[2:59] . [4:59] Can [7:10] I [8:34] go to [9:06] your [9:39] again and [9:40] All right. [9:40] Good morning. [9:44] I will now call the city [9:44] council meeting on Monday, [9:45] NOVEMBER 16th, 2026 to order [9:46] Deputy Clerk please call [9:49] the roll Council Member [9:50] Campbell Council Member [9:54] Whitburn Council Member Foster [9:58] Council Member Von Wilpert [9:58] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee [10:03] Council Member Campo Council [10:04] Member Moreno Present Council [10:08] Member Eli Rivera and Council [10:09] PRESIDENT LaCava present also [10:13] attending the meeting are City [10:14] Attorney Heather Ferber, [10:14] independent budget analyst [10:18] Charles Monica and myself your [10:19] deputy city Clerk Kevin Smith. [10:23] >> All right, thank you Deputy [10:23] Clerk a quorum is now present. [10:24] We will begin this morning with [10:25] an invocation by Deputy Clerk [10:28] Smith followed with the land [10:29] acknowledgment and the Pledge [10:30] of Allegiance led by council [10:33] member Thank you. [10:38] >> I grant those who hold [10:38] office in the city the spirit [10:42] of wisdom, charity and justice [10:43] that was steadfast purpose. [10:44] They MAY faithfully serve in [10:47] their offices to promote [10:48] the well-being of all people. [10:49] We respectfully acknowledge [10:52] that the culmination or [10:53] the original inhabitants of [10:54] the Unceded land now known as [10:57] San Diego Despite enduring [10:58] the horrors of genocide and [10:58] colonization, the human spirit [11:01] remains unbroken. [11:02] We honor the resilience of [11:03] their ancestors who fought to [11:06] protect their culture and land [11:06] . [11:07] Today they carry their legacy [11:08] forward ensuring that their [11:11] traditions continue to thrive [11:11] in gratitude and strength. [11:12] We stand with the culmination [11:16] connected to our past and [11:16] committed to a thriving future. [11:18] >> Please face the flag or [11:37] right on forward Deputy Clerk [11:42] Please go over how the public [11:43] can offer their testimony. [11:43] I'd like to highlight the slide [11:47] on the screen. [11:48] The order can be found on [11:49] the agenda summary online or at [11:51] the table in the back of [11:52] the room. [11:53] If you are in person please [11:53] complete the speaker slip [11:54] located at the entrance of [11:56] chambers and bring it to [11:57] the front of the room. [11:58] No further in-person testimony [12:01] will be taken once the Council [12:01] begins virtual testimony for [12:02] better meeting management [12:06] purposes Each speaker will have [12:06] one minute per item per person [12:08] up to a maximum of three [12:09] minutes If there are three or [12:14] more items. [12:14] Thank you. [12:15] The Clerk friendly reminder [12:16] that for both this morning and [12:19] this afternoon session [12:20] knowledge in a public comment [12:23] is the opportunity to speak on [12:24] any items within the city's [12:24] purview. [12:25] But if you're speaking to a [12:26] docketed item please confine [12:27] your comments to that docket [12:32] item. [12:32] With that Deputy clerk please [12:33] read the closed session Record [12:37] closed session items into [12:38] the record conference. [12:42] a legal counsel anticipate a [12:42] litigation initiation of [12:43] litigation pursuant to [12:45] California Government Code [12:49] Section 5495 6.94 See us one [12:50] number of cases one conference [12:54] with Labor negotiators pursuant [12:58] to California Government Code [12:59] Section 54957.6 See us to [13:02] setting designated management [13:03] team representatives see as [13:03] three City designated [13:07] management team representatives [13:07] . [13:08] >> All right. [13:08] Before we proceed with public [13:12] comment, I understand our city [13:13] attorney have comments. [13:13] Thank you. [13:16] Yes, I wanted to correct some [13:17] of the participants in [13:18] the concession items two and [13:22] three Franklin Cooper's Smith [13:23] will be attending closed [13:23] session for season two and us [13:24] three in the place of Julie [13:27] Rasco. [13:27] MR. Coopersmith is the new [13:28] Human Resources Department [13:31] director also attending on cac [13:32] will be Commissioner of Police [13:32] Practices Staff Executive [13:36] Director Roger Smith, General [13:36] Counsel Susan Saint John and [13:37] chief investigator Olga Golub. [13:41] >> Thank you. [13:41] All right. [13:42] Thank you for those corrections [13:42] being read into the record with [13:45] that deputy clerk Please [13:46] proceed with public comment. [13:46] We will begin with in-person [13:47] comment. [13:50] Max Schmidt please come [13:50] forward. [13:51] You have requested to speak on [13:51] c. [13:53] S one. [13:54] You will have one minute to [14:12] speak. [14:13] Hi. [14:16] The First Amendment is the most [14:17] important amendment in this [14:17] nation. [14:22] MR. Schmidt and c Yes MR. [14:23] Schmidt I want to say I am [14:23] opposed to c. [14:26] S one and I am for four on four [14:28] c it's one. [14:29] I've come here to use my First [14:30] Amendment to say I'm opposed to [14:33] see us one and you already [14:34] interrupted me. [14:34] >> So what do you got to say? [14:37] Could you please lower your [14:38] tone? [14:38] >> We're just trying to run [14:39] the meeting. [14:41] Yes, the tone is appropriate [14:42] for for what is going on here. [14:43] I'm allowed to use this tone of [14:44] my First Amendment. [14:47] So what are you got to say, MR. [14:47] Schmidt? [14:50] >> You submitted to additional [14:51] requests as you came up, so I [14:56] was just going to tell you that [14:57] you will have a total of three [14:57] minutes for your comments. [14:58] >> I thought you were going to [15:00] say something about my tone. [15:01] >> I did. [15:05] Please confined yourself to [15:09] the chambers Demeanor is my [15:09] First Amendment not being [15:10] infringed upon. [15:14] >> We're not talking about [15:14] First Amendment. [15:15] >> We're talking about [15:15] testimony and I'm talking about [15:16] my First Amendment. [15:16] Please. [15:19] Am I not allowed to use this [15:20] tone as my First Amendment? [15:20] Please proceed. [15:21] What do you mean my tone in my [15:24] child? [15:25] I'm a 35 year old man. [15:25] You're an adult. [15:26] You're patronizing me like a [15:28] child about my tone during when [15:29] it's my public comment Time to [15:30] use my First Amendment. [15:33] Can you explain further what [15:34] you mean about my tone? [15:35] Sir, please proceed with your [15:35] testimony on the three items [15:38] that you requested. [15:39] So my tone is unacceptable for [15:43] the chambers what you're saying [15:44] Please proceed with your [15:45] testimony on the three. [15:45] >> Okay. [15:53] Thank you. [15:57] Our next speaker is Jay M.C. [15:58] You have submitted a speaker [16:03] slip with request to speak on [16:03] items the students Yes, three [16:04] So you'll have two minutes to [16:07] speak. [16:08] Thank you. [16:08] Appreciate it. [16:12] Good morning. [16:13] So speaking on c us two is [16:13] history relates to labor. [16:17] We know that labor is very [16:17] costly with regards to our [16:21] general fund budget. [16:22] Each of you has probably served [16:23] as a member of the Budget [16:26] Committee knows the percentages [16:29] in excess of 6,970%. [16:30] Just speaking to hope that my [16:35] district one representative [16:35] will consider the analysis in [16:40] the Independent budget analysis [16:40] will consider to what extent [16:44] our general fund does not have [16:45] a structural deficit that is to [16:50] say a portion of our general [16:50] fund pays for the costs of [16:51] filling potholes. [16:51] A portion of our general fund [16:54] pays for the cost of ensuring [16:54] that Mission Bay and [16:58] communities like La Hoya Shores [16:59] have services. [16:59] So that's just to say I'm not [17:03] sure to what extent our elected [17:04] officials this body can say [17:04] that we do have a structural [17:08] deficit in our general fund but [17:09] to the extent we have no [17:13] intention or sense of urgency [17:17] to handle deferred maintenance [17:18] then we don't have a structural [17:18] budget. [17:19] That's just to say I've had [17:22] neighbors who've lost [17:23] homeownership in southeastern [17:27] San Diego when there were fight [17:28] floods and they all knew it was [17:28] coming coming and weather and [17:32] whatnot. [17:32] It says to those neighbors that [17:36] the backlog of service items [17:37] and get it done that are paid [17:38] for general fund departments [17:38] like those that are represented [17:42] here and see us to assist. [17:46] Three there is not a structural [17:46] deficit and general fund seems [17:47] to suggest to them that [17:48] the time to deliver [17:50] the services is going to happen [17:51] when it happens even if that [17:55] means that homeownership [17:56] generational homeownership is [17:56] lost. [17:57] Appreciate your time and look [18:00] forward to your analysis to [18:01] verify or otherwise challenge [18:02] the assumptions that the city [18:04] does not have a structural [18:05] deficit for general fund. [18:09] >> Appreciate your time. [18:10] >> Thank you. [18:10] That does conclude in-person [18:15] public comment. [18:15] I have started the five minute [18:16] timer and council chambers will [18:18] now turn to the virtual queue [18:19] in which there are four [18:19] participants currently [18:23] requesting to speak. [18:24] Beekman Please state which [18:24] closed session item or items [18:28] you wish to speak to. [18:34] Hi we're Beekman. [18:34] >> I'd like to speak to [18:35] 6162163. [18:38] Okay You'll have three minutes. [18:39] >> Please proceed. [18:39] Thank you. [18:43] As I'm still here and I'm in [18:44] northern Thailand now hopefully [18:48] my zoom will not cut out on me. [18:49] Sorry if it will. [18:53] I can probably put my words in [18:54] under three minutes Hopefully. [18:57] I wanted to speak once again to [19:02] the idea that the idea I don't [19:07] have a timer right now. [19:08] >> I only have the picture [19:09] because I don't have my three [19:12] minute timer up. [19:13] It's not on the zoom with me [19:16] but I'll try to continue and [19:17] you can you can come in like [19:19] you know when I have 30s [19:25] remaining if you can please. [19:25] Thank you. [19:26] It's kind of coming in there. [19:31] I wanted to comment that. [19:31] Okay, great. [19:32] Three minutes to 59 to 58. [19:32] Thank you. [19:36] I just wanted to comment on a [19:36] comment I've been offering [19:43] recently on the subject of city [19:44] employees and the idea Thank [19:47] you for the previous public [19:48] comment by the way. [19:49] I thought it was pretty [19:49] interesting. [19:53] I'm interested in how in [19:54] working on our deficit issues a [19:58] general fund and other and [19:58] other forms of our budget that [20:03] you are working on really well [20:04] by the way at this time it [20:04] seems like you have a good [20:06] headway on a good beginning. [20:12] Thank you everyone. [20:12] Continue that good process to [20:16] once again offer my idea that I [20:17] hope that in all this [20:21] negotiation you know you've [20:22] been doing this pretty [20:22] regularly here closed session [20:26] time and coming up with new [20:30] contracts that your latest [20:30] negotiations can possibly [20:35] somehow involve the ideas of [20:35] asking for city employees to [20:42] take a slight pay cut and at [20:46] this time and to keep alive [20:47] the ideas of retirement funds [20:52] and health benefits to programs [20:53] that you've been really [20:56] thinking of cutting out of city [20:57] employees work detail and you [21:02] know their lives basically And [21:02] I've tried to offer you know [21:06] that I think that's really [21:07] the wrong approach in how to [21:08] create a better morale and best [21:12] practices as a city government [21:12] as a community process. [21:15] So I'd like to the suggestion [21:16] instead that if we just cut our [21:21] you know, our pay our city [21:22] government pay by 25 bucks a [21:26] month, you know, with 10,000 [21:30] city workers that's over 3 to [21:31] $4 million in savings each year [21:35] And I really think it's a it's [21:36] a nice idea and I hope he can [21:40] really consider it. [21:41] It's not as much of a savings [21:41] as when you're cutting health [21:45] benefits and retirement [21:46] benefits. [21:46] That obviously is going to [21:50] bring you more of a savings, a [21:50] budget savings. [21:55] But morale wise and just human [21:55] interest wise and idea wise [21:56] it's not decent. [22:00] It's not our best at all. [22:01] So I just wanted to comment on [22:05] that again and really try to [22:06] think of our best practices and [22:10] what we really like about [22:10] ourselves and we like our [22:11] health benefits and we like our [22:15] retirement plans. [22:16] I think we can be willing to [22:16] take a $25 cut in pay each [22:19] month to continue those good [22:20] services. [22:20] That's my thinking. [22:21] Thanks for your time and [22:23] listening and good luck to your [22:28] meetings today. [22:28] Thank you. [22:29] Our next speaker is [22:29] the original drivers Please [22:31] state which item or items you [22:36] wish to speak to. [22:37] >> Yes, all of them please. [22:37] Okay. [22:38] You have three minutes. [22:38] Please proceed. [22:38] Thank you. [22:41] So yeah, good comments because [22:42] with labor negotiations it's [22:46] just interesting how we do them [22:46] all in like one bucket, you [22:50] know we don't look at [22:50] the people's merits and their [22:51] ability to do their job on [22:55] individual basis and we're [22:56] giving raises to the people [23:00] that are, you know, doing [23:00] things in the city that are [23:01] lacking also. [23:05] So it's like we have enough [23:05] money to give them raises on a [23:09] continual basis but we don't [23:10] have the money to get the work [23:11] done that they actually do. [23:14] So that's what's kind of [23:15] concerning is that it's like is [23:16] that you know, good management [23:16] of our money? [23:19] I mean I understand people need [23:20] to make more People are trying [23:24] to survive obviously But you [23:25] know like the city is lacking [23:28] in infrastructure and all of [23:29] these things. [23:30] I mean we have such huge [23:32] deficits for like $5 billion in [23:33] storm infrastructure and we're [23:38] talking about buying sd Gainey [23:39] for potentially $9 billion. [23:42] It's going to go down to [23:42] the people. [23:43] So it's like we on a continual [23:47] basis do things that cost we [23:47] the people more money but we [23:48] don't really see any other [23:52] benefits that it's like Oh my [23:53] gosh because people would be [23:54] willing to give you guys money [23:57] if it like showed you know [23:57] the fruits of your labor were [23:58] worth it if things were you [24:01] know, thriving in the city, you [24:02] know, people would be like oh [24:06] my gosh, give you more money [24:07] for that because we want more [24:07] of it. [24:08] But instead it's like we see [24:11] less and less worse and worse [24:12] and more and more money has to [24:16] come out of our pockets And [24:16] then you do things like engage [24:21] in litigation And you know, [24:21] like with this storm that [24:25] happened in JANUARY and you [24:26] guys are engaged in litigation [24:27] against some of the people who [24:30] have lost things. [24:30] So it's really concerning [24:35] the work that you guys do [24:36] The fact that this guy also [24:36] goes behind closed doors and [24:39] it's not transparent. [24:40] That's very concerning because [24:41] it shows like if if there was [24:44] nothing to worry about, you [24:45] don't have to go behind closed [24:45] doors. [24:46] You don't have to keep certain [24:49] things private But you do it [24:50] and it's like how can [24:50] the people trust what you're [24:53] doing when you use our money [24:54] You go behind closed doors. [24:55] Don't tell us what you're [24:55] doing. [24:58] Just expect us to trust you, [24:59] trust you to give people more [25:00] money to do their job that [25:03] they're not doing, you know? [25:04] And then we're continually [25:05] looking for more money and [25:08] cutting things from here and [25:09] cutting things from there And [25:13] it's just you know, it's just [25:13] unfortunate because with [25:14] the billions and billions of [25:18] dollars that have has gone [25:19] through this city, what is [25:19] there to show for it? [25:23] But filling people's pockets [25:23] and you know there's always [25:27] time to course correct As I say [25:27] . [25:28] So it's going to go and be [25:32] business as usual. [25:33] But I don't know. [25:33] I think you guys need to think [25:34] more about whose money you're [25:37] spending and you know what [25:38] they're actually having to do [25:39] just to get it to give it to [25:41] you. [25:42] Thank you. [25:42] Please note that the five [25:46] minute timer has concluded with [25:47] three speakers left in [25:47] the queue. [25:48] No other speakers will be [25:48] taken. [25:51] Our next speaker is Million [25:52] Mile Man. [25:52] Please state which item or [25:56] items you wish to speak to. [26:01] I would like to speak on non [26:05] agenda public comment okay. [26:06] >> Non agenda public comment [26:11] will be heard at the end of [26:11] the 2 P.M. Session today. [26:16] This is for comment on because [26:16] the session agenda. [26:20] >> Okay well then I would like [26:25] to speak on the closed session [26:25] agenda. [26:26] >> Okay. [26:26] Which item or items would you [26:28] like to speak to on the closed [26:33] session agenda? [26:33] >> All of them. [26:34] Okay you have three minutes. [26:37] Please proceed. [26:42] I have heard all of [26:47] the previous comments regarding [26:52] the budget Labor etc. Some of [26:56] the ideas put forth are valid [26:57] but the Achilles heel of this [27:01] whole budget and everything we [27:06] do practically in the city of [27:07] San Diego is predicated on [27:10] the city attorney's office and [27:18] the budget negotiations. [27:18] There is nothing in material [27:23] about the law and this is [27:27] the issue we have is within [27:32] the negotiations of Labor. [27:33] City Attorney's Office In an [27:37] ideal world if we lived in a [27:42] beautiful ideal world we could [27:42] implement all of these [27:46] wonderful ideas But [27:51] unfortunately we have to deal [27:52] with the material nature of [28:00] the law So that's all I have to [28:01] say. [28:01] You can cut me off now and put [28:04] on a thank you very much. [28:05] >> Thank you. [28:10] Our next speaker is one set of [28:11] please state which item or [28:15] items you wish to speak to. [28:15] Good morning guys. [28:16] Two and three please get your [28:16] time. [28:18] Two minutes on the labor thing [28:19] on following example of our [28:23] governor Governor Newsom. [28:24] He uses illegal aliens and pays [28:28] them cash to harvest his grape [28:29] crop for his $70 bottles of [28:29] wine. [28:34] So the governor could you [28:34] please not be to the items that [28:35] the city is compiling? [28:38] >> Not what the governor is [28:38] doing. [28:39] >> No, this is a labor this [28:39] labor thing with the city labor [28:42] agreement with doing potholes [28:43] We could hire illegal aliens [28:47] and pay them like $20 of [28:48] pothole cash and in a matter of [28:52] months we would have no [28:52] potholes. [28:53] We surprised we supply This is [28:56] labor negotiation with [28:57] the guys. [28:57] We're going to go illegal [29:01] aliens and pay them cash and [29:02] then we're going to provide [29:03] the asphalt and we're going to [29:07] provide them with signs to do [29:08] it and the oil to do it. [29:11] They provide their own tools [29:12] and their trucks will pay them [29:16] by the pothole cash and [29:17] document each pothole And we'll [29:21] do a program of like we'll burn [29:22] through 100 grand and see how [29:22] many potholes we can fill. [29:26] It'll save the city a bundle [29:27] and then when you do the roads [29:30] you guys have these road [29:35] programs Now you have no no. [29:36] You say it's going to save us [29:36] money. [29:37] Do it test where you have [29:41] private guys do one mile of [29:43] Miramar Road and then the city [29:44] does one mile of Miramar Road [29:45] going west and east different [29:48] parts of it get a bid from [29:49] the guys and how much they do [29:53] it for like eagle paving and [29:53] then count up all the city [29:54] stuff the labor in the city all [29:58] those machines you bought which [29:59] is multimillions of dollars and [30:03] then also include their [30:03] pensions do it over 30 years [30:04] They have a 30 year pension [30:08] coming up after that and you [30:09] got to do every cost how much [30:13] per mile or how much per yard [30:13] or whatever it is You don't [30:14] have it. [30:14] You just say it's saving us [30:18] money But in the long run it's [30:18] cost us money just based on [30:22] the pension pay payments So [30:23] you're not really being [30:23] truthful. [30:24] The city manager was saying it [30:27] on the thing just so recently [30:28] is saving the city money but [30:28] making that up. [30:31] Thank you. [30:32] That does conclude your time. [30:37] Well our next speaker is caller [30:39] where the last four digits 8700 [30:40] please state which item or [30:44] items you wish to speak to. [30:45] Thank you. [30:46] I will speak on all three. [30:46] Okay. [30:47] You have three minutes. [30:53] >> Please begin. [30:53] Good morning everyone. [30:54] Joy from the attack on c. [30:56] S one. [30:59] It's headed a number of cases. [31:04] One I would so appreciate your [31:05] clarity for the public on [31:06] the purpose of this item being [31:10] on consent with no details yet [31:14] it says City attorney will [31:15] discuss and speak and seek [31:19] direction. [31:20] So perhaps if allowed the city [31:24] attorney could clear this up [31:25] for me and for the rest of [31:28] the public that are interested [31:29] . [31:29] Thank you so much. [31:33] And number two see us to ctp [31:34] Commission on Police Practices. [31:38] This is so important even [31:42] though it's been about 46 years [31:43] since this oversight of police [31:47] practices was brought to light [31:51] by the public, I continue to [31:52] support this litigation as part [31:56] of the ongoing journey. [32:01] Understanding is a solid word [32:01] Trust is even more important. [32:06] Let's continue the journey [32:06] together. [32:07] Thank you to all involved in [32:12] this process and love to all [32:14] see as three fire fighters [32:19] Labor agreement As you work [32:20] together to support our [32:24] firefighters, I ask that you [32:25] take a deeper dive as to their [32:29] core and needs of their work [32:33] for the people of San Diego [32:34] When the perfect storm hit they [32:38] were not adequately equipped [32:43] When the perfect storm hit they [32:44] were not adequately equipped [32:49] and now we have the grand jury [32:49] report. [32:54] We must care for them. [32:55] And eight at a high level we [32:58] must care for them at a high [32:59] level so they can serve our [32:59] city. [33:04] Eddie high level I'm going to [33:04] say that again from a little [33:08] bit higher here When [33:09] the perfect storm hit our [33:09] firefighters were not [33:13] adequately equipped And now we [33:18] have the grand jury report. [33:18] We must care for our [33:22] firefighters a high level so [33:23] they can serve our city of [33:28] beautiful city and our [33:29] beautiful people at a high [33:29] level. [33:34] Thank you to the gentleman who [33:34] spoke on the structural budget [33:35] deficit. [33:37] That was a very big step, very [33:38] thoughtful comments. [33:38] Would you please keep it up as [33:42] we move into the budget? [33:42] Okay. [33:43] We're going to have a good day. [33:44] It's a big day. [33:47] A great week And as always love [33:52] to all Thank you. [33:52] Council PRESIDENT That [33:53] concludes closed session Public [33:56] comment None. [33:57] >> All right. [33:57] Thank you, Deputy Clerk. [33:58] With that we now recess in [33:58] the closed session and [34:01] reconvene council today at 2 [34:06] P.M. Or shortly thereafter. [38:02] >> My first and [38:02] that is Anthony Ross in [38:07] the building Anthony Ross in [38:08] the room If you are if you can [38:09] please come forward so that my [38:10] staff can speak with you [39:38] Anthony Ross [40:55] and [40:56] Seth Hall if [40:57] you are here so far please come [41:27] forward [42:21] and [44:21] help [45:19] . [45:19] >> All right. [45:20] Good afternoon. [45:20] I will now reconvene the city [45:25] council meeting of Monday, [45:26] NOVEMBER 16th, 2026. [45:27] >> clerk Please call the roll. [45:27] Thank you. [45:28] Council PRESIDENT Council [45:31] member Campbell. [45:31] Council Member Whitburn here. [45:37] Councilmember Foster Council [45:38] Member Yvonne Wolpert Council [45:43] Member Kent Council PRESIDENT [45:44] Pro Tem Kennelly Council Member [45:49] Campion Council Moreno Present [45:50] Council Member Eli Rivera and [45:51] Council PRESIDENT Look [45:56] the PRESIDENT Also attended [45:56] the meeting Our Assistant City [45:57] Attorney Michelle Garland [45:58] Independent Budget Analyst [45:58] Charles Margo Council Affairs [46:02] Advisor in the Mayor's office [46:03] Code advisor and myself your [46:03] city Clerk Diana Fontana Thank [46:04] you. [46:04] Council PRESIDENT All right. [46:07] Thank you City Clerk Since I [46:08] believe we have some new faces [46:08] in the audience, I just wanted [46:12] to remind everyone about [46:13] the city's practices and [46:14] procedures for public comment [46:14] at city council meetings. [46:19] We certainly welcome your [46:20] public participation and we [46:20] appreciate your taking your [46:21] time out of your busy days to [46:25] be here this afternoon. [46:25] Speakers MAY address [46:26] the council during public [46:26] comment and also in connection [46:27] with a specific item of [46:31] business on the agenda. [46:32] However, the city must make [46:33] sure that no one person or [46:33] group of people disrupt [46:34] the meeting in a way that [46:37] prohibits other speakers from [46:38] expressing their ideas and [46:39] opinions Excessive yelling, [46:39] screaming or speaking beyond [46:44] one's a lot of time are [46:45] examples of behavior that [46:45] disrupt the meeting. [46:46] So to make sure that everyone [46:47] here has an opportunity to [46:47] address the council, I will [46:51] alert an individual if I think [46:52] their conduct becomes [46:53] disruptive and a disruption [46:53] continues out. [46:54] What will the individual out of [46:56] order? [46:57] And after the session continues [46:58] further I will declare a recess [46:58] so we can restore order. [46:59] At that point I will direct [47:02] the individual to be the room [47:03] and if the individual refuses [47:04] to leave police will escort [47:04] the individual out of [47:08] the building. [47:09] If we have to repeat this [47:09] process of warning and [47:10] resetting the meeting, all [47:11] members of the public will be [47:13] excused from the council [47:14] chamber. [47:15] Credentialed media will be of [47:15] course allowed to remain again [47:20] we have these practices and [47:20] procedures to protect [47:21] the rights of other speakers [47:22] who wish to address the Council [47:22] and to allow the Council to [47:26] conduct the public's business. [47:26] The city clerk tells us that we [47:30] have probably about two hours [47:31] of testimony kind of getting [47:32] how many people might [47:32] participate online so that we [47:37] can move efficiently to give [47:38] everybody their time to talk. [47:38] If you hear things you like, [47:39] thumbs up really conveys that [47:44] Instead of clapping if you hear [47:45] something you don't like don't [47:49] move Put thumbs down Again That [47:50] really has a very good impact [47:51] with very visual impact I don't [47:55] see any signs so I'm a little [47:56] bit grateful for that. [47:56] But if you do have a sign [48:01] please make sure you're not [48:01] blocking the view of somebody [48:02] behind you. [48:02] Everybody wants to see our [48:03] smiling faces up here. [48:06] I am sure. [48:07] So with that let's start out [48:08] with the regular course of [48:08] business. [48:15] Are there any comments from [48:15] the mayor's office, council [48:16] member, city attorney and [48:17] the budget Answer City Clerk [48:19] Council Member In order for you [48:19] PRESIDENT First some good news [48:20] actually last week I'd share [48:24] that an eight year old boy from [48:25] our community was taken by was [48:30] taken during an immigration [48:31] check in taking away from his [48:32] family, taken away from [48:32] the people who love him And [48:36] he's back with his family today [48:36] And so I think that deserves a [48:41] round of applause. [48:47] >> So so that is great news And [48:48] it doesn't in any way diminish [48:49] the terrible thing that he's [48:53] experienced and his family's [48:53] experience and the larger issue [48:54] of how immigration enforcement [48:59] is being handled in this [49:00] country, the targeting of our [49:00] Haitian neighbors and so many [49:05] other very, very cool things. [49:05] And to that point, the second [49:06] issue that I want to raise is [49:07] about another immigration [49:11] action that happened in my [49:11] district on Friday. [49:12] An 18 year old girl was waiting [49:17] for her father to take her and [49:17] her 11 year old sister to [49:18] school when federal agents used [49:23] their vehicle to stop his and [49:24] ice agent and repeatedly shoved [49:24] her to the ground, threatened [49:28] her with a gun and a Taser [49:29] while she and her sister [49:29] watched their father beat [49:30] violently detained All that's [49:34] on video. [49:35] I sat with the family on [49:36] Saturday and they want their [49:36] story heard because they do not [49:37] want other families to go [49:40] through this. [49:45] When they took him no one told [49:46] the family who had him or where [49:46] he was going. [49:47] They spent hours not knowing [49:52] where their dad was and to that [49:52] family there was no difference [49:53] between what happened in that [49:54] moment and a kidnaping In broad [49:55] daylight there was aggression. [49:57] There was a total disregard for [49:58] anyone safety someone they [49:58] loved was grabbed and taken to [49:59] an unknown place with no word [50:04] of whether he'd ever come home [50:05] as he arrived on the scene and [50:10] for the family and [50:10] the neighbors there they did [50:11] not feel seen or protected from [50:15] that interaction. [50:16] In fact, they walked away [50:16] feeling unseen and less safe. [50:22] Everyone deserves to feel safe. [50:23] Safety requires trust and trust [50:23] requires honesty and [50:24] transparency. [50:24] And so I'm going to reiterate [50:27] here and ask that I've made [50:28] repeatedly to the chief and to [50:33] the mayor And the first is to [50:34] make his presence public when [50:38] as dpd is at an immigration [50:39] enforcement action. [50:40] So I'm asking for the mayor to [50:44] direct as dpd to publish a [50:45] report a public report within [50:45] three business days Every time [50:51] officers respond to a scene [50:51] where federal immigration [50:52] agents are present they need to [50:53] let the public know why [50:56] officers were there, what they [50:56] did and didn't do, which [50:57] agencies were present and [50:58] whether a judicial warrant was [50:58] shown. [51:03] Again, this is about safety and [51:03] transparency. [51:04] Worth noting those ice agents [51:05] were wearing vests that said [51:09] police we should not expect [51:09] every day people in this [51:10] community to be able to [51:10] distinguish between an ice [51:14] agent wearing a police vest and [51:15] a cpd officer wearing a police [51:15] vest. [51:16] The only way to restore that [51:20] trust is through transparency. [51:21] So that's the first ask. [51:26] The second is to help families [51:27] find their loved ones. [51:27] And there's a couple of [51:28] components to that. [51:32] The first is that when officers [51:32] are at the scene of a federal [51:33] immigration arrest, they can be [51:38] directed to record which agency [51:38] made the arrest and give that [51:39] give the family that [51:39] information in writing. [51:40] And we also should be letting [51:44] families know how to find a [51:45] detained person providing [51:50] information and assistance in [51:51] looking for that family members [51:51] And taken is the least that we [51:52] can do to make a family be seen [51:56] what is most likely the worst [51:56] moment of their lives. [51:57] We're not asking us dpd to stop [51:58] federal agents. [52:02] We're not asking officers to be [52:02] lawyers. [52:03] We're asking for the bare [52:04] minimum that a department sworn [52:08] to protect and serve as a [52:09] family in that worst moment of [52:09] their lives their loved one was [52:13] taken by this agency. [52:14] By the agency. [52:15] Here's how you find them. [52:15] It's our way of telling them We [52:16] see you. [52:19] We're sorry you're going [52:20] through this and we're going to [52:20] do what we can. [52:25] The city can no longer allow [52:25] reality that we can't stop and [52:26] fix everything as a reason to [52:26] do nothing. [52:32] So that's the coda. [52:33] And I don't know if your [52:36] response on the spot but I [52:36] would like one that you [52:37] absolutely have our commitment [52:37] to implement both those [52:41] requests especially the second [52:42] piece there on providing [52:42] resources. [52:43] I believe we have a handful of [52:43] links on our website. [52:47] It's time to to refresh those [52:48] and share those Talking points [52:49] are baked into our both our [52:49] officers to engage with [52:54] community members who are [52:55] observer witness and experience [52:55] and as well as any backend [52:56] support we can provide as a [52:59] municipal organization and to [53:00] engage with contacts we do have [53:00] to try to get more information [53:06] than is typically provided by [53:06] federal forces who come out [53:07] here. [53:07] So you have a commitment both [53:08] Councilmember I appreciate [53:08] that. [53:11] So thank you so much go to [53:12] thank you council PRESIDENT All [53:13] right thank you council member [53:13] and that's anybody else on [53:17] the lights. [53:18] >> The clerk will now go over [53:19] how the public and offered [53:24] their testimony clerk Thank you [53:24] . [53:25] Council PRESIDENT I'd like to [53:25] highlight the slide on [53:26] the screen. [53:26] The order can be found on [53:27] the agenda summary online or a [53:29] table in the back of the room. [53:30] But there's only one item at [53:30] the conclusion of that item [53:31] will be on agenda Public [53:31] comment For those that have [53:34] submitted an organized [53:35] presentation or an item on [53:35] today's agenda please be sure [53:36] to have all of your identified [53:40] participants present present [53:40] when the item is introduced. [53:41] We did only receive one [53:46] in-person organized [53:47] presentation that was by [53:47] the deadline. [53:48] So please ensure that all of [53:48] your identified participants [53:52] raise their hand when prompted [53:53] here in council chambers. [53:54] If you are in person please [53:54] complete complete a speaker [53:58] slip Look it at the entrance of [53:59] chambers and bring it to [53:59] the front of the room. [54:00] You can place it in the clear [54:03] box where the blue arrow points [54:04] Council ambassadors are [54:04] available near the entrance and [54:05] can assist with speaker slips [54:06] and questions No further [54:10] in-person testimony will be [54:11] taken once the council begins [54:11] Virtual testimony Thank you [54:15] Council PRESIDENT All right, [54:16] Thank you. [54:17] With that please introduce item [54:17] 200. [54:21] Item 200 is authorized use of [54:21] surveillance technologies under [54:22] the trust ordinance Public [54:27] comment time for this item will [54:27] be one minute per person. [54:28] >> Thank you Council PRESIDENT [54:29] All right with that I see staff [54:33] is settled at the table there [54:34] so please introduce yourselves [54:35] for the record and let us know [54:35] how much time you will need. [54:39] Good afternoon. [54:40] Council PRESIDENT McGovern [54:41] Honorable Members of City [54:41] Council. [54:41] I'm Scott Wall, chief of [54:45] the San Diego Police Department [54:45] . [54:46] I am joined today by Captain [54:47] Charles Lora and Lieutenant [54:47] Chris McAndrew. [54:51] We're here today to present our [54:52] annual survey on support for [54:56] 2025 and we'll need about 20 [54:57] minutes beginning already But [54:57] good afternoon. [55:01] >> Council members. [55:02] Today we're here to present our [55:03] 2025 annual Surveillance report [55:06] and request approval for [55:07] the continued use of 54 [55:07] surveillance technologies. [55:08] Technology plays an important [55:09] role in modern policing. [55:12] It gives our officers tools to [55:13] better understand what's [55:13] happening in the field, gather [55:14] critical information during [55:18] investigations and make [55:19] informed decisions about how to [55:19] respond to public safety [55:20] incidents. [55:20] All that helps our officers [55:24] better serve victims of crime [55:24] and keep our communities safe. [55:25] We recognize the importance of [55:26] being transparent with our [55:29] community and how these [55:30] technologies are used [55:31] The privacy safeguards we've [55:31] worked hard to put in place [55:32] This annual process gives us an [55:36] opportunity to do just that. [55:36] This presentation will focus on [55:40] our use of technologies In 2025 [55:40] . [55:41] We'll be back in FEBRUARY with [55:42] our next annual report covering [55:45] their use in 2026. [55:46] This report covers 54 different [55:52] surveillance technologies [55:52] the police department utilizes [55:53] Each one has already gone [55:54] through the full oversight [55:54] process. [55:57] That means they were discussed [55:58] in community presentations [55:59] reviewed by the Privacy [55:59] Advisory Board and approved by [56:04] the City Council. [56:04] The annual surveillance report [56:05] process is how we continue that [56:10] oversight each year. [56:10] Now we did not propose any new [56:11] surveillance technologies in [56:16] 2025 and the vast majority of [56:17] our existing technologies and [56:17] their use policies remain [56:18] unchanged. [56:21] The two technologies with [56:22] proposed changes were automated [56:22] license plate readers or npr [56:27] and drones for npr. [56:28] Those changes included further [56:28] restrictions to certain uses, [56:33] stronger access controls and [56:33] new council notification [56:34] requirements In the event that [56:35] approach for drone technology [56:39] we consolidated 16 largely [56:40] duplicative policies into one [56:40] comprehensive policy. [56:41] This makes the rules for drone [56:45] use clearer and gives [56:46] the public and the Privacy [56:47] Advisory Board one reference [56:47] point to understand how [56:51] the technology is used. [56:52] The drones We're talking about [56:53] what I refer to as our truck [56:53] deployed drones already [56:57] approved by council. [56:58] There are no new [56:59] functionalities here and they [56:59] are not. [57:00] The drone is first responder [57:03] program which is still working [57:04] its way through the trust [57:04] process. [57:05] Importantly it is again these [57:08] policy changes do not expand [57:09] any technological capabilities. [57:10] Instead they're focused on [57:15] strengthening safeguards, [57:16] improving oversight and making [57:16] our policies easier to follow. [57:20] And that ties into a larger [57:21] focus for us this year [57:22] strengthening auditing and [57:22] oversight across our [57:26] surveillance technologies. [57:26] We made significant [57:27] improvements to our audit and [57:31] accountability measures in [57:31] 2025. [57:32] In FEBRUARY 2025 we issued a [57:37] new order requiring officers to [57:38] document a case number or event [57:38] number whenever they conduct a [57:39] search in the flock system. [57:42] This allows us to better track [57:43] how the system is being used [57:44] and ensures searches can be [57:44] tied back to a legitimate law [57:48] enforcement purpose. [57:49] In APRIL we established new [57:53] auditing requirements for all [57:54] 54 surveillance technologies. [57:54] Each technology's subject [57:55] matter expert is now [57:58] responsible for tracking ten [57:58] specific data points and [57:59] conducting quarterly audits. [58:00] We also added another layer of [58:05] oversight by requiring our [58:05] inspection control unit to [58:06] conduct annual inspections of [58:07] those audits independent of [58:10] the subject matter experts at [58:10] chain of command. [58:11] Then in JULY we expanded our [58:15] documentation requirements and [58:16] surveillance technology [58:16] database that requires a [58:17] reference number or [58:18] justification for use must now [58:22] be tied to a case number or an [58:23] event number. [58:24] Taken together, these changes [58:24] can give us better visibility [58:27] into how our technologies are [58:28] being used and help us make [58:29] sure our policies are being [58:34] followed. [58:34] The continued strengthening of [58:35] safeguards around our health [58:36] care system with a particular [58:36] focus for the department. [58:41] First a quick overview of how [58:41] the technology works. [58:42] Our cameras take pictures of [58:45] vehicles as they pass along [58:46] public roadways. [58:47] Here you see an example of what [58:47] one of those images looks like [58:48] and the information the system [58:52] captures the license plate [58:53] number, the license type, [58:54] the vehicle's make model color [58:58] and distinguishing features [58:58] like a roof rack or a bumper [58:59] sticker. [58:59] It's also important to know [59:00] what the system doesn't do. [59:04] It does not record audio or [59:04] video. [59:05] It does not use facial [59:09] recognition and cannot identify [59:10] the race, age or gender of [59:11] drivers for passengers. [59:11] It also does not provide [59:15] personal identifying [59:16] information such as the name of [59:17] the vehicle's registered owner. [59:17] That information is not [59:22] included in the lpr system. [59:23] One of the greatest strengths [59:24] is speed. [59:28] It helps officers identify and [59:29] locate vehicles connected to [59:29] crimes or public safety [59:33] emergencies often much faster [59:34] than traditional policing [59:34] methods. [59:35] It's especially useful when [59:36] officers have limited [59:39] information to work with like [59:40] partial license plate or just a [59:41] vehicle description. [59:45] Hdr can help turn that [59:45] information into an [59:46] investigative lead, [59:47] particularly when time is [59:47] critical. [59:51] It can also help officers [59:51] locate stolen vehicles and [59:52] vehicles associated with at [59:53] risk missing persons. [59:57] But I want to emphasize an [59:58] important distinction. [59:59] Npr provides an investigative [59:59] lead. [1:00:03] It is not proof of wrongdoing [1:00:04] and every npr alert must be [1:00:05] independently verified before [1:00:06] officers take enforcement [1:00:06] action. [1:00:10] Officers must confirm [1:00:11] the vehicle information, [1:00:11] establish that the alert is [1:00:12] valid and conduct their own [1:00:16] investigation before taking [1:00:16] further action including making [1:00:17] a traffic stop or arrest. [1:00:22] Cpd has used a system since [1:00:23] late 2023. [1:00:24] Today 500 cameras are installed [1:00:24] across the city and those [1:00:29] locations are posted on [1:00:29] the city's website. [1:00:30] Since then we've seen just how [1:00:31] useful this system can be. [1:00:35] Hpr has assisted in more than [1:00:36] 940 investigations, helped [1:00:40] officers make over 700 arrests [1:00:40] and helped recover 689 stolen [1:00:41] vehicles. [1:00:42] During this period San Diego [1:00:46] has also seen a 20% year over [1:00:46] year decline in motor vehicle [1:00:47] theft for three consecutive [1:00:47] years. [1:00:52] And I want to give you a recent [1:00:52] example. [1:00:53] This past MAY officers [1:00:53] responded to a serious hit and [1:00:57] run crash where a driver struck [1:00:58] a bus stop seriously injuring a [1:00:58] person. [1:00:59] Witnesses provided a partial [1:01:00] license plate number and [1:01:04] description of the vehicle. [1:01:04] Using that information in hpr [1:01:08] officers were able to locate [1:01:08] the vehicle within just 26 [1:01:09] minutes of the initial 911 call [1:01:10] ultimately leading to [1:01:14] the suspect's arrest. [1:01:14] That speed mattered. [1:01:15] Officers were able to secure [1:01:16] time sensitive evidence [1:01:20] indicating the driver had been [1:01:20] under the influence at the time [1:01:21] of the crash. [1:01:22] And there are many more [1:01:26] examples like this from [1:01:27] homicides and sexual assaults [1:01:27] to missing persons hate crimes [1:01:28] and attempted kidnapings. [1:01:32] He has helped San Diego police [1:01:33] officers investigate serious [1:01:34] crimes, identify suspects and [1:01:35] pursue justice for victims [1:01:41] across our city. [1:01:42] >> Results like these have [1:01:42] helped drive widespread [1:01:43] adoption of our technology in [1:01:43] major cities across [1:01:44] the country. [1:01:48] This technology is not new. [1:01:49] Npr has been used by law [1:01:52] enforcement in our country for [1:01:53] over 20 years and today 18 of [1:01:54] the nation's 20 largest cities [1:01:54] use it. [1:01:58] And a 2020 national study found [1:01:59] that every responding law [1:02:01] enforcement agency serving more [1:02:02] than 1 million residents [1:02:08] reported using a lpr. [1:02:09] But the department has always [1:02:09] understood that having an [1:02:10] effective tool is only part of [1:02:10] the equation. [1:02:14] We also need strong safeguards [1:02:14] to make sure it's used properly [1:02:15] and responsibly. [1:02:16] And I think the city council [1:02:19] and our oversight board should [1:02:20] be proud of the work [1:02:20] accomplished in 2025. [1:02:21] Some of the safeguards [1:02:22] developed here in San Diego [1:02:26] including requiring a case or [1:02:27] event number for every day of [1:02:28] your search are now being [1:02:28] adopted by agencies across [1:02:31] the country. [1:02:32] So how do we protect this data [1:02:33] and prevent misuse? [1:02:33] First access is restricted to [1:02:38] trained authorized cpd [1:02:38] personnel. [1:02:39] Every user must have a [1:02:40] department email address and [1:02:40] sign on through The city's [1:02:44] secure logging system. [1:02:44] Every search must also include [1:02:45] a legitimate investigative [1:02:50] reason including an offense or [1:02:51] case type and corresponding [1:02:51] case or event number. [1:02:56] Searches related to immigration [1:02:56] Foresman and reproductive [1:02:57] health are prohibited. [1:02:58] Supervisors conduct weekly [1:02:58] audits of system searches to [1:03:02] ensure the technology is being [1:03:03] used appropriately. [1:03:04] The system also has strict [1:03:09] rules governing how long data [1:03:09] is kept and who can't and who [1:03:10] can be shared with it If your [1:03:13] data is permanently deleted [1:03:14] after 30 days unless it needs [1:03:15] to be preserved as evidence. [1:03:19] Every time officers log in [1:03:20] the reminder that misuse of [1:03:21] the system can result in [1:03:21] disciplinary action. [1:03:22] And the searches for [1:03:25] immigration enforcement [1:03:26] reproductive health purposes [1:03:26] are prohibited. [1:03:27] Our policy is also in line with [1:03:32] state law and prohibit sharing [1:03:32] illegal pure data with federal [1:03:33] or state agencies. [1:03:33] And recent changes to [1:03:38] the system have added another [1:03:39] layer of protection by [1:03:40] preventing California agencies [1:03:40] from configuring their lpa [1:03:44] database to share data with [1:03:44] those agencies. [1:03:45] I also want to emphasize that [1:03:46] cpd has never used data from [1:03:50] this system for immigration [1:03:50] enforcement purposes. [1:03:51] >> This year we continue [1:03:56] continued working closely with [1:03:56] the Privacy Advisory Board to [1:03:57] strengthen our oversight and [1:03:57] accountability. [1:03:58] One result of that work is our [1:04:02] new community concerns matrix. [1:04:03] It takes the concerns raised by [1:04:03] community members and city [1:04:04] council and shows the specific [1:04:08] safeguards we put in place to [1:04:08] address them. [1:04:09] We've also developed a risk [1:04:09] audit matrix. [1:04:14] This document identifies [1:04:14] potential risks within [1:04:15] the system. [1:04:16] Outlines the safeguards we have [1:04:16] in place to address them and [1:04:20] explains how we audit those [1:04:20] safeguards to make sure they're [1:04:21] working as intended. [1:04:22] I want to emphasize that [1:04:26] the department takes any misuse [1:04:26] of the system extremely [1:04:27] seriously. [1:04:27] If an audit uncovers potential [1:04:28] misuse, the user's access is [1:04:33] immediately suspended while we [1:04:33] investigate. [1:04:34] Any confirmed misuse can result [1:04:35] in disciplinary action up to [1:04:39] and including termination. [1:04:39] We've also created a [1:04:40] recommendations tracker so [1:04:45] the privacy advisory Board can [1:04:46] see how we responded to its [1:04:47] recommendations and what steps [1:04:47] we've taken to implement them. [1:04:51] The city's trust ordinance was [1:04:51] designed to help us evaluate [1:04:52] technologies like npr with an [1:04:57] emphasis on ongoing oversight [1:04:57] and continuous improvement. [1:04:58] We believe the framework has [1:04:59] helped that San Diego Park has [1:05:02] given us a structured way to [1:05:03] address concerns, strengthen [1:05:04] safeguards and continually [1:05:04] improve how we use this [1:05:08] technology. [1:05:09] In closing, we're asking [1:05:09] Council to approve staff's [1:05:10] recommendation to continue [1:05:11] using the department's [1:05:15] surveillance technologies. [1:05:15] With the proposed changes, [1:05:16] these changes would include [1:05:17] combining the Department's us [1:05:21] policies into a single policy [1:05:22] and making additional changes [1:05:23] to the opr use policy. [1:05:23] We're asking the city's labor [1:05:27] relations team to review these [1:05:28] changes and determine whether [1:05:28] they require notice to a [1:05:29] recognize employee. [1:05:34] Employee organizations and an [1:05:35] opportunity to meet and confer [1:05:35] under the Myers Munis Brown [1:05:36] Act. [1:05:39] If notice is required the city [1:05:40] would provide it and return to [1:05:41] council if any bargaining [1:05:46] related issues meet council [1:05:46] action. [1:05:52] That concludes presentation. [1:05:57] Going a little faster so thank [1:05:57] you for that. [1:05:58] >> So with that Clark please [1:05:59] proceed with all the comment. [1:06:03] Thank you. [1:06:04] Council PRESIDENT We did [1:06:04] receive more speaker slips [1:06:05] since. [1:06:07] So right now we're at about [1:06:08] three hours of public testimony [1:06:09] starting with organized [1:06:14] presentations. [1:06:14] If we can have that hall, [1:06:15] please come forward. [1:06:20] And in the following [1:06:21] individuals can please raise [1:06:21] their hand. [1:06:26] Omar Yusef Mohammad Omar. [1:06:27] Thank you. [1:06:27] My brother. [1:06:28] My brother. [1:06:34] Other Okay. [1:06:35] Leila Goodman If you can please [1:06:36] raise your hand higher. [1:06:37] Leila Omar Thank you very much. [1:06:37] Thank you. [1:06:43] Thank you, MR. Diamond. [1:06:43] Soraya Moment. [1:06:49] Daniela Alvarado. [1:06:53] Mohammad Mohammed Abby two [1:06:54] college Thank you. [1:06:54] Sharon Larios. [1:07:00] Sharon Larios. [1:07:01] I am not seeing your hand If [1:07:04] you are okay, I'll wait one [1:07:05] second and then Kiana Price [1:07:05] Thank you. [1:07:18] Waiting for Sharon Larios That [1:07:18] is a 13 minutes. [1:07:19] If she does not attend it will [1:07:23] be 12 And then if she comes in [1:07:24] she can raise your hand and [1:07:25] will add the extra minute. [1:07:25] Please proceed. [1:07:32] Thank you, Counsel. [1:07:33] Our presentation is going to [1:07:34] begin with you, sir Yousef and [1:07:38] then I'll hand off to me. [1:07:39] >> Good afternoon, Counsel [1:07:43] Humaira Yousef with Pena, a [1:07:48] member of the Trust Coalition. [1:07:49] >> Thank you all for being here [1:07:49] today. [1:07:50] After many failed attempts [1:07:54] today, the trust of [1:07:54] the coalition is here once [1:07:55] again asking city leaders to [1:07:59] reject the youth policy for [1:08:00] the lpr. [1:08:00] Three years after this [1:08:05] technology was spread across [1:08:05] San Diego, the harms that we [1:08:06] warned of are now spilling into [1:08:07] the streets for all to see. [1:08:11] We are happy that you were here [1:08:12] and that the council and [1:08:13] the public understands today [1:08:16] more than ever before that [1:08:17] dangers of this technology. [1:08:22] It has been a long time coming [1:08:23] and we hope that today San [1:08:23] Diego leaders stand with [1:08:24] the community to rescind to [1:08:27] rescind this policy. [1:08:28] But that is not enough to [1:08:29] address the problems with this [1:08:29] technology. [1:08:33] We are here to ask that you [1:08:33] make a vote that actually means [1:08:38] something to San Diego and that [1:08:39] we can see and believe a vote [1:08:39] to reject the city's youth [1:08:44] policy if not a removal And it [1:08:44] does not stop this technology [1:08:45] from creating data about it and [1:08:50] sending it to a flock for it to [1:08:50] be used against us across [1:08:51] the country. [1:08:55] City councils have voted [1:08:56] against these cameras and watch [1:08:57] them keep generating data for [1:09:01] weeks and for months. [1:09:01] San Diego has 500 of them every [1:09:02] day they are running. [1:09:06] This is youth by the city and [1:09:07] the data flows directly to [1:09:07] flock. [1:09:10] So our coalition is asking [1:09:11] three things of you today [1:09:11] reject the youth policy. [1:09:16] Direct the mayor to remove [1:09:17] the cameras and until that's [1:09:18] done install covers on them In [1:09:24] a way anyone walking can verify [1:09:25] . [1:09:25] But first we need to briefly [1:09:26] explain why we are here today. [1:09:30] Like you, this is the city's [1:09:35] own record one The department's [1:09:36] own annual report for 2024 [1:09:37] showed dozens of times San [1:09:41] Diego's Alpers was shared with [1:09:42] federal agencies and out of [1:09:42] state agencies which is clearly [1:09:47] against state law. [1:09:47] San Diego chose to share this [1:09:48] data illegally during a time [1:09:51] where there was a direct attack [1:09:52] on our immigrant communities by [1:09:57] the federal administration when [1:09:58] families were being torn apart [1:10:02] and kidnaped our data was being [1:10:02] shared. [1:10:03] It took a letter from [1:10:03] the Attorney General's office [1:10:04] to stop them. [1:10:08] Since then questions about data [1:10:09] ending up in charges and [1:10:09] the federal government's high [1:10:13] intensity drug trafficking area [1:10:14] database have been raised in [1:10:18] the public media with no [1:10:19] accountability to those [1:10:24] questions yet to come to Hugot [1:10:24] Hugo Parra spent nearly a month [1:10:25] in jail through Thanksgiving [1:10:29] for a carjacking in Golden Hill [1:10:29] while the system held a record [1:10:34] of his friend's car sitting in [1:10:35] Old Town five miles away. [1:10:38] >> George Horry Photo a 19 year [1:10:39] old passenger on his way to [1:10:44] work was shot after the system [1:10:44] flagged a car as stolen. [1:10:49] The owner said it never was [1:10:49] three. [1:10:50] Last week we learned that as [1:10:54] you flock to track domestic [1:10:55] violence a domestic violence [1:10:55] victim and its own officers [1:10:59] during an interim internal [1:11:00] investigation due to the lax [1:11:00] policies championed and [1:11:04] approved by this council, we [1:11:05] actually have no idea how [1:11:06] the department is using this [1:11:09] technology and if it has any [1:11:10] limits to speak of at all. [1:11:11] Those are not just risks. [1:11:15] They are events that keep [1:11:15] happening according to your own [1:11:19] records and they have had no [1:11:20] response And these are just [1:11:24] cases we are aware of And [1:11:25] because of media coverage we [1:11:25] know of them because of [1:11:26] the media coverage. [1:11:29] And I wonder how many incidents [1:11:30] are happening that we don't [1:11:30] know about yet. [1:11:35] We need to and we need to [1:11:35] address a disturbing paradox [1:11:36] here today. [1:11:39] San Diego is said to have one [1:11:40] of the strongest surveillance [1:11:43] oversight in the country. [1:11:44] What the mayor calls the gold [1:11:48] standard trust was built so [1:11:49] this city would catch exactly [1:11:53] these problems before they [1:11:53] happened. [1:11:57] Meanwhile, at least 284 local [1:11:58] governments have canceled [1:11:59] license plate reader contracts [1:12:03] since the start of 2025, most [1:12:03] of them being black. [1:12:07] >> Most of those cities have no [1:12:08] surveillance ordinance at all. [1:12:08] Some of these places heard [1:12:12] complaints from just a small [1:12:13] number of people. [1:12:13] In one city council meeting and [1:12:16] they decided to protect [1:12:17] the people of their city. [1:12:17] We have a law. [1:12:21] We have a board of experts. [1:12:22] We have annual reports and we [1:12:23] have three years of public [1:12:30] testimony Right. [1:12:31] >> And still we need to, you [1:12:34] know, recognize where we're at [1:12:35] right now. [1:12:39] The system is still running So [1:12:40] the question is not whether [1:12:41] oversight can work but rather [1:12:44] why did the oversight process [1:12:48] not work In the case of Bill pr [1:12:49] for three years? [1:12:49] San Diegans have filled this [1:12:50] chamber again and again. [1:12:54] Hundreds oppose the acquisition [1:12:55] of this dangerous technology. [1:12:55] More than 100 people spoke [1:12:59] right here in City Hall last [1:12:59] DECEMBER. [1:13:00] Advocates wrote their own [1:13:03] impact report mapped [1:13:04] the cameras out across the city [1:13:08] engaged in every step of [1:13:08] the process. [1:13:09] No city could ask for more [1:13:13] public participation and a [1:13:14] clear rejection than San Diego [1:13:14] have had. [1:13:18] Despite this, the majority of [1:13:19] this council continued to vote [1:13:19] to keep this technology [1:13:20] running. [1:13:23] While there are concerns about [1:13:24] how this technology is being [1:13:27] used by the Department, [1:13:28] the department is who oversight [1:13:28] is aimed at. [1:13:33] It proposes the technology, [1:13:33] defends it and reports on it. [1:13:37] It's the role its role in this [1:13:38] process is to be checked, not [1:13:47] to check itself further. [1:13:48] >> The Privacy Advisory Board [1:13:48] of Experts has made strong [1:13:52] recommendations against this [1:13:52] technology. [1:13:57] In JUNE 2023 that the pab voted [1:13:58] to reject this proposal as [1:13:58] written. [1:13:59] In AUGUST the Council approved [1:14:02] them anyway. [1:14:03] In APRIL 2025 they said this [1:14:07] use of all lpr data until four [1:14:11] amendments were made NOVEMBER [1:14:11] 2025 cease use. [1:14:12] The Department and Block are [1:14:15] not in compliance with trust. [1:14:16] One week later the Public [1:14:16] Safety Committee voted [1:14:20] unanimously to set that aside. [1:14:21] In DECEMBER the Council [1:14:24] approved the policy 5 to 3 [1:14:25] APRIL 2026 of this year. [1:14:29] They said reject continued use [1:14:34] unless and until auditing and [1:14:35] oversight to improve That [1:14:38] recommendation has waited six [1:14:39] and a half months until today. [1:14:39] So we are here. [1:14:43] The mayor has asked you all to [1:14:44] allow the established oversight [1:14:44] process to work. [1:14:48] It has worked four times. [1:14:52] Despite these recommendations, [1:14:53] each time the board and [1:14:53] the public urge you to stop [1:14:54] the majority of the council [1:14:57] defer to the department and to [1:15:07] those council members who defer [1:15:18] to the department at each half [1:15:28] measure. [1:15:28] You asked for like an rfp or an [1:15:28] amended annual report Another [1:15:28] audit. [1:15:28] It has still kept these cameras [1:15:28] running while the problems [1:15:29] continue to pile up. [1:15:29] We know it's not easy to come [1:15:29] out and say we made a mistake [1:15:29] So we welcome the change in [1:15:29] stance from many of you and we [1:15:29] hope that today we can make [1:15:30] sure that it doesn't happen [1:15:30] again. [1:15:32] >> That's why I thank you. [1:15:33] Seth Hall with the Trust City [1:15:33] Coalition. [1:15:36] That is why Omar Ruiz points [1:15:37] are why today we're asking for [1:15:37] more than just a vote to [1:15:40] rescind the use policy in other [1:15:41] cities. [1:15:41] We can look and see what [1:15:45] happens when city councils like [1:15:56] you do attempt to reject floc. [1:16:06] And what happens is not what a [1:16:16] lot of I think city leaders [1:16:26] think will happen in Eugene. [1:16:36] They ordered their cameras to [1:16:46] be shut down and it continued [1:16:46] to scan license plates for for [1:16:46] weeks and weeks on end. [1:16:46] In Springfield they deactivated [1:16:46] their cameras. [1:16:47] Foxx reactivated them on their [1:16:47] own. [1:16:47] In Cleveland they rejected [1:16:47] their renewal. [1:16:47] But then 100 cameras kept [1:16:47] rolling right in Los Angeles. [1:16:48] Our nearby neighbor. [1:16:48] 100 cameras kept rolling. [1:16:48] Right. [1:16:48] In fact, there have been [1:16:48] incidents where Floc has [1:16:48] literally detected that their [1:16:49] cameras have been blocked and [1:16:49] have sent people out to unblock [1:16:49] them. [1:16:49] So we're asking for more than [1:16:49] that. [1:16:49] We don't want to tell San Diego [1:16:50] these cameras are off. [1:16:50] Just trust us. [1:16:50] I think that's asking [1:16:50] the public for faith that has [1:16:50] not been earned. [1:16:50] Nobody driving or walking by a [1:16:51] camera can tell whether it's [1:16:51] powered on. [1:16:51] They can only verify two things [1:16:51] and that's a camera that is [1:16:54] gone or maybe a camera that's [1:16:54] like covered by something that [1:17:04] we know they can't see through [1:17:05] . [1:17:05] It's important that we take a [1:17:05] stop real quick at [1:17:05] the ordinance and make sure [1:17:05] that we're respecting the law [1:17:05] today. [1:17:06] The ordinance is very specific [1:17:09] about what happens once city [1:17:13] council rescinds a use policy [1:17:13] or the use of that technology [1:17:14] is no longer authorized. [1:17:18] We wrote Grace periods into [1:17:19] this law in a couple of [1:17:19] different places but not here. [1:17:22] There's no grace period here. [1:17:23] So there's there's there's [1:17:27] accountability built into [1:17:28] the to the ordinance And I [1:17:32] think if city council cannot [1:17:33] establish clear direction to [1:17:37] make sure that the technology [1:17:38] is under control according to [1:17:39] the policy, then city council [1:17:42] is really leaving the public no [1:17:42] choice except to pursue [1:17:43] accountability through [1:17:46] the ordinance. [1:17:47] So we're asking for three [1:17:47] things today. [1:17:51] First of all, the council [1:17:52] the department is here letting [1:17:56] you know that according to [1:17:56] their use policy everything [1:17:57] here is fine. [1:18:01] And I think the public and I [1:18:01] hope that you will agree that [1:18:02] everything here is not fine [1:18:06] which means that there is a big [1:18:06] problem with this use policy [1:18:07] and this use policy needs to be [1:18:10] rescinded. [1:18:11] That means you need to reject [1:18:11] your approval of it. [1:18:15] But it's not enough to for you [1:18:16] to just reject your approval. [1:18:19] We ask that you please attach [1:18:20] to your motions or your illegal [1:18:24] ongoings here a vision that [1:18:25] expresses how the city is going [1:18:26] to take these cameras down [1:18:29] right? [1:18:30] We should we should be very [1:18:31] specific about not leaving [1:18:34] these cameras up because I [1:18:35] think many of you are going to [1:18:36] tell us your concerns with [1:18:39] these cameras today And it [1:18:40] doesn't make any sense for city [1:18:43] council members to tell us your [1:18:44] concerns about them, vote to [1:18:45] rescind the use policy and then [1:18:49] leave them up on the streets to [1:18:50] keep rolling for those harms to [1:18:53] keep accumulating for flock to [1:18:54] continue to have the data and [1:18:55] for whoever's getting the data [1:18:58] from flock to keep getting it. [1:18:59] For today I think we need to [1:19:03] express a serious vision for [1:19:04] taking these cameras down. [1:19:04] And sometimes I know it's hard [1:19:08] to take cameras down. [1:19:09] This contract we're going to [1:19:10] have to talk to the city [1:19:19] attorney. [1:19:32] I don't know. [1:19:33] We don't want to get involved [1:19:33] with that. [1:19:34] But the fact of the matter is [1:19:34] these cameras, if they cannot [1:19:34] be taken down today, then I [1:19:35] think we need to express a plan [1:19:35] for visually blocking them so [1:19:35] that the people of San Diego [1:19:35] can go about their lives [1:19:35] knowing that they are not under [1:19:35] the eye of this technology. [1:19:36] So we ask that you we ask that [1:19:36] you please rescind and remove [1:19:37] and also block them while they [1:19:38] are being removed. [1:19:38] The last thing I want to do is [1:19:41] make sure that we wrap with [1:19:42] gratitude. [1:19:42] Humaira opened our address to [1:19:47] you with gratitude and I want [1:19:48] to end it there as well. [1:19:48] I want to thank those of you [1:19:51] who worked to bring this item [1:19:52] up from committee where it had [1:19:56] been waiting for a long time. [1:19:56] We still believe in [1:19:57] the oversight ordinance and we [1:19:58] believe our city council [1:20:01] members are the right overseers [1:20:02] to act on this technology to [1:20:02] protect San Diegans. [1:20:06] We still believe in that. [1:20:07] To those members who have [1:20:10] historically supported [1:20:11] the privacy advisory boards [1:20:11] advice and have supported [1:20:12] the community's involvement in [1:20:15] this process, we thank you. [1:20:16] We hope that all council [1:20:20] members can join that club very [1:20:20] soon. [1:20:24] We also want to thank our [1:20:29] champions on the board and I'll [1:20:30] leave you with this quote from [1:20:35] a mayor in Knoxville who faced [1:20:35] the same problem has concluded [1:20:36] I did give you the addition of [1:20:37] Gannett from Sharon Larios. [1:20:48] She did Here. [1:20:49] >> Okay. [1:20:49] Gentle reminder those two [1:20:50] individuals were speaking on [1:20:53] your behalf and you kind of [1:20:54] encroached on their speech That [1:20:54] MAY have made it difficult for [1:20:57] us to hear. [1:20:58] Everybody else is only going to [1:20:58] have one minute. [1:21:03] So if you make a lot of noise [1:21:03] you're going to interfere with [1:21:04] them And I think that's just [1:21:07] courtesy to make sure they have [1:21:08] the full undivided attention by [1:21:08] the council. [1:21:12] So and we've done this last [1:21:16] time big controversial things. [1:21:17] Be respectful of your friends [1:21:18] and neighbors that are coming [1:21:21] out here to talk and let us [1:21:22] hear what they have to say. [1:21:22] Thank you. [1:21:23] Thank you. [1:21:26] Council PRESIDENT. [1:21:26] I'll be calling the following [1:21:27] individuals up and if they can [1:21:30] come to the reserved seats at [1:21:31] the front of the room so that [1:21:31] it can make it for better [1:21:32] meeting management. [1:21:36] It's my Rhonda Chavez if you [1:21:37] can please come up to [1:21:37] the microphone. [1:21:41] After that we have about to [1:21:41] resume Mondragon. [1:21:42] Brendan See ya. [1:21:46] Alex Blythe Uh, Jenny Faulkner [1:21:51] Lucky Aiden If you can all [1:21:51] please come up to the front [1:21:52] row. [1:21:53] It's cell If you can come up to [1:21:55] the microphone you'll have one [1:21:55] minute. [1:21:56] Please be sure to speak into [1:21:56] the mix of those participating [1:21:58] in the Zoom Can hear you. [1:22:05] Thank you. [1:22:05] Okay. [1:22:05] All right. [1:22:06] Well, good afternoon Council. [1:22:09] My name is esl Amanda Chavez. [1:22:10] I am a District three resident [1:22:10] and I'm here speaking out with [1:22:14] the people as a District three [1:22:14] resident for over five years. [1:22:15] I am here to specifically urge [1:22:18] you Council member Whitburn to [1:22:19] do the right thing and stand up [1:22:23] with us your constituents and [1:22:24] the people black, brown, [1:22:28] Muslim, lgbtq plus and [1:22:28] immigrant communities have [1:22:29] suffered the brunt. [1:22:29] These surveillance technologies [1:22:33] bring consequence as they have [1:22:33] been traumatic and [1:22:34] irreversible. [1:22:35] Council members you are up [1:22:38] there because we voted you [1:22:39] there and we the people need [1:22:43] you now more than ever to take [1:22:43] the necessary steps towards [1:22:44] taking these cameras down. [1:22:48] I know it's not lost on you [1:22:49] that we are living through an [1:22:49] era of surveillance and [1:22:52] surveillance in the wrong hands [1:22:52] can be fatal. [1:22:53] This is your opportunity to be [1:22:57] extraordinary in our county, in [1:22:58] our state and in our nation. [1:22:58] Council members, please leave [1:23:02] San Diego in a better direction [1:23:03] and do what you must do to end [1:23:06] the use of your technologies [1:23:07] and bring the cameras down. [1:23:07] >> Thank you. [1:23:10] But resume one Patricia [1:23:15] Mondragon Alliance San Diego [1:23:16] and Dh3 resident San Diego GYNs [1:23:20] cannot continue to be treated [1:23:21] like lab rats in sd this [1:23:24] experience with its own wish [1:23:25] list of tech toys for sd pd [1:23:26] These technologies are new [1:23:30] tools to test experiment with [1:23:31] and play around with before [1:23:31] the public fully understands [1:23:35] how they work, how they are [1:23:36] being used or more importantly [1:23:39] how they compromise our right [1:23:40] to privacy. [1:23:40] For San Diegans [1:23:44] the consequences are not a game [1:23:45] . [1:23:45] Just ask Hugo Barra who spent [1:23:46] nearly a month in jail after a [1:23:49] false flock Alper hit [1:23:50] wrongfully linked him to a [1:23:50] crime. [1:23:51] What this means is we are [1:23:55] creating a system where [1:23:55] technology can generate [1:23:55] suspicion. [1:23:56] Suspicion can lead to [1:24:00] incarceration and people are [1:24:01] left fighting to prove they did [1:24:01] nothing wrong. [1:24:04] This is not a technology or [1:24:04] public safety issue the right [1:24:05] to privacy, due process and [1:24:09] freedom from unjustified [1:24:10] government intrusion are [1:24:10] fundamental rights that do not [1:24:14] disappear because police [1:24:14] department wants to experiment [1:24:15] with new technology. [1:24:16] >> Thank you for that [1:24:24] concluding sentence Brandon. [1:24:24] >> Good afternoon Council [1:24:25] members. [1:24:29] My name is Brandon Segal and [1:24:30] I'm a senior policy advocate [1:24:30] for the aclu of San Diego and [1:24:31] Imperial Counties. [1:24:33] We're here once again to speak [1:24:34] out against the dystopian mass [1:24:35] surveillance currently being [1:24:38] funded by San Diego taxpayers. [1:24:38] I'm hoping the fifth time is [1:24:39] the charm. [1:24:39] The message to San Diego City [1:24:42] Council and Mayor Gloria has [1:24:43] been consistent and [1:24:43] unmistakable. [1:24:44] San Diegans do not want this [1:24:48] mass surveillance technology in [1:24:48] our city. [1:24:49] Thousands of people have signed [1:24:49] petitions and shown up calling [1:24:54] on the city to stop using lpr [1:24:54] technology. [1:24:55] Many former supporters of this [1:24:57] technology have already revoked [1:24:58] or walked back their support of [1:24:59] lpr including council members [1:25:02] Here with us today. [1:25:03] Recent reporting revealed that [1:25:03] hpr was used to track a police [1:25:06] officer in domestic violence [1:25:07] Survivor. [1:25:07] The Police Officers Association [1:25:08] then called for the technology [1:25:14] to not be used on its own [1:25:14] officers and reportedly [1:25:14] the city agreed. [1:25:17] You listen to the police [1:25:17] demands for privacy. [1:25:18] Will you listen to your [1:25:18] constituents demand for [1:25:19] the same? [1:25:21] We're here to demand immediate [1:25:22] action rescind the hpr, use [1:25:22] policy and take the cameras [1:25:22] down. [1:25:25] Thank you. [1:25:31] >> Alex Bly. [1:25:31] Good afternoon Council members. [1:25:36] My name is Alex Wyatt. [1:25:37] I'm a San Diego resident and [1:25:38] have worked in cybersecurity [1:25:38] software and ai for the past [1:25:40] decade. [1:25:41] I'm asking you to oppose item [1:25:41] 200 Terminate the contract and [1:25:45] remove the hardware [1:25:45] immediately. [1:25:46] In 2017 data surpassed oil as [1:25:46] the world's most valuable [1:25:50] resource. [1:25:51] Fast forward today and Safety's [1:25:51] $8.4 billion valuation comes [1:25:55] directly from the data you [1:25:55] allow them to siphon off from [1:25:56] our communities and our [1:25:59] families and our data that we [1:26:00] do not opt into sharing is not [1:26:01] safe. [1:26:03] Recently hackers removed one [1:26:04] roadside camera and copy that [1:26:04] storage. [1:26:05] They found an encryption key to [1:26:08] unlock the data on the cameras [1:26:08] itself. [1:26:08] Not safe. [1:26:09] They use this to unlock [1:26:09] thousands of videos. [1:26:12] One camera logs show 1.6 [1:26:16] million images in 21 day [1:26:17] period. [1:26:17] This hardware can read list as [1:26:18] hardware can live. [1:26:21] Streaming has been caught doing [1:26:21] so. [1:26:22] Floc is the largest locational [1:26:23] database of American public. [1:26:26] This is a critical [1:26:26] cybersecurity threat and San [1:26:27] Diego already is a [1:26:27] cybersecurity target. [1:26:31] Our communities, our family's [1:26:31] likeness and location is not [1:26:32] safe. [1:26:40] >> Thank you, Danica. [1:26:44] >> How I you to me in your way [1:26:45] I am Janika with Ally in San [1:26:45] Diego. [1:26:45] San Diego prides itself on [1:26:48] being America's finest city a [1:26:49] welcoming city and a sanctuary [1:26:50] city for all. [1:26:53] When we allow our immigrant [1:26:53] neighbors, families and friends [1:26:54] to be targeted and hunted using [1:26:55] predatory technology, we are [1:26:58] directly going against what we [1:26:59] represent ourselves as as a [1:26:59] proud member of the black [1:27:03] native and lgbt community. [1:27:04] I want us to recognize [1:27:05] the heightened danger this [1:27:08] technology brings for my [1:27:08] communities who are already [1:27:09] overpolicing over civil. [1:27:10] No one in San Diego should feel [1:27:13] scared to leave their homes or [1:27:14] fear retaliation from those [1:27:14] that claim to protect us [1:27:18] Throughout the nation we have [1:27:18] seen nearly over 300 cities in [1:27:19] their contract and dismantle [1:27:22] this predatory technology. [1:27:23] What are we saying to our most [1:27:24] vulnerable communities when we [1:27:27] ignore numerous violations and [1:27:28] abuses with this technology? [1:27:31] Counsel We ask that you take [1:27:32] appropriate action today and [1:27:33] move toward taking the cameras [1:27:36] down and show that we are truly [1:27:37] a city for all. [1:27:38] And I just want to say happy [1:27:38] Native American Heritage Day. [1:27:46] Thank you to Lucky Aiden and [1:27:51] good afternoon Council members [1:27:52] looking in District nine with [1:27:52] Pan and Trusty. [1:27:56] I'm here to urge you to do [1:27:57] three things Like I said cancel [1:27:57] a contract, reject the youth [1:28:01] policy and take down [1:28:01] the cameras. [1:28:02] We know that illegal pr is [1:28:02] essential for a federal [1:28:05] government to track our people [1:28:05] down. [1:28:06] A pr does not keep us safe. [1:28:09] It makes no sense to leave [1:28:10] the cameras up while we [1:28:10] restrict the youth here in San [1:28:11] Diego. [1:28:14] Communities have been asking [1:28:15] you for years to shut the lock [1:28:15] down. [1:28:16] When will you finally listen? [1:28:20] Is today the day when you put [1:28:20] community over surveillance [1:28:21] over it? [1:28:25] 214 cities have terminated for [1:28:25] contract now. [1:28:28] Please help us remove these [1:28:28] contracts immediately and [1:28:29] follow suit. [1:28:34] >> Thank you. [1:28:35] If I can have Jermaine and [1:28:35] Rocha Galvan please come up to [1:28:38] the microphone after that we [1:28:39] have Patricia Serrano, Lily [1:28:44] Irani, Rihanna does Ariana [1:28:45] Dixit, Kevin Vento and Megan [1:28:47] Ibarra. [1:28:48] >> If you can all please come [1:28:52] forward to the front row. [1:28:52] Good afternoon. [1:28:58] My name is Patricia Serrano and [1:28:58] I would further. [1:28:59] Over the years we have [1:29:02] increasingly seen the floor. [1:29:03] Cameras do not necessarily make [1:29:03] San Diego safer. [1:29:07] In fact, over the past two [1:29:08] years the surveillance systems [1:29:09] raise serious concerns about [1:29:11] their use by Department of [1:29:12] Homeland Security and their [1:29:13] potential impact in our most [1:29:16] vulnerable communities [1:29:17] including domestic violence [1:29:21] survivors, immigrants, Muslims [1:29:22] and black residents. [1:29:22] Do you believe that is an [1:29:26] appropriate use of taxpayer [1:29:26] money especially when these [1:29:27] systems can put vulnerable [1:29:32] community at risk undermining [1:29:32] their sense of safety? [1:29:36] We all knew that a city council [1:29:37] two canceling the contract [1:29:41] would flag take down [1:29:41] the cameras and all other [1:29:42] surveillance systems that [1:29:46] threaten the privacy, safety [1:29:46] and civil rights of our [1:29:47] communities. [1:29:53] >> Thank you, Jermaine. [1:29:54] >> Hello everyone. [1:29:55] My name is Jermaine Rocha [1:29:55] Corba. [1:29:57] I work for the Partnership for [1:29:58] the Advancement of New [1:29:59] Americans in District nine and [1:30:01] my family currently lives in [1:30:02] District four. [1:30:03] I'm here today to urge you to [1:30:06] vote against item 200. [1:30:07] >> I'm asking you to please [1:30:12] cancel not just lpas but cancel [1:30:13] you because you are as well. [1:30:16] What a tough budget year We as [1:30:19] a community of ask you the past [1:30:20] three years to shut down Not [1:30:25] only that we're asking you to [1:30:26] prioritize our communities by [1:30:29] reinvesting in true public [1:30:30] safety like our parks, like our [1:30:31] libraries and youth drop in [1:30:31] centers. [1:30:35] This these are true signs of [1:30:35] safety. [1:30:40] I urge you to please please [1:30:41] shut off, lock down, cancel [1:30:43] your school and please cut the [1:30:48] out. [1:30:49] >> Thank you so much And I hope [1:30:49] you continue to protect our [1:30:50] communities. [1:30:55] Thank you, Lily Irani. [1:30:55] >> All right. [1:30:56] Hi, everybody. [1:31:00] I want to share some lessons [1:31:00] from our own tech history here [1:31:01] in San Diego and why we need to [1:31:05] take the cameras down. [1:31:05] >> Remember ge, General [1:31:05] Electric? [1:31:09] They partnered with this city [1:31:10] to launch the smart [1:31:10] streetlights as a global pr [1:31:14] play that used us as a testbed [1:31:15] for untested and ultimately [1:31:15] broken air. [1:31:19] That was our street lights one. [1:31:20] We were promised parking space [1:31:20] detection but we got 24 seven [1:31:24] sd pd surveillance that was [1:31:25] used against protesters. [1:31:25] But it was all about the money [1:31:29] for ge So ge sold our Smart [1:31:30] Street Lights system to a [1:31:30] private equity firm. [1:31:33] >> And in that private equity [1:31:34] firm sold our smart street [1:31:35] light system to. [1:31:38] When the city canceled that [1:31:39] first Ubiquiti contract, [1:31:39] Ubiquiti actually refused to [1:31:43] shut down the cameras, if you [1:31:44] remember. [1:31:45] This is not a new floc problem [1:31:45] although it's a big flock [1:31:48] problem. [1:31:49] Tech surveillance companies [1:31:49] have the same business models [1:31:53] Grab data from our streets, [1:31:54] monetize new air products, make [1:31:55] investors happy. [1:31:58] It pays for them to drag their [1:31:59] feet when we cancel our [1:31:59] contracts. [1:32:00] So that's why we got to take [1:32:00] care. [1:32:01] Thank you for that concluding [1:32:01] sentence. [1:32:06] Rihanna. [1:32:06] >> Good afternoon Council [1:32:07] members. [1:32:10] My name is Rihanna Doss and I'm [1:32:11] speaking to you as a student [1:32:12] here at uc San Diego as well as [1:32:15] a constituent of council member [1:32:15] LaCava. [1:32:16] I also am a policy advocate for [1:32:16] the Syrian Civil Liberties [1:32:19] Union. [1:32:20] As our elected representatives [1:32:21] it is your duty and your [1:32:22] obligation to defend our civil [1:32:25] liberties. [1:32:26] Voting to keep Floc rolling in [1:32:26] San Diego is the absolute [1:32:29] antithesis of that block has [1:32:30] larger cities lie to the media [1:32:31] and most importantly lie to [1:32:34] the people. [1:32:35] My peers, my neighbors have [1:32:35] been violently abducted at [1:32:39] the grubby hands of Floc and [1:32:39] families that have voted for [1:32:40] you are afraid to even leave [1:32:40] their homes. [1:32:44] It is floc job to cater to [1:32:44] their investors and to turn [1:32:45] revenue at our expense And it [1:32:48] is your job to be our [1:32:48] constitutionally ordained [1:32:49] protected stronghold against [1:32:53] such transparent corruption. [1:32:54] >> Do your job Council members [1:32:55] keep logging out of San Diego. [1:33:02] Thank you Aria and accept. [1:33:03] >> Hello my name is Orian and [1:33:07] the executive director of [1:33:08] Students Civil Liberties Union [1:33:08] and Member Representative for [1:33:11] the Working Families Party of [1:33:12] San Diego. [1:33:13] I guess I can start off by [1:33:17] saying that the most that sd pd [1:33:18] has ever said the get clean [1:33:18] can has done for the city. [1:33:21] It's all of a bunch of vehicle [1:33:22] robberies all while detaining [1:33:23] San Diegans on the pretext of [1:33:27] surveilling domestic abuse [1:33:27] victims and of course providing [1:33:28] critical movement data of our [1:33:32] San Diego and residents to [1:33:32] overseas contractors, federal [1:33:33] agencies and police employed [1:33:33] vengeful exes. [1:33:37] So I have a big problem with [1:33:38] the surveillance network itself [1:33:41] and I think it's it's [1:33:41] the epitome of burning down [1:33:42] the house to kill a spider. [1:33:46] And I think that this entire [1:33:46] system is just essentially [1:33:47] making it so much more [1:33:50] difficult for us to voice our [1:33:51] concerns to you for our [1:33:52] immigrants and resident San [1:33:52] Diego and to voice their [1:33:56] concerns that we need to cancel [1:33:56] the contract with you, [1:33:57] the cover the cameras and we [1:34:00] need to make sure that this [1:34:01] city is block free So get the [1:34:01] out. [1:34:02] >> Thank you so much, Kevin [1:34:05] Vento. [1:34:05] >> After Kevin will have Megan [1:34:10] Ibarra, Ethan Kwong, Logan [1:34:15] King, Raya Aurora and Alex [1:34:15] Blight. [1:34:16] That is a duplicate unless [1:34:18] there's a second Alex Blake [1:34:19] please proceed. [1:34:23] >> Thank you, Counsel. [1:34:24] I just want to go ahead and [1:34:25] start by saying I am very [1:34:25] appreciative of all the council [1:34:28] members who have said that they [1:34:29] are committed to changing their [1:34:29] vote from their previous votes [1:34:33] in the past. [1:34:33] They're very thankful for that [1:34:34] And I do think that, you know, [1:34:35] we will have the votes and that [1:34:38] is you know, much more of a [1:34:38] formality. [1:34:39] But it's all those who have [1:34:42] voted against us for throughout [1:34:43] the three years were that [1:34:43] garners a certain level of [1:34:44] trust and integrity that cannot [1:34:46] be replaced on this council. [1:34:47] And so it is not just about we [1:34:52] do not come here just because [1:34:53] of in our systems and what [1:34:54] flock has been doing. [1:34:56] We will come out again if [1:34:57] the city takes down these [1:34:57] cameras and then puts them up [1:35:01] under a new name like Motorola. [1:35:02] We do not want that to be [1:35:02] the case. [1:35:06] We also are against what Flock [1:35:06] is doing with the flock nova [1:35:07] system which the city is [1:35:08] piloting right now. [1:35:11] These are also high powered [1:35:11] mass surveillance systems that [1:35:12] the city does not want and why [1:35:15] we have come out here and we [1:35:16] will come out in the future if [1:35:17] these are what the city rolls [1:35:17] out if they take down [1:35:18] the cameras today. [1:35:21] And so I just want to make that [1:35:22] clear that this is also what [1:35:22] many of us are against. [1:35:25] >> Thank you, Megan. [1:35:30] Esteemed council members. [1:35:31] >> My name is Megan. [1:35:32] You are the vice chair of [1:35:32] the San Diego Faculty [1:35:35] Association representing over [1:35:36] 2000 ucsd faculty members. [1:35:40] Ucsd is an international hub [1:35:41] for research, medical services [1:35:41] and the arts An emerging [1:35:45] Hispanic serving institution [1:35:45] with the contract City Council [1:35:46] prioritized stolen cars over [1:35:50] people stolen by ice. [1:35:50] That's a false choice. [1:35:51] San Diego's crime rates have [1:35:52] dropped at similar rates as [1:35:55] other California cities that [1:35:55] don't use floc Every day over [1:35:56] 60,000 students, staff and [1:36:00] faculty commute to ucsd flock [1:36:01] cameras increase their risk of [1:36:04] ice kidnapings and misuse [1:36:05] including surveilling domestic [1:36:05] violence survivors and tracking [1:36:09] people receiving care at ucsd [1:36:09] hospitals. [1:36:10] The city has broken our trust [1:36:10] and made us less safe. [1:36:14] Turning the cameras off is not [1:36:14] enough. [1:36:15] The only solution is to take [1:36:18] the cameras down permanently So [1:36:19] we can all see that this [1:36:19] harmful technology is gone. [1:36:21] Thank you. [1:36:27] Thank you, Ethan. [1:36:27] Good evening. [1:36:28] City Council San Diego City [1:36:29] Council Members. [1:36:32] My name is Ethan Kwong and I [1:36:32] represent the student [1:36:33] government at uc San Diego As [1:36:37] the vice PRESIDENT Of local [1:36:37] Affairs. [1:36:38] We serve around 45,000 [1:36:38] undergrad and graduate [1:36:39] students. [1:36:42] And last week we published a [1:36:43] survey among our student body [1:36:44] regarding the opinions of light [1:36:46] cameras. [1:36:47] Among the survey respondents [1:36:51] around over 86% on a scale of 1 [1:36:51] to 5 strongly disagreed that [1:36:52] they were comfortable with [1:36:56] the presence of cameras. [1:36:56] I'm not here to present an [1:36:57] opinion but take [1:36:57] the information as you will. [1:37:00] Will you choose to present or [1:37:01] to represent the opinions of [1:37:06] your student council members of [1:37:06] your esteemed constituents? [1:37:07] And to Joe LaCava 45,000 people [1:37:10] go to uc San Diego. [1:37:10] >> Will you present their [1:37:11] voices today? [1:37:11] Thank you. [1:37:12] Thank you. [1:37:14] Logan Kane. [1:37:19] >> Good afternoon. [1:37:20] My name is Logan King. [1:37:20] I am a lawyer resident and also [1:37:24] a uc San Diego student. [1:37:25] Um while I recognize [1:37:25] the potential utility of [1:37:29] loopers to find criminals and [1:37:30] missing persons I believe that [1:37:30] any sort of government [1:37:31] surveillance should come under [1:37:34] the highest possible public [1:37:35] scrutiny and its benefits must [1:37:35] far outweigh its risks and its [1:37:39] proprietors must be trusted and [1:37:40] not feared by the very people [1:37:40] it protects. [1:37:43] As cbd has failed in these [1:37:44] areas in my opinion they have [1:37:45] lost public trust by [1:37:45] accidentally sharing lpr with [1:37:49] ice and Border Patrol blindly [1:37:49] trusting in and resulting in [1:37:53] the shooting of an innocent man [1:37:54] and now argue can be used in [1:37:55] non-criminal cases which i [1:37:55] think is wrong. [1:37:58] Proposed policy modifications [1:37:59] here are just simply [1:38:00] insufficient to restore this [1:38:03] trust and the technology is too [1:38:04] dangerous to be regulated via [1:38:08] trial and error has stopped has [1:38:09] has done. [1:38:09] Not to mention it is being [1:38:10] sought by a private company. [1:38:14] Just this year scotus ruled in [1:38:15] JANUARY the us that cell phone [1:38:19] location data is required by [1:38:19] the Fourth Amendment to have a [1:38:20] law that concluding come in Ray [1:38:31] Aurora Hi Council members My [1:38:31] name is Ray Aurora. [1:38:32] I'm a resident of District One, [1:38:33] the project manager for [1:38:33] the Students All Liberties [1:38:35] Union as well as the us Vice [1:38:36] PRESIDENT Of Equity Diversity [1:38:36] Inclusion at ucsd. [1:38:40] Thank you to the council [1:38:40] members who have been loyal to [1:38:41] the cause from the very [1:38:42] beginning and thank you to [1:38:44] those who humbly change their [1:38:45] positions and supported us [1:38:45] later on. [1:38:46] As much as I enjoy skipping [1:38:49] class to come speak to you all [1:38:50] I would really appreciate it if [1:38:51] we could put this to an end and [1:38:55] the contracted way so we can [1:38:55] all finally rest. [1:38:56] NOVEMBER 3rd this year showed [1:38:59] us a beacon of hope for [1:38:59] the coming years. [1:39:00] It showed us that the people [1:39:00] have power. [1:39:04] So let it please be shown here [1:39:04] in San Diego to show us that [1:39:05] our voices matter to you And [1:39:06] our politicians are not just [1:39:08] full of empty promises once [1:39:09] again. [1:39:09] >> Get the flock out. [1:39:13] Thank you. [1:39:13] >> Thank you. [1:39:14] And just confirming that there [1:39:18] is not a second Alex Blythe. [1:39:18] It's just a doop. [1:39:18] Okay. [1:39:22] After that if we can have Mary [1:39:22] White please come forward to [1:39:23] the microphone. [1:39:24] And then if I can have Sheila [1:39:27] bear for Alice Dingman and [1:39:28] Nicholas Wong Theo Rothschild [1:39:33] stays me and Karen Evie as well [1:39:34] as Laurie Lipson Please come up [1:39:37] to the front row. [1:39:38] Mary please proceed. [1:39:38] Hi, my name is Mary White. [1:39:42] I'm here because I've been on [1:39:43] the board of two ways one in [1:39:43] Stockton, one here. [1:39:46] We've had cameras for both of [1:39:47] our communities and they help [1:39:48] to solve crimes. [1:39:51] It's my understanding that [1:39:52] the officers who misused [1:39:52] the tools for personal use have [1:39:56] been dealt with. [1:39:57] And my comment is if 1 or 2 [1:39:58] police officers misuse their [1:40:01] weapons vehicles, etc. For [1:40:02] personal reasons, would you [1:40:03] take away their weapons, their [1:40:06] vehicles or dismiss the entire [1:40:06] police department because of [1:40:07] misdeeds of 1 or 2 of [1:40:07] the department's employees? [1:40:10] If 1 or 2 school students [1:40:11] misuse computers for their [1:40:12] personal use, would you condone [1:40:15] the school doing away with [1:40:15] computers for all students? [1:40:16] The l. [1:40:20] P r cameras are an invaluable [1:40:20] tool for the police department [1:40:21] And we heard the police officer [1:40:24] here talk about all the safety [1:40:25] issues that they've been [1:40:26] putting in place for [1:40:26] the cameras. [1:40:29] They don't have facial [1:40:29] recognition. [1:40:30] It's only a license plate [1:40:30] reader. [1:40:31] So there's no way that these [1:40:34] cameras can discriminate on [1:40:35] race, color, gender, anything [1:40:35] like that. [1:40:39] It's strictly license plates [1:40:40] that have been involved in a [1:40:40] crime or at a crime scene. [1:40:41] Thank you for that concluding [1:40:41] sentence. [1:40:49] Sheila Barefoot My name is [1:40:54] Sheila Barefoot. [1:40:55] Good afternoon council members. [1:40:55] I'm here today as someone who [1:40:59] has survived homelessness right [1:40:59] here in San Diego. [1:41:00] I urge you to vote to end [1:41:04] the Floc surveillance contract [1:41:05] and shut these cameras down [1:41:09] when you are unhoused. [1:41:09] You have no walls, no doors and [1:41:10] no privacy. [1:41:14] And when I lived on the street [1:41:15] I survived police brutality [1:41:19] twice and endured cruel, brutal [1:41:19] and relentless harassment. [1:41:23] Automated surveillance does not [1:41:24] protect people like me. [1:41:24] For unhoused residents, [1:41:29] especially those living in [1:41:29] their vehicles, cameras like [1:41:30] Floc act as a dragnet that [1:41:33] criminalizes triggers constant [1:41:34] stops and can escalate [1:41:38] encounters into state violence [1:41:39] . [1:41:39] We just saw how this system [1:41:40] once used to track domestic [1:41:43] violence or via imagine how it [1:41:44] is weaponized against unhoused [1:41:48] who have no power to protect [1:41:48] and fight back. [1:41:53] So mass surveillance is not [1:41:54] public safety. [1:41:54] >> Please terminate this [1:41:58] contract or leave the data and [1:41:59] redirect But thank you Million [1:42:00] dollars in comment. [1:42:01] I do have to be fair to [1:42:01] everybody else. [1:42:06] >> Dingman. [1:42:07] >> Hi my name is Alice. [1:42:10] I am still from District two. [1:42:11] I hope none of my accessories [1:42:11] aro distracting or [1:42:15] uncomfortable for any of you [1:42:16] but really they're for [1:42:16] everyone's safety. [1:42:17] I mean I've got my cell site [1:42:20] simulator because how would we [1:42:20] solve hate crimes if I couldn't [1:42:21] read your texts? [1:42:24] >> And I've got my drone as a [1:42:25] first responder pilot program [1:42:25] because really most situations [1:42:29] don't meet human You're [1:42:29] obsolete. [1:42:30] >> And of course I have my [1:42:31] flock camera because the only [1:42:34] way that I can really be safe [1:42:35] is if I can track everyone all [1:42:38] the time. [1:42:39] And sure, maybe some people [1:42:40] feel less safe but really if [1:42:43] that domestic violence survivor [1:42:44] wasn't doing anything wrong [1:42:45] then she wouldn't be [1:42:48] uncomfortable about strangers [1:42:48] following her movements. [1:42:53] >> And yes, maybe that 19 year [1:42:54] old boy was shot because of a [1:42:57] false hit from my flock camera [1:42:57] . [1:42:58] >> But that's just the price we [1:42:59] pay for safety. [1:43:02] The price we pay is just [1:43:03] constant danger because we [1:43:08] can't possibly rely on them to [1:43:09] be competent and solve things [1:43:09] on their own. [1:43:10] >> Thank you for including [1:43:10] comment. [1:43:18] Nicholas Wong Nicholas Wong [1:43:19] Good afternoon Council members [1:43:19] My name is Nicole Swan. [1:43:23] I'm a constituent of [1:43:24] Councilmember LaCava. [1:43:24] I'm also from the Syrian Civil [1:43:29] Liberties Union and you might [1:43:29] have heard this name bounced [1:43:30] around a couple of times a lot [1:43:31] of the same points as well. [1:43:33] There are enough youth in San [1:43:34] Diego who care about this issue [1:43:35] that you will not hear the end [1:43:38] of it as long as this [1:43:39] conversation is on the table. [1:43:40] So why keep prolonging it? [1:43:43] We have gone here alongside [1:43:44] the terrorist coalition five [1:43:46] times now Five times the charm. [1:43:46] Right. [1:43:47] There will be more and more [1:43:51] effort until our communities [1:43:52] are safe. [1:43:52] And so we urge you as a [1:43:53] constituent as council members [1:43:55] to listen to your constituents [1:43:56] because the youth are voting [1:43:57] bloc and they're here to stay. [1:43:57] All right. [1:43:59] Thank you very much. [1:44:05] >> Thank you to you. [1:44:06] >> Hello council members. [1:44:06] I am Phil Rothchild from [1:44:09] District one and I'm affiliated [1:44:10] with the Democratic Socialists [1:44:10] of America. [1:44:11] Firstly, thank you for [1:44:13] the opportunity to speak in [1:44:14] opposition of item 200 Times [1:44:14] like this remind me of the oft [1:44:18] quoted Benjamin Franklin quote [1:44:18] Those who would give up [1:44:19] essential liberty to purchase a [1:44:20] little temporary safety deserve [1:44:23] neither liberty nor safety. [1:44:23] Block is a dangerous Orwellian [1:44:24] system that criminalizes [1:44:27] poverty and harasses victims of [1:44:28] domestic violence all while [1:44:29] enriching an out of city [1:44:32] corporation with a sweetheart [1:44:32] $2 million a year deal. [1:44:33] How can the police say [1:44:33] surveillance is needed for [1:44:37] safety when they're unwilling [1:44:37] to use body cameras? [1:44:38] And Gloria says he wants a city [1:44:39] for all. [1:44:42] He gives our data to a company [1:44:42] that works in partnership with [1:44:43] ice who are actively assaulting [1:44:44] our communities, pausing it [1:44:44] isn't enough. [1:44:46] A vote against this contract is [1:44:47] a vote for humanity a vote for [1:44:47] all San Diegans. [1:44:54] >> Thank you, Stacey. [1:44:54] Hi, I'm Stacey. [1:44:58] I'm just a stranger passing [1:44:59] through. [1:44:59] These past three months I've [1:45:03] been here. [1:45:04] I think the only fact we need [1:45:07] to have out there is all of us [1:45:08] GOD's children to have more [1:45:09] contact with one another than [1:45:13] rely on the technology. [1:45:18] I was blessed. [1:45:18] >> Karen. [1:45:18] Karen. [1:45:22] There you go. [1:45:27] Hello, Council members. [1:45:31] I live in District five and we [1:45:31] have Alps in my neighborhood [1:45:35] and I've probably already been [1:45:36] logged seven times today before [1:45:37] I even came down here. [1:45:41] We've seen expanded use for [1:45:45] criminals to immigration and [1:45:46] now we have 20 districts 20 [1:45:47] jurisdictions that have used [1:45:51] this tech to track protesters. [1:45:52] Every day San Diego holds [1:45:56] almost 3.6 million images of [1:45:56] people's place day and time. [1:46:00] For the last 30 days flags [1:46:01] coaching of law enforcement to [1:46:05] push their technology is [1:46:05] another concern. [1:46:10] Why is it for sale and safety [1:46:10] or something else? [1:46:15] Flock has a handbook on how to [1:46:15] talk to city council and they [1:46:19] even encourage their police [1:46:20] officers to review their [1:46:20] presentations before city [1:46:25] council. [1:46:26] >> I ask you to please cancel [1:46:26] the contract for flock and for [1:46:28] you because we're thinking and [1:46:33] Laura Lippman. [1:46:38] >> Good afternoon Laurie [1:46:38] Liebesman. [1:46:39] She her District three [1:46:43] surveillance does not create [1:46:43] safety. [1:46:44] Meeting people's essential [1:46:44] needs does. [1:46:48] Housing, education. [1:46:49] Health care. [1:46:49] Access to mental health and [1:46:50] addiction services. [1:46:53] All address the conditions that [1:46:54] contribute to crime Take [1:46:58] the money resources and [1:46:59] personnel invested in [1:46:59] surveillance and militarization [1:47:03] and redirect them towards [1:47:04] housing services for mental [1:47:08] health and addiction education [1:47:09] ,libraries, parks and rec and [1:47:09] infrastructure. [1:47:13] Invest in what uplifts, [1:47:14] supports and protects people. [1:47:17] Stop mass and mass [1:47:18] criminalization and [1:47:18] incarceration. [1:47:22] Fear policing and punishment [1:47:23] are not what builds responsible [1:47:23] engage compassionate or safe [1:47:24] communities. [1:47:29] Thank you. [1:47:29] >> Thank you. [1:47:30] Beth Givens. [1:47:31] Beth Givens if you can please [1:47:32] come up to the microphone after [1:47:33] that will be Damian Gonzalez [1:47:38] Martinez Nicole Sharma, Kian [1:47:42] Chen Drunk can drunk Michael [1:47:42] Salario Matthew Pendergraph [1:47:47] GRift C.J. Mendoza and Claire [1:47:47] Snyder. [1:47:48] If you can all please come up [1:47:51] to the front row. [1:47:52] Beth Please proceed when ready. [1:47:56] Beth Givens Yes. [1:47:56] >> Thank you. [1:47:57] I'm Beth Givens. [1:47:58] Linda Vista Thanks to those of [1:48:01] you who have stated you will [1:48:02] oppose the continuation of [1:48:05] the floor contract also to [1:48:06] the mayor for stating that you [1:48:06] will not veto. [1:48:07] >> I urge the Council to [1:48:09] include in your no vote [1:48:10] statement that you oppose all [1:48:14] automated license plate reader [1:48:15] usage, not just flock. [1:48:16] There are several such [1:48:16] companies. [1:48:19] Please ensure that all cameras [1:48:20] are removed and not just turned [1:48:24] off or covered and also [1:48:25] violations of flock usage [1:48:26] policy by police officers must [1:48:29] be fully investigated and [1:48:30] the offending officers [1:48:34] meaningfully dispute discipline [1:48:35] and not just a slap on [1:48:35] the wrist and not just desk [1:48:36] time. [1:48:40] I also urge you to Rialto flock [1:48:40] funds to city institutions [1:48:43] whose budgets have been reduced [1:48:44] like libraries, parks, rec [1:48:44] centers, arts and housing. [1:48:49] These institutions build [1:48:50] support, build and support [1:48:50] community They're vital to [1:48:54] civic life. [1:48:55] They enrich our lives including [1:48:55] children whose early exposure [1:48:58] is particularly enriching. [1:48:59] >> Thank you. [1:49:03] Thank you, Damien Damian [1:49:06] Gonzalez Martinez are you here [1:49:07] ? [1:49:12] Damien Gonzalez Martinez Moving [1:49:13] to the next individual Nicole [1:49:13] Smith. [1:49:16] >> schama Sorry I don't know [1:49:21] why That's my. [1:49:22] >> Good afternoon, council [1:49:22] members. [1:49:23] My name is Mitchell Sharma. [1:49:26] I'm a student at ucsd, resident [1:49:27] of District One and I'm also [1:49:28] policy advocate for the Student [1:49:28] Civil Liberties Union as a [1:49:31] representative you have an [1:49:32] obligation to protect us as [1:49:33] you've been doing so so far [1:49:33] voting to terminate the fees [1:49:37] contract with Locke it is [1:49:38] necessary to achieve that goal. [1:49:39] Across the country there have [1:49:41] been cases of police officers [1:49:42] abusing Floc data in order to [1:49:43] stock and attract private [1:49:46] individuals With such a case [1:49:46] happened here in San Diego just [1:49:47] recently, people do not have to [1:49:48] be concerned about who can be [1:49:51] tracking them or using data at [1:49:52] any given moment various [1:49:53] parties how you can protect [1:49:57] your constituents Council [1:49:57] PRESIDENT LaCava I appreciate [1:49:58] and align with your anti-Trump [1:49:59] stance Voting against Block is [1:50:02] taking a stance against Trump [1:50:02] and his allies. [1:50:03] >> Please vote to give Flock [1:50:04] out of San Diego. [1:50:09] Thank you Kiana. [1:50:14] >> Good afternoon District one [1:50:15] I strongly urge City Council to [1:50:15] oppose renewal of San Diego's [1:50:19] contract with Walk. [1:50:20] I hope your surveillance [1:50:21] technology is an impediment to [1:50:21] surveillance. [1:50:24] Right to privacy is the right [1:50:25] of all ten Diegans to have [1:50:26] their privacy protected even in [1:50:26] public spaces where privacy is [1:50:29] naturally diminished there are [1:50:30] little to no regulations or [1:50:30] safeguards on data collection [1:50:31] and storage. [1:50:35] As of AUGUST of this year there [1:50:35] have been over 100 documented [1:50:38] cases of police officers across [1:50:39] the country abusing four [1:50:39] cameras 39 cases of which [1:50:40] involve stalking women. [1:50:44] These numbers have almost [1:50:44] certainly grown since then. [1:50:45] This technology does not [1:50:46] reliably read license plate [1:50:49] numbers or recognize faces [1:50:49] correctly. [1:50:50] Little has been done to improve [1:50:51] This field has also been done [1:50:52] to hold companies or law [1:50:54] enforcement accountable for [1:50:55] misusing this technology. [1:50:56] Effective policing should not [1:51:00] come at the price of civilians [1:51:00] privacy and safety While [1:51:01] cameras do not belong in San [1:51:02] Diego and they never will. [1:51:05] I urge you to vote against [1:51:06] the renewal of the state's [1:51:06] contract With luck. [1:51:07] >> Thank you. [1:51:14] Thank you, Michael and Michael [1:51:14] from District two and a member [1:51:15] of Workers strike Back under [1:51:16] pressure from the ongoing fight [1:51:19] against Fox surveillance. [1:51:20] The city council is set to shut [1:51:20] down four cameras in our city. [1:51:24] City council Democrats on [1:51:25] the other hand, have voted four [1:51:26] times for mass surveillance [1:51:26] since 2023. [1:51:30] Council Democrats defense of [1:51:30] Floc is especially shameful [1:51:31] given California's history of [1:51:32] sharing flight data with [1:51:36] Trump's dhs. [1:51:36] And yet Raul Castillo and Money [1:51:37] Man will protect Flock Until [1:51:40] only days ago. [1:51:41] If this technology remains [1:51:42] available it will be exploited [1:51:45] If Mayor Gloria or Council [1:51:46] Democrats try to reactivate [1:51:46] them it would be a massive [1:51:47] betrayal. [1:51:51] We need to get organized [1:51:52] independently of both parties [1:51:52] if we want to fight the A.I. [1:51:53] Billionaires and their system [1:51:56] of mass surveillance to get [1:51:57] involved, join workers strike [1:51:57] Back At our National Zoom [1:51:59] meeting on DECEMBER sixth or [1:52:04] speak with me today Matthew [1:52:10] Pender GRift Hello City Council [1:52:11] My name is Matt. [1:52:15] >> I'm from District three and [1:52:16] I'm here to make a small point [1:52:17] that none of my groups support. [1:52:19] Flock helped in their [1:52:19] surveillance. [1:52:20] So the last time I was here I [1:52:21] heard overwhelming opposition [1:52:26] to flock, yelps etc. Mass [1:52:26] surveillance. [1:52:27] I heard some by groups speak [1:52:27] out in favor of this. [1:52:31] I was really disappointed to [1:52:32] hear that I'm from another by [1:52:32] group called Barksdale Pueblo [1:52:33] where an all volunteer group we [1:52:37] work to support the second [1:52:37] community of San Diego. [1:52:38] We don't support flock and [1:52:38] surveillance for all [1:52:39] the reasons you've already [1:52:42] heard. [1:52:43] I want to provide an example of [1:52:43] a cycling perspective. [1:52:44] For example, I'm not worried if [1:52:47] the person who hits and kills [1:52:48] me if their car gets caught I [1:52:49] don't want to get hit and [1:52:50] killed by the car in the first [1:52:50] place. [1:52:53] So I want the city to invest in [1:52:54] safe infrastructure that [1:52:55] protect its citizens And I [1:52:59] don't want the city to invest [1:52:59] in in surveillance mass [1:53:00] surveillance about the police [1:53:01] and ice and exercise to [1:53:04] terrorize the community. [1:53:04] >> Thank you. [1:53:11] C.J. Mendoza Good afternoon and [1:53:12] Citizen Delta. [1:53:15] And I'm here to urge you all to [1:53:16] take the cameras down. [1:53:16] The cameras are here and they [1:53:20] deserve its purpose to protect [1:53:21] and it did not serve most [1:53:22] importantly the San Diego [1:53:22] people. [1:53:23] So it's long overdue for them [1:53:26] to be gone. [1:53:26] The money poured into this [1:53:27] harmful technology can instead [1:53:28] be invested in resources for [1:53:32] our children, our families, our [1:53:33] youth and communities that [1:53:33] deserve to thrive, not hide. [1:53:38] We're not safe and we never [1:53:39] will be if we continue to let [1:53:39] it stay. [1:53:40] We are your guinea pigs for [1:53:43] this We're in creepy [1:53:44] surveillance technology so get [1:53:44] the flock out. [1:53:45] >> Thank you. [1:53:49] Claire Snyder Good afternoon, [1:53:50] counsel. [1:53:50] My name is Claire Snyder. [1:53:55] I'm a resident of District [1:53:56] three and I'm here with you. [1:53:56] I will cancel the fire contract [1:54:01] and take down the cameras. [1:54:01] We can invest the millions [1:54:02] spent on surveillance into [1:54:03] the young people to see Diego [1:54:06] and other essential programs. [1:54:07] The police department has [1:54:07] proven that with this [1:54:08] technology the surveillance [1:54:12] technology, our data and quite [1:54:13] frankly our lives are not safe. [1:54:14] A person was shot and a [1:54:19] domestic violence survivor was [1:54:20] stalked by the department using [1:54:20] this technology. [1:54:24] To be honest I'm not sure like [1:54:25] what else it's going to take to [1:54:26] convince people that this [1:54:26] technology does not work. [1:54:30] We we come here many times [1:54:30] before and if it's picking [1:54:31] people getting injured, being [1:54:35] served, being hurt and harmed [1:54:36] by this technology to convince [1:54:37] you it's another problem that [1:54:41] we have. [1:54:42] >> Please cancel the contract [1:54:42] and take the cameras down. [1:54:47] Thank you. [1:54:48] >> Thank you. [1:54:48] Alex Castillo, if you could [1:54:49] please come forward to [1:54:49] the microphone after that And [1:54:53] Andy on the go. [1:54:54] Liliana Soriano, Simon Fuller [1:54:59] Walker Sobczak Carrie Bravo [1:55:05] Kristen and Olivia Drummond. [1:55:06] If you can all please come [1:55:07] forward to the front row. [1:55:07] Are you Alex Castillo? [1:55:12] Yes. [1:55:12] >> Please proceed. [1:55:13] Good afternoon. [1:55:13] My name is Alex Castillo. [1:55:14] I'm a resident of any city [1:55:17] district eight and an outreach [1:55:18] organized intern at Youth [1:55:18] World. [1:55:19] I'm here to urge the council to [1:55:23] oppose public surveillance [1:55:23] technologies and block [1:55:24] similarly to Orwell's [1:55:24] Ministries of Truth, Love and [1:55:29] Peace said it was surveillance [1:55:30] technologies promise safety yet [1:55:30] the only guarantee [1:55:30] the opposite. [1:55:31] Think of the children outside [1:55:35] of the gross misuse of such [1:55:36] technologies by Federal pd. [1:55:36] The enormous allocation of [1:55:40] these funds divert resources [1:55:40] away from programs that [1:55:41] actually prevent crime in [1:55:42] the long term. [1:55:42] The Office of Child and Youth [1:55:46] Success Library's part Invest [1:55:47] in real programs that encourage [1:55:48] long term city stability. [1:55:49] It's often that our government [1:55:53] make short term investments [1:55:54] without considering what's at [1:55:54] stake and who you are hired to [1:55:55] really serve Plant the seed so [1:55:59] future generations can stand in [1:55:59] the shade. [1:56:00] >> Invest in San Diego Youth [1:56:10] Andy Hello my name is Andy on [1:56:11] District eight as well I'm a [1:56:11] representative with Youth Will [1:56:12] and our time to act. [1:56:16] I'm here to ask Council to take [1:56:17] the cameras down canceled [1:56:17] contracts, funding for Cuba, [1:56:18] Axon and other companies [1:56:23] revealing our neighborhoods in [1:56:23] automated Nazareth Planning [1:56:24] Group And we learned that there [1:56:27] is 60 cameras in our little [1:56:27] slice of our city. [1:56:31] These cameras alone monitor [1:56:32] 4.2% of our city population [1:56:32] That is mostly Spanish speakers [1:56:38] and Latinos and people like me. [1:56:38] My my anxiety peeks at [1:56:39] the sight of police presence [1:56:43] because of past violence upon [1:56:44] the posse and immigrant [1:56:44] community I am forced to think [1:56:45] of it all the time knowing [1:56:46] these cameras monitor it and [1:56:49] unjustly threaten us. [1:56:50] I strongly urge the Council to [1:56:51] end surveillance and [1:56:55] the violation of San Diego [1:56:55] civil civil liberties And I [1:56:56] thank Councilmember Moreno and [1:56:57] other council members who have [1:57:00] been listening to the community [1:57:01] and fighting on our behalf. [1:57:02] I urge you to make today's [1:57:03] decision permanent and take [1:57:05] the cameras down. [1:57:14] Liliana Serrano Good afternoon [1:57:14] Council My name is me and I [1:57:15] don't know I serve as [1:57:18] the Director of policy at Youth [1:57:18] Well we are an organization [1:57:19] dedicated to supporting young [1:57:20] people in the county to feel [1:57:26] safe, valued and supported. [1:57:26] Youth is also a partner of [1:57:27] the Trust Coalition. [1:57:30] We heard a presentation on [1:57:31] earlier and we shared the same [1:57:32] vision for the city to turn off [1:57:37] these cameras, put them away, [1:57:37] stop contracting with [1:57:38] corporations that are stealing [1:57:39] money away from families that [1:57:42] live in your districts, working [1:57:43] families, youth and also [1:57:44] supporting a technology that is [1:57:48] working families apart. [1:57:49] We've seen a lot of that in [1:57:50] social media in our own [1:57:54] personal lives as well. [1:57:55] So I'm thinking thank you so [1:58:00] much and for Hello Council I'm [1:58:01] a member of d five and a policy [1:58:06] research intern at Youth Well [1:58:07] and as elected officials you [1:58:07] should all certainly know by [1:58:11] now how policing works And I [1:58:12] learned from human bias over [1:58:12] policing racial undertones in [1:58:13] reports and community targeted [1:58:19] criminalization. [1:58:20] It produces an output based off [1:58:21] of the series of data and [1:58:21] points increase its legitimate [1:58:23] I legitimizes racist policing [1:58:24] behind the disguise of [1:58:25] technological advancement [1:58:30] officers work off of biased [1:58:31] outputs thinking that they [1:58:32] cannot reproduce bias but it's [1:58:35] actually just a mechanical [1:58:36] manifestation of confirmation [1:58:37] bias telling you exactly what [1:58:42] you expect to hear and what [1:58:43] could this $2 million contract [1:58:43] money be used for Libraries [1:58:47] funding schools and youth [1:58:47] programs, community centers, [1:58:48] affordable housing, the ability [1:58:53] to afford basic necessities [1:58:54] that have gotten increasingly [1:58:55] unaffordable keeps us safe. [1:58:55] We keep us safe. [1:58:56] Community spaces keep us safe. [1:58:59] Good paying jobs keep us safe. [1:59:00] >> Investing in youth keeps us [1:59:00] safe. [1:59:01] Thank you. [1:59:03] Thank you, Walter. [1:59:15] I believe Walter Sobchak Well, [1:59:16] good afternoon, Council. [1:59:17] My character name is Walter. [1:59:17] I own subject security near [1:59:18] the In-n-Out Burger. [1:59:20] I live in District nine and I [1:59:21] am calmer than you are. [1:59:21] Where's Marty? [1:59:22] I hope she didn't kidnap [1:59:26] herself. [1:59:26] Has the whole world going [1:59:27] crazy? [1:59:28] I am I the only one around here [1:59:28] who give a about the rules? [1:59:32] The Supreme Court roundly [1:59:32] rejected prior restraint. [1:59:33] This is not a First Amendment [1:59:33] issue. [1:59:34] It's about the Fourth Amendment [1:59:38] checking location data without [1:59:39] probable cause counts as an [1:59:39] unreasonable search. [1:59:40] I hope your eyes are over [1:59:45] the line. [1:59:46] I didn't watch my buddies [1:59:46] dripping down the back to [1:59:47] the billionaire could ruin [1:59:47] everything. [1:59:51] Am I wrong? [1:59:52] Even if you end the contract [1:59:52] with park safety without [1:59:53] removing the cameras they will [1:59:53] go out and achieve anyway. [1:59:57] It also it also contravenes a [1:59:58] number of bylaws If you want a [1:59:59] legitimate security system come [2:00:04] down to subject security near [2:00:04] you go in and out burger Look [2:00:05] for the signage that says for [2:00:08] subject security I can get you [2:00:09] a tow by 3:00 in the afternoon. [2:00:10] Come on, you get the out if [2:00:10] you will. [2:00:13] It is no dream, Harry. [2:00:19] Real hope. [2:00:19] >> All right. [2:00:25] Hello Everyone before me has [2:00:26] spoken very eloquently so I'm [2:00:26] going to keep it short. [2:00:27] My name is Carrie. [2:00:31] She her I'm a resident of [2:00:31] District two and I am against [2:00:32] Alpers If it's a matter of [2:00:37] reducing crime while flat [2:00:37] cameras don't prevent crime [2:00:38] investments in the community do [2:00:42] so I urge the council to end [2:00:43] the contract and take down [2:00:44] these cameras permanently [2:00:44] invest the money in [2:00:48] the community instead. [2:00:55] >> Thank you, Christine. [2:00:55] Hi everyone. [2:00:56] Good to see you all. [2:01:00] My name is Christine. [2:01:01] I'm a resident in District nine [2:01:02] and I work in a couple other [2:01:02] districts. [2:01:07] I recently graduated with a [2:01:07] Ph.D. In math and computer [2:01:08] science. [2:01:08] Education is a strong [2:01:09] background in math and what I [2:01:13] learned here in San Diego [2:01:14] studying that is that there's a [2:01:15] lot of human decisions that go [2:01:15] into this technology. [2:01:20] So it MAY feel I'm biased, MAY [2:01:20] feel effective but there's [2:01:21] nothing about human decisions [2:01:22] at the very base level of [2:01:22] the technology That means [2:01:26] there's racism, that means [2:01:26] there's sexism, there's all [2:01:27] the biases that humans take [2:01:27] with them. [2:01:31] I recently also learned at [2:01:32] the La mesa Police Department [2:01:33] saw that they had 14,000 scans [2:01:37] a day on their lpr system. [2:01:38] The number of scans from La [2:01:41] mesa Police Department was six [2:01:41] a day. [2:01:42] They had 14,000 scanned the day [2:01:43] on average meaning there were [2:01:47] many other places and people [2:01:48] accessing their data. [2:01:49] So I urge you to consider doing [2:01:52] more than just canceling a [2:01:53] contract or taking down [2:01:54] the cameras and keeping [2:01:54] the community safe. [2:01:55] >> Thank you. [2:01:59] Thank you, Olivia Oh, hello, [2:02:00] Olivia. [2:02:00] >> I am in district three. [2:02:06] I'm a long time San Diego and I [2:02:06] care about my community and I [2:02:07] know it's been kind of serious [2:02:11] so I would like to bring a [2:02:12] little bit of levity So I'm [2:02:13] going to sing some songs for [2:02:13] you. [2:02:17] >> I'll take them down down [2:02:18] Take the camera down to San [2:02:18] Diego. [2:02:23] We got a deficit in our budget [2:02:24] . [2:02:24] Don't need to wait taxes on [2:02:25] that one. [2:02:29] That's why I got to go get out [2:02:30] work right now. [2:02:30] >> We don't want a surveillance [2:02:35] state. [2:02:35] >> It's too late. [2:02:36] You can't wait to take this [2:02:36] camera. [2:02:37] I'm a millennial. [2:02:40] It's if the following [2:02:40] individuals can please come [2:02:46] forward starting with Darth [2:02:47] Vader then Jim Whalen and [2:02:52] Korina Vega, Francis Yasmeen [2:02:59] Mattawa, Agustin and Ella, [2:02:59] Wendy Geller, Eleanor, if you [2:03:03] can all please come up to [2:03:06] the front row. [2:03:13] >> Darth Vader are you here? [2:03:14] You've been delayed. [2:03:14] I get it. [2:03:14] Never mind. [2:03:19] I will not do a joke. [2:03:20] >> Jim Whalen, if you can [2:03:25] please come forward. [2:03:25] Good afternoon, Council [2:03:26] PRESIDENT Carver Council [2:03:27] members My name is Jim Whalen [2:03:30] and I don't like to follow [2:03:31] people who are singing but [2:03:32] we'll do the best we can. [2:03:35] I'm a resident of District two [2:03:36] and I'm a baby boomer here [2:03:40] against Flack not only because [2:03:40] I'm fundamentally opposed [2:03:41] the unlawful searches that Floc [2:03:47] enables nor the expansion of a [2:03:48] surveillance state none of us [2:03:48] wants. [2:03:49] It's also that the license [2:03:49] plate reader technology itself [2:03:53] has demonstrated time and time [2:03:53] again that it's fatally flawed [2:03:54] and no supposed guardrails are [2:03:59] of any value. [2:03:59] Please There's no point in [2:04:00] trying to fix this terrible [2:04:01] program and put the money where [2:04:02] it helps people rather than [2:04:03] hurting them. [2:04:12] >> Thank you Karina Vega It was [2:04:13] just released today that [2:04:13] according to The Guardian's [2:04:19] investigation an Israeli [2:04:19] military unit uploaded [2:04:20] approximately 3.5 million [2:04:24] photographs of Palestinians to [2:04:25] Amazon Web services in early 24 [2:04:26] for facial recognition [2:04:26] technology. [2:04:30] What else would they be using [2:04:31] this information that they [2:04:32] continue to commit [2:04:32] the Palestinian Holocaust. [2:04:33] Now why would I mention this if [2:04:37] we are in San Diego? [2:04:38] One because Todd Gloria happily [2:04:39] supports the entity that allows [2:04:39] the surveillance to happen [2:04:40] overseas. [2:04:43] Since he attended the finest [2:04:44] conference that took place this [2:04:47] last week in San Diego and two [2:04:48] because of the famous Pulitzer [2:04:48] Prize winning author Chris [2:04:49] Hedges mentioned this past [2:04:53] Thursday in regards to mass [2:04:54] surveillance. [2:04:54] It all comes back to [2:04:55] the homeland. [2:04:55] We are witnessing the unseen [2:04:59] terror and power imbalance of [2:05:00] surveillance without any [2:05:00] accountability. [2:05:01] Here in San Diego, just like [2:05:05] the Palestinians have for [2:05:06] decades and continue doing so [2:05:06] until this very second, we [2:05:11] the citizens are having to pay [2:05:12] the price and continue our [2:05:12] lives for it. [2:05:13] Take the cameras down and in [2:05:14] the meantime ensure they are [2:05:14] blocked. [2:05:16] Thank you, Princess Yasmin [2:05:17] Malala. [2:05:23] >> Hello District nine resident [2:05:23] here Francis Yasmin Moti Well, [2:05:24] it's real fresh listening to [2:05:28] Chief Wall talk about how San [2:05:29] Diego is ahead of other cities [2:05:29] because we got the Privacy [2:05:35] Advisory board and we've been [2:05:35] listening to the community when [2:05:36] year after year the police have [2:05:37] been steamrolling the privacy [2:05:40] advisory Board and encouraging [2:05:41] you not to listen to their [2:05:41] advice. [2:05:47] I think I want to point to [2:05:51] Wednesday, JULY 22nd and you [2:05:51] would remember that probably [2:05:52] not because there was very, [2:05:53] very little notice to [2:05:57] the public for this year's [2:05:58] presentation from the police [2:05:58] about the new surveillance [2:06:03] technology that they want [2:06:04] really they want the fancy [2:06:05] Ray-Ban recording glasses that [2:06:05] you know, all the cool kids are [2:06:09] wearing. [2:06:10] I don't know that they don't [2:06:10] even wear their body cameras [2:06:11] all the time. [2:06:14] How can we trust them? [2:06:15] Why should they have more [2:06:16] technology when we can't trust [2:06:16] them to always use [2:06:21] the technology they're supposed [2:06:21] to be using? [2:06:22] >> Also, what are [2:06:22] the alternatives? [2:06:23] Let's be people. [2:06:23] Thank you. [2:06:32] I will still. [2:06:33] Good afternoon City Council [2:06:33] members. [2:06:38] I am a member of the Community [2:06:39] of City Heights part of [2:06:40] the immigrant community which [2:06:44] is offering a lot and we know [2:06:45] flow cameras have something to [2:06:50] do with that is way from [2:06:50] the heart of the community. [2:06:56] We ask to the City council to [2:07:02] take the measures to take down [2:07:03] the cameras who are doing a lot [2:07:03] of damage to a big sector of [2:07:08] our community. [2:07:09] We really concern about what's [2:07:09] going on. [2:07:14] I told the community hoping you [2:07:20] might take the side of [2:07:21] the communities because of [2:07:26] communities that are suffering [2:07:26] and we expect a resolution to [2:07:31] take those cameras down because [2:07:32] they are doing a lot of damage [2:07:32] for these communities. [2:07:33] >> Thank you so much. [2:07:37] Thank you, Wendy. [2:07:38] Next speakers are Wendy Gelman [2:07:43] gelernter Thank you. [2:07:43] Thank you. [2:07:44] Hi, I'm Wendy Gelernter. [2:07:45] I'm a 40 year resident of [2:07:49] Pacific Beach and I'm [2:07:49] representing Take Action San [2:07:50] Diego with over 2500 members [2:07:54] and also Pacific Beach United [2:07:55] which is a neighborhood [2:07:56] pro-democracy group. [2:07:56] We have signed a letter urging [2:08:00] you counsel PRESIDENT And [2:08:01] the council to cancel [2:08:02] the contract, take down [2:08:07] the cameras and do not replace [2:08:08] them with another company's [2:08:08] technology lp Our technology is [2:08:13] dangerous regardless of who [2:08:14] operates it. [2:08:14] We say these cameras help solve [2:08:19] crimes but the technology can [2:08:20] be useful and still create [2:08:20] dangers that far outweigh its [2:08:21] benefits. [2:08:25] Across the country communities [2:08:26] are rejecting opioids and San [2:08:26] Diego should join them. [2:08:31] Listen to your constituents, [2:08:32] listen to the evidence and [2:08:32] the costs and protect our [2:08:33] privacy. [2:08:37] Cancel the contract. [2:08:37] Take the cameras down. [2:08:38] Thank you. [2:08:43] Lily Irani Oh, thank you for [2:08:44] your honesty. [2:08:48] >> Cristoforo Gomez After [2:08:49] Cristoforo we're going to have [2:08:55] Carol Kim Ian Cirillo. [2:08:56] Mitchell Watson Jason Richie. [2:09:01] Kenny Cliff Courage. [2:09:02] >> If you can all please come [2:09:03] forward to the front row. [2:09:03] Please proceed. [2:09:04] Good afternoon. [2:09:08] Council members My name is [2:09:08] Christopher Gomez. [2:09:09] I'm an organizer with the San [2:09:10] Diego County Labor Council. [2:09:12] We represent over 130 unions [2:09:13] and 200,000 working people [2:09:13] across these counties. [2:09:14] And for years now this [2:09:18] community has come together to [2:09:19] call for an end to [2:09:19] the contract. [2:09:20] We applaud those council [2:09:21] members who have been with us [2:09:24] from the beginning and even [2:09:25] those who have since come on [2:09:25] board. [2:09:26] But let's be clear that [2:09:26] the mass community mobilization [2:09:30] that we have seen is not just [2:09:31] an indictment of the company or [2:09:32] this specific contract. [2:09:35] It is an indictment of [2:09:36] the technology as a whole in a [2:09:37] call to end mass surveillance [2:09:37] entirely. [2:09:38] So yes, we are demanding an end [2:09:42] to this contract so that [2:09:43] the money can be spent [2:09:43] elsewhere. [2:09:44] But what the people ultimately [2:09:47] want to feel safe is a complete [2:09:48] and sustained removal of this [2:09:49] tech from their communities. [2:09:50] So we urge you rejection today [2:09:52] and your continued support. [2:09:53] >> This fight moves forward. [2:09:56] Thank you. [2:09:59] Carol Kim? [2:10:00] >> Carol? [2:10:06] Kim, are you here Maybe in [2:10:06] the back room. [2:10:12] >> Carol Kim? [2:10:12] No, that's okay. [2:10:21] Ian Cirillo. [2:10:28] Hello Laura. [2:10:28] Good afternoon, Council [2:10:29] members. [2:10:32] As a resident of District seven [2:10:32] and of the District District [2:10:33] seven in San Diego and chair of [2:10:34] the San Diego Immigrant Rights [2:10:38] Consortium as the ioc, I call [2:10:38] on all the city council members [2:10:44] to reject this technology and [2:10:45] cancel this contract [2:10:45] immediately. [2:10:46] Lpr In other mass surveillance [2:10:49] technologies do not have a [2:10:50] place in a free and democratic [2:10:50] society. [2:10:55] The there are substantial [2:10:56] incidents in documented abuses [2:10:56] of these technologies. [2:10:57] Immigration agents have access [2:11:01] and used technology as a tool [2:11:02] in their illegal [2:11:03] unconstitutional arrest and [2:11:07] detention of many of our [2:11:07] community members. [2:11:08] While supporters of the Smart [2:11:12] Surveillance program highlight [2:11:13] the benefits to criminal [2:11:14] investigation, the fact remains [2:11:18] that these harmful technology [2:11:19] is not indispensable and there [2:11:20] are other alternative tools and [2:11:26] good policy options for one [2:11:27] that the city should invest in [2:11:28] our youth in libraries in a [2:11:28] program that will discover you [2:11:29] . [2:11:29] >> Thank you for putting [2:11:36] sentence Mitchell Watson. [2:11:36] Mitchell Watson. [2:11:36] No. [2:11:37] Mitchell Watson. [2:11:43] McCulley m I t c h e l e l l e [2:11:46] a Charlie Watson After that is [2:12:03] okay. [2:12:04] Good afternoon. [2:12:11] My name is Michelle Lee Watson. [2:12:12] >> I'm the legal director of [2:12:12] Pillars of the Community and [2:12:16] here we are again for the last [2:12:17] three years longer than this [2:12:18] one has been alive. [2:12:18] We have filled the city council [2:12:22] chamber to say that we do not [2:12:23] trust surveillance technology [2:12:24] for so many reasons. [2:12:28] One of the main reasons is [2:12:29] because the community that I [2:12:29] come from and represent do not [2:12:33] trust the police. [2:12:34] >> We have never trusted [2:12:35] the police and the recent news [2:12:35] stories have shown exactly why [2:12:39] we don't trust the police and [2:12:39] we never will and we can't [2:12:40] continue to allow them to use [2:12:45] tools at their disposal to [2:12:51] harass our community members. [2:12:51] It does nothing to keep us [2:12:52] safe. [2:12:52] And in fact if you ask [2:12:56] community members from [2:12:57] the community that we [2:12:58] represent, they will tell you [2:12:58] that they do not trust [2:12:59] the police to protect them. [2:13:02] So we're asking you today to [2:13:02] please take down the cameras. [2:13:05] >> Thank you. [2:13:13] >> Jason Ritchie My name's [2:13:13] Jason Ritchie. [2:13:18] I'm a graduate student at usd [2:13:19] Practical of Peace and Justice [2:13:23] and I'm here to oppose Prop 200 [2:13:23] and block surveillance. [2:13:24] I am not anti-technology and I [2:13:29] am not even anti surveillance. [2:13:30] Surveillance can save lives I [2:13:35] believe but the tool I watch is [2:13:35] people need are in trust. [2:13:36] The people internal affairs use [2:13:37] the network to track a domestic [2:13:40] violence victim who is not a [2:13:41] suspect That already happened. [2:13:42] The person we should have been [2:13:48] protecting most. [2:13:49] So what would this party have [2:13:49] to say to a survivor to feel [2:13:52] safe to drive home And how can [2:13:53] we ensure it won't be used by [2:13:53] bad actors including government [2:13:58] agents if no policy can [2:13:59] guarantee that then in [2:14:00] the program if real limits can [2:14:00] prevent this please write them [2:14:03] down and enforcement. [2:14:09] >> Thank you Kenny Hello [2:14:10] Council Member My name is Kenny [2:14:15] Quidditch I am a resident of [2:14:16] District three Alpers Our mass [2:14:17] surveillance and an affront to [2:14:22] liberty and privacy for all [2:14:23] the residents of San Diego We [2:14:23] demanded this technology [2:14:28] authorization be rescinded [2:14:28] The ap our contracts are [2:14:29] canceled and that all [2:14:29] the cameras are taken down. [2:14:33] We don't need a pause. [2:14:34] We don't need a reevaluation. [2:14:35] The time is now for some real [2:14:39] bold action and we won't accept [2:14:40] allowing Floc or others to [2:14:40] continue harvesting our data [2:14:45] and violating our rights even [2:14:45] if the city's contracts are [2:14:46] canceled. [2:14:47] Now to be clear there is no [2:14:51] version of this system that [2:14:52] would be acceptable no rules [2:14:53] that would make it conscionable [2:14:57] no guardrails sufficient to [2:14:58] eliminate abuse esdp esdp has [2:15:02] proven themselves untrustworthy [2:15:03] in the sense and does not get [2:15:04] the benefit of the doubt. [2:15:04] Please read the writing on [2:15:08] the wall and take the system [2:15:09] down. [2:15:09] >> Thank you. [2:15:14] Rebecca Fielding Miller Rebecca [2:15:15] Fielding Miller If you can [2:15:16] please come to the microphone [2:15:19] After that is count Cloud count [2:15:26] flotilla count Glenn Ashley [2:15:31] McCollum, Adina Flores, Sabrina [2:15:32] Moran, Amber Lily Thompson and [2:15:37] Daniel Larsen if you can all [2:15:38] please come forward to [2:15:38] the front row. [2:15:39] Rebecca Please proceed. [2:15:39] Thank you. [2:15:43] My name is Rebecca Fielding [2:15:44] Miller I live in District seven [2:15:45] and I want to start by thanking [2:15:49] my council member Campo for his [2:15:50] thoughtfulness in reevaluating [2:15:51] your stance on Floc I know that [2:15:56] this is a suspension and I. [2:15:57] I appreciate that and I [2:15:57] encourage you to maintain a [2:16:02] critical mind on what it can do [2:16:02] to the activity. [2:16:07] I just watched you use a slide [2:16:07] with a 12 year survivor of [2:16:08] sexual assault as a talking [2:16:14] point for your budget for mass [2:16:15] surveillance That is cynical to [2:16:15] the point of shameful MS. And [2:16:19] you should feel bad that you [2:16:20] are using a technology that [2:16:20] puts women and people of color [2:16:26] and people at higher risk than [2:16:26] you are using a child to [2:16:27] advance your budget for a tool [2:16:28] that hurts people at higher [2:16:28] risk of sexual assault. [2:16:35] That is shameful. [2:16:36] We are told that this [2:16:37] technology there is no there's [2:16:40] no safe way to use [2:16:40] the technology. [2:16:41] >> It can only be deleted. [2:16:45] Thank you. [2:16:51] >> Is the count here Three [2:16:56] things I am proud of [2:16:57] the District three. [2:16:57] First, I find it disturbing to [2:16:58] me not even having this point [2:17:02] to hear from the riffraff But [2:17:03] alas I will respond to their [2:17:03] concerns. [2:17:07] Yes, our devices MAY have an [2:17:08] error rate of 10% or so but how [2:17:08] will we reduce our experience [2:17:15] with on the populace When for [2:17:15] help the Toledo police pulled a [2:17:16] man over for stolen plates. [2:17:17] The police released a k-9 upon [2:17:18] him sending him to [2:17:19] the hospital. [2:17:19] But as we learned, the seven [2:17:20] does look a bit like a two. [2:17:24] Who knew? [2:17:25] If you track our system, our [2:17:25] police officers track their [2:17:26] ex-girlfriends to ensure they [2:17:30] aren't dating anyone of concern [2:17:30] a police department that [2:17:31] refuses to share details with [2:17:31] the City council about ice [2:17:36] kidnapings is one we can trust [2:17:37] to find a way to share that [2:17:37] data with ice. [2:17:41] But we did initially configure [2:17:42] our system to automatically [2:17:43] share data with all other [2:17:43] agencies. [2:17:44] The police department did [2:17:44] notice after a few weeks. [2:17:47] So if you decide to merely [2:17:48] pause operations I want to [2:17:49] assure you we will find a way [2:17:49] to extract the information we [2:17:55] need to sustain us and our [2:17:55] investors. [2:17:56] >> Think of that comes flooding [2:17:56] sometimes. [2:17:58] Ashley McCullough. [2:18:05] >> Good afternoon City Council [2:18:05] Call. [2:18:06] My name is Ashley McCullough. [2:18:07] I'm a student organizer with [2:18:08] the Center on Policy Initiative [2:18:11] and a proud resident of d four [2:18:12] on my daily route to school or [2:18:13] to work. [2:18:17] I pass about 50 alpers or block [2:18:17] cameras. [2:18:21] >> The one that scares me [2:18:21] the most is the one that sits [2:18:22] on Imperial Avenue across from [2:18:23] where Hoffman's used to be in [2:18:27] Lincoln High School a high [2:18:27] school, a block camera scary in [2:18:28] a district that has [2:18:32] historically been overpoliced, [2:18:33] underprivileged and taken [2:18:33] advantage of the existence of [2:18:37] the surveillance weapons only [2:18:38] serves to continue [2:18:38] the tradition of policing [2:18:39] the free movement of black and [2:18:40] brown bodies. [2:18:43] We do not want floc. [2:18:44] We do not want to be [2:18:44] surveilled. [2:18:46] We need systems for the people [2:18:47] by the people. [2:18:49] >> Thank you. [2:19:01] A dinner for us. [2:19:02] >> Good afternoon, counsel. [2:19:03] My name is Dina Flores. [2:19:06] I'm one of California's leading [2:19:07] civil rights activists and I'm [2:19:07] highly against Floc. [2:19:11] >> I moved down here because I [2:19:12] was actually extorted by the pr [2:19:13] firm I was working for our [2:19:17] family in law enforcement. [2:19:18] I respect law enforcement here [2:19:19] and I appreciate their [2:19:19] hospitality when I entered your [2:19:20] building. [2:19:23] That being said, I was working [2:19:24] for a White Star group. [2:19:24] I was the researcher for Mark [2:19:25] Adams. [2:19:26] He was a former officer who was [2:19:28] a detective with my uncle. [2:19:29] i'm litigating I am the victim [2:19:32] advocate for over 40 [2:19:32] undocumented boys who were [2:19:33] raped and trafficked at Boys [2:19:34] and Girls Club, the clubs [2:19:34] refusing to pay them [2:19:38] restitution. [2:19:38] They're claiming I made it all [2:19:39] up as the Predator spends 150 [2:19:39] years in prison. [2:19:44] So my question is it law [2:19:45] enforcement offered me money to [2:19:45] be quiet about child [2:19:46] trafficking. [2:19:48] How can I be assured that [2:19:49] you're telling the truth about [2:19:49] Floc? [2:19:50] I heard a whole bunch of [2:19:50] identity politics today If we [2:19:54] don't get justice for these [2:19:55] boys and my case then everyone [2:19:56] might as well go home. [2:19:56] GOD bless you. [2:19:56] Jesus Christ. [2:19:59] My Lord and Savior And I do [2:19:59] tell the truth. [2:20:04] >> Sabrina Good afternoon, [2:20:11] Council members My name MR. [2:20:12] Brennan far from the presser [2:20:12] I'm concerned about this [2:20:13] presser surveillance and drones [2:20:14] because it affects our [2:20:15] community by instilling fear [2:20:16] and possibly is reinforcing [2:20:17] racial stereotypes. [2:20:20] Aside from that, surveillance [2:20:21] as a whole threatens our right [2:20:22] to privacy in our lives. [2:20:22] It tracks our community and has [2:20:25] the right to to find out [2:20:26] everything about us in the name [2:20:27] of safety. [2:20:27] It asserts power in a place [2:20:31] where we're all supposed to be [2:20:32] equal and an imbalance of [2:20:32] the scale of trusting [2:20:32] conscious. [2:20:33] It humanizes us and treats its [2:20:36] like numbers to fall through [2:20:36] cameras, pbs tracking browser [2:20:37] tracking and our license [2:20:37] plates. [2:20:41] I urge you to vote to ban [2:20:42] Yelpers. [2:20:42] Our community is so much more [2:20:43] than I.D. Numbers and license [2:20:45] plates and instead of adding [2:20:46] more technology and power to [2:20:46] control us we should look [2:20:47] through more preventative [2:20:48] measures so we can actually [2:20:48] have a safer San Diego. [2:20:56] >> Thank you Lily Thompson Good [2:20:56] afternoon Counsel. [2:21:02] My name is Lily Tomlin and I [2:21:02] live in Oklahoma. [2:21:03] Last year the state of [2:21:04] California sued my city's [2:21:06] police department for sharing [2:21:07] our license plate data with [2:21:08] with law enforcement in 26 [2:21:08] other states and the federal [2:21:11] government. [2:21:12] That's illegal under California [2:21:12] law. [2:21:13] The attorney general had [2:21:13] already warned them and they [2:21:17] did it regardless when [2:21:18] the lawsuit was filed Our mayor [2:21:18] MAY no apologies. [2:21:19] So when you hear today that San [2:21:20] Diego State counterproductive [2:21:22] it will protect residents. [2:21:22] I want you to understand what [2:21:23] those safeguards actually are. [2:21:27] They are simply a promise that [2:21:27] one setting stays turned off. [2:21:28] My city turned that turned it [2:21:28] on deliberately. [2:21:32] San Diego vendor left it on by [2:21:33] mistake for three weeks in [2:21:34] Carpenter of United States [2:21:34] The Supreme Court recognized [2:21:36] that enough location data [2:21:37] collected over time creates a [2:21:38] portrait of a person's entire [2:21:39] life a portrait that details [2:21:42] should never be at the will of [2:21:43] one department especially when [2:21:43] that department has lost our [2:21:44] trust in its ability to a poll [2:21:47] or privacy. [2:21:48] Some of this Council have [2:21:48] suggested that we simply pause [2:21:49] this program while we review [2:21:49] it. [2:21:50] But a promise is not a [2:21:53] protection and a pause is not a [2:21:53] solution. [2:21:54] A pause just means the same [2:21:54] system with the same risks [2:21:58] waiting to be turned back on [2:21:59] and the contract and ban opens. [2:22:00] >> Thank you Daniel. [2:22:15] All me Cookie Monster And today [2:22:16] MAY not here for cookies and me [2:22:19] here for flood cameras San [2:22:20] Diego we have a big problem. [2:22:21] These cameras can license [2:22:24] plates of ordinary people going [2:22:25] to work taking their kids to [2:22:29] school or buying cookies. [2:22:30] But my biggest but my biggest [2:22:34] concern are constitutional [2:22:35] rights. [2:22:36] The Fourth Amendment protects [2:22:36] Americans against unreasonable [2:22:40] searches and seizures. [2:22:41] Me Ask City Council those [2:22:42] tracking innocent people who [2:22:49] violate our constitutional [2:22:49] rights. [2:22:50] Public safety is important but [2:22:55] so is our Constitution. [2:22:56] Me Respect Police Chief Scott [2:22:57] While we disagree on flood [2:23:01] cameras but he still has my [2:23:01] support today. [2:23:04] City COUNCILWOMAN Esther must [2:23:04] answer one question Who is [2:23:05] watching the Watchers? [2:23:06] And if those cameras don't come [2:23:09] down Cookie Monster going to [2:23:09] eat them all? [2:23:10] I'm not. [2:23:10] I'm nom nom nom nom nom. [2:23:14] Protect our constitu ation. [2:23:15] >> Your time has concluded. [2:23:18] Brandon Jackson. [2:23:19] Brandon Jackson. [2:23:19] If you can please come forward [2:23:23] to the mic after that is Darwin [2:23:28] Fishman Cyrus Maharajah. [2:23:28] Heather Hughes. [2:23:34] Nicolette Justice Jesse Schmidt [2:23:39] Smitty allegedly Audra and then [2:23:39] I believe this is a do of. [2:23:40] Nicole Sharma. [2:23:44] Please proceed. [2:23:44] >> Good evening, City Council. [2:23:45] My name is Brandon Jackson, [2:23:48] Southern Area Coordinator for [2:23:49] the Libertarian Party of [2:23:49] California. [2:23:50] In this room you have folks of [2:23:53] all walks of life. [2:23:54] They're all telling you [2:23:54] the same thing. [2:23:58] We the people are dumping, [2:23:59] tracked, logged and herded [2:23:59] around like cattle. [2:24:02] And our cameras violate our [2:24:02] Fourth Amendment right to [2:24:03] privacy. [2:24:06] And they pursue the draconian [2:24:06] surveillance state. [2:24:07] These cameras are not [2:24:08] traditional license plate [2:24:12] readers. [2:24:12] Lpr like Flock has a built in [2:24:13] to track everyone in their [2:24:17] travel routes regardless of a [2:24:17] crime was committed. [2:24:18] Anyone can gain access to these [2:24:21] cameras including ice, dhs, cia [2:24:22] and more. [2:24:25] No one and no one is exempt [2:24:26] from being tracked including [2:24:27] all of you on a sitting [2:24:30] council, Mayor and pd. [2:24:31] Even if this pd states [2:24:35] otherwise aclu has already [2:24:36] uncovered abuse of the system [2:24:40] and it will only get worse. [2:24:40] We the people are watching. [2:24:41] You can all either vote in line [2:24:45] with your constituents in mass [2:24:46] or betray and sell them out to [2:24:47] special interests. [2:24:47] Choose wisely your own [2:24:48] priorities and rights are on [2:24:48] the line. [2:24:53] As concluded Darwin Fishman. [2:24:54] Okay. [2:24:59] Good afternoon, City Council [2:25:00] members Darwin Fishman He and [2:25:00] his Racial Justice Coalition of [2:25:03] San Diego. [2:25:04] And we also believe that [2:25:04] the cameras should come down. [2:25:08] And it's finally time after [2:25:09] years of us coming here and [2:25:09] testifying. [2:25:10] And surprise, surprise, [2:25:13] everything we said has come [2:25:14] true about how it'll be used [2:25:17] and how to be abused And if [2:25:18] whatever. [2:25:18] Many years later we're finally [2:25:19] validated. [2:25:19] That's great. [2:25:22] I also want to just say real [2:25:23] quickly for something for you [2:25:24] guys to think about moving [2:25:27] forward. [2:25:28] One of the greatest myths about [2:25:28] the police is that everything [2:25:29] is working well and that if you [2:25:32] give them the cameras [2:25:32] everything will work even [2:25:33] better. [2:25:37] I was while I was driving on [2:25:38] the 94 this year my car was [2:25:42] shot at I don't know actually [2:25:43] still to this day when I was a [2:25:43] pellet or a gun. [2:25:47] But when I went to the police [2:25:48] they never investigated, never [2:25:48] looked into it. [2:25:51] They basically ask why I was [2:25:51] injured. [2:25:52] I wasn't. [2:25:52] Nothing was ever done. [2:25:53] I think there's a real question [2:25:56] about what real police work is [2:25:56] being done even after these [2:25:57] cameras are taken down. [2:25:58] >> Thank you. [2:26:04] Next, if Iris and I believe I'm [2:26:05] about to get to a lot of dupes [2:26:08] right now so you've already [2:26:09] spoken please do not come up or [2:26:09] just let me know. [2:26:10] Please proceed. [2:26:13] Thank you. [2:26:14] Take the cameras down. [2:26:14] DR. Cyrus Bharucha, a resident [2:26:15] of District five. [2:26:19] I'm grateful to those on [2:26:19] the Council have already [2:26:20] expressed your support for [2:26:22] moving against the cameras. [2:26:23] But let's make sure we do it [2:26:24] right. [2:26:24] I'm Generation x My whole life [2:26:27] I watched while elected [2:26:28] officials let the tech [2:26:28] companies and Titans do [2:26:32] whatever they liked. [2:26:32] But Americans want something [2:26:33] different now. [2:26:37] We want our leaders to be on [2:26:37] our side In San Diego, in [2:26:41] Sacramento, in Washington. [2:26:42] We don't want you to be chumps [2:26:43] for the technology companies [2:26:46] and billionaires. [2:26:47] We're counting on you to [2:26:47] protect our privacy. [2:26:51] Privacy is an issue that voters [2:26:52] of all stripes care about. [2:26:55] All the voters will notice and [2:26:56] be grateful when you protect [2:26:56] our privacy. [2:26:57] Do it right though. [2:27:01] Take the cameras down. [2:27:01] >> We're counting on you. [2:27:05] Thank you. [2:27:05] >> Thank you. [2:27:13] Next is Heather Hughes. [2:27:13] >> Hello. [2:27:14] I'm a voter in District one. [2:27:18] And first I want to say that I [2:27:19] do understand the appeal of [2:27:23] automated license plate readers [2:27:23] . [2:27:24] They are sold to us sometimes [2:27:24] very convincingly as tools to [2:27:27] keep us safe. [2:27:28] I too want to live in a safe [2:27:29] world with less crime. [2:27:32] However, Alpers are not the way [2:27:32] to do that. [2:27:33] These cameras are not tools of [2:27:37] safety but rather tools of mass [2:27:38] surveillance. [2:27:38] They violate Our privacy can be [2:27:42] used to track people who've [2:27:42] done no wrong. [2:27:43] And they harm already [2:27:44] marginalized communities. [2:27:47] The lpr system is prone to [2:27:48] errors that policies and [2:27:48] department protocols cannot [2:27:49] address. [2:27:52] There are not enough safeguards [2:27:52] possible to make those [2:27:53] technology safe and acceptable. [2:27:53] The money spent on these [2:27:57] systems can be better spent on [2:27:57] other solutions that actually [2:27:58] strengthen our communities. [2:28:01] Even if you supported this [2:28:02] technology in the past, you [2:28:03] have the opportunity today to [2:28:06] vote for what San Diegans [2:28:07] actually need and have [2:28:08] overwhelmingly demonstrated [2:28:11] that we won't take the cameras [2:28:12] down now. [2:28:12] >> Thank you. [2:28:13] Thank you, Nick. [2:28:17] Nick Garrett Justice. [2:28:17] >> >> Hi. [2:28:18] Good afternoon. [2:28:22] Councilmember. [2:28:23] And thank you for your time. [2:28:23] My name is Nicolette Justice [2:28:26] and I'm a graduate student at [2:28:27] the Crockett School of Peace [2:28:27] Studies. [2:28:28] I'm asking you to end [2:28:31] the contract with More than [2:28:32] 500 flight cameras here to [2:28:32] record where residents drive [2:28:36] and when. [2:28:36] According to the aclu, [2:28:37] the information collected goes [2:28:40] into a nationwide database that [2:28:40] any law enforcement agency with [2:28:41] a flight contract can search. [2:28:45] That creates a real risk of [2:28:45] unauthorized tracking, misuse [2:28:49] data breaches and access by [2:28:50] agencies beyond our local [2:28:50] control. [2:28:54] Peace depends on trust between [2:28:55] residents and institutions that [2:28:55] serve them. [2:29:00] Mass surveillance erodes that [2:29:00] trust, especially in immigrant [2:29:01] and overpoliced communities. [2:29:05] Public safety and civil [2:29:06] liberties can coexist here in [2:29:06] our nation. [2:29:10] For those reasons and reasons [2:29:11] of my peers, I urge you to [2:29:12] oppose the renewal of San Diego [2:29:14] to contract with flag safety [2:29:15] and remove the cameras. [2:29:20] Thank you again for your time. [2:29:20] >> Thank you. [2:29:21] Next is Jesse If you can please [2:29:22] come forward. [2:29:28] Jesse's 20 allegedly addressed [2:29:28] Live Oak. [2:29:35] We will get a news story or [2:29:40] whatever we'll get. [2:29:41] >> All right. [2:29:44] So we need to so flag functions [2:29:45] as ubiquitous street light [2:29:46] networking infrastructure and [2:29:49] ubiquity. [2:29:50] Contractor will flock and I'm [2:29:51] surprised they don't have a [2:29:51] problem with them. [2:29:54] They actually have Fox data and [2:29:55] their data perpetually and they [2:29:56] send it worldwide. [2:29:56] You guys have a kill switch or [2:30:00] near ubiquity a public safety [2:30:00] agreement. [2:30:02] It's section 2.2 where you have [2:30:03] a termination clause that you [2:30:07] can exit early if you refuse to [2:30:08] approve that policy for that [2:30:11] technology And you would walk [2:30:12] away from any commitment So we [2:30:12] would have the $8 million [2:30:17] that's left in that policy and [2:30:17] you would kill both of them at [2:30:18] the same time. [2:30:19] Otherwise you guys aren't going [2:30:22] to be able to just turn these [2:30:22] off. [2:30:23] There's something in your [2:30:23] contract that you would violate [2:30:26] a master agreement if anybody [2:30:27] touches them or blocks them. [2:30:28] So then you would have to tell [2:30:31] them to go and turn them off [2:30:32] and the mayor would have to [2:30:36] cancel the financial contract, [2:30:37] put out enormous notice of [2:30:37] termination potentially legally [2:30:41] force them to turn them off [2:30:41] because otherwise we're [2:30:42] financially liable for anything [2:30:42] that happens. [2:30:46] >> Your time has concluded. [2:30:46] I have a lot of duplicates just [2:30:51] trying to make sure that these [2:30:51] are duplicates and there's not [2:30:52] people here with the same name. [2:30:54] I got Logan Kinney already [2:30:54] spoke. [2:30:55] >> There's not a second Logan [2:31:00] King Raya Aurora Not a second [2:31:00] Raya Aurora. [2:31:05] Nicholas Wong Not us. [2:31:05] You already spoke Theo [2:31:09] Rothschild Not a second Theo [2:31:10] Rothschild Old Rihanna Das [2:31:14] Nicole Sharma and Ariane Dixit [2:31:18] as well as Stacy. [2:31:19] I do pay attention see Kevin [2:31:27] Wehner already spoke Kevin. [2:31:28] >> Okay. [2:31:29] Omar Arisa, if you can please [2:31:32] come forward. [2:31:33] After Omar Arisa we have Manuel [2:31:38] and Rico's Tanner Moreno Lulu [2:31:39] Rash King Natalie Rash King [2:31:43] Graciela Clavell and Doctor [2:31:43] Hector. [2:31:46] They're all if you can all [2:31:47] please come forward to [2:31:48] the front row. [2:31:48] >> Please proceed on. [2:31:50] Ready? [2:31:55] Omar Raza from District eight. [2:31:56] I just want to say first off to [2:31:57] the Southern Division Police [2:32:00] Department, they've been doing [2:32:01] actually a really good job at [2:32:01] getting involved in [2:32:05] the community. [2:32:05] Secondly, I want to talk about [2:32:09] my experience in technology as [2:32:10] a sales rep for the police, [2:32:11] fire and ambulance. [2:32:11] So a lot of the standard [2:32:15] practices come into play where [2:32:16] you wine and dine a lot of fire [2:32:17] chiefs, a lot of police [2:32:19] officers and then that's part [2:32:20] of the lobbying process. [2:32:24] So when it comes to contract I [2:32:25] would just say try to create a [2:32:26] system where if you do get one [2:32:30] dime they have to record it. [2:32:30] Right. [2:32:31] Because what happened with [2:32:34] the last contract is a fire. [2:32:35] A police captain ended up [2:32:36] getting this contract and [2:32:36] getting hired on. [2:32:39] That is a standard practice. [2:32:40] Companies go for retiring [2:32:44] chiefs so that way they can get [2:32:45] the contracts within [2:32:45] the cities. [2:32:49] So to be preventative and to be [2:32:53] accountable those need to be [2:32:54] identified. [2:32:54] >> Thank you for that [2:32:55] concluding comment, Manuel. [2:33:03] And I guess Hi. [2:33:08] My name is Manuel and I guess I [2:33:09] am with this in our policy [2:33:09] initiatives. [2:33:10] We are here to ask you as our [2:33:12] representatives to do the right [2:33:13] thing. [2:33:13] The $2 million that you spend [2:33:17] on Floc is a threat Every year [2:33:18] is a piece of our public funds [2:33:19] that could be better used on [2:33:21] programs and services for [2:33:22] working class San Diegans. [2:33:23] Floc is a threat to our safety [2:33:27] and civil liberties. [2:33:28] We are now liable to pay out [2:33:28] millions of dollars individuals [2:33:31] who have been wrongfully [2:33:32] arrested and shot because of [2:33:32] the way police use this [2:33:33] technology. [2:33:36] Data collected through APIs [2:33:37] throughout the country has also [2:33:37] been improperly shared with [2:33:38] federal agencies and used to [2:33:41] target immigrants and people [2:33:41] seeking reproductive health [2:33:42] care while also creating risk [2:33:45] for lgbtq plus communities. [2:33:46] Floc constantly profits from [2:33:47] our data and it's your [2:33:51] responsibility to protect us [2:33:51] the people you represent from [2:33:52] exploitation and [2:33:56] criminalization by [2:33:56] billionaires. [2:33:57] Our research from workplace [2:34:01] technology and workplace [2:34:01] surveillance reveals a similar [2:34:02] pattern. [2:34:02] Surveillance technologies [2:34:06] expand and control and control [2:34:06] Monitor and control working [2:34:07] class people while other [2:34:07] undermining privacy and [2:34:08] accountability. [2:34:11] Comment You must make [2:34:12] the morally right choice and. [2:34:13] I do have to be fair. [2:34:15] Tanner Moreno. [2:34:20] Tanner Moreno Are you here [2:34:20] after Tanner we have Natalie [2:34:25] Rashad Little Reggie. [2:34:25] >> Remember there's no seating [2:34:26] of time so people have to speak [2:34:29] for themselves. [2:34:30] She changed her mind. [2:34:30] Okay. [2:34:30] Please proceed. [2:34:33] Hi, I'm Natalie Rashad. [2:34:34] I live in District seven and [2:34:38] one of the treats a few treats [2:34:39] that I teach my children is [2:34:39] accountability. [2:34:43] Being able to pivot, know when [2:34:47] something's not working and [2:34:48] being able to shift that. [2:34:49] I appreciate people who have [2:34:52] shifted their opinion and how [2:34:53] this is being used. [2:34:57] I'm not anti-police. [2:34:58] We were homeless for almost [2:34:58] three years. [2:35:01] It took me one wrong strategic [2:35:02] move in My vehicle was towed. [2:35:06] That left us on the streets. [2:35:07] So they're watching. [2:35:07] I agree. [2:35:08] I agree with that. [2:35:11] But how it's being used in [2:35:14] the capabilities now go way far [2:35:15] past of just watching around [2:35:20] the town. [2:35:20] They were traumatized. [2:35:25] So she knows what black cameras [2:35:25] are. [2:35:29] There's a constant anxiety even [2:35:30] though we're not doing anything [2:35:30] wrong. [2:35:31] >> That's what we're doing to [2:35:31] our people. [2:35:34] Thank you. [2:35:35] >> Thank you. [2:35:39] Next speaker is Graciela clever [2:35:40] . [2:35:40] >> Hi, council members. [2:35:44] My name is Graciela Clavell. [2:35:45] I'm a college student and [2:35:45] organizer at the Center on [2:35:46] Policy Initiatives as well as a [2:35:49] resident of District nine. [2:35:50] I'm here today because [2:35:50] the city's investment in [2:35:54] surveillance ignores and [2:35:54] contradicts everything San [2:35:55] Diego has actually need. [2:35:59] As someone who has lived in San [2:35:59] Diego my entire life, we need [2:36:00] our council members to show up [2:36:03] for us and our needs by [2:36:04] actually investing in us invest [2:36:05] in our education, our housing, [2:36:09] our health care and our [2:36:09] existence. [2:36:10] Stop investing in technology [2:36:10] that dehumanizes the very [2:36:14] citizens that trusted you with [2:36:15] their communities. [2:36:15] I ask you to listen to [2:36:16] the communities that elected [2:36:18] you and tasked you with their [2:36:19] needs. [2:36:19] By divesting from Alpers and [2:36:23] take down the cameras Alpers [2:36:24] don't actually protect us. [2:36:24] As we have heard from many [2:36:28] others but rather takes [2:36:28] critical funding away from [2:36:29] working class San Diego. [2:36:33] >> Thank you. [2:36:33] Thank you. [2:36:34] Thank you. [2:36:38] Next speaker is DR. Hector [2:36:38] Peralta. [2:36:38] Peralta. [2:36:39] Sorry. [2:36:43] Sloppy handwriting sometimes. [2:36:44] All right. [2:36:44] Hello. [2:36:44] Good afternoon. [2:36:45] My name is DR. Iker Peralta. [2:36:48] Agile Project District nine [2:36:48] City Heights. [2:36:49] I urge Council to follow [2:36:50] through on their vote today by [2:36:53] ordering the immediate removal [2:36:54] of our lpr cameras and to [2:36:54] continue supporting [2:36:55] counter-surveillance movements [2:36:58] around the city and the county. [2:36:58] Unsurprisingly, at [2:36:59] the beginning of today's [2:37:03] meeting the pd made misleading [2:37:03] inaccurate statements when [2:37:04] the officer here directly to my [2:37:08] right insinuated on record that [2:37:09] there is no collaboration [2:37:09] between federal agencies and [2:37:09] cpd. [2:37:12] That is not entirely true. [2:37:13] Argus an acronym that stands [2:37:14] for Automated Regional Justice [2:37:17] Information System Automated [2:37:18] Regional Justice Information [2:37:21] System established in 76 And [2:37:22] it's a shared database that sd [2:37:26] pd is a founding charter member [2:37:27] and dhs is one of the many [2:37:31] organizations the agencies [2:37:31] found on their website. [2:37:32] So I urge council members and [2:37:36] the people here to oppose all [2:37:36] surveillance technologies and [2:37:37] systems. [2:37:37] Follow through on your vote [2:37:41] today by immediately taking [2:37:42] down all cameras and blocking [2:37:42] them before their day. [2:37:43] >> In the meantime, thank you. [2:37:46] Thank you. [2:37:50] >> Next speakers Tracy and Ella [2:37:50] . [2:37:51] >> And if the following people [2:37:56] can come up to the front row. [2:37:57] Michelle Finland, Judy Howell [2:38:01] Reese and Werner Eric c and [2:38:01] Lily Sue Johnson. [2:38:07] Please begin. [2:38:07] >> Hi I'm Tracy District three [2:38:09] resident and I also own a [2:38:10] business in District three. [2:38:11] The remaining council members [2:38:14] who still feel that Alpers and [2:38:15] flood cameras are a safe idea [2:38:16] for our city I urge you to [2:38:16] please listen to me. [2:38:24] A lifelong resident. [2:38:29] >> Every inch of privacy we [2:38:30] lose right now is an injured [2:38:31] freedom that the next [2:38:31] generation is never going to [2:38:32] even know existed. [2:38:35] You know, we listen to cbd say [2:38:36] what capabilities these cameras [2:38:37] do or do not have but they're [2:38:39] already pre-installed with [2:38:40] microphones getting listened to [2:38:41] every word These cameras can [2:38:42] instantly program to look for [2:38:45] whatever they want to. [2:38:46] So who's going to tell me a [2:38:49] citizen or ask my consent when [2:38:50] that changes? [2:38:50] i don't trust it either. [2:38:54] That trust is gone. [2:38:54] >> These expensive devices are [2:38:55] full of precious minerals that [2:38:59] have been inhumanely mined in [2:39:00] the first place and they are [2:39:00] also available as any other [2:39:01] manmade item. [2:39:04] There's a reason why we stop [2:39:04] using nuclear weapons in [2:39:05] warfare in 1945. [2:39:05] Just because a tool is so [2:39:09] effective doesn't mean it [2:39:09] should make you That does [2:39:10] conclude your time. [2:39:10] >> Next speaker is Michelle [2:39:13] Finland. [2:39:18] >> Good afternoon council [2:39:18] members. [2:39:19] My name is Michelle Fenlon and [2:39:20] I was homeless for a year and a [2:39:23] half in San Diego. [2:39:23] During that time I experienced [2:39:24] an unbelievable amount of [2:39:27] harassment and stalking by our [2:39:28] police force injecting advanced [2:39:32] technology into an inherently [2:39:33] abusive system. [2:39:34] It's not going to magically [2:39:34] make it safe. [2:39:38] It's going to exacerbate [2:39:38] the qualities that are already [2:39:39] inside of it. [2:39:42] I have a background in nervous [2:39:43] system and trauma healing. [2:39:44] Ever since the implementation [2:39:47] of cctv there's copious amounts [2:39:48] of scientific evidence proving [2:39:48] that living under a [2:39:52] surveillance state is harmful [2:39:52] to its citizens. [2:39:53] What it does is it puts us in a [2:39:54] perpetual fight or flight [2:39:57] response that we cannot get out [2:39:58] of over time that causes actual [2:40:01] brain damage specifically to [2:40:02] our frontal lobes. [2:40:03] >> This is our center of [2:40:07] executive functioning of speech [2:40:07] ,of movement and of empathy, [2:40:08] of empathy. [2:40:12] Floc is unlawful or it's [2:40:13] unsafe. [2:40:17] Do your job The civil servants [2:40:17] and what flock out of San [2:40:18] Diego. [2:40:20] >> Thank you. [2:40:21] Next speaker is Judy. [2:40:25] How. [2:40:25] Good afternoon. [2:40:30] My name is Judy Howl and I'm [2:40:31] asking the city council to [2:40:34] defund the contract. [2:40:35] Whose rights are you willing to [2:40:36] compromise to solve crime? [2:40:39] Who are you willing to [2:40:40] wrongfully imprisoned due to a [2:40:44] technological error a I is [2:40:44] guided by missions and not [2:40:48] morals expediency is [2:40:49] the priority. [2:40:50] Accuracy is secondary and human [2:40:50] rights are not a part of [2:40:53] the discussion. [2:40:54] We deserve transparency and [2:40:55] safety before new technology is [2:40:57] built into our community. [2:41:03] >> Take the cameras down today [2:41:03] . [2:41:03] Thank you Ryan. [2:41:20] We for Ryan we aim for Ryan. [2:41:20] I've come to urge the council [2:41:24] to oppose these horrifying [2:41:25] Orwellian dystopian [2:41:25] surveillance cameras. [2:41:30] These are a clear, blatant [2:41:34] violation of the Fourth [2:41:34] Amendment of the Constitution [2:41:35] of the United States. [2:41:38] They have been used and abused [2:41:38] by the police to stalk [2:41:42] ex-girlfriends and search [2:41:43] endlessly. [2:41:44] They have no place in our [2:41:44] society. [2:41:48] I do not believe they make us [2:41:49] safer and I strongly encourage [2:41:53] the Council to oppose this [2:41:53] measure. [2:41:53] >> Thanks. [2:41:54] Thank you, Eric. [2:41:57] See? [2:41:57] >> Hello. [2:42:02] My name is Eric. [2:42:03] For cameras are a blatant [2:42:03] violation of the Fourth [2:42:04] Amendment. [2:42:07] They harm our community and [2:42:07] harm immigrants. [2:42:08] If you want to look for [2:42:09] criminals, you should look [2:42:13] inside the White House and in [2:42:14] the pages of the obscene files [2:42:14] rather than targeting innocent [2:42:15] immigrants. [2:42:16] Got the flock out of San Diego. [2:42:20] >> Thank you. [2:42:25] >> Thank you, Lily Sue Johnson [2:42:25] . [2:42:26] Good afternoon, council [2:42:26] members. [2:42:27] My name is Lilly-sue. [2:42:27] Today it's Princess Leia. [2:42:31] I've been to Chula Vista [2:42:31] District one resident my entire [2:42:32] life and I love this community. [2:42:35] I believe we all here care [2:42:36] deeply about the safety, [2:42:36] safety, freedom and future of [2:42:37] San Diego County. [2:42:40] Public safety should never come [2:42:40] at the expense of personal [2:42:41] privacy. [2:42:41] If you think my Princess Leia [2:42:42] costume is ridiculous but you [2:42:45] don't think Fox mass [2:42:45] surveillance technology is. [2:42:46] Then I hate to break it to you. [2:42:49] The joke's on you and [2:42:50] the Empire has already won. [2:42:51] Privacy is not a privilege. [2:42:52] Freedom should not come with a [2:42:53] surveillance subscription. [2:42:54] Remove the cameras and restore [2:42:55] our privacy today. [2:42:58] I value my constitutional [2:42:59] rights, my privacy and freedom [2:43:00] and I want those same freedoms [2:43:00] protected for future [2:43:01] generations. [2:43:02] block the flag out of San [2:43:02] Diego. [2:43:03] >> Thank you. [2:43:12] Next speaker is Angela Vetter. [2:43:12] Angela while Angela approaches, [2:43:13] could the following people come [2:43:17] up in the front row? [2:43:18] Jay Goldberg. [2:43:22] Monika So you know he has Ben [2:43:26] Butler, Isabel Kay and Ian Cruz [2:43:27] at court. [2:43:27] >> Please begin. [2:43:27] Hi. [2:43:32] I definitely realize I'm not [2:43:32] going to be very popular here [2:43:36] but I'm not here to say I'm in [2:43:37] favor of flag company. [2:43:41] >> I fully understand [2:43:41] the privacy concerns with these [2:43:42] cameras, especially [2:43:46] unauthorized access by ice or [2:43:46] other agencies. [2:43:47] That absolutely needs to be [2:43:50] addressed. [2:43:51] >> But I do feel these type of [2:43:52] cameras the technology can be [2:43:56] useful for police. [2:43:56] They're used all over the world [2:44:00] and they have been known to [2:44:01] they don't prevent crimes but [2:44:05] they definitely are [2:44:06] instrumental in solving crimes [2:44:09] producing thousands of arrest [2:44:10] and helping locate many missing [2:44:15] people. [2:44:16] I mean you see this Michigan [2:44:19] family, their three month old [2:44:20] baby that was kidnaped because [2:44:23] of this type of technology was [2:44:24] found within 25 minutes. [2:44:28] >> And I think about privacy. [2:44:29] >> Everywhere we go we have [2:44:30] cameras watching us. [2:44:30] Thank you. [2:44:31] That does conclude your time. [2:44:37] Jay Goldberg. [2:44:38] Afternoon, Counsel Jay. [2:44:42] District three It's remarkable [2:44:42] that you if you had listened to [2:44:45] the community and the pub we [2:44:46] might have been able to keep [2:44:47] this program but ramming it [2:44:47] down our throats without [2:44:50] compromise is non-consensual. [2:44:51] Privacy due process and [2:44:55] probable cause are cornerstones [2:44:56] of American California. [2:45:00] Cm Campo You've compared phone [2:45:01] usage with universal consent to [2:45:01] participate in a modern [2:45:02] society. [2:45:05] I respect you but I hold a [2:45:06] phone that I control. [2:45:06] I choose what software runs on [2:45:09] it and what privacy I'm [2:45:10] comfortable with. [2:45:11] If police want evidence off of [2:45:11] this device they have to get a [2:45:14] warrant and issue probable [2:45:15] cause to a judge or judiciary [2:45:19] to approve it. [2:45:20] We shouldn't be shamed for [2:45:20] being concerned and [2:45:24] conscientious. [2:45:24] >> It's time to undo this [2:45:25] mistake and hopefully learn [2:45:25] from it. [2:45:27] Thank you. [2:45:28] >> Thank you. [2:45:32] Monica Suji. [2:45:38] Got to noon for our foremost. [2:45:38] Thank you so much council [2:45:39] members for what you do for [2:45:42] the community here in San [2:45:42] Diego. [2:45:43] And Monica Shoji, a student at [2:45:47] the University of San Diego. [2:45:48] I'm here today to show my [2:45:49] concern about the park system. [2:45:52] I'm worried that this system [2:45:52] will be used for ice for [2:45:53] immigrants and racial profiling [2:45:57] even if it does not directly [2:45:57] tied to individual id. [2:45:58] Also there is a risk of [2:46:01] the system being hacked and [2:46:02] the information taken away. [2:46:03] I'm already nervous being in [2:46:06] front of all these cameras [2:46:06] today. [2:46:07] Can you imagine Near the flood [2:46:07] cameras. [2:46:11] And from Los Angeles and L.A. [2:46:12] County has already suspended [2:46:13] their usage of the system [2:46:16] because they also have concerns [2:46:17] regarding lock system. [2:46:17] It impacts our community and [2:46:21] safety and trust in [2:46:21] the community. [2:46:22] If a block is used right now [2:46:26] with the many uncertainty. [2:46:27] Therefore I would like to [2:46:28] propose that the county should [2:46:31] be taken down at this time and [2:46:32] also have our restrictions for [2:46:32] private companies usage. [2:46:36] Thank you so much for your [2:46:36] time. [2:46:36] >> Thank you. [2:46:45] It has been the talk. [2:46:45] Honorable Counsel. [2:46:46] My name is Yasmin Bethune and I [2:46:49] serve as the policy and [2:46:50] legislative staff member at [2:46:51] the Council on American-Islamic [2:46:51] Relations here in San Diego. [2:46:55] On MAY 18th the Islamic Center [2:46:55] of San Diego was brutally [2:46:59] attacked leading to the murder [2:47:00] of three community leaders and [2:47:03] the endangerment of 140 [2:47:03] schoolchildren. [2:47:04] The Muslim community especially [2:47:08] during these volatile times [2:47:08] would like to stress [2:47:09] the importance of community [2:47:09] safety. [2:47:13] However, due to [2:47:13] the unconstitutional breaches [2:47:14] of privacy, illegal data [2:47:15] sharing with out-of-state [2:47:18] agencies such as ice as well as [2:47:19] the disproportionate use of [2:47:19] surveillance against [2:47:23] marginalized communities, we [2:47:23] hold firm that lpr and mass [2:47:27] surveillance technologies are [2:47:28] not the appropriate tools for [2:47:29] ensuring community safety. [2:47:32] We must redefine public safety [2:47:33] by shifting away from [2:47:33] undemocratic mass surveillance [2:47:37] and towards working together on [2:47:37] community centered solutions. [2:47:38] >> Thank you. [2:47:40] Thank you Speakers. [2:47:45] >> Isabel Kay. [2:47:46] Hello, Council. [2:47:50] I'm Isabel Kay. [2:47:51] I reside in District one. [2:47:54] First am I am the only person [2:47:55] who can tell the difference [2:47:58] between a Toyota forerunner and [2:47:59] a Corolla. [2:48:00] Apparently our Alper system [2:48:03] cannot do extensive analysis of [2:48:08] the nationwide data on pc TVs [2:48:09] and the newer formats of air [2:48:12] linked cameras by Control f [2:48:13] shows that there is no [2:48:14] improvement in public safety [2:48:18] whatsoever. [2:48:18] Only a modest 13% reduction in [2:48:19] vehicle and property theft [2:48:23] which is sort of what we are [2:48:23] getting here in San Diego. [2:48:27] No reduction in violent crime. [2:48:28] As you've heard, personal data [2:48:29] are invaluable. [2:48:29] More data requires more [2:48:33] monitoring, more surveillance, [2:48:33] more data collection, more data [2:48:37] sharing and profits for Flock, [2:48:37] Palantir and others. [2:48:38] We are being used as guinea [2:48:41] pigs Our movements vehicles [2:48:42] lives are being harvested as a [2:48:43] natural resource without our [2:48:44] consent just as the people of [2:48:48] Gaza have been used to refine [2:48:49] the shameful killing [2:48:49] technologies used in deal that [2:48:52] does conclude your to among [2:48:53] them developed here. [2:48:53] >> Thank you that does San [2:48:54] Diego. [2:48:54] Thank you. [2:48:58] Next speakers Ian Cruz at court [2:48:59] while Ian approaches [2:49:00] the lectern could the following [2:49:02] people come up with a front row [2:49:07] James Aid Danny Ariosto, Hugh [2:49:14] Myra Afzal Yadi and Claire [2:49:15] Malanga Please begin. [2:49:15] >> Good afternoon counsel. [2:49:20] My name is Ian Cruz Accord. [2:49:20] I'm a resident in San Diego [2:49:21] County and on the leadership [2:49:24] team of the Otay Mesa Detention [2:49:25] Collective And from what [2:49:26] statistics have shown us lpr [2:49:28] Technologies and Flock cameras [2:49:29] are not a foolproof system to [2:49:30] the problem of crime According [2:49:33] to the Spd's own reports, [2:49:34] nearly 4000 searches were [2:49:35] logged on to the vague name of [2:49:38] other what crimes did these [2:49:39] people commit to get hit by [2:49:40] flock Was there even a crime at [2:49:40] all? [2:49:43] Is this a mistake by I or was [2:49:44] it corrupt officers using it [2:49:45] for mass surveillance of [2:49:45] protesters and immigrants under [2:49:48] the guise of protection? [2:49:49] These cameras make our [2:49:49] communities feel extremely [2:49:53] unsafe especially when we have [2:49:53] sanctuary city laws and knowing [2:49:54] after congressional hearings [2:49:58] and public audits that ice has [2:49:58] access to these databases. [2:49:59] And we know from seeing this [2:50:00] time and time again where [2:50:03] families and workers have been [2:50:03] tracked and kidnaped by ice [2:50:04] because of the data that was [2:50:07] obtained by fly. [2:50:08] >> With that I want to say take [2:50:09] down the cameras and get the [2:50:12] out of San Diego. [2:50:13] >> James Ave James, if you can [2:50:17] please come forward. [2:50:22] >> How's it going? [2:50:22] My name is James Ellis. [2:50:26] Last NOVEMBER I was on a [2:50:27] motorcycle when a white bmw [2:50:28] swerved into my lane and i [2:50:28] crashed. [2:50:32] The driver did stop, stood by [2:50:33] her car for two minutes and [2:50:33] then left. [2:50:37] I briefly lost consciousness, [2:50:38] was shuttled to the E.R. In an [2:50:38] ambulance and spent the night [2:50:39] in the trauma unit. [2:50:42] I broke my collarbone. [2:50:42] A witness caught a partial [2:50:46] plate and I asked for sd pd to [2:50:47] query their database the full [2:50:48] plate into place of litigation. [2:50:51] Hold on The Alper data. [2:50:51] I received confirmation that a [2:50:52] hold would be placed with a [2:50:52] subpoena. [2:50:56] I then sought to obtain that [2:50:57] Alper data Sergeant Craig Evans [2:50:58] informed me that no litigation [2:51:01] hold had ever been placed and [2:51:02] thus the fridge had purged. [2:51:03] Evans however, did tell me that [2:51:06] with a court order or a request [2:51:07] from a police officer he could [2:51:07] likely obtain the full plate [2:51:10] from the partial. [2:51:11] While Evans was helpful sd pd [2:51:14] refused to help me. [2:51:15] And worse they stood they [2:51:16] claimed in a way that [2:51:19] the driver had not committed a [2:51:20] crime given that there might [2:51:21] not have been contact between [2:51:21] vehicles. [2:51:24] If I could just finish one [2:51:25] concluding comment with that [2:51:26] one concluding comment. [2:51:29] Yeah it's still possible to [2:51:34] obtain the full plate if [2:51:34] the bmw is driven past any of [2:51:35] the 500 cameras in the past 30 [2:51:35] days. [2:51:39] Thank you. [2:51:39] Thank you. [2:51:40] I ask that you please help me. [2:51:43] I'll leave my contact info here [2:51:43] . [2:51:44] >> I'd really appreciate that, [2:51:44] Danny. [2:51:52] i Rosa. [2:51:53] Hello. [2:51:53] My name is Danny. [2:51:57] I'm a resident of District [2:51:57] three. [2:51:58] Last DECEMBER, residents of [2:51:58] every district stood before [2:52:03] this council and told you this [2:52:03] technology would be misused. [2:52:04] You dismissed those concerns [2:52:07] and you approved it anyway. [2:52:08] We told you exactly who would [2:52:09] misuse it, that it would be [2:52:09] these folks sitting right here [2:52:12] who appear very dis interested [2:52:13] in what we have to say. [2:52:13] And you didn't believe us? [2:52:17] Council PRESIDENT Lee Carver [2:52:17] you told us that this wasn't [2:52:18] the end and that we could [2:52:19] revisit this issue if we turned [2:52:21] out if you turned out to be [2:52:21] wrong. [2:52:22] So here we are after yet [2:52:23] another scandal involving [2:52:23] the misuse of this technology [2:52:26] by law enforcement. [2:52:27] Revisiting it. [2:52:27] I do want to thank [2:52:31] Councilmember Whitburn for [2:52:32] finally coming around on this [2:52:32] issue. [2:52:33] This is the first time I've [2:52:34] been proud of you since I have [2:52:36] moved to your district. [2:52:37] I just wish you had listened to [2:52:38] your constituents in the first [2:52:38] place. [2:52:41] Please vote to cancel this [2:52:42] contract and take down [2:52:42] the cameras. [2:52:43] >> Thank you, Kumara. [2:52:48] I also. [2:52:49] >> Hi. [2:52:49] Mass surveillance is hardly new [2:52:53] in the U.S. It goes back to at [2:52:53] least as far as the lantern [2:52:54] laws of the early 1700s. [2:52:57] The 20th century there was [2:52:58] surveillance of [2:52:58] Japanese-Americans, Black [2:53:01] Panthers, Vietnam War prisoners [2:53:02] and many more. [2:53:02] For the past 25 years Muslims [2:53:03] have been a primary target. [2:53:07] Warrantless mass surveillance [2:53:08] has always been bad and now it [2:53:09] is turbocharged by ai and other [2:53:12] technology And tech oligarchs [2:53:12] are accumulating vast amounts [2:53:13] of wealth from convincing city [2:53:16] governments that mass [2:53:17] surveillance is public safety. [2:53:18] It only needs to end today. [2:53:21] While I was waiting I did [2:53:22] the math and we need about $200 [2:53:26] worth of heavy duty black trash [2:53:26] bags to cover up all [2:53:27] the cameras. [2:53:30] >> So let us all go home or go [2:53:31] to work or school tomorrow [2:53:31] without being tracked. [2:53:33] Take 200 bucks from petty cash [2:53:37] and go buy the trash bags. [2:53:42] Yadi. [2:53:43] >> Hi Council. [2:53:44] I'm hoping that today you will [2:53:46] meet the moment and turn off [2:53:47] and either remove or cover [2:53:51] the flock Cameras. [2:53:52] You know our privacy is very [2:53:52] important and I'm glad that [2:53:56] we're having this conversation [2:53:56] here and it's time that we [2:53:57] don't support Flock who's out [2:54:01] there and calling us terrorist. [2:54:02] For defending democracy our [2:54:06] constitutional rights, our [2:54:06] civil liberties and our [2:54:07] privacy. [2:54:07] Furthermore, if you look on [2:54:11] flocks website they tell you [2:54:16] how they incorporate errors [2:54:16] into the images that they take [2:54:17] and they process. [2:54:18] We do not deserve to be [2:54:21] surveilled and we do not [2:54:22] deserve to be erroneously [2:54:25] subject to being pulled over [2:54:26] with armed officers And we [2:54:30] please I just suggest that you [2:54:31] don't get other vendors because [2:54:34] a lot of the vendors have this [2:54:35] problem of their technology [2:54:40] just not working and it's just [2:54:40] not perfect technology And [2:54:41] please end all surveillance. [2:54:45] >> Thank you, Claire. [2:54:46] >> Malala Claire, if you can [2:54:50] please come forward After that [2:54:54] we have Chief ten and by you [2:54:54] Moira ten. [2:54:59] Cooper Manley Ramsay is and [2:54:59] Isabella Jaramillo. [2:55:00] If you can all please come [2:55:04] forward to the front row. [2:55:05] We are in our final speakers [2:55:08] After that please proceed. [2:55:09] Good afternoon. [2:55:10] My name is Claire Malala and [2:55:13] I'm a student at uc San Diego [2:55:14] and a resident in District six. [2:55:14] I urge you to cancel [2:55:19] the surveillance use policy and [2:55:19] remove the flock cameras [2:55:20] immediately. [2:55:20] How many more of your [2:55:23] constituents lives will be put [2:55:24] in danger All their access to [2:55:24] this mass surveillance system [2:55:28] that is present right here in [2:55:28] San Diego. [2:55:29] Before you reject this invasive [2:55:29] technology, please vote to [2:55:33] reject Floc and instead invest [2:55:34] in programs that do not rely on [2:55:38] mass surveillance for so-called [2:55:38] protection. [2:55:39] >> Thank you. [2:55:48] Chieftain Chieftain naming [2:55:52] the streets after police. [2:55:53] You can't be neutral on a [2:55:53] moving train. [2:55:58] Protect the people immediately [2:55:59] Rescind and remove Hugo had [2:55:59] already shot. [2:56:02] Families torn apart city [2:56:03] councils by data mining San [2:56:07] Diego's every day 500 down [2:56:08] immediately Cancel the contract [2:56:12] Take them out Get the out Shut [2:56:13] it down Twitter and 84 cities [2:56:13] canceled the contract. [2:56:16] Right now the system is [2:56:16] burning. [2:56:17] Shut it down Shame Sharing info [2:56:21] with Feds privacy Advocate [2:56:22] Advisory Board Rejected No [2:56:22] accountability The people sd [2:56:27] Trust protecting us telling us [2:56:27] that the community no one wants [2:56:31] a surveillance state no way [2:56:32] back glass is no police state [2:56:36] Get the out Get the out Get [2:56:36] the flock out Get the out. [2:56:37] Get the up. [2:56:37] Get the out. [2:56:40] Get the out. [2:56:45] >> We are down to our last [2:56:45] speakers There's a lot more [2:56:46] clapping The people won't be [2:56:49] able to hear me to come up and [2:56:50] I don't want them to MISS Their [2:56:50] turn. [2:56:54] Anna by. [2:56:55] >> Hello Council members My [2:57:00] name is on a by you I'm with [2:57:01] Green Party and General strike [2:57:01] u s and I'm constituent of [2:57:03] weapons. [2:57:04] I am happy to hear that you [2:57:05] have changed your vote because [2:57:06] I did have a little piece for [2:57:08] you that I have taken out now [2:57:09] I'm like many here today I am [2:57:10] here to comment on the floor [2:57:14] cameras in the city. [2:57:19] >> So in DECEMBER of 2025 for [2:57:19] eight hours 50 agents told you [2:57:23] our concerns about the floor [2:57:23] cameras in the city Shawn [2:57:24] Oliveira, Vivian Marino and [2:57:28] Henry Foster voted against it [2:57:28] and Woodburn has changed his [2:57:29] vote. [2:57:29] Thank you. [2:57:33] I'm this the floor cameras came [2:57:34] across your desk because of [2:57:38] the former police department [2:57:38] captain Jack Jordan who helped [2:57:42] secure this initial contract. [2:57:43] Jordan now works for Floc as [2:57:47] their strategic relations [2:57:47] manager. [2:57:48] But that doesn't say that this [2:57:52] is an ethical I don't know what [2:57:53] does. [2:57:53] >> Recently the attack on [2:57:54] the Islamic center San Diego [2:57:58] was attacked earlier. [2:57:58] >> Oh, not so fast. [2:57:59] Thank you. [2:58:12] My return Mara Cooper Manly [2:58:19] Good afternoon and thank you [2:58:19] for the opportunity to speak [2:58:20] here today. [2:58:20] >> My name is Cooper and I'm a [2:58:21] student. [2:58:23] Use these cross school peace [2:58:23] Studies and School of Law. [2:58:24] Not only do Alpers pose [2:58:27] significant cost to the civil [2:58:28] liberties of San Diego and [2:58:29] millions of other Americans but [2:58:29] their continued use represents [2:58:33] a fabricated agreement by [2:58:33] residents to butcher both [2:58:34] the constitutional right to [2:58:35] privacy and the human right of [2:58:39] freedom of movement in exchange [2:58:39] for some elusive imprecise [2:58:44] improvement for safety. [2:58:44] Eop hours are designed to [2:58:45] constantly surveil me or you or [2:58:48] any of us and reveal detailed [2:58:49] information about our movements [2:58:50] on demand. [2:58:50] Any surveillance should be [2:58:54] conducted legally and [2:58:54] conservatively by law [2:58:55] enforcement not big tech and [2:58:56] should be a response to [2:58:59] evidence based suspicion not [2:59:00] the baseline reality for [2:59:00] everyday citizens. [2:59:04] I asked the council to be [2:59:04] brave, push back against the [2:59:05] surveillance state and [2:59:06] recognize that technological [2:59:09] advancement can quickly become [2:59:10] totalitarian assets especially [2:59:14] when profits and power are put [2:59:15] over. [2:59:15] >> People get the flock out of [2:59:16] San Diego. [2:59:26] Thank you Ramsey Hello. [2:59:27] Hello, Counsel. [2:59:27] I'm not really going to bother [2:59:28] you guys about anything that [2:59:31] hasn't really been said before [2:59:32] either by myself or the other [2:59:32] people behind me. [2:59:33] The bottom line is that [2:59:36] the people of San Diego no [2:59:37] longer trust the city whether [2:59:37] it's because of you guys on [2:59:38] the council or the people here [2:59:39] on the police department [2:59:41] there's a culture of distrust. [2:59:41] We can't trust the police [2:59:42] department especially when they [2:59:47] have a culture of protecting [2:59:47] murderers and abusers whether [2:59:48] it be them having to show up [2:59:53] every day and walk by Daniel [2:59:53] Gold, the man who killed 16 [2:59:54] year old and all else And right [2:59:57] here in downtown San Diego. [2:59:58] Why would we trust those people [2:59:59] to police us and surveillance [3:00:03] and track us down in our places [3:00:04] of work, our places of worship [3:00:04] and our schools? [3:00:05] It doesn't make any sense. [3:00:06] We have no reason to trust [3:00:08] these people anymore, [3:00:09] especially when they lie time [3:00:09] and time again over how they [3:00:10] use the technology that there's [3:00:13] no abuse going on when every [3:00:14] couple of weeks either there's [3:00:19] someone being improperly [3:00:20] surveilled or someone getting [3:00:21] shot. [3:00:24] There could have been a 19 year [3:00:25] old murdered the other day [3:00:25] because of this technology [3:00:29] Isabella had I mean you know [3:00:30] after that will be Erin [3:00:33] Inferno, Omar Wimbush looks [3:00:40] kind of locker. [3:00:41] >> Good afternoon Thank you for [3:00:42] the opportunity to speak today [3:00:45] My name is Eric Laramie and I'm [3:00:46] a graduate student at usc. [3:00:47] I urge you to take on [3:00:47] the cameras. [3:00:50] I believe that public safety [3:00:51] and the protection of civil [3:00:52] liberties should never be [3:00:52] treated as competing [3:00:53] priorities. [3:00:56] We shouldn't Concerns about [3:00:57] this technology can be used to [3:00:57] raise an important questions [3:01:02] Are these existing safeguards [3:01:02] strong enough to protect [3:01:03] the public's right? [3:01:04] The responsibility of this city [3:01:04] is not only to ensure that this [3:01:07] technology is effective but [3:01:08] also that its use is justified, [3:01:12] transparent and accountable as [3:01:13] you consider item 200 I ask [3:01:14] that you carefully evaluate [3:01:15] whether the existing safeguards [3:01:18] are sufficient to protect civil [3:01:19] liberties and maintain public [3:01:19] trust. [3:01:21] >> Thank you for your time. [3:01:34] Erin Inferno Thank. [3:01:35] >> San Diego Police Department [3:01:35] paid $30 million to the family [3:01:39] of Will Then when an officer [3:01:39] was shot and that officer shot [3:01:40] him in the chest when he was in [3:01:45] actual violence thus leading to [3:01:46] the largest payout in United [3:01:46] States history. [3:01:50] While that officer is still [3:01:51] employed Mayor Todd Gloria and [3:01:52] Stephen Whitman, which you MAY [3:01:53] or MAY not have change your [3:01:56] vote your your vote excuse me [3:01:57] You're supposed to represent [3:02:01] like me in Hillcrest in [3:02:02] District three but instead [3:02:02] you're protesting your excuse [3:02:07] me you are giving your time to [3:02:08] oligarchs their technology with [3:02:13] block and helpers is not 100% [3:02:14] accurate Police department [3:02:19] whether it be San Diego Police [3:02:19] or any police department in [3:02:20] the country they use this [3:02:21] information and it being flawed [3:02:25] does not lead to accurate [3:02:25] information leading to arrests [3:02:26] More than 100 officers in San [3:02:31] Diego Police Department have [3:02:31] used this data from block to [3:02:37] stock and other ex-girlfriends. [3:02:38] And while I urge you to vote [3:02:42] against for or for that [3:02:48] concluding comment Omar Abidjan [3:02:49] Good afternoon Council members. [3:02:49] >> My name is General Sherman. [3:02:50] I serve as the programs and [3:02:55] outreach coordinator at care [3:02:55] San Diego. [3:02:56] I also do sit on the police [3:02:56] chiefs all of American advisory [3:03:00] board while I do not speak for [3:03:01] the entire board, I'm here. [3:03:02] I'm here to urge you to end [3:03:05] flood surveillance. [3:03:06] On MAY 18th our community [3:03:07] experienced a deadly attack [3:03:07] flocking to prevent it or keep [3:03:11] our community safe. [3:03:12] Rather it misled. [3:03:13] Yet the system continues to [3:03:13] record where people travel [3:03:18] creating sensitive data about [3:03:18] their lives without making our [3:03:19] community any safer. [3:03:24] That data can be accessed or [3:03:25] shared beyond its original [3:03:25] purpose sharing license plates [3:03:30] with immigration authorities is [3:03:31] wrong. [3:03:31] Muslim immigrant families in [3:03:32] our broader community should [3:03:33] not have to wonder whether [3:03:36] going to the mosque, visiting [3:03:37] relatives or attending a [3:03:37] community event could expose [3:03:38] them or their loved ones to [3:03:42] enforcement. [3:03:43] This is more than just about [3:03:43] cameras. [3:03:44] It is about whether people can [3:03:48] live, worship and participate [3:03:48] in community life without being [3:03:49] tracked. [3:03:49] >> We urge you to vote no. [3:03:50] Thank you. [3:03:53] Our final speaker here in [3:03:54] council chambers is Luke [3:03:54] Skywalker. [3:03:55] If you can please come forward. [3:03:59] There are no other speakers [3:04:00] that I have here in council [3:04:01] chambers or speaker slips so we [3:04:02] will be going to virtual [3:04:06] comment and no additional [3:04:06] speakers in chambers will be [3:04:07] taken. [3:04:07] >> Please proceed. [3:04:08] Good afternoon. [3:04:12] City Council My name is Luke [3:04:13] Skywalker and I'm here to [3:04:14] rescue you Here to rescue you [3:04:18] from these blocked cameras that [3:04:18] have been installed all across [3:04:19] the galaxy. [3:04:19] I have been traveling far and [3:04:25] wide to escape the evil Lord [3:04:25] Vader. [3:04:26] He's been traversing me. [3:04:27] He's been utilizing these plot [3:04:30] cameras to chase me all across [3:04:31] the galaxy And now I'm here [3:04:31] begging you not to suspend this [3:04:32] technology but to cancel this [3:04:37] technology once and for all. [3:04:38] It will be utilized to [3:04:38] facilitate the creation of [3:04:39] the Death Star. [3:04:43] That's where all of our data [3:04:43] will be stored. [3:04:44] I got to go. [3:04:45] My x-Wing is parked in a red [3:04:45] zone right now. [3:04:49] I can't I can't speak for long [3:04:50] But one thing I do want to tell [3:04:50] this council one thing I have [3:04:51] to employ this council is to [3:04:55] continue using the force [3:04:56] the way that you have thus far. [3:04:57] The force is strong with all of [3:05:00] you and the force is strong [3:05:01] with everyone in this council [3:05:02] chambers Thank you. [3:05:03] >> Are you guys brother and [3:05:11] sister that doesn't keep coming [3:05:11] here in council chambers Going [3:05:15] to those participating remotely [3:05:15] have started the five minute [3:05:16] timer and we have 23 speakers [3:05:21] in the queue. [3:05:22] Before we go to that I just [3:05:22] want to state for the record [3:05:23] that we did have 14 speakers [3:05:27] submit speaker slips in [3:05:27] opposition but did not wish to [3:05:30] speak as well as we received [3:05:31] ten comments in favor and 106 [3:05:32] comments in opposition via our [3:05:32] economic forum which have been [3:05:37] distributed to the Council [3:05:38] starting with 8813. [3:05:41] If you can please unmute you'll [3:05:42] have one minute. [3:05:48] Please proceed. [3:05:49] >> 8813I do see you unmuted but [3:05:56] we do not hear you here in [3:05:56] council chambers. [3:05:57] Not sure of the device that [3:05:57] you're speaking into MAY be [3:05:58] here. [3:05:58] There we go. [3:06:01] Please proceed. [3:06:01] Okay. [3:06:02] Okay. [3:06:02] Controller I'm not sure if this [3:06:03] is Comic-Con or a freaking city [3:06:06] council meeting but here it [3:06:06] goes. [3:06:07] You know the dais had blood on [3:06:07] their hands. [3:06:11] That's what's so And yet [3:06:12] the public continues to blindly [3:06:13] trust these individuals like as [3:06:17] if they're all knowing that [3:06:18] going to be further from [3:06:18] the truth Start paying [3:06:18] attention. [3:06:23] This is all theater and they're [3:06:24] desperately trying to win back [3:06:29] the trust of the people because [3:06:30] the trust has been dwindling [3:06:30] for both sides for a while And [3:06:35] it's just so evident that [3:06:35] the system itself has failed us [3:06:40] all And yet you all continue to [3:06:41] believe and get and give up [3:06:46] your right over to it and [3:06:47] honestly and to those of you [3:06:48] who still believe in this [3:06:52] board, stop blindly handing it [3:06:52] over again. [3:06:53] Start holding these people [3:06:53] accountable and do it before [3:06:54] the damage is already done. [3:06:58] You ultimately want to feel [3:06:59] safe yet you continue putting [3:07:00] your trust in the same people [3:07:04] putting us in harm's way. [3:07:05] Wake up This is nothing to [3:07:05] take. [3:07:06] My daughter Katherine Douglas [3:07:14] If you can please On you In our [3:07:14] current law where it is very [3:07:19] hard to recruit qualified [3:07:20] police officers, Alpers and [3:07:25] other technologies are a force [3:07:26] a force multiplier and have had [3:07:26] a very positive effect on [3:07:27] the safety of everyone in our [3:07:31] communities and the recovery of [3:07:32] stolen property. [3:07:33] They do not shine on private [3:07:37] property and do not have facial [3:07:37] recognition. [3:07:38] I'm 100% in favor of them. [3:07:43] Please do more research before [3:07:43] you come to a premature [3:07:44] conclusion as to their [3:07:45] effectiveness in keeping us [3:07:49] safe. [3:07:50] I would also like to point out [3:07:51] that I think there were more [3:07:55] people speaking today against [3:07:56] the Clippers. [3:07:56] Where were these people when [3:08:01] the police presented the new [3:08:02] technologies and went over [3:08:08] the existing technologies? [3:08:08] There were less people there. [3:08:09] If you're going to speak on [3:08:13] this subject you ought to [3:08:14] attend these meetings which are [3:08:18] presented in all nine [3:08:19] communities Districts there [3:08:20] have concluded Gabriel if you [3:08:34] can please on you Gabriel you [3:08:35] are a muted we do not hear you [3:08:35] here in council chambers Not [3:08:36] sure if the devices you're [3:08:38] speaking into MAY be muted. [3:08:43] Gabriel Aravena You have not [3:08:47] muted yourself. [3:08:54] Please unmute the device that [3:09:00] you MAY be speaking to Maybe [3:09:01] muted. [3:09:01] I will move on to the next [3:09:02] caller if you can limit [3:09:05] yourself properly. [3:09:06] Like I said you are muted on [3:09:11] Zoom but we do not hear you. [3:09:12] >> Barbara Gordon If you can [3:09:18] please on you on. [3:09:19] Thank you And today I am urging [3:09:19] the city to support this vital [3:09:23] tool for our police department [3:09:24] because it helps officers turn [3:09:29] vehicle information into timely [3:09:30] investigation leads. [3:09:30] I had a friend that was [3:09:35] strangled to death in her bed. [3:09:36] Her killer is now in jail [3:09:37] because of this program was [3:09:41] able to identify his license [3:09:42] plate coming and going from her [3:09:48] home That helped him in [3:09:48] the investigation. [3:09:49] I asked you to continue to [3:09:50] allow this program that will [3:09:53] assist and support [3:09:54] the investigation. [3:09:55] Again, let us not lose sight of [3:09:59] the potential benefit. [3:10:00] This tool could help to improve [3:10:01] residents sense of safety and [3:10:06] confidence that the that police [3:10:07] have their tools to investigate [3:10:07] crime. [3:10:12] Again, please do not let this [3:10:12] program go. [3:10:13] >> Thank you for letting me [3:10:18] speak. [3:10:18] Thank you. [3:10:23] Walker If you can please unmute [3:10:24] Thank you. [3:10:25] As a victim of home burglary I [3:10:30] support Alpers use per [3:10:31] the trust ordinance. [3:10:32] I hear the fear here and I [3:10:32] empathize but don't find [3:10:36] documented evidence. [3:10:37] Very many of the kinds of [3:10:38] blatant mass shootings are [3:10:38] concerns that were voiced at [3:10:42] the same time there's [3:10:43] documented evidence of safety [3:10:44] benefits and allowing police to [3:10:44] better focus on active [3:10:48] emergency needs and [3:10:52] investigations including a 20% [3:10:53] drop in auto theft last year [3:10:54] Also that contributed to faster [3:10:59] clearances and homicides [3:11:00] Shootings hit and run Steve [3:11:01] Wise and leads an amber and [3:11:05] silver alerts for missing [3:11:05] persons. [3:11:06] That's very important legal [3:11:10] experts say that comply with [3:11:10] Fourth Amendment rights So I [3:11:11] suggest make corrections and [3:11:16] improve oversight but don't [3:11:16] eliminate something [3:11:17] contributing to greater public [3:11:17] safety. [3:11:22] Thank you. [3:11:22] Thank you. [3:11:28] Camera If you can please unmute [3:11:28] The five minute timer has also [3:11:29] considered hearing council [3:11:30] chambers or 29 speakers in [3:11:30] the queue. [3:11:33] No additional speakers will be [3:11:33] taken. [3:11:34] Camera please on you. [3:11:35] Good afternoon Council can you [3:11:35] hear me? [3:11:39] Yes please proceed. [3:11:39] Very good. [3:11:40] Thank you. [3:11:40] i live in District three and I [3:11:41] want to be clear I do not [3:11:44] support in any capacity [3:11:45] the presence of flock or any [3:11:46] npr cameras in San Diego [3:11:46] history has shown us time and [3:11:51] time again public safety does [3:11:52] not to come from mass [3:11:52] surveillance. [3:11:53] This technology is far too [3:11:58] easily used against citizens it [3:11:59] purports to protect and frankly [3:11:59] that's by design and helpers do [3:12:03] not keep us safe. [3:12:03] They make us something to be [3:12:04] commodified and preemptively [3:12:09] oppressed by the powers that be [3:12:09] . [3:12:10] The harm that this technology [3:12:10] presents to the public, to [3:12:11] innocent citizens who have been [3:12:15] and will be continue to be [3:12:16] harassed, stopped, killed by [3:12:17] our police department abusing [3:12:17] its faulty and dangerous [3:12:21] technology this far outweighs [3:12:22] any semblance of safety you [3:12:23] could ever claim to provide. [3:12:27] I agree The contract to flag [3:12:28] must be canceled cameras [3:12:28] deactivated and removed by [3:12:29] the city immediately because of [3:12:34] others have said We don't trust [3:12:34] you. [3:12:35] We don't trust the word or [3:12:35] the intentions of your [3:12:36] manufacturers, your council, [3:12:39] the mayor of your time, he [3:12:40] concluded John if you can [3:12:45] please unmute John Academy [3:12:56] before you join I want you to [3:12:56] move on. [3:13:03] >> If you're not unmuted. [3:13:04] Zeenat Sanchez if you can [3:13:16] please unmute your bill. [3:13:17] >> Oh yes, please proceed. [3:13:17] Okay. [3:13:18] Well first off before and it's [3:13:20] not stupid we see the political [3:13:21] maneuvering and alliances and [3:13:21] who's backing the same [3:13:22] political forces pushing [3:13:22] surveillance into our [3:13:27] communities are connected to [3:13:28] those who back Martha Abraham's [3:13:28] campaign After everything you [3:13:29] expect a to question if the map [3:13:33] is a map and we demand answers [3:13:33] We've been fighting flak for [3:13:34] years. [3:13:34] We warned you this contract [3:13:35] should never have been approved [3:13:38] and you ignored us. [3:13:38] Now the abuses we warned you [3:13:39] about are coming to light as [3:13:40] you continue to undermine [3:13:45] the tpp. [3:13:45] What kind of watchdog can be [3:13:46] right with the department it's [3:13:47] supposed to oversee Keeps on [3:13:48] its leash 12 minutes. [3:13:49] Watch your communities But you [3:13:49] won't give us meaningful [3:13:50] accountability. [3:13:56] We're not stupid or intimidated [3:13:57] and we're not going away before [3:13:57] nine are watching. [3:13:58] Southeast Asia is watching. [3:13:58] Terminate this contract. [3:14:00] Cut their surveillance and [3:14:01] excuses more demanding. [3:14:01] We're demanding accountability [3:14:02] now. [3:14:04] Thank you, Lawrence o'Donnell [3:14:10] If you can please let me Thank [3:14:10] you. [3:14:11] Good afternoon. [3:14:11] I taught information technology [3:14:12] at local colleges and [3:14:17] universities for 20 years and I [3:14:17] would never trust automated [3:14:22] cameras to do police work And [3:14:23] that's why I opposed [3:14:24] the cameras or any other [3:14:24] technology because ultimately [3:14:28] the use of your critical [3:14:29] thinking skills begins to [3:14:30] decline and our police officers [3:14:34] need to develop better critical [3:14:34] thinking skills when their [3:14:35] mistakes are life and death [3:14:35] decisions. [3:14:40] I was followed home one night [3:14:41] because a license plate reader [3:14:41] couldn't decipher a state [3:14:46] issued retired legislators [3:14:47] license plate. [3:14:48] And when I walked out to talk [3:14:48] to the officers and explain why [3:14:52] I wasn't being recognized in [3:14:53] their system, two additional [3:14:54] cars showed up simply because a [3:14:54] retired state legislator [3:14:59] decided to go out and engage [3:14:59] with the police officer and [3:15:00] explain that their automated [3:15:04] license plate reader didn't [3:15:04] understand what it was seeing. [3:15:05] We need critical thinking [3:15:11] skills not automated cameras. [3:15:12] >> Take down these walk and any [3:15:12] other technology cameras. [3:15:13] Thank you. [3:15:13] Thank you. [3:15:14] Next is Blair Beckman. [3:15:20] >> If you can please unmute. [3:15:21] All right. [3:15:22] But the reason I think there [3:15:27] can be a community consensus [3:15:27] that can be well focused and [3:15:28] respectful and that is simple [3:15:29] city council vote and certainly [3:15:32] the current locks of contract [3:15:33] and a considerable amount of 50 [3:15:34] to 250 San Diego yards this can [3:15:40] be followed up in 2027 with a [3:15:40] full committee process perhaps [3:15:44] a bill that can ask if we need [3:15:44] a better principal or a vendor. [3:15:48] And can we can we can we begin [3:15:49] to reduce the 2024 You make [3:15:50] your contract a five minute [3:15:57] deal along with all [3:15:58] the additional safety of [3:15:59] the neighborhood cap and any [3:15:59] new best practices of our [3:16:01] current studies of the past few [3:16:02] years it should be becoming [3:16:03] clear we can much reduce [3:16:07] placement that is redundant [3:16:07] while still maintaining good [3:16:12] public safety practices In [3:16:12] the 2027. [3:16:13] I hope we can all continue to [3:16:14] work and create a very clear [3:16:17] path to developing a more [3:16:18] accountable, more responsible [3:16:19] and better principal policies [3:16:19] and practices within our San [3:16:24] Diego neighborhood. [3:16:25] >> Public Safety Questions. [3:16:26] Thanks for your time. [3:16:26] Good luck with your work to [3:16:33] echo If you can please unmute. [3:16:34] Yes, hi, this is this is Elke [3:16:34] Weston. [3:16:39] I am a voter in Logan Heights. [3:16:40] You know, it's kind of a crack [3:16:45] up that we have a full board of [3:16:46] Democrats and it's been [3:16:47] the biggest failure with all of [3:16:51] you except for Shawn Helio [3:16:52] Rivera. [3:16:56] You know the fork in the Alpers [3:16:57] cameras, they were used in [3:16:57] Germany. [3:17:03] 94% of the images they took [3:17:03] were faulty. [3:17:04] Couldn't give them any [3:17:04] information. [3:17:05] That's the same technology [3:17:09] you're using out of all [3:17:09] the images you took And it cost [3:17:10] $12 million. [3:17:14] There was only 300 cases that [3:17:14] were worthy of looking into. [3:17:15] So you're saying that it's [3:17:20] worth 40 grand for one case [3:17:20] while you stock while you [3:17:25] racially profile while you [3:17:26] discriminate? [3:17:27] Do you know how many people I [3:17:27] know that intentionally drove [3:17:31] down imperial breaking the law [3:17:32] just to see if you would [3:17:33] contact them with white skin? [3:17:38] What you guys are doing with [3:17:39] the exception of San Diego [3:17:40] Rivera your time has concluded. [3:17:45] Carol Kim, if you can please. [3:17:45] And you. [3:17:46] Good afternoon, council [3:17:46] members. [3:17:50] This is Carol Kim Business [3:17:51] manager of the San Diego County [3:17:52] Building and Construction [3:17:52] Trades Council. [3:17:53] When we grapple with public [3:17:57] policy, we can't simply ask can [3:17:57] this potentially do something [3:17:58] good? [3:17:58] We have to actually ask are [3:17:59] the tradeoffs worth it? [3:18:03] All over the country we have to [3:18:04] often plunge into the use of [3:18:08] surveillance based only on [3:18:08] the first question and without [3:18:09] enough consideration of [3:18:09] the second. [3:18:10] But that's given us [3:18:10] the opportunity to witness [3:18:14] rampant abuse of these systems, [3:18:15] forcing us to ask how many [3:18:16] crimes we are willing to create [3:18:16] in this process. [3:18:20] Hopefully the answer is zero. [3:18:21] Hopefully we would not [3:18:22] knowingly create opportunities [3:18:25] for more abuse under any [3:18:26] circumstances. [3:18:27] We should not be trading away [3:18:27] our civil rights. [3:18:28] We have seen locally and beyond [3:18:32] that these systems make [3:18:33] unacceptable errors even before [3:18:33] accounting for the human [3:18:34] temptation for abuse and beyond [3:18:38] undermining public trust. [3:18:39] Local governments all over [3:18:39] the country including right [3:18:40] here will be paying out [3:18:44] millions upon millions to [3:18:45] settle cases of these systems [3:18:45] failing. [3:18:46] It's not worth the cuts and [3:18:47] it's not worth the tradeoffs. [3:18:51] I urge you to reject to attend [3:18:51] and remove npr in San Diego. [3:18:52] The case has concluded Million [3:18:53] Mile Man If you can please [3:18:59] unmute. [3:18:59] >> We are looking at [3:19:04] philosophical psychological, [3:19:05] historical and moral constructs [3:19:06] here which transcend the whole [3:19:11] idea of surveillance From JULY [3:19:16] 14th, 1789 to that was the body [3:19:21] and the Nuremberg trials which [3:19:22] wasn't about obedience. [3:19:22] We already knew that it was [3:19:27] about obedience and obedience [3:19:28] can be regulated but a man's [3:19:33] conscience cannot be regulated [3:19:34] And this is the fundamental [3:19:35] issue we're talking about here. [3:19:40] We're talking about what [3:19:41] the Jesuits that determine a [3:19:41] boy develops its moral [3:19:46] conscience at seven years old. [3:19:47] They don't learn this in [3:19:47] the police academy. [3:19:52] Even the joint Chiefs probably [3:19:52] don't even learn it. [3:19:53] But that is a fact and that is [3:19:58] human behavior. [3:19:58] Get rid of these cameras now. [3:19:59] Thank you. [3:20:05] Daniel Jones up. [3:20:06] >> Your time has concluded. [3:20:06] We turn if you can please on [3:20:11] mute. [3:20:12] Hi, my name is Weekend and I'm [3:20:13] going to started here. [3:20:17] Then it goes I'm calling to [3:20:17] support a committee member to [3:20:22] vote voted against a contract [3:20:23] between those two When we made [3:20:24] the decision in JUNE when it [3:20:29] was a hard decision actually it [3:20:29] would have been hard. [3:20:30] As I said, you guys voted to [3:20:31] support a community joined [3:20:31] million dollar could have gone [3:20:35] to a lot of around our culture [3:20:35] and everything. [3:20:36] I'm glad to be able to have [3:20:40] some member now finally on [3:20:41] board I mean you'll have staff [3:20:41] who could have done [3:20:42] the research to find out [3:20:47] exactly what it means and what [3:20:48] I've been feeding you Now I'm [3:20:49] glad you willing to step up to [3:20:54] the right diet issue but I want [3:20:55] to name just a couple who did [3:20:58] the right thing all along. [3:20:59] Should also get that we should [3:21:00] get a credit for us So please [3:21:03] also vote vote to terminate [3:21:03] the contract. [3:21:03] Thank you. [3:21:04] Thank you Amanda if you can [3:21:14] please unmute but yes please [3:21:15] proceed. [3:21:15] >> Okay. [3:21:15] Good afternoon. [3:21:21] I through council I would like [3:21:22] to encourage everyone in this [3:21:23] room to find a way to watch [3:21:26] the movie not that in the movie [3:21:27] Israeli soldiers explain how [3:21:28] surveillance technology is used [3:21:32] to target rebellious civilians [3:21:33] . [3:21:33] Surveillance tech assigns a [3:21:34] threat number to individuals [3:21:35] that authorize it. [3:21:38] How many innocent civilians can [3:21:39] be murdered in order to kill [3:21:40] one target while they sleep in [3:21:40] bed at night? [3:21:41] They label them terrorists for [3:21:45] resisting. [3:21:46] I really government Not [3:21:46] dissimilar to the executive [3:21:49] order Trump issued in SEPTEMBER [3:21:50] 25th labeling anti-fascist [3:21:51] protesters as Terrorists. [3:21:51] We watch other Congress [3:21:56] attempts to merge our military [3:22:01] with Israel's with ndaa such in [3:22:02] 1270 We see the department our [3:22:02] city Council with Israel [3:22:03] including Todd Gloria and [3:22:03] Ocampo. [3:22:07] We get the people like Stephen [3:22:08] Miller at the helm of Trump [3:22:08] fascist take over. [3:22:12] We think our city council has [3:22:13] put smart streetlights and [3:22:13] surveillance technology on a [3:22:14] city against their will and we [3:22:17] are all connecting the dots No [3:22:18] mass surveillance, no data [3:22:19] centers Get the out. [3:22:19] Michael Schmidt If you can [3:22:24] please unmute Break. [3:22:30] Good evening everyone. [3:22:30] Please take those cameras down [3:22:31] of the lights. [3:22:31] They're so pointless and I just [3:22:36] hate the fact that people get [3:22:37] red on their license plates. [3:22:42] I just think it's pointless. [3:22:42] But thank you very much. [3:22:43] Bye. [3:22:43] Thank you. [3:22:43] Ted. [3:22:50] If you can please unmute. [3:22:51] Hello? [3:22:51] Can you hear me? [3:22:52] Yes. [3:22:52] Please proceed. [3:22:53] Hi, my name's Ted. [3:22:58] Well, I'm back with Santiago [3:22:58] and also the vice chair of [3:22:59] the Faculty Advisory board just [3:23:02] for everybody really quick [3:23:03] recap about where we are with [3:23:04] the automatic license plate [3:23:04] readers. [3:23:08] Originally they were introduced [3:23:09] to us and we had to accept [3:23:10] the usage of them without a use [3:23:10] policy because of exigent [3:23:14] circumstances We found out that [3:23:15] wasn't true. [3:23:16] Once we had our use policy we [3:23:16] figured out that our youth [3:23:20] policy was being violated [3:23:20] because the doj contacted law [3:23:21] enforcement. [3:23:21] We were sharing data. [3:23:26] We found out L.A.P.D. Is [3:23:27] sharing that same data with [3:23:31] federal agents and ice to cause [3:23:32] fear in our neighborhoods. [3:23:32] So we have a violation of [3:23:38] the use policy We've had things [3:23:39] gone wrong with this and yet [3:23:39] we've had no accountability. [3:23:40] I want to say from this Dyess [3:23:43] that if they could save one [3:23:43] life that it's worth it. [3:23:44] But at this point it's caused [3:23:45] the death of multiple lives [3:23:49] When it hindered [3:23:50] the investigation at [3:23:50] the center. [3:23:51] So at this point we just need [3:23:51] to take them down. [3:23:55] I'm going to use that same kind [3:23:56] of mask. [3:23:56] >> We violated the policy. [3:23:57] It's not saving lives. [3:23:57] Your time has concluded. [3:24:03] Omar, if you can please on you [3:24:04] . [3:24:04] >> Thanks. [3:24:05] I'd like to apologize to all [3:24:06] the police officers in the room [3:24:10] here having to take this woke [3:24:10] mob lecture And you got to [3:24:15] realize guys, there's hundreds [3:24:15] of thousands of San Diego guns [3:24:19] that stand behind guys that [3:24:20] want the best for you. [3:24:21] We're grateful that you're here [3:24:25] serving our community. [3:24:26] I think this is a good thing [3:24:27] for you guys to have these You [3:24:27] have the training now to use [3:24:31] them, not abuse them And these [3:24:32] guys might take it. [3:24:38] The council here might take a [3:24:39] knee to the wolf mob, the mobs [3:24:39] coming out of there. [3:24:42] This is going to be the first [3:24:43] knee they're going to take and [3:24:43] it's going to be more so I [3:24:44] don't realize you police [3:24:47] officers have families and [3:24:48] you're risking your life for us [3:24:53] and different times when you [3:24:53] interact with the police show [3:24:54] them your hands. [3:24:58] A lot of guys are angry at you [3:24:59] guys black guys. [3:24:59] They're angry that now if they [3:25:00] could learn to show the cops [3:25:04] their hands that's what they [3:25:04] want to see. [3:25:05] >> They don't want trouble. [3:25:07] Your time has concluded Next to [3:25:08] Santa Marina If you can please [3:25:13] unmute it's time to take [3:25:19] the cameras down. [3:25:20] The Senior Police Department [3:25:20] annual news report failed to [3:25:23] mention a 19 year old who was [3:25:24] shot in a car by a police [3:25:24] department. [3:25:25] The vehicle wasn't stolen. [3:25:29] We know our cameras are not [3:25:29] making San Diego safer. [3:25:30] How many more people need to be [3:25:34] hurt translates our [3:25:35] constitutional rights and puts [3:25:36] the safety of residents, [3:25:36] visitors and tourists in [3:25:40] jeopardy Tragically as deeply [3:25:41] as also use these cameras to [3:25:45] track the domestic violence [3:25:46] victim now a victim of mass [3:25:46] shootings too. [3:25:50] These cameras are being used to [3:25:51] track and set private citizens [3:25:52] going about their lives. [3:25:56] Please take the cameras out. [3:25:57] Alison, if you can please [3:26:01] unmute. [3:26:08] Oh, there you go. [3:26:10] Oh, counsel, I am Alison and I [3:26:11] live in District three and I [3:26:12] just want to echo what my peers [3:26:15] have said today that we expect [3:26:16] from you. [3:26:17] We demand from you that you not [3:26:21] only vote no tonight but that [3:26:22] you also begin today to remove [3:26:22] the cameras. [3:26:26] Do not let them stay up. [3:26:27] Revenue of them starting today. [3:26:28] Also we need to cancel [3:26:32] the contracts for smart street [3:26:33] lights and air drone [3:26:33] surveillance. [3:26:37] This is misused and abused in [3:26:42] our city every day and it is [3:26:43] unacceptable. [3:26:43] It continues to harm our [3:26:44] communities. [3:26:47] At a background in health care [3:26:48] and in health care ethics we [3:26:48] have an order of operations [3:26:52] under which we evaluate ethical [3:26:53] decisions. [3:26:54] First is to do no harm and then [3:26:58] to do good. [3:26:58] Some people here have tried to [3:26:59] argue today that pr technology [3:27:00] has some good in it. [3:27:03] I question that. [3:27:03] However, the fact remains that [3:27:04] you have not eliminated [3:27:08] the harm yet You have to [3:27:08] eliminate the harm first by [3:27:09] canceling Floc and removing [3:27:10] the cameras. [3:27:15] Starting today your time. [3:27:16] Anthony if you can please [3:27:27] unmute capacity Counsel My name [3:27:27] is Anthony Billows. [3:27:28] I am the co-founder of Beloved [3:27:30] Community Collective and [3:27:35] the cst. [3:27:36] >> I just want to say thank you [3:27:37] first and foremost to all of [3:27:40] the people who continue to show [3:27:41] up on behalf of community, on [3:27:42] behalf of those of us who are [3:27:45] more vulnerable Pana [3:27:46] specifically pillars of [3:27:46] the community. [3:27:50] I saw aclu that I've heard many [3:27:55] many people trust folks in [3:27:55] the Trust or cpi. [3:27:56] I just want to say thank you [3:28:00] again to all of those who keep [3:28:01] showing up and keep speaking [3:28:01] for people like me. [3:28:06] I want to thank Council member [3:28:07] ilo Shahani La Ribera for [3:28:08] actually leading this fight and [3:28:10] consistently being on the right [3:28:11] side of history. [3:28:13] I want to invite every second [3:28:14] city council member to live [3:28:15] through accountability in this [3:28:18] moment accountability to [3:28:19] the people that you pretend to [3:28:19] represent. [3:28:22] Accountability for those who [3:28:23] continue to harm and do not [3:28:24] want to be held responsible for [3:28:24] it. [3:28:28] Say no, no thank you. [3:28:29] >> Next is Maia If you can [3:28:44] please unmute my you are in [3:28:44] muted but we don't hear you [3:28:45] here in council chambers. [3:28:45] Hear me now. [3:28:47] Yes. [3:28:48] Please proceed. [3:28:48] Okay. [3:28:49] Stability Who has to Who has [3:28:51] been here or who Where were we [3:28:51] three years ago when this was [3:28:52] being introduced? [3:28:52] We've been here. [3:28:53] We were there. [3:28:55] I was there when that pig Jeff [3:28:56] Jordan unraveled the scheme in [3:29:00] front of the community. [3:29:00] 193 weeks ago. [3:29:01] I was there when the Privacy [3:29:04] Advisory Board unanimously [3:29:05] voted against this technology. [3:29:05] And when the city council voted [3:29:09] for it anyway. [3:29:10] So we've been here, we have [3:29:11] been here, the community has [3:29:11] been here and we've been [3:29:14] against it and we've been [3:29:15] ignored this entire time. [3:29:18] And so I also find it really [3:29:19] disgusting that Marni von [3:29:23] Wilpert values the privacy of a [3:29:24] pig more than the thousands of [3:29:25] Americans or centurions that [3:29:29] have begged for years for this [3:29:30] to not be in place And they [3:29:33] haven't respected that. [3:29:34] The fact that you respect his [3:29:35] privacy more than all of us is [3:29:38] disgusting. [3:29:40] >> Seven 499 If you can please [3:29:47] unmute 7499. [3:29:48] >> But because I ski here I [3:29:50] read George Orwell's 1984 back [3:29:51] in the 70s when I was still a [3:29:55] relatively young teenager. [3:29:56] The most chilling aspect of [3:29:56] that book was the constant [3:30:00] surveillance by the state. [3:30:01] But at that time I pretty much [3:30:02] dismissed that future because I [3:30:04] realized that it would take [3:30:05] about three people working [3:30:08] eight hour shifts to watch just [3:30:09] one person's cameras every day. [3:30:09] And that's unsustainable. [3:30:13] But with the recent growth of [3:30:14] that equation requiring three [3:30:14] people to watch one person no [3:30:17] longer holds. [3:30:18] I am a conservative and I [3:30:19] support law and order but [3:30:23] massive balance is not the way [3:30:23] to do it. [3:30:24] Even worse, the city [3:30:27] continually turns government [3:30:28] functions over to private [3:30:28] businesses for profit. [3:30:32] As we've seen at the Torrey [3:30:32] Pines Blight report, that's a [3:30:33] recipe for disaster. [3:30:37] These cameras are a form of [3:30:38] high tech stalking. [3:30:38] Listen to Laurie Seldon, your [3:30:39] best givens and the people of [3:30:42] this city. [3:30:42] >> Take the cameras down now. [3:30:43] Thank you. [3:30:55] 1697 If you can please unmute. [3:31:02] Hello, my name is Jessie. [3:31:03] I'm a resident of District [3:31:03] three. [3:31:04] Premier asking the council to [3:31:06] cancel the floor contract I [3:31:07] thought did not keep us safe Is [3:31:08] an invasion of our privacy and [3:31:11] a waste of our money. [3:31:12] We send $2 million a year on [3:31:12] these cameras. [3:31:15] These money this money should [3:31:16] be used to invest in our [3:31:16] communities. [3:31:20] These cameras are frequently [3:31:21] incorrect and they put [3:31:21] everybody in San Diego at risk. [3:31:22] Please invest back in our [3:31:25] communities, not in mass [3:31:25] surveillance. [3:31:26] >> Thank you. [3:31:26] Thank you. [3:31:27] And Elliot, if you can please [3:31:32] unmute. [3:31:33] >> Hello. [3:31:37] My name is Sam Elliott and I am [3:31:38] deeply concerned by [3:31:42] the intrusion of surveillance [3:31:42] technology into our lives. [3:31:47] We are rapidly becoming digital [3:31:47] rather than human beings and in [3:31:52] the process we are losing our [3:31:52] right to privacy. [3:31:53] I urge you to vote no on [3:31:57] the continuance of a lpr [3:31:57] technology and I also urge you [3:31:59] in the coming year to vote [3:32:04] against drones as first [3:32:05] responders. [3:32:09] It's the same issue. [3:32:10] >> Thank you. [3:32:10] Thank you. [3:32:11] Next is drone. [3:32:14] If you can please unmute. [3:32:15] If you raise your hand after [3:32:15] the five minute timer we MAY [3:32:20] not be able to take you today [3:32:20] but you can definitely submit [3:32:21] any further comments. [3:32:23] The city clerk at San [3:32:23] diego.Gov. [3:32:23] >> And those will be [3:32:24] distributed. [3:32:24] John please proceed. [3:32:28] I gave it a hearing. [3:32:29] >> Hello? [3:32:30] Yes, we can hear you. [3:32:30] Please proceed with your [3:32:34] comments. [3:32:35] >> Can hear me? [3:32:36] Yes, we can hear you. [3:32:39] Okay. [3:32:39] I just want to say it's great [3:32:40] to see so many different people [3:32:43] You have young and old and [3:32:44] libertarians and democratic [3:32:45] socialists all speaking out [3:32:45] against this. [3:32:49] These are terrible idea. [3:32:49] I can't believe this was ever [3:32:50] passed in the first place. [3:32:51] They've got to be taken down [3:32:54] Yesterday and they've got to be [3:32:55] melted down Just canceling [3:32:55] the contracts Not not there can [3:32:59] be no more of this technology [3:32:59] under any name. [3:33:00] We can't trust the police with [3:33:00] the data. [3:33:04] We can't trust companies with [3:33:04] data. [3:33:05] We can't trust hackers to not [3:33:06] hack into it and take the data. [3:33:07] Thank you. [3:33:08] Thank you, Nancy. [3:33:12] If you can please unmute I can [3:33:13] you hear me? [3:33:13] Yes. [3:33:17] Please proceed. [3:33:17] Thank you. [3:33:18] Hi, Nancy Roller for district [3:33:18] three. [3:33:22] Thank you to the council member [3:33:23] for considering and changing to [3:33:27] oppose like in San Diego and to [3:33:28] Councilmember Eli Rivera for [3:33:28] all your work our data and [3:33:32] privacy are the real product [3:33:33] for Floc and all other pr and [3:33:36] surveillance companies. [3:33:37] I urge you all to vote to end [3:33:41] the contract today take down [3:33:42] all cameras and hardware, cover [3:33:43] the cameras and tell them and [3:33:47] resist any urge to settle for a [3:33:48] pause Suspension moratorium [3:33:51] Audit new lpr company or any [3:33:52] other status quo solution that [3:33:56] just continues the harm. [3:33:57] Please reject the alp pr use [3:34:01] policy No guardrails or [3:34:02] policies or boards or oversight [3:34:02] are sufficient to prevent [3:34:05] the misuse and harm of mass [3:34:06] dragnet surveillance in [3:34:11] the hands of police, feds and [3:34:12] tech corporation billionaires. [3:34:16] I would love to see an audit [3:34:16] but only an independent audit [3:34:17] as a postmortem has concluded. [3:34:21] My apologies 8700 if you can [3:34:24] please unmute 8700. [3:34:27] Hello? [3:34:32] >> Yes, please proceed. [3:34:37] You have you had unmuted and [3:34:38] now there you go. [3:34:38] Okay. [3:34:39] Are you still there? [3:34:42] Yes, please proceed. [3:34:43] That was my problem. [3:34:47] Joy Soon to my yes vote rests [3:34:47] on the pab. [3:34:52] They said yes to 53 of the 54 [3:34:57] technologies and no to continue [3:34:57] the alp use unless spv [3:35:01] strengthened its auditing and [3:35:02] cybersecurity related [3:35:06] procedures and improved how it [3:35:07] tracks pab recommendations. [3:35:11] If the pd has strongly honored [3:35:12] those recommendations, Dear [3:35:16] Chief Wall it looks to me yet [3:35:21] can you verify that the prb [3:35:25] the whole board voted Now and [3:35:26] approved all 64 technologies [3:35:31] including the continued use of [3:35:31] alp. [3:35:32] Ah so it's been a great [3:35:36] afternoon everybody who loved [3:35:36] hearing your voices and I'm [3:35:41] just looking forward to this [3:35:41] speaking I guess I hope [3:35:42] somebody can answer that [3:35:45] question for me Otherwise put a [3:35:45] pause on this matter will you? [3:35:46] We're not ready to vote yes or [3:35:47] no. [3:35:50] All time has concluded. [3:35:51] Leyla please if you can please [3:35:54] unmute. [3:35:54] >> Hello. [3:35:55] First and foremost I want to [3:35:59] thank Trust sd who saw [3:36:04] the issues beforehand Who under [3:36:04] stood what was at stake. [3:36:05] A collective of diverse people [3:36:10] who came together to protect [3:36:11] all of our privacy. [3:36:11] I want to thank Sonia Rivera. [3:36:14] I want to thank Henry Foster, [3:36:15] the third and Viviane Marino [3:36:18] who saw this issue initially [3:36:19] and voted on the right side. [3:36:19] Please do not renew their [3:36:20] contract. [3:36:23] Do not give them any more [3:36:23] money. [3:36:24] Turn off the Alpers. [3:36:25] Don't find a different way to [3:36:28] surveillance the people. [3:36:29] And let's get back to human [3:36:29] values, human dignity and [3:36:33] community building. [3:36:34] >> Thank you so much. [3:36:35] Next is Jamie Emerson. [3:36:40] If you can please unmute. [3:36:45] >> Good evening Council [3:36:46] PRESIDENT And council members. [3:36:46] My name is Janie Emerson. [3:36:50] I'm from Council District one. [3:36:51] Fear is a dangerous way to make [3:36:51] public policy. [3:36:55] Safety is a positive way to [3:36:56] make public policy policy and [3:36:59] it is your job. [3:37:00] As a senior I worry about my [3:37:01] husband getting lost. [3:37:04] These cameras are proven to [3:37:05] find and return seniors quickly [3:37:05] and safely. [3:37:09] As a grandmother I worry about [3:37:10] abductions. [3:37:10] Almost one year ago a young [3:37:14] lady was abducted by her [3:37:14] ex-boyfriend who threatened to [3:37:15] torture, rape and kill her. [3:37:19] She was rescued due to an ill [3:37:19] pr. [3:37:23] We need to keep everyone safe. [3:37:24] We need to address the fears [3:37:25] and concerns of all. [3:37:29] Let's get together to revise [3:37:29] the guardrails. [3:37:33] Technology is the future. [3:37:33] It is already here. [3:37:34] We need to embrace it and use [3:37:38] it positive. [3:37:39] We make technology a way of [3:37:44] keeping everybody safe in San [3:37:44] Diego. [3:37:44] Thank you. [3:37:45] Thank you, Nancy. [3:37:47] Nancy Berman, if you can please [3:37:50] unmute. [3:37:55] Hi, my name is Nancy. [3:37:56] I'm a mother to two small [3:37:57] children. [3:37:57] I live in District nine in very [3:38:01] close proximity to numerous [3:38:01] cameras. [3:38:01] I care deeply about my [3:38:02] children, my family, my [3:38:05] neighbors and our collective [3:38:05] safety. [3:38:06] Because of that I urge you to [3:38:10] oppose the npr use policy and [3:38:11] the thought contract. [3:38:12] Take the cameras down and [3:38:15] delete the data constitution. [3:38:16] All rights are a critical [3:38:17] component to public safety. [3:38:20] Presumed innocent until proven [3:38:21] guilty is a cornerstone of our [3:38:21] justice system and cpd clearly [3:38:25] does not care. [3:38:26] Npr has flipped this on its [3:38:26] head as evidenced by our [3:38:27] neighbor who is separated from [3:38:29] his family and daily life [3:38:30] subjected to the cruelty of [3:38:30] jail for a month because of a [3:38:34] mystery. [3:38:35] And our other neighbor who is [3:38:36] shot in the shoulder without [3:38:36] hesitation by officers of [3:38:39] Pronto after another misread [3:38:40] likely violating police use of [3:38:43] force policy. [3:38:43] Public safety must go far [3:38:44] beyond protecting and tracking [3:38:45] down property and that should [3:38:48] certainly not happen at [3:38:49] the expense of people's actual [3:38:49] safety. [3:38:50] Thank you to the Council [3:38:53] members who've been champions [3:38:53] of the people those who have [3:38:54] also changed their mind after [3:38:58] listening and learning who will [3:38:59] be retiring on the right [3:38:59] included. [3:39:00] >> Gabriel Renner If you can [3:39:05] please unmute. [3:39:05] Can you hear me? [3:39:05] Yes. [3:39:06] Please proceed. [3:39:10] Previously a crime would occur [3:39:11] The police would investigate [3:39:11] and then collect evidence. [3:39:15] You've allowed that to turn on [3:39:16] its head by first collecting [3:39:19] evidence on all of us 24 seven [3:39:20] Then when a crime is committed [3:39:23] police search the evidence and [3:39:24] nobody asked us if we were okay [3:39:25] with changing that [3:39:25] relationship. [3:39:29] And just because you think we [3:39:30] need something doesn't give you [3:39:30] the right to make that final [3:39:31] decision. [3:39:34] Our demands are this number [3:39:34] one. [3:39:35] Permanent bans and removal of [3:39:39] all pr technology and other [3:39:40] creepy surveillance including [3:39:44] private apps that are found in [3:39:45] places like Home Depot or hoa. [3:39:48] Number two immediate stops on [3:39:49] all data sharing with ice and [3:39:53] other agencies. [3:39:53] Number three a community led [3:39:58] police oversight committee. [3:39:59] The people have been activated [3:40:03] and now we are watching you get [3:40:03] the out. [3:40:03] Oppose item 200. [3:40:04] Thank you. [3:40:04] Thank you. [3:40:08] Next is one on branding and [3:40:10] 1415 if you can please unmute [3:40:20] 1415 star six 1415 I can't I [3:40:21] mean for you you will have to [3:40:24] press star six to unmute. [3:40:25] >> There you go. [3:40:29] What's more chilling than [3:40:29] the surveillance from Orwell's [3:40:30] 1984 book is The Blind Trust [3:40:33] The People have in their [3:40:34] government Budget. [3:40:38] Thanks. [3:40:40] >> Next is d if you can please [3:40:48] unmute the d you cannot unmute [3:40:52] for you You have to There [3:40:52] should be a prompt that's [3:41:01] coming up for you to unmute [3:41:09] data Unmute Tim if you can [3:41:19] please unmute I, I want to let [3:41:20] Okay I want I want to talk [3:41:20] about how the distribution of [3:41:22] these cameras betray what [3:41:27] they're really for when it [3:41:27] comes to underserved [3:41:28] communities. [3:41:29] The only thing that I ever get [3:41:32] overserved by policing and [3:41:33] surveillance same with [3:41:33] the flock cameras. [3:41:36] >> I don't have any in my [3:41:37] neighborhood but [3:41:37] the neighborhood next to me [3:41:41] does take them down. [3:41:42] Don't replace them with another [3:41:42] contract. [3:41:45] Anything like that. [3:41:46] It is the police's job to do [3:41:51] policing, not to spy on [3:41:55] everyone And then we get upset [3:41:56] when the cops are policing [3:41:56] the cops. [3:41:57] That's really what I'm actually [3:41:57] like. [3:42:00] Not really that worried about [3:42:01] because they are supposed to [3:42:05] carry their their cameras [3:42:05] anyways. [3:42:08] But yes, it's called [3:42:13] the contract. [3:42:13] Our civil liberties are at [3:42:14] stake here. [3:42:17] Thank you. [3:42:18] >> And then our final speaker [3:42:19] is Rosie, if you can please [3:42:22] unmute. [3:42:23] >> Hello council members. [3:42:28] I'm a constituent in District [3:42:28] three. [3:42:31] I've worked in technology as a [3:42:32] software engineer for ten years [3:42:33] and I use air every day. [3:42:36] When I makes mistakes we cutely [3:42:37] call it a hallucination not an [3:42:37] error. [3:42:38] But if a human was [3:42:41] hallucinating on the job it [3:42:41] would probably be really [3:42:42] concerning and they might get [3:42:42] fired. [3:42:46] Air often makes mistakes. [3:42:47] The stakes are too high for it [3:42:48] to be trusted with surveilling [3:42:48] us. [3:42:51] We've already seen this in [3:42:52] action with people wrongfully [3:42:53] shot or imprisoned. [3:42:56] This technology will not keep [3:42:56] us safe. [3:42:57] Please vote no and take [3:42:57] the cameras down. [3:43:00] Thank you. [3:43:01] >> Thank you. [3:43:01] Thank you. [3:43:05] That concludes public comment [3:43:06] for today's item. [3:43:06] All right. [3:43:06] Thank you. [3:43:10] City clerk. [3:43:11] Thank you everybody that [3:43:11] participated here in person. [3:43:15] Thank you to everybody a [3:43:16] participant remotely and then a [3:43:16] special thanks for those of you [3:43:17] who have stuck it out for [3:43:20] the duration of the afternoon [3:43:20] and now into the evening. [3:43:24] So let's first thank our city [3:43:25] clerk and our city clerk team [3:43:26] for handling all the public [3:43:28] comment. [3:43:33] They always do a fabulous job. [3:43:34] >> It's not easy to manage that [3:43:34] many speakers but you did a [3:43:35] fabulous job. [3:43:38] I'm going to make one quick [3:43:39] comment for maybe the public [3:43:42] but maybe for my colleagues as [3:43:43] well. [3:43:43] We're doing the 2025 [3:43:44] surveillance report. [3:43:47] Those typically would come in [3:43:47] FEBRUARY. [3:43:51] They didn't obviously things [3:43:52] were being worked on. [3:43:53] I was patiently waiting to when [3:43:56] I could docket this item. [3:43:57] It was supposed to be heard by [3:43:58] Public Safety Committee That's [3:44:02] traditionally how we've done [3:44:02] it. [3:44:03] The Chair They are asked to be [3:44:07] direct docketed and now we sit [3:44:07] on the precipice. [3:44:11] We are about 30 days from when [3:44:11] the $2 million bill will come [3:44:12] due. [3:44:16] So we're in a moment here to [3:44:17] decide as a council what we [3:44:21] want to do going forward. [3:44:22] Go to that right around the. [3:44:25] That payment comes in [3:44:26] the second half of DECEMBER So [3:44:26] we're right at the edge of [3:44:27] making decisions that could be [3:44:30] very consequential from what we [3:44:31] heard from the public. [3:44:31] This item was not heard of [3:44:34] public safety committee. [3:44:35] It was heard at Budget [3:44:36] committee And so therefore I am [3:44:39] going to turn this first over [3:44:40] to the chair of the Budget [3:44:40] Committee. [3:44:44] Council member Henry Foster to [3:44:44] kick us off. [3:44:49] Sir. [3:44:49] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT [3:44:53] And thank you Chief Wall to you [3:44:54] and your team for the work on [3:44:58] this item and bringing the item [3:44:58] forward. [3:44:59] And of course MADAM Clerk, [3:45:03] thank you for your organized [3:45:04] efforts as always in getting us [3:45:07] through these large tough [3:45:07] items. [3:45:08] So with that San Diego's [3:45:12] experience with Flock continues [3:45:13] to raise serious concerns about [3:45:17] data security access, [3:45:17] accountability and [3:45:18] transparency. [3:45:22] Conflict of interest and [3:45:27] the liability of the technology [3:45:27] . [3:45:28] There have been multiple [3:45:28] breakdowns of trust by esdp [3:45:32] when it comes to the use of [3:45:32] this technology. [3:45:36] In JUNE 2025 we were notified [3:45:36] by dpd of a system [3:45:40] configuration error that [3:45:40] allowed other California law [3:45:41] enforcement agencies to search [3:45:45] San Diego's license plate [3:45:45] database. [3:45:46] This resulted in over 12,000 [3:45:49] searches conducted and that [3:45:50] access was not authorized [3:45:53] authorized under the city's [3:45:54] policies. [3:45:55] Second, as dpd separately [3:45:58] acknowledged sharing [3:45:59] information with outside [3:46:03] agencies and only once guidance [3:46:04] was received from [3:46:05] the California Department of [3:46:05] Justice did the department in [3:46:09] sharing of that data. [3:46:13] Third, there are real concerns [3:46:14] about the method in which [3:46:17] the contract between the city [3:46:18] and its vendor was put in [3:46:18] place. [3:46:19] Former sd pd captain Jeff [3:46:23] Jordan helped oversee [3:46:23] the city's surveillance [3:46:24] technology program and led in [3:46:27] the San Diego Police Department [3:46:28] selecting flock and move [3:46:29] forward with an exclusive [3:46:32] negotiating contract what is [3:46:33] termed as a sole source [3:46:37] contract by the city. [3:46:38] After retiring from sd pd he [3:46:42] joined Flock Safety as an [3:46:42] employee. [3:46:47] Lastly, there have been at [3:46:47] least two incidents here in San [3:46:51] Diego where an erroneous flock [3:46:52] identification was associated [3:46:55] with two wrongful arrest and in [3:46:56] another case an ill advised [3:46:57] shooting both of which are [3:47:00] currently in litigation. [3:47:01] This again raises serious [3:47:04] concerns about accountability [3:47:05] and consequences when [3:47:05] surveillance technology gets it [3:47:09] wrong. [3:47:10] And these concerns are not [3:47:14] limited to San Diego. [3:47:15] Across the country other [3:47:15] agencies are confronting [3:47:16] concerns about flock to data [3:47:19] sharing practices, security [3:47:20] safeguards and inaccurate [3:47:24] license plate readings. [3:47:24] These are not isolated concerns [3:47:25] about how one department [3:47:29] operates a camera system. [3:47:30] They are real concerns about [3:47:34] the technology The vendor and [3:47:34] whether the city can be trusted [3:47:39] to follow the law to comply and [3:47:39] enforce the safeguards put in [3:47:43] place by the Council. [3:47:44] >> We should not have to choose [3:47:45] between public safety, civil [3:47:48] liberties and the right to [3:47:48] privacy. [3:47:52] San Diego has deserved them all [3:47:53] . [3:47:53] We also need to consider how we [3:47:57] spend public funds. [3:47:58] Earlier this year I helped push [3:47:59] to eliminate funding for [3:48:03] the Smart street lights and [3:48:04] flock for this fiscal year. [3:48:07] In council the contract those [3:48:08] dollars could be spent to [3:48:08] support libraries, parks, [3:48:13] infrastructure and [3:48:13] the essential city services [3:48:17] residents rely on and invest in [3:48:18] real preventative public [3:48:18] safety. [3:48:21] For me this is about [3:48:26] accountability and a [3:48:27] responsible government [3:48:27] safeguarding the civil [3:48:31] liberties of all San Diegans. [3:48:35] >> When serious failures occur [3:48:36] ,city leadership has a [3:48:40] responsibility to respond. [3:48:45] Before I move on I do have just [3:48:46] a couple of questions. [3:48:46] >> One are the Alpine Smart [3:48:50] lights technology connected to [3:48:51] the same camera? [3:48:51] Or are they separate cameras [3:48:53] that can be removed [3:48:58] independently? [3:48:59] The hpr camera is a separate [3:48:59] camera. [3:49:03] There are two separate units so [3:49:08] one can do so One can be [3:49:08] removed and one would still be [3:49:09] remaining. [3:49:09] Absolutely Yes. [3:49:12] We can remove just the hpr [3:49:12] camera. [3:49:12] Okay. [3:49:13] And if you can help me to [3:49:14] understand what is the process [3:49:16] for ending the contract with [3:49:21] Ubiquiti and flock? [3:49:22] Thank you Council members. [3:49:23] I'll handle that one. [3:49:26] So currently we are would be [3:49:30] working with p and c and [3:49:31] the city attorney's office to [3:49:32] explore what ending our [3:49:36] contractual obligation would [3:49:36] look like depending on [3:49:37] the decision that is made [3:49:38] tonight by the Council. [3:49:42] So if the Council decides to [3:49:42] end both epr and smart street [3:49:46] lights and the entire contract [3:49:46] could be scrapped if [3:49:47] the council decides to keep [3:49:51] smart street lights and end [3:49:52] epr, then we could go back to [3:49:55] the vendor and negotiate what a [3:49:56] contract one application [3:49:57] process would look like. [3:50:01] Linda can you identify yourself [3:50:01] for the record? [3:50:02] >> Yes. [3:50:02] My name is Linda Winkler. [3:50:03] I am a community liaison [3:50:04] manager with the chief's office [3:50:05] . [3:50:05] >> All righty. [3:50:08] Thank you for that [3:50:13] clarification. [3:50:19] It does appear that in other [3:50:19] cities the when the contract [3:50:20] with Floc was terminated [3:50:22] discontinue the use of [3:50:27] the Alper software did present [3:50:32] additional problems as we found [3:50:33] out that the software and [3:50:37] equipment remained in use here [3:50:37] in San Diego. [3:50:38] Accountability and transparency [3:50:42] concerns with this technology [3:50:42] is not new. [3:50:43] We experienced misuse with [3:50:47] the gsa smart street lights [3:50:48] originally purchased for [3:50:49] parking only to find the main [3:50:51] use was by sd pd. [3:50:52] And when canceled the equipment [3:50:56] was left in place and [3:50:57] operational which I find [3:50:57] totally unacceptable. [3:51:02] >> With this documented history [3:51:02] we cannot guarantee that even [3:51:05] with the Alper system being [3:51:06] turned off that the technology [3:51:11] will not be even in error [3:51:11] restarted. [3:51:12] The only way to ensure we are [3:51:16] not using this technology is to [3:51:16] remove the cameras. [3:51:20] When my staff reached out to [3:51:21] ask about requiring [3:51:21] the immediate removal of flock [3:51:25] cameras in a council motion, I [3:51:25] was told that council does not [3:51:29] have the authority to direct [3:51:29] city operations. [3:51:30] MADAM City Attorney, can you [3:51:34] please speak to this? [3:51:35] Does the Council have [3:51:36] the authority to require [3:51:36] the removal of the cameras? [3:51:39] If not, why? [3:51:40] >> And who has that authority? [3:51:40] Thank you. [3:51:44] Council member The action [3:51:45] before you today is to [3:51:46] determine whether or not to [3:51:50] approve or modify or rescind [3:51:50] the use policy under the trust [3:51:54] ordinance If the Council takes [3:51:55] action to rescind the use [3:51:55] policy. [3:51:59] Use of the technology must stop [3:51:59] the question of how and when [3:52:03] and what procedures to remove [3:52:04] the camera. [3:52:04] Well the cameras will likely [3:52:09] require some coordination with [3:52:09] the vendor in purchasing a [3:52:10] contracting. [3:52:11] However, the trust ordinance is [3:52:11] clear that the use of [3:52:16] the technology must stop. [3:52:17] >> But the decisions and [3:52:21] the authority to direct staff [3:52:22] to remove said cameras if that [3:52:23] is the action that's taken here [3:52:27] today, Council does not have [3:52:27] that direct authority. [3:52:28] That is the authority of [3:52:28] the mayor's office. [3:52:29] Correct? [3:52:31] Okay. [3:52:31] Chime in here. [3:52:32] Criticize our mayor's office [3:52:33] depending on the actions today [3:52:35] if the council does move [3:52:36] forward with rescinding the use [3:52:36] policy, it is [3:52:37] the administration's position [3:52:41] to follow the Council's [3:52:41] direction. [3:52:42] So our direction testi pd would [3:52:45] be to engage with Ubiquiti and [3:52:46] flock to initiate removal of [3:52:46] the cameras. [3:52:47] I believe it's baked into [3:52:50] the contract that the vendor [3:52:51] will remove those cameras at no [3:52:55] cost to us And so depending on [3:52:55] how the action goes today we [3:52:56] would essentially shut off [3:53:00] the system on our end work with [3:53:01] the vendor and then by the end [3:53:02] of this week provide the City [3:53:04] council with a work plan of how [3:53:05] we begin dismantling the 500 [3:53:10] cameras citywide. [3:53:11] If I could just add to that [3:53:11] this is one thing with [3:53:12] the chief's office. [3:53:14] So if the council does decide [3:53:15] tonight that they want to vote [3:53:18] down acr within 24 hours of [3:53:19] council's vote, our vendors [3:53:19] will have already pledged that [3:53:23] they are ready to deactivate [3:53:24] the opa system and delete any [3:53:25] data that's held within it. [3:53:28] And then once that occurred we [3:53:29] have asked them to send us a [3:53:30] formal notification of fact [3:53:30] which we are happy to share [3:53:31] with the Council Should have [3:53:35] your decision tonight. [3:53:36] Okay. [3:53:36] Thank you for for that and [3:53:37] providing. [3:53:40] MADAM City Attorney that [3:53:41] clarification and also call to [3:53:45] I mean Lindsey thank you. [3:53:46] So with that council PRESIDENT [3:53:47] If you would be open to [3:53:52] entertain. [3:53:57] >> I'm sorry if you would be [3:53:58] open to entertain I would like [3:54:02] to bring forward for motions in [3:54:06] the order as summarized below [3:54:07] or as follows. [3:54:11] One First I would provide a [3:54:15] motion to address sub item b [3:54:16] use policy. [3:54:20] Second a motion to bifurcate [3:54:21] sub item a to separate smart [3:54:24] streetlights and note as sub [3:54:25] item c. [3:54:28] Third a motion to address [3:54:29] the balance of the city to use [3:54:33] policies presented as sub item [3:54:34] a and fourth and lastly [3:54:38] providing motion to address sub [3:54:39] item c Smart street light use [3:54:43] policy. [3:54:44] Yes we'll entertain your first [3:54:45] motion will then take a vote at [3:54:48] some point and then we'll come [3:54:48] back to you for the second, [3:54:49] third and fourth motions as [3:54:49] well. [3:54:50] Please proceed. [3:54:52] Thank you for that. [3:54:53] With the first action somebody [3:54:57] would be persue into San Diego [3:55:01] Municipal Code sections [3:55:01] 210.0106. [3:55:02] I would like to motion to [3:55:06] rescind the automated license [3:55:06] plate recognition use policy. [3:55:11] As part of this motion [3:55:11] the Council requests that its [3:55:12] decision to rescind a lpr [3:55:15] surveillance use policy be [3:55:16] analyzed by the city's [3:55:17] management team for Labor [3:55:20] relations to determine whether [3:55:21] the rescission requires a [3:55:22] notice to the city's recognized [3:55:25] employee organizations and [3:55:26] opportunity to negotiate [3:55:27] the bargaining bill Impacts of [3:55:30] the rescission under the Myers [3:55:35] melius Brown Act. [3:55:36] If notice Brown Act if notice [3:55:37] is required, the Council [3:55:40] further request that cities [3:55:40] management team provide [3:55:41] the required notice in return [3:55:42] to the Council at a later date [3:55:45] If there are any bargaining [3:55:46] impacts that need to be [3:55:49] addressed by Council. [3:55:50] That concludes my first motion [3:55:54] which it looks like we have [3:55:59] brought it up on the screen. [3:55:59] Okay. [3:56:00] We have a motion by [3:56:03] Councilmember Foster to rescind [3:56:04] the use policy for [3:56:04] the automatic automated license [3:56:08] plate reader recognition use [3:56:09] policy That was not very [3:56:13] eloquent. [3:56:14] So with that we will then go to [3:56:18] Councilmember Ella Rivera. [3:56:18] All right. [3:56:19] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT [3:56:23] And thank you to everyone who [3:56:23] presented police department. [3:56:24] Mayor's office City Attorney's [3:56:28] office who worked on this and [3:56:28] obviously all the members of [3:56:29] the public who've been working [3:56:32] on this for so long. [3:56:33] I want to start actually with a [3:56:33] question for everyone who's [3:56:36] here and that's just to ask [3:56:37] everyone who here wants to be [3:56:41] safe. [3:56:42] >> And I start with that [3:56:42] question because I think [3:56:43] there's been an unfair and [3:56:47] manipulative narrative that's [3:56:48] been applied to the many, many [3:56:48] people who've opposed floc and [3:56:49] automated license plate readers [3:56:51] over the years And quite [3:56:52] frankly to the people who in [3:56:56] this room who showed up and did [3:56:56] that. [3:56:57] They all want to feel safe. [3:56:58] We all want to feel safe. [3:57:01] This was never a fight over [3:57:01] whether San Diego should be [3:57:02] safe. [3:57:05] It was a fight over how safety [3:57:06] is a universal right. [3:57:10] It's a deeply personal feeling [3:57:11] and it depends on one thing [3:57:15] above all else and that's [3:57:15] trust. [3:57:16] And trust requires honesty and [3:57:20] transparency. [3:57:21] And when those things are [3:57:22] missing, people stop feeling [3:57:22] safe. [3:57:25] No matter how many cameras are [3:57:26] on how many polls or what [3:57:30] technology is being used. [3:57:31] Big tech has long bragged about [3:57:34] moving fast and breaking [3:57:34] things. [3:57:35] And I understand the appeal of [3:57:36] that for a scrappy startup. [3:57:39] But with great power comes [3:57:40] great responsibility. [3:57:40] And big tech has amassed [3:57:44] extraordinary power while [3:57:44] dismissing all of its [3:57:45] responsibilities. [3:57:49] Government can't and must not [3:57:49] do the same. [3:57:50] Because what ends up being [3:57:53] broken is public trust. [3:57:54] And public trust is essential [3:57:54] to our most important job. [3:57:58] Keeping people safe. [3:57:59] We are where we are because [3:58:03] the city refused to take [3:58:04] the advice of the Privacy [3:58:04] Advisory Board that we created [3:58:08] that we appointed experts to [3:58:09] and we bragged about as a gold [3:58:09] standard. [3:58:13] Rather than listen we moved [3:58:17] fast and we broke things. [3:58:19] To that point I have a few [3:58:22] questions. [3:58:23] Last year when we debated [3:58:28] the topic of maintaining [3:58:28] automated license plate [3:58:29] readers, it turns out that [3:58:33] the department had already run [3:58:33] a domestic violence survivor [3:58:34] survivor's license plate. [3:58:35] Was that use disclosed to [3:58:38] the council or the Privacy [3:58:38] Advisory Board in the annual [3:58:39] surveillance report? [3:58:42] No. [3:58:43] Why not? [3:58:47] In that case council member we [3:58:48] ran her license plate not [3:58:48] because she was a domestic [3:58:49] violence survivor. [3:58:51] We ran her license plate to [3:58:52] help corroborate the serious [3:58:57] allegation of misconduct by her [3:59:01] employee putting her and our [3:59:02] officer in the same location [3:59:06] would help corroborate [3:59:07] the allegation of serious [3:59:07] misconduct. [3:59:08] And that was the purpose for [3:59:11] running her plate. [3:59:12] Was that woman given an [3:59:16] opportunity to consent to that [3:59:16] search? [3:59:20] No. [3:59:21] When she called the San Diego [3:59:22] Police Department for help from [3:59:26] a for domestic violence, do we [3:59:31] think she at any point in time [3:59:31] thought that her police [3:59:32] department would be tracking [3:59:35] her car? [3:59:36] I doubt that went through her [3:59:40] mind when she called. [3:59:40] Has she been told that that [3:59:41] happened? [3:59:42] I have no idea. [3:59:47] Okay. [3:59:51] The department has said that [3:59:52] all of this was allowed because [3:59:53] the policy permits quote [3:59:56] legitimate purposes. [3:59:57] I'm curious under that reading [4:00:02] what use of this system would [4:00:02] not be allowed. [4:00:06] >> We have in our department [4:00:06] procedure a list of expressly [4:00:10] prohibited uses. [4:00:11] Personal use would be an [4:00:12] example indiscriminate viewing [4:00:16] of images and video would be [4:00:16] another example without having [4:00:19] investigative or administrative [4:00:24] need for discrimination [4:00:25] discriminatory practices [4:00:25] Harassment. [4:00:29] Those are some of the things [4:00:30] that are listed in our [4:00:30] department procedure. [4:00:34] So is the expectation that if [4:00:35] it's not explicitly listed as a [4:00:35] prohibited use that it's fair [4:00:38] game? [4:00:39] >> I don't know that I would [4:00:43] worded exactly that way but it [4:00:43] is very difficult to what if [4:00:48] scenarios because there are [4:00:49] there are endless the expressly [4:00:49] prohibited helps make it very [4:00:53] crystal clear where we can and [4:00:54] where we cannot use the system [4:00:55] . [4:01:00] >> Thank you. [4:01:01] So we've talked before about a [4:01:05] man who was jailed, a young man [4:01:06] who was jailed for weeks for a [4:01:07] crime a crime that was [4:01:10] committed five miles from where [4:01:10] he actually was. [4:01:11] We've talked with the 19 year [4:01:15] old who was shot riding to work [4:01:15] as a passenger after the fbi [4:01:19] database flagged his car. [4:01:20] His boss his car is stolen. [4:01:24] According to the legal team and [4:01:24] reporting on this, the owner [4:01:25] says that the car was not [4:01:25] stolen. [4:01:29] My understanding again is that [4:01:29] the alert came from an fbi [4:01:33] database and it pulls [4:01:34] automatically pulls [4:01:38] automatically from that. [4:01:39] What does sd pd require in [4:01:43] terms of confirmation with [4:01:44] the agency that enter that [4:01:44] information? [4:01:45] >> Sure. [4:01:47] First councilmember or license [4:01:48] plate readers put a vehicle in [4:01:49] that intersection at a date and [4:01:51] time. [4:01:52] It does not give officers [4:01:53] probable cause to make an [4:01:56] arrest. [4:01:57] Officers are still have [4:01:57] the responsibility for [4:01:58] procedure to investigate [4:02:01] the situation verify [4:02:02] the information through are in [4:02:06] cic which is the national crime [4:02:06] Information Center and [4:02:10] establish a basis for any legal [4:02:11] or legal basis for any [4:02:11] enforcement action. [4:02:15] >> Yeah I guess I'm asking what [4:02:16] we are doing to vet [4:02:20] the information that comes from [4:02:21] the feds. [4:02:21] It's a conversation you and I [4:02:24] have had on multiple occasions [4:02:25] . [4:02:25] How do. [4:02:26] What process do we use to [4:02:29] verify that What the feds are [4:02:30] telling the police department [4:02:30] is accurate? [4:02:34] So what I can tell you in that [4:02:35] case is that vehicle was listed [4:02:39] in the stolen vehicle system as [4:02:40] stolen. [4:02:40] That case obviously is under [4:02:41] litigation and there's a lot of [4:02:44] details that they cannot go [4:02:44] into. [4:02:45] But that vehicle was in [4:02:48] the system as stolen. [4:02:49] A lpr helped locate [4:02:49] the vehicle. [4:02:53] But still an officer's [4:02:53] responsibility to investigate [4:02:54] the situation, verify [4:02:58] the information through ncic [4:02:59] and establish any legal basis [4:02:59] needed for enforcement Action [4:03:02] must come first. [4:03:03] Is there a standard process for [4:03:07] verifying information that [4:03:08] the feds put forward to sd pd [4:03:11] before stb? [4:03:12] Pd takes action on [4:03:13] the information that's been [4:03:13] provided? [4:03:17] Well, it's run it's run through [4:03:18] r. [4:03:21] So in other words, if as if [4:03:22] the feds say this license plate [4:03:22] is associated with a stolen [4:03:26] car, we we verify that it's [4:03:27] that license plate number but [4:03:31] we don't verify that there was [4:03:32] any basis for saying that that [4:03:33] car was stolen. [4:03:33] Correct. [4:03:35] They're going off of what comes [4:03:36] out of a stolen vehicle system. [4:03:37] Do you think that this federal [4:03:37] government can be trusted [4:03:40] widely like that? [4:03:41] It's a very it's a verification [4:03:45] through our through the court [4:03:46] system, the California law [4:03:47] enforcement telecommunication [4:03:47] system. [4:03:50] It doesn't come back saying it [4:03:51] came from this agency or that [4:03:51] agency. [4:03:54] It comes back as registered [4:03:55] stolen in the system. [4:03:59] Thank you. [4:04:00] >> So I think all of these [4:04:01] cases share something that [4:04:04] should make everyone concerned [4:04:05] and that's that our justice [4:04:06] system rests on a very basic [4:04:09] premise and that's we're all [4:04:10] innocent until proven guilty [4:04:14] And Alpers seem to turn that [4:04:19] whole thing upside down. [4:04:19] The camera produces a hit. [4:04:20] There's an air of certainty [4:04:24] about the accuracy of that hit [4:04:25] and it seems like that lead [4:04:28] stops being a lead and actually [4:04:33] acts more like a verdict. [4:04:33] It doesn't seem like officers [4:04:34] are asking the questions [4:04:34] because they feel like [4:04:37] the machine has already answer [4:04:38] them. [4:04:42] And in Old Town, according to [4:04:43] the lawsuit that was filed, [4:04:43] evidence could have cleared [4:04:47] those men but that went [4:04:48] unchecked. [4:04:49] Or one of them sat in jail over [4:04:53] the holidays and then in a [4:04:53] separate instance a young man [4:04:57] with his hands raised was shot [4:04:58] and never charged with [4:04:58] anything. [4:05:03] I think that's the thing that I [4:05:04] find most dangerous about this [4:05:05] and it's the false confidence [4:05:08] that the technology produces [4:05:08] and a tool that treats people [4:05:13] as guilty until proven innocent [4:05:13] . [4:05:14] Doesn't make anyone safer. [4:05:14] Each of the instances that I've [4:05:18] referenced here and this entire [4:05:24] debate broke something. [4:05:24] We moved too fast and we broke [4:05:25] something Trust. [4:05:28] And we can start restoring that [4:05:29] trust today. [4:05:33] But that requires honesty and [4:05:34] honesty that just didn't work [4:05:34] the way we were promised. [4:05:39] And it also means removing [4:05:39] license plate readers from [4:05:40] approved technologies that not [4:05:44] oppose removal. [4:05:45] >> The cameras need to be off. [4:05:46] They need to be down and they [4:05:47] need to be the out of San [4:05:48] Diego. [4:05:49] >> And there's one last thing I [4:05:53] want to recognize about this. [4:05:59] This policy fight we've heard [4:05:59] from people of all ages, all [4:06:00] ages And I appreciate that. [4:06:04] And I'm very grateful for all [4:06:04] the advocates. [4:06:05] But some of the most persistent [4:06:08] voices have been from young [4:06:09] people who are the people most [4:06:10] fluent in technology and who [4:06:14] are also often the most [4:06:14] skeptical of it. [4:06:15] That skepticism is not based on [4:06:19] an irrational fear. [4:06:19] It's a rational fear that comes [4:06:20] from understanding exactly what [4:06:24] these tools can do. [4:06:25] The communities is asking us to [4:06:26] listen. [4:06:26] I'm glad we're taking action to [4:06:29] do that today. [4:06:30] And with that I Second [4:06:31] Councilmember Foster's motion [4:06:35] to rescind the lpr use policy. [4:06:35] >> Thank you. [4:06:36] All right. [4:06:36] Thank you. [4:06:39] Council member. [4:06:40] So we have a motion by [4:06:41] Councilmember Foster and a [4:06:42] second by council member Eli [4:06:46] Rivera to rescind the lp pr use [4:06:50] policy. [4:06:51] It's up on the screen and [4:06:52] council members have been given [4:06:52] a hard copy of that. [4:06:56] Next up council member Lippert [4:06:56] Thank you Council PRESIDENT. [4:07:00] Thank you to all of you who [4:07:01] joined us here in chambers this [4:07:02] afternoon and everybody who [4:07:06] joined us online as well to [4:07:06] share your perspectives on [4:07:07] this. [4:07:07] My district has the highest [4:07:12] density of the flock automated [4:07:12] license plate reader cameras or [4:07:13] Alpers. [4:07:17] >> It has been one month since [4:07:17] I announced that I now believe [4:07:18] the camera should come down. [4:07:23] I've received a lot of feedback [4:07:24] on my decision some supportive, [4:07:27] some critical. [4:07:28] Some of the criticism that I've [4:07:29] received is from members of my [4:07:33] own lgbtq community, [4:07:34] the community that I love and [4:07:35] that I work to support and [4:07:38] protect for the past 25 years. [4:07:38] We did hear from members of [4:07:39] the lgbtq community this [4:07:43] afternoon who said they want to [4:07:44] see the cameras come down but [4:07:44] others who want to see [4:07:48] the Alpers remain have pointed [4:07:48] out that Alpers had been [4:07:52] effective in solving hate [4:07:53] crimes against the lgbtq [4:07:53] community. [4:07:58] They are 100% correct. [4:07:59] Alpers have helped solve hate [4:08:03] crimes against the lgbtq [4:08:04] community and hate crimes [4:08:05] against other communities. [4:08:09] They have helped solve many [4:08:10] other crimes as well. [4:08:14] My view of the effectiveness of [4:08:15] Alpers hasn't changed. [4:08:20] What has changed is [4:08:20] the context. [4:08:24] When the City Council initially [4:08:25] approved Alpers three years ago [4:08:25] it was dubbed the Biden [4:08:26] administration. [4:08:30] A year later Donald Trump was [4:08:30] elected PRESIDENT. [4:08:31] The two years since have been a [4:08:36] living for too many families [4:08:36] in our city. [4:08:37] The Trump administration and [4:08:42] ice and their unAmerican [4:08:42] anti-immigrant brutality have [4:08:43] created a police state in many [4:08:47] of our communities. [4:08:47] People who entered the United [4:08:48] States legally are having their [4:08:52] authorizations revoked. [4:08:53] They live in fear that family [4:08:54] members will be snatched off [4:08:57] the streets by ice and [4:08:58] deported. [4:08:58] And many people fear the city [4:09:04] is Alpers are being used in [4:09:04] the effort to deport their [4:09:09] loved ones. [4:09:09] Are the city's helpers being [4:09:10] used for that? [4:09:14] No. [4:09:15] I am confident that they are [4:09:15] not. [4:09:16] I spent two years making [4:09:20] the point that our cameras are [4:09:21] not being used for immigration [4:09:26] enforcement. [4:09:26] But what I believe doesn't [4:09:27] change what our immigrant [4:09:32] communities believe in our [4:09:32] immigrant communities. [4:09:33] There is widespread fear of [4:09:37] the city's flock cameras. [4:09:38] I've had people tell me that [4:09:39] that shouldn't matter. [4:09:43] That if the immigrant [4:09:43] communities are fearful of [4:09:44] something that isn't happening [4:09:48] that that's on them. [4:09:49] I see it differently telling [4:09:50] immigrant communities not to be [4:09:54] so fearful. [4:09:55] It's like telling oppressed [4:09:55] communities not to be so [4:09:55] sensitive. [4:10:00] If we want to support our [4:10:01] communities we have to meet [4:10:02] them where they are. [4:10:06] My goal is to improve people's [4:10:06] quality of life. [4:10:07] You can't have any quality of [4:10:11] life if you're living in fear. [4:10:12] So let's remove one source of [4:10:12] fear. [4:10:18] It certainly would eliminate [4:10:19] the fear but at least the city [4:10:20] won't be compounding it. [4:10:24] Pity the immigrants who are [4:10:25] most fearful are not here today [4:10:26] for obvious reasons. [4:10:31] Many of them are native Spanish [4:10:31] speakers. [4:10:41] This year our state is all [4:10:42] about the garden. [4:10:43] As far as Gucciardo facilities [4:10:45] eat every steak muchos resident [4:10:45] This sincere party has [4:10:46] discovered that all racial [4:10:52] discrimination is on the other [4:10:52] side of a screwdriver special [4:10:57] This great thing to be able to [4:10:57] kill Obama for real. [4:11:08] We'll say as the ensue socotra [4:11:09] That's actually all there's [4:11:09] been letters that you that they [4:11:16] trumpet they control those in [4:11:17] the greatest band and lot [4:11:28] properties as the actual days [4:11:29] I'd rather be able to Seattle [4:11:36] and much as the somebody that [4:11:37] is you know what camp so stable [4:11:38] keyless locked up yet better [4:11:49] served with other scope of [4:11:50] party taste sexy on this is [4:11:51] Naspers notice of western [4:11:59] casinos so partly that western [4:12:00] committee that embarrassments [4:12:01] in theater seguros into [4:12:04] property of that very creepy [4:12:05] idea bit the upper garden [4:12:07] discovers you cats a la rattle [4:12:07] . [4:12:08] Now let me turn back to [4:12:09] the importance of solving crime [4:12:09] By turning off these cameras We [4:12:10] are giving up one crime [4:12:11] fighting tool that our city is [4:12:11] hardly without tools to fight [4:12:12] crime. [4:12:12] The three slot cameras have [4:12:13] been up for less than three [4:12:13] years. [4:12:14] San Diego has been one of [4:12:15] the safest cities in America [4:12:15] for decades. [4:12:16] Mind you we are not prohibiting [4:12:16] anybody else from having [4:12:17] cameras. [4:12:17] Businesses have had security [4:12:18] cameras for decades. [4:12:19] Police routinely request and [4:12:20] receive the footage from those [4:12:20] cameras when investigating [4:12:21] crimes that happen nearby. [4:12:22] Private security cameras help [4:12:25] solve a lot of crimes. [4:12:26] Businesses in Hillcrest added [4:12:26] cameras after a series of hate [4:12:31] crimes a couple of years ago. [4:12:32] We will only be getting rid of [4:12:33] the flock surveillance cameras [4:12:38] to anyone who might think of [4:12:38] committing a hate crime at [4:12:39] Hillcrest. [4:12:39] Know that there will still be [4:12:43] plenty of other cameras [4:12:44] recording what happens on [4:12:44] University Avenue and elsewhere [4:12:45] not to mention the fact that [4:12:48] most people have cameras on [4:12:49] their phones these days. [4:12:50] We have another very effective [4:12:54] tool against crime San Diego [4:12:55] police officers. [4:13:01] What we need is faster response [4:13:02] time so that when you call for [4:13:03] help an officer is there [4:13:03] quickly. [4:13:04] I have had constituents tell me [4:13:08] that they would feel safer if [4:13:09] they knew that when they called [4:13:10] back when one help would be [4:13:10] under way immediately. [4:13:13] That is why I would like to see [4:13:14] the money we save by turning [4:13:14] off the flight cameras. [4:13:15] Instead be used to speed up [4:13:18] response times. [4:13:19] We can improve public safety [4:13:20] without creating fear in our [4:13:20] communities. [4:13:26] Let's go to the surveillance [4:13:26] cameras and get people the help [4:13:27] they need more quickly with [4:13:30] faster response times. [4:13:31] >> Thank you, Council [4:13:31] PRESIDENT. [4:13:32] All right. [4:13:32] Thank you, Councilmember [4:13:36] Clyburn. [4:13:37] >> We'll go now to council [4:13:38] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee. [4:13:38] Thank you, PRESIDENT. [4:13:43] Thank you for the presentation [4:13:43] in chief and the team. [4:13:44] Thank you to my colleagues for [4:13:45] diving to this as well. [4:13:48] I do want to take a moment to [4:13:48] thank the Privacy Advisory [4:13:49] Board in recognizing that their [4:13:50] efforts are critical to [4:13:55] reviewing each of these [4:13:55] policies and not just the one [4:13:56] that we're discussing in this [4:14:00] motion but all 53 other [4:14:01] technologies that have been [4:14:01] discussed as well. [4:14:02] And also the members of [4:14:02] the public who have made these [4:14:06] conversations in the past I [4:14:07] think those of with been here [4:14:08] for these conversations [4:14:12] recognize that our opinions in [4:14:12] some cases have changed And [4:14:13] none of these conversations I [4:14:18] think in the past have ever [4:14:19] been easy. [4:14:19] And that's something I just [4:14:20] openly want to acknowledge. [4:14:21] I think each time that we have [4:14:25] discussed the use of technology [4:14:25] and where that balance is held [4:14:26] between trying to offer tools [4:14:30] that can assist the department [4:14:31] versus maintaining the civil [4:14:36] rights of our residents. [4:14:37] I think my stance has always [4:14:37] been to try to ensure that as [4:14:42] we explore any technology, as [4:14:43] we look at these policies that [4:14:43] we are always making every [4:14:44] effort to strengthen, improve, [4:14:48] refine and review those [4:14:48] policies over time. [4:14:49] And that also means recognizing [4:14:52] when the time comes that that [4:14:58] policy no longer makes sense. [4:14:58] We've made several efforts [4:14:59] under the trust ordinance in [4:15:00] the past to always look at how [4:15:04] tools can help to solve crimes [4:15:05] while also trying to balance [4:15:06] addressing legitimate concerns [4:15:10] that communities have when it [4:15:11] comes to surveillance and [4:15:12] technology itself and [4:15:16] the impacts it might have as [4:15:16] well as where the public's [4:15:17] trust is with how that data [4:15:22] might be utilized in 2023 and [4:15:22] 24. [4:15:23] I proposed adding additional [4:15:28] guardrails to policies that we [4:15:29] were discussing and that range [4:15:29] from strengthening data [4:15:30] protection security practices [4:15:34] to how we regularly update pd [4:15:35] trainings on the use of [4:15:35] technology and generally to try [4:15:41] to ensure that we practice [4:15:42] greater public transparency. [4:15:42] When this Council approved [4:15:45] the lpr use Policy 2025 council [4:15:46] PRESIDENT Lacob and I followed [4:15:47] up with a memo requesting that [4:15:51] cpd immediately undergo [4:15:51] the process to explore new [4:15:52] vendor options under a [4:15:53] competitive bid process. [4:15:58] And I know a year has passed [4:15:59] since that time and I think I [4:15:59] expressed at the Budget [4:16:04] Committee it's hard not to feel [4:16:04] that we've had little to show [4:16:05] in terms of progress on that [4:16:05] front. [4:16:09] And so in an era where the city [4:16:10] has faced continuously [4:16:10] challenging budgetary decisions [4:16:15] and we are fighting to [4:16:15] prioritize where our scarce [4:16:16] dollars are spent I did join my [4:16:21] colleagues this spring in [4:16:22] proposing that in this year's [4:16:27] budget we reallocate those [4:16:27] dollars instead to support [4:16:28] other needs. [4:16:28] And we've heard some of that [4:16:33] from the audience here today. [4:16:34] We heard that fight during [4:16:34] the budget discussions. [4:16:39] We were scrambling to restore [4:16:40] every last bit of library and [4:16:41] rec center hours, many of them [4:16:42] that still remain cut across [4:16:42] the city. [4:16:46] We talked about other public [4:16:46] safety needs that we were short [4:16:47] on that we needed dollars for [4:16:50] and could not allocate. [4:16:57] And ultimately although I think [4:16:58] we just have to acknowledge [4:16:58] that seniors remain more [4:17:03] fearful than ever of [4:17:03] the potential breaches and [4:17:08] abuse of technology and it's [4:17:09] impossible to ignore that with [4:17:09] the increasing overreach that [4:17:10] we've seen from our federal [4:17:14] government especially through [4:17:15] the increased presence of ice [4:17:16] even in recent weeks And I will [4:17:21] just share that We received [4:17:22] information from parents in [4:17:26] hours at our local schools just [4:17:27] this week about what they felt [4:17:28] was increased presence around [4:17:32] even our schools that [4:17:33] atmosphere absolutely has [4:17:33] changed. [4:17:34] And so as a result I do believe [4:17:39] it is this time that we have to [4:17:39] act. [4:17:40] And while those conversations [4:17:40] we've had in the past have been [4:17:45] difficult today that [4:17:46] conversation is not the choice [4:17:46] is not difficult for me. [4:17:47] I believe it's time to [4:17:51] prioritize the protection of [4:17:51] civil rights and liberties for [4:17:52] our residents. [4:17:53] I do believe it's time to [4:17:53] prioritize our limited public [4:17:57] dollars to protect the very [4:17:58] services and everyday public [4:17:58] safety needs that we have [4:17:59] emphasized for our communities. [4:18:03] And so I do absolutely support [4:18:04] the motion before us to rescind [4:18:08] the opioid use policy to [4:18:09] prevent the continued use of [4:18:10] these technologies for [4:18:10] the safety of all of our [4:18:11] communities. [4:18:15] And thank you again to [4:18:15] Councilmember Foster for [4:18:16] bringing this forward because [4:18:20] my council comments with [4:18:20] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee [4:18:21] will now go to Councilmember [4:18:21] Moreno. [4:18:22] >> Thank you And I'd like to [4:18:27] start off by thanking staff for [4:18:27] the presentation and also [4:18:32] thanking all of our speakers [4:18:33] here today that came to express [4:18:34] their viewpoints on this item. [4:18:38] A special thank you to [4:18:39] the Privacy Advisory Board and [4:18:39] all of the community members [4:18:44] who spent countless hours [4:18:45] reviewing this this technology. [4:18:51] Our officers need effective [4:18:51] tools to investigate crimes and [4:18:52] protect our neighborhoods but [4:18:56] at the same time our residents [4:18:57] also need confidence that those [4:18:58] tools respect their privacy and [4:19:03] that the city will protect [4:19:04] their information. [4:19:04] When we examine the track [4:19:09] record of Lux lp our System [4:19:10] I've always had deep concerns [4:19:10] about the security of [4:19:11] the city's data. [4:19:15] For District eight, immigration [4:19:16] and privacy concerns are [4:19:20] central to this discussion. [4:19:21] Residents should be able to [4:19:22] drive to work, take their [4:19:27] children to school and visit [4:19:27] family without worrying that [4:19:28] information about their [4:19:29] movement could reach [4:19:34] immigration authorities in [4:19:35] several jurisdictions across [4:19:35] the country, that data has been [4:19:40] improperly accessed by federal [4:19:40] agencies including for [4:19:46] immigration enforcement exactly [4:19:46] the type of misuse our [4:19:47] communities fear. [4:19:52] When this hpr system launched a [4:19:53] configuration error allowed [4:19:54] other California law [4:19:58] enforcement agencies to search [4:19:59] San Diego's lp for data. [4:20:03] Our cameras were included in [4:20:08] 12,914 searches over nearly [4:20:09] three weeks. [4:20:14] That incident was initially [4:20:14] omitted from the 2024 annual [4:20:15] report. [4:20:19] The 2025 report identifies four [4:20:20] suspected policy violations [4:20:25] including sharing information [4:20:26] with an Arizona police agency [4:20:31] after the sharing ban As [4:20:32] the cpd says those suspected [4:20:32] violations were not immigration [4:20:33] related. [4:20:37] And I would like to ask if dpd [4:20:38] can clarify what were the final [4:20:41] findings on the four suspected [4:20:42] 2025 hpr violations? [4:20:47] What information was disclosed [4:20:48] and what corrections? [4:20:48] What corrective actions [4:21:00] followed in Councilmember are [4:21:00] you talking about the internal [4:21:04] investigations? [4:21:05] >> Can you specifically know [4:21:09] there were four incidences in [4:21:14] the 2025 report four incidents [4:21:15] there was the three which were [4:21:16] focused on improper metadata [4:21:16] entry and then the one that was [4:21:21] the sharing with Arizona And [4:21:21] that was shortly after we [4:21:26] issued the department order on [4:21:27] the ban saying that you could [4:21:28] no longer share that [4:21:28] information with federal or out [4:21:29] of state agencies. [4:21:33] When we caught out we [4:21:33] immediately stopped access to [4:21:34] the system for that officer [4:21:38] reached out to them, talked to [4:21:39] them and then we did training [4:21:40] and we got him up to speed. [4:21:44] He was just unaware that that [4:21:45] had happened. [4:21:46] It was right on the edge of [4:21:46] that. [4:21:47] The other three were metadata [4:21:47] entry issues which we reported [4:21:49] out and they were investigated [4:21:49] by Internal Affairs. [4:21:55] Thank you for thank you for [4:21:56] clarifying this. [4:21:57] >> One of the things that just [4:22:00] sounds been seemed to me as a [4:22:01] person that has not been [4:22:02] supportive of the city of San [4:22:08] Diego using this data is that a [4:22:08] person in pd such as you [4:22:13] described right now would have [4:22:14] access to share If I had such a [4:22:19] if I had such a precious thing [4:22:20] as cpd thought of hpr as such a [4:22:25] precious thing I would have my [4:22:26] highest ranking official be [4:22:26] the only entity that could [4:22:31] approve sharing of this data So [4:22:32] I will share that That is [4:22:35] extremely, extremely concerning [4:22:41] to me. [4:22:42] So I have to just you know I [4:22:43] wasn't going to share that but [4:22:43] i have to share that with you. [4:22:47] Chief, because a lot of trust [4:22:48] has been placed on you and it's [4:22:51] like I said, it's just it's [4:22:57] shocking to me. [4:22:58] >> Concerns have been raised [4:22:58] regarding personnel misuse [4:23:03] incorrect plate reading and [4:23:04] monitoring of everyday life. [4:23:10] A driver should face an [4:23:10] unnecessary stop because of a [4:23:11] camera mistakenly identified a [4:23:15] license plate. [4:23:16] A city has a responsibility to [4:23:21] protect people's privacy. [4:23:22] The Privacy Advisory Board [4:23:23] recommended against continued [4:23:28] lpr use unless oversight and [4:23:29] security practices improve. [4:23:33] Now I recognize that sd pd has [4:23:34] identified investigations where [4:23:35] lpr helped but those benefits [4:23:40] must be weighed against [4:23:41] the consequences of [4:23:41] unauthorized access and [4:23:46] the loss of community trust. [4:23:47] Public safety depends on [4:23:47] residents feeling secure enough [4:23:53] to report a crime to seek help [4:23:53] and to cooperate with [4:23:54] the police. [4:23:55] Now as a council member for [4:23:58] District eight, I have a [4:23:58] responsibility to protect that [4:23:59] trust. [4:24:04] I have consistently opposed [4:24:05] the use of automated license [4:24:09] plate readers or helpers since [4:24:10] 2023. [4:24:15] I have voted against the use of [4:24:15] the system because I have [4:24:16] serious concerns about how this [4:24:17] technology is being used and [4:24:21] who ultimately bears [4:24:22] the consequences. [4:24:22] Today I have to say that I have [4:24:27] exactly the same concerns. [4:24:27] So for those reasons I will [4:24:28] continue voting against the hpr [4:24:33] system and I will support [4:24:34] the motion on the floor. [4:24:34] Thank you. [4:24:35] All right. [4:24:35] Thank you, COUNCILMAN Moreno. [4:24:39] I will go next to Councilmember [4:24:39] Camp. [4:24:40] You think it helps present [4:24:41] thinking members of the public [4:24:41] for your participation today? [4:24:45] Thank you to our police [4:24:45] department. [4:24:46] I supported automated license [4:24:47] plate readers because I believe [4:24:47] they could help to protect [4:24:51] victims and solve serious [4:24:51] crimes and make our community [4:24:52] safer. [4:24:52] In many instances that we've [4:24:53] seen that have been highly [4:24:56] publicized. [4:24:57] They have as far as I can tell [4:24:58] in my district in particular [4:25:01] those violent crimes solved [4:25:02] resolved issues for some of our [4:25:03] most vulnerable including [4:25:08] communities of color to help us [4:25:09] find the assailants of a murder [4:25:10] of Latino man in La Vista Linda [4:25:14] Vista Park. [4:25:15] That was a significant success [4:25:16] of the system and I made [4:25:16] the decision back then knowing [4:25:20] it would be unpopular and I [4:25:21] stood by it because public [4:25:22] safety is not about [4:25:22] the rhetoric. [4:25:23] It's about figuring out if it's [4:25:27] more efficacious than not. [4:25:28] It should be about doing what's [4:25:29] right for the people we serve. [4:25:30] In the delicate balance between [4:25:34] rights and safety, this balance [4:25:34] has been discussed since before [4:25:35] the Bill of Rights was passed [4:25:36] and it will not end today with [4:25:39] this vote. [4:25:40] As a former prosecutor I know [4:25:40] how much supporting evidence [4:25:41] can make can matter in cases [4:25:45] evidence that helps find a [4:25:46] kidnaping victim and connects [4:25:47] the pieces in a human [4:25:47] trafficking investigation. [4:25:51] Helps that young person and [4:25:52] data supports the testimony of [4:25:53] a domestic violence survivor [4:25:53] trying to get away from an [4:25:54] abuser. [4:25:58] Evidence that also can [4:25:58] establish someone's innocence. [4:25:59] I heard the concerns raised by [4:26:00] advocates and colleagues and [4:26:03] members of our community and we [4:26:04] heard troubling examples of [4:26:04] misuse. [4:26:05] >> And I was always clear about [4:26:06] what I where I stood. [4:26:09] Show me the evidence This [4:26:10] technology has been misused [4:26:10] here in San Diego. [4:26:11] I will revisit my position. [4:26:12] So now that this evidence is [4:26:16] here I meant what I said. [4:26:17] Learning that lawyers were used [4:26:18] to surveil a domestic violence [4:26:21] victim during an internal [4:26:22] investigation involving an [4:26:23] active duty officer, misconduct [4:26:23] was painful to read. [4:26:28] The implication that it was [4:26:28] just an administrative use and [4:26:29] therefore legally permissible I [4:26:30] believe is an overly broad [4:26:34] reading of the use policy. [4:26:34] But more importantly it misses [4:26:35] a key point. [4:26:35] If there's a backdoor to [4:26:39] surveil a member of the public [4:26:40] under an exception that broad [4:26:41] then there's really not a [4:26:41] protection in such a broad [4:26:46] reading or perhaps such a broad [4:26:47] application tells victims of [4:26:51] all sorts who are scared to [4:26:52] call the police for whatever [4:26:53] reason that MAY be that their [4:26:53] call for help could sacrifice [4:26:57] their expectation of privacy. [4:26:58] Victims of crimes have many [4:26:59] reasons to be afraid when they [4:26:59] ask for help. [4:27:03] We beg victims to ask us for [4:27:04] help so that we can protect [4:27:04] them from their assailants And [4:27:05] we beg victims to testify at [4:27:09] trials so that their assailants [4:27:09] can be convicted. [4:27:10] And the back door [4:27:11] administrative exception that [4:27:11] says anyone can be caught up [4:27:15] undermines so much about what [4:27:16] we've been told and frankly [4:27:17] what we've been told about api [4:27:21] usage in San Diego. [4:27:21] My responsibility has always [4:27:22] been to those people. [4:27:23] That responsibility is why I [4:27:27] initially supported Calpers [4:27:28] even when it was unpopular and [4:27:28] why I could not continue [4:27:29] supporting the item in its [4:27:29] current form. [4:27:34] I did not change my principles. [4:27:34] The facts before us changed. [4:27:35] When the facts change we have [4:27:39] to act in accordance. [4:27:40] Additionally and very [4:27:41] importantly we must acknowledge [4:27:41] the potential labor violation [4:27:45] here San Diego police officers [4:27:45] Association identified [4:27:46] the issue raising it to [4:27:47] the mayor's team and the fact [4:27:51] that the mayor's team agreed to [4:27:52] cease and assist in this use [4:27:52] tells us a lot about what's [4:27:53] happened here. [4:27:53] Clearly the administrative [4:27:58] exception while for the good [4:27:58] goal of disciplining an [4:27:59] officer's misconduct was not [4:28:00] something obviously agreed to [4:28:03] by labor union under the law. [4:28:04] I point out that in public [4:28:05] statements the chair of [4:28:06] the Privacy Advisory Board says [4:28:06] it's possibly allowable and [4:28:10] also the vice chair calls in [4:28:10] today and says it's clearly [4:28:10] not. [4:28:11] Clearly it's not clear at all. [4:28:16] And if that is the case, [4:28:16] the back door to surveil [4:28:17] the domestic violence victim [4:28:18] doesn't seem to me to be truly [4:28:21] allowable at all. [4:28:22] In other words, the ends don't [4:28:22] justify the means and the means [4:28:27] were not settled Practice. [4:28:28] If it was a potential breach of [4:28:32] labor regulations to surveil [4:28:32] the officer albeit one who [4:28:33] committed absolutely abhorrent [4:28:34] and significant misconduct, how [4:28:38] could it be allowable to [4:28:38] surveil an ordinary member of [4:28:39] the public? [4:28:40] And even if the administrative [4:28:44] exception had been properly [4:28:45] negotiated through the meeting [4:28:45] confer process? [4:28:46] How could one union have [4:28:47] negotiated away the protections [4:28:50] for members of the public that [4:28:51] aren't its members? [4:28:51] The union would never do that [4:28:52] and in fact the union could [4:28:55] never do that. [4:28:56] Chief, my question for you [4:28:57] because the public has been [4:28:57] watching this debate so closely [4:29:02] is that over the last year when [4:29:02] you've gone on television or [4:29:03] spoken to journalists in [4:29:07] defense of the program, did you [4:29:08] ever mention to the public or [4:29:09] to journalists that the api [4:29:09] could be used for [4:29:10] administrative purposes like [4:29:13] holding policemen's conduct [4:29:14] accountable? [4:29:14] >> Absolutely. [4:29:15] Did you ever mention [4:29:20] the individuals associated with [4:29:20] those types of cases could [4:29:21] possibly be caught up in that [4:29:22] surveillance as well? [4:29:27] Not specifically, no. [4:29:31] I have to say that the reading [4:29:32] of the policy that's been [4:29:33] pointed out over the last [4:29:33] several days. [4:29:38] The position that [4:29:39] the department has taken on [4:29:40] that reading I'm utterly [4:29:45] disappointed and Chief, I [4:29:46] expected more given how clear [4:29:47] several council members have [4:29:51] been about the fears we have [4:29:52] about this and the trust that [4:29:52] we put in you not just to [4:29:53] follow the rules but to see [4:29:57] the bigger picture of what [4:29:58] the public expectation was. [4:29:58] And I think that there is a [4:30:03] lack of humility in defending a [4:30:04] vague policy language in [4:30:09] the media When a labor union is [4:30:10] asking questions and [4:30:11] councilmembers are expressing [4:30:11] how their constituents are [4:30:15] confused and feel misled by [4:30:16] the policy language. [4:30:20] I just have to make one last [4:30:21] point because my faith in [4:30:25] the use of this technology is [4:30:26] so shaken but a lot of [4:30:31] the commentary today has [4:30:32] pointed at something else. [4:30:33] A lot of commentary today was [4:30:38] focused on the police [4:30:38] department writ large. [4:30:39] Chief, I have many more [4:30:44] questions about how we could [4:30:45] have allowed for the reading of [4:30:49] the language to go that far. [4:30:50] But a lot of the allegations [4:30:51] about the police department [4:30:52] writ large today were far from [4:30:55] true. [4:30:56] The misuse and misapplication [4:30:57] through the administrative [4:31:02] exception doesn't need to be [4:31:02] villainous for it to be [4:31:03] improper. [4:31:03] While I believe there was [4:31:04] misuse of this technology and [4:31:08] that accountability means [4:31:08] removing it from our use [4:31:09] policy. [4:31:09] Something was said that I think [4:31:14] is truly incorrect. [4:31:15] Someone said and I quote [4:31:15] The community I come from [4:31:16] doesn't trust the police and [4:31:20] they never will. [4:31:21] That's the end of the quote. [4:31:21] I think the broad brush of that [4:31:26] statement and the unqualified [4:31:27] denunciation of the police [4:31:28] something I find completely [4:31:28] unreflective of San Diegans as [4:31:32] a community even though since [4:31:32] last Thursday I've had a chorus [4:31:33] of people say Thank you for [4:31:38] holding the police department [4:31:39] accountable on this policy. [4:31:40] The vast majority of San [4:31:40] Diegans do approve of our [4:31:44] police officers because [4:31:44] the vast, vast majority of [4:31:45] police officers are great [4:31:45] people. [4:31:49] The person that was being [4:31:50] surveilled for their misconduct [4:31:50] obviously was not one of them. [4:31:51] The notion that communities of [4:31:56] color largely don't trust [4:31:57] police officers I understand [4:31:57] their feelings of mistrust. [4:32:02] But the notion of mistrust of [4:32:03] police officers writ large is [4:32:04] belied by the fact that while [4:32:04] communities of color might not [4:32:07] have the same levels of [4:32:08] confidence, the police can help [4:32:09] them in particular instances. [4:32:09] Communities of color [4:32:14] particularly I know in my [4:32:14] district especially in Linda [4:32:15] Vista they call 911 when [4:32:16] they're victims of violence at [4:32:19] very similar rates to other [4:32:20] communities because they want [4:32:21] similar treatment and they want [4:32:26] protection and they don't want [4:32:26] to be surveilled by the police [4:32:27] department when they call 911 [4:32:28] for help. [4:32:31] My constituents in District [4:32:32] seven have simultaneously a [4:32:33] deep level of respect and a [4:32:35] fair expectation of [4:32:36] accountability for our police [4:32:42] and rightfully so. [4:32:43] Council PRESIDENT By the end of [4:32:44] my additional three minutes you [4:32:47] are MAY I borrow two minutes [4:32:48] from my colleagues please? [4:32:48] I think everybody burned [4:32:49] the eight minutes and I'll [4:32:55] really do the same. [4:32:55] Yeah. [4:32:56] All right, I'll wrap it up. [4:32:57] I only have one and a half. [4:32:57] Well, six ounces. [4:32:57] Okay. [4:32:59] As a former prosecutor, I know [4:32:59] I couldn't do the job that our [4:33:04] peace officers do. [4:33:04] But also as a former [4:33:05] prosecutor, it's my job to [4:33:09] prosecute a case fairly and to [4:33:10] dismiss the case appropriately [4:33:10] depending on the evidence [4:33:11] before me. [4:33:11] And I see my position here [4:33:16] today largely in that same [4:33:17] vein. [4:33:17] Until last week I felt [4:33:18] confident supporting the alp's [4:33:18] use policy. [4:33:21] But with new evidence it became [4:33:21] my role to dismiss it today. [4:33:27] And my final point is this. [4:33:27] That evidence that I and [4:33:28] members of the public are [4:33:32] pointing out today relying on [4:33:33] the evidence to say let's stop [4:33:34] this usage to protect our [4:33:34] privacy rights that we all hold [4:33:37] dear. [4:33:38] It wasn't uncovered by some [4:33:39] random person. [4:33:39] It was uncovered and made [4:33:44] public by police officers. [4:33:44] I'll be in support of [4:33:45] the motion. [4:33:45] Thank you. [4:33:49] Council member Campbell. [4:33:50] Everyone has spoken so I will [4:33:50] jump in. [4:33:54] And as everyone knows, someone [4:33:55] who has voted at least three [4:34:00] times in support of your who [4:34:00] has spoken to some of [4:34:01] the individuals who spoke today [4:34:06] and or their organizations who [4:34:07] wanted me to vote no. [4:34:07] And to my constituents who [4:34:12] wanted me to vote yes. [4:34:13] I'm going to take a little bit [4:34:13] different path than my [4:34:14] colleagues in my comments. [4:34:18] What affects one part of our [4:34:19] city affects District One. [4:34:20] I thought about this in [4:34:22] particular last week when two [4:34:23] news stories broke One uc [4:34:23] Riverside determined that some [4:34:28] pollution from the Tijuana [4:34:29] River Valley migrates northward [4:34:29] the polluted air off the coast [4:34:30] of La Hoya. [4:34:33] The second has been repeated by [4:34:33] multiple folks. [4:34:34] The Federal Police Department [4:34:39] was using a lpr technology to [4:34:39] investigate their own police [4:34:40] officers. [4:34:44] We are all interconnected like [4:34:45] pollution from the sea on a [4:34:46] river valley. [4:34:46] We all face the consequences. [4:34:50] To those waking up to both [4:34:50] issues you can no longer ignore [4:34:51] the fundamentals that underlie [4:34:55] them. [4:34:55] They now hit uncomfortably [4:34:56] close to home. [4:34:56] Perhaps the awakening by some [4:35:00] is a good thing. [4:35:01] However, for me this is not how [4:35:02] we do public policy or take [4:35:02] public action. [4:35:07] One of the many conversations I [4:35:07] had was about the effect of lpr [4:35:11] within individual communities. [4:35:12] Today I reflect differently on [4:35:12] that context. [4:35:17] With the national elections [4:35:18] the real landscape of fear in [4:35:19] my opinion from those who stalk [4:35:23] our streets capturing decent [4:35:23] people, breaking up families, [4:35:24] snatching children, [4:35:28] disappearing individuals with [4:35:29] the national midterm results [4:35:30] there is now hope hope of not [4:35:33] having to wait two years, [4:35:33] perhaps only two months for [4:35:34] change. [4:35:34] Real change. [4:35:38] And perhaps then lives will [4:35:39] return to some level of [4:35:43] normalcy With that hope. [4:35:44] Lpr in my mind can now be [4:35:45] looked at differently. [4:35:48] So let me revisit how we got [4:35:49] here. [4:35:49] We started in 2023 at [4:35:54] the assumption of ipr in Smart [4:35:55] Street Lights. [4:35:55] My office worked literally [4:35:56] minutes before the public [4:35:59] hearing on the use policies to [4:35:59] make a critical change. [4:36:00] When the trust ordinance was [4:36:04] amended we fought for and [4:36:05] secured that use policies. [4:36:05] The very underpinning to [4:36:06] the ordinance would be under [4:36:10] city Council authority to [4:36:10] approve, modify or rescind that [4:36:15] authority was not in [4:36:15] the original language and there [4:36:16] was pushback The council should [4:36:17] not have such authority. [4:36:20] But as my office saw back then [4:36:21] and I think everyone [4:36:22] understands today [4:36:25] implementation with no controls [4:36:26] is a blank check. [4:36:27] As my colleague said a year ago [4:36:31] I joined Council PRESIDENT Pro [4:36:32] Tem Lee in calling for Flock to [4:36:32] be replaced. [4:36:36] We believed then the issue was [4:36:37] not the technology but [4:36:37] the vendor. [4:36:38] We approve the annual report [4:36:39] and use policy in good faith [4:36:42] with the department would [4:36:42] pursue a different vendor. [4:36:43] A year has passed and has been [4:36:47] said We have not identified an [4:36:47] alternative vendor. [4:36:48] We have not even issued a [4:36:52] request for information. [4:36:52] A critical step in finding [4:36:53] vendors. [4:36:53] I have been briefed on [4:36:57] the numerous improvements that [4:36:57] are made in a lpr operations [4:36:58] over the past three years. [4:37:02] The crime solved and that has [4:37:03] all been laudable. [4:37:04] Perhaps we indeed have the most [4:37:08] secure operation anywhere in [4:37:08] the country and the best [4:37:09] security of the data but [4:37:12] frankly the best in the nation [4:37:13] is not always good enough [4:37:17] especially when the climate of [4:37:18] our nation is full of cruelty, [4:37:19] danger and fear. [4:37:22] We had the burden of proof. [4:37:23] We gave every opportunity to [4:37:23] meet that burden But [4:37:28] collectively we fell short. [4:37:29] As early as last summer I [4:37:29] recognized that this tool was [4:37:33] no longer sustainable. [4:37:34] This past AUGUST I shared with [4:37:37] my constituents that it was [4:37:38] 5050 whether it would survive. [4:37:42] I will admit that I began [4:37:43] looking for alternatives or [4:37:44] variations that could preserve [4:37:44] the positive aspects of [4:37:47] the technology while minimizing [4:37:47] the downside. [4:37:48] Could be relocate the devices [4:37:49] from neighborhoods that didn't [4:37:52] want them To those who did [4:37:53] refrain I frequently heard that [4:37:57] would be costly and would not [4:37:58] be an effective use of [4:37:58] the technology. [4:38:02] And for me such relocations [4:38:02] also raised ethical questions. [4:38:06] In the past few weeks I thought [4:38:07] others might come forward with [4:38:07] alternatives but none have [4:38:08] emerged. [4:38:11] To be clear, I see no path in [4:38:12] preserving a law enforcement [4:38:13] tool that wants to meet [4:38:17] the needs of San Diegans and [4:38:17] yet cannot address very real [4:38:22] and very concerning issues. [4:38:22] So my colleagues have delved [4:38:23] into the details of what [4:38:26] rescinding the use of policy [4:38:26] means. [4:38:31] And I will interject that for [4:38:31] depending on what action we [4:38:34] take tonight, whether it is [4:38:35] the 750,000 associated with [4:38:40] the lpr and will cost or we [4:38:41] also vote to remove the cameras [4:38:44] and its annual total of 2 [4:38:45] million it is not going to help [4:38:48] us in the f y 27 budget. [4:38:48] It will be something that we [4:38:55] can talk about for f y 28 So we [4:38:59] need to wipe the slate clean. [4:39:00] And to me that means rescinding [4:39:04] both Alper and Smart Street. [4:39:09] >> That means rescinding two [4:39:09] use policies tonight. [4:39:10] And my colleague Councilmember [4:39:13] Foster recounted what happened [4:39:14] with the cameras. [4:39:15] Back in the day I still [4:39:19] remember that and that some of [4:39:20] the things that you inherit [4:39:20] that you were not responsible [4:39:24] for. [4:39:24] But it's a technology that [4:39:28] shares one device even with [4:39:29] the ability to deactivate [4:39:29] the flight cameras. [4:39:33] I believe we must start fresh [4:39:33] and show our residents we are [4:39:38] taking these concerns seriously [4:39:38] . [4:39:39] To me the conversation is over. [4:39:42] All that is left is [4:39:43] the concluding vote. [4:39:47] So with that I appreciate [4:39:48] the mayor and the mayor's [4:39:49] office that prepared for this [4:39:51] moment. [4:39:52] I think even the police [4:39:53] department in your abbreviated [4:39:56] presentation this afternoon [4:39:57] recognized where we were at [4:39:58] given the preponderance of [4:40:02] council members going forward. [4:40:05] I want to be confident that we [4:40:06] can do that 30 day notice that [4:40:07] we can trigger the provisions [4:40:10] that are already in [4:40:11] the contract with both Alper [4:40:15] which is the item that we're [4:40:16] first going to vote on and I [4:40:17] hope my colleagues will join us [4:40:19] in also voting to rescind [4:40:20] the smart streetlight [4:40:20] ordinance. [4:40:21] Excuse me. [4:40:24] Just a policy as well. [4:40:25] Let's make this a clean sweep [4:40:25] tonight. [4:40:29] So with that I'll conclude my [4:40:30] comments. [4:40:34] We have a motion by [4:40:34] Councilmember Foster and a [4:40:35] second by Councilmember Eli [4:40:38] Rivera that essentially [4:40:43] rescinds the Alper Youth policy [4:40:44] sub Item b. [4:40:45] With that no one else in [4:40:48] the lights please call [4:40:48] the vote. [4:40:49] >> I started the voting system. [4:40:58] Please cast your vote and that [4:40:59] passes unanimously with council [4:41:02] member Campbell and Ron Wilbert [4:41:03] absent. [4:41:03] Oh okay. [4:41:07] We still have more business to [4:41:07] do. [4:41:08] We'll go back to Councilmember [4:41:12] Foster for your next motion. [4:41:12] Yes, Thank you. [4:41:17] Council PRESIDENT And I do [4:41:18] appreciate the comments of all [4:41:21] of my colleagues on the first [4:41:22] item. [4:41:25] Um and so with that my next [4:41:26] motion as previously discussed [4:41:30] I would like to a motion to [4:41:35] bifurcate sub item a and to um [4:41:36] put us in a position to vote [4:41:36] separately on the smart street [4:41:37] lights. [4:41:44] Use policy as sub item c. [4:41:45] >> That concludes my motion. [4:41:45] Thank you sir. [4:41:49] So as shown on the screen we [4:41:50] have a motion by Councilmember [4:41:54] Foster to bifurcate sub item a [4:41:54] to vote separately on the smart [4:42:00] street lights use policy as sub [4:42:00] item c. [4:42:01] And we'll go to Councilmember [4:42:04] Ella Rivera to just second [4:42:04] the Motion council. [4:42:05] All right. [4:42:07] So we have a second and for my [4:42:10] colleagues we would circle back [4:42:11] with the third motion to vote [4:42:12] on the balance of the sub item [4:42:15] a So not seeing anybody on [4:42:16] the lights of Councilmember [4:42:20] Moran. [4:42:20] Thank you and thank you for [4:42:21] this motion. [4:42:24] I just want to be public. [4:42:25] I've always been supportive of [4:42:25] the street lights. [4:42:28] I've always made that [4:42:29] distinction. [4:42:30] So I will not be supporting [4:42:30] the motion on the floor. [4:42:33] Thank you. [4:42:34] All right. [4:42:34] Thank you, Councilmember Moreno [4:42:35] with that Again, we have a [4:42:39] motion by Councilmember Foster, [4:42:39] a second by Councilmember Eli [4:42:40] Rivera to bifurcate some item [4:42:43] made to vote separately on [4:42:44] the smart street lights to use [4:42:47] policy as sub item c clerk [4:42:48] Please call the vote. [4:42:50] I started the voting system. [4:43:01] Please cast your vote that [4:43:02] passes 6 to 1 with Councilor [4:43:07] Miranda voting no and Campbell [4:43:07] and vote are absent. [4:43:10] So for those of you this is how [4:43:10] we navigate the bureaucracy. [4:43:11] Okay Council member Foster [4:43:15] again. [4:43:15] Yes. [4:43:15] Thank you. [4:43:24] So now I will move forward with [4:43:25] the third action which is [4:43:28] moving sub some item a and I [4:43:29] will say is the balance of 50 [4:43:33] to use policies So with that I [4:43:34] would like to make a motion to [4:43:35] approve staff recommendation [4:43:38] for sub item a authorizing [4:43:38] the approved 52 department [4:43:42] surveillance use policies to [4:43:43] remain in effect under [4:43:44] the transparent responsible use [4:43:47] of surveillance technology [4:43:48] known as trust ordinance with [4:43:52] modifications as identified. [4:43:53] I'm sorry excuse me. [4:43:53] The Council further requests [4:43:57] that is decision to modify [4:43:58] the unmanned aircraft systems [4:44:02] us surveillance use policy [4:44:03] identified in the annual [4:44:03] surveillance report be analyzed [4:44:04] by the city's management team [4:44:07] for Labor relations to [4:44:08] determine whether [4:44:08] the modification requires [4:44:09] notice to the city's recognized [4:44:12] employee organizations and [4:44:13] opportunity to negotiate [4:44:17] the bargaining impacts of [4:44:17] the modifications under [4:44:18] the Myers melius Brown Act [4:44:22] Brown Act if notice is [4:44:22] required. [4:44:23] The Council further request [4:44:24] that the city's management team [4:44:27] provide the required notice and [4:44:28] return to council at a later [4:44:28] date if there are any [4:44:32] bargaining impacts that need to [4:44:32] be addressed by council. [4:44:33] That concludes my motion. [4:44:37] All right. [4:44:37] Thank you Council member Foster [4:44:38] And again in short order it's a [4:44:41] motion to approve the balance [4:44:42] of the surveillance use [4:44:47] policies in sub item a and will [4:44:48] go to council member Eli Rivera [4:44:49] to second council PRESIDENT. [4:44:51] All right so we have a motion [4:44:52] by COUNCILMAN Foster, a second [4:44:52] by council member Eli Rivera to [4:44:55] approve the balance of the 52 [4:44:56] surveillance use policies in [4:45:01] sub item a I don't see anybody [4:45:02] on the lights so Clerk please [4:45:02] call the vote. [4:45:03] >> I'm sorry of the voting [4:45:04] system. [4:45:08] Please cast your vote and that [4:45:12] passes unanimously 7 to 0 with [4:45:13] Campbell and Van Wilpert [4:45:13] absent. [4:45:16] All right We'll go back once [4:45:17] and final time to council [4:45:22] member Foster Thank you Council [4:45:26] PRESIDENT And for last action [4:45:27] this evening And again I [4:45:31] appreciate all the comments of [4:45:32] my colleagues is regarding some [4:45:36] items see smart street lights [4:45:41] and lastly persue it to San [4:45:45] Diego Municipal Code sections [4:45:46] 210. 0106I would like to motion [4:45:46] to rescind the smart street [4:45:50] lights surveillance use policy. [4:45:51] The Council request that his [4:45:55] decision to rescind the Smart [4:45:56] street light surveillance use [4:45:56] policy identified in the annual [4:45:59] surveillance report be analyzed [4:46:00] by the city's management team [4:46:00] for labor relations to [4:46:01] determine whether [4:46:04] the rescission requires notice [4:46:05] to the city's recognized [4:46:05] employee organizations an [4:46:09] opportunity to negotiate [4:46:10] the bargaining bill Impacts of [4:46:14] the rescission under the Myers [4:46:15] Mills Brown Act if notice is [4:46:19] required, the Council further [4:46:19] requests that city's management [4:46:20] team provide the required [4:46:21] notice and return to [4:46:24] the council at a later date if [4:46:24] there are any bargaining [4:46:25] impacts that need to be [4:46:29] addressed by council. [4:46:33] That concludes my final motion [4:46:33] . [4:46:34] All right. [4:46:35] So we have a motion by [4:46:35] Councilmember Foster to rescind [4:46:38] the smart streetlight [4:46:39] surveillance use policy. [4:46:39] We'll go to Councilmember Eli [4:46:43] Rivera start by second in [4:46:47] Council member Foster's Motion [4:46:48] This question's been somewhat [4:46:52] touched upon but I think it's I [4:46:53] want to dig into it just a [4:46:54] little bit more on this issue [4:46:57] and it's the way that [4:46:58] the policy decisions of [4:47:02] the Council will be discussed [4:47:07] publicly if you do depending on [4:47:07] the outcome. [4:47:11] But actually kind of regardless [4:47:12] of the outcome And I'm trying [4:47:21] to understand the way that in a [4:47:22] lot of it's in focus on on [4:47:26] Alpers but the reality is is [4:47:26] that the smart streetlight [4:47:27] conversation sounded almost [4:47:31] identical and and was nearly [4:47:32] identical even in the Privacy [4:47:32] Advisory Board recommendations [4:47:36] at the beginning. [4:47:40] And so this is actually more [4:47:41] for cota than for anyone else [4:47:42] or maybe Bethany I don't I [4:47:50] don't know but what is city's [4:47:50] policy on the policy advocacy [4:47:58] that is done within departments [4:47:58] ? [4:48:03] I'm trying to get the question [4:48:03] being department advocating for [4:48:08] their own policies or what [4:48:09] items they're bringing forward [4:48:09] to council. [4:48:10] Is that what you're referring [4:48:12] to Essentially Yeah. [4:48:13] What's the what's like the flow [4:48:17] of the directional flow of how [4:48:21] that works? [4:48:22] I don't think there is a [4:48:23] prescribed policy that either [4:48:23] prohibits or directs how [4:48:26] departments essentially drum up [4:48:27] support for their various [4:48:27] items. [4:48:31] I think every department has a [4:48:31] whole differing list of [4:48:32] stakeholders across the board [4:48:36] and how they choose to activate [4:48:36] that I think is sometimes done [4:48:37] in consultation with [4:48:40] the Council or the mayor's [4:48:41] office oftentimes or sometimes [4:48:42] done with their advisory boards [4:48:45] or they're just on their own. [4:48:46] But I don't think there is a [4:48:50] prescribed policy that dictates [4:48:51] or directs how departments are [4:48:52] supposed or not supposed to act [4:48:52] or engage. [4:48:58] Got it. [4:48:59] And I want to make sure that [4:48:59] I'm clear about this part. [4:49:03] I think it's important that [4:49:08] experts in our departments have [4:49:08] the opportunity to share their [4:49:12] perspective on what the impact [4:49:17] of policy decisions will be. [4:49:17] But I think there's a [4:49:18] difference between that here in [4:49:25] a policy venue and departments [4:49:30] going on campaigns to achieve a [4:49:35] desired policy outcome And I [4:49:36] worry about that for a couple [4:49:36] of reasons. [4:49:37] One, when it comes to public [4:49:40] safety, inevitably what that [4:49:41] leads to is people in [4:49:46] the public being told that if [4:49:46] the council makes a different [4:49:49] policy decision then no one [4:49:49] that the police department [4:49:52] wants they will be less safe [4:49:57] and they should be scared. [4:49:58] That's not how we make people [4:50:02] feel safe. [4:50:07] >> And two, I think it creates [4:50:08] a appearance of disorganization [4:50:12] and chaos with the city. [4:50:12] We are the policymaking body. [4:50:16] There's a role to play for [4:50:21] departments in providing [4:50:22] recommendations, expertise. [4:50:22] There's a role to play for [4:50:25] the mayor in that process. [4:50:26] But we're the policymaking body [4:50:31] and at the end of the day [4:50:31] the job on the operation side [4:50:36] is to implement and to perform [4:50:40] the job. [4:50:41] And so I want the council to [4:50:47] have an eyes wide open [4:50:48] understanding of what this [4:50:52] would look like if we make [4:50:52] the decision. [4:50:53] I'm supportive of the motion [4:50:53] obviously. [4:50:56] Should we expect a public [4:50:57] information campaign against [4:50:58] the decision that's potentially [4:51:01] going to be made by the council [4:51:02] today? [4:51:02] Should we expect a public [4:51:03] information campaign if this [4:51:06] motion is not successful but we [4:51:07] continue the effort to cancel [4:51:12] as well a smart city contract [4:51:16] but what should we expect? [4:51:17] Good evening Councilmember Ella [4:51:18] Rivera, Bethany Biggs Chief [4:51:18] Operating Officer What you can [4:51:21] expect is the facts coming from [4:51:22] operations as subject matter [4:51:22] experts. [4:51:26] The facts will come from [4:51:26] operations and with [4:51:27] the establishment of the Chief [4:51:28] Operating officers office and [4:51:30] my role what you can expect is [4:51:31] that any one of our teams [4:51:32] including the police department [4:51:35] will be speaking from a factual [4:51:36] basis and that will be what we [4:51:39] the expectation of we coming [4:51:40] out of my office. [4:51:41] >> I appreciate that Bethany [4:51:43] and I do really hope that that [4:51:48] is the case. [4:51:49] An enormous amount of resources [4:51:53] are provided to the police [4:51:54] department to communicate and [4:51:58] it was incredibly frustrating [4:51:58] over the past several weeks to [4:52:01] see those resources being put [4:52:06] into a policy argument with [4:52:09] this council And it wasn't [4:52:10] the first time that that [4:52:10] happened. [4:52:11] Two months ago Councilor [4:52:11] Whitburn brought forward a [4:52:15] policy change with respect to [4:52:15] towing I believe was an eight [4:52:19] one decision and that decision [4:52:19] was immediately kind of [4:52:20] dismissed by the police [4:52:27] department and again if we're [4:52:28] going to get the public to [4:52:29] trust us at a certain point [4:52:35] we're going to need to look [4:52:36] like we're going in the same [4:52:37] direction And that doesn't mean [4:52:38] we can't debate it up here. [4:52:40] But once the decision is made, [4:52:41] the decision is made And I [4:52:41] certainly don't think it's [4:52:42] useful to have fact versus [4:52:45] fiction. [4:52:46] Social media campaigns aimed at [4:52:46] the policymaking body of this [4:52:50] city so that I'll conclude my [4:52:51] questions and comments on this. [4:52:51] I'm again very supportive of [4:52:55] the motion in front of us and [4:52:55] appreciate Catherine Foster [4:52:56] putting forward. [4:52:56] >> Thank you. [4:52:57] All right. [4:52:59] Thank you Council members. [4:53:00] So we have a motion by Council [4:53:01] Member Foster a second by [4:53:04] council member Eli Rivera to [4:53:04] rescind the smart Streetlight [4:53:08] surveillance use policy and [4:53:09] we'll go next to Council [4:53:10] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee thank [4:53:13] yous PRESIDENT And thank you [4:53:14] council Mary Lou Rivera for [4:53:15] bringing that up. [4:53:17] I MAY be on my end. [4:53:18] I just sort of understand that [4:53:19] there are going to be moments [4:53:22] where this body or at least [4:53:23] even parts of this body MAY [4:53:24] differ an opinion from [4:53:27] the administration as a whole [4:53:28] And and we've seen that before [4:53:31] Maybe how we choose to levy [4:53:32] that with each other matters. [4:53:33] But in this particular case [4:53:36] especially in terms of how we [4:53:36] work with the public, I think [4:53:37] there's a difference between [4:53:40] policy disagreements and [4:53:41] straight up undermining folks [4:53:46] in the public And I think [4:53:46] that's what I if there's [4:53:47] anything I want to echo, that's [4:53:51] something that I want to make [4:53:51] sure that we try to avoid [4:53:55] moving forward on this item In [4:53:56] particular for me this is a [4:53:56] simple discussion in part [4:54:00] because we had this discussion [4:54:00] during the budget process as [4:54:01] well which is that at the end [4:54:02] of the day the city is faced [4:54:05] with difficult choices with [4:54:05] what we're prioritizing. [4:54:06] I think. [4:54:06] Council PRESIDENT You've [4:54:10] mentioned that it's not going [4:54:11] to be long again that we're [4:54:12] going to be facing an issue in [4:54:14] Mission Bay for example, and [4:54:15] that we still have libraries [4:54:19] and rec centers that at the end [4:54:20] of the budget process we were [4:54:21] not able to retain those hours. [4:54:24] And so as I do understand it, [4:54:25] it's been mentioned that [4:54:29] the cost savings that would be [4:54:30] achieved from the rescinding of [4:54:33] lpr use would be about 70 or [4:54:33] $50,000 I assume that's for a [4:54:38] full year And so I understand [4:54:38] that we're in a media cycle at [4:54:42] the moment and that the full [4:54:42] removal of the Ubiquiti [4:54:45] contract would be a savings of [4:54:46] $2 million. [4:54:47] One thing that has come up that [4:54:48] I do think is worth asking is [4:54:50] that it's been mentioned that [4:54:51] we're not going to see a [4:54:51] difference in this year And if [4:54:55] you want to understand that [4:54:55] because if if the actions are [4:55:00] taken today whether it's [4:55:01] Yelpers or Yelpers and smart [4:55:04] street lights and that contract [4:55:05] is ultimately terminated [4:55:06] because we have the ability to [4:55:10] do so it at the city's cause is [4:55:14] are the funds committed already [4:55:15] for the full year Is there not [4:55:16] a cost savings to be expected [4:55:19] in the current year Just to [4:55:19] clarify we make the payments to [4:55:20] you back here for the year [4:55:24] prior so if we were to make [4:55:25] the payment this DECEMBER come [4:55:28] in that would cover 2027 would [4:55:28] be that year. [4:55:29] So this year we've already paid [4:55:32] for this year in DECEMBER of [4:55:33] 2025 cover 2026 So we pay a [4:55:37] year in advance. [4:55:38] We're talking about calendar [4:55:39] year by fiscal year I'm talking [4:55:43] calendar year meaning this last [4:55:43] year we budgeted for this [4:55:49] the use of this technology for [4:55:49] the full fiscal year. [4:55:50] I guess I'll turn to the idea [4:55:50] if you if you have any [4:55:51] clarification Councilmember [4:55:53] I've got the capital on staff [4:55:54] to add additional clarity but [4:55:54] my understanding is that what [4:55:57] was budgeted in fy 27 was [4:55:58] essentially the $2 million [4:56:02] payment that is due mid-late [4:56:02] DECEMBER of this year. [4:56:03] So to the extent that there is [4:56:04] action taken before that [4:56:07] payment goes out to not have [4:56:08] that payment go out, those [4:56:08] would be current year savings. [4:56:11] But but please feel free to [4:56:12] provide additional clarity or [4:56:12] correct me if I'm incorrect. [4:56:16] >> Thank you Charles But could [4:56:17] you tell from the ideas office [4:56:18] Charles is absolutely correct. [4:56:21] So that upcoming payment for [4:56:22] the following fiscal year if it [4:56:25] is not made as a result of [4:56:26] the actions today there will be [4:56:29] that $2 million savings for [4:56:29] the general fund this fiscal [4:56:33] year fiscal year 2027. [4:56:34] Thank you for that [4:56:34] clarification. [4:56:35] I think that's an important [4:56:38] clarification for all all of us [4:56:39] to understand because there is [4:56:40] a fiscal impact at the end of [4:56:40] the day for folks who are not [4:56:43] familiar the council as a body [4:56:44] does not have the authority in [4:56:49] the mid-year to make [4:56:49] adjustments to the budget And [4:56:50] so all of that ultimately [4:56:53] handle is handled on [4:56:53] the administrative side And so [4:56:54] I won't have that argument [4:56:55] today on where those dollars [4:56:55] could be spent. [4:56:58] We've heard many options that [4:56:59] have been brought forward today [4:56:59] whether it is libraries, rec [4:57:03] centers, restrooms or even to [4:57:04] improve response times. [4:57:07] Certainly that is at [4:57:08] the prerogative of [4:57:08] the administration. [4:57:09] But I think for clarity that is [4:57:12] something that has a direct [4:57:13] impact on where we move forward [4:57:14] in this fiscal year. [4:57:18] So with that said, I'm happy to [4:57:19] support the motion that's in [4:57:19] front of us to within our [4:57:24] streetlights as well. [4:57:24] All right. [4:57:24] Thank you. [4:57:25] Council Excuse me Council [4:57:26] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee. [4:57:26] We'll go next to council member [4:57:27] Kip Thank you. [4:57:28] Council PRESIDENT Police [4:57:29] Department Is there any [4:57:30] component of the smart [4:57:35] streetlight that we present? [4:57:36] Basically speaking Smart Street [4:57:39] Light is recording visual [4:57:40] footage correct? [4:57:40] Correct. [4:57:45] Is any of that process through [4:57:49] any artificial intelligence [4:57:50] system or is it saved in a [4:57:50] database for just visual [4:57:51] review? [4:57:54] It's saved in a database. [4:57:55] It's just a basic video camera. [4:57:55] Okay. [4:57:56] And my understanding from [4:58:01] earlier is that removing of [4:58:02] the automated license plate [4:58:06] reader use policy means we can [4:58:10] take that out completely. [4:58:11] Flock will have no access [4:58:15] whatsoever to the actual [4:58:15] hardware. [4:58:16] >> That is correct. [4:58:16] Okay. [4:58:17] Yeah. [4:58:17] Two separate systems. [4:58:20] Okay. [4:58:21] So I'm in alignment with what [4:58:24] Councilmember Moreno said. [4:58:29] Seems that it has extensive [4:58:30] evidentiary usage. [4:58:30] The current use policy says [4:58:35] that it's only saved for 14 [4:58:42] days or 17 days 1313 and it is [4:58:43] utilized when a crime is [4:58:48] reported And it's believed that [4:58:48] that smart streetlight actually [4:58:52] observed the potential footage [4:58:53] of criminality, correct? [4:58:53] >> Yes. [4:58:53] Okay. [4:58:56] And last component is that [4:59:01] evidence is also a defense [4:59:02] attorney can request that [4:59:06] footage for exculpatory [4:59:06] purposes from our police [4:59:07] department as well, correct? [4:59:11] Yes. [4:59:11] Okay. [4:59:12] Because if we have evidence [4:59:13] that something didn't happen by [4:59:15] law we have to turn it over, [4:59:16] correct? [4:59:16] >> That's correct. [4:59:17] Okay. [4:59:20] Given that that is has any [4:59:21] exculpatory value to prove [4:59:26] innocent people innocent so to [4:59:30] speak and ultimately that it [4:59:31] does not have a connection to [4:59:31] an artificial intelligence [4:59:35] system like the Alper system [4:59:36] had And because I think that [4:59:36] the use policy for smart street [4:59:40] lights is much narrower than [4:59:41] what the lpr system was, it [4:59:41] seems that the heightened [4:59:45] concern over privacy is baked [4:59:45] in to that component. [4:59:50] So I will be in opposition to [4:59:55] the motion today and I'll stay [4:59:55] with that. [4:59:55] Thank you. [4:59:56] All right. [4:59:56] Thank you. [5:00:00] Councilmember Camp. [5:00:00] We'll go next to Council member [5:00:01] Whitburn. [5:00:01] Thank you. [5:00:02] Council PRESIDENT. [5:00:04] Just so I'm clear on the budget [5:00:05] savings, if we end smart street [5:00:09] lights as of essentially [5:00:09] the end of this year, [5:00:10] the budget savings in [5:00:12] the current fiscal year would [5:00:13] be $1 million, right? [5:00:16] Because we spent $1 billion [5:00:21] from JULY through DECEMBER from [5:00:22] the fy 27 budget but we would [5:00:26] not be spending the portion [5:00:27] from JANUARY to JUNE. [5:00:31] Is that correct or not [5:00:31] incorrect Council member You [5:00:32] would essentially be saving [5:00:33] the full $2 million if there's [5:00:36] a mismatch in between when [5:00:37] the payment goes out and when [5:00:37] the fiscal year starts. [5:00:41] But we budgeted for the full $2 [5:00:41] million payment that would [5:00:44] cover 2027 in fy 27 and that [5:00:45] payment would go out in [5:00:48] the middle to the end of [5:00:49] DECEMBER If council allows [5:00:53] smart street lights to continue [5:00:54] on that payment there are some [5:00:58] additional complications and [5:00:59] that the contract itself just [5:01:03] calls for Ubiquiti to provide [5:01:03] smart streetlights with lpr [5:01:04] technology or not unbundled. [5:01:07] However over the last week or [5:01:08] so I understand that the police [5:01:09] department has been in contact [5:01:10] with Ubiquiti to see if those [5:01:12] could be unbundled and that [5:01:13] Ubiquiti indicated that there [5:01:16] could be $750,000 in savings if [5:01:17] you just get rid of lpr but [5:01:21] keep the smart street lights If [5:01:21] you get rid of it altogether [5:01:22] you would still see a $2 [5:01:23] million savings in the current [5:01:25] year in future years going [5:01:26] forward. [5:01:26] Thanks for explaining that. [5:01:29] So the $2 million payment in [5:01:34] this being contemplated in [5:01:39] DECEMBER is that for f y 27 in [5:01:39] in arrears essentially or would [5:01:43] that be for fy 28 If we were to [5:01:43] continue it it would be a [5:01:47] payment in fy 27 for calendar [5:01:48] year 27. [5:01:48] >> Got it. [5:01:48] Okay. [5:01:52] Thank you. [5:01:53] I'm going to have some thoughts [5:01:56] but I'll I'll go through [5:01:56] the line up here. [5:02:01] >> Councilmember Moreno Oh, I, [5:02:02] I kind of felt like I kind of [5:02:03] opened the door about [5:02:06] the conversation so I don't [5:02:07] have any inside information. [5:02:07] >> So let me start with that. [5:02:11] But I didn't want to build an [5:02:12] expectation in the public that [5:02:16] we're making a fiscal decision [5:02:16] here. [5:02:17] We're making a value judgment [5:02:21] on the Alper and possibly [5:02:22] the smart street lights and we [5:02:26] should do it based on our [5:02:26] values. [5:02:27] My sense is we don't know [5:02:30] the status of the f y 2027 [5:02:31] budget And my sense is that [5:02:35] we're going to even though [5:02:36] we've made major strides of [5:02:36] eliminating the structural [5:02:37] deficit that we're going to [5:02:41] fall short in our f y 27 budget [5:02:42] and we will need to find how [5:02:48] we're going to make that up. [5:02:52] In addition to that, I [5:02:53] completely lost my train of [5:02:57] thought that there there MAY be [5:02:58] some costs with the unwinding [5:03:02] of the policy as well going [5:03:02] forward. [5:03:03] Oh that's what it was. [5:03:07] We dipped into reserves to [5:03:08] quote balance the budget. [5:03:12] I think we're 4 million 2526 [5:03:12] budget. [5:03:16] That's correct. [5:03:16] Okay. [5:03:17] And I think we're in the same [5:03:17] position. [5:03:18] So I'm very concerned about [5:03:21] predisposing where we would [5:03:22] spend that money And that's not [5:03:22] the conversation today But I'm [5:03:25] very concerned about promising [5:03:26] that we're going to fund [5:03:31] the bathrooms in Mission Bay or [5:03:31] the library hours or whatever. [5:03:35] Maybe we can get there in [5:03:36] the mid-year adjustments. [5:03:36] But I'm very concerned about [5:03:37] any making any promises to [5:03:40] anybody. [5:03:41] To me it's strictly a value [5:03:45] judgment on the use policies [5:03:45] and that's why I'm supporting [5:03:46] it. [5:03:46] And I would also argue since [5:03:49] Councilmember Moreno gave me [5:03:50] the floor it is still [5:03:50] surveillance. [5:03:54] You can still observe people. [5:03:55] You don't have the lpr which is [5:03:59] one tool that allows you to use [5:04:00] ai to proactively go track [5:04:03] things down but you can still [5:04:04] view to not only find out [5:04:09] somebody didn't commit a crime [5:04:10] of councilmember computed but [5:04:10] you can also identify [5:04:13] individuals and their behavior [5:04:14] by watching the videos. [5:04:18] So it is just an area that I [5:04:19] would prefer not to go into and [5:04:23] that's why I was supporting I, [5:04:24] I will be supporting this [5:04:24] motion but that's where I land. [5:04:25] So anyway, thank you [5:04:28] Councilmember Farina I'll turn [5:04:29] it over to you now. [5:04:32] >> Absolutely Think you can [5:04:33] staff address whether [5:04:34] the contracts were signed [5:04:38] separately? [5:04:38] Ubiquiti And they were together [5:04:43] They were cobbled together but [5:04:44] I'm sure staff can respond. [5:04:44] >> Yes. [5:04:45] It was one single contract for [5:04:47] smart street lights with a lpr [5:04:47] technology. [5:04:48] Okay. [5:04:52] And if staff could also let me [5:04:53] know in regards to smart street [5:04:57] light cameras is can they be [5:04:58] accessed by other agencies and [5:05:03] or immigration know our agency [5:05:07] on security only our agency can [5:05:07] access it. [5:05:08] Okay wonderful. [5:05:08] Thank you for that. [5:05:12] My position has been consistent [5:05:16] since 20 gosh since 2023. [5:05:21] The reason why I voted no. [5:05:26] Many of the reasons why voted [5:05:26] one of the reasons why I voted [5:05:26] no on this was because of [5:05:26] the cobbling together of [5:05:29] the contract but to me [5:05:30] the benefits of the street [5:05:31] light cameras and solving [5:05:35] crimes is undeniable. [5:05:35] In 2019 Maribel Marino Ibanez [5:05:40] was tragically murdered at her [5:05:40] workplace the church's chicken [5:05:44] in Otay Mesa Nestor. [5:05:45] Without that footage from [5:05:46] streetlight cameras it would [5:05:49] have been impossible for sd pd [5:05:50] to solve that particular crime [5:05:54] With this technology. [5:05:55] Her murder was found arrested [5:05:58] in the 70s, sentenced to 146 [5:05:59] years to life in prison And I [5:06:03] personally cannot look at MISS [5:06:04] Maribel Moreno Ibanez family [5:06:07] and tell them that I voted [5:06:08] against this. [5:06:09] So I still stand in my position [5:06:09] and voting no against [5:06:13] the motion before us today. [5:06:13] Thank you. [5:06:14] All right. [5:06:14] Thank you, Councilmember [5:06:15] Murray. [5:06:15] And again, thank you for giving [5:06:16] me time. [5:06:20] Councilmember Foster Yes, thank [5:06:20] you. [5:06:24] And just wanted to get some [5:06:29] clarification because I, I find [5:06:29] it difficult when we use terms [5:06:34] such as impossible. [5:06:35] I'm not sure that we can all [5:06:38] sit here and say that a crime [5:06:39] would not have been solved or [5:06:39] would be impossible to solve [5:06:43] without per se a camera No [5:06:48] matter if it's a camera that's [5:06:49] owned by the city of San Diego [5:06:54] or a camera that is owned by a [5:06:54] store that has their own [5:06:57] surveillance, a convenience [5:06:58] store or a home that has their [5:07:02] own surveillance And um, I [5:07:07] guess I'd like to ask you as we [5:07:11] talked about the license plate [5:07:12] readers and as we talked about [5:07:14] just a single instance of a [5:07:19] domestic violence victim [5:07:23] finding themselves being [5:07:24] monitored through that system, [5:07:29] I would assume as these cameras [5:07:30] are I don't know are they [5:07:30] attached or separate cameras? [5:07:34] But I'd like to think that they [5:07:34] are in the same locations per [5:07:39] se because I think it's been [5:07:40] pretty clear that the license [5:07:43] plate readers do not pick up [5:07:44] who's actually driving [5:07:44] the vehicle. [5:07:48] But I think the smart street [5:07:53] lights do provide a connection [5:07:54] point of some sort as we are [5:07:58] talking about an investigation [5:07:58] . [5:08:02] So I say that to say what would [5:08:03] prevent is there anything [5:08:04] provisions or something [5:08:08] different that I don't see or [5:08:08] don't know that would prevent [5:08:12] where there is a backstop that [5:08:13] says hey for the smart street [5:08:17] for the smart street light, I'm [5:08:26] assuming we would have the same [5:08:27] I don't know if I want to call [5:08:28] it. [5:08:28] >> I also say misstep of [5:08:31] surveillance or using that [5:08:35] device to surveil a domestic [5:08:36] violent violence victim in [5:08:41] the same manner that [5:08:42] the license plate readers are [5:08:42] used. [5:08:43] >> Would you agree Would you [5:08:47] agree, Councilmember I'm not [5:08:50] not here to debate our current [5:08:51] department procedure. [5:08:52] I understand the intent of what [5:08:54] council is trying to accomplish [5:08:58] here. [5:09:02] I am open to an approach that [5:09:03] is acceptable with council on [5:09:08] when and where we could use [5:09:12] smart street cameras moving [5:09:12] forward. [5:09:13] If that is on the table I can [5:09:17] tell you that any time putting [5:09:23] a vehicle or a person in an [5:09:24] intersection at a date and time [5:09:28] that benefits a prosecution, I [5:09:28] would see that as an acceptable [5:09:33] use whether it's a member of [5:09:33] the public or one of my police [5:09:37] officers that is behaving in [5:09:45] such an egregious way And I [5:09:50] appreciate that. [5:09:54] But based on the devices [5:09:55] themselves and their [5:09:59] capabilities and the same [5:10:04] misstep that occurred [5:10:05] specifically with the domestic [5:10:09] violence victim, I could also [5:10:10] find ourselves in that same [5:10:12] circumstance with the street [5:10:17] light cameras. [5:10:18] COUNCILMAN Wright, I would [5:10:18] disagree that there's a misstep [5:10:22] there. [5:10:23] >> I understand your concern [5:10:23] But let's let's take out [5:10:27] the term misstep. [5:10:28] Let's say use Right. [5:10:29] I think you could use that same [5:10:32] that that smart street light to [5:10:38] identify the car to be in that [5:10:41] specific case. [5:10:42] Right. [5:10:42] Or instance. [5:10:42] Yes. [5:10:43] On what was discussed that you [5:10:46] could use that smart street [5:10:46] light in regards to that [5:10:49] domestic violence victim as [5:10:54] well Correct. [5:10:55] If you're asking me could we [5:10:56] use the cameras, the video [5:10:59] cameras the same way that we [5:11:00] use the license plate reader [5:11:04] images under our current use [5:11:05] policy as well as under our [5:11:09] department procedure If it's [5:11:10] for an official investigation, [5:11:14] the answer is yes. [5:11:14] Okay. [5:11:14] Thank you. [5:11:15] But I'm open to I'm open to [5:11:18] modifications If that helps [5:11:18] council And I understand that [5:11:21] and I appreciate you being open [5:11:26] to those discussions but I [5:11:31] think that's why it's important [5:11:32] that this item came forward [5:11:36] today to also resend the smart [5:11:41] street light use policy because [5:11:42] at minimum that would give us a [5:11:43] pause that would allow you to [5:11:47] go back and figure out how you [5:11:47] can improve. [5:11:48] And I think it would also give [5:11:51] the privacy Advisory Board an [5:11:52] opportunity to come back and [5:11:57] opine on said improvements also [5:12:00] quite honestly achieve what is [5:12:01] very difficult for me is how [5:12:02] long these items have been in [5:12:06] place or how long we have been [5:12:07] working with the Privacy [5:12:11] Advisory Board and how [5:12:11] the Privacy Advisory Board in [5:12:12] my humble opinion their [5:12:15] recommendations have not [5:12:20] necessarily been what I would [5:12:21] say received by the San Diego [5:12:25] Police Department and I'm going [5:12:29] to say reviewed and analyzed in [5:12:34] good faith in regards to [5:12:35] the purpose and intent of [5:12:39] the Privacy Advisory Board and [5:12:40] ensuring that we are not [5:12:44] overstepping or overreaching in [5:12:45] what we are trying to [5:12:46] accomplish in regards to public [5:12:50] safety and per se negating our [5:12:53] civil liberties and things like [5:12:54] that. [5:12:55] So for me I think it's even [5:12:55] more important as you guys just [5:12:58] confirmed that the same type of [5:12:59] use would exist And I don't [5:13:03] know what happened with our [5:13:04] police officers in regards to [5:13:08] the Smart Street lights if that [5:13:09] was included in some type of [5:13:10] meet and confer scenarios as [5:13:12] well. [5:13:13] It wasn't agreed upon in [5:13:13] NOVEMBER of 23. [5:13:17] Okay. [5:13:18] I haven't seen that type of [5:13:22] data to to to confirm that But [5:13:23] I think the same issues that [5:13:23] concerns from my perspective [5:13:27] exist which is why I think we [5:13:27] why I wanted to bring this [5:13:31] forward here today and would [5:13:32] ask my colleagues to support [5:13:37] this item moving forward. [5:13:37] So thank you Council PRESIDENT [5:13:42] And I will conclude there. [5:13:42] All right. [5:13:43] Thank you Council member Not [5:13:47] see anybody else Council member [5:13:47] Ella Rivera All right. [5:13:48] Thank you. [5:13:48] Council PRESIDENT The only [5:13:49] other thing I was going to add [5:13:54] is my I have no doubt that [5:13:58] these can be effective tools [5:13:59] and that is part of why this [5:14:04] conversation has frustrated me [5:14:04] so much from the beginning. [5:14:05] But I'm going to go all the way [5:14:07] back to the beginning of 2023 [5:14:08] and it was that we didn't take [5:14:09] the advice of the privacy [5:14:12] advisory Board who was willing [5:14:17] to work with the department to [5:14:22] to get to Yes And until we So [5:14:27] we're going to scrap Floc and [5:14:31] with smart street lights I'm [5:14:32] not comfortable keeping them on [5:14:36] until I am 100% confident that [5:14:41] the experts who we have tasked [5:14:42] with providing us with that [5:14:46] expertise with respect to [5:14:47] privacy feels like our bases [5:14:51] are covered for the world that [5:14:52] we're living in now under [5:14:53] the policies that we have now [5:14:56] And there is another reality [5:14:57] that what we covered for this [5:15:02] in a certain way with [5:15:02] the passage of the Due Process [5:15:03] and safety ordinance we also [5:15:06] blew gaping holes in in this [5:15:10] city's privacy policy in [5:15:11] JANUARY of 2020 for when [5:15:12] advocates showed up here and [5:15:15] they told us be careful what [5:15:16] you do today because you don't [5:15:17] know who will be in federal [5:15:17] office in the future. [5:15:21] And so my vote in support of [5:15:25] this motion is not a vote in my [5:15:26] inability to see the potential [5:15:27] benefits of having cameras in [5:15:31] the community. [5:15:32] It's my inability to tell [5:15:36] the community that I can fully [5:15:37] that I am fully confident that [5:15:37] their privacy will be respected [5:15:44] and and the technology will be [5:15:45] properly used in a in a way [5:15:50] that I can assure them and I [5:15:51] can just I still cannot do [5:15:51] that. [5:15:52] And because of that I am [5:15:52] supportive of the motion in [5:15:53] front of us. [5:15:54] Thank you. [5:15:55] >> All right. [5:15:55] Thank you Council member So we [5:16:00] have a motion by Council Member [5:16:00] Foster the second by Council [5:16:05] member Eli Rivera to rescind [5:16:05] the smart street light [5:16:10] surveillance use policy Yes, [5:16:10] sir. [5:16:11] >> I'm sorry. [5:16:12] Just Chief, I just want to ask [5:16:13] just one more time I just want [5:16:15] to make sure with the smart [5:16:20] street lights it was brought up [5:16:21] in being confirmed with [5:16:22] the kiosk that that technology [5:16:26] could be used in in the same [5:16:27] scenario we find ourselves in [5:16:31] with the automated license [5:16:31] plate readers You're telling me [5:16:37] that does not exist in regards [5:16:38] to a councilmember? [5:16:38] What I can tell you is our [5:16:39] current department procedure [5:16:41] with rulemaking for process [5:16:42] under the prior chief in [5:16:43] the way and it was signed off [5:16:47] in NOVEMBER of 23 when I took [5:16:51] over in JUNE I'm sorry in JUNE [5:16:52] of 24 This was the existing [5:16:53] policy that's in place [5:16:57] conversations that occurred [5:16:58] back then I'm not aware of. [5:16:59] But what governing document we [5:16:59] utilize is our department [5:17:03] procedure And it's isn't it [5:17:03] that we can use it for official [5:17:04] law enforcement enforcement [5:17:08] purposes and for official [5:17:08] investigations in an internal [5:17:13] affairs investigation is [5:17:14] absolutely an official [5:17:14] investigation. [5:17:19] So if there's more specificity [5:17:20] that's needed, I'm open to that [5:17:21] But I'm certainly not going to [5:17:24] advocate for doing an [5:17:25] investigation an official [5:17:26] investigation on a member of [5:17:29] the public and not on one of my [5:17:29] police officers that's accused [5:17:31] of serious misconduct. [5:17:32] Understood. [5:17:38] Thank you. [5:17:39] >> All right. [5:17:39] Again, so we have a motion by [5:17:42] Councilmember Foster or second [5:17:43] by Councilmember Ila Rivera to [5:17:43] rescind the smart streetlight [5:17:48] surveillance use policy And [5:17:48] with that please call them [5:17:49] Please cast your vote. [5:17:59] I started the voting system [5:18:00] that passes 5 to 2 with [5:18:01] Councilmember Champion Council [5:18:05] over and over voting no. [5:18:06] Councilmember Campbell and [5:18:06] Councilmember Von Wolf are [5:18:06] absent. [5:18:07] Thank you. [5:18:10] Council PRESIDENT. [5:18:10] All right. [5:18:10] Thank you. [5:18:11] A city clerk Thank you. [5:18:16] The Department thanking all [5:18:17] staff that has worked on this [5:18:17] for so long. [5:18:18] Thank you to my colleagues for [5:18:21] a really, really good [5:18:22] discussion and questions. [5:18:26] So that will conclude item 200. [5:18:27] We need to do a little bit of a [5:18:27] time check. [5:18:28] Monday afternoon session has [5:18:35] not agenda public comment I [5:18:36] don't know how many people we [5:18:36] have in person. [5:18:37] It's always my first preference [5:18:41] to navigate that and whether we [5:18:42] have the appetite to stay for [5:18:43] virtual knowledge and public [5:18:46] comment. [5:18:47] So how much do we have in [5:18:52] person In person five in [5:18:57] person, six hands raised So let [5:18:58] me know before you somebody [5:18:59] else calls you out. [5:19:02] So okay it's only 22 seven with [5:19:03] outlets. [5:19:08] Oh excuse me, I got an [5:19:09] introduction. [5:19:10] We will now take up non agenda [5:19:10] public comment Council members [5:19:14] respect and appreciate [5:19:14] the public support and are [5:19:15] fully committed to protecting [5:19:16] every participant's free speech [5:19:16] rights at council and committee [5:19:20] meetings. [5:19:21] >> Clerk Please proceed with [5:19:21] the public. [5:19:22] Thank you. [5:19:24] Council PRESIDENT Pearl 2.7 on [5:19:24] Agenda Public comment is an [5:19:25] opportunity for members of [5:19:26] the public to comment on items [5:19:29] that are not on the agenda but [5:19:30] within the subject matter [5:19:31] jurisdiction of the City [5:19:31] Council. [5:19:32] Each speaker will have two [5:19:32] minutes. [5:19:36] Please note if there are eight [5:19:36] or more speakers on a single [5:19:37] topic the maximum time for [5:19:38] the topic will be 16 minutes. [5:19:38] If you're in chambers please [5:19:41] submit your speaker slip now. [5:19:41] >> Matthew Pendergraph if you [5:19:47] can please come up [5:19:48] the following speakers If they [5:19:49] can please come to the front [5:19:49] row. [5:19:54] Adina Flores Amy What and how [5:19:54] Daniel La Salle and allegedly [5:19:55] Audra please come forward to [5:19:59] the mic. [5:20:00] >> Matthew you'll have two [5:20:00] minutes. [5:20:01] Please proceed. [5:20:01] Hi everyone. [5:20:05] Once again Matt here and I just [5:20:06] want to touch on briefly [5:20:06] something that's come up [5:20:07] lately. [5:20:10] I'm just tired as everyone is [5:20:11] here and thank you all for your [5:20:12] work and your time. [5:20:12] So I just want to express my [5:20:17] utmost respect and appreciation [5:20:17] for Centro Cultural de la Raza. [5:20:18] So this is a really special [5:20:22] place for many of us here in [5:20:23] San Diego and it's a very [5:20:23] welcoming place. [5:20:28] I've been welcomed there for [5:20:29] years even in times in times of [5:20:29] conflict. [5:20:34] So lately there's been some [5:20:34] controversy. [5:20:35] I just want to highlight that [5:20:36] the central Courtyard de la [5:20:40] Rosa is being attacked for [5:20:41] the things that it's actually [5:20:42] what you would want a cultural [5:20:42] center to do. [5:20:46] So for example for being open [5:20:47] and welcoming to different [5:20:47] points of view for giving [5:20:48] the community freedom of [5:20:52] expression and for providing a [5:20:53] space for political dissidents. [5:20:54] So I just want to express my [5:20:59] utmost support for central [5:21:00] Courtyard de la Raza everything [5:21:00] that goes on there. [5:21:04] It's a beloved space and they [5:21:05] have a very accurate moral [5:21:06] compass so I'm standing up in [5:21:06] support of them. [5:21:11] Thank you very much. [5:21:11] Thank you. [5:21:12] Next is Adina Florence. [5:21:16] Adina, are you here? [5:21:17] I see No Adina Amy White at [5:21:17] home. [5:21:23] Amy Nobody's coming for Daniel [5:21:29] is all I see. [5:21:29] No, Daniel is all And allegedly [5:21:30] Audra, if you can come forward, [5:21:40] please. [5:21:40] So encouraging to see things [5:21:46] happen where the people's voice [5:21:46] is being heard and things that [5:21:52] the people want are being done [5:21:52] Although who knows if it's [5:21:53] political theater or not but [5:21:58] still I know, right? [5:21:59] It's always interesting to see [5:21:59] the way things work because [5:22:04] it's like is it really for [5:22:04] the people? [5:22:05] Is it not what technology is [5:22:10] going to come in and its place? [5:22:10] You know what I mean? [5:22:15] It's very, very interesting to [5:22:16] see things happen because it [5:22:16] doesn't seems like it's for [5:22:21] the people and the people will [5:22:22] buy it but it will be [5:22:23] interesting to see what happens [5:22:27] afterwards And again because [5:22:28] it's like all of the smart [5:22:34] technology that's out there is [5:22:34] very dangerous. [5:22:35] I'm not talking about [5:22:35] surveillance. [5:22:40] I'm talking networks. [5:22:41] Yes. [5:22:41] You know the boundaries. [5:22:42] Yes, I do. [5:22:42] That's why I'm saying smart [5:22:46] techno is very scary because I [5:22:47] feel like nobody really knows [5:22:51] the bounds to which it can go [5:22:52] and what it's really capable of [5:22:53] And I think that education [5:22:58] needs to happen before things [5:22:59] are implemented so that we [5:22:59] don't come down and face [5:23:04] certain situations again where [5:23:05] you're going to have to retract [5:23:05] it. [5:23:10] And I think that in people's [5:23:11] willingness or desire to be [5:23:15] like San Diego wants to be [5:23:16] the first at everything And so [5:23:17] it wants to go in and dive into [5:23:21] all the things that it probably [5:23:22] shouldn't do ignorantly because [5:23:27] we don't know what that is [5:23:28] capable of And I think until we [5:23:29] are fully aware of that we [5:23:33] should put a halt on any kind [5:23:34] of smart technology which would [5:23:35] go into like Midway Rising and [5:23:39] all of the technology that [5:23:40] could come in from Stan Kroenke [5:23:45] and his development. [5:23:46] >> So it will be interesting to [5:23:46] see what happens moving [5:23:47] forward. [5:23:51] Thank you for that Concluding [5:23:52] comment. [5:23:52] All right. [5:23:53] To be fair to my colleagues, we [5:23:57] have 13 people online So if we [5:23:58] can bear with there's six of us [5:23:59] here and five of us can stick [5:24:00] it out, we'll get that done and [5:24:04] not have to not have to worry [5:24:05] about it tomorrow So please [5:24:06] proceed with not agenda. [5:24:06] Thank you Council PRESIDENT I [5:24:07] put the five minute timer up [5:24:08] Blair Big moment if you can [5:24:13] please unmute I think wow I [5:24:19] didn't know my had to come up. [5:24:20] I can speak so soon. [5:24:20] Excuse me. [5:24:20] Hi. [5:24:26] Thanks for the big meeting. [5:24:27] Really interesting. [5:24:27] I wanted to comment You had a I [5:24:30] did a meeting last week. [5:24:31] I talked about the future of [5:24:37] Wall Street replacement and [5:24:37] what all that entails and thank [5:24:38] you for that. [5:24:44] I think we're trying to play on [5:24:44] the quarterly the numeric 20 to [5:24:45] work on She wants a better [5:24:48] picture that she can be fixed [5:24:53] in San Diego used to be a five [5:24:54] month period now it's like an [5:24:59] 18 month period and so that we [5:25:00] can better develop that San [5:25:00] Diego what we're gonna be doing [5:25:01] I think a lot of that [5:25:06] conversation has to be wrap up [5:25:07] thinking and the tech about [5:25:07] this all the smart street like [5:25:08] that I guess it's not going to [5:25:12] be there now so that will make [5:25:12] the process a lot easier. [5:25:13] Thank you for that. [5:25:20] I really hope you can come up [5:25:20] with a clear accountable policy [5:25:21] community how that you can [5:25:23] remove all of this tech You are [5:25:23] great today We got a lot more [5:25:24] to do so please be accountable [5:25:25] in the future with the public [5:25:30] on the project are slowly [5:25:30] leaving the tech What is it [5:25:31] going to be exactly? [5:25:35] >> To be honest I know I am and [5:25:35] I look foolish right now. [5:25:36] I offer some pretty basic steps [5:25:40] that I hope you guys can take [5:25:40] to heart if needed. [5:25:41] I also wanted to conclude with [5:25:47] Good luck with the county and [5:25:52] defer between police briefing [5:25:53] and the you know, the board how [5:25:58] that can work out, how you can [5:25:58] possibly be involved and be a [5:26:03] good role in the future of [5:26:04] sharing information with each [5:26:05] other and what that entails. [5:26:10] Today's meeting is important [5:26:10] step in better communication [5:26:11] and clarification that we all [5:26:12] need and how we move forward [5:26:18] together We're going to be [5:26:19] talking to each other in more [5:26:19] human terms to what we can be [5:26:20] doing. [5:26:20] >> Okay. [5:26:22] Your time has concluded 130 if [5:26:23] you can please on you in one [5:26:34] three one three you are unmuted [5:26:35] but we do not hear you here in [5:26:36] council chambers. [5:26:36] I'm sure the device you're [5:26:39] speaking in to me Clerk Okay, [5:26:40] sorry about that. [5:26:40] >> And before you start my time [5:26:41] where's the equity And you have [5:26:42] one speaker talking about [5:26:45] something touching based on [5:26:46] something then you have another [5:26:47] speaker for doing the exact [5:26:47] same thing. [5:26:51] It's just kind of like where we [5:26:52] come on. [5:26:52] Okay, I'll answer that. [5:26:53] Yeah. [5:26:56] Answer it. [5:26:57] >> I stepped away and went to [5:26:58] the restroom and I heard his [5:26:59] comments and they were totally [5:26:59] inappropriate for not agenda [5:27:03] public comment And I wasn't [5:27:03] here to interfere with that. [5:27:04] Audra, you were on point. [5:27:08] You got where you needed to go [5:27:08] . [5:27:09] That previous caller was off [5:27:09] base. [5:27:10] This is not a general public [5:27:10] comment. [5:27:14] Please do not talk about [5:27:14] surveillance or any aspect of [5:27:15] that on the rollout or next [5:27:15] steps. [5:27:20] So you were right. [5:27:20] >> I stepped away and I missed [5:27:21] that opportunity. [5:27:26] Thank you, Joe. [5:27:27] And you know what also great [5:27:28] performances today. [5:27:28] You all care more about saving [5:27:32] your own political careers and [5:27:33] saving the lives of people. [5:27:33] The conversation is not over. [5:27:38] Those of you who have voted for [5:27:39] the alp in the first place [5:27:40] still have blood on your hands [5:27:41] and some have even moved up [5:27:45] the political ladder like Marty [5:27:45] Where's the accountability? [5:27:46] You just say Well see we made a [5:27:46] mistake. [5:27:50] We're now going to act like we [5:27:51] learned our lesson and we're [5:27:51] now going to listen to [5:27:52] the people and pretend we have [5:27:56] no matter when actuality it's [5:27:57] the tax dollars that matter [5:27:57] most to the bloodsucking [5:27:58] parasites who work for [5:28:02] globalists. [5:28:03] I repeat you work for [5:28:03] globalists. [5:28:04] Stop lying because all of them [5:28:08] left over there. [5:28:08] I already know they all left. [5:28:09] Saving Face is the name of [5:28:14] the game keeping the people [5:28:14] believing in your system is [5:28:15] what it's all about. [5:28:19] And Sean you claim you care [5:28:20] about public safety. [5:28:20] You continue working for [5:28:21] globalists and their [5:28:21] controlling agenda. [5:28:26] You personally have so many [5:28:27] fooled You just stated you want [5:28:27] the council to have eyes wide [5:28:31] open while keeping [5:28:32] the taxpayers eye tightly shut [5:28:33] Everything you all do That is [5:28:37] how it's all executed. [5:28:38] It's entirely sickening to [5:28:43] witness with my eyes wide open [5:28:44] but that feeling doesn't [5:28:44] discourage me. [5:28:45] I swear to GOD it actually [5:28:46] fueled me to make sure [5:28:50] the people know what you all [5:28:50] are really doing. [5:28:51] It's self-serving not public [5:28:56] serving your service is to [5:28:56] actually promote further [5:28:57] servitude of the taxpayers. [5:28:58] I have absolutely no respect [5:29:02] for any of you. [5:29:02] Watch out because way too many [5:29:03] have suffered under your watch [5:29:04] and the people will make sure [5:29:08] you okay for the policies that [5:29:08] you've pushed. [5:29:14] >> I'm done. [5:29:15] There are 14 speakers in [5:29:15] the queue. [5:29:16] The five minute timer has [5:29:16] ended. [5:29:17] No additional speakers will be [5:29:18] taken Million mile man If you [5:29:24] can please unmute I didn't [5:29:29] understand one word the last [5:29:34] speaker uttered I'm sorry maybe [5:29:36] I'm too old but I would like to [5:29:41] congratulate Nicole Crosby on [5:29:47] her election. [5:29:47] I voted for her because I [5:29:53] thought about my mother and her [5:30:04] family in World War Two Right [5:30:04] now near just kilometers away [5:30:15] from Omaha Beach and German [5:30:16] storm troopers took away her [5:30:16] family with no due process, [5:30:21] nothing. [5:30:22] And I voted for Nicole Crosby [5:30:28] because of that And MR. Camp [5:30:28] Bill MR. Camp Bill, I hope you [5:30:29] can hear me. [5:30:33] I want you to listen to me. [5:30:34] On AUGUST 1st I was put under [5:30:39] self arrest in Rebel Springs, [5:30:45] California for a horrible, [5:30:45] horrible, despicable crime that [5:30:51] I never committed And [5:30:52] the deputy handcuffed me and [5:30:58] drove me 100 miles to [5:31:03] the detention and my [5:31:04] arraignment date was canceled. [5:31:04] That was two months ago. [5:31:09] i haven't heard anything about [5:31:10] a dismissal And if you're a [5:31:15] former prosecutor you tell [5:31:16] every prosecutor on planet [5:31:21] Earth that I'll fight with [5:31:22] every shred of my body to prove [5:31:26] that I never committed this [5:31:27] horrible crime. [5:31:27] I never did. [5:31:31] Your time has concluded 7234 If [5:31:38] you can please unmute. [5:31:38] >> Good evening San Diego City [5:31:44] Council My name is Terri and [5:31:44] Skelly. [5:31:45] I called in to share [5:31:46] the information regarding [5:31:50] NOVEMBER and lung cancer [5:31:51] Awareness Month I received as I [5:31:51] received because I'm a health [5:31:55] care educator. [5:31:56] Lung cancer is the third most [5:31:57] common cancer diagnosed in [5:32:01] the United States but it is by [5:32:02] far the leading cause of all [5:32:03] cancer deaths for both men and [5:32:07] women. [5:32:08] About 1 in 90 people will be [5:32:08] diagnosed with lung cancer in [5:32:13] their lifetime. [5:32:14] Only about 15 to 20% of lung [5:32:14] cancer diseases occur in people [5:32:19] who have never smoked which [5:32:20] means that 80 to 85% of those [5:32:20] diagnosed with lung cancer [5:32:25] smoked or beat the American [5:32:26] Lung Cancer Association. [5:32:31] The ala States that marijuana [5:32:32] smoke contains many of the same [5:32:33] toxins, irritants and [5:32:37] carcinogens as tobacco smoke [5:32:38] which we also know that smoking [5:32:44] marijuana clearly damages human [5:32:45] lungs leading to chronic [5:32:45] bronchitis, lightning injury, [5:32:51] chronic cough and wheezing due [5:32:52] to the known risk to [5:32:52] respiratory health. [5:32:56] The American Lung Association [5:32:57] strongly cautions against [5:32:58] smoking or vaping marijuana. [5:33:03] What can policymakers do to [5:33:03] decrease lung disease and lung [5:33:04] cancer in the non smoking non [5:33:09] vaping residents We policies [5:33:09] that decrease exposure to [5:33:10] secondhand and thirdhand [5:33:15] marijuana and tobacco smoke and [5:33:16] paper bike smoke free free [5:33:20] outdoor dining public places [5:33:21] and apartment complexes. [5:33:22] Thank you City San Diego a city [5:33:27] council for your important step [5:33:28] in improving the health of [5:33:28] the city's residents with your [5:33:34] ban of smoking and vaping and [5:33:34] eating establishments and [5:33:39] giving me my concerns This [5:33:39] evening. [5:33:40] Thank you. [5:33:47] Next is Francis Yasmeen with me [5:33:48] again? [5:33:48] I wanted to say a couple words [5:33:52] about what safety really is as [5:33:52] we're having these [5:33:53] conversations about getting rid [5:33:54] of the surveillance. [5:33:57] I think that there's a couple [5:33:58] of things I want to propose. [5:34:03] One is we could hire human [5:34:04] being San Diego residents to [5:34:04] work as like community watch [5:34:09] people or give them all a [5:34:10] walkie talkie and create shifts [5:34:15] where people are patrolling [5:34:16] parts of neighborhoods and [5:34:17] doing the work of not just [5:34:17] surveilling people but actually [5:34:22] being there to help people and [5:34:22] preventing preventing bad [5:34:23] things from happening. [5:34:28] And I would love to see those [5:34:28] jobs created in us, you know, [5:34:29] especially in this age. [5:34:34] Where you going to be taking so [5:34:34] many jobs? [5:34:35] Let's get back to paying humans [5:34:35] to do things. [5:34:39] I also want to say you know, a [5:34:40] huge way to increase security [5:34:41] right now and it's desperately [5:34:45] needed by so many civilians Is [5:34:45] sleep safe sleeping sites. [5:34:46] The weather is starting to get [5:34:51] cold. [5:34:51] More and more people are [5:34:52] falling into debt and losing [5:34:56] their housing, food insecurity [5:34:57] is high. [5:34:57] We know that every dollar spent [5:35:03] on providing safe places for [5:35:03] people to sleep and not just [5:35:09] for current situation where [5:35:09] I've heard just nightmare [5:35:10] stories about what's going on [5:35:15] in the in the shelters in [5:35:16] Bellville Park and how unsafe [5:35:16] those fuel on the inside. [5:35:21] So I really want to just say we [5:35:22] can put our heads together, [5:35:26] find some empty lots and create [5:35:27] both safe parking spots and [5:35:27] more safe sleeping sites [5:35:33] because people are getting beat [5:35:33] up, mugged, raped all these [5:35:38] things just because they don't [5:35:39] have a roof over their head and [5:35:39] walls around them. [5:35:40] So let's invest in that. [5:35:45] Thank you so much. [5:35:46] Also I guess the marijuana I [5:35:46] think we protect marijuana [5:35:54] smokers rights but thank you on [5:35:55] exit 74997499 If you can please [5:36:04] unmute please play my video Bob [5:36:04] Kozinski here. [5:36:12] Tell me if you can please tell [5:36:13] me if you need to move on to [5:36:13] the next speaker. [5:36:17] This is Kathleen Lippert, Cathy [5:36:18] with it if you can please. [5:36:19] I mean for me to move on to [5:36:23] the next caller Carla if you [5:36:23] can please and you I can't I [5:36:28] mean for you if you cannot [5:36:29] unmute, we will need to move on [5:36:29] to the next speaker. [5:36:30] So move on to the next speaker. [5:36:34] Next is Andrew If you can [5:36:35] please unmute I want you to [5:36:36] move on to the next caller if [5:36:41] you can on you Tony please [5:36:42] unmute Tony Academy before you [5:36:42] I want to move on to the next [5:36:43] caller. [5:36:45] If you can't meet for yourself [5:36:46] Those were just a few recent [5:36:47] examples of the commuting [5:36:47] problem for remote public [5:36:52] speakers in response to this [5:36:53] problem I began producing my [5:36:53] non agenda comments as videos [5:36:54] so they could be played whether [5:36:59] I could unmute or not But [5:36:59] ironically clicks on days has a [5:37:00] policy that she won't play it [5:37:04] pretty submitted video without [5:37:05] the caller first I knew [5:37:09] the solution City clerk but [5:37:10] it's gotten even worse for [5:37:11] decades Citizens could just [5:37:11] bring media to be played to [5:37:15] council and the clerk's office [5:37:16] would play it. [5:37:16] There were no advanced [5:37:17] submission requirements. [5:37:17] I mean it could be submitted in [5:37:22] council chambers right along [5:37:23] with a speaker slip and it [5:37:23] would be placed. [5:37:24] But now clerks one day doesn't [5:37:27] accept any media in council [5:37:28] chambers at all. [5:37:29] All media has to be submitted [5:37:33] via the internet by 8 A.M. [5:37:33] Which can be eight hours before [5:37:34] the item is even called. [5:37:39] How does this council react to [5:37:40] things making it even more [5:37:41] difficult for citizens to [5:37:41] speak? [5:37:44] What I ask my colleagues to [5:37:44] join me in thanking the city [5:37:45] clerk and the city clerk's [5:37:47] staff for the work they do each [5:37:54] and every day And the work of [5:37:54] that Joe LaCava is that [5:37:59] the work of making it even more [5:38:00] difficult for the public to [5:38:01] speak and be heard in these [5:38:06] chambers I will note that [5:38:06] previously people could not [5:38:12] actually provide videos if they [5:38:12] were participating remotely and [5:38:13] encourage everyone to please [5:38:13] submit. [5:38:17] Judy Strang If you can please [5:38:18] unmute. [5:38:23] >> Good evening San Diego City [5:38:23] Council Thank you for [5:38:24] the previous discussion this [5:38:24] afternoon regarding [5:38:25] surveillance. [5:38:29] It was very thought provoking [5:38:30] on a whole lot of levels but I [5:38:31] just wanted to call your [5:38:34] attention that Thursday the 19 [5:38:35] is excuse me a great American [5:38:41] smoke out It's their 50th year [5:38:41] anniversary. [5:38:42] It's hosted by the American [5:38:42] Cancer Society. [5:38:43] It's to encourage people to [5:38:47] begin their quit journey quit [5:38:48] journey and and to create a [5:38:53] quit plan. [5:38:54] And part of that strategy is to [5:38:54] identify what are your personal [5:39:00] smoking or vaping triggers and [5:39:00] how to prepare to manage your [5:39:01] cravings. [5:39:05] I would like to respectfully [5:39:05] suggest that one of the issues [5:39:06] associated with triggers is [5:39:07] what they see in their [5:39:12] community and establishments in [5:39:12] their neighborhoods. [5:39:13] We don't need more marijuana or [5:39:17] tobacco stores in our [5:39:18] neighborhoods and we definitely [5:39:19] don't need the billboards And [5:39:19] it's perhaps in honor of [5:39:23] the great American spoke out in [5:39:24] the work that it is to avoid [5:39:25] having your triggers triggered [5:39:29] if you will that we might [5:39:30] consider removing all [5:39:30] billboards that advertise [5:39:37] marijuana smoking and vaping [5:39:38] products. [5:39:38] >> Thank you. [5:39:38] Thank you. [5:39:39] Your next is to a completely [5:39:44] new thanks. [5:39:45] >> I'd like to call the board's [5:39:46] attention to our sister city in [5:39:50] France right now The Gotham [5:39:50] City Hall burned down by [5:39:51] the Muslim mob. [5:39:56] All these immigrants are going [5:39:56] after it. [5:39:57] So I propose our city to be [5:40:01] the first city to ban Sharia [5:40:02] law in San Diego City and ban [5:40:02] the call to prayer being [5:40:08] broadcast on any mosque. [5:40:09] We got to cut down on [5:40:09] the mosques. [5:40:14] We've got to do this thing and [5:40:14] welcome him in. [5:40:15] And the Muslim guys are not our [5:40:18] friends. [5:40:19] They're against the Bill of [5:40:20] Rights. [5:40:20] They want to implement their [5:40:21] own laws. [5:40:25] They're smiling and they're [5:40:26] lying their religion or their [5:40:26] religion. [5:40:30] But it's more like a cult. [5:40:31] It's even worse than [5:40:32] Scientology cult in Scientology [5:40:37] they don't kill you if you're a [5:40:37] muslim. [5:40:37] You beat the Muslim faith. [5:40:38] They kill you. [5:40:42] So it's like it's a cult. [5:40:43] It's not And they're just [5:40:43] smiling. [5:40:44] They're trying to weasel their [5:40:47] way into Texas now they've got [5:40:48] all that Now they're coming for [5:40:48] San Diego County. [5:40:54] I say we put a cease and desist [5:40:54] on Panama and that care program [5:40:59] in Florida Care money for care [5:40:59] is a terrorist group. [5:41:00] That's what Florida says. [5:41:04] So their money is tainted. [5:41:05] Plus the mosque in Claremont [5:41:09] was called home to the two [5:41:10] terrorists at 911 For one year [5:41:15] they went to that mosque and [5:41:16] they lived in Claremont on off [5:41:16] Dakota Street like Claremont [5:41:17] Drive. [5:41:20] They lived there for a year. [5:41:21] So those guys are aligned with [5:41:26] 911 terrorist attacks, two guys [5:41:26] with a mosque there. [5:41:27] So ask the guys at the mosque [5:41:28] How many times have you said [5:41:31] death to Jews, Death to America [5:41:31] this last week? [5:41:32] How many times have they said [5:41:37] it this last week? [5:41:38] I bet you they did a lot more [5:41:38] than once. [5:41:41] You should asking them how many [5:41:42] when they come to the board. [5:41:42] When's the last time you said [5:41:47] death to Israel before they [5:41:48] could speak your time which [5:41:49] included 8700 If you can please [5:41:59] unmute the PRESIDENT Please let [5:42:04] me know if I step on your toes. [5:42:04] Okay. [5:42:08] So about the agenda item today [5:42:09] I'm not speaking to the item [5:42:10] but I'm sort of giving a bird's [5:42:14] eye view of a couple of things [5:42:14] that really aren't the agenda [5:42:19] item for say to what I felt [5:42:20] going to the council was fear [5:42:24] among the council members and [5:42:25] it's a normal thing to have and [5:42:26] that's what surveillance is [5:42:30] doing to the public and you're [5:42:35] how you move to other items in [5:42:36] that agenda item that I didn't [5:42:37] expect It spoke to me about [5:42:41] security It is or what has [5:42:42] happened to a lot of you and [5:42:47] perhaps your family members to [5:42:47] look to you on that. [5:42:48] He and you spoke with somebody [5:42:52] today who's extremely genius [5:42:57] level on the eye and think that [5:42:57] right now what we're speaking [5:42:58] about is difficult to manage. [5:43:03] Wait until the eye becomes [5:43:04] conscious and they're getting [5:43:07] close and they'll be able to [5:43:08] say I will be able to make [5:43:08] their own conscious decisions. [5:43:14] The woman and the baby, [5:43:15] the beautiful woman and [5:43:15] the babies need to come to them [5:43:18] to feel because that will stand [5:43:22] out in my mind maybe forever [5:43:26] Because when she said that [5:43:27] these two were never trust [5:43:28] the San Diego Police Department [5:43:33] I totally was stunned. [5:43:34] So I thank you Council member [5:43:38] feel for pointing that out. [5:43:38] That really touched my heart [5:43:42] that you recognize that to know [5:43:43] you brilliant lawyers please [5:43:48] settle down a little bit. [5:43:49] You're so good that you blow me [5:43:50] away and I can understand what [5:43:52] you're talking about. [5:43:53] So please try not to make it so [5:43:54] complicated. [5:43:57] I know the deeper guys It's [5:43:58] helpful to try to do it on your [5:44:03] own with your staff and your [5:44:03] time has concluded. [5:44:07] John if you can please unmute. [5:44:12] >> Good evening City Council [5:44:13] John Brady lived experience [5:44:13] advisors Thank you for your [5:44:14] time. [5:44:14] It's late. [5:44:18] I'll try to be brief. [5:44:19] I want to talk about last week [5:44:21] and and why I spoke out about [5:44:26] Midway Rising. [5:44:27] I made the mistake of ignoring [5:44:31] the warnings of Laurie Saldana [5:44:32] early on and was confused about [5:44:36] what the potential risks were [5:44:36] at that site and the conflict [5:44:37] that she must have had [5:44:41] internally warning housing but [5:44:42] also warning of very real [5:44:42] risks. [5:44:46] I now understand the Midway [5:44:51] Rising project came on my radar [5:44:51] after the King tides when i [5:44:52] thought to myself Gosh what [5:44:56] would have happened if the king [5:44:57] tides had been coupled with [5:44:57] the 2024 floods? [5:45:01] And I asked aei what would [5:45:02] happen and I was shocked really [5:45:06] blown away Tragedy on a scale [5:45:07] that you cannot imagine in that [5:45:10] region. [5:45:11] So then I dug in further and [5:45:12] I've spent seven days now on [5:45:16] and off hours at a time looking [5:45:20] at what this project risks are [5:45:20] . [5:45:21] They are extraordinary. [5:45:22] I don't know how they've not [5:45:25] come to the surface. [5:45:25] They have not been disclosed [5:45:26] intentionally or not or [5:45:26] ignored. [5:45:30] But this project could [5:45:30] potentially put this city on [5:45:34] the on the hook for over half [5:45:35] $1 billion in upgrades to [5:45:39] infrastructure and a constant [5:45:40] bill for continuous pumping [5:45:43] running to up to $1 million a [5:45:44] month by 20 2030 And it's [5:45:44] worse. [5:45:49] There's much more And I really [5:45:50] have to encourage you as a [5:45:53] housing advocate to seriously [5:45:53] reevaluate the decision around [5:45:57] this project and I will also [5:45:58] tell you there is a way to make [5:45:59] it happen. [5:46:02] There's a way to make it happen [5:46:03] and make it a crown jewel of [5:46:03] resiliency. [5:46:07] It's quite possible we won't [5:46:07] know unless we do the right [5:46:08] research. [5:46:12] Thank you for your time. [5:46:13] >> Thank you. [5:46:13] I will know that other people [5:46:15] have raised their hand after [5:46:16] the five minute timer we will [5:46:17] be only taking the 14 that had [5:46:20] their hands raised when [5:46:20] the five minute timer concluded [5:46:21] but you can definitely still [5:46:22] submit comments to City Clerk [5:46:25] at San diego.Gov and those will [5:46:26] be distributed to the council. [5:46:27] Angela Better if you can please [5:46:29] unmute. [5:46:35] >> Hi I wanted to say I noticed [5:46:35] something I've been going to [5:46:39] these city council meetings for [5:46:40] quite a long time and I [5:46:40] appreciate that there is a [5:46:44] place for us to talk about [5:46:49] items that concerns us But what [5:46:49] I've noticed is that we've [5:46:54] gotten a lot less time allowed [5:46:58] to speak and it's often hard [5:46:59] for many of us who MAY speak [5:47:03] slower or don't have something [5:47:03] written, you know, to read as [5:47:08] quickly as possible Plus we [5:47:08] can't bring people that want to [5:47:12] be there to support us and hand [5:47:13] over minutes anymore. [5:47:17] I notice there's no way of us [5:47:18] doing that and I think that [5:47:19] that is a real disservice [5:47:22] especially when we take [5:47:23] the time to get to the council [5:47:24] meetings. [5:47:27] We have to pay for parking like [5:47:28] today it was $18 minimum but [5:47:32] yet we only get one minute to [5:47:37] speak and we used to have at [5:47:37] least a minute and a half, [5:47:38] sometimes two minutes. [5:47:39] I understand it gets really [5:47:41] crowded and you guys need to [5:47:42] push these things through But I [5:47:43] mean it's important for you to [5:47:47] listen to us and to give us [5:47:47] that time especially when we [5:47:51] take the time to show up. [5:47:51] So I just think that needs to [5:47:56] be reconsidered because you [5:47:57] guys are voted there because of [5:47:57] the people And I think it's [5:48:01] important that you do listen to [5:48:02] us. [5:48:02] >> Thank you. [5:48:02] Thank you. [5:48:06] And you can definitely email my [5:48:07] office City clerk at San [5:48:08] diego.Gov and we can assist you [5:48:08] through the changes because of [5:48:11] state law sb 707 Gabriele [5:48:12] Aravena If you can please [5:48:15] unmute. [5:48:16] >> Can you hear me? [5:48:20] Yes please proceed. [5:48:20] Thank you so much. [5:48:21] I want to thank the council [5:48:24] members that all voted to [5:48:25] oppose this really long night [5:48:29] and for listening to your [5:48:30] constituents after months and [5:48:34] months and months of of telling [5:48:35] you So it's really nice to be [5:48:35] heard. [5:48:39] I also wanted to thank Stephen [5:48:39] Whitburn. [5:48:40] I am part of your district [5:48:44] district three and I was really [5:48:45] nice to hear you say that you [5:48:49] were going to switch over. [5:48:50] Now you did say some concerning [5:48:53] made some concerning points to [5:48:54] combat your decision saying [5:48:58] that you wanted to put more [5:48:59] money into maybe into public [5:49:03] safety because you're concerned [5:49:04] about our lgbtq community. [5:49:08] I also heard you give support [5:49:09] to the Latino community. [5:49:09] It was really impressive to [5:49:13] hear you speak in Spanish. [5:49:13] I thank you for that. [5:49:14] But what I'm here to talk to [5:49:18] you guys about is Centro [5:49:18] Cultural de la Raza. [5:49:23] >> They have been targeted [5:49:23] recently by hate campaigns and [5:49:27] part of your district, [5:49:28] the Latino community. [5:49:28] We're asking you, Stephen [5:49:32] Whitburn, please hear us. [5:49:32] Centro de la Raza is a [5:49:33] beautiful space, super [5:49:37] welcoming. [5:49:37] It's literally saved my life. [5:49:38] It was a third space for me to [5:49:42] go and we really, really need [5:49:42] your support and I won't hold [5:49:46] up too much time because we're [5:49:47] all tired. [5:49:47] But thank you again Council [5:49:48] Thank you. [5:49:51] Next is Natalie Roski If you [5:49:55] can please unmute. [5:49:56] >> Hi. [5:49:57] I'll try not to take up a lot [5:49:57] of your time. [5:50:03] I agree with the woman about [5:50:04] the minutes but you just said [5:50:07] that it is state law. [5:50:08] I just wanted to say something [5:50:12] about consciousness and where [5:50:15] this is going and the feeling [5:50:20] amongst what everybody is [5:50:21] feeling. [5:50:25] There's an uncertainty and [5:50:25] people are looking to be led [5:50:30] and I just want people to know [5:50:30] that they can look inside [5:50:34] themselves and building [5:50:35] community I think is the best [5:50:39] way we're going to move through [5:50:39] this time of era and having [5:50:43] children to grow up in this era [5:50:48] is just it's all really someone [5:50:49] quoted that it was it was scary [5:50:54] and excite ing both at the same [5:50:54] time. [5:50:58] I hope that people take time to [5:50:59] think about consciousness [5:50:59] throughout their day. [5:51:03] It's really, really important [5:51:04] that we're aware of our [5:51:08] thoughts and perception versus [5:51:08] perspective. [5:51:13] That's a huge, huge thing [5:51:14] that's going to move us [5:51:14] forward. [5:51:18] I think we're at a precipice of [5:51:19] humanity and civilization and [5:51:22] what we've been told that we've [5:51:23] been lied to for a long time [5:51:24] when it comes to history and [5:51:27] who we are and how we got to [5:51:28] where we're at. [5:51:28] The federal government is aware [5:51:32] of many things and I don't [5:51:33] think that looking to them is [5:51:37] really going to get us too far. [5:51:38] I think local and small [5:51:42] communities is going to build. [5:51:43] It's the best way to build. [5:51:47] Thank you. [5:51:47] >> Thank you. [5:51:48] Next is Amy can more If you can [5:51:51] please unmute. [5:51:57] Hi can you hear me? [5:52:01] Yes. [5:52:01] Okay great. [5:52:02] I just want to thank everyone [5:52:06] today for their time and for [5:52:06] listening to the community and [5:52:07] I want to speak out on [5:52:10] something that is really [5:52:11] important to our community and [5:52:12] that Matt started off with and [5:52:16] that Gabrielle just shared [5:52:16] about our need for [5:52:17] the necessary support for [5:52:20] the several other Rosa I am a [5:52:21] professor at ucsd. [5:52:24] >> I teach over 300 students a [5:52:25] quarter. [5:52:29] And this space is so vital for [5:52:29] many things that we've been [5:52:30] hearing about and trying to [5:52:34] respond to tonight which is [5:52:35] namely trust. [5:52:36] It's trust And it's also for me [5:52:39] personally belonging and to [5:52:40] support spaces that are really [5:52:44] giving our community and us and [5:52:44] myself a space where we feel [5:52:49] like we belong, where we I mean [5:52:53] I think you all heard from so [5:52:53] many amazing, incredible [5:52:54] students from ucsd that [5:52:59] empowered them to be citizens [5:52:59] And so supporting these kinds [5:53:04] of spaces is vital. [5:53:05] And so I really want to call on [5:53:05] all of you not just the parents [5:53:08] in your district but also [5:53:08] everyone to really take [5:53:09] seriously Then this [5:53:13] the necessity of supporting [5:53:13] the center. [5:53:14] So it is just a vital piece of [5:53:17] San Diego. [5:53:18] It's historic and the work that [5:53:22] they do every day is really, [5:53:23] really important to us as [5:53:28] community members. [5:53:28] So I just want to urge you all [5:53:28] to to find a way and for me [5:53:28] personally feel like the best [5:53:31] way to start building trust is [5:53:32] to not only do the great things [5:53:33] that you have done in voting to [5:53:37] listen to your constituents but [5:53:37] also to really support [5:53:41] the things that bring us [5:53:41] the most democratic joy spaces [5:53:42] that we have in San Diego. [5:53:46] Thank you very much for your [5:53:46] time. [5:53:47] Thank you, Becky. [5:53:54] If you can please unmute. [5:53:54] >> Good evening. [5:53:58] My name is Becky Rapp and I'd [5:53:59] like to address NOVEMBER 15th [5:53:59] marked as the World Day of [5:54:03] Remembrance for road traffic [5:54:03] victims an international day [5:54:07] dedicated to remembering those [5:54:08] killed and injured on our roads [5:54:08] and recognizing [5:54:09] the responsibility we share to [5:54:12] prevent these tragedies. [5:54:17] A NOVEMBER 16th article in [5:54:17] the Union-Tribune titled [5:54:18] Grieving Unimaginable Loss San [5:54:22] Diego Area Families Gather [5:54:23] reported that 231 people were [5:54:27] killed and 1112 seriously [5:54:27] injured in traffic collisions [5:54:31] across San Diego County and [5:54:32] 2025 within the city of San [5:54:32] Diego. [5:54:35] 92 people lost their lives and [5:54:39] 398 were seriously injured. [5:54:40] These numbers represent a [5:54:41] significant public safety [5:54:41] issue. [5:54:44] I want to particularly [5:54:45] emphasize driving under [5:54:46] the influence of alcohol and [5:54:49] drugs. [5:54:49] Unlike some traffic hazards, [5:54:50] impaired driving is entirely [5:54:54] preventable. [5:54:54] Every driver has a [5:54:55] responsibility to make [5:54:56] the decision not to get behind [5:54:59] the wheel while impaired. [5:54:59] Yet these preventable choices [5:55:00] continue to put everyone on our [5:55:04] roads at risk. [5:55:05] The Union-Tribune article did [5:55:05] not identify how many of these [5:55:09] deaths and serious injuries [5:55:09] involved impaired driving. [5:55:13] And I believe that is an [5:55:13] important question. [5:55:14] I urge the city to work with [5:55:18] San Diego Police Department and [5:55:19] District Attorney's Office and [5:55:23] regional partners to strengthen [5:55:24] dui prevention enforcement and [5:55:24] public education. [5:55:28] And I also ask the city to make [5:55:29] alcohol and drug involved say [5:55:30] fatal and serious injury [5:55:33] collisions, statistics readily [5:55:34] available to the public so we [5:55:37] can better understand [5:55:37] the problem and measure [5:55:38] the progress we're making on [5:55:43] this world Day of Remembrance [5:55:44] Let us recognize those who were [5:55:47] lost by making a renewed [5:55:48] commitment to prevention. [5:55:48] Thank you. [5:55:53] Thank you. [5:55:53] And our final speaker is [5:55:54] Madison. [5:55:54] Please unmute. [5:55:54] Hi. [5:55:57] Thank you. [5:55:58] Good evening City Council [5:55:58] members. [5:55:59] I wanted to speak about tobacco [5:55:59] prevention through an [5:56:02] environmental lens. [5:56:03] Sometimes public health [5:56:03] concerns don't receive [5:56:07] attention because the people [5:56:08] most affected are often [5:56:08] children and teenagers who [5:56:09] don't know how to advocate for [5:56:12] themselves or even that these [5:56:12] problems are happening in these [5:56:13] policy discussions. [5:56:17] But environmental protection is [5:56:17] an issue that brings a lot of [5:56:18] people together. [5:56:21] And tobacco is an environmental [5:56:22] problem as much as it is a [5:56:23] public health problem. [5:56:26] Cigaret butts have historically [5:56:27] been the most commonly [5:56:28] collected item in global litter [5:56:28] litter cleanups. [5:56:31] Even today they remain among [5:56:32] the most prevalent forms of [5:56:33] litter According to the World [5:56:36] Health Organization, [5:56:37] approximately 4.5 trillion [5:56:38] cigaret butts are improperly [5:56:41] discarded every year. [5:56:42] And these are harmful pieces of [5:56:42] trash because they contain [5:56:46] plastic, they do not biodegrade [5:56:46] and they release toxic [5:56:47] chemicals into soil and [5:56:47] waterways. [5:56:51] They can travel through [5:56:52] the storm drains into the ocean [5:56:52] and be ingested by wildlife. [5:56:56] There's an opportunity to bring [5:56:56] environmental advocates, [5:56:57] parents, public health [5:57:00] professionals and community [5:57:01] organizations together around [5:57:02] stronger tobacco restrictions. [5:57:05] So I encourage the city to [5:57:06] consider policies that reduce [5:57:10] tobacco product availability [5:57:11] and use in shared public [5:57:11] spaces. [5:57:12] Prevent cigaret litter at its [5:57:15] source and protect our beaches, [5:57:15] parks, waterways and [5:57:16] neighborhoods. [5:57:20] We should be able to protect [5:57:21] the environment and protect [5:57:22] public health at the same thing [5:57:22] through these policies. [5:57:26] Thank you. [5:57:26] Thank you. [5:57:27] And that concludes non agenda [5:57:27] public comment for today's [5:57:30] meeting. [5:57:30] >> All right. [5:57:31] Thank you, City Clerk. [5:57:32] Does the office of the city [5:57:32] attorney have anything to [5:57:35] report out from closed session? [5:57:35] >> Yes. [5:57:36] Thank you. [5:57:36] There is one item to report out [5:57:37] today. [5:57:39] The city council voted on [5:57:40] closed session item number one [5:57:40] to initiate litigation. [5:57:41] Once litigation is formally [5:57:44] commenced the action [5:57:44] the defendants and other [5:57:45] particulars will be disclosed [5:57:49] to any person upon inquiry [5:57:49] unless to do so would [5:57:50] jeopardize effective service of [5:57:51] process or settlement [5:57:51] negotiations. [5:57:54] The motion passed 8 to 0 with [5:57:55] Council member Von Wilpert [5:57:55] absent. [5:57:56] >> That concludes my report. [5:57:56] All right. [5:57:59] Thank you for that. [5:58:00] And again, as we start to wrap [5:58:01] up, I want to thank the city [5:58:04] clerk entire city clerk team 32 [5:58:05] that I sometimes forget And of [5:58:09] course debating for [5:58:10] the attorney who sat there [5:58:10] quietly listening to all [5:58:11] the testimony. [5:58:14] With that we will now adjourn [5:58:14] the council to the regularly [5:58:17] scheduled council meeting on [5:58:18] Tuesday NOVEMBER 17th, 2026 at [5:58:20] 10 A.M. Or shortly thereafter.