[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [3:13] Hello, everybody. We're going to start the meeting momentarily, our third member will be here, so we'll get going. And this is the board, what Santa Clara Valley Water District Board audit committee. And can we take the roll call first. Thank you. [3:34] We have Director Estimera and he should be in shortly vice chair ballard and chair ball. [3:42] Thank you chair. [3:42] We have a quorum. [3:44] Okay. [3:45] Thank you. [3:46] The second item is for. [3:49] Okay. [3:49] Tony Estimera is now present. [3:51] So he made it. [3:53] Second item is. [3:57] Time open for public comment. [3:58] I'm not on the agenda. [4:00] Is there any public comment? [4:02] Any. [4:03] Thank you chair not at this time. [4:04] Okay, and we'll go on to number three, three point one is the approval of the July 28th board audit committee minutes is and we have the objection to those may have a motion. [4:19] Okay, there's most of the second to approve that. Do we have any public comment on this? [4:24] Thank you chair not at this time. Okay, and then all those in favor say aye. [4:29] Opposed carries. [4:30] Okay, we'll go to the regular agenda, this is first item is 4.1, receive and discuss the audit report of the water utility enterprise funds for fiscal year and a June 30 of 2025. [4:48] Okay, go ahead, please stop. [4:50] Good afternoon, committee members. [4:52] Daren Taylor chief financial officer and item four point one is the last piece of work that our financial auditors did as it really [5:00] 2. The fiscal year 25 annual financial audit and the committee may recall that the board accepted the FY25 annual comprehensive financial report back in January. [5:13] And so this is the last piece of work related to FY25 and the purpose of this piece of work is to have the external financial auditors conduct procedures to review the allocation of revenues and costs between the North County Zone W2. [5:29] to and the three South County groundwater benefits zones. [5:33] And so we began doing this particular audit work back in 2006 [5:37] to provide transparency and assurance [5:42] to the water retailers that exist in both of those zones. [5:46] And the report that you have in your packet indicates [5:50] that the Water Utility Fund Financial Statements [5:52] are fairly stated, including the schedule of revenues [5:55] and expenses by zone, which kind of shows [5:57] tell those revenues and costs are allocated by zone. [6:01] And so there are no findings in the audit. [6:04] And I'll pause there for any questions. [6:07] And just so you know, the next step would [6:09] be to take this final report to the full board [6:13] for their receipt. [6:16] OK. [6:17] This is kind of the basis for going into the rates, correct? [6:24] It is definitely support for the rate projections that we do because it affirms the allocations of revenues and costs between the zones. [6:36] Okay, I think it's a clean audit from BASK as a company or independent auditor. [6:44] Do you have any questions on this? [6:48] No? Okay. Public comments? [6:53] Thank you, Chair. [6:54] Not at this time. [6:55] Okay. [6:56] I think the action would be to just have this go to the full board, correct? [7:01] And it looks like it's ready for review by the full board. [7:05] Yes, thank you. [7:06] Okay, thank you. [7:07] Okay. [7:09] We'll go to 9. [7:11] 4.2, which is received a status report on the implementation of the audit recommendations and authorizing [7:19] staff to complete board-directed audits or refer them to the Chief Audit Executive for follow-up. [7:28] And we have a report on this. So 4.2. [7:32] Thank you. So this is the semi-annual status report on the implementation of audit recommendations [7:38] and across all the audits that have been done where there are recommendations still to be addressed. [7:46] And so with that I'm going to turn it over to Anthony Mendiola for brief presentation. [7:49] Okay, Anthony please make your presentation. [7:52] Good afternoon, Chair Bell. [7:54] Vice Chair Ballard and Director Estimera. [7:56] I'm Anthony Mendella, program administrator [7:58] for the continual improvement team. [8:02] Item 4.2 is a status update regarding open and pending [8:05] audit recommendations across five audits. [8:08] Staff returns every six months and in the last report [8:12] was back in February of this year. [8:15] Of the 23 recommendations across the five audits [8:18] reported back in February, staff have completed the implementation of nine additional recommendations, [8:24] which are identified in attachment two along with the detailed status updates. [8:28] The specific audits in today's report are the 2021 Permitting Best Practices Audit, the 2023 [8:34] Capital Improvement Performance Audit, the 2024 Human Resources Audit, the 2024 Renewed Safe Clean [8:42] Water Program Performance Audit, and the 2025 Water Conservation Program Performance [8:47] it. Overall, there are a total of 14 recommendations still pending or underway across the five audits. [8:56] Additionally, staff have provided the audit report for the 25 wattage usage and demand [9:02] forecasting audit to the board audit committee last month and is due to present the report [9:07] to the full board at its September 8th meeting. I will now provide a brief overview of the implementation [9:13] status for each of the open audits and staff familiar with the effort were invited to attend [9:18] and respond to any specific questions you may have. The 2021 Permitting Best Practices audit [10:00] At that time, staff reported that eight of the 14 recommendations had been implemented, six recommendations remained pending and underway all of which are ranked as low. [10:11] Recommendations that require assistance from information technology teams are anticipated to be completed by December of this year. [10:19] I will return in February with the next six month report and staff will provide the next detailed status report to the BAC again in May of 2027. [10:29] For the 2023 Capital Improvement Program Performance Audit, the Audit report was provided to the board on October of 2023. [10:39] The last update from the CIP team was provided in September of last year. [10:45] The Audit produced a total of 15 individual recommendations across eight problem statements. [10:51] And as of this report, two recommendations, one identified as high and one is medium, remain is pending and underway. [10:57] staff anticipate that the remaining recommendations are expected to be completed by June of [11:02] 2027. [11:05] For the 2024 Human Resources Performance Audit, the audit was reported to the board back in [11:10] April of 2025, and in April of this year staff reported that seven of the 10 recommendations [11:15] had already been implemented, and another two recommendations have been implemented since. [11:21] The remaining recommendations ranked as high and remains listed as pending another way. [11:26] The remaining recommendation is ongoing and will be completed as part of the current enterprise resource program implementation. [11:35] For the 2024 renewed safely in water program, which was a program required audit. [11:41] The audit report was provided to the board in November of 2025. [11:45] A total of nine recommendations were identified. [11:48] Today, seven of those recommendations have been implemented. [11:52] The two recommendations remaining one-high one-medium remain is pending a underway, and a [11:56] safely water team will return to the BAC annually in October to provide a detailed status [12:02] update of their progress. [12:04] And last, the 2025 water conservation audit was reported to the board back in February of [12:10] this year. [12:11] A total of five recommendations were identified to low ranked recommendations have been [12:16] implement it, three recommendations, two of them are medium, one low, still remain as pending [12:21] or underway and staff will return in January, until all recommendations have been implemented. [12:29] This completes the summary. [12:31] Thank you for your time. [12:32] Okay. [12:32] Great. [12:34] First of all, I'd like to thank everybody that worked on progress of all these audits. [12:40] It looked like some very difficult recommendations. [12:44] A lot of work had to go into implementing the audit recommendations, so we appreciate that. [12:55] I'm particularly interested in the board implementing part of the audit in the budget [13:04] for water conservation, and that was one of the recommendations. [13:09] I believe that we have to look out a little more closely about putting money into the budget for [13:19] more staff for water conservation. That was one of recommendations I believe to try to implement [13:26] you know a more aggressive program. So is there any, does anybody have any comment on that? I mean [13:34] So that's some of the board has to do, right? [13:39] Yeah, I think that's something that the board does. [13:41] And I know that staff is aware of that. [13:43] There are some staff here who could probably speak to this. [13:47] There was a recommendation to add staff to the program. [13:52] And that has been noted. [13:56] I think what the team is attempting to do is phase it in as the program expands. [14:03] And that's about all I know about it. [14:05] And I would, I'm seeing a nod from, from the, from staff that are here. [14:11] So the next time we review the audit status. [14:16] Maybe somebody can come and talk about that a little bit. [14:19] Okay, that's, that's, so that will be in. [14:21] When it will be the next time. [14:24] For my report, which comes every six months, my next report will be in February. [14:28] As for the actual team, I'll have to check their schedule. [14:31] Okay. [14:31] Which one of us will come back sooner? [14:33] and we'll make sure that item is included in their discussion. [14:37] And the HR ought to look like you covered everything on that one. [14:43] That was a big one. [14:44] The capital budget performance of that. [14:47] That was covered. [14:49] Look like they covered everything there. [14:52] We've done a lot of work on that. [14:57] It's the shows that we're working on. [15:00] The staff and management are progressing. I think there's one that is taking a little while to complete. Some of these require information technology or systems, which with the implementation of systems is revamping business processes that go along with it. So in some cases it takes some time that we're seeing progress. [15:24] Okay. Any questions anybody? Do you have any public comments on this? Oh, Sharda? Go ahead, please. [15:34] Thanks for the update. I had some specific questions, and I looked back on my notes from the text. [15:44] on the permit audit and I think you mentioned this we did review it earlier this year maybe it was [15:50] me. And I had the same questions, you know I read I read the report and I looked back and I was like [15:56] oh I have the same questions then that I have now and I didn't write down the answers and I didn't [16:02] go back and watch the video to see how you answered my questions back then. So I'm wondering if you [16:06] And George just alluded to this, but online 297 of the more detailed report and then subsequent ones. [16:17] It is talking about this customer service piece taking, it's taking a while. [16:24] And so I asked it last time, like, why is it taking so long? [16:27] And so can you refresh our memories about why this is taking so long? [16:32] Are there ways to speed it up? [16:33] and then I will write down your answer in my notes [16:35] so then the next time this comes up [16:37] and I'm like, why is it taking so long? [16:39] I go, oh, this is the answer. [16:41] So I will have to defer to management on that. [16:44] As the auditor, we typically don't do any follow-up work [16:49] or get into the progress that's being made until essentially [16:55] until management has indicated they've implemented [16:57] the recommendations were implemented [16:58] but they're going to implement and then we, [17:01] If authorized by the committee, would conduct a follow-up audit [17:04] to determine the status. [17:06] Yes, they've implemented, as they said so, or know they haven't. [17:10] So I think, on to that phase yet, [17:12] I would have to defer to either Anthony or management. [17:15] So that question. [17:16] Yes, it was regard to that question on the permitting on it. [17:19] I don't see the staff here that would subject matter experts [17:24] that could answer that question. [17:25] I know that the system, I know that they've [17:27] been working on that for several years now, [17:29] the database update or upgrade and I don't know if perhaps Cecil Lawson might have some insight [17:38] more than I would have but I'll stop there. [17:45] Cecil Lawson IT. We're using a product called [17:50] cityworks and it is a kind of ubiquitous platform and so the technology is in this case is generally [17:59] not the hardest part of it. I mean deployment of a database and applications as far as really [18:03] the workflow behind it and the interfaces behind it. And so it's taken a little bit longer [18:06] because I think the process we're changing some of the workflow will be more efficient and effective [18:11] and that's been sort of delaying, had providing a longer delay to this process. Beyond that, [18:18] they would have to get this, you know, I don't have to specific access to what specific workflow [18:21] is being changed or augmented or updated. What's that helps? Can we maybe get a written response to [18:28] question, and then it can go in the record, and then I can go back and say, oh, this was answered. [18:36] Absolutely, no problem. And I have informed staff that if they're not present, [18:40] that I will capture your questions, get back to them, and we will provide a response to you. [18:44] Okay, ask the question again. So why is it taking so long? So the on that particular, the, [18:53] You know, there were, there were concerns flagged around customer service and so this is solving that by as I understand it creating more than online system where, you know, whatever it's all done online and things are automated. [19:10] And as I understand it, this audit came out 2021. [19:14] It wasn't, it was not commissioned 21 but it came out in 2021. [19:19] I believe it actually was initiated in 2021. [19:23] Okay. So then let's assume that the audit came out end of 2022, and here we are mid-2026. [19:33] So, you know, I look at that as a part of a body that is supposed to be playing an oversight role, [19:39] and I say, why is it taking so long? And what can we do to speed this up and in the interim, [19:45] Are there things being done to make sure that those customer service, your customers are feeling good as we're fixing the problem? [19:56] And then the same question around the HR. [20:00] HR audit. [20:05] So just to clarify, if I understand it correctly, we're exploring putting in new software [20:12] to solve a number of problems that have surfaced. And my understanding from reading the report [20:19] is we've just kicked off a process to do that and select, you know, do the things that we need [20:25] do to select the software to then, and so it sounds like it's going to be the same kind [20:31] of process that we did for the permit audit, and so I read that and I go, are we going [20:37] to have the same very long process, or how do we make sure that this happens in a year [20:43] as opposed to four years? [20:45] I appreciate the question, and Anna Lee from HR is here. Hopefully she can respond? [20:51] Yes, good afternoon, analysts, it's an officer in human resources. [20:54] We have selected a vendor and we're actually in the process of the configuration and testing. [20:59] So we're building the systems so that way creates a lot of efficiencies that we have identified. [21:05] The implementation date, the goal-live, is March 15th of next year. [21:09] So right now we're still in that planning programming phase. [21:13] We'll have to do the testing. [21:14] We still have to do a few other elements that are all planned right now, [21:18] but it is March 15th, is our goal-live date. [21:20] So up until then we'll continue to plug it along. [21:23] Okay, cool, because I think that date, date was not in the report, so it might be good to just put that in there, because that was my question. [21:30] It was like, we're working on it. [21:32] It's like good. [21:34] Good. [21:34] So nice to hear that there's a date. [21:35] Thank you. [21:37] Okay. [21:39] Those are good questions. [21:41] We don't have any other comments on this. [21:46] So is this a report that goes to the full board? [21:50] No, okay. [21:53] So we'll see the next report in February of next year. [21:58] Debbie, where are next year? [22:00] Okay, maybe we get some updates on all those things. [22:03] Okay, let's go to four points. [22:06] I also wanted to second your comments about the conservation audit [22:09] and getting a status update on that particular recommendation [22:13] about expanding the budget. [22:15] So, thanks for raising that. Yeah, we need [22:21] to, it's a value added kind of thing. We got to [22:25] mix it's good for the water district to do that. So, let's go to 4.3 then. [22:35] This is to discuss potential autotovics for 2027 and you'll a lot of plan for five further guidance. [22:42] So, what we got, we got the same list of. [22:47] All right, thank you. [22:50] Chair Bell. [22:51] So, what I wanted to do here just in the memo is sort of certainly back on the last [22:56] risk assessment, where we identified [23:00] ranked 12 higher priority audit topics. [23:04] Of those 12 looks like we have several that were selected. [23:13] I think 10 audits were actually approved by the board of those 10, 7 were included in the [23:26] ranked audit topics, those include human resources, information technology, operations, and maintenance, [23:34] and asset management, which is currently ongoing board policies, purchasing and contracting [23:38] capital project delivery and water usage and demand forecasting. There were three [23:43] audits that were not in the risk assessment that were added subsequently through [23:47] conversations with the committee, the investigations process, the Pacheco Reservoir Project [23:53] Expansion Project and water conservation strategies. So that means there were five audit [24:01] topics that were included in that original list that have not been selected or authorized to move [24:07] where just go through those briefly, the clerk of the board, I had included, I did not include [24:16] district council in that list of priority autotopics, mostly because it had just been audited, [24:23] I think, the year before, two years before, three years. So it, from my perspective, it's important [24:31] to have broad coverage within an organization. So it's not that the clerk of the board is a high [24:36] risk operation, but it's important to get broad audit coverage. Same at the same is true of [24:40] just for council. So I think that would remain their safety and security. Treasury operations [24:46] was included in that list. I likely would recommend not including that it in that list this [24:52] next time. We touched on Treasury operations in the board policy. Performance audit, which is [24:58] in the exit conference date. [25:00] For the current risk assessment, is actually to take a different approach. On those obviously those are important subjects and minutes, it's why valley water is here. [25:10] But Director Bell, you had made a comment. This is going back probably several committee meetings ago. [25:16] You'd like to see the risk assessment focus less on just the organizational structure, but [25:23] this strategic priorities of valley water and this strategic plans and what are some of [25:28] the risks that could impede valley water achieving the its end policies or the core goals [25:36] and functions that it's here for. [25:38] So what I plan to do with those audit topics is actually scope them out a little bit differently [25:44] And I think more clearly, and rank those autotopics to be higher up in the risk assessments. [25:52] So that'll be worth that will occur in the risk assessment. [25:55] Don't have the scope doubt, but I envision the next list of priority topics would include those subjects, [26:01] but would have more specific scope and objectives associated with those more refined. [26:07] And so, that's sort of the prior list and what hasn't been done and what has been done. [26:14] Again, once we get the notice to proceed for the risk assessment, that'll really kick off [26:19] the planning of the process we use to identify additional audit topics. [26:26] But for the purpose of moving this forward, this agenda item is really to give an opportunity [26:34] for the committee members to identify any topics that you think are would be interesting or [26:39] a high priority for you. What is the upcoming risk assessment that I've reviewed? What's the timing [26:50] of that? Well, I think that we have a 20, 23 risk assessment. Yes. We've gone through that. And obviously [27:00] can't get everything, but you try to focus on the higher risk areas. Then we have this new [27:08] risk assessment looking at the current environment that we're in and when is that going to be [27:14] available to the committee to the fine or audit topics? Right, the timing is going to be tight. [27:23] So the charter says that the committee needs to submit proposed audit plan by the end of November. [27:30] each year so that the board can receive a proposed plan, move forward on it. [27:36] So my goal would be that the risk assessment is completed before that, so we can inform that audit plan. [27:43] Timing is tight, that only leaves a few months. [27:45] Now the benefit, the benefit I have is that I've been here Valley Water for a longer period of time, [27:50] so I am more familiar and I've conducted the prior risk assessment, but there's a fair amount of work to be done between now and then. [27:57] So what I can do is this will be an agenda item each month until we have a proposed audit [28:06] plan. [28:07] So I'll give you a status on where the risk assessment is. [28:11] If I believe that it would be beneficial to the committee to hold off on finalizing [28:16] an audit plan until that risk assessment is done, I'll make that recommendation and that's [28:21] something that the committee can decide what you want to do with that. [28:24] But the timing will be high and my goal will still be to have it completed in time for the committee to send the recommended audit plan in November. [28:37] I think we ought to have the ones we started finished. [28:43] And then we ought to, you know, if you have any alarm bells that go off on the risk assessment, [28:49] That's when you'll discover, oh, we should do something on this, maybe some reason, a new information that causes you to discuss something that we haven't talked about or covered and you should bring it to our attention so that we can address the issue. [29:11] And then I think that's, I think that's going to be very important in the next, you say it's going to be available in November probably. So that's not that far away. [29:22] Right. Yeah. If anything comes up that I think warrants urgent attention, then I will bring that up to the committee. [29:31] I don't know if anybody at 20, 20 comments, [30:04] In a couple of thoughts, comments and congratulations to being selected as our auditor going forward for the next [30:17] I had a couple of questions. [30:20] One is on the water conservation audit that we did this past time around. [30:26] We had some conversations about whether there was a need or an opportunity to do a [30:34] fall to that. [30:35] So I was wondering if staff might, I would want to hear from staff in terms of, do they feel [30:42] I like the audit was adequate, are there some, if we are hiring more staff, because that was one of the questions that I was hoping would be answered in that audit. [30:52] Since we do envision hiring 10 more staff or whatever it is, what are the ways that we should be deploying those staff? [30:59] What are the best practices out there? Where should we be focusing our resources? And I had hoped that an audit would kind of help guide us in that particular way. [31:08] So on that particular audit, I was hoping to hear from staff who were involved in that if they do feel like there is a need for additional research data gathering on our activities to help point us. [31:22] And in help focus our efforts as we're trying to expand the budget and where to spend those resources in terms of staff. [31:37] Yeah, I don't know that we have staff here to answer that question right now, but you may have thoughts on how to proceed. [31:47] Part of the risk assessment processes will be meeting with management throughout the organization, several layers of staff and management. [31:55] a lot of interviews and so we'll be cleaning those ideas and thoughts and where people think [32:01] there might be some value and additional work, you know, an independent set of eyes [32:07] so that that will be part of the process that I'll follow, including meeting with board members. [32:13] Well, another question, do we ever take a break from doing audits or audit in a different, [32:25] you know, [32:25] I love a good audit. Maybe maybe we do something different over every so often like we're [32:35] getting going a little deeper into the report that we just did for example and auditing how we're [32:40] doing on implementing audits. Do we ever do something like that? We haven't. The approach that we have taken [32:53] is to do some of that follow-up work, what work has been done, what work has been completed, [33:02] where is the unit at or where is the program at now versus where it was at when the audit was conducted. [33:09] That has all done after the fact. And we've really had, we've engaged in that and forward of the audits for a long time that that wasn't being done. [33:21] They're the models for doing what you're describing. [33:25] They're out there. [33:26] They're very different organizations take different approaches. [33:28] One approach that I like, and I don't know that it's the right fit here. [33:34] It is a little bit more resource intensive, but there'll be six month actual follow-up [33:40] audits. [33:41] Or maybe one in six months and another one a year from there. [33:45] So as it differs from the current approach, which is management, reporting to continuous improvement [33:53] and that report goes to you, it would be audit resources going in and looking where we at in six [33:59] months has there been progress within this period of time. And invariably there will be some recommendations [34:06] that will be completed and many that won't be. In six months is a fairly short amount of time. [34:13] But in 18 months, you would like to see a lot more implemented, and what is necessary to implement [34:20] a recommendation will vary in complexity. So that is an approach. It's not the approach taken [34:25] here. It tends to be the approach taken at much larger organizations, like probably the state auditor's [34:34] office. We would take that approach. Very common in cities and California, at least that I'm familiar [34:42] with it have a city auditor function. [34:44] They would have an annual audit follow up. [34:47] Where the auditors would go in and actually evaluate [34:50] where we at with the implementation. [34:53] And it's an that often ties into not just. [35:00] The process, but it is consistent with best practices and auditing to go in and do that kind of work. [35:06] Often, it's not a matter of pausing other audit work, it's doing it in addition. [35:12] It may be a matter of splitting up resources and single only due to new audits. [35:16] We'll follow up on these other audits. [35:20] A variety of ways to approach it, but those are some of the options. [35:25] Okay. [35:28] Also, I had a question about, because I know last year, there was, there were [35:36] some similar audits. Management did not audit, we had audit directed and there was some [35:41] crossover on those two items. Do we have a sense at this point what management audits [35:47] are have been initiated this year or planned to be initiated and initiated for next year? [35:55] Yeah, I can speak to that one. We have two management audit firms similar to how the [35:59] we're not equine us three firms. And right now one firm is doing some capital benchmarking work [36:06] for management or for staff right now there are no plans to do any management audits or any other [36:13] work with those two firms. [36:17] So capital benchmarking stuff. [36:25] Okay. [36:26] Thank you. [36:31] I think the auditor general and a legislative analyst in Sacramento, [36:39] were giving up the performance evaluations. [36:45] So he had like a dual kind of performance evaluation with the auditor general. [36:52] General, and then you had the legislative analysts who would analyze performance and analyze [37:00] What what does strategic view would be forward? [37:03] So they would focus more on the future [37:08] whereas auditors [37:10] tend to look at [37:12] past and present and some future, right, is that correct? [37:17] Yeah, I think that's probably a fair way of looking at it [37:21] You would have the legislative sentence that's that's looking at future impacts of proposed legislation or program and the auditor is often auditing the past right auditing what has been done because what's been done is a good indicator of what's going to be done and so [37:37] So I think that's a fair characterization and sometimes you will see overlap. I know with the demand forecasting there was that wasn't an audit that was a consulting engagement [37:47] engagement. But if the questions are important enough, the board wants an independent audit [37:54] sometimes the board will ask it. It's okay that you're doing that, but I want it. I want to [38:00] look at it with my set of eyes. And so that happens occasionally that happens at the state level [38:06] is where you'll have the legislative analyst or the state auditor looking at its topic. And sometimes [38:13] still produce reports that might be seemingly in conflict or they're looking at it from different [38:19] angles they can and so you know I think the ultimate goal is if you're answering key questions [38:25] or important questions and they're providing answers even though those answers might be a little [38:29] bit different different different angles of looking at the you know a program. Some of the [38:43] of strategy. And those people would look at, they would do a lot of reports on what kind [38:52] of strategy and what the risk are in the future. And combine it with a plan for audit, [39:00] it would perform its audits. So it would help guide those future goals that they have. [39:08] right now so so like I think state of New York and the city New York and Los Angeles do that [39:16] I see it sounds they had a legislative analyst and a performance auditor right two people [39:26] separate okay yeah okay thank you good discussion [39:35] George, we need to, we don't need to further guidance. [39:39] Well, I think the big mark on this is going to be when your assessment comes up. [39:46] And that will be what meeting will that be, please? [39:50] Well, the goal will be to bring it before the committee in time to consider the recommendations before the November. [40:01] BAC, it might be at the November meeting meeting, and even that's a pretty tight time frame. So as we meet in the subsequent months, going forward, I'll give you a status update on where that's at. And again, if I believe it'll be necessary or valuable to the committee to hold off on sending the recommended, the recommended annual audit plan, then I'll do that and I'll let you know where that's at. [40:26] of anything urgent comes up. I'll bring that to your attention as well. But one of the initial [40:33] steps that I'll take when we get the notice to proceed is to set up meetings, again with management, [40:39] but also for members. So here at this meeting, you can raise potential audit topics of interest, [40:45] but you can also raise those to me when we meet. Okay, thank you. Okay, thanks. Hey, thank you. [40:55] We're going to go to the next side and then we'll put a list here on C. [41:10] Okay, we did 4.3. We're going to 4.4. [41:16] We're talking about the risk assessment. [41:19] We'll go to 4.4. [41:20] discuss the annual 26, 20, 20, 20, 20, 20, 26, annual audit plan, risk assessment, [41:30] asset management, petraco reservoir, investigative process, review the status of open board, [41:35] directed audit engagements and provide feedback that's needed. [41:40] Staff? [41:41] Yes, thank you. [41:43] And yes, this item is a status update. [41:45] There are eight open board-directed audits. [41:48] And I'll also speak to kind of the status of a couple of them and then I'll turn it over to George Skiles for the rest. [41:54] As the committee knows, the water usage and demand forecasting on it was complete. [41:58] The committee got a chance to take a look at that report a couple of meetings ago and it's going to go to the full board in early September. [42:06] As far as the asset management audit goes, it commenced in February of 2026. [42:11] And the draft report is expected to be submitted to management for an initial review in Q3 of calendar year 2026. [42:20] And with regard to the investigations process on it, that audit has commenced. [42:26] And with an expectation of an initial report for management review in Q1 of calendar year 2027. [42:34] And with that, I'll pass it over to George. [42:35] Thank you. [42:38] Two projects on the current work plan, the Pacheca Resort Expansion Project and the district [42:45] wide risk assessment, as I mentioned, the risk assessment is we're planning on starting [42:50] it. [42:51] Hopefully within days, maybe a few weeks, I don't know what will work on the, the notes [42:56] we're seeing. [42:56] The Pacheca Resort Project, again, very soon as well, that project we will likely meet with [43:02] staff to determine when they hit, when they have completed their clothes out. [43:05] work. That was, that's been the plan from the beginning, allowing them to finish that close-out [43:10] work and then we would go in and begin that audit. So we're expecting that in Q3 of this year. [43:17] Three other audits remain open from prior years. One is a board policy. Compliance audit. That is [43:23] in the exit conference stage right now. Management has the draft of the report. The contracting [43:29] process is the same. Management has a copy of the report and that's in the exit conference [43:34] stage as well and then capital project delivery we've been we've had some some delays in the completion of that. [43:41] That is still expected to be completed either late Q3 or early Q4 of this year. [43:47] It'll be completed within a few months but that one has experienced some delays. [43:53] Any questions from anybody? [43:56] Discussion? [43:59] Feedback? [44:01] Okay. Okay. Thank you. Any public comments? [44:07] Thank you chair and I at this time. Okay. [44:11] Okay. Okay. We'll go to the last item which is [44:16] or second to last item review and discuss the 26 [44:20] Board of the committee work plan. [44:22] Thank you chair and so the committee has the [44:25] And the matrix work plan and the last page of your packet as we look forward to the [44:32] September meeting, the key items that are scheduled for that meeting include the CIP performance [44:38] audit status update and the financial status update for FY26 preliminary actual financials. [44:46] And then, of course, the discussion on the risk assessment. [44:50] Okay. Very good. Any questions? Okay, good. Thank you. [45:00] Next item would be clerk to review and clarification to many requests. [45:05] Thank you chair. I have under item 4.1 committee received and noted the clean audit report [45:10] of the Water Utility Enterprise Funds for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2025, an expressive [45:17] report for the final reports we consider by the board under item 4.2. The committee received [45:24] a status update on the implementation of audit recommendations and express interest in water [45:30] conservation being included in the board's budget and a follow-up discussion on a future [45:36] agenda on that and then there was interest in our written response from staff to confirm concerns [45:42] regarding customer service and the length of time. It is taking under the 2021 permitting best practices [45:49] audit and I have under item 4.3 the committee discussed and provided their feedback on the different [45:55] approaches and strategies regarding the potential audit topics for the 2027 annual audit plan and the [46:03] updates were noted by the committee for item 4.4 for the annual audit plan for 2026 and for [46:19] Justin's to add. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. And we're now adjourned. [46:28] Next meetings on the 16th of September. I want to clock.