[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:05] All to order the Board of Directors meeting for January 14, roll call Manim Clerk. Please. [0:14] Dr. Mr. Barron? Dr. Shoe? [0:19] Dr. Key you? [0:22] Dr. Kevin? [0:24] Dr. Dr. Santas? [0:26] Dr. Raela? [0:29] Dr. [0:29] And Chairperson, I'm here. [0:31] Thank you. [0:33] Adam Chu, time certain, noticed that a public, the Board of Directors meet in closed session [0:38] in accordance with the Ralphham Brown Act following the conclusion of closed session discussion. [0:42] the board will return for the remaining items on the regular agenda. [0:46] Our closed session items are 2.1 conference with legal counsel and [0:49] anticipated litigation, one potential claim, and the second one is [0:53] conference with legal counsel existing legal litigation pursuant to [0:58] government code, relevant code, valid water versus [1:04] Matizo, that all Santa Clara's county security court. [1:07] All right, we will go to closed session and then after closed session we will [1:11] come back out, at one o'clock. [2:48] Call it back into session, the record is meeting for Tuesday, January 14th, item 2.3 district council report and closed session. [3:00] Thank you, Madam Chair. With respect to item 2.1 and 2.2, the board members being present, [3:05] direction was going to stop. Thank you very much. [3:08] Item 2.4, pledge of allegiance, please join me in a salute to our Republic. [3:30] Thank you very much. Item 2.5, orders of the day, [3:36] director Santos' ass that we continue item 4.2 to our next board meeting. [3:45] unless there is an objection, we will so note that under orders of the day. [3:52] All right, do we need to get to stand? [3:53] We don't need a motion for that, do we? [3:57] So that's what we'll do with 4.2. [3:59] Next item on the agenda is 2.6. [4:03] Time open for public comment and adding item not on the agenda. [4:06] Madam Clerk, you have any cards? [4:10] I'm not. [4:11] I do not. [4:12] You do not. [4:13] Then I will need to read this. [4:14] Item 2.7, an election of board share and vice-chair for year 2020, [4:20] nominate and elect a new chairperson and vice-chairperson, Michelle. [4:24] Yeah, you remind us. This item is being presented in accordance with board governance policy [4:30] GP5.3, which is included in attachment number one. And it states that the board elects both [4:35] the chairperson and vice-chairperson of the board of directors to serve one-year terms [4:40] beginning at the first board meeting in January of each year. Under the provisions of board [4:46] Governor's policy GP 5.3, beginning in the calendar year 2012, the positions of chair and vice chair [4:52] rotate from member to member in numerical order, continuing from the 2010 rotations. Any board member [4:59] may... [5:00] His or her discretion, and on a one-time basis, postponed by one year, the acceptance of either the chair or vice chair, office by swapping with the director immediately following him or her on this list of succession. [5:13] And it's provided that any newly elected or appointed board members would postpone by one year, the acceptance of chair, the chair office by swapping with the director immediately following him or her on the list of session. [5:26] Any board member may at his or her discretion decline to serve as chair or vice chair, and in the event board member declines a serve. [5:34] The district shall be skipped and the next district board member shall serve in their stead. [5:39] The policy also requires that the clerk of the board maintain the list of board members serving as chair and vice chair. [5:45] And the historical list is provided for the board in attachment to. [5:49] Thank you very much. [5:50] I need a motion consistent with our board policy that would be for district five to be chair and district six to be vice chair. [5:57] We have a motion motion by Director Cremend. [6:00] Second, second by Director Keegan. [6:04] Okay, so the motion is to dominate to be chair for the 2020 year to be our current vice chair, director Shua and the vice chair to be director from district six. [6:17] direct to Ristemera. All those in favor. Hi, all those opposed any abstention, that motion carries unanimously. [6:25] With that my turn over the chair to the vice chair or the new chair. [6:32] We're going to switch CC a real quick. [7:00] I thought like switch air. [7:09] Thank you. [7:12] everyone for your support and I will do my best to be the chair. I view the job [7:21] up the chair more like a coordinator for the board. So anything you like to [7:26] accomplish doing this year, it's my job to support that so collectively we can [7:30] accomplish good things for the organization. So with that, that's continuous [7:36] This is our agenda, item 2.8, recognition of Al-Going Chair, [7:44] Norma, how do you guys start? [7:47] And I will start up Norma Camacho, CEO, [7:49] the Valley Water with the recognition. [7:52] And I just wanted to say to the Al-Going Chair, [7:55] Chervazot. [7:57] I was really honored to have worked for you as CEO. [8:01] During this time period, I believe [8:02] as an organization, we've got a lot of conferences here. [8:05] And very much, we did get a lot of conversations due to the way you're outlook and trying to balance the environmental issues with both our flood protection and our water supply issues as well. [8:19] You keep bringing that to the forefront and keep us on track to providing a balanced approach and to ensure that those three stools are equally supported throughout our organizations are really thankful for that. [8:34] And I think it's really fitting that, and I came to the district back in 2012, I believe you were chair when I started, and now as I go out of the district, it was just an honor to serve on to you as CEO. [8:47] And so again, to your wishes, I know that you didn't want anything large, but one thing that we did honor your wishes is basically providing you a gavel here, which I would like to now present to you. [9:01] You [9:25] want me to take a photo? [9:32] If you want me to take a photo? [9:34] Yeah. [9:34] Yeah. [9:42] What do you want me to take? [9:47] It's close and fast. [9:54] I'd like to hear you sound a little bit loud. [9:57] Wow. [10:07] Thank you. [10:22] Just real quickly, I just wanted to thank my colleagues for all of their assistance during my time as chair. [10:30] May the close sessions and the open sessions really help me to move them along and to accomplish a lot of what we want to accomplish this year. [10:38] I particularly want to thank and fortunately Michelle's not here, but I want to thank Michelle King for all of her help, as well as the district council and the CEO. [10:46] They are really helped me a lot and make sure that we accomplish what we wanted to so thank you everybody and this I decided I didn't need another one of those big posters [10:58] So this actually has both by years of my cheer aboard cheer 2012 and 2019 so hoping I'm starting a new trend for everyone, but to reach his own [11:10] I didn't need like I said it need another one of those big posters to put on my wall [11:13] So thank you very much everyone. [11:26] Thank you, Director of the SOT for serving SD chair in 2019. [11:32] I personally learned a lot from you as you vice chair and work together with you as several critical issues. [11:41] So just want to thank you for teaching me many things. [11:47] Are there any other comments from both members? [11:49] I want to say something? [11:56] No, [11:59] so we have Director Keegan. [12:04] Thank you. [12:05] Well, congratulations to Director Schweig for being a person that's going to be leading us ahead in 2020. [12:13] And a big thank you to Director Lizot for all her efforts in 2019. [12:17] No one thing that just struck me was when I was running for office and I used to sit out in the audience. [12:23] Linda was the only person woman up here, and there had never been more than one woman board member, and now we have last year's chair and this year's chair, and I think that that's great for the community to feel like we have a diverse board and different representation. [12:44] Anyone who knows Linda knows her passion for the environment and I really would like to thank her for everything she's done as chair in that regard, but also in terms of being on this board [12:55] You're always a reminder of the fact that this organization has three pillars that support what we do and environmental stewardship is a critical part of that. So thank you very much [13:10] Give our trust, oh, that's your, that's, uh, Estomerra. [13:14] Thank you, Madam Chair. [13:14] I wanted to congratulate you on your accepting accepting an, uh, new position. [13:22] I know how it is. [13:23] I've been there a number of times now. [13:24] I think three times. [13:26] And so I get it. [13:27] And that goes for Linda also. [13:30] I haven't done this before. [13:31] I know how much work it takes. [13:32] I know how much dedication. [13:35] Uh, and I wanted to thank you for serving. [13:36] It's, I think we did a tremendous job, and especially with the efficiency of our meetings, [13:44] but it made me very, we're all very appreciative of that, really helped us all out. [13:50] So thank you very much for being appreciated. [13:54] Director Kramman? [13:56] Thank you, Chair. Congratulations, number one. [14:01] You'll be in the firing seat that former chair is in, hopefully it won't rain too much or it'll be too dry. [14:17] You know, kind of a Goldilocks during your term and I want to thank former chair Lizot. [14:23] Just got through a lot of tough issues this year. [14:25] What's not forget anyone who's sat in the audience knows that we we've had a lot of challenges [14:33] In 2019 [14:35] Additionally, I don't think 2020 is gonna be that much easier. So it's great. You lean on former [14:43] Sheryl Zoth for [14:45] Thank you [14:48] Dr. Santos [14:56] Yes [15:00] Is it not a lot off? Okay, okay. Okay, Dr. Santos? Is it over yet? No, still not off, but the push that is good, okay. [15:13] No, anyway, congratulations to Dr. Schu for taking responsibilities in Linda. Thank you for your services. I do remember this and it takes a lot of work at that giant game. I watch that. [15:27] And to go out there and practice and have a good form, I know your arm was sore early. [15:33] But you know, nobody wants to be on the spot when you're every looking at you to get that ball over the home plate. [15:38] I did a one hell of a job. [15:45] Dactivarala? [15:46] Thank you, Cherish. [15:47] So I just wanted it out for my congratulations as well. [15:51] To directly resort for your hard work to coin and to quote our director Santos. [15:57] It's not how you start, but how you finish. [15:59] And we hear that quite often from him and it's a good quote. [16:04] And so I think you started and you gave your best, and it's like hurting cats sometime [16:10] when you're dealing with this dishes group of individuals at the board. [16:15] So coming from having the opportunity to sit as chair in 2017 during the flood period, it was quite [16:22] an interesting time for me, and it was for all board members that have the opportunity to sit [16:27] in the rotation as chair and also to director Swaya looking forward to working with you and [16:34] your leadership and congratulations to the both of you. Thank you. [16:38] Okay, thank you. [16:42] I don't have anything showing up here. Anybody want to speak? No, okay. [16:52] Item 2.9, public hearing on the proposed modification to the Safe Clean Water and Natural [16:57] of what protection programs, upper Yagus Creek [17:00] for protection project. [17:03] Staff recommendation is open the public hearing [17:07] and receive comments on the project [17:11] and close the public hearing and adopt the resolution, [17:15] proving the modification to upper Yagus Creek project. [17:19] So I think I'm going to start first to open the public hearing. [17:25] Good afternoon. [17:25] My name is Nishir, and I am the Santa Clara Valley Water District's director, Director Chair. [17:33] Item 2.9 is the public hearing on the proposed modification to project E6 Upper Yagres Full Protection Project. [17:42] Under the Safe Clean Water and Natural Full Protection Program. [17:46] I'd like to welcome everyone attending this public hearing this afternoon. [17:51] On July 24, 2012, the board adopted resolution number 12-62, which specified the limits [18:02] and conditions by which value water is authorized to institute a special parcel text for [18:09] the safely water and natural flow protection program. [18:12] As set force in that resolution, the board of directors may direct that proposed projects [18:19] in the Supreme Water Program be modified or not implemented depending upon a number of factors [18:26] including federal and state funding limitations. To modify a proposed project, the board must [18:33] hold a formal public hearing on the matter, which will be noticed by publication and notification [18:40] to interested parties before adoption of any such decision to modify or not implemented [18:47] project. At its special meeting on December 17, 2019, the board said the time and place [18:56] for a formal public hearing to take place on January 14, 2020, which is today's board meeting. [19:04] And value-water prepared and published, published, and advertisement in Santa Clara County, [19:10] consistent with the two-week notice requirements, stated in government code section 6066. [19:18] Staff also emailed the advertisement to interest parties. [19:26] So for the process of this public hearing, we will first have a presentation by staff, [19:32] the proposed modification to upper-yagastric project, then we will hear comments from the public. [19:40] So, if your public attending today's public hearing, wishing to provide comments to us, please [19:48] complete a public comment card and just submitted to the code, which I'm just sitting there. [19:54] Following staff's presentation on this item, I will call speakers in the older cards have been received. [20:00] So please raise your hand if you need a common card, and staff will provide you with a card for your use. [20:08] So I would now like to introduce Nina Halk, Chief Operating Officer of Wadio to the Enterprise [20:15] to begin the staff presentation and provide additional details on the subject. [20:20] Thank you, Chair. [20:22] At a special board meeting on December 17, 2019, staff developed a thorough presentation on the proposed modification to project E6 Upper Y august Creek flood protection project. [20:34] The modification reflects the recommendations from the Capital Improvement Program Committee, [20:39] Valley Water Staff supports the committee's recommendation and per board direction has prepared the memo and attachments detailing the proposed modification. [20:46] Today's staff will provide a brief presentation and so now I'd like to introduce Interim [20:53] Deputy Operating Officer for the Water Utility Capital overseeing Yogas Creek-Fled [20:57] Protection Projects, Mr. Tim Braimer. [21:01] Thank you, Cheshua, members of the board. Again, I'm Tim Braimer, interim Deputy Officer [21:07] for Water Utility Capital. As you are aware, phase one of the subject project is currently [21:13] under construction. We're making very good progress on that portion of the progress of the project. [21:21] And the subject item before you would continue some of that momentum. With that, I would like to [21:26] introduce Monarchy Ganju, a program administrator for the Watershed's Business Planning and Analysis [21:33] Unit. She will conduct the presentation and take this item further. [21:53] Good afternoon, Chair Shua [21:54] and members of the board. My name is Minakshi Ganju and I'm a Program Administrator for [21:59] Safe Clean Water Implementation Program. I'm here this afternoon to present the proposed [22:04] modifications to the Upper Yaga Street Blood Protection Project. First I would like to draw [22:09] your attention to the various attachments to this item. Attachment number one is the letter from [22:15] City of Morgan Hill supporting the proposed modification. Attachment number two shows the proposed [22:20] modification to the local funding only key performance indicator or KPI2 with the new text [22:27] in red font and the original text being removed shown as stride through. Attachment 3 is the [22:34] sample add and placement schedule. Attachment 4 is the resolution that the board would need to [22:40] adopt to formally modify the project. So the project has two KPIs. KPI1 is the preferred project [22:48] with federal and local funding and it is to provide blood protection to 1,100 homes, [22:54] 500 businesses and 1,300 agriculture acres while improving stream habitat. This calls for [23:02] constructing blood improvements along 13.9 miles of the channel. The second KPI, which is the [23:10] local funding only states provide 100-year blood protection for reach 7 only up to Weston Avenue [23:17] and Morgan Hill. This entails constructing flood improvements along 2.9 miles of the channel. [23:24] As mentioned in September 2019, we began construction on phase 1, which is going good. [23:31] While phase 1 construction is fully funded, completing the entire two-faced projects will require [23:38] additional external funding, which value water will be seeking. Meanwhile, to make the most [23:47] and maximize the potential external funding, [23:50] value water is proposing, changing the reach [23:52] has to be constructed under KPI2, which [23:55] has local dollars using local dollars only, [23:58] to include the high flow and ground bypass tunnel [24:02] and a section of underground box culverts. [24:05] The construction of these project elements [24:07] will fully utilize the remaining local funding [24:10] thus impacting our ability to fully build reach 7, which [24:16] is split into 7A and 7B. Also reach 7B cannot be constructed until completion of the downstream [24:24] reaches of 4, 4, 5, 6 and 7A to prevent induced flooding in lower reaches. As a result, [24:33] value water is proposing to modify the local funding only KPI KPI 2 and increase the length [24:39] of a project under this KPI from about 2.9 miles to about 4.9 miles. [24:46] This modified KPI entails constructing reaches 4, a portion of 5, 7A and a portion of 8 as [24:55] as the onsite compensatory mitigation at Lake Sylviaera in the [25:00] On behalf, you can see these reaches in yellow. The remaining project elements will be built later once the required funding becomes available. [25:09] Staff recommends that the board adopt the resolution, approving the modifications to the upper yagus quick blood protection project. [25:16] And I'm happy to answer any questions you may have at this time. [25:21] Are there any questions from both members for Ms. Gaudjou? [25:28] This is a consistent with the board's discussion and direction on December 17, 2019. [25:36] So if there is no question for Ms. Gaudjou, we will now receive the public comments on the proposed [25:43] modification to Opera Yacht's Creek. [25:48] As a reminder, if there's any public here, [25:52] wishing to provide comments on this proposed [25:55] modification, please raise your hand. [25:57] We will provide you with the card. [26:00] As of now, I do not have any speaker card request. [26:12] Can you just please approach the podium? [26:15] And we can do the paperwork after you speak. [26:24] Thank you so much for your presentation. [26:25] I did a fun quick question. [26:27] And it's about your expectations. [26:29] I'm going to do an expectation for starting this space. [26:38] Yeah, we didn't hear your question. [26:40] Can you OK? [26:42] Yeah, yes. [26:42] Yeah, yes. [26:42] Can you also first place? [26:45] Please, a state your name? [26:47] Yes. [26:48] address first? [26:49] Yes. [26:49] My name is Jevad. [26:50] I'm from Guatemala. [26:53] And my question is about your expectation time to start phase two of this project. [26:59] Thank you. [27:00] Okay. [27:00] Can you answer that question? [27:04] Yes. [27:06] So we expect, so once this action is taken, there's some additional work to do. [27:14] One of the primary things is to take the current contract documents and [27:20] repackage it into the read the smaller project, if you will, for the tunnel and then get [27:31] that together, bring it to the board for award, for advertisement and then award. [27:39] We expect that we could have a contract in place in the May timeframe, or by the end of fiscal [27:47] year. [27:49] Does that answer your question? [27:51] Thank you, Tim. [27:52] Thank you. [27:54] Miss Hawke? [27:55] Yeah, I just wanted to add to that. [27:57] We had definitely talked about preparation for this meeting that I'm forced. [28:00] Of course, if the board did approve this KPI, we went through this public hearing. [28:04] Then we would look forward to completing the plans and specifications related to phase 2A, specifically the tunnel, the two culverts, and then bringing that back to the board for approval plans and specs as an exploration. [28:14] and we also will be looking to come back to the Board to provide an overall update of this [28:18] timeline along with talking to you specifically about a special team needs of this project [28:23] given that there is a tunnel involved. We also know there is some urgency and some a letter [28:28] in here from our cities in the South County so they certainly want to be prudent of the [28:33] expedience to get this project out the door. It's in fact this is approved by the Board today. [28:38] Thank you. [28:41] Director LaRella? [28:41] Thank you chair, now this particular phase of the project cuts right into the heart and the soul of the city of Morgan Hill. [28:49] And as you know this project has been on the books for almost 65 years, so we're anticipating this. [28:55] So I'll move to approve the the resolution. [28:59] Maybe later when you two were still in the public hearing. [29:09] Are there any other public present wishing to make comment to the board? [29:19] No. [29:25] And this public hearing on the proposed modification to Project E6, [29:30] upper-yagoscript, full protection project, [29:32] under the safe clean water and natural full protection program, [29:35] is now closed. [29:37] So we're now in close to after closing the public hearing. [29:43] It's for the board discussion or maybe leading to emotion. [29:50] This is a resolution we need to have a roll call. [29:55] Director Stranger? [29:57] Director Keegan? [29:59] Director Kremlin? [30:00] Dr. Lassat, Dr. Santas, Dr. Varella, chairperson Schwain. [30:08] Yes. [30:11] So, the proposed modification is approved. [30:15] So, we'll move forward and hope to see the plans and specifications for the time being about six months. [30:28] Item 2.10 Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2019, and other independent auditors report. [30:42] Recommendation from staff is to accept the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2019, and other independent auditors report. [30:53] Ms. Taylor? [30:55] Good afternoon, Chair Schwain. [30:56] Members of the board. [30:57] Darren Taylor, Chief Financial Officer. [30:59] And item 2.10 staff is recommending acceptance of the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for FY19. [31:07] The independent auditor issued an unmodified or clean opinion of that particular report. [31:12] And I also wanted to note that this is the first year that we brought the draft report to the Board Audit Committee for review. [31:18] And as a result of that review, several updates to the narrative were made that would strengthen [31:25] the report and help them to be more informative. [31:27] I do appreciate Director Cremans, very thorough review of that draft report. [31:33] And also one dimension that there was one topic that came up during the board audit committee. [31:38] When the committee members talked about the unfunded pension liability and the idea of using [31:44] an alternate actuary, and I was happy to report to the Board on a committee that we are in [31:49] the process of purchasing a software program and consulting services through government [31:55] best, and that particular service in software program will allow value water to do our own [32:02] actuarial analysis on the unfunded pension liability. [32:06] And so that's something that we're in the process of purchasing and I'm looking forward [32:09] to demonstrating that to the board in the next couple of months. [32:13] Okay. Any comment from the, well, [32:20] Director Cremus? [32:21] Yes. Thank you, Mr. Taylor. I just want to be sure we formally agree. Just get consensus [32:28] that the Board Audit Committee will look at the financial audit that is in our group. [32:33] I don't know if we need a motion on that or what? [32:41] Thank you, I think what I would suggest is that we put an item on our, not our upcoming agenda, but the subsequent agenda, because we've already established the agenda for our next meeting and ask the board auditor, what are best practices at other public agencies. I don't want to move too far forward. I think that I think we do have some level of [33:09] do share responsibility, S, an audit committee, but I want to make sure that anything that [33:15] we do is consistent with best practices that other publications is. [33:19] And then report back to the full board if we're going to be doing anything differently. [33:26] Thank you. [33:26] Thank you. [33:27] My colleagues accept that. [33:28] Thank you, Director Keegan. [33:30] Just if you're not at the Web to Keegan, it is the chair for Board Audit Committee. [33:36] And also that I'm on the other committee too, that I also want to express my appreciation [33:44] for the expertise that you are to comment about into this review of the CAFER. [33:52] So if there's no discussion, we need an action motion from the Board to accept the report. [33:59] Thank you. [34:00] On favor? [34:02] Aye. [34:03] Motion carries. [34:04] Thank you. [34:07] Guess you're going to stay here for item 2-11. [34:11] Works the decision of preliminary fiscal year 2021. [34:16] Groundwater production charges and the capital improvement program. [34:23] And board consideration to approve the fiscal year 2021-25. [34:33] and the next one is to discuss and provide the [34:34] Staff has three recommendations, ABC. [34:37] First one is to review the pre-liminary [34:39] CIP and provide direction. [34:42] And the next one is to discuss and provide [34:46] direction to pre-liminary groundwater production [34:51] charges analysis. [34:52] staff have several specific questions for the board and then seeking boards. [35:11] I'm going to turn this over to Chris Hakes. Good afternoon, Chair Shua and members of the Board. Chris Hakes, deputy operating officer for the dam safety and capital delivery division. I'll be going through the preliminary CIP portion of the presentation. [35:29] and then handing off to Darin Taylor or CFO for the rest of the discussion on groundwater charges. [35:35] Thank you to Jessica for many of the slides for us. [35:39] So, as the Chair noted, we're here to talk about three recommendations from staff. [35:43] Review the preliminary CIP and provide comments and direction. [35:47] Discuss the preliminary groundwater charges. [35:49] And then there are three projects which were not included into the preliminary CIP as they came into the validation process parallel. [35:56] And so we'd like some discussion on this to whether include those in the CIP draft CIP moving forward. [36:03] In terms of our annual process, this is the groundwater presentation outline. [36:09] Darren, did you want to talk to this at all? [36:11] Speak to this. [36:14] I'll speak to it. [36:15] I think when we get to it. [36:17] But I think this is the overall outline that includes the CIP process, the preliminary CIP that you're going to be talking to. [36:23] And then toward the end we'll be talking about fun 12 and fun 26 overview and then the groundwater production charge analysis. [36:31] Next slide is our annual CIP review process as you can see we're right in the middle of it with the presentation of the preliminary CIP. [36:39] After this we'll come back in February for the draft CIP adoption and then get public review and comment and then adopt the final CIP in May. [36:52] This is the CI committee CIP committee draft 2020 work plan. [36:57] As you can see, they are very involved in the capital project monitoring and CIP development. [37:03] The CIP committee has been invaluable in helping shepherd through the CIP in both generation [37:08] and monitoring throughout the year, and we would like to say thank you to the current chair of the previous chair. [37:15] So, Chair Lizot, or previous Chair Lizot, [37:19] Chair Shua and Director Asimera, [37:21] the current Vice Chair for being on the CI committee [37:22] and helping us CIPE committee [37:23] and helping us through generation of this document. [37:28] We have six preliminary categories [37:30] that our project's fall into as project drivers. [37:33] We have regulatory requirements, [37:35] repair a replacement of aging infrastructure, [37:38] district commitments, which are commitments. [37:40] We have made with either public [37:41] or regulatory agencies, water supply master plan [37:44] or no regrets options. [37:45] and I'll talk a little bit about that when we get there and then our board policy as well as [37:49] discretionary projects done at the board direction. [37:54] For our regulatory requirements, these are [37:56] some of the key projects. They're not all encompassing, but these are some of the projects that [38:00] you can see in this category. A lot of the dams, size of graduates, Anderson, Colorado, and Guadalupe, [38:04] as well as our SMP mitigation instrument and watershed land preservation projects. Second category [38:11] is the repair or replacement of aging infrastructure. We have our pipeline rehabilitation projects [38:16] are water treatment plants, [38:18] rinking out a reliability improvement project, [38:21] Palo Alto, [38:22] flood basin, [38:23] tidegate structure, [38:24] watershed asset rehabilitation program, [38:26] which is an ongoing yearly project [38:28] program for watersheds. [38:30] Our ERP system improvements, [38:32] everyone's heard about the ERP, [38:33] that's currently going in. [38:34] And then one note is, [38:36] the Almadin Valley Pipeline Replacement project [38:37] is a new project that's been included [38:39] into the preliminary CFP this year. [38:41] We can speak a little bit about it [38:43] if necessary, [38:43] But basically, we did a project under an emergency circumstance on the Ombaden Valley pipeline [38:49] a couple of years ago. [38:51] We have been, we put in acoustic fiber optic monitoring to monitor the status of the pipeline. [38:56] And based on the results we've gotten, there is a section of pipeline that needs to be repaired. [39:01] And then, basically, I think we have an ongoing emergency project to do that repair. [39:05] But that is, the precursor to an eventual replacement project that's moving forward, and it's been included in the Polymercy IP. [39:12] Okay, [39:15] next product category is Valley Water Committments, Safe Clean Water and Face. [39:19] The project's listed here, either fall under the Safe Clean Water Program or Face. [39:23] You've got Almadine Lake, the IRP2 additional line valves, [39:27] San Franciscoito Creek County Creek and Guadalupe. [39:31] For our no regrets, we have no capital projects currently in this five year CIP, [39:36] although we do have operations projects that are devoted to that. [39:39] Those projects may eventually spawn capital improvement projects. [39:42] We do have a lot of different kind of work ongoing in terms of water conservation, while they haven't [39:48] risen to the need of capital projects now, we expect that they will in the future. [39:55] Ford Policy Projects, the Chaco Reservoir Expansion Project, one of the largest initiatives that the district is. [40:00] Or excuse me, valley water is undertaking to date, expedited purified water program, or P3 efforts, barriers to creek, lower penitence, or creek to Calvary's Boulevard, and Calvary House. [40:12] The last category is discretionary projects. These are not really discretionary [40:15] products. They do fit into the other categories. We may revise this moving forward for future years. [40:20] But right now, an example that would be the land rights that we have in South County, recycled water pipeline. [40:25] And basically we have a whole bunch of pipelines that just are fairly water owns that we don't have sufficient land rights to access, so that's that project there. [40:36] We do have some projects listed to close in 2020 and we'll be removed from the CIP. [40:41] There is one update. We have four projects listed. It's actually only three of them will close. [40:46] Main and the drone is complete and we'll close Kanoa's Creek as well. [40:49] The e-discovery management system is also being completed. [40:52] The watershed habitat enhancement studies is the feasibility studies. [40:57] We just received word from the project manager today that there is some work that needs [41:01] to be completed on the Metcalf Ponds feasibility study that will be completed into, I believe, [41:06] December 2020. [41:08] So we will, he's currently working on a change management memo to basically update attachment [41:13] to, which is our preliminary CIP listing that shows that we have no work for FY21. [41:18] We will have some dollars in FY21, so that project will remain open. [41:24] I have a question. [41:27] So, I thought there's another project named Project called MedCAP. [41:32] So, there's some study related to that project. [41:36] It's under here. He has those studies and not under there. [41:40] So, the enhancement studies are actually just, this specific project is just the feasibility portion of the [41:45] Once the feasibilities completed, they'll go to follow-up capital projects, so we actually have, I believe, a watershed habitat enhancement studies that's implementation of design as well as the MetCraft Fonds project. [41:59] The feasibility studies that were conducted under this were also included the Stephen's Great Fish Passage, which is also graduated to implementation and design as well as the Ojo Ponds feasibility study. [42:09] So everything, this is the first step, and then once this is completed, we'll be moving on to a new project. [42:16] I believe. [42:18] Okay. [42:19] Okay. [42:20] One project that is not listed because it is not closed is the Skater Remote Architecture Upgrade Project. [42:26] That has been removed from the CIP. [42:28] It's been handed over to operations to do the immediate upgrades. [42:31] And then one of the projects that's proposed to be included that Darren will go, [42:35] we will get into the discussion with Darren is actually a follow up to that Skater Master Plan. [42:42] Our validated and unfunded products for buildings and grounds, we just have the fleet and facility [42:46] annex improvements. [42:48] These are projects that have been previously validated, but currently are not funded in our [42:52] CEP, CIP. [42:54] For our water supply projects, we have several. [42:56] We have more dam seismic retrofits. [42:59] Once we get through the current batch that we have, we also have storage, or at Rinkinata, [43:05] ammonia storage and meteor and facility upgrade, as well as the long term purified water [43:09] program elements. [43:11] In terms of capital reimbursements, we expect to get 252 million during the term of this [43:17] CIP from FY21 through 25. [43:20] The majority of that will be through grants and cost sharing, including measure AA, about [43:24] 233 million. [43:25] We will be receiving about 19 million from states of vengeance. [43:29] States of vengeance, obviously, are authorized through state and it has reimbursement for about [43:34] 50 to 100% depending on the project. [43:36] For example, some of the older projects have a higher reimbursement rate, the upper [43:40] yogis project is so old, being around for 50 years that it's reimbursed at 100%. [43:45] Some of our other projects are a little bit lower between 50 and 70. [43:49] The board does determine when we receive submissions where that money is then allotted, and [43:55] I think on the next slide, we might have the 19 million from this CIP is intended to be allotted. [44:03] So, you can see we've got 5 million to lower pen, 3 million to cutting him, 9 million to lower [44:09] silver crate, and then 1.1 million to lower youngest. [44:13] Chris, start to interrupt your presentation. [44:18] Can you go back to this validate that I'm from the project? [44:21] Sure. [44:21] Slide to the thing, it's two slides before. [44:26] So, these projects are all what is the five project. [44:29] Does that mean that there's no validated, but unfunded project on the watershed side? [44:37] I believe for watersheds we may have covered them previously in... [44:41] No, there are no. [44:43] Oh, there are no? [44:43] There are none this year. [44:45] This year. [44:46] I just want to... [44:49] I'll... [44:49] Make it clear to the board. [44:52] Okay. [44:52] I'll please continue. [44:53] Sorry to interrupt you. [44:57] Director Kremlin. [44:58] Thank you, Chair. [44:59] Can you go back? [45:00] You mentioned something about this skater. Yep, I didn't catch all of that. Sure. I said it, it's actually not on the slide, but it was for the projects closing. The skater remote infrastructure and architectural project has been removed from the master, or not from the mastermind from the CIP. [45:15] For so last year it was in the CIP this year, it is out of the CIP. It's because that efforts being driven through our IT department as an operational upgrade. [45:22] So, basically the capital project had been going back and forth with our state of engineers as to development in order to move it forward in the more timely fashion it was given to operations to kind of implement on the fly and then we've gone into a larger analysis of what our state of upgrade needs to be that's the state of master plan that will be presented in the second half of the presentation to kind of outline upgrades to just more than the remote architecture. [45:46] are great. I know it's pretty old and not as secure as it should be. So happy to hear [45:53] we're moving forward. Thanks. [45:56] Miss Hawk? [45:56] Yeah, so I just wanted to jump in and clarify a couple of the projects that had been [46:00] in advance were actually highly needed to be implemented right away. And so those two are [46:05] advancing, but we actually have a more thorough description of that master planning effort [46:09] first data later in the presentation and other groundwater production charges. So we will [46:12] in a bit more and give you some more context of presentation. [46:17] Okay, Chris. [46:19] Okay, and this is our summary of our 21-325 projected CIP. [46:23] As you can see, we're about 5.4 million for the five-year period. [46:29] This is an increase of about 280 million. [46:32] Attachment 2 actually has a mathematical error in the spreadsheet and it shows that it's an [46:38] increase of about 1.5 billion. [46:41] That was carried forward into the agenda memo. [46:42] We are not increasing the CIP by 1.5 billion over last year. [46:46] It is 280 million. [46:47] I don't want to make it sound like that's Trump changed. [46:49] But it is not 1.5 billion. [46:51] We have not added any new initiatives that would increase [46:54] the cost of that much. [46:56] So we're about 5.4 right now, 3.8, 7 in the CIP. [47:02] And then, of course, we've already expanded 1.5 roughly. [47:08] And that takes us to the end of at least the preliminary CIP. [47:11] We'll come back in February with the draft CIP. [47:14] Based on any sort of comments that the board has, probably after our groundwater rate discussion, and then see again in February. [47:27] Any questions for staff? [47:30] I have a question for... [47:36] I have a question for... [47:37] So you're looking for just feedback from the board. [47:40] on Pulum the CRP, you're not looking for an action to approve the Pulum the CRP. [47:46] Correct. [47:47] So it's the next step is the Jeff CRP, that's when the action will be. [47:53] That is correct. So it's part of the groundwater production rate. [47:56] Discussion will present the three new projects. [47:59] We will need some direction from the borders to where the those should be incorporated into the draft CRP. [48:03] And if so then we'll bring those back in the draft CRP for approval. [48:07] Thank you. [48:16] Okay, I'm going to continue the presentation from here, and I want to address a couple of topics [48:21] with the board prior to getting into the water rate analysis, and a few months back, the board [48:28] asked the staff to take a look at the former redevelopment agency property tax revenue projection. [48:34] And I think it was Director Estimer asked about that, and so we did take a look at that, and this slide here [48:41] that the charge shows the FY-12 actuals through the FY-20 estimate, and we've got two sets [48:48] of former RDA property tax that the first upper half of the slide shows the pass through [48:54] and residual distributions. Those are basically ongoing and ongoing revenue source for the [49:01] district, and you can see the actuals of trended upward since FY-12 and broken out between the [49:07] general fund, water shed stream, storage of fund, and the water utility. [49:11] And then down to the bottom portion of that graphic shows the other [49:14] reportionment, other reportionments, specifically the district share of property [49:18] sale proceeds. [49:19] And I think that was really what the board was interested in seeing is what, what, [49:23] what have we received, what are we going to receive in the future? [49:26] And so in general, we've received less than a million dollars per year, other than [49:30] an FY 17, we received $2.5 million and then an FY 19, $6.4 million. [49:36] And these are one-time revenue sources, and as we look at the next slide, it shows the projection for FY21 through FY30. [49:46] Again, looking at the pass-through and residual distributions that ongoing revenue source were projecting that that would increase from six and a half million dollars in FY21 to nine million dollars. [49:56] And ultimately, when the RDA is fully dissolved. [50:00] These pieces of revenue will translate or turn into routine regular property tax revenues that would [50:07] be received by value water. And in terms of property sales proceeds, we are anticipating [50:12] about $530,000 in FY21 and no more proceeds beyond that as the all the properties would have [50:19] been sold. [50:23] Moving on to an update of the Watershed Stream [50:26] in the board may recall an update provided to the board on December 17th for the Watershed [50:34] Stream Storage Fund and this graphic, the way you read this graphic is the key indicator [50:39] of health is that blue bar and where it stacks up relative to that dash line which is the minimum [50:44] reserve requirement per board policy. And the board may recall that the key issue facing this [50:50] on is the $99 million backlog of O&M activities over the next 10 years and staff at that [50:58] on that day presented a watershed O&M plan that reflected that. [51:03] And so what we've modeled here is how much can we address that $99 million of O&M backlog? [51:10] And so we've incorporated what we call an O&M backlog placeholder in the financial model [51:15] to the tune of $2 million per year in FY21 through FY25, and then $7 million per year in FY26 to FY30. [51:24] So we could make progress toward that own end backlog and still maintain the financial [51:29] health of this particular fund as you can see that the blue bars are at or above the [51:35] minimum requirement of that dash line through the time frame through FY30. [51:40] And I also want to make sure that the board is aware that the ONM backlog is separate and [51:46] distinct, not to be confused what the watershed asset rehabilitation program, which is a capital [51:51] program. [51:52] So this is on the ONM side that we're referring to here. [52:00] Mr. Taylor, quick question. [52:06] What's the policy around reserves? [52:09] I mean, I know we've had that question asked by third parties in the past. [52:14] Maybe go back to that. [52:15] Oh, there it is, right? [52:17] Sure. [52:17] The board policy is to maintain 50% of operations outlays for the watershed stream's [52:24] Georgia fund. [52:25] So that's what that dash line that represents. [52:27] So does that include contingencies? [52:29] Oh, I guess that would be on the capital side, right? [52:32] Well, it's an operating and capital reserve. [52:34] So just one reserve for both maintain at 50% of operations outlays. [52:39] Thank you. [52:42] And I should maybe add the, just background on that, we received property tax revenue twice a year. [52:49] Basically 50% in the first half 50% in the second half. [52:52] So that's kind of the logic behind that particular policy. [52:57] Dr. Lissak. [52:59] Yeah, Darren, the, the, the, the, the owning backlog is greater than what's shown here. [53:06] Correct. [53:07] Okay. [53:07] What is it? [53:09] Well, $99 million over a 10 year time frame. [53:11] So you're looking at roughly $10 million a year if we were to do it all and obviously we can't afford [53:19] $10 million a year based on this financial projection. [53:22] I just, I just, because we heard that in the CIP committee, I just wanted to rest at a board [53:27] to realize how bad our our back load log is. [53:31] And so it's something we would have looked at every year to see if if we can increase this [53:36] to me in the year next year or the year after, [53:40] see what kind of adjustments we could do to get that backlog. [53:43] Under control, thank you. [53:49] Nice chair. [53:51] Yeah, just wanted to ask a follow-up on that question. [53:55] If we go back to the redevelopment agency property tax, [54:02] and we look up above on the residual distribution, [54:05] And I, as you mentioned, this was an annual that will after, after a while continue to increase. [54:15] This is basically the taxes that we've been missing for many years now. [54:20] And secondly, this is almost making enough of this 10 million dollars that we're talking about. [54:28] Did we include these numbers into this figure? [54:32] They're already baked in okay, so that's quite the fact this so it would have been maybe 20 million [54:38] But it's 10 because it is yes, [54:46] okay. I'm gonna move on to the safe cream water fund update and [54:52] Wait, oh, sorry. Oh, man. That's one more question. Thank you. If the O&M, you know 99 [55:00] Million dollars. What is the most urgent, you know, the couple most critical, one's number one and number two. Do you have a graph of the actual reserves that have been used in the past? Are we over reserved? Are we under reserved? You know, I think that would be good. Is this, you know, sometimes we have too much reserves, but like to hear about that. [55:22] Do you want to take number one? [55:25] Yes, Director Crimin, members of the board, Melanie Richardson, Chief Operating Officer Watershed. [55:30] One of the most critical projects you see we're putting in the shared budget, [55:34] which is the Guadalapay River Project, Tasman Drive to aid the IA80 that's listed right there. [55:40] That's picked into our current CIP, that's a $96 million effort [55:45] to really rehabilitate a flood protection project that we had previously built [55:50] that was primarily overgrown with vegetation, and we've already begun that, so that's one of our very urgent projects that we're currently working on. [55:59] We have, as you've heard, the Palo Alto tied base and improvement structure, which is another one we're working on. [56:05] And then we have a number of smaller projects, erosion repair and sediment removal, those types of projects. [56:11] I mean my question, thank you, my question went more to what are we not being able to do because of this? [56:19] What's the most urgent that we're not able to get to? [56:23] I don't have the list in front of me, but we could certainly bring that back to you. [56:26] At the next meeting, a list of some of the ones that are, you know, top of the list but currently unfunded. [56:31] Right, because as we do budget and we figure out groundwater charges, you know, [56:37] We might need that data to decide how much we want to do. [56:42] So that would be great. [56:45] Well, I'll ask a follow-up question to a Director of Cranis question. [56:54] So this O&M backlog right now is primarily viewed as operating costs. [57:01] They're not capital costs. [57:05] So, there's this placeholder two million per year and then increased to seven million per year, it's for operating costs. [57:15] So, and then the example that you use for urgent budget, those are major capital project. [57:23] So, it's the connection there that if we keep building up this backlog on the operation side, [57:33] and then eventually it's going to lead to some major capital project such as Lower Guadalupe River, [57:43] and the path of all the flow base and tight gates. [57:47] Is that correct? [57:48] Correct, sure. [57:49] Yeah. [57:49] So I think the concern I've heard from Director Luzati [57:55] and also Director Kramman is that how do we consider [58:02] this ongoing maintenance operation activity [58:06] to bring up the allocated budget level? [58:10] So we don't put ourselves in a situation [58:12] that 10 years down the road will have to do it, [58:16] a hundred and fifty million dollar project. [58:18] Santa Masks Creek or something, that's it. [58:21] So I think that's the issue that as we move on, [58:28] and may or may not be probably not likely [58:30] to be addressed in this year's budget, [58:33] but then it needs to be on our rate of screen time, [58:36] we need to continue working on it. [58:43] Sorry to belabor this point, but, you know, again, as we go through this budget process, I think we really need to have all [58:50] We got to be given some choices. I mean, I know there'll be a staff recommendation, but [58:55] You know, given this situation, we might want to defer or cut something and we got to [59:01] This is one of the things that we have to get. I think when we're starting to go down that is, you know [59:07] What don't do we want to do any on M to all the way to we want to fully fund it? [59:11] The same on capital projects we really need to have options. [59:17] It's actually, especially given the safe clean. [59:22] Well, I know we have time on that, but you know, [59:25] we got to look at probability of success and do we want [59:29] to pull the plane out at 30,000 feet, [59:33] or one foot, and it's usually better to know in advance. [59:38] Thank you. [59:40] Thank you. [59:45] Following along on Director Cremans comments, [59:50] I think that when we look at our past history in terms of delivering our capital program or even doing some of our operations and maintenance projects. [1:00:00] So, sometimes we have the money, but we don't have the resources or there's constraints that come into play that don't allow us to move forward. [1:00:09] So, I think we don't just need to do an analysis, a very sort of deterministic one. I think we may be need to be taking a probabilistic approach to, like in other words, if one project isn't ready to move forward, then maybe a project that was at a lower priority, [1:00:28] might be positioned and poised so that it can move forward because I think that having a bunch [1:00:35] of money left in these funds at the end of the year, at the expense of perhaps some other projects [1:00:41] we could have done is not the best outcome. And I know it's difficult to try and move things forward [1:00:50] simultaneously and then, because you're diluting the resources you have available to move those [1:00:57] But I don't want to see lost opportunities where we've gamble, not gamble, that's too strong in term. [1:01:04] But we've focused on a particular project and it's a priority and we might not be able to deliver it. [1:01:10] Is there anything that could potentially back that up so we could move that forward? [1:01:15] So I realize that's a challenging thing to ask for. [1:01:19] But to the extent that staff is able to think in that kind of way and come up with some. [1:01:27] some strategies that if this happens well this is what potentially we could do rather than [1:01:35] I think what a lot of government agencies do. It's not unique to us. It's that thing of like [1:01:42] okay we're going to try and make this happen and then a roadblock something outside of our control [1:01:47] happens and then we don't deliver on that but there's something else maybe we could have delivered on. [1:01:52] So thank you. [1:01:56] OK, I think these are really good comments that staff needs to, [1:02:02] it's for processing improvement. [1:02:03] That's something that we need to get into. [1:02:07] So with the five-year maintenance operation plan for the watershed [1:02:14] completed, I think you have a sound basis for that kind of analysis. [1:02:20] And then there's definitely going to be points [1:02:24] that there's a choice for board to make. [1:02:29] So there's just something that's keeping making it better. [1:02:34] So you want to say something now? [1:02:36] Yes, to address your concerns, Chair Shwaya, [1:02:39] and Director Keegan and all, one of the reasons [1:02:42] that we brought the ONM watershed ONM plan to the board [1:02:46] was so that you could see where we stand [1:02:48] in terms of funding shortfalls projected out [1:02:52] for the next five years. [1:02:53] And we're hoping to get your input as an example. [1:02:56] Next fiscal year FY22, we have a $2.58 million shortfall. [1:03:01] We're hoping that we hear from you, is it important to fund those as opposed to doing [1:03:06] other type of work? [1:03:07] Is this a priority? [1:03:09] Is something else a priority? [1:03:10] I mean, that's the kind of feedback we're really looking for. [1:03:13] If you all feel that we need to do everything possible to do that, [1:03:17] deferred background, that's the kind of feedback we'd like to hear. [1:03:22] So, I don't know if that was obvious, so we're very interested in, okay, [1:03:30] Jack, for the [1:03:30] thought. [1:03:31] Yeah, I just, I think you may have heard all of us say, no, that wasn't obvious. [1:03:35] And too, I think the comments you've heard is, we're really concerned about the backlog, [1:03:40] and so to the extent that you need direction from us, from my point of view, to have that [1:03:47] as a high priority or to fund it more. [1:03:49] I think that's something that you need to come back with. [1:03:56] And the other question is, [1:03:57] do I hear you say this on the key assumptions 96 million [1:04:00] for Guadalupe Project that maybe I misheard you? [1:04:05] Is that, it's not to do the project. [1:04:07] That's to clean up a project that's already been done. [1:04:11] Yes. [1:04:12] Yeah, I mean, I couldn't believe my ears. [1:04:15] I guess when I first saw this, [1:04:17] I didn't really pay attention to it. [1:04:19] So that's the kind of thing, right? [1:04:21] really really wanted before. And that was my point of asking, you know, we're doing [1:04:26] the minimal, you know, for the next, but 90, 10 years. You know, something like that [1:04:34] getting into that much of a backlog. This board, I've been here 12 years, I've never [1:04:39] heard anybody tell me, hey, backlog of what loop is getting, you know, or anything else is [1:04:44] getting to be, you know, this ban. [1:04:50] Yes, the cell is out here. You're absolutely right. This is a formal stretch of Godaloo Bay River that was previously improved that has overgrown with vegetation. [1:05:00] We spent, and I was going to talk about this later, but we spent a lot of extra effort this year, because you all gave us resources last year, and removed 56 acres of vegetation this year under our existing SNP, which greatly improved the situation. [1:05:15] We have more work to do. We have to do the removal of the larger trees. We have to do additional work. Perhaps we'll be lucky. We won't end up spending the entire 1996 million, but that's our current projection of what it's going to cost. [1:05:27] because I went on for quite some time. [1:05:31] I hope there's been staff changes. [1:05:34] You know, because isn't this where the trees got so big, [1:05:36] now we need a different kind of permit? [1:05:39] Yes, there are some trees that are beyond the 12-inch diameter [1:05:42] that we're currently allowed to take out under our SNP. [1:05:45] That just can't happen again. [1:05:47] Okay, thanks. [1:05:49] See you, I have Director Keegan. [1:05:50] You found a good year on to, you want to see? [1:05:54] No, I don't want to. [1:05:54] Dr. Keegan. [1:05:59] Thank you. [1:05:59] Director Luzat raised, I think, some very important points. [1:06:03] And I think, in particular, given what this board went through in the entire district [1:06:09] went [1:06:13] through, with the flooding that happened on Coyote Creek, where it wasn't even property [1:06:20] that we owned and actually were responsible for maintenance. [1:06:23] I think we would be very severely criticized if we are not maintaining the property that we own that we put improvements in. [1:06:35] I think first it's really essentially throwing away our prior investment if we're not working. [1:06:42] And I think that we would be held up for well-deserved criticism if we were not to take action to manage that situation. [1:06:58] Yes, I just wanted to add to this conversation. [1:07:01] I know that Director Luzad had mentioned that in your 12 years here, [1:07:05] she had not heard about these issues, [1:07:09] but I just wanted to give some historical perspective on how [1:07:13] the organization has done an operation and maintenance. [1:07:17] And over the years, what it occurred is that basically [1:07:20] operation in maintenance was kept at a cap budget with only a percentage CPI increase on a year [1:07:28] over your basis. And it wasn't until very recently as we started to inherit all of these [1:07:35] newly developed and designed capital projects that we had to really look closely at how to [1:07:41] design an operation maintenance program that's going to keep up with the increasing load because [1:07:48] A CPI increase is not really going to do it we have been very CIP focused in the past and now we have to make that change to really look at all of the assets that we have to maintain and that's why I think the watersheds have made a [1:08:20] topic? This is a very good discussion and it's also very important that I think Watershed [1:08:28] is getting to this SM management time for that. I personally I view like a project like [1:08:37] lower Guadalupe River equivalent to like we cannot a treatment plan we do. So while there [1:08:45] to these probably several years ahead of watershed on the SM management, but this is going [1:08:54] to be a huge issue facing us. [1:08:57] So, and you heard from all four members that the support for maybe higher budget allocation, [1:09:06] so we don't get into redoing project that we did 10, 15 years [1:09:14] ago. [1:09:14] There will be continued. [1:09:17] Sure. [1:09:18] I will move on to the Safe Cream Water Fund update. [1:09:21] And the key to reading this graph is taking a look at that FY28. [1:09:26] That final year of that 15 year program and looking at the blue bar. [1:09:30] When we showed this graph to the board back in December, December 17th, [1:09:34] we showed a $4 million surplus. [1:09:36] Now we're showing a $12 million funding shortfall. [1:09:39] And that's related to some corrections and refinements that were made [1:09:42] the preliminary CIP. For example, the Hale Creek Project now includes a $4 million increase [1:09:50] in costs and there were also some increases related to upper pen and the Cale Creek projects [1:09:55] that result in the shortfall that we're projecting as... [1:10:00] As of this particular moment, I also wanted to mention that this fund or this graphic assumes $80 million [1:10:07] of NRCS reimbursements for Upray August Creek to fully construct phases 1 and 2. But now we did [1:10:13] hear the board direction back in December 2 for Sue, the Upray August project construction [1:10:19] of phase 1, and the tunnel portion of phase 2, and do not count on NRCS funding. [1:10:28] But we also [1:10:29] this graph to the CIP committee yesterday, they reminded us of that that we should at a minimum [1:10:35] we showed that the second graph that excludes the energy of funding and a lower cost of [1:10:41] just constructing phase one and the tunnel portion of phase two. And so for the future we will [1:10:46] make that happen. Any questions on this graph before I move on? [1:10:57] So now I'm going to get into the [1:10:57] preliminary FY21 groundware production jarge analysis, and the topics are listed there. [1:11:05] A few slides on water usage, that's a big topic for this year, and then I'll get into some [1:11:09] of the financial analysis and the investment scenarios, and then show you the preliminary [1:11:14] forecast scenarios that we prepared for a board review today. [1:11:18] We'll talk about the translation to the modified groundware benefit zones, and then some [1:11:22] other information, schedule, and summary. [1:11:24] I'm starting with water usage, and this is our district-managed water usage trend. [1:11:32] This is the water usage that translates to revenue for valley water. [1:11:36] It's in a stack bar format with treated water at the bottom, and then groundwater right above [1:11:39] that. [1:11:40] And then surface and recycled water, historical axles and green, projection and blue. [1:11:45] And then in red, there is our just completed fiscal year FY19. [1:11:49] It's an estimate right now as we're waiting for final audits on our unmetered wells. [1:11:54] But, of course, the big story in FY19 was a wet spring that caused our water usage to decrease [1:12:00] fairly significantly relative to FY18, and so it begs the question as we move forward, [1:12:05] should we reduce the water use projection as we project forward. [1:12:09] So this is the starting point as of November 26th when we talked about a groundwater rate setting [1:12:16] cycle planning with the board. [1:12:19] This next slide shows a table where on the left-hand side we've got the ears going down [1:12:26] from FYO3 to the FY22 forecast and then going across the top. [1:12:31] We've got the disparate types of water-use, treated water, groundwater, surface and recycle [1:12:35] water, and then the total. [1:12:37] And then there's a note on that right-hand side showing when we had a wet spring or when [1:12:40] there was a drought, things that would have affected the water use for that year. [1:12:44] We know that wet springs occur about 30% of the time, at least over the past 20 years. [1:12:48] And so if we ask the question, we'll water usage bounce back and FY20 relative FY19, I think the answer is more than likely it will because only 30% of the time we see what springs. [1:12:59] But if there is a repeat of the same water usage in FY20 that we saw in FY19, we would have a significant revenue shortfall to the tip of about $40 million. [1:13:09] But when we ask ourselves the question, should we should water usage forecast in FY 2021 and beyond be reduced? [1:13:17] The staff answer and we've spent a lot of time talking about this and analyzing this. [1:13:22] The staff proposal is yes that we should reduce that water use projection down from roughly 250,000 acre feet to about 230,000 acre feet. [1:13:32] And what's the basis for doing that? [1:13:34] Well, if you take a look at that FY18 year for the bottom of the graphic, we see that our water [1:13:40] usage that year was 231,700 acre feet, but we know that the Monovino Water Treatment Plant [1:13:46] was only running at about half capacity that year, and that's a water source supply that [1:13:52] that San Jose Water Company has, in which they don't use district water, and they don't pass revenue [1:13:56] for that. So if we were to adjust that particular year, assuming that Monovino was running at [1:14:02] capacity, then that year would have been closer to 225,000 acre feet. So the staff [1:14:08] proposal of 230 in a couple of years does reflect a little bit of growth relative to [1:14:13] the FY18 year. And I do think there is going to be some growth. And the next slide [1:14:18] will show what I think that. So if we take a look at historic water usage for groundwater [1:14:25] and treated water, and this is our monthly account so we can see the seasonality in a given [1:14:29] year from January 3 December, the blue line reflects the 2013 year, which is our baseline. [1:14:37] The green line is 2016 year, that's our low year in terms of water usage. [1:14:42] And then the next line is 2018. [1:14:47] And then the dash black line is 2019 so far through through October. [1:14:53] And we see that in fiscal year 20, which would be July, August 10, October, those four [1:14:58] once, what the what are you [1:15:00] This is a trend for the first four months of FY20 as below the prior year, driven by Monovina running [1:15:06] at full capacity in FY19, whereas only about half capacity in those same months the prior year. [1:15:12] But we do see a crossover in that dash black line in October. [1:15:16] We see a kind of increasing toward 2018 and crossing over, which tells me that there is underlying [1:15:22] growth to a small degree as we project forward. [1:15:29] So given that, staff has this is a revised projection of district managed water usage. [1:15:36] We've lowered the water use projection in that blue, those blue columns, beginning in FY21, down to 230,000 acre feet, [1:15:44] and with a small amount of growth, less than half a percent in FY22 through FY26. [1:15:53] Derek, can you stop for a direct to the size of the question? [1:15:56] So, Derek, [1:16:00] why are we assuming what month of being is going to be at? [1:16:04] Can't we get a better answer at a sales-a-water? [1:16:08] We've talked to them, and we know that month of being a provides about 10% of their water supply, [1:16:15] which can range between 10 and 15,000 acre feet of their water supply. [1:16:18] It all depends on the hydrology, how wet the year is. [1:16:21] Some years it can be as low as 5,000 acre feet of water. [1:16:25] Some years it can be. [1:16:25] If it's very wet, they can produce 15,000 acre feet. [1:16:30] So weren't you saying that you were reducing 2018 from 231 to 225 if want to be and it was [1:16:40] at full capacity? [1:16:41] That's right. [1:16:43] So why are you still at 230 then for the next years if you, if you, we can't get [1:16:48] better handle on what Lana Bean is going to look like? [1:16:53] I think the point that I was trying to make is I think 225 is the bottom. [1:16:58] But staff is recommending 230,000 acre feet two years later because I do feel that there [1:17:04] is still growth underlying growth happening that would allow us to achieve 230,000 acre [1:17:10] feet in FY21, and I think that the next slide where I was showing the usage over the January [1:17:25] through December timeframe reflects that that black line that black dash line is showing [1:17:30] a growth pattern, even with Monovina at full capacity relative to 2018, which demonstrates [1:17:36] to me that there is underlying growth occurring and that 230,000 acre feet is a reasonable [1:17:41] projection. [1:17:45] I mean, I see what you're saying, but my perspective, I'd rather us be assuming [1:17:53] a worse taste scenario, and then if it isn't, then we've got money to burn. And that [1:18:01] certainly is the kind of feedback that we want to hear from the board. And I will say that [1:18:05] the more conservative we are with water usage, the more upward pressure there is on water [1:18:09] And I realize that, but I still think that [1:18:16] the difference between 2.25 and 2.30, I don't [1:18:20] think it's going to be a great change in water rates. [1:18:26] And if that enables us to be more stable because we are more conservative, and then [1:18:36] if you're a scenario is that we have more water than maybe the next couple of years. [1:18:42] water rates will have to go up as much, you know, if I'm just, I'm kind of balancing at that [1:18:47] way, I'd rather see it, you know, flatten out or be in a position to not have to raise [1:18:56] water rates as much as we think we should, because we were super conservative in our, what [1:19:03] we projected our demand would be. And I think we're hearing from, at least I've been hearing [1:19:08] from other sources that say that our, you know, water project demand projections are optimistic. [1:19:18] I think Miss Hop, can we want to join the conversation? [1:19:23] Yeah, so thank you through the chair. [1:19:25] So this is actually a really important conversation for the board and the feedback is really critical on this. [1:19:31] And the reason why is for the last few years coming out of the drought, [1:19:34] we have attempted to keep that projection a long standing projection in place but what we saw [1:19:40] specifically this past year is that we were below that projection enough that we saw some [1:19:45] fiscal impacts in the adverse and so what we're trying to do is look prudent into the future [1:19:52] where do the trends we've been seen and why really what I think it demonstrates and it's not just [1:19:56] a trend with any one retailer and we've actually reached out to all the retail. [1:20:00] We'll continue to talk to them in this right setting process. But to verify, what are your demand projections? They do provide us three year schedules. So we're able to look and see what is their projected use for the next three years. That happens annually. We did receive those. And so that was taken into consideration as part of this projection that you're seeing as well. Our concern is that we do put it too high and we anticipate additional revenue than what we anticipate. We would not be able to absorb it, specifically next year if we were to have the same [1:20:29] ahead we had this past year. So it is a difficult conversation. It does impact rates. We're going [1:20:35] to have additional analysis and discussion about some other mechanisms and ways we can manage [1:20:39] the groundwater basin into these coming fiscal year as part of this presentation. But we do want [1:20:43] to hear your feedback. [1:20:47] Dr. Cranman. Thank you, Chair. I heard what you said it will affect rates. [1:20:53] On the other hand, we have other knobs here. We can delay projects. We can decide not to do a capital [1:21:01] projects. For example, so it doesn't always affect rates and that's why I think it's [1:21:05] really important we get the entire list so we can kind of make some yes-notes [1:21:10] decisions on it as opposed to, oh, you discussed that before. So that's number one. [1:21:16] Number two, are you going to talk about costs on the side of water? Is that coming up? [1:21:20] Coming up. Okay, thank you. [1:21:22] Director Creman for your first question. I think staff is prepared to do a [1:21:28] preliminary changing the knobs, different knobs, and then, and you see that we have today [1:21:34] for staff, they can come back with more scenario analysis. [1:21:40] Just we need to know a little bit more information like the upper, O&M projects, you know, [1:21:48] we just saw we're in delay on those or backlog, I think we need to see them, I think we need [1:21:54] detailed CAPAX and staff recommendation if we actually decided to cut money what you would recommend. [1:22:03] I think the ordering would be here a staff recommendation on that would be great. [1:22:13] So I just touched on the revised projection of 230,000 acre feet. [1:22:17] Thank you for the feedback. [1:22:20] And as Chief Hawk mentioned, we're going to be discussing this in detail with the retailers. [1:22:24] And we'll get more and put on that as well. [1:22:29] The reduction that we made in water usage down to 230,000 acre feet only affects the North [1:22:34] County water usage. [1:22:36] So what we tried to do was line up the, if you look at the graph, the North County water [1:22:40] usage graph, and you look at FY21, that blue column, the blue bar, and relative to FY18, [1:22:46] we wanted it to, to drop that blue column and make it similar to the FY18 column. [1:22:53] In the South County, we didn't have to adjust it all. [1:22:55] we didn't, that FY18 column and the FY21 column are very similar. [1:23:01] And so what we're seeing is that water usage reduction [1:23:02] is primarily a North County phenomenon. [1:23:07] And that will play into the rate projection [1:23:09] that you'll see a little bit later on. [1:23:15] So moving on to the preliminary cost projection [1:23:18] for the water utility. [1:23:19] This is a stack bar graph that shows the cost projection [1:23:24] for the total water utility for the next 10 years. [1:23:27] The source of supply category and blue at the bottom of the graph represents important water costs, [1:23:33] groundwater management conservation, recycle water, and the Delta conveyance project. [1:23:38] And the right above that is the raw water transmission and distribution in red and then in green water treatment and transmission and distribution. [1:23:46] And then in light blue right above that is support services which include things like division management, customer relations, [1:23:51] and long-term financial planning, other studies, revenue collection, things like that. [1:23:57] And then the orange portion of the stack bar is debt service, which is increasing as we [1:24:02] issued debt to pay for the capital improvement program, which is reflected there in the [1:24:05] light below. [1:24:07] And as a large and substantial capital program as we look forward, and that's the key driver [1:24:12] of the water rate projection that you'll see in a little bit. [1:24:19] So, what did we forecast when it comes to delta-convance in a positive direction? [1:24:25] Sorry, yes, so many questions, but this is an important topic. [1:24:32] I saw P3, are we going to talk more about P3s? [1:24:36] Okay, nevermind. [1:24:39] We'll get there. [1:24:41] So, what did we forecast when it comes to the delta-convance project, in the middle of [1:24:46] slide, you see a cost estimate, and we lay out gap funding, and then the state side of the [1:24:53] delta-convance project, a 2.4% and then the CDP side at 3.2% and we project out those [1:24:58] costs. [1:24:59] Uh, forget it. [1:25:00] Get funding. We assumed, just under $20 million, we assumed 5.6% of $350 million spread over 2.5 years. That's included in the baseline scenario that you'll see. [1:25:11] And then we assumed the state side funding as well, included in the baseline scenario, that the CBP side is not baked in the baseline, but we did run a scenario where we show you the impacts of that. [1:25:22] I will say that in terms of the cost estimates, they're based on prior year costs adjusted [1:25:27] for timing. [1:25:28] We have not received any new cost information on this projects where you're using, I would [1:25:33] say, year old or older cost estimates at this particular time. [1:25:38] In terms of the status, back up at the top of the slide, the technical analysis is proceeding [1:25:43] to refine the project design and then we, in terms of the Bureau of Reclamation, they have [1:25:51] not indicated the degree to which CVP participation will occur, and then staff anticipates [1:25:57] reinitiation of negotiations to amend the State Water Project contract to include Delta [1:26:02] Convance in later on this month. [1:26:09] Sorry to ask all these questions, thank you chair. [1:26:14] What amount of commitment to the Delta Convance project is in the baseline scenario? [1:26:21] because we're going to have to make up our CVP if it's not part of the project by buying more state water [1:26:27] Project allocation are we assuming for the point of this that we're going to be making up our [1:26:34] CVP allocation with the state water project [1:26:37] Well, we're going to be talking we're going to hit that slide in a couple of slides but for to answer this question for the baseline [1:26:43] We're assuming the [1:26:45] Yes, the state side only and then we're showing the board of scenario where we include the CVP side and [1:26:50] Okay, so [1:26:52] You know, I think our policy is a director asked a mayor said before, you know, we need to [1:26:59] Keep our water supply hole if not more, so I think we have to have some realistic projections on this based on the board policy [1:27:06] Which is as much as we can [1:27:15] Okay, for the next slide, I'm gonna turn it over to Chief Hawke to talk about the water supply projects the master planning [1:27:21] Great, thank you, CFO, Taylor, so this is a pretty important discussion that we [1:27:28] have staff wanted to tee up and discuss with the board today. [1:27:31] Over the past year, the Water Utility staff has been liberating and trying to better [1:27:35] figure out as we move into multiple decades of investments, how do we do so in the most [1:27:40] prudent way possible and build out the CIP in a way that makes sense for future decades? [1:27:46] As the board is aware, we're significantly in the mix of a major dam rehabilitation era. [1:27:50] However, we also have an obligation both under the District Act which requires that we keep existing infrastructure at least an operable condition. [1:27:59] And then also we have the water supply master plan that also states under its policy and sure sustainability that we keep that existing water supply portfolio whole. [1:28:07] So back on November 20, the board approved the water supply master plan, which was the overarching policy document about water supply and the portfolio. [1:28:16] So, from that though, how we implement that for decades to come, and how do we tee up which [1:28:21] projects are prioritized ahead of others, which ones are in need more than others based [1:28:25] on service life, based on condition assessment, based on capacity needs into the future, [1:28:30] needs some sort of major structure. [1:28:33] And so what you have before you today is a diagram which shows you the overarching water [1:28:37] supply master plan that was just approved by the board, along with subsequent four plans [1:28:42] underneath those. [1:28:43] You see them as the distribution system master plan, which is actually beginning phase one as we speak today on raw water, [1:28:50] which includes distribution pipelines for both raw water and drinking water, treated water. [1:28:55] Water treatment master plan, which would include the treatment plan, all four. [1:29:00] In the skaters' systems master plan, which would include the skaters' systems across all the different treatment plans and pumping stations. [1:29:07] We will go into detail into each three of these plans, but the overall concept is that in order [1:29:12] for us to adequately determine the appropriate order and the investment needed for all of [1:29:17] the rehabilitation of all of the wholesale system, we need to have a programmatic way to look at this. [1:29:22] So I'd like to draw to your information, other major programs out there like this. [1:29:28] For example, SFPUC has what was called WESIP or the water system improvement program. [1:29:34] In that program it yielded 87 projects that were to be dealt with over 30 years, and that investment was taken care of through master planning efforts very similar to these, and then subsequent to that was able to strategically place these projects in order that made sense for both packaging, project delivery, and also allowed for SAP UC to engage its retailers, its rate base, on as to why they needed these infrastructure improvements to be. [1:30:00] So, the idea is to look at it like that. In addition, sack regional has done the same thing. They've done a $2 billion program of investment over 10 years, of which they spent 30 million in order to identify, do the planning and the master planning efforts associated with that infrastructure. [1:30:16] And the city of San Jose has done similar with their wastewater pollution control plan, a $2.2 billion program over 30 years in which they implement several smaller projects. [1:30:26] The basic concept here is that we are a world-class large agency who has an obligation to provide [1:30:32] wholesale water to our community. To do so in a way that's programmatic, that's responsible, [1:30:37] and allows us to execute the projects with both efficiency and for the best value to do so [1:30:43] from a programmatic standpoint makes sense. These master plans would achieve that, not only for the [1:30:48] planning efforts, but at the end, we would go through both feasibility, we'd go through planning, [1:30:52] and we'd end up with 10% conceptual design, which means we would already have a view into what [1:30:57] projects we'd have to do and how they would look. It will help us feed more successful and [1:31:01] implementing those projects and we would also look at doing programmatic EIRs. The programmatic [1:31:06] EIRs would then allow us to also execute the projects under a larger programmatic EIR and then just [1:31:12] do smaller project EIRs as we went through so then we'd be able to execute more readily and more [1:31:22] is it relates that these three master plans? I can ask questions now or we can let the staff [1:31:27] go through each of the three plans so they can have an overall description of what they include. [1:31:34] Are there any questions for staff at this point? [1:31:37] Oh, wait. Go ahead. [1:31:42] So we're going to talk about each of these three new projects. [1:31:46] We will. Thank you, Chair Lesot, Chair Schweyer and Board of Directors. [1:31:51] I'll speak to the treatment plant master plan. [1:31:54] So as Nina laid out, [1:31:56] now that the master plan, [1:31:57] what a supply master plan has been adopted, [1:32:00] it gives a sense for how much water [1:32:02] we're expecting to flow into the county over the next 20, 30, 40 years. [1:32:07] And then what do you do? [1:32:09] How do you manage and route that water [1:32:10] through the three treatment plans that we have [1:32:12] in our distribution system? [1:32:15] So two things that will determine how we do it. [1:32:17] Obviously there is regulatory drivers [1:32:19] for what we need to meet on treating levels over the next 30 years and then the existing [1:32:24] capacity and the condition of that infrastructure. So essentially this implementation project [1:32:29] looks at that holistically for all three treatment plans along with the parallel efforts of the [1:32:34] distribution system to see the most efficient way to manage that. It also looks at upcoming regulatory [1:32:40] developments we are hearing a lot about PFAS in the regulatory development as well as microplastics. [1:32:46] the last time we comprehensively looked at regulatory development that caused a trigger for upgrading [1:32:51] our treatment plans was back in the 1990s with the disinfection by product rules and hand [1:32:56] surface water read. So it's about time that we are getting to that place where we want to look at [1:33:00] these comprehensively. So Nina laid out as we talked about the importance of making it a programmatic [1:33:09] thing because all these three treatment plans have to work in conjunction with each other because [1:33:15] we can't take them all out at the same time and how we implement and timing of those will help us [1:33:21] give as the predict predictability and operating our treatment plans as well as the programmatic [1:33:27] EIR and the stakeholder engagement and even for the financial analysis, the capital impact, [1:33:32] the rate impact of these projects laid out after that year will give some financial [1:33:37] certainty as well as we go forward. We're also proposing that we take all of these projects to the [1:33:43] just because the more detail you have in defining the projects gives you more certainty over [1:33:49] the project's scope, cost, and the implementability or the feasibility of those projects. [1:33:55] It doesn't mean we're be circumventing any of our CIP processes will still be going through the [1:34:00] boat process and bringing it through CIP committee and our normal CIP process, [1:34:04] except they're coming at it as a programmatic thing broken down into individual projects and lay it. [1:34:09] So the skaters system master plan skaters a unique thing like I think of it as all of it the critical thing while the the treatment process [1:34:22] Segments are our distribution system infrastructure is the hearts and in and the physical [1:34:27] Lims of the system the treatment the skaters systems essentially at the brains years and eyes of the of what we do our business of how we deal with this projects [1:34:36] The challenge with the skatersystems is while the treatment plant infrastructure might have a life of 30, 35 to 50 years depending on concrete versus mechanical system. [1:34:47] Skatersystems have a much shorter lifespan, just because their technology driven and their advances and vendors change out or things become obsolete. [1:34:55] So they last only about 10, 15 years, most, and IT components of those work. [1:35:00] A much smaller replacement schedule. We did do a master plan in back in 2011, however, the implementation [1:35:07] of that speaking to how director Keegan was talking about. We had the projects but then the resources [1:35:13] and the implementation and taking out other projects like Rinkanada projects did not allow [1:35:18] us to implement them. So, this project is proposing to take that 2011, dusted up, updated. We already [1:35:24] know there are some critical projects that will happen advance, like the Skater Remote Architecture [1:35:28] projects that we put on pause I would say not completely define but we're hoping once we get [1:35:33] six months, eight months into this process we'll define that enough to know what route we need [1:35:38] to go over the risk technology or implementation sequencing the type of implementation whether it [1:35:43] or BDBDB that'll work for us. We do have newer technology that is really has grown leaps and bounds just [1:35:51] literally in the last five years when it comes to smart PLCs or information that comes back to us [1:35:57] can help us optimize our assets and operate our systems and get more data and make a database [1:36:04] decisions that will help move our business forward. This again we are thinking that the [1:36:09] three years is what it will take to implement it. Do some kind of a EIR either fold it with [1:36:15] the treatment plans or separately but then figure out the best way to implement it whether we [1:36:20] implement these projects individually or fold them into other treatment plan projects as they come [1:36:26] implementation, construction for both the treatment plant and this. It's not going to happen overnight. [1:36:31] It'll likely result in a 30 year CIP, just like the other plants around the Bay Area have resulted in long programmatic [1:36:37] capital improvement programs. Thank you. Turn it over to God for this vision. [1:36:43] Thank you chair. So I'm God forward to supply their beauty. So the order is of course there are pipelines. [1:36:49] we have 142 miles of them, including both the raw water system and the treated water system. [1:36:56] So, as the board is well familiar, we do your rehab, inspection rehab program, [1:37:00] a tenure, look on that on some of the raw water side, and we have done some, I think, [1:37:07] very prudent things in that regard, but in some sense, it's a myopic look. [1:37:12] If you had to take a life cycle look at our aging infrastructure around the pipelines, [1:37:16] which include three significant pump stations, a number of valves and a [1:37:20] pertainence, etc. We really need to have a better handle on it. In example, [1:37:27] of some of the questions we come up, which are hard for us to answer with our [1:37:31] good tools and analysis, [1:37:34] is that the recent interest is some of the [1:37:36] participants or potential participants in the last affairs expansion project have [1:37:41] asked us whether perhaps is one of their options to get the water through to them [1:37:45] from the Las Vegas Project, we could treat it at penitenture [1:37:49] and we let through to them. [1:37:51] And so we're looking at that. [1:37:53] However, the tools that we have and the analysis [1:37:57] that we'd have around the infrastructure really [1:38:00] need a better baseline, a better sense of what we've got [1:38:05] and what upgrades would be needed in order to answer that [1:38:09] question. [1:38:09] That's just one example. [1:38:11] So as we look through that and look at a 34, 30 to 40 [1:38:15] life cycle we will also look at the in a play because there's a beauty of having this in parallel [1:38:19] with the water treatment plan look because if there are changes to how we might operate and [1:38:27] make improvements to the water treatment plans we can factor that into the how does it interface [1:38:32] with the pipeline system. That's very important for us and then skater also would be important [1:38:38] because many of the skater points we were operating here are operating valves and various [1:38:42] the pertinence is on the pipeline system as well, it's a major part. [1:38:48] So one of the things that we expect out of that again is that for projects or identified [1:38:53] in order to satisfy a prudent life cycle is understanding how that would be operate. [1:39:00] That's assume that we have sections of the pipeline system that need to be replaced. [1:39:05] it is obviously is a complicated question because many of the solutions that we would take to [1:39:12] do that would take pipelines out for extended period of time. So how do we operate? Those are [1:39:18] our arteries. So we really have two major arteries into the system, one from the CVP side, one from [1:39:25] the state side. That's the major source, of course, Anderson features as well. But how do we plan for [1:39:34] And so, part of the plan needs to look at that. [1:39:37] It's all very well coming up with capital cost to replace the pipeline, [1:39:41] without giving the board an idea about how we would implement that. [1:39:45] A very critical question. [1:39:46] So, to accomplish all of that. [1:39:51] So, those are the three proposed new master-planning efforts. [1:40:00] Any questions on board, or I think staff is definitely asking the boards feedback on this kind of a way of looking at all of which you're kept to an improvement. So, Director Kigu. [1:40:17] Thank you. And first, I would like to commend Chief Hawk and her staff for what I'm sure was really a monumental effort to look at all of this and try and create a framework that helps us to move into the future. [1:40:31] I know it was no easy task, and I appreciate you bringing that before the board for our discussion. [1:40:39] You know, I like the idea of programmatic EIRs. [1:40:44] I think this we all know. [1:40:46] They make sense when you're looking at a wide range of individual projects, [1:40:52] implementation over a long time frame, [1:40:54] and implementation across a large geographic area. [1:40:57] So being able to kind of put everything together and I think will help us make more informed choices as we move along. [1:41:09] You know, it is some extra work, right? You do a programmatic EIR and it's looking at things, you know, a big picture level. [1:41:18] It's not looking at it in terms of the direct impacts that you would see on a project by project EIR. [1:41:25] So, I agree with the concept, but it always does make me a little worried where, you know, [1:41:32] we're giving regulators another opportunity, you know, additional bites of the apple and all of that. [1:41:38] But that's okay. I think the benefits outweigh any of the negatives. [1:41:43] And again, I think that this was a very strategic and rigorous approach to take. [1:41:50] and I appreciate being given this information to help us with our decision-making processes [1:41:57] and not just us but to help the community understand the stance of what we're looking at. [1:42:03] You know, sometimes people will talk to me and they'll be concerned about increases as we all are, right? [1:42:08] We're all, the people are paying more for water. [1:42:12] That's a hit on them, particularly people, low income people, or people on fixed incomes. [1:42:17] But I do think it's going to help us tell the story a little bit better when we're able to lay everything out. [1:42:24] And so the vast extent, the work that we need to do and how we're prioritizing amongst projects [1:42:32] that we're not trying to do everything all at once, we're doing it in a deliberative, long-term strategic kind of way. [1:42:39] So this is very good staff work and thank you. [1:42:45] And you have a comment for STEM? [1:42:47] So I totally agree with Director Keegan's comment [1:42:51] that I think this is the right way to approach our challenges [1:42:56] that have said this many times probably in the past [1:43:01] that this organization has a tendency to use individual project [1:43:06] to solve our programmatic problem, where a very program [1:43:10] We're a very project-oriented people, so we use a project to solve [1:43:16] program problems, to solve operation problems, to solve many of them. [1:43:21] But it's a programmatic view of what's the direction for the future, [1:43:27] what kind of investment for the next 30 years. [1:43:30] It is overwhelming, but I think this is the right thing to do. [1:43:33] And once thank you, thanks, staff, for a very self-fulthinking and bringing this to the board. [1:43:39] So if there's no other comments from board members, I guess I agree, I would say that [1:43:48] we agreed that to include these in the Twitter draft CIP and we'll follow this direction. [1:43:58] This is a long top. [1:44:01] We still have almost 20 slides to go to, yeah, so just thank the board members in advance for your engagement, but this is really very important. [1:44:14] So who is Daniel, can you continue? [1:44:17] Okay, so I'm going to move on to the next topic, which is an issue that we have been monitoring at the staff level for the past couple of years and [1:44:26] But now it's the right time to bring it up to board attention and that's the issue of water retailer reliance on treated water and just by way of background treated water provides in blue recharge to help protect the groundwater basin. [1:44:39] And what we've observed is increased retailer interest in reliance on treated water due to the increased life cycle cost of groundwater wells. [1:44:49] And today there's a healthy balance between groundwater usage and treated water usage. [1:44:55] But if there's a shift in that mix, then it will likely have a negative impact on valley waters. [1:45:00] The billiard to manage water supply optimally. Today, we know the groundwater provides 40 percent of water used in the county, and it's the largest emergency supply. Today, the groundwater basins are full. In a hypothetical situation, if retailers were to not maintain wells or the best of wells, not saying that they're intending to do that. But if they were to do that, then it would be much more difficult for us to incent them to take groundwater when we want groundwater to be used. [1:45:30] in situations where there's a surface water scarcity. [1:45:34] So it would help us, it would hinder us in our ability [1:45:37] to manage water optimally in the county. [1:45:40] And so the proposed solution in this case is [1:45:44] to increase the tree-to-water search charge from $100 [1:45:47] to $200 for acre-foot for FY21. [1:45:50] That would provide increased economic incentive [1:45:52] for tree-to-water retailers to sustain use of groundwater. [1:45:58] and if we could look at this over a multi-year timeframe, if this particular adjustment moves the needle [1:46:06] too much one way or too much the other way, then we can always adjust that in a future year. [1:46:12] And I will say that it's been 14 years since the Treated Water Surcharge has been changed. [1:46:16] It's been $100 brick or foot for the past 14 years and now we're seeing indications that [1:46:22] But treated water is the choice of our retailers over the long term. [1:46:27] And so that is why we're bringing this topic up. [1:46:33] Okay, so I'm going to move on to investment scenarios and we've prepared four scenarios [1:46:38] for the board. [1:46:39] Take a look at today, starting with the baseline scenario one on the left-hand side. [1:46:45] This is the scenario picks up where we left off with the board last year. [1:46:48] The investments listed under this scenario would meet 80% of average annual water demand in drop [1:46:55] years, and it's incorporates baseline projects, which include water treatment plant, [1:47:03] rickanada water treatment plant upgrade, dam seismic stability retrofits, the 10-year pipeline [1:47:08] rehabilitation, it includes the addition of the projects listed there in red font, [1:47:18] the [1:47:18] project as well, and then the three master implementation plans that we just talked about. [1:47:25] It includes the Delta Convance, the state side piece, which would be paid for by water charges, [1:47:30] not the state water project tax. [1:47:32] It does not include the CVP side in this particular scenario. [1:47:35] It does include the No Regrets Package, which would be things like AMI, Advanced Meter Infrastructure, [1:47:41] and Stormwater Capture. [1:47:42] It includes the portable reuse phase one project to produce 24,000 acre feet by FY28. [1:47:50] Go ahead. [1:47:50] Go ahead and pause now or. [1:47:51] Oh, I don't you have finished. [1:47:52] Okay. [1:47:52] I'll finish. [1:47:54] Which is a placeholder project. [1:47:55] This is a $690 million capital project. [1:47:58] It's it's a P3 public private partnership where the district would contribute 30% on a page. [1:48:04] You go basis for this project. [1:48:06] We've also included a P3 reserve at $10 million in FY21 growing to 20 million by FY28. [1:48:14] This scenario includes the particular reservoir expansion project, and we assume $250 million [1:48:20] of federal funding through the Wyn Act, and also a low cost federal loan with the loan. [1:48:26] And we assume partner agencies would pay 20% of the project. [1:48:29] It also includes the transfer of Bethany Pipeline, South County Recharge, New South County [1:48:33] Recharge, timing is beyond FY30, and then $200 million placeholder for dams of water treatment [1:48:39] plants, it's essentially a contingency amount, and so should I pause there or go to the [1:48:45] rest of the scenarios? [1:48:46] I'll get to the Director of Crimean. [1:48:50] Thank you. [1:48:50] This is actually when I read it before it was pretty informative, [1:48:57] so, you know, when I think [1:48:57] I'll wait till you're done with all, I'll actually look at it, sorry for that, I'll ask [1:49:01] him at the end. [1:49:03] No problem. [1:49:04] So, we'll move on and kind of talk to the rest of the scenarios, so now that you've [1:49:08] scenario one, each scenario progresses on the scenario before, and we just like changes in red [1:49:13] font. So scenario two is the same as scenario one, the baseline. But in this case, we're [1:49:18] assuming no wind funding, and we realize that achieving $250 million of a federal wind [1:49:24] funding is going to be a challenge. It's very competitive for those dollars, we're competing [1:49:29] against those for carols, chasta, sites, and so we wanted to show the board of scenario [1:49:33] or what would happen to water rates if we don't [1:49:36] receive that wind funding. [1:49:39] So that's scenario two. [1:49:40] scenario three is the same as scenario two. [1:49:43] Except in this scenario, we have revised the portable reuse [1:49:47] project from the placeholder that would produce 24,000 [1:49:50] acre feet by FY28 to the an IPR project [1:49:53] based on the Palo Alto agreement and Mountain View [1:49:56] to produce 10 to 13,000 acre feet by FY30. [1:49:59] this [1:50:00] And dollar, IPR capital project, where we're assuming is the district builds finances and operates, so it's not a P3 in this case, and therefore, accordingly, we've eliminated the P3 reserve under this particular scenario. [1:50:16] And then moving on to scenario 4, we show it's the same as scenario 3, except in this case, we add the Delta Convance CVP side investments. [1:50:25] And I will note at the very bottom of scenario for that this particular scenario exceeds the 80% level of service goal. [1:50:37] And so this next slide kind of dives into a strategic discussion with the board and which we're hoping to have a rich discussion and receive more very good feedback from the board. [1:50:49] just by way of background the baseline scenario scenario scenario one that we just looked at [1:50:53] slightly exceeds the 80% level of service goal and this was discussed with the board last year. [1:50:58] It's due to uncertainties that we discussed in 2019 the bay delta plan, the California [1:51:04] water fix at that time. So there were some uncertainties. [1:51:08] scenario three as I just mentioned includes the revised political reuse project based on the [1:51:20] It's also could be a potential DPR project, and it's a scaled down and pushed out version of that project. [1:51:30] So it's only producing 10 to 13,000 acre feet of supply versus 24,000 acre feet of supply. [1:51:35] So that begs a question for the board is, do we pursue additional investments to make up that difference between the 24,000 acre feet and the 10 to 13,000 acre feet? [1:51:45] Or do we want to hold off and wait to see for more information as we progress over the next year? [1:51:53] Speaking of more information, we know that regulations for direct political reuse are expected by the end of 2023. [1:52:00] We should see draft regulations in sometime in 2022. [1:52:04] And a DPR project may lower the total cost due to avoiding long pipelines to recharge areas. [1:52:12] And, as I mentioned, this particular project, at the 10 to 13,000 acre feet, maybe I didn't mention it, [1:52:18] at 10 to 13,000 acre feet of produced water supply, it still meets the 80% level of service goal, [1:52:24] because the baseline scenario slightly exceeded it, and this project can be staged. [1:52:29] So, depending on deep jar regulations and how the board wants to move forward. [1:52:35] Other background information is that staff is planning to provide a monitoring and assessment plan review, [1:52:40] Less than a year from now, that would include an updated 2040 demand forecast, so we'll get a better picture at that point in time as to whether or not there is a shortfall relative to meeting the 80% level of service goal or whether we're comfortably meeting that. [1:52:54] So if we're consideration, a number one given the reduced short term water demand projection should we wait for the fall, 2020 monitoring and assessment plan review to determine if a shortfall exists, [1:53:04] or two pursuits substitute water supply investments to make up that 11 to 14,000 acre foot shortfall to reach the 24,000 acre feet that we have in the baseline scenario. [1:53:15] And there's a host of potential investments that could be pursued, including the additional CVP side investments on the Delta conveyance. [1:53:25] But before the board answers that question, you probably want to look at the rate projections first. [1:53:28] So, that's the next slide, and in the blue shaded area we're showing the North County [1:53:34] M&I groundwater charge, year over year growth, showing the percentage growth over the [1:53:39] next 10 years, and again, staff has modeled this as a smooth projection, as opposed to a [1:53:44] volatile projection, so we're trying to smooth it out over the next 10 years, going down [1:53:48] the left-hand side, we show the May 2019 projection for North County at 6.6% per year, [1:53:58] and [1:53:58] at the 250,000 acre feet of water usage scenario one we dropped that water usage down to 230,000 [1:54:05] acre feet. So there is a fairly large increase or impact of lowering that water usage projection. [1:54:12] So we go from 6.5% annual increases to 8.1%. And certainly lowering to 225 would have an impact [1:54:23] probably about 25% or so of that impact that we see from 6.5 to 8.1, if we did that. [1:54:31] scenario 2, no wind funding, that would take our increase from 8.1% to 8.7. [1:54:38] Under scenario 3, we show 2 of them, 3A and 3B. [1:54:41] 3A assumes the revised purified water program that we spoke of, assuming that staff, [1:54:48] designs and builds and operates the P3 project or the purified water project, [1:54:52] not as a P3, that has no impact to the projection, the question. [1:55:00] What if we model that as a P3? Well, the answer is that it would lower the rate projection by about 3, 10th of a percent, going from 8.78.4. So just some information there for you. 3B assumes that we add the $200 treaty water search charge over the next 10 years, so that adds additional revenue to the scenarios, which would take it from 8.78.4. [1:55:23] And then scenario four is the scenario where we add the CVP side investments on the Delta [1:55:29] Convance, which would take our projection from 8.4 to 8.6. [1:55:33] So each scenario builds on the scenario before it. [1:55:36] As we look at South County, the May 2019 projection was 6.9%. [1:55:41] The baseline is 4.7. [1:55:43] And as I mentioned, when we reduce the water usage, it doesn't affect South County. [1:55:47] So we're still at 4.7. [1:55:49] And by the way, the reason why we go from 6.9 to 4.7 is because of a change [1:55:53] in schedule to extend the schedule to build Anderson Dam. [1:55:58] So as we extend that schedule, the cost of South County of the paying back for that particular [1:56:07] benefit of that project gets pushed out into the future and therefore we're able to lower that [1:56:12] rate projection for the South County for the next 10 years. scenario 2, no wind funding, [1:56:18] would take that increase in South County from 4.7 to 5.1 percent. [1:56:23] The revised purified water programs, North County only no change to South County. [1:56:26] 200 dollar treated water surcharge, no change to South County. [1:56:29] It's a North County impact in the Finally Center of 4, [1:56:32] where we add the CBP, Delta Convance Project. [1:56:35] That would take it to 5.3 percent in the South County. [1:56:41] The next slide shows the impact to the average household [1:56:45] average household for the monthly bill, ranging from in terms of the lower water use [1:56:52] scenarios, $3.83 in the North County to $4.12 in the South County, less than $1 [1:56:59] for all of the scenarios in FY21. [1:57:03] And I should caveat this by saying that the summer retailers have a mix of wholesale [1:57:09] water supply so that wouldn't exactly the way this plays out when exactly impact them [1:57:13] this way. And also this doesn't include any increase that a retailer would layer on top of the [1:57:19] wholesale increase that we're reflecting here. [1:57:24] And the next slide is our typical graph where we show [1:57:26] the M&I groundwater production charge projection. The blue solid line is the North County. We're showing [1:57:32] the May 2019 projection. And then the orange solid line is the South County May 2019 projection. [1:57:38] And then the purple line shows the baseline scenario one with the lower water usage and how that [1:57:43] impacts both North and South County. [1:57:46] The red dash line is the San Francisco PUC, [1:57:49] latest projection that we've gotten from them. [1:57:51] And the green line is reflecting board direction [1:57:53] to increase the agricultural ground [1:57:55] or production charge in FY22 to the full 25% [1:57:58] of the M&I, the District Act Limit. [1:58:04] And so how does this preliminary analysis [1:58:06] translate to the new and modified zones on the left hand side [1:58:10] of the tables? [1:58:10] You see the existing zone W2 and existing zone W5 [1:58:13] We're projecting the baseline scenario here in North County going from 1374 to 1485. [1:58:20] That's the 8.1% increase in the South County 481 to 504 per acre foot, and that's the 4.7% increase. [1:58:28] In terms of the modified zones, we were hoping to have to be able to kind of show you what that would look like. [1:58:34] We're still working on it. We don't quite have that done yet, but we do owe you that answer, and we're working hard on that to be able to provide that to the board soon. [1:58:44] In terms of the agricultural groundwater charge, we know that the board's direction is to stick with the six point to keep the agricultural charge at six percent of M&I for FY21. [1:58:53] And so that would be the $30.22 for existing zones and the modified and new zones. [1:58:59] Jerry, can you hold on a second? [1:59:03] Dr. Craigman, you earlier, you have questions about these scenarios. [1:59:07] You want to ask the question now? [1:59:09] Yeah, thank you. [1:59:11] My first question is, do the which scenarios exclude the San Jose recycling [1:59:19] if we're not able to get a agreement? [1:59:26] scenarios three and four. [1:59:29] Okay, so that's not in there. [1:59:33] Does none of these include an investment in [1:59:37] Lasfacarris, they just started the transfer [1:59:39] Bethany pipeline, right? [1:59:40] That's correct. [1:59:42] Well, maybe on the next round it would be [1:59:43] Good to see. [1:59:45] I know we talked to it. [1:59:51] Yeah. [1:59:52] Yeah, so through the chair, [1:59:53] actually feedback specifically on Las Vicaras Expansion as well. [1:59:56] We have built into the CIP. [2:00:00] The direction of the board, the pipeline. So that is built into our CIP, and we've been updating those numbers as we've been getting more information from CCWD. [2:00:08] Having said that, the larger question will be called this year about our long-term participation as it relates to the reservoir, and they will want to know about our engagement into a JPA by the end of this calendar year. [2:00:20] Staff is currently going to be working to provide an update to the storage committee and hopefully in February to then TFA larger discussion in March regarding LVE long-term participation. [2:00:29] They have not provided those reservoir investment dollars yet, as there's various scenarios, and we've gone through and had terrible discussions at the staff level, but it's certainly time for us as staff to bring additional analysis to you for deliberation on future investments for LVD. [2:00:47] Thank you. It's just my question. Right now it's out. [2:00:50] Correct. [2:00:50] Well, I would like to see a proposal next time when you're scenarios if it's in and I get, you know, and the logic behind it being out. [2:01:00] So, that was my, oh, and the third one is no regrets. [2:01:03] I think we heard earlier that there was no money allocated for no regrets. [2:01:07] Or did I hear that wrong? [2:01:09] From a capital project perspective, not from a no and end perspective. [2:01:12] Okay, so it's in there. [2:01:13] Because none of it's capital. [2:01:16] Okay, thank you. [2:01:18] Okay. [2:01:20] Why is she here? [2:01:21] Thank you, Madam Chair. [2:01:23] Have we looked at, if there's no, if there's no, when financing, if we looked at how [2:01:32] we could replace that, such as maybe something space in particular, [2:01:44] what that would require. [2:01:49] So, through the chair, we have been working closely with Chris and his team as it relates [2:01:54] to Pacheco and his operation and agreements in terms of receiving the money from the state. [2:02:01] So we're still working through that prop one process. [2:02:04] As part of that prop one process, we have to strike agreements with DWR and other entities CDFW to verify [2:02:11] what sort of water and benefits have to be secured for both the benefits for the fisheries [2:02:16] and also for our own emergency water supply. [2:02:19] So those negotiations are ongoing. [2:02:21] Once those get closer to wrapping up, [2:02:23] we will then have a better sense [2:02:24] of what availability is left in that reservoir [2:02:26] for other participants. [2:02:28] Having said that, we have had some discussion [2:02:30] at the storage committee about participation, [2:02:33] and that is something we need to start thinking about sites, [2:02:36] reservoir, LVE and others have models out there, [2:02:39] and we will need to start to get policy guidance [2:02:41] on what sort of models we might want to entertain [2:02:44] as we move forward in the coming year. [2:02:50] Do you want to see a scenario analysis from step? [2:02:58] That's okay. I'm just thinking that if you use baseline one and you had a scenario [2:03:06] way you would find where you would find more funding that way than even two and well I think [2:03:18] even two would work out, [2:03:24] but it should have to look at it. So in other words taking [2:03:28] two and looking at this scenario where you could find enough to just to cover that with [2:03:37] your loan just in case you could still do either one or two [2:03:49] or do one and it covers and it covers [2:03:51] the risk of not having a whip yet low. [2:03:57] Yeah, that's right. [2:04:01] Dr. Morrell. [2:04:02] Thank you, Chair. [2:04:04] So, Darren, I'm looking at these face lines in the scenarios. [2:04:08] Beyond your 2024-25. [2:04:12] And what I'm not seeing in here are any projections in South County, [2:04:16] for potential recycling or water treatment facilities that might be, [2:04:21] because this board has been working and talking to both councils and Bill Roy and Morgan Hill. [2:04:26] But yet, in your forecast and your scenarios, there's no projections or scenarios that could include those scenarios. [2:04:36] That's correct. [2:04:39] And I think to be prudent to have those scenarios to look at, well, certainly, because obviously those projections would increase an impact. [2:04:47] the overall cost compared to the northern and the south in the future. [2:04:52] I definitely would, and I'm not sure where staff is at and turn to preparing cost estimates, [2:04:57] but we could put together. [2:05:00] There were a projection if we had cast estimates. [2:05:02] Through the chair. [2:05:05] So certainly we are interested in board and guidance like with everything else here, but one of the elements [2:05:10] of the water supply mess plan we bought before you and November had a recharge project. [2:05:16] We normally called it Butterfield Channel, that is placeholder for a variety of specific [2:05:22] projects because in the out years, as you approach 2040, it appeared to us based on the [2:05:29] man forecast, it may be necessary. In other words, we continue with the groundwater solution [2:05:35] for South County as the most economic, but we would have to add additional recharge. Staff [2:05:41] had looked at the planning process and found that to be the most optimal thing. Recognizing [2:05:47] also that the South County Joint Committee has expressed an interest in a surface water [2:05:54] treatment alternative. And we are in the process of looking at that alternative. Also, [2:06:01] however, there's no change to the timeframe at which that could be useful. It is right at the [2:06:08] end of our planning horizon and depending on what comes out of the map that was referred to earlier, [2:06:14] which is the review of the elements of the water master plan in fall. We would have to take a look [2:06:21] also at the demand forecast then and see whether if we had lower demands that it may move the [2:06:27] need for the treatment plant even further out. Having said that, there may be strategic reasons [2:06:32] that the board indicates that look at that and implement it anyway in which case, as Mr. [2:06:38] Taylor said, we would include those for the board's consideration. [2:06:43] So, I've heard through different things. I think direction where I was talking about [2:06:47] recycled water. You mentioned treatment plan. Yes. And then on this scenario, [2:06:54] also there includes the South County recharge that's timing to be out for the school year, 30. [2:06:59] Yes. So there's, there's, there's a lot of things going on. Yeah, let me add another one to the three [2:07:04] and be specific on the recycled water. There are a recycle through the South County [2:07:10] recycled water master plan piece that was finished two years ago. There's some elements in there [2:07:16] for us to invest in, and those are included in the South County plan. [2:07:21] Yes. [2:07:21] Those are included in the current, the current, the current forecast. [2:07:29] Current forecast. [2:07:30] There are no projects that come within the 10 year, but they are included in the long-term forecast. [2:07:38] So they don't reflect any of these forecast and budget numbers that we're looking at here [2:07:44] and scenarios on any of the baselines we're out, so I'm just, I think I'm not sure how [2:07:52] I accept that information, since we're having these ongoing discussions in planning meetings [2:07:58] with the councils in South County, both Gilroy and Morgan Hill, but yet there's no data [2:08:04] information supporting any of the scenarios that we're speaking to here, future forecast for [2:08:10] cost assumptions, et cetera, water available, [2:08:12] recharge, recycling, et cetera. [2:08:15] And as I just know how to accept that information at this point. [2:08:24] I don't direct you, Kram, I want to speak, [2:08:27] but Nina, you're trying to answer this question. [2:08:31] So I'll get to you first. [2:08:33] Please, Holly. [2:08:33] Thank you, through the chair. [2:08:35] So I do want to bring kind of a larger conceptual policy [2:08:39] question that we're posing to the board today. [2:08:41] And it's the overall recycled water program. [2:08:43] We're right in the middle of the county-wide master [2:08:45] planning effort, which wraps up at the end of this calendar year, and we have slated and [2:08:51] currently having the rates in the board even took some action last year to bring down the [2:08:56] funding, but we have a sizable amount of money allocated for a purified water program. [2:09:01] And so I did want to speak a little bit to what we're doing there and some of the concepts [2:09:05] that are out there on the scenarios today for the board to deliberate on. [2:09:08] But specifically as it relates to a purified water program, obviously we just struck our first [2:09:14] long-term wastewater deal. So, we as staff have been talking quite a bit internally with the CO2 [2:09:19] to better understand what would be those next steps and what we don't want to do is just start to run [2:09:24] ahead and start to work upon some kind of next arrangement with some agency without touching [2:09:29] base with you as a whole because you can see it affects you it's the rates quite heavily. [2:09:34] And so, what scenario three tries to do is kind of show the board a potential avenue could be [2:09:41] to pursue a parallel to agreement in more detail [2:09:44] because we know we have wastewater rights there [2:09:47] and to actually build upon and utilize that funding [2:09:50] for an arrangement there. [2:09:52] One of the challenges we're also looking at right now [2:09:55] is we have an existing P3 procurement, however, [2:09:57] it has been shelf. [2:10:00] There's questions about the viability of the original RFP when we let it in terms of what's allowed and permissible in that RFP if we need to revisit the procurement or if we want to consider delivery as we do have such instruments such as DB at our fingertips. [2:10:16] We also see DPR regulations are now going to come out in 2022, 2023, which is right around the corner. [2:10:22] And this project was originally envisioned to be an IPR project and was bid that way through the P3 process. [2:10:29] So we do have kind of that larger policy discussion and that's what the slide that Darren just pulled up. [2:10:35] Evasking this board. [2:10:36] Do we keep marching down the IPR trail? [2:10:39] Do we keep working through a P3 process? [2:10:42] Or do we need to now that we have a wastewater right that's been procured? [2:10:45] Half of what the board is seeking us to get in terms of policy. [2:10:49] start to look towards a more project, a base look at how to make that investment come to life. [2:10:56] The agreement we did strike with Mountain View in Palo Alto does give us time to 13 years to build and get something into operation. [2:11:04] However, we want to be mindful of the policy direction which is to really move this program forward. [2:11:09] So you can see there are many things, there's a change condition that is occurred over this year which is also the regulations [2:11:13] which is really putting in a really large question on the table for us as an agency. [2:11:19] So I'll leave it right there, just let you know that we want to make sure we're moving [2:11:22] in the right direction related to the county wide, and also as it relates to the [2:11:26] Pierified Water Program Investments. [2:11:28] Thank you for your explanation. [2:11:33] But I'm not sure anybody answered your question yet. [2:11:37] Yeah, I didn't mean so let's keep that keep that in mind. I'll get to the other four members first [2:11:46] So your question is not answered [2:11:49] I think director Brawl wants more [2:11:54] Yeah, do these projections assume the renewal of safe clean water? [2:12:03] No, okay [2:12:08] Okay, P3, it could make sense to revisit that there's been a lot changed in the scope [2:12:13] is changed and everything like that. [2:12:18] Of course, we want to give credit to those that have submitted already, so it would be great [2:12:23] to come up with the process to discuss that more. [2:12:26] Thank you. [2:12:27] Dr. Pagan. [2:12:32] Thank you. My comments are related to what we just heard from Miss Hock in terms [2:12:43] of expansion of potable reuse, spreading things, maybe a little too much. Now that we have [2:12:53] a deal in place with Mountain View and Palo Alto. [2:12:58] I think maybe it's time for us to really move forward [2:13:04] with that, right, because they are our partners, [2:13:06] they have come, and they have step forward. [2:13:09] And I think that potentially I don't want to, [2:13:13] because I'm a San Jose resident, [2:13:14] and I would like to be able to have my neighbors, [2:13:18] benefits from an investment in advanced purified water, but I think maybe we need to clarify [2:13:27] what our expectations might be or what we would need to see happen before we could move forward [2:13:37] in that area. And I think that for a long time we've had discussions with the city of San Jose [2:13:43] and it's like, there have been things that we've thought aren't necessarily a major impediment [2:13:51] and yet they seem to have stalled us at this point. [2:13:54] And so I think having some clarity about what are our expectations, like just as an example [2:14:01] like the effluent issue, that we would need agreement on that, and there's some other things [2:14:07] as well. [2:14:08] And I think the benefit of approaching it that way is no one is playing hide the ball, especially not us that we could be very clear on here's what it would take for us to need or want to expand in that area. [2:14:22] And here are some potential issues like the statewide regulations that we would need to address first and then even the whole P3 thing and going out of that. [2:14:35] So I would like to see us really take a look at that sort of framework, and I'm sure that [2:14:41] this could be a topic of further discussion at the recycled water committee, director [2:14:47] Esther Mayer, is currently the chair of that, and again, I want to be clear with everyone, [2:14:53] because I feel like there's been, I don't want to, the waters have been muddied. [2:15:00] You know, a bad punt. But it's up to us to clarify what the current situation is. No one's going to clarify it for us. And so I really encourage us to be approaching things in that direction. Thank you. [2:15:16] Good. Director Mariah. [2:15:18] Thank you, Chair. So I'm just final point. So what I'm concerned about is any conflicting messages to the residents of South County and the decision and policy makers of the boards. [2:15:31] and elected and Gilroy Edmorgon Hill since I've been on this board for the last four years [2:15:38] that's all we've been talking about in South County. And at this board's discussion points [2:15:44] that we've had, what we meet with these folks, we continually speak to what we're talking about here. [2:15:50] And now I'm hearing now that, well, let's hold back, let's not be so fast. Now we have these agreements [2:15:55] in place with Pella Welto, Mountain View. Let's not be so fast and wanted to move forward beyond [2:16:00] that point. So, what do we say to the residents of South County? And what do we say to [2:16:06] the decision makers that we consistently have presented to them the decisions that are [2:16:12] now I'm here here that have been made to slow down the process? Am I wrong in that? Am I [2:16:19] interpreting this correctly? I just want to know where we stand and where we move forward [2:16:24] with the residents in the community of South County. [2:16:29] Director Keegan just perhaps the CEO can give us some guidance on this as well. [2:16:34] Director Keegan just made us a suggestion that this seems like the future of recycled [2:16:40] water program. [2:16:41] I mean, that's the changes that we're facing today. [2:16:45] Recycle water committee is the best place for this discussion to happen, but I'll just stop [2:16:53] there. [2:16:59] I just wanted to clarify earlier, I omitted that we currently do not have additional purple [2:17:06] pipe for South County in the CIP for the 10 year. [2:17:09] And so what Garth was speaking to was the potential, the water supply master plan looks at a longer [2:17:14] period 20 beyond 20 years. [2:17:17] We do have projects and like projects in the water supply master plan from a policy perspective. [2:17:22] We just haven't filtered that into the CIP yet. [2:17:26] So I hope that clarifies. [2:17:27] Through the chair. [2:17:28] May I just add one pointed case. [2:17:30] It's not clear. [2:17:31] And for director Rela, there's nothing in the baseline here that takes away the prior projects [2:17:37] that have been discussed extensively, the Recycle Order Committee around South County [2:17:43] expanding to the west of Gilroy. [2:17:45] Those pipeline projects that we have been involved with in many cases in conjunction with developers [2:17:50] is where we have synergies with their own layouts and so on, working closely with most [2:17:55] of the sort of deal-roy, but also of informing Morgan Hill, there's nothing in this plan [2:18:01] that takes away our continuation of those projects. They're in the baseline. I didn't [2:18:08] want to have you think that something has been taken away. What the answer earlier was, [2:18:13] we have not found justification as yet based on the current lands to add more in, but I think [2:18:20] Chief Hawk helped explain that the countywide massive plan has potential for adding those. [2:18:26] That will be available later this calendar year. [2:18:28] I hope that helps. [2:18:35] Nice chair. [2:18:37] Yeah, I think let's, let's be frank about what, what it is that we're talking about with respect [2:18:43] to recycle. [2:18:46] On the one hand, we have the city of San Jose that has to somehow decide and then express [2:18:52] whether they really want to participate. [2:18:55] And secondly, with respect to South County, [2:18:59] we have a governance issue that hasn't been able, [2:19:02] we haven't been able to resolve. [2:19:05] Those are two problems that are not ours, [2:19:07] that are not caused by us, [2:19:10] but there are two problems that are outstanding [2:19:12] that are going to prevent us from going forward [2:19:15] with those two areas. [2:19:18] And so I don't know what we do, but I think we can't put it into our plan if we don't [2:19:26] have any expectations that we're going to realistically get anywhere. [2:19:32] This is not an abstract plan. [2:19:35] This is a constructive plan that is realistic about what we can do until we have a governance [2:19:42] issue this resolved in South County until we have an agreement with the City of San Jose. [2:19:49] We can't include it anywhere. [2:19:51] At this point, those are both fictions. [2:19:54] And I don't think that we can put fiction in... [2:20:00] Our planning mechanisms doesn't work for us. It's not good for the community to think that we're going to do stuff that we haven't yet been able to at least make it realistic plan. [2:20:15] You know, just, that's reality, that's, that's what we have to do [2:20:24] with the other feedback. [2:20:26] I think, so what's that is looking for from the board is related to this, what's to be included in the planning process. [2:20:41] We're talking about more of a shorter-term planning process that so CIP is a five-year planning document. [2:20:50] And the rate analysis is a 10 year planning document. [2:20:54] What's to be included in these two documents, or these two planning processes? [2:21:04] So, Vice Chair, I will say that proposal that something that's not in our hand yet, [2:21:15] that's not included, and it which means that the focus will be with what we're [2:21:20] already know we have the water rights, which is the agreement site with City of Morgan Hill in City Alpha. [2:21:27] I'm sorry, City of Mountain View, City of Palo Alto. [2:21:34] So I was thinking about exactly the same thing. [2:21:39] So I will support that. I don't know what's other board members feedback on that. [2:21:44] It does, and then also knowing that we still have these issues with San Jose and the South [2:21:50] County that we need to continue working after that we can get a resolution just like [2:21:54] Uprayada's Creek. [2:21:56] We do the time though, but doesn't mean we give up on NRC, and San Diego continues working [2:22:01] on it. [2:22:02] So that will be my two sets. [2:22:05] Any other thoughts on that steps that's looking forward to that? [2:22:14] No. [2:22:15] I'll be fine. [2:22:18] I do want to summarize a little bit of the feedback we received because this is very important for us in terms of re-looking at anything we can do with these rates in order to put the resources in the right place. [2:22:31] What I heard was, look at LVE participation above and beyond just the pipeline and looking [2:22:39] to reservoir. [2:22:40] So in lieu of potential additional purified water investments, the partners that were [2:22:46] not there with I.E. San Jose, I heard participants with Pacheca, maybe try to make up some [2:22:52] of that when funding with the Pacheca participation. [2:22:56] I heard be realistic and I think we have a pretty creative executive team on the water utility side and they do have some ideas that we've been germinating on. [2:23:10] It was DPR IPR question. [2:23:13] I think it would be great to have additional dialogue with their psycha water committee and we have some ideas that we think could provide more realistic delivery of a program. [2:23:24] which we think could work, and work in line up with the regulations. [2:23:28] I think the regulations is key, is very key, is that we have a change [2:23:31] condition with the PR regulations, and so it's really got us thinking quite a bit about, [2:23:36] whoa, the conveyance of IPR is two-thirds of the cost, yeah, that's huge. [2:23:41] So we just want to make sure we do it right, especially if it's going to be for several decades. [2:23:47] And addition, I just want to return back to this slide that Darren has up because we do want to make [2:23:53] We get a little bit of guidance on one, and this is important because of the question that was [2:23:59] posed earlier, I believe by the Director of the Zot was, well how do you know these [2:24:03] demand projections are real and we're not making a reset too much too far. [2:24:07] Staff has recommended the 230 TAA resetting that baseline, but we're also recommending to [2:24:13] come back to you in the fall of this year. [2:24:15] We are actually doing the analysis right now to validate if we believe this will change the level of long-term investments. [2:24:26] Meaning if we can see that with the reset of the man projections is going to be a longer term issue, or new normal, [2:24:34] then that means our water supply need may be shorter and therefore those long-term investments might be able to go out a little longer or may be able to work better with those rates. [2:24:42] So that is something we'd like to do, is bring that back to you in the fall, and that may help inform you, but it won't inform you this rate cycle, but it would give you more information into the future. [2:24:53] So I just want to lay that out there as another potential way to have a deeper dive into that for longer. [2:25:01] Okay, any disagreement or about this hogs summary of the county back, she heard from the whole board? [2:25:15] So, I guess it also includes that the board is in agreement. She was a $200 treaty water surcharge and I know the projection into the future. [2:25:28] It's something that we need to on top of it, always for this rate setting process for the think I heard is that we will support staff's estimated 230,000 acre feet of demand. [2:25:54] Okay, pretty much, I have to say, so in other questions, the board hasn't pulled out [2:26:03] the feedback. [2:26:04] There were three more slides, but I think we've gotten what we needed. [2:26:09] I do think we need to reaffirm that we are including master plans that we're introduced [2:26:14] to master plans. [2:26:15] Yes. [2:26:15] That's when I clearly do need us to take action. [2:26:21] Basically, if the purview of the board is that we move forward with the scenario that considers [2:26:26] those inclusions is part of the rates in error. [2:26:29] We'll go ahead and put those in the graph to the idea that we've concluded earlier in the [2:26:33] presentation that that's the way to move forward and start those three programmatic [2:26:40] level studies. [2:26:41] studies, even though it's going to cost us money, but it's all right, I think to do so. [2:26:47] Okay. I think that's the end of this discussion. Thank you, staff, for all this material. [2:26:55] It's not easy to put together very complex. And so the board will expect further scenario analysis [2:27:06] based on some of the comments you have heard today. Is that right? [2:27:13] Yes. Okay. This is going to be before the draft CIP or after the draft CIP. [2:27:23] I think we're going to have to come back to the board prior to preparation of the [2:27:29] pause report, which is scheduled to be filed on February 28. So I think we need to come back [2:27:34] on the 20th of January or February 11th at the latest. [2:27:38] Okay. [2:27:39] Thank you. [2:27:41] And also, also, thank Board members for your engagement and the end of the act of staff. [2:27:49] So, we can move. [2:27:52] Chair. [2:27:53] May I also just clarify? [2:27:55] I just wanted to be clear. [2:27:57] I believe we heard direction from the Board today that they would like to see scenarios [2:28:03] regarding what are should ONM funding shortfalls and potential prioritization of that versus [2:28:09] some capital projects. Is that correct? [2:28:12] Well, or can we move forward with the preliminary CFP? [2:28:18] What I heard related to that is that it's something that's really, really important to the board. [2:28:29] I'm not sure it's something that you can put together in the next three weeks and then the board can go through the similar kind of discussion which is head on the water to the side. [2:28:42] So I think we should move forward with the preliminary CFP which the board discussed it at the December 17 meeting, including pretty much detail. [2:28:56] So, this is more of the operation site, so moving forward, we just need to have regular checking [2:29:08] with staff and how to move forward, so we don't get into another lower-global with our [2:29:13] reverse situation. [2:29:14] Okay. [2:29:14] Thank you for that clarification. [2:29:23] OK, and I have a request for staff to pull item 3.1. [2:29:44] So, OK, so, director, you want to pull 3.7? [2:29:48] Yes. [2:29:49] And then staff requires to pull 3.1 and for under 3.4 to 2. [2:30:01] Acknowledging all-going committee members, I may be, I can say that as part of the consent calendar [2:30:11] approval that I see Mr. Newark is in the audience that he is one of the outgoing committee [2:30:20] members from independent monitoring committee. So, thank you on behalf of the board. I want to say thank [2:30:27] very much for your service. It's a lot of work on the IMC. So I know you'll [2:30:33] will continue to be engaged in all these issues. So, so without either 3.1 [2:30:41] is 3.7 so I already have a motion and a second for Constant Calendar and we need [2:30:50] have a low color. [2:30:57] Dr. Trister Mara? [2:30:59] Dr. Kiegen? [2:31:01] Dr. Kramin? [2:31:04] Dr. Lizard? [2:31:07] Dr. Santers? [2:31:09] Dr. Rela? [2:31:11] Dr. Trister Schwain? [2:31:12] Yes. [2:31:15] Motion carries. [2:31:16] Item 3.1. [2:31:18] Is that knock? Who is going to? [2:31:26] Yes. Good afternoon. [2:31:27] Cheshire and members of the board, North Wind, Deputy Officer for Watershed Design Construction [2:31:34] Disease Division, staff is requesting the board to pull either 3.1 because we found some [2:31:43] inconsistencies in how the documentations, the attachments are referred to in the proposed [2:31:50] resolution. So we're proposing to pull it so that we can read the agenda. [2:31:54] This will be on future agenda. [2:31:56] That's correct. [2:31:57] Okay, thank you. [2:31:58] Item 3.7, Director Keegan, the question? [2:32:05] Thank you. [2:32:06] I have, so this is relating to the CEO reports. [2:32:11] And the first one is for the week of December 27th to 2019. [2:32:18] And there were a couple of items in there. [2:32:21] When is provide board with access, [2:32:24] Valley Water Comments received on stream maintenance, [2:32:28] sorted by improved and unimproved channels? [2:32:32] And there's also in the following CEO report, [2:32:37] there was some information provided directly [2:32:40] to board member Kremlin. [2:32:43] And essentially, both of the answers [2:32:45] responded that we're not able to provide that information [2:32:49] to you because of limitations with our existing system, which I understand and I guess my response [2:32:57] in two ways is as staff is moving forward with coming getting a new vendor hiring a new system. [2:33:07] I think it's interviewing the board members in terms of what our interests are and what type of [2:33:13] information that we would like to see that would be helpful for us to respond to our constituents. [2:33:18] You might not be able to accommodate everything we like, but I'm not sure that staff necessarily knows what are the kinds of questions or ways in which the information can be managed that we would be interested in. [2:33:32] So that's point number one. [2:33:33] Point number two is just, you know, I know that when we get requests regarding public records [2:33:44] requests, for example, I know that our library group actually does take a look at that and [2:33:51] develop some analytics and I feel like, and maybe I'm wrong with this, I'm not sure [2:33:57] that we're utilizing the request with access value [2:34:01] water in the same way. [2:34:02] I was not necessarily wanting something, [2:34:06] I guess my request was for something very quantitative, [2:34:11] but that doesn't exist, but at the same time, [2:34:13] I think that there's qualitative kinds of analyses [2:34:19] that can be done based on the information. [2:34:22] So to the extent that staff and our existing system [2:34:25] is able to, you know, win-o-out some nuggets of information. I think that's one of the ways in which [2:34:32] the community is interacting with the organization and the support member I'd like to be more informed [2:34:37] about that. So I know that staff may not be prepared to respond to this today, but just thinking about that. [2:34:47] If there is information that could be of meaning to the board, I would appreciate it being shared with us. [2:34:52] And then the other one is item six, [2:34:55] investigate homeless encampments on Wadalupe, [2:34:57] river between willow and mitten. [2:35:00] I was contacted as was Councilmember Dev Davis regarding some homeless encampments in that vicinity and their response was informative to me in that it talks about the fact that there's going to be an encampment cleanup of the new year, but it doesn't say whether or not we informed the constituent or whether that was coordinated with Councilmember Davis's office. [2:35:30] So if staff can provide me with feedback on that, I would appreciate it. [2:35:37] And if it is not happened, if it please. [2:35:40] But thank you. [2:35:44] The calendar you have. [2:35:48] Yes. [2:35:48] I'm through the chart. [2:35:49] I did one of the response to the Access Valley Water and our Compete System limitations. [2:35:54] Yes, we are in the process of upgrading the system. [2:35:57] What our intention is, when the new system does come online, being able to ensure that any request that comes in, [2:36:02] which is an indirect reserve that we can identify that and ensure that you're informed of the information. [2:36:08] In the meantime, what we're trying to do is put into place at least a manual system so that when things come in, [2:36:15] we can at least identify things that come in that are within your districts, [2:36:19] why we are still on convict. [2:36:21] We are probably looking about a year before the new system will be online. [2:36:25] So we will have at least a system in place so we can at least identify any and all things. [2:36:29] We're at least we're able to identify the location of what they're taking place, so you'll be able to be informed of any of all issues that come up through the value of what our [2:36:37] Comcase system is exists. [2:36:40] I think one thing that I would just thank you for that response, Mr. calendar. [2:36:44] And I think one thing I would just add is it could be helpful to the extent that you see trends, you know, whether they're within our district or not, but if we, you know, [2:36:54] Obviously, we've seen enough tick in the last few years in terms of homelessness complaints, [2:36:58] and those come to me directly so I'm aware of that. [2:37:01] But there might be other things like illegal dumping, or various things, and to the extent [2:37:07] that you're able to sort of tease that out, and those are trends that might be meaningful [2:37:11] to us. [2:37:12] I think that would be helpful information to have in the interim. [2:37:15] But again, I don't want to make this to owner, I understand that there's some real issues [2:37:22] with the existing system which isn't surprising. It's a pretty old system. But where you see [2:37:28] trends happening, I think that that's of interest to all of us. So thank you for your response. [2:37:35] See you. Yeah, I just wanted to add to that. Well, I also heard E.C. Jess Director Keegan [2:37:41] is that prior to really moving forward with finalizing the specs for any type of new system, [2:37:48] it would be good to get some feedback from each of the board members so that we're [2:37:51] moving in the right direction at the developing the appropriate specs to be able to extract the data that we want to extract, and so we'll do that as well. [2:38:01] I think that will be very helpful for all board members. [2:38:10] Let's go ahead and calculate it. [2:38:12] Item 4.1. [2:38:15] Set the time and place of regular meetings of Santa Clara Valley Walla District Board of Directors. [2:38:22] So staff is asking us two things. [2:38:26] First one is whether to continue the existing time and date of a regular board meeting or make any changes. [2:38:34] And second thing is if necessary, if there's any 2020 board meeting recess dates, as early as possible, we can identify that it will help staff planning for these meetings. [2:38:49] So let's do the first one first, that any proposal to change the current days and time of our regular board meeting. [2:39:02] Okay, there are two results. [2:39:03] Yeah, I have a question. [2:39:07] Now that we're a little more security minded. [2:39:10] Are people who are coming to the board meetings signing in? [2:39:16] We'll have the end of the past. [2:39:23] Well, good afternoon, Tinney O'C.O. of IT&AM in services. No, we do not require visitors [2:39:31] attending our board meetings to sign in. So, when people come in through the front door [2:39:36] if they're coming in this direction, the guard doesn't ask them to sign in. Identify themselves [2:39:41] if they haven't got a badge. I was stopped. [2:39:46] No, there's currently no guidance to require [2:39:49] members attending on public meetings to sign in. [2:39:54] We're probably beyond the scope of this item. [2:39:58] No, I miss this. [2:40:06] Okay, oh, just to respond to the issue, the Brown hat prohibits any requirement that our person identified [2:40:16] themselves in order to agenda item. So, signing in is not something they can voluntarily do it, [2:40:25] but it's not a requirement that we can impose. [2:40:32] What I was getting at is I'm trying to figure out if there was a way we could figure out [2:40:37] how many members of the public are attending the afternoon sessions and how many are attending the evening sessions. [2:40:45] Because I think we moved to the afternoon session thinking that we would get more people coming to these meetings. [2:40:53] And I don't see that there's a great difference but if there's no way for us to do it, I guess it's just a matter of whether to board once to continue [2:41:00] to come in the afternoon versus two evening meetings. [2:41:05] Thank you. [2:41:06] Thank you. [2:41:07] Last year. [2:41:09] Yeah, I wanted to move that. [2:41:11] We maintain the same schedule. [2:41:18] Ms. Yoke, do you want to say something? [2:41:23] I want to indicate that just following on the previous training. [2:41:27] Those provided to the board and our unclassified staff that we are having an upcoming meeting [2:41:33] certainly to pursue security related concerns that came from that previous training. [2:41:40] And we can implement any additional operational recommendations. [2:41:45] Please take a look at those recommendations and report back to the Board. [2:41:52] So we have a motion. [2:41:54] A second on keeping the current days in time of our regular board meeting. [2:42:02] All in favor say aye. [2:42:03] A pose? Motion carries. [2:42:11] Director Kramin? Yeah, thank you, Chair. I was wondering maybe this isn't [2:42:17] a time to discuss it, but look at sometimes our close sessions run against the beginning [2:42:24] of the meeting and we don't get to fill our, you know, get everything out of the way. Maybe we could [2:42:32] look into having them after the meeting. [2:42:36] I mean, other boards do that. [2:42:39] I think that's up to the board to decide [2:42:43] we don't need to take action or something. [2:42:46] So I'll do a, I want more survey of board members. [2:42:54] Director San Jose. [2:42:56] I know there's not on the topic, [2:42:57] the Metro Kremlin meeting suggested [2:42:59] about having closed sessions after. [2:43:01] I would just say a lot of times we make decisions [2:43:03] In the beginning, because the public is here, and therefore the public would go out the door so that would not be something I would care to do. [2:43:13] Yes, probably case by case. [2:43:16] So I'll definitely do our informal survey. [2:43:20] And so by keeping the current days and time of the regular meeting, we do not need to, [2:43:33] And then the second thing the staff ask is, is there any proposal for board meeting recess [2:43:44] doing 2020? Do we have any idea at the time? [2:43:47] or, well, we'll see if we can reach that. [2:43:51] Recess. [2:43:54] Please be alive. [2:44:01] Well, Mike. [2:44:03] OK, I have direct to Kegan first. [2:44:09] Thank you. [2:44:09] You know, I've long been a proponent for us getting a vacation, [2:44:14] just like every other agency does, [2:44:15] but it seems as if we can't quite get to that point. [2:44:19] So what I would like to recommend is possibly doing away [2:44:23] with one of the meetings in July, [2:44:25] So giving us a little bit more of an extended time off [2:44:29] without the whole month being off. [2:44:32] So I offered that up in the spirit of compromise [2:44:34] if anyone is interested in doing that. [2:44:39] That's here from Director Santos. [2:44:41] Yeah, always took the pride with our agency [2:44:43] is different than other governments [2:44:45] because we continue being open. [2:44:46] This slows down into simmer by itself. [2:44:49] So I'd rather see it's not changing anything. [2:44:51] We know how to work it. [2:44:52] We all know our staff and we're very open. [2:44:55] So when I want to continue government is open that's what the taxpayers pay for [2:45:00] Again, I really feel very proud of being here. Have you ever tried to call Saturday around December? Well, I've had a lot of urgency issues and guess what? You can't get anybody in a sad. And so we need to continue what we're doing. And we know how to work it out. Our staff, as an easier schedule in December, we kind of work towards that. But we're open for the taxpayer. [2:45:26] Director Cremden? Yeah, I hear what my fellow, some of my fellow directors are saying. [2:45:33] However, you know, there's a reason cities close and you know, our constituents aren't there. [2:45:39] I mean, the city part of it and I know July is tough for me. I probably won't be able to do anything in July. [2:45:47] But I can't make July. [2:45:49] So are you proposing to have July off or on July off? [2:45:56] The whole July off. [2:45:58] So that's the second proposal. [2:46:01] Director, was that? [2:46:02] Do you want to speak on this? [2:46:04] Or this is from the previous. [2:46:05] It was from the previous, by myself. [2:46:06] I do sense in. [2:46:08] As someone who used to get December-ange, [2:46:10] Lyoff, or at least two weeks in each. [2:46:13] I tend to agree with both Director Keegan and Director Santos and I think the compromise would be to have only one meeting in July. [2:46:27] I don't think it will ever happen because just the way this organization is. [2:46:31] We always have an emergency. [2:46:33] But if we strive to maybe go towards that, I know we've lightened. [2:46:37] But I was Chair, we sort of lightened our agenda items in July. [2:46:44] But I would go along with the compromise of being here. [2:46:49] One meeting in July and having one meeting of [2:46:56] Vice Chair. [2:47:00] Yeah, I agree, except that every time we say that, [2:47:03] we end up with more meetings in July than last. [2:47:06] So but I agree, we should just do one in July, schedule. [2:47:09] And then we'll probably have three or four more. [2:47:12] That's just the way it has been. [2:47:13] Been that way. [2:47:14] Twenty-some years has been like that. [2:47:18] I think we all have experienced with that. [2:47:22] Particularly for this year, 2020, [2:47:25] if the board decides to pursue the November [2:47:29] Bellum measure, [2:47:31] defining deadline is early August. [2:47:34] Think. [2:47:35] So July is going to probably be busy. [2:47:42] So based on what I heard from board members, the proposal is that set one board meeting of July and then if the situation requires to meet will meet. Is that the consensus? [2:48:02] Okay. Okay. [2:48:06] That's move on to suggest we do the one on July 9 instead of the one later on. [2:48:16] Yeah. [2:48:19] Yeah. [2:48:20] Instead of the last one. [2:48:23] So you're going to have the other three can be after that. [2:48:26] After that. [2:48:28] So July 9. [2:48:30] Is that right? [2:48:31] That's right. Do it there in the 23rd. Yeah, when we take it up. That's a consensus. Thanks a lot. Okay. [2:48:41] Moving. [2:48:43] I'm going to continue to future board meeting item 4.3. [2:48:51] Approved recommendation from board all the committee to approve the fiscal year 2018 to 19. [2:49:00] So this is a three-year annual audit work plan update by the Board Independent Auditor. [2:49:09] Recommendations is to approve the addition to the three-year audit work plan and also approve the updated. [2:49:21] And it's those two, the same thing, where I'll add in 4.3, [2:49:30] I'll go to Mr. Taylor to explain this. [2:49:36] Do you want to see them? [2:49:42] There and you have your [2:49:50] mic, it's not all. [2:50:01] Okay, thank you. Okay, there we go. [2:50:04] Yeah, so this item is a recommendation from the Board Audit Committee to update the annual audit work plan to include a property management audit that would audit the implementation of the encroachment program that the Board approved not too long ago. [2:50:21] So this audit would need to be sometime after that program is implemented and then it would be an audit to make sure to see how that program is going. [2:50:29] And that's basically what the side is all about. [2:50:34] So we need to take a action to approve that change to the three year, I guess, all [2:50:44] they will find. [2:50:44] Is there a motion to approve that? [2:50:46] Yeah, the question? [2:50:47] Yeah. [2:50:47] Oh, I'm sorry. [2:50:49] You can see that. [2:50:52] So, not specific to that, but that issue, but specific to the, [2:50:59] work plan in general. [2:51:01] I'm looking at the actual formal document, it's eight pages long. [2:51:09] On page three of seven, it says support services, ongoing provide support services [2:51:14] of the board, valley water staff, applicable to specific initiatives of planning projects, [2:51:18] et cetera, et cetera. [2:51:20] So my question is, and I don't know if there's anyone here from tap or of course there is. [2:51:26] So, [2:51:29] I had some questions and maybe if you don't have the answers today, you can get them for me. [2:51:38] So, do you know how many board meetings you attended last year? [2:51:42] Yes, ten. [2:51:43] You attended ten board meetings? [2:51:45] What about other committee meetings? [2:51:48] Board audit committee meetings. [2:51:49] Just one. [2:51:51] And what was on the agenda that you attended the ten meetings? [2:51:55] The most recent one, what was on the agenda? [2:51:58] Yeah, why were you here for those 10 meetings? [2:52:04] I can give you a list of all the meetings that I attended. [2:52:07] Yeah, well, okay, so that'd be great. [2:52:09] Then the other thing is, is that where is that reflected in the budget, your budget? [2:52:17] That's, as part of this work plan. [2:52:20] It is the attendance to board meetings is reflected in a task order that we prepared early last year. [2:52:27] So there's a set budget and then I typically review the agenda when it's issued and I see if there's any pertinent issues that I think I should be in attendance to observe and listen [2:52:43] And that's kind of how the process works right now [2:52:46] But is it is it in this audit work plan for next year? [2:52:52] Where would I fill in the hours or is that extra? [2:52:54] So yeah, that would be extra, yeah, that's not included in the annual audit work, and so what [2:53:00] does that is to describe the performance audit that will be conducted. [2:53:04] Okay, so what I'd like to note is what meetings you attend last year, what was on the agenda [2:53:08] that required your presence and how much that cost us? [2:53:12] Oh sure. [2:53:13] Thank you. [2:53:14] In fact, as part of the audit function, we put together an annual performance report as part [2:53:19] of the independent auditor in at least all our activities that we conducted as well as [2:53:24] I'll include hours and budget expended. [2:53:28] Yeah, it's more interested in your presence here. [2:53:31] Thank you. [2:53:40] So then going back to the audit work plan, [2:53:45] so I'll hurry the motion. [2:53:46] Yes, then a second. [2:53:48] OK. [2:53:49] All in favor. [2:53:50] I'm going to do that. [2:53:53] OK, no problem. [2:53:55] Item 4.4. [2:53:59] This is the board committee reports. [2:54:01] we have by the few reports posted. Are there any questions for any of these commuters? [2:54:10] No? Okay. That's called the forward. Item 5.1, update on the condition of the Almedavale [2:54:19] pipeline and the determination that the condition of the Almedavale pipeline continues to constitute [2:54:25] and emergency. [2:54:29] Aaron. [2:54:31] Good afternoon, honorable chair and members of the board. [2:54:33] I'm Aaron Baker deputy operating officer over the Rawwater Division. [2:54:37] A particular section of pre-stress concrete cylinder pipe on the Almanin Valley Pipeline [2:54:40] has not been previously repaired, is significantly distressed in a risk of imminent failure. [2:54:46] This section of pipe is located under Alamedos Creek adjacent to the Almanin Expressway [2:54:50] in between the Shannon Line valve and the Clareau Valvier. [2:54:53] On December 23rd, 2019, the CEO declared that the condition of the Almanin Valley Pipeline [2:54:57] constituted an emergency condition person. [2:55:00] Code. Since the emergency declaration staff has been intensely working to get the pipe section repaired. Recently, staff has prepared specifications for the emergency work and is in the process of finalizing construction contract with the contractor. A walkthrough with the contractor was completed earlier this week and they have indicated they are available to meet the February 27th return to service deadline. With the major construction work scheduled to begin on January 20th. No significant water supply or water quality issues will result from this work if the February 27th deadline is met. [2:55:30] The community outreach plan is being developed for the neighborhood that could be impacted by the construction. [2:55:37] Communications is working with direct agreement for a next-door post and printed notifications that will be delivered to the homes in the immediate area. [2:55:44] In conclusion, staff is recommending that the board determined by a fortress vote that there is a need to continue the emergency action declared by the CEO on December 23rd. [2:55:54] pursuant to California Public Contract Code 22050 to repair the almond and belly pipeline, [2:55:59] and I stand open for any questions. [2:56:02] The question for staff. [2:56:05] I have a question. [2:56:08] So in the discussion which is had on the PillarCIP, we have this Elvino Valley pipeline project. [2:56:17] It's as a rebuild of the entire health of that. [2:56:22] Right. [2:56:22] There's a replacement. [2:56:25] So, a question is that from now until the time we actually do the project, they're just [2:56:30] going to be this kind of emergency pop-up on a maybe not regular, but pretty frequent basis. [2:56:37] Is that a fair statement? [2:56:40] Right. [2:56:41] So, District staff is learning more and more about the acoustic fiber optic system and the [2:56:44] deterioration rates that we're beginning to see here. [2:56:46] And this one came up quick so as an emergency, but we do have future planned outages within [2:56:53] the next two to three years and then another one shortly after that so we can bake [2:56:57] in these planned outages to go and repair these particular sections. [2:57:01] That's not to say that something won't surprise us and kind of come in a little bit faster [2:57:06] than we think, but at this point we feel after this emergency that with the planned shutdowns [2:57:10] we have for the OmnR Valley pipeline coming up that we should be able to continue to repair [2:57:15] Those small sections until we're able to then institute that larger capital project to actually replace the failing pipe. [2:57:26] Is there a motion to approve of several recommendations? [2:57:30] So we need to recall things we need to have for four fifths in our field. [2:57:37] Dr. Strumara? [2:57:39] Dr. Keegan? [2:57:41] Dr. Corman? [2:57:43] Dr. Lazarot? [2:57:44] Dr. Santus? [2:57:46] Dr. Berlitz? [2:57:47] Treppers in Troy. Yes. Thank you. [2:57:58] Item 7.1. Receive update on the 2019 flood [2:58:03] preparedness campaign. Mr. Calendus? Okay. Yes. Good afternoon, Chair Shua and [2:58:11] members of the board. This is [2:58:16] item that was originally raised on September 24th during [2:58:20] one of the board work study sessions. When we talked about the get ready flood [2:58:23] campaign that was about to roll out the word, the word, the word questions about what we're [2:58:27] doing to communicate into the hot spots. And I say that make sure that we'd have the information [2:58:31] to come to the board. I'm going to ask Paola Giles, one of the newest PR3 members of the communications team [2:58:38] to come up and give the presentation. She was instrumental in putting all the information together [2:58:43] as well as the collateral materials. So I'm going to ask her to go ahead and kick off the presentation [2:58:46] of what we're doing in the community, the mailer that went out, what we're doing for hot spots, [2:58:52] et cetera, so I'd definitely seek it away. [2:58:56] Thank you. [2:58:56] Good afternoon. [2:58:58] Thank you. [2:58:59] Madam Chair and Members of the Board. [2:59:01] I'm very grateful for the opportunity [2:59:02] to present this campaign. [2:59:04] The theme for this year's campaign is Get Float Ready. [2:59:07] And we have a PowerPoint presentation that goes with it. [2:59:10] So I'm just going to pull it up. [2:59:18] I'll get some assistance with that. [2:59:20] In front of you, you have our Get Float Mailer, [2:59:25] and I will be referring to that during the presentation. [2:59:27] and also our hot spot outreach documents, so we'll be going through that as we pull up this power point. [2:59:54] Thank you very much. [3:00:00] This campaign, as I said, is getting flood ready. It's our flood awareness campaign 2019, 2020. And as you can see in the pamphlet that you have in front of you, we wanted to focus on very simple, concise messaging and three calls to action that we consider the most important for our community based on the research that we have seen. [3:00:21] And that's a really important people that they live in a flood zone, and that's outlining red in this [3:00:25] mirror that's going out to the homes that are in the FEMA SFI Chaves zone, also that they should know their [3:00:31] risk, meaning going to the FEMA map and putting in their address, you know, exactly where they're at, prepare their home, [3:00:37] whatever that means, as little or as much as possible, and get flood insurance, and this was an important point for both home owners and renters. [3:00:45] So these three points are outlined throughout the campaign consistently, and we wanted to have targeted them [3:00:50] So what we saw is that after the campaign in 2018, we found that groups that did not speak English as a first language [3:00:58] We're not always fully prepared [3:01:01] Maybe the message was a bit complicated for them to absorb and also we wanted to make sure that we were culturally sensitive [3:01:08] So that we acknowledge that there are people of different levels of language fluency [3:01:14] So we made the campaign multicultural and [3:01:16] and multilingual maintaining the key message in English, but the supporting more complex messages [3:01:22] were translated to four languages. We did a demographic study of the predominant language in each [3:01:30] area that we were targeting and we made sure that the billboards and transit ads were placed strategically [3:01:36] to reach the Vietnamese or Spanish or Chinese speaking communities that were most represented in that [3:01:42] The campaign also has a paid and earned media campaign component, community events and education. [3:01:50] They made it like you have in front of you and for the first time videos and for languages. [3:01:57] Also our education team is going to have to schools and spreading this message through our events. [3:02:03] And we want to make sure that children are aware about how to get flooded and that's why the pamphlet is also very accessible to children. [3:02:10] And we want them to be the leaders, maybe in their household, if their household is a home [3:02:15] of new immigrants to help their parents prepare for a flood. [3:02:20] The pamphlet, as we go through it, was mailed to 52,000 homes in the flood risk zone in [3:02:25] four languages. [3:02:27] In the cover we wanted to make sure that people understood that the information inside is multi-lingual. [3:02:33] We want that also to include something they could keep and refer to in the future after [3:02:37] maybe to not have the pamphlet anymore and that is a magnet that is at the back page and we start [3:02:43] off by letting people know that they are in a flood zone explaining what that means and also letting [3:02:48] them know that through our flood protection efforts our projects have resulted in 100,000 parcels being [3:02:56] removed from flood zones and this has resulted in lower insurance premium so maybe people think that [3:03:01] insurance is not so affordable it will be more motivated to look into it so we go through all of [3:03:07] 9 tips that we would like people to follow and back there is that magnet that we're hoping [3:03:14] they will keep throughout the year and their home on the refrigerator and it has the [3:03:18] key numbers and websites for them to make sure that one they choose to be flood ready [3:03:24] they're prepared to do so. [3:03:26] We also responded to the concern about hotspot outreach and this is where this other leaflet [3:03:32] have sent to play. We have reached out to 80 organizations in 12 areas that have been identified [3:03:38] as via our hydrology team as priority zones. So far 20 fixed organizations have responded. [3:03:46] They have requested this information. And also our posters and different languages. And six of them [3:03:51] have agreed to presentations. So we were willing to do as many as possible. Six so far won the presentations. [3:03:56] and we will present these materials, the videos, our social media materials, and the mailer to them, [3:04:04] as well as encouraged them to download the app once we go to those presentations, [3:04:09] the app for a sentaclera county. So we have social media videos. I don't know if you've seen them [3:04:13] on our Facebook page, but I invite you to visit it. Those videos are one minute long. They're [3:04:20] four languages. They feature staff members, and they really outline quickly what people can do to [3:04:24] get flood ready and link to all of our resources. [3:04:28] There are in English, Spanish, Vietnamese, and Chinese. [3:04:32] We have our blog that is hyperlinked to all of the resources, [3:04:36] so people can find a way to quickly get ready and just one page. [3:04:41] And we have our social media channels which have been branded with this message to our campaign. [3:04:45] And we were grateful that our city partners chose to share and amplify our message [3:04:50] after the winter preparedness guide. [3:04:51] We have received many shares throughout this campaign, [3:04:55] both from the public and from our partners. [3:04:57] So really, uh... [3:05:00] The efforts we think efforts haven't greatly amplified things to this sharing. And I wanted to just acknowledge [3:05:06] the contributions to this campaign by our graphics team and our CRS team. They came up with this concept [3:05:12] that was then taken by our advertising agency. So it was really a campaign that was very much developed internally. [3:05:18] So thank you. And if you have any questions, then happy to answer. Thank you for the presentation in the comment. [3:05:24] Okay, do I have to keep in? [3:05:28] Thank you, I just want to say that the graphics are really good. [3:05:33] Obviously, we always like multi-lingual approaches, so we reach all segments of our community. [3:05:39] And in particular, I really like the get-insured part in here. [3:05:44] I did go to the link and I looked it up and I didn't realize that blood simple policies [3:05:51] are a lot less expensive than FEMA and may work with your lender. [3:05:56] And I also really like that it said both as a homeowner and as a renter because there [3:06:01] were so many renters who with the coyote creek flood, you know, really went through a lot [3:06:07] And the fact that there are lower cost kind of loans [3:06:12] to help with potential flood situations [3:06:15] is great information for us to be getting out there. [3:06:17] So thank you. [3:06:19] Any other feedback for staff? [3:06:22] I just wanted to say that thank you very much for Mr. [3:06:27] Canada and all your staff to focus on this. [3:06:31] has but the residents and those being my just council need you and then I promise you I'm not going to say a word [3:06:41] I'll just point out because just pay special attention to them because they have the higher probability of getting flood. [3:06:49] So thank you. Thank you. Thank you for the presentation. [3:06:54] I then said 7.2 receive update on office of communication. [3:07:02] This is Mr. Calendar again. [3:07:04] Again, so every year, actually within the Board's work plan, it requests a presentation [3:07:10] from our office of communication. [3:07:12] So this is our annual presentation to the Board about the office of communications. [3:07:16] We are now doing this annually. [3:07:18] And so we'll probably be looking towards either the December of the end of the year or January [3:07:21] at the beginning of the Eurofly Communications, I will turn over to Lynn Hong, our communications [3:07:26] manager to lead us to the presentation. [3:07:29] Good afternoon, chair chair, and the little board members, Lynn Hong, Communications Manager, [3:07:35] and I'm here to present our annual Office of Communications Update as indicated. [3:07:39] It will include a brief overview of the work we do and conclude with the video. [3:07:44] The Office of Communications is made up of three teams, media and public relations, [3:07:48] graphic services and community outreach. We work together on internal and external communications [3:07:53] efforts which includes well-designed collateral featuring our new brand identity. [3:08:02] Media and [3:08:03] communications highlighting value water have garnered earn media from local, news publications [3:08:08] and media outlets throughout the region. We continually produce interesting and relevant content [3:08:13] that captivate both internal and external audiences. That content includes our public engagement [3:08:20] campaign that brings awareness about who we are and highlights our purpose while also featuring [3:08:27] eight employees as the faces of Valley Waters World Water People campaign. [3:08:34] Our community outreach and [3:08:35] his notification, coordination, and event management to ensure Valley Water Public Meetings or [3:08:40] events are made known to community members and offer opportunities to inform about Valley Water [3:08:45] Projects and efforts. And just this past year alone, there have been more than 35 public engagement [3:08:51] opportunities at Valley Water. Here's a video that captures a glimpse of the work, the office [3:08:56] of communications, delivers to highlight Valley Water, the Board of Directors, and all staff [3:09:01] efforts. [3:09:18] I'm seeing some technical difficulties. Let me just talk about it. [3:11:37] Thank you for the presentation. Thank you for the presentation. Thank you for the presentation. [3:11:42] Thank you. [3:11:46] Thank you. [3:11:48] Item 7.3, sponsorship of the water education for Latino leaders, conference 2020. [3:11:57] Staff is asking for the approval of the request of sponsorship in the amount of $12,500. [3:12:04] $10. [3:12:06] Okay. [3:12:08] Any discussion? [3:12:10] All in favor say aye? [3:12:14] Opposed? [3:12:17] Opposed? [3:12:18] Opposed? [3:12:19] Motion carries. [3:12:21] Okay. [3:12:22] I have an 8.1 CEO and Chiefs reports. [3:12:27] Yes. [3:12:28] Good afternoon, Norma Kamacho, CEO. [3:12:30] And I'd like to turn to first-cheap talks to talk about some late-breaking issues on the self-back of that. [3:12:37] Through the chair and the Board of Directors, a leak on the South by Aquidic was discovered yesterday near Summit Point Golf Club in Milpitus. [3:12:46] The SBA is owned and operated of course by the California Department of Water Resources as part of the state water project. [3:12:51] Valley Water typically receives this water for the state water project delivery through the SBA. [3:12:56] DWR is currently preparing for the repair of this leak on a 72 inch diameter pressurized raw water pipeline to perform an internal repair. [3:13:05] the section of the SBA must be shut down, isolated and drained. This means there'll be a [3:13:10] planned shutdown schedule for the repair, which is to be Sunday, this Sunday, January 20 [3:13:14] through Wednesday, January 22nd. Currently due to the plan outage of the cross valley pipeline, [3:13:20] which we currently have underway in our service area for rehabilitation. The SBA is the only available [3:13:25] source of raw water for all three of our valley water drinking water treatment plans. Therefore, [3:13:31] This shutdown of the SBA will require the shutdown of Valley Waters 3 drinking water treatment plants. [3:13:37] I repeat all three drinking water treatment plants will be out of service. [3:13:41] Comprehensive outreach and coordination with the retailers there are seven that will be impacted. [3:13:44] We'll be asked to switch to groundwater resources during this hopefully two to three days shutdown. [3:13:49] Those seven retailers include and we'll make sure to have them right. [3:13:54] City of Santa Clara City of Sunnyvale City of Milpita San Jose Municipal of City of San Jose San Jose Water Company Mountain View City of Mountain View and Cal Water Service Company. [3:14:04] We are doing outreach to those retailers as we speak that we're seeing an update post this board notification and then of course we'll do continued outreach with them in the days that follow. [3:14:15] We did also have recent meetings with DWR and we have another one schedule for January 29 to talk about the plan for rehabilitation and reliability for SBA. [3:14:23] of the board should know we're in communication with them quite regularly at an executive level. [3:14:29] In addition, a second updated item for the board is on December 26th of 2018 staff at the [3:14:36] Rinkanada Water Treating Plant, notice some sludge around a storm drainage ditch that potentially [3:14:40] washed into Smith Creek, staff reported the discharge to the state of California Office of Emergency [3:14:45] Services and initiated cleanup activities. A follow-up investigative report revealed that a [3:14:50] Combination of a film pumps storm pump state pump and a significant rainfall event cause [3:14:55] the process water from the sledge of the treatment plant to pull. [3:15:00] Assembly, and spill into the creek. Based on the initial filled inspection and clean [3:15:03] impactivity, it appears the amount of rainwater, sledge mixture released into Smith Creek was [3:15:08] limited with a minimal impact to the waterway. In totality, the investigative report believes [3:15:12] that 5,500 gallons did make its way to the Creek Smith Creek. We have done water quality samples [3:15:19] both during the event, post the event, and we've received those water quality samples back in which [3:15:24] indicates minimal impact of little impact to the waterway. In addition, we have groundwater soil [3:15:29] samples that are being taken and looked at now, so we'll be receiving those shortly. [3:15:33] We have followed up with a number of agencies, including the Regional Water Quality Control Board [3:15:37] and the Division of Drinking Water of the State Water Resources Control Board, of which there [3:15:41] would like additional information related to this incident. And then staff did follow up with [3:15:45] notifications to the West Valley Clean Water Program, which serves as the local stormwater [3:15:49] inspection agency from the town of Las Gatos. They also conducted a site inspection with no [3:15:54] additional findings and staff is continuing to work on identifying the root cause of the pump [3:15:59] failure as well as the potential for other similar incidences and will be implementing [3:16:02] the corrective actions and mitigate future occurrences in the future. [3:16:06] In general, the West Valley Clean Water Program was satisfied with our actions immediately [3:16:10] preceding this event. [3:16:15] And we also have some news and updates on Anderson Dam as well as our student maintenance [3:16:20] program in chief Richardson. [3:16:23] Yeah, so good afternoon. Members of the Board and congratulations, Chair Schwain. So on Anderson [3:16:28] Dam today, Valley Water received a letter from FERC that was requesting additional information [3:16:34] regarding the conclusions that we reached on the interim risk reduction situation that we sent [3:16:40] them on December 31st. Recall we sent a letter explaining that we thought the level that we [3:16:45] were currently keeping the reservoir was the correct one. We gave the reasons for that. They [3:16:49] asking for additional clarification on that and asking for that to be received within 14 [3:16:54] calendar days. [3:16:56] Concurrently, we're also finalizing an update to our emergency response plan and we're continuing [3:17:02] to engage working with NIMP's California Department of Fish and Wildlife and others to address [3:17:09] the potential impacts. [3:17:11] Finally, recently, as you probably have all been aware, there's been a series of moderate [3:17:14] to low magnitude earthquakes in the Gaurse and Martina area as well as Coyote Valley. [3:17:20] Although these earthquakes are well below the threshold that we would expect to cause [3:17:23] the impacts, we are continually inspecting the dam and appearances out of an abundance [3:17:28] of caution and as anticipated the dam has not experienced any degradation or change or [3:17:34] damage. [3:17:35] A second update I have is on the Palo Alto type gate improvement structure. [3:17:39] Yesterday, staff received a call from Palo Alto staff, a learning us to an unusual harmonic [3:17:47] vibration at the Palo Alto Tidegate structure, following the very high keen tides on Friday. [3:17:53] We suspected that debris may have been caught in one of the tides that caused the vibration. [3:17:59] So yesterday at 930 at low tide staff, 930 p.m., staff went out there to clean that out and [3:18:06] were able to open the gate clean all the surfaces and visible floating debris. [3:18:11] They didn't see anything stuck in there but they suspected could have been washed out with the high tide. [3:18:17] They went out again today and the problem appears to have been corrected as the harmonic vibration has gone. [3:18:23] We're hoping that's the case because we won't be able to get in there again until September to do any cleaning due to restrictions on the [3:18:32] Copper rails, or Ridgeway rails, so good news though that we at least cleared it up for now. [3:18:38] I do have another an update on the San Jose Police Department of Agreement renewal. [3:18:44] We are renewing that agreement with San Jose PD for the enforcement sleep. [3:18:48] It's enforcement sleep. [3:18:50] It will be coming to CEO Camacho for signature. [3:18:53] They have signed off. [3:18:54] It's coming to her this week for signature. [3:18:56] a new requirement that's been added to that is that officers assigned to the program will attend [3:19:01] environmental crimes training to enhance their ability to identify these crimes as they are [3:19:08] encountered and to be able to take appropriate enforcement action. So this is a new aspect that I [3:19:13] think aligns with our safe clean water program is beneficial to us. Lastly I'm going to just look [3:19:18] our Stream Maintenance Program. I have it here someone. I can't find it now. Our Stream Maintenance [3:19:26] Program update. [3:19:30] I'll care just now. Our Stream Maintenance Program update that gives kind [3:19:37] of the conclusion of this Stream Maintenance on season, which concluded in November. We did have [3:19:43] a very successful 2019 work season where we did sediment removal bank protection vegetation management [3:19:50] projects. It lists the amount of projects that we did that pretty significant amount and also [3:19:56] an industry habitat improvement project this year. [3:20:00] Our field vegetation operation unit is continuing to do work outside of the area that we can get into during the summer season to remove 35 invasive plant management program projects and 24 rebedge projects and of course they're continuing to remove channel obstructions from fallen trees, trash and debris throughout the season. [3:20:24] Also during this season, they cleaned up 170 homeless encampments and removed 840 cubic yards of trash in debris. [3:20:33] One thing of note is the Guadalupe River project that we were talking about earlier the four miles that we are rehabilitating is in our CIP this year. [3:20:43] This season under our S&P permit, they removed over 56 acres of in-channel vegetation, including 119 large trees, [3:20:52] And the good news is that that has significantly approved the channel capacity to a point where [3:21:01] the hundred year flood now only is about six inches and we're at over tops in certain sections. [3:21:07] So with that and being able to manage Lexington Reservoir, we should be able to, you know, manage it until we can get the full project completed. [3:21:15] And that concludes my report. [3:21:16] Thank you. [3:21:25] And with that chief calendar, you do have some updates from government relations. [3:21:31] Yes, I actually have several updates. [3:21:34] One was a GCRCT, GCRCD tour that took place last Friday. [3:21:40] They elected to do two tours. [3:21:43] One, this past tour was joined by Director Kagan as well, several staff. [3:21:47] They looked at the Guadalupe River, several sites. [3:21:50] of those kinds of seals, ponds, the alamedos, drop structure behind our headquarters. [3:21:56] They are planning another tour on January 31st, which is going to be geared towards Kiwi Creek, [3:22:01] where they plan on visiting Anderson Dam, Ojo Ponds, Fisher Creek, and Metcalf Ponds. [3:22:07] The GCRCD is reasoning behind the tours they want to make sure that their board members [3:22:10] are understanding as well as the public is aware of the projects. [3:22:15] We do have a couple of one pages, one from the Office of Civic Engagement and one from the Office of Communications. [3:22:21] There's always just pointing to a couple of different items that are in there on the Office of Civic Engagement. [3:22:25] I'll point to the fact that there is going to be a job shadow day that's going to be led by the Youth Commission, [3:22:30] which is going to be coming up February 20. [3:22:32] There is a video that was shot by the Chair of the Youth Commission that will be out very shortly. [3:22:37] I think it does a very good job of encouraging other youth to attend the job shadow day. [3:22:41] Also, we did have the Volunteer Recognition event on December 31st, excuse me, on December 11th, which went very well, was led by the chair and giving the Volunteer Recognition Awards as well as many of the directors were there to award the volunteers within their district. [3:22:57] I'm moving to the Office of Communications, one major, again, just highlighting a couple of things that are on there. [3:23:03] The one thing I did want to point out is a county-wide Miller did start to actually [3:23:08] should have landed and everybody's mailbox. So hopefully all the directors did receive it. [3:23:13] As of yesterday, I believe we had received 2300 requests for calendars and we do anticipate [3:23:19] more coming in for basically to have our calendar on the wall, which is also our annual report. [3:23:25] Also, finally, there will be an ex-band ribbon cutting that will be occurring tomorrow, [3:23:29] of the led by Director Santos out in the penitentiated area, as well as a CO [3:23:35] commercial. [3:23:36] We'll be joining that. [3:23:37] So hopefully we will get some press and some news, just due to the rain that we're currently [3:23:41] having and be able to talk about the different advantages, the X-Men radar will give us. [3:23:46] I'll turn it back over to CO. [3:23:48] Thank you. [3:23:49] That's a question of Mr. Calendar that this water ambassador program that I know [3:23:57] each four members appointing three candidates to serve on the program. [3:24:05] I was just, I think I really recommend that to all of you that if it's not too much [3:24:12] a problem, maybe we can consider extending more than three people, so we know that even [3:24:20] though they commit at the beginning of the program end up toward the end after six classes [3:24:26] It's quite a few of them just stopped and they're not doing the graduate. [3:24:32] So I'm not saying do it, but then just, since still you hope that you guys can evaluate it [3:24:38] and see if we can have a little bit more people. [3:24:41] And there's something. [3:24:42] Yeah. [3:24:42] For the right kind of. [3:24:43] So we are hoping they can be able to expand that program. [3:24:45] One of the things that we have notices that certain districts do get a lot more volunteers [3:24:49] to participate in the program than others. [3:24:52] Unfortunately, in certain districts, sometimes we only have received as low as three volunteers [3:24:56] and we'd actually have had to go back out to recruit others. [3:25:00] I'm up to 10 to 12 folks that would like to attend the program, even though your districts are all based on the same amount of residents from the districts. [3:25:08] We don't have equal participation, but we, and what our hope is this for next year's ambassadors program that will be able to at least expand the number of ambassadors participating. [3:25:17] So yes, we are looking at it, and we'll actively work towards getting that resolved. [3:25:20] Thank you, Dr. Lazzat. [3:25:24] I think I noticed in here a small update on creek signages. [3:25:30] How is that those identification signs coming not only with regard to the creeks, but also with regard to projects? [3:25:40] Well, we actually do have two signs that have been put up in the direct of a relisari. [3:25:44] So those are called our basically our historical signs that we identified one for each district. [3:25:50] We do have signs that are going to be rolling out, probably next I believe in the city, [3:25:54] Mopetus. [3:25:55] We're currently working with the city of Mopetus, but we are actively working towards [3:25:59] that. [3:26:00] We will be having a signage update for the board. [3:26:02] I'm going to look to the Lynn if maybe you can respond in terms of when we'll be coming back [3:26:07] to the board. [3:26:07] But we are actively working on the first two legacy signs. [3:26:11] We're rolled out. [3:26:12] One was on Lake Cunningham and the second was on the Madrome pipeline. [3:26:16] We do have others that have been identified that we'll be rolling out and each of the [3:26:19] as districts cannot turn the wind if she has any further update. [3:26:23] So, staff has been working towards a campus sign, and that extends out to an RFP involving [3:26:29] signage as relates to project signs, specifically legacy signs, and also holding increase [3:26:35] signage. [3:26:36] And we're going to work with the book of the Board to determine the best aid to come back [3:26:41] to present formally and provide you information as it relates to our signage and our efforts [3:26:49] since we visited last spring. [3:26:53] Okay, thank you. [3:26:54] And then I wanted to comment on the video. [3:26:56] I thought it was really well done. [3:26:59] Dwight Clark has the catch. [3:27:01] I now have the pitch. [3:27:02] Thank you very much. [3:27:05] Yeah, and just lastly, we have Chief York [3:27:07] with some updates as well. [3:27:11] Good afternoon. [3:27:14] To continue, keep the board or prize of value water projects, [3:27:17] the Office of Administrative Services [3:27:19] and IT plans to provide the attach quarterly updates, the first update of its kind, to really [3:27:28] keep the board informed by way of the many projects and initiatives underway within the [3:27:37] business unit. So in the interest of time, I will obviously cover the information that you all [3:27:43] can review at your leisure, but you'll see a theme by way of quite a bit of substantial technology [3:27:51] upgrade projects as well as facility projects to renovate our existing work environment build [3:27:59] data and maximize our work spaces to the greatest extent possible. The second update I have [3:28:07] for the board is in regards to the second handout. [3:28:11] It's the double sided page that's titled in for all. [3:28:15] This update is responding to the July 23rd Board meeting [3:28:21] when the IT Services Unit took the ERP contract for your award [3:28:30] and the board requested to be updated on the status [3:28:35] of the implementation and just updated as the project moves along. [3:28:40] And so this new sletters intended to provide a overview of where the project is currently [3:28:46] yet. [3:28:47] I also want to invite Mike Koch, the IT deputy up to provide any responses that you might have [3:28:54] as it relates to the import European project of any. [3:28:59] Go ahead, Mike. [3:29:01] So, I can give you a update on it as well. [3:29:06] So, a good afternoon, chair sway and numbers of the board. [3:29:09] Just to give you a couple of quick sentences on how we're doing right now. [3:29:14] The way things are going is we're kind of working in two large phases. [3:29:18] So, we have kind of our finance and supply chain modules that have our purchasing, [3:29:23] our procurement, our contracting processes. [3:29:25] And then we have our human resources out of the house. [3:29:27] We have our HR and Victoria recruitment, all those sorts of things. [3:29:30] So it's going on right now as that our finance and supply chain side of the house has recently completed about 16 weeks of training. [3:29:39] This is to get the teams familiar with the project, to get them familiar with the product itself, with each of the modules, so they can have better input as we actually start our design sessions. [3:29:49] That team as of the first of this year is now heads down working on those design phases of the project. [3:29:55] So we are rotating consultants in and out of our offices. [3:30:00] Actually, eight on-site this week, while we're working on our design for the finance side of the house. HR is scheduled to move about three months after the finance and supply chain project, so HR just started the beginning of January doing their series of training courses. [3:30:14] So, right now, we've got the full project team working on this thing. [3:30:18] We have sequestered ourselves over the sanitary sub-building. [3:30:22] There's twenty-one full-time staff who are working on the project right now, [3:30:27] as well as a very number of consultants based on what's going on during that particular week. [3:30:32] So, things are moving along swiftly. [3:30:34] We are moving on on schedule, and everything seems to be going well so far. [3:30:38] And I'm happy to answer any questions at the board may have. [3:30:42] Okay, and just lastly, if there are no other questions, I just wanted to end with what [3:30:48] you tell the young watersheds have jointly put together the storm report and we're going [3:30:51] to continue to do that as we progress towards the winter and so that has been provided [3:30:55] to you from December 10th through January 13th. [3:31:00] Thank you, Michael. [3:31:01] Thank you. [3:31:03] OK, how item 9.1, adopt resolution to amend the contract with CalPERS to include partial [3:31:14] service retirement benefits. [3:31:17] This is something that I think the board already discussed before. [3:31:23] Is there a need for staff presentation? [3:31:26] No, OK. [3:31:28] OK. [3:31:28] OK. [3:31:28] We'll have a motion in second. [3:31:30] Oh, this is the resolution, we need to do a local. [3:31:37] Territory Stimera? [3:31:39] Strictor Tegan? [3:31:40] Territory Cramon? [3:31:42] Territory Hesat? [3:31:43] Territory Hesat? [3:31:45] Territory Hesat? [3:31:46] Territory Hesat? [3:31:47] Yes. [3:31:52] District Council. [3:31:53] No report. [3:31:56] Board Member reports announcements. [3:31:59] Do you want to do a next slide? [3:32:01] Okay. [3:32:12] I was going to do it when I gave my report on my meetings, but I was really remiss when I was [3:32:19] thanking everybody for helping me when I was chair, and not publicly thanking chair [3:32:24] Shua. [3:32:25] I had seriously considered postponing being chair last year after I lost my mother, but I [3:32:31] to sort of have my back, take over some things behind the scenes and to help me in my responsibilities is chair. [3:32:42] And so any success that I have, I want to share it with her, so thank you very much. [3:32:50] Director Cramden? [3:32:52] Yeah, this is more of a question. [3:32:54] When are we bringing the Project Labor Agreement to discussion back? [3:32:59] I think that's slated for February. [3:33:01] I don't have things. [3:33:02] Oh, like birds, is here. [3:33:05] February 11th. [3:33:06] Thank you. [3:33:11] That's it? [3:33:12] I know. [3:33:13] Yes. [3:33:14] Yeah, I was. [3:33:14] OK. [3:33:15] So it's not all here. [3:33:17] OK. [3:33:17] Well, yeah, just go. [3:33:18] Something happens. [3:33:19] Something happens. [3:33:20] I was listed in it. [3:33:23] I'm not sure that it needs to be an item for a future agenda. [3:33:27] But over the holidays, I had requested some information on downtown [3:33:33] streets team. As we all know that there were some allegations made in the press, not proven, or disproven. [3:33:41] But I think it would be important for us to do similar to the county of Santa Clara and the city of Santa Zay to take a look. [3:33:50] We're giving them significant financial monies and if there's inappropriate behavior taking place within the organization or improper utilization of funds. [3:34:01] that something that we'd want to answer to. [3:34:04] It doesn't necessarily need to come back to the full board. [3:34:08] It could come back at the CEO's discretion as part of a CEO report. [3:34:13] But I thought I was going to get some follow-up info that has not yet happened. [3:34:17] So I just wanted to underscore that. [3:34:19] Madam Chair, I would second that. [3:34:22] I also make sure that the homeless committee gets any information because we're the ones [3:34:26] that supported that over a year ago to join that organization. [3:34:30] So I would definitely like to find out in the information should be sure with the committee, so we can make recommendations to the board [3:34:37] That makes sense. Yeah, so then there's a direction for that [3:34:42] Response to Director Keegan's question. I'm also going to the home is at [3:34:51] Clerk review and clarification of [3:34:54] Board requests [3:34:57] Okay, I have no [3:35:00] For more more, remember, questionless, this last one that you would like to put in as a BMR. [3:35:05] Okay, then steps to follow up with the outcome straight steam and review the use of funds, come back to the board. [3:35:11] And the homeless and cabinet ad hoc committee, if there are any concerns. [3:35:16] Okay, we have hours. This meeting is adjourned to our next regular meeting at 6 p.m. on January 28, 2020. [3:35:27] Thank you, everybody.