1
00:07:15,000 --> 00:07:23,000
Morning, everyone! Looks like we do have a quorum. I think there might be some traffic, but we will get started.

2
00:07:23,000 --> 00:07:30,000
So, good morning, the December 12th Board of Directors meeting is called to order. First, I'd like to ask our interpreters to explain how to access interpretation.

3
00:07:30,000 --> 00:07:32,000
please go ahead.

4
00:07:32,000 --> 00:07:37,000
Announcement from interpreter. To use the interpretation feature, please scroll to the bottom of the Zoom screen.

5
00:07:37,000 --> 00:07:42,000
where the meeting controls are, click on the interpretation icon, World.

6
00:07:42,000 --> 00:07:49,000
and select English as your language. If you are joining through the Zoom mobile app, cell phone, tablet, etc.

7
00:07:49,000 --> 00:07:53,000
Please press the ellipsis, then Interpretation, and then choose your language.

8
00:07:53,000 --> 00:07:59,000
Finally, click on Mute Original Audio to not hear the original Spanish low in the background.

9
00:07:59,000 --> 00:08:07,000
Headsets are available for interpretation. If you are in the meeting room, please check out a headset from the receptionist in the lobby.

10
00:08:07,000 --> 00:08:15,000
Abizo por parte del interprete. Para ser uso residicio de interpretacion favor de desplaza la parte imperio de la pantalla de Zoom.

11
00:08:15,000 --> 00:08:21,000
donde apparece nos controlles.

12
00:08:21,000 --> 00:08:26,000
y se leccione Spanish espanol. andro laplicacion movil de Zum.

13
00:08:26,000 --> 00:08:33,000
suspensivos. Luego interpretacion y luego livioma.

14
00:08:33,000 --> 00:08:41,000
Sino de se escuchar en laudio origin. Por favor seleccione Mute Original Audio.

15
00:08:41,000 --> 00:08:49,000
silenciar audio. Contamos con algurales disponibles para el servicio de interpretacion.

16
00:08:49,000 --> 00:08:54,000
Si se encuentran azala de reunion favor de pedira auricular es con la recepcionista.

17
00:08:54,000 --> 00:08:58,000
en el vestibulo. Thank you.

18
00:08:58,000 --> 00:09:03,000
Thank you. I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge the land that we call home, the tribal nations of San Diego.

19
00:09:03,000 --> 00:09:14,000
have historically faced injustices. We acknowledge the harmony that existed between the land, nature, and its original peoples, who have since endured displacement, persecution, and systemic oppression.

20
00:09:14,000 --> 00:09:22,000
We pay our respect to the unceded territory and homelands of the 18 tribal nations in our region, the most in any county in the United States, from our… from four cultural groups.

21
00:09:22,000 --> 00:09:30,000
The Kumeyaidenyota, the seno, the copenyo, and the kobeya. This land has nourished, healed, protected, and embraced them for many generations in a relationship of balance.

22
00:09:30,000 --> 00:09:39,000
and Harmony, as members of the Sandin community, we acknowledge this legacy. We aspire to learn from Indigenous traditional knowledge and experiences in undoing the injustices of the past.

23
00:09:39,000 --> 00:09:43,000
Now, please stand and join me in the flag salute.

24
00:09:43,000 --> 00:09:59,000
Ready? We can. One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

25
00:09:59,000 --> 00:10:09,000
Oops. Okay, Michael, can you please double confirm quorum? We do have a quorum chair with the cities of El Cajon, Escondido, La Mesa, National City, Oceanside.

26
00:10:09,000 --> 00:10:15,000
Highway Invista absent. Okay, let's move on to non-agenda public comment. How many do we have?

27
00:10:15,000 --> 00:10:20,000
We have, uh, 3 in person, and if you are online, please raise your hand now.

28
00:10:20,000 --> 00:10:32,000
And… 3 online. Okay. So first, we'll have, uh, truth followed by, uh, Perita Javier.

29
00:10:32,000 --> 00:10:41,000
Hi, Rebecca, love the jacket. Can that be my Christmas gift, please? Alright, for the long-term board members who remember, apparently there's a new mayor in town.

30
00:10:41,000 --> 00:10:49,000
the mayor of Vonita? Technically, the mayor of Bonita.

31
00:10:49,000 --> 00:10:54,000
Your symptoms. If that's true, Kim, while I go back to the mayor's paycheck?

32
00:10:54,000 --> 00:10:59,000
Remember when I said it'd only take one board member to send this board into disarray? Manuela is it?

33
00:10:59,000 --> 00:11:09,000
With the scheme provided by Dem Chair William Rodriguez-Kennedy, once accused of rape, Manuela tried to drag Sanak backwards by playing the FAPO game with $500 million in federal dollars.

34
00:11:09,000 --> 00:11:13,000
Racist equity means projects to the favored few at the expense of the many.

35
00:11:13,000 --> 00:11:19,000
Union grifters love to say they're for the minority and the underserved, yet they're the first who selfishly throw projects.

36
00:11:19,000 --> 00:11:24,000
Uh, for them on the sacrificial altar of their anti-Trump games.

37
00:11:24,000 --> 00:11:30,000
Republicans and Independents, your yes vote gave leverage to the progressives' political theater. How stupid can you be?

38
00:11:30,000 --> 00:11:38,000
The DIE show had zero strategy and zero values, because so-called California values should not consist of breaking the law.

39
00:11:38,000 --> 00:11:46,000
I want to commend Bill and Chris for not playing political games with SANDAC's bylaw compliance with federal law that affects funding for SAN-AG projects.

40
00:11:46,000 --> 00:11:51,000
Because here's what progressive union games with our transat tax dollars already resulted in.

41
00:11:51,000 --> 00:11:57,000
From a 2022 Reader article entitled, When the Temecula Traffic Hits Escondido, quote.

42
00:11:57,000 --> 00:12:05,000
Senator Communications Director Gary Benelli says, we hope to have a robust transit system in place by 2030. You're going to have 5-minute frequencies.

43
00:12:05,000 --> 00:12:12,000
transit, competitive with the car. Caltrans says, we need alternate work hours where we're not all on the freeway at the same time.

44
00:12:12,000 --> 00:12:18,000
Two questionnaires solicit citizens' views. The first asks, what transportation improvements people think will work?

45
00:12:18,000 --> 00:12:20,000
The second ask, what are they willing to do?

46
00:12:20,000 --> 00:12:26,000
People will say, oh, public transportation, I'm willing to spend the money. Will you ride it? Well, no, end quote.

47
00:12:26,000 --> 00:12:32,000
Same bleep, different day. In over two decades, Sanek has literally achieved nothing but broken promises.

48
00:12:32,000 --> 00:12:37,000
So, colon stockings and bah humbug to that. And you know what else bothers me? It's Fitzgerald stays silent.

49
00:12:37,000 --> 00:12:57,000
Thank you. Next is Parita Javier, followed by Cesar Javier.

50
00:12:57,000 --> 00:13:03,000
Good morning. I am Purita Javier. Senior with medical condition.

51
00:13:03,000 --> 00:13:10,000
And a victim of ceramic skin toxicity. next door.

52
00:13:10,000 --> 00:13:19,000
I've begun residence in 1997. Cesar, my husband came in.

53
00:13:19,000 --> 00:13:24,000
2012. Uh, divine intervention.

54
00:13:24,000 --> 00:13:34,000
I knew nothing about clean air. Oxygen, nor about air pollution. I was merely good at knowing.

55
00:13:34,000 --> 00:13:45,000
shopping and sales are… it was. That made me aware of the threat of our health and safety.

56
00:13:45,000 --> 00:13:57,000
He being a teacher and a contractor. in his curiosity, I gave him the story of the business and about them.

57
00:13:57,000 --> 00:14:06,000
Friends, honor. a business that began 1984 and in treacles.

58
00:14:06,000 --> 00:14:11,000
on and off storytelling. My late husband.

59
00:14:11,000 --> 00:14:19,000
Watch. Child. I'd only get out of there is.

60
00:14:19,000 --> 00:14:25,000
Stay away from there. Also, I told and showed Cesar about the permanent.

61
00:14:25,000 --> 00:14:35,000
Fascinating of… Windows. I told Cesar that the owner has not gone to hire.

62
00:14:35,000 --> 00:14:42,000
A higher education on. bless his wife, a nurse.

63
00:14:42,000 --> 00:14:48,000
I also inform Cesar that my late husband was sailor.

64
00:14:48,000 --> 00:15:00,000
Um, in a Navy guy and treated. a calm, uh… the couple, like, son and daughter.

65
00:15:00,000 --> 00:15:11,000
A father figure of them. Thank you, your time has expired. Next is Cesar Javier, followed by Mike Bullock, online.

66
00:15:11,000 --> 00:15:17,000
A beer family wishes everyone. Merry Christmas.

67
00:15:17,000 --> 00:15:29,000
Prayerfully after our toil for 4 years. Kneeling… Bleeding and even shouting at our elected.

68
00:15:29,000 --> 00:15:37,000
11 officials of the city of San Diego.

69
00:15:37,000 --> 00:15:42,000
acetylene. by our Constitution.

70
00:15:42,000 --> 00:15:49,000
Working together. Perfect union, ensure justice, a system fair for everyone.

71
00:15:49,000 --> 00:15:54,000
Including Haber family. Domestic tranquility defense.

72
00:15:54,000 --> 00:16:00,000
Our stance. Councillor Rivera, Cheryl Mario is defense.

73
00:16:00,000 --> 00:16:08,000
To protect our community. to serve our community.

74
00:16:08,000 --> 00:16:14,000
For the totality of patrimony and posterity for all American sons and daughters.

75
00:16:14,000 --> 00:16:22,000
We beg of you. Something is wrong, and we are supposed to correct it.

76
00:16:22,000 --> 00:16:31,000
That's the tenets of what we call. The good thing that we will remember.

77
00:16:31,000 --> 00:16:39,000
An owner. Forever, because… This is the greatest.

78
00:16:39,000 --> 00:16:43,000
country in the world, and perhaps in few more years.

79
00:16:43,000 --> 00:16:51,000
in the universe. We stand here… To remind our elected officials.

80
00:16:51,000 --> 00:16:57,000
Don, when you. I mean, when you take office.

81
00:16:57,000 --> 00:17:02,000
You raise your right hand, not your lap. Not your feet.

82
00:17:02,000 --> 00:17:08,000
But you raise your heart and mind. And say to the Filipino, sorry.

83
00:17:08,000 --> 00:17:15,000
We just attended the Filipino meeting yesterday. To all Americans.

84
00:17:15,000 --> 00:17:19,000
I will protect the… Thank you, your time has expired.

85
00:17:19,000 --> 00:17:26,000
Next is Mike Bullock online, followed by the original draw.

86
00:17:26,000 --> 00:17:32,000
Yes, thank you. I am, uh… Mike Bullock, I live in Oceanside, and um.

87
00:17:32,000 --> 00:17:37,000
I… when I retired from Lockheed Martin after 36 years, my title was Senior Staff.

88
00:17:37,000 --> 00:17:47,000
systems engineer. So, uh, Honorable chair and members of the board, I'm honored to speak with you this morning, and my topic is, uh, climate.

89
00:17:47,000 --> 00:17:52,000
change literacy. And, um, I'm gonna follow along with, uh.

90
00:17:52,000 --> 00:17:59,000
the way that is defined in the California Democratic Party platform in the education plank.

91
00:17:59,000 --> 00:18:05,000
And you'll find it there, and it says, uh, you have to know, um, why we have the problem and how bad.

92
00:18:05,000 --> 00:18:15,000
it could get. Um, and uh… Also, you need to know, um… Uh, the difference between climate stabilization and, uh.

93
00:18:15,000 --> 00:18:25,000
Uh, climate, uh, destabilization. Uh, and then also, uh, the, uh, requirements that the climate scientists have given us.

94
00:18:25,000 --> 00:18:30,000
Uh, so we can achieve the desired outcome, which is stabilizing the climate and avoiding.

95
00:18:30,000 --> 00:18:37,000
destabilization. Um, and then also the mitigation measures are there.

96
00:18:37,000 --> 00:18:39,000
Um, so I don't have a lot of time.

97
00:18:39,000 --> 00:18:45,000
But, um, it's really based on the NOAA plots.

98
00:18:45,000 --> 00:18:53,000
And, uh, the 800,000 year plots, so there's a ton of science there, that's 800,000 years going back in time.

99
00:18:53,000 --> 00:19:01,000
It shows the atmospheric CO2. And it shows the temperature anomaly, which is what the temperature of our atmosphere is relative to what it would.

100
00:19:01,000 --> 00:19:07,000
should be, uh, without, uh, climate change. And, you know, we're very close to 1.5 degrees centigrade now.

101
00:19:07,000 --> 00:19:26,000
Uh, and, uh… The plot, the other plot, the normal plot, is just 1,000 years, where you zero in on it, and it's very, very clear that it's the, um… our Industrial revolution. That's where our atmospheric CO2 climbed from where it should be, 280 parts per million, to 420.

102
00:19:26,000 --> 00:19:31,000
And the temperature anomaly that corresponds to that is 15 degrees centigrade, so we are in a lot of danger. Thank you.

103
00:19:31,000 --> 00:19:42,000
Thank you, your time has expired. Next, his original draw, followed by a last public comment, Casey?

104
00:19:42,000 --> 00:20:00,000
Good morning, as you guys are here for the last one of these meetings for the year and before the holidays, as you are going to be going and spending your holidays, whatever holiday that is, with your families, and I bet it's going to be a really, really beautiful time.

105
00:20:00,000 --> 00:20:17,000
Well, I would like you to think about, while you're with your family, all of the many children who have been ripped apart from their families in the county by the child trafficking organization known as CFWB, Child Family Wellbeing.

106
00:20:17,000 --> 00:20:23,000
Um, or, you know, people like to call it CPS. In fact, the County of San Diego was in a documentary.

107
00:20:23,000 --> 00:20:33,000
That has, um, gone viral, called Never in America. I suggest that you guys watch it, um, but it talks about this, um.

108
00:20:33,000 --> 00:20:40,000
business that is a conveyor belt to get children through the system after ASFA came in in 1997.

109
00:20:40,000 --> 00:20:49,000
through Bill and Hillary Clinton. to fast-track adoptions with children, and it's very lucrative, taking Title IV funding.

110
00:20:49,000 --> 00:21:01,000
Because states used to have to actually pay when they took it apart from their families, and they did it only when there was actual abuse, not to create cases because it's a lucrative business.

111
00:21:01,000 --> 00:21:06,000
But I want you guys to think about, how do you think it would feel for your child?

112
00:21:06,000 --> 00:21:11,000
If when they were seeing you and begging to go home with you.

113
00:21:11,000 --> 00:21:16,000
A social worker said. Isn't that sweet?

114
00:21:16,000 --> 00:21:27,000
Isn't that sweet? Isn't it? Isn't that horrific to have to hear when you're begging to go home and there's no reason for you to be separated from your family?

115
00:21:27,000 --> 00:21:35,000
Except for money. And all the while, the county is covering up sexual abuse, so you can't go home.

116
00:21:35,000 --> 00:21:46,000
I want you to think about what it's like being with your families and what it would be like if you weren't allowed to for absolutely no reason at all, but for profit.

117
00:21:46,000 --> 00:21:51,000
Our last public comment is Casey. If you are online, please be sure to raise your hand at the start of an item, please.

118
00:21:51,000 --> 00:21:54,000
Last other common Casey, go ahead.

119
00:21:54,000 --> 00:22:02,000
Hi, my name's Casey, I'm a high school student, and this morning I had to ask my AP human geography teacher if I could leave class early to give this comment.

120
00:22:02,000 --> 00:22:09,000
He asked, why do you need to give public comment during class? And I told him that SANDAG is jeopardizing my future.

121
00:22:09,000 --> 00:22:16,000
An AP Human Geography, one of the first things you learn in the urban planning unit is that widening highways doesn't fix congestion.

122
00:22:16,000 --> 00:22:22,000
It creates induced demand. You add lanes, people drive more, and then traffic comes back and emissions increase.

123
00:22:22,000 --> 00:22:29,000
So what I… when I see a plan proposing over 90 miles of new managed lanes costing more than $2 billion.

124
00:22:29,000 --> 00:22:35,000
It feels like we're choosing to ignore what decades of evidence, and frankly, what we teach teenagers already tell us.

125
00:22:35,000 --> 00:22:42,000
I do want to thank everyone for extending the Youth Opportunity Pass, and as a student who depends on transit, that decision genuinely matters.

126
00:22:42,000 --> 00:22:58,000
This plan still centers highway expansion, even through. SANDAG's own modeling labels, these projects as high VMT, to compensate, the plan leaves heavily on rapid bus routes, but we already have proof that rapid and name-only rhinos don't work.

127
00:22:58,000 --> 00:23:05,000
Take the rap at 2.15. When it launched in 2014, it was supposed to be faster and more reliable than the route replaced.

128
00:23:05,000 --> 00:23:08,000
Today, it takes 6 minutes longer than when it opened.

129
00:23:08,000 --> 00:23:16,000
on-time performance has dropped by about 10 points, and ridership is down 33%, even though overall trans ridership has largely recovered.

130
00:23:16,000 --> 00:23:24,000
It's not a demand problem, it's a design failure. Without dedicated lanes and strong transit signal priority, buses are just stuck in traffic.

131
00:23:24,000 --> 00:23:36,000
I'm also deeply concerned with how little attention the purple line gets for South County is meant to be a transit lifeline, and with SB79 enabling more housing near transit ridership potential is being underestimated.

132
00:23:36,000 --> 00:23:43,000
Also, removing references to NATCO's safe bike infrastructure guidelines sends the wrong message to young people like me.

133
00:23:43,000 --> 00:23:50,000
I want to be really clear at the end here, I'm genuinely begging you for my future and my generation's future, you are not powerless.

134
00:23:50,000 --> 00:24:00,000
All it takes is one of you to step up and call a weighted vote. You have the power to pass a regional plan that works for everyone.

135
00:24:00,000 --> 00:24:08,000
Thank you, your time has expired. That concludes our non-agenda public comment, Chair, and for the record, the cities of National City, Oceanside, and Poway are present.

136
00:24:08,000 --> 00:24:14,000
Very good, thank you so much. We'll go to knowledge and member comments, and I see Ann Fox from Caltrans on the board.

137
00:24:14,000 --> 00:24:21,000
Good morning! Um, so tis the season for holiday wishes, and retirement's usually around this time of year.

138
00:24:21,000 --> 00:24:26,000
So, I just wanted to announce that Karen Jewell.

139
00:24:26,000 --> 00:24:37,000
Right here behind me, will be retiring this month, um, with over 36 years with Caltrans, probably a little bit more of that, because she did start with us as a student assistant.

140
00:24:37,000 --> 00:24:42,000
She's been our hydraulics engineer, our traffic engineering and analysis lead.

141
00:24:42,000 --> 00:24:48,000
project manager in North County Corridors, working on State Routes 76, 78.

142
00:24:48,000 --> 00:24:58,000
Then, as a shared Caltrans, SANDAG corridor director for our central corridors, working on our routes 805, 52, 15.

143
00:24:58,000 --> 00:25:03,000
And as a good partner to many of you and your agencies around this dais.

144
00:25:03,000 --> 00:25:29,000
So, she was part of my lunch crew for probably well over a decade. One of the nicest, level-headed, active people you'll ever know, and someone will all miss in retirement. So, thank you, Karen, for making Caltrans and SANDAG better.

145
00:25:29,000 --> 00:25:33,000
Lovely tribute. Thank you. Sounds like you made your mark.

146
00:25:33,000 --> 00:25:39,000
All right, I have a few comments. This is the final meeting of the year, so I want to thank you all so much.

147
00:25:39,000 --> 00:25:47,000
And for stat… to staff for your engagement and hard work throughout this very, very busy year. I also want to wish everyone a wonderful holiday season.

148
00:25:47,000 --> 00:25:51,000
And I do look forward to working with you all next year together.

149
00:25:51,000 --> 00:25:57,000
As a quick reminder, the Audit Committee Chair is conducting the annual performance evaluation of SANDAG's independence.

150
00:25:57,000 --> 00:26:03,000
Performance Auditor. We received a request to fill out that questionnaire December 2, which.

151
00:26:03,000 --> 00:26:08,000
I somehow missed, um, got the reminder the other day and filled it out. So if you.

152
00:26:08,000 --> 00:26:15,000
please fill it out if you haven't already. There are QR codes taped to the desks in front of you, and also you have an email in your email box.

153
00:26:15,000 --> 00:26:19,000
Um, so please fill that out. Your feedback is important.

154
00:26:19,000 --> 00:26:26,000
Since our last meeting, Vice Chair LaCava and I had the opportunity to meet with the leadership of the Southern California Tribal Chairman's Association.

155
00:26:26,000 --> 00:26:37,000
They generously hosted, and we appreciated the chance. to share, um, and discuss priorities, strengthen our working relationship, and create some steps for ongoing discussions.

156
00:26:37,000 --> 00:26:46,000
I also met with Senator Webber Pearson to discuss housing policy, including SB79, and thanking her for her.

157
00:26:46,000 --> 00:26:58,000
non-support of SB79 and discussing a number of other issues, including border region resiliency and the ongoing need for SB375 reform.

158
00:26:58,000 --> 00:27:01,000
That's it, and I'll turn it over to Mario for his update.

159
00:27:01,000 --> 00:27:07,000
Thank you, Chair. And Karen, congratulations. We grew together in Caltrans.

160
00:27:07,000 --> 00:27:15,000
So, uh, I cannot envision, uh. not having you as a corridor director there, so we really, really, uh.

161
00:27:15,000 --> 00:27:21,000
a big hug, and again, you know, we grew 3 decades together in the agency.

162
00:27:21,000 --> 00:27:34,000
Um, we… yesterday, we had, um… Uh, city managers roundtable that we are starting to host here. We really appreciate those city managers who could make it.

163
00:27:34,000 --> 00:27:45,000
Uh, we had a very robust conversation of what's coming up next year, as well as city managers provided us some recommendations of how we should be working with the working groups.

164
00:27:45,000 --> 00:27:51,000
So we will be bringing up those ideas, we will bring them forward to the executive committee.

165
00:27:51,000 --> 00:27:55,000
I really encourage all of you to encourage your city managers.

166
00:27:55,000 --> 00:28:01,000
to come to this roundtable. It's… it's a good forum where we discuss.

167
00:28:01,000 --> 00:28:11,000
ongoing issues, upcoming grants, and we strategize. Uh, to make the discussions here as well as in the PACs more meaningful.

168
00:28:11,000 --> 00:28:20,000
So I really appreciate that. Also, this week, I participated at the California Infrastructure Development Conference in LA.

169
00:28:20,000 --> 00:28:26,000
Uh, with me was Komi Ajitsu, the SCAC executive Director, and we were together in a panel.

170
00:28:26,000 --> 00:28:32,000
talking about what we see in the future and how we collaborate in Southern California.

171
00:28:32,000 --> 00:28:44,000
Between SCAC and SANDAC. We cover, um… All Southern California, and a good chunk of the majority of the population of California.

172
00:28:44,000 --> 00:28:50,000
So, between both organizations, we can impact. quite a bit, as well as nationwide.

173
00:28:50,000 --> 00:28:55,000
Also, earlier this week, even though it feels way back.

174
00:28:55,000 --> 00:29:00,000
Uh, we took a really fast trip, a 23-hour trip to Washington, D.C.

175
00:29:00,000 --> 00:29:07,000
to meet with the Federal Highway Administrator, Mr. Sheen McCaster, as well as with Mexican Ambassador.

176
00:29:07,000 --> 00:29:14,000
in the U.S. Esteban Moctezuma. Um, with federal highways, we discuss all-time HIEs.

177
00:29:14,000 --> 00:29:25,000
And understanding some regulations that federal highways. has been directing us on it, and that could open… hopefully open the possibility.

178
00:29:25,000 --> 00:29:33,000
more partnerships, as well as with Ambassador Moctezuma, we discussed the project, but we also discussed the Tijuana River issues.

179
00:29:33,000 --> 00:29:42,000
And how do we more partner on improving not just the Tijuana issue, but all the environmental issues across the border.

180
00:29:42,000 --> 00:29:50,000
Uh, that's why we're working on the sustainability. plan that we're working for that, for the border region.

181
00:29:50,000 --> 00:29:57,000
on project updates. We had a huge accomplishment. The first climate action roadmap.

182
00:29:57,000 --> 00:30:01,000
for San Diego region was completed and submitted to EPA.

183
00:30:01,000 --> 00:30:05,000
Why is it important for then your cities can go and.

184
00:30:05,000 --> 00:30:14,000
take that plan and be eligible for funding because it's a regional plan, so you can take it as yours also in your cities. If you don't have that.

185
00:30:14,000 --> 00:30:29,000
in your cities, it's an option. But that's pretty big, because we… For those smaller cities who may not have the bandwidth to do it, you can adopt the ones from SANDAC, and that allows you to pursue funding for EPA.

186
00:30:29,000 --> 00:30:34,000
and other related subjects. So we really, really appreciate that.

187
00:30:34,000 --> 00:30:44,000
We're restoring the nesting habitat. And we're really working on that project. We really want to think.

188
00:30:44,000 --> 00:30:50,000
Santee. And the mayor for, uh, Mayor Mento for helping us.

189
00:30:50,000 --> 00:30:56,000
CalGrants in SANDAC, and Caltrans is leading this effort on the SR52.

190
00:30:56,000 --> 00:31:02,000
operational improvements, environmental document, so thank you for allowing us that.

191
00:31:02,000 --> 00:31:10,000
This is the… what you consider beginning of conversations to start moving the 52 into reality.

192
00:31:10,000 --> 00:31:16,000
those improvements, so… you know, it's a journey, and Mayormento is helping Caltrans and ourselves.

193
00:31:16,000 --> 00:31:20,000
on walking that journey, so thank you on that.

194
00:31:20,000 --> 00:31:27,000
on the audit update, um, we're really focusing and closing out the 2018 TrustNet recommendations.

195
00:31:27,000 --> 00:31:34,000
that were submitted to ITOC. Um, it was very concerning to me that we were.

196
00:31:34,000 --> 00:31:39,000
A decade behind in some recommendations, some of them from 2015. So.

197
00:31:39,000 --> 00:31:48,000
We needed to check the box out of the 2015, now we're going to try to check the box of 2018, as we can get closer to just have.

198
00:31:48,000 --> 00:31:55,000
Not a decade, but hopefully months or maybe a year to get to some recommendations.

199
00:31:55,000 --> 00:32:02,000
So we really appreciate that. Um, today you will be hearing, uh, the finance audit assessment.

200
00:32:02,000 --> 00:32:10,000
Uh, that's going to be really helpful, and I'll talk more about that, but we're also doing -- going to be launching internally in the agency.

201
00:32:10,000 --> 00:32:18,000
In HR department assessment, and we are already working on a toll ops organizational assessment. The information.

202
00:32:18,000 --> 00:32:22,000
has been very, very good. Uh, for us, that will help us.

203
00:32:22,000 --> 00:32:31,000
reinvent our toll operations department. conference, we're really exploring on different types of partnerships.

204
00:32:31,000 --> 00:32:44,000
So we can also align it with that reorganization of our toll department, also reorganize how we manage toll-ops. So we will have more information on that shortly.

205
00:32:44,000 --> 00:32:48,000
construction updates. There were some concerns about the Omarf blobs.

206
00:32:48,000 --> 00:33:08,000
a big dike that was built there, so we're going to coordinate with the mayor, with all the department, with the… City Manager, and… Again, it's a journey. The mitigation for the Del Mar Bluffs is a complex mitigation that was imposed to us by Coastal Commission.

207
00:33:08,000 --> 00:33:15,000
So, we're gonna work and try to balance. what Coastal wants, what the city wants, what the transit agency wants.

208
00:33:15,000 --> 00:33:23,000
And we're gonna try to get… like I said, a balance and all that. So we're meeting also with the Coastal Commission director.

209
00:33:23,000 --> 00:33:29,000
to try to figure that out next month. We have begun construction on the west.

210
00:33:29,000 --> 00:33:34,000
Washington Street and Mission Valley bikeways. So hopefully that will be moving forward.

211
00:33:34,000 --> 00:33:40,000
And finally, you know, I want to mention that our offices will be closed.

212
00:33:40,000 --> 00:33:44,000
to the public on December 25th and January 1st.

213
00:33:44,000 --> 00:33:56,000
Our toll operations customer center will close. at noon, around noon on the 24th to allow those employees to go home, and then we will be closed also on the 25th.

214
00:33:56,000 --> 00:34:05,000
And on the 1st. And I really want to wish you a happy holidays to all of you, and thank you for all the support during this calendar year.

215
00:34:05,000 --> 00:34:10,000
Thanks so much. Uh, Mayor Gastelin. Yes, thank you.

216
00:34:10,000 --> 00:34:16,000
Executive Director, thank you for mentioning the Del Mar Bluffs. I wanted to invite the board members here.

217
00:34:16,000 --> 00:34:19,000
to come to Del Mar sometime over the next few weeks.

218
00:34:19,000 --> 00:34:25,000
and walk the beach along the bottom of the bluff, see the over one mile of new seawall that's in.

219
00:34:25,000 --> 00:34:29,000
That is in between the beach and the bluff.

220
00:34:29,000 --> 00:34:36,000
And I also wanted to remind us. that the original cost of this project was $58 million in 2020.

221
00:34:36,000 --> 00:34:40,000
It's now estimated that it will wind up totaling $88 million.

222
00:34:40,000 --> 00:34:46,000
With $62 million spent so far. So, an extra $30 million has gone into this project.

223
00:34:46,000 --> 00:34:55,000
In June of 2022. The Coastal Commission approved the project conditionally. One of the conditions is actively, vigorously pursuing.

224
00:34:55,000 --> 00:35:00,000
And accomplishing getting the railroad tracks off the bluff into an inland location.

225
00:35:00,000 --> 00:35:04,000
So that's one. And the other was beach access.

226
00:35:04,000 --> 00:35:12,000
So, we're going to be asking for transparency and access to the construction plans that the Coastal Commission reviewed.

227
00:35:12,000 --> 00:35:17,000
The exhibits apparently weren't, you know, they showed a 4-foot-wide culvert.

228
00:35:17,000 --> 00:35:21,000
And the location at 11th Street, and what was built was 12 feet wide, 6 feet deep.

229
00:35:21,000 --> 00:35:25,000
At the 6 feet deep, 6 feet wide at the bottom.

230
00:35:25,000 --> 00:35:28,000
Yeah, it's a very large cement structure that stretches.

231
00:35:28,000 --> 00:35:32,000
Two blocks along the top of the bluff in Del Mar. It was a surprise.

232
00:35:32,000 --> 00:35:37,000
So, let's try to be more transparent and have no more surprises.

233
00:35:37,000 --> 00:35:42,000
Okay, we now move on to the consent calendar. Michael, do we have any public comments on consent?

234
00:35:42,000 --> 00:35:47,000
Yes, if you are online, please raise your hand now. We have two in person.

235
00:35:47,000 --> 00:35:55,000
That's truth, followed by Caesar.

236
00:35:55,000 --> 00:36:04,000
103.1, the remnants of a Dead Meeting should be admitted to say that crybaby William Rotigers Kennedy is the chair of the San Diego Democratic Party. For transparency.

237
00:36:04,000 --> 00:36:15,000
And 3.2 says that the Tribal Transportation program is considered as amended into the RTIP. Does that mean the tribal projects are automatically given to the Building Construction Trades Council if they cost over $5 million?

238
00:36:15,000 --> 00:36:21,000
Out of 3.3, I'd like to know why Loh Sun is so concerned about Form 700s, what corruption is going on there?

239
00:36:21,000 --> 00:36:28,000
Item 3.4, new to $40 million to UN Global Compact Partner Jacobs Project Management for the Lagoon double tracking.

240
00:36:28,000 --> 00:36:34,000
Also, there's a misspelling on the word qualification in the second paragraph, on the second page of this item.

241
00:36:34,000 --> 00:36:39,000
I don't 3.5, I do not approve of the $2.5 million investment in Nefarious Novartis.

242
00:36:39,000 --> 00:36:47,000
And then 3.6, if we follow the DIE nonsense that Lauren voted for, then I don't think that wealthy La Mesa should get a pass on their late financial report.

243
00:36:47,000 --> 00:36:52,000
In fact needs to provide a more detailed explanation as to why they need an extension.

244
00:36:52,000 --> 00:36:56,000
On a 3.7, here's a public transit needs story.

245
00:36:56,000 --> 00:37:04,000
On the trolley ride from. An abusive mansurder arguing with a woman. He suddenly grabbed the dog out of her arms and threw it like it was trash.

246
00:37:04,000 --> 00:37:17,000
Even worse, she didn't care. There was zero security able to respond to animal abuse, and that is a prime traumatic example of what you all voted to spend $6.5 million a year for children to experience.

247
00:37:17,000 --> 00:37:29,000
For the millionth time, make public transit safety an immediate priority, or shut up about reducing VMT and GHGs, because the only safe mode of transportation is by private car.

248
00:37:29,000 --> 00:37:36,000
I had a 3.8. Dona Escondido's unaffordable stack-and-pack trust fund with no required transit, and likely no parking either.

249
00:37:36,000 --> 00:37:41,000
Noto Bikeway for Lemon Grove, which doesn't even have fixed streets or sidewalks.

250
00:37:41,000 --> 00:37:45,000
And why did the LG only have to put up $1,000 in matching funds?

251
00:37:45,000 --> 00:37:50,000
Why did IB put up $0 for the stupid cap update?

252
00:37:50,000 --> 00:37:56,000
And for Sinex Excels, staff needs to more closely triple-check their mistaken work before releasing it, especially when it deals with who gets funding.

253
00:37:56,000 --> 00:38:01,000
How long is this agency gonna keep messing up, is my question.

254
00:38:01,000 --> 00:38:14,000
Next is Caesar, followed by Mike Bullock online.

255
00:38:14,000 --> 00:38:27,000
Advocacy for… Community life.

256
00:38:27,000 --> 00:38:35,000
Processes 3.1 to 3.8. We have to lump this, because there are.

257
00:38:35,000 --> 00:38:51,000
a chain. And… The strength of this change is the weakest link in all this process.

258
00:38:51,000 --> 00:38:57,000
Did we adequately. Prepared for this.

259
00:38:57,000 --> 00:39:04,000
toilsome effort. For example, amending.

260
00:39:04,000 --> 00:39:10,000
Rules and laws that are vintage. Not fitted.

261
00:39:10,000 --> 00:39:16,000
to the call of times. I say this because.

262
00:39:16,000 --> 00:39:31,000
the mission of SANDAG. To be specific, it's all about… Man's survivability as far as mobility and transportation. Without this.

263
00:39:31,000 --> 00:39:37,000
You know the answer.

264
00:39:37,000 --> 00:39:45,000
The changing time. Calls for changing roles.

265
00:39:45,000 --> 00:39:52,000
The call of time, state and condition. requires us to be vigilant and watchful.

266
00:39:52,000 --> 00:39:56,000
This is all about all these processes here today.

267
00:39:56,000 --> 00:40:03,000
And we share with you. We support this, and we encourage you thinkers.

268
00:40:03,000 --> 00:40:09,000
Including the public, of course. It's not your… jurisdiction alone.

269
00:40:09,000 --> 00:40:18,000
Because you never exist without us. Hear from us! Hear from you, and we learn together. Your time has expired.

270
00:40:18,000 --> 00:40:25,000
We have 4 comments online. That's Mike Bullock, followed by the original draw.

271
00:40:25,000 --> 00:40:34,000
Yeah, thank you very much. Uh, Mike Bullock and Oceanside, I guess I introduced myself before, and uh… So, Honorable Chair and members.

272
00:40:34,000 --> 00:40:42,000
Uh, I would like to, uh, resp… respectfully request that you consider removing, uh, 3.5.

273
00:40:42,000 --> 00:40:52,000
for discussion. Um… I really appreciated hearing the, uh… Uh, statement by the director, and, uh.

274
00:40:52,000 --> 00:40:57,000
I think the director, I agree with everything the director is saying in 3.5.

275
00:40:57,000 --> 00:41:01,000
However, I think we need to discuss what is not going on.

276
00:41:01,000 --> 00:41:09,000
And that is that, um, SANDAG is not. asking, uh, Sacramento, our legislators.

277
00:41:09,000 --> 00:41:14,000
Uh, our governor to please implement the CARB scoping Plan.

278
00:41:14,000 --> 00:41:21,000
And the reason that the scoping plan must be implemented as soon as possible is because it is.

279
00:41:21,000 --> 00:41:27,000
California's official plan to stabilize the climate and achieve SB 32, which is a state law.

280
00:41:27,000 --> 00:41:36,000
Uh, and, uh, corresponds to, uh. what the IPC is doing and corresponds to what the climate scientists tell us we must do.

281
00:41:36,000 --> 00:41:40,000
by 2030. We don't have a lot of choice about this.

282
00:41:40,000 --> 00:41:46,000
Uh, the climate scientists are not wrong, and climate, uh… destabilization is something.

283
00:41:46,000 --> 00:41:51,000
We need to avoid. And, uh, so we need to ask.

284
00:41:51,000 --> 00:41:59,000
the state of California to implement. The mitigation measures, which are in that plan and will reduce, uh.

285
00:41:59,000 --> 00:42:06,000
VMT by 25% by 2030. They didn't want to tell us that 25%, but it's just math.

286
00:42:06,000 --> 00:42:18,000
I have worked this problem myself, and they're in the ballpark. They're not, uh… off base at all. I did this 10 years ago, and I got 32% reduction by 2030.

287
00:42:18,000 --> 00:42:27,000
their assumptions are probably a little more updated than mine. Electric cars are far superior technology, and so they're probably.

288
00:42:27,000 --> 00:42:32,000
a little closer, but 25% is a lot. We have to get those mitigation measures. Thank you.

289
00:42:32,000 --> 00:42:40,000
Next is original draw, followed by phone number ending in 1415.

290
00:42:40,000 --> 00:42:47,000
Until you guys can maintain the infrastructure that we already have, you shouldn't be looking into things like double tracking.

291
00:42:47,000 --> 00:43:02,000
and whatnot. I mean, you know. Public transit is not beneficial to people. It takes longer, and it's just more of a pain in the butt. You actually are putting children in danger by not having security on there and having them ride for free unaccompanied.

292
00:43:02,000 --> 00:43:05,000
And when we sit here and we're talking about.

293
00:43:05,000 --> 00:43:10,000
You know, reducing GHGs and all of that, and we don't even look into.

294
00:43:10,000 --> 00:43:15,000
what Mexico, uh, the cars that are coming from there, and you're, you know, penalizing.

295
00:43:15,000 --> 00:43:22,000
our own communities for things, and, you know, potentially road usage charges are coming in, you should be implementing that.

296
00:43:22,000 --> 00:43:26,000
For people that are not having the same regulations that we do.

297
00:43:26,000 --> 00:43:43,000
Um, to ensure that you're gonna reduce those, otherwise you guys are just hypocrites, because you're allowing things to happen from people outside of our nation to come in, and then… And basically, the people that live here are punished for it, because we're never going to meet the goals that you want, because all of it's BS anyway.

298
00:43:43,000 --> 00:43:49,000
But your smart growth incentive program. And the way that you guys talk about projects and.

299
00:43:49,000 --> 00:43:57,000
You know, aligning them with growth principles and. You know, that are compact, transit-accessible, pedestrian-friendly.

300
00:43:57,000 --> 00:44:07,000
and environmentally responsible, you know, reduces. traffic congestion, you basically are putting people in these densely populated areas.

301
00:44:07,000 --> 00:44:20,000
That are gonna be, you know, where people are gonna be tracked and traced, you're gonna have to walk and bike everywhere. I mean, if you guys want something to work, because nothing you guys do is really beneficial to the people, why don't you do it first?

302
00:44:20,000 --> 00:44:31,000
Prove to us that it works, and then potentially ask us if we can want our money to be spent on that, and then we'll decide. Instead, you guys just push the United Nations agenda.

303
00:44:31,000 --> 00:44:45,000
And you don't care what the people in the communities have to say, you don't look into the fact that you're creating a huge fire hazard and potential death for a bunch of people the way that you're planning things out.

304
00:44:45,000 --> 00:44:57,000
Thank you. Next is phone number 1415, followed by phone number 8813.

305
00:44:57,000 --> 00:45:11,000
Oh, Lord, um… On the transnet smart group stuff, uh… So, does climate action stuff is funded by the Transcendent Extension?

306
00:45:11,000 --> 00:45:23,000
Our money going to places other than TransNet? Um, and I was just reminded that climate predictions often are based on.

307
00:45:23,000 --> 00:45:30,000
One or two. There are several particular regions.

308
00:45:30,000 --> 00:45:40,000
They're not applicable to all. To spread the divergent CAP projects with different goals is wasted money.

309
00:45:40,000 --> 00:45:47,000
It is interesting and instructive that most of the initiatives listed in the appendix.

310
00:45:47,000 --> 00:45:56,000
are not CAP-oriented. The same fold that you won't find as needed as affordable housing costs.

311
00:45:56,000 --> 00:46:01,000
when they'll have 3 million left to give initiative such fees.

312
00:46:01,000 --> 00:46:14,000
I also think it is unfair to deny. Funding completed the Escondido project simply because it relies on existing transportation infrastructure.

313
00:46:14,000 --> 00:46:21,000
I've been developing new transportation infrastructure. This is press front.

314
00:46:21,000 --> 00:46:30,000
Which means that not all of the individual housing projects or access routes are in planning at this time.

315
00:46:30,000 --> 00:46:38,000
Uh, the, um… And the same contract, uh.

316
00:46:38,000 --> 00:46:46,000
I'm glad to hear that there was a robust competitive bidding process for the construction management.

317
00:46:46,000 --> 00:46:52,000
Uh, doesn't look quite the constructability review bids were competitive.

318
00:46:52,000 --> 00:46:56,000
With two bidders, one of whom was locked out.

319
00:46:56,000 --> 00:47:02,000
Our reviews for Jacobs are mixed with good work life.

320
00:47:02,000 --> 00:47:03,000
Thank you, your time has expired. Our last public comment is phone number ending in 8813.

321
00:47:03,000 --> 00:47:13,000
Work-life balance…

322
00:47:13,000 --> 00:47:27,000
Controller here. So, um, because everything is connected, and um… Because everything we're seeing at the local level, from transportation policy to digital systems to financial restructuring.

323
00:47:27,000 --> 00:47:33,000
Uh, is connected. to a much larger pattern. Many people shrugged off.

324
00:47:33,000 --> 00:47:37,000
Uh, or didn't think twice when the penny was taken out of production.

325
00:47:37,000 --> 00:47:52,000
a month ago. And, uh, you know… Nothing government removes is ever too small to matter. Every disappearance is a shift in our human behavior. When you remove the lowest denomination of money.

326
00:47:52,000 --> 00:47:59,000
You normalize rising prices, you normalize rounding up, you normalize quiet inflation that nobody can track.

327
00:47:59,000 --> 00:48:03,000
It's a psychological conditioning tool. Not an economic update.

328
00:48:03,000 --> 00:48:10,000
And what happens next? Cash slowly disappears. Digital payment becomes.

329
00:48:10,000 --> 00:48:26,000
Default tracking becomes unavoidable, and control becomes programmable. And, um… It's clear in the very frameworks that agencies like SANDAG follow, including the Regional Implementation.

330
00:48:26,000 --> 00:48:39,000
Uh, for the UN 2030. Um, which pushes digitalized mobility, digital identity, cashless systems, and centralized data monitoring.

331
00:48:39,000 --> 00:48:53,000
As if they are harmless advances. And the truth is simple, when everything is digital, everything is trackable. When everything is trackable, everything is controllable, and when everything is controllable, human freedom becomes optional.

332
00:48:53,000 --> 00:49:00,000
And you see, this isn't a transportation planning, the push to restrict car usage increasing.

333
00:49:00,000 --> 00:49:11,000
increased tolling, expand surveillance-based mobility systems. High transportation access to digital accounts, it mirrors the same pattern we see in the financial system.

334
00:49:11,000 --> 00:49:18,000
Reduce physical freedom, increase digital dependency, shift power upward, make human behavior manageable.

335
00:49:18,000 --> 00:49:24,000
Thank you, your time has expired. That concludes our public comment on this item, Chair.

336
00:49:24,000 --> 00:49:30,000
Very good. Um, it's now time for the board to comment, um, and perhaps.

337
00:49:30,000 --> 00:49:37,000
Give me a motion. Um… First Vice Chair Lacava. Uh, I'll move the consent agenda. Very good.

338
00:49:37,000 --> 00:49:45,000
Second by Minto. Um, Mayor Sanchez, did you want to speak? I was just going to make the motion. Oh, okay, thank you. All right, so please use your devices to speak.

339
00:49:45,000 --> 00:49:54,000
I mean, to vote?

340
00:49:54,000 --> 00:50:06,000
Yeah.

341
00:50:06,000 --> 00:50:14,000
Encinitas, yeah. It's gonna do that.

342
00:50:14,000 --> 00:50:27,000
Okay, that passes unanimously. Uh, thank you. Uh, we'll now move to the 2025 Regional Plan. This is the time and place set for a public hearing on the 2025 Regional Plan and its final environmental impact report. The staff presentation will be heard first.

343
00:50:27,000 --> 00:50:33,000
And then we will take public comment. Next, we'll hear comments from board members, and then I'll close the public hearing.

344
00:50:33,000 --> 00:50:40,000
After the public hearing, we are being asked to certify the final EIR and adopt the 2025 Regional Plan.

345
00:50:40,000 --> 00:50:46,000
So, Antoinette? Please go ahead.

346
00:50:46,000 --> 00:50:54,000
Thank you, Chair. Good morning. I'm Antoinette Meyer, the Senior Director of Regional Planning here at SANDAG, and today is a big day. Today is the day.

347
00:50:54,000 --> 00:51:00,000
Um, when we're asking you to adopt the 2025 Regional Plan that we've been working on together over the last several years.

348
00:51:00,000 --> 00:51:17,000
And to certify the environmental impact report. Developing and adopting a regional plan every 4 years is one of SANDAG's most important responsibilities. You've heard me say this time and time again. Without a regional plan, the region, and that's every agency in the region, is not eligible.

349
00:51:17,000 --> 00:51:26,000
for state and federal funding for transportation projects. So, having a plan that meets all of the state and federal requirements is a very important thing for the.

350
00:51:26,000 --> 00:51:35,000
for the region. Um, in September. I presented to you the changes that we were proposing to make between draft and final. They were relatively minor changes.

351
00:51:35,000 --> 00:51:40,000
And those changes are reflected in the final plan. There haven't been any additional.

352
00:51:40,000 --> 00:51:48,000
changes since then. What you haven't heard about yet, though, is the environmental impact report, so we're going to spend a little bit more time on that today.

353
00:51:48,000 --> 00:51:54,000
Um, before we open it up for the public hearing part of the plan.

354
00:51:54,000 --> 00:52:05,000
So just a few quick reminders. This is really the culmination of years of technical work, coordination, collaboration with you, um, and your agencies.

355
00:52:05,000 --> 00:52:10,000
And a lot of public outreach. We started this process back in 2021.

356
00:52:10,000 --> 00:52:16,000
collecting current travel data, doing surveys, updating the modeling tools that we use.

357
00:52:16,000 --> 00:52:27,000
to evaluate the plan, and then we really kick this off with you in 2023 at your board retreat when I was doing a briefing yesterday, Mayor Gasterlin reminded me that we kicked this off with the puzzle exercise that you were.

358
00:52:27,000 --> 00:52:33,000
Your board retreat, um, and, um, you all helped us throughout the course of that year.

359
00:52:33,000 --> 00:52:37,000
determine what the priority is for the plan were, and to set the goals for the plan.

360
00:52:37,000 --> 00:52:45,000
We also started doing outreach really early for this plan, so getting input from communities about what their priorities were. Um, and then we developed an initial concept.

361
00:52:45,000 --> 00:52:50,000
for the plan in 2024. That was not the draft, but that was the pre-draft.

362
00:52:50,000 --> 00:52:59,000
We took that out, we got feedback from you, from communities, um, and then we incorporated that feedback into the draft plan that we released for public comment in May.

363
00:52:59,000 --> 00:53:04,000
Shortly after releasing that draft plan, we released the draft EIR.

364
00:53:04,000 --> 00:53:08,000
Um, and then, uh, the public comment period's closed. We've been addressing all of those comments.

365
00:53:08,000 --> 00:53:22,000
Um, in fact, there is, uh, responses to the public comments as an appendix to the plan, and now we are here. But the final step today, adopting the plan.

366
00:53:22,000 --> 00:53:31,000
This slide really summarizes all of the in-person outreach that we did over the course of the plan. You'll see there were quite a few board presentations and workshops, 20. Thank you for being.

367
00:53:31,000 --> 00:53:49,000
Patient and active participants in the process. But it was very helpful for staff, because it allowed you to really provide guidance and direction along the way, and to have a better understanding of what it takes to put together a regional plan and all the laws and requirements that we have to meet and why we make certain decisions to include things in the plan.

368
00:53:49,000 --> 00:53:56,000
We also worked a lot with your staff, both one-on-one and through our working groups, and we worked with our policy advisory committees.

369
00:53:56,000 --> 00:54:05,000
We did a lot of community events, um, and we worked with our tribes. We did consultation through our tribal working group, but also one-on-one with the different tribes.

370
00:54:05,000 --> 00:54:10,000
Um, and we went out and we met with groups all across the region, and that led to a lot of feedback.

371
00:54:10,000 --> 00:54:17,000
So when we were working on the initial concept for the plan, we had both in-person and online opportunities to provide feedback.

372
00:54:17,000 --> 00:54:27,000
That resulted in nearly 12,000 public comments. Then when we release the draft, I shared with you in September that we got, um, over 1,300, um, comments.

373
00:54:27,000 --> 00:54:39,000
on the plan, um, and we held, again. in person, um, events all across the region, um, and took feedback, um, through email, mail, every mechanism.

374
00:54:39,000 --> 00:54:44,000
And Appendix J, you can see the responses to those public comments.

375
00:54:44,000 --> 00:55:02,000
This is the network. I'm not going to spend a lot of time on it, because we've talked so much about it. But, you know, the feedback that we get on the plan is about as diverse as our region, and we tried to really respond to that with a very balanced, multimodal plan. So this plan has investments across all modes, transit, active transportation.

376
00:55:02,000 --> 00:55:06,000
roadways, safety and operation projects, um, it's all in the plan.

377
00:55:06,000 --> 00:55:17,000
It also includes improvements to existing services, so you don't see those lines on the map, but all of the transit across the region gets upgrades, um, additional hours of service, better frequencies.

378
00:55:17,000 --> 00:55:24,000
Um, there's community shuttles, we've heard a lot from you, um, about the desire to have more, um, neighborhood shuttle services.

379
00:55:24,000 --> 00:55:36,000
And we have those in both our rural and urban communities. And of course, safety and operational improvements, we've heard a lot from our rural communities and the tribes about the importance of that, so that is reflected in the plan.

380
00:55:36,000 --> 00:55:53,000
What you don't see is the programs and the projects, and we've received a lot of comments about the Youth Opportunity Pass program. I want to reassure you, YOP is in the plan for the life of the plan. In October, the board approved another additional few years of funding for that, and we're working with the operators.

381
00:55:53,000 --> 00:56:03,000
on a long-term, sustainable funding source. The other project I want to, um, mention, because it's been coming up a lot, and we've got a lot of questions on it, is the Purple Line.

382
00:56:03,000 --> 00:56:14,000
So the purple line, um, has not been delayed. It is… it is not removed from the plan, but we've done a lot of planning and analysis work, um, since the 2021 plan, and we learned a lot.

383
00:56:14,000 --> 00:56:23,000
About where the line should be, and how complicated and complex and expensive it is to construct. And that's reflected in the plan. So the new timeline for the purple line.

384
00:56:23,000 --> 00:56:32,000
Um, and the phasing for that project is based on reality. The cost of the project and how complex of a project it is to construct.

385
00:56:32,000 --> 00:56:48,000
There was also some confusion and public comments that came in about the airport and transit to the airport. There is no automated people mover in the regional plan. We assume in the outer years of the plan that the trolley light rail will connect to the airport, and in the near term, we have improvements to the existing shuttle.

386
00:56:48,000 --> 00:56:55,000
and bus service. And then last. I want to address Senate Bill 79, because there's been a lot of feedback and comments and concerns.

387
00:56:55,000 --> 00:57:00,000
about the potential impacts of Senate Bill 79, um, based on projects in the plan.

388
00:57:00,000 --> 00:57:06,000
So Senate Bill 79 applies to projects that have operated in the last 3 years, so it's backward-looking.

389
00:57:06,000 --> 00:57:21,000
And, um, routes for which a locally preferred alternative has been selected. So projects that are already well along in the planning, environmental, um, stage, um, and that are included in the RTIP. So the lines on the map in the regional plan aren't going to, unless they've been.

390
00:57:21,000 --> 00:57:38,000
really planned and gone through environmental trigger anything related to SB79. Also, we don't have the, um… what the state… how the state defines rapid in our region. So, the state's definition around rapid is dedicated infrastructure only for… exclusively used by the bus.

391
00:57:38,000 --> 00:57:52,000
You need to have transit signal priority, you need to have all door boarding, basically all of the bells and whistles, and we don't have any qualifying rapid in our region, nor do we assume that rapids in our plan will require all of those things or have all of those things.

392
00:57:52,000 --> 00:57:57,000
So I just wanted to clarify that about the plan.

393
00:57:57,000 --> 00:58:12,000
The good news is, is the plan achieves the goals that you all set early on, um, and the performance measures are included as an attachment to the Appendix to the plan itself. Um, so you all set goals around convenience.

394
00:58:12,000 --> 00:58:18,000
equity, health, and, um, safety, and at a high level.

395
00:58:18,000 --> 00:58:22,000
Travel times are decreased for all modes, and that includes commercial vehicles.

396
00:58:22,000 --> 00:58:30,000
So we achieve the convenience. Um, there's increased access to basic needs and opportunities for all populations in the region.

397
00:58:30,000 --> 00:58:35,000
Um, there's an increase in transportation-related physical activity and cleaner air.

398
00:58:35,000 --> 00:58:42,000
Um, and we have more safe transportation projects in the plan than we have in prior plans.

399
00:58:42,000 --> 00:58:51,000
And very importantly, we meet all of our federal and state requirements. So, uh, across the top there, you see the federal requirements, there's more than this, but these are some of the big ones.

400
00:58:51,000 --> 00:59:01,000
Um, there's a Title VI analysis that's included in the plan, that's Appendix E, and that demonstrates that the plan really does improve access to jobs, to education, to basic needs.

401
00:59:01,000 --> 00:59:11,000
for our most vulnerable populations. We have to do the air quality conformity determination. Fortunately, we are no longer in a conformity lockdown, so we're able to submit our.

402
00:59:11,000 --> 00:59:17,000
air quality conformity determination, um, to the federal, uh, government for approval, and that's one of the things you're being asked.

403
00:59:17,000 --> 00:59:24,000
to approve today, but that demonstrates that we comply with the Clean Air Act, and that the projects in the plan don't worsen air quality.

404
00:59:24,000 --> 00:59:40,000
And then fiscal constraint. We've talked a lot about this. The regionally plan has to be fiscally constrained. That means that the projects in the plan, um, we have to demonstrate how we could reasonably pay for them over the life of the plant, so it can't be a wish list. We do have a non-constrained list of projects. Those are projects that aren't.

405
00:59:40,000 --> 00:59:50,000
Part of our funding strategy, they're not lines on the map, but they're projects of interest to the region or that show up in other agencies, other entities, plans. Um, so this plan is $125 billion.

406
00:59:50,000 --> 00:59:55,000
That's quite a bit less than the last couple of plans.

407
00:59:55,000 --> 01:00:07,000
That does not just include the new projects in the plan, and this is not just SANDAX money, this is operations and maintenance projects for Caltrans. This is the money that we pass through to all of you for local streets and roads projects or our grant programs.

408
01:00:07,000 --> 01:00:13,000
Um, it's the bike projects that either you're building or that we're building.

409
01:00:13,000 --> 01:00:18,000
It, um, covers really everything, even paying off our debt.

410
01:00:18,000 --> 01:00:24,000
Um, and the bottom, we have the state requirements, so for housing and land use, we have to demonstrate how future job.

411
01:00:24,000 --> 01:00:31,000
Um, and housing growth will occur in areas where there's planned or existing multimodal transportation infrastructure. We achieve this.

412
01:00:31,000 --> 01:00:38,000
80% of the region's future growth, um, is in areas with planned or future transportation investments.

413
01:00:38,000 --> 01:00:52,000
And Senate Bill 375, the one that we talk a lot about, and the one that we're working on improving for future plans, is the, um, greenhouse gas emissions reduction target, and if you recall, we have to meet that GHG target by reducing vehicle miles traveled.

414
01:00:52,000 --> 01:01:00,000
The target that CARB set for this plan is a 19% per capita reduction by 2035, based on 2005 levels.

415
01:01:00,000 --> 01:01:11,000
This plan achieves a 19.35% reduction, so we exceed our target, and that's actually higher than the amended 2021 plan, which was $18.6%.

416
01:01:11,000 --> 01:01:29,000
So, we've met all of those laws. The last law that I'm going to turn over to Kirsten. Kirsten, you could tell, who's joining me today, is the project manager, um, for the EIR, the Programmatic EIR, um, for the plan, and she's going to walk you through the contents of the plan, the public comments that we received, and how we've addressed those.

417
01:01:29,000 --> 01:01:34,000
Thank you. My name is Kirsten.

418
01:01:34,000 --> 01:01:42,000
Kirsten, you could tell, and I'm here to give you an overview of the EIR and the other documents that are related that are in your packet.

419
01:01:42,000 --> 01:01:47,000
So we completed an environmental impact report for the 2025 Regional Plan.

420
01:01:47,000 --> 01:01:51,000
consistent with the California Environmental Quality Act, or CEQA.

421
01:01:51,000 --> 01:01:59,000
Which requires that we identify and analyze the environmental impacts of implementing the 2025 Regional Plan.

422
01:01:59,000 --> 01:02:09,000
This is called a programmatic or program EIR, and as it sounds, it's intended to look at an interconnected set of projects, a program of them.

423
01:02:09,000 --> 01:02:15,000
Over a longer time horizon, in this case, out to 2050, consistent with the regional plan.

424
01:02:15,000 --> 01:02:23,000
So this EIR is not. clearing individual projects, it's not completing environmental analysis for individual projects.

425
01:02:23,000 --> 01:02:37,000
site-specific impacts, or developing those related mitigation measures. It is analyzing the environmental impacts of the regional plan at the same level of detail contained in the regional plan.

426
01:02:37,000 --> 01:02:41,000
And the expectation is that as projects are further developed.

427
01:02:41,000 --> 01:02:53,000
and have a stable project description. They will then go through their own individual project-level CEQA analysis that will look at their impacts and alternatives and mitigation.

428
01:02:53,000 --> 01:03:00,000
This EIR is looking at this high programmatic level at environmental impacts of the 2025 plan.

429
01:03:00,000 --> 01:03:10,000
cumulative impacts. It contains an alternatives analysis. And it also contains programmatic mitigation measures.

430
01:03:10,000 --> 01:03:18,000
One of the elements of developing the EIR. is to put it out for public comment, as Antoinette had already mentioned.

431
01:03:18,000 --> 01:03:27,000
Our draft EIR went out in late August. And by the conclusion of the comment period, we had received 217 comments.

432
01:03:27,000 --> 01:03:33,000
On the EIR, consistent with CEQA, we've prepared written responses to each of these comments.

433
01:03:33,000 --> 01:03:39,000
And those are attached to your packet as Attachment 4, and they are Appendix N1.

434
01:03:39,000 --> 01:03:51,000
in the EIR. Of the 217 comments that we received, maybe 80 to 85% of them were actually comments on the regional plan.

435
01:03:51,000 --> 01:04:00,000
Those comments focused primarily on the purple line. On the Youth Opportunity Pass program, and on the desire for greater transit amenities.

436
01:04:00,000 --> 01:04:09,000
Of the comments received on the environmental impact analysis in the EIR, there were two primary themes. The comments emerged around.

437
01:04:09,000 --> 01:04:18,000
The first was GHG and VMT impacts. With most commenters opposing roadways, um, opposing roadway expansion.

438
01:04:18,000 --> 01:04:25,000
advocating for sooner implementation of transit to reduce those impacts.

439
01:04:25,000 --> 01:04:30,000
VMT and GHG impacts are fully analyzed in the EIR across.

440
01:04:30,000 --> 01:04:35,000
three primary sections, which are air quality, section 4.3.

441
01:04:35,000 --> 01:04:40,000
greenhouse gas and climate change, which is Section 4.8, and transportation.

442
01:04:40,000 --> 01:04:47,000
Which is Section 4.16. The second primary area of comment.

443
01:04:47,000 --> 01:04:56,000
was impacts to wildlife and habitat. With many commenters expressing concern that there is not an identified regional funding source.

444
01:04:56,000 --> 01:05:06,000
to subsidize local habitat conservation plants. Impacts to wildlife and impacts to habitat, along with other resources, are analyzed.

445
01:05:06,000 --> 01:05:18,000
in Section 4.4 of the EIR, Biological Resources. and comments to all… responses to all of those comments, as I said, are in the attachment to your packet.

446
01:05:18,000 --> 01:05:27,000
None of the comments that we received raised significant new information that had not already been analyzed in the draft EIR.

447
01:05:27,000 --> 01:05:33,000
Similarly, we had some changes draft to final in the EIR, and none of those changes.

448
01:05:33,000 --> 01:05:39,000
rise to the level of significant new information.

449
01:05:39,000 --> 01:05:46,000
In addition. to the EIR, CEQA requires preparation of some additional documents.

450
01:05:46,000 --> 01:05:51,000
That are also attached to your packet. The first one of those is the findings.

451
01:05:51,000 --> 01:05:58,000
which discusses the alternatives analyzed in the EIR. And also discusses.

452
01:05:58,000 --> 01:06:03,000
the environmental impacts of the 2025 plan after mitigation.

453
01:06:03,000 --> 01:06:12,000
That's attachment 1A to your packet. The second document is a statement of overriding considerations, or SOC.

454
01:06:12,000 --> 01:06:21,000
Which is attachment 1B. And that sets out the advantages and benefits of adopting the 2025 Regional Plan.

455
01:06:21,000 --> 01:06:27,000
And weighs them against the environmental impacts of the 2025 plan.

456
01:06:27,000 --> 01:06:34,000
The third document, Attachment 1C. is the mitigation monitoring and reporting program.

457
01:06:34,000 --> 01:06:41,000
Which sets out the mitigation that has been identified, analyzed, and committed to in the EIR at a programmatic level.

458
01:06:41,000 --> 01:06:52,000
For the regional plan. And that concludes my presentation, and I'll turn it back to Antoinette for next steps.

459
01:06:52,000 --> 01:07:08,000
Okay, so next steps, um, we will have the public hearing right after the presentation, and then the board will be asked to take two actions. The first will be to certify the EIR, and the second will be to approve, adopt the regional plan.

460
01:07:08,000 --> 01:07:23,000
Um, once that happens, we will submit the Sustainable Community Strategy to the state, California Air Resources Board, for acceptance, and we will submit the Air Quality Conformity determination and RTP to the U.S. Department of Transportation.

461
01:07:23,000 --> 01:07:29,000
And the EPA for approval. And with that, I will pass it back to the chair to open the public hearing.

462
01:07:29,000 --> 01:07:35,000
Very good. I've opened the public hearing, and we'll now go to public comments. Michael, how many do we have?

463
01:07:35,000 --> 01:07:37,000
If you are online, please raise your hand now.

464
01:07:37,000 --> 01:07:44,000
We have 9 in person. First up is Chris Roberts, followed by Eric Rear.

465
01:07:44,000 --> 01:07:51,000
Hello, I'm Chris Roberts, volunteer for San Diego 350 Climate Action. Thank you, SANDAG staff, for all your hard work on the plan.

466
01:07:51,000 --> 01:07:58,000
We are very happy that funding for Youth Opportunity Pass program has been extended. Thank you very much.

467
01:07:58,000 --> 01:08:12,000
Apart from this, we're very disappointed in the 2025 regional plan, and we don't believe that the plan is going to achieve the goals that were stated on particular decreasing transit across all modes. We don't believe it.

468
01:08:12,000 --> 01:08:20,000
Um, the plan, uh, will have 93 miles of new lanes added, managed lanes, costing more than $2 billion by 2035.

469
01:08:20,000 --> 01:08:24,000
This will result in induced demand, and so a few years after completion.

470
01:08:24,000 --> 01:08:28,000
The congestion on these highways will be as bad as it is now.

471
01:08:28,000 --> 01:08:33,000
And we don't think that's an effective way to spend $2 billion over the next 10 years.

472
01:08:33,000 --> 01:08:41,000
SANDEG's own modeling characterized disease as high VMT increase, so there'll be more cars on the road, more greenhouse gas emissions.

473
01:08:41,000 --> 01:08:46,000
to mitigate the greenhouse gas emissions, many new rapid bus routes are added.

474
01:08:46,000 --> 01:08:53,000
But as Antoinette said, these aren't real rapid bus routes. They're not going to have all the technology needed for them to be rapid.

475
01:08:53,000 --> 01:08:59,000
To get the greenhouse gas emissions, they're going to counterbalance all of the induced demand from the highway expansions.

476
01:08:59,000 --> 01:09:06,000
So, I don't… it's hard to believe we're going to meet our SB 375 greenhouse gas emissions in this plan.

477
01:09:06,000 --> 01:09:16,000
So, um, and of course, as well, a lot of the things that Rapid bus routes need, for example, bus-only lanes, are actively opposed.

478
01:09:16,000 --> 01:09:22,000
by many cities in the county. So, the biggest disappointment in the plan is the purple lines, barely mentioned.

479
01:09:22,000 --> 01:09:29,000
We feel that with the passage of SB 79, the numbers of riders on the plan are going to be much greater than stated.

480
01:09:29,000 --> 01:09:36,000
And it's extremely disappointing that NACTO-safe bicycle infrastructure guidelines have been removed from the plan.

481
01:09:36,000 --> 01:09:46,000
That means that bike infrastructure will be built. unsafe, and the community will declare victory. So we're sorry about that, and we're disappointed in the plan.

482
01:09:46,000 --> 01:09:51,000
Thank you very much. Next is Eric Ruhrer, followed by Truth.

483
01:09:51,000 --> 01:09:55,000
Good morning, my name is Eric Rohr. Good morning, members of the board and everyone attending.

484
01:09:55,000 --> 01:10:01,000
I'm a resident of San Diego, and just speaking as a resident, not.

485
01:10:01,000 --> 01:10:06,000
Representing anyone. I do work as a transportation engineering consultant in the San Diego region, so.

486
01:10:06,000 --> 01:10:11,000
I work for both private and public clients. I will.

487
01:10:11,000 --> 01:10:15,000
most likely be working on individual projects that are part of this plan.

488
01:10:15,000 --> 01:10:21,000
But I'm not speaking about any individual projects today. What my comment.

489
01:10:21,000 --> 01:10:25,000
is to speak in favor of adopting the plan and certifying the EIR.

490
01:10:25,000 --> 01:10:30,000
And, um, I followed the process from the beginning.

491
01:10:30,000 --> 01:10:35,000
And I want to let you know, I believe this has been a robust process that resulted in a.

492
01:10:35,000 --> 01:10:40,000
and a balanced plan, and I think you should adopt this plan. I think you should certify the EIR.

493
01:10:40,000 --> 01:10:52,000
And thank you for allowing me to speak. Nexus truth, followed by Cesar Javier.

494
01:10:52,000 --> 01:11:01,000
Total artificial input was 2,517 people divided by a 3.3 million population equals 0.0007% input.

495
01:11:01,000 --> 01:11:05,000
Thumbs down. All modes of transportation are faster? Yeah, right.

496
01:11:05,000 --> 01:11:15,000
An environmental impact report means nothing in the corrupt state of California. Ceqa is waived all the time for a dangerous and toxic projects like battery energy storage, fire facilities.

497
01:11:15,000 --> 01:11:29,000
Because whatever makes the big political unions, big NGO profiteers, big green deal scammers, and the big cartel campaign funders rich is what gets a fast-track approval. And that includes projects like border crossings, which should only be built by the federal government, not in EPSANDAG.

498
01:11:29,000 --> 01:11:36,000
The OTIMAC's project directly violates AQ07 because it will result in other emissions such as those leading to odors.

499
01:11:36,000 --> 01:11:44,000
By encouraging unregulated building in Tijuana, which violates POP 1's substantial unplanned population growth by extending roads and other infrastructure.

500
01:11:44,000 --> 01:11:54,000
Expansion of a state route by up to 25 cargo lanes and 20 passenger lanes, encouraging up to 12,000 cars and 1,500 trucks a day that are so-called fossil fuel based.

501
01:11:54,000 --> 01:12:02,000
And do not meet emission standards violates EN2's renewable energy, AQ1's GHG12, 3, 4, and Teres.

502
01:12:02,000 --> 01:12:13,000
emissions reduction goals in AQ6's carbon monoxide hotspots. What is the predicted GHG and VMT inventory of the OME project, and what highways are being sacrificed for those extra GHGs?

503
01:12:13,000 --> 01:12:19,000
I'd rather see that 1.3 billion taxars go to immediate safety measures for the 67 and 78.

504
01:12:19,000 --> 01:12:26,000
By not doing that, Sandek is violating has for impairing implementation resulting in inadequate emergency access.

505
01:12:26,000 --> 01:12:33,000
Sineag's bluff tracks move in Del Mar is also violating POP 1 by displacing substantial numbers of people or housing units.

506
01:12:33,000 --> 01:12:43,000
Necessitating the construction of replacement housing elsewhere. The City of San Diego is violating TR4 on lack of parking supply that causes secondary environmental impacts.

507
01:12:43,000 --> 01:12:51,000
Notice socialist welfare transit, tax road usage charges, higher parking pricing, managed lane pricing, and arterial and freeway speed reductions, which all increase.

508
01:12:51,000 --> 01:12:56,000
BMT, and emissions. And thank you for making me skim a lot of pages. I actually did it.

509
01:12:56,000 --> 01:13:04,000
Thank you. Next is Cesar Javier, followed by Noelle Garcia.

510
01:13:04,000 --> 01:13:10,000
Caesar and Purita. I solemnly swear.

511
01:13:10,000 --> 01:13:14,000
To support the Constitution. So, help me, God.

512
01:13:14,000 --> 01:13:20,000
What we are doing, ma'am, sir. Thank you for your presentation.

513
01:13:20,000 --> 01:13:26,000
is good, better, best. I wonder, in the presentation.

514
01:13:26,000 --> 01:13:31,000
Why only the air quality that is being given focus?

515
01:13:31,000 --> 01:13:42,000
This is the summation of the two presentations. item 4. Why? Why only air quality aspect?

516
01:13:42,000 --> 01:13:49,000
Why not the geological aspect, which is all. Within the sphere of the element shell.

517
01:13:49,000 --> 01:13:53,000
As we were taught in the urban planning course.

518
01:13:53,000 --> 01:14:01,000
Why? We won the war because of COVID communication.

519
01:14:01,000 --> 01:14:08,000
We were taught how to read. But we were not taught how to understand what we are reading.

520
01:14:08,000 --> 01:14:16,000
Is this how we… swore to the Constitution.

521
01:14:16,000 --> 01:14:25,000
But anyway, we are doing our best. And who prepares the EIR?

522
01:14:25,000 --> 01:14:36,000
Region-wide, citywide, community-wide. We, the residents in the community, suggest to you.

523
01:14:36,000 --> 01:14:42,000
What is the actual frontline happening as far as environment?

524
01:14:42,000 --> 01:14:48,000
And listen to us. Is this coded?

525
01:14:48,000 --> 01:14:54,000
You didn't consider. The underbead of our foundation, the land.

526
01:14:54,000 --> 01:15:02,000
Or geology aspect. What about hydrography?

527
01:15:02,000 --> 01:15:08,000
Where our… Circulation, mobility passes through.

528
01:15:08,000 --> 01:15:27,000
Where they are playing in the air. Thank you, your time has expired. Next is Noel Garcia, followed by Corelli Sadano.

529
01:15:27,000 --> 01:15:37,000
Good morning, I am here on behalf of MidCity Can to actually thank SANDAG for its commitment to continued funding and give another extension to the Utahni Pass program.

530
01:15:37,000 --> 01:15:44,000
And mid-city Can, we do a lot of work advocating for spreading the word about the importance of the youth's access to public transit to the residents and the local community.

531
01:15:44,000 --> 01:15:48,000
So, it's not just I who's grateful for the continuation of this program.

532
01:15:48,000 --> 01:15:53,000
It is mothers, dads, brothers, sisters, elders, and many, many workers.

533
01:15:53,000 --> 01:16:02,000
That being said, I still strongly urge that this program eventually receive the permanent funding that San Diegans deserve.

534
01:16:02,000 --> 01:16:16,000
Next is Coreli Serrano, followed by Anna Grossman. Good morning, board members. My name is Carly Serrano, the Transportation Organizer at Mid-City CAN. I just want to thank you all for your continued commitment to the Youth Opportunity Pass program.

535
01:16:16,000 --> 01:16:27,000
Um, including it in the regional plan and extending it, your leadership in supporting free transit for youth has made a meaningful impact across the region. We really appreciate your continued dedication to supporting transit-dependent communities.

536
01:16:27,000 --> 01:16:34,000
like City Heights to create a more equitable and connected region through transit services. Thank you.

537
01:16:34,000 --> 01:16:39,000
Nexus Anna Grossman, followed by Gillian Quint.

538
01:16:39,000 --> 01:16:44,000
Good morning. My name is Aria Grossman, and I'm the Policy Manager at Circulate San Diego.

539
01:16:44,000 --> 01:16:50,000
In 2022, Circulate published a report analyzing SANDEG's 2021 draft plan.

540
01:16:50,000 --> 01:16:57,000
The report ultimately found that the 2021 plan made billions of dollars in speculative revenue assumptions.

541
01:16:57,000 --> 01:17:04,000
For example, from road uses charges and enacting multiple ballot measures in a very short span of time.

542
01:17:04,000 --> 01:17:08,000
Circulate is supportive of these, you know, concepts in general, but finds that they're.

543
01:17:08,000 --> 01:17:15,000
that SANDAGS 2021 draft plan made very, um, speculative and high estimations for these revenues.

544
01:17:15,000 --> 01:17:23,000
The revenues were also set to be dedicated to extremely high-cost capital projects that were simply just not going to be built as proposed.

545
01:17:23,000 --> 01:17:31,000
Circulate is supportive of transit capital investments, but when we prioritize unrealistic projects over near-term transit service upgrades.

546
01:17:31,000 --> 01:17:36,000
We end up with no improvements to transits and implementing only highway projects.

547
01:17:36,000 --> 01:17:47,000
The 2025 plan improves upon these concerns. The revenue estimations no longer include these unrealistic road uses charges and scales back ballot measures to a more realistic goal.

548
01:17:47,000 --> 01:17:55,000
It's important to note that there is still $14.7 billion in revenue estimations that SANDAG currently doesn't have the authority to implement.

549
01:17:55,000 --> 01:18:01,000
As well as federal discretionary award projections, which are based on the past 5 years, which is.

550
01:18:01,000 --> 01:18:06,000
Very unrealistic, as the current authorizations expire at the end of 2026.

551
01:18:06,000 --> 01:18:15,000
Additionally, expenditures have made progress. The large-scale capital projects are scaled back in favor of more near-term transit service enhancements.

552
01:18:15,000 --> 01:18:22,000
Circulate supports the new rapid routes and encourages SANDAG to prioritize implementing rapid upgrades as soon as possible.

553
01:18:22,000 --> 01:18:26,000
Including the support of infrastructure necessary to ensure that they are actually rapid.

554
01:18:26,000 --> 01:18:32,000
I urge SANDAG to continue the trends I outlined in future plans. Thank you.

555
01:18:32,000 --> 01:18:48,000
Next is Jillian Quint, followed by Ian Hembree. Good morning, my name is Jillian Quint. I represent the San Diego River Park Foundation. We are very appreciative that the San Diego River Trail and Regional Bikeway is a featured element.

556
01:18:48,000 --> 01:19:02,000
in the 2025 regional plan, so many members of the community, including residents, regional travelers, and recreational visitors, have been waiting for the completion of this vital bike wave for over 20 years.

557
01:19:02,000 --> 01:19:16,000
I must also express our gratitude to SANDAX Transportation Committee, Chair Zito and Vice Chair Illa Rivera for their strong and decisive support of the West Valley River Crossing, which is the pedestrian and bike bridge.

558
01:19:16,000 --> 01:19:27,000
At last week's Transportation Committee, the leadership urged staff to utilize the next funding cycle to ensure that this crossing is funded.

559
01:19:27,000 --> 01:19:39,000
The West Valley Crossing is the crucial missing link that anchors the entire river trail and bikeway network. It's a central piece of the city's natural heritage.

560
01:19:39,000 --> 01:19:55,000
With no known opposition, and so many members of our community using the River Trail and anticipating the future enhanced safety and connectivity that this crossing will bring to unlock the entire regional bikeway all the way out to Santee.

561
01:19:55,000 --> 01:20:11,000
It truly is a project that will unite the county. As this West Valley Crossing project moves forward, we have one small, specific request. We ask that a note be made in somewhere that when the design moves ahead for the West Valley Crossing, it must include the design.

562
01:20:11,000 --> 01:20:16,000
eastward trail extension toward the future Riverwalk trolley Station.

563
01:20:16,000 --> 01:20:35,000
The good news is that the preliminary design for this extension is being funded through the Riverwalk development. However, the projects are currently split in the regional plan, and with the eastward trail extension lumped with other projects, their union is essential, because from a design aspect, you want the pieces to align.

564
01:20:35,000 --> 01:20:44,000
Thank you very much. Our next public comment is Ian Hembree, followed by Consuelo Online.

565
01:20:44,000 --> 01:20:53,000
Good morning, SANDAG board. My name is Ian Hembree with the San Diego County Bicycle Coalition. I want to begin by thanking SANDAG for building some of the best bike projects in the county.

566
01:20:53,000 --> 01:20:58,000
These projects make biking safer and more convenient, and they also make our communities more livable and sustainable.

567
01:20:58,000 --> 01:21:02,000
We're happy to see that more bike projects are included in this plan.

568
01:21:02,000 --> 01:21:10,000
However, there are worrying signs that present commitment to bike projects are under threat. In October, Sandai gave back $3.8 million.

569
01:21:10,000 --> 01:21:15,000
and grant funding for the Pacific Highway Project, and the project is missing a project delivery strategy.

570
01:21:15,000 --> 01:21:24,000
Pacific Highway is one of the most dangerous roadways in the county, and the painted bike lane along Pacific Highway has earned demerits as one of the worst bike lanes in the United States.

571
01:21:24,000 --> 01:21:32,000
It is a vital regional connector, serving as the most convenient corridor to connect many of San Diego's most dense, populous neighborhoods.

572
01:21:32,000 --> 01:21:38,000
Last week, Eric Woodson Jr. Was walking northbound along Pacific Highway when he was struck by a driver.

573
01:21:38,000 --> 01:21:45,000
And killed. The northbound side of Pacific Highway doesn't have a sidewalk, only the southbound side does.

574
01:21:45,000 --> 01:21:51,000
He was killed walking in the street because there is no sidewalk, or he was trying to cross to the other side that does.

575
01:21:51,000 --> 01:21:58,000
How is SANDAG's willingness to give back grant funds for the most dangerous roadways in the county represented in the regional plan?

576
01:21:58,000 --> 01:22:01,000
There are many assumptions about increased grant funding in this plan.

577
01:22:01,000 --> 01:22:07,000
But giving back grant funds for critical. projects runs counter to that assumption.

578
01:22:07,000 --> 01:22:15,000
We need this board and this SANDAIG leadership to commit to delivering bike projects by building a project delivery strategy for projects.

579
01:22:15,000 --> 01:22:22,000
funding projects that currently have a project delivery strategy, and not giving back grants that build life-saving infrastructure.

580
01:22:22,000 --> 01:22:26,000
As you develop the budget for this next year, keep this in mind.

581
01:22:26,000 --> 01:22:29,000
Thank you so much, and have a happy holiday season.

582
01:22:29,000 --> 01:22:39,000
We have 5 public comments online. The first is Consuelo, followed by Mike Bullock.

583
01:22:39,000 --> 01:22:54,000
Okay, so, um… 217 public commenters, okay, so, um… Index using as proof of public consent, that number means nothing.

584
01:22:54,000 --> 01:23:00,000
When the people you're questioning don't even understand the true power… the true purpose of this agency.

585
01:23:00,000 --> 01:23:05,000
So, uh, you're gathering opinions from a public that's been kept in the dark.

586
01:23:05,000 --> 01:23:17,000
And totally not informed. Um, you're asking questions, then using the answers to pretend people support policies they don't even realize will restrict their daily lives.

587
01:23:17,000 --> 01:23:26,000
And, um, SANDAG exists. solely to limit human mobility and not protect the environment, restrict movement.

588
01:23:26,000 --> 01:23:35,000
Uh, and you've packaged it in the nicest words possible, too. Equity, safety, sustainability. Meanwhile, younger… the younger generations.

589
01:23:35,000 --> 01:23:44,000
And I say this with sadness. Um, have been manipulated so deeply that they are now cheering their own restrictions.

590
01:23:44,000 --> 01:23:52,000
And they have no idea their future freedom is being quietly erased under the language of carbon reduction.

591
01:23:52,000 --> 01:23:56,000
And here's the reality, nobody on this board will say out loud.

592
01:23:56,000 --> 01:24:07,000
We are the carbon they're trying to reduce. That's why mobility is being targeted, not because of science, but because controlling movement means controlling people.

593
01:24:07,000 --> 01:24:13,000
And the forced bike lanes. Um, they're entirely inequitable.

594
01:24:13,000 --> 01:24:22,000
And everywhere I go in this county, people call them exactly what they are, those stupid bike lanes, they you know, like, they're just known as those stupid bike lanes.

595
01:24:22,000 --> 01:24:29,000
every demographic calls them those stupid bike lanes. Anyways… Um, yeah.

596
01:24:29,000 --> 01:24:38,000
So you didn't ask the communities if they wanted them, you opposed them. You remove lanes, increased congestion, damaged, all by design.

597
01:24:38,000 --> 01:24:46,000
Uh, damaged businesses and may travel harder for working families, all to force everyone into a system that they never agreed to join.

598
01:24:46,000 --> 01:24:56,000
Thank you, your time has expired. Next is Mike Bolek, followed by Rod.

599
01:24:56,000 --> 01:25:00,000
Yeah, thank you very much. This is Mike Bullock. I can introduce myself before.

600
01:25:00,000 --> 01:25:06,000
Uh, the FEIR for the 2025 RTP does not comply with CEQA.

601
01:25:06,000 --> 01:25:11,000
Because CEQA requires that the significant impacts of the RTP.

602
01:25:11,000 --> 01:25:17,000
be described. The RTP fails to comply with California's official plan.

603
01:25:17,000 --> 01:25:25,000
to achieve climate stabilization. That plan is the CARP scoping plan, which calls for reducing BMT by 25% with respect to 2019 levels.

604
01:25:25,000 --> 01:25:34,000
by 2030. The RTP, with its SCS, claims to reduce driving less than 20%.

605
01:25:34,000 --> 01:25:37,000
by 2035, which is 5 years later than 2030.

606
01:25:37,000 --> 01:25:41,000
Therefore, the RTP will contribute to destabilizing the Earth's climate.

607
01:25:41,000 --> 01:25:47,000
An environmental impact that can be briefly described as ending life forms on Earth.

608
01:25:47,000 --> 01:25:53,000
Except for microbiology. It includes destroying our habitat, resulting in starvation.

609
01:25:53,000 --> 01:26:01,000
Mass starvation and human extinction. CARB was tasked with creating its scoping plan under AB32.

610
01:26:01,000 --> 01:26:10,000
Now, there's no excuse for Sandag for not understanding this. In the famous September 11th, 2011 letter to Sandank from the California AG, this was written in the footnote.

611
01:26:10,000 --> 01:26:22,000
On page 8. Executive Order S305 is the official policy of the state of California established by gubernatorial order in 2005, and designated to meet the environmental objective that is relevant under CEQA.

612
01:26:22,000 --> 01:26:27,000
Climate stabilization. Sand egg thus cannot ignore it.

613
01:26:27,000 --> 01:26:35,000
The only difference now is that S305 has been replaced by SB32, which was established as a law of California.

614
01:26:35,000 --> 01:26:40,000
Now, regarding item 2, regarding the second request by the SAS achieving air conformity.

615
01:26:40,000 --> 01:26:46,000
There are, in effect, two different carbs. One is law-abiding. That carb.

616
01:26:46,000 --> 01:26:51,000
created the CARB scoping Plan. So that's the carb that matters.

617
01:26:51,000 --> 01:26:57,000
Um, the card that went for less than 20% by 2035.

618
01:26:57,000 --> 01:27:02,000
is ignoring SB32 and is ignoring the common decency.

619
01:27:02,000 --> 01:27:12,000
Thank you, your time has expired. Next is Rod, followed by Paul the Bold.

620
01:27:12,000 --> 01:27:21,000
Hi, my name is Rod Streper. I am a member of the Community Planning Group here in Lakeside, and.

621
01:27:21,000 --> 01:27:26,000
I'm also, uh, president of Fixed Pepper Drive Association.

622
01:27:26,000 --> 01:27:35,000
I'm really speaking on behalf of the Fixed Pepper Drive Association, and specifically as a bicyclist here in San Diego.

623
01:27:35,000 --> 01:27:41,000
Um, our East County is not really serviced very well with bike lanes.

624
01:27:41,000 --> 01:27:47,000
The main thing that we had requested in the public comments, I was in.

625
01:27:47,000 --> 01:27:54,000
I was one of the people that commented here when the draft plan came by here in El Cajon.

626
01:27:54,000 --> 01:27:57,000
was to put a bike lane along Pepper Drive.

627
01:27:57,000 --> 01:28:03,000
which would connect two of the major routes, uh, going north and south of East County.

628
01:28:03,000 --> 01:28:10,000
Specifically, it would have connected Winter Gardens Boulevard with Magnolia.

629
01:28:10,000 --> 01:28:18,000
Um, it would be an on… street bikeway, and so relatively inexpensive. So what I'd like to do is.

630
01:28:18,000 --> 01:28:22,000
put into the public record here that we are requesting a.

631
01:28:22,000 --> 01:28:31,000
By claiming to be included, hopefully it'll be included in the next master plan, but we'd like to see if this relatively low-cost.

632
01:28:31,000 --> 01:28:40,000
bikeway could be included. It's about 2.5 miles, and shouldn't be that, uh, difficult to, uh, request.

633
01:28:40,000 --> 01:28:47,000
Um… that is my request, so I'd like to put that on the public record, please.

634
01:28:47,000 --> 01:28:56,000
Next is Paul the Bold, followed by the original draw.

635
01:28:56,000 --> 01:29:05,000
Paul, yourself muted?

636
01:29:05,000 --> 01:29:13,000
Great. Um, sorry about that. I'm glad you answered every comment on Ian.

637
01:29:13,000 --> 01:29:24,000
EIR, and did, in fact, attach it. One major issue NCTD brought up on page 126.

638
01:29:24,000 --> 01:29:37,000
is that SENDAG overestimated VMT per 20 years. Because the accuracy of data used in the EIR and the error conformity.

639
01:29:37,000 --> 01:29:49,000
complete declaration. As I said, I just was reminded that climate predictions often are based on one or several particular regions.

640
01:29:49,000 --> 01:29:57,000
are not applicable to all. But the spread of divergent CAP projects with different goals and the.

641
01:29:57,000 --> 01:30:03,000
They pay a file is wasted money. Um, the letters.

642
01:30:03,000 --> 01:30:08,000
I noticed a lot about making bike lanes safe.

643
01:30:08,000 --> 01:30:14,000
I wouldn't do it on a city-by-city basis, one set or a side.

644
01:30:14,000 --> 01:30:19,000
That are one tags or set of guidelines does not fit all.

645
01:30:19,000 --> 01:30:27,000
Restoring the proposed purple line all the way to Sorrento Valley towards original length makes sense.

646
01:30:27,000 --> 01:30:33,000
You should keep your promises and not… forward promise in the first place.

647
01:30:33,000 --> 01:30:46,000
Uh, the meeting summary is a bit disturbing. The planning team had more presentations to the board than actual workgroup meetings, and I suspect, from my own experience.

648
01:30:46,000 --> 01:30:51,000
But the pop-ups that commander, the events were skewed to what SANDAG wanted.

649
01:30:51,000 --> 01:30:59,000
And we complete data and so on. The practice seems to have been on stakeholder groups and member agencies.

650
01:30:59,000 --> 01:31:10,000
156 versus 66 meetings. So again, commended the input was minimized, probably severely misinformed, too.

651
01:31:10,000 --> 01:31:16,000
On the other hand, I'm glad you answered every comment on plan.

652
01:31:16,000 --> 01:31:21,000
Thank you, your time has expired. Our last public comment is the original draw.

653
01:31:21,000 --> 01:31:28,000
Anything… anytime the government talks about our health and safety, and protecting or providing it.

654
01:31:28,000 --> 01:31:40,000
Means that they're going to exploit the people for profit. That's what you guys do, and this is all about control, and it's sad that so many people are encouraging their own enslavement because they don't understand.

655
01:31:40,000 --> 01:31:46,000
Because they do buy the propaganda that you guys give them, because on the surface, it seems.

656
01:31:46,000 --> 01:31:52,000
very virtuous what you're doing. And so anybody that, you know, would believe that would want to.

657
01:31:52,000 --> 01:31:58,000
Help and push that, but if you pull back the curtain and you see what's really going on, it is about total control.

658
01:31:58,000 --> 01:32:01,000
And you guys, you know, you take our money and.

659
01:32:01,000 --> 01:32:11,000
You know, you engage with contractors who wind up costing us more and more money and delayed projects, and things don't really ever get completed, yet you start more and more things.

660
01:32:11,000 --> 01:32:26,000
And you're hypocrites, because you sit here on one hand and say you want to protect the health and safety, or reduce greenhouse gases, but then you don't go to things like another country to say that the vehicles that don't have the same emissions as we do here.

661
01:32:26,000 --> 01:32:33,000
are going to be polluting in our area, as you can see in the South Bay, it has more pollution, that you guys say.

662
01:32:33,000 --> 01:32:37,000
Right? So, wouldn't you think, like, you could immediately fix things.

663
01:32:37,000 --> 01:32:42,000
If that was really what you were doing, but it isn't. It's about.

664
01:32:42,000 --> 01:32:52,000
racketeering. It's about putting people in controlled situations where you can track and trace their every movement, and make sure you have them under your thumb.

665
01:32:52,000 --> 01:33:02,000
And it's sad, because… You know, you could be doing things that are in line with what you speak, practice what you preach, but you guys don't, because.

666
01:33:02,000 --> 01:33:08,000
You know, some of you probably do also buy into the BS that you are spewing out to the people.

667
01:33:08,000 --> 01:33:14,000
But it's very dangerous, because at one point, we're going to get to a place where we're not going to be able to leave our own area.

668
01:33:14,000 --> 01:33:21,000
And people are gonna see that when you're, like, basically, you know, we're continuing to be giving back our own sewage, all while you guys.

669
01:33:21,000 --> 01:33:24,000
one of mine for lithium, and use our fresh water.

670
01:33:24,000 --> 01:33:29,000
People need to open up their eyes and see, and they'll see clearly what you're doing.

671
01:33:29,000 --> 01:33:32,000
That concludes our public comment on this item, Chair.

672
01:33:32,000 --> 01:33:38,000
Very good. Um, Antoinette, would you like to make any clarifications after the public comments?

673
01:33:38,000 --> 01:33:48,000
Sure, I can follow up on a couple. Um, first, there were comments about the scoping plan, and I want to clarify that the EIR does analyze consistency with CARB's scoping plan.

674
01:33:48,000 --> 01:34:03,000
Um, the scoping plan sets statewide goals for VMT and GHG, not regional. At the regional level, our requirement related to the scoping plan is Senate Bill 375, and as I stated in the presentation, we meet the target that CARP set for the region.

675
01:34:03,000 --> 01:34:16,000
Per Senate Bill 375. I think there were other comments related to transit and suggestions that there's less transit in this plan. I want to clarify that this plan has more transit than the 2021 regional plan did.

676
01:34:16,000 --> 01:34:28,000
And particularly in the near term, more cost-effective improvements to existing transit and more bus service in the near term, which was based on a lot of feedback that we got about the desire for communities to have ServiceNow.

677
01:34:28,000 --> 01:34:40,000
Not 25, 30 years from now. So those were two things I just wanted to clarify. Thank you for that opportunity. Sure, very good. We'll go to member comments now. We'll start with Ms. Maxson.

678
01:34:40,000 --> 01:34:45,000
Good morning, thank you. The unincorporated area is encouraged to see.

679
01:34:45,000 --> 01:34:56,000
The focus on rural corridors, um… And that not only are you focusing on them, but you truly understand the importance of those rural corridors. If you're a resident, it's vital for.

680
01:34:56,000 --> 01:35:00,000
work and school. If you're a visitor, it's important.

681
01:35:00,000 --> 01:35:08,000
For your recreational safety, as you… Come out with your trailers and all of your off-road equipment.

682
01:35:08,000 --> 01:35:16,000
The public outreach section of the. regional plan is lacking in.

683
01:35:16,000 --> 01:35:22,000
input from the unincorporated area. So I do encourage you to come out to where the people are present.

684
01:35:22,000 --> 01:35:28,000
Come out to each of the 18 community planning groups, come out to the sponsor groups. I know you've done a.

685
01:35:28,000 --> 01:35:36,000
A little bit of coming out to the. physical location, but there's a lot more to be done, and if you did, you might find that.

686
01:35:36,000 --> 01:35:43,000
programs such as the Youth Opportunity Pass. are equally embraced both in the urban and suburban setting and in the rural setting.

687
01:35:43,000 --> 01:35:48,000
But you also might find that the common themes under the CEQA.

688
01:35:48,000 --> 01:35:56,000
Uh, those themes might be quite different. When you… when you listen to the rural voice.

689
01:35:56,000 --> 01:36:00,000
Uh, finally, as a reminder, and for the record.

690
01:36:00,000 --> 01:36:06,000
As we move forward to develop this advisory seat into a voting seat in the new year.

691
01:36:06,000 --> 01:36:09,000
The Association of Planning Groups is comprised of all 18.

692
01:36:09,000 --> 01:36:16,000
elected official community planning groups. Those members are elected by their community, they're on a ballot.

693
01:36:16,000 --> 01:36:20,000
Their membership on the association is a voting seat.

694
01:36:20,000 --> 01:36:24,000
The community sponsor groups, who we also have invited to be part of.

695
01:36:24,000 --> 01:36:27,000
the association, because we want to hear their voice.

696
01:36:27,000 --> 01:36:32,000
They are not elected, and they are appointed by county supervisors to be on those boards.

697
01:36:32,000 --> 01:36:35,000
In our association, they also have advisory board member.

698
01:36:35,000 --> 01:36:41,000
status, they do not vote. Um, the Association of Planning Groups looks forward to increased equity.

699
01:36:41,000 --> 01:36:46,000
and representation in 2026. Thank you for presenting the regional plan.

700
01:36:46,000 --> 01:36:51,000
Thank you. Councilmember Molina. Thank you very much, Chair Huebner.

701
01:36:51,000 --> 01:36:58,000
Thank you for the presentation, and all of the comments regarding the EIR. I appreciate all of that.

702
01:36:58,000 --> 01:37:03,000
Ms. Antoinette, I wanted to ask you some clarification about.

703
01:37:03,000 --> 01:37:07,000
Uh, your comments regarding, um. The designation about rapid.

704
01:37:07,000 --> 01:37:13,000
Um, buses, and I know that our… or at least in the EIR, it does state expanding.

705
01:37:13,000 --> 01:37:22,000
Bus rapid transit, and, um, rapid bus lines. But, uh, can you help me understand what you… your comment earlier regarding.

706
01:37:22,000 --> 01:37:27,000
the actual definition of rapid, and perhaps it not quite.

707
01:37:27,000 --> 01:37:32,000
fitting to what we have for buses, for rapid bus lines?

708
01:37:32,000 --> 01:37:40,000
Thank you. And my comment was specific to Senate Bill 79, which says that a rapid bus has dedicated infrastructure exclusive for.

709
01:37:40,000 --> 01:37:53,000
the bus service. Uh, all-door boarding and transit signal priority, all of those things. We have some of those things in some areas in the region. At the regional plan level, though, we don't know what.

710
01:37:53,000 --> 01:38:07,000
types of priority measures we will have on a… on a particular route. It's really a line on a map that gets refined as we get into the more detailed planning alternatives analysis, and ultimately going through the environmental stage.

711
01:38:07,000 --> 01:38:16,000
But it is assumed that we will have some measures, maybe signal priority, queue jumps in some areas in dedicated lanes, managed lanes are.

712
01:38:16,000 --> 01:38:22,000
Um, planned throughout the regional network and will help to facilitate the rapid routes.

713
01:38:22,000 --> 01:38:35,000
But the exact, um… The exact route, the exact stops, and the exact priority measures are confirmed later in the planning alongside you and the transit operators.

714
01:38:35,000 --> 01:38:47,000
Okay, first Vice Chair La Cava. Oh, thank you, Chair. Uh, I want to thank Mario Antoinette, Kirsten, and all the staff who have worked so very hard to bring the regional plan, the environmental document forward.

715
01:38:47,000 --> 01:38:56,000
And all the public who have provided input, a plan we do every four years that was started in earnest 3 years ago, 3 years of relentless outreach and analysis.

716
01:38:56,000 --> 01:39:05,000
was documented in the presentation. The plan before us today delivers key projects across our region with more transit improvements than any prior plan.

717
01:39:05,000 --> 01:39:09,000
New bus routes, 36 neighborhood shuttles, and so much more.

718
01:39:09,000 --> 01:39:14,000
reflects the priorities we hear every day in our communities, improved mobility, affordability, climate action.

719
01:39:14,000 --> 01:39:23,000
economic opportunity. It's also rooted in reality, acknowledging our funding constraints and limitations. I appreciate the plan before us today.

720
01:39:23,000 --> 01:39:27,000
focuses on putting our dollars towards projects we can really deliver.

721
01:39:27,000 --> 01:39:31,000
It's a practical approach that will yield better, faster results for our region.

722
01:39:31,000 --> 01:39:35,000
We must continue to direct our focus on what we can realistically develop.

723
01:39:35,000 --> 01:39:43,000
and deliver within this time frame. The plan also reflects past promises made and our commitment to keeping those promises.

724
01:39:43,000 --> 01:39:48,000
And although this plant has the smallest roadway expansion footprints thus far, it does reflect.

725
01:39:48,000 --> 01:39:53,000
past promises kept to deliver some of those long-awaited projects in the pipeline.

726
01:39:53,000 --> 01:39:58,000
I appreciate the commitment to keeping and earning trust through the delivery of legacy projects.

727
01:39:58,000 --> 01:40:04,000
It is also important to note, as we've heard over and over again, that this plan is driven by the greenhouse gas reduction.

728
01:40:04,000 --> 01:40:12,000
target set by CARB. We are meeting this target by setting bold goals to focus future residential and employment growth, specifically in areas.

729
01:40:12,000 --> 01:40:17,000
With options like faster and frequent transit, complete corridors, flexible fleets.

730
01:40:17,000 --> 01:40:26,000
bikeways and walkable neighborhoods. Just playing Alliance Regional Investments with our local goals, strengthening connections between where people live, work, learn, and play.

731
01:40:26,000 --> 01:40:33,000
And residents in our region will see tangible improvements, better transit reliability, safer corridors, and cleaner air.

732
01:40:33,000 --> 01:40:40,000
I also want to thank not only the staff, but all the board members who have helped shape this plan over the past 4 years.

733
01:40:40,000 --> 01:40:45,000
And I'll close by adding my support for trying to figure out the funding solution.

734
01:40:45,000 --> 01:40:49,000
to the West Valley crossing, as we heard from the public testimony.

735
01:40:49,000 --> 01:40:55,000
Thank you, Mayor, and if it's appropriate, I'll go ahead and move. That'd be great. Thank you very much.

736
01:40:55,000 --> 01:41:00,000
Um, and we'll go to Deputy Mayor Chavez, and would you like to second this?

737
01:41:00,000 --> 01:41:07,000
I would like to say it. Very good. Sorry, I'm still dealing with the… sequels of some bronchitis.

738
01:41:07,000 --> 01:41:14,000
Um, so I'm just gonna be brief. We need more bathrooms. I can't express that enough.

739
01:41:14,000 --> 01:41:19,000
We need to include him. I know we have taken him away in the past.

740
01:41:19,000 --> 01:41:23,000
We need to find a way. We have a lot of elderly.

741
01:41:23,000 --> 01:41:32,000
Uh, use, um… just parents with children, we need to be mindful moving forward that we need to include more bathrooms. We need to do better.

742
01:41:32,000 --> 01:41:36,000
I can talk about the 125 being a necessity for the South Bay.

743
01:41:36,000 --> 01:41:41,000
You've heard me play this song like a broken record. I'm not going to give it up.

744
01:41:41,000 --> 01:41:47,000
We need this 125 to be free, and also the purple line, since we.

745
01:41:47,000 --> 01:41:53,000
house every single day, not house. But we have daytime visitors.

746
01:41:53,000 --> 01:42:00,000
Uh, around more than 100,000 people. coming from south to north to work to study for tourism.

747
01:42:00,000 --> 01:42:04,000
I would love to see a deadline in the near future for the purple line.

748
01:42:04,000 --> 01:42:14,000
And when that's happening, thank you so much. Very good. Um, Councilmember, um, Edson from NCTD.

749
01:42:14,000 --> 01:42:20,000
Thank you, Chair. And CTD's priorities for the plan include sprinter fleet replacement.

750
01:42:20,000 --> 01:42:26,000
Double tracking to improve system reliability and enhance transit rider experience.

751
01:42:26,000 --> 01:42:31,000
Coaster double tracking to improve system reliability and enhance the transit rider experience.

752
01:42:31,000 --> 01:42:40,000
grade separation along Coaster and sprinter corridors. to improve safety and reduce congestion in surrounding communities.

753
01:42:40,000 --> 01:42:51,000
Breeze bus increased capacity on key corridors. and CTD Plus implementation in strategic settings to support access to fixed-route transit service.

754
01:42:51,000 --> 01:42:59,000
Expand Transit's reach and respond to transit riders. desire for on-demand transit service.

755
01:42:59,000 --> 01:43:05,000
With regard to connections, new services in the regional plan should promote connections at key.

756
01:43:05,000 --> 01:43:13,000
transit hubs. Additionally, NCTD offers the following feedback. in response to the project's proposed in the plan.

757
01:43:13,000 --> 01:43:21,000
NCTD proposes including Sprinter fleet replacement as a transit project in the plan.

758
01:43:21,000 --> 01:43:28,000
And CTD suggests including a prioritized list of railroad grade separation projects.

759
01:43:28,000 --> 01:43:39,000
in an appendix to the plan. And finally, NCTD strong strongly supports the following near-term and long-term actions identified in the plan.

760
01:43:39,000 --> 01:43:50,000
Identifying sustainable funding to continue YOP. Developing a strategy for implementing grade separation projects that improve safety and rail operations.

761
01:43:50,000 --> 01:43:55,000
Continuing to implement low-san rail corridor improvement projects to improve safety.

762
01:43:55,000 --> 01:44:10,000
resiliency and reliability on the corridor. corridor, sorry. Continue seeking sustainable funding for transit operations and flexible fleets in partnership with MTS and NCTD.

763
01:44:10,000 --> 01:44:24,000
Thank you. Thank you. Councilmember Xin. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, staff, uh, so much for this presentation, and I, as I was trying my best to read the whole thing, that must be quite a bit of work that you guys created.

764
01:44:24,000 --> 01:44:30,000
Our city staff created a letter, and I know we got feedback back, and I just want us a little bit more clarification in regards to.

765
01:44:30,000 --> 01:44:40,000
Um, the EIR is Comprehensive countywide region-wide. Um, but the question was asked from our staff of sub-regional analysis.

766
01:44:40,000 --> 01:44:47,000
And I just wanted to get a better understanding of why we aren't able to do more sub-regional analysis on, um.

767
01:44:47,000 --> 01:45:01,000
you know, on our EIR and different strategies. What we're required to do is a regional analysis. That's not to say outside of the regional plan in the EIR, we couldn't work with you to, or your staff to look at sub-regional analysis.

768
01:45:01,000 --> 01:45:08,000
I think it, I think it should be considered, um, like almost across the board, you know, when I'm listening to everyone's concerns.

769
01:45:08,000 --> 01:45:11,000
I'm hearing about the rural areas, the urban areas.

770
01:45:11,000 --> 01:45:19,000
I would love to see, when I hear the comments and the stress about the 67 freeway, and it's so far removed from me.

771
01:45:19,000 --> 01:45:28,000
I'd love to see the metrics of not just the fact that the default is the regional area, but sub-regionally, we have to take exceptions, meaning that.

772
01:45:28,000 --> 01:45:35,000
Okay, the 67 may alleviate some traffic, but that might not be the priority why we're doing it. It may be the public safety reason.

773
01:45:35,000 --> 01:45:48,000
Or, um… Some folks live in the coastal area, some folks live in the inland area, and those sub-regions require such a dramatically, you know, different sense of permitting processes.

774
01:45:48,000 --> 01:45:54,000
What we can do. Some areas aren't built up for infrastructure, those costs are so different, and it would just be great to be able to.

775
01:45:54,000 --> 01:46:07,000
Kind of get a little bit more granular with these opportunities, as opposed to saying what works in one area must work in another. We kind of deal with that in regards to the state housing, and I would just like to see that we're not going to be the same, um.

776
01:46:07,000 --> 01:46:12,000
curators of that philosophy, if you will. So, yield back.

777
01:46:12,000 --> 01:46:20,000
Thank you very much. Mayor Gasterlin. Thank you so much. Antoinette, thank you for your time yesterday walking through this.

778
01:46:20,000 --> 01:46:25,000
And thank you for all the time for 4 years that have gone into this.

779
01:46:25,000 --> 01:46:29,000
You know, the next one's gonna start next week, right?

780
01:46:29,000 --> 01:46:37,000
Maybe 6 months. So, I wanted to say a little bit about how I approached reading the regional transportation plan and the EIR.

781
01:46:37,000 --> 01:46:48,000
Um, I first read the 471 pages of the appendix, which is SANDAG's responses to all of the comments that came into the EIR.

782
01:46:48,000 --> 01:46:52,000
I found Carlsbad's letter about the sub-regional analysis to be very compelling.

783
01:46:52,000 --> 01:47:01,000
I found the Coastal Commission's letter asking for consistency with the North County Coastal Cities LCP's Local Coastal programs.

784
01:47:01,000 --> 01:47:06,000
And sea level rise compelling. And I also found the Coastal Commission's.

785
01:47:06,000 --> 01:47:15,000
Making it clear, asking to make it clear that planning for realignment of the tracks in Del Mar, now I sound like a broken record.

786
01:47:15,000 --> 01:47:23,000
By 2035, be crystal clear in this plan. So, that brings me to three points, which are also questions.

787
01:47:23,000 --> 01:47:29,000
Um, one of the themes that came out was habitat and funding for habitat conservation.

788
01:47:29,000 --> 01:47:35,000
It mentions… Table 2 5. in the… in the RTP.

789
01:47:35,000 --> 01:47:42,000
talks about habitat for $1.5 billion. Could you elaborate on that a little bit?

790
01:47:42,000 --> 01:47:51,000
Um, so $1.5 billion is there for programs like the EMP, but this is above and beyond what we currently have in the EMP.

791
01:47:51,000 --> 01:48:01,000
Keith or Kirsten, I don't know if you want to talk a little bit about the types of programming that are covered by that funding.

792
01:48:01,000 --> 01:48:08,000
Keith, thank you also for yesterday's briefing. My pleasure. Good morning, Board. So, the question came up about the Habitat funding in the regional plan.

793
01:48:08,000 --> 01:48:15,000
So right now, the original plan looks at two things. One is the mitigation, that's the requirements to offset the transportation projects.

794
01:48:15,000 --> 01:48:17,000
And those are embedded in the cost in the regional plan.

795
01:48:17,000 --> 01:48:22,000
There's also a look ahead of what else would be needed above and beyond that for the region.

796
01:48:22,000 --> 01:48:30,000
The regional plan has a figure in there of $1.5 billion, as you mentioned, that's in the habitat plans for the acquisition and completion of the regional, um.

797
01:48:30,000 --> 01:48:34,000
acquisition of lands related to the regional plan itself.

798
01:48:34,000 --> 01:48:40,000
And you've heard today a desire for some people to push that beyond and to complete the funding for the region.

799
01:48:40,000 --> 01:48:45,000
So, that's above and beyond the regional plan itself. That would be an additional $1.5 billion.

800
01:48:45,000 --> 01:48:49,000
But there's a commitment in the regional plan to complete an assessment.

801
01:48:49,000 --> 01:48:54,000
of what's needed for the region to do the habitat conservation plans that many jurisdictions have approved.

802
01:48:54,000 --> 01:48:58,000
And what it would take to finish those plans up, both cost and actual implementation.

803
01:48:58,000 --> 01:49:02,000
That will be completed as part of the regional plan's near-term implementation this fall.

804
01:49:02,000 --> 01:49:08,000
Great, thank you. This is a really important part of the plan, and I wanted to make sure that we all understood that this is there.

805
01:49:08,000 --> 01:49:14,000
It… little tiny habitat losses can be huge. For example, the .28 wetlands that were lost.

806
01:49:14,000 --> 01:49:19,000
Recently, with a paving of. basically a half a mile of wetland along the toe of the bluff.

807
01:49:19,000 --> 01:49:32,000
Up above, east of the railroad tracks, the frogs aren't there anymore, they're gone. And I know I sound like a broken record on that also, but they're wonderful frogs, and we don't have many frog habitats here in San Diego County.

808
01:49:32,000 --> 01:49:45,000
TL003. is Oceanside to downtown San Diego, and it includes realignment in Del Mar. That's a $4.3 billion item that's only in the North County part.

809
01:49:45,000 --> 01:49:54,000
is that $4 billion mostly going to be the cost of the actual realignment itself?

810
01:49:54,000 --> 01:50:00,000
TL003.

811
01:50:00,000 --> 01:50:08,000
You can answer that question later if you don't have the answer immediately right now, that's okay, so let's pin that question.

812
01:50:08,000 --> 01:50:16,000
And the last is. in reading through all the items for each of the different regions, so we have North.

813
01:50:16,000 --> 01:50:21,000
County, East County, Central County, and South County, there's some elements that appear multiple times.

814
01:50:21,000 --> 01:50:34,000
An example is TL004, which is 9.144 billion. And that one is Camp Pendleton to downtown San Diego, grade separations, curve straightening, Miramar Tunnel.

815
01:50:34,000 --> 01:50:42,000
And that's a 2050 visionary. item, but it appears 3 times, so I just want to make sure that when you add it all up.

816
01:50:42,000 --> 01:50:46,000
That $9 billion is counted only once and not three times.

817
01:50:46,000 --> 01:50:52,000
So, can you confirm that.

818
01:50:52,000 --> 01:51:02,000
And if you don't have that right away, you can… yeah, let's just make sure the math is right. So we have… so, to summarize, we have a $125 billion strategic plan.

819
01:51:02,000 --> 01:51:13,000
It's all in, and I think it's very important to note that this is not just SANDAG's budget. This is also Caltrans. There are funds involved here that are Caltrans funds, MTS funds.

820
01:51:13,000 --> 01:51:22,000
NCTD and housing projects, and more. So, the $125 billion is more than SANDAG. Sandag's at the heart of it.

821
01:51:22,000 --> 01:51:29,000
So, I wanted to echo that. We talked about that yesterday.

822
01:51:29,000 --> 01:51:42,000
Hi, Rachel Kennedy, and um… One of the planning managers here at Zandig, so we do have some projects in Appendix A where we list them in multiple sub-regions, because they're projects that provide access and benefit to multiple sub-regions.

823
01:51:42,000 --> 01:51:48,000
But we only count the cost one time. So, yes, just making sure.

824
01:51:48,000 --> 01:51:55,000
Thank you, Mayor Minto. Well, thanks for the opportunity to speak. A lot of work, there's no doubt. Otherwise.

825
01:51:55,000 --> 01:52:02,000
It wouldn't have taken 3 or 4 years. Well, unless you guys just, you know, going that slow.

826
01:52:02,000 --> 01:52:08,000
I don't think so. So, I just kind of want to put some things into perspective.

827
01:52:08,000 --> 01:52:14,000
Uh, for, if not least for myself, for maybe many others, and.

828
01:52:14,000 --> 01:52:19,000
Others who are looking on. This is, I think, my third.

829
01:52:19,000 --> 01:52:23,000
Maybe my fourth regional plan that I've been involved in.

830
01:52:23,000 --> 01:52:29,000
And one thing that I realize is that. The county and the cities.

831
01:52:29,000 --> 01:52:36,000
are all responsible for transportation. and environment, and whatnot within their jurisdictions.

832
01:52:36,000 --> 01:52:42,000
Unfortunately, many, many years, or I should say fortunately, many, many years ago.

833
01:52:42,000 --> 01:52:45,000
It was found that we couldn't do that very well individually.

834
01:52:45,000 --> 01:52:51,000
The money wasn't there individually at the county level or the city level.

835
01:52:51,000 --> 01:52:57,000
So they created this crazy organization here to try and coordinate all that together.

836
01:52:57,000 --> 01:53:02,000
So, when we all talk about, um… specific regional, uh, areas.

837
01:53:02,000 --> 01:53:10,000
That's okay, because they have to be represented. And, uh, you know, Kevin, you touched on it, that we don't always.

838
01:53:10,000 --> 01:53:19,000
speak specifically about, like, for instance, I don't talk about what's going on in your neck of the woods, and you don't really talk about what's going on in my area.

839
01:53:19,000 --> 01:53:24,000
But I think one thing that we realize is that we do have to help each other to make sure that.

840
01:53:24,000 --> 01:53:33,000
things get accomplished. And so, uh, that's one thing that I want to continue to encourage everybody to keep thinking regionally.

841
01:53:33,000 --> 01:53:41,000
It's not just about our individual, um… places. And then, when we talk about reducing vehicle miles traveled.

842
01:53:41,000 --> 01:53:51,000
One of the things that we sometimes don't talk about is the fact that in the last few years we've been encouraging manufacturing and businesses.

843
01:53:51,000 --> 01:53:58,000
to spread out and not to be in just one area, whether it's a Sorrento Valley or downtown, etc.

844
01:53:58,000 --> 01:54:06,000
So what happens is that people don't necessarily always have to travel as far to go from maybe the East County to Serento Valley or downtown.

845
01:54:06,000 --> 01:54:10,000
And, uh, so that helps to reduce vehicle miles traveled.

846
01:54:10,000 --> 01:54:17,000
So having more, um, manufacturing and business. spread out is something that we should also continuously.

847
01:54:17,000 --> 01:54:22,000
Talked about with, with our economic development councils and our, even our, um.

848
01:54:22,000 --> 01:54:31,000
community, uh, chambers of commerce. Excuse me. One thing I do want to also talk about is, um.

849
01:54:31,000 --> 01:54:37,000
Some of the comments that were made about public safety as far as pedestrian and bicycle.

850
01:54:37,000 --> 01:54:45,000
lanes. And, um… There's… every bit of work that we do.

851
01:54:45,000 --> 01:54:52,000
to engineer bicycle lanes, pedestrian safety, and even motor vehicle safety.

852
01:54:52,000 --> 01:55:04,000
It can only go so far. We have to take into consideration that there are so many people out there that do not exercise personal safety when they're driving, walking, or bicycling.

853
01:55:04,000 --> 01:55:10,000
And as tragic as it is that there would be somebody severely injured or even killed.

854
01:55:10,000 --> 01:55:15,000
in these areas, we have to also remember it's not necessarily always the roadway or.

855
01:55:15,000 --> 01:55:22,000
the infrastructure that did that. I have personally bicycled over 6,000 miles.

856
01:55:22,000 --> 01:55:29,000
on the roads in East County, and part of La Mesa and Lemon Grove. I've mentioned it many times here.

857
01:55:29,000 --> 01:55:36,000
And I continue to see people that are riding bicycles in an unsafe manner. They ride on the wrong side of the street.

858
01:55:36,000 --> 01:55:46,000
I see people walking in the street where they shouldn't be, or you would think that common sense would say you don't walk in the street if there's a sidewalk.

859
01:55:46,000 --> 01:55:51,000
And so… and I don't want to say any of this to diminish.

860
01:55:51,000 --> 01:56:00,000
you know, the tragedies that occur. I just want us to also consider that we can't spend every dime that we have to make a street safe.

861
01:56:00,000 --> 01:56:17,000
When people won't act safely on those streets. and whatnot. So that was important for me. And then, and I do want to address real quickly that the gentleman that mentioned the pepper drive.

862
01:56:17,000 --> 01:56:25,000
Um, uh, bicycling lanes. And the fact that it would be pretty inexpensive just to.

863
01:56:25,000 --> 01:56:34,000
you know, draw some lines down there. Well, I've been on that road many times, and I try not to go on that road because it's unsafe.

864
01:56:34,000 --> 01:56:39,000
Not just because there's not a bicycle lane, but because the road conditions there are terrible.

865
01:56:39,000 --> 01:56:48,000
Um, it's really old there, for instance, and so there's not really a curb, there's not a gutter, there's no sidewalks.

866
01:56:48,000 --> 01:56:59,000
So you'd have to do a complete infrastructure change there, and I know that our supervisor for that area would love to do that, but you know what? The county still has limited funds also.

867
01:56:59,000 --> 01:57:05,000
And, um, I know in my city, we got a grant, and to me it was wasted money because.

868
01:57:05,000 --> 01:57:10,000
We put bicycle lanes on a roadway that was just unsafe for anybody to drive on.

869
01:57:10,000 --> 01:57:22,000
because of the condition of the roadway. And so then, you know, 6 months, a year later, we come by and we repave that road. Now we get to spend all that money again to put bicycle lanes and traffic lanes.

870
01:57:22,000 --> 01:57:27,000
So we also have to think about when do we put this stuff on the roadways?

871
01:57:27,000 --> 01:57:39,000
Are we spending money and then we're going to have to re-spend it, so that's a waste of time, waste of money, and I think we get a lot of that at our local levels. People talk about that thing all the time.

872
01:57:39,000 --> 01:57:42,000
Uh, why did you do this? You're wasting money.

873
01:57:42,000 --> 01:57:47,000
Well, I think we should at this much higher level, think about the same thing.

874
01:57:47,000 --> 01:57:53,000
What do we have to do first in order to save the greatest amount of money, to make our roads as safe as possible.

875
01:57:53,000 --> 01:57:59,000
Considering that not everybody appreciates. the work that we do, and that's all I have to say.

876
01:57:59,000 --> 01:58:06,000
Thank you, Mayor Jones? Thank you so much, Chair. Uh, first, I'd like to start by saying.

877
01:58:06,000 --> 01:58:11,000
This, um, this plan, thank you for all of the work that staff put into it.

878
01:58:11,000 --> 01:58:20,000
But also for leadership, because I have to say, after being on the board, uh, when the last plan came forward, and then now, it's a totally different experience.

879
01:58:20,000 --> 01:58:26,000
I actually feel heard, um, and I know that many of us, you know, do feel the same way.

880
01:58:26,000 --> 01:58:35,000
You know, um… the transparency that is in this, and not… Not having to feel like you have to look.

881
01:58:35,000 --> 01:58:40,000
and read things over and over to see if you're reading it right, because things are hidden.

882
01:58:40,000 --> 01:58:48,000
That, that to me is a big deal. Um, you know, so I do have a couple of clarifying questions, and then I have, um, some other comments.

883
01:58:48,000 --> 01:58:54,000
But first of all, there's no local road user charge or tax or fee or anything in this plan, right?

884
01:58:54,000 --> 01:59:07,000
Correct. Okay, I want everyone to hear that, so… When we have people out there dramatizing and acting like they're actually his one in here, there's not one in here that's a local road user tax or fee.

885
01:59:07,000 --> 01:59:12,000
Um, there is, however, the state one, which we have no control over. It is in this plan.

886
01:59:12,000 --> 01:59:20,000
Um, there's no federal one, though, but there was in our last… in the last plan, it was federal, state, and local. No local one in this one.

887
01:59:20,000 --> 01:59:25,000
Um, there is, however, a 3 quarter cent tax that will be.

888
01:59:25,000 --> 01:59:30,000
predicted, and this… so us approving this plan does not mean that we are approving a tax. It means.

889
01:59:30,000 --> 01:59:37,000
that we know that we're going to need some sort of funding mechanism that's about 3 quarters of a cent.

890
01:59:37,000 --> 01:59:44,000
You know, for me, I always talk about opium in my city. Everyone knows exactly what I mean when I say that, but it's other people's money.

891
01:59:44,000 --> 01:59:51,000
Um, I do know that we need to have local funds to get matching funds. So, uh, that's kind of the, um, the.

892
01:59:51,000 --> 01:59:58,000
more complex part of this. But, um, I do want to talk specifically about TransNet.

893
01:59:58,000 --> 02:00:06,000
I was thinking it ended in 2040, and then I looked on ChatGBT, and then I… and it said 2048, so it's actually 2048.

894
02:00:06,000 --> 02:00:12,000
Um, and then… and by the way, I never used it, I thought, you know, everyone tells me to use it, I'm going to fact check things.

895
02:00:12,000 --> 02:00:25,000
Um, so it… so this plan actually says that there'll be a new tax approved, I believe, in 2038, starting in 20… I think 2036. Is it 2039?

896
02:00:25,000 --> 02:00:31,000
Sorry. So this would be only if residents of the county.

897
02:00:31,000 --> 02:00:40,000
vote for this. Correct. Good morning. I'm Michelle Smith, Manager of Financial Programming. Yes, so we assume one, like, an additional transit sales tax in 2038.

898
02:00:40,000 --> 02:00:45,000
For the three quarters. The other sales tax that's closer is the MTS.

899
02:00:45,000 --> 02:00:50,000
sales tax that is assumed for 2036. And that would be just for the MTS service area?

900
02:00:50,000 --> 02:01:04,000
Correct, and the 2038, is it starts in 2038, or it's approved, and it needs to be approved in 2038? It would be approved in 2038, so what we assumed is, like, a small, like, a quarter of that would be in 2038, and the rest would start later.

901
02:01:04,000 --> 02:01:12,000
Correct, okay. Um, and then, um, okay, thank you on that. I just wanted to get clarification on that. You know.

902
02:01:12,000 --> 02:01:23,000
And, you know, back to the whole transparency. I know that all of North County, we've been talking time and time again, we did not want any current lanes, and this was in the last plan, which everyone knows.

903
02:01:23,000 --> 02:01:29,000
Um, no current lanes on the freeways to be converted.

904
02:01:29,000 --> 02:01:35,000
From a regular general-purpose lane into a managed lane, toll road, anything like that.

905
02:01:35,000 --> 02:01:40,000
I just want to get clarification on that, because again, you know, this is one of the things that we were running into.

906
02:01:40,000 --> 02:01:44,000
I think in the last plan that was so frustrating because.

907
02:01:44,000 --> 02:01:48,000
We would ask these questions, and our director at the time would say.

908
02:01:48,000 --> 02:01:58,000
Well, that's not what it says, but it actually was what it said. It was just named something different. So, I just want to get clarification. There are no lanes in.

909
02:01:58,000 --> 02:02:03,000
Um, in North County that are on… that are highway lanes on the 15, the 78.

910
02:02:03,000 --> 02:02:09,000
5 that are going to be converted to. Um, lanes that are general-purpose lanes.

911
02:02:09,000 --> 02:02:19,000
the HOV lanes on the 5, but not the general purpose lanes, and we're adding managed lanes on the 78. Correct, adding not… it's a new add, not something that's current and existing. This is a.

912
02:02:19,000 --> 02:02:25,000
big deal, because, you know, we've talked about this time and time again, it's been very frustrating.

913
02:02:25,000 --> 02:02:30,000
And I did see in here, finally, uh, the, um… oh, let me find it real quick.

914
02:02:30,000 --> 02:02:39,000
My tabs everywhere. Uh, the… Uh, TL046 on page A20 of Appendix A.

915
02:02:39,000 --> 02:02:50,000
That's the, um, new, uh, bus rapid transit. So, I do want to… I do want to mention that, because 2035 is when it's predicted to happen.

916
02:02:50,000 --> 02:03:00,000
Um, is that correct? No, so we don't do year-by-year phasing in the regional plan, so that's by 2035. We kicked off planning for that now, so the likelihood that it'll be much sooner.

917
02:03:00,000 --> 02:03:11,000
Uh, than 2035, but it's in that time frame, the early years of the plan. Perfect. I wanted to double check on that because, you know, we have the new Scripps Hospital that's coming to San Marcos specifically, and then Kaiser Permanente just opened up.

918
02:03:11,000 --> 02:03:16,000
Um, but that's going to land at, um, and that's from Riverside.

919
02:03:16,000 --> 02:03:21,000
To regular area to Palomar College, and then, um, also CSUSM.

920
02:03:21,000 --> 02:03:39,000
Correct? Yes, and we're doing the route planning now, so if there are other stops that you want us to consider, we'll be working with your staff and CTD and the other jurisdictions to identify that. So I've specifically heard from Palomar Hospital, and then also Kaiser Permanente. So those two, if we haven't reached out to them, I would definitely.

921
02:03:39,000 --> 02:03:53,000
Um, like, for that to happen. And then, um… let's see… I think that was it. I mean, I really am just loving the, um… the NCTD Plus, which, you know, I know Jewel's here today for them.

922
02:03:53,000 --> 02:04:05,000
We… we really are, um, finding that that is so helpful for people in our community. Obviously, we want to expand that, but I really like seeing that we're also bringing that to Fallbrook.

923
02:04:05,000 --> 02:04:11,000
And some of the unincorporated areas, because. If you don't have it yet, and I know, um, Escondido, uh, Dane's over there.

924
02:04:11,000 --> 02:04:18,000
You're gonna love it. It's great, it's on demand. Our residents really find it beneficial, and they can't.

925
02:04:18,000 --> 02:04:28,000
They just can't say enough about it. So, anyway, I love it when I come into my little neighborhood and I see it… I see it there, um, uh, stopped and picking up people, so it's really a great thing.

926
02:04:28,000 --> 02:04:34,000
Um, and I know that our high school students want to use it, so I think that's one of the things that would be helpful, and.

927
02:04:34,000 --> 02:04:38,000
Other than that, um, oh, one other thing. Sb375.

928
02:04:38,000 --> 02:04:47,000
When do we think there might… we might see some reform on that? Because there's been a lot of discussion about that. We will be coming to the Executive Committee in January.

929
02:04:47,000 --> 02:04:52,000
To bring up where we are with the discussions.

930
02:04:52,000 --> 02:04:57,000
and ask guidance from the Executive Committee. Where we should continue going.

931
02:04:57,000 --> 02:05:02,000
And might some executive committee members end up going to Sacramento to talk about this?

932
02:05:02,000 --> 02:05:04,000
Because I would love to be part of that.

933
02:05:04,000 --> 02:05:08,000
I know Chair Huebder and I have talked about that. Um, we definitely need.

934
02:05:08,000 --> 02:05:14,000
to hear from everyone, I think. That, you know, we need to perform on this and some relief.

935
02:05:14,000 --> 02:05:24,000
Perfect. Thank you. Thank you. Um, Councilmember Fisher. Thank you, Chair. I just want to echo the sentiments from Mayor Jones. You know, when I was on the board a few years back.

936
02:05:24,000 --> 02:05:34,000
All we talked about was the mileage tax and getting it out of the plan, and it really was… Um, I felt it was laborious just hearing about it. I can't imagine how staff felt about having to go back and.

937
02:05:34,000 --> 02:05:39,000
create a plan and get all the approvals. Um, it's good to see a plan that doesn't involve this.

938
02:05:39,000 --> 02:05:43,000
Um, big thing of 5 big moves and all the stuff that seems.

939
02:05:43,000 --> 02:05:52,000
like, it'd be nice, but probably unrealistic, and staff have to just run around and figure out how to do it. And to Mayor… to Mayor Jones' comments, you know, we heard a lot from.

940
02:05:52,000 --> 02:05:56,000
from the seat over here that made us think things were okay, but.

941
02:05:56,000 --> 02:06:03,000
Um, it really wasn't. There wasn't a whole lot of transparency, so I appreciate the transparency, I appreciate staff bringing something to the board.

942
02:06:03,000 --> 02:06:09,000
Um, that's very practical in nature. Um, you know, I can't imagine what it's like doing a plan like this. I feel like it's probably.

943
02:06:09,000 --> 02:06:15,000
Akin to having a family of 6 going on vacation, having to pack all their clothes for 2 seasons, and.

944
02:06:15,000 --> 02:06:18,000
three weeks in a suitcase and hoping it fits on the airplane.

945
02:06:18,000 --> 02:06:27,000
Um, and is okay, but… Uh, staff always does a great job with this. We've heard a lot of support for the Youth Opportunity Pass. I'm a big believer.

946
02:06:27,000 --> 02:06:33,000
That it has been good for our region. I've mentioned it once in a board meeting, probably a little bit more passively, but.

947
02:06:33,000 --> 02:06:38,000
I, you know, as we go forward, I really want to look at something, providing something for our seniors.

948
02:06:38,000 --> 02:06:42,000
Um, and it's something that, you know, be like a senior responsibility pass.

949
02:06:42,000 --> 02:06:45,000
youth at some point turn into young adults into adults.

950
02:06:45,000 --> 02:06:52,000
Seniors don't really change from being seniors. And we know that there are large populations going for.

951
02:06:52,000 --> 02:06:59,000
Um… being unhoused, and I'm sure the financial strains are very difficult on them, and I think that it would be.

952
02:06:59,000 --> 02:07:03,000
something that we should look at, um, because at some point.

953
02:07:03,000 --> 02:07:10,000
We will have a lot of seniors who will be needing transportation and probably will be struggling, unlike our youth, who we've heard from today.

954
02:07:10,000 --> 02:07:14,000
grateful they're here in attendance and to speak up, that's wonderful.

955
02:07:14,000 --> 02:07:21,000
Uh, but I think our seniors should probably have some opportunities in the future to have access to transit for a reduced or free.

956
02:07:21,000 --> 02:07:27,000
Uh, Kosh, thank you. Thank you, Supervisor Geary.

957
02:07:27,000 --> 02:07:40,000
Thank you, Chair. I want to start by thanking staff for all of their work around this plan. I think it's really great that it's guided by convenience, equity, health, and safety.

958
02:07:40,000 --> 02:07:47,000
Obviously, those are priorities for our region that we've all, including the board and staff, have been working very, very hard to.

959
02:07:47,000 --> 02:08:01,000
prioritize. I… I want to center my remarks around equity. I think that it's incredibly important to ensure that people have the same opportunities in all of our regions throughout the county.

960
02:08:01,000 --> 02:08:15,000
I think it's very important to make sure that our public transit, for example, offers opportunities, especially for, uh, you know, young adults that are on their path to entering the workforce.

961
02:08:15,000 --> 02:08:29,000
have the ability to reach job centers that are accessible by transit. So I think I really like that we're moving in the right direction with the purple line. I think that's incredibly important.

962
02:08:29,000 --> 02:08:39,000
I think it's also important to, um… look at, uh, the 24-hour, um, and express service for the blue line, the backbone of our public transit system.

963
02:08:39,000 --> 02:08:49,000
That is, um, so important for so many people who work and come across the border on a daily basis. I think that's incredibly important.

964
02:08:49,000 --> 02:08:57,000
Um, I think it's really important to focus on the flexible fleet microtransit, because it not only brings benefits, uh.

965
02:08:57,000 --> 02:09:11,000
to reducing greenhouse gas emissions, but especially in unincorporated areas and more of the rural areas, or where there's more limited public transit, like in North County, I think that first mile, last mile traveled will be essential.

966
02:09:11,000 --> 02:09:16,000
And by implementing these types of fleets will be very important, so I appreciate that we're focusing on that.

967
02:09:16,000 --> 02:09:23,000
And then as it relates to safety, I think it's great that we're focusing on complete.

968
02:09:23,000 --> 02:09:35,000
corridors. Um, I just wanted to mention the Federal Highway Administration evaluation show that complete corridor treatment reduces crashes by 19 to 47%.

969
02:09:35,000 --> 02:09:45,000
with strong reductions in pedestrian safety. raise medians and pedestrian refuge islands, reduce pedestrian crashes by 46%.

970
02:09:45,000 --> 02:09:51,000
Curb extensions, uh, reduce pedestrian crashes for… by up to 40%.

971
02:09:51,000 --> 02:09:55,000
And we know that every 10 miles per hour that are reduced.

972
02:09:55,000 --> 02:10:05,000
the likelihood of someone surviving increases. So, if you are involved in a crash, if you're a pedestrian that gets struck by a car moving at 40 miles per hour.

973
02:10:05,000 --> 02:10:09,000
Your likelihood of surviving is something close to 5%.

974
02:10:09,000 --> 02:10:14,000
If it's 30 miles per hour, your chances of surviving increase.

975
02:10:14,000 --> 02:10:28,000
Especially, uh, when you're talking about between 20 and 25 miles per hour, your chances of surviving exceed 85 to 90%. Now, I'm not advocating, of course, for free waste to be limited to 20 miles per hour.

976
02:10:28,000 --> 02:10:32,000
But it's important, because as we look at the next 5 years.

977
02:10:32,000 --> 02:10:39,000
planning regionally, these complete corridors are incredibly important for especially families that are walking their kids.

978
02:10:39,000 --> 02:10:46,000
seniors that are, um, having trouble crossing a very wide roadway and may not be.

979
02:10:46,000 --> 02:10:52,000
fast enough to beat the red light. We are seeing an unprecedented amount of.

980
02:10:52,000 --> 02:11:03,000
deaths, I'm pretty sure you've been watching it every day on the news. There's some new, you know, accident, a fatal accident, and I think it's important that.

981
02:11:03,000 --> 02:11:17,000
You know, we do it planning well. It may not be right for some communities, as Mayor Mintel mentioned, but for example, on Imperial Beach, where we have… it's a bedroom community where we have a lot of young families with kiddos.

982
02:11:17,000 --> 02:11:31,000
That's absolutely essential to ensure that families. Can… can walk to and from school, uh, in a safe way. So I think that's, that's really important, and I'll just close with, um.

983
02:11:31,000 --> 02:11:34,000
banking, uh, staff again for all of your hard work.

984
02:11:34,000 --> 02:11:43,000
Um, and echoing my colleagues' calls to. Uh, address the issue with the 125.

985
02:11:43,000 --> 02:11:49,000
and continuing to uplift the Youth Opportunity Passes, which is incredibly important to me, too.

986
02:11:49,000 --> 02:11:55,000
Thank you very much. Thank you, Mayor Sanchez.

987
02:11:55,000 --> 02:12:02,000
Thank you very much, um, I want to thank staff for the presentation. Um, I actually want to thank, um.

988
02:12:02,000 --> 02:12:09,000
staff and, uh, my colleagues. Um, because it's my first year on SANDAG.

989
02:12:09,000 --> 02:12:12,000
And, of course, I had heard a few things about.

990
02:12:12,000 --> 02:12:16,000
What had happened in the past, and so I wondered what this year was going to be like.

991
02:12:16,000 --> 02:12:26,000
I want to say that I've been. Thoroughly amazed at the level of cooperation, coordination, and just.

992
02:12:26,000 --> 02:12:32,000
being able to be heard as the most northern city in San Diego County.

993
02:12:32,000 --> 02:12:41,000
Um, and certainly… having different needs than, say, a metropolitan area. I've really appreciated being heard.

994
02:12:41,000 --> 02:12:48,000
Um, uh, it's, it's, uh, at certain levels at government, uh, you know, we feel like.

995
02:12:48,000 --> 02:12:52,000
Uh, there are certain assumptions that are made that just don't apply.

996
02:12:52,000 --> 02:12:58,000
And so, uh, for me to be able to see that our diverse.

997
02:12:58,000 --> 02:13:10,000
communities in San Diego County, um. the needs are being heard and are being taken into consideration by regional plans and by, um.

998
02:13:10,000 --> 02:13:18,000
I want to say our colleagues here. is truly refreshing, and for me, it's about unity and trying to get the best for our entire.

999
02:13:18,000 --> 02:13:25,000
Um, county. Um… in Oceanside especially.

1000
02:13:25,000 --> 02:13:30,000
We have over 60… I think it's about 64%.

1001
02:13:30,000 --> 02:13:38,000
of our workforce driving. I'm talking about how we need to reduce our greenhouse gas.

1002
02:13:38,000 --> 02:13:46,000
Um, to work. every day. How do… and that's… that's a… something that we need to figure out how to do.

1003
02:13:46,000 --> 02:13:50,000
Um, for me, and in what I'm seeing, it's the microtransit.

1004
02:13:50,000 --> 02:13:59,000
has really, really helped. And is helping us to, um, in terms of planning internally to meet the needs of our community.

1005
02:13:59,000 --> 02:14:05,000
And it does sound like this year there's even more interest in microtransit. I think.

1006
02:14:05,000 --> 02:14:13,000
Others have said, this is what we need, this is the gap, this is something that we thought we were going to get 25 years ago.

1007
02:14:13,000 --> 02:14:17,000
Um, we're getting it now. I feel that this.

1008
02:14:17,000 --> 02:14:22,000
Um, does build trust. This is kind of like ground zero.

1009
02:14:22,000 --> 02:14:34,000
In terms of, okay, this is where we're heading. If we are going to be needing another tax, it is going to get a lot more of us at the table saying, yeah, this, you know, we can all agree.

1010
02:14:34,000 --> 02:14:42,000
These are their needs based on, you know, all the needs of our diverse, geographically diverse communities.

1011
02:14:42,000 --> 02:14:48,000
Then we can, you know, look to. a better future for our communities.

1012
02:14:48,000 --> 02:14:55,000
Um, yesterday I was a little down because I heard that 6 of our businesses were closing.

1013
02:14:55,000 --> 02:14:59,000
Mostly restaurants. even longtime, long-term ones.

1014
02:14:59,000 --> 02:15:04,000
And I know that, uh, you know, things for us, um, and I'm sure in other places.

1015
02:15:04,000 --> 02:15:07,000
some of our affordable housing is being replaced by.

1016
02:15:07,000 --> 02:15:15,000
unattainable housing, high density, and we don't want to see that. We want to ensure that we can.

1017
02:15:15,000 --> 02:15:24,000
be able to survive and thrive. Um, as communities, each one of us. So… We're looking to see how can we make things better at every level.

1018
02:15:24,000 --> 02:15:30,000
So, thank you very much. Thank you. Um, I see Mayor Minto is back up again.

1019
02:15:30,000 --> 02:15:35,000
Yeah, I'm sorry about having to speak a second time, but there's something I completely forgot.

1020
02:15:35,000 --> 02:15:46,000
Hard to believe, right? Um… Mario mentioned the, um… Caltrans and Highway 52 meeting we had last night, and.

1021
02:15:46,000 --> 02:15:50,000
CNT. And the reason why I wanted to bring it up, because it's about hope.

1022
02:15:50,000 --> 02:15:58,000
Uh, you know, in 2019, I came up with this crazy idea about doing some things to increase the flow of traffic on.

1023
02:15:58,000 --> 02:16:09,000
Highway 52, because for so long, almost since the day it was built, all I ever heard was complaints about, we can't get out of Santee. People from El Cajon can't get through the bottlenecks.

1024
02:16:09,000 --> 02:16:15,000
And so, um, people coming southbound on the 15, coming home, can't get to.

1025
02:16:15,000 --> 02:16:19,000
the transition to the 52 East, uh, very well.

1026
02:16:19,000 --> 02:16:27,000
And so, we started talking with, uh, Sandag, of course. We met with all the leaders over at Caltrans.

1027
02:16:27,000 --> 02:16:38,000
Uh, very early on, then started just going out, you know, around the communities and talking then with the state representatives, the federal representatives, even the U.S. Chamber of Commerce saying.

1028
02:16:38,000 --> 02:16:48,000
We need help and so, um… Unfortunately, things were, uh… delayed a little bit because of some pandemic thing.

1029
02:16:48,000 --> 02:16:53,000
But, um, but what happened in 2019, one of the ideas was to.

1030
02:16:53,000 --> 02:16:59,000
Uh, take and create a new transition from 15 south to 52 east.

1031
02:16:59,000 --> 02:17:07,000
And so, even though we were raising the money, Caltrans saw that that was an extremely important, um.

1032
02:17:07,000 --> 02:17:13,000
project to take on. And believe it or not, from the inception of that concept of doing that.

1033
02:17:13,000 --> 02:17:23,000
to the engineering, the planning, design. Um, environmental, all the stuff that normally goes into that.

1034
02:17:23,000 --> 02:17:29,000
Today, that actually is… that portion of it is completed. The transition has changed.

1035
02:17:29,000 --> 02:17:33,000
And it is actually much easier to get on the 52 East.

1036
02:17:33,000 --> 02:17:38,000
So, for a 5-year, from conception to completion, and I'm talking about.

1037
02:17:38,000 --> 02:17:41,000
construction, that means, you know, pavement on the ground.

1038
02:17:41,000 --> 02:17:51,000
5 years is absolutely almost unheard of. So, if you work hard enough, and you have really good partners.

1039
02:17:51,000 --> 02:17:57,000
And District 11 is one of the best partners in Caltrans, in my opinion.

1040
02:17:57,000 --> 02:18:04,000
to work with because we do things that other places, when I'm traveling around the state, talking to other cities.

1041
02:18:04,000 --> 02:18:07,000
They're always asking, how do you get those things done?

1042
02:18:07,000 --> 02:18:14,000
Today, we're in the process of getting some changes on the 52 going westbound so that we can get those, uh.

1043
02:18:14,000 --> 02:18:23,000
the bottlenecks that happen in Santee, which. causes actually some environmental harm, um, because of all the cars.

1044
02:18:23,000 --> 02:18:27,000
idling, we expect now, and take that from about.

1045
02:18:27,000 --> 02:18:30,000
Um, it was scheduled to be done in 2050.

1046
02:18:30,000 --> 02:18:34,000
And we expect that to be completed now, I think, in 2034.

1047
02:18:34,000 --> 02:18:39,000
So to, you know, reduce, um, you know, that kind of.

1048
02:18:39,000 --> 02:18:54,000
issue by 25 years. Uh, we're gonna have to still work on some of the other things, the 78… the 67, but uh… We… I think we have some good formulas to get that work done a lot sooner and a lot faster.

1049
02:18:54,000 --> 02:18:59,000
than we ever thought that could be done, so I just wanted to give that message of hope.

1050
02:18:59,000 --> 02:19:06,000
That's good, thank you. Um, Councilmember Edson? Thank you, Chair.

1051
02:19:06,000 --> 02:19:14,000
Mayor Jones touched on the mixed rapid 483, which reminded me that I'd neglected to mention that NCTD.

1052
02:19:14,000 --> 02:19:25,000
has expressed concerns regarding the mixed rapid 483. Commuter Express from Temecula to Palomar Airport College via I-15, SR-78.

1053
02:19:25,000 --> 02:19:33,000
USM due to budget and operational constraints. Um, we support the concept, absolutely.

1054
02:19:33,000 --> 02:19:40,000
But request that it come with a sustainable source of operations… operational funding.

1055
02:19:40,000 --> 02:19:47,000
Um, also, I just wanted to take a moment to acknowledge and thank staff for the work that went into creating the plan.

1056
02:19:47,000 --> 02:19:55,000
And, um, the robust contributions from the board. And from the public are also appreciated.

1057
02:19:55,000 --> 02:20:01,000
Thanks. Thank you. Councilmember Lee.

1058
02:20:01,000 --> 02:20:06,000
Thank you, Chair. And, um, thank you to the team for your hard work on bringing this plant to fruition.

1059
02:20:06,000 --> 02:20:20,000
Of course, only been here for the tail end of it, or at least what feels like that, but the… efforts to really engage the public, I think, have been critical here, and what I always recognize is that what everyone is advocating for doesn't necessarily all make it into the plan.

1060
02:20:20,000 --> 02:20:28,000
Uh, for a variety of reasons, and we should be willing to acknowledge that the plan's not going to address every need that has been expressed.

1061
02:20:28,000 --> 02:20:31,000
But it is an opportunity for us to really chart.

1062
02:20:31,000 --> 02:20:41,000
in the realistic time frame, what we believe. can be accomplished. I find that, same thing with the City of San Diego, we often struggle, I think, as agencies to.

1063
02:20:41,000 --> 02:20:45,000
Think about what we're planning in terms of capacity and a vision.

1064
02:20:45,000 --> 02:20:51,000
And then what actually can come to fruition as well. And we both, you need to be able to dream and have a vision that is.

1065
02:20:51,000 --> 02:20:58,000
Um, long-term and bold enough that you can be shooting for something, but you also actually have to have projects that can be completed.

1066
02:20:58,000 --> 02:21:04,000
Um, and I do believe that this RTP does accomplish a bit of that. There are a couple things in it that I do want to.

1067
02:21:04,000 --> 02:21:09,000
Note in particular, um, one is the increase of microtransit and the.

1068
02:21:09,000 --> 02:21:17,000
talk about community shuttles. For me in particular, the Kerni Mason convoy area is one that has been discussed quite a bit, at least within the City of San Diego.

1069
02:21:17,000 --> 02:21:23,000
Um, being a growing, uh, both industrial, commercial, soon residential hub.

1070
02:21:23,000 --> 02:21:30,000
Tied to that, though, is of course, the purple line, and I want to acknowledge all those who have continued to advocate.

1071
02:21:30,000 --> 02:21:35,000
And fight for ensuring that the Purple Line is not just on a back burner somewhere, but that it is.

1072
02:21:35,000 --> 02:21:40,000
part of the long-term vision of what we need to accomplish, just maybe not within the shorter time frame that we've.

1073
02:21:40,000 --> 02:21:48,000
previously envisioned. The purple line, I think, is going to be critical for the region, especially, again, running up through some of the most critical.

1074
02:21:48,000 --> 02:21:54,000
economic corridors, especially in that Serena Valley, Serena Mesa area, moving forward.

1075
02:21:54,000 --> 02:22:00,000
And then one last thing I just thought I would ask about, since it came from some of the public comment, even today.

1076
02:22:00,000 --> 02:22:05,000
Um, but as we look at designing bike infrastructure in the region.

1077
02:22:05,000 --> 02:22:08,000
And I know there's always going to be a debate about.

1078
02:22:08,000 --> 02:22:17,000
Where and what infrastructure is wanted, needed, etc. Um, those debates will always happen, but when we have put into a plan.

1079
02:22:17,000 --> 02:22:24,000
Um, infrastructure that we are… planning on. I think it's important that we have best practices that help us guide.

1080
02:22:24,000 --> 02:22:29,000
the design of that infrastructure. And so, I know folks have mentioned that some of the previous.

1081
02:22:29,000 --> 02:22:36,000
language around design standards, specifically with NACTO. But aren't lined out in this plan.

1082
02:22:36,000 --> 02:22:43,000
And wanted to ask again. You know, the thinking behind that, and how SANDAG plans to move forward so that as we guide.

1083
02:22:43,000 --> 02:22:51,000
bike infrastructure from a SANDEC perspective, we ensure that design guidelines are applicable across the region.

1084
02:22:51,000 --> 02:23:08,000
Thank you, Councilmember. So, at the regional plan level, we don't get into project-specific design. We don't have design guidelines for any of the projects. Our transit projects, the roadway projects, um, and that is why the NACDO design guidelines were removed between draft and final, because it's really not appropriate at the regional plan level. We get into that.

1085
02:23:08,000 --> 02:23:14,000
when we start designing bike projects, and you all do when you start designing bike projects.

1086
02:23:14,000 --> 02:23:20,000
Thank you again for sharing that as well. That concludes my comments. Thank you. Mayor Jones, did you have a follow-up comment?

1087
02:23:20,000 --> 02:23:29,000
You're on the board. Yes, sorry, I just… it was about the funding. So, um, I know that Riverside used to actually fund a part of that, um.

1088
02:23:29,000 --> 02:23:34,000
Uh, that bus rapid from Riverside, so maybe we check out… check with them to see if.

1089
02:23:34,000 --> 02:23:39,000
They would be willing to, um… be participating in that.

1090
02:23:39,000 --> 02:23:43,000
Yeah, once we implement. project-specific mitigations.

1091
02:23:43,000 --> 02:23:52,000
and the environmental document that, um. Hasn't yet been finalized for 1578, but it's in the process. The draft went out.

1092
02:23:52,000 --> 02:24:00,000
It has on the mitigation that part of the managed lane revenues will be going to subsidized transit.

1093
02:24:00,000 --> 02:24:11,000
Which is into that line. Um, you know, I have to say that, like Antoine has said, it's not a project-specific, the regional plan.

1094
02:24:11,000 --> 02:24:15,000
the regional plan, it says Snapchat of what we can achieve by 2035.

1095
02:24:15,000 --> 02:24:23,000
or post-2035 to 2050. to achieve those goals that the federal government and the state governments are asking us.

1096
02:24:23,000 --> 02:24:30,000
then we have to have, and we have begun the conversation on funding priorities, and we began that here.

1097
02:24:30,000 --> 02:24:37,000
just recently, and we will continue that. Um, so it is very important.

1098
02:24:37,000 --> 02:24:40,000
that we understand that this is kind of the big snapshot.

1099
02:24:40,000 --> 02:24:44,000
But we do have some challenges ahead of us.

1100
02:24:44,000 --> 02:24:53,000
How do funding specific projects. And also, a big challenge that the entire San Diego region, north, south, east, west, will have to have.

1101
02:24:53,000 --> 02:25:00,000
All of us is also dealing with the financial clips that are transit agencies are dealing with.

1102
02:25:00,000 --> 02:25:04,000
So that's a big conversation. It's not within the regional plan.

1103
02:25:04,000 --> 02:25:09,000
conversation, but we are bringing it up, uh, and I think it is something that.

1104
02:25:09,000 --> 02:25:18,000
during the next coming calendar year. leadership here, as well as in North County Transit and MTS Boards.

1105
02:25:18,000 --> 02:25:21,000
as well as each of your individual city councils.

1106
02:25:21,000 --> 02:25:41,000
We have to have that hard discussion. Yeah, and you know, just to follow up on that, um, so recently, well, I guess it was last week, um, I was speaking to leadership over at NCTD, and I was mentioning, you know, there are a lot of beneficiaries from these specific projects. Like, for instance, in my city, with the microtransit.

1107
02:25:41,000 --> 02:25:46,000
You have Palomar, you have CSU San Marcos, you have the school district.

1108
02:25:46,000 --> 02:25:51,000
San Marcos Unified, and then also North City, which is our new downtown that's emerging.

1109
02:25:51,000 --> 02:26:01,000
I suggested to them that we start having meetings to talk about what they would be willing to participate in, because financing isn't all going to come from one place.

1110
02:26:01,000 --> 02:26:07,000
Again, I'm going to say it again, opium. Um, other people's money, I mean, when we cobble money together, it's less.

1111
02:26:07,000 --> 02:26:18,000
the one person paying for it, and it's, you know, kind of spread out. So, um, if we aren't having conversations with the transportation agency up in Riverside, I suggest we at least start that.

1112
02:26:18,000 --> 02:26:25,000
Um, so that we can see what their level of interest would be. And then we figure out who benefits the most.

1113
02:26:25,000 --> 02:26:29,000
And again, you know, back to the participants that actually would benefit.

1114
02:26:29,000 --> 02:26:38,000
Palomar Hospital, CSU San Marcos, Palomar College. Scripps, Kaiser, I mean, all of the different, um, you know, if you could make a stop.

1115
02:26:38,000 --> 02:26:48,000
then there should be some participation level financially in that. And not to deviate from the conversation of the regional plan, but you brought up SB375 in.

1116
02:26:48,000 --> 02:26:53,000
setting up some trips to have those discussions in Sacramento.

1117
02:26:53,000 --> 02:27:02,000
Um, next year, the funding package for the transportation bill is up for discussion in Congress.

1118
02:27:02,000 --> 02:27:10,000
So, I think we will organize as a region also to advocate at the federal level all the different funding paths for the next.

1119
02:27:10,000 --> 02:27:16,000
transportation bills, so… Hopefully you can come with us also to watch it in that advocacy. Absolutely.

1120
02:27:16,000 --> 02:27:27,000
Yes, thanks. Road trip, we'll all go. Um, well, thank you, everybody. Thank you, staff, so very, very much. I have to say, it was really gratifying to hear all of the comments.

1121
02:27:27,000 --> 02:27:39,000
Um, there was a real intentional change in the way this particular RTP was crafted. As was said, it was started 3 years ago, so if you're new to this board, the person who is sitting in your seat.

1122
02:27:39,000 --> 02:27:46,000
previously was in workshops, drawing lines and putting stickies on maps, and really working hard to.

1123
02:27:46,000 --> 02:27:58,000
do the… put on their regional hat as well as their city hat, and understand that this is a required plan. We've got all these goals that we have to meet, metrics that we have to meet.

1124
02:27:58,000 --> 02:28:04,000
Um, but this turns out to be a really great example of what happens when you listen to the locals.

1125
02:28:04,000 --> 02:28:16,000
Um, it would be lovely if other levels of government did the same thing. But when you listen to the locals, you can actually put together a plan that works for us all, because the beauty of this region is in our diversity.

1126
02:28:16,000 --> 02:28:25,000
And I mean that in every sense of that word. Each of our cities is unique in terms of the regional plan. Each of them is unique, and for us to.

1127
02:28:25,000 --> 02:28:31,000
homogenize our cities into one is just not what we want to do. We want to maintain.

1128
02:28:31,000 --> 02:28:44,000
our attributes, um, but also get around the region. The transportation plan doesn't know boundaries, so we need to work together to make sure that how they land in each of our communities works.

1129
02:28:44,000 --> 02:28:53,000
A reminder, as Mario said, this is a high-level plan. It's, um, as he said, a snapshot, but it's a really wide lens of a snapshot.

1130
02:28:53,000 --> 02:29:04,000
And each project that's in here, and again, these are, you know, visionary, they're… they each have to have their own plan. They're each going to come… it's got its own path, basically, to conclusion.

1131
02:29:04,000 --> 02:29:10,000
into construction. It's gonna have to have a design, it's gonna have to go through environmental.

1132
02:29:10,000 --> 02:29:21,000
We're gonna have the discussion about, are we gonna fund it or not? Is it going to be in the RTIP, which is the 5-year plan where we know, you know, that's what's getting done, that's getting funded, and it will be built?

1133
02:29:21,000 --> 02:29:27,000
And then there's construction, and then there's ribbon cutting. So we do this every four years. I think it's, uh.

1134
02:29:27,000 --> 02:29:41,000
And really great exercise to, uh, each of us to understand each other's cities a little bit more, too, and recognize the continuity that we want within our region, but also the, um, the uniqueness that we would like to maintain.

1135
02:29:41,000 --> 02:30:04,000
So with that, I'm going to close the public hearing, and let's vote on this. We have two, um… Uh, so the action is, uh, today to adopt Resolution 2026-08 and 2026-09, certifying the final EIR and adopting the 2025 Regional Plan.

1136
02:30:04,000 --> 02:30:08,000
Alrighty. I pass this with one note, and the rest, yeses.

1137
02:30:08,000 --> 02:30:11,000
And we are now going to go on to.

1138
02:30:11,000 --> 02:30:16,000
The assessment of SANDEG's finance department. The team will present items 5.1 and 5.2.

1139
02:30:16,000 --> 02:30:46,000
Followed by public comment, and then member discussion. Courtney.

1140
02:32:08,000 --> 02:32:14,000
So, are you ready?

1141
02:32:14,000 --> 02:32:20,000
Yes, Chair. Chair.

1142
02:32:20,000 --> 02:32:24,000
Chair Fisher, did you want to… Oh, I'm sorry, let me, um, turn this over to Councilmember Fisher.

1143
02:32:24,000 --> 02:32:28,000
to introduce this item. As the chair of the Audit Committee.

1144
02:32:28,000 --> 02:32:36,000
Thank you, Chair. Uh, board members. Uh, last week we got the, uh, results from the assessment that was done by Weaver.

1145
02:32:36,000 --> 02:32:41,000
Regarding the, uh, financial… the finance department. Oh, we had a good, robust discussion.

1146
02:32:41,000 --> 02:32:48,000
A lot of transparency. Not only from Weaver, from the audit side, but also from staff.

1147
02:32:48,000 --> 02:32:53,000
They were there, they were present, and you really could see the collaboration and bring this forward, you know.

1148
02:32:53,000 --> 02:32:58,000
Been through a few audits this year. Uh, assessment's a little bit different than an audit.

1149
02:32:58,000 --> 02:33:04,000
And some of the findings that we have were, um… kind of eye-opening, if you will.

1150
02:33:04,000 --> 02:33:10,000
Uh, but again, it helps us build up a roadmap of where the agency needs to be in the future.

1151
02:33:10,000 --> 02:33:17,000
Uh, and it was mentioned earlier that, you know, there's different assessments going on that one we'll see in the future for.

1152
02:33:17,000 --> 02:33:21,000
HR department, but it really was, uh… an eye-opener, and again, nothing that we probably was surprised, but.

1153
02:33:21,000 --> 02:33:30,000
Overall, you know, the key is that. This agency still operates well, still is really well-regarded in the nation, is very high functioning.

1154
02:33:30,000 --> 02:33:41,000
We continue to receive. funds much more in excess of what our budget is, and that continues. And so, some of the things that will be discussed today may be a little bit by opening.

1155
02:33:41,000 --> 02:33:50,000
Uh, to the board members, but I really want to thank Courtney for getting this going, finding a fine company with Weaver and the work that they did.

1156
02:33:50,000 --> 02:33:55,000
And again, the collaboration between Weaver and staff to work together.

1157
02:33:55,000 --> 02:33:59,000
To get the assessment done and to get to the point where.

1158
02:33:59,000 --> 02:34:05,000
It could get presented to the board at this point, so thank you.

1159
02:34:05,000 --> 02:34:15,000
Thank you, Chair. Good morning. I'm Courtney Ruby. I'm the Independent Performance Auditor, also known as the IPA, and as such, I am the Chief Audit Executive at SANDAG.

1160
02:34:15,000 --> 02:34:21,000
I'm pleased to introduce the Accounting and Finance Independent Assessment conducted by Weaver LLC today.

1161
02:34:21,000 --> 02:34:26,000
I'm joined by Rima Parapili, partner and subject matter IT Advisor.

1162
02:34:26,000 --> 02:34:31,000
and Holly Hart, Director and Project Manager for this engagement.

1163
02:34:31,000 --> 02:34:36,000
I'd like to give a little background as to why this report is before you today.

1164
02:34:36,000 --> 02:34:42,000
When I first became IPA, I was immediately thrust into the investigation of SR125.

1165
02:34:42,000 --> 02:34:47,000
The investigation found ETAN's Fastlane financial reporting could not be relied upon.

1166
02:34:47,000 --> 02:34:51,000
And the accounting and finance department lacked adequate internal controls.

1167
02:34:51,000 --> 02:34:59,000
Including proper review and supervision to ensure SR125's financial information was accurately recorded.

1168
02:34:59,000 --> 02:35:06,000
and reported. The investigation recommended an independent assessment of the accounting and Finance Department's policies.

1169
02:35:06,000 --> 02:35:17,000
procedures and practices. As a result, I wrote the scope of work that was advertised and is included in the transmittal letter that precedes the assessment.

1170
02:35:17,000 --> 02:35:22,000
Weaver was successfully awarded the work and has done an outstanding job.

1171
02:35:22,000 --> 02:35:32,000
Additionally, Weaver's assessment, when needed, extended into the areas that would provide greater operational insight and value to SANDAG's leadership.

1172
02:35:32,000 --> 02:35:38,000
I do want to highlight this work evaluated the current state in the operational areas being assessed.

1173
02:35:38,000 --> 02:35:51,000
It is not an audit, which typically looks backwards, but instead an assessment of the current state of operations. Holly will go over this as well in her introduction, as well as the Chair mentioned it in his comments.

1174
02:35:51,000 --> 02:36:00,000
I want to acknowledge SANDAC's Accounting and Finance Department and senior leadership for their patience, fortitude, and commitment to this assessment.

1175
02:36:00,000 --> 02:36:06,000
In addition to budget management, project management, and other senior managers who assisted in the assessment.

1176
02:36:06,000 --> 02:36:16,000
Management provided their response to the report at the same time that the Office of the Independent Performance Auditor, or what we factionally call OIPA.

1177
02:36:16,000 --> 02:36:22,000
release the report. And I'm pleased to report that management has stated their agreement with all the recommendations.

1178
02:36:22,000 --> 02:36:30,000
We will meet with management in the coming week to hash out the details to ensure we have actionable agreement that aligns with the recommendations.

1179
02:36:30,000 --> 02:36:35,000
And can be reported out during OYPA's annual and quarterly CAP reporting processes.

1180
02:36:35,000 --> 02:36:45,000
CAPSAN stands for Corrective Action Plan. I will now hand the presentation over to Holly Hart from Weaver to present the report findings and recommendations.

1181
02:36:45,000 --> 02:37:04,000
And then management will present their response next. Holly? So… I'm gonna start, but… My apologies. No worries. Um, so we had a strong team that helped support this, and one of the team members that's not available today is Brandon Tanos. He was the overall engagement partner.

1182
02:37:04,000 --> 02:37:08,000
Um, along with Holly that focus more on the overall accounting.

1183
02:37:08,000 --> 02:37:15,000
and operations areas then, kind of, my team and my role is really to focus on the IT area, and we really work together over those.

1184
02:37:15,000 --> 02:37:25,000
To broad subject matters. As Courtney described, we did an assessment, so separate from an audit where we are looking at the past and.

1185
02:37:25,000 --> 02:37:31,000
We're writing at a conclusion, we are really doing this assessment to be able to provide recommendations over the current state of the environment.

1186
02:37:31,000 --> 02:37:38,000
And to be able to look at those results and to be able to provide kind of a state of where you are and what those recommendations can look like, which.

1187
02:37:38,000 --> 02:37:48,000
management has started to think about, start to work on. We started our procedures earlier in the spring and are really reporting it out to you today, but management has been.

1188
02:37:48,000 --> 02:37:55,000
Um, aware of the things that they need to work on, and then this kind of really solidified it and kind of give them some direction on what.

1189
02:37:55,000 --> 02:38:06,000
What we looked at and the things that they recognized also needed some areas of improvement. And so the focus area of what we did as part of this assessment, which you can see really looked at the finance and accounting department over those.

1190
02:38:06,000 --> 02:38:17,000
process areas, accounting, finance, revenue, project control, toll operations accounting, and we really focus on a number of key functions and core functions in that. And then we also looked at.

1191
02:38:17,000 --> 02:38:23,000
the state of the ERP system implementation that occurred a couple years ago to really understand.

1192
02:38:23,000 --> 02:38:31,000
how that system implementation. Um, was performed, and then how has that helped support the processes that are occurring in the.

1193
02:38:31,000 --> 02:38:40,000
Uh, finance and accounting departments as well. So we did a number of different items, and one of the other areas that we looked at was really performing a, um.

1194
02:38:40,000 --> 02:38:56,000
skills assessment, which I'll have colleague go over. Thanks, Rima. Yes, so, uh, we also… included an organizational structure and skills assessment as part of this project, and that was really to look at role clarity, responsibilities.

1195
02:38:56,000 --> 02:39:02,000
qualifications, credentials, the three, what we like to call the three pillars of a successful.

1196
02:39:02,000 --> 02:39:15,000
competent team. And so, we also looked at how these teams collaborate, and I just want to be clear as well that this was not a staffing-level assessment. We didn't look at cycle times or.

1197
02:39:15,000 --> 02:39:28,000
do a heavy analysis of the, uh. various quantification of tasks that were performed, but we all… but we did identify some general resource constraints within the InScope process areas.

1198
02:39:28,000 --> 02:39:41,000
as a root cause of some of the conditions that we found at a high level, some of the procedures that we performed, again, as is an assessment, they were done in collaboration with the management team.

1199
02:39:41,000 --> 02:39:51,000
Looking at the current state, as Courtney mentioned, we looked at policies and procedures, looking at the internal controls benchmark to globally recognized internal control frameworks and standards.

1200
02:39:51,000 --> 02:40:01,000
We did lots of stakeholder interviews and follow-ups where needed to ensure that we had a good understanding of the current state, validating that understanding, making sure there was clarity.

1201
02:40:01,000 --> 02:40:08,000
between us and management and to how things were operating in its current state, we looked at evidence, a lot of various.

1202
02:40:08,000 --> 02:40:14,000
pieces of documentation. Uh, to validate and ensure that we had an accurate understanding.

1203
02:40:14,000 --> 02:40:21,000
Uh, and of course, really dug into the technology and systems implementation component, as you guys are transitioning.

1204
02:40:21,000 --> 02:40:29,000
in various systems in your current state. So, as a result of our assessment, we identified what we call our core themes.

1205
02:40:29,000 --> 02:40:37,000
We grouped these in core themes because they generally, overall, as you're going through the report, the results of the assessment.

1206
02:40:37,000 --> 02:40:51,000
really do kind of shine through, and so looking at the results through the lens of these core themes can help orient you in terms of what to really focus on whenever we're talking about our roadmap as well.

1207
02:40:51,000 --> 02:41:02,000
We had 18 observations associated with our recommendations, which we categorized into various groups as they naturally related to the process areas in which we found them.

1208
02:41:02,000 --> 02:41:10,000
Next slide. All right.

1209
02:41:10,000 --> 02:41:24,000
So to go a little bit more into those core themes, and I'll just provide a brief overview of these. They are not necessarily in any particular order. The first one is very critical and foundational to all the others, which is why it is first.

1210
02:41:24,000 --> 02:41:33,000
regarding governance and oversight, really an overarching theme for this assessment. We definitely identified the need for more.

1211
02:41:33,000 --> 02:41:46,000
clear oversight. governance and accountability, particularly within the areas of budget management, ERP, systems implementation, and of course, some of those core key accounting controls that we've identified throughout.

1212
02:41:46,000 --> 02:41:57,000
The assessment. The second area was really policies, procedures, and internal controls. Really, the backbone of your control environment and how we ensure that we implement.

1213
02:41:57,000 --> 02:42:09,000
our risk mitigation strategy in terms of control activities consistently. So we evaluated that and found that there is definitely a need for some standardization of key accounting controls as well as.

1214
02:42:09,000 --> 02:42:19,000
system implementation protocols to close some identified gaps that we identify in those controls, especially the ones that are fundamental to ensuring.

1215
02:42:19,000 --> 02:42:30,000
accurate, complete financial reporting, as well as ensuring that the information, operational information that's received by management, the board, and other stakeholders is also completely accurate.

1216
02:42:30,000 --> 02:42:36,000
We have a list of appendices in our report that have additional details if you're.

1217
02:42:36,000 --> 02:42:43,000
If you want to dig into that. The third area, uh, core theme, technology and systems integration.

1218
02:42:43,000 --> 02:42:47,000
really looking at some of the gaps in the implementation lifecycle that have.

1219
02:42:47,000 --> 02:42:58,000
limited the ERP's impact. Not that we can't move forward and continue to work on those things, but definitely some areas where in our.

1220
02:42:58,000 --> 02:43:04,000
requirements as we're going through the life cycle to better ensure that it's, uh.

1221
02:43:04,000 --> 02:43:15,000
really impactful and ensure… it meets our requirements as we configure our systems and work to reduce manual workarounds and improve reporting.

1222
02:43:15,000 --> 02:43:31,000
The fourth area, performance measurement and accountability. really, here we identify some opportunities to better define different various performance metrics that would give both management and the board insights into how effective our processes are in these various areas.

1223
02:43:31,000 --> 02:43:36,000
Particularly in the areas of budget management as well as IT governance. There are some.

1224
02:43:36,000 --> 02:43:47,000
very well-recognized KPIs that we think could be used in these areas to ensure that there's always a pulse on how effective we are in these areas.

1225
02:43:47,000 --> 02:43:57,000
The fifth core theme, Training and Workforce Development. Here we identified a lack of some formal development that is consistent with specific job responsibilities and duties.

1226
02:43:57,000 --> 02:44:03,000
As well as a need to formalize role-based training and then.

1227
02:44:03,000 --> 02:44:12,000
Look at how we emphasize and are intentional about the credentials and qualifications and experience that we expect for our workforce.

1228
02:44:12,000 --> 02:44:17,000
The second, uh, the sixth one here, the sixth core theme, change management and communication.

1229
02:44:17,000 --> 02:44:31,000
Change management is also fundamental and foundational to almost every evolving thing that goes on at Zandag, whether it's a new business process or assistance implementation, change management is always going to be a part.

1230
02:44:31,000 --> 02:44:41,000
of that journey to ensuring that it's an effective transition. And so, we did identify that there is a need for some consistency in our change management processes in both the process.

1231
02:44:41,000 --> 02:44:49,000
business process and the technology change. Um, and adoption and transition.

1232
02:44:49,000 --> 02:44:55,000
Uh, to ensure that we adopt and sustain our technology as well as integrate necessary updates.

1233
02:44:55,000 --> 02:45:06,000
to the business processes as we are implementing that technology. And then the seventh core theme here, roles, responsibilities, and collaboration. We did identify various ad hoc practices.

1234
02:45:06,000 --> 02:45:14,000
that don't have necessarily some well-defined. Uh, areas of roles, uh, responsibility, accountability, who's informed, who's consulted.

1235
02:45:14,000 --> 02:45:23,000
You know, really that foundational framework of ensuring that those roles and responsibilities are well-defined to reduce cross-departmental.

1236
02:45:23,000 --> 02:45:28,000
Um, to increase cost of departmental coordination and ensure clear understanding.

1237
02:45:28,000 --> 02:45:40,000
for optimal financial management and your operational processes. Okay, so as we talked about the core themes, we did identify, out of our 48.

1238
02:45:40,000 --> 02:45:50,000
48 recommendations, some priority actions that we hope can help orient management into where to focus on in both.

1239
02:45:50,000 --> 02:46:04,000
the short-term, medium-term, and long-term. So we will go into those a little bit. Those top 10 priority actions, the first one is really on the internal controls and compliance framework.

1240
02:46:04,000 --> 02:46:12,000
Here, we would recommend really standing up a unified internal controls and compliance.

1241
02:46:12,000 --> 02:46:17,000
framework. This is really evaluating our agency-wide controls in these finance accounting processes.

1242
02:46:17,000 --> 02:46:24,000
As we know, there's a lot of cross-functional activities and process and controls in these areas.

1243
02:46:24,000 --> 02:46:45,000
And so, having a well-recognized framework that defines key controls, owners, frequency, the various key components of internal control, and also looking at our residual risk and how are we comfortable with our mitigation strategy, and that can also be used to ensure consistency in succession planning.

1244
02:46:45,000 --> 02:46:48,000
And just make sure that everybody's on the same page about our control framework.

1245
02:46:48,000 --> 02:46:54,000
The second priority action is establishing that true technology and ERP governance.

1246
02:46:54,000 --> 02:47:12,000
Uh, structure. centralizing our IT governance, which we recommend to be led by a qualified CIO equivalent to oversee that technology strategy decision-making and issue escalation and ensure alignment between technology and the various business processes that technology is.

1247
02:47:12,000 --> 02:47:21,000
is touching. And then the third priority action here is really raising expectations for management competencies that are associated with.

1248
02:47:21,000 --> 02:47:28,000
those three pillars of qualification that I mentioned, which include experience, education, and credentials.

1249
02:47:28,000 --> 02:47:34,000
Uh, and tracking that training centrally, prioritizing high-quality technical training that is.

1250
02:47:34,000 --> 02:47:42,000
very clearly tied to specific job responsibilities. The fourth one, Titan System Implementation Quality Gates.

1251
02:47:42,000 --> 02:48:01,000
requirements such as traceability, testing, and go-live criteria. These are the critical actions that are needed for truly any systems implementation or major update to a system, anything that has a material or significant impact when we are transitioning our technology.

1252
02:48:01,000 --> 02:48:07,000
making sure that we map requirements to our testing before we go live, formal pre-go-live validations.

1253
02:48:07,000 --> 02:48:20,000
sign-offs and documented… we document any workarounds so that it's very clear to everybody in the agency. If for some reason there was something that was affected, um, that's well documented and we know our strategy and how we're going to.

1254
02:48:20,000 --> 02:48:27,000
Uh, implement various, uh… Or alternative methods of getting what we need from those systems.

1255
02:48:27,000 --> 02:48:37,000
The fifth one, institutionally and key accounting reconciliations. policy-approved templates and executive oversight, as well as the 6-1 centralization of invoice management.

1256
02:48:37,000 --> 02:48:47,000
and establishing risk-based approvals. These are specific challenges and opportunities to increase control effectiveness in key accounting controls, specifically.

1257
02:48:47,000 --> 02:48:54,000
Making sure that there are policies and expectations around these key accounting controls.

1258
02:48:54,000 --> 02:49:01,000
And also, centralizing certain areas of our invoicing processes.

1259
02:49:01,000 --> 02:49:16,000
To help with visibility, making sure that we are meeting our expectations for our stakeholders and making those payments and strengthening our vendor relationships as well as ensuring compliance.

1260
02:49:16,000 --> 02:49:23,000
The next four priority actions here are also focused on improving controls for some key financial management processes.

1261
02:49:23,000 --> 02:49:31,000
Uh, including oversight of funding sources, toll revenue accounting, and reporting, budget management, and grant payments and reimbursements.

1262
02:49:31,000 --> 02:49:35,000
The seventh when that centralized billing oversight across all funding sources.

1263
02:49:35,000 --> 02:49:47,000
This is really focused on creating a single mechanism with management review for real-time visibility into billing progress across our projects and programs, including our program requirements and deadlines.

1264
02:49:47,000 --> 02:49:55,000
all know that we have a lot of various funding sources that are critical to tracking and overseeing to ensure that we continue to meet our mission as an agency.

1265
02:49:55,000 --> 02:50:01,000
Stabilizing toll revenue accounting and reporting, reducing some single-point reliance that we.

1266
02:50:01,000 --> 02:50:08,000
identified, uh, to, um, ensure that those workarounds that are currently in place right now.

1267
02:50:08,000 --> 02:50:17,000
between Fastlane and ERP are well documented. any necessary reconciliations and reviews are happening on a consistent basis.

1268
02:50:17,000 --> 02:50:26,000
And then making sure that we have a path to reducing that single point of reliance as well as an integration between our accounting systems and the back-end tooling.

1269
02:50:26,000 --> 02:50:33,000
Uh, accounting system. 9 clarifying budget ownership and enforcing continuous budget to actual monitoring.

1270
02:50:33,000 --> 02:50:40,000
another key area of SANDAG that's critical to ensuring from a project management perspective that we're on track.

1271
02:50:40,000 --> 02:50:48,000
That's publishing agency-wide budgeting roles and responsibilities, as I mentioned before, making sure that we're performing that monthly, quarterly.

1272
02:50:48,000 --> 02:50:54,000
And, um, you know, as often as it's necessary, even real time if possible.

1273
02:50:54,000 --> 02:51:02,000
Uh, looking at budget to actual, and what is those variances, and why do we have those variances, and implementing a mandatory mid-cycle review.

1274
02:51:02,000 --> 02:51:08,000
And then finally, increasing grant reimbursement expectations, payments, controls, and visibility.

1275
02:51:08,000 --> 02:51:19,000
Grants are another critical area for the agency. Ensuring that we align our program guides to that, to our 30-day payment requirements, tracking receipt date status, any delay reasons.

1276
02:51:19,000 --> 02:51:26,000
And then reporting that compliance upwards to leadership as needed.

1277
02:51:26,000 --> 02:51:31,000
And just for a visual for you guys, the priority actions and recommended roadmap.

1278
02:51:31,000 --> 02:51:46,000
You know, in something like this, execution matters to ensure that an assessment like this is fully realized to its maximum benefit. So we did provide you a 0-18 month roadmap that aligns each priority action with a timeline for implementation.

1279
02:51:46,000 --> 02:51:55,000
Focusing on internal controls, IT governance, training, reconciliation, all the great priority actions that we talked about before, and that 0-6 month timeline.

1280
02:51:55,000 --> 02:52:04,000
timeline, really, the internal control framework, which we would say is definitely a high priority on those actions, standing up ERP governance.

1281
02:52:04,000 --> 02:52:15,000
initiating both the improved or enhanced credentialing and training program as well as quality gates for system implementation.

1282
02:52:15,000 --> 02:52:24,000
and proper change management, and then also looking at our institutionalizing all the various 50-plus reconciliations that occur in SANDAG.

1283
02:52:24,000 --> 02:52:34,000
Then within that 6 to 12 month timeline. Some of the things that might require a little bit more effort, especially the things that are cross-functional, across multiple departments.

1284
02:52:34,000 --> 02:52:39,000
Such as centralizing invoice receipts, approval, deploying that centralized billing oversight.

1285
02:52:39,000 --> 02:52:49,000
Which requires project management involved, stabilizing the toll revenue processes that we discussed, and embedding budget monitoring cadences throughout the agency.

1286
02:52:49,000 --> 02:52:55,000
And then some ongoing areas which will continue to evolve for SANDAG and should have an intentional focus.

1287
02:52:55,000 --> 02:53:00,000
is maturing our performance and KPI dashboards, automating and.

1288
02:53:00,000 --> 02:53:13,000
Automating integrations, completing those training pathways, and then hardening governance routines to improvement sustained through future system changes, which is ongoing.

1289
02:53:13,000 --> 02:53:26,000
That's all our prepared material, and so, uh, I think we're going to go through management response, and we welcome your feedback and questions. Thank you.

1290
02:53:26,000 --> 02:53:37,000
Once our team is setting up. They're gonna come in, give… their responses here, um… I think our… I want to start with.

1291
02:53:37,000 --> 02:53:53,000
a couple of comments here. Um, and probably go back a little bit and, uh… A little bit of memory lane, and… What have we done? We began, um… 18 months ago.

1292
02:53:53,000 --> 02:54:03,000
The first objective was to stabilize. Enhance trust inside and outside the agency.

1293
02:54:03,000 --> 02:54:11,000
and assess and implement. And that's the phase where we're at, assessing, implementing.

1294
02:54:11,000 --> 02:54:16,000
And we truly, truly appreciate this. Now, also.

1295
02:54:16,000 --> 02:54:24,000
SANDAC is… is… I want to go back and just… High level, what is SANDAC?

1296
02:54:24,000 --> 02:54:33,000
SANDAC is a very complex organization that meets multiple purposes, and it's probably very unique in the state.

1297
02:54:33,000 --> 02:54:42,000
It's an MPO, the planning organization. If you go to LA, there's one huge organization called SCACT.

1298
02:54:42,000 --> 02:54:46,000
But it only does the MPO. It only does the planning.

1299
02:54:46,000 --> 02:54:52,000
Ink here, our… Our responsibility as the MPO.

1300
02:54:52,000 --> 02:54:57,000
is we look at the transportation network, as well as we provide some housing.

1301
02:54:57,000 --> 02:55:03,000
information and policy. through a consolidation act.

1302
02:55:03,000 --> 02:55:09,000
that was passed around 2008. If my memory serves right.

1303
02:55:09,000 --> 02:55:16,000
We are also a capital delivery. agency, which other MPOs are not.

1304
02:55:16,000 --> 02:55:24,000
So we are responsible to delivering the transit projects, planning and delivering the transit project for San Diego County.

1305
02:55:24,000 --> 02:55:30,000
and coordinating with the state, Caltrans. on the state highway system.

1306
02:55:30,000 --> 02:55:35,000
projects. So that's another site, another business of SANDAC.

1307
02:55:35,000 --> 02:55:45,000
We are a toll operating agency. which we operate the SR125, we operate.

1308
02:55:45,000 --> 02:55:53,000
the I-15 managed lanes were the very first ones in the nation with having dynamic tolling.

1309
02:55:53,000 --> 02:55:59,000
So that came, that idea in the nation came out of SANDAC.

1310
02:55:59,000 --> 02:56:08,000
And we are in the process. of implementing a substantial amount of mileage of future managed lanes.

1311
02:56:08,000 --> 02:56:14,000
We are an agency that acts and houses. criminal justice information.

1312
02:56:14,000 --> 02:56:18,000
for every single police department that your city has.

1313
02:56:18,000 --> 02:56:23,000
Either via the county sheriff's department or your individual cities.

1314
02:56:23,000 --> 02:56:28,000
We are an information data center for both transportation, housing.

1315
02:56:28,000 --> 02:56:38,000
And in addition that houses, RGS houses, we also do criminal justice data analysis.

1316
02:56:38,000 --> 02:56:43,000
That's just a snapshot of what you all have as a responsibility.

1317
02:56:43,000 --> 02:56:47,000
But that's a snapshot of what each of those leaders in front of you.

1318
02:56:47,000 --> 02:56:55,000
are responsible to manage. with more than 100 different colors of money to be managed.

1319
02:56:55,000 --> 02:57:03,000
All of them with different requirements. That creates a humongous amount of stress in the organization.

1320
02:57:03,000 --> 02:57:07,000
of how we manage all that and keep the accounting.

1321
02:57:07,000 --> 02:57:12,000
I truly, truly appreciate this assessment. Because this is that.

1322
02:57:12,000 --> 02:57:17,000
turning point, like I said. We came, we stabilized.

1323
02:57:17,000 --> 02:57:23,000
We worked on enhancing the trust inside and out. We still need to work on that.

1324
02:57:23,000 --> 02:57:27,000
And we are now in that assessment, but also implementation.

1325
02:57:27,000 --> 02:57:37,000
And all that… While we're keeping an organization moving, and you just saw an awesome regional plan.

1326
02:57:37,000 --> 02:57:42,000
delivered. So… giving a tune-up to the car?

1327
02:57:42,000 --> 02:57:48,000
Changing the tires, and we're driving it in the freeway. That's no easy task.

1328
02:57:48,000 --> 02:57:55,000
So, you… you all have an incredible setup, more than 400 employees who really are working hard.

1329
02:57:55,000 --> 02:58:01,000
Among them, OYPA, who's really working hard on highlighting where we can get better.

1330
02:58:01,000 --> 02:58:11,000
So I really, really appreciate this assessment. Like I said in my opening statements, we're also internally doing an assessment of the organizational structure.

1331
02:58:11,000 --> 02:58:17,000
Optolabs, we will be putting out a request for proposals.

1332
02:58:17,000 --> 02:58:26,000
for an assessment of our HR department. We have had discussions about how we are going to go about.

1333
02:58:26,000 --> 02:58:31,000
our future management of our toll systems and the business structure of it.

1334
02:58:31,000 --> 02:58:36,000
And we will be having more conversations. So I just wanted to put it.

1335
02:58:36,000 --> 02:58:40,000
out there of all what's going on, all what the team is doing.

1336
02:58:40,000 --> 02:58:46,000
And in the… in the meantime, there is a humongous amount of opportunities.

1337
02:58:46,000 --> 02:58:49,000
There is a lot of places where we can work.

1338
02:58:49,000 --> 02:58:54,000
and focus and get better. No doubt about it, but I'll let the team.

1339
02:58:54,000 --> 02:58:57,000
tell you a little bit what they have identified.

1340
02:58:57,000 --> 02:59:02,000
And what they're working on, because the assessment, as well as all the other past.

1341
02:59:02,000 --> 02:59:08,000
uh, audits, let it be from OIPA or FDA or any other group.

1342
02:59:08,000 --> 02:59:13,000
I don't know, it compiles about 200 action items, or whatever. I can't remember.

1343
02:59:13,000 --> 02:59:16,000
I do have a meeting and keep track of them.

1344
02:59:16,000 --> 02:59:23,000
bringing that together with the assessments is one… what's going to help us make a better organization.

1345
02:59:23,000 --> 02:59:29,000
And it's a journey. It's a journey. It's not something that's going to happen tomorrow.

1346
02:59:29,000 --> 02:59:37,000
Team, take it over. Thank you. Good afternoon, I am Shanae Pickney-Forest, the Director of Internal Controls.

1347
02:59:37,000 --> 02:59:46,000
With me today is Kim Trammell, Director of Accounting and Finance, Susan Huntington, Director of Financial Planning, Budgets, and Grants.

1348
02:59:46,000 --> 02:59:53,000
Grace Mino, Senior Director of Data Science in Bits, and Don Vatis, our Chief Financial Officer.

1349
02:59:53,000 --> 02:59:57,000
We're here to provide an overview of our management response.

1350
02:59:57,000 --> 03:00:04,000
And today's presentation, we want to acknowledge that we agree with the recommendations from the Weaver Assessment.

1351
03:00:04,000 --> 03:00:09,000
We do thank Courtney and her team, as well as Weaver, for their observations.

1352
03:00:09,000 --> 03:00:17,000
The assessment identified 7 key areas where strengthened internal controls can help improve and elevate SANDAG's accounting.

1353
03:00:17,000 --> 03:00:26,000
finance and budgeting functions. We'll discuss how some of the core themes in the report relate to some of our existing efforts.

1354
03:00:26,000 --> 03:00:35,000
The report provided confirmation that we are on the correct track with the areas we prioritize and presented to you.

1355
03:00:35,000 --> 03:00:43,000
In earlier months related to policies and procedures. documentation, training, and change management.

1356
03:00:43,000 --> 03:00:52,000
The report also provides us with insight regarding the need for specific improvements within our budgeting, accounting, and IT departments.

1357
03:00:52,000 --> 03:00:57,000
Our team will then provide an overview of specific next steps within their respective.

1358
03:00:57,000 --> 03:01:06,000
Uh, purview. So, as you see in this slide, and as Holly discussed earlier.

1359
03:01:06,000 --> 03:01:11,000
The report summarized its observations into seven core themes.

1360
03:01:11,000 --> 03:01:22,000
We want to highlight that 3 of these themes we have as an internal focus as we continue to focus on the basics and bolster our foundational practices.

1361
03:01:22,000 --> 03:01:29,000
So, for example, with policies and procedures. We are in the process of finalizing our policy framework and guidance.

1362
03:01:29,000 --> 03:01:38,000
This framework is providing guidance that will standardize the content and the structure of the various types of guidance we have within the organization.

1363
03:01:38,000 --> 03:01:45,000
We're continuing to identify, draft, and or revise policies as specified in other audits.

1364
03:01:45,000 --> 03:01:56,000
other assessments and through internal discussion. The Weaver report also identified for us specific areas, um, where specific policy and procedure areas.

1365
03:01:56,000 --> 03:02:09,000
to enhance within our accounting and budgeting practices. Within the training and workforce development, we are currently identifying the needed content and training hours for our organization.

1366
03:02:09,000 --> 03:02:14,000
wide training plan. which has been informed by previous audits, assessments.

1367
03:02:14,000 --> 03:02:22,000
regulations and internal discussions. We're identifying mandatory trainings, trainings that are mandatory by legislation.

1368
03:02:22,000 --> 03:02:28,000
and required trainings, trainings that we're currently identifying internally as necessary.

1369
03:02:28,000 --> 03:02:36,000
to conduct job responsibilities. In that plan, we've also already identified anticipated training hours.

1370
03:02:36,000 --> 03:02:41,000
So we have training hours slated for budgeting and invoicing practices are ready.

1371
03:02:41,000 --> 03:02:47,000
And we'll use the Weaver report to inform the content for those two areas.

1372
03:02:47,000 --> 03:02:54,000
Additionally, we're currently developing the equivalent of a procurement training series and a project management series as well.

1373
03:02:54,000 --> 03:03:02,000
For change management, we're actively reviewing and revising our change management protocols to be in alignment with best practices.

1374
03:03:02,000 --> 03:03:09,000
We also want to note that all 7 of these themes, of course, are on our radar.

1375
03:03:09,000 --> 03:03:14,000
The assessment also recommended that the Director of Internal Controls develop an.

1376
03:03:14,000 --> 03:03:24,000
comprehensive internal control framework. that captures accounting, budgeting, and information technology risk and controls.

1377
03:03:24,000 --> 03:03:31,000
With this, I have already begun developing frameworks for practices related to our policies and procedures.

1378
03:03:31,000 --> 03:03:39,000
trainings and inventory management. These frameworks at a high level are iterative documents that are capturing risk.

1379
03:03:39,000 --> 03:03:44,000
that have been identified by previous audits, assessments in my discretion.

1380
03:03:44,000 --> 03:03:50,000
For documenting best practice controls in this particular framework.

1381
03:03:50,000 --> 03:04:00,000
We're assessing whether we have those controls currently in place. If we have them in place, we're documenting what we're doing. If those controls are currently missing.

1382
03:04:00,000 --> 03:04:09,000
It is an indicator for us to prioritize putting those controls in place, testing them, and making sure that they are effective.

1383
03:04:09,000 --> 03:04:15,000
Um, I will continue this effort of developing these frameworks and will include accounting, budgeting, and IT.

1384
03:04:15,000 --> 03:04:24,000
a risk as well. These frameworks will provide structure for how SANDAC manages its risk.

1385
03:04:24,000 --> 03:04:31,000
Um, continuously monitors its operations. And these frameworks will also serve as succession planning tools.

1386
03:04:31,000 --> 03:04:39,000
as how the organization conducts its business. would be documented, accessible, and easy to follow.

1387
03:04:39,000 --> 03:04:41,000
And now I will turn it over to Kim.

1388
03:04:41,000 --> 03:04:46,000
To discuss our next steps related to accounting and finance recommendations.

1389
03:04:46,000 --> 03:05:02,000
Good afternoon. Kimberly Trammell, the Director of Accounting and Finance, and I just want to cover the recommendations for the accounting and finance team, which fell into three general categories, the first one being vendor invoice processing.

1390
03:05:02,000 --> 03:05:13,000
Um, this area of SANDAG went through major changes with the implementation of our ERP system. Less than 2 years ago, and since then, we've been reevaluating the process.

1391
03:05:13,000 --> 03:05:16,000
Um, to see what is working and what's not working.

1392
03:05:16,000 --> 03:05:22,000
And so we had already been working on 3 of the 5 areas identified in the report for improvement.

1393
03:05:22,000 --> 03:05:30,000
One of those that we have already underway is the implementation of the vendor module that came in our ERP system.

1394
03:05:30,000 --> 03:05:35,000
Um, we are just getting ready to move forward with a pilot program, and then we'll have that available.

1395
03:05:35,000 --> 03:05:38,000
for all of our vendors at a later date.

1396
03:05:38,000 --> 03:05:47,000
Um, another area that we have been working on is our… establishing a risk-based threshold for approvals of our invoices.

1397
03:05:47,000 --> 03:06:00,000
And this has been a little complicated because SANDAG is not a one-size-fits-all. So, um, your toll operations might want to review invoices at a different RESC basis than your construction, um, versus your engineering.

1398
03:06:00,000 --> 03:06:10,000
So, um, we have been trying to figure out what will work best with the organization. We're moving forward with a dollar-based threshold, and we'll continue to evaluate whether that's meeting our risk needs.

1399
03:06:10,000 --> 03:06:17,000
Um, so establishing that, like I said, has been in process and will be available soon.

1400
03:06:17,000 --> 03:06:28,000
Another area that we've been looking at and working on are our invoice payment timeframes, and really making our staff aware of the timeliness for processing payments.

1401
03:06:28,000 --> 03:06:37,000
Um, and tracking of invoice dates should the invoice not meet our requirements, because there are a lot of requirements that come with a grant-funded invoice.

1402
03:06:37,000 --> 03:06:59,000
Um, we often have to do a lot of back and forth with our vendors and make sure we're getting all of the appropriate documentation, and so it's on SANDAG and our staff to make sure that we're documenting that back and forth time, and there's sufficient reason for why an invoice might not be paid in the appropriate time frame because it didn't have appropriate documentation.

1403
03:06:59,000 --> 03:07:05,000
So, um, we will be able to utilize our EIP system to track our received dates.

1404
03:07:05,000 --> 03:07:19,000
And, um, our due dates, and we have already put out guidance and, um, are working with our con… essentially our contract manager staff to make sure that they're documenting those dates and any of that back-and-forth that I mentioned.

1405
03:07:19,000 --> 03:07:32,000
The last area for vendor invoice processing is a centralized invoice receipt, and what we're proposing to do is put together a centralized invoice receipt within each department of SANDAG.

1406
03:07:32,000 --> 03:07:48,000
Um, that also includes additional monitoring. We get about 150 invoices a week here at SANDAG, and so, um, we think the best way to make sure that those are getting to the right person for processing is to do a centralized invoice receipt within each department.

1407
03:07:48,000 --> 03:08:06,000
The second area I want to talk about is reconciliations within the accounting department. Um, we do have over 50 documented reconciliations that the accounting group does right now, and with other priorities and projects going on, sometimes those don't get done until year-end, and that's an area we want to improve on.

1408
03:08:06,000 --> 03:08:19,000
Um, so we will institutionalize the existing reconciliation tracking schedule that we have, and make sure that it is being monitored to make sure that our reconciliations are happening more timely, and we'll also be going through.

1409
03:08:19,000 --> 03:08:26,000
to look and make sure that, um, if that list is comprehensive and includes all of the reconciliations that need to be included.

1410
03:08:26,000 --> 03:08:33,000
As an example with bringing payroll in-house in the last 6 months, there's additional reconciliations that need to be added to that list.

1411
03:08:33,000 --> 03:08:51,000
And to bring all of this into our policies and procedures around these areas. One thing we also noted, but was not necessarily a recommendation, was that we can add some clarifying language to some of our quarterly reporting to make sure that it's clear what we're reporting and how that information can be used.

1412
03:08:51,000 --> 03:09:02,000
The third area is around systems and manual processes, and we're always looking for ways to automate. It's been a big change for the agency to go into the ERP system.

1413
03:09:02,000 --> 03:09:11,000
And, um, so we continue to learn it and learn ways we can automate. Um, one of the areas touched on in the report is our toll revenue accounting.

1414
03:09:11,000 --> 03:09:24,000
And, um, that has been a difficult area the last couple years with limitations to the back office system. Our management team has been very hands-on in this area to build a reliable process.

1415
03:09:24,000 --> 03:09:31,000
for pulling the information we need out of the back office system and getting that into our accounting system, and making sure the reporting is accurate.

1416
03:09:31,000 --> 03:09:40,000
We had to identify a way to… we had to identify what the system could do and its limitations, and design a process around that that mitigated risk.

1417
03:09:40,000 --> 03:09:44,000
So we've now designed that process, it's in place, we've been using it.

1418
03:09:44,000 --> 03:09:56,000
it's working well with our audits, but we need to institutionalize that, essentially, and write up the policies and procedures that go with that, and make sure we're defining and assigning roles so that there's not a single point.

1419
03:09:56,000 --> 03:10:07,000
Of, um, in that process, but that the whole team is a part of it, the staff accountants working on the appropriate pieces, and the management is reviewing those pieces.

1420
03:10:07,000 --> 03:10:23,000
So that is something that we have in place, um, and as I said, we're looking at other ways that we can institutionalize automation in our programs, but you first have to kind of, once you put in a new system, you first have to kind of learn that one and learn what it can do, and then you learn how you can augment it.

1421
03:10:23,000 --> 03:10:27,000
So with that, I will turn it over to Susan Huntington. Thank you.

1422
03:10:27,000 --> 03:10:32,000
Good afternoon, I'm Susan Huntington, I'm Sandaga's Director of Financial Planning, Budgets, and Grants.

1423
03:10:32,000 --> 03:10:43,000
The assessment provided a clear path forward, and many of the recommendations align with work already underway in the financial planning, budgeting, and Grants Department.

1424
03:10:43,000 --> 03:10:49,000
Our top priority actions fall into two areas, the grant compliance and the budget monitoring.

1425
03:10:49,000 --> 03:10:56,000
on the grant compliance side, we're focused on ensuring accuracy and improving the timeliness of reimbursements to our grantees.

1426
03:10:56,000 --> 03:11:10,000
So, this will be, um, similar to what we've just heard from Kimberly as she was talking about the vendor invoice processes. So first, we're addressing the prompt payment requirements under CFR 200.

1427
03:11:10,000 --> 03:11:25,000
Which indicates that a recipient of federal funding must make payment to a subrecipient within 30 days after receipt of the payment request, unless the entity, in this case it's SANDAG, reasonably believes the request to be improper.

1428
03:11:25,000 --> 03:11:35,000
So the assessment noted that the invoice receive dates are not consistently tracked in the ERP, and some program managers maintain logs outside of the system.

1429
03:11:35,000 --> 03:11:44,000
In addition, there's been confusion about which date should be entered. The initial submittal date, or the date a complete and accurate invoice is received.

1430
03:11:44,000 --> 03:11:50,000
Which may come at a later date after issues are resolved with a grantee.

1431
03:11:50,000 --> 03:11:59,000
So, address this, we are evaluating updates to our contract language and training to our program managers to clearly define invoice requirements.

1432
03:11:59,000 --> 03:12:08,000
And to require the use of a standardized invoice form. Until now, we've strongly encouraged the use of the form, but have not required it.

1433
03:12:08,000 --> 03:12:17,000
in the near term, we will establish a central location for invoice logging, tracking, and issue documentations that all program managers will use.

1434
03:12:17,000 --> 03:12:23,000
This will increase transparency and accountability and better support timely reimbursements.

1435
03:12:23,000 --> 03:12:29,000
We'll also begin regular reporting of our timely payment performance to senior leadership.

1436
03:12:29,000 --> 03:12:36,000
This connects directly to our second priority action, developing invoice and reimbursement checklists tailored to each program.

1437
03:12:36,000 --> 03:12:50,000
So the current agency-wide checklist for our invoice review does not capture the program-specific requirements. We must verify across our federal, state, and local funding guidelines.

1438
03:12:50,000 --> 03:12:58,000
So documenting the full review steps for each program will strengthen accuracy, consistency, and compliance.

1439
03:12:58,000 --> 03:13:04,000
And then our other set of priority actions relate to the budget development, monitoring, and reporting.

1440
03:13:04,000 --> 03:13:31,000
The assessment notes that SANDAG does not yet have a single integrated budget development and monitoring system. So while implementing the ERP was an important step, our budget still spans several platforms. So we use, um… a tool, it's called PM Tools, to put together our capital budgets. We use IMBM for our personnel resource allocation, and we use ERP for non-capital budgets and actual expenditures.

1441
03:13:31,000 --> 03:13:41,000
to improve oversight, we're formalizing required monthly and quarterly budget to actual reviews for project managers, department directors, and senior leadership.

1442
03:13:41,000 --> 03:13:59,000
We have established a group of department analysts who serve as budget coordinators and provide support with annual development and ongoing monitoring. These staff are key collaborators with project managers, department directors, and central budgets, and provide additional oversight and analysis of budget utilization.

1443
03:13:59,000 --> 03:14:13,000
As part of documenting processes and procedures in a budget handbook, which is currently under development, a RACI matrix will be implemented to clearly define roles for each step of the budgeting and monitoring process.

1444
03:14:13,000 --> 03:14:23,000
In addition, we're working with our technology team to create automated reports that pull data from all these various Spirit systems to provide consistent, real-time financial information.

1445
03:14:23,000 --> 03:14:28,000
This will allow us to shift from reactive analysis to more proactive financial.

1446
03:14:28,000 --> 03:14:43,000
financial management and strengthen financial decision making. And I do want to note the timing of this assessment is particularly helpful as the agency is currently developing the FY27 budget, so this work occurs.

1447
03:14:43,000 --> 03:14:54,000
in the main… in the November through May timeframe. The findings and recommendations from this assessment will guide our work throughout this process and will inform our lessons learned for the upcoming year.

1448
03:14:54,000 --> 03:15:00,000
With that, I'll turn it over to Grace Mino to discuss technology implementation and change management.

1449
03:15:00,000 --> 03:15:12,000
Good afternoon, Chair, Vice Chair, Second Vice Chair, and Board Members. My name is Grace Mino, and I am your Senior Director of Data Science, and I oversee our IT department as well.

1450
03:15:12,000 --> 03:15:18,000
Again, I just want to echo Mario's sentiment to both Courtney Oipa and also the Weaver team.

1451
03:15:18,000 --> 03:15:24,000
Um, just for presenting gaps in areas of opportunity to help us improve, and also highlighting.

1452
03:15:24,000 --> 03:15:29,000
The systems development lifecycle, and how that is a very iterative process.

1453
03:15:29,000 --> 03:15:38,000
Where we're processing, analyzing, designing, developing, testing, implementing, and maintaining all the things when it comes to new software.

1454
03:15:38,000 --> 03:15:45,000
I want to also, um, echo what Shanae, Kimberly, and Susan have already highlighted, that.

1455
03:15:45,000 --> 03:15:55,000
A lot of the processes and recommendations from Weaver are things that staff have already been working on, and so that's like formalizing our change management process.

1456
03:15:55,000 --> 03:16:05,000
Formalizing our IT governance and data governance. And also, moving forward, that any technology or software that is being brought into the agency.

1457
03:16:05,000 --> 03:16:10,000
Um, is going through a needs assessment, a risk assessment, also going through systems requirements.

1458
03:16:10,000 --> 03:16:20,000
And we also want to ensure that it can integrate with our ERP system, and that we can also find ways to automate and make sure we're not doing these manual workarounds.

1459
03:16:20,000 --> 03:16:31,000
Um, another thing that was highlighted and is continuing to be highlighted is training. We want to ensure that our staff are being trained and are comfortable with anything new that's coming into the agency.

1460
03:16:31,000 --> 03:16:39,000
And moving forward internally in January, we'll be doing a cross-discipline deep dive workshop on our ERP system.

1461
03:16:39,000 --> 03:16:50,000
Taking the system's requirements when it was conducted as a competitive process about 3 to 4 years ago, and aligning it to what the business needs are within the agency. What is it not.

1462
03:16:50,000 --> 03:16:57,000
meeting right now. We're also looking into hiring an ERP-specific systems administrator.

1463
03:16:57,000 --> 03:17:08,000
And we'll probably be doing a RFP for a consultant to help us bridge the gaps and also help us maximize utilizing the system and helping us implement and develop the KPIs.

1464
03:17:08,000 --> 03:17:15,000
We've also been talking to our partner MPOs across the nation that are also doing ERP implementations.

1465
03:17:15,000 --> 03:17:26,000
And we're, uh, we're just sharing lessons learned. Lastly, Mario had highlighted that we, along with the financial assessment, we're doing an assessment of our HR department.

1466
03:17:26,000 --> 03:17:30,000
We are also looking into doing an assessment of our IT department.

1467
03:17:30,000 --> 03:17:36,000
Um, and then now I will also pass it over to our CFO, Don Batiste.

1468
03:17:36,000 --> 03:17:52,000
Hi, thank you. Wanted to just wrap this up today by acknowledging all of the work that's been going on in the agency that you've just heard about. There's a significant amount of work going on. As you heard Mario mention at the top, you know.

1469
03:17:52,000 --> 03:18:02,000
We still have outstanding. Um, uh, corrective action plan items from previous audits. We've added these in, but this assessment.

1470
03:18:02,000 --> 03:18:06,000
You know, really has given us a good roadmap.

1471
03:18:06,000 --> 03:18:12,000
And it took items that we knew we needed to work on, things that you've heard we had already started working on.

1472
03:18:12,000 --> 03:18:17,000
And really helped us prioritize them in a more efficient manner.

1473
03:18:17,000 --> 03:18:23,000
Um, so we really want to thank the Independent Audit Office. We really want to thank the Weaver team.

1474
03:18:23,000 --> 03:18:33,000
And I also want to acknowledge all the staff here at SANDEG who participated in this process, the interviews, the documents that were.

1475
03:18:33,000 --> 03:18:37,000
We're provided for it. So, with that, I think the audit.

1476
03:18:37,000 --> 03:19:06,000
team will come back up to the table, and we will close this out and be open for questions.

1477
03:19:06,000 --> 03:19:13,000
We're available to take questions. Okay, we'll go to the public first, and then we will go to the board for questions. Michael?

1478
03:19:13,000 --> 03:19:16,000
Yes, uh, we have two in person and three online.

1479
03:19:16,000 --> 03:19:26,000
First is truth, followed by Cesar Javier.

1480
03:19:26,000 --> 03:19:32,000
Mario, the SANDAG car has racked up way too many GHGs and VMTs and has refused to pay its tolls.

1481
03:19:32,000 --> 03:19:37,000
Why does it take 5 people for Sanag to just say they agree?

1482
03:19:37,000 --> 03:19:45,000
For some, the question is, what's the difference between an audit and assessment? But for me, the question is, what's the point of an assessment? Seems like a waste of tax dollars.

1483
03:19:45,000 --> 03:19:50,000
I don't know when this was approved or how much it cost us to do, but it feels like answers everybody should already know.

1484
03:19:50,000 --> 03:19:56,000
I had to look up the term principle of least privilege, and I like it because it's the equivalent of a need-to-know basis.

1485
03:19:56,000 --> 03:20:02,000
It's right next to Know Your Role. Hassan and the previous board did not know their roles, and that's why I showed up to disrupt.

1486
03:20:02,000 --> 03:20:12,000
their systems. Corrupt systems. And as I said before, Senek has not had a controls issue, or a technology issue, or a systems issue more than it's had a people issue.

1487
03:20:12,000 --> 03:20:28,000
If someone wants to argue that a corporate setup with 19-plus representatives who were never elected to be on SANDAG, deciding what happens for transportation and housing and who knows what in the future, is a technology-based system and control problem, I'll 100% agree to that.

1488
03:20:28,000 --> 03:20:37,000
Senang was built with policies that were not followed. Senag had plenty of well-qualified employees in the past who chose to do the wrong thing for either greed or fear.

1489
03:20:37,000 --> 03:20:44,000
Proven experience and proven character are the solutions that no assessment or audit can make everyone at Tanag willing to choose.

1490
03:20:44,000 --> 03:20:50,000
The right people in the right places will stay here when the transition and resolution to pass corruption is complete and consistent.

1491
03:20:50,000 --> 03:20:59,000
For transparency and accountability, sometimes all it takes is one brave whistleblower or speaker or board member to make permanent changes.

1492
03:20:59,000 --> 03:21:04,000
Don't allow SANDAG to go backwards like it almost did at the last meeting.

1493
03:21:04,000 --> 03:21:09,000
If this is a project-driven agency, then focus on projects, not checks.

1494
03:21:09,000 --> 03:21:16,000
checked box politics. I'm gonna repeat it again, so you really hear it. Projects, not politics.

1495
03:21:16,000 --> 03:21:21,000
It's very clear. Get the work done efficiently, timely, and ethically.

1496
03:21:21,000 --> 03:21:28,000
And then somebody, tell the county how to operate that way so we can all live much better. Thank you.

1497
03:21:28,000 --> 03:21:32,000
Next is Cesar Javier, followed by Paul the Bold Online.

1498
03:21:32,000 --> 03:21:42,000
Cesar and Purita in 2 minutes. Thank you, Sandag. We'll be repeated students in this great university.

1499
03:21:42,000 --> 03:21:52,000
Thank you, sir. Mito. I… Could switch to Honorable Sito.

1500
03:21:52,000 --> 03:21:56,000
Thank you, because it's… Educating us.

1501
03:21:56,000 --> 03:22:02,000
The city of San Diego. is an independent.

1502
03:22:02,000 --> 03:22:09,000
You know, planning… Visioning about… Shell, man.

1503
03:22:09,000 --> 03:22:18,000
shelter, society, and the specialty of Sandag. Which includes now, we heard.

1504
03:22:18,000 --> 03:22:23,000
sheltering. Home, home, or house.

1505
03:22:23,000 --> 03:22:34,000
For San Diegans. Thank you, Sandag. My question is, did you include in your investigation how this.

1506
03:22:34,000 --> 03:22:39,000
members of this elite thinkers. How they perform.

1507
03:22:39,000 --> 03:22:46,000
Like, a question. How did the mayor… declared in his.

1508
03:22:46,000 --> 03:22:55,000
city address last year. Oh, we have 252… The million deficit.

1509
03:22:55,000 --> 03:23:02,000
When the EBA organic element, says only 85. What's happening to our city.

1510
03:23:02,000 --> 03:23:07,000
Sir La Cawa, Shirley?

1511
03:23:07,000 --> 03:23:13,000
You know it, San Diegans. And we are fearful.

1512
03:23:13,000 --> 03:23:22,000
That our money. It's not going to where we should be enjoying life in our community.

1513
03:23:22,000 --> 03:23:27,000
Thank you for the investigation, that's a thesis writing.

1514
03:23:27,000 --> 03:23:35,000
Thank you for that dissertation. We are repeater for next year, and it's free.

1515
03:23:35,000 --> 03:23:41,000
Thank you, Sandag. the city of San Diego. Thank you, your time has expired.

1516
03:23:41,000 --> 03:23:53,000
Next is Paula Bold Online, followed by the original draw.

1517
03:23:53,000 --> 03:24:02,000
Oh, my test starts highlighting deficiencies in ants and eggs internal controls.

1518
03:24:02,000 --> 03:24:14,000
were bad, but this is scathing. It is shocking that Sandag still does not have a comprehensive framework to consistently assess and monitor.

1519
03:24:14,000 --> 03:24:21,000
key internal controls. After years of scandals and scathing audits.

1520
03:24:21,000 --> 03:24:30,000
The non-key deficiencies are basic areas that should have been properly controlled from the start.

1521
03:24:30,000 --> 03:24:35,000
But instead, you devise overly complex policies and procedures.

1522
03:24:35,000 --> 03:24:43,000
To weaken these. Does telling that this audit. Gently called an assessment.

1523
03:24:43,000 --> 03:24:55,000
specifically recommends. Quote, using external qualified advisors, unquote, rather than internal processes you have relied on.

1524
03:24:55,000 --> 03:25:01,000
So who is exactly… is calling the shots at Sandag?

1525
03:25:01,000 --> 03:25:07,000
It is time to include the Sandag and independent auditor on the board.

1526
03:25:07,000 --> 03:25:20,000
The continuing audit failures would be less. If there were regular finance, accounting, or audit advice right here for you to hear before this scandal.

1527
03:25:20,000 --> 03:25:29,000
As for the response, it's a real tragic comedy that management agrees with all of the recommendations.

1528
03:25:29,000 --> 03:25:34,000
That it is not implemented after all the promises we've heard.

1529
03:25:34,000 --> 03:25:44,000
We hear the excuses, but just do it! Amazing that there is still no centralized point for collecting invoices.

1530
03:25:44,000 --> 03:25:53,000
And now, time frame for paying them. I wonder how many potential contractors and workers this is alienated.

1531
03:25:53,000 --> 03:25:55,000
Because they want to get paid. Um, it's amazing that reconciliation.

1532
03:25:55,000 --> 03:26:00,000
No, thank you.

1533
03:26:00,000 --> 03:26:06,000
Thank you, your time has expired. Next is original draw, followed by Mike Bullock.

1534
03:26:06,000 --> 03:26:15,000
You know, part of the problem is that you guys never want to look at the people that are engaged in fraud, waste, and abuse, because you'll sit here and you bring up these.

1535
03:26:15,000 --> 03:26:25,000
presentations and, you know, sit there and try and paint a pretty picture that you guys are really, you know, mitigating things, but you have your hands in way too many buckets.

1536
03:26:25,000 --> 03:26:31,000
And you are ill-equipped to provide the things that you are, you know, professing that you're going to provide.

1537
03:26:31,000 --> 03:26:37,000
So when you sit here and virtue signal, like, it's so great that you're doing so many things.

1538
03:26:37,000 --> 03:26:41,000
When there's so many issues with all of the things that you're doing.

1539
03:26:41,000 --> 03:26:47,000
You know, it just shows that these things are… that you… this presentation is just to continue the.

1540
03:26:47,000 --> 03:26:50,000
fraud, waste, and abuse, because you just want to set up.

1541
03:26:50,000 --> 03:26:54,000
all this stuff, you know, and we pay more and more money to.

1542
03:26:54,000 --> 03:27:01,000
To try and have accountability and all this stuff, but I mean, you even sit there and profess that you listen to the local.

1543
03:27:01,000 --> 03:27:07,000
community. You don't. I mean, you don't even reach out to the people in the community like you should.

1544
03:27:07,000 --> 03:27:13,000
And you should be, you know, when you're implementing things like tools, be getting a vote from the people.

1545
03:27:13,000 --> 03:27:20,000
Because if you really did get the input from the people, you wouldn't have the support that you do. I mean, people don't even know who you are.

1546
03:27:20,000 --> 03:27:25,000
And that helps you guys so that you can say that you're doing what the people want.

1547
03:27:25,000 --> 03:27:34,000
You know, and it's unfortunate, because. the people should be, you know, having a voice, not the stakeholders, not all the people that you're gonna make money from.

1548
03:27:34,000 --> 03:27:38,000
The people that you get your money from, that you sit here and waste.

1549
03:27:38,000 --> 03:27:50,000
Because you engage, like I've said before, with people who, you know, cost us more and more money, are engaged in the fraud, waste, and abuse when you contract with them, whether it's internally or externally.

1550
03:27:50,000 --> 03:27:56,000
And nothing really gets done about it. People retire with, you know, pensions and all of these great things.

1551
03:27:56,000 --> 03:28:03,000
And the fraud, waste, and abuse continues, and the people, you know, are sitting here, you know.

1552
03:28:03,000 --> 03:28:12,000
Buying the propaganda, if they do listen. And so they think you're gonna do what you're gonna do, but all they have to do is look at the world around us and see.

1553
03:28:12,000 --> 03:28:20,000
Our next public comment is Mike Bullock, followed by our last public comment, ending in 8813.

1554
03:28:20,000 --> 03:28:29,000
Yeah, thank you, uh, Sandag. What I hear is a lot of very professional, smart, hardworking people.

1555
03:28:29,000 --> 03:28:36,000
trying their very best. to address a very unfortunate sequence of events.

1556
03:28:36,000 --> 03:28:42,000
Um, it may have seemed pretty simple to just have a toll road and operate a toll road.

1557
03:28:42,000 --> 03:28:45,000
Uh, but it didn't turn out to be that simple.

1558
03:28:45,000 --> 03:28:59,000
And, uh, I'm wondering, listening. to what is, uh… being described and being predicted in terms of what needs to be done in the future, if it's not really time to just cut the losses.

1559
03:28:59,000 --> 03:29:09,000
Um, I hate to say that, and I don't say that disrespectfully or, uh… But I want to talk about some things which are… have no future.

1560
03:29:09,000 --> 03:29:16,000
which are going to become obsolete. And the first one is the internal combustion engine vehicle.

1561
03:29:16,000 --> 03:29:20,000
All of them. It's very bad technology, as it turns out. We didn't know that.

1562
03:29:20,000 --> 03:29:22,000
It just went 100 degrees. of financials.

1563
03:29:22,000 --> 03:29:29,000
You know, we thought, uh… Cathode ray tube televisions were just great, didn't we, until we got digital televisions.

1564
03:29:29,000 --> 03:29:37,000
Every automobile manufacturer knows that there is no future for internal combustion engines, yet we're going electric.

1565
03:29:37,000 --> 03:29:42,000
So the other thing that there's no future for is, um, gasoline tax.

1566
03:29:42,000 --> 03:29:50,000
And that is actually a tax. And, um, because there's no future for that, because we're not going to be using gasoline.

1567
03:29:50,000 --> 03:30:03,000
Um, we have to move to, um… road use charge, and that road use charge has to replace the gasoline tax. We need to actually get rid of the California gasoline tax. That's the big tax.

1568
03:30:03,000 --> 03:30:12,000
57 cents a gallon. It's odd to me that so many Republicans there are so pro-tax.

1569
03:30:12,000 --> 03:30:13,000
Michael, please keep on topic, or remember we're on…

1570
03:30:13,000 --> 03:30:23,000
Um, the road use chart. is a charge. Oh, I am… This is on topic. You need to cut your losses because there's no future in toll roads.

1571
03:30:23,000 --> 03:30:26,000
There's no future in toll roads, because we have to have a road use charge.

1572
03:30:26,000 --> 03:30:42,000
Thank you, your time has expired. Last comment is phone number ending in 8813.

1573
03:30:42,000 --> 03:30:48,000
Consola, go ahead.

1574
03:30:48,000 --> 03:30:51,000
Oops, okay, my device is muted. Can you hear me?

1575
03:30:51,000 --> 03:30:52,000
Yes, go ahead.

1576
03:30:52,000 --> 03:31:03,000
Okay, great. Okay, so amen to… Um, all the previous concerned citizens, um, the handful who chime in and pay attention to the corruption.

1577
03:31:03,000 --> 03:31:13,000
Um, and especially Paul the Bold, uh. Uh, no, let's talk about this so-called audit and assessment. First question.

1578
03:31:13,000 --> 03:31:20,000
Is Sandag seriously still using TurboTax? I remember hearing that back in the Karada days.

1579
03:31:20,000 --> 03:31:23,000
And I thought it was a joke, but apparently not.

1580
03:31:23,000 --> 03:31:30,000
This is an agency handling billions of dollars in public funds and, um, yeah.

1581
03:31:30,000 --> 03:31:34,000
It was just funny to remember back in the day that you guys used to use that.

1582
03:31:34,000 --> 03:31:46,000
Software. Anyways, um… Let's see what else… what else, what else? And then you talk about best practices and controls. Controls is right, but in the way.

1583
03:31:46,000 --> 03:31:55,000
But not in the way you pretend, because nothing about this audit looks… Like, accountability. Um, more rubber stamping.

1584
03:31:55,000 --> 03:32:02,000
Um… And, uh… Yeah, and then when the person mentioned how.

1585
03:32:02,000 --> 03:32:11,000
Uh, what's working and not working. Uh, let me translate that for you. What's working is your rollout towards the UN, uh.

1586
03:32:11,000 --> 03:32:22,000
2030 plans, your ability to push policies. The public never actually agreed to, your ability to operate in the shadows while telling everyone it's for their own good.

1587
03:32:22,000 --> 03:32:26,000
Uh, what's not working… I mean, that is what was working.

1588
03:32:26,000 --> 03:32:33,000
What's not working is the fact that you keep pulling the wool over the public's eyes, especially the younger generations who have no idea.

1589
03:32:33,000 --> 03:32:43,000
How deep this manipulation runs. And then someone in the presentation said SANDAG is not a one… or… It's not a one-size-fits-all.

1590
03:32:43,000 --> 03:32:51,000
And, uh, really, because everything you're doing in this county looks exactly like a one-size-fits-all control system.

1591
03:32:51,000 --> 03:32:54,000
Restrict mobility imposed bike lanes, nobody wants to push.

1592
03:32:54,000 --> 03:32:59,000
Thank you, your time has expired. That concludes our public comment on this item, Chair.

1593
03:32:59,000 --> 03:33:10,000
Thanks, Michael. Mario, did you want to say a few things? Um, probably just wrap it up on making a point of clarification on certifications, which are extremely important.

1594
03:33:10,000 --> 03:33:15,000
For the different positions, but also putting that much weight on.

1595
03:33:15,000 --> 03:33:24,000
all that experience, and uh… that the employees have, um… It's to make a well-rounded professional.

1596
03:33:24,000 --> 03:33:32,000
It's a combination of both. Uh, in some cases, certifications are extremely important, others.

1597
03:33:32,000 --> 03:33:38,000
the certification, as well as that experience, you know, decades of experience.

1598
03:33:38,000 --> 03:33:42,000
And the uniquenesses of the positions, like, I try to.

1599
03:33:42,000 --> 03:33:49,000
highlight, uh, that, that it's also. uh, something that we put in, you know.

1600
03:33:49,000 --> 03:33:56,000
a lot… a lot into it. It's… you can't… put, uh, under just one single description.

1601
03:33:56,000 --> 03:34:04,000
for so many different specialties that we do. Um, sometimes you're required to.

1602
03:34:04,000 --> 03:34:10,000
have a whole life of experience. As well as certifications, uh.

1603
03:34:10,000 --> 03:34:14,000
sometimes. So I do want to highlight that because.

1604
03:34:14,000 --> 03:34:19,000
Our teams are very dedicated, very professional, if you see.

1605
03:34:19,000 --> 03:34:28,000
And I want to highlight that because. That's my job, highlighting the great team that I have.

1606
03:34:28,000 --> 03:34:34,000
Thank you. Now on to member comments. We'll start with, uh, Deputy Mayor Chavez.

1607
03:34:34,000 --> 03:34:42,000
Thank you so much, um… First of all, to our independent auditor team, but our staff and our leadership.

1608
03:34:42,000 --> 03:34:46,000
I know we've been talking about this for over 2 years.

1609
03:34:46,000 --> 03:34:51,000
Uh, since it was discovered, and. Unfortunately, this is impacting.

1610
03:34:51,000 --> 03:34:56,000
South County more than anyone. South County users, and.

1611
03:34:56,000 --> 03:35:00,000
Um, you know, SANDEC being, uh, over a billion.

1612
03:35:00,000 --> 03:35:08,000
dollar in budget, uh, association. that we represent. One thing that worries me, and I can go to the spell of.

1613
03:35:08,000 --> 03:35:17,000
what I've mentioned in many other meetings. And how Chula Vista, the fairness of the South County people, the community, traffic.

1614
03:35:17,000 --> 03:35:22,000
impact and the day visitors that we have that are impacting the 805 and the 5.

1615
03:35:22,000 --> 03:35:27,000
But I do want to mention that in page 16.

1616
03:35:27,000 --> 03:35:38,000
8.4… You mentioned, um… Our auditor marked this as a high risk for the agency.

1617
03:35:38,000 --> 03:35:42,000
And it's the reliance on a single individual for manual tracking.

1618
03:35:42,000 --> 03:35:48,000
Combined with undocumented processes and on. Timely reconciliations increase.

1619
03:35:48,000 --> 03:35:55,000
The risk of errors in complete records, non-compliance. and operational disruption.

1620
03:35:55,000 --> 03:36:07,000
So… are we relying on a single individual? To process every single payment from the tolls? Where am I reading it incorrectly?

1621
03:36:07,000 --> 03:36:12,000
Because we have toll system errors to this day.

1622
03:36:12,000 --> 03:36:22,000
And why is it a high risk? So, uh, Councilmember, we found… there's one person that is working on the reconciliation part, so there's a point.

1623
03:36:22,000 --> 03:36:30,000
a single point there. And I know the team is aware and working on putting the policies and procedures and training staff.

1624
03:36:30,000 --> 03:36:36,000
So it's not one person processing. It is a CPA at the Toll Ops.

1625
03:36:36,000 --> 03:36:41,000
That is mainly responsible for the reconciliation process, so that's what we're.

1626
03:36:41,000 --> 03:36:47,000
identifying in the report. So when we talk about reconciliation.

1627
03:36:47,000 --> 03:36:52,000
Can we be more specific? Do we still have toll errors?

1628
03:36:52,000 --> 03:37:01,000
I am going to leave that to Kimberly. I certainly will. Let me clarify, um, the one person is not processing.

1629
03:37:01,000 --> 03:37:12,000
payments or individual transactions. So we, um, on a monthly basis, will pull the information out of the back office system so that we can populate it into our accounting system.

1630
03:37:12,000 --> 03:37:23,000
So, as I said, because there are some system limitations, there's no direct integration, and we know that there have been, um, issues with how the information is pulled into the reports in the past.

1631
03:37:23,000 --> 03:37:28,000
We have developed a process so that we make sure the information that we're getting is correct.

1632
03:37:28,000 --> 03:37:37,000
So there's a couple steps that have to happen in the back office system, and then we run the reports that come out of that, and then the accounting entries are being booked from there.

1633
03:37:37,000 --> 03:37:42,000
So because this has been, as you said, something we've been working through for 2 years.

1634
03:37:42,000 --> 03:37:50,000
And, um, we really want to make sure that it's correct and accurate. We have had our manager in that area working on this.

1635
03:37:50,000 --> 03:37:58,000
Um, and as I said, we feel that we've got a good process in place now that's reliable, and so we can have… we can kind of spread that to.

1636
03:37:58,000 --> 03:38:03,000
Um, the rest of the total accountant area, so that it's not being done by.

1637
03:38:03,000 --> 03:38:09,000
There isn't one final person doing it, but it's done by various people throughout the process.

1638
03:38:09,000 --> 03:38:12,000
I think I want to add a little bit.

1639
03:38:12,000 --> 03:38:16,000
Again, we came… We stabilize.

1640
03:38:16,000 --> 03:38:21,000
And we have done the assessment. So the teams.

1641
03:38:21,000 --> 03:38:27,000
have set up a process. To adequately be doing.

1642
03:38:27,000 --> 03:38:31,000
The checks and balances. at the toll operations center.

1643
03:38:31,000 --> 03:38:38,000
Now, is that perfect? No. That's why we're going to be moving into a new back office system.

1644
03:38:38,000 --> 03:38:42,000
And we have had robust discussions with this board.

1645
03:38:42,000 --> 03:38:48,000
of where this organization is pivoting. from a new strategy of a back office.

1646
03:38:48,000 --> 03:38:55,000
to make it more enhanced with proven operators. So, first, we needed to stabilize.

1647
03:38:55,000 --> 03:39:00,000
and manage the current situation. as we are also working, this is a.

1648
03:39:00,000 --> 03:39:06,000
on the financial department process. I'm talking a little bit also of the operations.

1649
03:39:06,000 --> 03:39:13,000
But they all come together. Right? Um, so we… we… we are working very hard, and.

1650
03:39:13,000 --> 03:39:19,000
that people are not being mischarged? I think that was your question.

1651
03:39:19,000 --> 03:39:25,000
Um, but we are… that is… that checks and balances that has been put out there.

1652
03:39:25,000 --> 03:39:35,000
It's… it was to evaluate that. If the system has some errors at some point, identify them as soon as possible and reconcile them.

1653
03:39:35,000 --> 03:39:39,000
Again, that system is not perfect. And that's why we're pivoting.

1654
03:39:39,000 --> 03:39:43,000
to others who have done it better than us.

1655
03:39:43,000 --> 03:39:50,000
I so appreciate this, this transparency. And it's my job, it's our duty.

1656
03:39:50,000 --> 03:39:53,000
to represent, uh, who elected us to this seat.

1657
03:39:53,000 --> 03:40:01,000
And finally, um… What is the current estimate on that transition to the new system?

1658
03:40:01,000 --> 03:40:07,000
We will be coming and providing. a little bit more information, probably.

1659
03:40:07,000 --> 03:40:14,000
Later, early next year, we are evaluating all the options that we have in front of us.

1660
03:40:14,000 --> 03:40:25,000
We have begun some conversations. Um, if you were to ask me right now, I foresee that a transition will be happening within the next 12 to 18 months.

1661
03:40:25,000 --> 03:40:33,000
It's a very sophisticated system. But the first thing that we needed to do was shore up the existing system.

1662
03:40:33,000 --> 03:40:38,000
like I said, stabilize. I think we have achieved that.

1663
03:40:38,000 --> 03:40:43,000
Is it perfect? No, it's not perfect, and that's why the team is doing so much.

1664
03:40:43,000 --> 03:40:52,000
Checking and balancing. Um, but I'm very confident that we are having an appropriate operation, appropriate charging.

1665
03:40:52,000 --> 03:40:58,000
But we definitely need to pivot. to something more modern and more con… with more confidence.

1666
03:40:58,000 --> 03:41:04,000
And we're looking into. other partners, other governmental agencies who have done this.

1667
03:41:04,000 --> 03:41:08,000
and who are operating and seeing how we're going to partner with them.

1668
03:41:08,000 --> 03:41:15,000
Uh, we will be coming probably early next year with a full assessment, and more than anything.

1669
03:41:15,000 --> 03:41:24,000
a proposal of where we're pivoting. Thank you so much, and before… I stop my comments, I just want to say that.

1670
03:41:24,000 --> 03:41:27,000
We need to have a better conversation and how.

1671
03:41:27,000 --> 03:41:31,000
We can return the services and all the tools that have been paid.

1672
03:41:31,000 --> 03:41:37,000
To the community. Eventually, that's what our main purpose, right, to make a better life to everyone who's using our.

1673
03:41:37,000 --> 03:41:46,000
Our transportation, our roads, and. Just living in our community. Again, thank you.

1674
03:41:46,000 --> 03:41:58,000
Um, Councilmember Molina? Thank you very much, Chair Huebner. Uh, thank you once again to our OIPA team, our team of directors.

1675
03:41:58,000 --> 03:42:05,000
Excellent presentation again. Thank you for covering my questions last week, last Friday, during the audit committee.

1676
03:42:05,000 --> 03:42:10,000
I have one additional question that didn't… I didn't quite ask.

1677
03:42:10,000 --> 03:42:15,000
And it has to do with the timeline, how far back.

1678
03:42:15,000 --> 03:42:21,000
Did you look in the assessment of our financial, um, system?

1679
03:42:21,000 --> 03:42:25,000
I don't know if that was part of the presentation.

1680
03:42:25,000 --> 03:42:33,000
last Friday or today. Holly, can you go over the assessment, uh… How you conducted the time period.

1681
03:42:33,000 --> 03:42:43,000
Yes, so as Courtney mentioned earlier in our presentation, we really work to evaluate your processes in its most current state.

1682
03:42:43,000 --> 03:42:49,000
when we needed to, we referred to periods as far back as necessary to fully understand the current condition.

1683
03:42:49,000 --> 03:43:01,000
So, you know, that might have been for certain processes 6 months back, that might have been for others 18 months back. So, it's a little bit dynamic, you know, in order to truly dig into and understand the current state.

1684
03:43:01,000 --> 03:43:15,000
like Courtney mentioned, this is a forward-looking assessment, and so going back years and years, you know, and everything really doesn't make sense, and so… Everything that we evaluated should be looked at through the lens of a current state assessment. Thank you.

1685
03:43:15,000 --> 03:43:21,000
Uh, that is very helpful, and I think that is what helps me understand the fact that this is an assessment.

1686
03:43:21,000 --> 03:43:27,000
And we are looking at the current state versus an audit, which is, you know, looking back and.

1687
03:43:27,000 --> 03:43:33,000
And checking things that way. So I really do appreciate all of the work, and I have.

1688
03:43:33,000 --> 03:43:42,000
a good understanding of the work that's before us. And again, our team of directors and our CFO, um, being so willing.

1689
03:43:42,000 --> 03:43:59,000
to take this bull by the horn, you know, and being unafraid, and knowing that this is where we're headed and this is what we're gonna do. That is the attitude that really does give me a lot of confidence moving forward. Two other things I want to point out. One is.

1690
03:43:59,000 --> 03:44:11,000
Um, from our, um, Director Pickney Forrest. The internal risk assessment, um, that she previously mentioned, it was the chart that had the three X's.

1691
03:44:11,000 --> 03:44:18,000
on the, um, on her presentation, it identifies, of the seven core themes.

1692
03:44:18,000 --> 03:44:27,000
that the Weaver assessment, um, uh, discussed. 3 of them were already identified by our internal risk assessment.

1693
03:44:27,000 --> 03:44:35,000
team, and so I really do appreciate that. It shows that we are on the same track. We are on the right track. So that.

1694
03:44:35,000 --> 03:44:44,000
Again, gives me a lot of confidence. And then one other point that was made last Friday during the audit committee by the Weaver team.

1695
03:44:44,000 --> 03:44:52,000
Um, as part of the executive summary in their report, there was this, um, beautiful one-page roadmap.

1696
03:44:52,000 --> 03:44:58,000
that had green lines across it. It was a timeline, essentially, of how to get.

1697
03:44:58,000 --> 03:45:02,000
so that what we're speaking of, how to get to that next.

1698
03:45:02,000 --> 03:45:11,000
phase of SANDAG, which will inevitably be a better SAND Act. So, um, sadly, it didn't get presented today, but if you do dig in.

1699
03:45:11,000 --> 03:45:22,000
Um, it's a roadmap, and they went through it in detail last Friday, so you could also view the recording there, but I really did appreciate that one-page recommended roadmap.

1700
03:45:22,000 --> 03:45:28,000
And my final comment just has to do with the, um, entire attitude.

1701
03:45:28,000 --> 03:45:33,000
Um, of, um, not just our leadership, our CEO, Mario Orso.

1702
03:45:33,000 --> 03:45:45,000
Um, but being able to work, and I'm taking his words from last Friday, work with these independent arms, which is our OIPA, which is, um, the folks from Weber.

1703
03:45:45,000 --> 03:45:54,000
Um, and it is a huge strength. Uh, perhaps it wasn't initially realized as a strength, you know, from previous leadership.

1704
03:45:54,000 --> 03:46:03,000
Um, and it was instead something to resist. But now to see that it is, in fact, embraced by current leadership.

1705
03:46:03,000 --> 03:46:09,000
this proverbial car that we keep talking about, I feel not only has new tires.

1706
03:46:09,000 --> 03:46:22,000
But it also has a new engine. And, um, you know, I anticipate at some point it'll be driving on this journey on a toll-free 125, or a safer 78 or 52.

1707
03:46:22,000 --> 03:46:31,000
You know, um, or even taking the purple line. So… I look forward to a lot of good things in SANDAG. I have a lot of confidence.

1708
03:46:31,000 --> 03:46:36,000
Um, certainly I feel good with the leadership that's in place. There's a lot of work to be done.

1709
03:46:36,000 --> 03:46:39,000
That is for sure. Now we know what the work is.

1710
03:46:39,000 --> 03:46:52,000
And I appreciate that, thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Councilmember. All right, we're going to go on to Mayor Minto.

1711
03:46:52,000 --> 03:46:57,000
Well, you know, it's interesting, having sat here for a long time, and.

1712
03:46:57,000 --> 03:47:03,000
hearing all about the things that, uh… You know, you don't know what you don't know?

1713
03:47:03,000 --> 03:47:16,000
And I just need to know from the CEO, are we, uh… Uh, have we enhanced the, um… Medical, um… you know, benefits for these folks, because I know there's got to be some.

1714
03:47:16,000 --> 03:47:29,000
Traumatic brain injury from all the. So… repeatedly, because every time you get down there, tell me I'm not wrong. You get into this thing and it just… I can't believe it! One more time.

1715
03:47:29,000 --> 03:47:36,000
And uh… it's… the reason why it's frustrating for me is because I sat here for a long time, and I listened to.

1716
03:47:36,000 --> 03:47:40,000
reports on the budget and the finance and this and that.

1717
03:47:40,000 --> 03:47:47,000
And everything was just perfect. We were really going along. Then we had that big debacle with Marnie Cox, and.

1718
03:47:47,000 --> 03:47:56,000
Found out that not everything was being reported correctly, and then it just kind of like an avalanche of caving from the glaciers.

1719
03:47:56,000 --> 03:48:03,000
And to where we got, you know, the last CEO, who I think didn't tell us anything was true.

1720
03:48:03,000 --> 03:48:12,000
And, um, and so… I can't believe we've actually operated so well.

1721
03:48:12,000 --> 03:48:16,000
I don't know if you want to call it, so well over so many years.

1722
03:48:16,000 --> 03:48:22,000
Uh, with what we had, you know, with, um… You know, who is the MacGyver behind everything, holding it together.

1723
03:48:22,000 --> 03:48:28,000
Um, but what I see is, you know, and we did talk about this roadmap.

1724
03:48:28,000 --> 03:48:34,000
The roadmap is only as good as. You know, the people that are driving the car.

1725
03:48:34,000 --> 03:48:38,000
Because if you don't follow the map, you get off the road.

1726
03:48:38,000 --> 03:48:44,000
And so, from this time forward, we have to make sure that every bit of IT is the most.

1727
03:48:44,000 --> 03:48:56,000
Best and best and updated. We do this at our city all the time. We're always looking to say, is there a better finance program? Is there a better tracking program? And you know what?

1728
03:48:56,000 --> 03:49:01,000
The days of using, you know, an abacus for one thing to, you know.

1729
03:49:01,000 --> 03:49:10,000
figure out how much money we have is long gone. However, it seems like that's what we've kind of done in the past, and I'm not trying to disparage anybody that's.

1730
03:49:10,000 --> 03:49:18,000
that's working here today that has been working for us in the past, but I think there were probably some great frustrations about the notability.

1731
03:49:18,000 --> 03:49:34,000
What I would suggest is not having the ability to do your job the best that you could do, and just putting things together that you were told to put together. I don't know, I'm just kind of, it's conjecture, but based on the fact that we're seeing all the problems that had to be somewhere.

1732
03:49:34,000 --> 03:49:41,000
And, um… I just think that, uh, I think we're heading in the right direction, finally.

1733
03:49:41,000 --> 03:49:49,000
And, um, I just want to say to this board of directors, if we have people that aren't doing their job, we have to get rid of them a lot sooner.

1734
03:49:49,000 --> 03:49:52,000
And make sure that people are doing their job.

1735
03:49:52,000 --> 03:50:00,000
Not saying anything, Mario, but uh… That you're not doing your job. That's just things… things happen.

1736
03:50:00,000 --> 03:50:06,000
We have to be very cognizant of what's going on. So I just wanted to vent a little bit on.

1737
03:50:06,000 --> 03:50:11,000
what I see and how I feel about things and where we've come from, and.

1738
03:50:11,000 --> 03:50:24,000
It doesn't make me feel comfortable that we've had, you know, put these things together, paperclips and chewing gum all the way, so… I'm going to answer your question, who kept it together, the employees.

1739
03:50:24,000 --> 03:50:32,000
They really are a dedicated. group, um, and now the job that Courtney, myself.

1740
03:50:32,000 --> 03:50:38,000
The incoming general counsel and all of us. Here, all of you in the board.

1741
03:50:38,000 --> 03:50:51,000
It's to bring them together, right, and to. Institute the changeup culture, breaking those stockpipes so that different groups can talk to each other, as well as externally with the cities.

1742
03:50:51,000 --> 03:50:54,000
And then we can understand what are the needs. We codify the needs.

1743
03:50:54,000 --> 03:51:07,000
We call that Systems Requirements for. systems, but we also call systems requirements for, like, the gen… the regional plan, right? Understanding what you need in your city, what you need in your city, what you don't want in your city.

1744
03:51:07,000 --> 03:51:12,000
And what Carolina wants for South Bay, as well as Paloma.

1745
03:51:12,000 --> 03:51:17,000
and on and on and on. So we need to bring that together and have that.

1746
03:51:17,000 --> 03:51:24,000
Communications, but definitely what kept it moving, and it's keeping it moving, and it will keep it moving.

1747
03:51:24,000 --> 03:51:29,000
It's our employees, so that's where we need to invest.

1748
03:51:29,000 --> 03:51:39,000
Very good. I'm here, uh, Jones, you're up. Thank you so much, Chair. Um, I just want to say thank you, um, for everyone, uh, for this report.

1749
03:51:39,000 --> 03:51:50,000
And then, um… I really… I really want to understand when we're planning on having all of the infrastructure across the board. I know that's a big, um.

1750
03:51:50,000 --> 03:51:58,000
But, uh, Shawnee had talked a little bit about the infrastructure so that we have everything put in place, set in place. Maybe you called it, actually.

1751
03:51:58,000 --> 03:52:02,000
Framework. The framework, uh, when that will be in place, um.

1752
03:52:02,000 --> 03:52:05,000
Do we have any idea when that would be?

1753
03:52:05,000 --> 03:52:13,000
So, the goal… excuse me… the goal currently is to at least have an iterative document within the next 6 months.

1754
03:52:13,000 --> 03:52:20,000
Um, and that document is something where there's… it's foundational, and then based on what we see when we start, kind of.

1755
03:52:20,000 --> 03:52:26,000
diving deeper into the recommendations, we can update it accordingly, but.

1756
03:52:26,000 --> 03:52:35,000
At the very least, having some sort of draft documentation or iterative document within the next 6 months. So basically summer 2026.

1757
03:52:35,000 --> 03:52:40,000
Great, okay, and then, um, just as a follow-up on that, and maybe you want to answer this, Mario, I'm not sure.

1758
03:52:40,000 --> 03:52:46,000
Um, when we… You know, when we hired our internal controls person.

1759
03:52:46,000 --> 03:52:57,000
I was… it's a little different, but kind of the same. Uh, we are getting a 6-month check-in update back to the board. Do we have that scheduled? I think we talked about it, but I don't recall.

1760
03:52:57,000 --> 03:53:09,000
Uh, what that was going to be. We can curr… we can certainly place something on the calendar for a review. Uh, currently, right now, the idea is to.

1761
03:53:09,000 --> 03:53:14,000
Um, try to come back to the committee at the very earliest February.

1762
03:53:14,000 --> 03:53:19,000
Um, probably at the very latest March, but to get you some updates in terms of.

1763
03:53:19,000 --> 03:53:28,000
where we are regarding our recommendation, implementation, and then the frameworks would be a part of that review.

1764
03:53:28,000 --> 03:53:38,000
Or update. Is that going to be the audit committee or the full board, or both? I'm assuming both. Both. Okay, perfect, great. And we're also going to be coming with multiple assessments.

1765
03:53:38,000 --> 03:53:43,000
grace eventually, together with the team, will come in with a data governance.

1766
03:53:43,000 --> 03:53:49,000
assessment and where we are with all our different systems and where we need to do, we continue to assess.

1767
03:53:49,000 --> 03:53:55,000
Courtney keeps helping us. I have a lot of… a lot of conversations with her of where.

1768
03:53:55,000 --> 03:54:00,000
how we bring everything together, and we'll be reporting in us.

1769
03:54:00,000 --> 03:54:05,000
timely as we can to let you know where we are, but also.

1770
03:54:05,000 --> 03:54:10,000
tell us if we need to pivot, right? That's part of the new roles or the enhanced roles of the.

1771
03:54:10,000 --> 03:54:17,000
executive committee, so you're going to be seeing us coming more and talking about how to manage the agency.

1772
03:54:17,000 --> 03:54:21,000
and asking for your opinions and your advice and guidance on that.

1773
03:54:21,000 --> 03:54:28,000
Great, because this is really important work, because it's building the foundation of us being trusted again.

1774
03:54:28,000 --> 03:54:33,000
So, um, and again, thank you for all of your input, all of our staff.

1775
03:54:33,000 --> 03:54:40,000
One last thing, when you were talking about Mario, um, infrastructure as far as the toll itself goes.

1776
03:54:40,000 --> 03:54:45,000
the toll road, and then the infrastructure that other agencies, public agencies, have in place.

1777
03:54:45,000 --> 03:54:56,000
I think that's a prudent step because. We don't need to reinvent the wheel. If there's something that's actually working, because the one-off situation that we were in is just not.

1778
03:54:56,000 --> 03:55:05,000
Um, we know. I mean, I don't want to be the dead horse, we just, we can't go down that road again, so… Anyway, thank you. Thank you, Mayor Ehlers.

1779
03:55:05,000 --> 03:55:16,000
Yeah, thank you. Um… I really appreciate the Weaver analysis. This is as broad and comprehensive of a set of recommendations as I've seen in a long time.

1780
03:55:16,000 --> 03:55:20,000
I really support them. I love the detail you went into.

1781
03:55:20,000 --> 03:55:33,000
I want to talk a little bit about the roles. So, of course, you've got the independent auditor, and I always think of the Director of Controls as being the internal architect of the reporting structure, but not the operational person.

1782
03:55:33,000 --> 03:55:40,000
The operations, the implementation of this will all fall upon the people to the right here, the actual operation.

1783
03:55:40,000 --> 03:55:49,000
I appreciate the fact that the internal auditor is relatively new, and the internal control structure is relatively new.

1784
03:55:49,000 --> 03:56:00,000
tells me the, uh, sheriff, so to speak, coming into town and the internal sheriff are fresh eyes, and then bringing Weaver in was a very good move.

1785
03:56:00,000 --> 03:56:07,000
Uh, so I've worked on a lot of, uh… on several ERP implementations in my career, and they're always.

1786
03:56:07,000 --> 03:56:12,000
fun, I don't know, they're difficult, right? I think anybody that's done them.

1787
03:56:12,000 --> 03:56:16,000
They, uh, they cross over between software and IT.

1788
03:56:16,000 --> 03:56:22,000
Versus the operations side, be it, uh, be it, uh, finance, accounting.

1789
03:56:22,000 --> 03:56:31,000
toll collection, all that. And so, uh, I thought the one… I'm going to pick on one select recommendation. That was about a, uh.

1790
03:56:31,000 --> 03:56:40,000
status of a CIO. I really support getting that CIO in place, and I don't know if.

1791
03:56:40,000 --> 03:56:45,000
Mario, you have any comments on where we are on that?

1792
03:56:45,000 --> 03:56:51,000
First of all, you know, I have had a lot of discussions even with Courtney about this.

1793
03:56:51,000 --> 03:56:55,000
And for an organization of our size, 400 people.

1794
03:56:55,000 --> 03:57:00,000
You know, we aim for all the roles and responsibilities that we have.

1795
03:57:00,000 --> 03:57:06,000
our CIO, it's very important, but we need somebody.

1796
03:57:06,000 --> 03:57:13,000
far beyond just the CIO, due to the activity-based model runs that we're doing.

1797
03:57:13,000 --> 03:57:19,000
The data analysis, so… Actually, grace is… feels part of that role.

1798
03:57:19,000 --> 03:57:25,000
the IT person, we had one, and we lost it to private industry.

1799
03:57:25,000 --> 03:57:30,000
Um, we are putting that advertising out right now.

1800
03:57:30,000 --> 03:57:37,000
But Grace is my point person. for data and intelligence and information systems.

1801
03:57:37,000 --> 03:57:43,000
We will be evaluating if that's working. But it's very hard to have.

1802
03:57:43,000 --> 03:57:52,000
a chief data officer, a chief informational officer. So, therefore, we have consolidated based on some new models that are coming up.

1803
03:57:52,000 --> 03:57:58,000
And seeing how that works. We are advertising for an IT next week.

1804
03:57:58,000 --> 03:58:04,000
And we have put out that. Hopefully, we can keep them longer than what we kept the prior one.

1805
03:58:04,000 --> 03:58:09,000
Uh, industry went very hard on us. We had some very… a very good person who had.

1806
03:58:09,000 --> 03:58:19,000
come from Ravian, and they… poach him back. So we will be putting that out.

1807
03:58:19,000 --> 03:58:30,000
But definitely IT security system is an issue. Um, that we take very serious, and we've been focusing on that. Our cloud security also.

1808
03:58:30,000 --> 03:58:37,000
Our operations, I'm seeing, again. highlighting all the multiple activities that we're doing at one size.

1809
03:58:37,000 --> 03:58:46,000
one model doesn't fit all for the toll operations, we would… that's why we're looking into what others are doing.

1810
03:58:46,000 --> 03:58:52,000
And maybe rely more on operations with some of our other partner agencies.

1811
03:58:52,000 --> 03:58:55,000
I know I'm pivoting a little bit outside, but.

1812
03:58:55,000 --> 03:59:03,000
But that also affects our IT structures, right? So we're looking and kind of combining multiple things.

1813
03:59:03,000 --> 03:59:09,000
Being strong from an IT perspective internally, but also relying with others.

1814
03:59:09,000 --> 03:59:15,000
They have done other things better, so they can do those specialty items, and they can also take care of their IT.

1815
03:59:15,000 --> 03:59:30,000
security and efficiency. Okay, so, um… I think key in what you've said is that you're putting together an organization that will manage the ERP implementation and the overall IT data science strategy.

1816
03:59:30,000 --> 03:59:35,000
And that requires a very strong leader in that role with both.

1817
03:59:35,000 --> 03:59:41,000
operational experience and in IT understanding at the same time.

1818
03:59:41,000 --> 03:59:46,000
And then I did hear earlier, I thought I heard that you're hiring a.

1819
03:59:46,000 --> 03:59:56,000
ERP expert and outside consultant? Absolutely. I don't think I've ever done an ERP implementation without having somebody who is a nuts and bolts expert.

1820
03:59:56,000 --> 04:00:05,000
They make all the difference in the world. I guess what I'm looking for is an update in the future. I think along the lines of what Mayor Jones was asking for.

1821
04:00:05,000 --> 04:00:20,000
I would say quarterly. I would say quarterly timed with the internal auditor report. I would like to see it to the full board, but I'd like to see it go down to the level of what Weaver is describing at the high-level initiatives.

1822
04:00:20,000 --> 04:00:27,000
I certainly first, in the first review, would like to hear about the organizational changes or updates or additions.

1823
04:00:27,000 --> 04:00:32,000
Such as… and status of hiring whatever expert, ERP expert.

1824
04:00:32,000 --> 04:00:44,000
uh, IT, CIO, whatever it might be, because I think it's the people, as has been correctly identified here at all times, it's always the people that make things happen.

1825
04:00:44,000 --> 04:00:47,000
And that's the first phase. Get your organization straight.

1826
04:00:47,000 --> 04:01:01,000
I think that there are many more areas I could spend time going into, but I think the IT one and the ERP one is key. Tyler Technologies, they've got their act together. If we get on board with that and can integrate our systems with Tyler.

1827
04:01:01,000 --> 04:01:07,000
We… you will be orders of magnitude above where you've been. The trouble is, we've done too much.

1828
04:01:07,000 --> 04:01:13,000
glue by people and spreadsheets and that is destined to failure.

1829
04:01:13,000 --> 04:01:20,000
Or, uh, potentially corruption, whatever. And I think we've been down that path. We want to stop and.

1830
04:01:20,000 --> 04:01:27,000
get on a path to solution, which we are. I think we're headed down there. So I'm looking forward to quarterly updates if others agree with me.

1831
04:01:27,000 --> 04:01:33,000
Yeah, for sure, and we're also going to be bringing the updates of the different assessments.

1832
04:01:33,000 --> 04:01:38,000
HR, the one that Grace is planning for IT.

1833
04:01:38,000 --> 04:02:02,000
Um, the one that we're doing for Tollabs, because at the end of the day, everything glues together. Of course, the city… Yeah, and the city follow the money, right? We need to keep glued with finance. And in the interest of time, I was only picking on… on IT and ERP is probably one of the biggest ones, but I could have gone into many other areas. I won't do that today, because I think others have done that.

1834
04:02:02,000 --> 04:02:07,000
Okay, everybody else on the board. Yeah, Courtney. Thank you very much.

1835
04:02:07,000 --> 04:02:17,000
So I just wanted to address, um, two things. So, one, when you talk about the role of the IPA and the role of the Director of Internal Controls.

1836
04:02:17,000 --> 04:02:20,000
So the model is that there's three lines of.

1837
04:02:20,000 --> 04:02:25,000
defense for governance and risk management. That's how. It comes from the IIA.

1838
04:02:25,000 --> 04:02:33,000
So for… and you can even say people would consider the IPA a fourth line because of the independence. We're not an internal op.

1839
04:02:33,000 --> 04:02:38,000
internal audit function. Typically, internal audit is the third line of defense, so you have management.

1840
04:02:38,000 --> 04:02:46,000
who does the operations. You have the Director of Internal Controls, depending on how you address it, is doing the monitoring.

1841
04:02:46,000 --> 04:02:50,000
And then you have internal audit, and then you have independent or external.

1842
04:02:50,000 --> 04:02:55,000
on it. So those are your lines of defense when it comes to government and risk management, and it's really important.

1843
04:02:55,000 --> 04:03:00,000
that in order to give you all the assurance that that is occurring.

1844
04:03:00,000 --> 04:03:05,000
We were clear in the recommendations for the internal control framework.

1845
04:03:05,000 --> 04:03:12,000
that it be done, we recommend it because of the bandwidth from an external party, and then.

1846
04:03:12,000 --> 04:03:19,000
monitored, um, by the internal. the Director of Internal Controls, because you want that compliance.

1847
04:03:19,000 --> 04:03:29,000
You know, to ensure that before… so before we come in and spot issues, that issues are being managed internally. That is the model. So I just put that out there.

1848
04:03:29,000 --> 04:03:37,000
for information purposes. for the CIO, and as Mario said, we've had conversations, and the recommendation and.

1849
04:03:37,000 --> 04:03:43,000
in the report is for executive level. CIO, and I know he is working.

1850
04:03:43,000 --> 04:03:53,000
To determine, um, how has he expressed. Um, but I just want to stay true to the recommendations that we put forth, so thank you, Chair.

1851
04:03:53,000 --> 04:04:00,000
Great, thank you, and thank you to all of you, to Courtney and Weaver. It's… it's… Excellent work. I mean, I can't imagine.

1852
04:04:00,000 --> 04:04:12,000
the detail, and how you find out all of these things, the number of questions you must ask, and our team for, you know, responding and working well with them, and thank you for looking at all of these, I guess, corrective actions.

1853
04:04:12,000 --> 04:04:17,000
You're going to be really, really, really busy not only creating this foundation or framework, but then.

1854
04:04:17,000 --> 04:04:25,000
Doing the work that's going to go into all of that, just to keep this agency running, and the myriad ways that it runs. As Mario outlined.

1855
04:04:25,000 --> 04:04:34,000
So thank you so much for all of this. Um, there's just discussion on this, there's no action, and so we will now move to the revised position, classification and salary range table.

1856
04:04:34,000 --> 04:05:04,000
with Josh.

1857
04:05:11,000 --> 04:05:16,000
Good afternoon. My name is Joshua Golter, and I serve as SANDAG's Director of Human Resources.

1858
04:05:16,000 --> 04:05:25,000
And I will be presenting recommendations or recommended revisions to the FY2026 position classification and salary range table.

1859
04:05:25,000 --> 04:05:32,000
I do want to point out this item was updated yesterday, and you can see the current version online. You will find the summary of changes.

1860
04:05:32,000 --> 04:05:38,000
in Attachment 1, and… the red line table in attachment 2.

1861
04:05:38,000 --> 04:05:44,000
At a high level, the recommended changes are relocating the associate capital project manager to.

1862
04:05:44,000 --> 04:05:49,000
to strengthen mobility within the new capital delivery project management career ladder.

1863
04:05:49,000 --> 04:05:55,000
The recommendation is to relocate the classification as the current placement limits hiring transfer.

1864
04:05:55,000 --> 04:06:01,000
and promotional pathways from related career tracks within the agency.

1865
04:06:01,000 --> 04:06:07,000
Second, relocating Deputy director. to establish appropriate differential from direct reports.

1866
04:06:07,000 --> 04:06:13,000
And as part of a strategy to consolidate Director 1 and Director 2 into one classification.

1867
04:06:13,000 --> 04:06:20,000
The agency is recommending relocating the position from class range 130 to 131.

1868
04:06:20,000 --> 04:06:31,000
Also, relocating Deputy General Counsel classification. The agency reviewed the Deputy General Counsel role and found the position's responsibilities, complexity of work, and agency-wide impact.

1869
04:06:31,000 --> 04:06:39,000
are consistent with the director-level work. to maintain consistency across leadership roles, reclassifying the position from.

1870
04:06:39,000 --> 04:06:48,000
Class range 133 to 135 is recommended. Fourth, relocating Deputy Independent Performance Auditor.

1871
04:06:48,000 --> 04:06:53,000
This classification is recommended for salary reallocation from Class 131 to 135.

1872
04:06:53,000 --> 04:07:00,000
To maintain current alignment with newly proposed salary relocations for similar classifications.

1873
04:07:00,000 --> 04:07:11,000
Uh, streamlining the director-level structure to simplify and modernize the classification system, we recommend moving the current four-tier director structure to three levels.

1874
04:07:11,000 --> 04:07:16,000
Which would be Deputy Director, Director, and Senior Director.

1875
04:07:16,000 --> 04:07:21,000
The agency would no longer hire or promote into Director 1 or Director 2 classifications.

1876
04:07:21,000 --> 04:07:31,000
And these classifications would be removed from the salary range table once they are vacated, essentially no employees in those specific classifications.

1877
04:07:31,000 --> 04:07:41,000
A consolidated director classification is proposed for Class Range 13, based on scope and appropriate promotional differentials.

1878
04:07:41,000 --> 04:07:52,000
Elimination of the Chief of staff classification. This classification is recommended to be removed for elimination as it no longer aligns with the operational needs or the strategic direction of the agency.

1879
04:07:52,000 --> 04:07:57,000
The classification has no current incumbents and is no longer part of the organizational structure.

1880
04:07:57,000 --> 04:08:04,000
And lastly, the placement of the independent performance auditor position classification on the salary range table would be evaluated.

1881
04:08:04,000 --> 04:08:10,000
And recommendations will be presented to the Audit Committee and Board of Directors.

1882
04:08:10,000 --> 04:08:17,000
These updates maintain the board-approved FY2026 salary ranges while improving internal mobility, simplifying our structures.

1883
04:08:17,000 --> 04:08:23,000
and supporting our operational strategy. With that, I can take any questions you may have.

1884
04:08:23,000 --> 04:08:28,000
Thanks, Josh. We'll first take public comments, and then we'll go to the board member for questions and discussions. Michael.

1885
04:08:28,000 --> 04:08:37,000
Yes, we have two in-person, that's… Truth, followed by Caesar.

1886
04:08:37,000 --> 04:08:40,000
How many people actually want to be here? I don't.

1887
04:08:40,000 --> 04:08:47,000
Because you're crazy. When you present an item to the public about class ranges.

1888
04:08:47,000 --> 04:08:53,000
You need to include a clear explanation about what the differences actually are, so I don't continue to fall asleep.

1889
04:08:53,000 --> 04:08:57,000
I don't care if it's at the bottom of the page, there's an asterisk with information, it just needs to be defined.

1890
04:08:57,000 --> 04:09:05,000
I'm glad the two directors' rolls costing $228,000 and the chief of staff role costing $278,000 will be eliminated.

1891
04:09:05,000 --> 04:09:12,000
Uh, it's totally wasteful for us to be paying for somebody's coffee servers, binder deliverers, speechwriters, and parking validators.

1892
04:09:12,000 --> 04:09:21,000
Like, every county supervisor does with their money. But I'd like somebody to explain and justify why a CEO should be paid almost $500,000 a year at the maximum.

1893
04:09:21,000 --> 04:09:26,000
How is that an appropriate paycheck for a quasi-public service role?

1894
04:09:26,000 --> 04:09:33,000
And I'm not referring to Mario, but there have been a number of Sanic staffers that have made major flubs the last few years, and even this year.

1895
04:09:33,000 --> 04:09:38,000
And yet, some are making anywhere from $110,000 up to $338,000.

1896
04:09:38,000 --> 04:09:42,000
There needs to be matching pay reductions for major mistakes.

1897
04:09:42,000 --> 04:09:50,000
And SANDAG may technically be a blatant corporation, but if there's going to be an appearance of it being a public agency, and it is funded with our tax dollars.

1898
04:09:50,000 --> 04:09:54,000
And some of you are actually elected by somebody, or maybe not.

1899
04:09:54,000 --> 04:09:56,000
Uh, that means every penny of our money needs.

1900
04:09:56,000 --> 04:10:05,000
to be handled like it's gold. Take this job seriously, and the quality of your work, earn your paycheck, and you should be treated well, and be able to have fun doing it.

1901
04:10:05,000 --> 04:10:09,000
Uh, three great examples I've seen, uh, Michael, Francesca, and Arianna.

1902
04:10:09,000 --> 04:10:12,000
All very helpful and reliable people at the back.

1903
04:10:12,000 --> 04:10:18,000
Uh, even for Mario, I can say that he's able to somewhat have fun, get answers, and get the work done.

1904
04:10:18,000 --> 04:10:22,000
should have more fun. When people leave, you can… I think you're allowed to have more fun.

1905
04:10:22,000 --> 04:10:29,000
Uh, now somebody tell the representatives, some of them are not even here, that says a lot that they need to live up to that as well.

1906
04:10:29,000 --> 04:10:36,000
And I don't care if you get paid pennies on the hour, you get junk sodas and old XanXL, which isn't even chips, so come on.

1907
04:10:36,000 --> 04:10:40,000
Start working harder, quit making me fall asleep. Thank you.

1908
04:10:40,000 --> 04:10:45,000
Next is either Javier, followed by the original draw online.

1909
04:10:45,000 --> 04:10:51,000
Oh, next is original draw online, followed by Paul the Bolt.

1910
04:10:51,000 --> 04:10:57,000
It's funny to see you guys shift things around. It's like having a bunch of clutter, and then you just, like.

1911
04:10:57,000 --> 04:10:59,000
move it around to act like you cleaned it up.

1912
04:10:59,000 --> 04:11:09,000
Um, and, you know, this could potentially just be shifting things around to get people more money, and more of this, and more of that to not provide the things that.

1913
04:11:09,000 --> 04:11:14,000
You guys profess to provide, you know, because there'll always be something that gets in the way.

1914
04:11:14,000 --> 04:11:22,000
But it… I don't understand how you can have positions that you're saying that you're not going to need anymore, but you're going to keep them until there's no employees in there.

1915
04:11:22,000 --> 04:11:31,000
It doesn't make any sense. Why would you do that? And then even the ones that you take out and you say you no longer need, are those in the budget that you are.

1916
04:11:31,000 --> 04:11:34,000
Saying for the salaries that you need, that you'll, like.

1917
04:11:34,000 --> 04:11:38,000
pull that out as money that's needed, just in case that position was filled.

1918
04:11:38,000 --> 04:11:42,000
Um, and, you know, if they're not, and you did.

1919
04:11:42,000 --> 04:11:52,000
Um, you know, take that money out, where does that go? Does it go back? Does it go into somebody else's pockets? Are you just going to reclassify somebody to, you know, kind of put it in their pocket?

1920
04:11:52,000 --> 04:12:01,000
Um, just, you know, interesting to see the things that are so important to you guys to do, which is definitely making sure people are paid.

1921
04:12:01,000 --> 04:12:07,000
I mean, that is 100%, which, I mean, on the surface, that looks good, because you do want to be paid.

1922
04:12:07,000 --> 04:12:11,000
But then when you don't provide the things that, you know.

1923
04:12:11,000 --> 04:12:19,000
people that are promised to the people, and then you mismanage all of the money that you guys get because you do have your hands in so many buckets.

1924
04:12:19,000 --> 04:12:24,000
It's like, how many more positions are gonna be… I mean, like, 400 people.

1925
04:12:24,000 --> 04:12:32,000
To do all of this nonsense. And we just keep paying people more money, but we don't really have anything to show.

1926
04:12:32,000 --> 04:12:39,000
For the fruits of your labor, so it's like… You know, I mean, once people start to see that you're just paying more and more for nothing.

1927
04:12:39,000 --> 04:12:46,000
Um, but total control, because that's it. That's why you guys have to change behaviors, right? Through punitive actions.

1928
04:12:46,000 --> 04:12:57,000
Good. It's good. That's the way you treat the people, but if you're an employee, heck, you guys will make sure that you're paid a pretty penny all the time.

1929
04:12:57,000 --> 04:13:06,000
And our last public comment is Paul Devolt.

1930
04:13:06,000 --> 04:13:15,000
Not much to say here, but, um, after that scathing assessment in name only by a truly independent.

1931
04:13:15,000 --> 04:13:26,000
outside auditor. It is clear to me that some of the people here do not deserve raises. In fact, I suggest that maybe.

1932
04:13:26,000 --> 04:13:30,000
A lot of the people here seem to want.

1933
04:13:30,000 --> 04:13:41,000
Uh, long holiday, that's… Yeah. Um… Class 120 Associate Capital Project Manager 2.

1934
04:13:41,000 --> 04:13:49,000
Does not need a backhanded raise by reclassifying him or her to Class 121.

1935
04:13:49,000 --> 04:13:52,000
The only ways that I see on the list.

1936
04:13:52,000 --> 04:13:58,000
Um, capital projects cost us a lot more than it should.

1937
04:13:58,000 --> 04:14:08,000
Um, it is a rather sneaky move. What? We can, I think, expect from SANDAG.

1938
04:14:08,000 --> 04:14:20,000
I did not get to speak on non-agenda, by the way, because there was silence on the courting while waiting for quorums. Horn went to another room to see whether the meeting was on.

1939
04:14:20,000 --> 04:14:28,000
So, I suggest some background noise for. Um, the period of silence on the.

1940
04:14:28,000 --> 04:14:33,000
call-in systems. Happy Holidays!

1941
04:14:33,000 --> 04:14:42,000
Uh, to all. Um, where are you on getting voting seats for the Native Americans in East County?

1942
04:14:42,000 --> 04:14:51,000
But then taxation without a representation. Waymo driverless taxis are coming here.

1943
04:14:51,000 --> 04:14:58,000
The MTS Taxi Advisory Committee came out against Waymo, and I hope you do too.

1944
04:14:58,000 --> 04:15:07,000
These rowing menaces do not belong in our streets.

1945
04:15:07,000 --> 04:15:21,000
That concludes our public comment on this item, Chair. Okay, very good. Um, any board member comments? If not, I'd entertain a motion to approve the recommended changes to the SANDAG position classification salary range table, moved by Minto, second by Asterland.

1946
04:15:21,000 --> 04:15:38,000
Gastoline, okay, please vote. Nobody could do that fast.

1947
04:15:38,000 --> 04:15:41,000
I don't know if I should use hers are fine.

1948
04:15:41,000 --> 04:15:51,000
Use hers.

1949
04:15:51,000 --> 04:15:59,000
That was easy. Okay, that passes unanimously. Let's move to our last item, the bond issuance refunding Overview.

1950
04:15:59,000 --> 04:16:14,000
Dawn, this is you. As Don is setting up, um… She's going to be talking of, uh, there's some bonds coming for, for… Um, oh my god, I lose track of what we call… the call date for the bonds.

1951
04:16:14,000 --> 04:16:19,000
So our financial advisors evaluate if the terms that we have.

1952
04:16:19,000 --> 04:16:24,000
are good enough to continue, or if we go and do a reissuance.

1953
04:16:24,000 --> 04:16:29,000
This is not to get new money or anything like that, this is to save.

1954
04:16:29,000 --> 04:16:35,000
financing, and the team will talk about it through the life. I think we're talking about $40 million.

1955
04:16:35,000 --> 04:16:39,000
Um, potential savings, but I'll let Don take care of that.

1956
04:16:39,000 --> 04:16:47,000
All right, thank you. Um, so yes, I'm here with an overview of this proposed bond issuance.

1957
04:16:47,000 --> 04:16:54,000
We do everything that we do related to our debt in association with Board Policy 36.

1958
04:16:54,000 --> 04:17:06,000
Um, and so we have an opportunity. Uh, to achieve some savings here, the 2016 bond series is callable this year. They were issued as 10-year per call bonds.

1959
04:17:06,000 --> 04:17:10,000
Um, so I'm just gonna start out with an overview of.

1960
04:17:10,000 --> 04:17:16,000
Um, the team for this transaction, we have quite a few folks internally here at SANDAG.

1961
04:17:16,000 --> 04:17:25,000
working on this, um… PFM Financial Advisors is our financial advisor for this and on our retainer for.

1962
04:17:25,000 --> 04:17:32,000
Uh, everything else that we do. Mudra Patel from PFM is here with me today.

1963
04:17:32,000 --> 04:17:40,000
Our bond council selected for this transaction is Norton Rose Fulbright and Stradling Yoka Carlson, and Roth is our Disclosure counsel.

1964
04:17:40,000 --> 04:17:48,000
Our senior underwriting team is Wells Fargo. They are joined with co-managers from Barclays, B of A.

1965
04:17:48,000 --> 04:17:54,000
And Hilltop Securities.

1966
04:17:54,000 --> 04:18:03,000
So we're just gonna go over a few things, why we're issuing the bonds, uh, some issues related to the timing, potential size and the structure.

1967
04:18:03,000 --> 04:18:12,000
Our estimated savings and cost of issuance. Um, some issues concerning the credit ratings and the calendar of events.

1968
04:18:12,000 --> 04:18:19,000
So, again, Board Policy 36, um, is what we use. It guides us in our refunding considerations.

1969
04:18:19,000 --> 04:18:28,000
We're looking for net present value savings. In this case, we have an opportunity to do some blended arbitrage yield.

1970
04:18:28,000 --> 04:18:44,000
Um, scenarios that will actually help us, uh. Uh, earn a little bit more in our arbitrage of callable and non-callable bonds, both will be involved in this transaction. Typically, we would never have an opportunity on a non-callable bond.

1971
04:18:44,000 --> 04:18:49,000
Um, but in this case, the numbers are penciling out to blend these, uh.

1972
04:18:49,000 --> 04:18:58,000
Together, we can maintain our high credit ratings, that this structure will allow us to continue the matched maturity.

1973
04:18:58,000 --> 04:19:04,000
Um, leveled that service that we, uh, have on our senior lien bond.

1974
04:19:04,000 --> 04:19:10,000
So, timing, the 2016s, again, callable, uh, April 1st, 2026.

1975
04:19:10,000 --> 04:19:18,000
We have some callable 2019 A bonds and some callable and non-callables in the 2021A.

1976
04:19:18,000 --> 04:19:26,000
Again, I mentioned this positive arbitrage opportunity. So, within 90 days prior to the call date.

1977
04:19:26,000 --> 04:19:35,000
Um, we can actually, uh… do this refunding issuance and have an escrow deposit that earns a blended.

1978
04:19:35,000 --> 04:19:43,000
Uh, yield rate. So it blends the rates together and actually pushes up what we would be otherwise able to earn.

1979
04:19:43,000 --> 04:19:49,000
Uh, so we are trying to get this transaction through in January. That'll give us a couple months of.

1980
04:19:49,000 --> 04:20:00,000
of earnings on this as well. In terms of the size and structure, we're looking at about 334.3 million in PAR that we would refund.

1981
04:20:00,000 --> 04:20:05,000
Um, you know, we're saying all of the 2016 A's, but the actual.

1982
04:20:05,000 --> 04:20:12,000
2016 that are actually, um, coming. Uh, maturing in April.

1983
04:20:12,000 --> 04:20:17,000
Uh, may not be included in the actual refunding, we may let those just, um.

1984
04:20:17,000 --> 04:20:28,000
Mature and be paid. We're looking at, right now, what's penciling out about $17.4 million in the 2019 A's and 2021 A's at.

1985
04:20:28,000 --> 04:20:35,000
Uh, about 97.6 million, but we will have parameters, you'll see them in your documents.

1986
04:20:35,000 --> 04:20:43,000
So we do continue to watch this all the way from the time that we imagine doing the refunding to when we actually do it.

1987
04:20:43,000 --> 04:20:49,000
We are looking at the market, where things are.

1988
04:20:49,000 --> 04:20:55,000
lining up to achieve a minimum level of savings for the whole transaction.

1989
04:20:55,000 --> 04:21:00,000
and include the bonds that make the most sense to achieve that savings.

1990
04:21:00,000 --> 04:21:06,000
And, uh, these will be issued on the senior lien. They'll be tax-exempt fixed rate bonds.

1991
04:21:06,000 --> 04:21:11,000
And that matched maturity structure with uniform debt service savings.

1992
04:21:11,000 --> 04:21:23,000
Um, really, uh… We'll just keep things lined up the way they are now in terms of our debt structure. I know you see in the quarterly report the charts that show.

1993
04:21:23,000 --> 04:21:27,000
The only ascending debt level structure we have is on our TIFIA loan.

1994
04:21:27,000 --> 04:21:33,000
Everything else we really have been maintaining as a level debt service.

1995
04:21:33,000 --> 04:21:37,000
So, again, estimated savings and cost of issuance right now.

1996
04:21:37,000 --> 04:21:45,000
The 2016 A's are looking at nearly $40 million and another $3.4 million in net present value savings by.

1997
04:21:45,000 --> 04:21:52,000
Pulling those, um, maturities that are penciling out in the 2019 A's and 2021 A's.

1998
04:21:52,000 --> 04:21:57,000
with a cost of issuance of about $1.1 million.

1999
04:21:57,000 --> 04:22:01,000
In terms of the credit rating agency reviews, um.

2000
04:22:01,000 --> 04:22:07,000
We have our appointments lined up with Standard & Poor's and Fitch right now. We're carrying AAA ratings.

2001
04:22:07,000 --> 04:22:11,000
Uh, on the senior lane, we don't expect anything to change with that.

2002
04:22:11,000 --> 04:22:14,000
But what you can see here is on our subordinate lien.

2003
04:22:14,000 --> 04:22:21,000
S&P has us at AA, and FIT has us at AA+, and we think this is a very good opportunity.

2004
04:22:21,000 --> 04:22:26,000
to request S&P to look a little closer at this and not just up, because we feel strongly.

2005
04:22:26,000 --> 04:22:30,000
That we should be in the AA plus category.

2006
04:22:30,000 --> 04:22:37,000
Um, and again, that final junior subordinate lien of the TIFIA loan is an A-plus rating, which is.

2007
04:22:37,000 --> 04:22:49,000
Pretty… all of our ratings are very solid. Um, in terms of next steps, I wanted to mention first, um, what you have in your packet does include.

2008
04:22:49,000 --> 04:22:56,000
a pretty robust set of the draft documents. We are not planning to go over those with you today in detail.

2009
04:22:56,000 --> 04:23:02,000
We will be back in January with our bond council, with our disclosure Council, and we will be walking through.

2010
04:23:02,000 --> 04:23:07,000
the documents and what they contain and responsibilities for review.

2011
04:23:07,000 --> 04:23:15,000
Um, but today we wanted to give you the overview, uh, allow you to, you know, ask any questions about the overall transaction that you have.

2012
04:23:15,000 --> 04:23:18,000
And let you know, uh, what the process is.

2013
04:23:18,000 --> 04:23:24,000
So we anticipate receiving the ratings from the agencies the week of January 19.

2014
04:23:24,000 --> 04:23:30,000
Again, we'll come back, uh, January 23rd with the final bond documents.

2015
04:23:30,000 --> 04:23:36,000
We're going to post the preliminary official statement and do the marketing of bonds the following week.

2016
04:23:36,000 --> 04:23:41,000
With an anticipated pricing date, uh, that first week of February, and closing.

2017
04:23:41,000 --> 04:23:50,000
the second week of February. And with that, Mudra and I are available to answer any questions you might have.

2018
04:23:50,000 --> 04:23:56,000
Thank you very much. All right, we're going to go to public comment, please, Michael.

2019
04:23:56,000 --> 04:24:00,000
We have one public comment, if you are online, please raise your hand now.

2020
04:24:00,000 --> 04:24:08,000
Versus truth? I thought I'd get extra laughs, because you can't have enough of that in boring meetings. No offense!

2021
04:24:08,000 --> 04:24:18,000
No offense financing, but I hate numbers. Uh, let's see, I can say hi to somebody. There's Bruce. Hi, Bruce, how you doing? I did already give him a shout-out. Um… oh, I like Terry. Terry's great.

2022
04:24:18,000 --> 04:24:21,000
Kevin, I think about it.

2023
04:24:21,000 --> 04:24:32,000
All right, they look how much time my waist is. Sanag has a peak debt service of $161 million, a $2.2 billion in outstanding debt.

2024
04:24:32,000 --> 04:24:45,000
Thanks, Hasan and Andre. You know, it's, uh… Interesting that no matter what SANAG or the media says the numbers are showing that Trump policies seem to be resulting in a much more stable market than Biden policies. I'd just like to throw a controversy.

2025
04:24:45,000 --> 04:24:50,000
I'm not even a Trump fan, but when you look at the egg prices, $8 down to $3.

2026
04:24:50,000 --> 04:24:58,000
What are you gonna complain about? Uh, in fact, if you're outside of crazy California, you know, everything's affordable. It's amazing how that works.

2027
04:24:58,000 --> 04:25:11,000
Um, but let's see, let's see, uh… indentured debt slavery is what bonds are. Sati needs to pay the debt off that it unjustly incurred for fake transportation solutions, like toll lanes and then never implement managed toll lanes ever again.

2028
04:25:11,000 --> 04:25:16,000
Uh, and it's actually unjust to celebrate no road tax, but then confirm.

2029
04:25:16,000 --> 04:25:23,000
two new sales taxes, which. Actually, I say confirmed, but that's not gonna happen. I think that's dream world.

2030
04:25:23,000 --> 04:25:27,000
So, again, finance, you need to look at that, because that's not happening.

2031
04:25:27,000 --> 04:25:30,000
And it says something about, uh, there's a team.

2032
04:25:30,000 --> 04:25:35,000
that engage the financial advisor, uh, can we get names for those people that we're paying for it? I don't even know who that is.

2033
04:25:35,000 --> 04:25:48,000
Um, question, when the 2026 A bonds with Wells Fargo were decided, was that when SENAG was located within the Wells Fargo building? I would hope not, because that seems like a conflict of interest, or some kind of conflict.

2034
04:25:48,000 --> 04:25:59,000
And, uh, speaking of financials, uh, Terry officially joined the Broken Record Club today. Congratulations on that. And you did it with numbers, that's how it's relative. See, I put it all together.

2035
04:25:59,000 --> 04:26:09,000
Um, how everyone can stop being a broken record on every topic. Work is hard, as the Santee City Council members. How about that? Merry Christmas.

2036
04:26:09,000 --> 04:26:13,000
Next on line is the original draw, followed by Paul the Bold.

2037
04:26:13,000 --> 04:26:18,000
The item here is the proposed 2026 bond issuance.

2038
04:26:18,000 --> 04:26:32,000
Man, talk about a perpetual state of debt just all the time, and it's… It's interesting, because it makes you wonder how many, you know, projects have you guys engaged in that needed this bond, um, to use them to get the money to…

2039
04:26:32,000 --> 04:26:39,000
You know, complete, or start, or whatever, and that never were, and then we're just continuing to pay.

2040
04:26:39,000 --> 04:26:44,000
on debt, and it's like, you know, you guys just continue to get more.

2041
04:26:44,000 --> 04:26:45,000
money of our… I just… there's nothing to show for the amounts of money that comes across any government hands.

2042
04:26:45,000 --> 04:26:51,000
Ah.

2043
04:26:51,000 --> 04:26:56,000
I mean, it's astronomical amounts, all while people sit here and they're suffering, they don't get to sit and.

2044
04:26:56,000 --> 04:26:59,000
be in debt like this, I mean, you'll take their house.

2045
04:26:59,000 --> 04:27:08,000
And sell it for $100. Which is what the county does, because you can't pay your taxes. It's like, but you guys sit here, and you rob us.

2046
04:27:08,000 --> 04:27:13,000
of our money that could be used to help people actually, you know, just survive.

2047
04:27:13,000 --> 04:27:19,000
And instead, you go and you just create more debt for us to have to pay off.

2048
04:27:19,000 --> 04:27:28,000
And then you want to come at us and be like, we're gonna need some more money, because you know what? We need to pay our employees and make sure that we can still provide all the things that you guys.

2049
04:27:28,000 --> 04:27:39,000
that we're providing for you, which is nothing. It's like, you look around, and you're, like, taking things away. Like I said before, trying to change people's behaviors, which is psychotic in itself.

2050
04:27:39,000 --> 04:27:47,000
And it's like… it's just sad, because, I mean, nobody should have even given up their money for gold, like, their gold for IOUs.

2051
04:27:47,000 --> 04:27:50,000
But people who were stupid enough to do that.

2052
04:27:50,000 --> 04:27:55,000
And now money is worthless, and then we're gonna go into some, you know, fully digital kind of currency.

2053
04:27:55,000 --> 04:28:02,000
Or it's going to be even more easy to regulate people, because, you know, you're gonna bring in some kind of.

2054
04:28:02,000 --> 04:28:18,000
Or the… whatever the government will, we'll bring in some kind of, you know, um, universal basic income, and then take out how much you need to pay for your rent, your transportation, and everything, and they'll be like, here, you have a couple pennies left, but you know what? Pennies are worthless, and we're gonna take those out, so you don't even have anything. It is just so sad.

2055
04:28:18,000 --> 04:28:24,000
To see how much money goes through your hands, and we have nothing to show for it, and you virtue signal like you're perfect.

2056
04:28:24,000 --> 04:28:34,000
Thank you. Our last public comment is Paul the Bold.

2057
04:28:34,000 --> 04:28:39,000
bold here. Um… Again, the happy holidays.

2058
04:28:39,000 --> 04:28:45,000
Uh, the staff report cites, uh, $55 million savings under.

2059
04:28:45,000 --> 04:28:53,000
Current market conditions. current, that is the operative word.

2060
04:28:53,000 --> 04:29:00,000
The market is changing fast, so you might want to proceed rather quickly on this, but I'm not sure if.

2061
04:29:00,000 --> 04:29:09,000
really practical. Because there's another issue I hope people snap up the new bonds.

2062
04:29:09,000 --> 04:29:14,000
Otherwise, uh, there's… Debt refunding won't work.

2063
04:29:14,000 --> 04:29:24,000
And, um, are actually there are less and less people in the county, or probably who want this.

2064
04:29:24,000 --> 04:29:33,000
Who want the new bonds. Um, I see, by the way, that the draft resolution goes.

2065
04:29:33,000 --> 04:29:45,000
From Section 6 to Section 9. What would we do without people to actually check the resolution to see if the.

2066
04:29:45,000 --> 04:29:54,000
The sequence is logical. Proofreading error, or is this… Purposeful omission.

2067
04:29:54,000 --> 04:30:01,000
Um… anyway. As I say, happy holidays, uh, to all.

2068
04:30:01,000 --> 04:30:08,000
Um, and, um… keeping it short, thank you.

2069
04:30:08,000 --> 04:30:10,000
That concludes our public comment on this item, Chair.

2070
04:30:10,000 --> 04:30:18,000
Thank you very much. Okay, I see nobody on the board. Thank you so much, Don and Mudra. We'll see you early next year to do the deal.

2071
04:30:18,000 --> 04:30:24,000
Um, and get this done. I should be on the board. Oh, okay, Mayor Gasterland? Okay, thanks.

2072
04:30:24,000 --> 04:30:33,000
Um, Don, I wanted to… put 3 questions on the table, and I doubt that you have the answers right now.

2073
04:30:33,000 --> 04:30:40,000
But I'd like to get the answers. So the first one is, how much of the future transnet revenues are obligated by these bonds?

2074
04:30:40,000 --> 04:30:45,000
You know, what portion is going to the bond service, and what portion is.

2075
04:30:45,000 --> 04:30:56,000
Available going forward. I don't have it off the top of my head right now. I should have brought the last quarterly report… Yeah, and I didn't give you these questions in advance, but I will for sure get that to you.

2076
04:30:56,000 --> 04:31:04,000
Great. What will the bond revenue… what did the bond revenues pay for, or will be paying for, is my second question.

2077
04:31:04,000 --> 04:31:12,000
And what I'll request is a table of the 2016A 2019A, and 2021 bonds, how much each was.

2078
04:31:12,000 --> 04:31:19,000
And what they were for. I'd like to review that so that I have an understanding of what we have done with this money.

2079
04:31:19,000 --> 04:31:28,000
over the years since 2016. Yes, so first let me say that the bonds that have been issued with the transnet Revenue Pledge have been.

2080
04:31:28,000 --> 04:31:37,000
Transnet major corridor projects. Uh, the most of the debt was related to the Early Action Program.

2081
04:31:37,000 --> 04:31:45,000
of projects, so that… that group of projects that was identified for early action when the ordinance initially passed. Things like.

2082
04:31:45,000 --> 04:31:56,000
completion of State Route 5276. Mid-coast, I-5 North Coast corridor, the 8, uh… 805 HOV lanes.

2083
04:31:56,000 --> 04:32:06,000
Uh, just several projects that… oh, I-15, I think, was also in the list. This is my capital person who can remind me everything that was in the Early Action Program.

2084
04:32:06,000 --> 04:32:14,000
But the debt is related to the transnit major corridor Program, predominantly the Early Action Program.

2085
04:32:14,000 --> 04:32:22,000
It was envisioned that we would do debt financing on the projects that were prioritized at the time the ordinance passed.

2086
04:32:22,000 --> 04:32:30,000
then move into a pay-as-you-go. situation. Um, the board policy on debt.

2087
04:32:30,000 --> 04:32:37,000
It indicates that, so of the. Transnet revenues that come into the major corridor.

2088
04:32:37,000 --> 04:32:45,000
We are restricted to assuring that we have a one-to-one ratio, so the debt on the major corridor program can never be more than.

2089
04:32:45,000 --> 04:32:55,000
Uh, that one-time coverage. Right, so that we have money to go into the program. So every dollar we put into new capital projects that are currently in the program.

2090
04:32:55,000 --> 04:33:02,000
No more than a dollar and… Go into the debt. If you would like the table to include.

2091
04:33:02,000 --> 04:33:11,000
The specifics of projects that it went into. Uh, that may take a little bit more time to get, but the reality is that, I mean, so these bond issuances.

2092
04:33:11,000 --> 04:33:28,000
Um, I think the 2021 was… Likely, um… small amount of new money, maybe, but mostly a refunding. So some of these have been refundings as well over time, because we began issuing bonds back in 2008.

2093
04:33:28,000 --> 04:33:34,000
Um, and so when we have the call dates come up, we've done several additional refundings.

2094
04:33:34,000 --> 04:33:41,000
Um, so I can work directly with you and figure out what you want that table to encompass. That's great. Mayor, um.

2095
04:33:41,000 --> 04:33:46,000
If my memory serves me right, and Susan will correct me later on.

2096
04:33:46,000 --> 04:33:54,000
We have delivered… All the projects in the early action item except 52.

2097
04:33:54,000 --> 04:34:01,000
is the only one remaining, but all the ones on the early action were delivered.

2098
04:34:01,000 --> 04:34:06,000
have been delivered, so maybe a reminder to the board of what those early action items were, because.

2099
04:34:06,000 --> 04:34:09,000
then we'll be in a position to speak to.

2100
04:34:09,000 --> 04:34:16,000
What was this money used for, and we're being wise, and thank you for bringing the refunding or refinancing of this.

2101
04:34:16,000 --> 04:34:21,000
forward so that we hear about it. So, there's no motion to be made, correct?

2102
04:34:21,000 --> 04:34:27,000
Okay, very good. This concludes our meeting. Thanks for staying for the whole time. The next Board of Directors meeting will be January 9th.

2103
04:34:27,000 --> 04:34:37,000
2026 at 9am. This meeting is adjourned. Happy, safe, and healthy holidays.