[0:00] It's 5:30 and um our call meeting is slated for [0:05] that time. So, if you all will, we're going to begin our meeting and we're [0:12] going to ask our uh chief of police that he'll give us that invitation. Please [0:19] pray with me. What gracious God, we come to you now, Father, in your prayer, [0:23] Lord, call upon your name, Lord, dear God, to be with us tonight, Father. We [0:27] ask you to be with the city, Father. We have to meet with the attendees. Father, [0:30] we come here for a focus and a purpose, Lord. Dear God, tonight, Lord, I pray [0:34] that you will work with this city government. They'll be good stewardship, [0:38] Father. They'll do what's right for the city, Father, for everyone that's [0:41] involved here, Father. Father, we focus on the circumstance tonight. We ask for [0:45] the wisdom and the guidance, Lord, that it will be pleasing to everyone here, [0:49] Lord. Only you can work these things out, Father. I trust in you, Father. As [0:53] we come here tonight, Father, just give us everything we need that we all focus [0:57] that we come together as unity. Father, in unity become strength. Father, if it [1:02] is in the name of your son, Jesus, we pray for this. Thank you. Amen. In the [1:07] name of Jesus. >> Amen. [1:09] » If you all stand for pledge, please. [1:15] I pledge algiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the [1:20] republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and [1:26] justice for all. >> Thank you, sir. [1:39] » All right, y'all. We thank y'all for coming today. Um, our mayor had an [1:47] appointment so he's not able to be here and um, it's going to be informal. So, [1:54] we're going to go ahead. We have a councilman that is on the phone. I think [2:00] it is. >> Yes, sir. We have Elizabeth. You there? [2:04] » Yes, I'm here. >> So, uh, we're going to just have a [2:07] byside discussion. We're going to turn this part because we're here to discuss [2:11] the animal shelter and I'm going turn that part now in the hands of Mr. Jones. [2:18] » All right. Good afternoon or good evening. How's everybody doing today? [2:25] All right. So, um even though we we titled it as a call meeting, we won't be [2:30] making any votes tonight. This is strictly an informative [2:35] session that we're having dealing with the animal shelter and the procedures [2:41] that should happen from now on. So I just want everybody to understand that [2:48] um we have those policies are in um in our standing opposite of the [2:55] procedures that we have. We're just going to reiterate them. So then in case [2:59] something like this may happen again or close to this that everybody will know [3:03] what the protocol is. Okay. All right. [3:08] So once again I said this meeting is inform our partners that we have here. [3:12] Vhos where you at? Well Vh [3:18] okay good. And the citizens of the recent actions taking place in the city [3:23] on Friday. Um, that wasn't a call meeting. That wasn't a formal meeting, [3:28] but it was a meeting with certain individuals in it. We're just trying to [3:32] clarify the the policies that we have set in place months ago. [3:37] This is what the city must do to keep good [3:42] relationship with our partners cuz that's our focus. [3:46] Without our partners in the city, we do know based off of the budget and [3:51] everything else, we as a city cannot afford certain expenses. And we we [3:57] definitely appreciate what our partners do for us. [4:00] Like I said again, we will not be voting today. Just clarify. [4:06] The city shelter as we know it is shut down. [4:11] It means that we cannot have any intakes. [4:18] So what does that mean exactly for the citizens? I know we still have stray [4:22] dogs that may be running the area, whatever. We as a city cannot hold those [4:28] animals. We can't pick them up and we can't do [4:33] the things that needs to be done for the city. The shelter is closed due to some [4:39] replacing and repairs for the shelter due to the storm that happened almost [4:44] two years ago. So, it's needed repairs. Where's our uh carpenter? Uh [4:51] thank you ma'am for being here. Um and the reason that the shelter is shut [4:57] down because of the department of agriculture. We had two violations. One [5:02] of the violations was structure and the other violations was was drainage. [5:08] All linked into uh the storm that happened. [5:13] With that being said, we have to evacuate all the dogs. [5:19] What we will do, and it's in our policy, the first thing that we will do is that [5:24] we will notify our partners as soon as possible. I said our partners who [5:31] partner with the city. Raise your hand again for the ones that partner with the [5:35] city to make sure things happen and spending y'all volunteer time going out [5:39] there to the shelter feeding, bathing, worming, and all that. So from now on, [5:45] when we have to evacuate the shelter for whatever it may be, you guys will be the [5:52] first to be called. And after you are called, the city [5:58] um will give you a timeline on which the dogs, the animals can be picked up and [6:05] that timeline and for whatever reason sometime things come up where you can't [6:09] do it. Then we will activate our outside sources like we have now which is [6:15] Thomasville, Georgia. So the first step that we will do is activate Vhos. [6:26] Then if you cannot respond, we will activate our outside sources. [6:36] when the shelter reopens. What we would like also every dog names [6:42] I know y'all do already. But one thing that we we do have inside [6:47] of the shelter, we have an R on the board. Good, good idea, but we would [6:53] like to go a step further. This will help us out as well. [6:57] every dog that has been officially rescued with that with one of the [7:03] partners that you have that you've been talking with. We want the name of the [7:08] dog. We want the name of the rescue agency and the different medical things [7:13] that that rescue has took have done. That helps us out. That'll help Miss Kim [7:20] out. She's the one does accounts payable. So anything any transaction [7:24] that goes to the vet when she gets those bills in she can put name for name [7:29] procedures to procedures. With that being said [7:33] um we want that at the shelter and we want via email [7:39] so that way we can keep track and see just because we won't give you a [7:43] response but at least we'll have a paper trail in case something happens. [7:48] The individuals on that list who needs to be notified will be our spokesman. [7:54] The person that is supposed to speak for the city is Officer Brown, [8:01] Chief of Police, [8:05] Miss Bernese, Miss Kim, [8:09] the mayor, and the council members. [8:16] I know I don't know did that trans did we have any pickup today to go to um [8:24] I just said the name Thomas field today come and I think [8:30] » okay so right this moment it should be 6 at the shelter [8:35] » I do understand that you guys are making coordinations to move [8:40] but before they move this is going to our partners [8:44] before they move. We need the names of the dogs. I know y'all did that already. [8:50] Um, and we also need um the rescues or who is ever [8:58] giving monies or volunteering whatever that they have, whether toys or [9:03] whatever. We need that today so we can put that in our paperwork [9:07] to show that these dogs are taken care of. [9:12] Um, I know y'all say y'all want to do it today. So, I'm hoping y'all prepared to [9:16] give that up after this, right? And what we're also going to do is I'm going give [9:21] a timeline if we don't have it before 12:00 p.m. [9:26] tomorrow, right? We'll make the coordinations with Thomasville for the [9:31] additional six. This is to protect the city, [9:36] our partners, and the animals. clarify that right there, Chris. Go [9:41] ahead. 5 p.m. That just means we need the arrangements by 12 tomorrow. [9:46] » That is correct. I mean, we understand y'all are working or whatever. Like, [9:50] just so we know the arrangements, you know, and Thomasville has confirmation [9:54] that we do have them taken care of. We're all good. Not clear there. [9:59] » Did everybody get that? Just confirmation to ensure that they are [10:02] taken care of, that that [snorts] they're good to go. [10:06] And I guess >> like they don't physically have to be [10:09] picking up by 12:00 p.m. tomorrow. >> Yes. [10:11] » Um you just need the paperwork 5:00 p.m. tomorrow. Just the paperwork. [10:15] » Just the paperwork. That's what we need cuz we know it's I think one's supposed [10:18] to be potentially leaving tomorrow based off of the medical if it's going to [10:23] transport tomorrow. I think to Florida, right? Is that the one that you was [10:27] talking about? >> Working on. [10:28] » Okay. Um, [10:32] and lastly, we do appreciate everyone for showing up today, showing your [10:36] support. And I guess the last thing, Mr. Johnson, would be like, um, does anybody [10:42] have any questions or comments dealing with [10:44] » I would just like to clear clear something up really quick if I could on [10:49] the update to the procedure um that Chris explained. So we know that you [10:53] know there have been there has been recordeping on outtakes and intakes but [10:56] we're just asking moving forward that as soon as you know of a organization that [11:02] is going to rescue a dog that we get that both printed and electronic. So, [11:07] all the details that you would typically put on an outtake form, I'm assuming [11:10] could go just on a document to say, "Hey, on October 5th, this dog Rocky, [11:15] I'm just I'm using that name. No clue." But Rocky is going to be out to this [11:19] organization. And that is to protect you guys as much as the city, as much as our [11:24] officers that are working out there and our employees. That way, if this happens [11:28] again, we have it both written and electronic, you know, and everyone knows [11:31] where every dog is, what's in in in motion, right? because I realize a lot [11:36] of times y'all have worked on things in the background which we're so [11:40] appreciative of that we have no clue about. You know, I'm willing to admit [11:42] that like y'all are doing double triple the work that we even know of. And so, [11:47] but we need to know of that to have your back when this happens again in the [11:51] future. I think that's the biggest thing. And that could be as simple just [11:54] like today that email thread where you're just informing us like, "Hey, [11:58] we've talked to this organization in South Dakota and we're transporting this [12:02] dog on October 5th." That's all we're asking for moving forward. That's all I [12:07] got. >> Okay. [12:11] » I think one second. That's that's it for me, Mr. Johnson. But we had a hand in [12:17] the back and if you want to acknowledge or [12:19] » All right. >> May I ask when [12:21] » can you step up front, ma'am, please? >> Can I need your name for a minute? [12:25] » Space sellers. I was wondering when the city's going to have the repairs to the [12:30] animal shelter completed since it's been two years since the hurricane and when [12:34] will the drainage I mean it's something like lighting or power the wastewater [12:40] treatment plant when when will that be done? We actually have the contractor [12:46] for the city here with us tonight. Unfortunately, FEMA, GEMA, and insurance [12:52] companies do not work in a hurry. We had to hire a public adjuster for the city [12:57] to work our claim. >> So that is to be [13:00] » two years. >> Yes, ma'am. It's been two years and [13:02] we're still battling that. And I have talked with the public adjuster every [13:08] week, if not every week, every 10 days and they are telling us that it will be [13:13] settled by September the 30th. However, we as the city have to contacting Miss [13:19] Christina Jones. She is going to begin work this week. Roberto's work. You've [13:25] already started. We're going on the assumption that we'll be receiving a [13:31] check. I'm not going to say by the end of the month cuz I dealt with it for two [13:36] years. >> Let's not put a time on it, but we'll [13:38] get it. >> But we're working on it. [13:40] » And this will be up to the Department of Agriculture standards or [13:44] » Yes, ma'am. >> Department of the State [13:45] » and then we can place it off there again. Uh but once the department [13:50] because they will have to come in and inspect and do I'm very I'm pretty sure [13:55] I've never had to work with them before. Um whatever they say that's what will go [14:00] by. Okay. Well the people out there that have been taking care of the animal they [14:04] do a amazing job with very much support from the city and I just think that that [14:09] this needs to be a priority. I mean, if we have animals roaming the city, we [14:13] need to provide, you know, humane stuff for them to you wouldn't want your [14:18] animal, you know, the heat, poor drainage and structural problems and [14:22] stuff like that. And I think they need to be a top priority. And I'm here on [14:26] the animal. I'm the animal. I love animals and I think they do an amazing [14:30] job, but for some reason, it seems like they always get the [14:35] they get we've had to rearrange priorities since May. I'm not going to [14:39] tell you no fear. Trust me, as finance director and city clerk, I do all of it. [14:46] And we have moved this one to the top. We actually pulled her from another job [14:51] so that we can get this done. Unfortunately, with the state coming in [14:56] that kind of put it up there for us. So, and thankfully I've got good counsel [15:02] that they will see to that. So, you [15:05] [clears throat] say by September 30th I'll have all the renovations completed. [15:09] I don't know. Um >> I don't I don't So, this is the thing. [15:13] This is the the tricky part. I don't I don't like giving my opinion. For those [15:17] that know me, I don't like giving an opinion on something. I only speak on [15:21] facts. The fact is that right now is that it's been almost two years. Fact [15:26] is, we have people working on it now. I don't want to give my opinion and I [15:30] don't want anybody to give an opinion on the deadline or when it's going to be [15:34] completed. All we know is it's getting done and we're doing the best that we [15:37] can with the resources that we have. >> But for the state to have to step in, it [15:42] seems like it's a priority. >> Well, this so the state [15:48] comes and inspects all the time and last time we had a couple other things that [15:54] they said that needed to be done and then every time I know how y'all know [15:58] inspections when they come in, they'll see this and you fix that and then they [16:03] may come in again and see something else. So, I'm not want to blame the [16:07] state. I don't want to blame the city. I don't even want to blame the insurance [16:10] company. I want to blame the hurricane. That's who I want to blame. But that's [16:14] nobody at all. So, we're doing the best that we can. [16:17] » I just want to make sure it's priority. >> Yes, ma'am. It is. [16:24] Sir, asking you. [16:30] » I'm Ron Bonds. My first question I think has been asked and that was is this [16:34] going to be a permanent shutdown or is it just a temporary thing? [16:38] » Temporary. >> Temporary. And then my next question is [16:41] uh what steps, if any, are we taking to reassess what's going to cost in the [16:46] next fiscal year to run the shelter? Are we making any plans to augment that [16:52] funding somehow? So based off of our partners that we [16:57] have right we don't we can't do a guesstimation of cost and the main [17:02] reason is I mean for the building itself for the general maintenance we can do [17:07] that however we don't know what the intake is going to be we we can I think [17:12] we hold a total of the state level is 22 total [17:16] » your license >> 20 so if we have 20 the whole entire [17:20] time right like for like meals and whatever it could go up. Right now we [17:25] have well right now we have a total of six at our facility but prior to that we [17:30] had 14. So it does fluctuate. >> All right. Thank you. [17:34] » And your name again sir? >> Ron Bombs. [17:36] » Okay. Ba Ms. >> Thank you. [17:41] » Anyone else y'all? We thank y'all for coming and uh you say you finished. I'll [17:48] come up to you. >> No no I'm the club. Go ahead. Go ahead. [17:55] I was going to say something. >> And you are? [17:59] » My name is Janet Corker. I'm repres Hazelhurst Animal Shelter or VHAS. Over [18:04] the past two years, I stood in this room 15 times. I've spent more than a decade [18:09] volunteering at this shelter. VHAS is a nonprofit organization of volunteers, [18:14] fosters, advocates, donors, and rescue partners who spent nearly two decades [18:17] serving this community and the animals that live in shelter temporarily. [18:21] Together we've transformed the shelter from what was 100% euthanage rate to a [18:25] no kill shelter status by statistics. We provide medical care, spayneuter, um [18:32] cost of bedding, rescue, transport, education, and resources to reduce the [18:35] overpopulation of the internet community. We've cleaned kennels, walk [18:39] dogs, foster animals, dur rescue partners, and transported them thousands [18:42] of miles, quite literally 95,000 miles in my car. That's a year and a half. [18:47] We've raised money, paid vet bills, and spent countless weekends and holidays [18:51] caring for the dogs in this little pink building tucked away in the corner of [18:54] the town. We've all done this because we love the dogs. There are 14 dogs who [18:58] were residents of shelter yesterday. They're not numbers. They are not [19:02] spreadsheets. They're not pawns of controversy. They're living beings. We [19:06] know these dogs. We know their personalities, their fears, medical [19:09] histories, and needs. We've photographed them. We've written their bios, arranged [19:13] veterary care, networkkedorked them hundreds of times in social media and [19:16] emails to advocates and partners around the nation. [19:19] Before Thursday stop order, six of these dogs have confirmed rescue [19:22] opportunities. Then the stop order was issued. A rescue offered to take two [19:26] more, meaning we could have moved eight to 14 dogs the moment we were given [19:30] notice, but we were never given a chance. Today, eight dogs were moved to [19:35] Thomasville, Humane without meaningful discussion with EAS, despite our long [19:38] history with the shelter. Tonight I speak for Leah, Diamond, Licorice, [19:43] Flips, Domino, Cookie, Rocky, and Luna. They did not cause the stop order. They [19:47] did not fail an inspection and not choose any of this. They are individual [19:51] lies caught in the middle of decisions. They have no rule in making and just [19:54] want a second chance. My concern is not looking. I'm not here to judge them. I [19:58] have not done my research on them. My concern is the process and transparency. [20:02] I'm glad there's a calling tonight, but this is not it. There's more discussion [20:07] that's needed. On Thursday, the Georgia Department of [20:10] Agriculture issued a stop order affecting the Hayesburg personal [20:12] shelter. We were in this room Thursday night and not a soul said anything. On [20:17] Friday, members of the city, I'm told, had a meeting with representatives of [20:20] Department of A. That was not publicly announced. Details have really shared [20:24] off hands. Very limited at this point. Who attended? Where are the minutes? [20:27] When is that going to be provided? What was discussed? Why was the timeline [20:31] given to Wednesday? The first I've heard about a deadline for dogs to move was [20:35] today. Again, I've been involved with the [20:37] shelter for a decade. The state agency took significant [20:42] regulatory action against a city shelter on Thursday. Again, you guys met. You [20:46] made discussions, but you didn't involve those who've been [20:50] involved for a long time. I have questions about the dogs themselves and [20:53] what's going to happen to them. What's happening to Licorice? She's on stray [20:57] technically. She's not even been at the shelter for 10 days. She's been [21:00] transferred. We're actively trying to find her owners because she was recently [21:04] stay. What is the plan with Thomasville if she works around? [21:10] Who's responsible for the medical care going forward? What medical care are [21:12] they going to get? You've asked about medical cost brought up in the room. How [21:16] much do things cost? The dogs that were sent the eight of them over $3,000 in [21:21] veterary care could be provided. Are we going to be reimbured? Is that a [21:24] discussion? Will Thomasville Humane be adopting [21:27] these dogs out? Are they transferring them to other organizations with Best [21:30] Friends Animal Society they partner with? Are they simply housing them [21:33] temporarily? Can you give me those answers? And why again are people who've [21:38] been working volunteering at the shelter for rescue placements for over a decade [21:42] not brought to the conversation until afterwards? [21:45] We understand the stop board was issued. We've been a volunteer at the shelter [21:48] for a long time. I've been in this room to complain about standards. I've known [21:52] more many more of you than off record. We've dealt with the insecure the in [21:57] incompatible shelter needs are what we see is there. However, why was he [22:01] passing out the phone call? The very first one. I encourage you to think [22:04] about that thought every single day. Again, we've been your partner for two [22:09] decades. Trust cannot be rebuilt when [22:13] communication is absent. Early this year, a rescue relationship was damaged [22:16] related to puppies at the shelter that were there before the stop order and [22:20] meant to leave the day after. It took three weeks for the city to advocate for [22:24] those dogs to be released to us. Unfortunately, it took another week for [22:27] the stop order to be ended at 34 days. Those dogs waited another four months to [22:32] leave for rescue because we lost a rescue partner. That rescue partner [22:36] pulled 12 dogs from the shelter last year. They had not pulled a single one [22:39] since that first stop order. We spent months trying to rebuild that [22:43] relationship. Another rescue was meaning to visit in [22:46] September. That was just confirmed last week. I had to tell them they don't need [22:50] to come now. I had to turn away a potential adopter and turn them to [22:54] another local shelter and rescue organization. [22:56] There are dogs in this community need to help. For 39 days year this year in [23:01] counting, the city has been unable to provide animal services to its community [23:04] because of stop orders. 39 days. I will post that and regularly communicate that [23:09] to you. This is the second stop order 2026. I'm all for repairs to be done. I [23:15] support it. I can tell you about thousand things that could be done if [23:18] you want to listen. It's great that we have plans, but you haven't once again [23:22] picked up the phone and talked to me as I want transparency. How long are the [23:27] repairs in progress? We might wave on funds, but they've been designs and [23:31] thoughts. Again, you haven't encouraged people who've been out there for two [23:34] decades to be involved in the conversation [23:38] as it says for what is the timeline. I know you can't give an answer, so I'm [23:41] not going to continue on that topic. But the community deserves to know these [23:45] answers. The taxpayers deserve to know the donors to be pass again. $3,000 of [23:51] medical medical expenses gone. We have to account for it. We have to tell [23:55] people what happened to it. The volunteers and rescue partners in this [23:58] room tonight and those that are present for years have passed deserve answers. [24:02] This is a publicly funded shelter. VHAS has been a willing partner for decades. [24:07] VHAS and the rescue partners we work with locally have covered $15,000 of [24:11] veterary expenses this year. An additional $1,500 of physical items, not [24:17] including food and treats and toys, blankets, etc. have been donated. Over [24:21] 2,000 pounds of food and treats have been donated by the local rescues and [24:26] our donors to a shelter this year alone. Additionally, just last week, I was [24:30] asked to bring more food because there were concerns about paying a food bill. [24:33] 225 pounds of food was brought last week. [24:37] We provided volunteer hours on countless times, fosters, network, transportation, [24:42] etc. What are you going to do with your [24:45] medical rescues? We're your your point blank. I have three of your medical [24:49] fosters in my home. we take willingly and incur those costs. You have a bill [24:54] for $1,000 eped related to one of them on emergency care walk. Think about that [25:00] in the future when you want to isolate your partners. I am angry. I'm [25:04] exhausted. I'm heartbroken. Things have to change. If you want a partnership, it [25:09] is not excluding the people in the room who do the work. It starts with [25:13] communication. It continues with transparency. [25:17] And we want a seat at the table. Tell us the plan. Tell us what the Thomasville [25:22] agreement has been made with city with GDA. What are the details? What are the [25:26] future for the eight dogs who left today? Give a timeline the best of [25:30] possible. We're tracking for repairs. I'm glad again there are repairs [25:35] happening. There are so many that can happen. The well-being of the dogs. Tell [25:39] the community your actual plans. Be transparent to everyone. The dogs in [25:45] this community deserve better. The community deserves transparency and your [25:49] volunteers will only be here so long without all of that. [25:53] » Thank you. >> Can I just ask a question of her so she [25:58] can give us a little bit more information for clarity? Is that okay? [26:02] That I appreciate you. Um Janet, quick question for you. [26:06] » Can you come can you can >> you can't hear me? I am loud. [26:10] » Protocol. >> We want you to come say your name. [26:13] » Le Moore with guardians. I'm coming to ask a question. the microphone cuz I [26:17] need it. All right. You said that with these animals that [26:23] are going to Thomasville, right? You gave a bunch of numbers and I was trying [26:27] to follow, but was it was $3,000 of your funds on those dogs that are going to [26:34] Thomasville. So, we gave away >> They're already gone. They're already [26:36] gone. >> Okay. So, you your your [26:39] » your own us or our rescue partners directly locally that we work with. Yes. [26:44] And I I want to clarify something. So, Elizabeth made [26:47] » You don't have a microphone. >> I know. I'm loud enough. Mary Katherryn [26:51] Kimp, I think y'all can all hear me. Um Brown, sorry. Mary Catherine Brown. Um [26:57] so, Elizabeth wanted to make clarification [27:02] on we need to let you guys know what dogs we're working on. It's every dog in [27:06] your shelter. Always. >> I was getting there. [27:08] » Every dog. That's why there's $3,000 floating out [27:13] in somebody else's shelter now of ours. [27:17] » We can't sit a dog without some basic information related to that dog [27:20] depending basication rings, etc. So, every dog is our policy that was passed [27:25] in January is the guy who's gay. So, we do that. [27:28] » So, to to kind of >> clarify, [27:30] » can I ask this? What what vet bill what vet bills has the city paid in the last [27:34] like 15 years? Well, I think we paid them, but y'all definitely reimbursed [27:39] us. So, that's kind of a trick question. >> Okay, good clarity. [27:43] » May I ask how much the city funds the shelter [27:47] » and why the repairs take two years? >> No, we're talking So, I don't want to. [27:54] So, if you we you talking about the shelter, what about the structure that [27:58] we're in right this moment? We have repairs that need to be done to this [28:02] building right this moment since the storm for two years. It's not just the [28:06] shelter. It's buildings. We had an a I forgot her name on Thursday. [28:12] » But the state won't shut you down if it's not done. [28:15] » Does anybody live here? >> Does any [28:20] I I hear what you're saying, but we're talking about repairs. We're talking [28:23] about funds from the [clears throat] federal government. All of this stuff [28:27] sometimes. >> So, but do we have those funds to repair [28:30] the shelter? But we're saying we're going to repair it regardless of if we [28:34] have the funds or not. >> We're going to begin work on it. Mary [28:37] Catherine, yes. I mean, she's already out there. I haven't been out there, but [28:44] I've emailed the necessary persons and they're responding to me. Get the work [28:50] started. >> And the plan is to reopen the shelter [28:53] » as soon as possible. And then the the ones that's in Thomasville, the the I'm [29:00] sorry. >> You said the tentative date is September [29:02] 30th >> to do what? No, ma'am. [29:04] » No, we didn't give a tenative date. That's the to have you said. [29:09] » No, no, that's the reason why this is when they said they were going to settle [29:13] the insurance. >> That's September 30th. [29:16] » That's the reason I don't want to I said again, we don't know a date and I don't [29:22] want to give a date based off of my opinion because my opinion doesn't mean [29:26] anything. So, I can't give you that. But however, what has been going back and [29:31] forth with Thomasville, they're just a holding place until the repairs are [29:37] finished and they're supposed to be moving back to our facility once it [29:41] passes. >> That's the first time that we've heard [29:44] that for >> shelter or they are. [29:50] » So, are they going to be made to sit there? No. Sorry. Are they going to be [29:54] made to sit there? Because if you're transferring them back here, technically [29:58] they're still city property hazel. [30:02] So are they going to have to sit there till you finish repairs? [30:06] » Um I don't know and I don't want to give you an answer. [30:09] » Were they agency transfer >> from our agency to theirs? [30:15] I don't know that question, but I think they may be because license to license. [30:21] But hey, here we go. Officer Brown, our spokesman. Thank you, Jesus, for being [30:26] in here. Can you can you come forward, please, if you wouldn't mind? He's our [30:32] spokesman for the city. >> He's the guy. [30:37] » Ask my question from over there. >> Caus me trouble. [30:39] » I'm sorry. >> I didn't I didn't see you when you [30:42] walked in. >> You're fine. You're fine. [30:47] » Ask my question. It's fine. I'll get there. So we are [30:52] shipping from >> Hey, [30:55] » we're transfer >> transferring. So what does that mean [30:58] exactly? >> We transfer [31:02] those elements to time management. >> We're no longer responsible for those [31:08] elements >> until the repairs are finished and then [31:10] they come back over. >> That's right now. [31:13] » That's what the plan >> as right now. Yes. [31:15] » Okay. >> How is that written in the contract? So, [31:17] you have an agency transfer that is required by the Department of A that [31:20] says it's going from my agency license to this agency license. Therefore, all [31:24] liability is then transferred from this license to that license. How do we write [31:27] that contract that says it's for a specific amount of time that's [31:29] unidentified and that we're going to take them back? [31:34] » Exactly how you just said. >> I love that. Do you have a copy of that? [31:37] » Not on, >> but it's been done. And so both [31:39] Thomasville has that copy that states that they are just a temporary holding [31:43] facility and that they are holding on to care custody and control in the interim, [31:46] but that return will be done at some point in the future. [31:53] » I feel like you're not. >> All right. [laughter] [31:56] » There's no way you wrote that into a contract. [31:58] » Do we do we have any? >> But we'd love to have a copy of it. [32:01] » Okay. >> So, I'll tell you this. If you tell them [32:04] it's a contract, you better produce a contract. I want you to be clear with [32:08] this room. I drilled you hard today. Don't stand there and tell this audience [32:13] that there's a contract. There's not one. I'm going to be the first one you [32:16] going to deal with. >> Is there a contract? [32:20] » Oh, it's >> we have an agreement with them to [32:24] transfer them over to [32:28] » So, statement of understanding then is that what we have [32:31] » written? >> No, I'm No, no, stay with me for a [32:34] second. I I hear everybody else, but I'm just asking that question. Is it a [32:38] statement of understanding in writing >> or is it [32:41] » is it a verbal contract with verbal agreement with them [32:46] » to to everyone that is >> No, it can't be Hold on for a second, [32:50] Mr. It can't be completely written because if the if the animals leave our [32:54] facility, they must have paperwork transferred to [32:59] » you asking what happened in the whole process. That's what you're trying to [33:01] ask me. >> I want to I want to make it as [33:03] transparent as this. So when they left our facility, [33:07] » did we we should have did paperwork to show them going to the [33:10] » outtake form? >> That's what I'm there's an outtake forms [33:12] to transfer them over to Thomas Humane Society. [33:16] » This typical thing that we do for any other transfer or movement of the Thank [33:21] you. >> Yes. And that was their email. That's [33:24] what it was stated. >> Okay. [33:26] » Okay. Y'all received the council, received the email [33:29] coming back >> because that's how we transfer animals [33:32] out to other rescues. >> And the verbiage actually states on [33:35] those those transfer forms that care, custody, and control is now in [33:39] » transferred overact. And so, yes, they could out of the kindness of their heart [33:43] and I don't know why they wouldn't because nobody's fighting over dogs [33:46] right now. None of us can easily talk to us because we're not the point of [33:50] contact. So, >> yes. So the only point of contact that [33:53] we have that should be making contact is officer Brown and as soon as we have the [33:59] rest of those details. >> So what happens to those two that have [34:02] rescued one of our rescues? Like because he just transferred them to Thomas [34:06] Humane. So what I mean >> when you say those two that's including [34:11] the eight total that you >> two dogs that were stepped up after the [34:16] stop order. >> I don't understand. [34:17] » No, but why why not? Why not? Why am I being told that now I have to go to [34:22] Chandler through Brown? I have a phone. >> No, because he's he's our [34:28] » Oh, you guys have a contract with Thomasville. Is that what you're saying? [34:30] » No. >> So, they're your partner. [34:33] » Officer Brown. >> I'm asking [34:36] » and I'm trying to give it. Officer Brown is the person that's assigned to ask [34:41] questions and do whatever dealing with the department of a Thomasville or [34:46] anybody dealing with the shelter. But Thomas Gill Humane is a 501c3. I can [34:51] pick up the phone and call them at my own will in a court. Why are they [34:54] refusing to work with somebody that's a citizen? [34:57] » They're not refusing. What they want is our point of contact for the city of [35:02] Perth, which is officer Brown. >> But I'm not calling on behalf of the [35:06] city of H. Hold on. Let me let me stop that real quick because I want to make [35:08] some clarification. Hold on. You're still at that microphone. You got this. [35:11] So, let me ask Brown. How many animals have you as the spokesperson, as animal [35:18] control, as the person over the the shelter bequested by our our council [35:23] and the chief? Um, how many animals have you personallyworked [35:28] and moved to other rescues? >> As today, [35:34] » you personally, not through VAS, Brown has moved from this rescue license to [35:38] this rescue license, not including Thomasville, but any other time. When [35:42] have you personally moved a dog from point A to point B? Not ever. Okay. So, [35:47] when have you personally you as a spokesperson [35:52] with any other organization for the movement of the analyst that maybe just [35:56] didn't come to fruition? How often does that happen in your as a spokesperson [36:00] for this organization? How often does that happen [36:03] » recently? >> Just give me from the entire time you've [36:06] been animal control as a spokesperson here. And I'm about to defend you here [36:09] in a second. So, don't be too sad. I promise. [36:11] » No. You're fine. You're fine. U let me go back. [36:20] I can't be exactly wrong. I'm not going to lie to you. I can't [36:24] » But the reason for that is because you're not a live release coordinator, [36:27] right? You're an animal control officer. That's what you do. So, your job is [36:31] legal. We're going to protect the people of our city. We're going to go get that [36:35] dog that is being crazy and biting somebody. We're going to go try to [36:39] prosecute somebody who is treating a dog poorly. Right? Your job is law [36:42] enforcement and your job is kind of the overall management of the shelter as it [36:47] stands right now. Right? But live release coordination in most shelters is [36:51] its own separate designation. So it is the people who work those networks, know [36:56] all the other rescues, have been doing this for decades, have decades in their [37:00] pocket that says, "I know this rescue is really good with three-legged dogs, so [37:04] I'm going to call up Jenny on her cell phone when she's cooking dinner for her [37:07] kids and say, "Hey, Jenny, can you take this dog that I got? This is what we [37:10] have here. You've got a license. Since we've got a license, let's move them. [37:13] And pay, how many animals in the last 6 months has VHOSWorked [37:19] as a live release coordinator for our city? [37:22] » That's our numbers, girl. About 40. >> Okay. So, we went from 40 to none. And [37:28] the problem is we now have a conduit that is in between this ability for your [37:33] live release board names. How many over the last decade? [clears throat] Give me [37:36] a spitball number. I know that's ridiculous, but [37:38] » we're we're in problem with the five digits. So, if they are the sole people, [37:44] here's your your sole rescue that is acting as a live release coordinator, [37:48] which is a designated position, >> which is the designated position in most [37:54] no kill shelters, which we've been designated, right? We're on their kill [37:56] shelter now. So in that situation, we've now created a barrier which is causing [38:02] frustration with the girls who put on put their time, effort, energy, and [38:07] believe for this city to move these dogs and have worked for these these networks [38:11] and the opportunity to speak to all these other rescues. It's like you [38:14] scratch my back, I'll scratch yours, and we're all going to get along. We're [38:17] going to move dogs because everybody has the same common theme. They're not law [38:20] enforcement. So their job is not to run and go get the dog that has bit somebody [38:23] and quarantine them. They're two totally separate entities that are required for [38:28] a nokill shelter to be successful. What we've done, unfortunately, I think just [38:32] truly out of ignorance and and a lack of understanding of how these organizations [38:36] traditionally work. We've kind of put all this on Brown who's like squishing [38:40] under the pressure because it's not really fair. like we handed we said to [38:43] him the decades that these girls have worked in order to be able to get these [38:47] networking and and to know all these other rescues and to put their heart [38:51] into these dogs. We've now said he's responsible. [38:55] That's not really what animal control officers do. That's why they have live [38:59] release coordinator. So, I just wanted to make sure that we were all [39:01] appreciating there's two separate denotions here. It's not. We can't yell [39:05] and scream at him and we also can't block them from doing their job because [39:10] if these girls decide this is too hard and I can't effectively do my job and [39:14] the actions of this one officer trying to do our job is affecting our ability [39:18] to keep our promises to these other rescues. They're going to walk and they [39:23] should walk and then we are all in a world of trouble and it will look bad on [39:26] him and it will look bad on them and it will look bad on all of you and the [39:29] taxpayers will be mad because we'll be paying money that these other people [39:31] would then pay. But that's it. Got it. [39:37] Thank y'all. >> Oh, [laughter] wait, wait, wait. No, no, [39:41] no. I was just addressing that. Hold on. I got more I got more questions. [39:44] » No, [laughter] no, no. Serious. [39:47] » So, let me ask you. We were asking about the $3,000 because I want everybody to [39:51] understand, especially anybody who's reporting this or sending it off to [39:53] somebody else, whatever. $3,000. Your organization, you received the [39:59] donations. You've got your rescue partners. That money went into these [40:03] animals that were then just transferred by an animal control officer as a [40:06] spokesperson to another rescue. So now when you go back as a good steward of [40:11] the funding that you get to your donors, you're going to say, [40:16] "Sorry, we used $3,000 of your money um because our our council put somebody [40:22] else in this position and we're not working well right now and I've lost [40:28] eight dogs that had this funding in it that we were hoping to get somewhere." I [40:32] want that to be underscored because donations are hard to come by and those [40:36] donations mean our taxpayers like myself and the rest of you in here aren't [40:40] having to fund that. This is free money that they're working for that that one [40:46] person who doesn't understand because this is not his world. It's just handed [40:50] to somebody else as a spokesperson for all of you who are supposed to be good [40:54] stewards of taxpayer money. So there's not just these people who are angry. [40:59] It's not just the subsidiary rescues that are angry. Your taxpayers, if they [41:03] understood that their money that goes to you, that they think they have an animal [41:08] shelter, they think they have somebody who's coming to get some stuff done. And [41:10] it turns out that it's not. It's the behind the scenes and somebody making [41:14] decisions from donations that they're receiving. That's not okay. Just on a [41:19] business level, forget the dogs. Who cares? Nobody cares about animals. Think [41:21] about the money. That is screwing their ability to get the donations, which by [41:26] the way keep our city. So, we are not just hitting crazy animal people with [41:31] all their emotions. We're hitting their ability to keep our city going and keep [41:36] them safe. My next question for you, we are closed, right? Stop order, nothing [41:40] can come in. DOA said that we have certain legal requirements over there, [41:45] chief and soon to be chief chief almost. Um, [41:50] what happens when we have a bike dog? What's our plan? Good [41:53] » question. >> What's our plan? I've told this panel [41:57] from the getgo, I'm law enforcement. I know nothing about animal control. I've [42:01] been honest with Miss Mary Kay and the rest of them from the very getgo. [42:05] » We're going to call you. >> So, [42:07] » listen, I answer. You guys know it. >> That is a very good question. That [42:09] bothers me. Is it subject to happen? It is. How would I handle it? I'll be done. [42:16] » So, we have a problem because that legal so both the city and the county which is [42:20] I know not in your purview and I'll have that fight some other day but in the [42:24] city and the county we both have a requirement that if a dog bites somebody [42:28] we have to be able to quarantine them if that dog is vicious and we have to [42:31] quarantine them long enough that we can make sure that no rabies symptomology [42:34] shows up and right now I'm sure you guys have seen in the news we've had several [42:37] rabies cases that have come about. It used to be I would say we've been a [42:41] rabies pace since 1972 when it was down the border. But now we have them close [42:45] to home which means that this is an actual health risk that we have to take [42:49] into consideration. Where are we putting them if we have no containment? [42:55] And what's our what's our protocols going to be for our officers? [42:58] » We're going to call you. >> No. [43:01] » No. >> But so I'm I'm going to take that one. [43:04] » Seriously. Seriously, y'all. These are important questions and these are things [43:09] that when you started off the whole thing is communication [43:15] and you all do a beautiful job, a good job and the city is blessed to have you. [43:23] I think the word that I got was late Friday. I [43:28] think it was uh 7 something. [43:34] Anyway, when the stock order all of a sudden come and said nothing and the [43:40] city was put in a place that they had to do something right then because they [43:45] have to go out what the state said. And I think where the problem come in is [43:51] communication that we really and truly should have talked to the men's and [43:57] women who talk with the who handle the dogs who who go out there and people [44:03] sometime make mistakes by working too quick to get things done. So I want to [44:09] apologize that these things was done. I can assure you that somebody will be [44:14] getting in touch with Thomasville. make sure that those animals are took care of [44:19] and come back here. Hopefully that uh the money that was put in them will come [44:26] back and the work that you all do can continue [44:31] once this building is to put in place. My question to the mayor was now when is [44:39] this going to be done? Personally, I thought the building was perfect. I [44:44] didn't know that the Lord had decided to blow it over. [44:48] But now that it's being done, there is a process and there's [44:55] outline saying what they're going to do. If you all would allow us to start [45:01] getting those things in place, somebody will be talking to you to tell what [45:05] those steps are and what those thoughts I mean when you can bring them back. [45:10] Plus, we'll try to get in touch with [45:13] Thomasville to make sure that you know exactly what's going on with it. [45:19] » I'm going to visit Thomas. They're open shelter like they're open on Saturday. [45:24] » Well, let us let us talk with them [clears throat] so we don't have any [45:28] confusion and somebody has to have a a communication line between each other. [45:35] That's what's going on. Sometimes when people don't talk, this is where the [45:40] problems come in. So this was supposed to be a informal [45:49] uh meeting tonight and mainly to tell you all what [clears throat] was going [45:54] on or to ask answer question that we could without confusing [46:01] the pot any more than what it is. >> Mr. Dwayne, can I ask you a question? [46:06] Yes. >> Before about two or three years ago, how [46:09] many times had you ever seen me come to a city council meeting? [46:15] » Never. >> Never. [46:17] » Never. >> So, and I've been volunteering out there [46:19] for 14 years now. >> Yeah. [46:21] » So, there was a good working relationship at some point. There was [46:25] because I never had to call on any of you guys. [46:29] » But at some point down the line, I don't know what happened. [46:31] » When was that? But but three years ago, >> but that [46:37] » but I I don't know what happened, but what I'm telling you is that there has [46:41] been a lack of communication and we do feel like we're being shut out, [46:44] » right? But >> and [46:46] » but these this type of thing right here, guys, these bumps in the road sometimes [46:51] can actually help us more than hurt us because talking now [46:58] and and like she say, I've been given reports and what's going on now. We need [47:04] to know what's happening. This this can take place. That's what he says starting [47:10] off. Before these things are done, we have to do it. Yes sir. [47:14] » I can answer I can answer [47:20] » when the police department was issued the animal control pound. [47:26] » Mhm. >> It should have never been placed under [47:29] the police department. >> That's not when it happened. [47:32] » What? >> That's not when it happened. [47:34] » That's exactly when it happened. >> It wasn't. I'll tell you when it [47:37] happened. >> Our um ordinances are from 2012. That's [47:41] correct. >> It's been that long. It's been so the [47:44] old council before I even came to this state, the old council agreed to have [47:51] the uh the shel animal shelter fall underneath the category for the police [47:57] department. >> That's what happened. [48:00] » But it was put on me just last year. >> It was put on not last year, the year [48:03] before. But it was >> clarification. This problem started [48:05] before I had correct and cleaned that place up. [48:09] » That is correct. This problem started in January or February of 2024. [48:20] That's when this issue happened. January or February of 2024. You didn't get [48:26] » wasn't under there. >> It was still on the police department [48:29] » in 2014. >> It's been on the police department since [48:32] 2012. >> So what was the catalyst? You're going [48:35] to identify a catalyst. What was that? >> Changing the leadership control. [48:40] It doesn't matter what the chief. So, so I just I want I want y'all to understand [48:44] it does not matter if the old chief wasn't signed or not. The old council in [48:49] 2012 are the ones who assigned it to the [48:54] police department. >> I agree. They did it on paper. They [48:57] never took action. >> Then guess what? Then we messed up. We [49:01] shouldn't do anything on paper that we're not we're not willing to follow [49:05] through because that's that's focus. >> You are correct. Y'all council did it [49:08] and they never followed through with anything they said it was going to do. [49:12] They put stuff on paper and that's the >> No, 2012 was It was on paper in 2012 [49:18] for 8 years and it they never >> That's cuz you never That's cuz you [49:22] never read the charter. >> Yes, ma'am. [49:24] » Yes, ma'am. Wait, y'all. Wait, y'all. >> Don't accuse me not reading. [49:28] » I'm telling you. It's been in the charter since 2012. [49:32] » Wait a minute. Okay. Whoa. Whoa. Whoa. >> Go ahead, ma'am. [49:35] » Yes, ma'am. Department of Agriculture coming back, [49:38] pardon me. >> When is the Department of Agriculture [49:40] coming back to make sure that these >> we don't know yet. [49:44] » Okay. Um Department of Agriculture assess fines and penalties. [49:49] » Are y'all fine? I mean, if they found you deficiencies, [49:53] » no ma'am, we didn't get anything. >> No, ma'am. If you don't address this, [49:57] you could be. >> Yeah. [49:59] » That's that's what they that's what was going on here. But listen y'all. [50:03] » Well, I do I do have one more question leading to what we were just talking [50:07] about. So, we have had some rocky rocky situations lately. [50:12] » The other people that are pulling from you guys. Now, we just got hit right in [50:17] this meeting with a list of demands that you guys want us to do from here on out. [50:21] That's fine. >> I wouldn't say demands. [50:23] » That's fine. It were they were demands in in my [50:26] » required after I've been working with you guys for 14 years. They kind of look [50:29] like demands. So, did we also require that of Thomasville today? [50:35] » Or is this just new because we don't want because to your partners right [50:39] here, it looks like you don't want us involved. That's what it looks like. [50:43] That's what I'm trying to convey to you guys. [50:46] » No, you you want the partners involved. I again, I think the whole thing, y'all, [50:53] is the communication. People not talking to each other, not telling me what's [50:58] going on. As I constantly tell sometime my working [51:04] partners, we have too many chiefs and not enough Indian. I agree. [51:09] » And everybody want to know what's going on. But when we let people know who's [51:15] actually in the trenches doing the work, what's going on and and let you know [51:21] what's taking place, you won't have these situations. So I ask you I asked [51:27] you let's work together and there we we'll we can get to it. [51:32] » So did you know about the meeting on Friday with department? [51:36] » I didn't know about no meeting. The only thing I know about was when I was [51:41] contacted that the animal shelter was closed. I said again is what I said [51:47] » right >> and I said well now wait what's going on [51:49] at where the stone got. I said, "Well, whoa, wait a minute now. They just put [51:54] some air after dishes and all that out there. Then you mean the place is tore [51:58] up again, right?" >> Yes. And this time they demanded that [52:02] something be done immediately. This is why you all should have been contacting [52:08] them. Who should have been the the the gobetween with you? I don't know. That [52:16] has to be done. And that's why I say these meetings, I'm a firm believer. [52:21] » Do we know who was in the meeting? >> Can I interject here? My name has been [52:26] thrown around a few times even though I am there, but I'm not there. You know [52:29] what I mean? So, I need to clarify first of all that I sent those demands or [52:33] directions, if you will, in a me in an email to the VHOS email as well as [52:38] council um before lunchtime today, which gave you over 24 hours because it said [52:44] Wednesday by 5:00 p.m. First of all, second of all, I would just ask, you [52:49] know, look around in the room and even on the phone, who's phoning into this [52:54] meeting, who's at that meeting tonight, and you will see who is trying our best, [52:59] our absolute best. Because if y'all don't know, just the time and energy and [53:02] effort that you spend with this shelter, I devote to the city only coming on in [53:06] January. I will tell you, I lose money weekly with my employed job because I'm [53:12] self-employed, and time is money when you're self-employed. And this shelter [53:16] this week has taken up a lot of time, which I'm glad to do. That's the job [53:19] that I signed up to do. But I would like a little bit of the respect that we're [53:23] trying to give y'all in return to us. I am currently at home with my kids [53:27] phoning in and trying my best to listen and hear all of your concerns and answer [53:32] and give appropriate solutions best that I can. And that is all that I'm asking [53:37] for y'all to do. Give us the same respect back. a look around in the room [53:41] and see who is willing to partner with you all and try our best to move forward [53:47] with this. I gave those directions trying to propose a solution which you [53:52] can ask any council member and any city employee that I work with. That is my [53:57] number one goal to give appropriate feasible solutions for everyone involved [54:01] no matter what department and what issue is at hand. I gather all the information [54:05] that I can and then try to give solutions. That is all that I tried to [54:09] do. That is all that I'm asking for moving forward. And to your point [54:13] earlier about, you know, every dog in there is trying to be rescued. I [54:17] understand that. I'm sorry if it didn't come across that way. I understand that. [54:20] What I meant was if they if it is actively in motion, and I think I said [54:24] those two words, but if it's actively in motion, meaning you have confirmed [54:28] someone who is very interested in a dog to be rescued, like let us know that. [54:34] and you and even like an estimated timeline because I understand things can [54:38] fall through the cracks. You know, they might not fulfill that hole with another [54:41] dog from another area. I understand those things can happen. But if as long [54:45] as we're in the know about some sort of communication written and electronic, [54:50] that's all that I was asking for. And no, I don't want to put more on your [54:54] plate. And I'm sorry if it feels that way. I'm just trying to protect everyone [54:58] who is adequately and appropriately trying to partner together moving [55:01] forward because no, I don't want to see two decades of work and volunteer and [55:06] service thrown down the drain because I know that the city in our capacity [55:11] cannot take it on without you guys. I'm fully aware and I appreciate everything [55:15] that you do. Well, and we appreciate everything that you do and you've been [55:19] very responsive to me when I reach out to you and I'm that was not uh directed [55:24] towards you. But I I do want to say that there's some gray area there too, [55:28] Elizabeth. Sometimes we put money and bedding into dogs based off behavior. [55:33] You know, you might have a male dog at the shelter that needs to be neutered um [55:38] just for behavior reasons. So, it might not always be that we put money in this [55:43] dog because they've got a rescue party that's super interested and ready to [55:49] take them next week. Sometimes it's because we want your people that are out [55:52] there working every day to have a decent I don't know interaction with the dogs [55:58] because sometimes when you got females in heat, you got males out there going [56:02] crazy, they're getting out, they're tearing up kennels, they're I mean [56:05] they're acting crazy. So, it's not always just based off rescue interest. [56:09] whenever we put money into these dogs, but how much money does the city [56:14] actually put into the medical at all? Just as just in general, [56:17] » I don't have those figures for you, ma'am. [56:19] » Is it possibly zero? May I ask? >> Well, I will tell you it's not zero. [56:23] » Okay. >> It's not zero. [56:24] » Is it close to zero? >> Um [56:28] I don't I can't give you those figures. And the reason why cuz a few months ago [56:32] there was bills that came in and some covered and but that's why I'm saying I [56:36] don't know the exact figures. the person that knows. I'm not going to say it [56:41] because she does accounting. She does she does pay accounts payable. That's [56:45] why I say we need some of the names. >> The $3,000 I've spent. [56:51] » It can't be. And it was $16,000. >> And I knew I had one more ask of [56:57] Elizabeth. Elizabeth and I talked. She was not aware of the stock on Thursday [57:02] and she did not know what was going on Friday morning. So I know she wasn't [57:05] involved in the meeting. Mr. Jones, were you involved in the meeting? [57:09] » Let if I know the city clerk. Okay. Okay. [57:13] » And Miss Bernice, I mean, what about you? [57:15] » There was no meeting. >> Okay. So, I don't know who put it out [57:19] there that there was a meeting. >> Okay. [57:21] » I came in a little after 7 and at 77 on Friday morning, I had an email from [57:31] Officer Ram with the stop order attached. [57:34] » Okay. >> So, Why was nothing on Thursday evening [57:38] at city council? >> I didn't know anything about came in on [57:42] Thursday. So >> I I don't know. I can't answer that. I [57:46] truly cannot. >> But the only way I knew about this was [57:50] an email Friday morning and officer Brown said, "I do not remember the [57:55] mayor's email. Can you >> meaning?" So So when we say meeting, we [58:02] need to make sure that this wasn't a qual. You talking about just people [58:06] sitting down having conversations? >> What was the meeting? [58:09] » No, that's what that's what I'm saying cuz I wasn't at the meeting. Mr. Johnson [58:13] wasn't at the meeting. Elizabeth wasn't at the meeting. And that's three people [58:17] right there to in order to make the point. So just [58:20] » Elizabeth over the shelter. >> Is that [58:25] » technically she would be >> That's strange. Okay. But there was well [58:30] when I when you say a meeting I put the agenda out there and let everybody know [58:35] but there was not this type of meeting the department of agriculture come [58:44] » had to come see >> that was the brown though which is which [58:47] is appropriate because he's the animal control officer but I guess what I [58:50] really want the council to hear and hopefully stick in your pocket for the [58:54] next time the only rescue that is working the I've released side of this [59:00] is veh. If I as guardians wanted to pull a dog, I call Janet or I text M. If they [59:07] need help with a dog, they're going to text me. All of those things don't go [59:10] through Brown. So, the fact that we put Brown in this position and said all [59:16] of this weight goes on you and now you figure it out. That poor man's doing the [59:19] best that he can, but we sidestep the actual people who do it entirely and [59:24] none of this would have been an issue. If they ran into a stressful situation [59:28] and couldn't do it, it doesn't come down to Thomasville. It comes down to hey [59:31] heart, hey Boore, hey guys, we got to do something. We got to get this taken care [59:35] of because that is how we have done it for a decade. Well, then longer, but you [59:38] know, the rest of them come in the day. So, in this situation, I'm hoping that [59:42] you will take away that this is not what an animal control officer does. And we [59:46] have put this man in a a position of spokesperson without having any [59:50] knowledge about what he's supposed to do. The department of a does not care [59:53] about rep say that because someone quote me. The department of a [59:58] has a bunch of stuff on their plate. Rescues and the movement of animals and [1:00:02] whether or not the live release occurs isn't really top of their priority. [1:00:06] Right? For our citizens it is. For our rescues it is. And their understanding [1:00:12] of our inner structure is not necessarily what they're going to be [1:00:15] making their decisions on. So when Brown says, "Hey, I'm going to move those dogs [1:00:18] to where our our evacuation point is, they're going to say, "Check the box. [1:00:22] Love it. That works. It's all legal, right?" But then the people who have [1:00:26] been working under the table without the acknowledgement that they should have [1:00:29] forward funding all of this, they end up getting stuck holding the back and they [1:00:33] won't do it again. I have heard these ladies complain about things 10 years [1:00:38] and what I got was not a complaint. What I got was, I can't do it anymore. We're [1:00:42] going to lose them because we are not acknowledging them as the most intricral [1:00:48] part of our successful system. Not Brown, not the council, not the [1:00:53] taxpayers, the most intricral part of our system. They are why animals [1:00:58] survive. They are how animals get out. That is how we network. It has nothing [1:01:02] to do with Brown. It has nothing to do with the partner bag. It has nothing to [1:01:06] do with council. >> It is them. Okay, [1:01:08] » but let me go back really quick about what do we do with the doggies? Find [1:01:12] somebody. >> We'll talk about because we need your [1:01:14] help. >> Wait now. Uh, we got one more and then [1:01:18] one more and then we got to go. Y'all listen. Everybody saying the same thing, [1:01:25] the communication. If it wasn't done right this time by George, we have to [1:01:30] get it right and we have to talk to you. Only one chance to get it right. [1:01:38] » No. No. Wait. Wait. >> Are you trying to limit the amount of [1:01:41] concern in the room? >> No. No. No. No. Home eat dinner because [1:01:46] » I am ready to go home and eat dinner. But no. [1:01:51] Wait a minute. Wait. One second. Get a little bit of order. [1:01:54] » Hold it. Hold it. Listen. >> This is what I've been saying. Hold for [1:01:59] one second now. Just communication. And I'm not saying [1:02:04] everybody's been saying the same thing. When this when this stop order came [1:02:10] down, the city worked on it or whoever worked on it and was passed down to the [1:02:18] elected people and whoever made it the city and I don't know who, but they did [1:02:23] it and it should have been communicated with them, the people that's working out [1:02:29] there. It wasn't done. That's why I say I apologize on behalf of whoever and let [1:02:35] us make sure it don't happen again. >> But it sounds like it didn't happen. [1:02:40] Somebody's covering up because there's no communication. There's nobody up here [1:02:44] that's willing to say they had a meeting and Georgia Department of Agriculture [1:02:48] even step in. The facility has been in disrepair way longer than before the [1:02:53] storm. >> They have hosted several outreach days [1:02:56] where I personally have went out there. I got this. I have went out there [1:03:01] personally and walked animals with them and I've seen the love they pour into [1:03:05] that facility and although they didn't have a very nice facility, they have [1:03:09] made the most of it for several years and I just don't believe it's fair for [1:03:12] them to have to sit here and fight for the right to do a volunteer job. None of [1:03:17] these women are getting paid. They're taking money out of their own pockets to [1:03:21] fund animals [1:03:25] » and and they're doing a good job. And this is why I'm saying somebody cuz the [1:03:31] people that has been dealing with it should know a channel [1:03:35] » take over and deal with it instead of sliding it to somebody else. [1:03:39] » Absolutely. >> How much does the city fund the shelter? [1:03:44] Why is it disrepair to begin with? >> We fund the schools. We fund taxpayer [1:03:49] money. I'm a taxpayer. I back up. I'm a voter and I don't get rid of some of [1:03:53] these people up here who are not willing to success. [1:03:57] because y'all are not doing your jobs. >> Well, I wouldn't say that we're not [1:04:02] doing our jobs. >> Two years to appear. If you have a [1:04:07] squeaky door at the house, >> but did you know that the repairs needed [1:04:11] to happen? Did you guys actually know? >> Yes. [1:04:14] » So, you knew for two years and they that we were stuck in a bad spot. [1:04:17] » We knew the repairs needed to be done. We kept talking about the repairs. When [1:04:22] it came down to funding, we could not do the repairs because we did not have the [1:04:27] funding to do it. >> The budget for the following year. [1:04:32] » I want to clarify that budget. >> We even offered to donate which I I [1:04:37] spoke with Miss Bernice about that. Miss Bernice said it's insurance. Don't don't [1:04:41] touch it. cuz that was that was one of the procedures that we had because we [1:04:46] could not do any repairs on anything >> that was covered [1:04:50] » to your limitation on the insurance. >> We were instructed not to fix any [1:04:57] building that was covered by the insurance factors. [1:05:03] » How that go? >> Say again. Now that goal today, [1:05:11] » we're shut down. So now it's a priority because we [1:05:16] » became a priority because the Georgia Department of Agriculture bringing down [1:05:19] your neck. >> That's why I have a close working [1:05:22] relationship with the Georgia Department of Agriculture and they only step in [1:05:25] when things get in a terrible situation. Clearly they've been warning you and now [1:05:29] there's an issue at that hand that literally closed for animals to be [1:05:33] transported elsewhere and there's no documentation. There's definitely [1:05:36] nobody's answer >> for which what are you asking ma'am? [1:05:39] » The department they had to have meet with somebody. I mean somebody had to be [1:05:43] there as a chain of command >> give y'all the information that the [1:05:48] place was being closed down and why that was Brown though. Correct. Brown was [1:05:51] there. He's the animal control officer which is reasonable and that makes [1:05:54] sense. the dissemination of information after that is where we have a problem. [1:05:57] » And I got it Friday morning. Anybody knows me, I am straight up. I'm black [1:06:01] and white. And I'm sick of this mess. >> I have met with them. They dumped it on [1:06:06] me. I told the mayor that I have no knowledge of animal control or [1:06:10] operations, but he insisted I run it. I use this terminology. He throw me down a [1:06:16] black hole without a flashlight. Did I not tell y'all that? [1:06:19] » The problem didn't start with the police department. Let me crank something. It [1:06:22] was put on there by a previous council. >> That's correct. [1:06:25] » Nobody proofed anything. I'm always finding stuff that needs to be revised. [1:06:29] I'm steady bringing attention. Nothing being done. I am a police chief who [1:06:34] gives a data about everybody. And I will do the same for you I do for everybody [1:06:39] else. But when you can't get nothing done, I'm leaving here because of this [1:06:43] because I have fought and thought and false. It didn't start with us. It [1:06:48] started WITH THE MAYOR. NOBODY WILL SAY IT. [1:06:52] I will. Y'all can run me off tomorrow, but that's where it started at. [1:06:57] » I will say previously I met with the mayor that was not this mayor. [1:07:02] » So, I had never met with the police chief until this administration come [1:07:06] over. >> Well, I'm saying [1:07:08] » she is correct. And I'm sorry, y'all. >> You're good. [1:07:13] » Yes, ma'am. >> I've met with this lady here several [1:07:16] times, but I think she knows it. I've tried. I've worked with her. I want to [1:07:20] tell you something. I won't do. I ain't never fact down from nobody about [1:07:24] nothing. If I tell you I'm going to do it, you call me out on. [1:07:30] We got a problem here. I didn't know anything about till Friday. As far as a [1:07:33] meeting, I don't know of a meeting. I was not in a meeting. I don't know of [1:07:37] anybody here having a meeting. I honestly don't. I'm not offending [1:07:40] anybody. Okay? I just want some clarification here because we're just [1:07:43] talking around the room. I don't know of a meeting. As soon as I was aware of it, [1:07:47] I went straight to Bernice's office. So, a few minutes after 8, she said, "Honey, [1:07:51] I just got a paper, too. What we gonna do?" And I went back there and told the [1:07:56] mayor, "I'm in." >> Yes, ma'am. [1:08:00] » Yes, ma'am. >> There it is. Um, I said I wouldn't say [1:08:04] anything. Sorry. >> We miss you. [1:08:06] » We have to. >> We miss you. [1:08:07] » I walked away. I walked away when Rene last year. [1:08:12] » Um, I'm a retired educator. I spent 20 Karen Bowen. I am the um CEO of another [1:08:19] rescue in Hingley County, a part of Adley. We have a shelter license for [1:08:23] $40. I currently house 37 dogs. I'm 65 years old, retired. Um [1:08:30] work 8 to 10 hours a day with 37 dogs. Over [1:08:35] 50% of them are pets and black dogs that nobody wants. Don't ask me why, but that [1:08:40] came over 50% are from Jeff Davis County and the Z worst that we were called when [1:08:47] animal control could not or would not step in. I had [1:08:52] after I retired in 2011 from the school system, I went to the then mayor um and [1:08:58] said I had I started volunteering, excuse me, 2011, I started volunteering. [1:09:02] I guess that's where I really I mean I knew Mary could impact in some of these [1:09:05] but we started working together then as a volunteer I saw some egregious things [1:09:11] at that shelter awful dogs not being fed I will say it I have said this to the [1:09:16] mayor >> days on end dogs not being fed um anyway [1:09:21] so I went to then mayor and I said listen I'm retired hire me I won't cost [1:09:26] you anything but just $12 an hour when I work and I can keep that shelter clean I [1:09:31] can keep those dogs exercised and fed and tend to their medical needs. At that [1:09:35] time, I was not aware of how much um will be us was there, but we were I was [1:09:41] just getting education about what all they did. But anyway, as an employee um [1:09:46] we have a very good relationship. The former mayor really not care what [1:09:49] happened in that shelter as long as things were going smooth. And there and [1:09:53] guess what y'all? Everybody say that there were no hiccups. [1:09:57] the problems happened, the issues, the the uh lack of communication has got has [1:10:05] has occurred in the past two years and everybody's dancing around about it. [1:10:09] Don't want to blame the council member because I know the conversations I've [1:10:13] had with some of the individual council council members and I know we have a [1:10:17] newer now who I've not met, but I know they were more than willing to look into [1:10:20] things and try to do the right thing. They were the problem is they weren't. [1:10:26] They didn't know there had been too many things going on by closed doors starting [1:10:30] at the top decisions made without informing the public without informing [1:10:35] the even the people that are in that should be in charge that should make [1:10:39] decision and I said I wouldn't open my mouth but you danced around it and it's [1:10:43] right there for you. you have broken the trust of the people that have done and [1:10:48] done and done for the dogs and for the community. And until somebody steps in [1:10:54] and says this cannot continue to happen, you as an individual do not get to make [1:10:59] decisions about that shelter. Uh that's where all the problems started and it [1:11:03] started when the American. [1:11:07] » Yes, ma'am. >> Yes. [1:11:10] I'm sorry. That's all I want to say. [1:11:14] Well, again, [1:11:19] please don't leave sh. Please work with the city. Help us to [1:11:26] start communicating like we should and let's get it done. It can be done. um [1:11:34] the things that it brought to their attention as you said when you come and [1:11:39] give those reports those reports should mean something and they should uh if [1:11:43] it's something that you need out there something that's going on it should be [1:11:47] brought for us or brought to us when we have council meetings so it can be [1:11:51] addressed again I think these kind of meetings are good I think that when we [1:11:57] hear each other's side and we able to talk and and and get these things out in [1:12:04] the open, it works. That's all I can say. [1:12:08] » I'm sorry. I totally you. Excellent. And and if if we can get some procedures [1:12:12] into place so that the same thing doesn't keep happening that I struggled [1:12:15] with for ever since, you know, as I said, uh but the one thing we haven't [1:12:20] had answered, those eight dogs, is it I still don't hear an answer that we're [1:12:26] going to be able to get those eight dogs back. [1:12:28] » Yeah. Reasonably, you know. >> Hey, hey, I have an answer. I have an [1:12:31] answer. You guys know that at this point it's an agency transfer. The agency [1:12:34] transfer means we're now at the whim of Thomas. [1:12:37] » We're going to make contact and um >> I've already talked to Thomas. I called [1:12:41] him on the other line because I'm calling in. So I called him on another [1:12:44] line and he is willing to have documentation and do what if like if we [1:12:49] can he first of all he is willing for it to be a temporary thing and in you know [1:12:54] two weeks if construction is done and we can house them again they can return. [1:12:58] Also, if in those two weeks y'all can rescue them out, like he's perfectly [1:13:02] fine with that. However, if if y'all want to say, "Hey, work with us to get [1:13:06] these fostered out." Like, if he has connections, he's willing to do that, [1:13:09] too. He literally said he will work with us in any capacity that we need. He [1:13:13] literally wants to partner with us and do whatever is best for the dogs and for [1:13:17] us. [1:13:20] » Thank you, Elizabeth. You're awesome. >> We're missing the point, though, I [1:13:24] think. And that the issue is that you already have that support that's here [1:13:27] that could have dealt with those dogs had they been given the opportunity. I [1:13:30] know the number around but >> it's important because now their money [1:13:33] is in it and those dogs are there and Thomasville may be fantastic. By the [1:13:36] way, they lost their own contract with their county to do municipal sheltering [1:13:40] because they weren't doing what they should have done. But I digress on that. [1:13:43] At the other side of it, that's another county. All of us are struggling. Nobody [1:13:47] has good resources. We're all trying to get dogs. [1:13:50] to have them have those dogs. It's not even fair to them in their defense to [1:13:54] feed, farmer, manage, deal with those dogs. And to the dogs, it's not fair to [1:13:59] sit over there for two weeks not beingworked either. So, if that's truly [1:14:03] the case, you need your live release coordinators who know the dogs, who [1:14:07] understand what their needs are, who are our network connections to everybody [1:14:10] else to talk to Thomasville. That line of communication is what needs to open [1:14:15] up. Not Brown who does not know what he's doing in that aspect, who doesn't [1:14:18] have any business being in the light release side of rescue. Let them who've [1:14:23] done it this entire time, open up that communication with Thomasville because [1:14:26] right now what it looks like is it's Thomasville versus Beos with Brown in [1:14:30] the middle. And that's not going to be good for anybody including the dogs or [1:14:33] either rescue or the other rescues on the outside. So figure out how to open [1:14:37] up that communication. Let the girls who know what they're doing work with the [1:14:41] other gentlemen figure out what they want to do with the dogs that they have [1:14:44] money in if we're opening communication. [1:14:50] » That would be my thing. My question is those eight dogs right now, how do we [1:14:55] communicate to pull those dogs if we have a rescue within the two weeks? [1:14:59] » So those are some details that we're going to work. Basically, this meeting [1:15:03] here, this meeting here was just to inform everyone that there was a mistake [1:15:09] made. We're going to own it. I will take it [1:15:13] all myself. In the future, if this happens, similar to we have to evacuate [1:15:19] or do whatever we have to do at the shelter for whatever reason, the very [1:15:23] first persons that we're going to be calling is our partners. [1:15:26] » Are you changing the evacuation plan then? Stop. I don't think [1:15:30] » No, no, that's not No. The evacuation plan specifically says what I'm saying. [1:15:37] » Now, we're going to have priority. >> Well, the reason I'm asking is because [1:15:41] we never saw what the evacuation plan is made. [1:15:45] » Um, but I know that I know what we did for evacuation prior to that. I mean, I [1:15:50] know we were out there literally the day of Colleen because [1:15:54] » No, and I'm not taking out. I'm not taking anything from [1:15:57] » I'm just saying we were never made that was never made transparent and that's [1:16:00] been recent. VHOS is priority on moving any dogs that we [1:16:09] have in the city of Hazer shelter and if they cannot handle for whatever reason [1:16:14] meaning you're going to work your networks and whatever else the [1:16:16] surrounding area and let's just say they can't do anything with your connections [1:16:21] then you get back with the city and say hey we can't do it we have a partner in [1:16:26] Thomasville we're going to see what they can take and that's what's going to [1:16:29] happen from now on That is the procedure. [1:16:34] » We're going to have that in writing somewhere. [1:16:35] » Oh, yeah. It's going to Oh, yeah. It's going to be in writing and it will be a [1:16:38] policy. >> When will it be voted on? [1:16:43] » When will it be voted on? >> The evacuation plan has already been put [1:16:47] together. It's just the verbs needs to be cleaned up. [1:16:50] » So, when will it be voted? >> If [1:16:54] we can, >> we have we have one in place. It's just [1:16:58] which is a plan of action that we have. It just the verbage needs to be cleaned [1:17:02] up and vetted by our attorneys and then it will be published. [1:17:06] » Will this be excuse me for interrupting because I have to remind you all of [1:17:10] certain things. >> Will [clears throat] it be an ordinance? [1:17:14] » Mhm. >> Because if it's an ordinance, [1:17:18] » we have to have two readings and >> um a referendum. That's what we're going [1:17:23] to do. >> Refer referendum goes for a vote. [1:17:28] Resolution can be voted on in a regular council [1:17:32] meeting. If it's an ordinance, you have to have two readings. One one month, one [1:17:38] the next month. In a regular council meeting, not in a special call meeting, [1:17:42] not in a work session. side. >> But you're doing this for the [1:17:47] requirement of the department of a correct because the department of bag [1:17:52] what we're talking about now >> the evacuation plan it has to be noted [1:17:55] for the department of bag. >> That is correct. However, we're adding [1:17:58] in specific verbiage so this doesn't happen again. [1:18:05] » And you think that requires both? >> We're going to talk to our we going to [1:18:10] talk to our attorneys to make sure that we do what we're supposed to do. [1:18:13] » Yeah. We should have that to begin with. It would have not been under what we're [1:18:19] supposed to. >> Miss May, if I may say, I and I had this [1:18:22] to happen today. I've only been the city clerk 10 years. [1:18:27] So, someone was here in my spot for 50 years. [1:18:31] I literally had to go back to 97 to look for procedures [1:18:38] that were voted on and approved in n actually it was the gentleman was hired [1:18:44] in 97 that were voted on in 2000 that I had to send for an open records request [1:18:52] and it was only in the minutes of the city of Hurst. [1:18:58] So, those are the struggles that I as city clerk have to deal with in looking [1:19:05] for things. And I don't know, and Mary Katherine may be able to help with this [1:19:12] since she's been there 14 years. I don't even know that there was any written [1:19:18] things in the minutes when soaps came in. So, [1:19:23] that's the way it worked before. And we're Before I leave, I'm going on 70 [1:19:30] years old. I'm going on 70 years old. Before I leave, I hope a few things are [1:19:34] in place that never have been in place. [1:19:40] » I try. That's all I can do. >> What about the dogs that are left? [1:19:47] » Well, if we let Dwayne in the meeting, I will be taking the six dogs to the [1:19:51] rescue pulling. There are six dogs in the shelter that [1:19:56] were allowed to be released to be house rescue partners. [1:20:01] We end this meeting and I can go get them and take them where they need to be [1:20:05] tonight. Um so um we will continue to hopefully have good discussions. You all [1:20:11] have my phone number because give it out to the public so you have it. Um so [1:20:15] let's have some conversations. Let's be transparent to not only the behior [1:20:19] citizens in this community. Um, and let's make better choices and changes [1:20:23] moving forward. >> Wait, wait a minute. Now, you say you [1:20:28] going to take them yourself? >> I transport 99.9% of the dogs at least. [1:20:33] » She works right there. She likes road trips. [1:20:36] » I have 95,000 miles on that. >> She personally transport them to where [1:20:41] they need to go >> just for breakfast. [1:20:43] » All over the place. I mean, but thank you. That's okay. Okay. I'm [1:20:52] » That's [snorts] fine. That's fine. And did I understand that the other [1:20:56] eight that are in Thomasville now you or what someone from this council is [1:21:03] going to ensure work to ensure that they will be [1:21:08] transferred back here or that they can be pulled over there during the two week [1:21:13] or four-week interim by a licensed rescue. [1:21:16] » Yes, ma'am. Yeah. >> No, we're gonna I'm gonna [1:21:20] » I'm gonna work on this as soon as this is over with. [1:21:23] » We're going to get with one of our partners and ensure that this moves [1:21:27] smoothly. >> Are we good? [1:21:31] » We're going to relay this to everybody that sits at the table up there. Yes. [1:21:36] » Yes. >> But remember, before you get crucified [1:21:38] though, he really doesn't have the ability to do that. You guys know that [1:21:40] the ownership belongs to Thomasville. Now, I hope that it works, but I'm just [1:21:44] saying don't crucify him if he's trying. And I just [1:21:47] » they don't give up on >> I just meant the transparency of [1:21:50] speaking with you know your volunteers. >> Yes. [1:21:53] » To try to help you guys. >> Yes. [1:21:55] » That's what we're going to do. >> Okay. [1:21:56] » We're going to get better at it. >> Another thing like in the future. [1:22:00] » But can you stop? We encourage you and who's [1:22:04] just [1:22:08] I have a rescue rescue also frost rescue and um I volunteer [1:22:16] How many years? >> More than me. [1:22:19] Yes, she husb. [1:22:36] But anyways, in case something happens in the future, again like this, [1:22:41] » um I know officer Brown say, but you know, he he was sitting there saying, [1:22:46] "Yes, we have a contract with him." Well, in reality, no, he didn't have a [1:22:51] contract. >> What you're talking about in the future? [1:22:53] » In the future, have a contract so that whenever they leave [1:23:00] » or statement of understanding or something of that nature, [1:23:03] » they're going to be coming back. >> Yes, ma'am. And I do want to say because [1:23:07] I did volunteer for years. There have been things through the year. [1:23:12] This is before y'all. There have been things through the years. Always break [1:23:17] up the shelter. It's always put on the back burner. I I don't know if any of [1:23:22] y'all have ever went out there and tried to clean out a drain [1:23:27] with you know what all in it. But I've been there, done that. No pay, no [1:23:32] nothing. walked them, stayed out there with them for hours [1:23:37] cleaning. But it [1:23:43] you put your heart and soul in to do with this. [1:23:48] And these animals deserve better than the [1:23:52] chance they got. And that's what we're trying to give them is a better second [1:23:56] chance. And we put our heart and soul into them. and we just we want them [1:24:02] taken care of and we will, you know, we will still sit there and fix where [1:24:07] they've tried to bust out so that y'all don't have to. We piece things back [1:24:11] together, you know, but we just definitely want transparency from the [1:24:15] future in how things are going because we we put our heart and soul into this. [1:24:22] » Yes, ma'am. >> We definitely appreciate it. [1:24:27] » All right. Without further ado, [1:24:33] Mr. Johnson, do you have a motion? [1:24:36] » Oh, that's right. I'm glad glad y'all came [1:24:40] y'all. We have to have a open line and um communication is the key. [1:24:48] » Amen. >> Hey, y'all know today's Mr. Johnson's [1:24:51] birthday, too. >> He's 76. [applause]