1
00:00:08,270 --> 00:00:35,930
Good morning, everyone. This is the regular August meeting of the CalTrain Board of Directors. And Madam Secretary, please call the roll to establish that we have a quorum. Director Abbey Koga is delayed, director Burt. Director Canapas, absent director Cohen. Here. Director G. President. Director Walton. Director Simlita. Here. Vice Chair Medina. President. And Chair Heminger. Here. You have a quorum.

2
00:00:35,930 --> 00:00:41,550
So unlike the Texas legislature, we'll proceed to do our business now.

3
00:00:43,810 --> 00:00:45,570
Let's do the Pledge of Allegiance.

4
00:00:48,450 --> 00:00:55,410
Pledge of Allegiance to the United States of America, to the Republic, which just stands,

5
00:00:55,910 --> 00:01:00,810
one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.

6
00:01:00,810 --> 00:01:01,690
I

7
00:01:07,220 --> 00:01:18,440
believe that brings us to item 4 which is consideration of any request to declare an emergency and participate in our meetings nonetheless.

8
00:01:19,220 --> 00:01:23,300
Any requests? Any request to change the order of business?

9
00:01:24,800 --> 00:01:32,620
Seeing none, we'll leave it as it is. Item 6 is for public comment on items not on our agenda.

10
00:01:32,620 --> 00:01:35,300
and today are there any Madam Secretary?

11
00:01:35,520 --> 00:01:37,720
We do have one in person, Jeff Carter.

12
00:01:46,260 --> 00:01:46,880
Thank you very much.

13
00:01:47,040 --> 00:01:47,580
Good morning, everybody.

14
00:01:48,460 --> 00:01:50,120
Texas, I just say they do need help.

15
00:01:52,140 --> 00:01:59,240
Just like the mentioned that notice, you know, pretty good increase in ridership on trains.

16
00:01:59,240 --> 00:02:06,340
I've been riding and a lot of good increase in bike activity came down here on train 112 today.

17
00:02:06,340 --> 00:02:12,100
that one had a lot of bike activity and then my normal

18
00:02:12,100 --> 00:02:16,880
train when I go home from work at night from 22nd Street is

19
00:02:17,580 --> 00:02:23,520
train 518 and that one also is usually quite busy so you know I think

20
00:02:23,520 --> 00:02:27,220
really appreciate you know people are appreciating the new trains and all the

21
00:02:28,060 --> 00:02:33,200
everything that staff is doing to you know get Cal train you know back to

22
00:02:33,200 --> 00:02:41,600
pre-pandemic levels. Also looking forward to when the APCs are going to be certified. I know

23
00:02:41,600 --> 00:02:48,280
staffs diligently working on that and you know that's it for now. Thank you very much.

24
00:02:48,940 --> 00:02:52,460
We also have two virtual hands raised, Roland.

25
00:02:56,300 --> 00:02:59,440
Good morning and thank you. So what I would like

26
00:02:59,440 --> 00:03:06,360
to do this morning is to attract your attention to page four of your supplemental reading file,

27
00:03:07,080 --> 00:03:14,080
which is the B-New update, which shows that the preliminary design has now been delayed

28
00:03:14,080 --> 00:03:19,520
that these four months, because essentially what they're doing is they redesigning one of the

29
00:03:19,520 --> 00:03:29,180
cap cars and turning it into a battery electric locomotive. So the impact on the schedule is uncertain,

30
00:03:29,180 --> 00:03:33,220
But the thing I want to bring to you attention is that we are now two years and eighteen

31
00:03:33,220 --> 00:03:38,980
and a half million dollars into this thing and absolutely nothing to show for it whereby

32
00:03:39,520 --> 00:03:44,740
some members of the public suggested that we just buy battery electric locomotives

33
00:03:45,340 --> 00:03:52,500
and just tow EMUs up and down the patterns and all the way down to gear oil and back.

34
00:03:53,320 --> 00:03:58,420
The last thing I'd like to bring to you attention is that I'll certainly be a fancy meeting on

35
00:03:59,460 --> 00:04:05,380
Monday, and the best sound by it I got from the mayor of Salinas is that the Bay Area

36
00:04:05,380 --> 00:04:08,120
absolutely loves Monterey Bay on weekends.

37
00:04:09,520 --> 00:04:14,120
So my question in terms of planning is when are we going to start saying some kind of

38
00:04:14,120 --> 00:04:20,680
you know weekend service down to Giroi and hopefully beyond, and a midday service.

39
00:04:21,020 --> 00:04:25,400
And quite frankly, as I just counted correctly pointed out, everybody absolutely loves the

40
00:04:25,400 --> 00:04:31,480
B.M.U. That's included us, you know, a child's annual date and beyond. And down here, you know,

41
00:05:02,260 --> 00:05:32,240
Thank you. Good morning, Chair Steve Heminger and members. Alita Dupree for the record she and her with team folds. Wish I could be with you today. But I was in the room yesterday. I went to Sam Transit and some of you saw me and I did use the trains yesterday. We did have some problems around San Mateo. I endured some delays. I think it was a great crossing or track issue. I don't think the delays exceeded 10 minutes, but that's

42
00:05:32,240 --> 00:05:37,580
concerning. So I want to make sure that we tighten everything up with these great crossings.

43
00:05:38,220 --> 00:05:49,120
I also find that as I use your system, our system, is that I'm making multiple stops along the way.

44
00:05:49,320 --> 00:05:56,640
I'm not just writing San Francisco to San Carlos and back. Sometimes I write from San Francisco to

45
00:05:56,640 --> 00:06:02,720
San Mateo, then I backtracked to Berlin game, etc.

46
00:06:03,240 --> 00:06:06,420
What I'm finding I need to do is buy day passes on the app.

47
00:06:07,180 --> 00:06:09,380
It saves me money over buying Clipper.

48
00:06:10,260 --> 00:06:12,420
Because Clipper charges me for each ride.

49
00:06:13,840 --> 00:06:18,860
On one time last year I wrote Clipper back and forth to celebrate a couple of times

50
00:06:18,860 --> 00:06:21,580
and I guess it was a thing to save me money.

51
00:06:22,060 --> 00:06:24,080
I have to reach out the staff for that.

52
00:06:24,080 --> 00:06:35,740
but Clipper 2 is coming, though we don't have a date yet. However, Bart is planning to implement open payments later this month.

53
00:06:36,840 --> 00:06:48,940
This was disclosed at the Clipper Executive Board meeting, so what I'm sharing with you is public information that anyone can access, because I don't have special access to anything anyway, nor should I.

54
00:06:48,940 --> 00:06:51,480
So, how can we be ready for this?

55
00:06:52,700 --> 00:06:55,660
I'd like to see a skid into some kind of fair capping,

56
00:06:55,900 --> 00:06:58,560
because nobody should have to worry about overpaying.

57
00:06:58,840 --> 00:06:59,220
Thank you.

58
00:07:00,680 --> 00:07:02,560
We do have one more hand raised.

59
00:07:02,700 --> 00:07:03,520
Would you like to hear that?

60
00:07:03,900 --> 00:07:04,060
Yes.

61
00:07:04,260 --> 00:07:07,660
Susan, that is Adrian Brent.

62
00:07:12,660 --> 00:07:13,800
Okay, good morning, directors.

63
00:07:14,120 --> 00:07:15,700
Thank you for taking me.

64
00:07:15,720 --> 00:07:16,960
I joined a little bit late.

65
00:07:17,880 --> 00:07:22,380
I finally had a chance to review your special meeting on the budget.

66
00:07:22,380 --> 00:07:28,440
some months ago, and I was able to watch that video and I just had a couple of comments

67
00:07:28,440 --> 00:07:31,700
to add regarding distance-based fares.

68
00:07:31,900 --> 00:07:38,400
There was some conversation around that topic among the board and staff, and I believe

69
00:07:38,400 --> 00:07:43,720
the executive director said that we do have distance-based fares now, and I want to, there's

70
00:07:43,720 --> 00:07:49,460
a nuance to that is that we actually have zone-based fares right now, and I would like

71
00:07:49,460 --> 00:07:56,140
it too if you cross from one county into another in your car and you had to pay for gas to cross each

72
00:07:56,140 --> 00:08:02,880
entire county entirely. And that's what we have with the zone-based fare right now. If you cross

73
00:08:02,880 --> 00:08:09,440
from any zone into any other with one station stop, you have to pay for two entire fare zones.

74
00:08:10,020 --> 00:08:15,640
And so we actually have shorter rides that cost more than longer rides. So we clearly do not have

75
00:08:15,640 --> 00:08:21,380
distance-based fares. The CAC, some years ago, I can look it up for you. The staff has the

76
00:08:21,380 --> 00:08:26,840
resolution. unanimously, we put a lot of energy into this. We put it resolution together.

77
00:08:27,340 --> 00:08:33,640
unanimously put together an approved resolution requesting that the staff in the board work on

78
00:08:33,640 --> 00:08:39,040
moving to distance-based fares that are completely equitable and smooth, just like Bart has had since

79
00:08:39,040 --> 00:08:45,260
opening day. So that's something that I wanted to really clarify because I came up

80
00:08:45,640 --> 00:08:52,140
And the other one was, I think, around a question about if we could work with one conductor.

81
00:08:52,860 --> 00:08:57,300
Currently, many trains already may come to your surprise run with one conductor,

82
00:08:57,640 --> 00:08:59,140
because the other one isn't there.

83
00:08:59,880 --> 00:09:01,780
And they don't always collect fares.

84
00:09:02,180 --> 00:09:05,600
So what I'd like to suggest there is that we go to one conductor

85
00:09:05,600 --> 00:09:09,640
and then have, just like in Europe, a separate team of fairness factors.

86
00:09:09,840 --> 00:09:11,940
And that's much more effective. Thank you.

87
00:09:11,940 --> 00:09:13,000
We

88
00:09:15,880 --> 00:09:17,960
do have Adina Levin who just raised her hand.

89
00:09:18,680 --> 00:09:19,400
Allow.

90
00:09:20,640 --> 00:09:22,220
Well, sure, we'll bring you all on.

91
00:09:23,220 --> 00:09:24,300
Adina Levin.

92
00:09:25,500 --> 00:09:26,700
All right.

93
00:09:26,880 --> 00:09:27,400
Yes.

94
00:09:27,740 --> 00:09:33,980
So also on the clipper topic,

95
00:09:34,520 --> 00:09:41,440
it was announced that there's going to be open payment on

96
00:09:41,440 --> 00:09:48,860
start starting on at the end of August as you know the first release of that

97
00:09:48,860 --> 00:09:53,720
feature which is also going to be coming out on you know all the other

98
00:09:53,720 --> 00:09:57,040
or Clipper Agency sometime in the coming months.

99
00:09:58,020 --> 00:09:58,960
And...

100
00:10:00,590 --> 00:10:30,410
CalTrain has seen a lot of increase in ridership over the weekend in recreation and entertainment. And, you know, has marketing programs really focusing on people jumping on CalTrain to get to, you know, musical events and sports events and so on. And so, would like to encourage. And this may be already being done on the team, even though we don't know exactly what

101
00:10:30,410 --> 00:10:53,130
that open payment feature is going to be released for CalTrain, you know, to be ready to market and, you know, work with the other agencies to also market the open payment convenience for recreation and entertainment because that really greatly increases the convenience.

102
00:10:53,910 --> 00:11:03,250
You know, lots of people, if you use transit regularly, it doesn't matter as much if you have to have a special flip of card.

103
00:11:03,730 --> 00:11:10,730
But if you don't and you think, okay, I'm going to take how train do I need to get a special card or pay cash or get a special app it's confusing.

104
00:11:11,510 --> 00:11:16,210
And it's so much easier if you can pay with the credit or debit card if you have so getting ready to market it.

105
00:11:16,210 --> 00:11:23,380
we don't know exactly what date but it is predictable. So I'm working on that marketing is a opportunity to increase ridership. Thank you.

106
00:11:24,430 --> 00:11:25,870
That ends public comments.

107
00:11:27,210 --> 00:11:28,690
Thank you Madam Secretary.

108
00:11:29,930 --> 00:11:37,090
Colleagues that was part one of our meeting today. Part two is a closed session conference with our council.

109
00:11:37,870 --> 00:11:42,670
And I'll let him announce what we will be doing in closed session and for how long.

110
00:11:42,670 --> 00:11:50,210
Thank you, Chair. The board will be discussing Merlino versus PCJPB, and we anticipate that the

111
00:11:50,210 --> 00:11:56,510
closed session will last approximately 25 minutes with travel time up to the Gallagher

112
00:11:56,510 --> 00:11:56,930
Conference.

113
00:11:58,980 --> 00:12:04,860
So, everybody stay here except us, and we'll be back as quickly as we can.

114
00:12:15,420 --> 00:12:23,020
We are back in session, and I'll ask our council if he has anything to say.

115
00:12:23,420 --> 00:12:23,820
Thank you, Chair.

116
00:12:23,940 --> 00:12:25,480
There is nothing to report from close session.

117
00:12:26,140 --> 00:12:26,520
All right.

118
00:12:26,880 --> 00:12:32,840
So we move now to part three of our meeting, which is what we're used to seeing.

119
00:12:33,780 --> 00:12:36,960
And we'll begin with the report of our executive director.

120
00:12:37,460 --> 00:12:37,600
Great.

121
00:12:37,600 --> 00:12:46,240
Good morning, Chair Heminger Directors. Welcome back after a summer hiatus. It doesn't really feel like we had a summer hiatus.

122
00:12:47,400 --> 00:12:52,300
I really appreciate all of the good work that's been happening.

123
00:12:59,000 --> 00:13:03,020
Excuse me, so I will provide a brief update.

124
00:13:03,860 --> 00:13:06,340
First, as always, we start with safety.

125
00:13:07,220 --> 00:13:16,040
Again, we're bringing other grade crossings on board with the AI technology and so we have

126
00:13:16,040 --> 00:13:23,380
one in each county at this point really working through, again, using AI to identify the

127
00:13:23,380 --> 00:13:28,460
behaviors and then making very cost-effective changes to those grade crossings.

128
00:13:28,460 --> 00:13:33,120
We are really getting a lot of attention on this approach.

129
00:13:33,460 --> 00:13:38,440
I was presented at the APTA Rail Conference.

130
00:13:38,960 --> 00:13:43,880
We also are going to be presenting at the National Conference in Boston,

131
00:13:44,560 --> 00:13:46,060
as well as the Asheville Conference.

132
00:13:46,940 --> 00:13:51,880
And our friends from FTA and FRA are going to be at all of those places.

133
00:13:52,220 --> 00:13:56,820
And so we also have a single page that we've put together

134
00:13:56,820 --> 00:14:00,500
that talks about the program, I think we're calling it rapid deployment.

135
00:14:01,600 --> 00:14:06,580
And so, I'd like to provide a copy to you after this, in your travels, if you're talking

136
00:14:06,580 --> 00:14:12,700
about this, it does a really good job of identifying what we've been doing and really highlights

137
00:14:13,200 --> 00:14:17,720
using Broadway Burling Game as an example of how effective these changes can be.

138
00:14:18,200 --> 00:14:22,720
I also wanted to show you this, which is something that the team is incredibly proud of.

139
00:14:22,720 --> 00:14:29,400
At the rail conference, we were awarded the Rail Safety Gold Award, which is the highest

140
00:14:29,400 --> 00:14:32,140
award that a railroad can receive.

141
00:14:33,780 --> 00:14:40,460
And it just speaks to the good work that the team has been doing over the course of,

142
00:14:40,560 --> 00:14:46,400
frankly, the last three years at this point to really understand how safety culture needs

143
00:14:46,400 --> 00:14:54,940
needs to be a daily commitment and it needs daily attention and so anyways just wanted

144
00:14:54,940 --> 00:14:59,980
to let you know that we are very grateful for the support that we

145
00:15:01,720 --> 00:15:07,020
Discussions that are happening at the board level, including Sam Trans last night, VTA tonight.

146
00:15:07,780 --> 00:15:14,140
And Jason is going to be focused on this during his report under the legislative update.

147
00:15:15,820 --> 00:15:20,860
We are at work on the Guadalupe Creek Bridge. You see a couple of pictures here.

148
00:15:20,860 --> 00:15:33,240
We have diverted 155 fish from the stream, and so we are definitely moving forward.

149
00:15:33,960 --> 00:15:39,380
It is incredibly important that we've been able to maximize work windows as a result

150
00:15:39,380 --> 00:15:45,860
of not only diverting fish, but diverting the train traffic here, and sharing the team

151
00:15:45,860 --> 00:15:51,140
are working real hard to ensure that we are going to get this thing done in two creek windows.

152
00:15:51,420 --> 00:15:56,420
So you see here, we've just removed the last piece of MT1.

153
00:15:58,620 --> 00:16:01,960
Really good news on time performance and ridership.

154
00:16:03,220 --> 00:16:13,540
You see, we have reattained our 95% and are on track for 95% this month, but early days.

155
00:16:13,540 --> 00:16:17,480
But the real news here is all about ridership growth.

156
00:16:17,880 --> 00:16:20,920
For the first month, we are over a million riders.

157
00:16:22,240 --> 00:16:29,620
And you see, we're back at 65% pre-COVID, really outperforming what we thought we would

158
00:16:29,620 --> 00:16:33,320
on the weekend at 150% in excess of that.

159
00:16:34,120 --> 00:16:37,080
And June really has seen quite the spike.

160
00:16:37,660 --> 00:16:39,880
Special events really are contributing to this.

161
00:16:39,880 --> 00:16:45,600
But here's the thing, if we weren't providing the customer experience, if we weren't providing

162
00:16:45,600 --> 00:16:50,420
the on-time performance, a lot of those special event riders wouldn't be coming back.

163
00:16:50,640 --> 00:16:56,520
So I think that's sort of a, I was going to say gateway drug, that's the wrong, that's

164
00:16:56,520 --> 00:16:57,200
the wrong term.

165
00:16:58,600 --> 00:17:04,060
Really, people are testing the service and we find that they're coming back.

166
00:17:04,140 --> 00:17:05,120
So this is really good news.

167
00:17:05,220 --> 00:17:09,760
The other thing I want to emphasize here, because we always used to talk about our 75%

168
00:17:09,760 --> 00:17:16,260
on revenue recovery, and that was nation-leading pre-COVID.

169
00:17:17,120 --> 00:17:21,920
It was really important to emphasize, and it's in my executive director's report,

170
00:17:22,240 --> 00:17:26,120
but we have a little bit of a plug there because we're waiting for our year end.

171
00:17:26,600 --> 00:17:31,760
But, Calthrine is back at 30% Fairbox Recovery, and from everything we can glean,

172
00:17:32,640 --> 00:17:34,620
that is likely nation-leading.

173
00:17:35,340 --> 00:17:40,000
So, I want to point out, as we're talking about efficiency measures, and we're talking

174
00:17:40,000 --> 00:17:46,840
about accountability measures as part of SB-63, I do want to report that CalTrain really

175
00:17:46,840 --> 00:17:55,300
is continuing to cover a lot of its costs out of the Fairbox, and, you know, I will continue

176
00:17:55,300 --> 00:17:57,080
to emphasize that during these reports.

177
00:17:58,500 --> 00:18:04,580
Talked about special events through the summer, and we're going to continue to talk about

178
00:18:04,580 --> 00:18:07,620
places where people can go via

179
00:18:07,620 --> 00:18:11,080
CalTrain. And we have a marketing

180
00:18:11,080 --> 00:18:13,440
team that is really doing a great job of

181
00:18:13,440 --> 00:18:15,740
establishing partnerships with our local

182
00:18:15,740 --> 00:18:20,580
sports team. There will be a press event

183
00:18:20,580 --> 00:18:23,120
on Monday regarding the big sync. I think

184
00:18:23,120 --> 00:18:25,660
this is one of the major outcomes of the

185
00:18:25,660 --> 00:18:30,540
transformation action plan. We are looking

186
00:18:30,540 --> 00:18:34,460
at changing the schedules. I think it's

187
00:18:34,460 --> 00:18:40,780
twice a year but really doing it in concert with all of the agencies and so we don't see

188
00:18:41,620 --> 00:18:46,280
first of all the conversations are happening up front to make sure that there's not a gap

189
00:18:46,280 --> 00:18:53,940
in terms of transfers between systems and to the degree possible we are doing it at the same time

190
00:18:53,940 --> 00:19:01,520
and I think that is really really helping for riders who are transferring between systems to really

191
00:19:01,520 --> 00:19:06,880
have the the journey be a little bit more we call it legible. I think one of the metrics

192
00:19:06,880 --> 00:19:14,200
that we've started tracking are these transfers at Nobre. And we have had, again, this

193
00:19:14,200 --> 00:19:23,740
month a high point of nearly, I think it's more than 27,000. And this is, you know, higher

194
00:19:23,740 --> 00:19:28,360
as a percentage than it was pre-COVID. And I think that is a testament to the fact that

195
00:19:28,360 --> 00:19:34,820
that transfer is really much more convenient for our riders, so we'll continue to track

196
00:19:34,820 --> 00:19:39,760
that as a key KPI for how people are getting between the systems.

197
00:20:00,820 --> 00:20:28,960
Well, let's see if there are any. Colleagues, any questions of our executive director, director Burke? Yeah, Michelle, thanks so much for the update. I noticed in the correspondence that staff is moving forward with, if not quiet cars, quiet zones within cars. Correct, a quiet car. Apparently, that term is somehow copyrighted or whatever.

198
00:20:28,960 --> 00:20:56,980
So we're looking for a new term. So if anyone has any good ideas, and then second, I just want to note that on those safety measures that you alluded to that have been installed at Broadway Burling game and now Churchill in Palo Alto, several of us got a first hand walk through with Mike meter on really the details of those because I hadn't quite understood how the package all work.

199
00:20:56,980 --> 00:21:01,360
You know, we had heard it here, but until you go to an intersection, and one of the things

200
00:21:01,360 --> 00:21:05,640
that was really striking is, in addition to a whole bunch of other measures, the rail

201
00:21:05,640 --> 00:21:16,620
century, triggers an alert if someone lingers for 10 seconds in the crosswalk or moves out

202
00:21:16,620 --> 00:21:19,380
of the crosswalk upstream for two seconds.

203
00:21:19,380 --> 00:21:31,020
And then at our top committee, Mike presented a mock-up of a technology that's like a cattle

204
00:21:31,020 --> 00:21:36,260
guard for people that will be placed outside of the crosswalk.

205
00:21:36,720 --> 00:21:49,300
And I'm just really excited about how strong the access prevention will be from this

206
00:21:49,300 --> 00:21:58,200
a set of measures more than I think many of us thought was possible. And lastly, I noted

207
00:21:58,200 --> 00:22:06,100
that the weekday ridership is now up to 52% of pre-COVID. Overall, we're up to 65.

208
00:22:06,860 --> 00:22:15,240
But are we able to disaggregate the weekday numbers so that we know what where we are on

209
00:22:15,240 --> 00:22:20,480
mute hours, which is what really drives a number of trains and drives the need for grade

210
00:22:20,480 --> 00:22:21,100
crossings.

211
00:22:21,920 --> 00:22:28,320
Yeah, in answer to that, we do have a methodology that we use that is based on assumptions

212
00:22:28,860 --> 00:22:38,140
and clipper data, the great thing that I'm reporting it now, we have just finished some testing

213
00:22:38,140 --> 00:22:43,520
on our APCs that now shows that we're in excess of 95% accuracy.

214
00:22:43,520 --> 00:22:48,220
So we're looking to get those implemented on the entire fleet by end of August.

215
00:22:48,980 --> 00:22:56,420
I will report back in September on that, but that really is going to give us a train by train station by station.

216
00:22:57,560 --> 00:23:00,000
Composite and that will help us with all of our future planning.

217
00:23:00,960 --> 00:23:01,140
Yep.

218
00:23:04,040 --> 00:23:10,840
Michelle, you mentioned a fair box recovery number and you said it too fast for me to remember it.

219
00:23:12,100 --> 00:23:17,760
It's that we think roughly 30%, so it was 30% for last fiscal year.

220
00:23:18,000 --> 00:23:26,140
We're waiting for the audited numbers, so I believe it's in excess of 30% at this point.

221
00:23:26,320 --> 00:23:28,900
And where we were during the boom time?

222
00:23:29,060 --> 00:23:29,620
More than that.

223
00:23:31,620 --> 00:23:34,180
We were at almost 75%.

224
00:23:34,180 --> 00:23:34,400
Yeah.

225
00:23:35,060 --> 00:23:35,180
Yeah.

226
00:23:36,540 --> 00:23:43,700
Okay. Colleagues, any other questions, comments? Any public comment on the report?

227
00:23:44,140 --> 00:23:49,540
We do have one in-person and a virtual handway, so that starting in-person is Jeff Carter.

228
00:23:57,430 --> 00:24:03,950
All right. Thank you very much. I really appreciate the report, especially the safety improvements

229
00:24:03,950 --> 00:24:08,030
at grade crossings and I'd like to hear more about rail

230
00:24:08,030 --> 00:24:11,250
sentry as mentioned by Director Burke.

231
00:24:12,290 --> 00:24:15,010
But sounds like we're, CalTrain really

232
00:24:15,010 --> 00:24:18,470
makes some good progress at the grade crossings.

233
00:24:20,210 --> 00:24:22,930
Of course, ridership, I mentioned that earlier.

234
00:24:23,610 --> 00:24:24,670
I'm just meant in a report.

235
00:24:25,630 --> 00:24:27,650
Week end is up significantly.

236
00:24:28,030 --> 00:24:32,490
And I think that's because of the every 30-minute service.

237
00:24:32,490 --> 00:24:42,170
Now you don't have to really think about taking the train because it was running once per hour, but now every 30 minutes, that's a big, big difference.

238
00:24:42,650 --> 00:24:44,090
And that's a big, you know, incentive.

239
00:24:45,110 --> 00:24:59,570
And then as far as coordinating with Bart, you know, I know that the budget probably won't allow it, but at some point, maybe Carl Trink get to every 20 minute service that would match, you know, the Bart service, which is every 20 minutes currently.

240
00:25:00,000 --> 00:25:29,980
Member and members, so lead a decree for the record. She and her with team vaults. Good helpful report today. Thank you. 65% on our ridership. My expectations are exceeded. I think we're going to get a few more points by the end of the year. I think we think we can hit 75% by the end of the year. We're getting close to what's happening in New York. They're running about 80 to 90% on their commuter rail. I think people are going

241
00:25:29,980 --> 00:25:36,900
to come back to work in person. But more so, there's new users out there that we haven't seen yet,

242
00:25:38,000 --> 00:25:44,360
that we can show them the benefits of riding our train, especially with half-hour clock face

243
00:25:44,360 --> 00:25:50,640
service. It's pretty hard to find a place to park in San Carlos or San Mateo or Berlin Game.

244
00:25:51,700 --> 00:25:58,600
Take the train. You know, Berlin Game is kind of like the rodeo drive of the Bay Area. I was there

245
00:25:58,600 --> 00:26:02,920
yesterday and had dinner. That's very nice there.

246
00:26:05,560 --> 00:26:07,960
And Fairbox Recovery, we're coming back.

247
00:26:08,360 --> 00:26:16,280
I mean, certainly all the other funding we have to work on. As far as Bart transfers go, I mean,

248
00:26:16,300 --> 00:26:22,960
it's hard to get a number for that because let's say that I buy a day pass through the app,

249
00:26:22,960 --> 00:26:27,320
And then I get on Bart, which uses Clipper exclusively.

250
00:26:28,060 --> 00:26:30,820
Well, there's really no way that you're going to know that.

251
00:26:32,320 --> 00:26:35,700
So we have to allow that there may be some more Bart transfers

252
00:26:35,700 --> 00:26:39,460
for people who are using other means of paying for CalTrain,

253
00:26:40,040 --> 00:26:42,540
whether it be the app, which I use sometimes,

254
00:26:43,300 --> 00:26:50,400
or the small cadre of people that are buying tickets at our vending machines.

255
00:26:51,620 --> 00:26:53,700
So overall, it's a good report.

256
00:26:54,820 --> 00:26:57,840
I think our ridership is going to go up from here.

257
00:26:58,280 --> 00:26:58,680
Thank you.

258
00:26:59,920 --> 00:27:01,780
Next we have is Adrian Brent.

259
00:27:08,150 --> 00:27:09,350
Okay, there's the unmute.

260
00:27:10,550 --> 00:27:10,970
Thank you.

261
00:27:11,210 --> 00:27:14,830
Yeah, I wanted to tag on to the rail century conversation.

262
00:27:16,090 --> 00:27:20,070
What director Bert was talking about is all really great stuff

263
00:27:20,070 --> 00:27:23,970
and I really applaud Mike and everyone involved on the rail

264
00:27:23,970 --> 00:27:30,490
century, including the additional pavement markings, the soft hit, the linear pull, the

265
00:27:30,490 --> 00:27:35,730
linear pull, all of that is really proving to be very effective, very exciting stuff.

266
00:27:36,660 --> 00:27:44,290
The next segment I think of crossing danger that I think rail century is not yet addressing

267
00:27:44,290 --> 00:27:53,410
and I'm not sure it can, is automated enforcement of vehicle code violations that are occurring

268
00:27:53,410 --> 00:27:59,590
chronically all the time at many of our busy crossings including Churchill and

269
00:27:59,590 --> 00:28:05,990
Palo Alto. And that is where motorists are often mindedly or deliberately or

270
00:28:05,990 --> 00:28:11,010
impatiently they queue across the railroad tracks. And so that's where they're

271
00:28:11,010 --> 00:28:16,410
stopping their vehicle in a queue of cars waiting for a traffic light. And that is

272
00:28:16,410 --> 00:28:21,010
against the vehicle code. You're never allowed to begin crossing unless there is

273
00:28:21,010 --> 00:28:24,090
enough room to get your vehicle all the way across safely.

274
00:28:24,790 --> 00:28:28,070
There are camera systems that automatically

275
00:28:28,530 --> 00:28:31,090
can site those, catch those violations.

276
00:28:32,810 --> 00:28:34,930
And you can site or send warning letters

277
00:28:34,930 --> 00:28:37,970
like they do in Florida with Brightline.

278
00:28:38,610 --> 00:28:41,910
And increasingly we're hearing about the new speed cameras

279
00:28:41,910 --> 00:28:43,690
in San Francisco, et cetera.

280
00:28:44,070 --> 00:28:45,930
It's a super, super dangerous behavior.

281
00:28:46,490 --> 00:28:49,250
It can result in obviously a fatality and has

282
00:28:49,250 --> 00:28:52,190
and can damage our trains, in the worst case,

283
00:28:52,350 --> 00:28:54,850
can even derail a train if you're very unlucky.

284
00:28:55,070 --> 00:28:58,170
There have been cases of vehicles derailing trains.

285
00:28:58,170 --> 00:28:59,810
It's not common, but it's possible.

286
00:29:00,310 --> 00:29:03,570
So I think it's really the next low-hanging fruit piece

287
00:29:03,570 --> 00:29:04,590
that needs to be addressed.

288
00:29:05,350 --> 00:29:07,990
So, and I'm sure Mike and the team are thinking about it,

289
00:29:08,050 --> 00:29:09,310
but I wanted to bring it to your attention.

290
00:29:09,650 --> 00:29:10,010
Thank you.

291
00:29:11,370 --> 00:29:12,710
Last speaker is Roland.

292
00:29:16,360 --> 00:29:16,780
Thank you.

293
00:29:16,960 --> 00:29:19,420
And I've got a quick question to say in my hand,

294
00:29:19,420 --> 00:29:21,420
was raised before you went to closed session.

295
00:29:21,580 --> 00:29:23,440
Is this an appropriate time to make the comment

296
00:29:23,440 --> 00:29:24,260
that I was going to make?

297
00:29:24,660 --> 00:29:25,560
No, it's his email.

298
00:29:26,700 --> 00:29:27,020
Sure.

299
00:29:28,320 --> 00:29:28,800
OK.

300
00:29:29,940 --> 00:29:31,320
So let me kiss Samara.

301
00:29:31,480 --> 00:29:34,480
And then I'll speak to the executive director's comment.

302
00:29:35,620 --> 00:29:37,780
And then I'd like to bring you attention.

303
00:29:38,040 --> 00:29:40,220
Maliza Maliza was not reaching to the record.

304
00:30:00,000 --> 00:30:29,980
We know who the responsible party is. It's very well documented in the NTSB final accident report, but none of that report can be deposed in court of evidence. The appropriate code of action is to reach out to plaintiff counsel and recommend that they redirect the lawsuit to the actual party responsible for what happened. Now moving on to the executive directly.

305
00:30:29,980 --> 00:30:38,120
this report, as Chair Heminger pointed out, the Fairbox Recovery is not tracking the

306
00:30:38,120 --> 00:30:39,540
ridership recovery.

307
00:30:39,880 --> 00:30:46,600
That's an issue that needs to be studied and addressed as smart, currently at 130 percent

308
00:30:46,600 --> 00:30:54,380
of Fairbox Recovery, and in closing on the gray crossings, what's happening is very encouraging.

309
00:30:55,360 --> 00:31:02,780
The issue I've got is that the previous comments are commented about people backing up on the tracks.

310
00:31:03,360 --> 00:31:12,180
The issue that you've got is that you do not have road markings, clearly delimitating the area where people are not supposed to be backing up.

311
00:31:12,800 --> 00:31:18,660
And the way automated code enforcement is done in the UK is not because they just kind of stuck on the tracks.

312
00:31:18,660 --> 00:31:25,600
It's when the out of gate tries to close, the detection system detects a calendar track

313
00:31:25,600 --> 00:31:27,740
a lot of times, two things happen.

314
00:31:28,200 --> 00:31:32,680
The PTC stops the train and the camera takes a picture with a $1,000 fine.

315
00:31:32,880 --> 00:31:33,180
Thank you.

316
00:31:34,300 --> 00:31:35,760
That ends public comments.

317
00:31:36,600 --> 00:31:42,660
Thank you, Madam Secretary, which brings us to item 9, the consent calendar, which consists

318
00:31:42,660 --> 00:31:46,900
of items 9A through 9K.

319
00:31:46,900 --> 00:31:53,000
Okay. So first of all colleagues, is there a request for many of you to consider any

320
00:31:53,000 --> 00:31:54,260
of these matters separately?

321
00:31:58,220 --> 00:32:01,540
Seeing none, why don't we get it on the table? Is there

322
00:32:01,540 --> 00:32:08,060
a motion to approve the consent calendar? Still move? Is there any public comment on the

323
00:32:08,060 --> 00:32:11,940
consent calendar? There are no public comments. Okay. So let's call the roll.

324
00:32:12,420 --> 00:32:15,800
Director Abikoga? I. Director Burt. Yes. Director Cohen.

325
00:32:15,800 --> 00:32:17,520
one. All right. Director G. Yes.

326
00:32:17,680 --> 00:32:19,040
Circuit Walton. All right.

327
00:32:19,160 --> 00:32:20,360
Director Zimuda. All right.

328
00:32:20,520 --> 00:32:21,740
Vice Chair Medina. Yes.

329
00:32:21,960 --> 00:32:24,060
Chair Heminger. All right. Motion passes.

330
00:32:25,060 --> 00:32:25,720
Wonderful.

331
00:32:26,920 --> 00:32:29,800
That brings us down to item 10,

332
00:32:30,120 --> 00:32:34,640
which is a report on a report

333
00:32:35,420 --> 00:32:40,600
that we will shortly hear from Peter Rogoff about.

334
00:32:40,980 --> 00:32:41,940
I assume

335
00:32:41,940 --> 00:32:47,280
And our executive director would like to give him a few words of introduction.

336
00:32:47,280 --> 00:32:54,920
If she doesn't mind, I'll take the privilege of the chair and add to hers because I probably

337
00:32:54,920 --> 00:32:58,740
have known Peter a little bit longer than I've known Michelle.

338
00:32:59,760 --> 00:33:06,900
And I think we met on the Hill when you were working for the Senate Appropriations Committee.

339
00:33:07,760 --> 00:33:16,420
And Peter, no matter who he was meeting with, had a skull for everybody because the authorizing

340
00:33:16,420 --> 00:33:21,920
committees in the Congress like to promise the moon to anybody who crosses their doorstep.

341
00:33:22,280 --> 00:33:27,500
And then they dump the funding requests on the appropriators and they've got to figure

342
00:33:27,500 --> 00:33:28,720
out a way to pay for it.

343
00:33:29,200 --> 00:33:32,740
So it's a dynamic, I think, that continues to this day.

344
00:33:34,060 --> 00:33:38,780
But it was especially suited, I think, to Peter's temperament.

345
00:33:40,160 --> 00:33:46,440
In between then and now, he of course served as our nation's federal transit administrator.

346
00:33:47,940 --> 00:33:51,740
And I'm sure he's got plenty of war stories to tell about that.

347
00:33:53,860 --> 00:34:01,680
But it's been a pleasure knowing him this long and it's a pleasure introducing him and handing it off to you, Michelle, to do the honors.

348
00:34:02,540 --> 00:34:10,020
Thank you chair and I'll be I'll be very brief. Really appreciate Peter coming to talk to the board.

349
00:34:11,300 --> 00:34:19,420
Just with respect to context, as you all know, we are in the process of rebuilding our capital team.

350
00:34:20,600 --> 00:34:29,860
And as part of that, I just thought it would be very important for us to really arm ourselves with a little bit of data.

351
00:35:00,000 --> 00:35:29,980
That can be basically under our control. I think all of us have experienced this, first of all, at CalTrain, but second, at some of the other agencies where all of you serve. In addition to hearing from Peter today, Sherry has been having conversations with some of our existing contractors to really try and figure out from their perspective what could lead to, I want to say more success.

352
00:35:30,980 --> 00:35:38,600
delivery, which also would include certainly pricing certainty, but we do find ourselves

353
00:35:38,600 --> 00:35:46,840
in a situation where our jobs are coming in over which they are potentially fundable,

354
00:35:47,080 --> 00:35:53,260
even with some of the funding resources that we have through various transportation authorities.

355
00:35:53,620 --> 00:35:59,160
So I just wanted to use this opportunity to level set everybody's understanding of the influences

356
00:35:59,160 --> 00:36:04,880
that we're seeing out in the market. And I can't think of a better person to talk about that

357
00:36:04,880 --> 00:36:12,920
than Peter. I've actually became familiar with him during an APTA CEO's conference during which

358
00:36:12,920 --> 00:36:18,100
he presented about a couple of years ago. And I know he's been doing some work with VTA as well.

359
00:36:18,640 --> 00:36:23,580
So with that as an introduction and context setting, Peter, I'll turn it over to you.

360
00:36:24,400 --> 00:36:42,880
Well, thank you, Michelle. And yes, Stephen, I met when we both had a lot more hair many years ago, and it's really good to be with you and I'll apologize quickly in advance to board member Bert, who had received a similar but now dated version of this presentation a couple of years ago.

361
00:36:42,880 --> 00:36:46,400
So a lot has already been said about my background.

362
00:36:46,400 --> 00:36:50,620
I would just point out separate from my spin around government in a variety of positions.

363
00:36:51,340 --> 00:36:58,620
I did head up sound transit in Seattle, the regional transit provider that does both bus rapid

364
00:36:58,620 --> 00:37:04,000
transit and light rail and commuter rail for the less than seven years before going off

365
00:37:04,000 --> 00:37:05,560
into private practice where I am now.

366
00:37:05,560 --> 00:37:14,100
Now, I was really been asked as I have a number of times now to provide background on the

367
00:37:14,100 --> 00:37:18,880
acute cost pressures and sizable cost growth that a number of agencies have experienced.

368
00:37:19,080 --> 00:37:22,700
And I think the most important thing to just remind people in terms of grounding this

369
00:37:22,700 --> 00:37:28,220
discussion is this is not unique to transit projects and it is not unique to transportation

370
00:37:28,220 --> 00:37:32,860
projects, as you can see from this slide, it is something that's burdening infrastructure,

371
00:37:32,860 --> 00:37:35,860
not only all over the country but all over the world.

372
00:37:36,560 --> 00:37:38,580
While all projects have their own nuances,

373
00:37:39,220 --> 00:37:41,580
I'm going to discuss really the major factors

374
00:37:41,580 --> 00:37:43,940
that are driving this spiking costs

375
00:37:43,940 --> 00:37:46,260
in infrastructure construction

376
00:37:46,660 --> 00:37:50,660
and also conclude with some presenting some good news

377
00:37:50,660 --> 00:37:53,120
in terms of best practices that agencies are using

378
00:37:53,120 --> 00:37:56,320
to try to mitigate those costs

379
00:37:56,780 --> 00:37:58,860
even in this difficult pricing environment.

380
00:38:00,900 --> 00:38:02,560
Let me just catch up.

381
00:38:07,290 --> 00:38:11,890
I think most importantly, there was a lot of talk about supply chain challenges and

382
00:38:11,890 --> 00:38:17,410
the reality is, those have not returned to normal, notwithstanding what you might believe

383
00:38:17,410 --> 00:38:18,010
from the media.

384
00:38:18,150 --> 00:38:23,190
Earlier, 55% of surveyed construction firms reported that they are still having significant

385
00:38:23,190 --> 00:38:24,310
supply chain problems.

386
00:38:25,070 --> 00:38:29,590
As you can see, these graphs here from the Federal Reserve Economic Data Set show the price

387
00:38:29,590 --> 00:38:33,470
trajectory of the major construction materials through the first quarter of this year.

388
00:38:34,250 --> 00:38:38,090
And they make clear that the steady price climbs of the last five years have not yet really

389
00:38:38,090 --> 00:38:39,870
begun to seriously reverse themselves.

390
00:38:40,910 --> 00:38:46,610
To make matters even more challenging, transit projects specifically often require specialized

391
00:38:46,610 --> 00:38:52,570
components that require long lead times, and the uncertainty regarding future tariffs require

392
00:38:52,570 --> 00:38:58,630
a manufacturer is using any foreign content to assume worst-case scenarios when pricing

393
00:38:58,630 --> 00:38:59,290
their product.

394
00:39:00,330 --> 00:39:04,610
Even with these continuing price increases in material costs, there is another factor

395
00:39:04,610 --> 00:39:09,250
that looms far larger when it comes to driving up the cost of delivering these projects.

396
00:39:09,950 --> 00:39:15,110
And that is the acute shortage of skilled labor and the costs associated with obtaining and

397
00:39:15,110 --> 00:39:16,390
retaining skilled labor.

398
00:39:17,090 --> 00:39:22,130
As shown here, the annual survey performed by the associated general contractors showed

399
00:39:22,130 --> 00:39:26,890
that almost 80% of firms were struggling to fill some or all available positions.

400
00:39:27,610 --> 00:39:32,410
The industry wide shortages of skilled labor runs across all crafts and disciplines from

401
00:39:32,410 --> 00:39:36,410
carpenters, brick layers, pipe fitters, architects, and engineers.

402
00:39:37,130 --> 00:39:41,750
You hear that it is basically near impossible to find seasoned construction managers in the

403
00:39:41,750 --> 00:39:45,790
current market, and I will tell you from my own experience that the same is true for system

404
00:39:45,790 --> 00:39:46,270
engineers.

405
00:39:46,990 --> 00:39:56,370
When I was at Sound Transit, thanks to the $54 billion ballot measure we passed in 2016, we had five major projects progressing at the same time.

406
00:39:57,330 --> 00:39:59,910
And on a number of occasions we were saddened to learn

407
00:40:00,000 --> 00:40:29,020
Public hearing bonuses were effectively embedded somewhere in the prices we were being charged by our contractors. In the current market environment, what the contracting community is effectively saying is this. We know we are going to be busy for the next five years, no matter what. We are going to be incredibly selective on the projects that we will even bid on. But if you want to pay me a premium to build your project, I will take that premium and use it to steal staff and skilled crafts people away from my competitors to get your project built.

408
00:40:30,480 --> 00:40:34,840
We just aren't growing the pool of needed labor anywhere near, fast enough to meet demand.

409
00:40:35,220 --> 00:40:39,740
The associated building and contractors in their outlook for 2025 projected that we would

410
00:40:39,740 --> 00:40:46,660
need to attract 439,000 new workers into construction just to keep a pace with demand this year.

411
00:40:47,560 --> 00:40:52,200
Just two months ago, the NFIB reported that the shortage of the construction worker situation

412
00:40:52,200 --> 00:40:54,800
is actually worsened as this year has progressed.

413
00:40:56,020 --> 00:41:01,460
It is hard to overstate how much the historic surge in construction spending over the last

414
00:41:01,460 --> 00:41:05,780
four years is straining the capacity of the industry and fundamentally changing the

415
00:41:05,780 --> 00:41:09,160
negotiating leverage of contractors versus project owners.

416
00:41:09,940 --> 00:41:15,020
It was commonplace not that long ago and we all made remember these times that contractors

417
00:41:15,020 --> 00:41:20,540
would make money on some projects, lose money on others, with the goal of netting positive

418
00:41:20,540 --> 00:41:21,500
over the long term.

419
00:41:22,420 --> 00:41:27,760
Today, with this historic volume of construction money out on the street through the Recovery Act,

420
00:41:28,020 --> 00:41:33,020
through the Inflation Rejection Act, through the Chips Act, it's not hard to understand that

421
00:41:33,020 --> 00:41:37,740
no contractor wants to explain to their board in the current environment why they have lost money

422
00:41:37,740 --> 00:41:44,560
on any project. The AI revolution has also brought an entirely new demand segment to the construction

423
00:41:44,560 --> 00:41:50,980
market, data centers. AI companies are now willing to pay top dollar to get them built quickly.

424
00:41:51,500 --> 00:41:56,900
and quite frankly, public agencies really can't compete with those private AI companies in

425
00:41:56,900 --> 00:42:02,080
terms of the price they're willing to pay. Another cost driver for capital projects has been

426
00:42:02,080 --> 00:42:06,900
interest rates. Transit capital projects are of course financed using a wide variety of dead

427
00:42:06,900 --> 00:42:12,200
instruments and interest rates impact all of them. Rates are also impacting the carrying cost

428
00:42:12,200 --> 00:42:17,600
borne by the construction firms. Just a year ago the benchmark federal funds rate was at its highest

429
00:42:17,600 --> 00:42:22,640
level in 22 years. They have come down a bit obviously but we are still way above the levels

430
00:42:22,640 --> 00:42:27,400
experienced when the first cost estimates were developed for many of the projects currently

431
00:42:27,400 --> 00:42:33,560
trying to advance. Another important factor in the cost trajectory of these projects is reduced

432
00:42:33,560 --> 00:42:39,100
competition in the marketplace. I chose this particular project because it's less than four

433
00:42:39,100 --> 00:42:45,160
miles from my home in Seattle, but the state moved 520 bridge connects interstate 5 to the University

434
00:42:45,160 --> 00:42:51,280
the Washington campus and when washed out estimated, initially, they thought that it would

435
00:42:51,280 --> 00:42:53,380
cost roughly $800 million to replace.

436
00:42:54,380 --> 00:42:59,340
A couple of years ago, they received just two bids, the lowest of which was $1.3 billion.

437
00:43:00,640 --> 00:43:04,660
Back in 2021, the state received an average of six bids per project.

438
00:43:05,160 --> 00:43:10,660
In 2023, the average dropped to two and a half bids per project and today they have projects

439
00:43:10,660 --> 00:43:13,000
that are getting zero bids and just none.

440
00:43:13,800 --> 00:43:17,860
It also has to be noted that there have been a number of consolidations and mergers within

441
00:43:17,860 --> 00:43:21,620
the construction industry, which brings fewer competitors to the table.

442
00:43:22,960 --> 00:43:27,140
A much smaller and more recent project reflecting these troubling trends has been a bus rapid

443
00:43:27,140 --> 00:43:29,220
transit project in Raleigh, North Carolina.

444
00:43:30,140 --> 00:43:35,540
The new Bern Avenue BRT is the first of four planned BRT routes for Raleigh, and it basically

445
00:43:35,540 --> 00:43:39,260
involves fairly simple street work and some station work.

446
00:43:39,260 --> 00:43:44,960
This project was initially budgeted at $71.5 million with an estimated completion date

447
00:43:44,960 --> 00:43:46,260
at the end of this year.

448
00:43:47,160 --> 00:43:51,320
When they opened their bid solicitations in May of last year, they had received zero

449
00:43:51,320 --> 00:43:51,780
bids.

450
00:43:52,560 --> 00:43:56,740
When they went out for bid a second time, they received only one bid that was rejected

451
00:43:56,740 --> 00:43:57,580
as unaffordable.

452
00:43:57,840 --> 00:44:01,840
It was more than $40 million higher than the city's independent cost estimate.

453
00:44:02,820 --> 00:44:07,020
Only by going out a third time with smaller contract packages could they get something

454
00:44:07,020 --> 00:44:08,400
in the realm of affordability.

455
00:44:08,400 --> 00:44:14,280
The project is now expected to cost 97 million, given all the time it is taken to go out

456
00:44:14,280 --> 00:44:18,060
to bid three times the project now won't be delivered until 2030.

457
00:44:19,720 --> 00:44:24,440
In 2023, I had the opportunity to assist the White House Infrastructure Team in organizing

458
00:45:00,000 --> 00:45:29,720
Group of contractors. The continuing uncertainty around materials costs, labor availability, interest rates, and other factors like local permitting were requiring them to build those uncertainties into their asking price. The contractors today are looking for less complexity, less uncertainty, far less risk or shared risk with the project owner and a clear path to profitability. A very recent example of this has been the very sad but instructive lesson of the Washington Street Bridge and Providence

459
00:45:29,720 --> 00:45:35,600
Rhode Island. The bridge is a major arterial with very high traffic that had to be shut down overnight

460
00:45:36,040 --> 00:45:41,960
when an inspection revealed some very frightening structural concerns. Rhode Island DOT went to work

461
00:45:41,960 --> 00:45:47,660
right away to replace it. They estimated a new bridge would cost between 250 and 300 million and

462
00:45:47,660 --> 00:45:55,600
they invited more than 65 firms to submit bids. They received zero bids. When they surveyed the

463
00:45:55,600 --> 00:45:59,580
industry as to why nobody wanted to bid. It really came down to the complexity of the

464
00:45:59,580 --> 00:46:05,360
job and the contract terms right on Rhode Island DOT was insisting on. Basically, Rhode

465
00:46:05,360 --> 00:46:09,560
Island was using the old command and control approach to crafting their bid solicitation.

466
00:46:10,260 --> 00:46:14,900
They unilaterally set the terms and conditions and expected that the contracting community

467
00:46:14,900 --> 00:46:19,800
would be so enticed by such a large project that they would find a way to live within those

468
00:46:19,800 --> 00:46:22,700
terms. They were wrong and nobody bid.

469
00:46:23,940 --> 00:46:28,740
After extensive consultations with the industry, Rhode Island DOT eventually re-scoped to

470
00:46:28,740 --> 00:46:33,760
contract packages and revised their contract returns and received two bids.

471
00:46:34,640 --> 00:46:38,680
The new bridge is now finally under construction at a price that is nearly twice their initial

472
00:46:38,680 --> 00:46:42,020
estimate and will be delivered two years later than planned.

473
00:46:43,520 --> 00:46:48,620
So when you combine all the factors I've cited, the rising cost of materials, the supply chain

474
00:46:48,620 --> 00:46:54,620
disruptions, the acute shortage of skilled labor, higher interest rates, a lack of competition,

475
00:46:55,180 --> 00:47:00,420
and contractors either avoiding complexity or charging a premium for it, you end up with

476
00:47:00,420 --> 00:47:06,240
a skyward pointing curve on the construction cost index. This one happens to be produced by the

477
00:47:06,240 --> 00:47:12,040
Federal Highway Administration for Highway projects. Sadly, the FTA doesn't produce a parallel

478
00:47:12,040 --> 00:47:18,180
index just for transit projects, but if they did, given the added complexity of major transit projects,

479
00:47:18,180 --> 00:47:20,460
that cost curve might be even steeper.

480
00:47:21,380 --> 00:47:23,780
Transit projects can introduce unique risks.

481
00:47:24,160 --> 00:47:26,580
They are often built in dense urban environments

482
00:47:26,580 --> 00:47:28,500
that require limited construction hours

483
00:47:28,500 --> 00:47:30,780
and carry mandatory noise restrictions.

484
00:47:31,460 --> 00:47:34,940
They often involve extensive utility relocations.

485
00:47:35,180 --> 00:47:37,040
And as I know, you've experienced in California,

486
00:47:37,400 --> 00:47:39,680
we've certainly experienced in Washington State.

487
00:47:40,380 --> 00:47:42,720
The utilities can either be very cooperative

488
00:47:42,720 --> 00:47:43,940
or not very cooperative.

489
00:47:44,340 --> 00:47:45,780
And it just takes a whole lot of work

490
00:47:45,780 --> 00:47:46,800
to get them to the table.

491
00:47:47,700 --> 00:47:51,740
The property is often required to be purchased from private and public entities that may seek

492
00:47:51,740 --> 00:47:55,500
to delay the project to extract a higher price for the needed land.

493
00:47:56,520 --> 00:48:00,600
Local municipal governments often seek to impose their own will on projects being built

494
00:48:00,600 --> 00:48:04,120
within their city limits, adding to the risk and cost of the project.

495
00:48:04,840 --> 00:48:09,940
In the worst case scenarios, municipalities can insist on project changes very late in

496
00:48:09,940 --> 00:48:12,780
the process, triggering expensive change orders.

497
00:48:14,240 --> 00:48:19,060
The data I've been citing has all been national in scope and it's hard to tell if a situation

498
00:48:19,060 --> 00:48:23,800
is even more acute in California, but there is data available indicating that the challenges

499
00:48:23,800 --> 00:48:25,380
in California are very real.

500
00:48:26,300 --> 00:48:32,280
CalTrans publishes a very transparent, quarterly project watch list identifying projects that

501
00:48:32,280 --> 00:48:37,020
are at risk of exceeding their budget estimates, including projects that might exceed those estimates

502
00:48:37,020 --> 00:48:38,460
by more than 20%.

503
00:48:39,240 --> 00:48:44,240
I recently compared the reports between March of 2021 and the report from March of this year.

504
00:48:45,020 --> 00:48:49,300
And over that four-year span, the total number of cow trans projects deemed to be at risk

505
00:48:49,300 --> 00:48:55,060
for budget overruns more than doubled and the estimated dollars at risk based on the size

506
00:48:55,060 --> 00:49:00,640
of those projects for those projects grew by 634% over four years.

507
00:49:01,300 --> 00:49:06,460
The number of projects categorized as very high risk grew by 141%.

508
00:49:06,460 --> 00:49:09,200
namely likely to grow by 20% or more.

509
00:49:09,920 --> 00:49:13,880
While these numbers are grim, there actually is some positive news embedded in this data.

510
00:49:14,440 --> 00:49:18,160
While the percentage of projects at high or very high risk continues to grow,

511
00:49:18,420 --> 00:49:21,480
the rate at which they are growing is finally slowing down.

512
00:49:21,720 --> 00:49:24,740
So it's possible that we may actually be turning a corner.

513
00:49:26,100 --> 00:49:29,580
There are also added challenges of building projects in California that

514
00:49:29,580 --> 00:49:32,800
informs contractors thinking when bidding on projects here.

515
00:49:33,520 --> 00:49:39,060
contractors must price into their bid's risk premiums due to California's litigation

516
00:49:39,060 --> 00:49:44,340
climate, union labor requirements, and intense scrutiny from regulatory agencies.

517
00:49:45,780 --> 00:49:50,240
So how can public agencies still get their projects built in this extraordinarily challenging

518
00:49:50,240 --> 00:49:51,240
pricing environment?

519
00:49:51,880 --> 00:49:56,860
And the good news is that there actually are several best practices that are emerging that agencies

520
00:49:56,860 --> 00:49:59,980
these can employ to contain costs even on-

521
00:50:01,420 --> 00:50:20,500
They recognized that there were still riskiest, they had talked to their contractors who identified some of the riskiest elements that were driving their bid prices. And basically, mastod at MBTA decide, you know what, we'll do those jobs separately, sometimes with our own workforce, take it off the table so you could take that out of your price.

522
00:50:23,110 --> 00:50:28,410
AGCs can consider stipends to keep more competitors interested in the project longer, and I will

523
00:50:28,410 --> 00:50:31,390
tell you that we did this with some considerable success up in Seattle.

524
00:50:31,650 --> 00:50:37,630
We actually paid firms, we pre-qualified three firms when we were building a major maintenance

525
00:50:37,630 --> 00:50:41,690
facility, and we gave them each a million dollars to help develop their plans and their bids.

526
00:50:42,310 --> 00:50:47,090
It didn't cover all of their costs, but it made three of the companies much more receptive

527
00:50:47,090 --> 00:50:49,870
to staying in the game until we selected a final winner.

528
00:50:51,010 --> 00:50:59,810
and I should say even those agencies that didn't win, we were able to use some of the concepts in their bids in the final design for the best possible project.

529
00:51:01,010 --> 00:51:10,270
Increasingly, agencies are learning that if they can consult with the contract in community, they can bundle contracts and sequence work in a manner that brings more bidders to the table.

530
00:51:10,270 --> 00:51:21,570
Some contractors are much more comfortable taking on smaller jobs than large complex ones that are either beyond their expertise or beyond their ability to secure the necessary bonding or insurance.

531
00:51:22,630 --> 00:51:30,690
They may be fine with, for example, building station platforms as part of a rail extension, but they don't want any part of building the electrical substations.

532
00:51:32,290 --> 00:51:36,830
Nothing drives up the cost of projects more quickly than late breaking and painfully expensive

533
00:51:36,830 --> 00:51:41,710
change orders, and sadly, the reality is we have some construction firms out there who have

534
00:51:41,710 --> 00:51:47,070
seemingly embraced change orders as a business strategy. They submit the lowest bid to get the

535
00:51:47,070 --> 00:51:52,950
work knowing that their path to profitability is through change orders. When it comes to transit

536
00:51:52,950 --> 00:51:57,890
projects agencies need to get all the stakeholders to understand the trade-offs that must be made.

537
00:51:58,570 --> 00:52:03,030
Community leaders and elected officials need to appreciate that once the music has stopped

538
00:52:03,030 --> 00:52:08,390
on the design, they are not free to demand changes or hold up permits until those changes

539
00:52:08,390 --> 00:52:08,910
are made.

540
00:52:09,910 --> 00:52:14,490
This education efforts requires a ton of outreach at the very beginning of the project

541
00:52:14,490 --> 00:52:15,830
to get everyone on board.

542
00:52:16,910 --> 00:52:20,870
Project owners also need to make sure that they are selecting a delivery method for the project

543
00:52:20,870 --> 00:52:23,650
that actually matches their staff's ability to execute it.

544
00:52:24,770 --> 00:52:28,990
Lastly, while project owners naturally want to tell their taxpayers when a project will

545
00:52:28,990 --> 00:52:33,610
finally be delivered, it may make more sense for them to first consult with the contracting

546
00:52:33,610 --> 00:52:39,310
community on when it can be delivered given their availability and availability of needed

547
00:52:39,310 --> 00:52:39,690
labor.

548
00:52:40,130 --> 00:52:45,330
What you don't want to do is promise the project by a certain date and have a celebratory

549
00:52:45,330 --> 00:52:50,390
ground breaking and then watch the project get further and further behind schedule because

550
00:52:50,390 --> 00:52:54,130
is the contractor can't get the needed skilled labor on site.

551
00:52:54,900 --> 00:52:57,690
A contractor may bid a much more reachable price

552
00:52:58,040 --> 00:53:01,610
if they know that your project could fit into their schedule.

553
00:53:03,210 --> 00:53:06,850
So in conclusion, the many cost drivers I have cited

554
00:53:06,850 --> 00:53:09,230
are being felt across all infrastructure sectors,

555
00:53:09,410 --> 00:53:11,970
not just transit, not just transportation projects,

556
00:53:12,370 --> 00:53:13,890
and not just in the United States.

557
00:53:14,690 --> 00:53:16,650
Marketplace dynamics have changed dramatically

558
00:53:16,650 --> 00:53:19,490
due to strained industry capacity, lack of competition,

559
00:53:19,490 --> 00:53:24,750
high interest rates and contractors pursuing less complex and more profitable projects.

560
00:53:25,850 --> 00:53:29,690
And the new cost estimates for cow train projects and the similar projects in this region

561
00:53:29,690 --> 00:53:31,890
are in line with those national trends.

562
00:53:32,910 --> 00:53:36,670
Market conditions in the construction industry are always in flux, but I will tell you when

563
00:53:36,670 --> 00:53:41,290
I administered the Federal Transit Component of the Recovery Act in the early years of the

564
00:53:41,290 --> 00:53:46,390
first Obama term, we benefited from a very beneficial pricing environment when construction

565
00:53:46,390 --> 00:53:51,990
firms were thrilled to get any kind of work. We were in the midst of the greatest recession since

566
00:53:51,990 --> 00:53:57,050
the Great Depression, and the contracting community was just focused on securing enough cash flow

567
00:53:57,490 --> 00:54:02,990
to pay their leases on their equipment and keep staff employed. The market environment today

568
00:54:02,990 --> 00:54:08,690
couldn't be more different with contractors focusing on avoiding uncertainty and taking great care

569
00:54:08,690 --> 00:54:13,670
when selecting the projects on which they build. But the good news is that there are a variety of

570
00:54:13,670 --> 00:54:18,390
measures that agencies can take to contain costs even under these dramatically different

571
00:54:18,390 --> 00:54:19,270
market conditions.

572
00:54:20,150 --> 00:54:24,090
So that pretty much summarizes my presentation and I'm happy to answer any questions or

573
00:55:00,000 --> 00:55:07,980
There were a lot of rice miles around here and I'll leave it at that. I did want to ask you

574
00:55:07,980 --> 00:55:16,140
just to kick things off about the first cost change because the first one often happens

575
00:55:16,140 --> 00:55:23,740
when you've got an engineer's estimate and you go out to bid or you reach some other

576
00:55:23,740 --> 00:55:31,560
major milestone and then you've got a bust. And the fact is the project was never going

577
00:55:31,560 --> 00:55:38,440
to be brought in at the original engineers estimate anyway. And I'm wondering because

578
00:55:38,440 --> 00:55:44,460
this is endemic, I mean it's project after project after project and whether it's escalation

579
00:55:44,460 --> 00:55:50,980
or some kind of reserve that they're not willing to acknowledge that there are things they

580
00:55:50,980 --> 00:55:56,020
don't know, and they won't know them until they get to a certain point in the construction.

581
00:55:56,720 --> 00:55:58,860
Is there a way to get at that problem?

582
00:55:59,340 --> 00:56:06,340
Because that's not the contractor, that's the government agency that is responsible for

583
00:56:06,340 --> 00:56:07,780
giving us some kind of benchmark.

584
00:56:08,720 --> 00:56:10,700
Well, two answers to that.

585
00:56:10,900 --> 00:56:16,280
One, I've thought a fair bit about, you move your, I'm sorry, there you go.

586
00:56:16,660 --> 00:56:19,920
I've thought a fair bit about, let's get that slide back up.

587
00:56:19,920 --> 00:56:25,560
But the cow trans data, and I said, well, there may be a silver lining because the rate

588
00:56:25,560 --> 00:56:28,840
at which things are growing is slowing down.

589
00:56:29,180 --> 00:56:31,300
They're still growing, but it's slowing down.

590
00:56:32,180 --> 00:56:36,000
That could be because prices are normalizing a bit.

591
00:56:36,700 --> 00:56:41,040
It could also be that those initial estimates are just getting better, which is to say the

592
00:56:41,040 --> 00:56:46,060
delta between the initial estimate and the actual price is narrowing, and that doesn't

593
00:56:46,060 --> 00:56:48,940
necessarily speak to anything being cheaper for the taxpayer.

594
00:56:52,300 --> 00:56:58,000
One of the challenges, well coupled, I would always identify, I would often say that,

595
00:56:58,060 --> 00:57:04,420
you know, when sometimes those initial cost estimates are put together, you're at somewhere

596
00:57:04,420 --> 00:57:10,600
between zero and 30 percent design, there's just too many unknowns in that which is why

597
00:57:10,600 --> 00:57:15,180
at the federal level they insist on so much contingency when you're at such a low level

598
00:57:15,180 --> 00:57:21,140
of design, that in combination with the rapidity of which things are changing, and it's not

599
00:57:21,140 --> 00:57:27,520
just the material costs, labor costs, I guess I specifically focused on not just hiring

600
00:57:27,520 --> 00:57:32,320
the labor, but retaining them in this environment where someone's going to offer them an opportunity

601
00:57:32,920 --> 00:57:36,800
to go work for somebody else on a different job at a higher wage and a very short period

602
00:57:36,800 --> 00:57:44,920
of time, you know, the rate at which that has risen, you almost need to assume double digit

603
00:57:44,920 --> 00:57:52,060
percentage growth year-over-year. So when you're actually saying and putting a

604
00:57:52,060 --> 00:57:56,120
number and and transmitting it to a public owner be it a transit agency or a

605
00:57:56,120 --> 00:58:01,820
highway department and saying I can get this this is the price for something I'm

606
00:58:01,820 --> 00:58:07,320
going to deliver for you two and a half or three years hence they don't know that

607
00:58:07,320 --> 00:58:12,080
that trend is going to stop and and that often doesn't get into independent

608
00:58:12,080 --> 00:58:19,080
cost estimates. They have a tendency of looking at conditions now and companies that have the luxury

609
00:58:19,080 --> 00:58:24,240
of being selective are saying, I'm going to look at a worst-case scenario and bitter accordingly

610
00:58:24,240 --> 00:58:32,320
because again, my book is already busy for the next five years. So that's why I said, you know,

611
00:58:32,420 --> 00:58:38,520
the attitude seems to be, if you're willing to pay this premium, I'm willing to take on those risks

612
00:58:39,220 --> 00:58:44,220
and absent paying that premium. I'm going to be busy anyway with what I'm already booked up to do.

613
00:58:46,220 --> 00:58:52,560
It's like I say, a dramatically different mindset and attitude from where we were years ago,

614
00:58:53,620 --> 00:58:57,140
but the public owner is kind of need to adjust to the new reality.

615
00:58:58,460 --> 00:59:03,020
And I want to point out, you know, I don't want to make out the contractors to be

616
00:59:04,580 --> 00:59:09,460
you know, ripping anyone off and just lining their pockets.

617
00:59:10,580 --> 00:59:15,500
They are now starting to make the margins that they hope to make, you know, years ago.

618
00:59:17,560 --> 00:59:22,500
And they have boards of directors and in some cases public owners to answer to also.

619
00:59:22,500 --> 00:59:22,580
So,

620
00:59:25,450 --> 00:59:31,230
colleagues, anyone who joined the conversation, director G?

621
00:59:33,760 --> 00:59:46,140
Peter, thank you very much. I mean, this is my life. I mean, the work I do and there's so many ways to unpack what you've just shared and so many more stories to tell.

622
00:59:46,140 --> 00:59:51,920
I mean, we all have a role in cost management or cost increases.

623
00:59:52,400 --> 00:59:52,540
Yep.

624
00:59:53,100 --> 00:59:59,960
The public owner is burdened by bureaucracy and formulas and d-

625
01:00:00,000 --> 01:00:29,900
Books for decades, you know, and, you know, when I managed underground utility projects, I had to tell my administration, I'll blow that 5% in the first week and I did. I mean, you just started digging and you hit something and then it just falls apart right there. I've known elected officials in this region who say, well, it's $800 million right now. Maybe if I wait a little longer, the cost will go down. I know elected officials on a community

626
01:00:29,900 --> 01:00:34,920
center who will wait in during construction and want that change now, otherwise we won't go.

627
01:00:35,060 --> 01:00:42,040
I mean, the owner has a role in this to help manage cost or cost increases or mitigate changes.

628
01:00:42,380 --> 01:00:49,220
And the public owner is just alleging and looking backwards rather than looking forwards and anticipating.

629
01:00:49,220 --> 01:00:51,300
So the owner has a role in this too.

630
01:00:52,800 --> 01:00:59,080
Absolutely. I sometimes in the most frustrating parts of my career, I've said that the problem with

631
01:00:59,080 --> 01:01:06,340
public transportation is so damn public and sometimes that rears its head so in the sound

632
01:01:06,340 --> 01:01:12,240
transit taxing district we had 52 separate cities. We didn't build in all 52 but we built

633
01:01:12,240 --> 01:01:22,900
in many and we had to get permits for each one. And because we had such a large ballot measure

634
01:01:22,900 --> 01:01:29,600
pass, and because, not unlike California, the legislature is capped what local taxes can

635
01:01:29,600 --> 01:01:35,000
be raised. You're going through communities that are really hard pressed to just pay their bills.

636
01:01:36,180 --> 01:01:42,000
And here comes a transit agency that's $54 billion rich that wants to build through their community,

637
01:01:42,900 --> 01:01:48,320
and they start thinking about, well, maybe they'd also like to rebuild the street grid around all

638
01:01:48,320 --> 01:01:51,260
their stations because we haven't been able to afford to do that for years.

639
01:01:52,560 --> 01:01:55,840
And that somehow sometimes starts creeping into the project costs, right?

640
01:01:55,980 --> 01:02:00,080
I mean, those are the realities of building a public project.

641
01:02:00,400 --> 01:02:07,780
And that's why I talk about, if local leaders really want the project to be built,

642
01:02:07,780 --> 01:02:13,380
and are invested in its success, they also have to be invested in delivering it affordably,

643
01:02:13,840 --> 01:02:17,280
and not have the cost to be somebody else's problem.

644
01:02:18,320 --> 01:02:24,540
That's the typical what's in it for me, or current conversations about return to source.

645
01:02:25,420 --> 01:02:27,540
How do we get something out of it?

646
01:02:28,260 --> 01:02:32,740
The other trend line that you didn't talk about is the trend line for mega projects.

647
01:02:35,140 --> 01:02:42,480
My parent company's a construction company and we're just seeing the larger projects in the terms of mega project trends continue to grow.

648
01:02:42,480 --> 01:02:49,040
So, and not many firms are able to do that, and so the pond mega projects is getting smaller

649
01:02:49,040 --> 01:02:53,140
as the mega projects grow, 3, 4, 500, billion dollar projects.

650
01:02:53,620 --> 01:02:55,120
And that's just more challenging.

651
01:02:55,120 --> 01:03:01,220
Because as you know, the mergers and consolidations have brought fewer and fewer, I mean, you

652
01:03:01,220 --> 01:03:06,160
can almost count on one hand the number of firms that can come in and step in and do something

653
01:03:06,160 --> 01:03:06,640
like that.

654
01:03:07,700 --> 01:03:09,260
So, yes, absolutely.

655
01:03:11,440 --> 01:03:14,220
There's a slide I took out of this in the interest of time.

656
01:03:15,840 --> 01:03:20,720
In Missouri, the St. Louis Convention Center put out an expansion,

657
01:03:20,720 --> 01:03:25,220
their Convention Center, a fairly large project that also got zero bids

658
01:03:25,220 --> 01:03:26,520
in their first go-around.

659
01:03:27,360 --> 01:03:31,620
And when they asked the contracting community, you know, what's up?

660
01:03:31,620 --> 01:03:37,300
But they gave me like, hey, we're busy, your terms are kind of complicated.

661
01:03:38,420 --> 01:03:44,060
And by the way, we're also building a new sports arena and a whole new federal headquarters

662
01:03:44,060 --> 01:03:48,120
of the National Geospatial Agency.

663
01:03:48,960 --> 01:03:55,200
So even just having local capacity to be able to hire local capacity, we're not sure it's

664
01:03:55,200 --> 01:03:55,520
there.

665
01:03:56,480 --> 01:04:00,360
And if we have to pay, you're probably familiar with travelers.

666
01:04:02,080 --> 01:04:08,740
We in Seattle, we would, our contractors were importing skilled labor from other states.

667
01:04:09,200 --> 01:04:14,180
They would come in and work, you know, five or six days, get day off, work for, get

668
01:04:14,180 --> 01:04:14,820
flown home.

669
01:04:15,340 --> 01:04:16,660
You got to put them up in hotel rooms.

670
01:04:18,260 --> 01:04:20,780
You know, some of them were coming from Nebraska.

671
01:04:20,780 --> 01:04:25,760
I always felt they were getting Seattle wages while keeping their family in Nebraska.

672
01:04:25,760 --> 01:04:30,420
I always felt like I wanted to have the basketball concession in Nebraska because like they were

673
01:04:30,420 --> 01:04:33,800
doing really well and we needed them really badly.

674
01:04:35,700 --> 01:04:41,780
Now, you're sort of alluding to the toolkit of how we can help manage and I'm a fan for

675
01:04:41,780 --> 01:04:47,040
on these large projects, RFIs, getting at the contractor community and early laying out

676
01:04:47,040 --> 01:04:52,580
here the challenges and listening to what they will offer, the different project delivery

677
01:04:52,580 --> 01:04:57,920
methods, whether it be design bill, progressive design billed CMGs, CMGC stipends.

678
01:04:58,340 --> 01:04:59,980
we have to change as a problem.

679
01:05:00,000 --> 01:05:29,920
Donor, the way we deliver project and manage risk and share in that risk. And we have to de-risk projects, because the invisible hand in all of this are the insurance companies and others that are not willing to ensure we're not willing to bond. And they never show up at a meeting like this. They don't even pay attention. They're just looking at the sheet of the price. Yeah. Here's your price if you want to do it. Yeah. Increasingly folks are not, I wouldn't say it's a, it's, it's, it's

680
01:05:29,920 --> 01:05:30,960
pervasive at this point.

681
01:05:31,160 --> 01:05:32,700
But there are increasing number of examples

682
01:05:32,700 --> 01:05:34,580
where public owners are having to agree

683
01:05:35,320 --> 01:05:38,460
to monitor material costs

684
01:05:38,460 --> 01:05:41,260
and they will share in the cost of the upside.

685
01:05:41,900 --> 01:05:43,620
I've not seen it so much on labor costs,

686
01:05:44,260 --> 01:05:46,580
which is also always obviously a bigger driver.

687
01:05:48,120 --> 01:05:49,420
So yes, there is,

688
01:05:51,000 --> 01:05:53,500
I really think bringing folks in and saying,

689
01:05:54,600 --> 01:05:57,340
what about this project scares you the most

690
01:05:57,820 --> 01:06:01,120
And how can we either share in that cost,

691
01:06:01,600 --> 01:06:02,800
or can I take it off the table?

692
01:06:03,240 --> 01:06:04,620
Can I just bid that out separately

693
01:06:04,620 --> 01:06:07,300
for someone who might be specialized in that

694
01:06:07,300 --> 01:06:11,200
rather than you extend beyond your specialty

695
01:06:12,740 --> 01:06:14,320
and boost the price of it

696
01:06:14,320 --> 01:06:16,060
because you're just scared of it.

697
01:06:18,260 --> 01:06:19,740
And you might be able to,

698
01:06:19,940 --> 01:06:21,840
in the aggregate, bring the cost down.

699
01:06:22,220 --> 01:06:24,660
I also hear you on the different delivery methods

700
01:06:24,660 --> 01:06:26,220
I glossed over it rather quickly,

701
01:06:26,220 --> 01:06:35,900
But one of the things I really caution people is they just assume with all these different methods of delivering projects now that their staff can do any of them.

702
01:06:37,360 --> 01:06:42,520
And I will speak for myself we had a very rough time that sound transit for a few years.

703
01:06:43,520 --> 01:06:53,640
Moving from design bid bill to design build because we had because we had so many projects we had a lot of internal in house engineers that thought it was their job to design the project.

704
01:06:54,320 --> 01:06:59,680
and in a normal design bid build scenario it was and they were just very

705
01:06:59,680 --> 01:07:04,320
low to see that authority to contractor staff. So there was all this oversight

706
01:07:04,320 --> 01:07:08,240
going on and all of the second guessing going on and we were paying for it

707
01:07:08,240 --> 01:07:14,780
twice. Now I won't name a public agency south of here who was doing design bid

708
01:07:14,780 --> 01:07:19,340
build. I wanted to do CMGC design. Bill and all I did was word search and replace

709
01:07:19,340 --> 01:07:25,100
based design bid billed with CMGC, it doesn't work, it's a different culture, different mindset.

710
01:07:25,760 --> 01:07:30,600
The last comment and the chair mentioned this is that we know the players out there

711
01:07:30,600 --> 01:07:32,480
who will bid low and then change order.

712
01:07:33,360 --> 01:07:37,380
And we have to change the public owner, I believe the public owner culture just passing

713
01:07:37,380 --> 01:07:39,200
those contractors around to each other.

714
01:07:39,800 --> 01:07:45,820
They are just burning public owners left and right, and we all know who they are.

715
01:07:45,820 --> 01:07:51,740
And so any thoughts about how we can moderate those players that are out there?

716
01:07:52,320 --> 01:08:01,160
Well, because the lawyers are here, you know, saying that we should just name and shame them is carries risks.

717
01:08:02,040 --> 01:08:11,760
But I think there is, we at least in our, in our point, allotment process when competing projects in Seattle,

718
01:08:12,660 --> 01:08:20,100
were able to bring in the past performance of that contractor, at least on our projects.

719
01:08:21,560 --> 01:08:30,120
I think there should be ways within free and fair competition rules allowing you to have

720
01:08:30,120 --> 01:08:33,580
reputational issues brought into the conversation.

721
01:08:35,780 --> 01:08:44,760
I remember vividly watching one of, it was one of the cities, one of the 52 cities and

722
01:08:44,760 --> 01:08:51,800
I had caused to be watching the Everett City Council one day and watch them give for

723
01:08:51,800 --> 01:08:56,820
them a very large contract to a contractor that we had had just the hardest time with.

724
01:08:57,720 --> 01:09:02,180
And I was literally like texting the member of that council who was on my board saying,

725
01:09:02,180 --> 01:09:06,980
you know, you sure you want to do this, but things were wait, you know, they never asked us,

726
01:09:07,360 --> 01:09:12,800
right? So, you know, there's there should be a way of bringing those those conditions.

727
01:09:13,420 --> 01:09:19,200
The other reality, and I'm sure you've experienced this, there are some contractors who do a very

728
01:09:19,200 --> 01:09:24,780
good straight-up job five times out of six, and on that sixth job, it's just, you know, a litigious

729
01:09:24,780 --> 01:09:32,120
nightmare. Someone has to be careful for, you know, penalizing them into perpetuity. Sometimes that

730
01:09:32,120 --> 01:09:34,600
That might mean it was the owner's fault, not the contractors for it.

731
01:09:35,500 --> 01:09:39,660
No, I'm a big fan per qualification, where you can bring some of those things in, but

732
01:09:39,660 --> 01:09:45,040
it's just more work for the public owner, but I would argue cheaper work than paying attorneys

733
01:09:45,040 --> 01:09:48,100
on the back end in certain James, but it's just the reality of it.

734
01:09:48,140 --> 01:09:54,080
Well, the other thing is educating the public as to why you may not be taking the lowest bid.

735
01:09:55,800 --> 01:09:58,620
Because you said we're not going to pay that price in the end anyway.

736
01:09:58,620 --> 01:09:59,980
Thank you.

737
01:10:01,230 --> 01:10:28,610
As you've laid out, it's a really important topic and a really multifaceted one. There's not one panacea to solving it, but there are a number of areas that you and others have identified as really flaws in our current approach and which ones we might be able to turn the dial on and manage better ourselves, which ones were.

738
01:10:28,610 --> 01:10:44,550
We're subject to what's happening in the market right now, and just first touching on that you alluded to the difference between kind of the market during the Great Recession.

739
01:10:45,070 --> 01:10:57,650
We, in our city, had a major project and saw first time ever bids coming in well below projected estimates.

740
01:10:57,650 --> 01:11:05,210
We didn't see that during the COVID downturn because we primed the pump so much.

741
01:11:06,050 --> 01:11:11,870
Not to mention the whole supply chain disruption, those two factors coming together.

742
01:11:12,170 --> 01:11:13,930
And availability of labor during COVID?

743
01:11:14,490 --> 01:11:14,630
Yeah.

744
01:11:15,510 --> 01:11:27,250
But we're that those trends, the priming of the pump is now what we're continuing to see even after out of that COVID period.

745
01:11:27,250 --> 01:11:36,010
And I've thought that really a lot of the U.S. problem has been, you talked about the

746
01:11:36,010 --> 01:11:43,170
significant labor shortage at all levels, all the way up to kind of project upper levels

747
01:11:43,170 --> 01:11:47,430
in engineering and project management down to the skilled labor force.

748
01:11:48,390 --> 01:11:56,630
And as we've gone from a period nationally of under investing in major infrastructure projects,

749
01:11:56,630 --> 01:12:05,690
including transportation to a surge, it certainly seems like, unfortunately, that surge

750
01:12:05,690 --> 01:12:13,370
in overdue investment has compounded our problem perhaps pretty significantly on the

751
01:12:13,370 --> 01:12:18,570
cost side, and we really haven't been talking about that reality very much.

752
01:12:19,170 --> 01:12:23,550
And it's unfortunate because those of us who have said we've been under investing for

753
01:12:23,550 --> 01:12:30,510
long time, we get what we were looking for and we've created a whole new problem or at least

754
01:12:30,510 --> 01:12:37,550
compounded a problem that was already bad. But I do think that we need to recognize that.

755
01:12:38,330 --> 01:12:47,310
I also was thinking about kind of the overlap between the themes that you really pointed out

756
01:12:47,310 --> 01:12:55,810
and those that have been identified by Alon Levy in New York and their study on the transit

757
01:12:55,810 --> 01:13:02,990
cost project and then Flybear and all of his studies on mega projects and risks.

758
01:13:03,630 --> 01:13:10,230
Interestingly, we now have for the first time ever a book that is the masses are reading

759
01:13:10,230 --> 01:13:16,950
on many more of the masses on how big things get done and hopefully they'll then trickle

760
01:13:16,950 --> 01:13:20,770
down more of us into the more comprehensive studies.

761
01:13:20,970 --> 01:13:26,690
But a lot of that looks at why the US and certain other countries,

762
01:13:26,690 --> 01:13:35,290
and now Canada, are encountering drastically higher costs

763
01:13:35,290 --> 01:13:37,630
for these projects than elsewhere in the world,

764
01:13:37,630 --> 01:13:39,730
and what are the lessons to be learned there?

765
01:13:41,210 --> 01:13:44,610
And those, once again, the lessons are many.

766
01:13:44,610 --> 01:13:48,310
Unfortunately, it's not one or two and we solve the problem.

767
01:13:49,790 --> 01:13:54,650
But one of the things that struck me as I've been waiting into this even more deeply

768
01:13:54,650 --> 01:14:01,430
as you know on our BART extension, but actually I first kind of dove into this back when

769
01:14:01,430 --> 01:14:10,930
high speed rail first came forward in California and some really smart knowledgeable people predicting

770
01:15:00,000 --> 01:15:28,680
Look, you're heading down this path, and yet the policy makers and the policy makers and even leadership, executive leadership in agencies, continue to just head down a wrong path. And the educational part of that, how do we turn that around? I think, Michelle, bringing you here.

771
01:15:28,680 --> 01:15:44,780
is really valuable for us and it's part of what maybe needs to be a more systematic approach to how do we educate the policy makers, the executive teams,

772
01:15:45,600 --> 01:15:51,400
the legislators at the policy level, not just the agency, the press and the public.

773
01:15:53,240 --> 01:16:00,900
because if we aren't aligned in understanding how we need to do projects and the

774
01:16:00,900 --> 01:16:07,380
realities we face, then even if we get one or two of those segments starting to

775
01:16:07,380 --> 01:16:12,160
get it, we get pressure from elsewhere. I had, you know, we're looking in Palo Alto

776
01:16:12,160 --> 01:16:18,860
that we have through VTA, a committee on the future of the University Avenue

777
01:16:18,860 --> 01:16:29,060
intermodal station, one of the bigger regional hubs, and I had our local paper editor ask

778
01:16:29,060 --> 01:16:35,920
me just last week, well what's my grand vision for this and what would I really love to see

779
01:16:35,920 --> 01:16:44,040
and my answer was I want to see the best project that we can fund and execute. And he goes,

780
01:16:44,040 --> 01:16:49,980
No, but a whiteboard and I go no. We've got, I can show you five of those over the last 30 years

781
01:16:49,980 --> 01:16:58,980
and they've all gone nowhere. So I do think that your presentation today made me really reflect on

782
01:16:58,980 --> 01:17:08,600
how can we do a more deliberate and systematic education process that then will hopefully have

783
01:17:10,000 --> 01:17:16,100
a change in the systematic approaches at all levels and the understanding of what's

784
01:17:18,500 --> 01:17:26,340
feasible versus what we would ideally love to see and we start moving more toward what's

785
01:17:26,340 --> 01:17:26,780
feasible.

786
01:17:28,160 --> 01:17:32,740
And I'll add that one of the points that you brought out earlier on the skilled labor issue

787
01:17:32,740 --> 01:17:37,620
and then you went beyond the skilled labor into the engineering labor, etc.,

788
01:17:39,810 --> 01:17:45,740
four years ago as we were addressing electrification, transformation in our community

789
01:17:46,090 --> 01:17:52,340
and encountering the workforce, skilled labor workforce issues and the engineering workforce issues

790
01:17:52,340 --> 01:18:01,780
with that. I engage with our local legislators to look at the state taking on a more systematic

791
01:18:01,780 --> 01:18:25,360
approach to this in housing labor, electrification labor, and civil engineering labor, and to my knowledge we still don't have any real good analysis of what capacities we need over the next two decades to achieve the outcomes that we're anticipating and planning for.

792
01:18:25,360 --> 01:18:29,400
and then begin to address those capacity needs.

793
01:18:29,940 --> 01:18:32,680
We are on a piecemeal basis addressing capacity.

794
01:18:32,940 --> 01:18:34,640
Well, we know that we need more,

795
01:18:34,800 --> 01:18:36,360
so we're funding this program.

796
01:18:36,720 --> 01:18:38,540
But there's no systematic approach to it.

797
01:18:38,620 --> 01:18:43,040
There's no analysis that has really looked forward in these areas

798
01:18:43,040 --> 01:18:45,640
and say, what's the shortage?

799
01:18:46,340 --> 01:18:50,680
But we're just hoping that the market will actually catch up to demand

800
01:18:50,680 --> 01:18:52,440
and actually train all those people.

801
01:18:52,440 --> 01:19:18,300
and I wholeheartedly agreed is one of the, there actually was at one time a workforce development component of the infrastructure bill, at least in a variety of drafts that in order to make sure that it's stated by partisan infrastructure law, certain things fell out of it, and unfortunately the workforce piece of it did, I was not in the middle of those negotiations, but it had been reported to me.

802
01:19:18,300 --> 01:19:26,940
You know, this goes back a long way, going back to the dissolution of trade

803
01:19:26,940 --> 01:19:33,620
high schools, which we did away with in part because people had very strong

804
01:19:33,620 --> 01:19:36,840
feelings that everyone should have the opportunity to go to college and we

805
01:19:36,840 --> 01:19:40,580
should not be tracking people certainly based on income and race into certain

806
01:19:40,580 --> 01:19:45,900
tracks in high schools. So we eliminated them and just then somehow the the

807
01:19:45,900 --> 01:19:52,320
training and development, the whole kind of apprenticeship and process didn't have

808
01:19:52,320 --> 01:19:55,320
a pipeline, it had to be developed and it was very haphazard.

809
01:19:57,640 --> 01:19:59,840
And now you know when you asked about

810
01:20:00,000 --> 01:20:28,040
In a career potential, that learning carpentry or learning pipe fitting, or it would be very different. But, you know, I got two kids in their 20s, and sometimes they're on receive, and sometimes they're not listening to anything. And, you know, so it's, it's, um, the, uh, we really do need to kind of take on the workforce component. And your point about high speed railing, California, by itself,

811
01:20:28,040 --> 01:20:35,040
through its own community college system probably should be much more focused on serving as a pipeline.

812
01:20:35,360 --> 01:20:42,300
You know, you see when governors entice companies to open a manufacturing facility,

813
01:20:42,620 --> 01:20:48,200
or some kind of specialized facility, they often bring their community college system to the table

814
01:20:48,200 --> 01:20:52,760
and say, what do you need? We'll train it basically on the state's time.

815
01:20:53,900 --> 01:20:57,840
And probably we need to do that more comprehensively in this area.

816
01:20:59,160 --> 01:21:02,180
Yeah, I think you're exactly right on the role of community colleges.

817
01:21:02,240 --> 01:21:07,960
In fact, one of the things that we were discussing four years ago was whether the pilot for

818
01:21:08,920 --> 01:21:16,860
backloric degrees through community colleges in California might be extended to increase the

819
01:21:18,700 --> 01:21:29,620
the very limited number of universities in our state that provide degrees in, for

820
01:21:29,620 --> 01:21:34,440
instance, power supply engineering and things like that.

821
01:21:34,680 --> 01:21:37,280
We only have two or three schools in the whole state that do it.

822
01:21:38,220 --> 01:21:44,900
So I think you're right and we just need to, so how do we get the systematic approach?

823
01:21:44,900 --> 01:21:51,520
We need to get the legislators educated to understand the problem.

824
01:21:51,880 --> 01:21:54,540
We hear on our level need to understand it.

825
01:21:54,980 --> 01:21:59,900
But as I kept backing up stream, how do we get to the solution?

826
01:22:00,860 --> 01:22:03,240
We have legislators who don't understand this.

827
01:22:03,540 --> 01:22:11,700
They got big plates, but we need to really figure out how do we go into a significant,

828
01:22:11,700 --> 01:22:16,600
to maybe a series of these kinds of seminars and their tight schedules for at least a group

829
01:22:16,600 --> 01:22:22,060
of them, so they really understand the problems and they can help us solve it.

830
01:22:23,260 --> 01:22:27,660
Especially trying to bridge, you've got legislators who love to sit on the education committee

831
01:22:27,660 --> 01:22:30,660
and something who likes to sit on the transportation committee and I'm not sure they talk to

832
01:22:30,660 --> 01:22:31,060
each other.

833
01:22:31,700 --> 01:22:33,020
So it's, it's, it's, it's, thank you.

834
01:22:34,480 --> 01:22:38,980
Let me ask if there are any public comment on Peter's report.

835
01:22:39,700 --> 01:22:43,480
that now. Starting with in-person Jeff Carter.

836
01:22:53,200 --> 01:23:06,720
Thank you very much. Appreciate the report. I understand a lot of things that you've said. Being the blue collar myself. I understand, you know, skilled labor trying to find skilled labor.

837
01:23:07,640 --> 01:23:12,920
When I went to high school, they had shop classes. Now they don't seem to have shop classes anymore.

838
01:23:14,780 --> 01:23:22,020
The average age in my industry, which was a ship repair, the average age was over 50.

839
01:23:22,360 --> 01:23:26,700
So you couldn't find young people to come in here and learn these skills.

840
01:23:32,210 --> 01:23:38,030
Also, you mentioned change orders, company I worked for.

841
01:23:38,110 --> 01:23:43,750
They had experts that could go over every little thing and find any little thing to create

842
01:23:43,750 --> 01:23:49,750
to change order and make more money for the company, so I completely understand that.

843
01:23:52,070 --> 01:23:59,490
Then the other thing, you know, high speed rail, you know, it's long overdue and cost

844
01:23:59,490 --> 01:24:07,290
or runs, unfortunately, you know, there's people that use, you know, things like CEQUA to

845
01:24:07,290 --> 01:24:16,310
to delay these type of projects, and as mentioned, delay and projects brings up the cost.

846
01:24:16,890 --> 01:24:22,830
So I think I really appreciate the report, and the CalTrain is looking into this.

847
01:24:23,030 --> 01:24:23,290
Thank you.

848
01:24:24,430 --> 01:24:26,790
Moving over to virtual hands raised, Roland.

849
01:24:29,990 --> 01:24:31,030
Thank you.

850
01:24:31,170 --> 01:24:38,130
I really appreciate this presentation, and the way I look at it, if you look at the first

851
01:24:38,130 --> 01:24:46,290
20 slides. That pretty much describes basically what happened in Japan in the latter part of

852
01:24:46,290 --> 01:24:54,950
the last century. But a big difference in Japan is that most of the owners are private owners,

853
01:24:54,950 --> 01:24:59,970
private for profit on this and the Army recalls their gun.

854
01:25:00,000 --> 01:25:27,720
That's what the public owner would do. But how did they address these problems? Well, as I said, they had the exact same problem. In the case, the absentee chronic lack of a carpenters and retiring and not having a new generation of carpenters. They took a completely different approach, which was an engineering approach. They actually eliminated most of the carpentry in all that make a project.

855
01:25:28,700 --> 01:25:34,900
and they eliminated both the formwork and the falsework, so none of these props and all that,

856
01:25:35,040 --> 01:25:41,540
none of that exists, they're typically in Japan. And the way they did it is by starting a completely

857
01:25:42,320 --> 01:25:50,860
redesign of the Mega Project as a giant puzzle and breaking it all down into components and making sure

858
01:25:50,860 --> 01:25:58,000
that every single one of the components weighs less than 30 tons, so that they don't need special

859
01:25:58,000 --> 01:26:05,200
road permits to transport them to the building site, and then they assemble the gigantic puzzle at

860
01:26:05,200 --> 01:26:11,440
night. I'm not saying this anywhere in the United States, which possibly the exceptional exception

861
01:26:11,440 --> 01:26:17,080
of if you should look at NASA and SpaceX, be what SpaceX are doing, they essentially

862
01:26:17,080 --> 01:26:23,000
other Japanese equal the mega crochet. Thank you. Next we have Alita Dupri.

863
01:26:25,690 --> 01:26:30,390
Thanks again, Chair Steve. Having earned members Alita Dupri for the record she and her with

864
01:26:30,390 --> 01:26:36,670
team vaults. Wish I could be with you in person. I'm a big fan of sound transit. I have my reduced

865
01:26:36,670 --> 01:26:43,430
fare or record card had it for probably about a decade. So sound transit is always with me.

866
01:26:45,770 --> 01:26:54,170
I'm really seeing two parts to this complexity of contracting and a shortage of labor.

867
01:26:54,770 --> 01:26:59,990
I've seen it all over the country. When Las Vegas had a building boom of mega-resorts,

868
01:27:00,870 --> 01:27:06,290
a lot of workers came from all over the country to come in and do that heavy construction.

869
01:27:07,950 --> 01:27:14,390
and how do we get all this work done and the public's only willing to pay so much

870
01:27:14,390 --> 01:27:20,250
and I want to get this work done here at CalTrain and get it done at Bart

871
01:27:20,250 --> 01:27:24,850
and get 300 new accessible stations built on the New York City subway.

872
01:27:25,610 --> 01:27:28,690
And we're seeing the gateway tunnel between New York and New Jersey

873
01:27:28,690 --> 01:27:31,570
and Newport Authority bus terminals so much to do.

874
01:27:31,570 --> 01:27:34,310
So, where do we get the pipeline of people?

875
01:27:35,470 --> 01:27:43,730
I do wish that there was a greater pipeline of encouraging people over the years to learn

876
01:27:43,730 --> 01:27:44,490
the traits.

877
01:27:45,770 --> 01:27:47,570
I was blue collars they get.

878
01:27:48,210 --> 01:27:52,390
I just barely made it out of high school and ended up going in the army for a while.

879
01:27:52,390 --> 01:28:05,350
And so I worked in various kinds of blue collar work, but I wasn't involved in the skilled construction type trades.

880
01:28:06,270 --> 01:28:17,630
And I'm only one person. I'm retired now. But I believe that the trades are something that needs to absolutely be respected and promote it.

881
01:28:17,630 --> 01:28:25,470
because it really is the traits that are going to help bring the work forward in our country. Thank you.

882
01:28:26,570 --> 01:28:28,410
Next speaker is Doug Delong.

883
01:28:34,160 --> 01:28:35,800
Good morning, directors.

884
01:28:37,640 --> 01:28:43,060
Well, I appreciate all the thoughtful conversation that we've had on this item.

885
01:28:44,840 --> 01:28:51,500
But I had kind of a rather different take on the material.

886
01:28:51,500 --> 01:28:54,320
of this presentation that I reviewed in advance of the meeting.

887
01:28:56,840 --> 01:29:04,020
And it kind of resonated with some things that I've been aware of through, you know,

888
01:29:04,160 --> 01:29:09,300
concerned about issues like affordable housing and, you know, now what's getting a lot of

889
01:29:09,300 --> 01:29:16,760
press, the homelessness crisis, and, you know, years ago it was pretty clear to me that the

890
01:29:16,760 --> 01:29:24,300
local economy here in Mountain View, basically everything that wasn't the tech industry was being crushed by the tech industry.

891
01:29:27,120 --> 01:29:34,540
And, you know, the venture capital industry, their primary product is increasing income inequality.

892
01:30:00,000 --> 01:30:29,980
The question is to provide higher returns than any other vehicle. So their job, one, is increasing income and inequality. And they're very good at it. And they're creating homelessness faster than anybody could possibly deal with it. And now through this presentation, we're hearing that all these, this mania for AI data centers and crypto data centers, cryptocurrency data centers is basically throwing unlimited amounts of money at the

893
01:30:29,980 --> 01:30:35,520
construction industry and surprise surprise they have no interest in cost

894
01:30:35,520 --> 01:30:43,880
effectively bidding public infrastructure projects. So my takeaway is tech is

895
01:30:43,880 --> 01:30:47,380
not the solution, tech is the problem. Thank you very much.

896
01:30:48,780 --> 01:30:50,720
Last and final speakers, Adina Levin.

897
01:30:53,890 --> 01:31:00,110
Hello, Adina Levin with Seamless Bay Area. Glad to hear this presentation and to

898
01:31:00,110 --> 01:31:11,370
have the Caltrain Board engaging in this really important topic that impacts Caltrain and

899
01:31:11,810 --> 01:31:20,390
major projects in the Bay Area, California, and in the United States. It was good to hear

900
01:31:20,390 --> 01:31:29,750
where the interest in education, you know, at the higher level on what the problems are

901
01:31:29,750 --> 01:31:38,330
and what the causes are and potential ways of addressing them, there are initiatives

902
01:31:38,330 --> 01:31:46,070
like the Transit Cross project out of NYU that has, you know, put together a lot of information.

903
01:31:46,070 --> 01:31:51,330
There's Circula San Diego just put out a report this week.

904
01:31:52,240 --> 01:31:58,730
The Californians for Electric Rail have some good analysis about the role of patchwork

905
01:31:58,730 --> 01:32:11,490
funding in causing delays and overruns and having the education at the level of the people

906
01:32:11,490 --> 01:32:15,390
at agencies as well as people in the legislature is helpful.

907
01:32:16,170 --> 01:32:21,530
Last year, Buffy Wix led some hearings at Focus Day on permitting, and

908
01:32:21,530 --> 01:32:24,270
they talked about housing and energy and transportation.

909
01:32:24,830 --> 01:32:29,650
The transportation piece was the least mature, I think, out of that body of work.

910
01:32:30,390 --> 01:32:33,450
And there's an opportunity to come back and do more there.

911
01:32:34,050 --> 01:32:39,730
Another opportunity in the really short term, there's a state transit transformation task force,

912
01:32:39,730 --> 01:32:53,870
making policy recommendations to the legislature and there were some reluctance by transit to take this on would encourage Michelle Bouchart to work with CTA to make sure there's good recommendations coming out of that state task force. Thank you.

913
01:32:54,970 --> 01:32:57,010
We do have one more would you like to allow?

914
01:32:57,430 --> 01:32:58,070
Of course.

915
01:32:59,130 --> 01:32:59,970
Paul went.

916
01:32:59,970 --> 01:33:00,890
Hi,

917
01:33:03,240 --> 01:33:09,760
I'm just going to be very brief. This was just a wonderful eye-opening presentation. I applaud

918
01:33:10,440 --> 01:33:18,280
the speaker and and CalTrain board for for having this presentation that I just want to say. I

919
01:33:18,280 --> 01:33:23,000
attend these CalTrain board meetings and there's a lot of boring stuff that goes on and this just makes

920
01:33:23,000 --> 01:33:31,120
it all worthwhile to attend a very eye-opening. Most of the stuff I didn't realize, so thank you very

921
01:33:31,120 --> 01:33:34,300
much. That ends public comments.

922
01:33:34,660 --> 01:33:41,860
Well, and we won't take that personally, so colleagues, last call for any comments

923
01:33:41,860 --> 01:33:44,900
on this subject. Anybody?

924
01:33:46,220 --> 01:33:48,940
Peter, you're off the hook. It's great to see you again.

925
01:33:52,180 --> 01:33:58,700
That brings us to item 11, which is our legislative update and the proposed position on a bill.

926
01:34:01,320 --> 01:34:01,920
Mr. Baker.

927
01:34:03,160 --> 01:34:08,520
That's right, Mr. Chair, I was going to say I'll ask you to shift gears a little bit

928
01:34:08,520 --> 01:34:13,340
from thoughtful and interesting guy to me for a brief legislative update.

929
01:34:13,820 --> 01:34:18,020
I think what I'll do is do all the update first and then take that bill SB 30 so we can

930
01:34:18,020 --> 01:34:20,340
have it in a bite-sized chunk if that works for you.

931
01:34:21,960 --> 01:34:27,940
So in terms of appropriations, the House appropriations bill advanced out of Committee on July 14th

932
01:34:27,940 --> 01:34:31,600
And the Senate bill came out on July 24th, so that is moving along.

933
01:34:32,380 --> 01:34:37,360
The Senate bill appropriates the majority of public transit and rail funding authorized

934
01:34:37,360 --> 01:34:38,500
by the IAJA.

935
01:34:38,780 --> 01:34:42,640
And that's good news, because we weren't quite sure that that would happen.

936
01:34:43,220 --> 01:34:49,000
It provides about $21 billion for transit and $16 billion for passenger and freight rail,

937
01:34:49,160 --> 01:34:52,180
which is a little bit more than a fiscal year, $25.

938
01:34:53,160 --> 01:34:55,660
They'll be ongoing negotiations coming up in September.

939
01:34:55,660 --> 01:34:59,760
and there is a current.

940
01:35:00,110 --> 01:35:13,750
The current continuing resolution to fund the government is set to expire September 30th unless something else happens. The DOT announced Mark Mellonaro as a 16th Senate confirmed administrator to the FDA FTA.

941
01:35:16,790 --> 01:35:30,090
In terms of the surface transportation reauthorization, the DOT is issued a formal request for inviting comments for the next surface transportation bill, and Chairman Graves is continuing work on a bipartisan service bill before September 30th.

942
01:35:30,090 --> 01:35:31,550
October 30th, so we're tracking that.

943
01:35:32,130 --> 01:35:38,130
On June 30th, the DOT released revisions to the NEPO implementing process, including

944
01:35:38,130 --> 01:35:41,290
deadline reforms and page limit on environmental reviews.

945
01:35:42,510 --> 01:35:46,810
And then in high speed rail news, you probably have heard this on July 16th, Secretary Duffy

946
01:35:46,810 --> 01:35:52,870
announced the FRA would terminate two federal grant agreements totaling $4 billion for the

947
01:35:52,870 --> 01:35:55,730
California high speed rail project.

948
01:35:55,730 --> 01:36:00,970
on July 17th, California filed a lawsuit seeking declaratory and

949
01:36:00,970 --> 01:36:05,530
injective relief, and so we're following the progress of that.

950
01:36:07,110 --> 01:36:15,530
In terms of state legislative update, there are some dates up there in terms of the legislature's coming back on August 18th.

951
01:36:15,590 --> 01:36:23,890
And then there are days up there that you can read for yourself in terms of when the amended lines house passage in the governor to sign or

952
01:36:23,890 --> 01:36:28,990
our veto bills, that's particularly relevant schedule, considering SB-XB-63, it makes

953
01:36:28,990 --> 01:36:33,010
its way through the legislature and is bumping up against, I think, each of those deadlines

954
01:36:33,010 --> 01:36:35,130
on its way out of the legislature.

955
01:36:36,890 --> 01:36:41,550
In terms of a state budget agreement in late June, the governor and legislature did come

956
01:36:41,550 --> 01:36:48,270
to an agreement on the budget $321 billion and has reserves of $15.7 billion.

957
01:36:48,270 --> 01:36:54,130
dollars, our priority programs in the GHT reduction fund, which are those tourists

958
01:36:54,130 --> 01:36:59,270
that have been on the top, were maintained after there was some regional concern about

959
01:36:59,270 --> 01:36:59,550
those.

960
01:36:59,670 --> 01:37:04,070
There was cuts originally proposed by the governor, the legislature pushed back and those

961
01:37:04,070 --> 01:37:08,690
ended up coming out much more favorably than we then they might have.

962
01:37:09,050 --> 01:37:13,990
The budget also includes what we've talked about before, which is a $750 million emergency

963
01:37:13,990 --> 01:37:18,850
loan program for the general fund for select barrier transit agencies, including Caltrain.

964
01:37:18,850 --> 01:37:23,790
It's the folks that would receive funding from SB 63 if it were to pass.

965
01:37:24,270 --> 01:37:26,950
The loan would only take effect if SB 63 passes.

966
01:37:28,230 --> 01:37:32,050
And negotiations are ongoing in terms of what the loan terms would be.

967
01:37:33,550 --> 01:37:37,930
When they do come back on the 18th, the legislature is expected to resume discussion on the future

968
01:37:37,930 --> 01:37:39,490
of the cap and trade program.

969
01:37:39,490 --> 01:37:46,070
now it's called cap and invest, and that there are ongoing discussions that we are following

970
01:37:46,690 --> 01:37:51,610
around the region and in Sacramento about the future of that program, and a lot rides on

971
01:37:51,610 --> 01:37:55,250
that being extended and that funding coming to fruition.

972
01:37:58,810 --> 01:38:03,050
In terms of that, there's a CalSTAS, as I think you didn't mention this, CalSTAS transformation

973
01:38:03,050 --> 01:38:08,690
task force meeting on August 1st, and they have a draft report. It has for report for discussion,

974
01:38:08,690 --> 01:38:12,670
and they will deliver their final report on October 30th.

975
01:38:13,870 --> 01:38:17,190
As I mentioned, I'm thinking I'm going to skip over SB 30 real quick and come back to it

976
01:38:17,190 --> 01:38:20,110
since it is an action item and expect there may be some questions

977
01:38:20,650 --> 01:38:25,030
and just clean up the last piece which is SB 63.

978
01:38:26,190 --> 01:38:27,750
I think you're all pretty familiar with this.

979
01:38:28,370 --> 01:38:33,330
Here's a timeline of things that the one I think to focus on or the two are August 6th,

980
01:38:33,410 --> 01:38:36,530
which was yesterday or last night in this very room.

981
01:38:36,530 --> 01:38:41,230
Sam Trans met to discuss whether or not to opt-in and I'm pleased to report that the Sam

982
01:38:41,230 --> 01:38:46,410
Trans Board did degree to opt-in to the measure.

983
01:38:47,030 --> 01:38:52,290
They also voted to instruct the Bay Area Delegation to advance a slightly different expenditure

984
01:38:52,290 --> 01:38:58,530
plan, shifting some money from their municompetribution back to return source to San Mateo.

985
01:39:01,030 --> 01:39:05,590
And I wanted to thank, personally, Emily Beech and Jessica Epstein, and of course,

986
01:39:05,590 --> 01:39:10,530
April, Emily and Jessica did a Yomans work in terms of the staff reports, making sure

987
01:39:10,530 --> 01:39:14,710
all their boards were well informed with information coming over the weekends and in the evenings.

988
01:39:15,650 --> 01:39:20,450
And really, I think did good work that I think will come to the benefit of Bay Area Transit.

989
01:39:21,270 --> 01:39:26,530
The other date there is August 7th, where tonight VTA is going to meet and discuss whether

990
01:39:26,530 --> 01:39:32,010
are not the, they will opt in. I was obviously a big night for transit because this would

991
01:39:32,010 --> 01:39:37,190
be, this would make it a five county measure if VTA does in fact opt in. So if you want

992
01:39:37,190 --> 01:39:41,610
to send a hug emoji or a heart emoji to any of your friends on the VTA board, it might

993
01:39:41,610 --> 01:39:46,950
be a good time. It will be a monumental decision in there. I think a lot of folks' careers

994
01:39:46,950 --> 01:39:52,170
is not often you get to vote on something I think that's important for transit on a transit

995
01:39:52,170 --> 01:39:59,890
report. The staff recommendation from VTA is to opt-in at the rate.

996
01:40:00,000 --> 01:40:29,040
Or oversight body that would be established would be representatives from the tax counties, not MTC as a whole for instance. And they would separately ask the legislature to seek commitments from regional partners and leadership in the legislature to prioritize transportation needs in Santa Clara County for cap and trade and other state funding given Santa Clara County's contributions to CalTrain through SB 63. That's not a condition of opting in as I read the staff recommendation, but it is a request.

997
01:40:29,040 --> 01:40:35,300
just to work on those priorities.

998
01:40:35,960 --> 01:40:38,960
So that's my discussion of SB 63.

999
01:40:40,160 --> 01:40:43,140
I don't know if you want to, Mr. Chair, I want to pause here for questions on that or any

1000
01:40:43,140 --> 01:40:45,140
of the rest of the updates and then take SB 30.

1001
01:40:45,720 --> 01:40:48,500
No, I don't want to talk about this subject ever again.

1002
01:40:51,720 --> 01:40:53,340
Good luck, VTA tonight.

1003
01:40:55,120 --> 01:40:55,660
All right.

1004
01:40:56,000 --> 01:40:57,780
I'm not Mr. Corteszi's bill.

1005
01:40:57,780 --> 01:40:57,880
Bill.

1006
01:40:58,240 --> 01:40:59,280
All right, let's move back to that.

1007
01:40:59,400 --> 01:40:59,780
Thank you.

1008
01:41:01,520 --> 01:41:08,160
So, Senator Cortese's bill, SB 30, we're recommending an oppose unless amended position.

1009
01:41:08,740 --> 01:41:12,500
You'll note this is pretty late in the season for us to be opposing a bill.

1010
01:41:12,680 --> 01:41:18,680
We've done that out of an attempt to work with the authors on this as it made its way through

1011
01:41:18,680 --> 01:41:23,620
the legislature out of the Senate and in the assembly and now it has assembly approaches.

1012
01:41:24,000 --> 01:41:26,560
It's probably its last stop in the legislature.

1013
01:41:26,560 --> 01:41:36,060
We've had some of our Bay Area delegation as some of the errands voted against it.

1014
01:41:36,560 --> 01:41:42,060
Assemblymember Pappin voted to obtain which sort of counts as a no, and the CTA as long

1015
01:41:42,060 --> 01:41:46,480
had an oppose unless amended position in part because the effects that they know

1016
01:41:46,480 --> 01:41:52,840
that this would have on CalTrain, where there's a fair amount of information up there.

1017
01:41:52,840 --> 01:41:53,920
I don't want to read it all for you.

1018
01:41:54,040 --> 01:41:56,400
Essentially, the bill would prevent agencies

1019
01:41:56,400 --> 01:41:59,380
from transferring diesel locomotives

1020
01:41:59,380 --> 01:42:03,360
of tiers zero or one, any tiers below two.

1021
01:42:05,280 --> 01:42:08,660
And it would allow transfer of tiers two and above

1022
01:42:08,660 --> 01:42:12,140
if there was a showing that greenhouse gas

1023
01:42:12,140 --> 01:42:17,300
and emissions would be appropriate, it would be better for that.

1024
01:42:17,520 --> 01:42:21,520
So our essentially asking is for the tier zero and one locomotive

1025
01:42:21,520 --> 01:42:25,600
it's a countering as we have about nine of those locomotives and each of those locomotives

1026
01:42:25,600 --> 01:42:32,040
in fact has been upgraded and it has better emissions than traditional zero and one

1027
01:42:32,040 --> 01:42:37,060
tier locomotives but they keep that tier because the tier is based on one the locomotive is built

1028
01:42:37,060 --> 01:42:43,300
even if you're even if you overall that as we have so we're just asking amendments that would say

1029
01:42:43,300 --> 01:42:48,200
if we can have a positive showing that this actually would be better for the environment to make

1030
01:42:48,200 --> 01:42:53,880
the transfer and that could be showing by the air district or a car that we would be allowed

1031
01:42:53,880 --> 01:42:59,780
to make those transfers. And secondly there's a piece that would allow transfer of diesels to

1032
01:42:59,780 --> 01:43:06,620
museums but that would as currently written would require the engine to be removed. It is I have learned

1033
01:43:06,620 --> 01:43:12,220
a substantial thing to remove an engine from a diesel and also much less attractive to the museums

1034
01:43:12,220 --> 01:43:17,960
because that's a big percentage and a big piece of what a diesel locomotive is. And so we would

1035
01:43:17,960 --> 01:43:23,520
ask that the amendment say that the engine could be disabled rather than fully removed because

1036
01:43:23,520 --> 01:43:27,320
it financially just doesn't make any sense to take the entire engine out and then try

1037
01:43:27,320 --> 01:43:30,880
to transfer it and in fact to move it to a museum.

1038
01:43:31,080 --> 01:43:33,820
So those are the amendments we would look at.

1039
01:43:36,300 --> 01:43:42,000
Here they are up in writing and we'll see if I summarized them correctly and that's why

1040
01:43:42,000 --> 01:43:45,520
we're recommending impose unless amended position.

1041
01:43:45,520 --> 01:43:47,640
This would have real financial implications to CalTrain.

1042
01:43:47,880 --> 01:43:54,460
It would mean several million dollars of our ability to be able to transfer these if we just

1043
01:43:54,460 --> 01:43:57,300
decommissioned them and sold them a scrap for scrap.

1044
01:43:57,400 --> 01:43:58,840
We don't make really much money on scrap.

1045
01:43:58,840 --> 01:44:02,020
It ends up being about a push because it takes a lot to decommission them.

1046
01:44:02,880 --> 01:44:11,460
So this really is a financial piece and that's why we're asking for an opposed unless amended position.

1047
01:44:11,460 --> 01:44:31,970
All right, I do have a couple of questions, and colleagues, my general policy has always been that you should never oppose a bill introduced by a member of your delegation, unless you just really, really, really can't live with it.

1048
01:44:33,230 --> 01:44:42,030
And I believe this bill was generated as a reaction to the transaction we did in Lima, Peru.

1049
01:44:42,030 --> 01:44:51,590
is that correct? Yeah. Yeah. And isn't that transaction done and aren't the vehicles gone?

1050
01:44:52,230 --> 01:44:52,690
Yes.

1051
01:44:55,320 --> 01:44:56,500
That's my understanding.

1052
01:44:57,740 --> 01:44:59,480
We still have some remaining.

1053
01:45:00,000 --> 01:45:00,720
All right, two, so.

1054
01:45:05,860 --> 01:45:13,120
Hold on, let somebody responsible come to the microphone. They were all moved

1055
01:45:13,120 --> 01:45:18,960
to Stockton. We had, yeah, problems with one of the coaches, so we fixed it yesterday

1056
01:45:18,960 --> 01:45:24,580
and UP took it, so we don't have any on our property anymore. Okay, of the Peruvian. And

1057
01:45:24,580 --> 01:45:30,240
just to be clear, the transaction is complete. Lima has title to all of the trains.

1058
01:45:32,900 --> 01:45:33,400
They

1059
01:45:33,400 --> 01:45:34,540
answers to my question.

1060
01:45:34,620 --> 01:45:43,600
I look for the lawyer when you said complete, because in that sense, the big thing is

1061
01:45:44,460 --> 01:45:45,940
to the side now, right?

1062
01:45:46,260 --> 01:45:46,660
It's moved.

1063
01:45:48,180 --> 01:45:53,080
Well, we still have nine engines that are in our position that we're not subject to

1064
01:45:53,080 --> 01:45:57,240
the Peru transaction, including engines that are still running Gilroy's service, as well

1065
01:45:57,240 --> 01:45:57,780
as some of those.

1066
01:45:58,060 --> 01:45:59,220
Those haven't happened yet.

1067
01:45:59,220 --> 01:46:03,160
Right, those are not subject to the proof transaction.

1068
01:46:03,400 --> 01:46:07,700
They are just, have you had any reaction to these two amendments from the author?

1069
01:46:09,060 --> 01:46:17,940
We've, for months, requested that the author make them and we have not gotten any help from them.

1070
01:46:18,900 --> 01:46:24,540
CTA has been, you know, testified in an opposition to the bill and asked for these amendments and the amendments haven't been taken.

1071
01:46:24,540 --> 01:46:31,860
All right. Let me see if there are any other members of the board to the chair.

1072
01:46:32,220 --> 01:46:38,800
I just want to be clear on the agenda that it's informational, but you're asking for action.

1073
01:46:39,940 --> 01:46:43,860
So I want to make sure it actually can be even considered if that's not what is stated.

1074
01:46:44,920 --> 01:46:51,320
Yes, the agenda also notes that all items on the agenda are subject to action by the board.

1075
01:46:51,320 --> 01:47:05,320
So if notwithstanding that reference information rather than motion, the agenda preserves the opportunity for the Board to act and the title of the item does say consideration of position on SB 30, so we've given an appropriate note.

1076
01:47:05,460 --> 01:47:08,400
I'm not the lawyer. I just wanted to check. I appreciate my cheek. Thank you.

1077
01:47:08,580 --> 01:47:08,840
Thank you.

1078
01:47:08,840 --> 01:47:09,380
Keep it as honest.

1079
01:47:10,460 --> 01:47:12,440
Anyone else? Director Abbey Koga.

1080
01:47:13,000 --> 01:47:20,020
Thank you, Chair. I am in alignment with your comments and I was going to suggest rather than oppose

1081
01:47:20,020 --> 01:47:24,140
the less amended a support if amended position.

1082
01:47:27,440 --> 01:47:30,000
So that's another way of getting at the objective.

1083
01:47:33,020 --> 01:47:36,140
Colleagues, any other comments or discussion?

1084
01:47:37,900 --> 01:47:40,680
Mr. Chairman, I'm in the same flavor.

1085
01:47:41,040 --> 01:47:42,760
You know, when you have a member of your delegation,

1086
01:47:43,240 --> 01:47:46,460
it's very severe to use the word,

1087
01:47:47,240 --> 01:47:50,220
so support if amended is appropriate.

1088
01:47:52,540 --> 01:47:53,500
All right.

1089
01:47:54,840 --> 01:47:56,700
Any public comment on this?

1090
01:47:57,620 --> 01:47:59,560
We do have virtual hands raised.

1091
01:48:00,080 --> 01:48:01,500
First person is Alita Dupree?

1092
01:48:05,700 --> 01:48:08,140
Thanks again, Chair Steve Hammigard, members.

1093
01:48:08,480 --> 01:48:10,700
Alita Dupree for the record. She and her with team polls.

1094
01:48:11,620 --> 01:48:13,860
I have a problem with this bill.

1095
01:48:15,040 --> 01:48:18,100
And I'm not really seeing the rationale of this bill

1096
01:48:18,100 --> 01:48:26,580
in restraining transit agencies from being able to appropriately dispose of their equipment.

1097
01:48:27,820 --> 01:48:34,540
And I'm looking forward to seeing what Lima Peru is going to do in building their commuter rail.

1098
01:48:35,040 --> 01:48:37,560
I'm sure it's going to take a lot of cars off the road.

1099
01:48:39,100 --> 01:48:41,180
We don't live in a perfect world.

1100
01:48:41,180 --> 01:48:53,500
and these locomotives represent stranded capital, and in a day and age when public

1101
01:48:53,500 --> 01:49:00,740
transportation needs all the money it can get, we have to be able to transact

1102
01:49:00,740 --> 01:49:09,280
business appropriately. We don't want to throw money away. Yes, these locomotives

1103
01:49:09,280 --> 01:49:14,640
do produce emissions. And until they're at the end of their useful life, they're going

1104
01:49:14,640 --> 01:49:24,040
to produce emissions. Unless somebody, the state, et cetera, is willing to pay caltrain

1105
01:49:24,040 --> 01:49:32,280
and equivalent amount of what they can get to dispose of these locomotives. And caltrain

1106
01:49:32,280 --> 01:49:39,640
should be able to dispose of them appropriately. So yes, ideally, I would like to see us remove

1107
01:49:39,640 --> 01:49:47,760
a mission-producing equipment from the community. But the fact is that's not going to happen today,

1108
01:49:47,940 --> 01:49:53,600
and it's not going to happen tomorrow, just as we can't expect people who trade in their cars to

1109
01:49:53,600 --> 01:49:59,920
simply throw them away. They get a trade-in value with the dealer, and yes, people are still trading

1110
01:50:00,000 --> 01:50:18,230
And gas lean cars for new gasoline cars. And this bill doesn't apply to freight railroads. So I can't support this bill. And I think it should, it should be opposed regardless of where you live. Thank you. Next public commenter of Adina Levin.

1111
01:50:21,680 --> 01:50:31,620
Yes. So I am glad to see Caltrain paying some attention to this bill.

1112
01:50:31,620 --> 01:50:44,220
So, the CalTrain has just electrified the portion of the line from Tamion to San Francisco,

1113
01:50:44,740 --> 01:50:49,560
but as the staff have mentioned, there's still the diesel trains serving the Gilroy service.

1114
01:50:50,180 --> 01:50:55,880
And in the state of California overall, what CalTrain has done is 50 miles out of a 1,500

1115
01:50:55,880 --> 01:51:04,960
mild program of electrification in the state, and the amendments being proposed to assure

1116
01:51:04,960 --> 01:51:12,020
that if a diesel train is being moved somewhere, we're having a train would reduce emissions

1117
01:51:12,020 --> 01:51:18,600
compared to other forms of transportation. That seems like a sensible way of handling that.

1118
01:51:18,600 --> 01:51:27,460
that during this legislative session, the Senator Cortesian is role and Senate transportation

1119
01:51:27,460 --> 01:51:41,340
has played a key role in SB 63, VTA's decision tonight will go a long way towards settling

1120
01:51:41,340 --> 01:51:52,340
out where the county is on that and I do think that, you know, even at this hour pushing for

1121
01:51:52,340 --> 01:51:59,820
this bill to be made more constructive will be helpful not only for CalTrain, but for the rest

1122
01:51:59,820 --> 01:52:07,000
of the 1500 miles of electrification needed in the state of California that can build on CalTrain's

1123
01:52:07,000 --> 01:52:10,660
good example. Thank you. Next speaker is Roland.

1124
01:52:13,500 --> 01:52:18,820
Thank you. So on SB 30 absolutely support

1125
01:52:18,820 --> 01:52:26,320
and less amended but I want to talk about the $75 million folk out training in SB 63.

1126
01:52:27,280 --> 01:52:36,380
I would like this bold to make it very clear to answer Clara County that this $75 million

1127
01:52:36,380 --> 01:52:41,320
does not repeat, does not include the cost of the

1128
01:52:41,320 --> 01:52:44,040
giro extension, which includes health and

1129
01:52:44,040 --> 01:52:47,480
other wear li. Then the question comes to

1130
01:52:47,480 --> 01:52:50,860
great, so how we're going to finance and grow

1131
01:52:50,860 --> 01:52:53,060
the ridership. In that extension, quite

1132
01:52:53,060 --> 01:52:55,560
frankly, San Francisco to giro should be

1133
01:52:55,560 --> 01:52:59,000
one line end of discussion. The best

1134
01:52:59,000 --> 01:53:02,280
solution is to follow the French example who

1135
01:53:02,280 --> 01:53:05,360
turned the entire freeway network over to

1136
01:53:05,360 --> 01:53:13,000
the private sector that releases, and they use the least revenues to finance the development

1137
01:53:13,000 --> 01:53:15,740
of the high-speed rail network.

1138
01:53:17,020 --> 01:53:24,920
And we have got a similar situation between San Jose and Giroi, because we are about

1139
01:53:25,220 --> 01:53:33,760
to start funding the development of express lanes between North Morgan Hill and Giroi.

1140
01:53:33,760 --> 01:53:41,700
And we have to make sure at a regional level, I mean at a regional level, that should

1141
01:53:41,700 --> 01:53:49,640
this come to pass, is that all the revenue from these express lanes stayed within the corridor

1142
01:53:49,640 --> 01:53:56,240
and does not get shifted to some other mega project in another part of Santa Clara County.

1143
01:53:56,880 --> 01:54:02,800
And if we do this, everybody will be in support because we're not increasing taxes.

1144
01:54:02,800 --> 01:54:09,680
We're following the French. We're following the Japanese model is to basically use their

1145
01:54:09,680 --> 01:54:14,980
Instagram news and keep it there within the code scope on which you want to tend it and

1146
01:54:14,980 --> 01:54:19,700
give people a choice whether they drive or they like out frame. Thank you.

1147
01:54:19,760 --> 01:54:22,340
Last speaker is Adrian Brandt.

1148
01:55:00,000 --> 01:55:28,640
I just wanted to point out that there are numerous YouTube videos showing our equipment down in Lima, and there's considerable political jockey and going on down there on how to get those trains into service as soon as possible. And so that I also want to, you know, really align myself with the Dino's comments. I think on a state level, it's going to be really important that other, you know,

1149
01:55:28,640 --> 01:55:31,420
in support of other electrification throughout the state,

1150
01:55:31,980 --> 01:55:34,780
that commuter rail and other agencies like ours

1151
01:55:34,780 --> 01:55:37,980
are able to, if there is justification,

1152
01:55:38,460 --> 01:55:40,640
as it says in the staff recommendation,

1153
01:55:41,300 --> 01:55:43,940
if there's justification on a pollution basis,

1154
01:55:44,480 --> 01:55:49,340
that we and other agencies are able to monetize

1155
01:55:49,960 --> 01:55:53,600
and more easily and more environmentally, in fact,

1156
01:55:54,060 --> 01:55:57,960
pass on their no longer needed locomotives.

1157
01:55:57,960 --> 01:56:05,960
So, I think it's really very odd, just as a comment that Mr. Cortese's bill does not affect

1158
01:56:05,960 --> 01:56:12,560
freight railroads when they are, by far, a much, much larger source of locomotive pollution.

1159
01:56:12,920 --> 01:56:16,260
So that's a real head scratcher, but that's not our business.

1160
01:56:16,520 --> 01:56:16,820
Thank you.

1161
01:56:18,360 --> 01:56:19,900
That ends public comments.

1162
01:56:20,240 --> 01:56:23,500
We do have Devon Ryan online and with her hand raised.

1163
01:56:24,920 --> 01:56:25,120
But.

1164
01:56:25,560 --> 01:56:25,800
Staff.

1165
01:56:26,880 --> 01:56:41,980
Mr. Chair, I think we can, that may be from an earlier hand raise, I think, I just do want to make sure that the recommendation makes sense because we still at least would have a position on the bill and have a formal position in terms of amendments.

1166
01:56:41,980 --> 01:56:46,700
I want to make clear the board is aware that over time we think this would cost us in

1167
01:56:46,700 --> 01:56:51,440
terms of opportunity costs in terms of things we couldn't sell in the range of $20 million.

1168
01:56:51,880 --> 01:56:55,140
So I just wanted to put that on the record so that you all know, or if you see Senator

1169
01:56:55,140 --> 01:57:01,960
Courtais in the hall, you can mention our current fiscal situation and that that's not an easy

1170
01:57:01,960 --> 01:57:04,880
hit even if it's over a reasonably amount of time.

1171
01:57:05,540 --> 01:57:06,380
Director Burke.

1172
01:57:07,280 --> 01:57:07,440
Yeah.

1173
01:57:08,560 --> 01:57:18,720
Have we had any success in enlisting our other local legislators to lobby Senator Cortesia

1174
01:57:18,720 --> 01:57:19,260
on our behalf?

1175
01:57:19,920 --> 01:57:25,620
You know, our legislators, Patrick Carrons, who pursuant to the previous conversation

1176
01:57:25,620 --> 01:57:30,080
came from Community College and now is district and now is on the assembly transportation.

1177
01:57:30,540 --> 01:57:34,280
So maybe he'll be the solution to some of our previous speaker's issues, voted no on

1178
01:57:34,280 --> 01:57:39,840
this bill and because of the concerns from CalTrain and Assemblymember Papin, like I said,

1179
01:57:40,020 --> 01:57:40,340
abstained.

1180
01:57:40,600 --> 01:57:42,620
And I know that they've had discussions with Senator Cortese.

1181
01:57:43,280 --> 01:57:48,060
We've met with Senator Cortese's staff several times offered to me with him in person, but

1182
01:57:48,060 --> 01:57:49,460
just not had much luck.

1183
01:57:50,820 --> 01:57:55,420
Over time, he has accepted amendments, and so the bill didn't start out with all the tears

1184
01:57:55,420 --> 01:58:02,560
being able to be transferred with a GHG and emissions showing, but it didn't get down

1185
01:58:02,560 --> 01:58:04,360
of the ones we own, the nine.

1186
01:58:04,560 --> 01:58:07,160
Senator Maxker, have we engaged with him?

1187
01:58:09,080 --> 01:58:15,580
We've engaged with all of our, it's been a little while, because we've been doing this for a long time since the bill started in the Senate.

1188
01:58:16,280 --> 01:58:28,280
With every member of our delegation, I think we've informed about this bill, informed about CalTransition, that it would cost us a fair amount of money, and that we were just asking to have same showing that other tier locomotives could have.

1189
01:58:28,540 --> 01:58:28,800
Thank you.

1190
01:58:29,380 --> 01:58:30,200
Thank you for the questions.

1191
01:58:30,200 --> 01:58:43,360
So I believe what I heard is Director Abe Koga making a motion to support the bill if it's amended according to the information in the staff report.

1192
01:58:44,600 --> 01:58:45,960
Is that as is there a second?

1193
01:58:47,340 --> 01:58:47,840
Second.

1194
01:58:48,680 --> 01:58:50,780
Any further discussion or debate?

1195
01:58:51,340 --> 01:58:52,960
Yes, directors Mooda.

1196
01:58:52,960 --> 01:58:58,080
I just have a question in terms of the language here.

1197
01:58:59,540 --> 01:59:04,080
Unless amended, how do we state exactly how?

1198
01:59:06,020 --> 01:59:10,200
Yeah, there were two amendments on the thing.

1199
01:59:12,760 --> 01:59:14,820
Why don't we just get the screen?

1200
01:59:16,180 --> 01:59:17,040
There we go.

1201
01:59:18,720 --> 01:59:20,100
So there's two bullet points there.

1202
01:59:22,790 --> 01:59:39,930
Okay, fine. Thank you. All righty. Let's vote. All the roll, please. Director Abikoka. Hi. Director Bert. Yes. Director Cohen. Hi. Director G. Yes. Director Walton. Director Zemuda. Hi. Vice-Chimadina. Yes. Chair Hemminger. Hi. Motion passes.

1203
01:59:41,290 --> 01:59:47,490
Marvellous. We've got one more item here and that's a bunch of verbal reports which I will ask our

1204
01:59:47,490 --> 01:59:54,830
speakers to give quickly. 12A is the Citizens Advisory Committee, Mr. Brant.

1205
01:59:58,590 --> 01:59:59,190
There I am.

1206
02:00:00,000 --> 02:00:29,980
There I am. Yes, so staff did cancel our meeting. So we don't have a meeting to report on. I was somewhat disappointed because I think, you know, they stated that there were no staff available to give us presentations, but I feel that we have a lot to offer in our value goes well beyond the staff presentation. So I'm hopeful that we can avoid a surprise cancellations and still perform a good role in terms of feedback and interacting with staff on issues that

1207
02:00:29,980 --> 02:00:33,940
that occur whether other staff run vacation or not.

1208
02:00:34,400 --> 02:00:34,680
Thank you.

1209
02:00:37,330 --> 02:00:38,210
Thank you.

1210
02:00:38,590 --> 02:00:41,510
12B is me and I don't have a report.

1211
02:00:41,850 --> 02:00:45,830
So 12C is the local policy maker group director Burke.

1212
02:00:46,710 --> 02:00:50,070
We also did not have a meeting in July.

1213
02:00:51,190 --> 02:00:55,430
And we don't have one, let's see, the next one scheduled

1214
02:00:55,430 --> 02:00:57,610
for trying to remember it.

1215
02:00:58,010 --> 02:00:58,590
End of this month.

1216
02:00:58,590 --> 02:01:05,450
But I will say that Peter Rogoff's presentation, even though we may not be able to get him to

1217
02:01:05,450 --> 02:01:11,690
make that presentation, as staff providing that may be of interest to the city's up and

1218
02:01:11,690 --> 02:01:14,830
down the corridor, as they're struggling with grade separation issues.

1219
02:01:18,390 --> 02:01:18,850
That it?

1220
02:01:22,210 --> 02:01:30,430
Director Ovee has fled the building, so we will not get a TJPA report just as well, perhaps.

1221
02:01:30,430 --> 02:01:37,530
item 13 is for respondents yes we have public comment we have public comment on

1222
02:01:37,530 --> 02:01:45,450
the public comment okay virtual handraises Roland there were essentially no

1223
02:01:45,450 --> 02:01:54,030
reports given but go ahead I agree but I would like to make a suggestion is that

1224
02:01:54,030 --> 02:02:02,350
But when they are not available to make presentations, it's an opportunity for you to make it possible

1225
02:02:02,350 --> 02:02:11,030
for members of the public to give presentations such as great crossing and answering new construction

1226
02:02:11,030 --> 02:02:21,350
techniques, various ways that the Bureau of Extension could both be built, doing all the

1227
02:02:21,350 --> 02:02:26,310
industry capital projects and how I could be funded. Thank you.

1228
02:02:26,610 --> 02:02:28,110
That ends public comments.

1229
02:02:28,590 --> 02:02:31,550
All right. So back to correspondence which