[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [10:39] Good evening everyone and welcome to the Council meeting on September 28, 2026. Individuals interested in participating in today's meeting were eligible to register online using the delegation registration form at www.kitchener.ca slash delegation or via email at delegation at kitchener.ca. [11:02] Any written comments received prior to the commencement of today's meeting have been [11:07] circulated to members of Council and will form part of the public record. [11:11] The meeting live stream in archived videos are available at www.tichner.ca slash watch now. [11:20] Before we begin this evening's meeting, I'd like to acknowledge as we always do that this [11:25] evening we're gathering on the traditional territory of the neutral, Anishnabi and [11:29] of Nishoni peoples. We recognize a responsibility to serve as stewards for the land and honor [11:35] the original caretakers who came before us. Our communities enriched by the enduring knowledge [11:40] and deep-rooted additions of the diverse First Nations, Matei, and Inuit in Kitchener today. [11:47] And now, if I can invite everyone to stand as they're able for the singing of our national anthem. [13:25] Thank you, everyone. And before we begin this evening's meeting, I'd like to reflect on some [13:31] September and October days of significance. Before I do that, I do want to acknowledge two former [13:37] colleagues who are in the council chamber this evening. Councillor John Guzola and Councillor [13:43] Ivonne Fernandez. Welcome, welcome into the council chamber this evening. Before we begin [13:49] tonight's council meeting, I want to recognize several important days in advance that are meaningful [13:54] to people across our community. This Wednesday's September 30th, we will observe the National [13:59] day for truth and reconciliation and orange shirt day. On this day we remember the children who [14:06] were taken from their families and never returned home and we honor the survivors, their families [14:11] and communities who continue to live with the impacts of the residential school system. [14:19] The orange shirt that many of us will wear on that day comes from the story of Phyllis Webstead. [14:24] She was six years old when the new orange shirt her grandmother brought her was taken away on her [14:28] day at residential school. Her story reminds us of the thousands of children who were taken [14:34] from their families and of those who never came home. This is a day for remembrance but it [14:40] cannot end there. Reconciliation is slow work. It asks us to sit with truths about this country [14:47] that many of us were never taught to challenge what we thought we knew and to keep listening [14:52] even when what we hear is difficult. [14:56] The impact of residential schools and colonialism are not confined. [15:00] Members, families, and Indigenous communities today. That is why truth must remain at the heart of reconciliation, and why our responsibility to listen and learn, continue long after September 30th. [15:14] Here in Kitchener the City has a responsibility to keep learning, to build meaningful relationships with Indigenous communities, and to make space for Indigenous voices to help guide this work. [15:24] That responsibility reaches into the decisions we make about our programs, services, and public spaces, [15:31] and into how we build relationships with First Nations, A.T., Mesa, Inuit, and M.T. Peoples. [15:38] Each of us has a role as well to take time to learn about the history and ongoing impacts of residential schools. [15:44] Listen to the experiences and perspectives of indigenous peoples. [15:47] seek out Indigenous-led opportunities for learning and remembrance and consider what reconciliation asks of you beyond today. [15:56] Reconciliation requires more than a single day of reflection. [16:01] What matters is what we carry forward from it and what we learn in the relationships we build and in the choices we make. [16:08] And so on behalf of Kitchener City Council, I encourage our community to remember the children [16:14] who never came home, honor the survivors, their families and communities, and reflect [16:19] on the responsibility each of us carries on the path toward reconciliation. [16:25] October 4th, we will also recognize the National Day of Action for Missing and Murdered [16:29] Indigenous Women, Girls, and Two Spirited People. [16:32] It's a data honor those who have been lost, those who are still missing, and their families. [16:38] survivors and communities who continue to seek justice and safety. [16:43] As we mark these important days over the next few days, I hope we take time to understand [16:49] why they matter and the experiences behind them. [16:52] There's always more we can learn from one another, and there's always more we can do to [16:56] make sure people feel safe, respected, and at home. [17:02] As mayor and as a council, and as members of our community, I also am deeply troubled and [17:08] And them, the threats directed at Muslim individuals and Islamic schools in Kitchener and across [17:12] Canada late last week. [17:15] Our thoughts are especially with the children who may be feeling frightened, with parents who [17:19] are worried about their children's safety, and with the teachers and staff who care for [17:23] them every day. [17:25] No child should ever feel afraid to go to school, and no family should be made to feel unsafe [17:30] because of their fate. [17:32] To our Muslim neighbors, you are an important and valued part of our Kitchener family. [17:36] You are not alone and we stand with you, we care about you and your safety, and your sense [17:43] of belonging matter deeply to all of us. [17:46] Sadly, this wasn't the only act of hate and violence last week. [17:51] I also want to acknowledge a deeply disturbing act of violence in Belville that occurred not [17:57] that far from the city of Kitchener. [18:00] The shooting that took place upside the sons of Jacob Synagogue on September 20th as members [18:04] of the Jewish community gathered for Yom Kippur. [18:08] A police officer was seriously injured and Belville police [18:11] has since described the shooting as a hate motivated attack [18:14] targeting the Jewish community. [18:17] We must condemn this act of violence and anti-Semitic hate [18:20] in the strongest possible terms. [18:23] People should never have to fear for their safety [18:25] because of their faith or identity, [18:27] especially while gathering in a place of worship. [18:30] As a community, we stand with the Jewish community in Belville [18:33] and here at home and with everyone affected by this terrible act. [18:38] Hate in all its forms, including anti-Semitism and Islamophobia, [18:42] have no place in our city, in our country, or quite frankly, anywhere. [18:47] In moments like this, it's incumbent on us to speak out, to look out for one another, [18:52] to lead with compassion, and as a community, we affirm the kind of community we want [19:03] develop a deep sense of belonging. [19:07] As September comes to a close, I also [19:08] want to recognize a few important occasions in the days [19:11] and weeks ahead. [19:13] October is a slammer heritage month, [19:15] a time to recognize and learn about the history, culture, [19:18] and contributions of Muslim communities. [19:21] Here in Kitchener and across Waterloo region, [19:23] the Muslim communities an important part of who we are. [19:26] Throughout October, I encourage residents to learn [19:28] more about Islamic heritage, connect with their neighbors [19:31] and appreciate the experiences and contributions of Muslim residents in our community and across [19:37] the country. [19:38] October is also Latin American Heritage Month, a time to recognize the culture, traditions, [19:43] and contributions of Latin American communities across Canada. [19:48] Kitcheners home to a growing Latin American community whose members contribute to our neighborhoods, [19:53] businesses, arts, and community life. [19:56] And so we encourage residents to take part in the local events that will be taking place [20:00] month, learn more about the histories and cultures of Latin American countries and celebrate [20:05] with their neighbors. And finally, October 1st is National Senior's Day, an opportunity [20:12] across Canada to recognize older adults and the contributions they continue to make to our [20:17] families and communities. Seniors have helped build the kitchen where we know today. They continue [20:23] to contribute their experience, time, wisdom and perspective to our neighborhoods and community life. [20:29] To all of Kitchener's older adults, thank you for everything you have given and continue to give to make our community the great community that it is. [20:38] Thank you. [20:48] We'll now move to item two. [20:50] Unmotion by Councillor Johnson, the minutes of the regular meeting held August 24th and special meetings held August 24th and September 14th. [20:58] As mailed to the mayor and counsellors be accepted, those in favor, [21:05] any opposed. [21:06] I'm thinking the overview camera isn't quite working. [21:12] Sorry, look, do that again. [21:13] Those in favor? [21:15] Any opposed? [21:16] That is carried. [21:18] Any excuse me? [21:19] Any disclosures of pecuniary interest? [21:23] They're being none? [21:26] I'll note the communication to file, the flag raising, [21:30] that occurred on September 25th. [21:32] For the Association, they flanked the Kitchener Waterloo. [21:36] And at say, we was a great event with a few hundred young people [21:42] of French Canadian background, and it was great to celebrate the day with them. [21:48] We'll now move into our presentations for the 2026 Volunteer Long Service Awards. [21:55] And I think I'm supposed to go up to the other podium, correct? [21:59] Yeah. [22:17] Hey, before we begin tonight's presentations, I want to welcome the volunteers and representatives [22:24] who joined us in Council Chambers for AMA. [22:30] Here we are recognizing four affiliated neighborhood associations and seven affiliated minor sports groups. Together, these organizations represent an extraordinary 435 years of service to our community. [22:46] These numbers represent neighborhood programs that bring people together. They represent opportunities for residents to get active and participate in sport. [22:53] And they represent volunteers who have continued to give their time and knowledge to their community year after year. [23:01] These organizations help create connections that make a growing city feel like a community. [23:06] And tonight, Council has a privilege of recognizing that contribution and celebrating milestones ranging from five years to 65 years of service. [23:15] So on behalf of all of us in Kitchener City Council, thank you to everyone for everyone here for the recognition that these groups are having. [23:26] Your service has made a difference and we're very pleased to celebrate these milestones with you. [23:31] And now we'll begin with our affiliated neighborhood associations. [23:35] Neighborhood associations have a unique role in Kitchener because their work happens close to home. [23:40] There were neighbors meet one another where residents help shape what's happening in their community [23:46] and where local ideas can become programs and opportunities that people enjoy together. [23:52] The city works with 25 affiliated neighborhood associations including three that became affiliated this year [24:00] and I know that all members of council actively engage with their neighborhood associations. [24:05] Tonight, we're recognizing forest associations with milestones ranging from 5 to 45 years. [24:13] And to the volunteers behind these associations, thank you for your dedication and for continuing [24:19] to invest your time in your neighbors and in the places each of you call home. [24:24] So let's begin our presentations now. [24:27] And I'd like to invite Councillor Strachford and our first presentation is going to be to the [24:34] would neighborhood association ward 10, and I'd like to invite Matt Kuchach chair, at least [24:39] a rightful co-chair forward, to accept this certificate of appreciation for five years [24:44] of community programming. [24:56] Do you want us here? [25:01] Oh, we're not doing it anymore. [25:03] Okay. [25:03] We're doing some more. [25:05] Okay. [25:11] Okay. [25:12] Stephanie, if you can come back, because also in ward 10, tonight we recognize the auditorium [25:19] neighborhood association represented by Christine Gunther, and this association is celebrating [25:25] 35 years of neighborhood programming [25:34] next [25:59] I'd been like to invite Councillor Chapman forward [26:03] And I'd like to invite Ron Williams and Jennifer Yurosovich, a co-chairs of the Milwaukee [26:08] Court of Neighborhood Association Award 9, to accept the certificate of appreciation for [26:14] 40 remarkable years of strong community building. [26:32] And now I'd like to invite Councillor Kristy Nishow forward. [26:41] And in honor of the Dune Pioneer Park Community Association Award 4, celebrating a remarkable [26:48] 45 years of service to their community, please welcome Iván Fernandez President and [26:53] Geo Guigat to accept this certificate of appreciation. [27:19] Okay, well now move into our minor sports presentations. [27:22] Sport brings people together in different ways, but the volunteers behind it are just as important. [27:28] Kitchener works with more than 35 affiliated minor sport groups offering recreation and [27:34] sport opportunities for people of different ages, interests, and skill levels. [27:38] Those organizations depend on volunteers to keep those opportunities available in our community. [27:45] Tonight, we're recognizing seven groups whose milestones range from 25 to an incredible 65 years of service. [27:54] Think about how many seasons, practices, competitions and opportunities are represented by that history, [28:00] and how many volunteers have helped make all of that possible. [28:04] To everyone who gives their time, so residents can participate, learn, and stay active, a sincere thank you. [28:11] And so now let's recognize this year's minor sports recipients. [28:15] First, celebrating 30 years of service with the Waterloo Region Minor Football Association, [28:21] please welcome time and hardmen president and Ashley Andres to accept their certificate of appreciation. [28:42] Next, this is pretty remarkable. [28:45] In honor of a milestone of 50 years of commitment to the Kitchener Waterloo Waterpolot Club and to community sports, we welcome Kevin McPresident in Mariah Covatch, [28:59] coaching coordinator and social media person to accept this certificate of appreciation. [29:22] And our last group celebrating a remarkable 60 years of dedicated commitment to community sports. [29:30] I'd like to welcome a Heidi Lyon of the Kitchener Minor Girl Softball Association. [29:49] There are also several group celebrating milestone years of service who are not able to join us [29:54] to join us this evening, but we would also like to recognize. [30:00] Club of Kitchener Waterloo for 25 years of service. [30:05] To roll, to roll, kei, karate do, for 30 years of [30:09] community sports. The region of Waterloo swim club, roll for a milestone 50 years of programming, [30:16] and the Kanastoga sailing club who is celebrating 65 years of service. Please join me in giving [30:24] the volunteers of all these community associations and community sport groups a big round of applause. [30:36] Before I conclude, I want to come back to the number that I mentioned at the beginning of tonight's presentation, [30:43] 435 years. It's a remarkable collective milestone. [30:47] But those years are simply a measure of how long these organizations have existed. [30:52] They represent people, hundreds of people, making a choice to contribute and give back to their community. [30:58] They represent volunteers giving an evening a weekend a season, or for many of the many years [31:04] to something they believe makes our community better. [31:08] That kind of commitment can't be created at City Hall. [31:12] It comes from the hearts and souls of the residents themselves. [31:16] What the City can do is recognize it, support it, and clearly say how much it all matters. [31:23] So to every volunteer represented here tonight and to the many volunteers who have contributed [31:27] to these organizations over the years on behalf of all of us, council and staff at the city, [31:34] and on behalf of the residents of our community, a sincere thank you. Congratulations on [31:39] your milestones, and we hope you leave tonight proud of what you've helped build, and knowing [31:44] that your contributions will continue to be felt by the people and communities that come after you. [31:51] And once again on behalf of all of us, thank you for helping make Kitchener a place where people [31:56] and connect, participate, and belong. [32:00] Thank you for joining us. [32:02] And for those who don't want to spend the whole evening [32:03] in the council chambers, we won't be offended [32:06] if you decide to leave now or at some point during the meeting. [32:10] Thank you very much. [32:28] We'll just pause for a moment now while those who aren't as excited [32:34] about sitting through a council meeting decide [32:36] to go out and celebrate their years of experience. [33:17] Okay, we have two more presentations this evening. [33:21] The first one is from Tova Davidson, the Executive Director of Sustainable Waterloo Region. [33:29] Welcome. [33:29] Welcome Tova as you share with us your annual report. [33:36] On, yeah. [33:36] Good evening, Council. [33:37] So nice to be here. [33:38] I love doing these presentations. [33:39] I like talking to all of you and thank you for the time today. [33:42] I'm going to give you our report of what happened. [33:46] Actually, in 2025, but you know, we're far enough into 26. [33:49] So I'll give you a couple of highlights of what's happened. [33:51] And some of the ways that we work together. [33:54] So in 2025, we realized that the work of SWR [33:57] isn't just to keep going and do the things we've always done, [34:01] but we actually have really been focusing on scaling, [34:04] scaling up, scaling out, and scaling deep. [34:07] So those are going to be the stories I share with you today, [34:10] not sort of the standard numbers. [34:13] But I have to give you the standard numbers. [34:15] So here they are. [34:16] They are at the beginning of the year and report [34:18] that I had distributed to you earlier today. [34:21] If you listen to nothing else and tune me out [34:22] from this point forward, these numbers [34:24] are sort of the impact of the work that we did in that year. [34:28] So please reference those as you would like, [34:30] and they are always so near and dear to me, [34:32] but I think there's some great stories [34:33] I could share with you today. [34:35] So you'll see that we're calling ourselves officially SWR now. [34:39] Over the past six years or so, [34:41] we've had all of the neighboring communities ask us [34:44] if we could help because there isn't an organization [34:47] like ours in Guaugh Wellington, Perth Oxford, Gray, Dufferon. And so we're starting to [34:52] help these other communities. The innovation that started here in Waterloo region has [34:57] been scaled nationally through the Green Economy Canada Organization we created and then we launched [35:02] them but also we are now striving to help other communities. We know that the work of climate and the [35:08] benefit of climate doesn't stop at borders and so we're doing our best to help them as best we can. [35:13] So some of the things that we have going on now is to be our now offers an organic [35:18] diversion program where we do food rescue and we support organizations to rescue [35:23] food and feed people in need. And then to serve those who are not served by [35:28] regional waste management. So things like small businesses, multi-unit residential [35:33] schools, that sort of thing. And we have a program where they get a green bin just [35:37] like people all now have at home. They get picked up. A clean bin is left every time [35:42] everyone loves that part. And we actually take the organic waste to a digester and create clean energy from it. [35:49] This program was started through the circular innovation council and they came to us and asked if we could help them to keep it going. [35:57] And originally it was just in Guelph and Wellington, but we brought it here to Waterloo Region. So we're really happy about that. [36:05] The impact network, of course, is the thing you all know as for in the City of Kitchener is a really important member and partner in this program. [36:11] And the program is intended to give more supports [36:13] and more resources to your staff, [36:15] so that they can do more to enable your staff [36:18] in your own organizational corporate work. [36:21] The thing I wanted to talk about this time [36:23] is we've launched a new platform that every single employee [36:26] of the city of Kitchener is able to log in [36:28] to if they would like, where they can learn more [36:31] about what does climate mean, engage in challenges, [36:34] both within your organization and with other organizations. [36:38] Come to events that are like ask an expert [36:40] and they can learn more about all kinds of interesting things related to climate, and the things [36:44] that are sort of co-related, so it's not always just about climate, but it might be about [36:49] all the ways that things intersect with each other. We called it Engage, because I thought it was [36:53] really clever impact network, I engage. And the Carbon Cleans Program runs through the Engage platform [37:00] now. Carbon Cleans is our Intermember Challenge, and it starts in October, and you can do as much [37:05] with a little as you like. So if you've got a competitive spirit, there's prizes. You should join. [37:11] We also have a partnership with Explore Waterloo Region that you may have heard of, and these [37:15] photos actually are highlighting two events that happened here in Kitchener last year. The CSAE, [37:21] Canadian Society for Association Executives, held their conference here in Kitchener both at the [37:26] regional music. [37:30] The event that was at the odd may look familiar to some of you. Call of duty was hosted there. And through this partnership with the Explorer Waterloo Region, we actually did the work to reduce and measure and then offset the entire carbon footprint of these events, an esport event and a conference. [37:44] And as far as we are aware, it is some of the very first net zero conferences that have happened and they are innovating and happening right here in Kitchener. [37:53] And just as a side note for some of the new stuff is happening, we did the same for the Ontario Summer Games. [37:58] Some members have worked with many of the members of your team on your facilities and in one day alone through the Organics program because everything's connected [38:05] We rescue them more than 550 meals for this community [38:11] Of course you all know what they have all won building and I'm not gonna stay on it for too long because what I want to talk about is the ways that the of all project [38:17] Help with us to scale even more so the building continues to operate and then that positive energy standard [38:22] Meaning that there is all more than the energy we need generated on site and [38:27] those numbers are right there on the right side of that table, going anywhere from 106 [38:32] to 123% of the energy that the building requires and we've had thousands of people [38:38] come through. [38:39] But in the work of this project, the thing that we learned as SWR is that this development sector [38:46] is under incredible pressure to innovate and to change. [38:51] National building code is projected to be net zero by 2030. [38:54] that means changes to how they operate and they need help. [38:58] And we learned that there are building innovation exchanges in Canada. [39:02] There were three. [39:03] There is now four, and we launched frameworks. [39:06] We're the only building innovation exchange in Ontario. [39:10] And as I said, one of three across Canada. [39:12] So the original was in Vancouver. [39:14] We have also got one in Alberta and one in Nova Scotia. [39:17] And the frameworks program, which has been operating for about a year now, runs events, [39:21] best practices, resources, training, et cetera, to help the development sector to adopt [39:27] these new technologies, to find ways to have more efficient buildings to support them. [39:33] And it is driving towards some of those housing goals that we need to do in a way that is actually [39:39] respectful of our energy constraints. So there's a really important multi-solving piece of this work. [39:46] We are doing this project in this program and partnership with members of the sector. [39:50] So it's not SWR saying this is what the building and development sector needs. [39:55] It's the building and development sector saying here are where our challenges are, [39:58] and we find this speakers and the best practices to support them. [40:02] This work is funded by the Government of Canada, [40:03] so we're really proud of that support, [40:06] and we deliver it in partnership with the Grand Valley Construction Association. [40:11] However, we realize that training isn't enough, [40:15] but some practical tools are necessary. [40:17] And so we are now in the testing phase of a tool called Scout. [40:23] Scout is a large language model and machine learning tool [40:27] where developers and building owners can put in existing buildings, [40:32] putting your information on the building, your data on energy, [40:35] your building renewal, so when do you have to replace your furnace [40:38] and all of those kinds of things? [40:39] And it will tell you what your next best project will be, [40:43] what resources and funding opportunities are available, [40:46] what the projected cost and payback and life cycle costing is. [40:51] One of the technical pieces you need and gets you ready to talk to an engineer faster. [40:56] And the whole tool is designed to help us to mitigate some of the issues we have with existing building stock. [41:03] So we're of all of one is what we need to do with a new building. [41:05] This is how do we address what is needed in all of these buildings we already have. [41:10] And actually, we are in the testing phase working with some of the people in your facility's management team [41:15] to be able to test it on your buildings so that you can add some planning in your own [41:21] facilities and then even bigger I dream that it could be something that we could use to [41:26] suggest things for retrofit permits that come in so that we can encourage more and more [41:31] high efficiency buildings in this community. Again we are doing this work in partnership with [41:37] lots and lots and lots of organizations as we do all of our work and we are so happy that [41:41] government of Canada again has supported SWR on this work. [41:46] And we all know well the Micro Force program. [41:48] We launched this in 2021. [41:50] We planted by the end of 2025, more than 55 forests, more than 5,000 trees. [41:56] We've had 13, I think, go in this spring, so we're well over 60. [42:01] And this Saturday, we are planting in partnership with your team at Sunnyside, a community [42:07] planting and so we have trees going in there. [42:09] believe it's our third one that we're planting in partnership. [42:14] And then I will talk about climate action. [42:16] You all know about climate action, but I don't know if you all got there, many of you did, [42:20] to climate fest, which we hosted at Gockel Block on the 13th of September. This year it was our second [42:26] annual climate fest. It expanded. We had a great big concert with Alicia Burilla singing. [42:33] We had some local artists there, researchers, all kinds of activities. And a way for people to [42:38] understand what is available, what is happening in this community, and how they can engage in [42:42] ways that are meaningful to them. We know that the work of any civil society group, any [42:48] social movement, can be a long, hard slog, but sometimes you get together with other people [42:53] doing the work and you're uplifted and you're inspired. And so climate fest was one of the ways [42:58] that we strive to do that. I just want to end on this message that for many people, they see [43:04] the work is climate as being separate from other parts of what we need to do as a community. [43:10] But I want to encourage you to think about climate as the underpinning of almost everything [43:15] that a municipality thinks about. [43:17] It's how we get the people around. [43:19] It's how we make sure we've got good recreation. [43:21] How we encourage good economic development, businesses to come here. [43:25] Our energy systems being resilient, our roads in our infrastructure are being strong and able [43:30] to serve the community and we're so thankful for the partnership with the city and for [43:34] work that we've done together. Thanks. Thank you very much, Tauva, and thank you for all of the [43:42] great work that's a sustainable watered region has been doing. I know you've been working incredibly [43:48] hard over the past year and growing your reach beyond the boundaries of the region and [43:56] sharing some of the great work that we've been able to do here over over a number of years with [44:02] other municipalities and I think in the long run it actually makes all of us stronger in terms [44:09] of advancing this body of work. We do have a number of questions for you and we'll start with [44:15] the councillor Singh. [44:18] Yeah, thank you very much Mr Mayor. Not really questions but it was more [44:22] really complimenting the utilization of AI in the sustainability field. I think that's the greatest [44:31] immediate benefit that we can get from AI AI for good. Again, there's a lot of data [44:36] out there, but for a lot of property owners or even home owners, realizing exactly [44:43] the best way to retrofit their homes that may give them the best bang for the buck that [44:49] can be a very costly endeavor and having a directed tool that gives them because they can enter [44:54] in their data. I think this is the most exciting thing. [45:00] The more data that you guys can utilize, the better it is. And I think it's incumbent on all of us to really spread the word out there in the private sector as well. [45:08] Because again, data is gold and this is the gold that can be of community asset and community benefits. So kudos to you. [45:16] You specify that this is not a standalone, but it will be in conjunction with a lot of partnerships. [45:20] I was hoping a year's partnering up as a rep as well and again there on the early onset of [45:29] the booths on the ground that do the assessments for energy retrofits are they a partner with this tool. [45:36] Thank you for the question and through the mayor. [45:39] We always have partnered with refund almost everything which is amazing including climate action. [45:43] There is some work that they will be looking at the tool and partly the partnership is through the contractors [45:49] that then reap would be sending people out to so enabling that people they are working with [45:55] to be able to do some of the work that needs to be done in those residents. [45:59] I also get a lot of questions in the AI world about how can an environmental group be doing an AI tool [46:04] so we've done it in a very careful and thoughtful way. It uses a large language model [46:08] but only using a tiny AI scheme which means that it only goes to the websites we tell it to [46:16] And so that means it does not do the giant search of the entirety of the internet, which has two benefits. [46:21] One is that it doesn't use as much energy. [46:24] And two, it goes to credible sources, so the results are better, which is one of the things. [46:28] And then we've done machine learning as well. [46:30] So for the data analysis, all of those pieces, it's actually doing machine learning, which is not my strength to explain it to you. [46:38] But a different and not as an energy intensive way of doing some of these kinds of tools. [46:42] That's great. And thank you for specifying the back end. How how the function is going to be as well. So congratulations, you guys. [46:48] Thank you. [46:50] Thank you, Councillor Singh. Next up is Councillor Dino. [46:53] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, Tauva, for coming out. [46:56] I really do look forward to these last four years. [47:00] So thank you for really in-depth information. [47:03] And it's, you know, we've seen what kind of a summer we had. [47:06] We've had and our winters. [47:07] and I think we're at a critical juncture of what we need to do to take away some of that bad stuff that's happening. [47:19] My question is, does your organization go into schools and do classrooms and do presentations such as this or maybe a little modeled smaller model? [47:30] Through the mayor, we do work with schools in a number of ways. First off, both school boards are parts of the impact networks, so we are helping them with their own carbon footprint work. [47:40] We do go into both public schools and post-secondary to do presentations. The Climate Action program has also had school programs where kids are enabled to do some of their ideation and some of that was funded by the City of Kitchener. [47:55] So we can get some school projects and get them to launch that. [47:59] There was some jealousy in other communities that we didn't have it. [48:02] So we got funding from some place else to go to other cities, which is great. [48:05] So yes, certainly we do work with schools. [48:07] Awesome. And just a quick, quick comment. [48:10] We spoke in late last year about coming and helping divert some of our waste. [48:17] So the place I work at, a long-term care facility located in Kitchener, [48:21] We just did a big fundraising for one of these organic food compost, so taking all the leftover food from our residents and putting into compost that we can use in our community gardens, and so when that is up and running, I'll reach out and have you come and take a look at it. [48:38] Amazing. Sounds great. [48:41] Thanks, Councillor Denone. Next up is Councillor Chapman. [48:45] Yeah, thank you. And thank you for this report. [48:47] So, I have a couple questions first of all regarding data centers. [48:51] I mean, we talk about AI, but how do you envision SWR moving forward as, you know, [48:59] the threat of data centers? [49:01] Big, I'm talking about big data centers, increases. [49:05] Great question and through the mayor. [49:07] I don't have enough information. [49:09] I haven't said a full vision of where we go with that. [49:13] I think being mindful of energies and water in a community like this is really important and I can see it being something that SWR probably would like to support in trying to find ways to do a better. [49:25] I have heard about innovations in data centers where they have solar and they generate their own energy and there's water recycling and all of those things. [49:34] I've not looked into any of the technologies, I wouldn't want to say anything saying, [49:38] oh, I know that there's a good solution to this, but I believe that Kitchner is an innovative [49:43] community and if anywhere is willing to think about ways, we can do things well for the future. [49:51] It would be here and I would love to engage in that conversation and do my research before I fully answer that question. [49:57] That's fair. That's fair. I also wanted to ask a question about the frameworks program [50:04] And thinking mostly about high-performance standards, have you, do you have a sense from the development community that there is an interest in buying into this sort of thing? [50:18] There certainly is interest from this sector in so much as we are there to support them. [50:22] So it is not a program that has any particular standard [50:27] we're pushing towards. [50:29] We are more saying, oh, you're seeing that there's demand, [50:32] or even helping to build demand towards higher efficiency buildings. [50:36] So let us help you as a whole sector learn faster, be ready, [50:40] even be able to sell it for better buildings for the future. [50:46] So it's not dependent on any standard. [50:48] we do see of course national code is coming in 2030 and that it is intended to be much more energy [50:55] ambitious. And so we want to make sure that the sector here is well equipped and resilient in that. [51:02] Great. Thank you. And thanks very early. Thanks for the report. [51:05] Thanks, Councillor Chaplin. Councillor Mishol. Thank you. To have I don't have any questions for you. [51:10] I just want to say how remarkable the amount of work that you and your team have done over the years. I [51:15] Remember when you came and just might have been one of your first presentations here, and to [51:20] look at this report and all the community engagement, the support you're getting from the [51:24] community, and I love the fact that you're getting the development community involved in [51:28] this too. [51:28] This is your really, really on the right track and you're doing a remarkable job. [51:32] So congratulations. [51:33] Thank you. [51:36] Those are all the questions we have. [51:38] To over again, thank you so much for all, well, I'm not pretty okay. [51:43] Thank you again so much for all you do. [51:46] And please pass on our thanks to your team. [51:50] It's been quite the shared journey for all of us. [51:53] And it's great to see the progress being made. [51:56] Thanks. [51:58] Councillor Anettis? [52:00] Yeah, Mr. Mayor. [52:03] Being City of Kitchener is the biggest shareholder [52:06] of a Nova Power. [52:09] And the talk with the data centers. [52:12] I just want to make sure that's clarified out there [52:14] But an old power doesn't have the capacity to, to, to, to, to service a big data center is, is that correct? [52:24] Because that's what I recall. [52:26] Yeah, I mean. [52:30] It's a part of a broader conversation that obviously is going on, and I don't know if staff [52:36] want to comment at all and say they're saying no. But I think it's fair to say that it's [52:45] and any work that ends up being done on that will be aligned with both provincial and federal [52:51] priorities go in forward. [52:55] Okay, thank you. [53:00] I don't see, I don't see our next presentation here, [53:08] which was Sarah Shafik, the Director of the Center for Mutual Wellbeing. If she comes later, [53:14] we'll add her into the agenda and if not, we'll get that reschedule. And I'll actually move item 6.1 [53:21] up into presentations because it probably better belongs there than as a delegation since [53:27] it's our internal Compass Kitchener committee. [53:29] So with that, I'll invite up Troy Gloverchier of Compass Kitchener to present the Compass [53:35] Kitchener report card for the last time during this term of council. [53:41] Welcome, sir. [53:42] Thank you. [53:43] I'll start off by saying thank you to you and the entire committee for all the great work [53:48] that you do. [53:48] Over to you, Troy. [53:49] Thank you very much. [53:50] Good evening and thank you for having me today to present our 2026 report card from Compass [53:59] Kitchener. It's a great opportunity to do so and today I'm just going to briefly summarize [54:05] what we are, what we assessed as a committee, what we learned and what we believe Council [54:12] should carry forward into the city's next strategic plan. [54:19] Before I begin I would just like to [54:20] college, the members of Compass Kitchener who contributed their time perspectives and [54:26] careful judgment to this year's evaluation. Our committee brings together Kitchener [54:31] Residents with different experiences, backgrounds, and relationships to the city. [54:37] That diversity is important because Compass Kitchener's role is to offer a council [54:42] and independent, resident informed assessment of how well the city is implementing its [54:49] strategic plan. Our report is not intended to duplicate of the city's internal performance [54:56] reporting. It adds a community perspective. What do the results mean for residents? What [55:03] can the city learn from our work? And where should attention be directed next? [55:12] For this year's [55:13] report card, we evaluated 12 strategic actions completed in 2025 across all five goals of the city's [55:21] strategic plan. Our purpose was threefold, first to assess how responsibly and effectively [55:28] these projects were delivered, second to provide resident informed feedback to Council and [55:35] City staff and third to identify lessons that can inform the development and the implementation [55:42] of the next strategic plan. The report card therefore looks backward and forward. It recognizes [55:49] is what has been accomplished while also asking how the city can build on that work. [55:57] We assessed each project using four criteria. [56:00] We considered responsible project delivery. [56:03] Was the work well managed, evidence informed, and responsive to changing circumstances? [56:09] We considered community engagement. [56:12] We are residents and affected communities meaningfully involved. [56:17] We considered impact and public value. [56:19] Did the project produce or position the city to produce benefits that matter to residents? [56:27] And we considered equity. [56:29] Did the project recognize that different residents experience municipal decisions differently? [56:36] Each project received an overall rating of exceeds expectations, meets expectations, or does not meet expectations. [56:44] Importantly, equity was not treated as a separate [56:48] isolated consideration. [56:51] It underpinned our evaluation of every project. [56:57] The central finding is very encouraging. [56:59] All 12 projects met or exceeded expectations. [57:04] Four projects exceeded expectations in eight projects, [57:08] met expectations. [57:10] None was assessed as not meeting expectations. [57:13] These results reflect strong project management, collaboration across departments, and organizations, and a willingness to adapt when circumstances changed. [57:25] At the same time, a positive rating does not mean there is nothing more to do. [57:31] Several of the projects establish plans, frameworks, or foundations whose ultimate public value will depend on sustained implementation. [57:40] The ratings therefore should be understood as both recognition of good work and [57:47] encouragement to maintain momentum. [57:52] Four projects illustrate some of the [57:54] strongest features we observed. The housing for all initiative demonstrated how [57:59] the city can use the tools within its control while working with community [58:04] partners to address an urgent need. Among it's accomplishments the initiative [58:09] helped facilitate 188 supportive housing units with another 84 underway. [58:17] The localized transportation safety improvement project showed the value of combining [58:22] technical evidence with residents' knowledge of their streets and neighborhoods. [58:27] It demonstrated that relatively focused interventions can make everyday environments feel [58:33] safer and more responsive to local needs. [58:36] The tree canopy target plan established an important evidence-based foundation for protecting [58:44] and expanding Kitchener's urban forest. [58:48] Its long-term value will depend on implementation, monitoring, and sustained attention, particularly [58:55] in neighborhoods that experience greater heat in have less canopy coverage. [59:00] The entertainment venue management project demonstrated effective planning and collaboration around an important civic asset and an increasingly competitive sector. [59:13] Across all of these examples, the strongest results occurred when the city combined the tools within its control with evidence, partnerships and community knowledge. [59:24] That is an important lesson for future strategic initiatives. [59:31] Another recurring strength was the city's willingness to adapt. [59:35] Projects do not unfold in perfectly predictable circumstances, [59:40] timelines change, new evidence emerges, partnerships evolve, [59:45] and external conditions affect what is possible. [59:49] Adaptability should therefore be understood as a strength, [59:52] Not as evidence that a project has failed to follow its original plan. [1:00:00] Second, scope or direction changes, residents should be able to understand what changed, why it changed, and what outcome is now expected. [1:00:10] Adaptability and transparency need to work together. Clear communication helps residents distinguish between a thoughtful response to changing conditions and a project that has simply drifted from its original purpose. [1:00:24] It also strengthens confidence in the city's decision-making. [1:00:32] Several projects also reminded us that municipalities operate within significant external constraints. [1:00:39] Progress on housing, climate action, sustainable development and active transportation, [1:00:45] often depend on provincial legislation, funding decisions and partnerships with other governments and organizations. [1:00:52] For example, provincial changes limited the city's ability to advance some of its intended high [1:00:59] performance development standards. These constraints are real, but they do not eliminate the city's [1:01:06] responsibility or capacity to act. Our message is that the city should act decisively where it has [1:01:13] jurisdiction, collaborate where responsibility is shared, and advocate clearly where provincial policy [1:01:20] limits municipal action. [1:01:23] Residents should also be told what the city is doing, [1:01:27] what lies outside its authority, [1:01:30] and what it is asking other levels of government to do. [1:01:33] That transparency helps council demonstrate leadership [1:01:36] without creating unrealistic expectations [1:01:39] about what a municipality can accomplish alone. [1:01:45] Looking ahead, Compass Kitchener encourages the city [1:01:48] to carry three priorities into the next strategic plan. [1:01:51] First, measure the outcome's residence experience, not only the activities the city completes. [1:01:59] Completing a plan, establishing a framework, or launching a program, does matter. [1:02:05] But residents ultimately want to know what changed. [1:02:08] Is housing becoming more attainable? [1:02:11] Our street safer. [1:02:12] Our neighborhoods more resilient. [1:02:14] Do people feel included and connected. [1:02:17] Second, sustain attention across planning cycles, challenges such as housing affordability, [1:02:25] climate resilience, accessibility, neighborhood vitality, and social connection cannot be resolved [1:02:32] through a single project or within one term of council. They require continuity, long-term [1:02:38] stewardship, and clear measures of progress. Third, connect public reporting more directly to [1:02:45] in its lives, residents should be able to understand not only what the city completed, but [1:02:52] how that work contributes to affordability, safety, sustainability, and belonging. [1:02:59] The results in this report card demonstrate that the city can deliver responsibly. [1:03:04] The next strategic plan should make it equally clear how that work improves life in [1:03:11] over all Compass Kitchener values the city's collaborative approach and its openness to community input. [1:03:19] We're grateful to the staff members who supported this evaluation, who provided information and [1:03:24] responded thoughtfully to our questions, and we look forward to continuing our role as an independent [1:03:31] resident informed voice to work with council and staff toward a more connected [1:03:35] response of an inclusive kitchener. Thank you. I would be pleased to respond to any questions. [1:03:43] Wonderful. Thank you. Thank you very much, Troy, for that thorough presentation. [1:03:49] And I guess a collective thank you on behalf of Council and our staff team for the [1:03:55] assessment that you've shared this evening. No, a lot of work goes in [1:04:01] doing that analysis by the committee and and being as objective as possible as as you can be. [1:04:08] So it's it's always wonderful feedback. I've always deemed feedback as a as a gift and it's an opportunity for us to reflect on the things that they're going well and also the ones that, you know, we need to roll up or sleeves a little more on and maybe approach it a little differently in the future. [1:04:28] there are some questions and we'll begin with Councillor Chappin. [1:04:31] Yeah, thank you, Troy. [1:04:35] Is there a full report that has it been shared with us? [1:04:40] I mean, I don't know. I thought it was some slide deck. [1:04:44] Have we actually received the full report? [1:04:46] I believe so. [1:04:47] Yes. [1:04:47] Did we? [1:04:48] Oh, pardon me. [1:04:51] No, it's not in the agenda. [1:04:55] Okay, [1:05:00] well I'll look for it because okay, so I had my questions because I didn't see the report, I just had this slide deck. [1:05:06] But I was just wondering, I mean I'm really pleased to see that things are being approached without equity lands, [1:05:14] that under with every evaluation that you make, that and I assume that includes things like accessibility and equity of all sorts. [1:05:23] I just wondered if you had any details, [1:05:27] you could share, you talk with a tree canopy target plan. [1:05:32] Did you look at green spaces or park land at all? [1:05:36] Through the mayor, well, our responsibility [1:05:38] through the report card is to evaluate completed projects by the city. [1:05:44] So one of them, as I recall, was the park's plan [1:05:48] and that, you know, received a very positive response from our committee. [1:05:54] Okay. But a lot of these aren't completed. [1:05:58] Like I think of a strategic plan that just sort of goes on and on and on. [1:06:02] So my other question had to do with community and engagement, [1:06:05] because I know maybe not last year, but the year before we scored quite low on that. [1:06:10] And I just wonder what your findings were this time around. [1:06:14] Yeah, I don't know. I think that again through the mayor. [1:06:16] I think that Compass was very impressed with the work that the city staff are doing around [1:06:25] community engagement. It does seem like that more and more of the projects that the city [1:06:33] is undertaking is taking that component seriously and engaging important stakeholder groups. [1:06:40] So I'd say that no project that we evaluated received an individual assessment of does not meet expectations. [1:06:53] Yeah. [1:06:53] One last question, and I'm sorry, this is probably a report. [1:06:58] Did you look at retention of affordable housing? [1:07:01] So not just the building of new affordable housing, because when we talk about affordability, [1:07:06] what's built now a lot of it's 80% of market value. [1:07:09] It's not as affordable as some of the houses we're losing [1:07:14] that people have lived for many years. [1:07:16] So, did you look at retention of affordable housing at all? [1:07:20] Well, through the mayor, again, what our assessment is limited to is the project. [1:07:30] On the information that shared with us from the city, we may have additional questions as a committee and the staff have been very generous in terms of responding to all of our questions. [1:07:41] But ultimately we look at those different criteria that we set aside. [1:07:47] So, to answer, it's difficult for me to answer your questions specifically just because it has been a while since I've been involved in the finalization of this report. [1:07:58] But, you know, again, I would say that in terms of housing for all project, we felt very good about what the city staff has done, what the city has achieved. [1:08:10] Okay, thank you, sorry for that. [1:08:12] Having not read the report, but thank you. [1:08:14] Thank you very much, Councillor Chaplin, Councillor Singh. [1:08:17] Not really a question, but I'd love to be able to make a comment. [1:08:20] Troy, the fact that you specified the report addressing that, you know, within the completed projects [1:08:27] that we fared well as to the city of Kitchener and staff, as well as obviously it's [1:08:34] uncommon on city council as a part of a group of individuals that sets the priority for [1:08:40] the community and the things that need that to be addressed or which investments go further [1:08:49] to improve the lives of our citizens. [1:08:52] So I think it's a, it's a good news story for this council, as well as of course staff who [1:08:58] diligently follow that direction that's set out by council and make up she things happen. [1:09:03] So it's from an outside body that's unbiased and really looks at it and holds us accountable [1:09:08] at the end of the day to have that assurance that we have been meeting that metrics that in [1:09:13] this last term that this council and our staff supporting us have done well so that's a, [1:09:19] that's a good assurance. [1:09:19] So thank you for stating that. [1:09:22] Thank you. [1:09:23] Thanks, Councillor Stink, Councillor Davis. [1:09:27] Yes, I actually just want to echo that as well. [1:09:28] I did really appreciate this slide detailing the constraints that Council has and that's [1:09:33] put upon us that a lot of residents don't understand those constraints even though we [1:09:36] may want to see action in a lot of these areas where we just want to have the ability to do so. [1:09:41] So having said that though, I do really appreciate the feedback and the clear indication [1:09:45] that this Council is going in the right direction. [1:09:47] Thank you. [1:09:49] Thank you. [1:09:49] David and that looks like it's everyone. So just once again, Troy, thank you to you in the [1:09:56] entire committee. I just had the opportunity again last week to talk about the existence [1:10:02] of Compass Kitchener. It's something I like talking about when speaking with folks [1:10:08] from other communities as I think you're aware and again people are like, you've got what kind [1:10:14] committee? What do they do? And Councils okay with this? And it's like, yes, yes, yes, [1:10:20] and it's been tremendous to see. And I can honestly say in my years on Council, [1:10:26] I've, and I can't take everybody around this portion would say, nobody's ever regret it [1:10:30] having this committee. And the, the, the opening and honest feedback and advice that, [1:10:36] that it gives Councils. So thank you. Yeah, and thank you to this Council. [1:10:40] It's a credit to this city that it has a committee like this as you mentioned very few [1:10:46] if any other municipalities have a similar committee. [1:10:49] So we're very honored to be representing our fellow residents on it. [1:10:54] Thank you. [1:10:54] Thanks so much. [1:10:57] Okay. [1:10:58] We'll now move on then to our delegations. [1:11:04] And before we begin with delegations, I'd just like to remind all [1:11:06] that the city values and encourages participation in dialogue in a democratic process that occurs in council and committee meetings and through written submissions and correspondence. [1:11:18] It is important that these interactions remain respectful towards other members of the public, staff and council. [1:11:24] In cases where dialogue is not respectful or a delegate interrupts the mayor, counselors, staff or other delegations. [1:11:29] make serogatory statements about the mayor, [1:11:33] counselors, staff, or others that is disrespectful [1:11:35] or uses language that is considered harmful [1:11:38] or defamatory. [1:11:41] The chair may interject and take necessary actions to maintain [1:11:43] a respectful and inclusive environment for everyone, [1:11:47] which could involve removal from a meeting. [1:11:49] One last reminder, [1:11:50] delegations are permitted to address [1:11:51] accounts of her maximum five minutes, [1:11:54] which will be displayed on the screens in front of you. [1:11:56] When there's 30 seconds remaining in your time, you'll hear a small audio tone that will signal 30 seconds remaining. [1:12:03] Please take the time to conclude your presentation as there will be a second tone at the completion of your time, [1:12:09] and the microphones will turn off shortly after the exceeded five minute mark automatically. [1:12:14] Lastly, please do not take a fancy following your presentation. There's no questions from Council. [1:12:18] This is Council's time to really listen and reflect upon the opinions and ideas shared with us from our community members. [1:12:27] And so with that I'd now like to move on to item 6.2, which is consideration of the notice of intention to designate 265 Weber Street East. [1:12:40] And we have a dual delegation, Shell Secret, who's here, and John Alensky, who is a virtual representing east to cooperative ink, and I guess I'll let you figure out how you're going to split it up. [1:12:57] Excellent. [1:12:58] I will actually be doing the speaking here, and then I don't know if there's questions afterwards. [1:13:03] If that happens, John will be a virtual to be able to handle any questions. [1:13:08] Thank you. [1:13:10] Anything I can't handle? [1:13:11] Let's go. [1:13:12] Thank you. [1:13:13] So, Mayor Verbanovic and members of Council. [1:13:17] Thank you for hearing us tonight. [1:13:19] My name is Michelle Secret and I am Eastview Cooperative Apartments Volunteer President. [1:13:27] And I'm speaking on behalf of the people who call 265 Weaver Street East their home. [1:13:34] With me is her play behind me who has served as our volunteer president for more than a decade. [1:13:45] And so we really asked tonight that you vote against designating our building. [1:13:51] We hope that all council members have had the opportunity to read our very full objection letter that we passionately submitted back in July. [1:14:02] Our building has a history worth telling. [1:14:06] Built in 1948, it has been cared for by a cooperative community for nearly eight decades. [1:14:14] We are really proud of that history. [1:14:17] But the question before the council is more precise. [1:14:20] Does the evidence support individual designation under section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act? [1:14:27] Ontario Regulation, 9-06, sets out 9 criteria for cultural heritage, value, or interest. [1:14:39] At least two criteria must be met to designate, this property. Staffs say, East View meets five. [1:14:46] But when we examine the evidence for each acclaimed criterion, we question whether even two have actually been established. [1:14:55] That is the decision. [1:15:00] The first claim is design value. We agree that Eastview reflects post-war apartment design. It's brick, [1:15:08] exterior, flat roof, h-shaped plan, and symmetrical facade are very plain to see. But the city's [1:15:16] own account says several apartments were built around the same time by different owners using [1:15:23] in the same plan. [1:15:25] There are other examples of this style within 500 meters of east view. [1:15:30] So what establishes the design value of this specific example? [1:15:35] It also needs to account for changes to the property over time. [1:15:40] All the windows have been replaced at different times and with differing styles and materials. [1:15:45] Honings have been added at the rear. [1:15:48] The garage doors no longer present a consistent appearance. [1:15:52] When the region reconstructed Weber Street in 2019, the front railing was replaced without matching the building's existing railings. [1:16:03] We are asking Council to consider how much of the design being described remains intact and why the proposed attributes have been selected in light of those changes. [1:16:15] In terms of historical value, staff point to post-war demand cooperative ownership and reverend [1:16:23] Michael Cross. [1:16:25] Each view helped house people during the post-war period, as many other buildings did, [1:16:32] our cooperative has brought people together to provide stable housing for decades. [1:16:39] Yet the evaluation does not show that this property became a center or model for a wider [1:16:45] cooperative housing movement, and while Reverend Krauss's accomplishments deserve recognition, [1:16:52] Council should ask how those accomplishments relate directly to his involvement with this [1:16:58] building given his limited role. [1:17:04] He's few is self-managed. [1:17:07] Our members make the decisions, contribute their time, and pay the bills, many are retired, [1:17:13] or live with limited incomes, every added cost ultimately comes back to the people who live [1:17:19] in the building. We understand that affordability does not determine whether a property has [1:17:25] heritage value. It does make it especially important that council be confident in the evidence [1:17:30] before imposing those obligations. Please do not mistake our objection for a lack of care [1:17:38] for the building. The building's condition today is the direct result of the member's care [1:17:44] and we want to keep maintaining it and keep people housed in it. So please support us by upholding [1:17:51] our objection with drawing the notice and voting against the designation by law. Thank you [1:17:58] to all. Okay, thank you very much for that presentation. We do have some questions for you. [1:18:06] Council. [1:18:09] Yeah, thank you for coming in today. [1:18:11] I guess my question is, since you are a co-op, [1:18:16] how many of the members are an agreement with you? [1:18:19] Is it like you, an animus or? [1:18:22] Um, so this things came about pretty quickly. [1:18:26] Um, we received the, um, [1:18:29] sorry, the document from the city, [1:18:31] and then needed to work through a very robust response [1:18:35] in this objection letter. [1:18:36] So all the members are aware, but we have not held a separate meeting to discuss it directly, [1:18:44] but just we're a very small building. There's only 15 members, 15 units, and so just talking [1:18:52] in the halls most are in agreement, which is why they've sent me here tonight. [1:18:56] Okay, that's great. Thank you. Thanks, Councillor Annette. It's Councillor Sing. [1:19:01] Yeah, she'll thank you for presenting. There aren't many cooperatives that are small like this, [1:19:06] are a very close-knit community, as you said, there's only 15 members, and just looking [1:19:12] at even Google Street View, the properties kept in a very, very well state. It's a well-loved [1:19:19] property by its residents, and it's easily shown. So I don't really have the objection necessarily [1:19:25] to what you're outlining. You're request to not to designate. Do you want to pinpoint where [1:19:31] your concern would be that what impact to the cooperative would be if it were to be designated. [1:19:38] Yeah, I think. [1:19:39] Thank you. [1:19:39] We are, you know, I'll all jump in and then see if John has something to add to it, but [1:19:44] we are all volunteers on the board. [1:19:47] You know, some of us, some of them retired on me working full time. [1:19:53] And we're just doing all this work on our own free time. [1:19:57] or like I said, a volunteer board. [1:20:00] And so we are concerned too, especially [1:20:03] with a lot of retired folks. [1:20:05] I know I'm on my own in that building, [1:20:07] paying all my bills. [1:20:09] We really don't want restrictions of having additional costs [1:20:15] involved with what heritage designation would bring. [1:20:19] So that is one of the main things. [1:20:23] We've been, we do very well at keeping our cost low. [1:20:27] When ever something comes our way and we work as a membership to [1:20:34] To handle things really well John. Do you have anything to add to that? [1:20:38] Go ahead John. Oh, thank you. Thank you for adding me [1:20:43] I mean, it's it's quite the operation that's been powered exclusively by essentially volunteers and in a pool of 15 [1:20:50] That is a very limited pool. So even something like preparing for the delegation [1:20:57] tonight, took a very strong amount of time that takes away from other things, like, and I think [1:21:02] this council's really taking out the garbage, keeping the hallways clean, making sure issues [1:21:08] are dealt with daily. So, while we certainly, in Shell's said, don't deputation and appreciate [1:21:15] the recognition, really, we really believe that what it's doing is it's achieving that purpose [1:21:21] and it would be an extraordinary burden on a very small group of people with very limited [1:21:27] capacity from a very limited pool of people. And so I was trying to raise my hand for the last one. [1:21:32] Easy unanimous. I can't say that for sure, but amongst their board, which is approximately half of [1:21:37] the group, it was a unanimous and strong, and that's why we came so strongly with our position. So thank you. [1:21:45] Okay, thank you to both of you, Councillor Strach. [1:21:51] Yes, thank you, Shell. I just wanted to make sure [1:21:54] you're aware of any potential benefit that being designated heritage could bring. Tax relief or [1:22:01] granting opportunities and you've discussed that with your with your board and are aware and this is [1:22:07] still your your position. Yes we are aware we have been made aware of that but we really do [1:22:16] believe that any benefit would, you know, really just the work involved would actually [1:22:23] be too much to even think of that as a benefit. [1:22:33] Thank you. Dr. Linsky, do you want to add something to that? [1:22:36] Yeah, thank you. I think we've just, we took a look at other examples and I think it was you council who referenced 30 [1:22:42] shirt place and just going through the window evaluation. I know that property and [1:22:47] grew up in Kitschering over the neighborhood well. And even that to look at the windows, [1:22:52] I know there's a modification. But the time and the cost of getting it to the heritage level, [1:22:58] which frankly, I don't even know if we could something that was mentioned in the show's opening [1:23:02] statement was they're all different right now. So even getting a standardization from [1:23:08] but also from getting our members to a degree is quite the challenge for a group of 15 units. [1:23:15] I'll say democracy is alive and well and very robust. [1:23:20] And I'm not sure the things that we're able to do through having our co-op structure, [1:23:25] which is very strong for the group, would actually get done. [1:23:27] I think it would cause a burden that goes well beyond any benefits. [1:23:31] And we did take the time to evaluate this. [1:23:33] So thank you for the question. [1:23:36] Thank you. [1:23:38] Councillor Schneider. [1:23:39] Thank you, Mayor, and John, you kind of touched on where I wanted to go about the cost of replacing things to heritage standards. [1:23:51] Again, how many people are living? How many units? 15 units? 15 units, okay. [1:23:59] So, when you have to do maintenance to the building, is that split evenly among the residents? [1:24:07] Yes, we actually all pay condo fees and monthly and so it comes out of a reserve fund. [1:24:17] Okay, but but something like if you had to replace all the windows to heritage standards, [1:24:24] would that be covered by what's in your reserve fund right now? [1:24:29] John, you want to speak to that one? [1:24:31] Yeah, you go ahead, John. [1:24:34] The short answer is no being a cooperative [1:24:36] versus the condos we are not held [1:24:38] on the same standards on reserves. [1:24:41] So I personally believe there's enough [1:24:42] to sustain our level of living, [1:24:47] but something extraordinary would probably wipe it out. [1:24:50] It's under $100,000. [1:24:51] I'll share that with you. [1:24:53] And that's to pave the lot to do the roof [1:24:55] and to just fix things that are broken. [1:24:58] To answer your question, it's not 15 units. [1:25:01] There's a few people in the building who are, say, [1:25:03] at the stage of life where we're thankful they've been [1:25:07] long to remember, but aren't able to contribute physically [1:25:10] or in the same way as a smaller group. [1:25:13] So it's not even the whole group who's able to, [1:25:15] I don't want to single it her. [1:25:17] But her was our president for many years. [1:25:19] And basically said, can someone please take over? [1:25:22] I'm ready to step away. [1:25:24] I'm not, and herbs an amazing volunteer. [1:25:27] But we're very thankful she'll be able to do that. [1:25:29] So I think it's a good example of, you know, it's a great question because even a little [1:25:35] thing like this can cause it. [1:25:37] So I think that's really what's driving this is, we do value this and if you ask him [1:25:42] but they're incredibly proud to live in this and incredibly proud that's a state itself [1:25:46] as a co-op. [1:25:48] But seeing yourself as a co-op isn't part of this and we are deeply concerned with that. [1:25:53] So they thank you for the question, really appreciate it. [1:25:55] Okay, and just it's probably obvious answer to this, but having the co-op does that keep living in this building affordable for the residents? [1:26:06] 100%. [1:26:07] Absolutely. [1:26:08] It's why I was one of the newest folks to purchase there. [1:26:14] And it's one of the reasons why I did purchase at Eastview. [1:26:18] I don't know what I would do if costs were a lot more. [1:26:22] So, yeah, and I think just for anyone who has purchased that East View, we have to be thinking about the future. [1:26:34] And we've all come into this knowing what East View has stood for for almost 80 years, [1:26:41] and we don't want that to change. [1:26:43] And we have shown that folks like her have shown for so long that we can maintain this building [1:26:50] in a very respectful way, you know, we have done that. [1:26:55] I agree, I'll have some comments later, but thank you for those answers. [1:27:01] Thank you, Councillor Schneider, Councillor Wooddoni. [1:27:05] Thank you, Chair. I was just wondering if there's a chance to ask staff questions. [1:27:09] I'll do that after the delegation. Okay, thank you. Thanks. [1:27:15] Okay, I don't see any of their hands up, so she'll just, and John, you know, I look at other examples, quite frankly, where the city hasn't designated and I'll use the club boss as an example and I recognize that that, you know, is a corporate entity that owns it and not a, not a co-op, but they didn't designate and, and sorry, Council didn't designate, [1:27:43] And yet, we've seen that the outcome has been very successful. [1:27:47] I drive by your building twice every day, [1:27:51] on my way to and from work. [1:27:53] And so I had lots of opportunities to take a good look at it. [1:27:57] And it's clearly very well taken care of. [1:28:01] And so I think one of the things that would be important to us is, [1:28:06] I mean, is there an ongoing commitment from the board to [1:28:11] is reasonably possible and keep while keeping affordability top of mind at a time when that's [1:28:17] a big challenge to continue to try to look after the building and its historical representation [1:28:25] as best as possible. Absolutely and one thing that I can say I came was elected into the role [1:28:32] of President just in April of this year and one thing that I care deeply about is when we have [1:28:41] turn over in East View, I want to make sure that when we are all sitting around and having [1:28:47] a meeting, meeting somebody new, that we ask some questions about what you have to offer [1:28:53] because we need people going forward who have things to offer, whether it's their brains [1:28:58] or their able-bodiedness because we do want to keep maintaining the physical attributes outside [1:29:07] people like me who can manage to do something like this. Okay, if we didn't have those [1:29:13] capabilities, I don't know what you would turn into. So we are very passionate, which is why [1:29:19] we're here on a Monday night. You know, why John was up very late last night? Why I've been [1:29:25] working hard months ago in the middle of summer to make sure that we could get this very [1:29:33] robust report into you folks by the deadline. Okay, that's how we spent our July, John and I. [1:29:41] So we're here tonight. Matt was city staff. Okay. That was a little while ago, a couple of weeks ago. [1:29:50] We met with the Heritage Department. We care very much about our stance on this. [1:30:00] You know, see yourself there. There's incredible pride of ownership from the outside, but on the inside, there's an even harder focus on cost containment. And I will say that to some of this, as other, has led to other places. No one works harder to save pennies on the dollar and trying to maintain that. And it's an incredible thing. And certainly can be sometimes time consuming in our debates, but it's a great thing. And it would be ashamed to lose that. [1:30:28] because it's a shell set, it's an important piece for this group. [1:30:33] Wonderful, thank you to both of you for coming in and delegating. [1:30:37] And I'll now take questions of staff. [1:30:41] I can't so do any, you indicated you had a question. [1:30:45] Yeah, thank you. Thank you, Chair. [1:30:47] So I just wanted, in terms of, sorry if I missed this, [1:30:51] quantification, how to bring it up to heritage standard, [1:30:57] What would that cost to look like for the average resident there? [1:31:03] I think from my understanding, it might be put from their condo reserve fund, [1:31:08] but it would just be good to have an understanding of what that looks like. [1:31:12] That's just Stevenson. [1:31:14] Through you, Mr. Mayor. [1:31:15] So in terms of the Heritage designation does not require any physical changes to the building, [1:31:21] What it does is recognizes through a designating by law, the unique features that are in [1:31:28] staffs opinion are contextual heritage value. [1:31:32] The example of the windows, and we've had debates about windows before in replacements, [1:31:37] the windows are not original and they're not identified as a specific heritage element [1:31:42] that's part of this building in the designating by law. [1:31:45] So window replacements, we certainly would have an opinion in some advice on what that style [1:31:51] could be but there would not be a material or a certain type of window that had to be replaced [1:31:57] because they are not original to the building. So it would be that the Heritage designation [1:32:04] has specific elements, so talking about the mass in the flat roof, the fact that it's an H plan, [1:32:10] the red rub brick, brick banding, symmetrical facade, castones around the entry and the windows, [1:32:17] as well as a concrete foundation. [1:32:20] If there were changes to any of those parts of the building, [1:32:24] if it was designated, we would want to review that. [1:32:28] And those elements would be so substantial [1:32:32] that in a heritage evaluation would be a very small part [1:32:34] of any of those undertakings. [1:32:36] So we did not, it's not that a building has to be changed, [1:32:39] or that any physical changes would happen. [1:32:42] As parts of the building go through a natural life cycle, [1:32:44] we would require a heritage permit to take an additional review. [1:32:48] So, sorry, I'm just, so what I'm hearing is we're not asking the change but don't drop [1:32:56] in those certain standard. [1:32:58] No? [1:32:59] Still no? [1:33:00] Through you Mr. Mayor. [1:33:01] So, the Heritage Designation identifies the key features as part of the [1:33:05] designating bylaw and if there were changes, the Heritage Designation is an additional [1:33:11] lens or review. We're not, they would not be required to make any physical changes as a result [1:33:18] of a decimating by law. [1:33:20] Okay, thank you. Councillor Chaffin. [1:33:24] Thank you. So can you just speak a bit to if, so I understand the window part. But if they [1:33:35] wanted to put a new roof on, I mean they'd have to maintain the flat roof, but it's not [1:33:40] get cedar shingles or something special that would have to be placed the current roof as [1:33:46] need comes to be right. [1:33:49] Through Mr. Mayor, so specifically the attribute that's identified is the fact that it [1:33:54] is a flat roof. [1:33:56] We have an example of a property in Kitchener where the original roof is cedar. [1:34:03] The cedar shingles are identified as a heritage resource and we are working with them to find [1:34:08] an alternative material that would have a longer lifespan [1:34:11] recognizing the cost. [1:34:13] So even if a heritage attribute is identified, [1:34:16] it doesn't necessarily mean like for like replacement. [1:34:19] I'd say that Kicester has evolved our heritage conservation [1:34:23] practices to ensure that the overall character and intent [1:34:27] is maintained, but we also recognize building code changes [1:34:31] and requirements have also happened. [1:34:33] And we are flexible to alternative materials [1:34:35] where it's either cost prohibited [1:34:37] did or would be more appropriate? [1:34:40] And do you have any concerns with, I mean, we had, what's the name of it? [1:34:48] Bed and Rose, as we had, they came to us with some changes they wanted to make, and I think [1:34:53] staff worked very well with them, and that's also a housing co-op, right? [1:34:56] Do you have any concerns that if we do not accept moving forward with the designation process, [1:35:03] which were at the very beginning stages of it, I think, are we not? [1:35:09] Through Mr. Mayer, this would be the final step for this particular notice of intention to [1:35:13] designate. [1:35:14] But its intention to designate, it doesn't mean it would be designated as a tonight or [1:35:18] it would. [1:35:19] Correct, it would be yes. [1:35:20] This is the final step. [1:35:22] Okay, do you have any concerns that if we don't proceed with the designation that [1:35:28] this sets a precedent for other, I'll say co-ops, not just houses in general, that we're willing [1:35:36] to wave designation simply because they are co-op. [1:35:42] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I think Council has various considerations to weigh in the decision [1:35:48] of whether or not to designate this evening, and I think any designation is specific to a property, [1:35:54] And I know that you would weigh all of the options for every single application as they move forward. [1:36:02] This is a challenging one because I think, and I heard the discussion around the horseshoe, [1:36:06] they have done an incredible job of maintaining their building. [1:36:09] There are a lot of original elements that are worthy of designation in our opinion. [1:36:14] And this property has been on our heritage inventory for quite some time. [1:36:19] Do some legislative changes. We have to make the decision this year if we proceed with designation of many of these properties or if they come off the heritage inventory. [1:36:29] So the reason this is before you tonight is part of that built 23 work program. It's not in response to anything that [1:36:36] Eastview co-op has done to their building or anything like that. It's just that we are evaluating everything on a register by the end of this year. [1:36:44] Okay. Thank you. [1:36:46] Thank you, Councillor Sting. [1:36:56] Yeah, thank you. [1:36:56] Yeah, thank you. [1:36:57] Councilor Duny had asked clear of fine questions about the overall impact of a heritage assessment. [1:37:03] None of us here are heritage planners. [1:37:06] So having that brought a more detailed understanding, [1:37:10] helps us to understand the general impact as the delegation has specified the [1:37:16] concern with the staff recommendation. [1:37:19] the recommendation from the Heritage Committee. So, understandably, nothing is going to be required of them, just because they are dead. [1:37:30] A place additional parameters on any changes to the heritage specified attributes of the building. [1:37:37] So you said that a heritage application would have to be made if they want to make any renovations. [1:37:45] And any building over time deteriorates and renovations are required. Nothing stands alone the way in the test of time. [1:37:51] All construction needs upgrades. Beyond the application itself would a heritage impact assessment be required as well. [1:38:00] Through Mr. Mayor, so we would require heritage and pack assessment based on the scale of what a proposal is. [1:38:08] So if it was simply a window change, I don't know that we would require a full heritage and pack assessment. [1:38:15] And we've had some changes to the delegated by law for processing heritage permit applications with a routine matters are delegated to staff and there's no fee for heritage permit application. [1:38:26] What is true is that there's an additional review and a heritage lens applied to change [1:38:32] just to a building, which is the point of the Heritage Permanent Application. [1:38:36] So there is an additional oversight for a designated heritage building, but any additional [1:38:42] costs would vary based on the scale and the magnitude of what's being proposed. [1:38:48] And in fairness, the windows are already vinyl. [1:38:51] So I don't think that they themselves should or would be in the designation controlled but beyond that the building is brick. [1:39:01] So if there's factors, deterioration or changes to the brick facade, would something like that require a heritage impact assessment as part of the application. [1:39:11] Through Mr. Mayor, if it was a like for like replacement unlikely. [1:39:15] you know, we would maybe provide some advice about a motor that would be appropriate and maybe [1:39:21] want to see a brick sample, but we would scale our review to the extent of the change. So if it's [1:39:29] a like for like replacement, if the entire facade was being removed and they were proposing a totally [1:39:34] different material and the brick and the limestone are identified as as features, then yes, [1:39:42] would require an assessment of what that change would be. [1:39:46] All right. [1:39:46] Thank you. [1:39:47] And painting, if they wanted to change any colors, schemes, that's exterior. [1:39:54] Three of them is so paint is largely considered an easily reversible change. [1:39:59] So again, it would depend on what was being painted. [1:40:03] There's not a lot of painted elements on this building, the windows, but if they're [1:40:07] violently, they're white vinyl windows, there wouldn't be a lot of paint change. [1:40:11] Okay. [1:40:12] Thank you. [1:40:12] Thank you, Councillor St. Councillor Dunno. [1:40:16] Thanks, Mr. Mayor. Thanks, Garrett. [1:40:19] Can you, I know Councillor Stratch referred to some benefits. [1:40:23] Can you explain what are the benefits if this building does become designated as heritage? [1:40:30] A few Mr. Mayor, so the mean reason that we do designate buildings is to preserve part of our cultural history [1:40:38] and to ensure that elements that have a story to tell about the evolution of our community [1:40:43] over time are preserved. There are, you know, maintaining cultural heritage assets and [1:40:50] communities important for storytelling. We have seen an increase in interest for heritage [1:40:56] designation and describing some tourism. I wouldn't say it's not more than October fast, [1:41:03] but you know, we are hosting the National Heritage Trust Conference at the end of next month. [1:41:08] So there's a renewed interest in in what's happening in terms of cultural heritage in one of the region. [1:41:13] But in a financial incentive program, this council may recall that we revised that program to increase our grant program to $5,000, which is a matching grant. [1:41:25] So if there is contributions, we would match that as part of that program. [1:41:29] That program is only available and that financial assistance is only available to properties which have a heritage designation. [1:41:35] So that's the only benefit that the homeowners would receive. [1:41:43] It's just a matching grant that the only benefit that they get by being designated. [1:41:49] So that would be the financial benefit and then there would be a cultural heritage benefit overall of preserving important parts of our history. [1:41:57] Okay. Thank you. [1:41:59] Thank you, Councillor No. Councillor Misho. [1:42:01] Thank you. [1:42:03] In the Heritage Report, was it included that this was a co-op housing project building? [1:42:11] Through you, Mr. Mayor, yes, it was a purpose built and it was the first cooperative [1:42:16] housing in the kitchen. [1:42:18] But it was currently a co-op. [1:42:20] I'm on the Heritage Committee and I did not get that it was currently co-op housing. [1:42:25] I thought it was part of the history of it, not that it was currently a co-op housing. [1:42:29] So, I think that was a little not misleading on your part, just not clear enough to quite [1:42:35] understand it. [1:42:37] I've been on the heritage for 8 years, and I don't recall ever having a situation like [1:42:44] this where we've got a co-op housing building where people are living in a good community [1:42:49] to take care of it, and we're instilling a heritage designation on, how many of these [1:42:56] that we had or have that in your experience. [1:42:59] I don't recall any. [1:43:00] Through Mr. Mayor, so the other example [1:43:03] that we're aware of is the Bradden Rose's [1:43:04] cooperative housing in Kitchener. [1:43:07] That's one other one. [1:43:08] OK, yeah. [1:43:08] Thank you. [1:43:12] OK, thank you. [1:43:14] Councillor O'Concern, I noticed you had a follow-up. [1:43:16] Yes, thank you. [1:43:18] Karen, this design that I've seen for this particular property, [1:43:26] I've seen it probably throughout the city in several spots, have we designated all those? [1:43:33] Through Mr. Mayor, no we have not, so heritage designation, this one means, in our opinion, [1:43:40] additional criteria of the nine, so this would be an opportunity to designate both by a social [1:43:47] value and by design. Okay, thank you. Okay, Councilor Chaplin. Yeah, can I just ask [1:43:56] what I'm asking about? Yes, go ahead. Yeah, so have you spoken to the residents of the [1:44:02] co-op about their concerns and is there any road to come to some agreement? Mr. Stevenson? [1:44:09] A few Mr. Mayor, I haven't spoken directly with the residents, but our heritage planner [1:44:17] has met with them. [1:44:19] I think that we're, if you saw their submission, it's a respectful submission based [1:44:25] on their opinion on the contextual value. [1:44:28] I think on those aspects, we just, we just simply disagree, and so if you were a decision [1:44:37] It would have to be made, Council has two options, but it would, a decision would have to be made prior to October 31st on this particular designation, or it would not be able to proceed. [1:44:48] So we could have a deferral and further negotiations could go on with our discussions, I guess, with staff and the residents with that. [1:45:00] All the residents in the building with that, is that something you'd be willing to work with? [1:45:06] Through the mayor, we're in council's hands if a deferral would be helpful, and we could definitely arrange to find a way to bring it back before the next meeting. [1:45:18] I do think that staff's position is that six of the nine criteria are met. [1:45:23] and according to the Ontario Heritage Act, it would be worthy of designation, they're of the opinion that too, but maybe last I heard in the delegation this evening, I don't know that we, that a deferral would result in a different outcome, I think we've respectfully disagree on how to move forward. [1:45:43] Okay, thank you. [1:45:46] Councillor Strattree, how do you follow up? [1:45:48] Yes, I'm curious about if no action is taken. [1:45:54] So, the 120-day statutory period expires and what does that leave 265 weaver with? [1:46:07] What is? [1:46:10] Mr. Stevenson. [1:46:11] Mr. Mayor. [1:46:12] So, there's a couple of considerations and options that Council does have. [1:46:18] So, declining the objection would mean that we would follow, we would follow, we would [1:46:27] the designating by law. If you accept the objection and withdraw the notice of intention to [1:46:33] designate, you can do that. And if you don't proceed with designation before October 31st, [1:46:43] then it would not proceed to designation and at the end of this year, it would be removed from [1:46:48] the Heritage Register in accordance with applicable legislation for five years. [1:46:56] Okay, so, [1:47:02] well, we're going to take a motion first, Councillor Stratcha, are you moving [1:47:08] on? [1:47:11] Has the copy. [1:47:11] Okay, thank you. [1:47:14] So the motion that's before us, I'll read it out, is that with respect to the notice of [1:47:18] objection dated July 30th, 2026, concerning the notice of intention to designate, that [1:47:23] was approved at the June 29th, 2026 Council meeting for the property, municipally address [1:47:29] at 265, we were street east that staff be directed to take no further action on the proposed [1:47:35] designation and to allow the applicable 120 day statutory period to expire and further [1:47:41] that pursuant to the act that clerk be directed to publish a notice of withdrawal of [1:47:46] intention to designate the property municipally addressed as 265, we were street east. [1:47:52] Yes, my only question on that, and I will take that as your motion, is perhaps ask, I don't think, if we take no further action on the designation, do we need to go through the expense of a notice of withdrawal? Mr. Stevenson? [1:48:14] If Council wishes to not proceed with the designation, I would suggest following option 2 on page 8 of the staff report, which is that [1:48:32] we accept the notice and we withdraw the notice of intention to designate. [1:48:36] So we simply staff would not proceed any further with this designation. [1:48:41] But we don't need to like put a new ad in the paper or anything like that through to you. [1:48:50] I don't believe so if we did, it would be a cost to the city that's part of the heritage budget. [1:48:58] That's already been determined for the bill 23 work. [1:49:01] So it wouldn't be a huge financial burden if we did. [1:49:05] Okay. Thank you. [1:49:07] So, Councilor Stretch, you've moved it. [1:49:09] Do we have a seconder for the motion? [1:49:11] Move by seconder by Councilor Dino, thank you. [1:49:14] Councilor Stretch, did you want to comment on it? [1:49:19] Go ahead. [1:49:21] Yes, thank you. [1:49:22] I'm just hearing and having conversation with the co-op owners. [1:49:29] They're very reluctant because of the cost involved. [1:49:32] And they are really great property owners [1:49:35] and seem to be working together and mobilizing. [1:49:38] And I think, in our past, when we've heard from delegates about their pause about becoming [1:49:48] heritage and not being a much more cumbersome designation for them to be able to move forward [1:49:53] as something that I'd be willing to support and support their cause and hearing from them. [1:49:59] I think it's a strong case. [1:50:01] Thank you, Councillor Gino. [1:50:03] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [1:50:05] And the picture on Google Maps, that's a beautiful grass you guys have. [1:50:08] I wish mine looked as good as that, but the reality is we actually need more co-ops in the city, [1:50:17] to keep affordable rates or affordable rents going forward, and I've seen and heard [1:50:24] firsthand what happens when a heritage designation is applied to a home, it really hamstrings [1:50:30] the homeowners as to what they can do and what they can't do, and I'm not in the business [1:50:34] of subjecting house or a building to a standard that really ties people's hands and so I'm in [1:50:41] favor of Councillor Strach's motion and keep up the good work on this on this apartment. [1:50:50] Thank you, Councillor Misho. [1:50:52] Thank you. As a heritage committee member, I find myself sitting in a little awkward situation here [1:50:58] but this is a heavy file. This is a file where we have people that are living in a home [1:51:04] building, keeping it in excellent condition, they clearly love where they live, and all for heritage [1:51:11] designation, I think it's really important to secure as much history as we can in our community. [1:51:19] But this is something that I would not support. I will support Councillor. [1:51:25] I'm sorry. [1:51:26] I'll support councilor stretches motion to to remove the designation so thank you [1:51:36] So just to be clear we're not removing the designation because we haven't designated the cat [1:51:41] Council chaplain. Yeah, can I just ask one more question sure. Go ahead. Thank you [1:51:48] I just wonder if [1:51:50] The building were to be sold at a later date. Can we always come back to the question of designation [1:51:59] I'm just going to call your councillor Stevenson. [1:52:02] Stevenson. [1:52:03] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [1:52:04] This property would be removed from our heritage register at the end of this year. [1:52:10] And could not be added again back on the register for five years after that. [1:52:16] In terms of that would be our first steps. [1:52:20] It would be not for five years. [1:52:23] I'll just say I'm also on the Heritage Committee and I, you know, I understand. [1:52:30] I do appreciate the work that's being done and the fact that it is a cooperative and I feel [1:52:36] I have a bit of, I'm glad to hear that at some point it could come back. I don't anything [1:52:44] is going to happen over the next five years at the co-op I trust. So I'm willing to not go ahead [1:52:52] with the designation at this point, aye. Also. [1:52:55] Thank you, Councillor Schneeter. [1:52:59] Thank you, Mayor. [1:53:00] Thank you, shall. [1:53:02] And then thank you, John. [1:53:03] And for coming in. [1:53:05] This is a building. [1:53:06] I'm very familiar with. [1:53:08] I want the Shepherd School as a kid. [1:53:10] So I saw this building every day after school. [1:53:14] I like the mayor. [1:53:15] I drive by it almost every day. [1:53:18] It is in pristine condition. [1:53:21] It's gorgeous. [1:53:21] It's one of those buildings for open doors, I'd love to go through it, I'd love to see what it looks like on the inside, because it takes you back to a very special time, and you have lovingly taken great care of this building, and we are in a time where affordability is on people's minds. [1:53:44] I'm hearing that after-door campaign. [1:53:49] Precarity, people are worried about what's going to happen. [1:53:54] Can they stay where they are? [1:53:57] You have a building, a cooperative team of people that [1:54:02] that together keep a building looking good in great shape [1:54:09] and you live affordably and collectively. [1:54:12] And this is a beautiful thing, and I just feel so strongly that this is not needed. [1:54:21] It's done out of love already, it's done out of pride, and she said, for 80 years, it's gone [1:54:29] this way. [1:54:30] And it'll continue to go this way, because there will be this continuation, as there has been, [1:54:36] for 80 years of lovingly taking care of this building and being proud of it and being a great place to live. [1:54:44] So, thank you, Councilor stretch for your good work on this. [1:54:48] Councillor Sing? [1:54:50] Yeah, I share an agreement with what know everything that Councillor Schneider has said and it's difficult to add anything further because he's very eloquently outlined exactly. [1:54:59] That we need to support cooperatives like this. [1:55:02] that are well-intentioned, positive community members that are putting tremendous care [1:55:14] in their housing, not just how it looks on the inside, but also on the outside. [1:55:18] And to preserve a building of the age of this, to look immaculate, and it's true original [1:55:24] built form, is why you got the interest of what, perhaps, where the heritage attributes [1:55:29] are. [1:55:29] So, you should be applauded not additional, I think, conditions opposed. [1:55:36] The other thing tonight, I think, which was said very succinctly in a pre-shade counterchampment, [1:55:40] having said this and her viewpoint in recognizing again the affordability and the commission [1:55:45] he had made earlier, was it's not necessarily about new affordable housing only, but it's [1:55:49] the preservation of existing affordable housing, and you guys are already providing that affordable [1:55:55] housing to occupants. [1:55:58] And this is where I was going back and forth with Mr. Stephenson [1:56:00] and I appreciate their pride. [1:56:01] He gave that it's hard for, as a staff opinion, [1:56:05] to outline exactly when an impact assessment is required. [1:56:09] But just doing quick Google search, [1:56:11] a cost of heritage impact assessment can cost anywhere [1:56:14] between 6,000 to 30,000. [1:56:17] And the fact is, a designation could at some point [1:56:20] require an necessity that heritage impact assessment. [1:56:23] And imagining a $30,000 cost to $50 occupants while that could undo financial pressure. [1:56:32] So that's why we have to make these decisions very responsibly. [1:56:36] And I think the building form and its heritage character is in good hands and respectful hands [1:56:43] and have good confidence the building will continue and be looking the way it is. [1:56:47] So I'm supporting Councillor Strich's amendment. [1:56:52] Thanks. Thanks, Councillor Sting, and I'll speak to it in a moment. I will just note that Mr. [1:56:58] Stevenson has informed me that the legislation does require us to publish a notice of withdrawal [1:57:05] of designation. Sounds like a good thing for us to suggest to the provinces as something [1:57:12] for their red tape committee to look at. I need to suggest, you know, [1:57:21] to require posting if you're going to designate, removing the designation seems, seems a little unnecessary. [1:57:29] But anyway, that is a cost covered by the municipality as part of the process. [1:57:34] I will support Councillor Stratch's motion. [1:57:37] I am someone who historically has believed and supported heritage. [1:57:45] But I also think it's different when we're looking at a personally owned individual property or in this instance and not for profit co-op, which is very different than a for profit business that also has the ability to write expenses often and so on. That is a different set of circumstances and I will note that as as I did earlier on with the example of the glove box where we didn't go ahead. [1:58:14] with designation. And I think we've all seen the outcome of that. And in fact, the investment [1:58:21] by the property owner into that building is attracted companies like Zurich Insurance to, [1:58:28] which, you know, to look at that space and move part of their operation into the city of [1:58:34] Kitchener. And so, you know, as has been pointed out by several colleagues, [1:58:40] This is a property that really exhibits the pride and the love that the residents of the [1:58:48] co-op put into the building and I think it has been noted as well from a affordability [1:58:55] perspective. [1:58:57] This would add an unnecessary stress and potentially financial burden on people at a time when [1:59:03] that's not necessary and I'm confident that they will continue to care for it as they have [1:59:07] for many decades up until now. [1:59:09] So, it has been moved in seconded, all those recorded vote, okay? [1:59:18] Haven't done one of those in a while? [1:59:24] Maybe. [1:59:35] And that is carried unanimously. [1:59:39] Okay, thank you, thank you very much to all the two of you here as well as to John who's joined virtually. [1:59:46] Okay, we'll now move on to item 6.3, which is the Heritage Permanent Application for 16-20 [1:59:55] screen street north. [2:00:00] And altering existing window opening into a door and floor two of the front facade, the clerk has advised me that at Heritage Kitchener, this matter was considered on September 1, 2026, and the staff recommendation, which was to approve the recommendation was voted on and was lost. [2:00:19] lost. The staff, the staff recommendation is outlined in the [2:00:23] academic report has been included on the council agenda and the [2:00:26] affirmative. And so if it is council's will to refuse the heritage [2:00:30] permit application, members of council should vote in opposition of [2:00:34] the recommendation. So in other words, if [2:00:40] if you want to vote in favor [2:00:44] of allowing the renovations that have been requested by the applicant, [2:00:47] you would vote in favor of the recommendation before us, and if you want to vote against the recommendation of that you would sort of you would vote against the recommendation to deny it. [2:01:02] I'm still confused by this. [2:01:04] I will also note that there have been three written submissions from MHBC planning, Suciver and Leslie Stollard, and we do have four delegations here this evening and our first delegation. [2:01:15] Mr. Dan Curry from MHBC Planning. Welcome. [2:01:19] Thank you. [2:01:21] Excuse me. [2:01:23] The purpose of my delegation on behalf of my client, [2:01:28] I'll mention who are the owner and the developer, [2:01:30] is to request the council to defer decision on the heritage permit tonight. [2:01:36] And the reason for their request on the deferral [2:01:40] is that my clients understand there's a number of questions [2:01:45] and possibly concerns around the use of the community benefit space, [2:01:51] which is part of the ground floor. [2:01:52] It's not directly related to the Heritage Permit application, [2:01:56] but given that this is one of the approvals that they have to go through. [2:02:00] And just as background council, you will recall that when this was approved [2:02:04] in originally approved in 2021, [2:02:06] It's a mixed use building, a tall residential tower, and among the uses on the ground floor, one of those is a community benefit space, which is what it's the name implies. [2:02:19] And although there's revisions to the application and hence the need for a heritage permit, because there are some changes to the building. [2:02:26] that affect the heritage attributes, there's still a community benefit space, but it will change. [2:02:33] So they recognize there's some questions, they're in discussions with the number of groups [2:02:38] and others around that space. They just haven't finalized it. So what they would prefer [2:02:43] is if Council would agree to a deferral to sometime later this fall. They'd be able to finalize [2:02:49] some of those discussions, have some answers to what some of the potential questions or concerns [2:02:54] could be and I would return and or they would return and request you approved the heritage [2:03:01] permitted at that time. But that concludes what is my intention with this delegation is to ask [2:03:07] that you defer a decision tonight. Thank you. Thank you for that questions of Mr. Curry, [2:03:15] Councillor Chapman. Yes. Thank you. I'd be happy to bring a deferral motion forward. [2:03:22] But one thing that, I mean, I know the community developed what he called the community space [2:03:30] is really important, but the other thing that I think was highlighted at the Heritage Committee [2:03:36] meeting was the engineers report that was missing in the report we received at Heritage Committee [2:03:45] regarding the size of the facade. [2:03:50] So is that something that you can have ready for us [2:03:52] in the next, well, between now and the deferral date? [2:03:57] Yes, we can prefer the engineer reports [2:04:00] and the process of the stabilization plan [2:04:04] and those types of implementation measures, [2:04:06] we can provide further information on that at that time. [2:04:09] Okay. [2:04:10] And what I would add, sorry, through you, [2:04:14] of a benefit is if there are specific questions that would be important for council to know, [2:04:21] if you pass those students staff would be happy to provide the information that the [2:04:26] developer is going to a great deal of work in terms of some of that information. [2:04:30] Okay, great. [2:04:30] Thank you. [2:04:32] Thank you. [2:04:33] Next up, we have councilor stretch. [2:04:36] Thank you. [2:04:36] Happy to support a deferral to learn more about what's possible with community space, affordable [2:04:42] housing. [2:04:43] that's a big difference between the first 2021 proposal and the one considered down. So happy to [2:04:51] have some time to gain more information. Thank you. Councillor Sing. He has going to speak to the [2:04:59] same effect. Glad that Councillor Stratch has touched on the affordable housing. Of course, [2:05:04] the conversation about community space is important. And thank you for Councillor Chapman for [2:05:09] looking at the deferrals so that we can have a more nuanced conversation of how the overall [2:05:13] benefit can be to the community in that but also I think this is the up that opportunity for specifying the overall community need for affordable housing as well. [2:05:22] I think obviously you were in the the gallery having hearing the importance for as a critical importance of affordable housing that plays when we are balancing so those decisions along with the as important things of heritage as well. [2:05:36] We especially have to look at the more immediate also, which is that affordable housing, so hopefully we can have some progress along that as well, and I'm looking forward to seeing what you guys have to offer. [2:05:47] Thank you. [2:05:49] Councillor Sting, Councillor Schneider. [2:05:51] Thank you, Mayor. [2:05:52] And like my fellow Councillors, I'd like the offer of us getting our questions to staff, so that we can have a really full-sum conversation. [2:06:00] because the community space, the loss of units, [2:06:04] a loss of affordable units, just want to get an understanding. [2:06:06] And I was going to crazy market out there lately, [2:06:09] but to have the proper information, [2:06:11] so the council and the community can have all the transparent information [2:06:15] we need is necessary. [2:06:17] So thank you for that. [2:06:19] Thank you. [2:06:20] Thank you, Councillor Schneider and Mr. Curry. [2:06:23] Thank you for making that offer. [2:06:25] And we will give the other delegations the opportunity to decide [2:06:31] if they still want to speak tonight or if they want to wait [2:06:35] to see if this issue or when this issue comes back for it. [2:06:39] So thank you. [2:06:40] Thank you. [2:06:41] OK. [2:06:43] Mr. Merenness de Groot, did you still want to speak this evening? [2:06:46] Or did you want to hold for next time? [2:06:50] It's up to you. [2:06:54] Yeah, up to you. [2:06:54] You want to come down to the podium then? [2:06:56] And I'll ask the same in a moment of Mr. Yager as well as Ivonnep. [2:07:06] Take good time. [2:07:20] And spoke in favor of the whole designation of the building, but my purpose was really just... [2:07:30] Time. The developers themselves had said they were interested in a civil conversation, and I was all in favour of a civil eager for a civil conversation. [2:07:42] And then it was disappointing in the end the way things turned out. [2:07:46] But I really wasn't discouraged. I thought that that civil conversation could still happen. [2:07:50] But it did, now it's five years later. [2:07:55] I'm still up for that civil conversation. [2:07:58] So I would have recommended that you defer [2:08:01] the decision, at least until after the election. [2:08:06] And give us a bit of time. [2:08:08] Maybe spring march, something like that, [2:08:10] so that we can actually look at the whole context [2:08:14] in part in the developers themselves, [2:08:16] because I think this scaled down version. [2:08:19] There were a lot of good things about the original, was quite grand and it was bold and [2:08:26] it had that, the arts component, and I think that's lost now. [2:08:34] And I think if we talk and everybody contributes, we might become up with somebody that's [2:08:40] a lot better. [2:08:42] So that's all I wanted to say. [2:08:44] Wonderful. [2:08:44] and I know Mr. DeGrewt, you have a long passionate history about arts and culture in the [2:08:50] communities so thank you for coming forward this evening. [2:08:54] I was actually going to propose a friend of the Queen's Speak Conservatory thinking about [2:08:59] our time of the Friends of the Queen's Speak Conservatory thinking about our time of [2:09:04] the Friends of the Queen's Speak Conservatory thinking about our time of the Friends of the Queen's Speak [2:09:16] So talking friends of the conservatory, you never know what the result is going to be, and it might not be in that particular site, but I think a good result can come. [2:09:27] Let's just not see the same result that we saw at the old St. Jerome's building, which unfortunately, as you know, got fell victim to a fire, so let's not see that happen. [2:09:40] Thank you for coming in. Mr. Yager, did you just go on a speak this evening? [2:09:51] I could already ask him for that and I support that and I think that I think a more [2:09:55] offline conversation will be more productive. [2:09:58] Okay, thank you for that and I want it. [2:10:07] Thank you. You just saved me from having to read through my two pages. [2:10:12] What I want to say is [2:10:14] It is, I'm in favor of being deferred as well, and I think that's what one of my [2:10:20] hoax was, but at the same time deferred not so that it's a decision in isolation [2:10:27] as it has been brought forward today, as, you know, a consideration of a heritage application. [2:10:37] The project is to be seen globally in its historic decisions that I went into it. [2:10:44] And so the items of affordability, the cultural space, the heritage part of it was a piece of that for some decision, and now that there is a proposal for a materially changed project proposal, those decisions have to be revisited and reinterpreted into your new thinking about it, so thank you. [2:11:12] Okay, thank you very much. [2:11:17] So there is a, who's moving the deferral, Councillor Chapman. [2:11:22] Thank you, do I have a seconder? [2:11:23] Councillor Stratch, thank you. [2:11:26] Oh, yes, we need a date. [2:11:32] Mr. Courier, Mr. Stevenson, do you want to help here? [2:11:39] Mr. Courier? [2:11:40] Yeah, just on behalf. [2:11:42] You, Mr. Mayor, or two, you, Mr. Mayor, I guess is the question. [2:11:45] And my client needs several weeks to continue on the discussion, they're thinking at least [2:11:53] later into this fall, for the cleric has to, you know, when the next council meetings [2:11:59] would be, but they would like this to return at the earliest, sometime later this fall. [2:12:06] So realistically, there will only be one other meeting, and it will be of the new council [2:12:11] in like we have one meeting yet of this council but it's really more just they it's not a decision [2:12:20] meeting it's just kind of a wrap up of the the term of council meeting and then we have the [2:12:26] next council will have it inaugural and and and there'll be one round of meetings in December [2:12:34] if I can make a suggestion to you you may want to leave it till the first round in January [2:12:39] Okay, just to give the new council an opportunity in case there will be at least one change. [2:12:45] We know because Councillor Wooddonis and working and we don't know how elections will play out. [2:12:53] And so you may want to give people an opportunity to just get their feet wet before this comes back in. [2:13:01] We'll communicate that to January works. [2:13:04] Okay, so that's your motion then. [2:13:06] Thank you. [2:13:11] Okay, [2:13:14] no, just it'll come back to the January round of meetings. [2:13:18] So, so that's been moved in seconded, any discussion? [2:13:23] All those in favor? [2:13:24] Opposed? [2:13:25] That's carried. [2:13:25] Thank you everyone for coming in this evening for that item. [2:13:31] We'll now move on to the reports of the committee's council. [2:13:35] Mr. Misha, does that, does it leave some? [2:13:37] Do you want to bring those forward, please? [2:13:39] It has been moved by myself and seconded by Councilor Deb Chapman that the balance of the heritage of the [2:13:45] report, State of September 1st, 2026 listed as item 71b to 71d on the agenda of this [2:13:52] day to be adopted. [2:13:54] Thank you. [2:13:55] There has been movement of seconded any discussion. [2:13:58] All those in favor opposed that is carried. [2:14:02] Councilor Davy, the Finance and Corporate Services Committee, please. [2:14:05] Yes, this has been moved by myself and seconded by a Councilor Billionitis that the [2:14:09] three items coming from Finance and Corporate Services Committee be adopted. [2:14:13] Okay, thank you. [2:14:17] Any discussion? Has been moved and seconded all those in favor? Any opposed [2:14:23] that to is carried? There's no unfinished business, any new business? [2:14:31] Under mayoral business [2:14:32] It's an update, I'd just like to provide a little bit of an update on the media event that [2:14:41] myself in Council held earlier this afternoon when we shared with the public kitcheners [2:14:46] planned to support local and protect jobs, the coordinated response to the ongoing, tariff [2:14:52] and trade uncertainty affecting businesses, workers and families across our community. [2:15:00] But I do want to highlight what this work means for a city moving forward. This plan is focused on practical actions that are within the city's control. [2:15:08] We will continue using our purchasing power to support Ontario and Canadian businesses, build stronger domestic supply chains and create more opportunities for local firms to compete for city and other government contracts. [2:15:20] Today, approximately 98% of the city spending and good services and construction already remains [2:15:27] with Ontario-based businesses. [2:15:29] We intend to build on that strong foundation. [2:15:32] We will also work directly with businesses and sectors most exposed to trade disruption [2:15:37] and helping connect them with funding opportunities, growth supports, export resources, and [2:15:43] new supply chain options. [2:15:45] At the same time, we will continue bringing kitchen and voice to provincial and federal decision [2:15:49] makers and advocating for solutions that reflect the realities facing local employers and workers. [2:15:55] A second element of the plan is activating the community, and today we relaunch support [2:16:00] local. [2:16:01] Build Kitchen Center, a renewed citywide campaign that gives residents a practical way to be part [2:16:07] of the solution. [2:16:09] The campaign will encourage people to choose local businesses and Canadian-made products whenever [2:16:13] possible, while highlighting the entrepreneurs and employers and innovators who help drive [2:16:18] kitcheners economy. It'll be supported through local business storytelling, partnerships, [2:16:23] events, and year-round outreach across the community, and we'll also be planning to reopen [2:16:30] our online store for some of the support local merchandise. [2:16:35] Importantly, the campaign is not separate from the action plan. It's one part of a broader [2:16:40] effort to strengthen economic resilience. Alongside procurement changes, business supports [2:16:45] supply change development in advocacy, it all will help keep more spending circulating within [2:16:50] our local economy and support the jobs that depend on it. [2:16:54] Trade uncertainty may be beyond our control, but how we respond to it is not. [2:16:59] And so Kitchener will continue using the tools available to us, working closely with businesses [2:17:04] and community partners, and taking practical steps to support local jobs, strengthen our [2:17:09] economy and build resilience for the future, [2:17:17] and there is one other thing that I just want [2:17:20] to touch on in my report and acknowledge that somebody in our staff team today is celebrating [2:17:31] the start of their 40th year as an employee with the City of Kitchener. [2:17:36] And so, I don't quite understand how the math works because I was told she's only 39. [2:17:44] And so, I just want to acknowledge our city solicitor, [2:17:49] Leslie McDonald, for your dedication and public service to the city of Kitchener. Congratulations. [2:18:01] So we'll move on to item number 10 and any questions and answers. [2:18:07] Okay, then we'll move on to staff reports and there are just one item. [2:18:13] and that is the twenty twenty seven calendar. Do I have a mover for that? [2:18:18] Move by Councillor Singh, seconded by Councillor Stratch, any discussion? All those in [2:18:23] favor? Opposed? That's carried? There's three information items there. Any discussion? [2:18:37] Nope. Okay. Then we'll move on to the bylaws. [2:18:45] Thank you. [2:18:46] Thank you. [2:18:46] There's an item arising from in camera. [2:18:48] We will display it on the screen. [2:18:50] Thank you. [2:18:51] So there is an item noted on the screen. [2:18:53] Do I have a mover for that? [2:18:55] Councillor. [2:18:55] I need a second by Councillor Denow. [2:18:57] Any discussion? [2:19:00] All those in favor? [2:19:01] Opposed? [2:19:02] That's carried. [2:19:03] Thank you. [2:19:04] And now, Madam Clerk. [2:19:05] Are there any additional bylaws? [2:19:07] Through the chair. [2:19:07] Given the discussion regarding two six five [2:19:10] We do need to strike item 121G from the list of by-laws. [2:19:15] Okay, so with that change, somebody cared to move the by-laws. [2:19:20] Councillor Chapman, Councillor Houdini, any discussion? [2:19:25] All those in favour? [2:19:27] Opposed? [2:19:28] That's carried. [2:19:31] And with that, I just want to remind everyone that October 26 is municipal election day. [2:19:39] You can check out the City of Kitchener website if you need to find out information about voting. [2:19:46] And with that, I will now take a motion to adjourn, moved by Councillor Schneider, seconded by Councillor Miso, any discussion? [2:19:56] All those in favour? [2:19:58] Opposed? [2:19:59] That is carried. [2:20:00] Thank you everyone.