1
00:03:54,750 --> 00:03:56,750
council

2
00:03:56,745 --> 00:03:59,145
[Meeting will begin shortly]

3
00:03:59,915 --> 00:04:00,949
Mtc abag community advisory

4
00:04:00,949 --> 00:04:02,949
council

5
00:04:04,685 --> 00:04:07,850
[Meeting will begin shortly]

6
00:04:07,321 --> 00:04:08,390
Mtc abag community advisory

7
00:04:08,390 --> 00:04:10,390
council

8
00:04:11,580 --> 00:04:13,458
[Meeting will begin shortly]

9
00:04:14,228 --> 00:04:15,296
Mtc abag community advisory

10
00:04:15,296 --> 00:04:17,296
council

11
00:04:18,966 --> 00:04:21,366
[Meeting will begin shortly]

12
00:04:21,670 --> 00:04:22,737
Mtc abag community advisory

13
00:04:22,737 --> 00:04:24,737
council

14
00:04:25,340 --> 00:04:27,740
[Meeting will begin shortly]

15
00:04:28,510 --> 00:04:29,577
Mtc abag community advisory

16
00:04:29,577 --> 00:04:31,577
council

17
00:04:33,314 --> 00:04:35,714
[Meeting will begin shortly]

18
00:04:35,917 --> 00:04:36,984
Mtc abag community advisory

19
00:04:36,984 --> 00:04:38,984
council

20
00:04:39,687 --> 00:04:42,870
[Meeting will begin shortly]

21
00:04:42,824 --> 00:04:43,891
Mtc abag community advisory

22
00:04:43,891 --> 00:04:45,891
council

23
00:04:47,595 --> 00:04:49,995
[Meeting will begin shortly]

24
00:04:50,297 --> 00:04:51,298
Mtc abag community advisory

25
00:04:51,298 --> 00:04:53,298
council

26
00:04:53,968 --> 00:04:56,368
[Meeting will begin shortly]

27
00:04:57,137 --> 00:04:58,205
Mtc abag community advisory

28
00:04:58,205 --> 00:05:00,205
council

29
00:05:01,909 --> 00:05:04,309
[Meeting will begin shortly]

30
00:05:04,545 --> 00:05:05,646
Mtc abag community advisory

31
00:05:05,646 --> 00:05:07,646
council

32
00:05:08,248 --> 00:05:10,648
[Meeting will begin shortly]

33
00:05:11,418 --> 00:05:12,520
Mtc abag community advisory

34
00:05:12,520 --> 00:05:14,520
council

35
00:05:16,190 --> 00:05:18,590
[Meeting will begin shortly]

36
00:05:18,860 --> 00:05:19,893
Mtc abag community advisory

37
00:05:19,893 --> 00:05:21,893
council

38
00:05:22,563 --> 00:05:24,963
[Meeting will begin shortly]

39
00:05:25,733 --> 00:05:26,800
mtc abag community advisory

40
00:05:26,800 --> 00:05:28,800
council

41
00:05:30,504 --> 00:05:32,904
[Meeting will begin shortly]

42
00:05:33,140 --> 00:05:34,241
Mtc abag community advisory

43
00:05:34,241 --> 00:05:36,241
council

44
00:05:36,844 --> 00:05:39,244
[Meeting will begin shortly]

45
00:05:40,800 --> 00:05:41,148
Mtc abag community advisory

46
00:05:41,148 --> 00:05:43,148
council

47
00:05:44,852 --> 00:05:47,252
[Meeting will begin shortly]

48
00:05:47,487 --> 00:05:48,522
Mtc abag community advisory

49
00:05:48,522 --> 00:05:50,522
council

50
00:05:51,158 --> 00:05:53,558
[Meeting will begin shortly]

51
00:05:54,361 --> 00:05:55,395
Mtc abag community advisory

52
00:05:55,395 --> 00:05:57,395
council

53
00:05:59,990 --> 00:06:01,499
[Meeting will begin shortly]

54
00:06:01,735 --> 00:06:02,803
Mtc abag community advisory

55
00:06:02,803 --> 00:06:04,803
council

56
00:06:05,439 --> 00:06:07,839
[Meeting will begin shortly]

57
00:06:08,643 --> 00:06:09,743
Mtc abag community advisory

58
00:06:09,743 --> 00:06:11,743
council

59
00:06:13,413 --> 00:06:15,813
[Meeting will begin shortly]

60
00:06:16,830 --> 00:06:17,117
Mtc abag community advisory

61
00:06:17,117 --> 00:06:19,117
council

62
00:06:19,753 --> 00:06:22,153
[Meeting will begin shortly]

63
00:06:22,956 --> 00:06:24,250
Mtc abag community advisory

64
00:06:24,250 --> 00:06:26,250
council

65
00:06:27,694 --> 00:06:30,940
[Meeting will begin shortly]

66
00:06:30,363 --> 00:06:31,431
Mtc abag community advisory

67
00:06:31,431 --> 00:06:33,431
council

68
00:06:34,601 --> 00:06:37,100
[Meeting will begin shortly]

69
00:06:37,237 --> 00:06:38,305
Mtc abag community advisory

70
00:06:38,305 --> 00:06:40,305
council

71
00:06:42,800 --> 00:06:44,408
[Meeting will begin shortly]

72
00:06:44,644 --> 00:06:45,745
Mtc abag community advisory

73
00:06:45,745 --> 00:06:47,745
council

74
00:06:48,348 --> 00:06:50,748
[Meeting will begin shortly]

75
00:06:51,551 --> 00:06:52,619
Mtc abag community advisory

76
00:06:52,619 --> 00:06:54,619
council

77
00:06:56,323 --> 00:06:58,723
[Meeting will begin shortly]

78
00:06:58,992 --> 00:07:00,590
Mtc abag community advisory

79
00:07:00,590 --> 00:07:02,590
council

80
00:07:02,662 --> 00:07:05,620
[Meeting will begin shortly]

81
00:07:05,832 --> 00:07:07,434
Mtc abag community advisory

82
00:07:07,434 --> 00:07:09,434
council

83
00:07:10,637 --> 00:07:13,370
[Meeting will begin shortly]

84
00:07:13,240 --> 00:07:14,307
Mtc abag community advisory

85
00:07:14,307 --> 00:07:16,307
council

86
00:07:16,977 --> 00:07:19,377
[Meeting will begin shortly]

87
00:07:20,146 --> 00:07:21,214
Mtc abag community advisory

88
00:07:21,214 --> 00:07:23,214
council

89
00:07:24,951 --> 00:07:27,351
[Meeting will begin shortly]

90
00:07:27,587 --> 00:07:28,621
Mtc abag community advisory

91
00:07:28,621 --> 00:07:30,621
council

92
00:07:31,290 --> 00:07:33,690
[Meeting will begin shortly]

93
00:07:34,460 --> 00:07:35,495
Mtc abag community advisory

94
00:07:35,495 --> 00:07:37,495
council

95
00:07:39,199 --> 00:07:41,599
[Meeting will begin shortly]

96
00:07:41,901 --> 00:07:42,969
Mtc abag community advisory

97
00:07:42,969 --> 00:07:44,969
council

98
00:07:45,605 --> 00:07:48,500
[Meeting will begin shortly]

99
00:07:48,741 --> 00:07:49,843
Mtc abag community advisory

100
00:07:49,843 --> 00:07:51,843
council

101
00:07:53,513 --> 00:07:55,913
[Meeting will begin shortly]

102
00:07:56,182 --> 00:07:57,216
Mtc abag community advisory

103
00:07:57,216 --> 00:07:59,216
council

104
00:07:59,886 --> 00:08:02,286
[Meeting will begin shortly]

105
00:08:03,560 --> 00:08:04,123
Mtc abag community advisory

106
00:08:04,123 --> 00:08:06,123
council

107
00:08:07,827 --> 00:08:10,227
[Meeting will begin shortly]

108
00:08:10,463 --> 00:08:11,531
Mtc abag community advisory

109
00:08:11,531 --> 00:08:13,531
council

110
00:08:14,167 --> 00:08:16,567
[Meeting will begin shortly]

111
00:08:17,336 --> 00:08:18,437
Mtc abag community advisory

112
00:08:18,437 --> 00:08:20,437
council

113
00:08:22,142 --> 00:08:24,542
[Meeting will begin shortly]

114
00:08:24,744 --> 00:08:25,845
Mtc abag community advisory

115
00:08:25,845 --> 00:08:27,845
council

116
00:08:28,481 --> 00:08:30,881
[Meeting will begin shortly]

117
00:08:31,617 --> 00:08:32,718
Mtc abag community advisory

118
00:08:32,718 --> 00:08:34,718
council

119
00:08:36,422 --> 00:08:38,822
[Meeting will begin shortly]

120
00:08:39,910 --> 00:08:40,126
Mtc abag community advisory

121
00:08:40,126 --> 00:08:42,126
council

122
00:08:42,762 --> 00:08:45,162
[Meeting will begin shortly]

123
00:08:45,932 --> 00:08:47,000
Mtc abag community advisory

124
00:08:47,000 --> 00:08:49,000
council

125
00:08:50,736 --> 00:08:53,136
[Meeting will begin shortly]

126
00:08:53,372 --> 00:08:54,440
Mtc abag community advisory

127
00:08:54,440 --> 00:08:56,440
council

128
00:08:57,760 --> 00:08:59,476
[Meeting will begin shortly]

129
00:09:00,246 --> 00:09:01,347
Mtc abag community advisory

130
00:09:01,347 --> 00:09:03,347
council

131
00:09:05,170 --> 00:09:07,417
[Meeting will begin shortly]

132
00:09:07,686 --> 00:09:08,721
Mtc abag community advisory

133
00:09:08,721 --> 00:09:10,721
council

134
00:09:11,390 --> 00:09:13,790
[Meeting will begin shortly]

135
00:09:14,593 --> 00:09:15,594
Mtc abag community advisory

136
00:09:15,594 --> 00:09:17,594
council

137
00:09:19,331 --> 00:09:21,731
[Meeting will begin shortly]

138
00:09:21,968 --> 00:09:23,350
Mtc abag community advisory

139
00:09:23,350 --> 00:09:25,350
council

140
00:09:25,671 --> 00:09:28,710
[Meeting will begin shortly]

141
00:09:28,841 --> 00:09:29,908
Mtc abag community advisory

142
00:09:29,908 --> 00:09:31,908
council

143
00:09:33,645 --> 00:09:36,450
[Meeting will begin shortly]

144
00:09:36,281 --> 00:09:37,350
Mtc abag community advisory

145
00:09:37,350 --> 00:09:39,350
council

146
00:09:39,985 --> 00:09:42,385
[Meeting will begin shortly]

147
00:09:43,188 --> 00:09:44,256
Mtc abag community advisory

148
00:09:44,256 --> 00:09:46,256
council

149
00:09:47,926 --> 00:09:50,326
[Meeting will begin shortly]

150
00:09:50,562 --> 00:09:51,630
Mtc abag community advisory

151
00:09:51,630 --> 00:09:53,630
council

152
00:09:54,266 --> 00:09:56,666
[Meeting will begin shortly]

153
00:09:57,970 --> 00:09:58,537
Mtc abag community advisory

154
00:09:58,537 --> 00:10:00,537
council

155
00:10:02,241 --> 00:10:04,641
[Meeting will begin shortly]

156
00:10:04,910 --> 00:10:05,944
Mtc abag community advisory

157
00:10:05,944 --> 00:10:07,944
council

158
00:10:08,614 --> 00:10:11,140
[Meeting will begin shortly]

159
00:10:11,783 --> 00:10:12,818
Mtc abag community advisory

160
00:10:12,818 --> 00:10:14,818
council

161
00:10:16,521 --> 00:10:18,921
[Meeting will begin shortly]

162
00:10:19,191 --> 00:10:20,258
Mtc abag community advisory

163
00:10:20,258 --> 00:10:22,258
council

164
00:10:22,894 --> 00:10:25,294
[Meeting will begin shortly]

165
00:10:26,640 --> 00:10:27,132
Mtc abag community advisory

166
00:10:27,132 --> 00:10:29,132
council

167
00:10:30,802 --> 00:10:33,202
[Meeting will begin shortly]

168
00:10:33,472 --> 00:10:34,540
Mtc abag community advisory

169
00:10:34,540 --> 00:10:36,540
council

170
00:10:37,242 --> 00:10:39,642
[Meeting will begin shortly]

171
00:10:40,412 --> 00:10:41,446
Mtc abag community advisory

172
00:10:41,446 --> 00:10:43,446
council

173
00:10:45,183 --> 00:10:47,583
[Meeting will begin shortly]

174
00:10:47,820 --> 00:10:49,421
Mtc abag community advisory

175
00:10:49,421 --> 00:10:51,421
council

176
00:10:51,523 --> 00:10:53,923
[Meeting will begin shortly]

177
00:10:54,760 --> 00:10:55,794
Mtc abag community advisory

178
00:10:55,794 --> 00:10:57,794
council

179
00:10:59,464 --> 00:11:01,864
[Meeting will begin shortly]

180
00:11:02,133 --> 00:11:03,201
Mtc abag community advisory

181
00:11:03,201 --> 00:11:05,201
council

182
00:11:05,837 --> 00:11:08,237
[Meeting will begin shortly]

183
00:11:09,700 --> 00:11:10,740
Mtc abag community advisory

184
00:11:10,740 --> 00:11:12,740
council

185
00:11:13,812 --> 00:11:16,212
[Meeting will begin shortly]

186
00:11:16,447 --> 00:11:17,449
Mtc abag community advisory

187
00:11:17,449 --> 00:11:19,449
council

188
00:11:20,118 --> 00:11:22,518
[Meeting will begin shortly]

189
00:11:23,322 --> 00:11:24,355
mtc abag community advisory

190
00:11:24,355 --> 00:11:26,355
council

191
00:11:28,600 --> 00:11:30,460
[Meeting will begin shortly]

192
00:11:30,728 --> 00:11:31,763
Mtc abag community advisory

193
00:11:31,763 --> 00:11:33,763
council

194
00:11:34,432 --> 00:11:36,832
[Meeting will begin shortly]

195
00:11:37,602 --> 00:11:38,670
Mtc abag community advisory

196
00:11:38,670 --> 00:11:40,670
council

197
00:11:42,373 --> 00:11:44,773
[Meeting will begin shortly]

198
00:11:45,100 --> 00:11:46,110
Mtc abag community advisory

199
00:11:46,110 --> 00:11:48,110
council

200
00:11:48,713 --> 00:11:51,113
[Meeting will begin shortly]

201
00:11:51,916 --> 00:11:52,984
Mtc abag community advisory

202
00:11:52,984 --> 00:11:54,984
council

203
00:11:56,721 --> 00:11:59,121
[Meeting will begin shortly]

204
00:11:59,323 --> 00:12:00,391
Mtc abag community advisory

205
00:12:00,391 --> 00:12:02,391
council

206
00:12:03,270 --> 00:12:05,427
[Meeting will begin shortly]

207
00:12:06,197 --> 00:12:07,265
Mtc abag community advisory

208
00:12:07,265 --> 00:12:09,265
council

209
00:12:11,200 --> 00:12:13,402
[Meeting will begin shortly]

210
00:12:13,638 --> 00:12:14,739
Mtc abag community advisory

211
00:12:14,739 --> 00:12:16,739
council

212
00:12:17,375 --> 00:12:19,775
[Meeting will begin shortly]

213
00:12:20,545 --> 00:12:21,612
Mtc abag community advisory

214
00:12:21,612 --> 00:12:23,612
council

215
00:12:25,316 --> 00:12:27,716
[Meeting will begin shortly]

216
00:12:27,952 --> 00:12:29,200
Mtc abag community advisory

217
00:12:29,200 --> 00:12:31,200
council

218
00:12:31,689 --> 00:12:34,890
[Meeting will begin shortly]

219
00:12:34,859 --> 00:12:35,926
Mtc abag community advisory

220
00:12:35,926 --> 00:12:37,926
council

221
00:12:39,630 --> 00:12:42,300
[Meeting will begin shortly]

222
00:12:42,266 --> 00:12:43,334
Mtc abag community advisory

223
00:12:43,334 --> 00:12:45,334
council

224
00:12:46,400 --> 00:12:48,404
[Meeting will begin shortly]

225
00:12:49,176 --> 00:12:50,207
Mtc abag community advisory

226
00:12:50,207 --> 00:12:52,207
council

227
00:12:53,911 --> 00:12:56,311
[Meeting will begin shortly]

228
00:12:56,614 --> 00:12:57,648
Mtc abag community advisory

229
00:12:57,648 --> 00:12:59,648
council

230
00:13:00,284 --> 00:13:02,684
[Meeting will begin shortly]

231
00:13:03,454 --> 00:13:04,555
Mtc abag community advisory

232
00:13:04,555 --> 00:13:06,555
council

233
00:13:08,225 --> 00:13:10,625
[Meeting will begin shortly]

234
00:13:10,895 --> 00:13:11,962
Mtc abag community advisory

235
00:13:11,962 --> 00:13:13,962
council

236
00:13:14,599 --> 00:13:16,999
[Meeting will begin shortly]

237
00:13:17,768 --> 00:13:18,836
Mtc abag community advisory

238
00:13:18,836 --> 00:13:20,836
council

239
00:13:22,540 --> 00:13:24,940
[Meeting will begin shortly]

240
00:13:25,175 --> 00:13:26,243
Mtc abag community advisory

241
00:13:26,243 --> 00:13:28,243
council

242
00:13:28,912 --> 00:13:31,312
[Meeting will begin shortly]

243
00:13:32,820 --> 00:13:33,150
Mtc abag community advisory

244
00:13:33,150 --> 00:13:35,150
council

245
00:13:36,854 --> 00:13:39,254
[Meeting will begin shortly]

246
00:13:39,490 --> 00:13:40,591
Mtc abag community advisory

247
00:13:40,591 --> 00:13:42,591
council

248
00:13:43,226 --> 00:13:45,626
[Meeting will begin shortly]

249
00:13:46,363 --> 00:13:47,431
Mtc abag community advisory

250
00:13:47,431 --> 00:13:49,431
council

251
00:13:51,135 --> 00:13:53,535
[Meeting will begin shortly]

252
00:13:53,804 --> 00:13:54,872
Mtc abag community advisory

253
00:13:54,872 --> 00:13:56,872
council

254
00:13:57,508 --> 00:13:59,908
[Meeting will begin shortly]

255
00:14:00,711 --> 00:14:01,745
Mtc abag community advisory

256
00:14:01,745 --> 00:14:03,745
council

257
00:14:05,482 --> 00:14:07,882
[Meeting will begin shortly]

258
00:14:08,151 --> 00:14:09,186
Mtc abag community advisory

259
00:14:09,186 --> 00:14:11,186
council

260
00:14:11,855 --> 00:14:14,255
[Meeting will begin shortly]

261
00:14:15,250 --> 00:14:16,930
Mtc abag community advisory

262
00:14:16,930 --> 00:14:18,930
council

263
00:14:19,796 --> 00:14:22,196
[Meeting will begin shortly]

264
00:14:22,432 --> 00:14:23,500
Mtc abag community advisory

265
00:14:23,500 --> 00:14:25,500
council

266
00:14:26,136 --> 00:14:28,536
[Meeting will begin shortly]

267
00:14:29,373 --> 00:14:30,374
Mtc abag community advisory

268
00:14:30,374 --> 00:14:32,374
council

269
00:14:34,780 --> 00:14:36,478
[Meeting will begin shortly]

270
00:14:36,746 --> 00:14:37,781
Mtc abag community advisory

271
00:14:37,781 --> 00:14:39,781
council

272
00:14:40,450 --> 00:14:42,850
[Meeting will begin shortly]

273
00:14:43,620 --> 00:14:44,688
Mtc abag community advisory

274
00:14:44,688 --> 00:14:46,688
council

275
00:14:48,391 --> 00:14:50,791
[Meeting will begin shortly]

276
00:14:51,270 --> 00:14:52,620
Mtc abag community advisory

277
00:14:52,620 --> 00:14:54,620
council

278
00:14:54,731 --> 00:14:57,131
[Meeting will begin shortly]

279
00:14:57,934 --> 00:14:59,200
Mtc abag community advisory

280
00:14:59,200 --> 00:15:01,200
council

281
00:15:02,705 --> 00:15:05,105
[Meeting will begin shortly]

282
00:15:05,341 --> 00:15:06,376
Mtc abag community advisory

283
00:15:06,376 --> 00:15:08,376
council

284
00:15:09,450 --> 00:15:11,445
[Meeting will begin shortly]

285
00:15:12,215 --> 00:15:13,283
Mtc abag community advisory

286
00:15:13,283 --> 00:15:15,283
council

287
00:15:17,200 --> 00:15:19,420
[Meeting will begin shortly]

288
00:15:19,692 --> 00:15:20,690
Mtc abag community advisory

289
00:15:20,690 --> 00:15:22,690
council

290
00:15:23,393 --> 00:15:25,793
[Meeting will begin shortly]

291
00:15:26,530 --> 00:15:27,564
Mtc abag community advisory

292
00:15:27,564 --> 00:15:29,564
council

293
00:15:31,301 --> 00:15:33,701
[Meeting will begin shortly]

294
00:15:35,400 --> 00:15:35,238
Mtc abag community advisory

295
00:15:35,238 --> 00:15:37,238
council

296
00:15:37,674 --> 00:15:40,740
[Meeting will begin shortly]

297
00:15:40,877 --> 00:15:41,878
Mtc abag community advisory

298
00:15:41,878 --> 00:15:43,878
council

299
00:15:45,615 --> 00:15:48,150
[Meeting will begin shortly]

300
00:15:48,251 --> 00:15:49,319
Mtc abag community advisory

301
00:15:49,319 --> 00:15:51,319
council

302
00:15:51,988 --> 00:15:54,388
[Meeting will begin shortly]

303
00:15:55,158 --> 00:15:56,192
Mtc abag community advisory

304
00:15:56,192 --> 00:15:58,192
council

305
00:15:59,896 --> 00:16:02,296
[Meeting will begin shortly]

306
00:16:02,598 --> 00:16:03,633
Mtc abag community advisory

307
00:16:03,633 --> 00:16:05,633
council

308
00:16:06,269 --> 00:16:08,669
[Meeting will begin shortly]

309
00:16:09,472 --> 00:16:10,506
Mtc abag community advisory

310
00:16:10,506 --> 00:16:12,506
council

311
00:16:14,211 --> 00:16:16,611
[Meeting will begin shortly]

312
00:16:16,879 --> 00:16:17,914
Mtc abag community advisory

313
00:16:17,914 --> 00:16:19,914
council

314
00:16:20,550 --> 00:16:22,950
[Meeting will begin shortly]

315
00:16:23,753 --> 00:16:24,820
Mtc abag community advisory

316
00:16:24,820 --> 00:16:26,820
council

317
00:16:28,491 --> 00:16:30,891
[Meeting will begin shortly]

318
00:16:31,127 --> 00:16:32,194
Mtc abag community advisory

319
00:16:32,194 --> 00:16:34,194
council

320
00:16:34,830 --> 00:16:37,230
[Meeting will begin shortly]

321
00:16:38,670 --> 00:16:39,101
Mtc abag community advisory

322
00:16:39,101 --> 00:16:41,101
council

323
00:16:43,373 --> 00:16:45,773
[Meeting will begin shortly]

324
00:16:47,430 --> 00:16:47,276
Mtc abag community advisory

325
00:16:47,276 --> 00:16:49,276
council

326
00:16:49,745 --> 00:16:52,145
[Meeting will begin shortly]

327
00:16:52,882 --> 00:16:53,950
Mtc abag community advisory

328
00:16:53,950 --> 00:16:55,950
council

329
00:16:57,686 --> 00:17:00,860
[Meeting will begin shortly]

330
00:17:00,356 --> 00:17:01,391
Mtc abag community advisory

331
00:17:01,391 --> 00:17:03,391
council

332
00:17:04,260 --> 00:17:06,426
[Meeting will begin shortly]

333
00:17:07,230 --> 00:17:08,264
Mtc abag community advisory

334
00:17:08,264 --> 00:17:10,264
council

335
00:17:11,968 --> 00:17:14,368
[Meeting will begin shortly]

336
00:17:14,603 --> 00:17:15,704
Mtc abag community advisory

337
00:17:15,704 --> 00:17:17,704
council

338
00:17:18,307 --> 00:17:20,707
[Meeting will begin shortly]

339
00:17:21,510 --> 00:17:22,611
mtc abag community advisory

340
00:17:22,611 --> 00:17:24,611
council

341
00:17:26,282 --> 00:17:28,682
[Meeting will begin shortly]

342
00:17:28,984 --> 00:17:30,190
Mtc abag community advisory

343
00:17:30,190 --> 00:17:32,190
council

344
00:17:32,688 --> 00:17:35,880
[Meeting will begin shortly]

345
00:17:35,824 --> 00:17:36,892
Mtc abag community advisory

346
00:17:36,892 --> 00:17:38,892
council

347
00:17:41,960 --> 00:17:43,265
[Meeting will begin shortly]

348
00:17:43,265 --> 00:17:44,333
Mtc abag community advisory

349
00:17:44,333 --> 00:17:46,333
council

350
00:17:47,200 --> 00:17:49,402
[Meeting will begin shortly]

351
00:17:50,205 --> 00:17:51,273
Mtc abag community advisory

352
00:17:51,273 --> 00:17:53,273
council

353
00:17:54,943 --> 00:17:57,343
[Meeting will begin shortly]

354
00:17:57,613 --> 00:17:58,681
Mtc abag community advisory

355
00:17:58,681 --> 00:18:00,681
council

356
00:18:01,316 --> 00:18:03,716
[Meeting will begin shortly]

357
00:18:04,520 --> 00:18:05,554
Mtc abag community advisory

358
00:18:05,554 --> 00:18:07,554
council

359
00:18:09,291 --> 00:18:11,691
[Meeting will begin shortly]

360
00:18:11,927 --> 00:18:12,995
Mtc abag community advisory

361
00:18:12,995 --> 00:18:14,995
council

362
00:18:15,630 --> 00:18:18,300
[Meeting will begin shortly]

363
00:18:18,800 --> 00:18:19,868
Mtc abag community advisory

364
00:18:19,868 --> 00:18:21,868
council

365
00:18:23,572 --> 00:18:25,972
[Meeting will begin shortly]

366
00:18:26,241 --> 00:18:27,275
Mtc abag community advisory

367
00:18:27,275 --> 00:18:29,275
council

368
00:18:29,911 --> 00:18:32,311
[Meeting will begin shortly]

369
00:18:33,115 --> 00:18:34,149
Mtc abag community advisory

370
00:18:34,149 --> 00:18:36,149
council

371
00:18:37,886 --> 00:18:40,286
[Meeting will begin shortly]

372
00:18:40,555 --> 00:18:41,590
Mtc abag community advisory

373
00:18:41,590 --> 00:18:43,590
council

374
00:18:44,226 --> 00:18:46,626
[Meeting will begin shortly]

375
00:18:47,462 --> 00:18:48,463
Mtc abag community advisory

376
00:18:48,463 --> 00:18:50,463
council

377
00:18:52,634 --> 00:18:54,836
[Meeting will begin shortly]

378
00:18:54,836 --> 00:18:55,904
Mtc abag community advisory

379
00:18:55,904 --> 00:18:57,904
council

380
00:18:58,540 --> 00:19:00,940
[Meeting will begin shortly]

381
00:19:01,743 --> 00:19:02,811
Mtc abag community advisory

382
00:19:02,811 --> 00:19:04,811
council

383
00:19:06,514 --> 00:19:08,914
[Meeting will begin shortly]

384
00:19:09,117 --> 00:19:10,218
Mtc abag community advisory

385
00:19:10,218 --> 00:19:12,218
council

386
00:19:12,854 --> 00:19:15,254
[Meeting will begin shortly]

387
00:19:16,250 --> 00:19:17,920
Mtc abag community advisory

388
00:19:17,920 --> 00:19:19,920
council

389
00:19:21,296 --> 00:19:23,465
[Meeting will begin shortly]

390
00:19:23,465 --> 00:19:24,499
Mtc abag community advisory

391
00:19:24,499 --> 00:19:26,499
council

392
00:19:27,702 --> 00:19:30,102
[Meeting will begin shortly]

393
00:19:30,839 --> 00:19:31,907
Mtc abag community advisory

394
00:19:31,907 --> 00:19:33,907
council

395
00:19:35,610 --> 00:19:38,100
[Meeting will begin shortly]

396
00:19:38,313 --> 00:19:39,848
Mtc abag community advisory

397
00:19:39,848 --> 00:19:41,848
council

398
00:19:41,983 --> 00:19:44,383
[Meeting will begin shortly]

399
00:19:45,186 --> 00:19:46,220
Mtc abag community advisory

400
00:19:46,220 --> 00:19:48,220
council

401
00:19:49,924 --> 00:19:52,324
[Meeting will begin shortly]

402
00:19:52,627 --> 00:19:53,962
Mtc abag community advisory

403
00:19:53,962 --> 00:19:55,962
council

404
00:19:56,298 --> 00:19:58,698
[Meeting will begin shortly]

405
00:19:59,467 --> 00:20:00,502
Mtc abag community advisory

406
00:20:00,502 --> 00:20:02,502
council

407
00:20:04,238 --> 00:20:06,638
[Meeting will begin shortly]

408
00:20:06,908 --> 00:20:07,942
Mtc abag community advisory

409
00:20:07,942 --> 00:20:09,942
council

410
00:20:10,578 --> 00:20:12,978
[Meeting will begin shortly]

411
00:20:13,748 --> 00:20:14,849
Mtc abag community advisory

412
00:20:14,849 --> 00:20:16,849
council

413
00:20:18,519 --> 00:20:20,919
[Meeting will begin shortly]

414
00:20:21,189 --> 00:20:22,256
Mtc abag community advisory

415
00:20:22,256 --> 00:20:24,256
council

416
00:20:24,892 --> 00:20:27,292
[Meeting will begin shortly]

417
00:20:28,596 --> 00:20:29,130
Mtc abag community advisory

418
00:20:29,130 --> 00:20:31,130
council

419
00:20:32,867 --> 00:20:35,267
[Meeting will begin shortly]

420
00:20:35,570 --> 00:20:36,637
Mtc abag community advisory

421
00:20:36,637 --> 00:20:38,637
council

422
00:20:39,274 --> 00:20:41,674
[Meeting will begin shortly]

423
00:20:42,477 --> 00:20:43,544
Mtc abag community advisory

424
00:20:43,544 --> 00:20:45,544
council

425
00:20:47,214 --> 00:20:49,614
[Meeting will begin shortly]

426
00:20:49,884 --> 00:20:50,951
Mtc abag community advisory

427
00:20:50,951 --> 00:20:52,951
council

428
00:20:53,554 --> 00:20:55,954
[Meeting will begin shortly]

429
00:20:56,757 --> 00:20:57,792
Mtc abag community advisory

430
00:20:57,792 --> 00:20:59,792
council

431
00:21:01,495 --> 00:21:03,895
[Meeting will begin shortly]

432
00:21:04,732 --> 00:21:05,299
Mtc abag community advisory

433
00:21:05,299 --> 00:21:07,299
council

434
00:21:07,935 --> 00:21:10,335
[Meeting will begin shortly]

435
00:21:11,138 --> 00:21:12,173
Mtc abag community advisory

436
00:21:12,173 --> 00:21:14,173
council

437
00:21:15,910 --> 00:21:18,310
[Meeting will begin shortly]

438
00:21:18,546 --> 00:21:19,613
Mtc abag community advisory

439
00:21:19,613 --> 00:21:21,613
council

440
00:21:22,249 --> 00:21:24,649
[Meeting will begin shortly]

441
00:21:25,420 --> 00:21:26,487
Mtc abag community advisory

442
00:21:26,487 --> 00:21:28,487
council

443
00:21:30,190 --> 00:21:32,590
[Meeting will begin shortly]

444
00:21:32,859 --> 00:21:33,861
Mtc abag community advisory

445
00:21:33,861 --> 00:21:35,861
council

446
00:21:36,530 --> 00:21:38,930
[Meeting will begin shortly]

447
00:21:39,700 --> 00:21:40,801
Mtc abag community advisory

448
00:21:40,801 --> 00:21:42,801
council

449
00:21:44,471 --> 00:21:46,871
[Meeting will begin shortly]

450
00:21:47,140 --> 00:21:48,175
Mtc abag community advisory

451
00:21:48,175 --> 00:21:50,175
council

452
00:21:50,811 --> 00:21:53,211
[Meeting will begin shortly]

453
00:21:54,140 --> 00:21:55,480
Mtc abag community advisory

454
00:21:55,480 --> 00:21:57,480
council

455
00:21:58,752 --> 00:22:01,152
[Meeting will begin shortly]

456
00:22:01,421 --> 00:22:02,490
Mtc abag community advisory

457
00:22:02,490 --> 00:22:04,490
council

458
00:22:05,692 --> 00:22:08,920
[Meeting will begin shortly]

459
00:22:09,897 --> 00:22:10,130
Mtc abag community advisory

460
00:22:10,130 --> 00:22:12,130
council

461
00:22:13,600 --> 00:22:16,000
[Meeting will begin shortly]

462
00:22:16,270 --> 00:22:17,304
Mtc abag community advisory

463
00:22:17,304 --> 00:22:19,304
council

464
00:22:19,973 --> 00:22:22,373
[Meeting will begin shortly]

465
00:22:23,143 --> 00:22:24,210
Mtc abag community advisory

466
00:22:24,210 --> 00:22:26,210
council

467
00:22:28,448 --> 00:22:30,848
[Meeting will begin shortly]

468
00:22:31,118 --> 00:22:32,152
Mtc abag community advisory

469
00:22:32,152 --> 00:22:34,152
council

470
00:22:34,888 --> 00:22:37,288
[Meeting will begin shortly]

471
00:22:38,580 --> 00:22:39,920
Mtc abag community advisory

472
00:22:39,920 --> 00:22:41,920
council

473
00:22:42,830 --> 00:22:45,230
[Meeting will begin shortly]

474
00:22:45,465 --> 00:22:46,533
Mtc abag community advisory

475
00:22:46,533 --> 00:22:48,533
council

476
00:22:49,169 --> 00:22:51,569
[Meeting will begin shortly]

477
00:22:52,339 --> 00:22:53,406
Mtc abag community advisory

478
00:22:53,406 --> 00:22:55,406
council

479
00:22:57,110 --> 00:22:59,510
[Meeting will begin shortly]

480
00:22:59,746 --> 00:23:00,814
Mtc abag community advisory

481
00:23:00,814 --> 00:23:02,814
council

482
00:23:03,483 --> 00:23:05,883
[Meeting will begin shortly]

483
00:23:06,686 --> 00:23:07,720
Mtc abag community advisory

484
00:23:07,720 --> 00:23:09,720
council

485
00:23:11,424 --> 00:23:13,824
[Meeting will begin shortly]

486
00:23:15,950 --> 00:23:15,328
Mtc abag community advisory

487
00:23:15,328 --> 00:23:17,328
council

488
00:23:17,764 --> 00:23:20,164
[Meeting will begin shortly]

489
00:23:20,967 --> 00:23:22,100
mtc abag community advisory

490
00:23:22,100 --> 00:23:24,100
council

491
00:23:25,705 --> 00:23:28,105
[Meeting will begin shortly]

492
00:23:28,374 --> 00:23:29,409
Mtc abag community advisory

493
00:23:29,409 --> 00:23:31,409
council

494
00:23:32,450 --> 00:23:34,445
[Meeting will begin shortly]

495
00:23:35,248 --> 00:23:36,315
Mtc abag community advisory

496
00:23:36,315 --> 00:23:38,315
council

497
00:23:40,860 --> 00:23:42,486
[Meeting will begin shortly]

498
00:23:42,756 --> 00:23:43,823
Mtc abag community advisory

499
00:23:43,823 --> 00:23:45,823
council

500
00:23:46,960 --> 00:23:49,360
[Meeting will begin shortly]

501
00:23:49,629 --> 00:23:50,698
Mtc abag community advisory

502
00:23:50,698 --> 00:23:52,698
council

503
00:23:54,367 --> 00:23:56,767
[Meeting will begin shortly]

504
00:23:57,370 --> 00:23:58,104
Mtc abag community advisory

505
00:23:58,104 --> 00:24:00,104
council

506
00:24:00,773 --> 00:24:03,173
[Meeting will begin shortly]

507
00:24:03,944 --> 00:24:05,110
Mtc abag community advisory

508
00:24:05,110 --> 00:24:07,110
council

509
00:24:08,714 --> 00:24:11,114
[Meeting will begin shortly]

510
00:24:11,350 --> 00:24:12,418
Mtc abag community advisory

511
00:24:12,418 --> 00:24:14,418
council

512
00:24:15,880 --> 00:24:17,488
[Meeting will begin shortly]

513
00:24:18,257 --> 00:24:19,358
Mtc abag community advisory

514
00:24:19,358 --> 00:24:21,358
council

515
00:24:23,290 --> 00:24:25,429
[Meeting will begin shortly]

516
00:24:25,665 --> 00:24:26,733
Mtc abag community advisory

517
00:24:26,733 --> 00:24:28,733
council

518
00:24:29,368 --> 00:24:31,768
[Meeting will begin shortly]

519
00:24:32,538 --> 00:24:33,606
Mtc abag community advisory

520
00:24:33,606 --> 00:24:35,606
council

521
00:24:37,843 --> 00:24:40,243
[Meeting will begin shortly]

522
00:24:40,513 --> 00:24:41,580
Mtc abag community advisory

523
00:24:41,580 --> 00:24:43,580
council

524
00:24:44,216 --> 00:24:46,616
[Meeting will begin shortly]

525
00:24:47,386 --> 00:24:48,454
Mtc abag community advisory

526
00:24:48,454 --> 00:24:50,454
council

527
00:24:52,158 --> 00:24:54,558
[Meeting will begin shortly]

528
00:24:54,827 --> 00:24:55,895
Mtc abag community advisory

529
00:24:55,895 --> 00:24:57,895
council

530
00:24:58,564 --> 00:25:00,964
[Meeting will begin shortly]

531
00:25:02,301 --> 00:25:02,835
Mtc abag community advisory

532
00:25:02,835 --> 00:25:04,835
council

533
00:25:06,539 --> 00:25:08,939
[Meeting will begin shortly]

534
00:25:09,208 --> 00:25:10,242
Mtc abag community advisory

535
00:25:10,242 --> 00:25:12,242
council

536
00:25:12,911 --> 00:25:15,311
[Meeting will begin shortly]

537
00:25:16,810 --> 00:25:17,150
Mtc abag community advisory

538
00:25:17,150 --> 00:25:19,150
council

539
00:25:20,853 --> 00:25:23,253
[Meeting will begin shortly]

540
00:25:23,523 --> 00:25:24,556
Mtc abag community advisory

541
00:25:24,556 --> 00:25:26,556
council

542
00:25:41,440 --> 00:25:43,840
[Meeting will begin shortly]

543
00:31:17,374 --> 00:31:17,631
Mtc abag community advisory

544
00:31:17,631 --> 00:31:19,631
council

545
00:31:21,211 --> 00:31:23,611
[Meeting will begin shortly]

546
00:32:15,831 --> 00:32:18,231
Mtc abag community advisory

547
00:32:33,349 --> 00:32:35,349
council

548
00:38:02,542 --> 00:38:03,770
amanda.

549
00:38:03,770 --> 00:38:03,744
Amanda.

550
00:38:03,744 --> 00:38:04,378
>>chair, carina vinh lieu: good

551
00:38:04,378 --> 00:38:05,379
morning looks like we have

552
00:38:05,379 --> 00:38:08,282
quorum. We're going to get

553
00:38:08,282 --> 00:38:09,683
ready to start. Love all the

554
00:38:09,683 --> 00:38:11,683
chatter. Happy friday.

555
00:38:11,953 --> 00:38:14,154
Everyone feels like a friday

556
00:38:14,154 --> 00:38:15,622
doesn't it? So to begin this

557
00:38:15,622 --> 00:38:17,257
meeting is being webcast on the

558
00:38:17,257 --> 00:38:18,492
mtc and abag websites committee

559
00:38:18,492 --> 00:38:20,930
members and members of the

560
00:38:20,930 --> 00:38:22,950
public participating by zoom

561
00:38:22,950 --> 00:38:25,265
wishing to speak should use the

562
00:38:25,265 --> 00:38:28,835
raised hand feature or dial star

563
00:38:28,835 --> 00:38:29,937
nine and you will call upon you

564
00:38:29,937 --> 00:38:31,380
at the appropriate time.

565
00:38:31,380 --> 00:38:32,372
Members of the public

566
00:38:32,372 --> 00:38:35,800
participating by zoom who would

567
00:38:35,800 --> 00:38:36,843
like to give public comment on

568
00:38:36,843 --> 00:38:38,979
any agenda item MAY use the

569
00:38:38,979 --> 00:38:39,813
raised hand feature or dial star

570
00:38:39,813 --> 00:38:41,381
nine. Members of the public in

571
00:38:41,381 --> 00:38:43,317
the boardroom should form a line

572
00:38:43,317 --> 00:38:46,120
near the podium. The clerk will

573
00:38:46,120 --> 00:38:48,688
call upon you to speak. Roll

574
00:38:48,688 --> 00:38:50,758
call vote will be conducted for

575
00:38:50,758 --> 00:38:51,658
agenda action items because of

576
00:38:51,658 --> 00:38:52,526
remote teleconference

577
00:38:52,526 --> 00:38:54,261
participation. I would like to

578
00:38:54,261 --> 00:38:55,863
call this regular meeting of the

579
00:38:55,863 --> 00:38:58,263
mtc abag community advisory

580
00:38:59,165 --> 00:39:02,436
couple to order. Will the clerk

581
00:39:02,436 --> 00:39:04,471
call the roll? Confirm quorum?

582
00:39:04,471 --> 00:39:04,905
>>clerk, jessica lewis: chair

583
00:39:04,905 --> 00:39:05,505
lieu?

584
00:39:05,505 --> 00:39:05,772
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

585
00:39:05,772 --> 00:39:06,373
present.

586
00:39:06,373 --> 00:39:07,574
>>clerk, jessica lewis: vice

587
00:39:07,574 --> 00:39:08,174
chair benitez?

588
00:39:08,174 --> 00:39:08,842
>>v. Chair, diana benitez:

589
00:39:08,842 --> 00:39:09,510
present.

590
00:39:09,510 --> 00:39:11,910
>>clerk, jessica lewis: madrid,

591
00:39:12,779 --> 00:39:15,779
we'll come back. Member chang?

592
00:39:19,686 --> 00:39:21,686
Is absent. Duong?

593
00:39:25,725 --> 00:39:27,725
>>bryant duong: present.

594
00:39:31,197 --> 00:39:32,832
>>clerk, jessica lewis: lavery?

595
00:39:32,832 --> 00:39:35,832
Cantrell? We'll come back to

596
00:39:37,771 --> 00:39:40,771
member hankerson we'll come back

597
00:39:46,246 --> 00:39:48,246
to --

598
00:39:49,315 --> 00:39:51,315
member orantes?

599
00:39:51,784 --> 00:39:53,453
>>gabriela yamilet orantes:

600
00:39:53,453 --> 00:39:55,388
present.

601
00:39:55,388 --> 00:39:57,223
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

602
00:39:57,223 --> 00:39:57,757
trachtenberg?

603
00:39:57,757 --> 00:39:58,240
>>gaetano trachtenberg:

604
00:39:58,240 --> 00:39:58,558
present.

605
00:39:58,558 --> 00:40:00,558
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

606
00:40:03,163 --> 00:40:05,163
saunders? Gerasimenko? Is

607
00:40:05,832 --> 00:40:06,666
absent. Nemsick?

608
00:40:06,666 --> 00:40:08,666
>>karen nemsick: present.

609
00:40:11,471 --> 00:40:13,706
>>clerk, jessica lewis: cha?

610
00:40:13,706 --> 00:40:15,706
>>kathleen cha: present.

611
00:40:15,942 --> 00:40:17,942
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

612
00:40:21,130 --> 00:40:21,280
salazar? We'll come back.

613
00:40:21,280 --> 00:40:22,849
Baldini?

614
00:40:22,849 --> 00:40:24,849
>>michael baldini: present.

615
00:40:25,752 --> 00:40:27,587
>>clerk, jessica lewis: balaji?

616
00:40:27,587 --> 00:40:29,523
>>padma balaji: present.

617
00:40:29,523 --> 00:40:30,900
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

618
00:40:30,900 --> 00:40:31,900
harshfield?

619
00:40:31,900 --> 00:40:33,900
>>peter saathodd-harshfield:

620
00:40:33,959 --> 00:40:35,270
present.

621
00:40:35,270 --> 00:40:36,229
>>clerk, jessica lewis: miles?

622
00:40:36,229 --> 00:40:37,463
>>r. Shay miles: present.

623
00:40:37,463 --> 00:40:39,863
>>clerk, jessica lewis: come

624
00:40:48,808 --> 00:40:50,343
back to shephard. Sbranti?

625
00:40:50,343 --> 00:40:52,245
>>speaker: present.

626
00:40:52,245 --> 00:40:54,245
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

627
00:40:55,470 --> 00:40:56,115
kallins? Is absent. Quorum has

628
00:40:56,115 --> 00:40:56,782
been established.

629
00:40:56,782 --> 00:40:59,652
>>chair, carina vinh lieu: we

630
00:40:59,652 --> 00:41:01,554
have several members requesting

631
00:41:01,554 --> 00:41:03,554
remote participation.

632
00:41:08,940 --> 00:41:09,395
>>speaker:

633
00:41:09,395 --> 00:41:10,996
>>speaker: hi everyone good

634
00:41:10,996 --> 00:41:13,396
morning I'm requesting remote

635
00:41:13,866 --> 00:41:15,340
participation pursuant to the

636
00:41:15,340 --> 00:41:18,340
brown act there isn't anyone

637
00:41:18,737 --> 00:41:18,970
age 18 or older in the room with

638
00:41:18,970 --> 00:41:19,505
me.

639
00:41:19,505 --> 00:41:21,340
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

640
00:41:21,340 --> 00:41:23,542
thank you council member.

641
00:41:23,542 --> 00:41:24,710
Request for remote participation

642
00:41:24,710 --> 00:41:25,544
from chuck cantrell.

643
00:41:25,544 --> 00:41:26,645
>>chuck cantrell: good morning

644
00:41:26,645 --> 00:41:28,547
I'm requesting remote

645
00:41:28,547 --> 00:41:30,716
participation pursuant to the

646
00:41:30,716 --> 00:41:33,720
brown act and there isn't anyone

647
00:41:33,720 --> 00:41:34,587
in the room older than 18 with

648
00:41:34,587 --> 00:41:35,154
me.

649
00:41:35,154 --> 00:41:36,288
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

650
00:41:36,288 --> 00:41:39,288
thank you. Council member miles

651
00:41:40,920 --> 00:41:41,727
we have a request for remote

652
00:41:41,727 --> 00:41:43,727
participation.

653
00:41:44,230 --> 00:41:47,230
>>r. Shay miles: hi council

654
00:41:47,300 --> 00:41:48,767
member r. Shay miles I'm

655
00:41:48,767 --> 00:41:50,235
requesting remote participation

656
00:41:50,235 --> 00:41:52,504
pursuant to the brown act.

657
00:41:52,504 --> 00:41:54,940
There isn't anyone age 18 or

658
00:41:54,940 --> 00:41:56,375
older in the room with me.

659
00:41:56,375 --> 00:41:57,843
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

660
00:41:57,843 --> 00:41:58,211
thank you. Council member

661
00:41:58,211 --> 00:41:58,877
salazar?

662
00:41:58,877 --> 00:42:01,277
>>marlene salazar: good morning

663
00:42:01,280 --> 00:42:02,181
everybody I'm requesting remote

664
00:42:02,181 --> 00:42:03,215
participation pursuant to the

665
00:42:03,215 --> 00:42:06,452
brown act there isn't anyone age

666
00:42:06,452 --> 00:42:07,190
18 or older in the room with me.

667
00:42:07,190 --> 00:42:08,120
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

668
00:42:08,120 --> 00:42:11,120
thank you council member. We

669
00:42:11,590 --> 00:42:12,927
also have a request for remote

670
00:42:12,927 --> 00:42:14,927
participation from council

671
00:42:15,894 --> 00:42:17,950
member dwayne hankerson.

672
00:42:17,950 --> 00:42:19,970
>>dwayne hankerson: I don't

673
00:42:19,970 --> 00:42:20,650
have a script but I'm requesting

674
00:42:20,650 --> 00:42:21,600
remote participating pursuant to

675
00:42:21,600 --> 00:42:23,535
the brown act and there is no

676
00:42:23,535 --> 00:42:24,136
one in the room over 18 with me.

677
00:42:24,136 --> 00:42:25,337
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

678
00:42:25,337 --> 00:42:27,306
thank you council member. And

679
00:42:27,306 --> 00:42:28,206
we have another request for

680
00:42:28,206 --> 00:42:29,741
remote participation from

681
00:42:29,741 --> 00:42:30,776
council member mirante.

682
00:42:30,776 --> 00:42:32,776
Hirudinea hirudinea hey

683
00:42:33,745 --> 00:42:34,513
everyone. Sorry I'm late. I'm

684
00:42:34,513 --> 00:42:35,714
requesting remote participation

685
00:42:35,714 --> 00:42:37,149
pursuant to the brown act.

686
00:42:37,149 --> 00:42:38,450
There is no one over the age of

687
00:42:38,450 --> 00:42:39,500
18 in the room with me.

688
00:42:39,500 --> 00:42:39,751
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

689
00:42:39,751 --> 00:42:41,853
thank you council members. Your

690
00:42:41,853 --> 00:42:44,853
requests are noted. You will

691
00:42:45,223 --> 00:42:47,492
all be marked as present. Will

692
00:42:47,492 --> 00:42:47,859
the clerk read the compensation

693
00:42:47,859 --> 00:42:48,727
announcement?

694
00:42:48,727 --> 00:42:50,695
>>clerk, jessica lewis: as

695
00:42:50,695 --> 00:42:52,832
authorized by state law, I'm

696
00:42:52,832 --> 00:42:54,165
making the following

697
00:42:54,165 --> 00:42:56,334
announcement. Each member of

698
00:42:56,334 --> 00:42:57,636
the mtc abag community advisory

699
00:42:57,636 --> 00:42:59,170
council here today will be

700
00:42:59,170 --> 00:43:01,473
entitled to receive $100 per

701
00:43:01,473 --> 00:43:03,875
meeting attended up to maximum

702
00:43:03,875 --> 00:43:04,976
of 500 per month per agency.

703
00:43:04,976 --> 00:43:07,379
This amount is provided as a

704
00:43:07,379 --> 00:43:08,981
result of convening a meeting of

705
00:43:08,981 --> 00:43:12,581
which each member is entitled to

706
00:43:12,617 --> 00:43:13,218
collect such amount.

707
00:43:13,218 --> 00:43:14,452
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

708
00:43:14,452 --> 00:43:16,555
thank you, MADAM Clerk. Would

709
00:43:16,555 --> 00:43:18,857
you like to use this opportunity

710
00:43:18,857 --> 00:43:21,126
to just mention, like, anything

711
00:43:21,126 --> 00:43:22,727
about the updated process with

712
00:43:22,727 --> 00:43:24,950
stipends or travel

713
00:43:24,950 --> 00:43:26,950
reimbursements? Just for

714
00:43:26,998 --> 00:43:27,298
everyone to be clear on the

715
00:43:27,298 --> 00:43:28,300
process?

716
00:43:28,300 --> 00:43:29,670
>>clerk, jessica lewis: yes,

717
00:43:29,670 --> 00:43:31,200
chair.

718
00:43:31,200 --> 00:43:34,200
We have the reimbursement forms

719
00:43:34,339 --> 00:43:35,840
over by the name plates. So, if

720
00:43:35,840 --> 00:43:36,942
you have any bridge toll

721
00:43:36,942 --> 00:43:39,942
receipts please e-mail them to

722
00:43:40,311 --> 00:43:42,647
me, or if you have -- well, yes,

723
00:43:42,647 --> 00:43:44,820
e-mail them to me, and if you're

724
00:43:44,820 --> 00:43:45,350
parking and you have the receipt

725
00:43:45,350 --> 00:43:47,318
in-person you can provide them

726
00:43:47,318 --> 00:43:48,653
to me directly or you can scan

727
00:43:48,653 --> 00:43:51,222
them and e-mail them to me as

728
00:43:51,222 --> 00:43:52,290
well. And also for stipends I

729
00:43:52,290 --> 00:43:54,292
mark everyone that's present

730
00:43:54,292 --> 00:43:57,292
then provide that to accounting

731
00:43:58,330 --> 00:43:59,530
so no need to put that on the

732
00:43:59,530 --> 00:44:00,865
reimbursement form I will mark

733
00:44:00,865 --> 00:44:02,233
everybody that's present and

734
00:44:02,233 --> 00:44:04,168
provide that to accounting and

735
00:44:04,168 --> 00:44:04,836
from there they will issue the

736
00:44:04,836 --> 00:44:05,503
stipends.

737
00:44:05,503 --> 00:44:07,305
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

738
00:44:07,305 --> 00:44:09,374
thank you so much. We'll move

739
00:44:09,374 --> 00:44:10,775
on to agenda item two which is

740
00:44:10,775 --> 00:44:11,710
for council members to make

741
00:44:11,710 --> 00:44:13,440
announcements. I want to

742
00:44:13,440 --> 00:44:15,513
mention that this is a great

743
00:44:15,513 --> 00:44:18,820
opportunity for any of our

744
00:44:18,820 --> 00:44:19,183
council members in on your

745
00:44:19,183 --> 00:44:20,485
geographic region to share

746
00:44:20,485 --> 00:44:23,870
activities that are going on in

747
00:44:23,870 --> 00:44:24,756
your region and news. So, I

748
00:44:24,756 --> 00:44:26,958
encourage everyone to share and

749
00:44:26,958 --> 00:44:27,992
speak up. Because your

750
00:44:27,992 --> 00:44:29,860
contribution is really valuable.

751
00:44:29,860 --> 00:44:33,564
And we like to hear what's going

752
00:44:33,564 --> 00:44:35,366
on in your area. So, are there

753
00:44:35,366 --> 00:44:37,766
any announcements from council

754
00:44:41,939 --> 00:44:44,939
members? I see member cushman,

755
00:44:47,845 --> 00:44:50,245
member mensic, and member

756
00:44:50,948 --> 00:44:51,382
benitez. I'll start with member

757
00:44:51,382 --> 00:44:52,500
cushman.

758
00:44:52,500 --> 00:44:54,450
>>warren cushman: sounds like

759
00:45:00,900 --> 00:45:01,158
I'm on. Yes, I am. I want to

760
00:45:01,158 --> 00:45:02,594
announce that my agency

761
00:45:02,594 --> 00:45:04,395
community resources for

762
00:45:04,395 --> 00:45:06,330
independent living has a

763
00:45:06,330 --> 00:45:07,799
fundraisinger on SEPTEMBER 26th

764
00:45:07,799 --> 00:45:10,199
which is saturday afternoon

765
00:45:10,534 --> 00:45:13,304
between 12 and 3. If anyone is

766
00:45:13,304 --> 00:45:16,307
interested can go up on our

767
00:45:16,307 --> 00:45:19,307
website and find donations pages

768
00:45:19,343 --> 00:45:20,344
for sponsorships and there are

769
00:45:20,344 --> 00:45:21,779
sponsorships if you're

770
00:45:21,779 --> 00:45:24,179
interested in coming. The

771
00:45:25,816 --> 00:45:28,219
tickets are $15. And again it's

772
00:45:28,219 --> 00:45:30,619
kril hayward, and hayward

773
00:45:33,524 --> 00:45:34,825
offices are at 439, 8th street

774
00:45:34,825 --> 00:45:36,126
in hayward on saturday

775
00:45:36,126 --> 00:45:38,395
SEPTEMBER 26th. And I will be

776
00:45:38,395 --> 00:45:40,131
there. So come on down and have

777
00:45:40,131 --> 00:45:40,698
some fun. Thank you.

778
00:45:40,698 --> 00:45:42,533
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

779
00:45:42,533 --> 00:45:43,401
thank you member cushman.

780
00:45:43,401 --> 00:45:45,401
Member nemsick.

781
00:45:46,170 --> 00:45:49,170
>>karen nemsick: yeah, I wanted

782
00:45:49,173 --> 00:45:50,241
to say that the united way area

783
00:45:50,241 --> 00:45:53,440
joining with the bar association

784
00:45:53,440 --> 00:45:54,611
of san francisco is holding a

785
00:45:54,611 --> 00:45:56,847
community screening in two weeks

786
00:45:56,847 --> 00:46:00,447
on SEPTEMBER 14th at the mission

787
00:46:00,684 --> 00:46:03,684
bay campus ucsf mission bay

788
00:46:03,720 --> 00:46:05,455
campus auditorium this is a

789
00:46:05,455 --> 00:46:07,455
screening of the

790
00:46:07,591 --> 00:46:09,560
documentary "beyond the bridge."

791
00:46:09,560 --> 00:46:11,280
this is a solution to

792
00:46:11,280 --> 00:46:11,862
homelessness type of

793
00:46:11,862 --> 00:46:13,862
documentary, we're really

794
00:46:14,331 --> 00:46:15,900
excited about it we have 26 of

795
00:46:15,900 --> 00:46:17,468
the bay area of san francisco

796
00:46:17,468 --> 00:46:18,802
housing and homelessness

797
00:46:18,802 --> 00:46:21,138
organizations hosting this with

798
00:46:21,138 --> 00:46:22,773
us so it's free. But you do

799
00:46:22,773 --> 00:46:25,420
need to register so come find me

800
00:46:25,420 --> 00:46:28,642
and I will send you an

801
00:46:28,745 --> 00:46:29,313
invitation. So you can register

802
00:46:29,313 --> 00:46:29,913
SEPTEMBER 14th.

803
00:46:29,913 --> 00:46:31,415
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

804
00:46:31,415 --> 00:46:32,983
thank you member nemsick.

805
00:46:32,983 --> 00:46:35,319
Apologies for mispropsing your

806
00:46:35,319 --> 00:46:36,653
name that second time. Council

807
00:46:36,653 --> 00:46:37,654
member benitez?

808
00:46:37,654 --> 00:46:40,654
>>v. Chair, diana benitez: yes,

809
00:46:40,958 --> 00:46:42,860
I want to share a quick update

810
00:46:42,860 --> 00:46:44,762
and I know ky-nam will give more

811
00:46:44,762 --> 00:46:47,264
information but a few weeks ago

812
00:46:47,264 --> 00:46:49,132
we had our first cbo partnership

813
00:46:49,132 --> 00:46:50,434
exchange where a whole bunch of

814
00:46:50,434 --> 00:46:52,135
agencies or things connected

815
00:46:52,135 --> 00:46:55,135
here to this building came

816
00:46:55,239 --> 00:46:57,340
together as well as over 50

817
00:46:57,340 --> 00:46:59,340
participants from different

818
00:47:00,343 --> 00:47:02,379
cbo's and non-profit from across

819
00:47:02,379 --> 00:47:03,881
the bay area and it was really

820
00:47:03,881 --> 00:47:06,500
cool and I want to encourage us

821
00:47:06,500 --> 00:47:08,285
all for future events to join in

822
00:47:08,285 --> 00:47:09,352
and network and I know ky-nam

823
00:47:09,352 --> 00:47:11,721
will share more information but

824
00:47:11,721 --> 00:47:13,156
it was great and I'm excited

825
00:47:13,156 --> 00:47:16,156
that we're continuing this work

826
00:47:16,226 --> 00:47:18,495
and I know I see folks from the

827
00:47:18,495 --> 00:47:20,895
public participation team so

828
00:47:21,197 --> 00:47:23,197
thank you.

829
00:47:23,333 --> 00:47:25,368
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

830
00:47:25,368 --> 00:47:27,470
thank you member benitez.

831
00:47:27,470 --> 00:47:28,272
Member trachtenberg.

832
00:47:28,272 --> 00:47:30,340
>>gaetano trachtenberg: yeah I

833
00:47:30,340 --> 00:47:32,909
want to share briefly about the

834
00:47:32,909 --> 00:47:34,477
upcoming all hands regional

835
00:47:34,477 --> 00:47:36,413
convenience have we talked about

836
00:47:36,413 --> 00:47:38,813
the regional housing stakeholder

837
00:47:39,116 --> 00:47:40,850
committee here yet at this body?

838
00:47:40,850 --> 00:47:42,886
No? Okay. Well this is a

839
00:47:42,886 --> 00:47:44,120
regional convening that is

840
00:47:44,120 --> 00:47:46,356
happening, sort of, in parallel

841
00:47:46,356 --> 00:47:48,491
to the formal process at abag

842
00:47:48,491 --> 00:47:50,593
mtc to help inform a potential

843
00:47:50,593 --> 00:47:52,993
regional housing measure as

844
00:47:53,230 --> 00:47:55,231
early as 2028 there is a number

845
00:47:55,231 --> 00:47:56,532
of us on the council whose

846
00:47:56,532 --> 00:47:58,340
organizations are involved so I

847
00:47:58,340 --> 00:47:59,636
wont get into all the details

848
00:47:59,636 --> 00:48:00,803
but this is around the

849
00:48:00,803 --> 00:48:03,573
possibility of a future bahfa

850
00:48:03,573 --> 00:48:05,208
measure so there is a couple of

851
00:48:05,208 --> 00:48:07,608
upcoming meetings that are

852
00:48:07,810 --> 00:48:11,247
happening one in south bay on

853
00:48:11,247 --> 00:48:14,247
friday SEPTEMBER 25th from 10 to

854
00:48:14,917 --> 00:48:17,520
12 and another east bay friday

855
00:48:17,520 --> 00:48:20,189
OCTOBER 9th from 2:30 to five.

856
00:48:20,189 --> 00:48:21,958
I can send that information out

857
00:48:21,958 --> 00:48:23,460
and these are opportunity for

858
00:48:23,460 --> 00:48:25,161
anyone to come and provide input

859
00:48:25,161 --> 00:48:28,464
about what you would like to see

860
00:48:28,464 --> 00:48:28,798
in the future housing measure.

861
00:48:28,798 --> 00:48:29,399
Thank you.

862
00:48:29,399 --> 00:48:31,799
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

863
00:48:33,202 --> 00:48:33,570
thank you so much member

864
00:48:33,570 --> 00:48:34,103
trachtenberg.

865
00:48:34,103 --> 00:48:36,103
Member wong?

866
00:48:36,372 --> 00:48:37,907
>>janelle wong: thank you I

867
00:48:37,907 --> 00:48:39,475
want to make an announcement to

868
00:48:39,475 --> 00:48:41,875
everyone that SEPTEMBER is

869
00:48:42,545 --> 00:48:45,140
transit month and mtc is a

870
00:48:45,140 --> 00:48:46,582
sponsor of the month it happens

871
00:48:46,582 --> 00:48:48,500
in all nine counties and there

872
00:48:48,500 --> 00:48:49,352
is to knows of a beingtivities

873
00:48:49,352 --> 00:48:51,787
in all of the counties so go and

874
00:48:51,787 --> 00:48:53,256
look locally and see if there is

875
00:48:53,256 --> 00:48:55,791
any fun transit related happy

876
00:48:55,791 --> 00:48:57,560
hours or ride-a-long or others

877
00:48:57,560 --> 00:48:58,527
activities happening to

878
00:48:58,527 --> 00:49:00,927
celebrate transit all agencies

879
00:49:01,130 --> 00:49:02,565
are participating so that's

880
00:49:02,565 --> 00:49:05,534
wonderful in our county I want

881
00:49:05,534 --> 00:49:07,700
to plug the muni heritage so if

882
00:49:07,700 --> 00:49:09,238
you have never seen locally here

883
00:49:09,238 --> 00:49:11,474
in san francisco muni heritage

884
00:49:11,474 --> 00:49:12,875
weekend that's a wonderful

885
00:49:12,875 --> 00:49:15,100
weekend to see the vintage buses

886
00:49:15,100 --> 00:49:16,412
and cars here in san francisco.

887
00:49:16,412 --> 00:49:16,979
Happy transit month everybody.

888
00:49:16,979 --> 00:49:18,514
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

889
00:49:18,514 --> 00:49:21,514
thank you member wong. Are

890
00:49:21,817 --> 00:49:23,520
there other council members?

891
00:49:23,520 --> 00:49:23,720
Baldini?

892
00:49:23,720 --> 00:49:25,287
>>michael baldini: good

893
00:49:25,287 --> 00:49:28,157
morning. Thank you chair. My

894
00:49:28,157 --> 00:49:30,920
commute here this morning again

895
00:49:30,920 --> 00:49:31,994
208 car automobiles and trucks

896
00:49:31,994 --> 00:49:33,896
passed me that were in the

897
00:49:33,896 --> 00:49:35,564
commute lane that I counted and

898
00:49:35,564 --> 00:49:38,564
I'm not a traffic enforcement

899
00:49:39,680 --> 00:49:41,237
just a note and I do have a

900
00:49:41,237 --> 00:49:43,710
counter in the car 181 were in

901
00:49:43,710 --> 00:49:46,710
violation meaning they only had

902
00:49:47,343 --> 00:49:51,480
one person in the vehicle out of

903
00:49:51,480 --> 00:49:53,482
208 a small% that was from the

904
00:49:53,482 --> 00:49:54,816
carquinez bridge to ashby

905
00:49:54,816 --> 00:49:56,785
overpass on interstate 80 cars

906
00:49:56,785 --> 00:49:57,386
that passed me. Thank you.

907
00:49:57,386 --> 00:49:58,954
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

908
00:49:58,954 --> 00:50:00,522
thank you member baldini. If

909
00:50:00,522 --> 00:50:02,925
there are no other announcements

910
00:50:02,925 --> 00:50:04,360
from other council members I

911
00:50:04,360 --> 00:50:06,280
have one announcement that is

912
00:50:06,280 --> 00:50:07,896
just to congratulate member

913
00:50:07,896 --> 00:50:09,831
benitez she is going to be

914
00:50:09,831 --> 00:50:11,800
receiving an award for emerging

915
00:50:11,800 --> 00:50:14,403
planner for the apa northern

916
00:50:14,403 --> 00:50:16,271
california chapter this month.

917
00:50:16,271 --> 00:50:18,207
Congratulations member benitez.

918
00:50:18,207 --> 00:50:20,142
All right. Will the clerk

919
00:50:20,142 --> 00:50:21,610
inform us of public comments

920
00:50:21,610 --> 00:50:22,678
submitted for this item or

921
00:50:22,678 --> 00:50:24,380
whether there are members of the

922
00:50:24,380 --> 00:50:24,646
public who wish to give public

923
00:50:24,646 --> 00:50:25,247
comment.

924
00:50:25,247 --> 00:50:26,214
>>clerk, jessica lewis: we

925
00:50:26,214 --> 00:50:27,550
received no public comments for

926
00:50:27,550 --> 00:50:29,451
it this item there are no

927
00:50:29,451 --> 00:50:31,530
speakers at the podium and no

928
00:50:31,530 --> 00:50:31,987
speakers in the zoom space

929
00:50:31,987 --> 00:50:32,287
requesting to provide public

930
00:50:32,287 --> 00:50:32,854
comment.

931
00:50:32,854 --> 00:50:33,622
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

932
00:50:33,622 --> 00:50:34,957
thank you so much. Next I move

933
00:50:34,957 --> 00:50:37,859
to agenda item three, which is

934
00:50:37,859 --> 00:50:40,296
the chair's report. And this is

935
00:50:40,296 --> 00:50:42,898
just an information item. I

936
00:50:42,898 --> 00:50:44,900
want to, again, welcome all of

937
00:50:44,900 --> 00:50:46,902
our colleagues to this meeting's

938
00:50:46,902 --> 00:50:48,703
-- this morning's meeting.

939
00:50:48,703 --> 00:50:49,404
Additionally, I just want to

940
00:50:49,404 --> 00:50:51,106
thank everyone for their

941
00:50:51,106 --> 00:50:53,750
continued presence and

942
00:50:53,750 --> 00:50:55,475
engagement. I think learning

943
00:50:56,511 --> 00:50:58,447
about mtc MAY feel like a

944
00:50:58,447 --> 00:51:00,847
waterfall of information, and

945
00:51:01,783 --> 00:51:04,850
all the work it takes to figure

946
00:51:04,850 --> 00:51:06,521
out how this place works and all

947
00:51:06,521 --> 00:51:07,489
the information to enable you to

948
00:51:07,489 --> 00:51:09,691
meaningfully engage with this

949
00:51:09,691 --> 00:51:10,893
body is just a lot. So, I want

950
00:51:10,893 --> 00:51:12,361
to thank you all for your

951
00:51:12,361 --> 00:51:13,995
continued service on this body

952
00:51:13,995 --> 00:51:14,896
as well as your patience and

953
00:51:14,896 --> 00:51:16,798
grace. I also want to

954
00:51:16,798 --> 00:51:18,166
acknowledge staff. I think that

955
00:51:18,166 --> 00:51:19,568
you all have been very

956
00:51:19,568 --> 00:51:21,670
responsive to the questions and

957
00:51:21,670 --> 00:51:24,205
concerns raised on this dais.

958
00:51:24,205 --> 00:51:27,309
And I'm really happy that we get

959
00:51:27,309 --> 00:51:29,711
to work together this time. And

960
00:51:29,711 --> 00:51:33,311
ky-nam, I want to commend you

961
00:51:35,517 --> 00:51:37,180
for a really great staff liaison

962
00:51:37,180 --> 00:51:40,180
report. It's very thorough so

963
00:51:40,388 --> 00:51:41,560
lots of updates in there. Great

964
00:51:41,560 --> 00:51:43,910
information. Thank you so much

965
00:51:43,910 --> 00:51:45,661
for that. And jessica I'm not

966
00:51:45,661 --> 00:51:47,262
sure that I have thanked you and

967
00:51:47,262 --> 00:51:48,496
welcomed on you to this board.

968
00:51:48,496 --> 00:51:50,498
But thanks for coming in in the

969
00:51:50,498 --> 00:51:53,101
middle of our term and getting

970
00:51:53,101 --> 00:51:54,569
things going and keeping things

971
00:51:54,569 --> 00:51:56,969
really smooth. Appreciate you.

972
00:51:58,507 --> 00:52:01,420
Then on that note, also knowing

973
00:52:01,420 --> 00:52:02,910
that this body can have a lot of

974
00:52:02,910 --> 00:52:04,912
information, I want to just

975
00:52:04,912 --> 00:52:07,482
remind us to participate, so if

976
00:52:07,482 --> 00:52:08,483
anything is unclear, or if

977
00:52:08,483 --> 00:52:10,318
information is new, I don't

978
00:52:10,318 --> 00:52:11,953
think there is any silly

979
00:52:11,953 --> 00:52:14,155
questions. I encourage everyone

980
00:52:14,155 --> 00:52:15,590
to keep asking questions for

981
00:52:15,590 --> 00:52:17,925
clarification. One thing our

982
00:52:17,925 --> 00:52:19,161
former clerk martha said that I

983
00:52:19,161 --> 00:52:20,595
still remember is you're on this

984
00:52:20,595 --> 00:52:23,364
council for your mind and how

985
00:52:23,364 --> 00:52:25,633
your mind thinks. So, please to

986
00:52:25,633 --> 00:52:27,568
not hesitate to bring all of

987
00:52:27,568 --> 00:52:28,870
your mind and all the questions

988
00:52:28,870 --> 00:52:30,400
and the ways that your mind

989
00:52:30,400 --> 00:52:32,807
works into this council to

990
00:52:32,807 --> 00:52:34,807
better this council.

991
00:52:36,770 --> 00:52:39,770
There are a couple upcoming

992
00:52:39,447 --> 00:52:41,116
opportunities that I want to

993
00:52:41,116 --> 00:52:43,985
mention. So, there has been

994
00:52:43,985 --> 00:52:46,200
talk on this council about an

995
00:52:46,200 --> 00:52:46,854
opportunity to meet our abag

996
00:52:46,854 --> 00:52:48,990
executive board members and our

997
00:52:48,990 --> 00:52:51,726
mtc commissioners. And so there

998
00:52:51,726 --> 00:52:54,726
will be an upcoming opportunity

999
00:52:54,729 --> 00:52:56,697
for us to do that on

1000
00:52:56,697 --> 00:52:59,697
OCTOBER 29th. There is a

1001
00:53:04,887 --> 00:53:05,200
breakfast convening that will be

1002
00:53:05,200 --> 00:53:05,421
held here at the bay area metro

1003
00:53:05,421 --> 00:53:08,421
center. There will be breakfast

1004
00:53:09,710 --> 00:53:12,110
scheduled for 9:00 A.M.

1005
00:53:17,843 --> 00:53:18,750
Interested council members

1006
00:53:18,750 --> 00:53:18,250
should rsvp to the clerk,

1007
00:53:18,250 --> 00:53:18,415
jessica. There will be

1008
00:53:18,415 --> 00:53:18,599
opportunities after -- so, the

1009
00:53:18,599 --> 00:53:20,521
breakfast, you can network with

1010
00:53:20,521 --> 00:53:22,390
all of the board members and the

1011
00:53:22,390 --> 00:53:23,691
executive members. And then

1012
00:53:23,691 --> 00:53:24,925
there will be opportunity to

1013
00:53:24,925 --> 00:53:27,728
stay and observe the workshop,

1014
00:53:27,728 --> 00:53:29,430
which will focus on kicking off

1015
00:53:29,430 --> 00:53:32,430
the planned bay area 2060. And

1016
00:53:32,900 --> 00:53:34,101
there will be lots of, like,

1017
00:53:34,101 --> 00:53:34,969
local experts who can kind of

1018
00:53:34,969 --> 00:53:37,370
share information that will

1019
00:53:37,370 --> 00:53:38,505
inform the plan. So, it's a

1020
00:53:38,505 --> 00:53:39,840
really great opportunity to get

1021
00:53:39,840 --> 00:53:42,510
the same information as the

1022
00:53:42,510 --> 00:53:44,445
board, as well as network. So,

1023
00:53:44,445 --> 00:53:47,876
I think staff will be sending

1024
00:53:47,876 --> 00:53:50,876
out more information about that,

1025
00:53:55,129 --> 00:53:55,296
as well.

1026
00:53:55,296 --> 00:53:55,461
And then I -- I also want to

1027
00:53:55,461 --> 00:53:55,756
mention that the accessible

1028
00:53:55,756 --> 00:53:57,925
futures report will be released

1029
00:53:57,925 --> 00:53:59,927
quite soon. I think staff will

1030
00:53:59,927 --> 00:54:01,595
be e-mailing that out to

1031
00:54:01,595 --> 00:54:03,997
everyone. And staff has also

1032
00:54:03,997 --> 00:54:06,330
identified someone to come and

1033
00:54:06,330 --> 00:54:08,100
present at a future meeting.

1034
00:54:08,100 --> 00:54:09,670
So, that will be coming up soon.

1035
00:54:09,670 --> 00:54:11,400
I think we're looking at maybe

1036
00:54:11,400 --> 00:54:13,807
two or three meetings out from

1037
00:54:13,807 --> 00:54:15,576
today.

1038
00:54:15,576 --> 00:54:18,345
Also, we have been talking about

1039
00:54:18,345 --> 00:54:20,347
housing as a topic, and there is

1040
00:54:20,347 --> 00:54:21,816
also a housing presenter who has

1041
00:54:21,816 --> 00:54:24,551
been identified, who will be

1042
00:54:24,551 --> 00:54:26,853
coming to the council to present

1043
00:54:26,853 --> 00:54:28,853
about housing.

1044
00:54:31,325 --> 00:54:35,525
And then, as far as, like, an

1045
00:54:35,830 --> 00:54:38,598
opportunity to participate at an

1046
00:54:38,598 --> 00:54:41,168
-- committee level, or to be

1047
00:54:41,168 --> 00:54:41,902
volunteer to be on an advisory

1048
00:54:41,902 --> 00:54:43,270
group, there will be

1049
00:54:43,270 --> 00:54:44,404
opportunities next spring. If

1050
00:54:44,404 --> 00:54:46,404
that's something you're

1051
00:54:46,573 --> 00:54:48,442
interested in, definitely feel

1052
00:54:48,442 --> 00:54:51,579
free to reach out any time

1053
00:54:51,579 --> 00:54:53,680
between now and DECEMBER. So

1054
00:54:53,680 --> 00:54:54,849
just let me or vice chair

1055
00:54:54,849 --> 00:54:55,449
benitez know about your

1056
00:54:55,449 --> 00:54:57,500
interest.

1057
00:54:57,500 --> 00:54:58,385
And then, finally, with the

1058
00:54:58,385 --> 00:54:59,586
equity priority communities, the

1059
00:54:59,586 --> 00:55:02,456
staff has also expressed an

1060
00:55:02,456 --> 00:55:04,457
interest in convening a small

1061
00:55:04,457 --> 00:55:05,992
kitchen cabinet for members who

1062
00:55:05,992 --> 00:55:06,827
are interested in working on

1063
00:55:06,827 --> 00:55:08,827
equity priority communities.

1064
00:55:09,262 --> 00:55:11,598
And, so, that would also convene

1065
00:55:11,598 --> 00:55:13,133
early next spring. Again, if

1066
00:55:13,133 --> 00:55:14,801
that's something you feel

1067
00:55:14,801 --> 00:55:17,801
interested in, and you would

1068
00:55:19,706 --> 00:55:22,842
like to participate in that, let

1069
00:55:22,842 --> 00:55:24,945
both, or either of us know, vice

1070
00:55:24,945 --> 00:55:26,479
chair benitez and myself, and we

1071
00:55:26,479 --> 00:55:27,414
would be happy to coordinate

1072
00:55:27,414 --> 00:55:29,414
that.

1073
00:55:29,950 --> 00:55:31,951
So, this concludes the chair's

1074
00:55:31,951 --> 00:55:34,951
report. Is there any council

1075
00:55:37,257 --> 00:55:39,257
member discussion?

1076
00:55:49,302 --> 00:55:51,302
Council member cushman?

1077
00:55:53,473 --> 00:55:54,974
>>warren cushman: are we on?

1078
00:55:54,974 --> 00:55:57,143
Okay. Just a quick question

1079
00:55:57,143 --> 00:55:59,145
around accessible futures. You

1080
00:55:59,145 --> 00:56:00,913
had said, chair lieu, that the

1081
00:56:00,913 --> 00:56:02,482
staff is going to identify

1082
00:56:02,482 --> 00:56:04,717
someone to present at some

1083
00:56:04,717 --> 00:56:06,486
point, there has been some

1084
00:56:06,486 --> 00:56:09,188
confusion around this in the

1085
00:56:09,188 --> 00:56:10,890
community, so I'm wondering is

1086
00:56:10,890 --> 00:56:12,759
there a consideration with staff

1087
00:56:12,759 --> 00:56:15,795
and the chair and vice chair to

1088
00:56:15,795 --> 00:56:16,996
also to some, sort of, kitchen

1089
00:56:16,996 --> 00:56:18,164
cabinet or some, sort of,

1090
00:56:18,164 --> 00:56:19,198
placeholder where the disability

1091
00:56:19,198 --> 00:56:20,667
community on this council can

1092
00:56:20,667 --> 00:56:21,902
interact with staff and others

1093
00:56:21,902 --> 00:56:24,700
in the community around this.

1094
00:56:24,700 --> 00:56:25,405
It's really important. I hope

1095
00:56:25,405 --> 00:56:27,730
that is around consideration.

1096
00:56:27,730 --> 00:56:29,730
Thank you.

1097
00:56:29,976 --> 00:56:32,612
>>matt maloney: I can respond.

1098
00:56:32,612 --> 00:56:34,280
Through the chair. Matt maloney

1099
00:56:34,280 --> 00:56:35,514
deputy executive director metro

1100
00:56:35,514 --> 00:56:39,114
planning and policy. I think we

1101
00:56:39,719 --> 00:56:43,890
can bring that back, warren, and

1102
00:56:43,890 --> 00:56:44,557
discuss. I think that's a good

1103
00:56:44,557 --> 00:56:46,359
idea at this point in time.

1104
00:56:46,359 --> 00:56:48,861
What we're trying to do first is

1105
00:56:48,861 --> 00:56:51,197
to engage the advisory group

1106
00:56:51,197 --> 00:56:53,132
that was assembled to help guide

1107
00:56:53,132 --> 00:56:54,533
the first conference, the

1108
00:56:54,533 --> 00:56:55,968
accessible futures conference,

1109
00:56:55,968 --> 00:56:57,970
which I think you're a part of

1110
00:56:57,970 --> 00:57:01,700
that, and so it's a small group

1111
00:57:01,700 --> 00:57:02,341
of about ten or 12 folks. Sos I

1112
00:57:02,341 --> 00:57:04,143
think the idea of moving forward

1113
00:57:04,143 --> 00:57:05,944
right now is to start with that

1114
00:57:05,944 --> 00:57:07,213
group. Kind of take a look at

1115
00:57:07,213 --> 00:57:08,848
the report and discuss the

1116
00:57:08,848 --> 00:57:10,583
report and make sure that the

1117
00:57:10,583 --> 00:57:12,318
report is, sort of, hitting the

1118
00:57:12,318 --> 00:57:14,787
right notes and I think moving

1119
00:57:14,787 --> 00:57:16,789
forward from there I think we

1120
00:57:16,789 --> 00:57:18,190
should consider how the council

1121
00:57:18,190 --> 00:57:19,792
is involved in accessibility

1122
00:57:19,792 --> 00:57:21,794
issues writ large and assembling

1123
00:57:21,794 --> 00:57:23,696
a kitchen cabinet of members

1124
00:57:23,696 --> 00:57:25,631
might be one way to do that, but

1125
00:57:25,631 --> 00:57:27,766
I also suggest we think about

1126
00:57:27,766 --> 00:57:28,367
what options there are.

1127
00:57:28,367 --> 00:57:30,767
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1128
00:57:30,936 --> 00:57:31,837
thank you, matt. Member

1129
00:57:31,837 --> 00:57:32,271
hankerson, you have your hand

1130
00:57:32,271 --> 00:57:34,206
up?

1131
00:57:34,206 --> 00:57:37,206
>>dwayne hankerson: I wanted to

1132
00:57:37,342 --> 00:57:40,512
ask a quick question. On some

1133
00:57:40,512 --> 00:57:42,181
of the committees, will both the

1134
00:57:42,181 --> 00:57:44,160
chair and vice chair recommend

1135
00:57:44,160 --> 00:57:45,818
people and let them know that

1136
00:57:45,818 --> 00:57:46,518
they want them to be a part of

1137
00:57:46,518 --> 00:57:47,850
that committee?

1138
00:57:47,850 --> 00:57:47,686
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1139
00:57:47,686 --> 00:57:48,687
thanks for the question. I

1140
00:57:48,687 --> 00:57:51,230
think the process we're going to

1141
00:57:51,230 --> 00:57:52,459
look at is, one, we're going to

1142
00:57:52,459 --> 00:57:53,692
look at the whole council. And

1143
00:57:53,692 --> 00:57:55,227
if there is somebody who is

1144
00:57:55,227 --> 00:57:56,195
already on a body, like, for

1145
00:57:56,195 --> 00:57:58,195
example, regional network

1146
00:57:58,564 --> 00:58:00,198
management is a body that we

1147
00:58:00,198 --> 00:58:02,201
have already pointed people to,

1148
00:58:02,201 --> 00:58:03,635
then we might look at the whole

1149
00:58:03,635 --> 00:58:04,804
and say, if you are interested

1150
00:58:04,804 --> 00:58:07,105
in moving off of that committee

1151
00:58:07,105 --> 00:58:09,574
and joining a different one, we

1152
00:58:09,574 --> 00:58:11,476
could, you know, look at that.

1153
00:58:11,476 --> 00:58:12,878
So, the idea that we would want

1154
00:58:12,878 --> 00:58:14,413
to balance the participation of

1155
00:58:14,413 --> 00:58:16,480
all council members on the

1156
00:58:16,480 --> 00:58:18,483
different committees and give as

1157
00:58:18,483 --> 00:58:20,852
many people an opportunity as

1158
00:58:20,852 --> 00:58:23,252
possible to participate. So,

1159
00:58:23,789 --> 00:58:26,424
the idea is if you let us know

1160
00:58:26,424 --> 00:58:28,193
-- the sooner you let us know,

1161
00:58:28,193 --> 00:58:30,950
we can kind of get, like, a

1162
00:58:30,950 --> 00:58:32,764
picture of what people are

1163
00:58:32,764 --> 00:58:34,332
interested in. We also balance

1164
00:58:34,332 --> 00:58:36,732
geography and the interest

1165
00:58:36,768 --> 00:58:39,671
groups that people represent on

1166
00:58:39,671 --> 00:58:42,671
the different bodies just to

1167
00:58:43,709 --> 00:58:45,430
make sure that all the

1168
00:58:45,430 --> 00:58:47,443
perspectives represent on the

1169
00:58:47,446 --> 00:58:49,281
bodies are balanced in those

1170
00:58:49,281 --> 00:58:50,810
ways as well.

1171
00:58:50,810 --> 00:58:51,383
>>dwayne hankerson: one of the

1172
00:58:51,383 --> 00:58:54,453
reasons I asked the question is

1173
00:58:54,453 --> 00:58:56,188
because all the committees need

1174
00:58:56,188 --> 00:58:57,889
to be manned. And some of us,

1175
00:58:57,889 --> 00:59:00,992
like, have our schedules so that

1176
00:59:00,992 --> 00:59:03,128
we can attend the meetings. But

1177
00:59:03,128 --> 00:59:04,696
that was really the reason I

1178
00:59:04,696 --> 00:59:05,297
askeds are because -- thank you.

1179
00:59:05,297 --> 00:59:06,298
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1180
00:59:06,298 --> 00:59:08,990
thank you for the question. I

1181
00:59:08,990 --> 00:59:09,601
think that's a fair point,

1182
00:59:09,601 --> 00:59:12,601
especially since some of these

1183
00:59:12,971 --> 00:59:15,971
MAY not convene until early

1184
00:59:18,111 --> 00:59:22,311
spring. It's -- we're -- it's a

1185
00:59:22,347 --> 00:59:23,782
heads up, hi, there maybe some

1186
00:59:23,782 --> 00:59:25,117
committee opportunities to

1187
00:59:25,117 --> 00:59:26,251
participate and then I think

1188
00:59:26,251 --> 00:59:27,986
once more information comes

1189
00:59:27,986 --> 00:59:30,322
about timing we can share with

1190
00:59:30,322 --> 00:59:33,910
people. I think as far as I

1191
00:59:33,910 --> 00:59:35,261
know, the epc subcommittee would

1192
00:59:35,261 --> 00:59:37,663
meet perhaps once a month for a

1193
00:59:37,663 --> 00:59:39,464
couple months in 2027. And then

1194
00:59:39,464 --> 00:59:40,165
not too sure about how the

1195
00:59:40,165 --> 00:59:42,401
delegates to the housing groups

1196
00:59:42,401 --> 00:59:43,702
would work, but once we have

1197
00:59:43,702 --> 00:59:45,303
more information, we'll

1198
00:59:45,303 --> 00:59:47,105
definitely share back out for

1199
00:59:47,105 --> 00:59:49,105
transparency sake. We

1200
00:59:49,174 --> 00:59:51,543
definitely want people to make

1201
00:59:51,543 --> 00:59:53,111
an informed decision. All

1202
00:59:53,111 --> 00:59:55,511
right. Any other council

1203
00:59:57,382 --> 00:59:59,584
members with comments? Okay.

1204
00:59:59,584 --> 01:00:00,852
Will the clerk let us know if

1205
01:00:00,852 --> 01:00:02,789
there is any public comments

1206
01:00:02,789 --> 01:00:03,722
submitted for this item? Or

1207
01:00:03,722 --> 01:00:05,924
whether any members of the

1208
01:00:05,924 --> 01:00:08,226
public would like to provide

1209
01:00:08,226 --> 01:00:08,994
public comment?

1210
01:00:08,994 --> 01:00:10,162
>>clerk, jessica lewis: we

1211
01:00:10,162 --> 01:00:11,931
received no written public

1212
01:00:11,931 --> 01:00:14,766
comments in item. There are no

1213
01:00:14,766 --> 01:00:16,602
speakers at the podium and no

1214
01:00:16,602 --> 01:00:17,502
raised hands in the zoom space

1215
01:00:17,502 --> 01:00:17,803
requesting to provide public

1216
01:00:17,803 --> 01:00:18,403
comment.

1217
01:00:18,403 --> 01:00:19,700
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1218
01:00:19,700 --> 01:00:20,972
thank you. We'll move on to

1219
01:00:20,972 --> 01:00:22,809
agenda item four, which is the

1220
01:00:22,809 --> 01:00:25,610
consent calendar. This is an

1221
01:00:25,610 --> 01:00:27,512
mtc abag community advisory

1222
01:00:27,512 --> 01:00:29,314
council action item. And this

1223
01:00:29,314 --> 01:00:31,349
includes the approval of our

1224
01:00:31,349 --> 01:00:33,218
minutes from our AUGUST 7th

1225
01:00:33,218 --> 01:00:37,418
meeting. Do I have a motion and

1226
01:00:40,625 --> 01:00:41,930
a second to approve the consent

1227
01:00:41,930 --> 01:00:43,930
calendar?

1228
01:00:43,528 --> 01:00:45,928
>>speaker: move to approve.

1229
01:00:46,331 --> 01:00:46,598
>>michael baldini: baldini

1230
01:00:46,598 --> 01:00:47,365
seconds.

1231
01:00:47,365 --> 01:00:49,602
>>chair, carina vinh lieu: who

1232
01:00:49,602 --> 01:00:51,369
moved it?

1233
01:00:51,369 --> 01:00:51,970
>>joshua saunders: josh.

1234
01:00:51,970 --> 01:00:53,720
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1235
01:00:53,720 --> 01:00:55,240
member saunders made the motion

1236
01:00:55,240 --> 01:00:56,442
seconded by member baldini. Is

1237
01:00:56,442 --> 01:00:58,842
there any council member

1238
01:00:59,143 --> 01:01:00,713
discussion? Okay seeing no hand

1239
01:01:00,713 --> 01:01:01,780
raised. Will the clerk inform

1240
01:01:01,780 --> 01:01:03,480
us if any public comments

1241
01:01:03,480 --> 01:01:04,820
submitted for this item or

1242
01:01:04,820 --> 01:01:06,618
whether there are members of the

1243
01:01:06,618 --> 01:01:07,520
public who wish to give public

1244
01:01:07,520 --> 01:01:07,652
comment?

1245
01:01:07,652 --> 01:01:08,920
>>clerk, jessica lewis: we

1246
01:01:08,920 --> 01:01:09,921
received no written public

1247
01:01:09,921 --> 01:01:12,390
comments for this item there are

1248
01:01:12,390 --> 01:01:14,960
no speakers at the podium and no

1249
01:01:14,960 --> 01:01:16,962
raised hands in the zoom space

1250
01:01:16,962 --> 01:01:17,230
requesting to provide public

1251
01:01:17,230 --> 01:01:17,828
comment.

1252
01:01:17,828 --> 01:01:20,228
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1253
01:01:20,298 --> 01:01:21,434
thank you. Will you please

1254
01:01:21,434 --> 01:01:22,100
conduct roll call vote.

1255
01:01:22,100 --> 01:01:24,500
>>clerk, jessica lewis: motion

1256
01:01:25,670 --> 01:01:26,471
by saunders second by baldini.

1257
01:01:26,471 --> 01:01:27,272
Chair lieu?

1258
01:01:27,272 --> 01:01:27,873
>>chair, carina vinh lieu: yes.

1259
01:01:27,873 --> 01:01:29,407
>>clerk, jessica lewis: vice

1260
01:01:29,407 --> 01:01:30,410
chair benitez?

1261
01:01:30,410 --> 01:01:30,710
>>v. Chair, diana benitez: yes.

1262
01:01:30,710 --> 01:01:33,110
>>clerk, jessica lewis: madrid

1263
01:01:34,746 --> 01:01:37,182
is absent. Chang is absent.

1264
01:01:37,182 --> 01:01:38,483
Madrid?

1265
01:01:38,483 --> 01:01:40,483
>>alexander madrid: yes.

1266
01:01:41,988 --> 01:01:44,880
>>clerk, jessica lewis: duong?

1267
01:01:44,880 --> 01:01:45,657
>>bryant duong: yes.

1268
01:01:45,657 --> 01:01:48,570
>>clerk, jessica lewis: lavery?

1269
01:01:48,528 --> 01:01:49,929
Cantrell? Hankerson?

1270
01:01:49,929 --> 01:01:52,329
>>dwayne hankerson: I abstain.

1271
01:01:52,430 --> 01:01:53,598
I wasn't here.

1272
01:01:53,598 --> 01:01:55,467
>>clerk, jessica lewis: member

1273
01:01:55,467 --> 01:01:56,334
orantes?

1274
01:01:56,334 --> 01:01:56,535
>>gabriela yamilet orantes:

1275
01:01:56,535 --> 01:01:57,169
yes.

1276
01:01:57,169 --> 01:01:57,535
>>clerk, jessica lewis: tract

1277
01:01:57,535 --> 01:01:58,870
app berg?

1278
01:01:58,870 --> 01:02:00,571
>>gaetano trachtenberg: yes.

1279
01:02:00,571 --> 01:02:01,840
>>clerk, jessica lewis: wong?

1280
01:02:01,840 --> 01:02:03,141
>>janelle wong: yes.

1281
01:02:03,141 --> 01:02:04,543
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1282
01:02:04,543 --> 01:02:06,543
saunders?

1283
01:02:08,212 --> 01:02:09,150
>>joshua saunders: yes.

1284
01:02:09,150 --> 01:02:11,150
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1285
01:02:11,183 --> 01:02:12,516
gerasimenko? Is absent.

1286
01:02:12,516 --> 01:02:14,516
Nemsick?

1287
01:02:14,753 --> 01:02:16,753
>>karen nemsick: yes.

1288
01:02:17,122 --> 01:02:17,857
>>clerk, jessica lewis: cha?

1289
01:02:17,857 --> 01:02:18,956
>>kathleen cha: yes.

1290
01:02:18,956 --> 01:02:19,592
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1291
01:02:19,592 --> 01:02:20,591
mirante?

1292
01:02:20,591 --> 01:02:21,592
>>louis mirante: yes.

1293
01:02:21,592 --> 01:02:22,127
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1294
01:02:22,127 --> 01:02:22,861
salazar?

1295
01:02:22,861 --> 01:02:24,396
>>marlene salazar: yes.

1296
01:02:24,396 --> 01:02:25,530
>>clerk, jessica lewis: member

1297
01:02:25,530 --> 01:02:26,231
baldini?

1298
01:02:26,231 --> 01:02:28,231
>>michael baldini: yes.

1299
01:02:28,632 --> 01:02:29,301
>>clerk, jessica lewis: member

1300
01:02:29,301 --> 01:02:30,601
balaji?

1301
01:02:30,601 --> 01:02:32,601
>>padma balaji: yes.

1302
01:02:33,606 --> 01:02:36,600
>>clerk, jessica lewis: member

1303
01:02:36,842 --> 01:02:37,509
sat of harshfield?

1304
01:02:37,509 --> 01:02:37,709
>>peter saathodd-harshfield:

1305
01:02:37,709 --> 01:02:38,742
yes.

1306
01:02:38,742 --> 01:02:39,443
>>clerk, jessica lewis: r. Shay

1307
01:02:39,443 --> 01:02:40,479
miles?

1308
01:02:40,479 --> 01:02:41,120
>>r. Shay miles: yes.

1309
01:02:41,120 --> 01:02:42,481
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1310
01:02:42,481 --> 01:02:43,883
shephard?

1311
01:02:43,883 --> 01:02:45,883
>>sonja shephard: yes.

1312
01:02:45,985 --> 01:02:47,985
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1313
01:02:48,820 --> 01:02:49,921
sbranti?

1314
01:02:49,921 --> 01:02:51,921
>>speaker: yes.

1315
01:02:52,992 --> 01:02:53,592
>>clerk, jessica lewis: arvelo?

1316
01:02:53,592 --> 01:02:54,392
>>victorina arevelo: yes.

1317
01:02:54,392 --> 01:02:54,826
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1318
01:02:54,826 --> 01:02:55,360
cushman?

1319
01:02:55,360 --> 01:02:56,361
>>warren cushman: yes.

1320
01:02:56,361 --> 01:02:58,361
>>clerk, jessica lewis:

1321
01:02:58,631 --> 01:03:00,699
kallins? Is absent. With one

1322
01:03:00,699 --> 01:03:01,299
abstention, the motion passes.

1323
01:03:01,299 --> 01:03:02,466
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1324
01:03:02,466 --> 01:03:05,337
thank you so much. We'll now

1325
01:03:05,337 --> 01:03:07,500
move on to agenda item 5a, which

1326
01:03:07,500 --> 01:03:09,405
is planned bay area 2060,

1327
01:03:09,407 --> 01:03:11,807
OCTOBER 2026 kickoff. This is

1328
01:03:12,545 --> 01:03:13,912
an information item. I just

1329
01:03:13,912 --> 01:03:17,512
want to mention for the council,

1330
01:03:18,830 --> 01:03:22,870
we -- because we are in the kind

1331
01:03:22,870 --> 01:03:23,389
of opportunity -- opportunist --

1332
01:03:23,389 --> 01:03:24,991
opportunity -- wow -- in the

1333
01:03:24,991 --> 01:03:26,292
phase where we have an

1334
01:03:26,292 --> 01:03:27,793
opportunity to provide comment

1335
01:03:27,793 --> 01:03:29,962
on the shaping of planned bay

1336
01:03:29,962 --> 01:03:31,996
area 2060, we will continuously

1337
01:03:31,996 --> 01:03:33,765
receive various updates on this

1338
01:03:33,765 --> 01:03:35,434
topic. And so today we'll

1339
01:03:35,434 --> 01:03:37,202
receive the report from staff

1340
01:03:37,202 --> 01:03:40,202
member chirag rabari, and I'll

1341
01:03:46,812 --> 01:03:48,130
turn it over to you. Thank you.

1342
01:03:48,130 --> 01:03:49,848
>>chirag rabari: thank you

1343
01:03:49,848 --> 01:03:51,490
chair lieu and good morning

1344
01:03:51,490 --> 01:03:53,449
everyone. Chirag rabari I'm

1345
01:03:53,919 --> 01:03:56,319
assistant director of major

1346
01:03:56,555 --> 01:03:57,856
plans and mtc abag regional

1347
01:03:57,856 --> 01:04:00,856
planning program. Last we came

1348
01:04:01,920 --> 01:04:01,960
to this body in MAY to share key

1349
01:04:01,960 --> 01:04:03,628
opportunities early and planning

1350
01:04:03,628 --> 01:04:06,280
priorities identified for mtc

1351
01:04:06,298 --> 01:04:07,699
abag's long range plan update.

1352
01:04:07,699 --> 01:04:08,767
And the council had thoughtful

1353
01:04:08,767 --> 01:04:11,471
discussion at that time. Since

1354
01:04:11,471 --> 01:04:12,204
then parallel to the public

1355
01:04:12,204 --> 01:04:14,372
participation plan update you're

1356
01:04:14,372 --> 01:04:16,274
going to be hearing more about

1357
01:04:16,274 --> 01:04:18,110
later we have been considering

1358
01:04:18,110 --> 01:04:19,644
feedback from some of our more

1359
01:04:19,644 --> 01:04:22,644
technical partners as well as

1360
01:04:23,316 --> 01:04:25,484
our elected officials as we work

1361
01:04:25,484 --> 01:04:26,985
to finalize a proposed scope.

1362
01:04:26,985 --> 01:04:29,287
So consider this a preview of

1363
01:04:29,287 --> 01:04:32,900
what we plan to share next month

1364
01:04:32,900 --> 01:04:33,191
as part of the formal kickoff of

1365
01:04:33,191 --> 01:04:34,759
planned bay area 2060 to be

1366
01:04:34,759 --> 01:04:36,128
followed by first round of

1367
01:04:36,128 --> 01:04:37,295
engagement and I will definitely

1368
01:04:37,295 --> 01:04:38,797
endorse the chair comment you

1369
01:04:38,797 --> 01:04:42,330
will be seeing our team a lot

1370
01:04:42,330 --> 01:04:42,467
over the next few years. Next

1371
01:04:42,467 --> 01:04:44,437
slide.

1372
01:04:44,437 --> 01:04:47,540
Before we look too far ahead,

1373
01:04:47,540 --> 01:04:49,241
it's worth a quick stop at our

1374
01:04:49,241 --> 01:04:51,420
current long range plan, planned

1375
01:04:51,420 --> 01:04:52,611
bay area 2050+ which was

1376
01:04:52,611 --> 01:04:54,800
approved unanimously by mtc and

1377
01:04:54,800 --> 01:04:56,140
abag just six months ago. On

1378
01:04:56,140 --> 01:04:59,851
that front, we do have good news

1379
01:04:59,851 --> 01:05:03,289
to share, which is that it has

1380
01:05:03,289 --> 01:05:05,690
secured all of the approvals it

1381
01:05:05,690 --> 01:05:08,294
needs to act as our approved

1382
01:05:08,294 --> 01:05:10,280
long range plan. So that

1383
01:05:10,280 --> 01:05:13,280
includes approval by our state

1384
01:05:13,632 --> 01:05:15,667
partners, as well as federal

1385
01:05:15,667 --> 01:05:17,136
partners, and it also passed

1386
01:05:17,136 --> 01:05:19,204
through the ceqa challenge

1387
01:05:19,204 --> 01:05:21,506
window without any lawsuits.

1388
01:05:21,506 --> 01:05:23,809
So, although planned bay area

1389
01:05:23,809 --> 01:05:26,809
2050+ is now in the rear-view

1390
01:05:28,680 --> 01:05:30,150
mirror as a process, it does and

1391
01:05:30,150 --> 01:05:32,150
will remain our currently

1392
01:05:32,150 --> 01:05:33,718
adopted long range plan through

1393
01:05:33,718 --> 01:05:37,318
the year 2030 and as such will

1394
01:05:37,923 --> 01:05:40,959
be the focus and benchmark for

1395
01:05:40,959 --> 01:05:42,794
mtc abag's ongoing

1396
01:05:42,794 --> 01:05:44,794
implementation efforts. Next

1397
01:05:45,397 --> 01:05:46,965
slide. As we have been working

1398
01:05:46,965 --> 01:05:48,667
to scope planned bay area 2060

1399
01:05:48,667 --> 01:05:52,267
over the last several months we

1400
01:05:53,773 --> 01:05:57,973
have been guided by what I might

1401
01:05:58,810 --> 01:06:00,412
characterize as these statement

1402
01:06:00,412 --> 01:06:03,216
or commitment for this plan

1403
01:06:03,216 --> 01:06:04,850
update which is really about

1404
01:06:04,850 --> 01:06:06,850
finding balance specifically

1405
01:06:07,519 --> 01:06:09,154
between a plan that is

1406
01:06:09,154 --> 01:06:12,900
constrained and grounded in some

1407
01:06:12,900 --> 01:06:14,327
of the key challenges and

1408
01:06:14,327 --> 01:06:16,595
realities where we are today

1409
01:06:16,595 --> 01:06:17,896
what we can realistically

1410
01:06:17,896 --> 01:06:19,931
accomplish in the near-term

1411
01:06:19,931 --> 01:06:20,899
while remaining appropriately

1412
01:06:20,899 --> 01:06:22,634
ambitious and visionary about

1413
01:06:22,634 --> 01:06:24,469
where we want to be as a region

1414
01:06:24,469 --> 01:06:26,771
in the future and this means

1415
01:06:26,771 --> 01:06:29,700
working to develop a plan that

1416
01:06:29,700 --> 01:06:30,776
respond to the intersection of

1417
01:06:30,776 --> 01:06:31,943
pressing issues whether

1418
01:06:31,943 --> 01:06:33,545
affordability public health

1419
01:06:33,545 --> 01:06:34,346
economic opportunity ongoing

1420
01:06:34,346 --> 01:06:36,746
financial challenges key trends

1421
01:06:37,482 --> 01:06:38,951
whether automation or ai, best

1422
01:06:38,951 --> 01:06:40,385
practices across the field

1423
01:06:40,385 --> 01:06:41,953
addressing core regulatory

1424
01:06:41,953 --> 01:06:43,953
requirements and whether

1425
01:06:44,624 --> 01:06:46,240
achieving our climate target or

1426
01:06:46,240 --> 01:06:48,194
accommodating future growth at

1427
01:06:48,194 --> 01:06:49,261
all income levels as well as

1428
01:06:49,261 --> 01:06:51,196
furthering towards a shared

1429
01:06:51,196 --> 01:06:51,831
vision for the year 2060. Next

1430
01:06:51,831 --> 01:06:53,265
slide.

1431
01:06:53,265 --> 01:06:55,330
In terms of some of the feedback

1432
01:06:55,330 --> 01:06:58,330
during the early scoping process

1433
01:06:58,703 --> 01:07:02,903
I want to emphasize we heard a

1434
01:07:03,375 --> 01:07:04,976
lot on the side synthesizing

1435
01:07:04,976 --> 01:07:07,379
messages that came up in various

1436
01:07:07,379 --> 01:07:08,580
different context briefly this

1437
01:07:08,580 --> 01:07:09,915
includes transportation safety

1438
01:07:09,915 --> 01:07:11,650
that topic came up a lot

1439
01:07:11,650 --> 01:07:13,840
particularly in context of

1440
01:07:13,840 --> 01:07:14,853
children and areas around

1441
01:07:14,853 --> 01:07:15,454
schools as well as safety and

1442
01:07:15,454 --> 01:07:16,788
accessibility of our

1443
01:07:16,788 --> 01:07:18,457
transportation system for

1444
01:07:18,457 --> 01:07:19,524
elderly as well as with people

1445
01:07:19,524 --> 01:07:22,160
with disabilities in terms of

1446
01:07:22,160 --> 01:07:24,529
land use and housing there was a

1447
01:07:24,529 --> 01:07:26,665
lot of interest in exploring how

1448
01:07:26,665 --> 01:07:30,335
the region can grow in a way

1449
01:07:30,335 --> 01:07:31,838
that balance equity access,

1450
01:07:31,838 --> 01:07:33,138
opportunity, regional dinism,

1451
01:07:33,138 --> 01:07:35,140
and climate considerations as

1452
01:07:35,140 --> 01:07:37,176
well as resilience to issues

1453
01:07:37,176 --> 01:07:39,377
like wildfire, I think about

1454
01:07:39,377 --> 01:07:40,612
some of the fiscal challenges

1455
01:07:40,612 --> 01:07:43,515
that the region is facing

1456
01:07:43,515 --> 01:07:45,915
leaning into the scenario

1457
01:07:46,585 --> 01:07:47,986
planning as a means to weigh

1458
01:07:47,986 --> 01:07:49,880
tradeoffs and explore

1459
01:07:49,880 --> 01:07:51,560
alternatives and we heard a lot

1460
01:07:51,560 --> 01:07:52,858
about the need to enhance our

1461
01:07:52,858 --> 01:07:54,593
engagement with key partners

1462
01:07:54,593 --> 01:07:56,560
including this body and we'll

1463
01:07:56,560 --> 01:07:58,463
talk more about that a bit

1464
01:07:58,463 --> 01:07:59,599
later. And then emphasizing

1465
01:07:59,599 --> 01:08:01,999
implementation this has been

1466
01:08:04,303 --> 01:08:07,539
ongoing area of focus for us but

1467
01:08:07,539 --> 01:08:09,574
interest in deepening that focus

1468
01:08:09,574 --> 01:08:10,675
in the long range plan. Next

1469
01:08:10,675 --> 01:08:11,810
slide.

1470
01:08:11,810 --> 01:08:13,979
related to the last point, there

1471
01:08:13,979 --> 01:08:15,814
is a lot of interest in

1472
01:08:15,814 --> 01:08:17,820
measuring our progress and doing

1473
01:08:17,820 --> 01:08:19,820
more communications is

1474
01:08:19,651 --> 01:08:21,720
storytelling around what has and

1475
01:08:21,720 --> 01:08:25,320
has not worked through the last

1476
01:08:25,791 --> 01:08:27,592
few plan cycles, as we delve

1477
01:08:27,592 --> 01:08:28,728
into environmental issues, sea

1478
01:08:28,728 --> 01:08:30,628
level rise continues to be a

1479
01:08:30,628 --> 01:08:31,930
topic of interest, including how

1480
01:08:31,930 --> 01:08:34,930
our regional efforts can align

1481
01:08:39,705 --> 01:08:41,606
with local planning. Anden

1482
01:08:41,606 --> 01:08:43,375
then we heard various different

1483
01:08:43,375 --> 01:08:45,410
voices on the issue of adapting

1484
01:08:45,410 --> 01:08:47,790
the region to future sea level

1485
01:08:47,790 --> 01:08:48,213
rise and how much that would

1486
01:08:48,213 --> 01:08:49,382
cost to implement versus

1487
01:08:49,382 --> 01:08:50,816
potentially exploring managed

1488
01:08:50,816 --> 01:08:52,984
retreat. In the transit space,

1489
01:08:52,984 --> 01:08:54,821
there is a lot of interest in

1490
01:08:54,821 --> 01:08:56,455
highlighting the benefits of our

1491
01:08:56,455 --> 01:08:58,190
regional transit system, while

1492
01:08:58,190 --> 01:09:00,590
also considering how projects

1493
01:09:01,493 --> 01:09:03,662
MAY be prioritized in a future

1494
01:09:03,662 --> 01:09:05,330
with fewer resources and

1495
01:09:05,330 --> 01:09:06,331
increased constraints.

1496
01:09:06,331 --> 01:09:08,667
Certainly heard a lot about

1497
01:09:08,667 --> 01:09:11,670
emerging issues like ai,

1498
01:09:11,102 --> 01:09:13,502
automation, and e-bikes, and

1499
01:09:13,538 --> 01:09:16,700
then, of course, very important

1500
01:09:16,700 --> 01:09:16,741
and core to the plan are

1501
01:09:16,741 --> 01:09:18,741
affordability, whether for

1502
01:09:18,878 --> 01:09:21,278
housing or transportation, as

1503
01:09:21,646 --> 01:09:22,147
well as retaining our region's

1504
01:09:22,147 --> 01:09:24,116
diversity and ensuring

1505
01:09:24,116 --> 01:09:26,116
opportunity for all.

1506
01:09:29,550 --> 01:09:31,550
Next slide.

1507
01:09:32,290 --> 01:09:34,292
So, this is a preliminary

1508
01:09:34,292 --> 01:09:37,892
timeline for the plan, from now

1509
01:09:38,296 --> 01:09:40,366
through early 2029. And I will

1510
01:09:40,366 --> 01:09:40,966
talk more about the different

1511
01:09:40,966 --> 01:09:42,567
phases of the plan on the

1512
01:09:42,567 --> 01:09:45,937
subsequent slides, but I do want

1513
01:09:45,937 --> 01:09:47,906
to highlight a few things. You

1514
01:09:47,906 --> 01:09:50,306
know, first, engagement with

1515
01:09:50,308 --> 01:09:51,777
both the public as well as our

1516
01:09:51,777 --> 01:09:52,644
technical partners will be

1517
01:09:52,644 --> 01:09:55,440
continuous throughout the plan

1518
01:09:55,480 --> 01:09:56,915
process. But in general, we can

1519
01:09:56,915 --> 01:09:59,351
expect engagement peaks to be

1520
01:09:59,351 --> 01:10:01,553
happening around the spring and

1521
01:10:01,553 --> 01:10:03,953
fall of every year.

1522
01:10:04,990 --> 01:10:06,324
Through early 2029, you can

1523
01:10:06,324 --> 01:10:09,324
expect at least five significant

1524
01:10:09,328 --> 01:10:11,296
board level actions, including

1525
01:10:11,296 --> 01:10:13,532
the adoption of our public

1526
01:10:13,532 --> 01:10:15,932
participation plan later this

1527
01:10:16,769 --> 01:10:18,570
month. The adoption of the

1528
01:10:18,570 --> 01:10:19,704
plan's vision and fwiegd

1529
01:10:19,704 --> 01:10:21,704
principles in approximately

1530
01:10:21,773 --> 01:10:23,375
spring of 2027. The adoption of

1531
01:10:23,375 --> 01:10:25,775
the regional growth forecast

1532
01:10:25,777 --> 01:10:27,279
methodology in the fall of 2027,

1533
01:10:27,279 --> 01:10:29,848
then the adoption of the plan's

1534
01:10:29,848 --> 01:10:32,848
draft and final blueprint in

1535
01:10:33,350 --> 01:10:34,219
early spring 2028, and spring

1536
01:10:34,219 --> 01:10:35,720
2029.

1537
01:10:35,720 --> 01:10:38,123
Again, I'll talk more about

1538
01:10:38,123 --> 01:10:40,590
these different phases, but I'll

1539
01:10:40,590 --> 01:10:41,159
just briefly note that the

1540
01:10:41,159 --> 01:10:42,494
foundations phase of the plan is

1541
01:10:42,494 --> 01:10:44,329
kind of where we're starting

1542
01:10:44,329 --> 01:10:45,998
right now, with that work

1543
01:10:45,998 --> 01:10:48,267
expected to run through a good

1544
01:10:48,267 --> 01:10:49,935
chunk of 2027. The outlook

1545
01:10:49,935 --> 01:10:52,270
phase of the plan will run

1546
01:10:52,270 --> 01:10:55,641
through later this year, all the

1547
01:10:55,641 --> 01:10:56,641
way through 2027 as we then

1548
01:10:56,641 --> 01:10:59,641
shift into the blueprint and

1549
01:11:00,745 --> 01:11:03,248
final plan phases in 2028 and

1550
01:11:03,248 --> 01:11:05,648
2029. With final plan adoption

1551
01:11:06,351 --> 01:11:08,751
anticipated for early 2030, and

1552
01:11:14,920 --> 01:11:15,594
as the footnote says, this is an

1553
01:11:15,594 --> 01:11:16,696
approximate schedule subject to

1554
01:11:16,696 --> 01:11:17,762
change. Next slide.

1555
01:11:17,762 --> 01:11:19,300
So the foundations phase of the

1556
01:11:19,300 --> 01:11:21,166
plan is really about where we

1557
01:11:21,166 --> 01:11:23,468
are right now, as a region,

1558
01:11:23,468 --> 01:11:24,870
where do we want to go, and also

1559
01:11:24,870 --> 01:11:28,173
where are we starting from in

1560
01:11:28,173 --> 01:11:30,108
terms of our existing long range

1561
01:11:30,108 --> 01:11:32,377
plan. So, core to that is our

1562
01:11:32,377 --> 01:11:33,678
vision and guiding principles.

1563
01:11:33,678 --> 01:11:35,800
If you all recall, planned bay

1564
01:11:35,800 --> 01:11:37,283
area has an adopted vision of a

1565
01:11:37,283 --> 01:11:39,683
region that is affordable,

1566
01:11:40,652 --> 01:11:41,920
connected, diverse, healthy and

1567
01:11:41,920 --> 01:11:43,456
vibrant for all by the year

1568
01:11:43,456 --> 01:11:44,790
2050. And we want to see

1569
01:11:44,790 --> 01:11:47,392
whether, you know, that vision

1570
01:11:47,392 --> 01:11:47,793
still resonates, or maybe should

1571
01:11:47,793 --> 01:11:49,793
evolve.

1572
01:11:51,620 --> 01:11:52,697
We also have, you know, an

1573
01:11:52,697 --> 01:11:55,697
existing set of 35 strategies in

1574
01:11:55,967 --> 01:11:57,937
our long range plan, as well as

1575
01:11:57,937 --> 01:11:59,938
an existing land use framework,

1576
01:11:59,938 --> 01:12:01,473
and really try to look at

1577
01:12:01,473 --> 01:12:03,841
literature review and analysis

1578
01:12:03,841 --> 01:12:06,841
to understand, again, you know,

1579
01:12:07,145 --> 01:12:09,115
what -- what can we say we know

1580
01:12:09,115 --> 01:12:11,183
about what has worked and not

1581
01:12:11,183 --> 01:12:12,651
worked with these existing sects

1582
01:12:12,651 --> 01:12:15,754
of the plan and how should they

1583
01:12:15,754 --> 01:12:17,489
evolve. Next slide.

1584
01:12:17,489 --> 01:12:19,558
The outlook phase of the plan is

1585
01:12:19,558 --> 01:12:21,526
where we're looking ahead and

1586
01:12:21,526 --> 01:12:23,940
working to develop the primary

1587
01:12:23,940 --> 01:12:25,320
planning assumptions that are a

1588
01:12:25,320 --> 01:12:26,298
core part of the plan, many of

1589
01:12:26,298 --> 01:12:28,133
which are required by federal or

1590
01:12:28,133 --> 01:12:29,534
state or other requirements.

1591
01:12:29,534 --> 01:12:31,934
This includes our regional

1592
01:12:32,710 --> 01:12:34,471
growth forecast of population,

1593
01:12:34,506 --> 01:12:36,906
jobs, and households, our

1594
01:12:37,800 --> 01:12:39,408
financial needs and revenue

1595
01:12:39,678 --> 01:12:41,481
estimates, in terms of what

1596
01:12:41,481 --> 01:12:43,649
funds are available to support

1597
01:12:43,649 --> 01:12:45,584
implementation of the plan, as

1598
01:12:45,584 --> 01:12:46,218
well as certain external forces

1599
01:12:46,218 --> 01:12:49,354
that are outside of our direct

1600
01:12:49,354 --> 01:12:50,889
control.

1601
01:12:50,889 --> 01:12:52,257
Importantly, for this plan

1602
01:12:52,257 --> 01:12:54,600
update, this is one of the main

1603
01:12:54,600 --> 01:12:56,129
areas where we really want to

1604
01:12:56,129 --> 01:12:57,262
lean in scenario planning,

1605
01:12:57,262 --> 01:12:58,831
whether different growth

1606
01:12:58,831 --> 01:13:00,650
scenarios, different funding

1607
01:13:00,650 --> 01:13:02,267
scenarios, but also exploring

1608
01:13:02,267 --> 01:13:04,667
certain key emerging issues,

1609
01:13:05,171 --> 01:13:07,571
whether autonomous vehicles, sea

1610
01:13:07,974 --> 01:13:08,574
level rise, remote work, or, you

1611
01:13:08,574 --> 01:13:09,708
know, mode preferences for

1612
01:13:09,708 --> 01:13:11,708
travel.

1613
01:13:14,790 --> 01:13:15,280
Next slide.

1614
01:13:15,280 --> 01:13:18,880
So, the blueprint phase of the

1615
01:13:20,886 --> 01:13:23,210
man, I think this is, you know,

1616
01:13:23,210 --> 01:13:25,421
important, especially for member

1617
01:13:25,491 --> 01:13:27,691
who MAY be new, I really try to

1618
01:13:27,691 --> 01:13:29,327
emphasize, that this is really

1619
01:13:29,327 --> 01:13:31,896
the blueprint is the thing this

1620
01:13:31,896 --> 01:13:32,899
is the core of the plan as a

1621
01:13:32,899 --> 01:13:34,299
planning and policy document

1622
01:13:34,299 --> 01:13:35,233
where different planning

1623
01:13:35,233 --> 01:13:37,233
assumptions, the strategies

1624
01:13:37,269 --> 01:13:38,271
including policies and

1625
01:13:38,271 --> 01:13:39,571
investments, as well as

1626
01:13:39,571 --> 01:13:41,571
associated analysis come

1627
01:13:42,175 --> 01:13:43,575
together to see whether if

1628
01:13:43,575 --> 01:13:44,843
implemented the plan will

1629
01:13:44,843 --> 01:13:47,113
succeed at achieving its key

1630
01:13:47,113 --> 01:13:48,747
targets and goals. So, I think

1631
01:13:48,747 --> 01:13:52,347
as we think about those approval

1632
01:13:52,851 --> 01:13:54,850
items, you know, spring 2028,

1633
01:13:54,850 --> 01:13:56,688
and spring 2029, as those foe

1634
01:13:56,688 --> 01:13:58,623
before the board, this is, you

1635
01:13:58,623 --> 01:14:00,292
know, really the important thing

1636
01:14:00,292 --> 01:14:01,760
that, sort of, sets the

1637
01:14:01,760 --> 01:14:03,496
framework for how long range

1638
01:14:03,496 --> 01:14:05,764
plan is going to move forward.

1639
01:14:05,764 --> 01:14:07,498
So again that's where we

1640
01:14:07,498 --> 01:14:09,267
anticipate leaning into our

1641
01:14:09,267 --> 01:14:11,667
engagement and ensuring everyone

1642
01:14:11,937 --> 01:14:13,171
gets multiple bytes at the apple

1643
01:14:13,171 --> 01:14:14,506
before anything goes before our

1644
01:14:14,506 --> 01:14:15,341
boards for consideration. Next

1645
01:14:15,341 --> 01:14:17,341
slide.

1646
01:14:17,375 --> 01:14:19,678
So, I would say that the draft

1647
01:14:19,678 --> 01:14:23,278
and final plan, you know, this

1648
01:14:23,381 --> 01:14:25,117
is really more of a regulatory

1649
01:14:25,117 --> 01:14:26,952
and communications document.

1650
01:14:26,952 --> 01:14:29,355
You know, this is where we are

1651
01:14:29,355 --> 01:14:33,158
telling the story of the plan in

1652
01:14:33,158 --> 01:14:34,826
a series of documents, as well

1653
01:14:34,826 --> 01:14:37,826
as supplemental reports, that is

1654
01:14:38,130 --> 01:14:39,431
then, you know, considered for

1655
01:14:39,431 --> 01:14:42,431
adoption. It's also where we

1656
01:14:43,503 --> 01:14:46,238
have to do a required ceqa

1657
01:14:46,238 --> 01:14:46,772
process to analyze and disclose

1658
01:14:46,772 --> 01:14:47,973
potentially significant

1659
01:14:47,973 --> 01:14:49,241
environmental impacts of the

1660
01:14:49,241 --> 01:14:51,810
plan. But importantly, this is

1661
01:14:51,810 --> 01:14:54,380
also where we try to figure out

1662
01:14:54,380 --> 01:14:55,213
how to translate these ambitious

1663
01:14:55,213 --> 01:14:57,149
30-year strategies into

1664
01:14:57,149 --> 01:14:59,584
near-term actions that mtc and

1665
01:14:59,584 --> 01:15:01,190
abag can implement over the next

1666
01:15:01,190 --> 01:15:01,653
five years to implement the

1667
01:15:01,653 --> 01:15:04,356
long-term vision of the plan.

1668
01:15:04,356 --> 01:15:06,290
Next slide.

1669
01:15:06,290 --> 01:15:09,294
So, you're going to hear a lot

1670
01:15:09,294 --> 01:15:11,697
more about the public engagement

1671
01:15:11,697 --> 01:15:13,297
in my colleague veronica's item

1672
01:15:13,297 --> 01:15:16,101
coming up next. But just in

1673
01:15:16,101 --> 01:15:18,403
terms of how we're approaching

1674
01:15:18,403 --> 01:15:20,380
this for the scope of planned

1675
01:15:20,380 --> 01:15:21,600
bay area, specifically,

1676
01:15:21,600 --> 01:15:22,407
obviously creating different

1677
01:15:22,407 --> 01:15:23,642
opportunities for residents,

1678
01:15:23,642 --> 01:15:26,420
workers, and community partners

1679
01:15:26,211 --> 01:15:28,130
to share their perspectives and

1680
01:15:28,130 --> 01:15:29,748
insights, and there are kind of

1681
01:15:29,748 --> 01:15:31,283
three key themes along

1682
01:15:31,283 --> 01:15:33,840
highlights, which is depth over

1683
01:15:33,840 --> 01:15:35,388
breadth, which I know has been

1684
01:15:35,388 --> 01:15:38,900
an ongoing focus of this body in

1685
01:15:38,900 --> 01:15:39,524
terms of emphasizing sustained

1686
01:15:39,524 --> 01:15:41,924
conversations rather than, you

1687
01:15:42,161 --> 01:15:44,290
know, just having these one-time

1688
01:15:44,290 --> 01:15:45,597
efforts. And then on the far

1689
01:15:45,597 --> 01:15:47,597
right, collaboration, elevating

1690
01:15:48,133 --> 01:15:50,368
the role of our cbo partners, as

1691
01:15:50,368 --> 01:15:53,400
we work to engage the region's

1692
01:15:53,400 --> 01:15:54,474
diverse communities. I know,

1693
01:15:54,474 --> 01:15:56,874
again, a long-standing priority

1694
01:15:56,941 --> 01:15:59,440
of this body. In the middle, in

1695
01:15:59,440 --> 01:16:00,445
terms of highlighting, you know,

1696
01:16:00,445 --> 01:16:02,845
exploring new avenues, we're

1697
01:16:03,115 --> 01:16:05,183
very interested in looking at

1698
01:16:05,183 --> 01:16:06,486
gamification, short form video,

1699
01:16:06,486 --> 01:16:09,486
innovative web content to make

1700
01:16:09,921 --> 01:16:11,189
more engaging material for our

1701
01:16:11,189 --> 01:16:13,589
different audiences. And you

1702
01:16:13,725 --> 01:16:15,627
know, in the image in the

1703
01:16:15,627 --> 01:16:19,650
middle, I'll direct -- it's kind

1704
01:16:19,650 --> 01:16:19,898
of like a street grid, that's

1705
01:16:19,898 --> 01:16:20,832
showing some different

1706
01:16:20,832 --> 01:16:22,502
development as well as

1707
01:16:22,502 --> 01:16:24,690
transportation and some green

1708
01:16:24,690 --> 01:16:25,605
fields. And this is a

1709
01:16:25,605 --> 01:16:27,205
screenshot of an actual game

1710
01:16:27,205 --> 01:16:29,807
that has been developed by one

1711
01:16:29,807 --> 01:16:31,209
of our mineta institute

1712
01:16:31,209 --> 01:16:33,609
students, and we're really

1713
01:16:33,744 --> 01:16:35,810
looking at, you know, different

1714
01:16:35,810 --> 01:16:36,782
game options that these students

1715
01:16:36,782 --> 01:16:38,850
have been developed to inform

1716
01:16:38,850 --> 01:16:40,860
some of our scenario planning

1717
01:16:40,860 --> 01:16:42,254
work that we expect to move

1718
01:16:42,254 --> 01:16:44,790
forward next year. So, really

1719
01:16:44,790 --> 01:16:45,390
excited about those types of

1720
01:16:45,390 --> 01:16:47,390
collaboration opportunities.

1721
01:16:49,127 --> 01:16:51,127
Next slide.

1722
01:16:51,396 --> 01:16:53,666
You know, on the -- engaging

1723
01:16:53,666 --> 01:16:54,766
with our more technical

1724
01:16:54,766 --> 01:16:56,301
partners, you know, which does

1725
01:16:56,301 --> 01:16:58,136
include this body, as well as

1726
01:16:58,136 --> 01:17:00,536
our local jurisdictions, are

1727
01:17:00,840 --> 01:17:02,840
transit operators, labor,

1728
01:17:03,608 --> 01:17:05,608
business, cbo's, non-profits,

1729
01:17:05,677 --> 01:17:07,112
you know, I think there are a

1730
01:17:07,112 --> 01:17:08,447
few key themes we want to

1731
01:17:08,447 --> 01:17:10,282
highlight which is, again,

1732
01:17:10,282 --> 01:17:11,383
showing up. So, obviously

1733
01:17:11,383 --> 01:17:12,884
meeting folks and elected

1734
01:17:12,884 --> 01:17:14,419
officials where they are,

1735
01:17:14,419 --> 01:17:16,755
through some of these existing

1736
01:17:16,755 --> 01:17:19,755
networks and meetings. And also

1737
01:17:20,920 --> 01:17:22,327
doing our traditional convenings

1738
01:17:22,327 --> 01:17:23,862
where, you know, we do hold

1739
01:17:23,862 --> 01:17:25,564
webinars, workshops, office

1740
01:17:25,564 --> 01:17:27,299
hours, where we bring people

1741
01:17:27,299 --> 01:17:29,340
together where they can be

1742
01:17:29,340 --> 01:17:30,268
different partners can bring

1743
01:17:30,268 --> 01:17:32,300
different perspectives together

1744
01:17:32,300 --> 01:17:33,939
in the same environment together

1745
01:17:33,939 --> 01:17:35,140
to discuss, share priorities and

1746
01:17:35,140 --> 01:17:36,641
explore tradeoffs. And then

1747
01:17:36,641 --> 01:17:39,412
something that we will make sure

1748
01:17:39,412 --> 01:17:41,646
that you all get access to this.

1749
01:17:41,646 --> 01:17:44,683
It will be an attachment in the

1750
01:17:44,683 --> 01:17:45,684
OCTOBER kickoff item. We are

1751
01:17:45,684 --> 01:17:47,684
developing what we're

1752
01:17:48,860 --> 01:17:50,486
calling "coordination road maps:

1753
01:17:51,190 --> 01:17:52,958
which is if you are a

1754
01:17:52,958 --> 01:17:54,559
transportation stakeholders or

1755
01:17:54,559 --> 01:17:56,559
environmental stakeholder, or

1756
01:17:56,762 --> 01:17:58,630
housing stakeholder, how can you

1757
01:17:58,630 --> 01:17:59,998
navigate this long and complex

1758
01:17:59,998 --> 01:18:02,467
process. And I want to

1759
01:18:02,467 --> 01:18:03,702
highlight for some of our newer

1760
01:18:03,702 --> 01:18:05,303
members, we very much encourage

1761
01:18:05,303 --> 01:18:07,239
council napgz all of the events

1762
01:18:07,239 --> 01:18:08,540
that we convene. So if we're

1763
01:18:08,540 --> 01:18:11,540
holding a workshop at the

1764
01:18:12,578 --> 01:18:14,130
building, or we're doing a

1765
01:18:14,130 --> 01:18:15,313
webinar, you know, we really

1766
01:18:15,313 --> 01:18:17,382
support and hope that you all

1767
01:18:17,382 --> 01:18:18,850
can be some of the voices at the

1768
01:18:18,850 --> 01:18:20,186
table with some of these broader

1769
01:18:20,186 --> 01:18:23,186
-- broader range of partners.

1770
01:18:23,221 --> 01:18:24,856
next slide.

1771
01:18:24,856 --> 01:18:25,992
So, do I want to highlight, you

1772
01:18:25,992 --> 01:18:28,226
know, the plan does not take

1773
01:18:28,226 --> 01:18:30,395
place in a vacuum. There are

1774
01:18:30,395 --> 01:18:31,329
ongoing changes at the state and

1775
01:18:31,329 --> 01:18:34,329
federal level that can impact

1776
01:18:35,100 --> 01:18:37,836
how the plan is going to

1777
01:18:37,836 --> 01:18:39,404
proceed. And this includes

1778
01:18:39,404 --> 01:18:40,106
anticipated updates to the

1779
01:18:40,106 --> 01:18:41,306
greenhouse gas emission

1780
01:18:41,306 --> 01:18:43,706
reduction targets from the

1781
01:18:43,809 --> 01:18:45,645
california air resources boards,

1782
01:18:45,645 --> 01:18:47,647
as well as the associated

1783
01:18:47,647 --> 01:18:50,470
guidelines. And we do

1784
01:18:50,115 --> 01:18:51,820
anticipate those coming

1785
01:18:51,820 --> 01:18:53,482
mid-cycle which could have

1786
01:18:53,753 --> 01:18:55,555
impact on the plan. Senate bill

1787
01:18:55,555 --> 01:18:58,323
1087, which is the bill to

1788
01:18:58,323 --> 01:19:00,723
modernize our existing long

1789
01:19:02,600 --> 01:19:04,496
range plan framework of sb 375

1790
01:19:04,496 --> 01:19:05,464
is currently on the governor's

1791
01:19:05,464 --> 01:19:07,966
desk, if signed could have some

1792
01:19:07,966 --> 01:19:10,366
significant impacts, and also

1793
01:19:10,769 --> 01:19:12,337
assembly bill 2296 could shift

1794
01:19:12,337 --> 01:19:13,972
timelines for the parallel rhna

1795
01:19:13,972 --> 01:19:14,639
process. And at the federal

1796
01:19:14,639 --> 01:19:16,108
level, I think everyone

1797
01:19:16,108 --> 01:19:17,142
understands that the funding

1798
01:19:17,142 --> 01:19:18,210
environment is quite uncertain

1799
01:19:18,210 --> 01:19:19,712
there which could have

1800
01:19:19,712 --> 01:19:22,712
meaningful impacts on the plan,

1801
01:19:23,381 --> 01:19:24,884
and there are, you know, various

1802
01:19:24,884 --> 01:19:26,840
rulemakings under way, or being

1803
01:19:26,840 --> 01:19:28,121
considered on equity that,

1804
01:19:28,121 --> 01:19:28,787
again, we MAY have to respond to

1805
01:19:28,787 --> 01:19:31,787
if those move forward. Next

1806
01:19:32,624 --> 01:19:34,624
slide.

1807
01:19:35,260 --> 01:19:38,626
This is my last slide. Thank

1808
01:19:38,631 --> 01:19:40,566
you for your patience as I wade

1809
01:19:40,566 --> 01:19:42,966
through some dense materials.

1810
01:19:43,169 --> 01:19:44,870
Some of the immediate next

1811
01:19:44,870 --> 01:19:45,971
steps. The commission will

1812
01:19:45,971 --> 01:19:46,872
consider adoption of the public

1813
01:19:46,872 --> 01:19:48,306
participation plan later this

1814
01:19:48,306 --> 01:19:50,510
month. We anticipate formally

1815
01:19:50,510 --> 01:19:52,677
kicking off the plan at the mtc

1816
01:19:52,677 --> 01:19:53,312
abag -- mtc planning and abag

1817
01:19:53,312 --> 01:19:55,280
administrative committee meeting

1818
01:19:55,280 --> 01:19:58,280
on OCTOBER 9th. The joint

1819
01:19:58,950 --> 01:20:01,254
workshop is on OCTOBER 29th.

1820
01:20:01,254 --> 01:20:03,540
and then we'll kickoff the first

1821
01:20:03,540 --> 01:20:05,123
round of engagement on the plan

1822
01:20:05,123 --> 01:20:06,625
with a particular focus on the

1823
01:20:06,625 --> 01:20:09,250
plan's vision and guiding

1824
01:20:11,396 --> 01:20:12,798
principles. So stay tuned for

1825
01:20:12,798 --> 01:20:14,766
more on that. Then we

1826
01:20:14,766 --> 01:20:16,369
anticipate coming back to the

1827
01:20:16,369 --> 01:20:19,305
council as well as our

1828
01:20:19,305 --> 01:20:21,439
committees for more detailed

1829
01:20:21,439 --> 01:20:23,740
updates on the foundations and

1830
01:20:23,740 --> 01:20:24,376
outlook phases of the work.

1831
01:20:24,376 --> 01:20:25,777
That concludes my presentation.

1832
01:20:25,777 --> 01:20:27,460
You know, always happy to answer

1833
01:20:27,460 --> 01:20:28,680
any questions that you MAY have,

1834
01:20:28,680 --> 01:20:30,150
and you know, just for

1835
01:20:30,150 --> 01:20:31,983
consideration, we do have a

1836
01:20:31,983 --> 01:20:34,520
couple of discussion questions,

1837
01:20:34,520 --> 01:20:36,955
including which phases of the

1838
01:20:36,955 --> 01:20:38,156
planned bay area process are of

1839
01:20:38,156 --> 01:20:39,459
greatest interest to you, and

1840
01:20:39,459 --> 01:20:40,892
whether you have any thoughts

1841
01:20:40,892 --> 01:20:41,993
and perspectives on the proposed

1842
01:20:41,993 --> 01:20:44,393
engagement approach that we

1843
01:20:45,831 --> 01:20:46,431
highlighted. Thank you, again.

1844
01:20:46,431 --> 01:20:47,300
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1845
01:20:47,300 --> 01:20:50,435
thank you so much chirag. This

1846
01:20:50,435 --> 01:20:51,503
was a really great presentation.

1847
01:20:51,503 --> 01:20:53,805
And I just want to respond

1848
01:20:53,805 --> 01:20:55,107
quickly and say, like, I really

1849
01:20:55,107 --> 01:20:58,107
love the gaming option. It's

1850
01:21:02,347 --> 01:21:04,749
like a dream to me, and I really

1851
01:21:04,749 --> 01:21:07,819
lawful that our duong people are

1852
01:21:07,819 --> 01:21:10,355
the ones taking the lead like

1853
01:21:10,355 --> 01:21:12,757
help us reimagine and then so

1854
01:21:12,757 --> 01:21:14,192
appreciate the naming that these

1855
01:21:14,192 --> 01:21:15,194
documents are basically

1856
01:21:15,194 --> 01:21:16,128
communication documents.

1857
01:21:16,128 --> 01:21:17,863
They're opportunities for us to

1858
01:21:17,863 --> 01:21:19,598
learn and digest the information

1859
01:21:19,598 --> 01:21:21,800
this's going to guide our future

1860
01:21:21,800 --> 01:21:23,703
and finally I want to underscore

1861
01:21:23,703 --> 01:21:24,836
what you said about encouraging

1862
01:21:24,836 --> 01:21:27,236
our council members to

1863
01:21:28,473 --> 01:21:30,643
participate in convenings, I

1864
01:21:30,643 --> 01:21:33,112
think that's very valuable and

1865
01:21:33,112 --> 01:21:34,446
so I hope that we take his

1866
01:21:34,446 --> 01:21:36,449
invitation to go and do that.

1867
01:21:36,449 --> 01:21:38,417
Now I would like to see if there

1868
01:21:38,417 --> 01:21:41,353
are council members who would

1869
01:21:41,353 --> 01:21:42,621
like to participate in

1870
01:21:42,621 --> 01:21:43,989
discussion, please raise your

1871
01:21:43,989 --> 01:21:46,989
hands. Actually going to start

1872
01:21:47,360 --> 01:21:49,161
on my right, council member

1873
01:21:49,161 --> 01:21:50,529
wong, council member duong,

1874
01:21:50,529 --> 01:21:52,697
council member trotten berg,

1875
01:21:52,697 --> 01:21:54,366
council member baldini, council

1876
01:21:54,366 --> 01:21:56,502
member saurnlds and council

1877
01:21:56,502 --> 01:21:58,737
member cushman. I'll start with

1878
01:21:58,737 --> 01:21:59,338
you council member wong.

1879
01:21:59,338 --> 01:21:59,971
>>janelle wong: thank you so

1880
01:21:59,971 --> 01:22:01,339
much for this presentation.

1881
01:22:01,339 --> 01:22:04,939
This was good laying out the

1882
01:22:08,246 --> 01:22:09,948
process and the plan. So that's

1883
01:22:09,948 --> 01:22:12,217
one. My question although it's

1884
01:22:12,217 --> 01:22:14,953
not the guiding questions in

1885
01:22:14,953 --> 01:22:17,490
terms of preparing for emerging

1886
01:22:17,490 --> 01:22:19,758
to tells, like ai automation and

1887
01:22:19,758 --> 01:22:21,593
e-bikes, I'm curious as to why

1888
01:22:21,593 --> 01:22:23,993
e-bikes autonomous vehicles were

1889
01:22:25,630 --> 01:22:25,997
grouped together as an emerging

1890
01:22:25,997 --> 01:22:28,734
technology. E likes have been

1891
01:22:28,734 --> 01:22:32,205
around for a while and I know

1892
01:22:32,205 --> 01:22:35,205
there is hot debated discussion

1893
01:22:35,374 --> 01:22:37,420
about different versions of

1894
01:22:37,420 --> 01:22:38,777
e-motos, versus e-bikes and I'm

1895
01:22:38,777 --> 01:22:40,746
curious as to how we're going to

1896
01:22:40,746 --> 01:22:43,746
approach that discussion in this

1897
01:22:43,782 --> 01:22:44,516
plan in terms of infrastructure.

1898
01:22:44,516 --> 01:22:47,452
>>chair, carina vinh lieu: go

1899
01:22:47,452 --> 01:22:48,920
ahead and respond.

1900
01:22:48,920 --> 01:22:50,622
>>chirag rabari: thank you for

1901
01:22:50,622 --> 01:22:52,570
that I think the intention

1902
01:22:52,570 --> 01:22:53,325
wasn't necessarily to

1903
01:22:53,325 --> 01:22:55,394
communicate that these are, sort

1904
01:22:55,394 --> 01:22:58,394
of, going together it's just

1905
01:22:58,498 --> 01:23:01,234
these are kind of topics that we

1906
01:23:01,234 --> 01:23:02,534
have heard and very much agree

1907
01:23:02,534 --> 01:23:04,469
that they have distinct avenues

1908
01:23:04,469 --> 01:23:07,373
for exploration. I will say the

1909
01:23:07,373 --> 01:23:09,341
thing we have heard on e-bikes

1910
01:23:09,341 --> 01:23:10,409
really maybe was more of that

1911
01:23:10,409 --> 01:23:12,477
connection to the safety angle

1912
01:23:12,477 --> 01:23:13,880
because there has been so much

1913
01:23:13,880 --> 01:23:15,348
in the news recently about

1914
01:23:15,348 --> 01:23:17,617
incidents involving duong folks.

1915
01:23:17,617 --> 01:23:20,253
So I think it would probably be

1916
01:23:20,253 --> 01:23:21,553
more with respect to thinking

1917
01:23:21,553 --> 01:23:23,953
about our transportation safety

1918
01:23:24,790 --> 01:23:27,190
strategies whereas you know

1919
01:23:28,728 --> 01:23:31,128
automation is about future

1920
01:23:31,330 --> 01:23:33,310
assumptions about ai adoption do

1921
01:23:33,310 --> 01:23:34,801
we need strategies to help

1922
01:23:34,801 --> 01:23:36,768
address some of those potential

1923
01:23:36,768 --> 01:23:39,137
impact and I think ai writ large

1924
01:23:39,137 --> 01:23:40,772
is kind of a big trajectory of

1925
01:23:40,772 --> 01:23:43,172
the region. Particularly in

1926
01:23:43,675 --> 01:23:44,976
terms of jobs and opportunities.

1927
01:23:44,976 --> 01:23:46,278
So, they all get explored kind

1928
01:23:46,278 --> 01:23:47,680
of through the appropriate plan

1929
01:23:47,680 --> 01:23:49,480
phases. And I think as we

1930
01:23:49,480 --> 01:23:51,584
develop those road maps, we can

1931
01:23:51,584 --> 01:23:54,453
try to spell that out a little

1932
01:23:54,453 --> 01:23:56,555
bit more, like, okay, if you're

1933
01:23:56,555 --> 01:23:58,390
interested in this topic this is

1934
01:23:58,390 --> 01:24:00,158
the phase and work stream that

1935
01:24:00,158 --> 01:24:03,610
we would encourage you to follow

1936
01:24:03,610 --> 01:24:03,829
closely.

1937
01:24:03,829 --> 01:24:06,229
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1938
01:24:06,531 --> 01:24:08,633
thank you. Next we have council

1939
01:24:08,633 --> 01:24:09,267
member duong.

1940
01:24:09,267 --> 01:24:12,267
>>bryant duong: thank you for

1941
01:24:12,871 --> 01:24:14,871
the presentation. Foundations

1942
01:24:18,643 --> 01:24:21,614
for me, is, settled -- but most

1943
01:24:21,614 --> 01:24:24,783
decided. But one thing I would

1944
01:24:24,783 --> 01:24:26,585
encourage us to keep front and

1945
01:24:26,585 --> 01:24:28,585
center is implementation

1946
01:24:28,988 --> 01:24:30,555
feasibility. In my community

1947
01:24:30,555 --> 01:24:31,891
development work I see a gap

1948
01:24:31,891 --> 01:24:33,258
sometimes between setting

1949
01:24:33,258 --> 01:24:35,127
regional goals particularly as

1950
01:24:35,127 --> 01:24:36,661
it relates to housing, and

1951
01:24:36,661 --> 01:24:38,997
having ecosystem needed to

1952
01:24:38,997 --> 01:24:40,499
actually deliver them, whether

1953
01:24:40,499 --> 01:24:42,670
that's project pipeline,

1954
01:24:42,670 --> 01:24:42,802
predevelopment resources,

1955
01:24:42,802 --> 01:24:43,602
organizational capacity, or

1956
01:24:43,602 --> 01:24:46,200
coordination across agencies and

1957
01:24:46,339 --> 01:24:48,339
developers.

1958
01:24:49,700 --> 01:24:51,143
Since the foundations and

1959
01:24:51,143 --> 01:24:53,145
outlook phases will be

1960
01:24:53,145 --> 01:24:55,514
revisiting the land use

1961
01:24:55,514 --> 01:24:56,748
framework, evaluating existing

1962
01:24:56,748 --> 01:24:59,148
strategies, and testing growth

1963
01:24:59,416 --> 01:25:01,520
and fiscal assumptions, I think

1964
01:25:01,520 --> 01:25:03,540
this could be a good point to

1965
01:25:03,540 --> 01:25:05,560
make sure those strategies are

1966
01:25:05,560 --> 01:25:07,359
grounded in what actually it

1967
01:25:07,359 --> 01:25:09,161
takes to deliver housing. I

1968
01:25:09,161 --> 01:25:11,561
would be especially interested

1969
01:25:12,430 --> 01:25:15,434
in lessons about what has and

1970
01:25:15,434 --> 01:25:17,402
hasn't worked in prior plans,

1971
01:25:17,402 --> 01:25:19,370
what informed that analysis.

1972
01:25:19,370 --> 01:25:19,638
Thank you.

1973
01:25:19,638 --> 01:25:21,139
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1974
01:25:21,139 --> 01:25:23,410
thank you council member duong.

1975
01:25:23,410 --> 01:25:24,142
Was there a question -- was that

1976
01:25:24,142 --> 01:25:26,578
question something you want a

1977
01:25:26,578 --> 01:25:30,178
response for? Or was it more

1978
01:25:31,116 --> 01:25:33,118
like a rhetorical, like, broader

1979
01:25:33,118 --> 01:25:34,485
question?

1980
01:25:34,485 --> 01:25:36,154
>>bryant duong: perhaps just a

1981
01:25:36,154 --> 01:25:36,488
comment doesn't exactly get a

1982
01:25:36,488 --> 01:25:37,189
response.

1983
01:25:37,189 --> 01:25:39,124
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

1984
01:25:39,124 --> 01:25:41,920
okay. Thank you. Council

1985
01:25:41,920 --> 01:25:41,726
member trachtenberg?

1986
01:25:41,726 --> 01:25:42,428
>>gaetano trachtenberg: thank

1987
01:25:42,428 --> 01:25:44,229
you staff for the presentation

1988
01:25:44,229 --> 01:25:45,630
and the level-setting. It's

1989
01:25:45,630 --> 01:25:47,632
very helpful. And I appreciate

1990
01:25:47,632 --> 01:25:48,201
your comments, as well, council

1991
01:25:48,201 --> 01:25:50,201
member.

1992
01:25:51,690 --> 01:25:52,270
I really like the idea of these

1993
01:25:52,270 --> 01:25:54,506
coordination road maps. That

1994
01:25:54,506 --> 01:25:55,474
feels extremely helpful, and I

1995
01:25:55,474 --> 01:25:56,508
was wondering if you could

1996
01:25:56,508 --> 01:25:57,710
describe a little bit more

1997
01:25:57,710 --> 01:26:00,450
about, you know, what you are

1998
01:26:00,450 --> 01:26:01,914
imagining there, and when we

1999
01:26:01,914 --> 01:26:04,914
might expect seeing some version

2000
01:26:05,118 --> 01:26:08,118
of that, or another opportunity

2001
01:26:08,220 --> 01:26:11,220
to engage and maybe provide

2002
01:26:13,920 --> 01:26:14,193
feedback would be helpful to us.

2003
01:26:14,193 --> 01:26:16,329
>>chirag rabari: yes, I think

2004
01:26:16,329 --> 01:26:18,331
we're hoping to include maybe

2005
01:26:18,331 --> 01:26:21,331
the first iteration of these

2006
01:26:22,100 --> 01:26:23,801
road maps as part of our formal

2007
01:26:23,801 --> 01:26:25,304
kick offer item next month, and

2008
01:26:25,304 --> 01:26:26,705
we can ensure that council

2009
01:26:26,705 --> 01:26:28,407
members receive a copy of that.

2010
01:26:28,407 --> 01:26:31,344
I would just say briefly what it

2011
01:26:31,344 --> 01:26:34,447
will try to do is, through a

2012
01:26:34,447 --> 01:26:36,782
topic based lens, whether

2013
01:26:36,782 --> 01:26:38,782
transportation, housing, land

2014
01:26:40,180 --> 01:26:40,653
use growth, environmental

2015
01:26:40,653 --> 01:26:43,530
resilience, sort of, highlight

2016
01:26:44,890 --> 01:26:47,689
the big picture issues that, you

2017
01:26:50,228 --> 01:26:51,497
know, those particular tracks of

2018
01:26:51,497 --> 01:26:52,965
work are trying to address and

2019
01:26:52,965 --> 01:26:55,365
then provide a detailed

2020
01:26:55,667 --> 01:26:57,569
accounting of, like, which items

2021
01:26:57,569 --> 01:26:59,437
will be coming forward, how it

2022
01:26:59,437 --> 01:27:01,739
was likely to manifest in both

2023
01:27:01,739 --> 01:27:03,375
public and partner engagement

2024
01:27:03,375 --> 01:27:06,110
context. What some of the key

2025
01:27:06,110 --> 01:27:08,110
expected deliverables and

2026
01:27:08,460 --> 01:27:10,815
milestones will be for that --

2027
01:27:10,815 --> 01:27:12,150
those topics, and then, you

2028
01:27:12,150 --> 01:27:14,386
know, what are the kind of

2029
01:27:14,386 --> 01:27:15,922
keyboard level decisions, and

2030
01:27:15,922 --> 01:27:18,157
when. So, that way folks can,

2031
01:27:18,157 --> 01:27:20,859
you know, if -- you were

2032
01:27:20,859 --> 01:27:23,259
particularly interested in how

2033
01:27:23,930 --> 01:27:26,731
we think about the performance

2034
01:27:26,731 --> 01:27:28,700
of transportation strategies or

2035
01:27:28,700 --> 01:27:31,700
projects, for example, you know,

2036
01:27:31,771 --> 01:27:33,939
we're likely in the spring of

2037
01:27:33,939 --> 01:27:35,340
2027, putting forward, like, a

2038
01:27:35,340 --> 01:27:36,542
draft methodology. We would be

2039
01:27:36,542 --> 01:27:39,344
doing more analysis in the

2040
01:27:39,344 --> 01:27:41,913
spring of 2028. So, I think it

2041
01:27:41,913 --> 01:27:44,820
will hopefully just give folks a

2042
01:27:44,820 --> 01:27:45,250
better sense of, like, okay,

2043
01:27:45,250 --> 01:27:47,520
these are the things I care

2044
01:27:47,520 --> 01:27:51,156
about and these are the things I

2045
01:27:51,156 --> 01:27:53,590
should be paying attention and

2046
01:27:53,590 --> 01:27:53,660
plugging in.

2047
01:27:53,660 --> 01:27:55,393
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2048
01:27:55,393 --> 01:27:56,261
thank you. I noticed that

2049
01:27:56,261 --> 01:27:58,463
council member madrid just

2050
01:27:58,463 --> 01:28:01,833
joined us online. Do we need to

2051
01:28:01,833 --> 01:28:03,101
acknowledge? Or we can -- okay.

2052
01:28:03,101 --> 01:28:05,700
Thank you.

2053
01:28:05,700 --> 01:28:07,974
So we'll move on to the next

2054
01:28:07,974 --> 01:28:08,840
member in the queue member

2055
01:28:08,840 --> 01:28:09,508
baldini.

2056
01:28:09,508 --> 01:28:11,510
>>michael baldini: yes good

2057
01:28:11,510 --> 01:28:13,111
morning and thank you for the

2058
01:28:13,111 --> 01:28:15,511
presentation. And your comment

2059
01:28:16,414 --> 01:28:18,884
to my fellow council members,

2060
01:28:18,884 --> 01:28:20,485
regarding the slide of looking

2061
01:28:20,485 --> 01:28:22,885
at ambitious and visionary

2062
01:28:23,622 --> 01:28:26,622
projects, as well as the

2063
01:28:27,794 --> 01:28:30,194
benefits and the financial

2064
01:28:32,300 --> 01:28:34,430
tradeoffs, and the project

2065
01:28:35,468 --> 01:28:36,501
priorities. Then again, as I

2066
01:28:36,501 --> 01:28:38,870
have participated somewhat over

2067
01:28:38,870 --> 01:28:40,739
the past few years, you're

2068
01:28:40,739 --> 01:28:44,339
looking at what seems to be

2069
01:28:44,377 --> 01:28:47,179
moving ahead without regard to

2070
01:28:47,179 --> 01:28:50,150
any, sort of -- and I'm reminded

2071
01:28:50,150 --> 01:28:52,415
of the conversation between

2072
01:28:53,919 --> 01:28:55,554
admiral kirk and spock in the

2073
01:28:55,554 --> 01:28:58,491
dying moments in the needs of

2074
01:28:58,491 --> 01:29:00,593
the -- many outweigh the needs

2075
01:29:00,593 --> 01:29:03,161
of the few or the one. And

2076
01:29:03,161 --> 01:29:06,970
that's now how we look at the

2077
01:29:06,970 --> 01:29:08,700
disabled population, or even the

2078
01:29:08,700 --> 01:29:11,602
bicycle coalition in many of our

2079
01:29:11,602 --> 01:29:14,239
decisions. But looking at cost.

2080
01:29:14,239 --> 01:29:16,608
And it's difficult for me to

2081
01:29:16,608 --> 01:29:18,176
wrap around, and what I'm

2082
01:29:18,176 --> 01:29:19,845
looking forward as for as my

2083
01:29:19,845 --> 01:29:22,180
answer is how will these be

2084
01:29:22,180 --> 01:29:25,151
addressed as I drill down, like

2085
01:29:25,151 --> 01:29:28,151
spending $6.7 billion to go a

2086
01:29:28,221 --> 01:29:31,821
couple of miles from 4th street

2087
01:29:31,958 --> 01:29:34,590
station in caltrain to

2088
01:29:34,590 --> 01:29:36,729
salesforce tower. The north bay

2089
01:29:36,729 --> 01:29:38,763
could use $6.7 billion, when

2090
01:29:38,763 --> 01:29:41,166
let's say you could walk or take

2091
01:29:41,166 --> 01:29:44,137
a cab for 3 to $11, you could

2092
01:29:44,137 --> 01:29:47,106
take a bus for $2. That's

2093
01:29:47,106 --> 01:29:49,506
enough to pay 600 million

2094
01:29:49,575 --> 01:29:52,575
passengers -- people that were

2095
01:29:52,712 --> 01:29:53,912
going to go to salesforce tower

2096
01:29:53,912 --> 01:29:55,980
anywhere in the city. So then

2097
01:29:55,980 --> 01:29:57,149
you're looking at diridon, as

2098
01:29:57,149 --> 01:29:59,318
well, when you're giving more

2099
01:29:59,318 --> 01:30:00,852
money -- and I don't mean you, I

2100
01:30:00,852 --> 01:30:04,452
mean the mtc, in general, and

2101
01:30:04,488 --> 01:30:07,488
the taxpayers, giving more money

2102
01:30:09,761 --> 01:30:10,996
to connect, you know, six miles

2103
01:30:10,996 --> 01:30:13,996
of bart who already hasn't

2104
01:30:14,650 --> 01:30:16,670
demonstrated that they know how

2105
01:30:16,670 --> 01:30:17,203
to manage money, giving them

2106
01:30:17,203 --> 01:30:19,404
more to manage and operate as

2107
01:30:19,404 --> 01:30:23,400
far as budget. So, are we

2108
01:30:24,810 --> 01:30:28,410
actually going to say, no this

2109
01:30:29,816 --> 01:30:32,317
doesn't work? Or doesn't make

2110
01:30:32,317 --> 01:30:34,287
sense, given our little post

2111
01:30:34,287 --> 01:30:37,656
money. Or do we just ask and

2112
01:30:37,656 --> 01:30:41,526
ask and ask, I haven't had a pay

2113
01:30:41,526 --> 01:30:43,280
raise in three years and I'm a

2114
01:30:43,280 --> 01:30:45,290
general population but do we

2115
01:30:45,290 --> 01:30:47,299
continue to carry the burden of

2116
01:30:47,299 --> 01:30:50,603
these projects that some make no

2117
01:30:50,603 --> 01:30:52,205
sense at all and I understand to

2118
01:30:52,205 --> 01:30:54,105
one or many it means a lot but

2119
01:30:54,105 --> 01:30:55,807
it's difficult to see these

2120
01:30:55,807 --> 01:30:58,544
numbers and actual benefits that

2121
01:30:58,544 --> 01:31:00,780
we have as far as our agencies,

2122
01:31:00,780 --> 01:31:03,780
27 of them, manage their funds

2123
01:31:04,383 --> 01:31:06,818
and taxpayer money, so I would

2124
01:31:06,818 --> 01:31:09,555
like to see really dig down deep

2125
01:31:09,555 --> 01:31:12,724
as how does this benefit the

2126
01:31:12,724 --> 01:31:15,361
network? I still can't get to

2127
01:31:15,361 --> 01:31:16,996
napa or sonoma from here without

2128
01:31:16,996 --> 01:31:18,430
multiple hours of my day spent

2129
01:31:18,430 --> 01:31:20,265
travelling and non-productive.

2130
01:31:20,265 --> 01:31:22,367
And so looking at these major

2131
01:31:22,367 --> 01:31:24,690
projects and many of the smaller

2132
01:31:24,690 --> 01:31:25,871
projects t doesn't make sense.

2133
01:31:25,871 --> 01:31:27,205
Livermore valley connecting 300

2134
01:31:27,205 --> 01:31:29,208
feet or whatever, that means

2135
01:31:29,208 --> 01:31:32,440
somebody in a wheelchair has to

2136
01:31:32,440 --> 01:31:33,912
have an umbrella get out of the

2137
01:31:33,912 --> 01:31:35,413
train and get on to another

2138
01:31:35,413 --> 01:31:37,549
vehicle and off they go. So

2139
01:31:37,549 --> 01:31:40,151
looking at that last mile. It's

2140
01:31:40,151 --> 01:31:42,254
kind of frustrating to see these

2141
01:31:42,254 --> 01:31:43,455
expenditures and hope this will

2142
01:31:43,455 --> 01:31:44,823
provide some answers when we get

2143
01:31:44,823 --> 01:31:46,758
down to t thank you very much

2144
01:31:46,758 --> 01:31:47,359
for your time.

2145
01:31:47,359 --> 01:31:48,660
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2146
01:31:48,660 --> 01:31:51,660
thank you for your comments

2147
01:31:52,300 --> 01:31:54,300
council member baldini.

2148
01:31:54,700 --> 01:31:55,935
Council member saunders is next

2149
01:31:55,935 --> 01:31:56,835
on the queue.

2150
01:31:56,835 --> 01:31:59,235
>>joshua saunders: thank you.

2151
01:32:00,572 --> 01:32:03,750
I wanted to mention -- and

2152
01:32:03,750 --> 01:32:04,176
thafrngsz thanks for the

2153
01:32:04,176 --> 01:32:05,143
presentation. I'm glad that in

2154
01:32:05,143 --> 01:32:06,979
the presentation you brought up

2155
01:32:06,979 --> 01:32:08,140
the sea level rise and the cost

2156
01:32:08,140 --> 01:32:09,414
of sea level rise, and one of

2157
01:32:09,414 --> 01:32:11,550
the questions I was just going

2158
01:32:11,550 --> 01:32:13,485
to put out there was, I know

2159
01:32:13,485 --> 01:32:15,387
it's hard to quantify, but I'm

2160
01:32:15,387 --> 01:32:17,789
wondering if you have a sense of

2161
01:32:17,789 --> 01:32:19,524
how much these costs are going

2162
01:32:19,524 --> 01:32:21,527
to be, and how much they're

2163
01:32:21,527 --> 01:32:23,495
going to take from other sources

2164
01:32:23,495 --> 01:32:27,950
and other things we could be

2165
01:32:27,990 --> 01:32:30,990
doing with our resources, and

2166
01:32:31,970 --> 01:32:33,806
how much that would impact it?

2167
01:32:33,806 --> 01:32:35,407
And my other question has to do

2168
01:32:35,407 --> 01:32:36,741
with e-bike technology. And the

2169
01:32:36,741 --> 01:32:38,845
reason I bring up this is I live

2170
01:32:38,845 --> 01:32:41,680
in the east bay area, and I walk

2171
01:32:41,680 --> 01:32:44,680
along the ohlone greenway often,

2172
01:32:44,816 --> 01:32:46,852
and I will see -- and I have

2173
01:32:46,852 --> 01:32:48,860
some vision, I'll see zipping

2174
01:32:48,860 --> 01:32:49,121
past me, and I'm wondering

2175
01:32:49,121 --> 01:32:52,580
sooner or later, someone is

2176
01:32:52,580 --> 01:32:53,959
going to hit me. I mean, people

2177
01:32:53,959 --> 01:32:55,427
are people, and they make their

2178
01:32:55,427 --> 01:32:58,798
mistakes. I reached out to the

2179
01:32:58,798 --> 01:33:02,234
poem at the local level, you

2180
01:33:02,234 --> 01:33:04,736
know, my COUNCILMAN And staff,

2181
01:33:04,736 --> 01:33:07,607
in el cerrito, and I'm just

2182
01:33:07,607 --> 01:33:09,841
wondering how that ties into

2183
01:33:09,841 --> 01:33:10,509
what you at mtc are doing with

2184
01:33:10,509 --> 01:33:11,108
that. Thank you.

2185
01:33:11,108 --> 01:33:12,110
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2186
01:33:12,110 --> 01:33:13,411
thank you member saunders just

2187
01:33:13,411 --> 01:33:15,800
because there are two questions

2188
01:33:15,800 --> 01:33:16,548
about cost and then separate

2189
01:33:16,548 --> 01:33:17,548
question about e-bikes and

2190
01:33:17,548 --> 01:33:19,948
disability community, just going

2191
01:33:20,386 --> 01:33:22,521
to pause to see if staff wants

2192
01:33:22,521 --> 01:33:23,122
to respond to those before

2193
01:33:23,122 --> 01:33:25,122
moving on?

2194
01:33:25,157 --> 01:33:26,459
>>chirag rabari: yes, on the --

2195
01:33:26,459 --> 01:33:27,826
thank you for that question

2196
01:33:27,826 --> 01:33:29,528
member saunders. On the sea

2197
01:33:29,528 --> 01:33:31,329
level rise, you know, we have

2198
01:33:31,329 --> 01:33:32,664
been collaborating with bcdc on

2199
01:33:32,664 --> 01:33:35,664
this work over several years,

2200
01:33:35,967 --> 01:33:36,968
and you know, we do -- we have

2201
01:33:36,968 --> 01:33:38,968
developed various cost

2202
01:33:40,639 --> 01:33:43,639
estimates, which is, you know,

2203
01:33:43,909 --> 01:33:46,378
in order to adapt the entire bay

2204
01:33:46,378 --> 01:33:50,482
to up to five feet of water

2205
01:33:50,482 --> 01:33:54,820
rise, you know, it would cost

2206
01:33:56,154 --> 01:33:58,154
approximately $100 billion, or

2207
01:33:58,156 --> 01:34:01,156
thereabouts, looking all the way

2208
01:34:01,760 --> 01:34:02,829
out to 2050, you know, the

2209
01:34:02,829 --> 01:34:04,330
analytical teams have also done

2210
01:34:04,330 --> 01:34:06,265
estimates of what the cost of

2211
01:34:06,265 --> 01:34:08,400
not adapting the bay could be,

2212
01:34:08,400 --> 01:34:12,338
and you know, these are on order

2213
01:34:12,338 --> 01:34:15,338
of 2 to 3 times in magnitude.

2214
01:34:16,342 --> 01:34:16,875
You know, this space, there is

2215
01:34:16,875 --> 01:34:18,875
certainly less available

2216
01:34:19,778 --> 01:34:21,980
resources in terms of how to

2217
01:34:21,980 --> 01:34:24,516
fund that adaptation, and, you

2218
01:34:24,516 --> 01:34:26,840
know, I think that's simple

2219
01:34:26,840 --> 01:34:27,953
y an

2220
01:34:27,953 --> 01:34:30,220
aspect that we want to continue

2221
01:34:30,220 --> 01:34:31,624
to highlight and exploring for

2222
01:34:31,624 --> 01:34:35,128
our, as a region in terms of

2223
01:34:35,128 --> 01:34:37,597
what would it take to pursue

2224
01:34:37,597 --> 01:34:39,597
these different adaptation

2225
01:34:40,165 --> 01:34:42,367
pathways and how might we

2226
01:34:42,367 --> 01:34:45,367
respond if there were not

2227
01:34:51,244 --> 01:34:53,644
greater levels of resources

2228
01:34:57,817 --> 01:35:00,118
available. On the e-bikes the

2229
01:35:00,118 --> 01:35:01,586
plan context certainly an area

2230
01:35:01,586 --> 01:35:03,756
one of the plan strategies

2231
01:35:03,756 --> 01:35:05,924
existing plan strategies has to

2232
01:35:05,924 --> 01:35:07,994
do with speed limits on

2233
01:35:07,994 --> 01:35:09,427
highways, speed limits on

2234
01:35:09,427 --> 01:35:11,296
roadways, perhaps there is

2235
01:35:11,296 --> 01:35:12,365
something related to bike speed

2236
01:35:12,365 --> 01:35:13,800
limits and that could be

2237
01:35:13,800 --> 01:35:14,466
explored and we could

2238
01:35:14,466 --> 01:35:15,667
demonstrate what the potential

2239
01:35:15,667 --> 01:35:18,667
safety benefits of that could

2240
01:35:19,237 --> 01:35:21,373
be. So I think this is

2241
01:35:21,373 --> 01:35:22,742
definitely something that's on

2242
01:35:22,742 --> 01:35:24,844
our radar and we're interested

2243
01:35:24,844 --> 01:35:26,445
in discussing further with our

2244
01:35:26,445 --> 01:35:27,613
different partners who are more

2245
01:35:27,613 --> 01:35:28,346
engaged in this space.

2246
01:35:28,346 --> 01:35:30,746
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2247
01:35:32,484 --> 01:35:34,884
thank you. Member cushman?

2248
01:35:35,555 --> 01:35:37,623
>>warren cushman: okay. So I

2249
01:35:37,623 --> 01:35:39,925
want to talk about three

2250
01:35:39,925 --> 01:35:41,259
categories each one a little

2251
01:35:41,259 --> 01:35:43,362
bit. First with transportation.

2252
01:35:43,362 --> 01:35:45,230
It's a huge category, I think

2253
01:35:45,230 --> 01:35:47,200
the themes I'm thinking of is

2254
01:35:47,200 --> 01:35:49,569
needs and tradeoffs, and how the

2255
01:35:49,569 --> 01:35:52,700
needs and tradeoffs balance out.

2256
01:35:52,700 --> 01:35:53,738
In the realm of transportation,

2257
01:35:53,738 --> 01:35:55,639
one of the things I noticed is a

2258
01:35:55,639 --> 01:35:57,476
lot of funding is spent in the

2259
01:35:57,476 --> 01:35:58,677
rail realm, and I live in

2260
01:35:58,677 --> 01:36:01,113
alameda county where a lot of

2261
01:36:01,113 --> 01:36:04,182
buses are being used. And, so

2262
01:36:04,182 --> 01:36:07,320
one tradeoff that I wonder about

2263
01:36:07,320 --> 01:36:10,156
is how to balance the needs of

2264
01:36:10,156 --> 01:36:12,624
all of the 27 different transit

2265
01:36:12,624 --> 01:36:14,559
agencies, and how some of those

2266
01:36:14,559 --> 01:36:16,828
MAY be more rail focused and

2267
01:36:16,828 --> 01:36:18,997
some MAY be more bus focused,

2268
01:36:18,997 --> 01:36:20,966
and how you balance those needs

2269
01:36:20,966 --> 01:36:23,100
all across communities. With

2270
01:36:23,100 --> 01:36:26,601
regard to the public rights of

2271
01:36:26,906 --> 01:36:29,308
way piece, or the pedestrian

2272
01:36:29,308 --> 01:36:30,876
piece, I do think that there are

2273
01:36:30,876 --> 01:36:33,612
also tradeoffs and needs there.

2274
01:36:33,612 --> 01:36:36,215
I would foe further than

2275
01:36:36,215 --> 01:36:37,949
roadways. I would think about

2276
01:36:37,949 --> 01:36:39,818
the sidewalk as a shared space,

2277
01:36:39,818 --> 01:36:42,555
and thinking about how to

2278
01:36:42,555 --> 01:36:44,230
navigate that. One of the

2279
01:36:44,230 --> 01:36:46,910
struggles that blind folks have

2280
01:36:46,910 --> 01:36:49,270
are around e scooters or

2281
01:36:49,270 --> 01:36:51,130
scooters, and how some of those

2282
01:36:51,130 --> 01:36:52,831
can create safety challenges for

2283
01:36:52,831 --> 01:36:55,660
blind folks and I'm sure other

2284
01:36:55,660 --> 01:36:57,769
folks as well. So, I think the

2285
01:36:57,769 --> 01:37:00,739
whole public rights of way, sort

2286
01:37:00,739 --> 01:37:03,676
of, space, or the pedestrian

2287
01:37:03,676 --> 01:37:05,410
space needs to be looked at.

2288
01:37:05,410 --> 01:37:07,145
And I don't know how to -- some

2289
01:37:07,145 --> 01:37:07,947
women call it active

2290
01:37:07,947 --> 01:37:09,748
transportation. I think that

2291
01:37:09,748 --> 01:37:10,849
space needs to be looked at more

2292
01:37:10,849 --> 01:37:13,685
broadly. In the housing space,

2293
01:37:13,685 --> 01:37:16,540
I just want to say that's a huge

2294
01:37:16,540 --> 01:37:17,656
topic and a huge category. I

2295
01:37:17,656 --> 01:37:19,758
hope we go deeper in housing.

2296
01:37:19,758 --> 01:37:20,860
There are a lot of aspects, and

2297
01:37:20,860 --> 01:37:22,661
I'm not going to be talking

2298
01:37:22,661 --> 01:37:25,363
about all of them here, but I

2299
01:37:25,363 --> 01:37:26,765
think we need to think about

2300
01:37:26,765 --> 01:37:28,765
housing, deeply affordable

2301
01:37:29,100 --> 01:37:30,703
housing for people who struggle,

2302
01:37:30,703 --> 01:37:33,905
and who are either homeless or

2303
01:37:33,905 --> 01:37:36,474
close to it. I think in terms

2304
01:37:36,474 --> 01:37:39,474
of universal design and access,

2305
01:37:40,145 --> 01:37:42,948
that's a big housing issue. And

2306
01:37:42,948 --> 01:37:44,349
then tenant protections. Then

2307
01:37:44,349 --> 01:37:45,750
finally in the realm of

2308
01:37:45,750 --> 01:37:47,860
environmental piece and sea

2309
01:37:47,860 --> 01:37:49,955
level rise and all that, I would

2310
01:37:49,955 --> 01:37:52,757
just SARAs we think about 2060

2311
01:37:52,757 --> 01:37:54,926
that, topic of sea level rise,

2312
01:37:54,926 --> 01:37:55,928
environmental concerns, disaster

2313
01:37:55,928 --> 01:37:57,729
preparedness, and preparing for

2314
01:37:57,729 --> 01:37:58,697
what's to come, is going to be

2315
01:37:58,697 --> 01:38:00,331
so much more important as we

2316
01:38:00,331 --> 01:38:02,534
MARCH on through the years. I

2317
01:38:02,534 --> 01:38:04,360
hope that we will be talking

2318
01:38:04,360 --> 01:38:05,737
about disaster preparedness,

2319
01:38:05,737 --> 01:38:07,439
preparing for fires,

2320
01:38:07,439 --> 01:38:09,141
earthquakes, floods, and also

2321
01:38:09,141 --> 01:38:11,543
thinking about preparing for the

2322
01:38:11,543 --> 01:38:13,543
environmental challenges we're

2323
01:38:16,148 --> 01:38:16,748
all facing. Thank you.

2324
01:38:16,748 --> 01:38:18,351
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2325
01:38:18,351 --> 01:38:20,352
thank you member cushman. Have

2326
01:38:20,352 --> 01:38:22,821
I also third theme come up

2327
01:38:22,821 --> 01:38:25,821
twice, how to balance the

2328
01:38:28,590 --> 01:38:30,459
different 27 transit agencies in

2329
01:38:30,595 --> 01:38:32,698
the plan, can staff -- give

2330
01:38:32,698 --> 01:38:33,298
opportunity to respond to that.

2331
01:38:33,298 --> 01:38:34,132
>>chirag rabari: thank you

2332
01:38:34,132 --> 01:38:35,133
chair lieu thank you member

2333
01:38:35,133 --> 01:38:36,768
cushman for the question, as

2334
01:38:36,768 --> 01:38:38,770
well as member baldini. I think

2335
01:38:38,770 --> 01:38:40,539
one thing I do want to maybe

2336
01:38:40,539 --> 01:38:42,841
point to as something that we're

2337
01:38:42,841 --> 01:38:45,410
hoping to build off of is the

2338
01:38:45,410 --> 01:38:47,646
work that we did in

2339
01:38:47,646 --> 01:38:49,648
collaboration with our transit

2340
01:38:49,648 --> 01:38:51,216
operators in transit 2050+ which

2341
01:38:51,216 --> 01:38:53,251
is part of the most recently

2342
01:38:53,251 --> 01:38:56,251
adopted long range plan. And

2343
01:38:56,288 --> 01:38:59,524
this did really try to lean more

2344
01:38:59,524 --> 01:39:01,993
into a network and service

2345
01:39:01,993 --> 01:39:03,562
oriented vision for the region's

2346
01:39:03,562 --> 01:39:06,562
transit. You know, with the

2347
01:39:06,998 --> 01:39:08,300
idea of in the near-term, we

2348
01:39:08,300 --> 01:39:10,700
really have to prioritize

2349
01:39:10,702 --> 01:39:11,937
service and customer focused

2350
01:39:11,937 --> 01:39:14,937
improvements, while at the same

2351
01:39:15,907 --> 01:39:17,576
time, you know, planning for our

2352
01:39:17,576 --> 01:39:19,976
long-term needs through capital

2353
01:39:20,246 --> 01:39:21,346
in, you know, major capital

2354
01:39:21,346 --> 01:39:22,982
investments. I think we

2355
01:39:22,982 --> 01:39:25,217
understand that the fiscal

2356
01:39:25,217 --> 01:39:26,518
picture is shifting, and is

2357
01:39:26,518 --> 01:39:28,353
likely to be more challenging

2358
01:39:28,353 --> 01:39:29,921
and that is where we hope to

2359
01:39:29,921 --> 01:39:31,356
bring all of our different

2360
01:39:31,356 --> 01:39:33,580
partners and stakeholders

2361
01:39:33,580 --> 01:39:34,593
together to really look at some

2362
01:39:34,593 --> 01:39:36,595
of these different scenarios and

2363
01:39:36,595 --> 01:39:38,230
to think about, well, what are

2364
01:39:38,230 --> 01:39:40,499
our shared priorities in a

2365
01:39:40,499 --> 01:39:42,868
future where there MAY be less

2366
01:39:42,868 --> 01:39:45,670
resources. But, you know, this

2367
01:39:45,670 --> 01:39:46,972
is a topic that has many

2368
01:39:46,972 --> 01:39:48,272
different interests, many

2369
01:39:48,272 --> 01:39:49,741
different priorities, and i

2370
01:39:49,741 --> 01:39:52,310
think to the extent possible, we

2371
01:39:52,310 --> 01:39:54,450
want the plan to be a venue that

2372
01:39:54,450 --> 01:39:57,450
can bring folks together and

2373
01:39:57,449 --> 01:39:59,785
find, like, the best version of

2374
01:39:59,785 --> 01:40:03,385
regional consensus as we can, as

2375
01:40:06,692 --> 01:40:07,292
we develop the long range plan.

2376
01:40:07,292 --> 01:40:09,127
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2377
01:40:09,127 --> 01:40:12,664
thank you. I see three hands in

2378
01:40:12,664 --> 01:40:15,664
the zoom space, member madrid,

2379
01:40:17,502 --> 01:40:17,769
mirante and hankerson. Member

2380
01:40:17,769 --> 01:40:19,337
madrid?

2381
01:40:19,337 --> 01:40:21,737
>>alexander madrid: thank you

2382
01:40:26,311 --> 01:40:29,311
for the presentation. This was

2383
01:40:32,818 --> 01:40:36,418
mentioned, I want to ask the

2384
01:40:39,758 --> 01:40:42,128
question, is it worthy, good for

2385
01:40:42,128 --> 01:40:45,128
the transportation space, but I

2386
01:40:45,230 --> 01:40:48,830
noticed there is a lot of

2387
01:40:55,307 --> 01:40:57,707
accidents in san francisco

2388
01:40:58,544 --> 01:41:00,544
regarding people using

2389
01:41:01,947 --> 01:41:03,947
sidewalks. Scooters and

2390
01:41:15,660 --> 01:41:18,600
sometimes e-bikes, using, some

2391
01:41:21,801 --> 01:41:24,803
people you run over them, we

2392
01:41:24,803 --> 01:41:26,371
talked to people in san

2393
01:41:26,371 --> 01:41:29,371
francisco, and they said they

2394
01:41:34,112 --> 01:41:37,112
cannot cite them unless only

2395
01:41:37,415 --> 01:41:40,415
police department only can do

2396
01:41:41,721 --> 01:41:44,721
that. And I understand you

2397
01:41:44,756 --> 01:41:47,756
mentioned about speed limit, and

2398
01:41:49,261 --> 01:41:52,861
right now it doesn't work. And

2399
01:41:57,200 --> 01:41:59,237
also companies tend to try to

2400
01:41:59,237 --> 01:42:02,308
mitigate and it doesn't work as

2401
01:42:02,308 --> 01:42:07,108
of now. So, I just want to hear

2402
01:42:12,518 --> 01:42:16,718
from you on how do you mitigate

2403
01:42:21,226 --> 01:42:21,960
and how to plan to prevent it

2404
01:42:21,960 --> 01:42:24,360
happening. Of course, you're

2405
01:42:26,264 --> 01:42:29,264
going to talk to partner

2406
01:42:30,335 --> 01:42:32,735
agencies, but, again, but,

2407
01:42:36,541 --> 01:42:39,541
again, talk is cheap, and

2408
01:42:40,712 --> 01:42:43,112
planning implementation is what

2409
01:42:45,840 --> 01:42:45,917
I'm looking to do. Thank you.

2410
01:42:45,917 --> 01:42:47,850
>>chair, carina vinh lieu: I

2411
01:42:47,850 --> 01:42:49,121
thank all our council members

2412
01:42:49,121 --> 01:42:50,555
for highlighting these issues

2413
01:42:50,555 --> 01:42:52,955
around policy and also

2414
01:42:53,191 --> 01:42:54,693
enforcement around, like,

2415
01:42:54,693 --> 01:42:56,361
different modes, especially for

2416
01:42:56,361 --> 01:42:58,163
our communities with disability.

2417
01:42:58,163 --> 01:42:59,464
So, sounds like this was a topic

2418
01:42:59,464 --> 01:43:01,601
that definitely could be

2419
01:43:01,601 --> 01:43:02,668
addressed here. I'm going to

2420
01:43:02,668 --> 01:43:06,268
give staff a chance to respond

2421
01:43:06,305 --> 01:43:07,506
to that.

2422
01:43:07,506 --> 01:43:09,506
>>chirag rabari: certainly.

2423
01:43:09,608 --> 01:43:10,442
Thank you member madrid for the

2424
01:43:10,442 --> 01:43:11,777
comment. We have certainly

2425
01:43:11,777 --> 01:43:13,578
heard a lot about this issue,

2426
01:43:13,578 --> 01:43:16,348
and I think, you know, our

2427
01:43:16,348 --> 01:43:19,348
commitment is to really work

2428
01:43:19,718 --> 01:43:21,153
with our partners to try to

2429
01:43:21,153 --> 01:43:22,687
determine what the best solution

2430
01:43:22,687 --> 01:43:25,870
in the long-range planning

2431
01:43:25,624 --> 01:43:26,992
context is. You know, I want to

2432
01:43:26,992 --> 01:43:29,992
be honest and transparent that,

2433
01:43:30,610 --> 01:43:31,763
you know, the long range plan

2434
01:43:31,763 --> 01:43:32,931
does include a lot of very

2435
01:43:32,931 --> 01:43:35,331
ambitious strategies related to

2436
01:43:35,467 --> 01:43:36,434
safety, related to vision zero,

2437
01:43:36,434 --> 01:43:37,968
related to active

2438
01:43:37,968 --> 01:43:40,710
transportation, related to speed

2439
01:43:40,710 --> 01:43:42,507
limits. I think the challenge

2440
01:43:42,507 --> 01:43:44,409
has been on the implementation

2441
01:43:44,409 --> 01:43:45,477
side. So, you know, I think

2442
01:43:45,477 --> 01:43:47,479
there are certain additional

2443
01:43:47,479 --> 01:43:49,381
things that we can explore in

2444
01:43:49,381 --> 01:43:51,249
the long-range planning context.

2445
01:43:51,249 --> 01:43:54,620
There are summer things we can

2446
01:43:54,620 --> 01:43:56,922
do in terms of communications

2447
01:43:56,922 --> 01:43:58,957
and emphasis. But the challenge

2448
01:43:58,957 --> 01:44:00,592
is always translating that plan

2449
01:44:00,592 --> 01:44:02,694
into reality. And I think

2450
01:44:02,694 --> 01:44:05,564
that's where, as we develop our

2451
01:44:05,564 --> 01:44:07,299
implementation plan and we think

2452
01:44:07,299 --> 01:44:08,600
about near-term priorities, that

2453
01:44:08,600 --> 01:44:10,936
is certainly something that we

2454
01:44:10,936 --> 01:44:13,338
can explore, but, you know, we

2455
01:44:13,338 --> 01:44:15,639
have a vision zero and safety

2456
01:44:15,639 --> 01:44:17,342
program internally. I know many

2457
01:44:17,342 --> 01:44:18,910
of our partners have their own

2458
01:44:18,910 --> 01:44:20,712
programs, and you know, this

2459
01:44:20,712 --> 01:44:22,714
could just be a -- a --

2460
01:44:22,714 --> 01:44:24,116
something that, you know, we

2461
01:44:24,116 --> 01:44:25,684
need to explore through multiple

2462
01:44:25,684 --> 01:44:28,684
avenues, while also finding the

2463
01:44:29,887 --> 01:44:31,356
right kind of angle in a long

2464
01:44:31,356 --> 01:44:32,357
range plan.

2465
01:44:32,357 --> 01:44:34,459
>>alexander madrid: so can you

2466
01:44:34,459 --> 01:44:38,659
tell us a little bit of that

2467
01:44:40,599 --> 01:44:43,599
idea right now? You mentioned

2468
01:44:44,103 --> 01:44:45,904
you are exploring those ideas.

2469
01:44:45,904 --> 01:44:50,104
Can you tell us some of those

2470
01:44:52,110 --> 01:44:54,179
right now, if you MAY?

2471
01:44:54,179 --> 01:44:56,810
>>chirag rabari: yes. So, I

2472
01:44:56,810 --> 01:44:57,983
think, again, in the long-range

2473
01:44:57,983 --> 01:45:00,983
planning context, we think about

2474
01:45:01,620 --> 01:45:02,954
these long-term policies and

2475
01:45:02,954 --> 01:45:05,354
investments that we can

2476
01:45:06,424 --> 01:45:08,727
implement. So, you know, maybe

2477
01:45:08,727 --> 01:45:10,495
there are revisions or

2478
01:45:10,495 --> 01:45:12,497
clarifications that we can make

2479
01:45:12,497 --> 01:45:14,897
to our existing safety

2480
01:45:15,367 --> 01:45:17,569
strategies or existing vision

2481
01:45:17,569 --> 01:45:19,738
zero strategies, as we think

2482
01:45:19,738 --> 01:45:22,138
about our potential investments

2483
01:45:23,809 --> 01:45:24,943
at a programmatic level, in

2484
01:45:24,943 --> 01:45:26,440
active transportation, are there

2485
01:45:26,440 --> 01:45:28,440
additional investments that

2486
01:45:28,790 --> 01:45:29,548
could potentially be highlighted

2487
01:45:29,548 --> 01:45:30,916
that could address some of the

2488
01:45:30,916 --> 01:45:33,916
challenges in this space. And

2489
01:45:34,286 --> 01:45:34,954
then, again, as we develop that

2490
01:45:34,954 --> 01:45:36,954
near-term implementation plan,

2491
01:45:37,989 --> 01:45:40,859
are there maybe, you know,

2492
01:45:40,859 --> 01:45:42,270
further studies or programmatic

2493
01:45:42,270 --> 01:45:44,296
efforts that mtc abag could

2494
01:45:44,296 --> 01:45:45,464
commit to that, again, will

2495
01:45:45,464 --> 01:45:47,980
speak more directly to these

2496
01:45:47,980 --> 01:45:48,990
challenges. So, those are just

2497
01:45:48,990 --> 01:45:51,503
some of the ideas on the table.

2498
01:45:51,503 --> 01:45:54,239
But, you know, we know that a

2499
01:45:54,239 --> 01:45:56,942
lot of our implementing partners

2500
01:45:56,942 --> 01:45:58,945
at the cities and their public

2501
01:45:58,945 --> 01:46:00,312
works departments, at the, you

2502
01:46:00,312 --> 01:46:02,281
know, the various different

2503
01:46:02,281 --> 01:46:03,548
operators, this is something

2504
01:46:03,548 --> 01:46:05,917
that's front of mind for them,

2505
01:46:05,917 --> 01:46:08,954
as well, and do look forward to

2506
01:46:08,954 --> 01:46:11,823
exploring with them over the

2507
01:46:11,823 --> 01:46:12,858
multi-year playing process. --

2508
01:46:12,858 --> 01:46:13,425
planning process.

2509
01:46:13,425 --> 01:46:14,392
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2510
01:46:14,392 --> 01:46:15,827
thank you. Just to be mindful

2511
01:46:15,827 --> 01:46:17,896
that there are two more people

2512
01:46:17,896 --> 01:46:20,310
in the queue, I want to move on

2513
01:46:20,310 --> 01:46:22,431
to member mirante's question,

2514
01:46:23,335 --> 01:46:25,203
and member hankerson's question.

2515
01:46:25,203 --> 01:46:26,671
Member mirante.

2516
01:46:26,671 --> 01:46:27,572
>>louis mirante: thank you. No

2517
01:46:27,572 --> 01:46:29,775
specific question. I'm just

2518
01:46:29,775 --> 01:46:30,842
hoping you can tell us a little

2519
01:46:30,842 --> 01:46:32,544
bit more about the threats you

2520
01:46:32,544 --> 01:46:33,678
have identified to planning for

2521
01:46:33,678 --> 01:46:35,113
race equity in this document

2522
01:46:35,113 --> 01:46:38,113
from the federal government and

2523
01:46:39,518 --> 01:46:42,518
how mtc abag are anticipating

2524
01:46:44,389 --> 01:46:44,990
insulating ourselves from that?

2525
01:46:44,990 --> 01:46:46,358
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2526
01:46:46,358 --> 01:46:47,459
thank you for that member

2527
01:46:47,459 --> 01:46:49,427
mirante. Since we also have

2528
01:46:49,427 --> 01:46:51,563
member hankerson in the queue.

2529
01:46:51,563 --> 01:46:53,799
We'll let you ask your question,

2530
01:46:53,799 --> 01:46:56,902
and see if staff can circle back

2531
01:46:56,902 --> 01:46:58,469
with an answer for both. Member

2532
01:46:58,469 --> 01:46:59,471
hankerson?

2533
01:46:59,471 --> 01:47:02,471
>>dwayne hankerson: I just want

2534
01:47:02,641 --> 01:47:04,376
to know -- oh, thank you for the

2535
01:47:04,376 --> 01:47:05,877
presentation I thought it was

2536
01:47:05,877 --> 01:47:07,646
straightforward and really

2537
01:47:07,646 --> 01:47:10,315
appreciate it. I just wanted to

2538
01:47:10,315 --> 01:47:12,717
know if you could give me an

2539
01:47:12,717 --> 01:47:15,854
update on, you said adapting the

2540
01:47:15,854 --> 01:47:18,854
bay area, is that considering

2541
01:47:21,760 --> 01:47:23,161
highway 37 as a priority?

2542
01:47:23,161 --> 01:47:24,663
Considering the sea level rise

2543
01:47:24,663 --> 01:47:26,298
that floods the highway right

2544
01:47:26,298 --> 01:47:27,699
now, and will eventually flood

2545
01:47:27,699 --> 01:47:30,268
the city of vallejo, can you

2546
01:47:30,268 --> 01:47:30,869
give us an update on that?

2547
01:47:30,869 --> 01:47:32,103
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2548
01:47:32,103 --> 01:47:33,972
thank you member hankerson.

2549
01:47:33,972 --> 01:47:37,142
Let's turn it over to staff to

2550
01:47:37,142 --> 01:47:39,542
respond 50 to member mirante's

2551
01:47:39,611 --> 01:47:40,312
question, and then member

2552
01:47:40,312 --> 01:47:41,847
hankerson's question.

2553
01:47:41,847 --> 01:47:43,849
>>chirag rabari: yes, I think,

2554
01:47:43,849 --> 01:47:46,651
you know, certainly want to

2555
01:47:46,651 --> 01:47:49,221
acknowledge that this is a, you

2556
01:47:49,221 --> 01:47:51,823
know, a dynamic environment and

2557
01:47:51,823 --> 01:47:52,124
there are lots of shifting

2558
01:47:52,124 --> 01:47:54,124
[Laughter]

2559
01:47:54,426 --> 01:47:56,795
-- you know, shifting orders

2560
01:47:56,795 --> 01:47:58,196
coming down. There are various

2561
01:47:58,196 --> 01:47:59,965
lawsuits. So, I think our --

2562
01:47:59,965 --> 01:48:02,965
our perspective has always been,

2563
01:48:03,268 --> 01:48:05,203
you know, we don't want to over

2564
01:48:05,203 --> 01:48:07,639
react, but we also need to, you

2565
01:48:07,639 --> 01:48:09,876
know, be prepared and nimble in

2566
01:48:09,876 --> 01:48:10,876
the event that there are, you

2567
01:48:10,876 --> 01:48:13,876
know, various changes that are

2568
01:48:14,247 --> 01:48:16,848
required. I think, you know,

2569
01:48:16,848 --> 01:48:19,848
centering equity has and will

2570
01:48:20,180 --> 01:48:22,880
continue to be a core aspect of

2571
01:48:22,880 --> 01:48:24,220
the long range plan, and I don't

2572
01:48:24,220 --> 01:48:27,225
think that that is going to

2573
01:48:27,225 --> 01:48:29,494
change, because this is the bay

2574
01:48:29,494 --> 01:48:31,894
area's regional vision for

2575
01:48:32,532 --> 01:48:34,932
transportation, housing, and the

2576
01:48:35,333 --> 01:48:36,968
environment. But the plan does

2577
01:48:36,968 --> 01:48:38,670
have, you know, certain federal

2578
01:48:38,670 --> 01:48:41,670
requirements that it does need

2579
01:48:41,807 --> 01:48:44,910
to address. The feds do certify

2580
01:48:44,910 --> 01:48:47,879
our status as a metropolitan

2581
01:48:47,879 --> 01:48:50,279
planning organization, you know,

2582
01:48:53,219 --> 01:48:54,119
every, I think, four years or

2583
01:48:54,119 --> 01:48:55,419
thereabouts. And as these

2584
01:48:55,419 --> 01:48:57,122
different rulemakings come

2585
01:48:57,122 --> 01:48:58,757
through, we're going to have to

2586
01:48:58,757 --> 01:49:00,892
be thoughtful about how to, you

2587
01:49:00,892 --> 01:49:02,528
know, respond to them in our

2588
01:49:02,528 --> 01:49:04,928
capacity as a federally

2589
01:49:05,664 --> 01:49:08,664
designated mpo. But I don't

2590
01:49:08,967 --> 01:49:12,567
think that our emphasis on, you

2591
01:49:12,971 --> 01:49:16,571
know, equity is going to change

2592
01:49:23,448 --> 01:49:24,490
in the long range plan itself.

2593
01:49:24,490 --> 01:49:24,916
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2594
01:49:24,916 --> 01:49:26,918
thank you. Are there any

2595
01:49:26,918 --> 01:49:27,453
responses to member hankerson's

2596
01:49:27,453 --> 01:49:28,753
question?

2597
01:49:28,753 --> 01:49:31,753
>>chirag rabari: yeah, I think

2598
01:49:32,190 --> 01:49:35,127
the question was just about the

2599
01:49:35,127 --> 01:49:37,262
sr37 and some of the work that's

2600
01:49:37,262 --> 01:49:40,262
moving forward in terms adapting

2601
01:49:42,767 --> 01:49:45,971
the bay area. So, you know, we

2602
01:49:45,971 --> 01:49:46,771
have, in terms of the, you know,

2603
01:49:46,771 --> 01:49:49,171
the transportation projects that

2604
01:49:50,408 --> 01:49:54,800
are included in the long range

2605
01:49:57,820 --> 01:50:00,682
plan, there -- we -- our

2606
01:50:02,870 --> 01:50:04,870
fiscally constrained

2607
01:50:04,256 --> 01:50:06,656
transportation plan does include

2608
01:50:06,691 --> 01:50:08,361
an interim project you know the

2609
01:50:08,361 --> 01:50:09,928
smaller scale project that mtc

2610
01:50:09,928 --> 01:50:11,463
and caltrans and our various

2611
01:50:11,463 --> 01:50:13,980
partners in the north bay are

2612
01:50:13,980 --> 01:50:15,267
looking to implement to deal

2613
01:50:15,267 --> 01:50:17,469
with some of the near-term

2614
01:50:17,469 --> 01:50:19,171
protection needs. The plan also

2615
01:50:19,171 --> 01:50:22,171
has a resilience project list

2616
01:50:27,579 --> 01:50:28,880
which is not a fiscally

2617
01:50:28,880 --> 01:50:31,280
constrained document that does

2618
01:50:31,316 --> 01:50:34,316
identify that longer term need

2619
01:50:35,287 --> 01:50:36,855
to adapt to sr37 to the broader

2620
01:50:36,855 --> 01:50:38,390
range of challenges. So that is

2621
01:50:38,390 --> 01:50:41,793
kind of our starting point for

2622
01:50:41,793 --> 01:50:43,361
our work as we head into planned

2623
01:50:43,361 --> 01:50:45,564
bay area 2060, and as the

2624
01:50:45,564 --> 01:50:46,898
project lists do develop, we

2625
01:50:46,898 --> 01:50:48,834
would anticipate getting new

2626
01:50:48,834 --> 01:50:50,834
information, getting new

2627
01:50:51,504 --> 01:50:53,904
details, and updating those

2628
01:50:55,741 --> 01:50:57,309
project characterses as

2629
01:50:57,309 --> 01:51:00,309
appropriate based on the fiscal

2630
01:51:00,847 --> 01:51:01,513
resources that are available.

2631
01:51:01,513 --> 01:51:02,148
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2632
01:51:02,148 --> 01:51:03,515
matt?

2633
01:51:03,515 --> 01:51:05,583
>>matt maloney: I want to make

2634
01:51:05,583 --> 01:51:06,918
a couple comments about the

2635
01:51:06,918 --> 01:51:08,987
plan. Kind of that we're in

2636
01:51:08,987 --> 01:51:10,990
this period of time, you know,

2637
01:51:10,990 --> 01:51:11,823
beginning a new plan with all of

2638
01:51:11,823 --> 01:51:15,423
you, and you're going to be

2639
01:51:15,594 --> 01:51:18,330
hearing a lot about it over the

2640
01:51:18,330 --> 01:51:20,980
next few years. You know, I

2641
01:51:20,980 --> 01:51:21,399
think these plans are obviously

2642
01:51:21,399 --> 01:51:23,569
very important for the region,

2643
01:51:23,569 --> 01:51:27,205
and we put a lot of staff energy

2644
01:51:27,205 --> 01:51:28,306
into them. But I also think

2645
01:51:28,306 --> 01:51:29,641
foundationally, just for the

2646
01:51:29,641 --> 01:51:31,375
council, is understanding, sort

2647
01:51:31,375 --> 01:51:33,646
of, what the plan is and what it

2648
01:51:33,646 --> 01:51:36,646
isn't. You know, it's a

2649
01:51:36,648 --> 01:51:39,648
long-term vision, and really a

2650
01:51:40,510 --> 01:51:41,520
guide for action for this

2651
01:51:41,520 --> 01:51:43,210
region. It has some

2652
01:51:43,210 --> 01:51:44,210
implementation teeth to it,

2653
01:51:44,210 --> 01:51:46,525
depending on what part of the

2654
01:51:46,525 --> 01:51:50,610
plan we're talking about, but in

2655
01:51:50,610 --> 01:51:51,530
large part, it sets the vision

2656
01:51:51,530 --> 01:51:52,931
and the implementation details

2657
01:51:52,931 --> 01:51:55,330
need to be carried out, usually

2658
01:51:55,330 --> 01:51:56,802
by our partners, whether they're

2659
01:51:56,802 --> 01:51:59,202
local governments, you know,

2660
01:52:00,405 --> 01:52:01,840
transit agencies, the state, the

2661
01:52:01,840 --> 01:52:03,675
feds, you know, everybody is

2662
01:52:03,675 --> 01:52:05,210
involved in kind of getting that

2663
01:52:05,210 --> 01:52:07,210
stuff done.

2664
01:52:07,479 --> 01:52:09,714
I guess what I'm trying to say

2665
01:52:09,714 --> 01:52:11,349
is that it doesn't also legend

2666
01:52:11,349 --> 01:52:13,180
itself to ga going deep and

2667
01:52:13,180 --> 01:52:15,287
granular on every single topic.

2668
01:52:15,287 --> 01:52:16,655
We just comment do it in the

2669
01:52:16,655 --> 01:52:18,957
plan. Sometimes we have to be

2670
01:52:18,957 --> 01:52:20,491
at a certain level, maybe not

2671
01:52:20,491 --> 01:52:21,960
30,000 feet, but sometimes like

2672
01:52:21,960 --> 01:52:25,231
5 to 10,000 feet on a lot of

2673
01:52:25,231 --> 01:52:26,298
these issues, you know, and the

2674
01:52:26,298 --> 01:52:27,666
goal being that we're laying out

2675
01:52:27,666 --> 01:52:29,202
strategies for the region to,

2676
01:52:29,202 --> 01:52:30,235
sort of, move forward. So,

2677
01:52:30,235 --> 01:52:31,236
really, the policy making and

2678
01:52:31,236 --> 01:52:32,471
the strategies are really the

2679
01:52:32,471 --> 01:52:34,105
foundation of what makes the

2680
01:52:34,105 --> 01:52:36,408
plan work, but we also have to

2681
01:52:36,408 --> 01:52:38,444
remember that there is so much

2682
01:52:38,444 --> 01:52:41,346
on the implementation side that

2683
01:52:41,346 --> 01:52:43,648
we can't control ourselves.

2684
01:52:43,648 --> 01:52:45,351
And, you know, that it requires

2685
01:52:45,351 --> 01:52:46,652
a lot of action from others.

2686
01:52:46,652 --> 01:52:49,921
And I think that's a theme we'll

2687
01:52:49,921 --> 01:52:50,355
return to throughout this

2688
01:52:50,355 --> 01:52:51,691
process. Thanks.

2689
01:52:51,691 --> 01:52:53,258
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2690
01:52:53,258 --> 01:52:54,559
thank you, matt. Thank you

2691
01:52:54,559 --> 01:52:56,959
council members for your

2692
01:52:57,662 --> 01:52:59,664
discussion. And, also, I just

2693
01:52:59,664 --> 01:53:01,233
want to acknowledge chirag, you

2694
01:53:01,233 --> 01:53:02,200
just took on a lot of hard

2695
01:53:02,200 --> 01:53:05,170
questions on the spot. So,

2696
01:53:05,170 --> 01:53:07,390
thank you. You did a great job.

2697
01:53:07,390 --> 01:53:08,739
Will the clerk please inform us

2698
01:53:08,739 --> 01:53:10,750
if there is any public comment

2699
01:53:10,750 --> 01:53:12,111
submitted for this item and

2700
01:53:12,111 --> 01:53:14,180
whether there are any members of

2701
01:53:14,180 --> 01:53:15,114
the public who wish to give

2702
01:53:15,114 --> 01:53:16,114
public comment?

2703
01:53:16,114 --> 01:53:17,916
>>clerk, jessica lewis: we

2704
01:53:17,916 --> 01:53:19,651
received no public comments for

2705
01:53:19,651 --> 01:53:21,353
this item no speakers at the

2706
01:53:21,353 --> 01:53:24,221
podium and no raised hands in

2707
01:53:24,221 --> 01:53:25,900
the zoom space requesting to

2708
01:53:25,900 --> 01:53:25,956
provide public comment.

2709
01:53:25,956 --> 01:53:27,259
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

2710
01:53:27,259 --> 01:53:29,259
thank you.

2711
01:53:29,995 --> 01:53:32,565
We'll move to agenda item five b

2712
01:53:32,565 --> 01:53:33,265
this is the draft 2026 public

2713
01:53:33,265 --> 01:53:34,900
participation plan for the san

2714
01:53:34,900 --> 01:53:37,900
francisco bay area, summary of

2715
01:53:39,205 --> 01:53:42,205
input received. This is an

2716
01:53:43,676 --> 01:53:45,410
information item from veronica

2717
01:53:45,410 --> 01:53:46,211
cummings, and also for

2718
01:53:46,211 --> 01:53:49,211
edification of the council this

2719
01:53:49,915 --> 01:53:51,116
is an item on our work plan and

2720
01:53:51,116 --> 01:53:52,618
so is the planned bay area 2060

2721
01:53:52,618 --> 01:53:53,853
so just acknowledging that we

2722
01:53:53,853 --> 01:53:55,821
are hearing things directly

2723
01:53:55,821 --> 01:53:57,550
about our work plan. So

2724
01:53:57,550 --> 01:53:59,455
veronica cummings will you

2725
01:54:00,325 --> 01:54:00,992
please give us the report?

2726
01:54:00,992 --> 01:54:01,993
>>veronica cummings good

2727
01:54:01,993 --> 01:54:04,796
morning. Thank you very much.

2728
01:54:04,796 --> 01:54:06,163
My name is veronica cummings I'm

2729
01:54:06,163 --> 01:54:08,990
the principal public information

2730
01:54:08,990 --> 01:54:10,499
officer for engagement. I'm

2731
01:54:11,903 --> 01:54:13,805
here today to share what we

2732
01:54:13,805 --> 01:54:15,507
heard during the public review

2733
01:54:15,507 --> 01:54:16,708
of the draft 2026 public

2734
01:54:16,708 --> 01:54:19,708
participation plan or the ppp

2735
01:54:21,313 --> 01:54:23,315
and how that feedback is

2736
01:54:23,315 --> 01:54:25,715
informing the revised plan.

2737
01:54:26,751 --> 01:54:29,522
I'll start with the quick

2738
01:54:29,522 --> 01:54:31,156
refresher on the ppp and the

2739
01:54:31,156 --> 01:54:32,591
federal state requirements it

2740
01:54:32,591 --> 01:54:34,393
fulfills. Then walk through the

2741
01:54:34,393 --> 01:54:36,128
engagement we conducted during

2742
01:54:36,128 --> 01:54:37,829
the 45 day public comment period

2743
01:54:37,829 --> 01:54:40,650
and key themes that emerged

2744
01:54:40,650 --> 01:54:42,167
across these activities. I'll

2745
01:54:42,167 --> 01:54:44,200
close with remaining milestones

2746
01:54:44,200 --> 01:54:45,236
leading to consideration of the

2747
01:54:45,236 --> 01:54:47,305
revised plan by the commission

2748
01:54:47,305 --> 01:54:49,808
later this month. Next slide.

2749
01:54:49,808 --> 01:54:52,410
As you MAY remember, printed the

2750
01:54:52,410 --> 01:54:54,790
draft 2026ppp to you in JUNE, so

2751
01:54:54,790 --> 01:54:56,648
these next couple of slides are

2752
01:54:56,648 --> 01:54:59,951
meant to just be a refresher.

2753
01:54:59,951 --> 01:55:01,219
At its core, the ppp serves as a

2754
01:55:01,219 --> 01:55:02,754
guide for how bay area residents

2755
01:55:02,754 --> 01:55:04,723
and our partners can engage with

2756
01:55:04,723 --> 01:55:06,492
mtc's planning and

2757
01:55:06,492 --> 01:55:08,930
decision-making processes. It

2758
01:55:08,930 --> 01:55:10,263
explains where people can find

2759
01:55:10,263 --> 01:55:11,396
information, how to stay

2760
01:55:11,396 --> 01:55:13,231
informed about participation

2761
01:55:13,231 --> 01:55:15,631
opportunities, how to provide

2762
01:55:15,734 --> 01:55:17,402
input and how public comments

2763
01:55:17,402 --> 01:55:19,802
are documented and reported

2764
01:55:21,720 --> 01:55:22,974
back. The ppp also fulfills

2765
01:55:22,974 --> 01:55:23,675
federal and state public

2766
01:55:23,675 --> 01:55:25,675
participation plan requirements

2767
01:55:25,877 --> 01:55:28,790
for major regional planning and

2768
01:55:28,790 --> 01:55:28,613
funding efforts, including

2769
01:55:28,613 --> 01:55:31,613
planned bay area and the

2770
01:55:31,616 --> 01:55:33,616
transportation improvement plan.

2771
01:55:33,652 --> 01:55:35,120
The document also guides our --

2772
01:55:35,120 --> 01:55:36,488
I'm sorry -- includes our

2773
01:55:36,488 --> 01:55:38,488
guiding principles for

2774
01:55:39,157 --> 01:55:40,191
engagement and our engagement

2775
01:55:40,191 --> 01:55:41,660
framework. Together these

2776
01:55:41,660 --> 01:55:43,862
provide direction for how staff

2777
01:55:43,862 --> 01:55:46,640
plans, convicts, and evaluates

2778
01:55:46,640 --> 01:55:47,299
public engagement. Ultimately

2779
01:55:47,299 --> 01:55:49,534
the goal is to make

2780
01:55:49,534 --> 01:55:50,902
participation clearer, more

2781
01:55:50,902 --> 01:55:51,636
accessible, and more

2782
01:55:51,636 --> 01:55:53,171
transparent, both for members of

2783
01:55:53,171 --> 01:55:55,707
the public who want to

2784
01:55:55,707 --> 01:55:56,775
understand how and when they can

2785
01:55:56,775 --> 01:55:58,310
participate, and for staff

2786
01:55:58,310 --> 01:56:00,310
designing these opportunities.

2787
01:56:02,347 --> 01:56:04,149
Next slide.

2788
01:56:04,149 --> 01:56:05,717
This slide summarizes the

2789
01:56:05,717 --> 01:56:07,752
federal and state requirements

2790
01:56:07,752 --> 01:56:11,156
that provide the legal basis for

2791
01:56:11,156 --> 01:56:13,556
the ppp. Under federal

2792
01:56:13,725 --> 01:56:16,125
regulations, mtc must create

2793
01:56:16,595 --> 01:56:17,496
opportunities for public

2794
01:56:17,496 --> 01:56:18,664
involvement, participation and

2795
01:56:18,664 --> 01:56:19,798
consultation throughout the

2796
01:56:19,798 --> 01:56:20,398
development of the regional

2797
01:56:20,398 --> 01:56:20,966
transportation plan and the

2798
01:56:20,966 --> 01:56:22,966
transportation improvement

2799
01:56:26,938 --> 01:56:28,938
program. Or tip.

2800
01:56:29,107 --> 01:56:31,409
The tip is the region's

2801
01:56:31,409 --> 01:56:33,440
federally required four-year

2802
01:56:33,440 --> 01:56:34,946
list of near-term transportation

2803
01:56:34,946 --> 01:56:37,820
projects and programs expected

2804
01:56:37,820 --> 01:56:39,417
to receive funding. State law

2805
01:56:39,417 --> 01:56:41,319
also requires mtc to develop an

2806
01:56:41,319 --> 01:56:42,488
engagement plan for the

2807
01:56:42,488 --> 01:56:43,655
sustainable community strategy.

2808
01:56:43,655 --> 01:56:44,656
Together the regional

2809
01:56:44,656 --> 01:56:45,490
transportation plan and

2810
01:56:45,490 --> 01:56:47,490
sustainable community strategy

2811
01:56:47,993 --> 01:56:50,394
make up the region's long range

2812
01:56:50,394 --> 01:56:51,696
plan, planned bay area, and I do

2813
01:56:51,696 --> 01:56:54,366
want to clarify one point about

2814
01:56:54,366 --> 01:56:55,968
the scope of the ppp, it is an

2815
01:56:55,968 --> 01:56:58,300
mtc required document adopted by

2816
01:56:58,300 --> 01:57:01,300
the commission. While it does

2817
01:57:01,390 --> 01:57:03,439
not impose legal participation

2818
01:57:04,876 --> 01:57:07,479
requirements of abag, mtc/abag

2819
01:57:07,479 --> 01:57:09,347
staff uses it as a guide -- uses

2820
01:57:09,347 --> 01:57:10,649
it to guide engagement for joint

2821
01:57:10,649 --> 01:57:13,418
planning work, such as planned

2822
01:57:13,418 --> 01:57:15,987
bay area, and the ppp is

2823
01:57:15,987 --> 01:57:16,655
primarily centered on mtc's core

2824
01:57:16,655 --> 01:57:18,655
planning and funding

2825
01:57:19,191 --> 01:57:21,591
responsibilities. It is not

2826
01:57:22,627 --> 01:57:25,564
intended to be a comprehensive

2827
01:57:25,564 --> 01:57:26,698
inventory of every engagement

2828
01:57:26,698 --> 01:57:27,967
activity conducted across mtc

2829
01:57:27,967 --> 01:57:30,367
abag and related authorities.

2830
01:57:30,736 --> 01:57:32,736
Next slide.

2831
01:57:33,380 --> 01:57:35,340
I'll now turn to the engagement

2832
01:57:35,340 --> 01:57:37,175
we conducted during the public

2833
01:57:37,175 --> 01:57:39,575
review and comment period.

2834
01:57:40,278 --> 01:57:42,315
Staff released the draft ppp on

2835
01:57:42,315 --> 01:57:43,815
JUNE 8th for a 45-day public

2836
01:57:43,815 --> 01:57:45,550
comment period that closed

2837
01:57:45,550 --> 01:57:48,550
JULY 23rd. During that period,

2838
01:57:48,787 --> 01:57:49,621
we convened focus groups with

2839
01:57:49,621 --> 01:57:50,956
representatives from

2840
01:57:50,956 --> 01:57:52,458
community-based organizations

2841
01:57:52,458 --> 01:57:54,192
serving a range of bay area

2842
01:57:54,192 --> 01:57:55,994
communities, including older

2843
01:57:55,994 --> 01:57:57,462
adults, immigrants, tribal

2844
01:57:57,462 --> 01:57:59,862
communities, youth, and people

2845
01:57:59,898 --> 01:58:00,699
with disabilities. We also held

2846
01:58:00,699 --> 01:58:02,300
discussion groups with high

2847
01:58:02,300 --> 01:58:04,700
school students participating in

2848
01:58:06,838 --> 01:58:08,838
the normal

2849
01:58:13,780 --> 01:58:14,545
alan -- norman mineta

2850
01:58:14,545 --> 01:58:15,747
bay area summer academy, and

2851
01:58:15,747 --> 01:58:17,747
these conversations focus

2852
01:58:17,816 --> 01:58:19,318
specifically on how mtc can make

2853
01:58:19,318 --> 01:58:20,385
participation more relevant,

2854
01:58:20,385 --> 01:58:21,553
accessible and appealing to

2855
01:58:21,553 --> 01:58:23,889
duong people. More personally

2856
01:58:23,889 --> 01:58:24,723
for today's discussion, we held

2857
01:58:24,723 --> 01:58:25,924
two discussion groups with

2858
01:58:25,924 --> 01:58:28,226
members of this council focused

2859
01:58:28,226 --> 01:58:30,362
on equity, accessibility, trust

2860
01:58:30,362 --> 01:58:31,729
building and community centered

2861
01:58:31,729 --> 01:58:33,499
engagement. Finally staff

2862
01:58:33,499 --> 01:58:34,432
administered an online survey in

2863
01:58:34,432 --> 01:58:35,667
english, spanish, and

2864
01:58:35,667 --> 01:58:37,667
traditional chinese. Together

2865
01:58:38,603 --> 01:58:40,105
these activities gave us both

2866
01:58:40,105 --> 01:58:41,673
broad survey data and more

2867
01:58:41,673 --> 01:58:43,275
detailed feedback from community

2868
01:58:43,275 --> 01:58:45,275
partners, couth, council

2869
01:58:45,644 --> 01:58:48,440
members, and formal commenters.

2870
01:58:48,180 --> 01:58:50,683
in all more than 1300 people

2871
01:58:50,683 --> 01:58:51,316
participated. Next slide. Youth, council

2872
01:58:51,316 --> 01:58:51,917
members, and formal commenters.

2873
01:58:51,917 --> 01:58:52,683
In all more than 1300 people

2874
01:58:52,683 --> 01:58:55,830
participated. Next slide. What

2875
01:58:55,420 --> 01:58:57,923
we heard, this slide gives a

2876
01:58:57,923 --> 01:59:00,923
high-level picture of what we

2877
01:59:02,260 --> 01:59:02,762
heard. All the participants

2878
01:59:02,762 --> 01:59:04,596
represented different

2879
01:59:04,596 --> 01:59:07,596
communities and engaged with us

2880
01:59:07,732 --> 01:59:08,366
in different ways, the feedback

2881
01:59:08,366 --> 01:59:09,935
was remarkably consistent.

2882
01:59:09,935 --> 01:59:11,537
First and foremost, people want

2883
01:59:11,537 --> 01:59:13,400
us to close the feedback loop.

2884
01:59:13,400 --> 01:59:14,573
They want us to report back on

2885
01:59:14,573 --> 01:59:16,740
what we heard and show how

2886
01:59:16,740 --> 01:59:17,142
public input influenced

2887
01:59:17,142 --> 01:59:19,142
recommendations and decisions.

2888
01:59:19,177 --> 01:59:21,279
They also want us to meet people

2889
01:59:21,279 --> 01:59:24,879
where they are, both in trusted

2890
01:59:25,117 --> 01:59:27,517
community spaces and through

2891
01:59:27,586 --> 01:59:28,453
digital channels and

2892
01:59:28,453 --> 01:59:30,453
communication networks they

2893
01:59:32,900 --> 01:59:34,490
already use. Reducing barriers

2894
01:59:35,261 --> 01:59:37,661
to participation was another

2895
01:59:39,698 --> 01:59:41,199
major theme, and participants

2896
01:59:41,199 --> 01:59:42,267
identified language, disability,

2897
01:59:42,267 --> 01:59:43,369
technology, transportation,

2898
01:59:43,369 --> 01:59:46,369
scheduling and child care and

2899
01:59:46,538 --> 01:59:48,306
other practical barriers that

2900
01:59:48,306 --> 01:59:49,508
can make participation

2901
01:59:49,508 --> 01:59:50,944
difficult. We also heard the

2902
01:59:50,944 --> 01:59:52,110
need for plain language and

2903
01:59:52,110 --> 01:59:54,110
clearer connection between

2904
01:59:54,120 --> 01:59:54,979
regional planning and funding

2905
01:59:54,979 --> 01:59:57,379
decisions and issues people

2906
01:59:57,382 --> 01:59:59,782
snrns their daily lives.

2907
01:59:59,985 --> 02:00:01,920
Participants want clearer value

2908
02:00:01,920 --> 02:00:04,589
proposition for their time, they

2909
02:00:04,589 --> 02:00:06,424
want to know why their input is

2910
02:00:06,424 --> 02:00:08,127
needed, what is actually open

2911
02:00:08,127 --> 02:00:10,228
for discussion, and how their

2912
02:00:10,228 --> 02:00:12,197
participation MAY affect a

2913
02:00:12,197 --> 02:00:13,665
decision. Finally they ask us

2914
02:00:13,665 --> 02:00:15,400
to keep our communications

2915
02:00:15,400 --> 02:00:17,800
clear, concise, and accessible.

2916
02:00:17,836 --> 02:00:20,105
What is striking is how closely

2917
02:00:20,105 --> 02:00:21,907
these findings align with what

2918
02:00:21,907 --> 02:00:24,750
we have heard from this couple

2919
02:00:24,750 --> 02:00:25,644
both during our JUNE ppp

2920
02:00:25,644 --> 02:00:27,120
discussion and in your broader

2921
02:00:27,120 --> 02:00:29,120
conversations about community

2922
02:00:29,114 --> 02:00:31,514
engagement. The next slides

2923
02:00:32,284 --> 02:00:35,884
take a closer look at these

2924
02:00:41,927 --> 02:00:43,862
themes. Next slide.

2925
02:00:43,862 --> 02:00:44,762
Increased transparency and

2926
02:00:44,762 --> 02:00:46,762
accountability, participants

2927
02:00:46,832 --> 02:00:48,660
consistently asked mtc to close

2928
02:00:48,660 --> 02:00:50,635
the feedback loop by showing how

2929
02:00:50,635 --> 02:00:52,300
public input influences plans,

2930
02:00:52,300 --> 02:00:53,271
policies programs, invest

2931
02:00:53,271 --> 02:00:56,271
decisions, they want us to

2932
02:00:56,541 --> 02:00:57,542
report back on what we heard,

2933
02:00:57,542 --> 02:00:58,210
share engagement results and

2934
02:00:58,210 --> 02:00:59,878
identify tangible outcomes

2935
02:00:59,878 --> 02:01:01,746
associated with public input.

2936
02:01:01,746 --> 02:01:02,948
Many people told us they would

2937
02:01:02,948 --> 02:01:05,584
be more willing to participate

2938
02:01:05,584 --> 02:01:08,186
if they could see how their

2939
02:01:08,186 --> 02:01:09,880
input led to action or

2940
02:01:09,880 --> 02:01:10,422
meaningfully informed a

2941
02:01:10,422 --> 02:01:12,422
recommendation. Conversely

2942
02:01:13,910 --> 02:01:14,459
frustration grows when people

2943
02:01:14,459 --> 02:01:16,595
never hear what happened after

2944
02:01:16,595 --> 02:01:18,630
inn game activity or feel that a

2945
02:01:18,630 --> 02:01:19,331
decision was already made before

2946
02:01:19,331 --> 02:01:20,899
they were invited to the

2947
02:01:20,899 --> 02:01:23,435
process. And this echoes pint

2948
02:01:23,435 --> 02:01:25,904
that came up in this council's

2949
02:01:25,904 --> 02:01:27,738
discussion as well, that people

2950
02:01:27,738 --> 02:01:29,608
need to understand not only how

2951
02:01:29,608 --> 02:01:30,709
to provide input but what is

2952
02:01:30,709 --> 02:01:33,440
actually within their influence

2953
02:01:33,440 --> 02:01:34,379
and what happens to that input

2954
02:01:34,379 --> 02:01:36,448
afterward. So in practical

2955
02:01:36,448 --> 02:01:38,416
terms that means being clear at

2956
02:01:38,416 --> 02:01:41,419
the beginning about what is open

2957
02:01:41,419 --> 02:01:45,190
for input then reporting back on

2958
02:01:45,124 --> 02:01:46,591
on what we heard and how it was

2959
02:01:46,591 --> 02:01:48,126
considered. When something

2960
02:01:48,126 --> 02:01:49,661
cannot be incorporated and why.

2961
02:01:49,661 --> 02:01:51,960
The bottom line is that closing

2962
02:01:51,960 --> 02:01:52,864
the loop is fundamental to trust

2963
02:01:52,864 --> 02:01:54,320
and people are more likely to

2964
02:01:54,320 --> 02:01:56,268
participate when they could see

2965
02:01:56,268 --> 02:01:58,300
that their time and input

2966
02:01:58,300 --> 02:02:00,300
matter. Next slide.

2967
02:02:00,438 --> 02:02:02,974
Number two meeting people where

2968
02:02:02,974 --> 02:02:04,910
they are participants encouraged

2969
02:02:04,910 --> 02:02:05,977
us to expand engagement beyond

2970
02:02:05,977 --> 02:02:08,146
traditional public meetings and

2971
02:02:08,146 --> 02:02:09,548
government buildings. They

2972
02:02:09,548 --> 02:02:10,882
recommended reaching people in

2973
02:02:10,882 --> 02:02:12,952
familiar trusted places such as

2974
02:02:12,952 --> 02:02:14,219
schools, libraries, senior

2975
02:02:14,219 --> 02:02:16,619
centers, transit hubs, health

2976
02:02:17,189 --> 02:02:18,557
care facilities, cultural

2977
02:02:18,557 --> 02:02:19,257
events, faith based

2978
02:02:19,257 --> 02:02:20,558
organizations, and other

2979
02:02:20,558 --> 02:02:22,558
community space presidency.

2980
02:02:23,228 --> 02:02:24,129
They asked us to use the

2981
02:02:24,129 --> 02:02:26,310
communication channels that

2982
02:02:26,310 --> 02:02:28,134
people already rely on, and

2983
02:02:28,134 --> 02:02:30,969
depending on the audience that

2984
02:02:30,969 --> 02:02:32,404
might be social media, school

2985
02:02:32,404 --> 02:02:33,805
notification systems, community

2986
02:02:33,805 --> 02:02:35,805
organization networks or

2987
02:02:35,841 --> 02:02:37,509
messaging applications. So it's

2988
02:02:37,509 --> 02:02:39,578
more than changing the location

2989
02:02:39,578 --> 02:02:40,779
of a meeting, it's about fitting

2990
02:02:40,779 --> 02:02:42,482
participation into people's

2991
02:02:42,482 --> 02:02:44,882
existing lives rather than

2992
02:02:45,383 --> 02:02:46,384
expecting them to navigate an

2993
02:02:46,384 --> 02:02:47,518
unfamiliar government process.

2994
02:02:47,518 --> 02:02:49,722
This was also very clear in

2995
02:02:49,722 --> 02:02:51,990
terms of messaging from this

2996
02:02:51,990 --> 02:02:53,492
council during last month's

2997
02:02:53,492 --> 02:02:55,492
meeting discussion.

2998
02:02:55,827 --> 02:02:58,227
Members talked about going

2999
02:03:00,732 --> 02:03:02,400
directly to cbo sites and

3000
02:03:02,400 --> 02:03:04,400
existing community events,

3001
02:03:04,903 --> 02:03:07,472
rather than expecting are thes

3002
02:03:07,472 --> 02:03:09,541
to come to us just refreshing

3003
02:03:09,541 --> 02:03:11,941
last month's discussion. So

3004
02:03:12,377 --> 02:03:13,513
this reinforces the value of

3005
02:03:13,513 --> 02:03:15,380
partnering with community

3006
02:03:15,380 --> 02:03:16,681
organizations are that already

3007
02:03:16,681 --> 02:03:17,616
have trusted relationships and

3008
02:03:17,616 --> 02:03:19,251
understand how to reach people

3009
02:03:19,251 --> 02:03:21,860
they serve. The bottom line is

3010
02:03:21,860 --> 02:03:22,420
that engagement is most

3011
02:03:22,420 --> 02:03:23,655
effective when it happens in

3012
02:03:23,655 --> 02:03:25,323
trusted community spaces and

3013
02:03:25,323 --> 02:03:26,358
through channels people already

3014
02:03:26,358 --> 02:03:28,358
use. Next slide.

3015
02:03:29,127 --> 02:03:31,496
Key finding number three, access

3016
02:03:31,496 --> 02:03:33,365
and accessibility. Participants

3017
02:03:33,365 --> 02:03:34,933
identified a number of barriers

3018
02:03:34,933 --> 02:03:36,335
that can prevent people from

3019
02:03:36,335 --> 02:03:38,270
participating even when they

3020
02:03:38,270 --> 02:03:40,639
care about an issue, barriers

3021
02:03:40,639 --> 02:03:42,700
such as language, limited

3022
02:03:42,700 --> 02:03:43,375
mobility, disability access,

3023
02:03:43,375 --> 02:03:45,430
technology, transportation, work

3024
02:03:45,430 --> 02:03:47,379
schedules, child care, and

3025
02:03:47,379 --> 02:03:49,779
family obligations. They called

3026
02:03:49,948 --> 02:03:51,416
for higher I'm sorry -- they

3027
02:03:51,416 --> 02:03:53,816
called for expanded language

3028
02:03:54,119 --> 02:03:55,921
access, including translated

3029
02:03:55,921 --> 02:03:57,322
materials, and high quality

3030
02:03:57,322 --> 02:03:59,125
interpretation, as well as

3031
02:03:59,125 --> 02:04:00,426
accommodations for people with

3032
02:04:00,426 --> 02:04:01,960
disabilities and consistent

3033
02:04:01,960 --> 02:04:03,960
virtual participation options.

3034
02:04:04,729 --> 02:04:07,399
Survey respondents, as well as

3035
02:04:07,399 --> 02:04:08,233
the council also emphasized

3036
02:04:08,233 --> 02:04:09,301
evening and weekend

3037
02:04:09,301 --> 02:04:11,701
opportunities for people whose

3038
02:04:17,443 --> 02:04:18,477
work or family obligations make

3039
02:04:18,477 --> 02:04:20,477
daytime participation difficult.

3040
02:04:21,460 --> 02:04:22,781
Let's see. The practical

3041
02:04:22,781 --> 02:04:24,820
takeaway is that the

3042
02:04:24,820 --> 02:04:25,784
participation method, schedule,

3043
02:04:25,784 --> 02:04:27,552
location, and accessibility

3044
02:04:27,552 --> 02:04:28,887
services need to be considered

3045
02:04:28,887 --> 02:04:31,189
together from the beginning, and

3046
02:04:31,189 --> 02:04:33,589
not addressed separately after

3047
02:04:34,250 --> 02:04:36,995
an aqtively has already been

3048
02:04:36,995 --> 02:04:38,995
designed. Next slide.

3049
02:04:40,640 --> 02:04:42,502
Key finding number four, using

3050
02:04:42,502 --> 02:04:45,502
plain language, as well as

3051
02:04:45,570 --> 02:04:46,837
language this's relevant.

3052
02:04:46,837 --> 02:04:48,640
Participants asked mtc to

3053
02:04:48,640 --> 02:04:49,509
explain our role,

3054
02:04:49,509 --> 02:04:50,842
responsibilities, and decision

3055
02:04:50,842 --> 02:04:53,242
make authority more clearly.

3056
02:04:53,278 --> 02:04:55,515
Many community members do not

3057
02:04:55,515 --> 02:04:57,449
fully understand how mtc differs

3058
02:04:57,449 --> 02:04:58,984
from local governments and

3059
02:04:58,984 --> 02:05:00,485
transit operators, or how

3060
02:05:00,485 --> 02:05:02,885
regional planning and funding

3061
02:05:03,488 --> 02:05:05,857
decisions affect their daily

3062
02:05:05,857 --> 02:05:06,958
lives. They recommend concise,

3063
02:05:06,958 --> 02:05:08,126
non-technical language,

3064
02:05:08,126 --> 02:05:10,126
practical examples, and

3065
02:05:11,129 --> 02:05:13,129
relatable explanations, along

3066
02:05:14,299 --> 02:05:16,699
with simpler surveys, websites

3067
02:05:17,269 --> 02:05:19,269
and other public-facing

3068
02:05:20,710 --> 02:05:22,471
materials. And plain language

3069
02:05:23,708 --> 02:05:26,344
it's about more than just

3070
02:05:26,344 --> 02:05:27,646
removing jargon, it means giving

3071
02:05:27,646 --> 02:05:29,470
people enough context to

3072
02:05:29,470 --> 02:05:30,282
understand why the issues matter

3073
02:05:30,282 --> 02:05:31,783
and what decisions are being

3074
02:05:31,783 --> 02:05:33,651
made, how they can participate.

3075
02:05:33,651 --> 02:05:36,651
The bottom line is that

3076
02:05:37,689 --> 02:05:39,591
residents can engage more

3077
02:05:39,591 --> 02:05:42,527
meaningfully when we explain our

3078
02:05:42,527 --> 02:05:45,497
role, our decisions and their

3079
02:05:45,497 --> 02:05:46,731
impacts in clear relatable

3080
02:05:46,731 --> 02:05:48,731
terms. Next slide.

3081
02:05:49,202 --> 02:05:50,402
Key finding number five.

3082
02:05:50,402 --> 02:05:52,402
Strengthen community partnership

3083
02:05:52,504 --> 02:05:53,738
presidency, community-based

3084
02:05:53,738 --> 02:05:55,240
organizations and this council.

3085
02:05:55,240 --> 02:05:56,808
Emphasize the importance of

3086
02:05:56,808 --> 02:05:58,808
involving community partners

3087
02:06:00,479 --> 02:06:03,115
earlier in the planning process,

3088
02:06:03,115 --> 02:06:04,816
partners when an opportunity to

3089
02:06:04,816 --> 02:06:06,318
help shape engagement

3090
02:06:06,318 --> 02:06:07,919
strategies rather than being

3091
02:06:07,919 --> 02:06:10,455
asked to implement an approach

3092
02:06:10,455 --> 02:06:11,990
after its already been

3093
02:06:11,990 --> 02:06:13,990
developed. Participants

3094
02:06:15,930 --> 02:06:15,727
recommend cocreating these

3095
02:06:15,727 --> 02:06:16,561
outreach strategies improving

3096
02:06:16,561 --> 02:06:17,929
coordination among organizations

3097
02:06:17,929 --> 02:06:19,998
and creating more opportunity

3098
02:06:19,998 --> 02:06:21,933
for community partners to

3099
02:06:21,933 --> 02:06:24,569
convene and learn from one

3100
02:06:24,569 --> 02:06:26,969
another. They also emphasize

3101
02:06:28,173 --> 02:06:30,173
broad geographic representation

3102
02:06:31,910 --> 02:06:34,146
and recognizing the time,

3103
02:06:34,146 --> 02:06:35,714
expertise, and lived experience

3104
02:06:35,714 --> 02:06:37,714
community members contribute.

3105
02:06:37,916 --> 02:06:39,117
Earlier more consistent

3106
02:06:39,117 --> 02:06:40,852
collaboration can help staff

3107
02:06:40,852 --> 02:06:42,852
choose relevant engagement

3108
02:06:43,880 --> 02:06:45,290
methods anticipate barriers and

3109
02:06:45,290 --> 02:06:46,692
avoid duplicating outreach that

3110
02:06:46,692 --> 02:06:48,660
partners or other agencies have

3111
02:06:48,660 --> 02:06:49,895
heard conducted. Let's see.

3112
02:06:49,895 --> 02:06:51,463
Bottom line is that early

3113
02:06:51,463 --> 02:06:52,364
coordinated and ongoing

3114
02:06:52,364 --> 02:06:54,333
collaboration with trusted

3115
02:06:54,333 --> 02:06:56,733
community partners leads to

3116
02:06:56,935 --> 02:06:58,336
broader more equitable and more

3117
02:06:58,336 --> 02:06:58,771
effective engagement. Next

3118
02:06:58,771 --> 02:07:00,771
slide.

3119
02:07:02,400 --> 02:07:03,608
Key finding number six, equity

3120
02:07:03,608 --> 02:07:05,608
centered equity throughout

3121
02:07:06,612 --> 02:07:08,748
engagement across all activities

3122
02:07:08,748 --> 02:07:10,215
participants encouraged mtc

3123
02:07:10,215 --> 02:07:11,984
prioritize communities that have

3124
02:07:11,984 --> 02:07:13,218
historically been underserved or

3125
02:07:13,218 --> 02:07:14,286
excluded from public

3126
02:07:14,286 --> 02:07:16,686
decision-making. They asked us

3127
02:07:17,189 --> 02:07:19,589
to work with trusted

3128
02:07:19,724 --> 02:07:22,124
organizations and messengers and

3129
02:07:22,161 --> 02:07:23,295
ensure broad geographic

3130
02:07:23,295 --> 02:07:23,762
demographic representation and

3131
02:07:23,762 --> 02:07:24,831
design participation

3132
02:07:24,831 --> 02:07:26,398
opportunities that are

3133
02:07:26,398 --> 02:07:28,398
inclusive, culturally responsive

3134
02:07:29,334 --> 02:07:31,871
and accessible. And so this

3135
02:07:31,871 --> 02:07:33,872
means equity should shape who is

3136
02:07:33,872 --> 02:07:35,640
engaged, how engagement is

3137
02:07:35,640 --> 02:07:37,309
designed, what resources are

3138
02:07:37,309 --> 02:07:39,112
provided and how input is

3139
02:07:39,112 --> 02:07:40,679
considered. And it also means

3140
02:07:40,679 --> 02:07:41,913
recognizing that the same

3141
02:07:41,913 --> 02:07:44,784
engagement method will not work

3142
02:07:44,784 --> 02:07:46,818
equally for every community.

3143
02:07:46,818 --> 02:07:49,121
The bottom line is that equity

3144
02:07:49,121 --> 02:07:50,555
needs to be embedded throughout

3145
02:07:50,555 --> 02:07:52,900
engagement, planning and

3146
02:07:52,900 --> 02:07:54,590
implementation, rather than

3147
02:07:54,590 --> 02:07:54,626
treated as a separate or

3148
02:07:54,626 --> 02:07:56,626
standalone objective. Next

3149
02:07:59,432 --> 02:08:01,432
slide.

3150
02:08:01,766 --> 02:08:03,435
This final slide outlines the

3151
02:08:03,435 --> 02:08:05,170
remaining steps in this process.

3152
02:08:05,170 --> 02:08:06,204
Staff is now finalizing

3153
02:08:06,204 --> 02:08:08,807
revisions to the plan based on

3154
02:08:08,807 --> 02:08:11,544
what we heard from this council,

3155
02:08:11,544 --> 02:08:12,478
as well as the feedback we

3156
02:08:12,478 --> 02:08:14,212
received during our public

3157
02:08:14,212 --> 02:08:16,448
comment period, and the revised

3158
02:08:16,448 --> 02:08:18,650
plan will then be presented to

3159
02:08:18,650 --> 02:08:20,485
the joint mtc abag legislation

3160
02:08:20,485 --> 02:08:22,870
committee next friday, with a

3161
02:08:22,870 --> 02:08:23,989
recommendation to forward it to

3162
02:08:23,989 --> 02:08:24,489
the commission for consideration

3163
02:08:24,489 --> 02:08:26,458
of adoption.

3164
02:08:26,458 --> 02:08:28,661
I do want to close by thanking

3165
02:08:28,661 --> 02:08:30,662
you for the feedback that you

3166
02:08:30,662 --> 02:08:32,130
have provided throughout this

3167
02:08:32,130 --> 02:08:35,130
process. Not only during the

3168
02:08:36,200 --> 02:08:39,200
formal ppp review, but through

3169
02:08:39,400 --> 02:08:40,873
the broader conversations the

3170
02:08:40,873 --> 02:08:41,540
council has had about what

3171
02:08:41,540 --> 02:08:43,208
meaningful community engagement

3172
02:08:43,208 --> 02:08:45,444
should look like. The

3173
02:08:45,444 --> 02:08:46,578
consistency between what we have

3174
02:08:46,578 --> 02:08:48,747
heard through the public review

3175
02:08:48,747 --> 02:08:51,349
and what you have been telling

3176
02:08:51,349 --> 02:08:53,385
us reinforces the direction of

3177
02:08:53,385 --> 02:08:56,188
this update. This does conclude

3178
02:08:56,188 --> 02:08:58,991
my presentation, and I would be

3179
02:08:58,991 --> 02:08:59,592
happy to answer any questions.

3180
02:08:59,592 --> 02:09:00,293
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3181
02:09:00,293 --> 02:09:01,827
thank you so much, veronica.

3182
02:09:01,827 --> 02:09:02,694
It's great it see our own

3183
02:09:02,694 --> 02:09:04,729
feedback incorporated into this

3184
02:09:04,729 --> 02:09:07,129
slide deck. Thank you.

3185
02:09:07,999 --> 02:09:09,901
And also just noting that as a

3186
02:09:09,901 --> 02:09:12,337
community organizer, a lot of

3187
02:09:12,337 --> 02:09:12,904
these things sound like

3188
02:09:12,904 --> 02:09:13,171
organizing

3189
02:09:13,171 --> 02:09:15,171
[Laughter]

3190
02:09:15,408 --> 02:09:17,742
-- incorporated into this. So,

3191
02:09:17,742 --> 02:09:19,878
I hope that it does get realized

3192
02:09:19,878 --> 02:09:21,714
and resourced well. Are

3193
02:09:21,714 --> 02:09:22,882
there council members who would

3194
02:09:22,882 --> 02:09:24,249
like to participate in

3195
02:09:24,249 --> 02:09:26,649
discussion? Please raise your

3196
02:09:26,651 --> 02:09:30,251
hand. I'm going to start from

3197
02:09:32,570 --> 02:09:34,457
my left. Member sbranti.

3198
02:09:46,400 --> 02:09:48,404
Member demong. Member duong,

3199
02:09:49,342 --> 02:09:52,342
cha, madrid on zoom. Let's

3200
02:09:52,378 --> 02:09:53,245
start with you member sbranti.

3201
02:09:53,245 --> 02:09:54,279
>>speaker: great. Thank you.

3202
02:09:54,279 --> 02:09:55,947
Great presentation. I think I

3203
02:09:55,947 --> 02:09:57,150
don't know if it's more of a

3204
02:09:57,150 --> 02:09:58,517
question or comment, I guess

3205
02:09:58,517 --> 02:10:00,218
it's a question. So there is a

3206
02:10:00,218 --> 02:10:01,186
lot of rev representatives to

3207
02:10:01,186 --> 02:10:03,186
community-based organizations

3208
02:10:03,188 --> 02:10:04,757
which is fantastic and I

3209
02:10:04,757 --> 02:10:06,458
participate in those. I'm not

3210
02:10:06,458 --> 02:10:07,225
sure about the level of

3211
02:10:07,225 --> 02:10:08,194
engagement with business

3212
02:10:08,194 --> 02:10:10,762
community and I don't know if

3213
02:10:10,762 --> 02:10:11,963
you're just community-based

3214
02:10:11,963 --> 02:10:13,398
organizations is broadly

3215
02:10:13,398 --> 02:10:16,101
incorporating business but a lot

3216
02:10:16,101 --> 02:10:18,501
of times business community

3217
02:10:18,570 --> 02:10:20,138
doesn't proactively think to

3218
02:10:20,138 --> 02:10:21,173
participate in these kinds of

3219
02:10:21,173 --> 02:10:23,375
processes and sometimes doesn't

3220
02:10:23,375 --> 02:10:25,944
think these processes are for

3221
02:10:25,944 --> 02:10:27,447
them. You know it's like

3222
02:10:27,447 --> 02:10:29,382
governments doing this

3223
02:10:29,382 --> 02:10:31,382
community-based organizations,

3224
02:10:31,883 --> 02:10:34,720
ngo's, you know, there is a lot

3225
02:10:34,720 --> 02:10:36,722
of silo effect so I want to make

3226
02:10:36,722 --> 02:10:38,490
sure they're incorporated

3227
02:10:38,490 --> 02:10:39,691
proactively into this process

3228
02:10:39,691 --> 02:10:41,460
and also with the business

3229
02:10:41,460 --> 02:10:43,860
community recognizing that it's

3230
02:10:45,130 --> 02:10:47,666
not monolither so you have

3231
02:10:47,666 --> 02:10:49,367
businesses like bay area council

3232
02:10:49,367 --> 02:10:50,702
east bay commerce level small

3233
02:10:50,702 --> 02:10:53,710
business those might be two

3234
02:10:53,710 --> 02:10:54,906
different perspectives and

3235
02:10:54,906 --> 02:10:56,740
thinking about labor as well

3236
02:10:56,740 --> 02:10:57,641
interest that needs to be a

3237
02:10:57,641 --> 02:10:59,712
participant in this you know,

3238
02:10:59,712 --> 02:11:01,847
those that you know are bringing

3239
02:11:01,847 --> 02:11:03,483
their lunch pail to work they're

3240
02:11:03,483 --> 02:11:06,885
working noon to five or whatever

3241
02:11:06,885 --> 02:11:09,885
their hours are, figuring out

3242
02:11:09,921 --> 02:11:10,889
sometimes how it was alluded to

3243
02:11:10,889 --> 02:11:12,924
that they will be different

3244
02:11:12,924 --> 02:11:14,493
times evening sessions and

3245
02:11:14,493 --> 02:11:16,428
everything else but again being

3246
02:11:16,428 --> 02:11:18,163
intentional and proactive

3247
02:11:18,163 --> 02:11:20,866
because they MAY if something's

3248
02:11:20,866 --> 02:11:22,766
taking place at a community

3249
02:11:22,766 --> 02:11:24,636
center or something they MAY not

3250
02:11:24,636 --> 02:11:26,739
-- we might just need to have a

3251
02:11:26,739 --> 02:11:28,740
bit more tailored outreach just

3252
02:11:28,740 --> 02:11:29,307
something to think about.

3253
02:11:29,307 --> 02:11:31,610
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3254
02:11:31,610 --> 02:11:34,179
thank you member sbranti. I

3255
02:11:34,179 --> 02:11:37,183
think to add to that would be

3256
02:11:37,183 --> 02:11:38,917
nice to see where the consensus

3257
02:11:38,917 --> 02:11:41,586
is if there were challenges of

3258
02:11:41,586 --> 02:11:42,922
meeting people where they are in

3259
02:11:42,922 --> 02:11:44,589
terms of feedback different

3260
02:11:44,589 --> 02:11:46,989
interests angles that benefit

3261
02:11:47,125 --> 02:11:50,195
mtc to find out what's the

3262
02:11:50,195 --> 02:11:52,798
consensus about what we all need

3263
02:11:52,798 --> 02:11:53,698
or something like that.

3264
02:11:53,698 --> 02:11:55,233
>>speaker: amazing presentation

3265
02:11:55,233 --> 02:11:57,435
as always it's great to hear

3266
02:11:57,435 --> 02:11:59,938
about all the great work you

3267
02:11:59,938 --> 02:12:02,400
guys are doing. Particularly

3268
02:12:02,400 --> 02:12:03,976
with working with the mineta

3269
02:12:03,976 --> 02:12:06,976
summer program and getting them

3270
02:12:07,450 --> 02:12:08,280
to participate but I think you

3271
02:12:08,280 --> 02:12:09,648
mentioned already it would be

3272
02:12:09,648 --> 02:12:12,350
good once you guys are done with

3273
02:12:12,350 --> 02:12:14,986
the revisions you submit to the

3274
02:12:14,986 --> 02:12:17,386
commission on connecting back

3275
02:12:17,721 --> 02:12:20,721
with the youth who participated

3276
02:12:21,920 --> 02:12:24,920
and in the process specifically

3277
02:12:24,596 --> 02:12:25,664
or broadly letting them know

3278
02:12:25,664 --> 02:12:28,640
their engagement led to

3279
02:12:29,935 --> 02:12:31,700
something actionable.

3280
02:12:31,700 --> 02:12:33,470
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3281
02:12:36,141 --> 02:12:37,800
thank you. Member?

3282
02:12:37,800 --> 02:12:38,978
>>speaker: thank you for the

3283
02:12:38,978 --> 02:12:41,113
presentation. Two comments and

3284
02:12:41,113 --> 02:12:43,114
question. First what stood out

3285
02:12:43,114 --> 02:12:46,714
most was close of the feedback

3286
02:12:54,292 --> 02:12:57,892
loop when we're asking cbo's and

3287
02:12:58,330 --> 02:13:01,330
and advisory bodies to stay

3288
02:13:03,902 --> 02:13:04,137
engaged over a multi-year

3289
02:13:04,137 --> 02:13:05,538
process

3290
02:13:05,538 --> 02:13:07,538
process.

3291
02:13:09,740 --> 02:13:10,543
>>bryant duong: people need

3292
02:13:10,543 --> 02:13:13,678
to be able to see what happened

3293
02:13:13,678 --> 02:13:16,780
with their input. Second,

3294
02:13:16,248 --> 02:13:17,849
survey more than 1200, 1300

3295
02:13:17,849 --> 02:13:18,950
participants came through it's

3296
02:13:18,950 --> 02:13:21,350
carrying this effort but

3297
02:13:21,386 --> 02:13:23,889
attachment b doesn't report who

3298
02:13:23,889 --> 02:13:25,924
responded so there is no

3299
02:13:25,924 --> 02:13:27,692
language by county income race

3300
02:13:27,692 --> 02:13:29,895
is staff able to release that or

3301
02:13:29,895 --> 02:13:31,998
provide council with that? If

3302
02:13:31,998 --> 02:13:34,398
you know demographics weren't

3303
02:13:34,432 --> 02:13:36,368
collected? I think that's worth

3304
02:13:36,368 --> 02:13:38,400
knowing too worth considering by

3305
02:13:38,400 --> 02:13:38,570
the next cycle. Thank you.

3306
02:13:38,570 --> 02:13:40,970
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3307
02:13:41,573 --> 02:13:45,173
would you like to respond to

3308
02:13:46,678 --> 02:13:48,678
that?

3309
02:13:50,160 --> 02:13:52,160
>>veronica cummings

3310
02:13:52,500 --> 02:13:53,619
>>veronica cummings thank you

3311
02:13:53,619 --> 02:13:54,386
very much for elevates the

3312
02:13:54,386 --> 02:13:56,622
business community as a

3313
02:13:56,622 --> 02:13:57,689
stakeholder which we recognize

3314
02:13:57,689 --> 02:14:00,890
in your public participation

3315
02:14:00,259 --> 02:14:02,761
plan we do have a list of

3316
02:14:02,761 --> 02:14:04,129
stakeholders including chambers

3317
02:14:04,129 --> 02:14:06,899
of commerce we absolutely try to

3318
02:14:06,899 --> 02:14:09,100
be inclusive of all stakeholders

3319
02:14:09,100 --> 02:14:11,436
in the bay area and thank you

3320
02:14:11,436 --> 02:14:14,105
member duong for your suggestion

3321
02:14:14,105 --> 02:14:15,174
to bring back the feedback to

3322
02:14:15,174 --> 02:14:16,241
our high school academy

3323
02:14:16,241 --> 02:14:17,776
participants I agree with you

3324
02:14:17,776 --> 02:14:19,177
that it would be wonderful for

3325
02:14:19,177 --> 02:14:20,179
them to see how their

3326
02:14:20,179 --> 02:14:22,579
contribution to the discussion

3327
02:14:22,614 --> 02:14:23,382
was incorporated into the public

3328
02:14:23,382 --> 02:14:25,160
participation plan and then last

3329
02:14:25,160 --> 02:14:26,651
question in response to the

3330
02:14:26,651 --> 02:14:29,421
survey we do have the

3331
02:14:29,421 --> 02:14:31,821
information of the survey

3332
02:14:31,990 --> 02:14:33,892
respondents, the language

3333
02:14:33,892 --> 02:14:35,460
participation, we also try to

3334
02:14:35,460 --> 02:14:37,460
collect demographic information

3335
02:14:37,496 --> 02:14:39,970
it's voluntary but it's not

3336
02:14:39,970 --> 02:14:40,999
mandatory so that's a challenge

3337
02:14:40,999 --> 02:14:42,467
in providing that information

3338
02:14:42,467 --> 02:14:43,702
because we just tonight

3339
02:14:43,702 --> 02:14:45,237
necessarily receive it.

3340
02:14:45,237 --> 02:14:46,438
Including we're asked a lot of

3341
02:14:46,438 --> 02:14:47,672
times to provide survey

3342
02:14:47,672 --> 02:14:49,307
information at the county level

3343
02:14:49,307 --> 02:14:50,542
which we also include, but again

3344
02:14:50,542 --> 02:14:52,942
it's not required for

3345
02:14:53,645 --> 02:14:54,446
respondents to provide. But we

3346
02:14:54,446 --> 02:14:56,314
can absolutely provide any

3347
02:14:56,314 --> 02:14:57,315
demographic information that we

3348
02:14:57,315 --> 02:14:58,517
collected.

3349
02:14:58,517 --> 02:15:00,185
>>bryant duong: great. Thank

3350
02:15:00,185 --> 02:15:00,786
you.

3351
02:15:00,786 --> 02:15:03,186
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3352
02:15:05,157 --> 02:15:05,892
thank you. Next is member cha?

3353
02:15:05,892 --> 02:15:08,292
>>kathleen cha: I really

3354
02:15:09,728 --> 02:15:10,829
thought a very thorough

3355
02:15:10,829 --> 02:15:11,630
presentation, it really did

3356
02:15:11,630 --> 02:15:13,632
incorporate not only our

3357
02:15:13,632 --> 02:15:16,735
thoughts but quite a few. And

3358
02:15:16,735 --> 02:15:19,571
it did -- and I really under

3359
02:15:19,571 --> 02:15:20,605
score what's been said about

3360
02:15:20,605 --> 02:15:22,575
community-based organizations,

3361
02:15:22,575 --> 02:15:25,610
but it also inspired in me that

3362
02:15:25,610 --> 02:15:27,379
there are two ways to this.

3363
02:15:27,379 --> 02:15:28,981
There is a lot of already

3364
02:15:28,981 --> 02:15:30,415
feeling before this in prior

3365
02:15:30,415 --> 02:15:32,517
plans, which I have participated

3366
02:15:32,517 --> 02:15:34,653
in over the course of time, and

3367
02:15:34,653 --> 02:15:37,889
one of the things that has come

3368
02:15:37,889 --> 02:15:40,625
up is that -- and you have

3369
02:15:40,625 --> 02:15:42,428
addressed this, and it's the

3370
02:15:42,428 --> 02:15:43,428
very fact, so we come,

3371
02:15:43,428 --> 02:15:44,896
participate, give you some

3372
02:15:44,896 --> 02:15:48,496
ideas, but you don't see that

3373
02:15:49,902 --> 02:15:51,603
they actually had, or they are

3374
02:15:51,603 --> 02:15:52,437
come in sense too late in the

3375
02:15:52,437 --> 02:15:53,972
process, things have already

3376
02:15:53,972 --> 02:15:55,807
been decided. So what I'm

3377
02:15:55,807 --> 02:15:58,109
moving to -- and I know that's

3378
02:15:58,109 --> 02:16:00,112
still the challenge to overcome

3379
02:16:00,112 --> 02:16:02,380
that particular feeling or bias,

3380
02:16:02,380 --> 02:16:05,980
or however you want to describe

3381
02:16:06,518 --> 02:16:10,155
it -- but I think there is a

3382
02:16:10,155 --> 02:16:11,791
need to make sure that it would

3383
02:16:11,791 --> 02:16:13,791
the community-based

3384
02:16:14,359 --> 02:16:16,759
organizations, the business, the

3385
02:16:18,130 --> 02:16:21,730
whole group, you need to come

3386
02:16:23,102 --> 02:16:24,136
back to them, and say, you know,

3387
02:16:24,136 --> 02:16:25,704
there is your responsibility as

3388
02:16:25,704 --> 02:16:26,438
someone representing the

3389
02:16:26,438 --> 02:16:27,539
communities to be able to

3390
02:16:27,539 --> 02:16:29,674
present these opportunities and

3391
02:16:29,674 --> 02:16:32,844
be part of that process p they

3392
02:16:32,844 --> 02:16:35,380
have to be a good pipeline. And

3393
02:16:35,380 --> 02:16:37,482
this is their way because it

3394
02:16:37,482 --> 02:16:39,217
will serve our communities if we

3395
02:16:39,217 --> 02:16:41,520
do do that. So I'm just saying

3396
02:16:41,520 --> 02:16:43,255
that really needs to be brought

3397
02:16:43,255 --> 02:16:45,757
up and we need to obviously keep

3398
02:16:45,757 --> 02:16:47,259
bringing in as many

3399
02:16:47,259 --> 02:16:49,259
community-based organizations to

3400
02:16:49,728 --> 02:16:52,164
this process as possible. Just

3401
02:16:52,164 --> 02:16:53,932
something that I think that we

3402
02:16:53,932 --> 02:16:56,340
forget. We think well,

3403
02:16:56,340 --> 02:16:58,434
that's your problem. No,

3404
02:16:59,171 --> 02:17:02,171
actually, I think it's our

3405
02:17:02,174 --> 02:17:05,174
problem as part of whatever

3406
02:17:10,649 --> 02:17:12,518
community

3407
02:17:12,518 --> 02:17:13,985
organization,

3408
02:17:13,985 --> 02:17:15,554
whatever community and how we

3409
02:17:15,554 --> 02:17:17,220
serve our communities.

3410
02:17:17,220 --> 02:17:18,557
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3411
02:17:18,557 --> 02:17:19,157
thank you. Member wong?

3412
02:17:19,157 --> 02:17:20,792
>>janelle wong: thank you so

3413
02:17:20,792 --> 02:17:23,192
much for this presentation.

3414
02:17:23,194 --> 02:17:24,996
This is wonderful to see. Our

3415
02:17:24,996 --> 02:17:27,996
thoughts reflected here, also as

3416
02:17:29,334 --> 02:17:30,936
an organizer, I have been

3417
02:17:30,936 --> 02:17:33,710
screaming into the ether for a

3418
02:17:33,710 --> 02:17:34,773
very long time to have a lot of

3419
02:17:34,773 --> 02:17:36,410
these things be real and have

3420
02:17:36,410 --> 02:17:39,641
people hear why people want to

3421
02:17:39,945 --> 02:17:40,645
be heard. And so we deeply

3422
02:17:40,645 --> 02:17:41,513
appreciate this document

3423
02:17:41,513 --> 02:17:43,513
hopefully it's successful

3424
02:17:44,516 --> 02:17:46,451
because I think that's one thing

3425
02:17:46,451 --> 02:17:47,953
I echo council member lieu is

3426
02:17:47,953 --> 02:17:49,454
that even though a lot us have

3427
02:17:49,454 --> 02:17:50,789
been saying it, we don't

3428
02:17:50,789 --> 02:17:53,292
actually know how successful it

3429
02:17:53,292 --> 02:17:55,260
is. So I hope to see in the

3430
02:17:55,260 --> 02:17:58,263
years to come success on this

3431
02:17:58,263 --> 02:17:59,364
type of communication and

3432
02:17:59,364 --> 02:18:01,266
organizing. The other thing I

3433
02:18:01,266 --> 02:18:03,503
would say in terms of relaying

3434
02:18:03,503 --> 02:18:04,569
back to us the success of these

3435
02:18:04,569 --> 02:18:05,837
types of communications because

3436
02:18:05,837 --> 02:18:08,507
this is the first time I have

3437
02:18:08,507 --> 02:18:11,276
seen the framework publicly be

3438
02:18:11,276 --> 02:18:14,276
inclusive. That maybe there is

3439
02:18:14,880 --> 02:18:17,280
framework for other agencies,

3440
02:18:18,184 --> 02:18:21,860
other local counties to take on

3441
02:18:21,860 --> 02:18:22,621
these things because the topics

3442
02:18:22,621 --> 02:18:23,722
we're talking about both

3443
02:18:23,722 --> 02:18:26,122
transportation and housing can

3444
02:18:26,291 --> 02:18:28,293
be polarizing so even at your

3445
02:18:28,293 --> 02:18:30,362
best efforts to include all the

3446
02:18:30,362 --> 02:18:32,397
voices that sometimes it can be

3447
02:18:32,397 --> 02:18:34,634
challenging to hear that your

3448
02:18:34,634 --> 02:18:37,340
participation MAY not have

3449
02:18:37,902 --> 02:18:40,405
gotten to the place where you

3450
02:18:40,405 --> 02:18:41,740
thought it should be and that's

3451
02:18:41,740 --> 02:18:43,175
on both sides of the I'll in

3452
02:18:43,175 --> 02:18:45,430
terms of housing and

3453
02:18:45,430 --> 02:18:46,879
transportation. So would be

3454
02:18:46,879 --> 02:18:50,479
interesting to see in the future

3455
02:18:51,820 --> 02:18:54,319
how this is working, a case

3456
02:18:54,319 --> 02:18:55,887
study in particular challenging

3457
02:18:55,887 --> 02:18:56,688
topics whether it's housing or

3458
02:18:56,688 --> 02:18:59,880
transportation, pick either of

3459
02:19:00,759 --> 02:19:03,161
the two, in a community where it

3460
02:19:03,161 --> 02:19:05,931
is challenging to see if the way

3461
02:19:05,931 --> 02:19:08,500
you framed it and the way that

3462
02:19:08,500 --> 02:19:09,601
this organizing has been

3463
02:19:09,601 --> 02:19:11,571
executed, not a perfect answer

3464
02:19:11,571 --> 02:19:13,972
but got us to an answer that

3465
02:19:13,972 --> 02:19:15,440
makes the implementation of long

3466
02:19:15,440 --> 02:19:17,642
term vision and the plan better.

3467
02:19:17,642 --> 02:19:21,242
That's what I would like to

3468
02:19:22,414 --> 02:19:24,416
hear, a couple years from now,

3469
02:19:24,416 --> 02:19:26,685
ongoing basis for the public to,

3470
02:19:26,685 --> 02:19:28,154
sort of, understand. It's not

3471
02:19:28,154 --> 02:19:30,355
perfect we're dealing with

3472
02:19:30,355 --> 02:19:32,958
topics that people have lots of

3473
02:19:32,958 --> 02:19:36,862
opinions on so it would be nice

3474
02:19:36,862 --> 02:19:38,531
if this framework from beginning

3475
02:19:38,531 --> 02:19:40,650
to end, it's great start for us

3476
02:19:40,650 --> 02:19:42,767
moving forward in terms of

3477
02:19:42,767 --> 02:19:43,101
advocating in these spaces.

3478
02:19:43,101 --> 02:19:43,802
Thank you.

3479
02:19:43,802 --> 02:19:46,710
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3480
02:19:46,710 --> 02:19:48,673
thank you member wong. Council

3481
02:19:48,673 --> 02:19:51,730
member madrid then continuing

3482
02:19:51,877 --> 02:19:52,811
over to you to respond.

3483
02:19:52,811 --> 02:19:54,980
>>alexander madrid: thank you

3484
02:19:54,980 --> 02:19:56,481
for covering veronica. I think

3485
02:19:56,481 --> 02:19:59,850
we mentioned this already but I

3486
02:19:59,850 --> 02:20:03,285
think it would be good to bring

3487
02:20:05,990 --> 02:20:09,590
back some of the milestones that

3488
02:20:10,496 --> 02:20:12,896
organizations take to the

3489
02:20:16,636 --> 02:20:19,137
community and give them an

3490
02:20:19,137 --> 02:20:22,137
update. That's one thing. And

3491
02:20:22,374 --> 02:20:25,974
the second thing I want to

3492
02:20:31,382 --> 02:20:34,382
strongly suggest that we should

3493
02:20:38,757 --> 02:20:42,127
think about is that this plan

3494
02:20:42,127 --> 02:20:45,727
would change and pivot and I

3495
02:20:46,631 --> 02:20:50,831
want to ask if there is any

3496
02:20:51,536 --> 02:20:54,105
opportunity to push push back to

3497
02:20:54,105 --> 02:20:56,505
those communities that when

3498
02:20:57,476 --> 02:21:00,145
reached out to in the past, and

3499
02:21:00,145 --> 02:21:03,682
I said who had to make a change,

3500
02:21:03,682 --> 02:21:07,120
what do you think about this, or

3501
02:21:07,120 --> 02:21:09,121
any suggestion that MAY suggest

3502
02:21:09,121 --> 02:21:11,121
to

3503
02:21:11,890 --> 02:21:15,260
to do. So, just want to bring

3504
02:21:15,260 --> 02:21:18,860
that up. If there is any

3505
02:21:19,831 --> 02:21:20,432
opportunity to do that.

3506
02:21:20,432 --> 02:21:21,466
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3507
02:21:21,466 --> 02:21:24,466
thank you council member madrid.

3508
02:21:25,904 --> 02:21:28,773
I'll turn it over to you,

3509
02:21:28,773 --> 02:21:30,475
veronica.

3510
02:21:30,475 --> 02:21:32,875
>>veronica cummings okay. Thank

3511
02:21:33,513 --> 02:21:36,281
you for the feedback, the

3512
02:21:36,281 --> 02:21:39,281
continued feedback. And I do

3513
02:21:39,418 --> 02:21:40,986
agree that with this public

3514
02:21:40,986 --> 02:21:43,386
participation plan, the feedback

3515
02:21:43,421 --> 02:21:47,210
loop is important, as well as

3516
02:21:47,726 --> 02:21:50,194
thank you for recognizing the

3517
02:21:50,194 --> 02:21:53,194
inclusivity of this plan, which

3518
02:21:55,233 --> 02:21:57,200
I do -- so, there are, as an

3519
02:21:57,200 --> 02:21:59,400
agency, a lot of projects that

3520
02:21:59,400 --> 02:22:00,472
we're engaging different

3521
02:22:00,472 --> 02:22:02,472
stakeholders, the communities,

3522
02:22:03,708 --> 02:22:05,177
et cetera, and this public

3523
02:22:05,177 --> 02:22:08,790
participation plan is the broad

3524
02:22:08,790 --> 02:22:11,790
plan for the various projects.

3525
02:22:11,683 --> 02:22:13,119
And we are working to coordinate

3526
02:22:13,119 --> 02:22:14,986
internally so that when we are

3527
02:22:14,986 --> 02:22:16,922
out in the community, again,

3528
02:22:16,922 --> 02:22:20,522
we're trying to -- we really

3529
02:22:20,625 --> 02:22:22,930
want to be cognizant of reducing

3530
02:22:22,930 --> 02:22:23,728
the engagement fatigue, and

3531
02:22:23,728 --> 02:22:26,128
duplication, et cetera, et

3532
02:22:26,832 --> 02:22:28,733
cetera. Any time you are

3533
02:22:28,733 --> 02:22:30,135
undertaking an ambitious

3534
02:22:30,135 --> 02:22:32,236
process, you know, there does

3535
02:22:32,236 --> 02:22:33,572
need to be a little bit of grace

3536
02:22:33,572 --> 02:22:35,807
at the beginning. Because it's

3537
02:22:35,807 --> 02:22:37,477
-- it's not as though we can

3538
02:22:37,477 --> 02:22:39,444
stop all of the work on these

3539
02:22:39,444 --> 02:22:41,446
projects so that we could then

3540
02:22:41,446 --> 02:22:43,482
do the engagement, right?

3541
02:22:43,482 --> 02:22:45,882
Especially when we're talking

3542
02:22:47,251 --> 02:22:48,187
about things, the hot topics,

3543
02:22:48,187 --> 02:22:50,187
housing, transportation, et

3544
02:22:50,355 --> 02:22:52,525
cetera. I want to at least say

3545
02:22:52,525 --> 02:22:54,258
to this council that we -- we do

3546
02:22:54,258 --> 02:22:56,128
hear everything that you're

3547
02:22:56,128 --> 02:22:57,129
saying, and that we are

3548
02:22:57,129 --> 02:22:59,529
committed to being responsive

3549
02:23:01,732 --> 02:23:04,732
while recognizing the work is

3550
02:23:04,936 --> 02:23:08,305
ongoing. And so that then to

3551
02:23:08,305 --> 02:23:08,772
member matradition's

3552
02:23:08,772 --> 02:23:10,772
drid

3553
02:23:11,877 --> 02:23:13,545
madrid's feedback and

3554
02:23:13,545 --> 02:23:14,713
question, you know, giving the

3555
02:23:14,713 --> 02:23:16,648
community updates and the

3556
02:23:16,648 --> 02:23:18,717
opportunity for communities to

3557
02:23:18,717 --> 02:23:21,286
respond, this is it go back to

3558
02:23:21,286 --> 02:23:24,286
just there being many projects,

3559
02:23:24,623 --> 02:23:26,391
and so I -- this broad ppp is

3560
02:23:26,391 --> 02:23:28,693
applicable to us as an agency,

3561
02:23:28,693 --> 02:23:31,563
and then we would -- the

3562
02:23:31,563 --> 02:23:33,963
individual project members, you

3563
02:23:34,266 --> 02:23:37,702
know, we would then pass this

3564
02:23:37,702 --> 02:23:39,104
information along to make sure

3565
02:23:39,104 --> 02:23:41,972
that they receive it and are

3566
02:23:41,972 --> 02:23:44,342
also then incorporating the

3567
02:23:44,342 --> 02:23:47,342
feedback from this council into

3568
02:23:47,579 --> 02:23:49,381
it. So, I can't say yes

3569
02:23:49,381 --> 02:23:51,817
absolutely, because I -- it's

3570
02:23:51,817 --> 02:23:54,520
just not me to over promise and

3571
02:23:54,520 --> 02:23:54,954
underdlifrment but I can only

3572
02:23:54,954 --> 02:23:56,456
say that we're absolutely

3573
02:23:56,456 --> 02:23:58,560
hearing what you are saying, and

3574
02:23:58,560 --> 02:23:59,723
would be happy to come back to

3575
02:23:59,723 --> 02:24:01,260
this council to report back on

3576
02:24:01,260 --> 02:24:03,663
the various things that you have

3577
02:24:03,663 --> 02:24:05,463
offered today, as well as in

3578
02:24:05,463 --> 02:24:06,640
previous meetings.

3579
02:24:06,640 --> 02:24:06,998
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3580
02:24:06,998 --> 02:24:08,998
thank you veronica.

3581
02:24:09,902 --> 02:24:13,839
And last we have member -- or

3582
02:24:13,839 --> 02:24:16,675
vice chair benitez. No? Okay.

3583
02:24:16,675 --> 02:24:18,176
Well then, will the clerk please

3584
02:24:18,176 --> 02:24:19,679
inform us of any public comment

3585
02:24:19,679 --> 02:24:20,679
submitted for this item or

3586
02:24:20,679 --> 02:24:23,315
whether there were any members

3587
02:24:23,315 --> 02:24:26,318
of the public wishing to give

3588
02:24:26,318 --> 02:24:27,619
public comment?

3589
02:24:27,619 --> 02:24:28,653
>>clerk, jessica lewis: we

3590
02:24:28,653 --> 02:24:29,855
received no written public

3591
02:24:29,855 --> 02:24:31,723
comment for this item. There

3592
02:24:31,723 --> 02:24:33,526
are no speakers at the podium

3593
02:24:33,526 --> 02:24:34,759
and no raised hands in the zoom

3594
02:24:34,759 --> 02:24:35,930
space wishing to provide public

3595
02:24:35,930 --> 02:24:35,694
comment.

3596
02:24:35,694 --> 02:24:36,762
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3597
02:24:36,762 --> 02:24:38,697
thank you. So now we'll move

3598
02:24:38,697 --> 02:24:40,700
over to agenda item number six

3599
02:24:40,700 --> 02:24:41,833
which is the staff liaison

3600
02:24:41,833 --> 02:24:43,335
report, an overview of the

3601
02:24:43,335 --> 02:24:46,171
recent mtc and abag policy

3602
02:24:46,171 --> 02:24:48,390
decisions and other activities.

3603
02:24:48,390 --> 02:24:50,308
This is an information item.

3604
02:24:50,308 --> 02:24:53,110
Ky-nam miller will you please

3605
02:24:53,110 --> 02:24:55,110
give the report?

3606
02:24:55,847 --> 02:24:56,515
>>ky-nam miller: gladly chair

3607
02:24:56,515 --> 02:24:57,349
lieu. In addition to the

3608
02:24:57,349 --> 02:24:59,349
written report acknowledging

3609
02:24:59,751 --> 02:25:02,788
what you mentioned at the top of

3610
02:25:02,788 --> 02:25:04,157
the meeting that we have the

3611
02:25:04,157 --> 02:25:06,557
upcoming OCTOBER 29th workshop

3612
02:25:07,225 --> 02:25:10,825
which jessica and I will e-mail

3613
02:25:11,496 --> 02:25:14,332
out for our sps purposes along

3614
02:25:14,332 --> 02:25:16,467
with the soon-to-be unveiled

3615
02:25:16,467 --> 02:25:18,203
accessible futures proceedings

3616
02:25:18,203 --> 02:25:20,438
report. Following up on my

3617
02:25:20,438 --> 02:25:22,438
colleague veronica's excellent

3618
02:25:22,507 --> 02:25:23,975
presentation that was made

3619
02:25:23,975 --> 02:25:26,244
manifest took approximate a week

3620
02:25:26,244 --> 02:25:29,247
ago AUGUST 24th when mtc and

3621
02:25:29,247 --> 02:25:31,283
abag hosted the inaugural

3622
02:25:31,283 --> 02:25:33,283
community partnership exchange

3623
02:25:37,990 --> 02:25:38,623
which brought together 50

3624
02:25:38,623 --> 02:25:40,623
representatives from 37

3625
02:25:41,226 --> 02:25:42,360
community-based organizations to

3626
02:25:42,360 --> 02:25:43,996
strengthen relationship and

3627
02:25:43,996 --> 02:25:45,996
explore future collaborations

3628
02:25:47,599 --> 02:25:48,567
my colleagues here on my left,

3629
02:25:48,567 --> 02:25:50,368
matt maloney and my other

3630
02:25:50,368 --> 02:25:52,768
colleagues vice chair diana

3631
02:25:52,771 --> 02:25:54,372
benitez, both spoke at the group

3632
02:25:54,372 --> 02:25:57,372
and staff shared efforts to

3633
02:25:57,409 --> 02:25:59,211
improve cbo engagement including

3634
02:25:59,211 --> 02:26:00,545
partner compensation streamline

3635
02:26:00,545 --> 02:26:02,545
contracting better coordination

3636
02:26:02,914 --> 02:26:05,314
and more continuous cocreation.

3637
02:26:06,170 --> 02:26:06,985
There were 13 mtc abag teams who

3638
02:26:06,985 --> 02:26:08,653
showcased 18 projects and

3639
02:26:08,653 --> 02:26:10,255
programs giving cbo's

3640
02:26:10,255 --> 02:26:11,890
opportunity to connect directly

3641
02:26:11,890 --> 02:26:14,890
with staff and learn about

3642
02:26:16,194 --> 02:26:18,130
current upcoming work. And I

3643
02:26:18,130 --> 02:26:20,530
will send out professional

3644
02:26:20,766 --> 02:26:22,467
photos that were taken from the

3645
02:26:22,467 --> 02:26:23,802
event. There's also an update

3646
02:26:23,802 --> 02:26:25,270
specific for our mind and

3647
02:26:25,270 --> 02:26:26,972
visually impaired council

3648
02:26:26,972 --> 02:26:29,574
members. The agency is moving

3649
02:26:29,574 --> 02:26:31,610
away from granicus. The new

3650
02:26:31,610 --> 02:26:34,646
system will not be granicus, and

3651
02:26:34,646 --> 02:26:35,814
so we want to be aware of how

3652
02:26:35,814 --> 02:26:39,284
that will impact folks who for

3653
02:26:39,284 --> 02:26:41,920
example, don't read pdf's and

3654
02:26:41,920 --> 02:26:43,456
need html based formats so I

3655
02:26:43,456 --> 02:26:45,357
will reach out to members on

3656
02:26:45,357 --> 02:26:47,492
this body to make sure that it's

3657
02:26:47,492 --> 02:26:50,163
working for you all. But just

3658
02:26:50,163 --> 02:26:53,199
giving you a head's up that in

3659
02:26:53,199 --> 02:26:54,466
coming months or so that

3660
02:26:54,466 --> 02:26:56,866
transition is happening and

3661
02:26:57,302 --> 02:26:58,403
we're moving away from granicus.

3662
02:26:58,403 --> 02:27:00,639
And I want to congratulate

3663
02:27:00,639 --> 02:27:02,541
member balaji who I believe just

3664
02:27:02,541 --> 02:27:06,544
started at cal and is going to

3665
02:27:06,544 --> 02:27:08,280
be around. Are you a freshman?

3666
02:27:08,280 --> 02:27:09,681
Yes. So yeah, go bears.

3667
02:27:09,681 --> 02:27:10,816
Looking forward to having you

3668
02:27:10,816 --> 02:27:13,351
for the next four years at least

3669
02:27:13,351 --> 02:27:13,919
around here. That's it.

3670
02:27:13,919 --> 02:27:16,319
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3671
02:27:16,755 --> 02:27:19,324
thank you ky-nam. Is there

3672
02:27:19,324 --> 02:27:21,324
council member discussion?

3673
02:27:30,335 --> 02:27:33,335
Cushman then baldini. Curb cash

3674
02:27:34,940 --> 02:27:36,908
I want to since ky-nam did bring

3675
02:27:36,908 --> 02:27:39,745
up access all features I want to

3676
02:27:39,745 --> 02:27:41,780
say that I do think that when

3677
02:27:41,780 --> 02:27:43,348
matt maloney brought up the old

3678
02:27:43,348 --> 02:27:46,318
working group that happened a

3679
02:27:46,318 --> 02:27:47,786
while ago I hope we look at that

3680
02:27:47,786 --> 02:27:50,489
again we hook add how that might

3681
02:27:50,489 --> 02:27:52,424
be updated because I feel there

3682
02:27:52,424 --> 02:27:54,260
are folks who were on that

3683
02:27:54,260 --> 02:27:57,463
working group that are not as

3684
02:27:57,463 --> 02:27:59,765
engaged as others. Perhaps

3685
02:27:59,765 --> 02:28:02,100
that are engaged more strongly

3686
02:28:02,100 --> 02:28:04,300
so I'm going to recommend that

3687
02:28:04,300 --> 02:28:06,338
we take a look at that in terms

3688
02:28:06,338 --> 02:28:07,906
of mtc is going to look at that

3689
02:28:07,906 --> 02:28:09,808
working group as a touch tone

3690
02:28:09,808 --> 02:28:11,143
moving forward. I really think

3691
02:28:11,143 --> 02:28:12,478
it should be accurately

3692
02:28:12,478 --> 02:28:13,912
reflecting people who are

3693
02:28:13,912 --> 02:28:14,513
engaged at mtc. Thank you.

3694
02:28:14,513 --> 02:28:15,413
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3695
02:28:15,413 --> 02:28:17,813
thank you member cushman.

3696
02:28:18,350 --> 02:28:20,850
Member baldini.

3697
02:28:20,850 --> 02:28:21,654
>>michael baldini: I wanted to

3698
02:28:21,654 --> 02:28:23,822
suggest for future agenda item

3699
02:28:23,822 --> 02:28:26,558
I'll leave it you as board

3700
02:28:26,558 --> 02:28:27,192
chair, but perhaps in our

3701
02:28:27,192 --> 02:28:29,228
earlier discussion, that we

3702
02:28:29,228 --> 02:28:31,628
explore establishing tenants for

3703
02:28:34,433 --> 02:28:36,668
mtc that look at things like,

3704
02:28:36,668 --> 02:28:39,680
you know, benefits, overall

3705
02:28:39,938 --> 02:28:40,572
benefit to the system, to the

3706
02:28:40,572 --> 02:28:42,674
actual transportation of the

3707
02:28:42,674 --> 02:28:44,643
nine bay area counties, as far

3708
02:28:44,643 --> 02:28:46,711
as projects. And, yes, I

3709
02:28:46,711 --> 02:28:49,247
realize that might be outside of

3710
02:28:49,247 --> 02:28:51,820
our scope, but at least some,

3711
02:28:51,820 --> 02:28:54,519
sort of, tenant or pillar that

3712
02:28:54,519 --> 02:28:58,719
we look at these projects from a

3713
02:28:59,859 --> 02:29:04,590
cost benefit and how they add to

3714
02:29:04,330 --> 02:29:04,763
our -- to the system, if you

3715
02:29:04,763 --> 02:29:05,364
will. Thank you.

3716
02:29:05,364 --> 02:29:07,764
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3717
02:29:07,899 --> 02:29:10,299
noted. Thank you member

3718
02:29:11,303 --> 02:29:13,303
baldini. Member madrid?

3719
02:29:20,480 --> 02:29:20,711
>>alexander madrid: yeah, thank

3720
02:29:20,711 --> 02:29:22,711
you

3721
02:29:25,984 --> 02:29:29,584
you. Thank you for the update

3722
02:29:36,761 --> 02:29:39,198
just curious I'm hear you

3723
02:29:39,198 --> 02:29:39,998
correctly discussing the

3724
02:29:39,998 --> 02:29:42,398
conversation with members and

3725
02:29:43,136 --> 02:29:46,736
I'm curious what the staff and

3726
02:29:46,872 --> 02:29:50,472
other work of public inn game

3727
02:29:56,470 --> 02:29:58,818
does, and if you considered

3728
02:29:58,818 --> 02:30:01,218
participation and stipends? I

3729
02:30:04,756 --> 02:30:08,356
just want to have a clarifying

3730
02:30:08,927 --> 02:30:11,927
question. So maybe ky-nam, can

3731
02:30:13,698 --> 02:30:15,333
you clarify on that?

3732
02:30:15,333 --> 02:30:16,434
>>ky-nam miller: sure. Through

3733
02:30:16,434 --> 02:30:18,434
the chair.

3734
02:30:19,700 --> 02:30:22,700
Council member madrid, I'm going

3735
02:30:22,908 --> 02:30:25,760
to restate it as best, if I got

3736
02:30:25,760 --> 02:30:26,745
this right, you asked about

3737
02:30:26,745 --> 02:30:29,114
based on veronica cummings's

3738
02:30:29,114 --> 02:30:30,482
presentation about compensating

3739
02:30:30,482 --> 02:30:31,683
cbo's and group participants and

3740
02:30:31,683 --> 02:30:33,685
how that relates with you being

3741
02:30:33,685 --> 02:30:34,920
a can only member and basically

3742
02:30:34,920 --> 02:30:36,422
different hats you might wear,

3743
02:30:36,422 --> 02:30:38,224
like would you be getting a

3744
02:30:38,224 --> 02:30:41,159
stipend versus paid for that

3745
02:30:41,159 --> 02:30:43,559
experience. Is that right?

3746
02:30:43,895 --> 02:30:45,531
>>alexander madrid: no. No.

3747
02:30:45,531 --> 02:30:47,531
>>ky-nam miller: no?

3748
02:30:47,999 --> 02:30:49,999
>>alexander madrid: no.

3749
02:30:52,103 --> 02:30:55,103
My question was for the

3750
02:30:57,543 --> 02:31:00,745
staffing, and I don't -- to do

3751
02:31:00,745 --> 02:31:03,745
public engagement and outside of

3752
02:31:04,916 --> 02:31:07,916
this events, and with things

3753
02:31:08,820 --> 02:31:12,420
like that, does that consider us

3754
02:31:14,250 --> 02:31:16,425
as participation, constituting a

3755
02:31:23,302 --> 02:31:24,536
stipend? Or -- let me know,

3756
02:31:24,536 --> 02:31:25,537
clarify?

3757
02:31:25,537 --> 02:31:26,605
>>ky-nam miller: I'll restate

3758
02:31:26,605 --> 02:31:27,973
it again now that I understand

3759
02:31:27,973 --> 02:31:29,142
it better. You're asking if

3760
02:31:29,142 --> 02:31:30,976
there is public engagement

3761
02:31:30,976 --> 02:31:32,444
efforts that you are called to

3762
02:31:32,444 --> 02:31:34,980
as a member of council to

3763
02:31:34,980 --> 02:31:37,980
participate in, is that eligible

3764
02:31:38,251 --> 02:31:40,251
for a stipend?

3765
02:31:41,319 --> 02:31:42,722
>>alexander madrid: yes, I'm

3766
02:31:42,722 --> 02:31:43,722
encouraged to participate in.

3767
02:31:43,722 --> 02:31:45,456
>>ky-nam miller: there is

3768
02:31:45,456 --> 02:31:47,692
precedent for that. But there

3769
02:31:47,692 --> 02:31:49,929
would be a little more case by

3770
02:31:49,929 --> 02:31:51,163
case review about which ones

3771
02:31:51,163 --> 02:31:52,697
we're talking about, so

3772
02:31:52,697 --> 02:31:54,432
certainly I'll work with my

3773
02:31:54,432 --> 02:31:56,735
colleagues and legal counsel

3774
02:31:56,735 --> 02:31:58,571
just it make sure we're

3775
02:31:58,571 --> 02:31:59,806
absolutely clear about those

3776
02:31:59,806 --> 02:32:02,206
opportunities and what if

3777
02:32:02,274 --> 02:32:03,410
stipend are eligible for a

3778
02:32:03,410 --> 02:32:05,378
stipend. I don't know if my

3779
02:32:05,378 --> 02:32:06,745
colleagues have anything else to

3780
02:32:06,745 --> 02:32:07,480
add?

3781
02:32:07,480 --> 02:32:08,647
>>alexander madrid: thank you.

3782
02:32:08,647 --> 02:32:09,714
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3783
02:32:09,714 --> 02:32:12,384
okay. Thank you. Will the

3784
02:32:12,384 --> 02:32:13,519
clerk let us know if there is

3785
02:32:13,519 --> 02:32:15,210
any public comments submitted

3786
02:32:15,210 --> 02:32:16,188
for this item or whether there

3787
02:32:16,188 --> 02:32:17,722
are members of the public who

3788
02:32:17,722 --> 02:32:18,290
wish to give public comment.

3789
02:32:18,290 --> 02:32:19,391
>>clerk of the board: we

3790
02:32:19,391 --> 02:32:20,325
received no written public

3791
02:32:20,325 --> 02:32:22,961
comments for this item there are

3792
02:32:22,961 --> 02:32:25,310
no speakers at the podium and no

3793
02:32:25,310 --> 02:32:25,897
raised hands in the zoom space

3794
02:32:25,897 --> 02:32:26,231
wishing to provide public

3795
02:32:26,231 --> 02:32:27,199
comment.

3796
02:32:27,199 --> 02:32:28,733
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3797
02:32:28,733 --> 02:32:31,770
thank you now we will move to

3798
02:32:31,770 --> 02:32:33,239
agenda item seven which is new

3799
02:32:33,239 --> 02:32:34,407
business, this is an information

3800
02:32:34,407 --> 02:32:36,174
item, members of the council can

3801
02:32:36,174 --> 02:32:39,174
add new business. And actually

3802
02:32:40,445 --> 02:32:42,814
would like to start us off with

3803
02:32:42,814 --> 02:32:44,616
a report from member lavery from

3804
02:32:44,616 --> 02:32:47,160
the regional network management

3805
02:32:47,850 --> 02:32:49,485
customer advisory group. And

3806
02:32:51,156 --> 02:32:54,259
then I'll take any hands raised.

3807
02:32:54,259 --> 02:32:56,659
>>charles lavery: sure. Great.

3808
02:32:58,763 --> 02:33:00,799
This is from the AUGUST rnm cag

3809
02:33:00,799 --> 02:33:03,799
group. The meeting focused on

3810
02:33:04,536 --> 02:33:06,538
two primary topics, the transit

3811
02:33:06,538 --> 02:33:08,938
transformation action plan and

3812
02:33:10,108 --> 02:33:13,108
the customer advisory group work

3813
02:33:16,314 --> 02:33:18,314
plan through 20 --

3814
02:33:18,383 --> 02:33:20,783
DECEMBER 2027. On the transit

3815
02:33:22,287 --> 02:33:24,222
plan, the cag brought up

3816
02:33:24,222 --> 02:33:25,924
advancing transit equity

3817
02:33:25,924 --> 02:33:27,425
principles and exploring

3818
02:33:27,425 --> 02:33:29,825
consistency related to safety

3819
02:33:30,496 --> 02:33:32,230
and immigration enforcement

3820
02:33:32,230 --> 02:33:34,630
practices. They looked at

3821
02:33:34,666 --> 02:33:35,734
improving accessibility,

3822
02:33:35,734 --> 02:33:37,734
including mobility management

3823
02:33:39,272 --> 02:33:40,706
and one-seat paratransit

3824
02:33:40,706 --> 02:33:43,106
options. And expressed an

3825
02:33:43,141 --> 02:33:45,541
interest in future network

3826
02:33:45,877 --> 02:33:47,877
planning efforts, including

3827
02:33:47,880 --> 02:33:50,280
mascots and expanded fare

3828
02:33:50,983 --> 02:33:53,383
integration options, similar to

3829
02:33:54,419 --> 02:33:57,419
bay pass. On the customer

3830
02:33:57,956 --> 02:33:59,758
advisory work plan, members

3831
02:33:59,758 --> 02:34:00,660
generally supported the plan and

3832
02:34:00,660 --> 02:34:01,661
recommended stronger

3833
02:34:01,661 --> 02:34:04,610
communication and feedback loops

3834
02:34:06,631 --> 02:34:09,134
between the cag and the rnm

3835
02:34:09,134 --> 02:34:10,969
council. And earlier customer

3836
02:34:10,969 --> 02:34:13,672
advisory group review of items

3837
02:34:13,672 --> 02:34:16,441
before they advance to rnm

3838
02:34:16,441 --> 02:34:18,441
decision-making bodies. More

3839
02:34:20,579 --> 02:34:22,579
customer focused communication,

3840
02:34:24,850 --> 02:34:26,218
and a periodic review of rnm

3841
02:34:26,218 --> 02:34:28,530
performance measures. Greater

3842
02:34:28,530 --> 02:34:30,453
attention to underbanked and

3843
02:34:31,456 --> 02:34:33,456
unbanked populations, and

3844
02:34:34,926 --> 02:34:36,662
consideration of international

3845
02:34:36,662 --> 02:34:38,431
best practices to improve

3846
02:34:38,431 --> 02:34:40,198
regional coordination. Most

3847
02:34:40,198 --> 02:34:42,198
important take-away's, continued

3848
02:34:42,534 --> 02:34:44,302
emphasis on equity,

3849
02:34:44,302 --> 02:34:46,302
accessibility, and paratransit,

3850
02:34:46,872 --> 02:34:48,373
and interest in regional fare

3851
02:34:48,373 --> 02:34:50,543
integration, and desire for

3852
02:34:50,543 --> 02:34:51,143
stronger customer engagement and

3853
02:34:51,143 --> 02:34:53,143
communication.

3854
02:34:54,450 --> 02:34:56,982
The body also approved the work

3855
02:34:56,982 --> 02:34:57,550
plan through 2027.

3856
02:34:57,550 --> 02:34:58,183
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3857
02:34:58,183 --> 02:34:59,518
thank you for that. Appreciate

3858
02:34:59,518 --> 02:35:00,451
it.

3859
02:35:00,451 --> 02:35:01,921
Are there any other council

3860
02:35:01,921 --> 02:35:05,521
members who would like to add

3861
02:35:06,757 --> 02:35:08,757
new business?

3862
02:35:13,465 --> 02:35:15,200
Member sbranti?

3863
02:35:15,200 --> 02:35:17,200
>>speaker: good afternoon.

3864
02:35:20,539 --> 02:35:23,442
It's past the 12:00 hour. This

3865
02:35:23,442 --> 02:35:25,411
relates to our purview maybe

3866
02:35:25,411 --> 02:35:26,912
just getting information and

3867
02:35:26,912 --> 02:35:28,912
offering feedback. But

3868
02:35:31,516 --> 02:35:33,585
reference the at the outset that

3869
02:35:33,585 --> 02:35:34,686
bahfa and obviously critical

3870
02:35:34,686 --> 02:35:37,860
importance that everything that

3871
02:35:38,123 --> 02:35:41,723
we do as it relates to

3872
02:35:42,227 --> 02:35:43,762
everything we do regional

3873
02:35:43,762 --> 02:35:45,762
housing and transportation

3874
02:35:46,932 --> 02:35:51,132
intrar play, and it might be a

3875
02:35:52,103 --> 02:35:53,238
bit premature, I know those

3876
02:35:53,238 --> 02:35:55,638
conversations reniche at this

3877
02:35:55,975 --> 02:35:57,242
timing if possible at some point

3878
02:35:57,242 --> 02:35:59,979
later this fall early next year

3879
02:35:59,979 --> 02:36:01,580
would be good if we can get

3880
02:36:01,580 --> 02:36:02,781
update about where things are

3881
02:36:02,781 --> 02:36:03,983
what's being considered and have

3882
02:36:03,983 --> 02:36:06,251
opportunity to offer some

3883
02:36:06,251 --> 02:36:08,651
feedback or input because

3884
02:36:10,822 --> 02:36:12,457
ultimately to get that adopts

3885
02:36:12,457 --> 02:36:13,425
you're going to need broad

3886
02:36:13,425 --> 02:36:15,825
community engagement support and

3887
02:36:16,128 --> 02:36:18,290
I think being able to

3888
02:36:18,290 --> 02:36:20,265
participate and enage at least

3889
02:36:20,265 --> 02:36:23,535
as part of the process to relay

3890
02:36:23,535 --> 02:36:24,369
maybe it's done through our

3891
02:36:24,369 --> 02:36:25,705
council member sounds like he's

3892
02:36:25,705 --> 02:36:27,707
a representative on that

3893
02:36:27,707 --> 02:36:28,274
committee. But just food for

3894
02:36:28,274 --> 02:36:28,875
thought.

3895
02:36:28,875 --> 02:36:29,508
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3896
02:36:29,508 --> 02:36:31,144
thank you. Any other council

3897
02:36:31,144 --> 02:36:33,145
members with new business to

3898
02:36:33,145 --> 02:36:34,479
add? Will the clerk please

3899
02:36:34,479 --> 02:36:35,982
inform us of public comments

3900
02:36:35,982 --> 02:36:37,215
submitted for this item whether

3901
02:36:37,215 --> 02:36:39,452
there are members of the public

3902
02:36:39,452 --> 02:36:39,718
who wish to provide public

3903
02:36:39,718 --> 02:36:40,418
comment.

3904
02:36:40,418 --> 02:36:41,219
>>clerk, jessica lewis: we

3905
02:36:41,219 --> 02:36:42,320
received no written public

3906
02:36:42,320 --> 02:36:44,190
comments for this item there are

3907
02:36:44,190 --> 02:36:45,757
no speakers at the podium and no

3908
02:36:45,757 --> 02:36:47,259
raised hands in the zoom space

3909
02:36:47,259 --> 02:36:47,559
requesting to provide public

3910
02:36:47,559 --> 02:36:48,126
comment.

3911
02:36:48,126 --> 02:36:49,662
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

3912
02:36:49,662 --> 02:36:51,130
thank you. We'll move to agenda

3913
02:36:51,130 --> 02:36:52,831
item eight which is public

3914
02:36:52,831 --> 02:36:54,320
comment. This is an information

3915
02:36:54,320 --> 02:36:57,320
item. Will the clerk please

3916
02:36:57,903 --> 02:37:00,273
inform us if anyone from the

3917
02:37:00,273 --> 02:37:03,809
public would like to submit --

3918
02:37:03,809 --> 02:37:06,545
has submitted a comment or

3919
02:37:06,545 --> 02:37:07,813
whether there are any members of

3920
02:37:07,813 --> 02:37:09,470
the public who wish to give

3921
02:37:09,470 --> 02:37:09,648
public comment?

3922
02:37:09,648 --> 02:37:11,349
>>clerk, jessica lewis: we

3923
02:37:11,349 --> 02:37:12,552
received no written public

3924
02:37:12,552 --> 02:37:14,419
comments. No raised hands in

3925
02:37:14,419 --> 02:37:17,122
the zoom space. We do two

3926
02:37:17,122 --> 02:37:20,122
speaks wishing to approach the

3927
02:37:21,590 --> 02:37:22,294
podium. Jane kraemer. You can

3928
02:37:22,294 --> 02:37:23,562
go first.

3929
02:37:23,562 --> 02:37:24,830
Chair, how many minutes would

3930
02:37:24,830 --> 02:37:25,498
you like to give?

3931
02:37:25,498 --> 02:37:25,764
>>chair, carina vinh lieu: two

3932
02:37:25,764 --> 02:37:26,398
minutes.

3933
02:37:26,398 --> 02:37:28,798
>>clerk, jessica lewis: thank

3934
02:37:38,275 --> 02:37:39,779
you.

3935
02:37:39,779 --> 02:37:42,280
>>jane kramer: I'm not quite

3936
02:37:42,280 --> 02:37:45,917
sure how I want to say this, but

3937
02:37:45,917 --> 02:37:50,717
here it goes. I think I heard a

3938
02:37:51,230 --> 02:37:54,230
lot of people today saying

3939
02:37:55,661 --> 02:37:58,610
communication between and among

3940
02:37:59,331 --> 02:38:02,331
administration and the public is

3941
02:38:05,303 --> 02:38:08,372
a matter of time and energy and

3942
02:38:08,372 --> 02:38:09,975
attendance in membership. And

3943
02:38:09,975 --> 02:38:12,375
that's saying a mouthful.

3944
02:38:13,440 --> 02:38:16,314
Because there is a lot of

3945
02:38:16,314 --> 02:38:18,314
cultural

3946
02:38:19,384 --> 02:38:21,353
cultural, social unstated

3947
02:38:21,353 --> 02:38:24,353
thoughts behind the words that

3948
02:38:28,693 --> 02:38:30,693
are said.

3949
02:38:30,729 --> 02:38:33,129
Everybody has their own

3950
02:38:33,698 --> 02:38:36,980
assumptions and their own

3951
02:38:39,639 --> 02:38:42,639
outlook on a particular issue.

3952
02:38:44,709 --> 02:38:47,709
Something gets lost when it's

3953
02:38:48,279 --> 02:38:49,681
put on the internet, and about,

3954
02:38:49,681 --> 02:38:52,810
maybe, 90% of the communication

3955
02:38:52,751 --> 02:38:55,620
gets lost. That's a barrier.

3956
02:38:55,620 --> 02:38:57,924
And you have to come -- you have

3957
02:38:57,924 --> 02:38:58,924
to overcome it. Because not

3958
02:38:58,924 --> 02:39:01,924
everybody can attend a meeting

3959
02:39:06,898 --> 02:39:09,801
at a given time on a given day.

3960
02:39:09,801 --> 02:39:12,972
I think one person really was

3961
02:39:12,972 --> 02:39:16,572
outstanding to me when she said

3962
02:39:17,430 --> 02:39:19,443
the issue of effective

3963
02:39:20,112 --> 02:39:22,512
communication is you find

3964
02:39:24,116 --> 02:39:26,219
someone who is a pipeline, back

3965
02:39:26,219 --> 02:39:29,354
and forth. And when you find

3966
02:39:29,354 --> 02:39:32,954
that person, make sure that you

3967
02:39:34,590 --> 02:39:36,459
don't unintentionally coopt that

3968
02:39:38,497 --> 02:39:42,970
person. I'm going to leave it

3969
02:39:48,340 --> 02:39:49,774
there. I have to think it's

3970
02:39:49,774 --> 02:39:50,408
where I'm coming from.

3971
02:39:50,408 --> 02:39:51,977
>>clerk, jessica lewis: thank

3972
02:39:51,977 --> 02:39:54,977
you. Aleta dupree. Can you

3973
02:39:56,148 --> 02:39:56,415
approach the podium you have two

3974
02:39:56,415 --> 02:39:58,490
minutes.

3975
02:39:58,490 --> 02:40:01,490
>>speaker: thank you chair for

3976
02:40:05,290 --> 02:40:09,490
the record she and her with team

3977
02:40:10,996 --> 02:40:13,996
folds. Good meeting today. A

3978
02:40:17,936 --> 02:40:20,205
lot of it's abstract. It's very

3979
02:40:20,205 --> 02:40:22,605
important. I'm used to

3980
02:40:43,762 --> 02:40:47,362
operating but this comes. I can

3981
02:40:48,700 --> 02:40:49,701
only share things. But I want

3982
02:40:49,701 --> 02:40:52,701
public transportation to be here

3983
02:40:52,804 --> 02:40:54,272
for me. I want this community

3984
02:40:54,272 --> 02:40:57,709
to be affordable. So I can

3985
02:40:57,709 --> 02:40:59,811
enjoy it when I come here. I

3986
02:40:59,811 --> 02:41:01,646
want our community to be

3987
02:41:01,646 --> 02:41:03,748
accessible. I'm a person with a

3988
02:41:03,748 --> 02:41:06,748
disability. I have a house

3989
02:41:06,885 --> 02:41:09,285
might who has disabilities.

3990
02:41:10,880 --> 02:41:11,490
And I want to be able to use

3991
02:41:11,490 --> 02:41:14,192
elevators and escalators and all

3992
02:41:14,192 --> 02:41:16,695
the other kinds of tools in our

3993
02:41:16,695 --> 02:41:19,264
toolbox. And I would like to

3994
02:41:19,264 --> 02:41:22,367
see us move to a fully clipper

3995
02:41:22,367 --> 02:41:25,904
based system. And we can do

3996
02:41:25,904 --> 02:41:26,738
that and it won't exclude

3997
02:41:26,738 --> 02:41:27,506
cashless. Because find change

3998
02:41:27,506 --> 02:41:30,343
on the ground sometimes and I

3999
02:41:30,343 --> 02:41:32,780
want a vending machine to put it

4000
02:41:32,780 --> 02:41:34,247
in. In new york they're going

4001
02:41:34,247 --> 02:41:36,148
to an all omni based system. I

4002
02:41:36,148 --> 02:41:37,749
have 56 years of using the new

4003
02:41:37,749 --> 02:41:39,918
york city subway, and I hope to

4004
02:41:39,918 --> 02:41:41,520
see that famous transportation

4005
02:41:41,520 --> 02:41:45,720
system soon. And but for now, I

4006
02:41:46,424 --> 02:41:49,261
am here, and we have our subway

4007
02:41:49,261 --> 02:41:51,630
with small s nearby. But

4008
02:41:51,630 --> 02:41:54,666
anyway, I leave you with this.

4009
02:41:54,666 --> 02:41:56,536
You can never have enough grand

4010
02:41:56,536 --> 02:41:57,102
central terminal. Thank you.

4011
02:41:57,102 --> 02:41:59,502
>>chair, carina vinh lieu:

4012
02:42:02,674 --> 02:42:04,342
thank you. And since that was

4013
02:42:04,342 --> 02:42:06,945
our last speaker, we get to move

4014
02:42:06,945 --> 02:42:09,582
to agenda item nine, which is

4015
02:42:09,582 --> 02:42:11,550
adjournment. Our next meeting

4016
02:42:11,550 --> 02:42:13,218
of the regular mtc abag

4017
02:42:13,218 --> 02:42:15,487
community advisory council will

4018
02:42:15,487 --> 02:42:17,880
be held on OCTOBER 2nd. This

4019
02:42:17,880 --> 02:42:18,356
meeting of the mtc abag

4020
02:42:18,356 --> 02:42:20,756
community advisory council is

4021
02:42:22,861 --> 02:42:23,162
adjourned. Thank you everyone.

4022
02:42:23,162 --> 02:42:25,162
[Adjourned]