[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:00] We're meeting to order six o'clock. Tonight, we will be ending the meeting at nine regardless of where we are in the agenda. [0:10] Tomorrow's first day of school. [0:13] And I would like to get some sleep before I'm expected to work. [0:21] You don't see any public ears, but is there any public online that would like to make a public comment at this time? [0:38] Seeing none, I moved down into an action item to approve the agenda and I get emotionally free. [0:44] So moved Meredith first. [0:46] Any discussion? [0:48] Yeah, of course. [0:51] I think it is tax about the work, man, is that something that we are proving tonight, or is that going to be discussed in a proved attempt? [1:02] I was quite clear from the agenda. [1:05] Hold on one second. [1:06] I mean, locate what you're talking about. [1:07] I think it was approved in the spring. [1:09] I'm sorry. [1:09] Thank you. [1:10] It was approved in the spring. [1:11] We're a view work plan in additional agenda items for September. [1:14] Is that what you're referencing? [1:15] we have this. I'm just here, it wasn't clear to me whether we were discussing and approving [1:21] tonight or in September. So when Patrick Meredith and I meet to build the agenda, if there's an [1:29] item that you know of that you'd like to have on the agenda, that's an addition or along with a work plan, [1:38] that would be when you'd say, hey, it can be sure that's there. Yeah, so I had some thoughts on the work plan [1:43] some stuff that I think, you know, we've talked about that we want to get fit in there, [1:49] suffer. When we get there, let's put it back. Yeah, yeah. The other question I had about the [1:55] agenda, and it's not necessarily for tonight, but you know, your chair notes were quite pointed, [2:03] and I respect that. I'm wondering if we're going to have a chance to have a discussion about that. [2:10] I think it, [2:14] you know, there's some questions, assumptions in there that, you know, I think [2:17] would be good to talk about if we'd want to get back on track here, and obviously we've [2:23] got a full agenda tonight, but I wanted to make sure that at some point we had that discussion. [2:28] I think it raises some pretty fundamental questions that I think we haven't been able to answer. [2:34] And so the assumptions that you know might be good to talk through, because I think some of those things have been part of the dynamic that have been frustrating for a lot of people. [2:52] So my question is not necessarily tonight, but can we have a discussion of the issues that you raised in your fair notes at some point? [3:01] Sure, I'm okay with that. [3:07] Yes. [3:11] Are you all connected to MEUSB guest? [3:15] Excuse me. Excuse me. Excuse me. [3:19] Thank you. [3:21] All right. Any other discussion about the agenda? [3:26] It's been a long time. [3:28] It's happy it's not going to be board-highly. [3:30] I was going to start going to do it, but I don't have the document to fill in. [3:33] It says general code sent to you, so I was trying to be helpful, and I don't think I help. [3:37] Sorry, please. [3:39] Let's see if I can put permissions to share that meeting. [3:43] All those in favour of approving the agenda please stay on. [3:48] Any opposed? [3:50] I have a question. [3:51] Okay. [3:52] Next is the consent agenda. [3:54] I get a motion to move. [3:56] So. [3:58] Second. [3:58] Second. [3:59] Discussion, please? [4:01] Yes. [4:01] So in A, it talks about the minutes or August 17th, I think we didn't see those. [4:13] Under separate cover. [4:14] They were sent. [4:16] I think. [4:17] They were sent in? [4:18] I don't. [4:20] We call this evening. [4:22] I actually know you're right. [4:24] I don't know either. [4:25] Apologies. [4:25] Jennifer's in smaller minutes. [4:27] Yeah. [4:27] I'm not being critical. [4:29] I know I don't know. [4:30] I just don't know how I can approve. [4:31] you know, at the minutes that I haven't seen. [4:39] And with respect to the June minutes, [4:47] there was some discussion during the June meeting [4:50] about the CSUN appointment and some members of the board had expressed an interest in having [5:00] board liaison to CISA board. We didn't vote on that, but members said indicated that they [5:13] would have been appreciated at the time, which deserved that role. And then after, you know, [5:19] that happened, it was pretty clear that that role was not welcome. And so, [5:28] I don't know what to say, [5:29] That kind of isn't cat and again, it wasn't voted on but I was taking it as an expression of, you know, [5:37] Jesus certainly should do something here and that's not what I did in the minutes. [5:43] Yeah. [5:46] And, no, I think we just need to think to the minutes. [5:50] You know, absolutely. [5:52] No, I don't. [5:53] Just as a reminder, I capture some parts of the other questions and certainly all boats and points with [6:03] It was just a little awkward, you know, for me, because I thought I was supposed to do something, clearly I wasn't welcome, and so I had to back out of that, so I probably didn't. [6:19] What would you like as a remedy to what you're talking about? [6:30] I guess some reflection that the board had expressed an interest in having a board liaison [6:35] to this season board, and but that it was not put to vote. [6:41] I think that's that captures pretty accurately our discussion that we discussed. [6:47] We can only really appoint one person, but we said it would be helpful to have additional participation [6:54] in there for public comment, like we talked about holding one person would be an official [7:01] member of the board, but that, I mean, the more input to the better rate, that's. [7:07] Yeah, that there was sort of a long blind John, I mean public comment anyone can public, you [7:13] know, participate, public comment, my impression is that the board wanted some greater [7:20] level of participation, even if we're sort of voting participation, and obviously that was not [7:25] welcome. I think not welcome is your interpretation, which [7:30] You are absolutely allowed to have, but I just want to make sure that we're not putting words in other [7:35] people else. Well, then I'm just saying that, as I, how I, how I, uh, interpret it, uh, [7:45] uh, being new. That's a very interpretation. Part of the challenge, I think, is the, and the [7:50] U.S.D. gets one rapid to this, he's a board. This board can't decide. It's going to send a second [7:55] person representing this board voting or not, nothing prevents [8:01] some of them attending an open meeting in commenting or in public comment [8:04] and taking notes and bringing information back and all those things, [8:07] but we don't get to have a second person at the C-Cetable. [8:11] So the discussion, I mean, you weren't able to participate in that meeting, [8:16] but the discussion wasn't about having a second representative. [8:20] The discussion was about having a board relay, the A-zone that would able [8:24] to participate in this discussion, to have a better [8:30] means of communication that understanding how important it is [8:34] that we, you know, utilize the greatest gossip, and this is [8:38] okay. [8:40] Yeah, I guess I think they think in response to what you're [8:43] talking about, we came to this place where we're going to write [8:48] a board charge, right, which will give direction to Patrick [8:52] for the CSAT and also get directed to over the board. So, and I did reach out to try to understand [9:01] what the CSAT board was built on because it's important that if we're saying the board wants [9:07] the liaison not to be, I don't have the power to change other building things. So, it's not about [9:15] being unwelcome. It's about how they built it and what we're allowed to say or not say we're doing. [9:20] So there's no unwell and that has to be for any change in there [9:26] I'll drop the woman you know, you know, never mind [9:30] It's I think it's communicating your feelings or it's good for us to be able to talk about that [9:36] I appreciate your perspective. [9:40] Are there any other [9:42] Discussion items on the consent agenda? [9:50] That's about it. It's probably a month. Right. That's we don't have the x-clawing and stuff. Yep [9:58] So what made the motion? [10:00] Well, let's not think I did on it. [10:02] Now, we make up from the amendment to approve the consent [10:07] and if you under without the minutes from eight, seven. [10:11] Yes. [10:12] I believe my second and fifth, so I can [10:20] make them perfect. [10:21] All those in favor of approving the consent and gender, [10:24] please say aye. [10:27] Any opposed? [10:30] Any abstentions? [10:32] OK. [10:32] Then we'll go on then to the executive limitations [10:35] monitoring. [10:35] nine minutes I had a schedule. [10:40] This is just an update, so it doesn't require a motion. [10:46] And he thought about the financial report. [10:51] Anything for you would call out specifically? [10:55] Well, we're at the end of the year, we're looking at almost $400,000. It's a fun [11:01] to work with. Our process starts next week. So those numbers will start to firm up and then [11:10] get the order, the order, plus the order. We're fairly bumping in this summer and I think here [11:18] reflects not a lot of work done, I hope, of course, the year as a district. [11:26] We certainly boosted [11:29] revenue a little bit, partially because of our ability to better apply and receive funds under the [11:43] extraordinary expenses under the special education reimbursement structure. That might have [11:50] and so here's to that whether the net on all of their solid reports. [11:59] Good. [12:00] It's not that. [12:02] Thank you. [12:06] And move down onto the board management and governance section. [12:09] The first is an action item to a point of proxy to vote at the visbit annual engineering. [12:15] I get a motion. [12:18] This one always feels back for instance. [12:19] We will talk about it before we have points. [12:21] I'm going to give some time to have the next chart. [12:24] So we participate in visbit of remote school boards and insurance trusts. [12:28] They provide insurance for multiple districts around the state. [12:31] We participate in the multi-line insurance and also the unemployment insurance. [12:38] So we actually get two votes at the annual meeting for visbit. [12:43] And basically this morning's to decide, does it either want to appoint a board member to [12:47] It was a great day present and cast those two votes for us, or do we want to assign the [12:53] visbit board, which is made up of a couple of superintendents, I think maybe some board members [12:59] from around the state. We can assign those two votes to that board as proxy, and their vote [13:05] would carry our weight for those two. And that happens, I think the day is October 30th. [13:12] Yes, it will be in Burlington, both in South Burlington. Where would the April conference as being held? [13:21] Well, any votes make any form of difference? [13:25] I looked at the agenda. The only real action I am on the agenda are to appoint two members to fill bacon seats. [13:33] And it's possible that those same members are running. It didn't actually see a list in there of candidates. [13:38] I think that might be something that's coming out later. [13:40] That's a very priority to it. [13:45] When does the rate setting happen? [13:46] It wouldn't happen to me. [13:48] But this is the end of the day. [13:50] Right. [13:51] Liability kind of things, right? [13:53] The VA is sort of an underlying fit. [13:58] I typically go to these meetings [14:03] and have been the prophecy before. [14:08] Last year's meeting with the minutes was like 12 minutes long or something. [14:13] I've never really thought. [14:14] Yeah, I should. [14:16] So, you know, if you want to be there and, you know, go ahead. [14:20] Folks may or may not know that I was a insurance or a dealer or a employer. [14:26] And including, you know, doing issues around the, you know, live a living insurance, [14:32] I kind of, and dealing with the unemployment insurance, so I'm certainly happy to do that, but [14:42] Aaron, if you wish to use your prerogative, do you do that? [14:45] Go ahead. [14:45] I'll be there anyway for the rest of that day, for other meetings, so if it saves someone [14:52] in 8 a.m. trip to Berlin, then that's great. [14:56] Look, that's your favorite sex one. [14:59] It's not my choice. [15:00] It's the board stress. Oh, that's true. [15:07] So someone needs to make a motion to appoint a prophecy to vote, or either [15:12] proxy or a person from this board to vote. Hi, move that we appoint, arrange it there as the [15:18] vaccine for our board. [15:24] Sorry, second. Second. [15:29] Second. All of them, any other [15:30] discussion. [15:35] All those in favor of appointing me to the Park City to go and visit, please say aye. [15:40] Aye. Aye. Any opposed? [15:43] And we have sanctions. [15:46] Okay. And that's just an action item. [15:48] But point members who emerge or study committee. [15:53] And I don't know if we want to provide context first again. [15:55] Thank you a little bit of context here. We talked about it some other retreat. [15:58] Right now, the only thing that's very clear in the legislation is that this board needs to [16:02] point at least one board member to the Moder Study Committee. [16:05] It's unclear at this point how many reps this portal send to that Moder Study Committee [16:09] is there are a few other steps that need to settle down to even know that. [16:14] We talked about the how proportional representation will be handled in particular given some [16:18] of the extreme cases in other parts of the state, so that's still getting ironed out. [16:23] And we also talked about the fact that districts have the opportunity to change what [16:28] study region there in, which would also have an impact on proportionality. So until those two things get settled out, [16:34] we won't really know how many members, but we know it's at least one. So I think you could identify one for sure tonight, [16:41] and then we're compliant with the law, which has we have to do that by September 1, 2015. [16:47] You could think about are there others in addition to the one that are interested that might get appointed, [16:52] should we get more seats than this the one, which from my perspective, I think it's likely [16:58] there will be more than one but again it's unclear how many and even that's not necessarily for [17:04] sure and this the timeline is pretty aggressive there isn't a meeting schedule yet I don't think [17:11] I think the study committees will kind of figure that out but there's effectively so by September [17:18] of next year this murder study committee will have to produce a report with its findings [17:25] So it's a pre-type online, [17:29] there's work happening right now, we have there has been identified [17:33] as state-wide merger study kind of the facilitator lead and that person is currently working [17:39] to recruit merger study sort of regional facilitators. [17:45] It's likely that each facilitator is going to have more than one region, [17:51] but I think you [17:52] expect at the very least monthly meetings for the murder study committee, possibly more depending [17:59] on how the process unfolds and the timeline kind of comes to the reality. [18:06] The question character does the different facilities are going to be, there will be a specific [18:13] I think facilitator appointing each emergency statement, [18:18] and under the guidance of kind of head to facilitator, [18:21] kind of, is, you know, what's the dynamic there? [18:28] Is that, I understand at some point, [18:31] the facilitator is obligated to meet with the boards, [18:36] the various district boards. [18:38] Is there some, [18:42] You know, is there some opportunity to talk with the facilitator before the facilitator is locked in? [18:54] Various? [18:56] I mean, think it really makes a difference. This is a really existential question, you know, for our district. [19:01] It's going to make a huge, huge big deal for how we operate going forward, you know, just who we are. [19:09] And it really, in my experience, it really makes a difference [19:12] who that facilitator is and, you know, what sort of inclinations they have. [19:20] And so I'm just wondering, Patrick, what's the sequence there? [19:26] Do we give some opportunity to talk with who might be proposed [19:29] before they're from where you pointed at what? [19:33] I don't believe any board has authority to choose the facilitator. [19:37] I think that's a sign. [19:38] I think the opportunity to meet you mentioned that the facilitators will meet with each [19:42] boards in their region, which I think is true, but I don't think that's necessarily sort of [19:47] an interview process and generally good whether selecting or agreeing or anything like that. [19:51] It's more sort of a get to know you kind of think perhaps and maybe maybe try to get a sense of [19:56] stuff. Yeah, so I'm trying to get a sense, you know, choose, choose, I didn't [20:01] certainly intend to mean that choose, you know, that's not our role. [20:06] But I do think it's important to have some sort of conversation. [20:11] Maybe with the lead to silicate, you know, about what our dynamics are and what the attributes of the silicate of my being that would help us through this process. [20:26] So, it sounds like this is going on sort of behind the scenes, what's that process that definition? [20:32] Can we be involved in that? [20:34] So the lead facilitator was selected through a process, facilitated by the remont learning collaborative, which is the one season that currently uses remont. [20:48] So that's sort of the governing body, I guess, for this process. [20:52] So they've selected the lead facilitator to meet facilitators' charges to get the other facilitators to, [20:57] Is that something to pass through to McCormick? [20:59] No. [21:00] Is he going to McCormick involved? [21:03] I'll I know is that she's not the lead facilitator. Okay, because she did great job. [21:09] I had experience with her. She did great job. [21:13] Yeah, Meredith. [21:15] I'm so sorry for what I'm going to do to you because I didn't tell you I'm going to do this beforehand. [21:19] But in my perfect world, my dash would be our representative for the Director of Study Committee. [21:27] I know you may not actually be able to do it because you have a life and family and a day job, [21:33] but I feel like the Mergers Study Committee is kind of bring up lots of strong emotions [21:39] and lots of strong disagreement between our committees. [21:41] And I haven't seen anybody be able to walk the center of that and hold multiple viewpoints [21:47] while still adequately, you've been appropriately representing our board of like you have made. [21:54] So if you had unlimited time resources, [21:57] finance is desire to do it. [21:59] I would love for you to do it, [22:00] but I know you might not. [22:02] So that's just my choice. [22:04] Good work. [22:05] Good fun. [22:07] I think Mike's great choice. [22:08] I think we had a lot of diversity on the board, [22:11] and I think it might be helpful. [22:15] In a way, diminishing, you know, [22:17] when Meredith said about mine, [22:19] who I think is a good choice. [22:20] I think it's important to have some diversity on the board in terms of perspective. [22:30] And it's not a matter necessarily of having more than one vote. It's a matter, I think, of having representatives on the committee that are reflective of the board. [22:47] And, you know, we've been through the ringer this past year, and worried [22:59] that if we don't have a diversity of representation on the board, we'll be starting out on the wrong foot. [23:09] I share that concern to her. [23:10] Yeah, and so that's why, you know, the notion of having more than one representative is I think it's very helpful. [23:16] And we can give him to the charges well, too. [23:20] I think whoever the representative of a representative [23:24] are going to be need to have some feedback [23:27] to the court. [23:30] I'm not comfortable. [23:32] I'm comfortable. [23:32] I trust Mike, but I'm not comfortable for anyone [23:36] to have unlimited delegation of authority [23:40] to represent a board on the committee. [23:43] I would like, you know, maybe this is the next time I'm on the agenda, you know, but I'd like to see a charge that [23:50] identifies, you know, what our goals are, reporting mechanism, and some assurance that decisions won't be made by anyone. [23:59] Without the approval of the board. [24:04] So, I'm firmly happy, everybody. [24:07] I think there should be someone else as a representative also. [24:14] Hey, this is Liz, I'm sorry to jump in. [24:18] I'm coming out. [24:19] One second, Liz. [24:21] Go ahead. [24:22] Liz didn't hear you. [24:23] I said, keep going. [24:24] Oh, I sure. [24:25] I'll be happy to serve as a diverse representative. [24:30] I, you know, I enjoy working with mine. [24:33] Go ahead, Liz. [24:35] No, it's fine. I can't raise my hand and I'm on an audio only. I think I'm logged in poorly, probably, and also I can't see you guys. It's just the Z. [24:45] So I can't see like bikes reaction when we said that. I would say I appreciate that he's very data-informed. [24:54] So I've always found it really helpful that you've got the good grasp on what information we have and where to find it. [25:03] I've always found that really helpful, but then if we could get the visual, that would be great. [25:10] And if there's a way so that I could be allowed to raise my hand, that would be great too. [25:16] But that's all right, we can do it next meeting too. [25:19] Thank you. [25:19] Thank you. [25:20] Are you serious? [25:23] Are you serious? [25:25] Are you serious? [25:26] Are you serious? [25:29] When I first signed on, I couldn't, and then I signed in again, and I can. [25:34] But my other, I don't know, my duplicate went away. Great. Sorry. Try signing it again. [25:40] Thanks, Kara. [25:42] Okay. So right now, we're losing more. [25:47] I think I think someone asked if I could see the board. [25:51] I can see snippets of people, but not the whole board. [25:54] I don't know what the vantage point is for the camera. [25:57] But thank you. [25:59] Thanks, Barbara. [26:01] All right, so right now we have Mike as the first delegate and perhaps her buzz the second delegate. [26:11] Does anyone want to make a motion? [26:13] Well, I don't want to nominate Mike unless Mike is not going to single- [26:18] Well, that's when he would get to speak. [26:22] A more discussion. [26:24] What do you take actively? [26:26] Yeah, I think I can talk now or later. [26:29] We're going to be now our forever older. [26:32] Yeah. [26:32] Yeah. [26:33] Sitting here thinking about this. [26:36] Yeah. [26:36] I mean, look, I think any of us can do a good job as a member. [26:43] That is my first. [26:44] Like at the end, it's an important place to have discussion as a part of [26:48] place to be able to report back here. [26:50] And I think to her point, some important place to be able to take [26:53] perspective from the whole board. [26:55] I can't imagine delegating so much authority to this. [26:58] person either, because in the end there's a really big choice. So with that kind of perspective, [27:05] I'm perfectly happy, I think, but any of us doing that is others are unable or on well-being. [27:14] I could have my arm twisted. It would be an arduous to be honest. [27:18] Like, was I first care arduous? Well, do you all say, what am I going to do it, and I'm like, [27:22] well, so I have to do it, and then I do it. That's pretty much the way this goes. And if that's the case, [27:26] And I will happily do it, and I will put it in good faith efforts, and it will represent the board, and I will have these conversations. [27:34] But I don't feel like I have to do this. I guess that's what I'm saying. [27:38] So we have this really excited. Like that works too. But I'm billed up. [27:43] So that's about the most circular way I could tell. [27:47] And so I would like to do it this way. [27:50] And the reason I hear what you're saying, like around, you know, whoever's pointed is going [27:56] to have to be, you know, learn the board, so we'll be able to report back to the board. [28:03] I think there's more that goes into that presentation. [28:12] We have, we have some diverse viewpoints on this board. [28:15] I think it's important to be able to talk through those issues and make sure that the committee understands those perspectives. [28:30] Not that money couldn't do it, but I think the participation will be helpful. [28:36] And the communication will be helpful, which is why, you know, I think I could be useful in that we're all acting with Mike. [28:50] Does anyone so just to bring on what Mike was saying, is there anybody else that's interested? [28:57] And just another reminder, we may be required to have somewhere in the range of three to five. [29:04] I don't think that's a volunteering. [29:10] Oh, it's not shipping your head. [29:13] What I was going to suggest, [29:15] I'm not necessarily interested, [29:18] but I was wondering if it could be offered to one representative from each town [29:23] and then they could rotate or something. [29:27] Figure out a schedule so it not everybody has to go each time. [29:33] I like that I can't be engaged. I don't think that's the idea that I think you lose continuity, meaning sorry bar. [29:40] It's possible that it wouldn't be allowed. [29:42] I like the idea of a representative from each town, sorry, let me be more clear. [29:45] I don't think rotating makes sense because of a loss of continuity. [29:49] Yeah, I hear what you're saying. [29:51] I think that there would be a responsibility to make sure that the notes were read, et cetera. [29:58] But I understand where you're coming from. [30:00] It would be nice to have each town represented in my ideal world. I would love to see each kind of representative. Whether that's possible or not, I don't know. [30:13] And again, that isn't about how many votes you get. You know, maybe we only get it when vote. [30:20] But having four or members to display each reflecting, you know, what they know about that community, I think would be, you know, I feel. [30:31] That was going to be my question of doing, you know, if each representative will get a vote. [30:37] That's part of the lack of clarity around proportionality because you can achieve proportionality with each district represented by one person and that one person's vote carries different weight based on the size of their district. [30:49] It will be based on long term way, weighted average [30:52] daily membership. [30:53] That's sort of weighted pupil count figure. [30:55] That's what will determine sort of the weight [30:57] that a district gets in that mega study committee. [31:00] One other somewhat limiting factor is it's clear [31:04] that a lot that has to be a current board member. [31:07] So if somebody's turned us up in March, [31:08] that's going to be before this work is done. [31:11] If they're not reelected, they can't continue on the committee [31:15] and then someone else will need to be appointed. [31:17] and then we have the continuity of things. [31:19] So ideally, I don't think it's a deal breaker, [31:21] but ideally, it'll be someone who doesn't have a term [31:24] ending in March, and that uncertain day becomes with that. [31:29] You know, I think I would add that the issue of how many votes [31:32] the district gets is a separate one. [31:35] I think how many representatives we send to this page [31:38] because you could have, for example, [31:41] you know, a member for me, Cham, [31:44] and somehow the rules turn out you only get one vote, [31:46] Well, you cast one vote, and hopefully I would think that that vote would be reflective [31:55] of what the board has already proved, so it's not really an issue. [32:00] And important to remember, too, that the, the, the, the, the emergency study committee has a lot of [32:07] important work to do and at least the way it has worked historically under the, the statute [32:13] just slightly modified by the new piece of legislation, but that, that, that, that [32:19] merges that a committee makes recommendations boards then are have the authority to warn [32:26] above the electorate on that issue. So it's going to have to funnel back through boards to get [32:31] before voters. So yeah, we really have an opportunity here to ensure that we have a direct connection [32:41] between what the work of the Merge static committee is, and decision swing may, in what we [32:47] as a board, I really want to do. And I think that's a little different from how Merge of [32:52] static committees have been asked and I think it's a welcome change. So if we don't know how many [32:59] people were required to appoint right now, does it make the most sense to take the person who [33:04] already said like clearly wants to and then if time comes and we need three to five that we say we're [33:12] going to delegate one for each time. This is a public forum and I please not take this the wrong way [33:20] because I respect the heck out of you. I just I know how deep your values are and how deep you hold [33:31] the values around a small school in every town and how deep you feel about the articles of agreement [33:37] looking a certain way and I worry that we're going to appoint you, her, to this merger study committee, [33:45] that we'd be putting you in an impossible position where you may have to represent [33:50] or what the board has said and it might not be reflective of your own personal values and I personally [33:59] would feel comfortable with you sitting in that role, just because I know it's important [34:04] your balance on to you. So let me say something about that. It, you know, I don't want to be [34:11] with the fact that my career was spent as a lawyer. Exactly. And I'm perfectly comfortable [34:22] representing Brian, and if I was a representative on the board, the client not go to the [34:31] corner, but in a sense the client would be the board, and I would not just as an attorney [34:38] does some do things without the provision of the client. I wouldn't think of making a decision [34:48] or representing anything that was not okay with the corner, or the board. [34:57] So I'm comfortable. [35:03] I mean, I do like the idea of a couple of people, you know, for maybe that reason. [35:11] So I put that out there, that I'm comfortable with it. I think it is an experience to me. I can't [35:18] I'm pretty familiar with the murder static committee process and for me familiarity with the [35:23] policy issues. I'm a familiar, I think when we get into that charge, I think we need to work [35:30] pretty hard on what are the goals to the board. And what sort of process we would put in place to make [35:39] sure that whatever the representative is going to be, that they not only will be put back, but get [35:47] give the concurrence approval of the board before they make some critical decisions. [35:53] So, in a sense. [35:53] You're clear, but not easy to tell. [35:55] So, in a sense, Meredith, yeah, you may think you're involved in crazy guy, but [36:02] not well ultimately, the way I'm envisioning this working is that it's the board that's ultimately going to be a control of how we're going to be represented on the board. [36:18] And we do that by reporting by signaling to the board. [36:25] Hey, you know, we're going to be talking about articles of agreement in the next few weeks. [36:31] Here are the issues, here are the issues. [36:33] You know, it's worth northwest, for Genesis thinking about, it's worth. [36:37] A little bit of thinking about, Amy, you have their own. [36:40] It is a credit kind of things that they want to achieve in terms of that. [36:45] And, you know, what do you want to do for it in terms of that? [36:49] And, you know, there will be an issue, right? [36:52] School court, ultimately, you know, I think the board would need to give some direction [36:58] to the representative of how they want to go on that. [37:04] And I'm particularly happy and capable to represent that decision, even if it is something [37:10] that I might, you know, agree. [37:12] That's just where it is. [37:13] Thank you, Herbe, and I'm sorry that I felt that I had to say that, but you put my mind at ease. [37:19] Thank you. [37:20] All right, so we do a long one for you, we're saying Erin, and we're, say, five representatives. [37:28] That's the inside, but. [37:30] Can we appoint a meeting member to that have to be a board member? [37:34] That has to be a board member. Which is different than I was asked processes a bit. [37:41] We can do it as much as I want that timeline to be. They're going to be first sort of facilitated. [37:47] Well, I think the first meeting has to happen in October, so. [37:50] Yeah, it's very pretty quick. [37:52] October 5, October 5, I think so. [37:54] And then the culmination, the end date, is March, [38:01] the town meeting in 2008. [38:03] So you talked about a year and a half, clearly, [38:08] decision making time, I would guess, [38:11] would be, you know, nine to 12 months or so, man. [38:14] Yeah, the report do in September, [38:16] and that has a review process through AOA. [38:20] And then once the AOA has proved the report, [38:24] that I think it's in a position for boards to act to warn it. [38:31] It can I emphasize that I think there's a lot of trepidation. [38:37] You know, in some parts around the merge study committee itself. [38:42] I actually think that there's a lot of great positives that come to the details really matter. [38:50] In terms of what our communities are and making sure that they're expressed. [38:54] or at least communicating and when I lose in terms of the process, [39:00] but I think I can see you [39:04] on a positive. You know, we got two things going on. We got to see support, which is really [39:10] sort of focused on how we can capture this mesh savings in terms of shared services. [39:15] and then we have this verse dedicated which is sort of looks like it's more just [39:23] organizational but in terms of the work I think that it can touch on a lot of [39:28] things that might also improve certain learning and save some money to so I [39:47] process here and we want to know some needs to make a motion to appoint someone to the [39:52] merger study committee. Well, my question is, do we, and then we'll come to what we have a special [39:59] meeting? Well, if we learn that we get more or have to have more of them, yes, that would be it. [40:05] If it doesn't fall within already standard. Okay. The only way to avoid a special meeting like that [40:11] would be if you sort of appointed a number one number two and number three and [40:17] number four and then we sort of know if there is three. It's number one two and three [40:21] if there's four it's one through four. [40:28] Again, I'd like to do it. I think I need to do it [40:32] each time. I'd even more like to do it with mine. But however, folks want to see the [40:38] all of them that re-employed her bolstering as our number one representative and like [40:45] dash as our number two if we're granted just something for a minute. I'll find it that. [40:53] Any other discussion? [41:01] Well, those in favor of appointing her bolstering as number one and [41:05] like dash as a number two for the mergers study committee, please say that. Any opposed? Any abstinence? [41:14] Okay, then we'll move down to action item C, which is to designate a board charge for the C set and measure study and work. [41:24] And I guess we'll do the work first before we does it that. [41:30] Sure. [41:31] The process of this is throwing me off tonight because so much of it requires discussion before we take an action item on it. [41:39] So I'm just getting hung up on that. [41:46] So I have her abuse sent me something about some language. [41:51] I also got some language for a charge sent to me by Jeanine. [41:54] We met with during our retreat. [41:59] And it was language that she is used for other charges for different study committees. [42:07] So, we can share, I don't know, can you share that up on this free to repeat this? [42:11] Just maybe the structure of it. [42:14] And then we can start to think about how we want to fill it in. [42:21] Do you have it? [42:21] Yeah, just fine. [42:24] But her, well, Patrick's finding that, do you want to talk about what you sent me in? [42:30] Yeah. [42:32] So, both for the CSAT Board and for the Merchspity Committee, there's some similarities [42:39] in what I was, my thoughts were, I mean, I wanted to hear what people have to say, but [42:45] my thinking was really kind of long-analyzed before I was talking about in terms of Merchspity [42:50] committee representative, that representative is authorized by this board to represent, you [43:02] know, the season board of the committee, but it's really a board that I think is, it would [43:13] just be like, we have a finance and facilities committee, we don't, we don't tell mice for [43:19] you know, how to set a budget or, you know, what cat or expenditures to make the process that I would see would be, you point somebody, and you have them report back to the board, you know, frequently as frequently as possible, try to identify what's happened, what's might be happening, what's going to come on board, and most critically, I think, [43:48] You know, trying to figure out a way to make sure that, you know, when you have a timeline, [43:55] if you know a decision is going to come off, that's kind of critical. [43:59] To identify it and be able to talk it through as a board support mix of this decision. [44:03] It tells the representative, this is how we as a board want you to represent us at that body. [44:12] I think it's important to sort of identify goals. [44:16] For CISA, I don't think we have time for that tonight, but I think, you know, like some other meeting, I think it would be important to identify, you know, what are the kind of savings that we would like to have the representative encourage and communicate, you know, I think, [44:34] Causes, it's a big deal. [44:37] Agreed. [44:37] It's a real opportunity here. [44:39] I think we should be as expansive as we can. [44:41] Basically, we can't about that. [44:45] But those are the features of that, that, that, that, those notes that I should have. [44:53] Yeah. [44:54] I think you did a really nice job and I appreciate it. [44:56] We've been putting that together. [44:57] I think it was a great framework. [44:59] Thank you. [45:05] So this is what I received from G. And it's just sort of a bare bones, it's a structure. And so the language she has in here does not need to stay in here. We can fill it with whatever makes good sense for us. [45:20] But it walks through things like kind of exactly what her was sort of laying out, right? So what this charge protects. [45:31] So what we're saying is that protects then what kind of financial control, what that means, [45:39] what the bright lines are, so the bright lines are like the muskews, right? [45:45] Then what our representative is free to do versus what they have to bring back to the board [45:50] and then what our commitment is to the person that we put in the representatives fund. [45:59] Where is the talk about, is this the season in particular in the world? [46:03] This was the merger study one, I think. [46:07] Yes, so for this, if you're talking about the season one first anyway, [46:13] what I [46:13] kind of vision is that we identify some of the areas that we'd like to see support [46:20] to explore in terms of cost savings. [46:24] It's that kind of, I, well, that, this is more just strengthening. [46:32] You know, the administrative kind of issues, [46:34] pants, bending, you know, purchasing. [46:38] But beyond just sort of those kind of kind of dry kind of things, [46:45] you know, trying to explore the ability to expand opportunities for kids, [46:51] in terms of course work and those kinds of things. [46:53] because I think there's some real opportunities there. [47:00] I'd love to explore a more collaboration with Hanford and the high schools. [47:05] Ultimately, I'd love to see them. [47:07] This is more of maybe a murderous study committee issue, [47:10] but I'd love to see a comprehensive regional high school, [47:13] but it integrates Hanford and high schools. [47:17] I know that's not an immediate issue, [47:19] but if you want to get there, you've got to start somewhere. [47:23] And I think some of that work could be done at the C support and others other work in the end of the emergency study committee. [47:31] So I don't know how you want to handle this, Aaron. [47:37] I think there's some similarities. [47:40] Maybe mine's a little simpler. [47:43] But I don't know. [47:44] So I was thinking about, like when I think about a C son, maybe that's an important distinction to make. [47:50] And I think about the CSM, not so much thinking about savings, as I am, how do we condense services of the money stays as close to kids as possible? [48:02] And I think that's the frame I'm walking into it with, because I'm not sure how much money is actually going to be saved versus what's the reallocation. [48:14] like um so when that's just how my brain is putting it together so then when I'm thinking about [48:23] if I'm going to charge a representative to go and represent what we are as a board I think about [48:31] what our portrait of a learner has told us and what our ends are saying to us as what our priorities are [48:37] right and so from our last meeting we we had a number one priority [48:44] And if our number one priority is academic excellence, then does that live in a CSA? [48:49] I like you were saying expanding opportunities in coursework, or does it live then what our merger study is focused on? [48:56] And the CSA is more focused on how do we condense all the things to make sure that the money isn't going to [49:04] branching out too far and staying closer to kids? [49:07] I would love to dig into this document a little bit more. I think just in the interest of time, [49:13] I think we could spend a long time talking about the philosophical differences between a merger [49:20] study in a CSP, but I think we're going to end at nine, I would love to start putting stuff [49:27] down. [49:28] So what I agree, I just wanted to make sure that when we're doing that, that are very [49:33] more of sort of the same. [49:34] So that we're not just, you know, you're having, you're getting ideas of what we're talking [49:38] about when we're putting goals on paper for that turn. [49:43] And I appreciate what you say, but I'm thinking that you care notes too and the perspective there. [49:51] And I think you were making a case that in order to expand opportunities for kids. [50:00] We've got to have the resources to do that. [50:04] So that's why I was focusing on in terms of the CSR and how can we maximize our [50:09] cost savings with the ultimate goal of trying to expand our afternoon circuit and having [50:17] the resources to do that. So the eye, I wouldn't want to get into maybe the deep [50:26] I think it deserves a lot more discussion, in terms of what we do. [50:37] I think the framework of sort of, you know, where are goals? [50:42] Can I think we need to discuss that in the work? [50:46] Reporting back, and making sure that, you know, the key decisions [50:52] that represent the makes are decisions that are approved by the board. [50:56] I think those are three elements that I admire, you know, for charge of season. [51:02] Yeah, and that's fine. I guess one word we just need to be really clear about what we mean when we say [51:08] what's living in the merger study world and what's living in a CSO world. Those are totally separate things. [51:18] So looking at we've got the merger study committee representative charged right now, and I [51:24] number one, what this target protects is our ends. So I think specifically what is an italics, [51:34] all students have equitable access to high quality pre-K to 12 grade education. Yes, academic [51:40] excellence is our first priority. Yes, and for other we can say, MAUSD places an emphasis on and [51:49] lists the other things from Portrait of Alert and we want these. We don't want to lose [51:55] sight of this in our emergency committee work. Maybe we're just in. I feel like I'm talking a [52:04] lot. So I'm going to make sure that's doing. [52:10] Definitely. [52:14] I'm going to drop a lot of the two. [52:16] Yeah, I think we're the similarities. [52:18] Gosh, pictures are a practical question on the CISA side of science. [52:27] What is anything is the role of the... [52:30] Board, or the community in terms of implementing solutions within the context of the system. [52:37] So whether it was on this committee, or whether this is done in the conversation with you, [52:42] the superintendent of Ascent North West, before this committee existed, those feel like those will [52:47] be operational choices for how you're going to structure the services. And in that sense, [52:54] but really wasn't the purview of the board. [52:58] To what extent does the cease of structure shift that or [53:02] where do you and other superintendents see it really as it's a forced conversation amongst you all to figure out what administratively you can do as opposed to [53:12] something that's fundamentally shifting the way education is delivered or something else that feels more centered on the board. [53:20] So yeah, it, again, it's early, but I, my perception of it is it's more operational. [53:29] Like, how do we, how do we operationalize editing students, and really, that may be a piece of it. [53:38] But it's also how do we operationalize running businesses, [53:43] collectively, because there's a business side to education. [53:47] And how do you create those efficiencies? [53:50] So it feels more to me working with the superintendent [53:53] as our request to figure out how to create a food service [53:56] qualitative to create efficiencies [53:58] and deliver high quality at a lower cost. [54:01] It feels very much more like that on a bigger scale. [54:05] And I think that was widely recognized. [54:08] I mean, I don't know the composition of every single CSA, [54:11] but I think the lion share of CSA members [54:14] are superintendents. [54:15] because they have the operational knowledge [54:17] of those organizations to look for where is their opportunity [54:20] and how do we actually get this done? [54:24] Yeah, so for me, the reason I ask that is [54:27] that it sets up sort of two, at least in my mind, [54:30] kind of distinct charges in terms of what we set up for a virtual [54:34] committee versus what we set up for a CISA. [54:36] In some level, like, it almost feels like the CISA, [54:40] we might want to set up something [54:41] equivalent to executive limitations, right? And maybe, since the suggestions of, these are [54:47] some things that you might want to consider, right? These are things you, you know, really [54:52] shouldn't do the war that you would need to check in what the board does, those feel like you're [54:55] no longer just in the history of. Like if we can set that up for the CSO on that would then allow [54:59] Patrick and the other superintendents to have really conversations about operations and hopefully [55:06] we need that to a way that they all collectively felt they could implement. I get with some guys [55:10] of supplies, but the merchant community feels somewhat different in that sense. [55:15] But from that, because those are really like existential questions about how you [55:18] deliver education and that's sort of satisfying that as opposed to the nuts and bolts. [55:26] There are many nuts and bolts components, I think to the murder study work, like as I was [55:30] thinking about, I was appreciating the reflection on portrait of a learner and ends and [55:34] the focus on spoon outcomes and opportunities, because that ought to be the lens that we [55:39] like everything that we do, and that's reinforced every time we have conversations about [55:44] ends in a portion of a learner and that work. [55:49] And I think it's important to bear in mind as well that some of the nuts and bolts can [55:54] impact that. [55:55] As I think about merger, I think about X73 that speaks to Pass size law, you have to have [56:01] a class size minimum. [56:03] We can save all the dollars in the world through the CISA, and we can kind of do whatever [56:07] we end up doing with merger or not merger, [56:09] but if we don't put more high school students [56:11] under the same roof, we will not meet class size law [56:14] and we'll have to cut programs to be compliant with that law. [56:18] So there are some nuts and bolts, things like that [56:21] that have a direct impact on what we can provide [56:24] for opportunities and generate outcomes for students. [56:27] So, shall you be thinking that in the murderous study? [56:29] This is about it. [56:31] That's, I don't, I think that's murderous study. [56:33] See, so I don't think is gonna have an opportunity [56:35] to figure out a effectively murdered high schools, that's outside the purview of season. [56:41] Maybe some of the course things, but just as we've been trying to make that happen. [56:45] Well, that's just where it was getting to. [56:50] It's an issue that's forgotten about, you know, [56:53] you got, for example, in, you know, some kind of, you got three high schools and a tax [56:59] right? And they're all relatively small, little ways a little bit. So I think the issue there [57:10] is, you know, even if you maintain those four, you know, secondary facilities, you know, [57:20] what can you share? What can you share to try to expand some opportunities there as well as [57:28] maybe meet those minimum classes. [57:30] You know, if you have some sort of sharing, [57:34] where you're able to bring your enrollment [57:36] in a French or whatever class up there, [57:41] you meet minimum classes, [57:42] and you expand your opportunities at the same time. [57:47] Which, so those are the things that I'm thinking about [57:52] with CSA that might be really helpful [57:53] both to be described as the same opportunities and I would hope that what I just don't want. [58:05] I like to see, like you say, like hash goals, you know, say some policy, right, about what [58:13] our vision is, where our goals are for the season and then maybe some limitations, I'm not prepared [58:21] to say, I don't think we have time to get through that whole thing this evening, but I'd [58:27] like to see us as forward looking at some canby around what the goals are, so that we can [58:34] say it as much as it can and expand the opportunities because we're a savings of money. [58:40] What I fear is that, you know, long hanging fruit, right, you know, let's do just what seems, [58:51] that we could do it. [58:54] I hate the set of the barred too low in terms of what we're doing. [58:58] We should have that discussion. [59:00] And I think that should be in the kind of ends in the chart. [59:04] And I think this is a board, but that's maybe for another day. [59:12] What do you want to do about this? [59:14] More questions. [59:25] Talk on that. [59:30] So if you want to get out this day, I can put a motion on the table. [59:37] It's got a gap in there because it's going to have sort of ends for limitations that Mike was talking about. [59:43] But I think those three elements are something that I'm comfortable with. [59:47] And maybe at a later meeting, we could fill out what we think the goals are, um, that, that, that we're, the board wants to achieve. [59:58] I don't think that. [1:00:00] Discussion is so much around what the content of it is. First is what are the actual things in them. So this structure is just a suggestion of structure. So we can change it to fit what you're saying. This is not, this is just a suggestion structure. [1:00:16] So I'm not so much married to this structure. What I am wondering about is how long is it going to take us to figure out the difference between a ceasea and what we want to say there. [1:00:27] and the mergers study work and what we want to say there. [1:00:29] And then underneath those two things, [1:00:31] how long it's going to take us to then decide [1:00:33] what the goals for each one are. [1:00:35] Because we're sort of on a tight time line [1:00:37] to give any sort of board charge if we're going to do that. [1:00:42] If we're not prepared to do it tonight, [1:00:44] I just say someone table it [1:00:46] and we'll do it again another night. [1:00:48] But I don't want to, [1:00:50] I wonder if it would be helpful [1:00:54] to send something out [1:00:57] that delineates what the two things are so that when we come back to house this discussion then [1:01:03] where people are operating under the same like what are two things and then we'd be able to [1:01:10] I don't know any other way to. Yeah so what I was proposing I think is this impact or with that [1:01:16] Aaron because what I was talking about was process as opposed to delineating you know which [1:01:23] which pocket we're talking about, so, you know, in both areas where we're starting to [1:01:32] commit and in the C support, you know, I was thinking of making sure that this recording [1:01:40] mechanism, you know, what's happened, what's going to happen, making sure that the board [1:01:45] approves give direction, you know, about key issues, what's coming out. [1:01:52] I understand those ghosts. I think we could adopt those. That's that framework. And then, like you say, [1:02:00] lead for maybe another discussion. [1:02:04] What the vision is, what the goal is to use for each, each, [1:02:08] each objective, each, each board equipment. [1:02:13] Yeah, Meredith. [1:02:14] So, [1:02:19] something that Jamie said at our retreat really struck me, I know representation wasn't perfect, [1:02:28] but when she said like, clear and good enough is better than perfect wording, like, something [1:02:41] that I've been feeling is frustration with peace. And I don't know if that's just me. I don't [1:02:48] know if everybody else is okay with us having to push things and push things and push things. [1:02:55] But I feel like this is something that we can do right now. That's good enough. Maybe we table [1:03:02] this piece. Maybe we just talk about the merger study committee. Like we just talk about some bullet [1:03:08] and get some things down there, like I'm looking around the room and it looks like everybody feels how I feel, which is tired, hot, worried about back to school season, [1:03:22] and I would love to just make some progress on this tonight if we can. [1:03:30] And I'd love to hear from other board members too. [1:03:36] So we have one more board meeting before the first piece of public policy. [1:03:44] For the first murder study. The first piece that has happened. [1:03:47] The first murder study. [1:03:48] We have board meeting. [1:03:50] I know. [1:03:52] Do we be a free board meeting for an executive session to start the eighth and then be committees? [1:03:58] I think is the plan. [1:04:00] And then September, the regime's heads were for the 22nd. [1:04:04] That's actually a conflict with Mani, a broken house. [1:04:06] So we're looking to move that to September 29th. [1:04:09] It would be the next official board meeting, [1:04:11] which will be before the first merger study meeting. [1:04:16] But that will be after the second season meeting. [1:04:18] There's been one, and there'll be one more between now and then. [1:04:22] What is why are we thinking of trying to split up? [1:04:27] You know, sort of, if it can almost be the easy part tonight. [1:04:31] Yeah, so the important thing to me, anyway, is the process and, you know, [1:04:38] the same to the representative, whether it's participating, or the CSM, okay, [1:04:45] the other representative, and we'll talk later on our next meeting about the specifics of the charge, [1:04:52] But, you know, here's the process, and you've got to be point back, and you have to get [1:04:58] to get people to look forward before even get a good book. [1:05:03] Just on your organization. [1:05:05] Um, I mean, when we think about the merger, I mean, we like Meredith said we could just go through [1:05:09] quickly and just kind of ramp it fire ideas and just at least write down some stuff to fill [1:05:16] in the blank. [1:05:17] Not that are not that our charge has to look exactly like this, but the back gain traction. [1:05:25] You know, I think what is the charge, you know, or something like that? [1:05:30] The community faculty, the board all worked on torture of a learner, seems like me. [1:05:35] That's in that. [1:05:37] I'm going to, that closing our small schools. [1:05:41] You know, that should probably be in there as well. [1:05:43] Based on the community has called the sort of last year. [1:05:46] Um, [1:05:48] I hope that's, I'll start. [1:05:54] First of all, it was just on a screw, and I can share it with you, um, this is just a [1:06:00] just thing. [1:06:01] But again, if the, if the idea is to think about what the process is, for this outline is essentially [1:06:13] what you've said, which I would, [1:06:15] change. Because the top language we are available, the top one would be your goals. The next one would be, you know, what are we might not need the financials part of it, but maybe we do keep that. Then the bright lines are the things you have to bring back. [1:06:33] then what the representative is free to do. Okay, so the reporting structure and then what our commitment is to the representative. So this is what you've said. [1:06:44] And we could just fill in. It's pulled the chart on the assets. Yeah, I'm just sorry. I'm having trouble reading it. [1:06:51] I mean, if that's fine, I mean, if that's fine, if that's fine, if that's fine. [1:06:55] Can you back up to three maybe? [1:06:57] I'll tell you where it is. [1:06:59] Maybe it's here to read behind you or just throw it out. [1:07:02] Maybe it's here to read behind you or throw it out out there. [1:07:05] I don't think that's the representative of the Mergers study committee to talk [1:07:09] about articles of agreement, or should fill an articles of agreement [1:07:12] without talking before about it. [1:07:15] And articles of agreement about the committee, not of our form. [1:07:19] I would be part of the agreement of a new district. [1:07:23] The way the process, at least for a last time, and it sounds like is set up to work this time, is... [1:07:30] The merger study committee in consideration of whether merger is advisable or not will kind of build what would be the articles of agreement, and at the end sort of see if that is something they could get behind or not, and then if it did move forward and the draft articles of agreement that would effectively govern the new district would be already in place. [1:07:53] And some important things in there is that we're talking about in terms of school closure process and [1:07:59] held voting works and things of that nature. [1:08:04] It is a lot of discussion and part of the problem. [1:08:10] I hope that they don't, the committee doesn't try to construct the articles that we're in the first. [1:08:15] I think that's kind of what happened in some of the other. [1:08:18] Um, I'd really like to focus on, you know, what are the, the private highs, I guess, you know, [1:08:25] what, what's really important to the board? [1:08:27] Yes. [1:08:28] So there are some things that are really important to the board in terms of marker. [1:08:33] What's that? [1:08:34] What are some things that are really important to the board in terms of merger? [1:08:38] I think that we're getting there in the end policy in terms of what we think is really [1:08:44] important. [1:08:47] And those could be renowned in the charge there. [1:08:52] I knew discharge should, I'm sorry, didn't mean to interrupt you go ahead. [1:08:56] I think that clearly articles of agreement that are consistent with the values and desires of the communities, I think it's important. [1:09:11] I think that I'd like to see discussion around this idea of a comprehensive regional high school that [1:09:21] integrates tech and, and the, you know, the code traditional. [1:09:33] I'd like to explore some way, [1:09:37] maybe this is more seesay than the merge of the committee. [1:09:40] but again, the idea that we can share some teaching and coursework so that we can [1:09:48] stand after these while meeting our minimum supply size issues. [1:09:54] So my thought with getting back to what Erin you had suggested, [1:09:59] meeting putting some thought into this and coming back to it as a court, and I actually was on [1:10:05] work with that, because one of our other gender items today is to discuss the ends work. [1:10:11] And I feel like that is very, you know, that's kind of for the chart. [1:10:19] But I also think like we could do some of the low-haired fruits in it. [1:10:23] Just [1:10:25] talk about the ends and then spend some time. [1:10:30] I need to do a little bit more research. [1:10:32] And I like I said, I can't see this document. [1:10:34] and your document, so we'll see how there similar and different would be helpful. [1:10:42] I can send out the, I can send this out, the structure, if you're comfortable with me sharing [1:10:48] what you've sent me. [1:10:50] And did you share that with a little more? [1:10:51] Yes. [1:10:52] Okay. [1:10:53] Okay. [1:10:55] So then you'll have both. [1:10:58] I think it's also important to just familiarize yourself with CISA and what that is. [1:11:04] and what the murder study is, and while they are related [1:11:10] they are in my mind, very separate. [1:11:13] And I want to make sure that one more writing [1:11:15] our charges that we are operating under the same guidelines. [1:11:21] And maybe you know, should that be at the next meeting? [1:11:25] But the board meeting? [1:11:26] I'll be there. [1:11:27] I mean, I guess so. [1:11:28] Like I, I, yes. [1:11:32] I mean, I think we could, [1:11:33] I was going to say, we also have a P&G ready meeting before then, but perhaps we could discuss [1:11:38] it then, but I know we have a pretty big deal with this, so I don't know if I should have [1:11:45] been mentioned that. [1:11:50] I know, just seems we get into analysis paralysis a lot. And we're going [1:11:55] to sit here and talk about the problem rather than putting stuff down on paper and I fear that. [1:12:00] But when we got down the process, we got to adapt the process and the next feeding, you know, adapt the goals. [1:12:09] I'm not sure what the process does absent the meat of it and other people can disagree with me. [1:12:17] I'm not sure if we say we adopt a process, what are we saying? [1:12:24] Well, I think, the two elements, and I'm thinking of I think a pretty important. [1:12:29] I don't know. [1:12:30] You just mean, like, maybe more using different forms, you know, thinking of one word means [1:12:37] different things. [1:12:39] But, for example, how often they report things like that, what that report looks like. [1:12:44] Do we have it as, like, a standing agenda item, is it a written report, a verbal report, [1:12:48] like, get into those details, right? [1:12:52] That's how I was at her standard. [1:12:54] Well, in this document, it feels like both. [1:12:56] It feels like church and process. [1:12:58] So I read quickly on my left-rake, [1:13:01] so not as deeply as I would have liked to, what you sent. [1:13:05] But I do like this format, [1:13:07] mainly because I like numbers of bullet points, [1:13:09] and I think it also lays out the process. [1:13:12] And maybe we could take some of what her has [1:13:14] if we agree on that and plug it into this. [1:13:19] And that's fun. [1:13:19] and then identify what we have it completed as our to-do or the other step camera. [1:13:30] So that's true. Then if we scroll down then to what our representative is free to do [1:13:35] or reporting back to the board. That's where I think the process lives. Yes. [1:13:44] And if that's true, then what part of her's [1:13:51] structure fits here that feels like the whole board agrees with. [1:13:58] to ask me. Where is the provision that says that more Hispanic may representative, [1:14:12] he's gifted a program or before maybe, okay, but I don't see that. [1:14:21] That's something you can add though. That's what that's one thing. Yeah, that's what salt [1:14:25] we need to do is. But I have to, I completely understand you're wanting to put something like that [1:14:31] in there and I'm questioning how that works because if they're saying that a committee meeting [1:14:35] and something's put to vote, we can't say, well hold on, I gotta go to my next four meeting [1:14:41] which isn't four weeks, so can we, like I guess I'm just literally cemented to put, like, how [1:14:45] do I want it? I thought the same thing, but did you see something, Patrick? I was like, [1:14:49] And I think that many would have a chance to bring an information about that to work before they vote. [1:14:57] But design the entire document, like it would be. [1:15:00] We perhaps draft our government agreement. This board would receive the report, and it would be this [1:15:07] board that would have to warn of the MAUSD electorate on Berger. [1:15:12] But that's at the end of that. [1:15:13] That's the end, not every decision point along the way in the process. [1:15:17] Right. That's, I think that's the challenge that you're highlighting, which is pretty real, [1:15:21] because the cadence of these board meetings and the cadence of the murder study committee meetings [1:15:26] would have to line up pretty well, they would do that and not really jam up a process. [1:15:30] It's going to move quickly because of the compressed timeline. [1:15:33] OK, thank you for clarifying that. [1:15:35] Because I had the same thought and then I'm in some of which stood. [1:15:39] Yeah, but it doesn't seem realistic. [1:15:41] It's not realistic. [1:15:42] But at the same time, if we don't have something in place, [1:15:44] you could get to a point of the end that comes back to this board and we look at it at the first time itself. [1:15:50] What the hell were you doing? [1:15:50] Exactly. [1:15:51] and then all of that fall on it. [1:15:53] So I agree that there needs to be some... [1:15:56] Just make it not get so specific that we trap. [1:15:59] Okay, then we're abstaining from our vote. [1:16:03] I wonder about, in the reporting back to the board section, [1:16:07] having something about what they share. [1:16:11] So it has the drafts of proposals and things like that, [1:16:14] but I wonder about other things like, [1:16:16] if we know there's a vote coming out of the board, [1:16:18] If there's right, we could put it there to say, [1:16:23] we have to alert the board to when important [1:16:25] votes are happening or something to that effect. [1:16:27] So that we're all, we've got to head up. [1:16:30] Absolutely, that's what I imagine that, you know, [1:16:34] whoever's represented with C.C. [1:16:35] The Merchetti Committee, they're going to know [1:16:38] from the agenda in the timeline. [1:16:41] What's going to come up? [1:16:44] And maybe anyone, maybe there might be some issues. [1:16:46] So you mean, yeah, yeah. [1:16:47] But by and large, if the board gets to say the murder [1:16:51] of the study, because it is working on, [1:16:53] well, what do we want to say about school and closure? [1:16:56] I don't think that's going to be tough, [1:16:58] but probably not, but maybe without a lot of evidence. [1:17:02] Well, and if we put in, sorry, maybe we put something in there [1:17:05] that way, because we don't know the schedule. [1:17:07] We don't know how often it's meeting. [1:17:09] We, there's so many unknowns right now. [1:17:10] And so we could also put something in there that, sorry, guys, [1:17:14] we may have to meet off schedule. [1:17:15] in order to ensure that you and Mike and Colorado is going to the meeting has what you need from this [1:17:22] for to support the action. You need to take, which may mean we don't wait till our next [1:17:26] business lady because you need to know. Right, so we need to get what's going on. [1:17:30] And I would imagine that you could, if something comes up, you know, and maybe the board meeting [1:17:39] isn't three weeks away or something. But you know something is going to come out, that's important [1:17:44] to the board. You let the board go. So you find some sort of feedback loop to make sure you're on the right track. [1:17:54] So I was going to jump in. I think the second point under number five does this. I think it's actually. [1:17:59] Yeah, one. [1:18:00] Number five. Well, at point one. [1:18:02] I could read it for a second, but now that's anything that they're sorry, Patrick. [1:18:06] Liz, we'll get to you in just a second thing. [1:18:08] It says, bring drafts proposals or facilitator recommendations to the board before any committee [1:18:12] voting. [1:18:13] Thank you. [1:18:13] Thank you. [1:18:14] When are the 80s? [1:18:15] And the only other thing that seems missing from the Department of Work, which I appreciate [1:18:19] is the first bullet line, or it says report, and we'll figure out the details, but on what [1:18:24] was discussed in any issue, I think to capture our discussion, it should be what was discussed, [1:18:30] any self-sitative votes that took place, and any issue touching section 3, like, just [1:18:35] specified that if you took a vote on something that's substantive, you need to tell a [1:18:40] before that vote was taken. And in the second bullet point says, whenever possible, [1:18:45] you're going to tell us before any vote is taken. And that way, we either know an advance [1:18:49] of something big, or if you voted on something and we then decide after the fact like, [1:18:55] that was actually kind of the big deal. You'd be in a position to bring that back to the [1:19:05] need to know that from my back to my home, like, and that may pose a serious problem when this [1:19:12] ultimately comes back to that board or to that community, because in the end, in the [1:19:15] emergency study committee asked to thread some needle where they keep each of these boards and [1:19:20] their committees, they're happy enough, they're going to need to go back, they're going to need that. [1:19:25] So it seemed like those two would take care of that for us. I would also offer that [1:19:30] if you took a few minutes to reflect on our current articles of agreement right now, [1:19:35] most of the most controversial topics that are going to come up are not a mystery. [1:19:41] You could have not a mystery. You could have conversations tonight in anticipation of what will be forthcoming conversations at the murder study committee [1:19:49] Who has the authority to close the school? [1:19:51] This board hasn't talked about that. You don't need to wait for that to show up on a murder study committee agenda to have that conversation and decide as a board where to stand on that topic [1:19:59] because it's going to come up and there are probably a handful of others like that that [1:20:03] You don't need to wait and you can be out in front of that and then whoever the murder state committee reps are have that in their in their knowledge. [1:20:12] Yeah, I could. [1:20:13] Liz, you have your hand up. [1:20:17] I also just want to keep in mind that we can have these conversations as a board, but I would expect our representatives to be learning at the meetings. [1:20:29] So I would expect they would hear something whether CSa or merger and that they would be willing to grow and learn and compromise based on what they hear from other representatives. [1:20:43] So I think that we can have a discussion and have a position to start a conversation, but I don't think that we should limit the representative from what is required the good faith effort to merge and coming up with middle ground with our neighboring districts so that's something to consider. [1:21:11] and abstaining from our vote, like Melissa would say. [1:21:16] And yeah, it was great. [1:21:23] So what I'm doing right now is as you all are talking, [1:21:26] I've taken the framework that Gini sent. [1:21:29] I made a copy of it. [1:21:31] I'm putting in the language that we're all saying. [1:21:34] And I'm highlighting that. [1:21:36] So when I share it back to you all, [1:21:37] people will have this with the highlighted changes. [1:21:42] And then you have herbs as well. [1:21:46] And when would be act on there? [1:21:48] Well, I don't think we're going to act on it tonight. [1:21:50] Okay. [1:21:52] That's my sense. [1:21:53] Maybe we do. [1:21:53] Maybe we say this is the preliminary. [1:21:55] One might have to go back to the agenda real quick. [1:21:59] I've looked at the old document. [1:22:02] Yep. [1:22:04] Well, this right now says, [1:22:06] donate the board charge for CISA and merger study work. Right now we're largely just talking about the [1:22:14] merger. And we have even touched a CISA you want yet. So I'm okay if we [1:22:20] if we table the action item for tonight if something says that and we can put it on the next one, [1:22:25] but that would come with this stipulation that we're ready to actually do the work. [1:22:30] Next time, because I don't think we need to keep kicking it down the road. We can do this. [1:22:38] Are there any other thoughts based on what we can see and what our general feelings are right now about what a recording structure needs to look like. What the feedback loop me to look like. Any great lines. [1:22:54] Can you scroll up to, I believe, section three? [1:23:04] So, like Patrick said, there are things that we know are controversial that are going to come up. [1:23:13] And I think to be fair to her and anybody else who might be on the board, we need to get ahead of that. [1:23:22] So I think at some point, obviously it's not going to be today, maybe it'll be next week, [1:23:29] maybe not. [1:23:30] We as a board should be able to, as one voice, say, this is who we believe should have [1:23:39] authority to close a school in the Mergers City Committee and any other controversial topics [1:23:45] that we know are going to come up. [1:23:46] I think we should have a stance so we can arm her and be there. [1:23:50] So are there suggestions that you have for language that needs to be? [1:23:57] We recommend that we as a board recommend that the articles of agreement stipulate [1:24:04] that blank has the authority to close a school through this process and the right lines. [1:24:12] in the right lines, in the right lines. [1:24:16] Our major study committee representative may not represent [1:24:20] a viewpoint contrary to this. [1:24:26] So, I said trust, you know, [1:24:33] so you kind of play in doing that, everyone has, [1:24:36] we have a meeting? [1:24:38] Well, I mean, probably not, [1:24:40] but we're gonna have to do it at some point. [1:24:42] Well, I understand what we're gonna do [1:24:43] in some point, but you know, it's been a long meter. [1:24:46] And I [1:24:51] think we need to reflect on how, you know, what's happening in the past year. [1:24:58] This is going to be a difficult issue, I think. [1:25:01] And [1:25:04] I think it's also going to talk depending on what the other districts are thinking about this. [1:25:12] So I'm going to have different opinions. [1:25:13] They might, they all three might have different opinions, and then you got a break in. [1:25:21] So I want to get out ahead of, I want to take my time to make sure we get that one, [1:25:26] because that's going to be critical to getting the support of the board as whole in our community. [1:25:33] That'll be a key to it. [1:25:35] So. [1:25:35] Probably other key. [1:25:36] Yeah. [1:25:37] I agree. [1:25:38] I wouldn't rush out. [1:25:39] Maybe I'll let a little loss. [1:25:40] How are the goals of a minute could fit our current articles of a minute? [1:25:44] Could fill in those points? [1:25:45] Yes. [1:25:46] Right? [1:25:47] Yes. [1:25:47] And let's so you're saying, are you, was your response and consideration to us changing [1:25:54] or also agreement? [1:25:56] So, well, I think some thought was, we do need to talk about how to represent the Board's [1:26:03] position in the marriage setting. [1:26:06] My baseline would be, you know, we already got an article about that, and everybody has a different [1:26:17] It's quite possible that you could have a unified district with different [1:26:24] provisions relating to the school to each one of those former districts. [1:26:30] So by getting that level of specificity, it might not allow us to find [1:26:35] common ground. [1:26:36] That would just be with amongst the other districts. [1:26:39] Can I have one common ground with the other district? [1:26:42] You know, I could see a way that, if that's not fast, but comes in agreement with the other districts that reflects where they're coming from, either from a different subject of, and I wouldn't want to include that at all. [1:26:57] Could I chime in? [1:27:02] A couple of months ago, I did a deep dive into the last merger study committee, [1:27:06] and it seems like this question on who has the authority to close a school was a big driver on [1:27:14] why community members did or did not support the last merger study committee. And specifically, [1:27:21] The medicine northwest does not require that the citizens in the town where a school is located have the final vote on whether or not that school is closed and it really [1:27:35] For my understanding, having not been there made it difficult to draft a new district's articles of agreement with both districts having a different viewpoints and then even within districts different towns having different viewpoints on that as well. [1:27:49] So. [1:27:51] Right, but one of the ways that, I mean, I wasn't part of that murder [1:27:55] aesthetic of any, but I think you'd write that it was, you think we had [1:27:59] different articles on that point. [1:28:02] But James actually had a cam vote, but it was constructed, the language was [1:28:06] different, and you could, it would have removed a pencil out, obstacle to a [1:28:15] I'm encouraging if they could have found a way to somehow accommodate both the communities. [1:28:23] And I could see that in Middlebury has their own perspective, [1:28:27] right? [1:28:28] And, you know, accommodate that. [1:28:30] Okay, for the schools that were formerly in as a central, [1:28:37] you know, here's how to go about thinking about clothing and school. [1:28:41] If it's in an artist, here's how we go about to it. [1:28:44] and we have a book. [1:28:47] I just think it's important not to rush that issue, [1:28:53] both to get the flavor of where the other dishes are coming from and not to get a kind of [1:29:01] where our communities are coming from. We got to know some trust here and so we got to take [1:29:09] One of the things that's... [1:29:10] On that issue. [1:29:12] And probably others, but that's certainly the biggie. [1:29:15] One of the things that's coming in mind for me as we're talking about the charge and sort of this guidance being provided to the reps, which I think is helpful, is also the reality that. [1:29:26] There is no way that the reps, whether there's one or four, are going to be able to replicate for this board. [1:29:34] everything they've learned and the time they've invested in the study that's in the [1:29:38] merger study committee. [1:29:42] It's just thinking about, like, to what extent do you want to remove the authority [1:29:48] of the people that have the deeper knowledge because they've invested three hour [1:29:53] meetings every month, say, that not the World Board has and they're going to bring back [1:29:58] summaries of some of the highlights of them. [1:30:00] But it isn't going to be the same as sitting in those meetings and having a conversation in reading people's faces and hearing the stories and all those things. [1:30:08] So that was one thought I had, yeah, could be on pause there for now. [1:30:17] Vote. [1:30:19] I'd like to have some sort of executive limitations for the charge that say, don't go off at worst in these areas. [1:30:28] I think that's what the bright light is. [1:30:30] I think it's important to be. [1:30:32] So I was thinking around what you were saying, [1:30:36] No, maybe it's not that specific, [1:30:38] but it's like anything that, [1:30:45] right? [1:30:45] Because you had very specific light. [1:30:47] I did. [1:30:47] Can you say it again? [1:30:49] Just so. [1:30:50] Well, I can make it more general. [1:30:52] So bright lines. [1:30:54] We understand that school closure is a controversial topic. [1:31:00] When school closure comes up to the best of your ability of representative diverse perspectives of multiple communities within a MAUSD because we know we don't have a consensus in all circumstances. [1:31:12] So the way I read it is, our representatives may discuss, explore a lot, they may not agree to sign on to or represent as a district's position, anything that touches. [1:31:24] I mean, I don't want to say that they can't at all, right? [1:31:27] But prior to discussing with the board. [1:31:30] Yeah, right. [1:31:32] I guess part of what I was thinking when I made that earlier comment. [1:31:34] I'm thinking about Liz's comment before about sort of the open-mindedness [1:31:38] and going into this looking proper opportunities to learn and grow. [1:31:43] Even if we take that really controversial topic, [1:31:45] that there's a lot of different thoughts and opinions around. [1:31:49] The representatives that sit at the Mergers study table are going to be afforded the opportunity. [1:31:55] This is different than last time we talked about Mergers to hear and learn about. [1:32:01] So we all have different articles of agreement around school closure. [1:32:04] How has the language difference impacted students differently in our communities? [1:32:10] Like, what's there? What do we learn from what has happened and how does that inform what makes sense going forward? [1:32:17] So for this board to set really hard lines on anything prior to that opportunity that might be forthcoming [1:32:25] Yeah, it creates a difficult situation [1:32:29] Although we say you know the way this number three is constructed it says bright lines bring these back to the first full board first [1:32:38] So that doesn't mean so let's say we had something like you know bright lines [1:32:46] And we want to preserve our current articles [1:32:48] agreement around school plan. [1:32:50] Did we? [1:32:51] It was a study in the last space. [1:32:53] But we can even be less specific than that. [1:32:56] We could just say school code number. [1:32:58] I, that's what I wish. [1:33:01] I wish. [1:33:01] All right. [1:33:01] Anything with any school plan? [1:33:03] I would, I would say, we should already have a policy [1:33:07] because it's in our articles and agreement. [1:33:09] But yeah, before the representative certainly goes on that, whatever the committee is deciding, gotta come back to work for you. [1:33:28] I don't know, you know, the best way to do that would hit might be to adopt a set, you know, [1:33:35] have different, different art of research history. So I just put in our, you know, it's article of a [1:33:43] agreement, some consideration needs to be made regarding the board's feeling about that. Yeah, so, [1:33:47] okay, we can thank you. Perfect. And one other just sort of conceptualizing this, [1:33:54] so I've heard you say a couple of times about each district in this merger. [1:34:00] Mm-hmm. Theoretically there won't be each district in this merger. There will be any [1:34:04] It's great when I heard it. [1:34:07] It's interesting. [1:34:07] It's interesting. [1:34:08] I meant to say existing things. [1:34:10] Good for representatives of existing districts that are thinking about becoming [1:34:15] single-deserved and what are the terms and what are the nuances that you can have to construct [1:34:26] to make sure that the values of the communities are carried forward. [1:34:33] And you might have beautiful many on most issues, but you might have less than uniformity [1:34:40] on some of them, because you want to get a virtue, right? [1:34:43] And when you get a virtue, you know, you might want to, you know, some wrinkleful. [1:34:49] Okay, so in terms of what we have tonight, there's only a couple highlighted suggestions [1:34:56] of language. [1:34:57] I will send that out to you, or do someone want to table the action item C for tonight? [1:35:04] Two more. [1:35:06] First. [1:35:07] Second. [1:35:08] Second. [1:35:08] Highly second. [1:35:10] All those in favor of table action item C, please say aye. [1:35:14] Or any opposed. [1:35:17] Thank you. [1:35:20] Any of extensions? [1:35:23] No motion passes. [1:35:23] I will send that document out to you and we can start to digest that and be prepared to come next meeting and actually do that. [1:35:36] Up to negotiations for support staff. [1:35:40] They haven't started yet. [1:35:42] Right. This is just here as a reminder, who's on the support staff. [1:35:47] and negotiations committee and S, Kathy Meredith and Liz, and those were appointed [1:35:51] at the reorganizational meeting on March 10. Those meetings have started yet, but they'll [1:35:55] likely pick up fleet fall orally mentored probably November December. [1:35:59] Okay. [1:36:05] Next is a discussion for monitoring reports, structure, and I am drawing a blank [1:36:10] off the eye, that's it. [1:36:13] Likewise. [1:36:18] What's this topic, I didn't know it's needed. [1:36:19] Yeah, my brain is not braining the reason that we put this on, [1:36:29] we will hold the tube. [1:36:30] Thank you. It felt important at the time, clearly. [1:36:35] You're not familiar with that. It's not anything I have it in. [1:36:39] I have a couple of holes right now. [1:36:44] Yeah, if you guys found time, that's fine with me. [1:36:50] Yeah, I don't know why. [1:36:53] It was the table. [1:36:55] I could move to pass it. [1:36:58] No, no, actually. [1:36:59] No, I don't actually need it. [1:37:01] Post-phoned consideration in Zephyr's. [1:37:04] It's only just not that I'd ever have a critic. [1:37:07] And the only thing that comes to mind maybe coming out of the retreat was there's some talk briefly about when we would [1:37:22] That's the only thing that they should migrate into that bucket. [1:37:28] I can't right now pull it out of me. [1:37:30] So I really apologize for that. But we can go down to the ends work that we need to finish, which is linked in the agenda. [1:37:43] And the last part that we didn't get to, because we had a really robust suspension about 6th grade, is activity 2 and 3, really. [1:37:56] The reminder is that we had, we did the initial, like, what are people's premises, then we did a virtual gallery walk with each other, and the ones that rose to the top in terms of what ones we found most important, [1:38:14] number one was skillful and knowledgeable, and that was true across all the groups. So if we're [1:38:21] sticking with that skillful and knowledgeable as being the number one end out of the six we have, [1:38:29] then we would go through the activity activity too, which is imagine this end becoming the defining [1:38:36] strength of an AOC five years from now, and then we would complete the prompts given. And then number three is [1:38:44] start to pick it apart a little bit in terms of board expectations, what the superintendents [1:38:49] responsible for, what kind of evidence might we suggest. And this gets a little bit into [1:38:57] slightly into means, but I think we're just trying to vision what it might, what it might look [1:39:03] like thinking outward. So I want you to get two stuck on like this is the hard and fast of things [1:39:10] as much as it's, like, how do we think forward? [1:39:16] Yeah. [1:39:17] What are we doing? [1:39:18] So tonight, I would love us to go through activity too, [1:39:21] which is really thinking about if [1:39:23] Spillful and knowledgeable was defining strength [1:39:27] of us in five years, what would it, [1:39:30] what would it look like for students, [1:39:33] what would teachers do, what would families notice, [1:39:35] what would the community say, [1:39:37] what would the board receive evidence, [1:39:40] And then if there's anything that would not be different. [1:39:45] I love this. Thank you for putting this together. [1:39:48] You're welcome. [1:39:49] So initially these were supposed to be in small groups. [1:39:52] I know we have some people online, which may still touch more challenging. [1:39:58] But if people wanted to have a group discussion, [1:40:02] and then we can start to plug in some stuff, that would be really helpful. [1:40:08] I think students would be reading. [1:40:12] And I think they'd be reading for fun, they'd be reading proficiently. [1:40:22] It's go full and knowledgeable. [1:40:24] Was it a finding strength of USD-5 years from now? [1:40:27] Okay. [1:40:28] So, you want to sort of fill one book? [1:40:30] Please, and thank you. [1:40:31] There we go. [1:40:32] I did. [1:40:34] Because I always feel it wasn't much to me. [1:40:36] Great. [1:40:37] Can you read them to me? [1:40:39] I sure did. [1:40:39] I sure did. [1:40:40] So. [1:40:41] So, you know, I didn't know how to really do this very well, but the thing came to mind. [1:40:50] And maybe this is more of the evidence, but students who are detained, reasonable. [1:40:54] The fish team editors in literacy, math, and the arts, as in a claim. [1:41:00] Maybe that's more metrics of a. [1:41:03] teachers would have the discretion, except if parameters can achieve those methods and the resources [1:41:09] sufficient to accomplish the families we notice, they improve staccatetic behavior. [1:41:19] I would like to add teachers would stay. [1:41:24] They would want to work at MEUSC and teachers would apply in-fruits to all of our decisions. [1:41:33] decisions, and teachers would feel like their work was the center of our community. [1:41:45] But they're better. [1:41:49] Thank you. [1:41:54] So one of the things that I'm thinking about, I've been reading this in students would [1:41:57] teacherhood, and then families would notice, and I'm brought back to it. [1:42:01] I think it was an article you do head share about ethnicity. [1:42:05] I know that. [1:42:07] It was the three red states. [1:42:08] Yeah, and it was fascinating to read about, so thank you for sharing, but [1:42:13] families weren't engaged in the success of their students. And I'm not saying they're not, [1:42:18] but I'm saying it's not here. We're saying that families would notice, but we're not leaving [1:42:22] space for the families to engage. Like we are the students and the teachers. And I looked at some S. [1:42:29] Well, we can say if I'm as we've noticed that they are engaged. [1:42:32] today the family or the students, right? [1:42:38] Yeah. [1:42:39] Yeah, that was a fascinating article. [1:42:43] Yeah. [1:42:43] You know, the three states it must be way far behind. [1:42:48] You know, and the parent interested in one of these states. [1:42:51] That used to be way far ahead. [1:42:54] Yeah. [1:42:55] What might be other other things students would or teachers would? [1:43:01] I think. [1:43:01] the discussion on the retreat, we've made a group of sort of thought about skillful and [1:43:05] knowledgeable as being somewhat of a precursor to being able to engage correctly. [1:43:10] So I think in both students, what teachers would there's space to add, so [1:43:14] those students would have the foundation to be able to apply knowledge bases, [1:43:20] particularly for something along those lines, and teachers would have the opportunity [1:43:25] to encourage students to extend their thinking beyond their skill and knowledge set, to [1:43:35] apply it to new challenges, problems, or something. [1:43:40] But we can do later. [1:43:42] But we really get at this idea that if in five years students can really have these foundations, [1:43:49] that's a prerequisite for them being able to put those together in a really in-way. [1:43:53] Yeah, they combat mode again. [1:43:56] Yeah, get to that as well. [1:43:57] So they kind of touched on getting to each of those other parts of our portrait or whatever. [1:44:02] Yeah. [1:44:03] They can make that a pyramid. [1:44:04] It's very important. [1:44:05] I mean, they're all important. [1:44:06] Yeah. [1:44:07] But I think there's a reason why we collectively settled on this is the presentation. [1:44:12] But being able to acknowledge here that that leads to some of those other goals that we had as well. [1:44:18] Students would leave any SD with their robust skillset, [1:44:23] set preparing them for employment or further attribution. [1:44:33] And looking at how we define a skillful and knowledgeable, [1:44:37] because they'll have the academic and skills, [1:44:39] perhaps the life skills to allow them to participate in [1:44:42] contribute to society in fairly ways, which kind of goes to a [1:44:46] little bit of what they're saying and applying it. [1:44:49] But it makes me think about what the community would say. [1:44:54] Maybe they're active in contributing or engaged. [1:45:01] I'll use members of community, I don't know, there's a lot of different parts we could put in there. [1:45:10] Imagine that the community wouldn't have its whole relative nature. I mean, to me, this is a pretty optimistic place to be. [1:45:18] And the students are at this point, like the things you're going to know. [1:45:23] I'm going to tell their friends to move here. [1:45:26] And I'm serious, but I'm serious, like. [1:45:34] So this is really important issue I think for a lot of folks in the community and so I sort of thought that if we, you know, really can do a job on this one, you know, in terms of policy, how we express it. [1:45:50] That would be very positive, you know, for our community. [1:45:54] And in terms of our degree responsive to something that they said is really important, because, you know, I get that would be important, [1:46:03] you know, that trust issue, I think it's really important to be able to, so that would be helpful. [1:46:13] What any, not different, Barbara, are you going to say something? [1:46:18] Yeah, this keeps going through my head. I'm not sure belongs in this category, but teachers would meet students their levels that they could become skillful and knowledgeable. [1:46:35] I love that art. [1:46:39] I might extend that a smidge to say teachers would have the resources to suit students. [1:46:50] I [1:46:53] think it's a little bit different, right, because teachers make accommodations all the time [1:46:57] to me as students where they are, versus having a really robust system to do that work. [1:47:06] I think there's two different things. [1:47:08] But who can they come and say anything? [1:47:13] It's a similar thing. [1:47:14] It's a similar thing. [1:47:15] It's a similar thing. [1:47:18] It's a some way that we can incorporate in terms of students who would issues around running [1:47:26] environment, you know, some of the social emotional skills that they need as sort of [1:47:33] predicates to be in successful in this academic area, what is that kind of different time. [1:47:41] Well, scope one knowledge was not defined just by academics. [1:47:44] science, science, which is why we're sinking, [1:47:52] but it's believed I identified some [1:47:54] academic skills, maybe if you're saying we should identify some feedback [1:47:57] the rest of the world. Or, you know, just issues around the way they're coming from [1:48:05] in terms of being able to forward, and not doing a very good job, sorry to that, but it's [1:48:12] probably pretty important to mention it somewhere around the [1:48:19] world. [1:48:19] Who said it? Yeah, I'm sorry. Can you say that again? I'm not following. I said that. Yeah, I like to say it a bit. [1:48:28] So, I think one of the other, and maybe it's getting into another topic. We had confidence of what it is. [1:48:34] It's the same as the potential, you know, authorities. [1:48:41] And we talked about an oil group. [1:48:43] So I would go by doing that in a lot of it. [1:48:48] I think I have to do with the warning of five [1:48:50] and in supporting kids so that they confident in one of it. [1:48:56] And then can do some of the academic issues [1:48:59] that's going to be in scope and scope. [1:49:01] I don't know what I can do. [1:49:03] So they go back to the whole foundation, [1:49:06] foundation, inclusive, and then it's like I was [1:49:07] attached to that, do you feel like the foundation [1:49:10] that's scope and knowledgeable, but are you saying, [1:49:12] But in maybe that way, I don't know if I'm like with the resources that they need for it. [1:49:19] I think it's probably a different element in the portrait of the situation. [1:49:28] I think it's definitely broken out in that way. [1:49:32] But I think what you're staying there for is we talk about it sometimes in terms of MTSF's, for example, [1:49:40] right, like meeting a student where they're at, might be on this full range of ways, might be [1:49:47] in a behavioral way, might be in an academic way. And then how teachers and admins identify [1:49:53] and then work with that could look many different ways. And sometimes it looks like, [1:50:00] from my own experience, like administration takes that role of being the fixer in the duper. [1:50:07] And sometimes it looks like a teacher is asked to do ex-sonant of accommodations to meet that. [1:50:13] And I think there's a way that those two things go together so that it's a together process, [1:50:21] which sometimes get lost and gets lost in a big structure of support. [1:50:27] As we're very used to just for fixtures, right? [1:50:30] So I think my point and I think what you're getting out to is that in order to support students [1:50:37] no matter where they're coming from, there has to be some sort of way that we're moving the fence. [1:50:46] If people are familiar with the latter against the fence and like you add wrongs to make it equitable and really what we're looking for is take the fence down, right? [1:50:54] Remove all the barrier stacks up. [1:50:55] Yeah. [1:50:59] Love that image. [1:51:02] Okay. [1:51:02] What would the board receive evidence filling? [1:51:10] I would say it's from my picture and some of those core. [1:51:18] And at least, you know, partly, some of the areas would be, [1:51:23] how are we doing in terms of efficiencies for some of the extent of the measure on an annual basis? [1:51:29] I'd say, like. [1:51:32] Demonstrating growth and proficiency in summited end of the year assessments as well as [1:51:39] Whatever benchmarking tool we use showing [1:51:44] Is to work in that sense [1:51:49] Showing growth for it's purpose same with [1:51:54] Meeting students where they're had right we begin those little that [1:52:01] It's great. It shows like a student's progress over the course of the year. [1:52:05] So it's like how did your child progress and relation to the rest of the kids and their grade? [1:52:12] Right? Where were they on the graph? [1:52:16] Just meaning we think of my own personal example with one of my children, right? [1:52:20] Like, they were below grade level, but their progress was like way above, you know, [1:52:26] they were like making progress of lesion bounds, which told me that. [1:52:30] They weren't even where he was at. He was able to grow up. So I feel like we probably do have access to data right now. [1:52:40] I mean, I mean, there's a better idea. [1:52:41] I think that's a good idea. [1:52:43] That's a good idea. [1:52:45] But it would be, what do you say? [1:52:47] Math should have like a growth score. [1:52:50] Yeah, that's the one I have in thinking of. [1:52:53] But I'm not necessarily recommending one. [1:52:56] I guess as an, you know, people who are educators probably have a recommendation. [1:53:00] any assessment of that caliber will have something that shows that. So I think just there are [1:53:08] two-normed ways to report on your growth for a child that I think we could see and look at [1:53:14] it to evaluate progress. And it's probably like in the first couple of years for one that we would have to focus on. [1:53:19] Yeah, where our sport is already out, we're off at feet, we have to be ready. We might have to take [1:53:24] free level, but we see it with growth as well. [1:53:26] Is that in our way, that way? [1:53:29] Dark. [1:53:30] Yeah, I think we're protecting for five years. [1:53:34] And I think it would be really [1:53:36] written to not be tied to traditional norms [1:53:44] of data collection to open up the scope of that. [1:53:48] And I think that as education changes, [1:53:51] you can see the variables and the opportunities that might arise for evaluating students [1:54:01] work years ago, the report folios, writing, for example, versus, you know, test scores, [1:54:11] but, you know, there might be some futuristic ways of analyzing student growth, and I would [1:54:18] to have them not included, I think that's a bigger question. [1:54:26] What is the Patrick, each student is to create their own personal own right, plan or something, right, what is that called? [1:54:35] First-class learning plan. [1:54:36] Yeah. [1:54:36] Okay. [1:54:36] And that starts in Sanskrit. [1:54:39] Can you talk about the details in that a little bit about what that looks like? [1:54:45] really it's sort of it it's nature is personalized to that student thinking about [1:54:49] here is they're going to grow in and they really think about ways in which they're [1:54:52] going to grow and there's some progress monitoring them and really that carries [1:54:56] through senior year and as they get right as they get towards senior year they're [1:55:02] presenting to groups and kind of grows with them as they get toward the end of their [1:55:11] I'm just wondering if that's something that we can look at, and it allows students at thinking, you know, [1:55:21] by simply like, you know, something so traditional, right? [1:55:25] I'm going to weigh them down. [1:55:28] The other thing I was thinking of as hopeful and knowledgeable is like, [1:55:36] Right, because you gain skill from knowing a little bit about a lot of things sometimes, right? [1:55:44] So it's thinking about students would demonstrate diversity in their exposure or something to programming. [1:55:54] So the boards would receive evidence showing diversity in programming. [1:56:02] Yeah, I love the branding of breadth and depth of what it's worth collection. [1:56:06] It's all well and good if you have a really strong thing here, but you might need other aspects. [1:56:13] But also if you only spread yourself through the neighborhood, the expertise that you might need to apply to some of the particular, [1:56:21] I would say, I'd love it if we had data that showed us why and why our students have a wide knowledge base. [1:56:29] And each one has a least-hand area that they pursue at some level of depth, and that would be. [1:56:36] That would be very satisfying. [1:56:39] But I like it. [1:56:41] We're thinking big. [1:56:42] Good. [1:56:45] And in my mind, that includes, you know, perhaps they're pursuing that depth in mathematics, [1:56:50] or English, for example, or could be diesel mechanics of the twisted area, or sea, or whatever, [1:56:58] or anything, or that's to be granted to these two audits. [1:57:01] And that's how the opportunity will do that. [1:57:04] But the PLP reflects that. [1:57:05] Potentially. [1:57:06] I mean, yeah. [1:57:08] The PLP process, again, my design is not so steered to take a kid deep in something, [1:57:13] and that the individual student may want to explore a range of things, [1:57:17] which means they're not going as deeply at least in their PLP. [1:57:21] So it would be hard to necessarily look to that every time, as an example. [1:57:26] But for some kids it would be [1:57:31] is there anything we think would not be different. [1:57:38] I had trouble with that. Well, I'm sure I didn't have a little badge me with that was getting it [1:57:46] I mean really it's not being what we meant so yeah, oh, yeah, what would not be different. Oh, yeah [1:57:53] I mean this is maybe just a way the signal the broader audience I don't think like our teachers would be different [1:58:00] And I don't think they're a commitment that you can get for it, right? [1:58:04] By the other words, if I don't get the sense right now that it's a Q&A report, things [1:58:09] that the efficiency is in skillful and knowledge at present are the results of our staff, for example. [1:58:18] But rather, as a result of structures and resources and opportunity approaches, and so I think [1:58:24] it's nice to call out there that this is a vision that talks about the way [1:58:29] systems, help shape out a couple of steps. [1:58:35] I don't know. [1:58:39] Just so that this is an introvert as us, as a board [1:58:41] scenario, teachers better do some better shower here, like, I don't [1:58:44] think that some of that should be true. [1:58:46] Thank you. [1:58:47] For Patrick and the administration team, our financial system isn't going to be [1:58:55] different. We're going to have the same thought structure over the next [1:58:59] back here. I actually probably not. I don't think it's going to look anything like it [1:59:08] does right now. Five years ago. Okay, that's a great point. I think it's passive and we [1:59:16] don't have heard to fix it anymore. It adds. Well, be fine, char. So I had a bar. Yeah, I was just [1:59:26] I was just reflecting on what Patrick just said I was thinking but there would be teachers, hopefully, and there would be students. [1:59:37] Yeah, to educate students, right? [1:59:39] I was just thinking the primary function of schools doesn't change, right? [1:59:43] To educate students. [1:59:48] Anything else? [1:59:53] It's okay, I got not. [1:59:53] Our students are going to change but they're also not. It's not like we're going to do anything. [2:00:12] So the last activity was talking about a governance lens. And it's it's aid a cough. And if people are feeling like digging into this, I'm okay. But really, this is a much more micro-low-low-low-low-low-low-low, [2:00:29] look at what we would need to do, whether superintendent would need to do evidence and such. [2:00:37] Do people feel like they want to dig into that part to this activity, right? [2:00:45] How are we doing? [2:00:50] Go ahead. [2:00:51] Go ahead. [2:00:52] Go ahead. [2:00:52] Go ahead. [2:00:55] How would digging into this work help policy and governance shake the end for at your next minute? [2:01:05] What this might do for us is help to put the language in place that will allow Patrick to interpret it in a way we need. [2:01:13] then I would want to consider it. I think we can great. I'm happy to do that. I just wanted to give you all the option. [2:01:25] One of the key components I think that maybe is implied in what you have listed there, but maybe not expressly is the notion that comes out I think in the district quality standard and measurable goals. [2:01:40] with, so you got goals, you know, around this area and you try to define it as squeal [2:01:48] basically. But you also set the metrics for that too. Yeah. And it's inevitably going [2:01:56] to be a think a little bit of, you know, back and forth. We're talking about what Google wants [2:02:02] right and there were ways that he could do what I think the board has stood. He feeds [2:02:10] to set some measurable goals. You know how to think about doing that in a way that doesn't [2:02:15] interfere with how the teachers are teaching and I can't stop. And then there's that layer of [2:02:22] the strategic plan. So you know my sort of vision is kind of iterative, you know that the board [2:02:30] It does, you know, I think to sense some metrics for those goals, but they should do that after consulting with Patrick and the teachers about, you know, what's the use of it, okay. [2:02:45] This two ways to go about either have it, I think, in the actual Anne's policy, those measures. [2:02:52] or theoretically, you know, you could, it is in this age of plan. You could have the board of [2:02:57] crew, this teaching plan, but this free-dature plan is going to have a lot more of things besides [2:03:03] service metrics, that is magical with objectives. [2:03:08] So, you know, I would favor having metrics in [2:03:12] our ins policy. But do so, make sure they're reasonable in terms of kind of space with the [2:03:21] That's just throwing it out, you know, maybe we should, we need to talk about that a little bit more. [2:03:26] Okay. [2:03:27] There's a couple of options there. [2:03:29] That's fine. [2:03:31] So using, sorry, I have to stand out by myself. [2:03:34] You're all right. [2:03:35] So using kind of the example, you put together a number of secrets starting point. [2:03:40] So I'm going to build off of that. [2:03:41] Yep. [2:03:42] So going down to evidence we need to do more growth measures, student voice, [2:03:47] class motivations and graduation that I'd like to also hear the teacher voice and [2:03:57] teacher [2:03:58] or support staff like I at the end. Okay, just to be clear, those were the end of one of the [2:04:19] other additions. Professional learning specifically around the staff without the thought process [2:04:28] on the floor. I think all of our staff members. I'm sorry, under Superintendent Samford, [2:04:33] because then I was found to run. [2:04:34] Yes, she. [2:04:36] Okay, question on the law. [2:04:38] There's a, I think there's an, [2:04:40] an item that is work conversation [2:04:43] to determine who has ownership of, [2:04:45] and that's staffing. [2:04:47] So it's staffing decisions. [2:04:54] I'm sorry, what do you think? [2:04:55] What do you mean? [2:04:57] So that needs to be able to, [2:04:58] how many teachers, [2:04:58] how many interventionists like who owns [2:05:01] or should or intend and decisions around the staff [2:05:04] that need to deliver on or talking about them? [2:05:06] It does sort of do not want to. [2:05:09] Now is the good thing that that's aren't taking them. [2:05:11] I know we've great that line. [2:05:13] That's kind of what I'm asking you. [2:05:14] Because it comes up from time to time. [2:05:16] I think this is an opportunity to process that outside of any controversial context and who owns that. [2:05:21] So when the controversy comes, we get to record a balance. [2:05:24] Probably we're going to maybe it's cork along and stopping the support of that work. [2:05:31] about right. Instructions, yeah. [2:05:37] So I think in the first instance, of course, [2:05:40] it's been been in this phase. [2:05:43] The love comes when it's very different, right? [2:05:52] And you know, we get a recommendation [2:05:54] and sometimes it talks about the how we deal with staff. [2:05:59] And because the budget is going to have an impact on it. [2:06:06] Like that. [2:06:07] know. I was thinking about it too because I think about a kind of two tracks going in my brain. [2:06:13] One is yes, it lives with a superintendent. I think that's clear, but I think it lives with a [2:06:18] superintendent. So long as it doesn't negate or go against what the board is set as priority. [2:06:25] And I want more thinking about the ends, which our our old ones didn't do anything for you in [2:06:30] terms of saying what our priorities are. And so staffing decisions could largely be made based on [2:06:36] me good sense in their staff at Britain's and all those things. But now I wonder a little bit [2:06:41] about that only if, if we say, in terms of our skillful and knowledgeable and us wanting [2:06:50] depths and breaths, but we start cutting sports and arts, are we providing depths and breaths? [2:06:58] And I would say no, right? So I, I am a little stuck because staffing is your decision [2:07:06] And so long as it doesn't go against that, and I, is that from the go, or is that something we need to say? [2:07:15] I think it's helpful to say it because it has been tricky at times. [2:07:22] Right. [2:07:22] And this board has made decisions about we will put these positions back in specifically. [2:07:30] The conversation outside of the context. I also think, you know, if you have been making the input you just gave about breath and death, [2:07:39] there are circumstances where, even if the money I'm out it, to experience staffing, to create greater depth and breadth, I go against other laws we just talked about, class size, et cetera. So, there are constraints outside of my control or necessarily your control that are going to drive some of this. [2:07:56] So to, you know, we might need to make a decision in the very near future, I'm nervous about it by 2020 as we talked about, that constricts rapid depth, because of the numbers of students and no class sizes and the economics, and then subsequent to that, a forthcoming class size last time. [2:08:18] So some of those issues, I mean, yeah, like sort of, sorry, no, I'm kind of kind of, I'm sorry for [2:08:26] me. [2:08:28] You got you. Yeah, I, I, I, what's hearing, hearing and probably a long time while I've been on the board that rationale. [2:08:39] And I think it would go a long way because I do think this mostly follows under operational, however, [2:08:50] As a board member, it would be so much clear and helpful to know the rationale and the thinking process that goes into some of those decisions and it might clarify how you got to or how those decisions are made and why they seem to be best her students. [2:09:14] I [2:09:17] have two possible quicks, so made a quick solution, if I have to be honest, if I have to be honest, [2:09:22] one could be in the superintendent, there would be the whole point of staffing, and then [2:09:28] raise something consistent with resource priorities, community accountability, and, if you think [2:09:35] they're all lost, which would sort of be a broad catch all of, like, yeah, you're in charge of staffing, [2:09:41] but even you're not fully in charge of staffing, because there are these pressures that you [2:09:47] way that might be simpler or more straightforward and still signal to the community the role that [2:09:51] the board has overall would be to just list staffing as superintendent loans and then have a [2:09:58] fifth bullet point on board loans which is like superintendent performance or district superintendent [2:10:04] and district performance which is to say that ultimately I want Patrick to be making the [2:10:11] choices, but in the end, that's not leading to the results that we want for our research [2:10:18] prioritization or community accountability. It's incumbent on the board to express that, [2:10:25] to find a new superintendent, but that is the role of the board. So I don't know which of those [2:10:31] is a more palatable approach today, so they say that, at its core, staffing, curie, and a story, [2:10:37] but in the end we have to assess how that actually worked or to say that thing and yes, [2:10:44] it is to be cognizant of them. Yeah. Yeah. So we own ownership. That's actually done. Yeah. [2:10:49] Well, that's it. To me, those are two ways of saying essentially the same thing. Your second [2:10:54] example was a very consistent policy governance. With what? With the policy governance. That's exactly [2:10:59] what policy governance says. Right. So maybe since we are policy governance, we're going to be [2:11:04] this more the way to write the suit in the ends. [2:11:08] And, to acknowledge that we have that responsibility. [2:11:11] How are we going to use this activity? [2:11:14] Well, we're going to end up, we're always sewing. [2:11:16] Well, hopefully to PNG, where we can start to really hone in on the language for the [2:11:21] ends, and then the next step would be, put that language back out to you to say, is this [2:11:26] what we meant? [2:11:27] And then Patrick can start to build interpretations around that language to then bring [2:11:31] to ask to say, is this what you men are we understanding each other? Does that work from that? [2:11:37] Because I don't have my executive limitations memorized. [2:11:42] Does that mention the staffing kind of [2:11:49] I don't think it really gets out names. Staffings specifically. It's an attempt to separate means and ends. [2:11:58] I just want to make sure we didn't have to consider that, too, we're not leaving, so contradicting. [2:12:04] No, I think within the policy governance framework, staffing decisions is clearly means, [2:12:09] and therefore clearly within the responsibility of the superintendent, as Mike was saying before, [2:12:13] and then accountability to the board for the ends, and generating outcomes that have been identified, because we're the board's role. [2:12:20] I think the tricky part is when it comes to the budget. [2:12:25] I always thought that that was something that the board was, and the budget is a lot at the [2:12:34] end. [2:12:35] You got all these factors, and it's a very practical, some more policy oriented, but that [2:12:41] whole aspect of resource out of it, it's really something that, you know, the superintendent [2:12:47] brings us a proposal, but then we own, you know, what, what, what we do with that, and sometimes [2:12:55] that's going to deal with the staffing issue. So I don't know how it says. You know, in the first [2:13:02] instance, in our day-to-day months and months, it's your bonding. But in terms of how we [2:13:10] fund, how how we deal with that budget and allocate things, you know, that's the board. So [2:13:16] inevitably it's going to be some extra overlap. I think the challenge, day-to-day months and months, [2:13:24] I think I agree that it is clear that the budget, and when I say the budget, the dollar amount, is the board's responsibility. [2:13:38] I think it gets very slippery when we get into the allocations, because allocations is means, and when the board has certainly been determined how we're going to achieve these ends, I'm no longer responsible for them. [2:13:48] And I don't think that's the position the board wants to be on. [2:13:50] I think the revision, though, if we say, our vision for our U.S.D., and Patrick and [2:13:57] Florida are going to take the dollars that we haven't make it happen, that's where we [2:14:01] would say there's fuel flow knowledgeable, and when we say that, we mean this. [2:14:06] And then if Patrick starts to say, well, I'm in a cut arts and whatever, then we say, [2:14:10] hold on a second. [2:14:11] That goes against what's still pull a knowledgeable net, that's just my example, but, right? [2:14:17] So if we're really specific about that here, right? [2:14:22] Scelf one knowledgeable to us means this and underneath that this is why, right? [2:14:27] Then when he brings us a budget that says we're cutting our in music here, [2:14:32] then we can say that's, you know, that's not what we meant. [2:14:35] And we can have that iterative process of that. [2:14:37] But that's why it's important to nail down like what we mean by scelf one, [2:14:42] I don't know what it looks like, what we mean to say. [2:14:45] So that when we go back, when PNG goes back and starts to type in, those variables, that [2:14:53] Patrick has a really good understanding of what the game. [2:14:58] So I don't disagree with you, Herr. [2:15:00] That I think the vision will be the resource allocation that we're talking about in terms of what are we finding important. [2:15:07] And then underneath that practical employing will need to make decisions about how money goes to support that. [2:15:14] So it's an interesting, it's collaborative and overlap. [2:15:18] I think it's collaborative, you know, that's the level of a lot of that. [2:15:22] I don't, I'm a little nervous about this, at least in terms of the budget, discussion, and those decisions. [2:15:31] I'm a little worried about making two black lines that are two black lines, because I think it is collaborative. [2:15:40] And I don't think it's just, you know, I'll do a snack. [2:15:44] I think it's a matter of the board, you talked to the board about, you know, this is what we've made me to do. [2:15:55] If you want to do live kind of issues, or if you want to do just, you know, people be tired. [2:16:04] You know, those, you bring that to us and we need to think about that. [2:16:08] So those are, those are allocation, those are budget allocation, [2:16:12] that's just also, we don't want to get too deep in the way [2:16:16] it's about, you know, allocation. [2:16:20] But I don't think it can taste just the bomb. [2:16:22] It's just back now. [2:16:23] No, I don't think that's really, really. [2:16:26] I understand where you come from. [2:16:28] Just that the gray becomes really tricky when it's contentious [2:16:31] in as budget time. [2:16:32] Yeah, I agree. [2:16:33] We have at that point. [2:16:34] names and it might just be a little intro to these and we need to just be very sensitive [2:16:43] about, you know, what we're thinking about is that it's a good job, but we also, you know, [2:16:51] when it comes time to setting the budget, you know, we're part of that process too, that's [2:16:58] my first offer. Not big day, but you know, it's got to be a conversation. [2:17:04] That's why this visioning work and thinking forward is super important, as we're thinking [2:17:09] about like what is education and what do we need to be providing? [2:17:14] I know you have some feelings [2:17:15] about my chair notes, but my points and they're really about how, if we're going to start thinking [2:17:23] about education long-term and what we mean to be providing then this sort of vision work will be [2:17:29] essential to getting there and I don't think we can continue to sit here and say we're going to [2:17:35] think about that and that's all we're going to show right we need to put some stuff on paper so we can [2:17:42] talk about that later. What I'm talking about is that there's a [2:17:46] relationship that is that. [2:17:51] Do the policies that are clear enough that they reflect, [2:17:57] you know, with the community once and what are almost want and what our expectations are [2:18:04] of, you know, I know, the CEO. That's why the end is so important. [2:18:07] That's why this, so let's, we got a little side back, that's saddening. [2:18:12] So, so I've got some good things down. [2:18:16] I think we'll bring it back to PNG, and then it'll come back to you in a different iteration, the ads policy. [2:18:22] And then for the work list, Patrick around interpretations. [2:18:26] One more evidence, we need to get rid of the mentioned benchmarks. [2:18:31] I like that as we have evidence that we need here. [2:18:37] really, it's really hard to look at our district's performance in a [2:18:43] factored tech, right? And so I think, however, we've, I don't know what those [2:18:46] bench ranks are, but I already isn't, but I hate to think about us without [2:18:51] thinking about the broader topics. [2:18:55] I'm wondering if we also need some [2:18:57] form of like community with evidence. [2:19:09] Great. [2:19:12] Can someone please fill up the board about your issue? [2:19:18] I'm going to open the floor for public comment. [2:19:22] Pardon? [2:19:26] I've got this over there. [2:19:27] Barb, you had your hand up too. [2:19:29] I want to make sure you, I don't overstep [2:19:32] if you were ready to speak. [2:19:37] But you're muted. [2:19:38] That's the right one. [2:19:40] Sorry, if I could sneak this in along with the Benchmark comments, I think if we look at [2:19:45] aligning with our higher education, whether it be vocational or collegic, the assessments [2:19:56] would guide our students to that next step versus not having that connection. [2:20:01] So I just wanted to throw that out. [2:20:05] Thanks. [2:20:06] Okay. [2:20:06] Thank you. [2:20:07] It's [2:20:11] good to see you all. [2:20:12] I hope you had a really restful summer. [2:20:15] I want to offer a suggestion of, there was some mention [2:20:21] of social emotional wellbeing. [2:20:25] I'd like to include grit as a consideration [2:20:28] and also think about how students critically [2:20:34] analyze resources and what their sense of factuality is. [2:20:38] we can't anticipate what the new technology will be in five years, but being able to establish [2:20:48] whether or not it's credible, [2:20:52] or to be able to trace the source of the information and [2:20:54] know whether or not it's reliable, I think is incredibly important in this changing technology [2:21:02] world. And I just my public comment is that I really appreciate the work that you're doing. [2:21:10] I want to think back on the last year as not just a lot of hard discussions but also an opportunity [2:21:19] when community came forward and really showed what we care about and there was dialogue and you [2:21:29] change some of the ways that you did meetings that enabled increased exchange of ideas and I [2:21:37] wanted to thank you for that and brought in additional resources like Rebecca Holcomb to inform [2:21:43] the process. I want to thank you for that. I think there were some really big wins. I know that [2:21:49] there were uncomfortable conversations but if we think about how we want to come together as a district [2:21:55] in a time of change, the opportunity that we have now that people have given their attention [2:22:02] are cut in, care about this work, is to build trust because that was rocked last year. [2:22:10] So I think having people's ear to the work that you're doing, it's a big opportunity to [2:22:19] and bring people in and help people in the community to feel informed and involved in the work that you're doing. [2:22:30] Thank you for the work that you're doing to create a charge for the Board and I share your goals [2:22:39] for progress and cost savings with merger and CSA and creating opportunities for improved delivery [2:22:48] of education. And I hope that we can think differently about the experience we had together [2:22:56] as a community. Thank you. [2:22:58] Thanks, Karen. [2:23:01] Any other public comment? [2:23:10] See any. [2:23:11] Mike, do you want any walk us? [2:23:13] Yeah, level of engagement for board numbers. [2:23:16] Higher level. [2:23:17] I don't know. [2:23:19] I don't know. [2:23:19] About agenda. [2:23:24] Relative. [2:23:26] You just, you know, it hasn't ended in minus the one, [2:23:29] I know the most special bite. [2:23:32] Sorry. [2:23:32] The [2:23:36] chair effectively serves the identity of the chair as a distribution of the board. [2:23:40] And so. [2:23:43] And is it chair, effect of impostering an additional culture regarding the fare of the deliberation, [2:23:49] full participation of members and ensuring the integrity of our processes. [2:23:53] Feel free for comments. [2:23:54] Any feedback for the chair? [2:23:57] I really like the expectations setting of we are ending at nine. [2:24:02] That was awesome. [2:24:02] Yep, they like until it also really like to push not having on [2:24:07] those ever, I don't know, it's hard as it is. [2:24:15] What we were with meeting. [2:24:19] I got what for now. [2:24:20] There you go. [2:24:21] We did a lot of great work on our ends. [2:24:29] Any suggestions for bringing future meetings? [2:24:34] I'm thinking of how we're this. [2:24:39] Just to really love that we could [2:24:41] challenge ourselves to be a little more action oriented. [2:24:45] And that, I think, where the making sure we're not on our separate cover things is those time. [2:24:50] Yeah. [2:24:55] Okay, so it's also... [2:24:58] It's related to, I mean, on your separate cover. [2:25:01] And then, also just having materials, graphs, and advance, sort of think, even, perv sending out that draft. [2:25:07] But if you have the draft sending that early, I think people can adjust it. [2:25:11] I haven't been helpful. [2:25:12] I didn't get it earlier. [2:25:13] Yeah. [2:25:14] Yeah. [2:25:14] I know, it was supposed to go a nice, specific, [2:25:16] could you say, wait, a proof of the truth? [2:25:18] It turns out. [2:25:20] So just in general, I think that all [2:25:22] people to be more action oriented because we'll come in with some [2:25:25] some thoughts. [2:25:26] Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. [2:25:29] And, frankly, what I say now is pretty late. [2:25:32] I only, if I, if I'm not, I'm just going to get it. [2:25:34] I'm just going to get it. [2:25:35] One time at a day, I'll be stopped. [2:25:37] And, yeah. [2:25:38] Well, in this particular meeting was tricky [2:25:40] because the agenda end of August, a few days after the retreat. [2:25:42] Yeah, it actually happens so that a little unusual turnaround time I just still points taken through all in a great way [2:25:51] Is it okay? [2:25:51] That's it. [2:25:52] Okay. [2:25:52] I'll wait. [2:25:55] Motion food journey. [2:25:56] So that's it. [2:25:58] Oh, thank you so much. [2:25:59] Do you want to sub-tember thing? [2:26:01] No, I can just send you some for that. [2:26:04] That's it for now. [2:26:05] I signed up for that. [2:26:07] Get a new control. [2:26:09] A lot of it going forward. [2:26:10] Oh great. [2:26:10] But I am kind of Danny Degason. [2:26:13] Seems the least I did there. [2:26:14] That will get down to a force of effort. [2:26:16] No, no one even went there. [2:26:18] I think we're all sitting there. [2:26:19] Yeah, you're most patient. [2:26:21] OK. [2:26:22] Well, it was the second. [2:26:23] Yeah. [2:26:23] All those in paper have a journey at 8.26. [2:26:26] You say, I'm I. [2:26:27] In your post. [2:26:29] And their sounds. [2:26:31] Thank you. [2:26:32] Just no matter the next meeting, [2:26:33] we'll have to wait for the second to the 29th. [2:26:35] We'll put something out.