[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:03] Good morning, everyone. Thank you all for being here. I call this meeting to order a time 1031. My name is Council Member Jimmy Paluso. I'm very grateful to see such a large crowd. I had a feeling that we'd have a good, a good group show of this morning. We're just going to go around the table real quick and do introductions, starting with Colleen. [0:21] Colleen Hamsey, Council Research? [0:25] Red is speaking. [0:26] for the administration. [0:29] Shannon MacGales office of general council. [0:32] Nick Howland City Council at large group three. [0:36] Jimmy Pulsos City Council District 7. [0:38] Monet holders City Council elect at large group 1. [0:42] We're grateful to have a city council member elect [0:44] holder with us going to be swearing in on Monday. [0:48] I also want to recognize we have state representative Dean Black [0:51] in the room. [0:52] He came here as well. [0:53] We're grateful to your presence. [0:57] So this meeting's gotten a good amount of fanfare and I'm glad to see such a large group [1:02] of folks in here who I think kind of me or the political spectrum. [1:07] And I think that's really important because this is an issue, or at least this is a conversation [1:11] that's happening at the national level, at the state level, and at the local level, about [1:16] what are these cameras that have been popping up a lot in the past several years? [1:20] what kind of data do they have, what relationship do they have with law enforcement is law enforcement getting the best use out of them? [1:27] And also, is there constitutionality questions that we should be asking and that, you know, neighbors and communities have been asking for a while now? [1:36] And so I just kind of want to get as many answers as we could at this moment. There's no draft legislation as it yet. [1:42] Kind of kind of tinkering with ideas of what I would expect to file if we can. [1:49] And so, you know, we have one of our attorneys here, one of our best attorneys who also worked in the prosecutor's office for quite some time, so she has a really good expertise on, you know, that kind of level of criminal justice. [2:01] And all that to say, if you do have public comment cards, please bring them up. I want to hear from as many folks as possible that we do have the room only for a limited amount of time. [2:09] All right, so heading down the agenda goals for the automated surveillance equipment policies regulation and a possible temporary moratorium. [2:20] So, as we've been kind of looking at stuff from the policy perspective from city council's perspective, I just don't know what as a county and as a municipality we have the rights to do when it comes to anything involving these cameras. [2:34] right. They're in the right of way, a public right of way. So one may assume that being in the [2:39] public right of way, you have to get a permit or there must be some sort of methodology as [2:44] to how they got installed. And so first off, I don't know, if the mayor's office or someone [2:50] has done any research on this as to how some of these got installed or if anyone has any knowledge [2:57] of that. [3:02] Breeding noise for the administration. I don't have direct answers for you, but I've made lists [3:06] some of these questions, and we'll get inside it back to you guys. [3:10] So yeah, that was one of my first questions [3:11] is who's installing these cameras? [3:14] And our taxpayer dollars being used to install them, [3:17] are there no taxpayer dollars being used to install them? [3:19] But then when there is a subscription service, [3:22] whether it be flock or one of the other things, [3:24] and that's the other thing of note here, [3:26] is it's not just flock, right? [3:28] This is a larger conversation [3:31] about kind of these automated camera devices. [3:35] So, I think what I would like to see in the minor draft legislation that I have is kind [3:43] of a couple different points. One is an immediate moratorium for about 120 days on a new [3:49] cameras being installed in the city of Jacksonville. Two was an inventory of all cameras [3:55] for the city of Jacksonville. [4:00] A new process to be drafted that allows for public participation for when cameras do get installed [4:06] or are going through the installation process, which I believe would go through the CPACs, [4:11] setting that makes sense. [4:12] CPACs for those of you familiar are the community groups, the citizen-like groups. [4:19] We have, I think, five of them. [4:21] They're six one throughout the city and so oftentimes kind of land use and zoning issues. [4:26] Go before the CPAC, it's a good way for the public to be involved in the process. [4:30] So hey, if any new cameras are being installed, it has to go through and be brief in front of that group. [4:36] And then the last thing that I've really been tinkering with is, and it's what I've been hearing a lot, [4:41] is how do we maybe remove these cameras? [4:45] Now, the first thing I should note is, as in my conversations with JSO, [4:49] They're very much in support of these cameras, and have said they have helped lead to reducing crime, to solving crimes, to ensuring that if there's a missing persons or something along those lines. [5:00] Or someone who's running from the law that these are a value add. And I don't dispute that. I don't think that is, you know, I think so long as one crime is solved because of it, you could say, alright, I see the value in this, the crime prevention piece. [5:15] However, it's just a matter of the constitutional side. Well, we want to make sure that neighbors and those who live in the communities adjacent to these cameras are a way that there's a camera to begin with. [5:26] And two, if they don't want the camera right outside their neighborhood or within their neighborhood, [5:32] what kind of process exists to not only give them as much information about that camera as possible, [5:36] but ways to potentially remove the camera. [5:39] And so what I've been kind of tinkering with is if ever a neighborhood wants a speed hump, [5:45] right? I'm using a weird process here. [5:47] If ever a neighborhood wants a speed hump, they usually go through their city council member [5:52] or go through a process where they get a petition solicited from their neighbors. [5:56] Then a more formal petition process goes out to the property owners and they select whether or not they want a speedhump or not [6:02] So I would envision if we were looking to remove a camera that it would go through a similar process that the neighborhood would come to their [6:10] Elected or through the CPAC or through the city in general and just sort of [6:14] You know a petition process would go out to folks [6:17] They would say yes or no they want the camera removed as for how much it would cost remove the camera at that part [6:22] I don't know nor do I know you know [6:25] What if public dollars would be used to remove the camera or if it would be up to the neighborhoods and communities these are things [6:30] I'm just tinkering with that I've spoken to [6:32] General council about and they are doing their best to research this are they're any thoughts or comments from my colleagues at this moment [6:42] Council president Helen [6:43] Yeah, thank you customer to who so I was in the office today. So I wanted to [6:48] Already and when I saw you're having this meeting I wanted to drop by because this is a serious issue [6:52] It's a polarizing issue and I think it's one that [6:56] is really at the juxtaposition between public safety and privacy. [7:00] I think it's one we shouldn't rush into. [7:04] We should have a kind of a community-wide debate on this. [7:08] I know I've been talking about besides being Council President. [7:12] I'm also the JSO liaison. [7:13] So I speak regularly with the sheriff and his team on issues such as this. [7:16] And we've been talking on this issue. [7:18] And the sheriff shares the same concerns. [7:21] it's a very effective public safety tool, but he's concerned about misuse of data and [7:26] concerned about protecting Fourth Amendment privacy rights. [7:30] And I think he's shown through his four-year tenure in the office, four plus years that [7:36] he's willing to hold his own officers accountable and misuse. [7:41] And I think they've done that with David data and other things. [7:46] So that's, we have to think about those things as we go forward. [7:49] We also need to think about the state as an employer that they want to address this issue. [7:53] I heard Colonel Governor mentioned that he'd like to address it. [7:57] I've heard the incoming Governor mentioned that he'd like to address it. [8:03] Have you already chosen who the Governor is? [8:04] How are you, sir? [8:05] I have. [8:06] I've heard the state legislature think about how they want to address it. [8:10] So I think we need to think about the issue very carefully and make sure that we find the right balance [8:16] to listen to community concerns, and ensure that we protect people's privacy rights. [8:23] Thank you, Council President. Council member, I like to have any comments or thoughts on this. [8:28] You don't have to, but I just want to give you an opportunity. [8:31] Now, I feel like I have to. [8:33] Now, I just appreciate the opportunity. [8:35] Glad that the room is full. [8:37] This is an issue that I've heard a lot about over the last couple of weeks and months. [8:41] and a lot of concerns from all over Jacksonville [8:44] from Beaches, North Side, South Side. [8:46] I know there's something that we need to come into alignment [8:49] on but to appreciate the benefits of public safety [8:54] with these cameras, but also understand the concern [8:57] around surveillance and privacy. [9:00] So happy to be here today to hear more from the public. [9:06] Excellent, thank you. [9:07] And Ms. McGill, I'm sorry to put you on the hot seat here. [9:11] I'm seeing that a number of counties and cities within the state of Florida because, you know, if you look at the back of this handout, it shows a, thank you very much. [9:20] It shows a number of municipalities and parts of the country where a contract was canceled with whether it be flock or one of the other private companies. [9:31] However, very few of them are within the state of Florida, right, and so state law mandates a lot and they have a lot of control over our counties and our municipalities. [9:39] So it is kind of better, you know, it's good to see stuff from Connecticut and Massachusetts and Wyoming, but state law in Florida is very different. [9:49] So I don't know, Ms. McGill, I'm seeing a few stuff in here from Tampa, St. Pete, Leon County, and Lake County. [9:55] What kind of rights do we potentially have? Are we able to say, hey, you can't build anything? [10:00] In the right of way, even if it's a public entity, they can do it, or do you have any thoughts on that? [10:12] What other counties have done and what other cities and other counties have done in other states? [10:20] I have a distinct feeling that there is a lot more being done. It just doesn't make an Internet search very quickly. [10:28] Especially when you're talking about the passage of laws, sometimes it takes, you know, our process takes six weeks minimum. [10:35] So sometimes it's just not actually in the public view quite yet. [10:40] But the second level on that and it would be something I'd have to look at each one of these separately is just because a municipality has passed. [10:51] an ordinance doesn't mean that ordinance is actually fully lawful because they may be having a policy [10:59] declaration more than actually a change in the law. So I'd have to drill down on each one of them and as [11:05] to what can you do where it depends on the what and the where because of is it a state road, is it a [11:12] city road whose camera is it there's a lot it's it's a really broad detailed fact based question [11:19] that I'm happy to dig into. [11:21] Excellent. [11:22] And we appreciate that. [11:23] I think it's kind of worth digging into. [11:26] And, and, you know, to the, actually, [11:30] Stewart presented a game like, do you want to come up here and speak [11:32] from kind of your perspective on this? [11:34] It is not mandatory, sir. [11:36] I just, I want to give you the, the time and attention if you'd like. [11:39] Sure. [11:42] Have a seat with us. [11:47] All of the involvement on water waves. [11:56] Thank you. [11:57] Well, I think the city council president said it well, [12:01] when he said we stand at the juxtaposition [12:04] between security and liberty. [12:09] And we have to be very cautious in how we proceed. [12:13] We want to be safe. [12:14] We want to make sure law enforcement has the tools to keep us so. [12:17] But we also want to make sure that we don't create the tools [12:21] inadvertently in the service of security for one day [12:26] a police surveillance state to emerge. [12:29] And speaking as your state representative, I know that many of my colleagues in Tallahassee [12:34] share this concern. [12:36] We want to make sure that we remain a free people but also a secure people. [12:45] And so to that end, Councilman, thank you for calling this meeting. [12:49] President, Councilman, thank you for being here. [12:51] I think this is a very healthy discourse. [12:54] And I stepped in here before my other meeting, because above all else, I wanted to hear what you all have to say. [13:04] And so the less I speak, the more value I will get from you. [13:09] And so with that I'll close and thank you, Councilman. [13:12] Thank you, Rapid. [13:13] And I do appreciate you showing up. [13:14] I didn't want to put you on the spot, but I knew you'd have some pretty good perspective on this. [13:18] And you do have a district that is very diverse in terms of, you know, it's very rural in some parts [13:23] and quite a lot of new neighborhoods. [13:27] I do want to dive into public comment, [13:29] because I do think, do you have something that's going to [13:31] maybe one last thing? [13:32] Please go ahead and come up in case anyone wants to [13:34] make mention of it during public comment. [13:37] When I was talking with sheriff waters recently about how [13:40] the state is likely to take a position on this. [13:43] He said, well, there's no reason that we can't take a position [13:46] now to shore up privacy rights in the meantime. [13:50] And I understand that there might be another council member [13:52] considering a piece of legislation that would potentially make misuse of LPR data, a more [13:59] serious transgression. [14:01] So, a classy misdemeanor or accompanied by fines and potentially jail time. [14:07] And that is a measure to address concerns right now about abuse of LPR data and then wait [14:15] and see how the state handles some other things. [14:17] So, there might be some of those things, which would be a proactive way of protecting privacy [14:21] rights in the meantime while we had this discussion. [14:23] Understood. [14:24] And yeah, I mean, I'm not here to necessarily rush things, but I am also here to recognize [14:27] that we have an election in March, and then is it January or is it December at the new [14:32] government that the new governor shows up and the new judge's later gets the same thing? [14:36] I mean, there's a significant amount of time. [14:38] We're in August or in August right now. [14:41] And so, you know, I do want to make sure that even if we just do a moratorium and tell that [14:45] point where the new legislature kind of meets, which I think is January. [14:51] We should do something, and I think we're about to hear from speakers and I kind of want to get there thoughts. [14:56] We're going to go through quickly, just because there's a lot of stuff. [15:00] Speaker cards. I want to get people that two minutes time just because we don't have the room too long. [15:05] Aaron Perkins. Next up, after Aaron is Brooke [15:11] Badb, Beneer. [15:16] And would each speakers please say your name and if you're either your address or if your address [15:23] is on the card, you can simply say address on file. [15:31] Is give the red, look for red. I'm going to go. I'm about now. Hey, by hearing me. [15:35] All right, Erin Perkins, 55 West Knight Street, [15:37] live here in Springford, where I'm a bike up here [15:38] and I'm going to try and get into three hours [15:39] of conversation in two minutes. [15:41] OK, one of the things that's not being discussed [15:43] and I'm a little concerned of is a fiduciary responsibility. [15:46] As it's mapped out, like we're setting ourselves up [15:48] to have yet another asset that we have to pay maintenance [15:51] and keep on hurricane comes through. [15:52] People are going to cut these down. [15:54] The newest and greatest technology comes out. [15:56] How is that contract settled? [15:57] Installed improperly, oh, we own the hood [15:59] because of technician installed in it correctly. [16:01] That's one big issue. [16:02] We definitely need to pause and get that sorted out. [16:04] the safety, the other regulations, the other cities. [16:07] This is a brand new tool. [16:09] First off, the assembly line concept, [16:11] we're making a ring camera system for the whole city [16:13] and other cities are taking a pause button. [16:15] We should pull back. [16:16] This thing is going to evolve. [16:17] Other municipalities are going to figure out the rights [16:20] and regulations and how to use this. [16:22] We shouldn't be spending money [16:23] and we shouldn't be wasting all the taxpayers' time [16:26] if we're going to do it wrong. [16:27] Let's get back paused, get it right. [16:29] The first time in my world of air traffic, [16:31] when we put a new equipment system in, [16:32] a safety panel and we try to determine is it even feasible or is it worth the time and investment [16:38] or are we going down the right way? [16:39] It seems like this case what we did was put the technology in place first and now we're trying [16:43] to figure out how we should deploy it. [16:45] We need to pull back, figure out how to deploy it and make it sensible and for last piece I want [16:51] to get and try to go fast. [16:52] Once I'm going to do a glass piece I want to get across is that the frustration you're hearing [16:56] in multiple places is in the absence of information people are going to insert their own opinion [17:01] into that space. If we move forward with this concept, there needs to be clear, concise information [17:08] how it's going to be deployed and people should have a chance to ask questions and get [17:12] answers. Not I'll get back with you. There should be a clear information of how this is [17:16] done so we can know how it's deployed. So I don't insert my own fears into that space. [17:21] Thank you for your time. I was less than two minutes. You're a great job. Brooke, Benerk, [17:25] And then Fred Rick, let's go. [17:30] Good morning. [17:31] My name is Brooke Babano, and I'm the citizen here, and concerned. [17:37] One of the points that I'm not sure was totally addressed is that the [17:42] front companies have been provided with access to driver's license information. [17:49] That to me is a definite concern. [17:53] And initially, how do these companies get ruling or be allowed to install a private camera [18:02] on public device, public locations? [18:06] And secondly, that needs to be tracked back. [18:10] Are there any restrictions or are there any requirements for that licensure? [18:16] And are there any limitations as to what they can have access to? [18:19] That is a deep concern. [18:21] Because if it's wide open, technology like the front cameras are essentially like a hammer. [18:28] You can use it to build things or you can use it to destroy things. [18:32] It's all depending upon the restrictions or the intent of using that tool. [18:39] And that's my concern. [18:41] Thank you very much. [18:50] My name is Frederick Rodolf, my address is on the card. [18:53] I'm here now to present my opinion against the broad collection of private systems. [18:59] We've been data through automatic license plate readers, signal detection systems such as signal trace, similar systems operated by private entities. [19:06] Our first argument I want to make is that every person on their way to this meeting likely past multiple flock cameras, [19:12] very recent history, association data like this, what absolutely have been used to target individuals for harassment, [19:18] list them as political dissidents, or to have them in person under false pretense. [19:22] Can you get closer to the microphone so you can get recorded? [19:25] Thank you. [19:26] Recently, we have been shown that the slippery slope is not a fallacy. [19:29] These automatic tracking systems are operated by private companies and are beholden to the shareholders [19:35] who will push them to make as much money as possible. [19:37] That means a constant flow of new products and services all centered around [19:42] the collection and analysis of the movement data of private citizens. [19:48] the expansion of these networks to an artificially intelligent [19:51] beenoptic on is not that far from science fiction. [19:55] The comparison of location data collected by cell phone companies [19:58] is often brought up the part where... [20:00] It's always left out, is that federal and state statutes requires specific legal thresholds to be met before those records are obtained. [20:10] Right now, all that needs for all, right now, all that's needed for any officers to access civilian movements through the ALPR's case number. [20:19] I can believe we're the point all day, but the bottom line is this. The average distance should be free from government overreaching constants surveillance. [20:25] So this is like these ALPRs collect every bit collecting every bit of movement from every citizen just in case is an invasive cancer [20:33] Thank you. Thank you, sir [20:37] Tim Vorgans followed by Michael Melton. [20:43] I'm sorry. My name is Tim Vorgans. My address is on file [20:48] I work as a senior software engineer at a civic tech company. I have [20:52] Followed much of the reporting around flock and other [20:55] of surveillance companies, and I am, I've brave concerns about security [20:59] posters that many of these companies about the actual design of the products to be [21:03] able to, like, enforce restrictions on who can search things, like, they are designed to [21:10] make it easier for law enforcement to access these records. [21:13] That's part of their value proposition. [21:15] And I think that they, they will always be prioritizing making it easier over making [21:21] for the Citizens Privacy rights and constitutional rights are protected. [21:28] I don't think that penalties for misuse are likely. [21:32] I have very little faith that that would make much of an impact on privacy [21:36] because if anything, it would just raise the stakes for police officers [21:42] to, it's more of a, oh no, I'm throwing a colleague under the bus [21:47] And potentially, but in the mid-Jail, which is not something that police officers are, don't want to do. [21:54] I also just wanted to add that I would love for the moratorium to include not just don't add new cameras, [22:02] but let's also disable the cameras that we have for now. [22:05] We don't even have to take things down. [22:06] You could, like, there are cities that have put bags over them. [22:09] You can, like, until a public policy has been decided as a community, [22:14] I think that would be a great way to, in the short term, [22:18] make sure that, yeah, they're not filing people's privacy rates. [22:22] Thank you. [22:26] Two minutes. [22:26] I'm very grateful. [22:27] Michael Melton. [22:29] And then Ben Alcorn. [22:36] Hello. [22:36] My name is Michael Melton. [22:37] I'm an archaeologist in the study of human populations. [22:41] There's going to be some tax revenue from tickets that are going to be distributed [22:46] from the system. [22:47] But the value is from the data itself. [22:49] Facebook has a revenue of $270 billion a year from a free website. [22:55] Why is it free? [22:57] Well, it's not. [22:57] It's taking your data and giving it to advertisers. [23:00] Those advertisers then tell you what you want to buy. [23:03] TikTok collects data on American users. [23:06] Chinese company has our data, but we don't have data on them. [23:09] Pokemon Go, a company that has spent 10 years collecting our data. [23:13] The parent company, Niantic, has sold itself to the Saudi Arabian government. [23:17] not a company, a government has data on where our children go after school in what they buy. [23:25] They have our shopping habits, our leisure activities. Could you imagine if we were to go to war [23:31] with a nation that knew what our behavior was during school shooting or a natural disaster or [23:37] a celebrity death? And the question that I have to really ask is what happens to our data when [23:42] block goes bankrupt and they have to sell their assets. [23:47] Thank you. [23:48] Thank you, sir. [23:49] Ben Alcorn, followed by Laura Harris. [23:56] Benjamin Alcorn, my address is on file. [24:02] I think it's a complicated issue that doesn't fit into our [24:05] traditional two parties system. [24:08] Like we've got a design like most issues do. [24:11] So it's a little nuance. [24:12] And I think the next thing I want to say is a more [24:17] It's pouring on. It's not a ban. It's just time. It's just a pause to take time to look at the issues and talk it through, especially since it is a nuanced issue. [24:28] There are some pros. I've seen it. I work in the construction industry and cameras have been put on job sites. It's stopped and helped catch criminals that have, you know, gone to job sites to steal things, which makes affordability of how it's higher. [24:44] Right? So I mean there's real good case uses of this, however, [24:51] you know, and we want to get JSO, you know, the tools to do their job. We want to be safe. [24:56] But miss identification, harassment, privacy. [25:00] Liberty was a issues that matter, and they need to be discussed. And so I think transparency is really the issue. This is obviously authorized in JSO's budget, which is a long budget with a lot of line items. You know, the not a lot of people necessarily see. What is the cost of this? Because there is a taxpayer cost, ultimately, our taxes pay JSO, right? So, some transparency there. What is it being used for? Is it just being used for license plates? [25:30] I think JSO made a statement that that's the case. [25:33] I don't know if that's necessarily fully true or not. [25:36] So transparency is the issue. [25:38] Who is this data being shared with who else has access to this data besides JSO? [25:44] It is, for instance, immigration customs. [25:47] Do they have access to this? [25:49] Is that access to this? [25:51] You know, just wondering. [25:53] And we don't know the answers to that, right? [25:55] So I want to go back to a moreatorium is not a ban. [26:02] So, thank you. [26:03] Next up, Laura Harris, followed by Matt Hammond. [26:13] You're fine. [26:14] You're fine? [26:15] Matt, if you can just kind of prep. [26:20] I am not an activist. [26:22] I'm just an old lady who's retired. [26:27] I'm here to tell you about an experience that I had in 2022, [26:31] where one Saturday morning, I went out to my driveway. [26:34] my car was gone. Name an address please. It's on the car. He's got that. Your name, please. [26:42] Oh, I apologize. Laura Harris. I'm sorry. I'm not a custom to public speaking. [26:49] You're doing great. You got it. You got it. I'm in in 40 seconds. [26:53] If you don't mind, I'm just going to read this since I'm going to be consistently interrupted. [27:03] My name is Laura Harris, I live in Jacksonville, Florida, in 2022, one beautiful Saturday [27:08] morning. [27:09] I walked out to my driveway. [27:11] It was empty. [27:12] My car was gone. [27:13] I posted on Facebook, looking for my vehicle. [27:17] I fell for a scheme, claiming to have the ability to find my car. [27:21] I paid them for help, victimized again. [27:25] When police eventually recovered, my vehicle in a week or so, all my belongings were gone, [27:33] in their place were dozens of other people's credit cards, purses, and wallets. [27:41] Initially, I didn't understand why I was asked to retrieve my car from the suspect's [27:45] address or the suspect's residence, or why the police had not removed items that obviously [27:52] did not want to me. I eventually realized that I was being ruled out as a suspect. I was [27:59] one victim. There were many others. If lock cameras had been in place, then that car might have [28:07] been located faster. And some of those people might have been spared the theft and the months [28:13] of cleanup that followed. I understand the privacy concerns. We're already tracked on our phones. [28:23] We're already tracked on our phones, our computers, our streaming accounts. [28:29] These cameras photographed. [28:30] That's two minutes. [28:31] That's two minutes. [28:33] Could I ask for just one? [28:34] I'm afraid we have a very, I've got a large stack, man. [28:37] We gave you two minutes. [28:38] Well, I would just like to add that it cost me well over $5,000. [28:43] Understood. [28:44] Matt. [28:44] Please come up. [28:45] Next up, Addison Patrick after Matt. [28:49] Hello, Mr. Matt Hammond addresses on file, [28:54] obviously everyone has been in most of us, or many of us in here have been victims of crimes. That's not the point of question here. [29:00] This use of flock. [29:03] Get closer. [29:04] Use of flock cameras, other APLRs, or any other devices that have been around for many years, or direct violation of our Fourth Amendment rights. [29:12] There is U.S. Supreme Court law, U.S. [29:15] First is James 565, U.S. 400, [29:18] the Justice Court reversed the concluding [29:19] that the mission of evidence obtained [29:21] by warrantless U.S. of GPS device [29:23] violated the Fourth Amendment, right? [29:24] So this is pervasive warrantless search of citizens, right? [29:29] Carbeder versus U.S. 585, U.S. 296, [29:32] the U.S. Supreme Court again reversed, [29:34] holding that the acquisition of Carbeder's [29:36] cell site records was a Fourth Amendment search. [29:39] So, the third party records basis is not hold here either. [29:44] So, other thoughts holding it, or the state's holding it, right? [29:47] If the state's holding this information, then it's public record. [29:51] People can access it from themselves. [29:52] If they destroy it in seven days, then they are in violation of protecting state records, right? [30:00] So Florida has a anti-stalking statute. It's 784.048, which makes it a crime for any person. This is a putting more office to willfully and repeatedly follow another person. [30:15] Thank you for your time. [30:22] Chair, go ahead. [30:23] Do you see a person up there out of town? [30:25] Addison. [30:26] Hello. [30:27] Do you see a person up there? [30:28] I got it. [30:29] All right. Thank you, Cory. [30:32] Go ahead, Addison. [30:32] Good morning. My name is Addison Patrick. Addison Liberty Patrick and my address is on file. [30:40] I'm sure there's going to be a lot more people who are going to talk about the violation of our fourth amendment rights. [30:46] So I will leave that alone for now. [30:49] I do want to say something that I don't believe I've heard anybody say this morning. [30:54] Somebody did mention what happens to the data if flock or any other companies like Axon or whoever purchases these. [31:01] Like, where is that data go? [31:03] How long do they have access to the data? [31:08] Right now, I believe some of it is in the AWS cloud. [31:13] I think that's an issue. [31:14] I think this could be a national security issue. [31:17] I think this is a bad, bad, bad thing all around. [31:20] We have people from all political parties represented [31:24] who are speaking against this, you know, [31:26] for some reason or another. [31:29] And we have to, we have to pay attention to all of this. [31:37] The JSO town home meeting that they have for district six, that I was at, they mentioned that they're a nine month backlog of just responding to body camera requests because of all the things that have to be redacted. [31:50] So if we have flock cameras and JSO has any control over those and they have to redact public information that's sensitive. [31:57] how long would it take us to even find out what they even have going on there for a record request? [32:02] So if we're already an almost a year of a backlog, they also have drones. [32:06] I think this is a slippery slippery slope. [32:09] We've got all the cameras everywhere. [32:11] They're all talking to each other. [32:13] We're being tracked and now we've got the drones. [32:16] So if you're not aware, go look those up. [32:19] JSO has those are deploying those in certain situations. [32:21] So, I support canceling the full contracts, getting rid of them and anything else that we have in that sphere. [32:30] And if not, I support the temporary moratorium so we can just get rid of them now. [32:36] Thank you so much. [32:37] I think it's Patrick Jennifer Dean followed by Rachel Reabout. [32:42] Bob out. [32:43] My apologies. [32:45] Jennifer Dean. [32:46] I'm sorry. [32:50] I'm Jennifer two minutes. [32:51] Rachel, you're next. [32:51] Hi. Good morning. My name is Jennifer Dean after some record. I want to make [32:56] think one thing very clear. I am not against security and I'm not against [32:59] technology. I support technology that helps law enforcement protect [33:03] communities and improves emergency response. But the security and [33:07] surveillance are not the same thing. Security protects people, [33:12] surveillance monitors people. And when technology can track, [33:16] record, collect, store information about ordinary citizens. [33:20] We need to safeguard before that technology expands. [33:24] Technology is moving faster than many of our laws and policies. [33:29] We do not know exactly what these systems may be capable of five or ten years from now. [33:34] How databases may connect, how artificial intelligence may analyze the information, [33:39] or how information collected day can be used tomorrow. [33:42] That is why the public deserves answers now. [33:45] who owns this technology, who controls it, [33:48] who has access to it, why is the information being collected? [33:53] How long is it stored, how are audits used? [33:58] What happens if it's abused? [34:00] That should be clear limits. [34:02] There should be clear limits, limits. [34:05] Oversight, transparency, accountability, [34:07] and meaningful public input before surveillance technology [34:12] is installed, expanded, or renewed. [34:17] We should also ask whether the technology is actually solving the problem. [34:22] Not every public safety problem requires another camera. [34:27] Sometimes better lighting, staffing, communication, emergency response, or less intrusive [34:32] technology may be a better situation. [34:35] The question should always be, what actually makes people safer while creating the least [34:40] necessary intrusion of their lives. I support law enforcement. I support fighting crime. [34:47] I support innovation, but I also support privacy, civil liberties, and reasonable government. [34:54] There are things that are not mutually exclusive to public safety matters. [35:00] Thank you. Thank you very much. Rachel Bobout. And then Marshall Brannick. [35:08] You have two minutes, ma'am. [35:10] Thank you. My name is Rachel. Be about my addresses on file. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. This is my first time ever speaking at a public meeting. So I'm, excuse [35:27] me, I'm sorry. [35:29] You're okay. I'll stop your time for a minute. [35:32] You're all right. [35:33] Good evening, brother. [35:34] I stopped time for a minute. [35:35] I told my son that I was coming this morning, [35:37] and I would just like to say that. [35:39] I'm speaking on his behalf. [35:41] He's been taking civics class in public school. [35:44] And I told him that it's basically a citizen's responsibility. [35:49] So if I don't come to a public meeting and speak up, [35:53] I know that he can't and so on. [35:56] I do want to just mention that state representative Black said that we want to remain a free [36:02] people it's important and that to keep our freedom for security and safety in the spirit of [36:11] our 250th birthday I just would like to read the Thomas Jefferson said in 1774 that a free [36:19] people claim their rights as derived from the laws of nature, and not as the gift of their [36:26] chief magistrate. [36:28] It seems that there's an emphasis on government rights, municipal jurisdiction, to install [36:33] this equipment. [36:36] Recently, on a Columbus Ohio town meeting, Dr. Viet Trin, who is a PhD in crime surveillance [36:44] in policing at Ohio State University said on the record that he believes in his professional [36:52] opinion that flawed cameras is basically investigating everyone is under investigation at [36:59] all times and he equivocated that to pre-crime. [37:03] I'm sure everyone in this room a certain movie comes to mind when you think of that. [37:10] So, it goes beyond protecting Fourth Amendment rights to be secure in our personal property and our effects. [37:19] Good minutes, ma'am. [37:20] Okay. [37:20] Thank you. [37:21] Thank you. [37:22] Marshall Brannick, followed by Latasha Hobbs. [37:28] Good morning. [37:29] Marshall Brannick, my address is on file. [37:31] Counciling, please. [37:31] First, thank you for holding this meeting and taking the time to hear us out. [37:35] And thank you for your service and the Navy. [37:36] That's going to be important in a second. [37:38] For context, I just retired from the Navy last month after 20 years. [37:43] I spent that time aboard the U.S. [37:44] before it left Jacksonville. [37:47] And we actually may have been stationed in Jack or Norfolk around the same time. [37:52] There's no more along the way. [37:54] I also developed a strong interest in technology and data. [37:57] Couldn't code my way out of a paper bag, but I spent enough time working with data. [38:01] And I can understand how seemingly insignificant pieces of information [38:05] can be aggregated and what that can bring forth. [38:10] So, I'm not here simply because Constitutional [38:12] Gober or to repeat some argument that you've [38:14] probably already heard. [38:15] I want to look at this risk created by collecting and [38:18] retaining this data from a different, for I'm sorry, [38:21] from a few different angles that I don't think I've received [38:24] enough attention in public conversation. [38:26] Maybe in private, but I'm going to say it out loud. [38:29] ATFP training, otherwise known as anti-terrorism force protection, [38:33] teaches us to recognize patterns and protect [38:35] information about our routines. [38:37] We bear our routines, minimize our digital footprints, [38:39] and avoid unnecessary revealing, [38:43] where we live, where we work, when we arrive, [38:45] what our daily patterns look like. [38:47] We do that because these individually harmless pieces [38:49] of information can become valuable intelligence [38:51] when aggregated. [38:53] I mean, we were literally told to stop using Fitbits [38:57] while on base because they map out our movements. [39:00] Now, I understand that all these items [39:01] mentioned aren't collected by flock, and that a single picture of a license plate on a road [39:07] is not particularly revealing, but thousands of them pain a different story and the Supreme [39:12] Court just ruled on this recently with the Carter case. Now apply that concern here in Jacksonville. [39:19] We have an enormous military presence. If a foreign adversary associates a person of interest with [39:24] the vehicle and license plate access to retained LPR data or active feeds can turn into ordinary [39:29] traffic and the observations and you know, you understand. [39:33] I appreciate it and thank you for your service. [39:35] Congrats on your retirement. [39:37] Latasha, after Latasha's going to be Chad Charlond. [39:43] Hi, good afternoon, Latasha Hobbs. [39:45] My address is on file. [39:47] I wanted to take a minute a moment to speak about the importance [39:51] of lock cameras in Jacksonville. [39:53] As a mother of a murder child, this is my son, Maurice Hobbs. [39:58] As a mother of a murder child. [40:00] Friday and for justice for my son. Maurice, I understand firsthand how critical evidence can be when a family is searching for answers. According to the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office, as I stated at the last agenda meeting at City Hall, the license plate reader cameras have helped solve 15 murders, 17 kidnappings, six possible sex offenses, nearly a hundred shootings, [40:28] and 172 missing person cases since 2024. [40:34] Those are not just numbers. [40:37] They represent families who need answers, [40:39] victims who need to justice, and live that were saved. [40:43] I fully support the continue use of lock cameras [40:46] because I believe public safety and accountability matter. [40:50] I'm advocating to keep locked cameras in use [40:53] because I know what it feels like when the families left [40:55] searching for justice. [40:57] I will continue fighting for Marie's, I will continue fighting for other families who deserve answers when violence into their lives. [41:05] If technology can help law enforcement identify suspects, violent criminals, murderers, locate missing people, recover evidence and bring justice to families and I believe we should continue investing in it while also ensuring appropriate safeguards and accountability. [41:23] My son was robbed of his life, I was robbed of my son, my children robbed of their [41:30] brother. [41:32] I'll be damned if I let anyone rob me of his justice and justice for other families. [41:37] Please keep up the flock cameras. [41:40] Thank you for your time. [41:42] Thank you. [41:42] Good touch. [41:43] Chad Sharlon, followed by Albert Stern. [41:49] My name is Chad Sharlon, I live at 304-6B first avenue in Fernandina Beach, and I am running [41:54] State House in District 15, which includes [41:56] cannot you cannot campaign here sir. [41:58] No, this is part of the, even that. [42:00] Even that. [42:00] District includes parts of Northern and northwestern [42:03] Duval County and one I drive from my home in [42:06] Fernandina through Nassau and into Duval as I routinely do. [42:09] I am under constant surveillance from a network of [42:11] flat cameras installed by local police and sheriff's [42:14] department. [42:14] I am treated like a suspect. [42:16] The master valence is unwarranted and performed without [42:18] any reasonable suspicion. [42:20] It is only a matter of time before this technology has turned on [42:22] people like me. And I say people like me, meaning people in the political minority. I am [42:27] non-party affiliated. But I oppose big tech and flat cameras and data centers. I support [42:32] ending Florida law enforcement 287 degree agreements with ICE. And for doing all of this, [42:37] I am considered an enemy of the state as spelled out in a presidential executive order. [42:41] I subject myself to additional tracking and targeting by speaking out at meetings like this, [42:46] giving my home address to the very companies with the technology capable of tracking my [42:50] remove. I am also an environmentalist, and it has been proven that the state of Florida [42:56] through the Fish and Wildlife Commission has been using privilege, law enforcement, [42:59] tracking data, and tools to illegally, and without cause, investigate environmentalists in [43:04] the state. I am a target. The people in this room are targets. These cameras make it easier for [43:09] big tech and law enforcement and corporations to target, track, harass us and do God knows [43:14] what else in the future. The first responsibility of government is to protect the people. [43:19] You can protect the people by removing these master valence cameras. [43:22] Thank you. [43:23] Thank you, sir. [43:25] Albert Stern, followed by Dragon Ballot. [43:30] Hi, my name is Albert Stern. [43:32] My address is on file. [43:36] Thank you for having this meeting. [43:38] Thank you for looking at the moratorium. [43:40] Please do that. [43:42] There's a lot of concerns, and I am deeply concerned [43:44] about the massive valence state. [43:46] Specifically, I want to speak about the flock camera company [43:49] specifically, this company has created a system that has been abused throughout the country, [43:55] even here in the state of Florida, where people are using it inappropriately to stalk people. [44:04] And it is clear that that company is not a serious security company. [44:08] You wouldn't make something like that. [44:10] There CEO has gone on records saying that they've made mistakes. [44:15] So, what I ask you to do is to think about that company, they have been, they have funded, [44:20] they start up funds, comes from places like by Combinator, Mark Andries, this group, they're [44:25] a tech company, like every other tech company, they're going to play by those rules. [44:30] Once you get hooked on the heroin of this, they're going to change the price structure, they're [44:35] going to change what they offer you, and then the camera's going to be up there, and it's [44:38] going to be too expensive, and what are you going to do? [44:40] You're going to take them down with them. [44:41] The only thing about child companies is that they get hacked every tech company gets hacked. [44:47] This is a tech company. [44:49] It's not a security company. [44:50] Thank you. [44:52] Thank you. [44:52] Thank you very much, sir. [44:53] Dragon Ballot. [44:54] Followed by Casey Jones. [45:02] Hey everybody, I'm dragging below my addresses on file and as you know, I've been advocating about this for several months now. [45:09] So I think it's really interesting that we think that we shouldn't rush into a decision, but these showed up overnight. [45:16] Dishes the people installing them by the way. I've seen Dish go around installing them and they're installed without breakaway plates at the bottom, which means if a car hits them, that metal doesn't move, and that person in the car gets very hurt. [45:28] It's also really interesting that we think 2K waters will hold off his accountable. [45:33] Charles Fagger, William McNeil Jr., Woo Hayden and Asia Bennett have something else to say on that. [45:40] We have a lot of concerns with people that can't be here. [45:42] I actually have a list of the concerns that I've put in on file for all the people that couldn't be here because it's 10.30 a.m. [45:51] I understand we have to do it sometime, right? [45:53] But a lot of people are working right now. [45:54] So, the working people that are being tracked every day usually couldn't come here. [46:00] Also, if you're concerned about what other counties are doing, Pasco County has just canceled [46:04] its entire flock contract even after the purchase of several flock drones. [46:09] And the replacement contract with Axon, it is not just flock, it is also Axon, it is all just full Motorola. [46:15] Again, these are tech companies, not security companies, and they are not secure. [46:19] Ben Jordan is a guy on YouTube, right? [46:22] He's not exactly a huge whiz, [46:25] but he's able to hack into these cameras within about 15 seconds. [46:29] I don't want to know what people that do this as their job [46:33] and as the way they make money, [46:35] illicitly or otherwise, can do with that camera, [46:38] that data and that database. [46:41] I am very concerned about the safety and security of Jacksonville. [46:44] I am very concerned about the fact [46:46] that I have within a mile of my house, literally more than 20. [46:53] I, they are pointed at children's homes. [46:56] They are pointed at apartment complexes. [46:59] They are pointed at public pools. [47:01] These should not be used for this purpose, [47:04] and I don't think we can. [47:06] Thank you. [47:07] You, Casey Jones, followed by, yet here are Gonzalez. [47:13] I don't want to case you Jones, 725, 1st Street, South Jack's Beach, all the truss that [47:23] we the people have, they're all lost, every bit, or being tracked, I mean, it's super scary. [47:33] So we the people won't them go on. [47:36] We don't want them restricted, we don't want to, if you can't do what you're supposed to [47:40] And what is that? What are you supposed to do? You know, you go to the cops want to do what they want to look at they want to track you [47:50] They want to see your GPS want to see your Google whatever because what they got to do [47:55] Everybody knows what they got to do [47:58] So so let me ask you a question [48:01] How is the government dancing all over the fourth amendment? [48:05] Does anybody know that they're dancing on the Constitution because they're using a third party? [48:14] That's what they're doing and nobody, I've all the people that speak and I appreciate everybody that speaks. [48:20] But nobody's brought up the Constitution and the fourth amendment. [48:23] This is what it's all about. [48:25] They're dancing on the Constitution and the fourth amendment because they're using a third party. [48:32] Period. [48:33] So, let me, let me, let me, let me, let me, there was the clock at. [48:38] Minute 30. [48:39] Huh? [48:40] You got a minute 26. [48:41] So, let me, let me quote our great governor to state of Florida. [48:45] And I know there's people on both sides, there's people on both sides that are against it. [48:50] So, I'm not eliminating this. [48:52] But let me, let me quote our great governor, [48:56] I think these and these mean the LPR, the [49:02] his tag reader. He just got quote yesterday. I think these license tag bleep [49:07] wrote it out of control. That's what he said. The video's up on my Facebook page. [49:14] So, that's two minutes are. They are out of control. [49:18] Thank you. You're here at Gonzalez followed by Robert Jeffries. [49:27] Good morning council members. My name is here at Gonzalez. I'm a graduate public student [49:31] at the University of North Florida. I'm here to talk about [49:36] So the Fox CEO recently has said that we should compromise our privacy, just so we can operate these cameras. [49:43] I think that is a crazy statement to say. [49:46] I think also as a public health student, I want to talk about how we shouldn't compromise our privacy just so we can solve murders and cannot be ins now. [49:56] I do have empathy and sympathize with you that you're so much murdered. I'm so sorry that. [50:00] I think it also, we should get to the bottom the roots of this problem of why Jacksonville has so much crime, why we have so much gain inflated activity. [50:11] I think instead of installing more cameras in our privacy, we should instead get to the root problem and have more violence prevention programs and we shouldn't have that money. [50:25] And so spending it on floor cameras, we should spend that money more on after school programs, [50:30] things that prevent violence, having community members go into the community, and just spend [50:36] it more where the money should be spent. [50:38] I think having floor cameras as a waste of tax payer money, we could use it to sell the [50:43] homelessness problem every, every, I work myself, every time I go to class, I see a homeless [50:49] person and it's just, it's not cool to have that many as big as big as Jacksonal as we [50:56] shouldn't have this many homeless people. I've also volunteered at a food pantry recently [51:01] and so many people have to go and get food. So I think we can also try to lower grocery prices, [51:12] but thank you. Thank you. Robert Jeffers, followed by Andrew Scott. [51:21] Good morning council. Thank you [51:22] or putting together this meeting, my name is Robert Jeffers, [51:24] my address is on file. [51:25] This may be a remedial reference to some people, [51:28] but many people have gotten up here and talked about [51:30] what this AI can do, right? [51:32] Hollywood is giving us the script. [51:34] We know what AI can do. [51:36] When it is not put, the good use, [51:40] Hollywood is gave us a script. [51:41] What can happen, right? [51:43] And we all know that. [51:44] It might be funny to some people, but it's not. [51:46] I haven't taken a stance for our against [51:48] because I think that there's some very good things [51:50] that can come out of lock cameras. [51:51] I think that there's very good things [51:52] come out of surveillance. I do believe in that. But then whenever it is used in a negative [51:56] light, problems can occur, right? And the privacy of our citizens are at risk. And it [52:01] can potentially harm us as a society. My problem is, is that this is a reaction. All right, [52:08] this meeting is a reaction. There's thousands of block cameras over the state of Florida, [52:11] right? Where was the protections at the beginning when this stuff started coming out to say, [52:16] hey, we don't want that that our state government not come together and say, hey, [52:20] Who's going to start, who's going to start installing this and what protections are we're going to put before we start mass installing these all the way across our state? [52:28] This is a very reactive instead of a proactive thing, right? [52:32] So now it's here and now we have to deal with it. [52:34] So now we're trying to figure out how to deal with it. [52:36] So from here on out, I just want to make a statement. [52:38] Let's be proactive Jacksonville. [52:40] I'm tired of being aggressive, okay? [52:42] We start thinking about things in the past and how and how we want to move forward. [52:46] But we can't move forward if we're being reactive. [52:50] We need to be progressive and be on the forefront of this. [52:53] This is a terrible, it's great that we're looking at this and putting the more torque in place. [53:00] We believe, but we need to be progressive and not reactive. [53:04] Thank you. [53:05] Thanks, sir. [53:06] Andrew Scott, followed by DL Cummings. [53:19] Good morning. [53:20] My name's Andrew Scott. [53:21] My address is on file. [53:23] I've been a software developer and manager for over 15 years, worked in computer vision and some machine learning. [53:33] So I'm a little bit familiar with this. [53:35] And like this is how you get a police surveillance state. [53:38] This is basically a package deal. [53:41] This is the data set that anyone who wanted to abuse would dream of. [53:49] It is all the status on AWS, [53:53] Jack's may own it, but they will not control it. [53:58] And I found, along my research saying that basically, [54:01] JSO has extended their data retention for a year. [54:06] A year-to-year-threathe data. [54:08] Now, flocks since they're coming under fire, [54:11] has actually gone back and recommended seven days as a recommendation. [54:16] Think about what you could do with everyone's traffic data. [54:21] for a year, correlating that with any other data set would be crazy. [54:38] So yeah, and I didn't even know before that that they had been given access to data or the DMV information. [54:45] So that's another data set. [54:48] But I'm really concerned about this because their tech company, all the protections in place, it can still be hacked. [54:54] it will be hacked, it will be abused in the data system now. [55:00] And we have no saying [55:03] it. [55:04] Sir, deal, Cummings, followed by John Nooney. [55:16] And we do have to cut off more. This will be the last public comment card I'm going to take. We got [55:20] to go through public comment, and then I got a few more comments. I'm going to make [55:22] and we have to adjourn. Go ahead, sir. You have two minutes. [55:24] All right. Good morning. My name is deal Cummings, addresses on file. [55:28] So I think there are two questions that have not yet been answered that are very critical. [55:32] That's number one. What is the actual efficacy in solving cases, crimes, et cetera? [55:38] number two how necessary are these devices in doing so. So there's not a lot of data out there, [55:45] and earlier this month, JSO posted on X and presumably elsewhere, a number of cases of [55:52] some were criminals, some were people missing, so on and so forth, of cases that were solved [55:58] through the use of LPRs. Interesting, but doesn't tell me a whole lot. So I did a little digging, [56:04] Turns out, in 2024 in May, they actually posted JSO likewise on X and other social media of a particular case of a shooting in the Hogan Creek area where they're ended up being no fatalities, no injuries, but there was a bullet that went into a school bus full of children. [56:25] They credited these devices in solving the case. [56:29] And I think the problem comes with the word solved. [56:32] So I did a little more digging. [56:34] And I went to the Duball Clerk. [56:36] And I started digging up because they posted the names. [56:39] And I read the Charging document as it turns out, [56:43] all of the information that they would have needed [56:45] to arrest the two individuals that they did [56:48] came from witnesses. [56:50] Witnesses said, this person did it, this person did it, [56:53] this is what they were wearing, [56:54] this is the vehicle they got in, [56:56] this is the location that they went to. [56:58] the cameras were just supplemental. Well, there's more to that story. Because I did a little more digging, [57:05] and as it turns out, the two individuals at the time, one was 23, one was 17. The 17-year-old, [57:11] unfortunately passed away earlier this year. Circumstances are unknown, but I can only presume [57:17] if you're involved in a shootout when you're 17, that doesn't leave you a very long life. The other [57:23] individual had their charges dropped two minutes or yes. Thank you. Thank you so much. John [57:28] Nune, followed by Sean Costello. [57:35] I'm not seeing John Nune because John Costello in the audience [57:38] for the room. [57:41] Hello. My name is Sean Costello. My address is on file. I think some of the previous [57:45] speakers are recover this, but just to reiterate, there is a flawed camera pointed at a community [57:50] pool as a premier apartments and I've noticed that during this meeting today and also all [57:58] of flocks official information they're referred to as license plate readers. So it seemed [58:04] a little bit like a reflecting me that we're calling them license plate readers but some of [58:07] them are pointed in a spot where they would not be reading any license plates and I know [58:13] another speaker also mentioned that it's important that we understand how these cameras are being [58:17] but also I think it's important to understand what they're capable of, and, again, like, previous speakers I've mentioned with AI, [58:25] whether capable of today may be different than whether capable of tomorrow. [58:29] So it's probably going to be quite a difficult task to, like, make it clear what they're capable of. [58:36] I think that's really important for the council. Thank you. [58:42] Excuse sir Nick Harding followed by Zary Davis. [58:47] I don't know if there are an overflow. [58:49] Gore here. [58:50] All right. [58:51] I'll remember you're at 11 30. [58:53] I-I-I-I-Are we able to extend a 12? [58:54] No. [58:55] No. [58:55] You were noticed till 11 30. [58:57] I apologize but can we can we can we can? [58:58] Can we can we can? [59:02] You are outside of public notice. [59:06] Look, it all stick around. [59:07] We are gonna we are going to we are going to join this meeting. [59:09] I will stick around and talk to anyone that has any more comments. [59:14] We had a number of common cards left. [59:16] I want to thank my colleagues for being here today. [59:18] This is incredibly important. [59:20] I do intend to continue to move forward. [59:21] I'm very concerned about these devices, but I do want to make sure that JSA was a major role [59:27] to play and make sure that they're able to continue to solve crimes. [59:30] But there is a line to be walked when it comes to personal security, personal privacy, and [59:38] law enforcement. [59:40] So, there will be more to come in this conversation. [59:42] I'm here to stick around, though. [59:47] If you did not get a chance to speak, you can't know. [59:49] You can email me directly. [59:51] J. Peluso, P.E.L. USO at COJ. [59:54] Those comments are, you can also get one of my cards over there. [59:58] Thank you. [59:58] This means journey.