,920 --> 03:03:11,840 Commissioner Low. 2232 03:03:12,580 --> 03:03:13,440 Commissioner Myers. 2233 03:03:13,720 --> 03:03:14,220 Yes. 2234 03:03:14,560 --> 03:03:15,280 Commissioner Stevens. 2235 03:03:15,680 --> 03:03:15,920 Yes. 2236 03:03:16,260 --> 03:03:16,800 Chair Hardy. 2237 03:03:19,580 --> 03:03:22,400 We will now move on to our commission reports. 2238 03:03:22,940 --> 03:03:23,980 Mr. LeCairfolk. 2239 03:03:24,180 --> 03:03:25,620 Do you have a report for us? 2240 03:03:25,900 --> 03:03:29,880 Just one quick announcement, which is that we do have one item scheduled for the June 2241 03:03:29,880 --> 03:03:35,640 12 planning commission meeting, and it is consideration on a recommendation to council on the 2242 03:03:35,640 --> 03:03:41,300 preservation ordinance update that staff has been working on right now. We don't currently have 2243 03:03:41,300 --> 03:03:46,280 anything scheduled for the June 26 meeting but I will update the commission on the meeting 2244 03:03:46,280 --> 03:03:49,920 on the 12th whether or not that meeting will actually happen so you can plan your summer. 2245 03:03:51,580 --> 03:03:57,280 Thank you. Are there any commissioner reports? Commissioner Myers. Thank you chair. 2246 03:03:58,680 --> 03:04:04,060 So starting tomorrow night for I believe two weekends, Mount Eden High School is doing their 2247 03:04:04,060 --> 03:04:09,960 version of the Lion King. It's at the new Performing Arts Center, right next to Mani and 2248 03:04:09,960 --> 03:04:15,080 High. So just tickets are cheap and I think we should support our students and we're 2249 03:04:15,080 --> 03:04:18,280 going to be there and just recommend everybody to go. Thanks. 2250 03:04:19,540 --> 03:04:23,860 Thank you for that. My granddaughter would love to see it. Are there any other commissioner 2251 03:04:23,860 --> 03:04:30,580 reports? Not seeing any. So with that, our next meeting can is scheduled for June 12th and 2252 03:04:30,580 --> 03:04:33,660 me as adjourned at 10-16 p.m. 2253 03:04:36,460 --> 03:04:37,300 Recording Stop.