1 00:00:08,136 --> 00:00:14,136 Mayor Lisa M. Gillmor: If we Could have roll call. 2 00:00:18,311 --> 00:00:19,728 >> The confirmation of the quorum. 3 00:00:19,728 --> 00:00:24,528 For the record Council member Chahal is online. 4 00:00:31,109 --> 00:00:35,728 Councilmember Chahal: online and no one's in the room. 5 00:00:35,728 --> 00:00:38,128 >> Thank you for that. 6 00:00:41,976 --> 00:00:44,554 Mayor Gonzalez: We will conduct resignation and applicant 7 00:00:44,554 --> 00:00:47,649 interviews and point of application to planning 8 00:00:47,649 --> 00:00:51,170 Commission serve one partial term ending June 30th. 9 00:00:51,170 --> 00:00:52,545 >> Thank you vice mayor Gonzalez. 10 00:00:52,545 --> 00:00:57,458 I'll note for the record that all the applicants have received 11 00:00:57,458 --> 00:01:00,458 logistics of this evening. -- 12 00:01:21,537 --> 00:01:23,937 >> Can everybody hear me? 13 00:01:25,130 --> 00:01:27,609 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Good evening. 14 00:01:27,609 --> 00:01:29,729 >> Thank you for letting me join. 15 00:01:29,729 --> 00:01:34,529 To be a candidate for your planning commission. 16 00:01:35,962 --> 00:01:38,450 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you for applying 17 00:01:38,450 --> 00:01:41,249 and we'll start with your three minute introduction. 18 00:01:41,249 --> 00:01:46,255 >> My name is Naai, I've been a resident of Santa Clara. 19 00:01:46,255 --> 00:01:48,655 I moved here in 97. 20 00:01:49,443 --> 00:01:53,809 I bought my home in Santa Clara in 2003. 21 00:01:53,809 --> 00:02:00,409 My kids have gone in Santa Clara and the school district 22 00:02:01,409 --> 00:02:03,809 from third grade onwards. 23 00:02:05,730 --> 00:02:08,649 My oldest and youngest have been in kindergarten all the way 24 00:02:08,649 --> 00:02:10,173 through high school. 25 00:02:10,173 --> 00:02:14,973 All three kids have gone through universities here. 26 00:02:15,489 --> 00:02:20,777 I'm a professional software engineer director at a company. 27 00:02:20,777 --> 00:02:24,377 A software company in this area. 28 00:02:24,825 --> 00:02:30,809 I wanted to volunteer my time back to the community. 29 00:02:30,809 --> 00:02:35,900 As the manager and director I've also 30 00:02:37,629 --> 00:02:40,629 been volunteering on the boards. 31 00:02:41,609 --> 00:02:44,849 I'd like to talk about strategic planning. 32 00:02:44,849 --> 00:02:47,249 Planning a future endeavor. 33 00:02:48,315 --> 00:02:54,915 And I have an MBA background and that fits my alley 34 00:02:55,830 --> 00:02:59,704 and then I can help the Planning Commission. 35 00:02:59,704 --> 00:03:02,149 Get some time back to the city. 36 00:03:02,149 --> 00:03:04,849 I think that'd be worthwhile for myself. 37 00:03:04,849 --> 00:03:06,849 Thank you. 38 00:03:07,994 --> 00:03:09,952 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you for that. 39 00:03:09,952 --> 00:03:11,869 We're going to get started with our questions. 40 00:03:11,869 --> 00:03:16,669 The first would be by Council member Chahal. 41 00:03:22,211 --> 00:03:24,253 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Thank you for applying. 42 00:03:24,253 --> 00:03:30,253 What government is a good example of planning and why? 43 00:03:31,129 --> 00:03:33,649 >> I'd have a development for me personally. 44 00:03:33,649 --> 00:03:36,290 Open space and parks. 45 00:03:36,290 --> 00:03:40,249 We do more parks and open space areas 46 00:03:40,249 --> 00:03:42,625 for our citizens, Santa Clara. 47 00:03:42,625 --> 00:03:44,649 Yes, we need development. 48 00:03:44,649 --> 00:03:46,640 Nothing wrong with development. 49 00:03:46,640 --> 00:03:49,173 We need open spaces for young people. 50 00:03:49,173 --> 00:03:52,689 For people, young kids to move around. 51 00:03:52,689 --> 00:03:56,889 And enjoy the beautiful of Santa Clara. 52 00:03:58,490 --> 00:04:00,175 And everything about it. 53 00:04:00,175 --> 00:04:04,601 I'd like to plant more parks comet recreational areas 54 00:04:04,601 --> 00:04:07,100 and finding that out. 55 00:04:08,169 --> 00:04:10,537 Build some open spaces. 56 00:04:10,537 --> 00:04:12,537 Not just development. 57 00:04:12,809 --> 00:04:14,689 Development is important. 58 00:04:14,689 --> 00:04:15,809 Altogether. 59 00:04:15,809 --> 00:04:17,505 Parks are important also. 60 00:04:17,505 --> 00:04:19,229 And everything else. 61 00:04:19,229 --> 00:04:22,329 I think development spaces for people 62 00:04:22,329 --> 00:04:27,129 and for parks to recreational is important also. 63 00:04:27,929 --> 00:04:30,969 Having a planning development open spaces 64 00:04:30,969 --> 00:04:33,969 is a nice thing personally. 65 00:04:34,190 --> 00:04:35,602 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 66 00:04:35,602 --> 00:04:38,409 We're going to get Council member Hardy. 67 00:04:38,409 --> 00:04:41,128 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Do you 68 00:04:41,128 --> 00:04:46,409 have any thoughts about the El Camino specific area plan? 69 00:04:46,409 --> 00:04:50,209 >> I saw the plan and it is interesting. 70 00:04:50,209 --> 00:04:52,209 Nothing specific. 71 00:04:52,789 --> 00:04:55,172 I just briefly viewed it. 72 00:04:55,172 --> 00:04:59,257 I should have looked at it more, apologies for that. 73 00:04:59,257 --> 00:05:00,822 It was interesting. 74 00:05:00,822 --> 00:05:04,649 I have to look at it in more detail about it. 75 00:05:04,649 --> 00:05:05,489 Sorry about that. 76 00:05:05,489 --> 00:05:09,890 I Councilmember Karen Hardy: Thank you. 77 00:05:09,891 --> 00:05:11,683 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: I will give you 78 00:05:11,683 --> 00:05:15,269 the third question which is, Santa Clara continues 79 00:05:15,269 --> 00:05:17,153 to face significant pressure for new housing 80 00:05:17,153 --> 00:05:19,190 and development Commonwealth residents 81 00:05:19,190 --> 00:05:22,490 are concerned about traffic, infrastructure, neighborhood 82 00:05:22,490 --> 00:05:23,689 character and quality of life. 83 00:05:23,689 --> 00:05:26,115 How would you approach balancing these competing interests 84 00:05:26,115 --> 00:05:29,115 when considering a development proposal? 85 00:05:29,662 --> 00:05:32,242 >> As you said, it has to be a balance. 86 00:05:32,242 --> 00:05:37,889 I would look at how many units we currently have. 87 00:05:37,889 --> 00:05:38,814 In the city. 88 00:05:38,814 --> 00:05:40,919 How many do we need. 89 00:05:40,919 --> 00:05:43,919 Especially for basic service people. 90 00:05:46,449 --> 00:05:48,849 Fire and police, teachers. 91 00:05:50,369 --> 00:05:53,929 They have to commute far away. 92 00:05:53,929 --> 00:05:56,739 And for low income housing people. 93 00:05:56,739 --> 00:06:00,462 So they can afford to live in the city. 94 00:06:00,462 --> 00:06:03,119 We need people living here. 95 00:06:03,119 --> 00:06:06,119 Honestly, we cannot Overbuild also. 96 00:06:07,305 --> 00:06:09,305 And cram everybody. 97 00:06:09,429 --> 00:06:13,629 That's very difficult. It is a balance. 98 00:06:13,909 --> 00:06:16,999 I know a lot of corporate buildings 99 00:06:16,999 --> 00:06:22,197 are being emptied because people work more and more for home. 100 00:06:22,197 --> 00:06:26,249 We can look at converting commercial buildings 101 00:06:26,249 --> 00:06:28,142 into residential buildings more. 102 00:06:28,142 --> 00:06:32,379 I know a lot of people, a lot of corporations 103 00:06:32,379 --> 00:06:34,779 work remote from home. 104 00:06:35,289 --> 00:06:36,249 Is there. 105 00:06:36,249 --> 00:06:37,553 Like our company. 106 00:06:37,553 --> 00:06:39,737 We closed our central office. 107 00:06:39,737 --> 00:06:41,737 We work 100% remotely. 108 00:06:43,309 --> 00:06:47,489 I think other companies don't do long term leases are going 109 00:06:47,489 --> 00:06:49,627 to that model, because it makes a lot easier 110 00:06:49,627 --> 00:06:50,502 financially for them. 111 00:06:50,502 --> 00:06:55,902 It opens up an opportunity for city like ours. 112 00:06:56,104 --> 00:06:57,687 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 113 00:06:57,687 --> 00:07:02,487 Council member park will give the next question. 114 00:07:03,704 --> 00:07:07,904 Councilmember Kevin Park: Thank you very much. 115 00:07:08,489 --> 00:07:10,889 Planning commissioners are sometimes 116 00:07:11,179 --> 00:07:15,220 faced with strong opinions from residents, developers, 117 00:07:15,220 --> 00:07:17,422 organizations and other stakeholders. 118 00:07:17,819 --> 00:07:21,809 How would you evaluate a project fairly and independently 119 00:07:21,809 --> 00:07:26,755 when there is significant public advocacy on both sides? 120 00:07:26,755 --> 00:07:31,490 >> I would look at the concerns of the residents. 121 00:07:31,490 --> 00:07:35,169 I also have to weigh the benefit overall of the city. 122 00:07:35,169 --> 00:07:37,882 It's a hard thing to trade off. 123 00:07:37,882 --> 00:07:43,882 Any project look at the trade cost and benefit analysis. 124 00:07:44,121 --> 00:07:49,690 You have to see, s, if the residents are 100% against it. 125 00:07:49,690 --> 00:07:51,865 The trade off is not that much. 126 00:07:51,865 --> 00:07:54,169 You might cite with a resident. 127 00:07:54,169 --> 00:07:56,597 It's almost a balanced equaled out. 128 00:07:56,597 --> 00:08:00,929 You have to weigh that and it's a tough decision. 129 00:08:00,929 --> 00:08:03,809 Sometimes you may have to go against the residents feeling. 130 00:08:03,809 --> 00:08:08,405 To put something that's better for the greater community. 131 00:08:08,405 --> 00:08:10,174 It is a tough act. 132 00:08:10,174 --> 00:08:12,147 But you look at cost dependent value. 133 00:08:12,147 --> 00:08:15,441 If I'm getting more value, let's say housing 134 00:08:15,441 --> 00:08:18,441 provides more low income homes. 135 00:08:18,589 --> 00:08:21,345 More income homes for our community. 136 00:08:21,345 --> 00:08:23,259 And the people are against it. 137 00:08:23,259 --> 00:08:26,809 I'd say, there's a greater benefit 138 00:08:26,809 --> 00:08:29,459 for those building a new home construction 139 00:08:29,459 --> 00:08:31,539 for a certain segment. 140 00:08:31,539 --> 00:08:34,822 It's more important the city because we 141 00:08:34,822 --> 00:08:37,142 need to have affordable homes in our city also. 142 00:08:37,142 --> 00:08:41,449 Yes, I would look at the cost benefit of it. 143 00:08:41,449 --> 00:08:44,419 Simply drivers trying to maximize profit 144 00:08:44,419 --> 00:08:45,334 for private things. 145 00:08:45,334 --> 00:08:48,345 But if it's more of a community good on that project. 146 00:08:48,345 --> 00:08:51,345 I would weigh that more. 147 00:08:52,300 --> 00:08:54,300 Councilmember Kevin Park: Thank you so much sir. 148 00:08:54,300 --> 00:08:56,378 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: That concludes the questions. 149 00:08:56,378 --> 00:08:59,194 You have one more minute for your closing remarks. 150 00:08:59,194 --> 00:09:00,569 >> Thank you for the opportunity. 151 00:09:00,569 --> 00:09:04,529 Sorry I did not review the El Camino project. 152 00:09:04,529 --> 00:09:05,835 I apologize for that. 153 00:09:05,835 --> 00:09:08,900 But I hopefully you'll select me, 154 00:09:08,900 --> 00:09:09,484 I'll be more than honored to serve 155 00:09:09,484 --> 00:09:10,609 in the Planning Commission. 156 00:09:10,609 --> 00:09:13,900 Thank you very much. 157 00:09:14,450 --> 00:09:16,330 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 158 00:09:16,330 --> 00:09:19,289 And if you stick around, we'll decide in this 159 00:09:19,289 --> 00:09:21,200 here after we hear from all the applicants. 160 00:09:21,200 --> 00:09:23,729 So you can stick around if you want. 161 00:09:23,729 --> 00:09:24,895 >> I will stick around. 162 00:09:24,895 --> 00:09:26,895 Thank you. 163 00:09:32,849 --> 00:09:35,249 A quiet little pause. 164 00:09:38,609 --> 00:09:41,900 Jonathan will get ready. 165 00:09:53,369 --> 00:09:55,649 I think it should be on. 166 00:09:55,649 --> 00:09:57,649 >> Hello, hello, hello. 167 00:09:59,809 --> 00:10:03,332 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We will continue here. 168 00:10:03,332 --> 00:10:08,169 Jonathan Marinaro, if you have three minutes, opening remarks. 169 00:10:08,169 --> 00:10:11,330 >> Thank you vice mayor as well as council members. 170 00:10:11,330 --> 00:10:14,529 It's always a pleasure seeing your faces today. 171 00:10:14,529 --> 00:10:18,649 I will just have to hear your delightful voice. 172 00:10:18,649 --> 00:10:24,113 With that mind, I have been a citizen of Santa Clara 173 00:10:24,113 --> 00:10:26,492 for going on 14 years now. 174 00:10:26,492 --> 00:10:28,969 It seems like it is a short time. 175 00:10:28,969 --> 00:10:30,969 I've been actually coming up here as a kid 176 00:10:30,969 --> 00:10:34,970 because my grandma still lives behind Santa Clara High. 177 00:10:34,970 --> 00:10:38,105 Eight years ago, actually wanted to be on this commission. 178 00:10:38,105 --> 00:10:42,305 This is what actually chooses and figures 179 00:10:42,449 --> 00:10:44,490 out how the city grows. 180 00:10:44,490 --> 00:10:48,277 It figures out the intent of what we want to do with it. 181 00:10:48,277 --> 00:10:52,477 After applying and getting delightfully knocked out. 182 00:10:52,569 --> 00:10:54,795 I was approached by the council members 183 00:10:54,795 --> 00:10:56,862 at the time who said I should have applied 184 00:10:56,862 --> 00:11:00,577 to one of the other commissions where my time could be better 185 00:11:00,577 --> 00:11:03,529 used working there and bringing the energy and ideas I 186 00:11:03,529 --> 00:11:04,565 had to that. 187 00:11:04,565 --> 00:11:09,161 With that I did seven years of our amazing cultural commission. 188 00:11:09,161 --> 00:11:12,609 Please go to our events, they are fantastic. 189 00:11:12,609 --> 00:11:14,370 Then a year on Bpac. 190 00:11:14,370 --> 00:11:19,620 When we can transition over from a basically ad hoc kind 191 00:11:19,620 --> 00:11:24,659 of in the middle committee onto a proper brown act 192 00:11:24,659 --> 00:11:25,665 compliant commission. 193 00:11:25,665 --> 00:11:28,969 It was that year that really brought 194 00:11:28,969 --> 00:11:33,121 my love of transportation on into the forefront. 195 00:11:33,121 --> 00:11:36,330 Now I was working directly with the folks 196 00:11:36,330 --> 00:11:38,273 who advised you on this. 197 00:11:38,273 --> 00:11:41,489 Who understood and didn't just have 198 00:11:41,489 --> 00:11:45,289 to deal with the aspects of placemaking. 199 00:11:45,289 --> 00:11:48,169 But really getting between those places 200 00:11:48,169 --> 00:11:50,389 and understanding that placemaking is not 201 00:11:50,389 --> 00:11:52,809 just location, but everything in between 202 00:11:52,809 --> 00:11:54,189 and how it ties together. 203 00:11:54,189 --> 00:11:56,469 That knowledge and that experience 204 00:11:56,469 --> 00:11:59,195 has been foundational to me wanting 205 00:11:59,195 --> 00:12:01,290 to come back here and apply again 206 00:12:01,290 --> 00:12:03,365 for the Planning Commission. 207 00:12:03,365 --> 00:12:07,502 I am very happy that Nancy is doing well. 208 00:12:07,502 --> 00:12:10,329 And that she's no longer on the Planning commission. 209 00:12:10,329 --> 00:12:14,433 After chatting with her over years in many events, 210 00:12:14,433 --> 00:12:18,742 I am excited to petition to fill her shoes on this. 211 00:12:18,742 --> 00:12:22,339 With that in mind, I have a background 212 00:12:22,339 --> 00:12:25,892 in journalism and working in that space, 213 00:12:25,892 --> 00:12:29,124 as well as the eight years of that. 214 00:12:29,124 --> 00:12:32,669 Working directly with all of you on many, many different projects 215 00:12:32,669 --> 00:12:34,709 all over the city. 216 00:12:34,709 --> 00:12:38,736 Please come choose me for planning commission. 217 00:12:38,736 --> 00:12:40,319 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 218 00:12:40,319 --> 00:12:44,519 With that, we'll start with our questions. 219 00:12:44,639 --> 00:12:46,264 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: Thank you 220 00:12:46,264 --> 00:12:47,259 for applying, Jonathan. 221 00:12:47,259 --> 00:12:49,529 What development in Santa Clara is a good example 222 00:12:49,529 --> 00:12:51,929 of planning and why? 223 00:12:52,289 --> 00:12:56,321 >> I do not think good planning should necessarily be judged, 224 00:12:56,321 --> 00:12:59,321 whether a project is perfect. 225 00:13:00,683 --> 00:13:04,289 I took or I look at whether the planning process successfully 226 00:13:04,289 --> 00:13:06,160 reconciled the constraint of the site 227 00:13:06,160 --> 00:13:07,993 with the needs of the surrounding community. 228 00:13:07,993 --> 00:13:10,699 With that in mind, I'm actually really 229 00:13:10,699 --> 00:13:13,970 impressed with what's happened with Santa Clara Square. 230 00:13:13,970 --> 00:13:16,209 As a development has done wonders 231 00:13:16,209 --> 00:13:22,209 to a area with a certain amount of nightlife, walkability, 232 00:13:22,275 --> 00:13:25,275 market access, and just placemaking. 233 00:13:26,713 --> 00:13:30,509 That as someone who has watched the Planning Commission meetings 234 00:13:30,509 --> 00:13:32,609 when that was first being built, because that's 235 00:13:32,609 --> 00:13:35,337 when I was first originally going through and applying. 236 00:13:35,337 --> 00:13:39,529 I am very impressed with how that turned out 237 00:13:39,529 --> 00:13:43,235 as an aspect of not just what could potentially be, 238 00:13:43,235 --> 00:13:46,656 but what was actually done at the end of that. 239 00:13:46,656 --> 00:13:48,112 It is a mixed. 240 00:13:48,112 --> 00:13:52,769 You want to address not just what individual citizens 241 00:13:52,769 --> 00:13:53,902 in the district need. 242 00:13:53,902 --> 00:13:56,191 You need to address what the city needs. 243 00:13:56,191 --> 00:13:59,822 You have to look at how that can help us 244 00:13:59,822 --> 00:14:01,769 grow smartly and innovatively. 245 00:14:01,769 --> 00:14:04,915 It is because of that development, not just 246 00:14:04,915 --> 00:14:08,649 the commerce and the residences but the industrial 247 00:14:08,649 --> 00:14:11,761 and I guess heavy commercial space around it. 248 00:14:11,761 --> 00:14:14,789 That is netted us three more fortune 500 249 00:14:14,789 --> 00:14:16,549 companies, which is fantastic. 250 00:14:16,549 --> 00:14:20,269 I'm really excited to see where the planning is going forward 251 00:14:20,269 --> 00:14:23,729 with now Nvidia's third building that's over on Walsh. 252 00:14:23,729 --> 00:14:27,349 It's really that example of just innovation. 253 00:14:27,349 --> 00:14:32,749 But really good planning that's creating places, not just 254 00:14:32,959 --> 00:14:34,959 projects. 255 00:14:35,649 --> 00:14:36,655 Thank you. 256 00:14:36,655 --> 00:14:41,123 We will continue on with Council member Chahal. 257 00:14:41,123 --> 00:14:43,810 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Thank you Vice mayor. 258 00:14:43,810 --> 00:14:44,599 Thanks for applying, Jonathan. 259 00:14:44,599 --> 00:14:47,729 My question to you is do you have any thoughts about the El 260 00:14:47,729 --> 00:14:50,129 Camino specific area plan? 261 00:14:50,449 --> 00:14:52,729 >> El Camino holds a special place on my heart. 262 00:14:52,729 --> 00:14:56,729 I grew up on the southern end of it, near San Juan Capistrano. 263 00:14:56,729 --> 00:15:00,900 So having come up here and driven along one of our biggest 264 00:15:00,900 --> 00:15:00,625 Stroad. 265 00:15:00,625 --> 00:15:04,993 It also impacted me with regards to being on the Bay path. 266 00:15:04,993 --> 00:15:08,969 We're looking to turn that into a bikeable and walkable 267 00:15:08,969 --> 00:15:09,969 corridor. 268 00:15:09,969 --> 00:15:12,949 Which seems insane to most. 269 00:15:12,949 --> 00:15:15,809 But you look at what's been done with that same stretch 270 00:15:15,809 --> 00:15:19,689 in other cities nearby, and it is fantastic. 271 00:15:19,689 --> 00:15:23,420 The value of the specific plan is 272 00:15:23,420 --> 00:15:26,769 that we're deciding what we want El Camino to become 273 00:15:26,769 --> 00:15:29,619 before deciding those individual projects. 274 00:15:29,619 --> 00:15:32,110 We want to give an idea. 275 00:15:32,110 --> 00:15:35,499 We want to give a metric of where to work with. 276 00:15:35,499 --> 00:15:37,662 It borders established neighborhoods. 277 00:15:37,662 --> 00:15:39,897 It contains neighborhoods serving businesses 278 00:15:39,897 --> 00:15:43,810 and it's a major transportation route with a visible part 279 00:15:43,810 --> 00:15:44,409 of Santa Clara. 280 00:15:44,409 --> 00:15:48,769 Having the specific plan to work out that middle ground. 281 00:15:48,769 --> 00:15:51,575 Being able to get people through it and to places. 282 00:15:51,575 --> 00:15:53,559 But not also take over neighborhoods 283 00:15:53,559 --> 00:15:55,461 characteristics is important. 284 00:15:55,461 --> 00:15:58,761 I think the density alone does not 285 00:15:58,761 --> 00:16:00,965 tell whether a project is good. 286 00:16:00,965 --> 00:16:04,549 It is not just about putting that on up there, 287 00:16:04,549 --> 00:16:06,635 it's seeing what else has been built 288 00:16:06,635 --> 00:16:10,235 that draws people to that area. 289 00:16:11,763 --> 00:16:14,853 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Thank you very much. 290 00:16:14,853 --> 00:16:17,191 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Councilmember Hardy. 291 00:16:17,191 --> 00:16:18,774 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Santa Clara 292 00:16:18,774 --> 00:16:21,240 continues to face significant pressure for new housing 293 00:16:21,240 --> 00:16:23,190 and development, while residents are concerned 294 00:16:23,190 --> 00:16:25,582 with traffic, infrastructure, neighborhood character 295 00:16:25,582 --> 00:16:26,829 and quality of life. 296 00:16:26,829 --> 00:16:30,409 How would you approach balancing these competing interests, 297 00:16:30,409 --> 00:16:33,409 when considering a development proposal? 298 00:16:34,889 --> 00:16:38,281 >> There is a false binary I found in this. 299 00:16:38,281 --> 00:16:43,249 That people believe it's either the old post war neighborhood 300 00:16:43,249 --> 00:16:45,649 characteristic or New York. 301 00:16:46,129 --> 00:16:49,349 The choice shouldn't be between development 302 00:16:49,349 --> 00:16:53,995 at any cost or preservation of that status quo at any cost. 303 00:16:53,995 --> 00:16:56,330 It should be good development. 304 00:16:56,330 --> 00:16:58,201 We want to start with a framework that 305 00:16:58,201 --> 00:17:01,135 understands the state law we have to deal with. 306 00:17:01,135 --> 00:17:04,497 The general plan and applicable specific plan and then 307 00:17:04,497 --> 00:17:06,379 the zoning required findings. 308 00:17:06,379 --> 00:17:11,779 Take for example, the state requirements around public -- 309 00:17:12,193 --> 00:17:15,369 or the dense public transportation permit that 310 00:17:15,369 --> 00:17:19,975 circuit directly nets us, Santa Clara you and a bunch of old 311 00:17:19,975 --> 00:17:20,629 quad houses. 312 00:17:20,629 --> 00:17:24,429 How are we going to develop that so that it's useful? 313 00:17:24,429 --> 00:17:25,669 Look north. 314 00:17:25,669 --> 00:17:29,890 Look to that area between the train tracks and the airport 315 00:17:29,890 --> 00:17:31,822 to be able to develop what is traditionally 316 00:17:31,822 --> 00:17:35,689 an industrial space into the density that 317 00:17:35,689 --> 00:17:38,209 should be around Bart station. 318 00:17:38,209 --> 00:17:42,169 That should be around Caltrain and multimodal transportation 319 00:17:42,169 --> 00:17:42,809 there. 320 00:17:42,809 --> 00:17:47,900 The change itself is not automatically impact. 321 00:17:47,969 --> 00:17:50,449 Change is going to happen. 322 00:17:50,449 --> 00:17:52,464 That is point of a planning commission. 323 00:17:52,464 --> 00:17:54,365 The city will grow. 324 00:17:54,365 --> 00:17:58,229 The idea is setting it up for success. 325 00:17:58,229 --> 00:18:00,889 Setting it up when that change happens, 326 00:18:00,889 --> 00:18:03,349 we're able to mitigate the impact on people 327 00:18:03,349 --> 00:18:07,549 and allow for the greatest growth possible. 328 00:18:08,482 --> 00:18:10,266 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Thank you. 329 00:18:10,266 --> 00:18:11,808 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you 330 00:18:11,808 --> 00:18:16,608 and the last question is, planning commissioners sometimes 331 00:18:17,289 --> 00:18:20,489 faced with strong opinions for residents, developers, 332 00:18:20,489 --> 00:18:22,379 organized people and other stakeholders. 333 00:18:22,379 --> 00:18:25,489 How would you evaluate your project fairly and independently 334 00:18:25,489 --> 00:18:30,409 when there's a significant public advocacy on both sides? 335 00:18:30,409 --> 00:18:33,519 >> I have a bit of experience with this with both the Cultural 336 00:18:33,519 --> 00:18:34,825 Commission and the Bpac. 337 00:18:34,825 --> 00:18:37,422 Everybody deserves to be heard. 338 00:18:37,422 --> 00:18:42,275 No one is entitled to that predetermined outcome is 339 00:18:42,275 --> 00:18:43,322 the biggest thing. 340 00:18:43,322 --> 00:18:46,889 I have had people come on up to me 341 00:18:46,889 --> 00:18:53,489 when I was planning a free party that was easily accessible. 342 00:18:53,969 --> 00:18:56,799 With food and sometimes even provided 343 00:18:56,799 --> 00:18:58,790 and they had complaints. 344 00:18:58,790 --> 00:19:01,809 I have gone through and dealt with people 345 00:19:01,809 --> 00:19:07,809 who want to make and shut down every car transportation 346 00:19:08,129 --> 00:19:11,909 corridor in the city and make it all just bikes and pedestrians. 347 00:19:11,909 --> 00:19:17,529 It is a combination of finding what their actual desire is. 348 00:19:17,529 --> 00:19:21,219 What they want permit how you can come on up 349 00:19:21,219 --> 00:19:23,749 please m, but understand their issues on this. 350 00:19:23,749 --> 00:19:26,149 Public participation is essential. 351 00:19:27,000 --> 00:19:29,542 Participation decision making are different responsibilities. 352 00:19:29,542 --> 00:19:32,974 You want to start with a record, that staff 353 00:19:32,974 --> 00:19:34,689 report, an applicable plans. 354 00:19:34,689 --> 00:19:38,169 You want studies and evidence, required findings. 355 00:19:38,169 --> 00:19:39,713 It's the work that's done beforehand 356 00:19:39,713 --> 00:19:42,113 that if someone is raging against it, 357 00:19:42,113 --> 00:19:44,229 but it's already established, I'm sorry, 358 00:19:44,229 --> 00:19:47,169 there's nothing we can do about something like that. 359 00:19:47,169 --> 00:19:49,819 But don't count the speakers. 360 00:19:49,819 --> 00:19:51,561 If you have too many people in the room, 361 00:19:51,561 --> 00:19:54,989 and one person that's up against it, counts just as much. 362 00:19:54,989 --> 00:19:59,284 They have an opinion that also needs to be heard about this. 363 00:19:59,284 --> 00:20:00,969 Because maybe the other people aren't 364 00:20:00,969 --> 00:20:02,529 able to show up to a meeting. 365 00:20:02,529 --> 00:20:04,825 You want to separate the volume of advocacy 366 00:20:04,825 --> 00:20:07,145 from the merits of the argument. 367 00:20:07,145 --> 00:20:09,120 It really comes back down to my work 368 00:20:09,120 --> 00:20:11,409 with the Brown Act and the Bpac. 369 00:20:11,409 --> 00:20:16,145 I mean, it is taking what is legally required 370 00:20:16,145 --> 00:20:19,900 and then taking the opinions of the folks that are out there 371 00:20:19,900 --> 00:20:21,522 and understanding that it's not choosing 372 00:20:21,522 --> 00:20:24,209 who wins come who gets a right. 373 00:20:24,209 --> 00:20:29,522 It's about figuring out what is the best use of that space two 374 00:20:29,522 --> 00:20:30,985 more forward with. 375 00:20:30,985 --> 00:20:34,799 Two figure out what maybe drawbacks are there there 376 00:20:34,799 --> 00:20:36,799 and address them. 377 00:20:37,350 --> 00:20:38,933 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 378 00:20:38,933 --> 00:20:42,129 Now you have your one minute closing. 379 00:20:42,129 --> 00:20:44,169 >> Thank you, vice mayor. 380 00:20:44,169 --> 00:20:48,369 Really planning commission is probably -- no, 381 00:20:49,311 --> 00:20:53,161 it is the most important commission when it comes 382 00:20:53,161 --> 00:20:53,785 to cities. 383 00:20:53,785 --> 00:20:56,846 Because the choice of going through and taking 384 00:20:56,846 --> 00:21:01,462 the nitty gritty load off your shoulders of individual 385 00:21:01,462 --> 00:21:05,620 easements to zoning, to property fines. 386 00:21:05,537 --> 00:21:08,189 I have a breadth of experience. 387 00:21:08,189 --> 00:21:12,550 I have shown not just to be capable of doing the job, 388 00:21:12,550 --> 00:21:15,119 but have done the job in finding consensus. 389 00:21:15,119 --> 00:21:19,319 Figuring out what's the best move forward. 390 00:21:19,329 --> 00:21:22,209 I think that's what makes me a perfect candidate 391 00:21:22,209 --> 00:21:25,435 to fill Nancy's shoes, as she's done before me. 392 00:21:25,435 --> 00:21:27,435 Thank you. 393 00:21:27,625 --> 00:21:29,208 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 394 00:21:29,208 --> 00:21:35,208 Next we're going to hear from applicant Jeffrey Jeff Razza. 395 00:21:35,769 --> 00:21:40,569 You will have your three minutes opening statement. 396 00:21:41,890 --> 00:21:44,841 >> Thank you, council members, vice mayor and staff. 397 00:21:44,841 --> 00:21:46,801 Thank you for being here for us tonight. 398 00:21:46,801 --> 00:21:49,721 I moved to Santa Clara in 1989. 399 00:21:49,721 --> 00:21:52,249 Literally a month before the earthquake. 400 00:21:52,249 --> 00:21:54,431 So welcome on that. 401 00:21:54,431 --> 00:21:59,953 I met my now wife and moved into what I never thought 402 00:21:59,953 --> 00:22:01,641 would be a lifetime here. 403 00:22:01,641 --> 00:22:05,429 I first moved in an apartment a homestead Avenue next 404 00:22:05,429 --> 00:22:06,575 to firehouse three. 405 00:22:06,575 --> 00:22:09,517 After being able to buy in San Jose 406 00:22:09,517 --> 00:22:14,217 come right on the north side of San Jose near the Santa Clara 407 00:22:14,217 --> 00:22:14,717 border. 408 00:22:14,717 --> 00:22:16,942 I moved back into the Kearny Farms area 409 00:22:16,942 --> 00:22:19,609 to the home I've called for 35 years. 410 00:22:19,609 --> 00:22:22,419 I have three kids who raised in that development 411 00:22:22,419 --> 00:22:27,109 and gone through the Santa Clara Unified System through Sutter. 412 00:22:27,109 --> 00:22:30,649 Books are middle and Santa Clara High. 413 00:22:30,649 --> 00:22:32,642 Two of the schools which my wife went 414 00:22:32,642 --> 00:22:34,709 to come which is nice to see actually 415 00:22:34,709 --> 00:22:36,873 some people from those days. 416 00:22:36,873 --> 00:22:39,535 It's been 30 years of high tech sales 417 00:22:39,535 --> 00:22:41,969 until COVID when I aged out. 418 00:22:41,969 --> 00:22:44,346 Then transitioned into real estate. 419 00:22:44,346 --> 00:22:47,111 I got a chance to move around the area of Santa Clara 420 00:22:47,111 --> 00:22:50,550 to see what is there and what has been moved to. 421 00:22:50,550 --> 00:22:51,681 As someone who lives on the South Side, 422 00:22:51,681 --> 00:22:54,535 thought the north side was really going to take place. 423 00:22:54,535 --> 00:23:00,795 Over my time here, I've seen the city change from a rural city 424 00:23:00,795 --> 00:23:03,151 to a more urban city. 425 00:23:03,151 --> 00:23:07,442 I used to drive down the street to see the orchards where 426 00:23:07,442 --> 00:23:08,149 Kaiser is. 427 00:23:08,149 --> 00:23:11,729 I used to drive down Lawrence and see the pumphouse. 428 00:23:11,729 --> 00:23:14,690 Sunnyvale, but now it's townhomes. 429 00:23:14,690 --> 00:23:18,205 I love the opportunity to help promote excuse 430 00:23:18,205 --> 00:23:19,519 me come a little nervous. 431 00:23:19,519 --> 00:23:21,209 I'm not going to lie. 432 00:23:21,209 --> 00:23:24,495 To help influence the growth that Santa Clara has 433 00:23:24,495 --> 00:23:26,971 in front of us, while maintaining the beauty 434 00:23:26,971 --> 00:23:31,204 that we have and we can still have again. 435 00:23:31,204 --> 00:23:34,101 Especially as Santa Clara looks to its redevelopment 436 00:23:34,101 --> 00:23:36,190 of the old golf and tennis court. 437 00:23:36,190 --> 00:23:38,569 And as we see the son of Great America. 438 00:23:38,569 --> 00:23:40,137 We're losing our entertainment, I'd 439 00:23:40,137 --> 00:23:42,713 like to see and possibly help influence what we 440 00:23:42,713 --> 00:23:45,858 have in store for our futures. 441 00:23:45,858 --> 00:23:47,441 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 442 00:23:47,441 --> 00:23:48,941 We'll get started with our question. 443 00:23:48,941 --> 00:23:51,781 We'll start with Council member Park. 444 00:23:51,781 --> 00:23:54,239 Councilmember Kevin Park: Thank you very much for applying. 445 00:23:54,239 --> 00:23:56,969 What development is Santa Clara is a good example of planning 446 00:23:56,969 --> 00:23:58,369 and why? 447 00:23:58,369 --> 00:23:59,949 >> Thank you Council member Park. 448 00:23:59,949 --> 00:24:03,270 Come down twice when I was looking 449 00:24:03,270 --> 00:24:05,569 through the questions that was either going to be Santa Clara 450 00:24:05,569 --> 00:24:06,929 Square or Lawrence Station. 451 00:24:06,929 --> 00:24:10,121 Since Jonathan talked about Santa Clara where. 452 00:24:10,121 --> 00:24:12,822 I'm talking about Lawrence Station. 453 00:24:12,822 --> 00:24:14,369 Lawrence Station is a primary example 454 00:24:14,369 --> 00:24:17,609 of utilizing the state's Metropolitan Transportation 455 00:24:17,609 --> 00:24:18,305 Commission. 456 00:24:18,305 --> 00:24:22,730 To utilize and get growth in areas 457 00:24:22,730 --> 00:24:23,299 near public transportation. 458 00:24:23,299 --> 00:24:27,209 Also based on the fact that I do have 225 year old twins 459 00:24:27,209 --> 00:24:29,873 that they don't want to drive around town anymore 460 00:24:29,873 --> 00:24:32,995 fulfills the need of having an area where 461 00:24:32,995 --> 00:24:34,825 you don't have to drive. 462 00:24:34,825 --> 00:24:38,441 Areas like Montecito where you can go down from your apartment 463 00:24:38,441 --> 00:24:41,729 to get your groceries and get your pizza at California Pizza 464 00:24:41,729 --> 00:24:44,930 Kitchen or your Starbucks coffee in the morning. 465 00:24:44,930 --> 00:24:46,758 This is what we're looking for. 466 00:24:46,758 --> 00:24:55,626 It needs to be a short distance to work and to be able to stay 467 00:24:55,626 --> 00:24:57,889 here when we get back home. 468 00:24:57,889 --> 00:24:59,889 Thank you. 469 00:25:02,669 --> 00:25:06,869 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Council member Jain. 470 00:25:08,190 --> 00:25:09,519 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: Do you 471 00:25:09,519 --> 00:25:12,249 have thoughts about the El Camino plan. 472 00:25:12,249 --> 00:25:13,449 >> I absolutely do. 473 00:25:13,449 --> 00:25:15,375 It was great read. 474 00:25:15,375 --> 00:25:18,375 The 216 pages of the brief. 475 00:25:18,677 --> 00:25:21,349 It's giving this outside something that's really needed. 476 00:25:21,349 --> 00:25:23,890 Personally this addresses a problem 477 00:25:23,890 --> 00:25:25,309 that always I felt needed to be corrected. 478 00:25:25,309 --> 00:25:27,793 As major land errors comment like 479 00:25:27,793 --> 00:25:31,490 the ten acres on Lawrence Square, 15 acres of moonlight 480 00:25:31,490 --> 00:25:34,129 and the other 12 at Lawrence Plaza. 481 00:25:34,129 --> 00:25:35,729 They are all underutilized. 482 00:25:35,729 --> 00:25:37,929 The plant would be able to help that 483 00:25:37,929 --> 00:25:42,395 with the addition of almost 4400 houses, additional businesses, 484 00:25:42,395 --> 00:25:45,675 restaurants, and the needs that we need. 485 00:25:45,675 --> 00:25:48,937 I drive down El Camino and we only 486 00:25:48,937 --> 00:25:51,113 have 3.2 miles of historic road. 487 00:25:51,113 --> 00:25:54,617 But it needs something to make us. 488 00:25:54,617 --> 00:25:56,249 We're here and we can do it. 489 00:25:56,249 --> 00:25:58,272 We just need to put that plan into effect. 490 00:25:58,272 --> 00:26:00,631 One thing I didn't see in the plan, 491 00:26:00,631 --> 00:26:02,509 and then I'm very happy about it, 492 00:26:02,509 --> 00:26:04,749 because of the traffic congestion a lot of this 493 00:26:04,749 --> 00:26:05,629 is going to take. 494 00:26:05,629 --> 00:26:07,849 We're not bringing a third and we're not 495 00:26:07,849 --> 00:26:11,390 taking a dedicated road for busses and public transportation 496 00:26:11,390 --> 00:26:15,452 Burbank it took me seven, ten minutes to get here. 497 00:26:15,452 --> 00:26:17,799 When it would take me 20 with that. 498 00:26:17,799 --> 00:26:22,599 So I look forward to helping implement that. 499 00:26:23,165 --> 00:26:25,813 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: Thank you. 500 00:26:25,813 --> 00:26:27,730 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: The final question 501 00:26:27,730 --> 00:26:31,930 will be Read by Council member Chalal. 502 00:26:37,877 --> 00:26:40,169 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Thank you for applying, Jeff. 503 00:26:40,169 --> 00:26:41,819 Santa Clara continues to face significant pressure 504 00:26:41,819 --> 00:26:44,259 for new housing and development, while the residents 505 00:26:44,259 --> 00:26:47,462 are concerned about traffic, infrastructure, neighborhood 506 00:26:47,462 --> 00:26:49,469 character, and quality of life. 507 00:26:49,469 --> 00:26:52,715 How would you approach the balancing these competing 508 00:26:52,715 --> 00:26:56,247 interests when considering a development proposal? 509 00:26:56,247 --> 00:26:58,705 >> Definitely be our job on the Planning Commission to look 510 00:26:58,705 --> 00:27:01,105 at these complex impacts. 511 00:27:01,489 --> 00:27:03,483 Additional housing creates more traffic. 512 00:27:03,483 --> 00:27:06,919 If we can do it the right way and we 513 00:27:06,919 --> 00:27:09,889 minimize how far people have to go to, 514 00:27:09,889 --> 00:27:14,129 whether it's traveling from Killarney Farms to Costco. 515 00:27:14,129 --> 00:27:17,260 Whether it's the one in Kifer or the one on Coleman. 516 00:27:17,260 --> 00:27:19,323 Keeping us where we need to be. 517 00:27:19,323 --> 00:27:21,510 We don't have the grocery stores. 518 00:27:21,510 --> 00:27:22,509 We don't have the department stores 519 00:27:22,509 --> 00:27:25,662 that we had a dozen or 15 years ago. 520 00:27:25,662 --> 00:27:28,929 By bringing that back and allowing people to travel less, 521 00:27:28,929 --> 00:27:30,905 traffic actually goes down. 522 00:27:30,905 --> 00:27:33,729 By allowing people to be closer to public transit 523 00:27:33,729 --> 00:27:38,729 to get it to people to come you know public transportation again 524 00:27:38,729 --> 00:27:40,489 brings traffic down. 525 00:27:40,489 --> 00:27:44,679 It'll work itself out as we run those simulations. 526 00:27:44,679 --> 00:27:47,900 For what we'll need in the future, 527 00:27:47,900 --> 00:27:49,429 depending on the type of housing comet whether rental 528 00:27:49,429 --> 00:27:51,222 or point of sale and ownership. 529 00:27:51,222 --> 00:27:54,120 Ownership brings a lot more families. 530 00:27:54,120 --> 00:27:56,989 Apartments bring in families or single people. 531 00:27:56,989 --> 00:27:59,389 Infrastructure dependent will change 532 00:27:59,649 --> 00:28:03,849 on what route we take for that. 533 00:28:04,736 --> 00:28:07,435 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Thank you. 534 00:28:07,435 --> 00:28:09,352 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: The final question 535 00:28:09,352 --> 00:28:11,134 will be read by Council Member Hardy. 536 00:28:11,134 --> 00:28:13,176 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Planning commissioners 537 00:28:13,176 --> 00:28:15,220 are sometimes faced with strong opinions 538 00:28:15,220 --> 00:28:17,422 from residents, developers, organized 539 00:28:18,569 --> 00:28:21,569 and they get other stakeholders. 540 00:28:22,625 --> 00:28:24,769 I did not write this one. 541 00:28:24,769 --> 00:28:25,905 I'm just reading it. 542 00:28:25,905 --> 00:28:29,759 How would you evaluate a project fairly and independently? 543 00:28:29,759 --> 00:28:35,159 When there are significant public advocacy on both sides? 544 00:28:35,489 --> 00:28:38,389 >> I'm glad to see I'm not the only one who get tongue tied up 545 00:28:38,389 --> 00:28:38,969 here. 546 00:28:38,969 --> 00:28:43,115 This is a great situation and you're probably 547 00:28:43,115 --> 00:28:45,549 going to have an unpopular opinion of this. 548 00:28:45,549 --> 00:28:50,349 Obviously, public opinion is and there's 130,000 people here 549 00:28:50,553 --> 00:28:53,969 in Santa Clara but when I looked at. 550 00:28:53,969 --> 00:28:55,662 Depending on what numbers you believe. 551 00:28:55,662 --> 00:28:58,227 Everybody wants Paradise for themselves, 552 00:28:58,227 --> 00:28:59,935 but not everyone's going to get Paradise. 553 00:28:59,935 --> 00:29:03,466 When I was in high tech sales, I never thought to myself, 554 00:29:03,466 --> 00:29:05,151 we got a win win. 555 00:29:05,151 --> 00:29:07,250 We got lost. 556 00:29:07,250 --> 00:29:11,157 So maybe you're going to get a park not in your complex, 557 00:29:11,157 --> 00:29:13,322 but maybe close by that you can walk your kids to. 558 00:29:13,322 --> 00:29:15,631 It's going to be the matter of that we're 559 00:29:15,631 --> 00:29:19,113 going to have to bridge the gaps between the city's needs, 560 00:29:19,113 --> 00:29:21,809 in terms of the revenues for those common areas 561 00:29:21,809 --> 00:29:24,537 and infrastructure that's going to be needed, 562 00:29:24,537 --> 00:29:26,989 and bringing people here that want 563 00:29:26,989 --> 00:29:34,900 to stay and want to be and call Santa Clara our home. 564 00:29:34,900 --> 00:29:37,273 Just many of us on this side of the podium and on that side. 565 00:29:37,273 --> 00:29:41,822 The bottom line is you're not going to make everybody happy. 566 00:29:41,822 --> 00:29:45,422 Everybody does deserve to be heard. 567 00:29:46,890 --> 00:29:51,433 Sometimes what they want is not just going to happen. 568 00:29:51,433 --> 00:29:53,391 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you for that. 569 00:29:53,391 --> 00:29:56,969 With that, you have your one minute closing statement. 570 00:29:56,969 --> 00:29:58,669 >> Thank you, vice mayor. 571 00:29:58,669 --> 00:30:00,922 A couple of years ago when I realized 572 00:30:00,922 --> 00:30:03,949 I was more on the retirement side of my career, 573 00:30:03,949 --> 00:30:06,509 I started getting more involved with things. 574 00:30:06,509 --> 00:30:08,449 Real estate kind of opened my eyes 575 00:30:08,449 --> 00:30:12,385 as to what was going on in my main city. 576 00:30:12,385 --> 00:30:15,985 In contrast here, we have amazing routes. 577 00:30:15,985 --> 00:30:20,617 The average owner here stays and doesn't sell their home 578 00:30:20,617 --> 00:30:22,209 for almost 19 years. 579 00:30:22,209 --> 00:30:24,969 In some areas it's 5 to 7. 580 00:30:24,969 --> 00:30:26,570 There's reasons people want to stay. 581 00:30:26,570 --> 00:30:28,480 I want to keep it that way. 582 00:30:28,480 --> 00:30:30,769 My son's recently moved out of the house at 25, 583 00:30:30,769 --> 00:30:32,497 because of the high cost. 584 00:30:32,497 --> 00:30:34,975 And they couldn't stay in Santa Clara, 585 00:30:34,975 --> 00:30:36,933 because they could find things in their budget. 586 00:30:36,933 --> 00:30:38,595 I want to bring them back. 587 00:30:38,595 --> 00:30:40,711 I want other people to come back. 588 00:30:40,711 --> 00:30:44,410 I hope that my influence and the influence of the other members 589 00:30:44,410 --> 00:30:45,729 of the Planning Commission can do 590 00:30:45,729 --> 00:30:48,440 things that would allow others to enjoy 591 00:30:48,440 --> 00:30:50,195 this city the same way I have. 592 00:30:50,195 --> 00:30:52,789 Thank you for your time. 593 00:30:52,789 --> 00:30:54,372 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 594 00:30:54,372 --> 00:30:55,579 Thank you for applying. 595 00:30:55,579 --> 00:31:00,379 With that, our fourth candidate is Nicholas Rapido. 596 00:31:08,198 --> 00:31:10,310 >>, Council I think on question number four, 597 00:31:10,310 --> 00:31:12,830 the author meant to say organized groups. 598 00:31:12,830 --> 00:31:14,349 I think it is a typo. 599 00:31:14,349 --> 00:31:16,276 Sorry. 600 00:31:16,276 --> 00:31:18,859 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: You have your three minute opening 601 00:31:18,859 --> 00:31:19,359 statement. 602 00:31:19,359 --> 00:31:20,649 Go ahead. 603 00:31:20,649 --> 00:31:21,782 >> Thank you very much. 604 00:31:21,782 --> 00:31:23,342 My name is Nick Repetto. 605 00:31:23,342 --> 00:31:27,362 I was born in Santa Clara at the Kaiser Hospital. 606 00:31:27,362 --> 00:31:29,362 Almost 26 years ago. 607 00:31:31,889 --> 00:31:35,729 I've been at Santa Clara resident my entire life. 608 00:31:35,729 --> 00:31:36,969 All 25 years. 609 00:31:36,969 --> 00:31:39,929 I went to Bowers Elementary School. 610 00:31:39,929 --> 00:31:42,329 When I was 5 to 6. 611 00:31:43,271 --> 00:31:47,497 Then I transferred to a school in San Jose, Saint Leo's. 612 00:31:47,497 --> 00:31:51,970 I spent my middle school there. 613 00:31:51,401 --> 00:31:55,601 After that, I wanted to stay back 614 00:31:57,102 --> 00:32:00,193 in Santa Clara for the rest of my high school. 615 00:32:00,193 --> 00:32:04,410 I went to Saint Lawrence High School. 616 00:32:04,410 --> 00:32:07,641 And it's located near the expressway. 617 00:32:07,849 --> 00:32:10,615 Also, I went to Wilson. 618 00:32:10,615 --> 00:32:12,403 Almost the old quad area. 619 00:32:12,403 --> 00:32:14,199 Next to the monastery. 620 00:32:14,199 --> 00:32:19,369 Going to that school gave me the opportunity to graduate early. 621 00:32:19,369 --> 00:32:23,369 I was able to graduate when I was 16. 622 00:32:23,369 --> 00:32:28,169 Because of that, my pretty much only option 623 00:32:29,679 --> 00:32:33,569 for continuing school at that point was to go to De Anza. 624 00:32:33,569 --> 00:32:37,409 Just any community college come because didn't get a chance 625 00:32:37,409 --> 00:32:39,609 to take the SATs comment because I graduated 626 00:32:39,609 --> 00:32:43,209 before that was open to me. 627 00:32:43,277 --> 00:32:46,265 I did that and because I went to community college, 628 00:32:46,265 --> 00:32:50,409 I was able to transfer into a four year. 629 00:32:50,409 --> 00:32:51,334 That worked out. 630 00:32:51,334 --> 00:32:53,822 I went to San Jose State. 631 00:32:53,822 --> 00:32:58,699 Then I got a degree from the Department of Geography 632 00:32:58,699 --> 00:33:00,409 and Urban Planning. 633 00:33:00,409 --> 00:33:05,209 I have been working in the solar industry. 634 00:33:06,782 --> 00:33:08,692 Just installations. 635 00:33:08,692 --> 00:33:14,193 I've been doing that because I'm interested in both the energy 636 00:33:14,193 --> 00:33:17,129 industry and now I'm here because this is 637 00:33:17,129 --> 00:33:19,409 my other interest is planning. 638 00:33:19,409 --> 00:33:22,409 That is pretty much it. 639 00:33:23,231 --> 00:33:24,814 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 640 00:33:24,814 --> 00:33:26,731 We're going to get started with the questions. 641 00:33:26,731 --> 00:33:28,954 I will start with the first question. 642 00:33:28,954 --> 00:33:32,489 What development in Santa Clara is a good example 643 00:33:32,489 --> 00:33:34,889 of planning and why? 644 00:33:35,209 --> 00:33:39,729 >> I think both the elements I was thinking or that were 645 00:33:39,729 --> 00:33:45,482 mentioned already, Santa Clara Square and the other one that 646 00:33:45,482 --> 00:33:46,319 was mentioned. 647 00:33:46,319 --> 00:33:49,802 I was mainly thinking of Santa Clara Square. 648 00:33:49,802 --> 00:33:53,795 Mainly because it is a new development. 649 00:33:53,795 --> 00:33:59,149 It is kind of outside the rest of Santa Clara. 650 00:33:59,149 --> 00:34:02,289 It's more in the office area, industrial area. 651 00:34:02,289 --> 00:34:08,105 So most residents I feel are like too connected to it. 652 00:34:08,105 --> 00:34:11,549 It does provide an opportunity for people to travel there. 653 00:34:11,549 --> 00:34:14,472 Get away for a little bit. 654 00:34:14,472 --> 00:34:19,217 It's kind of a good location for traveling to 655 00:34:19,217 --> 00:34:21,545 and it's right next to 101. 656 00:34:21,545 --> 00:34:23,490 Major arteries. 657 00:34:23,490 --> 00:34:28,250 It makes sense to have a development in that area. 658 00:34:28,250 --> 00:34:29,192 Vice Mayor Albert Thank you. 659 00:34:29,192 --> 00:34:32,659 Questions should be read by council member. . 660 00:34:32,659 --> 00:34:34,867 Councilmember Park: Thank you very much for applying. 661 00:34:34,867 --> 00:34:40,488 Do you have any thoughts about the El Camino specifically? 662 00:34:40,488 --> 00:34:43,389 >> I have some positive thoughts and a little bit of negative 663 00:34:43,389 --> 00:34:45,389 thoughts. 664 00:34:46,129 --> 00:34:48,129 Councilmember Park: Leave the negative thoughts. 665 00:34:48,129 --> 00:34:49,555 I'm kidding. 666 00:34:49,555 --> 00:34:53,102 >> I probably live closer to El Camino than anyone's here 667 00:34:53,102 --> 00:34:53,602 probably. 668 00:34:53,602 --> 00:34:57,961 I live right in the backyard to it. 669 00:34:57,961 --> 00:35:02,331 It's probably a minute walk away from where I live. 670 00:35:02,331 --> 00:35:07,222 There are a lot of good things about it. 671 00:35:07,222 --> 00:35:12,220 I think developing the El Camino is necessary, 672 00:35:12,490 --> 00:35:14,849 because it's a major corridor. 673 00:35:14,849 --> 00:35:19,849 I think more focus should be on developing it. 674 00:35:19,849 --> 00:35:24,490 Especially talking to the owners of businesses 675 00:35:25,417 --> 00:35:31,417 who have one story, two story kind of commercial buildings. 676 00:35:31,868 --> 00:35:36,361 Also the ones that are vacant along the entire stretch 677 00:35:36,361 --> 00:35:37,408 of the road. 678 00:35:37,408 --> 00:35:39,899 There's a significant amount of vacant properties 679 00:35:39,899 --> 00:35:43,429 or underutilized properties along that whole route. 680 00:35:43,429 --> 00:35:47,929 Some of them have been absent or absented 681 00:35:47,929 --> 00:35:50,243 for more than ten years. 682 00:35:50,243 --> 00:35:53,689 It is just kind of sad to see that. 683 00:35:53,689 --> 00:35:58,488 That's such a major road is being neglected. 684 00:35:58,488 --> 00:36:02,688 That's like the positive parts about it. 685 00:36:02,689 --> 00:36:05,229 The negative parts come in my opinion, 686 00:36:05,229 --> 00:36:08,229 it doesn't really concern me. 687 00:36:09,129 --> 00:36:11,506 When you think about in my example, 688 00:36:11,506 --> 00:36:15,706 I live in a one story house . 689 00:36:17,329 --> 00:36:21,649 A lot of the plant or the El Camino specific plan 690 00:36:21,649 --> 00:36:24,929 talks about wanting larger or higher 691 00:36:24,929 --> 00:36:29,729 density residential buildings along the whole El Camino. 692 00:36:31,102 --> 00:36:34,993 It is kind of like a one story to a six story 693 00:36:34,993 --> 00:36:36,345 kind of transition. 694 00:36:36,345 --> 00:36:40,439 In some ways, that kind of bothers me 695 00:36:40,439 --> 00:36:41,894 it rubs me the wrong way. 696 00:36:41,894 --> 00:36:44,689 Because you have like 100 windows looking down at you. 697 00:36:44,689 --> 00:36:47,890 That kind of opinion. 698 00:36:48,329 --> 00:36:53,729 It kind of doesn't bother me in a way, 699 00:36:55,889 --> 00:37:01,889 because it would be nicer to see a little bit 700 00:37:02,449 --> 00:37:06,224 of median residential houses in the area. 701 00:37:06,224 --> 00:37:11,624 Higher residential is probably the better investment to have. 702 00:37:12,409 --> 00:37:15,889 Just because these buildings are intended 703 00:37:15,889 --> 00:37:18,769 to sit there or just kind of serve 704 00:37:18,769 --> 00:37:21,451 the community for many decades. 705 00:37:21,451 --> 00:37:25,651 Not just 10 or 20 years down the line. 706 00:37:25,776 --> 00:37:27,776 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you very much. 707 00:37:27,776 --> 00:37:33,776 The next question will be read by Council member Jain. 708 00:37:34,568 --> 00:37:36,776 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: Thank you for applying. 709 00:37:36,776 --> 00:37:38,859 Santa Clara continues to face significant pressure 710 00:37:38,859 --> 00:37:40,691 for new housing and development comment 711 00:37:40,691 --> 00:37:43,149 while residents are concerned about traffic, infrastructure 712 00:37:43,149 --> 00:37:46,179 comment neighborhood character, and quality of life. 713 00:37:46,179 --> 00:37:49,620 How will you approach balancing these competing interests 714 00:37:49,620 --> 00:37:52,620 when considering a development proposal? 715 00:37:57,780 --> 00:38:00,454 >> I think just simply meeting the middle is the best way 716 00:38:00,454 --> 00:38:04,237 to make or appease as many people as possible. 717 00:38:04,237 --> 00:38:08,269 You can't pick overwhelmingly one side or the other. 718 00:38:08,269 --> 00:38:13,385 You have to show that you care a little bit for everyone. 719 00:38:13,385 --> 00:38:19,385 Show that you're not being and just towards some people 720 00:38:19,681 --> 00:38:22,409 and not listening to other people. 721 00:38:22,409 --> 00:38:26,649 Kind of gathering an opinion poll of what the thoughts are 722 00:38:26,649 --> 00:38:28,695 out there in the community. 723 00:38:28,695 --> 00:38:33,129 Is the most important thing you have to do. 724 00:38:33,129 --> 00:38:36,129 I think also finding alternatives. 725 00:38:39,239 --> 00:38:42,239 Especially just big development plans. 726 00:38:44,969 --> 00:38:49,249 I was thinking in relation to the other question that's been 727 00:38:49,249 --> 00:38:51,249 asked . 728 00:38:57,427 --> 00:38:58,969 That it's probably like a better idea 729 00:38:58,969 --> 00:39:02,569 to place more development in areas. 730 00:39:04,900 --> 00:39:08,209 Certainly long corridors, like major expressways, Lawrence 731 00:39:08,209 --> 00:39:14,290 Expressway and poly, even though there's not a lot of development 732 00:39:14,290 --> 00:39:15,529 on Santa Moss. 733 00:39:15,529 --> 00:39:17,159 It's mostly surrounded by residences. 734 00:39:17,159 --> 00:39:20,649 It makes most sense to have those kind 735 00:39:20,649 --> 00:39:22,169 of quarters developed. 736 00:39:22,169 --> 00:39:26,969 More so than middle of corridors or areas 737 00:39:27,795 --> 00:39:31,995 that are far away from transit corridors. 738 00:39:35,900 --> 00:39:39,465 Also, this is kind of a related topic. 739 00:39:39,465 --> 00:39:42,465 There is what's called SB 79. 740 00:39:43,517 --> 00:39:48,917 It is kind of like a state imposed legislation 741 00:39:48,949 --> 00:39:54,349 to promote the construction are basically control comment not 742 00:39:55,833 --> 00:39:57,369 control, but control the development 743 00:39:57,369 --> 00:39:59,649 of the corridors in the area. 744 00:39:59,649 --> 00:40:05,617 It kind of overshadows local from what I know about it. 745 00:40:05,617 --> 00:40:09,817 It overshadows a lot of local planning. 746 00:40:10,814 --> 00:40:17,449 So in one example that's how you meet in the middle with that. 747 00:40:17,449 --> 00:40:22,169 It's kind of hard when you have the state saying something. 748 00:40:22,169 --> 00:40:26,969 Then local residences being at odds with that. 749 00:40:27,617 --> 00:40:32,639 Like we don't have voices because our city is being 750 00:40:32,639 --> 00:40:34,633 overshadowed by the state. 751 00:40:34,633 --> 00:40:40,330 I think the other alternative that has shown up 752 00:40:41,969 --> 00:40:44,975 or people combating that kind of thing 753 00:40:44,975 --> 00:40:48,889 is getting sued by the state, because you're not 754 00:40:48,889 --> 00:40:53,890 abiding by the legislation that's being suggested. 755 00:40:56,409 --> 00:40:59,149 I think some kind of pushing against that 756 00:40:59,149 --> 00:41:00,579 is probably necessary. 757 00:41:00,579 --> 00:41:04,779 To have voices of the residents heard. 758 00:41:05,769 --> 00:41:09,969 Just so input is from both directions. 759 00:41:14,538 --> 00:41:21,138 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: The final question will be read by-- 760 00:41:24,928 --> 00:41:26,928 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Thank you, vice mayor. 761 00:41:26,928 --> 00:41:29,900 Thanks for applying, Nicholas. 762 00:41:29,900 --> 00:41:30,569 Planning commissioners are sometimes 763 00:41:30,569 --> 00:41:34,890 faced with strong opinions from residents. 764 00:41:34,890 --> 00:41:37,689 Developers, organized groups, and other stakeholders. 765 00:41:37,959 --> 00:41:43,359 How would you evaluate a project fairly and independently, 766 00:41:43,389 --> 00:41:48,189 when their significant public advocacy on both sides? 767 00:41:52,817 --> 00:41:57,449 >> I think this question is a little bit and similarly worded 768 00:41:57,449 --> 00:41:58,889 to the other one. 769 00:41:58,889 --> 00:42:01,302 My response would be almost the same thing. 770 00:42:01,302 --> 00:42:04,781 Just meet in the middle with both parties or all parties. 771 00:42:04,781 --> 00:42:08,981 To make sure everyone's voices are considered. 772 00:42:16,529 --> 00:42:18,290 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Thank you. 773 00:42:18,290 --> 00:42:20,321 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: You'll have your one minute 774 00:42:20,321 --> 00:42:22,321 closing statement now. 775 00:42:22,729 --> 00:42:25,369 >> I may not have all the experience as all the other 776 00:42:25,369 --> 00:42:26,589 candidates here. 777 00:42:26,589 --> 00:42:30,759 There are certainly a number of other or everyone here is 778 00:42:30,759 --> 00:42:36,759 certainly qualified , in my eyes, to have a position here. 779 00:42:38,113 --> 00:42:42,900 I really liked what I heard here. 780 00:42:42,900 --> 00:42:48,769 I think specifically if you want a voice for El Camino itself, 781 00:42:48,769 --> 00:42:52,209 just the corridor, I travel the corridor every single day. 782 00:42:52,209 --> 00:42:53,291 Weekends included. 783 00:42:53,291 --> 00:42:55,893 I know what and I've seen the changes 784 00:42:55,893 --> 00:43:01,689 that have happened across the El Camino over the last 25 years. 785 00:43:01,689 --> 00:43:04,189 For input on the corridor itself, 786 00:43:04,189 --> 00:43:08,389 I think I'd be the best candidate. 787 00:43:08,529 --> 00:43:11,982 Because I am familiar with all the communities 788 00:43:11,982 --> 00:43:16,782 along the corridor and I've seen the change. 789 00:43:18,960 --> 00:43:20,221 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you and thank you 790 00:43:20,221 --> 00:43:20,835 for applying. 791 00:43:20,835 --> 00:43:25,635 With that, our last but not least candidate 792 00:43:27,945 --> 00:43:29,433 is Sean Williams. 793 00:43:29,433 --> 00:43:32,969 If you can go ahead and give your three minute opening 794 00:43:32,969 --> 00:43:34,969 statement. 795 00:43:35,129 --> 00:43:38,601 >> First off, I want to say to each candidate that got up here 796 00:43:38,601 --> 00:43:40,309 comment you had some valid points. 797 00:43:40,309 --> 00:43:41,963 Your passions are amazing. 798 00:43:41,963 --> 00:43:44,329 Listening to what you had to say about our city 799 00:43:44,329 --> 00:43:47,666 filled me with even more pride as a Santa Clara. 800 00:43:47,666 --> 00:43:48,705 Thank you guys. 801 00:43:48,705 --> 00:43:49,833 It's pretty awesome. 802 00:43:49,833 --> 00:43:52,629 My name is Sean Williams and I've been in Santa Clara 803 00:43:52,629 --> 00:43:53,795 for quite a while. 804 00:43:53,795 --> 00:43:55,909 My children went to school here. 805 00:43:55,909 --> 00:43:57,789 Almost sound redundant with these guys. 806 00:43:57,789 --> 00:44:00,233 I've been involved with a lot of city activities. 807 00:44:00,233 --> 00:44:03,777 As a recent, Edmc, global Relations Committee. 808 00:44:03,777 --> 00:44:08,169 The face of Santa Clara, which I saw many of you at last night. 809 00:44:08,169 --> 00:44:10,634 Not you, man, where were you at? 810 00:44:10,634 --> 00:44:11,835 But that is okay. 811 00:44:11,835 --> 00:44:14,849 It has been a privilege and an honor 812 00:44:14,849 --> 00:44:17,969 to be involved with these voluntary projects 813 00:44:17,969 --> 00:44:20,949 to showcase my love for the city. 814 00:44:20,949 --> 00:44:23,913 To highlight other people that have 815 00:44:23,913 --> 00:44:25,689 been involved with our city. 816 00:44:25,689 --> 00:44:28,431 To bring some really awesome events to the city. 817 00:44:28,431 --> 00:44:32,946 The other thing I did a while back, I want to say it was 2016, 818 00:44:32,946 --> 00:44:34,673 I served on the planning commission. 819 00:44:34,673 --> 00:44:37,250 I had to step down for some personal reasons. 820 00:44:37,250 --> 00:44:38,862 I had family issues going on. 821 00:44:38,862 --> 00:44:40,835 I regret that it happened. 822 00:44:40,835 --> 00:44:43,177 However, those issues have been resolved 823 00:44:43,177 --> 00:44:45,809 for quite some time which is why I 824 00:44:45,809 --> 00:44:48,489 got involved with the Edmc and other committees 825 00:44:48,489 --> 00:44:49,999 as I previously stated. 826 00:44:49,999 --> 00:44:52,457 Now I'm coming back for the Planning Commission. 827 00:44:52,457 --> 00:44:56,890 As a Santa Clara, I've seen a lot of growth. 828 00:44:56,890 --> 00:44:58,235 I've seen both ends. 829 00:44:58,235 --> 00:45:00,469 I've seen growth that I like. 830 00:45:00,469 --> 00:45:02,569 I've seen growth that I don't like. 831 00:45:02,569 --> 00:45:05,382 Ultimately, I think Santa Clara is 832 00:45:05,382 --> 00:45:09,440 headed in the right direction as a proud Santa Clara, 833 00:45:09,440 --> 00:45:11,431 I really want to be proud of that. 834 00:45:11,431 --> 00:45:16,290 Most of a small business owner I own a studio, tattoo parlor, 835 00:45:16,290 --> 00:45:18,875 dream school and a live venue in downtown San Jose. 836 00:45:18,875 --> 00:45:22,817 We had to move because they built condos on our old property 837 00:45:22,817 --> 00:45:25,441 period I understand the growth is important 838 00:45:25,441 --> 00:45:28,209 and the future is moving forward no matter what. 839 00:45:28,209 --> 00:45:33,170 It is one of the biggest reasons why I want to be part of this. 840 00:45:33,170 --> 00:45:36,170 I'm passionate about our city. 841 00:45:36,295 --> 00:45:37,878 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 842 00:45:37,878 --> 00:45:39,569 We'll get started with our questions. 843 00:45:39,569 --> 00:45:41,569 Councilmember Hardy. 844 00:45:42,392 --> 00:45:44,809 Councilmember Karen Hardy: What development in Santa Clara 845 00:45:44,809 --> 00:45:48,769 is a good example of planning and why? 846 00:45:48,769 --> 00:45:50,305 >> What John said. 847 00:45:50,305 --> 00:45:51,985 Everything he said. 848 00:45:51,985 --> 00:45:53,985 Santa Clara square. 849 00:45:54,489 --> 00:45:57,769 What I wrote down is it took an industrial area 850 00:45:57,769 --> 00:46:01,350 and it created a neighborhood that aligns with the hometown 851 00:46:01,350 --> 00:46:02,750 vibe of our city. 852 00:46:02,750 --> 00:46:06,235 While truly showing growth and with the future of Santa Clara 853 00:46:06,235 --> 00:46:08,397 or where the future of Santa Clara is headed. 854 00:46:08,397 --> 00:46:12,435 A lot of these pop up cities, the little 15 minute 855 00:46:12,435 --> 00:46:13,809 cities they're calling them. 856 00:46:13,809 --> 00:46:14,889 15 minute towns. 857 00:46:14,889 --> 00:46:17,681 Where everything is right there. 858 00:46:17,681 --> 00:46:20,255 Is Montecito the name of it? 859 00:46:20,255 --> 00:46:22,157 I was just over there. 860 00:46:22,157 --> 00:46:26,201 I shop at that Nob Hill and California Pizza kitchen 861 00:46:26,201 --> 00:46:26,993 is cool. 862 00:46:26,993 --> 00:46:29,216 That kind of stuff having convenience of that. 863 00:46:29,216 --> 00:46:30,902 It cuts down on congestion. 864 00:46:30,902 --> 00:46:33,201 As everybody else has stated. 865 00:46:33,201 --> 00:46:35,734 I think that but over there off of Santa 866 00:46:35,734 --> 00:46:36,817 Clara Square is brilliant. 867 00:46:36,817 --> 00:46:39,795 It has been sitting empty for quite a while. 868 00:46:39,795 --> 00:46:42,657 To see something pop up right next to the stadium, 869 00:46:42,657 --> 00:46:47,457 other than empty office buildings is pretty awesome. 870 00:46:47,880 --> 00:46:49,422 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Thank you. 871 00:46:49,422 --> 00:46:50,489 >> You're welcome. 872 00:46:50,489 --> 00:46:53,232 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: I have question number two. 873 00:46:53,232 --> 00:46:55,649 Do you have any thoughts about the El Camino specific area 874 00:46:55,649 --> 00:46:56,769 plan. 875 00:46:56,769 --> 00:46:58,574 >> Sir, yes sir. 876 00:46:58,574 --> 00:47:01,515 It is a concept allowing growth for our city 877 00:47:01,515 --> 00:47:03,723 while we care our hometown vibe that we love so much. 878 00:47:03,723 --> 00:47:06,290 It's a win win for Santa Clara and it 879 00:47:06,290 --> 00:47:07,469 sets stage for future projects. 880 00:47:07,469 --> 00:47:09,733 It's clearly where everything is headed. 881 00:47:09,733 --> 00:47:11,177 It was a good vision. 882 00:47:11,177 --> 00:47:12,422 It was executed well. 883 00:47:12,422 --> 00:47:14,695 Or it will be executed well. 884 00:47:14,695 --> 00:47:17,895 I think as it moves forward, it is 885 00:47:17,895 --> 00:47:20,508 going to be a good win for us. 886 00:47:20,508 --> 00:47:22,797 We are on the global stage now. 887 00:47:22,797 --> 00:47:26,255 Let's show what we can do with our space. 888 00:47:26,255 --> 00:47:27,838 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 889 00:47:27,838 --> 00:47:31,438 Council number three is council member. . 890 00:47:32,154 --> 00:47:34,529 Councilmember Kevin Park: Thank you very much for coming. 891 00:47:34,529 --> 00:47:35,329 >> You are welcome. 892 00:47:35,329 --> 00:47:38,829 I came to see you, buddy. 893 00:47:38,829 --> 00:47:40,787 Councilmember Kevin Park: Actually I knew that. 894 00:47:40,787 --> 00:47:42,389 Santa Clara continues to face significant pressure 895 00:47:42,389 --> 00:47:44,931 for new housing and development while residents are concerned 896 00:47:44,931 --> 00:47:47,555 about traffic, infrastructure, neighborhood character 897 00:47:47,555 --> 00:47:48,909 and quality of life. 898 00:47:48,909 --> 00:47:51,409 How would you approach balancing these competing interests 899 00:47:51,409 --> 00:47:53,923 while considering a development proposal? 900 00:47:53,923 --> 00:47:54,673 >> Great question. 901 00:47:54,673 --> 00:47:56,380 I'm glad you asked. 902 00:47:56,380 --> 00:47:58,961 Approaches to treat it not as a competition at all. 903 00:47:58,961 --> 00:48:02,369 Evaluate each proposal as a complete neighborhood assessment 904 00:48:02,369 --> 00:48:04,369 or investment. 905 00:48:05,489 --> 00:48:09,689 With on going housing crisis, we have 906 00:48:11,600 --> 00:48:14,953 to ask how much the housing proposal and what it brings 907 00:48:14,953 --> 00:48:18,189 to our community and what comes with it to keep a functional 908 00:48:18,189 --> 00:48:20,589 Santa Clara moving forward. 909 00:48:22,440 --> 00:48:24,169 Councilmember Kevin Park: Thank you very much, sir. 910 00:48:24,169 --> 00:48:26,169 >> You are welcome. 911 00:48:34,714 --> 00:48:37,890 >> Planning commissioners are sometimes faced with strong 912 00:48:37,890 --> 00:48:39,489 opinions from residents, developers, 913 00:48:40,609 --> 00:48:42,609 organized stakeholders. 914 00:48:42,869 --> 00:48:48,269 How would you evaluate a project fairly and independently 915 00:48:48,379 --> 00:48:53,689 when there is significant public advocacy on both sides? 916 00:48:53,689 --> 00:48:56,377 >> To reiterate what's already been said. 917 00:48:56,377 --> 00:48:57,969 You cannot please everybody. 918 00:48:57,969 --> 00:49:00,529 All the people of all the time. 919 00:49:00,529 --> 00:49:03,490 We're also not selling ice cream here either. 920 00:49:03,490 --> 00:49:05,349 We are building the future of our city. 921 00:49:05,349 --> 00:49:09,549 I think the most solid approach would 922 00:49:09,969 --> 00:49:13,809 be to review what the evidence and what the city policy is 923 00:49:13,809 --> 00:49:15,769 and the current laws tell me. 924 00:49:15,769 --> 00:49:18,193 It's not which side has the better argument. 925 00:49:18,193 --> 00:49:21,792 But what we are legally allowed to do. 926 00:49:21,792 --> 00:49:24,890 As John stated, you listen to everybody. 927 00:49:24,890 --> 00:49:26,900 You take in their input. 928 00:49:26,900 --> 00:49:28,875 What it boils down to is the law and what 929 00:49:28,875 --> 00:49:32,475 we're allowed to do with it. 930 00:49:33,475 --> 00:49:35,580 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 931 00:49:35,580 --> 00:49:39,489 With that, we will have your one minute closing statement. 932 00:49:39,489 --> 00:49:40,574 >> These guys are great. 933 00:49:40,574 --> 00:49:41,969 I was really impressed. 934 00:49:41,969 --> 00:49:45,900 I felt underprepared as I listened to their speeches 935 00:49:45,900 --> 00:49:46,730 and their answers. 936 00:49:46,730 --> 00:49:49,449 However, I do have experience with the city planning 937 00:49:49,449 --> 00:49:49,949 Commission. 938 00:49:49,949 --> 00:49:52,382 I would like to continue that experience. 939 00:49:52,382 --> 00:49:54,695 I've experienced giving back to the city. 940 00:49:54,695 --> 00:49:56,529 I would love to continue that. 941 00:49:56,529 --> 00:49:59,422 With your vote, I think that gives me 942 00:49:59,422 --> 00:50:00,502 the opportunity to do so. 943 00:50:00,502 --> 00:50:03,810 Also thank you all for listening to me. 944 00:50:03,810 --> 00:50:07,866 I'm usually for both, but I kept my answer short on purpose. 945 00:50:07,866 --> 00:50:09,449 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 946 00:50:09,449 --> 00:50:13,490 With that, up to the Council. 947 00:50:16,969 --> 00:50:19,705 >> The council may deliberate when you're ready. 948 00:50:19,705 --> 00:50:23,849 You can either come however come we do have a public speaker. 949 00:50:23,849 --> 00:50:25,749 This normally doesn't occur. 950 00:50:25,749 --> 00:50:29,617 We have someone online who has their hand up to make a comment. 951 00:50:29,617 --> 00:50:35,239 This is a public meeting period so it is open to public comment. 952 00:50:35,239 --> 00:50:37,489 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We'll take public comment. 953 00:50:37,489 --> 00:50:42,890 Anyone in the chamber who would want to speak? 954 00:50:42,890 --> 00:50:45,513 We will take the person online. 955 00:50:45,513 --> 00:50:47,513 Kirk Vartan. 956 00:50:48,849 --> 00:50:50,657 >> Good evening council members. 957 00:50:50,657 --> 00:50:52,361 Kirk Vartan here. 958 00:50:52,361 --> 00:50:54,569 You have now heard from all five candidates. 959 00:50:54,569 --> 00:50:58,249 As you deliberate, I ask you to waive what you heard tonight 960 00:50:58,249 --> 00:51:02,309 against three test: First, when the city adopted policies, 961 00:51:02,309 --> 00:51:05,409 the general plan, housing element, point 962 00:51:05,409 --> 00:51:07,542 when direction and the loudest voices in the room 963 00:51:07,542 --> 00:51:10,573 point the other, which way did each candidate Tell you 964 00:51:10,573 --> 00:51:14,349 they would go Kim in you're feeling only matters 965 00:51:14,349 --> 00:51:17,502 on the nights when following adopted policy is uncomfortable. 966 00:51:17,502 --> 00:51:23,329 Second, what wait did they give the commitments already made? 967 00:51:23,329 --> 00:51:26,369 Covenants recorded on title, conditions of approval, 968 00:51:26,369 --> 00:51:29,321 promises made with public land and public money changed hands. 969 00:51:29,321 --> 00:51:31,817 Commission seat is not a place to renegotiate 970 00:51:31,817 --> 00:51:35,330 the public side of a bargain after the private side has 971 00:51:35,330 --> 00:51:35,645 been paid. 972 00:51:35,645 --> 00:51:39,551 Third, did they treat the housing element as binding site 973 00:51:39,551 --> 00:51:42,179 by site or a document we celebrate 974 00:51:42,179 --> 00:51:45,155 when it's adopted and abandoned parcel by parcel. 975 00:51:45,155 --> 00:51:47,309 One can it stood out tonight. 976 00:51:47,309 --> 00:51:50,909 Mr. Mariano Ray's place making unprompted. 977 00:51:51,900 --> 00:51:53,625 Mentioned San Juan Capistrano, where 978 00:51:53,625 --> 00:51:57,753 the ecology center is grounded and the Agrihood farm was model. 979 00:51:57,753 --> 00:52:00,849 When asked about pressure, described standing 980 00:52:00,849 --> 00:52:02,649 with one voice against ten because everyone 981 00:52:02,649 --> 00:52:03,617 needs to be heard. 982 00:52:03,617 --> 00:52:05,849 That answer is the whole job. 983 00:52:05,849 --> 00:52:09,161 I spent a decade and my own money 984 00:52:09,161 --> 00:52:11,490 on placemaking in the city. 985 00:52:11,490 --> 00:52:13,732 I know the lens and the seat needs when I hear it. 986 00:52:13,732 --> 00:52:15,299 I support his appointment. 987 00:52:15,299 --> 00:52:18,549 The commission has a major item pending, where exactly 988 00:52:18,549 --> 00:52:20,737 these tests will be applied. 989 00:52:20,737 --> 00:52:23,409 Point the candidate whose answers showed backbone. 990 00:52:23,409 --> 00:52:25,400 Thank you. 991 00:52:25,400 --> 00:52:26,983 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 992 00:52:26,983 --> 00:52:30,289 I do not see another hand. 993 00:52:30,289 --> 00:52:33,529 We will get on to voting. 994 00:52:33,529 --> 00:52:36,249 Typically we have a top pick. 995 00:52:36,249 --> 00:52:42,490 Nor, unless I am wrong, unless you haven't done it, correct. 996 00:52:42,490 --> 00:52:47,213 Our topic and then -- >> This evening you have one. 997 00:52:47,213 --> 00:52:49,213 One select. 998 00:52:50,890 --> 00:52:55,609 And other meetings you have elected to choose your top two 999 00:52:55,609 --> 00:52:56,249 candidates. 1000 00:52:56,249 --> 00:53:00,257 The highest vote getter would be the appointed person. 1001 00:53:00,257 --> 00:53:04,609 If you choose to establish an eligibility list, 1002 00:53:04,609 --> 00:53:07,771 then the second vote getter can be on that 1003 00:53:07,771 --> 00:53:13,771 and should a vacancy occur within six months from today. 1004 00:53:13,867 --> 00:53:17,580 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Council member Jain. 1005 00:53:17,580 --> 00:53:19,205 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: I believe 1006 00:53:19,205 --> 00:53:20,788 the instructions that were given to us 1007 00:53:20,788 --> 00:53:26,412 is if there are more than four candidates, we do two votes. 1008 00:53:26,412 --> 00:53:31,890 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: That's what you said. 1009 00:53:31,890 --> 00:53:34,950 if there are four or fewer applicants. 1010 00:53:34,950 --> 00:53:39,290 So if five or more applicants, the council casts one vote each 1011 00:53:39,290 --> 00:53:40,353 for two desired appointees. 1012 00:53:40,353 --> 00:53:43,659 Only one vote per applicant is allowed. 1013 00:53:43,659 --> 00:53:45,759 Can choose to vote for only one applicant, 1014 00:53:45,759 --> 00:53:49,189 but will relinquish the other vote. 1015 00:53:49,189 --> 00:53:49,942 Okay. 1016 00:53:49,942 --> 00:53:53,537 So vote for the top two, you are saying. 1017 00:53:53,537 --> 00:53:56,797 That's the way it seems to read. 1018 00:53:56,797 --> 00:54:00,397 I will let Nora pull us. 1019 00:54:00,549 --> 00:54:04,195 >> If the council is ready, I will begin. 1020 00:54:04,195 --> 00:54:08,995 We will start with council member chahal online. 1021 00:54:09,490 --> 00:54:13,849 Would you like to cast your vote please. 1022 00:54:15,990 --> 00:54:23,190 Councilmember Raj Chahal: I will go for Jeff Bereza and Nesma hi. 1023 00:54:23,729 --> 00:54:25,729 >> Council member Hardy. 1024 00:54:28,346 --> 00:54:30,221 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Jonathan Marinari, 1025 00:54:30,221 --> 00:54:32,221 and Sean Williams. 1026 00:54:34,929 --> 00:54:36,929 >> Council member. 1027 00:54:39,810 --> 00:54:41,649 Park 1028 00:54:41,649 --> 00:54:44,680 Councilmember Kevin Park: I'm going the odd man out. 1029 00:54:44,680 --> 00:54:46,680 Nick and John. 1030 00:54:48,890 --> 00:54:50,890 >> John being Jonathan? 1031 00:54:51,490 --> 00:54:53,490 Council member Jain. 1032 00:54:57,263 --> 00:55:00,863 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: Jeff and Sean. 1033 00:55:03,609 --> 00:55:07,209 it is between Jonathan Marinaro -- 1034 00:55:09,609 --> 00:55:11,609 I am sorry. 1035 00:55:17,333 --> 00:55:23,333 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Can I have Jonathan and Sean. 1036 00:55:25,317 --> 00:55:27,250 >> It has been between Jonathan and Sean. 1037 00:55:27,250 --> 00:55:28,242 Three and three. 1038 00:55:28,242 --> 00:55:31,842 Do we do another vote now? 1039 00:55:34,209 --> 00:55:36,729 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We can look that Jonathan 1040 00:55:36,729 --> 00:55:37,999 has the most number one. 1041 00:55:37,999 --> 00:55:39,265 You can do that. 1042 00:55:39,265 --> 00:55:44,650 We'll take another vote for the top two. 1043 00:55:45,675 --> 00:55:47,675 >> Okay. 1044 00:55:50,490 --> 00:55:52,490 Council member Hardy. 1045 00:55:54,742 --> 00:55:57,129 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Jonathan. 1046 00:55:57,129 --> 00:55:59,129 >> Council member. . 1047 00:56:00,446 --> 00:56:02,846 Councilmember Kevin Park: Jonathan. 1048 00:56:02,929 --> 00:56:04,929 >> Sean. 1049 00:56:05,249 --> 00:56:07,249 >> Council member Chahal. 1050 00:56:08,736 --> 00:56:10,422 Councilmember Raj Chahal: John. 1051 00:56:10,422 --> 00:56:12,422 >> Vice mayor Gonzalez. 1052 00:56:14,514 --> 00:56:16,889 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: John. 1053 00:56:16,889 --> 00:56:18,829 >> Jonathan gets the appointment. 1054 00:56:18,829 --> 00:56:23,629 And Sean Williams will be on the list. 1055 00:56:24,987 --> 00:56:26,404 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Can we 1056 00:56:26,404 --> 00:56:30,604 have a motion to approve the resignation 1057 00:56:30,649 --> 00:56:36,490 and appoint Jonathan to the Planning Commission for one 1058 00:56:37,689 --> 00:56:38,755 partial term. 1059 00:56:38,755 --> 00:56:42,355 And Sean on the eligibility list. 1060 00:56:42,635 --> 00:56:45,350 Sorry, Council member Hardy. 1061 00:56:45,929 --> 00:56:48,803 Councilmember Karen Hardy: I'd like to make a motion. 1062 00:56:48,803 --> 00:56:53,490 We first have to accept the resignation of Nancy Biagini. 1063 00:56:53,490 --> 00:56:54,249 Unfortunately. 1064 00:56:54,249 --> 00:56:59,649 I will nominate Jonathan Marinaro as our next planning 1065 00:57:01,822 --> 00:57:02,635 commissioner. 1066 00:57:02,635 --> 00:57:07,649 Then Sean Williams on our eligibility list, which will 1067 00:57:07,649 --> 00:57:11,249 be in place for six months. 1068 00:57:14,602 --> 00:57:15,409 >> I second that. 1069 00:57:15,409 --> 00:57:17,284 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We have a motion. 1070 00:57:17,284 --> 00:57:22,684 And we have a second by council member Jain. 1071 00:57:23,741 --> 00:57:27,941 Can we have a roll call vote. 1072 00:57:34,890 --> 00:57:36,889 I will just read the motion back. 1073 00:57:36,889 --> 00:57:41,689 It's accepting the resignation from Planning Commissioner Nancy 1074 00:57:42,620 --> 00:57:42,929 Biagini. 1075 00:57:42,929 --> 00:57:46,989 Appoint Jonathan Marinara to the partial term ending June 30th, 1076 00:57:46,989 --> 00:57:47,489 2030. 1077 00:57:47,489 --> 00:57:53,489 Set the eligibility list with Sean Williams for six months. 1078 00:58:07,569 --> 00:58:09,569 Council member Chahal. 1079 00:58:13,331 --> 00:58:17,531 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Councilmember Karen Hardy: Yes. 1080 00:58:19,970 --> 00:58:21,125 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: Yes. 1081 00:58:21,125 --> 00:58:22,458 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Yes. 1082 00:58:22,458 --> 00:58:24,849 That motion passes unanimously. 1083 00:58:24,849 --> 00:58:26,849 All in attendance. 1084 00:58:27,359 --> 00:58:29,759 Thank you for applying. 1085 00:58:30,515 --> 00:58:34,115 >> Thank you to all the candidates. 1086 00:58:36,946 --> 00:58:38,946 [Applause] 1087 00:58:45,707 --> 00:58:48,249 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We will take a five minute break. 1088 00:58:48,249 --> 00:58:54,249 Let's get started here at seven in a few minutes. 1089 00:58:56,889 --> 00:58:58,889 Stretch your legs. 1090 01:05:38,974 --> 01:05:41,266 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: If you can grab your seats. 1091 01:05:41,266 --> 01:05:42,121 Council members. 1092 01:05:42,121 --> 01:05:45,281 We are going to get started here. 1093 01:05:45,281 --> 01:05:49,481 We're going to get back in session. 1094 01:06:30,489 --> 01:06:35,289 Hopefully comet will see how long it takes. 1095 01:06:35,857 --> 01:06:38,257 Council member Jain and.. 1096 01:06:40,649 --> 01:06:43,490 Please take your seats. 1097 01:06:46,689 --> 01:06:50,889 We're not doing that today are we? 1098 01:06:55,472 --> 01:07:02,672 Councilmember Karen Hardy: I can do it or somebody can do it. 1099 01:07:11,833 --> 01:07:16,633 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Let's take our seats. 1100 01:07:19,644 --> 01:07:21,477 Councilmember Karen Hardy: And all the right 1101 01:07:21,477 --> 01:07:24,477 places with bright shiny faces. 1102 01:07:25,609 --> 01:07:29,280 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We are going to reconvene 1103 01:07:29,280 --> 01:07:32,280 our meeting for September 1st. 1104 01:07:33,657 --> 01:07:35,749 We have one item. 1105 01:07:35,749 --> 01:07:40,549 I will start with public hearings general business. 1106 01:07:43,986 --> 01:07:45,463 >> The roll call. 1107 01:07:45,463 --> 01:07:49,663 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Roll call, please. 1108 01:07:52,490 --> 01:07:54,257 >> Before I take the roll, I'll mention in accordance 1109 01:07:54,257 --> 01:07:57,977 in the Brown Act government code section 5493 B, 1110 01:07:57,977 --> 01:08:02,155 Council member Chahal is attending tonight's meeting via 1111 01:08:02,155 --> 01:08:03,369 teleconference. 1112 01:08:03,369 --> 01:08:05,900 The location from where he's attending 1113 01:08:05,900 --> 01:08:07,929 is included on the agenda for this meeting. 1114 01:08:07,929 --> 01:08:10,529 Council member Chahal at this time 1115 01:08:10,529 --> 01:08:13,189 will you please confirm that the agenda for this meeting 1116 01:08:13,189 --> 01:08:15,315 is posted at teleconference location. 1117 01:08:15,315 --> 01:08:18,529 That this location is accessible to the public. 1118 01:08:18,529 --> 01:08:21,581 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Yes the agenda 1119 01:08:21,581 --> 01:08:23,521 was posted and is accessible to the public 1120 01:08:23,521 --> 01:08:25,729 and nobody is in my room right now. 1121 01:08:25,729 --> 01:08:29,682 >> All votes during the teleconference meeting shall be 1122 01:08:29,682 --> 01:08:31,950 by roll call vote. 1123 01:08:31,950 --> 01:08:34,950 With that, Council member Chahal. 1124 01:08:36,426 --> 01:08:38,826 Councilmember Raj Chahal: Present. 1125 01:08:39,311 --> 01:08:41,711 Councilmember Karen Hardy: Present. 1126 01:08:43,292 --> 01:08:45,692 Councilmember Kevin Park: Here. 1127 01:08:46,684 --> 01:08:48,489 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Here. 1128 01:08:48,489 --> 01:08:51,689 >> And I'll make note that council member Cox and Mayor 1129 01:08:51,689 --> 01:08:53,737 Gilmore are absent this evening. 1130 01:08:53,737 --> 01:08:56,753 I will read one statement of behavioral standards. 1131 01:08:56,753 --> 01:08:59,189 The city of Santa Clara has adopted 1132 01:08:59,189 --> 01:09:02,290 a code of ethics and values and behavioral standards 1133 01:09:02,290 --> 01:09:04,601 for the public meeting to promote and maintain 1134 01:09:04,601 --> 01:09:06,439 the highest level of conduct. 1135 01:09:06,439 --> 01:09:09,619 This includes virtual respect common discussion 1136 01:09:09,619 --> 01:09:11,865 and allowing city business to be done 1137 01:09:11,865 --> 01:09:13,909 in an efficient and consistent manner. 1138 01:09:13,909 --> 01:09:18,809 Please note that as Presiding Officer, the chairs direction, 1139 01:09:18,809 --> 01:09:21,955 the Vice Mayor's chair direction in matters of process and quorum 1140 01:09:21,955 --> 01:09:24,930 should be followed and the use of the gavel 1141 01:09:24,930 --> 01:09:26,929 indicates that all conversation must conclude 1142 01:09:26,929 --> 01:09:30,169 and everyone attends should come to order and attention. 1143 01:09:30,169 --> 01:09:34,107 Welcome and thank you for your participation. 1144 01:09:34,107 --> 01:09:36,315 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We have one item tonight. 1145 01:09:36,315 --> 01:09:40,499 Action City Council's response to the City grant report 1146 01:09:40,499 --> 01:09:44,990 entitled report entitled -- city manager. 1147 01:09:51,249 --> 01:09:55,297 >> Good evening vice mayor and members of City Council. 1148 01:09:55,297 --> 01:09:59,249 This was on August 25th agenda but do not have time to hear it. 1149 01:09:59,249 --> 01:10:03,839 This is the second report of the grand jury from their 2025-26 1150 01:10:03,839 --> 01:10:08,639 season that is recommendations specifically related to Santa 1151 01:10:09,149 --> 01:10:09,649 Clara. 1152 01:10:09,649 --> 01:10:13,689 The report focuses on Vta's management and oversight 1153 01:10:13,689 --> 01:10:17,790 of the Bart Silicon Valley Phase two project. 1154 01:10:17,790 --> 01:10:20,429 Importantly it contains ten findings and recommendation. 1155 01:10:20,429 --> 01:10:23,879 The city is responsible for responding 1156 01:10:23,879 --> 01:10:28,169 to findings six and seven, which relate to appointments 1157 01:10:28,169 --> 01:10:29,273 of the VTA board. 1158 01:10:29,273 --> 01:10:33,462 I'll turn the presentation over to Assistant City Manager 1159 01:10:33,462 --> 01:10:35,462 Arcelli, a Zito. 1160 01:10:41,449 --> 01:10:44,872 >> Good evening vice mayor and city Council members. 1161 01:10:44,872 --> 01:10:47,872 Do I need to wait? 1162 01:10:51,599 --> 01:10:58,199 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We will take a quick pause here. 1163 01:11:01,569 --> 01:11:05,769 Councilmember Park, if you can join us. 1164 01:11:07,369 --> 01:11:09,769 We are good to. 1165 01:11:12,769 --> 01:11:16,641 >> This evening the item before you is requesting council 1166 01:11:16,641 --> 01:11:21,309 approval of the city's response to the civil Grand jury report 1167 01:11:21,309 --> 01:11:26,709 titled, Vta's Management and Oversight of Bart Silicon Valley 1168 01:11:26,837 --> 01:11:28,329 phase two. 1169 01:11:28,329 --> 01:11:33,449 As background, the report was published on June 17th. 1170 01:11:33,449 --> 01:11:36,433 We have 90 days to provide a response. 1171 01:11:36,433 --> 01:11:40,349 That we are required to provide a response September 15th. 1172 01:11:40,349 --> 01:11:45,249 The report focuses primarily on Vta's Management and oversight. 1173 01:11:45,249 --> 01:11:49,449 However, there are two findings and recommendations. 1174 01:11:49,889 --> 01:11:55,761 Six and seven, that focus on how cities appoint VTA board 1175 01:11:55,761 --> 01:11:56,261 members. 1176 01:11:56,261 --> 01:11:59,249 The city of Santa Clara along with other agencies 1177 01:11:59,249 --> 01:12:01,649 are required to respond to that. 1178 01:12:01,649 --> 01:12:05,249 For reference, the Vta's administrative code 1179 01:12:05,249 --> 01:12:07,509 does have six groupings. 1180 01:12:07,509 --> 01:12:10,753 Under each grouping, there's a list of agencies. 1181 01:12:10,753 --> 01:12:13,900 We fall into group five. 1182 01:12:13,900 --> 01:12:16,609 Along with Sunny Mill and Milpitas. 1183 01:12:17,745 --> 01:12:21,345 With respect to responses to findings, 1184 01:12:22,479 --> 01:12:24,953 the penal code provides two options: 1185 01:12:24,953 --> 01:12:28,105 We either agree with the finding or disagree 1186 01:12:28,105 --> 01:12:31,650 with the finding in whole or in part. 1187 01:12:31,650 --> 01:12:34,819 We are required to provide a response if we disagree. 1188 01:12:34,819 --> 01:12:39,190 With respect to recommendations, the penal code 1189 01:12:39,799 --> 01:12:43,189 provides four options: One, the recommendation 1190 01:12:43,189 --> 01:12:44,829 has been implemented. 1191 01:12:44,829 --> 01:12:47,825 Two, the recommendation will be implemented 1192 01:12:47,825 --> 01:12:49,915 over a period of time. 1193 01:12:49,915 --> 01:12:54,577 Three, the recommendation needs further review and analysis 1194 01:12:54,577 --> 01:12:58,729 and we're required to complete that analysis within six months. 1195 01:12:58,729 --> 01:13:01,404 Four, the recommendation will not 1196 01:13:01,404 --> 01:13:03,889 be implemented because it's not warranted 1197 01:13:03,889 --> 01:13:08,689 or it's not reasonable, and we are required 1198 01:13:08,939 --> 01:13:10,129 to provide an explanation. 1199 01:13:10,129 --> 01:13:12,789 As I mentioned, required to respond 1200 01:13:12,789 --> 01:13:16,950 to findings and recommendations to six and seven. 1201 01:13:16,950 --> 01:13:20,330 For finding six, it states that city groups often 1202 01:13:20,330 --> 01:13:22,769 do not follow Vta's administrative code 1203 01:13:22,769 --> 01:13:25,995 on appointing members with transportation experience. 1204 01:13:25,995 --> 01:13:28,862 We also don't reappoint individuals 1205 01:13:28,862 --> 01:13:30,509 to consecutive terms. 1206 01:13:30,509 --> 01:13:32,793 The city's proposed draft response 1207 01:13:32,793 --> 01:13:36,490 is to partially disagree with this finding. 1208 01:13:36,490 --> 01:13:40,209 The reasons for that is as follows: The cities appointments 1209 01:13:40,209 --> 01:13:41,699 comply with the state law. 1210 01:13:41,699 --> 01:13:44,209 Which requires that the mayor or a council member 1211 01:13:44,209 --> 01:13:46,529 be appointed to the VTA board. 1212 01:13:46,529 --> 01:13:49,529 Second, set of charter section 600, 1213 01:13:49,769 --> 01:13:52,809 outlines a requirement for an elected position 1214 01:13:52,809 --> 01:13:56,809 and it doesn't include any specific subject matter 1215 01:13:56,809 --> 01:13:57,509 expertise. 1216 01:13:57,509 --> 01:14:01,109 And three, Vta's own administrative code, 1217 01:14:01,235 --> 01:14:04,235 section 214, states that appointing authorities 1218 01:14:04,689 --> 01:14:07,689 are strongly encouraged, not required, 1219 01:14:09,449 --> 01:14:11,569 where possible to appoint individuals 1220 01:14:11,569 --> 01:14:13,569 with transportation experience. 1221 01:14:15,329 --> 01:14:17,249 Again, it's not a requirement. 1222 01:14:17,249 --> 01:14:18,705 It is just strongly encouraged. 1223 01:14:18,705 --> 01:14:21,702 So moving on to the recommendation, 1224 01:14:21,702 --> 01:14:26,890 their recommendation is to have each agency certify adherence 1225 01:14:26,890 --> 01:14:28,650 to Vta's code. 1226 01:14:28,650 --> 01:14:32,490 The proposed draft response is that the city not 1227 01:14:32,490 --> 01:14:35,329 implement the recommendation, because it's not warranted. 1228 01:14:35,329 --> 01:14:37,900 The reason for that is we will continue 1229 01:14:37,900 --> 01:14:39,433 to follow the state law, which is 1230 01:14:39,433 --> 01:14:42,475 to appoint either the mayor or a council member. 1231 01:14:42,475 --> 01:14:46,555 The City Council has a practice when making appointments 1232 01:14:46,555 --> 01:14:48,955 to commissions and boards. 1233 01:14:49,297 --> 01:14:52,989 That includes city boards and commissions as well as 1234 01:14:52,989 --> 01:14:54,649 external boards and commissions. 1235 01:14:54,649 --> 01:14:58,420 Our current practice is that the mayor brings forward 1236 01:14:58,420 --> 01:14:58,709 recommendations. 1237 01:14:58,709 --> 01:15:01,769 We bring that in open session. 1238 01:15:01,769 --> 01:15:06,169 There is discussion and consideration of the recommended 1239 01:15:06,169 --> 01:15:06,715 appointments. 1240 01:15:06,715 --> 01:15:09,489 Ultimately the City Council approves those. 1241 01:15:09,489 --> 01:15:15,724 The city cannot guarantee what a future council makeup will be. 1242 01:15:15,724 --> 01:15:20,209 We cannot confirm that a future council will have a council 1243 01:15:20,209 --> 01:15:23,699 member or mayor that's going to have expertise in the area 1244 01:15:23,699 --> 01:15:25,319 of transportation. 1245 01:15:25,319 --> 01:15:29,342 Moving on to finding and recommendation seven. 1246 01:15:29,342 --> 01:15:32,649 The proposed draft response is to partially disagree 1247 01:15:32,649 --> 01:15:33,815 with this finding. 1248 01:15:33,815 --> 01:15:37,289 To the extent that it suggests that the absence 1249 01:15:37,289 --> 01:15:39,769 of uniform process results in appointments 1250 01:15:39,769 --> 01:15:42,505 that do not comply with state laws. 1251 01:15:42,505 --> 01:15:45,349 Again, we follow the state law. 1252 01:15:45,349 --> 01:15:47,505 We have a consistent annual process. 1253 01:15:47,505 --> 01:15:50,481 We have not deviated from that process. 1254 01:15:50,481 --> 01:15:54,609 We also cannot speak to what other agencies do. 1255 01:15:54,609 --> 01:16:00,900 The report doesn't include any specificity, specificity on what 1256 01:16:00,281 --> 01:16:01,689 those agencies have done. 1257 01:16:01,689 --> 01:16:05,865 We have a couple policies that some agencies have. 1258 01:16:05,865 --> 01:16:07,929 But they do vary. 1259 01:16:07,929 --> 01:16:10,489 Recommendation seven states that agencies 1260 01:16:10,489 --> 01:16:14,169 should agree on a uniform process for making appointments. 1261 01:16:14,169 --> 01:16:17,782 The proposed draft response is the recommendation not 1262 01:16:17,782 --> 01:16:18,729 be implemented. 1263 01:16:18,729 --> 01:16:23,900 Because each city's approach reflects its own charter, 1264 01:16:23,900 --> 01:16:25,409 practice, policies and needs. 1265 01:16:25,845 --> 01:16:28,429 Again, we follow the state law. 1266 01:16:28,429 --> 01:16:33,609 With that, our recommendation is that the City Council approve 1267 01:16:33,609 --> 01:16:38,219 the draft responses to the Civil Grand Jury report and authorizes 1268 01:16:38,219 --> 01:16:42,779 City Manager to issue a report prior to the deadline 1269 01:16:42,779 --> 01:16:44,529 of September 15th. 1270 01:16:44,529 --> 01:16:49,329 With that, I'm available to answer any questions. 1271 01:16:51,974 --> 01:16:53,349 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We're 1272 01:16:53,349 --> 01:16:55,595 going to take counsel questions. 1273 01:16:55,595 --> 01:16:57,595 Council member Jain. 1274 01:17:03,412 --> 01:17:04,787 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: I'm 1275 01:17:04,787 --> 01:17:09,869 going to make a few comments before I ask my questions to set 1276 01:17:09,869 --> 01:17:12,869 the stage for my comments. 1277 01:17:13,849 --> 01:17:19,249 The Vta's project come the Bart Silicon Valley project 1278 01:17:20,737 --> 01:17:23,890 which this refers to. 1279 01:17:23,890 --> 01:17:26,689 It's a very long term project. 1280 01:17:26,849 --> 01:17:28,789 It's over 20 years in the making. 1281 01:17:28,789 --> 01:17:35,389 One of the things that the grand jury is interested in 1282 01:17:35,733 --> 01:17:39,333 is having longevity with the commissioners. 1283 01:17:39,682 --> 01:17:41,682 The committee members. 1284 01:17:41,709 --> 01:17:44,450 Because the project is so long, we 1285 01:17:44,450 --> 01:17:46,249 lose a lot of institutional knowledge. 1286 01:17:46,249 --> 01:17:49,250 We lose a lot of history if you keep 1287 01:17:49,250 --> 01:17:51,425 changing members board members. 1288 01:17:52,879 --> 01:17:56,479 That balances against expertise and interest. 1289 01:17:56,838 --> 01:18:02,745 This project is and I have been very skeptical and critical 1290 01:18:02,745 --> 01:18:07,585 of the three grand jury reports against the city of Santa Clara 1291 01:18:07,585 --> 01:18:08,449 around the stadium. 1292 01:18:08,449 --> 01:18:13,185 There were a lot of errors in those reports. 1293 01:18:13,185 --> 01:18:17,797 In this report I am actually 80% in agreement 1294 01:18:17,797 --> 01:18:24,769 with what the grand jury has recommended for the rest of VTA. 1295 01:18:24,769 --> 01:18:30,769 I just want to say that when I was appointed 1296 01:18:33,900 --> 01:18:37,209 to be the representative to the VTA, 1297 01:18:37,379 --> 01:18:42,100 I had a little bit of a fight on the council. 1298 01:18:42,100 --> 01:18:47,545 The mayor had been the previous representative to the VTA, 1299 01:18:47,545 --> 01:18:52,769 but she didn't seem to have a lot of commitment to the agency. 1300 01:18:52,769 --> 01:18:57,900 As a result, now that I've been on the VTA board, 1301 01:18:57,900 --> 01:19:02,769 I am now in the oversight committee for this Bart project. 1302 01:19:02,769 --> 01:19:07,409 I'm on the representative to the capital quarter, GPA. 1303 01:19:07,409 --> 01:19:11,890 I'm now going to be the new chair of the safety security 1304 01:19:11,890 --> 01:19:15,289 transportation planning period the organization and operations. 1305 01:19:18,340 --> 01:19:21,569 I've been very committed to this agency. 1306 01:19:21,569 --> 01:19:25,889 Spending a lot of my time talking to a lot of people. 1307 01:19:25,889 --> 01:19:31,889 You have to balance longevity with commitment to the agency. 1308 01:19:32,889 --> 01:19:35,524 Sometimes those are competing interests. 1309 01:19:35,524 --> 01:19:38,524 It doesn't actually make sense . 1310 01:19:46,525 --> 01:19:49,637 There's the longevity does it matter 1311 01:19:49,637 --> 01:19:51,729 if the person serving is not terribly 1312 01:19:51,729 --> 01:19:54,129 interested in the agency. 1313 01:19:55,129 --> 01:19:59,950 Sunnyvale had this problem with one of their members. 1314 01:19:59,950 --> 01:20:01,271 Did show up to meetings and I was the alternate. 1315 01:20:01,271 --> 01:20:03,389 I showed up to all the meetings. 1316 01:20:03,389 --> 01:20:06,209 I got to be able to vote on the items. 1317 01:20:06,209 --> 01:20:10,890 This project is seriously over budget and Overschedule period 1318 01:20:10,890 --> 01:20:12,895 it started at $4.7 billion project 1319 01:20:12,895 --> 01:20:14,513 and then went to 6.9 billion. 1320 01:20:14,513 --> 01:20:16,489 Then went to 9.3 billion. 1321 01:20:16,489 --> 01:20:18,489 Then to 12.1 billion. 1322 01:20:18,669 --> 01:20:20,573 Then to 12.7 billion. 1323 01:20:20,573 --> 01:20:23,569 Now they're doing a rebaselining and they'll probably 1324 01:20:23,569 --> 01:20:27,169 put it at 13.7 billion and up. 1325 01:20:28,410 --> 01:20:34,900 This project really does need to have very dedicated board 1326 01:20:34,900 --> 01:20:36,937 members who pay attention to the packets. 1327 01:20:36,937 --> 01:20:39,413 Read the packets and follow the issues. 1328 01:20:39,413 --> 01:20:41,233 We don't always get that. 1329 01:20:41,233 --> 01:20:43,445 We often get people that are there 1330 01:20:43,445 --> 01:20:46,952 to build their resumes to run for higher office. 1331 01:20:46,952 --> 01:20:48,229 It is unfortunate. 1332 01:20:48,229 --> 01:20:50,529 It doesn't serve the agency. 1333 01:20:50,529 --> 01:20:55,929 We want people who are more committed than longevity. 1334 01:20:59,890 --> 01:21:03,435 There's no way and having the longevity allows us to then get 1335 01:21:03,435 --> 01:21:07,179 into leadership you can be vice chair of the board 1336 01:21:07,179 --> 01:21:08,975 and then you can be chair of the board. 1337 01:21:08,975 --> 01:21:11,649 But you have to be there for a number of years. 1338 01:21:11,649 --> 01:21:14,609 The current strategy kind of disadvantages. 1339 01:21:14,609 --> 01:21:18,209 The smaller agencies, like Santa Clara. 1340 01:21:18,409 --> 01:21:20,977 Because we're actually on for two years. 1341 01:21:20,977 --> 01:21:24,469 We're in a group of three and we only have two board seats. 1342 01:21:24,469 --> 01:21:27,909 That means each member will serve for two consecutive years. 1343 01:21:27,909 --> 01:21:29,197 Then offer one. 1344 01:21:29,197 --> 01:21:32,929 So it makes it hard for us to get into leadership positions. 1345 01:21:32,929 --> 01:21:37,199 Because you're not there long enough to be able to get 1346 01:21:37,199 --> 01:21:38,793 into leadership positions. 1347 01:21:38,793 --> 01:21:44,169 I like the fact that we have some flexibility. 1348 01:21:44,169 --> 01:21:47,509 I've been very committed to being on the oversight committee 1349 01:21:47,509 --> 01:21:49,909 for the Bart project. 1350 01:21:50,599 --> 01:21:54,822 Art normal rotation as I've been on for two years 1351 01:21:54,822 --> 01:21:57,929 and then I would be off this coming year. 1352 01:21:57,929 --> 01:22:01,357 Carmen Montana from Milpitas was gracious enough 1353 01:22:01,357 --> 01:22:03,689 to allow me to stay on for another year. 1354 01:22:03,689 --> 01:22:06,377 So that I could follow through some critical votes 1355 01:22:06,377 --> 01:22:08,889 that are coming up for this project. 1356 01:22:08,889 --> 01:22:11,134 Having flexibility is important. 1357 01:22:11,134 --> 01:22:14,734 And I agree with our responses. 1358 01:22:16,515 --> 01:22:19,970 So I will be voting for these responses. 1359 01:22:19,970 --> 01:22:22,379 I wanted to put into perspective why 1360 01:22:22,379 --> 01:22:24,804 it's important to have some flexibility. 1361 01:22:24,804 --> 01:22:28,929 I think there's some real need for the governance. 1362 01:22:28,929 --> 01:22:31,329 For VTA to change. 1363 01:22:34,569 --> 01:22:40,410 And that is really kind of what the grand jury report refers to. 1364 01:22:40,410 --> 01:22:42,441 The governance of VTA. 1365 01:22:44,329 --> 01:22:47,513 But that is going to be done at the state level. 1366 01:22:47,513 --> 01:22:52,913 Because we're authorized by the Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: 1367 01:22:54,850 --> 01:22:56,485 Is there any questions ? 1368 01:23:03,805 --> 01:23:04,281 Councilmember Sudhanshu Jain: I don't really have a question. 1369 01:23:04,281 --> 01:23:05,899 I just have the comments. 1370 01:23:05,899 --> 01:23:10,699 My question is that is there any way 1371 01:23:11,260 --> 01:23:16,222 the city can try to advocate to change the governance of VTA? 1372 01:23:16,222 --> 01:23:19,222 That is my only question. 1373 01:23:19,886 --> 01:23:21,469 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 1374 01:23:21,469 --> 01:23:23,469 Council member Hardy. 1375 01:23:25,104 --> 01:23:27,729 Councilmember Karen Hardy: That is very similar to my question. 1376 01:23:27,729 --> 01:23:33,129 I, too, was frustrated with past grand jury reports. 1377 01:23:35,742 --> 01:23:38,409 This was in my mind much better. 1378 01:23:38,409 --> 01:23:40,889 We have very little control over things. 1379 01:23:40,889 --> 01:23:43,155 I felt staff's answers were very good. 1380 01:23:43,155 --> 01:23:45,182 I can support that. 1381 01:23:45,182 --> 01:23:49,349 My question is, knowing that our representative needs 1382 01:23:49,349 --> 01:23:50,657 to be committed. 1383 01:23:50,657 --> 01:23:56,151 Then they have to go off for a year is confusing to me. 1384 01:23:56,151 --> 01:24:01,518 I was wondering if that could be any part of our answer back. 1385 01:24:01,518 --> 01:24:05,700 That's some of the other agencies 1386 01:24:05,700 --> 01:24:07,929 can they have more of a consistent vote 1387 01:24:07,929 --> 01:24:12,129 or a consistent voice on this committee? 1388 01:24:12,640 --> 01:24:14,223 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: All right. 1389 01:24:14,223 --> 01:24:17,823 I don't see any other hands. 1390 01:24:22,929 --> 01:24:28,929 With that, we will take the answers or staff responses. 1391 01:24:35,360 --> 01:24:37,369 >> Why don't I start with the first Council member Jane. 1392 01:24:37,369 --> 01:24:40,313 Essentially, how can the city advocate 1393 01:24:40,313 --> 01:24:46,102 for its desire to have changes to the VTA governance structure. 1394 01:24:46,102 --> 01:24:51,569 As council knows, we have a lap legislative advocacy policy 1395 01:24:51,569 --> 01:24:54,241 that the Council reviews each year. 1396 01:24:54,241 --> 01:24:57,939 You adopt what your legislative policies are. 1397 01:24:57,939 --> 01:25:01,849 And there are certain guidelines for how staff responds, 1398 01:25:01,849 --> 01:25:05,889 depending on legislations and any legislation at the state 1399 01:25:05,889 --> 01:25:06,801 or federal level. 1400 01:25:06,801 --> 01:25:12,489 That does not govern or speak to vta's governance structure. 1401 01:25:12,489 --> 01:25:16,689 And so amending that is one way. 1402 01:25:16,795 --> 01:25:21,762 A zero 30 with direction to staff to issue a letter 1403 01:25:21,762 --> 01:25:23,806 would be the other way. 1404 01:25:23,806 --> 01:25:26,846 Zero 30 or an amendment to the LAPD. 1405 01:25:26,846 --> 01:25:31,940 We can follow up later once I have some time to talk to staff. 1406 01:25:31,940 --> 01:25:35,294 If there's a preference for the two. 1407 01:25:42,631 --> 01:25:45,890 >> The only thing I would add, is we fall under group five. 1408 01:25:45,890 --> 01:25:48,401 What we don't know is if the other groups 1409 01:25:48,401 --> 01:25:51,659 have a certain procedure they follow. 1410 01:25:51,659 --> 01:25:55,233 We wouldn't be able to speak to those other groups. 1411 01:25:55,233 --> 01:25:58,182 We can only speak to group five. 1412 01:25:58,182 --> 01:26:00,233 It's really in speaking to Council member 1413 01:26:00,233 --> 01:26:02,169 Jane on how that process works. 1414 01:26:02,169 --> 01:26:06,259 There's nothing formal on the appointment of the two board 1415 01:26:06,259 --> 01:26:08,659 members and the alternate. 1416 01:26:09,849 --> 01:26:14,177 It's just a consensus that that is a process that they follow. 1417 01:26:14,177 --> 01:26:19,570 But it is not Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: Thank you. 1418 01:26:19,570 --> 01:26:20,737 I don't see any other hands. 1419 01:26:20,737 --> 01:26:23,849 Anybody from the public that wants to speak on this? 1420 01:26:23,849 --> 01:26:25,849 Anybody online? 1421 01:26:26,489 --> 01:26:27,809 Okay. 1422 01:26:27,809 --> 01:26:29,809 Any comments? 1423 01:26:30,240 --> 01:26:31,814 Any motions? 1424 01:26:31,814 --> 01:26:33,814 Council member Hardy. 1425 01:26:34,890 --> 01:26:39,480 Councilmember Karen Hardy: I'd like to make a motion -- sorry. 1426 01:26:39,480 --> 01:26:41,844 I thought we did. 1427 01:26:41,844 --> 01:26:46,502 I'd like to make a motion for staff recommendation. 1428 01:26:46,502 --> 01:26:47,889 >> I second it. 1429 01:26:47,889 --> 01:26:50,829 Vice Mayor Albert Gonzalez: We have a motion and a second. 1430 01:26:50,829 --> 01:26:52,129 Council member. . 1431 01:26:52,129 --> 01:26:56,872 Councilmember Kevin Park: I want to make questions. 1432 01:26:56,872 --> 01:26:59,969 I was worried about responses because like many of the council 1433 01:26:59,969 --> 01:27:04,177 members come I was here during the previous civil grand jury 1434 01:27:04,177 --> 01:27:06,759 reports period some of those reports 1435 01:27:06,759 --> 01:27:10,265 and I will just say they were factually incorrect. 1436 01:27:10,265 --> 01:27:14,233 I was worried that perhaps with Gilman amnesia 1437 01:27:14,233 --> 01:27:20,809 we would accept a report that wasn't exactly pointed at us. 1438 01:27:20,809 --> 01:27:23,482 The fact that we looked at the report 1439 01:27:23,482 --> 01:27:25,590 and we looked at the recommendation, 1440 01:27:25,590 --> 01:27:26,841 looked at the findings. 1441 01:27:26,841 --> 01:27:30,134 Came up with with what we need to do. 1442 01:27:30,134 --> 01:27:32,929 These are the changes and these are the light disagreements 1443 01:27:32,929 --> 01:27:33,737 that we have. 1444 01:27:33,737 --> 01:27:35,254 I'm actually very happy with that. 1445 01:27:35,254 --> 01:27:38,649 I also want to make a point that Council Member Jane has probably 1446 01:27:38,649 --> 01:27:41,962 been the most educated person on the VTA board.