[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:00] Okay, all right. Call, I'm meeting all of her. Roll call, please, men chair, matman, clerk. [0:08] Dr. Shua, director Keegan, director Cremey, director Liza, director Santos, director Verella, chair, [0:21] chair, extramar. Here. We have all members present. [0:27] Thank you, Madam Clerk. We'll move right along then to pledge of allegiance. [0:33] Is there a tissue? Could you please lead us [0:42] to the flag in the United States of America? [0:46] I'm a two-year-old father. I'm a two-year-old father. I'm a two-year-old father. [0:48] I'm a two-year-old father. I'm a two-year-old father. Thank you. [1:02] Okay, we'll go to orders of the day. [1:05] I'll start right out by pointing out that we're going to continue [1:11] item 4.1. We'll have adequate notice for when we set it. Again, [1:23] are there any other [1:24] requests for taking any items up or moving them or bringing them back or you're [1:34] going to request? I do not see any at this time, Mr. Chair. Okay, all right then we'll [1:39] right along to 1.4, time open for public comment on any item not on the agenda. [1:47] Now's the time for any members of the public that might want to address us on any issue [1:52] that is not on the agenda this evening. [1:56] Do we have any requests? [1:58] I do not see any at this time. [2:05] We'll go right along with 2.1, Santa Clara Valley Water District Government Relations Program, [2:10] update and legislative outlook. I think is it is done going to do this one? Yes, chair. [2:19] Yeah, good evening, done. Thank you, introduction. I'm going to share my screen here. [2:31] Can you [2:32] see this presentation? One second. [2:38] Yes, [2:41] we do now. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, chair. [2:44] So as mentioned, I have done Rocha Deputy Government Relations, and I'm here to present on [2:49] item 2.1, our annual Government Relations Program Update and the 2021 legislative outlet. [2:56] I want to first thank everybody who allowed this item to go first in order to accommodate [3:00] the time change for our consultants to live in DC, so I'm sure they're very much appreciated. [3:05] So that's cool. [3:08] So to start, this is a visual image of Government Relations Actions. [3:12] And as you can see on the right, these are the bullets that really kind of captured the mission of these efforts. [3:18] Whether it's responding to emerging issues in the public realm, helping to shape public policy and regulatory policies to advance value waters missions, [3:26] advocating to secure and protect funding for value water projects, defend value water against punitive legislation and regulatory initiatives, [3:34] Finally, the managed values values reputation through external efforts, with advocacy, strategic partnerships and stakeholder engagement, all while working hand-in-hand with the other units within external affairs. [3:46] This document is one of the familiar view. We have a picture of our legislative proposals and guiding principles, which support a prune that the end of 2020. [3:54] This acts as our math and guide and all of our legislative advocacy efforts. [3:59] These are some visual images of the work that we do here in OGR, and in many instances, [4:05] you, the director's help in these efforts, and it can be very effective with your support. [4:10] We very much appreciate it. [4:11] I'm sure all staff does. [4:13] Whether it's in our mayor and city manager meetings with the local municipalities and cities [4:17] here in the county, or helping to gain support for our legislative efforts from outside stakeholders [4:22] and elected officials. [4:23] It's a true team effort here at Valleywater. [4:27] And this slide is another key component of our work, which self-filled our maintain our relationships with those stakeholders that I previously mentioned. [4:34] In normal times, retaining events in person, participating in panels, educating the public and the incredible work that we do here at the agency, [4:42] is just as important as it's assessed a value of water as it is with all of our other efforts. [4:47] This was especially a two-part work supporting the safe thing water growth. [4:51] And the boards were all over this vision, and this is also key. [4:54] So thank you once more for you all and is to give your time and energy to help support all of our efforts. [5:00] So, one of the attachments here in the document that you have in front of you is has a list of the tours, community events and sponsorships for 2020. [5:10] And your participation in these, whether it's attending the events that we sponsor or bring sponsorship opportunities to our attention. [5:17] It's all a part of the work that we do to be true community partners with the communities that we serve. [5:22] And we want to maintain that relationship with all those folks in our community here by the way. [5:26] So I can personally tell you that many of the folks in that organization that we partner with are very thankful for these efforts, and they recognize Bell and Water as an engaged public agency in more ways than just a water provider, and I think that's really key to success of Bell and Water. [5:42] And last, this is our last slide, and this shows a snapshot of our passport from 2020. [5:47] Some of which, what you get in me participate in, and I do want to take this opportunity [5:51] to remind everybody how difficult it was to do the work of external affairs and OGR during [5:57] this pandemic and shelter in place. [5:59] But the staff here at Valley Water activity very quickly under the leadership of CEO, Calendar [6:04] and Chief Gibson, and we are able to accomplish quite a bit during 2020. [6:10] So here we have a list of the consultants that are present and they're available to answer [6:16] any questions that you have. [6:17] I'm going to read them off here just so you know we've got Monica Miller, Sacramento advocates. [6:23] On the federal side, we have Julie Minerva and Laura Morgan Kessler with Carpey and Clay. [6:27] And finally Mark Kadesh, joined by his colleagues, Dave Raming and Ben Miller, all with Kadeshness. [6:33] I want to take this opportunity to publicly thank them for all the work that they've done supporting [6:37] by the water and our division over the EU. [6:40] So with that, that wraps it up. [6:42] They're here to answer any questions [6:43] if you have any specific for them, [6:45] or I'm here to do my best to respect them. [6:48] Thank you, Dan. [6:49] I'm sure we have some questions, especially, [6:52] of our federal folks. [6:55] Well, there's also some statewide issues. [6:58] Any questions? [7:00] More members? [7:02] The director of his life has a question? [7:03] The director of his life? [7:11] I wanted to clarify that the only change to the legislative proposals and guiding principles [7:18] handout from last year is that something was added with regard to seeking legislation [7:25] for best value on track. Is that the only change? [7:29] That was for on the state side, huh? [7:31] Yes, it's part of legislation. Yes, there were a few and forgive me for not having any. There were a few that I think dropped off and then a few on the guiding principles that were added, but on the legislative side, that was only a decline. [7:46] So, you know, I'm always interested. I know, Don, thank you for your report. This is your first time, but it's always helpful for us to know what came off, what went on, what was changed from the prior year. [7:59] So, you know, maybe a red line copy. [8:02] Are we going to approve this tonight? [8:05] You approved it at the end of 2020, [8:07] and I think we had some direction [8:09] of director, friends, and we challenged each individual director, [8:13] and go through it in division with you, [8:14] and I had not to need you to do that with you. [8:17] OK. [8:17] I can't be called participate in that. [8:20] I think it might have been great to be said. [8:22] Yeah, OK. [8:23] So those are the, so I, I'm going to wear [8:26] when the directors wanted or handed to it. [8:29] So I guess that it would be helpful to see what the change is for you. [8:35] So a recap on what the life of the case [8:37] part of that document would be very helpful next. [8:39] Yeah, yeah, even just a red line version or a recap now. [8:43] Yeah. [8:43] We've got it. [8:44] Thank you. [8:45] Thank you. [8:50] Any other questions? [8:55] Do we? [8:56] I'm not seeing any of the questions. [8:57] I wrote the key in the reason. [8:59] Oh, they're good. [9:00] Okay. [9:00] That's right, Keegan. Thank you, Chira Scramera. So this is probably a very obvious question [9:09] and it's also probably too soon really to respond. But what are some of the positive things [9:15] potentially that we see with, you know, a new administration in place, one that potentially [9:22] to be friendly California. [9:26] Well, I'm going to, you know, give them eSports live and breathe the DC in [9:32] the area. [9:33] I'm going to kick that one and say hi to Billy or Mark. [9:36] And one of you would like to jump in and not for your output for 20-20-20-20-1 [9:40] with the RSDCs concern? [9:43] So, all right, this is Julia. [9:44] I can start quickly with the administration piece and then pass it over to Mark. [9:47] Talks about Homura. [9:49] But you know we've already seen that this administration is printing ahead and we are on [9:55] Day 7 of the Biden administration and already they've taken a number of actions. [10:00] I'm here. Some of the harmful regulations that we saw put in place by the previous administration. So, you're going to see a much more timely regulatory platform. [10:10] We are also seeing a lot of folks that you have previously worked with in Congress or the Obama administration, go back into the administration. [10:20] So, you're going to be re-meeting people and re-introducing your projects and priorities. So, I think you're going to find us friendly landscape both in terms of people, as well as the policy. [10:33] I would just add to that. I'm sure, well, no, we have now one party control of both houses, [10:43] although by a very narrow margin, the narrowest margins in the set of 50-50, but it doesn't [10:48] mean that a lot of the major infrastructure request that we've been making will, [10:56] I already have this administration that I already have this Congress. [11:01] So there is a much better chance that there will be real funds for projects that we've been interested in for many years. [11:11] And it's still a tough way to how. There's still a lot of negotiation. [11:16] And it will not be easy. We have a new Senator who we have to get to know from the California Center for DIA. [11:22] But we have a very good delegation that's worked on the priorities, and I think we have a lot of opportunity this year in this Congress. [11:31] Thanks, everyone. [11:33] It's very exciting to use. [11:34] Thank you. [11:35] Great. Yes. [11:37] Anybody anybody else? [11:41] Okay. Well, great. [11:42] Thank you. Thank you very much, Dan. [11:45] Thank you. [11:46] Thank you. [11:47] Thank you. [11:59] I'm going to take 5.1 out of order, we've got Council at a DC, also frozen with Julian Markle over there, so we want to take a little earlier, so let's let's call up 5.1. [12:17] one then for that reason. [12:22] Okay, 5.1. [12:26] Good evening, Chair and board members. I'm 5.1. [12:30] Consider the decommissioning of the Anderson High School. [12:34] I have an ingredient and if you have any questions based on staff's recommendations, [12:43] and we can take those now with light and you can walk through the recommendations. [12:52] Let's walk through them real quick because it's Anderson. [12:58] I, sorry, I didn't mind. [13:01] Yes, thank you very much. [13:03] Thank you, Greg. [13:04] I am the acting of all water depth, [13:08] a song, a song, an operations manager who will, uh, [13:12] that was a, uh, staff's recommendation. [13:21] Okay, what do you mean? [13:23] Good evening, Mr. [13:23] myself, [13:28] but I can read the first recommendation and then if you have questions about how we got to [13:33] these organizations, I'll be happy to answer all I have with us on the panel of the [13:40] Balak Foundation [13:53] since I did most quickly out of order and I have that not open. [14:08] So, [14:08] see because back in the United States, showing why we're planning to [14:18] vote at the board [14:18] and conquer the United States with our nation, which is based on how to handle the [14:23] United States. [14:24] That it's just too far for a very more people to pursue this surrender and the commission [14:29] that has a city. [14:30] And the third recommendation is for the board to direct start, to take the necessary steps [14:35] to seek approval from the Federal Energy Administration for the surrender and the [14:43] includes, but it's not going to be to the following two items. [14:48] If I'll wait, there's a rank of the license, the license and the convention of the facility. [15:17] All [15:20] right, let's take some questions, yes. [15:24] I will concur that we look at the cost benefit that we concur with staff determination and we direct staff to take the necessary steps. [15:34] So that would be a motion even though there was no action steps [15:39] We've done those things until they have some more questions. Okay, is there a second? [15:45] So we have a motion. Okay, uh, discussion. Yeah, discussion [15:51] And question [15:54] Directing, we're all over the question [15:57] Sorry, I'm just a second [15:59] Direct, we're all just a second. He's going to direct or show up first. Yeah. Okay, so I'll find it [16:10] It's probably a little late that I was just going to say that staff did a very good job explaining the business reasons for his recommendation in the amendment. [16:23] But as the chair said, because it's the Anderson dam related to Anderson dam, there are probably a lot of public. [16:36] Publicity is interested, so I was just going to say that as step to explain a little bit more about these business reasons that [16:44] They mentioned this calls and then the review comes in and they're how we how we reach our recommendation [16:49] Yeah, even though we already have a motion and [16:54] Second yeah, no, I agree so Kusam [17:03] Yeah, let me take the right to Keegan and then and then you got [17:06] you can give us a little more description on it. [17:10] Direct the Kegan. [17:11] Actually, I was just going to second the motion. [17:13] So, okay. [17:15] Direct the verella. [17:16] Okay. [17:17] Direct the verella. [17:17] All right. [17:18] Direct the verella. [17:19] Thank you. [17:20] So, what is the timeline that we're looking at on this? [17:25] The timeline, basically, I might have to talk about the question to 20 and a long [17:32] picture. [17:33] But what I'm looking at the commissioning as soon as we can. [17:37] basically receiving the approval of the board. [17:40] And once we say the commissioning, [17:42] we stop losing the application. [17:44] I actually really stop losing losing it. [17:46] Because we are not at that point. [17:48] So physically, we can't lose it. [17:50] But if you decide to the commission, [17:52] at this point, we will unblock everything. [17:54] That's an easy operation. [17:56] We'll unblock all the laws and stuff. [17:57] So we can not lose it anymore. [17:59] But then, to go through the commissioning, [18:01] we put a part of the IR and work on this. [18:05] It may take some thought, and you don't want to say that once or once a year or two, you don't sound like [18:24] that. [18:24] So this is Anthony Fosers in your system. [18:27] Thank you. [18:28] So we would have to submit an application to Part to request, to basically just surrender our license [18:34] for the hydroelectric facility. [18:37] I think that application. [18:38] I mean, I'm not sure if Chris Hakes is on. [18:40] He could probably explain the timing of when we submit that application. [18:43] but for purposes of the EIR occurred for innocent, we need to know whether or not [18:49] we are going to decommission that hydroelectricity, because that will be part of the [18:53] project of scripts into the innocent project. That's where it comes to the war now for [18:58] their approval, hopefully, approval of the recommendation. [19:02] This is Chris AXWD operating officer for Dan Safety at face correct. So basically, we are, [19:06] as you know, under emergency action now for the Anderson Dam tunnel project, immediately after the [19:11] will go into construction. We're going to be pivoting into the Anderson-Dancisen [19:15] Prejudicial Permitting Action. And during that action, probably I'd say within 12 [19:19] months or so, we'll be putting together and officially submitting an application for surrender. [19:25] Now, if that is approved, the actual decommissioning of the plant won't be officially completed, [19:30] and so the size and pressure fit portion of the project is completed. So the timeframe [19:34] would be somewhere between 2025 and 2030 depending on the progress of the size and [19:39] the project. Thank you for the answers, appreciate it. [19:47] Okay, thank you for other [19:48] no more questions. So Kassan, give us a little description of what we're [19:51] doing. I think it helps for the community. It's pretty interested in the [19:58] project. So I think that's it. [20:00] It would be helpful to give them a description. [20:30] that facility has the money that we lose in mind. [20:34] So the operations and maintenance tasks have been [20:38] have exceeded the limits of this facility. [20:42] And on average, in the last few years, [20:44] numbers show that the world losing around 75,000 per year [20:49] on this facility. [20:52] And that's why we are coming to the [20:57] world. [20:57] In fact, the hydro, in the first 14 years of the life of the hydro, [21:00] It was profitable because the rate's structure of the PG&B in power company was designed to help [21:07] by the water and cover the emissions. [21:10] But after that, it's such a change in the last few years we have been in our business. [21:16] And we do those money because we cannot afford it all the time. [21:19] It's really depends on how much water we have and understand. [21:22] How much we need to produce to the creek. [21:24] Remember, this is not over there. [21:36] So that's why we don't need a lot of pump, a proper part of this facility. [21:45] And furthermore, other ways of why [21:51] we keep this facility, and if you go out and there's [21:59] But we need to maintain it, it's gotten gold. [22:02] There are at least 3 million gold in the rehabilitation [22:05] and at least 1,000 plus some of the benefits. [22:09] So we need to change benefits. [22:11] It's like you have another chart and you are typically [22:14] that you have to use and then you want to use. [22:17] You're there as per month. [22:19] So in the middle of the dollar, in addition to, we don't make money out of it. [22:23] So it's a music on both sides, on one of the talls [22:31] and the fish. [22:35] So that's why we don't have to do this. [22:40] Thank you. [22:43] Thank you, Lassan. [22:44] All right, then there's no further questions that we'll go to. [22:48] Go to a roll call, please. [22:53] Director Shua? [22:54] Yes. [22:55] Director Keegan? [22:57] Yes. [22:58] Director Kremlin? [23:00] Yes. [23:00] Director Lassan? [23:02] Yes. [23:03] Director Santos? [23:05] Director Verella. Yes. [23:07] Chair Estrimer. Hi. Have you been in our smoke? [23:11] Really, I just have it. We'll move right along to our consent calendar. Any items to be taken out? [23:19] Any requests? [23:22] Motion to second the proof. I don't see any requests to take out items. [23:27] We've got a couple of resolutions, so we'll roll call. [23:32] Dr. Shua? Yes. Dr. Keegan? Yes. [23:38] Dr. Crennan? Yes. [23:40] Dr. Lezott? Yes. [23:42] Dr. Santos? Yes. [23:43] Dr. Verella? [23:50] Dr. Verella? Yes. [23:53] Chair Estimer. [23:54] Hi. [23:55] Do you need an animus vote? [23:57] Great. Thank you. [24:01] Is there a request? [24:03] Yeah. [24:04] I just like to make a comment that won't you [24:07] I congratulate staff on completing the Anderson Tunnel Project meeting this very important milestone. [24:16] I know I have already worked very hard. [24:19] I will also congratulate staff on meeting the major milestone on the Lord Clara Creek. [24:30] Thank you, Director Schuang. [24:33] Okay, we'll move right along to 4.2. [24:36] Approval of redistricting advisory committee nominations. [24:41] but we're already there it's 10 years later. [24:45] Why? [24:46] Little bit brutal. [24:48] Motion is second for approval. [24:51] Have you just cut? [24:53] Yes. [24:53] Mr. America made Don Rocha again. [24:56] Yes, Don. [24:57] I did have a presentation last time. [24:59] It's the interest of the bull. [25:01] To move forward with it, we had some updates as to what the next steps. I think so of the actions I needed tonight. [25:07] Yeah, go ahead, go ahead, because we may also have some questions. And now just a second. [25:12] Okay, so Director Keegan, you have a hand raise, you have a question? [25:16] I'm waiting until dawn is okay. He might, yeah, he might answer some of it. [25:20] I was going to ask him a little bit about the timeline, so he probably will cover that. [25:24] All right, thanks, Tom. Thank you, Chair. [25:25] directors here for my repeat performance. This is item 4.2 as a [25:30] measure and this is the board approval and direction for our 2021 [25:33] redistricting efforts. On this particular one, this recaps what you did in [25:40] terms of your approvals at the December 8 meeting, which you established [25:43] for several seven member redistricting advisory committee. You adopted a [25:47] criteria to guide the process and you approved the schedule and appointment [25:51] process or if you come in. And then today we are asking you to approve those nominations that you [25:58] provide it and then also approve additional recommendations guidelines and directions for the procedures [26:04] of the committee. And then finally to approve the agenda for the redistricting advisory committee's [26:10] first meeting, which is now scheduled for March 17th. This is the list that we have from all of your [26:18] appointments. I don't need to go through those, and I'm sure you're off familiar with your own appointments, [26:24] and I do want to acknowledge and thank you for the timely nominations that you've provided us to make our work a lot easier. [26:32] This one here we have all the nominees thankfully met requirements that were established, [26:40] whether it was residing the electoral district that'd be a pointing board member or being a registered voter [26:44] and understanding the time commitment needed to serve on the committee. [26:47] OGR staff has made contact with each nominee. [26:53] We are also requesting the board to adopt these additional operating guidelines for the committee. [26:58] I don't think it's necessary to reach each and every one of them. [27:01] If you have questions, of course, I'm happy to answer. [27:06] And we want to acknowledge and point out that these words, similar guidelines, [27:11] there's really only one modification. [27:13] So the ones that were adopted 10 years ago. [27:15] The last time we went through this process, and we believe that this will further encourage [27:19] and support and open fair and transparent redistribution process. [27:22] I know that is critical to the board and the public that we serve. [27:27] So following the board's actions today, these would be our next steps. [27:31] We would notify the nominees of their appointments of the committee. [27:34] We would initiate an extensive outreach effort to encourage more public participation [27:38] and partnerships with communications. [27:41] And then we would also make preparations for that first committee meeting, which is again, [27:45] as I mentioned scheduled for March 17. [27:48] Now, I want to take a moment here to shift off topic a little bit and talk a little bit [27:53] about some unforeseen factors. [27:54] We have been committed to that March 17th timeline [27:57] in terms of our first committee meeting, [28:00] but given some circumstances, [28:01] we're going to need to maybe modify that timeline. [28:04] And really, you'll see some of the reasons here [28:06] are the anomalies that were found in the census data. [28:08] And as a result, the December 31st, 2020 deadline was delayed. [28:13] And this impact of the overall date [28:15] for release to the public in terms of those census numbers. [28:18] As far as we understand it was nothing to various, [28:20] it was the Census Bureau that identified the anomalies. [28:22] it wasn't a political issue at all. [28:25] And then the county mythology ordered by President Trump was modified by the Biden administration [28:30] through an executive order, and this executive order overturned the previous direction [28:34] to not count undocumented Americans, and now they will be included in the count. [28:39] Once that census data is released, we must have waited analysis of the prison population [28:43] that is now mandated by the here in the state of California. [28:46] These delays will impact the schedule release of the data, resulting in the delay of the [28:51] start date and compressing the frequency of the meetings. As opposed to having them monthly, [28:56] they may have to do two a month or maybe even tighter than that. So we've communicated [29:00] this with our committee members already, so they understand that we may have a delay in the [29:04] starting. And please appreciate that it's a little early speculate that we feel the first meeting [29:10] we may be able to April or May. And this is speculation and point, but we're going to discuss this [29:15] with our redistricting consultant right now. We're in the middle of negotiating that contract. We expect [29:20] to be finalized in February and we'll be utilizing their expertise to suggest one that we should [29:26] start that day. What we don't want to do is call the committee together and not have an [29:30] information for them to act on. There are times of pressures just as anybody in the public [29:35] participate. So from there, I think that pretty much captures it. Now this concludes my presentations [29:44] and again, these are the actions that we're asking for your approval on tonight. Thank you for your time. [29:49] Thank you, Doc. [29:51] Start the Kegan? [29:53] Yes, I just would like to thank my fellow board members in looking at the nominees for the redistricting advice. [30:01] It's a really excellent group of people. So I think we did a very good job in terms of making our selections to have a diverse group that I hope we'll give us good results. So thank you everyone. [30:19] Any further comments, questions? [30:21] that quick me question yes here that was around last time who runs these meetings are they [30:29] staff do they elect a chair no they no no they they're a committee they're basically a [30:35] committee generally like our committees so they'll elect their own chair on officers [30:41] they'll run their own meetings the experts are staff will work with our experts you know [30:49] extracted experts to staff the committee, so they'll help them work on the legal issues, [30:59] so they'll respond to legal issues, they'll give them a good legal orientation as to their [31:04] responsibilities, then we'll have staff also orient them about the Brown Act and everything [31:11] else that they need to follow, and then they'll get working right away, the rule of this [31:17] leaves and they'll start looking at first of all, you know, population, census data, and after [31:26] that, they'll start doing analysis and they'll all be supported by contract to staff and [31:33] you know, some of our staff. [31:39] Thank you. [31:39] Thank you. [31:40] Thank you. [31:40] Thank you. [31:41] Thank you. [31:43] Absolutely. [31:45] Appreciate it. [31:46] So we do want to let you folks know that we don't anticipate the timeline in terms of the work getting to you by October, November by the final maps that that shouldn't change. [31:59] So regardless of what may happen in terms of the census data, we're committed at that timeline to get in this in front of you before the end of 2020. [32:06] We want to make sure that we have our maps and we have everything prepared for the public to for the public to involve themselves in. [32:15] help us make a final determination and then and then thereafter for people that are interested in running for office [32:23] for next year's election they'll be prepared they'll know exactly what where they live, what district and so on. [32:32] Any further questions? [32:37] Okay I'll entertain the motion then. [32:40] Staff recommendation. [32:41] I had a motion from director as well. [32:43] Oh I'm sorry I forgot we started that way. [32:46] Direct of a relevant you had a question? [32:48] No. [32:49] Just go second. [32:50] Okay. [32:51] I see you there. [32:52] Okay. [32:53] Move the second and so we'll do a roll call then. [32:58] Dr. Shua? [33:02] Yes. [33:03] Dr. Keegan? [33:04] Yes. [33:05] Dr. Kremlin? [33:06] Yes. [33:07] Dr. Lizot? [33:08] Yes. [33:09] Dr. Sanchez? [33:10] Dr. Verella? [33:12] Yes. [33:12] Chair Estromera. [33:14] Hi. [33:14] We have a unanimous vote. [33:17] Thank you. [33:17] All right. Thank you, Doug. Okay, we'll move right along to 4.3. Consider the board audit committee recommendation to receive and discuss the final audit report and the management response for the district council audit. [33:36] Good evening, Chairman. I'm going to turn this item over to the board's auditor, tap it on national and Denise. [33:43] Thank you, Darren. [33:46] Good evening, Denise. [33:49] Good morning. [34:00] Good evening, Chair, Estimera, by Chair President. [34:04] Directors, I'm Denise Kallahan, Principal Consultant at Tapet International. [34:08] Tapet International serves as the Board's Independent Fogger. [34:12] With me is Greg Mayoshi, who served as a lead auditor on the project. [34:17] I'm pleased to be here at the same team to present the results of the audit that we concluded [34:21] of the District Council's office. I want to thank first the District Council and his team for [34:26] working with us on the audit and especially Brian Hopper who served as our point of contact [34:31] throughout the audit process is timelyness in response to our request was exceptional. I do not [34:38] have a PowerPoint because I plan to keep my remarks free describing two key points of the audit. [34:44] First, customer satisfaction with the District Council's office was mixed. [34:48] value water praise the district council's office for their quality of legal advice, but there [34:54] weren't needs to improve communication on the status of work underway and the time [34:59] in us. [35:00] Which it was completed. The audit found that both valid water and the district council's office share responsibility for some of the timely necessities that we described in the audit report. [35:11] The audit found that it took longer for attorneys to complete their work when documents submitted by dividends require heavy-evident editing or when contract templates or incorrect contract templates were used. [35:25] But on the other hand, some of the attorneys' review activities extended beyond a traditional [35:30] legal review when in question scopes of work and other business decisions, which I'd [35:36] love to delay. [35:37] The second point that I want to make is that the audit report describes that updating the [35:42] district council's operating model can address these communication and time-inous concerns [35:47] and increase customer satisfaction. [35:49] On the 26th of the Auditor Report, a recommendation was made to this effect and the report [35:55] describes different strategies for consideration by the office when it develops that updated model. [36:02] The strategies include implementation of new work tracking systems and use of service level [36:07] agreements and other things. [36:10] The district council provided a response to the five recommendations in the Auditor Report. [36:15] And for this one, on updating its operating strategy, it said they would like to defer implementation of that recommendation until a new successor, [36:24] a new successor district council is in place. [36:28] And we actually agreement that. [36:30] Two other recommendations described in the auto reporting include developments of new contractual and agreement templates, new policies and procedures and criteria that would trigger early attorney engagement on specific projects. [36:43] In its response, the district council plans to address these recommendations in when it [36:49] develops criteria for its early engagement, with other valid water divisions in units, [36:54] the office, the useful support and participation of executive management throughout [36:59] value water. [37:00] A fourth recommendation is about having the district council discuss with all of you the [37:06] board about the need to use in master service agreement, use these types of contracting vehicles, [37:12] which will provide a list of all qualified law firms to do business with a district as [37:17] another procurement mechanism for legal services. It also gets the contracts and [37:23] procurement division involved in the procurement activities of the district council's office. [37:28] And it's response to this recommendation. The district council explained that in the event [37:33] that the board determines that master service agreements should be used to procure legal [37:39] services should be, it should continue to be allowed to retain legal services separately from [37:45] the master services agreement. Our recommendation is designed to add to the procurement mechanisms [37:51] available to the district council's office and not to reuse them. Our fifth and final recommendation [37:57] in the Audit Report discusses adding and audit to the annual audit work plan that evaluates [38:03] the advantages and disadvantages of implementing alternative organizational [38:08] elements for the Christmas management unit and the Workers Compensation Program. [38:13] In our report, we described the rationale for reorganizing the unit based on practices [38:19] from other public agencies where risk management and workers' compensations [38:24] programs report directly to the CEO or other administrative units. [38:28] We did not make specific suggestions on if or how the department should be organized until [38:35] a thorough analysis is done on its merit, including whether other value water divisions and units [38:41] can take on added responsibilities. [38:44] The manager of the mismatchment unit previously discussed with the board last month's [38:48] position about this recommendation, and I believe this item is up next for discussion. [38:54] I want to thank the district council for the early action reported on these various recommendations. [39:00] And always I want to thank the Board Audit Committee and the Board for support of your independent audit function. [39:06] We are presently conducting an audit of the Community Projects Resource Unit. [39:11] And I am pleased to report that my staff have received compliments about the value that these Board directed audits have on [39:19] potential to improve service delivery. So I detected shift in the perception of the [39:24] boards independent audit function which is all good. So this concludes my remarks. Thank you very [39:30] much. And I'm available for any questions. Thank you Denise. Questions? [39:42] I'd like to make a motion [39:45] to approve all the committee recommendation. [39:49] Second. [39:51] Second. [39:51] Second. [39:52] Motion. [39:52] Second. [39:56] Only on question I would have is I know that. [40:00] But we're working pretty diligently to have our new general council on board sooner rather than later. [40:10] And I wonder, I want to make sure that that person, obviously, is involved in addressing any issues that were raised by the audit. [40:23] So I hope that unless it's something that has been done immediately that we can wait for the new general council, [40:33] whether it's an inside or outside person, it'd be better to wait until then. [40:40] I think we are moving pretty expeditiously and it wouldn't be such a long way. [40:47] So we'll take a roll call Dr. Shua. Yes, Dr. Keegan. Yes, Dr. Cremany. Yes, Dr. Lazarot. Yes, Dr. Santos. [41:02] Director of Rela. [41:06] Yes. [41:06] Charistra. [41:07] Hi. [41:07] The unanimous vote. [41:10] Chair. [41:11] Yes. [41:11] I believe the timeline will work. [41:13] Particularly with the the last recommendation about the alignment of the risk management function. [41:21] Right. [41:22] So the timing on what work when the the new strategic council will be on. [41:27] Thank you. [41:28] Thank you. [41:29] Okay, we'll move right along then to 4.4. Consider the January 13th Board Order Committee [41:37] recommendation to add any valuation of the risk management functions. [41:44] Good evening, Chair Estimera. Is there a warm, dear Ontario Chief Financial Officer? [41:49] So, I'd for point four is a recommendation from the Board Order Committee as it relates to [41:53] the risk management functions, alignment, organizationally in Valley Water. And the Board [41:59] 2020 took up this discussion at their January 13 meeting and discussed options to evaluate the [42:05] risk management organizational alignment. And the committee recommends that an additional [42:09] objective be added to the planned risk management audit. The risk management audit is the [42:16] next audit in Q in the annual audit work plan that was attached to this item. Upon board approval, [42:23] the annual audit work plan would be updated to include this objective for the risk management [42:30] audit and the estimated time frame to perform this audit ranges from 9 to 15 months [42:36] estimated cost of ranges from 102,000 to 200,000 and I will pause there and see if there's any questions. [42:50] Thank [42:54] you, Chair. I have one question and one comment. The question is that the estimated costs are range of 111,000, all the way to almost 200,000. [43:10] Is it for the entire risk management performance audit or is it just for adding this evaluation of a advantage and disadvantage? [43:23] of alignment of the organization of risk management. [43:28] And thank you. I should have been clear that that would be the cost range for the total [43:31] eye, including the objective of the organizational analysis. [43:37] Okay, thank you. And I also want to say that I think it's a good idea to, for the [43:48] to looking to the advantage and disadvantage of the alignment within the organization of risk [43:57] management or function. But then I think that's where the audit should probably stop. [44:06] I think that that that that that that that evaluation will be a great information for our [44:11] VAOs, particularly CEO, to use to, if there's need for movement of the risk management to align with other functions, and I just want to be cautious that the organization structure has really the authority that the board delegate to the VAOs to determine what's the best way to structure the organization to meet all kinds of challenges. [44:40] So I just want you to see that up front. [44:45] Dr. Keegan. [44:47] Dr. Keegan? [44:49] Yes, thank you. [44:51] Good comments. [44:52] Dr. Shua and Darren, you can jump in and add if you choose to. [44:58] I wanted the things about this. [45:00] We discussed about risk management functions is they're not always within a discrete part of an organization. Sometimes there's [45:07] sliced and diced in different components or elsewhere. So I think what we'd be looking at is, here's some [45:13] opportunities, not necessarily let's move this function from one part of the organization to another, [45:19] but really giving executive staff the tools that could be helpful in terms of making potential changes [45:28] And that would be a good answer. [45:30] Thank you, Director Keith. [45:35] Anyone else? [45:40] So we'll be saying that this audit in particular [45:45] by itself is related to the 101,000 to 200,000 figure. [45:54] Correct. [45:55] With the addition of the cost estimate, [45:58] in other words, the cost estimate would be a little lower [46:00] without adding that objective. [46:02] Yeah, but that's a pretty high. I don't know about. [46:11] Yeah, that's, that's a pretty expensive audit. [46:17] Is it, I mean, is it going to take that much? I could tell you, I could tell you what's probably best to do. [46:25] Compare, can compare this number with how much is for the district council office all day, so give us a reference. [46:38] Perhaps the New Zealand could chime in on on on the cost. [46:45] Questions, you know, in general, from my perspective, the audits are typically right around in the, in the 150, 120, 150,000 dollar range for each audit. [46:54] But Denise can probably add a little more to that. [46:58] Right, their range is based on if you went out to bid on the project. [47:04] So we wanted to provide at least a minimum and a maximum. [47:07] So you can expect the audit depending on the number of firms. [47:11] If you go out to bid to submit cost estimates in the range of about 100 to 200,000, [47:17] to do a comprehensive review of the risk management unit [47:22] with the organizational analysis. [47:28] So Darren is right on. [47:29] They typically, I would expect, probably, [47:33] you'll get a lot of bids around the $150,000 range. [47:38] I put an minimum bid because there are some firms [47:41] that have a lot of experience with the risk management [47:43] and so they'll come in with that working knowledge. [47:46] So that's our best estimate. [47:55] Chair? [47:56] Yes. [47:56] Third requirement. [47:58] Yeah, I agree with you. [47:59] That's a lot of money. [48:00] Maybe we just either like to see a decide or just do it. [48:06] You know, I think we know what the answer is here. [48:10] We don't want to have one of these. [48:12] We spend so much time in analysis paralysis. [48:15] We don't do it. [48:16] I think we've seen some of the positives and negatives. [48:19] So, I'd like to know if the rest of the more things on that. [48:25] Three chair? [48:26] Yes, third. [48:27] What do we just said, a cat? [48:29] The 150. [48:31] A range from 100,000 to 150. [48:33] That way, followed between. [48:35] Can we do that? [48:37] You can do whatever we want, right? [48:39] That's right. [48:39] Yeah, we can do that. [48:40] Directed to the bottom. [48:42] Third to the Zat? [48:43] Yeah. [48:47] could what has the last couple of full blown on its cost like the [48:52] the district council audit etc. I think someone said they're probably around [48:56] the same range. [49:01] I don't have that information at my fingertips and not [49:05] sure if Denise does. Yeah I don't I do know that for the district council's [49:11] office that we did write off his significant amount of money so he [49:15] to total all of the cost, you'll probably, it'll be around probably 140,000, 150,000 [49:22] range. [49:23] And so, are much less. [49:27] So the risk management audit has been part of the, that we were going to do that. [49:34] We're just adding this extra thing to look at the question that the regard to district [49:40] So, you know, I don't think it's simply a matter of, you know, just pick and choose and read [49:48] that you're going to do a full flow of risk management, organizational, you know, alignment [49:53] to study on it for, for, for what we're not. [49:56] And, you know, it's been on, on the agenda for the Audit committee. [50:00] I mean, I think that's a decision that needs to be done. We need to do it and we need to help. [50:05] But it seems like it's in the ballpark of some of the other audits that we've done. [50:12] Yes. [50:15] Thank you. [50:16] Thank you, Mr. Chair. [50:18] Yeah. I think that director Kremlin has a suggestion that maybe our CEO could take a look at it, [50:23] and look at the areas that part of that risk management, [50:26] It may be can cut some of the costs and get more out of it in certain areas, and I think that's what something we should give input before even putting a cap or saying this is what it is because that just gives other items that come up later on [50:39] We're going to say it's 150 or 200 grand and I don't think this may not be the case. I think we should have the CEO way in this and find out what's pertinent [50:47] Thank you. [50:50] Thank you. [50:51] Thank you. [50:51] Thank you. [50:51] So, Director Kremlin and Director Santos forgive me if I misinterpret what you mean. [50:59] The way I read the agenda memo is that the majority of this audit is for a performance [51:06] audit of the risk management and then out of the other result of the district councils [51:16] audit, auditors recommending adding a piece to the overall performance audit, which is looking [51:25] at the alignment of organization structure in other parts of the organization. [51:32] So if both of you are saying that that just give it to the CEO, look at the organization [51:37] structure, and not doing the performance audit, and that will be a change to our [51:43] Yeah, switching. So the majority of it is the performance audit. And earlier that [51:49] I'll remember the meeting that we have to review the insurance management and all that. [52:01] So performance management is really the majority of the work the way I reach such an opportunity. [52:06] Well, yeah. Well, thank you. Thank you for that clarification. [52:10] I think that makes a lot of sense, not, not understand why, why it causes much as it does. [52:16] See, okay, I wonder why. [52:18] It's basically a performance audit. [52:20] Yeah. [52:21] Not the function. [52:22] And then we're talking about adding, adding, adding this kind of analysis of where it should go, [52:30] if it should go elsewhere in the organization. [52:33] Yeah. [52:33] So that kind of... [52:34] We're portions of it, though, elsewhere. [52:36] Yeah. [52:37] to answer that question right yeah to do an analysis of what to do see you [52:44] calendar would like to speak yes see you yes good evening [52:51] remember members of the board to listen to the discussion I think I was [52:56] leaning towards exactly where I'd like to show was immediately talking I think [53:00] you do have an audit in your hand that just made some recommendations as it [53:04] to risk management. If I can make a recommendation, maybe you delay the action on the performance [53:11] audit around the risk and then you allow for me to work with the next board of pointed [53:16] officer as it relates to what came in from the immediate last audit, we do also have an auditor [53:22] on stat and then make a determination of what next actions would occur. If indeed, the risk management [53:28] function does move into the area of the administration. We also do have auditors which are [53:34] and it's finance that we can try to figure out what are the areas that we probably want to take on and looking at a future on it. [53:41] So if I can make that recommendation, I think that maybe something that could probably be right in the middle and still would be able to look at where the placement of the office should be and I could live in conjunction with the incoming board appointed officer council when they do arrive. [53:58] Okay, [54:02] for me, that seems to make more sense, [54:05] but what are one of the other folks think? [54:07] I think we really, we're onto something, I think the committee's right about having to do a, needing to do a performance audit. [54:17] Yeah. [54:17] The figure out exactly what fits best for us. [54:20] I will recommend, I guess I'll make a motion, that continue with the current board, [54:30] approved audit, committee work plan, to do the performance audit for the risk management [54:37] function and then delegate to CEO and the new district council to look at the [54:52] If there's a need, then you can always go back to the audit. [54:55] You can always refer to the audit. [54:57] You could even refer it back. [55:00] To the audit committee. Is there a second? [55:06] That was a motion. So, okay, there's a second. Hey, discussion for the discussion. [55:14] Okay, I think that a work. Those two BIOs can always, in fact, you know, clarify exactly what we want to look at and then and then still refer back to the audit committee. So, okay, we'll do a roll call on the motion. [55:32] Dr. Shua, Director Keegan, Director Cramman, Director of the Zodd, Director of the Zodd, Director [55:40] Santos, Director of Rela, Chair Estimar, I, [55:45] Fabian Nassau, great. [55:47] We're moving right along then to 4.5, [55:53] consider the December 16 Board Order Committee [55:55] recommendations to have tap international conduct in the next try annual [56:00] risk assessment that is due by October 2021. Prior to the expiration on June 30th of the [56:11] of their contract. [56:16] So I believe we'll request, well, I'll let the TIG and explain it. [56:27] Is that right to KIGA? [56:28] Yes, thank you. [56:31] So a lot of this is based on the time that it's going to take in terms of the recruitment process. [56:39] So there's an interest in moving forward and the audit committee felt that this would be the most expeditious way to do that. [56:48] But there are, you know, other options, it certainly could be deferred until we go through that recruitment process and look at [57:00] answering into a new board independent auditing services agreement. [57:04] So, it's really at the discretion of the board. [57:08] I think that our feeling was that it was important to be timely, [57:14] and that there was a certain efficiency in having someone who had already conducted a few audits for us. [57:21] But again, it's at the discretion of the board. [57:29] Okay. [57:29] But thank you. [57:31] Discussion? [57:34] Any requests? [57:36] They're at the shoe. [57:38] I think this is a great recommendation from the other committee, so that we can move things. [57:45] just keep moving. So I'd like to make a motion to approve all the committee recommendation. [57:55] Here's a second. All right, motion second. So we'll make sure then that the plan will be completed before the expiration of the present contract. [58:07] All right, okay, good. All right, I think it makes a lot of sense like the right Tiggins said that we have someone that's already done it [58:14] And it's familiar and understands what's going on, so now [58:17] So we have motion the second any questions? [58:23] Okay, we've got a roll call then. Please. Dr. Shua [58:27] Director Kigan [58:29] Yes, Director Cramon [58:33] Yes, Director the Zot. Yes, Director Santos. Director Verella [58:38] Yes. Chair, Mr. Mayor. [58:40] Aye. [58:40] We have unanimous vote. [58:42] Thank you. [58:44] Okay, we've got a 4.6 board committee reports. [58:53] We have all the committee reports and I think we also were. [58:58] Yeah, we have. [58:58] We have. [59:01] Follow the committee reports. [59:03] Is this any questions on any of the reports? [59:07] I'm Director, Mr. Mayor. [59:08] If I just highlight the. [59:10] Mr. Planning and Operations Committee meeting since it was our first meeting as the new committee. [59:16] Yes, I would take you in. I just wanted to thank staff for their hard work in terms of preparing [59:23] a history of the phase program adaptation and progress and it was a great opportunity to [59:31] re-educate those of us on the committee as well as members of the public as to where we've been [59:38] the accomplished movements we've made and how we move forward. So I think all the committee members [59:44] We're appreciative of staff's effort and look forward to greater engagement with the external community. [59:54] Thank you, Director Kizyan, absolutely correct. [59:56] Audited the meeting, it was excellent. [59:59] Yeah, great. [1:00:00] Okay, orientation and staff was really good to answer questions and stuff. So it was really a good meeting. Also was the closed meeting, but you know, the open meeting that you talked about was excellent. Any anything further questions, discussion? [1:00:15] Okay, we'll move right along then to 4.7, propose a future board agenda items if there be any. [1:00:23] I don't see any hands raised or anybody moving to make any recommendations. [1:00:30] We've got plenty, so we might have even more tomorrow. [1:00:36] Okay, so we'll move right along then to, we did 5.1. [1:00:42] So we're at water sheds. [1:00:45] So we'll go to 6.1. [1:00:50] Approval of amendment number 1 to this agreement [1:00:54] on geotech engineering services? [1:01:00] Good evening. [1:01:01] We're shall-point Deputy Operating Officer of Watershed Design and Construction. [1:01:05] Good evening, we're shall. [1:01:10] Here to please request recommendation to approve the amendment number one to [1:01:15] implement with the on-hog geotech for services with the first consultant increasing [1:01:23] the amount by 750,000, or not total not to the city at 1.75 million, and put the second [1:01:30] agreement with Calming Union to increase that amount as well by 750,000, but also not to [1:01:38] see total 1.75 million. Both these on-calls are used regularly by water sheds and [1:01:44] to the CFP Capone Agreement program project and they've actually been utilized quite a bit [1:01:52] for the Anderson of the Florida Compliance Project as to the need why we are requesting these [1:01:58] amendments. [1:01:59] Are my stand ready to answer any questions to be having me? [1:02:03] Thank you for the show questions [1:02:07] on the Tane Motion. [1:02:11] Motion is secret approval. [1:02:14] Who is secret? [1:02:15] Yes. [1:02:16] Thank you. [1:02:16] We've got a motion in a second. [1:02:22] Director Shua? Yes. Director Keegan? Yes. Director Kramin? Yes. Director the Zod? Yes. [1:02:32] Director Santos? Yes. Director Verella? Yes. Chair Estimera? Aye. We have a unanimous vote? [1:02:40] Thank you. We'll move right along the 6.2 authorizes Chief Executive Officer Executive Master Agreement with the City of Melpeetus. [1:02:48] All [1:02:52] right, motion is second. [1:02:57] No, no, no. [1:02:58] Motion is second. [1:03:02] Is the one this one? [1:03:03] Is also you retail? [1:03:05] Yes, it is. [1:03:06] I wish I did not. [1:03:07] There's any questions on the screen. [1:03:09] Thank you. [1:03:10] I'm sorry. [1:03:10] I'm sorry. [1:03:13] I'm sorry. [1:03:15] I'm sorry. [1:03:16] I'm sorry. [1:03:18] I'm sorry. [1:03:19] Questions? [1:03:22] Okay. [1:03:22] We have a local. [1:03:24] Thank you so. [1:03:26] Director Shua? [1:03:28] Yes. [1:03:29] Director Keegan. [1:03:33] Director Creman? [1:03:34] Yes. [1:03:35] Director the Zot. [1:03:37] Yes. [1:03:37] Director Santas. [1:03:38] Director Verella? [1:03:40] Yes. [1:03:40] Chair Estimera. [1:03:41] All right. [1:03:42] You're a Nama's vote? [1:03:46] Yes. [1:03:55] Thank you, Mr. Chair. [1:03:57] I was in conversation with the city manager and in our CEO and I understand both agencies are just working real well together. [1:04:05] So I just want to straight to turn this challenges. [1:04:07] Thank you for both sides really working together. [1:04:09] Thank you. [1:04:11] Thank you. [1:04:12] That's true. [1:04:12] The chair. [1:04:13] Also that Mr. Not Newyon had spent significant amount of time. [1:04:17] Yes. [1:04:18] He wanted to get this thing done before he retired. [1:04:21] So maybe someone reached out. [1:04:24] Maybe you can knock a cock. [1:04:25] Tell me. [1:04:26] Have that. [1:04:27] Does that agreement was approved by the board today? [1:04:29] Yeah. [1:04:30] Tell him was still waiting for him to show up to work. [1:04:33] I don't know where he is. [1:04:36] yeah absolutely but yeah do call him final one he hasn't been workly was still looking [1:04:44] for right number seven assisted chief executive officer there's nothing on the external [1:04:53] there's CEO, 9.1 Valley World Cup rehearsal, and you'll find it. [1:05:00] This is a report for the fiscal year, ending June 30, 2020. [1:05:07] There it? [1:05:08] Yeah, it's a good evening. Chair, Mr. Mayor, Members of the Board. [1:05:11] Thank you. [1:05:11] Chair, Chair, Chair, Chair, Chair, Chair, Chief National Officer. [1:05:13] Item 9.1 is on the fiscal year 2020 Comprehensive Bank of Natural Report, [1:05:19] or CAFER for short. [1:05:20] And the staff recommendation is for the Board to accept the FY20 CAFER. [1:05:25] I would like to take a moment to thank Director Kremlin for his investment in reviewing [1:05:29] and drafts of this document, and for his many excellent suggestions, which I believe make this [1:05:34] report. [1:05:35] Monterey Bustanet ever has been, and I did also want to mention one change to this year's [1:05:41] report that I want to make sure that the board was aware of. [1:05:44] This year's report recognizes water inventory as an asset. [1:05:49] This is a policy issue that was discussed by the board out of committee and the committee [1:05:59] for transparency purposes, there is no accounting requirement to do so some water agencies across the [1:06:05] state reflect water inventory as an asset and some do not. The net effect of doing this [1:06:12] is that the assets were increased by $134 million for FY20, which represents the value of water [1:06:18] stored in the semi-traffic groundwater basin in current county, as well as value water's local [1:06:25] reservoirs. And so with that, I stand over for any questions. [1:06:28] Great. Thank you, Darren. [1:06:30] The report. Questions? [1:06:37] OK, as usual, great report. [1:06:41] Comprehensive report, very clear. [1:06:43] Thank you, Darren. [1:06:45] We'll move right along then to 9.2. [1:06:49] See you. [1:06:50] Mr. Chair, I'm sorry. [1:06:51] 9.1, the board needs to accept the country [1:06:53] comprehensive report. [1:06:54] Oh, sorry. [1:06:55] I'll make a motion to accept. [1:06:57] All right. [1:06:58] We've got a motion in the second. Sorry about that. Okay, roll, go. [1:07:03] Director, sorry. Director Shua. Oh, someone. Oh, yeah. Oh, sorry. Sorry about that. Sorry about that. [1:07:15] Yes, Mr. Here. I can maybe I'm the next item. [1:07:27] I'm going to the point nine points. Thank you, Mr. [1:07:33] Mr. Chair. Mr. Herald wants to speak on the next item. Nine points. [1:07:40] Yeah, okay, 9.2. Thank you. Hang on just a minute. Mr. Harris, we'll just do the vote. Then we'll call you up. [1:07:47] I have by the way, I've read your letter and agree with it and I have the same question. So hang on. [1:07:54] Okay, roll call me one. Yeah, the vote for 9.1. [1:07:58] Yes. Director Shua? Yes. Director Keegan? Yes. Director Kremlin? [1:08:05] Oh, sorry. He did note. He did something. [1:08:08] know that he was stepping out for a second. Probably went to heat up a bottle or something. [1:08:13] Director of the thought? [1:08:13] Change the diapers. [1:08:15] Director Santos. Director Braula. [1:08:18] Yes. [1:08:18] Chair Estrimer. [1:08:19] Aye. [1:08:21] Okay, we'll get that right. The criminals vote next. [1:08:24] Okay, 9.2. [1:08:28] C.O. and a cheese report. [1:08:31] Mr. Hare? [1:08:32] Yes. [1:08:33] Yes. You're going to address us now. [1:08:35] Okay, thank you. [1:08:37] Chair, Esra Merri, members of the board. [1:08:39] My name is Chair Frey here, and for those who don't know me, [1:08:42] and I've lived down town next to Toyota Creek [1:08:45] for the last 30, 40 years, and I want to wish to comment [1:08:49] on the stream Mainland Street Fort, [1:08:50] which is an attachment to item 92. [1:08:54] According to the water districts, one water plan, [1:08:57] belly water is focused on water supply, environmental stewardship, [1:09:01] and flood protection. [1:09:02] You recently convinced the voters to approve [1:09:04] permanent extension of the parcel tax to provide safe clean water and flood protection. [1:09:10] But as you know, Anderson Reservoir, the largest reservoir in the county, is out of operation [1:09:15] for the next 10 years. This means the largest watershed in the county will now drain without [1:09:20] impound through Toyota Creek. It was seem to me that in light of these facts that we should [1:09:26] be spending more attention on Toyota Creek. The stream maintenance report details significant [1:09:32] maintenance efforts by staff in terms of sediment removal, bank protection, and habitat protection [1:09:38] projects in 17 separate creeks during the 2020 season. Yet there is no mention of any work [1:09:47] in clearly creek. Maybe I was missing something so I asked staff why. They initially responded, [1:09:53] well it was probably because of staffing problems due to COVID and then that and also because [1:09:59] the district building. [1:10:18] Thank you, [1:10:25] Mr. Chair. [1:10:29] Can we have someone answer those? I have the same question by the way. [1:10:33] Good evening, Sheriff's from our Recalner again CEO. [1:10:36] Let's go ahead and start the CEO report. [1:10:38] I'm going to ask for Chiefs Tiffets. [1:10:41] I can Chief Tiffets to respond to that portion. [1:10:44] And then we will go and take it from the top from there. [1:10:47] So Chiefs of it. [1:10:48] Thank you. [1:10:50] Yes, thank you CEO calendar. [1:10:52] Yes, I can respond to the items on the S&P report. [1:10:57] Their stream maintenance report. [1:10:58] And those are items that we conduct in maintaining [1:11:03] the facilities that we have constructed for flood protection and maintaining those of the [1:11:08] the function as they were designed and and so of those three have mostly those [1:11:13] works recorded on or on the bank repair and the sentiment removal work although we do [1:11:18] other minor maintenance projects. The vegetation work is also listed there and I think [1:11:24] It says there's three hundred and eighty vegetation projects. [1:11:28] Of those, there were 19 that were actually conducted in [1:11:34] the cavity creek that were related to the flow commands. [1:11:38] And of those were largely down the lower reaches north [1:11:42] of Montague expressway. [1:11:45] And those are in the areas where we, [1:11:48] where valley water owns property. [1:11:50] The other in comparison, while it would be a river, had 24 projects, [1:11:56] teams, weeks, seven, August, eight. [1:11:59] So we continue to do that work throughout the valley. [1:12:04] In addition, in preparation for the work for Anderson, [1:12:08] we do have work that will be protected work that will be constructed [1:12:12] on County Creek during through that area of concern. [1:12:16] So, hopefully that addresses those questions that are not in here to answer any further. [1:12:24] Follow up questions. [1:12:26] Thank you. [1:12:26] So, to the chair, I don't know if there's any kind of disorder further question, [1:12:30] that you have a series of other reports from our system CO and other chiefs. [1:12:34] I'm going to start off with Assistant CEO Richard Sin, [1:12:38] so we can provide a few updates. [1:12:40] So, Melanie, I'll turn over you. [1:12:42] All right, yes, thank you, CEO. [1:12:44] calendar, so I'm going to start off with a bit of good news, and that is last Friday, January [1:12:49] 22nd, the US Army Corps actually released for solicitation, reaches one-two-in-three of [1:12:56] the shoreline project. This is the reaches of the project that goes from the Alficell, Marina, [1:13:02] to the Dom Edwards Center. This is a project that went out to bed about a year ago, if you [1:13:07] would call the Bids came into high and kind of scrapped it in the last year to try to bring [1:13:13] cost down and finally through a lot of current work that come to a point where we believe we can [1:13:20] hopefully get within the cost estimate of 80 million, which is roughly the cost estimate of [1:13:25] the project that is expected to bid or expected to open around mid-March. And if all those wealth [1:13:32] construction will begin the song on that bridge. And then the next item we are having doing a [1:13:39] of preparations for this upcoming storm that is beginning right as we speak. [1:13:44] And I wanted to let staff give a brief update to the board of some of the preparations [1:13:49] we've been doing beginning with Chief Operating Office of Tributes. [1:13:57] Thank you. [1:13:58] I'll give you a report out on the correct weather forecast for expecting an intense but short [1:14:06] stormy that that's predicted to last from midnight tonight and continuing on until Thursday [1:14:11] me, precipitation totals for that adventure, and be about two to two and a half inches in the [1:14:16] valley floor, up to eight inches in the mountains. And we also expect in some very high winds, [1:14:23] up to 40, 50 miles an hour in the valley floor. The forecast for the National Weather Service [1:14:30] forecast for flooding is for flooding on small streams and strong rains, which may include [1:14:34] Ross Creek, one with your River at Elman, and perhaps West Side, little yogas. [1:14:40] We don't expect any of the reservoirs to still. [1:14:43] So our emergency operations center will be activated virtually tonight at 1130 at a level [1:14:48] free monitoring. [1:14:50] The number of staff will be ready in the event that the EOC operations need to be expanded, so it will [1:14:55] be standing by. [1:14:56] And our flood information teams will need to be deployed and about. [1:15:00] I want to clock this morning. Actually, tomorrow morning, sorry. Field staff are also standing by to respond. [1:15:08] We've looked at our field, our pure noses and trash rats, our hotspots. They've been checked in the debris has been removed. [1:15:16] Our sandbag locations are all stopped. And actually, an extra sandbag station was established at the palm more far from your raw screen. [1:15:26] The storm planning team has participated in a number of operational area calls and you see the national weather service updates. [1:15:34] And an other county and the teams have also been contacted by our emergency service staff. [1:15:41] Staff is also met with the San Francisco multi-agency team and the city of San Jose in accordance with our joint emergency action plan. [1:15:48] You know, just a couple of items of the city of San Jose will be doing. [1:15:54] They have reached out to the homeless accountment areas, along several of the major creeks. [1:15:58] The planning to open up an evacuation center if needed at the Canada Community Center. [1:16:03] And have sent out SCC alerts to the Rossi and Guadalupe areas or have a will. [1:16:10] And they will be setting up a field information field inspection teams that will go out to the starting of midnight. [1:16:18] And then I'd also like to turn this over to Aaron and he has any updates for regarding the reservoirs and to Rachel if she has any updates on the communications. [1:16:30] Mr. Chair, Director of the Zodd has a question. [1:16:33] Yes, Director of the Zodd. [1:16:35] So, under our EAP, who was responsible for sending out notices of potential for flash flooding to tour neighborhoods? [1:16:47] I got something from the city of San Jose, [1:16:50] about a look near Ross Creek. [1:16:52] It's just a part of their, [1:16:53] they sent it out, that's what like the officials. [1:16:56] And then District 6 Councilwoman sent out something, [1:16:59] but nothing came from District 9 Councilwoman [1:17:01] who's District it is. [1:17:05] So what is, what is, like I said, [1:17:08] as part of the EAP, who's responsible for telling [1:17:13] the constituents, our joint constituents, [1:17:16] it's where they can get sandbagged and that there's a visit to the tentative of blood. [1:17:22] Yeah, that would be a responsibility of the city to take on those tasks. [1:17:28] Okay, because I've been the last year, we sent out a next door message to the Ross Creek area about where they could find sandbags. [1:17:42] You know, we can send out no notices regarding sandbags, but it's really the city's responsibility for those alerts and for any evacuation notices. [1:17:53] Well I think, you know, I know we're all working together. [1:17:57] I just want to make sure that, you know, people are really getting the message about sandbags because, you know, that area around Sherry and Ross is really, really vulnerable. [1:18:08] Yes, and perhaps Rachel can cover that and tell me more. [1:18:12] Okay. [1:18:12] Thank you. [1:18:16] Dr. Keegan, have a question. [1:18:17] Dr. Keegan. [1:18:20] So I think he directs your little thought, because I have very similar questions. [1:18:23] In fact, like for the email, I received from the council member to the CEO. [1:18:30] And so I got a county alert, and I also got the notification from the city of San Jose. [1:18:35] And I think we need to really be looking at this closely to make sure that it, this works smoothly. [1:18:47] I was a little surprised that my presentation came from the city of San Jose. [1:18:53] And I know that staff is working on something more substantive. [1:18:56] So it's just the devils and the details and we don't want to be in a situation. I think, you know, none of us where [1:19:08] Where when agency maybe doesn't do another agency expect so I don't want to be over the pessimistic [1:19:14] I want to be optimistic and and I'm I'm looking forward to [1:19:19] As smooth roll out of all this. So thank you [1:19:22] There it's a cremine [1:19:25] Yeah, I just kind of following up on those that being a thought. [1:19:30] Here we checked at the sandbag locations that there's shovels there because there was, you know, in the past. [1:19:41] We've been told there's no shovels. [1:19:46] Yeah, I've provided plastic shovels or scoops in the past, but they tend to disappear. [1:19:54] So I don't believe what we have stopped with shovels there. [1:19:57] Well, let's, I would direct, ask the CEO. [1:20:31] Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Chair. [1:20:33] Richard Gibson, Chief of External Affairs, wanted to address definitely something to be out of some of the questions that Director Lizot and Director Keegan raised as well. [1:20:40] So to begin earlier this week in the days leading up to the storm, we posted multiple social media posts on both Facebook and Twitter, [1:20:47] highlighting sandbake locations, how to report a creep blockage, [1:20:51] flood preparedness messaging, leading up to two this event, which we knew was going to be significant. [1:20:55] against. We also just sent a next door closed out, Tony White, under chair, extra mirror signature [1:21:00] on the activation of Vela Lerz EOC, for the storm, as well as the same storm, correct [1:21:05] tips. Again, hammering on the sanded locations. There was actually a small notation in [1:21:10] a tube to try to be prepared and bring your own shovel, just in case you have to shovel [1:21:14] your own, but I know that's going to be followed up on separately now as well, in relation [1:21:19] to correct performance of vice-trap performance. And then step is also sent out a post to tens [1:21:24] thousands of folks and a large variety of stakeholder groups through constant contacts on the [1:21:29] activation of Delaware's EOC with those same tips. And again, really getting reiterating [1:21:34] the sand big locations, having a preferred creep blockages, et cetera, and just generally [1:21:37] staying safe. And what to do before during any after storm. In addition, we sent an all-employed [1:21:44] communication set for noon on the flood preparedness resources for staff to plan and prepare ahead of [1:21:48] the storm. And updated the Valley Water Emergency Banner on our website regarding the storm monitoring [1:21:53] and resources on the emergency web page. [1:21:56] I failed to note too that we also do point two, [1:21:58] our stream gauge network so that folks can get [1:22:01] real-time conditions on streams [1:22:02] at Creek Systems near their homes. [1:22:04] And then now that the EOC has been activated for the storm, [1:22:07] the EOC PIO has been and will continue to coordinate very closely [1:22:11] with city of San Jose's EOC PIO. [1:22:14] We got the name just a few hours of go [1:22:16] of who to coordinate with in terms of messaging [1:22:18] and outreach on that and as well. [1:22:20] So we will continue updating the communications [1:22:22] across all of our platforms as the storm develops, and we'll certainly, of course, be starting [1:22:27] our reign of board updates as well in the seat room. [1:22:32] All right, Mr. Baker, should I have anything to add? [1:22:35] Yes, thank you. [1:22:36] So, we've got, I want us ready to resume our operations, using the latest forecast, we have [1:22:40] our resume operations plans in place, our 24-7 Robb Center is keyed in with the EOC, which [1:22:45] is opening later tonight, or yeah, later tonight, as you've heard at 1130, we have staff [1:22:50] available on call to address any reservoir operations issues and our reservoirs have significant [1:22:55] storage available and we do not expect any to spill tonight or tomorrow. [1:22:59] Allotted reservoir may fill over the next couple of days and could slightly spill but no flooding [1:23:03] is expected, allotted as a small reservoir that spills most years. [1:23:08] In addition, we are also some high-winded expected over the next couple of days and valley waters [1:23:12] all prepared for power issues that may occur as a result of these high-wind events or [1:23:17] other things that happen. So we've been testing our generators and making sure all those [1:23:21] transfer switches and everything else is ready. And so for that I stand open for any questions [1:23:26] for what do you tell the operations? [1:23:30] Thank you. [1:23:31] And so I believe that's a pretty comprehensive report on everything that we're doing not only [1:23:36] the utility, the EOC as well as water sheds with will, to make sure that we are looking [1:23:42] to make sure that we have scoops or some kind of shovels at the sites for the future. [1:23:49] I do know we do have shovels in our storage and so the warehouse so maybe we can ensure that [1:23:55] we are providing that level of support. We do know that the shovels do disappear so hopefully [1:23:59] what's the messaging that we provided that make sure that they bring their own that will be [1:24:03] able to provide a level of service expected from the community. I'm going to go on to Mr. [1:24:10] This is, did you have anything further that you wanted to add on Permanente? [1:24:16] I guess I didn't. Thank you, Chief. [1:24:18] Let's see you, Connor. Yes, I'm Permanente Creek. I just wanted to be forcing good news on that [1:24:24] and that is that the Calbee Park Detention Basin has been awarded the 2021 American Council [1:24:30] of Engineering Companies of California, Engineering Excellence, Merit Award. This will [1:24:36] Award recognizes the attention based on this appropriate work project that demonstrates excellence [1:24:42] in its planning, design, and construction and coordinated efforts between various stakeholders [1:24:46] to complete the project. And those made in the award about what are key within the structured [1:24:51] West and Motnikong and the award ceremony celebration for that will be held virtually on [1:24:58] February 4th [1:25:05] All right, and then finally, I'm going to go back to Ms. Gibson for extortal affairs on this. [1:25:11] Thank you, Senator. A couple of quick items. First, the Board has the monthly Office of Government Relations [1:25:16] one patron for you, just one quick highlight from that. [1:25:19] The Assembly for Robert Reedus has, especially, [1:25:21] introduced the CARE down Anderson-Gandell. [1:25:24] This is definitely Bill 271, [1:25:25] the board's former bill. [1:25:27] And we've just found out that it will be for these first policy committee in March or April, [1:25:31] and first we'll keep the board of prizes, [1:25:32] as we don't make this way, [1:25:33] and that will be the same process. [1:25:35] And then a bit of good news as well. [1:25:36] At their last meeting in California, Water Commission, [1:25:39] a Board of the Chica was a more extensive project, [1:25:41] an additional $12 million to account for inflation costs. [1:25:44] They also put into create a screen process to a more than $64 million to new projects. [1:25:50] So staff is reviewing which value-water projects may be eligible for that fully including [1:25:54] ends in the motion to keep the point of time and take. [1:25:59] And thank you, Mr. Chairman. [1:26:00] I think that wraps up all of our reports for tomorrow. [1:26:02] Unless there's any questions and any reports of it, right? [1:26:05] Thank you. [1:26:06] Thanks, Ray. [1:26:08] All right. [1:26:08] We'll move right along then directly to board member reports. [1:26:13] We'll start with Director Morella. [1:26:17] Thank you, Chair. [1:26:18] Mayor. [1:26:18] So, had several meetings in the last couple of weeks. [1:26:22] Have the opportunity to meet with really elected in South County. [1:26:25] Council member, City of Oregon, Yellow, Gina Borgielli. [1:26:29] Mayor Marie Blankley of Gilroy. [1:26:32] And City Council member, Gilroy, Zachary Hilton. [1:26:36] Bring them up to speed as to what we're doing and give them an orientation on the [1:26:40] water issues in South County of their districts. Also, had a meeting with the Assembly's [1:26:48] Dr. Mendoza Water Authority. We had a more good health to one as a presentation. Chris [1:26:58] Hanks and I, again, presentation on Andrews Dam and Upper Yoggers for Attention Project [1:27:05] in this region. Let's see and there's pretty much it. Thank you. [1:27:13] Third, the KIGA. [1:27:16] Okay, many meetings since our last board meeting, the January [1:27:23] Board Audit Committee meeting, the All-Ballied Water Town Home Meeting, the Screen Planning [1:27:30] in Operations Committee, Formally Fests meeting, [1:27:35] and a briefing on does with advance, the [1:27:41] Recycle Water Committee meeting, Special Board meeting, [1:27:50] let's see, [1:27:55] Director of the Zodonite [1:27:56] to the Center for Valley and Habitat implementation plan meeting and I had a DCA stakeholder engagement committee shares briefing prior to our next meeting and had met with the CEO and had a board policy and planning committee meeting. [1:28:19] So, January is going to be a piece of art. [1:28:23] Thank you. [1:28:24] Third, the Santos. [1:28:29] Thank you, Mr. Chair. [1:28:31] On a note to the CEO and to my colleagues, [1:28:34] when it comes to sandbags and we've been through this before, [1:28:37] and I totally understand the ceiling of shovels and whatever have you. [1:28:40] And it is a problem. [1:28:42] But to me, I've been through the floods and been through all this [1:28:45] and all the different locations. [1:28:47] And if the bags are not full, it's really tough. [1:28:50] Because the shovel will trick and then run down somewhere [1:28:53] there's a difficult exam. So the more full sign bags we can have, be more appreciative. [1:28:58] And going back to that, I just met with the CEO along with Tony and I think Gary [1:29:02] came on later. The CEO has a attachment to our meeting, has the agenda. And next to that, [1:29:09] had all the locations of all the sign bags of what we're doing so on. So if our colleagues [1:29:14] need more, I have no problem. I received some stuff that I'm ill about the water district. [1:29:18] I also had a briefing with suit-tippets, Chief Ferguson, and another staff member that my [1:29:25] Alex someone on Coyote and so on about, we're doing everything we can, but that we're [1:29:30] still having problems with owners who don't grant us permission to help with the maintenance. [1:29:35] So that's a major issue. [1:29:38] And Mr. Harris, if you're listening, you can always call Director Kigan, Mr. Mayor of [1:29:42] myself, and if there's not enough or something, give us a call, we'll speed things up, but [1:29:46] we've been briefed and we're doing maintenance work in Kyri Kachiniumy. [1:29:51] So there's nothing new we had a Delta Madonna meeting and of course the various [1:29:54] citizens advisory and with that I want to add also a sad and good news is Jerry D. La Piere. [1:30:00] Redra retired and had a little ceremony for him, so the best jerry in his family. Thank you. Thank you. [1:30:07] The work goes on. [1:30:13] So I had several meetings, joint meetings with the CEO and Director Keegan, staff briefing on Rancho San Antonio, [1:30:21] several board meetings, the board audit committee, the Sponk, slash base committee, [1:30:26] We saw a water committee, I wanted it, [1:30:30] funded the flood preparation workshop, [1:30:33] had a staff briefing on the can of Camden Brook Pods [1:30:37] and what the shutdown of Central Pipeline will do. [1:30:40] The BPPC meeting and the HCP joint board meeting. [1:30:46] Thank you. [1:30:48] Good to see you. [1:30:50] Thank you chair. [1:30:52] Since my last report at our regular meeting, [1:30:55] I actually did not have that many meetings, that's a welcome change for you. [1:31:03] So my head says, are you going to be okay? [1:31:06] What are you doing? [1:31:11] I had a, I met with the CEO and our special board meeting, and let me see. [1:31:20] I had the monthly PPC meeting and also had the EWRC committee meeting. [1:31:31] Thank you. [1:31:33] Vice Chair. [1:31:36] Thank you, Chair. [1:31:38] Let's see. [1:31:40] When I wanted to see a call on water transfers meeting with our discussion with Mr. Cook. [1:31:52] And IIT, a bunch of San Frisquito Creek issues, meeting with Mr. Hopper, [1:32:00] gripping meeting, I will compliment staff on explaining the complexities [1:32:04] to my limited mind of our setback policies, DEC, finance, [1:32:10] authority, where Santa Clara's now chair, quarterly retailers, meeting [1:32:16] where we heard how retailers felt about some of our policies, [1:32:22] and that's it. [1:32:26] And one other thing I did here from a constituent that the City of San Jose is pounding [1:32:32] on doors today for those living against Ross Creek, at least one person got it. [1:32:39] Well, that's good news, I know they have, I know they have some notices out from how [1:32:45] person. I said the same council person has direct the key again and she's having a meeting tomorrow night and [1:32:53] she sent out a lot of notices. We've got Cherry Street with pretty close to here and and a few others Ross Creek and so on [1:33:03] So it's good that city council folks are activated. For me, I had a number of meetings [1:33:11] our regular meetings, our regular board meetings, [1:33:17] I ordered the board order committee meeting, [1:33:21] I had a delta-convanced meeting, spark meeting, recycle committee meeting, [1:33:28] a town hall meeting, [1:33:31] also the county redevelopment meeting, environmental advisory board meeting, and we hear today, [1:33:37] and then a number of different meetings with staff on different issues. [1:33:42] Great, so we're at the point of a German, we're a clerk review and clarification of the board request. [1:33:49] Thank you, Mr. Chair, at this time I have no formal request. [1:33:53] Great, so at this time we'll adjourn to our special meeting tomorrow at 10 a.m. [1:34:02] So thank you, be safe, be careful tomorrow, should be, I understand overnight there'll be a lot of wind and a lot of rain. [1:34:11] So be careful tomorrow morning, and we'll see everybody then tomorrow morning. [1:34:16] Thank you all very much, and...