[0:11] hello everyone. I will [0:12] start the meeting. Today is the [0:15] Sherborn Board of Education meeting [0:16] . It [0:19] seems to be Tuesday, September 22nd, and I am having a meeting at the Dover-Sherborn Middle School [0:21] library [0:22] . The time [0:24] is 5:30. The first agenda item [0:27] is listening to the opinions of local residents. [0:31] It seems no one is online. Does [0:33] anyone have any opinions? does [0:37] n't exist. Is there [0:39] anyone here who would like to share their opinion [0:40] ? doesn't exist. [0:41] great. Then, let's move straight to the Superintendent's [0:44] remarks. [0:47] hello everyone. I will keep it brief as I explained it in [0:50] more detail at last week's joint meeting [0:53] . [0:54] In particular, I would like to thank the residents of Sherborn and the [0:58] Pine Hill community for their efforts in ensuring a smooth start to the school year [1:00] . Thank you to everyone, including students, teachers, [1:01] administrators, parents, and bus [1:03] drivers [1:05] . Everything is going well now [1:06] . [1:08] We have already held several all-student meetings, and Ms. [1:09] Heather also [1:10] had the opportunity to attend the first one. [1:12] I was very impressed. [1:15] And [1:16] there is an open class for parents on Thursday evening at 6 PM [1:17] . I look forward to meeting the Pine Hill parents in person [1:19] . If you [1:22] have any other questions or comments, please feel free to let me know at any time [1:23] . [1:26] Do you have any questions for Superintendent McCoy? It seems like there isn't one. [1:28] Ah, wait a minute. Did you [1:30] mean you wished Kate would come back? [1:31] Ah, yes. I briefly forgot. My [1:33] last name just changed. I [1:35] agree as well. The all-student meeting is a [1:36] really good time. [1:37] Hello, Kate. We've held a [1:39] school-wide meeting every Friday for the past five years [1:40] . I really like the all-student meeting. [1:42] It's a really good time. [1:43] Yes, it is a good opportunity to foster a sense of community [1:44] . Okay, I will [1:45] continue. I will [1:47] move on to the financial report. Mr. [1:48] Shore, [1:50] would you like to pass the microphone? all right. [1:51] sorry. [1:52] I didn't understand it well [1:53] . It seems like you have quite a few more cases [1:54] . [1:56] Well, the [1:57] items in today's report are those sent to City Hall since the last meeting [1:59] , so it [2:00] seems there are quite a lot of them. [2:02] And I am telling you about all the materials you sent by Friday [2:06] . It seems like September 11th was the last [2:08] data. To [2:09] reiterate, this document is a [2:14] summary of all materials processed by our office and sent to the city. These are materials to be processed in the general fund [2:16] and other special income funds [2:18] . Mr. Bill [2:21] prepares the slides, and we are [2:27] very grateful that he comes every two weeks to create them on behalf of our committee. [2:30] Today's data [2:32] also includes the final settlement data for the 2026 fiscal year [2:34] . [2:40] You have likely seen various small figures, but this [2:42] fiscal year was a year where we had to keep monitoring because the budget was tight between May and June [2:47] . We have been talking a lot [2:54] about changes to the regional budget throughout this year [2:56] . This [2:58] report summarizes the overall situation [3:00] . For more [3:02] details, please refer to other monthly reports [3:04] . Basically, the [3:06] salary budget was adjusted [3:08] to within $9,000 of the originally set amount [3:10] . Of course, there are instances where the budget and [3:13] actual expenditures diverge, but [3:17] because unexpected variables can arise, we always [3:21] try to operate with a total payroll budget secured [3:23] . [3:29] There was a cost-saving effect in the special education teacher budget, [3:35] because there were positions that were decided not to be filled after the budget was allocated. Thanks to this, we were [3:37] able to recruit other necessary personnel [3:38] , one of which is [3:40] the hiring of 0.2 additional special education teachers [3:41] . Therefore, 1.0 special education teacher is assigned to Pine Hill [3:45] based on the student body size [3:48] . In addition, there was flexibility in the recruitment process, which [3:55] resulted in a slight negative increase in the general teacher budget [3:57] . Well, after budgeting, we [4:03] hired one more educational assistant based on the students' needs [4:05] . However, overall, [4:10] this year's salaries were finalized within the allocated budget [4:13] . In terms of expenditure as well, it [4:15] was almost the same. [4:17] There was a slight cost-saving effect, and it was [4:22] fortunate that we were able to save on items such as special education services. As I mentioned before [4:24] , we are still adjusting to the aftermath of the Connections program [4:25] migrating to Chickering [4:28] . As you know, it is [4:33] expected that the figure will be further reduced when formulating the budget for fiscal year 2027. However, [4:35] fortunately, there were cost-saving effects [4:37] , but one of the unexpected things was the [4:39] increase in public utility rates [4:40] . The biggest increase was in [4:43] electricity costs, which resulted from adding two [4:47] new RTUs and [4:51] switching out the existing RTUs [4:53] . Both RTUs [4:55] are fully electric. Therefore, [5:00] much more electricity is [5:02] used to maintain the same temperature during the winter than when using gas. [5:05] And there was an unexpected increase in regulations [5:07] . Well, this is [5:12] something I mentioned before. I was [5:14] n't exactly sure, but I confirmed that it is an item that the regulatory [5:15] authorities can add [5:18] . [5:20] If you look at your electricity bill, that item will be included [5:21] . Fortunately, [5:25] electricity supply costs are [5:27] expected to decrease starting in December. This is [5:32] because a new electricity supply contract has been signed. This is a [5:35] contract signed about a year ago. You will be able to [5:37] see significant cost savings [5:38] . Currently, we are [5:41] paying nearly 16 cents per kilowatt, but it will [5:43] go down to 12.6 cents per kilowatt [5:44] . This will help offset the increase in usage to [5:46] some extent [5:47] . In addition, the [5:53] fee calculation method for areas outside the jurisdiction will change, and [5:58] fees will be significantly reduced starting in 2017 [6:00] . The only [6:02] thing we need to worry about is students from kindergarten [6:03] to 5th grade [6:05] moving out of our jurisdiction [6:07] , and all other students are [6:09] transferred to the local education office. [6:13] However, as you will see if you read my report [6:15] , we [6:20] exceeded the budget by nearly $265,000 due to some deployment changes outside the jurisdiction [6:22] . Fortunately, we had an [6:27] additional budget for emergencies [6:29] . [6:32] So, we were able to utilize $241,000 in [6:34] emergency funds [6:35] . You are aware that I have emphasized every year that it is [6:41] very important to ensure that the budget for emergencies does not run out [6:42] . [6:44] This is exactly the safety net we need [6:45] . Thanks to this, we did [6:50] not need to request additional budget from the city. Since I took [6:52] office, there have been times when I had to make a request at least [6:53] once [6:55] . Therefore, we [6:58] needed a budget for emergencies, and we utilized it effectively. [7:01] Well, so in the end, we returned [7:03] $590 to the village according to the budget [7:05] . The [7:08] fact that the budget was set at $590 is truly [7:10] surprising. yes [7:11] . Well, I can't take that ball [7:13] . As you can see, the fluctuations [7:15] are severe. What I deserve to be [7:16] recognized for is that I demonstrated a [7:18] firm determination to protect the emergency funds [7:19] . That is [7:20] certainly true. yes. It is really [7:22] important. Budget volatility is [7:27] too high, and the number of [7:29] students transferring from other states is [7:31] increasing in both towns. There are absolutely no [7:33] protection measures for students coming from out of state [7:34] . For students [7:38] transferring from a different school district within the same state, the [7:40] transfer [7:41] district provides one year's worth of support and [7:45] buys time for that district to factor it into the budget, but there is [7:52] no such safety net for students coming from other states or students in cooperative school districts. So, we experienced [7:57] that situation in both regions and ended up [7:59] bearing 100% of the cost [8:01] , but naturally, we did [8:03] not reflect it in the budget. This is [8:06] because I was unaware of such a situation. [8:07] So, well, this is a [8:09] summary of the current situation for fiscal year 2026 [8:11] . You will receive the [8:13] first report for fiscal year 2027 in October, and the [8:15] first budget proposal for fiscal year 2028 in November [8:18] . [8:19] thank you. It is like [8:26] experiencing the 2027 fiscal year for one month before talking about the 2028 fiscal year [8:27] . Regarding the 2028 fiscal year [8:30] , as the Committee and Mr. Bill are [8:32] aware, we were [8:39] asked to attend a preliminary budget planning meeting in October with the Election Committee and the Advisory Committee. I am [8:43] scheduled to attend one of the election committee meetings. Mr. Bill will [8:47] attend representing the Sherborn Board of Education, and local [8:48] leaders will also attend [8:50] . Beth and I are also planning to attend [8:52] . I think they are trying to explain the situation [8:55] in advance before the budget guidelines are released [8:57] . As you know, [8:59] the budget was tight the year before last, [9:01] so it seems they are trying to ensure [9:02] everyone [9:04] gets as much information as possible before starting the budget planning [9:06] . [9:08] great. [9:08] The committee will continue to keep you [9:10] updated on the situation. [9:11] And I think we need to know how much money is left in our region's financial circuit [9:12] breaker budget and [9:14] how it works [9:15] . There is currently [9:17] about $12,000 remaining [9:18] . yes. [9:23] I collaborated with both regions to [9:30] manage the Sherborn and Dover regions separately, which are responsible for the regional portion of the budget for resolving financial stagnation. That is [9:31] correct regarding the regional manager. [9:32] So, we were able to secure $98,000 [9:34] . and. thank god [9:36] . [9:37] Because we have already [9:39] spent more than that amount. yes [9:41] . [9:41] Sherborn spent the money from the non-regional budget at the local level [9:43] , [9:45] leaving nearly $478,000 in Dover [9:47] . So, there is a [9:50] kind of safety net in our region [9:51] . We are trying to come up with emergency measures at the local level [9:55] . So, about 12 people [9:57] remained, and since the fourth quarter was [9:58] our region's share, you did a [10:00] great job. I had to [10:02] start over from scratch and build it up step by step [10:04] . yes. [10:07] Fortunately, the number of students has decreased significantly [10:09] . And [10:11] for the Connections program, [10:13] we have to cover the tuition for three out-of-district students, [10:15] but we [10:17] can control the costs to some extent [10:18] . Transportation costs are [10:21] n't expensive either. So there are a few advantages [10:23] . [10:24] In particular, as you mentioned, I think it is truly excellent to take such a preemptive measure in a situation where the [10:25] number of incoming students cannot be predicted [10:30] . yes [10:31] . you're right. I have completely [10:34] failed before, and I do [10:37] not want to go through that situation again. I'm [10:37] sorry, but could you please [10:39] explain the move-in process in more detail [10:41] ? It depends on how much it costs [10:42] , or... [10:44] well, where the student is placed [10:45] . The [10:47] reason I am bringing this up is that [10:49] if a student comes to Sherborn and [10:51] we do not [10:53] know much about them, two [10:55] situations arise [10:56] . If you are a student coming from the same state, you [11:00] have about a year to plan, but if you are a [11:01] student coming from another state, you must take [11:03] full responsibility immediately. [11:05] We are experiencing such a situation in both regions [11:06] . [11:08] Therefore, we cannot afford to reflect it in the budget in advance [11:10] . [11:13] The cost varies depending on the student's needs [11:15] . For example, if you can receive [11:17] training through our Connections program [11:19] , you only need to cover the [11:21] costs required to send it to Chikering [11:23] . However, [11:27] sending them to Indigenous public schools or boarding programs [11:29] naturally costs much more [11:30] . So, costs [11:33] vary from case to case, but the uncertain [11:35] part is when students move from another state [11:37] . In that [11:38] case, you have to pay the cost right away [11:40] . [11:41] And when discussing the 2020-2027 fiscal year in the October report [11:44] , I will provide a summary of the current situation and [11:46] expectations [11:48] . [11:50] In addition, if [11:51] there are any deployment cases we were unaware of, we will [11:52] explain the reasons as well [11:53] . There are cases where some of our students [12:00] suddenly lose their eligibility and [12:02] can no longer stay at the school, and we will [12:04] inform you of such cases as well [12:04] . You understood, right? [12:11] To speak about the facility improvement project carried out this year, although it was [12:14] not on the school committee's list of responsibilities, it [12:17] was a project conducted by the village. It was a [12:21] water tank replacement project conducted at Pine Hill, and it [12:23] was already completed before the start of the school year. The other one [12:25] was the installation of a water purification system, but [12:27] when the bidding results came out, it [12:29] exceeded the budget set by the city [12:31] . So, the city [12:32] proceeded with the water tank construction first [12:34] and completed all preparatory work for the installation of the water purification system [12:38] . However, it seems we will need to request additional budget once the water purification system [12:39] installation is complete [12:44] . [12:50] Thank you for the support from the Sherborn City Public Works Department [12:51] . Employees from the City Public Works Department [12:52] frequently visited the campus and [12:54] helped with other tasks as well [12:55] . They also did the landscaping work [12:58] . [13:00] Thank you so much for being with us this summer; it [13:04] was helpful to both sides. Thank you once again [13:05] . Do you have anything else to say [13:07] ? does [13:08] n't exist. [13:09] thank you. [13:11] It seems there are no further matters to discuss. Then, we will [13:15] move on to the next agenda item [13:16] . Let's look at them one by one [13:19] . The first item on the agenda [13:24] is the second deliberation of the Pine Hill Improvement Plan. Let [13:29] me give you some background information [13:31] . As I mentioned at last week's joint meeting [13:32] , I reminded you once again of our school district [13:34] 's five-year strategic plan [13:35] . [13:36] Under this plan, the school district [13:38] sets goals every year, and [13:39] last week I shared the district's goals and my own [13:41] . [13:42] And to support this, [13:43] each school—that is, all four schools— [13:46] establishes and implements their own improvement plans. [13:48] And teachers set [13:49] their goals based on this plan [13:51] . Therefore, there is a close link between the school district [13:52] 's planning and teachers' activities in the classroom [13:55] . For example, Ms. [13:56] Alison Gullin Lynx-Rudd of Pine Hill Elementary School collaborated [14:01] very cooperatively with Ms. Deborah Inman of Chickering Elementary School to [14:02] jointly develop a school improvement plan [14:04] . It has already been several years since the two of you [14:05] started cooperating like this [14:06] , and I think this is a good example of the cooperation and support our [14:07] school district aims to [14:08] provide to all students from kindergarten to fifth grade [14:12] . It is to [14:13] help students have similar experiences [14:14] . School culture might be somewhat [14:16] different, though. While there may [14:19] be slight differences from school to school [14:20] , it is important to note, as Allison pointed out, that [14:22] we are all moving in the same direction toward literacy [14:24] programs, new [14:26] extracurricular activity timetables in elementary schools, and ensuring that [14:28] students are truly at the [14:30] center of their learning, engaging in physical activities and [14:37] hands-on experiences to understand the content [14:40] . If [14:41] you have any questions, please feel free to ask at any time [14:42] . It is [14:43] no different from what you saw in the spring, and it is [14:46] also consistent with the process in chicering. [14:48] great. Kate or Mason, [14:50] do you have any questions? doesn't exist. [14:52] Kate, do you have any questions? does [14:54] n't exist. great. Well then, um [14:58] , I'm sorry. [15:01] Would you agree to approve the Pine Hill improvement plan [15:03] ? [15:04] Mason Kay, I agree. [15:07] thank you. Would [15:08] you like to second? [15:09] Kate Man Delini, I second [15:10] . [15:11] Okay, Kate. Hmm, is there anything else [15:13] to discuss? [15:16] Since we are conducting the meeting remotely, we need to vote for attendance [15:18] . Ms. Kate, [15:20] would you mind speaking first? yes. yes [15:23] . [15:24] Mr. Mason? yes [15:25] . [15:25] Mr. Al Panu, yes. The agenda item [15:28] has been passed. The next item on the agenda is the [15:32] appointment of a liaison for the Medco Education Committee [15:34] . [15:37] It looks like Ms. Kimberly is attending a meeting... [15:39] ah, she was, wasn't she? [15:40] Could the connection have been lost? [15:42] Ah, here you are. Ah, so it was [15:44] Kate. You need to attend [15:46] ... No, it is [15:47] n't strictly necessary, but as you [15:48] mentioned, Ms. Kimberly has been [15:50] performing this role for the past two years and [15:51] wants to participate again [15:52] . I am [15:53] highly experienced and ready to start working immediately [15:54] , so I would appreciate it if you could appoint me [15:56] . great. [16:01] May I propose the agenda item to appoint Ms. Kimberly as the Education Committee Liaison for MedCo? Mr. [16:01] Mason Gates, I agree [16:03] . [16:03] thank you. Would [16:04] you like to second? I [16:05] second Kate Menzel Linney [16:07] . [16:07] thank you. [16:09] I will check attendance once again. Kate? yes [16:10] . great. [16:12] Mason? yes [16:12] . [16:13] Bill Alpha No? yes [16:14] . The agenda item has been passed. [16:17] The following is the motion. [16:20] All three agenda items [16:21] can be processed together without objection. The [16:28] retroactive approval of ACED's Town Show recommendations, the approval of building rent [16:30] , and the approval of the Sherman Board of Education minutes of June 2 [16:34] . Is there [16:38] anyone who would like to talk about talent shows [16:39] ? Yes, I actually [16:41] asked a question about that part as well. [16:42] We pay [16:43] various allowances to teachers for work they do outside of class hours [16:46] . Most middle and [16:47] high schools, especially high schools, [16:48] receive a large amount of allowances, as [16:49] you know, because there are many [16:51] diverse clubs and sports activities in high schools [16:52] . Although there are [16:56] not many recipients in elementary schools, a stipend began to be paid to [16:57] Ms. Kelly Hodge two years ago in [17:00] recognition of her dedication to the talent show for over 10 years [17:03] . She [17:05] did so purely out of good intentions, but [17:09] the committee that reviews and approves the allowance every year thought that her contribution should be [17:10] recognized [17:12] . It was originally supposed to be [17:14] included in the agenda for the Spring 2025 meeting [17:16] , but somehow it [17:17] was omitted. sorry. I would [17:25] appreciate it if you could formally approve retroactive payment so that we can continue to pay allowances to the massage therapists [17:27] . [17:28] great. And do you have anything to [17:30] say about money and building usage fees [17:32] ? [17:33] Yes, we have [17:38] reviewed the building rental fees for all three regions [17:39] . I looked into the [17:42] rental fees, especially because of the new lawn [17:44] . We [17:47] also reviewed rental fees in similar areas [17:49] , and as a result, decided to set different [17:51] rates depending on whether the group is local or external [17:54] . The number of external organizations renting Merji Auditorium has [17:58] increased significantly, and I [18:01] believe this is because our rental fees are very affordable [18:03] . So we wanted to strike a balance between the village [18:06] assets and the fees we charge [18:09] . Also, over time, I [18:17] found out that the gym usage fees were set differently for youth basketball teams (our gym's main rental targets) [18:19] . So I wanted to [18:22] set everything right and make it clear [18:24] . Therefore, it [18:28] has been approved by all three school districts, and [18:30] the rates presented here [18:33] are based on the typical rental rates in Pine Hill [18:35] . Therefore, there are no major changes, and in [18:44] fact, gym fees [18:47] have been slightly reduced to be closer to the existing charges. [18:51] However, we are satisfied with the current level and are [18:56] trying to increase management fees every three years in accordance with contractual cost increases. [18:59] Therefore, it is very simple. This [19:01] rate applies from July 1st [19:02] . [19:04] Discussions regarding the entire region were already [19:05] concluded at the June meeting. We are [19:06] short on time, so [19:08] you will need to handle the matters regarding the two regions tonight [19:09] . However, this [19:10] information has already been conveyed to the most important [19:12] stakeholders, the youth basketball team [19:13] . They have [19:15] prepared a budget and know the fees [19:16] . Now, the [19:18] same fee [19:19] applies to both elementary schools. Thank you for your hard work [19:20] once again. [19:22] All meeting minutes are included in the materials [19:23] . [19:24] I hope you have reviewed everything. Um, three [19:26] information items, no, I'm sorry [19:28] . May I consent to approve the three agenda items [19:33] ? The retroactive approval of ACED recommendations [19:35] , approval of building rental fees, and approval of the [19:37] Sherborn Board of Education minutes for June 2 [19:39] . [19:41] Mason K, I second. Wait, [19:44] may I ask you a question? [19:49] How widely known are the building rental fees and opportunities to use the building [19:51] ? This building [19:56] is a truly valuable asset. [19:57] Yes, so when people [19:59] come to the administrative office to inquire, [20:00] groups like the Girl Scouts [20:02] sometimes rent the space [20:04] . Well, CSA naturally does [20:06] not receive rent. [20:08] We do not necessarily intend to make money with this, but rather to [20:11] serve the local community. [20:13] So, although we do [20:14] not go out of our way to promote it, we are aware that if anyone [20:16] inquires, it is [20:17] available for rent at the faculty office and [20:19] can be used at any time [20:20] . all [20:22] right. thank you. [20:25] Kate. great. Would [20:28] you like to consent to approve the three motions? [20:29] Jason K, I agree. [20:31] thank you. Would [20:32] you like to second? [20:33] Kate Jolie, I second [20:35] . [20:35] thank you. [20:37] Do you have any further discussions? Yes, I have a [20:38] question. It does [20:41] not affect whether I agree or not, but I have a [20:43] question. I am wondering if [20:44] these [20:46] allowance payments, which I fully support, require changes to the contract or job [20:48] description [20:50] . I would also like to know if this allowance will continue to be paid in the future, if [20:51] Mr. Hodges is [20:53] no longer at Pine Hill [20:57] . [20:58] Teachers sign standard contracts every year based on their teaching performance [21:02] . And these [21:05] are the additional contracts they receive. Whether it is a talent competition or a [21:07] soccer coach, each position [21:08] is assigned annually. Mr. Hoji has [21:10] gladly applied every year and [21:11] done a truly excellent job, but [21:12] if he decides not to apply, [21:13] someone else [21:15] may apply. [21:16] great. yes [21:16] . [21:17] And in fact, it was [21:19] already included in Appendix C when you signed the final contract [21:20] . It is just that I did [21:23] not receive your approval before proceeding to this point [21:25] . That is why I am here now [21:26] . yes. [21:27] Mr. Hodge was truly excellent [21:28] . [21:29] You always did your best. yes [21:30] . So, it is not a [21:31] problem with the person, but a [21:32] problem with the position. yes [21:33] . yes. yes. [21:35] The position has been approved. yes. yes [21:36] . [21:37] Yes, the position has been approved and is now [21:39] included in your educator contract [21:40] . So, it will be [21:42] filled at the principal's discretion [21:43] . Because there might be some years when you do [21:45] n't want to do a talent show [21:46] . However, the [21:49] position exists in any case, and the allowance has been [21:54] paid to the relevant employee since it was approved by ACED [21:55] . Therefore, the [21:57] payment was not delayed due to this incident [21:59] . [21:59] The payment was processed successfully [22:00] . [22:01] The committee holds a meeting every November [22:02] . We will review it if additional opportunities [22:04] or allowances arise [22:06] . For example, if the talent show [22:12] becomes very popular and the workload of the person in charge doubles, the allowance amount will be [22:13] reviewed. For more [22:16] details, please refer to Appendix C of the contract [22:18] . Yes, [22:20] that's all. Isn't that [22:21] amazing? Now, we will [22:25] proceed with the attendance vote [22:26] . Kate, [22:28] would you mind voting first? thank you [22:29] . Mason, yes. [22:31] Alpha No, yes. The motion has [22:33] been passed. Hmm, it seems like you just need to look at the information materials [22:37] . Is that right? As shown in the data [22:39] , we do [22:40] not vote on these materials [22:42] . The composition of the subcommittee [22:45] reflects the opinion of the Sherborn Education Committee [22:47] . I would appreciate it if Kate, Mason, [22:50] and Megan Nathaniel would all [22:52] review these materials thoroughly [22:54] . And [22:56] Dunn and Diane, who is sending the memos that [22:57] connect you with other organizations [22:58] ? It's [23:01] probably Diane; she should be [23:03] on the chart. If you [23:09] are a contact person for another organization, such as CSA or Town Success, the contact person will be [23:11] listed there. I would appreciate it if you could briefly [23:13] introduce yourself and let me know that you are available to [23:14] help at any time if needed [23:17] . all [23:18] right. Mason, since you are the [23:20] Chairman of the CSA, [23:22] we will take care of that part. all [23:26] right. The next item on the agenda is, [23:30] um, the minutes of the Dover Board of Education meeting [23:32] . Thank you very much for [23:33] including the meeting minutes in the meeting materials [23:35] . [23:36] Thanks to you, I was able to see what was happening in Dover [23:38] and [23:41] also view the minutes of the Dover-Sherborn Regional Board of Education meetings [23:42] . Yes, that's all [23:45] . The next meeting is on October 20 [23:47] . Hmm, [23:50] does anyone have any other questions? [23:53] Dr. Ronan, do you have any questions [23:54] ? [23:55] Yes, it's fine. [23:56] Then, since the meeting has concluded, [23:58] would you please move to adjourn [24:00] ? It is 5:54 now. [24:02] Would you please move to adjourn? [24:04] Mason K, I agree to adjourn. [24:05] thank you. [24:07] Would you please second the motion? [24:08] Kate Mansol Lilo, I second [24:09] . [24:09] thank you. [24:11] Is there anyone who agrees? Kate? yes [24:13] . [24:13] Mason? yes [24:14] . [24:15] Bella Alpha No, yes. [24:17] It seems the agreement has been passed. I will now close the meeting [24:20] .