[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:06] Good evening, everyone. It's Monday, June 22nd, 2026. It is 701 PM, and I'd like to welcome everyone to the City of [0:15] Shorewood City Council regular meeting. Please rise for the pledge of allegiance. [0:38] Our recording secretary will make note of council's attendance for the record. We do have one council member appearing online tonight. [0:46] there for all the votes must go via roll call. [0:52] Council, we do have an agenda that's been prepared. [0:54] It's been distributed to council. [0:56] It's been posted online. [0:58] In a copy can be found here in City Hall by scanning the QR code. [1:03] Are there any additions or corrections to the agenda this evening? [1:09] If not, do I have a motion to adopt the agenda? [1:13] I move to approve the agenda. [1:15] I have a motion by Council Member Sanchigrin and a second by Gorham. [1:19] We'll take a roll call vote. [1:20] Council Member Sanchigrin. [1:22] Gorham? [1:22] Degertolo? [1:24] Great. [1:25] Labdee. [1:25] I, motion carries unanimously four to zero, and tonight's agenda is here by approved. [1:31] We'll now move on to agenda item number two, the consent agenda. [1:34] The consent agenda is a series of actions, which are being considered for adoption this [1:38] evening under a single motion. [1:40] Tonight we have consent agenda items 2A through 2H. [1:45] Council, are there any questions relating to the consent agenda items? [1:51] I just have a request on item E for this one. [1:54] The water efficiency grant program. [1:57] I know that there's been some confusion among residents who qualifies. [2:02] And I went into the website and it is indicated, but further down into the website, [2:07] that only houses that subscribe to Municipal Water qualify, but I've heard some concerns with [2:15] some residents who didn't know that and went ahead and potentially bought some water-efficient [2:22] appliances. So I just want to make it clear as clear as possible in any communications that we [2:27] have that really clearly says which households qualify which ones don't. [2:35] I see staff nodding their [2:37] so note it. Any other concerns here at the council table? I do see council member [2:46] DiGritolo has her hand raised. Council member? So I wanted to, I don't have a [2:52] question about that. I have a question about item G about the elections. You [3:00] can proceed? Okay, so I would like for Ms. Thone to sort of explain so that I understand better, [3:11] how this works in terms of, I noticed that we had three city staff members that are acting [3:20] as election judges, and I know that that is normal to have some residents who happen to work for [3:29] city staff also be election judges, but it seems strange or odd to me that the person who [3:37] is setting the rate for what we pay the election judges and is responsible for doing the recruiting [3:44] of the election judges will also be a separately paid election judge. I just need to have the [4:00] Yeah, thank you, Council Member DeGrudelo. [4:03] So this year is a little bit different. [4:06] There was some legislation that was passed. [4:09] And it requires even deputized staff, [4:14] which is what our staff is. [4:16] I'm an election administrator [4:18] and I deputized staff at Shorewood [4:23] that also can do election duties in house [4:28] in a non-partisan matter. [4:32] Election judges stand for our precincts, primarily, [4:38] and they also, the two major parties, [4:45] some things have to be done in the precincts [4:49] that require one person from each major party [4:53] to ensure the fairness of elections. [4:57] and there are a few specific duties, so in the last election there were some issues with [5:06] deputized staff doing some of these duties, [5:11] and so this year legislation was passed that there [5:16] are certain duties that even deputized staff have to be trained as election judges, which we [5:25] off of the training, so we all go through the training anyway, and we have to declare our [5:31] party and then to be able to do some of these duties fairly that they have taken away [5:41] that right of deputized staff to be able to do that, and now we need to act as an election [5:50] judge to do certain duties. So, that's why, I mean, if you look back, every election year [5:59] our staff is on there because we also act as the absentee ballot board along with other [6:08] election judges. So, there are many, many rules that we play, and there's a wide variation [6:17] and of what falls into deputy staff and an election judge role. [6:22] We do not staff the precincts ourselves. [6:25] We do not work in the precincts. [6:27] That's all election judges that we hire and have recruited [6:32] as are in this resolution tonight. [6:36] Does that make sense? [6:38] OK, so are you saying that they're not being paid separately? [6:42] It's just duties that they're doing [6:44] in their salary job as the city staff? [6:47] Correct. [6:48] So that be positive legislation. [6:52] We actually have to take this training [6:54] and become an election judge [6:58] to do these party balance, certain party balance, tasks, [7:06] in lieu of what we used to be able to do [7:10] as deputy staff, correct. [7:11] But we still, we're still working under election staff. [7:17] Okay, but you're not, they're not receiving additional pay as election judges, I guess, was my question. [7:22] No, no, no, they're not. [7:25] Okay, thank you. That makes sense. [7:30] Council, other any other questions relating to consent agenda items 2A through 2H. Hearing none, do I have a motion? [7:40] I move to approve the consent agenda. [7:43] I have a motion by council member San Chagrin, and a second by gorum will do a roll call vote, San Chagrin. [7:48] I. Gorham, digger tolo, I. Labdee, I. Motion carries unanimously for zero. [7:55] We'll now move on to matters from the floor. Matters from the floor is an opportunity for members of the public to bring a matter related to the governance of the city of Shorewood to the attention of the city council. [8:07] If the matter relates to a topic that is identified on tonight's agenda as a public hearing, please hold your comments until the public hearing is opened. [8:15] The full rules for this forum can be found on the agenda table in back and on the city's website. [8:23] Anyone wishing to address the council should raise their hand, or if you're appearing remotely, [8:29] please click the Raise Your Hand button on your screen and wait to be called on. [8:33] Please make your comments from the podium and identify yourself by your first and your last name as well as your address for our record. [8:40] Please limit your comments to five minutes. [8:42] No discussion or action will be taken by the Council on this matter. [8:47] If requested by the Council, City staff will prepare a report for the Council regarding [8:53] the matter and place it on a future agenda. [8:56] And there are no public hearings this evening. [8:59] So if you want to discuss the matter that you see later on in the agenda, we will not [9:04] be opening it up to the public later in the agenda. [9:07] So speaking, it matters from the floor would be the proper space to air your concerns if you have any. [9:15] Is there anyone here this evening for matters from the floor? [9:19] Sir, if you could come up please and identify yourself by your first and your last name as well as your address for the record. [9:31] Hi, I'm Todd Martha, 2 5 6 5 0 maple view court. [9:36] Mayor and council members, I'm here to talk again. [9:39] Unfortunately, about Watt and Ponds, I'm sure you were hoping that that was in the rear [9:43] of your mirror. [9:44] I want to bring to your attention what I believe is a serious problem with the record [9:48] that has been filed in the appeal of your decision to require the environmental assessment [9:52] worksheet for the Watt and Ponds project. [9:54] The appeals court makes this decision based on the record that was available to you. [9:59] Unfortunately, if the record filed with the court of appeals does not appear to contain [10:03] all the information provided to you and discuss value for your decision, that matters [10:08] because the court is not going to decide whether it agrees with your decision, it decides whether [10:13] your decision was reasonable based on the information that was before you. In other words, [10:17] the court can only judge you by evaluating the record that it receives, which it assumes [10:22] is the same record that you had. The problem is that important portions of that record appear [10:26] to be missing. They were not filed with the court of appeals. For example, the record contains [10:31] agenda packets, but the packets do not contain all materials that are provided to the council [10:36] before the February 23 meeting. For example, I submitted a detailed letter regarding the EAW that provided extensive factual support [10:43] for why the EAW exception claimed by the developer did not apply. The letter was provided to Council members prior to the meeting [10:50] and Council members discussed information from that submission during the deliberations. Yet the letter itself is not included in the record. [10:58] Even though my cover email said, please ensure that this material is entered into the public record for the Council's discussion of this matter. [11:04] Even more troubling, the transcript provided to the Court as part of the record omits the discussion that occurred during matters from the floor. [11:13] Residents, as this meeting, were not allowed to speak during the Council's discussion if the EAW itself. [11:19] The only opportunity residents had to prevent it to present information was during matters from the floor. [11:24] Residents provided extensive factual information, observation, and analysis that supported the EAW. [11:29] Yet that entire discussion appears to be missing from the transcript that was filed with the court, residents were simply erased. [11:37] The effect of these emissions is significant, much of the factual support for your decision seems to have disappeared from the record. [11:44] I want to emphasize what this means. [11:46] When the court reviews your decision, it will not know what information is missing. [11:50] It will not second-guess the record. [11:52] It will simply see a record that contains less evidence supporting your decision than was actually presented to you. [11:57] In other words, a current record does not fully reflect the basis for your decision and incorrectly [12:03] suggest that you may not have had a valid basis for that decision. [12:07] You voted to require an EW after reviewing information from staff, developers, experts, [12:12] and residents. [12:13] If materials that you reviewed and relied on are absent from the record, the court is not [12:17] seeing the same case that you saw. [12:19] The practical impact is significant. [12:21] The city may lose a legal case, not because of any issues with the city's conduct, but [12:26] because the city's team failed to present an accurate picture of the Council's actions. [12:31] That should concern you regardless of your position on the E.A.W. [12:34] The issue is or that the Council can rely on its team to properly represent the Council [12:38] in its decisions. [12:39] This is much bigger than Watt and Ponds, it goes to the very authority of this Council. [12:44] The outcome in this matter may come down not to what the Council did, or how the Council [12:49] evoked it, but to administrative activities undertaken in the background. [12:52] In fact, it's not the council deciding this issue, but the person who is preparing the record. [12:58] A failure to have a complete record also creates the impression that each of you did not act with proper care and diligence, [13:05] and made important decisions, basically, willy-nilly, you made them up. It was a flight of fancy. [13:12] Without bothering to understand the facts, it is an unjustified and unfair stain on the record of this council, [13:18] and a deep and extensive work that you put into reviewing and judging the E.A.W. request. [13:24] You might recall that you had to make a decision on whether part of the development was in [13:28] 300 feet of an adjacent wetland. Every bit of factual information about that has been removed from the [13:33] record. Your decision on that looks like it was just made up, fabricated. Now, I'm not sure from [13:40] your perspective whether you really felt that that decision was any, any, my, no, but when it comes to [13:46] the Court of Appeals is going to see that is exactly what they are going to be told. [13:52] I encourage the Council to review the record that has been filed and determine whether accurately [13:56] affects the information that was presented to you before your decision. If it does not, [14:01] then the city's legal counsel is being weak, position is being weakened unnecessarily because [14:06] evidence supporting your decision is not being presented to the Court. We know that gravity [14:11] investment's position from the very beginning is that the Council made all kinds of decisions [14:15] with no factual basis. We know that, that's what they've said because they have to say that. [14:21] But in this case, to have a public filing made by your team that supports the narrative [14:26] that the City Council acted without basis. That's got to hurt. And I think we need to decide [14:32] you need to decide, is that what you want posterity to see? Do you want them to forever believe [14:38] that that's how you make your decisions? Thank you. Thank you for your comments, Mr. Murza. [14:44] Yeah, I'd like that to be done, I think we need to review, make sure the record's full and with all the information that we provided, how we still timely to add new items to the record. [14:55] I think those are questions for the attorney. [15:03] Is there anyone else here this evening for matters from the floor? Sir, if you could come up, please state your first and last name for the record, as well as your address, and at that point in time, you'll have approximately five minutes. [15:14] Thank you. My name is Kline Geisinger. My wife and I, on our daughter live at 6140 Mill Street in Shorewood. [15:25] We have been there for 38 years and we have had two wells, the well that was existing [15:35] when we first moved and then we had to drill another well because that one went dry. [15:41] So I am standing here today to support the installation of the water main along mill street [15:50] So that we can have water that is good water. [16:00] I have some questions, but I'm assuming that I won't get any answers, is that correct? [16:09] That's correct. [16:10] This part of the meeting is not an interactive. [16:12] However, the Milk Street Water Main Project is going to be discussed at length tonight, [16:17] and that is item 4F. [16:19] Right. [16:20] I saw that. [16:21] I encourage you to stay. [16:23] I'll do. [16:24] Thank you. [16:25] your comments. Is there anyone else here this evening who would like to speak to the council [16:29] at matters from the floor? Sir, if you could come up, [16:36] if you could please state your [16:37] name and address for the record and at that point in time you'll have approximately five minutes. [16:42] My name is Daniel Brzoni. I live at 61 10 mill Street, Glenn's my neighbor. I've been there [16:49] for about four years. I am also here in support of the water main. I think there are a few [16:57] A few issues for discussion that I hope the board will get to this evening. [17:01] We recently received a survey to assess interest in view of the additional costs being assessed [17:07] by Chan Hassan. [17:09] I did not fill in that survey because I didn't feel that I could, given the ways that the questions [17:15] were phrased. [17:15] I had too much uncertainty. [17:18] I believe the first question was something about what I still support the project. [17:22] Obviously, I'm standing here today, I'm strongly in favor of it. [17:25] But I think the costs are both the reason and the amount are unclear to homeowners along [17:31] mill Street. [17:33] I live on about two and a half acres. [17:35] I don't know where the connection would be from my house to the street. [17:39] That could be a very large difference in the amount of directional drilling. [17:44] I also don't understand why both shorewood and chan has some are applying a fee for what [17:50] seems like the same work. [17:52] And so if there's, you know, if Chan Hassan is decided to assess a fee, or are they going to do some of the work, [17:57] such that Shorewood wouldn't need to charge that fee. [18:00] So I think the materials we've received when I do the math, [18:05] depending on where the connections would be to my house, [18:08] whether Chan Hassan would be assessing the fee as well as Shorewood, [18:12] I get a range of something like 10,000 to 75,000 altars. [18:16] That is a huge difference in the cost of attaching our house to the city water. [18:24] We've also seen some materials about the city providing financing for these options, [18:30] but we don't have any information about over a time period, at what interest rate, [18:35] what the terms of that would look like. [18:37] And so, well-in theory, I'm very much in favor of this project. [18:41] I think we need to have more information about both of the costs would be and what the project would look like in order to answer the questions that were provided in that survey. [18:52] I also know that many folks myself included along Milk Street have gravel driveways. [18:58] We've seen a lot about directional drilling, but I don't know if I can dig a trench. [19:03] There seem like a lot of options that we could be considering, and maybe it's just too early in the process to know, [19:09] which of those options are going to be feasible for the city. [19:13] But anyway, a lack of clarity, but overall support, [19:16] despite not filling in the survey. [19:19] OK, thank you for your comments. [19:21] Is there anyone else here this evening for matters from the floor? [19:25] Barry, if you could come up please, Mr. Brown. [19:29] I know. [19:35] Barry Brown, 60, 50, Burlwood Court. [19:37] Since there was a $20,000 invoice from Bolton and make for the Shorewood Lane Revene project on the agenda tonight, I thought I'd talk about it. [19:47] The City Project is Project 17-15. I want to raise awareness of the project since November of 2021, four and a half years, Bolton and make has invoiced the city 36 times for 149,475 dollars. [20:06] And it looks like funding for Bolton and making invoices are coming from two sources. [20:12] The Street Reconstruction Fund, which is ST-2306, and a $50,000 grant from Hennepin County, [20:20] have been reviewing the council meeting minutes going back several years, and I want to [20:24] raise a few questions and make a request. [20:27] I'm not here to oppose fixing the Revene, that's for council to decide. [20:31] My concern is about cost, funding, and how the project has moved through the council. [20:38] Here's what the record shows. [20:40] The city has tracked the remains since 2014. [20:44] When it was first budgeted, the figure was around $300,000. [20:49] The most recent estimate is between $640 and $805,000. [20:55] I understand why, piping the channel turned out to be not permittable. [21:00] And the design had shifted over the years towards a Gambian basket. [21:05] That was not permitted. [21:06] And now it's towards soft armoring the watershed district. [21:10] Engineering, reality, realities are a change. [21:15] But a project that grows from $300,000 to potentially $800,000 [21:22] deserves a clear public accounting of how it got there. [21:26] My second concern is how the funding has come together because the entire plan depends on stacking outside money on top of the city tax dollars. [21:37] Over the past two years the Council authorized grant applications to several sources. [21:42] and MPEC Stormwater Resiliency Grant, the League of Minnesota City's Grant, a [21:49] Hennepin County Opportunity Grant, and a Hennepin County Cost Participation [21:54] Request. [21:55] The meeting minutes also mentioned MNDAT MSA State Aid covering 55% of the cost. [22:03] I can only confirm from the records that the City accepted a $50,000 Hennepin County [22:10] opportunity grant. In March of last year, what I can't find in the meeting minutes is the outcome of the others. [22:20] So my questions are simple, and I'd ask the staff to put the answers on the record. [22:27] We're the MPCA and the League of Minnesota. [22:30] What a city grant applications awarded, denied, or withdrawn. Did henniping county cost participation [22:37] request come through? And what is the current confirmed funding break down for the project today? [22:45] How much from the grants, how much from state aid, and how much from shoreward taxpayers? [22:52] My third point is about the process. Almost every council action on this project from grant [22:58] authorization, grant acceptance, cost participation request was approved on the consent agenda. [23:07] In a single-budget bundled motion with no separate discussions, individually each step may [23:15] have been routine, but taking together, they add up to a project approaching three quarters [23:21] of a million dollars that has held very little public airing. [23:25] As far as I can tell, the last time there was a substantial discussion was August of 2023. [23:34] This is on a 12-year project. [23:37] So here's my request before we spend any more money on designs and research. [23:42] I'm asking the council to put it on a regular agenda as a standalone item. [23:46] Let the staff walk us all through the design, the total cost, the confirming funding sources, [23:52] and that'll bring daylight to the final decisions that you all will make. [23:58] I appreciate that this is on as a project request and it is solving a potential problems. [24:05] I do mean a potential problem because 14 year or 12 years ago, [24:09] it was also slated as a potential problem. [24:13] So we don't know if it's still a potential problem or if it's a real big problem right now. [24:18] Thank you very much for your time. [24:20] Thank you, Mr. Brown, your comments are noted for the record and they've been heard by staff. [24:25] Is there anyone else here this evening for matters from the floor? [24:30] Sir, if you could come up and please state your first and last name and your address for the record, [24:34] and at that point in time, you'll be given approximately five minutes. [24:37] No problem. Mike Bedford, 6025, Milk Street, [24:42] been there since August of 2000. [24:44] I'm going to show a resident for 50 some years. [24:49] It's about the Mill Street Project, which was in discussion for 15 years, probably. [24:55] At the last second, we're throwing in city water. [24:59] I'm not for the city water at 30 to 60,000 bucks. [25:04] I have my own well. [25:05] It's great. [25:06] Drink coffee every day. [25:07] I can fly in water from Italy from my neighbor. [25:12] So, the cost of this, in the last second, after talking about the project for 15 years, [25:19] city water was just brought up. [25:22] Not a fan of the city water. [25:23] I have it well. [25:25] Don't have the funds. [25:26] We negotiated. [25:27] We got a hand-uping county commissioner here tonight. [25:30] We negotiated with hand-uping county because we lost trees. [25:33] We lost landscape. [25:35] And we settled for pennies on the dollar. [25:38] I can't hire a landscape company to replace what we had. [25:43] Now you're talking about double that those funds for me to pay for city water. [25:47] I'm out. [25:48] Not doing it. [25:49] And there's plenty more people that should get up here and talk tonight. [25:54] Okay, thank you for your comments, staff. [25:56] You heard the questions, perhaps when we discuss this later on in agenda for F, you can address [26:02] some of those this evening. [26:04] Serve if you'd like to come up and if you could state your first and last name and your [26:08] address for the record and at that point in time you'll have approximately five minutes. [26:12] Bert Cotkey, 60, 40 in those street, I left between the flashing go faster signs, [26:20] they know what [26:21] I mean. [26:21] And you do too. [26:29] I'm not against this if the majority of the residents on that road wanted. [26:39] in two weeks, we're having the 250th anniversary of our country. It's we the people. [26:46] It's not a few, and I'm not, I know all the neighbors. The cost is ridiculous. There's [26:53] young people that I've talked to that aren't here for what the reason. We can't blame them for [26:57] not being here. They were astounded as what the cost is going to be. The communication with the [27:04] City is terrible. [27:07] County is better. [27:10] You can't even get the garbage there, right, for us. [27:13] We can't even get old. [27:16] This is ridiculous. [27:19] Thank you. [27:20] Thank you for your comments, sir. [27:23] Is there anyone else here this evening for matters from the floor? [27:25] Sir, if you could come up and sit your first last name in your address for the record, [27:29] and then you'll have approximately five minutes. [27:32] My name is David Anderson, I live at 1635, Mill Street, my neighbors. [27:39] So I am not against it 100 percent, but it's out of this world of expensive. [27:46] Just because I plan to have this house in my generations for years and years. [27:53] It'll be in my family, it'll be in my grandchildren, I don't plan to sell it. [27:57] So the idea of having fresh water would be great. [27:59] I'm not too impressed with some of the notes we get. [28:05] We got a bulletin through, but a month ago from City of Excelsior, better [28:11] bouleur water. [28:12] I don't want to do with any of that. [28:13] I would rather deal with the bad weld that I have, but it's all, there's arsenic in my [28:19] water, there's rust, everybody has rusty toilets, it's okay. [28:24] But I would rather have that than boiling my water. [28:27] So that's my biggest concern is that are you going to provide good enough water and if you if you did the math [28:37] It's seven to ten thousand dollars a [28:40] Well time [28:42] So what they're proposing I could do maybe 15 wells for that price and I would black gladly pay that [28:51] but again it has to be affordable it has to be [28:57] Frankly, because what happens is we pay for all this and we don't hook up to it but it [29:04] runs through our house according to what you put out. [29:08] You're still going to charge us a monthly fee for nothing. [29:11] It's going to sit in my basement because I won't hook it up but for my future children, [29:17] I would love to have that. [29:19] I would talk to Bert every now and then and many years ago when he first moved in, they [29:25] could have dropped the line but they did not do it because I don't know what was it and I don't [29:30] know why it goes from there to there that's either miss whatever never mind. So I think it has [29:39] to be revisited affordability and I'm in construction. I know what I need inch well cost to [29:46] put in. I mean a water line because we had a building up on Highway 7 and we worked with the [29:51] we worked with the state because it was the highway and they're like, just dig it and we'll connect it. [29:58] They didn't charge us a million dollars. [30:11] Thank you for your comments. Is there anyone else here this evening for matters from the floor? [30:23] Okay? Seeing no one in our audience here, is there anyone in our online viewing audience who would like to speak matters from the floor? [30:30] If so, please indicate by pushing the raise your hand feature on the bottom of your screen. [30:39] Staff, I'm not seeing any, are you? [30:43] Okay, then that concludes matters from the floor. [30:47] We'll now move on to agenda item number four general business. [30:51] Four A, we have a presentation by Hennepang County Commissioner Heather Edelson. [30:55] Ms. Edelson? Commissioner? [31:02] Well, good evening. I apologize. My presentation's like 20 minutes. [31:06] Sorry, I know you guys didn't really want to see this, and I'm just going to pull it up here in case I can't see. [31:12] Okay, well, thank you. Yeah, if you guys want to get some outside time and don't want to listen to me, I totally understand and won't be offended. [31:20] All right, so I also just want to say it's good to see all of you, but I love. I've been, you know, I've 16 cities that I represent 200,000 people. It's a lot. [31:29] spend a lot of city councils and you're the first one that allows [31:32] speaking from at home. So thank you. That's really, I just want to know that. [31:36] That's a, that's a nice thing that I, that you just did. [31:39] All right. So, all right. So, [31:41] ahead of in county, we are, we're going to go ahead and get started because I know people want [31:44] to talk about military project. So, oh, hold on. That's not me. [31:49] Oh, we're going to go down. Good. All right. So, 1852 is when the county was [31:54] started anybody have a fun trivia I like trivia competition like anybody know when the state [31:59] of Minnesota became a state. Just guess, come on come on you guys, huh? 50 years, good job, all right. [32:09] I would play trivia with you. 1858 became a state. So county was the county became a county before [32:14] we became a state. So kind of a fun fact. We have 45 cities, 1.3 million residents. I have 16 [32:20] of those 45 cities, and I think I have a graph that shows you, we have 8, Fortune 500 [32:25] companies, 607 square miles, and 11 watershed districts, biggest being, sorry I'll stop this, [32:33] just one more, just give me one more. Largest lake in Hennepin County is, who? Yes, [32:41] Lake Wendysack, okay, I promise I'm done, all right. So this is just a little word cloud that I [32:47] have my staff put together, I can't see it that far because it's too small, but hopefully [32:53] you probably can't either. But there's some good stuff on there. People wonder what [32:56] had it been County does. We do a lot. We do a lot. So we have H.C.M. Sandress. So when you're [33:02] calling 911 and you know fire is dispatching, well we first of all we do the dispatch. So when [33:07] you're calling 911 and who's answering the phone, it's dispatch for the sheriff's department. [33:11] we're dispatching and then we're sending out, [33:14] it will go to the Excel Sear Fire or South Lake PD. [33:20] If they can respond, but if we need an ambulance, [33:23] they're both responding. [33:24] And of course, the cities make in the contract [33:25] of how that response looks. [33:27] But Hennepen EMS is responding for sure would. [33:31] And when I came on, Mayor, I just want to thank you. [33:33] I had a conversation with the mayor and all of the, [33:37] and round of the lakes and I said, [33:38] well, how are service times doing? [33:40] And one of the things that we [33:41] worked on right away with making sure we had a station of an EMS ambulance, I would have [33:46] the Sherwood area and so just congrats on helping fix that and hopefully times are getting [33:52] better. [33:53] If they're not, you have my cards so you can pass them around. [33:58] All right, so other things, so I just want to highlight a few other things. [34:01] So when you're going any public pool, I mean we do a lot more than these things, but I just [34:05] want to give you three tangible things that we do that people don't think about. [34:09] When you go to a public pool, every public pool in Hennep and County, we inspect, we make sure [34:14] it safe. [34:15] So, chlorine levels, things like that. [34:17] Every restaurant you attend, or that you're going out to eat, we make sure that the restaurant [34:22] is safe to eat at. [34:24] So, just fun things, and then we, of course, issue your property taxes and you pay for all [34:29] of these things. [34:30] All right. [34:31] So, the current budget, what I'm going to talk about today, is healthcare, state and federal [34:35] cost shifts that we're seeing and county service delivery. [34:39] All right, so what you'll see is our budget is 3.15 billion, [34:43] and you'll see what the pie, this is the revenue. [34:47] So 35% of that is property taxes. A lot of this, you'll see it's kind of broken up, [34:53] but state federal and then federal and state combined are a big chunk [34:57] of where we actually get a lot of our funding to. [35:01] And what we're going to go to expenditures though, here we go. [35:04] So this is where the money goes. [35:05] So that was where the money comes in, [35:07] the money goes out here. [35:09] And so the money goes out with health and human services, [35:11] being about 50% of our budget. [35:13] I was at therapist before I came elected. [35:16] I was also in the House of Representatives [35:17] before I took this job specifically [35:20] because of all the health and human services [35:22] that, and it's not partisan, which is kind of nice. [35:25] So we have health and human services, [35:27] a big part of it, we do county waivers, [35:30] we do senior assistance, as well, [35:33] resident services, you'll see that little orange line of budget, it's a very small amount, [35:38] but it's what a lot of people think about is our libraries. [35:42] Public works is our roads and bridges, and that's also capital improvements though we talked [35:47] about, I was giving residents, letting them know that our coalabridge we're going to be updating [35:53] that in a few years and so we're going to have to do a lot of outreach, I think that's [35:57] going to be very disruptive in general for the Lake area community. [36:01] and then lost safety and justice, so that's the county attorney's office share of [36:05] department. And so we're going to keep going. And then in this budget, I just want to [36:09] make sure you guys know 3.5 billion. That does not include the hospital in this [36:14] budget. The hospital is actually a separate entity. It's a $1.7 billion entity [36:18] all of itself. And we're currently right now, which I did not want to be, but why [36:22] I'm on the hospital board. So that's a whole different area of policy. I know [36:26] policy, but I've never worked in a hospital. I was an outpatient therapist, and so [36:31] totally different than what I was thinking. So we're hiring a board, and I'm going to talk [36:34] about this later. We're hiring a board, which is good, and we've hired a company now that [36:38] will help us fill that seat. Okay, so this is the sources of revenue. No one can see this. I [36:43] really apologize. It's incredibly small, but what I just want to show you here is the trend [36:47] with the first one. The trend with the first is how property tax reliance has gone up. And you'll [36:53] the trend line is going up. So the navy blue is for 2024. The light blue line is 2025 and then the [37:01] green line is 2026. That trend is something we need to get a hand a hold of. I've let my colleagues [37:07] know we're having we've all agreed that monthly budget meetings is what we're doing usually [37:11] what happens in local government is you have everything truth in taxation happens towards the end of [37:16] the year. We're trying to get ahead of that because ultimately we can't all be fighting at the end of [37:21] It's too much and so we're trying to make sure that we're cutting as we're going earlier is better because that trendline cannot continue [37:30] I think my colleagues are agreeing, which is great. So we'll also see is the third column over. You'll see that federal funding has gone down. It's gone down even more than that. [37:41] The green being the current and then state funding is right next to the federal and you'll see that it's kind of shifted up and down. So not really reliable. [37:49] and then just a, you know, fees for service that big shot up the LCS 12345 over. [37:55] There's a big, a lot of, remember, real ID? Well, our service centers were really bit busy. [38:00] Everybody hopefully has their real ID now. Next, I can't see this. Does that say expenditures? [38:08] Sorry, I need my glasses. Okay, okay. Okay, so expenditures, yes. So what we have is public safety [38:16] budget has been going up in law safety injustice. You'll see that trend line. We made the news a few [38:23] weeks ago or maybe there was a month ago some of my colleagues said, you know, the sheriff's [38:28] department, we shouldn't be funding public safety. I disagree. Of course, the sheriff plays a really [38:33] important role in public safety for our county. As you all probably know, the sheriff is who does [38:39] water patrol for Lake Minotanka and actually all waterways in [38:43] Hennep and County. Also, we run the jail, the Sheriff runs the jail, [38:47] for Hennep and County. And so law enforcement all throughout Hennep [38:50] and County will bring people to the jail. The sheriff does not have [38:54] the authority to say, Oh, you know what? Our jail's full. We can't take [38:57] you. We have to actually find another place for that person. So, or [39:02] we have to take them if we have room. And then, so people also say, well, [39:05] we have them in there so long. [39:08] Who lets the people out of the jail? [39:10] It's not the sheriff either. [39:11] It is not the county attorney's office. [39:13] It is the courts. [39:15] So the judge is the one that gets to say, [39:16] okay, you can leave the court. [39:17] So we have a lot of people that are staying longer. [39:20] There's complex mental illness happening. [39:23] And so the costs are going up, [39:25] but we have a statutory authority to provide the public safety. [39:28] And so just so you know, [39:30] if you hear news about that, [39:32] always feel free to talk to me. [39:33] I'm happy to answer questions about that. [39:35] Our health budget has gone up dramatically. [39:38] There's been some shifts in things which have been challenging. [39:42] So some of that has been funding that we have given for the hospital. [39:46] And then human services we've been pretty steady. [39:48] So we'll see. [39:49] The last one I just want to point out is our capital improvement program has gone down. [39:53] When there's not a lot of money investments go down. [39:55] So always think about if you're having a hard time paying your mortgage, [39:58] you're probably not going to do an addition. [40:01] All right. [40:02] So apologize. [40:02] I really love analogies. [40:04] 2026 federal cuts. And so here I'm going to go through it's just a few and I'm trying to be as fast as I can. I know people don't want to listen to this totally. [40:12] But SNAP we have some cuts here that I want to highlight for you eight million was cut this year. [40:19] And those are, so SNAP how that works is that's the food benefit that we have now in a lot of other states. [40:25] How SNAP works is that a food assistance program is that the state actually administers it here in Minnesota [40:32] We it is the county administer program so all the counties [40:36] If you meet with any of us right now, we're saying we're we're we're we're having a hard time here [40:42] Because we do a lot for the state [40:45] So what they did is they cut eight million of the administrative cost and so we had to make those cuts, but we've already [40:52] essentially spent that money. So that happened and there's more coming up. Terminated grants, we have these [40:58] FEMA grants which are for supportive housing, so those people with disabilities that we have housed. We got cut 2.18 million. [41:06] We're going to keep going. All right, anticipated cuts here. So for Snap, there's an error rate. This is a little [41:12] complicated council, so I'm going to stick with me here for a second. So a Snap error rate. So again, [41:17] and other states administering the SNAP program. [41:20] Hennep and County are error rate is, I think we are at 8.9. [41:27] And the federal government in HR1 said we want error rates to be at 6%. [41:33] And so the difference between that 6% and that 8.9% is what we're going to be hit with [41:39] as about $20 million. [41:40] So we have asked the federal administration to give us more time. [41:47] The only person that got carved out Clevver Senator was Alaska. [41:52] So Alaska was able to make a deal that they are not subject to the error rate. [41:56] Everybody else is in who actually has an error rate that's higher than 6% [42:00] in the United States is about 45 other states. [42:05] So HUD. [42:07] What's the error rate again? [42:08] So the error. Oh, yeah, thank you. I didn't get no, thank you council member. So what the error rate is is somebody [42:13] So there's a met system [42:16] Sorry you guys county policies really complicated [42:18] All right, so there's a met system which is where people apply for food assistance that goes into the met system [42:24] So our people are county employees are entering in somebody calls and says I want food assistance [42:29] We say okay give us your income and they'll provide their pay checkstubs [42:33] For the last two pay checkstubs sometimes they don't have a paycheck step [42:37] So then we say, well, can you estimate what your income was last year on your tax returns? [42:41] Sometimes people don't file tax returns. [42:43] So we are having to sometimes take the paycheck steps, which their income can go up or down. [42:49] We are sometimes having to take other amounts and maybe what they just report, [42:53] they're Social Security income to be. [42:55] And then maybe there's a change in that. [42:57] But the error rate is what they say their income is to what it shows up as a tax return. [43:02] people don't always have tax returns, the Met system will connect with the federal government and we don't get a return back. [43:09] It's kind of like a black hole. We put the numbers in and about six weeks to eight weeks later, we'll get a number that it says there's might be some disparity between the numbers. [43:19] So that's the error rate. I know it's complicated. It's hard to explain quite frankly. [43:24] All right, so, HUD, I was in Washington DC for a conference and we're looking at what is this [43:32] 12 million for cuts in, this is again for our support of housing, grants and the federal government [43:40] is reporting that we have too many people on this, we've had a lot of success with this. [43:45] We know that when people are housed, our ER visits go down, when people are housed, the criminal justice system calls go down. [43:52] And so we're really at a challenging point. [43:54] We want to keep these funded. [43:56] We want to keep people housed. [43:58] But we're in a moment where we're very challenged on this. [44:01] In Medicaid numbers, that's so weird. [44:03] We actually have a number for it. [44:04] It's about 40 million that we're going to be cut in Medicaid. [44:07] HR1 and the funding bill that they have. [44:09] So you think about this. [44:11] People don't think about what the county's funded, [44:13] where we get Medicaid. [44:14] You're like, what do you mean you get Medicaid? [44:15] Well, we get Medicaid. [44:16] When any time somebody works with the child protection system, [44:19] we have a lot of social workers. [44:20] We get Medicaid for that. [44:21] we have a lot of at home visitors. We get Medicaid for that. And so now we are faced with, [44:27] oh, and this is the other thing, about 75% of what we do is mandated by the state and federal [44:34] government. They've said, you must do this, but they have cut us in terms of the funding. So [44:39] when I was at the legislature, they called that it unfunded mandate, and I was always like, [44:43] are you sure and then I get it because it actually is. [44:48] So yeah, that's the all funding that we have to do. [44:51] We are cutting back on some of the things, [44:53] and so we're going through everything [44:55] that's mandated versus not mandated and we're making cuts. [45:00] All right, we're going to keep almost done. So, property taxes, residence and shortwards, property tax increase of about 8.6%. So, if your home was 721,000, it went up to about 740,000, and you saw 2.6% increase taxable value and tax capacity, tax capacity is incredibly complicated, but I just like to say it's the state law that shows you're going to pay a bigger portion of the pie because you have homes that are worth more. [45:30] look at all of Hennep and County, the people that are paying more districts, all of our homes [45:34] are not all of them, but a lot of them, a large percentage of them are 5,500,000 or more, [45:41] and then with 500,000 or more, you're paying 1.25% right, you guys 1.25% it's ringing right, [45:48] I'm just going to go with it. 1.25% versus 1% so you're paying a larger portion of the pie based [45:56] on how much your home value is. [45:58] So 8.6% is what sure would residents [46:01] on property taxes. [46:02] We're going to try to keep that lower. [46:04] I'm doing what I can. [46:06] All right, just a few more slides. [46:08] Had it been county medical center, [46:10] we all probably have saw the news about it. [46:12] We just got saved from the state government. [46:15] We got 25 million for this year. [46:18] And then we have a reserve account for 500 million. [46:21] Before that, and I just want to make, [46:23] So our levy last year for Hennep and County was 7.79. [46:29] Levy increased and four points of that was specifically for the hospital. [46:36] And so we have a lot of people. [46:37] I think you've still that's 40 million. [46:40] So 40 million of that of that 40 million. [46:43] An uncompensated care under care that is not rimbursed. [46:47] About 20 million of that was coming from outside of our district. [46:52] And so we went to the state and said this can't continue. [46:56] And so we did get money for that. [46:57] We still do have some limits on other hospitals transferring patients with no insurance [47:02] to us because this is what happens. [47:05] It's getting very frustrating. [47:06] This stabilized people because, and Tala policies, it's federal policy that says you have to [47:11] stabilize the person, but then they'll transfer them to HCMC for care. [47:15] So making it so that taxpayers are paying for it versus the hospitals, other hospitals. [47:20] So we're trying to fight that a little bit. [47:23] All right, and making sure you know about this mark, [47:26] we have a Hennepin County. [47:27] We're doing 9,000 for each city for early voting. [47:31] OK, good. [47:31] We've made sure you've emailed for that good. [47:34] And then we're going to continue working [47:36] on how to support cities. [47:37] I think it's something we should be doing more [47:39] as supporting cities, other counties, [47:41] actually do a lot around elections [47:42] and I want to see a few more support for elections. [47:46] And so financially, that could be a big savings for cities [47:49] if we continue to look at resources on that. [47:53] Just a few things we've opened up, [47:54] Youth Crisis Stabilization Center, [47:56] this project was about 15 million. [47:58] There's only 13 beds. [47:59] You're like 15 million, 13 beds. [48:01] How does the math math here? [48:03] But it actually does. [48:04] So when we a child has turned over to Hennepin County [48:07] and they're in our custody and have behavioral concerns, [48:10] as well as mental health concerns, [48:11] and usually those are co-occurring at the same time, [48:14] we would have instances where we'd be over $1 million [48:17] for a child to send them to another state and so and we would it would be for [48:22] quite some time. They would be also removed from their family. Here we're [48:26] able to do family therapy, have the child in a sort of term stay and it's been [48:30] very successful. We have the new public safety headquarters in Plymouth, the [48:35] Sheriff's Department's very happy about this. Lovely. If you haven't seen it, I'm [48:39] sending out an email. I think it's two weeks from now, just to start setting up [48:43] a choice for August, if anybody wants to come. [48:47] And last year, I think we went to the middle of the seminar [48:48] office. [48:49] I think you came, so that mayor of which was nice, [48:51] given that we drive the exact same car. [48:53] I think I went to your car or you came to mind. [48:56] All right, so these are short-shore wood projects [48:58] that we have. [49:02] So there's the County Road Night Team Preservation Project. [49:06] We have the Sunset Drive Road, Reconstruction, [49:08] and of course the Mill Street Pathway Project, [49:10] which it doesn't sound like you need [49:12] before because that city water would not actually be a part of the county but you guys keep [49:17] us posted on what you decide on that. And that is it. I like that. Thank you commissioner [49:25] council. There are any questions for the commissioner regarding her report. Thanks for your [49:30] report commissioner Allison. Just a couple questions. The hospital is that self fund, how does [49:35] a funding with the hospital work? Is it subsidized by the county taxpayers or is it self funding? [49:42] Thank you council member. It's a great question. I wish it was all so funded. There has been a [49:48] subsidy. We subsidized the hospital for 40 million every year and we last year we took over as [49:57] the hospital board because we were having some issues for the funding. Well maybe you've read that you've [50:02] probably heard some of the news hopefully. There was a possibility that we were going to have to close [50:07] and then we looked at projections where we were going to have to cut 100 million, we were able [50:11] to make some cuts from the hospital, but nowhere near enough. So it is subsidized by the [50:17] county. What I would like to see as we move forward, I've been doing a lot of, I'm a public policy [50:24] nerd, why I always kid say I'm like Bob the builder, but like I love policy. What I would say [50:29] is the best, what I've looked at is having a hospital district. And so that's keeping HCMC intact, [50:36] but creating instead of it's a subsidiary of the county, creating a hospital district, which would [50:42] essentially keep it there, but then we would have it a part of a subsidiary of the state. [50:47] And now it's historic that the state of Minnesota actually gave funding for this. [50:51] They've never gave money for an institution in this nature for a hospital, but also a hospital [50:57] that is publicly owned hospital. So it says something Jim Malcolm is going to be cheering the [51:01] forward, figuring out what's our path forward, but I think our path forward is not just relying [51:05] on pre-entiping county property taxpayers, because, again, for levy, that's for levy point, [51:10] so 7.79 percent, that's for, you know, four of that seven is coming from kind of an [51:15] county property taxpayer, so absolutely subsidized. [51:19] One of the complaints I hear a lot from residents is a property tax bill. [51:23] Can you elaborate a little bit on what the county is doing to try to manage, cost, [51:28] increase, because you see it's such? [51:29] Yeah, well, that's the we're having monthly meetings. [51:32] Like I said, we're just like, [51:34] how a city is run, but we have a much larger budget [51:36] and a lot more that we are responsible in terms for, [51:40] because cities don't have to do helping human services. [51:44] So it is challenging, and I told you, [51:47] that's about 50% of our budget. [51:48] What we are looking at is we're meeting monthly to go over [51:53] And what I, we are having mandated versus not mandated services. [52:00] So we're disintegrating those in data. [52:04] And then we're looking at every single contract. [52:07] Now, we have about 90, 9,100 employees. [52:12] So property taxes, just so you know, also go for, [52:16] we have heavily unionized labor force, too. [52:19] So when you think about a city's budget, [52:22] I bet a lot of your budget is going to staffing it. [52:25] Imagine a county, right? [52:27] And then you think about 1.3 million residents. [52:30] That's the size of Rhode Island. So, I always think of, kind of in county, other counties, teas us like we're a state, and I'm like, we are like a state. We do everything the state of Minnesota does, but we do it on a bit of a smaller scale. [52:42] So, we are looking at ways to reduce costs by contracts that we can eliminate, and that has been, we're making progress there. [52:52] But I just want to acknowledge, I don't think the trajectory, I don't think the upward trend is acceptable at all. [52:58] I've been here for two years and I've pushed back and you know, I would say I'm more of the moderate one on the board even though it's non-partisan. [53:06] And because our district's moderate, our district does not want us to price people out of their homes. [53:10] People want to age in place and I agree with that and so we want to make sure that residents can stay where they are. [53:19] Thank you for coming, first of all. [53:22] I'm amazed you were here last year. [53:23] I'm amazed by the breadth of topics [53:25] you need to be in expert on, [53:29] and that the county has its hands in. [53:31] So I apologize for like, [53:32] piling on with this question. [53:35] But we recently bagged our flock camera [53:37] and I know you've got, [53:39] I don't know if you have a lot of them, [53:41] but you have some. [53:42] And we have a few concerns [53:44] around the provider and the general nature of the camera itself. Have you heard from other cities [53:53] with similar issues or even on county roads about flock cameras and their concerns around privacy? [54:01] Thank you, councilmember for the question. It's a good question. I have heard [54:05] flock cameras specifically at other council meetings when I'm doing doing presentations I've heard [54:11] the address in Excel Sear as Tonka Bay as well. [54:14] So I have heard residents speak up about them. [54:17] In terms of lock cameras and what we have, [54:19] it's typically cities that are installing them, [54:22] but I can check with the sheriff's department to see [54:24] if we have them. [54:26] But for the most part, these are, [54:28] that is a city function, [54:30] because we're, again, we're not fixing those cameras. [54:33] Those would be primarily cities deciding that. [54:37] I have a chance of background, and I'm wondering, blue line shines a lot. [54:43] One of your bar charts can show the federal contribution, continuing to dwindle, [54:51] and it's probably not going to shift any time in the next two years, [54:55] and I know you're not, like, sure it isn't directly affected by blue line, [54:58] but what is the latest by the county? [55:00] Because it may just suck the oxygen out of the room, [55:02] that is a big decision for the state. [55:05] Absolutely, yeah, I think you'll count some up, [55:07] but that's a great question. [55:08] I've gotten several emails about that. [55:10] So blue line, we have Southwest Light Rail, [55:12] which runs through our district. [55:15] And when you probably are sure, [55:16] we're not thinking that, [55:17] but actually through district six, [55:18] some of the city's I represent, [55:19] which is Eden Prairie, [55:21] Minotank and Hopkins. [55:22] It is going to run through that. [55:24] So that is hopefully going to be opening up in 2027, [55:26] and I am on by default of being elected [55:29] to the county. [55:30] I am on the financial team monitoring that as well. [55:33] So blue line is going to be running through North Minneapolis, [55:37] and then all the way up through the Brooklyns. [55:40] So with that project, you can't win every fight. [55:44] It's just like a city council, right? [55:46] Some things you pick, some things you don't. [55:48] If we get federal funding, every single one of my council members [55:52] supports the blue line. [55:54] It was like when I was at the state, I couldn't win every issue. [55:57] That's not an issue that I can really stop. [56:01] unless there's not, if the federal funding stops [56:03] and I will be fighting against that project [56:05] because we can't afford it. [56:06] So where the funding comes from, [56:08] it's actually not, it does not impact property taxpayers. [56:11] Where the funding for blue and white comes from [56:13] is actually from a sales tax. [56:14] It's a transit sales tax that was passed. [56:17] And so it comes specifically out of those allocated funds. [56:20] And so if it did impact property taxpayers, [56:23] I would be fighting diligently against that. [56:26] But again, because I don't have the votes on the council, [56:29] It's like it math has to math, they have all the votes to pass it. [56:33] The only thing I will be outspoken is if we don't get federal funding, then they would try to have the county pay, which would come for properties taxpayers, which is when you will start hearing the sound alarms for me. [56:44] Thank you. [56:46] Consmember Degertolo. [56:49] Thank you. [56:49] Thank you again for coming Commissioner. [56:52] We really appreciate your sort of filling us in on what's happening. [56:56] My question is, of your cities that in the county, how many of them are less than 50% [57:04] served with municipal water, [57:09] like have more than 50% on wells? [57:12] It's a problem in shorewood and it's something we're going to be talking about tonight, so [57:16] I'm just trying to understand if this is something that a lot of other cities in [57:20] have a county are facing or if we are if we're a different council member, that's a really [57:28] great question. I'm trying to, you know, the lakes, communities that's always a challenge. [57:35] So I have Mound, which is not. Edina, Minotanka, Hapkins, all municipal water. And I want to be [57:47] very clear that the county does not get involved with city functions like this. And so mill street [57:53] is our project but adding city municipal water onto that would be a city issue and I had to [57:59] wake up my brain it's been a long day before I was like yes so this would be something that [58:03] the city would up. I don't I'd have to check all of the lake other lake area communities I mean [58:09] as you know excelsier there's talk a bay there's green one deep haven I I don't know right off [58:16] hands and to the council members point I have to know about so many things council member I don't [58:21] that I would be able to retrieve that for you right away. [58:24] But I can follow that, certainly. [58:26] No, I wasn't trying to place dump the chump. [58:28] I was just curious if this is something that you've run into since you have such a diverse [58:33] county. [58:34] We have some rural cities that are more built out and I was just wondering if shore would [58:40] was kind of odd or if you run into that quite a bit. [58:45] So I appreciate it. [58:45] I don't expect you to know everything. [58:48] I wasn't playing dump the chump. [58:50] That's okay. [58:50] If I did know that, that would be like, I should really win a trivia, like I'm not [58:55] bored. [58:56] You would have to give me one, right, Mayor? [58:58] Right. [58:58] Commissioner, I have a question. [59:02] So several years ago, the Highway 7 group received some funding to form a traffic [59:08] management organization, which consists of 10 cities, including shorewood, five school districts, [59:16] Minotankah Hopkins, Morconia Westankah, and Eastern Carvering County, and two counties, [59:24] Carver and Hennepin. And you probably drove Highway 7 to get here and you'll go on Highway 7 to get home. [59:32] Recently, the amount of funding we received for that traffic management organization is coming to an end. [59:39] So we, as a group, have agreed, it would be in our interest to join the Southwest Court [59:45] or Transportation Coalition, or SWCT. [59:50] That group advocated a lot for 2012 and Highway 5 improvements. [59:58] And the reason we're... [1:00:00] This still staying together as a group is because all of these small cities along Highway 7 really [1:00:05] feel we have a stronger voice to advocate, to testify before the House and Senate, for funding, [1:00:12] for grant, etc. [1:00:16] By joining that existing coalition, we have some momentum. I've been attending [1:00:22] the meetings along with several others on behalf of Highway 7, and at the meetings, like [1:00:30] the last one, there were three Carver County commissioners because again, they're dealing [1:00:36] with 2,12 and 5. So I would like to talk to you down the road about getting hennapping county [1:00:43] representatives at these meetings. [1:00:47] Carver County was a big financial backer of the Highway 5 and the Highway 212 [1:00:54] corridors improvements and Highway 7 is scheduled for a routine pavement management improvement [1:01:02] project in 2029. [1:01:05] And that's great, but what the people in this area are really concerned about is the safety. [1:01:10] And if, in the next, probably 12 months, we can obtain some funding for safety improvements, [1:01:20] Minda has given a green light that we can roll them into their pavement project and get them [1:01:27] done at the same time as a nice, pretty surface. So I would love to get some of the [1:01:40] of the communities out here because almost every community along that [1:01:44] corridors is in your district. [1:01:49] And Carver County had three commissioners there, [1:01:53] like I said, but their portion of Highway 7 is very small. It's really just [1:01:58] along the Chanhas and Edge. But Hennepin counties is the entire rest of the [1:02:04] 26-mile corridor. So I would love to get you guys involved as many commissioners as [1:02:10] possible that we can advocate together as a group, and we did testifying front of the Senate [1:02:17] Transportation Commission this past season, this past legislative session, pardon me, [1:02:25] on a bill that was drafted by Senator Julia Coleman from Chan Hassan, a Republican, and [1:02:31] it was presented to the Commission by Senator Ann Johnson Stewart DFL. [1:02:35] So, we have bipartisan support, but we just simply need more money to get safety improvements [1:02:43] done. We are applying for grants. We're knocking on doors. We're doing the best we can, [1:02:49] but I would love to bring the commissioners up to speed. And if invite you all to be my guests [1:02:56] at the next SWCT or Southwest Court or Transportation Coalition meeting. They're held in [1:03:04] Yeah, I mean, Mary, I would love to, I've never been invited once. [1:03:07] So yeah, I would love to come, I mean, absolutely, I mean, as you know, how [1:03:11] way seven is a state road, but with that said, I think there's got to be a way for us to [1:03:18] figure out, I mean, in our sections of county roads are so many. [1:03:22] And so maybe there is something that could be an argument that could be found there, and I mean, [1:03:26] I'm in for it. [1:03:26] So just invite me, please. [1:03:28] I would love to come. [1:03:28] And you know, we're just trying to think outside the box and explore any other avenues [1:03:33] we could. Absolutely. I'm all for it. I'll do it. I'll do it. I'll let you know. Let me know. [1:03:38] Yeah. And I was just I was sorry. I was not to be rude. I was just trying to look because I was on the [1:03:42] I for 94 commission for a while. And I was just trying to think of how were they funded. And so I was [1:03:48] going to look it up because my again I need to like know I'll I'll text you when I find out because yeah, [1:03:54] when I was at the state I remember going to that. And so that was funded. And so if that's funded, [1:03:59] that commission. Because I think I was seven even when we do have we should have an [1:04:02] constantly improvement commission going and that was just established right when Kelly Morrison [1:04:08] drafted that first bill that's correct. So I think that we have to think of like longevity [1:04:12] of how that stays sustainable and I feel like the I 484 commission which has mirrors and [1:04:19] county commissioners and senators and representatives that when they meet in businesses along [1:04:24] that corridor as well in residents when they meet I believe they have a funding mechanism. [1:04:30] So I would love to connect with you on that too so that we can maybe think about that [1:04:32] So please do. Pull me on. I would love that. [1:04:34] That sounds great. I'll be in touch. [1:04:37] Awesome. [1:04:37] And it takes a lot more than that for me to think you're rude. [1:04:41] So any other questions for the commissioner? [1:04:46] Thank you so much for your presentation. [1:04:48] You're welcome to stick around, but I know you're busy. [1:04:50] If you want to head out, you're welcome to do that as well. [1:04:53] Thank you, commissioner. [1:04:55] We'll now move on to the next agenda on our item. [1:05:00] Our agenda item on our schedule here. [1:05:02] Let's see, we are now moving on to, for me, for where am I here, for B and for that matter we have a memo that has been prepared by our planning director Mr. Jake Griffiths, and this is, I'll let you take it away. [1:05:26] Thank you, Mayor members of the council. I'll start by saying this is the first of three items we have on what is apparently garage. [1:05:32] at the City Council meeting. [1:05:33] We should be named. [1:05:35] Yeah, so we'll bear with me here as we go through these. [1:05:38] I know that we have a lot of people in the audience for a different agenda, [1:05:41] but I will cover these briefly. [1:05:44] Our first one is a conditional use permit at 5850 Boulder Bridge Lane, [1:05:48] again, for construction of a garage. [1:05:51] I won't spend too much time going over what the CUP is, [1:05:53] but you can basically think of it as a building permit [1:05:55] that the City Council has to approve. [1:05:57] The City Code has a laundry list of conditions [1:05:59] that if they're met, a property owner has a right to do a certain activity on their property. [1:06:05] So in this case, the reason why we're here is that the city code says that if your home [1:06:09] is located in the R1A zoning district, you can build over 1,200 square feet of accessory [1:06:15] buildings on your property through a conditional use permit, as long as you meet a set list [1:06:20] of conditions. [1:06:21] And so the property we're talking about here tonight is shown on the map in front of you, [1:06:25] again we're in the Boulder Bridge neighborhood and the garage that we're talking about is [1:06:30] circled in right on the screen in front of you. Really it's a fairly typical attached [1:06:35] garage that you would see on other residential properties in shorewood. Again the reason [1:06:40] we're here is just because it exceeds the 1200 square foot threshold established in the [1:06:45] city code. Some of our contextual running at renderings were provided by the applicant. [1:06:51] Again you can kind of further see if this is a typical garage design. It would be consistent [1:06:55] and with the existing home that's on the site. [1:06:59] With respect to the review criteria, [1:07:01] this is all included in the staff report, [1:07:03] so I won't read through all of it. [1:07:05] But basically what the CECode gets at [1:07:07] is there are a couple mathematical calculations [1:07:09] that you have to meet in order to be able to go beyond [1:07:13] that 1200 square foot maximum. [1:07:16] For example, the total square footage [1:07:18] of accessory buildings can't exceed the floor area of the home. [1:07:23] right so it's trying to level set this kind of ratio in the city code and it goes from there [1:07:30] You know, the couple other mathematical calculations that have to be met by the property owner. The property owner has met all of those review criteria as part of their application. [1:07:40] And additionally, we have kind of a standard set of review criteria for all conditional use permits, no matter what they're for. [1:07:47] Things like, are they consistent with the comprehensive plan? [1:07:51] Is it compatible with present and future land uses? [1:07:54] Are there adequate public facilities to accommodate the conditional use and so on? [1:08:00] Again, scenes, this is kind of a fairly typical attach garage, residential project. [1:08:05] Staff feels that the applicants request meets all of the established review criteria by the city code. [1:08:13] So, based on that staff does recommend approval with conditions based on the consistency with the comprehensive plan. [1:08:19] Again, we're on a residential property doing a fairly typical residential project. [1:08:24] It's consistency with the requirements of the R1AZoning District and also the Boulder Bridge PUD. [1:08:30] I should note the Boulder Bridge neighborhood is a planned unit development. [1:08:33] It has a little bit unique rules, but for the case of accessory buildings, we follow the R1AZoning District, [1:08:39] much like the surrounding neighborhoods, and also it meets those mathematical review criteria [1:08:45] that I just talked through and also the conditional use permit review criteria established [1:08:49] by the city code. The planning commission did hold a public hearing at their last meeting on [1:08:54] this item. During the public hearing, we had one resident who spoke with a couple of questions. [1:08:59] They were from the Brinmar place neighborhood to the north. They asked how far the proposed garage [1:09:06] would be from any of those adjacent homes to the north. [1:09:11] It would be about 125 feet away at the closest point. [1:09:15] So we're quite a bit farther than our 50-foot building [1:09:18] setback requires. [1:09:21] There hasn't also had some questions about tree preservation, [1:09:24] particularly near that northern property line. [1:09:27] If I go back to the map, you can see that again, [1:09:31] we're quite a large distance away from where [1:09:33] a lot of the stands of trees are on this property. [1:09:36] So, as part of the condition that the applicant obtains a billing permit, we'll have to show [1:09:40] their true preservation plan to the city and make sure that meets the city code requirements, [1:09:45] but there's very limited tree removal that's anticipated as part of this project. [1:09:50] So with that, the Planning Commission did hold the public hearing and they recommended approval [1:09:54] with the conditions they're listed in the resolution in your packet. [1:09:59] And with that, staff would simply ask the Council to consider the recommendation of the [1:10:04] And I'll ultimately make the motion to approve with conditions that's on your screen. [1:10:10] I believe the applicant is here this evening, as well as planning Commissioner Holker, [1:10:14] if either of them would like to add additional context. [1:10:17] So with that, I'll stand for questions. [1:10:19] Thank you, Director Griffiths. [1:10:21] Commissioner, would you like to say anything or just wait if there's questions? [1:10:25] And would the applicant like to say anything just wait if there's questions? [1:10:29] Easy. [1:10:29] I'll now turn this over to Council, Council, do you have any questions for director Griffiths [1:10:35] the applicant or the commissioner? [1:10:37] Would you mind showing that map of showing where in proximity, Brinmar is correctly? [1:10:43] Yeah. [1:10:44] I think the easier one is actually this map, so the Brinmar neighborhood, the Brinmar neighborhood, [1:10:55] the Brinmar neighborhood are these homes here, it's the north. [1:10:57] And so what we're referring to in the staff report is the garage that's proposed to be built right about here, right? [1:11:04] And so you have a distance to get to the northern property line of the lot. [1:11:09] Then there's a 40-foot common area owned by the Boulder Bridge neighborhood association. [1:11:15] And then you get the homes and then most of those homes are our distance as well. [1:11:20] So the distance between the garage and this property line is about 125 feet. [1:11:26] It could be technically as close as 50 to this southern property line, but again we're greatly exceeding that with this application. [1:11:38] Councilor, are there any other questions? [1:11:45] This seems pretty straightforward to me. [1:11:48] I don't have any issues. [1:11:49] I don't either. [1:11:50] Do I have a motion? [1:11:52] I moved to a top resolution 26-34. [1:11:55] Approving the conditional use permit for 5-8-5-0, bolder bridge lane. [1:12:01] Second. [1:12:01] I have a motion by Councilmember San Chagrin and a second by Gorham, is there any further discussion on this matter? [1:12:08] Hearing none, I'll call the matter for a roll call vote, San Chagrin. [1:12:12] Gorham? [1:12:13] Degertolo? [1:12:15] Aye. [1:12:16] Labdee, aye. [1:12:16] Motion carries unanimously four zero and is here by approved. [1:12:20] Good luck with your project. [1:12:22] We'll now move on to agenda item four C. [1:12:26] That is a variance relating to sixty one forty five club valley road. [1:12:31] Again, we have a memo that will be presented by our planning director, Mr. Griffiths, and was prepared by our planner, Mr. Oselsky. [1:12:43] Thank you, Mayor. Members of the council. [1:12:46] So, a little bit different flavor with this garage. We're still talking about it in the touch garage. [1:12:51] But instead of a conditional use permit, we're looking at the variants. [1:12:55] And so, just a quick refresher. I think it's been a little bit since we've looked at one of these. [1:12:59] A variance is essentially an exception to a dimensional standard in the city code. [1:13:04] And typically, cities can grants variances. [1:13:08] If the enforcement of the rule would create a practical difficulty to land owner on a property. [1:13:15] And practical difficulties are defined by state law. [1:13:17] Typically, a three-part test, you look at the reasonableness of the applicants request, [1:13:22] the uniqueness of their requests, and also whether or not their request would impact the essential character of the neighborhood. [1:13:28] Once the variance is approved, it does become a property right, which runs with the land [1:13:33] forever. So it doesn't expire that that property owner and subsequent property owners have a right to [1:13:39] whatever is approved under that variance into the future. [1:13:43] In this case, the property at 6145 is shown in front of you. [1:13:48] I want to just note out at the outset, you might call attention to kind of how the unique shape of this [1:13:58] We are in a corner lock here, and you'll see that the house is shifted a little bit to the north side of that lot, which we'll come in a play later. [1:14:07] Really what the applicant is looking to do is to reduce that rear yard set back from 40 feet to 27 feet. [1:14:14] So by the 13 foot reduction, and the reason they want to do that is they want to accommodate construction of a attach garage to make some accessibility improvements to their home. [1:14:23] The applicant did provide a narrative, which is in your packet, kind of all lighting the needs they have for their property, [1:14:29] whether it's a different lift or ramps or different things, and the added third stall provides them additional space to make those accessibility improvements to their home. [1:14:40] It's a little bit tricky to see on this map, but you can see where the proposed garage edition is on the north side of the property in yellow. [1:14:47] It is essentially a one-car garage, and currently the property is two cars, so this results in the third stall. [1:14:55] And probably the most unique part of this slide is how the setbacks are applied. [1:15:01] Going back, looking at how setbacks are defined for this property, the backyard is actually the north property line. [1:15:08] If you look at our city code and how this home was initially built along with some other homes in the area, your front yard was that small sliver of land on the south end of the site. [1:15:18] So that was a 35-foot setback. Your rear yard is opposite of that, which was the north property line, and then the side yard was 35 as well. [1:15:26] So it's created a very odd configuration for the property owner, where they have essentially [1:15:31] their functional side yard, the zoning code says is their rear yard, and their functional [1:15:37] rear yard, and the zoning code says is their side yard. [1:15:41] So I like it's into a little bit of the semantics, but that's part of the reason why we're here [1:15:45] tonight. [1:15:46] This is something that happens on other properties in shortwood, and the city council has reviewed [1:15:51] and approved variances for similar situations like this in the past. [1:15:56] Let me look at various review criteria. [1:15:59] It's kind of this checklist. [1:16:00] We look at the intensive comprehensive plan [1:16:01] and the zoning ordinance. [1:16:03] The practical difficulties I mentioned earlier. [1:16:06] You're also asked to consider whether or not [1:16:08] the applicant's request is purely due [1:16:10] to economic considerations. [1:16:11] If there are any impact on other properties. [1:16:14] And if the variance request is the minimum [1:16:16] to alleviate that practical difficulty. [1:16:19] So these staff did review the application [1:16:21] as well as I should be attorney with respect to the review criteria and staff is recommending approval. [1:16:29] Based upon our feeling that as outlined in the staff report on how that request meets that review criteria, [1:16:36] we do have a couple conditions just pretty standard ones that the applicant must attain a building permit. [1:16:42] Prior to the construction and that whatever is built has to be architecturally consistent with the existing home in the surrounding neighborhood that's out there already. [1:16:51] During the Planning Commission meeting, we did have four residents who spoke during the [1:16:56] public hearing that were in favor of the variance request. [1:16:59] I don't believe any of them are here this evening, but their comments were included in [1:17:04] the draft minutes, which were attached to the packet. [1:17:08] And the Planning Commission ultimately reviewed the requests, their comments, and recommended [1:17:12] approval of the variance with the conditions that are listed in your resolution. [1:17:17] So, with that, I would simply ask, I'll stand for questions, and the council is asked to consider their [1:17:22] recommendation to approve. Again, Commissioner Holker is here for any additional context, as well as the applicants and their contractor. [1:17:31] So, with that I'll stand for any questions. Okay, thank you, director. Would the commissioner like to weigh in on this or would you just want to stand for questions? [1:17:41] How about the applicants? [1:17:44] Okay. [1:17:45] Council, are there any questions for the planning director, Mr. Griffiths? [1:17:50] I thought I read somewhere. [1:17:51] I might be getting my garage just mixed up. [1:17:53] So bear with me. [1:17:55] But I think if you go to the map that shows the setbacks that you had, [1:17:59] which I thought was very helpful, [1:18:01] I thought I read somewhere in the materials that, [1:18:04] if we had the same code as other cities, [1:18:07] They wouldn't even require a variance for the setbacks, because you could redefine the front, the front, the front. [1:18:14] I believe that was a different request. [1:18:17] I have never worked in the seat, it does that, but that is a zoning tool that's out there. [1:18:22] We currently don't have that in our city code. [1:18:25] So the variance is the only channel that we have to process the type of request. [1:18:30] I know talking with City Attorney Shepherd, we do have a couple ideas on how to, [1:18:35] maybe make these requests a little more streamlined [1:18:38] in the future if that's the council's intent. [1:18:41] But we would obviously follow your direction [1:18:44] from tonight's meeting and then, you know, [1:18:46] we can incorporate any changes in the future. [1:18:49] From your perspective, what's the purpose [1:18:51] of these setbacks, the way that they are right now? [1:18:56] You know, it's tough for me to say exactly why. [1:18:59] I mean, sure would historically the setbacks [1:19:01] have been established to kind of push everything [1:19:03] to the center and the back of a property. [1:19:05] right. This is a bit of a unique neighborhood where we have a bit of an odd configuration [1:19:12] of a lot. It's not really a corner lot, it's kind of almost not a curve, but it functions [1:19:18] like a corner lot, and at one point the property owner could have chose to build a much larger [1:19:27] home or shift the home slightly, but for whatever reason when the home was initially built, [1:19:31] they built it right at that 40-foot setback, which left them lots of room on the other side [1:19:38] as you can see with the map here, but almost no room on their garage side where they need [1:19:42] the extra space. [1:19:44] So I don't know exactly why, but the general purpose of setbacks in Shorewood has been to [1:19:51] protect public health safety and push things kind of towards the center in the back of [1:19:56] property. [1:19:57] Thank you. [1:19:58] So is the, the house is currently [1:20:02] complying with setbacks? [1:20:04] Yes. [1:20:05] Okay, and the, the [1:20:09] argument we're making about [1:20:13] permitting the variances because [1:20:16] they could build it. [1:20:20] I guess I don't know what north [1:20:22] south of the property. [1:20:24] Is that what we're saying? [1:20:25] So in the staff for it and their narrative, the applicant is outlined kind of how they feel they request meets the variance review criteria. [1:20:35] You know, really what they're looking at is, you know, again, is the request reasonable. [1:20:39] Construction of a third-salt garage is a pretty typical residential improvement. It's allowed by our city code. [1:20:46] Is it a unique situation versus self-created? [1:20:48] You know, the applicant really is arguing that, you know, like, as you mentioned, they could build something in a different location, but [1:20:57] they need the space where they need the space, it's a garage, you know, and it functionally, the setbacks on this lot, there are [1:21:05] don't, the basically with the applicant's arguing is that the setbacks don't match the functional use of the home, right? [1:21:12] We're calling what their side yard is if you looked at the house, they're backyard. [1:21:16] But as you looked at the house, that's their side yard, right? [1:21:21] And so that's a lot of the rationale provided by the applicant. [1:21:25] You keep saying that, but you are also recommending approval of it. [1:21:33] Okay. [1:21:33] And so that's an argument that you agree with? [1:21:35] Yes. [1:21:36] Okay. [1:21:37] This is some unique situation. [1:21:39] I do. [1:21:41] Because of the sighting of the house. [1:21:44] So, the uniqueness here is, it's not a typical lot, right, we're on a, not necessarily [1:21:53] a corner lot, it's kind of on this curve, the, you know, the function, it's not a lot [1:21:59] that's compliant. [1:22:01] So, it is. [1:22:01] But the functional orientation of the home does not match with the technical, you know, definition [1:22:08] of what the EGR is in our city code. [1:22:12] And historically, I don't have that example in front of me, [1:22:16] the City Council has approved variances for similar situations in the past. [1:22:22] But ultimately, the City Council could reasonably find otherwise, [1:22:26] if you feel differently with the review criteria. [1:22:30] Tell me more about the second argument about it being it's functional placement. What does that mean? [1:22:39] So imagine you're looking at the house from the street, right? Every part of the house faces what is club value road, right? [1:22:49] So the front side. So the front side, okay? So then what we're talking about really is this north side. [1:22:56] And the side is not the side. [1:22:59] So there's a mismatch here between what our city code defines [1:23:03] each setback as and how the home is actually built on. [1:23:06] The side yard worth 10 feet, it would work. [1:23:09] Got it. [1:23:09] OK. [1:23:09] Thank you. [1:23:12] Yeah. [1:23:14] OK. [1:23:15] Council, are there any other questions? [1:23:20] It is a unique situation. [1:23:23] So I like the fact four neighbors came [1:23:27] and state it that they had no problem with it. [1:23:31] So I think this is a proper use of a variance council. [1:23:36] I agree. [1:23:37] I don't see any issues with this. [1:23:39] Do I have a motion? [1:23:42] I move to adopt resolution 26-37, [1:23:46] approving the variance for 6145 Club Valley Road. [1:23:53] Second. [1:23:54] I have a motion by Council Member Sanchigrin, [1:23:56] and a second by Gorham, [1:23:57] And we'll now do a roll call vote. [1:23:59] Sanchkin. [1:24:00] Hi. [1:24:00] Gorum. [1:24:01] Hi. [1:24:02] Degertolo. [1:24:03] Hi. [1:24:04] Labdee I. [1:24:05] Motion carries unanimously for zero, [1:24:08] and is hereby approved. [1:24:09] Good luck with your project. [1:24:11] We'll now move on to agenda item 4D, [1:24:14] that is a variance for 2, 3, 1, 2, 0, some at Avenue. [1:24:19] And I'll turn that over to planning director Griffiths. [1:24:23] All right. [1:24:23] Last garage. [1:24:25] Problems. [1:24:26] Again, very similar situation, but slightly different. [1:24:30] We're again looking at the variance, so the same application we just did, exception to the city code. [1:24:36] I'm really what we're looking at is the property on the screen in front of you as in blue. [1:24:41] This property is on Summit Avenue, and it's a little bit tough to see, but for those of you who have been out to Summit Avenue, you probably know that it's an aptly named road. [1:24:50] It's quite the hill. [1:24:51] And this property is at the very bottom of that hill right at the intersection of some of the avenue and I don't I can't read the other road there, but right at the bottom. [1:25:03] Thank you. [1:25:04] And what the applicant is looking to do here is they have a 35 foot front yard set back. [1:25:09] They are also looking to add a third stall onto their home for a garage. [1:25:14] And they're requesting a very similar reduction of 12.3 feet, we're 35 feet required. [1:25:21] So dropping that set back from 35 to 22.7. What you see in front of you here is the applicant [1:25:28] survey. You can see the proposed garage circled in red. Again, a third stall where there's already [1:25:33] a two car garage. And again, to kind of highlight the slope on the property, you can see the [1:25:39] to rely on the screen in front of you, this is one of the steepest properties in shorewood that's [1:25:47] not on a bluff, right, right, not on the lake. And so really, what the applicants looking to do [1:25:54] is to add this third stall, they've provided rationale in the staff report and in their narrative [1:26:00] on how they feel that request meets the review criteria. Again, we have the same review criteria [1:26:05] as our last request. We look at the intent of the comprehensive plan in the city code, [1:26:09] And again, really a lot of this hinges on the practical difficulties. [1:26:14] When staff looks at the practical difficulties here, you know, again, constructing a third stall in the residential property is very common for similar residential lots in Shorewood. [1:26:24] When you look at the uniqueness of this situation, this is a fairly unique lot. [1:26:29] It almost comes to a point, which creates an interesting layout from a setback perspective. [1:26:37] And between that and the steep rate on the property, there's not a lot of other buildable locations on this lot. [1:26:44] Particularly when you look at the essential character of this surrounding area, there are other properties in the vicinity of this one that have reduced front yard setbacks as you go farther up some of the avenue. [1:26:56] And there are also properties in the area that have proposed garage additions in similar type situations. [1:27:06] The other thing to keep in mind here is that when we're looking at this front yard setback, [1:27:09] we're not actually building any closer to a neighboring home. [1:27:13] We're building closer to the street side. [1:27:16] So none of the existing homeowners will have a new building that's built closer to their house. [1:27:21] It'd be the same distance as the existing home. [1:27:23] And based on the impact on the other review criteria with public lands, [1:27:30] minimum to alleviate the practical difficulty, [1:27:33] this again is the smallest garage the applicant could propose. [1:27:37] It's a single-stall edition. [1:27:41] And so with that, [1:27:43] staff's recommendation, again, here is to approve the variance request based on the variance review criteria [1:27:49] with basically the same conditions as the last request that the applicant obtained at Bill [1:27:54] and Permit, and then also that the proposed addition should be architecturally compatible [1:27:59] with the home. The planning commission did hold their review with their last meeting, and we did [1:28:04] get one written comment, which is including your packet. That comment is from the neighbor directly [1:28:10] up the hill on Summit Avenue or to the east of the site, and they were in favor of the variance [1:28:15] request. No other public feedback was received on this application, and ultimately the plan [1:28:21] and commission recommended approval with those conditions. So with that, again I'll stand [1:28:26] for any questions. The applicants and their contractor are here as well as planning commissioner [1:28:31] holker. So I'll stand for any questions, the council may have. Okay, thank you for your report, [1:28:36] commissioner. Holding for questions, applicants. Holding for questions. Okay. Turn this over to [1:28:42] Council. It looks like the practical difficulties test of reasonable unique situation [1:28:48] versus self-created and essential character have all been addressed by our planning [1:28:52] director, and it, okay, okay, let me, I'll turn it over. [1:28:59] I'll turn it over. Dr. Griffiths here. In this case, the front is the front, yes. [1:29:07] Okay, and I guess everyone deserves a third stall, but in this case it feels self-created. [1:29:19] Like, it's a third stall. [1:29:22] I wish I had a third stall, but I am too close to my side here. [1:29:28] It's not like the other one where you could argue that it's oriented incorrectly. [1:29:33] What's the front set back supposed to be? 35 feet. 35 feet and so [1:29:42] without the garage [1:29:45] They're about [1:29:46] 34 almost compliant. It's yeah substantially 35 feet to the existing hole. Okay, so now what do you talk me out of this one here? [1:29:59] Well, I'm not gonna talk [1:30:00] The city council can recently find otherwise with any of this review criteria. This is up for interpretation. You know, the analysis that the applicant has provided really hinges a lot on the fact that we have a lot of similar situations in this area with home so they're closer than that 35 foot setback. I kind of challenge you to find one on some of the avenue that actually meets that setback, which the applicant did provide a map of that with their narrative. [1:30:30] of in the memo. And then, you know, really, again, the applicants is hinting in their [1:30:35] review criteria here on the slope and the unique shape a lot, not allowing them other [1:30:40] locations to really make these improvements. [1:30:44] But you buy the property on some of that, this is going to be unique. You can't give a [1:30:48] variance to everyone on some of that, or, you know, bolder bridge, or, you know, any [1:30:54] reach anything of the word ridge in it, the council can clearly find otherwise. [1:31:00] Okay. Yeah, you guys might feel differently, but this is a front facing lot and they're [1:31:06] pushing into the, they're pushing into the front setback for a third stall, which, you [1:31:13] know, it's not like, this is what the variant, this is what setbacks are for. And every decision [1:31:21] is a chance to get it right, that's how I feel. So that's a null for me, but you may feel [1:31:25] for like. Okay, Sanchigan. [1:31:29] Can you show the pictures of the house? [1:31:36] I don't have those in my [1:31:37] presentation. Okay. [1:31:42] Are you afraid to the ones in the packet? Yeah, the ones in the packet. [1:31:45] I thought you might have them in there. Okay. [1:31:49] So the distance from just going back to the narrative, [1:31:52] What's the distance again? [1:31:54] So the applicant's request in 22.7 feet [1:31:58] where 35 is required. [1:32:00] So it's a reduction of about 13 feet. [1:32:04] And what's on the bottom is out of streets? [1:32:10] Yep. [1:32:10] So this is the property line. [1:32:14] And then the sum of the avenue is actually a bit farther south. [1:32:18] We have some additional right of way there. [1:32:20] It's a little bit easier to see in this photo or even three nights the street. [1:32:25] Yep, so that's the street there. [1:32:26] What I'm pushing it against somebody's, somebody else's property, we're pushing it against [1:32:31] the street. [1:32:35] I'm comfortable with this. I'm in favor. [1:32:41] You could tell me in the comments. [1:32:44] I just want to have one question. I mean, I'm generally in favor of it. I was looking at the [1:32:54] understand from the planning director, what the down side, [1:32:59] we know obviously there's a reason to have 35 feet, [1:33:02] what are we giving up or what's the con of putting this [1:33:07] of approving this if there is one? [1:33:11] Well, I mean, as with any, you know, [1:33:13] variance application or any rule, right? [1:33:15] There's obviously a reason for it. [1:33:17] Again, kind of looking at similar to the last application, [1:33:21] setbacks are established, you know, as part of our zoning code, to establish kind of community [1:33:27] standards and preserve property values, tech public health safety, those things. I guess [1:33:33] you could argue that the 35 foot setback is critically important to do those things for [1:33:40] this lot and that could be something the city council could consider. Again, staff's perspective [1:33:47] simply was that we have a lot of other situations in this area where there isn't a real [1:33:54] of a established setback and that's why, you know, part of the reason why we're recommending [1:33:58] approval in addition to the other, you know, points the applicant's made. [1:34:05] I don't have anything off time I had that's, you know, a negative to the city. [1:34:10] You could argue, I guess, that, you know, some of the adjacent property owners might be impacted [1:34:15] in some way, but none of them have brought any of those concerns forward. [1:34:22] So I don't know if I answered your question. [1:34:26] Council member Degertal, though. [1:34:28] No, I think I guess the, I guess you answered it, [1:34:31] that the purpose of this setback is for standardization, nothing else. [1:34:38] That's right. [1:34:39] Well, there's no other, I know the setback. [1:34:41] I wouldn't say just standardization, [1:34:43] right, with any zoning rule, there's a reason behind that right going back to protecting [1:34:48] public health, safety, welfare, property values, all those things. In this case, it just [1:34:54] seems like we don't have a neighborhood where the rule has been applied consistently [1:34:58] in the past. And that's kind of where staff is coming from. But again, as I've said, the [1:35:04] review criteria is certainly open for interpretation, [1:35:09] so staff can certainly move forward [1:35:11] with whatever direction the council derides. [1:35:18] I do think it's a unique situation [1:35:19] because I do think that this is one of our [1:35:22] steeper graded parts of the city. [1:35:28] And as you said in your memo, [1:35:30] it significantly limits the billable areas on this site. [1:35:34] I think that's an accurate statement. [1:35:38] The fact that other properties have been allowed [1:35:40] to do something similar, I think makes it [1:35:43] the essential character of the area, and I think it's reasonable, due to the topography and [1:35:51] the unique nature of this. [1:35:53] Now, I'm going to turn down here. [1:35:56] We have a unique situation, Mr. Nivinsky and our city attorney, with four council members [1:36:01] here. [1:36:02] Can you remind me if there's a Thai vote essentially what happens on anything this evening? [1:36:11] So if there's a tie vote with four council members, the motion is tied, it therefore fails. [1:36:20] Okay, thank you. [1:36:22] Are there any other questions council for either a planning director or the planning commissioner or the applicants? [1:36:29] Any other discussion? [1:36:33] Hearing none, do I have a motion? [1:36:36] I move to a top resolution 26-36 approving the variance for 2, 3, 1, 2, 0, 7. [1:36:43] Some at Avenue. [1:36:47] I'll second. [1:36:49] We have a motion by Council Member Sanchigan, the second by Labdy. [1:36:52] I'll call the matter for roll call vote. [1:36:54] Sanchigan. [1:36:56] Gorham. [1:36:57] Ne. [1:36:58] DeGotolo. [1:37:00] I. [1:37:01] Labdy. [1:37:02] I. [1:37:02] Motion carries 3, 1 and is here by approved. [1:37:05] good luck with your project. [1:37:08] We'll now move on to agenda item e-curbside organic recycling. [1:37:15] We have a report that's been prepared this evening by Mr. Eric Wilson, our recycling coordinator. [1:37:24] Hello. [1:37:25] Yeah, I'm here tonight to talk about curbsite organics in order in its 13. [1:37:29] Just very... [1:37:30] I briefly just to the history of it. 2018 is when ordinance 13 is updated to include curbside [1:37:35] organics within the definition of what we know as traditional recycling. And so then in 2022, [1:37:42] what happened is by 2022 cities had to provide organics service. And so that looked different [1:37:49] for cities of different sizes. For sure, what since we're a population above 5,000 are only [1:37:55] requirement was to offer either drop off site or to offer a curbside option and short [1:38:01] when ahead and went with the drop off sites. So we currently do operate two of those. [1:38:06] We have 178 as of today household signed up for that. In 2023 and around 2024, [1:38:15] as when we heard a little bit more about it, I would say from other cities in the news and got [1:38:20] a little bit more phone calls and questions from residents about it because that was when [1:38:23] the MPCA clarified the statute that prohibits charging residents who recycle more than those who don't. [1:38:31] So that required all haulers to bill all residents for organic recycling. I mean, you couldn't [1:38:35] opt in or opt out of it. So cities like the surrounding city, Excel is for example, was offering [1:38:42] curbside organic but when away with that because they didn't charge all their residents. It didn't [1:38:47] really affect us, but there was a lot of questions around it. And then as we move forward, there's [1:38:53] October 24 later that year, the Metro-Saldways Management Plan came out and adopted the rule [1:39:01] that by 2030, cities of 5,000 plus must offer a curbside organics option. So that is what brings [1:39:09] us here to the discussion today, is just to get some direction on that. There's two ways. I can [1:39:14] do the next slide. There's two ways that sure we can look at it. We can either do our own [1:39:20] organized city collection, I'm in due as we do is with recycling, where we charge all residents [1:39:26] the same and negotiate a price with one holler, or we can look at option two and allow [1:39:34] we would allow our trash hollers to offer the service. [1:39:39] They would have to offer the service to be licensed and in short would, and they would [1:39:44] be the ones to set their prices and residents could go out and shop around with the option [1:39:50] that they would like to do. [1:39:52] So part of the reason why we're bringing it up now [1:39:54] before way ahead of 2030 is to start looking [1:39:57] at the transition that we want to go into. [1:40:01] So if we're looking at an organized city collection, [1:40:03] we're looking at a little bit more, I would say, [1:40:05] a higher transition effort as the city will take on, [1:40:07] like the RFP process, having to negotiate prices. [1:40:11] In both cases, we'll have to do a lot of education [1:40:14] and do communication around it with residents [1:40:16] just to get everyone to understand [1:40:19] what's going on with it, but then what the open hallart system we're just looking at a lower [1:40:25] transition effort just because we're not the one negotiating the prices, it'll just be [1:40:30] having to update codes and the licensing requirements from hollers. So a couple of examples [1:40:37] of cities that do the Organized City Collection is Manitanka Hopkins Bloomington and there's [1:40:43] only two that we know of in Hennep and County that offer it and that's Edam Prairie and Rogers. [1:40:49] And they'd offer it through their trash services and they make it required from them to have to do that. [1:40:58] So that's what's going on with the Organics Collection and then just kind of up [1:41:03] a discussion just the next slide has just a few questions to consider or a number of questions to consider. [1:41:10] And just to get some direction from Council of how we would like to move forward with that. [1:41:16] And then in the packet is also, there is, when we went out for the RFP in 2025, we did ask for organics pricing, [1:41:25] just so we could start to get an idea of what rates looked like. [1:41:28] So that's in the Council's packet, we can't have that one out because we didn't award anyone that out to the public. [1:41:35] But, and then there's also just like a sample transition plan draft if we wanted to look at what we would look into if we were going to kind of do the transition over a number of years. [1:41:48] If we did want to go into our own organized collection as a city. [1:41:53] So with that I will leave it to any questions or discussion that you may have. [1:41:58] Okay, thank you. [1:42:00] Councillor, are there any questions for Mr. Wilson? [1:42:01] Under the open hauler system is this another whole truck that comes through or is it can't are they using the same trucks to do multiple collections? [1:42:13] I would think it could be another truck, so I don't I don't think that they would have I don't know I don't think trash collects the same as organics [1:42:23] They have in designs special trucks for this type of maybe by 2030 they will I don't know [1:42:29] Which option would be most cost-effective overall of these two? [1:42:36] Well, what I've heard from other cities, or the feedback I got, I talked to our representative [1:42:40] at Helen and Ben County, that works with us through recycling. [1:42:43] And she said that pretty much all the only reason why there's two cities there that do [1:42:47] the open-hall system is because all the other cities switched because they could negotiate better prices. [1:42:53] To do it as a city versus leaving it open for the haulers to do their own pricing. [1:42:58] And as somebody who's dog barks at every truck that goes by, I prefer. [1:43:03] I personally would prefer a few or trucks coming up in my street. [1:43:07] I mean, that is, I think one advantage of going with the city organizing it, in theory, there would [1:43:13] be definitely less trucks. [1:43:17] Yeah, as we're putting a lot of money into our infrastructure and our road system to me, fewer [1:43:22] trucks makes a lot more sense. [1:43:24] As well as, I don't, I think if the whole entire city is negotiating one price for the whole city and we have a set term, in other words we have the ability to renegotiate every year or every other year. [1:43:42] I don't see how we wouldn't get a good price when they're getting every household in the whole city. [1:43:49] So I think this is, you know, without having numbers in front of me in theory, this is probably the most [1:43:57] cost-effective method for our residents because we can negotiate and bulk, just like we do with our recycling. [1:44:04] So I would support option one. [1:44:09] Councilmember Degretella? [1:44:11] Yeah, I have two questions. [1:44:13] I'm leaning toward, you know, option one, you know, the city, sort of organizing this. [1:44:20] But my two questions are, do we have any feedback yet? [1:44:23] Have we put out any surveys to get a feel for or a sense of what the majority of homeowners prefer? [1:44:31] And if we don't or haven't, is there a way to, you know, send out some communication, [1:44:38] explaining both the options and the pros and cons of each option because I know [1:44:45] insure whether our number of sort of more libertarian thinking folks that want [1:44:52] to be able to have more control and more sale over who they choose and who they [1:44:56] don't and then there are quite a few that don't care. [1:45:00] As long as it's cheap, as cheap as they can get it, I would just be curious to know if we have already done an initial outreach, what the results were, and if we haven't, could we do that, you know, and say, hey, this is coming, whether you like it or not, so one way or the other, this is happening, you have two choices, here are the pros and the cons of each of the two. [1:45:24] Yeah, we did some outreach through that survey that we did all citywide, so I would say that those numbers we would need to get more participation rate to understand better feedback from folks. [1:45:36] We have the recycling committee, we have a few volunteers that do have gone out to different neighborhoods and doorknock and ask people. [1:45:42] It's been more specifically around the organic drop sites than it has been around the curb side. [1:45:48] So I think that was a large part of the reason [1:45:52] of wanting to start this transition process now [1:45:54] to start understanding what more folks would be interested in, [1:45:59] or which way would rather go with it. [1:46:02] I do think understanding or explaining that education piece [1:46:05] that it's going to be required and everyone's [1:46:08] going to have to pay for it. [1:46:10] I think we'll just allow people to make a better decision [1:46:14] on that instead of knowing that they either, [1:46:18] whether they participate or not, [1:46:20] they're required to pay for that fee. [1:46:23] Yeah, I think we need to do that sooner, [1:46:25] rather than later, so that people aren't surprised, [1:46:28] and we need to give them sort of a ballpark. [1:46:30] You know, like, hey, if the city does this, [1:46:32] it's gonna cost you $10, if you do it yourself, [1:46:35] it could be 100, right? [1:46:36] Like, I know I'm just making those numbers up, [1:46:38] but I think we owe it to them to be pretty clear. [1:46:41] I agree that, you know, with the amount of money we put into roads, I would like to see fewer [1:46:47] trucks and just pollution-wise and, you know, all of that, but also, I know there's a number [1:46:54] of people that are very, I don't know what the word is, but they want to make their own choices, [1:47:00] right? So, I'd just like to get a sense, even if it's 51-49. [1:47:05] Okay, [1:47:08] Mr. Wilson, this timeline draft that you've got in the packet. [1:47:15] It sounds like you're getting feedback that organized city collection is preferred as opposed. [1:47:22] How does that then feed into this timeline draft? [1:47:26] That, I think the draft would have to be updated a little bit just to reflect, I think [1:47:30] more, better timing, just I probably would have to build in a little bit more time for [1:47:35] community feedback, but then looking at where the, you know, kind of budget counter [1:47:39] of lies in which year we want to start negotiating prices or looking at RFPs. [1:47:44] It'll just have a little bit more refined version. [1:47:47] I would say if when that would fit into there. [1:47:50] So, and I do know we have, again, like we have a great group of volunteers [1:47:53] through the recycling committee who, I think we definitely have folks who would be willing [1:48:00] to go out and start working on that feedback. [1:48:05] And is there a pilot program as part of one decision or the other, are they both, would you do a pilot program for city collection? [1:48:14] Yeah, oh, sorry. [1:48:17] If it's city or if it's city or hall or third party or city contracted? [1:48:22] Yeah, I think it would be like just as an idea to play, put the girl that put that pilot program in there. [1:48:27] I know kind of more like a phased in approach to see if there's certain neighborhoods that have more interest or more engagement around it. [1:48:33] that we could start with just to learn a little bit more, kind of work out the [1:48:37] kinks of what's going on or the, I guess, to know when we do do a 100% roll-out [1:48:45] wide, how it goes, but I think we'd have to look at how that gets paid for, right, [1:48:54] because we can't pay for, like, just some people can't opt in, because I want to have to [1:48:59] charge, be charged for it, so then do we look at, you know, do we have funding to bring down [1:49:05] the cost or buy out the cost a little bit to make it cheaper right off the bat forever and [1:49:09] who wants to participate or maybe incentivize signing up earlier, it can be part of that program [1:49:17] or something. It just feels really early. It's like not even Q3, 2020, 26 and we're targeting [1:49:23] at 20, 30 launch, is that my reading this right? [1:49:27] Yeah, we have to, we have to offer it by 2030, yep. [1:49:30] And so we've got three and a half years of planning here. [1:49:38] And maybe we can't do a pilot program. [1:49:40] Like what do we, what do we, I don't know, just feels early to make a decision [1:49:44] about one of the others. [1:49:46] It's a survey, and some survey engagement will certainly help. [1:49:52] Yeah, I mean, I don't think you have to wait until 2030. [1:49:56] Do we just has to be implemented by 2030? So we probably want to start it in [1:50:01] 29, which really only gives us a year and a half of planning and it just seemed like from all [1:50:09] of the information that was in our packet, but there's a lot for the city to have to do. [1:50:15] Yeah, I'm just going by the timeline draft of 2030 target readiness full program availability. [1:50:23] Yeah, and when we have the rates with the holler, we look at [1:50:27] kind of they started off like year one is they base it off as zero to 10% participation rate for [1:50:33] example and then we build on that so we might so we would you know may say something like [1:50:38] we offer this to everyone called to get a cart but we're not going to deliver carts to everyone [1:50:43] like you call in and let us know when you want a cart sort of a thing and they base and then the [1:50:48] rate goes up the higher the participation rate goes up. [1:51:04] I think what we're saying is we want to get [1:51:05] more information through the surveys and discussions with residents. [1:51:12] As always I'm leary about surveys because I really do feel the way the questions are [1:51:17] worded can be inaccurate. It can make people not want to fill it out. However, I would [1:51:24] support getting resident input at like our pop-up events in the park or movie in the park [1:51:29] music in the park. Surveys can be lengthy and you know I agree with engagement but I think [1:51:42] there might be better ways to engage the community. [1:51:47] So you've heard I think all of us have [1:51:51] stayed it we would like some more community engagement. Now that's not exactly addressing your [1:51:57] main question of option one or option two. [1:52:04] Council regarding option one and option two, which is what the [1:52:10] staff is looking for. [1:52:12] Do we feel we kind of unanimously that we all just want a little more [1:52:16] resident input before we can give a definitive answer on that? [1:52:21] It's like we're trying to do so. [1:52:23] I think that's the direction from the council will be and we'll look forward to [1:52:27] bringing it back to us. [1:52:29] Right. [1:52:29] Okay. [1:52:30] That's perfect. Great. Thank you, Mr. Wilson. Yes, this is thanks. We'll throw a report. Thank you. [1:52:36] We'll now move on to Duttada for F. Mill Street Water Main Project. So for this, we have a report that's been prepared by our staff for the city council and for the community. [1:52:50] and that has been prepared by City Engineer Andrew Buddy, Matt Moriam, our public [1:52:56] works director and Martin Vinsky, the City Administrator, and I'm assuming the [1:53:01] public works director is going to take the lead here. Yeah, thank you, Marin [1:53:06] Comso. Andrew had a prior commitment that could not get out of. So I will be [1:53:13] going through this item along with Mark. I would say Mark Andrew and I have all [1:53:19] working on this over the last couple weeks to bring this item back to you as we discussed in the [1:53:27] June 8th meeting. So to give some background here again at the June 8th meeting we discussed [1:53:36] so the city awarded the bid in April to install Waterman along Mill Street as part of the [1:53:48] from a previous area shown up here, with municipal water that was served by Chan Hassan and [1:53:57] shorewood buys water from Chan Hassan, and following the bit award, we communicated with [1:54:07] Chan Hassan that this has been approved, and they brought up the topic of additional [1:54:12] connection fees, which we have not paid additional connection fees in the past for some properties [1:54:19] that have been added in the service area. And so this was, I guess, an item that was not [1:54:30] expected. So with this new information, we went back, came back to Council to communicate this [1:54:39] and then ultimately provide the best pass for our recommendation [1:54:45] to provide the best path forward. [1:54:50] A little bit more background. [1:54:51] The metered interconnection between Chanhason and Sherwood [1:54:54] had previously been installed in 2006 [1:54:58] when the a well existing well on Apple Road failed. [1:55:05] A connection fee was paid to Chanhason [1:55:08] for the service area, six additional properties in that area connected, and there was a two [1:55:18] properties outside, which are identified here that connected, and then three lots in that [1:55:23] area that connected to Excelsior over that time. [1:55:27] The service area with the proposed water main extension would service 25 properties. [1:55:43] So, at the June 8th Council meeting, Council directed staff to continue discussions with Chan Hassan, [1:55:52] regarding the connection fees and to communicate with residents and [1:56:00] obtain feedback and answer any questions that potentially had. [1:56:05] This is a pretty quick turnaround from the council meeting to essentially [1:56:10] getting this information in the packet was about eight days, so it wasn't the [1:56:15] most thorough communication admittedly, but we did our best to try to [1:56:22] out. I know there was I think four residents that talk to Andrew and went through any questions [1:56:33] that they had on there. As some of the residents have mentioned, these properties are [1:56:38] some of these or many of these properties are unique in size and where their houses are located. [1:56:45] So there is a large variability. We've gone through that in past council meetings prior to [1:56:50] the last council meeting in June. So that's, well, there is a high range of costs for the properties. [1:57:01] We did our best. We did put flyers all last year to communicate to residents and work with them. [1:57:09] I know Andrew would work with residents that did communicate with us to potentially get a little bit more [1:57:14] in estimate of anybody had any questions and there was a few people that certainly took us up [1:57:22] on that and met with Andrew or talked to Andrew via phone. So over the past couple weeks [1:57:32] staff did meet with the two with Chan Hassan regarding the connection fee, Chan Hassan is not agreeable [1:57:39] to zero connection fees, which is what the council preferred. [1:57:44] Certainly, all of us would have preferred that. [1:57:47] However, they were agreeable to a reduced rate [1:57:50] that we were already working towards prior to the last [1:57:55] council meeting. [1:57:56] We did have it, things finalized with that, as we were [1:57:59] continually meeting with them to work on something. [1:58:05] So the reduced connection fee takes into account [1:58:08] overall infrastructure costs on their end, [1:58:11] required in our end required to operate their water system, [1:58:16] which includes storage, treatment, conveyance [1:58:19] for which is essentially pipes. [1:58:23] And we came up with a calculation that [1:58:29] reduced the hookup charge that Chan Hassan has [1:58:33] by 44% would so it would be 56% of Chan Hessens water hook-up charge, and I say water [1:58:44] hook-up charge, because that's what they use in their user fee schedule. [1:58:49] In 2026 fees, that would equate to $5,494.9 cents, originally if you remember, with the [1:59:03] 25 properties, we were in the range where I think over $300,000 at that fee would be with this and the kind of negotiating the different properties within the service areas. [1:59:20] We got to agreed to 15 additional properties at that reduced rate, which in $20, $26, or $26 connection charges would come to a fee of 82,411 and 35 cents. [1:59:43] In the discussions, we've discussed this before last Council meeting with Chan Hasson, but [1:59:49] solidified it with them that we would agree that the hookup charges would only be paid [1:59:56] if a property connects to the system. [2:00:00] Currently sure what does not require connection. So if somebody did not want to connect ever, there really wouldn't be an additional charge with the exception of the water base fee if the water main gets installed that is now fee for customers that have water main in front of their house and they're not connected. [2:00:29] Which is, I think like $32 a quarter or something like that. [2:00:35] That is not in a new, what's new as of January 1st, 2026, but not new because of this project. [2:00:45] The [2:00:53] one, the, so some of the numbers and some of the different service areas, it gets [2:01:01] a little bit confusing and when we're talking about having the, let me see, having the [2:01:13] the JPA, the joint powers agreement, so we had a joint powers agreement in 2006 that needs [2:01:19] to be updated as part of this process. The chain has in details that are part of the general [2:01:26] chain has in details that are part of this process are the reduced connection fee of 56%. [2:01:33] So we talk about the 56%. It's always going to be 56% as part of this JPA of their connection [2:01:42] charge, or the water hook-up charge, the current one, as of whatever somebody would connect. [2:01:51] So if it's three years from now, potentially their connection charge would be maybe $200 [2:01:58] more expensive, it would be 56% of that charge. [2:02:03] Does that make sense? [2:02:10] The, and that would be for the 15 properties outside of the 2006 service area. [2:02:18] And so we have the new amended joint power agreement with the city of Chanasent draft. [2:02:25] That is for consideration. [2:02:27] The shore would details, so this is separate from the joint powers agreement, but obviously [2:02:35] connected as we're talking about all the different percentages in the properties. [2:02:41] The what staff is proposing as part of this military water main extension project is that [2:02:50] we designate a military water main service area that would incorporate all of the 25 properties [2:02:56] that this would, that this extension would affect, [2:03:03] and the what we would propose is distribute [2:03:09] the chain has and hook up charge associated with the 15 parcels to the 25 parcels. [2:03:17] So that's kind of that bullet number two. So then you'd result in a fee that is 33.6% of the [2:03:27] So that's basically 15-20-fifths of the 56% sorry there's just a lot of math. [2:03:39] And so in 20-26 dollars for chan hasons hookup charge that would reduce that number [2:03:49] down to 3300 and seven dollars and 25 cents and I have the calculation out on that [2:03:56] the fourth bullet point in the memo. [2:04:00] We also recommend that any properties outside of the 25 parcels in that [2:04:06] military water main service or any future lot splits within any of the service [2:04:10] areas would pay the 56% of Chanhasins water hookup fee and that's detailed in the [2:04:18] joint powers agreement. [2:04:22] We did. As mentioned, we did reach out to residents. We put together a short survey. We kind of went back and forth on how detailed and how many questions we wanted to ask residents. [2:04:38] but we did do a short like three questions survey, you know, certainly mixed responses and that was [2:04:48] included. After the fact in the packet, sorry about that, it was an attached formally in the packet. [2:04:58] Ian Drew received, I think, four calls from residents reaching out, having questions about that as well. [2:05:04] And certainly we've heard from residents in this meeting that are in support or varying levels of support or do not want the water main to be extended with this. [2:05:20] So the, as communicated in past meetings, certainly this is kind of one of the still is the opportunity to extend the water main to this street. [2:05:32] This is basically a reconstruction of a street. [2:05:37] We would not consider installation a water main until a major maintenance or rehabilitation project, which is at least 30 years, but it's probably even more than that. [2:05:52] So this certainly is that opportunity. [2:05:54] We've discussed in the past the opportunity if the city ever does want to connect the east [2:06:02] and the west water systems, this piece is essentially critical to that and then certainly [2:06:09] another point is with the the there are development opportunities on the southern part [2:06:15] of this service area you can see kind of the vacant lots larger two lots on the east side [2:06:24] of military potential expansion of that, which is, again, is separate from the service area, and [2:06:33] that would be a future discussion with them. [2:06:42] I think [2:06:45] I'll leave it there, I'm sure there's going to be a lot of questions, so I don't [2:06:51] just don't want to keep talking, and so I'll open it up to questions and go from there. [2:06:57] Thank you. [2:06:58] Dr. Moriam. [2:07:00] And just to add, if Council moves ahead with approving the amended joint powers agreement, [2:07:10] tonight, fine, if you decide not to move ahead with that, we'd also like you to add [2:07:17] a motion to rescind approval of City Project 24-07. [2:07:22] and we should have included that in the memo, [2:07:26] kind of a scramble to get all this put together [2:07:28] the last minute. [2:07:29] Bye. [2:07:30] I think having that clarity on the record is important, so. [2:07:34] Thank you. Anything to add, Director Moriam? [2:07:38] Okay. So, Director Moriam, I'm going to jump in with a couple of questions. [2:07:44] So, one of the residents earlier tonight raised a concern that these discussions have just started happening. [2:07:52] How long can you recall that we've actually been talking about the possibility of installing [2:08:00] water lines into this area? [2:08:04] Yes, I mean this has been going since 2022. [2:08:09] When Hannah Bancouni scoped. [2:08:12] I mean this has been in Hennepin County CIP for a while. [2:08:16] So, part of those scoping conversations when they get into their planning phases, this was part of those conversations with Council at that point. [2:08:26] And then when, how long ago did we find out that Chan Hassan was not being as cooperative as we hoped they would be? [2:08:37] That was about three days after it got approved when we communicated that it was approved and then [2:08:46] they communicated the connection fees, which again at that time where [2:08:52] 25 properties plus some of the other ones that weren't in the service area and about [2:08:59] Again, I can't remember what the exact number was, but I think it was like 308,000 or something like that [2:09:07] And like for reference, that was like a month ago, no two weeks ago. [2:09:11] That was in middle of April, and we immediately kind of started trying to figure out what we can do. [2:09:20] We looked at different options of whether or not we could look at water rates as an option. [2:09:28] We kind of moved on from that option just because the water rates would have been elevated to the point where it really went to [2:09:37] kind of a good option for residents, because then that would have been kind of long-term [2:09:41] elevated with those fees. I would say that for Chan Hassan for any development, like new [2:09:53] development, and this is kind of, I would say this is typical for most cities. Most [2:09:58] houses and developments pay for the water main, pay for the services, and then they pay [2:10:03] city fees. I would say each house in a new development for their utilities and you can [2:10:12] correct me from you probably a little bit more familiar. You're in the 40 to 60,000 [2:10:17] dollars range for utilities and that's for a typical installation. Now some of these [2:10:21] properties are again a bit different. But the just the water connections for city [2:10:29] The Chan Hessen is 20,000, or around 20,000, because they also have a lateral connection [2:10:35] fee, which they are not charging as part of this project, because we are doing the infrastructure. [2:10:44] That part of the infrastructure. [2:10:48] And at our last meeting, Council Member Gourmet asked me to reach out to the Chan Hessen mayor [2:10:54] and discuss this at a mayor to mayor level. [2:10:56] And I did, and basically she confirms the numbers that have been presented by her staff, to our staff. [2:11:06] So, going at it from one mayor to the other didn't change anything. [2:11:11] I did, I did try though. [2:11:14] So, we've been discussing the issue of water hookups for several years, [2:11:20] But the issue of Chan Hassan requesting or these additional hook-up fees just came about recently. [2:11:32] And honestly, we wouldn't be in this situation if the many, many councils before us, [2:11:38] back when sewer went in, had also had the foresight to put in water at the same time, but it didn't happen. [2:11:45] So, here we are, [2:11:50] and this also council is a decision that requires a majority vote. [2:11:56] So, a Thai vote will fail, and a majority in the negative, it will fail as well. [2:12:06] In the past, we've been discussing this at numerous council meetings, and we've had two council members express [2:12:14] express a desire not to go ahead with this and one is Council Member Dicotolo in Santa [2:12:24] Grin. [2:12:25] Do your opinions remain the same? [2:12:30] I share the early residents' discussion about having sticker shock with the costs and [2:12:38] you know, the request was made, the lower the cost but there's no way to do that. [2:12:42] costs, I just don't understand why, so it depends on what pipe in the ground, but I guess [2:12:49] it is. [2:12:50] And I just wonder if there are any other solutions that would be more cost-effective. [2:12:55] I'm not a practicing engineer, but I just wonder if the neighborhood could organize a [2:13:02] well-local well, just thinking outside the box like that, as opposed to spending, remind me, [2:13:09] What was the cost? [2:13:10] Is it 1.6 million or something? [2:13:13] Uh, I don't know. [2:13:15] It is not that much. [2:13:17] Um, I think it's $800,000. [2:13:20] That's right. [2:13:22] Yeah. [2:13:22] But part of, I mean, so the per unit cost, I mean, when you look at water main that goes into an area, [2:13:29] I mean, you actually could kind of see it on this picture right now, you look at the [2:13:39] 75 feet, lots, and mill street, some of those properties [2:13:44] they're front footage is 200 feet. [2:13:48] So some of the maybe increased costs or the expense [2:13:53] that people maybe feel that is more expensive [2:13:56] is actually kind of as a result of, [2:13:59] that goes for a lot of the areas in Sherwood, [2:14:02] as a result of the properties that have been developed [2:14:06] or kind of just happened, [2:14:08] because we don't have a lot of planned developments. [2:14:11] Here is just a lot of houses that are there or properties that are kind of came about. [2:14:19] And we have at least nine residents that said that they're not interested at all in connecting. [2:14:26] So that takes a whole good chunk of the neighborhood out of the equation. [2:14:33] Does changes have hook up to our water by any chance, by the way? [2:14:36] We have our inner connect, so they are connected to the water, their water goes to us, though. [2:14:45] Oh, no, they are not connected to our water system, sorry. [2:14:49] Okay, no. [2:14:50] I just was curious about that, but I think I answered your question there. [2:14:56] I don't want to misinterpret, so. [2:15:00] Yes, I'm not in favor of this. [2:15:04] Councilmember Degotolo. [2:15:07] No, my opinion has not changed, and in fact, I think this makes it worse. I think a small number of residents will be sort of compelled to shoulder an unfair or inequitable burden of risk. [2:15:25] And one of my questions is, if the staff is so confident that this is, you know, a great savings and a great idea, why do they not propose to use some of the money that we have and reserve to pay for this project? [2:15:42] I just am not sure that the risk of future demand is a risk that we should make the residents [2:15:52] who in the main told us that they don't, at this point, they don't want it, not at this price [2:16:00] point. [2:16:01] Anyway, maybe possibly potentially in the future, but again, that's a risk. [2:16:07] That's a huge financial risk that we're asking them to take on. [2:16:11] So, Mayor and Carltsle, I mean, certainly if so, again, the JPA, the terms that we have [2:16:21] in that really have no reflection on how the council potentially would want to fund this. [2:16:29] If council wants to supplement the Chanhason fee for residents, that is, [2:16:41] decision that Council can make, I would say that the water utility is probably supplementing [2:16:53] this project considerably, and we're not collecting if every resident on here connected, [2:17:01] which if it ever happens, won't happen for probably many decades, doesn't pay for the price [2:17:08] of the project. So I would already say that the water utility is supplementing that. There are again [2:17:14] more benefits beyond just the residents that are connecting here, which I went over earlier. [2:17:21] So that's, I think that's part of the reason why this was the decision was made to move for [2:17:27] with this project prior, but certainly the cost or, you know, the estimated cost of [2:17:36] $82,000, again, $26, which there would be no connections in 2026, it would be 2027, [2:17:44] but just to give a level of expectation for cost is $82,411, and that is only born if people [2:17:55] connect. So if I don't connect, we don't pay. [2:17:59] Dr. Morham, can you explain the two and why there's a [2:18:04] chain-hassen connection fee in a shortward one? [2:18:08] Yep, so the connection fee for chain-hassen. So both of them are for [2:18:13] the infrastructure of the water system. [2:18:16] Chan hasons is for their conveyance, treatment, storage, and ours is similar that it's for the conveyance, the service, and certainly more of the maintenance side of things with our treatment and our storage is borne by our user rates, and that we choose to do that. [2:18:43] Now, Chanas and bears most more of that side of things [2:18:49] on their connection fee. [2:18:51] So, why can't we, if we're saying that it costs 10K for us, [2:18:57] why can't we just carve out a 10K? [2:19:03] What the Chanas importion is? [2:19:05] I mean, that's not a question for dirt and more [2:19:07] than that's a question for, I guess, just mayor, [2:19:10] of gravity, like charge and tank K, part of it goes to us. [2:19:15] Chain S and gets what it's saying it needs. [2:19:20] That's an option, but we ultimately would have to pit [2:19:23] for those 15 properties outside of that service area, [2:19:27] and any additional outside of this or any lot splits, [2:19:31] we would have to pay the 56% of their hookup. [2:19:36] I think it did that. [2:19:38] Yep. [2:19:38] I mean, conceivably, let's say it is 10K, the actual cost, it is in this odd situation here [2:19:50] where there's a map of people who are also kind of a JNS and presumably are burdened [2:19:56] is lower, right? [2:19:58] It's not like, it's all in my house, which is 100% on shoreways, it's probably a JNS. [2:20:04] So I mean, where are we given them the full 10K plus the JNS important? [2:20:09] I'm asking, I don't know, is that, is that, do they really, are they 100% unsure or what, but there's also this chain has to be? [2:20:16] I think the theory is that these costs, the 10k, which is actually didn't even cover our costs. [2:20:22] It's imaginative, oh, I like, we're still charging this. [2:20:25] Yeah, but it doesn't. [2:20:26] It should cover, it's theoretically should cover our costs. [2:20:29] It should, the total cost divided by number of residents should be what we charge. [2:20:34] Right, but we charge thinking. [2:20:37] So, now you're making it even worse by taking out a chunk, you know, it's even a [2:20:41] question. [2:20:42] But let's presume for a second that when we were charging tank k, for [2:20:44] so we're saying that's what it costs, but in this universe, it doesn't cost [2:20:49] tank k, part of it's part of it, part of it is being borne by Chiant Hassan, who was [2:20:53] own money because they support this system. [2:20:57] I think we're doing a lot of high, wishful hypotheticals, [2:21:05] I don't know. [2:21:05] One thing for this, let's reduce our fee then to make this work. [2:21:10] I'm proposing that to you too, so we're not like squandering an opportunity for a legacy [2:21:15] project here to potentially open up water to the entire area beyond 7. [2:21:24] I agree with you in the sense that I really do try to make decisions based on the concept [2:21:31] that it's a generational decision, [2:21:34] that issue of whether or not to install water [2:21:37] in this portion of town impacts not only the current homeowners [2:21:42] but the future homeowners. [2:21:45] And the fact, it's possible we may not touch this area of town [2:21:48] again for up to 30 years, [2:21:51] and that we would turn it away when the street is being torn up. [2:21:55] It almost makes me sick. [2:21:58] But on the other hand, the amount that's being asked of our residents, it's unfortunate that this came about with Chan Hassan, but it did. [2:22:07] The issue before us is not playing with numbers or playing with percentages. [2:22:13] It's whether or not we're going to approve the amended joint powers agreement with Chan Hassan or not. [2:22:20] That's the issue this evening. [2:22:21] Can move forward? [2:22:23] and move forward installing water main or not so we can do [2:22:32] We were told that the last meeting tonight, the staff needs a drop dead answer, because [2:22:45] county needs the answer to go forward with the project. [2:22:49] What going anywhere? [2:22:51] Yeah, but we can't negotiate with ourselves. [2:22:53] I mean, like... [2:22:54] We would reduce our 10K. [2:22:55] We can make that decision ourselves, correct? [2:22:58] For this map of the city? [2:23:04] That's very different than what's been done for every other water project in this city. [2:23:09] And I mean, I know what you're trying to make it more equitable for this neighborhood. [2:23:14] But for a different neighborhood who's paid the 10K. [2:23:18] It was entirely on, if they're entirely on shorewood. [2:23:20] Yes, like I paid the 10K. [2:23:23] Council Member Gorham, I'm with you. [2:23:24] I want this project to happen. [2:23:26] But I don't think on the eve of the 11th hour going into midnight here. [2:23:33] We are in the position to be creative. [2:23:38] I think the position is, do we approve the joint powers agreement with Chan Hassan? [2:23:43] And order water, installed, or do we not? [2:23:47] I think the answers that say no to that. [2:23:52] You what? [2:23:53] I want to hear them say no to that. [2:23:57] No. [2:23:57] Michelle, you are no? [2:23:59] I'm a no. [2:24:01] I mean, I don't even think that's a valid issue. [2:24:03] There's no that's not an issue on the table. [2:24:06] You said no. [2:24:07] Yeah. [2:24:08] It's because it's $3,800 by $800,000 by 25 properties is $3,000 and it's more than [2:24:16] $800. [2:24:18] So your math is correct? [2:24:20] 10K hasn't come even close as it is and now we're saying we're going to give part of it to [2:24:26] Janas and it makes it even worse. [2:24:30] Your math is correct. [2:24:31] Their math is correct. [2:24:32] It's just the reality that any infrastructure project we do today will never ever get cheaper. [2:24:44] The raw materials won't get cheaper, the labor won't get cheaper. [2:24:50] And so I understand truly residents, [2:24:53] every aspect of this argument. [2:24:55] And I think we're going to have a split vote here, maybe. [2:24:58] and unless we have a majority, which is three saying one or the other, it's the motion will fail. [2:25:05] So, I'm just going to move it right along. [2:25:08] I think we've all set our parts. [2:25:12] And honestly, I don't think anyone, we don't have a meeting of the minds here, [2:25:18] but everyone is representing something that they believe in. [2:25:23] And it's okay that councils don't have a meeting of the minds. [2:25:26] So, do I have a motion to approve the amended joint powers agreement with the City of Chan Hassan? [2:25:35] Yes, I'll make a motion to approve the amended joint powers agreement with the City of Chan Hassan. [2:25:40] And I'll second that motion. Now we're going to call the matter for a vote. All in, up, up. [2:25:46] Rule call vote. Councilmember Sanchigan? [2:25:48] No. [2:25:49] Councilmember Gorham? [2:25:50] Council Member Digrittolo, council member, Mayor Labdy, I motion fails because it's a [2:25:59] taevil we don't have our fifth person here. Council is that correct? [2:26:08] That is [2:26:08] correct your honor it needs to be a majority. So I think I do want the [2:26:13] residents to walk away feeling they were heard. This is a big issue. I think [2:26:19] All of us had interests of the residents at heart, [2:26:24] whether we were looking at generations down the road. [2:26:28] The fact that your neighborhood won't get water now [2:26:30] for a long time, the cost of the project, [2:26:34] the cost of the hookups, every single council member here, [2:26:39] was trying their best. [2:26:41] We just didn't have a meeting of the minds. [2:26:43] We didn't meet a majority and the motion there for fails. [2:26:49] So, Mayor, I did hear the second part that, oh, sorry to go ahead. [2:26:54] Oh, no, thank you. [2:26:55] Thank you, Councillor Degertola, you're reading my mind. [2:26:59] If we could get a motion, then I might suggest the language be a motion to resend city project 24-07. [2:27:08] That's going to fail too, probably. [2:27:12] Well, perhaps, but there's been a motion made, [2:27:15] And I think it would be helpful if there's some clarity on whether this project actually moves forward [2:27:21] because you did previously approve on a three to vote moving this forward. [2:27:26] So. [2:27:27] Yeah, and if I could Mayor, it's not necessarily indicative of a feeling when we're another about the motion that was made. [2:27:35] And the decision that was made tonight, but rather the fact that without a motion on the decision of the prior project approval. [2:27:44] right, we would then have an outstanding council ruling that. It has no way of being effective. [2:27:54] Right. Okay, so who is willing to make that motion? [2:28:04] What's it? What's the wording? I moved to [2:28:07] recent. I'm not sure because uh, city administrator just handed me a note and I think he must be a doctor [2:28:16] in his spare time, because his handwriting is illegible. [2:28:20] I would suggest motion to rescind the city project, 24-07, and I think that will suffice. [2:28:30] I think, and if we just move to rescind approval of it, okay? [2:28:35] I move to rescind the approval of city projects, 24-09-07. [2:28:43] seven. [2:28:47] Second. Okay, I have a motion by [2:28:49] Councilmember Sandchigan and a second by [2:28:51] Degertolo will do a roll call [2:28:53] vote. Sandchigan. I. Gorham. [2:28:57] I have to say I do this. You don't have [2:29:00] to, but procedurally we've already [2:29:01] said we're not going forward with it. [2:29:03] So to clean it up procedurally. [2:29:08] Degertolo. I. Labdy. I. [2:29:14] The motion carries unanimously in the [2:29:17] project, as previously approved, has now been rescinded. [2:29:24] So there you go. [2:29:27] Thanks for your hard work on this staff. [2:29:29] I know you guys worked hard on this, I appreciate it. [2:29:30] I do, the staff really did work the hard on this, trying to get this at a palatable situation [2:29:38] and they really met a lot of hours outside and above and beyond, so thank you. [2:29:45] So I know there's some people happy and there's some people not, and that's how it goes [2:29:50] unfortunately. [2:29:54] So, you're free to stay for the rest of the meeting, however, the people that we're here [2:29:58] for Mill Street, you're also free to... [2:30:00] We'll now move on to agenda item 4G discussion of proposed changes to the Excelsior Fire District [2:30:08] JPA. Thank you, residents for coming. [2:30:12] Thank you. [2:30:12] There are a few more. [2:30:15] The rants and hoses. [2:30:19] Thank you. [2:30:24] Okay, we took a brief pause here and now we'll move on to discussion of proposed changes to the Excelsior [2:30:31] Fire District, JPA, and with that we have a Council report that's been prepared by our [2:30:39] City Administrator, Mark Novinsky, Mr. Novinsky. [2:30:42] Madam Mayor, and Council members, [2:30:47] last month at a Fire Board meeting, the City of Depaivin [2:30:50] had proposed some changes to the Joint Powers Agreement that forms and constitutes the [2:30:57] the Excel's your fire district and the board had some pretty lively discussion I think about [2:31:05] the proposed changes but in the end said cities why don't you take this back to your councils [2:31:13] for some discussion consideration and so that's essentially what we are doing here tonight in your [2:31:23] back at you've got basically the memorandum from the dep Haven City Council in City Attorney about [2:31:32] what they're recommending. You've got a summary table of those recommendations with some [2:31:38] comments from from Shorewood staff for your consideration and then you also have the full [2:31:47] joint powers agreement. I don't know how much time you want to spend discussing all of [2:31:53] this tonight, but I think some feedback would be helpful for council member Maddie to bring [2:32:01] back to the fireboard. [2:32:04] I will say that the Excelsior representative was very clear that I think, at least in [2:32:15] her opinion, and I think this is also, at least the city of Excelsior, opening up the [2:32:23] heavy lift. And so if it's something that we are going to do and start making amendments [2:32:31] be prepared for for some long discussions and a lot of work, I think there's some feeling [2:32:37] too that now may not be the right time. That's maybe a judgment that you as council needs to make, [2:32:44] but just given the transition that the fire department is in, this might be kind of [2:32:52] Mending the JPA right now and making lots of changes might be too much, but that doesn't mean that [2:32:58] you know, there aren't things that you thoughts you might have about the JPA that you want to share. [2:33:06] Those can be captured and then brought out at another point. [2:33:11] So how does this amendment work? Is it replacing the JPA or is it just a separate document that sits on top of the JPA existing JPA? [2:33:20] That's a great question, and I don't know that, you know, would this be, you know, sort of like the letter from the D.P. of an attorney suggests, [2:33:32] delete this section, replace it with this. [2:33:35] That could be kind of messy and ugly. [2:33:39] So, in the document is old enough. [2:33:41] I mean, it's 20 some years old. [2:33:44] There's probably just a lot of cleanup that should happen anyway. [2:33:48] a lot of reference to dates that no longer matter, things like that. [2:33:54] So I would envision that if the district is going to go through this process, it's going [2:33:58] to be a full rewrite. [2:34:01] So. [2:34:02] I'm very opposed to taking bits and pieces of the JPA under consideration for amendment just [2:34:11] because one city is unhappy with how that provision applies to them. [2:34:17] I think if we are modifying the JPA, the document should be analyzed from the first word to the last word and any kind of modification should be entertained and fair game all at the same time. [2:34:35] Again, to do that, it's a big process, because I think that's how it should be done that everything [2:34:42] is looked at in totality. [2:34:45] And I don't think now on the heels of firing our police chief, having an interim chief, trying [2:34:52] to figure out if we need to restructure the organization. [2:34:58] I don't think that's the time to delve into this. [2:35:01] That's my opinion. [2:35:02] Is that because things might change, we do the whole agreement and then as we're restructuring the organization that might impact the agreement? [2:35:11] Is that what you think? [2:35:12] It's several fold. First, I do think it's dangerous to knit and pick one item at a time. [2:35:22] But second, that's exactly right. [2:35:23] I think as we go on through the discussions with the board, trying to restructure, you know, [2:35:31] before we can hire a chief, we have to interview and get resumes and seek candidates before [2:35:39] we can do that, we have to analyze the job description. [2:35:43] Before we do that, we need to discuss things like, do we need a different type of job description [2:35:49] and would that involve a different individual [2:35:51] at the helm helping the chief like a financial person. [2:35:55] So I just think that timing is wrong, [2:35:58] and I would oppose this. [2:36:03] I'm not afraid to open this upboard to examine it. [2:36:07] I just think right now, it's not the right time [2:36:10] for several reasons, especially not tonight, [2:36:12] since our representative to the fireboard, [2:36:15] who could answer questions? [2:36:16] My critical question is like, why are they doing this now? [2:36:19] what problem does this solve, and also the point that the mayor made about being in transition [2:36:27] right now with leadership. So not only do we not have our, you know, like city expert or [2:36:35] representative to provide guidance or answer questions, you know, even tonight about this discussion, [2:36:42] but we also don't have a fire chief in place, right? And so if we're going to even think about [2:36:47] making changes, you know, like, without the input of the most knowledgeable person about [2:36:53] fire stuff, right, like, fire policies, how things have worked or whatever, I don't [2:37:00] know, I just, I agree that the timing doesn't feel right. [2:37:03] I'm not opposed to examining this, I think I agree with, you know, administrative and [2:37:08] that if this is an old document and all the other cities think that we shouldn't review. [2:37:17] Okay, I don't have a problem. I'm not afraid of that. I just think the timing, you know, while the [2:37:22] boat is rocking is probably not the best time to be standing up and, you know, looking out. Just saying. [2:37:30] Your thoughts, council? [2:37:33] Why would depaving get two votes? Because that's what they're proposing. [2:37:38] There's no reason depaving should get two votes. [2:37:44] Well, I will state the obvious when I read this. To me, it feels like the reason that this is being proposed. [2:37:52] and the votes specifically are that if each, if Shorewood and D.P. haven't had both had two votes, [2:38:00] the former police chief would still be in place. I'm sorry, fire chief, would still be in place. [2:38:06] And I think there was a huge amount of frustration, which is why I think that we shouldn't be [2:38:11] having this conversation without council number Maddie, because he was there. He knows the background, [2:38:19] the history, the context, all of that. So I think it's kind of a fool's errand to have this [2:38:25] conversation tonight without him. [2:38:30] Some of the language, just to comment on some of the things [2:38:32] like the two votes, things, and one other thing I wanted to comment on is some of the language [2:38:38] that talks about serving at the pleasure of the board, just to me, it doesn't put it in the right [2:38:43] spirit, like really it was they're serving the community and the cities and to serve at the [2:38:54] pleasure of the board sort of emphasizes that this board is I know it's definitely it's the [2:38:59] governing body for sure but it just to me it it flates the the collaborative spirit of the overall [2:39:07] organization so I just want to comment on that I know it's maybe a legal terminology that [2:39:13] that's used, but if we can avoid using that kind of language, I would prefer that. [2:39:19] But there again that supports the concept of like there might be many things we want to open up and look at all in totality. [2:39:28] So, let's see, [2:39:34] we are looking to give feedback to Councilmember Maddie. [2:39:41] I would oppose the proposed changes. [2:39:56] Is that a yes? Yes. Yes. And Degertolo. Okay. So we will let our EFD board wrap council member Maddie, who, by the way, has a family emergency this evening, couldn't be here. So, um, we will let our EFD board wrap council member Maddie, who, by the way, has a family emergency this evening and couldn't be here. [2:40:16] know the position of the council, which is for OU-Nanimous. [2:40:24] All right, staff is that does that give adequate direction? [2:40:27] It's fine for us. [2:40:29] We'll now move on to agenda five, staff and council reports. [2:40:33] We'll go around the table. [2:40:36] Mr. Moriam, anything from our public works director. [2:40:39] Nothing really knew over the last couple of weeks. [2:40:42] The only one thing, we had water main repair item on the last council meeting, they will be doing that tomorrow, Wednesday, and Thursday. [2:40:53] That's pretty much it for now. [2:40:56] Okay. [2:40:57] Mr. Griffiths, anything from planning? [2:41:00] Just a few things. [2:41:02] A quick reminder, our July planning commission meeting has been cancelled. [2:41:05] So the next planning commission will be in May the August. [2:41:09] I'll note that one was moved due to night tea and night. [2:41:11] So August 18th, we'll be the next planning commission meeting. [2:41:16] Part of the reason why that meeting was canceled is we initially had hope to have our zoning code update on that agenda. [2:41:23] And I'm actually very pleased to report that we had over 300 individual comments on our draft zoning code. [2:41:29] For members of the community, from planning commissioners, from council members. [2:41:32] So we're taking some time to go through that feedback. [2:41:35] a lot of it's really good feedback, a lot of it we can save for our comprehensive plan or for future code updates and we'll be bringing that hopefully to the planning commission in August. [2:41:46] And then finally we are still working hard on the comprehensive plan update. [2:41:50] Sassman having a lot of conversations with groups like the Chamber of Commerce trying to start some outreach to some of our businesses in the community. [2:41:57] and we're really gearing up for a pop-up event [2:41:59] to consider in the park in July. [2:42:02] Otherwise, we do still have our first survey on our website. [2:42:05] There'll be up kind of until it trickles out. [2:42:09] And there'll be a mailing going out to every home [2:42:11] with the next utility bill in July [2:42:14] with more information on the comp plan. [2:42:16] I know that we are at over 100 responses on that survey, [2:42:21] which I mean, that sounds like a lot, [2:42:22] but for really only doing, I think, a newsletter [2:42:24] and a couple small events like community cleanup, I think that's been really great and hopefully [2:42:30] with this next direct mailing to the whole community we'll get even more feedback so things [2:42:35] are moving along. I'll be reaching out to the council probably in later this summer with more [2:42:41] opportunities for all of you to participate but that's what I have this evening. [2:42:47] Okay thank you, Mr. Stone, anything from our city clerk HR director. Yeah just real quick we will be [2:42:53] training over 60 election judges Wednesday and Thursday. [2:43:00] This week, I had a really great recruitment. [2:43:02] I had to turn off the recruiting mechanism [2:43:07] because we just don't know where we're going to put everybody. [2:43:11] But so I started a wait list as of today. [2:43:15] This Friday, June 26, early voting, [2:43:20] but AB voting, the city will be accepting drop-offs here at the city and July 24th, early voting begins, that's a Friday, and July 14th through the 28th is Canada filing, and we do have to open seats in the city's election. [2:43:44] Thank you. Anything from our city attorney this evening? [2:43:49] Nothing, I know updates from the City Attorney's Office, thank you, Mayor. [2:43:53] Thank you, Mr. Nivinsky, anything from our City Administrator. [2:43:56] A couple of quick updates. [2:43:58] One, park tours are tomorrow night, a Freeman park, six PM, [2:44:02] but watch the website because the weather is looking a little sketchy, [2:44:06] so that may get rescheduled. [2:44:09] I was talking to the police chief earlier today, [2:44:11] and he informed me that Flock cameras [2:44:16] Well, the contract has been terminated. [2:44:20] In fact, at the end of the year, so I don't know the exact schedule [2:44:25] for anything being removed, but we were in a two-year contract. [2:44:30] We'll essentially have just a one-year contract and then those cameras will be done. [2:44:36] So, quick update for you on that. [2:44:38] And then, last week, I sent you a quick email about the Highway 7 regional [2:44:44] solicitation and just a little bit of an update for you on that. I sure would have been asked if we [2:44:50] would be the applicant. So we're working collaboratively with the other 9 or 10 cities and community [2:44:55] school districts along with corridor. And that makes... [2:45:00] Our regional solicitation application, a little bit unusual, maybe not totally unique, but unusual. [2:45:09] I did have a chance to talk with MinDOT's federal state aid program coordinator today to sort of learn more about what an application being the applicant, you know, means. [2:45:21] I'm concerned about time and workload commitments that that might obligate the city to or any other obligations. [2:45:32] And so I learned from her today that this is actually pretty common. [2:45:37] Cities become applicants from MINDOT projects quite a bit to the point that to the point that they actually have a template to kind of transfer those funds and obligations. [2:45:51] over to MinDat, [2:45:55] on the other end of any other obligations, the one thing that we don't [2:45:59] have figured out is sort of the local match requirement that could come along with regional [2:46:05] solicitation. So we were not successful with bonding dollars this year. We have had [2:46:12] some conversations, or say our consultants have had some conversations with MinDat about [2:46:19] possibly restructuring some of the financing so that some of those [2:46:22] min-dot dollars can become the local match. They seem open to that, but we [2:46:27] don't have a solid commitment on that. If we are successful in getting this [2:46:33] application that does give us some cloud and credibility to go back to [2:46:38] the legislature and say, hey, we're assembling these grant dollars in this [2:46:43] financing. We need some help from the legislature for this. So there's some momentum that [2:46:50] could be built there, potentially. In worst case scenario, if we don't, if we get the [2:47:00] regional solicitation and no other local match, there may be a decision that we're not going [2:47:04] to move forward with that project. Apparently that does happen. Communities do return the regional [2:47:13] solicitation dollars. So, I was told today there's always an offer, but I just want to be [2:47:20] clear with council if we're going to move. Unless you've got concerns, we can be the applicant, [2:47:26] but if you have concerns and would rather not, please let me know now because the application [2:47:30] is due Thursday. So, [2:47:36] no concerns for me. Anyone? Does it impact how costs are shoulderer? [2:47:44] Well, I think, you know, because all of the cities have sort of put in money to fund the writing of this application, [2:47:55] even cities that aren't going to benefit directly, you know, from this project, or the work that Mindad does, [2:48:04] you know, trying to think holistically and trying to get some state funding, [2:48:12] or have mid-out rearrange some funding is probably the most logical solution and I think [2:48:18] there's a good case to be made there. [2:48:23] It's possible that there would be some mid-out has a cost share policy so we do have some [2:48:33] funds in the CIP thinking about cost share obligations that might emerge. [2:48:41] But I mean, that's kind of where we're at at this point, I think, with financing, things [2:48:48] are very big, big picture right now, and it's possible that, you know, if this funding [2:48:54] does come to fruition, mind that may even delay the project another year or two, just so [2:49:02] that they've got enough time to do the environmental work, acquire any additional right [2:49:06] ways, some of those things. So that's kind of what I know right now, which isn't, it doesn't [2:49:12] feel like a lot. A lot of questions. [2:49:17] All right. Well, unless there are other comments, [2:49:21] I'll plan to continue. Do you go to a little shaking or head, yes? Yeah. I have no other questions [2:49:27] about that. Okay. All right. Thank you, Mr. Nivinsky. We'll now go around the council table, [2:49:34] I have some updates from the LMCC Executive Committee meeting from June 11th. [2:49:41] You're today revenue slightly above projections due to video on demand production work like planning commission meetings. [2:49:51] We are a current projections show that LMCC will be financially viable through the near future, which is good. [2:50:01] The big news here is that candidate forums on for the election will not be offered this year [2:50:14] because of staff capacity and the lack of their studio facility. [2:50:18] Do you mean the presentation? [2:50:21] Those forums that we do where we are. [2:50:24] The community center. [2:50:25] We'll have them at the community center. [2:50:28] Well, I think we've had them in many locations, [2:50:30] but so they're not doing that. [2:50:32] They won't feel me. [2:50:33] That's what they're saying here, [2:50:35] but maybe we can talk to Mark after I guess, [2:50:38] but that's what this update says. [2:50:43] Okay. [2:50:44] I thought we should, it seems like a right of passage [2:50:46] if you're running, do you have to suffer through videos? [2:50:52] But let's say. [2:50:53] Thank you. [2:50:54] Councilmember Dicutolo. [2:50:57] I just wanted to echo what's already been said to Director Moran in appreciation for all the hard work that went into the packet and I'm very grateful for really for all the staff that's trying to give us more information and I did receive a lot of positive feedback from the last meeting about how we talked about flock. [2:51:22] People felt we were very respectful and that we tried to be balanced, and that was a word I heard a lot, so just sharing that with that feedback with everyone. [2:51:49] Thank you. [2:51:50] about the historical summary of the project with the shore-ready ravines for the Lain ravine. [2:52:01] Yes, we have been talking about that at staff, so I think we'll be happy to do an update. [2:52:08] Thank you. [2:52:08] I have a couple of things. [2:52:10] I did attend the last meeting of the Southwest Court or Transportation Coalition. [2:52:15] At this point in time, we're just kind of attending. [2:52:18] and not really participating a whole lot, but the group itself, which in the past has historically [2:52:25] represented Highway 5 and Highway 12, are really interested in help. [2:52:30] We're helping us with Highway 7 as their projects are wrapping up, so I think it's valuable just to go even if we're not saying much and just learning. [2:52:39] I attended the Christmas Lake Homeowners Association annual meeting, and that meeting, in my opinion, they are the most organized homeowners association in our city. [2:52:50] The meeting went for two hours, it was very organized, they had an agenda, all the committee members, the heads spoke, they have 15 different committees for their late association, [2:53:04] and it was just a great meeting and Heather Edelson, the Kenneth and Connie Commissioner, was also there. [2:53:11] So thank you to the Christmas Lake people for inviting me to speak again this year. [2:53:15] We had the SLMPD meeting and we had the performance review of the chief after that we went to our regular meeting. [2:53:26] We have several issues there. [2:53:30] Obviously we talked about the budget. [2:53:33] We have a review of the draft of the 2027 budget. [2:53:37] Unfortunately, you guys, the funding formula is based on several factors, one of which is population, and our population has gone up. [2:53:49] While some of the other cities have gone down or stayed stagnant. [2:53:54] So our share of the funding formula in the past was 49.7% and based on the formula, we are now going to bump up to 52% of the police budget. [2:54:08] So that right there is a big increase. [2:54:14] The other unfortunate news is that we have some major capital expenditures that are looking at us in the face. [2:54:21] We need improvements to the building itself. [2:54:26] We need, which would be shared with fire. [2:54:29] We need a battery system backup replacement. [2:54:33] Our record management system needs replacement. [2:54:38] It's, it just does. [2:54:40] And we also have our vehicles on leases, [2:54:44] and we need to continue that. [2:54:47] And so we are talking about the possibility of going out [2:54:50] a bond. [2:54:54] The SLMPD is still figuring out health insurance funding and costs and what not. [2:54:59] And then the next meeting will be discussing the budget is July 8th and the police chief [2:55:08] of SLMPD will be at our July 27th council meeting. The other issues discussed where the [2:55:16] amended parking patrol agreement with Excellseer. It was reduced to 25,000. Excellseer contracts [2:55:24] with a vendor for parking enforcement. This is a class that they paid separate independent [2:55:30] from the JPA. So they don't need SLMPD to do the work. So that's frees up our officers in theory, [2:55:38] but at the same time they were paying extra anyway. The other issue and Council Member Sanchigan was [2:55:45] I'm sure he found it very interesting, as I've highlighted in the past, the mayor of [2:55:51] the city of Greenwood, the JPA for the SLMPD requires that the mayor's serve on the coordinating [2:55:58] committee. The operating committee is the administrators and or say directors of each city. Greenwood [2:56:08] is not have a city administrator, and the mayor is insisting he serve on both committees [2:56:17] that would be the policy committee, as well as the day-to-day functioning committee, [2:56:23] and it has raised concerns amongst the other mayors, therefore as you know that I highlighted [2:56:31] last time we hired an outside attorney to give an opinion who agreed with the concept that [2:56:38] that needs to be two separate people. And at this last meeting, Greenwood once again, [2:56:46] after we brought it to our councils and told the Green City of Greenwood that we want two [2:56:53] different people in those two different roles with the two different boards, they state that they [2:57:01] But it's 3-1 that the Greenwood Mayor would not serve on both committees and the one dissenting [2:57:09] vote was obviously Greenwood. [2:57:13] Some of the reasons it's functionally awkward and we feel and it's been raised by the [2:57:18] mayors that it's a matter of good governance that two individual people are holding these [2:57:24] individual roles. It's a better division of duties. And it just has more transparency when [2:57:33] it's two different individuals. And we didn't feel much sympathy for the fact that they're [2:57:41] too little to have a city administrator well, then they need to figure this out. So that was [2:57:47] how that was left, that on that issue, that the mayor of Greenwood should not serve on both [2:57:56] committees. [2:57:58] And that about sums it up, the League of Minnesota City's conference is this Wednesday, [2:58:03] Thursday and Friday, there's still accepting registrations council and I'll be down there [2:58:11] early because they're adding an additional mayor's seminar at the beginning due to requests [2:58:17] from mayors, some of the topics are going to be handling contentious meetings, policies [2:58:27] and procedures, so I'm actually looking forward to that. [2:58:30] So if anyone wants to go, let me know who can carpool, and with that, do I have a motion? [2:58:36] And move to adjourn. [2:58:38] I'll second. [2:58:39] I have a motion by San Chagrin, a second by Lavity, to adjourn the meeting all in [2:58:44] Thanks. [2:58:45] Sandra Grin. [2:58:46] Gorham. [2:58:48] DiGurtollo. [2:58:50] Good. [2:58:50] Labdee I. [2:58:51] Motion carries unanimously, and the meeting is here by a journey at 10 o'clock. [2:59:03] Okay, good evening everyone, it's June, it's Monday, June 22nd, 2026. [2:59:10] It is 531 PM, and I'd like to call to order the city of shorewood city council work, session. [2:59:17] We have an agenda that's been prepared, it's been distributed to Council, it's been posted [2:59:22] online, and a copy can be found here in City Hall. [2:59:26] Council, are there any questions or concerns with the agenda if not, do I have a motion? [2:59:33] I move to approve the agenda. [2:59:35] I'll second. [2:59:36] I have a motion by Council Member Sanchagrin, a second by Gorham, all in favor. [2:59:41] I opposed. [2:59:43] And you know what, actually we have one council member appearing via video, so I'm sorry council we're going to have to do roll call vote this evening. [2:59:54] Council member Sanchigan. [2:59:56] Goorum. [2:59:57] Degrittolo. [2:59:59] Bye. [3:00:00] Labody, aye. The agendas hereby unanimously approved. We'll now have our recording secretary make note of council's attendance for our record. [3:00:09] And we'll move on to agenda item number two. We have a discussion on our budget work session number two personnel. And I'll turn that over to our finance director, Ms. Schmuck. [3:00:20] Thank you, Madam Mary. So tonight is our second budget work session. We're going to be discussing the personnel budget that we have. [3:00:27] In going forward, we're going to first take a look at our calendar that we have established a new calendar this year during their goal setting session. [3:00:37] We took some information that we got from our January 12th budget debriefing from the prior year, [3:00:42] and revised the schedule downsized it, and we're talking more about the larger picture items that we have. [3:00:48] So tonight is personnel, which is a majority of our budget, along with the CIP, which will be in July, [3:00:55] and then the long-term financial management plan [3:00:57] will pull everything together in August prior [3:01:00] to the preliminary budget and levy that's established [3:01:05] in September. [3:01:07] But first before we kind of get started, Sandy's going [3:01:10] to talk a little bit about personnel [3:01:12] and how we are where we're at and how we function [3:01:17] with our compensation, our benefits, [3:01:19] and any new requests that we have for this year's budget. [3:01:25] All right, thank you, thank you, Jimmy. [3:01:29] So we're going to start off, and this is all in your packet. [3:01:34] The actual PowerPoint presentation is in your packet, [3:01:40] and we'll see this in detail, [3:01:42] but we'll just kind of look at it as a higher level. [3:01:46] So in 2023, we did a compensation study with David Drown. [3:01:51] The study compared our pay structure to 21 pure cities. [3:01:58] At the time, the council made a decision to choose a market analysis and a pay [3:02:06] grid model. [3:02:08] We had the choice of about five different models. [3:02:11] This one was about mid cost for us, cost us $7,650 versus the 12,000 [3:02:22] at the time for a complete classification compensation study. [3:02:30] We decided to forego with the annual maintenance costs at the time of 4200 a year, [3:02:37] and then we implemented it ourselves through the budget, [3:02:42] which would have been another 2450 for them to implement it for us. [3:02:47] So we took on some of the work ourselves and we're able to save some money with that. [3:02:53] Basically, the findings of that study show that we were near market average, but that many [3:03:01] pure cities at the time were paying above the market to stay competitive. [3:03:07] Several positions were reclassified. Those are all in your packet tonight. [3:03:12] They were reclassified to typically just one higher grade. [3:03:17] Some of them, two higher grades, to better reflect their responsibilities. [3:03:22] All job descriptions for all positions in the city were updated. [3:03:29] It costs about $250 to do that per description, through the ground. [3:03:36] We did those all internally. [3:03:37] But we did spend an additional 175 to reclassify those positions that needed reclassification. [3:03:49] So it was a good kind of housekeeping overall process for us. [3:03:56] And all of our job descriptions were current with what those people were doing in those positions. [3:04:02] and then they were all classified appropriately to their job responsibilities. [3:04:09] So that formal pay grid that was, I believe adopted by the council in October became effective [3:04:17] January 1, 2024. [3:04:22] The grid added a top step for employee growth and the grid is also in your [3:04:28] packet so you can kind of see what that looks like to grid with many different steps. [3:04:34] So what they did to our previous grid was they added a top step for employee growth because [3:04:40] many of our employees at the time were all maxed out, which meant they get their cost [3:04:45] of living increase but they have no opportunity to step up and pay for any other reason. [3:04:53] and then we removed that lowest step because it was no longer competitive. [3:05:02] It positioned us more competitively in the labor market. [3:05:07] It compared us more with some of those pure cities [3:05:09] that were paying a little bit above market. [3:05:13] And it obviously supported our recruitment. [3:05:15] Our retention, we've definitely seen trends in both of those areas [3:05:21] that have really favored us and doing that. It also provides just for a more transparent [3:05:29] consistent system for pay decisions. It's always a balance to be able to employ your [3:05:37] or pay your employees well and retain them and continue that high level of service but also [3:05:47] to balance that with keeping the faith of your taxpayers. [3:05:54] So that was something that was one of our aims in doing the compensation study. [3:06:03] It also really helps us with the pay equity, Minnesota pay equity, which is a process that [3:06:13] entities have to go through every three years and so it helped us align those [3:06:18] physicians with that as well. So DDA at the time of the comp and class study did [3:06:26] recommend that we have a full external compensation study every three to five [3:06:32] years. We implemented that in 24 so we're getting to that point where we want to [3:06:42] 27, but it should just kind of stay on our minds as we go into the next couple of budget cycles. [3:06:51] They did recommend annual maintenance updates. [3:06:54] We have not necessarily done that. [3:06:58] Between the studies we opted at the time to forego that. [3:07:02] We do feel like we're in a fairly competitive space, [3:07:06] so we feel good about where we've been the last few years. [3:07:11] So it's just something that we chose to do at the time to save those dollars. [3:07:17] They do recommend that sometimes an off-cycle review may be needed if you're starting to see a lot of turnover [3:07:23] or vacancies or remain open for a long time and you're having trouble filling them. [3:07:30] Our pay equity risks arise. I completed that last year, our pay equity is fine. And we have not seen these issues at [3:07:39] shorewood, so we feel pretty confident that, you know, it's served as well. The proposed 2027 compensation schedule, [3:07:49] which is in your packet, includes a 3% cost of living increase over 2026. This is a compensation [3:07:59] schedule a little hard to see on the screen and in your packet, I know, but it gives you a general idea, [3:08:10] happy to give you a better copy of that if you want to see that. But that's what it would look [3:08:18] like for 2027 as we put that proposed 3% cola into those salaries. [3:08:26] This is, we do have one union, [3:08:30] It supports our public works employees. [3:08:34] These are the four positions that are in that union. [3:08:39] It's the AFSME union, and these are the 2027 wage increases per that contract. [3:08:47] This is, we're in the third year of a three-year contract with them, 2025 to 2027. [3:08:53] So, we will enter negotiations again in 2028, [3:09:01] and that utility, utility lead position is one of the positions that was identified during the comp study that there was a person at public works who was performing that current role, but was in a utility operator job. [3:09:18] job. So that was one of the things that was identified during that study. So a lot of good [3:09:24] things that come out of it because many times you just are kind of status quo moving along [3:09:30] and you don't realize that, you know, someone's working out a class and this was a prime [3:09:39] example of that where he was working in a utility lead position, but designated as a utility [3:09:45] operator and getting paid to utility operator salaries so that was something good [3:09:51] that came out of this as well. So position classification, this is just a slide that [3:09:59] tells a little bit about what that means, what that is. We did have George G. Mark who I [3:10:07] think he eventually did go over to DDA but he had performed a study before I got here in [3:10:16] And I believe that was the first time that sure would have had a formal grade step schedule [3:10:24] was when George G. Mac did that. And I believe it was put into place in 2016, maybe 2017. [3:10:33] And so between these two studies, these are the, this is the formal classification [3:10:40] and compensation system that we currently use that sure would. [3:10:46] Those are just some of the factors that they base the classifications on. [3:10:52] As you can see in your packet, there were about seven positions that were [3:10:56] re-classified because they were identified to be doing work that was classified [3:11:03] in one of these areas or many of these areas that were they weren't [3:11:09] being fairly compensated for their work in that area, so, and like I said, those are outlined [3:11:16] in your packet. [3:11:20] As far as why hiring decisions are best when made with a compensation schedule like this, [3:11:28] it promotes equity, fairness. [3:11:32] There's a lot of work that goes into these studies. [3:11:34] there's a lot of work behind a classification for a position and you're not just guessing [3:11:42] at what people should make, it's pretty scientific and so the salary range within each [3:11:57] grade provides some flexibility when you're hiring people to decide where they'll be [3:12:04] in that, Canada's meeting only a minimum qualification may start at minimum or step one, our process [3:12:13] at Shorewood here and all cities have experience in rating steps before you get to a hiring decision. [3:12:25] Actually, before you get to even the interview stage, all candidates are ranked and rated [3:12:33] on their experience, their education, and the minimum qualifications, and the preferred [3:12:38] qualifications. [3:12:40] So if you have a candidate with minimum qualifications and you end up hiring that candidate, [3:12:46] it's real likely that they'll start at that minimum step or step one, because they're coming [3:12:54] with exactly what you've asked for, but no more. We've been really fortunate at [3:13:00] sure what to hire a lot of people at that mid-step and even some of those [3:13:06] higher steps, which means they're coming in with a lot of the preferred [3:13:10] qualifications that we would like, but don't necessarily have to have. So we have [3:13:20] There's a lot of room between that minimum qualifications [3:13:24] and those preferred qualifications. [3:13:27] So they may be higher data higher step in the range. [3:13:31] This is a practice that sometimes gets questioned. [3:13:37] And I think it's responsible to question things like that. [3:13:41] But paying in or near the top of the range [3:13:44] can really be a smart investment for the city. [3:13:47] And, when you hire highly qualified employees, you take a lot less risk in other ways, even though you're paying them more. [3:13:59] So, you know, they can come in and just start working, get the job done. [3:14:06] There's not a lot of training, there's not a lot of time spent, and they can make a difference really quickly. [3:14:15] And I think what we have now with our staff in Shorewood is that we have, we're super grateful to have really quality technical and leadership in our current positions and a lot of the reason that we feel like we have that is that we really value helping [3:14:46] recruit those really talented people. We have policies that support them. We work hard internally to retain people and [3:14:57] and evaluate them as employees, and I think. [3:15:00] That one of the things we did with this compensation study has really further that objective for us. [3:15:17] That's all I have in compensation. I believe that after we go through this PowerPoint, we'll have time to discuss all of these things. [3:15:25] So I think I'll just hop right into benefits and then a new staffing request and I'll turn [3:15:30] up back over to Jeannie. [3:15:33] So we don't have a whole lot to ask this year for benefits. [3:15:37] We started a benefits committee last year and we continued that benefits committee this year. [3:15:44] We did a lot of the hard lifting last year when we asked council to consider a three-tier [3:15:49] approach when covering employee benefits. [3:15:52] Our philosophy around benefits has always been that we want to cover a single employee with our city contribution, [3:16:03] all of their benefits. [3:16:08] And probably about five years ago we started to have people turn down positions that we wanted to hire them for, [3:16:19] because our family benefit rates were really challenging for them. [3:16:29] And so we were successful at covering a single employee's benefits fully, [3:16:37] but we weren't very successful at covering people that wanted to cover a [3:16:42] or children or a family and currently our current coverage is age-banded, which means as you age, [3:16:52] the coverage goes up and then also each individual on your plan pays a rate for like your medical insurance. [3:17:04] So if you have three children, every every child is another $350 a month. [3:17:11] So, it really starts to add up. [3:17:13] So, last year, what council agreed to and what has really helped employees who are covering [3:17:19] their family members is we changed to a three-tiered system and went to the 1930-2030 [3:17:27] for an employee plus one, and then 21-30 for a family. [3:17:31] This has really helped a lot of those employees not completely cover that cost, but really [3:17:37] make a good dent in it, so when we met this year, we had a couple things that we talked about and one of them was how we felt where that contribution was landing to cover those benefits for employees, a lot of the people on the benefits committee. [3:17:58] They come from all different scenarios, they're covering their whole family, some are covering [3:18:04] single, some are covering them in a spouse, so it was a good set of people to kind of discuss [3:18:12] this with. [3:18:14] And we made the decision as a committee that we could stand with this for this year, not [3:18:25] asked for an additional increase, knowing that the rates for the Minnesota paid leave were [3:18:34] going up, and that's not a large cost. If we would have asked for $50 per employee, a month [3:18:45] for that benefit contribution, it would equate to about $15,000 for the year, whereas the Minnesota [3:18:51] paid leave premium is increasing from 0.88 to 0.96. [3:18:56] The city is required to cover at least 50% of that cost, [3:19:01] but is recovering now 100%. [3:19:06] And the benefit committee is asking that we recommend the city [3:19:10] continue to cover that 100% city paid coverage for 2027, [3:19:15] which is an additional cost to MPL of $3,500 for the year, [3:19:20] quite a lot less than the $15,000 that we would have asked for the $50 increase to the [3:19:29] contribution. So we felt like that was kind of a fair. So the benefit contribution would be [3:19:35] budget neutral and then we would ask that the Council consider covering that at 100% again for [3:19:42] 20, 27. We have had two employees who have already taken advantage of Minnesota paid leave. [3:19:49] So, the next thing is a new staffing request. [3:19:54] This is a request for a recreation coordinator. [3:19:58] Later on, Michigan, I'll just give you an overview. [3:20:01] Michigan answer any questions later on when we discuss. [3:20:05] But it's basically adding it to the 2027 budget, [3:20:09] a full-time recreation coordinator. [3:20:12] We currently have a part-time recreation specialist in this position. [3:20:15] would actually replace that position, so it would replace that position with a full-time [3:20:23] role focused on scheduling rentals, senior programming, customer service, facility coordination. [3:20:32] This is a proactive staffing adjustment tied to either the anticipated growth or if the senior [3:20:40] partners does dissolve in the near future, we're going to need someone to pick up that [3:20:45] senior programming. So this is an in anticipation of a couple things, right? The senior [3:20:52] programming and then also what the SEC task force comes back with and recommends for the [3:21:01] community center. [3:21:06] Basically, if they want to increase that utilization programming and revenue [3:21:13] generation at the center, [3:21:17] staff feels strongly that this position is going to help them [3:21:20] do that if that's what they come back with. It would provide that one consistent point of contact [3:21:27] And then also, the center is currently staffed nine to three, I believe it is by this senior partner's Monday through Friday, so not understanding how exactly that would all change, but this would strengthen that coordination across all of those programs. [3:21:52] And then we did class, we did unofficially classify the position that grades seven on our compensation schedule. [3:22:01] Obviously, if it came to the point where we were ready for this position and Council approved it, [3:22:07] we would have to classify it through like DDAs who we used to classify the positions. [3:22:13] but we expect that this is pretty close to what it would cost annually with that 3% [3:22:21] colada that's proposed for 2027 so that additionally fully loaded it would be around that [3:22:27] 68,000 odd. [3:22:30] Aller range. Because remember that we're replacing this position not, not adding it completely new. The position would be expected to be split in the budget, 5050 to the SEC and then to the park and route budget, and there's some expected benefits. [3:22:55] There's just a proposed timeline. [3:22:57] This is very flexible and at this point, not really known. [3:23:05] But it just gives a general idea of how this might look [3:23:08] with the things that are coming up with the task force [3:23:11] and the senior partners. [3:23:18] It does help us respond quickly if needed [3:23:22] if something transpires in the next couple months. [3:23:25] So that's all I got. [3:23:27] I'll turn it back to Jeannie. [3:23:31] Thank you, Sandy. [3:23:33] So now we'll kind of look at the vegetarian impact of all of this. [3:23:36] So our personnel is covered by the general fund, [3:23:40] our senior community, and against center, [3:23:42] and then the four enterprise funds all have [3:23:44] personnel expenses within them. [3:23:50] Like Sandy said, our cost of living that we're projecting in this budget [3:23:53] is the 3% that's in alignment with the labor agreement [3:23:57] that we have with the union, the paid family leave is increasing to 0.96% that's a state [3:24:04] estimate from from deed at this point. It's not a locked-in number, but that's the best [3:24:09] estimate they have at this point in time. And then the insurance contributions, the Sandy [3:24:13] said are going to remain the same at the 1930-2030 and 2130. And that's been based on recommendations [3:24:22] that have come through several discussions with the committee and departments. [3:24:29] So if you look at our personnel, we have 25 full-time employees. [3:24:34] In their time is expense to cross various components of what they do. [3:24:38] So these are various departments that we have and people are tracking their time, they're [3:24:43] managing what they're working on. [3:24:45] Those type of activities and those are the allocations then. [3:24:48] So no one person is allocated just to one department or one division, we're all distributed. [3:24:56] So I go to part of finance, I part of water and part of sanitary sewer, and those type [3:25:01] of things based on the activities that we do. [3:25:04] And public works is monitoring their time on an hourly basis or quarterly, hourly basis, [3:25:09] I believe they're quarterly. [3:25:11] Every 15 minutes, they're tracking their time and that's how these allocations come about. [3:25:15] So if you see the Streets Department is our largest component of activity that we have then it kind of gets down into some of the administrative things and then at the bottom you can see [3:25:28] elections is at zero as this is a non-election year for 2027. [3:25:36] It's just kind of another look of how the departments distribute the permanent employment employees that we have throughout the budget. [3:25:46] And if you look at the expenses, it's about 3.8 million dollars for all of our personnel [3:25:54] expenses, compensation and benefits. [3:25:57] The general fund houses about $3 million of that. [3:26:01] Senior Community and Events Center is about 125,000. [3:26:04] That's with the change of positions that Sandy talked about as far as the new employee request. [3:26:10] Water is 365 sanitary sewers just over 300,000 recycling's about $33,000 and then storm [3:26:18] water is just shy of $100,000 so those are our personal expenses distributed throughout [3:26:24] all of our city funds. [3:26:26] Quick question. [3:26:28] Are these allocations change from year to year based on workloads for example streets? [3:26:32] I remember streets goes up and down every year. [3:26:36] Right, so what we do is public works will track their hours on a regular basis, that's how their actual expenses get charged [3:26:44] and then we take those allocations from the current year and use those for projections for the next year. [3:26:50] So those adjustments shift and then public works director and the various staff members analyze those to make sure they're in alignment [3:26:58] what they're anticipating for projects for the following year and how they'll be allocated. [3:27:03] And then administration, we don't have as much change from year to year. [3:27:10] So we do time studies, Sandy had a her step to a time study this last year, and they [3:27:14] track their time for an estimated period of time, and you're allowed to project that over [3:27:19] a course of a year with time study allocations. [3:27:22] And that's authorized from the Office of State Auditors as a practice. [3:27:27] So if we go back up to the FTEs for streets, is that pretty constant? [3:27:32] or does it all that change to be- [3:27:34] It will change just slightly. [3:27:36] You figure we have- [3:27:37] How many employees do you have? [3:27:39] Six, twelve? [3:27:41] Twelve. [3:27:43] Overall employees that are allocated throughout the various departments. [3:27:46] And so it will shift some, but not drastically. [3:27:50] The biggest shift is if it's a heavy snowier, [3:27:54] or we have park maintenance projects, [3:27:57] like a lot of this bookthorn removal, [3:27:59] was a big project that they took on a couple of years ago, [3:28:01] that kind of shifted those allocations and those expenditures. [3:28:05] But that's why we review a mononeno basis. [3:28:13] So here's just another look at our personal expenses. [3:28:16] Again, the general fund is about 75% of all the overall costs [3:28:22] for personnel. [3:28:24] The water fund is just shy of 10% sanitary sewer is 8%. [3:28:30] The SEC with the new position would be about three and a quarter. [3:28:34] Again, 50% of that new position is going to the SEC, 50% of that would go to Parks and [3:28:40] Recreation with Chiz housed in the general fund. [3:28:48] And again, here's a breakout of the compensation. [3:28:51] This is 71% is actually wages. [3:28:54] The rest are taxes and insurance and benefits that we have for our employees. [3:29:00] So about 30% is covered with those other mandates. [3:29:05] So, overall, our cost of living and step-in-creases that we have based on that compensation [3:29:11] study is $121,000. [3:29:14] And that's kind of the benefit of that compensation study and having that great step system [3:29:19] that we have in place. [3:29:20] It's very common through all cities, throughout all of Minnesota as a compensation plan, [3:29:27] because it gives you a finite way of budgeting before you would be making estimates and some [3:29:33] would be up and someone would be down and these great steps an employee will get a step [3:29:38] increase if they have a satisfactory performance review. So we assume that most all employees [3:29:46] are going to receive that satisfactory because we're going to budget on a conservative basis. [3:29:51] But certainly if they do not receive that good performance review, they will not get that [3:29:56] step increase for the next year. And then that's 3% [3:30:00] The cost of living adjustment was made across the board for all employees based on that union contract that we have in place. [3:30:07] Taxes and insurance aren't the insurance side of it is not changing, but taxes are changing at the tax scales are shifting. [3:30:15] And then that's the point 96% as well for the paid family leave. [3:30:25] The new request that Sandy was talking about for the recreation coordinator, that's $101,300, [3:30:35] expense that split 50-50 between the General Fund and the Community and Events Center. [3:30:41] And as Sandy said, 67,000 of it is impacting this overall in the budget, [3:30:46] because we are removing a half-time recreation specialist. [3:30:50] So that's the net effect of turning a full-time position [3:30:55] adding the benefits and removing that other person. [3:30:58] And so that's the 67,668. [3:31:01] That's the budgetary impact for 2020, 7 for that position. [3:31:06] So overall, when you put all this together, [3:31:09] $179,000 for personnel, changes that we have going on [3:31:14] through all of the city, that's about a 2.1% [3:31:19] Let me increase for 2027 if you just looked at person now only and again like we talked about during the budget debriefing [3:31:29] We talked about various things that we had we liked having the public engagement but kind of some of the steps that we put into place last year [3:31:36] We're not being utilized. We weren't utilizing the office hours [3:31:40] But certainly my contact information is there anybody can contact me at any point in time [3:31:46] be happy to schedule time. We did have hours before and after office hours as well [3:31:51] or city hall hours so we can meet to accommodate people's schedules of necessary. We are going [3:31:58] to maintain that budget page on the city's website. If you go to the government, the city [3:32:05] departments under finance, there's a city budget page. Every budget work session that's going to be [3:32:12] on the calendar is listed on there. [3:32:14] And as we have these meetings prepared [3:32:18] and as the packets are becoming available, [3:32:20] those links are all being added to that budget page [3:32:23] via communications coordinator. [3:32:25] And then also the minutes from these meetings [3:32:27] are also being added to those as well. [3:32:30] As any power points, any presentations, [3:32:34] we have any attachments to the agenda items. [3:32:37] And then you can sign up for emails to get notifications [3:32:41] on any budget-related activity that we have, and you can do that on the city's budget [3:32:45] page as well. And then, new this year, we have a form that you can fill out to share [3:32:51] your input on the city budget, tell us about their priorities, any feedback they want to give [3:32:57] us those type of things, so we can implement some of that feedback into our budgetary process. [3:33:05] We have received one form completed to date, and so other than that, we haven't had any feedback [3:33:14] to date on any of our budget activity, but that's kind of where we've shifted our public engagement. [3:33:22] We're trying to still really put a lot of information in our news blasts and our notices, [3:33:28] is our email distributions as well as the short report and various other communications that [3:33:35] we have out there as well. So with that, we can turn it over to Council for any questions [3:33:44] and further discussion on the personnel and compensation that we have for the city. [3:33:49] Okay, thank you both. And can our recording secretary please make an amendment that the report [3:33:55] was both prepared and presented collaboratively by Ms. Schmuck, our finance director and Ms. [3:34:02] Thone, our city clerk, HR director. [3:34:05] Thank you. [3:34:06] Councilor, are there any questions? [3:34:09] A couple of clarifications. [3:34:11] One was the additional cost for the full-time employee. [3:34:17] That was factored into the budget by just adding that item rate. [3:34:20] We still have the part-time that's on there. [3:34:23] And so, how was it listed? [3:34:26] No, so we put in, we calculated what the full-time position is, which is $101,000. [3:34:33] We removed the part-time person, which brings that $100,000 down to the $67,000. [3:34:38] The $67,000 is what we have in our current budget at this point. [3:34:45] So the 67 is part of what they earn, [3:34:52] or is it half? [3:34:53] No, the difference between the 67 and the 101, that 38,000, that's what the current [3:35:00] part-time recreation specialist makes and we're removing that out of the budget. [3:35:07] And so only the budget impact, when we put 101,000 in, remove 30,000, we come up with [3:35:14] the 67 and that's the budgetary impact for the 20, 27 budget. [3:35:21] that includes benefits and all that's like everything. [3:35:26] Correct, that's not their salary. [3:35:29] Correct, it's full compensation. [3:35:32] And just on these detail ledgers that you put in, [3:35:35] and there's an attachment for more detail, [3:35:38] I noticed that the 2026 estimated was blank, [3:35:44] and the FTE's column was blank, [3:35:46] because that's just because of the format of the... [3:35:49] So the reason those are blank in the detail is because there's within our integrated financial [3:35:56] system. [3:35:57] There is a human resources module that can be used that you actually put the FTEs and those [3:36:02] type of things in the integrated system and they roll into and they populate the compensation [3:36:09] and benefits in the personnel categories within the general edger and the extended budgeting. [3:36:15] We do not utilize that at this point in time, so I have spreadsheets that I create to do all this, and then we hand add those in. [3:36:24] So they're not coming in from that. [3:36:27] Extend human resources module that's available through our integrated financial system. [3:36:33] That's why they're blank. [3:36:35] And so there's no way to omit those columns in the report. [3:36:39] You just have to... [3:36:39] Nope, it's a can report and to customize it. [3:36:43] Yeah. [3:36:44] They're just there. [3:36:47] I do see, I'm sorry. [3:36:50] Yeah. I had the same question. How do we know how many people that covers? [3:36:56] So we have the 25 full time employees that we have. [3:37:02] And so in each department, they're listed here. [3:37:06] So when you look at the street department, department 31, [3:37:10] 4.8 percent, 4.8 FTE's are included in that line item. [3:37:16] If you look at water, 2.48 of FTEs would be in the water fund under personnel. [3:37:26] So this is a manual breakout of what- [3:37:30] Would be there, but would be not utilizing that system, so I can't populate it in their report. [3:37:36] I was trying to compare that with the pie chart that you show later on, but I think that that's showing different. [3:37:42] It's a different presentation, is that right? [3:37:45] I had a few pie charts, which one are you? [3:37:47] The one that shows percentage of allocation. [3:37:51] This one here? [3:37:53] Yeah, so 75% to answer. [3:37:55] So that's 75% of the revenue, or the expenses? [3:37:59] This dollar amount, so different employees make more money if they're allocated to the general [3:38:06] fund versus SEC specialist or something else. [3:38:12] The total expenditures, this is an allocation of total expenditures. [3:38:16] The other was an allocation of their actual hours and the distribution of those expenditures. [3:38:26] Consmemored Digotolo, I see your hand is raised. Could you unmute her microphone please? [3:38:32] I'm unmuted. [3:38:34] Thank you. [3:38:35] So I have a couple of questions. [3:38:38] But first I want to say that I'm not opposed to paying employees fairly. [3:38:43] But to me, a compensation philosophy is a policy decision or discussion that needs to be held pretty much every year, [3:38:53] especially when we have new council members that were not present when the, you know, the compensation [3:39:01] study was initially done. So I have some questions about how this really came about and what [3:39:12] problems we were facing that we actually had to solve because it doesn't make entire sense to me. [3:39:19] I would, you know, an open to an explanation or understanding of why a city of only less than [3:39:27] 8,000 people needs to be highly competitive and not just market competitive, especially [3:39:35] given the fact that I've heard the mayor and Ms. Thone repeatedly say that, sure what is [3:39:43] stepping stone city, you know, for employees that are coming here to develop their skills and then [3:39:53] to move on to other cities. And the reason I ask that is because, you know, looking at your numbers, [3:40:00] it looks like within six years, anybody that is hired at the top of the scale is maxowed in six [3:40:07] And just that one pay scale that you showed, just quick back at the Amolote Math, in six years, they're making 25% more than they were on their first day. [3:40:21] So, that's my first question. I'll leave that there, and then I'll have a few more questions after that. [3:40:33] Yeah, so it sounds like that once for me, I think there were a lot of questions in there. [3:40:40] I'm not sure which one to start answering, and I appreciate the questions. [3:40:46] I think they're important and they're responsible, [3:40:51] but all cities do come in class studies. [3:40:56] I don't know any cities that don't do it. [3:40:59] If you don't keep up with the market you wouldn't really be able to get any employees to come to a city and work if the compensation schedule isn't keeping up with what other cities are paying and with, you know, with the cost of living, right? [3:41:23] So I, that was a nice question. [3:41:29] I'm sorry if I missed, if you missed, [3:41:31] my question is, why do we have to be, [3:41:33] what problem we're resolving from being [3:41:36] market competitive, which is what was written in the DDA study. [3:41:40] We were market competitive. [3:41:42] We decided that we had to be Uber market, [3:41:45] highly, in fact that's what it says, [3:41:47] we had to become highly competitive. [3:41:50] Why? Why do we have to become highly competitive? [3:41:52] And then that result in hiring at the highest end and people that come here in six years are making 25% more than they did on their first day, especially if you've acknowledged that this is potentially and maybe the likely a stepping stone city. [3:42:14] So I'm sorry that seems like a series of questions. [3:42:17] I support paying fairly and competitively market rates, which is what the DDA study said we were at market. [3:42:24] And then we decided something that triggered you to decide to go to highly competitive. [3:42:32] And I don't know what that was. [3:42:34] What problem were we trying to solve at that time? [3:42:38] Was it COVID? [3:42:39] was it, like, I don't understand why a city of 8,000 needs to be highly competitive against [3:42:46] 21 pure cities who are not actually the same as us in size, development, you know, where we are [3:42:53] on the government like the city life cycle. So that's my primary question is why did we go from [3:42:59] being market competitive to highly competitive? Well, I think at the time it was a council decision [3:43:08] and DDA presented several options. [3:43:13] And I don't know that we landed on highly competitive. [3:43:18] I think it definitely made us more competitive. [3:43:21] I think we were facing some really low recruitment numbers. [3:43:27] We were having trouble in some positions getting one or two candidates [3:43:33] and sometimes they weren't qualified. [3:43:35] and we'd have to go out for additional recruitment. [3:43:39] So we were struggling with recruitment. [3:43:41] It has increased the quality of candidates [3:43:47] that we have been able to attract since. [3:43:50] So that's one thing. [3:43:51] Number two is that currently, as I see it, [3:43:56] and this is not a professional opinion, [3:43:58] but we are falling again, [3:44:00] be low some of our neighboring cities in competitive compensation. [3:44:08] So even though it appears as, and they're good questions, it's fair, 25% from minimum to max is not unusual. [3:44:20] Look at everybody's compensation schedule, it pretty much follows that, that's very typical. [3:44:25] and the one thing that I want to also acknowledge is that, yeah, we are a stepping stone city, [3:44:35] and that's hard for cities of our size. [3:44:39] And I think that what this compensation schedule does, and by placing us, [3:44:46] we always kind of internally say, sure, what is the little city that acts like a bigger city, [3:44:51] because we like to stay on trend and on path with some of these larger cities. [3:45:00] And we offer services and service levels that most cities our size don't. And it's because we have a lot of quality employees. And they're staying care. We're retaining them because of a lot of our policies, not just compensation, but we place a high value on employees and employee retention. [3:45:21] and we do a lot of things to try to retain them. [3:45:26] And I'm a perfect example. [3:45:28] I planned on staying here three to five years [3:45:31] and I'm coming up on ten. [3:45:34] So when you treat your employees well [3:45:36] and you pay them well [3:45:38] and you value that relationship [3:45:41] that you have with your employees, [3:45:44] you get a high level of service. [3:45:46] Do you pay a little more for it? [3:45:47] Yes, you do. [3:45:48] But they have much more loyalty and they're more apt to stick around for you. [3:45:55] And when I leave at 10 years, all of my institutional knowledge and everything I've done [3:46:04] here in the service level that I've been able to achieve and get to, leaves with me and [3:46:10] you start over with a new employee and they can bring a lot to the table, I'm not saying [3:46:16] they can't, but a lot of that is a cost in dollars as well as some other significant [3:46:28] losses. So that's what we're trying to balance. And so as you may see it as overpaying [3:46:41] employees or trying to hire people that are more talented, maybe, then we need more experienced, [3:46:48] more educated. [3:46:51] Maybe, I mean, I think that's fair. [3:46:55] We have a lot of very experienced educated employees, and we pay them well, we treat them well. [3:47:03] But there are other people in my position in neighboring cities that make a lot more money [3:47:09] than I do. [3:47:10] So, we're not highly competitive, but we strive to stay competitive. [3:47:20] Thank you. [3:47:21] I guess I struggled to understand since over the last three years, we've had a turnover [3:47:26] of almost every major senior person in the city staff. [3:47:31] The administrator, the director of parks and public works and planning, the finance director, [3:47:37] the assistant finance director, the accountant, the assistant planning director, a brand new [3:47:44] admin, then communications director, we have had a lot of turnover over just in the last two [3:47:51] to three years. So I'm not sure that our philosophy is actually working and I'd like to understand [3:47:57] how much it's cost the city to implement this very high standard and what quantifiable metrics [3:48:06] that we received, right? [3:48:09] Can we point to, okay, we hired a person with a PhD in planning or in planning, and now that saved us X amount of money? [3:48:18] So, I'm not saying we shouldn't pay people fairly, I would never ever say that we should not pay people fairly. [3:48:24] But I feel like our program is not right-sized, and I feel like a lot of these policy decisions about personnel and how much we pay them, [3:48:33] what qualifications they required to be in a city of 8,000 people, less than 8,000, which is [3:48:40] already mostly built out, right? Why do we need to hire people at such a high-high standard that [3:48:49] where could we be, what trade-offs are we not making, right? Like where could that money be, you know, [3:48:56] as well or better spent? And are we right-sized, personnel-wise, and budget for the small city [3:49:03] that we are. I know we're proud to be able to offer amazing services, but if there's not a demand for that, [3:49:11] is this money potentially being better sent elsewhere? So I don't know, maybe Ms. Schmuck can tell us [3:49:19] how much we have spent, how much these new, you know, positions and rural reclassifications and personnel [3:49:26] decisions have caused the city over the since the 20 since January 1st of 2024 when [3:49:33] we implemented this new scale and why we can't possibly review this every year with new city [3:49:42] council members. Can I just add one thing because you did have a question about the turnover and [3:49:48] four of those senior level positions were retirements. So I do think we've done a really good job [3:49:55] with turnover. Obviously, I'm going to retire in a couple of years, so everybody deserves [3:50:02] to retire, right? So with that, that wasn't related to our compensation schedule or anything [3:50:10] having to do with that, so I'll turn it over to Jeannie for the additional. [3:50:15] Thank you, Sandy. So one of the things that if you look at the reason we don't do this [3:50:20] on an annual basis is because it's very intense. [3:50:23] It's very labor-intensive, it's expensive, [3:50:26] as far as doing a study to have it done, [3:50:29] to have a reposition, graded, and scaled, and scored. [3:50:33] So if you look at the compensation study, the layout, [3:50:37] there's a point's minimum and a point's maximum. [3:50:40] They take every item in the job description [3:50:43] and then they take our duties and qualifications [3:50:46] and the amount of independent decision making or knowledge that's necessary for each of the tasks that a person does in those roles, and that's how those points are generated. [3:50:58] And so those points then end up having how they get into the grades of the various grades. [3:51:05] So the city of Shorewood, back in 2016 they started this whole process back in 2016. [3:51:10] We had a great step system prior to 2016 similar to this. It just was shifted in 2016. [3:51:18] They hired George, what was his last name? [3:51:20] Jima. [3:51:22] To do this study, then in 2017, the council had a big part of it role into a budget work session through [3:51:32] that budget work session of council retreat the beginning of 2018. [3:51:37] They then had separate meetings of determining who the 21 comparative cities they wanted to compare to. [3:51:46] It was this large process, then DDA took over because George had gone to DDA. [3:51:54] Then the compensation became part of that whole process. [3:51:57] That was implemented back then in 2018 for 2019. [3:52:02] Then the study was updated in 2024 and there were those handful of positions based on that score, [3:52:12] those points system that Sandy indicated that a few positions, what were their six of them, seven, [3:52:19] got adjusted between a certain grade step to a new level. [3:52:24] Based on the change of the type of duties they were doing. [3:52:28] Now, every position... [3:52:30] We've all evolved year to year. And we do not score those on the point basis on an annual basis. That's the hundreds [3:52:38] of dollars every year we would have for every 25 positions that we have. And so that's where those [3:52:46] cost savings are because we're internally doing them. And that's why DDA is recommending that we do [3:52:51] these analyses on a three to five year basis. Some cities do it on a five to seven year basis, but [3:52:58] most cities do want to write around that five-year sweet spot of making sure you don't get [3:53:04] too far out of alignment. Because if you do wait too long, then your correction is that much [3:53:09] more expensive, usually on the other end. So a lot of the positions that have changed over [3:53:16] time, like Sandy said, were based on retirements. So there are cost savings in those positions [3:53:21] because we're bringing people that are retiring at the highest step possible because they've [3:53:26] here first, significant amount of years, and they've maxed out the potential of the qualifications [3:53:31] that they have for that position. And we're bringing in not as senior positions or senior [3:53:37] employees for some of those positions. So there are some savings in there. There are some [3:53:42] hires that we've done at a higher step grade, but we also have the cost savings that counter [3:53:48] counter act. And I think councilman to good tell us once, I think we're all interested [3:53:56] and finding out what those savings are. [3:53:58] So the cost benefit analysis. [3:54:00] For example, the paid family and medical leave decision [3:54:04] to pay 100% instead of 50 or 75 or whatever. [3:54:08] How does that translate to a benefit [3:54:10] for shortward taxpayers? [3:54:12] Is it part of our recruiting strategy? [3:54:14] I mean, we should articulate this. [3:54:16] So we discussed that in the budget process last year. [3:54:18] So the paid family leave was a new item for 2026. [3:54:23] So when we discussed the 2026 budget, it was about 25,500, I don't remember the number, but about that increase to our overall budget to pay a hundred percent of that paid family leave. [3:54:37] We had a conversation when we talked about personnel last year about whether we wanted to split that 50 50 or have that going forward. [3:54:45] So at the same time we were analyzing the insurance dollar amounts that we were doing and like Sandy said not asking for that $50 increase in insurance which would have been a higher dollar amount versus the $3,500 in this case going forward or half of that $2,500 last year when we just shifted to the three tier system that was more equitable and a benefit to the city at the time. [3:55:12] And so you as a council when we approve the 2026 budget wanted to do the 100% coverage. [3:55:19] And so that's how it got implemented into the budget. [3:55:22] We certainly can discuss it with the union and the employees to change that going forward [3:55:28] if that's something that the council would like. [3:55:31] We're just maintaining status quo as far as benefits are going in the 2027 budget. [3:55:36] So that was our projections for the reason we left it at 100% is because we're leaving the [3:55:44] health and benefits, premium contribution as a flat number, and we were leaving the paid family [3:55:51] leave as a flat number. The only thing that's changing in the person now is the compensation [3:55:57] grades step in the cost of living in Justin. So I appreciate the background and the history that you [3:56:08] I asked her the two questions that I had. [3:56:11] One, how much did it cost when we regrated? [3:56:14] How much did it cost the city? [3:56:16] When we regrated those seven positions [3:56:18] and created the new rules. [3:56:21] And then the other question that I asked is, [3:56:25] why, you answered, maybe you didn't understand my question, [3:56:27] but my question wasn't, you know, [3:56:29] why aren't we having a new study every year? [3:56:31] I'm not asking for a new study every year, [3:56:33] but I am asking for a discussion with the council [3:56:37] When we are looking at the roles and the descriptions and when we're hiring people because we are in you know in my personal opinion [3:56:46] This is just one person's opinion, but we are hiring people with backgrounds that are overkill for the jobs that they're doing here and maybe they're bored [3:56:55] Maybe they come here and the reason that they leave isn't because they were training for things [3:57:00] It's because oh, hey, I'm a PhD in urban planning and they are already built out [3:57:06] There's really nothing for me to do or as our public works director said before, if we hired an engineer, he'd have a hard time, you know, or even an engineering tech, he'd have a hard time giving him anything to do. [3:57:19] So my question was how much did it cost the city and why can't we have an annual discussion with the council before we, because we don't usually find out, like, you know, why what, what this person has been graded, what their new duties are, what duties are removed, [3:57:36] what you know what efficiencies we might have been able to to accumulate using AI or other [3:57:42] technologies or things like that. And that's why you get a lot of pushback for me personally [3:57:47] when I see on the consent agenda some of the were just supposed to approve that we have hired someone [3:57:54] at this salary because they had these amazing qualities which may or may not have been required [3:58:00] for the job that they are doing. [3:58:03] So those are my two questions, [3:58:06] are how much did it cost us, [3:58:08] and why is it impossible or [3:58:11] like unfeasible for us to have discussions [3:58:13] as a council before we make hiring decisions [3:58:17] about salaries, pay grades, [3:58:20] and qualifications? [3:58:23] So at this point in time, [3:58:24] what we have is our compensation study [3:58:27] that we've adopted. [3:58:29] Council, the city of Shorewood has adopted this. So this is our existing policy. So when we bring a new position that's vacant forward, a job description is first reviewed, and it shows the grade and step and the range of the salary that that position is going to be published in the newspaper advertised for. And that's what we're trying to capture somebody that's based on the existing point system. We are not reanalyzing points based on any shift in a job [3:58:58] description. These points are still based on the 23 points that were allocated. So even though my job has changed in the last few years that I've been here, my points haven't changed because we haven't done that analysis again. We won't do that analysis again until we do a new compensation study, and we revamp all of that. Back in 2023, there were four different reclassification options that the council discussed. [3:59:26] There was one that had a financial impact of $6,400 option two had a financial impact of $11,000. [3:59:36] Option three had an budgetary impact of $1,100 in the option four was $9,000. [3:59:46] So the discussion back in 2023 I was not here, so I don't know. [3:59:50] just reading memos and minutes and seeing that this was what was conducted. At the end of the day it doesn't really [4:00:00] How we got to where we are. I'm just required to implement what we have in place. We certainly can change our philosophy. We can certainly add a compensation study into the 2027 budget and go through this process that will be an increase to the budget. It'll probably be 20,000 dollars for compensation study. And if we're going to re-score all our positions, I think Sandy said 250 per job description on those 20 years ago. [4:00:30] five employees as well. So, we can certainly add those in as part of the 2027 budget if that [4:00:37] is council's direction as a whole of what you would like us to do going forward. But that [4:00:45] would be a budgetary and a levy increase for 2027 if we're going to implement that in 2027. [4:00:53] So, are you saying you cannot tell me exactly how much it costs the city? It's just one of those four [4:00:59] numbers and we can't measure what we got in return. There's no cost-benefit analysis, new trade-off [4:01:07] analysis, none of that. Am I, is that what I am understanding or am I wrong? [4:01:13] I did not exist back in 2023. I could go and tell you this is X amount of dollars of what it was in [4:01:20] 2022. This is X amount of dollars of what it was in 2023 and this is X amount of dollars in 2024. [4:01:25] But I don't know why those numbers shifted or why those numbers changed. [4:01:30] I wasn't here. [4:01:31] I wasn't part of that. [4:01:32] That wasn't something that the city did in the past as far as a cost benefit of [4:01:38] I'm getting this or not that I can run through and see if a line item changed in a job description. [4:01:47] But based on a compensation study, I put cloud into the consultants and the staff that [4:01:55] here at the time that put forth all the effort in going through that. I do know the council worked hard in many different meetings between 2016 and 2018 to establish this and then in 2023 to update this. So I think there's a lot of just going backwards and I'm not sure where the gain is. [4:02:17] I would rather invest the time if you want to do a study to invest the time in 2027 to prove [4:02:25] where we're at and that we are in a stable place than to try to relive history to not change [4:02:31] the status quo today. [4:02:33] I think the proving is a good idea just to go through and show the cost versus benefits [4:02:38] quantify. [4:02:40] Okay, we hired this highly experienced highly qualified employee. [4:02:43] There were other lesser qualified employees. [4:02:47] We went to, we hired this hire, this one at a higher rate. [4:02:51] But because we did that, we were able to save on training. [4:02:53] How much that was? [4:02:56] We wouldn't know that. [4:02:57] I wasn't hearing the training. [4:02:58] So, moving forward. [4:03:00] Going forward. [4:03:00] Going forward. [4:03:02] Ms. Thong can, looking back, [4:03:07] we changed the way we interview for department heads. [4:03:10] It used to be certain council members were in on department head interviews, and then we made the change and I believe you were here that whole time. [4:03:21] So the way it is now is why it results as a line item on the consent agenda. [4:03:28] Could you explain a little about how council used to be involved and why we moved away from that method? [4:03:38] Yeah, sure, mayor levity. [4:03:40] So basically, and I, you know, throw this out there [4:03:44] for council member, degree to low and, you know, [4:03:49] the council member's answering, [4:03:50] because I think this will be helpful. [4:03:52] But number one, we've always brought them the final approval [4:03:58] for a position, always comes on consent to council. [4:04:02] There is an opportunity when council is approving the recruitment to look at the job description [4:04:11] and to look at the pay grade, the pay scale, and to provide any kind of feedback for that [4:04:22] recruitment. [4:04:23] I think one thing we have not done at the city, and I think, as I said before, I think [4:04:30] It's really helped us to retain some top talent, [4:04:34] but we could move to in some positions [4:04:38] where council thinks it would be prudent. [4:04:42] We could move to a model that's more of a, [4:04:48] this is our range, this is our salary range [4:04:51] for this position, but this is our hiring range. [4:04:54] And it cuts that hiring range off at midpoint [4:04:58] or three quarters of the way saying, eventually you're going to be able to come here and make [4:05:04] this salary, but to be, you're going to be hired in no higher than this point. It does less [4:05:12] in your recruitment. There are people that we have hired more at the top range that aren't going [4:05:17] to apply for that position then, because we're restricting that hiring salary instead of offering [4:05:25] that full range were restricting it to this is our hiring range and yeah we're not going to [4:05:31] go above that and that's a common practice and people will call who want that job maybe but [4:05:39] won't come in at that level but would take the highest range and typically they say nope we're [4:05:45] not going to hire beyond this range and that's to control that balance that I talked about [4:05:50] before. And you just have to know the costs at doing that is that you are going to have a subset [4:05:58] of people that aren't going to apply for that position because it's not the full range. [4:06:04] But it's an option. And maybe it's an option that we discuss when we're hiring. If it's [4:06:12] a really important position to the city, which they all are, right? But if it's something [4:06:18] we know we're going to struggle to recruit four or that we really need to find the expertise [4:06:23] because it's an important position in the city. Maybe we don't put those parameters on that [4:06:30] position. But if it's one where we feel like we can, you know, maybe lesson that chance that we're [4:06:41] going to end up paying this person more than we want to, maybe we discuss that when it comes [4:06:49] for your approval to recruit for a position that has become vacant. So that's my, I think [4:06:57] that's what council member DeGrudelo is asking. Can we have more say when we're looking at [4:07:05] these positions to recruit for? So that may be something that we can look at in the future [4:07:11] as far as council used to, this has transpired in a couple different ways. [4:07:21] So for department heads for me, for instance, when I was hired, I had an interview with the entire council. [4:07:30] And that was typical back then. And that was before we had a HR department. And so, the administrator was doing all the HR role. And so, after I took my role in HR and with my background, we changed that to adding two council members being involved, trying to avoid the open meeting law, get two council members involved. So there's still involved in that final interview for department heads. [4:08:00] and then you're part of that decision process, and that's where a lot of you became familiar with how it all works behind the scenes, right? [4:08:11] And then after a couple of those, we, I think that we did it that way last time. [4:08:18] So I think that that stands the way that we do it currently is to pull two council members into that final interview for department heads. [4:08:27] thankfully we haven't had to do that one for a while so um but does that answer your question? [4:08:34] Yeah and I mean I think a couple of the council members have been on those committees I think [4:08:38] council member Gorham was with either council member cycle or colleagues I can't remember [4:08:43] I don't know if you were yeah ghee was on with council member Sandra Green was on [4:08:49] leaf for finance yep so um I do feel council has been involved and it's not just one [4:08:56] council member who's filled that role. We've modified it. We specifically, as a council, [4:09:03] want it, council member Sen. Grinne on with his finance background. [4:09:09] So. [4:09:10] And I appreciate your willingness to involve the council in some of the hiring, not necessarily [4:09:19] decisions, but the discussions about it. And you know, like there are other, you bring up a very good [4:09:25] point, there were several positions this year alone that I was shocked at the amount of money [4:09:33] that we were paying for, for example, the administrative assistant and a lot of these [4:09:39] part-time or even temporary employees. So I would genuinely appreciate the offer to involve [4:09:46] us earlier in the discussion rather than us find out. I mean, because when I ask about these [4:09:54] things, you're like, well, we can't do anything about it now. We've already made the offer. [4:09:59] That's what's been told to me at least three times. So I would like to be involved in this [4:10:04] or have the council's input at least because that is our role as to, you know, give offer advice [4:10:10] and give input on some of these decisions that are going to have an impact, especially on the city [4:10:17] budget and on how much we pay people has a huge impact. So thank you, Miss Thone, I actually appreciate [4:10:24] the offer to get us involved at least earlier on in the process where we can have a discussion about it. [4:10:34] Well, and if I can, if I can jump in, you know, council's role is really to set policy and [4:10:40] direction and then have staff implement that. And so by having conversations around something like [4:10:49] a compensation study in thinking about what is the level of service that you want for residents [4:10:57] and need for residents. What are you hearing about expectations? Those are important considerations [4:11:05] as you're setting policy and then helps to inform where you act with in this case your pay schedule. [4:11:15] And do you want to be a certain percentage of market or a certain percentage over? [4:11:20] Because you absolutely all the time want to attract the very best people. [4:11:25] That's really the main role for Council. [4:11:30] And you've got to struggle with some of those questions around the level of service and what you want. [4:11:37] But then trust your staff to go out and implement your policy. [4:11:45] And so it's good to have these discussions so that we're familiar with what those policies are. [4:11:51] So that staff knows where councils, [4:11:56] indications and preferences are as that does change from time to time. [4:12:01] But I guess I just want to make sure that we're clear about the roles that we do have here [4:12:10] and that we're not heading towards a situation where we're bogging down in certain details. [4:12:19] I agree. [4:12:20] If you raise the concern council member, Dicurtle, about some of the salaries for the part-time [4:12:26] or seasonal employees, we should be at the [4:12:31] the council should be involved in the discussion of what rate we're going to pay. I don't think [4:12:36] that the council needs to be involved in the interviews of the ice-rank attendance, for example. [4:12:42] But the discussion relating to the pay range of those attendance, we did raise that because [4:12:48] for several years we didn't even get enough applicants to fill the warming house spots. [4:12:55] And it's a seasonal spot that we need a lot of kids to do that because not all the kids want to work the same number of hours as the next kid. [4:13:08] So, being involved in, for example, are we going to, man both warming houses? What rate do we think we want to be in for a range? [4:13:16] That's council, that's a policy, but like being involved in the interviews, I don't, I think Mr. [4:13:24] Nivinsky's right, we have to just trust the staff that we're getting quality people. [4:13:31] I wasn't suggesting we should be involved in interviews of temporary people. [4:13:34] I was suggesting we should be involved in the discussion, just as you said, around how much should we [4:13:40] be paying them. [4:13:40] If we can't attract them at this level, do we need? [4:13:43] Is this a service we really need to provide? [4:13:45] So, I mean, I agree, but I would say, and I appreciate it, [4:13:50] both of your comments about what our roles are, [4:13:53] but the reason this is coming up now is because this is a big budget item [4:13:58] and it is more than 50% of the budget. [4:14:01] So, I am thinking that this is a big policy issue [4:14:04] that we should be involved in. [4:14:06] And the fact that we don't get involved in it until the budget comes around [4:14:09] is not the right way to do it. [4:14:11] And that's why I get a little bit exercised [4:14:14] about the issue of personnel, because it is the largest chunk of the budget. So yes, I feel [4:14:22] like we need to pay very close attention to detail when it comes to what we're paying people [4:14:28] and why we're paying that and what trade-offs we are making, what is the cost-benefit analysis. [4:14:34] And it may seem like it's two detailed or two in the weeds, but when we have to answer [4:14:39] to our residents and to the people who elected us about our budget decisions, if we are not [4:14:46] armed with all the information and all the data and can defend our budget decisions, then [4:14:51] we are not doing our jobs. That's our role. [4:14:55] And I think we took positive proactive a step. [4:15:00] By hiring David Drone in Associates in 2023, an agreeing to talk about it annually, which is what we're doing now. [4:15:09] Unfortunately, we're past the time for this work session. It's probably time to wrap it up. [4:15:15] Councillor, are there any last questions? [4:15:20] Do we need to reconvene or do we? [4:15:22] No, I think this was just an informal presentation. Are you looking for guidance from Council on this matter? [4:15:31] Well, at this point in time, what we have in the budget and we will bring forward and we go forward with the various fund budgets is the 3% cost of living to maintain the 100% paid family leave and to not increase the contributions towards premiums. [4:15:50] So that's what we're proposing in this budget, and if there are no concerns with those, that's [4:15:55] what we will continue going forward. [4:15:57] If Council would like to put a compensation study or some other information in the budget [4:16:02] for 2027 to review anything further, we can certainly do that. [4:16:08] There's certainly not enough time in between now and 2027 to do a full study or revise what [4:16:17] we have. [4:16:17] We are implementing the policy that was decided upon by council that the city has. [4:16:24] And so that's what we're going to do going forward. [4:16:27] But if you'd like to give us any direction outside of that, we would take that now because [4:16:32] that's how we're going to build the budget going forward. [4:16:36] Council? [4:16:37] Any comments? [4:16:38] Yeah, I think we just have those policy discussions around compensation and make sure [4:16:43] It's clear that we're not always shooting at the top end of the range. [4:16:48] That's a perception, you know? [4:16:51] Make sure that we're measuring that so that we're balancing out fair pay with positions, [4:16:58] level of positions, and taxpayer values for taxpayers. [4:17:02] The benefits that this creates. [4:17:04] And I'm assuming Sandy can when she presents a recommendation for a hiring that a little [4:17:11] more detail on the justification of the, [4:17:15] less, the great step on the compensation could be included in that instead of just this is where we're at. [4:17:21] Right. I think that we appreciate it. [4:17:23] Concephember, Gorham any final thoughts? [4:17:25] At this time, we're not including a, the recreation coordinator. Is that right? [4:17:31] This does have the recreation coordinator position in the budget, [4:17:35] and it is removing the recreation specialist out of the budget at this point in time. [4:17:40] Because I'm not in favor of that, you know, pardon? [4:17:45] I'm not in favor. We have not actually discussed that coordination that person's job or description or any of that. [4:17:52] So I can't say that I'm in favor of including a full-time employee in the as a recreation coordinator to replace the other part-time person. [4:18:04] Is that consensus of the council that I remove that out of the budget? [4:18:08] I'm not there yet either. [4:18:11] I'm cautious because in the event that the South Shore senior partners is at the correct [4:18:18] folds, the only way we can continue to offer senior programming, which all of the council [4:18:26] has said is a valuable asset to the community, would be to have someone step in that role. [4:18:31] And the current individuals who work at the community center have their jobs filled right now. [4:18:40] I mean, what I'm trying to say is their hours, the only way we could add those additional tasks would be adding additional hours. [4:18:48] Perhaps we could put that topic on a future. [4:18:57] And it's kind of just joined it because we're going through the SEC task force currently, which is ultimately going to get recommendations that's an include staffing budgeting all that stuff. [4:19:08] However, right now we're planning for personnel for 2027. [4:19:11] So that position is essentially a placeholder, assuming that the task force comes back with recommendations that involves that position as well to achieve the council's goals. [4:19:23] So, it's a lot easier to take that out of the budget once we get into that process than try to add that back in. [4:19:30] So that position as a whole will get flushed out through this process. [4:19:34] It's more of a placeholder of. [4:19:36] If we get to that point, we know that we're going to be taking on a lot more workload to get to that revenue, [4:19:41] which is going to mean we're going to need more manpower to achieve that. [4:19:45] So I think further discussion will organically come with that. [4:19:48] It's just essentially a placeholder right now. [4:19:50] I mean, essentially, the volunteers staff, the desk of about 30 hours a week, correct? [4:19:57] So, I mean, that's a big, if that organization folds in those volunteers, no longer volunteer in that capacity to do what we're doing now, we need to hire someone to fill the 30 hours. [4:20:10] So, I'm reluctant to pull it out. [4:20:13] I understand your concerns, Council Member DiGritolo, and Council Member Gorham. [4:20:18] But as a placeholder concept, as we go through the budget, I support that concept, knowing [4:20:23] that if that doesn't happen, we could always pull it back out, but adding it back in [4:20:28] is tough. [4:20:29] And really, the preliminary levy, once it's established, we can never raise that levy. [4:20:34] We can only lower it. [4:20:36] And so like Miss Thone was pointing out earlier is we'd review the task force information [4:20:42] in the early 2027 and mid 2027, we'd finalize the scope of this position and we wouldn't [4:20:48] even be looking to hire or recruit until mid to late 2027. [4:20:53] So those items will come back to council, but if we don't have it in there at some point [4:20:58] in time, we're going to fall short on that levy at the September preliminary levy component. [4:21:06] I understand that I'm still not for it. This is a proactive not-demand triggered request and I, like, I don't understand necessarily that there is demand for this yet and we don't have any, like, measurable, I'm just, I'm a no, so the rest of the council can, you know, decide what they want to, but I don't think we should include it. [4:21:32] especially if it's not going to be to mid late of a 2027 that would maybe only be a three-month [4:21:38] gap before 2028 when we could hire someone in January if we needed to. So I don't think we need to [4:21:45] proactively put this in there. The senior partners have expressed that their longevity is not long, [4:21:53] like the end of this year, they're struggling right now financially. They're a printer for their [4:22:00] newsletter or their software they use for their newsletter is not going to be functioning [4:22:05] after this year. So they are looking to move on. So with all things play out, if we don't [4:22:12] have this position in our budget for 27, we will likely be eliminating senior programming [4:22:17] in 27. In your presentation earlier, couple meetings ago, couple months ago, you highlighted [4:22:27] the different programs that we offer the money. [4:22:30] On of people who take advantage of them, and it was surprising how many people are in the center on a daily basis. [4:22:38] And I know we've all kind of expressed that the seniors really don't have anywhere to go. [4:22:45] Tonka Bay doesn't have a facility, Excel Sear doesn't have a facility, [4:22:49] Deep Haven doesn't have a facility, Greenwood doesn't have a facility. [4:22:54] So, you know, it's a nice community gathering spot, [4:22:58] and I would think that the anywhere from 6 to 18 men who meet every single day [4:23:05] at 10 a.m. for coffee would agree with that. [4:23:08] Madam Mayor, may I, we're, we're about at time and I know Councilor DeGrello has expressed her, her thought that the rest of council, do we leave this in here and kick this decision, you know, down down the road, or do you do you want to take it out? [4:23:27] No, so I think it's my personal opinion. I think it's prudent to leave it in and we can always lower the levy. [4:23:36] We cannot raise the levy and we'll have many more times to discuss this in the meantime. [4:23:44] Director Chek will have more conversations with the senior partners. [4:23:48] I just see we've all talked about the programming as an amenity to the community. [4:23:54] But the bottom line is if we don't budget for it and the senior partners fall apart, there's no way we can pay for 30 hours of staffing time to man that desk. [4:24:06] And without someone at that desk and someone representing the city, we're going to have to cut programming. [4:24:14] Council, final thoughts. [4:24:17] I'm okay as long as it's clear that we can remove it before the year end, if there's no justification for it. [4:24:24] I think there's its own agenda item, like I don't know a lot about the programming, it's just a, I don't want to keep pouring costs into here too, like we're already, like how many of these seniors are even from shoreward and all the costs are being borne by us for this, you know, no one else chips in for it. [4:24:43] So as long as we're bringing it back, we can always take it out, but I want to know more about it at its own. [4:24:48] But plus I think it's good to do it after the shorewood group that's analyzing the center has met a few more times and they come with an analysis to us and recommendations because at this point we don't even know how that group is thinking yet. [4:25:06] So I think, say, if you've heard us, I think we're kind of voicing a majority to keep it in as a line item knowing that we can always take it out if that is the need be. [4:25:18] Staff, do you have any other issues we need to weigh in on quick or can we adjourn? [4:25:23] Can I adjourn? [4:25:23] Okay, council, do I have a motion? [4:25:25] I move to adjourn. [4:25:27] I have a motion by council member, San Chicago in a second by Gorm to adjourn the work session all in favor. [4:25:34] Oh, oh, yeah, and I have to do a roll call. [4:25:38] Comments member, San Francisco. [4:25:40] Gorham. [4:25:41] Digotolo. [4:25:44] Labody. [4:25:45] Eye. [4:25:45] Motion carries unanimously. [4:25:47] And the work session is hereby adjourned at 6.58 PM. [4:25:52] You're watching LNCC.