1 00:02:59,692 --> 00:03:01,692 . 2 00:04:59,243 --> 00:05:01,243 Can 3 00:07:10,175 --> 00:07:12,175 I 4 00:08:34,930 --> 00:08:36,930 go to 5 00:09:06,659 --> 00:09:08,659 your 6 00:09:39,959 --> 00:09:40,359 again and 7 00:09:40,359 --> 00:09:40,793 All right. 8 00:09:40,793 --> 00:09:42,793 Good morning. 9 00:09:44,130 --> 00:09:44,764 I will now call the city 10 00:09:44,764 --> 00:09:45,430 council meeting on Monday, 11 00:09:45,430 --> 00:09:46,310 NOVEMBER 16th, 2026 to order 12 00:09:46,310 --> 00:09:48,431 Deputy Clerk please call 13 00:09:49,402 --> 00:09:50,200 the roll Council Member 14 00:09:50,200 --> 00:09:52,200 Campbell Council Member 15 00:09:54,730 --> 00:09:56,473 Whitburn Council Member Foster 16 00:09:58,210 --> 00:09:58,911 Council Member Von Wilpert 17 00:09:58,911 --> 00:10:01,911 Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee 18 00:10:03,716 --> 00:10:04,417 Council Member Campo Council 19 00:10:04,417 --> 00:10:06,817 Member Moreno Present Council 20 00:10:08,488 --> 00:10:09,188 Member Eli Rivera and Council 21 00:10:09,188 --> 00:10:11,588 PRESIDENT LaCava present also 22 00:10:13,493 --> 00:10:14,930 attending the meeting are City 23 00:10:14,930 --> 00:10:14,727 Attorney Heather Ferber, 24 00:10:14,727 --> 00:10:16,727 independent budget analyst 25 00:10:18,665 --> 00:10:19,365 Charles Monica and myself your 26 00:10:19,365 --> 00:10:22,365 deputy city Clerk Kevin Smith. 27 00:10:23,135 --> 00:10:23,903 >> All right, thank you Deputy 28 00:10:23,903 --> 00:10:24,636 Clerk a quorum is now present. 29 00:10:24,636 --> 00:10:25,405 We will begin this morning with 30 00:10:25,405 --> 00:10:28,405 an invocation by Deputy Clerk 31 00:10:28,641 --> 00:10:29,342 Smith followed with the land 32 00:10:29,342 --> 00:10:30,900 acknowledgment and the Pledge 33 00:10:30,900 --> 00:10:33,900 of Allegiance led by council 34 00:10:33,179 --> 00:10:35,179 member Thank you. 35 00:10:38,151 --> 00:10:38,851 >> I grant those who hold 36 00:10:38,851 --> 00:10:42,451 office in the city the spirit 37 00:10:42,991 --> 00:10:43,690 of wisdom, charity and justice 38 00:10:43,690 --> 00:10:44,356 that was steadfast purpose. 39 00:10:44,356 --> 00:10:47,356 They MAY faithfully serve in 40 00:10:47,760 --> 00:10:48,461 their offices to promote 41 00:10:48,461 --> 00:10:49,128 the well-being of all people. 42 00:10:49,128 --> 00:10:51,128 We respectfully acknowledge 43 00:10:52,665 --> 00:10:53,333 that the culmination or 44 00:10:53,333 --> 00:10:54,330 the original inhabitants of 45 00:10:54,330 --> 00:10:57,437 the Unceded land now known as 46 00:10:57,437 --> 00:10:58,104 San Diego Despite enduring 47 00:10:58,104 --> 00:10:58,805 the horrors of genocide and 48 00:10:58,805 --> 00:11:01,205 colonization, the human spirit 49 00:11:01,674 --> 00:11:02,442 remains unbroken. 50 00:11:02,442 --> 00:11:03,143 We honor the resilience of 51 00:11:03,143 --> 00:11:06,143 their ancestors who fought to 52 00:11:06,545 --> 00:11:06,879 protect their culture and land 53 00:11:06,879 --> 00:11:07,580 . 54 00:11:07,580 --> 00:11:08,248 Today they carry their legacy 55 00:11:08,248 --> 00:11:10,648 forward ensuring that their 56 00:11:11,840 --> 00:11:11,717 traditions continue to thrive 57 00:11:11,717 --> 00:11:12,418 in gratitude and strength. 58 00:11:12,418 --> 00:11:15,418 We stand with the culmination 59 00:11:16,122 --> 00:11:16,856 connected to our past and 60 00:11:16,856 --> 00:11:18,691 committed to a thriving future. 61 00:11:18,691 --> 00:11:21,691 >> Please face the flag or 62 00:11:37,977 --> 00:11:40,977 right on forward Deputy Clerk 63 00:11:42,482 --> 00:11:43,115 Please go over how the public 64 00:11:43,115 --> 00:11:43,850 can offer their testimony. 65 00:11:43,850 --> 00:11:47,450 I'd like to highlight the slide 66 00:11:47,754 --> 00:11:48,388 on the screen. 67 00:11:48,388 --> 00:11:49,122 The order can be found on 68 00:11:49,122 --> 00:11:51,924 the agenda summary online or at 69 00:11:51,924 --> 00:11:52,292 the table in the back of 70 00:11:52,292 --> 00:11:53,260 the room. 71 00:11:53,260 --> 00:11:53,659 If you are in person please 72 00:11:53,659 --> 00:11:54,293 complete the speaker slip 73 00:11:54,293 --> 00:11:56,863 located at the entrance of 74 00:11:56,863 --> 00:11:57,429 chambers and bring it to 75 00:11:57,429 --> 00:11:58,131 the front of the room. 76 00:11:58,131 --> 00:12:00,531 No further in-person testimony 77 00:12:01,330 --> 00:12:01,701 will be taken once the Council 78 00:12:01,701 --> 00:12:02,335 begins virtual testimony for 79 00:12:02,335 --> 00:12:04,335 better meeting management 80 00:12:06,172 --> 00:12:06,873 purposes Each speaker will have 81 00:12:06,873 --> 00:12:08,875 one minute per item per person 82 00:12:08,875 --> 00:12:09,643 up to a maximum of three 83 00:12:09,643 --> 00:12:13,243 minutes If there are three or 84 00:12:14,280 --> 00:12:14,680 more items. 85 00:12:14,680 --> 00:12:15,348 Thank you. 86 00:12:15,348 --> 00:12:16,490 The Clerk friendly reminder 87 00:12:16,490 --> 00:12:19,519 that for both this morning and 88 00:12:19,519 --> 00:12:20,220 this afternoon session 89 00:12:20,220 --> 00:12:23,220 knowledge in a public comment 90 00:12:23,823 --> 00:12:24,491 is the opportunity to speak on 91 00:12:24,491 --> 00:12:24,825 any items within the city's 92 00:12:24,825 --> 00:12:25,492 purview. 93 00:12:25,492 --> 00:12:26,159 But if you're speaking to a 94 00:12:26,159 --> 00:12:27,627 docketed item please confine 95 00:12:27,627 --> 00:12:30,627 your comments to that docket 96 00:12:32,650 --> 00:12:32,766 item. 97 00:12:32,766 --> 00:12:33,466 With that Deputy clerk please 98 00:12:33,466 --> 00:12:36,466 read the closed session Record 99 00:12:37,471 --> 00:12:38,370 closed session items into 100 00:12:38,370 --> 00:12:40,370 the record conference. 101 00:12:42,209 --> 00:12:42,809 a legal counsel anticipate a 102 00:12:42,809 --> 00:12:43,377 litigation initiation of 103 00:12:43,377 --> 00:12:45,377 litigation pursuant to 104 00:12:45,679 --> 00:12:47,679 California Government Code 105 00:12:49,750 --> 00:12:50,450 Section 5495 6.94 See us one 106 00:12:50,450 --> 00:12:53,450 number of cases one conference 107 00:12:54,321 --> 00:12:56,721 with Labor negotiators pursuant 108 00:12:58,458 --> 00:12:59,259 to California Government Code 109 00:12:59,259 --> 00:13:01,659 Section 54957.6 See us to 110 00:13:02,729 --> 00:13:03,396 setting designated management 111 00:13:03,396 --> 00:13:03,964 team representatives see as 112 00:13:03,964 --> 00:13:05,964 three City designated 113 00:13:07,267 --> 00:13:07,501 management team representatives 114 00:13:07,501 --> 00:13:08,100 . 115 00:13:08,100 --> 00:13:08,702 >> All right. 116 00:13:08,702 --> 00:13:11,702 Before we proceed with public 117 00:13:12,505 --> 00:13:13,106 comment, I understand our city 118 00:13:13,106 --> 00:13:13,473 attorney have comments. 119 00:13:13,473 --> 00:13:15,473 Thank you. 120 00:13:16,876 --> 00:13:17,476 Yes, I wanted to correct some 121 00:13:17,476 --> 00:13:18,145 of the participants in 122 00:13:18,145 --> 00:13:21,145 the concession items two and 123 00:13:22,616 --> 00:13:23,216 three Franklin Cooper's Smith 124 00:13:23,216 --> 00:13:23,916 will be attending closed 125 00:13:23,916 --> 00:13:24,585 session for season two and us 126 00:13:24,585 --> 00:13:27,153 three in the place of Julie 127 00:13:27,153 --> 00:13:27,788 Rasco. 128 00:13:27,788 --> 00:13:28,422 MR. Coopersmith is the new 129 00:13:28,422 --> 00:13:30,422 Human Resources Department 130 00:13:31,357 --> 00:13:32,590 director also attending on cac 131 00:13:32,590 --> 00:13:32,693 will be Commissioner of Police 132 00:13:32,693 --> 00:13:34,693 Practices Staff Executive 133 00:13:36,630 --> 00:13:36,730 Director Roger Smith, General 134 00:13:36,730 --> 00:13:37,430 Counsel Susan Saint John and 135 00:13:37,430 --> 00:13:39,830 chief investigator Olga Golub. 136 00:13:41,101 --> 00:13:41,502 >> Thank you. 137 00:13:41,502 --> 00:13:42,235 All right. 138 00:13:42,235 --> 00:13:42,970 Thank you for those corrections 139 00:13:42,970 --> 00:13:45,539 being read into the record with 140 00:13:45,539 --> 00:13:46,206 that deputy clerk Please 141 00:13:46,206 --> 00:13:46,873 proceed with public comment. 142 00:13:46,873 --> 00:13:47,207 We will begin with in-person 143 00:13:47,207 --> 00:13:49,207 comment. 144 00:13:50,310 --> 00:13:50,644 Max Schmidt please come 145 00:13:50,644 --> 00:13:51,345 forward. 146 00:13:51,345 --> 00:13:51,611 You have requested to speak on 147 00:13:51,611 --> 00:13:53,112 c. 148 00:13:53,112 --> 00:13:54,810 S one. 149 00:13:54,810 --> 00:13:57,681 You will have one minute to 150 00:14:12,766 --> 00:14:13,133 speak. 151 00:14:13,133 --> 00:14:15,133 Hi. 152 00:14:16,470 --> 00:14:17,137 The First Amendment is the most 153 00:14:17,137 --> 00:14:17,471 important amendment in this 154 00:14:17,471 --> 00:14:19,471 nation. 155 00:14:22,543 --> 00:14:23,310 MR. Schmidt and c Yes MR. 156 00:14:23,310 --> 00:14:23,744 Schmidt I want to say I am 157 00:14:23,744 --> 00:14:25,744 opposed to c. 158 00:14:26,747 --> 00:14:28,915 S one and I am for four on four 159 00:14:28,915 --> 00:14:29,783 c it's one. 160 00:14:29,783 --> 00:14:30,551 I've come here to use my First 161 00:14:30,551 --> 00:14:33,587 Amendment to say I'm opposed to 162 00:14:33,587 --> 00:14:34,540 see us one and you already 163 00:14:34,540 --> 00:14:34,822 interrupted me. 164 00:14:34,822 --> 00:14:37,925 >> So what do you got to say? 165 00:14:37,925 --> 00:14:38,225 Could you please lower your 166 00:14:38,225 --> 00:14:38,926 tone? 167 00:14:38,926 --> 00:14:39,326 >> We're just trying to run 168 00:14:39,326 --> 00:14:41,326 the meeting. 169 00:14:41,895 --> 00:14:42,763 Yes, the tone is appropriate 170 00:14:42,763 --> 00:14:43,564 for for what is going on here. 171 00:14:43,564 --> 00:14:44,980 I'm allowed to use this tone of 172 00:14:44,980 --> 00:14:46,980 my First Amendment. 173 00:14:47,268 --> 00:14:47,601 So what are you got to say, MR. 174 00:14:47,601 --> 00:14:49,601 Schmidt? 175 00:14:50,671 --> 00:14:51,638 >> You submitted to additional 176 00:14:51,638 --> 00:14:55,838 requests as you came up, so I 177 00:14:56,377 --> 00:14:57,144 was just going to tell you that 178 00:14:57,144 --> 00:14:57,778 you will have a total of three 179 00:14:57,778 --> 00:14:58,579 minutes for your comments. 180 00:14:58,579 --> 00:15:00,848 >> I thought you were going to 181 00:15:00,848 --> 00:15:01,348 say something about my tone. 182 00:15:01,348 --> 00:15:03,348 >> I did. 183 00:15:05,385 --> 00:15:07,785 Please confined yourself to 184 00:15:09,890 --> 00:15:09,723 the chambers Demeanor is my 185 00:15:09,723 --> 00:15:10,191 First Amendment not being 186 00:15:10,191 --> 00:15:12,191 infringed upon. 187 00:15:14,228 --> 00:15:14,695 >> We're not talking about 188 00:15:14,695 --> 00:15:15,262 First Amendment. 189 00:15:15,262 --> 00:15:15,996 >> We're talking about 190 00:15:15,996 --> 00:15:16,530 testimony and I'm talking about 191 00:15:16,530 --> 00:15:16,864 my First Amendment. 192 00:15:16,864 --> 00:15:18,864 Please. 193 00:15:19,366 --> 00:15:20,330 Am I not allowed to use this 194 00:15:20,330 --> 00:15:20,501 tone as my First Amendment? 195 00:15:20,501 --> 00:15:21,469 Please proceed. 196 00:15:21,469 --> 00:15:24,204 What do you mean my tone in my 197 00:15:24,204 --> 00:15:25,720 child? 198 00:15:25,720 --> 00:15:25,539 I'm a 35 year old man. 199 00:15:25,539 --> 00:15:26,207 You're an adult. 200 00:15:26,207 --> 00:15:28,876 You're patronizing me like a 201 00:15:28,876 --> 00:15:29,577 child about my tone during when 202 00:15:29,577 --> 00:15:30,177 it's my public comment Time to 203 00:15:30,177 --> 00:15:32,577 use my First Amendment. 204 00:15:33,714 --> 00:15:34,314 Can you explain further what 205 00:15:34,314 --> 00:15:35,150 you mean about my tone? 206 00:15:35,150 --> 00:15:35,683 Sir, please proceed with your 207 00:15:35,683 --> 00:15:38,619 testimony on the three items 208 00:15:38,619 --> 00:15:39,552 that you requested. 209 00:15:39,552 --> 00:15:43,152 So my tone is unacceptable for 210 00:15:43,891 --> 00:15:44,492 the chambers what you're saying 211 00:15:44,492 --> 00:15:45,920 Please proceed with your 212 00:15:45,920 --> 00:15:45,426 testimony on the three. 213 00:15:45,426 --> 00:15:47,426 >> Okay. 214 00:15:53,167 --> 00:15:55,167 Thank you. 215 00:15:57,605 --> 00:15:58,305 Our next speaker is Jay M.C. 216 00:15:58,305 --> 00:16:01,305 You have submitted a speaker 217 00:16:03,100 --> 00:16:03,711 slip with request to speak on 218 00:16:03,711 --> 00:16:04,578 items the students Yes, three 219 00:16:04,578 --> 00:16:07,882 So you'll have two minutes to 220 00:16:07,882 --> 00:16:08,249 speak. 221 00:16:08,249 --> 00:16:08,683 Thank you. 222 00:16:08,683 --> 00:16:10,683 Appreciate it. 223 00:16:12,320 --> 00:16:13,187 Good morning. 224 00:16:13,187 --> 00:16:13,821 So speaking on c us two is 225 00:16:13,821 --> 00:16:16,221 history relates to labor. 226 00:16:17,358 --> 00:16:17,992 We know that labor is very 227 00:16:17,992 --> 00:16:20,992 costly with regards to our 228 00:16:21,995 --> 00:16:22,797 general fund budget. 229 00:16:22,797 --> 00:16:23,564 Each of you has probably served 230 00:16:23,564 --> 00:16:26,801 as a member of the Budget 231 00:16:26,801 --> 00:16:29,201 Committee knows the percentages 232 00:16:29,904 --> 00:16:30,871 in excess of 6,970%. 233 00:16:30,871 --> 00:16:34,471 Just speaking to hope that my 234 00:16:35,109 --> 00:16:35,910 district one representative 235 00:16:35,910 --> 00:16:38,910 will consider the analysis in 236 00:16:40,180 --> 00:16:40,848 the Independent budget analysis 237 00:16:40,848 --> 00:16:43,848 will consider to what extent 238 00:16:44,351 --> 00:16:45,860 our general fund does not have 239 00:16:45,860 --> 00:16:48,686 a structural deficit that is to 240 00:16:50,157 --> 00:16:50,791 say a portion of our general 241 00:16:50,791 --> 00:16:51,291 fund pays for the costs of 242 00:16:51,291 --> 00:16:51,993 filling potholes. 243 00:16:51,993 --> 00:16:54,394 A portion of our general fund 244 00:16:54,394 --> 00:16:54,929 pays for the cost of ensuring 245 00:16:54,929 --> 00:16:57,329 that Mission Bay and 246 00:16:58,566 --> 00:16:59,000 communities like La Hoya Shores 247 00:16:59,000 --> 00:16:59,833 have services. 248 00:16:59,833 --> 00:17:03,437 So that's just to say I'm not 249 00:17:03,437 --> 00:17:04,105 sure to what extent our elected 250 00:17:04,105 --> 00:17:04,906 officials this body can say 251 00:17:04,906 --> 00:17:08,309 that we do have a structural 252 00:17:08,309 --> 00:17:09,760 deficit in our general fund but 253 00:17:09,760 --> 00:17:12,676 to the extent we have no 254 00:17:13,247 --> 00:17:16,247 intention or sense of urgency 255 00:17:17,384 --> 00:17:18,219 to handle deferred maintenance 256 00:17:18,219 --> 00:17:18,553 then we don't have a structural 257 00:17:18,553 --> 00:17:19,219 budget. 258 00:17:19,219 --> 00:17:22,456 That's just to say I've had 259 00:17:22,456 --> 00:17:23,157 neighbors who've lost 260 00:17:23,157 --> 00:17:25,157 homeownership in southeastern 261 00:17:27,328 --> 00:17:28,195 San Diego when there were fight 262 00:17:28,195 --> 00:17:28,963 floods and they all knew it was 263 00:17:28,963 --> 00:17:31,963 coming coming and weather and 264 00:17:32,100 --> 00:17:32,900 whatnot. 265 00:17:32,900 --> 00:17:36,500 It says to those neighbors that 266 00:17:36,638 --> 00:17:37,505 the backlog of service items 267 00:17:37,505 --> 00:17:38,172 and get it done that are paid 268 00:17:38,172 --> 00:17:38,906 for general fund departments 269 00:17:38,906 --> 00:17:41,906 like those that are represented 270 00:17:42,410 --> 00:17:46,100 here and see us to assist. 271 00:17:46,247 --> 00:17:46,948 Three there is not a structural 272 00:17:46,948 --> 00:17:47,549 deficit and general fund seems 273 00:17:47,549 --> 00:17:48,115 to suggest to them that 274 00:17:48,115 --> 00:17:50,515 the time to deliver 275 00:17:50,985 --> 00:17:51,653 the services is going to happen 276 00:17:51,653 --> 00:17:55,253 when it happens even if that 277 00:17:55,523 --> 00:17:56,224 means that homeownership 278 00:17:56,224 --> 00:17:56,523 generational homeownership is 279 00:17:56,523 --> 00:17:57,224 lost. 280 00:17:57,224 --> 00:18:00,224 Appreciate your time and look 281 00:18:00,894 --> 00:18:01,595 forward to your analysis to 282 00:18:01,595 --> 00:18:02,296 verify or otherwise challenge 283 00:18:02,296 --> 00:18:04,465 the assumptions that the city 284 00:18:04,465 --> 00:18:05,990 does not have a structural 285 00:18:05,990 --> 00:18:07,499 deficit for general fund. 286 00:18:09,571 --> 00:18:10,710 >> Appreciate your time. 287 00:18:10,710 --> 00:18:10,738 >> Thank you. 288 00:18:10,738 --> 00:18:13,138 That does conclude in-person 289 00:18:15,176 --> 00:18:15,910 public comment. 290 00:18:15,910 --> 00:18:16,644 I have started the five minute 291 00:18:16,644 --> 00:18:18,446 timer and council chambers will 292 00:18:18,446 --> 00:18:19,114 now turn to the virtual queue 293 00:18:19,114 --> 00:18:19,681 in which there are four 294 00:18:19,681 --> 00:18:21,681 participants currently 295 00:18:23,685 --> 00:18:24,318 requesting to speak. 296 00:18:24,318 --> 00:18:24,986 Beekman Please state which 297 00:18:24,986 --> 00:18:27,986 closed session item or items 298 00:18:28,189 --> 00:18:31,189 you wish to speak to. 299 00:18:34,195 --> 00:18:34,962 Hi we're Beekman. 300 00:18:34,962 --> 00:18:35,296 >> I'd like to speak to 301 00:18:35,296 --> 00:18:37,296 6162163. 302 00:18:38,499 --> 00:18:39,000 Okay You'll have three minutes. 303 00:18:39,000 --> 00:18:39,367 >> Please proceed. 304 00:18:39,367 --> 00:18:41,367 Thank you. 305 00:18:43,304 --> 00:18:44,380 As I'm still here and I'm in 306 00:18:44,380 --> 00:18:46,438 northern Thailand now hopefully 307 00:18:48,777 --> 00:18:49,377 my zoom will not cut out on me. 308 00:18:49,377 --> 00:18:51,777 Sorry if it will. 309 00:18:53,714 --> 00:18:54,415 I can probably put my words in 310 00:18:54,415 --> 00:18:56,815 under three minutes Hopefully. 311 00:18:57,886 --> 00:19:02,860 I wanted to speak once again to 312 00:19:02,790 --> 00:19:06,990 the idea that the idea I don't 313 00:19:07,862 --> 00:19:08,697 have a timer right now. 314 00:19:08,697 --> 00:19:09,396 >> I only have the picture 315 00:19:09,396 --> 00:19:12,633 because I don't have my three 316 00:19:12,633 --> 00:19:13,401 minute timer up. 317 00:19:13,401 --> 00:19:16,805 It's not on the zoom with me 318 00:19:16,805 --> 00:19:17,705 but I'll try to continue and 319 00:19:17,705 --> 00:19:19,975 you can you can come in like 320 00:19:19,975 --> 00:19:23,575 you know when I have 30s 321 00:19:25,347 --> 00:19:25,813 remaining if you can please. 322 00:19:25,813 --> 00:19:26,614 Thank you. 323 00:19:26,614 --> 00:19:30,214 It's kind of coming in there. 324 00:19:31,186 --> 00:19:31,586 I wanted to comment that. 325 00:19:31,586 --> 00:19:32,354 Okay, great. 326 00:19:32,354 --> 00:19:32,821 Three minutes to 59 to 58. 327 00:19:32,821 --> 00:19:34,821 Thank you. 328 00:19:36,224 --> 00:19:36,892 I just wanted to comment on a 329 00:19:36,892 --> 00:19:39,292 comment I've been offering 330 00:19:43,397 --> 00:19:44,650 recently on the subject of city 331 00:19:44,650 --> 00:19:47,650 employees and the idea Thank 332 00:19:47,869 --> 00:19:48,470 you for the previous public 333 00:19:48,470 --> 00:19:49,137 comment by the way. 334 00:19:49,137 --> 00:19:49,537 I thought it was pretty 335 00:19:49,537 --> 00:19:51,537 interesting. 336 00:19:53,408 --> 00:19:54,142 I'm interested in how in 337 00:19:54,142 --> 00:19:57,742 working on our deficit issues a 338 00:19:58,246 --> 00:19:58,947 general fund and other and 339 00:19:58,947 --> 00:20:02,547 other forms of our budget that 340 00:20:03,485 --> 00:20:04,152 you are working on really well 341 00:20:04,152 --> 00:20:04,786 by the way at this time it 342 00:20:04,786 --> 00:20:06,955 seems like you have a good 343 00:20:06,955 --> 00:20:09,955 headway on a good beginning. 344 00:20:12,127 --> 00:20:12,828 Thank you everyone. 345 00:20:12,828 --> 00:20:15,828 Continue that good process to 346 00:20:16,565 --> 00:20:17,365 once again offer my idea that I 347 00:20:17,365 --> 00:20:20,365 hope that in all this 348 00:20:21,703 --> 00:20:22,270 negotiation you know you've 349 00:20:22,270 --> 00:20:22,971 been doing this pretty 350 00:20:22,971 --> 00:20:25,371 regularly here closed session 351 00:20:26,575 --> 00:20:30,175 time and coming up with new 352 00:20:30,345 --> 00:20:30,978 contracts that your latest 353 00:20:30,978 --> 00:20:32,978 negotiations can possibly 354 00:20:35,117 --> 00:20:35,784 somehow involve the ideas of 355 00:20:35,784 --> 00:20:38,784 asking for city employees to 356 00:20:42,824 --> 00:20:46,995 take a slight pay cut and at 357 00:20:46,995 --> 00:20:47,762 this time and to keep alive 358 00:20:47,762 --> 00:20:50,762 the ideas of retirement funds 359 00:20:52,401 --> 00:20:53,100 and health benefits to programs 360 00:20:53,100 --> 00:20:55,401 that you've been really 361 00:20:56,772 --> 00:20:57,472 thinking of cutting out of city 362 00:20:57,472 --> 00:21:00,472 employees work detail and you 363 00:21:02,770 --> 00:21:02,778 know their lives basically And 364 00:21:02,778 --> 00:21:06,378 I've tried to offer you know 365 00:21:06,548 --> 00:21:07,249 that I think that's really 366 00:21:07,249 --> 00:21:08,116 the wrong approach in how to 367 00:21:08,116 --> 00:21:11,716 create a better morale and best 368 00:21:12,540 --> 00:21:12,654 practices as a city government 369 00:21:12,654 --> 00:21:15,540 as a community process. 370 00:21:15,991 --> 00:21:16,859 So I'd like to the suggestion 371 00:21:16,859 --> 00:21:21,590 instead that if we just cut our 372 00:21:21,697 --> 00:21:22,364 you know, our pay our city 373 00:21:22,364 --> 00:21:25,364 government pay by 25 bucks a 374 00:21:26,680 --> 00:21:28,468 month, you know, with 10,000 375 00:21:30,105 --> 00:21:31,600 city workers that's over 3 to 376 00:21:31,600 --> 00:21:34,600 $4 million in savings each year 377 00:21:35,611 --> 00:21:36,679 And I really think it's a it's 378 00:21:36,679 --> 00:21:40,182 a nice idea and I hope he can 379 00:21:40,182 --> 00:21:41,500 really consider it. 380 00:21:41,500 --> 00:21:41,817 It's not as much of a savings 381 00:21:41,817 --> 00:21:44,817 as when you're cutting health 382 00:21:45,654 --> 00:21:46,210 benefits and retirement 383 00:21:46,210 --> 00:21:46,655 benefits. 384 00:21:46,655 --> 00:21:49,655 That obviously is going to 385 00:21:50,459 --> 00:21:50,926 bring you more of a savings, a 386 00:21:50,926 --> 00:21:52,926 budget savings. 387 00:21:55,197 --> 00:21:55,898 But morale wise and just human 388 00:21:55,898 --> 00:21:56,365 interest wise and idea wise 389 00:21:56,365 --> 00:21:58,365 it's not decent. 390 00:22:00,235 --> 00:22:01,203 It's not our best at all. 391 00:22:01,203 --> 00:22:05,403 So I just wanted to comment on 392 00:22:05,441 --> 00:22:06,242 that again and really try to 393 00:22:06,242 --> 00:22:09,842 think of our best practices and 394 00:22:10,120 --> 00:22:10,646 what we really like about 395 00:22:10,646 --> 00:22:11,479 ourselves and we like our 396 00:22:11,479 --> 00:22:15,790 health benefits and we like our 397 00:22:15,184 --> 00:22:16,180 retirement plans. 398 00:22:16,180 --> 00:22:16,885 I think we can be willing to 399 00:22:16,885 --> 00:22:19,822 take a $25 cut in pay each 400 00:22:19,822 --> 00:22:20,189 month to continue those good 401 00:22:20,189 --> 00:22:20,723 services. 402 00:22:20,723 --> 00:22:21,356 That's my thinking. 403 00:22:21,356 --> 00:22:23,459 Thanks for your time and 404 00:22:23,459 --> 00:22:27,590 listening and good luck to your 405 00:22:28,264 --> 00:22:28,664 meetings today. 406 00:22:28,664 --> 00:22:29,231 Thank you. 407 00:22:29,231 --> 00:22:29,898 Our next speaker is 408 00:22:29,898 --> 00:22:31,267 the original drivers Please 409 00:22:31,267 --> 00:22:34,867 state which item or items you 410 00:22:36,438 --> 00:22:37,206 wish to speak to. 411 00:22:37,206 --> 00:22:37,505 >> Yes, all of them please. 412 00:22:37,505 --> 00:22:38,106 Okay. 413 00:22:38,106 --> 00:22:38,574 You have three minutes. 414 00:22:38,574 --> 00:22:38,941 Please proceed. 415 00:22:38,941 --> 00:22:40,941 Thank you. 416 00:22:41,610 --> 00:22:42,277 So yeah, good comments because 417 00:22:42,277 --> 00:22:44,677 with labor negotiations it's 418 00:22:46,480 --> 00:22:46,815 just interesting how we do them 419 00:22:46,815 --> 00:22:50,118 all in like one bucket, you 420 00:22:50,118 --> 00:22:50,820 know we don't look at 421 00:22:50,820 --> 00:22:51,487 the people's merits and their 422 00:22:51,487 --> 00:22:55,870 ability to do their job on 423 00:22:55,391 --> 00:22:56,580 individual basis and we're 424 00:22:56,580 --> 00:22:59,580 giving raises to the people 425 00:23:00,229 --> 00:23:00,896 that are, you know, doing 426 00:23:00,896 --> 00:23:01,330 things in the city that are 427 00:23:01,330 --> 00:23:03,330 lacking also. 428 00:23:05,100 --> 00:23:05,768 So it's like we have enough 429 00:23:05,768 --> 00:23:09,905 money to give them raises on a 430 00:23:09,905 --> 00:23:10,606 continual basis but we don't 431 00:23:10,606 --> 00:23:11,276 have the money to get the work 432 00:23:11,276 --> 00:23:14,276 done that they actually do. 433 00:23:14,610 --> 00:23:15,344 So that's what's kind of 434 00:23:15,344 --> 00:23:16,450 concerning is that it's like is 435 00:23:16,450 --> 00:23:16,479 that you know, good management 436 00:23:16,479 --> 00:23:18,479 of our money? 437 00:23:19,849 --> 00:23:20,549 I mean I understand people need 438 00:23:20,549 --> 00:23:24,149 to make more People are trying 439 00:23:24,720 --> 00:23:25,421 to survive obviously But you 440 00:23:25,421 --> 00:23:28,991 know like the city is lacking 441 00:23:28,991 --> 00:23:29,425 in infrastructure and all of 442 00:23:29,425 --> 00:23:30,259 these things. 443 00:23:30,259 --> 00:23:32,928 I mean we have such huge 444 00:23:32,928 --> 00:23:33,629 deficits for like $5 billion in 445 00:23:33,629 --> 00:23:36,290 storm infrastructure and we're 446 00:23:38,634 --> 00:23:39,302 talking about buying sd Gainey 447 00:23:39,302 --> 00:23:41,302 for potentially $9 billion. 448 00:23:42,205 --> 00:23:42,605 It's going to go down to 449 00:23:42,605 --> 00:23:43,406 the people. 450 00:23:43,406 --> 00:23:47,276 So it's like we on a continual 451 00:23:47,276 --> 00:23:47,944 basis do things that cost we 452 00:23:47,944 --> 00:23:48,744 the people more money but we 453 00:23:48,744 --> 00:23:51,744 don't really see any other 454 00:23:52,782 --> 00:23:53,449 benefits that it's like Oh my 455 00:23:53,449 --> 00:23:54,150 gosh because people would be 456 00:23:54,150 --> 00:23:57,286 willing to give you guys money 457 00:23:57,286 --> 00:23:57,987 if it like showed you know 458 00:23:57,987 --> 00:23:58,754 the fruits of your labor were 459 00:23:58,754 --> 00:24:01,991 worth it if things were you 460 00:24:01,991 --> 00:24:02,692 know, thriving in the city, you 461 00:24:02,692 --> 00:24:06,292 know, people would be like oh 462 00:24:06,562 --> 00:24:07,263 my gosh, give you more money 463 00:24:07,263 --> 00:24:07,563 for that because we want more 464 00:24:07,563 --> 00:24:08,431 of it. 465 00:24:08,431 --> 00:24:11,367 But instead it's like we see 466 00:24:11,367 --> 00:24:12,168 less and less worse and worse 467 00:24:12,168 --> 00:24:16,380 and more and more money has to 468 00:24:16,380 --> 00:24:16,806 come out of our pockets And 469 00:24:16,806 --> 00:24:20,406 then you do things like engage 470 00:24:21,440 --> 00:24:21,678 in litigation And you know, 471 00:24:21,678 --> 00:24:24,678 like with this storm that 472 00:24:25,615 --> 00:24:26,315 happened in JANUARY and you 473 00:24:26,315 --> 00:24:27,160 guys are engaged in litigation 474 00:24:27,160 --> 00:24:30,219 against some of the people who 475 00:24:30,219 --> 00:24:30,854 have lost things. 476 00:24:30,854 --> 00:24:33,254 So it's really concerning 477 00:24:35,491 --> 00:24:36,192 the work that you guys do 478 00:24:36,192 --> 00:24:36,859 The fact that this guy also 479 00:24:36,859 --> 00:24:39,729 goes behind closed doors and 480 00:24:39,729 --> 00:24:40,463 it's not transparent. 481 00:24:40,463 --> 00:24:41,164 That's very concerning because 482 00:24:41,164 --> 00:24:44,500 it shows like if if there was 483 00:24:44,500 --> 00:24:45,201 nothing to worry about, you 484 00:24:45,201 --> 00:24:45,501 don't have to go behind closed 485 00:24:45,501 --> 00:24:46,202 doors. 486 00:24:46,202 --> 00:24:49,705 You don't have to keep certain 487 00:24:49,705 --> 00:24:50,273 things private But you do it 488 00:24:50,273 --> 00:24:50,940 and it's like how can 489 00:24:50,940 --> 00:24:53,809 the people trust what you're 490 00:24:53,809 --> 00:24:54,477 doing when you use our money 491 00:24:54,477 --> 00:24:55,111 You go behind closed doors. 492 00:24:55,111 --> 00:24:55,411 Don't tell us what you're 493 00:24:55,411 --> 00:24:57,411 doing. 494 00:24:58,815 --> 00:24:59,515 Just expect us to trust you, 495 00:24:59,515 --> 00:25:00,284 trust you to give people more 496 00:25:00,284 --> 00:25:03,884 money to do their job that 497 00:25:03,986 --> 00:25:04,620 they're not doing, you know? 498 00:25:04,620 --> 00:25:05,355 And then we're continually 499 00:25:05,355 --> 00:25:08,355 looking for more money and 500 00:25:08,757 --> 00:25:09,459 cutting things from here and 501 00:25:09,459 --> 00:25:12,459 cutting things from there And 502 00:25:13,290 --> 00:25:13,630 it's just you know, it's just 503 00:25:13,630 --> 00:25:14,297 unfortunate because with 504 00:25:14,297 --> 00:25:17,297 the billions and billions of 505 00:25:18,400 --> 00:25:19,350 dollars that have has gone 506 00:25:19,350 --> 00:25:19,602 through this city, what is 507 00:25:19,602 --> 00:25:22,602 there to show for it? 508 00:25:23,390 --> 00:25:23,706 But filling people's pockets 509 00:25:23,706 --> 00:25:26,706 and you know there's always 510 00:25:27,310 --> 00:25:27,610 time to course correct As I say 511 00:25:27,610 --> 00:25:28,477 . 512 00:25:28,477 --> 00:25:32,549 So it's going to go and be 513 00:25:32,549 --> 00:25:33,115 business as usual. 514 00:25:33,115 --> 00:25:33,950 But I don't know. 515 00:25:33,950 --> 00:25:34,717 I think you guys need to think 516 00:25:34,717 --> 00:25:37,717 more about whose money you're 517 00:25:37,954 --> 00:25:38,655 spending and you know what 518 00:25:38,655 --> 00:25:39,589 they're actually having to do 519 00:25:39,589 --> 00:25:41,791 just to get it to give it to 520 00:25:41,791 --> 00:25:42,158 you. 521 00:25:42,158 --> 00:25:42,792 Thank you. 522 00:25:42,792 --> 00:25:45,792 Please note that the five 523 00:25:46,696 --> 00:25:47,297 minute timer has concluded with 524 00:25:47,297 --> 00:25:47,664 three speakers left in 525 00:25:47,664 --> 00:25:48,297 the queue. 526 00:25:48,297 --> 00:25:48,598 No other speakers will be 527 00:25:48,598 --> 00:25:50,598 taken. 528 00:25:51,901 --> 00:25:52,301 Our next speaker is Million 529 00:25:52,301 --> 00:25:52,969 Mile Man. 530 00:25:52,969 --> 00:25:55,969 Please state which item or 531 00:25:56,172 --> 00:25:59,772 items you wish to speak to. 532 00:26:01,444 --> 00:26:05,644 I would like to speak on non 533 00:26:05,982 --> 00:26:06,950 agenda public comment okay. 534 00:26:06,950 --> 00:26:09,350 >> Non agenda public comment 535 00:26:11,288 --> 00:26:11,921 will be heard at the end of 536 00:26:11,921 --> 00:26:14,921 the 2 P.M. Session today. 537 00:26:16,250 --> 00:26:16,559 This is for comment on because 538 00:26:16,559 --> 00:26:18,559 the session agenda. 539 00:26:20,630 --> 00:26:23,663 >> Okay well then I would like 540 00:26:25,268 --> 00:26:25,668 to speak on the closed session 541 00:26:25,668 --> 00:26:26,690 agenda. 542 00:26:26,690 --> 00:26:26,836 >> Okay. 543 00:26:26,836 --> 00:26:28,400 Which item or items would you 544 00:26:28,400 --> 00:26:32,204 like to speak to on the closed 545 00:26:33,176 --> 00:26:33,743 session agenda? 546 00:26:33,743 --> 00:26:34,477 >> All of them. 547 00:26:34,477 --> 00:26:37,477 Okay you have three minutes. 548 00:26:37,914 --> 00:26:39,914 Please proceed. 549 00:26:42,719 --> 00:26:45,719 I have heard all of 550 00:26:47,124 --> 00:26:49,524 the previous comments regarding 551 00:26:52,128 --> 00:26:55,728 the budget Labor etc. Some of 552 00:26:56,299 --> 00:26:57,267 the ideas put forth are valid 553 00:26:57,267 --> 00:27:00,867 but the Achilles heel of this 554 00:27:01,905 --> 00:27:04,905 whole budget and everything we 555 00:27:06,143 --> 00:27:07,110 do practically in the city of 556 00:27:07,110 --> 00:27:10,470 San Diego is predicated on 557 00:27:10,470 --> 00:27:13,470 the city attorney's office and 558 00:27:18,221 --> 00:27:18,989 the budget negotiations. 559 00:27:18,989 --> 00:27:21,989 There is nothing in material 560 00:27:23,360 --> 00:27:26,960 about the law and this is 561 00:27:27,965 --> 00:27:31,565 the issue we have is within 562 00:27:32,335 --> 00:27:33,103 the negotiations of Labor. 563 00:27:33,103 --> 00:27:36,103 City Attorney's Office In an 564 00:27:37,640 --> 00:27:41,840 ideal world if we lived in a 565 00:27:42,780 --> 00:27:42,679 beautiful ideal world we could 566 00:27:42,679 --> 00:27:45,790 implement all of these 567 00:27:46,916 --> 00:27:48,916 wonderful ideas But 568 00:27:51,388 --> 00:27:52,255 unfortunately we have to deal 569 00:27:52,255 --> 00:27:55,255 with the material nature of 570 00:28:00,731 --> 00:28:01,490 the law So that's all I have to 571 00:28:01,490 --> 00:28:01,899 say. 572 00:28:01,899 --> 00:28:04,735 You can cut me off now and put 573 00:28:04,735 --> 00:28:05,235 on a thank you very much. 574 00:28:05,235 --> 00:28:07,235 >> Thank you. 575 00:28:10,574 --> 00:28:11,208 Our next speaker is one set of 576 00:28:11,208 --> 00:28:14,208 please state which item or 577 00:28:15,312 --> 00:28:15,813 items you wish to speak to. 578 00:28:15,813 --> 00:28:16,580 Good morning guys. 579 00:28:16,580 --> 00:28:16,879 Two and three please get your 580 00:28:16,879 --> 00:28:18,682 time. 581 00:28:18,682 --> 00:28:19,349 Two minutes on the labor thing 582 00:28:19,349 --> 00:28:22,349 on following example of our 583 00:28:23,787 --> 00:28:24,655 governor Governor Newsom. 584 00:28:24,655 --> 00:28:28,255 He uses illegal aliens and pays 585 00:28:28,825 --> 00:28:29,493 them cash to harvest his grape 586 00:28:29,493 --> 00:28:29,827 crop for his $70 bottles of 587 00:28:29,827 --> 00:28:31,827 wine. 588 00:28:34,231 --> 00:28:34,965 So the governor could you 589 00:28:34,965 --> 00:28:35,532 please not be to the items that 590 00:28:35,532 --> 00:28:37,932 the city is compiling? 591 00:28:38,680 --> 00:28:38,368 >> Not what the governor is 592 00:28:38,368 --> 00:28:39,236 doing. 593 00:28:39,236 --> 00:28:39,970 >> No, this is a labor this 594 00:28:39,970 --> 00:28:42,872 labor thing with the city labor 595 00:28:42,872 --> 00:28:43,540 agreement with doing potholes 596 00:28:43,540 --> 00:28:46,540 We could hire illegal aliens 597 00:28:47,711 --> 00:28:48,479 and pay them like $20 of 598 00:28:48,479 --> 00:28:52,282 pothole cash and in a matter of 599 00:28:52,282 --> 00:28:52,650 months we would have no 600 00:28:52,650 --> 00:28:53,351 potholes. 601 00:28:53,351 --> 00:28:56,854 We surprised we supply This is 602 00:28:56,854 --> 00:28:57,221 labor negotiation with 603 00:28:57,221 --> 00:28:57,855 the guys. 604 00:28:57,855 --> 00:29:00,855 We're going to go illegal 605 00:29:01,992 --> 00:29:02,660 aliens and pay them cash and 606 00:29:02,660 --> 00:29:03,360 then we're going to provide 607 00:29:03,360 --> 00:29:06,960 the asphalt and we're going to 608 00:29:07,431 --> 00:29:08,980 provide them with signs to do 609 00:29:08,980 --> 00:29:11,869 it and the oil to do it. 610 00:29:11,869 --> 00:29:12,636 They provide their own tools 611 00:29:12,636 --> 00:29:16,236 and their trucks will pay them 612 00:29:16,607 --> 00:29:17,341 by the pothole cash and 613 00:29:17,341 --> 00:29:20,341 document each pothole And we'll 614 00:29:21,277 --> 00:29:22,460 do a program of like we'll burn 615 00:29:22,460 --> 00:29:22,679 through 100 grand and see how 616 00:29:22,679 --> 00:29:25,679 many potholes we can fill. 617 00:29:26,783 --> 00:29:27,651 It'll save the city a bundle 618 00:29:27,651 --> 00:29:30,955 and then when you do the roads 619 00:29:30,955 --> 00:29:33,955 you guys have these road 620 00:29:35,593 --> 00:29:36,460 programs Now you have no no. 621 00:29:36,460 --> 00:29:36,761 You say it's going to save us 622 00:29:36,761 --> 00:29:37,628 money. 623 00:29:37,628 --> 00:29:41,310 Do it test where you have 624 00:29:41,310 --> 00:29:43,868 private guys do one mile of 625 00:29:43,868 --> 00:29:44,668 Miramar Road and then the city 626 00:29:44,668 --> 00:29:45,369 does one mile of Miramar Road 627 00:29:45,369 --> 00:29:48,369 going west and east different 628 00:29:48,939 --> 00:29:49,639 parts of it get a bid from 629 00:29:49,639 --> 00:29:53,310 the guys and how much they do 630 00:29:53,310 --> 00:29:53,944 it for like eagle paving and 631 00:29:53,944 --> 00:29:54,679 then count up all the city 632 00:29:54,679 --> 00:29:58,582 stuff the labor in the city all 633 00:29:58,582 --> 00:29:59,315 those machines you bought which 634 00:29:59,315 --> 00:30:02,315 is multimillions of dollars and 635 00:30:03,253 --> 00:30:03,920 then also include their 636 00:30:03,920 --> 00:30:04,722 pensions do it over 30 years 637 00:30:04,722 --> 00:30:07,722 They have a 30 year pension 638 00:30:08,292 --> 00:30:09,930 coming up after that and you 639 00:30:09,930 --> 00:30:13,640 got to do every cost how much 640 00:30:13,640 --> 00:30:13,731 per mile or how much per yard 641 00:30:13,731 --> 00:30:14,640 or whatever it is You don't 642 00:30:14,640 --> 00:30:14,899 have it. 643 00:30:14,899 --> 00:30:18,350 You just say it's saving us 644 00:30:18,350 --> 00:30:18,736 money But in the long run it's 645 00:30:18,736 --> 00:30:22,336 cost us money just based on 646 00:30:22,773 --> 00:30:23,374 the pension pay payments So 647 00:30:23,374 --> 00:30:23,741 you're not really being 648 00:30:23,741 --> 00:30:24,441 truthful. 649 00:30:24,441 --> 00:30:27,578 The city manager was saying it 650 00:30:27,578 --> 00:30:28,245 on the thing just so recently 651 00:30:28,245 --> 00:30:28,713 is saving the city money but 652 00:30:28,713 --> 00:30:30,713 making that up. 653 00:30:31,682 --> 00:30:32,383 Thank you. 654 00:30:32,383 --> 00:30:35,383 That does conclude your time. 655 00:30:37,621 --> 00:30:39,457 Well our next speaker is caller 656 00:30:39,457 --> 00:30:40,910 where the last four digits 8700 657 00:30:40,910 --> 00:30:43,910 please state which item or 658 00:30:44,929 --> 00:30:45,329 items you wish to speak to. 659 00:30:45,329 --> 00:30:46,970 Thank you. 660 00:30:46,970 --> 00:30:46,464 I will speak on all three. 661 00:30:46,464 --> 00:30:47,265 Okay. 662 00:30:47,265 --> 00:30:49,665 You have three minutes. 663 00:30:53,170 --> 00:30:53,738 >> Please begin. 664 00:30:53,738 --> 00:30:54,405 Good morning everyone. 665 00:30:54,405 --> 00:30:56,207 Joy from the attack on c. 666 00:30:56,207 --> 00:30:58,207 S one. 667 00:30:59,979 --> 00:31:03,579 It's headed a number of cases. 668 00:31:04,849 --> 00:31:05,550 One I would so appreciate your 669 00:31:05,550 --> 00:31:06,317 clarity for the public on 670 00:31:06,317 --> 00:31:09,917 the purpose of this item being 671 00:31:10,588 --> 00:31:14,188 on consent with no details yet 672 00:31:14,357 --> 00:31:15,126 it says City attorney will 673 00:31:15,126 --> 00:31:18,126 discuss and speak and seek 674 00:31:19,964 --> 00:31:20,832 direction. 675 00:31:20,832 --> 00:31:24,432 So perhaps if allowed the city 676 00:31:24,702 --> 00:31:25,369 attorney could clear this up 677 00:31:25,369 --> 00:31:28,973 for me and for the rest of 678 00:31:28,973 --> 00:31:29,273 the public that are interested 679 00:31:29,273 --> 00:31:29,840 . 680 00:31:29,840 --> 00:31:32,240 Thank you so much. 681 00:31:33,711 --> 00:31:34,445 And number two see us to ctp 682 00:31:34,445 --> 00:31:36,845 Commission on Police Practices. 683 00:31:38,449 --> 00:31:41,449 This is so important even 684 00:31:42,487 --> 00:31:43,288 though it's been about 46 years 685 00:31:43,288 --> 00:31:46,288 since this oversight of police 686 00:31:47,580 --> 00:31:50,580 practices was brought to light 687 00:31:51,496 --> 00:31:52,230 by the public, I continue to 688 00:31:52,230 --> 00:31:55,230 support this litigation as part 689 00:31:56,534 --> 00:31:58,934 of the ongoing journey. 690 00:32:01,238 --> 00:32:01,973 Understanding is a solid word 691 00:32:01,973 --> 00:32:04,973 Trust is even more important. 692 00:32:06,144 --> 00:32:06,510 Let's continue the journey 693 00:32:06,510 --> 00:32:07,245 together. 694 00:32:07,245 --> 00:32:10,845 Thank you to all involved in 695 00:32:12,316 --> 00:32:14,819 this process and love to all 696 00:32:14,819 --> 00:32:17,819 see as three fire fighters 697 00:32:19,724 --> 00:32:20,325 Labor agreement As you work 698 00:32:20,325 --> 00:32:22,725 together to support our 699 00:32:24,829 --> 00:32:25,830 firefighters, I ask that you 700 00:32:25,830 --> 00:32:29,701 take a deeper dive as to their 701 00:32:29,701 --> 00:32:33,301 core and needs of their work 702 00:32:33,571 --> 00:32:34,339 for the people of San Diego 703 00:32:34,339 --> 00:32:37,939 When the perfect storm hit they 704 00:32:38,777 --> 00:32:41,177 were not adequately equipped 705 00:32:43,782 --> 00:32:44,449 When the perfect storm hit they 706 00:32:44,449 --> 00:32:46,849 were not adequately equipped 707 00:32:49,487 --> 00:32:49,821 and now we have the grand jury 708 00:32:49,821 --> 00:32:51,821 report. 709 00:32:54,125 --> 00:32:55,590 We must care for them. 710 00:32:55,590 --> 00:32:58,663 And eight at a high level we 711 00:32:58,663 --> 00:32:59,364 must care for them at a high 712 00:32:59,364 --> 00:32:59,664 level so they can serve our 713 00:32:59,664 --> 00:33:01,664 city. 714 00:33:04,169 --> 00:33:04,869 Eddie high level I'm going to 715 00:33:04,869 --> 00:33:08,373 say that again from a little 716 00:33:08,373 --> 00:33:09,700 bit higher here When 717 00:33:09,700 --> 00:33:09,574 the perfect storm hit our 718 00:33:09,574 --> 00:33:11,574 firefighters were not 719 00:33:13,878 --> 00:33:16,878 adequately equipped And now we 720 00:33:18,490 --> 00:33:18,716 have the grand jury report. 721 00:33:18,716 --> 00:33:21,716 We must care for our 722 00:33:22,687 --> 00:33:23,555 firefighters a high level so 723 00:33:23,555 --> 00:33:27,155 they can serve our city of 724 00:33:28,393 --> 00:33:29,270 beautiful city and our 725 00:33:29,270 --> 00:33:29,327 beautiful people at a high 726 00:33:29,327 --> 00:33:31,327 level. 727 00:33:34,320 --> 00:33:34,733 Thank you to the gentleman who 728 00:33:34,733 --> 00:33:35,660 spoke on the structural budget 729 00:33:35,660 --> 00:33:37,660 deficit. 730 00:33:37,569 --> 00:33:38,102 That was a very big step, very 731 00:33:38,102 --> 00:33:38,804 thoughtful comments. 732 00:33:38,804 --> 00:33:42,440 Would you please keep it up as 733 00:33:42,440 --> 00:33:42,741 we move into the budget? 734 00:33:42,741 --> 00:33:43,508 Okay. 735 00:33:43,508 --> 00:33:44,109 We're going to have a good day. 736 00:33:44,109 --> 00:33:46,509 It's a big day. 737 00:33:47,479 --> 00:33:51,679 A great week And as always love 738 00:33:52,217 --> 00:33:52,784 to all Thank you. 739 00:33:52,784 --> 00:33:53,517 Council PRESIDENT That 740 00:33:53,517 --> 00:33:55,917 concludes closed session Public 741 00:33:56,588 --> 00:33:57,890 comment None. 742 00:33:57,890 --> 00:33:57,689 >> All right. 743 00:33:57,689 --> 00:33:58,390 Thank you, Deputy Clerk. 744 00:33:58,390 --> 00:33:58,990 With that we now recess in 745 00:33:58,990 --> 00:34:01,390 the closed session and 746 00:34:01,627 --> 00:34:04,270 reconvene council today at 2 747 00:34:06,364 --> 00:34:09,364 P.M. Or shortly thereafter. 748 00:38:02,960 --> 00:38:02,897 >> My first and 749 00:38:02,897 --> 00:38:05,897 that is Anthony Ross in 750 00:38:07,902 --> 00:38:08,669 the building Anthony Ross in 751 00:38:08,669 --> 00:38:09,370 the room If you are if you can 752 00:38:09,370 --> 00:38:10,370 please come forward so that my 753 00:38:10,370 --> 00:38:13,370 staff can speak with you 754 00:39:38,659 --> 00:39:40,659 Anthony Ross 755 00:40:55,470 --> 00:40:56,400 and 756 00:40:56,400 --> 00:40:57,338 Seth Hall if 757 00:40:57,338 --> 00:41:01,538 you are here so far please come 758 00:41:27,268 --> 00:41:29,268 forward 759 00:42:21,189 --> 00:42:23,189 and 760 00:44:21,510 --> 00:44:23,510 help 761 00:45:19,268 --> 00:45:19,802 . 762 00:45:19,802 --> 00:45:20,269 >> All right. 763 00:45:20,269 --> 00:45:20,970 Good afternoon. 764 00:45:20,970 --> 00:45:24,570 I will now reconvene the city 765 00:45:25,908 --> 00:45:26,442 council meeting of Monday, 766 00:45:26,442 --> 00:45:27,143 NOVEMBER 16th, 2026. 767 00:45:27,143 --> 00:45:27,509 >> clerk Please call the roll. 768 00:45:27,509 --> 00:45:28,144 Thank you. 769 00:45:28,144 --> 00:45:30,144 Council PRESIDENT Council 770 00:45:31,180 --> 00:45:31,881 member Campbell. 771 00:45:31,881 --> 00:45:34,281 Council Member Whitburn here. 772 00:45:37,520 --> 00:45:38,221 Councilmember Foster Council 773 00:45:38,221 --> 00:45:40,621 Member Yvonne Wolpert Council 774 00:45:43,759 --> 00:45:44,493 Member Kent Council PRESIDENT 775 00:45:44,493 --> 00:45:47,493 Pro Tem Kennelly Council Member 776 00:45:49,732 --> 00:45:50,432 Campion Council Moreno Present 777 00:45:50,432 --> 00:45:51,000 Council Member Eli Rivera and 778 00:45:51,000 --> 00:45:53,000 Council PRESIDENT Look 779 00:45:56,105 --> 00:45:56,806 the PRESIDENT Also attended 780 00:45:56,806 --> 00:45:57,440 the meeting Our Assistant City 781 00:45:57,440 --> 00:45:58,740 Attorney Michelle Garland 782 00:45:58,740 --> 00:45:58,774 Independent Budget Analyst 783 00:45:58,774 --> 00:46:01,174 Charles Margo Council Affairs 784 00:46:02,345 --> 00:46:03,450 Advisor in the Mayor's office 785 00:46:03,450 --> 00:46:03,746 Code advisor and myself your 786 00:46:03,746 --> 00:46:04,130 city Clerk Diana Fontana Thank 787 00:46:04,130 --> 00:46:04,680 you. 788 00:46:04,680 --> 00:46:07,800 Council PRESIDENT All right. 789 00:46:07,249 --> 00:46:08,500 Thank you City Clerk Since I 790 00:46:08,500 --> 00:46:08,751 believe we have some new faces 791 00:46:08,751 --> 00:46:12,351 in the audience, I just wanted 792 00:46:12,989 --> 00:46:13,589 to remind everyone about 793 00:46:13,589 --> 00:46:14,290 the city's practices and 794 00:46:14,290 --> 00:46:14,924 procedures for public comment 795 00:46:14,924 --> 00:46:17,324 at city council meetings. 796 00:46:19,628 --> 00:46:20,296 We certainly welcome your 797 00:46:20,296 --> 00:46:20,963 public participation and we 798 00:46:20,963 --> 00:46:21,664 appreciate your taking your 799 00:46:21,664 --> 00:46:25,340 time out of your busy days to 800 00:46:25,340 --> 00:46:25,567 be here this afternoon. 801 00:46:25,567 --> 00:46:26,202 Speakers MAY address 802 00:46:26,202 --> 00:46:26,902 the council during public 803 00:46:26,902 --> 00:46:27,503 comment and also in connection 804 00:46:27,503 --> 00:46:30,503 with a specific item of 805 00:46:31,707 --> 00:46:32,374 business on the agenda. 806 00:46:32,374 --> 00:46:33,420 However, the city must make 807 00:46:33,420 --> 00:46:33,642 sure that no one person or 808 00:46:33,642 --> 00:46:34,277 group of people disrupt 809 00:46:34,277 --> 00:46:37,877 the meeting in a way that 810 00:46:37,981 --> 00:46:38,614 prohibits other speakers from 811 00:46:38,614 --> 00:46:39,282 expressing their ideas and 812 00:46:39,282 --> 00:46:39,949 opinions Excessive yelling, 813 00:46:39,949 --> 00:46:42,349 screaming or speaking beyond 814 00:46:44,553 --> 00:46:45,188 one's a lot of time are 815 00:46:45,188 --> 00:46:45,721 examples of behavior that 816 00:46:45,721 --> 00:46:46,422 disrupt the meeting. 817 00:46:46,422 --> 00:46:47,560 So to make sure that everyone 818 00:46:47,560 --> 00:46:47,724 here has an opportunity to 819 00:46:47,724 --> 00:46:50,724 address the council, I will 820 00:46:51,961 --> 00:46:52,527 alert an individual if I think 821 00:46:52,527 --> 00:46:53,196 their conduct becomes 822 00:46:53,196 --> 00:46:53,629 disruptive and a disruption 823 00:46:53,629 --> 00:46:54,364 continues out. 824 00:46:54,364 --> 00:46:56,833 What will the individual out of 825 00:46:56,833 --> 00:46:57,634 order? 826 00:46:57,634 --> 00:46:58,367 And after the session continues 827 00:46:58,367 --> 00:46:58,968 further I will declare a recess 828 00:46:58,968 --> 00:46:59,635 so we can restore order. 829 00:46:59,635 --> 00:47:02,906 At that point I will direct 830 00:47:02,906 --> 00:47:03,606 the individual to be the room 831 00:47:03,606 --> 00:47:04,273 and if the individual refuses 832 00:47:04,273 --> 00:47:04,841 to leave police will escort 833 00:47:04,841 --> 00:47:07,241 the individual out of 834 00:47:08,411 --> 00:47:09,178 the building. 835 00:47:09,178 --> 00:47:09,745 If we have to repeat this 836 00:47:09,745 --> 00:47:10,379 process of warning and 837 00:47:10,379 --> 00:47:11,800 resetting the meeting, all 838 00:47:11,800 --> 00:47:13,983 members of the public will be 839 00:47:13,983 --> 00:47:14,317 excused from the council 840 00:47:14,317 --> 00:47:15,180 chamber. 841 00:47:15,180 --> 00:47:15,718 Credentialed media will be of 842 00:47:15,718 --> 00:47:18,718 course allowed to remain again 843 00:47:20,189 --> 00:47:20,757 we have these practices and 844 00:47:20,757 --> 00:47:21,424 procedures to protect 845 00:47:21,424 --> 00:47:22,158 the rights of other speakers 846 00:47:22,158 --> 00:47:22,825 who wish to address the Council 847 00:47:22,825 --> 00:47:26,129 and to allow the Council to 848 00:47:26,129 --> 00:47:26,862 conduct the public's business. 849 00:47:26,862 --> 00:47:30,833 The city clerk tells us that we 850 00:47:30,833 --> 00:47:31,500 have probably about two hours 851 00:47:31,500 --> 00:47:32,680 of testimony kind of getting 852 00:47:32,680 --> 00:47:32,768 how many people might 853 00:47:32,768 --> 00:47:35,768 participate online so that we 854 00:47:37,474 --> 00:47:38,174 can move efficiently to give 855 00:47:38,174 --> 00:47:38,842 everybody their time to talk. 856 00:47:38,842 --> 00:47:39,575 If you hear things you like, 857 00:47:39,575 --> 00:47:42,575 thumbs up really conveys that 858 00:47:44,380 --> 00:47:45,810 Instead of clapping if you hear 859 00:47:45,810 --> 00:47:48,810 something you don't like don't 860 00:47:49,585 --> 00:47:50,286 move Put thumbs down Again That 861 00:47:50,286 --> 00:47:51,153 really has a very good impact 862 00:47:51,153 --> 00:47:54,753 with very visual impact I don't 863 00:47:55,491 --> 00:47:56,590 see any signs so I'm a little 864 00:47:56,590 --> 00:47:56,726 bit grateful for that. 865 00:47:56,726 --> 00:48:00,926 But if you do have a sign 866 00:48:01,164 --> 00:48:01,865 please make sure you're not 867 00:48:01,865 --> 00:48:02,265 blocking the view of somebody 868 00:48:02,265 --> 00:48:02,898 behind you. 869 00:48:02,898 --> 00:48:03,466 Everybody wants to see our 870 00:48:03,466 --> 00:48:05,866 smiling faces up here. 871 00:48:06,837 --> 00:48:07,604 I am sure. 872 00:48:07,604 --> 00:48:08,238 So with that let's start out 873 00:48:08,238 --> 00:48:08,605 with the regular course of 874 00:48:08,605 --> 00:48:10,605 business. 875 00:48:15,244 --> 00:48:15,912 Are there any comments from 876 00:48:15,912 --> 00:48:16,546 the mayor's office, council 877 00:48:16,546 --> 00:48:17,213 member, city attorney and 878 00:48:17,213 --> 00:48:19,115 the budget Answer City Clerk 879 00:48:19,115 --> 00:48:19,816 Council Member In order for you 880 00:48:19,816 --> 00:48:20,483 PRESIDENT First some good news 881 00:48:20,483 --> 00:48:23,483 actually last week I'd share 882 00:48:24,854 --> 00:48:25,722 that an eight year old boy from 883 00:48:25,722 --> 00:48:29,322 our community was taken by was 884 00:48:30,860 --> 00:48:31,560 taken during an immigration 885 00:48:31,560 --> 00:48:32,161 check in taking away from his 886 00:48:32,161 --> 00:48:32,829 family, taken away from 887 00:48:32,829 --> 00:48:36,990 the people who love him And 888 00:48:36,990 --> 00:48:36,866 he's back with his family today 889 00:48:36,866 --> 00:48:41,660 And so I think that deserves a 890 00:48:41,704 --> 00:48:43,704 round of applause. 891 00:48:47,810 --> 00:48:48,578 >> So so that is great news And 892 00:48:48,578 --> 00:48:49,245 it doesn't in any way diminish 893 00:48:49,245 --> 00:48:52,245 the terrible thing that he's 894 00:48:53,490 --> 00:48:53,783 experienced and his family's 895 00:48:53,783 --> 00:48:54,484 experience and the larger issue 896 00:48:54,484 --> 00:48:56,884 of how immigration enforcement 897 00:48:59,422 --> 00:49:00,123 is being handled in this 898 00:49:00,123 --> 00:49:00,823 country, the targeting of our 899 00:49:00,823 --> 00:49:03,823 Haitian neighbors and so many 900 00:49:05,161 --> 00:49:05,895 other very, very cool things. 901 00:49:05,895 --> 00:49:06,596 And to that point, the second 902 00:49:06,596 --> 00:49:07,230 issue that I want to raise is 903 00:49:07,230 --> 00:49:09,230 about another immigration 904 00:49:11,670 --> 00:49:11,601 action that happened in my 905 00:49:11,601 --> 00:49:12,535 district on Friday. 906 00:49:12,535 --> 00:49:16,135 An 18 year old girl was waiting 907 00:49:17,341 --> 00:49:17,974 for her father to take her and 908 00:49:17,974 --> 00:49:18,708 her 11 year old sister to 909 00:49:18,708 --> 00:49:21,708 school when federal agents used 910 00:49:23,513 --> 00:49:24,247 their vehicle to stop his and 911 00:49:24,247 --> 00:49:24,948 ice agent and repeatedly shoved 912 00:49:24,948 --> 00:49:27,948 her to the ground, threatened 913 00:49:28,685 --> 00:49:29,352 her with a gun and a Taser 914 00:49:29,352 --> 00:49:29,987 while she and her sister 915 00:49:29,987 --> 00:49:30,686 watched their father beat 916 00:49:30,686 --> 00:49:33,860 violently detained All that's 917 00:49:34,724 --> 00:49:35,391 on video. 918 00:49:35,391 --> 00:49:36,590 I sat with the family on 919 00:49:36,590 --> 00:49:36,793 Saturday and they want their 920 00:49:36,793 --> 00:49:37,427 story heard because they do not 921 00:49:37,427 --> 00:49:40,230 want other families to go 922 00:49:40,230 --> 00:49:42,230 through this. 923 00:49:45,668 --> 00:49:46,403 When they took him no one told 924 00:49:46,403 --> 00:49:46,836 the family who had him or where 925 00:49:46,836 --> 00:49:47,504 he was going. 926 00:49:47,504 --> 00:49:50,504 They spent hours not knowing 927 00:49:52,176 --> 00:49:52,876 where their dad was and to that 928 00:49:52,876 --> 00:49:53,576 family there was no difference 929 00:49:53,576 --> 00:49:54,310 between what happened in that 930 00:49:54,310 --> 00:49:55,120 moment and a kidnaping In broad 931 00:49:55,120 --> 00:49:57,412 daylight there was aggression. 932 00:49:57,647 --> 00:49:58,281 There was a total disregard for 933 00:49:58,281 --> 00:49:58,981 anyone safety someone they 934 00:49:58,981 --> 00:49:59,683 loved was grabbed and taken to 935 00:49:59,683 --> 00:50:03,283 an unknown place with no word 936 00:50:04,154 --> 00:50:05,210 of whether he'd ever come home 937 00:50:05,210 --> 00:50:09,221 as he arrived on the scene and 938 00:50:10,260 --> 00:50:10,694 for the family and 939 00:50:10,694 --> 00:50:11,428 the neighbors there they did 940 00:50:11,428 --> 00:50:15,280 not feel seen or protected from 941 00:50:15,365 --> 00:50:16,320 that interaction. 942 00:50:16,320 --> 00:50:16,733 In fact, they walked away 943 00:50:16,733 --> 00:50:19,733 feeling unseen and less safe. 944 00:50:22,472 --> 00:50:23,206 Everyone deserves to feel safe. 945 00:50:23,206 --> 00:50:23,740 Safety requires trust and trust 946 00:50:23,740 --> 00:50:24,174 requires honesty and 947 00:50:24,174 --> 00:50:24,874 transparency. 948 00:50:24,874 --> 00:50:27,978 And so I'm going to reiterate 949 00:50:27,978 --> 00:50:28,745 here and ask that I've made 950 00:50:28,745 --> 00:50:32,345 repeatedly to the chief and to 951 00:50:33,383 --> 00:50:34,840 the mayor And the first is to 952 00:50:34,840 --> 00:50:37,840 make his presence public when 953 00:50:38,922 --> 00:50:39,456 as dpd is at an immigration 954 00:50:39,456 --> 00:50:40,157 enforcement action. 955 00:50:40,157 --> 00:50:44,357 So I'm asking for the mayor to 956 00:50:44,595 --> 00:50:45,295 direct as dpd to publish a 957 00:50:45,295 --> 00:50:45,996 report a public report within 958 00:50:45,996 --> 00:50:48,996 three business days Every time 959 00:50:51,680 --> 00:50:51,701 officers respond to a scene 960 00:50:51,701 --> 00:50:52,436 where federal immigration 961 00:50:52,436 --> 00:50:53,360 agents are present they need to 962 00:50:53,360 --> 00:50:56,360 let the public know why 963 00:50:56,240 --> 00:50:56,907 officers were there, what they 964 00:50:56,907 --> 00:50:57,540 did and didn't do, which 965 00:50:57,540 --> 00:50:58,242 agencies were present and 966 00:50:58,242 --> 00:50:58,542 whether a judicial warrant was 967 00:50:58,542 --> 00:51:00,542 shown. 968 00:51:03,380 --> 00:51:03,814 Again, this is about safety and 969 00:51:03,814 --> 00:51:04,515 transparency. 970 00:51:04,515 --> 00:51:05,181 Worth noting those ice agents 971 00:51:05,181 --> 00:51:08,181 were wearing vests that said 972 00:51:09,180 --> 00:51:09,620 police we should not expect 973 00:51:09,620 --> 00:51:10,220 every day people in this 974 00:51:10,220 --> 00:51:10,854 community to be able to 975 00:51:10,854 --> 00:51:13,254 distinguish between an ice 976 00:51:14,758 --> 00:51:15,459 agent wearing a police vest and 977 00:51:15,459 --> 00:51:15,759 a cpd officer wearing a police 978 00:51:15,759 --> 00:51:16,526 vest. 979 00:51:16,526 --> 00:51:20,126 The only way to restore that 980 00:51:20,964 --> 00:51:21,565 trust is through transparency. 981 00:51:21,565 --> 00:51:24,565 So that's the first ask. 982 00:51:26,737 --> 00:51:27,304 The second is to help families 983 00:51:27,304 --> 00:51:27,905 find their loved ones. 984 00:51:27,905 --> 00:51:28,439 And there's a couple of 985 00:51:28,439 --> 00:51:30,439 components to that. 986 00:51:32,800 --> 00:51:32,709 The first is that when officers 987 00:51:32,709 --> 00:51:33,444 are at the scene of a federal 988 00:51:33,444 --> 00:51:36,444 immigration arrest, they can be 989 00:51:38,480 --> 00:51:38,748 directed to record which agency 990 00:51:38,748 --> 00:51:39,282 made the arrest and give that 991 00:51:39,282 --> 00:51:39,883 give the family that 992 00:51:39,883 --> 00:51:40,584 information in writing. 993 00:51:40,584 --> 00:51:44,184 And we also should be letting 994 00:51:44,755 --> 00:51:45,388 families know how to find a 995 00:51:45,388 --> 00:51:47,388 detained person providing 996 00:51:50,527 --> 00:51:51,261 information and assistance in 997 00:51:51,261 --> 00:51:51,962 looking for that family members 998 00:51:51,962 --> 00:51:52,796 And taken is the least that we 999 00:51:52,796 --> 00:51:56,367 can do to make a family be seen 1000 00:51:56,367 --> 00:51:56,934 what is most likely the worst 1001 00:51:56,934 --> 00:51:57,667 moment of their lives. 1002 00:51:57,667 --> 00:51:58,135 We're not asking us dpd to stop 1003 00:51:58,135 --> 00:52:00,135 federal agents. 1004 00:52:02,373 --> 00:52:02,706 We're not asking officers to be 1005 00:52:02,706 --> 00:52:03,340 lawyers. 1006 00:52:03,340 --> 00:52:04,740 We're asking for the bare 1007 00:52:04,740 --> 00:52:07,740 minimum that a department sworn 1008 00:52:08,412 --> 00:52:09,113 to protect and serve as a 1009 00:52:09,113 --> 00:52:09,847 family in that worst moment of 1010 00:52:09,847 --> 00:52:13,447 their lives their loved one was 1011 00:52:13,917 --> 00:52:14,451 taken by this agency. 1012 00:52:14,451 --> 00:52:15,850 By the agency. 1013 00:52:15,850 --> 00:52:15,853 Here's how you find them. 1014 00:52:15,853 --> 00:52:16,187 It's our way of telling them We 1015 00:52:16,187 --> 00:52:18,187 see you. 1016 00:52:19,656 --> 00:52:20,390 We're sorry you're going 1017 00:52:20,390 --> 00:52:20,858 through this and we're going to 1018 00:52:20,858 --> 00:52:23,258 do what we can. 1019 00:52:25,129 --> 00:52:25,896 The city can no longer allow 1020 00:52:25,896 --> 00:52:26,596 reality that we can't stop and 1021 00:52:26,596 --> 00:52:26,997 fix everything as a reason to 1022 00:52:26,997 --> 00:52:28,997 do nothing. 1023 00:52:32,836 --> 00:52:33,570 So that's the coda. 1024 00:52:33,570 --> 00:52:36,390 And I don't know if your 1025 00:52:36,390 --> 00:52:36,640 response on the spot but I 1026 00:52:36,640 --> 00:52:37,341 would like one that you 1027 00:52:37,341 --> 00:52:37,941 absolutely have our commitment 1028 00:52:37,941 --> 00:52:40,341 to implement both those 1029 00:52:41,478 --> 00:52:42,790 requests especially the second 1030 00:52:42,790 --> 00:52:42,446 piece there on providing 1031 00:52:42,446 --> 00:52:43,147 resources. 1032 00:52:43,147 --> 00:52:43,714 I believe we have a handful of 1033 00:52:43,714 --> 00:52:46,114 links on our website. 1034 00:52:47,718 --> 00:52:48,418 It's time to to refresh those 1035 00:52:48,418 --> 00:52:49,860 and share those Talking points 1036 00:52:49,860 --> 00:52:49,686 are baked into our both our 1037 00:52:49,686 --> 00:52:52,860 officers to engage with 1038 00:52:54,458 --> 00:52:55,192 community members who are 1039 00:52:55,192 --> 00:52:55,827 observer witness and experience 1040 00:52:55,827 --> 00:52:56,493 and as well as any backend 1041 00:52:56,493 --> 00:52:59,296 support we can provide as a 1042 00:52:59,296 --> 00:53:00,300 municipal organization and to 1043 00:53:00,300 --> 00:53:00,731 engage with contacts we do have 1044 00:53:00,731 --> 00:53:04,331 to try to get more information 1045 00:53:06,137 --> 00:53:06,837 than is typically provided by 1046 00:53:06,837 --> 00:53:07,138 federal forces who come out 1047 00:53:07,138 --> 00:53:07,838 here. 1048 00:53:07,838 --> 00:53:08,472 So you have a commitment both 1049 00:53:08,472 --> 00:53:08,773 Councilmember I appreciate 1050 00:53:08,773 --> 00:53:10,773 that. 1051 00:53:11,875 --> 00:53:12,609 So thank you so much go to 1052 00:53:12,609 --> 00:53:13,310 thank you council PRESIDENT All 1053 00:53:13,310 --> 00:53:13,944 right thank you council member 1054 00:53:13,944 --> 00:53:16,944 and that's anybody else on 1055 00:53:17,815 --> 00:53:18,582 the lights. 1056 00:53:18,582 --> 00:53:19,216 >> The clerk will now go over 1057 00:53:19,216 --> 00:53:22,216 how the public and offered 1058 00:53:24,880 --> 00:53:24,421 their testimony clerk Thank you 1059 00:53:24,421 --> 00:53:25,122 . 1060 00:53:25,122 --> 00:53:25,689 Council PRESIDENT I'd like to 1061 00:53:25,689 --> 00:53:26,900 highlight the slide on 1062 00:53:26,900 --> 00:53:26,723 the screen. 1063 00:53:26,723 --> 00:53:27,425 The order can be found on 1064 00:53:27,425 --> 00:53:29,260 the agenda summary online or a 1065 00:53:29,260 --> 00:53:30,270 table in the back of the room. 1066 00:53:30,270 --> 00:53:30,695 But there's only one item at 1067 00:53:30,695 --> 00:53:31,295 the conclusion of that item 1068 00:53:31,295 --> 00:53:31,963 will be on agenda Public 1069 00:53:31,963 --> 00:53:34,331 comment For those that have 1070 00:53:34,331 --> 00:53:35,320 submitted an organized 1071 00:53:35,320 --> 00:53:35,733 presentation or an item on 1072 00:53:35,733 --> 00:53:36,433 today's agenda please be sure 1073 00:53:36,433 --> 00:53:40,330 to have all of your identified 1074 00:53:40,370 --> 00:53:40,704 participants present present 1075 00:53:40,704 --> 00:53:41,405 when the item is introduced. 1076 00:53:41,405 --> 00:53:44,405 We did only receive one 1077 00:53:46,410 --> 00:53:47,100 in-person organized 1078 00:53:47,100 --> 00:53:47,444 presentation that was by 1079 00:53:47,444 --> 00:53:48,112 the deadline. 1080 00:53:48,112 --> 00:53:48,779 So please ensure that all of 1081 00:53:48,779 --> 00:53:50,779 your identified participants 1082 00:53:52,984 --> 00:53:53,618 raise their hand when prompted 1083 00:53:53,618 --> 00:53:54,285 here in council chambers. 1084 00:53:54,285 --> 00:53:54,952 If you are in person please 1085 00:53:54,952 --> 00:53:57,352 complete complete a speaker 1086 00:53:58,722 --> 00:53:59,323 slip Look it at the entrance of 1087 00:53:59,323 --> 00:53:59,891 chambers and bring it to 1088 00:53:59,891 --> 00:54:00,591 the front of the room. 1089 00:54:00,591 --> 00:54:03,594 You can place it in the clear 1090 00:54:03,594 --> 00:54:04,195 box where the blue arrow points 1091 00:54:04,195 --> 00:54:04,928 Council ambassadors are 1092 00:54:04,928 --> 00:54:05,630 available near the entrance and 1093 00:54:05,630 --> 00:54:06,230 can assist with speaker slips 1094 00:54:06,230 --> 00:54:08,630 and questions No further 1095 00:54:10,501 --> 00:54:11,202 in-person testimony will be 1096 00:54:11,202 --> 00:54:11,869 taken once the council begins 1097 00:54:11,869 --> 00:54:14,269 Virtual testimony Thank you 1098 00:54:15,939 --> 00:54:16,341 Council PRESIDENT All right, 1099 00:54:16,341 --> 00:54:17,750 Thank you. 1100 00:54:17,750 --> 00:54:17,341 With that please introduce item 1101 00:54:17,341 --> 00:54:19,341 200. 1102 00:54:21,110 --> 00:54:21,746 Item 200 is authorized use of 1103 00:54:21,746 --> 00:54:22,380 surveillance technologies under 1104 00:54:22,380 --> 00:54:24,780 the trust ordinance Public 1105 00:54:27,218 --> 00:54:27,919 comment time for this item will 1106 00:54:27,919 --> 00:54:28,620 be one minute per person. 1107 00:54:28,620 --> 00:54:29,354 >> Thank you Council PRESIDENT 1108 00:54:29,354 --> 00:54:33,554 All right with that I see staff 1109 00:54:33,824 --> 00:54:34,525 is settled at the table there 1110 00:54:34,525 --> 00:54:35,226 so please introduce yourselves 1111 00:54:35,226 --> 00:54:35,893 for the record and let us know 1112 00:54:35,893 --> 00:54:39,493 how much time you will need. 1113 00:54:39,764 --> 00:54:40,398 Good afternoon. 1114 00:54:40,398 --> 00:54:41,320 Council PRESIDENT McGovern 1115 00:54:41,320 --> 00:54:41,366 Honorable Members of City 1116 00:54:41,366 --> 00:54:41,966 Council. 1117 00:54:41,966 --> 00:54:44,966 I'm Scott Wall, chief of 1118 00:54:45,436 --> 00:54:45,736 the San Diego Police Department 1119 00:54:45,736 --> 00:54:46,503 . 1120 00:54:46,503 --> 00:54:47,171 I am joined today by Captain 1121 00:54:47,171 --> 00:54:47,638 Charles Lora and Lieutenant 1122 00:54:47,638 --> 00:54:49,638 Chris McAndrew. 1123 00:54:51,709 --> 00:54:52,377 We're here today to present our 1124 00:54:52,377 --> 00:54:55,377 annual survey on support for 1125 00:54:56,647 --> 00:54:57,348 2025 and we'll need about 20 1126 00:54:57,348 --> 00:54:57,815 minutes beginning already But 1127 00:54:57,815 --> 00:54:59,815 good afternoon. 1128 00:55:01,619 --> 00:55:02,486 >> Council members. 1129 00:55:02,486 --> 00:55:03,221 Today we're here to present our 1130 00:55:03,221 --> 00:55:05,221 2025 annual Surveillance report 1131 00:55:06,758 --> 00:55:07,358 and request approval for 1132 00:55:07,358 --> 00:55:07,992 the continued use of 54 1133 00:55:07,992 --> 00:55:08,692 surveillance technologies. 1134 00:55:08,692 --> 00:55:09,293 Technology plays an important 1135 00:55:09,293 --> 00:55:11,693 role in modern policing. 1136 00:55:12,497 --> 00:55:13,970 It gives our officers tools to 1137 00:55:13,970 --> 00:55:13,797 better understand what's 1138 00:55:13,797 --> 00:55:14,465 happening in the field, gather 1139 00:55:14,465 --> 00:55:16,465 critical information during 1140 00:55:18,336 --> 00:55:19,700 investigations and make 1141 00:55:19,700 --> 00:55:19,671 informed decisions about how to 1142 00:55:19,671 --> 00:55:20,380 respond to public safety 1143 00:55:20,380 --> 00:55:20,705 incidents. 1144 00:55:20,705 --> 00:55:23,705 All that helps our officers 1145 00:55:24,175 --> 00:55:24,876 better serve victims of crime 1146 00:55:24,876 --> 00:55:25,577 and keep our communities safe. 1147 00:55:25,577 --> 00:55:26,210 We recognize the importance of 1148 00:55:26,210 --> 00:55:28,610 being transparent with our 1149 00:55:29,748 --> 00:55:30,348 community and how these 1150 00:55:30,348 --> 00:55:31,150 technologies are used 1151 00:55:31,150 --> 00:55:31,683 The privacy safeguards we've 1152 00:55:31,683 --> 00:55:32,417 worked hard to put in place 1153 00:55:32,417 --> 00:55:36,170 This annual process gives us an 1154 00:55:36,254 --> 00:55:36,988 opportunity to do just that. 1155 00:55:36,988 --> 00:55:39,988 This presentation will focus on 1156 00:55:40,258 --> 00:55:40,558 our use of technologies In 2025 1157 00:55:40,558 --> 00:55:41,326 . 1158 00:55:41,326 --> 00:55:42,127 We'll be back in FEBRUARY with 1159 00:55:42,127 --> 00:55:45,127 our next annual report covering 1160 00:55:45,697 --> 00:55:46,464 their use in 2026. 1161 00:55:46,464 --> 00:55:48,864 This report covers 54 different 1162 00:55:52,360 --> 00:55:52,737 surveillance technologies 1163 00:55:52,737 --> 00:55:53,371 the police department utilizes 1164 00:55:53,371 --> 00:55:54,500 Each one has already gone 1165 00:55:54,500 --> 00:55:54,339 through the full oversight 1166 00:55:54,339 --> 00:55:56,339 process. 1167 00:55:57,809 --> 00:55:58,443 That means they were discussed 1168 00:55:58,443 --> 00:55:59,440 in community presentations 1169 00:55:59,440 --> 00:55:59,744 reviewed by the Privacy 1170 00:55:59,744 --> 00:56:02,744 Advisory Board and approved by 1171 00:56:04,115 --> 00:56:04,849 the City Council. 1172 00:56:04,849 --> 00:56:05,584 The annual surveillance report 1173 00:56:05,584 --> 00:56:09,184 process is how we continue that 1174 00:56:10,210 --> 00:56:10,888 oversight each year. 1175 00:56:10,888 --> 00:56:11,556 Now we did not propose any new 1176 00:56:11,556 --> 00:56:13,556 surveillance technologies in 1177 00:56:16,428 --> 00:56:17,128 2025 and the vast majority of 1178 00:56:17,128 --> 00:56:17,762 our existing technologies and 1179 00:56:17,762 --> 00:56:18,128 their use policies remain 1180 00:56:18,128 --> 00:56:20,128 unchanged. 1181 00:56:21,433 --> 00:56:22,167 The two technologies with 1182 00:56:22,167 --> 00:56:22,834 proposed changes were automated 1183 00:56:22,834 --> 00:56:25,834 license plate readers or npr 1184 00:56:27,405 --> 00:56:28,106 and drones for npr. 1185 00:56:28,106 --> 00:56:28,807 Those changes included further 1186 00:56:28,807 --> 00:56:31,207 restrictions to certain uses, 1187 00:56:33,210 --> 00:56:33,811 stronger access controls and 1188 00:56:33,811 --> 00:56:34,512 new council notification 1189 00:56:34,512 --> 00:56:35,213 requirements In the event that 1190 00:56:35,213 --> 00:56:37,613 approach for drone technology 1191 00:56:39,718 --> 00:56:40,418 we consolidated 16 largely 1192 00:56:40,418 --> 00:56:40,986 duplicative policies into one 1193 00:56:40,986 --> 00:56:41,686 comprehensive policy. 1194 00:56:41,686 --> 00:56:45,286 This makes the rules for drone 1195 00:56:45,924 --> 00:56:46,558 use clearer and gives 1196 00:56:46,558 --> 00:56:47,225 the public and the Privacy 1197 00:56:47,225 --> 00:56:47,826 Advisory Board one reference 1198 00:56:47,826 --> 00:56:50,226 point to understand how 1199 00:56:51,963 --> 00:56:52,664 the technology is used. 1200 00:56:52,664 --> 00:56:53,330 The drones We're talking about 1201 00:56:53,330 --> 00:56:53,931 what I refer to as our truck 1202 00:56:53,931 --> 00:56:55,931 deployed drones already 1203 00:56:57,769 --> 00:56:58,336 approved by council. 1204 00:56:58,336 --> 00:56:59,370 There are no new 1205 00:56:59,370 --> 00:56:59,371 functionalities here and they 1206 00:56:59,371 --> 00:57:00,380 are not. 1207 00:57:00,380 --> 00:57:03,380 The drone is first responder 1208 00:57:03,442 --> 00:57:04,750 program which is still working 1209 00:57:04,750 --> 00:57:04,409 its way through the trust 1210 00:57:04,409 --> 00:57:05,110 process. 1211 00:57:05,110 --> 00:57:08,110 Importantly it is again these 1212 00:57:08,914 --> 00:57:09,648 policy changes do not expand 1213 00:57:09,648 --> 00:57:10,282 any technological capabilities. 1214 00:57:10,282 --> 00:57:12,682 Instead they're focused on 1215 00:57:15,487 --> 00:57:16,188 strengthening safeguards, 1216 00:57:16,188 --> 00:57:16,888 improving oversight and making 1217 00:57:16,888 --> 00:57:19,888 our policies easier to follow. 1218 00:57:20,759 --> 00:57:21,460 And that ties into a larger 1219 00:57:21,460 --> 00:57:22,930 focus for us this year 1220 00:57:22,930 --> 00:57:22,627 strengthening auditing and 1221 00:57:22,627 --> 00:57:24,627 oversight across our 1222 00:57:26,431 --> 00:57:26,965 surveillance technologies. 1223 00:57:26,965 --> 00:57:27,699 We made significant 1224 00:57:27,699 --> 00:57:30,699 improvements to our audit and 1225 00:57:31,103 --> 00:57:31,403 accountability measures in 1226 00:57:31,403 --> 00:57:32,104 2025. 1227 00:57:32,104 --> 00:57:35,104 In FEBRUARY 2025 we issued a 1228 00:57:37,476 --> 00:57:38,243 new order requiring officers to 1229 00:57:38,243 --> 00:57:38,944 document a case number or event 1230 00:57:38,944 --> 00:57:39,610 number whenever they conduct a 1231 00:57:39,610 --> 00:57:42,610 search in the flock system. 1232 00:57:42,948 --> 00:57:43,615 This allows us to better track 1233 00:57:43,615 --> 00:57:44,283 how the system is being used 1234 00:57:44,283 --> 00:57:44,983 and ensures searches can be 1235 00:57:44,983 --> 00:57:48,583 tied back to a legitimate law 1236 00:57:48,853 --> 00:57:49,521 enforcement purpose. 1237 00:57:49,521 --> 00:57:52,521 In APRIL we established new 1238 00:57:53,659 --> 00:57:54,359 auditing requirements for all 1239 00:57:54,359 --> 00:57:54,993 54 surveillance technologies. 1240 00:57:54,993 --> 00:57:55,527 Each technology's subject 1241 00:57:55,527 --> 00:57:57,927 matter expert is now 1242 00:57:58,397 --> 00:57:58,997 responsible for tracking ten 1243 00:57:58,997 --> 00:57:59,664 specific data points and 1244 00:57:59,664 --> 00:58:00,365 conducting quarterly audits. 1245 00:58:00,365 --> 00:58:03,965 We also added another layer of 1246 00:58:05,700 --> 00:58:05,704 oversight by requiring our 1247 00:58:05,704 --> 00:58:06,405 inspection control unit to 1248 00:58:06,405 --> 00:58:07,720 conduct annual inspections of 1249 00:58:07,720 --> 00:58:09,472 those audits independent of 1250 00:58:10,409 --> 00:58:10,909 the subject matter experts at 1251 00:58:10,909 --> 00:58:11,576 chain of command. 1252 00:58:11,576 --> 00:58:15,176 Then in JULY we expanded our 1253 00:58:15,647 --> 00:58:16,248 documentation requirements and 1254 00:58:16,248 --> 00:58:16,849 surveillance technology 1255 00:58:16,849 --> 00:58:17,382 database that requires a 1256 00:58:17,382 --> 00:58:18,830 reference number or 1257 00:58:18,830 --> 00:58:21,830 justification for use must now 1258 00:58:22,921 --> 00:58:23,355 be tied to a case number or an 1259 00:58:23,355 --> 00:58:24,550 event number. 1260 00:58:24,550 --> 00:58:24,756 Taken together, these changes 1261 00:58:24,756 --> 00:58:27,756 can give us better visibility 1262 00:58:27,792 --> 00:58:28,593 into how our technologies are 1263 00:58:28,593 --> 00:58:29,361 being used and help us make 1264 00:58:29,361 --> 00:58:32,361 sure our policies are being 1265 00:58:34,166 --> 00:58:34,900 followed. 1266 00:58:34,900 --> 00:58:35,567 The continued strengthening of 1267 00:58:35,567 --> 00:58:36,268 safeguards around our health 1268 00:58:36,268 --> 00:58:36,902 care system with a particular 1269 00:58:36,902 --> 00:58:39,302 focus for the department. 1270 00:58:41,172 --> 00:58:41,739 First a quick overview of how 1271 00:58:41,739 --> 00:58:42,408 the technology works. 1272 00:58:42,408 --> 00:58:45,408 Our cameras take pictures of 1273 00:58:45,844 --> 00:58:46,311 vehicles as they pass along 1274 00:58:46,311 --> 00:58:47,790 public roadways. 1275 00:58:47,790 --> 00:58:47,780 Here you see an example of what 1276 00:58:47,780 --> 00:58:48,480 one of those images looks like 1277 00:58:48,480 --> 00:58:51,480 and the information the system 1278 00:58:52,818 --> 00:58:53,451 captures the license plate 1279 00:58:53,451 --> 00:58:54,152 number, the license type, 1280 00:58:54,152 --> 00:58:57,152 the vehicle's make model color 1281 00:58:58,900 --> 00:58:58,957 and distinguishing features 1282 00:58:58,957 --> 00:58:59,290 like a roof rack or a bumper 1283 00:58:59,290 --> 00:58:59,958 sticker. 1284 00:58:59,958 --> 00:59:00,625 It's also important to know 1285 00:59:00,625 --> 00:59:03,625 what the system doesn't do. 1286 00:59:04,596 --> 00:59:04,897 It does not record audio or 1287 00:59:04,897 --> 00:59:05,464 video. 1288 00:59:05,464 --> 00:59:08,464 It does not use facial 1289 00:59:09,802 --> 00:59:10,502 recognition and cannot identify 1290 00:59:10,502 --> 00:59:11,103 the race, age or gender of 1291 00:59:11,103 --> 00:59:11,704 drivers for passengers. 1292 00:59:11,704 --> 00:59:14,704 It also does not provide 1293 00:59:15,741 --> 00:59:16,508 personal identifying 1294 00:59:16,508 --> 00:59:17,242 information such as the name of 1295 00:59:17,242 --> 00:59:17,843 the vehicle's registered owner. 1296 00:59:17,843 --> 00:59:20,243 That information is not 1297 00:59:22,981 --> 00:59:23,682 included in the lpr system. 1298 00:59:23,682 --> 00:59:24,490 One of the greatest strengths 1299 00:59:24,490 --> 00:59:26,490 is speed. 1300 00:59:28,487 --> 00:59:29,154 It helps officers identify and 1301 00:59:29,154 --> 00:59:29,755 locate vehicles connected to 1302 00:59:29,755 --> 00:59:32,155 crimes or public safety 1303 00:59:33,926 --> 00:59:34,560 emergencies often much faster 1304 00:59:34,560 --> 00:59:34,893 than traditional policing 1305 00:59:34,893 --> 00:59:35,561 methods. 1306 00:59:35,561 --> 00:59:36,128 It's especially useful when 1307 00:59:36,128 --> 00:59:38,128 officers have limited 1308 00:59:39,865 --> 00:59:40,599 information to work with like 1309 00:59:40,599 --> 00:59:41,132 partial license plate or just a 1310 00:59:41,132 --> 00:59:43,132 vehicle description. 1311 00:59:45,404 --> 00:59:45,938 Hdr can help turn that 1312 00:59:45,938 --> 00:59:46,472 information into an 1313 00:59:46,472 --> 00:59:47,105 investigative lead, 1314 00:59:47,105 --> 00:59:47,473 particularly when time is 1315 00:59:47,473 --> 00:59:49,473 critical. 1316 00:59:51,177 --> 00:59:51,810 It can also help officers 1317 00:59:51,810 --> 00:59:52,477 locate stolen vehicles and 1318 00:59:52,477 --> 00:59:53,450 vehicles associated with at 1319 00:59:53,450 --> 00:59:55,450 risk missing persons. 1320 00:59:57,883 --> 00:59:58,450 But I want to emphasize an 1321 00:59:58,450 --> 00:59:59,151 important distinction. 1322 00:59:59,151 --> 00:59:59,451 Npr provides an investigative 1323 00:59:59,451 --> 01:00:01,451 lead. 1324 01:00:03,923 --> 01:00:04,723 It is not proof of wrongdoing 1325 01:00:04,723 --> 01:00:05,424 and every npr alert must be 1326 01:00:05,424 --> 01:00:06,580 independently verified before 1327 01:00:06,580 --> 01:00:06,392 officers take enforcement 1328 01:00:06,392 --> 01:00:08,392 action. 1329 01:00:10,663 --> 01:00:11,263 Officers must confirm 1330 01:00:11,263 --> 01:00:11,930 the vehicle information, 1331 01:00:11,930 --> 01:00:12,598 establish that the alert is 1332 01:00:12,598 --> 01:00:15,598 valid and conduct their own 1333 01:00:16,235 --> 01:00:16,969 investigation before taking 1334 01:00:16,969 --> 01:00:17,603 further action including making 1335 01:00:17,603 --> 01:00:20,603 a traffic stop or arrest. 1336 01:00:22,942 --> 01:00:23,309 Cpd has used a system since 1337 01:00:23,309 --> 01:00:24,430 late 2023. 1338 01:00:24,430 --> 01:00:24,677 Today 500 cameras are installed 1339 01:00:24,677 --> 01:00:27,677 across the city and those 1340 01:00:29,249 --> 01:00:29,781 locations are posted on 1341 01:00:29,781 --> 01:00:30,483 the city's website. 1342 01:00:30,483 --> 01:00:31,117 Since then we've seen just how 1343 01:00:31,117 --> 01:00:34,117 useful this system can be. 1344 01:00:35,521 --> 01:00:36,154 Hpr has assisted in more than 1345 01:00:36,154 --> 01:00:38,154 940 investigations, helped 1346 01:00:40,292 --> 01:00:40,993 officers make over 700 arrests 1347 01:00:40,993 --> 01:00:41,360 and helped recover 689 stolen 1348 01:00:41,360 --> 01:00:42,270 vehicles. 1349 01:00:42,270 --> 01:00:45,270 During this period San Diego 1350 01:00:46,980 --> 01:00:46,799 has also seen a 20% year over 1351 01:00:46,799 --> 01:00:47,466 year decline in motor vehicle 1352 01:00:47,466 --> 01:00:47,767 theft for three consecutive 1353 01:00:47,767 --> 01:00:49,767 years. 1354 01:00:52,304 --> 01:00:52,638 And I want to give you a recent 1355 01:00:52,638 --> 01:00:53,205 example. 1356 01:00:53,205 --> 01:00:53,906 This past MAY officers 1357 01:00:53,906 --> 01:00:57,506 responded to a serious hit and 1358 01:00:57,810 --> 01:00:58,544 run crash where a driver struck 1359 01:00:58,544 --> 01:00:58,878 a bus stop seriously injuring a 1360 01:00:58,878 --> 01:00:59,545 person. 1361 01:00:59,545 --> 01:01:00,146 Witnesses provided a partial 1362 01:01:00,146 --> 01:01:02,546 license plate number and 1363 01:01:04,183 --> 01:01:04,884 description of the vehicle. 1364 01:01:04,884 --> 01:01:07,884 Using that information in hpr 1365 01:01:08,187 --> 01:01:08,821 officers were able to locate 1366 01:01:08,821 --> 01:01:09,555 the vehicle within just 26 1367 01:01:09,555 --> 01:01:10,122 minutes of the initial 911 call 1368 01:01:10,122 --> 01:01:12,122 ultimately leading to 1369 01:01:14,327 --> 01:01:14,861 the suspect's arrest. 1370 01:01:14,861 --> 01:01:15,528 That speed mattered. 1371 01:01:15,528 --> 01:01:16,129 Officers were able to secure 1372 01:01:16,129 --> 01:01:18,129 time sensitive evidence 1373 01:01:20,232 --> 01:01:20,967 indicating the driver had been 1374 01:01:20,967 --> 01:01:21,400 under the influence at the time 1375 01:01:21,400 --> 01:01:22,100 of the crash. 1376 01:01:22,100 --> 01:01:25,100 And there are many more 1377 01:01:26,539 --> 01:01:27,239 examples like this from 1378 01:01:27,239 --> 01:01:27,940 homicides and sexual assaults 1379 01:01:27,940 --> 01:01:28,573 to missing persons hate crimes 1380 01:01:28,573 --> 01:01:30,573 and attempted kidnapings. 1381 01:01:32,712 --> 01:01:33,379 He has helped San Diego police 1382 01:01:33,379 --> 01:01:34,790 officers investigate serious 1383 01:01:34,790 --> 01:01:35,248 crimes, identify suspects and 1384 01:01:35,248 --> 01:01:37,648 pursue justice for victims 1385 01:01:41,354 --> 01:01:42,210 across our city. 1386 01:01:42,210 --> 01:01:42,622 >> Results like these have 1387 01:01:42,622 --> 01:01:43,323 helped drive widespread 1388 01:01:43,323 --> 01:01:43,856 adoption of our technology in 1389 01:01:43,856 --> 01:01:44,256 major cities across 1390 01:01:44,256 --> 01:01:46,256 the country. 1391 01:01:48,293 --> 01:01:49,610 This technology is not new. 1392 01:01:49,610 --> 01:01:52,661 Npr has been used by law 1393 01:01:52,665 --> 01:01:53,433 enforcement in our country for 1394 01:01:53,433 --> 01:01:54,133 over 20 years and today 18 of 1395 01:01:54,133 --> 01:01:54,467 the nation's 20 largest cities 1396 01:01:54,467 --> 01:01:56,467 use it. 1397 01:01:58,504 --> 01:01:59,138 And a 2020 national study found 1398 01:01:59,138 --> 01:02:01,538 that every responding law 1399 01:02:01,641 --> 01:02:02,274 enforcement agency serving more 1400 01:02:02,274 --> 01:02:04,274 than 1 million residents 1401 01:02:08,281 --> 01:02:09,470 reported using a lpr. 1402 01:02:09,470 --> 01:02:09,682 But the department has always 1403 01:02:09,682 --> 01:02:10,382 understood that having an 1404 01:02:10,382 --> 01:02:10,816 effective tool is only part of 1405 01:02:10,816 --> 01:02:12,816 the equation. 1406 01:02:14,153 --> 01:02:14,887 We also need strong safeguards 1407 01:02:14,887 --> 01:02:15,355 to make sure it's used properly 1408 01:02:15,355 --> 01:02:16,220 and responsibly. 1409 01:02:16,220 --> 01:02:19,622 And I think the city council 1410 01:02:19,759 --> 01:02:20,293 and our oversight board should 1411 01:02:20,293 --> 01:02:20,860 be proud of the work 1412 01:02:20,860 --> 01:02:21,427 accomplished in 2025. 1413 01:02:21,427 --> 01:02:22,950 Some of the safeguards 1414 01:02:22,950 --> 01:02:25,950 developed here in San Diego 1415 01:02:26,732 --> 01:02:27,437 including requiring a case or 1416 01:02:27,437 --> 01:02:28,670 event number for every day of 1417 01:02:28,670 --> 01:02:28,701 your search are now being 1418 01:02:28,701 --> 01:02:31,101 adopted by agencies across 1419 01:02:31,604 --> 01:02:32,472 the country. 1420 01:02:32,472 --> 01:02:33,500 So how do we protect this data 1421 01:02:33,500 --> 01:02:33,706 and prevent misuse? 1422 01:02:33,706 --> 01:02:36,706 First access is restricted to 1423 01:02:38,378 --> 01:02:38,745 trained authorized cpd 1424 01:02:38,745 --> 01:02:39,345 personnel. 1425 01:02:39,345 --> 01:02:40,130 Every user must have a 1426 01:02:40,130 --> 01:02:40,646 department email address and 1427 01:02:40,646 --> 01:02:43,646 sign on through The city's 1428 01:02:44,216 --> 01:02:44,918 secure logging system. 1429 01:02:44,918 --> 01:02:45,552 Every search must also include 1430 01:02:45,552 --> 01:02:47,552 a legitimate investigative 1431 01:02:50,690 --> 01:02:51,358 reason including an offense or 1432 01:02:51,358 --> 01:02:51,925 case type and corresponding 1433 01:02:51,925 --> 01:02:54,325 case or event number. 1434 01:02:56,295 --> 01:02:56,930 Searches related to immigration 1435 01:02:56,930 --> 01:02:57,496 Foresman and reproductive 1436 01:02:57,496 --> 01:02:58,130 health are prohibited. 1437 01:02:58,130 --> 01:02:58,798 Supervisors conduct weekly 1438 01:02:58,798 --> 01:03:01,798 audits of system searches to 1439 01:03:02,835 --> 01:03:03,369 ensure the technology is being 1440 01:03:03,369 --> 01:03:04,300 used appropriately. 1441 01:03:04,300 --> 01:03:07,300 The system also has strict 1442 01:03:09,142 --> 01:03:09,843 rules governing how long data 1443 01:03:09,843 --> 01:03:10,677 is kept and who can't and who 1444 01:03:10,677 --> 01:03:13,880 can be shared with it If your 1445 01:03:13,880 --> 01:03:14,647 data is permanently deleted 1446 01:03:14,647 --> 01:03:15,315 after 30 days unless it needs 1447 01:03:15,315 --> 01:03:18,315 to be preserved as evidence. 1448 01:03:19,786 --> 01:03:20,453 Every time officers log in 1449 01:03:20,453 --> 01:03:21,530 the reminder that misuse of 1450 01:03:21,530 --> 01:03:21,587 the system can result in 1451 01:03:21,587 --> 01:03:22,122 disciplinary action. 1452 01:03:22,122 --> 01:03:24,522 And the searches for 1453 01:03:25,825 --> 01:03:26,492 immigration enforcement 1454 01:03:26,492 --> 01:03:26,959 reproductive health purposes 1455 01:03:26,959 --> 01:03:27,694 are prohibited. 1456 01:03:27,694 --> 01:03:31,894 Our policy is also in line with 1457 01:03:32,980 --> 01:03:32,799 state law and prohibit sharing 1458 01:03:32,799 --> 01:03:33,300 illegal pure data with federal 1459 01:03:33,300 --> 01:03:33,867 or state agencies. 1460 01:03:33,867 --> 01:03:36,267 And recent changes to 1461 01:03:38,872 --> 01:03:39,472 the system have added another 1462 01:03:39,472 --> 01:03:40,173 layer of protection by 1463 01:03:40,173 --> 01:03:40,807 preventing California agencies 1464 01:03:40,807 --> 01:03:43,207 from configuring their lpa 1465 01:03:44,176 --> 01:03:44,644 database to share data with 1466 01:03:44,644 --> 01:03:45,344 those agencies. 1467 01:03:45,344 --> 01:03:46,112 I also want to emphasize that 1468 01:03:46,112 --> 01:03:49,712 cpd has never used data from 1469 01:03:50,216 --> 01:03:50,784 this system for immigration 1470 01:03:50,784 --> 01:03:51,384 enforcement purposes. 1471 01:03:51,384 --> 01:03:53,784 >> This year we continue 1472 01:03:56,155 --> 01:03:56,856 continued working closely with 1473 01:03:56,856 --> 01:03:57,523 the Privacy Advisory Board to 1474 01:03:57,523 --> 01:03:57,991 strengthen our oversight and 1475 01:03:57,991 --> 01:03:58,691 accountability. 1476 01:03:58,691 --> 01:04:02,395 One result of that work is our 1477 01:04:02,395 --> 01:04:03,230 new community concerns matrix. 1478 01:04:03,230 --> 01:04:03,863 It takes the concerns raised by 1479 01:04:03,863 --> 01:04:04,564 community members and city 1480 01:04:04,564 --> 01:04:07,564 council and shows the specific 1481 01:04:08,435 --> 01:04:08,869 safeguards we put in place to 1482 01:04:08,869 --> 01:04:09,535 address them. 1483 01:04:09,535 --> 01:04:09,970 We've also developed a risk 1484 01:04:09,970 --> 01:04:11,970 audit matrix. 1485 01:04:14,341 --> 01:04:14,908 This document identifies 1486 01:04:14,908 --> 01:04:15,308 potential risks within 1487 01:04:15,308 --> 01:04:16,420 the system. 1488 01:04:16,420 --> 01:04:16,710 Outlines the safeguards we have 1489 01:04:16,710 --> 01:04:20,213 in place to address them and 1490 01:04:20,213 --> 01:04:20,947 explains how we audit those 1491 01:04:20,947 --> 01:04:21,481 safeguards to make sure they're 1492 01:04:21,481 --> 01:04:22,820 working as intended. 1493 01:04:22,820 --> 01:04:25,820 I want to emphasize that 1494 01:04:26,219 --> 01:04:26,820 the department takes any misuse 1495 01:04:26,820 --> 01:04:27,187 of the system extremely 1496 01:04:27,187 --> 01:04:27,888 seriously. 1497 01:04:27,888 --> 01:04:28,555 If an audit uncovers potential 1498 01:04:28,555 --> 01:04:31,555 misuse, the user's access is 1499 01:04:33,293 --> 01:04:33,692 immediately suspended while we 1500 01:04:33,692 --> 01:04:34,427 investigate. 1501 01:04:34,427 --> 01:04:35,940 Any confirmed misuse can result 1502 01:04:35,940 --> 01:04:38,940 in disciplinary action up to 1503 01:04:39,650 --> 01:04:39,699 and including termination. 1504 01:04:39,699 --> 01:04:40,333 We've also created a 1505 01:04:40,333 --> 01:04:42,333 recommendations tracker so 1506 01:04:45,605 --> 01:04:46,306 the privacy advisory Board can 1507 01:04:46,306 --> 01:04:47,700 see how we responded to its 1508 01:04:47,700 --> 01:04:47,707 recommendations and what steps 1509 01:04:47,707 --> 01:04:50,707 we've taken to implement them. 1510 01:04:51,244 --> 01:04:51,912 The city's trust ordinance was 1511 01:04:51,912 --> 01:04:52,612 designed to help us evaluate 1512 01:04:52,612 --> 01:04:55,612 technologies like npr with an 1513 01:04:57,840 --> 01:04:57,751 emphasis on ongoing oversight 1514 01:04:57,751 --> 01:04:58,418 and continuous improvement. 1515 01:04:58,418 --> 01:04:59,119 We believe the framework has 1516 01:04:59,119 --> 01:05:02,719 helped that San Diego Park has 1517 01:05:02,922 --> 01:05:03,590 given us a structured way to 1518 01:05:03,590 --> 01:05:04,224 address concerns, strengthen 1519 01:05:04,224 --> 01:05:04,825 safeguards and continually 1520 01:05:04,825 --> 01:05:07,825 improve how we use this 1521 01:05:08,762 --> 01:05:09,363 technology. 1522 01:05:09,363 --> 01:05:09,997 In closing, we're asking 1523 01:05:09,997 --> 01:05:10,630 Council to approve staff's 1524 01:05:10,630 --> 01:05:11,198 recommendation to continue 1525 01:05:11,198 --> 01:05:13,198 using the department's 1526 01:05:15,350 --> 01:05:15,735 surveillance technologies. 1527 01:05:15,735 --> 01:05:16,403 With the proposed changes, 1528 01:05:16,403 --> 01:05:17,104 these changes would include 1529 01:05:17,104 --> 01:05:19,504 combining the Department's us 1530 01:05:21,741 --> 01:05:22,442 policies into a single policy 1531 01:05:22,442 --> 01:05:23,900 and making additional changes 1532 01:05:23,900 --> 01:05:23,710 to the opr use policy. 1533 01:05:23,710 --> 01:05:26,710 We're asking the city's labor 1534 01:05:27,681 --> 01:05:28,381 relations team to review these 1535 01:05:28,381 --> 01:05:28,982 changes and determine whether 1536 01:05:28,982 --> 01:05:29,515 they require notice to a 1537 01:05:29,515 --> 01:05:31,515 recognize employee. 1538 01:05:34,421 --> 01:05:35,122 Employee organizations and an 1539 01:05:35,122 --> 01:05:35,789 opportunity to meet and confer 1540 01:05:35,789 --> 01:05:36,560 under the Myers Munis Brown 1541 01:05:36,560 --> 01:05:38,560 Act. 1542 01:05:39,760 --> 01:05:40,460 If notice is required the city 1543 01:05:40,460 --> 01:05:41,930 would provide it and return to 1544 01:05:41,930 --> 01:05:43,493 council if any bargaining 1545 01:05:46,266 --> 01:05:46,604 related issues meet council 1546 01:05:46,604 --> 01:05:48,604 action. 1547 01:05:52,390 --> 01:05:54,390 That concludes presentation. 1548 01:05:57,211 --> 01:05:57,644 Going a little faster so thank 1549 01:05:57,644 --> 01:05:58,378 you for that. 1550 01:05:58,378 --> 01:05:59,790 >> So with that Clark please 1551 01:05:59,790 --> 01:06:02,790 proceed with all the comment. 1552 01:06:03,484 --> 01:06:04,840 Thank you. 1553 01:06:04,840 --> 01:06:04,718 Council PRESIDENT We did 1554 01:06:04,718 --> 01:06:05,180 receive more speaker slips 1555 01:06:05,180 --> 01:06:07,180 since. 1556 01:06:07,821 --> 01:06:08,555 So right now we're at about 1557 01:06:08,555 --> 01:06:09,155 three hours of public testimony 1558 01:06:09,155 --> 01:06:11,155 starting with organized 1559 01:06:14,194 --> 01:06:14,962 presentations. 1560 01:06:14,962 --> 01:06:15,495 If we can have that hall, 1561 01:06:15,495 --> 01:06:17,495 please come forward. 1562 01:06:20,901 --> 01:06:21,568 And in the following 1563 01:06:21,568 --> 01:06:21,969 individuals can please raise 1564 01:06:21,969 --> 01:06:23,969 their hand. 1565 01:06:26,874 --> 01:06:27,274 Omar Yusef Mohammad Omar. 1566 01:06:27,274 --> 01:06:27,675 Thank you. 1567 01:06:27,675 --> 01:06:28,750 My brother. 1568 01:06:28,750 --> 01:06:30,750 My brother. 1569 01:06:34,715 --> 01:06:35,482 Other Okay. 1570 01:06:35,482 --> 01:06:36,830 Leila Goodman If you can please 1571 01:06:36,830 --> 01:06:37,517 raise your hand higher. 1572 01:06:37,517 --> 01:06:37,917 Leila Omar Thank you very much. 1573 01:06:37,917 --> 01:06:39,917 Thank you. 1574 01:06:43,156 --> 01:06:43,656 Thank you, MR. Diamond. 1575 01:06:43,656 --> 01:06:45,656 Soraya Moment. 1576 01:06:49,563 --> 01:06:51,563 Daniela Alvarado. 1577 01:06:53,601 --> 01:06:54,134 Mohammad Mohammed Abby two 1578 01:06:54,134 --> 01:06:54,568 college Thank you. 1579 01:06:54,568 --> 01:06:56,568 Sharon Larios. 1580 01:07:00,400 --> 01:07:01,800 Sharon Larios. 1581 01:07:01,800 --> 01:07:04,612 I am not seeing your hand If 1582 01:07:04,612 --> 01:07:05,278 you are okay, I'll wait one 1583 01:07:05,278 --> 01:07:05,646 second and then Kiana Price 1584 01:07:05,646 --> 01:07:07,646 Thank you. 1585 01:07:18,292 --> 01:07:18,859 Waiting for Sharon Larios That 1586 01:07:18,859 --> 01:07:19,692 is a 13 minutes. 1587 01:07:19,692 --> 01:07:23,892 If she does not attend it will 1588 01:07:23,931 --> 01:07:24,733 be 12 And then if she comes in 1589 01:07:24,733 --> 01:07:25,365 she can raise your hand and 1590 01:07:25,365 --> 01:07:25,832 will add the extra minute. 1591 01:07:25,832 --> 01:07:27,832 Please proceed. 1592 01:07:32,640 --> 01:07:33,307 Thank you, Counsel. 1593 01:07:33,307 --> 01:07:34,800 Our presentation is going to 1594 01:07:34,800 --> 01:07:37,608 begin with you, sir Yousef and 1595 01:07:38,646 --> 01:07:39,313 then I'll hand off to me. 1596 01:07:39,313 --> 01:07:41,313 >> Good afternoon, Counsel 1597 01:07:43,284 --> 01:07:46,284 Humaira Yousef with Pena, a 1598 01:07:48,389 --> 01:07:49,256 member of the Trust Coalition. 1599 01:07:49,256 --> 01:07:49,557 >> Thank you all for being here 1600 01:07:49,557 --> 01:07:50,191 today. 1601 01:07:50,191 --> 01:07:52,591 After many failed attempts 1602 01:07:54,295 --> 01:07:54,928 today, the trust of 1603 01:07:54,928 --> 01:07:55,596 the coalition is here once 1604 01:07:55,596 --> 01:07:58,596 again asking city leaders to 1605 01:07:59,667 --> 01:08:00,100 reject the youth policy for 1606 01:08:00,100 --> 01:08:00,568 the lpr. 1607 01:08:00,568 --> 01:08:02,968 Three years after this 1608 01:08:05,171 --> 01:08:05,940 technology was spread across 1609 01:08:05,940 --> 01:08:06,674 San Diego, the harms that we 1610 01:08:06,674 --> 01:08:07,341 warned of are now spilling into 1611 01:08:07,341 --> 01:08:10,941 the streets for all to see. 1612 01:08:11,913 --> 01:08:12,513 We are happy that you were here 1613 01:08:12,513 --> 01:08:13,180 and that the council and 1614 01:08:13,180 --> 01:08:15,580 the public understands today 1615 01:08:16,817 --> 01:08:17,485 more than ever before that 1616 01:08:17,485 --> 01:08:19,885 dangers of this technology. 1617 01:08:22,389 --> 01:08:23,191 It has been a long time coming 1618 01:08:23,191 --> 01:08:23,791 and we hope that today San 1619 01:08:23,791 --> 01:08:24,458 Diego leaders stand with 1620 01:08:24,458 --> 01:08:27,458 the community to rescind to 1621 01:08:27,594 --> 01:08:28,362 rescind this policy. 1622 01:08:28,362 --> 01:08:29,630 But that is not enough to 1623 01:08:29,630 --> 01:08:29,463 address the problems with this 1624 01:08:29,463 --> 01:08:31,463 technology. 1625 01:08:33,340 --> 01:08:33,768 We are here to ask that you 1626 01:08:33,768 --> 01:08:37,368 make a vote that actually means 1627 01:08:38,439 --> 01:08:39,306 something to San Diego and that 1628 01:08:39,306 --> 01:08:39,941 we can see and believe a vote 1629 01:08:39,941 --> 01:08:42,941 to reject the city's youth 1630 01:08:44,177 --> 01:08:44,879 policy if not a removal And it 1631 01:08:44,879 --> 01:08:45,612 does not stop this technology 1632 01:08:45,612 --> 01:08:49,212 from creating data about it and 1633 01:08:50,351 --> 01:08:50,985 sending it to a flock for it to 1634 01:08:50,985 --> 01:08:51,386 be used against us across 1635 01:08:51,386 --> 01:08:53,386 the country. 1636 01:08:55,590 --> 01:08:56,323 City councils have voted 1637 01:08:56,323 --> 01:08:57,240 against these cameras and watch 1638 01:08:57,240 --> 01:09:00,240 them keep generating data for 1639 01:09:01,280 --> 01:09:01,996 weeks and for months. 1640 01:09:01,996 --> 01:09:02,563 San Diego has 500 of them every 1641 01:09:02,563 --> 01:09:04,963 day they are running. 1642 01:09:06,901 --> 01:09:07,534 This is youth by the city and 1643 01:09:07,534 --> 01:09:07,835 the data flows directly to 1644 01:09:07,835 --> 01:09:09,835 flock. 1645 01:09:10,705 --> 01:09:11,338 So our coalition is asking 1646 01:09:11,338 --> 01:09:11,939 three things of you today 1647 01:09:11,939 --> 01:09:14,339 reject the youth policy. 1648 01:09:16,978 --> 01:09:17,645 Direct the mayor to remove 1649 01:09:17,645 --> 01:09:18,346 the cameras and until that's 1650 01:09:18,346 --> 01:09:21,946 done install covers on them In 1651 01:09:24,652 --> 01:09:25,340 a way anyone walking can verify 1652 01:09:25,340 --> 01:09:25,687 . 1653 01:09:25,687 --> 01:09:26,387 But first we need to briefly 1654 01:09:26,387 --> 01:09:29,987 explain why we are here today. 1655 01:09:30,658 --> 01:09:34,258 Like you, this is the city's 1656 01:09:35,730 --> 01:09:36,397 own record one The department's 1657 01:09:36,397 --> 01:09:37,980 own annual report for 2024 1658 01:09:37,980 --> 01:09:40,980 showed dozens of times San 1659 01:09:41,535 --> 01:09:42,203 Diego's Alpers was shared with 1660 01:09:42,203 --> 01:09:42,937 federal agencies and out of 1661 01:09:42,937 --> 01:09:45,937 state agencies which is clearly 1662 01:09:47,174 --> 01:09:47,942 against state law. 1663 01:09:47,942 --> 01:09:48,710 San Diego chose to share this 1664 01:09:48,710 --> 01:09:51,710 data illegally during a time 1665 01:09:51,946 --> 01:09:52,714 where there was a direct attack 1666 01:09:52,714 --> 01:09:55,714 on our immigrant communities by 1667 01:09:57,719 --> 01:09:58,419 the federal administration when 1668 01:09:58,419 --> 01:10:01,419 families were being torn apart 1669 01:10:02,190 --> 01:10:02,524 and kidnaped our data was being 1670 01:10:02,524 --> 01:10:03,910 shared. 1671 01:10:03,910 --> 01:10:03,792 It took a letter from 1672 01:10:03,792 --> 01:10:04,225 the Attorney General's office 1673 01:10:04,225 --> 01:10:06,225 to stop them. 1674 01:10:08,429 --> 01:10:09,300 Since then questions about data 1675 01:10:09,300 --> 01:10:09,731 ending up in charges and 1676 01:10:09,731 --> 01:10:12,131 the federal government's high 1677 01:10:13,701 --> 01:10:14,369 intensity drug trafficking area 1678 01:10:14,369 --> 01:10:17,369 database have been raised in 1679 01:10:18,606 --> 01:10:19,207 the public media with no 1680 01:10:19,207 --> 01:10:21,207 accountability to those 1681 01:10:24,212 --> 01:10:24,979 questions yet to come to Hugot 1682 01:10:24,979 --> 01:10:25,647 Hugo Parra spent nearly a month 1683 01:10:25,647 --> 01:10:28,470 in jail through Thanksgiving 1684 01:10:29,830 --> 01:10:29,784 for a carjacking in Golden Hill 1685 01:10:29,784 --> 01:10:33,384 while the system held a record 1686 01:10:34,855 --> 01:10:35,490 of his friend's car sitting in 1687 01:10:35,490 --> 01:10:38,490 Old Town five miles away. 1688 01:10:38,560 --> 01:10:39,260 >> George Horry Photo a 19 year 1689 01:10:39,260 --> 01:10:42,860 old passenger on his way to 1690 01:10:44,332 --> 01:10:44,932 work was shot after the system 1691 01:10:44,932 --> 01:10:47,932 flagged a car as stolen. 1692 01:10:49,638 --> 01:10:49,937 The owner said it never was 1693 01:10:49,937 --> 01:10:50,705 three. 1694 01:10:50,705 --> 01:10:54,305 Last week we learned that as 1695 01:10:54,409 --> 01:10:55,760 you flock to track domestic 1696 01:10:55,760 --> 01:10:55,744 violence a domestic violence 1697 01:10:55,744 --> 01:10:58,744 victim and its own officers 1698 01:10:59,648 --> 01:11:00,315 during an interim internal 1699 01:11:00,315 --> 01:11:00,915 investigation due to the lax 1700 01:11:00,915 --> 01:11:02,915 policies championed and 1701 01:11:04,753 --> 01:11:05,386 approved by this council, we 1702 01:11:05,386 --> 01:11:06,530 actually have no idea how 1703 01:11:06,530 --> 01:11:09,530 the department is using this 1704 01:11:09,824 --> 01:11:10,457 technology and if it has any 1705 01:11:10,457 --> 01:11:11,192 limits to speak of at all. 1706 01:11:11,192 --> 01:11:14,192 Those are not just risks. 1707 01:11:15,163 --> 01:11:15,931 They are events that keep 1708 01:11:15,931 --> 01:11:18,931 happening according to your own 1709 01:11:19,733 --> 01:11:20,402 records and they have had no 1710 01:11:20,402 --> 01:11:23,402 response And these are just 1711 01:11:24,372 --> 01:11:25,390 cases we are aware of And 1712 01:11:25,390 --> 01:11:25,640 because of media coverage we 1713 01:11:25,640 --> 01:11:26,173 know of them because of 1714 01:11:26,173 --> 01:11:28,173 the media coverage. 1715 01:11:29,377 --> 01:11:30,450 And I wonder how many incidents 1716 01:11:30,450 --> 01:11:30,512 are happening that we don't 1717 01:11:30,512 --> 01:11:32,512 know about yet. 1718 01:11:35,150 --> 01:11:35,817 We need to and we need to 1719 01:11:35,817 --> 01:11:36,217 address a disturbing paradox 1720 01:11:36,217 --> 01:11:38,217 here today. 1721 01:11:39,621 --> 01:11:40,322 San Diego is said to have one 1722 01:11:40,322 --> 01:11:42,722 of the strongest surveillance 1723 01:11:43,391 --> 01:11:44,159 oversight in the country. 1724 01:11:44,159 --> 01:11:47,759 What the mayor calls the gold 1725 01:11:48,597 --> 01:11:49,296 standard trust was built so 1726 01:11:49,296 --> 01:11:52,296 this city would catch exactly 1727 01:11:53,435 --> 01:11:53,802 these problems before they 1728 01:11:53,802 --> 01:11:55,802 happened. 1729 01:11:57,706 --> 01:11:58,340 Meanwhile, at least 284 local 1730 01:11:58,340 --> 01:11:59,400 governments have canceled 1731 01:11:59,400 --> 01:12:01,440 license plate reader contracts 1732 01:12:03,450 --> 01:12:03,578 since the start of 2025, most 1733 01:12:03,578 --> 01:12:05,978 of them being black. 1734 01:12:07,615 --> 01:12:08,316 >> Most of those cities have no 1735 01:12:08,316 --> 01:12:08,984 surveillance ordinance at all. 1736 01:12:08,984 --> 01:12:11,984 Some of these places heard 1737 01:12:12,554 --> 01:12:13,550 complaints from just a small 1738 01:12:13,550 --> 01:12:13,788 number of people. 1739 01:12:13,788 --> 01:12:16,926 In one city council meeting and 1740 01:12:16,926 --> 01:12:17,559 they decided to protect 1741 01:12:17,559 --> 01:12:17,993 the people of their city. 1742 01:12:17,993 --> 01:12:20,393 We have a law. 1743 01:12:21,963 --> 01:12:22,731 We have a board of experts. 1744 01:12:22,731 --> 01:12:23,498 We have annual reports and we 1745 01:12:23,498 --> 01:12:26,498 have three years of public 1746 01:12:30,172 --> 01:12:31,138 testimony Right. 1747 01:12:31,138 --> 01:12:34,643 >> And still we need to, you 1748 01:12:34,643 --> 01:12:35,430 know, recognize where we're at 1749 01:12:35,430 --> 01:12:37,430 right now. 1750 01:12:39,648 --> 01:12:40,315 The system is still running So 1751 01:12:40,315 --> 01:12:41,150 the question is not whether 1752 01:12:41,150 --> 01:12:44,150 oversight can work but rather 1753 01:12:44,920 --> 01:12:47,920 why did the oversight process 1754 01:12:48,490 --> 01:12:49,240 not work In the case of Bill pr 1755 01:12:49,240 --> 01:12:49,691 for three years? 1756 01:12:49,691 --> 01:12:50,292 San Diegans have filled this 1757 01:12:50,292 --> 01:12:52,692 chamber again and again. 1758 01:12:54,396 --> 01:12:55,960 Hundreds oppose the acquisition 1759 01:12:55,960 --> 01:12:55,764 of this dangerous technology. 1760 01:12:55,764 --> 01:12:58,164 More than 100 people spoke 1761 01:12:59,567 --> 01:12:59,935 right here in City Hall last 1762 01:12:59,935 --> 01:13:00,569 DECEMBER. 1763 01:13:00,569 --> 01:13:02,969 Advocates wrote their own 1764 01:13:03,938 --> 01:13:04,673 impact report mapped 1765 01:13:04,673 --> 01:13:08,273 the cameras out across the city 1766 01:13:08,410 --> 01:13:08,811 engaged in every step of 1767 01:13:08,811 --> 01:13:09,511 the process. 1768 01:13:09,511 --> 01:13:13,111 No city could ask for more 1769 01:13:13,549 --> 01:13:14,249 public participation and a 1770 01:13:14,249 --> 01:13:14,616 clear rejection than San Diego 1771 01:13:14,616 --> 01:13:16,616 have had. 1772 01:13:18,420 --> 01:13:19,121 Despite this, the majority of 1773 01:13:19,121 --> 01:13:19,722 this council continued to vote 1774 01:13:19,722 --> 01:13:20,550 to keep this technology 1775 01:13:20,550 --> 01:13:22,550 running. 1776 01:13:23,425 --> 01:13:24,920 While there are concerns about 1777 01:13:24,920 --> 01:13:27,920 how this technology is being 1778 01:13:27,796 --> 01:13:28,530 used by the Department, 1779 01:13:28,530 --> 01:13:28,931 the department is who oversight 1780 01:13:28,931 --> 01:13:30,931 is aimed at. 1781 01:13:33,350 --> 01:13:33,735 It proposes the technology, 1782 01:13:33,735 --> 01:13:37,335 defends it and reports on it. 1783 01:13:37,673 --> 01:13:38,373 It's the role its role in this 1784 01:13:38,373 --> 01:13:41,973 process is to be checked, not 1785 01:13:47,316 --> 01:13:48,830 to check itself further. 1786 01:13:48,830 --> 01:13:48,751 >> The Privacy Advisory Board 1787 01:13:48,751 --> 01:13:51,751 of Experts has made strong 1788 01:13:52,555 --> 01:13:52,955 recommendations against this 1789 01:13:52,955 --> 01:13:54,955 technology. 1790 01:13:57,393 --> 01:13:58,590 In JUNE 2023 that the pab voted 1791 01:13:58,590 --> 01:13:58,393 to reject this proposal as 1792 01:13:58,393 --> 01:13:59,930 written. 1793 01:13:59,930 --> 01:14:02,930 In AUGUST the Council approved 1794 01:14:02,665 --> 01:14:03,432 them anyway. 1795 01:14:03,432 --> 01:14:06,432 In APRIL 2025 they said this 1796 01:14:07,570 --> 01:14:11,373 use of all lpr data until four 1797 01:14:11,373 --> 01:14:11,840 amendments were made NOVEMBER 1798 01:14:11,840 --> 01:14:12,508 2025 cease use. 1799 01:14:12,508 --> 01:14:15,508 The Department and Block are 1800 01:14:15,678 --> 01:14:16,412 not in compliance with trust. 1801 01:14:16,412 --> 01:14:16,978 One week later the Public 1802 01:14:16,978 --> 01:14:18,978 Safety Committee voted 1803 01:14:20,415 --> 01:14:21,183 unanimously to set that aside. 1804 01:14:21,183 --> 01:14:23,583 In DECEMBER the Council 1805 01:14:24,620 --> 01:14:25,287 approved the policy 5 to 3 1806 01:14:25,287 --> 01:14:27,687 APRIL 2026 of this year. 1807 01:14:29,758 --> 01:14:32,758 They said reject continued use 1808 01:14:34,530 --> 01:14:35,164 unless and until auditing and 1809 01:14:35,164 --> 01:14:37,564 oversight to improve That 1810 01:14:38,333 --> 01:14:39,134 recommendation has waited six 1811 01:14:39,134 --> 01:14:39,702 and a half months until today. 1812 01:14:39,702 --> 01:14:42,102 So we are here. 1813 01:14:43,739 --> 01:14:44,473 The mayor has asked you all to 1814 01:14:44,473 --> 01:14:44,940 allow the established oversight 1815 01:14:44,940 --> 01:14:46,940 process to work. 1816 01:14:48,444 --> 01:14:51,444 It has worked four times. 1817 01:14:52,581 --> 01:14:53,182 Despite these recommendations, 1818 01:14:53,182 --> 01:14:53,849 each time the board and 1819 01:14:53,849 --> 01:14:54,517 the public urge you to stop 1820 01:14:54,517 --> 01:14:57,517 the majority of the council 1821 01:14:57,586 --> 01:15:01,186 defer to the department and to 1822 01:15:07,857 --> 01:15:10,857 those council members who defer 1823 01:15:18,690 --> 01:15:21,669 to the department at each half 1824 01:15:28,104 --> 01:15:28,266 measure. 1825 01:15:28,266 --> 01:15:28,457 You asked for like an rfp or an 1826 01:15:28,457 --> 01:15:28,619 amended annual report Another 1827 01:15:28,619 --> 01:15:28,790 audit. 1828 01:15:28,790 --> 01:15:28,964 It has still kept these cameras 1829 01:15:28,964 --> 01:15:29,141 running while the problems 1830 01:15:29,141 --> 01:15:29,310 continue to pile up. 1831 01:15:29,310 --> 01:15:29,476 We know it's not easy to come 1832 01:15:29,476 --> 01:15:29,638 out and say we made a mistake 1833 01:15:29,638 --> 01:15:29,805 So we welcome the change in 1834 01:15:29,805 --> 01:15:29,969 stance from many of you and we 1835 01:15:29,969 --> 01:15:30,140 hope that today we can make 1836 01:15:30,140 --> 01:15:30,315 sure that it doesn't happen 1837 01:15:30,315 --> 01:15:32,315 again. 1838 01:15:32,421 --> 01:15:33,122 >> That's why I thank you. 1839 01:15:33,122 --> 01:15:33,489 Seth Hall with the Trust City 1840 01:15:33,489 --> 01:15:35,489 Coalition. 1841 01:15:36,525 --> 01:15:37,226 That is why Omar Ruiz points 1842 01:15:37,226 --> 01:15:37,893 are why today we're asking for 1843 01:15:37,893 --> 01:15:40,930 more than just a vote to 1844 01:15:40,930 --> 01:15:41,264 rescind the use policy in other 1845 01:15:41,264 --> 01:15:41,897 cities. 1846 01:15:41,897 --> 01:15:45,497 We can look and see what 1847 01:15:45,868 --> 01:15:48,868 happens when city councils like 1848 01:15:56,720 --> 01:15:59,672 you do attempt to reject floc. 1849 01:16:06,273 --> 01:16:10,473 And what happens is not what a 1850 01:16:16,475 --> 01:16:20,750 lot of I think city leaders 1851 01:16:26,674 --> 01:16:29,674 think will happen in Eugene. 1852 01:16:36,874 --> 01:16:39,874 They ordered their cameras to 1853 01:16:46,680 --> 01:16:46,239 be shut down and it continued 1854 01:16:46,239 --> 01:16:46,404 to scan license plates for for 1855 01:16:46,404 --> 01:16:46,658 weeks and weeks on end. 1856 01:16:46,658 --> 01:16:46,835 In Springfield they deactivated 1857 01:16:46,835 --> 01:16:47,300 their cameras. 1858 01:16:47,300 --> 01:16:47,163 Foxx reactivated them on their 1859 01:16:47,163 --> 01:16:47,344 own. 1860 01:16:47,344 --> 01:16:47,504 In Cleveland they rejected 1861 01:16:47,504 --> 01:16:47,715 their renewal. 1862 01:16:47,715 --> 01:16:47,884 But then 100 cameras kept 1863 01:16:47,884 --> 01:16:48,380 rolling right in Los Angeles. 1864 01:16:48,380 --> 01:16:48,214 Our nearby neighbor. 1865 01:16:48,214 --> 01:16:48,388 100 cameras kept rolling. 1866 01:16:48,388 --> 01:16:48,562 Right. 1867 01:16:48,562 --> 01:16:48,726 In fact, there have been 1868 01:16:48,726 --> 01:16:48,899 incidents where Floc has 1869 01:16:48,899 --> 01:16:49,600 literally detected that their 1870 01:16:49,600 --> 01:16:49,220 cameras have been blocked and 1871 01:16:49,220 --> 01:16:49,380 have sent people out to unblock 1872 01:16:49,380 --> 01:16:49,534 them. 1873 01:16:49,534 --> 01:16:49,697 So we're asking for more than 1874 01:16:49,697 --> 01:16:49,868 that. 1875 01:16:49,868 --> 01:16:50,390 We don't want to tell San Diego 1876 01:16:50,390 --> 01:16:50,224 these cameras are off. 1877 01:16:50,224 --> 01:16:50,384 Just trust us. 1878 01:16:50,384 --> 01:16:50,548 I think that's asking 1879 01:16:50,548 --> 01:16:50,713 the public for faith that has 1880 01:16:50,713 --> 01:16:50,880 not been earned. 1881 01:16:50,880 --> 01:16:51,600 Nobody driving or walking by a 1882 01:16:51,600 --> 01:16:51,221 camera can tell whether it's 1883 01:16:51,221 --> 01:16:51,383 powered on. 1884 01:16:51,383 --> 01:16:51,543 They can only verify two things 1885 01:16:51,543 --> 01:16:54,300 and that's a camera that is 1886 01:16:54,300 --> 01:16:54,704 gone or maybe a camera that's 1887 01:16:54,704 --> 01:16:57,704 like covered by something that 1888 01:17:04,913 --> 01:17:05,124 we know they can't see through 1889 01:17:05,124 --> 01:17:05,306 . 1890 01:17:05,306 --> 01:17:05,464 It's important that we take a 1891 01:17:05,464 --> 01:17:05,629 stop real quick at 1892 01:17:05,629 --> 01:17:05,784 the ordinance and make sure 1893 01:17:05,784 --> 01:17:05,943 that we're respecting the law 1894 01:17:05,943 --> 01:17:06,100 today. 1895 01:17:06,100 --> 01:17:09,170 The ordinance is very specific 1896 01:17:09,170 --> 01:17:12,170 about what happens once city 1897 01:17:13,890 --> 01:17:13,890 council rescinds a use policy 1898 01:17:13,890 --> 01:17:14,490 or the use of that technology 1899 01:17:14,490 --> 01:17:16,890 is no longer authorized. 1900 01:17:18,394 --> 01:17:19,950 We wrote Grace periods into 1901 01:17:19,950 --> 01:17:19,796 this law in a couple of 1902 01:17:19,796 --> 01:17:22,796 different places but not here. 1903 01:17:22,799 --> 01:17:23,499 There's no grace period here. 1904 01:17:23,499 --> 01:17:25,899 So there's there's there's 1905 01:17:27,937 --> 01:17:28,570 accountability built into 1906 01:17:28,570 --> 01:17:32,170 the to the ordinance And I 1907 01:17:32,675 --> 01:17:33,342 think if city council cannot 1908 01:17:33,342 --> 01:17:35,742 establish clear direction to 1909 01:17:37,714 --> 01:17:38,481 make sure that the technology 1910 01:17:38,481 --> 01:17:39,182 is under control according to 1911 01:17:39,182 --> 01:17:42,182 the policy, then city council 1912 01:17:42,218 --> 01:17:42,819 is really leaving the public no 1913 01:17:42,819 --> 01:17:43,386 choice except to pursue 1914 01:17:43,386 --> 01:17:45,386 accountability through 1915 01:17:46,823 --> 01:17:47,557 the ordinance. 1916 01:17:47,557 --> 01:17:47,991 So we're asking for three 1917 01:17:47,991 --> 01:17:49,991 things today. 1918 01:17:51,894 --> 01:17:52,595 First of all, the council 1919 01:17:52,595 --> 01:17:55,595 the department is here letting 1920 01:17:56,232 --> 01:17:56,899 you know that according to 1921 01:17:56,899 --> 01:17:57,334 their use policy everything 1922 01:17:57,334 --> 01:17:59,334 here is fine. 1923 01:18:01,171 --> 01:18:01,871 And I think the public and I 1924 01:18:01,871 --> 01:18:02,538 hope that you will agree that 1925 01:18:02,538 --> 01:18:05,538 everything here is not fine 1926 01:18:06,750 --> 01:18:06,743 which means that there is a big 1927 01:18:06,743 --> 01:18:07,711 problem with this use policy 1928 01:18:07,711 --> 01:18:10,280 and this use policy needs to be 1929 01:18:10,280 --> 01:18:11,140 rescinded. 1930 01:18:11,140 --> 01:18:11,548 That means you need to reject 1931 01:18:11,548 --> 01:18:13,948 your approval of it. 1932 01:18:15,385 --> 01:18:16,860 But it's not enough to for you 1933 01:18:16,860 --> 01:18:19,860 to just reject your approval. 1934 01:18:19,823 --> 01:18:20,624 We ask that you please attach 1935 01:18:20,624 --> 01:18:24,224 to your motions or your illegal 1936 01:18:24,761 --> 01:18:25,495 ongoings here a vision that 1937 01:18:25,495 --> 01:18:26,129 expresses how the city is going 1938 01:18:26,129 --> 01:18:29,129 to take these cameras down 1939 01:18:29,833 --> 01:18:30,600 right? 1940 01:18:30,600 --> 01:18:31,234 We should we should be very 1941 01:18:31,234 --> 01:18:33,634 specific about not leaving 1942 01:18:34,971 --> 01:18:35,738 these cameras up because I 1943 01:18:35,738 --> 01:18:36,439 think many of you are going to 1944 01:18:36,439 --> 01:18:39,439 tell us your concerns with 1945 01:18:39,476 --> 01:18:40,210 these cameras today And it 1946 01:18:40,210 --> 01:18:43,546 doesn't make any sense for city 1947 01:18:43,546 --> 01:18:44,456 council members to tell us your 1948 01:18:44,456 --> 01:18:45,115 concerns about them, vote to 1949 01:18:45,115 --> 01:18:48,715 rescind the use policy and then 1950 01:18:49,486 --> 01:18:50,253 leave them up on the streets to 1951 01:18:50,253 --> 01:18:53,853 keep rolling for those harms to 1952 01:18:53,923 --> 01:18:54,624 keep accumulating for flock to 1953 01:18:54,624 --> 01:18:55,325 continue to have the data and 1954 01:18:55,325 --> 01:18:58,325 for whoever's getting the data 1955 01:18:58,328 --> 01:18:59,196 from flock to keep getting it. 1956 01:18:59,196 --> 01:19:03,366 For today I think we need to 1957 01:19:03,366 --> 01:19:04,000 express a serious vision for 1958 01:19:04,000 --> 01:19:04,701 taking these cameras down. 1959 01:19:04,701 --> 01:19:08,301 And sometimes I know it's hard 1960 01:19:08,672 --> 01:19:09,439 to take cameras down. 1961 01:19:09,439 --> 01:19:10,400 This contract we're going to 1962 01:19:10,400 --> 01:19:13,640 have to talk to the city 1963 01:19:19,164 --> 01:19:21,164 attorney. 1964 01:19:32,763 --> 01:19:33,581 I don't know. 1965 01:19:33,581 --> 01:19:33,976 We don't want to get involved 1966 01:19:33,976 --> 01:19:34,340 with that. 1967 01:19:34,340 --> 01:19:34,769 But the fact of the matter is 1968 01:19:34,769 --> 01:19:34,956 these cameras, if they cannot 1969 01:19:34,956 --> 01:19:35,122 be taken down today, then I 1970 01:19:35,122 --> 01:19:35,282 think we need to express a plan 1971 01:19:35,282 --> 01:19:35,455 for visually blocking them so 1972 01:19:35,455 --> 01:19:35,614 that the people of San Diego 1973 01:19:35,614 --> 01:19:35,787 can go about their lives 1974 01:19:35,787 --> 01:19:35,959 knowing that they are not under 1975 01:19:35,959 --> 01:19:36,117 the eye of this technology. 1976 01:19:36,117 --> 01:19:36,287 So we ask that you we ask that 1977 01:19:36,287 --> 01:19:37,634 you please rescind and remove 1978 01:19:37,634 --> 01:19:38,134 and also block them while they 1979 01:19:38,134 --> 01:19:38,902 are being removed. 1980 01:19:38,902 --> 01:19:41,905 The last thing I want to do is 1981 01:19:41,905 --> 01:19:42,272 make sure that we wrap with 1982 01:19:42,272 --> 01:19:42,973 gratitude. 1983 01:19:42,973 --> 01:19:45,973 Humaira opened our address to 1984 01:19:47,444 --> 01:19:48,111 you with gratitude and I want 1985 01:19:48,111 --> 01:19:48,978 to end it there as well. 1986 01:19:48,978 --> 01:19:51,748 I want to thank those of you 1987 01:19:51,748 --> 01:19:52,449 who worked to bring this item 1988 01:19:52,449 --> 01:19:56,490 up from committee where it had 1989 01:19:56,186 --> 01:19:56,787 been waiting for a long time. 1990 01:19:56,787 --> 01:19:57,488 We still believe in 1991 01:19:57,488 --> 01:19:58,880 the oversight ordinance and we 1992 01:19:58,880 --> 01:20:00,488 believe our city council 1993 01:20:01,492 --> 01:20:02,192 members are the right overseers 1994 01:20:02,192 --> 01:20:02,726 to act on this technology to 1995 01:20:02,726 --> 01:20:04,726 protect San Diegans. 1996 01:20:06,263 --> 01:20:07,300 We still believe in that. 1997 01:20:07,300 --> 01:20:10,300 To those members who have 1998 01:20:10,334 --> 01:20:11,100 historically supported 1999 01:20:11,100 --> 01:20:11,635 the privacy advisory boards 2000 01:20:11,635 --> 01:20:12,335 advice and have supported 2001 01:20:12,335 --> 01:20:14,735 the community's involvement in 2002 01:20:15,806 --> 01:20:16,573 this process, we thank you. 2003 01:20:16,573 --> 01:20:19,573 We hope that all council 2004 01:20:20,277 --> 01:20:20,577 members can join that club very 2005 01:20:20,577 --> 01:20:22,577 soon. 2006 01:20:24,815 --> 01:20:28,415 We also want to thank our 2007 01:20:29,252 --> 01:20:30,190 champions on the board and I'll 2008 01:20:30,190 --> 01:20:33,619 leave you with this quote from 2009 01:20:35,292 --> 01:20:35,993 a mayor in Knoxville who faced 2010 01:20:35,993 --> 01:20:36,693 the same problem has concluded 2011 01:20:36,693 --> 01:20:37,361 I did give you the addition of 2012 01:20:37,361 --> 01:20:39,761 Gannett from Sharon Larios. 2013 01:20:48,538 --> 01:20:49,600 She did Here. 2014 01:20:49,600 --> 01:20:49,640 >> Okay. 2015 01:20:49,640 --> 01:20:50,307 Gentle reminder those two 2016 01:20:50,307 --> 01:20:52,707 individuals were speaking on 2017 01:20:53,410 --> 01:20:54,144 your behalf and you kind of 2018 01:20:54,144 --> 01:20:54,845 encroached on their speech That 2019 01:20:54,845 --> 01:20:57,614 MAY have made it difficult for 2020 01:20:57,614 --> 01:20:58,482 us to hear. 2021 01:20:58,482 --> 01:20:58,949 Everybody else is only going to 2022 01:20:58,949 --> 01:21:00,949 have one minute. 2023 01:21:03,190 --> 01:21:03,720 So if you make a lot of noise 2024 01:21:03,720 --> 01:21:04,388 you're going to interfere with 2025 01:21:04,388 --> 01:21:07,324 them And I think that's just 2026 01:21:07,324 --> 01:21:08,570 courtesy to make sure they have 2027 01:21:08,570 --> 01:21:08,459 the full undivided attention by 2028 01:21:08,459 --> 01:21:10,459 the council. 2029 01:21:12,496 --> 01:21:16,960 So and we've done this last 2030 01:21:16,634 --> 01:21:17,434 time big controversial things. 2031 01:21:17,434 --> 01:21:18,135 Be respectful of your friends 2032 01:21:18,135 --> 01:21:21,135 and neighbors that are coming 2033 01:21:21,605 --> 01:21:22,272 out here to talk and let us 2034 01:21:22,272 --> 01:21:22,639 hear what they have to say. 2035 01:21:22,639 --> 01:21:23,600 Thank you. 2036 01:21:23,600 --> 01:21:25,600 Thank you. 2037 01:21:26,110 --> 01:21:26,810 Council PRESIDENT. 2038 01:21:26,810 --> 01:21:27,511 I'll be calling the following 2039 01:21:27,511 --> 01:21:30,548 individuals up and if they can 2040 01:21:30,548 --> 01:21:31,248 come to the reserved seats at 2041 01:21:31,248 --> 01:21:31,916 the front of the room so that 2042 01:21:31,916 --> 01:21:32,449 it can make it for better 2043 01:21:32,449 --> 01:21:34,449 meeting management. 2044 01:21:36,921 --> 01:21:37,521 It's my Rhonda Chavez if you 2045 01:21:37,521 --> 01:21:37,988 can please come up to 2046 01:21:37,988 --> 01:21:39,988 the microphone. 2047 01:21:41,425 --> 01:21:41,925 After that we have about to 2048 01:21:41,925 --> 01:21:42,393 resume Mondragon. 2049 01:21:42,393 --> 01:21:44,393 Brendan See ya. 2050 01:21:46,630 --> 01:21:49,630 Alex Blythe Uh, Jenny Faulkner 2051 01:21:51,680 --> 01:21:51,735 Lucky Aiden If you can all 2052 01:21:51,735 --> 01:21:52,200 please come up to the front 2053 01:21:52,200 --> 01:21:53,300 row. 2054 01:21:53,300 --> 01:21:55,206 It's cell If you can come up to 2055 01:21:55,206 --> 01:21:55,538 the microphone you'll have one 2056 01:21:55,538 --> 01:21:56,207 minute. 2057 01:21:56,207 --> 01:21:56,907 Please be sure to speak into 2058 01:21:56,907 --> 01:21:58,943 the mix of those participating 2059 01:21:58,943 --> 01:22:02,543 in the Zoom Can hear you. 2060 01:22:05,490 --> 01:22:05,449 Thank you. 2061 01:22:05,449 --> 01:22:05,850 Okay. 2062 01:22:05,850 --> 01:22:06,550 All right. 2063 01:22:06,550 --> 01:22:08,950 Well, good afternoon Council. 2064 01:22:09,219 --> 01:22:10,540 My name is esl Amanda Chavez. 2065 01:22:10,540 --> 01:22:10,888 I am a District three resident 2066 01:22:10,888 --> 01:22:14,291 and I'm here speaking out with 2067 01:22:14,291 --> 01:22:14,992 the people as a District three 2068 01:22:14,992 --> 01:22:15,826 resident for over five years. 2069 01:22:15,826 --> 01:22:18,762 I am here to specifically urge 2070 01:22:18,762 --> 01:22:19,630 you Council member Whitburn to 2071 01:22:19,630 --> 01:22:23,830 do the right thing and stand up 2072 01:22:23,934 --> 01:22:24,535 with us your constituents and 2073 01:22:24,535 --> 01:22:26,935 the people black, brown, 2074 01:22:28,720 --> 01:22:28,706 Muslim, lgbtq plus and 2075 01:22:28,706 --> 01:22:29,240 immigrant communities have 2076 01:22:29,240 --> 01:22:29,974 suffered the brunt. 2077 01:22:29,974 --> 01:22:31,974 These surveillance technologies 2078 01:22:33,444 --> 01:22:33,944 bring consequence as they have 2079 01:22:33,944 --> 01:22:34,377 been traumatic and 2080 01:22:34,377 --> 01:22:35,120 irreversible. 2081 01:22:35,120 --> 01:22:38,120 Council members you are up 2082 01:22:38,349 --> 01:22:39,160 there because we voted you 2083 01:22:39,160 --> 01:22:42,616 there and we the people need 2084 01:22:43,870 --> 01:22:43,754 you now more than ever to take 2085 01:22:43,754 --> 01:22:44,388 the necessary steps towards 2086 01:22:44,388 --> 01:22:46,788 taking these cameras down. 2087 01:22:48,425 --> 01:22:49,126 I know it's not lost on you 2088 01:22:49,126 --> 01:22:49,727 that we are living through an 2089 01:22:49,727 --> 01:22:52,127 era of surveillance and 2090 01:22:52,530 --> 01:22:52,964 surveillance in the wrong hands 2091 01:22:52,964 --> 01:22:53,798 can be fatal. 2092 01:22:53,798 --> 01:22:57,368 This is your opportunity to be 2093 01:22:57,368 --> 01:22:58,690 extraordinary in our county, in 2094 01:22:58,690 --> 01:22:58,769 our state and in our nation. 2095 01:22:58,769 --> 01:23:01,169 Council members, please leave 2096 01:23:02,573 --> 01:23:03,374 San Diego in a better direction 2097 01:23:03,374 --> 01:23:06,611 and do what you must do to end 2098 01:23:06,611 --> 01:23:07,311 the use of your technologies 2099 01:23:07,311 --> 01:23:07,779 and bring the cameras down. 2100 01:23:07,779 --> 01:23:09,779 >> Thank you. 2101 01:23:10,314 --> 01:23:12,714 But resume one Patricia 2102 01:23:15,987 --> 01:23:16,721 Mondragon Alliance San Diego 2103 01:23:16,721 --> 01:23:20,321 and Dh3 resident San Diego GYNs 2104 01:23:20,358 --> 01:23:21,125 cannot continue to be treated 2105 01:23:21,125 --> 01:23:24,725 like lab rats in sd this 2106 01:23:24,996 --> 01:23:25,863 experience with its own wish 2107 01:23:25,863 --> 01:23:26,496 list of tech toys for sd pd 2108 01:23:26,496 --> 01:23:28,896 These technologies are new 2109 01:23:30,368 --> 01:23:31,350 tools to test experiment with 2110 01:23:31,350 --> 01:23:31,702 and play around with before 2111 01:23:31,702 --> 01:23:34,102 the public fully understands 2112 01:23:35,539 --> 01:23:36,240 how they work, how they are 2113 01:23:36,240 --> 01:23:39,240 being used or more importantly 2114 01:23:39,810 --> 01:23:40,211 how they compromise our right 2115 01:23:40,211 --> 01:23:40,812 to privacy. 2116 01:23:40,812 --> 01:23:42,812 For San Diegans 2117 01:23:44,815 --> 01:23:45,116 the consequences are not a game 2118 01:23:45,116 --> 01:23:45,850 . 2119 01:23:45,850 --> 01:23:46,718 Just ask Hugo Barra who spent 2120 01:23:46,718 --> 01:23:49,921 nearly a month in jail after a 2121 01:23:49,921 --> 01:23:50,555 false flock Alper hit 2122 01:23:50,555 --> 01:23:50,855 wrongfully linked him to a 2123 01:23:50,855 --> 01:23:51,689 crime. 2124 01:23:51,689 --> 01:23:55,260 What this means is we are 2125 01:23:55,260 --> 01:23:55,626 creating a system where 2126 01:23:55,626 --> 01:23:55,994 technology can generate 2127 01:23:55,994 --> 01:23:56,563 suspicion. 2128 01:23:56,563 --> 01:23:58,963 Suspicion can lead to 2129 01:24:00,297 --> 01:24:01,320 incarceration and people are 2130 01:24:01,320 --> 01:24:01,466 left fighting to prove they did 2131 01:24:01,466 --> 01:24:03,466 nothing wrong. 2132 01:24:04,202 --> 01:24:04,903 This is not a technology or 2133 01:24:04,903 --> 01:24:05,570 public safety issue the right 2134 01:24:05,570 --> 01:24:08,570 to privacy, due process and 2135 01:24:09,440 --> 01:24:10,410 freedom from unjustified 2136 01:24:10,410 --> 01:24:10,742 government intrusion are 2137 01:24:10,742 --> 01:24:13,742 fundamental rights that do not 2138 01:24:14,245 --> 01:24:14,946 disappear because police 2139 01:24:14,946 --> 01:24:15,480 department wants to experiment 2140 01:24:15,480 --> 01:24:16,470 with new technology. 2141 01:24:16,470 --> 01:24:18,447 >> Thank you for that 2142 01:24:24,880 --> 01:24:24,723 concluding sentence Brandon. 2143 01:24:24,723 --> 01:24:25,560 >> Good afternoon Council 2144 01:24:25,560 --> 01:24:27,560 members. 2145 01:24:29,394 --> 01:24:30,940 My name is Brandon Segal and 2146 01:24:30,940 --> 01:24:30,795 I'm a senior policy advocate 2147 01:24:30,795 --> 01:24:31,300 for the aclu of San Diego and 2148 01:24:31,300 --> 01:24:33,300 Imperial Counties. 2149 01:24:33,698 --> 01:24:34,399 We're here once again to speak 2150 01:24:34,399 --> 01:24:35,660 out against the dystopian mass 2151 01:24:35,660 --> 01:24:37,660 surveillance currently being 2152 01:24:38,135 --> 01:24:38,903 funded by San Diego taxpayers. 2153 01:24:38,903 --> 01:24:39,270 I'm hoping the fifth time is 2154 01:24:39,270 --> 01:24:39,971 the charm. 2155 01:24:39,971 --> 01:24:42,807 The message to San Diego City 2156 01:24:42,807 --> 01:24:43,340 Council and Mayor Gloria has 2157 01:24:43,340 --> 01:24:43,775 been consistent and 2158 01:24:43,775 --> 01:24:44,442 unmistakable. 2159 01:24:44,442 --> 01:24:48,120 San Diegans do not want this 2160 01:24:48,120 --> 01:24:48,380 mass surveillance technology in 2161 01:24:48,380 --> 01:24:49,114 our city. 2162 01:24:49,114 --> 01:24:49,814 Thousands of people have signed 2163 01:24:49,814 --> 01:24:52,814 petitions and shown up calling 2164 01:24:54,218 --> 01:24:54,618 on the city to stop using lpr 2165 01:24:54,618 --> 01:24:55,320 technology. 2166 01:24:55,320 --> 01:24:57,755 Many former supporters of this 2167 01:24:57,755 --> 01:24:58,556 technology have already revoked 2168 01:24:58,556 --> 01:24:59,257 or walked back their support of 2169 01:24:59,257 --> 01:25:01,657 lpr including council members 2170 01:25:02,459 --> 01:25:03,194 Here with us today. 2171 01:25:03,194 --> 01:25:03,895 Recent reporting revealed that 2172 01:25:03,895 --> 01:25:06,831 hpr was used to track a police 2173 01:25:06,831 --> 01:25:07,198 officer in domestic violence 2174 01:25:07,198 --> 01:25:07,932 Survivor. 2175 01:25:07,932 --> 01:25:08,633 The Police Officers Association 2176 01:25:08,633 --> 01:25:11,633 then called for the technology 2177 01:25:14,910 --> 01:25:14,253 to not be used on its own 2178 01:25:14,253 --> 01:25:14,441 officers and reportedly 2179 01:25:14,441 --> 01:25:16,441 the city agreed. 2180 01:25:17,175 --> 01:25:17,709 You listen to the police 2181 01:25:17,709 --> 01:25:18,310 demands for privacy. 2182 01:25:18,310 --> 01:25:18,910 Will you listen to your 2183 01:25:18,910 --> 01:25:19,277 constituents demand for 2184 01:25:19,277 --> 01:25:21,277 the same? 2185 01:25:21,345 --> 01:25:22,120 We're here to demand immediate 2186 01:25:22,120 --> 01:25:22,681 action rescind the hpr, use 2187 01:25:22,681 --> 01:25:22,980 policy and take the cameras 2188 01:25:22,980 --> 01:25:24,980 down. 2189 01:25:25,784 --> 01:25:27,784 Thank you. 2190 01:25:31,156 --> 01:25:31,923 >> Alex Bly. 2191 01:25:31,923 --> 01:25:34,323 Good afternoon Council members. 2192 01:25:36,928 --> 01:25:37,661 My name is Alex Wyatt. 2193 01:25:37,661 --> 01:25:38,330 I'm a San Diego resident and 2194 01:25:38,330 --> 01:25:38,997 have worked in cybersecurity 2195 01:25:38,997 --> 01:25:40,398 software and ai for the past 2196 01:25:40,398 --> 01:25:41,266 decade. 2197 01:25:41,266 --> 01:25:41,966 I'm asking you to oppose item 2198 01:25:41,966 --> 01:25:44,366 200 Terminate the contract and 2199 01:25:45,300 --> 01:25:45,403 remove the hardware 2200 01:25:45,403 --> 01:25:46,104 immediately. 2201 01:25:46,104 --> 01:25:46,738 In 2017 data surpassed oil as 2202 01:25:46,738 --> 01:25:49,138 the world's most valuable 2203 01:25:50,342 --> 01:25:51,760 resource. 2204 01:25:51,760 --> 01:25:51,743 Fast forward today and Safety's 2205 01:25:51,743 --> 01:25:53,743 $8.4 billion valuation comes 2206 01:25:55,113 --> 01:25:55,814 directly from the data you 2207 01:25:55,814 --> 01:25:56,415 allow them to siphon off from 2208 01:25:56,415 --> 01:25:58,815 our communities and our 2209 01:25:59,985 --> 01:26:00,751 families and our data that we 2210 01:26:00,751 --> 01:26:01,520 do not opt into sharing is not 2211 01:26:01,520 --> 01:26:03,520 safe. 2212 01:26:03,421 --> 01:26:04,122 Recently hackers removed one 2213 01:26:04,122 --> 01:26:04,456 roadside camera and copy that 2214 01:26:04,456 --> 01:26:05,190 storage. 2215 01:26:05,190 --> 01:26:08,260 They found an encryption key to 2216 01:26:08,260 --> 01:26:08,360 unlock the data on the cameras 2217 01:26:08,360 --> 01:26:08,727 itself. 2218 01:26:08,727 --> 01:26:09,394 Not safe. 2219 01:26:09,394 --> 01:26:09,928 They use this to unlock 2220 01:26:09,928 --> 01:26:11,928 thousands of videos. 2221 01:26:12,264 --> 01:26:14,664 One camera logs show 1.6 2222 01:26:16,700 --> 01:26:17,350 million images in 21 day 2223 01:26:17,350 --> 01:26:17,736 period. 2224 01:26:17,736 --> 01:26:18,236 This hardware can read list as 2225 01:26:18,236 --> 01:26:20,236 hardware can live. 2226 01:26:21,407 --> 01:26:21,706 Streaming has been caught doing 2227 01:26:21,706 --> 01:26:22,441 so. 2228 01:26:22,441 --> 01:26:23,108 Floc is the largest locational 2229 01:26:23,108 --> 01:26:25,508 database of American public. 2230 01:26:26,770 --> 01:26:26,745 This is a critical 2231 01:26:26,745 --> 01:26:27,245 cybersecurity threat and San 2232 01:26:27,245 --> 01:26:27,812 Diego already is a 2233 01:26:27,812 --> 01:26:29,812 cybersecurity target. 2234 01:26:31,830 --> 01:26:31,749 Our communities, our family's 2235 01:26:31,749 --> 01:26:32,500 likeness and location is not 2236 01:26:32,500 --> 01:26:34,500 safe. 2237 01:26:40,625 --> 01:26:42,625 >> Thank you, Danica. 2238 01:26:44,196 --> 01:26:45,630 >> How I you to me in your way 2239 01:26:45,630 --> 01:26:45,364 I am Janika with Ally in San 2240 01:26:45,364 --> 01:26:45,998 Diego. 2241 01:26:45,998 --> 01:26:48,967 San Diego prides itself on 2242 01:26:48,967 --> 01:26:49,667 being America's finest city a 2243 01:26:49,667 --> 01:26:50,101 welcoming city and a sanctuary 2244 01:26:50,101 --> 01:26:52,101 city for all. 2245 01:26:53,171 --> 01:26:53,905 When we allow our immigrant 2246 01:26:53,905 --> 01:26:54,639 neighbors, families and friends 2247 01:26:54,639 --> 01:26:55,307 to be targeted and hunted using 2248 01:26:55,307 --> 01:26:57,707 predatory technology, we are 2249 01:26:58,343 --> 01:26:59,100 directly going against what we 2250 01:26:59,100 --> 01:26:59,645 represent ourselves as as a 2251 01:26:59,645 --> 01:27:02,645 proud member of the black 2252 01:27:03,748 --> 01:27:04,382 native and lgbt community. 2253 01:27:04,382 --> 01:27:05,160 I want us to recognize 2254 01:27:05,160 --> 01:27:07,416 the heightened danger this 2255 01:27:08,187 --> 01:27:08,854 technology brings for my 2256 01:27:08,854 --> 01:27:09,454 communities who are already 2257 01:27:09,454 --> 01:27:10,221 overpolicing over civil. 2258 01:27:10,221 --> 01:27:13,625 No one in San Diego should feel 2259 01:27:13,625 --> 01:27:14,293 scared to leave their homes or 2260 01:27:14,293 --> 01:27:14,893 fear retaliation from those 2261 01:27:14,893 --> 01:27:17,893 that claim to protect us 2262 01:27:18,130 --> 01:27:18,831 Throughout the nation we have 2263 01:27:18,831 --> 01:27:19,497 seen nearly over 300 cities in 2264 01:27:19,497 --> 01:27:21,897 their contract and dismantle 2265 01:27:22,568 --> 01:27:23,402 this predatory technology. 2266 01:27:23,402 --> 01:27:24,102 What are we saying to our most 2267 01:27:24,102 --> 01:27:26,502 vulnerable communities when we 2268 01:27:27,573 --> 01:27:28,240 ignore numerous violations and 2269 01:27:28,240 --> 01:27:30,640 abuses with this technology? 2270 01:27:31,744 --> 01:27:32,411 Counsel We ask that you take 2271 01:27:32,411 --> 01:27:33,112 appropriate action today and 2272 01:27:33,112 --> 01:27:36,112 move toward taking the cameras 2273 01:27:36,715 --> 01:27:37,316 down and show that we are truly 2274 01:27:37,316 --> 01:27:38,183 a city for all. 2275 01:27:38,183 --> 01:27:38,884 And I just want to say happy 2276 01:27:38,884 --> 01:27:41,284 Native American Heritage Day. 2277 01:27:46,457 --> 01:27:50,570 Thank you to Lucky Aiden and 2278 01:27:51,730 --> 01:27:52,431 good afternoon Council members 2279 01:27:52,431 --> 01:27:52,897 looking in District nine with 2280 01:27:52,897 --> 01:27:54,897 Pan and Trusty. 2281 01:27:56,402 --> 01:27:57,136 I'm here to urge you to do 2282 01:27:57,136 --> 01:27:57,803 three things Like I said cancel 2283 01:27:57,803 --> 01:28:00,803 a contract, reject the youth 2284 01:28:01,273 --> 01:28:01,674 policy and take down 2285 01:28:01,674 --> 01:28:02,308 the cameras. 2286 01:28:02,308 --> 01:28:02,908 We know that illegal pr is 2287 01:28:02,908 --> 01:28:05,308 essential for a federal 2288 01:28:05,611 --> 01:28:05,911 government to track our people 2289 01:28:05,911 --> 01:28:06,779 down. 2290 01:28:06,779 --> 01:28:09,515 A pr does not keep us safe. 2291 01:28:09,515 --> 01:28:10,115 It makes no sense to leave 2292 01:28:10,115 --> 01:28:10,816 the cameras up while we 2293 01:28:10,816 --> 01:28:11,116 restrict the youth here in San 2294 01:28:11,116 --> 01:28:13,116 Diego. 2295 01:28:14,586 --> 01:28:15,354 Communities have been asking 2296 01:28:15,354 --> 01:28:15,654 you for years to shut the lock 2297 01:28:15,654 --> 01:28:16,355 down. 2298 01:28:16,355 --> 01:28:19,355 When will you finally listen? 2299 01:28:20,125 --> 01:28:20,793 Is today the day when you put 2300 01:28:20,793 --> 01:28:21,126 community over surveillance 2301 01:28:21,126 --> 01:28:23,126 over it? 2302 01:28:25,300 --> 01:28:25,464 214 cities have terminated for 2303 01:28:25,464 --> 01:28:27,464 contract now. 2304 01:28:28,330 --> 01:28:28,667 Please help us remove these 2305 01:28:28,667 --> 01:28:29,680 contracts immediately and 2306 01:28:29,680 --> 01:28:31,680 follow suit. 2307 01:28:34,306 --> 01:28:35,174 >> Thank you. 2308 01:28:35,174 --> 01:28:35,940 If I can have Jermaine and 2309 01:28:35,940 --> 01:28:38,778 Rocha Galvan please come up to 2310 01:28:38,778 --> 01:28:39,445 the microphone after that we 2311 01:28:39,445 --> 01:28:41,845 have Patricia Serrano, Lily 2312 01:28:44,382 --> 01:28:45,150 Irani, Rihanna does Ariana 2313 01:28:45,150 --> 01:28:47,353 Dixit, Kevin Vento and Megan 2314 01:28:47,353 --> 01:28:48,220 Ibarra. 2315 01:28:48,220 --> 01:28:51,820 >> If you can all please come 2316 01:28:52,358 --> 01:28:52,824 forward to the front row. 2317 01:28:52,824 --> 01:28:54,824 Good afternoon. 2318 01:28:58,197 --> 01:28:58,664 My name is Patricia Serrano and 2319 01:28:58,664 --> 01:28:59,231 I would further. 2320 01:28:59,231 --> 01:29:02,231 Over the years we have 2321 01:29:02,501 --> 01:29:03,235 increasingly seen the floor. 2322 01:29:03,235 --> 01:29:03,702 Cameras do not necessarily make 2323 01:29:03,702 --> 01:29:05,702 San Diego safer. 2324 01:29:07,639 --> 01:29:08,340 In fact, over the past two 2325 01:29:08,340 --> 01:29:09,800 years the surveillance systems 2326 01:29:09,800 --> 01:29:11,408 raise serious concerns about 2327 01:29:11,877 --> 01:29:12,545 their use by Department of 2328 01:29:12,545 --> 01:29:13,212 Homeland Security and their 2329 01:29:13,212 --> 01:29:16,212 potential impact in our most 2330 01:29:16,649 --> 01:29:17,316 vulnerable communities 2331 01:29:17,316 --> 01:29:19,316 including domestic violence 2332 01:29:21,687 --> 01:29:22,220 survivors, immigrants, Muslims 2333 01:29:22,220 --> 01:29:22,922 and black residents. 2334 01:29:22,922 --> 01:29:26,225 Do you believe that is an 2335 01:29:26,225 --> 01:29:26,892 appropriate use of taxpayer 2336 01:29:26,892 --> 01:29:27,527 money especially when these 2337 01:29:27,527 --> 01:29:29,927 systems can put vulnerable 2338 01:29:32,980 --> 01:29:32,664 community at risk undermining 2339 01:29:32,664 --> 01:29:35,640 their sense of safety? 2340 01:29:36,602 --> 01:29:37,236 We all knew that a city council 2341 01:29:37,236 --> 01:29:39,636 two canceling the contract 2342 01:29:41,174 --> 01:29:41,807 would flag take down 2343 01:29:41,807 --> 01:29:42,441 the cameras and all other 2344 01:29:42,441 --> 01:29:44,441 surveillance systems that 2345 01:29:46,345 --> 01:29:46,945 threaten the privacy, safety 2346 01:29:46,945 --> 01:29:47,346 and civil rights of our 2347 01:29:47,346 --> 01:29:49,346 communities. 2348 01:29:53,920 --> 01:29:54,520 >> Thank you, Jermaine. 2349 01:29:54,520 --> 01:29:55,188 >> Hello everyone. 2350 01:29:55,188 --> 01:29:55,488 My name is Jermaine Rocha 2351 01:29:55,488 --> 01:29:57,488 Corba. 2352 01:29:57,756 --> 01:29:58,391 I work for the Partnership for 2353 01:29:58,391 --> 01:29:59,910 the Advancement of New 2354 01:29:59,910 --> 01:30:01,928 Americans in District nine and 2355 01:30:01,928 --> 01:30:02,361 my family currently lives in 2356 01:30:02,361 --> 01:30:03,162 District four. 2357 01:30:03,162 --> 01:30:06,966 I'm here today to urge you to 2358 01:30:06,966 --> 01:30:07,700 vote against item 200. 2359 01:30:07,700 --> 01:30:10,700 >> I'm asking you to please 2360 01:30:12,805 --> 01:30:13,473 cancel not just lpas but cancel 2361 01:30:13,473 --> 01:30:16,676 you because you are as well. 2362 01:30:16,676 --> 01:30:19,912 What a tough budget year We as 2363 01:30:19,912 --> 01:30:20,880 a community of ask you the past 2364 01:30:20,880 --> 01:30:24,480 three years to shut down Not 2365 01:30:25,585 --> 01:30:26,285 only that we're asking you to 2366 01:30:26,285 --> 01:30:28,685 prioritize our communities by 2367 01:30:29,689 --> 01:30:30,456 reinvesting in true public 2368 01:30:30,456 --> 01:30:31,124 safety like our parks, like our 2369 01:30:31,124 --> 01:30:31,457 libraries and youth drop in 2370 01:30:31,457 --> 01:30:33,457 centers. 2371 01:30:35,527 --> 01:30:35,862 This these are true signs of 2372 01:30:35,862 --> 01:30:37,862 safety. 2373 01:30:40,634 --> 01:30:41,300 I urge you to please please 2374 01:30:41,300 --> 01:30:43,690 shut off, lock down, cancel 2375 01:30:43,690 --> 01:30:46,669 your school and please cut the 2376 01:30:48,240 --> 01:30:49,142 out. 2377 01:30:49,142 --> 01:30:49,809 >> Thank you so much And I hope 2378 01:30:49,809 --> 01:30:50,209 you continue to protect our 2379 01:30:50,209 --> 01:30:52,209 communities. 2380 01:30:55,114 --> 01:30:55,715 Thank you, Lily Irani. 2381 01:30:55,715 --> 01:30:56,182 >> All right. 2382 01:30:56,182 --> 01:30:58,182 Hi, everybody. 2383 01:31:00,219 --> 01:31:00,920 I want to share some lessons 2384 01:31:00,920 --> 01:31:01,921 from our own tech history here 2385 01:31:01,921 --> 01:31:05,240 in San Diego and why we need to 2386 01:31:05,240 --> 01:31:05,625 take the cameras down. 2387 01:31:05,625 --> 01:31:05,992 >> Remember ge, General 2388 01:31:05,992 --> 01:31:07,992 Electric? 2389 01:31:09,495 --> 01:31:10,960 They partnered with this city 2390 01:31:10,960 --> 01:31:10,763 to launch the smart 2391 01:31:10,763 --> 01:31:13,763 streetlights as a global pr 2392 01:31:14,567 --> 01:31:15,235 play that used us as a testbed 2393 01:31:15,235 --> 01:31:15,635 for untested and ultimately 2394 01:31:15,635 --> 01:31:17,635 broken air. 2395 01:31:19,339 --> 01:31:20,390 That was our street lights one. 2396 01:31:20,390 --> 01:31:20,739 We were promised parking space 2397 01:31:20,739 --> 01:31:23,739 detection but we got 24 seven 2398 01:31:24,444 --> 01:31:25,440 sd pd surveillance that was 2399 01:31:25,440 --> 01:31:25,745 used against protesters. 2400 01:31:25,745 --> 01:31:29,415 But it was all about the money 2401 01:31:29,415 --> 01:31:30,490 for ge So ge sold our Smart 2402 01:31:30,490 --> 01:31:30,582 Street Lights system to a 2403 01:31:30,582 --> 01:31:32,582 private equity firm. 2404 01:31:33,953 --> 01:31:34,620 >> And in that private equity 2405 01:31:34,620 --> 01:31:35,880 firm sold our smart street 2406 01:31:35,880 --> 01:31:37,880 light system to. 2407 01:31:38,691 --> 01:31:39,292 When the city canceled that 2408 01:31:39,292 --> 01:31:39,959 first Ubiquiti contract, 2409 01:31:39,959 --> 01:31:42,359 Ubiquiti actually refused to 2410 01:31:43,929 --> 01:31:44,297 shut down the cameras, if you 2411 01:31:44,297 --> 01:31:45,310 remember. 2412 01:31:45,310 --> 01:31:45,798 This is not a new floc problem 2413 01:31:45,798 --> 01:31:48,535 although it's a big flock 2414 01:31:48,535 --> 01:31:49,269 problem. 2415 01:31:49,269 --> 01:31:49,969 Tech surveillance companies 2416 01:31:49,969 --> 01:31:52,969 have the same business models 2417 01:31:53,873 --> 01:31:54,607 Grab data from our streets, 2418 01:31:54,607 --> 01:31:55,750 monetize new air products, make 2419 01:31:55,750 --> 01:31:57,750 investors happy. 2420 01:31:58,845 --> 01:31:59,445 It pays for them to drag their 2421 01:31:59,445 --> 01:31:59,813 feet when we cancel our 2422 01:31:59,813 --> 01:32:00,480 contracts. 2423 01:32:00,480 --> 01:32:00,780 So that's why we got to take 2424 01:32:00,780 --> 01:32:01,481 care. 2425 01:32:01,481 --> 01:32:01,848 Thank you for that concluding 2426 01:32:01,848 --> 01:32:03,848 sentence. 2427 01:32:06,190 --> 01:32:06,786 Rihanna. 2428 01:32:06,786 --> 01:32:07,120 >> Good afternoon Council 2429 01:32:07,120 --> 01:32:09,120 members. 2430 01:32:10,990 --> 01:32:11,658 My name is Rihanna Doss and I'm 2431 01:32:11,658 --> 01:32:12,425 speaking to you as a student 2432 01:32:12,425 --> 01:32:15,261 here at uc San Diego as well as 2433 01:32:15,261 --> 01:32:15,595 a constituent of council member 2434 01:32:15,595 --> 01:32:16,363 LaCava. 2435 01:32:16,363 --> 01:32:16,996 I also am a policy advocate for 2436 01:32:16,996 --> 01:32:19,396 the Syrian Civil Liberties 2437 01:32:19,866 --> 01:32:20,667 Union. 2438 01:32:20,667 --> 01:32:21,301 As our elected representatives 2439 01:32:21,301 --> 01:32:22,680 it is your duty and your 2440 01:32:22,680 --> 01:32:25,680 obligation to defend our civil 2441 01:32:25,572 --> 01:32:26,339 liberties. 2442 01:32:26,339 --> 01:32:26,973 Voting to keep Floc rolling in 2443 01:32:26,973 --> 01:32:29,876 San Diego is the absolute 2444 01:32:29,876 --> 01:32:30,576 antithesis of that block has 2445 01:32:30,576 --> 01:32:31,244 larger cities lie to the media 2446 01:32:31,244 --> 01:32:34,244 and most importantly lie to 2447 01:32:34,580 --> 01:32:35,348 the people. 2448 01:32:35,348 --> 01:32:35,982 My peers, my neighbors have 2449 01:32:35,982 --> 01:32:38,382 been violently abducted at 2450 01:32:39,510 --> 01:32:39,719 the grubby hands of Floc and 2451 01:32:39,719 --> 01:32:40,387 families that have voted for 2452 01:32:40,387 --> 01:32:40,787 you are afraid to even leave 2453 01:32:40,787 --> 01:32:42,787 their homes. 2454 01:32:44,570 --> 01:32:44,724 It is floc job to cater to 2455 01:32:44,724 --> 01:32:45,425 their investors and to turn 2456 01:32:45,425 --> 01:32:48,362 revenue at our expense And it 2457 01:32:48,362 --> 01:32:48,995 is your job to be our 2458 01:32:48,995 --> 01:32:49,662 constitutionally ordained 2459 01:32:49,662 --> 01:32:51,662 protected stronghold against 2460 01:32:53,633 --> 01:32:54,401 such transparent corruption. 2461 01:32:54,401 --> 01:32:55,101 >> Do your job Council members 2462 01:32:55,101 --> 01:32:58,701 keep logging out of San Diego. 2463 01:33:02,676 --> 01:33:03,710 Thank you Aria and accept. 2464 01:33:03,710 --> 01:33:07,310 >> Hello my name is Orian and 2465 01:33:07,314 --> 01:33:08,140 the executive director of 2466 01:33:08,140 --> 01:33:08,715 Students Civil Liberties Union 2467 01:33:08,715 --> 01:33:11,115 and Member Representative for 2468 01:33:11,817 --> 01:33:12,219 the Working Families Party of 2469 01:33:12,219 --> 01:33:13,186 San Diego. 2470 01:33:13,186 --> 01:33:17,157 I guess I can start off by 2471 01:33:17,157 --> 01:33:18,240 saying that the most that sd pd 2472 01:33:18,240 --> 01:33:18,725 has ever said the get clean 2473 01:33:18,725 --> 01:33:21,895 can has done for the city. 2474 01:33:21,895 --> 01:33:22,595 It's all of a bunch of vehicle 2475 01:33:22,595 --> 01:33:23,296 robberies all while detaining 2476 01:33:23,296 --> 01:33:26,896 San Diegans on the pretext of 2477 01:33:27,234 --> 01:33:27,967 surveilling domestic abuse 2478 01:33:27,967 --> 01:33:28,668 victims and of course providing 2479 01:33:28,668 --> 01:33:31,668 critical movement data of our 2480 01:33:32,500 --> 01:33:32,705 San Diego and residents to 2481 01:33:32,705 --> 01:33:33,373 overseas contractors, federal 2482 01:33:33,373 --> 01:33:33,807 agencies and police employed 2483 01:33:33,807 --> 01:33:35,807 vengeful exes. 2484 01:33:37,277 --> 01:33:38,110 So I have a big problem with 2485 01:33:38,110 --> 01:33:40,411 the surveillance network itself 2486 01:33:41,315 --> 01:33:41,981 and I think it's it's 2487 01:33:41,981 --> 01:33:42,649 the epitome of burning down 2488 01:33:42,649 --> 01:33:46,860 the house to kill a spider. 2489 01:33:46,860 --> 01:33:46,720 And I think that this entire 2490 01:33:46,720 --> 01:33:47,287 system is just essentially 2491 01:33:47,287 --> 01:33:50,287 making it so much more 2492 01:33:50,958 --> 01:33:51,558 difficult for us to voice our 2493 01:33:51,558 --> 01:33:52,226 concerns to you for our 2494 01:33:52,226 --> 01:33:52,826 immigrants and resident San 2495 01:33:52,826 --> 01:33:55,826 Diego and to voice their 2496 01:33:56,229 --> 01:33:56,796 concerns that we need to cancel 2497 01:33:56,796 --> 01:33:57,463 the contract with you, 2498 01:33:57,463 --> 01:34:00,634 the cover the cameras and we 2499 01:34:00,634 --> 01:34:01,435 need to make sure that this 2500 01:34:01,435 --> 01:34:01,701 city is block free So get the 2501 01:34:01,701 --> 01:34:02,502 out. 2502 01:34:02,502 --> 01:34:05,380 >> Thank you so much, Kevin 2503 01:34:05,380 --> 01:34:05,806 Vento. 2504 01:34:05,806 --> 01:34:08,806 >> After Kevin will have Megan 2505 01:34:10,760 --> 01:34:12,476 Ibarra, Ethan Kwong, Logan 2506 01:34:15,349 --> 01:34:15,682 King, Raya Aurora and Alex 2507 01:34:15,682 --> 01:34:16,316 Blight. 2508 01:34:16,316 --> 01:34:18,719 That is a duplicate unless 2509 01:34:18,719 --> 01:34:19,186 there's a second Alex Blake 2510 01:34:19,186 --> 01:34:21,186 please proceed. 2511 01:34:23,723 --> 01:34:24,491 >> Thank you, Counsel. 2512 01:34:24,491 --> 01:34:25,192 I just want to go ahead and 2513 01:34:25,192 --> 01:34:25,926 start by saying I am very 2514 01:34:25,926 --> 01:34:28,562 appreciative of all the council 2515 01:34:28,562 --> 01:34:29,296 members who have said that they 2516 01:34:29,296 --> 01:34:29,996 are committed to changing their 2517 01:34:29,996 --> 01:34:32,996 vote from their previous votes 2518 01:34:33,167 --> 01:34:33,900 in the past. 2519 01:34:33,900 --> 01:34:34,601 They're very thankful for that 2520 01:34:34,601 --> 01:34:35,369 And I do think that, you know, 2521 01:34:35,369 --> 01:34:38,337 we will have the votes and that 2522 01:34:38,337 --> 01:34:38,705 is you know, much more of a 2523 01:34:38,705 --> 01:34:39,373 formality. 2524 01:34:39,373 --> 01:34:42,710 But it's all those who have 2525 01:34:42,710 --> 01:34:43,344 voted against us for throughout 2526 01:34:43,344 --> 01:34:43,977 the three years were that 2527 01:34:43,977 --> 01:34:44,712 garners a certain level of 2528 01:34:44,712 --> 01:34:46,880 trust and integrity that cannot 2529 01:34:46,880 --> 01:34:47,781 be replaced on this council. 2530 01:34:47,781 --> 01:34:52,581 And so it is not just about we 2531 01:34:52,886 --> 01:34:53,653 do not come here just because 2532 01:34:53,653 --> 01:34:54,220 of in our systems and what 2533 01:34:54,220 --> 01:34:56,523 flock has been doing. 2534 01:34:56,523 --> 01:34:57,157 We will come out again if 2535 01:34:57,157 --> 01:34:57,858 the city takes down these 2536 01:34:57,858 --> 01:35:01,395 cameras and then puts them up 2537 01:35:01,395 --> 01:35:02,262 under a new name like Motorola. 2538 01:35:02,262 --> 01:35:02,630 We do not want that to be 2539 01:35:02,630 --> 01:35:04,630 the case. 2540 01:35:06,233 --> 01:35:06,934 We also are against what Flock 2541 01:35:06,934 --> 01:35:07,534 is doing with the flock nova 2542 01:35:07,534 --> 01:35:08,680 system which the city is 2543 01:35:08,680 --> 01:35:10,680 piloting right now. 2544 01:35:11,105 --> 01:35:11,805 These are also high powered 2545 01:35:11,805 --> 01:35:12,506 mass surveillance systems that 2546 01:35:12,506 --> 01:35:15,876 the city does not want and why 2547 01:35:15,876 --> 01:35:16,644 we have come out here and we 2548 01:35:16,644 --> 01:35:17,343 will come out in the future if 2549 01:35:17,343 --> 01:35:17,912 these are what the city rolls 2550 01:35:17,912 --> 01:35:18,412 out if they take down 2551 01:35:18,412 --> 01:35:20,412 the cameras today. 2552 01:35:21,348 --> 01:35:22,150 And so I just want to make that 2553 01:35:22,150 --> 01:35:22,616 clear that this is also what 2554 01:35:22,616 --> 01:35:25,616 many of us are against. 2555 01:35:25,819 --> 01:35:27,819 >> Thank you, Megan. 2556 01:35:30,991 --> 01:35:31,692 Esteemed council members. 2557 01:35:31,692 --> 01:35:32,326 >> My name is Megan. 2558 01:35:32,326 --> 01:35:32,893 You are the vice chair of 2559 01:35:32,893 --> 01:35:35,293 the San Diego Faculty 2560 01:35:35,763 --> 01:35:36,397 Association representing over 2561 01:35:36,397 --> 01:35:38,397 2000 ucsd faculty members. 2562 01:35:40,301 --> 01:35:41,100 Ucsd is an international hub 2563 01:35:41,100 --> 01:35:41,602 for research, medical services 2564 01:35:41,602 --> 01:35:44,602 and the arts An emerging 2565 01:35:45,272 --> 01:35:45,973 Hispanic serving institution 2566 01:35:45,973 --> 01:35:46,640 with the contract City Council 2567 01:35:46,640 --> 01:35:49,400 prioritized stolen cars over 2568 01:35:50,343 --> 01:35:50,911 people stolen by ice. 2569 01:35:50,911 --> 01:35:51,578 That's a false choice. 2570 01:35:51,578 --> 01:35:52,246 San Diego's crime rates have 2571 01:35:52,246 --> 01:35:55,181 dropped at similar rates as 2572 01:35:55,181 --> 01:35:55,883 other California cities that 2573 01:35:55,883 --> 01:35:56,550 don't use floc Every day over 2574 01:35:56,550 --> 01:35:58,550 60,000 students, staff and 2575 01:36:00,354 --> 01:36:01,550 faculty commute to ucsd flock 2576 01:36:01,550 --> 01:36:04,550 cameras increase their risk of 2577 01:36:04,325 --> 01:36:05,250 ice kidnapings and misuse 2578 01:36:05,250 --> 01:36:05,759 including surveilling domestic 2579 01:36:05,759 --> 01:36:08,159 violence survivors and tracking 2580 01:36:09,300 --> 01:36:09,396 people receiving care at ucsd 2581 01:36:09,396 --> 01:36:10,970 hospitals. 2582 01:36:10,970 --> 01:36:10,664 The city has broken our trust 2583 01:36:10,664 --> 01:36:13,664 and made us less safe. 2584 01:36:14,335 --> 01:36:14,669 Turning the cameras off is not 2585 01:36:14,669 --> 01:36:15,336 enough. 2586 01:36:15,336 --> 01:36:18,472 The only solution is to take 2587 01:36:18,472 --> 01:36:19,240 the cameras down permanently So 2588 01:36:19,240 --> 01:36:19,907 we can all see that this 2589 01:36:19,907 --> 01:36:21,909 harmful technology is gone. 2590 01:36:21,909 --> 01:36:23,909 Thank you. 2591 01:36:27,548 --> 01:36:27,982 Thank you, Ethan. 2592 01:36:27,982 --> 01:36:28,649 Good evening. 2593 01:36:28,649 --> 01:36:29,116 City Council San Diego City 2594 01:36:29,116 --> 01:36:31,116 Council Members. 2595 01:36:32,219 --> 01:36:32,787 My name is Ethan Kwong and I 2596 01:36:32,787 --> 01:36:33,487 represent the student 2597 01:36:33,487 --> 01:36:37,870 government at uc San Diego As 2598 01:36:37,458 --> 01:36:37,791 the vice PRESIDENT Of local 2599 01:36:37,791 --> 01:36:38,359 Affairs. 2600 01:36:38,359 --> 01:36:38,926 We serve around 45,000 2601 01:36:38,926 --> 01:36:39,293 undergrad and graduate 2602 01:36:39,293 --> 01:36:41,293 students. 2603 01:36:42,763 --> 01:36:43,463 And last week we published a 2604 01:36:43,463 --> 01:36:44,198 survey among our student body 2605 01:36:44,198 --> 01:36:46,800 regarding the opinions of light 2606 01:36:46,800 --> 01:36:47,535 cameras. 2607 01:36:47,535 --> 01:36:49,935 Among the survey respondents 2608 01:36:51,272 --> 01:36:51,939 around over 86% on a scale of 1 2609 01:36:51,939 --> 01:36:52,573 to 5 strongly disagreed that 2610 01:36:52,573 --> 01:36:54,973 they were comfortable with 2611 01:36:56,430 --> 01:36:56,810 the presence of cameras. 2612 01:36:56,810 --> 01:36:57,277 I'm not here to present an 2613 01:36:57,277 --> 01:36:57,945 opinion but take 2614 01:36:57,945 --> 01:37:00,915 the information as you will. 2615 01:37:00,915 --> 01:37:01,582 Will you choose to present or 2616 01:37:01,582 --> 01:37:04,582 to represent the opinions of 2617 01:37:06,120 --> 01:37:06,788 your student council members of 2618 01:37:06,788 --> 01:37:07,522 your esteemed constituents? 2619 01:37:07,522 --> 01:37:10,192 And to Joe LaCava 45,000 people 2620 01:37:10,192 --> 01:37:10,858 go to uc San Diego. 2621 01:37:10,858 --> 01:37:11,291 >> Will you present their 2622 01:37:11,291 --> 01:37:11,658 voices today? 2623 01:37:11,658 --> 01:37:12,260 Thank you. 2624 01:37:12,260 --> 01:37:14,260 Thank you. 2625 01:37:14,395 --> 01:37:16,395 Logan Kane. 2626 01:37:19,467 --> 01:37:20,134 >> Good afternoon. 2627 01:37:20,134 --> 01:37:20,968 My name is Logan King. 2628 01:37:20,968 --> 01:37:24,439 I am a lawyer resident and also 2629 01:37:24,439 --> 01:37:25,138 a uc San Diego student. 2630 01:37:25,138 --> 01:37:25,740 Um while I recognize 2631 01:37:25,740 --> 01:37:28,140 the potential utility of 2632 01:37:29,310 --> 01:37:30,110 loopers to find criminals and 2633 01:37:30,110 --> 01:37:30,578 missing persons I believe that 2634 01:37:30,578 --> 01:37:31,279 any sort of government 2635 01:37:31,279 --> 01:37:33,679 surveillance should come under 2636 01:37:34,315 --> 01:37:35,160 the highest possible public 2637 01:37:35,160 --> 01:37:35,783 scrutiny and its benefits must 2638 01:37:35,783 --> 01:37:39,383 far outweigh its risks and its 2639 01:37:39,487 --> 01:37:40,187 proprietors must be trusted and 2640 01:37:40,187 --> 01:37:40,587 not feared by the very people 2641 01:37:40,587 --> 01:37:42,587 it protects. 2642 01:37:43,858 --> 01:37:44,659 As cbd has failed in these 2643 01:37:44,659 --> 01:37:45,193 areas in my opinion they have 2644 01:37:45,193 --> 01:37:45,893 lost public trust by 2645 01:37:45,893 --> 01:37:48,293 accidentally sharing lpr with 2646 01:37:49,300 --> 01:37:49,697 ice and Border Patrol blindly 2647 01:37:49,697 --> 01:37:52,697 trusting in and resulting in 2648 01:37:53,634 --> 01:37:54,501 the shooting of an innocent man 2649 01:37:54,501 --> 01:37:55,136 and now argue can be used in 2650 01:37:55,136 --> 01:37:55,603 non-criminal cases which i 2651 01:37:55,603 --> 01:37:57,603 think is wrong. 2652 01:37:58,873 --> 01:37:59,407 Proposed policy modifications 2653 01:37:59,407 --> 01:38:00,740 here are just simply 2654 01:38:00,740 --> 01:38:02,474 insufficient to restore this 2655 01:38:03,811 --> 01:38:04,512 trust and the technology is too 2656 01:38:04,512 --> 01:38:07,512 dangerous to be regulated via 2657 01:38:08,749 --> 01:38:09,150 trial and error has stopped has 2658 01:38:09,150 --> 01:38:09,917 has done. 2659 01:38:09,917 --> 01:38:10,585 Not to mention it is being 2660 01:38:10,585 --> 01:38:13,585 sought by a private company. 2661 01:38:14,555 --> 01:38:15,356 Just this year scotus ruled in 2662 01:38:15,356 --> 01:38:18,956 JANUARY the us that cell phone 2663 01:38:19,126 --> 01:38:19,827 location data is required by 2664 01:38:19,827 --> 01:38:20,696 the Fourth Amendment to have a 2665 01:38:20,696 --> 01:38:24,296 law that concluding come in Ray 2666 01:38:31,305 --> 01:38:31,906 Aurora Hi Council members My 2667 01:38:31,906 --> 01:38:32,673 name is Ray Aurora. 2668 01:38:32,673 --> 01:38:33,274 I'm a resident of District One, 2669 01:38:33,274 --> 01:38:33,908 the project manager for 2670 01:38:33,908 --> 01:38:35,776 the Students All Liberties 2671 01:38:35,776 --> 01:38:36,478 Union as well as the us Vice 2672 01:38:36,478 --> 01:38:36,978 PRESIDENT Of Equity Diversity 2673 01:38:36,978 --> 01:38:38,978 Inclusion at ucsd. 2674 01:38:40,180 --> 01:38:40,882 Thank you to the council 2675 01:38:40,882 --> 01:38:41,482 members who have been loyal to 2676 01:38:41,482 --> 01:38:42,116 the cause from the very 2677 01:38:42,116 --> 01:38:44,586 beginning and thank you to 2678 01:38:44,586 --> 01:38:45,219 those who humbly change their 2679 01:38:45,219 --> 01:38:45,586 positions and supported us 2680 01:38:45,586 --> 01:38:46,321 later on. 2681 01:38:46,321 --> 01:38:49,857 As much as I enjoy skipping 2682 01:38:49,857 --> 01:38:50,592 class to come speak to you all 2683 01:38:50,592 --> 01:38:51,526 I would really appreciate it if 2684 01:38:51,526 --> 01:38:55,130 we could put this to an end and 2685 01:38:55,130 --> 01:38:55,630 the contracted way so we can 2686 01:38:55,630 --> 01:38:56,331 all finally rest. 2687 01:38:56,331 --> 01:38:59,000 NOVEMBER 3rd this year showed 2688 01:38:59,000 --> 01:38:59,500 us a beacon of hope for 2689 01:38:59,500 --> 01:39:00,201 the coming years. 2690 01:39:00,201 --> 01:39:00,602 It showed us that the people 2691 01:39:00,602 --> 01:39:02,602 have power. 2692 01:39:04,720 --> 01:39:04,938 So let it please be shown here 2693 01:39:04,938 --> 01:39:05,607 in San Diego to show us that 2694 01:39:05,607 --> 01:39:06,374 our voices matter to you And 2695 01:39:06,374 --> 01:39:08,843 our politicians are not just 2696 01:39:08,843 --> 01:39:09,143 full of empty promises once 2697 01:39:09,143 --> 01:39:09,711 again. 2698 01:39:09,711 --> 01:39:12,111 >> Get the flock out. 2699 01:39:13,114 --> 01:39:13,682 Thank you. 2700 01:39:13,682 --> 01:39:14,415 >> Thank you. 2701 01:39:14,415 --> 01:39:17,415 And just confirming that there 2702 01:39:18,530 --> 01:39:18,620 is not a second Alex Blythe. 2703 01:39:18,620 --> 01:39:18,920 It's just a doop. 2704 01:39:18,920 --> 01:39:20,920 Okay. 2705 01:39:22,222 --> 01:39:22,891 After that if we can have Mary 2706 01:39:22,891 --> 01:39:23,358 White please come forward to 2707 01:39:23,358 --> 01:39:24,125 the microphone. 2708 01:39:24,125 --> 01:39:27,695 And then if I can have Sheila 2709 01:39:27,695 --> 01:39:28,396 bear for Alice Dingman and 2710 01:39:28,396 --> 01:39:30,796 Nicholas Wong Theo Rothschild 2711 01:39:33,201 --> 01:39:34,200 stays me and Karen Evie as well 2712 01:39:34,200 --> 01:39:37,602 as Laurie Lipson Please come up 2713 01:39:37,672 --> 01:39:38,206 to the front row. 2714 01:39:38,206 --> 01:39:38,940 Mary please proceed. 2715 01:39:38,940 --> 01:39:42,511 Hi, my name is Mary White. 2716 01:39:42,511 --> 01:39:43,211 I'm here because I've been on 2717 01:39:43,211 --> 01:39:43,745 the board of two ways one in 2718 01:39:43,745 --> 01:39:45,745 Stockton, one here. 2719 01:39:46,981 --> 01:39:47,682 We've had cameras for both of 2720 01:39:47,682 --> 01:39:48,150 our communities and they help 2721 01:39:48,150 --> 01:39:50,150 to solve crimes. 2722 01:39:51,553 --> 01:39:52,153 It's my understanding that 2723 01:39:52,153 --> 01:39:52,888 the officers who misused 2724 01:39:52,888 --> 01:39:56,488 the tools for personal use have 2725 01:39:56,525 --> 01:39:57,492 been dealt with. 2726 01:39:57,492 --> 01:39:58,160 And my comment is if 1 or 2 2727 01:39:58,160 --> 01:40:00,560 police officers misuse their 2728 01:40:01,863 --> 01:40:02,531 weapons vehicles, etc. For 2729 01:40:02,531 --> 01:40:03,231 personal reasons, would you 2730 01:40:03,231 --> 01:40:06,000 take away their weapons, their 2731 01:40:06,000 --> 01:40:06,668 vehicles or dismiss the entire 2732 01:40:06,668 --> 01:40:07,269 police department because of 2733 01:40:07,269 --> 01:40:07,936 misdeeds of 1 or 2 of 2734 01:40:07,936 --> 01:40:09,936 the department's employees? 2735 01:40:10,839 --> 01:40:11,473 If 1 or 2 school students 2736 01:40:11,473 --> 01:40:12,206 misuse computers for their 2737 01:40:12,206 --> 01:40:15,110 personal use, would you condone 2738 01:40:15,110 --> 01:40:15,777 the school doing away with 2739 01:40:15,777 --> 01:40:16,780 computers for all students? 2740 01:40:16,780 --> 01:40:18,780 The l. 2741 01:40:20,282 --> 01:40:20,981 P r cameras are an invaluable 2742 01:40:20,981 --> 01:40:21,716 tool for the police department 2743 01:40:21,716 --> 01:40:24,953 And we heard the police officer 2744 01:40:24,953 --> 01:40:25,554 here talk about all the safety 2745 01:40:25,554 --> 01:40:26,880 issues that they've been 2746 01:40:26,880 --> 01:40:26,488 putting in place for 2747 01:40:26,488 --> 01:40:28,488 the cameras. 2748 01:40:29,357 --> 01:40:29,758 They don't have facial 2749 01:40:29,758 --> 01:40:30,392 recognition. 2750 01:40:30,392 --> 01:40:30,725 It's only a license plate 2751 01:40:30,725 --> 01:40:31,426 reader. 2752 01:40:31,426 --> 01:40:34,563 So there's no way that these 2753 01:40:34,563 --> 01:40:35,263 cameras can discriminate on 2754 01:40:35,263 --> 01:40:35,631 race, color, gender, anything 2755 01:40:35,631 --> 01:40:37,631 like that. 2756 01:40:39,601 --> 01:40:40,268 It's strictly license plates 2757 01:40:40,268 --> 01:40:40,901 that have been involved in a 2758 01:40:40,901 --> 01:40:41,603 crime or at a crime scene. 2759 01:40:41,603 --> 01:40:41,970 Thank you for that concluding 2760 01:40:41,970 --> 01:40:43,970 sentence. 2761 01:40:49,311 --> 01:40:52,311 Sheila Barefoot My name is 2762 01:40:54,316 --> 01:40:55,117 Sheila Barefoot. 2763 01:40:55,117 --> 01:40:55,850 Good afternoon council members. 2764 01:40:55,850 --> 01:40:59,421 I'm here today as someone who 2765 01:40:59,421 --> 01:40:59,955 has survived homelessness right 2766 01:40:59,955 --> 01:41:00,989 here in San Diego. 2767 01:41:00,989 --> 01:41:04,960 I urge you to vote to end 2768 01:41:04,960 --> 01:41:05,627 the Floc surveillance contract 2769 01:41:05,627 --> 01:41:08,627 and shut these cameras down 2770 01:41:09,310 --> 01:41:09,898 when you are unhoused. 2771 01:41:09,898 --> 01:41:10,299 You have no walls, no doors and 2772 01:41:10,299 --> 01:41:12,299 no privacy. 2773 01:41:14,403 --> 01:41:15,700 And when I lived on the street 2774 01:41:15,700 --> 01:41:17,470 I survived police brutality 2775 01:41:19,107 --> 01:41:19,742 twice and endured cruel, brutal 2776 01:41:19,742 --> 01:41:21,742 and relentless harassment. 2777 01:41:23,479 --> 01:41:24,790 Automated surveillance does not 2778 01:41:24,790 --> 01:41:24,680 protect people like me. 2779 01:41:24,680 --> 01:41:26,680 For unhoused residents, 2780 01:41:29,183 --> 01:41:29,851 especially those living in 2781 01:41:29,851 --> 01:41:30,552 their vehicles, cameras like 2782 01:41:30,552 --> 01:41:33,689 Floc act as a dragnet that 2783 01:41:33,689 --> 01:41:34,255 criminalizes triggers constant 2784 01:41:34,255 --> 01:41:36,655 stops and can escalate 2785 01:41:38,727 --> 01:41:39,270 encounters into state violence 2786 01:41:39,270 --> 01:41:39,762 . 2787 01:41:39,762 --> 01:41:40,428 We just saw how this system 2788 01:41:40,428 --> 01:41:43,428 once used to track domestic 2789 01:41:43,499 --> 01:41:44,199 violence or via imagine how it 2790 01:41:44,199 --> 01:41:46,599 is weaponized against unhoused 2791 01:41:48,360 --> 01:41:48,536 who have no power to protect 2792 01:41:48,536 --> 01:41:50,536 and fight back. 2793 01:41:53,809 --> 01:41:54,243 So mass surveillance is not 2794 01:41:54,243 --> 01:41:54,843 public safety. 2795 01:41:54,843 --> 01:41:56,843 >> Please terminate this 2796 01:41:58,847 --> 01:41:59,548 contract or leave the data and 2797 01:41:59,548 --> 01:42:00,820 redirect But thank you Million 2798 01:42:00,820 --> 01:42:01,830 dollars in comment. 2799 01:42:01,830 --> 01:42:01,550 I do have to be fair to 2800 01:42:01,550 --> 01:42:03,550 everybody else. 2801 01:42:06,754 --> 01:42:07,622 >> Dingman. 2802 01:42:07,622 --> 01:42:10,258 >> Hi my name is Alice. 2803 01:42:10,258 --> 01:42:11,600 I am still from District two. 2804 01:42:11,600 --> 01:42:11,627 I hope none of my accessories 2805 01:42:11,627 --> 01:42:13,627 aro distracting or 2806 01:42:15,498 --> 01:42:16,650 uncomfortable for any of you 2807 01:42:16,650 --> 01:42:16,565 but really they're for 2808 01:42:16,565 --> 01:42:17,332 everyone's safety. 2809 01:42:17,332 --> 01:42:20,169 I mean I've got my cell site 2810 01:42:20,169 --> 01:42:20,903 simulator because how would we 2811 01:42:20,903 --> 01:42:21,370 solve hate crimes if I couldn't 2812 01:42:21,370 --> 01:42:23,370 read your texts? 2813 01:42:24,540 --> 01:42:25,241 >> And I've got my drone as a 2814 01:42:25,241 --> 01:42:25,941 first responder pilot program 2815 01:42:25,941 --> 01:42:28,341 because really most situations 2816 01:42:29,245 --> 01:42:29,612 don't meet human You're 2817 01:42:29,612 --> 01:42:30,312 obsolete. 2818 01:42:30,312 --> 01:42:31,130 >> And of course I have my 2819 01:42:31,130 --> 01:42:34,130 flock camera because the only 2820 01:42:34,249 --> 01:42:35,183 way that I can really be safe 2821 01:42:35,183 --> 01:42:38,687 is if I can track everyone all 2822 01:42:38,687 --> 01:42:39,455 the time. 2823 01:42:39,455 --> 01:42:40,255 And sure, maybe some people 2824 01:42:40,255 --> 01:42:43,855 feel less safe but really if 2825 01:42:43,926 --> 01:42:44,593 that domestic violence survivor 2826 01:42:44,593 --> 01:42:45,127 wasn't doing anything wrong 2827 01:42:45,127 --> 01:42:47,527 then she wouldn't be 2828 01:42:48,330 --> 01:42:48,931 uncomfortable about strangers 2829 01:42:48,931 --> 01:42:50,931 following her movements. 2830 01:42:53,535 --> 01:42:54,336 >> And yes, maybe that 19 year 2831 01:42:54,336 --> 01:42:57,540 old boy was shot because of a 2832 01:42:57,540 --> 01:42:57,840 false hit from my flock camera 2833 01:42:57,840 --> 01:42:58,641 . 2834 01:42:58,641 --> 01:42:59,108 >> But that's just the price we 2835 01:42:59,108 --> 01:43:01,108 pay for safety. 2836 01:43:02,611 --> 01:43:03,245 The price we pay is just 2837 01:43:03,245 --> 01:43:05,645 constant danger because we 2838 01:43:08,650 --> 01:43:09,385 can't possibly rely on them to 2839 01:43:09,385 --> 01:43:09,819 be competent and solve things 2840 01:43:09,819 --> 01:43:10,452 on their own. 2841 01:43:10,452 --> 01:43:10,786 >> Thank you for including 2842 01:43:10,786 --> 01:43:12,786 comment. 2843 01:43:18,560 --> 01:43:19,262 Nicholas Wong Nicholas Wong 2844 01:43:19,262 --> 01:43:19,861 Good afternoon Council members 2845 01:43:19,861 --> 01:43:22,861 My name is Nicole Swan. 2846 01:43:23,699 --> 01:43:24,266 I'm a constituent of 2847 01:43:24,266 --> 01:43:24,967 Councilmember LaCava. 2848 01:43:24,967 --> 01:43:28,567 I'm also from the Syrian Civil 2849 01:43:29,380 --> 01:43:29,705 Liberties Union and you might 2850 01:43:29,705 --> 01:43:30,406 have heard this name bounced 2851 01:43:30,406 --> 01:43:31,730 around a couple of times a lot 2852 01:43:31,730 --> 01:43:33,542 of the same points as well. 2853 01:43:33,542 --> 01:43:34,276 There are enough youth in San 2854 01:43:34,276 --> 01:43:35,110 Diego who care about this issue 2855 01:43:35,110 --> 01:43:38,948 that you will not hear the end 2856 01:43:38,948 --> 01:43:39,649 of it as long as this 2857 01:43:39,649 --> 01:43:40,282 conversation is on the table. 2858 01:43:40,282 --> 01:43:43,282 So why keep prolonging it? 2859 01:43:43,719 --> 01:43:44,386 We have gone here alongside 2860 01:43:44,386 --> 01:43:46,555 the terrorist coalition five 2861 01:43:46,555 --> 01:43:46,855 times now Five times the charm. 2862 01:43:46,855 --> 01:43:47,656 Right. 2863 01:43:47,656 --> 01:43:51,256 There will be more and more 2864 01:43:51,660 --> 01:43:52,280 effort until our communities 2865 01:43:52,280 --> 01:43:52,795 are safe. 2866 01:43:52,795 --> 01:43:53,496 And so we urge you as a 2867 01:43:53,496 --> 01:43:55,896 constituent as council members 2868 01:43:55,931 --> 01:43:56,599 to listen to your constituents 2869 01:43:56,599 --> 01:43:57,299 because the youth are voting 2870 01:43:57,299 --> 01:43:57,666 bloc and they're here to stay. 2871 01:43:57,666 --> 01:43:59,635 All right. 2872 01:43:59,635 --> 01:44:02,350 Thank you very much. 2873 01:44:05,475 --> 01:44:06,108 >> Thank you to you. 2874 01:44:06,108 --> 01:44:06,909 >> Hello council members. 2875 01:44:06,909 --> 01:44:09,412 I am Phil Rothchild from 2876 01:44:09,412 --> 01:44:10,112 District one and I'm affiliated 2877 01:44:10,112 --> 01:44:10,513 with the Democratic Socialists 2878 01:44:10,513 --> 01:44:11,820 of America. 2879 01:44:11,820 --> 01:44:13,449 Firstly, thank you for 2880 01:44:13,449 --> 01:44:14,116 the opportunity to speak in 2881 01:44:14,116 --> 01:44:14,817 opposition of item 200 Times 2882 01:44:14,817 --> 01:44:18,540 like this remind me of the oft 2883 01:44:18,540 --> 01:44:18,755 quoted Benjamin Franklin quote 2884 01:44:18,755 --> 01:44:19,489 Those who would give up 2885 01:44:19,489 --> 01:44:20,222 essential liberty to purchase a 2886 01:44:20,222 --> 01:44:22,622 little temporary safety deserve 2887 01:44:23,590 --> 01:44:23,793 neither liberty nor safety. 2888 01:44:23,793 --> 01:44:24,394 Block is a dangerous Orwellian 2889 01:44:24,394 --> 01:44:26,394 system that criminalizes 2890 01:44:27,930 --> 01:44:28,598 poverty and harasses victims of 2891 01:44:28,598 --> 01:44:29,198 domestic violence all while 2892 01:44:29,198 --> 01:44:32,100 enriching an out of city 2893 01:44:32,100 --> 01:44:32,702 corporation with a sweetheart 2894 01:44:32,702 --> 01:44:33,302 $2 million a year deal. 2895 01:44:33,302 --> 01:44:33,936 How can the police say 2896 01:44:33,936 --> 01:44:36,336 surveillance is needed for 2897 01:44:37,373 --> 01:44:37,973 safety when they're unwilling 2898 01:44:37,973 --> 01:44:38,808 to use body cameras? 2899 01:44:38,808 --> 01:44:39,142 And Gloria says he wants a city 2900 01:44:39,142 --> 01:44:41,142 for all. 2901 01:44:42,450 --> 01:44:42,779 He gives our data to a company 2902 01:44:42,779 --> 01:44:43,513 that works in partnership with 2903 01:44:43,513 --> 01:44:44,180 ice who are actively assaulting 2904 01:44:44,180 --> 01:44:44,613 our communities, pausing it 2905 01:44:44,613 --> 01:44:46,613 isn't enough. 2906 01:44:46,682 --> 01:44:47,450 A vote against this contract is 2907 01:44:47,450 --> 01:44:47,917 a vote for humanity a vote for 2908 01:44:47,917 --> 01:44:49,917 all San Diegans. 2909 01:44:54,257 --> 01:44:54,724 >> Thank you, Stacey. 2910 01:44:54,724 --> 01:44:56,724 Hi, I'm Stacey. 2911 01:44:58,761 --> 01:44:59,950 I'm just a stranger passing 2912 01:44:59,950 --> 01:44:59,762 through. 2913 01:44:59,762 --> 01:45:02,762 These past three months I've 2914 01:45:03,832 --> 01:45:04,701 been here. 2915 01:45:04,701 --> 01:45:07,903 I think the only fact we need 2916 01:45:07,903 --> 01:45:08,604 to have out there is all of us 2917 01:45:08,604 --> 01:45:09,372 GOD's children to have more 2918 01:45:09,372 --> 01:45:12,372 contact with one another than 2919 01:45:13,643 --> 01:45:16,430 rely on the technology. 2920 01:45:18,470 --> 01:45:18,448 I was blessed. 2921 01:45:18,448 --> 01:45:18,747 >> Karen. 2922 01:45:18,747 --> 01:45:20,747 Karen. 2923 01:45:22,685 --> 01:45:24,685 There you go. 2924 01:45:27,724 --> 01:45:29,724 Hello, Council members. 2925 01:45:31,161 --> 01:45:31,828 I live in District five and we 2926 01:45:31,828 --> 01:45:34,828 have Alps in my neighborhood 2927 01:45:35,765 --> 01:45:36,499 and I've probably already been 2928 01:45:36,499 --> 01:45:37,133 logged seven times today before 2929 01:45:37,133 --> 01:45:40,133 I even came down here. 2930 01:45:41,371 --> 01:45:44,371 We've seen expanded use for 2931 01:45:45,508 --> 01:45:46,309 criminals to immigration and 2932 01:45:46,309 --> 01:45:47,100 now we have 20 districts 20 2933 01:45:47,100 --> 01:45:49,410 jurisdictions that have used 2934 01:45:51,214 --> 01:45:52,150 this tech to track protesters. 2935 01:45:52,150 --> 01:45:55,150 Every day San Diego holds 2936 01:45:56,185 --> 01:45:56,853 almost 3.6 million images of 2937 01:45:56,853 --> 01:45:59,853 people's place day and time. 2938 01:46:00,723 --> 01:46:01,491 For the last 30 days flags 2939 01:46:01,491 --> 01:46:04,491 coaching of law enforcement to 2940 01:46:05,195 --> 01:46:05,661 push their technology is 2941 01:46:05,661 --> 01:46:07,661 another concern. 2942 01:46:10,100 --> 01:46:10,600 Why is it for sale and safety 2943 01:46:10,600 --> 01:46:12,600 or something else? 2944 01:46:15,138 --> 01:46:15,838 Flock has a handbook on how to 2945 01:46:15,838 --> 01:46:19,438 talk to city council and they 2946 01:46:19,609 --> 01:46:20,210 even encourage their police 2947 01:46:20,210 --> 01:46:20,877 officers to review their 2948 01:46:20,877 --> 01:46:22,877 presentations before city 2949 01:46:25,115 --> 01:46:26,820 council. 2950 01:46:26,820 --> 01:46:26,783 >> I ask you to please cancel 2951 01:46:26,783 --> 01:46:28,952 the contract for flock and for 2952 01:46:28,952 --> 01:46:31,952 you because we're thinking and 2953 01:46:33,589 --> 01:46:35,589 Laura Lippman. 2954 01:46:38,460 --> 01:46:38,828 >> Good afternoon Laurie 2955 01:46:38,828 --> 01:46:39,395 Liebesman. 2956 01:46:39,395 --> 01:46:41,795 She her District three 2957 01:46:43,433 --> 01:46:43,767 surveillance does not create 2958 01:46:43,767 --> 01:46:44,401 safety. 2959 01:46:44,401 --> 01:46:44,801 Meeting people's essential 2960 01:46:44,801 --> 01:46:46,801 needs does. 2961 01:46:48,471 --> 01:46:49,500 Housing, education. 2962 01:46:49,500 --> 01:46:49,673 Health care. 2963 01:46:49,673 --> 01:46:50,206 Access to mental health and 2964 01:46:50,206 --> 01:46:52,206 addiction services. 2965 01:46:53,810 --> 01:46:54,411 All address the conditions that 2966 01:46:54,411 --> 01:46:56,811 contribute to crime Take 2967 01:46:58,481 --> 01:46:59,480 the money resources and 2968 01:46:59,480 --> 01:46:59,783 personnel invested in 2969 01:46:59,783 --> 01:47:01,783 surveillance and militarization 2970 01:47:03,453 --> 01:47:04,121 and redirect them towards 2971 01:47:04,121 --> 01:47:06,521 housing services for mental 2972 01:47:08,391 --> 01:47:09,158 health and addiction education 2973 01:47:09,158 --> 01:47:09,625 ,libraries, parks and rec and 2974 01:47:09,625 --> 01:47:11,625 infrastructure. 2975 01:47:13,363 --> 01:47:14,630 Invest in what uplifts, 2976 01:47:14,630 --> 01:47:16,463 supports and protects people. 2977 01:47:17,537 --> 01:47:18,680 Stop mass and mass 2978 01:47:18,680 --> 01:47:18,501 criminalization and 2979 01:47:18,501 --> 01:47:20,501 incarceration. 2980 01:47:22,539 --> 01:47:23,306 Fear policing and punishment 2981 01:47:23,306 --> 01:47:23,973 are not what builds responsible 2982 01:47:23,973 --> 01:47:24,374 engage compassionate or safe 2983 01:47:24,374 --> 01:47:26,374 communities. 2984 01:47:29,346 --> 01:47:29,813 Thank you. 2985 01:47:29,813 --> 01:47:30,213 >> Thank you. 2986 01:47:30,213 --> 01:47:31,181 Beth Givens. 2987 01:47:31,181 --> 01:47:32,816 Beth Givens if you can please 2988 01:47:32,816 --> 01:47:33,483 come up to the microphone after 2989 01:47:33,483 --> 01:47:36,483 that will be Damian Gonzalez 2990 01:47:38,689 --> 01:47:41,890 Martinez Nicole Sharma, Kian 2991 01:47:42,920 --> 01:47:42,792 Chen Drunk can drunk Michael 2992 01:47:42,792 --> 01:47:44,792 Salario Matthew Pendergraph 2993 01:47:47,230 --> 01:47:47,565 GRift C.J. Mendoza and Claire 2994 01:47:47,565 --> 01:47:48,398 Snyder. 2995 01:47:48,398 --> 01:47:51,901 If you can all please come up 2996 01:47:51,901 --> 01:47:52,636 to the front row. 2997 01:47:52,636 --> 01:47:55,636 Beth Please proceed when ready. 2998 01:47:56,406 --> 01:47:56,873 Beth Givens Yes. 2999 01:47:56,873 --> 01:47:57,374 >> Thank you. 3000 01:47:57,374 --> 01:47:58,342 I'm Beth Givens. 3001 01:47:58,342 --> 01:48:01,645 Linda Vista Thanks to those of 3002 01:48:01,645 --> 01:48:02,279 you who have stated you will 3003 01:48:02,279 --> 01:48:04,679 oppose the continuation of 3004 01:48:05,549 --> 01:48:06,250 the floor contract also to 3005 01:48:06,250 --> 01:48:06,683 the mayor for stating that you 3006 01:48:06,683 --> 01:48:07,417 will not veto. 3007 01:48:07,417 --> 01:48:09,886 >> I urge the Council to 3008 01:48:09,886 --> 01:48:10,587 include in your no vote 3009 01:48:10,587 --> 01:48:13,587 statement that you oppose all 3010 01:48:14,925 --> 01:48:15,492 automated license plate reader 3011 01:48:15,492 --> 01:48:16,590 usage, not just flock. 3012 01:48:16,590 --> 01:48:16,426 There are several such 3013 01:48:16,426 --> 01:48:18,426 companies. 3014 01:48:19,496 --> 01:48:20,230 Please ensure that all cameras 3015 01:48:20,230 --> 01:48:23,830 are removed and not just turned 3016 01:48:24,902 --> 01:48:25,535 off or covered and also 3017 01:48:25,535 --> 01:48:26,236 violations of flock usage 3018 01:48:26,236 --> 01:48:29,236 policy by police officers must 3019 01:48:29,740 --> 01:48:30,306 be fully investigated and 3020 01:48:30,306 --> 01:48:32,306 the offending officers 3021 01:48:34,477 --> 01:48:35,245 meaningfully dispute discipline 3022 01:48:35,245 --> 01:48:35,913 and not just a slap on 3023 01:48:35,913 --> 01:48:36,212 the wrist and not just desk 3024 01:48:36,212 --> 01:48:38,212 time. 3025 01:48:40,250 --> 01:48:40,884 I also urge you to Rialto flock 3026 01:48:40,884 --> 01:48:43,284 funds to city institutions 3027 01:48:43,720 --> 01:48:44,355 whose budgets have been reduced 3028 01:48:44,355 --> 01:48:44,988 like libraries, parks, rec 3029 01:48:44,988 --> 01:48:47,388 centers, arts and housing. 3030 01:48:49,426 --> 01:48:50,600 These institutions build 3031 01:48:50,600 --> 01:48:50,694 support, build and support 3032 01:48:50,694 --> 01:48:53,940 community They're vital to 3033 01:48:54,498 --> 01:48:55,232 civic life. 3034 01:48:55,232 --> 01:48:55,933 They enrich our lives including 3035 01:48:55,933 --> 01:48:58,333 children whose early exposure 3036 01:48:58,702 --> 01:48:59,169 is particularly enriching. 3037 01:48:59,169 --> 01:49:01,169 >> Thank you. 3038 01:49:03,207 --> 01:49:05,607 Thank you, Damien Damian 3039 01:49:06,910 --> 01:49:07,210 Gonzalez Martinez are you here 3040 01:49:07,210 --> 01:49:09,210 ? 3041 01:49:12,650 --> 01:49:13,350 Damien Gonzalez Martinez Moving 3042 01:49:13,350 --> 01:49:13,650 to the next individual Nicole 3043 01:49:13,650 --> 01:49:15,650 Smith. 3044 01:49:16,386 --> 01:49:19,386 >> schama Sorry I don't know 3045 01:49:21,591 --> 01:49:22,225 why That's my. 3046 01:49:22,225 --> 01:49:22,559 >> Good afternoon, council 3047 01:49:22,559 --> 01:49:23,226 members. 3048 01:49:23,226 --> 01:49:26,226 My name is Mitchell Sharma. 3049 01:49:26,696 --> 01:49:27,397 I'm a student at ucsd, resident 3050 01:49:27,397 --> 01:49:28,132 of District One and I'm also 3051 01:49:28,132 --> 01:49:28,765 policy advocate for the Student 3052 01:49:28,765 --> 01:49:31,735 Civil Liberties Union as a 3053 01:49:31,735 --> 01:49:32,402 representative you have an 3054 01:49:32,402 --> 01:49:33,700 obligation to protect us as 3055 01:49:33,700 --> 01:49:33,737 you've been doing so so far 3056 01:49:33,737 --> 01:49:36,737 voting to terminate the fees 3057 01:49:37,841 --> 01:49:38,575 contract with Locke it is 3058 01:49:38,575 --> 01:49:39,276 necessary to achieve that goal. 3059 01:49:39,276 --> 01:49:41,812 Across the country there have 3060 01:49:41,812 --> 01:49:42,513 been cases of police officers 3061 01:49:42,513 --> 01:49:43,146 abusing Floc data in order to 3062 01:49:43,146 --> 01:49:45,546 stock and attract private 3063 01:49:46,116 --> 01:49:46,917 individuals With such a case 3064 01:49:46,917 --> 01:49:47,651 happened here in San Diego just 3065 01:49:47,651 --> 01:49:48,352 recently, people do not have to 3066 01:49:48,352 --> 01:49:51,889 be concerned about who can be 3067 01:49:51,889 --> 01:49:52,490 tracking them or using data at 3068 01:49:52,490 --> 01:49:53,157 any given moment various 3069 01:49:53,157 --> 01:49:56,157 parties how you can protect 3070 01:49:57,610 --> 01:49:57,761 your constituents Council 3071 01:49:57,761 --> 01:49:58,461 PRESIDENT LaCava I appreciate 3072 01:49:58,461 --> 01:49:59,162 and align with your anti-Trump 3073 01:49:59,162 --> 01:50:02,162 stance Voting against Block is 3074 01:50:02,366 --> 01:50:02,833 taking a stance against Trump 3075 01:50:02,833 --> 01:50:03,501 and his allies. 3076 01:50:03,501 --> 01:50:04,100 >> Please vote to give Flock 3077 01:50:04,100 --> 01:50:06,401 out of San Diego. 3078 01:50:09,874 --> 01:50:11,874 Thank you Kiana. 3079 01:50:14,278 --> 01:50:15,120 >> Good afternoon District one 3080 01:50:15,120 --> 01:50:15,713 I strongly urge City Council to 3081 01:50:15,713 --> 01:50:18,713 oppose renewal of San Diego's 3082 01:50:19,650 --> 01:50:20,384 contract with Walk. 3083 01:50:20,384 --> 01:50:21,850 I hope your surveillance 3084 01:50:21,850 --> 01:50:21,519 technology is an impediment to 3085 01:50:21,519 --> 01:50:23,519 surveillance. 3086 01:50:24,755 --> 01:50:25,456 Right to privacy is the right 3087 01:50:25,456 --> 01:50:26,190 of all ten Diegans to have 3088 01:50:26,190 --> 01:50:26,891 their privacy protected even in 3089 01:50:26,891 --> 01:50:29,560 public spaces where privacy is 3090 01:50:29,560 --> 01:50:30,227 naturally diminished there are 3091 01:50:30,227 --> 01:50:30,928 little to no regulations or 3092 01:50:30,928 --> 01:50:31,329 safeguards on data collection 3093 01:50:31,329 --> 01:50:33,329 and storage. 3094 01:50:35,199 --> 01:50:35,900 As of AUGUST of this year there 3095 01:50:35,900 --> 01:50:38,300 have been over 100 documented 3096 01:50:38,702 --> 01:50:39,303 cases of police officers across 3097 01:50:39,303 --> 01:50:39,937 the country abusing four 3098 01:50:39,937 --> 01:50:40,538 cameras 39 cases of which 3099 01:50:40,538 --> 01:50:42,538 involve stalking women. 3100 01:50:44,241 --> 01:50:44,908 These numbers have almost 3101 01:50:44,908 --> 01:50:45,509 certainly grown since then. 3102 01:50:45,509 --> 01:50:46,176 This technology does not 3103 01:50:46,176 --> 01:50:48,576 reliably read license plate 3104 01:50:49,513 --> 01:50:49,880 numbers or recognize faces 3105 01:50:49,880 --> 01:50:50,615 correctly. 3106 01:50:50,615 --> 01:50:51,315 Little has been done to improve 3107 01:50:51,315 --> 01:50:52,160 This field has also been done 3108 01:50:52,160 --> 01:50:54,852 to hold companies or law 3109 01:50:54,852 --> 01:50:55,486 enforcement accountable for 3110 01:50:55,486 --> 01:50:56,186 misusing this technology. 3111 01:50:56,186 --> 01:50:58,586 Effective policing should not 3112 01:51:00,291 --> 01:51:00,891 come at the price of civilians 3113 01:51:00,891 --> 01:51:01,559 privacy and safety While 3114 01:51:01,559 --> 01:51:02,192 cameras do not belong in San 3115 01:51:02,192 --> 01:51:05,192 Diego and they never will. 3116 01:51:05,462 --> 01:51:06,960 I urge you to vote against 3117 01:51:06,960 --> 01:51:06,631 the renewal of the state's 3118 01:51:06,631 --> 01:51:07,640 contract With luck. 3119 01:51:07,640 --> 01:51:09,640 >> Thank you. 3120 01:51:14,710 --> 01:51:14,839 Thank you, Michael and Michael 3121 01:51:14,839 --> 01:51:15,506 from District two and a member 3122 01:51:15,506 --> 01:51:16,240 of Workers strike Back under 3123 01:51:16,240 --> 01:51:19,240 pressure from the ongoing fight 3124 01:51:19,342 --> 01:51:20,211 against Fox surveillance. 3125 01:51:20,211 --> 01:51:20,912 The city council is set to shut 3126 01:51:20,912 --> 01:51:24,512 down four cameras in our city. 3127 01:51:24,715 --> 01:51:25,449 City council Democrats on 3128 01:51:25,449 --> 01:51:26,117 the other hand, have voted four 3129 01:51:26,117 --> 01:51:26,517 times for mass surveillance 3130 01:51:26,517 --> 01:51:28,517 since 2023. 3131 01:51:30,288 --> 01:51:30,955 Council Democrats defense of 3132 01:51:30,955 --> 01:51:31,656 Floc is especially shameful 3133 01:51:31,656 --> 01:51:32,256 given California's history of 3134 01:51:32,256 --> 01:51:34,656 sharing flight data with 3135 01:51:36,160 --> 01:51:36,894 Trump's dhs. 3136 01:51:36,894 --> 01:51:37,562 And yet Raul Castillo and Money 3137 01:51:37,562 --> 01:51:40,562 Man will protect Flock Until 3138 01:51:40,632 --> 01:51:41,298 only days ago. 3139 01:51:41,298 --> 01:51:42,000 If this technology remains 3140 01:51:42,000 --> 01:51:45,000 available it will be exploited 3141 01:51:45,502 --> 01:51:46,170 If Mayor Gloria or Council 3142 01:51:46,170 --> 01:51:46,804 Democrats try to reactivate 3143 01:51:46,804 --> 01:51:47,171 them it would be a massive 3144 01:51:47,171 --> 01:51:49,171 betrayal. 3145 01:51:51,409 --> 01:51:52,110 We need to get organized 3146 01:51:52,110 --> 01:51:52,777 independently of both parties 3147 01:51:52,777 --> 01:51:53,478 if we want to fight the A.I. 3148 01:51:53,478 --> 01:51:55,878 Billionaires and their system 3149 01:51:56,414 --> 01:51:57,114 of mass surveillance to get 3150 01:51:57,114 --> 01:51:57,748 involved, join workers strike 3151 01:51:57,748 --> 01:51:59,150 Back At our National Zoom 3152 01:51:59,150 --> 01:52:02,150 meeting on DECEMBER sixth or 3153 01:52:04,422 --> 01:52:07,422 speak with me today Matthew 3154 01:52:10,528 --> 01:52:11,620 Pender GRift Hello City Council 3155 01:52:11,620 --> 01:52:13,462 My name is Matt. 3156 01:52:15,666 --> 01:52:16,401 >> I'm from District three and 3157 01:52:16,401 --> 01:52:17,135 I'm here to make a small point 3158 01:52:17,135 --> 01:52:19,504 that none of my groups support. 3159 01:52:19,504 --> 01:52:19,937 Flock helped in their 3160 01:52:19,937 --> 01:52:20,638 surveillance. 3161 01:52:20,638 --> 01:52:21,339 So the last time I was here I 3162 01:52:21,339 --> 01:52:23,339 heard overwhelming opposition 3163 01:52:26,310 --> 01:52:26,744 to flock, yelps etc. Mass 3164 01:52:26,744 --> 01:52:27,411 surveillance. 3165 01:52:27,411 --> 01:52:27,979 I heard some by groups speak 3166 01:52:27,979 --> 01:52:30,979 out in favor of this. 3167 01:52:31,416 --> 01:52:32,116 I was really disappointed to 3168 01:52:32,116 --> 01:52:32,817 hear that I'm from another by 3169 01:52:32,817 --> 01:52:33,551 group called Barksdale Pueblo 3170 01:52:33,551 --> 01:52:37,121 where an all volunteer group we 3171 01:52:37,121 --> 01:52:37,722 work to support the second 3172 01:52:37,722 --> 01:52:38,389 community of San Diego. 3173 01:52:38,389 --> 01:52:38,923 We don't support flock and 3174 01:52:38,923 --> 01:52:39,558 surveillance for all 3175 01:52:39,558 --> 01:52:41,958 the reasons you've already 3176 01:52:42,160 --> 01:52:43,600 heard. 3177 01:52:43,600 --> 01:52:43,627 I want to provide an example of 3178 01:52:43,627 --> 01:52:44,362 a cycling perspective. 3179 01:52:44,362 --> 01:52:47,932 For example, I'm not worried if 3180 01:52:47,932 --> 01:52:48,799 the person who hits and kills 3181 01:52:48,799 --> 01:52:49,434 me if their car gets caught I 3182 01:52:49,434 --> 01:52:50,135 don't want to get hit and 3183 01:52:50,135 --> 01:52:50,435 killed by the car in the first 3184 01:52:50,435 --> 01:52:52,435 place. 3185 01:52:53,772 --> 01:52:54,372 So I want the city to invest in 3186 01:52:54,372 --> 01:52:55,600 safe infrastructure that 3187 01:52:55,600 --> 01:52:58,600 protect its citizens And I 3188 01:52:59,310 --> 01:52:59,982 don't want the city to invest 3189 01:52:59,982 --> 01:53:00,678 in in surveillance mass 3190 01:53:00,678 --> 01:53:01,279 surveillance about the police 3191 01:53:01,279 --> 01:53:04,279 and ice and exercise to 3192 01:53:04,349 --> 01:53:04,849 terrorize the community. 3193 01:53:04,849 --> 01:53:06,849 >> Thank you. 3194 01:53:11,890 --> 01:53:12,324 C.J. Mendoza Good afternoon and 3195 01:53:12,324 --> 01:53:14,324 Citizen Delta. 3196 01:53:15,660 --> 01:53:16,227 And I'm here to urge you all to 3197 01:53:16,227 --> 01:53:16,928 take the cameras down. 3198 01:53:16,928 --> 01:53:20,528 The cameras are here and they 3199 01:53:20,799 --> 01:53:21,599 deserve its purpose to protect 3200 01:53:21,599 --> 01:53:22,233 and it did not serve most 3201 01:53:22,233 --> 01:53:22,567 importantly the San Diego 3202 01:53:22,567 --> 01:53:23,268 people. 3203 01:53:23,268 --> 01:53:26,104 So it's long overdue for them 3204 01:53:26,104 --> 01:53:26,771 to be gone. 3205 01:53:26,771 --> 01:53:27,472 The money poured into this 3206 01:53:27,472 --> 01:53:28,139 harmful technology can instead 3207 01:53:28,139 --> 01:53:31,139 be invested in resources for 3208 01:53:32,510 --> 01:53:33,144 our children, our families, our 3209 01:53:33,144 --> 01:53:33,812 youth and communities that 3210 01:53:33,812 --> 01:53:36,812 deserve to thrive, not hide. 3211 01:53:38,850 --> 01:53:39,551 We're not safe and we never 3212 01:53:39,551 --> 01:53:39,884 will be if we continue to let 3213 01:53:39,884 --> 01:53:40,685 it stay. 3214 01:53:40,685 --> 01:53:43,621 We are your guinea pigs for 3215 01:53:43,621 --> 01:53:44,322 this We're in creepy 3216 01:53:44,322 --> 01:53:44,756 surveillance technology so get 3217 01:53:44,756 --> 01:53:45,190 the flock out. 3218 01:53:45,190 --> 01:53:47,190 >> Thank you. 3219 01:53:49,895 --> 01:53:50,227 Claire Snyder Good afternoon, 3220 01:53:50,227 --> 01:53:50,862 counsel. 3221 01:53:50,862 --> 01:53:53,862 My name is Claire Snyder. 3222 01:53:55,433 --> 01:53:56,100 I'm a resident of District 3223 01:53:56,100 --> 01:53:56,867 three and I'm here with you. 3224 01:53:56,867 --> 01:54:00,467 I will cancel the fire contract 3225 01:54:01,306 --> 01:54:01,973 and take down the cameras. 3226 01:54:01,973 --> 01:54:02,607 We can invest the millions 3227 01:54:02,607 --> 01:54:03,308 spent on surveillance into 3228 01:54:03,308 --> 01:54:06,778 the young people to see Diego 3229 01:54:06,778 --> 01:54:07,411 and other essential programs. 3230 01:54:07,411 --> 01:54:07,979 The police department has 3231 01:54:07,979 --> 01:54:08,646 proven that with this 3232 01:54:08,646 --> 01:54:10,646 technology the surveillance 3233 01:54:12,783 --> 01:54:13,518 technology, our data and quite 3234 01:54:13,518 --> 01:54:14,252 frankly our lives are not safe. 3235 01:54:14,252 --> 01:54:17,852 A person was shot and a 3236 01:54:19,357 --> 01:54:20,920 domestic violence survivor was 3237 01:54:20,920 --> 01:54:20,559 stalked by the department using 3238 01:54:20,559 --> 01:54:22,559 this technology. 3239 01:54:24,696 --> 01:54:25,564 To be honest I'm not sure like 3240 01:54:25,564 --> 01:54:26,198 what else it's going to take to 3241 01:54:26,198 --> 01:54:26,831 convince people that this 3242 01:54:26,831 --> 01:54:29,231 technology does not work. 3243 01:54:30,302 --> 01:54:30,936 We we come here many times 3244 01:54:30,936 --> 01:54:31,636 before and if it's picking 3245 01:54:31,636 --> 01:54:34,360 people getting injured, being 3246 01:54:35,941 --> 01:54:36,642 served, being hurt and harmed 3247 01:54:36,642 --> 01:54:37,342 by this technology to convince 3248 01:54:37,342 --> 01:54:40,342 you it's another problem that 3249 01:54:41,646 --> 01:54:42,346 we have. 3250 01:54:42,346 --> 01:54:42,981 >> Please cancel the contract 3251 01:54:42,981 --> 01:54:45,981 and take the cameras down. 3252 01:54:47,519 --> 01:54:48,200 Thank you. 3253 01:54:48,200 --> 01:54:48,687 >> Thank you. 3254 01:54:48,687 --> 01:54:49,253 Alex Castillo, if you could 3255 01:54:49,253 --> 01:54:49,955 please come forward to 3256 01:54:49,955 --> 01:54:52,955 the microphone after that And 3257 01:54:53,625 --> 01:54:54,492 Andy on the go. 3258 01:54:54,492 --> 01:54:56,892 Liliana Soriano, Simon Fuller 3259 01:54:59,965 --> 01:55:02,365 Walker Sobczak Carrie Bravo 3260 01:55:05,703 --> 01:55:06,471 Kristen and Olivia Drummond. 3261 01:55:06,471 --> 01:55:07,105 If you can all please come 3262 01:55:07,105 --> 01:55:07,672 forward to the front row. 3263 01:55:07,672 --> 01:55:10,720 Are you Alex Castillo? 3264 01:55:12,110 --> 01:55:12,711 Yes. 3265 01:55:12,711 --> 01:55:13,178 >> Please proceed. 3266 01:55:13,178 --> 01:55:13,812 Good afternoon. 3267 01:55:13,812 --> 01:55:14,646 My name is Alex Castillo. 3268 01:55:14,646 --> 01:55:17,849 I'm a resident of any city 3269 01:55:17,849 --> 01:55:18,483 district eight and an outreach 3270 01:55:18,483 --> 01:55:18,783 organized intern at Youth 3271 01:55:18,783 --> 01:55:19,518 World. 3272 01:55:19,518 --> 01:55:23,210 I'm here to urge the council to 3273 01:55:23,210 --> 01:55:23,589 oppose public surveillance 3274 01:55:23,589 --> 01:55:24,155 technologies and block 3275 01:55:24,155 --> 01:55:24,856 similarly to Orwell's 3276 01:55:24,856 --> 01:55:27,856 Ministries of Truth, Love and 3277 01:55:29,327 --> 01:55:30,620 Peace said it was surveillance 3278 01:55:30,620 --> 01:55:30,562 technologies promise safety yet 3279 01:55:30,562 --> 01:55:30,996 the only guarantee 3280 01:55:30,996 --> 01:55:31,696 the opposite. 3281 01:55:31,696 --> 01:55:34,696 Think of the children outside 3282 01:55:35,434 --> 01:55:36,101 of the gross misuse of such 3283 01:55:36,101 --> 01:55:36,735 technologies by Federal pd. 3284 01:55:36,735 --> 01:55:39,135 The enormous allocation of 3285 01:55:40,372 --> 01:55:40,973 these funds divert resources 3286 01:55:40,973 --> 01:55:41,607 away from programs that 3287 01:55:41,607 --> 01:55:42,400 actually prevent crime in 3288 01:55:42,400 --> 01:55:42,741 the long term. 3289 01:55:42,741 --> 01:55:46,341 The Office of Child and Youth 3290 01:55:46,945 --> 01:55:47,713 Success Library's part Invest 3291 01:55:47,713 --> 01:55:48,346 in real programs that encourage 3292 01:55:48,346 --> 01:55:49,470 long term city stability. 3293 01:55:49,470 --> 01:55:52,470 It's often that our government 3294 01:55:53,519 --> 01:55:54,219 make short term investments 3295 01:55:54,219 --> 01:55:54,920 without considering what's at 3296 01:55:54,920 --> 01:55:55,621 stake and who you are hired to 3297 01:55:55,621 --> 01:55:59,221 really serve Plant the seed so 3298 01:55:59,291 --> 01:55:59,658 future generations can stand in 3299 01:55:59,658 --> 01:56:00,425 the shade. 3300 01:56:00,425 --> 01:56:03,425 >> Invest in San Diego Youth 3301 01:56:10,402 --> 01:56:11,170 Andy Hello my name is Andy on 3302 01:56:11,170 --> 01:56:11,870 District eight as well I'm a 3303 01:56:11,870 --> 01:56:12,404 representative with Youth Will 3304 01:56:12,404 --> 01:56:15,404 and our time to act. 3305 01:56:16,642 --> 01:56:17,275 I'm here to ask Council to take 3306 01:56:17,275 --> 01:56:17,943 the cameras down canceled 3307 01:56:17,943 --> 01:56:18,543 contracts, funding for Cuba, 3308 01:56:18,543 --> 01:56:20,943 Axon and other companies 3309 01:56:23,215 --> 01:56:23,883 revealing our neighborhoods in 3310 01:56:23,883 --> 01:56:24,617 automated Nazareth Planning 3311 01:56:24,617 --> 01:56:27,452 Group And we learned that there 3312 01:56:27,452 --> 01:56:27,953 is 60 cameras in our little 3313 01:56:27,953 --> 01:56:30,353 slice of our city. 3314 01:56:31,423 --> 01:56:32,157 These cameras alone monitor 3315 01:56:32,157 --> 01:56:32,892 4.2% of our city population 3316 01:56:32,892 --> 01:56:35,892 That is mostly Spanish speakers 3317 01:56:38,263 --> 01:56:38,931 and Latinos and people like me. 3318 01:56:38,931 --> 01:56:39,598 My my anxiety peeks at 3319 01:56:39,598 --> 01:56:42,598 the sight of police presence 3320 01:56:43,502 --> 01:56:44,103 because of past violence upon 3321 01:56:44,103 --> 01:56:44,804 the posse and immigrant 3322 01:56:44,804 --> 01:56:45,437 community I am forced to think 3323 01:56:45,437 --> 01:56:46,105 of it all the time knowing 3324 01:56:46,105 --> 01:56:49,105 these cameras monitor it and 3325 01:56:49,942 --> 01:56:50,743 unjustly threaten us. 3326 01:56:50,743 --> 01:56:51,277 I strongly urge the Council to 3327 01:56:51,277 --> 01:56:53,277 end surveillance and 3328 01:56:55,247 --> 01:56:55,947 the violation of San Diego 3329 01:56:55,947 --> 01:56:56,649 civil civil liberties And I 3330 01:56:56,649 --> 01:56:57,349 thank Councilmember Moreno and 3331 01:56:57,349 --> 01:57:00,349 other council members who have 3332 01:57:00,953 --> 01:57:01,654 been listening to the community 3333 01:57:01,654 --> 01:57:02,421 and fighting on our behalf. 3334 01:57:02,421 --> 01:57:03,880 I urge you to make today's 3335 01:57:03,880 --> 01:57:05,488 decision permanent and take 3336 01:57:05,958 --> 01:57:07,958 the cameras down. 3337 01:57:14,100 --> 01:57:14,866 Liliana Serrano Good afternoon 3338 01:57:14,866 --> 01:57:15,467 Council My name is me and I 3339 01:57:15,467 --> 01:57:18,204 don't know I serve as 3340 01:57:18,204 --> 01:57:18,971 the Director of policy at Youth 3341 01:57:18,971 --> 01:57:19,671 Well we are an organization 3342 01:57:19,671 --> 01:57:20,339 dedicated to supporting young 3343 01:57:20,339 --> 01:57:23,939 people in the county to feel 3344 01:57:26,780 --> 01:57:26,812 safe, valued and supported. 3345 01:57:26,812 --> 01:57:27,346 Youth is also a partner of 3346 01:57:27,346 --> 01:57:29,346 the Trust Coalition. 3347 01:57:30,616 --> 01:57:31,317 We heard a presentation on 3348 01:57:31,317 --> 01:57:32,510 earlier and we shared the same 3349 01:57:32,510 --> 01:57:36,251 vision for the city to turn off 3350 01:57:37,156 --> 01:57:37,723 these cameras, put them away, 3351 01:57:37,723 --> 01:57:38,423 stop contracting with 3352 01:57:38,423 --> 01:57:39,125 corporations that are stealing 3353 01:57:39,125 --> 01:57:42,125 money away from families that 3354 01:57:42,828 --> 01:57:43,428 live in your districts, working 3355 01:57:43,428 --> 01:57:44,163 families, youth and also 3356 01:57:44,163 --> 01:57:47,163 supporting a technology that is 3357 01:57:48,901 --> 01:57:49,768 working families apart. 3358 01:57:49,768 --> 01:57:50,369 We've seen a lot of that in 3359 01:57:50,369 --> 01:57:53,369 social media in our own 3360 01:57:54,507 --> 01:57:55,274 personal lives as well. 3361 01:57:55,274 --> 01:57:58,874 So I'm thinking thank you so 3362 01:58:00,446 --> 01:58:01,346 much and for Hello Council I'm 3363 01:58:01,346 --> 01:58:06,146 a member of d five and a policy 3364 01:58:06,418 --> 01:58:07,860 research intern at Youth Well 3365 01:58:07,860 --> 01:58:07,753 and as elected officials you 3366 01:58:07,753 --> 01:58:10,753 should all certainly know by 3367 01:58:11,591 --> 01:58:12,258 now how policing works And I 3368 01:58:12,258 --> 01:58:12,959 learned from human bias over 3369 01:58:12,959 --> 01:58:13,659 policing racial undertones in 3370 01:58:13,659 --> 01:58:16,590 reports and community targeted 3371 01:58:19,699 --> 01:58:20,466 criminalization. 3372 01:58:20,466 --> 01:58:21,100 It produces an output based off 3373 01:58:21,100 --> 01:58:21,801 of the series of data and 3374 01:58:21,801 --> 01:58:23,970 points increase its legitimate 3375 01:58:23,970 --> 01:58:24,537 I legitimizes racist policing 3376 01:58:24,537 --> 01:58:25,171 behind the disguise of 3377 01:58:25,171 --> 01:58:27,171 technological advancement 3378 01:58:30,876 --> 01:58:31,510 officers work off of biased 3379 01:58:31,510 --> 01:58:32,211 outputs thinking that they 3380 01:58:32,211 --> 01:58:35,211 cannot reproduce bias but it's 3381 01:58:35,947 --> 01:58:36,649 actually just a mechanical 3382 01:58:36,649 --> 01:58:37,349 manifestation of confirmation 3383 01:58:37,349 --> 01:58:40,349 bias telling you exactly what 3384 01:58:42,322 --> 01:58:43,220 you expect to hear and what 3385 01:58:43,220 --> 01:58:43,689 could this $2 million contract 3386 01:58:43,689 --> 01:58:46,689 money be used for Libraries 3387 01:58:47,930 --> 01:58:47,760 funding schools and youth 3388 01:58:47,760 --> 01:58:48,494 programs, community centers, 3389 01:58:48,494 --> 01:58:50,894 affordable housing, the ability 3390 01:58:53,966 --> 01:58:54,667 to afford basic necessities 3391 01:58:54,667 --> 01:58:55,334 that have gotten increasingly 3392 01:58:55,334 --> 01:58:55,802 unaffordable keeps us safe. 3393 01:58:55,802 --> 01:58:56,502 We keep us safe. 3394 01:58:56,502 --> 01:58:59,502 Community spaces keep us safe. 3395 01:58:59,905 --> 01:59:00,639 Good paying jobs keep us safe. 3396 01:59:00,639 --> 01:59:00,940 >> Investing in youth keeps us 3397 01:59:00,940 --> 01:59:01,307 safe. 3398 01:59:01,307 --> 01:59:03,420 Thank you. 3399 01:59:03,420 --> 01:59:05,420 Thank you, Walter. 3400 01:59:15,922 --> 01:59:16,522 I believe Walter Sobchak Well, 3401 01:59:16,522 --> 01:59:17,190 good afternoon, Council. 3402 01:59:17,190 --> 01:59:17,857 My character name is Walter. 3403 01:59:17,857 --> 01:59:18,391 I own subject security near 3404 01:59:18,391 --> 01:59:20,391 the In-n-Out Burger. 3405 01:59:20,960 --> 01:59:21,561 I live in District nine and I 3406 01:59:21,561 --> 01:59:21,995 am calmer than you are. 3407 01:59:21,995 --> 01:59:22,762 Where's Marty? 3408 01:59:22,762 --> 01:59:25,762 I hope she didn't kidnap 3409 01:59:26,265 --> 01:59:26,933 herself. 3410 01:59:26,933 --> 01:59:27,233 Has the whole world going 3411 01:59:27,233 --> 01:59:28,100 crazy? 3412 01:59:28,100 --> 01:59:28,667 I am I the only one around here 3413 01:59:28,667 --> 01:59:32,267 who give a about the rules? 3414 01:59:32,338 --> 01:59:32,972 The Supreme Court roundly 3415 01:59:32,972 --> 01:59:33,673 rejected prior restraint. 3416 01:59:33,673 --> 01:59:33,973 This is not a First Amendment 3417 01:59:33,973 --> 01:59:34,706 issue. 3418 01:59:34,706 --> 01:59:37,706 It's about the Fourth Amendment 3419 01:59:38,744 --> 01:59:39,412 checking location data without 3420 01:59:39,412 --> 01:59:39,945 probable cause counts as an 3421 01:59:39,945 --> 01:59:40,580 unreasonable search. 3422 01:59:40,580 --> 01:59:44,180 I hope your eyes are over 3423 01:59:45,584 --> 01:59:46,252 the line. 3424 01:59:46,252 --> 01:59:46,886 I didn't watch my buddies 3425 01:59:46,886 --> 01:59:47,520 dripping down the back to 3426 01:59:47,520 --> 01:59:47,921 the billionaire could ruin 3427 01:59:47,921 --> 01:59:49,921 everything. 3428 01:59:51,257 --> 01:59:52,240 Am I wrong? 3429 01:59:52,240 --> 01:59:52,625 Even if you end the contract 3430 01:59:52,625 --> 01:59:53,326 with park safety without 3431 01:59:53,326 --> 01:59:53,960 removing the cameras they will 3432 01:59:53,960 --> 01:59:56,960 go out and achieve anyway. 3433 01:59:57,530 --> 01:59:58,333 It also it also contravenes a 3434 01:59:58,333 --> 01:59:59,650 number of bylaws If you want a 3435 01:59:59,650 --> 02:00:01,465 legitimate security system come 3436 02:00:04,103 --> 02:00:04,871 down to subject security near 3437 02:00:04,871 --> 02:00:05,572 you go in and out burger Look 3438 02:00:05,572 --> 02:00:08,507 for the signage that says for 3439 02:00:08,507 --> 02:00:09,309 subject security I can get you 3440 02:00:09,309 --> 02:00:10,143 a tow by 3:00 in the afternoon. 3441 02:00:10,143 --> 02:00:10,510 Come on, you get the out if 3442 02:00:10,510 --> 02:00:12,510 you will. 3443 02:00:13,379 --> 02:00:16,379 It is no dream, Harry. 3444 02:00:19,119 --> 02:00:19,619 Real hope. 3445 02:00:19,619 --> 02:00:21,619 >> All right. 3446 02:00:25,458 --> 02:00:26,159 Hello Everyone before me has 3447 02:00:26,159 --> 02:00:26,759 spoken very eloquently so I'm 3448 02:00:26,759 --> 02:00:27,260 going to keep it short. 3449 02:00:27,260 --> 02:00:29,660 My name is Carrie. 3450 02:00:31,230 --> 02:00:31,932 She her I'm a resident of 3451 02:00:31,932 --> 02:00:32,699 District two and I am against 3452 02:00:32,699 --> 02:00:36,299 Alpers If it's a matter of 3453 02:00:37,360 --> 02:00:37,704 reducing crime while flat 3454 02:00:37,704 --> 02:00:38,438 cameras don't prevent crime 3455 02:00:38,438 --> 02:00:41,438 investments in the community do 3456 02:00:42,942 --> 02:00:43,577 so I urge the council to end 3457 02:00:43,577 --> 02:00:44,210 the contract and take down 3458 02:00:44,210 --> 02:00:44,744 these cameras permanently 3459 02:00:44,744 --> 02:00:47,144 invest the money in 3460 02:00:48,348 --> 02:00:50,348 the community instead. 3461 02:00:55,489 --> 02:00:55,889 >> Thank you, Christine. 3462 02:00:55,889 --> 02:00:56,556 Hi everyone. 3463 02:00:56,556 --> 02:00:59,556 Good to see you all. 3464 02:01:00,961 --> 02:01:01,728 My name is Christine. 3465 02:01:01,728 --> 02:01:02,395 I'm a resident in District nine 3466 02:01:02,395 --> 02:01:02,762 and I work in a couple other 3467 02:01:02,762 --> 02:01:04,762 districts. 3468 02:01:07,133 --> 02:01:07,834 I recently graduated with a 3469 02:01:07,834 --> 02:01:08,167 Ph.D. In math and computer 3470 02:01:08,167 --> 02:01:08,735 science. 3471 02:01:08,735 --> 02:01:09,436 Education is a strong 3472 02:01:09,436 --> 02:01:13,360 background in math and what I 3473 02:01:13,540 --> 02:01:14,307 learned here in San Diego 3474 02:01:14,307 --> 02:01:15,800 studying that is that there's a 3475 02:01:15,800 --> 02:01:15,575 lot of human decisions that go 3476 02:01:15,575 --> 02:01:17,575 into this technology. 3477 02:01:20,113 --> 02:01:20,747 So it MAY feel I'm biased, MAY 3478 02:01:20,747 --> 02:01:21,448 feel effective but there's 3479 02:01:21,448 --> 02:01:22,820 nothing about human decisions 3480 02:01:22,820 --> 02:01:22,716 at the very base level of 3481 02:01:22,716 --> 02:01:25,116 the technology That means 3482 02:01:26,186 --> 02:01:26,853 there's racism, that means 3483 02:01:26,853 --> 02:01:27,521 there's sexism, there's all 3484 02:01:27,521 --> 02:01:27,887 the biases that humans take 3485 02:01:27,887 --> 02:01:29,887 with them. 3486 02:01:31,825 --> 02:01:32,525 I recently also learned at 3487 02:01:32,525 --> 02:01:33,226 the La mesa Police Department 3488 02:01:33,226 --> 02:01:36,226 saw that they had 14,000 scans 3489 02:01:37,831 --> 02:01:38,598 a day on their lpr system. 3490 02:01:38,598 --> 02:01:41,534 The number of scans from La 3491 02:01:41,534 --> 02:01:41,835 mesa Police Department was six 3492 02:01:41,835 --> 02:01:42,602 a day. 3493 02:01:42,602 --> 02:01:43,303 They had 14,000 scanned the day 3494 02:01:43,303 --> 02:01:46,303 on average meaning there were 3495 02:01:47,741 --> 02:01:48,307 many other places and people 3496 02:01:48,307 --> 02:01:49,420 accessing their data. 3497 02:01:49,420 --> 02:01:52,980 So I urge you to consider doing 3498 02:01:52,980 --> 02:01:53,579 more than just canceling a 3499 02:01:53,579 --> 02:01:54,180 contract or taking down 3500 02:01:54,180 --> 02:01:54,715 the cameras and keeping 3501 02:01:54,715 --> 02:01:55,147 the community safe. 3502 02:01:55,147 --> 02:01:57,147 >> Thank you. 3503 02:01:59,920 --> 02:02:00,254 Thank you, Olivia Oh, hello, 3504 02:02:00,254 --> 02:02:00,921 Olivia. 3505 02:02:00,921 --> 02:02:03,921 >> I am in district three. 3506 02:02:06,259 --> 02:02:06,960 I'm a long time San Diego and I 3507 02:02:06,960 --> 02:02:07,661 care about my community and I 3508 02:02:07,661 --> 02:02:11,261 know it's been kind of serious 3509 02:02:11,732 --> 02:02:12,399 so I would like to bring a 3510 02:02:12,399 --> 02:02:13,660 little bit of levity So I'm 3511 02:02:13,660 --> 02:02:13,333 going to sing some songs for 3512 02:02:13,333 --> 02:02:15,333 you. 3513 02:02:17,704 --> 02:02:18,405 >> I'll take them down down 3514 02:02:18,405 --> 02:02:18,705 Take the camera down to San 3515 02:02:18,705 --> 02:02:20,705 Diego. 3516 02:02:23,710 --> 02:02:24,110 We got a deficit in our budget 3517 02:02:24,110 --> 02:02:24,745 . 3518 02:02:24,745 --> 02:02:25,112 Don't need to wait taxes on 3519 02:02:25,112 --> 02:02:27,112 that one. 3520 02:02:29,583 --> 02:02:30,500 That's why I got to go get out 3521 02:02:30,500 --> 02:02:30,950 work right now. 3522 02:02:30,950 --> 02:02:33,950 >> We don't want a surveillance 3523 02:02:35,188 --> 02:02:35,756 state. 3524 02:02:35,756 --> 02:02:36,490 >> It's too late. 3525 02:02:36,490 --> 02:02:36,824 You can't wait to take this 3526 02:02:36,824 --> 02:02:37,324 camera. 3527 02:02:37,324 --> 02:02:39,324 I'm a millennial. 3528 02:02:40,294 --> 02:02:40,994 It's if the following 3529 02:02:40,994 --> 02:02:43,394 individuals can please come 3530 02:02:46,933 --> 02:02:47,601 forward starting with Darth 3531 02:02:47,601 --> 02:02:50,601 Vader then Jim Whalen and 3532 02:02:52,706 --> 02:02:55,106 Korina Vega, Francis Yasmeen 3533 02:02:59,113 --> 02:02:59,880 Mattawa, Agustin and Ella, 3534 02:02:59,880 --> 02:03:02,880 Wendy Geller, Eleanor, if you 3535 02:03:03,117 --> 02:03:06,253 can all please come up to 3536 02:03:06,253 --> 02:03:08,253 the front row. 3537 02:03:13,460 --> 02:03:14,280 >> Darth Vader are you here? 3538 02:03:14,280 --> 02:03:14,528 You've been delayed. 3539 02:03:14,528 --> 02:03:14,928 I get it. 3540 02:03:14,928 --> 02:03:16,928 Never mind. 3541 02:03:19,599 --> 02:03:20,367 I will not do a joke. 3542 02:03:20,367 --> 02:03:23,367 >> Jim Whalen, if you can 3543 02:03:25,172 --> 02:03:25,773 please come forward. 3544 02:03:25,773 --> 02:03:26,373 Good afternoon, Council 3545 02:03:26,373 --> 02:03:27,740 PRESIDENT Carver Council 3546 02:03:27,740 --> 02:03:30,674 members My name is Jim Whalen 3547 02:03:30,744 --> 02:03:31,378 and I don't like to follow 3548 02:03:31,378 --> 02:03:32,120 people who are singing but 3549 02:03:32,120 --> 02:03:35,516 we'll do the best we can. 3550 02:03:35,516 --> 02:03:36,183 I'm a resident of District two 3551 02:03:36,183 --> 02:03:39,783 and I'm a baby boomer here 3552 02:03:40,254 --> 02:03:40,888 against Flack not only because 3553 02:03:40,888 --> 02:03:41,622 I'm fundamentally opposed 3554 02:03:41,622 --> 02:03:44,622 the unlawful searches that Floc 3555 02:03:47,394 --> 02:03:48,950 enables nor the expansion of a 3556 02:03:48,950 --> 02:03:48,395 surveillance state none of us 3557 02:03:48,395 --> 02:03:49,290 wants. 3558 02:03:49,290 --> 02:03:49,730 It's also that the license 3559 02:03:49,730 --> 02:03:52,130 plate reader technology itself 3560 02:03:53,166 --> 02:03:53,868 has demonstrated time and time 3561 02:03:53,868 --> 02:03:54,568 again that it's fatally flawed 3562 02:03:54,568 --> 02:03:57,568 and no supposed guardrails are 3563 02:03:59,720 --> 02:03:59,740 of any value. 3564 02:03:59,740 --> 02:04:00,407 Please There's no point in 3565 02:04:00,407 --> 02:04:01,141 trying to fix this terrible 3566 02:04:01,141 --> 02:04:02,976 program and put the money where 3567 02:04:02,976 --> 02:04:03,410 it helps people rather than 3568 02:04:03,410 --> 02:04:05,410 hurting them. 3569 02:04:12,586 --> 02:04:13,187 >> Thank you Karina Vega It was 3570 02:04:13,187 --> 02:04:13,854 just released today that 3571 02:04:13,854 --> 02:04:16,254 according to The Guardian's 3572 02:04:19,590 --> 02:04:19,627 investigation an Israeli 3573 02:04:19,627 --> 02:04:20,260 military unit uploaded 3574 02:04:20,260 --> 02:04:22,260 approximately 3.5 million 3575 02:04:24,998 --> 02:04:25,766 photographs of Palestinians to 3576 02:04:25,766 --> 02:04:26,333 Amazon Web services in early 24 3577 02:04:26,333 --> 02:04:26,734 for facial recognition 3578 02:04:26,734 --> 02:04:28,734 technology. 3579 02:04:30,971 --> 02:04:31,605 What else would they be using 3580 02:04:31,605 --> 02:04:32,105 this information that they 3581 02:04:32,105 --> 02:04:32,740 continue to commit 3582 02:04:32,740 --> 02:04:33,474 the Palestinian Holocaust. 3583 02:04:33,474 --> 02:04:37,674 Now why would I mention this if 3584 02:04:37,845 --> 02:04:38,579 we are in San Diego? 3585 02:04:38,579 --> 02:04:39,313 One because Todd Gloria happily 3586 02:04:39,313 --> 02:04:39,946 supports the entity that allows 3587 02:04:39,946 --> 02:04:40,314 the surveillance to happen 3588 02:04:40,314 --> 02:04:42,314 overseas. 3589 02:04:43,584 --> 02:04:44,318 Since he attended the finest 3590 02:04:44,318 --> 02:04:47,318 conference that took place this 3591 02:04:47,555 --> 02:04:48,256 last week in San Diego and two 3592 02:04:48,256 --> 02:04:48,889 because of the famous Pulitzer 3593 02:04:48,889 --> 02:04:49,524 Prize winning author Chris 3594 02:04:49,524 --> 02:04:51,924 Hedges mentioned this past 3595 02:04:53,861 --> 02:04:54,295 Thursday in regards to mass 3596 02:04:54,295 --> 02:04:54,828 surveillance. 3597 02:04:54,828 --> 02:04:55,262 It all comes back to 3598 02:04:55,262 --> 02:04:55,930 the homeland. 3599 02:04:55,930 --> 02:04:58,930 We are witnessing the unseen 3600 02:04:59,734 --> 02:05:00,334 terror and power imbalance of 3601 02:05:00,334 --> 02:05:00,801 surveillance without any 3602 02:05:00,801 --> 02:05:01,469 accountability. 3603 02:05:01,469 --> 02:05:05,690 Here in San Diego, just like 3604 02:05:05,306 --> 02:05:06,700 the Palestinians have for 3605 02:05:06,700 --> 02:05:06,640 decades and continue doing so 3606 02:05:06,640 --> 02:05:09,640 until this very second, we 3607 02:05:11,679 --> 02:05:12,313 the citizens are having to pay 3608 02:05:12,313 --> 02:05:12,746 the price and continue our 3609 02:05:12,746 --> 02:05:13,413 lives for it. 3610 02:05:13,413 --> 02:05:14,810 Take the cameras down and in 3611 02:05:14,810 --> 02:05:14,415 the meantime ensure they are 3612 02:05:14,415 --> 02:05:16,415 blocked. 3613 02:05:16,950 --> 02:05:17,285 Thank you, Princess Yasmin 3614 02:05:17,285 --> 02:05:19,285 Malala. 3615 02:05:23,900 --> 02:05:23,791 >> Hello District nine resident 3616 02:05:23,791 --> 02:05:24,459 here Francis Yasmin Moti Well, 3617 02:05:24,459 --> 02:05:27,459 it's real fresh listening to 3618 02:05:28,529 --> 02:05:29,230 Chief Wall talk about how San 3619 02:05:29,230 --> 02:05:29,863 Diego is ahead of other cities 3620 02:05:29,863 --> 02:05:32,863 because we got the Privacy 3621 02:05:35,200 --> 02:05:35,736 Advisory board and we've been 3622 02:05:35,736 --> 02:05:36,470 listening to the community when 3623 02:05:36,470 --> 02:05:37,171 year after year the police have 3624 02:05:37,171 --> 02:05:39,571 been steamrolling the privacy 3625 02:05:40,541 --> 02:05:41,209 advisory Board and encouraging 3626 02:05:41,209 --> 02:05:41,542 you not to listen to their 3627 02:05:41,542 --> 02:05:43,542 advice. 3628 02:05:47,349 --> 02:05:51,119 I think I want to point to 3629 02:05:51,119 --> 02:05:51,785 Wednesday, JULY 22nd and you 3630 02:05:51,785 --> 02:05:52,453 would remember that probably 3631 02:05:52,453 --> 02:05:53,200 not because there was very, 3632 02:05:53,200 --> 02:05:55,420 very little notice to 3633 02:05:57,392 --> 02:05:58,590 the public for this year's 3634 02:05:58,590 --> 02:05:58,693 presentation from the police 3635 02:05:58,693 --> 02:06:01,930 about the new surveillance 3636 02:06:03,798 --> 02:06:04,431 technology that they want 3637 02:06:04,431 --> 02:06:05,132 really they want the fancy 3638 02:06:05,132 --> 02:06:05,867 Ray-Ban recording glasses that 3639 02:06:05,867 --> 02:06:09,169 you know, all the cool kids are 3640 02:06:09,169 --> 02:06:10,400 wearing. 3641 02:06:10,400 --> 02:06:10,671 I don't know that they don't 3642 02:06:10,671 --> 02:06:11,105 even wear their body cameras 3643 02:06:11,105 --> 02:06:13,105 all the time. 3644 02:06:14,775 --> 02:06:15,443 How can we trust them? 3645 02:06:15,443 --> 02:06:16,144 Why should they have more 3646 02:06:16,144 --> 02:06:16,711 technology when we can't trust 3647 02:06:16,711 --> 02:06:19,111 them to always use 3648 02:06:21,820 --> 02:06:21,482 the technology they're supposed 3649 02:06:21,482 --> 02:06:22,500 to be using? 3650 02:06:22,500 --> 02:06:22,550 >> Also, what are 3651 02:06:22,550 --> 02:06:23,170 the alternatives? 3652 02:06:23,170 --> 02:06:23,384 Let's be people. 3653 02:06:23,384 --> 02:06:25,384 Thank you. 3654 02:06:32,993 --> 02:06:33,661 I will still. 3655 02:06:33,661 --> 02:06:33,995 Good afternoon City Council 3656 02:06:33,995 --> 02:06:35,995 members. 3657 02:06:38,833 --> 02:06:39,434 I am a member of the Community 3658 02:06:39,434 --> 02:06:40,134 of City Heights part of 3659 02:06:40,134 --> 02:06:42,534 the immigrant community which 3660 02:06:44,605 --> 02:06:45,306 is offering a lot and we know 3661 02:06:45,306 --> 02:06:48,306 flow cameras have something to 3662 02:06:50,211 --> 02:06:50,879 do with that is way from 3663 02:06:50,879 --> 02:06:53,879 the heart of the community. 3664 02:06:56,184 --> 02:07:00,384 We ask to the City council to 3665 02:07:02,290 --> 02:07:03,570 take the measures to take down 3666 02:07:03,570 --> 02:07:03,958 the cameras who are doing a lot 3667 02:07:03,958 --> 02:07:08,158 of damage to a big sector of 3668 02:07:08,196 --> 02:07:09,300 our community. 3669 02:07:09,300 --> 02:07:09,397 We really concern about what's 3670 02:07:09,397 --> 02:07:11,397 going on. 3671 02:07:14,435 --> 02:07:18,350 I told the community hoping you 3672 02:07:20,742 --> 02:07:21,543 might take the side of 3673 02:07:21,543 --> 02:07:23,943 the communities because of 3674 02:07:26,140 --> 02:07:26,715 communities that are suffering 3675 02:07:26,715 --> 02:07:30,315 and we expect a resolution to 3676 02:07:31,686 --> 02:07:32,420 take those cameras down because 3677 02:07:32,420 --> 02:07:32,987 they are doing a lot of damage 3678 02:07:32,987 --> 02:07:33,555 for these communities. 3679 02:07:33,555 --> 02:07:35,955 >> Thank you so much. 3680 02:07:37,492 --> 02:07:38,460 Thank you, Wendy. 3681 02:07:38,460 --> 02:07:41,460 Next speakers are Wendy Gelman 3682 02:07:43,264 --> 02:07:43,665 gelernter Thank you. 3683 02:07:43,665 --> 02:07:44,299 Thank you. 3684 02:07:44,299 --> 02:07:45,100 Hi, I'm Wendy Gelernter. 3685 02:07:45,100 --> 02:07:48,100 I'm a 40 year resident of 3686 02:07:49,700 --> 02:07:49,737 Pacific Beach and I'm 3687 02:07:49,737 --> 02:07:50,405 representing Take Action San 3688 02:07:50,405 --> 02:07:52,805 Diego with over 2500 members 3689 02:07:54,876 --> 02:07:55,477 and also Pacific Beach United 3690 02:07:55,477 --> 02:07:56,110 which is a neighborhood 3691 02:07:56,110 --> 02:07:56,711 pro-democracy group. 3692 02:07:56,711 --> 02:08:00,311 We have signed a letter urging 3693 02:08:00,982 --> 02:08:01,549 you counsel PRESIDENT And 3694 02:08:01,549 --> 02:08:02,150 the council to cancel 3695 02:08:02,150 --> 02:08:04,550 the contract, take down 3696 02:08:07,389 --> 02:08:08,560 the cameras and do not replace 3697 02:08:08,560 --> 02:08:08,790 them with another company's 3698 02:08:08,790 --> 02:08:11,790 technology lp Our technology is 3699 02:08:13,862 --> 02:08:14,262 dangerous regardless of who 3700 02:08:14,262 --> 02:08:14,996 operates it. 3701 02:08:14,996 --> 02:08:18,596 We say these cameras help solve 3702 02:08:19,367 --> 02:08:20,680 crimes but the technology can 3703 02:08:20,680 --> 02:08:20,769 be useful and still create 3704 02:08:20,769 --> 02:08:21,136 dangers that far outweigh its 3705 02:08:21,136 --> 02:08:23,136 benefits. 3706 02:08:25,674 --> 02:08:26,374 Across the country communities 3707 02:08:26,374 --> 02:08:26,975 are rejecting opioids and San 3708 02:08:26,975 --> 02:08:29,375 Diego should join them. 3709 02:08:31,646 --> 02:08:32,280 Listen to your constituents, 3710 02:08:32,280 --> 02:08:32,914 listen to the evidence and 3711 02:08:32,914 --> 02:08:33,248 the costs and protect our 3712 02:08:33,248 --> 02:08:35,248 privacy. 3713 02:08:37,219 --> 02:08:37,819 Cancel the contract. 3714 02:08:37,819 --> 02:08:38,186 Take the cameras down. 3715 02:08:38,186 --> 02:08:40,186 Thank you. 3716 02:08:43,792 --> 02:08:44,225 Lily Irani Oh, thank you for 3717 02:08:44,225 --> 02:08:46,225 your honesty. 3718 02:08:48,997 --> 02:08:49,698 >> Cristoforo Gomez After 3719 02:08:49,698 --> 02:08:52,698 Cristoforo we're going to have 3720 02:08:55,537 --> 02:08:56,237 Carol Kim Ian Cirillo. 3721 02:08:56,237 --> 02:08:58,637 Mitchell Watson Jason Richie. 3722 02:09:01,709 --> 02:09:02,511 Kenny Cliff Courage. 3723 02:09:02,511 --> 02:09:03,144 >> If you can all please come 3724 02:09:03,144 --> 02:09:03,612 forward to the front row. 3725 02:09:03,612 --> 02:09:04,780 Please proceed. 3726 02:09:04,780 --> 02:09:06,780 Good afternoon. 3727 02:09:08,383 --> 02:09:08,884 Council members My name is 3728 02:09:08,884 --> 02:09:09,584 Christopher Gomez. 3729 02:09:09,584 --> 02:09:10,252 I'm an organizer with the San 3730 02:09:10,252 --> 02:09:12,420 Diego County Labor Council. 3731 02:09:12,420 --> 02:09:13,540 We represent over 130 unions 3732 02:09:13,540 --> 02:09:13,622 and 200,000 working people 3733 02:09:13,622 --> 02:09:14,189 across these counties. 3734 02:09:14,189 --> 02:09:17,189 And for years now this 3735 02:09:18,694 --> 02:09:19,299 community has come together to 3736 02:09:19,299 --> 02:09:19,728 call for an end to 3737 02:09:19,728 --> 02:09:20,328 the contract. 3738 02:09:20,328 --> 02:09:21,290 We applaud those council 3739 02:09:21,290 --> 02:09:24,599 members who have been with us 3740 02:09:24,599 --> 02:09:25,266 from the beginning and even 3741 02:09:25,266 --> 02:09:25,567 those who have since come on 3742 02:09:25,567 --> 02:09:26,168 board. 3743 02:09:26,168 --> 02:09:26,902 But let's be clear that 3744 02:09:26,902 --> 02:09:29,302 the mass community mobilization 3745 02:09:30,839 --> 02:09:31,573 that we have seen is not just 3746 02:09:31,573 --> 02:09:32,174 an indictment of the company or 3747 02:09:32,174 --> 02:09:34,174 this specific contract. 3748 02:09:35,977 --> 02:09:36,779 It is an indictment of 3749 02:09:36,779 --> 02:09:37,479 the technology as a whole in a 3750 02:09:37,479 --> 02:09:37,846 call to end mass surveillance 3751 02:09:37,846 --> 02:09:38,647 entirely. 3752 02:09:38,647 --> 02:09:42,718 So yes, we are demanding an end 3753 02:09:42,718 --> 02:09:43,285 to this contract so that 3754 02:09:43,285 --> 02:09:43,652 the money can be spent 3755 02:09:43,652 --> 02:09:44,352 elsewhere. 3756 02:09:44,352 --> 02:09:47,352 But what the people ultimately 3757 02:09:47,990 --> 02:09:48,691 want to feel safe is a complete 3758 02:09:48,691 --> 02:09:49,358 and sustained removal of this 3759 02:09:49,358 --> 02:09:50,590 tech from their communities. 3760 02:09:50,590 --> 02:09:52,528 So we urge you rejection today 3761 02:09:52,528 --> 02:09:53,262 and your continued support. 3762 02:09:53,262 --> 02:09:55,662 >> This fight moves forward. 3763 02:09:56,498 --> 02:09:58,498 Thank you. 3764 02:09:59,801 --> 02:10:00,169 Carol Kim? 3765 02:10:00,169 --> 02:10:02,169 >> Carol? 3766 02:10:06,374 --> 02:10:06,809 Kim, are you here Maybe in 3767 02:10:06,809 --> 02:10:08,809 the back room. 3768 02:10:12,470 --> 02:10:12,814 >> Carol Kim? 3769 02:10:12,814 --> 02:10:14,814 No, that's okay. 3770 02:10:21,924 --> 02:10:23,924 Ian Cirillo. 3771 02:10:28,197 --> 02:10:28,864 Hello Laura. 3772 02:10:28,864 --> 02:10:29,197 Good afternoon, Council 3773 02:10:29,197 --> 02:10:31,197 members. 3774 02:10:32,201 --> 02:10:32,868 As a resident of District seven 3775 02:10:32,868 --> 02:10:33,602 and of the District District 3776 02:10:33,602 --> 02:10:34,303 seven in San Diego and chair of 3777 02:10:34,303 --> 02:10:37,303 the San Diego Immigrant Rights 3778 02:10:38,400 --> 02:10:38,774 Consortium as the ioc, I call 3779 02:10:38,774 --> 02:10:42,374 on all the city council members 3780 02:10:44,680 --> 02:10:45,214 to reject this technology and 3781 02:10:45,214 --> 02:10:45,614 cancel this contract 3782 02:10:45,614 --> 02:10:46,315 immediately. 3783 02:10:46,315 --> 02:10:49,315 Lpr In other mass surveillance 3784 02:10:49,785 --> 02:10:50,519 technologies do not have a 3785 02:10:50,519 --> 02:10:50,853 place in a free and democratic 3786 02:10:50,853 --> 02:10:52,853 society. 3787 02:10:55,391 --> 02:10:56,920 The there are substantial 3788 02:10:56,920 --> 02:10:56,659 incidents in documented abuses 3789 02:10:56,659 --> 02:10:57,359 of these technologies. 3790 02:10:57,359 --> 02:10:59,759 Immigration agents have access 3791 02:11:01,997 --> 02:11:02,464 and used technology as a tool 3792 02:11:02,464 --> 02:11:03,132 in their illegal 3793 02:11:03,132 --> 02:11:05,132 unconstitutional arrest and 3794 02:11:07,436 --> 02:11:07,936 detention of many of our 3795 02:11:07,936 --> 02:11:08,637 community members. 3796 02:11:08,637 --> 02:11:11,637 While supporters of the Smart 3797 02:11:12,942 --> 02:11:13,542 Surveillance program highlight 3798 02:11:13,542 --> 02:11:14,276 the benefits to criminal 3799 02:11:14,276 --> 02:11:16,676 investigation, the fact remains 3800 02:11:18,714 --> 02:11:19,415 that these harmful technology 3801 02:11:19,415 --> 02:11:20,148 is not indispensable and there 3802 02:11:20,148 --> 02:11:23,148 are other alternative tools and 3803 02:11:26,756 --> 02:11:27,456 good policy options for one 3804 02:11:27,456 --> 02:11:28,124 that the city should invest in 3805 02:11:28,124 --> 02:11:28,924 our youth in libraries in a 3806 02:11:28,924 --> 02:11:29,224 program that will discover you 3807 02:11:29,224 --> 02:11:29,892 . 3808 02:11:29,892 --> 02:11:32,292 >> Thank you for putting 3809 02:11:36,310 --> 02:11:36,499 sentence Mitchell Watson. 3810 02:11:36,499 --> 02:11:36,765 Mitchell Watson. 3811 02:11:36,765 --> 02:11:37,232 No. 3812 02:11:37,232 --> 02:11:39,232 Mitchell Watson. 3813 02:11:43,500 --> 02:11:46,342 McCulley m I t c h e l e l l e 3814 02:11:46,342 --> 02:11:49,942 a Charlie Watson After that is 3815 02:12:03,692 --> 02:12:04,293 okay. 3816 02:12:04,293 --> 02:12:06,293 Good afternoon. 3817 02:12:11,467 --> 02:12:12,135 My name is Michelle Lee Watson. 3818 02:12:12,135 --> 02:12:12,802 >> I'm the legal director of 3819 02:12:12,802 --> 02:12:15,802 Pillars of the Community and 3820 02:12:16,872 --> 02:12:17,540 here we are again for the last 3821 02:12:17,540 --> 02:12:18,730 three years longer than this 3822 02:12:18,730 --> 02:12:18,808 one has been alive. 3823 02:12:18,808 --> 02:12:22,408 We have filled the city council 3824 02:12:22,778 --> 02:12:23,479 chamber to say that we do not 3825 02:12:23,479 --> 02:12:24,130 trust surveillance technology 3826 02:12:24,130 --> 02:12:26,413 for so many reasons. 3827 02:12:28,518 --> 02:12:29,185 One of the main reasons is 3828 02:12:29,185 --> 02:12:29,885 because the community that I 3829 02:12:29,885 --> 02:12:33,485 come from and represent do not 3830 02:12:33,655 --> 02:12:34,323 trust the police. 3831 02:12:34,323 --> 02:12:35,240 >> We have never trusted 3832 02:12:35,240 --> 02:12:35,725 the police and the recent news 3833 02:12:35,725 --> 02:12:38,725 stories have shown exactly why 3834 02:12:39,227 --> 02:12:39,895 we don't trust the police and 3835 02:12:39,895 --> 02:12:40,763 we never will and we can't 3836 02:12:40,763 --> 02:12:44,363 continue to allow them to use 3837 02:12:45,134 --> 02:12:48,134 tools at their disposal to 3838 02:12:51,140 --> 02:12:51,907 harass our community members. 3839 02:12:51,907 --> 02:12:52,208 It does nothing to keep us 3840 02:12:52,208 --> 02:12:52,775 safe. 3841 02:12:52,775 --> 02:12:56,375 And in fact if you ask 3842 02:12:56,846 --> 02:12:57,413 community members from 3843 02:12:57,413 --> 02:12:58,114 the community that we 3844 02:12:58,114 --> 02:12:58,681 represent, they will tell you 3845 02:12:58,681 --> 02:12:59,348 that they do not trust 3846 02:12:59,348 --> 02:13:02,285 the police to protect them. 3847 02:13:02,285 --> 02:13:02,985 So we're asking you today to 3848 02:13:02,985 --> 02:13:05,855 please take down the cameras. 3849 02:13:05,855 --> 02:13:07,855 >> Thank you. 3850 02:13:13,162 --> 02:13:13,596 >> Jason Ritchie My name's 3851 02:13:13,596 --> 02:13:15,596 Jason Ritchie. 3852 02:13:18,635 --> 02:13:19,335 I'm a graduate student at usd 3853 02:13:19,335 --> 02:13:22,335 Practical of Peace and Justice 3854 02:13:23,139 --> 02:13:23,743 and I'm here to oppose Prop 200 3855 02:13:23,743 --> 02:13:24,440 and block surveillance. 3856 02:13:24,440 --> 02:13:28,400 I am not anti-technology and I 3857 02:13:29,779 --> 02:13:30,480 am not even anti surveillance. 3858 02:13:30,480 --> 02:13:33,480 Surveillance can save lives I 3859 02:13:35,118 --> 02:13:35,819 believe but the tool I watch is 3860 02:13:35,819 --> 02:13:36,552 people need are in trust. 3861 02:13:36,552 --> 02:13:37,287 The people internal affairs use 3862 02:13:37,287 --> 02:13:40,824 the network to track a domestic 3863 02:13:40,824 --> 02:13:41,524 violence victim who is not a 3864 02:13:41,524 --> 02:13:42,225 suspect That already happened. 3865 02:13:42,225 --> 02:13:45,825 The person we should have been 3866 02:13:48,397 --> 02:13:49,165 protecting most. 3867 02:13:49,165 --> 02:13:49,933 So what would this party have 3868 02:13:49,933 --> 02:13:52,235 to say to a survivor to feel 3869 02:13:52,235 --> 02:13:53,200 safe to drive home And how can 3870 02:13:53,200 --> 02:13:53,736 we ensure it won't be used by 3871 02:13:53,736 --> 02:13:56,136 bad actors including government 3872 02:13:58,975 --> 02:13:59,542 agents if no policy can 3873 02:13:59,542 --> 02:14:00,243 guarantee that then in 3874 02:14:00,243 --> 02:14:00,944 the program if real limits can 3875 02:14:00,944 --> 02:14:03,120 prevent this please write them 3876 02:14:03,120 --> 02:14:05,120 down and enforcement. 3877 02:14:09,752 --> 02:14:10,487 >> Thank you Kenny Hello 3878 02:14:10,487 --> 02:14:14,870 Council Member My name is Kenny 3879 02:14:15,625 --> 02:14:16,326 Quidditch I am a resident of 3880 02:14:16,326 --> 02:14:17,260 District three Alpers Our mass 3881 02:14:17,260 --> 02:14:20,260 surveillance and an affront to 3882 02:14:22,565 --> 02:14:23,266 liberty and privacy for all 3883 02:14:23,266 --> 02:14:23,867 the residents of San Diego We 3884 02:14:23,867 --> 02:14:25,867 demanded this technology 3885 02:14:28,380 --> 02:14:28,638 authorization be rescinded 3886 02:14:28,638 --> 02:14:29,205 The ap our contracts are 3887 02:14:29,205 --> 02:14:29,872 canceled and that all 3888 02:14:29,872 --> 02:14:32,872 the cameras are taken down. 3889 02:14:33,944 --> 02:14:34,677 We don't need a pause. 3890 02:14:34,677 --> 02:14:35,478 We don't need a reevaluation. 3891 02:14:35,478 --> 02:14:39,482 The time is now for some real 3892 02:14:39,482 --> 02:14:40,116 bold action and we won't accept 3893 02:14:40,116 --> 02:14:40,783 allowing Floc or others to 3894 02:14:40,783 --> 02:14:43,183 continue harvesting our data 3895 02:14:45,288 --> 02:14:45,955 and violating our rights even 3896 02:14:45,955 --> 02:14:46,323 if the city's contracts are 3897 02:14:46,323 --> 02:14:47,123 canceled. 3898 02:14:47,123 --> 02:14:51,323 Now to be clear there is no 3899 02:14:51,661 --> 02:14:52,328 version of this system that 3900 02:14:52,328 --> 02:14:53,630 would be acceptable no rules 3901 02:14:53,630 --> 02:14:56,630 that would make it conscionable 3902 02:14:57,300 --> 02:14:58,100 no guardrails sufficient to 3903 02:14:58,100 --> 02:15:01,100 eliminate abuse esdp esdp has 3904 02:15:02,706 --> 02:15:03,506 proven themselves untrustworthy 3905 02:15:03,506 --> 02:15:04,141 in the sense and does not get 3906 02:15:04,141 --> 02:15:04,774 the benefit of the doubt. 3907 02:15:04,774 --> 02:15:07,774 Please read the writing on 3908 02:15:08,711 --> 02:15:09,450 the wall and take the system 3909 02:15:09,450 --> 02:15:09,546 down. 3910 02:15:09,546 --> 02:15:11,546 >> Thank you. 3911 02:15:14,885 --> 02:15:15,585 Rebecca Fielding Miller Rebecca 3912 02:15:15,585 --> 02:15:16,286 Fielding Miller If you can 3913 02:15:16,286 --> 02:15:19,286 please come to the microphone 3914 02:15:19,388 --> 02:15:22,988 After that is count Cloud count 3915 02:15:26,829 --> 02:15:29,229 flotilla count Glenn Ashley 3916 02:15:31,835 --> 02:15:32,535 McCollum, Adina Flores, Sabrina 3917 02:15:32,535 --> 02:15:35,535 Moran, Amber Lily Thompson and 3918 02:15:37,441 --> 02:15:38,800 Daniel Larsen if you can all 3919 02:15:38,800 --> 02:15:38,442 please come forward to 3920 02:15:38,442 --> 02:15:39,420 the front row. 3921 02:15:39,420 --> 02:15:39,409 Rebecca Please proceed. 3922 02:15:39,409 --> 02:15:41,409 Thank you. 3923 02:15:43,547 --> 02:15:44,281 My name is Rebecca Fielding 3924 02:15:44,281 --> 02:15:45,150 Miller I live in District seven 3925 02:15:45,150 --> 02:15:49,215 and I want to start by thanking 3926 02:15:49,720 --> 02:15:50,420 my council member Campo for his 3927 02:15:50,420 --> 02:15:51,154 thoughtfulness in reevaluating 3928 02:15:51,154 --> 02:15:55,354 your stance on Floc I know that 3929 02:15:56,493 --> 02:15:57,160 this is a suspension and I. 3930 02:15:57,160 --> 02:15:57,827 I appreciate that and I 3931 02:15:57,827 --> 02:16:00,827 encourage you to maintain a 3932 02:16:02,365 --> 02:16:02,832 critical mind on what it can do 3933 02:16:02,832 --> 02:16:04,832 to the activity. 3934 02:16:07,370 --> 02:16:07,838 I just watched you use a slide 3935 02:16:07,838 --> 02:16:08,505 with a 12 year survivor of 3936 02:16:08,505 --> 02:16:11,505 sexual assault as a talking 3937 02:16:14,344 --> 02:16:15,780 point for your budget for mass 3938 02:16:15,780 --> 02:16:15,779 surveillance That is cynical to 3939 02:16:15,779 --> 02:16:19,379 the point of shameful MS. And 3940 02:16:19,415 --> 02:16:20,830 you should feel bad that you 3941 02:16:20,830 --> 02:16:20,784 are using a technology that 3942 02:16:20,784 --> 02:16:24,384 puts women and people of color 3943 02:16:26,123 --> 02:16:26,924 and people at higher risk than 3944 02:16:26,924 --> 02:16:27,624 you are using a child to 3945 02:16:27,624 --> 02:16:28,292 advance your budget for a tool 3946 02:16:28,292 --> 02:16:28,892 that hurts people at higher 3947 02:16:28,892 --> 02:16:31,292 risk of sexual assault. 3948 02:16:35,699 --> 02:16:36,366 That is shameful. 3949 02:16:36,366 --> 02:16:37,670 We are told that this 3950 02:16:37,670 --> 02:16:40,670 technology there is no there's 3951 02:16:40,304 --> 02:16:40,771 no safe way to use 3952 02:16:40,771 --> 02:16:41,405 the technology. 3953 02:16:41,405 --> 02:16:44,405 >> It can only be deleted. 3954 02:16:45,242 --> 02:16:47,242 Thank you. 3955 02:16:51,715 --> 02:16:54,715 >> Is the count here Three 3956 02:16:56,720 --> 02:16:57,254 things I am proud of 3957 02:16:57,254 --> 02:16:57,954 the District three. 3958 02:16:57,954 --> 02:16:58,656 First, I find it disturbing to 3959 02:16:58,656 --> 02:17:02,256 me not even having this point 3960 02:17:02,359 --> 02:17:03,260 to hear from the riffraff But 3961 02:17:03,260 --> 02:17:03,393 alas I will respond to their 3962 02:17:03,393 --> 02:17:05,393 concerns. 3963 02:17:07,298 --> 02:17:08,265 Yes, our devices MAY have an 3964 02:17:08,265 --> 02:17:08,966 error rate of 10% or so but how 3965 02:17:08,966 --> 02:17:11,966 will we reduce our experience 3966 02:17:15,500 --> 02:17:15,739 with on the populace When for 3967 02:17:15,739 --> 02:17:16,407 help the Toledo police pulled a 3968 02:17:16,407 --> 02:17:17,107 man over for stolen plates. 3969 02:17:17,107 --> 02:17:18,575 The police released a k-9 upon 3970 02:17:18,575 --> 02:17:19,900 him sending him to 3971 02:17:19,900 --> 02:17:19,677 the hospital. 3972 02:17:19,677 --> 02:17:20,344 But as we learned, the seven 3973 02:17:20,344 --> 02:17:24,314 does look a bit like a two. 3974 02:17:24,314 --> 02:17:25,820 Who knew? 3975 02:17:25,820 --> 02:17:25,749 If you track our system, our 3976 02:17:25,749 --> 02:17:26,450 police officers track their 3977 02:17:26,450 --> 02:17:28,850 ex-girlfriends to ensure they 3978 02:17:30,540 --> 02:17:30,654 aren't dating anyone of concern 3979 02:17:30,654 --> 02:17:31,355 a police department that 3980 02:17:31,355 --> 02:17:31,988 refuses to share details with 3981 02:17:31,988 --> 02:17:34,988 the City council about ice 3982 02:17:36,561 --> 02:17:37,294 kidnapings is one we can trust 3983 02:17:37,294 --> 02:17:37,728 to find a way to share that 3984 02:17:37,728 --> 02:17:39,728 data with ice. 3985 02:17:41,832 --> 02:17:42,499 But we did initially configure 3986 02:17:42,499 --> 02:17:43,133 our system to automatically 3987 02:17:43,133 --> 02:17:43,500 share data with all other 3988 02:17:43,500 --> 02:17:44,134 agencies. 3989 02:17:44,134 --> 02:17:44,768 The police department did 3990 02:17:44,768 --> 02:17:47,768 notice after a few weeks. 3991 02:17:47,805 --> 02:17:48,439 So if you decide to merely 3992 02:17:48,439 --> 02:17:49,139 pause operations I want to 3993 02:17:49,139 --> 02:17:49,840 assure you we will find a way 3994 02:17:49,840 --> 02:17:52,840 to extract the information we 3995 02:17:55,413 --> 02:17:55,779 need to sustain us and our 3996 02:17:55,779 --> 02:17:56,513 investors. 3997 02:17:56,513 --> 02:17:56,881 >> Think of that comes flooding 3998 02:17:56,881 --> 02:17:58,415 sometimes. 3999 02:17:58,415 --> 02:18:00,415 Ashley McCullough. 4000 02:18:05,556 --> 02:18:05,956 >> Good afternoon City Council 4001 02:18:05,956 --> 02:18:06,757 Call. 4002 02:18:06,757 --> 02:18:07,425 My name is Ashley McCullough. 4003 02:18:07,425 --> 02:18:08,158 I'm a student organizer with 4004 02:18:08,158 --> 02:18:11,158 the Center on Policy Initiative 4005 02:18:11,962 --> 02:18:12,696 and a proud resident of d four 4006 02:18:12,696 --> 02:18:13,300 on my daily route to school or 4007 02:18:13,300 --> 02:18:15,300 to work. 4008 02:18:17,434 --> 02:18:17,768 I pass about 50 alpers or block 4009 02:18:17,768 --> 02:18:19,768 cameras. 4010 02:18:21,710 --> 02:18:21,839 >> The one that scares me 4011 02:18:21,839 --> 02:18:22,540 the most is the one that sits 4012 02:18:22,540 --> 02:18:23,240 on Imperial Avenue across from 4013 02:18:23,240 --> 02:18:26,840 where Hoffman's used to be in 4014 02:18:27,178 --> 02:18:27,911 Lincoln High School a high 4015 02:18:27,911 --> 02:18:28,545 school, a block camera scary in 4016 02:18:28,545 --> 02:18:30,945 a district that has 4017 02:18:32,583 --> 02:18:33,217 historically been overpoliced, 4018 02:18:33,217 --> 02:18:33,918 underprivileged and taken 4019 02:18:33,918 --> 02:18:36,918 advantage of the existence of 4020 02:18:37,754 --> 02:18:38,255 the surveillance weapons only 4021 02:18:38,255 --> 02:18:38,889 serves to continue 4022 02:18:38,889 --> 02:18:39,590 the tradition of policing 4023 02:18:39,590 --> 02:18:40,240 the free movement of black and 4024 02:18:40,240 --> 02:18:42,240 brown bodies. 4025 02:18:43,327 --> 02:18:44,620 We do not want floc. 4026 02:18:44,620 --> 02:18:44,462 We do not want to be 4027 02:18:44,462 --> 02:18:46,462 surveilled. 4028 02:18:46,930 --> 02:18:47,365 We need systems for the people 4029 02:18:47,365 --> 02:18:49,365 by the people. 4030 02:18:49,867 --> 02:18:51,867 >> Thank you. 4031 02:19:01,979 --> 02:19:02,747 A dinner for us. 4032 02:19:02,747 --> 02:19:03,414 >> Good afternoon, counsel. 4033 02:19:03,414 --> 02:19:06,414 My name is Dina Flores. 4034 02:19:06,450 --> 02:19:07,150 I'm one of California's leading 4035 02:19:07,150 --> 02:19:07,686 civil rights activists and I'm 4036 02:19:07,686 --> 02:19:09,686 highly against Floc. 4037 02:19:11,922 --> 02:19:12,657 >> I moved down here because I 4038 02:19:12,657 --> 02:19:13,291 was actually extorted by the pr 4039 02:19:13,291 --> 02:19:16,891 firm I was working for our 4040 02:19:17,728 --> 02:19:18,462 family in law enforcement. 4041 02:19:18,462 --> 02:19:19,290 I respect law enforcement here 4042 02:19:19,290 --> 02:19:19,764 and I appreciate their 4043 02:19:19,764 --> 02:19:20,131 hospitality when I entered your 4044 02:19:20,131 --> 02:19:22,131 building. 4045 02:19:23,601 --> 02:19:24,202 That being said, I was working 4046 02:19:24,202 --> 02:19:24,902 for a White Star group. 4047 02:19:24,902 --> 02:19:25,203 I was the researcher for Mark 4048 02:19:25,203 --> 02:19:26,103 Adams. 4049 02:19:26,103 --> 02:19:28,572 He was a former officer who was 4050 02:19:28,572 --> 02:19:29,273 a detective with my uncle. 4051 02:19:29,273 --> 02:19:32,176 i'm litigating I am the victim 4052 02:19:32,176 --> 02:19:32,810 advocate for over 40 4053 02:19:32,810 --> 02:19:33,477 undocumented boys who were 4054 02:19:33,477 --> 02:19:34,111 raped and trafficked at Boys 4055 02:19:34,111 --> 02:19:34,644 and Girls Club, the clubs 4056 02:19:34,644 --> 02:19:37,440 refusing to pay them 4057 02:19:38,150 --> 02:19:38,782 restitution. 4058 02:19:38,782 --> 02:19:39,484 They're claiming I made it all 4059 02:19:39,484 --> 02:19:39,950 up as the Predator spends 150 4060 02:19:39,950 --> 02:19:41,950 years in prison. 4061 02:19:44,455 --> 02:19:45,189 So my question is it law 4062 02:19:45,189 --> 02:19:45,723 enforcement offered me money to 4063 02:19:45,723 --> 02:19:46,124 be quiet about child 4064 02:19:46,124 --> 02:19:48,124 trafficking. 4065 02:19:48,426 --> 02:19:49,127 How can I be assured that 4066 02:19:49,127 --> 02:19:49,427 you're telling the truth about 4067 02:19:49,427 --> 02:19:50,270 Floc? 4068 02:19:50,270 --> 02:19:50,728 I heard a whole bunch of 4069 02:19:50,728 --> 02:19:53,728 identity politics today If we 4070 02:19:54,765 --> 02:19:55,466 don't get justice for these 4071 02:19:55,466 --> 02:19:56,330 boys and my case then everyone 4072 02:19:56,330 --> 02:19:56,467 might as well go home. 4073 02:19:56,467 --> 02:19:56,901 GOD bless you. 4074 02:19:56,901 --> 02:19:58,901 Jesus Christ. 4075 02:19:59,437 --> 02:19:59,904 My Lord and Savior And I do 4076 02:19:59,904 --> 02:20:01,904 tell the truth. 4077 02:20:04,542 --> 02:20:06,542 >> Sabrina Good afternoon, 4078 02:20:11,449 --> 02:20:12,116 Council members My name MR. 4079 02:20:12,116 --> 02:20:12,717 Brennan far from the presser 4080 02:20:12,717 --> 02:20:13,451 I'm concerned about this 4081 02:20:13,451 --> 02:20:14,180 presser surveillance and drones 4082 02:20:14,180 --> 02:20:15,987 because it affects our 4083 02:20:15,987 --> 02:20:16,654 community by instilling fear 4084 02:20:16,654 --> 02:20:17,188 and possibly is reinforcing 4085 02:20:17,188 --> 02:20:19,188 racial stereotypes. 4086 02:20:20,892 --> 02:20:21,593 Aside from that, surveillance 4087 02:20:21,593 --> 02:20:22,193 as a whole threatens our right 4088 02:20:22,193 --> 02:20:22,927 to privacy in our lives. 4089 02:20:22,927 --> 02:20:25,963 It tracks our community and has 4090 02:20:25,963 --> 02:20:26,698 the right to to find out 4091 02:20:26,698 --> 02:20:27,650 everything about us in the name 4092 02:20:27,650 --> 02:20:27,731 of safety. 4093 02:20:27,731 --> 02:20:31,331 It asserts power in a place 4094 02:20:31,402 --> 02:20:32,360 where we're all supposed to be 4095 02:20:32,360 --> 02:20:32,603 equal and an imbalance of 4096 02:20:32,603 --> 02:20:32,971 the scale of trusting 4097 02:20:32,971 --> 02:20:33,670 conscious. 4098 02:20:33,670 --> 02:20:36,241 It humanizes us and treats its 4099 02:20:36,241 --> 02:20:36,941 like numbers to fall through 4100 02:20:36,941 --> 02:20:37,542 cameras, pbs tracking browser 4101 02:20:37,542 --> 02:20:37,875 tracking and our license 4102 02:20:37,875 --> 02:20:39,875 plates. 4103 02:20:41,679 --> 02:20:42,130 I urge you to vote to ban 4104 02:20:42,130 --> 02:20:42,713 Yelpers. 4105 02:20:42,713 --> 02:20:43,415 Our community is so much more 4106 02:20:43,415 --> 02:20:45,617 than I.D. Numbers and license 4107 02:20:45,617 --> 02:20:46,284 plates and instead of adding 4108 02:20:46,284 --> 02:20:46,918 more technology and power to 4109 02:20:46,918 --> 02:20:47,552 control us we should look 4110 02:20:47,552 --> 02:20:48,219 through more preventative 4111 02:20:48,219 --> 02:20:48,820 measures so we can actually 4112 02:20:48,820 --> 02:20:51,820 have a safer San Diego. 4113 02:20:56,461 --> 02:20:56,961 >> Thank you Lily Thompson Good 4114 02:20:56,961 --> 02:20:58,961 afternoon Counsel. 4115 02:21:02,300 --> 02:21:02,801 My name is Lily Tomlin and I 4116 02:21:02,801 --> 02:21:03,368 live in Oklahoma. 4117 02:21:03,368 --> 02:21:04,200 Last year the state of 4118 02:21:04,200 --> 02:21:06,402 California sued my city's 4119 02:21:06,838 --> 02:21:07,506 police department for sharing 4120 02:21:07,506 --> 02:21:08,139 our license plate data with 4121 02:21:08,139 --> 02:21:08,806 with law enforcement in 26 4122 02:21:08,806 --> 02:21:11,543 other states and the federal 4123 02:21:11,543 --> 02:21:12,277 government. 4124 02:21:12,277 --> 02:21:12,544 That's illegal under California 4125 02:21:12,544 --> 02:21:13,144 law. 4126 02:21:13,144 --> 02:21:13,812 The attorney general had 4127 02:21:13,812 --> 02:21:16,812 already warned them and they 4128 02:21:17,349 --> 02:21:18,830 did it regardless when 4129 02:21:18,830 --> 02:21:18,583 the lawsuit was filed Our mayor 4130 02:21:18,583 --> 02:21:19,317 MAY no apologies. 4131 02:21:19,317 --> 02:21:20,180 So when you hear today that San 4132 02:21:20,180 --> 02:21:22,180 Diego State counterproductive 4133 02:21:22,187 --> 02:21:22,921 it will protect residents. 4134 02:21:22,921 --> 02:21:23,622 I want you to understand what 4135 02:21:23,622 --> 02:21:26,220 those safeguards actually are. 4136 02:21:27,250 --> 02:21:27,725 They are simply a promise that 4137 02:21:27,725 --> 02:21:28,460 one setting stays turned off. 4138 02:21:28,460 --> 02:21:28,926 My city turned that turned it 4139 02:21:28,926 --> 02:21:30,926 on deliberately. 4140 02:21:32,830 --> 02:21:33,465 San Diego vendor left it on by 4141 02:21:33,465 --> 02:21:34,990 mistake for three weeks in 4142 02:21:34,990 --> 02:21:34,766 Carpenter of United States 4143 02:21:34,766 --> 02:21:36,968 The Supreme Court recognized 4144 02:21:36,968 --> 02:21:37,669 that enough location data 4145 02:21:37,669 --> 02:21:38,370 collected over time creates a 4146 02:21:38,370 --> 02:21:39,370 portrait of a person's entire 4147 02:21:39,370 --> 02:21:42,370 life a portrait that details 4148 02:21:42,374 --> 02:21:43,730 should never be at the will of 4149 02:21:43,730 --> 02:21:43,741 one department especially when 4150 02:21:43,741 --> 02:21:44,442 that department has lost our 4151 02:21:44,442 --> 02:21:47,245 trust in its ability to a poll 4152 02:21:47,245 --> 02:21:48,130 or privacy. 4153 02:21:48,130 --> 02:21:48,713 Some of this Council have 4154 02:21:48,713 --> 02:21:49,381 suggested that we simply pause 4155 02:21:49,381 --> 02:21:49,648 this program while we review 4156 02:21:49,648 --> 02:21:50,214 it. 4157 02:21:50,214 --> 02:21:53,840 But a promise is not a 4158 02:21:53,840 --> 02:21:53,451 protection and a pause is not a 4159 02:21:53,451 --> 02:21:54,119 solution. 4160 02:21:54,119 --> 02:21:54,752 A pause just means the same 4161 02:21:54,752 --> 02:21:57,752 system with the same risks 4162 02:21:58,890 --> 02:21:59,624 waiting to be turned back on 4163 02:21:59,624 --> 02:22:00,258 and the contract and ban opens. 4164 02:22:00,258 --> 02:22:02,258 >> Thank you Daniel. 4165 02:22:15,740 --> 02:22:16,541 All me Cookie Monster And today 4166 02:22:16,541 --> 02:22:19,745 MAY not here for cookies and me 4167 02:22:19,745 --> 02:22:20,445 here for flood cameras San 4168 02:22:20,445 --> 02:22:21,213 Diego we have a big problem. 4169 02:22:21,213 --> 02:22:23,613 These cameras can license 4170 02:22:24,982 --> 02:22:25,684 plates of ordinary people going 4171 02:22:25,684 --> 02:22:29,284 to work taking their kids to 4172 02:22:29,621 --> 02:22:30,489 school or buying cookies. 4173 02:22:30,489 --> 02:22:34,890 But my biggest but my biggest 4174 02:22:34,859 --> 02:22:35,360 concern are constitutional 4175 02:22:35,360 --> 02:22:36,610 rights. 4176 02:22:36,610 --> 02:22:36,762 The Fourth Amendment protects 4177 02:22:36,762 --> 02:22:38,762 Americans against unreasonable 4178 02:22:40,866 --> 02:22:41,533 searches and seizures. 4179 02:22:41,533 --> 02:22:42,233 Me Ask City Council those 4180 02:22:42,233 --> 02:22:44,633 tracking innocent people who 4181 02:22:49,574 --> 02:22:49,908 violate our constitutional 4182 02:22:49,908 --> 02:22:50,609 rights. 4183 02:22:50,609 --> 02:22:53,609 Public safety is important but 4184 02:22:55,847 --> 02:22:56,648 so is our Constitution. 4185 02:22:56,648 --> 02:22:57,415 Me Respect Police Chief Scott 4186 02:22:57,415 --> 02:23:00,415 While we disagree on flood 4187 02:23:01,860 --> 02:23:01,520 cameras but he still has my 4188 02:23:01,520 --> 02:23:03,520 support today. 4189 02:23:04,223 --> 02:23:04,923 City COUNCILWOMAN Esther must 4190 02:23:04,923 --> 02:23:05,490 answer one question Who is 4191 02:23:05,490 --> 02:23:06,224 watching the Watchers? 4192 02:23:06,224 --> 02:23:09,427 And if those cameras don't come 4193 02:23:09,427 --> 02:23:09,862 down Cookie Monster going to 4194 02:23:09,862 --> 02:23:10,229 eat them all? 4195 02:23:10,229 --> 02:23:10,996 I'm not. 4196 02:23:10,996 --> 02:23:14,366 I'm nom nom nom nom nom. 4197 02:23:14,366 --> 02:23:15,133 Protect our constitu ation. 4198 02:23:15,133 --> 02:23:17,533 >> Your time has concluded. 4199 02:23:18,637 --> 02:23:19,104 Brandon Jackson. 4200 02:23:19,104 --> 02:23:19,805 Brandon Jackson. 4201 02:23:19,805 --> 02:23:23,405 If you can please come forward 4202 02:23:23,842 --> 02:23:28,420 to the mic after that is Darwin 4203 02:23:28,480 --> 02:23:28,980 Fishman Cyrus Maharajah. 4204 02:23:28,980 --> 02:23:30,980 Heather Hughes. 4205 02:23:34,787 --> 02:23:37,187 Nicolette Justice Jesse Schmidt 4206 02:23:39,240 --> 02:23:39,892 Smitty allegedly Audra and then 4207 02:23:39,892 --> 02:23:40,325 I believe this is a do of. 4208 02:23:40,325 --> 02:23:42,325 Nicole Sharma. 4209 02:23:44,129 --> 02:23:44,863 Please proceed. 4210 02:23:44,863 --> 02:23:45,531 >> Good evening, City Council. 4211 02:23:45,531 --> 02:23:48,400 My name is Brandon Jackson, 4212 02:23:48,400 --> 02:23:49,340 Southern Area Coordinator for 4213 02:23:49,340 --> 02:23:49,433 the Libertarian Party of 4214 02:23:49,433 --> 02:23:50,202 California. 4215 02:23:50,202 --> 02:23:53,605 In this room you have folks of 4216 02:23:53,605 --> 02:23:54,206 all walks of life. 4217 02:23:54,206 --> 02:23:54,672 They're all telling you 4218 02:23:54,672 --> 02:23:56,672 the same thing. 4219 02:23:58,544 --> 02:23:59,178 We the people are dumping, 4220 02:23:59,178 --> 02:23:59,712 tracked, logged and herded 4221 02:23:59,712 --> 02:24:01,712 around like cattle. 4222 02:24:02,810 --> 02:24:02,714 And our cameras violate our 4223 02:24:02,714 --> 02:24:03,480 Fourth Amendment right to 4224 02:24:03,480 --> 02:24:05,480 privacy. 4225 02:24:06,452 --> 02:24:06,985 And they pursue the draconian 4226 02:24:06,985 --> 02:24:07,552 surveillance state. 4227 02:24:07,552 --> 02:24:08,187 These cameras are not 4228 02:24:08,187 --> 02:24:10,187 traditional license plate 4229 02:24:12,240 --> 02:24:12,891 readers. 4230 02:24:12,891 --> 02:24:13,525 Lpr like Flock has a built in 4231 02:24:13,525 --> 02:24:16,525 to track everyone in their 4232 02:24:17,162 --> 02:24:17,697 travel routes regardless of a 4233 02:24:17,697 --> 02:24:18,429 crime was committed. 4234 02:24:18,429 --> 02:24:21,800 Anyone can gain access to these 4235 02:24:21,800 --> 02:24:22,167 cameras including ice, dhs, cia 4236 02:24:22,167 --> 02:24:24,167 and more. 4237 02:24:25,871 --> 02:24:26,538 No one and no one is exempt 4238 02:24:26,538 --> 02:24:27,139 from being tracked including 4239 02:24:27,139 --> 02:24:30,376 all of you on a sitting 4240 02:24:30,376 --> 02:24:31,343 council, Mayor and pd. 4241 02:24:31,343 --> 02:24:34,343 Even if this pd states 4242 02:24:35,414 --> 02:24:36,114 otherwise aclu has already 4243 02:24:36,114 --> 02:24:39,114 uncovered abuse of the system 4244 02:24:40,520 --> 02:24:40,719 and it will only get worse. 4245 02:24:40,719 --> 02:24:41,487 We the people are watching. 4246 02:24:41,487 --> 02:24:45,687 You can all either vote in line 4247 02:24:45,928 --> 02:24:46,792 with your constituents in mass 4248 02:24:46,792 --> 02:24:47,293 or betray and sell them out to 4249 02:24:47,293 --> 02:24:47,860 special interests. 4250 02:24:47,860 --> 02:24:48,527 Choose wisely your own 4251 02:24:48,527 --> 02:24:48,894 priorities and rights are on 4252 02:24:48,894 --> 02:24:50,894 the line. 4253 02:24:53,832 --> 02:24:54,133 As concluded Darwin Fishman. 4254 02:24:54,133 --> 02:24:56,133 Okay. 4255 02:24:59,505 --> 02:25:00,206 Good afternoon, City Council 4256 02:25:00,206 --> 02:25:00,940 members Darwin Fishman He and 4257 02:25:00,940 --> 02:25:03,342 his Racial Justice Coalition of 4258 02:25:03,342 --> 02:25:04,900 San Diego. 4259 02:25:04,900 --> 02:25:04,710 And we also believe that 4260 02:25:04,710 --> 02:25:07,710 the cameras should come down. 4261 02:25:08,381 --> 02:25:09,480 And it's finally time after 4262 02:25:09,480 --> 02:25:09,448 years of us coming here and 4263 02:25:09,448 --> 02:25:10,490 testifying. 4264 02:25:10,490 --> 02:25:12,490 And surprise, surprise, 4265 02:25:13,552 --> 02:25:14,253 everything we said has come 4266 02:25:14,253 --> 02:25:17,723 true about how it'll be used 4267 02:25:17,723 --> 02:25:18,900 and how to be abused And if 4268 02:25:18,900 --> 02:25:18,790 whatever. 4269 02:25:18,790 --> 02:25:19,158 Many years later we're finally 4270 02:25:19,158 --> 02:25:19,592 validated. 4271 02:25:19,592 --> 02:25:21,592 That's great. 4272 02:25:22,794 --> 02:25:23,496 I also want to just say real 4273 02:25:23,496 --> 02:25:24,196 quickly for something for you 4274 02:25:24,196 --> 02:25:27,196 guys to think about moving 4275 02:25:27,499 --> 02:25:28,233 forward. 4276 02:25:28,233 --> 02:25:28,935 One of the greatest myths about 4277 02:25:28,935 --> 02:25:29,669 the police is that everything 4278 02:25:29,669 --> 02:25:32,700 is working well and that if you 4279 02:25:32,700 --> 02:25:32,705 give them the cameras 4280 02:25:32,705 --> 02:25:33,390 everything will work even 4281 02:25:33,390 --> 02:25:35,390 better. 4282 02:25:37,410 --> 02:25:38,177 I was while I was driving on 4283 02:25:38,177 --> 02:25:41,777 the 94 this year my car was 4284 02:25:42,615 --> 02:25:43,482 shot at I don't know actually 4285 02:25:43,482 --> 02:25:43,983 still to this day when I was a 4286 02:25:43,983 --> 02:25:46,383 pellet or a gun. 4287 02:25:47,587 --> 02:25:48,287 But when I went to the police 4288 02:25:48,287 --> 02:25:48,754 they never investigated, never 4289 02:25:48,754 --> 02:25:50,754 looked into it. 4290 02:25:51,590 --> 02:25:51,924 They basically ask why I was 4291 02:25:51,924 --> 02:25:52,291 injured. 4292 02:25:52,291 --> 02:25:52,858 I wasn't. 4293 02:25:52,858 --> 02:25:53,592 Nothing was ever done. 4294 02:25:53,592 --> 02:25:56,295 I think there's a real question 4295 02:25:56,295 --> 02:25:56,996 about what real police work is 4296 02:25:56,996 --> 02:25:57,596 being done even after these 4297 02:25:57,596 --> 02:25:58,300 cameras are taken down. 4298 02:25:58,300 --> 02:26:00,300 >> Thank you. 4299 02:26:04,837 --> 02:26:05,705 Next, if Iris and I believe I'm 4300 02:26:05,705 --> 02:26:08,640 about to get to a lot of dupes 4301 02:26:08,640 --> 02:26:09,408 right now so you've already 4302 02:26:09,408 --> 02:26:09,909 spoken please do not come up or 4303 02:26:09,909 --> 02:26:10,376 just let me know. 4304 02:26:10,376 --> 02:26:12,376 Please proceed. 4305 02:26:13,546 --> 02:26:14,179 Thank you. 4306 02:26:14,179 --> 02:26:14,881 Take the cameras down. 4307 02:26:14,881 --> 02:26:15,381 DR. Cyrus Bharucha, a resident 4308 02:26:15,381 --> 02:26:17,381 of District five. 4309 02:26:19,185 --> 02:26:19,785 I'm grateful to those on 4310 02:26:19,785 --> 02:26:20,420 the Council have already 4311 02:26:20,420 --> 02:26:22,820 expressed your support for 4312 02:26:22,822 --> 02:26:23,756 moving against the cameras. 4313 02:26:23,756 --> 02:26:24,560 But let's make sure we do it 4314 02:26:24,560 --> 02:26:24,757 right. 4315 02:26:24,757 --> 02:26:27,560 I'm Generation x My whole life 4316 02:26:27,560 --> 02:26:28,127 I watched while elected 4317 02:26:28,127 --> 02:26:28,728 officials let the tech 4318 02:26:28,728 --> 02:26:31,128 companies and Titans do 4319 02:26:32,650 --> 02:26:32,732 whatever they liked. 4320 02:26:32,732 --> 02:26:33,165 But Americans want something 4321 02:26:33,165 --> 02:26:35,165 different now. 4322 02:26:37,300 --> 02:26:37,703 We want our leaders to be on 4323 02:26:37,703 --> 02:26:41,303 our side In San Diego, in 4324 02:26:41,474 --> 02:26:42,341 Sacramento, in Washington. 4325 02:26:42,341 --> 02:26:43,900 We don't want you to be chumps 4326 02:26:43,900 --> 02:26:45,409 for the technology companies 4327 02:26:46,445 --> 02:26:47,213 and billionaires. 4328 02:26:47,213 --> 02:26:47,747 We're counting on you to 4329 02:26:47,747 --> 02:26:49,747 protect our privacy. 4330 02:26:51,384 --> 02:26:52,180 Privacy is an issue that voters 4331 02:26:52,180 --> 02:26:55,180 of all stripes care about. 4332 02:26:55,921 --> 02:26:56,589 All the voters will notice and 4333 02:26:56,589 --> 02:26:56,990 be grateful when you protect 4334 02:26:56,990 --> 02:26:57,523 our privacy. 4335 02:26:57,523 --> 02:26:59,923 Do it right though. 4336 02:27:01,940 --> 02:27:01,828 Take the cameras down. 4337 02:27:01,828 --> 02:27:04,228 >> We're counting on you. 4338 02:27:05,498 --> 02:27:05,999 Thank you. 4339 02:27:05,999 --> 02:27:07,999 >> Thank you. 4340 02:27:13,390 --> 02:27:13,439 Next is Heather Hughes. 4341 02:27:13,439 --> 02:27:14,273 >> Hello. 4342 02:27:14,273 --> 02:27:17,873 I'm a voter in District one. 4343 02:27:18,778 --> 02:27:19,445 And first I want to say that I 4344 02:27:19,445 --> 02:27:22,445 do understand the appeal of 4345 02:27:23,820 --> 02:27:23,383 automated license plate readers 4346 02:27:23,383 --> 02:27:24,117 . 4347 02:27:24,117 --> 02:27:24,817 They are sold to us sometimes 4348 02:27:24,817 --> 02:27:27,654 very convincingly as tools to 4349 02:27:27,654 --> 02:27:28,655 keep us safe. 4350 02:27:28,655 --> 02:27:29,222 I too want to live in a safe 4351 02:27:29,222 --> 02:27:31,622 world with less crime. 4352 02:27:32,458 --> 02:27:32,858 However, Alpers are not the way 4353 02:27:32,858 --> 02:27:33,827 to do that. 4354 02:27:33,827 --> 02:27:37,427 These cameras are not tools of 4355 02:27:37,796 --> 02:27:38,230 safety but rather tools of mass 4356 02:27:38,230 --> 02:27:38,965 surveillance. 4357 02:27:38,965 --> 02:27:42,401 They violate Our privacy can be 4358 02:27:42,401 --> 02:27:42,835 used to track people who've 4359 02:27:42,835 --> 02:27:43,402 done no wrong. 4360 02:27:43,402 --> 02:27:44,360 And they harm already 4361 02:27:44,360 --> 02:27:46,360 marginalized communities. 4362 02:27:47,673 --> 02:27:48,274 The lpr system is prone to 4363 02:27:48,274 --> 02:27:48,941 errors that policies and 4364 02:27:48,941 --> 02:27:49,275 department protocols cannot 4365 02:27:49,275 --> 02:27:51,275 address. 4366 02:27:52,770 --> 02:27:52,645 There are not enough safeguards 4367 02:27:52,645 --> 02:27:53,379 possible to make those 4368 02:27:53,379 --> 02:27:53,980 technology safe and acceptable. 4369 02:27:53,980 --> 02:27:56,980 The money spent on these 4370 02:27:57,250 --> 02:27:57,951 systems can be better spent on 4371 02:27:57,951 --> 02:27:58,618 other solutions that actually 4372 02:27:58,618 --> 02:28:00,618 strengthen our communities. 4373 02:28:01,954 --> 02:28:02,622 Even if you supported this 4374 02:28:02,622 --> 02:28:03,323 technology in the past, you 4375 02:28:03,323 --> 02:28:06,323 have the opportunity today to 4376 02:28:06,926 --> 02:28:07,494 vote for what San Diegans 4377 02:28:07,494 --> 02:28:08,161 actually need and have 4378 02:28:08,161 --> 02:28:10,161 overwhelmingly demonstrated 4379 02:28:11,731 --> 02:28:12,231 that we won't take the cameras 4380 02:28:12,231 --> 02:28:12,699 down now. 4381 02:28:12,699 --> 02:28:13,199 >> Thank you. 4382 02:28:13,199 --> 02:28:15,199 Thank you, Nick. 4383 02:28:17,170 --> 02:28:17,637 Nick Garrett Justice. 4384 02:28:17,637 --> 02:28:18,104 >> >> Hi. 4385 02:28:18,104 --> 02:28:20,104 Good afternoon. 4386 02:28:22,275 --> 02:28:23,430 Councilmember. 4387 02:28:23,430 --> 02:28:23,743 And thank you for your time. 4388 02:28:23,743 --> 02:28:26,743 My name is Nicolette Justice 4389 02:28:26,746 --> 02:28:27,414 and I'm a graduate student at 4390 02:28:27,414 --> 02:28:27,747 the Crockett School of Peace 4391 02:28:27,747 --> 02:28:28,314 Studies. 4392 02:28:28,314 --> 02:28:31,314 I'm asking you to end 4393 02:28:31,617 --> 02:28:32,252 the contract with More than 4394 02:28:32,252 --> 02:28:32,919 500 flight cameras here to 4395 02:28:32,919 --> 02:28:35,319 record where residents drive 4396 02:28:36,322 --> 02:28:36,890 and when. 4397 02:28:36,890 --> 02:28:37,591 According to the aclu, 4398 02:28:37,591 --> 02:28:39,991 the information collected goes 4399 02:28:40,590 --> 02:28:40,794 into a nationwide database that 4400 02:28:40,794 --> 02:28:41,495 any law enforcement agency with 4401 02:28:41,495 --> 02:28:44,495 a flight contract can search. 4402 02:28:45,310 --> 02:28:45,732 That creates a real risk of 4403 02:28:45,732 --> 02:28:47,732 unauthorized tracking, misuse 4404 02:28:49,936 --> 02:28:50,570 data breaches and access by 4405 02:28:50,570 --> 02:28:50,904 agencies beyond our local 4406 02:28:50,904 --> 02:28:52,904 control. 4407 02:28:54,607 --> 02:28:55,342 Peace depends on trust between 4408 02:28:55,342 --> 02:28:55,742 residents and institutions that 4409 02:28:55,742 --> 02:28:57,742 serve them. 4410 02:29:00,247 --> 02:29:00,947 Mass surveillance erodes that 4411 02:29:00,947 --> 02:29:01,615 trust, especially in immigrant 4412 02:29:01,615 --> 02:29:03,615 and overpoliced communities. 4413 02:29:05,422 --> 02:29:06,119 Public safety and civil 4414 02:29:06,119 --> 02:29:06,520 liberties can coexist here in 4415 02:29:06,520 --> 02:29:08,520 our nation. 4416 02:29:10,556 --> 02:29:11,324 For those reasons and reasons 4417 02:29:11,324 --> 02:29:12,580 of my peers, I urge you to 4418 02:29:12,580 --> 02:29:14,761 oppose the renewal of San Diego 4419 02:29:14,761 --> 02:29:15,362 to contract with flag safety 4420 02:29:15,362 --> 02:29:17,762 and remove the cameras. 4421 02:29:20,333 --> 02:29:20,801 Thank you again for your time. 4422 02:29:20,801 --> 02:29:21,668 >> Thank you. 4423 02:29:21,668 --> 02:29:22,102 Next is Jesse If you can please 4424 02:29:22,102 --> 02:29:24,102 come forward. 4425 02:29:28,375 --> 02:29:28,775 Jesse's 20 allegedly addressed 4426 02:29:28,775 --> 02:29:30,775 Live Oak. 4427 02:29:35,349 --> 02:29:39,549 We will get a news story or 4428 02:29:40,620 --> 02:29:41,153 whatever we'll get. 4429 02:29:41,153 --> 02:29:43,153 >> All right. 4430 02:29:44,991 --> 02:29:45,625 So we need to so flag functions 4431 02:29:45,625 --> 02:29:46,326 as ubiquitous street light 4432 02:29:46,326 --> 02:29:48,326 networking infrastructure and 4433 02:29:49,863 --> 02:29:50,564 ubiquity. 4434 02:29:50,564 --> 02:29:51,231 Contractor will flock and I'm 4435 02:29:51,231 --> 02:29:51,732 surprised they don't have a 4436 02:29:51,732 --> 02:29:53,732 problem with them. 4437 02:29:54,835 --> 02:29:55,569 They actually have Fox data and 4438 02:29:55,569 --> 02:29:56,690 their data perpetually and they 4439 02:29:56,690 --> 02:29:56,804 send it worldwide. 4440 02:29:56,804 --> 02:30:00,406 You guys have a kill switch or 4441 02:30:00,406 --> 02:30:00,774 near ubiquity a public safety 4442 02:30:00,774 --> 02:30:02,774 agreement. 4443 02:30:02,976 --> 02:30:03,676 It's section 2.2 where you have 4444 02:30:03,676 --> 02:30:06,676 a termination clause that you 4445 02:30:07,548 --> 02:30:08,215 can exit early if you refuse to 4446 02:30:08,215 --> 02:30:11,215 approve that policy for that 4447 02:30:11,451 --> 02:30:12,219 technology And you would walk 4448 02:30:12,219 --> 02:30:12,853 away from any commitment So we 4449 02:30:12,853 --> 02:30:15,253 would have the $8 million 4450 02:30:17,157 --> 02:30:17,957 that's left in that policy and 4451 02:30:17,957 --> 02:30:18,392 you would kill both of them at 4452 02:30:18,392 --> 02:30:19,126 the same time. 4453 02:30:19,126 --> 02:30:22,126 Otherwise you guys aren't going 4454 02:30:22,129 --> 02:30:22,395 to be able to just turn these 4455 02:30:22,395 --> 02:30:23,290 off. 4456 02:30:23,290 --> 02:30:23,766 There's something in your 4457 02:30:23,766 --> 02:30:26,766 contract that you would violate 4458 02:30:26,934 --> 02:30:27,633 a master agreement if anybody 4459 02:30:27,633 --> 02:30:28,569 touches them or blocks them. 4460 02:30:28,569 --> 02:30:31,871 So then you would have to tell 4461 02:30:31,871 --> 02:30:32,539 them to go and turn them off 4462 02:30:32,539 --> 02:30:36,139 and the mayor would have to 4463 02:30:36,543 --> 02:30:37,210 cancel the financial contract, 4464 02:30:37,210 --> 02:30:37,945 put out enormous notice of 4465 02:30:37,945 --> 02:30:39,945 termination potentially legally 4466 02:30:41,140 --> 02:30:41,615 force them to turn them off 4467 02:30:41,615 --> 02:30:42,349 because otherwise we're 4468 02:30:42,349 --> 02:30:42,783 financially liable for anything 4469 02:30:42,783 --> 02:30:44,783 that happens. 4470 02:30:46,120 --> 02:30:46,987 >> Your time has concluded. 4471 02:30:46,987 --> 02:30:51,240 I have a lot of duplicates just 4472 02:30:51,240 --> 02:30:51,725 trying to make sure that these 4473 02:30:51,725 --> 02:30:52,459 are duplicates and there's not 4474 02:30:52,459 --> 02:30:54,194 people here with the same name. 4475 02:30:54,194 --> 02:30:54,495 I got Logan Kinney already 4476 02:30:54,495 --> 02:30:55,362 spoke. 4477 02:30:55,362 --> 02:30:58,362 >> There's not a second Logan 4478 02:31:00,367 --> 02:31:00,767 King Raya Aurora Not a second 4479 02:31:00,767 --> 02:31:02,767 Raya Aurora. 4480 02:31:05,500 --> 02:31:05,572 Nicholas Wong Not us. 4481 02:31:05,572 --> 02:31:07,972 You already spoke Theo 4482 02:31:09,543 --> 02:31:10,177 Rothschild Not a second Theo 4483 02:31:10,177 --> 02:31:12,577 Rothschild Old Rihanna Das 4484 02:31:14,381 --> 02:31:17,381 Nicole Sharma and Ariane Dixit 4485 02:31:18,919 --> 02:31:19,886 as well as Stacy. 4486 02:31:19,886 --> 02:31:23,486 I do pay attention see Kevin 4487 02:31:27,861 --> 02:31:28,362 Wehner already spoke Kevin. 4488 02:31:28,362 --> 02:31:29,196 >> Okay. 4489 02:31:29,196 --> 02:31:32,796 Omar Arisa, if you can please 4490 02:31:32,900 --> 02:31:33,667 come forward. 4491 02:31:33,667 --> 02:31:37,267 After Omar Arisa we have Manuel 4492 02:31:38,471 --> 02:31:39,240 and Rico's Tanner Moreno Lulu 4493 02:31:39,240 --> 02:31:42,240 Rash King Natalie Rash King 4494 02:31:43,577 --> 02:31:43,910 Graciela Clavell and Doctor 4495 02:31:43,910 --> 02:31:45,910 Hector. 4496 02:31:46,913 --> 02:31:47,615 They're all if you can all 4497 02:31:47,615 --> 02:31:48,480 please come forward to 4498 02:31:48,480 --> 02:31:48,616 the front row. 4499 02:31:48,616 --> 02:31:50,484 >> Please proceed on. 4500 02:31:50,484 --> 02:31:52,484 Ready? 4501 02:31:55,456 --> 02:31:56,424 Omar Raza from District eight. 4502 02:31:56,424 --> 02:31:57,910 I just want to say first off to 4503 02:31:57,910 --> 02:31:59,491 the Southern Division Police 4504 02:32:00,593 --> 02:32:01,295 Department, they've been doing 4505 02:32:01,295 --> 02:32:01,896 actually a really good job at 4506 02:32:01,896 --> 02:32:03,896 getting involved in 4507 02:32:05,320 --> 02:32:05,766 the community. 4508 02:32:05,766 --> 02:32:09,366 Secondly, I want to talk about 4509 02:32:09,837 --> 02:32:10,571 my experience in technology as 4510 02:32:10,571 --> 02:32:11,104 a sales rep for the police, 4511 02:32:11,104 --> 02:32:11,805 fire and ambulance. 4512 02:32:11,805 --> 02:32:15,405 So a lot of the standard 4513 02:32:15,576 --> 02:32:16,444 practices come into play where 4514 02:32:16,444 --> 02:32:17,211 you wine and dine a lot of fire 4515 02:32:17,211 --> 02:32:19,847 chiefs, a lot of police 4516 02:32:19,847 --> 02:32:20,448 officers and then that's part 4517 02:32:20,448 --> 02:32:22,848 of the lobbying process. 4518 02:32:24,885 --> 02:32:25,752 So when it comes to contract I 4519 02:32:25,752 --> 02:32:26,553 would just say try to create a 4520 02:32:26,553 --> 02:32:30,224 system where if you do get one 4521 02:32:30,224 --> 02:32:30,524 dime they have to record it. 4522 02:32:30,524 --> 02:32:31,157 Right. 4523 02:32:31,157 --> 02:32:33,557 Because what happened with 4524 02:32:34,995 --> 02:32:35,663 the last contract is a fire. 4525 02:32:35,663 --> 02:32:36,297 A police captain ended up 4526 02:32:36,297 --> 02:32:36,796 getting this contract and 4527 02:32:36,796 --> 02:32:38,796 getting hired on. 4528 02:32:39,933 --> 02:32:40,701 That is a standard practice. 4529 02:32:40,701 --> 02:32:43,101 Companies go for retiring 4530 02:32:44,839 --> 02:32:45,373 chiefs so that way they can get 4531 02:32:45,373 --> 02:32:45,773 the contracts within 4532 02:32:45,773 --> 02:32:47,773 the cities. 4533 02:32:49,443 --> 02:32:53,643 So to be preventative and to be 4534 02:32:53,681 --> 02:32:54,810 accountable those need to be 4535 02:32:54,810 --> 02:32:54,682 identified. 4536 02:32:54,682 --> 02:32:55,349 >> Thank you for that 4537 02:32:55,349 --> 02:32:57,349 concluding comment, Manuel. 4538 02:33:03,157 --> 02:33:05,557 And I guess Hi. 4539 02:33:08,896 --> 02:33:09,563 My name is Manuel and I guess I 4540 02:33:09,563 --> 02:33:09,964 am with this in our policy 4541 02:33:09,964 --> 02:33:10,664 initiatives. 4542 02:33:10,664 --> 02:33:12,900 We are here to ask you as our 4543 02:33:12,900 --> 02:33:13,201 representatives to do the right 4544 02:33:13,201 --> 02:33:13,901 thing. 4545 02:33:13,901 --> 02:33:16,901 The $2 million that you spend 4546 02:33:17,772 --> 02:33:18,573 on Floc is a threat Every year 4547 02:33:18,573 --> 02:33:19,240 is a piece of our public funds 4548 02:33:19,240 --> 02:33:21,809 that could be better used on 4549 02:33:21,809 --> 02:33:22,443 programs and services for 4550 02:33:22,443 --> 02:33:23,177 working class San Diegans. 4551 02:33:23,177 --> 02:33:27,215 Floc is a threat to our safety 4552 02:33:27,215 --> 02:33:28,820 and civil liberties. 4553 02:33:28,820 --> 02:33:28,816 We are now liable to pay out 4554 02:33:28,816 --> 02:33:31,216 millions of dollars individuals 4555 02:33:31,619 --> 02:33:32,287 who have been wrongfully 4556 02:33:32,287 --> 02:33:32,887 arrested and shot because of 4557 02:33:32,887 --> 02:33:33,287 the way police use this 4558 02:33:33,287 --> 02:33:35,287 technology. 4559 02:33:36,390 --> 02:33:37,125 Data collected through APIs 4560 02:33:37,125 --> 02:33:37,791 throughout the country has also 4561 02:33:37,791 --> 02:33:38,459 been improperly shared with 4562 02:33:38,459 --> 02:33:41,129 federal agencies and used to 4563 02:33:41,129 --> 02:33:41,796 target immigrants and people 4564 02:33:41,796 --> 02:33:42,496 seeking reproductive health 4565 02:33:42,496 --> 02:33:45,496 care while also creating risk 4566 02:33:45,999 --> 02:33:46,734 for lgbtq plus communities. 4567 02:33:46,734 --> 02:33:47,468 Floc constantly profits from 4568 02:33:47,468 --> 02:33:50,468 our data and it's your 4569 02:33:51,720 --> 02:33:51,773 responsibility to protect us 4570 02:33:51,773 --> 02:33:52,240 the people you represent from 4571 02:33:52,240 --> 02:33:54,240 exploitation and 4572 02:33:56,244 --> 02:33:56,678 criminalization by 4573 02:33:56,678 --> 02:33:57,345 billionaires. 4574 02:33:57,345 --> 02:33:59,745 Our research from workplace 4575 02:34:01,115 --> 02:34:01,816 technology and workplace 4576 02:34:01,816 --> 02:34:02,149 surveillance reveals a similar 4577 02:34:02,149 --> 02:34:02,784 pattern. 4578 02:34:02,784 --> 02:34:04,784 Surveillance technologies 4579 02:34:06,120 --> 02:34:06,788 expand and control and control 4580 02:34:06,788 --> 02:34:07,388 Monitor and control working 4581 02:34:07,388 --> 02:34:07,989 class people while other 4582 02:34:07,989 --> 02:34:08,456 undermining privacy and 4583 02:34:08,456 --> 02:34:10,456 accountability. 4584 02:34:11,992 --> 02:34:12,694 Comment You must make 4585 02:34:12,694 --> 02:34:13,260 the morally right choice and. 4586 02:34:13,260 --> 02:34:15,430 I do have to be fair. 4587 02:34:15,430 --> 02:34:17,430 Tanner Moreno. 4588 02:34:20,134 --> 02:34:20,835 Tanner Moreno Are you here 4589 02:34:20,835 --> 02:34:23,835 after Tanner we have Natalie 4590 02:34:25,720 --> 02:34:25,773 Rashad Little Reggie. 4591 02:34:25,773 --> 02:34:26,707 >> Remember there's no seating 4592 02:34:26,707 --> 02:34:29,477 of time so people have to speak 4593 02:34:29,477 --> 02:34:30,440 for themselves. 4594 02:34:30,440 --> 02:34:30,345 She changed her mind. 4595 02:34:30,345 --> 02:34:30,812 Okay. 4596 02:34:30,812 --> 02:34:32,812 Please proceed. 4597 02:34:33,848 --> 02:34:34,715 Hi, I'm Natalie Rashad. 4598 02:34:34,715 --> 02:34:38,315 I live in District seven and 4599 02:34:38,586 --> 02:34:39,253 one of the treats a few treats 4600 02:34:39,253 --> 02:34:39,721 that I teach my children is 4601 02:34:39,721 --> 02:34:41,721 accountability. 4602 02:34:43,557 --> 02:34:47,157 Being able to pivot, know when 4603 02:34:47,595 --> 02:34:48,229 something's not working and 4604 02:34:48,229 --> 02:34:49,640 being able to shift that. 4605 02:34:49,640 --> 02:34:52,640 I appreciate people who have 4606 02:34:52,867 --> 02:34:53,401 shifted their opinion and how 4607 02:34:53,401 --> 02:34:55,801 this is being used. 4608 02:34:57,472 --> 02:34:58,172 I'm not anti-police. 4609 02:34:58,172 --> 02:34:58,573 We were homeless for almost 4610 02:34:58,573 --> 02:35:00,573 three years. 4611 02:35:01,609 --> 02:35:02,310 It took me one wrong strategic 4612 02:35:02,310 --> 02:35:05,910 move in My vehicle was towed. 4613 02:35:06,581 --> 02:35:07,114 That left us on the streets. 4614 02:35:07,114 --> 02:35:07,449 So they're watching. 4615 02:35:07,449 --> 02:35:08,490 I agree. 4616 02:35:08,490 --> 02:35:10,449 I agree with that. 4617 02:35:11,520 --> 02:35:14,652 But how it's being used in 4618 02:35:14,856 --> 02:35:15,824 the capabilities now go way far 4619 02:35:15,824 --> 02:35:18,824 past of just watching around 4620 02:35:20,610 --> 02:35:20,728 the town. 4621 02:35:20,728 --> 02:35:22,728 They were traumatized. 4622 02:35:25,633 --> 02:35:25,900 So she knows what black cameras 4623 02:35:25,900 --> 02:35:27,900 are. 4624 02:35:29,704 --> 02:35:30,437 There's a constant anxiety even 4625 02:35:30,437 --> 02:35:30,738 though we're not doing anything 4626 02:35:30,738 --> 02:35:31,438 wrong. 4627 02:35:31,438 --> 02:35:31,839 >> That's what we're doing to 4628 02:35:31,839 --> 02:35:33,839 our people. 4629 02:35:34,910 --> 02:35:35,410 Thank you. 4630 02:35:35,410 --> 02:35:37,410 >> Thank you. 4631 02:35:39,713 --> 02:35:40,480 Next speaker is Graciela clever 4632 02:35:40,480 --> 02:35:40,649 . 4633 02:35:40,649 --> 02:35:42,649 >> Hi, council members. 4634 02:35:44,653 --> 02:35:45,320 My name is Graciela Clavell. 4635 02:35:45,320 --> 02:35:45,953 I'm a college student and 4636 02:35:45,953 --> 02:35:46,688 organizer at the Center on 4637 02:35:46,688 --> 02:35:49,457 Policy Initiatives as well as a 4638 02:35:49,457 --> 02:35:50,250 resident of District nine. 4639 02:35:50,250 --> 02:35:50,625 I'm here today because 4640 02:35:50,625 --> 02:35:53,250 the city's investment in 4641 02:35:54,290 --> 02:35:54,662 surveillance ignores and 4642 02:35:54,662 --> 02:35:55,263 contradicts everything San 4643 02:35:55,263 --> 02:35:57,663 Diego has actually need. 4644 02:35:59,670 --> 02:35:59,768 As someone who has lived in San 4645 02:35:59,768 --> 02:36:00,469 Diego my entire life, we need 4646 02:36:00,469 --> 02:36:03,938 our council members to show up 4647 02:36:03,938 --> 02:36:04,673 for us and our needs by 4648 02:36:04,673 --> 02:36:05,373 actually investing in us invest 4649 02:36:05,373 --> 02:36:08,373 in our education, our housing, 4650 02:36:09,177 --> 02:36:09,544 our health care and our 4651 02:36:09,544 --> 02:36:10,212 existence. 4652 02:36:10,212 --> 02:36:10,845 Stop investing in technology 4653 02:36:10,845 --> 02:36:13,245 that dehumanizes the very 4654 02:36:14,549 --> 02:36:15,500 citizens that trusted you with 4655 02:36:15,500 --> 02:36:15,650 their communities. 4656 02:36:15,650 --> 02:36:16,351 I ask you to listen to 4657 02:36:16,351 --> 02:36:18,751 the communities that elected 4658 02:36:18,820 --> 02:36:19,121 you and tasked you with their 4659 02:36:19,121 --> 02:36:19,788 needs. 4660 02:36:19,788 --> 02:36:22,788 By divesting from Alpers and 4661 02:36:23,392 --> 02:36:24,260 take down the cameras Alpers 4662 02:36:24,260 --> 02:36:24,659 don't actually protect us. 4663 02:36:24,659 --> 02:36:28,630 As we have heard from many 4664 02:36:28,630 --> 02:36:28,697 others but rather takes 4665 02:36:28,697 --> 02:36:29,297 critical funding away from 4666 02:36:29,297 --> 02:36:31,697 working class San Diego. 4667 02:36:33,301 --> 02:36:33,768 >> Thank you. 4668 02:36:33,768 --> 02:36:34,169 Thank you. 4669 02:36:34,169 --> 02:36:36,169 Thank you. 4670 02:36:38,140 --> 02:36:38,573 Next speaker is DR. Hector 4671 02:36:38,573 --> 02:36:38,907 Peralta. 4672 02:36:38,907 --> 02:36:39,207 Peralta. 4673 02:36:39,207 --> 02:36:41,207 Sorry. 4674 02:36:43,645 --> 02:36:44,460 Sloppy handwriting sometimes. 4675 02:36:44,460 --> 02:36:44,346 All right. 4676 02:36:44,346 --> 02:36:44,813 Hello. 4677 02:36:44,813 --> 02:36:45,480 Good afternoon. 4678 02:36:45,480 --> 02:36:48,483 My name is DR. Iker Peralta. 4679 02:36:48,483 --> 02:36:48,917 Agile Project District nine 4680 02:36:48,917 --> 02:36:49,518 City Heights. 4681 02:36:49,518 --> 02:36:50,218 I urge Council to follow 4682 02:36:50,218 --> 02:36:53,521 through on their vote today by 4683 02:36:53,521 --> 02:36:54,222 ordering the immediate removal 4684 02:36:54,222 --> 02:36:54,756 of our lpr cameras and to 4685 02:36:54,756 --> 02:36:55,457 continue supporting 4686 02:36:55,457 --> 02:36:57,457 counter-surveillance movements 4687 02:36:58,160 --> 02:36:58,760 around the city and the county. 4688 02:36:58,760 --> 02:36:59,361 Unsurprisingly, at 4689 02:36:59,361 --> 02:37:01,761 the beginning of today's 4690 02:37:03,265 --> 02:37:03,899 meeting the pd made misleading 4691 02:37:03,899 --> 02:37:04,633 inaccurate statements when 4692 02:37:04,633 --> 02:37:08,233 the officer here directly to my 4693 02:37:08,403 --> 02:37:09,360 right insinuated on record that 4694 02:37:09,360 --> 02:37:09,705 there is no collaboration 4695 02:37:09,705 --> 02:37:09,972 between federal agencies and 4696 02:37:09,972 --> 02:37:11,972 cpd. 4697 02:37:12,641 --> 02:37:13,308 That is not entirely true. 4698 02:37:13,308 --> 02:37:14,900 Argus an acronym that stands 4699 02:37:14,900 --> 02:37:16,409 for Automated Regional Justice 4700 02:37:17,880 --> 02:37:18,547 Information System Automated 4701 02:37:18,547 --> 02:37:20,547 Regional Justice Information 4702 02:37:21,683 --> 02:37:22,550 System established in 76 And 4703 02:37:22,550 --> 02:37:26,150 it's a shared database that sd 4704 02:37:26,388 --> 02:37:27,222 pd is a founding charter member 4705 02:37:27,222 --> 02:37:31,930 and dhs is one of the many 4706 02:37:31,930 --> 02:37:31,727 organizations the agencies 4707 02:37:31,727 --> 02:37:32,561 found on their website. 4708 02:37:32,561 --> 02:37:36,161 So I urge council members and 4709 02:37:36,231 --> 02:37:36,932 the people here to oppose all 4710 02:37:36,932 --> 02:37:37,266 surveillance technologies and 4711 02:37:37,266 --> 02:37:37,933 systems. 4712 02:37:37,933 --> 02:37:40,933 Follow through on your vote 4713 02:37:41,436 --> 02:37:42,137 today by immediately taking 4714 02:37:42,137 --> 02:37:42,705 down all cameras and blocking 4715 02:37:42,705 --> 02:37:43,405 them before their day. 4716 02:37:43,405 --> 02:37:46,375 >> In the meantime, thank you. 4717 02:37:46,375 --> 02:37:48,375 Thank you. 4718 02:37:50,612 --> 02:37:50,913 >> Next speakers Tracy and Ella 4719 02:37:50,913 --> 02:37:51,713 . 4720 02:37:51,713 --> 02:37:54,713 >> And if the following people 4721 02:37:56,318 --> 02:37:57,190 can come up to the front row. 4722 02:37:57,190 --> 02:37:59,419 Michelle Finland, Judy Howell 4723 02:38:01,123 --> 02:38:01,657 Reese and Werner Eric c and 4724 02:38:01,657 --> 02:38:03,657 Lily Sue Johnson. 4725 02:38:07,582 --> 02:38:07,748 Please begin. 4726 02:38:07,748 --> 02:38:09,865 >> Hi I'm Tracy District three 4727 02:38:09,865 --> 02:38:10,532 resident and I also own a 4728 02:38:10,532 --> 02:38:11,233 business in District three. 4729 02:38:11,233 --> 02:38:13,633 The remaining council members 4730 02:38:14,903 --> 02:38:15,704 who still feel that Alpers and 4731 02:38:15,704 --> 02:38:16,338 flood cameras are a safe idea 4732 02:38:16,338 --> 02:38:16,872 for our city I urge you to 4733 02:38:16,872 --> 02:38:19,272 please listen to me. 4734 02:38:24,513 --> 02:38:26,513 A lifelong resident. 4735 02:38:29,952 --> 02:38:30,718 >> Every inch of privacy we 4736 02:38:30,718 --> 02:38:31,287 lose right now is an injured 4737 02:38:31,287 --> 02:38:31,953 freedom that the next 4738 02:38:31,953 --> 02:38:32,454 generation is never going to 4739 02:38:32,454 --> 02:38:34,454 even know existed. 4740 02:38:35,658 --> 02:38:36,392 You know, we listen to cbd say 4741 02:38:36,392 --> 02:38:37,920 what capabilities these cameras 4742 02:38:37,920 --> 02:38:39,995 do or do not have but they're 4743 02:38:39,995 --> 02:38:40,729 already pre-installed with 4744 02:38:40,729 --> 02:38:41,396 microphones getting listened to 4745 02:38:41,396 --> 02:38:42,970 every word These cameras can 4746 02:38:42,970 --> 02:38:45,970 instantly program to look for 4747 02:38:45,167 --> 02:38:46,100 whatever they want to. 4748 02:38:46,100 --> 02:38:49,705 So who's going to tell me a 4749 02:38:49,705 --> 02:38:50,139 citizen or ask my consent when 4750 02:38:50,139 --> 02:38:50,739 that changes? 4751 02:38:50,739 --> 02:38:53,739 i don't trust it either. 4752 02:38:54,143 --> 02:38:54,977 That trust is gone. 4753 02:38:54,977 --> 02:38:55,677 >> These expensive devices are 4754 02:38:55,677 --> 02:38:58,677 full of precious minerals that 4755 02:38:59,582 --> 02:39:00,249 have been inhumanely mined in 4756 02:39:00,249 --> 02:39:00,916 the first place and they are 4757 02:39:00,916 --> 02:39:01,350 also available as any other 4758 02:39:01,350 --> 02:39:03,350 manmade item. 4759 02:39:04,530 --> 02:39:04,653 There's a reason why we stop 4760 02:39:04,653 --> 02:39:05,121 using nuclear weapons in 4761 02:39:05,121 --> 02:39:05,888 warfare in 1945. 4762 02:39:05,888 --> 02:39:09,910 Just because a tool is so 4763 02:39:09,910 --> 02:39:09,725 effective doesn't mean it 4764 02:39:09,725 --> 02:39:10,259 should make you That does 4765 02:39:10,259 --> 02:39:10,959 conclude your time. 4766 02:39:10,959 --> 02:39:13,359 >> Next speaker is Michelle 4767 02:39:13,529 --> 02:39:15,529 Finland. 4768 02:39:18,233 --> 02:39:18,567 >> Good afternoon council 4769 02:39:18,567 --> 02:39:19,268 members. 4770 02:39:19,268 --> 02:39:20,200 My name is Michelle Fenlon and 4771 02:39:20,200 --> 02:39:23,390 I was homeless for a year and a 4772 02:39:23,390 --> 02:39:23,739 half in San Diego. 4773 02:39:23,739 --> 02:39:24,372 During that time I experienced 4774 02:39:24,372 --> 02:39:26,772 an unbelievable amount of 4775 02:39:27,810 --> 02:39:28,544 harassment and stalking by our 4776 02:39:28,544 --> 02:39:30,944 police force injecting advanced 4777 02:39:32,882 --> 02:39:33,349 technology into an inherently 4778 02:39:33,349 --> 02:39:34,160 abusive system. 4779 02:39:34,160 --> 02:39:34,450 It's not going to magically 4780 02:39:34,450 --> 02:39:36,450 make it safe. 4781 02:39:38,540 --> 02:39:38,753 It's going to exacerbate 4782 02:39:38,753 --> 02:39:39,188 the qualities that are already 4783 02:39:39,188 --> 02:39:41,188 inside of it. 4784 02:39:42,892 --> 02:39:43,525 I have a background in nervous 4785 02:39:43,525 --> 02:39:44,227 system and trauma healing. 4786 02:39:44,227 --> 02:39:46,627 Ever since the implementation 4787 02:39:47,763 --> 02:39:48,464 of cctv there's copious amounts 4788 02:39:48,464 --> 02:39:48,997 of scientific evidence proving 4789 02:39:48,997 --> 02:39:51,397 that living under a 4790 02:39:52,167 --> 02:39:52,701 surveillance state is harmful 4791 02:39:52,701 --> 02:39:53,703 to its citizens. 4792 02:39:53,703 --> 02:39:54,369 What it does is it puts us in a 4793 02:39:54,369 --> 02:39:56,769 perpetual fight or flight 4794 02:39:57,306 --> 02:39:58,390 response that we cannot get out 4795 02:39:58,390 --> 02:40:01,639 of over time that causes actual 4796 02:40:01,877 --> 02:40:02,378 brain damage specifically to 4797 02:40:02,378 --> 02:40:03,450 our frontal lobes. 4798 02:40:03,450 --> 02:40:06,450 >> This is our center of 4799 02:40:07,216 --> 02:40:07,984 executive functioning of speech 4800 02:40:07,984 --> 02:40:08,384 ,of movement and of empathy, 4801 02:40:08,384 --> 02:40:10,384 of empathy. 4802 02:40:12,921 --> 02:40:13,255 Floc is unlawful or it's 4803 02:40:13,255 --> 02:40:15,255 unsafe. 4804 02:40:17,159 --> 02:40:17,959 Do your job The civil servants 4805 02:40:17,959 --> 02:40:18,261 and what flock out of San 4806 02:40:18,261 --> 02:40:20,261 Diego. 4807 02:40:20,830 --> 02:40:21,396 >> Thank you. 4808 02:40:21,396 --> 02:40:23,796 Next speaker is Judy. 4809 02:40:25,434 --> 02:40:25,901 How. 4810 02:40:25,901 --> 02:40:27,901 Good afternoon. 4811 02:40:30,806 --> 02:40:31,440 My name is Judy Howl and I'm 4812 02:40:31,440 --> 02:40:34,440 asking the city council to 4813 02:40:34,710 --> 02:40:35,578 defund the contract. 4814 02:40:35,578 --> 02:40:36,212 Whose rights are you willing to 4815 02:40:36,212 --> 02:40:38,612 compromise to solve crime? 4816 02:40:39,382 --> 02:40:40,830 Who are you willing to 4817 02:40:40,830 --> 02:40:43,830 wrongfully imprisoned due to a 4818 02:40:44,319 --> 02:40:44,987 technological error a I is 4819 02:40:44,987 --> 02:40:47,987 guided by missions and not 4820 02:40:48,858 --> 02:40:49,291 morals expediency is 4821 02:40:49,291 --> 02:40:50,250 the priority. 4822 02:40:50,250 --> 02:40:50,726 Accuracy is secondary and human 4823 02:40:50,726 --> 02:40:53,829 rights are not a part of 4824 02:40:53,829 --> 02:40:54,496 the discussion. 4825 02:40:54,496 --> 02:40:55,231 We deserve transparency and 4826 02:40:55,231 --> 02:40:57,967 safety before new technology is 4827 02:40:57,967 --> 02:41:00,367 built into our community. 4828 02:41:03,390 --> 02:41:03,339 >> Take the cameras down today 4829 02:41:03,339 --> 02:41:03,806 . 4830 02:41:03,806 --> 02:41:05,806 Thank you Ryan. 4831 02:41:20,255 --> 02:41:20,956 We for Ryan we aim for Ryan. 4832 02:41:20,956 --> 02:41:24,556 I've come to urge the council 4833 02:41:24,694 --> 02:41:25,228 to oppose these horrifying 4834 02:41:25,228 --> 02:41:25,795 Orwellian dystopian 4835 02:41:25,795 --> 02:41:27,795 surveillance cameras. 4836 02:41:30,400 --> 02:41:33,400 These are a clear, blatant 4837 02:41:34,103 --> 02:41:34,804 violation of the Fourth 4838 02:41:34,804 --> 02:41:35,371 Amendment of the Constitution 4839 02:41:35,371 --> 02:41:37,771 of the United States. 4840 02:41:38,408 --> 02:41:38,975 They have been used and abused 4841 02:41:38,975 --> 02:41:41,975 by the police to stalk 4842 02:41:42,946 --> 02:41:43,412 ex-girlfriends and search 4843 02:41:43,412 --> 02:41:44,112 endlessly. 4844 02:41:44,112 --> 02:41:44,447 They have no place in our 4845 02:41:44,447 --> 02:41:46,447 society. 4846 02:41:48,584 --> 02:41:49,285 I do not believe they make us 4847 02:41:49,285 --> 02:41:52,285 safer and I strongly encourage 4848 02:41:53,560 --> 02:41:53,389 the Council to oppose this 4849 02:41:53,389 --> 02:41:53,756 measure. 4850 02:41:53,756 --> 02:41:54,224 >> Thanks. 4851 02:41:54,224 --> 02:41:56,224 Thank you, Eric. 4852 02:41:57,427 --> 02:41:57,927 See? 4853 02:41:57,927 --> 02:41:59,927 >> Hello. 4854 02:42:02,432 --> 02:42:03,199 My name is Eric. 4855 02:42:03,199 --> 02:42:03,800 For cameras are a blatant 4856 02:42:03,800 --> 02:42:04,167 violation of the Fourth 4857 02:42:04,167 --> 02:42:06,167 Amendment. 4858 02:42:07,303 --> 02:42:07,770 They harm our community and 4859 02:42:07,770 --> 02:42:08,371 harm immigrants. 4860 02:42:08,371 --> 02:42:09,500 If you want to look for 4861 02:42:09,500 --> 02:42:11,405 criminals, you should look 4862 02:42:13,476 --> 02:42:14,177 inside the White House and in 4863 02:42:14,177 --> 02:42:14,877 the pages of the obscene files 4864 02:42:14,877 --> 02:42:15,278 rather than targeting innocent 4865 02:42:15,278 --> 02:42:16,450 immigrants. 4866 02:42:16,450 --> 02:42:20,245 Got the flock out of San Diego. 4867 02:42:20,250 --> 02:42:22,250 >> Thank you. 4868 02:42:25,355 --> 02:42:25,655 >> Thank you, Lily Sue Johnson 4869 02:42:25,655 --> 02:42:26,256 . 4870 02:42:26,256 --> 02:42:26,589 Good afternoon, council 4871 02:42:26,589 --> 02:42:27,156 members. 4872 02:42:27,156 --> 02:42:27,791 My name is Lilly-sue. 4873 02:42:27,791 --> 02:42:30,191 Today it's Princess Leia. 4874 02:42:31,940 --> 02:42:31,828 I've been to Chula Vista 4875 02:42:31,828 --> 02:42:32,562 District one resident my entire 4876 02:42:32,562 --> 02:42:35,565 life and I love this community. 4877 02:42:35,565 --> 02:42:36,199 I believe we all here care 4878 02:42:36,199 --> 02:42:36,900 deeply about the safety, 4879 02:42:36,900 --> 02:42:37,399 safety, freedom and future of 4880 02:42:37,399 --> 02:42:39,399 San Diego County. 4881 02:42:40,690 --> 02:42:40,704 Public safety should never come 4882 02:42:40,704 --> 02:42:41,370 at the expense of personal 4883 02:42:41,370 --> 02:42:41,738 privacy. 4884 02:42:41,738 --> 02:42:42,439 If you think my Princess Leia 4885 02:42:42,439 --> 02:42:45,175 costume is ridiculous but you 4886 02:42:45,175 --> 02:42:45,842 don't think Fox mass 4887 02:42:45,842 --> 02:42:46,576 surveillance technology is. 4888 02:42:46,576 --> 02:42:49,813 Then I hate to break it to you. 4889 02:42:49,813 --> 02:42:50,480 The joke's on you and 4890 02:42:50,480 --> 02:42:51,147 the Empire has already won. 4891 02:42:51,147 --> 02:42:52,150 Privacy is not a privilege. 4892 02:42:52,150 --> 02:42:53,850 Freedom should not come with a 4893 02:42:53,850 --> 02:42:54,584 surveillance subscription. 4894 02:42:54,584 --> 02:42:55,850 Remove the cameras and restore 4895 02:42:55,850 --> 02:42:57,850 our privacy today. 4896 02:42:58,888 --> 02:42:59,589 I value my constitutional 4897 02:42:59,589 --> 02:43:00,290 rights, my privacy and freedom 4898 02:43:00,290 --> 02:43:00,824 and I want those same freedoms 4899 02:43:00,824 --> 02:43:01,224 protected for future 4900 02:43:01,224 --> 02:43:02,459 generations. 4901 02:43:02,459 --> 02:43:02,758 block the flag out of San 4902 02:43:02,758 --> 02:43:03,263 Diego. 4903 02:43:03,263 --> 02:43:05,263 >> Thank you. 4904 02:43:12,102 --> 02:43:12,835 Next speaker is Angela Vetter. 4905 02:43:12,835 --> 02:43:13,570 Angela while Angela approaches, 4906 02:43:13,570 --> 02:43:16,570 could the following people come 4907 02:43:17,707 --> 02:43:18,141 up in the front row? 4908 02:43:18,141 --> 02:43:20,141 Jay Goldberg. 4909 02:43:22,712 --> 02:43:26,683 Monika So you know he has Ben 4910 02:43:26,683 --> 02:43:27,840 Butler, Isabel Kay and Ian Cruz 4911 02:43:27,840 --> 02:43:27,617 at court. 4912 02:43:27,617 --> 02:43:27,884 >> Please begin. 4913 02:43:27,884 --> 02:43:29,884 Hi. 4914 02:43:32,220 --> 02:43:32,889 I definitely realize I'm not 4915 02:43:32,889 --> 02:43:36,489 going to be very popular here 4916 02:43:36,927 --> 02:43:37,494 but I'm not here to say I'm in 4917 02:43:37,494 --> 02:43:39,894 favor of flag company. 4918 02:43:41,131 --> 02:43:41,865 >> I fully understand 4919 02:43:41,865 --> 02:43:42,398 the privacy concerns with these 4920 02:43:42,398 --> 02:43:44,398 cameras, especially 4921 02:43:46,169 --> 02:43:46,636 unauthorized access by ice or 4922 02:43:46,636 --> 02:43:47,436 other agencies. 4923 02:43:47,436 --> 02:43:50,436 That absolutely needs to be 4924 02:43:50,941 --> 02:43:51,908 addressed. 4925 02:43:51,908 --> 02:43:52,709 >> But I do feel these type of 4926 02:43:52,709 --> 02:43:55,709 cameras the technology can be 4927 02:43:56,179 --> 02:43:56,947 useful for police. 4928 02:43:56,947 --> 02:44:00,547 They're used all over the world 4929 02:44:00,817 --> 02:44:01,517 and they have been known to 4930 02:44:01,517 --> 02:44:04,517 they don't prevent crimes but 4931 02:44:05,589 --> 02:44:06,289 they definitely are 4932 02:44:06,289 --> 02:44:08,689 instrumental in solving crimes 4933 02:44:09,859 --> 02:44:10,727 producing thousands of arrest 4934 02:44:10,727 --> 02:44:13,727 and helping locate many missing 4935 02:44:15,365 --> 02:44:16,233 people. 4936 02:44:16,233 --> 02:44:19,336 I mean you see this Michigan 4937 02:44:19,336 --> 02:44:20,360 family, their three month old 4938 02:44:20,360 --> 02:44:23,360 baby that was kidnaped because 4939 02:44:23,807 --> 02:44:24,408 of this type of technology was 4940 02:44:24,408 --> 02:44:26,408 found within 25 minutes. 4941 02:44:28,945 --> 02:44:29,780 >> And I think about privacy. 4942 02:44:29,780 --> 02:44:30,314 >> Everywhere we go we have 4943 02:44:30,314 --> 02:44:30,681 cameras watching us. 4944 02:44:30,681 --> 02:44:31,882 Thank you. 4945 02:44:31,882 --> 02:44:34,882 That does conclude your time. 4946 02:44:37,621 --> 02:44:38,288 Jay Goldberg. 4947 02:44:38,288 --> 02:44:40,288 Afternoon, Counsel Jay. 4948 02:44:42,920 --> 02:44:42,860 District three It's remarkable 4949 02:44:42,860 --> 02:44:45,896 that you if you had listened to 4950 02:44:45,896 --> 02:44:46,663 the community and the pub we 4951 02:44:46,663 --> 02:44:47,331 might have been able to keep 4952 02:44:47,331 --> 02:44:47,931 this program but ramming it 4953 02:44:47,931 --> 02:44:50,331 down our throats without 4954 02:44:50,834 --> 02:44:51,435 compromise is non-consensual. 4955 02:44:51,435 --> 02:44:53,835 Privacy due process and 4956 02:44:55,838 --> 02:44:56,440 probable cause are cornerstones 4957 02:44:56,440 --> 02:44:58,440 of American California. 4958 02:45:00,411 --> 02:45:01,145 Cm Campo You've compared phone 4959 02:45:01,145 --> 02:45:01,745 usage with universal consent to 4960 02:45:01,745 --> 02:45:02,790 participate in a modern 4961 02:45:02,790 --> 02:45:04,790 society. 4962 02:45:05,482 --> 02:45:06,490 I respect you but I hold a 4963 02:45:06,490 --> 02:45:06,750 phone that I control. 4964 02:45:06,750 --> 02:45:09,853 I choose what software runs on 4965 02:45:09,853 --> 02:45:10,354 it and what privacy I'm 4966 02:45:10,354 --> 02:45:11,540 comfortable with. 4967 02:45:11,540 --> 02:45:11,922 If police want evidence off of 4968 02:45:11,922 --> 02:45:14,691 this device they have to get a 4969 02:45:14,691 --> 02:45:15,392 warrant and issue probable 4970 02:45:15,392 --> 02:45:18,992 cause to a judge or judiciary 4971 02:45:19,396 --> 02:45:20,650 to approve it. 4972 02:45:20,650 --> 02:45:20,664 We shouldn't be shamed for 4973 02:45:20,664 --> 02:45:22,664 being concerned and 4974 02:45:24,168 --> 02:45:24,902 conscientious. 4975 02:45:24,902 --> 02:45:25,568 >> It's time to undo this 4976 02:45:25,568 --> 02:45:25,903 mistake and hopefully learn 4977 02:45:25,903 --> 02:45:27,504 from it. 4978 02:45:27,504 --> 02:45:28,500 Thank you. 4979 02:45:28,500 --> 02:45:30,500 >> Thank you. 4980 02:45:32,776 --> 02:45:34,776 Monica Suji. 4981 02:45:38,248 --> 02:45:38,915 Got to noon for our foremost. 4982 02:45:38,915 --> 02:45:39,683 Thank you so much council 4983 02:45:39,683 --> 02:45:42,352 members for what you do for 4984 02:45:42,352 --> 02:45:42,652 the community here in San 4985 02:45:42,652 --> 02:45:43,353 Diego. 4986 02:45:43,353 --> 02:45:46,953 And Monica Shoji, a student at 4987 02:45:47,691 --> 02:45:48,558 the University of San Diego. 4988 02:45:48,558 --> 02:45:49,260 I'm here today to show my 4989 02:45:49,260 --> 02:45:52,620 concern about the park system. 4990 02:45:52,620 --> 02:45:52,863 I'm worried that this system 4991 02:45:52,863 --> 02:45:53,596 will be used for ice for 4992 02:45:53,596 --> 02:45:55,996 immigrants and racial profiling 4993 02:45:57,234 --> 02:45:57,835 even if it does not directly 4994 02:45:57,835 --> 02:45:58,602 tied to individual id. 4995 02:45:58,602 --> 02:46:01,905 Also there is a risk of 4996 02:46:01,905 --> 02:46:02,572 the system being hacked and 4997 02:46:02,572 --> 02:46:03,240 the information taken away. 4998 02:46:03,240 --> 02:46:06,240 I'm already nervous being in 4999 02:46:06,476 --> 02:46:06,810 front of all these cameras 5000 02:46:06,810 --> 02:46:07,544 today. 5001 02:46:07,544 --> 02:46:07,877 Can you imagine Near the flood 5002 02:46:07,877 --> 02:46:09,877 cameras. 5003 02:46:11,748 --> 02:46:12,416 And from Los Angeles and L.A. 5004 02:46:12,416 --> 02:46:13,500 County has already suspended 5005 02:46:13,500 --> 02:46:16,500 their usage of the system 5006 02:46:16,520 --> 02:46:17,870 because they also have concerns 5007 02:46:17,870 --> 02:46:17,760 regarding lock system. 5008 02:46:17,760 --> 02:46:20,760 It impacts our community and 5009 02:46:21,292 --> 02:46:21,758 safety and trust in 5010 02:46:21,758 --> 02:46:22,559 the community. 5011 02:46:22,559 --> 02:46:26,759 If a block is used right now 5012 02:46:26,797 --> 02:46:27,464 with the many uncertainty. 5013 02:46:27,464 --> 02:46:28,165 Therefore I would like to 5014 02:46:28,165 --> 02:46:31,165 propose that the county should 5015 02:46:31,669 --> 02:46:32,369 be taken down at this time and 5016 02:46:32,369 --> 02:46:32,970 also have our restrictions for 5017 02:46:32,970 --> 02:46:34,970 private companies usage. 5018 02:46:36,139 --> 02:46:36,440 Thank you so much for your 5019 02:46:36,440 --> 02:46:36,874 time. 5020 02:46:36,874 --> 02:46:38,874 >> Thank you. 5021 02:46:45,383 --> 02:46:45,916 It has been the talk. 5022 02:46:45,916 --> 02:46:46,850 Honorable Counsel. 5023 02:46:46,850 --> 02:46:49,787 My name is Yasmin Bethune and I 5024 02:46:49,787 --> 02:46:50,454 serve as the policy and 5025 02:46:50,454 --> 02:46:51,188 legislative staff member at 5026 02:46:51,188 --> 02:46:51,855 the Council on American-Islamic 5027 02:46:51,855 --> 02:46:54,855 Relations here in San Diego. 5028 02:46:55,326 --> 02:46:55,959 On MAY 18th the Islamic Center 5029 02:46:55,959 --> 02:46:58,959 of San Diego was brutally 5030 02:46:59,330 --> 02:47:00,970 attacked leading to the murder 5031 02:47:00,970 --> 02:47:03,970 of three community leaders and 5032 02:47:03,167 --> 02:47:03,634 the endangerment of 140 5033 02:47:03,634 --> 02:47:04,368 schoolchildren. 5034 02:47:04,368 --> 02:47:06,768 The Muslim community especially 5035 02:47:08,239 --> 02:47:08,839 during these volatile times 5036 02:47:08,839 --> 02:47:09,507 would like to stress 5037 02:47:09,507 --> 02:47:09,840 the importance of community 5038 02:47:09,840 --> 02:47:11,840 safety. 5039 02:47:13,143 --> 02:47:13,844 However, due to 5040 02:47:13,844 --> 02:47:14,445 the unconstitutional breaches 5041 02:47:14,445 --> 02:47:15,780 of privacy, illegal data 5042 02:47:15,780 --> 02:47:17,780 sharing with out-of-state 5043 02:47:18,549 --> 02:47:19,216 agencies such as ice as well as 5044 02:47:19,216 --> 02:47:19,750 the disproportionate use of 5045 02:47:19,750 --> 02:47:21,750 surveillance against 5046 02:47:23,153 --> 02:47:23,854 marginalized communities, we 5047 02:47:23,854 --> 02:47:27,454 hold firm that lpr and mass 5048 02:47:27,724 --> 02:47:28,425 surveillance technologies are 5049 02:47:28,425 --> 02:47:29,600 not the appropriate tools for 5050 02:47:29,600 --> 02:47:31,600 ensuring community safety. 5051 02:47:32,663 --> 02:47:33,230 We must redefine public safety 5052 02:47:33,230 --> 02:47:33,931 by shifting away from 5053 02:47:33,931 --> 02:47:35,931 undemocratic mass surveillance 5054 02:47:37,201 --> 02:47:37,902 and towards working together on 5055 02:47:37,902 --> 02:47:38,335 community centered solutions. 5056 02:47:38,335 --> 02:47:40,335 >> Thank you. 5057 02:47:40,437 --> 02:47:42,437 Thank you Speakers. 5058 02:47:45,977 --> 02:47:46,511 >> Isabel Kay. 5059 02:47:46,511 --> 02:47:48,511 Hello, Council. 5060 02:47:50,681 --> 02:47:51,449 I'm Isabel Kay. 5061 02:47:51,449 --> 02:47:54,449 I reside in District one. 5062 02:47:54,785 --> 02:47:55,453 First am I am the only person 5063 02:47:55,453 --> 02:47:58,453 who can tell the difference 5064 02:47:58,956 --> 02:47:59,323 between a Toyota forerunner and 5065 02:47:59,323 --> 02:48:00,240 a Corolla. 5066 02:48:00,240 --> 02:48:02,424 Apparently our Alper system 5067 02:48:03,928 --> 02:48:06,928 cannot do extensive analysis of 5068 02:48:08,733 --> 02:48:09,399 the nationwide data on pc TVs 5069 02:48:09,399 --> 02:48:12,905 and the newer formats of air 5070 02:48:12,905 --> 02:48:13,504 linked cameras by Control f 5071 02:48:13,504 --> 02:48:14,172 shows that there is no 5072 02:48:14,172 --> 02:48:16,572 improvement in public safety 5073 02:48:18,410 --> 02:48:18,809 whatsoever. 5074 02:48:18,809 --> 02:48:19,443 Only a modest 13% reduction in 5075 02:48:19,443 --> 02:48:21,843 vehicle and property theft 5076 02:48:23,214 --> 02:48:23,847 which is sort of what we are 5077 02:48:23,847 --> 02:48:26,847 getting here in San Diego. 5078 02:48:27,918 --> 02:48:28,753 No reduction in violent crime. 5079 02:48:28,753 --> 02:48:29,219 As you've heard, personal data 5080 02:48:29,219 --> 02:48:29,821 are invaluable. 5081 02:48:29,821 --> 02:48:32,221 More data requires more 5082 02:48:33,157 --> 02:48:33,891 monitoring, more surveillance, 5083 02:48:33,891 --> 02:48:36,891 more data collection, more data 5084 02:48:37,295 --> 02:48:37,829 sharing and profits for Flock, 5085 02:48:37,829 --> 02:48:38,496 Palantir and others. 5086 02:48:38,496 --> 02:48:41,899 We are being used as guinea 5087 02:48:41,899 --> 02:48:42,667 pigs Our movements vehicles 5088 02:48:42,667 --> 02:48:43,335 lives are being harvested as a 5089 02:48:43,335 --> 02:48:44,350 natural resource without our 5090 02:48:44,350 --> 02:48:47,635 consent just as the people of 5091 02:48:48,473 --> 02:48:49,600 Gaza have been used to refine 5092 02:48:49,600 --> 02:48:49,707 the shameful killing 5093 02:48:49,707 --> 02:48:52,676 technologies used in deal that 5094 02:48:52,676 --> 02:48:53,211 does conclude your to among 5095 02:48:53,211 --> 02:48:53,945 them developed here. 5096 02:48:53,945 --> 02:48:54,244 >> Thank you that does San 5097 02:48:54,244 --> 02:48:54,612 Diego. 5098 02:48:54,612 --> 02:48:56,612 Thank you. 5099 02:48:58,883 --> 02:48:59,417 Next speakers Ian Cruz at court 5100 02:48:59,417 --> 02:49:00,151 while Ian approaches 5101 02:49:00,151 --> 02:49:02,719 the lectern could the following 5102 02:49:02,719 --> 02:49:06,919 people come up with a front row 5103 02:49:07,357 --> 02:49:10,357 James Aid Danny Ariosto, Hugh 5104 02:49:14,699 --> 02:49:15,266 Myra Afzal Yadi and Claire 5105 02:49:15,266 --> 02:49:15,900 Malanga Please begin. 5106 02:49:15,900 --> 02:49:17,900 >> Good afternoon counsel. 5107 02:49:20,400 --> 02:49:20,771 My name is Ian Cruz Accord. 5108 02:49:20,771 --> 02:49:21,438 I'm a resident in San Diego 5109 02:49:21,438 --> 02:49:24,438 County and on the leadership 5110 02:49:24,776 --> 02:49:25,376 team of the Otay Mesa Detention 5111 02:49:25,376 --> 02:49:26,440 Collective And from what 5112 02:49:26,440 --> 02:49:28,713 statistics have shown us lpr 5113 02:49:28,713 --> 02:49:29,480 Technologies and Flock cameras 5114 02:49:29,480 --> 02:49:30,181 are not a foolproof system to 5115 02:49:30,181 --> 02:49:33,181 the problem of crime According 5116 02:49:33,685 --> 02:49:34,318 to the Spd's own reports, 5117 02:49:34,318 --> 02:49:35,190 nearly 4000 searches were 5118 02:49:35,190 --> 02:49:38,822 logged on to the vague name of 5119 02:49:38,822 --> 02:49:39,491 other what crimes did these 5120 02:49:39,491 --> 02:49:40,225 people commit to get hit by 5121 02:49:40,225 --> 02:49:40,492 flock Was there even a crime at 5122 02:49:40,492 --> 02:49:42,492 all? 5123 02:49:43,895 --> 02:49:44,561 Is this a mistake by I or was 5124 02:49:44,561 --> 02:49:45,162 it corrupt officers using it 5125 02:49:45,162 --> 02:49:45,897 for mass surveillance of 5126 02:49:45,897 --> 02:49:48,297 protesters and immigrants under 5127 02:49:48,600 --> 02:49:49,167 the guise of protection? 5128 02:49:49,167 --> 02:49:49,801 These cameras make our 5129 02:49:49,801 --> 02:49:51,801 communities feel extremely 5130 02:49:53,171 --> 02:49:53,904 unsafe especially when we have 5131 02:49:53,904 --> 02:49:54,572 sanctuary city laws and knowing 5132 02:49:54,572 --> 02:49:56,572 after congressional hearings 5133 02:49:58,420 --> 02:49:58,675 and public audits that ice has 5134 02:49:58,675 --> 02:49:59,344 access to these databases. 5135 02:49:59,344 --> 02:50:00,111 And we know from seeing this 5136 02:50:00,111 --> 02:50:03,111 time and time again where 5137 02:50:03,148 --> 02:50:03,815 families and workers have been 5138 02:50:03,815 --> 02:50:04,482 tracked and kidnaped by ice 5139 02:50:04,482 --> 02:50:07,819 because of the data that was 5140 02:50:07,819 --> 02:50:08,853 obtained by fly. 5141 02:50:08,853 --> 02:50:09,554 >> With that I want to say take 5142 02:50:09,554 --> 02:50:12,289 down the cameras and get the 5143 02:50:12,289 --> 02:50:13,258 out of San Diego. 5144 02:50:13,258 --> 02:50:16,858 >> James Ave James, if you can 5145 02:50:17,128 --> 02:50:19,128 please come forward. 5146 02:50:22,330 --> 02:50:22,834 >> How's it going? 5147 02:50:22,834 --> 02:50:25,834 My name is James Ellis. 5148 02:50:26,637 --> 02:50:27,338 Last NOVEMBER I was on a 5149 02:50:27,338 --> 02:50:28,380 motorcycle when a white bmw 5150 02:50:28,380 --> 02:50:28,373 swerved into my lane and i 5151 02:50:28,373 --> 02:50:30,373 crashed. 5152 02:50:32,476 --> 02:50:33,178 The driver did stop, stood by 5153 02:50:33,178 --> 02:50:33,545 her car for two minutes and 5154 02:50:33,545 --> 02:50:35,545 then left. 5155 02:50:37,349 --> 02:50:38,490 I briefly lost consciousness, 5156 02:50:38,490 --> 02:50:38,750 was shuttled to the E.R. In an 5157 02:50:38,750 --> 02:50:39,284 ambulance and spent the night 5158 02:50:39,284 --> 02:50:41,684 in the trauma unit. 5159 02:50:42,870 --> 02:50:42,720 I broke my collarbone. 5160 02:50:42,720 --> 02:50:45,720 A witness caught a partial 5161 02:50:46,858 --> 02:50:47,558 plate and I asked for sd pd to 5162 02:50:47,558 --> 02:50:48,292 query their database the full 5163 02:50:48,292 --> 02:50:51,162 plate into place of litigation. 5164 02:50:51,162 --> 02:50:51,896 Hold on The Alper data. 5165 02:50:51,896 --> 02:50:52,563 I received confirmation that a 5166 02:50:52,563 --> 02:50:52,931 hold would be placed with a 5167 02:50:52,931 --> 02:50:54,931 subpoena. 5168 02:50:56,600 --> 02:50:57,335 I then sought to obtain that 5169 02:50:57,335 --> 02:50:58,360 Alper data Sergeant Craig Evans 5170 02:50:58,360 --> 02:51:01,360 informed me that no litigation 5171 02:51:01,773 --> 02:51:02,440 hold had ever been placed and 5172 02:51:02,440 --> 02:51:03,207 thus the fridge had purged. 5173 02:51:03,207 --> 02:51:06,611 Evans however, did tell me that 5174 02:51:06,611 --> 02:51:07,312 with a court order or a request 5175 02:51:07,312 --> 02:51:07,979 from a police officer he could 5176 02:51:07,979 --> 02:51:10,915 likely obtain the full plate 5177 02:51:10,915 --> 02:51:11,783 from the partial. 5178 02:51:11,783 --> 02:51:14,986 While Evans was helpful sd pd 5179 02:51:14,986 --> 02:51:15,654 refused to help me. 5180 02:51:15,654 --> 02:51:16,254 And worse they stood they 5181 02:51:16,254 --> 02:51:19,254 claimed in a way that 5182 02:51:19,858 --> 02:51:20,525 the driver had not committed a 5183 02:51:20,525 --> 02:51:21,226 crime given that there might 5184 02:51:21,226 --> 02:51:21,593 not have been contact between 5185 02:51:21,593 --> 02:51:23,593 vehicles. 5186 02:51:24,996 --> 02:51:25,664 If I could just finish one 5187 02:51:25,664 --> 02:51:26,264 concluding comment with that 5188 02:51:26,264 --> 02:51:28,264 one concluding comment. 5189 02:51:29,767 --> 02:51:32,767 Yeah it's still possible to 5190 02:51:34,205 --> 02:51:34,973 obtain the full plate if 5191 02:51:34,973 --> 02:51:35,674 the bmw is driven past any of 5192 02:51:35,674 --> 02:51:35,974 the 500 cameras in the past 30 5193 02:51:35,974 --> 02:51:37,974 days. 5194 02:51:39,476 --> 02:51:39,844 Thank you. 5195 02:51:39,844 --> 02:51:40,712 Thank you. 5196 02:51:40,712 --> 02:51:43,548 I ask that you please help me. 5197 02:51:43,548 --> 02:51:43,848 I'll leave my contact info here 5198 02:51:43,848 --> 02:51:44,616 . 5199 02:51:44,616 --> 02:51:44,916 >> I'd really appreciate that, 5200 02:51:44,916 --> 02:51:46,916 Danny. 5201 02:51:52,924 --> 02:51:53,325 i Rosa. 5202 02:51:53,325 --> 02:51:53,925 Hello. 5203 02:51:53,925 --> 02:51:56,325 My name is Danny. 5204 02:51:57,262 --> 02:51:57,596 I'm a resident of District 5205 02:51:57,596 --> 02:51:58,263 three. 5206 02:51:58,263 --> 02:51:58,931 Last DECEMBER, residents of 5207 02:51:58,931 --> 02:52:01,331 every district stood before 5208 02:52:03,201 --> 02:52:03,869 this council and told you this 5209 02:52:03,869 --> 02:52:04,536 technology would be misused. 5210 02:52:04,536 --> 02:52:06,936 You dismissed those concerns 5211 02:52:07,772 --> 02:52:08,606 and you approved it anyway. 5212 02:52:08,606 --> 02:52:09,274 We told you exactly who would 5213 02:52:09,274 --> 02:52:09,975 misuse it, that it would be 5214 02:52:09,975 --> 02:52:12,510 these folks sitting right here 5215 02:52:12,510 --> 02:52:13,145 who appear very dis interested 5216 02:52:13,145 --> 02:52:13,846 in what we have to say. 5217 02:52:13,846 --> 02:52:16,846 And you didn't believe us? 5218 02:52:17,115 --> 02:52:17,983 Council PRESIDENT Lee Carver 5219 02:52:17,983 --> 02:52:18,617 you told us that this wasn't 5220 02:52:18,617 --> 02:52:19,351 the end and that we could 5221 02:52:19,351 --> 02:52:21,686 revisit this issue if we turned 5222 02:52:21,686 --> 02:52:21,987 out if you turned out to be 5223 02:52:21,987 --> 02:52:22,654 wrong. 5224 02:52:22,654 --> 02:52:23,288 So here we are after yet 5225 02:52:23,288 --> 02:52:23,989 another scandal involving 5226 02:52:23,989 --> 02:52:26,692 the misuse of this technology 5227 02:52:26,692 --> 02:52:27,125 by law enforcement. 5228 02:52:27,125 --> 02:52:27,826 Revisiting it. 5229 02:52:27,826 --> 02:52:30,826 I do want to thank 5230 02:52:31,897 --> 02:52:32,597 Councilmember Whitburn for 5231 02:52:32,597 --> 02:52:32,898 finally coming around on this 5232 02:52:32,898 --> 02:52:33,565 issue. 5233 02:52:33,565 --> 02:52:34,266 This is the first time I've 5234 02:52:34,266 --> 02:52:36,335 been proud of you since I have 5235 02:52:36,335 --> 02:52:37,302 moved to your district. 5236 02:52:37,302 --> 02:52:38,200 I just wish you had listened to 5237 02:52:38,200 --> 02:52:38,303 your constituents in the first 5238 02:52:38,303 --> 02:52:40,303 place. 5239 02:52:41,707 --> 02:52:42,273 Please vote to cancel this 5240 02:52:42,273 --> 02:52:42,674 contract and take down 5241 02:52:42,674 --> 02:52:43,241 the cameras. 5242 02:52:43,241 --> 02:52:45,241 >> Thank you, Kumara. 5243 02:52:48,717 --> 02:52:49,114 I also. 5244 02:52:49,114 --> 02:52:49,848 >> Hi. 5245 02:52:49,848 --> 02:52:52,848 Mass surveillance is hardly new 5246 02:52:53,185 --> 02:52:53,852 in the U.S. It goes back to at 5247 02:52:53,852 --> 02:52:54,453 least as far as the lantern 5248 02:52:54,453 --> 02:52:57,453 laws of the early 1700s. 5249 02:52:57,589 --> 02:52:58,560 The 20th century there was 5250 02:52:58,560 --> 02:52:58,690 surveillance of 5251 02:52:58,690 --> 02:53:00,690 Japanese-Americans, Black 5252 02:53:01,526 --> 02:53:02,270 Panthers, Vietnam War prisoners 5253 02:53:02,270 --> 02:53:02,794 and many more. 5254 02:53:02,794 --> 02:53:03,462 For the past 25 years Muslims 5255 02:53:03,462 --> 02:53:06,462 have been a primary target. 5256 02:53:07,633 --> 02:53:08,400 Warrantless mass surveillance 5257 02:53:08,400 --> 02:53:09,301 has always been bad and now it 5258 02:53:09,301 --> 02:53:12,237 is turbocharged by ai and other 5259 02:53:12,237 --> 02:53:12,938 technology And tech oligarchs 5260 02:53:12,938 --> 02:53:13,638 are accumulating vast amounts 5261 02:53:13,638 --> 02:53:16,638 of wealth from convincing city 5262 02:53:16,742 --> 02:53:17,443 governments that mass 5263 02:53:17,443 --> 02:53:18,109 surveillance is public safety. 5264 02:53:18,109 --> 02:53:21,280 It only needs to end today. 5265 02:53:21,280 --> 02:53:22,140 While I was waiting I did 5266 02:53:22,140 --> 02:53:25,614 the math and we need about $200 5267 02:53:26,218 --> 02:53:26,818 worth of heavy duty black trash 5268 02:53:26,818 --> 02:53:27,219 bags to cover up all 5269 02:53:27,219 --> 02:53:29,219 the cameras. 5270 02:53:30,789 --> 02:53:31,423 >> So let us all go home or go 5271 02:53:31,423 --> 02:53:31,990 to work or school tomorrow 5272 02:53:31,990 --> 02:53:33,592 without being tracked. 5273 02:53:33,592 --> 02:53:36,592 Take 200 bucks from petty cash 5274 02:53:37,195 --> 02:53:40,795 and go buy the trash bags. 5275 02:53:42,568 --> 02:53:43,350 Yadi. 5276 02:53:43,350 --> 02:53:44,300 >> Hi Council. 5277 02:53:44,300 --> 02:53:46,637 I'm hoping that today you will 5278 02:53:46,637 --> 02:53:47,339 meet the moment and turn off 5279 02:53:47,339 --> 02:53:50,339 and either remove or cover 5280 02:53:51,410 --> 02:53:52,277 the flock Cameras. 5281 02:53:52,277 --> 02:53:52,945 You know our privacy is very 5282 02:53:52,945 --> 02:53:55,945 important and I'm glad that 5283 02:53:56,810 --> 02:53:56,849 we're having this conversation 5284 02:53:56,849 --> 02:53:57,650 here and it's time that we 5285 02:53:57,650 --> 02:54:00,650 don't support Flock who's out 5286 02:54:01,820 --> 02:54:02,554 there and calling us terrorist. 5287 02:54:02,554 --> 02:54:04,954 For defending democracy our 5288 02:54:06,158 --> 02:54:06,758 constitutional rights, our 5289 02:54:06,758 --> 02:54:07,920 civil liberties and our 5290 02:54:07,920 --> 02:54:07,759 privacy. 5291 02:54:07,759 --> 02:54:10,759 Furthermore, if you look on 5292 02:54:11,330 --> 02:54:14,330 flocks website they tell you 5293 02:54:16,340 --> 02:54:16,735 how they incorporate errors 5294 02:54:16,735 --> 02:54:17,236 into the images that they take 5295 02:54:17,236 --> 02:54:18,700 and they process. 5296 02:54:18,700 --> 02:54:21,406 We do not deserve to be 5297 02:54:21,406 --> 02:54:22,400 surveilled and we do not 5298 02:54:22,400 --> 02:54:24,440 deserve to be erroneously 5299 02:54:25,511 --> 02:54:26,278 subject to being pulled over 5300 02:54:26,278 --> 02:54:29,278 with armed officers And we 5301 02:54:30,716 --> 02:54:31,450 please I just suggest that you 5302 02:54:31,450 --> 02:54:34,450 don't get other vendors because 5303 02:54:34,987 --> 02:54:35,654 a lot of the vendors have this 5304 02:54:35,654 --> 02:54:38,540 problem of their technology 5305 02:54:40,225 --> 02:54:40,859 just not working and it's just 5306 02:54:40,859 --> 02:54:41,526 not perfect technology And 5307 02:54:41,526 --> 02:54:43,926 please end all surveillance. 5308 02:54:45,163 --> 02:54:46,310 >> Thank you, Claire. 5309 02:54:46,310 --> 02:54:49,310 >> Malala Claire, if you can 5310 02:54:50,302 --> 02:54:53,302 please come forward After that 5311 02:54:54,340 --> 02:54:54,773 we have Chief ten and by you 5312 02:54:54,773 --> 02:54:56,773 Moira ten. 5313 02:54:59,178 --> 02:54:59,712 Cooper Manley Ramsay is and 5314 02:54:59,712 --> 02:55:00,445 Isabella Jaramillo. 5315 02:55:00,445 --> 02:55:04,450 If you can all please come 5316 02:55:04,417 --> 02:55:05,284 forward to the front row. 5317 02:55:05,284 --> 02:55:08,854 We are in our final speakers 5318 02:55:08,854 --> 02:55:09,388 After that please proceed. 5319 02:55:09,388 --> 02:55:10,890 Good afternoon. 5320 02:55:10,890 --> 02:55:13,426 My name is Claire Malala and 5321 02:55:13,426 --> 02:55:14,193 I'm a student at uc San Diego 5322 02:55:14,193 --> 02:55:14,860 and a resident in District six. 5323 02:55:14,860 --> 02:55:17,860 I urge you to cancel 5324 02:55:19,310 --> 02:55:19,632 the surveillance use policy and 5325 02:55:19,632 --> 02:55:20,320 remove the flock cameras 5326 02:55:20,320 --> 02:55:20,598 immediately. 5327 02:55:20,598 --> 02:55:23,569 How many more of your 5328 02:55:23,569 --> 02:55:24,269 constituents lives will be put 5329 02:55:24,269 --> 02:55:24,970 in danger All their access to 5330 02:55:24,970 --> 02:55:27,370 this mass surveillance system 5331 02:55:28,239 --> 02:55:28,607 that is present right here in 5332 02:55:28,607 --> 02:55:29,342 San Diego. 5333 02:55:29,342 --> 02:55:29,975 Before you reject this invasive 5334 02:55:29,975 --> 02:55:32,375 technology, please vote to 5335 02:55:33,612 --> 02:55:34,380 reject Floc and instead invest 5336 02:55:34,380 --> 02:55:38,250 in programs that do not rely on 5337 02:55:38,250 --> 02:55:38,651 mass surveillance for so-called 5338 02:55:38,651 --> 02:55:39,850 protection. 5339 02:55:39,850 --> 02:55:41,850 >> Thank you. 5340 02:55:48,600 --> 02:55:50,600 Chieftain Chieftain naming 5341 02:55:52,331 --> 02:55:53,980 the streets after police. 5342 02:55:53,980 --> 02:55:53,532 You can't be neutral on a 5343 02:55:53,532 --> 02:55:55,532 moving train. 5344 02:55:58,471 --> 02:55:59,171 Protect the people immediately 5345 02:55:59,171 --> 02:55:59,605 Rescind and remove Hugo had 5346 02:55:59,605 --> 02:56:01,605 already shot. 5347 02:56:02,675 --> 02:56:03,342 Families torn apart city 5348 02:56:03,342 --> 02:56:06,342 councils by data mining San 5349 02:56:07,313 --> 02:56:08,470 Diego's every day 500 down 5350 02:56:08,470 --> 02:56:10,447 immediately Cancel the contract 5351 02:56:12,451 --> 02:56:13,152 Take them out Get the out Shut 5352 02:56:13,152 --> 02:56:13,718 it down Twitter and 84 cities 5353 02:56:13,718 --> 02:56:15,718 canceled the contract. 5354 02:56:16,655 --> 02:56:16,989 Right now the system is 5355 02:56:16,989 --> 02:56:17,722 burning. 5356 02:56:17,722 --> 02:56:21,322 Shut it down Shame Sharing info 5357 02:56:21,527 --> 02:56:22,161 with Feds privacy Advocate 5358 02:56:22,161 --> 02:56:22,829 Advisory Board Rejected No 5359 02:56:22,829 --> 02:56:25,229 accountability The people sd 5360 02:56:27,266 --> 02:56:27,999 Trust protecting us telling us 5361 02:56:27,999 --> 02:56:31,370 that the community no one wants 5362 02:56:31,370 --> 02:56:32,171 a surveillance state no way 5363 02:56:32,171 --> 02:56:35,771 back glass is no police state 5364 02:56:36,420 --> 02:56:36,809 Get the out Get the out Get 5365 02:56:36,809 --> 02:56:37,276 the flock out Get the out. 5366 02:56:37,276 --> 02:56:37,777 Get the up. 5367 02:56:37,777 --> 02:56:39,777 Get the out. 5368 02:56:40,460 --> 02:56:42,460 Get the out. 5369 02:56:45,218 --> 02:56:45,885 >> We are down to our last 5370 02:56:45,885 --> 02:56:46,552 speakers There's a lot more 5371 02:56:46,552 --> 02:56:49,552 clapping The people won't be 5372 02:56:49,889 --> 02:56:50,690 able to hear me to come up and 5373 02:56:50,690 --> 02:56:50,990 I don't want them to MISS Their 5374 02:56:50,990 --> 02:56:52,990 turn. 5375 02:56:54,193 --> 02:56:55,610 Anna by. 5376 02:56:55,610 --> 02:56:57,461 >> Hello Council members My 5377 02:57:00,333 --> 02:57:01,340 name is on a by you I'm with 5378 02:57:01,340 --> 02:57:01,801 Green Party and General strike 5379 02:57:01,801 --> 02:57:03,803 u s and I'm constituent of 5380 02:57:03,803 --> 02:57:04,704 weapons. 5381 02:57:04,704 --> 02:57:05,405 I am happy to hear that you 5382 02:57:05,405 --> 02:57:06,105 have changed your vote because 5383 02:57:06,105 --> 02:57:08,575 I did have a little piece for 5384 02:57:08,575 --> 02:57:09,441 you that I have taken out now 5385 02:57:09,441 --> 02:57:10,242 I'm like many here today I am 5386 02:57:10,242 --> 02:57:13,842 here to comment on the floor 5387 02:57:14,479 --> 02:57:16,879 cameras in the city. 5388 02:57:19,180 --> 02:57:19,718 >> So in DECEMBER of 2025 for 5389 02:57:19,718 --> 02:57:22,718 eight hours 50 agents told you 5390 02:57:23,890 --> 02:57:23,722 our concerns about the floor 5391 02:57:23,722 --> 02:57:24,390 cameras in the city Shawn 5392 02:57:24,390 --> 02:57:26,790 Oliveira, Vivian Marino and 5393 02:57:28,328 --> 02:57:28,995 Henry Foster voted against it 5394 02:57:28,995 --> 02:57:29,295 and Woodburn has changed his 5395 02:57:29,295 --> 02:57:29,662 vote. 5396 02:57:29,662 --> 02:57:31,662 Thank you. 5397 02:57:33,366 --> 02:57:34,100 I'm this the floor cameras came 5398 02:57:34,100 --> 02:57:37,100 across your desk because of 5399 02:57:38,104 --> 02:57:38,837 the former police department 5400 02:57:38,837 --> 02:57:41,837 captain Jack Jordan who helped 5401 02:57:42,775 --> 02:57:43,476 secure this initial contract. 5402 02:57:43,476 --> 02:57:47,760 Jordan now works for Floc as 5403 02:57:47,347 --> 02:57:47,814 their strategic relations 5404 02:57:47,814 --> 02:57:48,515 manager. 5405 02:57:48,515 --> 02:57:52,115 But that doesn't say that this 5406 02:57:52,952 --> 02:57:53,253 is an ethical I don't know what 5407 02:57:53,253 --> 02:57:53,886 does. 5408 02:57:53,886 --> 02:57:54,554 >> Recently the attack on 5409 02:57:54,554 --> 02:57:57,554 the Islamic center San Diego 5410 02:57:58,224 --> 02:57:58,891 was attacked earlier. 5411 02:57:58,891 --> 02:57:59,292 >> Oh, not so fast. 5412 02:57:59,292 --> 02:58:01,292 Thank you. 5413 02:58:12,338 --> 02:58:15,338 My return Mara Cooper Manly 5414 02:58:19,212 --> 02:58:19,879 Good afternoon and thank you 5415 02:58:19,879 --> 02:58:20,280 for the opportunity to speak 5416 02:58:20,280 --> 02:58:20,980 here today. 5417 02:58:20,980 --> 02:58:21,314 >> My name is Cooper and I'm a 5418 02:58:21,314 --> 02:58:23,820 student. 5419 02:58:23,820 --> 02:58:23,716 Use these cross school peace 5420 02:58:23,716 --> 02:58:24,317 Studies and School of Law. 5421 02:58:24,317 --> 02:58:27,317 Not only do Alpers pose 5422 02:58:27,554 --> 02:58:28,320 significant cost to the civil 5423 02:58:28,320 --> 02:58:29,550 liberties of San Diego and 5424 02:58:29,550 --> 02:58:29,756 millions of other Americans but 5425 02:58:29,756 --> 02:58:32,156 their continued use represents 5426 02:58:33,920 --> 02:58:33,726 a fabricated agreement by 5427 02:58:33,726 --> 02:58:34,394 residents to butcher both 5428 02:58:34,394 --> 02:58:35,950 the constitutional right to 5429 02:58:35,950 --> 02:58:38,695 privacy and the human right of 5430 02:58:39,650 --> 02:58:39,699 freedom of movement in exchange 5431 02:58:39,699 --> 02:58:42,990 for some elusive imprecise 5432 02:58:44,200 --> 02:58:44,671 improvement for safety. 5433 02:58:44,671 --> 02:58:45,405 Eop hours are designed to 5434 02:58:45,405 --> 02:58:48,942 constantly surveil me or you or 5435 02:58:48,942 --> 02:58:49,676 any of us and reveal detailed 5436 02:58:49,676 --> 02:58:50,430 information about our movements 5437 02:58:50,430 --> 02:58:50,676 on demand. 5438 02:58:50,676 --> 02:58:53,760 Any surveillance should be 5439 02:58:54,314 --> 02:58:54,880 conducted legally and 5440 02:58:54,880 --> 02:58:55,548 conservatively by law 5441 02:58:55,548 --> 02:58:56,149 enforcement not big tech and 5442 02:58:56,149 --> 02:58:59,149 should be a response to 5443 02:58:59,619 --> 02:59:00,219 evidence based suspicion not 5444 02:59:00,219 --> 02:59:00,719 the baseline reality for 5445 02:59:00,719 --> 02:59:02,719 everyday citizens. 5446 02:59:04,123 --> 02:59:04,824 I asked the council to be 5447 02:59:04,824 --> 02:59:05,391 brave, push back against the 5448 02:59:05,391 --> 02:59:06,590 surveillance state and 5449 02:59:06,590 --> 02:59:08,590 recognize that technological 5450 02:59:09,796 --> 02:59:10,497 advancement can quickly become 5451 02:59:10,497 --> 02:59:12,497 totalitarian assets especially 5452 02:59:14,901 --> 02:59:15,201 when profits and power are put 5453 02:59:15,201 --> 02:59:15,969 over. 5454 02:59:15,969 --> 02:59:16,336 >> People get the flock out of 5455 02:59:16,336 --> 02:59:18,336 San Diego. 5456 02:59:26,780 --> 02:59:27,247 Thank you Ramsey Hello. 5457 02:59:27,247 --> 02:59:27,948 Hello, Counsel. 5458 02:59:27,948 --> 02:59:28,615 I'm not really going to bother 5459 02:59:28,615 --> 02:59:31,615 you guys about anything that 5460 02:59:31,618 --> 02:59:32,419 hasn't really been said before 5461 02:59:32,419 --> 02:59:32,918 either by myself or the other 5462 02:59:32,918 --> 02:59:33,519 people behind me. 5463 02:59:33,519 --> 02:59:36,519 The bottom line is that 5464 02:59:36,523 --> 02:59:37,224 the people of San Diego no 5465 02:59:37,224 --> 02:59:37,891 longer trust the city whether 5466 02:59:37,891 --> 02:59:38,592 it's because of you guys on 5467 02:59:38,592 --> 02:59:39,192 the council or the people here 5468 02:59:39,192 --> 02:59:41,361 on the police department 5469 02:59:41,361 --> 02:59:41,995 there's a culture of distrust. 5470 02:59:41,995 --> 02:59:42,729 We can't trust the police 5471 02:59:42,729 --> 02:59:45,129 department especially when they 5472 02:59:47,670 --> 02:59:47,767 have a culture of protecting 5473 02:59:47,767 --> 02:59:48,435 murderers and abusers whether 5474 02:59:48,435 --> 02:59:52,635 it be them having to show up 5475 02:59:53,140 --> 02:59:53,807 every day and walk by Daniel 5476 02:59:53,807 --> 02:59:54,541 Gold, the man who killed 16 5477 02:59:54,541 --> 02:59:57,944 year old and all else And right 5478 02:59:57,944 --> 02:59:58,712 here in downtown San Diego. 5479 02:59:58,712 --> 02:59:59,413 Why would we trust those people 5480 02:59:59,413 --> 03:00:02,413 to police us and surveillance 5481 03:00:03,550 --> 03:00:04,251 and track us down in our places 5482 03:00:04,251 --> 03:00:04,718 of work, our places of worship 5483 03:00:04,718 --> 03:00:05,352 and our schools? 5484 03:00:05,352 --> 03:00:06,190 It doesn't make any sense. 5485 03:00:06,190 --> 03:00:08,488 We have no reason to trust 5486 03:00:08,488 --> 03:00:09,188 these people anymore, 5487 03:00:09,188 --> 03:00:09,857 especially when they lie time 5488 03:00:09,857 --> 03:00:10,590 and time again over how they 5489 03:00:10,590 --> 03:00:13,590 use the technology that there's 5490 03:00:13,693 --> 03:00:14,494 no abuse going on when every 5491 03:00:14,494 --> 03:00:17,494 couple of weeks either there's 5492 03:00:19,999 --> 03:00:20,701 someone being improperly 5493 03:00:20,701 --> 03:00:21,000 surveilled or someone getting 5494 03:00:21,000 --> 03:00:23,000 shot. 5495 03:00:24,704 --> 03:00:25,339 There could have been a 19 year 5496 03:00:25,339 --> 03:00:25,972 old murdered the other day 5497 03:00:25,972 --> 03:00:28,372 because of this technology 5498 03:00:29,876 --> 03:00:30,477 Isabella had I mean you know 5499 03:00:30,477 --> 03:00:33,477 after that will be Erin 5500 03:00:33,680 --> 03:00:36,800 Inferno, Omar Wimbush looks 5501 03:00:40,554 --> 03:00:41,321 kind of locker. 5502 03:00:41,321 --> 03:00:42,220 >> Good afternoon Thank you for 5503 03:00:42,220 --> 03:00:45,220 the opportunity to speak today 5504 03:00:45,892 --> 03:00:46,526 My name is Eric Laramie and I'm 5505 03:00:46,526 --> 03:00:47,227 a graduate student at usc. 5506 03:00:47,227 --> 03:00:47,627 I urge you to take on 5507 03:00:47,627 --> 03:00:49,627 the cameras. 5508 03:00:50,964 --> 03:00:51,665 I believe that public safety 5509 03:00:51,665 --> 03:00:52,299 and the protection of civil 5510 03:00:52,299 --> 03:00:52,833 liberties should never be 5511 03:00:52,833 --> 03:00:53,233 treated as competing 5512 03:00:53,233 --> 03:00:55,233 priorities. 5513 03:00:56,536 --> 03:00:57,237 We shouldn't Concerns about 5514 03:00:57,237 --> 03:00:57,905 this technology can be used to 5515 03:00:57,905 --> 03:01:00,305 raise an important questions 5516 03:01:02,275 --> 03:01:02,876 Are these existing safeguards 5517 03:01:02,876 --> 03:01:03,410 strong enough to protect 5518 03:01:03,410 --> 03:01:04,144 the public's right? 5519 03:01:04,144 --> 03:01:04,878 The responsibility of this city 5520 03:01:04,878 --> 03:01:07,581 is not only to ensure that this 5521 03:01:07,581 --> 03:01:08,315 technology is effective but 5522 03:01:08,315 --> 03:01:11,915 also that its use is justified, 5523 03:01:12,986 --> 03:01:13,787 transparent and accountable as 5524 03:01:13,787 --> 03:01:14,455 you consider item 200 I ask 5525 03:01:14,455 --> 03:01:15,189 that you carefully evaluate 5526 03:01:15,189 --> 03:01:17,589 whether the existing safeguards 5527 03:01:18,759 --> 03:01:19,459 are sufficient to protect civil 5528 03:01:19,459 --> 03:01:19,759 liberties and maintain public 5529 03:01:19,759 --> 03:01:21,628 trust. 5530 03:01:21,628 --> 03:01:24,628 >> Thank you for your time. 5531 03:01:34,308 --> 03:01:35,410 Erin Inferno Thank. 5532 03:01:35,410 --> 03:01:35,743 >> San Diego Police Department 5533 03:01:35,743 --> 03:01:38,743 paid $30 million to the family 5534 03:01:39,780 --> 03:01:39,846 of Will Then when an officer 5535 03:01:39,846 --> 03:01:40,748 was shot and that officer shot 5536 03:01:40,748 --> 03:01:45,452 him in the chest when he was in 5537 03:01:45,452 --> 03:01:46,119 actual violence thus leading to 5538 03:01:46,119 --> 03:01:46,586 the largest payout in United 5539 03:01:46,586 --> 03:01:48,586 States history. 5540 03:01:50,891 --> 03:01:51,591 While that officer is still 5541 03:01:51,591 --> 03:01:52,292 employed Mayor Todd Gloria and 5542 03:01:52,292 --> 03:01:53,260 Stephen Whitman, which you MAY 5543 03:01:53,260 --> 03:01:56,530 or MAY not have change your 5544 03:01:56,530 --> 03:01:57,197 vote your your vote excuse me 5545 03:01:57,197 --> 03:01:59,597 You're supposed to represent 5546 03:02:01,368 --> 03:02:02,200 like me in Hillcrest in 5547 03:02:02,200 --> 03:02:02,703 District three but instead 5548 03:02:02,703 --> 03:02:05,103 you're protesting your excuse 5549 03:02:07,908 --> 03:02:08,642 me you are giving your time to 5550 03:02:08,642 --> 03:02:11,420 oligarchs their technology with 5551 03:02:13,513 --> 03:02:14,148 block and helpers is not 100% 5552 03:02:14,148 --> 03:02:16,148 accurate Police department 5553 03:02:19,180 --> 03:02:19,753 whether it be San Diego Police 5554 03:02:19,753 --> 03:02:20,387 or any police department in 5555 03:02:20,387 --> 03:02:21,120 the country they use this 5556 03:02:21,120 --> 03:02:24,120 information and it being flawed 5557 03:02:25,225 --> 03:02:25,926 does not lead to accurate 5558 03:02:25,926 --> 03:02:26,627 information leading to arrests 5559 03:02:26,627 --> 03:02:29,627 More than 100 officers in San 5560 03:02:31,232 --> 03:02:31,899 Diego Police Department have 5561 03:02:31,899 --> 03:02:35,499 used this data from block to 5562 03:02:37,404 --> 03:02:38,272 stock and other ex-girlfriends. 5563 03:02:38,272 --> 03:02:42,472 And while I urge you to vote 5564 03:02:42,810 --> 03:02:45,810 against for or for that 5565 03:02:48,348 --> 03:02:49,820 concluding comment Omar Abidjan 5566 03:02:49,820 --> 03:02:49,784 Good afternoon Council members. 5567 03:02:49,784 --> 03:02:50,451 >> My name is General Sherman. 5568 03:02:50,451 --> 03:02:54,510 I serve as the programs and 5569 03:02:55,220 --> 03:02:55,389 outreach coordinator at care 5570 03:02:55,389 --> 03:02:56,122 San Diego. 5571 03:02:56,122 --> 03:02:56,857 I also do sit on the police 5572 03:02:56,857 --> 03:02:59,857 chiefs all of American advisory 5573 03:03:00,560 --> 03:03:01,228 board while I do not speak for 5574 03:03:01,228 --> 03:03:02,290 the entire board, I'm here. 5575 03:03:02,290 --> 03:03:05,899 I'm here to urge you to end 5576 03:03:05,899 --> 03:03:06,567 flood surveillance. 5577 03:03:06,567 --> 03:03:07,234 On MAY 18th our community 5578 03:03:07,234 --> 03:03:07,935 experienced a deadly attack 5579 03:03:07,935 --> 03:03:11,535 flocking to prevent it or keep 5580 03:03:11,872 --> 03:03:12,373 our community safe. 5581 03:03:12,373 --> 03:03:13,400 Rather it misled. 5582 03:03:13,400 --> 03:03:13,674 Yet the system continues to 5583 03:03:13,674 --> 03:03:16,740 record where people travel 5584 03:03:18,145 --> 03:03:18,846 creating sensitive data about 5585 03:03:18,846 --> 03:03:19,380 their lives without making our 5586 03:03:19,380 --> 03:03:21,380 community any safer. 5587 03:03:24,418 --> 03:03:25,520 That data can be accessed or 5588 03:03:25,520 --> 03:03:25,753 shared beyond its original 5589 03:03:25,753 --> 03:03:28,153 purpose sharing license plates 5590 03:03:30,991 --> 03:03:31,314 with immigration authorities is 5591 03:03:31,314 --> 03:03:31,959 wrong. 5592 03:03:31,959 --> 03:03:32,626 Muslim immigrant families in 5593 03:03:32,626 --> 03:03:33,260 our broader community should 5594 03:03:33,260 --> 03:03:36,260 not have to wonder whether 5595 03:03:36,464 --> 03:03:37,640 going to the mosque, visiting 5596 03:03:37,640 --> 03:03:37,732 relatives or attending a 5597 03:03:37,732 --> 03:03:38,398 community event could expose 5598 03:03:38,398 --> 03:03:41,998 them or their loved ones to 5599 03:03:42,369 --> 03:03:43,137 enforcement. 5600 03:03:43,137 --> 03:03:43,470 This is more than just about 5601 03:03:43,470 --> 03:03:44,171 cameras. 5602 03:03:44,171 --> 03:03:47,771 It is about whether people can 5603 03:03:48,241 --> 03:03:48,976 live, worship and participate 5604 03:03:48,976 --> 03:03:49,310 in community life without being 5605 03:03:49,310 --> 03:03:49,944 tracked. 5606 03:03:49,944 --> 03:03:50,311 >> We urge you to vote no. 5607 03:03:50,311 --> 03:03:52,311 Thank you. 5608 03:03:53,680 --> 03:03:54,281 Our final speaker here in 5609 03:03:54,281 --> 03:03:54,649 council chambers is Luke 5610 03:03:54,649 --> 03:03:55,383 Skywalker. 5611 03:03:55,383 --> 03:03:58,983 If you can please come forward. 5612 03:03:59,954 --> 03:04:00,755 There are no other speakers 5613 03:04:00,755 --> 03:04:01,488 that I have here in council 5614 03:04:01,488 --> 03:04:02,890 chambers or speaker slips so we 5615 03:04:02,890 --> 03:04:05,890 will be going to virtual 5616 03:04:06,126 --> 03:04:06,794 comment and no additional 5617 03:04:06,794 --> 03:04:07,940 speakers in chambers will be 5618 03:04:07,940 --> 03:04:07,595 taken. 5619 03:04:07,595 --> 03:04:08,620 >> Please proceed. 5620 03:04:08,620 --> 03:04:10,620 Good afternoon. 5621 03:04:12,900 --> 03:04:13,534 City Council My name is Luke 5622 03:04:13,534 --> 03:04:14,235 Skywalker and I'm here to 5623 03:04:14,235 --> 03:04:17,835 rescue you Here to rescue you 5624 03:04:18,139 --> 03:04:18,839 from these blocked cameras that 5625 03:04:18,839 --> 03:04:19,239 have been installed all across 5626 03:04:19,239 --> 03:04:19,941 the galaxy. 5627 03:04:19,941 --> 03:04:23,541 I have been traveling far and 5628 03:04:25,413 --> 03:04:25,713 wide to escape the evil Lord 5629 03:04:25,713 --> 03:04:26,313 Vader. 5630 03:04:26,313 --> 03:04:27,140 He's been traversing me. 5631 03:04:27,140 --> 03:04:30,140 He's been utilizing these plot 5632 03:04:30,585 --> 03:04:31,252 cameras to chase me all across 5633 03:04:31,252 --> 03:04:31,986 the galaxy And now I'm here 5634 03:04:31,986 --> 03:04:32,719 begging you not to suspend this 5635 03:04:32,719 --> 03:04:35,719 technology but to cancel this 5636 03:04:37,458 --> 03:04:38,125 technology once and for all. 5637 03:04:38,125 --> 03:04:38,758 It will be utilized to 5638 03:04:38,758 --> 03:04:39,226 facilitate the creation of 5639 03:04:39,226 --> 03:04:41,226 the Death Star. 5640 03:04:43,363 --> 03:04:43,832 That's where all of our data 5641 03:04:43,832 --> 03:04:44,365 will be stored. 5642 03:04:44,365 --> 03:04:45,990 I got to go. 5643 03:04:45,990 --> 03:04:45,566 My x-Wing is parked in a red 5644 03:04:45,566 --> 03:04:47,566 zone right now. 5645 03:04:49,170 --> 03:04:50,370 I can't I can't speak for long 5646 03:04:50,370 --> 03:04:50,738 But one thing I do want to tell 5647 03:04:50,738 --> 03:04:51,439 this council one thing I have 5648 03:04:51,439 --> 03:04:55,390 to employ this council is to 5649 03:04:55,710 --> 03:04:56,476 continue using the force 5650 03:04:56,476 --> 03:04:57,244 the way that you have thus far. 5651 03:04:57,244 --> 03:05:00,915 The force is strong with all of 5652 03:05:00,915 --> 03:05:01,616 you and the force is strong 5653 03:05:01,616 --> 03:05:02,150 with everyone in this council 5654 03:05:02,150 --> 03:05:03,351 chambers Thank you. 5655 03:05:03,351 --> 03:05:06,351 >> Are you guys brother and 5656 03:05:11,590 --> 03:05:11,759 sister that doesn't keep coming 5657 03:05:11,759 --> 03:05:14,759 here in council chambers Going 5658 03:05:15,162 --> 03:05:15,830 to those participating remotely 5659 03:05:15,830 --> 03:05:16,531 have started the five minute 5660 03:05:16,531 --> 03:05:19,531 timer and we have 23 speakers 5661 03:05:21,169 --> 03:05:22,200 in the queue. 5662 03:05:22,200 --> 03:05:22,670 Before we go to that I just 5663 03:05:22,670 --> 03:05:23,371 want to state for the record 5664 03:05:23,371 --> 03:05:26,371 that we did have 14 speakers 5665 03:05:27,275 --> 03:05:27,976 submit speaker slips in 5666 03:05:27,976 --> 03:05:30,878 opposition but did not wish to 5667 03:05:30,878 --> 03:05:31,579 speak as well as we received 5668 03:05:31,579 --> 03:05:32,279 ten comments in favor and 106 5669 03:05:32,279 --> 03:05:32,981 comments in opposition via our 5670 03:05:32,981 --> 03:05:35,981 economic forum which have been 5671 03:05:37,885 --> 03:05:38,419 distributed to the Council 5672 03:05:38,419 --> 03:05:40,419 starting with 8813. 5673 03:05:41,856 --> 03:05:42,357 If you can please unmute you'll 5674 03:05:42,357 --> 03:05:44,357 have one minute. 5675 03:05:48,463 --> 03:05:49,397 Please proceed. 5676 03:05:49,397 --> 03:05:52,997 >> 8813I do see you unmuted but 5677 03:05:56,104 --> 03:05:56,603 we do not hear you here in 5678 03:05:56,603 --> 03:05:57,271 council chambers. 5679 03:05:57,271 --> 03:05:57,939 Not sure of the device that 5680 03:05:57,939 --> 03:05:58,239 you're speaking into MAY be 5681 03:05:58,239 --> 03:05:58,639 here. 5682 03:05:58,639 --> 03:06:00,639 There we go. 5683 03:06:01,342 --> 03:06:01,743 Please proceed. 5684 03:06:01,743 --> 03:06:02,420 Okay. 5685 03:06:02,420 --> 03:06:02,776 Okay. 5686 03:06:02,776 --> 03:06:03,545 Controller I'm not sure if this 5687 03:06:03,545 --> 03:06:06,470 is Comic-Con or a freaking city 5688 03:06:06,470 --> 03:06:06,347 council meeting but here it 5689 03:06:06,347 --> 03:06:07,480 goes. 5690 03:06:07,480 --> 03:06:07,448 You know the dais had blood on 5691 03:06:07,448 --> 03:06:09,448 their hands. 5692 03:06:11,653 --> 03:06:12,387 That's what's so And yet 5693 03:06:12,387 --> 03:06:13,120 the public continues to blindly 5694 03:06:13,120 --> 03:06:16,120 trust these individuals like as 5695 03:06:17,459 --> 03:06:18,590 if they're all knowing that 5696 03:06:18,590 --> 03:06:18,626 going to be further from 5697 03:06:18,626 --> 03:06:18,993 the truth Start paying 5698 03:06:18,993 --> 03:06:20,993 attention. 5699 03:06:23,932 --> 03:06:24,632 This is all theater and they're 5700 03:06:24,632 --> 03:06:27,632 desperately trying to win back 5701 03:06:29,437 --> 03:06:30,105 the trust of the people because 5702 03:06:30,105 --> 03:06:30,838 the trust has been dwindling 5703 03:06:30,838 --> 03:06:35,380 for both sides for a while And 5704 03:06:35,760 --> 03:06:35,810 it's just so evident that 5705 03:06:35,810 --> 03:06:39,410 the system itself has failed us 5706 03:06:40,849 --> 03:06:41,549 all And yet you all continue to 5707 03:06:41,549 --> 03:06:45,149 believe and get and give up 5708 03:06:46,621 --> 03:06:47,489 your right over to it and 5709 03:06:47,489 --> 03:06:48,122 honestly and to those of you 5710 03:06:48,122 --> 03:06:51,122 who still believe in this 5711 03:06:52,260 --> 03:06:52,661 board, stop blindly handing it 5712 03:06:52,661 --> 03:06:53,294 over again. 5713 03:06:53,294 --> 03:06:53,961 Start holding these people 5714 03:06:53,961 --> 03:06:54,629 accountable and do it before 5715 03:06:54,629 --> 03:06:57,629 the damage is already done. 5716 03:06:58,866 --> 03:06:59,568 You ultimately want to feel 5717 03:06:59,568 --> 03:07:00,268 safe yet you continue putting 5718 03:07:00,268 --> 03:07:03,868 your trust in the same people 5719 03:07:04,839 --> 03:07:05,606 putting us in harm's way. 5720 03:07:05,606 --> 03:07:05,907 Wake up This is nothing to 5721 03:07:05,907 --> 03:07:06,608 take. 5722 03:07:06,608 --> 03:07:09,800 My daughter Katherine Douglas 5723 03:07:14,150 --> 03:07:14,916 If you can please On you In our 5724 03:07:14,916 --> 03:07:18,516 current law where it is very 5725 03:07:19,454 --> 03:07:20,120 hard to recruit qualified 5726 03:07:20,120 --> 03:07:22,520 police officers, Alpers and 5727 03:07:25,327 --> 03:07:26,940 other technologies are a force 5728 03:07:26,940 --> 03:07:26,728 a force multiplier and have had 5729 03:07:26,728 --> 03:07:27,462 a very positive effect on 5730 03:07:27,462 --> 03:07:31,620 the safety of everyone in our 5731 03:07:31,999 --> 03:07:32,467 communities and the recovery of 5732 03:07:32,467 --> 03:07:33,135 stolen property. 5733 03:07:33,135 --> 03:07:36,735 They do not shine on private 5734 03:07:37,406 --> 03:07:37,806 property and do not have facial 5735 03:07:37,806 --> 03:07:38,473 recognition. 5736 03:07:38,473 --> 03:07:41,473 I'm 100% in favor of them. 5737 03:07:43,278 --> 03:07:43,979 Please do more research before 5738 03:07:43,979 --> 03:07:44,546 you come to a premature 5739 03:07:44,546 --> 03:07:45,213 conclusion as to their 5740 03:07:45,213 --> 03:07:47,613 effectiveness in keeping us 5741 03:07:49,785 --> 03:07:50,652 safe. 5742 03:07:50,652 --> 03:07:51,386 I would also like to point out 5743 03:07:51,386 --> 03:07:54,986 that I think there were more 5744 03:07:55,723 --> 03:07:56,158 people speaking today against 5745 03:07:56,158 --> 03:07:56,992 the Clippers. 5746 03:07:56,992 --> 03:07:59,992 Where were these people when 5747 03:08:01,630 --> 03:08:02,264 the police presented the new 5748 03:08:02,264 --> 03:08:04,664 technologies and went over 5749 03:08:08,169 --> 03:08:08,870 the existing technologies? 5750 03:08:08,870 --> 03:08:09,603 There were less people there. 5751 03:08:09,603 --> 03:08:13,203 If you're going to speak on 5752 03:08:13,742 --> 03:08:14,476 this subject you ought to 5753 03:08:14,476 --> 03:08:17,476 attend these meetings which are 5754 03:08:18,413 --> 03:08:19,800 presented in all nine 5755 03:08:19,800 --> 03:08:20,615 communities Districts there 5756 03:08:20,615 --> 03:08:23,615 have concluded Gabriel if you 5757 03:08:34,620 --> 03:08:35,300 can please on you Gabriel you 5758 03:08:35,300 --> 03:08:35,697 are a muted we do not hear you 5759 03:08:35,697 --> 03:08:36,331 here in council chambers Not 5760 03:08:36,331 --> 03:08:38,300 sure if the devices you're 5761 03:08:38,300 --> 03:08:41,300 speaking into MAY be muted. 5762 03:08:43,171 --> 03:08:46,171 Gabriel Aravena You have not 5763 03:08:47,609 --> 03:08:49,609 muted yourself. 5764 03:08:54,810 --> 03:08:57,810 Please unmute the device that 5765 03:09:00,689 --> 03:09:01,122 you MAY be speaking to Maybe 5766 03:09:01,122 --> 03:09:01,857 muted. 5767 03:09:01,857 --> 03:09:02,658 I will move on to the next 5768 03:09:02,658 --> 03:09:05,658 caller if you can limit 5769 03:09:05,960 --> 03:09:06,828 yourself properly. 5770 03:09:06,828 --> 03:09:11,280 Like I said you are muted on 5771 03:09:11,999 --> 03:09:12,868 Zoom but we do not hear you. 5772 03:09:12,868 --> 03:09:15,868 >> Barbara Gordon If you can 5773 03:09:18,240 --> 03:09:19,108 please on you on. 5774 03:09:19,108 --> 03:09:19,875 Thank you And today I am urging 5775 03:09:19,875 --> 03:09:23,475 the city to support this vital 5776 03:09:23,645 --> 03:09:24,345 tool for our police department 5777 03:09:24,345 --> 03:09:27,345 because it helps officers turn 5778 03:09:29,718 --> 03:09:30,252 vehicle information into timely 5779 03:09:30,252 --> 03:09:30,885 investigation leads. 5780 03:09:30,885 --> 03:09:34,485 I had a friend that was 5781 03:09:35,791 --> 03:09:36,658 strangled to death in her bed. 5782 03:09:36,658 --> 03:09:37,325 Her killer is now in jail 5783 03:09:37,325 --> 03:09:40,325 because of this program was 5784 03:09:41,897 --> 03:09:42,664 able to identify his license 5785 03:09:42,664 --> 03:09:46,264 plate coming and going from her 5786 03:09:48,360 --> 03:09:48,671 home That helped him in 5787 03:09:48,671 --> 03:09:49,404 the investigation. 5788 03:09:49,404 --> 03:09:50,710 I asked you to continue to 5789 03:09:50,710 --> 03:09:53,710 allow this program that will 5790 03:09:53,876 --> 03:09:54,376 assist and support 5791 03:09:54,376 --> 03:09:55,277 the investigation. 5792 03:09:55,277 --> 03:09:59,477 Again, let us not lose sight of 5793 03:09:59,881 --> 03:10:00,716 the potential benefit. 5794 03:10:00,716 --> 03:10:01,416 This tool could help to improve 5795 03:10:01,416 --> 03:10:04,416 residents sense of safety and 5796 03:10:06,622 --> 03:10:07,356 confidence that the that police 5797 03:10:07,356 --> 03:10:07,656 have their tools to investigate 5798 03:10:07,656 --> 03:10:09,656 crime. 5799 03:10:12,427 --> 03:10:12,828 Again, please do not let this 5800 03:10:12,828 --> 03:10:13,662 program go. 5801 03:10:13,662 --> 03:10:16,662 >> Thank you for letting me 5802 03:10:18,990 --> 03:10:18,500 speak. 5803 03:10:18,500 --> 03:10:20,500 Thank you. 5804 03:10:23,839 --> 03:10:24,273 Walker If you can please unmute 5805 03:10:24,273 --> 03:10:25,107 Thank you. 5806 03:10:25,107 --> 03:10:29,307 As a victim of home burglary I 5807 03:10:30,846 --> 03:10:31,380 support Alpers use per 5808 03:10:31,380 --> 03:10:32,470 the trust ordinance. 5809 03:10:32,470 --> 03:10:32,648 I hear the fear here and I 5810 03:10:32,648 --> 03:10:35,480 empathize but don't find 5811 03:10:36,685 --> 03:10:37,453 documented evidence. 5812 03:10:37,453 --> 03:10:38,860 Very many of the kinds of 5813 03:10:38,860 --> 03:10:38,754 blatant mass shootings are 5814 03:10:38,754 --> 03:10:41,754 concerns that were voiced at 5815 03:10:42,891 --> 03:10:43,592 the same time there's 5816 03:10:43,592 --> 03:10:44,326 documented evidence of safety 5817 03:10:44,326 --> 03:10:44,893 benefits and allowing police to 5818 03:10:44,893 --> 03:10:47,293 better focus on active 5819 03:10:48,731 --> 03:10:50,731 emergency needs and 5820 03:10:52,968 --> 03:10:53,668 investigations including a 20% 5821 03:10:53,668 --> 03:10:54,403 drop in auto theft last year 5822 03:10:54,403 --> 03:10:57,403 Also that contributed to faster 5823 03:10:59,909 --> 03:11:00,609 clearances and homicides 5824 03:11:00,609 --> 03:11:01,477 Shootings hit and run Steve 5825 03:11:01,477 --> 03:11:05,770 Wise and leads an amber and 5826 03:11:05,381 --> 03:11:05,715 silver alerts for missing 5827 03:11:05,715 --> 03:11:06,382 persons. 5828 03:11:06,382 --> 03:11:08,782 That's very important legal 5829 03:11:10,119 --> 03:11:10,786 experts say that comply with 5830 03:11:10,786 --> 03:11:11,454 Fourth Amendment rights So I 5831 03:11:11,454 --> 03:11:13,854 suggest make corrections and 5832 03:11:16,325 --> 03:11:16,859 improve oversight but don't 5833 03:11:16,859 --> 03:11:17,560 eliminate something 5834 03:11:17,560 --> 03:11:17,893 contributing to greater public 5835 03:11:17,893 --> 03:11:19,893 safety. 5836 03:11:22,131 --> 03:11:22,598 Thank you. 5837 03:11:22,598 --> 03:11:24,598 Thank you. 5838 03:11:28,137 --> 03:11:28,838 Camera If you can please unmute 5839 03:11:28,838 --> 03:11:29,471 The five minute timer has also 5840 03:11:29,471 --> 03:11:30,105 considered hearing council 5841 03:11:30,105 --> 03:11:30,473 chambers or 29 speakers in 5842 03:11:30,473 --> 03:11:32,473 the queue. 5843 03:11:33,542 --> 03:11:33,843 No additional speakers will be 5844 03:11:33,843 --> 03:11:34,410 taken. 5845 03:11:34,410 --> 03:11:35,111 Camera please on you. 5846 03:11:35,111 --> 03:11:35,443 Good afternoon Council can you 5847 03:11:35,443 --> 03:11:37,443 hear me? 5848 03:11:39,248 --> 03:11:39,749 Yes please proceed. 5849 03:11:39,749 --> 03:11:40,149 Very good. 5850 03:11:40,149 --> 03:11:40,883 Thank you. 5851 03:11:40,883 --> 03:11:41,517 i live in District three and I 5852 03:11:41,517 --> 03:11:44,954 want to be clear I do not 5853 03:11:44,954 --> 03:11:45,621 support in any capacity 5854 03:11:45,621 --> 03:11:46,222 the presence of flock or any 5855 03:11:46,222 --> 03:11:46,989 npr cameras in San Diego 5856 03:11:46,989 --> 03:11:50,589 history has shown us time and 5857 03:11:51,627 --> 03:11:52,228 time again public safety does 5858 03:11:52,228 --> 03:11:52,662 not to come from mass 5859 03:11:52,662 --> 03:11:53,295 surveillance. 5860 03:11:53,295 --> 03:11:56,295 This technology is far too 5861 03:11:58,434 --> 03:11:59,168 easily used against citizens it 5862 03:11:59,168 --> 03:11:59,902 purports to protect and frankly 5863 03:11:59,902 --> 03:12:03,205 that's by design and helpers do 5864 03:12:03,205 --> 03:12:03,973 not keep us safe. 5865 03:12:03,973 --> 03:12:04,640 They make us something to be 5866 03:12:04,640 --> 03:12:06,640 commodified and preemptively 5867 03:12:09,211 --> 03:12:09,512 oppressed by the powers that be 5868 03:12:09,512 --> 03:12:10,213 . 5869 03:12:10,213 --> 03:12:10,846 The harm that this technology 5870 03:12:10,846 --> 03:12:11,580 presents to the public, to 5871 03:12:11,580 --> 03:12:14,580 innocent citizens who have been 5872 03:12:15,818 --> 03:12:16,485 and will be continue to be 5873 03:12:16,485 --> 03:12:17,186 harassed, stopped, killed by 5874 03:12:17,186 --> 03:12:17,787 our police department abusing 5875 03:12:17,787 --> 03:12:20,187 its faulty and dangerous 5876 03:12:21,857 --> 03:12:22,524 technology this far outweighs 5877 03:12:22,524 --> 03:12:23,192 any semblance of safety you 5878 03:12:23,192 --> 03:12:26,192 could ever claim to provide. 5879 03:12:27,630 --> 03:12:28,231 I agree The contract to flag 5880 03:12:28,231 --> 03:12:28,865 must be canceled cameras 5881 03:12:28,865 --> 03:12:29,598 deactivated and removed by 5882 03:12:29,598 --> 03:12:32,598 the city immediately because of 5883 03:12:34,202 --> 03:12:34,470 others have said We don't trust 5884 03:12:34,470 --> 03:12:35,104 you. 5885 03:12:35,104 --> 03:12:35,671 We don't trust the word or 5886 03:12:35,671 --> 03:12:36,339 the intentions of your 5887 03:12:36,339 --> 03:12:38,339 manufacturers, your council, 5888 03:12:39,375 --> 03:12:40,430 the mayor of your time, he 5889 03:12:40,430 --> 03:12:43,430 concluded John if you can 5890 03:12:45,248 --> 03:12:47,648 please unmute John Academy 5891 03:12:56,325 --> 03:12:56,659 before you join I want you to 5892 03:12:56,659 --> 03:12:58,659 move on. 5893 03:13:03,599 --> 03:13:04,334 >> If you're not unmuted. 5894 03:13:04,334 --> 03:13:07,334 Zeenat Sanchez if you can 5895 03:13:16,846 --> 03:13:17,547 please unmute your bill. 5896 03:13:17,547 --> 03:13:17,846 >> Oh yes, please proceed. 5897 03:13:17,846 --> 03:13:18,547 Okay. 5898 03:13:18,547 --> 03:13:20,450 Well first off before and it's 5899 03:13:20,450 --> 03:13:21,150 not stupid we see the political 5900 03:13:21,150 --> 03:13:21,718 maneuvering and alliances and 5901 03:13:21,718 --> 03:13:22,318 who's backing the same 5902 03:13:22,318 --> 03:13:22,885 political forces pushing 5903 03:13:22,885 --> 03:13:24,885 surveillance into our 5904 03:13:27,357 --> 03:13:28,910 communities are connected to 5905 03:13:28,910 --> 03:13:28,791 those who back Martha Abraham's 5906 03:13:28,791 --> 03:13:29,525 campaign After everything you 5907 03:13:29,525 --> 03:13:33,296 expect a to question if the map 5908 03:13:33,296 --> 03:13:33,962 is a map and we demand answers 5909 03:13:33,962 --> 03:13:34,264 We've been fighting flak for 5910 03:13:34,264 --> 03:13:34,931 years. 5911 03:13:34,931 --> 03:13:35,665 We warned you this contract 5912 03:13:35,665 --> 03:13:38,168 should never have been approved 5913 03:13:38,168 --> 03:13:38,935 and you ignored us. 5914 03:13:38,935 --> 03:13:39,601 Now the abuses we warned you 5915 03:13:39,601 --> 03:13:40,269 about are coming to light as 5916 03:13:40,269 --> 03:13:42,669 you continue to undermine 5917 03:13:45,740 --> 03:13:45,942 the tpp. 5918 03:13:45,942 --> 03:13:46,642 What kind of watchdog can be 5919 03:13:46,642 --> 03:13:47,343 right with the department it's 5920 03:13:47,343 --> 03:13:48,578 supposed to oversee Keeps on 5921 03:13:48,578 --> 03:13:49,278 its leash 12 minutes. 5922 03:13:49,278 --> 03:13:49,879 Watch your communities But you 5923 03:13:49,879 --> 03:13:50,346 won't give us meaningful 5924 03:13:50,346 --> 03:13:52,346 accountability. 5925 03:13:56,453 --> 03:13:57,222 We're not stupid or intimidated 5926 03:13:57,222 --> 03:13:57,721 and we're not going away before 5927 03:13:57,721 --> 03:13:58,388 nine are watching. 5928 03:13:58,388 --> 03:13:58,988 Southeast Asia is watching. 5929 03:13:58,988 --> 03:14:00,623 Terminate this contract. 5930 03:14:00,623 --> 03:14:01,224 Cut their surveillance and 5931 03:14:01,224 --> 03:14:01,924 excuses more demanding. 5932 03:14:01,924 --> 03:14:02,192 We're demanding accountability 5933 03:14:02,192 --> 03:14:04,192 now. 5934 03:14:04,994 --> 03:14:07,394 Thank you, Lawrence o'Donnell 5935 03:14:10,266 --> 03:14:10,571 If you can please let me Thank 5936 03:14:10,571 --> 03:14:11,340 you. 5937 03:14:11,340 --> 03:14:11,768 Good afternoon. 5938 03:14:11,768 --> 03:14:12,335 I taught information technology 5939 03:14:12,335 --> 03:14:14,735 at local colleges and 5940 03:14:17,400 --> 03:14:17,707 universities for 20 years and I 5941 03:14:17,707 --> 03:14:20,107 would never trust automated 5942 03:14:22,912 --> 03:14:23,446 cameras to do police work And 5943 03:14:23,446 --> 03:14:24,460 that's why I opposed 5944 03:14:24,460 --> 03:14:24,747 the cameras or any other 5945 03:14:24,747 --> 03:14:26,747 technology because ultimately 5946 03:14:28,752 --> 03:14:29,385 the use of your critical 5947 03:14:29,385 --> 03:14:30,119 thinking skills begins to 5948 03:14:30,119 --> 03:14:33,119 decline and our police officers 5949 03:14:34,190 --> 03:14:34,824 need to develop better critical 5950 03:14:34,824 --> 03:14:35,492 thinking skills when their 5951 03:14:35,492 --> 03:14:35,859 mistakes are life and death 5952 03:14:35,859 --> 03:14:37,859 decisions. 5953 03:14:40,663 --> 03:14:41,363 I was followed home one night 5954 03:14:41,363 --> 03:14:41,998 because a license plate reader 5955 03:14:41,998 --> 03:14:44,398 couldn't decipher a state 5956 03:14:46,770 --> 03:14:47,202 issued retired legislators 5957 03:14:47,202 --> 03:14:48,380 license plate. 5958 03:14:48,380 --> 03:14:48,772 And when I walked out to talk 5959 03:14:48,772 --> 03:14:52,372 to the officers and explain why 5960 03:14:52,776 --> 03:14:53,442 I wasn't being recognized in 5961 03:14:53,442 --> 03:14:54,177 their system, two additional 5962 03:14:54,177 --> 03:14:54,777 cars showed up simply because a 5963 03:14:54,777 --> 03:14:56,777 retired state legislator 5964 03:14:59,282 --> 03:14:59,950 decided to go out and engage 5965 03:14:59,950 --> 03:15:00,617 with the police officer and 5966 03:15:00,617 --> 03:15:03,170 explain that their automated 5967 03:15:04,254 --> 03:15:04,955 license plate reader didn't 5968 03:15:04,955 --> 03:15:05,589 understand what it was seeing. 5969 03:15:05,589 --> 03:15:07,989 We need critical thinking 5970 03:15:11,360 --> 03:15:12,229 skills not automated cameras. 5971 03:15:12,229 --> 03:15:12,863 >> Take down these walk and any 5972 03:15:12,863 --> 03:15:13,230 other technology cameras. 5973 03:15:13,230 --> 03:15:13,597 Thank you. 5974 03:15:13,597 --> 03:15:14,197 Thank you. 5975 03:15:14,197 --> 03:15:16,597 Next is Blair Beckman. 5976 03:15:20,971 --> 03:15:21,338 >> If you can please unmute. 5977 03:15:21,338 --> 03:15:22,380 All right. 5978 03:15:22,380 --> 03:15:25,638 But the reason I think there 5979 03:15:27,100 --> 03:15:27,811 can be a community consensus 5980 03:15:27,811 --> 03:15:28,511 that can be well focused and 5981 03:15:28,511 --> 03:15:29,245 respectful and that is simple 5982 03:15:29,245 --> 03:15:32,245 city council vote and certainly 5983 03:15:32,782 --> 03:15:33,550 the current locks of contract 5984 03:15:33,550 --> 03:15:34,418 and a considerable amount of 50 5985 03:15:34,418 --> 03:15:38,180 to 250 San Diego yards this can 5986 03:15:40,256 --> 03:15:40,957 be followed up in 2027 with a 5987 03:15:40,957 --> 03:15:43,357 full committee process perhaps 5988 03:15:44,160 --> 03:15:44,960 a bill that can ask if we need 5989 03:15:44,960 --> 03:15:48,560 a better principal or a vendor. 5990 03:15:48,899 --> 03:15:49,599 And can we can we can we begin 5991 03:15:49,599 --> 03:15:50,266 to reduce the 2024 You make 5992 03:15:50,266 --> 03:15:53,266 your contract a five minute 5993 03:15:57,808 --> 03:15:58,408 deal along with all 5994 03:15:58,408 --> 03:15:59,750 the additional safety of 5995 03:15:59,750 --> 03:15:59,709 the neighborhood cap and any 5996 03:15:59,709 --> 03:16:01,812 new best practices of our 5997 03:16:01,812 --> 03:16:02,479 current studies of the past few 5998 03:16:02,479 --> 03:16:03,180 years it should be becoming 5999 03:16:03,180 --> 03:16:06,180 clear we can much reduce 6000 03:16:07,250 --> 03:16:07,918 placement that is redundant 6001 03:16:07,918 --> 03:16:10,318 while still maintaining good 6002 03:16:12,255 --> 03:16:12,623 public safety practices In 6003 03:16:12,623 --> 03:16:13,423 the 2027. 6004 03:16:13,423 --> 03:16:14,123 I hope we can all continue to 6005 03:16:14,123 --> 03:16:17,723 work and create a very clear 6006 03:16:17,727 --> 03:16:18,428 path to developing a more 6007 03:16:18,428 --> 03:16:19,129 accountable, more responsible 6008 03:16:19,129 --> 03:16:19,796 and better principal policies 6009 03:16:19,796 --> 03:16:22,796 and practices within our San 6010 03:16:24,701 --> 03:16:25,469 Diego neighborhood. 6011 03:16:25,469 --> 03:16:26,360 >> Public Safety Questions. 6012 03:16:26,360 --> 03:16:26,970 Thanks for your time. 6013 03:16:26,970 --> 03:16:30,570 Good luck with your work to 6014 03:16:33,544 --> 03:16:34,411 echo If you can please unmute. 6015 03:16:34,411 --> 03:16:34,744 Yes, hi, this is this is Elke 6016 03:16:34,744 --> 03:16:36,744 Weston. 6017 03:16:39,916 --> 03:16:40,950 I am a voter in Logan Heights. 6018 03:16:40,950 --> 03:16:45,150 You know, it's kind of a crack 6019 03:16:45,756 --> 03:16:46,356 up that we have a full board of 6020 03:16:46,356 --> 03:16:47,900 Democrats and it's been 6021 03:16:47,900 --> 03:16:50,690 the biggest failure with all of 6022 03:16:51,761 --> 03:16:52,960 you except for Shawn Helio 6023 03:16:52,960 --> 03:16:54,960 Rivera. 6024 03:16:56,967 --> 03:16:57,634 You know the fork in the Alpers 6025 03:16:57,634 --> 03:16:57,967 cameras, they were used in 6026 03:16:57,967 --> 03:16:59,967 Germany. 6027 03:17:03,139 --> 03:17:03,540 94% of the images they took 6028 03:17:03,540 --> 03:17:04,108 were faulty. 6029 03:17:04,108 --> 03:17:04,508 Couldn't give them any 6030 03:17:04,508 --> 03:17:05,142 information. 6031 03:17:05,142 --> 03:17:07,542 That's the same technology 6032 03:17:09,179 --> 03:17:09,947 you're using out of all 6033 03:17:09,947 --> 03:17:10,347 the images you took And it cost 6034 03:17:10,347 --> 03:17:12,347 $12 million. 6035 03:17:14,510 --> 03:17:14,718 There was only 300 cases that 6036 03:17:14,718 --> 03:17:15,485 were worthy of looking into. 6037 03:17:15,485 --> 03:17:18,485 So you're saying that it's 6038 03:17:20,240 --> 03:17:20,791 worth 40 grand for one case 6039 03:17:20,791 --> 03:17:23,791 while you stock while you 6040 03:17:25,896 --> 03:17:26,330 racially profile while you 6041 03:17:26,330 --> 03:17:27,300 discriminate? 6042 03:17:27,300 --> 03:17:27,731 Do you know how many people I 6043 03:17:27,731 --> 03:17:30,131 know that intentionally drove 6044 03:17:31,769 --> 03:17:32,469 down imperial breaking the law 6045 03:17:32,469 --> 03:17:33,169 just to see if you would 6046 03:17:33,169 --> 03:17:36,169 contact them with white skin? 6047 03:17:38,842 --> 03:17:39,476 What you guys are doing with 6048 03:17:39,476 --> 03:17:40,210 the exception of San Diego 6049 03:17:40,210 --> 03:17:43,210 Rivera your time has concluded. 6050 03:17:45,481 --> 03:17:45,883 Carol Kim, if you can please. 6051 03:17:45,883 --> 03:17:46,483 And you. 6052 03:17:46,483 --> 03:17:46,817 Good afternoon, council 6053 03:17:46,817 --> 03:17:48,817 members. 6054 03:17:50,887 --> 03:17:51,621 This is Carol Kim Business 6055 03:17:51,621 --> 03:17:52,256 manager of the San Diego County 6056 03:17:52,256 --> 03:17:52,723 Building and Construction 6057 03:17:52,723 --> 03:17:53,390 Trades Council. 6058 03:17:53,390 --> 03:17:56,390 When we grapple with public 6059 03:17:57,194 --> 03:17:57,895 policy, we can't simply ask can 6060 03:17:57,895 --> 03:17:58,195 this potentially do something 6061 03:17:58,195 --> 03:17:58,862 good? 6062 03:17:58,862 --> 03:17:59,463 We have to actually ask are 6063 03:17:59,463 --> 03:18:01,863 the tradeoffs worth it? 6064 03:18:03,600 --> 03:18:04,268 All over the country we have to 6065 03:18:04,268 --> 03:18:07,868 often plunge into the use of 6066 03:18:08,500 --> 03:18:08,706 surveillance based only on 6067 03:18:08,706 --> 03:18:09,306 the first question and without 6068 03:18:09,306 --> 03:18:09,706 enough consideration of 6069 03:18:09,706 --> 03:18:10,241 the second. 6070 03:18:10,241 --> 03:18:10,875 But that's given us 6071 03:18:10,875 --> 03:18:13,275 the opportunity to witness 6072 03:18:14,712 --> 03:18:15,345 rampant abuse of these systems, 6073 03:18:15,345 --> 03:18:16,800 forcing us to ask how many 6074 03:18:16,800 --> 03:18:16,547 crimes we are willing to create 6075 03:18:16,547 --> 03:18:18,547 in this process. 6076 03:18:20,784 --> 03:18:21,352 Hopefully the answer is zero. 6077 03:18:21,352 --> 03:18:22,520 Hopefully we would not 6078 03:18:22,520 --> 03:18:24,520 knowingly create opportunities 6079 03:18:25,856 --> 03:18:26,323 for more abuse under any 6080 03:18:26,323 --> 03:18:27,240 circumstances. 6081 03:18:27,240 --> 03:18:27,524 We should not be trading away 6082 03:18:27,524 --> 03:18:28,259 our civil rights. 6083 03:18:28,259 --> 03:18:31,859 We have seen locally and beyond 6084 03:18:32,562 --> 03:18:33,297 that these systems make 6085 03:18:33,297 --> 03:18:33,897 unacceptable errors even before 6086 03:18:33,897 --> 03:18:34,632 accounting for the human 6087 03:18:34,632 --> 03:18:37,632 temptation for abuse and beyond 6088 03:18:38,502 --> 03:18:39,136 undermining public trust. 6089 03:18:39,136 --> 03:18:39,804 Local governments all over 6090 03:18:39,804 --> 03:18:40,403 the country including right 6091 03:18:40,403 --> 03:18:43,403 here will be paying out 6092 03:18:44,607 --> 03:18:45,309 millions upon millions to 6093 03:18:45,309 --> 03:18:45,642 settle cases of these systems 6094 03:18:45,642 --> 03:18:46,310 failing. 6095 03:18:46,310 --> 03:18:47,120 It's not worth the cuts and 6096 03:18:47,120 --> 03:18:50,120 it's not worth the tradeoffs. 6097 03:18:51,215 --> 03:18:51,882 I urge you to reject to attend 6098 03:18:51,882 --> 03:18:52,583 and remove npr in San Diego. 6099 03:18:52,583 --> 03:18:53,417 The case has concluded Million 6100 03:18:53,417 --> 03:18:57,170 Mile Man If you can please 6101 03:18:59,190 --> 03:18:59,957 unmute. 6102 03:18:59,957 --> 03:19:02,357 >> We are looking at 6103 03:19:04,929 --> 03:19:05,663 philosophical psychological, 6104 03:19:05,663 --> 03:19:06,363 historical and moral constructs 6105 03:19:06,363 --> 03:19:09,363 here which transcend the whole 6106 03:19:11,869 --> 03:19:14,869 idea of surveillance From JULY 6107 03:19:16,874 --> 03:19:20,474 14th, 1789 to that was the body 6108 03:19:21,679 --> 03:19:22,279 and the Nuremberg trials which 6109 03:19:22,279 --> 03:19:22,947 wasn't about obedience. 6110 03:19:22,947 --> 03:19:26,547 We already knew that it was 6111 03:19:27,585 --> 03:19:28,252 about obedience and obedience 6112 03:19:28,252 --> 03:19:31,852 can be regulated but a man's 6113 03:19:33,757 --> 03:19:34,458 conscience cannot be regulated 6114 03:19:34,458 --> 03:19:35,193 And this is the fundamental 6115 03:19:35,193 --> 03:19:38,193 issue we're talking about here. 6116 03:19:40,764 --> 03:19:41,432 We're talking about what 6117 03:19:41,432 --> 03:19:41,999 the Jesuits that determine a 6118 03:19:41,999 --> 03:19:44,399 boy develops its moral 6119 03:19:46,403 --> 03:19:47,710 conscience at seven years old. 6120 03:19:47,710 --> 03:19:47,604 They don't learn this in 6121 03:19:47,604 --> 03:19:49,604 the police academy. 6122 03:19:52,376 --> 03:19:52,910 Even the joint Chiefs probably 6123 03:19:52,910 --> 03:19:53,911 don't even learn it. 6124 03:19:53,911 --> 03:19:58,149 But that is a fact and that is 6125 03:19:58,149 --> 03:19:58,916 human behavior. 6126 03:19:58,916 --> 03:19:59,283 Get rid of these cameras now. 6127 03:19:59,283 --> 03:20:01,283 Thank you. 6128 03:20:05,289 --> 03:20:06,230 Daniel Jones up. 6129 03:20:06,230 --> 03:20:06,991 >> Your time has concluded. 6130 03:20:06,991 --> 03:20:11,191 We turn if you can please on 6131 03:20:11,829 --> 03:20:12,663 mute. 6132 03:20:12,663 --> 03:20:13,230 Hi, my name is Weekend and I'm 6133 03:20:13,230 --> 03:20:15,630 going to started here. 6134 03:20:17,135 --> 03:20:17,835 Then it goes I'm calling to 6135 03:20:17,835 --> 03:20:20,835 support a committee member to 6136 03:20:22,709 --> 03:20:23,508 vote voted against a contract 6137 03:20:23,508 --> 03:20:24,175 between those two When we made 6138 03:20:24,175 --> 03:20:27,775 the decision in JUNE when it 6139 03:20:29,113 --> 03:20:29,680 was a hard decision actually it 6140 03:20:29,680 --> 03:20:30,415 would have been hard. 6141 03:20:30,415 --> 03:20:31,480 As I said, you guys voted to 6142 03:20:31,480 --> 03:20:31,749 support a community joined 6143 03:20:31,749 --> 03:20:34,749 million dollar could have gone 6144 03:20:35,386 --> 03:20:35,853 to a lot of around our culture 6145 03:20:35,853 --> 03:20:36,588 and everything. 6146 03:20:36,588 --> 03:20:40,524 I'm glad to be able to have 6147 03:20:40,524 --> 03:20:41,225 some member now finally on 6148 03:20:41,225 --> 03:20:41,759 board I mean you'll have staff 6149 03:20:41,759 --> 03:20:42,360 who could have done 6150 03:20:42,360 --> 03:20:45,360 the research to find out 6151 03:20:47,432 --> 03:20:48,132 exactly what it means and what 6152 03:20:48,132 --> 03:20:49,330 I've been feeding you Now I'm 6153 03:20:49,330 --> 03:20:53,233 glad you willing to step up to 6154 03:20:54,338 --> 03:20:55,206 the right diet issue but I want 6155 03:20:55,206 --> 03:20:58,409 to name just a couple who did 6156 03:20:58,409 --> 03:20:59,277 the right thing all along. 6157 03:20:59,277 --> 03:21:00,145 Should also get that we should 6158 03:21:00,145 --> 03:21:03,181 get a credit for us So please 6159 03:21:03,181 --> 03:21:03,615 also vote vote to terminate 6160 03:21:03,615 --> 03:21:03,981 the contract. 6161 03:21:03,981 --> 03:21:04,682 Thank you. 6162 03:21:04,682 --> 03:21:08,282 Thank you Amanda if you can 6163 03:21:14,825 --> 03:21:15,160 please unmute but yes please 6164 03:21:15,160 --> 03:21:15,493 proceed. 6165 03:21:15,493 --> 03:21:15,961 >> Okay. 6166 03:21:15,961 --> 03:21:17,961 Good afternoon. 6167 03:21:21,933 --> 03:21:22,634 I through council I would like 6168 03:21:22,634 --> 03:21:23,401 to encourage everyone in this 6169 03:21:23,401 --> 03:21:26,904 room to find a way to watch 6170 03:21:26,904 --> 03:21:27,572 the movie not that in the movie 6171 03:21:27,572 --> 03:21:28,306 Israeli soldiers explain how 6172 03:21:28,306 --> 03:21:30,706 surveillance technology is used 6173 03:21:32,977 --> 03:21:33,311 to target rebellious civilians 6174 03:21:33,311 --> 03:21:33,978 . 6175 03:21:33,978 --> 03:21:34,645 Surveillance tech assigns a 6176 03:21:34,645 --> 03:21:35,146 threat number to individuals 6177 03:21:35,146 --> 03:21:37,146 that authorize it. 6178 03:21:38,783 --> 03:21:39,484 How many innocent civilians can 6179 03:21:39,484 --> 03:21:40,185 be murdered in order to kill 6180 03:21:40,185 --> 03:21:40,618 one target while they sleep in 6181 03:21:40,618 --> 03:21:41,319 bed at night? 6182 03:21:41,319 --> 03:21:44,319 They label them terrorists for 6183 03:21:45,423 --> 03:21:46,240 resisting. 6184 03:21:46,240 --> 03:21:46,691 I really government Not 6185 03:21:46,691 --> 03:21:49,910 dissimilar to the executive 6186 03:21:49,828 --> 03:21:50,462 order Trump issued in SEPTEMBER 6187 03:21:50,462 --> 03:21:51,950 25th labeling anti-fascist 6188 03:21:51,950 --> 03:21:51,696 protesters as Terrorists. 6189 03:21:51,696 --> 03:21:54,960 We watch other Congress 6190 03:21:56,434 --> 03:21:59,434 attempts to merge our military 6191 03:22:01,640 --> 03:22:02,340 with Israel's with ndaa such in 6192 03:22:02,340 --> 03:22:02,941 1270 We see the department our 6193 03:22:02,941 --> 03:22:03,574 city Council with Israel 6194 03:22:03,574 --> 03:22:03,909 including Todd Gloria and 6195 03:22:03,909 --> 03:22:05,909 Ocampo. 6196 03:22:07,579 --> 03:22:08,246 We get the people like Stephen 6197 03:22:08,246 --> 03:22:08,746 Miller at the helm of Trump 6198 03:22:08,746 --> 03:22:10,746 fascist take over. 6199 03:22:12,517 --> 03:22:13,151 We think our city council has 6200 03:22:13,151 --> 03:22:13,818 put smart streetlights and 6201 03:22:13,818 --> 03:22:14,519 surveillance technology on a 6202 03:22:14,519 --> 03:22:17,889 city against their will and we 6203 03:22:17,889 --> 03:22:18,523 are all connecting the dots No 6204 03:22:18,523 --> 03:22:19,900 mass surveillance, no data 6205 03:22:19,900 --> 03:22:19,723 centers Get the out. 6206 03:22:19,723 --> 03:22:22,723 Michael Schmidt If you can 6207 03:22:24,295 --> 03:22:26,295 please unmute Break. 6208 03:22:30,340 --> 03:22:30,735 Good evening everyone. 6209 03:22:30,735 --> 03:22:31,169 Please take those cameras down 6210 03:22:31,169 --> 03:22:31,970 of the lights. 6211 03:22:31,970 --> 03:22:35,570 They're so pointless and I just 6212 03:22:36,608 --> 03:22:37,275 hate the fact that people get 6213 03:22:37,275 --> 03:22:40,275 red on their license plates. 6214 03:22:42,147 --> 03:22:42,747 I just think it's pointless. 6215 03:22:42,747 --> 03:22:43,140 But thank you very much. 6216 03:22:43,140 --> 03:22:43,381 Bye. 6217 03:22:43,381 --> 03:22:43,681 Thank you. 6218 03:22:43,681 --> 03:22:45,681 Ted. 6219 03:22:50,922 --> 03:22:51,230 If you can please unmute. 6220 03:22:51,230 --> 03:22:51,790 Hello? 6221 03:22:51,790 --> 03:22:52,900 Can you hear me? 6222 03:22:52,900 --> 03:22:52,557 Yes. 6223 03:22:52,557 --> 03:22:53,580 Please proceed. 6224 03:22:53,580 --> 03:22:55,458 Hi, my name's Ted. 6225 03:22:58,329 --> 03:22:58,963 Well, I'm back with Santiago 6226 03:22:58,963 --> 03:22:59,698 and also the vice chair of 6227 03:22:59,698 --> 03:23:02,634 the Faculty Advisory board just 6228 03:23:02,634 --> 03:23:03,335 for everybody really quick 6229 03:23:03,335 --> 03:23:04,200 recap about where we are with 6230 03:23:04,200 --> 03:23:04,335 the automatic license plate 6231 03:23:04,335 --> 03:23:06,335 readers. 6232 03:23:08,540 --> 03:23:09,441 Originally they were introduced 6233 03:23:09,441 --> 03:23:10,175 to us and we had to accept 6234 03:23:10,175 --> 03:23:10,809 the usage of them without a use 6235 03:23:10,809 --> 03:23:13,209 policy because of exigent 6236 03:23:14,980 --> 03:23:15,380 circumstances We found out that 6237 03:23:15,380 --> 03:23:16,810 wasn't true. 6238 03:23:16,810 --> 03:23:16,882 Once we had our use policy we 6239 03:23:16,882 --> 03:23:19,882 figured out that our youth 6240 03:23:20,285 --> 03:23:20,985 policy was being violated 6241 03:23:20,985 --> 03:23:21,386 because the doj contacted law 6242 03:23:21,386 --> 03:23:21,953 enforcement. 6243 03:23:21,953 --> 03:23:24,353 We were sharing data. 6244 03:23:26,658 --> 03:23:27,326 We found out L.A.P.D. Is 6245 03:23:27,326 --> 03:23:30,326 sharing that same data with 6246 03:23:31,496 --> 03:23:32,130 federal agents and ice to cause 6247 03:23:32,130 --> 03:23:32,864 fear in our neighborhoods. 6248 03:23:32,864 --> 03:23:36,464 So we have a violation of 6249 03:23:38,537 --> 03:23:39,203 the use policy We've had things 6250 03:23:39,203 --> 03:23:39,871 gone wrong with this and yet 6251 03:23:39,871 --> 03:23:40,572 we've had no accountability. 6252 03:23:40,572 --> 03:23:43,207 I want to say from this Dyess 6253 03:23:43,207 --> 03:23:43,809 that if they could save one 6254 03:23:43,809 --> 03:23:44,576 life that it's worth it. 6255 03:23:44,576 --> 03:23:45,277 But at this point it's caused 6256 03:23:45,277 --> 03:23:48,277 the death of multiple lives 6257 03:23:49,715 --> 03:23:50,249 When it hindered 6258 03:23:50,249 --> 03:23:50,648 the investigation at 6259 03:23:50,648 --> 03:23:51,349 the center. 6260 03:23:51,349 --> 03:23:51,850 So at this point we just need 6261 03:23:51,850 --> 03:23:54,250 to take them down. 6262 03:23:55,754 --> 03:23:56,870 I'm going to use that same kind 6263 03:23:56,870 --> 03:23:56,721 of mask. 6264 03:23:56,721 --> 03:23:57,289 >> We violated the policy. 6265 03:23:57,289 --> 03:23:57,889 It's not saving lives. 6266 03:23:57,889 --> 03:24:00,289 Your time has concluded. 6267 03:24:03,962 --> 03:24:04,295 Omar, if you can please on you 6268 03:24:04,295 --> 03:24:04,663 . 6269 03:24:04,663 --> 03:24:05,430 >> Thanks. 6270 03:24:05,430 --> 03:24:06,164 I'd like to apologize to all 6271 03:24:06,164 --> 03:24:09,764 the police officers in the room 6272 03:24:10,200 --> 03:24:10,869 here having to take this woke 6273 03:24:10,869 --> 03:24:14,469 mob lecture And you got to 6274 03:24:15,400 --> 03:24:15,741 realize guys, there's hundreds 6275 03:24:15,741 --> 03:24:19,341 of thousands of San Diego guns 6276 03:24:19,878 --> 03:24:20,445 that stand behind guys that 6277 03:24:20,445 --> 03:24:21,179 want the best for you. 6278 03:24:21,179 --> 03:24:24,179 We're grateful that you're here 6279 03:24:25,651 --> 03:24:26,484 serving our community. 6280 03:24:26,484 --> 03:24:27,185 I think this is a good thing 6281 03:24:27,185 --> 03:24:27,953 for you guys to have these You 6282 03:24:27,953 --> 03:24:31,553 have the training now to use 6283 03:24:31,556 --> 03:24:32,900 them, not abuse them And these 6284 03:24:32,900 --> 03:24:34,490 guys might take it. 6285 03:24:38,530 --> 03:24:39,231 The council here might take a 6286 03:24:39,231 --> 03:24:39,764 knee to the wolf mob, the mobs 6287 03:24:39,764 --> 03:24:42,164 coming out of there. 6288 03:24:42,567 --> 03:24:43,268 This is going to be the first 6289 03:24:43,268 --> 03:24:43,936 knee they're going to take and 6290 03:24:43,936 --> 03:24:44,603 it's going to be more so I 6291 03:24:44,603 --> 03:24:47,300 don't realize you police 6292 03:24:47,840 --> 03:24:48,574 officers have families and 6293 03:24:48,574 --> 03:24:52,174 you're risking your life for us 6294 03:24:53,145 --> 03:24:53,845 and different times when you 6295 03:24:53,845 --> 03:24:54,313 interact with the police show 6296 03:24:54,313 --> 03:24:56,313 them your hands. 6297 03:24:58,717 --> 03:24:59,184 A lot of guys are angry at you 6298 03:24:59,184 --> 03:24:59,885 guys black guys. 6299 03:24:59,885 --> 03:25:00,585 They're angry that now if they 6300 03:25:00,585 --> 03:25:04,185 could learn to show the cops 6301 03:25:04,356 --> 03:25:04,790 their hands that's what they 6302 03:25:04,790 --> 03:25:05,457 want to see. 6303 03:25:05,457 --> 03:25:07,857 >> They don't want trouble. 6304 03:25:07,893 --> 03:25:08,761 Your time has concluded Next to 6305 03:25:08,761 --> 03:25:12,361 Santa Marina If you can please 6306 03:25:13,765 --> 03:25:16,765 unmute it's time to take 6307 03:25:19,338 --> 03:25:20,390 the cameras down. 6308 03:25:20,390 --> 03:25:20,706 The Senior Police Department 6309 03:25:20,706 --> 03:25:23,542 annual news report failed to 6310 03:25:23,542 --> 03:25:24,310 mention a 19 year old who was 6311 03:25:24,310 --> 03:25:24,713 shot in a car by a police 6312 03:25:24,713 --> 03:25:25,344 department. 6313 03:25:25,344 --> 03:25:27,744 The vehicle wasn't stolen. 6314 03:25:29,114 --> 03:25:29,715 We know our cameras are not 6315 03:25:29,715 --> 03:25:30,683 making San Diego safer. 6316 03:25:30,683 --> 03:25:34,883 How many more people need to be 6317 03:25:34,920 --> 03:25:35,620 hurt translates our 6318 03:25:35,620 --> 03:25:36,222 constitutional rights and puts 6319 03:25:36,222 --> 03:25:36,822 the safety of residents, 6320 03:25:36,822 --> 03:25:39,222 visitors and tourists in 6321 03:25:40,426 --> 03:25:41,930 jeopardy Tragically as deeply 6322 03:25:41,930 --> 03:25:44,693 as also use these cameras to 6323 03:25:45,363 --> 03:25:46,132 track the domestic violence 6324 03:25:46,132 --> 03:25:46,565 victim now a victim of mass 6325 03:25:46,565 --> 03:25:48,565 shootings too. 6326 03:25:50,869 --> 03:25:51,570 These cameras are being used to 6327 03:25:51,570 --> 03:25:52,171 track and set private citizens 6328 03:25:52,171 --> 03:25:54,571 going about their lives. 6329 03:25:56,742 --> 03:25:57,709 Please take the cameras out. 6330 03:25:57,709 --> 03:26:00,709 Alison, if you can please 6331 03:26:01,947 --> 03:26:03,947 unmute. 6332 03:26:08,353 --> 03:26:10,753 Oh, there you go. 6333 03:26:10,823 --> 03:26:11,590 Oh, counsel, I am Alison and I 6334 03:26:11,590 --> 03:26:12,324 live in District three and I 6335 03:26:12,324 --> 03:26:15,828 just want to echo what my peers 6336 03:26:15,828 --> 03:26:16,228 have said today that we expect 6337 03:26:16,228 --> 03:26:17,960 from you. 6338 03:26:17,960 --> 03:26:21,296 We demand from you that you not 6339 03:26:21,534 --> 03:26:22,234 only vote no tonight but that 6340 03:26:22,234 --> 03:26:22,635 you also begin today to remove 6341 03:26:22,635 --> 03:26:24,635 the cameras. 6342 03:26:26,705 --> 03:26:27,473 Do not let them stay up. 6343 03:26:27,473 --> 03:26:28,307 Revenue of them starting today. 6344 03:26:28,307 --> 03:26:31,307 Also we need to cancel 6345 03:26:32,578 --> 03:26:33,112 the contracts for smart street 6346 03:26:33,112 --> 03:26:33,545 lights and air drone 6347 03:26:33,545 --> 03:26:35,545 surveillance. 6348 03:26:37,617 --> 03:26:41,217 This is misused and abused in 6349 03:26:42,888 --> 03:26:43,322 our city every day and it is 6350 03:26:43,322 --> 03:26:43,923 unacceptable. 6351 03:26:43,923 --> 03:26:44,323 It continues to harm our 6352 03:26:44,323 --> 03:26:46,323 communities. 6353 03:26:47,326 --> 03:26:48,940 At a background in health care 6354 03:26:48,940 --> 03:26:48,761 and in health care ethics we 6355 03:26:48,761 --> 03:26:51,761 have an order of operations 6356 03:26:52,865 --> 03:26:53,232 under which we evaluate ethical 6357 03:26:53,232 --> 03:26:54,320 decisions. 6358 03:26:54,320 --> 03:26:58,700 First is to do no harm and then 6359 03:26:58,700 --> 03:26:58,804 to do good. 6360 03:26:58,804 --> 03:26:59,505 Some people here have tried to 6361 03:26:59,505 --> 03:27:00,720 argue today that pr technology 6362 03:27:00,720 --> 03:27:03,900 has some good in it. 6363 03:27:03,900 --> 03:27:03,709 I question that. 6364 03:27:03,709 --> 03:27:04,310 However, the fact remains that 6365 03:27:04,310 --> 03:27:06,710 you have not eliminated 6366 03:27:08,147 --> 03:27:08,815 the harm yet You have to 6367 03:27:08,815 --> 03:27:09,482 eliminate the harm first by 6368 03:27:09,482 --> 03:27:10,583 canceling Floc and removing 6369 03:27:10,583 --> 03:27:12,583 the cameras. 6370 03:27:15,922 --> 03:27:16,889 Starting today your time. 6371 03:27:16,889 --> 03:27:19,889 Anthony if you can please 6372 03:27:27,330 --> 03:27:27,566 unmute capacity Counsel My name 6373 03:27:27,566 --> 03:27:28,401 is Anthony Billows. 6374 03:27:28,401 --> 03:27:30,603 I am the co-founder of Beloved 6375 03:27:30,603 --> 03:27:32,603 Community Collective and 6376 03:27:35,407 --> 03:27:36,475 the cst. 6377 03:27:36,475 --> 03:27:37,143 >> I just want to say thank you 6378 03:27:37,143 --> 03:27:40,379 first and foremost to all of 6379 03:27:40,379 --> 03:27:41,147 the people who continue to show 6380 03:27:41,147 --> 03:27:42,115 up on behalf of community, on 6381 03:27:42,115 --> 03:27:45,818 behalf of those of us who are 6382 03:27:45,818 --> 03:27:46,419 more vulnerable Pana 6383 03:27:46,419 --> 03:27:46,853 specifically pillars of 6384 03:27:46,853 --> 03:27:48,853 the community. 6385 03:27:50,757 --> 03:27:54,957 I saw aclu that I've heard many 6386 03:27:55,394 --> 03:27:55,894 many people trust folks in 6387 03:27:55,894 --> 03:27:56,662 the Trust or cpi. 6388 03:27:56,662 --> 03:28:00,433 I just want to say thank you 6389 03:28:00,433 --> 03:28:01,100 again to all of those who keep 6390 03:28:01,100 --> 03:28:01,634 showing up and keep speaking 6391 03:28:01,634 --> 03:28:04,340 for people like me. 6392 03:28:06,806 --> 03:28:07,473 I want to thank Council member 6393 03:28:07,473 --> 03:28:08,274 ilo Shahani La Ribera for 6394 03:28:08,274 --> 03:28:10,543 actually leading this fight and 6395 03:28:10,543 --> 03:28:11,900 consistently being on the right 6396 03:28:11,900 --> 03:28:13,900 side of history. 6397 03:28:13,980 --> 03:28:14,646 I want to invite every second 6398 03:28:14,646 --> 03:28:15,348 city council member to live 6399 03:28:15,348 --> 03:28:17,748 through accountability in this 6400 03:28:18,685 --> 03:28:19,385 moment accountability to 6401 03:28:19,385 --> 03:28:19,752 the people that you pretend to 6402 03:28:19,752 --> 03:28:21,752 represent. 6403 03:28:22,989 --> 03:28:23,757 Accountability for those who 6404 03:28:23,757 --> 03:28:24,490 continue to harm and do not 6405 03:28:24,490 --> 03:28:24,757 want to be held responsible for 6406 03:28:24,757 --> 03:28:26,757 it. 6407 03:28:28,828 --> 03:28:29,762 Say no, no thank you. 6408 03:28:29,762 --> 03:28:33,362 >> Next is Maia If you can 6409 03:28:44,144 --> 03:28:44,843 please unmute my you are in 6410 03:28:44,843 --> 03:28:45,478 muted but we don't hear you 6411 03:28:45,478 --> 03:28:45,878 here in council chambers. 6412 03:28:45,878 --> 03:28:47,747 Hear me now. 6413 03:28:47,747 --> 03:28:48,214 Yes. 6414 03:28:48,214 --> 03:28:48,515 Please proceed. 6415 03:28:48,515 --> 03:28:49,315 Okay. 6416 03:28:49,315 --> 03:28:51,217 Stability Who has to Who has 6417 03:28:51,217 --> 03:28:51,918 been here or who Where were we 6418 03:28:51,918 --> 03:28:52,419 three years ago when this was 6419 03:28:52,419 --> 03:28:52,885 being introduced? 6420 03:28:52,885 --> 03:28:53,319 We've been here. 6421 03:28:53,319 --> 03:28:55,319 We were there. 6422 03:28:55,889 --> 03:28:56,589 I was there when that pig Jeff 6423 03:28:56,589 --> 03:28:59,589 Jordan unraveled the scheme in 6424 03:29:00,326 --> 03:29:00,827 front of the community. 6425 03:29:00,827 --> 03:29:01,594 193 weeks ago. 6426 03:29:01,594 --> 03:29:04,530 I was there when the Privacy 6427 03:29:04,530 --> 03:29:05,231 Advisory Board unanimously 6428 03:29:05,231 --> 03:29:05,965 voted against this technology. 6429 03:29:05,965 --> 03:29:09,565 And when the city council voted 6430 03:29:09,769 --> 03:29:10,536 for it anyway. 6431 03:29:10,536 --> 03:29:11,204 So we've been here, we have 6432 03:29:11,204 --> 03:29:11,838 been here, the community has 6433 03:29:11,838 --> 03:29:14,674 been here and we've been 6434 03:29:14,674 --> 03:29:15,308 against it and we've been 6435 03:29:15,308 --> 03:29:17,708 ignored this entire time. 6436 03:29:18,712 --> 03:29:19,345 And so I also find it really 6437 03:29:19,345 --> 03:29:21,745 disgusting that Marni von 6438 03:29:23,916 --> 03:29:24,651 Wilpert values the privacy of a 6439 03:29:24,651 --> 03:29:25,318 pig more than the thousands of 6440 03:29:25,318 --> 03:29:27,718 Americans or centurions that 6441 03:29:29,289 --> 03:29:30,156 have begged for years for this 6442 03:29:30,156 --> 03:29:33,860 to not be in place And they 6443 03:29:33,860 --> 03:29:34,561 haven't respected that. 6444 03:29:34,561 --> 03:29:35,495 The fact that you respect his 6445 03:29:35,495 --> 03:29:38,431 privacy more than all of us is 6446 03:29:38,431 --> 03:29:40,431 disgusting. 6447 03:29:40,966 --> 03:29:43,966 >> Seven 499 If you can please 6448 03:29:47,106 --> 03:29:48,241 unmute 7499. 6449 03:29:48,241 --> 03:29:50,710 >> But because I ski here I 6450 03:29:50,710 --> 03:29:51,478 read George Orwell's 1984 back 6451 03:29:51,478 --> 03:29:55,548 in the 70s when I was still a 6452 03:29:55,548 --> 03:29:56,216 relatively young teenager. 6453 03:29:56,216 --> 03:29:56,849 The most chilling aspect of 6454 03:29:56,849 --> 03:29:59,849 that book was the constant 6455 03:30:00,520 --> 03:30:01,455 surveillance by the state. 6456 03:30:01,455 --> 03:30:02,222 But at that time I pretty much 6457 03:30:02,222 --> 03:30:04,791 dismissed that future because I 6458 03:30:04,791 --> 03:30:05,425 realized that it would take 6459 03:30:05,425 --> 03:30:07,825 about three people working 6460 03:30:08,328 --> 03:30:09,620 eight hour shifts to watch just 6461 03:30:09,620 --> 03:30:09,696 one person's cameras every day. 6462 03:30:09,696 --> 03:30:11,696 And that's unsustainable. 6463 03:30:13,366 --> 03:30:14,670 But with the recent growth of 6464 03:30:14,670 --> 03:30:14,767 that equation requiring three 6465 03:30:14,767 --> 03:30:17,871 people to watch one person no 6466 03:30:17,871 --> 03:30:18,672 longer holds. 6467 03:30:18,672 --> 03:30:19,439 I am a conservative and I 6468 03:30:19,439 --> 03:30:22,439 support law and order but 6469 03:30:23,109 --> 03:30:23,543 massive balance is not the way 6470 03:30:23,543 --> 03:30:24,110 to do it. 6471 03:30:24,110 --> 03:30:26,510 Even worse, the city 6472 03:30:27,414 --> 03:30:28,480 continually turns government 6473 03:30:28,480 --> 03:30:28,615 functions over to private 6474 03:30:28,615 --> 03:30:30,615 businesses for profit. 6475 03:30:32,850 --> 03:30:32,786 As we've seen at the Torrey 6476 03:30:32,786 --> 03:30:33,320 Pines Blight report, that's a 6477 03:30:33,320 --> 03:30:35,320 recipe for disaster. 6478 03:30:37,691 --> 03:30:38,225 These cameras are a form of 6479 03:30:38,225 --> 03:30:38,925 high tech stalking. 6480 03:30:38,925 --> 03:30:39,626 Listen to Laurie Seldon, your 6481 03:30:39,626 --> 03:30:42,229 best givens and the people of 6482 03:30:42,229 --> 03:30:42,928 this city. 6483 03:30:42,928 --> 03:30:43,363 >> Take the cameras down now. 6484 03:30:43,363 --> 03:30:45,363 Thank you. 6485 03:30:55,575 --> 03:30:58,575 1697 If you can please unmute. 6486 03:31:02,716 --> 03:31:03,416 Hello, my name is Jessie. 6487 03:31:03,416 --> 03:31:03,717 I'm a resident of District 6488 03:31:03,717 --> 03:31:04,418 three. 6489 03:31:04,418 --> 03:31:06,753 Premier asking the council to 6490 03:31:06,753 --> 03:31:07,521 cancel the floor contract I 6491 03:31:07,521 --> 03:31:08,322 thought did not keep us safe Is 6492 03:31:08,322 --> 03:31:11,257 an invasion of our privacy and 6493 03:31:11,257 --> 03:31:12,920 a waste of our money. 6494 03:31:12,920 --> 03:31:12,525 We send $2 million a year on 6495 03:31:12,525 --> 03:31:14,525 these cameras. 6496 03:31:15,528 --> 03:31:16,196 These money this money should 6497 03:31:16,196 --> 03:31:16,596 be used to invest in our 6498 03:31:16,596 --> 03:31:18,596 communities. 6499 03:31:20,400 --> 03:31:21,000 These cameras are frequently 6500 03:31:21,000 --> 03:31:21,735 incorrect and they put 6501 03:31:21,735 --> 03:31:22,503 everybody in San Diego at risk. 6502 03:31:22,503 --> 03:31:25,503 Please invest back in our 6503 03:31:25,539 --> 03:31:25,973 communities, not in mass 6504 03:31:25,973 --> 03:31:26,406 surveillance. 6505 03:31:26,406 --> 03:31:26,773 >> Thank you. 6506 03:31:26,773 --> 03:31:27,808 Thank you. 6507 03:31:27,808 --> 03:31:31,408 And Elliot, if you can please 6508 03:31:32,445 --> 03:31:33,130 unmute. 6509 03:31:33,130 --> 03:31:35,130 >> Hello. 6510 03:31:37,885 --> 03:31:38,485 My name is Sam Elliott and I am 6511 03:31:38,485 --> 03:31:40,485 deeply concerned by 6512 03:31:42,356 --> 03:31:42,990 the intrusion of surveillance 6513 03:31:42,990 --> 03:31:45,390 technology into our lives. 6514 03:31:47,127 --> 03:31:47,894 We are rapidly becoming digital 6515 03:31:47,894 --> 03:31:51,494 rather than human beings and in 6516 03:31:52,433 --> 03:31:52,933 the process we are losing our 6517 03:31:52,933 --> 03:31:53,700 right to privacy. 6518 03:31:53,700 --> 03:31:57,104 I urge you to vote no on 6519 03:31:57,104 --> 03:31:57,905 the continuance of a lpr 6520 03:31:57,905 --> 03:31:59,707 technology and I also urge you 6521 03:31:59,707 --> 03:32:03,307 in the coming year to vote 6522 03:32:04,912 --> 03:32:05,312 against drones as first 6523 03:32:05,312 --> 03:32:07,312 responders. 6524 03:32:09,750 --> 03:32:10,217 It's the same issue. 6525 03:32:10,217 --> 03:32:10,617 >> Thank you. 6526 03:32:10,617 --> 03:32:11,118 Thank you. 6527 03:32:11,118 --> 03:32:13,118 Next is drone. 6528 03:32:14,455 --> 03:32:15,222 If you can please unmute. 6529 03:32:15,222 --> 03:32:15,889 If you raise your hand after 6530 03:32:15,889 --> 03:32:19,489 the five minute timer we MAY 6531 03:32:20,160 --> 03:32:20,861 not be able to take you today 6532 03:32:20,861 --> 03:32:21,428 but you can definitely submit 6533 03:32:21,428 --> 03:32:23,630 any further comments. 6534 03:32:23,630 --> 03:32:23,430 The city clerk at San 6535 03:32:23,430 --> 03:32:23,964 diego.Gov. 6536 03:32:23,964 --> 03:32:24,365 >> And those will be 6537 03:32:24,365 --> 03:32:24,898 distributed. 6538 03:32:24,898 --> 03:32:26,898 John please proceed. 6539 03:32:28,869 --> 03:32:29,370 I gave it a hearing. 6540 03:32:29,370 --> 03:32:30,370 >> Hello? 6541 03:32:30,370 --> 03:32:30,804 Yes, we can hear you. 6542 03:32:30,804 --> 03:32:33,204 Please proceed with your 6543 03:32:34,842 --> 03:32:35,442 comments. 6544 03:32:35,442 --> 03:32:36,209 >> Can hear me? 6545 03:32:36,209 --> 03:32:39,112 Yes, we can hear you. 6546 03:32:39,112 --> 03:32:39,947 Okay. 6547 03:32:39,947 --> 03:32:40,681 I just want to say it's great 6548 03:32:40,681 --> 03:32:43,751 to see so many different people 6549 03:32:43,751 --> 03:32:44,418 You have young and old and 6550 03:32:44,418 --> 03:32:45,850 libertarians and democratic 6551 03:32:45,850 --> 03:32:45,519 socialists all speaking out 6552 03:32:45,519 --> 03:32:47,519 against this. 6553 03:32:49,230 --> 03:32:49,790 These are terrible idea. 6554 03:32:49,790 --> 03:32:50,424 I can't believe this was ever 6555 03:32:50,424 --> 03:32:51,192 passed in the first place. 6556 03:32:51,192 --> 03:32:54,528 They've got to be taken down 6557 03:32:54,528 --> 03:32:55,162 Yesterday and they've got to be 6558 03:32:55,162 --> 03:32:55,896 melted down Just canceling 6559 03:32:55,896 --> 03:32:59,660 the contracts Not not there can 6560 03:32:59,660 --> 03:32:59,533 be no more of this technology 6561 03:32:59,533 --> 03:33:00,233 under any name. 6562 03:33:00,233 --> 03:33:00,601 We can't trust the police with 6563 03:33:00,601 --> 03:33:02,601 the data. 6564 03:33:04,538 --> 03:33:04,839 We can't trust companies with 6565 03:33:04,839 --> 03:33:05,539 data. 6566 03:33:05,539 --> 03:33:06,273 We can't trust hackers to not 6567 03:33:06,273 --> 03:33:07,607 hack into it and take the data. 6568 03:33:07,607 --> 03:33:08,208 Thank you. 6569 03:33:08,208 --> 03:33:10,208 Thank you, Nancy. 6570 03:33:12,613 --> 03:33:13,130 If you can please unmute I can 6571 03:33:13,130 --> 03:33:13,314 you hear me? 6572 03:33:13,314 --> 03:33:15,314 Yes. 6573 03:33:17,551 --> 03:33:17,918 Please proceed. 6574 03:33:17,918 --> 03:33:18,619 Thank you. 6575 03:33:18,619 --> 03:33:18,919 Hi, Nancy Roller for district 6576 03:33:18,919 --> 03:33:20,919 three. 6577 03:33:22,689 --> 03:33:23,424 Thank you to the council member 6578 03:33:23,424 --> 03:33:26,424 for considering and changing to 6579 03:33:27,528 --> 03:33:28,195 oppose like in San Diego and to 6580 03:33:28,195 --> 03:33:28,929 Councilmember Eli Rivera for 6581 03:33:28,929 --> 03:33:32,467 all your work our data and 6582 03:33:32,467 --> 03:33:33,302 privacy are the real product 6583 03:33:33,302 --> 03:33:36,804 for Floc and all other pr and 6584 03:33:36,804 --> 03:33:37,838 surveillance companies. 6585 03:33:37,838 --> 03:33:41,975 I urge you all to vote to end 6586 03:33:41,975 --> 03:33:42,710 the contract today take down 6587 03:33:42,710 --> 03:33:43,410 all cameras and hardware, cover 6588 03:33:43,410 --> 03:33:47,100 the cameras and tell them and 6589 03:33:47,448 --> 03:33:48,115 resist any urge to settle for a 6590 03:33:48,115 --> 03:33:50,115 pause Suspension moratorium 6591 03:33:51,819 --> 03:33:52,520 Audit new lpr company or any 6592 03:33:52,520 --> 03:33:55,520 other status quo solution that 6593 03:33:56,657 --> 03:33:57,425 just continues the harm. 6594 03:33:57,425 --> 03:34:01,250 Please reject the alp pr use 6595 03:34:01,463 --> 03:34:02,196 policy No guardrails or 6596 03:34:02,196 --> 03:34:02,830 policies or boards or oversight 6597 03:34:02,830 --> 03:34:05,230 are sufficient to prevent 6598 03:34:05,866 --> 03:34:06,467 the misuse and harm of mass 6599 03:34:06,467 --> 03:34:08,467 dragnet surveillance in 6600 03:34:11,639 --> 03:34:12,340 the hands of police, feds and 6601 03:34:12,340 --> 03:34:14,340 tech corporation billionaires. 6602 03:34:16,110 --> 03:34:16,811 I would love to see an audit 6603 03:34:16,811 --> 03:34:17,512 but only an independent audit 6604 03:34:17,512 --> 03:34:20,512 as a postmortem has concluded. 6605 03:34:21,349 --> 03:34:24,285 My apologies 8700 if you can 6606 03:34:24,285 --> 03:34:26,285 please unmute 8700. 6607 03:34:27,210 --> 03:34:29,210 Hello? 6608 03:34:32,193 --> 03:34:34,193 >> Yes, please proceed. 6609 03:34:37,932 --> 03:34:38,433 You have you had unmuted and 6610 03:34:38,433 --> 03:34:38,733 now there you go. 6611 03:34:38,733 --> 03:34:39,300 Okay. 6612 03:34:39,300 --> 03:34:41,700 Are you still there? 6613 03:34:42,636 --> 03:34:43,204 Yes, please proceed. 6614 03:34:43,204 --> 03:34:45,604 That was my problem. 6615 03:34:47,275 --> 03:34:47,675 Joy Soon to my yes vote rests 6616 03:34:47,675 --> 03:34:49,675 on the pab. 6617 03:34:52,379 --> 03:34:55,979 They said yes to 53 of the 54 6618 03:34:57,185 --> 03:34:57,952 technologies and no to continue 6619 03:34:57,952 --> 03:35:00,952 the alp use unless spv 6620 03:35:01,756 --> 03:35:02,323 strengthened its auditing and 6621 03:35:02,323 --> 03:35:04,323 cybersecurity related 6622 03:35:06,794 --> 03:35:07,462 procedures and improved how it 6623 03:35:07,462 --> 03:35:09,462 tracks pab recommendations. 6624 03:35:11,532 --> 03:35:12,200 If the pd has strongly honored 6625 03:35:12,200 --> 03:35:14,200 those recommendations, Dear 6626 03:35:16,970 --> 03:35:21,170 Chief Wall it looks to me yet 6627 03:35:21,309 --> 03:35:24,909 can you verify that the prb 6628 03:35:25,946 --> 03:35:26,714 the whole board voted Now and 6629 03:35:26,714 --> 03:35:28,714 approved all 64 technologies 6630 03:35:31,419 --> 03:35:31,686 including the continued use of 6631 03:35:31,686 --> 03:35:32,520 alp. 6632 03:35:32,520 --> 03:35:36,120 Ah so it's been a great 6633 03:35:36,291 --> 03:35:36,991 afternoon everybody who loved 6634 03:35:36,991 --> 03:35:39,991 hearing your voices and I'm 6635 03:35:41,280 --> 03:35:41,629 just looking forward to this 6636 03:35:41,629 --> 03:35:42,230 speaking I guess I hope 6637 03:35:42,230 --> 03:35:44,630 somebody can answer that 6638 03:35:45,166 --> 03:35:45,867 question for me Otherwise put a 6639 03:35:45,867 --> 03:35:46,700 pause on this matter will you? 6640 03:35:46,700 --> 03:35:47,340 We're not ready to vote yes or 6641 03:35:47,340 --> 03:35:49,340 no. 6642 03:35:50,939 --> 03:35:51,840 All time has concluded. 6643 03:35:51,840 --> 03:35:54,408 Leyla please if you can please 6644 03:35:54,408 --> 03:35:54,809 unmute. 6645 03:35:54,809 --> 03:35:55,543 >> Hello. 6646 03:35:55,543 --> 03:35:59,143 First and foremost I want to 6647 03:35:59,247 --> 03:36:02,247 thank Trust sd who saw 6648 03:36:04,510 --> 03:36:04,786 the issues beforehand Who under 6649 03:36:04,786 --> 03:36:05,487 stood what was at stake. 6650 03:36:05,487 --> 03:36:08,487 A collective of diverse people 6651 03:36:10,525 --> 03:36:11,590 who came together to protect 6652 03:36:11,590 --> 03:36:11,760 all of our privacy. 6653 03:36:11,760 --> 03:36:14,495 I want to thank Sonia Rivera. 6654 03:36:14,495 --> 03:36:15,163 I want to thank Henry Foster, 6655 03:36:15,163 --> 03:36:18,163 the third and Viviane Marino 6656 03:36:18,400 --> 03:36:19,100 who saw this issue initially 6657 03:36:19,100 --> 03:36:19,734 and voted on the right side. 6658 03:36:19,734 --> 03:36:20,101 Please do not renew their 6659 03:36:20,101 --> 03:36:22,101 contract. 6660 03:36:23,237 --> 03:36:23,538 Do not give them any more 6661 03:36:23,538 --> 03:36:24,720 money. 6662 03:36:24,720 --> 03:36:25,600 Turn off the Alpers. 6663 03:36:25,600 --> 03:36:28,510 Don't find a different way to 6664 03:36:28,510 --> 03:36:29,344 surveillance the people. 6665 03:36:29,344 --> 03:36:29,978 And let's get back to human 6666 03:36:29,978 --> 03:36:32,378 values, human dignity and 6667 03:36:33,815 --> 03:36:34,482 community building. 6668 03:36:34,482 --> 03:36:35,116 >> Thank you so much. 6669 03:36:35,116 --> 03:36:37,516 Next is Jamie Emerson. 6670 03:36:40,789 --> 03:36:43,789 If you can please unmute. 6671 03:36:45,393 --> 03:36:46,940 >> Good evening Council 6672 03:36:46,940 --> 03:36:46,727 PRESIDENT And council members. 6673 03:36:46,727 --> 03:36:49,727 My name is Janie Emerson. 6674 03:36:50,531 --> 03:36:51,466 I'm from Council District one. 6675 03:36:51,466 --> 03:36:51,900 Fear is a dangerous way to make 6676 03:36:51,900 --> 03:36:53,900 public policy. 6677 03:36:55,604 --> 03:36:56,304 Safety is a positive way to 6678 03:36:56,304 --> 03:36:59,304 make public policy policy and 6679 03:36:59,607 --> 03:37:00,575 it is your job. 6680 03:37:00,575 --> 03:37:01,142 As a senior I worry about my 6681 03:37:01,142 --> 03:37:03,142 husband getting lost. 6682 03:37:04,646 --> 03:37:05,380 These cameras are proven to 6683 03:37:05,380 --> 03:37:05,780 find and return seniors quickly 6684 03:37:05,780 --> 03:37:07,780 and safely. 6685 03:37:09,784 --> 03:37:10,185 As a grandmother I worry about 6686 03:37:10,185 --> 03:37:10,852 abductions. 6687 03:37:10,852 --> 03:37:14,155 Almost one year ago a young 6688 03:37:14,155 --> 03:37:14,856 lady was abducted by her 6689 03:37:14,856 --> 03:37:15,524 ex-boyfriend who threatened to 6690 03:37:15,524 --> 03:37:18,524 torture, rape and kill her. 6691 03:37:19,294 --> 03:37:19,561 She was rescued due to an ill 6692 03:37:19,561 --> 03:37:21,561 pr. 6693 03:37:23,864 --> 03:37:24,566 We need to keep everyone safe. 6694 03:37:24,566 --> 03:37:25,133 We need to address the fears 6695 03:37:25,133 --> 03:37:27,533 and concerns of all. 6696 03:37:29,400 --> 03:37:29,471 Let's get together to revise 6697 03:37:29,471 --> 03:37:31,471 the guardrails. 6698 03:37:33,375 --> 03:37:33,942 Technology is the future. 6699 03:37:33,942 --> 03:37:34,876 It is already here. 6700 03:37:34,876 --> 03:37:38,213 We need to embrace it and use 6701 03:37:38,213 --> 03:37:39,147 it positive. 6702 03:37:39,147 --> 03:37:42,747 We make technology a way of 6703 03:37:44,251 --> 03:37:44,553 keeping everybody safe in San 6704 03:37:44,553 --> 03:37:44,920 Diego. 6705 03:37:44,920 --> 03:37:45,420 Thank you. 6706 03:37:45,420 --> 03:37:47,222 Thank you, Nancy. 6707 03:37:47,222 --> 03:37:50,725 Nancy Berman, if you can please 6708 03:37:50,725 --> 03:37:52,725 unmute. 6709 03:37:55,998 --> 03:37:56,765 Hi, my name is Nancy. 6710 03:37:56,765 --> 03:37:57,131 I'm a mother to two small 6711 03:37:57,131 --> 03:37:57,932 children. 6712 03:37:57,932 --> 03:38:01,690 I live in District nine in very 6713 03:38:01,690 --> 03:38:01,403 close proximity to numerous 6714 03:38:01,403 --> 03:38:01,969 cameras. 6715 03:38:01,969 --> 03:38:02,570 I care deeply about my 6716 03:38:02,570 --> 03:38:04,970 children, my family, my 6717 03:38:05,606 --> 03:38:05,941 neighbors and our collective 6718 03:38:05,941 --> 03:38:06,642 safety. 6719 03:38:06,642 --> 03:38:10,812 Because of that I urge you to 6720 03:38:10,812 --> 03:38:11,380 oppose the npr use policy and 6721 03:38:11,380 --> 03:38:12,140 the thought contract. 6722 03:38:12,140 --> 03:38:15,140 Take the cameras down and 6723 03:38:15,751 --> 03:38:16,518 delete the data constitution. 6724 03:38:16,518 --> 03:38:17,185 All rights are a critical 6725 03:38:17,185 --> 03:38:19,585 component to public safety. 6726 03:38:20,322 --> 03:38:21,880 Presumed innocent until proven 6727 03:38:21,880 --> 03:38:21,790 guilty is a cornerstone of our 6728 03:38:21,790 --> 03:38:24,790 justice system and cpd clearly 6729 03:38:25,193 --> 03:38:26,280 does not care. 6730 03:38:26,280 --> 03:38:26,628 Npr has flipped this on its 6731 03:38:26,628 --> 03:38:27,329 head as evidenced by our 6732 03:38:27,329 --> 03:38:29,530 neighbor who is separated from 6733 03:38:29,530 --> 03:38:30,199 his family and daily life 6734 03:38:30,199 --> 03:38:30,999 subjected to the cruelty of 6735 03:38:30,999 --> 03:38:34,503 jail for a month because of a 6736 03:38:34,503 --> 03:38:35,370 mystery. 6737 03:38:35,370 --> 03:38:36,380 And our other neighbor who is 6738 03:38:36,380 --> 03:38:36,672 shot in the shoulder without 6739 03:38:36,672 --> 03:38:39,720 hesitation by officers of 6740 03:38:39,574 --> 03:38:40,275 Pronto after another misread 6741 03:38:40,275 --> 03:38:43,211 likely violating police use of 6742 03:38:43,211 --> 03:38:43,979 force policy. 6743 03:38:43,979 --> 03:38:44,680 Public safety must go far 6744 03:38:44,680 --> 03:38:45,380 beyond protecting and tracking 6745 03:38:45,380 --> 03:38:48,380 down property and that should 6746 03:38:48,851 --> 03:38:49,551 certainly not happen at 6747 03:38:49,551 --> 03:38:49,885 the expense of people's actual 6748 03:38:49,885 --> 03:38:50,485 safety. 6749 03:38:50,485 --> 03:38:53,155 Thank you to the Council 6750 03:38:53,155 --> 03:38:53,855 members who've been champions 6751 03:38:53,855 --> 03:38:54,556 of the people those who have 6752 03:38:54,556 --> 03:38:57,556 also changed their mind after 6753 03:38:58,994 --> 03:38:59,595 listening and learning who will 6754 03:38:59,595 --> 03:38:59,962 be retiring on the right 6755 03:38:59,962 --> 03:39:00,662 included. 6756 03:39:00,662 --> 03:39:03,662 >> Gabriel Renner If you can 6757 03:39:05,100 --> 03:39:05,667 please unmute. 6758 03:39:05,667 --> 03:39:05,968 Can you hear me? 6759 03:39:05,968 --> 03:39:06,435 Yes. 6760 03:39:06,435 --> 03:39:08,435 Please proceed. 6761 03:39:10,506 --> 03:39:11,175 Previously a crime would occur 6762 03:39:11,175 --> 03:39:11,807 The police would investigate 6763 03:39:11,807 --> 03:39:14,207 and then collect evidence. 6764 03:39:15,644 --> 03:39:16,312 You've allowed that to turn on 6765 03:39:16,312 --> 03:39:19,312 its head by first collecting 6766 03:39:19,348 --> 03:39:20,480 evidence on all of us 24 seven 6767 03:39:20,480 --> 03:39:23,648 Then when a crime is committed 6768 03:39:23,986 --> 03:39:24,886 police search the evidence and 6769 03:39:24,886 --> 03:39:25,386 nobody asked us if we were okay 6770 03:39:25,386 --> 03:39:25,821 with changing that 6771 03:39:25,821 --> 03:39:27,821 relationship. 6772 03:39:29,458 --> 03:39:30,192 And just because you think we 6773 03:39:30,192 --> 03:39:30,859 need something doesn't give you 6774 03:39:30,859 --> 03:39:31,226 the right to make that final 6775 03:39:31,226 --> 03:39:33,226 decision. 6776 03:39:34,630 --> 03:39:34,897 Our demands are this number 6777 03:39:34,897 --> 03:39:35,698 one. 6778 03:39:35,698 --> 03:39:38,698 Permanent bans and removal of 6779 03:39:39,334 --> 03:39:40,350 all pr technology and other 6780 03:39:40,350 --> 03:39:42,350 creepy surveillance including 6781 03:39:44,907 --> 03:39:45,607 private apps that are found in 6782 03:39:45,607 --> 03:39:48,410 places like Home Depot or hoa. 6783 03:39:48,410 --> 03:39:49,211 Number two immediate stops on 6784 03:39:49,211 --> 03:39:52,811 all data sharing with ice and 6785 03:39:53,820 --> 03:39:53,749 other agencies. 6786 03:39:53,749 --> 03:39:56,749 Number three a community led 6787 03:39:58,387 --> 03:39:59,870 police oversight committee. 6788 03:39:59,870 --> 03:40:02,870 The people have been activated 6789 03:40:03,250 --> 03:40:03,425 and now we are watching you get 6790 03:40:03,425 --> 03:40:03,993 the out. 6791 03:40:03,993 --> 03:40:04,393 Oppose item 200. 6792 03:40:04,393 --> 03:40:04,860 Thank you. 6793 03:40:04,860 --> 03:40:06,860 Thank you. 6794 03:40:08,970 --> 03:40:10,833 Next is one on branding and 6795 03:40:10,833 --> 03:40:13,833 1415 if you can please unmute 6796 03:40:20,442 --> 03:40:21,210 1415 star six 1415 I can't I 6797 03:40:21,210 --> 03:40:24,513 mean for you you will have to 6798 03:40:24,513 --> 03:40:25,181 press star six to unmute. 6799 03:40:25,181 --> 03:40:27,181 >> There you go. 6800 03:40:29,510 --> 03:40:29,752 What's more chilling than 6801 03:40:29,752 --> 03:40:30,453 the surveillance from Orwell's 6802 03:40:30,453 --> 03:40:33,453 1984 book is The Blind Trust 6803 03:40:33,756 --> 03:40:34,256 The People have in their 6804 03:40:34,256 --> 03:40:36,256 government Budget. 6805 03:40:38,861 --> 03:40:40,960 Thanks. 6806 03:40:40,960 --> 03:40:44,296 >> Next is d if you can please 6807 03:40:48,571 --> 03:40:52,171 unmute the d you cannot unmute 6808 03:40:52,241 --> 03:40:52,875 for you You have to There 6809 03:40:52,875 --> 03:40:55,875 should be a prompt that's 6810 03:41:01,317 --> 03:41:04,917 coming up for you to unmute 6811 03:41:09,859 --> 03:41:13,459 data Unmute Tim if you can 6812 03:41:19,168 --> 03:41:20,690 please unmute I, I want to let 6813 03:41:20,690 --> 03:41:20,769 Okay I want I want to talk 6814 03:41:20,769 --> 03:41:22,104 about how the distribution of 6815 03:41:22,104 --> 03:41:24,504 these cameras betray what 6816 03:41:27,376 --> 03:41:27,910 they're really for when it 6817 03:41:27,910 --> 03:41:28,310 comes to underserved 6818 03:41:28,310 --> 03:41:29,100 communities. 6819 03:41:29,100 --> 03:41:32,648 The only thing that I ever get 6820 03:41:32,648 --> 03:41:33,215 overserved by policing and 6821 03:41:33,215 --> 03:41:33,716 surveillance same with 6822 03:41:33,716 --> 03:41:35,716 the flock cameras. 6823 03:41:36,752 --> 03:41:37,219 >> I don't have any in my 6824 03:41:37,219 --> 03:41:37,887 neighborhood but 6825 03:41:37,887 --> 03:41:40,887 the neighborhood next to me 6826 03:41:41,758 --> 03:41:42,491 does take them down. 6827 03:41:42,491 --> 03:41:42,859 Don't replace them with another 6828 03:41:42,859 --> 03:41:44,859 contract. 6829 03:41:45,928 --> 03:41:46,996 Anything like that. 6830 03:41:46,996 --> 03:41:51,196 It is the police's job to do 6831 03:41:51,234 --> 03:41:54,234 policing, not to spy on 6832 03:41:55,571 --> 03:41:56,272 everyone And then we get upset 6833 03:41:56,272 --> 03:41:56,639 when the cops are policing 6834 03:41:56,639 --> 03:41:57,373 the cops. 6835 03:41:57,373 --> 03:41:57,673 That's really what I'm actually 6836 03:41:57,673 --> 03:41:59,673 like. 6837 03:42:00,743 --> 03:42:01,410 Not really that worried about 6838 03:42:01,410 --> 03:42:04,410 because they are supposed to 6839 03:42:05,381 --> 03:42:05,714 carry their their cameras 6840 03:42:05,714 --> 03:42:07,714 anyways. 6841 03:42:08,151 --> 03:42:10,551 But yes, it's called 6842 03:42:13,155 --> 03:42:13,822 the contract. 6843 03:42:13,822 --> 03:42:14,223 Our civil liberties are at 6844 03:42:14,223 --> 03:42:16,223 stake here. 6845 03:42:17,592 --> 03:42:18,460 Thank you. 6846 03:42:18,460 --> 03:42:19,328 >> And then our final speaker 6847 03:42:19,328 --> 03:42:22,832 is Rosie, if you can please 6848 03:42:22,832 --> 03:42:23,466 unmute. 6849 03:42:23,466 --> 03:42:25,466 >> Hello council members. 6850 03:42:28,400 --> 03:42:28,304 I'm a constituent in District 6851 03:42:28,304 --> 03:42:30,304 three. 6852 03:42:31,907 --> 03:42:32,641 I've worked in technology as a 6853 03:42:32,641 --> 03:42:33,242 software engineer for ten years 6854 03:42:33,242 --> 03:42:36,646 and I use air every day. 6855 03:42:36,646 --> 03:42:37,347 When I makes mistakes we cutely 6856 03:42:37,347 --> 03:42:37,646 call it a hallucination not an 6857 03:42:37,646 --> 03:42:38,380 error. 6858 03:42:38,380 --> 03:42:41,317 But if a human was 6859 03:42:41,317 --> 03:42:41,917 hallucinating on the job it 6860 03:42:41,917 --> 03:42:42,618 would probably be really 6861 03:42:42,618 --> 03:42:42,919 concerning and they might get 6862 03:42:42,919 --> 03:42:44,919 fired. 6863 03:42:46,889 --> 03:42:47,624 Air often makes mistakes. 6864 03:42:47,624 --> 03:42:48,324 The stakes are too high for it 6865 03:42:48,324 --> 03:42:48,591 to be trusted with surveilling 6866 03:42:48,591 --> 03:42:50,591 us. 6867 03:42:51,828 --> 03:42:52,527 We've already seen this in 6868 03:42:52,527 --> 03:42:53,620 action with people wrongfully 6869 03:42:53,620 --> 03:42:55,620 shot or imprisoned. 6870 03:42:56,232 --> 03:42:56,566 This technology will not keep 6871 03:42:56,566 --> 03:42:57,200 us safe. 6872 03:42:57,200 --> 03:42:57,700 Please vote no and take 6873 03:42:57,700 --> 03:42:59,700 the cameras down. 6874 03:43:00,803 --> 03:43:01,303 Thank you. 6875 03:43:01,303 --> 03:43:01,670 >> Thank you. 6876 03:43:01,670 --> 03:43:03,670 Thank you. 6877 03:43:05,541 --> 03:43:06,410 That concludes public comment 6878 03:43:06,410 --> 03:43:06,476 for today's item. 6879 03:43:06,476 --> 03:43:06,843 All right. 6880 03:43:06,843 --> 03:43:08,843 Thank you. 6881 03:43:10,513 --> 03:43:11,114 City clerk. 6882 03:43:11,114 --> 03:43:11,780 Thank you everybody that 6883 03:43:11,780 --> 03:43:14,180 participated here in person. 6884 03:43:15,418 --> 03:43:16,152 Thank you to everybody a 6885 03:43:16,152 --> 03:43:16,886 participant remotely and then a 6886 03:43:16,886 --> 03:43:17,520 special thanks for those of you 6887 03:43:17,520 --> 03:43:20,256 who have stuck it out for 6888 03:43:20,256 --> 03:43:20,889 the duration of the afternoon 6889 03:43:20,889 --> 03:43:23,889 and now into the evening. 6890 03:43:24,927 --> 03:43:25,628 So let's first thank our city 6891 03:43:25,628 --> 03:43:26,296 clerk and our city clerk team 6892 03:43:26,296 --> 03:43:28,980 for handling all the public 6893 03:43:28,980 --> 03:43:30,980 comment. 6894 03:43:33,270 --> 03:43:34,137 They always do a fabulous job. 6895 03:43:34,137 --> 03:43:34,804 >> It's not easy to manage that 6896 03:43:34,804 --> 03:43:35,238 many speakers but you did a 6897 03:43:35,238 --> 03:43:37,238 fabulous job. 6898 03:43:38,707 --> 03:43:39,375 I'm going to make one quick 6899 03:43:39,375 --> 03:43:42,375 comment for maybe the public 6900 03:43:42,712 --> 03:43:43,120 but maybe for my colleagues as 6901 03:43:43,120 --> 03:43:43,546 well. 6902 03:43:43,546 --> 03:43:44,790 We're doing the 2025 6903 03:43:44,790 --> 03:43:46,790 surveillance report. 6904 03:43:47,384 --> 03:43:47,751 Those typically would come in 6905 03:43:47,751 --> 03:43:49,751 FEBRUARY. 6906 03:43:51,955 --> 03:43:52,522 They didn't obviously things 6907 03:43:52,522 --> 03:43:53,256 were being worked on. 6908 03:43:53,256 --> 03:43:56,856 I was patiently waiting to when 6909 03:43:56,993 --> 03:43:57,827 I could docket this item. 6910 03:43:57,827 --> 03:43:58,528 It was supposed to be heard by 6911 03:43:58,528 --> 03:44:00,928 Public Safety Committee That's 6912 03:44:02,232 --> 03:44:02,499 traditionally how we've done 6913 03:44:02,499 --> 03:44:03,300 it. 6914 03:44:03,300 --> 03:44:07,169 The Chair They are asked to be 6915 03:44:07,169 --> 03:44:07,671 direct docketed and now we sit 6916 03:44:07,671 --> 03:44:09,671 on the precipice. 6917 03:44:11,274 --> 03:44:11,975 We are about 30 days from when 6918 03:44:11,975 --> 03:44:12,242 the $2 million bill will come 6919 03:44:12,242 --> 03:44:14,242 due. 6920 03:44:16,579 --> 03:44:17,280 So we're in a moment here to 6921 03:44:17,280 --> 03:44:20,880 decide as a council what we 6922 03:44:21,351 --> 03:44:22,118 want to do going forward. 6923 03:44:22,118 --> 03:44:25,589 Go to that right around the. 6924 03:44:25,589 --> 03:44:26,288 That payment comes in 6925 03:44:26,288 --> 03:44:26,923 the second half of DECEMBER So 6926 03:44:26,923 --> 03:44:27,624 we're right at the edge of 6927 03:44:27,624 --> 03:44:30,593 making decisions that could be 6928 03:44:30,593 --> 03:44:31,161 very consequential from what we 6929 03:44:31,161 --> 03:44:31,795 heard from the public. 6930 03:44:31,795 --> 03:44:34,898 This item was not heard of 6931 03:44:34,898 --> 03:44:35,565 public safety committee. 6932 03:44:35,565 --> 03:44:36,299 It was heard at Budget 6933 03:44:36,299 --> 03:44:39,669 committee And so therefore I am 6934 03:44:39,669 --> 03:44:40,303 going to turn this first over 6935 03:44:40,303 --> 03:44:40,670 to the chair of the Budget 6936 03:44:40,670 --> 03:44:42,670 Committee. 6937 03:44:44,240 --> 03:44:44,641 Council member Henry Foster to 6938 03:44:44,641 --> 03:44:46,641 kick us off. 6939 03:44:49,790 --> 03:44:49,747 Sir. 6940 03:44:49,747 --> 03:44:52,147 Thank you, Council PRESIDENT 6941 03:44:53,984 --> 03:44:54,685 And thank you Chief Wall to you 6942 03:44:54,685 --> 03:44:58,355 and your team for the work on 6943 03:44:58,355 --> 03:44:58,688 this item and bringing the item 6944 03:44:58,688 --> 03:44:59,323 forward. 6945 03:44:59,323 --> 03:45:02,323 And of course MADAM Clerk, 6946 03:45:03,293 --> 03:45:04,270 thank you for your organized 6947 03:45:04,270 --> 03:45:07,464 efforts as always in getting us 6948 03:45:07,464 --> 03:45:07,764 through these large tough 6949 03:45:07,764 --> 03:45:08,532 items. 6950 03:45:08,532 --> 03:45:11,532 So with that San Diego's 6951 03:45:12,636 --> 03:45:13,370 experience with Flock continues 6952 03:45:13,370 --> 03:45:16,370 to raise serious concerns about 6953 03:45:17,341 --> 03:45:17,841 data security access, 6954 03:45:17,841 --> 03:45:18,275 accountability and 6955 03:45:18,275 --> 03:45:20,275 transparency. 6956 03:45:22,812 --> 03:45:25,212 Conflict of interest and 6957 03:45:27,183 --> 03:45:27,484 the liability of the technology 6958 03:45:27,484 --> 03:45:28,185 . 6959 03:45:28,185 --> 03:45:28,851 There have been multiple 6960 03:45:28,851 --> 03:45:31,851 breakdowns of trust by esdp 6961 03:45:32,355 --> 03:45:32,823 when it comes to the use of 6962 03:45:32,823 --> 03:45:34,823 this technology. 6963 03:45:36,159 --> 03:45:36,827 In JUNE 2025 we were notified 6964 03:45:36,827 --> 03:45:39,827 by dpd of a system 6965 03:45:40,129 --> 03:45:40,797 configuration error that 6966 03:45:40,797 --> 03:45:41,498 allowed other California law 6967 03:45:41,498 --> 03:45:43,898 enforcement agencies to search 6968 03:45:45,102 --> 03:45:45,469 San Diego's license plate 6969 03:45:45,469 --> 03:45:46,136 database. 6970 03:45:46,136 --> 03:45:48,536 This resulted in over 12,000 6971 03:45:49,772 --> 03:45:50,474 searches conducted and that 6972 03:45:50,474 --> 03:45:52,874 access was not authorized 6973 03:45:53,977 --> 03:45:54,344 authorized under the city's 6974 03:45:54,344 --> 03:45:55,450 policies. 6975 03:45:55,450 --> 03:45:57,445 Second, as dpd separately 6976 03:45:58,915 --> 03:45:59,516 acknowledged sharing 6977 03:45:59,516 --> 03:46:01,516 information with outside 6978 03:46:03,854 --> 03:46:04,354 agencies and only once guidance 6979 03:46:04,354 --> 03:46:05,220 was received from 6980 03:46:05,220 --> 03:46:05,722 the California Department of 6981 03:46:05,722 --> 03:46:08,722 Justice did the department in 6982 03:46:09,627 --> 03:46:12,270 sharing of that data. 6983 03:46:13,497 --> 03:46:14,130 Third, there are real concerns 6984 03:46:14,130 --> 03:46:17,130 about the method in which 6985 03:46:17,867 --> 03:46:18,635 the contract between the city 6986 03:46:18,635 --> 03:46:18,936 and its vendor was put in 6987 03:46:18,936 --> 03:46:19,736 place. 6988 03:46:19,736 --> 03:46:22,736 Former sd pd captain Jeff 6989 03:46:23,206 --> 03:46:23,807 Jordan helped oversee 6990 03:46:23,807 --> 03:46:24,508 the city's surveillance 6991 03:46:24,508 --> 03:46:27,508 technology program and led in 6992 03:46:27,945 --> 03:46:28,545 the San Diego Police Department 6993 03:46:28,545 --> 03:46:29,179 selecting flock and move 6994 03:46:29,179 --> 03:46:31,579 forward with an exclusive 6995 03:46:32,716 --> 03:46:33,384 negotiating contract what is 6996 03:46:33,384 --> 03:46:36,384 termed as a sole source 6997 03:46:37,254 --> 03:46:38,322 contract by the city. 6998 03:46:38,322 --> 03:46:41,922 After retiring from sd pd he 6999 03:46:42,920 --> 03:46:42,459 joined Flock Safety as an 7000 03:46:42,459 --> 03:46:44,459 employee. 7001 03:46:47,970 --> 03:46:47,998 Lastly, there have been at 7002 03:46:47,998 --> 03:46:51,598 least two incidents here in San 7003 03:46:51,668 --> 03:46:52,369 Diego where an erroneous flock 7004 03:46:52,369 --> 03:46:54,369 identification was associated 7005 03:46:55,673 --> 03:46:56,340 with two wrongful arrest and in 7006 03:46:56,340 --> 03:46:57,740 another case an ill advised 7007 03:46:57,740 --> 03:47:00,740 shooting both of which are 7008 03:47:00,511 --> 03:47:01,144 currently in litigation. 7009 03:47:01,144 --> 03:47:03,544 This again raises serious 7010 03:47:04,648 --> 03:47:05,215 concerns about accountability 7011 03:47:05,215 --> 03:47:05,950 and consequences when 7012 03:47:05,950 --> 03:47:08,350 surveillance technology gets it 7013 03:47:09,553 --> 03:47:10,221 wrong. 7014 03:47:10,221 --> 03:47:13,221 And these concerns are not 7015 03:47:14,558 --> 03:47:15,192 limited to San Diego. 7016 03:47:15,192 --> 03:47:15,793 Across the country other 7017 03:47:15,793 --> 03:47:16,460 agencies are confronting 7018 03:47:16,460 --> 03:47:19,460 concerns about flock to data 7019 03:47:19,729 --> 03:47:20,364 sharing practices, security 7020 03:47:20,364 --> 03:47:22,364 safeguards and inaccurate 7021 03:47:24,100 --> 03:47:24,735 license plate readings. 7022 03:47:24,735 --> 03:47:25,336 These are not isolated concerns 7023 03:47:25,336 --> 03:47:27,736 about how one department 7024 03:47:29,390 --> 03:47:30,700 operates a camera system. 7025 03:47:30,700 --> 03:47:33,700 They are real concerns about 7026 03:47:34,780 --> 03:47:34,812 the technology The vendor and 7027 03:47:34,812 --> 03:47:38,412 whether the city can be trusted 7028 03:47:39,283 --> 03:47:39,984 to follow the law to comply and 7029 03:47:39,984 --> 03:47:42,984 enforce the safeguards put in 7030 03:47:43,586 --> 03:47:44,422 place by the Council. 7031 03:47:44,422 --> 03:47:45,890 >> We should not have to choose 7032 03:47:45,890 --> 03:47:47,489 between public safety, civil 7033 03:47:48,626 --> 03:47:48,959 liberties and the right to 7034 03:47:48,959 --> 03:47:50,959 privacy. 7035 03:47:52,697 --> 03:47:53,300 San Diego has deserved them all 7036 03:47:53,300 --> 03:47:53,897 . 7037 03:47:53,897 --> 03:47:57,935 We also need to consider how we 7038 03:47:57,935 --> 03:47:58,802 spend public funds. 7039 03:47:58,802 --> 03:47:59,503 Earlier this year I helped push 7040 03:47:59,503 --> 03:48:01,903 to eliminate funding for 7041 03:48:03,373 --> 03:48:04,410 the Smart street lights and 7042 03:48:04,410 --> 03:48:07,410 flock for this fiscal year. 7043 03:48:07,712 --> 03:48:08,345 In council the contract those 7044 03:48:08,345 --> 03:48:08,980 dollars could be spent to 7045 03:48:08,980 --> 03:48:10,980 support libraries, parks, 7046 03:48:13,500 --> 03:48:13,717 infrastructure and 7047 03:48:13,717 --> 03:48:16,117 the essential city services 7048 03:48:17,454 --> 03:48:18,550 residents rely on and invest in 7049 03:48:18,550 --> 03:48:18,389 real preventative public 7050 03:48:18,389 --> 03:48:20,389 safety. 7051 03:48:21,726 --> 03:48:24,726 For me this is about 7052 03:48:26,564 --> 03:48:27,130 accountability and a 7053 03:48:27,130 --> 03:48:27,698 responsible government 7054 03:48:27,698 --> 03:48:29,698 safeguarding the civil 7055 03:48:31,702 --> 03:48:34,702 liberties of all San Diegans. 7056 03:48:35,640 --> 03:48:36,340 >> When serious failures occur 7057 03:48:36,340 --> 03:48:38,740 ,city leadership has a 7058 03:48:40,411 --> 03:48:42,411 responsibility to respond. 7059 03:48:45,483 --> 03:48:46,117 Before I move on I do have just 7060 03:48:46,117 --> 03:48:46,951 a couple of questions. 7061 03:48:46,951 --> 03:48:49,951 >> One are the Alpine Smart 7062 03:48:50,721 --> 03:48:51,189 lights technology connected to 7063 03:48:51,189 --> 03:48:51,856 the same camera? 7064 03:48:51,856 --> 03:48:53,324 Or are they separate cameras 7065 03:48:53,324 --> 03:48:55,724 that can be removed 7066 03:48:58,896 --> 03:48:59,664 independently? 7067 03:48:59,664 --> 03:48:59,997 The hpr camera is a separate 7068 03:48:59,997 --> 03:49:01,997 camera. 7069 03:49:03,467 --> 03:49:07,670 There are two separate units so 7070 03:49:08,272 --> 03:49:08,973 one can do so One can be 7071 03:49:08,973 --> 03:49:09,339 removed and one would still be 7072 03:49:09,339 --> 03:49:09,807 remaining. 7073 03:49:09,807 --> 03:49:11,807 Absolutely Yes. 7074 03:49:12,276 --> 03:49:12,609 We can remove just the hpr 7075 03:49:12,609 --> 03:49:12,910 camera. 7076 03:49:12,910 --> 03:49:13,644 Okay. 7077 03:49:13,644 --> 03:49:14,345 And if you can help me to 7078 03:49:14,345 --> 03:49:16,981 understand what is the process 7079 03:49:16,981 --> 03:49:19,981 for ending the contract with 7080 03:49:21,986 --> 03:49:22,620 Ubiquiti and flock? 7081 03:49:22,620 --> 03:49:23,187 Thank you Council members. 7082 03:49:23,187 --> 03:49:25,587 I'll handle that one. 7083 03:49:26,424 --> 03:49:30,240 So currently we are would be 7084 03:49:30,795 --> 03:49:31,496 working with p and c and 7085 03:49:31,496 --> 03:49:32,960 the city attorney's office to 7086 03:49:32,960 --> 03:49:34,496 explore what ending our 7087 03:49:36,401 --> 03:49:36,969 contractual obligation would 7088 03:49:36,969 --> 03:49:37,602 look like depending on 7089 03:49:37,602 --> 03:49:38,202 the decision that is made 7090 03:49:38,202 --> 03:49:40,602 tonight by the Council. 7091 03:49:42,206 --> 03:49:42,907 So if the Council decides to 7092 03:49:42,907 --> 03:49:46,311 end both epr and smart street 7093 03:49:46,311 --> 03:49:46,844 lights and the entire contract 7094 03:49:46,844 --> 03:49:47,512 could be scrapped if 7095 03:49:47,512 --> 03:49:50,512 the council decides to keep 7096 03:49:51,315 --> 03:49:52,182 smart street lights and end 7097 03:49:52,182 --> 03:49:55,954 epr, then we could go back to 7098 03:49:55,954 --> 03:49:56,554 the vendor and negotiate what a 7099 03:49:56,554 --> 03:49:57,155 contract one application 7100 03:49:57,155 --> 03:49:59,555 process would look like. 7101 03:50:01,292 --> 03:50:01,759 Linda can you identify yourself 7102 03:50:01,759 --> 03:50:02,930 for the record? 7103 03:50:02,930 --> 03:50:02,760 >> Yes. 7104 03:50:02,760 --> 03:50:03,461 My name is Linda Winkler. 7105 03:50:03,461 --> 03:50:04,729 I am a community liaison 7106 03:50:04,729 --> 03:50:05,290 manager with the chief's office 7107 03:50:05,290 --> 03:50:05,529 . 7108 03:50:05,529 --> 03:50:07,529 >> All righty. 7109 03:50:08,660 --> 03:50:10,466 Thank you for that 7110 03:50:13,238 --> 03:50:15,238 clarification. 7111 03:50:19,770 --> 03:50:19,744 It does appear that in other 7112 03:50:19,744 --> 03:50:20,345 cities the when the contract 7113 03:50:20,345 --> 03:50:22,745 with Floc was terminated 7114 03:50:22,747 --> 03:50:25,147 discontinue the use of 7115 03:50:27,651 --> 03:50:30,651 the Alper software did present 7116 03:50:32,290 --> 03:50:33,240 additional problems as we found 7117 03:50:33,240 --> 03:50:36,240 out that the software and 7118 03:50:37,495 --> 03:50:37,929 equipment remained in use here 7119 03:50:37,929 --> 03:50:38,663 in San Diego. 7120 03:50:38,663 --> 03:50:40,663 Accountability and transparency 7121 03:50:42,500 --> 03:50:42,901 concerns with this technology 7122 03:50:42,901 --> 03:50:43,635 is not new. 7123 03:50:43,635 --> 03:50:46,350 We experienced misuse with 7124 03:50:47,705 --> 03:50:48,306 the gsa smart street lights 7125 03:50:48,306 --> 03:50:49,700 originally purchased for 7126 03:50:49,700 --> 03:50:51,910 parking only to find the main 7127 03:50:51,910 --> 03:50:52,644 use was by sd pd. 7128 03:50:52,644 --> 03:50:55,644 And when canceled the equipment 7129 03:50:56,748 --> 03:50:57,349 was left in place and 7130 03:50:57,349 --> 03:50:57,916 operational which I find 7131 03:50:57,916 --> 03:50:59,916 totally unacceptable. 7132 03:51:02,186 --> 03:51:02,887 >> With this documented history 7133 03:51:02,887 --> 03:51:05,887 we cannot guarantee that even 7134 03:51:05,924 --> 03:51:06,690 with the Alper system being 7135 03:51:06,690 --> 03:51:09,690 turned off that the technology 7136 03:51:11,329 --> 03:51:11,696 will not be even in error 7137 03:51:11,696 --> 03:51:12,497 restarted. 7138 03:51:12,497 --> 03:51:16,101 The only way to ensure we are 7139 03:51:16,101 --> 03:51:16,635 not using this technology is to 7140 03:51:16,635 --> 03:51:18,635 remove the cameras. 7141 03:51:20,572 --> 03:51:21,106 When my staff reached out to 7142 03:51:21,106 --> 03:51:21,806 ask about requiring 7143 03:51:21,806 --> 03:51:24,806 the immediate removal of flock 7144 03:51:25,176 --> 03:51:25,877 cameras in a council motion, I 7145 03:51:25,877 --> 03:51:29,281 was told that council does not 7146 03:51:29,281 --> 03:51:29,748 have the authority to direct 7147 03:51:29,748 --> 03:51:30,414 city operations. 7148 03:51:30,414 --> 03:51:33,414 MADAM City Attorney, can you 7149 03:51:34,886 --> 03:51:35,453 please speak to this? 7150 03:51:35,453 --> 03:51:36,540 Does the Council have 7151 03:51:36,540 --> 03:51:36,721 the authority to require 7152 03:51:36,721 --> 03:51:39,690 the removal of the cameras? 7153 03:51:39,690 --> 03:51:40,592 If not, why? 7154 03:51:40,592 --> 03:51:40,959 >> And who has that authority? 7155 03:51:40,959 --> 03:51:42,959 Thank you. 7156 03:51:44,796 --> 03:51:45,363 Council member The action 7157 03:51:45,363 --> 03:51:46,164 before you today is to 7158 03:51:46,164 --> 03:51:49,164 determine whether or not to 7159 03:51:50,350 --> 03:51:50,735 approve or modify or rescind 7160 03:51:50,735 --> 03:51:54,335 the use policy under the trust 7161 03:51:54,706 --> 03:51:55,340 ordinance If the Council takes 7162 03:51:55,340 --> 03:51:55,673 action to rescind the use 7163 03:51:55,673 --> 03:51:57,673 policy. 7164 03:51:59,100 --> 03:51:59,711 Use of the technology must stop 7165 03:51:59,711 --> 03:52:03,311 the question of how and when 7166 03:52:03,749 --> 03:52:04,149 and what procedures to remove 7167 03:52:04,149 --> 03:52:04,816 the camera. 7168 03:52:04,816 --> 03:52:07,816 Well the cameras will likely 7169 03:52:09,253 --> 03:52:09,888 require some coordination with 7170 03:52:09,888 --> 03:52:10,288 the vendor in purchasing a 7171 03:52:10,288 --> 03:52:11,220 contracting. 7172 03:52:11,220 --> 03:52:11,589 However, the trust ordinance is 7173 03:52:11,589 --> 03:52:14,589 clear that the use of 7174 03:52:16,928 --> 03:52:17,662 the technology must stop. 7175 03:52:17,662 --> 03:52:20,620 >> But the decisions and 7176 03:52:21,566 --> 03:52:22,367 the authority to direct staff 7177 03:52:22,367 --> 03:52:23,134 to remove said cameras if that 7178 03:52:23,134 --> 03:52:26,734 is the action that's taken here 7179 03:52:27,500 --> 03:52:27,571 today, Council does not have 7180 03:52:27,571 --> 03:52:28,172 that direct authority. 7181 03:52:28,172 --> 03:52:28,706 That is the authority of 7182 03:52:28,706 --> 03:52:29,410 the mayor's office. 7183 03:52:29,410 --> 03:52:31,410 Correct? 7184 03:52:31,343 --> 03:52:31,944 Okay. 7185 03:52:31,944 --> 03:52:32,610 Chime in here. 7186 03:52:32,610 --> 03:52:33,312 Criticize our mayor's office 7187 03:52:33,312 --> 03:52:35,547 depending on the actions today 7188 03:52:35,547 --> 03:52:36,281 if the council does move 7189 03:52:36,281 --> 03:52:36,715 forward with rescinding the use 7190 03:52:36,715 --> 03:52:37,415 policy, it is 7191 03:52:37,415 --> 03:52:39,415 the administration's position 7192 03:52:41,520 --> 03:52:41,886 to follow the Council's 7193 03:52:41,886 --> 03:52:42,621 direction. 7194 03:52:42,621 --> 03:52:45,357 So our direction testi pd would 7195 03:52:45,357 --> 03:52:46,580 be to engage with Ubiquiti and 7196 03:52:46,580 --> 03:52:46,458 flock to initiate removal of 7197 03:52:46,458 --> 03:52:47,159 the cameras. 7198 03:52:47,159 --> 03:52:50,159 I believe it's baked into 7199 03:52:50,462 --> 03:52:51,196 the contract that the vendor 7200 03:52:51,196 --> 03:52:54,796 will remove those cameras at no 7201 03:52:55,000 --> 03:52:55,801 cost to us And so depending on 7202 03:52:55,801 --> 03:52:56,435 how the action goes today we 7203 03:52:56,435 --> 03:52:58,835 would essentially shut off 7204 03:53:00,639 --> 03:53:01,340 the system on our end work with 7205 03:53:01,340 --> 03:53:02,400 the vendor and then by the end 7206 03:53:02,400 --> 03:53:04,776 of this week provide the City 7207 03:53:04,776 --> 03:53:05,444 council with a work plan of how 7208 03:53:05,444 --> 03:53:07,844 we begin dismantling the 500 7209 03:53:10,182 --> 03:53:11,490 cameras citywide. 7210 03:53:11,490 --> 03:53:11,617 If I could just add to that 7211 03:53:11,617 --> 03:53:12,151 this is one thing with 7212 03:53:12,151 --> 03:53:14,151 the chief's office. 7213 03:53:14,953 --> 03:53:15,754 So if the council does decide 7214 03:53:15,754 --> 03:53:18,590 tonight that they want to vote 7215 03:53:18,590 --> 03:53:19,258 down acr within 24 hours of 7216 03:53:19,258 --> 03:53:19,958 council's vote, our vendors 7217 03:53:19,958 --> 03:53:22,958 will have already pledged that 7218 03:53:23,695 --> 03:53:24,396 they are ready to deactivate 7219 03:53:24,396 --> 03:53:25,630 the opa system and delete any 7220 03:53:25,630 --> 03:53:28,630 data that's held within it. 7221 03:53:28,600 --> 03:53:29,334 And then once that occurred we 7222 03:53:29,334 --> 03:53:30,200 have asked them to send us a 7223 03:53:30,200 --> 03:53:30,669 formal notification of fact 7224 03:53:30,669 --> 03:53:31,335 which we are happy to share 7225 03:53:31,335 --> 03:53:34,335 with the Council Should have 7226 03:53:35,640 --> 03:53:36,410 your decision tonight. 7227 03:53:36,410 --> 03:53:36,808 Okay. 7228 03:53:36,808 --> 03:53:37,175 Thank you for for that and 7229 03:53:37,175 --> 03:53:39,175 providing. 7230 03:53:40,980 --> 03:53:41,680 MADAM City Attorney that 7231 03:53:41,680 --> 03:53:44,680 clarification and also call to 7232 03:53:45,450 --> 03:53:46,185 I mean Lindsey thank you. 7233 03:53:46,185 --> 03:53:47,753 So with that council PRESIDENT 7234 03:53:47,753 --> 03:53:51,353 If you would be open to 7235 03:53:52,958 --> 03:53:54,958 entertain. 7236 03:53:57,930 --> 03:53:58,631 >> I'm sorry if you would be 7237 03:53:58,631 --> 03:54:02,231 open to entertain I would like 7238 03:54:02,501 --> 03:54:06,101 to bring forward for motions in 7239 03:54:06,939 --> 03:54:07,540 the order as summarized below 7240 03:54:07,540 --> 03:54:09,540 or as follows. 7241 03:54:11,176 --> 03:54:14,776 One First I would provide a 7242 03:54:15,714 --> 03:54:16,215 motion to address sub item b 7243 03:54:16,215 --> 03:54:18,215 use policy. 7244 03:54:20,152 --> 03:54:21,200 Second a motion to bifurcate 7245 03:54:21,200 --> 03:54:24,620 sub item a to separate smart 7246 03:54:24,990 --> 03:54:25,391 streetlights and note as sub 7247 03:54:25,391 --> 03:54:27,391 item c. 7248 03:54:28,594 --> 03:54:29,295 Third a motion to address 7249 03:54:29,295 --> 03:54:33,495 the balance of the city to use 7250 03:54:33,632 --> 03:54:34,400 policies presented as sub item 7251 03:54:34,400 --> 03:54:37,400 a and fourth and lastly 7252 03:54:38,570 --> 03:54:39,438 providing motion to address sub 7253 03:54:39,438 --> 03:54:43,380 item c Smart street light use 7254 03:54:43,709 --> 03:54:44,410 policy. 7255 03:54:44,410 --> 03:54:45,144 Yes we'll entertain your first 7256 03:54:45,144 --> 03:54:48,800 motion will then take a vote at 7257 03:54:48,800 --> 03:54:48,748 some point and then we'll come 7258 03:54:48,748 --> 03:54:49,415 back to you for the second, 7259 03:54:49,415 --> 03:54:49,715 third and fourth motions as 7260 03:54:49,715 --> 03:54:50,182 well. 7261 03:54:50,182 --> 03:54:52,182 Please proceed. 7262 03:54:52,685 --> 03:54:53,452 Thank you for that. 7263 03:54:53,452 --> 03:54:56,452 With the first action somebody 7264 03:54:57,256 --> 03:55:00,856 would be persue into San Diego 7265 03:55:01,127 --> 03:55:01,493 Municipal Code sections 7266 03:55:01,493 --> 03:55:02,194 210.0106. 7267 03:55:02,194 --> 03:55:05,794 I would like to motion to 7268 03:55:06,265 --> 03:55:06,966 rescind the automated license 7269 03:55:06,966 --> 03:55:09,366 plate recognition use policy. 7270 03:55:11,270 --> 03:55:11,970 As part of this motion 7271 03:55:11,970 --> 03:55:12,605 the Council requests that its 7272 03:55:12,605 --> 03:55:15,605 decision to rescind a lpr 7273 03:55:15,875 --> 03:55:16,442 surveillance use policy be 7274 03:55:16,442 --> 03:55:17,760 analyzed by the city's 7275 03:55:17,760 --> 03:55:19,476 management team for Labor 7276 03:55:20,846 --> 03:55:21,480 relations to determine whether 7277 03:55:21,480 --> 03:55:22,214 the rescission requires a 7278 03:55:22,214 --> 03:55:25,214 notice to the city's recognized 7279 03:55:25,918 --> 03:55:26,519 employee organizations and 7280 03:55:26,519 --> 03:55:27,219 opportunity to negotiate 7281 03:55:27,219 --> 03:55:30,219 the bargaining bill Impacts of 7282 03:55:30,522 --> 03:55:33,522 the rescission under the Myers 7283 03:55:35,727 --> 03:55:36,495 melius Brown Act. 7284 03:55:36,495 --> 03:55:37,960 If notice Brown Act if notice 7285 03:55:37,960 --> 03:55:39,496 is required, the Council 7286 03:55:40,299 --> 03:55:40,900 further request that cities 7287 03:55:40,900 --> 03:55:41,601 management team provide 7288 03:55:41,601 --> 03:55:42,302 the required notice in return 7289 03:55:42,302 --> 03:55:45,437 to the Council at a later date 7290 03:55:45,437 --> 03:55:46,380 If there are any bargaining 7291 03:55:46,380 --> 03:55:49,380 impacts that need to be 7292 03:55:49,875 --> 03:55:50,742 addressed by Council. 7293 03:55:50,742 --> 03:55:53,742 That concludes my first motion 7294 03:55:54,813 --> 03:55:58,413 which it looks like we have 7295 03:55:59,510 --> 03:55:59,352 brought it up on the screen. 7296 03:55:59,352 --> 03:56:00,190 Okay. 7297 03:56:00,190 --> 03:56:03,190 We have a motion by 7298 03:56:03,622 --> 03:56:04,222 Councilmember Foster to rescind 7299 03:56:04,222 --> 03:56:04,957 the use policy for 7300 03:56:04,957 --> 03:56:07,357 the automatic automated license 7301 03:56:08,427 --> 03:56:09,161 plate reader recognition use 7302 03:56:09,161 --> 03:56:12,161 policy That was not very 7303 03:56:13,232 --> 03:56:14,200 eloquent. 7304 03:56:14,200 --> 03:56:18,370 So with that we will then go to 7305 03:56:18,370 --> 03:56:18,570 Councilmember Ella Rivera. 7306 03:56:18,570 --> 03:56:19,238 All right. 7307 03:56:19,238 --> 03:56:21,638 Thank you, Council PRESIDENT 7308 03:56:23,175 --> 03:56:23,843 And thank you to everyone who 7309 03:56:23,843 --> 03:56:24,543 presented police department. 7310 03:56:24,543 --> 03:56:26,943 Mayor's office City Attorney's 7311 03:56:28,213 --> 03:56:28,881 office who worked on this and 7312 03:56:28,881 --> 03:56:29,582 obviously all the members of 7313 03:56:29,582 --> 03:56:32,351 the public who've been working 7314 03:56:32,351 --> 03:56:33,219 on this for so long. 7315 03:56:33,219 --> 03:56:33,886 I want to start actually with a 7316 03:56:33,886 --> 03:56:36,286 question for everyone who's 7317 03:56:36,288 --> 03:56:37,156 here and that's just to ask 7318 03:56:37,156 --> 03:56:40,756 everyone who here wants to be 7319 03:56:41,194 --> 03:56:42,610 safe. 7320 03:56:42,610 --> 03:56:42,662 >> And I start with that 7321 03:56:42,662 --> 03:56:43,363 question because I think 7322 03:56:43,363 --> 03:56:46,363 there's been an unfair and 7323 03:56:47,333 --> 03:56:48,340 manipulative narrative that's 7324 03:56:48,340 --> 03:56:48,734 been applied to the many, many 7325 03:56:48,734 --> 03:56:49,468 people who've opposed floc and 7326 03:56:49,468 --> 03:56:51,838 automated license plate readers 7327 03:56:51,838 --> 03:56:52,505 over the years And quite 7328 03:56:52,505 --> 03:56:56,105 frankly to the people who in 7329 03:56:56,409 --> 03:56:56,709 this room who showed up and did 7330 03:56:56,709 --> 03:56:57,410 that. 7331 03:56:57,410 --> 03:56:58,210 They all want to feel safe. 7332 03:56:58,210 --> 03:57:01,470 We all want to feel safe. 7333 03:57:01,470 --> 03:57:01,714 This was never a fight over 7334 03:57:01,714 --> 03:57:02,150 whether San Diego should be 7335 03:57:02,150 --> 03:57:04,150 safe. 7336 03:57:05,885 --> 03:57:06,451 It was a fight over how safety 7337 03:57:06,451 --> 03:57:08,851 is a universal right. 7338 03:57:10,957 --> 03:57:11,758 It's a deeply personal feeling 7339 03:57:11,758 --> 03:57:15,358 and it depends on one thing 7340 03:57:15,628 --> 03:57:15,929 above all else and that's 7341 03:57:15,929 --> 03:57:16,796 trust. 7342 03:57:16,796 --> 03:57:19,796 And trust requires honesty and 7343 03:57:20,866 --> 03:57:21,533 transparency. 7344 03:57:21,533 --> 03:57:22,202 And when those things are 7345 03:57:22,202 --> 03:57:22,502 missing, people stop feeling 7346 03:57:22,502 --> 03:57:24,502 safe. 7347 03:57:25,639 --> 03:57:26,338 No matter how many cameras are 7348 03:57:26,338 --> 03:57:29,938 on how many polls or what 7349 03:57:30,477 --> 03:57:31,244 technology is being used. 7350 03:57:31,244 --> 03:57:34,580 Big tech has long bragged about 7351 03:57:34,580 --> 03:57:34,914 moving fast and breaking 7352 03:57:34,914 --> 03:57:35,648 things. 7353 03:57:35,648 --> 03:57:36,316 And I understand the appeal of 7354 03:57:36,316 --> 03:57:39,316 that for a scrappy startup. 7355 03:57:39,452 --> 03:57:40,190 But with great power comes 7356 03:57:40,190 --> 03:57:40,720 great responsibility. 7357 03:57:40,720 --> 03:57:43,720 And big tech has amassed 7358 03:57:44,324 --> 03:57:44,891 extraordinary power while 7359 03:57:44,891 --> 03:57:45,392 dismissing all of its 7360 03:57:45,392 --> 03:57:47,392 responsibilities. 7361 03:57:49,229 --> 03:57:49,629 Government can't and must not 7362 03:57:49,629 --> 03:57:50,397 do the same. 7363 03:57:50,397 --> 03:57:53,397 Because what ends up being 7364 03:57:53,600 --> 03:57:54,300 broken is public trust. 7365 03:57:54,300 --> 03:57:54,967 And public trust is essential 7366 03:57:54,967 --> 03:57:57,967 to our most important job. 7367 03:57:58,638 --> 03:57:59,506 Keeping people safe. 7368 03:57:59,506 --> 03:58:03,106 We are where we are because 7369 03:58:03,543 --> 03:58:04,176 the city refused to take 7370 03:58:04,176 --> 03:58:04,878 the advice of the Privacy 7371 03:58:04,878 --> 03:58:07,878 Advisory Board that we created 7372 03:58:08,515 --> 03:58:09,315 that we appointed experts to 7373 03:58:09,315 --> 03:58:09,686 and we bragged about as a gold 7374 03:58:09,686 --> 03:58:11,686 standard. 7375 03:58:13,860 --> 03:58:16,860 Rather than listen we moved 7376 03:58:17,923 --> 03:58:19,580 fast and we broke things. 7377 03:58:19,580 --> 03:58:22,929 To that point I have a few 7378 03:58:22,929 --> 03:58:23,596 questions. 7379 03:58:23,596 --> 03:58:26,596 Last year when we debated 7380 03:58:28,340 --> 03:58:28,635 the topic of maintaining 7381 03:58:28,635 --> 03:58:29,268 automated license plate 7382 03:58:29,268 --> 03:58:32,268 readers, it turns out that 7383 03:58:33,105 --> 03:58:33,807 the department had already run 7384 03:58:33,807 --> 03:58:34,441 a domestic violence survivor 7385 03:58:34,441 --> 03:58:35,750 survivor's license plate. 7386 03:58:35,750 --> 03:58:38,750 Was that use disclosed to 7387 03:58:38,770 --> 03:58:38,745 the council or the Privacy 7388 03:58:38,745 --> 03:58:39,279 Advisory Board in the annual 7389 03:58:39,279 --> 03:58:41,279 surveillance report? 7390 03:58:42,883 --> 03:58:43,250 No. 7391 03:58:43,250 --> 03:58:45,250 Why not? 7392 03:58:47,420 --> 03:58:48,530 In that case council member we 7393 03:58:48,530 --> 03:58:48,688 ran her license plate not 7394 03:58:48,688 --> 03:58:49,189 because she was a domestic 7395 03:58:49,189 --> 03:58:51,189 violence survivor. 7396 03:58:51,992 --> 03:58:52,691 We ran her license plate to 7397 03:58:52,691 --> 03:58:55,910 help corroborate the serious 7398 03:58:57,300 --> 03:59:00,300 allegation of misconduct by her 7399 03:59:01,768 --> 03:59:02,435 employee putting her and our 7400 03:59:02,435 --> 03:59:05,435 officer in the same location 7401 03:59:06,607 --> 03:59:07,240 would help corroborate 7402 03:59:07,240 --> 03:59:07,641 the allegation of serious 7403 03:59:07,641 --> 03:59:08,308 misconduct. 7404 03:59:08,308 --> 03:59:11,878 And that was the purpose for 7405 03:59:11,878 --> 03:59:12,712 running her plate. 7406 03:59:12,712 --> 03:59:15,712 Was that woman given an 7407 03:59:16,483 --> 03:59:16,816 opportunity to consent to that 7408 03:59:16,816 --> 03:59:18,816 search? 7409 03:59:20,954 --> 03:59:21,654 No. 7410 03:59:21,654 --> 03:59:22,389 When she called the San Diego 7411 03:59:22,389 --> 03:59:25,389 Police Department for help from 7412 03:59:26,460 --> 03:59:30,600 a for domestic violence, do we 7413 03:59:31,264 --> 03:59:31,865 think she at any point in time 7414 03:59:31,865 --> 03:59:32,531 thought that her police 7415 03:59:32,531 --> 03:59:34,931 department would be tracking 7416 03:59:35,302 --> 03:59:36,169 her car? 7417 03:59:36,169 --> 03:59:39,769 I doubt that went through her 7418 03:59:40,140 --> 03:59:40,874 mind when she called. 7419 03:59:40,874 --> 03:59:41,241 Has she been told that that 7420 03:59:41,241 --> 03:59:42,342 happened? 7421 03:59:42,342 --> 03:59:44,742 I have no idea. 7422 03:59:47,514 --> 03:59:49,514 Okay. 7423 03:59:51,751 --> 03:59:52,553 The department has said that 7424 03:59:52,553 --> 03:59:53,153 all of this was allowed because 7425 03:59:53,153 --> 03:59:55,553 the policy permits quote 7426 03:59:56,991 --> 03:59:57,958 legitimate purposes. 7427 03:59:57,958 --> 04:00:00,958 I'm curious under that reading 7428 04:00:02,396 --> 04:00:02,863 what use of this system would 7429 04:00:02,863 --> 04:00:04,863 not be allowed. 7430 04:00:06,200 --> 04:00:06,900 >> We have in our department 7431 04:00:06,900 --> 04:00:09,900 procedure a list of expressly 7432 04:00:10,771 --> 04:00:11,438 prohibited uses. 7433 04:00:11,438 --> 04:00:12,138 Personal use would be an 7434 04:00:12,138 --> 04:00:14,138 example indiscriminate viewing 7435 04:00:16,110 --> 04:00:16,810 of images and video would be 7436 04:00:16,810 --> 04:00:19,210 another example without having 7437 04:00:19,279 --> 04:00:21,279 investigative or administrative 7438 04:00:24,918 --> 04:00:25,519 need for discrimination 7439 04:00:25,519 --> 04:00:25,919 discriminatory practices 7440 04:00:25,919 --> 04:00:27,919 Harassment. 7441 04:00:29,489 --> 04:00:30,560 Those are some of the things 7442 04:00:30,560 --> 04:00:30,624 that are listed in our 7443 04:00:30,624 --> 04:00:32,624 department procedure. 7444 04:00:34,495 --> 04:00:35,228 So is the expectation that if 7445 04:00:35,228 --> 04:00:35,963 it's not explicitly listed as a 7446 04:00:35,963 --> 04:00:38,531 prohibited use that it's fair 7447 04:00:38,531 --> 04:00:39,399 game? 7448 04:00:39,399 --> 04:00:42,999 >> I don't know that I would 7449 04:00:43,270 --> 04:00:43,937 worded exactly that way but it 7450 04:00:43,937 --> 04:00:47,537 is very difficult to what if 7451 04:00:48,375 --> 04:00:49,109 scenarios because there are 7452 04:00:49,109 --> 04:00:49,810 there are endless the expressly 7453 04:00:49,810 --> 04:00:52,810 prohibited helps make it very 7454 04:00:53,113 --> 04:00:54,915 crystal clear where we can and 7455 04:00:54,915 --> 04:00:55,215 where we cannot use the system 7456 04:00:55,215 --> 04:00:57,215 . 7457 04:01:00,120 --> 04:01:01,155 >> Thank you. 7458 04:01:01,155 --> 04:01:04,755 So we've talked before about a 7459 04:01:05,526 --> 04:01:06,293 man who was jailed, a young man 7460 04:01:06,293 --> 04:01:07,610 who was jailed for weeks for a 7461 04:01:07,610 --> 04:01:10,610 crime a crime that was 7462 04:01:10,297 --> 04:01:10,764 committed five miles from where 7463 04:01:10,764 --> 04:01:11,465 he actually was. 7464 04:01:11,465 --> 04:01:14,465 We've talked with the 19 year 7465 04:01:15,235 --> 04:01:15,903 old who was shot riding to work 7466 04:01:15,903 --> 04:01:19,503 as a passenger after the fbi 7467 04:01:19,539 --> 04:01:20,274 database flagged his car. 7468 04:01:20,274 --> 04:01:23,874 His boss his car is stolen. 7469 04:01:24,244 --> 04:01:24,912 According to the legal team and 7470 04:01:24,912 --> 04:01:25,546 reporting on this, the owner 7471 04:01:25,546 --> 04:01:25,879 says that the car was not 7472 04:01:25,879 --> 04:01:27,879 stolen. 7473 04:01:29,316 --> 04:01:29,950 My understanding again is that 7474 04:01:29,950 --> 04:01:33,550 the alert came from an fbi 7475 04:01:33,887 --> 04:01:34,421 database and it pulls 7476 04:01:34,421 --> 04:01:36,421 automatically pulls 7477 04:01:38,425 --> 04:01:39,192 automatically from that. 7478 04:01:39,192 --> 04:01:42,792 What does sd pd require in 7479 04:01:43,664 --> 04:01:44,298 terms of confirmation with 7480 04:01:44,298 --> 04:01:44,699 the agency that enter that 7481 04:01:44,699 --> 04:01:45,320 information? 7482 04:01:45,320 --> 04:01:47,320 >> Sure. 7483 04:01:47,868 --> 04:01:48,569 First councilmember or license 7484 04:01:48,569 --> 04:01:49,370 plate readers put a vehicle in 7485 04:01:49,370 --> 04:01:51,739 that intersection at a date and 7486 04:01:51,739 --> 04:01:52,406 time. 7487 04:01:52,406 --> 04:01:53,173 It does not give officers 7488 04:01:53,173 --> 04:01:56,173 probable cause to make an 7489 04:01:56,477 --> 04:01:57,144 arrest. 7490 04:01:57,144 --> 04:01:57,711 Officers are still have 7491 04:01:57,711 --> 04:01:58,312 the responsibility for 7492 04:01:58,312 --> 04:02:00,312 procedure to investigate 7493 04:02:01,682 --> 04:02:02,383 the situation verify 7494 04:02:02,383 --> 04:02:05,383 the information through are in 7495 04:02:06,860 --> 04:02:06,654 cic which is the national crime 7496 04:02:06,654 --> 04:02:08,654 Information Center and 7497 04:02:10,524 --> 04:02:11,225 establish a basis for any legal 7498 04:02:11,225 --> 04:02:11,759 or legal basis for any 7499 04:02:11,759 --> 04:02:13,759 enforcement action. 7500 04:02:15,396 --> 04:02:16,960 >> Yeah I guess I'm asking what 7501 04:02:16,960 --> 04:02:19,960 we are doing to vet 7502 04:02:20,668 --> 04:02:21,350 the information that comes from 7503 04:02:21,350 --> 04:02:21,735 the feds. 7504 04:02:21,735 --> 04:02:24,772 It's a conversation you and I 7505 04:02:24,772 --> 04:02:25,720 have had on multiple occasions 7506 04:02:25,720 --> 04:02:25,473 . 7507 04:02:25,473 --> 04:02:26,240 How do. 7508 04:02:26,240 --> 04:02:29,644 What process do we use to 7509 04:02:29,644 --> 04:02:30,344 verify that What the feds are 7510 04:02:30,344 --> 04:02:30,745 telling the police department 7511 04:02:30,745 --> 04:02:32,745 is accurate? 7512 04:02:34,982 --> 04:02:35,716 So what I can tell you in that 7513 04:02:35,716 --> 04:02:39,316 case is that vehicle was listed 7514 04:02:39,787 --> 04:02:40,121 in the stolen vehicle system as 7515 04:02:40,121 --> 04:02:40,787 stolen. 7516 04:02:40,787 --> 04:02:41,522 That case obviously is under 7517 04:02:41,522 --> 04:02:44,425 litigation and there's a lot of 7518 04:02:44,425 --> 04:02:44,725 details that they cannot go 7519 04:02:44,725 --> 04:02:45,326 into. 7520 04:02:45,326 --> 04:02:48,326 But that vehicle was in 7521 04:02:48,796 --> 04:02:49,397 the system as stolen. 7522 04:02:49,397 --> 04:02:49,797 A lpr helped locate 7523 04:02:49,797 --> 04:02:51,797 the vehicle. 7524 04:02:53,267 --> 04:02:53,968 But still an officer's 7525 04:02:53,968 --> 04:02:54,535 responsibility to investigate 7526 04:02:54,535 --> 04:02:56,535 the situation, verify 7527 04:02:58,372 --> 04:02:59,730 the information through ncic 7528 04:02:59,730 --> 04:02:59,773 and establish any legal basis 7529 04:02:59,773 --> 04:03:02,173 needed for enforcement Action 7530 04:03:02,510 --> 04:03:03,377 must come first. 7531 04:03:03,377 --> 04:03:06,977 Is there a standard process for 7532 04:03:07,414 --> 04:03:08,316 verifying information that 7533 04:03:08,316 --> 04:03:11,986 the feds put forward to sd pd 7534 04:03:11,986 --> 04:03:12,586 before stb? 7535 04:03:12,586 --> 04:03:13,253 Pd takes action on 7536 04:03:13,253 --> 04:03:13,621 the information that's been 7537 04:03:13,621 --> 04:03:15,621 provided? 7538 04:03:17,925 --> 04:03:18,244 Well, it's run it's run through 7539 04:03:18,244 --> 04:03:20,244 r. 7540 04:03:21,530 --> 04:03:22,263 So in other words, if as if 7541 04:03:22,263 --> 04:03:22,930 the feds say this license plate 7542 04:03:22,930 --> 04:03:25,930 is associated with a stolen 7543 04:03:26,968 --> 04:03:27,668 car, we we verify that it's 7544 04:03:27,668 --> 04:03:30,668 that license plate number but 7545 04:03:31,906 --> 04:03:32,607 we don't verify that there was 7546 04:03:32,607 --> 04:03:33,740 any basis for saying that that 7547 04:03:33,740 --> 04:03:33,408 car was stolen. 7548 04:03:33,408 --> 04:03:35,408 Correct. 7549 04:03:35,710 --> 04:03:36,577 They're going off of what comes 7550 04:03:36,577 --> 04:03:37,278 out of a stolen vehicle system. 7551 04:03:37,278 --> 04:03:37,912 Do you think that this federal 7552 04:03:37,912 --> 04:03:40,312 government can be trusted 7553 04:03:40,481 --> 04:03:41,349 widely like that? 7554 04:03:41,349 --> 04:03:44,949 It's a very it's a verification 7555 04:03:45,786 --> 04:03:46,421 through our through the court 7556 04:03:46,421 --> 04:03:47,121 system, the California law 7557 04:03:47,121 --> 04:03:47,454 enforcement telecommunication 7558 04:03:47,454 --> 04:03:49,454 system. 7559 04:03:50,325 --> 04:03:51,250 It doesn't come back saying it 7560 04:03:51,250 --> 04:03:51,359 came from this agency or that 7561 04:03:51,359 --> 04:03:53,359 agency. 7562 04:03:54,929 --> 04:03:55,496 It comes back as registered 7563 04:03:55,496 --> 04:03:57,896 stolen in the system. 7564 04:03:59,467 --> 04:04:00,435 Thank you. 7565 04:04:00,435 --> 04:04:01,690 >> So I think all of these 7566 04:04:01,690 --> 04:04:03,469 cases share something that 7567 04:04:04,972 --> 04:04:05,673 should make everyone concerned 7568 04:04:05,673 --> 04:04:06,441 and that's that our justice 7569 04:04:06,441 --> 04:04:09,777 system rests on a very basic 7570 04:04:09,777 --> 04:04:10,444 premise and that's we're all 7571 04:04:10,444 --> 04:04:12,844 innocent until proven guilty 7572 04:04:14,515 --> 04:04:18,115 And Alpers seem to turn that 7573 04:04:19,220 --> 04:04:19,853 whole thing upside down. 7574 04:04:19,853 --> 04:04:20,555 The camera produces a hit. 7575 04:04:20,555 --> 04:04:23,555 There's an air of certainty 7576 04:04:24,626 --> 04:04:25,493 about the accuracy of that hit 7577 04:04:25,493 --> 04:04:28,263 and it seems like that lead 7578 04:04:28,263 --> 04:04:31,863 stops being a lead and actually 7579 04:04:33,670 --> 04:04:33,768 acts more like a verdict. 7580 04:04:33,768 --> 04:04:34,369 It doesn't seem like officers 7581 04:04:34,369 --> 04:04:34,936 are asking the questions 7582 04:04:34,936 --> 04:04:37,336 because they feel like 7583 04:04:37,872 --> 04:04:38,306 the machine has already answer 7584 04:04:38,306 --> 04:04:40,306 them. 7585 04:04:42,610 --> 04:04:43,277 And in Old Town, according to 7586 04:04:43,277 --> 04:04:43,945 the lawsuit that was filed, 7587 04:04:43,945 --> 04:04:46,345 evidence could have cleared 7588 04:04:47,882 --> 04:04:48,249 those men but that went 7589 04:04:48,249 --> 04:04:49,150 unchecked. 7590 04:04:49,150 --> 04:04:53,188 Or one of them sat in jail over 7591 04:04:53,188 --> 04:04:53,888 the holidays and then in a 7592 04:04:53,888 --> 04:04:56,888 separate instance a young man 7593 04:04:57,858 --> 04:04:58,426 with his hands raised was shot 7594 04:04:58,426 --> 04:04:58,793 and never charged with 7595 04:04:58,793 --> 04:05:00,793 anything. 7596 04:05:03,732 --> 04:05:04,432 I think that's the thing that I 7597 04:05:04,432 --> 04:05:05,133 find most dangerous about this 7598 04:05:05,133 --> 04:05:08,133 and it's the false confidence 7599 04:05:08,169 --> 04:05:08,870 that the technology produces 7600 04:05:08,870 --> 04:05:12,470 and a tool that treats people 7601 04:05:13,108 --> 04:05:13,408 as guilty until proven innocent 7602 04:05:13,408 --> 04:05:14,420 . 7603 04:05:14,420 --> 04:05:14,776 Doesn't make anyone safer. 7604 04:05:14,776 --> 04:05:18,376 Each of the instances that I've 7605 04:05:18,546 --> 04:05:21,546 referenced here and this entire 7606 04:05:24,119 --> 04:05:24,986 debate broke something. 7607 04:05:24,986 --> 04:05:25,453 We moved too fast and we broke 7608 04:05:25,453 --> 04:05:27,453 something Trust. 7609 04:05:28,990 --> 04:05:29,391 And we can start restoring that 7610 04:05:29,391 --> 04:05:31,391 trust today. 7611 04:05:33,494 --> 04:05:34,195 But that requires honesty and 7612 04:05:34,195 --> 04:05:34,830 honesty that just didn't work 7613 04:05:34,830 --> 04:05:37,830 the way we were promised. 7614 04:05:39,100 --> 04:05:39,733 And it also means removing 7615 04:05:39,733 --> 04:05:40,435 license plate readers from 7616 04:05:40,435 --> 04:05:42,835 approved technologies that not 7617 04:05:44,939 --> 04:05:45,807 oppose removal. 7618 04:05:45,807 --> 04:05:46,608 >> The cameras need to be off. 7619 04:05:46,608 --> 04:05:47,542 They need to be down and they 7620 04:05:47,542 --> 04:05:48,810 need to be the out of San 7621 04:05:48,810 --> 04:05:49,678 Diego. 7622 04:05:49,678 --> 04:05:53,278 >> And there's one last thing I 7623 04:05:53,815 --> 04:05:56,815 want to recognize about this. 7624 04:05:59,870 --> 04:05:59,788 This policy fight we've heard 7625 04:05:59,788 --> 04:06:00,455 from people of all ages, all 7626 04:06:00,455 --> 04:06:03,455 ages And I appreciate that. 7627 04:06:04,580 --> 04:06:04,493 And I'm very grateful for all 7628 04:06:04,493 --> 04:06:05,227 the advocates. 7629 04:06:05,227 --> 04:06:08,827 But some of the most persistent 7630 04:06:08,830 --> 04:06:09,531 voices have been from young 7631 04:06:09,531 --> 04:06:10,198 people who are the people most 7632 04:06:10,198 --> 04:06:13,198 fluent in technology and who 7633 04:06:14,200 --> 04:06:14,503 are also often the most 7634 04:06:14,503 --> 04:06:15,270 skeptical of it. 7635 04:06:15,270 --> 04:06:18,870 That skepticism is not based on 7636 04:06:19,140 --> 04:06:19,908 an irrational fear. 7637 04:06:19,908 --> 04:06:20,642 It's a rational fear that comes 7638 04:06:20,642 --> 04:06:23,420 from understanding exactly what 7639 04:06:24,947 --> 04:06:25,747 these tools can do. 7640 04:06:25,747 --> 04:06:26,800 The communities is asking us to 7641 04:06:26,800 --> 04:06:26,815 listen. 7642 04:06:26,815 --> 04:06:29,751 I'm glad we're taking action to 7643 04:06:29,751 --> 04:06:30,418 do that today. 7644 04:06:30,418 --> 04:06:31,119 And with that I Second 7645 04:06:31,119 --> 04:06:33,119 Councilmember Foster's motion 7646 04:06:35,457 --> 04:06:35,924 to rescind the lpr use policy. 7647 04:06:35,924 --> 04:06:36,325 >> Thank you. 7648 04:06:36,325 --> 04:06:36,691 All right. 7649 04:06:36,691 --> 04:06:38,691 Thank you. 7650 04:06:39,995 --> 04:06:40,862 Council member. 7651 04:06:40,862 --> 04:06:41,496 So we have a motion by 7652 04:06:41,496 --> 04:06:42,164 Councilmember Foster and a 7653 04:06:42,164 --> 04:06:45,164 second by council member Eli 7654 04:06:46,668 --> 04:06:50,738 Rivera to rescind the lp pr use 7655 04:06:50,738 --> 04:06:51,439 policy. 7656 04:06:51,439 --> 04:06:52,174 It's up on the screen and 7657 04:06:52,174 --> 04:06:52,708 council members have been given 7658 04:06:52,708 --> 04:06:55,708 a hard copy of that. 7659 04:06:56,110 --> 04:06:56,678 Next up council member Lippert 7660 04:06:56,678 --> 04:06:59,780 Thank you Council PRESIDENT. 7661 04:07:00,983 --> 04:07:01,750 Thank you to all of you who 7662 04:07:01,750 --> 04:07:02,416 joined us here in chambers this 7663 04:07:02,416 --> 04:07:04,816 afternoon and everybody who 7664 04:07:06,221 --> 04:07:06,855 joined us online as well to 7665 04:07:06,855 --> 04:07:07,155 share your perspectives on 7666 04:07:07,155 --> 04:07:07,823 this. 7667 04:07:07,823 --> 04:07:10,823 My district has the highest 7668 04:07:12,161 --> 04:07:12,895 density of the flock automated 7669 04:07:12,895 --> 04:07:13,228 license plate reader cameras or 7670 04:07:13,228 --> 04:07:15,228 Alpers. 7671 04:07:17,320 --> 04:07:17,733 >> It has been one month since 7672 04:07:17,733 --> 04:07:18,400 I announced that I now believe 7673 04:07:18,400 --> 04:07:21,400 the camera should come down. 7674 04:07:23,405 --> 04:07:24,139 I've received a lot of feedback 7675 04:07:24,139 --> 04:07:27,139 on my decision some supportive, 7676 04:07:27,876 --> 04:07:28,677 some critical. 7677 04:07:28,677 --> 04:07:29,377 Some of the criticism that I've 7678 04:07:29,377 --> 04:07:32,977 received is from members of my 7679 04:07:33,782 --> 04:07:34,488 own lgbtq community, 7680 04:07:34,488 --> 04:07:35,250 the community that I love and 7681 04:07:35,250 --> 04:07:38,220 that I work to support and 7682 04:07:38,220 --> 04:07:38,954 protect for the past 25 years. 7683 04:07:38,954 --> 04:07:39,555 We did hear from members of 7684 04:07:39,555 --> 04:07:41,955 the lgbtq community this 7685 04:07:43,525 --> 04:07:44,226 afternoon who said they want to 7686 04:07:44,226 --> 04:07:44,893 see the cameras come down but 7687 04:07:44,893 --> 04:07:47,893 others who want to see 7688 04:07:48,230 --> 04:07:48,830 the Alpers remain have pointed 7689 04:07:48,830 --> 04:07:51,830 out that Alpers had been 7690 04:07:52,968 --> 04:07:53,569 effective in solving hate 7691 04:07:53,569 --> 04:07:53,935 crimes against the lgbtq 7692 04:07:53,935 --> 04:07:55,935 community. 7693 04:07:58,307 --> 04:07:59,141 They are 100% correct. 7694 04:07:59,141 --> 04:08:02,141 Alpers have helped solve hate 7695 04:08:03,879 --> 04:08:04,513 crimes against the lgbtq 7696 04:08:04,513 --> 04:08:05,147 community and hate crimes 7697 04:08:05,147 --> 04:08:07,147 against other communities. 7698 04:08:09,585 --> 04:08:10,185 They have helped solve many 7699 04:08:10,185 --> 04:08:12,585 other crimes as well. 7700 04:08:14,723 --> 04:08:15,290 My view of the effectiveness of 7701 04:08:15,290 --> 04:08:17,290 Alpers hasn't changed. 7702 04:08:20,295 --> 04:08:20,696 What has changed is 7703 04:08:20,696 --> 04:08:22,696 the context. 7704 04:08:24,366 --> 04:08:25,100 When the City Council initially 7705 04:08:25,100 --> 04:08:25,701 approved Alpers three years ago 7706 04:08:25,701 --> 04:08:26,168 it was dubbed the Biden 7707 04:08:26,168 --> 04:08:28,168 administration. 7708 04:08:30,438 --> 04:08:30,939 A year later Donald Trump was 7709 04:08:30,939 --> 04:08:31,674 elected PRESIDENT. 7710 04:08:31,674 --> 04:08:35,874 The two years since have been a 7711 04:08:36,212 --> 04:08:36,612 living for too many families 7712 04:08:36,612 --> 04:08:37,413 in our city. 7713 04:08:37,413 --> 04:08:39,813 The Trump administration and 7714 04:08:42,840 --> 04:08:42,785 ice and their unAmerican 7715 04:08:42,785 --> 04:08:43,485 anti-immigrant brutality have 7716 04:08:43,485 --> 04:08:47,220 created a police state in many 7717 04:08:47,220 --> 04:08:47,723 of our communities. 7718 04:08:47,723 --> 04:08:48,457 People who entered the United 7719 04:08:48,457 --> 04:08:51,457 States legally are having their 7720 04:08:52,795 --> 04:08:53,562 authorizations revoked. 7721 04:08:53,562 --> 04:08:54,230 They live in fear that family 7722 04:08:54,230 --> 04:08:57,230 members will be snatched off 7723 04:08:57,666 --> 04:08:58,340 the streets by ice and 7724 04:08:58,340 --> 04:08:58,834 deported. 7725 04:08:58,834 --> 04:09:02,434 And many people fear the city 7726 04:09:04,400 --> 04:09:04,673 is Alpers are being used in 7727 04:09:04,673 --> 04:09:07,673 the effort to deport their 7728 04:09:09,245 --> 04:09:09,978 loved ones. 7729 04:09:09,978 --> 04:09:10,412 Are the city's helpers being 7730 04:09:10,412 --> 04:09:12,412 used for that? 7731 04:09:14,550 --> 04:09:15,417 No. 7732 04:09:15,417 --> 04:09:15,685 I am confident that they are 7733 04:09:15,685 --> 04:09:16,485 not. 7734 04:09:16,485 --> 04:09:19,485 I spent two years making 7735 04:09:20,623 --> 04:09:21,424 the point that our cameras are 7736 04:09:21,424 --> 04:09:24,424 not being used for immigration 7737 04:09:26,280 --> 04:09:26,729 enforcement. 7738 04:09:26,729 --> 04:09:27,362 But what I believe doesn't 7739 04:09:27,362 --> 04:09:29,762 change what our immigrant 7740 04:09:32,101 --> 04:09:32,668 communities believe in our 7741 04:09:32,668 --> 04:09:33,335 immigrant communities. 7742 04:09:33,335 --> 04:09:36,335 There is widespread fear of 7743 04:09:37,639 --> 04:09:38,507 the city's flock cameras. 7744 04:09:38,507 --> 04:09:39,750 I've had people tell me that 7745 04:09:39,750 --> 04:09:41,750 that shouldn't matter. 7746 04:09:43,146 --> 04:09:43,779 That if the immigrant 7747 04:09:43,779 --> 04:09:44,480 communities are fearful of 7748 04:09:44,480 --> 04:09:46,880 something that isn't happening 7749 04:09:48,784 --> 04:09:49,519 that that's on them. 7750 04:09:49,519 --> 04:09:50,253 I see it differently telling 7751 04:09:50,253 --> 04:09:53,253 immigrant communities not to be 7752 04:09:54,357 --> 04:09:55,240 so fearful. 7753 04:09:55,240 --> 04:09:55,625 It's like telling oppressed 7754 04:09:55,625 --> 04:09:55,992 communities not to be so 7755 04:09:55,992 --> 04:09:57,992 sensitive. 7756 04:10:00,930 --> 04:10:01,596 If we want to support our 7757 04:10:01,596 --> 04:10:02,131 communities we have to meet 7758 04:10:02,131 --> 04:10:04,531 them where they are. 7759 04:10:06,200 --> 04:10:06,471 My goal is to improve people's 7760 04:10:06,471 --> 04:10:07,170 quality of life. 7761 04:10:07,170 --> 04:10:10,770 You can't have any quality of 7762 04:10:11,808 --> 04:10:12,574 life if you're living in fear. 7763 04:10:12,574 --> 04:10:12,875 So let's remove one source of 7764 04:10:12,875 --> 04:10:14,875 fear. 7765 04:10:18,714 --> 04:10:19,415 It certainly would eliminate 7766 04:10:19,415 --> 04:10:20,150 the fear but at least the city 7767 04:10:20,150 --> 04:10:22,415 won't be compounding it. 7768 04:10:24,887 --> 04:10:25,621 Pity the immigrants who are 7769 04:10:25,621 --> 04:10:26,155 most fearful are not here today 7770 04:10:26,155 --> 04:10:28,155 for obvious reasons. 7771 04:10:31,194 --> 04:10:31,561 Many of them are native Spanish 7772 04:10:31,561 --> 04:10:33,561 speakers. 7773 04:10:41,804 --> 04:10:42,305 This year our state is all 7774 04:10:42,305 --> 04:10:43,600 about the garden. 7775 04:10:43,600 --> 04:10:45,275 As far as Gucciardo facilities 7776 04:10:45,275 --> 04:10:45,842 eat every steak muchos resident 7777 04:10:45,842 --> 04:10:46,475 This sincere party has 7778 04:10:46,475 --> 04:10:48,875 discovered that all racial 7779 04:10:52,150 --> 04:10:52,782 discrimination is on the other 7780 04:10:52,782 --> 04:10:55,782 side of a screwdriver special 7781 04:10:57,420 --> 04:10:57,954 This great thing to be able to 7782 04:10:57,954 --> 04:11:00,354 kill Obama for real. 7783 04:11:08,431 --> 04:11:09,980 We'll say as the ensue socotra 7784 04:11:09,980 --> 04:11:09,832 That's actually all there's 7785 04:11:09,832 --> 04:11:13,432 been letters that you that they 7786 04:11:16,506 --> 04:11:17,173 trumpet they control those in 7787 04:11:17,173 --> 04:11:20,173 the greatest band and lot 7788 04:11:28,751 --> 04:11:29,452 properties as the actual days 7789 04:11:29,452 --> 04:11:33,520 I'd rather be able to Seattle 7790 04:11:36,593 --> 04:11:37,360 and much as the somebody that 7791 04:11:37,360 --> 04:11:38,160 is you know what camp so stable 7792 04:11:38,160 --> 04:11:41,160 keyless locked up yet better 7793 04:11:49,605 --> 04:11:50,306 served with other scope of 7794 04:11:50,306 --> 04:11:51,700 party taste sexy on this is 7795 04:11:51,700 --> 04:11:53,407 Naspers notice of western 7796 04:11:59,849 --> 04:12:00,550 casinos so partly that western 7797 04:12:00,550 --> 04:12:01,151 committee that embarrassments 7798 04:12:01,151 --> 04:12:03,551 in theater seguros into 7799 04:12:04,620 --> 04:12:05,255 property of that very creepy 7800 04:12:05,255 --> 04:12:07,424 idea bit the upper garden 7801 04:12:07,424 --> 04:12:07,724 discovers you cats a la rattle 7802 04:12:07,724 --> 04:12:08,457 . 7803 04:12:08,457 --> 04:12:09,192 Now let me turn back to 7804 04:12:09,192 --> 04:12:09,926 the importance of solving crime 7805 04:12:09,926 --> 04:12:10,526 By turning off these cameras We 7806 04:12:10,526 --> 04:12:11,227 are giving up one crime 7807 04:12:11,227 --> 04:12:11,928 fighting tool that our city is 7808 04:12:11,928 --> 04:12:12,228 hardly without tools to fight 7809 04:12:12,228 --> 04:12:12,895 crime. 7810 04:12:12,895 --> 04:12:13,563 The three slot cameras have 7811 04:12:13,563 --> 04:12:13,863 been up for less than three 7812 04:12:13,863 --> 04:12:14,496 years. 7813 04:12:14,496 --> 04:12:15,165 San Diego has been one of 7814 04:12:15,165 --> 04:12:15,565 the safest cities in America 7815 04:12:15,565 --> 04:12:16,299 for decades. 7816 04:12:16,299 --> 04:12:16,899 Mind you we are not prohibiting 7817 04:12:16,899 --> 04:12:17,234 anybody else from having 7818 04:12:17,234 --> 04:12:17,900 cameras. 7819 04:12:17,900 --> 04:12:18,435 Businesses have had security 7820 04:12:18,435 --> 04:12:19,102 cameras for decades. 7821 04:12:19,102 --> 04:12:20,360 Police routinely request and 7822 04:12:20,360 --> 04:12:20,670 receive the footage from those 7823 04:12:20,670 --> 04:12:21,303 cameras when investigating 7824 04:12:21,303 --> 04:12:22,500 crimes that happen nearby. 7825 04:12:22,500 --> 04:12:24,405 Private security cameras help 7826 04:12:25,509 --> 04:12:26,209 solve a lot of crimes. 7827 04:12:26,209 --> 04:12:26,910 Businesses in Hillcrest added 7828 04:12:26,910 --> 04:12:30,510 cameras after a series of hate 7829 04:12:31,581 --> 04:12:32,449 crimes a couple of years ago. 7830 04:12:32,449 --> 04:12:33,149 We will only be getting rid of 7831 04:12:33,149 --> 04:12:35,549 the flock surveillance cameras 7832 04:12:38,221 --> 04:12:38,855 to anyone who might think of 7833 04:12:38,855 --> 04:12:39,222 committing a hate crime at 7834 04:12:39,222 --> 04:12:39,923 Hillcrest. 7835 04:12:39,923 --> 04:12:43,523 Know that there will still be 7836 04:12:43,527 --> 04:12:44,160 plenty of other cameras 7837 04:12:44,160 --> 04:12:44,894 recording what happens on 7838 04:12:44,894 --> 04:12:45,562 University Avenue and elsewhere 7839 04:12:45,562 --> 04:12:48,898 not to mention the fact that 7840 04:12:48,898 --> 04:12:49,499 most people have cameras on 7841 04:12:49,499 --> 04:12:50,233 their phones these days. 7842 04:12:50,233 --> 04:12:53,233 We have another very effective 7843 04:12:54,971 --> 04:12:55,438 tool against crime San Diego 7844 04:12:55,438 --> 04:12:57,438 police officers. 7845 04:13:01,844 --> 04:13:02,578 What we need is faster response 7846 04:13:02,578 --> 04:13:03,179 time so that when you call for 7847 04:13:03,179 --> 04:13:03,513 help an officer is there 7848 04:13:03,513 --> 04:13:04,247 quickly. 7849 04:13:04,247 --> 04:13:07,847 I have had constituents tell me 7850 04:13:08,585 --> 04:13:09,386 that they would feel safer if 7851 04:13:09,386 --> 04:13:10,530 they knew that when they called 7852 04:13:10,530 --> 04:13:10,619 back when one help would be 7853 04:13:10,619 --> 04:13:12,619 under way immediately. 7854 04:13:13,724 --> 04:13:14,391 That is why I would like to see 7855 04:13:14,391 --> 04:13:14,992 the money we save by turning 7856 04:13:14,992 --> 04:13:15,658 off the flight cameras. 7857 04:13:15,658 --> 04:13:18,795 Instead be used to speed up 7858 04:13:18,795 --> 04:13:19,495 response times. 7859 04:13:19,495 --> 04:13:20,163 We can improve public safety 7860 04:13:20,163 --> 04:13:20,564 without creating fear in our 7861 04:13:20,564 --> 04:13:22,564 communities. 7862 04:13:26,236 --> 04:13:26,970 Let's go to the surveillance 7863 04:13:26,970 --> 04:13:27,637 cameras and get people the help 7864 04:13:27,637 --> 04:13:30,637 they need more quickly with 7865 04:13:30,807 --> 04:13:31,475 faster response times. 7866 04:13:31,475 --> 04:13:31,841 >> Thank you, Council 7867 04:13:31,841 --> 04:13:32,209 PRESIDENT. 7868 04:13:32,209 --> 04:13:32,809 All right. 7869 04:13:32,809 --> 04:13:34,809 Thank you, Councilmember 7870 04:13:36,713 --> 04:13:37,580 Clyburn. 7871 04:13:37,580 --> 04:13:38,148 >> We'll go now to council 7872 04:13:38,148 --> 04:13:38,715 PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee. 7873 04:13:38,715 --> 04:13:40,715 Thank you, PRESIDENT. 7874 04:13:43,286 --> 04:13:43,887 Thank you for the presentation 7875 04:13:43,887 --> 04:13:44,688 in chief and the team. 7876 04:13:44,688 --> 04:13:45,288 Thank you to my colleagues for 7877 04:13:45,288 --> 04:13:48,288 diving to this as well. 7878 04:13:48,358 --> 04:13:48,992 I do want to take a moment to 7879 04:13:48,992 --> 04:13:49,726 thank the Privacy Advisory 7880 04:13:49,726 --> 04:13:50,326 Board in recognizing that their 7881 04:13:50,326 --> 04:13:52,726 efforts are critical to 7882 04:13:55,232 --> 04:13:55,933 reviewing each of these 7883 04:13:55,933 --> 04:13:56,633 policies and not just the one 7884 04:13:56,633 --> 04:13:59,633 that we're discussing in this 7885 04:14:00,404 --> 04:14:01,710 motion but all 53 other 7886 04:14:01,710 --> 04:14:01,572 technologies that have been 7887 04:14:01,572 --> 04:14:02,172 discussed as well. 7888 04:14:02,172 --> 04:14:02,873 And also the members of 7889 04:14:02,873 --> 04:14:06,473 the public who have made these 7890 04:14:06,810 --> 04:14:07,511 conversations in the past I 7891 04:14:07,511 --> 04:14:08,112 think those of with been here 7892 04:14:08,112 --> 04:14:10,112 for these conversations 7893 04:14:12,282 --> 04:14:12,950 recognize that our opinions in 7894 04:14:12,950 --> 04:14:13,650 some cases have changed And 7895 04:14:13,650 --> 04:14:16,650 none of these conversations I 7896 04:14:18,755 --> 04:14:19,125 think in the past have ever 7897 04:14:19,125 --> 04:14:19,790 been easy. 7898 04:14:19,790 --> 04:14:20,457 And that's something I just 7899 04:14:20,457 --> 04:14:21,158 openly want to acknowledge. 7900 04:14:21,158 --> 04:14:25,295 I think each time that we have 7901 04:14:25,295 --> 04:14:25,996 discussed the use of technology 7902 04:14:25,996 --> 04:14:26,696 and where that balance is held 7903 04:14:26,696 --> 04:14:29,696 between trying to offer tools 7904 04:14:30,700 --> 04:14:31,368 that can assist the department 7905 04:14:31,368 --> 04:14:33,768 versus maintaining the civil 7906 04:14:36,407 --> 04:14:37,141 rights of our residents. 7907 04:14:37,141 --> 04:14:37,907 I think my stance has always 7908 04:14:37,907 --> 04:14:42,107 been to try to ensure that as 7909 04:14:42,513 --> 04:14:43,213 we explore any technology, as 7910 04:14:43,213 --> 04:14:43,847 we look at these policies that 7911 04:14:43,847 --> 04:14:44,548 we are always making every 7912 04:14:44,548 --> 04:14:46,948 effort to strengthen, improve, 7913 04:14:48,170 --> 04:14:48,552 refine and review those 7914 04:14:48,552 --> 04:14:49,286 policies over time. 7915 04:14:49,286 --> 04:14:52,286 And that also means recognizing 7916 04:14:52,322 --> 04:14:55,922 when the time comes that that 7917 04:14:58,162 --> 04:14:58,796 policy no longer makes sense. 7918 04:14:58,796 --> 04:14:59,463 We've made several efforts 7919 04:14:59,463 --> 04:15:00,164 under the trust ordinance in 7920 04:15:00,164 --> 04:15:04,364 the past to always look at how 7921 04:15:04,935 --> 04:15:05,603 tools can help to solve crimes 7922 04:15:05,603 --> 04:15:06,303 while also trying to balance 7923 04:15:06,303 --> 04:15:08,303 addressing legitimate concerns 7924 04:15:10,841 --> 04:15:11,475 that communities have when it 7925 04:15:11,475 --> 04:15:12,420 comes to surveillance and 7926 04:15:12,420 --> 04:15:14,420 technology itself and 7927 04:15:16,280 --> 04:15:16,914 the impacts it might have as 7928 04:15:16,914 --> 04:15:17,681 well as where the public's 7929 04:15:17,681 --> 04:15:21,281 trust is with how that data 7930 04:15:22,286 --> 04:15:22,553 might be utilized in 2023 and 7931 04:15:22,553 --> 04:15:23,219 24. 7932 04:15:23,219 --> 04:15:25,619 I proposed adding additional 7933 04:15:28,392 --> 04:15:29,920 guardrails to policies that we 7934 04:15:29,920 --> 04:15:29,693 were discussing and that range 7935 04:15:29,693 --> 04:15:30,394 from strengthening data 7936 04:15:30,394 --> 04:15:32,394 protection security practices 7937 04:15:34,498 --> 04:15:35,980 to how we regularly update pd 7938 04:15:35,980 --> 04:15:35,833 trainings on the use of 7939 04:15:35,833 --> 04:15:38,833 technology and generally to try 7940 04:15:41,372 --> 04:15:42,390 to ensure that we practice 7941 04:15:42,390 --> 04:15:42,673 greater public transparency. 7942 04:15:42,673 --> 04:15:45,730 When this Council approved 7943 04:15:45,976 --> 04:15:46,677 the lpr use Policy 2025 council 7944 04:15:46,677 --> 04:15:47,444 PRESIDENT Lacob and I followed 7945 04:15:47,444 --> 04:15:51,440 up with a memo requesting that 7946 04:15:51,315 --> 04:15:51,949 cpd immediately undergo 7947 04:15:51,949 --> 04:15:52,516 the process to explore new 7948 04:15:52,516 --> 04:15:53,117 vendor options under a 7949 04:15:53,117 --> 04:15:55,117 competitive bid process. 7950 04:15:58,555 --> 04:15:59,323 And I know a year has passed 7951 04:15:59,323 --> 04:15:59,924 since that time and I think I 7952 04:15:59,924 --> 04:16:02,324 expressed at the Budget 7953 04:16:04,161 --> 04:16:04,862 Committee it's hard not to feel 7954 04:16:04,862 --> 04:16:05,529 that we've had little to show 7955 04:16:05,529 --> 04:16:05,829 in terms of progress on that 7956 04:16:05,829 --> 04:16:07,829 front. 7957 04:16:09,567 --> 04:16:10,134 And so in an era where the city 7958 04:16:10,134 --> 04:16:10,868 has faced continuously 7959 04:16:10,868 --> 04:16:12,868 challenging budgetary decisions 7960 04:16:15,239 --> 04:16:15,906 and we are fighting to 7961 04:16:15,906 --> 04:16:16,707 prioritize where our scarce 7962 04:16:16,707 --> 04:16:20,907 dollars are spent I did join my 7963 04:16:21,545 --> 04:16:22,246 colleagues this spring in 7964 04:16:22,246 --> 04:16:25,246 proposing that in this year's 7965 04:16:27,118 --> 04:16:27,752 budget we reallocate those 7966 04:16:27,752 --> 04:16:28,152 dollars instead to support 7967 04:16:28,152 --> 04:16:28,819 other needs. 7968 04:16:28,819 --> 04:16:32,419 And we've heard some of that 7969 04:16:33,691 --> 04:16:34,392 from the audience here today. 7970 04:16:34,392 --> 04:16:34,992 We heard that fight during 7971 04:16:34,992 --> 04:16:36,992 the budget discussions. 7972 04:16:39,964 --> 04:16:40,765 We were scrambling to restore 7973 04:16:40,765 --> 04:16:41,465 every last bit of library and 7974 04:16:41,465 --> 04:16:42,133 rec center hours, many of them 7975 04:16:42,133 --> 04:16:42,499 that still remain cut across 7976 04:16:42,499 --> 04:16:44,499 the city. 7977 04:16:46,370 --> 04:16:46,771 We talked about other public 7978 04:16:46,771 --> 04:16:47,572 safety needs that we were short 7979 04:16:47,572 --> 04:16:50,708 on that we needed dollars for 7980 04:16:50,708 --> 04:16:53,108 and could not allocate. 7981 04:16:57,381 --> 04:16:58,480 And ultimately although I think 7982 04:16:58,480 --> 04:16:58,649 we just have to acknowledge 7983 04:16:58,649 --> 04:17:01,490 that seniors remain more 7984 04:17:03,187 --> 04:17:03,821 fearful than ever of 7985 04:17:03,821 --> 04:17:06,221 the potential breaches and 7986 04:17:08,526 --> 04:17:09,227 abuse of technology and it's 7987 04:17:09,227 --> 04:17:09,927 impossible to ignore that with 7988 04:17:09,927 --> 04:17:10,595 the increasing overreach that 7989 04:17:10,595 --> 04:17:13,595 we've seen from our federal 7990 04:17:14,765 --> 04:17:15,466 government especially through 7991 04:17:15,466 --> 04:17:16,200 the increased presence of ice 7992 04:17:16,200 --> 04:17:20,400 even in recent weeks And I will 7993 04:17:21,538 --> 04:17:22,206 just share that We received 7994 04:17:22,206 --> 04:17:24,606 information from parents in 7995 04:17:26,644 --> 04:17:27,345 hours at our local schools just 7996 04:17:27,345 --> 04:17:28,450 this week about what they felt 7997 04:17:28,450 --> 04:17:30,445 was increased presence around 7998 04:17:32,950 --> 04:17:33,584 even our schools that 7999 04:17:33,584 --> 04:17:33,918 atmosphere absolutely has 8000 04:17:33,918 --> 04:17:34,652 changed. 8001 04:17:34,652 --> 04:17:39,560 And so as a result I do believe 8002 04:17:39,560 --> 04:17:39,323 it is this time that we have to 8003 04:17:39,323 --> 04:17:40,240 act. 8004 04:17:40,240 --> 04:17:40,758 And while those conversations 8005 04:17:40,758 --> 04:17:44,958 we've had in the past have been 8006 04:17:45,463 --> 04:17:46,164 difficult today that 8007 04:17:46,164 --> 04:17:46,764 conversation is not the choice 8008 04:17:46,764 --> 04:17:47,365 is not difficult for me. 8009 04:17:47,365 --> 04:17:50,365 I believe it's time to 8010 04:17:51,268 --> 04:17:51,970 prioritize the protection of 8011 04:17:51,970 --> 04:17:52,404 civil rights and liberties for 8012 04:17:52,404 --> 04:17:53,370 our residents. 8013 04:17:53,370 --> 04:17:53,737 I do believe it's time to 8014 04:17:53,737 --> 04:17:56,137 prioritize our limited public 8015 04:17:57,642 --> 04:17:58,309 dollars to protect the very 8016 04:17:58,309 --> 04:17:58,943 services and everyday public 8017 04:17:58,943 --> 04:17:59,677 safety needs that we have 8018 04:17:59,677 --> 04:18:02,770 emphasized for our communities. 8019 04:18:03,648 --> 04:18:04,381 And so I do absolutely support 8020 04:18:04,381 --> 04:18:07,981 the motion before us to rescind 8021 04:18:08,953 --> 04:18:09,620 the opioid use policy to 8022 04:18:09,620 --> 04:18:10,188 prevent the continued use of 8023 04:18:10,188 --> 04:18:10,788 these technologies for 8024 04:18:10,788 --> 04:18:11,189 the safety of all of our 8025 04:18:11,189 --> 04:18:13,189 communities. 8026 04:18:15,293 --> 04:18:15,894 And thank you again to 8027 04:18:15,894 --> 04:18:16,594 Councilmember Foster for 8028 04:18:16,594 --> 04:18:18,994 bringing this forward because 8029 04:18:20,265 --> 04:18:20,965 my council comments with 8030 04:18:20,965 --> 04:18:21,632 Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee 8031 04:18:21,632 --> 04:18:21,966 will now go to Councilmember 8032 04:18:21,966 --> 04:18:22,834 Moreno. 8033 04:18:22,834 --> 04:18:26,434 >> Thank you And I'd like to 8034 04:18:27,172 --> 04:18:27,805 start off by thanking staff for 8035 04:18:27,805 --> 04:18:30,205 the presentation and also 8036 04:18:32,510 --> 04:18:33,310 thanking all of our speakers 8037 04:18:33,310 --> 04:18:34,120 here today that came to express 8038 04:18:34,120 --> 04:18:37,120 their viewpoints on this item. 8039 04:18:38,582 --> 04:18:39,284 A special thank you to 8040 04:18:39,284 --> 04:18:39,951 the Privacy Advisory Board and 8041 04:18:39,951 --> 04:18:42,951 all of the community members 8042 04:18:44,789 --> 04:18:45,523 who spent countless hours 8043 04:18:45,523 --> 04:18:47,923 reviewing this this technology. 8044 04:18:51,290 --> 04:18:51,763 Our officers need effective 8045 04:18:51,763 --> 04:18:52,464 tools to investigate crimes and 8046 04:18:52,464 --> 04:18:54,864 protect our neighborhoods but 8047 04:18:56,768 --> 04:18:57,501 at the same time our residents 8048 04:18:57,501 --> 04:18:58,236 also need confidence that those 8049 04:18:58,236 --> 04:19:01,236 tools respect their privacy and 8050 04:19:03,507 --> 04:19:04,800 that the city will protect 8051 04:19:04,800 --> 04:19:04,643 their information. 8052 04:19:04,643 --> 04:19:07,643 When we examine the track 8053 04:19:09,514 --> 04:19:10,215 record of Lux lp our System 8054 04:19:10,215 --> 04:19:10,781 I've always had deep concerns 8055 04:19:10,781 --> 04:19:11,249 about the security of 8056 04:19:11,249 --> 04:19:13,249 the city's data. 8057 04:19:15,954 --> 04:19:16,554 For District eight, immigration 8058 04:19:16,554 --> 04:19:18,954 and privacy concerns are 8059 04:19:20,858 --> 04:19:21,559 central to this discussion. 8060 04:19:21,559 --> 04:19:22,193 Residents should be able to 8061 04:19:22,193 --> 04:19:25,193 drive to work, take their 8062 04:19:27,331 --> 04:19:27,999 children to school and visit 8063 04:19:27,999 --> 04:19:28,599 family without worrying that 8064 04:19:28,599 --> 04:19:29,134 information about their 8065 04:19:29,134 --> 04:19:31,134 movement could reach 8066 04:19:34,405 --> 04:19:35,730 immigration authorities in 8067 04:19:35,730 --> 04:19:35,807 several jurisdictions across 8068 04:19:35,807 --> 04:19:39,407 the country, that data has been 8069 04:19:40,145 --> 04:19:40,712 improperly accessed by federal 8070 04:19:40,712 --> 04:19:42,712 agencies including for 8071 04:19:46,184 --> 04:19:46,785 immigration enforcement exactly 8072 04:19:46,785 --> 04:19:47,285 the type of misuse our 8073 04:19:47,285 --> 04:19:49,285 communities fear. 8074 04:19:52,857 --> 04:19:53,525 When this hpr system launched a 8075 04:19:53,525 --> 04:19:54,580 configuration error allowed 8076 04:19:54,580 --> 04:19:56,580 other California law 8077 04:19:58,563 --> 04:19:59,164 enforcement agencies to search 8078 04:19:59,164 --> 04:20:02,164 San Diego's lp for data. 8079 04:20:03,301 --> 04:20:06,301 Our cameras were included in 8080 04:20:08,974 --> 04:20:09,374 12,914 searches over nearly 8081 04:20:09,374 --> 04:20:11,374 three weeks. 8082 04:20:14,790 --> 04:20:14,746 That incident was initially 8083 04:20:14,746 --> 04:20:15,800 omitted from the 2024 annual 8084 04:20:15,800 --> 04:20:17,800 report. 8085 04:20:19,751 --> 04:20:20,418 The 2025 report identifies four 8086 04:20:20,418 --> 04:20:22,418 suspected policy violations 8087 04:20:25,457 --> 04:20:26,158 including sharing information 8088 04:20:26,158 --> 04:20:29,158 with an Arizona police agency 8089 04:20:31,430 --> 04:20:32,960 after the sharing ban As 8090 04:20:32,960 --> 04:20:32,831 the cpd says those suspected 8091 04:20:32,831 --> 04:20:33,165 violations were not immigration 8092 04:20:33,165 --> 04:20:35,165 related. 8093 04:20:37,436 --> 04:20:38,236 And I would like to ask if dpd 8094 04:20:38,236 --> 04:20:41,806 can clarify what were the final 8095 04:20:41,806 --> 04:20:42,340 findings on the four suspected 8096 04:20:42,340 --> 04:20:44,340 2025 hpr violations? 8097 04:20:47,613 --> 04:20:48,179 What information was disclosed 8098 04:20:48,179 --> 04:20:48,780 and what corrections? 8099 04:20:48,780 --> 04:20:50,780 What corrective actions 8100 04:21:00,125 --> 04:21:00,826 followed in Councilmember are 8101 04:21:00,826 --> 04:21:03,826 you talking about the internal 8102 04:21:04,829 --> 04:21:05,664 investigations? 8103 04:21:05,664 --> 04:21:08,640 >> Can you specifically know 8104 04:21:09,968 --> 04:21:12,968 there were four incidences in 8105 04:21:14,773 --> 04:21:15,474 the 2025 report four incidents 8106 04:21:15,474 --> 04:21:16,140 there was the three which were 8107 04:21:16,140 --> 04:21:16,875 focused on improper metadata 8108 04:21:16,875 --> 04:21:21,750 entry and then the one that was 8109 04:21:21,800 --> 04:21:21,713 the sharing with Arizona And 8110 04:21:21,713 --> 04:21:24,713 that was shortly after we 8111 04:21:26,885 --> 04:21:27,586 issued the department order on 8112 04:21:27,586 --> 04:21:28,120 the ban saying that you could 8113 04:21:28,120 --> 04:21:28,854 no longer share that 8114 04:21:28,854 --> 04:21:29,354 information with federal or out 8115 04:21:29,354 --> 04:21:31,354 of state agencies. 8116 04:21:33,250 --> 04:21:33,725 When we caught out we 8117 04:21:33,725 --> 04:21:34,393 immediately stopped access to 8118 04:21:34,393 --> 04:21:37,393 the system for that officer 8119 04:21:38,931 --> 04:21:39,631 reached out to them, talked to 8120 04:21:39,631 --> 04:21:40,298 them and then we did training 8121 04:21:40,298 --> 04:21:44,498 and we got him up to speed. 8122 04:21:44,803 --> 04:21:45,237 He was just unaware that that 8123 04:21:45,237 --> 04:21:46,710 had happened. 8124 04:21:46,710 --> 04:21:46,372 It was right on the edge of 8125 04:21:46,372 --> 04:21:47,720 that. 8126 04:21:47,720 --> 04:21:47,773 The other three were metadata 8127 04:21:47,773 --> 04:21:49,740 entry issues which we reported 8128 04:21:49,740 --> 04:21:49,608 out and they were investigated 8129 04:21:49,608 --> 04:21:51,608 by Internal Affairs. 8130 04:21:55,914 --> 04:21:56,381 Thank you for thank you for 8131 04:21:56,381 --> 04:21:57,820 clarifying this. 8132 04:21:57,820 --> 04:22:00,682 >> One of the things that just 8133 04:22:00,686 --> 04:22:01,353 sounds been seemed to me as a 8134 04:22:01,353 --> 04:22:02,154 person that has not been 8135 04:22:02,154 --> 04:22:05,754 supportive of the city of San 8136 04:22:08,930 --> 04:22:08,761 Diego using this data is that a 8137 04:22:08,761 --> 04:22:12,361 person in pd such as you 8138 04:22:13,198 --> 04:22:14,166 described right now would have 8139 04:22:14,166 --> 04:22:18,966 access to share If I had such a 8140 04:22:19,939 --> 04:22:20,906 if I had such a precious thing 8141 04:22:20,906 --> 04:22:25,511 as cpd thought of hpr as such a 8142 04:22:25,511 --> 04:22:26,178 precious thing I would have my 8143 04:22:26,178 --> 04:22:26,812 highest ranking official be 8144 04:22:26,812 --> 04:22:29,812 the only entity that could 8145 04:22:31,884 --> 04:22:32,785 approve sharing of this data So 8146 04:22:32,785 --> 04:22:35,540 I will share that That is 8147 04:22:35,540 --> 04:22:37,540 extremely, extremely concerning 8148 04:22:41,560 --> 04:22:42,428 to me. 8149 04:22:42,428 --> 04:22:43,128 So I have to just you know I 8150 04:22:43,128 --> 04:22:43,829 wasn't going to share that but 8151 04:22:43,829 --> 04:22:47,500 i have to share that with you. 8152 04:22:47,500 --> 04:22:48,467 Chief, because a lot of trust 8153 04:22:48,467 --> 04:22:51,403 has been placed on you and it's 8154 04:22:51,403 --> 04:22:55,300 like I said, it's just it's 8155 04:22:57,509 --> 04:22:58,177 shocking to me. 8156 04:22:58,177 --> 04:22:58,811 >> Concerns have been raised 8157 04:22:58,811 --> 04:23:00,811 regarding personnel misuse 8158 04:23:03,882 --> 04:23:04,550 incorrect plate reading and 8159 04:23:04,550 --> 04:23:06,950 monitoring of everyday life. 8160 04:23:10,289 --> 04:23:10,990 A driver should face an 8161 04:23:10,990 --> 04:23:11,690 unnecessary stop because of a 8162 04:23:11,690 --> 04:23:14,900 camera mistakenly identified a 8163 04:23:15,728 --> 04:23:16,695 license plate. 8164 04:23:16,695 --> 04:23:20,295 A city has a responsibility to 8165 04:23:21,900 --> 04:23:22,535 protect people's privacy. 8166 04:23:22,535 --> 04:23:23,235 The Privacy Advisory Board 8167 04:23:23,235 --> 04:23:25,235 recommended against continued 8168 04:23:28,341 --> 04:23:29,800 lpr use unless oversight and 8169 04:23:29,800 --> 04:23:31,800 security practices improve. 8170 04:23:33,713 --> 04:23:34,447 Now I recognize that sd pd has 8171 04:23:34,447 --> 04:23:35,147 identified investigations where 8172 04:23:35,147 --> 04:23:38,147 lpr helped but those benefits 8173 04:23:40,686 --> 04:23:41,219 must be weighed against 8174 04:23:41,219 --> 04:23:41,821 the consequences of 8175 04:23:41,821 --> 04:23:43,821 unauthorized access and 8176 04:23:46,625 --> 04:23:47,226 the loss of community trust. 8177 04:23:47,226 --> 04:23:47,960 Public safety depends on 8178 04:23:47,960 --> 04:23:50,360 residents feeling secure enough 8179 04:23:53,332 --> 04:23:53,899 to report a crime to seek help 8180 04:23:53,899 --> 04:23:54,299 and to cooperate with 8181 04:23:54,299 --> 04:23:55,100 the police. 8182 04:23:55,100 --> 04:23:58,700 Now as a council member for 8183 04:23:58,700 --> 04:23:58,771 District eight, I have a 8184 04:23:58,771 --> 04:23:59,710 responsibility to protect that 8185 04:23:59,710 --> 04:24:01,710 trust. 8186 04:24:04,343 --> 04:24:05,110 I have consistently opposed 8187 04:24:05,110 --> 04:24:08,110 the use of automated license 8188 04:24:09,749 --> 04:24:10,480 plate readers or helpers since 8189 04:24:10,480 --> 04:24:12,480 2023. 8190 04:24:15,153 --> 04:24:15,788 I have voted against the use of 8191 04:24:15,788 --> 04:24:16,522 the system because I have 8192 04:24:16,522 --> 04:24:17,190 serious concerns about how this 8193 04:24:17,190 --> 04:24:20,190 technology is being used and 8194 04:24:21,560 --> 04:24:22,600 who ultimately bears 8195 04:24:22,600 --> 04:24:22,929 the consequences. 8196 04:24:22,929 --> 04:24:27,166 Today I have to say that I have 8197 04:24:27,166 --> 04:24:27,933 exactly the same concerns. 8198 04:24:27,933 --> 04:24:28,667 So for those reasons I will 8199 04:24:28,667 --> 04:24:31,667 continue voting against the hpr 8200 04:24:33,806 --> 04:24:34,407 system and I will support 8201 04:24:34,407 --> 04:24:34,774 the motion on the floor. 8202 04:24:34,774 --> 04:24:35,140 Thank you. 8203 04:24:35,140 --> 04:24:35,842 All right. 8204 04:24:35,842 --> 04:24:38,242 Thank you, COUNCILMAN Moreno. 8205 04:24:39,512 --> 04:24:39,812 I will go next to Councilmember 8206 04:24:39,812 --> 04:24:40,446 Camp. 8207 04:24:40,446 --> 04:24:41,147 You think it helps present 8208 04:24:41,147 --> 04:24:41,848 thinking members of the public 8209 04:24:41,848 --> 04:24:44,248 for your participation today? 8210 04:24:45,218 --> 04:24:45,617 Thank you to our police 8211 04:24:45,617 --> 04:24:46,319 department. 8212 04:24:46,319 --> 04:24:47,530 I supported automated license 8213 04:24:47,530 --> 04:24:47,686 plate readers because I believe 8214 04:24:47,686 --> 04:24:50,686 they could help to protect 8215 04:24:51,223 --> 04:24:51,924 victims and solve serious 8216 04:24:51,924 --> 04:24:52,225 crimes and make our community 8217 04:24:52,225 --> 04:24:52,892 safer. 8218 04:24:52,892 --> 04:24:53,526 In many instances that we've 8219 04:24:53,526 --> 04:24:56,526 seen that have been highly 8220 04:24:56,596 --> 04:24:57,530 publicized. 8221 04:24:57,530 --> 04:24:58,197 They have as far as I can tell 8222 04:24:58,197 --> 04:25:01,197 in my district in particular 8223 04:25:01,900 --> 04:25:02,669 those violent crimes solved 8224 04:25:02,669 --> 04:25:03,302 resolved issues for some of our 8225 04:25:03,302 --> 04:25:05,302 most vulnerable including 8226 04:25:08,641 --> 04:25:09,375 communities of color to help us 8227 04:25:09,375 --> 04:25:10,242 find the assailants of a murder 8228 04:25:10,242 --> 04:25:14,442 of Latino man in La Vista Linda 8229 04:25:14,848 --> 04:25:15,615 Vista Park. 8230 04:25:15,615 --> 04:25:16,215 That was a significant success 8231 04:25:16,215 --> 04:25:16,916 of the system and I made 8232 04:25:16,916 --> 04:25:19,916 the decision back then knowing 8233 04:25:20,853 --> 04:25:21,488 it would be unpopular and I 8234 04:25:21,488 --> 04:25:22,210 stood by it because public 8235 04:25:22,210 --> 04:25:22,455 safety is not about 8236 04:25:22,455 --> 04:25:23,189 the rhetoric. 8237 04:25:23,189 --> 04:25:26,789 It's about figuring out if it's 8238 04:25:27,827 --> 04:25:28,595 more efficacious than not. 8239 04:25:28,595 --> 04:25:29,295 It should be about doing what's 8240 04:25:29,295 --> 04:25:30,290 right for the people we serve. 8241 04:25:30,290 --> 04:25:33,290 In the delicate balance between 8242 04:25:34,000 --> 04:25:34,734 rights and safety, this balance 8243 04:25:34,734 --> 04:25:35,435 has been discussed since before 8244 04:25:35,435 --> 04:25:36,136 the Bill of Rights was passed 8245 04:25:36,136 --> 04:25:39,239 and it will not end today with 8246 04:25:39,239 --> 04:25:40,106 this vote. 8247 04:25:40,106 --> 04:25:40,774 As a former prosecutor I know 8248 04:25:40,774 --> 04:25:41,441 how much supporting evidence 8249 04:25:41,441 --> 04:25:45,410 can make can matter in cases 8250 04:25:45,745 --> 04:25:46,446 evidence that helps find a 8251 04:25:46,446 --> 04:25:47,130 kidnaping victim and connects 8252 04:25:47,130 --> 04:25:47,647 the pieces in a human 8253 04:25:47,647 --> 04:25:49,647 trafficking investigation. 8254 04:25:51,751 --> 04:25:52,452 Helps that young person and 8255 04:25:52,452 --> 04:25:53,119 data supports the testimony of 8256 04:25:53,119 --> 04:25:53,753 a domestic violence survivor 8257 04:25:53,753 --> 04:25:54,870 trying to get away from an 8258 04:25:54,870 --> 04:25:56,870 abuser. 8259 04:25:58,580 --> 04:25:58,758 Evidence that also can 8260 04:25:58,758 --> 04:25:59,458 establish someone's innocence. 8261 04:25:59,458 --> 04:26:00,126 I heard the concerns raised by 8262 04:26:00,126 --> 04:26:02,526 advocates and colleagues and 8263 04:26:03,997 --> 04:26:04,664 members of our community and we 8264 04:26:04,664 --> 04:26:04,998 heard troubling examples of 8265 04:26:04,998 --> 04:26:05,732 misuse. 8266 04:26:05,732 --> 04:26:06,299 >> And I was always clear about 8267 04:26:06,299 --> 04:26:09,299 what I where I stood. 8268 04:26:09,569 --> 04:26:10,236 Show me the evidence This 8269 04:26:10,236 --> 04:26:10,737 technology has been misused 8270 04:26:10,737 --> 04:26:11,404 here in San Diego. 8271 04:26:11,404 --> 04:26:12,172 I will revisit my position. 8272 04:26:12,172 --> 04:26:15,772 So now that this evidence is 8273 04:26:16,776 --> 04:26:17,510 here I meant what I said. 8274 04:26:17,510 --> 04:26:18,211 Learning that lawyers were used 8275 04:26:18,211 --> 04:26:21,211 to surveil a domestic violence 8276 04:26:21,848 --> 04:26:22,482 victim during an internal 8277 04:26:22,482 --> 04:26:23,216 investigation involving an 8278 04:26:23,216 --> 04:26:23,750 active duty officer, misconduct 8279 04:26:23,750 --> 04:26:26,150 was painful to read. 8280 04:26:28,288 --> 04:26:28,989 The implication that it was 8281 04:26:28,989 --> 04:26:29,723 just an administrative use and 8282 04:26:29,723 --> 04:26:30,356 therefore legally permissible I 8283 04:26:30,356 --> 04:26:33,356 believe is an overly broad 8284 04:26:34,294 --> 04:26:34,995 reading of the use policy. 8285 04:26:34,995 --> 04:26:35,395 But more importantly it misses 8286 04:26:35,395 --> 04:26:35,995 a key point. 8287 04:26:35,995 --> 04:26:38,995 If there's a backdoor to 8288 04:26:39,766 --> 04:26:40,467 surveil a member of the public 8289 04:26:40,467 --> 04:26:41,101 under an exception that broad 8290 04:26:41,101 --> 04:26:41,801 then there's really not a 8291 04:26:41,801 --> 04:26:44,801 protection in such a broad 8292 04:26:46,539 --> 04:26:47,207 reading or perhaps such a broad 8293 04:26:47,207 --> 04:26:49,607 application tells victims of 8294 04:26:51,845 --> 04:26:52,512 all sorts who are scared to 8295 04:26:52,512 --> 04:26:53,213 call the police for whatever 8296 04:26:53,213 --> 04:26:53,914 reason that MAY be that their 8297 04:26:53,914 --> 04:26:56,914 call for help could sacrifice 8298 04:26:57,851 --> 04:26:58,518 their expectation of privacy. 8299 04:26:58,518 --> 04:26:59,219 Victims of crimes have many 8300 04:26:59,219 --> 04:26:59,654 reasons to be afraid when they 8301 04:26:59,654 --> 04:27:01,654 ask for help. 8302 04:27:03,490 --> 04:27:04,191 We beg victims to ask us for 8303 04:27:04,191 --> 04:27:04,891 help so that we can protect 8304 04:27:04,891 --> 04:27:05,559 them from their assailants And 8305 04:27:05,559 --> 04:27:09,159 we beg victims to testify at 8306 04:27:09,429 --> 04:27:09,930 trials so that their assailants 8307 04:27:09,930 --> 04:27:10,430 can be convicted. 8308 04:27:10,430 --> 04:27:11,131 And the back door 8309 04:27:11,131 --> 04:27:11,798 administrative exception that 8310 04:27:11,798 --> 04:27:15,398 says anyone can be caught up 8311 04:27:15,969 --> 04:27:16,636 undermines so much about what 8312 04:27:16,636 --> 04:27:17,337 we've been told and frankly 8313 04:27:17,337 --> 04:27:20,937 what we've been told about api 8314 04:27:21,174 --> 04:27:21,842 usage in San Diego. 8315 04:27:21,842 --> 04:27:22,409 My responsibility has always 8316 04:27:22,409 --> 04:27:23,142 been to those people. 8317 04:27:23,142 --> 04:27:26,142 That responsibility is why I 8318 04:27:27,580 --> 04:27:28,282 initially supported Calpers 8319 04:27:28,282 --> 04:27:28,882 even when it was unpopular and 8320 04:27:28,882 --> 04:27:29,516 why I could not continue 8321 04:27:29,516 --> 04:27:29,950 supporting the item in its 8322 04:27:29,950 --> 04:27:31,950 current form. 8323 04:27:34,121 --> 04:27:34,788 I did not change my principles. 8324 04:27:34,788 --> 04:27:35,489 The facts before us changed. 8325 04:27:35,489 --> 04:27:39,890 When the facts change we have 8326 04:27:39,860 --> 04:27:40,427 to act in accordance. 8327 04:27:40,427 --> 04:27:41,161 Additionally and very 8328 04:27:41,161 --> 04:27:41,862 importantly we must acknowledge 8329 04:27:41,862 --> 04:27:44,262 the potential labor violation 8330 04:27:45,332 --> 04:27:45,899 here San Diego police officers 8331 04:27:45,899 --> 04:27:46,500 Association identified 8332 04:27:46,500 --> 04:27:47,200 the issue raising it to 8333 04:27:47,200 --> 04:27:50,800 the mayor's team and the fact 8334 04:27:51,438 --> 04:27:52,239 that the mayor's team agreed to 8335 04:27:52,239 --> 04:27:52,906 cease and assist in this use 8336 04:27:52,906 --> 04:27:53,340 tells us a lot about what's 8337 04:27:53,340 --> 04:27:53,974 happened here. 8338 04:27:53,974 --> 04:27:55,974 Clearly the administrative 8339 04:27:58,780 --> 04:27:58,712 exception while for the good 8340 04:27:58,712 --> 04:27:59,379 goal of disciplining an 8341 04:27:59,379 --> 04:28:00,800 officer's misconduct was not 8342 04:28:00,800 --> 04:28:02,480 something obviously agreed to 8343 04:28:03,951 --> 04:28:04,818 by labor union under the law. 8344 04:28:04,818 --> 04:28:05,418 I point out that in public 8345 04:28:05,418 --> 04:28:06,153 statements the chair of 8346 04:28:06,153 --> 04:28:06,820 the Privacy Advisory Board says 8347 04:28:06,820 --> 04:28:09,220 it's possibly allowable and 8348 04:28:10,560 --> 04:28:10,724 also the vice chair calls in 8349 04:28:10,724 --> 04:28:10,991 today and says it's clearly 8350 04:28:10,991 --> 04:28:11,692 not. 8351 04:28:11,692 --> 04:28:15,292 Clearly it's not clear at all. 8352 04:28:16,230 --> 04:28:16,830 And if that is the case, 8353 04:28:16,830 --> 04:28:17,498 the back door to surveil 8354 04:28:17,498 --> 04:28:18,198 the domestic violence victim 8355 04:28:18,198 --> 04:28:21,502 doesn't seem to me to be truly 8356 04:28:21,502 --> 04:28:22,235 allowable at all. 8357 04:28:22,235 --> 04:28:22,970 In other words, the ends don't 8358 04:28:22,970 --> 04:28:26,570 justify the means and the means 8359 04:28:27,975 --> 04:28:28,941 were not settled Practice. 8360 04:28:28,941 --> 04:28:32,145 If it was a potential breach of 8361 04:28:32,145 --> 04:28:32,780 labor regulations to surveil 8362 04:28:32,780 --> 04:28:33,480 the officer albeit one who 8363 04:28:33,480 --> 04:28:34,214 committed absolutely abhorrent 8364 04:28:34,214 --> 04:28:36,614 and significant misconduct, how 8365 04:28:38,285 --> 04:28:38,986 could it be allowable to 8366 04:28:38,986 --> 04:28:39,386 surveil an ordinary member of 8367 04:28:39,386 --> 04:28:40,860 the public? 8368 04:28:40,860 --> 04:28:43,860 And even if the administrative 8369 04:28:44,758 --> 04:28:45,459 exception had been properly 8370 04:28:45,459 --> 04:28:45,926 negotiated through the meeting 8371 04:28:45,926 --> 04:28:46,527 confer process? 8372 04:28:46,527 --> 04:28:47,260 How could one union have 8373 04:28:47,260 --> 04:28:49,660 negotiated away the protections 8374 04:28:50,564 --> 04:28:51,980 for members of the public that 8375 04:28:51,980 --> 04:28:51,798 aren't its members? 8376 04:28:51,798 --> 04:28:52,466 The union would never do that 8377 04:28:52,466 --> 04:28:55,735 and in fact the union could 8378 04:28:55,735 --> 04:28:56,403 never do that. 8379 04:28:56,403 --> 04:28:57,700 Chief, my question for you 8380 04:28:57,700 --> 04:28:57,805 because the public has been 8381 04:28:57,805 --> 04:29:00,805 watching this debate so closely 8382 04:29:02,208 --> 04:29:02,876 is that over the last year when 8383 04:29:02,876 --> 04:29:03,477 you've gone on television or 8384 04:29:03,477 --> 04:29:05,877 spoken to journalists in 8385 04:29:07,948 --> 04:29:08,649 defense of the program, did you 8386 04:29:08,649 --> 04:29:09,316 ever mention to the public or 8387 04:29:09,316 --> 04:29:09,817 to journalists that the api 8388 04:29:09,817 --> 04:29:10,484 could be used for 8389 04:29:10,484 --> 04:29:12,484 administrative purposes like 8390 04:29:13,921 --> 04:29:14,321 holding policemen's conduct 8391 04:29:14,321 --> 04:29:14,755 accountable? 8392 04:29:14,755 --> 04:29:15,289 >> Absolutely. 8393 04:29:15,289 --> 04:29:17,689 Did you ever mention 8394 04:29:20,127 --> 04:29:20,828 the individuals associated with 8395 04:29:20,828 --> 04:29:21,528 those types of cases could 8396 04:29:21,528 --> 04:29:22,960 possibly be caught up in that 8397 04:29:22,960 --> 04:29:24,960 surveillance as well? 8398 04:29:27,670 --> 04:29:29,670 Not specifically, no. 8399 04:29:31,972 --> 04:29:32,640 I have to say that the reading 8400 04:29:32,640 --> 04:29:33,274 of the policy that's been 8401 04:29:33,274 --> 04:29:33,707 pointed out over the last 8402 04:29:33,707 --> 04:29:35,707 several days. 8403 04:29:38,812 --> 04:29:39,480 The position that 8404 04:29:39,480 --> 04:29:40,800 the department has taken on 8405 04:29:40,800 --> 04:29:42,480 that reading I'm utterly 8406 04:29:45,852 --> 04:29:46,554 disappointed and Chief, I 8407 04:29:46,554 --> 04:29:47,220 expected more given how clear 8408 04:29:47,220 --> 04:29:49,620 several council members have 8409 04:29:51,459 --> 04:29:52,159 been about the fears we have 8410 04:29:52,159 --> 04:29:52,793 about this and the trust that 8411 04:29:52,793 --> 04:29:53,494 we put in you not just to 8412 04:29:53,494 --> 04:29:57,940 follow the rules but to see 8413 04:29:57,565 --> 04:29:58,232 the bigger picture of what 8414 04:29:58,232 --> 04:29:58,899 the public expectation was. 8415 04:29:58,899 --> 04:30:03,990 And I think that there is a 8416 04:30:03,237 --> 04:30:04,370 lack of humility in defending a 8417 04:30:04,370 --> 04:30:06,437 vague policy language in 8418 04:30:09,977 --> 04:30:10,511 the media When a labor union is 8419 04:30:10,511 --> 04:30:11,212 asking questions and 8420 04:30:11,212 --> 04:30:11,846 councilmembers are expressing 8421 04:30:11,846 --> 04:30:14,246 how their constituents are 8422 04:30:15,916 --> 04:30:16,450 confused and feel misled by 8423 04:30:16,450 --> 04:30:18,450 the policy language. 8424 04:30:20,454 --> 04:30:21,880 I just have to make one last 8425 04:30:21,880 --> 04:30:24,880 point because my faith in 8426 04:30:25,960 --> 04:30:26,661 the use of this technology is 8427 04:30:26,661 --> 04:30:30,261 so shaken but a lot of 8428 04:30:31,832 --> 04:30:32,466 the commentary today has 8429 04:30:32,466 --> 04:30:33,300 pointed at something else. 8430 04:30:33,300 --> 04:30:36,900 A lot of commentary today was 8431 04:30:38,105 --> 04:30:38,674 focused on the police 8432 04:30:38,674 --> 04:30:39,306 department writ large. 8433 04:30:39,306 --> 04:30:42,306 Chief, I have many more 8434 04:30:44,278 --> 04:30:45,120 questions about how we could 8435 04:30:45,120 --> 04:30:48,612 have allowed for the reading of 8436 04:30:49,884 --> 04:30:50,651 the language to go that far. 8437 04:30:50,651 --> 04:30:51,319 But a lot of the allegations 8438 04:30:51,319 --> 04:30:52,180 about the police department 8439 04:30:52,180 --> 04:30:55,618 writ large today were far from 8440 04:30:55,990 --> 04:30:56,724 true. 8441 04:30:56,724 --> 04:30:57,358 The misuse and misapplication 8442 04:30:57,358 --> 04:30:59,358 through the administrative 8443 04:31:02,296 --> 04:31:02,997 exception doesn't need to be 8444 04:31:02,997 --> 04:31:03,364 villainous for it to be 8445 04:31:03,364 --> 04:31:03,998 improper. 8446 04:31:03,998 --> 04:31:04,698 While I believe there was 8447 04:31:04,698 --> 04:31:07,698 misuse of this technology and 8448 04:31:08,302 --> 04:31:08,902 that accountability means 8449 04:31:08,902 --> 04:31:09,236 removing it from our use 8450 04:31:09,236 --> 04:31:09,971 policy. 8451 04:31:09,971 --> 04:31:13,571 Something was said that I think 8452 04:31:14,508 --> 04:31:15,176 is truly incorrect. 8453 04:31:15,176 --> 04:31:15,810 Someone said and I quote 8454 04:31:15,810 --> 04:31:16,477 The community I come from 8455 04:31:16,477 --> 04:31:19,477 doesn't trust the police and 8456 04:31:20,448 --> 04:31:21,149 they never will. 8457 04:31:21,149 --> 04:31:21,883 That's the end of the quote. 8458 04:31:21,883 --> 04:31:26,830 I think the broad brush of that 8459 04:31:26,821 --> 04:31:27,455 statement and the unqualified 8460 04:31:27,455 --> 04:31:28,122 denunciation of the police 8461 04:31:28,122 --> 04:31:28,823 something I find completely 8462 04:31:28,823 --> 04:31:31,823 unreflective of San Diegans as 8463 04:31:32,930 --> 04:31:32,827 a community even though since 8464 04:31:32,827 --> 04:31:33,628 last Thursday I've had a chorus 8465 04:31:33,628 --> 04:31:37,228 of people say Thank you for 8466 04:31:38,766 --> 04:31:39,434 holding the police department 8467 04:31:39,434 --> 04:31:40,340 accountable on this policy. 8468 04:31:40,340 --> 04:31:40,668 The vast majority of San 8469 04:31:40,668 --> 04:31:43,668 Diegans do approve of our 8470 04:31:44,272 --> 04:31:44,906 police officers because 8471 04:31:44,906 --> 04:31:45,539 the vast, vast majority of 8472 04:31:45,539 --> 04:31:45,873 police officers are great 8473 04:31:45,873 --> 04:31:47,873 people. 8474 04:31:49,543 --> 04:31:50,278 The person that was being 8475 04:31:50,278 --> 04:31:50,979 surveilled for their misconduct 8476 04:31:50,979 --> 04:31:51,679 obviously was not one of them. 8477 04:31:51,679 --> 04:31:54,679 The notion that communities of 8478 04:31:56,383 --> 04:31:57,510 color largely don't trust 8479 04:31:57,510 --> 04:31:57,719 police officers I understand 8480 04:31:57,719 --> 04:32:00,119 their feelings of mistrust. 8481 04:32:02,657 --> 04:32:03,357 But the notion of mistrust of 8482 04:32:03,357 --> 04:32:04,580 police officers writ large is 8483 04:32:04,580 --> 04:32:04,759 belied by the fact that while 8484 04:32:04,759 --> 04:32:07,759 communities of color might not 8485 04:32:07,863 --> 04:32:08,596 have the same levels of 8486 04:32:08,596 --> 04:32:09,297 confidence, the police can help 8487 04:32:09,297 --> 04:32:09,831 them in particular instances. 8488 04:32:09,831 --> 04:32:11,831 Communities of color 8489 04:32:14,269 --> 04:32:14,936 particularly I know in my 8490 04:32:14,936 --> 04:32:15,537 district especially in Linda 8491 04:32:15,537 --> 04:32:16,237 Vista they call 911 when 8492 04:32:16,237 --> 04:32:19,237 they're victims of violence at 8493 04:32:19,707 --> 04:32:20,408 very similar rates to other 8494 04:32:20,408 --> 04:32:21,142 communities because they want 8495 04:32:21,142 --> 04:32:24,142 similar treatment and they want 8496 04:32:26,280 --> 04:32:26,981 protection and they don't want 8497 04:32:26,981 --> 04:32:27,682 to be surveilled by the police 8498 04:32:27,682 --> 04:32:28,490 department when they call 911 8499 04:32:28,490 --> 04:32:30,490 for help. 8500 04:32:31,719 --> 04:32:32,387 My constituents in District 8501 04:32:32,387 --> 04:32:33,121 seven have simultaneously a 8502 04:32:33,121 --> 04:32:35,857 deep level of respect and a 8503 04:32:35,857 --> 04:32:36,558 fair expectation of 8504 04:32:36,558 --> 04:32:38,958 accountability for our police 8505 04:32:42,597 --> 04:32:43,364 and rightfully so. 8506 04:32:43,364 --> 04:32:44,990 Council PRESIDENT By the end of 8507 04:32:44,990 --> 04:32:47,990 my additional three minutes you 8508 04:32:47,469 --> 04:32:48,102 are MAY I borrow two minutes 8509 04:32:48,102 --> 04:32:48,702 from my colleagues please? 8510 04:32:48,702 --> 04:32:49,337 I think everybody burned 8511 04:32:49,337 --> 04:32:52,337 the eight minutes and I'll 8512 04:32:55,143 --> 04:32:55,542 really do the same. 8513 04:32:55,542 --> 04:32:56,311 Yeah. 8514 04:32:56,311 --> 04:32:57,450 All right, I'll wrap it up. 8515 04:32:57,450 --> 04:32:57,545 I only have one and a half. 8516 04:32:57,545 --> 04:32:57,845 Well, six ounces. 8517 04:32:57,845 --> 04:32:59,114 Okay. 8518 04:32:59,114 --> 04:32:59,881 As a former prosecutor, I know 8519 04:32:59,881 --> 04:33:04,810 I couldn't do the job that our 8520 04:33:04,319 --> 04:33:04,986 peace officers do. 8521 04:33:04,986 --> 04:33:05,619 But also as a former 8522 04:33:05,619 --> 04:33:08,619 prosecutor, it's my job to 8523 04:33:09,357 --> 04:33:10,580 prosecute a case fairly and to 8524 04:33:10,580 --> 04:33:10,692 dismiss the case appropriately 8525 04:33:10,692 --> 04:33:11,590 depending on the evidence 8526 04:33:11,590 --> 04:33:11,693 before me. 8527 04:33:11,693 --> 04:33:15,293 And I see my position here 8528 04:33:16,831 --> 04:33:17,163 today largely in that same 8529 04:33:17,163 --> 04:33:17,732 vein. 8530 04:33:17,732 --> 04:33:18,433 Until last week I felt 8531 04:33:18,433 --> 04:33:18,833 confident supporting the alp's 8532 04:33:18,833 --> 04:33:20,833 use policy. 8533 04:33:21,269 --> 04:33:21,936 But with new evidence it became 8534 04:33:21,936 --> 04:33:25,536 my role to dismiss it today. 8535 04:33:27,108 --> 04:33:27,741 And my final point is this. 8536 04:33:27,741 --> 04:33:28,376 That evidence that I and 8537 04:33:28,376 --> 04:33:31,376 members of the public are 8538 04:33:32,881 --> 04:33:33,581 pointing out today relying on 8539 04:33:33,581 --> 04:33:34,215 the evidence to say let's stop 8540 04:33:34,215 --> 04:33:34,950 this usage to protect our 8541 04:33:34,950 --> 04:33:37,853 privacy rights that we all hold 8542 04:33:37,853 --> 04:33:38,619 dear. 8543 04:33:38,619 --> 04:33:39,540 It wasn't uncovered by some 8544 04:33:39,540 --> 04:33:39,788 random person. 8545 04:33:39,788 --> 04:33:42,788 It was uncovered and made 8546 04:33:44,920 --> 04:33:44,693 public by police officers. 8547 04:33:44,693 --> 04:33:45,930 I'll be in support of 8548 04:33:45,930 --> 04:33:45,459 the motion. 8549 04:33:45,459 --> 04:33:47,459 Thank you. 8550 04:33:49,264 --> 04:33:50,310 Council member Campbell. 8551 04:33:50,310 --> 04:33:50,365 Everyone has spoken so I will 8552 04:33:50,365 --> 04:33:52,365 jump in. 8553 04:33:54,702 --> 04:33:55,370 And as everyone knows, someone 8554 04:33:55,370 --> 04:33:58,970 who has voted at least three 8555 04:34:00,175 --> 04:34:00,843 times in support of your who 8556 04:34:00,843 --> 04:34:01,576 has spoken to some of 8557 04:34:01,576 --> 04:34:04,576 the individuals who spoke today 8558 04:34:06,548 --> 04:34:07,149 and or their organizations who 8559 04:34:07,149 --> 04:34:07,883 wanted me to vote no. 8560 04:34:07,883 --> 04:34:10,883 And to my constituents who 8561 04:34:12,454 --> 04:34:13,288 wanted me to vote yes. 8562 04:34:13,288 --> 04:34:13,855 I'm going to take a little bit 8563 04:34:13,855 --> 04:34:14,489 different path than my 8564 04:34:14,489 --> 04:34:16,889 colleagues in my comments. 8565 04:34:18,894 --> 04:34:19,528 What affects one part of our 8566 04:34:19,528 --> 04:34:20,128 city affects District One. 8567 04:34:20,128 --> 04:34:22,597 I thought about this in 8568 04:34:22,597 --> 04:34:23,231 particular last week when two 8569 04:34:23,231 --> 04:34:23,932 news stories broke One uc 8570 04:34:23,932 --> 04:34:26,332 Riverside determined that some 8571 04:34:28,303 --> 04:34:29,370 pollution from the Tijuana 8572 04:34:29,370 --> 04:34:29,738 River Valley migrates northward 8573 04:34:29,738 --> 04:34:30,138 the polluted air off the coast 8574 04:34:30,138 --> 04:34:32,138 of La Hoya. 8575 04:34:33,408 --> 04:34:33,875 The second has been repeated by 8576 04:34:33,875 --> 04:34:34,576 multiple folks. 8577 04:34:34,576 --> 04:34:36,976 The Federal Police Department 8578 04:34:39,280 --> 04:34:39,948 was using a lpr technology to 8579 04:34:39,948 --> 04:34:40,315 investigate their own police 8580 04:34:40,315 --> 04:34:42,315 officers. 8581 04:34:44,920 --> 04:34:45,587 We are all interconnected like 8582 04:34:45,587 --> 04:34:46,200 pollution from the sea on a 8583 04:34:46,200 --> 04:34:46,722 river valley. 8584 04:34:46,722 --> 04:34:49,722 We all face the consequences. 8585 04:34:50,158 --> 04:34:50,893 To those waking up to both 8586 04:34:50,893 --> 04:34:51,593 issues you can no longer ignore 8587 04:34:51,593 --> 04:34:53,993 the fundamentals that underlie 8588 04:34:55,230 --> 04:34:55,863 them. 8589 04:34:55,863 --> 04:34:56,297 They now hit uncomfortably 8590 04:34:56,297 --> 04:34:56,999 close to home. 8591 04:34:56,999 --> 04:34:59,999 Perhaps the awakening by some 8592 04:35:00,501 --> 04:35:01,470 is a good thing. 8593 04:35:01,470 --> 04:35:02,137 However, for me this is not how 8594 04:35:02,137 --> 04:35:02,571 we do public policy or take 8595 04:35:02,571 --> 04:35:04,571 public action. 8596 04:35:07,420 --> 04:35:07,776 One of the many conversations I 8597 04:35:07,776 --> 04:35:11,713 had was about the effect of lpr 8598 04:35:11,713 --> 04:35:12,447 within individual communities. 8599 04:35:12,447 --> 04:35:12,881 Today I reflect differently on 8600 04:35:12,881 --> 04:35:14,881 that context. 8601 04:35:17,786 --> 04:35:18,487 With the national elections 8602 04:35:18,487 --> 04:35:19,221 the real landscape of fear in 8603 04:35:19,221 --> 04:35:22,821 my opinion from those who stalk 8604 04:35:23,192 --> 04:35:23,892 our streets capturing decent 8605 04:35:23,892 --> 04:35:24,426 people, breaking up families, 8606 04:35:24,426 --> 04:35:26,426 snatching children, 8607 04:35:28,564 --> 04:35:29,231 disappearing individuals with 8608 04:35:29,231 --> 04:35:30,320 the national midterm results 8609 04:35:30,320 --> 04:35:33,235 there is now hope hope of not 8610 04:35:33,235 --> 04:35:33,902 having to wait two years, 8611 04:35:33,902 --> 04:35:34,236 perhaps only two months for 8612 04:35:34,236 --> 04:35:34,636 change. 8613 04:35:34,636 --> 04:35:36,636 Real change. 8614 04:35:38,574 --> 04:35:39,174 And perhaps then lives will 8615 04:35:39,174 --> 04:35:42,174 return to some level of 8616 04:35:43,879 --> 04:35:44,713 normalcy With that hope. 8617 04:35:44,713 --> 04:35:45,281 Lpr in my mind can now be 8618 04:35:45,281 --> 04:35:47,281 looked at differently. 8619 04:35:48,918 --> 04:35:49,217 So let me revisit how we got 8620 04:35:49,217 --> 04:35:49,784 here. 8621 04:35:49,784 --> 04:35:52,184 We started in 2023 at 8622 04:35:54,889 --> 04:35:55,324 the assumption of ipr in Smart 8623 04:35:55,324 --> 04:35:55,957 Street Lights. 8624 04:35:55,957 --> 04:35:56,591 My office worked literally 8625 04:35:56,591 --> 04:35:58,991 minutes before the public 8626 04:35:59,395 --> 04:35:59,995 hearing on the use policies to 8627 04:35:59,995 --> 04:36:00,663 make a critical change. 8628 04:36:00,663 --> 04:36:03,663 When the trust ordinance was 8629 04:36:04,733 --> 04:36:05,367 amended we fought for and 8630 04:36:05,367 --> 04:36:05,968 secured that use policies. 8631 04:36:05,968 --> 04:36:06,635 The very underpinning to 8632 04:36:06,635 --> 04:36:09,635 the ordinance would be under 8633 04:36:10,139 --> 04:36:10,873 city Council authority to 8634 04:36:10,873 --> 04:36:13,873 approve, modify or rescind that 8635 04:36:15,144 --> 04:36:15,878 authority was not in 8636 04:36:15,878 --> 04:36:16,612 the original language and there 8637 04:36:16,612 --> 04:36:17,212 was pushback The council should 8638 04:36:17,212 --> 04:36:19,612 not have such authority. 8639 04:36:20,983 --> 04:36:21,517 But as my office saw back then 8640 04:36:21,517 --> 04:36:22,170 and I think everyone 8641 04:36:22,170 --> 04:36:24,170 understands today 8642 04:36:25,787 --> 04:36:26,388 implementation with no controls 8643 04:36:26,388 --> 04:36:27,323 is a blank check. 8644 04:36:27,323 --> 04:36:31,523 As my colleague said a year ago 8645 04:36:31,760 --> 04:36:32,528 I joined Council PRESIDENT Pro 8646 04:36:32,528 --> 04:36:32,928 Tem Lee in calling for Flock to 8647 04:36:32,928 --> 04:36:34,928 be replaced. 8648 04:36:36,899 --> 04:36:37,500 We believed then the issue was 8649 04:36:37,500 --> 04:36:37,900 not the technology but 8650 04:36:37,900 --> 04:36:38,567 the vendor. 8651 04:36:38,567 --> 04:36:39,235 We approve the annual report 8652 04:36:39,235 --> 04:36:42,337 and use policy in good faith 8653 04:36:42,337 --> 04:36:42,972 with the department would 8654 04:36:42,972 --> 04:36:43,672 pursue a different vendor. 8655 04:36:43,672 --> 04:36:47,242 A year has passed and has been 8656 04:36:47,242 --> 04:36:47,777 said We have not identified an 8657 04:36:47,777 --> 04:36:48,411 alternative vendor. 8658 04:36:48,411 --> 04:36:52,110 We have not even issued a 8659 04:36:52,214 --> 04:36:52,882 request for information. 8660 04:36:52,882 --> 04:36:53,215 A critical step in finding 8661 04:36:53,215 --> 04:36:53,783 vendors. 8662 04:36:53,783 --> 04:36:56,783 I have been briefed on 8663 04:36:57,860 --> 04:36:57,887 the numerous improvements that 8664 04:36:57,887 --> 04:36:58,521 are made in a lpr operations 8665 04:36:58,521 --> 04:37:01,521 over the past three years. 8666 04:37:02,792 --> 04:37:03,292 The crime solved and that has 8667 04:37:03,292 --> 04:37:04,260 all been laudable. 8668 04:37:04,260 --> 04:37:07,626 Perhaps we indeed have the most 8669 04:37:08,300 --> 04:37:08,631 secure operation anywhere in 8670 04:37:08,631 --> 04:37:09,231 the country and the best 8671 04:37:09,231 --> 04:37:12,231 security of the data but 8672 04:37:12,601 --> 04:37:13,235 frankly the best in the nation 8673 04:37:13,235 --> 04:37:16,235 is not always good enough 8674 04:37:17,940 --> 04:37:18,708 especially when the climate of 8675 04:37:18,708 --> 04:37:19,175 our nation is full of cruelty, 8676 04:37:19,175 --> 04:37:21,175 danger and fear. 8677 04:37:22,712 --> 04:37:23,412 We had the burden of proof. 8678 04:37:23,412 --> 04:37:23,979 We gave every opportunity to 8679 04:37:23,979 --> 04:37:26,379 meet that burden But 8680 04:37:28,317 --> 04:37:29,510 collectively we fell short. 8681 04:37:29,510 --> 04:37:29,752 As early as last summer I 8682 04:37:29,752 --> 04:37:32,752 recognized that this tool was 8683 04:37:33,622 --> 04:37:34,690 no longer sustainable. 8684 04:37:34,690 --> 04:37:37,526 This past AUGUST I shared with 8685 04:37:37,526 --> 04:37:38,226 my constituents that it was 8686 04:37:38,226 --> 04:37:40,626 5050 whether it would survive. 8687 04:37:42,665 --> 04:37:43,332 I will admit that I began 8688 04:37:43,332 --> 04:37:44,330 looking for alternatives or 8689 04:37:44,330 --> 04:37:44,634 variations that could preserve 8690 04:37:44,634 --> 04:37:47,340 the positive aspects of 8691 04:37:47,236 --> 04:37:47,669 the technology while minimizing 8692 04:37:47,669 --> 04:37:48,371 the downside. 8693 04:37:48,371 --> 04:37:49,710 Could be relocate the devices 8694 04:37:49,710 --> 04:37:51,471 from neighborhoods that didn't 8695 04:37:52,708 --> 04:37:53,443 want them To those who did 8696 04:37:53,443 --> 04:37:56,443 refrain I frequently heard that 8697 04:37:57,479 --> 04:37:58,800 would be costly and would not 8698 04:37:58,800 --> 04:37:58,548 be an effective use of 8699 04:37:58,548 --> 04:38:00,548 the technology. 8700 04:38:02,184 --> 04:38:02,885 And for me such relocations 8701 04:38:02,885 --> 04:38:05,285 also raised ethical questions. 8702 04:38:06,621 --> 04:38:07,323 In the past few weeks I thought 8703 04:38:07,323 --> 04:38:07,957 others might come forward with 8704 04:38:07,957 --> 04:38:08,291 alternatives but none have 8705 04:38:08,291 --> 04:38:10,291 emerged. 8706 04:38:11,994 --> 04:38:12,662 To be clear, I see no path in 8707 04:38:12,662 --> 04:38:13,262 preserving a law enforcement 8708 04:38:13,262 --> 04:38:16,262 tool that wants to meet 8709 04:38:17,166 --> 04:38:17,833 the needs of San Diegans and 8710 04:38:17,833 --> 04:38:20,833 yet cannot address very real 8711 04:38:22,400 --> 04:38:22,804 and very concerning issues. 8712 04:38:22,804 --> 04:38:23,439 So my colleagues have delved 8713 04:38:23,439 --> 04:38:26,439 into the details of what 8714 04:38:26,676 --> 04:38:26,976 rescinding the use of policy 8715 04:38:26,976 --> 04:38:28,976 means. 8716 04:38:31,113 --> 04:38:31,814 And I will interject that for 8717 04:38:31,814 --> 04:38:34,750 depending on what action we 8718 04:38:34,750 --> 04:38:35,418 take tonight, whether it is 8719 04:38:35,418 --> 04:38:37,418 the 750,000 associated with 8720 04:38:40,723 --> 04:38:41,490 the lpr and will cost or we 8721 04:38:41,490 --> 04:38:44,426 also vote to remove the cameras 8722 04:38:44,426 --> 04:38:45,227 and its annual total of 2 8723 04:38:45,227 --> 04:38:48,640 million it is not going to help 8724 04:38:48,640 --> 04:38:48,830 us in the f y 27 budget. 8725 04:38:48,830 --> 04:38:52,430 It will be something that we 8726 04:38:55,380 --> 04:38:59,742 can talk about for f y 28 So we 8727 04:38:59,742 --> 04:39:00,676 need to wipe the slate clean. 8728 04:39:00,676 --> 04:39:04,276 And to me that means rescinding 8729 04:39:04,580 --> 04:39:07,580 both Alper and Smart Street. 8730 04:39:09,118 --> 04:39:09,685 >> That means rescinding two 8731 04:39:09,685 --> 04:39:10,386 use policies tonight. 8732 04:39:10,386 --> 04:39:12,786 And my colleague Councilmember 8733 04:39:13,990 --> 04:39:14,490 Foster recounted what happened 8734 04:39:14,490 --> 04:39:15,900 with the cameras. 8735 04:39:15,900 --> 04:39:18,690 Back in the day I still 8736 04:39:19,495 --> 04:39:20,162 remember that and that some of 8737 04:39:20,162 --> 04:39:20,863 the things that you inherit 8738 04:39:20,863 --> 04:39:23,863 that you were not responsible 8739 04:39:24,100 --> 04:39:24,767 for. 8740 04:39:24,767 --> 04:39:27,767 But it's a technology that 8741 04:39:28,538 --> 04:39:29,172 shares one device even with 8742 04:39:29,172 --> 04:39:29,706 the ability to deactivate 8743 04:39:29,706 --> 04:39:31,706 the flight cameras. 8744 04:39:33,109 --> 04:39:33,809 I believe we must start fresh 8745 04:39:33,809 --> 04:39:37,409 and show our residents we are 8746 04:39:38,347 --> 04:39:38,648 taking these concerns seriously 8747 04:39:38,648 --> 04:39:39,516 . 8748 04:39:39,516 --> 04:39:42,819 To me the conversation is over. 8749 04:39:42,819 --> 04:39:43,352 All that is left is 8750 04:39:43,352 --> 04:39:45,352 the concluding vote. 8751 04:39:47,757 --> 04:39:48,391 So with that I appreciate 8752 04:39:48,391 --> 04:39:49,910 the mayor and the mayor's 8753 04:39:49,910 --> 04:39:51,961 office that prepared for this 8754 04:39:51,961 --> 04:39:52,695 moment. 8755 04:39:52,695 --> 04:39:53,396 I think even the police 8756 04:39:53,396 --> 04:39:55,796 department in your abbreviated 8757 04:39:56,933 --> 04:39:57,600 presentation this afternoon 8758 04:39:57,600 --> 04:39:58,234 recognized where we were at 8759 04:39:58,234 --> 04:40:00,634 given the preponderance of 8760 04:40:02,104 --> 04:40:04,504 council members going forward. 8761 04:40:05,675 --> 04:40:06,542 I want to be confident that we 8762 04:40:06,542 --> 04:40:07,244 can do that 30 day notice that 8763 04:40:07,244 --> 04:40:10,244 we can trigger the provisions 8764 04:40:10,379 --> 04:40:11,470 that are already in 8765 04:40:11,470 --> 04:40:14,470 the contract with both Alper 8766 04:40:15,785 --> 04:40:16,519 which is the item that we're 8767 04:40:16,519 --> 04:40:17,252 first going to vote on and I 8768 04:40:17,252 --> 04:40:19,889 hope my colleagues will join us 8769 04:40:19,889 --> 04:40:20,456 in also voting to rescind 8770 04:40:20,456 --> 04:40:20,824 the smart streetlight 8771 04:40:20,824 --> 04:40:21,191 ordinance. 8772 04:40:21,191 --> 04:40:23,191 Excuse me. 8773 04:40:24,661 --> 04:40:25,428 Just a policy as well. 8774 04:40:25,428 --> 04:40:25,762 Let's make this a clean sweep 8775 04:40:25,762 --> 04:40:27,762 tonight. 8776 04:40:29,799 --> 04:40:30,166 So with that I'll conclude my 8777 04:40:30,166 --> 04:40:32,166 comments. 8778 04:40:34,337 --> 04:40:34,971 We have a motion by 8779 04:40:34,971 --> 04:40:35,638 Councilmember Foster and a 8780 04:40:35,638 --> 04:40:38,380 second by Councilmember Eli 8781 04:40:38,808 --> 04:40:40,808 Rivera that essentially 8782 04:40:43,947 --> 04:40:44,447 rescinds the Alper Youth policy 8783 04:40:44,447 --> 04:40:45,314 sub Item b. 8784 04:40:45,314 --> 04:40:48,618 With that no one else in 8785 04:40:48,618 --> 04:40:48,985 the lights please call 8786 04:40:48,985 --> 04:40:49,719 the vote. 8787 04:40:49,719 --> 04:40:52,719 >> I started the voting system. 8788 04:40:58,795 --> 04:40:59,529 Please cast your vote and that 8789 04:40:59,529 --> 04:41:01,929 passes unanimously with council 8790 04:41:02,699 --> 04:41:03,330 member Campbell and Ron Wilbert 8791 04:41:03,330 --> 04:41:03,432 absent. 8792 04:41:03,432 --> 04:41:05,432 Oh okay. 8793 04:41:07,571 --> 04:41:07,871 We still have more business to 8794 04:41:07,871 --> 04:41:08,604 do. 8795 04:41:08,604 --> 04:41:11,604 We'll go back to Councilmember 8796 04:41:12,750 --> 04:41:12,643 Foster for your next motion. 8797 04:41:12,643 --> 04:41:14,643 Yes, Thank you. 8798 04:41:17,346 --> 04:41:18,480 Council PRESIDENT And I do 8799 04:41:18,480 --> 04:41:21,480 appreciate the comments of all 8800 04:41:21,818 --> 04:41:22,118 of my colleagues on the first 8801 04:41:22,118 --> 04:41:24,118 item. 8802 04:41:25,722 --> 04:41:26,423 Um and so with that my next 8803 04:41:26,423 --> 04:41:28,823 motion as previously discussed 8804 04:41:30,927 --> 04:41:35,127 I would like to a motion to 8805 04:41:35,265 --> 04:41:36,650 bifurcate sub item a and to um 8806 04:41:36,650 --> 04:41:36,767 put us in a position to vote 8807 04:41:36,767 --> 04:41:37,100 separately on the smart street 8808 04:41:37,100 --> 04:41:39,100 lights. 8809 04:41:44,841 --> 04:41:45,542 Use policy as sub item c. 8810 04:41:45,542 --> 04:41:45,976 >> That concludes my motion. 8811 04:41:45,976 --> 04:41:47,976 Thank you sir. 8812 04:41:49,946 --> 04:41:50,646 So as shown on the screen we 8813 04:41:50,646 --> 04:41:53,646 have a motion by Councilmember 8814 04:41:54,150 --> 04:41:54,918 Foster to bifurcate sub item a 8815 04:41:54,918 --> 04:41:58,518 to vote separately on the smart 8816 04:42:00,424 --> 04:42:00,758 street lights use policy as sub 8817 04:42:00,758 --> 04:42:01,591 item c. 8818 04:42:01,591 --> 04:42:04,428 And we'll go to Councilmember 8819 04:42:04,428 --> 04:42:04,961 Ella Rivera to just second 8820 04:42:04,961 --> 04:42:05,329 the Motion council. 8821 04:42:05,329 --> 04:42:07,329 All right. 8822 04:42:07,497 --> 04:42:10,600 So we have a second and for my 8823 04:42:10,600 --> 04:42:11,301 colleagues we would circle back 8824 04:42:11,301 --> 04:42:12,200 with the third motion to vote 8825 04:42:12,200 --> 04:42:15,973 on the balance of the sub item 8826 04:42:15,973 --> 04:42:16,640 a So not seeing anybody on 8827 04:42:16,640 --> 04:42:19,400 the lights of Councilmember 8828 04:42:20,430 --> 04:42:20,911 Moran. 8829 04:42:20,911 --> 04:42:21,311 Thank you and thank you for 8830 04:42:21,311 --> 04:42:23,311 this motion. 8831 04:42:24,714 --> 04:42:25,416 I just want to be public. 8832 04:42:25,416 --> 04:42:25,916 I've always been supportive of 8833 04:42:25,916 --> 04:42:27,916 the street lights. 8834 04:42:28,986 --> 04:42:29,386 I've always made that 8835 04:42:29,386 --> 04:42:30,120 distinction. 8836 04:42:30,120 --> 04:42:30,721 So I will not be supporting 8837 04:42:30,721 --> 04:42:33,721 the motion on the floor. 8838 04:42:33,791 --> 04:42:34,258 Thank you. 8839 04:42:34,258 --> 04:42:34,991 All right. 8840 04:42:34,991 --> 04:42:35,726 Thank you, Councilmember Moreno 8841 04:42:35,726 --> 04:42:39,129 with that Again, we have a 8842 04:42:39,129 --> 04:42:39,830 motion by Councilmember Foster, 8843 04:42:39,830 --> 04:42:40,531 a second by Councilmember Eli 8844 04:42:40,531 --> 04:42:43,531 Rivera to bifurcate some item 8845 04:42:43,567 --> 04:42:44,267 made to vote separately on 8846 04:42:44,267 --> 04:42:47,838 the smart street lights to use 8847 04:42:47,838 --> 04:42:48,405 policy as sub item c clerk 8848 04:42:48,405 --> 04:42:50,708 Please call the vote. 8849 04:42:50,708 --> 04:42:53,708 I started the voting system. 8850 04:43:01,218 --> 04:43:02,850 Please cast your vote that 8851 04:43:02,850 --> 04:43:04,485 passes 6 to 1 with Councilor 8852 04:43:07,190 --> 04:43:07,724 Miranda voting no and Campbell 8853 04:43:07,724 --> 04:43:10,124 and vote are absent. 8854 04:43:10,327 --> 04:43:10,995 So for those of you this is how 8855 04:43:10,995 --> 04:43:11,628 we navigate the bureaucracy. 8856 04:43:11,628 --> 04:43:14,280 Okay Council member Foster 8857 04:43:15,990 --> 04:43:15,499 again. 8858 04:43:15,499 --> 04:43:15,865 Yes. 8859 04:43:15,865 --> 04:43:17,865 Thank you. 8860 04:43:24,408 --> 04:43:25,420 So now I will move forward with 8861 04:43:25,420 --> 04:43:28,420 the third action which is 8862 04:43:28,612 --> 04:43:29,380 moving sub some item a and I 8863 04:43:29,380 --> 04:43:32,980 will say is the balance of 50 8864 04:43:33,716 --> 04:43:34,518 to use policies So with that I 8865 04:43:34,518 --> 04:43:35,185 would like to make a motion to 8866 04:43:35,185 --> 04:43:37,185 approve staff recommendation 8867 04:43:38,355 --> 04:43:38,989 for sub item a authorizing 8868 04:43:38,989 --> 04:43:40,989 the approved 52 department 8869 04:43:42,793 --> 04:43:43,360 surveillance use policies to 8870 04:43:43,360 --> 04:43:44,950 remain in effect under 8871 04:43:44,950 --> 04:43:46,495 the transparent responsible use 8872 04:43:47,498 --> 04:43:48,232 of surveillance technology 8873 04:43:48,232 --> 04:43:51,232 known as trust ordinance with 8874 04:43:52,435 --> 04:43:53,104 modifications as identified. 8875 04:43:53,104 --> 04:43:53,770 I'm sorry excuse me. 8876 04:43:53,770 --> 04:43:56,170 The Council further requests 8877 04:43:57,374 --> 04:43:58,740 that is decision to modify 8878 04:43:58,740 --> 04:44:00,474 the unmanned aircraft systems 8879 04:44:02,413 --> 04:44:03,130 us surveillance use policy 8880 04:44:03,130 --> 04:44:03,750 identified in the annual 8881 04:44:03,750 --> 04:44:04,448 surveillance report be analyzed 8882 04:44:04,448 --> 04:44:07,448 by the city's management team 8883 04:44:07,617 --> 04:44:08,118 for Labor relations to 8884 04:44:08,118 --> 04:44:08,752 determine whether 8885 04:44:08,752 --> 04:44:09,487 the modification requires 8886 04:44:09,487 --> 04:44:12,487 notice to the city's recognized 8887 04:44:12,723 --> 04:44:13,323 employee organizations and 8888 04:44:13,323 --> 04:44:15,323 opportunity to negotiate 8889 04:44:17,361 --> 04:44:17,961 the bargaining impacts of 8890 04:44:17,961 --> 04:44:18,595 the modifications under 8891 04:44:18,595 --> 04:44:21,595 the Myers melius Brown Act 8892 04:44:22,433 --> 04:44:22,799 Brown Act if notice is 8893 04:44:22,799 --> 04:44:23,467 required. 8894 04:44:23,467 --> 04:44:24,201 The Council further request 8895 04:44:24,201 --> 04:44:27,201 that the city's management team 8896 04:44:27,404 --> 04:44:28,104 provide the required notice and 8897 04:44:28,104 --> 04:44:28,706 return to council at a later 8898 04:44:28,706 --> 04:44:31,706 date if there are any 8899 04:44:32,108 --> 04:44:32,710 bargaining impacts that need to 8900 04:44:32,710 --> 04:44:33,343 be addressed by council. 8901 04:44:33,343 --> 04:44:35,743 That concludes my motion. 8902 04:44:37,140 --> 04:44:37,748 All right. 8903 04:44:37,748 --> 04:44:38,482 Thank you Council member Foster 8904 04:44:38,482 --> 04:44:41,485 And again in short order it's a 8905 04:44:41,485 --> 04:44:42,119 motion to approve the balance 8906 04:44:42,119 --> 04:44:44,519 of the surveillance use 8907 04:44:47,758 --> 04:44:48,493 policies in sub item a and will 8908 04:44:48,493 --> 04:44:49,160 go to council member Eli Rivera 8909 04:44:49,160 --> 04:44:51,295 to second council PRESIDENT. 8910 04:44:51,295 --> 04:44:52,290 All right so we have a motion 8911 04:44:52,290 --> 04:44:52,763 by COUNCILMAN Foster, a second 8912 04:44:52,763 --> 04:44:55,332 by council member Eli Rivera to 8913 04:44:55,332 --> 04:44:56,000 approve the balance of the 52 8914 04:44:56,000 --> 04:44:58,400 surveillance use policies in 8915 04:45:01,772 --> 04:45:02,473 sub item a I don't see anybody 8916 04:45:02,473 --> 04:45:02,906 on the lights so Clerk please 8917 04:45:02,906 --> 04:45:03,674 call the vote. 8918 04:45:03,674 --> 04:45:04,700 >> I'm sorry of the voting 8919 04:45:04,700 --> 04:45:06,700 system. 8920 04:45:08,479 --> 04:45:12,790 Please cast your vote and that 8921 04:45:12,984 --> 04:45:13,584 passes unanimously 7 to 0 with 8922 04:45:13,584 --> 04:45:13,917 Campbell and Van Wilpert 8923 04:45:13,917 --> 04:45:15,917 absent. 8924 04:45:16,921 --> 04:45:17,622 All right We'll go back once 8925 04:45:17,622 --> 04:45:20,622 and final time to council 8926 04:45:22,126 --> 04:45:25,126 member Foster Thank you Council 8927 04:45:26,931 --> 04:45:27,531 PRESIDENT And for last action 8928 04:45:27,531 --> 04:45:30,531 this evening And again I 8929 04:45:31,602 --> 04:45:32,336 appreciate all the comments of 8930 04:45:32,336 --> 04:45:35,336 my colleagues is regarding some 8931 04:45:36,908 --> 04:45:39,908 items see smart street lights 8932 04:45:41,812 --> 04:45:45,412 and lastly persue it to San 8933 04:45:45,516 --> 04:45:46,250 Diego Municipal Code sections 8934 04:45:46,250 --> 04:45:46,918 210. 0106I would like to motion 8935 04:45:46,918 --> 04:45:49,918 to rescind the smart street 8936 04:45:50,488 --> 04:45:51,155 lights surveillance use policy. 8937 04:45:51,155 --> 04:45:54,155 The Council request that his 8938 04:45:55,326 --> 04:45:56,260 decision to rescind the Smart 8939 04:45:56,260 --> 04:45:56,761 street light surveillance use 8940 04:45:56,761 --> 04:45:59,530 policy identified in the annual 8941 04:45:59,530 --> 04:46:00,231 surveillance report be analyzed 8942 04:46:00,231 --> 04:46:00,798 by the city's management team 8943 04:46:00,798 --> 04:46:01,298 for labor relations to 8944 04:46:01,298 --> 04:46:03,298 determine whether 8945 04:46:04,535 --> 04:46:05,136 the rescission requires notice 8946 04:46:05,136 --> 04:46:05,770 to the city's recognized 8947 04:46:05,770 --> 04:46:07,770 employee organizations an 8948 04:46:09,574 --> 04:46:10,275 opportunity to negotiate 8949 04:46:10,275 --> 04:46:13,275 the bargaining bill Impacts of 8950 04:46:14,545 --> 04:46:15,313 the rescission under the Myers 8951 04:46:15,313 --> 04:46:18,913 Mills Brown Act if notice is 8952 04:46:19,116 --> 04:46:19,850 required, the Council further 8953 04:46:19,850 --> 04:46:20,485 requests that city's management 8954 04:46:20,485 --> 04:46:21,180 team provide the required 8955 04:46:21,180 --> 04:46:23,418 notice and return to 8956 04:46:24,288 --> 04:46:24,889 the council at a later date if 8957 04:46:24,889 --> 04:46:25,590 there are any bargaining 8958 04:46:25,590 --> 04:46:28,590 impacts that need to be 8959 04:46:29,160 --> 04:46:31,160 addressed by council. 8960 04:46:33,698 --> 04:46:33,998 That concludes my final motion 8961 04:46:33,998 --> 04:46:34,399 . 8962 04:46:34,399 --> 04:46:35,166 All right. 8963 04:46:35,166 --> 04:46:35,900 So we have a motion by 8964 04:46:35,900 --> 04:46:38,300 Councilmember Foster to rescind 8965 04:46:38,502 --> 04:46:39,103 the smart streetlight 8966 04:46:39,103 --> 04:46:39,871 surveillance use policy. 8967 04:46:39,871 --> 04:46:42,871 We'll go to Councilmember Eli 8968 04:46:43,641 --> 04:46:46,641 Rivera start by second in 8969 04:46:47,612 --> 04:46:48,313 Council member Foster's Motion 8970 04:46:48,313 --> 04:46:50,713 This question's been somewhat 8971 04:46:52,917 --> 04:46:53,718 touched upon but I think it's I 8972 04:46:53,718 --> 04:46:54,485 want to dig into it just a 8973 04:46:54,485 --> 04:46:57,522 little bit more on this issue 8974 04:46:57,522 --> 04:46:58,122 and it's the way that 8975 04:46:58,122 --> 04:47:00,522 the policy decisions of 8976 04:47:02,160 --> 04:47:05,160 the Council will be discussed 8977 04:47:07,432 --> 04:47:07,832 publicly if you do depending on 8978 04:47:07,832 --> 04:47:09,832 the outcome. 8979 04:47:11,970 --> 04:47:12,671 But actually kind of regardless 8980 04:47:12,671 --> 04:47:16,271 of the outcome And I'm trying 8981 04:47:21,246 --> 04:47:22,460 to understand the way that in a 8982 04:47:22,460 --> 04:47:26,183 lot of it's in focus on on 8983 04:47:26,183 --> 04:47:26,817 Alpers but the reality is is 8984 04:47:26,817 --> 04:47:27,485 that the smart streetlight 8985 04:47:27,485 --> 04:47:29,485 conversation sounded almost 8986 04:47:31,389 --> 04:47:32,900 identical and and was nearly 8987 04:47:32,900 --> 04:47:32,790 identical even in the Privacy 8988 04:47:32,790 --> 04:47:34,790 Advisory Board recommendations 8989 04:47:36,194 --> 04:47:38,194 at the beginning. 8990 04:47:40,598 --> 04:47:41,399 And so this is actually more 8991 04:47:41,399 --> 04:47:42,670 for cota than for anyone else 8992 04:47:42,670 --> 04:47:45,667 or maybe Bethany I don't I 8993 04:47:50,275 --> 04:47:50,975 don't know but what is city's 8994 04:47:50,975 --> 04:47:53,975 policy on the policy advocacy 8995 04:47:58,160 --> 04:47:58,324 that is done within departments 8996 04:47:58,324 --> 04:48:00,324 ? 8997 04:48:03,210 --> 04:48:03,755 I'm trying to get the question 8998 04:48:03,755 --> 04:48:06,155 being department advocating for 8999 04:48:08,360 --> 04:48:09,600 their own policies or what 9000 04:48:09,600 --> 04:48:09,461 items they're bringing forward 9001 04:48:09,461 --> 04:48:10,161 to council. 9002 04:48:10,161 --> 04:48:12,497 Is that what you're referring 9003 04:48:12,497 --> 04:48:13,532 to Essentially Yeah. 9004 04:48:13,532 --> 04:48:17,350 What's the what's like the flow 9005 04:48:17,350 --> 04:48:20,635 of the directional flow of how 9006 04:48:21,673 --> 04:48:22,440 that works? 9007 04:48:22,440 --> 04:48:23,141 I don't think there is a 9008 04:48:23,141 --> 04:48:23,741 prescribed policy that either 9009 04:48:23,741 --> 04:48:26,141 prohibits or directs how 9010 04:48:26,745 --> 04:48:27,378 departments essentially drum up 9011 04:48:27,378 --> 04:48:27,679 support for their various 9012 04:48:27,679 --> 04:48:29,679 items. 9013 04:48:31,316 --> 04:48:31,917 I think every department has a 9014 04:48:31,917 --> 04:48:32,617 whole differing list of 9015 04:48:32,617 --> 04:48:35,170 stakeholders across the board 9016 04:48:36,220 --> 04:48:36,922 and how they choose to activate 9017 04:48:36,922 --> 04:48:37,488 that I think is sometimes done 9018 04:48:37,488 --> 04:48:39,488 in consultation with 9019 04:48:40,592 --> 04:48:41,293 the Council or the mayor's 9020 04:48:41,293 --> 04:48:42,260 office oftentimes or sometimes 9021 04:48:42,260 --> 04:48:45,260 done with their advisory boards 9022 04:48:45,864 --> 04:48:46,798 or they're just on their own. 9023 04:48:46,798 --> 04:48:50,768 But I don't think there is a 9024 04:48:50,768 --> 04:48:51,469 prescribed policy that dictates 9025 04:48:51,469 --> 04:48:52,204 or directs how departments are 9026 04:48:52,204 --> 04:48:52,837 supposed or not supposed to act 9027 04:48:52,837 --> 04:48:54,837 or engage. 9028 04:48:58,209 --> 04:48:59,440 Got it. 9029 04:48:59,440 --> 04:48:59,678 And I want to make sure that 9030 04:48:59,678 --> 04:49:02,678 I'm clear about this part. 9031 04:49:03,480 --> 04:49:06,480 I think it's important that 9032 04:49:08,286 --> 04:49:08,987 experts in our departments have 9033 04:49:08,987 --> 04:49:11,987 the opportunity to share their 9034 04:49:12,391 --> 04:49:15,391 perspective on what the impact 9035 04:49:17,328 --> 04:49:17,996 of policy decisions will be. 9036 04:49:17,996 --> 04:49:18,730 But I think there's a 9037 04:49:18,730 --> 04:49:21,730 difference between that here in 9038 04:49:25,304 --> 04:49:28,304 a policy venue and departments 9039 04:49:30,676 --> 04:49:34,276 going on campaigns to achieve a 9040 04:49:35,680 --> 04:49:36,381 desired policy outcome And I 9041 04:49:36,381 --> 04:49:36,782 worry about that for a couple 9042 04:49:36,782 --> 04:49:37,549 of reasons. 9043 04:49:37,549 --> 04:49:40,786 One, when it comes to public 9044 04:49:40,786 --> 04:49:41,553 safety, inevitably what that 9045 04:49:41,553 --> 04:49:44,553 leads to is people in 9046 04:49:46,191 --> 04:49:46,892 the public being told that if 9047 04:49:46,892 --> 04:49:49,610 the council makes a different 9048 04:49:49,610 --> 04:49:49,694 policy decision then no one 9049 04:49:49,694 --> 04:49:52,940 that the police department 9050 04:49:52,864 --> 04:49:56,464 wants they will be less safe 9051 04:49:57,670 --> 04:49:58,537 and they should be scared. 9052 04:49:58,537 --> 04:50:02,137 That's not how we make people 9053 04:50:02,607 --> 04:50:04,607 feel safe. 9054 04:50:07,412 --> 04:50:08,146 >> And two, I think it creates 9055 04:50:08,146 --> 04:50:10,546 a appearance of disorganization 9056 04:50:12,151 --> 04:50:12,985 and chaos with the city. 9057 04:50:12,985 --> 04:50:15,985 We are the policymaking body. 9058 04:50:16,155 --> 04:50:19,755 There's a role to play for 9059 04:50:21,526 --> 04:50:22,194 departments in providing 9060 04:50:22,194 --> 04:50:22,894 recommendations, expertise. 9061 04:50:22,894 --> 04:50:25,931 There's a role to play for 9062 04:50:25,931 --> 04:50:26,899 the mayor in that process. 9063 04:50:26,899 --> 04:50:29,899 But we're the policymaking body 9064 04:50:31,700 --> 04:50:31,770 and at the end of the day 9065 04:50:31,770 --> 04:50:35,370 the job on the operation side 9066 04:50:36,275 --> 04:50:39,875 is to implement and to perform 9067 04:50:40,346 --> 04:50:41,113 the job. 9068 04:50:41,113 --> 04:50:45,313 And so I want the council to 9069 04:50:47,386 --> 04:50:48,200 have an eyes wide open 9070 04:50:48,200 --> 04:50:50,420 understanding of what this 9071 04:50:52,524 --> 04:50:52,958 would look like if we make 9072 04:50:52,958 --> 04:50:53,625 the decision. 9073 04:50:53,625 --> 04:50:53,993 I'm supportive of the motion 9074 04:50:53,993 --> 04:50:55,993 obviously. 9075 04:50:56,862 --> 04:50:57,529 Should we expect a public 9076 04:50:57,529 --> 04:50:58,263 information campaign against 9077 04:50:58,263 --> 04:51:00,663 the decision that's potentially 9078 04:51:01,733 --> 04:51:02,340 going to be made by the council 9079 04:51:02,340 --> 04:51:02,668 today? 9080 04:51:02,668 --> 04:51:03,336 Should we expect a public 9081 04:51:03,336 --> 04:51:05,736 information campaign if this 9082 04:51:06,972 --> 04:51:07,673 motion is not successful but we 9083 04:51:07,673 --> 04:51:10,673 continue the effort to cancel 9084 04:51:12,110 --> 04:51:15,611 as well a smart city contract 9085 04:51:16,648 --> 04:51:17,383 but what should we expect? 9086 04:51:17,383 --> 04:51:18,500 Good evening Councilmember Ella 9087 04:51:18,500 --> 04:51:18,751 Rivera, Bethany Biggs Chief 9088 04:51:18,751 --> 04:51:21,653 Operating Officer What you can 9089 04:51:21,653 --> 04:51:22,321 expect is the facts coming from 9090 04:51:22,321 --> 04:51:22,655 operations as subject matter 9091 04:51:22,655 --> 04:51:24,655 experts. 9092 04:51:26,240 --> 04:51:26,625 The facts will come from 9093 04:51:26,625 --> 04:51:27,326 operations and with 9094 04:51:27,326 --> 04:51:28,270 the establishment of the Chief 9095 04:51:28,270 --> 04:51:30,427 Operating officers office and 9096 04:51:30,763 --> 04:51:31,464 my role what you can expect is 9097 04:51:31,464 --> 04:51:32,197 that any one of our teams 9098 04:51:32,197 --> 04:51:34,597 including the police department 9099 04:51:35,434 --> 04:51:36,235 will be speaking from a factual 9100 04:51:36,235 --> 04:51:39,839 basis and that will be what we 9101 04:51:39,839 --> 04:51:40,339 the expectation of we coming 9102 04:51:40,339 --> 04:51:41,730 out of my office. 9103 04:51:41,730 --> 04:51:43,473 >> I appreciate that Bethany 9104 04:51:43,942 --> 04:51:48,142 and I do really hope that that 9105 04:51:48,180 --> 04:51:49,480 is the case. 9106 04:51:49,480 --> 04:51:52,480 An enormous amount of resources 9107 04:51:53,686 --> 04:51:54,387 are provided to the police 9108 04:51:54,387 --> 04:51:56,787 department to communicate and 9109 04:51:58,570 --> 04:51:58,757 it was incredibly frustrating 9110 04:51:58,757 --> 04:52:01,260 over the past several weeks to 9111 04:52:01,260 --> 04:52:04,260 see those resources being put 9112 04:52:06,332 --> 04:52:09,332 into a policy argument with 9113 04:52:09,602 --> 04:52:10,202 this council And it wasn't 9114 04:52:10,202 --> 04:52:10,570 the first time that that 9115 04:52:10,570 --> 04:52:11,170 happened. 9116 04:52:11,170 --> 04:52:11,804 Two months ago Councilor 9117 04:52:11,804 --> 04:52:14,204 Whitburn brought forward a 9118 04:52:15,107 --> 04:52:15,807 policy change with respect to 9119 04:52:15,807 --> 04:52:19,780 towing I believe was an eight 9120 04:52:19,780 --> 04:52:19,778 one decision and that decision 9121 04:52:19,778 --> 04:52:20,379 was immediately kind of 9122 04:52:20,379 --> 04:52:22,779 dismissed by the police 9123 04:52:27,620 --> 04:52:28,254 department and again if we're 9124 04:52:28,254 --> 04:52:29,880 going to get the public to 9125 04:52:29,880 --> 04:52:32,688 trust us at a certain point 9126 04:52:35,961 --> 04:52:36,629 we're going to need to look 9127 04:52:36,629 --> 04:52:37,362 like we're going in the same 9128 04:52:37,362 --> 04:52:38,300 direction And that doesn't mean 9129 04:52:38,300 --> 04:52:40,366 we can't debate it up here. 9130 04:52:40,366 --> 04:52:41,000 But once the decision is made, 9131 04:52:41,000 --> 04:52:41,634 the decision is made And I 9132 04:52:41,634 --> 04:52:42,268 certainly don't think it's 9133 04:52:42,268 --> 04:52:45,268 useful to have fact versus 9134 04:52:45,371 --> 04:52:46,105 fiction. 9135 04:52:46,105 --> 04:52:46,839 Social media campaigns aimed at 9136 04:52:46,839 --> 04:52:49,839 the policymaking body of this 9137 04:52:50,343 --> 04:52:51,760 city so that I'll conclude my 9138 04:52:51,760 --> 04:52:51,778 questions and comments on this. 9139 04:52:51,778 --> 04:52:54,778 I'm again very supportive of 9140 04:52:55,115 --> 04:52:55,781 the motion in front of us and 9141 04:52:55,781 --> 04:52:56,249 appreciate Catherine Foster 9142 04:52:56,249 --> 04:52:56,682 putting forward. 9143 04:52:56,682 --> 04:52:57,490 >> Thank you. 9144 04:52:57,490 --> 04:52:59,490 All right. 9145 04:52:59,719 --> 04:53:00,553 Thank you Council members. 9146 04:53:00,553 --> 04:53:01,187 So we have a motion by Council 9147 04:53:01,187 --> 04:53:04,900 Member Foster a second by 9148 04:53:04,900 --> 04:53:04,790 council member Eli Rivera to 9149 04:53:04,790 --> 04:53:07,190 rescind the smart Streetlight 9150 04:53:08,861 --> 04:53:09,528 surveillance use policy and 9151 04:53:09,528 --> 04:53:10,195 we'll go next to Council 9152 04:53:10,195 --> 04:53:13,195 PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee thank 9153 04:53:13,833 --> 04:53:14,500 yous PRESIDENT And thank you 9154 04:53:14,500 --> 04:53:15,000 council Mary Lou Rivera for 9155 04:53:15,000 --> 04:53:17,000 bringing that up. 9156 04:53:17,836 --> 04:53:18,637 I MAY be on my end. 9157 04:53:18,637 --> 04:53:19,339 I just sort of understand that 9158 04:53:19,339 --> 04:53:22,939 there are going to be moments 9159 04:53:22,975 --> 04:53:23,676 where this body or at least 9160 04:53:23,676 --> 04:53:24,277 even parts of this body MAY 9161 04:53:24,277 --> 04:53:26,677 differ an opinion from 9162 04:53:27,513 --> 04:53:28,214 the administration as a whole 9163 04:53:28,214 --> 04:53:31,814 And and we've seen that before 9164 04:53:31,884 --> 04:53:32,585 Maybe how we choose to levy 9165 04:53:32,585 --> 04:53:33,253 that with each other matters. 9166 04:53:33,253 --> 04:53:36,188 But in this particular case 9167 04:53:36,188 --> 04:53:36,889 especially in terms of how we 9168 04:53:36,889 --> 04:53:37,556 work with the public, I think 9169 04:53:37,556 --> 04:53:39,956 there's a difference between 9170 04:53:40,793 --> 04:53:41,561 policy disagreements and 9171 04:53:41,561 --> 04:53:43,961 straight up undermining folks 9172 04:53:46,365 --> 04:53:46,966 in the public And I think 9173 04:53:46,966 --> 04:53:47,733 that's what I if there's 9174 04:53:47,733 --> 04:53:51,271 anything I want to echo, that's 9175 04:53:51,271 --> 04:53:51,938 something that I want to make 9176 04:53:51,938 --> 04:53:55,538 sure that we try to avoid 9177 04:53:55,608 --> 04:53:56,275 moving forward on this item In 9178 04:53:56,275 --> 04:53:56,910 particular for me this is a 9179 04:53:56,910 --> 04:53:59,310 simple discussion in part 9180 04:54:00,790 --> 04:54:00,747 because we had this discussion 9181 04:54:00,747 --> 04:54:01,447 during the budget process as 9182 04:54:01,447 --> 04:54:02,115 well which is that at the end 9183 04:54:02,115 --> 04:54:05,184 of the day the city is faced 9184 04:54:05,184 --> 04:54:05,785 with difficult choices with 9185 04:54:05,785 --> 04:54:06,118 what we're prioritizing. 9186 04:54:06,118 --> 04:54:06,719 I think. 9187 04:54:06,719 --> 04:54:08,719 Council PRESIDENT You've 9188 04:54:10,623 --> 04:54:11,291 mentioned that it's not going 9189 04:54:11,291 --> 04:54:12,910 to be long again that we're 9190 04:54:12,910 --> 04:54:14,728 going to be facing an issue in 9191 04:54:14,728 --> 04:54:15,395 Mission Bay for example, and 9192 04:54:15,395 --> 04:54:18,395 that we still have libraries 9193 04:54:19,766 --> 04:54:20,466 and rec centers that at the end 9194 04:54:20,466 --> 04:54:21,200 of the budget process we were 9195 04:54:21,200 --> 04:54:24,638 not able to retain those hours. 9196 04:54:24,638 --> 04:54:25,238 And so as I do understand it, 9197 04:54:25,238 --> 04:54:27,638 it's been mentioned that 9198 04:54:29,275 --> 04:54:30,900 the cost savings that would be 9199 04:54:30,900 --> 04:54:33,900 achieved from the rescinding of 9200 04:54:33,212 --> 04:54:33,913 lpr use would be about 70 or 9201 04:54:33,913 --> 04:54:36,913 $50,000 I assume that's for a 9202 04:54:38,151 --> 04:54:38,918 full year And so I understand 9203 04:54:38,918 --> 04:54:42,155 that we're in a media cycle at 9204 04:54:42,155 --> 04:54:42,755 the moment and that the full 9205 04:54:42,755 --> 04:54:45,155 removal of the Ubiquiti 9206 04:54:45,992 --> 04:54:46,393 contract would be a savings of 9207 04:54:46,393 --> 04:54:47,127 $2 million. 9208 04:54:47,127 --> 04:54:48,940 One thing that has come up that 9209 04:54:48,940 --> 04:54:50,397 I do think is worth asking is 9210 04:54:50,397 --> 04:54:51,310 that it's been mentioned that 9211 04:54:51,310 --> 04:54:51,731 we're not going to see a 9212 04:54:51,731 --> 04:54:55,101 difference in this year And if 9213 04:54:55,101 --> 04:54:55,801 you want to understand that 9214 04:54:55,801 --> 04:54:59,401 because if if the actions are 9215 04:55:00,707 --> 04:55:01,374 taken today whether it's 9216 04:55:01,374 --> 04:55:04,374 Yelpers or Yelpers and smart 9217 04:55:04,710 --> 04:55:05,311 street lights and that contract 9218 04:55:05,311 --> 04:55:06,120 is ultimately terminated 9219 04:55:06,120 --> 04:55:09,612 because we have the ability to 9220 04:55:10,417 --> 04:55:14,754 do so it at the city's cause is 9221 04:55:14,754 --> 04:55:15,555 are the funds committed already 9222 04:55:15,555 --> 04:55:16,256 for the full year Is there not 9223 04:55:16,256 --> 04:55:19,920 a cost savings to be expected 9224 04:55:19,920 --> 04:55:19,826 in the current year Just to 9225 04:55:19,826 --> 04:55:20,460 clarify we make the payments to 9226 04:55:20,460 --> 04:55:24,600 you back here for the year 9227 04:55:24,430 --> 04:55:25,131 prior so if we were to make 9228 04:55:25,131 --> 04:55:28,131 the payment this DECEMBER come 9229 04:55:28,334 --> 04:55:28,769 in that would cover 2027 would 9230 04:55:28,769 --> 04:55:29,503 be that year. 9231 04:55:29,503 --> 04:55:32,806 So this year we've already paid 9232 04:55:32,806 --> 04:55:33,573 for this year in DECEMBER of 9233 04:55:33,573 --> 04:55:36,573 2025 cover 2026 So we pay a 9234 04:55:37,644 --> 04:55:38,311 year in advance. 9235 04:55:38,311 --> 04:55:39,450 We're talking about calendar 9236 04:55:39,450 --> 04:55:42,645 year by fiscal year I'm talking 9237 04:55:43,250 --> 04:55:43,884 calendar year meaning this last 9238 04:55:43,884 --> 04:55:46,884 year we budgeted for this 9239 04:55:49,122 --> 04:55:49,689 the use of this technology for 9240 04:55:49,689 --> 04:55:50,390 the full fiscal year. 9241 04:55:50,390 --> 04:55:50,991 I guess I'll turn to the idea 9242 04:55:50,991 --> 04:55:51,658 if you if you have any 9243 04:55:51,658 --> 04:55:53,426 clarification Councilmember 9244 04:55:53,426 --> 04:55:54,127 I've got the capital on staff 9245 04:55:54,127 --> 04:55:54,828 to add additional clarity but 9246 04:55:54,828 --> 04:55:57,828 my understanding is that what 9247 04:55:57,831 --> 04:55:58,464 was budgeted in fy 27 was 9248 04:55:58,464 --> 04:56:00,464 essentially the $2 million 9249 04:56:02,302 --> 04:56:02,902 payment that is due mid-late 9250 04:56:02,902 --> 04:56:03,736 DECEMBER of this year. 9251 04:56:03,736 --> 04:56:04,337 So to the extent that there is 9252 04:56:04,337 --> 04:56:06,737 action taken before that 9253 04:56:07,474 --> 04:56:08,141 payment goes out to not have 9254 04:56:08,141 --> 04:56:08,842 that payment go out, those 9255 04:56:08,842 --> 04:56:11,378 would be current year savings. 9256 04:56:11,378 --> 04:56:12,780 But but please feel free to 9257 04:56:12,780 --> 04:56:12,746 provide additional clarity or 9258 04:56:12,746 --> 04:56:15,746 correct me if I'm incorrect. 9259 04:56:16,716 --> 04:56:17,417 >> Thank you Charles But could 9260 04:56:17,417 --> 04:56:18,118 you tell from the ideas office 9261 04:56:18,118 --> 04:56:20,518 Charles is absolutely correct. 9262 04:56:21,488 --> 04:56:22,222 So that upcoming payment for 9263 04:56:22,222 --> 04:56:25,425 the following fiscal year if it 9264 04:56:25,425 --> 04:56:26,293 is not made as a result of 9265 04:56:26,293 --> 04:56:29,296 the actions today there will be 9266 04:56:29,296 --> 04:56:29,963 that $2 million savings for 9267 04:56:29,963 --> 04:56:32,963 the general fund this fiscal 9268 04:56:33,967 --> 04:56:34,535 year fiscal year 2027. 9269 04:56:34,535 --> 04:56:34,968 Thank you for that 9270 04:56:34,968 --> 04:56:35,636 clarification. 9271 04:56:35,636 --> 04:56:38,605 I think that's an important 9272 04:56:38,605 --> 04:56:39,306 clarification for all all of us 9273 04:56:39,306 --> 04:56:40,600 to understand because there is 9274 04:56:40,600 --> 04:56:40,774 a fiscal impact at the end of 9275 04:56:40,774 --> 04:56:43,977 the day for folks who are not 9276 04:56:43,977 --> 04:56:44,778 familiar the council as a body 9277 04:56:44,778 --> 04:56:48,378 does not have the authority in 9278 04:56:49,215 --> 04:56:49,917 the mid-year to make 9279 04:56:49,917 --> 04:56:50,550 adjustments to the budget And 9280 04:56:50,550 --> 04:56:53,153 so all of that ultimately 9281 04:56:53,153 --> 04:56:53,854 handle is handled on 9282 04:56:53,854 --> 04:56:54,488 the administrative side And so 9283 04:56:54,488 --> 04:56:55,155 I won't have that argument 9284 04:56:55,155 --> 04:56:55,622 today on where those dollars 9285 04:56:55,622 --> 04:56:57,622 could be spent. 9286 04:56:58,358 --> 04:56:59,920 We've heard many options that 9287 04:56:59,920 --> 04:56:59,759 have been brought forward today 9288 04:56:59,759 --> 04:57:02,759 whether it is libraries, rec 9289 04:57:03,597 --> 04:57:04,198 centers, restrooms or even to 9290 04:57:04,198 --> 04:57:06,198 improve response times. 9291 04:57:07,601 --> 04:57:08,101 Certainly that is at 9292 04:57:08,101 --> 04:57:08,635 the prerogative of 9293 04:57:08,635 --> 04:57:09,503 the administration. 9294 04:57:09,503 --> 04:57:12,906 But I think for clarity that is 9295 04:57:12,906 --> 04:57:13,640 something that has a direct 9296 04:57:13,640 --> 04:57:14,174 impact on where we move forward 9297 04:57:14,174 --> 04:57:16,574 in this fiscal year. 9298 04:57:18,612 --> 04:57:19,280 So with that said, I'm happy to 9299 04:57:19,280 --> 04:57:19,913 support the motion that's in 9300 04:57:19,913 --> 04:57:23,513 front of us to within our 9301 04:57:24,510 --> 04:57:24,451 streetlights as well. 9302 04:57:24,451 --> 04:57:24,818 All right. 9303 04:57:24,818 --> 04:57:25,452 Thank you. 9304 04:57:25,452 --> 04:57:26,190 Council Excuse me Council 9305 04:57:26,190 --> 04:57:26,753 PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee. 9306 04:57:26,753 --> 04:57:27,921 We'll go next to council member 9307 04:57:27,921 --> 04:57:28,522 Kip Thank you. 9308 04:57:28,522 --> 04:57:29,123 Council PRESIDENT Police 9309 04:57:29,123 --> 04:57:30,223 Department Is there any 9310 04:57:30,223 --> 04:57:32,623 component of the smart 9311 04:57:35,695 --> 04:57:36,430 streetlight that we present? 9312 04:57:36,430 --> 04:57:38,830 Basically speaking Smart Street 9313 04:57:39,800 --> 04:57:40,267 Light is recording visual 9314 04:57:40,267 --> 04:57:40,601 footage correct? 9315 04:57:40,601 --> 04:57:42,601 Correct. 9316 04:57:45,390 --> 04:57:48,639 Is any of that process through 9317 04:57:49,443 --> 04:57:50,310 any artificial intelligence 9318 04:57:50,310 --> 04:57:50,911 system or is it saved in a 9319 04:57:50,911 --> 04:57:51,245 database for just visual 9320 04:57:51,245 --> 04:57:53,245 review? 9321 04:57:54,615 --> 04:57:55,382 It's saved in a database. 9322 04:57:55,382 --> 04:57:55,682 It's just a basic video camera. 9323 04:57:55,682 --> 04:57:56,450 Okay. 9324 04:57:56,450 --> 04:57:58,850 And my understanding from 9325 04:58:01,621 --> 04:58:02,289 earlier is that removing of 9326 04:58:02,289 --> 04:58:04,689 the automated license plate 9327 04:58:06,560 --> 04:58:10,160 reader use policy means we can 9328 04:58:10,865 --> 04:58:11,500 take that out completely. 9329 04:58:11,500 --> 04:58:14,500 Flock will have no access 9330 04:58:15,569 --> 04:58:15,936 whatsoever to the actual 9331 04:58:15,936 --> 04:58:16,470 hardware. 9332 04:58:16,470 --> 04:58:16,770 >> That is correct. 9333 04:58:16,770 --> 04:58:17,710 Okay. 9334 04:58:17,710 --> 04:58:17,638 Yeah. 9335 04:58:17,638 --> 04:58:19,638 Two separate systems. 9336 04:58:20,240 --> 04:58:21,108 Okay. 9337 04:58:21,108 --> 04:58:24,708 So I'm in alignment with what 9338 04:58:24,978 --> 04:58:26,978 Councilmember Moreno said. 9339 04:58:29,683 --> 04:58:30,184 Seems that it has extensive 9340 04:58:30,184 --> 04:58:30,851 evidentiary usage. 9341 04:58:30,851 --> 04:58:33,851 The current use policy says 9342 04:58:35,289 --> 04:58:38,289 that it's only saved for 14 9343 04:58:42,930 --> 04:58:43,597 days or 17 days 1313 and it is 9344 04:58:43,597 --> 04:58:46,597 utilized when a crime is 9345 04:58:48,135 --> 04:58:48,869 reported And it's believed that 9346 04:58:48,869 --> 04:58:51,269 that smart streetlight actually 9347 04:58:52,606 --> 04:58:53,207 observed the potential footage 9348 04:58:53,207 --> 04:58:53,541 of criminality, correct? 9349 04:58:53,541 --> 04:58:53,841 >> Yes. 9350 04:58:53,841 --> 04:58:55,841 Okay. 9351 04:58:56,777 --> 04:58:59,777 And last component is that 9352 04:59:01,882 --> 04:59:02,516 evidence is also a defense 9353 04:59:02,516 --> 04:59:04,916 attorney can request that 9354 04:59:06,353 --> 04:59:06,954 footage for exculpatory 9355 04:59:06,954 --> 04:59:07,621 purposes from our police 9356 04:59:07,621 --> 04:59:10,210 department as well, correct? 9357 04:59:11,391 --> 04:59:11,692 Yes. 9358 04:59:11,692 --> 04:59:12,360 Okay. 9359 04:59:12,360 --> 04:59:13,930 Because if we have evidence 9360 04:59:13,930 --> 04:59:15,896 that something didn't happen by 9361 04:59:15,896 --> 04:59:16,230 law we have to turn it over, 9362 04:59:16,230 --> 04:59:16,731 correct? 9363 04:59:16,731 --> 04:59:17,310 >> That's correct. 9364 04:59:17,310 --> 04:59:19,310 Okay. 9365 04:59:20,835 --> 04:59:21,536 Given that that is has any 9366 04:59:21,536 --> 04:59:23,936 exculpatory value to prove 9367 04:59:26,730 --> 04:59:29,730 innocent people innocent so to 9368 04:59:30,510 --> 04:59:31,212 speak and ultimately that it 9369 04:59:31,212 --> 04:59:31,845 does not have a connection to 9370 04:59:31,845 --> 04:59:33,845 an artificial intelligence 9371 04:59:35,382 --> 04:59:36,183 system like the Alper system 9372 04:59:36,183 --> 04:59:36,917 had And because I think that 9373 04:59:36,917 --> 04:59:40,454 the use policy for smart street 9374 04:59:40,454 --> 04:59:41,122 lights is much narrower than 9375 04:59:41,122 --> 04:59:41,755 what the lpr system was, it 9376 04:59:41,755 --> 04:59:44,155 seems that the heightened 9377 04:59:45,426 --> 04:59:45,993 concern over privacy is baked 9378 04:59:45,993 --> 04:59:48,393 in to that component. 9379 04:59:50,731 --> 04:59:54,931 So I will be in opposition to 9380 04:59:55,690 --> 04:59:55,436 the motion today and I'll stay 9381 04:59:55,436 --> 04:59:55,803 with that. 9382 04:59:55,803 --> 04:59:56,170 Thank you. 9383 04:59:56,170 --> 04:59:56,537 All right. 9384 04:59:56,537 --> 04:59:58,537 Thank you. 9385 05:00:00,700 --> 05:00:00,774 Councilmember Camp. 9386 05:00:00,774 --> 05:00:01,142 We'll go next to Council member 9387 05:00:01,142 --> 05:00:01,509 Whitburn. 9388 05:00:01,509 --> 05:00:02,900 Thank you. 9389 05:00:02,900 --> 05:00:04,900 Council PRESIDENT. 9390 05:00:04,379 --> 05:00:05,113 Just so I'm clear on the budget 9391 05:00:05,113 --> 05:00:08,713 savings, if we end smart street 9392 05:00:09,383 --> 05:00:09,950 lights as of essentially 9393 05:00:09,950 --> 05:00:10,551 the end of this year, 9394 05:00:10,551 --> 05:00:12,920 the budget savings in 9395 05:00:12,920 --> 05:00:13,488 the current fiscal year would 9396 05:00:13,488 --> 05:00:15,488 be $1 million, right? 9397 05:00:16,723 --> 05:00:19,123 Because we spent $1 billion 9398 05:00:21,629 --> 05:00:22,496 from JULY through DECEMBER from 9399 05:00:22,496 --> 05:00:26,960 the fy 27 budget but we would 9400 05:00:26,534 --> 05:00:27,101 not be spending the portion 9401 05:00:27,101 --> 05:00:29,501 from JANUARY to JUNE. 9402 05:00:31,305 --> 05:00:31,973 Is that correct or not 9403 05:00:31,973 --> 05:00:32,640 incorrect Council member You 9404 05:00:32,640 --> 05:00:33,340 would essentially be saving 9405 05:00:33,340 --> 05:00:36,310 the full $2 million if there's 9406 05:00:36,310 --> 05:00:37,110 a mismatch in between when 9407 05:00:37,110 --> 05:00:37,611 the payment goes out and when 9408 05:00:37,611 --> 05:00:40,110 the fiscal year starts. 9409 05:00:41,148 --> 05:00:41,782 But we budgeted for the full $2 9410 05:00:41,782 --> 05:00:44,182 million payment that would 9411 05:00:44,418 --> 05:00:45,185 cover 2027 in fy 27 and that 9412 05:00:45,185 --> 05:00:48,185 payment would go out in 9413 05:00:48,957 --> 05:00:49,590 the middle to the end of 9414 05:00:49,590 --> 05:00:51,990 DECEMBER If council allows 9415 05:00:53,628 --> 05:00:54,595 smart street lights to continue 9416 05:00:54,595 --> 05:00:58,195 on that payment there are some 9417 05:00:58,833 --> 05:00:59,534 additional complications and 9418 05:00:59,534 --> 05:01:02,534 that the contract itself just 9419 05:01:03,204 --> 05:01:03,871 calls for Ubiquiti to provide 9420 05:01:03,871 --> 05:01:04,539 smart streetlights with lpr 9421 05:01:04,539 --> 05:01:06,939 technology or not unbundled. 9422 05:01:07,981 --> 05:01:08,710 However over the last week or 9423 05:01:08,710 --> 05:01:09,410 so I understand that the police 9424 05:01:09,410 --> 05:01:10,111 department has been in contact 9425 05:01:10,111 --> 05:01:12,713 with Ubiquiti to see if those 9426 05:01:12,713 --> 05:01:13,414 could be unbundled and that 9427 05:01:13,414 --> 05:01:15,814 Ubiquiti indicated that there 9428 05:01:16,784 --> 05:01:17,585 could be $750,000 in savings if 9429 05:01:17,585 --> 05:01:21,154 you just get rid of lpr but 9430 05:01:21,154 --> 05:01:21,990 keep the smart street lights If 9431 05:01:21,990 --> 05:01:22,656 you get rid of it altogether 9432 05:01:22,656 --> 05:01:23,358 you would still see a $2 9433 05:01:23,358 --> 05:01:25,994 million savings in the current 9434 05:01:25,994 --> 05:01:26,327 year in future years going 9435 05:01:26,327 --> 05:01:26,995 forward. 9436 05:01:26,995 --> 05:01:29,395 Thanks for explaining that. 9437 05:01:29,897 --> 05:01:32,897 So the $2 million payment in 9438 05:01:34,135 --> 05:01:36,535 this being contemplated in 9439 05:01:39,390 --> 05:01:39,774 DECEMBER is that for f y 27 in 9440 05:01:39,774 --> 05:01:42,774 in arrears essentially or would 9441 05:01:43,244 --> 05:01:43,912 that be for fy 28 If we were to 9442 05:01:43,912 --> 05:01:47,512 continue it it would be a 9443 05:01:47,715 --> 05:01:48,116 payment in fy 27 for calendar 9444 05:01:48,116 --> 05:01:48,583 year 27. 9445 05:01:48,583 --> 05:01:48,883 >> Got it. 9446 05:01:48,883 --> 05:01:50,883 Okay. 9447 05:01:52,387 --> 05:01:53,154 Thank you. 9448 05:01:53,154 --> 05:01:56,458 I'm going to have some thoughts 9449 05:01:56,458 --> 05:01:56,958 but I'll I'll go through 9450 05:01:56,958 --> 05:01:59,358 the line up here. 9451 05:02:01,563 --> 05:02:02,429 >> Councilmember Moreno Oh, I, 9452 05:02:02,429 --> 05:02:03,310 I kind of felt like I kind of 9453 05:02:03,310 --> 05:02:05,431 opened the door about 9454 05:02:06,467 --> 05:02:07,135 the conversation so I don't 9455 05:02:07,135 --> 05:02:07,835 have any inside information. 9456 05:02:07,835 --> 05:02:11,435 >> So let me start with that. 9457 05:02:11,606 --> 05:02:12,307 But I didn't want to build an 9458 05:02:12,307 --> 05:02:15,307 expectation in the public that 9459 05:02:16,478 --> 05:02:16,778 we're making a fiscal decision 9460 05:02:16,778 --> 05:02:17,479 here. 9461 05:02:17,479 --> 05:02:20,479 We're making a value judgment 9462 05:02:21,683 --> 05:02:22,383 on the Alper and possibly 9463 05:02:22,383 --> 05:02:25,983 the smart street lights and we 9464 05:02:26,540 --> 05:02:26,387 should do it based on our 9465 05:02:26,387 --> 05:02:27,122 values. 9466 05:02:27,122 --> 05:02:30,722 My sense is we don't know 9467 05:02:30,725 --> 05:02:31,393 the status of the f y 2027 9468 05:02:31,393 --> 05:02:34,993 budget And my sense is that 9469 05:02:35,363 --> 05:02:36,640 we're going to even though 9470 05:02:36,640 --> 05:02:36,698 we've made major strides of 9471 05:02:36,698 --> 05:02:37,365 eliminating the structural 9472 05:02:37,365 --> 05:02:40,365 deficit that we're going to 9473 05:02:41,169 --> 05:02:42,704 fall short in our f y 27 budget 9474 05:02:42,704 --> 05:02:46,904 and we will need to find how 9475 05:02:48,243 --> 05:02:51,843 we're going to make that up. 9476 05:02:52,380 --> 05:02:53,148 In addition to that, I 9477 05:02:53,148 --> 05:02:56,148 completely lost my train of 9478 05:02:57,786 --> 05:02:58,486 thought that there there MAY be 9479 05:02:58,486 --> 05:03:01,486 some costs with the unwinding 9480 05:03:02,657 --> 05:03:02,991 of the policy as well going 9481 05:03:02,991 --> 05:03:03,558 forward. 9482 05:03:03,558 --> 05:03:06,558 Oh that's what it was. 9483 05:03:07,562 --> 05:03:08,196 We dipped into reserves to 9484 05:03:08,196 --> 05:03:10,596 quote balance the budget. 9485 05:03:12,134 --> 05:03:12,467 I think we're 4 million 2526 9486 05:03:12,467 --> 05:03:14,467 budget. 9487 05:03:16,400 --> 05:03:16,305 That's correct. 9488 05:03:16,305 --> 05:03:17,720 Okay. 9489 05:03:17,720 --> 05:03:17,439 And I think we're in the same 9490 05:03:17,439 --> 05:03:18,139 position. 9491 05:03:18,139 --> 05:03:21,139 So I'm very concerned about 9492 05:03:21,276 --> 05:03:22,100 predisposing where we would 9493 05:03:22,100 --> 05:03:22,777 spend that money And that's not 9494 05:03:22,777 --> 05:03:25,777 the conversation today But I'm 9495 05:03:25,814 --> 05:03:26,581 very concerned about promising 9496 05:03:26,581 --> 05:03:29,581 that we're going to fund 9497 05:03:31,219 --> 05:03:31,920 the bathrooms in Mission Bay or 9498 05:03:31,920 --> 05:03:34,920 the library hours or whatever. 9499 05:03:35,657 --> 05:03:36,290 Maybe we can get there in 9500 05:03:36,290 --> 05:03:36,958 the mid-year adjustments. 9501 05:03:36,958 --> 05:03:37,591 But I'm very concerned about 9502 05:03:37,591 --> 05:03:40,591 any making any promises to 9503 05:03:40,829 --> 05:03:41,596 anybody. 9504 05:03:41,596 --> 05:03:45,000 To me it's strictly a value 9505 05:03:45,000 --> 05:03:45,734 judgment on the use policies 9506 05:03:45,734 --> 05:03:46,100 and that's why I'm supporting 9507 05:03:46,100 --> 05:03:46,768 it. 9508 05:03:46,768 --> 05:03:49,905 And I would also argue since 9509 05:03:49,905 --> 05:03:50,472 Councilmember Moreno gave me 9510 05:03:50,472 --> 05:03:50,906 the floor it is still 9511 05:03:50,906 --> 05:03:52,906 surveillance. 9512 05:03:54,309 --> 05:03:55,177 You can still observe people. 9513 05:03:55,177 --> 05:03:59,377 You don't have the lpr which is 9514 05:03:59,681 --> 05:04:00,315 one tool that allows you to use 9515 05:04:00,315 --> 05:04:03,315 ai to proactively go track 9516 05:04:03,518 --> 05:04:04,486 things down but you can still 9517 05:04:04,486 --> 05:04:08,860 view to not only find out 9518 05:04:09,458 --> 05:04:10,158 somebody didn't commit a crime 9519 05:04:10,158 --> 05:04:10,725 of councilmember computed but 9520 05:04:10,725 --> 05:04:13,125 you can also identify 9521 05:04:13,695 --> 05:04:14,329 individuals and their behavior 9522 05:04:14,329 --> 05:04:16,729 by watching the videos. 9523 05:04:18,901 --> 05:04:19,769 So it is just an area that I 9524 05:04:19,769 --> 05:04:23,572 would prefer not to go into and 9525 05:04:23,572 --> 05:04:24,206 that's why I was supporting I, 9526 05:04:24,206 --> 05:04:24,940 I will be supporting this 9527 05:04:24,940 --> 05:04:25,574 motion but that's where I land. 9528 05:04:25,574 --> 05:04:27,974 So anyway, thank you 9529 05:04:28,510 --> 05:04:29,111 Councilmember Farina I'll turn 9530 05:04:29,111 --> 05:04:32,111 it over to you now. 9531 05:04:32,981 --> 05:04:33,548 >> Absolutely Think you can 9532 05:04:33,548 --> 05:04:34,182 staff address whether 9533 05:04:34,182 --> 05:04:36,582 the contracts were signed 9534 05:04:38,153 --> 05:04:38,921 separately? 9535 05:04:38,921 --> 05:04:41,921 Ubiquiti And they were together 9536 05:04:43,358 --> 05:04:44,590 They were cobbled together but 9537 05:04:44,590 --> 05:04:44,426 I'm sure staff can respond. 9538 05:04:44,426 --> 05:04:45,127 >> Yes. 9539 05:04:45,127 --> 05:04:47,395 It was one single contract for 9540 05:04:47,395 --> 05:04:47,796 smart street lights with a lpr 9541 05:04:47,796 --> 05:04:48,960 technology. 9542 05:04:48,960 --> 05:04:50,960 Okay. 9543 05:04:52,634 --> 05:04:53,402 And if staff could also let me 9544 05:04:53,402 --> 05:04:57,200 know in regards to smart street 9545 05:04:57,840 --> 05:04:58,640 light cameras is can they be 9546 05:04:58,640 --> 05:05:01,640 accessed by other agencies and 9547 05:05:03,780 --> 05:05:06,780 or immigration know our agency 9548 05:05:07,315 --> 05:05:07,682 on security only our agency can 9549 05:05:07,682 --> 05:05:08,149 access it. 9550 05:05:08,149 --> 05:05:08,683 Okay wonderful. 9551 05:05:08,683 --> 05:05:11,830 Thank you for that. 9552 05:05:12,454 --> 05:05:15,454 My position has been consistent 9553 05:05:16,325 --> 05:05:18,325 since 20 gosh since 2023. 9554 05:05:21,196 --> 05:05:24,796 The reason why I voted no. 9555 05:05:26,290 --> 05:05:26,447 Many of the reasons why voted 9556 05:05:26,447 --> 05:05:26,604 one of the reasons why I voted 9557 05:05:26,604 --> 05:05:26,759 no on this was because of 9558 05:05:26,759 --> 05:05:29,159 the cobbling together of 9559 05:05:29,972 --> 05:05:30,606 the contract but to me 9560 05:05:30,606 --> 05:05:31,240 the benefits of the street 9561 05:05:31,240 --> 05:05:33,640 light cameras and solving 9562 05:05:35,440 --> 05:05:35,744 crimes is undeniable. 9563 05:05:35,744 --> 05:05:38,144 In 2019 Maribel Marino Ibanez 9564 05:05:40,149 --> 05:05:40,849 was tragically murdered at her 9565 05:05:40,849 --> 05:05:43,249 workplace the church's chicken 9566 05:05:44,720 --> 05:05:45,387 in Otay Mesa Nestor. 9567 05:05:45,387 --> 05:05:46,540 Without that footage from 9568 05:05:46,540 --> 05:05:48,454 streetlight cameras it would 9569 05:05:49,558 --> 05:05:50,259 have been impossible for sd pd 9570 05:05:50,259 --> 05:05:53,259 to solve that particular crime 9571 05:05:54,797 --> 05:05:55,497 With this technology. 9572 05:05:55,497 --> 05:05:58,200 Her murder was found arrested 9573 05:05:58,200 --> 05:05:59,100 in the 70s, sentenced to 146 9574 05:05:59,100 --> 05:06:03,201 years to life in prison And I 9575 05:06:03,505 --> 05:06:04,173 personally cannot look at MISS 9576 05:06:04,173 --> 05:06:06,573 Maribel Moreno Ibanez family 9577 05:06:07,976 --> 05:06:08,410 and tell them that I voted 9578 05:06:08,410 --> 05:06:09,344 against this. 9579 05:06:09,344 --> 05:06:09,945 So I still stand in my position 9580 05:06:09,945 --> 05:06:12,345 and voting no against 9581 05:06:13,382 --> 05:06:13,748 the motion before us today. 9582 05:06:13,748 --> 05:06:14,115 Thank you. 9583 05:06:14,115 --> 05:06:14,716 All right. 9584 05:06:14,716 --> 05:06:15,500 Thank you, Councilmember 9585 05:06:15,500 --> 05:06:15,784 Murray. 9586 05:06:15,784 --> 05:06:16,118 And again, thank you for giving 9587 05:06:16,118 --> 05:06:18,118 me time. 9588 05:06:20,588 --> 05:06:20,856 Councilmember Foster Yes, thank 9589 05:06:20,856 --> 05:06:22,856 you. 9590 05:06:24,192 --> 05:06:27,792 And just wanted to get some 9591 05:06:29,298 --> 05:06:29,999 clarification because I, I find 9592 05:06:29,999 --> 05:06:33,599 it difficult when we use terms 9593 05:06:34,236 --> 05:06:35,710 such as impossible. 9594 05:06:35,710 --> 05:06:38,374 I'm not sure that we can all 9595 05:06:38,374 --> 05:06:39,175 sit here and say that a crime 9596 05:06:39,175 --> 05:06:39,942 would not have been solved or 9597 05:06:39,942 --> 05:06:42,942 would be impossible to solve 9598 05:06:43,912 --> 05:06:47,512 without per se a camera No 9599 05:06:48,350 --> 05:06:49,318 matter if it's a camera that's 9600 05:06:49,318 --> 05:06:53,518 owned by the city of San Diego 9601 05:06:54,560 --> 05:06:54,823 or a camera that is owned by a 9602 05:06:54,823 --> 05:06:57,626 store that has their own 9603 05:06:57,626 --> 05:06:58,561 surveillance, a convenience 9604 05:06:58,561 --> 05:07:02,761 store or a home that has their 9605 05:07:02,898 --> 05:07:05,898 own surveillance And um, I 9606 05:07:07,537 --> 05:07:11,407 guess I'd like to ask you as we 9607 05:07:11,407 --> 05:07:12,107 talked about the license plate 9608 05:07:12,107 --> 05:07:14,276 readers and as we talked about 9609 05:07:14,276 --> 05:07:17,876 just a single instance of a 9610 05:07:19,448 --> 05:07:21,448 domestic violence victim 9611 05:07:23,886 --> 05:07:24,586 finding themselves being 9612 05:07:24,586 --> 05:07:26,986 monitored through that system, 9613 05:07:29,591 --> 05:07:30,259 I would assume as these cameras 9614 05:07:30,259 --> 05:07:30,960 are I don't know are they 9615 05:07:30,960 --> 05:07:33,360 attached or separate cameras? 9616 05:07:34,630 --> 05:07:34,764 But I'd like to think that they 9617 05:07:34,764 --> 05:07:38,364 are in the same locations per 9618 05:07:39,368 --> 05:07:40,690 se because I think it's been 9619 05:07:40,690 --> 05:07:43,690 pretty clear that the license 9620 05:07:43,739 --> 05:07:44,307 plate readers do not pick up 9621 05:07:44,307 --> 05:07:44,706 who's actually driving 9622 05:07:44,706 --> 05:07:46,706 the vehicle. 9623 05:07:48,711 --> 05:07:52,311 But I think the smart street 9624 05:07:53,482 --> 05:07:54,216 lights do provide a connection 9625 05:07:54,216 --> 05:07:58,200 point of some sort as we are 9626 05:07:58,200 --> 05:07:58,320 talking about an investigation 9627 05:07:58,320 --> 05:08:00,320 . 9628 05:08:02,825 --> 05:08:03,459 So I say that to say what would 9629 05:08:03,459 --> 05:08:04,590 prevent is there anything 9630 05:08:04,590 --> 05:08:06,590 provisions or something 9631 05:08:08,197 --> 05:08:08,964 different that I don't see or 9632 05:08:08,964 --> 05:08:11,964 don't know that would prevent 9633 05:08:12,835 --> 05:08:13,603 where there is a backstop that 9634 05:08:13,603 --> 05:08:17,203 says hey for the smart street 9635 05:08:17,406 --> 05:08:21,600 for the smart street light, I'm 9636 05:08:26,816 --> 05:08:27,784 assuming we would have the same 9637 05:08:27,784 --> 05:08:28,500 I don't know if I want to call 9638 05:08:28,500 --> 05:08:28,951 it. 9639 05:08:28,951 --> 05:08:31,951 >> I also say misstep of 9640 05:08:31,987 --> 05:08:34,387 surveillance or using that 9641 05:08:35,858 --> 05:08:36,625 device to surveil a domestic 9642 05:08:36,625 --> 05:08:39,250 violent violence victim in 9643 05:08:41,630 --> 05:08:42,331 the same manner that 9644 05:08:42,331 --> 05:08:42,631 the license plate readers are 9645 05:08:42,631 --> 05:08:43,399 used. 9646 05:08:43,399 --> 05:08:46,399 >> Would you agree Would you 9647 05:08:47,300 --> 05:08:49,403 agree, Councilmember I'm not 9648 05:08:50,773 --> 05:08:51,341 not here to debate our current 9649 05:08:51,341 --> 05:08:52,107 department procedure. 9650 05:08:52,107 --> 05:08:54,109 I understand the intent of what 9651 05:08:54,109 --> 05:08:57,109 council is trying to accomplish 9652 05:08:58,548 --> 05:09:00,548 here. 9653 05:09:02,885 --> 05:09:03,586 I am open to an approach that 9654 05:09:03,586 --> 05:09:06,586 is acceptable with council on 9655 05:09:08,390 --> 05:09:11,990 when and where we could use 9656 05:09:12,628 --> 05:09:12,962 smart street cameras moving 9657 05:09:12,962 --> 05:09:13,796 forward. 9658 05:09:13,796 --> 05:09:17,967 If that is on the table I can 9659 05:09:17,967 --> 05:09:21,567 tell you that any time putting 9660 05:09:23,340 --> 05:09:24,107 a vehicle or a person in an 9661 05:09:24,107 --> 05:09:27,707 intersection at a date and time 9662 05:09:28,177 --> 05:09:28,912 that benefits a prosecution, I 9663 05:09:28,912 --> 05:09:32,512 would see that as an acceptable 9664 05:09:33,118 --> 05:09:33,816 use whether it's a member of 9665 05:09:33,816 --> 05:09:37,286 the public or one of my police 9666 05:09:37,286 --> 05:09:40,286 officers that is behaving in 9667 05:09:45,962 --> 05:09:49,562 such an egregious way And I 9668 05:09:50,600 --> 05:09:52,600 appreciate that. 9669 05:09:54,837 --> 05:09:55,405 But based on the devices 9670 05:09:55,405 --> 05:09:57,405 themselves and their 9671 05:09:59,475 --> 05:10:01,875 capabilities and the same 9672 05:10:04,380 --> 05:10:05,810 misstep that occurred 9673 05:10:05,810 --> 05:10:07,481 specifically with the domestic 9674 05:10:09,619 --> 05:10:10,386 violence victim, I could also 9675 05:10:10,386 --> 05:10:12,555 find ourselves in that same 9676 05:10:12,555 --> 05:10:14,955 circumstance with the street 9677 05:10:17,560 --> 05:10:18,194 light cameras. 9678 05:10:18,194 --> 05:10:18,928 COUNCILMAN Wright, I would 9679 05:10:18,928 --> 05:10:21,928 disagree that there's a misstep 9680 05:10:22,631 --> 05:10:23,332 there. 9681 05:10:23,332 --> 05:10:23,967 >> I understand your concern 9682 05:10:23,967 --> 05:10:26,967 But let's let's take out 9683 05:10:27,670 --> 05:10:28,238 the term misstep. 9684 05:10:28,238 --> 05:10:29,205 Let's say use Right. 9685 05:10:29,205 --> 05:10:32,509 I think you could use that same 9686 05:10:32,509 --> 05:10:36,109 that that smart street light to 9687 05:10:38,347 --> 05:10:41,851 identify the car to be in that 9688 05:10:41,851 --> 05:10:42,152 specific case. 9689 05:10:42,152 --> 05:10:42,552 Right. 9690 05:10:42,552 --> 05:10:42,819 Or instance. 9691 05:10:42,819 --> 05:10:43,586 Yes. 9692 05:10:43,586 --> 05:10:46,256 On what was discussed that you 9693 05:10:46,256 --> 05:10:46,856 could use that smart street 9694 05:10:46,856 --> 05:10:49,592 light in regards to that 9695 05:10:49,592 --> 05:10:51,992 domestic violence victim as 9696 05:10:54,798 --> 05:10:55,565 well Correct. 9697 05:10:55,565 --> 05:10:56,199 If you're asking me could we 9698 05:10:56,199 --> 05:10:59,199 use the cameras, the video 9699 05:10:59,569 --> 05:11:00,236 cameras the same way that we 9700 05:11:00,236 --> 05:11:03,236 use the license plate reader 9701 05:11:04,407 --> 05:11:05,175 images under our current use 9702 05:11:05,175 --> 05:11:08,775 policy as well as under our 9703 05:11:09,345 --> 05:11:10,460 department procedure If it's 9704 05:11:10,460 --> 05:11:12,446 for an official investigation, 9705 05:11:14,170 --> 05:11:14,316 the answer is yes. 9706 05:11:14,316 --> 05:11:14,684 Okay. 9707 05:11:14,684 --> 05:11:15,518 Thank you. 9708 05:11:15,518 --> 05:11:18,880 But I'm open to I'm open to 9709 05:11:18,880 --> 05:11:18,787 modifications If that helps 9710 05:11:18,787 --> 05:11:21,691 council And I understand that 9711 05:11:21,691 --> 05:11:25,291 and I appreciate you being open 9712 05:11:26,530 --> 05:11:29,530 to those discussions but I 9713 05:11:31,334 --> 05:11:32,350 think that's why it's important 9714 05:11:32,350 --> 05:11:35,350 that this item came forward 9715 05:11:36,573 --> 05:11:40,173 today to also resend the smart 9716 05:11:41,745 --> 05:11:42,511 street light use policy because 9717 05:11:42,511 --> 05:11:43,313 at minimum that would give us a 9718 05:11:43,313 --> 05:11:46,913 pause that would allow you to 9719 05:11:47,840 --> 05:11:47,484 go back and figure out how you 9720 05:11:47,484 --> 05:11:48,452 can improve. 9721 05:11:48,452 --> 05:11:51,955 And I think it would also give 9722 05:11:51,955 --> 05:11:52,722 the privacy Advisory Board an 9723 05:11:52,722 --> 05:11:55,722 opportunity to come back and 9724 05:11:57,127 --> 05:12:00,127 opine on said improvements also 9725 05:12:00,964 --> 05:12:01,732 quite honestly achieve what is 9726 05:12:01,732 --> 05:12:02,599 very difficult for me is how 9727 05:12:02,599 --> 05:12:06,199 long these items have been in 9728 05:12:06,970 --> 05:12:07,571 place or how long we have been 9729 05:12:07,571 --> 05:12:09,971 working with the Privacy 9730 05:12:11,141 --> 05:12:11,841 Advisory Board and how 9731 05:12:11,841 --> 05:12:12,442 the Privacy Advisory Board in 9732 05:12:12,442 --> 05:12:14,842 my humble opinion their 9733 05:12:15,946 --> 05:12:17,946 recommendations have not 9734 05:12:20,584 --> 05:12:21,451 necessarily been what I would 9735 05:12:21,451 --> 05:12:25,510 say received by the San Diego 9736 05:12:25,489 --> 05:12:28,489 Police Department and I'm going 9737 05:12:29,760 --> 05:12:33,360 to say reviewed and analyzed in 9738 05:12:34,664 --> 05:12:35,299 good faith in regards to 9739 05:12:35,299 --> 05:12:38,299 the purpose and intent of 9740 05:12:39,869 --> 05:12:40,571 the Privacy Advisory Board and 9741 05:12:40,571 --> 05:12:43,571 ensuring that we are not 9742 05:12:44,641 --> 05:12:45,308 overstepping or overreaching in 9743 05:12:45,308 --> 05:12:46,430 what we are trying to 9744 05:12:46,430 --> 05:12:49,430 accomplish in regards to public 9745 05:12:50,180 --> 05:12:53,780 safety and per se negating our 9746 05:12:53,851 --> 05:12:54,150 civil liberties and things like 9747 05:12:54,150 --> 05:12:55,180 that. 9748 05:12:55,180 --> 05:12:55,886 So for me I think it's even 9749 05:12:55,886 --> 05:12:58,822 more important as you guys just 9750 05:12:58,822 --> 05:12:59,625 confirmed that the same type of 9751 05:12:59,625 --> 05:13:03,225 use would exist And I don't 9752 05:13:03,694 --> 05:13:04,393 know what happened with our 9753 05:13:04,393 --> 05:13:07,393 police officers in regards to 9754 05:13:08,799 --> 05:13:09,499 the Smart Street lights if that 9755 05:13:09,499 --> 05:13:10,267 was included in some type of 9756 05:13:10,267 --> 05:13:12,836 meet and confer scenarios as 9757 05:13:12,836 --> 05:13:13,504 well. 9758 05:13:13,504 --> 05:13:13,971 It wasn't agreed upon in 9759 05:13:13,971 --> 05:13:15,971 NOVEMBER of 23. 9760 05:13:17,774 --> 05:13:18,541 Okay. 9761 05:13:18,541 --> 05:13:22,141 I haven't seen that type of 9762 05:13:22,413 --> 05:13:23,800 data to to to confirm that But 9763 05:13:23,800 --> 05:13:23,747 I think the same issues that 9764 05:13:23,747 --> 05:13:26,147 concerns from my perspective 9765 05:13:27,170 --> 05:13:27,684 exist which is why I think we 9766 05:13:27,684 --> 05:13:31,284 why I wanted to bring this 9767 05:13:31,588 --> 05:13:32,288 forward here today and would 9768 05:13:32,288 --> 05:13:35,288 ask my colleagues to support 9769 05:13:37,600 --> 05:13:37,795 this item moving forward. 9770 05:13:37,795 --> 05:13:40,795 So thank you Council PRESIDENT 9771 05:13:42,266 --> 05:13:42,800 And I will conclude there. 9772 05:13:42,800 --> 05:13:43,466 All right. 9773 05:13:43,466 --> 05:13:46,466 Thank you Council member Not 9774 05:13:47,104 --> 05:13:47,671 see anybody else Council member 9775 05:13:47,671 --> 05:13:48,380 Ella Rivera All right. 9776 05:13:48,380 --> 05:13:48,672 Thank you. 9777 05:13:48,672 --> 05:13:49,472 Council PRESIDENT The only 9778 05:13:49,472 --> 05:13:53,672 other thing I was going to add 9779 05:13:54,378 --> 05:13:58,578 is my I have no doubt that 9780 05:13:58,882 --> 05:13:59,683 these can be effective tools 9781 05:13:59,683 --> 05:14:03,883 and that is part of why this 9782 05:14:04,287 --> 05:14:04,955 conversation has frustrated me 9783 05:14:04,955 --> 05:14:05,856 so much from the beginning. 9784 05:14:05,856 --> 05:14:07,858 But I'm going to go all the way 9785 05:14:07,858 --> 05:14:08,658 back to the beginning of 2023 9786 05:14:08,658 --> 05:14:09,293 and it was that we didn't take 9787 05:14:09,293 --> 05:14:12,293 the advice of the privacy 9788 05:14:12,464 --> 05:14:15,464 advisory Board who was willing 9789 05:14:17,101 --> 05:14:20,701 to work with the department to 9790 05:14:22,573 --> 05:14:27,373 to get to Yes And until we So 9791 05:14:27,578 --> 05:14:31,178 we're going to scrap Floc and 9792 05:14:31,815 --> 05:14:32,549 with smart street lights I'm 9793 05:14:32,549 --> 05:14:35,549 not comfortable keeping them on 9794 05:14:36,186 --> 05:14:39,186 until I am 100% confident that 9795 05:14:41,591 --> 05:14:42,359 the experts who we have tasked 9796 05:14:42,359 --> 05:14:45,359 with providing us with that 9797 05:14:46,697 --> 05:14:47,398 expertise with respect to 9798 05:14:47,398 --> 05:14:50,398 privacy feels like our bases 9799 05:14:51,935 --> 05:14:52,569 are covered for the world that 9800 05:14:52,569 --> 05:14:53,304 we're living in now under 9801 05:14:53,304 --> 05:14:56,904 the policies that we have now 9802 05:14:56,973 --> 05:14:57,674 And there is another reality 9803 05:14:57,674 --> 05:15:01,274 that what we covered for this 9804 05:15:02,212 --> 05:15:02,913 in a certain way with 9805 05:15:02,913 --> 05:15:03,580 the passage of the Due Process 9806 05:15:03,580 --> 05:15:06,580 and safety ordinance we also 9807 05:15:06,883 --> 05:15:10,483 blew gaping holes in in this 9808 05:15:10,855 --> 05:15:11,522 city's privacy policy in 9809 05:15:11,522 --> 05:15:12,189 JANUARY of 2020 for when 9810 05:15:12,189 --> 05:15:15,189 advocates showed up here and 9811 05:15:15,626 --> 05:15:16,393 they told us be careful what 9812 05:15:16,393 --> 05:15:17,610 you do today because you don't 9813 05:15:17,610 --> 05:15:17,628 know who will be in federal 9814 05:15:17,628 --> 05:15:20,280 office in the future. 9815 05:15:21,231 --> 05:15:25,431 And so my vote in support of 9816 05:15:25,869 --> 05:15:26,570 this motion is not a vote in my 9817 05:15:26,570 --> 05:15:27,271 inability to see the potential 9818 05:15:27,271 --> 05:15:30,271 benefits of having cameras in 9819 05:15:31,509 --> 05:15:32,276 the community. 9820 05:15:32,276 --> 05:15:35,276 It's my inability to tell 9821 05:15:36,347 --> 05:15:37,148 the community that I can fully 9822 05:15:37,148 --> 05:15:37,882 that I am fully confident that 9823 05:15:37,882 --> 05:15:40,882 their privacy will be respected 9824 05:15:44,788 --> 05:15:45,756 and and the technology will be 9825 05:15:45,756 --> 05:15:49,956 properly used in a in a way 9826 05:15:50,661 --> 05:15:51,295 that I can assure them and I 9827 05:15:51,295 --> 05:15:51,595 can just I still cannot do 9828 05:15:51,595 --> 05:15:52,196 that. 9829 05:15:52,196 --> 05:15:52,863 And because of that I am 9830 05:15:52,863 --> 05:15:53,264 supportive of the motion in 9831 05:15:53,264 --> 05:15:54,465 front of us. 9832 05:15:54,465 --> 05:15:55,310 Thank you. 9833 05:15:55,310 --> 05:15:55,800 >> All right. 9834 05:15:55,800 --> 05:15:59,400 Thank you Council member So we 9835 05:16:00,238 --> 05:16:00,904 have a motion by Council Member 9836 05:16:00,904 --> 05:16:03,904 Foster the second by Council 9837 05:16:05,242 --> 05:16:05,809 member Eli Rivera to rescind 9838 05:16:05,809 --> 05:16:08,209 the smart street light 9839 05:16:10,681 --> 05:16:10,948 surveillance use policy Yes, 9840 05:16:10,948 --> 05:16:11,382 sir. 9841 05:16:11,382 --> 05:16:12,183 >> I'm sorry. 9842 05:16:12,183 --> 05:16:13,840 Just Chief, I just want to ask 9843 05:16:13,840 --> 05:16:15,719 just one more time I just want 9844 05:16:15,719 --> 05:16:19,319 to make sure with the smart 9845 05:16:20,825 --> 05:16:21,459 street lights it was brought up 9846 05:16:21,459 --> 05:16:22,159 in being confirmed with 9847 05:16:22,159 --> 05:16:25,159 the kiosk that that technology 9848 05:16:26,630 --> 05:16:27,398 could be used in in the same 9849 05:16:27,398 --> 05:16:30,398 scenario we find ourselves in 9850 05:16:31,202 --> 05:16:31,936 with the automated license 9851 05:16:31,936 --> 05:16:34,936 plate readers You're telling me 9852 05:16:37,442 --> 05:16:38,420 that does not exist in regards 9853 05:16:38,420 --> 05:16:38,909 to a councilmember? 9854 05:16:38,909 --> 05:16:39,577 What I can tell you is our 9855 05:16:39,577 --> 05:16:41,577 current department procedure 9856 05:16:41,779 --> 05:16:42,446 with rulemaking for process 9857 05:16:42,446 --> 05:16:43,247 under the prior chief in 9858 05:16:43,247 --> 05:16:47,447 the way and it was signed off 9859 05:16:47,852 --> 05:16:51,452 in NOVEMBER of 23 when I took 9860 05:16:51,823 --> 05:16:52,523 over in JUNE I'm sorry in JUNE 9861 05:16:52,523 --> 05:16:53,910 of 24 This was the existing 9862 05:16:53,910 --> 05:16:55,491 policy that's in place 9863 05:16:57,561 --> 05:16:58,363 conversations that occurred 9864 05:16:58,363 --> 05:16:59,630 back then I'm not aware of. 9865 05:16:59,630 --> 05:16:59,697 But what governing document we 9866 05:16:59,697 --> 05:17:02,970 utilize is our department 9867 05:17:03,101 --> 05:17:03,901 procedure And it's isn't it 9868 05:17:03,901 --> 05:17:04,569 that we can use it for official 9869 05:17:04,569 --> 05:17:06,569 law enforcement enforcement 9870 05:17:08,272 --> 05:17:08,973 purposes and for official 9871 05:17:08,973 --> 05:17:11,373 investigations in an internal 9872 05:17:13,678 --> 05:17:14,245 affairs investigation is 9873 05:17:14,245 --> 05:17:14,679 absolutely an official 9874 05:17:14,679 --> 05:17:16,679 investigation. 9875 05:17:19,584 --> 05:17:20,385 So if there's more specificity 9876 05:17:20,385 --> 05:17:21,850 that's needed, I'm open to that 9877 05:17:21,850 --> 05:17:24,685 But I'm certainly not going to 9878 05:17:24,956 --> 05:17:25,589 advocate for doing an 9879 05:17:25,589 --> 05:17:26,257 investigation an official 9880 05:17:26,257 --> 05:17:29,930 investigation on a member of 9881 05:17:29,930 --> 05:17:29,793 the public and not on one of my 9882 05:17:29,793 --> 05:17:31,796 police officers that's accused 9883 05:17:31,796 --> 05:17:32,196 of serious misconduct. 9884 05:17:32,196 --> 05:17:34,196 Understood. 9885 05:17:38,570 --> 05:17:39,103 Thank you. 9886 05:17:39,103 --> 05:17:39,904 >> All right. 9887 05:17:39,904 --> 05:17:42,473 Again, so we have a motion by 9888 05:17:42,473 --> 05:17:43,174 Councilmember Foster or second 9889 05:17:43,174 --> 05:17:43,874 by Councilmember Ila Rivera to 9890 05:17:43,874 --> 05:17:46,274 rescind the smart streetlight 9891 05:17:48,313 --> 05:17:48,947 surveillance use policy And 9892 05:17:48,947 --> 05:17:49,513 with that please call them 9893 05:17:49,513 --> 05:17:51,913 Please cast your vote. 9894 05:17:59,624 --> 05:18:00,424 I started the voting system 9895 05:18:00,424 --> 05:18:01,125 that passes 5 to 2 with 9896 05:18:01,125 --> 05:18:03,125 Councilmember Champion Council 9897 05:18:05,363 --> 05:18:06,290 over and over voting no. 9898 05:18:06,290 --> 05:18:06,664 Councilmember Campbell and 9899 05:18:06,664 --> 05:18:06,998 Councilmember Von Wolf are 9900 05:18:06,998 --> 05:18:07,365 absent. 9901 05:18:07,365 --> 05:18:09,365 Thank you. 9902 05:18:10,134 --> 05:18:10,502 Council PRESIDENT. 9903 05:18:10,502 --> 05:18:10,902 All right. 9904 05:18:10,902 --> 05:18:11,569 Thank you. 9905 05:18:11,569 --> 05:18:14,569 A city clerk Thank you. 9906 05:18:16,374 --> 05:18:17,740 The Department thanking all 9907 05:18:17,740 --> 05:18:17,475 staff that has worked on this 9908 05:18:17,475 --> 05:18:18,176 for so long. 9909 05:18:18,176 --> 05:18:21,446 Thank you to my colleagues for 9910 05:18:21,446 --> 05:18:22,800 a really, really good 9911 05:18:22,800 --> 05:18:24,800 discussion and questions. 9912 05:18:26,184 --> 05:18:27,218 So that will conclude item 200. 9913 05:18:27,218 --> 05:18:27,619 We need to do a little bit of a 9914 05:18:27,619 --> 05:18:28,286 time check. 9915 05:18:28,286 --> 05:18:30,686 Monday afternoon session has 9916 05:18:35,526 --> 05:18:36,294 not agenda public comment I 9917 05:18:36,294 --> 05:18:36,761 don't know how many people we 9918 05:18:36,761 --> 05:18:37,495 have in person. 9919 05:18:37,495 --> 05:18:40,495 It's always my first preference 9920 05:18:41,666 --> 05:18:42,367 to navigate that and whether we 9921 05:18:42,367 --> 05:18:43,340 have the appetite to stay for 9922 05:18:43,340 --> 05:18:45,434 virtual knowledge and public 9923 05:18:46,270 --> 05:18:47,205 comment. 9924 05:18:47,205 --> 05:18:51,405 So how much do we have in 9925 05:18:52,430 --> 05:18:55,430 person In person five in 9926 05:18:57,882 --> 05:18:58,583 person, six hands raised So let 9927 05:18:58,583 --> 05:18:59,117 me know before you somebody 9928 05:18:59,117 --> 05:19:01,517 else calls you out. 9929 05:19:02,821 --> 05:19:03,154 So okay it's only 22 seven with 9930 05:19:03,154 --> 05:19:05,154 outlets. 9931 05:19:08,927 --> 05:19:09,360 Oh excuse me, I got an 9932 05:19:09,360 --> 05:19:10,610 introduction. 9933 05:19:10,610 --> 05:19:10,762 We will now take up non agenda 9934 05:19:10,762 --> 05:19:13,162 public comment Council members 9935 05:19:14,310 --> 05:19:14,666 respect and appreciate 9936 05:19:14,666 --> 05:19:15,366 the public support and are 9937 05:19:15,366 --> 05:19:16,101 fully committed to protecting 9938 05:19:16,101 --> 05:19:16,835 every participant's free speech 9939 05:19:16,835 --> 05:19:19,835 rights at council and committee 9940 05:19:20,640 --> 05:19:21,406 meetings. 9941 05:19:21,406 --> 05:19:21,806 >> Clerk Please proceed with 9942 05:19:21,806 --> 05:19:22,173 the public. 9943 05:19:22,173 --> 05:19:24,173 Thank you. 9944 05:19:24,275 --> 05:19:24,942 Council PRESIDENT Pearl 2.7 on 9945 05:19:24,942 --> 05:19:25,577 Agenda Public comment is an 9946 05:19:25,577 --> 05:19:26,278 opportunity for members of 9947 05:19:26,278 --> 05:19:29,878 the public to comment on items 9948 05:19:29,915 --> 05:19:30,549 that are not on the agenda but 9949 05:19:30,549 --> 05:19:31,149 within the subject matter 9950 05:19:31,149 --> 05:19:31,483 jurisdiction of the City 9951 05:19:31,483 --> 05:19:32,117 Council. 9952 05:19:32,117 --> 05:19:32,450 Each speaker will have two 9953 05:19:32,450 --> 05:19:34,450 minutes. 9954 05:19:36,540 --> 05:19:36,754 Please note if there are eight 9955 05:19:36,754 --> 05:19:37,389 or more speakers on a single 9956 05:19:37,389 --> 05:19:38,890 topic the maximum time for 9957 05:19:38,890 --> 05:19:38,757 the topic will be 16 minutes. 9958 05:19:38,757 --> 05:19:41,590 If you're in chambers please 9959 05:19:41,590 --> 05:19:41,760 submit your speaker slip now. 9960 05:19:41,760 --> 05:19:44,160 >> Matthew Pendergraph if you 9961 05:19:47,933 --> 05:19:48,632 can please come up 9962 05:19:48,632 --> 05:19:49,301 the following speakers If they 9963 05:19:49,301 --> 05:19:49,568 can please come to the front 9964 05:19:49,568 --> 05:19:51,568 row. 9965 05:19:54,390 --> 05:19:54,740 Adina Flores Amy What and how 9966 05:19:54,740 --> 05:19:55,406 Daniel La Salle and allegedly 9967 05:19:55,406 --> 05:19:58,406 Audra please come forward to 9968 05:19:59,478 --> 05:20:00,245 the mic. 9969 05:20:00,245 --> 05:20:00,578 >> Matthew you'll have two 9970 05:20:00,578 --> 05:20:01,460 minutes. 9971 05:20:01,460 --> 05:20:01,446 Please proceed. 9972 05:20:01,446 --> 05:20:03,446 Hi everyone. 9973 05:20:05,584 --> 05:20:06,217 Once again Matt here and I just 9974 05:20:06,217 --> 05:20:06,818 want to touch on briefly 9975 05:20:06,818 --> 05:20:07,152 something that's come up 9976 05:20:07,152 --> 05:20:09,152 lately. 9977 05:20:10,722 --> 05:20:11,589 I'm just tired as everyone is 9978 05:20:11,589 --> 05:20:12,124 here and thank you all for your 9979 05:20:12,124 --> 05:20:12,990 work and your time. 9980 05:20:12,990 --> 05:20:17,620 So I just want to express my 9981 05:20:17,620 --> 05:20:17,796 utmost respect and appreciation 9982 05:20:17,796 --> 05:20:18,629 for Centro Cultural de la Raza. 9983 05:20:18,629 --> 05:20:22,229 So this is a really special 9984 05:20:22,801 --> 05:20:23,434 place for many of us here in 9985 05:20:23,434 --> 05:20:23,902 San Diego and it's a very 9986 05:20:23,902 --> 05:20:25,902 welcoming place. 9987 05:20:28,373 --> 05:20:29,141 I've been welcomed there for 9988 05:20:29,141 --> 05:20:29,508 years even in times in times of 9989 05:20:29,508 --> 05:20:31,508 conflict. 9990 05:20:34,546 --> 05:20:34,947 So lately there's been some 9991 05:20:34,947 --> 05:20:35,647 controversy. 9992 05:20:35,647 --> 05:20:36,315 I just want to highlight that 9993 05:20:36,315 --> 05:20:39,315 the central Courtyard de la 9994 05:20:40,852 --> 05:20:41,553 Rosa is being attacked for 9995 05:20:41,553 --> 05:20:42,254 the things that it's actually 9996 05:20:42,254 --> 05:20:42,688 what you would want a cultural 9997 05:20:42,688 --> 05:20:44,688 center to do. 9998 05:20:46,692 --> 05:20:47,325 So for example for being open 9999 05:20:47,325 --> 05:20:47,959 and welcoming to different 10000 05:20:47,959 --> 05:20:48,560 points of view for giving 10001 05:20:48,560 --> 05:20:50,960 the community freedom of 10002 05:20:52,564 --> 05:20:53,298 expression and for providing a 10003 05:20:53,298 --> 05:20:54,132 space for political dissidents. 10004 05:20:54,132 --> 05:20:58,332 So I just want to express my 10005 05:20:59,304 --> 05:21:00,380 utmost support for central 10006 05:21:00,380 --> 05:21:00,572 Courtyard de la Raza everything 10007 05:21:00,572 --> 05:21:02,972 that goes on there. 10008 05:21:04,909 --> 05:21:05,544 It's a beloved space and they 10009 05:21:05,544 --> 05:21:06,245 have a very accurate moral 10010 05:21:06,245 --> 05:21:06,711 compass so I'm standing up in 10011 05:21:06,711 --> 05:21:08,711 support of them. 10012 05:21:11,349 --> 05:21:11,717 Thank you very much. 10013 05:21:11,717 --> 05:21:12,317 Thank you. 10014 05:21:12,317 --> 05:21:14,717 Next is Adina Florence. 10015 05:21:16,722 --> 05:21:17,555 Adina, are you here? 10016 05:21:17,555 --> 05:21:17,856 I see No Adina Amy White at 10017 05:21:17,856 --> 05:21:19,856 home. 10018 05:21:23,795 --> 05:21:26,795 Amy Nobody's coming for Daniel 10019 05:21:29,201 --> 05:21:29,935 is all I see. 10020 05:21:29,935 --> 05:21:30,736 No, Daniel is all And allegedly 10021 05:21:30,736 --> 05:21:34,336 Audra, if you can come forward, 10022 05:21:40,450 --> 05:21:40,812 please. 10023 05:21:40,812 --> 05:21:43,812 So encouraging to see things 10024 05:21:46,285 --> 05:21:46,985 happen where the people's voice 10025 05:21:46,985 --> 05:21:50,585 is being heard and things that 10026 05:21:52,224 --> 05:21:52,858 the people want are being done 10027 05:21:52,858 --> 05:21:53,625 Although who knows if it's 10028 05:21:53,625 --> 05:21:56,625 political theater or not but 10029 05:21:58,430 --> 05:21:59,131 still I know, right? 10030 05:21:59,131 --> 05:21:59,798 It's always interesting to see 10031 05:21:59,798 --> 05:22:02,798 the way things work because 10032 05:22:04,136 --> 05:22:04,536 it's like is it really for 10033 05:22:04,536 --> 05:22:05,204 the people? 10034 05:22:05,204 --> 05:22:08,804 Is it not what technology is 10035 05:22:10,342 --> 05:22:10,976 going to come in and its place? 10036 05:22:10,976 --> 05:22:13,976 You know what I mean? 10037 05:22:15,514 --> 05:22:16,181 It's very, very interesting to 10038 05:22:16,181 --> 05:22:16,849 see things happen because it 10039 05:22:16,849 --> 05:22:19,849 doesn't seems like it's for 10040 05:22:21,687 --> 05:22:22,388 the people and the people will 10041 05:22:22,388 --> 05:22:23,155 buy it but it will be 10042 05:22:23,155 --> 05:22:26,155 interesting to see what happens 10043 05:22:27,693 --> 05:22:28,494 afterwards And again because 10044 05:22:28,494 --> 05:22:32,940 it's like all of the smart 10045 05:22:34,400 --> 05:22:34,866 technology that's out there is 10046 05:22:34,866 --> 05:22:35,434 very dangerous. 10047 05:22:35,434 --> 05:22:35,868 I'm not talking about 10048 05:22:35,868 --> 05:22:37,868 surveillance. 10049 05:22:40,706 --> 05:22:41,106 I'm talking networks. 10050 05:22:41,106 --> 05:22:41,707 Yes. 10051 05:22:41,707 --> 05:22:42,174 You know the boundaries. 10052 05:22:42,174 --> 05:22:42,841 Yes, I do. 10053 05:22:42,841 --> 05:22:45,841 That's why I'm saying smart 10054 05:22:46,445 --> 05:22:47,146 techno is very scary because I 10055 05:22:47,146 --> 05:22:50,146 feel like nobody really knows 10056 05:22:51,750 --> 05:22:52,550 the bounds to which it can go 10057 05:22:52,550 --> 05:22:53,185 and what it's really capable of 10058 05:22:53,185 --> 05:22:56,185 And I think that education 10059 05:22:58,690 --> 05:22:59,325 needs to happen before things 10060 05:22:59,325 --> 05:22:59,992 are implemented so that we 10061 05:22:59,992 --> 05:23:02,992 don't come down and face 10062 05:23:04,697 --> 05:23:05,430 certain situations again where 10063 05:23:05,430 --> 05:23:05,698 you're going to have to retract 10064 05:23:05,698 --> 05:23:07,698 it. 10065 05:23:10,303 --> 05:23:11,300 And I think that in people's 10066 05:23:11,300 --> 05:23:14,300 willingness or desire to be 10067 05:23:15,608 --> 05:23:16,308 like San Diego wants to be 10068 05:23:16,308 --> 05:23:17,750 the first at everything And so 10069 05:23:17,750 --> 05:23:21,614 it wants to go in and dive into 10070 05:23:21,614 --> 05:23:22,348 all the things that it probably 10071 05:23:22,348 --> 05:23:24,748 shouldn't do ignorantly because 10072 05:23:27,687 --> 05:23:28,454 we don't know what that is 10073 05:23:28,454 --> 05:23:29,880 capable of And I think until we 10074 05:23:29,880 --> 05:23:32,688 are fully aware of that we 10075 05:23:33,526 --> 05:23:34,293 should put a halt on any kind 10076 05:23:34,293 --> 05:23:35,930 of smart technology which would 10077 05:23:35,930 --> 05:23:38,693 go into like Midway Rising and 10078 05:23:39,532 --> 05:23:40,265 all of the technology that 10079 05:23:40,265 --> 05:23:43,865 could come in from Stan Kroenke 10080 05:23:45,237 --> 05:23:46,105 and his development. 10081 05:23:46,105 --> 05:23:46,705 >> So it will be interesting to 10082 05:23:46,705 --> 05:23:47,390 see what happens moving 10083 05:23:47,390 --> 05:23:49,390 forward. 10084 05:23:51,777 --> 05:23:52,245 Thank you for that Concluding 10085 05:23:52,245 --> 05:23:52,612 comment. 10086 05:23:52,612 --> 05:23:53,445 All right. 10087 05:23:53,445 --> 05:23:57,645 To be fair to my colleagues, we 10088 05:23:57,883 --> 05:23:58,751 have 13 people online So if we 10089 05:23:58,751 --> 05:23:59,452 can bear with there's six of us 10090 05:23:59,452 --> 05:24:00,186 here and five of us can stick 10091 05:24:00,186 --> 05:24:04,386 it out, we'll get that done and 10092 05:24:04,990 --> 05:24:05,691 not have to not have to worry 10093 05:24:05,691 --> 05:24:06,292 about it tomorrow So please 10094 05:24:06,292 --> 05:24:06,993 proceed with not agenda. 10095 05:24:06,993 --> 05:24:07,660 Thank you Council PRESIDENT I 10096 05:24:07,660 --> 05:24:08,327 put the five minute timer up 10097 05:24:08,327 --> 05:24:11,927 Blair Big moment if you can 10098 05:24:13,466 --> 05:24:17,660 please unmute I think wow I 10099 05:24:19,505 --> 05:24:20,172 didn't know my had to come up. 10100 05:24:20,172 --> 05:24:20,572 I can speak so soon. 10101 05:24:20,572 --> 05:24:20,873 Excuse me. 10102 05:24:20,873 --> 05:24:22,873 Hi. 10103 05:24:26,511 --> 05:24:27,460 Thanks for the big meeting. 10104 05:24:27,460 --> 05:24:27,847 Really interesting. 10105 05:24:27,847 --> 05:24:30,583 I wanted to comment You had a I 10106 05:24:30,583 --> 05:24:31,350 did a meeting last week. 10107 05:24:31,350 --> 05:24:34,950 I talked about the future of 10108 05:24:37,190 --> 05:24:37,924 Wall Street replacement and 10109 05:24:37,924 --> 05:24:38,357 what all that entails and thank 10110 05:24:38,357 --> 05:24:40,357 you for that. 10111 05:24:44,300 --> 05:24:44,764 I think we're trying to play on 10112 05:24:44,764 --> 05:24:45,398 the quarterly the numeric 20 to 10113 05:24:45,398 --> 05:24:48,901 work on She wants a better 10114 05:24:48,901 --> 05:24:52,501 picture that she can be fixed 10115 05:24:53,740 --> 05:24:54,440 in San Diego used to be a five 10116 05:24:54,440 --> 05:24:58,400 month period now it's like an 10117 05:24:59,412 --> 05:25:00,113 18 month period and so that we 10118 05:25:00,113 --> 05:25:00,847 can better develop that San 10119 05:25:00,847 --> 05:25:01,414 Diego what we're gonna be doing 10120 05:25:01,414 --> 05:25:05,140 I think a lot of that 10121 05:25:06,318 --> 05:25:07,190 conversation has to be wrap up 10122 05:25:07,190 --> 05:25:07,720 thinking and the tech about 10123 05:25:07,720 --> 05:25:08,588 this all the smart street like 10124 05:25:08,588 --> 05:25:12,158 that I guess it's not going to 10125 05:25:12,158 --> 05:25:12,791 be there now so that will make 10126 05:25:12,791 --> 05:25:13,326 the process a lot easier. 10127 05:25:13,326 --> 05:25:15,726 Thank you for that. 10128 05:25:20,990 --> 05:25:20,833 I really hope you can come up 10129 05:25:20,833 --> 05:25:21,467 with a clear accountable policy 10130 05:25:21,467 --> 05:25:23,200 community how that you can 10131 05:25:23,200 --> 05:25:23,803 remove all of this tech You are 10132 05:25:23,803 --> 05:25:24,504 great today We got a lot more 10133 05:25:24,504 --> 05:25:25,205 to do so please be accountable 10134 05:25:25,205 --> 05:25:28,805 in the future with the public 10135 05:25:30,243 --> 05:25:30,910 on the project are slowly 10136 05:25:30,910 --> 05:25:31,444 leaving the tech What is it 10137 05:25:31,444 --> 05:25:33,844 going to be exactly? 10138 05:25:35,315 --> 05:25:35,949 >> To be honest I know I am and 10139 05:25:35,949 --> 05:25:36,682 I look foolish right now. 10140 05:25:36,682 --> 05:25:40,282 I offer some pretty basic steps 10141 05:25:40,286 --> 05:25:40,887 that I hope you guys can take 10142 05:25:40,887 --> 05:25:41,654 to heart if needed. 10143 05:25:41,654 --> 05:25:45,254 I also wanted to conclude with 10144 05:25:47,694 --> 05:25:51,294 Good luck with the county and 10145 05:25:52,599 --> 05:25:53,566 defer between police briefing 10146 05:25:53,566 --> 05:25:57,766 and the you know, the board how 10147 05:25:58,171 --> 05:25:58,972 that can work out, how you can 10148 05:25:58,972 --> 05:26:02,572 possibly be involved and be a 10149 05:26:03,776 --> 05:26:04,476 good role in the future of 10150 05:26:04,476 --> 05:26:05,145 sharing information with each 10151 05:26:05,145 --> 05:26:08,145 other and what that entails. 10152 05:26:10,160 --> 05:26:10,784 Today's meeting is important 10153 05:26:10,784 --> 05:26:11,484 step in better communication 10154 05:26:11,484 --> 05:26:12,151 and clarification that we all 10155 05:26:12,151 --> 05:26:15,751 need and how we move forward 10156 05:26:18,324 --> 05:26:19,250 together We're going to be 10157 05:26:19,250 --> 05:26:19,726 talking to each other in more 10158 05:26:19,726 --> 05:26:20,260 human terms to what we can be 10159 05:26:20,260 --> 05:26:20,360 doing. 10160 05:26:20,360 --> 05:26:22,360 >> Okay. 10161 05:26:22,995 --> 05:26:23,963 Your time has concluded 130 if 10162 05:26:23,963 --> 05:26:28,163 you can please on you in one 10163 05:26:34,873 --> 05:26:35,675 three one three you are unmuted 10164 05:26:35,675 --> 05:26:36,176 but we do not hear you here in 10165 05:26:36,176 --> 05:26:36,810 council chambers. 10166 05:26:36,810 --> 05:26:39,579 I'm sure the device you're 10167 05:26:39,579 --> 05:26:40,800 speaking in to me Clerk Okay, 10168 05:26:40,800 --> 05:26:40,814 sorry about that. 10169 05:26:40,814 --> 05:26:41,548 >> And before you start my time 10170 05:26:41,548 --> 05:26:42,182 where's the equity And you have 10171 05:26:42,182 --> 05:26:44,582 one speaker talking about 10172 05:26:45,785 --> 05:26:46,519 something touching based on 10173 05:26:46,519 --> 05:26:47,186 something then you have another 10174 05:26:47,186 --> 05:26:47,587 speaker for doing the exact 10175 05:26:47,587 --> 05:26:49,587 same thing. 10176 05:26:51,825 --> 05:26:52,158 It's just kind of like where we 10177 05:26:52,158 --> 05:26:52,759 come on. 10178 05:26:52,759 --> 05:26:53,590 Okay, I'll answer that. 10179 05:26:53,590 --> 05:26:55,590 Yeah. 10180 05:26:56,996 --> 05:26:57,831 Answer it. 10181 05:26:57,831 --> 05:26:58,498 >> I stepped away and went to 10182 05:26:58,498 --> 05:26:59,199 the restroom and I heard his 10183 05:26:59,199 --> 05:26:59,866 comments and they were totally 10184 05:26:59,866 --> 05:27:02,266 inappropriate for not agenda 10185 05:27:03,303 --> 05:27:03,969 public comment And I wasn't 10186 05:27:03,969 --> 05:27:04,604 here to interfere with that. 10187 05:27:04,604 --> 05:27:07,604 Audra, you were on point. 10188 05:27:08,474 --> 05:27:08,808 You got where you needed to go 10189 05:27:08,808 --> 05:27:09,475 . 10190 05:27:09,475 --> 05:27:09,776 That previous caller was off 10191 05:27:09,776 --> 05:27:10,443 base. 10192 05:27:10,443 --> 05:27:10,777 This is not a general public 10193 05:27:10,777 --> 05:27:12,777 comment. 10194 05:27:14,180 --> 05:27:14,881 Please do not talk about 10195 05:27:14,881 --> 05:27:15,549 surveillance or any aspect of 10196 05:27:15,549 --> 05:27:15,849 that on the rollout or next 10197 05:27:15,849 --> 05:27:17,849 steps. 10198 05:27:20,120 --> 05:27:20,954 So you were right. 10199 05:27:20,954 --> 05:27:21,454 >> I stepped away and I missed 10200 05:27:21,454 --> 05:27:23,454 that opportunity. 10201 05:27:26,826 --> 05:27:27,593 Thank you, Joe. 10202 05:27:27,593 --> 05:27:28,128 And you know what also great 10203 05:27:28,128 --> 05:27:28,828 performances today. 10204 05:27:28,828 --> 05:27:32,428 You all care more about saving 10205 05:27:32,432 --> 05:27:33,990 your own political careers and 10206 05:27:33,990 --> 05:27:33,800 saving the lives of people. 10207 05:27:33,800 --> 05:27:36,800 The conversation is not over. 10208 05:27:38,972 --> 05:27:39,672 Those of you who have voted for 10209 05:27:39,672 --> 05:27:40,373 the alp in the first place 10210 05:27:40,373 --> 05:27:41,141 still have blood on your hands 10211 05:27:41,141 --> 05:27:44,741 and some have even moved up 10212 05:27:45,212 --> 05:27:45,879 the political ladder like Marty 10213 05:27:45,879 --> 05:27:46,613 Where's the accountability? 10214 05:27:46,613 --> 05:27:46,947 You just say Well see we made a 10215 05:27:46,947 --> 05:27:48,947 mistake. 10216 05:27:50,617 --> 05:27:51,317 We're now going to act like we 10217 05:27:51,317 --> 05:27:51,885 learned our lesson and we're 10218 05:27:51,885 --> 05:27:52,586 now going to listen to 10219 05:27:52,586 --> 05:27:56,186 the people and pretend we have 10220 05:27:56,423 --> 05:27:57,900 no matter when actuality it's 10221 05:27:57,900 --> 05:27:57,690 the tax dollars that matter 10222 05:27:57,690 --> 05:27:58,258 most to the bloodsucking 10223 05:27:58,258 --> 05:28:00,658 parasites who work for 10224 05:28:02,863 --> 05:28:03,530 globalists. 10225 05:28:03,530 --> 05:28:03,930 I repeat you work for 10226 05:28:03,930 --> 05:28:04,631 globalists. 10227 05:28:04,631 --> 05:28:08,100 Stop lying because all of them 10228 05:28:08,100 --> 05:28:08,869 left over there. 10229 05:28:08,869 --> 05:28:09,536 I already know they all left. 10230 05:28:09,536 --> 05:28:13,136 Saving Face is the name of 10231 05:28:14,174 --> 05:28:14,841 the game keeping the people 10232 05:28:14,841 --> 05:28:15,375 believing in your system is 10233 05:28:15,375 --> 05:28:17,775 what it's all about. 10234 05:28:19,579 --> 05:28:20,112 And Sean you claim you care 10235 05:28:20,112 --> 05:28:20,713 about public safety. 10236 05:28:20,713 --> 05:28:21,248 You continue working for 10237 05:28:21,248 --> 05:28:21,782 globalists and their 10238 05:28:21,782 --> 05:28:23,782 controlling agenda. 10239 05:28:26,453 --> 05:28:27,187 You personally have so many 10240 05:28:27,187 --> 05:28:27,888 fooled You just stated you want 10241 05:28:27,888 --> 05:28:31,488 the council to have eyes wide 10242 05:28:31,991 --> 05:28:32,693 open while keeping 10243 05:28:32,693 --> 05:28:33,392 the taxpayers eye tightly shut 10244 05:28:33,392 --> 05:28:36,992 Everything you all do That is 10245 05:28:37,330 --> 05:28:38,310 how it's all executed. 10246 05:28:38,310 --> 05:28:40,431 It's entirely sickening to 10247 05:28:43,870 --> 05:28:44,471 witness with my eyes wide open 10248 05:28:44,471 --> 05:28:44,905 but that feeling doesn't 10249 05:28:44,905 --> 05:28:45,539 discourage me. 10250 05:28:45,539 --> 05:28:46,272 I swear to GOD it actually 10251 05:28:46,272 --> 05:28:49,272 fueled me to make sure 10252 05:28:50,244 --> 05:28:50,744 the people know what you all 10253 05:28:50,744 --> 05:28:51,411 are really doing. 10254 05:28:51,411 --> 05:28:53,811 It's self-serving not public 10255 05:28:56,316 --> 05:28:56,917 serving your service is to 10256 05:28:56,917 --> 05:28:57,584 actually promote further 10257 05:28:57,584 --> 05:28:58,252 servitude of the taxpayers. 10258 05:28:58,252 --> 05:29:01,252 I have absolutely no respect 10259 05:29:02,222 --> 05:29:02,990 for any of you. 10260 05:29:02,990 --> 05:29:03,690 Watch out because way too many 10261 05:29:03,690 --> 05:29:04,391 have suffered under your watch 10262 05:29:04,391 --> 05:29:07,991 and the people will make sure 10263 05:29:08,395 --> 05:29:08,829 you okay for the policies that 10264 05:29:08,829 --> 05:29:10,829 you've pushed. 10265 05:29:14,668 --> 05:29:15,335 >> I'm done. 10266 05:29:15,335 --> 05:29:15,702 There are 14 speakers in 10267 05:29:15,702 --> 05:29:16,336 the queue. 10268 05:29:16,336 --> 05:29:16,636 The five minute timer has 10269 05:29:16,636 --> 05:29:17,337 ended. 10270 05:29:17,337 --> 05:29:18,370 No additional speakers will be 10271 05:29:18,370 --> 05:29:21,637 taken Million mile man If you 10272 05:29:24,144 --> 05:29:27,144 can please unmute I didn't 10273 05:29:29,617 --> 05:29:32,617 understand one word the last 10274 05:29:34,988 --> 05:29:36,560 speaker uttered I'm sorry maybe 10275 05:29:36,560 --> 05:29:40,856 I'm too old but I would like to 10276 05:29:41,829 --> 05:29:44,229 congratulate Nicole Crosby on 10277 05:29:47,300 --> 05:29:47,935 her election. 10278 05:29:47,935 --> 05:29:51,535 I voted for her because I 10279 05:29:53,974 --> 05:29:57,574 thought about my mother and her 10280 05:30:04,500 --> 05:30:04,818 family in World War Two Right 10281 05:30:04,818 --> 05:30:07,818 now near just kilometers away 10282 05:30:15,462 --> 05:30:16,130 from Omaha Beach and German 10283 05:30:16,130 --> 05:30:16,830 storm troopers took away her 10284 05:30:16,830 --> 05:30:19,830 family with no due process, 10285 05:30:21,435 --> 05:30:22,235 nothing. 10286 05:30:22,235 --> 05:30:25,835 And I voted for Nicole Crosby 10287 05:30:28,142 --> 05:30:28,875 because of that And MR. Camp 10288 05:30:28,875 --> 05:30:29,309 Bill MR. Camp Bill, I hope you 10289 05:30:29,309 --> 05:30:31,309 can hear me. 10290 05:30:33,347 --> 05:30:34,415 I want you to listen to me. 10291 05:30:34,415 --> 05:30:38,615 On AUGUST 1st I was put under 10292 05:30:39,620 --> 05:30:42,620 self arrest in Rebel Springs, 10293 05:30:45,159 --> 05:30:45,893 California for a horrible, 10294 05:30:45,893 --> 05:30:48,293 horrible, despicable crime that 10295 05:30:51,966 --> 05:30:52,666 I never committed And 10296 05:30:52,666 --> 05:30:55,666 the deputy handcuffed me and 10297 05:30:58,380 --> 05:31:00,438 drove me 100 miles to 10298 05:31:03,678 --> 05:31:04,378 the detention and my 10299 05:31:04,378 --> 05:31:04,979 arraignment date was canceled. 10300 05:31:04,979 --> 05:31:07,979 That was two months ago. 10301 05:31:09,917 --> 05:31:10,718 i haven't heard anything about 10302 05:31:10,718 --> 05:31:14,318 a dismissal And if you're a 10303 05:31:15,589 --> 05:31:16,223 former prosecutor you tell 10304 05:31:16,223 --> 05:31:18,623 every prosecutor on planet 10305 05:31:21,395 --> 05:31:22,263 Earth that I'll fight with 10306 05:31:22,263 --> 05:31:26,463 every shred of my body to prove 10307 05:31:26,901 --> 05:31:27,368 that I never committed this 10308 05:31:27,368 --> 05:31:27,768 horrible crime. 10309 05:31:27,768 --> 05:31:29,768 I never did. 10310 05:31:31,906 --> 05:31:34,906 Your time has concluded 7234 If 10311 05:31:38,112 --> 05:31:38,979 you can please unmute. 10312 05:31:38,979 --> 05:31:41,979 >> Good evening San Diego City 10313 05:31:44,652 --> 05:31:44,986 Council My name is Terri and 10314 05:31:44,986 --> 05:31:45,520 Skelly. 10315 05:31:45,520 --> 05:31:46,153 I called in to share 10316 05:31:46,153 --> 05:31:48,153 the information regarding 10317 05:31:50,291 --> 05:31:51,580 NOVEMBER and lung cancer 10318 05:31:51,580 --> 05:31:51,758 Awareness Month I received as I 10319 05:31:51,758 --> 05:31:54,758 received because I'm a health 10320 05:31:55,795 --> 05:31:56,597 care educator. 10321 05:31:56,597 --> 05:31:57,231 Lung cancer is the third most 10322 05:31:57,231 --> 05:31:59,631 common cancer diagnosed in 10323 05:32:01,702 --> 05:32:02,369 the United States but it is by 10324 05:32:02,369 --> 05:32:03,170 far the leading cause of all 10325 05:32:03,170 --> 05:32:06,770 cancer deaths for both men and 10326 05:32:07,241 --> 05:32:08,175 women. 10327 05:32:08,175 --> 05:32:08,876 About 1 in 90 people will be 10328 05:32:08,876 --> 05:32:11,876 diagnosed with lung cancer in 10329 05:32:13,313 --> 05:32:14,182 their lifetime. 10330 05:32:14,182 --> 05:32:14,915 Only about 15 to 20% of lung 10331 05:32:14,915 --> 05:32:17,915 cancer diseases occur in people 10332 05:32:19,287 --> 05:32:20,880 who have never smoked which 10333 05:32:20,880 --> 05:32:20,755 means that 80 to 85% of those 10334 05:32:20,755 --> 05:32:23,155 diagnosed with lung cancer 10335 05:32:25,760 --> 05:32:26,360 smoked or beat the American 10336 05:32:26,360 --> 05:32:28,360 Lung Cancer Association. 10337 05:32:31,832 --> 05:32:32,566 The ala States that marijuana 10338 05:32:32,566 --> 05:32:33,134 smoke contains many of the same 10339 05:32:33,134 --> 05:32:35,134 toxins, irritants and 10340 05:32:37,839 --> 05:32:38,573 carcinogens as tobacco smoke 10341 05:32:38,573 --> 05:32:42,173 which we also know that smoking 10342 05:32:44,645 --> 05:32:45,246 marijuana clearly damages human 10343 05:32:45,246 --> 05:32:45,946 lungs leading to chronic 10344 05:32:45,946 --> 05:32:47,946 bronchitis, lightning injury, 10345 05:32:51,586 --> 05:32:52,119 chronic cough and wheezing due 10346 05:32:52,119 --> 05:32:52,654 to the known risk to 10347 05:32:52,654 --> 05:32:54,654 respiratory health. 10348 05:32:56,924 --> 05:32:57,557 The American Lung Association 10349 05:32:57,557 --> 05:32:58,226 strongly cautions against 10350 05:32:58,226 --> 05:33:00,626 smoking or vaping marijuana. 10351 05:33:03,970 --> 05:33:03,797 What can policymakers do to 10352 05:33:03,797 --> 05:33:04,499 decrease lung disease and lung 10353 05:33:04,499 --> 05:33:08,990 cancer in the non smoking non 10354 05:33:09,102 --> 05:33:09,737 vaping residents We policies 10355 05:33:09,737 --> 05:33:10,338 that decrease exposure to 10356 05:33:10,338 --> 05:33:12,338 secondhand and thirdhand 10357 05:33:15,643 --> 05:33:16,277 marijuana and tobacco smoke and 10358 05:33:16,277 --> 05:33:19,277 paper bike smoke free free 10359 05:33:20,982 --> 05:33:21,582 outdoor dining public places 10360 05:33:21,582 --> 05:33:22,516 and apartment complexes. 10361 05:33:22,516 --> 05:33:26,716 Thank you City San Diego a city 10362 05:33:27,522 --> 05:33:28,155 council for your important step 10363 05:33:28,155 --> 05:33:28,857 in improving the health of 10364 05:33:28,857 --> 05:33:31,857 the city's residents with your 10365 05:33:34,262 --> 05:33:34,896 ban of smoking and vaping and 10366 05:33:34,896 --> 05:33:36,896 eating establishments and 10367 05:33:39,601 --> 05:33:39,934 giving me my concerns This 10368 05:33:39,934 --> 05:33:40,301 evening. 10369 05:33:40,301 --> 05:33:42,301 Thank you. 10370 05:33:47,809 --> 05:33:48,149 Next is Francis Yasmeen with me 10371 05:33:48,149 --> 05:33:48,977 again? 10372 05:33:48,977 --> 05:33:52,280 I wanted to say a couple words 10373 05:33:52,280 --> 05:33:52,781 about what safety really is as 10374 05:33:52,781 --> 05:33:53,514 we're having these 10375 05:33:53,514 --> 05:33:54,480 conversations about getting rid 10376 05:33:54,480 --> 05:33:56,480 of the surveillance. 10377 05:33:57,785 --> 05:33:58,486 I think that there's a couple 10378 05:33:58,486 --> 05:34:02,860 of things I want to propose. 10379 05:34:03,625 --> 05:34:04,325 One is we could hire human 10380 05:34:04,325 --> 05:34:04,992 being San Diego residents to 10381 05:34:04,992 --> 05:34:07,992 work as like community watch 10382 05:34:09,731 --> 05:34:10,465 people or give them all a 10383 05:34:10,465 --> 05:34:13,465 walkie talkie and create shifts 10384 05:34:15,804 --> 05:34:16,438 where people are patrolling 10385 05:34:16,438 --> 05:34:17,720 parts of neighborhoods and 10386 05:34:17,720 --> 05:34:17,806 doing the work of not just 10387 05:34:17,806 --> 05:34:20,206 surveilling people but actually 10388 05:34:22,310 --> 05:34:22,944 being there to help people and 10389 05:34:22,944 --> 05:34:23,511 preventing preventing bad 10390 05:34:23,511 --> 05:34:25,511 things from happening. 10391 05:34:28,116 --> 05:34:28,816 And I would love to see those 10392 05:34:28,816 --> 05:34:29,417 jobs created in us, you know, 10393 05:34:29,417 --> 05:34:31,817 especially in this age. 10394 05:34:34,890 --> 05:34:34,456 Where you going to be taking so 10395 05:34:34,456 --> 05:34:35,190 many jobs? 10396 05:34:35,190 --> 05:34:35,623 Let's get back to paying humans 10397 05:34:35,623 --> 05:34:37,623 to do things. 10398 05:34:39,728 --> 05:34:40,428 I also want to say you know, a 10399 05:34:40,428 --> 05:34:41,129 huge way to increase security 10400 05:34:41,129 --> 05:34:44,129 right now and it's desperately 10401 05:34:45,333 --> 05:34:45,967 needed by so many civilians Is 10402 05:34:45,967 --> 05:34:46,701 sleep safe sleeping sites. 10403 05:34:46,701 --> 05:34:50,301 The weather is starting to get 10404 05:34:51,139 --> 05:34:51,806 cold. 10405 05:34:51,806 --> 05:34:52,473 More and more people are 10406 05:34:52,473 --> 05:34:55,473 falling into debt and losing 10407 05:34:56,744 --> 05:34:57,780 their housing, food insecurity 10408 05:34:57,780 --> 05:34:57,845 is high. 10409 05:34:57,845 --> 05:35:01,445 We know that every dollar spent 10410 05:35:03,117 --> 05:35:03,985 on providing safe places for 10411 05:35:03,985 --> 05:35:07,585 people to sleep and not just 10412 05:35:09,257 --> 05:35:09,891 for current situation where 10413 05:35:09,891 --> 05:35:10,592 I've heard just nightmare 10414 05:35:10,592 --> 05:35:13,592 stories about what's going on 10415 05:35:15,363 --> 05:35:16,640 in the in the shelters in 10416 05:35:16,640 --> 05:35:16,698 Bellville Park and how unsafe 10417 05:35:16,698 --> 05:35:19,698 those fuel on the inside. 10418 05:35:21,336 --> 05:35:22,300 So I really want to just say we 10419 05:35:22,300 --> 05:35:25,300 can put our heads together, 10420 05:35:26,575 --> 05:35:27,242 find some empty lots and create 10421 05:35:27,242 --> 05:35:27,843 both safe parking spots and 10422 05:35:27,843 --> 05:35:30,243 more safe sleeping sites 10423 05:35:33,140 --> 05:35:33,681 because people are getting beat 10424 05:35:33,681 --> 05:35:36,681 up, mugged, raped all these 10425 05:35:38,520 --> 05:35:39,320 things just because they don't 10426 05:35:39,320 --> 05:35:39,821 have a roof over their head and 10427 05:35:39,821 --> 05:35:40,422 walls around them. 10428 05:35:40,422 --> 05:35:43,422 So let's invest in that. 10429 05:35:45,327 --> 05:35:46,280 Thank you so much. 10430 05:35:46,280 --> 05:35:46,695 Also I guess the marijuana I 10431 05:35:46,695 --> 05:35:49,950 think we protect marijuana 10432 05:35:54,503 --> 05:35:55,571 smokers rights but thank you on 10433 05:35:55,571 --> 05:35:58,571 exit 74997499 If you can please 10434 05:36:04,312 --> 05:36:04,746 unmute please play my video Bob 10435 05:36:04,746 --> 05:36:06,746 Kozinski here. 10436 05:36:12,154 --> 05:36:13,210 Tell me if you can please tell 10437 05:36:13,210 --> 05:36:13,522 me if you need to move on to 10438 05:36:13,522 --> 05:36:15,522 the next speaker. 10439 05:36:17,759 --> 05:36:18,427 This is Kathleen Lippert, Cathy 10440 05:36:18,427 --> 05:36:19,461 with it if you can please. 10441 05:36:19,461 --> 05:36:23,165 I mean for me to move on to 10442 05:36:23,165 --> 05:36:23,932 the next caller Carla if you 10443 05:36:23,932 --> 05:36:28,132 can please and you I can't I 10444 05:36:28,270 --> 05:36:29,137 mean for you if you cannot 10445 05:36:29,137 --> 05:36:29,671 unmute, we will need to move on 10446 05:36:29,671 --> 05:36:30,405 to the next speaker. 10447 05:36:30,405 --> 05:36:34,605 So move on to the next speaker. 10448 05:36:34,643 --> 05:36:35,344 Next is Andrew If you can 10449 05:36:35,344 --> 05:36:36,440 please unmute I want you to 10450 05:36:36,440 --> 05:36:40,244 move on to the next caller if 10451 05:36:41,316 --> 05:36:42,170 you can on you Tony please 10452 05:36:42,170 --> 05:36:42,717 unmute Tony Academy before you 10453 05:36:42,717 --> 05:36:43,520 I want to move on to the next 10454 05:36:43,520 --> 05:36:45,520 caller. 10455 05:36:45,721 --> 05:36:46,521 If you can't meet for yourself 10456 05:36:46,521 --> 05:36:47,155 Those were just a few recent 10457 05:36:47,155 --> 05:36:47,789 examples of the commuting 10458 05:36:47,789 --> 05:36:50,189 problem for remote public 10459 05:36:52,561 --> 05:36:53,228 speakers in response to this 10460 05:36:53,228 --> 05:36:53,929 problem I began producing my 10461 05:36:53,929 --> 05:36:54,663 non agenda comments as videos 10462 05:36:54,663 --> 05:36:58,263 so they could be played whether 10463 05:36:59,167 --> 05:36:59,902 I could unmute or not But 10464 05:36:59,902 --> 05:37:00,736 ironically clicks on days has a 10465 05:37:00,736 --> 05:37:04,336 policy that she won't play it 10466 05:37:04,406 --> 05:37:05,700 pretty submitted video without 10467 05:37:05,700 --> 05:37:08,700 the caller first I knew 10468 05:37:09,712 --> 05:37:10,345 the solution City clerk but 10469 05:37:10,345 --> 05:37:11,130 it's gotten even worse for 10470 05:37:11,130 --> 05:37:11,680 decades Citizens could just 10471 05:37:11,680 --> 05:37:15,280 bring media to be played to 10472 05:37:15,551 --> 05:37:16,510 council and the clerk's office 10473 05:37:16,510 --> 05:37:16,652 would play it. 10474 05:37:16,652 --> 05:37:17,252 There were no advanced 10475 05:37:17,252 --> 05:37:17,987 submission requirements. 10476 05:37:17,987 --> 05:37:22,187 I mean it could be submitted in 10477 05:37:22,825 --> 05:37:23,525 council chambers right along 10478 05:37:23,525 --> 05:37:23,993 with a speaker slip and it 10479 05:37:23,993 --> 05:37:24,693 would be placed. 10480 05:37:24,693 --> 05:37:27,863 But now clerks one day doesn't 10481 05:37:27,863 --> 05:37:28,330 accept any media in council 10482 05:37:28,330 --> 05:37:29,980 chambers at all. 10483 05:37:29,980 --> 05:37:32,698 All media has to be submitted 10484 05:37:33,168 --> 05:37:33,902 via the internet by 8 A.M. 10485 05:37:33,902 --> 05:37:34,503 Which can be eight hours before 10486 05:37:34,503 --> 05:37:37,503 the item is even called. 10487 05:37:39,808 --> 05:37:40,442 How does this council react to 10488 05:37:40,442 --> 05:37:41,760 things making it even more 10489 05:37:41,760 --> 05:37:41,377 difficult for citizens to 10490 05:37:41,377 --> 05:37:43,377 speak? 10491 05:37:44,246 --> 05:37:44,913 What I ask my colleagues to 10492 05:37:44,913 --> 05:37:45,548 join me in thanking the city 10493 05:37:45,548 --> 05:37:47,783 clerk and the city clerk's 10494 05:37:47,783 --> 05:37:51,983 staff for the work they do each 10495 05:37:54,190 --> 05:37:54,790 and every day And the work of 10496 05:37:54,790 --> 05:37:57,790 that Joe LaCava is that 10497 05:37:59,962 --> 05:38:00,629 the work of making it even more 10498 05:38:00,629 --> 05:38:01,363 difficult for the public to 10499 05:38:01,363 --> 05:38:04,963 speak and be heard in these 10500 05:38:06,268 --> 05:38:06,935 chambers I will note that 10501 05:38:06,935 --> 05:38:09,335 previously people could not 10502 05:38:12,207 --> 05:38:12,942 actually provide videos if they 10503 05:38:12,942 --> 05:38:13,609 were participating remotely and 10504 05:38:13,609 --> 05:38:13,943 encourage everyone to please 10505 05:38:13,943 --> 05:38:15,943 submit. 10506 05:38:17,947 --> 05:38:18,280 Judy Strang If you can please 10507 05:38:18,280 --> 05:38:20,280 unmute. 10508 05:38:23,152 --> 05:38:23,752 >> Good evening San Diego City 10509 05:38:23,752 --> 05:38:24,419 Council Thank you for 10510 05:38:24,419 --> 05:38:24,953 the previous discussion this 10511 05:38:24,953 --> 05:38:25,387 afternoon regarding 10512 05:38:25,387 --> 05:38:27,387 surveillance. 10513 05:38:29,725 --> 05:38:30,526 It was very thought provoking 10514 05:38:30,526 --> 05:38:31,193 on a whole lot of levels but I 10515 05:38:31,193 --> 05:38:34,193 just wanted to call your 10516 05:38:34,797 --> 05:38:35,531 attention that Thursday the 19 10517 05:38:35,531 --> 05:38:39,131 is excuse me a great American 10518 05:38:41,690 --> 05:38:41,470 smoke out It's their 50th year 10519 05:38:41,470 --> 05:38:42,138 anniversary. 10520 05:38:42,138 --> 05:38:42,605 It's hosted by the American 10521 05:38:42,605 --> 05:38:43,272 Cancer Society. 10522 05:38:43,272 --> 05:38:46,272 It's to encourage people to 10523 05:38:47,209 --> 05:38:48,770 begin their quit journey quit 10524 05:38:48,770 --> 05:38:51,677 journey and and to create a 10525 05:38:53,820 --> 05:38:54,500 quit plan. 10526 05:38:54,500 --> 05:38:54,817 And part of that strategy is to 10527 05:38:54,817 --> 05:38:57,817 identify what are your personal 10528 05:39:00,220 --> 05:39:00,723 smoking or vaping triggers and 10529 05:39:00,723 --> 05:39:01,900 how to prepare to manage your 10530 05:39:01,900 --> 05:39:03,900 cravings. 10531 05:39:05,227 --> 05:39:05,962 I would like to respectfully 10532 05:39:05,962 --> 05:39:06,629 suggest that one of the issues 10533 05:39:06,629 --> 05:39:07,196 associated with triggers is 10534 05:39:07,196 --> 05:39:10,196 what they see in their 10535 05:39:12,301 --> 05:39:12,835 community and establishments in 10536 05:39:12,835 --> 05:39:13,669 their neighborhoods. 10537 05:39:13,669 --> 05:39:17,269 We don't need more marijuana or 10538 05:39:17,906 --> 05:39:18,641 tobacco stores in our 10539 05:39:18,641 --> 05:39:19,341 neighborhoods and we definitely 10540 05:39:19,341 --> 05:39:19,942 don't need the billboards And 10541 05:39:19,942 --> 05:39:22,942 it's perhaps in honor of 10542 05:39:23,779 --> 05:39:24,479 the great American spoke out in 10543 05:39:24,479 --> 05:39:25,181 the work that it is to avoid 10544 05:39:25,181 --> 05:39:27,581 having your triggers triggered 10545 05:39:29,585 --> 05:39:30,153 if you will that we might 10546 05:39:30,153 --> 05:39:30,786 consider removing all 10547 05:39:30,786 --> 05:39:32,786 billboards that advertise 10548 05:39:37,660 --> 05:39:38,270 marijuana smoking and vaping 10549 05:39:38,270 --> 05:39:38,461 products. 10550 05:39:38,461 --> 05:39:38,828 >> Thank you. 10551 05:39:38,828 --> 05:39:39,695 Thank you. 10552 05:39:39,695 --> 05:39:43,295 Your next is to a completely 10553 05:39:44,500 --> 05:39:45,334 new thanks. 10554 05:39:45,334 --> 05:39:46,169 >> I'd like to call the board's 10555 05:39:46,169 --> 05:39:49,769 attention to our sister city in 10556 05:39:50,339 --> 05:39:50,940 France right now The Gotham 10557 05:39:50,940 --> 05:39:51,407 City Hall burned down by 10558 05:39:51,407 --> 05:39:53,407 the Muslim mob. 10559 05:39:56,212 --> 05:39:56,579 All these immigrants are going 10560 05:39:56,579 --> 05:39:57,380 after it. 10561 05:39:57,380 --> 05:40:01,450 So I propose our city to be 10562 05:40:01,450 --> 05:40:02,317 the first city to ban Sharia 10563 05:40:02,317 --> 05:40:02,986 law in San Diego City and ban 10564 05:40:02,986 --> 05:40:05,986 the call to prayer being 10565 05:40:08,357 --> 05:40:09,158 broadcast on any mosque. 10566 05:40:09,158 --> 05:40:09,558 We got to cut down on 10567 05:40:09,558 --> 05:40:11,558 the mosques. 10568 05:40:14,263 --> 05:40:14,730 We've got to do this thing and 10569 05:40:14,730 --> 05:40:15,631 welcome him in. 10570 05:40:15,631 --> 05:40:18,935 And the Muslim guys are not our 10571 05:40:18,935 --> 05:40:19,669 friends. 10572 05:40:19,669 --> 05:40:20,200 They're against the Bill of 10573 05:40:20,200 --> 05:40:20,670 Rights. 10574 05:40:20,670 --> 05:40:21,360 They want to implement their 10575 05:40:21,360 --> 05:40:23,360 own laws. 10576 05:40:25,508 --> 05:40:26,209 They're smiling and they're 10577 05:40:26,209 --> 05:40:26,576 lying their religion or their 10578 05:40:26,576 --> 05:40:28,576 religion. 10579 05:40:30,947 --> 05:40:31,614 But it's more like a cult. 10580 05:40:31,614 --> 05:40:32,348 It's even worse than 10581 05:40:32,348 --> 05:40:34,748 Scientology cult in Scientology 10582 05:40:37,200 --> 05:40:37,353 they don't kill you if you're a 10583 05:40:37,353 --> 05:40:37,987 muslim. 10584 05:40:37,987 --> 05:40:38,421 You beat the Muslim faith. 10585 05:40:38,421 --> 05:40:40,421 They kill you. 10586 05:40:42,992 --> 05:40:43,660 So it's like it's a cult. 10587 05:40:43,660 --> 05:40:43,993 It's not And they're just 10588 05:40:43,993 --> 05:40:44,694 smiling. 10589 05:40:44,694 --> 05:40:47,564 They're trying to weasel their 10590 05:40:47,564 --> 05:40:48,331 way into Texas now they've got 10591 05:40:48,331 --> 05:40:48,831 all that Now they're coming for 10592 05:40:48,831 --> 05:40:50,831 San Diego County. 10593 05:40:54,103 --> 05:40:54,904 I say we put a cease and desist 10594 05:40:54,904 --> 05:40:58,504 on Panama and that care program 10595 05:40:59,142 --> 05:40:59,709 in Florida Care money for care 10596 05:40:59,709 --> 05:41:00,343 is a terrorist group. 10597 05:41:00,343 --> 05:41:02,743 That's what Florida says. 10598 05:41:04,848 --> 05:41:05,514 So their money is tainted. 10599 05:41:05,514 --> 05:41:08,514 Plus the mosque in Claremont 10600 05:41:09,419 --> 05:41:10,120 was called home to the two 10601 05:41:10,120 --> 05:41:13,120 terrorists at 911 For one year 10602 05:41:15,392 --> 05:41:16,158 they went to that mosque and 10603 05:41:16,158 --> 05:41:16,826 they lived in Claremont on off 10604 05:41:16,826 --> 05:41:17,126 Dakota Street like Claremont 10605 05:41:17,126 --> 05:41:19,126 Drive. 10606 05:41:20,563 --> 05:41:21,330 They lived there for a year. 10607 05:41:21,330 --> 05:41:24,930 So those guys are aligned with 10608 05:41:26,235 --> 05:41:26,770 911 terrorist attacks, two guys 10609 05:41:26,770 --> 05:41:27,470 with a mosque there. 10610 05:41:27,470 --> 05:41:28,271 So ask the guys at the mosque 10611 05:41:28,271 --> 05:41:31,207 How many times have you said 10612 05:41:31,207 --> 05:41:31,674 death to Jews, Death to America 10613 05:41:31,674 --> 05:41:32,375 this last week? 10614 05:41:32,375 --> 05:41:35,975 How many times have they said 10615 05:41:37,380 --> 05:41:38,414 it this last week? 10616 05:41:38,414 --> 05:41:38,782 I bet you they did a lot more 10617 05:41:38,782 --> 05:41:40,782 than once. 10618 05:41:41,517 --> 05:41:42,252 You should asking them how many 10619 05:41:42,252 --> 05:41:42,952 when they come to the board. 10620 05:41:42,952 --> 05:41:46,552 When's the last time you said 10621 05:41:47,790 --> 05:41:48,458 death to Israel before they 10622 05:41:48,458 --> 05:41:49,259 could speak your time which 10623 05:41:49,259 --> 05:41:52,259 included 8700 If you can please 10624 05:41:59,335 --> 05:42:02,335 unmute the PRESIDENT Please let 10625 05:42:04,400 --> 05:42:04,341 me know if I step on your toes. 10626 05:42:04,341 --> 05:42:06,341 Okay. 10627 05:42:08,879 --> 05:42:09,546 So about the agenda item today 10628 05:42:09,546 --> 05:42:10,346 I'm not speaking to the item 10629 05:42:10,346 --> 05:42:14,170 but I'm sort of giving a bird's 10630 05:42:14,170 --> 05:42:14,718 eye view of a couple of things 10631 05:42:14,718 --> 05:42:17,718 that really aren't the agenda 10632 05:42:19,623 --> 05:42:20,323 item for say to what I felt 10633 05:42:20,323 --> 05:42:23,923 going to the council was fear 10634 05:42:24,628 --> 05:42:25,428 among the council members and 10635 05:42:25,428 --> 05:42:26,960 it's a normal thing to have and 10636 05:42:26,960 --> 05:42:28,496 that's what surveillance is 10637 05:42:30,667 --> 05:42:34,267 doing to the public and you're 10638 05:42:35,939 --> 05:42:36,639 how you move to other items in 10639 05:42:36,639 --> 05:42:37,507 that agenda item that I didn't 10640 05:42:37,507 --> 05:42:41,107 expect It spoke to me about 10641 05:42:41,744 --> 05:42:42,545 security It is or what has 10642 05:42:42,545 --> 05:42:46,745 happened to a lot of you and 10643 05:42:47,250 --> 05:42:47,951 perhaps your family members to 10644 05:42:47,951 --> 05:42:48,717 look to you on that. 10645 05:42:48,717 --> 05:42:52,222 He and you spoke with somebody 10646 05:42:52,222 --> 05:42:54,622 today who's extremely genius 10647 05:42:57,127 --> 05:42:57,828 level on the eye and think that 10648 05:42:57,828 --> 05:42:58,528 right now what we're speaking 10649 05:42:58,528 --> 05:43:01,528 about is difficult to manage. 10650 05:43:03,467 --> 05:43:04,167 Wait until the eye becomes 10651 05:43:04,167 --> 05:43:06,567 conscious and they're getting 10652 05:43:07,204 --> 05:43:08,710 close and they'll be able to 10653 05:43:08,710 --> 05:43:08,771 say I will be able to make 10654 05:43:08,771 --> 05:43:11,171 their own conscious decisions. 10655 05:43:14,477 --> 05:43:15,780 The woman and the baby, 10656 05:43:15,780 --> 05:43:15,812 the beautiful woman and 10657 05:43:15,812 --> 05:43:18,248 the babies need to come to them 10658 05:43:18,248 --> 05:43:21,848 to feel because that will stand 10659 05:43:22,953 --> 05:43:26,553 out in my mind maybe forever 10660 05:43:26,656 --> 05:43:27,324 Because when she said that 10661 05:43:27,324 --> 05:43:28,580 these two were never trust 10662 05:43:28,580 --> 05:43:31,580 the San Diego Police Department 10663 05:43:33,196 --> 05:43:34,164 I totally was stunned. 10664 05:43:34,164 --> 05:43:37,764 So I thank you Council member 10665 05:43:38,340 --> 05:43:38,701 feel for pointing that out. 10666 05:43:38,701 --> 05:43:41,701 That really touched my heart 10667 05:43:42,940 --> 05:43:43,640 that you recognize that to know 10668 05:43:43,640 --> 05:43:46,400 you brilliant lawyers please 10669 05:43:48,345 --> 05:43:49,246 settle down a little bit. 10670 05:43:49,246 --> 05:43:50,130 You're so good that you blow me 10671 05:43:50,130 --> 05:43:52,749 away and I can understand what 10672 05:43:52,749 --> 05:43:53,717 you're talking about. 10673 05:43:53,717 --> 05:43:54,116 So please try not to make it so 10674 05:43:54,116 --> 05:43:56,116 complicated. 10675 05:43:57,887 --> 05:43:58,788 I know the deeper guys It's 10676 05:43:58,788 --> 05:44:03,393 helpful to try to do it on your 10677 05:44:03,393 --> 05:44:03,927 own with your staff and your 10678 05:44:03,927 --> 05:44:05,927 time has concluded. 10679 05:44:07,970 --> 05:44:10,697 John if you can please unmute. 10680 05:44:12,469 --> 05:44:13,136 >> Good evening City Council 10681 05:44:13,136 --> 05:44:13,804 John Brady lived experience 10682 05:44:13,804 --> 05:44:14,104 advisors Thank you for your 10683 05:44:14,104 --> 05:44:14,471 time. 10684 05:44:14,471 --> 05:44:16,471 It's late. 10685 05:44:18,108 --> 05:44:19,142 I'll try to be brief. 10686 05:44:19,142 --> 05:44:21,545 I want to talk about last week 10687 05:44:21,545 --> 05:44:25,745 and and why I spoke out about 10688 05:44:26,350 --> 05:44:27,830 Midway Rising. 10689 05:44:27,830 --> 05:44:30,683 I made the mistake of ignoring 10690 05:44:31,555 --> 05:44:32,355 the warnings of Laurie Saldana 10691 05:44:32,355 --> 05:44:35,955 early on and was confused about 10692 05:44:36,260 --> 05:44:36,794 what the potential risks were 10693 05:44:36,794 --> 05:44:37,428 at that site and the conflict 10694 05:44:37,428 --> 05:44:40,428 that she must have had 10695 05:44:41,398 --> 05:44:42,320 internally warning housing but 10696 05:44:42,320 --> 05:44:42,333 also warning of very real 10697 05:44:42,333 --> 05:44:44,333 risks. 10698 05:44:46,337 --> 05:44:49,337 I now understand the Midway 10699 05:44:51,241 --> 05:44:51,909 Rising project came on my radar 10700 05:44:51,909 --> 05:44:52,576 after the King tides when i 10701 05:44:52,576 --> 05:44:55,576 thought to myself Gosh what 10702 05:44:56,680 --> 05:44:57,348 would have happened if the king 10703 05:44:57,348 --> 05:44:57,815 tides had been coupled with 10704 05:44:57,815 --> 05:44:59,815 the 2024 floods? 10705 05:45:01,852 --> 05:45:02,619 And I asked aei what would 10706 05:45:02,619 --> 05:45:06,219 happen and I was shocked really 10707 05:45:06,756 --> 05:45:07,658 blown away Tragedy on a scale 10708 05:45:07,658 --> 05:45:10,961 that you cannot imagine in that 10709 05:45:10,961 --> 05:45:11,895 region. 10710 05:45:11,895 --> 05:45:12,763 So then I dug in further and 10711 05:45:12,763 --> 05:45:16,166 I've spent seven days now on 10712 05:45:16,166 --> 05:45:20,366 and off hours at a time looking 10713 05:45:20,537 --> 05:45:20,838 at what this project risks are 10714 05:45:20,838 --> 05:45:21,437 . 10715 05:45:21,437 --> 05:45:22,173 They are extraordinary. 10716 05:45:22,173 --> 05:45:25,109 I don't know how they've not 10717 05:45:25,109 --> 05:45:25,909 come to the surface. 10718 05:45:25,909 --> 05:45:26,510 They have not been disclosed 10719 05:45:26,510 --> 05:45:26,844 intentionally or not or 10720 05:45:26,844 --> 05:45:28,844 ignored. 10721 05:45:30,280 --> 05:45:30,948 But this project could 10722 05:45:30,948 --> 05:45:33,948 potentially put this city on 10723 05:45:34,652 --> 05:45:35,285 the on the hook for over half 10724 05:45:35,285 --> 05:45:37,685 $1 billion in upgrades to 10725 05:45:39,623 --> 05:45:40,291 infrastructure and a constant 10726 05:45:40,291 --> 05:45:42,691 bill for continuous pumping 10727 05:45:43,994 --> 05:45:44,662 running to up to $1 million a 10728 05:45:44,662 --> 05:45:44,962 month by 20 2030 And it's 10729 05:45:44,962 --> 05:45:46,962 worse. 10730 05:45:49,133 --> 05:45:50,000 There's much more And I really 10731 05:45:50,000 --> 05:45:53,236 have to encourage you as a 10732 05:45:53,236 --> 05:45:53,938 housing advocate to seriously 10733 05:45:53,938 --> 05:45:56,338 reevaluate the decision around 10734 05:45:57,975 --> 05:45:58,809 this project and I will also 10735 05:45:58,809 --> 05:45:59,176 tell you there is a way to make 10736 05:45:59,176 --> 05:46:01,176 it happen. 10737 05:46:02,413 --> 05:46:03,279 There's a way to make it happen 10738 05:46:03,279 --> 05:46:03,680 and make it a crown jewel of 10739 05:46:03,680 --> 05:46:05,680 resiliency. 10740 05:46:07,285 --> 05:46:07,952 It's quite possible we won't 10741 05:46:07,952 --> 05:46:08,318 know unless we do the right 10742 05:46:08,318 --> 05:46:10,318 research. 10743 05:46:12,623 --> 05:46:13,900 Thank you for your time. 10744 05:46:13,900 --> 05:46:13,858 >> Thank you. 10745 05:46:13,858 --> 05:46:15,660 I will know that other people 10746 05:46:15,660 --> 05:46:16,359 have raised their hand after 10747 05:46:16,359 --> 05:46:17,610 the five minute timer we will 10748 05:46:17,610 --> 05:46:20,264 be only taking the 14 that had 10749 05:46:20,264 --> 05:46:20,997 their hands raised when 10750 05:46:20,997 --> 05:46:21,665 the five minute timer concluded 10751 05:46:21,665 --> 05:46:22,366 but you can definitely still 10752 05:46:22,366 --> 05:46:25,366 submit comments to City Clerk 10753 05:46:25,569 --> 05:46:26,270 at San diego.Gov and those will 10754 05:46:26,270 --> 05:46:27,400 be distributed to the council. 10755 05:46:27,400 --> 05:46:29,773 Angela Better if you can please 10756 05:46:29,773 --> 05:46:31,773 unmute. 10757 05:46:35,112 --> 05:46:35,780 >> Hi I wanted to say I noticed 10758 05:46:35,780 --> 05:46:38,780 something I've been going to 10759 05:46:39,417 --> 05:46:40,184 these city council meetings for 10760 05:46:40,184 --> 05:46:40,818 quite a long time and I 10761 05:46:40,818 --> 05:46:43,818 appreciate that there is a 10762 05:46:44,188 --> 05:46:47,788 place for us to talk about 10763 05:46:49,193 --> 05:46:49,827 items that concerns us But what 10764 05:46:49,827 --> 05:46:52,827 I've noticed is that we've 10765 05:46:54,310 --> 05:46:57,631 gotten a lot less time allowed 10766 05:46:58,369 --> 05:46:59,236 to speak and it's often hard 10767 05:46:59,236 --> 05:47:03,140 for many of us who MAY speak 10768 05:47:03,140 --> 05:47:03,908 slower or don't have something 10769 05:47:03,908 --> 05:47:07,508 written, you know, to read as 10770 05:47:08,246 --> 05:47:08,980 quickly as possible Plus we 10771 05:47:08,980 --> 05:47:12,580 can't bring people that want to 10772 05:47:12,617 --> 05:47:13,184 be there to support us and hand 10773 05:47:13,184 --> 05:47:15,184 over minutes anymore. 10774 05:47:17,755 --> 05:47:18,422 I notice there's no way of us 10775 05:47:18,422 --> 05:47:19,223 doing that and I think that 10776 05:47:19,223 --> 05:47:22,223 that is a real disservice 10777 05:47:22,993 --> 05:47:23,694 especially when we take 10778 05:47:23,694 --> 05:47:24,620 the time to get to the council 10779 05:47:24,620 --> 05:47:26,620 meetings. 10780 05:47:27,832 --> 05:47:28,833 We have to pay for parking like 10781 05:47:28,833 --> 05:47:31,833 today it was $18 minimum but 10782 05:47:32,403 --> 05:47:36,603 yet we only get one minute to 10783 05:47:37,308 --> 05:47:37,975 speak and we used to have at 10784 05:47:37,975 --> 05:47:38,543 least a minute and a half, 10785 05:47:38,543 --> 05:47:39,210 sometimes two minutes. 10786 05:47:39,210 --> 05:47:41,679 I understand it gets really 10787 05:47:41,679 --> 05:47:42,413 crowded and you guys need to 10788 05:47:42,413 --> 05:47:43,248 push these things through But I 10789 05:47:43,248 --> 05:47:46,848 mean it's important for you to 10790 05:47:47,117 --> 05:47:47,785 listen to us and to give us 10791 05:47:47,785 --> 05:47:50,785 that time especially when we 10792 05:47:51,220 --> 05:47:51,890 take the time to show up. 10793 05:47:51,890 --> 05:47:56,900 So I just think that needs to 10794 05:47:56,327 --> 05:47:57,610 be reconsidered because you 10795 05:47:57,610 --> 05:47:57,795 guys are voted there because of 10796 05:47:57,795 --> 05:48:01,395 the people And I think it's 10797 05:48:01,866 --> 05:48:02,133 important that you do listen to 10798 05:48:02,133 --> 05:48:02,567 us. 10799 05:48:02,567 --> 05:48:02,934 >> Thank you. 10800 05:48:02,934 --> 05:48:04,934 Thank you. 10801 05:48:06,604 --> 05:48:07,271 And you can definitely email my 10802 05:48:07,271 --> 05:48:08,600 office City clerk at San 10803 05:48:08,600 --> 05:48:08,706 diego.Gov and we can assist you 10804 05:48:08,706 --> 05:48:11,309 through the changes because of 10805 05:48:11,309 --> 05:48:12,110 state law sb 707 Gabriele 10806 05:48:12,110 --> 05:48:15,110 Aravena If you can please 10807 05:48:15,413 --> 05:48:16,181 unmute. 10808 05:48:16,181 --> 05:48:18,581 >> Can you hear me? 10809 05:48:20,151 --> 05:48:20,785 Yes please proceed. 10810 05:48:20,785 --> 05:48:21,553 Thank you so much. 10811 05:48:21,553 --> 05:48:24,689 I want to thank the council 10812 05:48:24,689 --> 05:48:25,390 members that all voted to 10813 05:48:25,390 --> 05:48:28,390 oppose this really long night 10814 05:48:29,727 --> 05:48:30,428 and for listening to your 10815 05:48:30,428 --> 05:48:32,828 constituents after months and 10816 05:48:34,398 --> 05:48:35,166 months and months of of telling 10817 05:48:35,166 --> 05:48:35,466 you So it's really nice to be 10818 05:48:35,466 --> 05:48:37,466 heard. 10819 05:48:39,604 --> 05:48:39,971 I also wanted to thank Stephen 10820 05:48:39,971 --> 05:48:40,771 Whitburn. 10821 05:48:40,771 --> 05:48:44,371 I am part of your district 10822 05:48:44,642 --> 05:48:45,510 district three and I was really 10823 05:48:45,510 --> 05:48:49,581 nice to hear you say that you 10824 05:48:49,581 --> 05:48:50,382 were going to switch over. 10825 05:48:50,382 --> 05:48:53,752 Now you did say some concerning 10826 05:48:53,752 --> 05:48:54,419 made some concerning points to 10827 05:48:54,419 --> 05:48:56,819 combat your decision saying 10828 05:48:58,490 --> 05:48:59,391 that you wanted to put more 10829 05:48:59,391 --> 05:49:02,391 money into maybe into public 10830 05:49:03,528 --> 05:49:04,162 safety because you're concerned 10831 05:49:04,162 --> 05:49:06,562 about our lgbtq community. 10832 05:49:08,633 --> 05:49:09,234 I also heard you give support 10833 05:49:09,234 --> 05:49:09,901 to the Latino community. 10834 05:49:09,901 --> 05:49:12,901 It was really impressive to 10835 05:49:13,137 --> 05:49:13,805 hear you speak in Spanish. 10836 05:49:13,805 --> 05:49:14,672 I thank you for that. 10837 05:49:14,672 --> 05:49:18,276 But what I'm here to talk to 10838 05:49:18,276 --> 05:49:18,810 you guys about is Centro 10839 05:49:18,810 --> 05:49:21,210 Cultural de la Raza. 10840 05:49:23,810 --> 05:49:23,782 >> They have been targeted 10841 05:49:23,782 --> 05:49:26,782 recently by hate campaigns and 10842 05:49:27,552 --> 05:49:28,119 part of your district, 10843 05:49:28,119 --> 05:49:28,753 the Latino community. 10844 05:49:28,753 --> 05:49:31,153 We're asking you, Stephen 10845 05:49:32,123 --> 05:49:32,991 Whitburn, please hear us. 10846 05:49:32,991 --> 05:49:33,558 Centro de la Raza is a 10847 05:49:33,558 --> 05:49:35,558 beautiful space, super 10848 05:49:37,161 --> 05:49:37,863 welcoming. 10849 05:49:37,863 --> 05:49:38,996 It's literally saved my life. 10850 05:49:38,996 --> 05:49:42,134 It was a third space for me to 10851 05:49:42,134 --> 05:49:42,834 go and we really, really need 10852 05:49:42,834 --> 05:49:46,434 your support and I won't hold 10853 05:49:46,872 --> 05:49:47,238 up too much time because we're 10854 05:49:47,238 --> 05:49:47,906 all tired. 10855 05:49:47,906 --> 05:49:48,273 But thank you again Council 10856 05:49:48,273 --> 05:49:50,273 Thank you. 10857 05:49:51,376 --> 05:49:54,976 Next is Natalie Roski If you 10858 05:49:55,981 --> 05:49:56,381 can please unmute. 10859 05:49:56,381 --> 05:49:57,149 >> Hi. 10860 05:49:57,149 --> 05:49:57,616 I'll try not to take up a lot 10861 05:49:57,616 --> 05:49:59,616 of your time. 10862 05:50:03,521 --> 05:50:04,222 I agree with the woman about 10863 05:50:04,222 --> 05:50:07,525 the minutes but you just said 10864 05:50:07,525 --> 05:50:08,393 that it is state law. 10865 05:50:08,393 --> 05:50:11,993 I just wanted to say something 10866 05:50:12,431 --> 05:50:14,831 about consciousness and where 10867 05:50:15,100 --> 05:50:18,700 this is going and the feeling 10868 05:50:20,773 --> 05:50:21,105 amongst what everybody is 10869 05:50:21,105 --> 05:50:23,105 feeling. 10870 05:50:25,110 --> 05:50:25,977 There's an uncertainty and 10871 05:50:25,977 --> 05:50:29,577 people are looking to be led 10872 05:50:30,115 --> 05:50:30,749 and I just want people to know 10873 05:50:30,749 --> 05:50:33,749 that they can look inside 10874 05:50:34,419 --> 05:50:35,120 themselves and building 10875 05:50:35,120 --> 05:50:38,720 community I think is the best 10876 05:50:39,570 --> 05:50:39,858 way we're going to move through 10877 05:50:39,858 --> 05:50:43,458 this time of era and having 10878 05:50:43,829 --> 05:50:48,290 children to grow up in this era 10879 05:50:48,633 --> 05:50:49,501 is just it's all really someone 10880 05:50:49,501 --> 05:50:53,701 quoted that it was it was scary 10881 05:50:54,139 --> 05:50:54,438 and excite ing both at the same 10882 05:50:54,438 --> 05:50:56,438 time. 10883 05:50:58,777 --> 05:50:59,411 I hope that people take time to 10884 05:50:59,411 --> 05:50:59,978 think about consciousness 10885 05:50:59,978 --> 05:51:01,978 throughout their day. 10886 05:51:03,481 --> 05:51:04,249 It's really, really important 10887 05:51:04,249 --> 05:51:07,249 that we're aware of our 10888 05:51:08,519 --> 05:51:08,920 thoughts and perception versus 10889 05:51:08,920 --> 05:51:10,920 perspective. 10890 05:51:13,692 --> 05:51:14,293 That's a huge, huge thing 10891 05:51:14,293 --> 05:51:14,626 that's going to move us 10892 05:51:14,626 --> 05:51:16,626 forward. 10893 05:51:18,363 --> 05:51:19,640 I think we're at a precipice of 10894 05:51:19,640 --> 05:51:21,464 humanity and civilization and 10895 05:51:22,668 --> 05:51:23,535 what we've been told that we've 10896 05:51:23,535 --> 05:51:24,236 been lied to for a long time 10897 05:51:24,236 --> 05:51:27,539 when it comes to history and 10898 05:51:27,539 --> 05:51:28,600 who we are and how we got to 10899 05:51:28,600 --> 05:51:28,740 where we're at. 10900 05:51:28,740 --> 05:51:31,740 The federal government is aware 10901 05:51:32,978 --> 05:51:33,678 of many things and I don't 10902 05:51:33,678 --> 05:51:37,278 think that looking to them is 10903 05:51:37,983 --> 05:51:38,851 really going to get us too far. 10904 05:51:38,851 --> 05:51:41,851 I think local and small 10905 05:51:42,487 --> 05:51:43,155 communities is going to build. 10906 05:51:43,155 --> 05:51:46,755 It's the best way to build. 10907 05:51:47,358 --> 05:51:47,826 Thank you. 10908 05:51:47,826 --> 05:51:48,894 >> Thank you. 10909 05:51:48,894 --> 05:51:51,430 Next is Amy can more If you can 10910 05:51:51,430 --> 05:51:53,430 please unmute. 10911 05:51:57,200 --> 05:52:00,200 Hi can you hear me? 10912 05:52:01,400 --> 05:52:01,540 Yes. 10913 05:52:01,540 --> 05:52:02,341 Okay great. 10914 05:52:02,341 --> 05:52:05,941 I just want to thank everyone 10915 05:52:06,178 --> 05:52:06,879 today for their time and for 10916 05:52:06,879 --> 05:52:07,546 listening to the community and 10917 05:52:07,546 --> 05:52:10,882 I want to speak out on 10918 05:52:10,882 --> 05:52:11,583 something that is really 10919 05:52:11,583 --> 05:52:12,284 important to our community and 10920 05:52:12,284 --> 05:52:15,884 that Matt started off with and 10921 05:52:16,388 --> 05:52:16,889 that Gabrielle just shared 10922 05:52:16,889 --> 05:52:17,522 about our need for 10923 05:52:17,522 --> 05:52:19,922 the necessary support for 10924 05:52:20,558 --> 05:52:21,600 the several other Rosa I am a 10925 05:52:21,600 --> 05:52:23,600 professor at ucsd. 10926 05:52:24,730 --> 05:52:25,640 >> I teach over 300 students a 10927 05:52:25,640 --> 05:52:27,640 quarter. 10928 05:52:29,168 --> 05:52:29,869 And this space is so vital for 10929 05:52:29,869 --> 05:52:30,536 many things that we've been 10930 05:52:30,536 --> 05:52:33,536 hearing about and trying to 10931 05:52:34,807 --> 05:52:35,240 respond to tonight which is 10932 05:52:35,240 --> 05:52:36,141 namely trust. 10933 05:52:36,141 --> 05:52:39,378 It's trust And it's also for me 10934 05:52:39,378 --> 05:52:40,145 personally belonging and to 10935 05:52:40,145 --> 05:52:43,145 support spaces that are really 10936 05:52:44,116 --> 05:52:44,817 giving our community and us and 10937 05:52:44,817 --> 05:52:48,417 myself a space where we feel 10938 05:52:49,355 --> 05:52:53,292 like we belong, where we I mean 10939 05:52:53,292 --> 05:52:53,893 I think you all heard from so 10940 05:52:53,893 --> 05:52:54,493 many amazing, incredible 10941 05:52:54,493 --> 05:52:56,893 students from ucsd that 10942 05:52:59,197 --> 05:52:59,899 empowered them to be citizens 10943 05:52:59,899 --> 05:53:02,899 And so supporting these kinds 10944 05:53:04,236 --> 05:53:05,204 of spaces is vital. 10945 05:53:05,204 --> 05:53:05,938 And so I really want to call on 10946 05:53:05,938 --> 05:53:08,740 all of you not just the parents 10947 05:53:08,740 --> 05:53:08,674 in your district but also 10948 05:53:08,674 --> 05:53:09,208 everyone to really take 10949 05:53:09,208 --> 05:53:11,208 seriously Then this 10950 05:53:13,450 --> 05:53:13,445 the necessity of supporting 10951 05:53:13,445 --> 05:53:14,479 the center. 10952 05:53:14,479 --> 05:53:17,416 So it is just a vital piece of 10953 05:53:17,416 --> 05:53:18,217 San Diego. 10954 05:53:18,217 --> 05:53:21,817 It's historic and the work that 10955 05:53:22,622 --> 05:53:23,255 they do every day is really, 10956 05:53:23,255 --> 05:53:26,255 really important to us as 10957 05:53:28,389 --> 05:53:28,544 community members. 10958 05:53:28,544 --> 05:53:28,712 So I just want to urge you all 10959 05:53:28,712 --> 05:53:28,891 to to find a way and for me 10960 05:53:28,891 --> 05:53:31,891 personally feel like the best 10961 05:53:31,997 --> 05:53:32,731 way to start building trust is 10962 05:53:32,731 --> 05:53:33,532 to not only do the great things 10963 05:53:33,532 --> 05:53:37,690 that you have done in voting to 10964 05:53:37,690 --> 05:53:37,637 listen to your constituents but 10965 05:53:37,637 --> 05:53:40,370 also to really support 10966 05:53:41,140 --> 05:53:41,840 the things that bring us 10967 05:53:41,840 --> 05:53:42,475 the most democratic joy spaces 10968 05:53:42,475 --> 05:53:46,750 that we have in San Diego. 10969 05:53:46,579 --> 05:53:46,879 Thank you very much for your 10970 05:53:46,879 --> 05:53:47,380 time. 10971 05:53:47,380 --> 05:53:49,380 Thank you, Becky. 10972 05:53:54,190 --> 05:53:54,520 If you can please unmute. 10973 05:53:54,520 --> 05:53:56,520 >> Good evening. 10974 05:53:58,356 --> 05:53:59,580 My name is Becky Rapp and I'd 10975 05:53:59,580 --> 05:53:59,725 like to address NOVEMBER 15th 10976 05:53:59,725 --> 05:54:03,620 marked as the World Day of 10977 05:54:03,620 --> 05:54:03,729 Remembrance for road traffic 10978 05:54:03,729 --> 05:54:06,129 victims an international day 10979 05:54:07,700 --> 05:54:08,501 dedicated to remembering those 10980 05:54:08,501 --> 05:54:08,968 killed and injured on our roads 10981 05:54:08,968 --> 05:54:09,669 and recognizing 10982 05:54:09,669 --> 05:54:12,538 the responsibility we share to 10983 05:54:12,538 --> 05:54:14,538 prevent these tragedies. 10984 05:54:17,242 --> 05:54:17,844 A NOVEMBER 16th article in 10985 05:54:17,844 --> 05:54:18,544 the Union-Tribune titled 10986 05:54:18,544 --> 05:54:20,944 Grieving Unimaginable Loss San 10987 05:54:22,248 --> 05:54:23,490 Diego Area Families Gather 10988 05:54:23,490 --> 05:54:25,449 reported that 231 people were 10989 05:54:27,119 --> 05:54:27,821 killed and 1112 seriously 10990 05:54:27,821 --> 05:54:30,221 injured in traffic collisions 10991 05:54:31,657 --> 05:54:32,325 across San Diego County and 10992 05:54:32,325 --> 05:54:32,625 2025 within the city of San 10993 05:54:32,625 --> 05:54:34,625 Diego. 10994 05:54:35,762 --> 05:54:38,762 92 people lost their lives and 10995 05:54:39,932 --> 05:54:40,599 398 were seriously injured. 10996 05:54:40,599 --> 05:54:41,234 These numbers represent a 10997 05:54:41,234 --> 05:54:41,534 significant public safety 10998 05:54:41,534 --> 05:54:43,534 issue. 10999 05:54:44,871 --> 05:54:45,471 I want to particularly 11000 05:54:45,471 --> 05:54:46,139 emphasize driving under 11001 05:54:46,139 --> 05:54:49,139 the influence of alcohol and 11002 05:54:49,241 --> 05:54:49,942 drugs. 11003 05:54:49,942 --> 05:54:50,610 Unlike some traffic hazards, 11004 05:54:50,610 --> 05:54:53,100 impaired driving is entirely 11005 05:54:54,279 --> 05:54:54,848 preventable. 11006 05:54:54,848 --> 05:54:55,415 Every driver has a 11007 05:54:55,415 --> 05:54:56,115 responsibility to make 11008 05:54:56,115 --> 05:54:59,180 the decision not to get behind 11009 05:54:59,180 --> 05:54:59,718 the wheel while impaired. 11010 05:54:59,718 --> 05:55:00,453 Yet these preventable choices 11011 05:55:00,453 --> 05:55:04,530 continue to put everyone on our 11012 05:55:04,523 --> 05:55:05,224 roads at risk. 11013 05:55:05,224 --> 05:55:05,992 The Union-Tribune article did 11014 05:55:05,992 --> 05:55:09,161 not identify how many of these 11015 05:55:09,161 --> 05:55:09,796 deaths and serious injuries 11016 05:55:09,796 --> 05:55:11,796 involved impaired driving. 11017 05:55:13,466 --> 05:55:13,999 And I believe that is an 11018 05:55:13,999 --> 05:55:14,667 important question. 11019 05:55:14,667 --> 05:55:18,737 I urge the city to work with 11020 05:55:18,737 --> 05:55:19,438 San Diego Police Department and 11021 05:55:19,438 --> 05:55:21,838 District Attorney's Office and 11022 05:55:23,543 --> 05:55:24,276 regional partners to strengthen 11023 05:55:24,276 --> 05:55:24,777 dui prevention enforcement and 11024 05:55:24,777 --> 05:55:26,777 public education. 11025 05:55:28,781 --> 05:55:29,481 And I also ask the city to make 11026 05:55:29,481 --> 05:55:30,820 alcohol and drug involved say 11027 05:55:30,820 --> 05:55:32,482 fatal and serious injury 11028 05:55:33,486 --> 05:55:34,187 collisions, statistics readily 11029 05:55:34,187 --> 05:55:37,390 available to the public so we 11030 05:55:37,390 --> 05:55:37,990 can better understand 11031 05:55:37,990 --> 05:55:38,658 the problem and measure 11032 05:55:38,658 --> 05:55:41,658 the progress we're making on 11033 05:55:43,329 --> 05:55:44,630 this world Day of Remembrance 11034 05:55:44,630 --> 05:55:47,663 Let us recognize those who were 11035 05:55:47,967 --> 05:55:48,600 lost by making a renewed 11036 05:55:48,600 --> 05:55:48,968 commitment to prevention. 11037 05:55:48,968 --> 05:55:50,968 Thank you. 11038 05:55:53,172 --> 05:55:53,840 Thank you. 11039 05:55:53,840 --> 05:55:54,173 And our final speaker is 11040 05:55:54,173 --> 05:55:54,607 Madison. 11041 05:55:54,607 --> 05:55:54,874 Please unmute. 11042 05:55:54,874 --> 05:55:56,874 Hi. 11043 05:55:57,477 --> 05:55:58,177 Thank you. 11044 05:55:58,177 --> 05:55:58,511 Good evening City Council 11045 05:55:58,511 --> 05:55:59,245 members. 11046 05:55:59,245 --> 05:55:59,813 I wanted to speak about tobacco 11047 05:55:59,813 --> 05:56:01,813 prevention through an 11048 05:56:02,681 --> 05:56:03,282 environmental lens. 11049 05:56:03,282 --> 05:56:03,850 Sometimes public health 11050 05:56:03,850 --> 05:56:05,850 concerns don't receive 11051 05:56:07,454 --> 05:56:08,540 attention because the people 11052 05:56:08,540 --> 05:56:08,687 most affected are often 11053 05:56:08,687 --> 05:56:09,389 children and teenagers who 11054 05:56:09,389 --> 05:56:12,580 don't know how to advocate for 11055 05:56:12,580 --> 05:56:12,792 themselves or even that these 11056 05:56:12,792 --> 05:56:13,326 problems are happening in these 11057 05:56:13,326 --> 05:56:15,326 policy discussions. 11058 05:56:17,130 --> 05:56:17,897 But environmental protection is 11059 05:56:17,897 --> 05:56:18,365 an issue that brings a lot of 11060 05:56:18,365 --> 05:56:20,365 people together. 11061 05:56:21,968 --> 05:56:22,836 And tobacco is an environmental 11062 05:56:22,836 --> 05:56:23,402 problem as much as it is a 11063 05:56:23,402 --> 05:56:25,402 public health problem. 11064 05:56:26,739 --> 05:56:27,307 Cigaret butts have historically 11065 05:56:27,307 --> 05:56:28,410 been the most commonly 11066 05:56:28,410 --> 05:56:28,508 collected item in global litter 11067 05:56:28,508 --> 05:56:30,508 litter cleanups. 11068 05:56:31,912 --> 05:56:32,579 Even today they remain among 11069 05:56:32,579 --> 05:56:33,279 the most prevalent forms of 11070 05:56:33,279 --> 05:56:36,279 litter According to the World 11071 05:56:36,883 --> 05:56:37,517 Health Organization, 11072 05:56:37,517 --> 05:56:38,184 approximately 4.5 trillion 11073 05:56:38,184 --> 05:56:40,584 cigaret butts are improperly 11074 05:56:41,354 --> 05:56:42,121 discarded every year. 11075 05:56:42,121 --> 05:56:42,789 And these are harmful pieces of 11076 05:56:42,789 --> 05:56:45,189 trash because they contain 11077 05:56:46,359 --> 05:56:46,926 plastic, they do not biodegrade 11078 05:56:46,926 --> 05:56:47,527 and they release toxic 11079 05:56:47,527 --> 05:56:47,894 chemicals into soil and 11080 05:56:47,894 --> 05:56:49,894 waterways. 11081 05:56:51,331 --> 05:56:52,660 They can travel through 11082 05:56:52,660 --> 05:56:52,732 the storm drains into the ocean 11083 05:56:52,732 --> 05:56:55,732 and be ingested by wildlife. 11084 05:56:56,269 --> 05:56:56,870 There's an opportunity to bring 11085 05:56:56,870 --> 05:56:57,437 environmental advocates, 11086 05:56:57,437 --> 05:56:59,437 parents, public health 11087 05:57:00,874 --> 05:57:01,575 professionals and community 11088 05:57:01,575 --> 05:57:02,275 organizations together around 11089 05:57:02,275 --> 05:57:04,275 stronger tobacco restrictions. 11090 05:57:05,946 --> 05:57:06,646 So I encourage the city to 11091 05:57:06,646 --> 05:57:09,460 consider policies that reduce 11092 05:57:10,316 --> 05:57:11,170 tobacco product availability 11093 05:57:11,170 --> 05:57:11,351 and use in shared public 11094 05:57:11,351 --> 05:57:12,840 spaces. 11095 05:57:12,840 --> 05:57:15,840 Prevent cigaret litter at its 11096 05:57:15,221 --> 05:57:15,755 source and protect our beaches, 11097 05:57:15,755 --> 05:57:16,189 parks, waterways and 11098 05:57:16,189 --> 05:57:18,189 neighborhoods. 11099 05:57:20,660 --> 05:57:21,328 We should be able to protect 11100 05:57:21,328 --> 05:57:22,620 the environment and protect 11101 05:57:22,620 --> 05:57:22,662 public health at the same thing 11102 05:57:22,662 --> 05:57:24,662 through these policies. 11103 05:57:26,320 --> 05:57:26,433 Thank you. 11104 05:57:26,433 --> 05:57:27,134 Thank you. 11105 05:57:27,134 --> 05:57:27,801 And that concludes non agenda 11106 05:57:27,801 --> 05:57:30,201 public comment for today's 11107 05:57:30,337 --> 05:57:30,871 meeting. 11108 05:57:30,871 --> 05:57:31,437 >> All right. 11109 05:57:31,437 --> 05:57:32,105 Thank you, City Clerk. 11110 05:57:32,105 --> 05:57:32,739 Does the office of the city 11111 05:57:32,739 --> 05:57:35,139 attorney have anything to 11112 05:57:35,141 --> 05:57:35,641 report out from closed session? 11113 05:57:35,641 --> 05:57:36,420 >> Yes. 11114 05:57:36,420 --> 05:57:36,876 Thank you. 11115 05:57:36,876 --> 05:57:37,177 There is one item to report out 11116 05:57:37,177 --> 05:57:39,177 today. 11117 05:57:39,379 --> 05:57:40,790 The city council voted on 11118 05:57:40,790 --> 05:57:40,681 closed session item number one 11119 05:57:40,681 --> 05:57:41,347 to initiate litigation. 11120 05:57:41,347 --> 05:57:43,747 Once litigation is formally 11121 05:57:44,150 --> 05:57:44,751 commenced the action 11122 05:57:44,751 --> 05:57:45,452 the defendants and other 11123 05:57:45,452 --> 05:57:47,852 particulars will be disclosed 11124 05:57:49,550 --> 05:57:49,722 to any person upon inquiry 11125 05:57:49,722 --> 05:57:50,457 unless to do so would 11126 05:57:50,457 --> 05:57:51,240 jeopardize effective service of 11127 05:57:51,240 --> 05:57:51,458 process or settlement 11128 05:57:51,458 --> 05:57:53,458 negotiations. 11129 05:57:54,828 --> 05:57:55,462 The motion passed 8 to 0 with 11130 05:57:55,462 --> 05:57:55,795 Council member Von Wilpert 11131 05:57:55,795 --> 05:57:56,463 absent. 11132 05:57:56,463 --> 05:57:56,830 >> That concludes my report. 11133 05:57:56,830 --> 05:57:58,830 All right. 11134 05:57:59,299 --> 05:58:00,266 Thank you for that. 11135 05:58:00,266 --> 05:58:01,100 And again, as we start to wrap 11136 05:58:01,100 --> 05:58:04,437 up, I want to thank the city 11137 05:58:04,437 --> 05:58:05,305 clerk entire city clerk team 32 11138 05:58:05,305 --> 05:58:08,905 that I sometimes forget And of 11139 05:58:09,376 --> 05:58:10,100 course debating for 11140 05:58:10,100 --> 05:58:10,611 the attorney who sat there 11141 05:58:10,611 --> 05:58:11,440 quietly listening to all 11142 05:58:11,440 --> 05:58:13,440 the testimony. 11143 05:58:14,214 --> 05:58:14,881 With that we will now adjourn 11144 05:58:14,881 --> 05:58:17,750 the council to the regularly 11145 05:58:17,750 --> 05:58:18,452 scheduled council meeting on 11146 05:58:18,452 --> 05:58:20,153 Tuesday NOVEMBER 17th, 2026 at 11147 05:58:20,153 --> 05:58:23,153 10 A.M. Or shortly thereafter.