[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:00] All right. Okay, so this is March 11th. March 10th. Is it March 10th? March 10th, thank you. So, this is a meeting as a curbi planning commission. And we are here to do a conditional use of hearing for a short term rental with Melissa and Ned Cobb. Okay, [0:29] Okay, so the first thing is I would really appreciate that people would introduce themselves. [0:35] So any letter to the stars? [0:37] Any comments? [0:39] Hillary DeCarlo? [0:40] Dr. Sherbrook. [0:42] Jerry Tumey. [0:43] Tracy Sherbrook. [0:45] Marty Eder. [0:46] Elizabeth Hubbard. [0:48] Melissa Hall of 19th Ward. [0:50] Eric Wilson. [0:52] Kristen Tyler. [0:53] Neighbors with Eric and Elizabeth. [0:55] And I'm here with my son who has a scouting requirement. [0:59] to attend a tell meeting and a decoction on what goes on. [1:04] Okay. [1:05] I love that you get code on staff. [1:09] Welcome, Brad. [1:11] Can you, yeah? [1:12] Hi. [1:14] We're going to do a conditional use here first. [1:17] Is that... [1:17] Yeah, I know. [1:17] ...closed to you. [1:18] Is it privacy? [1:19] No. [1:19] Not at all. [1:25] So, the five... [1:34] The considerations for approval are you eat all have one of those, right? [1:44] Does anybody else live on Willie? [1:55] If I may, I apologize but I'm just clarifying the procedure. [2:02] The permit is disapproved upon application because short-term rentals are not approved. [2:11] They're prone to use. [2:13] It's conditional. [2:15] So that's what generates the conditional use hearing. [2:18] Right. [2:19] And then we examine the conditional use criteria. [2:22] Right. [2:23] And so it was, I think it's Annie and Marty [2:28] that went through so much a couple of years ago. [2:31] Yeah. [2:31] And it was so much work around this short-term rental. [2:36] So we now have pretty good guidelines. [2:40] And it's gone pretty smooth too. [2:42] It has gone pretty smoothly. [2:44] It's not pretty crying. [2:45] So, the first one is the capacity of existing or planned community facilities. [2:50] A conditional use shall not overburden or exhaust existing or planned municipal facilities [2:57] or services. [2:59] I think that's pretty much. [3:03] I mean, it's already a residence and it's going to keep being used in that way, right? [3:07] So everything's good there. [3:09] Private water, private sewer, private traffic. [3:12] Well, the sewer? [3:14] So the sewer? [3:16] Well, that handle it is, I went digging. [3:20] I found the e-readable septic permanent. [3:22] It's for a four-bedroom house. [3:24] A four-bedroom house. [3:27] So with no more than two people per bed. [3:33] OK. [3:35] And the second one is the character [3:37] What are the area affected as defined by purposes of the zoning district within which the project [3:43] is located specifically stated policies and standards of the municipal plan? [4:02] I think that's not affected by that. [4:08] Nick, Melissa, perhaps you can speak to what you want from this endeavor, what do you imagine [4:19] is happening, what kind of rentals, what kind of people, [4:22] I think the fear for a lot of folks is, [4:26] and has played out in communities [4:28] where short-term rentals become problem houses [4:31] and are brought with all kinds of drama and police. [4:35] Hardly. [4:37] So, please, yes. [4:39] Educators. [4:41] I grew up on the birth. [4:43] We have a place over on the mountain. [4:44] This is a home that my uncle built 20 years ago. [4:47] So, what's the remind us, men has lived there until last May, basically a medical disability [4:54] caused him to not be able to live there any longer on his own. [4:58] So we worked out something, we wanted to keep the house in the family. [5:02] So we worked out something with my uncle, and we don't need two homes here, but we love [5:09] the area, we love coming up. [5:11] It's very easy for us because we're out here all the time to pay attention to a property [5:16] like this. And so our goal is a short-term rental mostly weekends as the season dictates [5:24] and the skiers and hikers. We want to be respectful, obviously the neighborhood, vet all the [5:30] neighborhoods that most probably knew before this, obviously. But they've also kept an eye [5:36] on the house and transitioned very much. We're moving out, thus fixing it up for goals to provide [5:42] a family-friendly atmosphere, for people to come up and do it, and put together, I brought [5:50] a copy of it, you know, on an eight-page kind of guide to renters. We talked about it [5:56] last kind of pre-hearing weapons. We talked to the neighbors about whether there is access [6:02] or not to the snowmobiling trails, not to see if there isn't. So we have an advertising [6:07] as such, we will advertise proximity to the vast trails, but I haven't been on to myself [6:16] in this neighborhood to say exactly where they are. [6:18] The panel left that is go check out the website. [6:23] And so... [6:24] Do you have a website? [6:25] Or... [6:26] We have the VRBOs. [6:28] Okay. [6:28] Yeah. [6:31] So happy to share. [6:32] Obviously we went through the entire house. [6:39] So we've finished it, we've furnished it, we've got the chimney inspected, all the smoke detectors, fire extinguishers, we talked about the last, it's all referenced in the main mold for people. [6:56] Is that a copy that we can keep for the absolute. [7:06] I can see the family resentment. [7:11] It's there. [7:13] Great. [7:16] Buttercup. [7:18] No. [7:19] It's little cheerful. [7:20] It's yellow. [7:20] He chose yellow as we come. [7:22] Okay. [7:25] Okay. [7:26] Does that answer our question? [7:28] That sounds good. [7:29] Yeah. [7:29] I mean, I think just from past, [7:32] like sort of same situation, [7:35] like the biggest thing that's come up [7:37] is like communication with the neighborhood [7:40] and it sounds like you guys have a good plan for it. [7:44] And you know, like the board really is here [7:46] to like what's the word, you know, [7:50] just help things run along. [7:52] So, but if you guys are good, [7:54] you know, take care of each other, [7:55] like that's where it starts, so. [7:57] So it sounds like a good point to me. [8:01] Marty, was there a prerequisite condition on an on-site manager? [8:07] There was, so as we talked about on the phone, [8:13] some of the issues like firearms or whatever on the property, [8:17] those are restrictions that we have, [8:19] but those are sort of points of contention in the past, [8:23] so that's why we encourage to lay those out clearly. [8:27] communicated with your guests and your neighborhood you know and in those cases [8:33] where there was like some issues like we did ask for there to be a manager like [8:41] you know within I forget the distance like half hour hour or whatever it was [8:46] like they they sort of helped to arrange that and we were just trying to help [8:50] moderate but you know I don't know how that works like because you you said you [8:55] guys are up a lot so you don't necessarily need the property manager you know [9:00] local guys to work on the house like our farm and I used up here here's not [9:05] a couple projects you live over in Newark you would be here within 20 minutes if I [9:10] called and I think yeah like if you know the thing was to have like someone to have [9:16] like someone you can call 24-7 if there's a problem you know obviously not like [9:21] like there's police there's other but like something like that just so you're [9:27] available with there's some issue that we were forming obviously yeah that's [9:34] why we had that one in there yeah so I don't know if you know because that was [9:39] I was looking at that earlier and it was also noise like outside noise for [9:47] like campfires or anything like that and cut that off at 10 p.m. on weekend. I [9:54] think a lot of people wouldn't list it they do that anyway so they do them [9:57] why at times when they list it? Do you have that? We don't. If we don't have it [10:02] certainly you have it. [10:05] It's not really good. It's not really good. It's not really good, but it's [10:07] good. But if you want to list it ahead of time, then they probably let it use. I mean it's always a good thing to put on there I think. [10:14] So you know campgrounds do it, everybody, you know, [10:17] like as you say, you do it quite times. [10:19] And if useful, if you laid out there for your test, [10:22] it had a time. [10:23] Now, do you guys have questions at this point? [10:27] Because you're welcome to. [10:30] Not specifically. [10:31] I just wanted to come over and see what was going on. [10:36] And see if anybody else had anything. [10:38] I mean, I personally have known [10:43] issue with it. I mean, I've been up to the house. I see what they're, I kind of knew what they were, what was going on. [10:49] I can't imagine that anybody would come and rent that and be a worse person than me and my kids. [10:59] I mean, but, you know, I don't know. I think it's a great thing to try. I mean, if it's a disaster or a catastrophe, I would be the first one to call you and be like, [11:10] Okay, I don't know what's going on over the house, but yeah, we move on and call. [11:13] So, I, you know, I think it's great that it's going to be used and maybe bring some [11:21] people into the area and maybe they'll come over to the farm and buy some stuff from our [11:27] farms, too. [11:28] Yeah, exactly. [11:33] You can definitely add that because it is a great resource. [11:39] I don't know, that's my feeling. [11:42] I don't get really to work double about two things. [11:46] So I have some questions on what it's [11:50] coupled and maybe concerned about. [11:53] What if there was issues? [11:55] And is this like approved, is it permanent? [11:59] Or is there recourse on the part of the neighbors? [12:02] Is we're right above them? [12:04] Our driveway, their driveway goes [12:06] is borders our property we see that. [12:12] I'm concerned about trash we've had problems [12:17] with trash in the area with renters at other places in the bears and they come [12:24] by and so that's an issue the trash what's the you know what's gonna happen with [12:30] that, who's going to do that, get rid of that. [12:34] Our dog's allowed. [12:36] We're not at that speed. [12:37] How do you know pet policy? [12:39] No pet, no pet, no pet. [12:41] But I guess, you know, I'm not, we're not opposed to force, [12:45] but we're just concerned about noise parties, [12:50] because we heard the horror stories up [12:51] on the other place there. [12:54] And that's a very big concern. [12:58] And what kind of recourse? [12:59] if we have, if it's that approved, and then it's a disaster, is this a permanent thing, [13:06] or is it a, hey, you know, it's so for a year, or two, or whatever, I don't know. [13:12] Our approval is basically forever. [13:16] Yeah, I mean, with the, like, I would, I would say this, if there's a lot of issues, like [13:22] document them, you know, like somehow, and that's between your eyes. [13:26] Well, yeah, if you're like, hey, I had to call them at 11 p.m. because it was loud something [13:33] like let that and then if it's a continuous, you got a couple things, send us an email [13:39] at the curvy planning board and we can reach out to them and be like, listen, we're starting [13:46] to get some complaints, we need to either adjust that, change the conditions, or consider [13:54] They're like rethinking, like you know what I mean, it's ongoing, there's no end date [14:01] on it, but obviously if there's issues with neighbors, like we're here to moderate that [14:08] into... [14:09] We had a permits issue that passed that down, it's like it was down, nothing you can do about [14:17] it. [14:22] We've only started doing this since 2022, it's only been three years on here, and you've had trouble with this? [14:33] Well, you're coming out with others. [14:35] Oh. [14:36] So, for example, because you're mentioning the one on a drive, right? [14:44] So what happened is like that one was already running and there was no condition for this it was unregulated. [14:52] So what we did is like three years ago we put in it has to be a conditional use because you can't make one. [15:02] Local government meeting. Local government meeting. [15:04] But it was already running, like that. [15:06] There was already issues there. [15:08] What we did is we met, we put conditions. [15:12] I know there was a lot of issues. [15:14] And we tried to like get the neighbors to figure out [15:17] how it's going to work in a fair way. [15:21] Like we were the ones that were walking through it [15:25] and saying like, OK, you have a right to this, [15:27] but you also have a right to that. [15:29] Where's the line? [15:30] And it's best coming from the neighbors, [15:32] which as I understood you guys already have some familiarity that's like a [15:37] plus you know what I mean that situation the landowner live farther away [15:44] there wasn't any connection to the area you know what I mean this is also a [15:51] conditional use it's approved whether without conditions so we can put conditions [15:54] on this as we get feedback from people but it would need to happen before we [16:01] issue the conditional use. So if you have concerns that would require additional conditions [16:07] on what they're doing, we would just need to know those up front. [16:12] Hi, what happened just might, just this would help you guys actually, but there's, um, [16:17] there's a rental in East Haven and it was, you know, people who looked amazing and young [16:22] and snowboarders and there was, uh, two near overdoses. Um, and so that was like a great [16:29] example of like yeah so but it you know it caused lots of issues within the [16:38] neighborhood because [16:42] they were doing cereal weekend like in other words they [16:45] had rented it for five weeks or six weeks and that's that's like [16:49] obviously that's in the right that actually said wow you know if you you [16:55] commit a crime that your lease is negated. Like there wasn't the landlords themselves [17:03] didn't have a mechanism so then the neighbors were like oh no. So like just to finish what [17:09] I was saying there like since we issued that permit up there to my knowledge they've submitted [17:14] no complaints. So like you were saying that it was left it was done and it was left I'm I'm [17:20] not aware of any complaint from there in he's not talking about that no I [17:25] would have said that there's some in town that like haven't been addressed so [17:30] we're here if they ever have an issue like they just need to tell us and we you [17:36] know we work that out like that's that's the process so far and I haven't [17:41] heard any complaints back from that right I'm sure there's some things but they [17:45] haven't brought it to us so it's hard for us to address that kind of thing [17:49] But garbage, garbage is, we've set it up with, [17:59] it's not left outside, no it's not left outside. [18:04] In the winter we have them putting it outside and only because then we're taking it on our [18:08] way by so we don't have to bother going inside the house but as soon as we get past winter season [18:14] the clean will take. Stanley used to put his compost out there. [18:24] Thank you for the question. It's a good question for us as a municipality and as a board [18:29] to understand that if we're issuing a conditional use permit with conditions, then what is [18:38] the enforcement compliance if those conditions are violated? It is something that, as a board, [18:44] or you should revisit if those conditions are being violated. [18:49] So if there's stipulations as to no parties, and then there are parties, there has to be [18:58] a problem. [18:59] My biggest concern is late night, [19:04] likely it happened, or in this kind of situation. [19:08] How far do you live away from 388 Locustritt with you, youth at the 80 yards, okay? [19:19] They can hear everything. [19:21] Yeah. [19:22] I would just say to that, if you've got, where are you guys listed doing the quiet time hours, [19:29] and then putting a string like, if you violate this, you may terminate your state. [19:36] So would you be open to language in your life? [19:40] proposal that submitted that say that this is a family-friendly neighborhood [19:46] this is for family gatherings this is not a party house and they say being [19:51] respected if I get a neighbor there's already a call from the neighbor there's [19:57] already you know yeah we're we're screening we're not a place that's a big [20:02] We have to be kicking out of hand. [20:06] Let's start out on the air. [20:09] We have to even be here in this church. [20:12] Yay. [20:13] And these two buildings. [20:17] It's quite, more or less a quiet neighborhood, residential. [20:25] Yeah, that's your history. [20:28] That's your retirement home. [20:29] and like to go outside, I'm sure, enjoy the evening. [20:34] Okay, let's move on to our third one because I'm interested in this one, traffic on roads [20:42] and highways and the vicinity. [20:44] That's a private road, right? [20:47] The estimated traffic generator, but a conditional use shall not exceed the estimated volume of [20:52] traffic. [20:53] Well, you don't need to hear all that. [20:58] So if you had eight people there, you might have four cars. [21:05] Is that a fair cap? [21:07] Yes. [21:07] Four cars. [21:09] That's maximum. [21:11] Yeah. [21:13] There's not enough parking. [21:14] There's not enough parking. [21:15] I don't have a problem with it. [21:19] Well, how much parking do you have? [21:21] How much do you have parking for? [21:24] It depends whether you want to get out or not. [21:26] I mean, it's got a decent size turnaround on the top, but that's it, nobody's part there. [21:32] So, it's a one lane driveway and one lane driveway out, you can park on the sides of the driveway [21:37] and so get out. [21:38] So, I think the floor is fairly open. [21:41] Okay. [21:41] Yeah. [21:42] Okay. [21:43] So, if it's a private road, who fixes it? [21:48] The land owners all go in together. [21:50] So that was where that was a similar situation on a private road or drive like they made an arrangement, you know, we can't [21:59] obligate any resident on that road to pay a certain amount of like, you know, road maintenance on a private road. [22:08] But we, like, we help them to sort of sort out an arrangement where like, what are, you know, if you are getting constant traffic like, are you helping, you know, [22:19] I don't know that on a private road, we can force that, but they worked out some system. [22:26] Yeah, there was a problem with the road, like there was three years ago. [22:30] Absolutely. [22:31] Thank our pieces. [22:32] Yeah, [22:35] just, I mean, better we throw it out now before it becomes an issue, you know, like [22:39] if that works or it doesn't work, like we need to kind of have a shared plan. [22:44] We obviously have the best interest in the road being possible. [22:51] May I clarify how many resonances are on Locust Ridge? [22:56] On the right away from the town of the 10 is Elizabeth, us, your place, and Mariah of [23:07] that. [23:11] Have there been, have there been maintenance requirements that were shared in recent history? [23:37] I don't know if you guys already have a system for how you make that work. [23:44] I'm just curious, we're not trying to impose something on you but we're just... [23:50] I don't know. [23:51] Do you have a way to tell us we'll try and make that a new suggestion? [23:55] We paid some for the recent repair and we got some fee in the money. [23:59] Stanley got some fee in the money that he put in. [24:04] Others have just created it occasionally because she's got it all. [24:07] And I had some leftover gravel or whatever that they took when I excavated from my house [24:15] and you're some of that in it. [24:22] But your system is like sort of as needed, like everybody kind of kicks in a little. [24:28] So, okay. [24:28] I mean, it doesn't have to. [24:30] Oh, just that, that was the rare. [24:33] Yeah. [24:34] We haven't really put anything into it, but it badly needed it, so, and it needs some more [24:41] in the first half. [24:43] Yeah. [24:44] So, that, I mean, that's where the, yeah. [24:47] contention was last times. How people were supporting that? [24:53] Fix up and walk away. We're actively managing and we're not farming it out. [24:59] So the [25:05] zoning regulations between that and the non-entry utilization of renewable energy [25:14] resources. Conditioner you shall not excessively inhibit or restrict access to a [25:21] visa in your natural resources. I don't think that that's a problem either. [25:32] So I would say that this is all sort of whatever conditions we're coming up with [25:40] obviously you can just put them on your BRBO listing and that's something we can [25:54] I was just wondering how would you fill if you put a condition on your property that [26:00] if we didn't allow fireworks a because of the I would mainly mainly because of and [26:12] the noise and then also you know we'll have a lot of dry periods where we [26:17] won't have open burning or a fire pit and then the other condition I would [26:24] just like to kick out there as fire arms no shooting on the property it is [26:30] already on the air. No but that would be great yeah that's the only concerns I [26:38] Yeah. [26:46] Should we just review the ones that we have been, the conditions, like, is what [26:53] I have to put it on them. [26:59] Yep. I mean, I think a lot of it's already in your, your visitor guide here. [27:05] Yeah. I mean, we'll add the quiet times for. [27:07] But just to like put them on, you know, on our record, and like I said, if there are things [27:12] we come back. So we'll add, we'll add, we'll make this a little something. Yeah, give [27:22] you that and you'll see it this before. [27:31] The rest of it will be in your VRBO. [27:39] So you're, [27:40] you're calling this House of Buttercup? Are you going to require all guests to watch the princess [27:47] this broad, you'll repeat when you walk in. [27:52] So, will you talk about just gun disclosure, [27:56] but you decided, no gun, no, no, okay, no. [28:05] Okay, so the next, so we'll work out the conditional use. [28:12] Yeah, I won't write it up. [28:14] And with, I don't know if you want to review the conditions [28:18] or they're kind of like, for example, if we put, [28:21] like must have a contact available. I understand you guys already have their [28:28] numbers so we'll just formalize that and there's nothing but it's nothing like [28:49] The one we did before was 11 on weekends. [28:58] How do you feel about that, Mr. Erick? [29:07] Okay. [29:08] Okay. [29:11] Okay. [29:15] Road maintenance, fireworks, and I think that was it. [29:19] Trash security. [29:20] Trash security. [29:21] Thanks, Tray. [29:23] Can I ask you a question on the trash security? [29:26] So you said during the winter, you're going to take care of it, and during the summer months, [29:32] No, is that person there every day or the end of the rental? [29:38] Okay, so in the news, somebody's there for a week or two. [29:42] Okay. [29:43] Where's that trash going? [29:46] So there's three trash barrels in the detention. [29:49] Three full-out trash barrels. [29:51] There's a fairly micro-fatty of the kids living there. [29:53] Okay. [29:53] And I am expecting you and then every veteran of the house can find the patterns of trash cans. [30:00] And then, because I'm just thinking, if somebody doesn't want to have all that smelly stuff in the house while they're there, they're going to be putting it outside. And then once it's outside, then it's going to attract your animals. I'm just wondering if there's something there. Okay. You'll try love. Yeah, I feel like an experience. People that are staying [30:29] don't usually stay there all the time. So they want to come up with the trash that you were on. Right? You know, because a lot of them, they're gone. [30:36] Yeah, you could have picked the boxes or tank out. [30:41] Fish. [30:43] My thoughts. [30:45] Well, we just sent the completed conditional. [30:52] What's that? [30:53] I usually send the findings of that. [30:56] Okay. [30:56] Do you guys know if you want to do that? [30:58] No, that's totally fine. [31:00] Okay, so you'll do that. [31:03] Okay. [31:04] So, yeah, Mary. [31:06] I just wanted to mention, I know I tried to people in the past [31:09] had outdoor trash receptacles of a bear proof. [31:13] And so those were approved because they were bear proof. [31:17] And that, like, if you didn't want to have to write a sound, [31:36] That's what they use in remote campsite, bare voxels, they're metal loggable unless the [31:44] and pick up a multi-hundred pound. [31:46] So far so good. [31:49] Just a little off. [31:49] It's really wonderful. [31:50] Yeah. [31:53] Okay, so you'll hear from us. [31:57] Okay. [31:57] Thank you for your time. [31:58] Thank you so much for coming up. [32:02] What? [32:04] What? [32:05] We could vote on it now. [32:07] I thought that's what we did. [32:08] Yeah. [32:10] We could just, yeah. [32:11] We issued the conditional use with, with conditions asking. [32:15] Yeah, we've noted. Well, yeah, any other discipline? Do you do you have any of it? [32:26] Motion to accrue the conditional use short-term [32:36] Got our support [32:50] Yeah, thank you, isn't it? [33:01] That old guy right there. [33:03] Well, what you got, Malcolm. [33:05] That's why he's on school board for many, many years. [33:08] And he's... [33:10] We can... [33:11] All right. [33:13] Let's um... [33:13] Do you have any comments? [33:15] Yeah, it's okay. [33:16] Has everybody else cast a look at the minutes? [33:18] We don't want you to get it in the end. [33:25] No, we can move on to the next. [33:28] Can [33:32] everybody look at it? [33:34] Any other comments or questions about what we did? [33:38] Just to your friend. [33:41] On to the next part. [33:46] Buttercup. [33:47] Did you take the minute? [33:49] Aaron. [33:50] Pardon? [33:58] She did, that's January, so I'm kind of sorry, people have had a chance to meet. [34:07] I mean, they're all happy, I mean, they're all happy, I'm their talk, all in favor. [34:14] Hi. [34:15] Second. [34:20] Okay, we're ready to talk about the education, we're ready to hear about education. [34:36] So I just want to be clear, like we've been working on the town plan for, it's my second [34:49] time doing it, right, and it's always like forward-looking, forward-looking, so we're [34:54] We're just asking questions about where is it going, right, like development, you know, [35:00] and that's all. [35:01] And I think one factor that we need to consider is, you know, what how school does attract [35:11] families to Kirby, because that does change development, you know. [35:15] So that's kind of the angle I see us coming at it from, like as far as what our work has [35:20] been. [35:20] And I would like just better clarity on our numbers because it's just hard to pull our numbers out in the whole district's data, you know, and like I think that would help us all to better understand how we should be planning for this, you know, I don't know what anyone else wants to. [35:43] I'm interested in specific numbers for sure I mean we they're in the town it's one point yeah [35:51] it's one point which is a jump and that's it's also a jump for I think Gil Hall and there was one [35:55] of the town that had a big jump he said thank you so and that's it's relatively exponential jump it's [36:02] not just a small jump so that that was what I was when Scott Campbell stood up we brought that up [36:11] They didn't really have any answer. [36:14] Yeah, like how much has it grown? [36:17] Our numbers have been history across the board, [36:20] and that's how pretty good. [36:21] I mean, 10 tons have been increased quite a bit. [36:24] Kirby's been relatively consistent in terms of [36:27] the number of students that we've had at school, [36:29] and on a very high level student, [36:32] and some of the poor students. [36:36] The other town's been increased. [36:38] He's taken his place in St. John's since [36:52] can you tell us like so we're up we've been around 130 or one somewhere in [36:59] there like is that going back to like 10 years ago or do you know how many [37:07] How long has it been at 130 or roughly? [37:15] I would say since COVID, since we joined, since COVID has been a pretty steady increase, [37:22] COVID came and everything took up quite a bit. [37:24] Where would we find the numbers of how many students in curvy? [37:32] Okay, but is it just for curvy or it's for the the whole? [37:39] Oh, yeah, yeah, like that's kind of like that's the trend that we want to understand. It's like [38:04] No, I understand that it's on the pre-major party that involved, so I wouldn't say it for a couple of years and it's still something drastic happening, [38:13] which is the room that everybody seems to be looking to. It may hold where we're at. It may go up slightly. [38:24] It's going to take two to three years for a major change to be implemented. [38:29] If we were to split our district because of this split up which is one of the planners [38:33] in Newville with the same J area, I don't know what that's going to be defined as as choice. [38:40] I mean it could still include the choices that we had. [38:43] There's been conversations about both districts being formed, bringing strengths on the numbers [38:49] because the schools when they give the district [38:50] can only be so many, so I don't know if that's true. [38:53] There's a lot of opportunities in the same fashion [38:55] that it has, so it's kind of hard, you know. [39:00] So it's pretty hard to predict what's going on. [39:03] No, I totally understand. [39:05] I mean, for the couple of years, [39:07] before those changes are implemented, [39:09] I would say that they're going to stay in the pretty [39:11] curve, you should stay in a fairly low level. [39:14] So what I'm looking for, I think, [39:18] or what I think we're looking for is it is hard to predict it and like you said there's [39:22] very many variables. [39:23] So what we really need is we need to look at the trend of the past 10 to 20 years and [39:30] see how has our numbers changed because that would tell us information about how the town [39:36] has developed, how it's grown and that would help us understand like do we think it's going [39:42] to come to an end or you know flat and off but like you said it's hard to predict but we [39:46] We just need to look at the historical data first [40:09] Yeah, I think it would actually be a good it'd be a good graphic to have in the town plans to be like you know [40:15] So here's how it's changed, because we're not just doing this so we make up our mind [40:20] about it. [40:21] We want to present information and then have people see, like, here's the trend or whatever [40:27] it is. [40:27] It's not depending on getting census numbers. [40:29] Yeah. [40:30] And then here's where, like you said, there's potential to go flat and go elsewhere. [40:36] I also think that it's changed just, I think that when we do that, we'll come over to give [40:40] you some guidelines. [40:41] But I think it's important that you have some context around us. [40:46] So an area that we address when we were BCSU and we were our own district and we had [40:54] our own contracts of schools where that was at some of the problems we faced with there. [41:00] Even within that framework of years we sent kids to curving, we had issues where we were paying [41:05] a state average and contracts were for a long period of time and then we negotiated a short [41:13] period of time and then we started paying a little bit more so I mean some of those variables [41:17] would help you understand some of those numbers much better in terms of that and in terms [41:24] of projecting some of those scenarios are going to be important to know to put some validity [41:30] and some understanding to the numbers that you're looking to judge on how things are going. [41:37] Isn't it also likely to be true? I'm kind of just supposed to be sure. [41:41] But as long as Kirby maintains choice, [41:44] has the opportunity for families to choose schools for their kids, [41:48] whatever parameters there are on that, [41:50] Kirby is going to continue to attract young families. [41:54] And it's going to attract as many young families as there are houses [41:57] is at local affordable rates for sale, right? [42:02] Not second home prices, but. [42:03] And so, isn't it kind of dependent on, like, how much, [42:07] and this is the work you guys do, but, like, [42:09] we would have more students get them [42:11] a more poverty for sale. [42:13] So, well, can I? [42:14] Yeah, I'm not that has a view or a bad thing. [42:16] I'm not putting any judgment on it. [42:18] I have to say, like, if you can divide curvy up [42:20] into five acre lots, there will be [42:22] not many of them in the family for sale. [42:24] Yeah, I think that's where we look at it, [42:26] is if people can't do that, [42:30] then do we need to change the lot size? [42:32] Like, that's a planning board issue. [42:34] That's, we're not, we're not like, [42:36] take away school choice. [42:37] No, I understand. [42:38] That gets thrown out and people get all defensive [42:41] and no one here is like, take away school choice. [42:44] I totally understand. [42:45] So I just, I just want to clarify like, again, [42:47] our angle is, can we get the demographic information [42:51] on how the populations change? [42:52] Because that would help with planning development. [42:54] Can we, I don't, like personally, I don't even need to see the numbers yet. [42:59] I'd like to see the demographics of population first, right? [43:03] Then school, cost of school is complicated, like maybe the school board puts out a thing [43:08] about that. [43:09] You know, I think also Kirby residents want to know more about Kirby and not only about [43:15] the district, because some of those towns are like one student and mixing them in, it drastically [43:22] confused as the formula so we would maybe like one of those towns is the most [43:28] it's just very hard when we talk district right now talking some choice [43:32] we're just the other thing they're called [43:34] demographically [43:39] I just wanted to clarify that what crime was for ever was kids who lived in [43:49] I had a choice of what school to go to. [43:51] I wanted to say it before she left, but I made mistake reading my hand. [43:57] They didn't attract young families. [44:00] Like, we weren't a hub attracting young families for decades. [44:05] It was just curvy. [44:07] And there was not very much transition or growth. [44:13] But there was a choice for the kids who lived in Kirby. [44:18] If we're going to be a hub that's attracting young families, [44:22] then I think we need to look at what that's common somewhat of a transient population. [44:29] Not transient meaning, you know, here for two months, but transient meaning here for six or even years. [44:36] It's an eight year rental. [44:38] It totally changes or your ownership, whatever, but yeah, and if we're going to be, if we are heading towards being a transient population, [44:49] then that has to be planned for very differently than if it's a town of people who live here for the decades. [45:00] That is, yes, is there that much turnover in home in terms of sale? That's my question. That's where we need to. That's where we're behind the paper. [45:11] I think we could go back into town records and see, if you look at the size of the landlords, we came here back in 2008, it wasn't a common land out there, there's still a lot of big grids, landowners that were logging or whatever, and that is shifted as, you know, that's in the name of the early eights, so that shifted going into the 90s, things change, you got a population that can manage the farms, so those things have changed, so I think when you look at a number of demographics, [45:44] what was the age of population? What was the population doing? How did they make the [45:50] livelihood? I mean, that's changed draft. It's all very early. I mean, you can't not [45:56] bring some of that information into any type of projection of what you do. You have manufacturing [46:01] plans. Well, that is in the plan. It does speak to a little history of it, so there is some [46:08] of that is like I think like you said you know you're looking at the number of [46:12] farms has gone down just in five years just in ten years that lands maybe [46:20] going to get divided up and then we're looking at another increase of like [46:25] residents moving in you know so we're just trying to plan ahead yeah so we need [46:30] to we need the data up to now and then try and base our predictions on what we [46:36] You see, if there are a significant number of houses that are cycling, flipping constantly, [46:44] and neighboring communities, and I know this has happened on a few occasions, I don't know how many, [46:49] but if there are neighboring communities that are essentially using curvy [46:55] to send their children not to their municipal schools, but in the curvy, so that curvy has choice, [47:01] so that they can go to independent schools and then when they're done with that, they're gone. [47:07] And then how slips in its cycles. [47:09] And so if that's recurring a lot, it's an enormous problem for curving in terms of the educational cost. [47:17] That was one of the things she was saying. [47:21] That's the piece you need where it says domestic violence. [47:24] They have to domestic violence. [47:26] I know St. James has that because people do that the game will do the game and they require [47:33] a domicile. [47:34] A lot of her has dealt with that for years and it's the same thing and the schools know [47:42] whether you're in that town and actually will come forward to the board and say this person [47:48] said domicile. [47:49] I think there are people who don't decide. [47:52] Oh, how do you say it? [47:53] Don't decide. [47:54] It still is a slow turnover, but it's still a constant turnover. [48:00] And it would make a difference. [48:04] I have to be funny because I'm not aware of maybe that. [48:11] I are and I'm not seeing that. [48:13] So maybe it's a lot more on North Kirby. [48:16] And you guys have a lot of living at home? [48:20] I mean, it's not a flip over, no, but I've been very aware of families that I know [48:26] that you moved in and the children went to Riverside. [48:33] I actually would think at first that they were curvy neighbors. [48:37] It's like, well, it's cool. [48:39] But then at certain point, they sold and moved away. [48:51] And maybe I just am lucky enough to know a few of the people who did that and it's not [48:56] that they got things. [48:58] I think that's what I was talking about. [49:00] It would be really, really interesting to know the numbers because I know I've seen people [49:05] building and purposely purchasing and building for school choice. [49:12] It's for school choice, but I mean, their idea is that they're not, and their monitors who wanted to be both the choice of, they like Kirby. [49:27] So, I don't know if they're free. [49:33] Well, some boy, Holmes, there's someone passed away, and then something else I can do. [49:39] What Kirby had schooled in, down to the police in the beginning, he started to hear [49:44] choice, not choice. [49:46] He said that he was out very well in law groups. [49:48] He wrote down that he was home. [49:51] He knew that he was home in the same day. [49:53] So, the ability to centralize the community has miscited it. [49:57] Because, whether it be at Riverside or in Riverside, the choice not simply has been a draw [50:04] are people that look for situations that work for the kids. [50:10] I think you probably remember when we had big, too many of you know, [50:14] quite some people in this hall when we had the idea of getting rid of choice [50:20] and trying to start a school because people were tired of paying the amount of life [50:24] or paying non-riversight. [50:27] And it was ironic that one of the persons who had run into college [50:32] the school they were in, where they started school, where they lived in a situation where [50:37] whatever wasn't working for them had options. [50:41] You started school, you run one school, and you're in it, and not every school would come [50:45] and accept it. [50:47] You don't have much leverage to build that, whereas with choice, we offered that, we offered [50:55] a chance to find an education for your kid with a lot of work with him, C.J. [51:00] Linda Bill, Riverside. [51:03] The college has school. [51:05] So that was a big draw. [51:06] I mean, you know, a lot of it went to Riverside. [51:09] That was a big issue. [51:10] And I think people stood behind that back then. [51:13] But that has decentralized. [51:16] It has. [51:17] So I don't know. [51:18] Regardless of what you do to school. [51:20] I mean, if you took that community at Riverside, that was the hub at school here. [51:24] We have a community of people that have common interests to do it. [51:31] So I don't know how you recovered without a school. [51:34] I don't know how you recover the central community. [51:38] I mean, you can help without the attraction of the school [51:41] that brings a lot of people together. [51:45] I'm not saying anything, but it's a challenge. [51:48] When I look at the schools that we were talking about, [51:50] you know, you can call them, they call us a school. [51:56] They went down to zero kids to school, back up to 42, they went on to school, they don't have much choice but a lot of people from the cancer can move into that town because they want to go there and go to pay the tax rate that will be paid in Vermont in order to have their kids so it's hard to know what is going to attract people and what does those people work in the cancer but they don't want to live in the cancer. [52:19] Where do those guild halls do most go? [52:25] This is a couple of odd things that they did down here. [52:29] It was all as a couple of people they built in. [52:32] I think they never saw it. [52:36] But, you know, most people can't make that work. [52:39] A lot of people let me talk to you. [52:41] I mean, a lot of people are basically telling me [52:43] that they have to take their kids to St.J. Academy. [52:58] So, it's in my ride, you know how getting all of this number, I'd be like to get the number [53:03] show where our kids go, but like a shirt on my whole district, which it would pay out [53:09] just where curvy kids go in the past ten years. [53:35] That's fine. The longer back the better, you know, it's data. [53:46] I think just one thing though is like you said there wasn't centralized but like 20 years ago [53:52] they used to drop a tree and you couldn't drive over the mountain so it's not like any kid on that [53:58] side of Kirby was going over you know like that they used to put a tree down and that's it so I [54:07] We don't know, it never has been. [54:10] That's why there's mud hollow school, [54:12] South Caribbean school, but there's more traffic now [54:17] because you can drive, and there's more mud now, [54:19] and there's more road damage now, [54:21] and that's taxes, education, and roads. [54:26] And so that's where development becomes another key issue [54:30] because that's what we spend money on, it's rules. [54:32] I just want to say, I might just say somebody can pass [54:34] on the john like these roads should be horrible coming over I know when we first moved here trying to [54:40] come on multiple days that are wishing like this it would have been impossible like he's got that [54:48] arch going and it is raining it is raining so I remember getting stuck so I was expecting it and I'm [55:00] Wow. [55:02] I think along the schools and education, [55:05] now families are the greatest. [55:06] I think what we do for the old people who are in this town, [55:10] for the 50 years, 30 years, [55:14] we do taxes, we do taxes, we do keep up. [55:17] I know we have a veteran like him, [55:18] and we want to have a hard time making it, [55:21] we are offending, big, or some kind of a disaster. [55:24] So I don't know if there's any way of people [55:38] We're 30 years. [55:40] We don't think we can afford it. [55:43] Yeah, because if you take that tax burden off of those people, which is going to add to the, [55:49] so the younger people's tax burden, right? [55:51] I mean, somebody's got pay to taxes to make up the debt. [55:53] Right, right. [55:54] But they're moving here. [55:54] So if that's given the factor of moving in this place, [55:58] it's actually common, and they get a tax rate to the old people. [56:03] And they want to move. [56:04] I mean, I don't know what to trade up. [56:06] You want people to stay, you want people to come in, [56:09] you just don't want to be forced out, you don't want to force them out. [56:12] Right. [56:12] So, I mean, just the point of, just the point of, [56:15] the point of, I mean, is that you can manage to allow people [56:19] to set their whole life here, I mean, [56:20] the way that we can be together for instance. [56:25] But then we'll have a bunch of people that just hit whatever age move in here to get [56:29] those taxes. [56:31] You know, one of the things, no, you have to look at the school taxes because otherwise [56:39] as it'll be like, all right, 75, moving a curvy. [56:43] What else do you say? [56:45] You have to pay taxes for 30 years. [56:48] In our decision on that, you went on that. [56:52] We've done that. [56:55] You know, the other thing though is that I think, [57:01] as a taxpayer who's been here for 30 years, [57:04] we never had children. [57:05] I believe in education more than anything, and I've always voted for it, but now we're [57:14] retired. [57:15] And the other thing is that there's a lack of community in this town. [57:21] There's a lack of people who are willing to do things to have a community. [57:25] and that's that frustration that really does. I mean we sent out a survey, the [57:33] planning committee did, to get some feedback about we got 50 surveys back and [57:40] some people thought that was great. [57:42] Can I just add in now? So I heard about the survey and I was like, how did I use it? [57:51] So thank you so I it was the wrong thing today no no it was actually a great [57:57] idea to organize people however what I did was what my neighbors did [58:05] my daughter and I are going to all our paperwork like here it is so we did [58:10] the same thing we knew that our tax bill was going to explode and so we did all [58:16] All the same things, like I opened it, I looked at it and said it in the same way. [58:19] I am not looking at it anymore, I know, and the extra is going up. [58:23] And that is actually what Jennifer Wood did, it's what Bill Wolf did, like I was asking [58:28] around, we all did the same thing. [58:30] And it wasn't because we wouldn't have answered it, it was because we were dreading that [58:35] test Bill, and we literally said it aside. [58:38] I totally get it. [58:39] I totally get it. [58:40] I totally get it. [58:41] And I thought of that when we sent it out that way. [58:44] It was actually a really good idea because everybody was because of expense. [58:49] We have nothing to put into it. [58:51] I mean, we don't have money. [58:53] And we're all voluntary. [58:55] Yes. [58:56] No. [58:56] I don't like that. [58:57] And I'm not criticism. [58:59] No, I totally get it. [59:00] And people did not purposefully not answer that. [59:03] A lot of them never thought you would. [59:07] I am Alex. [59:08] I just want to say just about the community thing, like I, you know, as a very new resident [59:12] here like last say six years like we were like the new people were the new people who aren't doing [59:17] anything with the new people who are not like you know creating the community remember but like [59:21] all I know is like you know I come this is my experience we love it here we have kids at Riverside [59:27] whatever you know I come to town meeting day right and I try to meet people and I've met people [59:33] and then I see the people I know from Kirby who go to Riverside because that as we've talked about [59:39] But I just want to, I guess, sort of forcefully reject the idea that, like, we've, there's [59:44] somehow, like, a lack of community, like, because of the people in the community and we're [59:48] just, it's like, we don't have a school. And, like, I don't, I'm not aware of any events [59:54] I've missed. Do you know what I mean? I'm now coming to this. But in terms of, like, I'm, like, [1:00:00] I think I would love to be part of something that attempts to create community, and I think part of community is welcoming newcomers, you know what I'm saying? And so, like, for example, I know people in Lindenville who said to me, hey, you're a lawyer, can you be in the Linden downtown development, whatever? And I said, yes, so I'm on that thing. Because people knew me and they asked, and I said yes. And my experience in Kirby, and I love Kirby, and I want to be more involved, is that I haven't seen, like, I've come to the annual meeting. [1:00:29] and I know anecdotally I hear and I believe that there are gaps in the planning commission or whatever and then they want people to film up but by the time I get to the town meeting it seems like that sort of been hammered out and someone nominate somebody and it's like yes nominate accepted and I'm sitting there I don't know anybody so I'm like okay it sounds like that's a done you know so I would just say I know I would just say like the one thing that I just I have to like [1:00:58] to accept that we don't have community, which may well be true and you all know much better than I do. [1:01:04] It's not because the people who are here don't want community, it's not because the new people don't want community. [1:01:10] It's because for whatever reason we aren't finding a way and maybe we are together as a group. [1:01:16] So I would just say it's not about like... [1:01:18] We totally, I totally hear it and I am not. [1:01:22] Yeah, I just, we do have a community happening this year. [1:01:31] As a result of our last time meeting, [1:01:34] Nelia has volunteered to do some community, [1:01:38] Nelia who is a single parent and has no time at all. [1:01:42] So we need to get behind her to do that. [1:01:45] and so we can do that but this is yeah yeah yeah yeah I hear you totally [1:01:56] Alex I absolutely do but I would like to add also that we have in here for [1:02:03] 30 years and we're not sure if we can make it because of taxes separate issue [1:02:08] I agree. Yeah. Yeah. Separate issue. Yeah. Separate issue and date. [1:02:15] So. [1:02:17] Yeah. Yeah. [1:02:21] Anyway. Is it worth asking? [1:02:28] So what were you saying Mary? [1:02:30] Well, now we're... [1:02:33] We had 40 still in the town for decades after the school has changed. [1:02:40] And that served at least one, but there were, and I know there was one that I was curbian as [1:02:48] one, sometimes, and there were seasonal things, you know, there was a harvest dinner where [1:02:54] kids would be cooked for whatever grown up wanted to come, there were, the kids got involved [1:03:02] and adults being green updates, which now you still take care of advertising for the [1:03:08] group. [1:03:08] There was a lot of seasonal activities to all the neighbors close by, they were organized [1:03:17] by forage. [1:03:18] The people who were running it got old, [1:03:23] and there was nobody there who stepped up to [1:03:28] run in a big way. [1:03:29] That's a big stake, and I know that's not always true, but I do believe that can happen but [1:03:35] without school, but there can be amazing community events. [1:03:44] I haven't seen in the, I don't, I wonder sometimes [1:03:52] is it just a change in society overall, that 40 and 30, [1:03:58] 45 year olds aren't even interested in doing that anymore? [1:04:02] You know, like they're busy. [1:04:03] It's, they're working. [1:04:04] I was busy in working when I was 30. [1:04:07] No, I know, but I know I was working two jobs, and I still did that, so I hear that, but is it a change in values of perception and what, but the people who used to keep those community get together going? [1:04:24] I mean, the yarns sail, but the fun activities are for the art world. [1:04:31] Well, it needs something. [1:04:34] We used to have a girl younger, the Kirby Community Action Council, and we knew a lot [1:04:37] of the activities through that. [1:04:39] Alex, I think what we're also suffering from is the old guard and the new guard. [1:04:44] And I say that as the old guard and, you know, I certainly had massive energy for doing [1:04:51] the stuff with this time when I was younger and I had kids when you want somebody to do something [1:04:57] and ask a busy person. [1:05:01] So I think there is some division and I will say that I'm very [1:05:05] happy to meet you, very happy to meet you. It's got me here. I have got to know some of my [1:05:11] neighbors. And I'm here because you have anything and it's nice to get to know people because [1:05:17] As I, when I, and I move it, when I was driving over here, I said to myself, I used to [1:05:23] know every single person in this town, I used to know who they were and where they lived. [1:05:28] And I don't know that anymore. [1:05:30] And that's on me. [1:05:32] But I will say it also only takes one person to decide they're going to do something and [1:05:38] have an event and hold it. [1:05:39] Aaron's always very happy to [1:05:43] Lone out the town hall for whatever activity and has addresses. We can get you know messages people [1:05:50] There's a curvy community page that I started [1:05:53] That we could put something on. It's just I don't think it's that difficult [1:06:00] But when you don't know everybody it can be a little bit daunting to do something like that [1:06:06] And I certainly think about that a lot. [1:06:09] I think about the fact that we just need community activities. [1:06:12] They don't have to be fancy. [1:06:13] They can be a bot luck. [1:06:15] They could be a square dance. [1:06:16] And we used to do a lot of those here. [1:06:19] Believe it or not, we used to fit a lot of people into this little square, [1:06:22] with the square dance band up on the stage. [1:06:27] And we had community. [1:06:29] I will also say that when we lost the schools that we had here, [1:06:33] we lost community. [1:06:34] And it was hard for people, but we still came together for harvest [1:06:39] uppers and things like that. So I think that is sort of dwindled over the [1:06:42] years because of the age of the group that knew everybody and used to do. [1:06:48] I do live in a new house in town, or do you live in a... [1:06:51] I live in... [1:06:52] The Brains. [1:06:54] Yeah, okay. [1:06:54] So people would probably still say that, oh, you know the old Carobling Brains place? [1:06:58] So I'm sorry, but we do that. [1:06:59] I know, that's why. [1:07:00] Yeah. [1:07:00] So, I don't necessarily, I don't know that we have answers regarding how to bridge some [1:07:06] of those gaps, but I really do think it just takes a small group of people who want that [1:07:12] to make it happen. [1:07:14] And I'm certainly willing to be a part of that because I've done it before, and I feel [1:07:18] like, and I got to know some lovely people, we decided to do a little bit of food pantry [1:07:24] here. [1:07:24] I got to know Lynn, Lynn, I can vary in gender problem and I already knew a native but got to know her a little better and it just takes a few people and we can start driving some change and I think Kirby is full of people who want that. [1:07:42] It's just that there's some division of a generational but absolutely no blame. [1:07:48] That doesn't really, it's not something we can really address in them. [1:07:51] Yeah, and we're except for a little bit of our community action council with that. [1:07:56] We can try, I mean, get information out and all that's good. [1:08:03] So, anyway, we're a little bit off topic. [1:08:06] Yes. [1:08:06] Martin, you're gonna get us the miles. [1:08:11] Marty, miles. [1:08:12] Marty, Mary. It's the end. They named me. I had no part in this. [1:08:20] Victim. Miles, you're going to get us some numbers. [1:08:22] Yes, I'll have the self-worth. [1:08:24] Okay, thank you. [1:08:25] Aaron, Mary, who are the town agents? [1:08:32] Is it worth asking Clark if it's legal to create a tax structure? [1:08:40] or like 30 years, 10% rebate. [1:08:43] Yes. [1:08:45] Is that just ending in legal to pursue debt? [1:08:48] Yeah, because I don't want to take a long time to know. [1:08:51] Because that does put the burden on to. [1:08:53] It does put the burden on to. [1:08:56] This is the nature of economics, and it speaks [1:08:59] to the question of, OK, where are we off to? [1:09:03] Because health don't need the money. [1:09:05] And if we're not getting it from, it goes back. [1:09:09] And it would be some sort of like list or card requirement that your 30-year residency [1:09:14] then the bill goes down and then that obviously gets pushed on to the other 90%. [1:09:20] And you have to give it up beyond planning commission for 30 years. [1:09:25] Right? [1:09:26] That's right. [1:09:26] Don't worry about it. [1:09:27] Don't worry about it. [1:09:29] Don't worry about it. [1:09:30] Don't worry about it. [1:09:33] Don't worry about it. [1:09:36] Don't worry about it. [1:09:37] Don't worry about it. [1:09:38] Don't worry about it. [1:09:39] Don't worry about it. [1:09:41] I think you can bring up your question because just having the questions and the ideas brought [1:09:47] up I think we talked about is the beginning of the second. [1:09:51] Thank you. [1:09:52] And we would love to, in the future, have a nice attorney before having part. [1:09:57] Sometimes that's very important. [1:09:58] Do you want to be the town attorney? [1:09:59] No, we'll see. [1:10:00] We'll see. [1:10:01] You don't. [1:10:03] Well, we meet every month and it's public meeting so you don't have to be officially [1:10:08] You know, you can come in and just sit back at this level, you mean it's like four over a year. [1:10:13] No, for this plan, it's only a plan. [1:10:15] If you want, I'm saying it's, you can always come in, chime in. [1:10:19] They're not very exciting right now because we're working on this. [1:10:22] Yeah. [1:10:22] John said that that should have been done. [1:10:24] Are you kidding me? [1:10:25] This thing is ridding. [1:10:28] I don't know. [1:10:28] I'm going down for it. [1:10:29] Go down for it. [1:10:32] Well, we're very glad that you do want to have this open and see how it is and if it worked out sometime. [1:10:40] And we have your face in our memory, just in case we need a plan or a loop, yeah? [1:10:48] Next meeting, April 7th. [1:10:52] That's right, so you're going to eventually, I think that was it. [1:10:57] Next meeting, and now, adjourned. [1:11:01] Just going to put it out there though, and here's 16 years, it's going all-wondering. [1:11:06] I'm just going to go. [1:11:08] No, in the category, 16 years. [1:11:11] I mean, Park is our country. [1:11:12] I'm just going to pick the next one. [1:11:15] We'll keep word check. [1:11:17] I think so. [1:11:17] Oh, yeah. [1:11:18] Does it show? [1:11:19] They know? [1:11:21] Yeah. [1:11:22] I'm just going to pick the next one. [1:11:24] I'm going to pick the next one. [1:11:26] I mean, I can't pick the next one. [1:11:28] I'm going to give you a little bit of water. [1:11:30] Yeah. [1:11:31] Yeah. [1:11:34] Are you there? [1:11:35] Yeah. [1:11:36] Hey. [1:11:37] I'm worried. [1:11:37] My wife. [1:11:38] Any calendar? [1:11:39] Yeah. [1:11:40] No, I wasn't saying all this today. [1:11:41] Check. [1:11:42] Don't forget to greet her on the long run. [1:11:45] Why isn't that vague? [1:11:48] Well, it's basic. [1:11:49] Yeah. [1:11:50] Yeah. [1:11:50] And then on that. [1:11:51] Okay. [1:11:53] We're going to bring this back. [1:11:57] I think we're going to go into endless. [1:12:05] Do we have a motion? [1:12:09] Go ahead. [1:12:13] Second. [1:12:15] Okay, thank you guys.