1
00:00:15,770 --> 00:00:16,110
city council meeting.

2
00:00:16,110 --> 00:00:17,613
>> good ever wantoning, I

3
00:00:17,613 --> 00:00:18,113
would like to call the

4
00:00:18,113 --> 00:00:20,113
regular

5
00:00:21,149 --> 00:00:23,549
city council meeting for

6
00:00:24,153 --> 00:00:24,520
wednesday MARCH 26, 2025 to

7
00:00:24,520 --> 00:00:26,520
order.

8
00:00:27,423 --> 00:00:28,123
MAY I please have roll call.

9
00:00:28,123 --> 00:00:29,240
>> councilmember coleman?

10
00:00:29,240 --> 00:00:29,958
>> here.

11
00:00:29,958 --> 00:00:31,360
>> councilmember nagales?

12
00:00:31,360 --> 00:00:32,600
>> here.

13
00:00:32,600 --> 00:00:32,795
>> councilmember nicolas

14
00:00:32,795 --> 00:00:33,962
?Frjts present.

15
00:00:33,962 --> 00:00:35,130
>> vice mayor addiego?

16
00:00:35,130 --> 00:00:35,831
>> here.

17
00:00:35,831 --> 00:00:37,831
>> mayor flores?

18
00:00:38,434 --> 00:00:41,270
>> I am present, thank you.

19
00:00:41,270 --> 00:00:42,571
Tonight we have as I've been

20
00:00:42,571 --> 00:00:44,707
doing two special guests that

21
00:00:44,707 --> 00:00:45,174
will lead us in pledge of

22
00:00:45,174 --> 00:00:47,174
allegiance.

23
00:00:48,210 --> 00:00:50,790
I would like to invite

24
00:00:50,790 --> 00:00:52,615
jonathan I.Pak who is five

25
00:00:52,615 --> 00:00:54,249
years old in transitional

26
00:00:54,249 --> 00:00:55,484
kindergarten at our lady o

27
00:00:55,484 --> 00:00:57,484
mercy.

28
00:00:58,287 --> 00:00:59,455
He also plays tee ball for

29
00:00:59,455 --> 00:01:01,855
south san francisco yuth

30
00:01:02,425 --> 00:01:06,250
baseball and he's in the kids

31
00:01:06,395 --> 00:01:08,931
gym in south city as well as

32
00:01:08,931 --> 00:01:09,865
dylan munsayak who is 14

33
00:01:09,865 --> 00:01:11,865
years

34
00:01:14,303 --> 00:01:17,303
old, 8th grader at st.

35
00:01:17,340 --> 00:01:19,642
Veronica's sx, teen gym in

36
00:01:19,642 --> 00:01:21,430
south city to lead us in the

37
00:01:21,430 --> 00:01:22,445
pledge of allegiance this

38
00:01:22,445 --> 00:01:23,746
evening, so please stand if

39
00:01:23,746 --> 00:01:24,114
you are able to and place

40
00:01:24,114 --> 00:01:24,914
your

41
00:01:24,914 --> 00:01:26,416
right has happened over your

42
00:01:26,416 --> 00:01:30,160
heart and I will have them

43
00:01:31,530 --> 00:01:34,653
lead us in the pledge of

44
00:01:34,957 --> 00:01:35,725
allegiance.

45
00:01:35,725 --> 00:01:36,493
>> I pledge allegiance to the

46
00:01:36,493 --> 00:01:37,226
flag of the united states of

47
00:01:37,226 --> 00:01:37,894
america and to the republic

48
00:01:37,894 --> 00:01:38,294
for which it stands one

49
00:01:38,294 --> 00:01:39,620
nation

50
00:01:39,620 --> 00:01:41,462
under GOD, indivisible, with

51
00:01:46,736 --> 00:01:49,539
liberty and justice for all.

52
00:01:49,539 --> 00:01:51,141
>> thank you very much.

53
00:01:51,141 --> 00:01:51,508
Stay right tl. Let's give

54
00:01:51,508 --> 00:01:53,508
them

55
00:01:53,710 --> 00:01:54,177
a hand, why don't we do that.

56
00:01:54,177 --> 00:01:56,177
[Applause].

57
00:01:56,679 --> 00:01:58,515
And I would like to present

58
00:01:58,515 --> 00:01:59,215
dylan and jonathan with two

59
00:01:59,215 --> 00:02:01,215
of

60
00:02:02,686 --> 00:02:05,686
our official city key pins

61
00:02:07,624 --> 00:02:10,624
this evening, so I'll come

62
00:02:11,795 --> 00:02:14,231
down and we'll take a picture.

63
00:02:14,231 --> 00:02:16,231
>> he's coming down.

64
00:02:46,330 --> 00:02:47,931
(Taking photograph).

65
00:02:47,931 --> 00:02:49,931
>> great.

66
00:02:52,937 --> 00:02:53,337
Let's have next agenda item,

67
00:02:53,337 --> 00:02:54,104
please.

68
00:02:54,104 --> 00:02:55,806
>> thank you, MAY yo, moving

69
00:02:55,806 --> 00:02:58,206
on to agenda review.

70
00:02:58,342 --> 00:02:59,430
>> we hve no changes to the

71
00:02:59,430 --> 00:02:59,843
agenda, mayor flores.

72
00:02:59,843 --> 00:03:01,843
>> thank you.

73
00:03:02,790 --> 00:03:03,247
>> thank you, moving on to

74
00:03:03,247 --> 00:03:04,315
levine act disclosures, does

75
00:03:04,315 --> 00:03:05,816
the council have anything to

76
00:03:05,816 --> 00:03:07,551
report tonight?

77
00:03:07,551 --> 00:03:09,185
Thank you.

78
00:03:09,185 --> 00:03:10,210
And we'll move on to

79
00:03:10,210 --> 00:03:12,210
announcements pr staff.

80
00:03:23,267 --> 00:03:25,103
>> great.

81
00:03:25,103 --> 00:03:26,738
>> welcome, chief samson?

82
00:03:26,738 --> 00:03:29,738
>> thank you, I'm trying to

83
00:03:30,775 --> 00:03:32,377
get the slide up here.

84
00:03:32,377 --> 00:03:32,710
I'm going to stop before I

85
00:03:32,710 --> 00:03:34,110
get

86
00:03:34,110 --> 00:03:36,110
too crazy.

87
00:03:39,651 --> 00:03:42,510
>> good evening, mayor eddie,

88
00:03:42,420 --> 00:03:43,787
matt samson, your fire chief,

89
00:03:43,787 --> 00:03:44,188
first we're incredibly

90
00:03:44,188 --> 00:03:46,900
excited

91
00:03:46,900 --> 00:03:49,327
for next friday the 4th, it's

92
00:03:49,327 --> 00:03:50,929
a really big day for nt only

93
00:03:50,929 --> 00:03:53,929
our department but for our

94
00:03:54,990 --> 00:03:55,667
city to christen the city's

95
00:03:55,667 --> 00:03:59,170
brand new fire boat, it will

96
00:03:59,170 --> 00:04:00,305
take place on friday the 4th

97
00:04:00,305 --> 00:04:01,473
at oyster point, a little

98
00:04:01,473 --> 00:04:03,274
history of the water rescue

99
00:04:03,274 --> 00:04:05,243
program ask a water show and

100
00:04:05,243 --> 00:04:05,610
ip viet the public on the

101
00:04:05,610 --> 00:04:06,844
boat

102
00:04:06,844 --> 00:04:07,312
for tours if they'd like to

103
00:04:07,312 --> 00:04:09,312
come.

104
00:04:09,881 --> 00:04:11,783
We hope to see everyone there.

105
00:04:11,783 --> 00:04:12,684
Second, in support of our

106
00:04:12,684 --> 00:04:13,840
public outreach to help

107
00:04:13,840 --> 00:04:13,851
inform

108
00:04:13,851 --> 00:04:14,286
our community about the

109
00:04:14,286 --> 00:04:16,286
impact

110
00:04:17,322 --> 00:04:18,623
tos the state's most recent

111
00:04:18,623 --> 00:04:18,990
fire hazard severity zone

112
00:04:18,990 --> 00:04:19,891
maps

113
00:04:19,891 --> 00:04:21,260
released at the end of

114
00:04:21,260 --> 00:04:21,426
FEBRUARY websinger ear

115
00:04:21,426 --> 00:04:23,426
hosting

116
00:04:23,895 --> 00:04:26,198
our town hall 65 at the terra

117
00:04:26,198 --> 00:04:29,100
bay neighborhood up on APRIL

118
00:04:29,100 --> 00:04:30,868
7, that will go from 6:30 to

119
00:04:30,868 --> 00:04:33,171
8:30 and we're here to answer

120
00:04:33,171 --> 00:04:34,773
questions regarding the fire

121
00:04:34,773 --> 00:04:36,375
hazard severity zone mps but

122
00:04:36,375 --> 00:04:37,542
also anything wild fire

123
00:04:37,542 --> 00:04:38,643
related, any comments or

124
00:04:38,643 --> 00:04:41,430
comments or anything the

125
00:04:41,379 --> 00:04:42,547
public would like to know how

126
00:04:42,547 --> 00:04:42,915
they can make their home

127
00:04:42,915 --> 00:04:44,383
safer

128
00:04:44,383 --> 00:04:44,750
from wild fire and is the

129
00:04:44,750 --> 00:04:46,452
town

130
00:04:46,452 --> 00:04:50,522
hall is open to anyone in the

131
00:04:50,522 --> 00:04:50,889
city, we hope to see everyone

132
00:04:50,889 --> 00:04:51,723
there.

133
00:04:51,723 --> 00:04:52,858
>> I have a question.

134
00:04:52,858 --> 00:04:54,858
>> please.

135
00:04:56,695 --> 00:04:59,532
>> if I could, so I know that

136
00:04:59,532 --> 00:05:01,932
these fire hazard severity

137
00:05:02,334 --> 00:05:03,502
maps, are they through fema

138
00:05:03,502 --> 00:05:05,805
?Frnlts they're produced by

139
00:05:05,805 --> 00:05:07,406
cal fire and they're released

140
00:05:07,406 --> 00:05:08,941
by mandate under state

141
00:05:08,941 --> 00:05:09,809
ordinance to incorporate all

142
00:05:09,809 --> 00:05:10,876
the etire state of

143
00:05:10,876 --> 00:05:12,876
california.

144
00:05:12,979 --> 00:05:14,113
>> where you fall on that

145
00:05:14,113 --> 00:05:15,548
map,

146
00:05:15,548 --> 00:05:16,449
does that determine maybe an

147
00:05:16,449 --> 00:05:18,751
impact to your home insurance?

148
00:05:18,751 --> 00:05:20,620
>> that is a current concern

149
00:05:20,620 --> 00:05:23,620
right now, we've been assured

150
00:05:23,756 --> 00:05:24,991
that these maps do not impact

151
00:05:24,991 --> 00:05:26,993
insurance rate and is we'll

152
00:05:26,993 --> 00:05:28,695
spend a a quite a bit of time

153
00:05:28,695 --> 00:05:29,462
why we agree with that

154
00:05:29,462 --> 00:05:30,950
perspective during the town

155
00:05:30,950 --> 00:05:31,263
hall.

156
00:05:31,263 --> 00:05:33,663
>> okay, thank you, chief.

157
00:05:35,968 --> 00:05:37,968
>> thank you.

158
00:05:38,838 --> 00:05:41,140
>> we'll go on without the

159
00:05:41,140 --> 00:05:42,475
slide, but I'm very excited

160
00:05:42,475 --> 00:05:42,976
also as the third

161
00:05:42,976 --> 00:05:44,177
announcement

162
00:05:44,177 --> 00:05:45,144
tonight, I would like to

163
00:05:45,144 --> 00:05:47,144
announce officially and

164
00:05:47,213 --> 00:05:50,213
introduce our new dputy fire

165
00:05:50,916 --> 00:05:53,316
chief, devon flannery, he's

166
00:05:54,420 --> 00:05:56,220
been with the city for 23

167
00:05:56,220 --> 00:05:56,756
years, and started in the

168
00:05:56,756 --> 00:05:58,756
fire

169
00:06:01,528 --> 00:06:04,264
service as an explorer and

170
00:06:04,264 --> 00:06:06,132
spent quite a bit of time in

171
00:06:06,132 --> 00:06:07,500
the pacific palisades area.

172
00:06:07,500 --> 00:06:09,900
With our department, chief

173
00:06:11,438 --> 00:06:12,439
flannery has served as

174
00:06:12,439 --> 00:06:14,839
paramedic firefighter, ba tan

175
00:06:20,580 --> 00:06:22,482
I -- battalion fire chief.

176
00:06:22,482 --> 00:06:22,949
Chief flannery has invested

177
00:06:22,949 --> 00:06:24,350
in

178
00:06:24,350 --> 00:06:24,818
his own education, he was

179
00:06:24,818 --> 00:06:26,687
able

180
00:06:26,687 --> 00:06:27,354
to obtain his undergarage

181
00:06:27,354 --> 00:06:29,189
walt

182
00:06:29,189 --> 00:06:30,357
degree from san francisco

183
00:06:30,357 --> 00:06:31,992
state, a doctoral degree f

184
00:06:31,992 --> 00:06:32,926
the university of southern

185
00:06:32,926 --> 00:06:33,393
california in education so,

186
00:06:33,393 --> 00:06:34,794
he

187
00:06:34,794 --> 00:06:37,364
brings a unique skill set and

188
00:06:37,364 --> 00:06:37,831
a lot of capabilities to our

189
00:06:37,831 --> 00:06:39,633
department.

190
00:06:39,633 --> 00:06:39,967
We're going to leverage him

191
00:06:39,967 --> 00:06:41,335
to

192
00:06:41,335 --> 00:06:43,337
make sure we can advance the

193
00:06:43,337 --> 00:06:44,504
department to the future, s

194
00:06:44,504 --> 00:06:46,607
I'm excited and I would like

195
00:06:46,607 --> 00:06:46,973
to bring him up for a few

196
00:06:46,973 --> 00:06:48,973
words.

197
00:06:51,440 --> 00:06:53,440
>> con -- congratulations,

198
00:06:54,248 --> 00:06:56,160
let's bring him up, please.

199
00:06:56,160 --> 00:06:57,584
[Applause].

200
00:06:57,584 --> 00:06:59,530
>> good evening, council, i

201
00:06:59,530 --> 00:07:00,453
want to thank the fire chief

202
00:07:00,453 --> 00:07:02,323
for believes in me, it's been

203
00:07:02,323 --> 00:07:02,690
a a pleasure to serve the

204
00:07:02,690 --> 00:07:03,323
city

205
00:07:03,323 --> 00:07:03,891
the last 230 23

206
00:07:03,891 --> 00:07:04,458
years, I

207
00:07:04,458 --> 00:07:06,160
look

208
00:07:06,160 --> 00:07:07,795
forward to the next

209
00:07:07,795 --> 00:07:08,128
opportunity in my new role

210
00:07:08,128 --> 00:07:09,563
and

211
00:07:09,563 --> 00:07:10,597
using my skill set to further

212
00:07:10,597 --> 00:07:11,565
the mission of the fire

213
00:07:11,565 --> 00:07:11,999
department, I want to thank

214
00:07:11,999 --> 00:07:13,999
everybody.

215
00:07:18,973 --> 00:07:19,607
>> thank you, con fwrafp --

216
00:07:19,607 --> 00:07:21,607
congratulations again.

217
00:07:22,309 --> 00:07:23,430
>> thank you.

218
00:07:23,430 --> 00:07:25,430
[Applause].

219
00:07:25,179 --> 00:07:28,179
>> alright, now I would like

220
00:07:28,316 --> 00:07:29,583
to do a special I guess

221
00:07:29,583 --> 00:07:30,885
announcement, recognition and

222
00:07:30,885 --> 00:07:31,251
for that, I would like to

223
00:07:31,251 --> 00:07:33,870
turn

224
00:07:33,870 --> 00:07:34,880
it over to our city manager,

225
00:07:34,880 --> 00:07:36,880
sharon ranals.

226
00:07:36,457 --> 00:07:37,892
>> good evening, I'm sharon

227
00:07:37,892 --> 00:07:38,593
ranals, city manager, she is

228
00:07:38,593 --> 00:07:38,960
not expecting this but I

229
00:07:38,960 --> 00:07:40,960
would

230
00:07:41,762 --> 00:07:44,762
like to call up christina

231
00:07:48,403 --> 00:07:50,171
fernandez if I could.

232
00:07:50,171 --> 00:07:50,972
Hi, chris taoep na.

233
00:07:50,972 --> 00:07:51,272
>> hi.

234
00:07:51,272 --> 00:07:53,272
Er

235
00:07:53,508 --> 00:07:53,975
>> so, tonight is

236
00:07:53,975 --> 00:07:55,143
christina's

237
00:07:55,143 --> 00:07:55,443
last city council meeting as

238
00:07:55,443 --> 00:07:57,443
a

239
00:07:57,445 --> 00:08:01,450
city employee, we hope to see

240
00:08:01,249 --> 00:08:01,683
her at future council

241
00:08:01,683 --> 00:08:03,510
meetings

242
00:08:03,510 --> 00:08:03,718
because she is still a a

243
00:08:03,718 --> 00:08:04,452
resident, christina has

244
00:08:04,452 --> 00:08:05,186
accepted a position as the

245
00:08:05,186 --> 00:08:06,540
assistant city manager with

246
00:08:06,540 --> 00:08:07,210
the city of brisbane which is

247
00:08:07,210 --> 00:08:08,857
a promotional opportunity for

248
00:08:08,857 --> 00:08:10,692
her so we're happy for

249
00:08:10,692 --> 00:08:12,227
christina but we are very sad

250
00:08:12,227 --> 00:08:13,695
to see her go.

251
00:08:13,695 --> 00:08:14,620
christina has been in the

252
00:08:14,620 --> 00:08:15,960
city

253
00:08:15,960 --> 00:08:15,463
manager's office for six

254
00:08:15,463 --> 00:08:16,797
years

255
00:08:16,797 --> 00:08:19,200
and during that time, she's

256
00:08:19,200 --> 00:08:19,634
worked on a number of

257
00:08:19,634 --> 00:08:21,360
projects

258
00:08:21,360 --> 00:08:22,671
including many grant

259
00:08:22,671 --> 00:08:23,405
applications, many grant

260
00:08:23,405 --> 00:08:23,738
reports, legislative niche

261
00:08:23,738 --> 00:08:25,738
yat

262
00:08:26,408 --> 00:08:26,775
I fevers such as minimum

263
00:08:26,775 --> 00:08:28,743
wage,

264
00:08:28,743 --> 00:08:30,378
styrofoam reach codes and

265
00:08:30,378 --> 00:08:32,414
could back koe which we'll

266
00:08:32,414 --> 00:08:32,848
hear about and emergency

267
00:08:32,848 --> 00:08:34,549
response.

268
00:08:34,549 --> 00:08:35,650
She has also been our

269
00:08:35,650 --> 00:08:36,840
sustainability officer and

270
00:08:36,840 --> 00:08:37,686
has

271
00:08:37,686 --> 00:08:37,986
served as staff liaison with

272
00:08:37,986 --> 00:08:39,986
a

273
00:08:40,656 --> 00:08:42,590
null of outside agencies such

274
00:08:42,590 --> 00:08:44,660
as wet sxa, the harbor

275
00:08:44,660 --> 00:08:45,827
district, one of christina's

276
00:08:45,827 --> 00:08:48,697
major projects has been to

277
00:08:48,697 --> 00:08:49,732
establish a a community

278
00:08:49,732 --> 00:08:51,330
district which is progress

279
00:08:51,330 --> 00:08:51,366
thanks to her effort and is

280
00:08:51,366 --> 00:08:52,534
we

281
00:08:52,534 --> 00:08:53,936
hope it will be successful.

282
00:08:53,936 --> 00:08:54,303
I think there's a special

283
00:08:54,303 --> 00:08:56,303
bond

284
00:08:56,672 --> 00:08:58,540
among the staff who served

285
00:08:58,540 --> 00:08:58,874
during covid and christina

286
00:08:58,874 --> 00:09:00,874
was

287
00:09:00,909 --> 00:09:02,544
really instrumental in

288
00:09:02,544 --> 00:09:04,646
organizing -- I'm getting

289
00:09:04,646 --> 00:09:08,246
choked up -- covid was a

290
00:09:08,317 --> 00:09:10,152
trying time, she was

291
00:09:10,152 --> 00:09:10,853
instrumental in organizing

292
00:09:10,853 --> 00:09:11,587
vaccination clinic, food

293
00:09:11,587 --> 00:09:11,921
distributions, maintaining

294
00:09:11,921 --> 00:09:12,988
the

295
00:09:12,988 --> 00:09:14,323
continuity of operations as

296
00:09:14,323 --> 00:09:16,425
well as staff morale and we

297
00:09:16,425 --> 00:09:18,961
owe her a lot of appreciation.

298
00:09:18,961 --> 00:09:20,429
So w that, I have this little

299
00:09:20,429 --> 00:09:21,530
token of appreciation which

300
00:09:21,530 --> 00:09:24,330
christina, I want dwrou hang

301
00:09:24,330 --> 00:09:26,102
this in your office in

302
00:09:26,102 --> 00:09:29,102
brisbane, just a reminder of

303
00:09:29,338 --> 00:09:32,938
all your friends in south san

304
00:09:34,777 --> 00:09:36,679
francisco.

305
00:09:36,679 --> 00:09:39,515
>> oh my gosh, thank you.

306
00:09:39,515 --> 00:09:42,515
>> nice picture of city hall.

307
00:09:43,786 --> 00:09:44,453
>> thank you so much.

308
00:09:44,453 --> 00:09:46,453
[Applause].

309
00:09:47,790 --> 00:09:48,858
And I'm putting you on the

310
00:09:48,858 --> 00:09:49,225
spot, I don't know if you

311
00:09:49,225 --> 00:09:50,590
want

312
00:09:50,590 --> 00:09:51,127
to say a few words.

313
00:09:51,127 --> 00:09:52,528
>> first of all, thank you so

314
00:09:52,528 --> 00:09:52,962
much to sharon and to

315
00:09:52,962 --> 00:09:54,962
everyone

316
00:09:55,698 --> 00:09:56,165
and to all of you for your

317
00:09:56,165 --> 00:09:57,320
leadership.

318
00:09:57,320 --> 00:10:00,360
You know, when I was brought

319
00:10:00,360 --> 00:10:01,637
on board, I wasn't quite sure

320
00:10:01,637 --> 00:10:03,306
what to expect.

321
00:10:03,306 --> 00:10:04,907
Initially I was to serve as a

322
00:10:04,907 --> 00:10:07,277
commissioner for the city and

323
00:10:07,277 --> 00:10:10,146
then I got recruited to come

324
00:10:10,146 --> 00:10:10,613
work for the city and for

325
00:10:10,613 --> 00:10:11,247
that

326
00:10:11,247 --> 00:10:12,715
I'm forever grateful.

327
00:10:12,715 --> 00:10:14,350
I have a vested interest in

328
00:10:14,350 --> 00:10:15,518
seeing the city succeed and

329
00:10:15,518 --> 00:10:18,880
I'm very, very proud of the

330
00:10:18,880 --> 00:10:19,255
work that the staff has done,

331
00:10:19,255 --> 00:10:21,391
the staff goes above and

332
00:10:21,391 --> 00:10:22,959
beyond every day for the

333
00:10:22,959 --> 00:10:24,427
community and I just feel so

334
00:10:24,427 --> 00:10:27,397
grateful to have been a small

335
00:10:27,397 --> 00:10:28,698
part of it, just a big thanks

336
00:10:28,698 --> 00:10:31,101
to sharon for her leadership

337
00:10:31,101 --> 00:10:31,868
and to all of you for your

338
00:10:31,868 --> 00:10:34,868
leadership and just thank you

339
00:10:35,105 --> 00:10:37,105
so much.

340
00:10:37,374 --> 00:10:39,209
[Applause].

341
00:10:39,209 --> 00:10:40,877
>> any comments from my

342
00:10:40,877 --> 00:10:41,377
colleagues on the dais?

343
00:10:41,377 --> 00:10:43,180
>> MR. Mayor?

344
00:10:43,180 --> 00:10:45,180
>> yes.

345
00:10:46,116 --> 00:10:46,883
>> as christina staining a

346
00:10:46,883 --> 00:10:48,785
picture, christina, I wanted

347
00:10:48,785 --> 00:10:49,720
to say thank you for all your

348
00:10:49,720 --> 00:10:50,887
amazing work, you're

349
00:10:50,887 --> 00:10:51,221
absolutely right, you first

350
00:10:51,221 --> 00:10:53,190
--

351
00:10:53,190 --> 00:10:54,224
we first met you as someone

352
00:10:54,224 --> 00:10:55,359
applying as a commissioner I

353
00:10:55,359 --> 00:10:57,193
think to the planning

354
00:10:57,193 --> 00:10:58,628
commission I think it was.

355
00:10:58,628 --> 00:11:00,300
>> general plan.

356
00:11:00,300 --> 00:11:02,430
>> general plan, that' right.

357
00:11:03,333 --> 00:11:04,735
We were so amazed by you that

358
00:11:04,735 --> 00:11:07,604
we wanted to hire you.

359
00:11:07,604 --> 00:11:09,506
I just wanted to say thank

360
00:11:09,506 --> 00:11:11,740
you, this city really owes a

361
00:11:11,740 --> 00:11:12,420
great debt to you for all the

362
00:11:12,420 --> 00:11:12,376
great work you've done and

363
00:11:12,376 --> 00:11:14,376
the

364
00:11:14,478 --> 00:11:14,845
fact that you are -- ask

365
00:11:14,845 --> 00:11:16,845
still

366
00:11:17,470 --> 00:11:17,414
are a south city resident

367
00:11:17,414 --> 00:11:19,414
gave

368
00:11:19,583 --> 00:11:20,884
a unique perspective in terms

369
00:11:20,884 --> 00:11:21,652
of issues happening in south

370
00:11:21,652 --> 00:11:23,287
san francisco.

371
00:11:23,287 --> 00:11:23,654
I know you're not too far

372
00:11:23,654 --> 00:11:25,654
away

373
00:11:26,490 --> 00:11:27,424
as you go up north --

374
00:11:27,424 --> 00:11:28,859
>> a town over.

375
00:11:28,859 --> 00:11:29,159
>> but we know you're only a

376
00:11:29,159 --> 00:11:31,159
a

377
00:11:31,395 --> 00:11:31,829
phone call away if we need

378
00:11:31,829 --> 00:11:32,329
anything.

379
00:11:32,329 --> 00:11:33,764
>> absolutely.

380
00:11:33,764 --> 00:11:35,132
>> thank you very much.

381
00:11:35,132 --> 00:11:36,670
>> thank you, councilmember.

382
00:11:36,670 --> 00:11:37,468
Anyone else?

383
00:11:37,468 --> 00:11:39,103
>> christina, of course, when

384
00:11:39,103 --> 00:11:41,172
I ws mayor, you have been a

385
00:11:41,172 --> 00:11:41,905
tremendous help and I really

386
00:11:41,905 --> 00:11:44,675
do appreciate all that you

387
00:11:44,675 --> 00:11:46,878
have done for us and for the

388
00:11:46,878 --> 00:11:47,778
city, and as a woman, I am

389
00:11:47,778 --> 00:11:49,447
very supportive of you

390
00:11:49,447 --> 00:11:49,847
climbing up the career

391
00:11:49,847 --> 00:11:51,847
ladder,

392
00:11:52,249 --> 00:11:53,417
more power to you and I'll be

393
00:11:53,417 --> 00:11:53,884
here to support you all the

394
00:11:53,884 --> 00:11:54,819
time.

395
00:11:54,819 --> 00:11:56,819
Thank you, cristina.

396
00:11:57,255 --> 00:11:59,255
>> thank you.

397
00:11:59,657 --> 00:12:01,580
>> I will say you are a

398
00:12:01,580 --> 00:12:02,860
resident of the best district

399
00:12:02,860 --> 00:12:03,194
in south san francisco and

400
00:12:03,194 --> 00:12:04,896
now

401
00:12:04,896 --> 00:12:06,130
that -- I know it was

402
00:12:06,130 --> 00:12:07,165
mentioned earlier, now that

403
00:12:07,165 --> 00:12:08,633
you're no longer employed by

404
00:12:08,633 --> 00:12:09,133
the city, maybe you could

405
00:12:09,133 --> 00:12:10,735
join

406
00:12:10,735 --> 00:12:12,370
a commission and continue to

407
00:12:12,370 --> 00:12:14,472
just be around and contribute

408
00:12:14,472 --> 00:12:16,307
b so many of your talents and

409
00:12:16,307 --> 00:12:18,743
you have many talents that

410
00:12:18,743 --> 00:12:21,143
pansies so many different

411
00:12:22,781 --> 00:12:24,616
topic areas as we noticed the

412
00:12:24,616 --> 00:12:25,984
city manager said you've done

413
00:12:25,984 --> 00:12:26,318
lots of diverse work tere

414
00:12:26,318 --> 00:12:28,318
and

415
00:12:29,120 --> 00:12:31,520
your work on sustainability

416
00:12:31,923 --> 00:12:34,923
which the city with reach

417
00:12:37,696 --> 00:12:40,298
codes, with the poorly l --

418
00:12:40,298 --> 00:12:42,133
polystyrene ban, I hope to

419
00:12:42,133 --> 00:12:42,534
susie you come back in the

420
00:12:42,534 --> 00:12:44,534
future.

421
00:12:45,404 --> 00:12:47,380
>> sharon hosted a lunch at

422
00:12:47,380 --> 00:12:48,773
city hall and we got the

423
00:12:48,773 --> 00:12:51,643
express ourselves and I said

424
00:12:51,643 --> 00:12:53,440
how nice it was for south san

425
00:12:53,440 --> 00:12:55,444
francisco to have an

426
00:12:55,580 --> 00:12:56,748
operative, I had a dream of

427
00:12:56,748 --> 00:12:57,883
annexation but you don't have

428
00:12:57,883 --> 00:13:00,283
to foat that yet.

429
00:13:00,786 --> 00:13:01,653
You can't be any closer than

430
00:13:01,653 --> 00:13:03,188
brisbane, good luck to you.

431
00:13:03,188 --> 00:13:04,356
>> thank you.

432
00:13:04,356 --> 00:13:05,991
>> equally grateful for your

433
00:13:05,991 --> 00:13:07,292
time, for your dedication but

434
00:13:07,292 --> 00:13:09,261
most importantly for your

435
00:13:09,261 --> 00:13:10,194
passion as it was said as a

436
00:13:10,194 --> 00:13:12,594
resident, you certainly care

437
00:13:13,232 --> 00:13:15,133
about the city and it was

438
00:13:15,133 --> 00:13:15,467
highlighted and underscored

439
00:13:15,467 --> 00:13:16,769
in

440
00:13:16,769 --> 00:13:19,380
every presentation and every

441
00:13:19,380 --> 00:13:19,470
staff report that you

442
00:13:19,470 --> 00:13:19,972
provided

443
00:13:19,972 --> 00:13:21,840
and shared.

444
00:13:21,840 --> 00:13:23,909
Thank you for representing,

445
00:13:23,909 --> 00:13:24,276
for being a true resident

446
00:13:24,276 --> 00:13:26,110
like

447
00:13:26,110 --> 00:13:27,179
many in this hall and around

448
00:13:27,179 --> 00:13:27,546
our community that really

449
00:13:27,546 --> 00:13:28,780
care

450
00:13:28,780 --> 00:13:30,115
about south san francisco, so

451
00:13:30,115 --> 00:13:30,649
con grafp lacing, GOD's speed

452
00:13:30,649 --> 00:13:32,649
to you.

453
00:13:32,684 --> 00:13:33,853
If I could ask city manager

454
00:13:33,853 --> 00:13:35,888
and council to join me down

455
00:13:35,888 --> 00:13:37,857
here fr a picture wth

456
00:13:37,857 --> 00:13:39,857
christina, please.

457
00:14:21,330 --> 00:14:22,468
(Taking photograph).

458
00:14:22,468 --> 00:14:24,537
>> thank you very much.

459
00:14:24,537 --> 00:14:25,238
Now we're moving o to the

460
00:14:25,238 --> 00:14:27,238
next agenda item.

461
00:14:27,774 --> 00:14:28,641
>> thank you, mayor, moving

462
00:14:28,641 --> 00:14:30,641
on

463
00:14:31,411 --> 00:14:31,911
to proclamations,

464
00:14:31,911 --> 00:14:33,480
proclamation

465
00:14:33,480 --> 00:14:34,130
recognizing APRIL as fair

466
00:14:34,130 --> 00:14:34,747
housing months.

467
00:14:34,747 --> 00:14:36,449
>> I've asked councilmember

468
00:14:36,449 --> 00:14:36,950
mark nagales to present this

469
00:14:36,950 --> 00:14:38,950
proclamation.

470
00:14:40,687 --> 00:14:42,880
>> this is an honor for me to

471
00:14:42,880 --> 00:14:43,456
recognize the month of APRIL

472
00:14:43,456 --> 00:14:45,856
as fair housing month.

473
00:14:47,827 --> 00:14:50,300
I had the distinct honor to

474
00:14:50,300 --> 00:14:51,398
work with project sentinel

475
00:14:51,398 --> 00:14:51,865
where we helped numerous

476
00:14:51,865 --> 00:14:53,865
south

477
00:14:54,468 --> 00:14:55,669
san francisco residents with

478
00:14:55,669 --> 00:14:56,502
tenant/landlord issues ask

479
00:14:56,502 --> 00:14:58,502
fair housing issues.

480
00:14:59,306 --> 00:15:00,940
You know, you would be

481
00:15:00,940 --> 00:15:03,900
surprised at the fact of the

482
00:15:03,900 --> 00:15:05,345
number of residents who will

483
00:15:05,345 --> 00:15:05,812
get denied for rental units

484
00:15:05,812 --> 00:15:07,812
or

485
00:15:08,382 --> 00:15:11,382
for housing based upon their

486
00:15:11,384 --> 00:15:14,984
gender or their age or the

487
00:15:15,823 --> 00:15:17,458
fact they had children and it

488
00:15:17,458 --> 00:15:19,659
was organization like project

489
00:15:19,659 --> 00:15:22,196
sentinel who went above and

490
00:15:22,196 --> 00:15:23,130
beyond to make sure all our

491
00:15:23,130 --> 00:15:24,965
residents had accessible to

492
00:15:24,965 --> 00:15:25,299
fair housing so I'm honored

493
00:15:25,299 --> 00:15:26,667
to

494
00:15:26,667 --> 00:15:28,736
recognize APRIL as fair

495
00:15:28,736 --> 00:15:30,871
housing month and to read a

496
00:15:30,871 --> 00:15:32,472
proclamation where it says

497
00:15:32,472 --> 00:15:34,107
whereas housing is a basic

498
00:15:34,107 --> 00:15:36,210
right of all people and where

499
00:15:36,210 --> 00:15:37,378
this year we celebrate the

500
00:15:37,378 --> 00:15:39,246
57th anniversary of the

501
00:15:39,246 --> 00:15:41,181
federal fair housing act of

502
00:15:41,181 --> 00:15:42,282
1968 which states that

503
00:15:42,282 --> 00:15:44,682
discrimination t sale and

504
00:15:45,719 --> 00:15:48,489
rental of housing is illegal

505
00:15:48,489 --> 00:15:49,857
and based on race, national

506
00:15:49,857 --> 00:15:51,459
origin, whereas the fair

507
00:15:51,459 --> 00:15:53,859
housing amendment act extend

508
00:15:56,396 --> 00:15:57,765
fair housing rights on

509
00:15:57,765 --> 00:15:58,933
familial status to people

510
00:15:58,933 --> 00:16:00,801
with

511
00:16:00,801 --> 00:16:02,103
children, and whereas

512
00:16:02,103 --> 00:16:04,103
california statutes protect

513
00:16:04,772 --> 00:16:05,706
its citizens on the basis of

514
00:16:05,706 --> 00:16:07,542
age, sexual orientation,

515
00:16:07,542 --> 00:16:09,643
gender identity and source of

516
00:16:09,643 --> 00:16:10,611
income and california

517
00:16:10,611 --> 00:16:11,512
celebrates the 66th

518
00:16:11,512 --> 00:16:12,246
anniversary of the fair

519
00:16:12,246 --> 00:16:12,580
employment and housing act

520
00:16:12,580 --> 00:16:14,810
and

521
00:16:14,810 --> 00:16:15,249
whereas the city of south san

522
00:16:15,249 --> 00:16:17,118
francisco supports fair

523
00:16:17,118 --> 00:16:18,553
housing efforts to eliminate

524
00:16:18,553 --> 00:16:19,921
discrimination in housing and

525
00:16:19,921 --> 00:16:22,223
recognizes the benefits of

526
00:16:22,223 --> 00:16:23,591
project sentinel to educate

527
00:16:23,591 --> 00:16:23,992
home seekers, apartment

528
00:16:23,992 --> 00:16:25,927
owners

529
00:16:25,927 --> 00:16:27,950
on federal and state housing

530
00:16:27,950 --> 00:16:28,296
laws and investigate

531
00:16:28,296 --> 00:16:29,964
complaints of illegal housing

532
00:16:29,964 --> 00:16:31,766
discrimination in south san

533
00:16:31,766 --> 00:16:32,533
francisco, whereas the

534
00:16:32,533 --> 00:16:33,868
heightened public awareness,

535
00:16:33,868 --> 00:16:35,970
the city of south san

536
00:16:35,970 --> 00:16:37,572
francisco wishes to focus

537
00:16:37,572 --> 00:16:38,740
public attention of APRIL as

538
00:16:38,740 --> 00:16:40,809
fair housing mother, now

539
00:16:40,809 --> 00:16:42,209
therefore be it resolved the

540
00:16:42,209 --> 00:16:45,313
city council of the city of

541
00:16:45,313 --> 00:16:47,649
south san francisco does

542
00:16:47,649 --> 00:16:48,416
recognize APRIL as fair

543
00:16:48,416 --> 00:16:49,150
housing month and encouraging

544
00:16:49,150 --> 00:16:49,884
all residents and community

545
00:16:49,884 --> 00:16:50,218
organizations to celebrate

546
00:16:50,218 --> 00:16:52,218
the

547
00:16:53,488 --> 00:16:54,555
value of harm nows and diverse

548
00:16:54,555 --> 00:16:56,570
[Inaudible] With neighbor and

549
00:16:56,570 --> 00:16:57,225
is this is signed by the

550
00:16:57,225 --> 00:17:00,225
entire city council and I'm

551
00:17:00,662 --> 00:17:04,165
going to ask jacob to accept

552
00:17:04,165 --> 00:17:06,165
this proclamation, jacob?

553
00:17:21,983 --> 00:17:23,983
>> welcome.

554
00:17:24,519 --> 00:17:26,155
>> so, my name's jacob, I'm a

555
00:17:26,155 --> 00:17:26,989
fair housing coordinator at

556
00:17:26,989 --> 00:17:27,355
project sentinel, I first

557
00:17:27,355 --> 00:17:29,355
want

558
00:17:29,724 --> 00:17:33,324
to thank the city council for

559
00:17:33,362 --> 00:17:34,996
your continued support of

560
00:17:34,996 --> 00:17:36,398
project sentinel.

561
00:17:36,398 --> 00:17:38,968
You know, it's been a

562
00:17:38,968 --> 00:17:41,968
difficult couple of weeks for

563
00:17:45,374 --> 00:17:47,374
fair housing.

564
00:17:48,644 --> 00:17:50,246
The public was caught around

565
00:17:50,246 --> 00:17:50,612
60-70%, our projects were

566
00:17:50,612 --> 00:17:52,612
just

567
00:17:52,815 --> 00:17:54,950
cut from the federal

568
00:17:54,950 --> 00:17:57,620
government and, you know, our

569
00:17:57,620 --> 00:17:59,522
funding has really taken --

570
00:17:59,522 --> 00:17:59,922
we've had to take some

571
00:17:59,922 --> 00:18:01,922
drastic

572
00:18:04,360 --> 00:18:06,662
measures with our funding.

573
00:18:06,662 --> 00:18:07,630
Cities like south city

574
00:18:07,630 --> 00:18:08,864
provide

575
00:18:08,864 --> 00:18:09,332
a lot for us and it

576
00:18:09,332 --> 00:18:10,499
solidifies

577
00:18:10,499 --> 00:18:13,499
the relationship that we have

578
00:18:14,370 --> 00:18:14,737
with the cities that we work

579
00:18:14,737 --> 00:18:16,505
with.

580
00:18:16,505 --> 00:18:18,574
So, yeah, again, I want to

581
00:18:18,574 --> 00:18:19,942
thank this council for your

582
00:18:19,942 --> 00:18:21,544
continued support and I look

583
00:18:21,544 --> 00:18:22,712
forward to this year and many

584
00:18:22,712 --> 00:18:24,712
more to come.

585
00:18:29,218 --> 00:18:29,786
>> thank you very much.

586
00:18:29,786 --> 00:18:30,453
[Applause].

587
00:18:30,453 --> 00:18:32,453
>> thank you.

588
00:18:33,220 --> 00:18:34,190
>> thank you again.

589
00:18:34,190 --> 00:18:35,758
Next agenda item, please.

590
00:18:35,758 --> 00:18:37,227
>> thank you, moving on the

591
00:18:37,227 --> 00:18:38,862
item 2 is a presentation on

592
00:18:38,862 --> 00:18:39,329
the san mateo county

593
00:18:39,329 --> 00:18:41,329
accessory

594
00:18:42,599 --> 00:18:43,660
dwelling unit adu resource

595
00:18:43,660 --> 00:18:44,934
center.

596
00:18:44,934 --> 00:18:46,436
>> good evening, mayor, vice

597
00:18:46,436 --> 00:18:47,704
MAY yo, councilmembers, billy

598
00:18:47,704 --> 00:18:48,938
gross with the planning

599
00:18:48,938 --> 00:18:50,506
commission and I have the

600
00:18:50,506 --> 00:18:51,308
pleasure of presenting the

601
00:18:51,308 --> 00:18:53,308
next speaker.

602
00:18:53,376 --> 00:18:55,211
As you all know, the adu

603
00:18:55,211 --> 00:18:58,211
resource center of san mateo

604
00:19:00,383 --> 00:19:02,383
county opened in 2024.

605
00:19:02,719 --> 00:19:03,386
It's intended as a one stop

606
00:19:03,386 --> 00:19:04,921
shop for adu resources.

607
00:19:04,921 --> 00:19:06,550
We thought it would be the

608
00:19:06,550 --> 00:19:08,458
director had offered to come

609
00:19:08,458 --> 00:19:09,659
and speak so we thought it

610
00:19:09,659 --> 00:19:10,260
would be good as we were

611
00:19:10,260 --> 00:19:12,260
going

612
00:19:12,862 --> 00:19:16,566
to be in front of you talk

613
00:19:16,566 --> 00:19:17,534
about the general plan and

614
00:19:17,534 --> 00:19:20,534
housing project, so I would

615
00:19:25,842 --> 00:19:26,610
like to introduce anna

616
00:19:26,610 --> 00:19:27,770
alekseyeva, she'll go through

617
00:19:27,770 --> 00:19:28,846
the program.

618
00:19:28,846 --> 00:19:30,246
>> thank you for giving me an

619
00:19:30,246 --> 00:19:30,581
opportunity to present the

620
00:19:30,581 --> 00:19:31,114
adu

621
00:19:31,114 --> 00:19:32,348
resource center.

622
00:19:32,348 --> 00:19:35,853
I want to give you a sense of

623
00:19:35,853 --> 00:19:37,221
what the center is all about

624
00:19:37,221 --> 00:19:38,622
sdp&services it provides to

625
00:19:38,622 --> 00:19:39,560
home owners in member

626
00:19:39,560 --> 00:19:39,790
justices

627
00:19:39,790 --> 00:19:40,991
teases including south city.

628
00:19:40,991 --> 00:19:42,626
Before I do that, I wanted to

629
00:19:42,626 --> 00:19:44,495
set the stage a little bit

630
00:19:44,495 --> 00:19:45,863
about adu's in the state and

631
00:19:45,863 --> 00:19:48,465
more locally which you will

632
00:19:48,465 --> 00:19:50,800
probably be familiar with.

633
00:19:50,800 --> 00:19:52,937
Adu's are really popular

634
00:19:52,937 --> 00:19:55,337
housing typology, ever since

635
00:19:55,673 --> 00:19:56,373
the state started

636
00:19:56,373 --> 00:19:57,474
liberalizing

637
00:19:57,474 --> 00:19:57,942
adu statute across

638
00:19:57,942 --> 00:19:59,942
california,

639
00:20:00,770 --> 00:20:02,146
the number of adu's that are

640
00:20:02,146 --> 00:20:04,582
built every single year has

641
00:20:04,582 --> 00:20:06,582
grown something like 15

642
00:20:07,484 --> 00:20:09,884
thousand percent, so hugely,

643
00:20:10,540 --> 00:20:11,489
hugely popular housing type.

644
00:20:11,489 --> 00:20:13,889
Most recent data suggesters

645
00:20:14,250 --> 00:20:15,559
that one in five new units in

646
00:20:15,559 --> 00:20:15,893
california housing units is

647
00:20:15,893 --> 00:20:17,495
an

648
00:20:17,495 --> 00:20:19,296
adu, if you look at lower

649
00:20:19,296 --> 00:20:20,965
income or very low income,

650
00:20:20,965 --> 00:20:21,465
housing units, that

651
00:20:21,465 --> 00:20:23,670
percentage

652
00:20:23,670 --> 00:20:24,769
is high e more than one third

653
00:20:24,769 --> 00:20:25,102
of housing units are adu's,

654
00:20:25,102 --> 00:20:26,404
so

655
00:20:26,404 --> 00:20:28,600
of course it's not the only

656
00:20:28,600 --> 00:20:29,173
housing type but it is an

657
00:20:29,173 --> 00:20:30,341
important one across the

658
00:20:30,341 --> 00:20:31,509
state

659
00:20:31,509 --> 00:20:33,711
and more locally in sn mateo

660
00:20:33,711 --> 00:20:35,580
and in south city.

661
00:20:35,580 --> 00:20:37,140
And I think billy aluded to

662
00:20:37,140 --> 00:20:38,616
the housing element and

663
00:20:38,616 --> 00:20:40,685
progress the city has made

664
00:20:40,685 --> 00:20:42,787
around the most recent rhna

665
00:20:42,787 --> 00:20:44,856
cycle but south city has a

666
00:20:44,856 --> 00:20:47,256
goal of producing almost 400

667
00:20:47,458 --> 00:20:48,860
adu's in the current 8 year

668
00:20:48,860 --> 00:20:50,462
rhna cycle of which the

669
00:20:50,462 --> 00:20:52,463
majority are projected to be

670
00:20:52,463 --> 00:20:53,932
at the low icome or very low

671
00:20:53,932 --> 00:20:55,932
income levels.

672
00:20:56,501 --> 00:20:56,901
So we like adu's for a lot of

673
00:20:56,901 --> 00:20:58,603
reasons.

674
00:20:58,603 --> 00:21:01,603
One, because it's a housing

675
00:21:03,108 --> 00:21:05,410
type and more housing is GOD

676
00:21:05,410 --> 00:21:07,946
but they're also a housing

677
00:21:07,946 --> 00:21:08,647
type, they allow for

678
00:21:08,647 --> 00:21:09,800
multigenerational living,

679
00:21:09,800 --> 00:21:11,800
they

680
00:21:12,150 --> 00:21:14,180
have a wealth building tool,

681
00:21:14,180 --> 00:21:14,653
they are smaller so they have

682
00:21:14,653 --> 00:21:15,887
environmental and

683
00:21:15,887 --> 00:21:17,956
sustainability benefit and is

684
00:21:17,956 --> 00:21:18,423
we know older adults like

685
00:21:18,423 --> 00:21:20,250
them

686
00:21:20,250 --> 00:21:20,358
because they allow them to

687
00:21:20,358 --> 00:21:21,893
age

688
00:21:21,893 --> 00:21:22,728
in place without having to

689
00:21:22,728 --> 00:21:24,429
leave their community.

690
00:21:24,429 --> 00:21:24,896
Is wah is adu resource

691
00:21:24,896 --> 00:21:26,896
center,

692
00:21:27,633 --> 00:21:30,633
it was launched in SEPTEMBER

693
00:21:31,503 --> 00:21:33,105
of 2024, so we just had our

694
00:21:33,105 --> 00:21:34,706
six month birthday, not --

695
00:21:34,706 --> 00:21:36,375
still baby hood when it comes

696
00:21:36,375 --> 00:21:37,543
to being an organization, but

697
00:21:37,543 --> 00:21:40,312
wanted to share some of the

698
00:21:40,312 --> 00:21:41,460
services we have live already.

699
00:21:41,460 --> 00:21:42,448
Working with jurisdictions

700
00:21:42,448 --> 00:21:43,348
and

701
00:21:43,348 --> 00:21:45,348
with home owners.

702
00:21:45,483 --> 00:21:46,385
It is a non-profit

703
00:21:46,385 --> 00:21:48,320
organization, the funding

704
00:21:48,320 --> 00:21:49,870
primarily comes from local

705
00:21:49,870 --> 00:21:50,222
jurisdictions like south city

706
00:21:50,222 --> 00:21:52,222
f city.

707
00:21:52,291 --> 00:21:53,892
The goal is t drive housing

708
00:21:53,892 --> 00:21:54,260
production by being a one

709
00:21:54,260 --> 00:21:56,260
stop

710
00:21:56,895 --> 00:21:59,431
shop to help get adu's built.

711
00:21:59,431 --> 00:22:00,833
We do that through two

712
00:22:00,833 --> 00:22:02,340
different mechanisms, one is

713
00:22:02,340 --> 00:22:04,103
working with jurisdictions to

714
00:22:04,103 --> 00:22:06,639
meet their adu policy goals

715
00:22:06,639 --> 00:22:07,339
and the second is working

716
00:22:07,339 --> 00:22:08,707
with

717
00:22:08,707 --> 00:22:09,141
home owners directly

718
00:22:09,141 --> 00:22:10,476
providing

719
00:22:10,476 --> 00:22:10,910
resources and direct

720
00:22:10,910 --> 00:22:11,610
technical

721
00:22:11,610 --> 00:22:11,977
assistance so I wanted to

722
00:22:11,977 --> 00:22:13,446
give

723
00:22:13,446 --> 00:22:16,415
you a flavor of each of these

724
00:22:16,415 --> 00:22:19,415
areas so you know what's

725
00:22:19,418 --> 00:22:20,586
offered to residents and sto

726
00:22:20,586 --> 00:22:22,421
-- to staff, the center

727
00:22:22,421 --> 00:22:24,256
provides a raping of support

728
00:22:24,256 --> 00:22:25,925
around housing element

729
00:22:25,925 --> 00:22:27,593
implementation related to adu

730
00:22:27,593 --> 00:22:28,294
policy goals, it elapses

731
00:22:28,294 --> 00:22:30,162
jurisdictions stay in

732
00:22:30,162 --> 00:22:31,970
compliance with hcd

733
00:22:31,970 --> 00:22:33,970
expectations and understand

734
00:22:33,866 --> 00:22:36,502
what the latest adu statutes,

735
00:22:36,502 --> 00:22:37,270
rules and standards are.

736
00:22:37,270 --> 00:22:39,670
And helps jurisdictions stay

737
00:22:40,707 --> 00:22:42,107
up to date about the latest

738
00:22:42,107 --> 00:22:44,610
adu best practices and what's

739
00:22:44,610 --> 00:22:47,213
going on at the state level.

740
00:22:47,213 --> 00:22:49,515
As you all probably know very

741
00:22:49,515 --> 00:22:51,150
well, state housing law

742
00:22:51,150 --> 00:22:53,190
changes rapidly, every sickle

743
00:22:53,190 --> 00:22:53,453
year, that is the same for

744
00:22:53,453 --> 00:22:54,854
adu

745
00:22:54,854 --> 00:22:56,523
laws, so every single year,

746
00:22:56,523 --> 00:22:57,923
there's a slate of new adu

747
00:22:57,923 --> 00:22:59,920
bills that are passed and go

748
00:22:59,920 --> 00:22:59,459
into effect and it can be

749
00:22:59,459 --> 00:23:01,194
hard

750
00:23:01,194 --> 00:23:02,829
to keep up with any o them.

751
00:23:02,829 --> 00:23:03,162
And so one of the roles of

752
00:23:03,162 --> 00:23:05,162
the

753
00:23:05,631 --> 00:23:07,333
center is to make sure that

754
00:23:07,333 --> 00:23:08,802
staff understand what the

755
00:23:08,802 --> 00:23:09,169
latest rules and statutes

756
00:23:09,169 --> 00:23:11,169
are,

757
00:23:11,171 --> 00:23:11,971
going to go through a lecture

758
00:23:11,971 --> 00:23:14,740
of the adu standards because

759
00:23:14,740 --> 00:23:15,342
that would be an a hour

760
00:23:15,342 --> 00:23:15,675
lecture, as you can see on

761
00:23:15,675 --> 00:23:17,675
the

762
00:23:17,777 --> 00:23:19,479
right hand side of the slide,

763
00:23:19,479 --> 00:23:21,114
I noted a few laws that went

764
00:23:21,114 --> 00:23:23,683
into effect this year, all of

765
00:23:23,683 --> 00:23:24,851
them in some way, shape or

766
00:23:24,851 --> 00:23:26,920
form encouraging adu's are

767
00:23:26,920 --> 00:23:27,287
making it easier to build

768
00:23:27,287 --> 00:23:28,588
adu's.

769
00:23:28,588 --> 00:23:28,955
One law I want to call to

770
00:23:28,955 --> 00:23:30,657
your

771
00:23:30,657 --> 00:23:32,250
attention in particular is

772
00:23:32,250 --> 00:23:34,250
legalization of unpermitted

773
00:23:34,361 --> 00:23:37,431
units, so the state as of

774
00:23:37,431 --> 00:23:39,733
JANUARY of this year has made

775
00:23:39,733 --> 00:23:42,133
it easier the legalize

776
00:23:44,638 --> 00:23:47,600
unpermitted adu's, we no in

777
00:23:47,600 --> 00:23:48,876
some place, the ratio is one

778
00:23:48,876 --> 00:23:49,810
to three depending on the

779
00:23:49,810 --> 00:23:51,445
jurisdiction, this has a

780
00:23:51,445 --> 00:23:52,346
potential to have pretty

781
00:23:52,346 --> 00:23:54,448
substantial long term effects

782
00:23:54,448 --> 00:23:55,382
down the road in terms of

783
00:23:55,382 --> 00:23:56,490
bringing unpermitted units on

784
00:23:56,490 --> 00:23:57,451
to the market.

785
00:23:57,451 --> 00:23:57,852
Something else that the

786
00:23:57,852 --> 00:23:59,852
center

787
00:24:04,258 --> 00:24:07,940
is working on is it's working

788
00:24:07,940 --> 00:24:08,229
on affordable adu program,

789
00:24:08,229 --> 00:24:08,596
these programs have been

790
00:24:08,596 --> 00:24:09,697
tried

791
00:24:09,697 --> 00:24:10,664
in different place ins

792
00:24:10,664 --> 00:24:11,332
california and adrsz

793
00:24:11,332 --> 00:24:11,799
f cross

794
00:24:11,799 --> 00:24:12,967
the knotty

795
00:24:12,967 --> 00:24:14,967
f ri.

796
00:24:15,269 --> 00:24:16,403
What they do is provide some

797
00:24:16,403 --> 00:24:18,505
financial incentive for home

798
00:24:18,505 --> 00:24:19,206
own teaser build an adu and

799
00:24:19,206 --> 00:24:19,640
those home owners are

800
00:24:19,640 --> 00:24:21,640
required

801
00:24:22,900 --> 00:24:24,612
to rent their adu's at

802
00:24:24,612 --> 00:24:25,120
affordable rates so it's

803
00:24:25,120 --> 00:24:26,880
below

804
00:24:26,880 --> 00:24:28,515
market rate housing program

805
00:24:28,515 --> 00:24:28,983
that subsidizes home owners

806
00:24:28,983 --> 00:24:29,717
directly.

807
00:24:29,717 --> 00:24:31,850
There's interesting pilots

808
00:24:31,850 --> 00:24:32,520
that have been tried in

809
00:24:32,520 --> 00:24:34,121
different places that we're

810
00:24:34,121 --> 00:24:36,230
exploring and the goal is to

811
00:24:36,230 --> 00:24:37,558
have a program model that any

812
00:24:37,558 --> 00:24:37,892
jurisdiction in the county

813
00:24:37,892 --> 00:24:39,460
can

814
00:24:39,460 --> 00:24:40,862
participate in with the goal

815
00:24:40,862 --> 00:24:43,598
of launching next year, so

816
00:24:43,598 --> 00:24:44,799
very excited about that and

817
00:24:44,799 --> 00:24:46,634
innovating in that space.

818
00:24:46,634 --> 00:24:48,269
And in terms of the services

819
00:24:48,269 --> 00:24:48,636
to hope own oers, you can

820
00:24:48,636 --> 00:24:50,636
find

821
00:24:53,508 --> 00:24:54,375
a lot of information on the

822
00:24:54,375 --> 00:24:55,610
website, smadu.Org, this is

823
00:24:55,610 --> 00:24:59,147
just some of the resources we

824
00:24:59,147 --> 00:25:00,514
have op the website, a very

825
00:25:00,514 --> 00:25:01,449
comprehensive guide book

826
00:25:01,449 --> 00:25:02,383
around the different stages

827
00:25:02,383 --> 00:25:04,383
of

828
00:25:04,953 --> 00:25:06,554
building an adu specific to

829
00:25:06,554 --> 00:25:08,954
with local information, we

830
00:25:09,323 --> 00:25:10,910
have local rules for every

831
00:25:10,910 --> 00:25:12,910
jurisdiction including south

832
00:25:12,560 --> 00:25:13,962
city, we have stories of

833
00:25:13,962 --> 00:25:14,329
residents who have built

834
00:25:14,329 --> 00:25:16,329
adu's

835
00:25:16,531 --> 00:25:16,898
in different use case, we

836
00:25:16,898 --> 00:25:18,133
have

837
00:25:18,133 --> 00:25:18,533
a proprietary tol that

838
00:25:18,533 --> 00:25:20,533
allows

839
00:25:21,135 --> 00:25:22,700
people to put in some details

840
00:25:22,700 --> 00:25:24,470
about a prospective project

841
00:25:25,540 --> 00:25:26,675
and get an estimate of the

842
00:25:26,675 --> 00:25:28,430
projected project cost and is

843
00:25:28,430 --> 00:25:28,543
the return on investment

844
00:25:28,543 --> 00:25:30,145
which

845
00:25:30,145 --> 00:25:30,512
they can expect which is

846
00:25:30,512 --> 00:25:32,130
based

847
00:25:32,130 --> 00:25:32,447
on hyperlocal construction

848
00:25:32,447 --> 00:25:34,447
data.

849
00:25:35,584 --> 00:25:36,351
and w also do and

850
00:25:36,351 --> 00:25:38,286
increasingly are rolling ot

851
00:25:38,286 --> 00:25:39,320
service that is are direct

852
00:25:39,320 --> 00:25:40,489
technical assistance to home

853
00:25:40,489 --> 00:25:42,557
owners which we're excited

854
00:25:42,557 --> 00:25:43,240
about, so starting next

855
00:25:43,240 --> 00:25:44,892
month,

856
00:25:44,892 --> 00:25:45,594
residents o member

857
00:25:45,594 --> 00:25:46,328
jurisdictions, including

858
00:25:46,328 --> 00:25:48,397
residents of city are going

859
00:25:48,397 --> 00:25:49,310
the have ak says to a free

860
00:25:49,310 --> 00:25:49,187
feasibility consult s

861
00:25:49,187 --> 00:25:51,187
frs

862
00:25:51,600 --> 00:25:53,680
where they can talk with an

863
00:25:53,680 --> 00:25:55,103
adu expert for an hour, get a

864
00:25:55,103 --> 00:25:56,238
sense of what is possible on

865
00:25:56,238 --> 00:25:58,638
their property talk through

866
00:25:59,141 --> 00:26:01,176
their goals and get a free

867
00:26:01,176 --> 00:26:01,710
customized report on

868
00:26:01,710 --> 00:26:03,710
recommendations.

869
00:26:03,979 --> 00:26:06,548
We have a homeowner help line

870
00:26:06,548 --> 00:26:07,716
which is like a hotline when

871
00:26:07,716 --> 00:26:10,716
they're in the process of

872
00:26:11,320 --> 00:26:13,822
building an adu if they have

873
00:26:13,822 --> 00:26:16,392
an issue, we have a range of

874
00:26:16,392 --> 00:26:16,825
educational content and

875
00:26:16,825 --> 00:26:17,860
resources.

876
00:26:17,860 --> 00:26:19,662
We've launched a webinar

877
00:26:19,662 --> 00:26:21,630
series wth a few successful

878
00:26:21,630 --> 00:26:22,932
webinars that a couple of

879
00:26:22,932 --> 00:26:23,399
hundred people have attended

880
00:26:23,399 --> 00:26:24,800
already.

881
00:26:24,800 --> 00:26:26,435
Next week we're hosting

882
00:26:26,435 --> 00:26:28,270
another webinar about adu

883
00:26:28,270 --> 00:26:29,905
financing, so really want to

884
00:26:29,905 --> 00:26:30,239
delve into different topics

885
00:26:30,239 --> 00:26:32,239
we

886
00:26:32,875 --> 00:26:33,276
know are of interest to home

887
00:26:33,276 --> 00:26:34,430
owners.

888
00:26:34,430 --> 00:26:37,546
And finally this is just a

889
00:26:37,546 --> 00:26:38,914
list of the center's member

890
00:26:38,914 --> 00:26:40,914
jurisdictions, we're thankful

891
00:26:41,160 --> 00:26:41,516
for everyone who

892
00:26:41,516 --> 00:26:43,516
participates,

893
00:26:43,586 --> 00:26:44,821
san mateo is unique in the

894
00:26:44,821 --> 00:26:45,454
collaboration that is across

895
00:26:45,454 --> 00:26:47,454
jurisdiction asks the

896
00:26:47,557 --> 00:26:47,890
existence of the center is

897
00:26:47,890 --> 00:26:49,125
one

898
00:26:49,125 --> 00:26:49,659
example of that

899
00:26:49,659 --> 00:26:51,227
collaboration,

900
00:26:51,227 --> 00:26:53,529
so thankful to south city as

901
00:26:53,529 --> 00:26:54,297
well as all the other member

902
00:26:54,297 --> 00:26:56,199
jurisdictions for supporting

903
00:26:56,199 --> 00:26:59,200
the role of the center and

904
00:26:59,200 --> 00:27:00,370
with that, I will open it up

905
00:27:00,370 --> 00:27:03,970
to questions if there are any.

906
00:27:04,600 --> 00:27:06,406
>> thank you very much.

907
00:27:06,609 --> 00:27:09,900
Any questions or comments?

908
00:27:09,412 --> 00:27:11,140
>> I think it's perfect that

909
00:27:11,140 --> 00:27:12,315
you are presenting since we

910
00:27:12,315 --> 00:27:14,500
just gave a certificate to

911
00:27:14,500 --> 00:27:16,450
fair housing as well.

912
00:27:17,787 --> 00:27:18,721
And adu is a major part of

913
00:27:18,721 --> 00:27:20,721
affordable housing.

914
00:27:25,795 --> 00:27:26,563
It's been a while that I did

915
00:27:26,563 --> 00:27:27,230
an adu presentation, there's

916
00:27:27,230 --> 00:27:27,631
one of your slides that

917
00:27:27,631 --> 00:27:28,298
talked

918
00:27:28,298 --> 00:27:29,320
about the primary owner

919
00:27:29,320 --> 00:27:31,401
couldn't reside in the adu.

920
00:27:31,401 --> 00:27:32,801
>> yes.

921
00:27:32,801 --> 00:27:33,202
>> so, yeah, I want to

922
00:27:33,202 --> 00:27:35,202
clarify

923
00:27:35,805 --> 00:27:39,509
to make sure I got it right.

924
00:27:39,509 --> 00:27:41,844
So, if a homeowner builds an

925
00:27:41,844 --> 00:27:45,444
adu, that junior adu or full

926
00:27:46,550 --> 00:27:48,284
adu cannot be their primary

927
00:27:48,284 --> 00:27:48,752
residencey for that

928
00:27:48,752 --> 00:27:49,186
particular

929
00:27:49,186 --> 00:27:49,920
homeowner?

930
00:27:49,920 --> 00:27:50,553
>> no, it can be, if you're

931
00:27:50,553 --> 00:27:50,988
referencing no owner

932
00:27:50,988 --> 00:27:51,655
occupancy.

933
00:27:51,655 --> 00:27:52,289
Thafrjts's where I was

934
00:27:52,289 --> 00:27:54,689
confused on the rule.

935
00:27:54,725 --> 00:27:57,627
>> no, yeah, sorry, that's --

936
00:27:57,627 --> 00:27:59,730
it's kind of phrased

937
00:27:59,730 --> 00:28:01,364
awkwardly, what that means is

938
00:28:01,364 --> 00:28:03,633
that a jurisdiction can't

939
00:28:03,633 --> 00:28:04,134
prevent owner occupancy, so

940
00:28:04,134 --> 00:28:05,436
--

941
00:28:05,436 --> 00:28:06,437
or can't enforce owner

942
00:28:06,437 --> 00:28:08,339
occupancy, you don't have to

943
00:28:08,339 --> 00:28:11,542
be an owner occupant to build

944
00:28:11,542 --> 00:28:13,744
an adu, that's what it means.

945
00:28:13,744 --> 00:28:15,812
>> for a a lot o folks who

946
00:28:15,812 --> 00:28:16,180
are aging out in terms of

947
00:28:16,180 --> 00:28:18,115
home

948
00:28:18,115 --> 00:28:19,983
ownership or they want to

949
00:28:19,983 --> 00:28:22,860
reduce their size, a junior

950
00:28:22,860 --> 00:28:24,455
adu or an adu is a perfect

951
00:28:24,455 --> 00:28:25,723
play for folks to transition

952
00:28:25,723 --> 00:28:26,991
to and potentially rent out

953
00:28:26,991 --> 00:28:28,392
their home.

954
00:28:28,392 --> 00:28:28,564
>> absolutely, and there's a

955
00:28:28,564 --> 00:28:30,564
-

956
00:28:31,629 --> 00:28:32,596
new state law that's

957
00:28:32,596 --> 00:28:34,596
referenced here, canonization

958
00:28:36,766 --> 00:28:38,736
that is an optional law that

959
00:28:38,736 --> 00:28:40,871
allows jurisdiction tos enact

960
00:28:40,871 --> 00:28:41,339
an ordinance to sell the adu

961
00:28:41,339 --> 00:28:43,339
separately.

962
00:28:43,640 --> 00:28:46,640
>> that's a new law now?

963
00:28:48,112 --> 00:28:50,181
>> yes, san jose enacted,

964
00:28:50,181 --> 00:28:51,115
it's the first jurisdiction

965
00:28:51,115 --> 00:28:52,483
statewide that enacted it and

966
00:28:52,483 --> 00:28:53,160
san francisco is apparently

967
00:28:53,160 --> 00:28:53,484
in

968
00:28:53,484 --> 00:28:54,152
discussions.

969
00:28:54,152 --> 00:28:56,152
It's an interesting

970
00:28:56,521 --> 00:28:56,721
opportunity to caoe kate

971
00:28:56,721 --> 00:28:58,721
f

972
00:28:58,756 --> 00:29:00,224
yait a stock of starter homes

973
00:29:00,224 --> 00:29:02,224
from adu's.

974
00:29:02,293 --> 00:29:02,660
>> so, they have to enact

975
00:29:02,660 --> 00:29:03,694
that

976
00:29:03,694 --> 00:29:06,694
law for that to happen?

977
00:29:06,731 --> 00:29:08,800
>> t yes, it's an opt-in law.

978
00:29:08,800 --> 00:29:09,601
I'm looking at sky now.

979
00:29:09,601 --> 00:29:12,601
You're going to jump in

980
00:29:13,637 --> 00:29:15,637
>>?

981
00:29:15,940 --> 00:29:18,340
Nell selander, your questions

982
00:29:18,643 --> 00:29:19,878
are preserving one rving --

983
00:29:19,878 --> 00:29:21,746
preempting one of the

984
00:29:21,746 --> 00:29:23,348
council's extra strategic

985
00:29:23,348 --> 00:29:25,717
goals is more diversity in

986
00:29:25,717 --> 00:29:26,484
housing stock and more

987
00:29:26,484 --> 00:29:28,530
particularly home ownership,

988
00:29:28,530 --> 00:29:29,454
this is one of the task items

989
00:29:29,454 --> 00:29:30,855
you might see in a future

990
00:29:30,855 --> 00:29:33,255
report on those strategic

991
00:29:33,558 --> 00:29:35,360
goals is do we want to

992
00:29:35,360 --> 00:29:36,828
consider this locally as a

993
00:29:36,828 --> 00:29:37,462
pretty easy pathway into home

994
00:29:37,462 --> 00:29:39,462
ownership.

995
00:29:40,310 --> 00:29:42,333
>> great, thank you, nell.

996
00:29:42,333 --> 00:29:44,202
>> it's exciting and san jose

997
00:29:44,202 --> 00:29:46,370
just enacted this in the last

998
00:29:46,370 --> 00:29:48,573
one and a half year sos it's

999
00:29:48,573 --> 00:29:49,741
excite tog se -- a lot of

1000
00:29:49,741 --> 00:29:52,141
jurisdictions twaont see what

1001
00:29:52,744 --> 00:29:53,812
happen ins san jose, but in

1002
00:29:53,812 --> 00:29:56,212
seattle, in portland where

1003
00:29:57,115 --> 00:29:59,184
this exists, I mean, it's a

1004
00:29:59,184 --> 00:29:59,884
massive part of new home

1005
00:29:59,884 --> 00:30:01,519
starters.

1006
00:30:01,519 --> 00:30:01,987
>> great, thank you for the

1007
00:30:01,987 --> 00:30:03,987
information.

1008
00:30:04,723 --> 00:30:05,157
Great, any other questions,

1009
00:30:05,157 --> 00:30:06,558
comments?

1010
00:30:06,558 --> 00:30:07,259
Community, this is a great

1011
00:30:07,259 --> 00:30:08,160
resource, please take

1012
00:30:08,160 --> 00:30:10,280
advantage.

1013
00:30:10,280 --> 00:30:11,196
We are a member city, so

1014
00:30:11,196 --> 00:30:12,598
please utilize the resources.

1015
00:30:12,598 --> 00:30:13,265
Thank you again fr the

1016
00:30:13,265 --> 00:30:13,665
presentation for coming

1017
00:30:13,665 --> 00:30:15,167
tonight.

1018
00:30:15,167 --> 00:30:17,200
>> thank you very much.

1019
00:30:17,200 --> 00:30:17,302
>> next agenda item, please.

1020
00:30:17,302 --> 00:30:19,302
Er

1021
00:30:20,239 --> 00:30:20,805
>> moving on to council

1022
00:30:20,805 --> 00:30:22,174
comments/requests.

1023
00:30:22,174 --> 00:30:22,607
>> great.

1024
00:30:22,607 --> 00:30:23,242
Would who

1025
00:30:23,242 --> 00:30:23,403
would like to

1026
00:30:23,403 --> 00:30:25,344
-

1027
00:30:25,344 --> 00:30:27,344
start

1028
00:30:28,347 --> 00:30:30,347
sharing?

1029
00:30:30,649 --> 00:30:31,160
>> you're look at me so I

1030
00:30:31,160 --> 00:30:31,449
will

1031
00:30:31,449 --> 00:30:32,840
go first.

1032
00:30:32,840 --> 00:30:34,484
Thank you, MR. Mayor.

1033
00:30:38,791 --> 00:30:40,660
A lot of great events that I

1034
00:30:40,660 --> 00:30:42,495
attended, the holly event, it

1035
00:30:42,495 --> 00:30:43,662
was such a great event to

1036
00:30:43,662 --> 00:30:45,662
celebrate our diversity.

1037
00:30:46,232 --> 00:30:47,433
It was a avery colorful

1038
00:30:47,433 --> 00:30:49,833
event, there's great pictures

1039
00:30:49,902 --> 00:30:51,470
of myself and councilmember

1040
00:30:51,470 --> 00:30:52,939
nicolas with bright paint on

1041
00:30:52,939 --> 00:30:53,405
our face, so I look forward

1042
00:30:53,405 --> 00:30:55,405
to

1043
00:30:55,741 --> 00:30:57,430
as that event grows every

1044
00:30:57,430 --> 00:30:57,610
year, so I'm looking forward

1045
00:30:57,610 --> 00:30:59,110
to it.

1046
00:30:59,110 --> 00:31:00,846
And I think councilmember

1047
00:31:00,846 --> 00:31:03,215
nicolas and I are hoping by

1048
00:31:03,215 --> 00:31:03,649
next year we're throwing

1049
00:31:03,649 --> 00:31:04,984
paint

1050
00:31:04,984 --> 00:31:08,584
-- yeah, so staff might be

1051
00:31:09,222 --> 00:31:10,423
freaking out as I say that.

1052
00:31:10,423 --> 00:31:14,230
I went to a wonderful event

1053
00:31:14,600 --> 00:31:16,460
with the mayor and

1054
00:31:18,531 --> 00:31:20,531
councilmember coleman, we

1055
00:31:21,868 --> 00:31:22,902
attended the naac99th gala

1056
00:31:22,902 --> 00:31:24,971
celebration where there were

1057
00:31:24,971 --> 00:31:25,338
leaders across the region

1058
00:31:25,338 --> 00:31:27,338
that

1059
00:31:27,373 --> 00:31:27,841
celebrate the san mateo

1060
00:31:27,841 --> 00:31:29,841
county

1061
00:31:29,943 --> 00:31:32,712
chapter and our very own

1062
00:31:32,712 --> 00:31:33,879
superintendent of schools,

1063
00:31:33,879 --> 00:31:34,347
shantera moore was

1064
00:31:34,347 --> 00:31:35,782
recognized,

1065
00:31:35,782 --> 00:31:36,949
it was great to see her and

1066
00:31:36,949 --> 00:31:37,217
all of the accomplishments

1067
00:31:37,217 --> 00:31:38,284
she

1068
00:31:38,284 --> 00:31:40,820
was able to put together.

1069
00:31:40,820 --> 00:31:41,154
I had a great meeting with

1070
00:31:41,154 --> 00:31:41,888
the

1071
00:31:41,888 --> 00:31:43,390
westborough water district.

1072
00:31:43,390 --> 00:31:45,959
I know staff was there, I'm

1073
00:31:45,959 --> 00:31:46,693
going plug them for our

1074
00:31:46,693 --> 00:31:48,280
westborough residents, make

1075
00:31:48,280 --> 00:31:48,562
sure you pay your water bill

1076
00:31:48,562 --> 00:31:50,130
on time.

1077
00:31:50,130 --> 00:31:51,631
They have a lot of great

1078
00:31:51,631 --> 00:31:52,565
resources and I look forward

1079
00:31:52,565 --> 00:31:55,502
to continuing the part naer

1080
00:31:55,502 --> 00:31:56,570
ship with the water district

1081
00:31:56,570 --> 00:31:58,400
and if heresies any

1082
00:31:58,400 --> 00:31:59,873
information they want to

1083
00:31:59,873 --> 00:32:01,274
provide in terms of our

1084
00:32:01,274 --> 00:32:02,909
constituents, I know that the

1085
00:32:02,909 --> 00:32:05,110
mayor would be willing to

1086
00:32:05,110 --> 00:32:05,479
provide that information on

1087
00:32:05,479 --> 00:32:07,113
to

1088
00:32:07,113 --> 00:32:09,113
his newsletter.

1089
00:32:09,883 --> 00:32:11,985
And then last week I had a

1090
00:32:11,985 --> 00:32:14,385
town hall with about 50

1091
00:32:14,521 --> 00:32:16,423
residents and we had a lot of

1092
00:32:16,423 --> 00:32:18,758
great questions from the

1093
00:32:18,758 --> 00:32:20,758
audience specifically about

1094
00:32:20,994 --> 00:32:23,394
traffic, about public safety

1095
00:32:23,530 --> 00:32:25,165
and we had the police chief,

1096
00:32:25,165 --> 00:32:26,800
the fire chief, public works

1097
00:32:26,800 --> 00:32:27,767
and we had a great

1098
00:32:27,767 --> 00:32:29,603
presentation about what's

1099
00:32:29,603 --> 00:32:32,205
coming in terms of our new

1100
00:32:32,205 --> 00:32:33,840
child care center up in

1101
00:32:33,840 --> 00:32:34,975
westborough and a lot of

1102
00:32:34,975 --> 00:32:36,143
great

1103
00:32:36,143 --> 00:32:38,120
feedback from residents, I

1104
00:32:38,120 --> 00:32:39,846
know we're following up for w

1105
00:32:39,846 --> 00:32:40,181
a lot of residents in term

1106
00:32:40,181 --> 00:32:40,948
ofs

1107
00:32:40,948 --> 00:32:43,250
their questions, I've been

1108
00:32:43,250 --> 00:32:44,485
doing it for the lst 7 years

1109
00:32:44,485 --> 00:32:46,820
now, to see all those

1110
00:32:46,820 --> 00:32:47,521
residents come out and ask

1111
00:32:47,521 --> 00:32:48,288
questions and engaging

1112
00:32:48,288 --> 00:32:49,623
witching staff because I know

1113
00:32:49,623 --> 00:32:49,957
this is how w can continue

1114
00:32:49,957 --> 00:32:51,910
to

1115
00:32:51,910 --> 00:32:54,910
engage with our residents and

1116
00:32:54,562 --> 00:32:58,366
a lot of things we're able to

1117
00:32:58,366 --> 00:33:00,201
accomplish in terms of stop

1118
00:33:00,201 --> 00:33:01,569
signs and curbs came from

1119
00:33:01,569 --> 00:33:02,570
these town halls, people were

1120
00:33:02,570 --> 00:33:02,937
interested how do I get a

1121
00:33:02,937 --> 00:33:03,938
stop

1122
00:33:03,938 --> 00:33:06,700
sign in my neighborhood and

1123
00:33:06,700 --> 00:33:07,441
there's a process for that.

1124
00:33:07,441 --> 00:33:08,376
With that, MR. Mayor, that's

1125
00:33:08,376 --> 00:33:10,100
all I have, thank you.

1126
00:33:10,100 --> 00:33:12,100
>> thank you, councilmember.

1127
00:33:13,914 --> 00:33:15,316
Anyone else?

1128
00:33:15,316 --> 00:33:17,752
Go ahead, MR. Vice mayor.

1129
00:33:17,752 --> 00:33:19,353
>> thank you, mayor flores,

1130
00:33:19,353 --> 00:33:22,353
the nice thing about being

1131
00:33:24,259 --> 00:33:26,160
vice mayor to a mayor who is

1132
00:33:26,160 --> 00:33:27,795
actively involved and a

1133
00:33:27,795 --> 00:33:28,496
demanding career is he can't

1134
00:33:28,496 --> 00:33:28,930
attend everything so

1135
00:33:28,930 --> 00:33:30,365
sometimes

1136
00:33:30,365 --> 00:33:32,233
he sends the vice mayor, so

1137
00:33:32,233 --> 00:33:36,433
about a week ago on the 19th,

1138
00:33:37,710 --> 00:33:39,307
I was out at biomed, the

1139
00:33:39,307 --> 00:33:41,176
campus's gateway on oyster

1140
00:33:41,176 --> 00:33:44,176
point boulevard for a ribbon

1141
00:33:44,312 --> 00:33:44,713
cutting for a new food

1142
00:33:44,713 --> 00:33:45,947
vendor,

1143
00:33:45,947 --> 00:33:48,490
proper food, and proper food

1144
00:33:48,490 --> 00:33:52,186
is moving fast f you go the

1145
00:33:52,186 --> 00:33:53,121
san francisco, they're on

1146
00:33:53,121 --> 00:33:53,521
every mayor employment

1147
00:33:53,521 --> 00:33:54,689
center,

1148
00:33:54,689 --> 00:33:55,123
so they have quite a

1149
00:33:55,123 --> 00:33:57,123
following

1150
00:33:58,126 --> 00:34:00,610
already, so we did a ribbon

1151
00:34:00,610 --> 00:34:02,631
cutting and then a tour of

1152
00:34:02,631 --> 00:34:04,466
biomed who still remains vry

1153
00:34:04,466 --> 00:34:05,400
bullish on what has happened

1154
00:34:05,400 --> 00:34:05,734
and will continue to hppen

1155
00:34:05,734 --> 00:34:06,801
in

1156
00:34:06,801 --> 00:34:08,801
south san francisco.

1157
00:34:09,671 --> 00:34:12,373
The next day I found myself

1158
00:34:12,373 --> 00:34:13,750
and again the mayor was at

1159
00:34:13,750 --> 00:34:14,476
the

1160
00:34:14,476 --> 00:34:15,877
skyline college PRESIDENT's

1161
00:34:15,877 --> 00:34:17,746
breakfast and that's 7:30 the

1162
00:34:17,746 --> 00:34:20,490
morning, as many of you know,

1163
00:34:20,490 --> 00:34:22,651
I'm a little older than the

1164
00:34:22,651 --> 00:34:25,651
average colleague up here and

1165
00:34:27,289 --> 00:34:27,756
I don't do 7:30 willingly

1166
00:34:27,756 --> 00:34:28,757
very

1167
00:34:28,757 --> 00:34:31,326
often, he convinced he I

1168
00:34:31,326 --> 00:34:34,563
needed to be tere, it was my

1169
00:34:34,563 --> 00:34:36,198
first time building 12 at

1170
00:34:36,198 --> 00:34:38,767
skyline college, it looks out

1171
00:34:38,767 --> 00:34:40,602
into the pacific ocean and

1172
00:34:40,602 --> 00:34:41,770
it's inspirational, it's an

1173
00:34:41,770 --> 00:34:44,770
amazing venue for an event,

1174
00:34:45,440 --> 00:34:48,440
they had well over 240 people

1175
00:34:48,911 --> 00:34:52,515
there and they had a dj, mc,

1176
00:34:52,515 --> 00:34:54,750
and the music was gj quality,

1177
00:34:54,750 --> 00:34:56,180
the early hour and the dj

1178
00:34:56,180 --> 00:34:57,586
music, I found a table way in

1179
00:34:57,586 --> 00:34:59,955
the corner and it worked okay

1180
00:34:59,955 --> 00:35:01,955
for me.

1181
00:35:02,240 --> 00:35:02,391
The previous saturday on

1182
00:35:02,391 --> 00:35:03,692
MARCH

1183
00:35:03,692 --> 00:35:07,292
15, I spent a lot hof time

1184
00:35:09,131 --> 00:35:10,766
with the mayor lately, he put

1185
00:35:10,766 --> 00:35:13,766
together cafecito, this was a

1186
00:35:16,572 --> 00:35:20,172
second one, this was on the

1187
00:35:22,478 --> 00:35:23,646
star bucks on mclellan drive,

1188
00:35:23,646 --> 00:35:25,281
I met new people in the

1189
00:35:25,281 --> 00:35:27,116
district and to see them get

1190
00:35:27,116 --> 00:35:28,551
involved and care about their

1191
00:35:28,551 --> 00:35:30,853
community and one of them is

1192
00:35:30,853 --> 00:35:32,221
in the audience tonight,

1193
00:35:32,221 --> 00:35:33,155
hello, anne trres, thank you

1194
00:35:33,155 --> 00:35:34,323
for joining us.

1195
00:35:34,323 --> 00:35:35,792
That's always great to see.

1196
00:35:35,792 --> 00:35:37,860
She's been a a resident of

1197
00:35:37,860 --> 00:35:39,529
south san francisco since the

1198
00:35:39,529 --> 00:35:40,530
70's and to see hr

1199
00:35:40,530 --> 00:35:42,930
willingness to get involved

1200
00:35:43,133 --> 00:35:44,901
and play a role is truly

1201
00:35:44,901 --> 00:35:45,768
remarkable, so it was all

1202
00:35:45,768 --> 00:35:46,636
worthwhile.

1203
00:35:46,636 --> 00:35:48,636
>> great.

1204
00:35:49,773 --> 00:35:50,206
>> and then we found

1205
00:35:50,206 --> 00:35:52,206
ourselves

1206
00:35:53,543 --> 00:35:56,246
out of south san francisco at

1207
00:35:56,246 --> 00:35:56,913
the japan town center for a

1208
00:35:56,913 --> 00:35:57,313
special exhibit for our

1209
00:35:57,313 --> 00:35:58,814
sister

1210
00:35:58,814 --> 00:35:59,282
city in japan is kish shi

1211
00:35:59,282 --> 00:36:00,450
watt

1212
00:36:00,450 --> 00:36:01,851
ta, the cultural district up

1213
00:36:01,851 --> 00:36:03,353
there was doing a rbbon

1214
00:36:03,353 --> 00:36:03,553
cutting for a special x

1215
00:36:03,553 --> 00:36:04,988
I

1216
00:36:04,988 --> 00:36:06,456
exhibit for the three sister

1217
00:36:06,456 --> 00:36:06,620
city that is are here in san

1218
00:36:06,620 --> 00:36:07,257
-

1219
00:36:07,257 --> 00:36:08,892
mateo county.

1220
00:36:08,892 --> 00:36:11,194
We were joined by the former

1221
00:36:11,194 --> 00:36:11,561
MAY yr of daly city, they

1222
00:36:11,561 --> 00:36:13,290
just

1223
00:36:13,290 --> 00:36:16,290
initiated just last year or

1224
00:36:16,266 --> 00:36:17,434
this year a new sister city

1225
00:36:17,434 --> 00:36:17,834
that we'll be visiting

1226
00:36:17,834 --> 00:36:19,503
shortly.

1227
00:36:19,503 --> 00:36:19,870
This is a a great segway,

1228
00:36:19,870 --> 00:36:20,904
I've

1229
00:36:20,904 --> 00:36:22,105
mentioned we are looking for

1230
00:36:22,105 --> 00:36:24,174
people that might want to

1231
00:36:24,174 --> 00:36:25,342
travel to japan with the

1232
00:36:25,342 --> 00:36:26,943
sister city's committee, we

1233
00:36:26,943 --> 00:36:27,878
are not quite maxed out of

1234
00:36:27,878 --> 00:36:28,912
the

1235
00:36:28,912 --> 00:36:29,279
trip, there still might be a

1236
00:36:29,279 --> 00:36:31,279
a

1237
00:36:31,615 --> 00:36:32,515
couple of openings but I

1238
00:36:32,515 --> 00:36:33,684
understand that COUNCILWOMAN

1239
00:36:33,684 --> 00:36:35,319
Nicolas and her husband might

1240
00:36:35,319 --> 00:36:36,987
be joining us so there's even

1241
00:36:36,987 --> 00:36:38,987
less space.

1242
00:36:40,257 --> 00:36:41,658
Anyway, on SEPTEMBER 12th, we

1243
00:36:41,658 --> 00:36:43,600
fly to japan and we don't

1244
00:36:43,600 --> 00:36:44,610
return until the 27th but

1245
00:36:44,610 --> 00:36:47,970
we're going there to be part

1246
00:36:47,970 --> 00:36:48,666
of the sister city

1247
00:36:48,666 --> 00:36:50,666
international committee which

1248
00:36:51,435 --> 00:36:53,504
is being hosted in diernl not

1249
00:36:53,504 --> 00:36:55,840
going to get the name right,

1250
00:36:55,840 --> 00:36:57,207
in the small city daly city

1251
00:36:57,207 --> 00:36:58,843
is

1252
00:36:58,843 --> 00:37:01,843
twined with, we'll spend some

1253
00:37:02,780 --> 00:37:03,547
time in osaka, there's an

1254
00:37:03,547 --> 00:37:05,549
international expo that goes

1255
00:37:05,549 --> 00:37:07,217
for a number of months, we'll

1256
00:37:07,217 --> 00:37:09,753
be in osaka for a little bit

1257
00:37:09,753 --> 00:37:11,188
and find our way to tokyo

1258
00:37:11,188 --> 00:37:11,654
where we'll all be

1259
00:37:11,654 --> 00:37:12,923
overwhelmed

1260
00:37:12,923 --> 00:37:14,191
by the energy there and fly

1261
00:37:14,191 --> 00:37:15,326
home, so there are still

1262
00:37:15,326 --> 00:37:15,826
opportunities if you're

1263
00:37:15,826 --> 00:37:17,826
interested.

1264
00:37:19,463 --> 00:37:21,132
We can send you the itinerary

1265
00:37:21,132 --> 00:37:23,132
and the particulars.

1266
00:37:24,202 --> 00:37:27,371
And then I guess -- oh, and

1267
00:37:27,371 --> 00:37:29,440
I'm looking forward -- very

1268
00:37:29,440 --> 00:37:29,841
much looking forward to

1269
00:37:29,841 --> 00:37:31,841
monday

1270
00:37:32,100 --> 00:37:33,678
MARCH 31, I have rceive add

1271
00:37:33,678 --> 00:37:34,779
guarantee from city hall from

1272
00:37:34,779 --> 00:37:35,246
the city manager's office

1273
00:37:35,246 --> 00:37:37,246
that

1274
00:37:39,183 --> 00:37:39,951
on that day, we will begin

1275
00:37:39,951 --> 00:37:42,351
removing the derelict vehicle

1276
00:37:43,755 --> 00:37:47,355
that is are in the oyster

1277
00:37:49,727 --> 00:37:50,628
cove, vao that -- vehicles

1278
00:37:50,628 --> 00:37:52,630
that have completely sunk.

1279
00:37:52,630 --> 00:37:52,497
Do you know what time we're

1280
00:37:52,497 --> 00:37:53,498
starting?

1281
00:37:53,498 --> 00:37:53,898
>> I don't know, we will find

1282
00:37:53,898 --> 00:37:55,500
out.

1283
00:37:55,500 --> 00:37:56,935
>> we're going to start with

1284
00:37:56,935 --> 00:37:58,536
ten of the worst vehicles,

1285
00:37:58,536 --> 00:37:59,938
pulling them out of the water

1286
00:37:59,938 --> 00:38:01,172
and destroying them on-site

1287
00:38:01,172 --> 00:38:01,673
and I'm going to cheer every

1288
00:38:01,673 --> 00:38:02,400
one of those.

1289
00:38:02,400 --> 00:38:02,841
Er

1290
00:38:02,841 --> 00:38:03,908
>> just one bit of

1291
00:38:03,908 --> 00:38:04,975
information that I haven't

1292
00:38:04,975 --> 00:38:06,677
shared with council yet, I

1293
00:38:06,677 --> 00:38:08,412
believe three of the vehicles

1294
00:38:08,412 --> 00:38:11,516
that we -- or the boats that

1295
00:38:11,516 --> 00:38:12,250
we were going to hve

1296
00:38:12,250 --> 00:38:14,850
removed,

1297
00:38:14,850 --> 00:38:16,355
once they were posted, they

1298
00:38:16,355 --> 00:38:16,855
left of their own accord,

1299
00:38:16,855 --> 00:38:18,456
each

1300
00:38:18,456 --> 00:38:21,456
removal is very costly, so

1301
00:38:21,593 --> 00:38:25,193
that was good news to us.

1302
00:38:26,331 --> 00:38:26,865
>> monday MARCH 31 out near

1303
00:38:26,865 --> 00:38:27,165
the ac mare yo

1304
00:38:27,165 --> 00:38:28,767
t hotel, we're

1305
00:38:28,767 --> 00:38:30,168
going to get started on that

1306
00:38:30,168 --> 00:38:31,336
day and there will be more to

1307
00:38:31,336 --> 00:38:34,336
come, thank you, MR. Mayor.

1308
00:38:40,579 --> 00:38:42,979
>> tank you, well said.

1309
00:38:47,386 --> 00:38:50,555
>> so, I was also able to

1310
00:38:50,555 --> 00:38:52,858
attend the naacp gala and I

1311
00:38:52,858 --> 00:38:54,693
want to also congratulate the

1312
00:38:54,693 --> 00:38:56,962
honorees, also last week I

1313
00:38:56,962 --> 00:38:58,564
attended the orange park

1314
00:38:58,564 --> 00:39:00,964
memorial pool beam topping

1315
00:39:01,233 --> 00:39:02,401
where we signed the last I

1316
00:39:02,401 --> 00:39:04,690
guess team that will b used

1317
00:39:04,690 --> 00:39:05,771
for the structure of the pool

1318
00:39:05,771 --> 00:39:07,473
and they are building that

1319
00:39:07,473 --> 00:39:11,730
pool quickly and I can't be

1320
00:39:19,919 --> 00:39:21,530
more excited and I guess

1321
00:39:21,530 --> 00:39:21,387
weather permissible, I hope

1322
00:39:21,387 --> 00:39:22,488
it

1323
00:39:22,488 --> 00:39:24,790
will be done soon.

1324
00:39:24,790 --> 00:39:26,580
I want to thank everyone for

1325
00:39:26,580 --> 00:39:27,893
making that possible.

1326
00:39:27,893 --> 00:39:28,293
That is all I have for

1327
00:39:28,293 --> 00:39:28,828
tonight.

1328
00:39:28,828 --> 00:39:30,828
>> COUNCILWOMAN?

1329
00:39:34,333 --> 00:39:36,402
>> and for that kish wad da

1330
00:39:36,402 --> 00:39:37,837
trip, we are paying our own

1331
00:39:37,837 --> 00:39:40,837
way websinger are making sure.

1332
00:39:40,840 --> 00:39:41,774
So, as a testament for us

1333
00:39:41,774 --> 00:39:44,174
being an inclusive community,

1334
00:39:44,543 --> 00:39:46,145
I did enjoy the holy

1335
00:39:46,145 --> 00:39:48,545
celebration and shout-out to

1336
00:39:55,955 --> 00:39:57,790
ver con ka ortiz, devon

1337
00:39:57,790 --> 00:40:00,190
stenhouse for the celebration.

1338
00:40:00,693 --> 00:40:01,600
We don't know that we're

1339
00:40:01,600 --> 00:40:03,600
going

1340
00:40:03,229 --> 00:40:05,432
to be having a bigger

1341
00:40:05,432 --> 00:40:07,832
celebration next year, and

1342
00:40:10,870 --> 00:40:13,673
then also I attended on MARCH

1343
00:40:13,673 --> 00:40:14,140
20 the third sister

1344
00:40:14,140 --> 00:40:15,575
leadership

1345
00:40:15,575 --> 00:40:17,377
conference, all of those who

1346
00:40:17,377 --> 00:40:18,311
don't know about the sister

1347
00:40:18,311 --> 00:40:19,479
and sister leadership

1348
00:40:19,479 --> 00:40:21,479
conference, it's something

1349
00:40:22,150 --> 00:40:23,617
that's been going on in santa

1350
00:40:23,617 --> 00:40:25,685
clara county for the last 30

1351
00:40:25,685 --> 00:40:26,853
years, I brought it to san

1352
00:40:26,853 --> 00:40:28,922
mateo county three years ago,

1353
00:40:28,922 --> 00:40:30,990
the first two years were held

1354
00:40:30,990 --> 00:40:33,990
here in the south san

1355
00:40:34,261 --> 00:40:34,961
francisco and that's for

1356
00:40:34,961 --> 00:40:36,830
asian

1357
00:40:36,830 --> 00:40:38,432
american native hawaiian,

1358
00:40:38,432 --> 00:40:38,765
pacific islander girls who

1359
00:40:38,765 --> 00:40:40,660
are

1360
00:40:40,660 --> 00:40:43,660
from sixth grade to high

1361
00:40:44,504 --> 00:40:45,405
school and there's a lot of

1362
00:40:45,405 --> 00:40:47,405
women empowerment sessions

1363
00:40:47,741 --> 00:40:48,108
that we go through making

1364
00:40:48,108 --> 00:40:49,877
sure

1365
00:40:49,877 --> 00:40:51,945
that they're comfortable and

1366
00:40:51,945 --> 00:40:52,446
this year's theme is

1367
00:40:52,446 --> 00:40:54,114
embracing

1368
00:40:54,114 --> 00:40:55,682
the journey, so they heard

1369
00:40:55,682 --> 00:40:57,784
about people who are

1370
00:40:57,784 --> 00:40:58,952
successful now and how they

1371
00:40:58,952 --> 00:41:01,352
had gone through difficulties

1372
00:41:01,922 --> 00:41:03,323
in life and we are -- we keep

1373
00:41:03,323 --> 00:41:05,159
on telling them they're more

1374
00:41:05,159 --> 00:41:05,492
than enough, so we had the

1375
00:41:05,492 --> 00:41:06,560
big

1376
00:41:06,560 --> 00:41:07,227
group from -- and I'm so

1377
00:41:07,227 --> 00:41:09,227
happy

1378
00:41:09,330 --> 00:41:12,930
to have a big group from

1379
00:41:13,333 --> 00:41:15,168
westborough middle school in

1380
00:41:15,168 --> 00:41:16,170
alta loma, el camino and

1381
00:41:16,170 --> 00:41:17,571
south

1382
00:41:17,571 --> 00:41:19,673
city high school, so it was a

1383
00:41:19,673 --> 00:41:20,708
a wonderful event for all the

1384
00:41:20,708 --> 00:41:21,750
young ladies, and I also

1385
00:41:21,750 --> 00:41:22,276
would

1386
00:41:22,276 --> 00:41:24,645
like to request that we

1387
00:41:24,645 --> 00:41:27,248
adjourn the meeting in memory

1388
00:41:27,248 --> 00:41:29,317
of one of the persons I met

1389
00:41:29,317 --> 00:41:31,786
when we were just beginning

1390
00:41:31,786 --> 00:41:35,386
our life here in south san

1391
00:41:35,723 --> 00:41:38,493
francisco, he was the founder

1392
00:41:38,493 --> 00:41:39,860
of [Inaudible] Dance company,

1393
00:41:39,860 --> 00:41:40,561
a filipino dance cmpany

1394
00:41:40,561 --> 00:41:42,561
where

1395
00:41:43,630 --> 00:41:44,465
my children started dancing,

1396
00:41:44,465 --> 00:41:46,333
filipino folk dancing and

1397
00:41:46,333 --> 00:41:46,768
having the love for art and

1398
00:41:46,768 --> 00:41:48,768
is

1399
00:41:52,807 --> 00:41:56,407
music, his name is bonafo sta

1400
00:41:56,878 --> 00:41:57,278
balera junior and MS.

1401
00:41:57,278 --> 00:41:58,579
Maurice

1402
00:41:58,579 --> 00:41:59,647
copia and MAY their memories

1403
00:41:59,647 --> 00:42:00,815
serve as a blessing.

1404
00:42:00,815 --> 00:42:01,182
>> I appreciate that, the

1405
00:42:01,182 --> 00:42:02,917
good

1406
00:42:02,917 --> 00:42:03,251
thing about being mayor is

1407
00:42:03,251 --> 00:42:05,153
all

1408
00:42:05,153 --> 00:42:06,788
of you share the places we've

1409
00:42:06,788 --> 00:42:09,570
already been so I say check,

1410
00:42:09,570 --> 00:42:09,390
check, check, thank you to

1411
00:42:09,390 --> 00:42:09,724
the

1412
00:42:09,724 --> 00:42:10,458
va

1413
00:42:10,458 --> 00:42:12,327
is mayor for subbing in.

1414
00:42:12,327 --> 00:42:14,162
A lot of folks don't realize

1415
00:42:14,162 --> 00:42:16,631
that being mayor and being

1416
00:42:16,631 --> 00:42:19,310
councilmember, it naoets a

1417
00:42:19,330 --> 00:42:19,801
full

1418
00:42:19,801 --> 00:42:20,535
time job, many of us have a

1419
00:42:20,535 --> 00:42:20,869
full time job like many of

1420
00:42:20,869 --> 00:42:21,569
you

1421
00:42:21,569 --> 00:42:22,270
working 8-5 five day as week

1422
00:42:22,270 --> 00:42:22,637
so I appreciate that very

1423
00:42:22,637 --> 00:42:23,905
much

1424
00:42:23,905 --> 00:42:24,839
to be able to cover, I'm

1425
00:42:24,839 --> 00:42:26,708
grateful to the resident and

1426
00:42:26,708 --> 00:42:28,577
is the community members that

1427
00:42:28,577 --> 00:42:30,712
stopped by for our cafecito

1428
00:42:30,712 --> 00:42:33,181
with the myor x the vice

1429
00:42:33,181 --> 00:42:34,616
mayor, it's not just district

1430
00:42:34,616 --> 00:42:36,951
1 residents, there were just

1431
00:42:36,951 --> 00:42:37,318
like the last cafecito we

1432
00:42:37,318 --> 00:42:38,620
had,

1433
00:42:38,620 --> 00:42:40,188
residents from all over south

1434
00:42:40,188 --> 00:42:42,524
san francisco and this is

1435
00:42:42,524 --> 00:42:43,225
really what it is, it's

1436
00:42:43,225 --> 00:42:44,459
bringing different

1437
00:42:44,459 --> 00:42:45,160
neighborhoods together, it's

1438
00:42:45,160 --> 00:42:46,294
a

1439
00:42:46,294 --> 00:42:46,628
a little national night out

1440
00:42:46,628 --> 00:42:47,896
on

1441
00:42:47,896 --> 00:42:48,296
a saturday morning with

1442
00:42:48,296 --> 00:42:50,296
coffee

1443
00:42:50,465 --> 00:42:52,300
so it's great to see some

1444
00:42:52,300 --> 00:42:53,935
parents stop by on their way

1445
00:42:53,935 --> 00:42:55,103
to baseball practice or other

1446
00:42:55,103 --> 00:42:56,380
endeavors on a saturday

1447
00:42:56,380 --> 00:42:56,471
morning, but building

1448
00:42:56,471 --> 00:42:58,140
xhaoent,

1449
00:42:58,140 --> 00:42:59,308
it's really what it's about.

1450
00:42:59,308 --> 00:42:59,775
There's still many

1451
00:42:59,775 --> 00:43:00,709
individuals

1452
00:43:00,709 --> 00:43:02,544
that say, you live right

1453
00:43:02,544 --> 00:43:04,313
there, I liver right there,

1454
00:43:04,313 --> 00:43:05,814
you work right there, I'm a

1455
00:43:05,814 --> 00:43:06,181
history buff as the vice

1456
00:43:06,181 --> 00:43:08,181
mayor

1457
00:43:09,718 --> 00:43:11,853
knows and hearing about the

1458
00:43:11,853 --> 00:43:13,220
old macy's warehouses before

1459
00:43:13,220 --> 00:43:13,389
the costco years here in

1460
00:43:13,389 --> 00:43:14,423
south

1461
00:43:14,423 --> 00:43:15,591
city is a great time so I

1462
00:43:15,591 --> 00:43:16,525
appreciate that and we do it

1463
00:43:16,525 --> 00:43:18,127
in different ways.

1464
00:43:18,127 --> 00:43:19,328
We engage with our community

1465
00:43:19,328 --> 00:43:21,328
in different ways.

1466
00:43:22,565 --> 00:43:23,632
I was also happy to join

1467
00:43:23,632 --> 00:43:24,333
councilmember nagales at his

1468
00:43:24,333 --> 00:43:25,367
community meeting as well

1469
00:43:25,367 --> 00:43:26,135
websinger ear out there and

1470
00:43:26,135 --> 00:43:27,236
connecting and sharing the

1471
00:43:27,236 --> 00:43:29,636
information so I appreciate

1472
00:43:30,390 --> 00:43:30,973
all of you, everyone is

1473
00:43:30,973 --> 00:43:31,307
welcome, stay tuned because

1474
00:43:31,307 --> 00:43:32,608
we

1475
00:43:32,608 --> 00:43:34,710
have many more coming during

1476
00:43:34,710 --> 00:43:36,111
the course of this year.

1477
00:43:36,111 --> 00:43:37,513
Indeed I attended some of the

1478
00:43:37,513 --> 00:43:37,914
ve lents that were already

1479
00:43:37,914 --> 00:43:39,148
shared.

1480
00:43:39,148 --> 00:43:40,983
I do want to point a little

1481
00:43:40,983 --> 00:43:43,953
bit of some of the work I'm

1482
00:43:43,953 --> 00:43:46,689
doing here with the support

1483
00:43:46,689 --> 00:43:47,890
of our city staff and city

1484
00:43:47,890 --> 00:43:49,890
manager.

1485
00:43:49,692 --> 00:43:52,280
We hosted and met our new

1486
00:43:52,280 --> 00:43:52,762
assembly member and the state

1487
00:43:52,762 --> 00:43:54,130
legislature, catherine

1488
00:43:54,130 --> 00:43:55,298
stephanie who represents

1489
00:43:55,298 --> 00:43:57,166
assembly dstrict 19, we

1490
00:43:57,166 --> 00:44:00,336
hosted her last week at south

1491
00:44:00,336 --> 00:44:01,504
city at our city hall and

1492
00:44:01,504 --> 00:44:03,239
discussed many important

1493
00:44:03,239 --> 00:44:04,574
policy issues, many assembly

1494
00:44:04,574 --> 00:44:04,907
bills but also things that

1495
00:44:04,907 --> 00:44:06,342
are

1496
00:44:06,342 --> 00:44:08,945
really important to south san

1497
00:44:08,945 --> 00:44:10,790
francisco and this is a great

1498
00:44:10,790 --> 00:44:10,446
opportunity to really say

1499
00:44:10,446 --> 00:44:12,446
this

1500
00:44:12,882 --> 00:44:14,217
has been something that has

1501
00:44:14,217 --> 00:44:16,118
ben filets our community and

1502
00:44:16,118 --> 00:44:18,455
we need additional support on

1503
00:44:18,455 --> 00:44:20,290
this, she was extremely open,

1504
00:44:20,290 --> 00:44:21,224
extremely welcoming and

1505
00:44:21,224 --> 00:44:21,558
extremely willing to work,

1506
00:44:21,558 --> 00:44:22,658
her

1507
00:44:22,658 --> 00:44:24,260
and her team, I want to

1508
00:44:24,260 --> 00:44:25,928
acknowledge and recognize we

1509
00:44:25,928 --> 00:44:28,231
have a strong -- another

1510
00:44:28,231 --> 00:44:28,698
representative in the state

1511
00:44:28,698 --> 00:44:29,866
legislature.

1512
00:44:29,866 --> 00:44:30,233
We're very lucky here in

1513
00:44:30,233 --> 00:44:31,701
south

1514
00:44:31,701 --> 00:44:33,136
san francisco, we have two

1515
00:44:33,136 --> 00:44:35,171
state senators covering, we

1516
00:44:35,171 --> 00:44:37,400
have two assembly members, we

1517
00:44:37,400 --> 00:44:38,441
have two also members of the

1518
00:44:38,441 --> 00:44:40,477
san mateo county board of

1519
00:44:40,477 --> 00:44:42,379
supervisors, we have two san

1520
00:44:42,379 --> 00:44:44,481
mateo county board of

1521
00:44:44,481 --> 00:44:45,916
education trustees, so we're

1522
00:44:45,916 --> 00:44:48,916
-- we're well represented and

1523
00:44:50,187 --> 00:44:52,555
again it's about advocacy,

1524
00:44:52,555 --> 00:44:54,391
it's about ensuring that our

1525
00:44:54,391 --> 00:44:54,758
policy priorities that we

1526
00:44:54,758 --> 00:44:56,590
will

1527
00:44:56,590 --> 00:44:59,590
discuss later are well spoken

1528
00:44:59,620 --> 00:45:00,564
for as well.

1529
00:45:00,564 --> 00:45:02,465
I did want to talk about

1530
00:45:02,465 --> 00:45:04,865
upcoming and you'll start

1531
00:45:05,669 --> 00:45:07,538
seeing some of the promotions

1532
00:45:07,538 --> 00:45:08,238
websinger are on APRIL 5 and

1533
00:45:08,238 --> 00:45:09,873
I

1534
00:45:09,873 --> 00:45:10,273
believe the 19th, we're

1535
00:45:10,273 --> 00:45:12,142
moving

1536
00:45:12,142 --> 00:45:13,310
forward with south san

1537
00:45:13,310 --> 00:45:13,710
francisco neighborhood

1538
00:45:13,710 --> 00:45:15,646
cleanup.

1539
00:45:15,646 --> 00:45:18,682
In particular, kick it off in

1540
00:45:18,682 --> 00:45:19,450
some of the areas most

1541
00:45:19,450 --> 00:45:21,452
affected, downtown, old town

1542
00:45:21,452 --> 00:45:21,919
where we see a lot of illegal

1543
00:45:21,919 --> 00:45:23,919
dumping.

1544
00:45:27,457 --> 00:45:28,192
We kicked tis off last year,

1545
00:45:28,192 --> 00:45:28,959
it was extremely successful.

1546
00:45:28,959 --> 00:45:29,660
Thank tos the support of our

1547
00:45:29,660 --> 00:45:30,260
staff, we couldn't do it,

1548
00:45:30,260 --> 00:45:30,761
also

1549
00:45:30,761 --> 00:45:32,196
our volunteer, people that

1550
00:45:32,196 --> 00:45:32,529
came out early on saturday

1551
00:45:32,529 --> 00:45:34,529
and

1552
00:45:34,965 --> 00:45:36,667
we held it it on sunday, this

1553
00:45:36,667 --> 00:45:39,667
year is both on saturdays,

1554
00:45:40,103 --> 00:45:42,239
this is part of an initiative

1555
00:45:42,239 --> 00:45:44,508
I'm so thrilled about, clean

1556
00:45:44,508 --> 00:45:46,811
ssf, part of that we envision

1557
00:45:46,811 --> 00:45:48,813
providing you with some

1558
00:45:48,813 --> 00:45:50,281
shovels, sme picks and some

1559
00:45:50,281 --> 00:45:50,615
garbage bag and is lending

1560
00:45:50,615 --> 00:45:52,615
you

1561
00:45:53,751 --> 00:45:55,586
some gloves and come out and

1562
00:45:55,586 --> 00:45:56,521
build community, cleaning up

1563
00:45:56,521 --> 00:45:57,989
our neighborhoods, you'll see

1564
00:45:57,989 --> 00:45:59,791
that on social media, you'll

1565
00:45:59,791 --> 00:46:01,859
see that in my newsletter

1566
00:46:01,859 --> 00:46:02,326
coming up so I want to

1567
00:46:02,326 --> 00:46:04,195
welcome

1568
00:46:04,195 --> 00:46:06,595
all residents, even visitors

1569
00:46:06,797 --> 00:46:08,633
of south san francisco to

1570
00:46:08,633 --> 00:46:12,233
partake and join me and staff

1571
00:46:13,304 --> 00:46:13,738
and let's clean up south san

1572
00:46:13,738 --> 00:46:15,506
francisco.

1573
00:46:15,506 --> 00:46:16,507
With that in mind, I'm excite

1574
00:46:16,507 --> 00:46:18,109
ted share with our city

1575
00:46:18,109 --> 00:46:20,509
manager that south san

1576
00:46:20,745 --> 00:46:21,513
francisco should be pursuing

1577
00:46:21,513 --> 00:46:23,810
the [Inaudible] Designation,

1578
00:46:23,810 --> 00:46:23,548
that is the clean california

1579
00:46:23,548 --> 00:46:24,682
designation.

1580
00:46:24,682 --> 00:46:27,652
I would like the share that,

1581
00:46:27,652 --> 00:46:30,210
this is a special initiative

1582
00:46:30,210 --> 00:46:31,422
designation put on by the

1583
00:46:31,422 --> 00:46:33,822
governor's office and managed

1584
00:46:33,958 --> 00:46:35,360
by cal trans and it really

1585
00:46:35,360 --> 00:46:37,195
honors communities that are

1586
00:46:37,195 --> 00:46:38,797
dedicated to doing something

1587
00:46:38,797 --> 00:46:40,432
about it, not just saying,

1588
00:46:40,432 --> 00:46:42,567
well, we got to blame so and

1589
00:46:42,567 --> 00:46:44,902
so or that agency has to come

1590
00:46:44,902 --> 00:46:47,205
up and step up for us, so it

1591
00:46:47,205 --> 00:46:48,840
really brings a sense of

1592
00:46:48,840 --> 00:46:50,242
community, it's improving the

1593
00:46:50,242 --> 00:46:51,910
health, it's improving our e

1594
00:46:51,910 --> 00:46:54,910
economy and it's really aso

1595
00:46:58,160 --> 00:46:58,750
as part of this designation,

1596
00:46:58,750 --> 00:47:00,252
it's allowing south city to

1597
00:47:00,252 --> 00:47:00,585
apply for money torx apply

1598
00:47:00,585 --> 00:47:01,887
for

1599
00:47:01,887 --> 00:47:04,189
grants that potentially could

1600
00:47:04,189 --> 00:47:07,125
support us in continuing to

1601
00:47:07,125 --> 00:47:08,760
clean up south city and all

1602
00:47:08,760 --> 00:47:11,760
locations in every area that

1603
00:47:13,499 --> 00:47:13,866
you can imagine, so, the

1604
00:47:13,866 --> 00:47:15,634
first

1605
00:47:15,634 --> 00:47:16,101
hundred designated

1606
00:47:16,101 --> 00:47:16,869
communities

1607
00:47:16,869 --> 00:47:17,302
will continue to receive this

1608
00:47:17,302 --> 00:47:18,237
resource.

1609
00:47:18,237 --> 00:47:19,404
There are already cities,

1610
00:47:19,404 --> 00:47:21,273
bakersfield, fresno, irvine,

1611
00:47:21,273 --> 00:47:22,207
la, can dewing that are part

1612
00:47:22,207 --> 00:47:23,409
of this initiative and I want

1613
00:47:23,409 --> 00:47:23,876
to se our city be

1614
00:47:23,876 --> 00:47:24,810
represented

1615
00:47:24,810 --> 00:47:26,645
as well.

1616
00:47:26,645 --> 00:47:28,948
Now just turning a little

1617
00:47:28,948 --> 00:47:30,316
different lens, I did want to

1618
00:47:30,316 --> 00:47:31,717
ask our city manager if we

1619
00:47:31,717 --> 00:47:32,418
could look into two items

1620
00:47:32,418 --> 00:47:34,418
that

1621
00:47:34,520 --> 00:47:36,880
I've been monitoring as I'm

1622
00:47:36,880 --> 00:47:36,455
driving around connecting

1623
00:47:36,455 --> 00:47:37,222
with

1624
00:47:37,222 --> 00:47:39,124
neighborhoods and different

1625
00:47:39,124 --> 00:47:40,292
shopping centers, there are

1626
00:47:40,292 --> 00:47:41,694
certain donation insets in

1627
00:47:41,694 --> 00:47:43,528
various parking lotuses and

1628
00:47:43,528 --> 00:47:45,928
shopping centers, one in

1629
00:47:46,297 --> 00:47:48,567
particular is the parking lot

1630
00:47:48,567 --> 00:47:48,967
right behind five guys

1631
00:47:48,967 --> 00:47:49,968
burgers

1632
00:47:49,968 --> 00:47:52,968
in westborough square, as I

1633
00:47:55,508 --> 00:47:58,508
was there this weekend, it

1634
00:47:58,711 --> 00:48:00,512
wasn't a nice sited to look

1635
00:48:00,512 --> 00:48:02,748
at, I would like to see if we

1636
00:48:02,748 --> 00:48:04,490
could work with the donation

1637
00:48:04,490 --> 00:48:06,850
vendor, how often they clean

1638
00:48:06,850 --> 00:48:07,453
up and that sort of thing.

1639
00:48:07,453 --> 00:48:10,222
The oher thing I started

1640
00:48:10,222 --> 00:48:13,222
noticing is on weekends, many

1641
00:48:13,826 --> 00:48:15,695
amazon trucks are parking for

1642
00:48:15,695 --> 00:48:18,264
more than whatever it is,

1643
00:48:18,264 --> 00:48:19,699
saturdays and sundays, taking

1644
00:48:19,699 --> 00:48:21,334
up perhaps a parking lot that

1645
00:48:21,334 --> 00:48:23,903
could be for residents so I

1646
00:48:23,903 --> 00:48:26,720
want to look at are there

1647
00:48:26,720 --> 00:48:27,206
amazon parking lots that are

1648
00:48:27,206 --> 00:48:28,374
designated, in particular in

1649
00:48:28,374 --> 00:48:29,108
district 5, I'm seeing in

1650
00:48:29,108 --> 00:48:31,108
many

1651
00:48:31,177 --> 00:48:34,177
of our surface city parking

1652
00:48:34,180 --> 00:48:35,581
lotuses, there's a lot of

1653
00:48:35,581 --> 00:48:36,316
amazon distribution delivery

1654
00:48:36,316 --> 00:48:37,417
trucks on there, so I would

1655
00:48:37,417 --> 00:48:39,850
like to follow up and discuss

1656
00:48:39,850 --> 00:48:41,788
a little bit on that.

1657
00:48:41,788 --> 00:48:43,156
>> we're happy to do that.

1658
00:48:43,156 --> 00:48:45,156
>> thank you.

1659
00:48:48,495 --> 00:48:52,950
Lastly I want to adjourn in

1660
00:48:52,698 --> 00:48:54,300
the memory of jose flores.

1661
00:48:54,300 --> 00:48:54,634
He passed away suddenly this

1662
00:48:54,634 --> 00:48:56,634
mo

1663
00:48:57,303 --> 00:48:59,139
bt, I met jose at my

1664
00:48:59,139 --> 00:49:01,539
swearing in this past

1665
00:49:03,810 --> 00:49:04,977
DECEMBER, he's the father of

1666
00:49:04,977 --> 00:49:05,278
douglas cotoad1 resident and

1667
00:49:05,278 --> 00:49:07,278
a

1668
00:49:07,381 --> 00:49:09,149
graduate of our citizens

1669
00:49:09,149 --> 00:49:09,616
academy, I would like to

1670
00:49:09,616 --> 00:49:11,251
honor

1671
00:49:11,251 --> 00:49:12,419
and my his manly continue to

1672
00:49:12,419 --> 00:49:16,190
be a blessing for all tloez

1673
00:49:16,890 --> 00:49:17,491
and equally with the names

1674
00:49:17,491 --> 00:49:17,924
that COUNCILWOMAN Flor

1675
00:49:17,924 --> 00:49:19,559
nicolas

1676
00:49:19,559 --> 00:49:20,994
shared, our condolences to

1677
00:49:20,994 --> 00:49:23,630
those families and loved ones.

1678
00:49:23,630 --> 00:49:24,310
Thank you, that's all I had.

1679
00:49:24,310 --> 00:49:25,432
Next agenda item, please.

1680
00:49:25,432 --> 00:49:26,600
>> thank you, mayor, we will

1681
00:49:26,600 --> 00:49:29,636
now move on to public comment

1682
00:49:29,636 --> 00:49:33,236
and is we will begin with

1683
00:49:38,450 --> 00:49:40,450
cynthia markopoulos.

1684
00:49:40,780 --> 00:49:42,883
>> good evening, at the

1685
00:49:42,883 --> 00:49:44,883
JANUARY 9, 1985 city council

1686
00:49:46,387 --> 00:49:47,870
meeting, the clerk's minutes

1687
00:49:47,870 --> 00:49:49,870
documented mayor hafy's

1688
00:49:49,657 --> 00:49:51,725
comments about the surplus

1689
00:49:51,725 --> 00:49:52,626
magnolia building stating "to

1690
00:49:52,626 --> 00:49:55,260
provide housing was important

1691
00:49:55,663 --> 00:49:56,864
but should not overshadow the

1692
00:49:56,864 --> 00:49:57,298
senior center and I should

1693
00:49:57,298 --> 00:49:58,232
be

1694
00:49:58,232 --> 00:50:00,568
revitalized for seniors and

1695
00:50:00,568 --> 00:50:02,637
use of the community".

1696
00:50:02,637 --> 00:50:05,637
The most recent e-mail to

1697
00:50:05,740 --> 00:50:08,140
attendees of magnolia teglia

1698
00:50:08,342 --> 00:50:11,342
center is they will be

1699
00:50:13,481 --> 00:50:14,182
relocated to the bola center

1700
00:50:14,182 --> 00:50:14,781
for months, and mingling

1701
00:50:14,781 --> 00:50:16,781
adult

1702
00:50:16,851 --> 00:50:18,252
widths daycare center where

1703
00:50:18,252 --> 00:50:21,756
mayor edie said it was a

1704
00:50:21,756 --> 00:50:23,257
concern having adults with

1705
00:50:23,257 --> 00:50:25,126
young kids.

1706
00:50:25,126 --> 00:50:25,526
I agree with you, mayor

1707
00:50:25,526 --> 00:50:26,961
eddie,

1708
00:50:26,961 --> 00:50:28,963
that history is important

1709
00:50:28,963 --> 00:50:30,899
learning about macy's

1710
00:50:30,899 --> 00:50:32,899
warehouse, etc., the

1711
00:50:32,934 --> 00:50:33,334
historical society and

1712
00:50:33,334 --> 00:50:34,369
library

1713
00:50:34,369 --> 00:50:35,360
have limited if no

1714
00:50:35,360 --> 00:50:37,360
information

1715
00:50:38,339 --> 00:50:40,909
on the msb even though they

1716
00:50:40,909 --> 00:50:43,144
had orange library grand

1717
00:50:43,144 --> 00:50:44,712
avenue's information as well.

1718
00:50:44,712 --> 00:50:46,414
As we witnessed over decades

1719
00:50:46,414 --> 00:50:48,883
in history, it is to wipe out

1720
00:50:48,883 --> 00:50:50,352
any mem ray or eliminate any

1721
00:50:50,352 --> 00:50:52,752
significance of something but

1722
00:50:52,887 --> 00:50:54,522
we have researched the past

1723
00:50:54,522 --> 00:50:56,922
thorough clerk's minutes over

1724
00:50:57,125 --> 00:50:58,460
the past six decades

1725
00:50:58,460 --> 00:51:00,860
documenting the importance of

1726
00:51:00,996 --> 00:51:03,640
the msb and we will not let

1727
00:51:03,640 --> 00:51:04,699
you forget it especially when

1728
00:51:04,699 --> 00:51:07,100
30% of our population is 55

1729
00:51:07,100 --> 00:51:09,805
years and older and that the

1730
00:51:09,805 --> 00:51:11,406
msb had 188 thousand visitors

1731
00:51:11,406 --> 00:51:11,773
annually and was the most

1732
00:51:11,773 --> 00:51:13,773
used

1733
00:51:14,476 --> 00:51:15,610
facility as noted in jim

1734
00:51:15,610 --> 00:51:17,610
steel's staff report.

1735
00:51:18,847 --> 00:51:21,216
I copied each of you in an

1736
00:51:21,216 --> 00:51:21,550
e-mail to marie patea, not

1737
00:51:21,550 --> 00:51:21,950
one

1738
00:51:21,950 --> 00:51:23,752
replay

1739
00:51:23,752 --> 00:51:25,220
f mri for you, I put

1740
00:51:25,220 --> 00:51:27,122
in a public records request

1741
00:51:27,122 --> 00:51:29,157
dated MARCH 14 and I received

1742
00:51:29,157 --> 00:51:30,580
an extension on MARCH 24

1743
00:51:30,580 --> 00:51:32,580
specifically addressing the

1744
00:51:32,194 --> 00:51:33,762
special city council meeting

1745
00:51:33,762 --> 00:51:35,762
of APRIL 29.

1746
00:51:35,898 --> 00:51:37,499
Let hope in fairness it is

1747
00:51:37,499 --> 00:51:39,801
complied with in ample time

1748
00:51:39,801 --> 00:51:40,436
before the 29th meeting

1749
00:51:40,436 --> 00:51:42,436
concerning the msb.

1750
00:51:43,538 --> 00:51:45,700
Thank you.

1751
00:51:45,700 --> 00:51:46,800
>> thank you, MADAM City

1752
00:51:46,800 --> 00:51:47,977
manager, can you confirm the

1753
00:51:47,977 --> 00:51:49,912
date, time and location for

1754
00:51:49,912 --> 00:51:52,312
the upcoming meeting, please.

1755
00:51:52,481 --> 00:51:53,849
>> for the msb study session?

1756
00:51:53,849 --> 00:51:55,117
>> yes.

1757
00:51:55,117 --> 00:51:57,117
>> it's wednesday APRIL 29

1758
00:51:57,586 --> 00:51:58,687
here at the library parks and

1759
00:51:58,687 --> 00:51:59,210
recreation council chambers

1760
00:51:59,210 --> 00:51:59,388
at

1761
00:51:59,388 --> 00:52:01,388
6:30.

1762
00:52:02,858 --> 00:52:04,727
>> thank you.

1763
00:52:04,727 --> 00:52:05,895
>> thank you, mayor, if I MAY

1764
00:52:05,895 --> 00:52:06,328
add for that specific

1765
00:52:06,328 --> 00:52:08,328
meeting,

1766
00:52:09,980 --> 00:52:11,601
we intend to have the agenda

1767
00:52:11,601 --> 00:52:12,768
published by friday APRIL 25.

1768
00:52:12,768 --> 00:52:14,768
>> thank you.

1769
00:52:29,619 --> 00:52:33,890
Moving on the sam ch icuti.

1770
00:52:33,890 --> 00:52:33,489
>> mayor flores, board

1771
00:52:33,489 --> 00:52:34,724
member,

1772
00:52:34,724 --> 00:52:36,559
south san francisco city

1773
00:52:36,559 --> 00:52:38,427
council, my name is sam, I'm

1774
00:52:38,427 --> 00:52:38,761
glad that the city council

1775
00:52:38,761 --> 00:52:40,290
has

1776
00:52:40,290 --> 00:52:41,597
finally decided to have a

1777
00:52:41,597 --> 00:52:43,499
special meeting for the msb

1778
00:52:43,499 --> 00:52:44,734
next month on the 29th.

1779
00:52:44,734 --> 00:52:48,334
After all, it's only been two

1780
00:52:48,638 --> 00:52:50,773
and a half years.

1781
00:52:50,773 --> 00:52:51,474
I suppose that the city

1782
00:52:51,474 --> 00:52:52,242
council imagined that the

1783
00:52:52,242 --> 00:52:53,976
coalition of citizens against

1784
00:52:53,976 --> 00:52:56,976
tearing down the msb would

1785
00:52:57,547 --> 00:52:59,415
have dissipated by now.

1786
00:52:59,415 --> 00:53:00,783
That in and of itself is

1787
00:53:00,783 --> 00:53:01,718
short

1788
00:53:01,718 --> 00:53:04,118
sighted by this council.

1789
00:53:04,955 --> 00:53:06,590
As you have heard in past

1790
00:53:06,590 --> 00:53:08,990
meetings, more than 30% of

1791
00:53:09,326 --> 00:53:10,794
south san francisco residents

1792
00:53:10,794 --> 00:53:13,363
are retired, will be retired

1793
00:53:13,363 --> 00:53:15,232
or are close to retirement in

1794
00:53:15,232 --> 00:53:18,832
a very short period of time.

1795
00:53:20,503 --> 00:53:20,870
I recently saw a youtube

1796
00:53:20,870 --> 00:53:22,870
video

1797
00:53:22,906 --> 00:53:23,240
of the city council meeting

1798
00:53:23,240 --> 00:53:23,707
of

1799
00:53:23,707 --> 00:53:24,374
last AUGUST.

1800
00:53:24,374 --> 00:53:27,311
In this video, the city

1801
00:53:27,311 --> 00:53:27,744
planner of south san

1802
00:53:27,744 --> 00:53:29,179
francisco

1803
00:53:29,179 --> 00:53:29,613
tony said almost all

1804
00:53:29,613 --> 00:53:31,448
available

1805
00:53:31,448 --> 00:53:31,815
parcels of land owned by

1806
00:53:31,815 --> 00:53:33,815
south

1807
00:53:33,984 --> 00:53:34,318
san francisco have been or

1808
00:53:34,318 --> 00:53:35,385
are

1809
00:53:35,385 --> 00:53:37,221
being developed.

1810
00:53:37,221 --> 00:53:38,550
What exactly is the city

1811
00:53:38,550 --> 00:53:39,356
council's outlook for south

1812
00:53:39,356 --> 00:53:40,724
san francisco?

1813
00:53:40,724 --> 00:53:43,724
Do they see south san

1814
00:53:45,829 --> 00:53:46,262
francisco as a mini me to san

1815
00:53:46,262 --> 00:53:47,310
francisco?

1816
00:53:47,310 --> 00:53:48,832
Additional apartments are not

1817
00:53:48,832 --> 00:53:50,701
the answer to those that have

1818
00:53:50,701 --> 00:53:51,869
been residents of south san

1819
00:53:51,869 --> 00:53:53,360
francisco for decades.

1820
00:53:53,360 --> 00:53:56,600
Community center where w can

1821
00:53:56,600 --> 00:53:58,342
can gather is a necessity for

1822
00:53:58,342 --> 00:53:59,143
an aging populous.

1823
00:53:59,143 --> 00:54:01,111
The magnolia center is

1824
00:54:01,111 --> 00:54:03,681
certainly not the answer, it

1825
00:54:03,681 --> 00:54:04,949
can barely accommodate the

1826
00:54:04,949 --> 00:54:07,349
people going there now.

1827
00:54:07,384 --> 00:54:08,753
What will happen when more

1828
00:54:08,753 --> 00:54:10,753
people become seniors?

1829
00:54:10,821 --> 00:54:11,288
Is this council's answer to

1830
00:54:11,288 --> 00:54:13,288
go

1831
00:54:13,590 --> 00:54:14,525
to the senior center in san

1832
00:54:14,525 --> 00:54:16,525
bruno?

1833
00:54:16,627 --> 00:54:18,963
Save the msb as a community

1834
00:54:18,963 --> 00:54:21,320
center for us, thank you.

1835
00:54:21,320 --> 00:54:23,320
>> thank you.

1836
00:54:37,915 --> 00:54:39,317
Next up.

1837
00:54:39,317 --> 00:54:39,751
>> a correction to the

1838
00:54:39,751 --> 00:54:41,751
meeting

1839
00:54:43,254 --> 00:54:43,955
is tuesday APRIL 29th, thank

1840
00:54:43,955 --> 00:54:45,356
you.

1841
00:54:45,356 --> 00:54:47,356
>> my apologies.

1842
00:54:47,926 --> 00:54:50,495
>> now we're moving on to

1843
00:54:50,495 --> 00:54:52,495
tony

1844
00:54:58,970 --> 00:55:00,970
allen.

1845
00:55:01,380 --> 00:55:04,380
>> good evening, my name is

1846
00:55:08,146 --> 00:55:10,248
tony alan, I live near loss

1847
00:55:10,248 --> 00:55:13,785
aritos, I wanted to just say

1848
00:55:13,785 --> 00:55:16,785
thank you for your newsletter

1849
00:55:16,821 --> 00:55:19,291
that comes out, mayor eddie,

1850
00:55:19,291 --> 00:55:21,193
and I host english language

1851
00:55:21,193 --> 00:55:23,295
students and I have students

1852
00:55:23,295 --> 00:55:24,363
often that are spanish

1853
00:55:24,363 --> 00:55:26,498
speaking or speak another

1854
00:55:26,498 --> 00:55:27,999
language and I just really

1855
00:55:27,999 --> 00:55:29,267
appreciate that your

1856
00:55:29,267 --> 00:55:30,350
newsletter gave a whole lot

1857
00:55:30,350 --> 00:55:31,869
of

1858
00:55:31,869 --> 00:55:33,939
good information about how

1859
00:55:33,939 --> 00:55:36,939
inclusive and diverse and how

1860
00:55:37,108 --> 00:55:39,444
south san francisco really

1861
00:55:39,444 --> 00:55:41,713
values our diversity and our

1862
00:55:41,713 --> 00:55:43,582
inclusiveness and that you

1863
00:55:43,582 --> 00:55:44,883
gave great resources and so

1864
00:55:44,883 --> 00:55:46,118
please, I hope we continue to

1865
00:55:46,118 --> 00:55:47,519
do that.

1866
00:55:47,519 --> 00:55:51,119
I obviously came at the right

1867
00:55:52,357 --> 00:55:54,590
time, I'm also an adu person

1868
00:55:54,590 --> 00:55:55,894
and so I'm proud of south san

1869
00:55:55,894 --> 00:55:56,227
francisco and I just wanted

1870
00:55:56,227 --> 00:55:56,728
to

1871
00:55:56,728 --> 00:55:57,162
mention that.

1872
00:55:57,162 --> 00:55:59,162
Thank you.

1873
00:56:01,667 --> 00:56:03,667
>> thank you.

1874
00:56:18,417 --> 00:56:20,417
>> fianola?

1875
00:56:21,353 --> 00:56:22,821
>> good evening,

1876
00:56:22,821 --> 00:56:24,821
councilmembers, and everyone

1877
00:56:28,928 --> 00:56:29,362
in the auditorium and

1878
00:56:29,362 --> 00:56:31,362
watching.

1879
00:56:31,430 --> 00:56:31,897
In 1977, the city exercised

1880
00:56:31,897 --> 00:56:33,897
an

1881
00:56:34,300 --> 00:56:37,300
option to purchase the value

1882
00:56:39,504 --> 00:56:42,504
giant, also known as the

1883
00:56:42,642 --> 00:56:44,642
municipal services building.

1884
00:56:45,544 --> 00:56:47,544
1977.

1885
00:56:47,680 --> 00:56:50,680
You exercised the option and

1886
00:56:54,520 --> 00:56:56,920
you purchased the building.

1887
00:56:59,626 --> 00:57:03,226
That was quite a while ago.

1888
00:57:04,898 --> 00:57:05,398
Now, in part, you needed

1889
00:57:05,398 --> 00:57:06,166
extra

1890
00:57:06,166 --> 00:57:08,201
space, documents, proof, one

1891
00:57:08,201 --> 00:57:08,568
of the things you needed

1892
00:57:08,568 --> 00:57:10,303
extra

1893
00:57:10,303 --> 00:57:11,300
space for was a senior

1894
00:57:11,300 --> 00:57:13,300
center,

1895
00:57:13,306 --> 00:57:16,906
so you dedicated space at the

1896
00:57:19,546 --> 00:57:20,747
msb for a senior center.

1897
00:57:20,747 --> 00:57:22,282
Where MR. Rozzi is that

1898
00:57:22,282 --> 00:57:23,160
documented in the

1899
00:57:23,160 --> 00:57:25,160
environmental impact report

1900
00:57:28,588 --> 00:57:28,889
with respect to with drawing

1901
00:57:28,889 --> 00:57:30,889
a

1902
00:57:30,891 --> 00:57:32,292
senior center, a dedicated

1903
00:57:32,292 --> 00:57:35,292
senior center from tens of

1904
00:57:41,501 --> 00:57:42,235
thousands of peopl

1905
00:57:42,235 --> 00:57:43,300
in this city, where is that

1906
00:57:43,300 --> 00:57:43,536
environmental impact report,

1907
00:57:43,536 --> 00:57:45,536
it's supposed to

1908
00:57:45,572 --> 00:57:47,572
document significant impacts,

1909
00:57:48,442 --> 00:57:50,377
not documented.

1910
00:57:50,377 --> 00:57:53,377
In addition, you put a

1911
00:57:54,947 --> 00:57:57,718
proposition on the ballot to

1912
00:57:57,718 --> 00:58:00,718
reimburse you for the payment

1913
00:58:01,322 --> 00:58:03,722
of 1.39 million dollars for

1914
00:58:04,658 --> 00:58:06,658
that property.

1915
00:58:08,329 --> 00:58:10,729
You assessed 5 cents per

1916
00:58:11,165 --> 00:58:13,565
hundred dollars, per hundred

1917
00:58:16,403 --> 00:58:16,870
dollars, 5 cents, for 20

1918
00:58:16,870 --> 00:58:18,870
years

1919
00:58:19,807 --> 00:58:20,174
on taxable property in this

1920
00:58:20,174 --> 00:58:22,174
city.

1921
00:58:23,677 --> 00:58:24,440
We paid for that building

1922
00:58:24,440 --> 00:58:26,440
over

1923
00:58:26,280 --> 00:58:28,680
there, property owners did.

1924
00:58:30,651 --> 00:58:32,651
Where's the money?

1925
00:58:33,454 --> 00:58:34,550
I asked for an accounting of

1926
00:58:34,550 --> 00:58:34,755
where that money is.

1927
00:58:34,755 --> 00:58:35,222
How much money did you

1928
00:58:35,222 --> 00:58:37,222
collect?

1929
00:58:38,693 --> 00:58:41,930
You know, roughly speaking,

1930
00:58:44,865 --> 00:58:46,801
let's say 44 thousand dollars

1931
00:58:46,801 --> 00:58:50,401
was paid by a property over

1932
00:58:50,705 --> 00:58:52,340
the 20 years, that's 350

1933
00:58:52,340 --> 00:58:53,574
properties to cover that

1934
00:58:53,574 --> 00:58:55,574
price, okay.

1935
00:58:56,100 --> 00:58:57,645
Where is the money?

1936
00:58:57,645 --> 00:58:59,450
I've requested that money --

1937
00:58:59,450 --> 00:59:02,450
the accounting of that money

1938
00:59:03,170 --> 00:59:04,752
from the city, mo response of

1939
00:59:04,752 --> 00:59:06,921
records, I wonder why.

1940
00:59:06,921 --> 00:59:09,758
The msb has been a cash cow

1941
00:59:09,758 --> 00:59:10,592
for you as you know including

1942
00:59:10,592 --> 00:59:12,293
the fire department which

1943
00:59:12,293 --> 00:59:15,293
turned out to be political

1944
00:59:16,165 --> 00:59:16,830
suicide, didn't it, MR.

1945
00:59:16,830 --> 00:59:17,465
Addiego.

1946
00:59:17,465 --> 00:59:18,233
Where's the money?

1947
00:59:18,233 --> 00:59:20,233
Thank you.

1948
00:59:23,838 --> 00:59:25,838
>> thank you.

1949
00:59:33,648 --> 00:59:34,882
>> judy?

1950
00:59:34,882 --> 00:59:35,250
>> my name's judy, I have

1951
00:59:35,250 --> 00:59:37,250
been

1952
00:59:38,186 --> 00:59:39,454
a a resident of south city

1953
00:59:39,454 --> 00:59:39,754
since 1963, this is my home,

1954
00:59:39,754 --> 00:59:41,289
I

1955
00:59:41,289 --> 00:59:41,790
love it and I hate some of

1956
00:59:41,790 --> 00:59:42,457
the

1957
00:59:42,457 --> 00:59:44,457
changes I'm seeing.

1958
00:59:45,727 --> 00:59:48,830
I would hate to see the msb

1959
00:59:48,830 --> 00:59:51,830
building gone because we need

1960
00:59:52,267 --> 00:59:53,868
it for groups.

1961
00:59:53,868 --> 00:59:55,437
AUGUST 24, 2019, I was

1962
00:59:55,437 --> 00:59:55,971
diagnosed with advanced

1963
00:59:55,971 --> 00:59:56,438
breast

1964
00:59:56,438 --> 00:59:58,240
cancer.

1965
00:59:58,240 --> 01:00:00,876
What I found is that there is

1966
01:00:00,876 --> 01:00:02,244
no breast cancer support

1967
01:00:02,244 --> 01:00:03,645
group

1968
01:00:03,645 --> 01:00:03,979
anywhere near, the closest

1969
01:00:03,979 --> 01:00:04,913
one

1970
01:00:04,913 --> 01:00:06,615
was san francisco which I

1971
01:00:06,615 --> 01:00:10,520
don't care to g to at night.

1972
01:00:10,520 --> 01:00:11,353
The other one was palo alto,

1973
01:00:11,353 --> 01:00:11,753
that building would be

1974
01:00:11,753 --> 01:00:13,422
perfect

1975
01:00:13,422 --> 01:00:13,789
for a breast cancer support

1976
01:00:13,789 --> 01:00:15,789
group.

1977
01:00:16,926 --> 01:00:18,127
One in every four women get

1978
01:00:18,127 --> 01:00:19,295
breast cancer during their

1979
01:00:19,295 --> 01:00:19,761
lifetime and you need the

1980
01:00:19,761 --> 01:00:21,363
support.

1981
01:00:21,363 --> 01:00:24,363
I am currently in remission

1982
01:00:24,366 --> 01:00:25,868
but I'm not cancer free.

1983
01:00:25,868 --> 01:00:27,269
So, -- ask it was tough

1984
01:00:27,269 --> 01:00:27,603
because like I said, 2019,

1985
01:00:27,603 --> 01:00:29,603
the

1986
01:00:30,106 --> 01:00:32,700
end of it, I was diagnosed,

1987
01:00:32,700 --> 01:00:33,609
I'm -- I'll keep my time,

1988
01:00:33,609 --> 01:00:34,777
eddie, don't worry.

1989
01:00:34,777 --> 01:00:35,110
>> she hadn't started.

1990
01:00:35,110 --> 01:00:37,460
Er

1991
01:00:37,460 --> 01:00:39,282
>> that's okay, I'm aware,

1992
01:00:39,282 --> 01:00:39,982
anyway, when I started, it

1993
01:00:39,982 --> 01:00:41,982
was

1994
01:00:42,840 --> 01:00:44,887
beginning of covid, going for

1995
01:00:44,887 --> 01:00:46,188
cancer treatment, they're

1996
01:00:46,188 --> 01:00:48,558
phenomenal at ucsf, during

1997
01:00:48,558 --> 01:00:49,910
that time it was scary and

1998
01:00:49,910 --> 01:00:50,226
not

1999
01:00:50,226 --> 01:00:52,626
having a support system,

2000
01:00:52,828 --> 01:00:55,828
you're in your home, you're

2001
01:00:56,310 --> 01:00:58,167
isolating, it was very

2002
01:00:58,167 --> 01:01:01,704
depressing and to be in your

2003
01:01:01,704 --> 01:01:04,704
home alone fr years because

2004
01:01:08,478 --> 01:01:09,212
you're immune -- immune know

2005
01:01:09,212 --> 01:01:11,714
fomented was horrible ad I

2006
01:01:11,714 --> 01:01:12,548
would like the start one in

2007
01:01:12,548 --> 01:01:14,284
that building as soon as we

2008
01:01:14,284 --> 01:01:15,510
decide not to demolish it,

2009
01:01:15,510 --> 01:01:16,952
thank you.

2010
01:01:16,952 --> 01:01:18,354
>> just for your information,

2011
01:01:18,354 --> 01:01:20,189
so just for your iformation

2012
01:01:20,189 --> 01:01:22,250
for breast cancer support

2013
01:01:22,250 --> 01:01:22,425
group, contact bay area

2014
01:01:22,425 --> 01:01:24,425
cancer

2015
01:01:24,561 --> 01:01:24,894
connections and this is in

2016
01:01:24,894 --> 01:01:26,894
san

2017
01:01:27,229 --> 01:01:29,229
mateo county.

2018
01:01:29,299 --> 01:01:30,330
>> thank you, mayor, that

2019
01:01:30,330 --> 01:01:30,700
concludes anyone registered

2020
01:01:30,700 --> 01:01:31,670
to

2021
01:01:31,670 --> 01:01:32,102
speak.

2022
01:01:32,102 --> 01:01:33,737
Do we have anyone else in the

2023
01:01:33,737 --> 01:01:34,169
audience that did not

2024
01:01:34,169 --> 01:01:36,169
register?

2025
01:01:37,600 --> 01:01:39,600
Go ahead.

2026
01:01:39,108 --> 01:01:40,510
F you don't mind coming up to

2027
01:01:40,510 --> 01:01:41,878
the mic., please, thank you.

2028
01:01:41,878 --> 01:01:42,345
Just so everyone at home can

2029
01:01:42,345 --> 01:01:44,345
hear you.

2030
01:01:45,182 --> 01:01:48,182
>> I was wondering, I heard

2031
01:01:48,552 --> 01:01:49,180
archer aviation is going to

2032
01:01:49,180 --> 01:01:50,620
be

2033
01:01:50,620 --> 01:01:50,988
flying this year, is that

2034
01:01:50,988 --> 01:01:52,988
true

2035
01:01:55,425 --> 01:01:57,394
in south city?

2036
01:01:57,394 --> 01:01:58,394
>> sorry, we can't respond to

2037
01:01:58,394 --> 01:02:00,394
public comment.

2038
01:02:00,496 --> 01:02:02,132
>> that's basically -- it was

2039
01:02:02,132 --> 01:02:02,565
more of a question than a

2040
01:02:02,565 --> 01:02:03,934
statement.

2041
01:02:03,934 --> 01:02:05,101
That's it.

2042
01:02:05,101 --> 01:02:06,869
That was basically it.

2043
01:02:06,869 --> 01:02:07,571
>> MADAM City manager, if you

2044
01:02:07,571 --> 01:02:08,371
could follow up with the

2045
01:02:08,371 --> 01:02:10,371
individual.

2046
01:02:10,440 --> 01:02:11,374
>> if I could get your name

2047
01:02:11,374 --> 01:02:13,210
and contact number, aisle

2048
01:02:13,210 --> 01:02:14,411
give

2049
01:02:14,411 --> 01:02:16,280
-- I'll give you a call.

2050
01:02:16,280 --> 01:02:16,980
>> thank you, mayor, that

2051
01:02:16,980 --> 01:02:17,748
kondsbacker concludes our

2052
01:02:17,748 --> 01:02:18,715
speakers and I wanted to note

2053
01:02:18,715 --> 01:02:20,884
for the record, we received

2054
01:02:20,884 --> 01:02:23,870
and you should all receive in

2055
01:02:23,870 --> 01:02:23,787
your ipad an e-comment from

2056
01:02:23,787 --> 01:02:25,422
chef ava.

2057
01:02:25,422 --> 01:02:25,990
>> great, thank you, that has

2058
01:02:25,990 --> 01:02:27,990
been received.

2059
01:02:28,225 --> 01:02:29,260
>> thank you, moving on to

2060
01:02:29,260 --> 01:02:30,427
consent calendar.

2061
01:02:30,427 --> 01:02:32,963
Item 3 is a motion to approve

2062
01:02:32,963 --> 01:02:35,363
the minutes of MARCH 12, 2025.

2063
01:02:35,766 --> 01:02:38,102
Item 4 is a motion to accept

2064
01:02:38,102 --> 01:02:39,270
measure w citizens' oversight

2065
01:02:39,270 --> 01:02:39,770
committee report

2066
01:02:39,770 --> 01:02:41,770
independently

2067
01:02:43,641 --> 01:02:45,743
verifying fiscal year 2023-24

2068
01:02:45,743 --> 01:02:46,243
measure w revenue and is

2069
01:02:46,243 --> 01:02:47,144
expenditures.

2070
01:02:47,144 --> 01:02:49,480
Item 5 is a motion to receive

2071
01:02:49,480 --> 01:02:50,180
and file the city's housing

2072
01:02:50,180 --> 01:02:50,881
successor agency annual

2073
01:02:50,881 --> 01:02:52,881
report

2074
01:02:53,550 --> 01:02:55,253
for fiscal year 2023-24.

2075
01:02:55,253 --> 01:02:55,552
Item 6 is a report regarding

2076
01:02:55,552 --> 01:02:57,552
a

2077
01:02:58,756 --> 01:03:00,691
funding agreement with san

2078
01:03:00,691 --> 01:03:01,392
mateo county transportation

2079
01:03:01,392 --> 01:03:02,994
authority for the harbor

2080
01:03:02,994 --> 01:03:04,862
master spit project.

2081
01:03:04,862 --> 01:03:06,497
6a is the resolution.

2082
01:03:06,497 --> 01:03:07,164
Item 7 is a report regarding

2083
01:03:07,164 --> 01:03:09,164
a

2084
01:03:11,435 --> 01:03:13,435
resolution authorizing the

2085
01:03:13,671 --> 01:03:16,507
creation of cdbg ramps and

2086
01:03:16,507 --> 01:03:18,610
paths, approval of budget

2087
01:03:18,610 --> 01:03:19,777
amendment number 25.046 and

2088
01:03:19,777 --> 01:03:20,912
authorization o advertise the

2089
01:03:20,912 --> 01:03:22,580
project for cnstruction.

2090
01:03:22,580 --> 01:03:24,215
Item 7a is the resolution.

2091
01:03:24,215 --> 01:03:24,516
Item 8 is a report regarding

2092
01:03:24,516 --> 01:03:25,616
a

2093
01:03:25,616 --> 01:03:25,950
second reading and adoption

2094
01:03:25,950 --> 01:03:27,652
of

2095
01:03:27,652 --> 01:03:29,200
an ordinance amending the

2096
01:03:29,200 --> 01:03:31,420
south san francisco municipal

2097
01:03:32,723 --> 01:03:33,958
code to add chapter 8.100

2098
01:03:33,958 --> 01:03:35,360
local preference and is

2099
01:03:35,360 --> 01:03:36,728
requirements to title 8 to

2100
01:03:36,728 --> 01:03:38,563
define a preference policy

2101
01:03:38,563 --> 01:03:40,198
requirement for housing units

2102
01:03:40,198 --> 01:03:40,565
regulated by the city of

2103
01:03:40,565 --> 01:03:42,534
south

2104
01:03:42,534 --> 01:03:43,935
san francisco in order to

2105
01:03:43,935 --> 01:03:45,770
prioritize housing applicants

2106
01:03:45,770 --> 01:03:46,137
who live and/or work in the

2107
01:03:46,137 --> 01:03:48,137
city.

2108
01:03:48,807 --> 01:03:50,175
Item 8a is the ordinance.

2109
01:03:50,175 --> 01:03:52,244
>> thank you, are there any

2110
01:03:52,244 --> 01:03:52,710
members who wuld like to

2111
01:03:52,710 --> 01:03:53,644
pull

2112
01:03:53,644 --> 01:03:55,644
any agenda items?

2113
01:03:55,680 --> 01:03:56,614
>> item 6 and 7.

2114
01:03:56,614 --> 01:03:57,849
>> 6 and 7.

2115
01:03:57,849 --> 01:03:59,450
Anyone else?

2116
01:03:59,450 --> 01:04:01,185
Okay.

2117
01:04:01,185 --> 01:04:01,753
I'm okay with doing those

2118
01:04:01,753 --> 01:04:03,753
right now.

2119
01:04:04,423 --> 01:04:07,423
So we'll start with item 6.

2120
01:04:09,528 --> 01:04:11,398
>> let me promote our staff

2121
01:04:11,398 --> 01:04:13,398
here.

2122
01:04:13,932 --> 01:04:14,633
She's online, are you going

2123
01:04:14,633 --> 01:04:16,633
to

2124
01:04:18,537 --> 01:04:21,537
talk, I'm going promote her.

2125
01:04:22,410 --> 01:04:24,376
>> who are we talking to?

2126
01:04:24,376 --> 01:04:25,778
>> she's coming, adrianna.

2127
01:04:25,778 --> 01:04:27,778
Here she is.

2128
01:04:28,130 --> 01:04:28,380
>> is she here?

2129
01:04:28,380 --> 01:04:30,380
Okay.

2130
01:04:32,684 --> 01:04:35,120
So, this item has to do with

2131
01:04:35,120 --> 01:04:35,820
roughly an one acre piece of

2132
01:04:35,820 --> 01:04:36,354
property that's out a the

2133
01:04:36,354 --> 01:04:36,588
marina with wr

2134
01:04:36,588 --> 01:04:38,457
the harbor

2135
01:04:38,457 --> 01:04:41,457
master is and it's habitually

2136
01:04:41,693 --> 01:04:43,829
under water when we have king

2137
01:04:43,829 --> 01:04:44,764
tides to an amazing degree.

2138
01:04:44,764 --> 01:04:47,164
We've identified some money

2139
01:04:48,601 --> 01:04:49,769
but I just need to understand

2140
01:04:49,769 --> 01:04:50,102
we were aarded a grant and

2141
01:04:50,102 --> 01:04:51,404
we

2142
01:04:51,404 --> 01:04:51,703
have to match the grant with

2143
01:04:51,703 --> 01:04:53,703
a

2144
01:04:53,806 --> 01:04:55,874
like amount of dollars but

2145
01:04:55,874 --> 01:04:56,209
that grant has expired, so

2146
01:04:56,209 --> 01:04:57,710
can

2147
01:04:57,710 --> 01:04:59,111
you explain to me the

2148
01:04:59,111 --> 01:05:02,111
mechanism that is going to

2149
01:05:03,416 --> 01:05:03,917
ensure that we have

2150
01:05:03,917 --> 01:05:04,851
participation.

2151
01:05:04,851 --> 01:05:06,851
>> yes, of course.

2152
01:05:07,320 --> 01:05:08,210
So, we've had this fnding

2153
01:05:08,210 --> 01:05:10,210
agreement ongoing.

2154
01:05:11,790 --> 01:05:13,426
It's kind of a logistical

2155
01:05:13,426 --> 01:05:15,426
funding agreement adjustment.

2156
01:05:16,762 --> 01:05:18,631
We applied for an extension

2157
01:05:18,631 --> 01:05:22,231
and the ta denied that and

2158
01:05:22,735 --> 01:05:23,436
said they wanted to create a

2159
01:05:23,436 --> 01:05:25,305
new funding agreement.

2160
01:05:25,305 --> 01:05:25,672
All of our invoices will

2161
01:05:25,672 --> 01:05:27,606
still

2162
01:05:27,606 --> 01:05:27,941
be paid between the gap of

2163
01:05:27,941 --> 01:05:29,142
the

2164
01:05:29,142 --> 01:05:31,311
old funding agreement and the

2165
01:05:31,311 --> 01:05:32,612
new one.

2166
01:05:32,612 --> 01:05:33,646
Yeah, did that answer your

2167
01:05:33,646 --> 01:05:35,646
question, councilmember?

2168
01:05:35,748 --> 01:05:36,115
>> so, the invoices that

2169
01:05:36,115 --> 01:05:37,650
we've

2170
01:05:37,650 --> 01:05:39,285
incurred to date are going to

2171
01:05:39,285 --> 01:05:40,220
be covered by the ta grant?

2172
01:05:40,220 --> 01:05:41,854
>> correct.

2173
01:05:41,854 --> 01:05:44,854
>> and then moving ahead once

2174
01:05:44,924 --> 01:05:47,460
we have the design for how

2175
01:05:47,460 --> 01:05:50,460
we're going to improve that

2176
01:05:52,640 --> 01:05:53,934
air -- area so it's not

2177
01:05:53,934 --> 01:05:55,769
overtaught with water, the

2178
01:05:55,769 --> 01:05:57,170
water would eventually

2179
01:05:57,170 --> 01:05:58,338
penetrate the landfill and be

2180
01:05:58,338 --> 01:06:00,106
an environmental disaster, so

2181
01:06:00,106 --> 01:06:02,575
where do we expect to find

2182
01:06:02,575 --> 01:06:04,511
funds potentially for the

2183
01:06:04,511 --> 01:06:06,146
actual construction?

2184
01:06:06,146 --> 01:06:07,747
>> excellent question.

2185
01:06:07,747 --> 01:06:08,448
Currently we have a

2186
01:06:08,448 --> 01:06:10,250
consultant

2187
01:06:10,250 --> 01:06:12,219
looking into feasible gants

2188
01:06:12,219 --> 01:06:14,521
to cover this construction.

2189
01:06:14,521 --> 01:06:15,689
We are at the beginning

2190
01:06:15,689 --> 01:06:17,689
phases

2191
01:06:17,758 --> 01:06:19,159
of grant research and I can

2192
01:06:19,159 --> 01:06:20,494
certainly update you as we

2193
01:06:20,494 --> 01:06:22,529
look into our options.

2194
01:06:22,529 --> 01:06:23,664
>> okay.

2195
01:06:23,664 --> 01:06:26,934
Thank you, that's all I have.

2196
01:06:26,934 --> 01:06:28,934
>> thank you.

2197
01:06:30,370 --> 01:06:31,572
Item number 7?

2198
01:06:31,572 --> 01:06:33,540
>> who's going to help me

2199
01:06:33,540 --> 01:06:35,342
with

2200
01:06:35,342 --> 01:06:37,342
that?

2201
01:06:37,677 --> 01:06:39,677
So, MR. Wilson.

2202
01:06:41,414 --> 01:06:42,817
So, is tere a list of

2203
01:06:42,817 --> 01:06:44,985
projects that we've already

2204
01:06:44,985 --> 01:06:47,454
determined are going to be

2205
01:06:47,454 --> 01:06:50,240
part of this ramp and path

2206
01:06:50,240 --> 01:06:51,425
million dollar project?

2207
01:06:51,425 --> 01:06:53,425
>> good evening, honorable

2208
01:06:53,461 --> 01:06:55,563
members tof council, johnny

2209
01:06:55,563 --> 01:06:57,563
wilson, your associate

2210
01:07:01,435 --> 01:07:01,903
engineer with the engineering

2211
01:07:01,903 --> 01:07:03,700
department.

2212
01:07:03,700 --> 01:07:05,720
So, your question is with

2213
01:07:05,720 --> 01:07:07,241
regard to the scope of the

2214
01:07:07,241 --> 01:07:09,241
project, yeah.

2215
01:07:12,113 --> 01:07:13,514
Approximately 80 curb ramps

2216
01:07:13,514 --> 01:07:15,183
distributed roughly equally

2217
01:07:15,183 --> 01:07:16,584
among the five districts.

2218
01:07:16,584 --> 01:07:17,180
>> that was the next

2219
01:07:17,180 --> 01:07:17,752
question,

2220
01:07:17,752 --> 01:07:18,860
that's great, so that list

2221
01:07:18,860 --> 01:07:18,853
can

2222
01:07:18,853 --> 01:07:20,254
be shared?

2223
01:07:20,254 --> 01:07:21,189
>> yeah.

2224
01:07:21,189 --> 01:07:23,557
Just putting together a

2225
01:07:23,557 --> 01:07:23,891
website for it, I've got a

2226
01:07:23,891 --> 01:07:24,392
map

2227
01:07:24,392 --> 01:07:26,392
that's ready.

2228
01:07:28,596 --> 01:07:29,464
As soon as this project is

2229
01:07:29,464 --> 01:07:30,698
created, I'll create that

2230
01:07:30,698 --> 01:07:33,534
website and share that map,

2231
01:07:33,534 --> 01:07:36,571
it's teed up and ready to go

2232
01:07:36,571 --> 01:07:36,904
and we're also constructing

2233
01:07:36,904 --> 01:07:38,139
an

2234
01:07:38,139 --> 01:07:38,640
accessible path to cypress

2235
01:07:38,640 --> 01:07:39,741
and

2236
01:07:39,741 --> 01:07:40,542
pine park, that's the other

2237
01:07:40,542 --> 01:07:42,343
component.

2238
01:07:42,343 --> 01:07:43,678
>> for downtown?

2239
01:07:43,678 --> 01:07:44,110
That's great, I just needed

2240
01:07:44,110 --> 01:07:45,146
to

2241
01:07:45,146 --> 01:07:46,748
know there was something we

2242
01:07:46,748 --> 01:07:49,351
could see where the money

2243
01:07:49,351 --> 01:07:49,751
might be allocated, so thank

2244
01:07:49,751 --> 01:07:51,751
you.

2245
01:07:52,821 --> 01:07:55,123
>> aisle be happy to share

2246
01:07:55,123 --> 01:07:56,524
with you, tomorrow I'll be

2247
01:07:56,524 --> 01:07:58,627
working on the website.

2248
01:07:58,627 --> 01:07:59,360
>> thank you, having no other

2249
01:07:59,360 --> 01:08:01,163
items being pulled, could I

2250
01:08:01,163 --> 01:08:01,496
have a a motion to approve

2251
01:08:01,496 --> 01:08:02,300
the

2252
01:08:02,300 --> 01:08:02,798
consent agenda?

2253
01:08:02,798 --> 01:08:03,498
>> so moved.

2254
01:08:03,498 --> 01:08:04,332
>> I'll scond.

2255
01:08:04,332 --> 01:08:04,633
>> first and second, can can

2256
01:08:04,633 --> 01:08:06,633
I

2257
01:08:07,335 --> 01:08:08,360
have a roll call, please.

2258
01:08:08,360 --> 01:08:08,193
>> councilmember coleman?

2259
01:08:08,193 --> 01:08:09,738
-

2260
01:08:09,738 --> 01:08:10,672
>> yes.

2261
01:08:10,672 --> 01:08:12,400
>> vice mayor addiego?

2262
01:08:12,400 --> 01:08:12,974
>> yes.

2263
01:08:12,974 --> 01:08:14,974
>> coupes member nicolas?

2264
01:08:17,479 --> 01:08:18,146
>> aye.

2265
01:08:18,146 --> 01:08:18,547
>> cuncilmember nagales?

2266
01:08:18,547 --> 01:08:19,147
>> yes.

2267
01:08:19,147 --> 01:08:19,781
>> and mayor flores?

2268
01:08:19,781 --> 01:08:20,449
>> yes, motion passes.

2269
01:08:20,449 --> 01:08:20,983
>> moving on to

2270
01:08:20,983 --> 01:08:22,317
administrative

2271
01:08:22,317 --> 01:08:23,252
business, item 9 is a report

2272
01:08:23,252 --> 01:08:25,870
regarding the 2024 general

2273
01:08:25,870 --> 01:08:27,487
plan and housing element

2274
01:08:40,235 --> 01:08:42,300
annual progress reports.

2275
01:08:42,300 --> 01:08:42,738
>> good evening,

2276
01:08:42,738 --> 01:08:44,738
councilmembers, billy gross

2277
01:08:47,576 --> 01:08:49,512
with the planning division.

2278
01:08:49,512 --> 01:08:51,347
Myself and stephanie will be

2279
01:08:51,347 --> 01:08:52,748
here for our yearly annual

2280
01:08:52,748 --> 01:08:55,148
progress reports on the

2281
01:08:55,984 --> 01:08:56,384
general plan and housing

2282
01:08:56,384 --> 01:08:58,120
element.

2283
01:08:58,120 --> 01:08:59,288
So I'll go through just a few

2284
01:08:59,288 --> 01:08:59,688
slides that talk about

2285
01:08:59,688 --> 01:09:01,688
actions

2286
01:09:01,891 --> 01:09:03,590
that happened in 2024 for the

2287
01:09:03,590 --> 01:09:04,226
general plan and then

2288
01:09:04,226 --> 01:09:07,226
stephanie will go through the

2289
01:09:08,598 --> 01:09:09,799
housing element for the 2024

2290
01:09:09,799 --> 01:09:10,933
progress.

2291
01:09:10,933 --> 01:09:13,569
As you'll recall, the current

2292
01:09:13,569 --> 01:09:14,737
general pan was adopted in

2293
01:09:14,737 --> 01:09:16,906
2022 and continues to be

2294
01:09:16,906 --> 01:09:17,406
consistent with all state

2295
01:09:17,406 --> 01:09:18,741
requirements.

2296
01:09:18,741 --> 01:09:20,876
There were no amendment ts

2297
01:09:20,876 --> 01:09:23,120
the general plan has were

2298
01:09:23,120 --> 01:09:24,647
adopted in 2024.

2299
01:09:24,647 --> 01:09:26,282
This chart shows when each of

2300
01:09:26,282 --> 01:09:26,649
the required elements was

2301
01:09:26,649 --> 01:09:27,884
last

2302
01:09:27,884 --> 01:09:30,284
updated, all of these

2303
01:09:31,354 --> 01:09:33,890
occurring in e ver 2022 or

2304
01:09:33,890 --> 01:09:36,290
2023 when we adopted the

2305
01:09:38,461 --> 01:09:40,330
lindenville specific plan.

2306
01:09:40,330 --> 01:09:41,731
Attachments 1 and 2 to your

2307
01:09:41,731 --> 01:09:44,100
staff report are the detailed

2308
01:09:44,100 --> 01:09:44,834
general plan implementation

2309
01:09:44,834 --> 01:09:47,234
tables showing the current

2310
01:09:48,237 --> 01:09:49,505
status of each of the 764

2311
01:09:49,505 --> 01:09:50,673
policy ins actions within the

2312
01:09:50,673 --> 01:09:52,442
general plan.

2313
01:09:52,442 --> 01:09:54,511
Items that you see that are

2314
01:09:54,511 --> 01:09:54,944
highlighted in yellow

2315
01:09:54,944 --> 01:09:56,813
indicate

2316
01:09:56,813 --> 01:09:57,180
an updated entry from last

2317
01:09:57,180 --> 01:09:58,949
year.

2318
01:09:58,949 --> 01:10:00,817
The majority of the these are

2319
01:10:00,817 --> 01:10:02,219
descriptions of progress in

2320
01:10:02,219 --> 01:10:03,520
2024 in the notes column but

2321
01:10:03,520 --> 01:10:06,890
there are others that MAY

2322
01:10:06,890 --> 01:10:09,890
indicate a change in status

2323
01:10:09,893 --> 01:10:10,327
or

2324
01:10:10,327 --> 01:10:11,561
timeframe.

2325
01:10:11,561 --> 01:10:14,131
This chart which is also

2326
01:10:14,131 --> 01:10:15,665
included in the staff report

2327
01:10:15,665 --> 01:10:17,665
indicates implementation

2328
01:10:17,768 --> 01:10:18,669
status by element.

2329
01:10:18,669 --> 01:10:20,669
Overall, items cnsidered

2330
01:10:21,437 --> 01:10:23,837
either complete or ongoing

2331
01:10:24,440 --> 01:10:24,841
have increased from 51 to 55

2332
01:10:24,841 --> 01:10:26,760
percent.

2333
01:10:26,760 --> 01:10:28,476
Items considered under way

2334
01:10:28,812 --> 01:10:31,181
have increased from 16 to 19

2335
01:10:31,181 --> 01:10:33,160
percent and items with no

2336
01:10:33,160 --> 01:10:33,483
action have decreased from

2337
01:10:33,483 --> 01:10:34,884
33%

2338
01:10:34,884 --> 01:10:36,530
to 26 percent s we are

2339
01:10:36,530 --> 01:10:37,354
continuing to make progress

2340
01:10:37,354 --> 01:10:39,354
in

2341
01:10:41,570 --> 01:10:41,491
all of these actions and

2342
01:10:41,491 --> 01:10:43,360
policies.

2343
01:10:43,360 --> 01:10:44,940
And for the general plan

2344
01:10:44,940 --> 01:10:45,663
progress report, the last

2345
01:10:45,663 --> 01:10:47,298
thing I wanted to highlight

2346
01:10:47,298 --> 01:10:48,699
was the data dashboard.

2347
01:10:48,699 --> 01:10:49,466
This is intended to assist in

2348
01:10:49,466 --> 01:10:50,334
trag tr

2349
01:10:50,334 --> 01:10:51,635
tracking

2350
01:10:51,635 --> 01:10:52,869
implementation progress on

2351
01:10:52,869 --> 01:10:54,238
performance measure that is

2352
01:10:54,238 --> 01:10:54,938
were identified in the

2353
01:10:54,938 --> 01:10:55,305
general

2354
01:10:55,305 --> 01:10:55,973
plan.

2355
01:10:55,973 --> 01:10:56,373
The dashboard has been

2356
01:10:56,373 --> 01:10:58,373
updated

2357
01:10:58,409 --> 01:10:58,875
with the most recent data

2358
01:10:58,875 --> 01:11:00,875
that

2359
01:11:00,944 --> 01:11:01,378
is currently accessible if

2360
01:11:01,378 --> 01:11:03,790
available.

2361
01:11:03,790 --> 01:11:05,116
We have also worked with our

2362
01:11:05,116 --> 01:11:06,283
website consultant team to

2363
01:11:06,283 --> 01:11:07,952
provide documentation on how

2364
01:11:07,952 --> 01:11:09,987
the data for each performance

2365
01:11:09,987 --> 01:11:10,688
measure is obtained and that

2366
01:11:10,688 --> 01:11:11,789
documentation is now

2367
01:11:11,789 --> 01:11:13,324
available

2368
01:11:13,324 --> 01:11:16,661
on the dashboard which can be

2369
01:11:16,661 --> 01:11:19,661
found on the general plan

2370
01:11:20,464 --> 01:11:21,232
website shape ssf.Net under

2371
01:11:21,232 --> 01:11:23,100
measuring progress, with that

2372
01:11:23,100 --> 01:11:24,000
I'm going the hand it over to

2373
01:11:24,000 --> 01:11:24,502
stephanie to talk to you

2374
01:11:24,502 --> 01:11:25,436
about

2375
01:11:25,436 --> 01:11:27,836
the housing elements progress

2376
01:11:33,744 --> 01:11:34,446
and I'm happy to answer any

2377
01:11:34,446 --> 01:11:34,812
questions you haver after

2378
01:11:34,812 --> 01:11:35,413
that.

2379
01:11:35,413 --> 01:11:37,413
>> thank you, billy.

2380
01:11:37,949 --> 01:11:38,315
>> good evening, thank you,

2381
01:11:38,315 --> 01:11:40,151
billy.

2382
01:11:40,151 --> 01:11:42,551
Stephanie skangos with the

2383
01:11:43,187 --> 01:11:44,555
planning division.

2384
01:11:44,555 --> 01:11:46,391
As billy mentioned, I will be

2385
01:11:46,391 --> 01:11:47,358
going over the housing

2386
01:11:47,358 --> 01:11:48,359
element

2387
01:11:48,359 --> 01:11:50,359
annual progress report.

2388
01:11:50,628 --> 01:11:52,697
Just to offer a quick little

2389
01:11:52,697 --> 01:11:53,980
recap, what is the husing

2390
01:11:53,980 --> 01:11:54,299
element?

2391
01:11:54,299 --> 01:11:55,934
The housing element is one of

2392
01:11:55,934 --> 01:11:58,269
the 7 state mandated elements

2393
01:11:58,269 --> 01:11:59,404
of the general plan.

2394
01:11:59,404 --> 01:12:01,272
Although unlike the other

2395
01:12:01,272 --> 01:12:04,142
elements of a general plan,

2396
01:12:04,142 --> 01:12:04,876
the housing element must be

2397
01:12:04,876 --> 01:12:06,244
updated by deadlines set by

2398
01:12:06,244 --> 01:12:08,244
the state.

2399
01:12:09,781 --> 01:12:12,216
The t city adopted a new

2400
01:12:12,216 --> 01:12:12,951
housing element in JANUARY of

2401
01:12:12,951 --> 01:12:13,652
2023 and the department of

2402
01:12:13,652 --> 01:12:15,200
housing and community

2403
01:12:15,200 --> 01:12:16,588
development or hcd certified

2404
01:12:16,588 --> 01:12:18,230
our housing element in

2405
01:12:18,230 --> 01:12:20,230
NOVEMBER 2023.

2406
01:12:20,910 --> 01:12:21,926
And this new housing element

2407
01:12:21,926 --> 01:12:24,326
covers a planning cycle

2408
01:12:26,310 --> 01:12:28,310
running from JANUARY 31, 2023

2409
01:12:28,567 --> 01:12:30,335
through JANUARY 31, 2031, so

2410
01:12:30,335 --> 01:12:32,335
an 8 year period.

2411
01:12:32,504 --> 01:12:34,339
And again the housing element

2412
01:12:34,339 --> 01:12:35,307
is essentially the blueprint

2413
01:12:35,307 --> 01:12:36,800
for future housing

2414
01:12:36,800 --> 01:12:38,800
development

2415
01:12:38,770 --> 01:12:39,244
within the city ad it

2416
01:12:39,244 --> 01:12:41,480
includes goals, policies and

2417
01:12:41,480 --> 01:12:43,880
programs that will direct

2418
01:12:45,951 --> 01:12:47,951
residential decision-making.

2419
01:12:48,190 --> 01:12:49,621
The housing element -- sorry.

2420
01:12:49,621 --> 01:12:52,210
The housing element process

2421
01:12:52,291 --> 01:12:53,825
begins with the state setting

2422
01:12:53,825 --> 01:12:55,694
a regions regional housing

2423
01:12:55,694 --> 01:12:56,161
needs allocation or rhna

2424
01:12:56,161 --> 01:12:57,830
which

2425
01:12:57,830 --> 01:12:59,164
is the estimated number of

2426
01:12:59,164 --> 01:13:01,100
housing units that will be

2427
01:13:01,100 --> 01:13:03,500
needed over the 8 year

2428
01:13:04,336 --> 01:13:05,938
planning cycle to assist with

2429
01:13:05,938 --> 01:13:08,338
regional growth and trends.

2430
01:13:10,543 --> 01:13:10,910
The 8 year cycle for rhna

2431
01:13:10,910 --> 01:13:12,910
does

2432
01:13:13,313 --> 01:13:15,648
differ slightly by about 6

2433
01:13:15,648 --> 01:13:18,351
months t rhna cycle run from

2434
01:13:18,351 --> 01:13:18,784
JUNE 30, 2022 through

2435
01:13:18,784 --> 01:13:19,352
DECEMBER

2436
01:13:19,352 --> 01:13:21,187
15, 2030.

2437
01:13:21,187 --> 01:13:22,754
It's important to note with

2438
01:13:22,754 --> 01:13:25,624
rhna that these units don't

2439
01:13:25,624 --> 01:13:27,225
need to be constructed during

2440
01:13:27,225 --> 01:13:29,610
the time period, but the city

2441
01:13:29,610 --> 01:13:31,197
is required to ensure that it

2442
01:13:31,197 --> 01:13:33,699
is possible to build these

2443
01:13:33,699 --> 01:13:34,133
units trough appropriate

2444
01:13:34,133 --> 01:13:35,735
zoning.

2445
01:13:35,735 --> 01:13:38,735
New units are counted towards

2446
01:13:38,738 --> 01:13:39,905
rhna at the time of building

2447
01:13:39,905 --> 01:13:42,800
permit issuance and this

2448
01:13:42,800 --> 01:13:44,430
applies for all new

2449
01:13:44,430 --> 01:13:44,777
residential unit tpes,

2450
01:13:44,777 --> 01:13:46,777
single

2451
01:13:47,790 --> 01:13:48,681
family dwellings, accessory

2452
01:13:48,681 --> 01:13:50,681
dwelling units, duplexes,

2453
01:13:52,752 --> 01:13:54,454
duplexes and our larger

2454
01:13:54,454 --> 01:13:56,454
multifamily buildings.

2455
01:13:58,824 --> 01:14:01,394
The current rhna cycle sixth,

2456
01:14:01,394 --> 01:14:04,764
we were -- sorry, we were

2457
01:14:04,764 --> 01:14:05,298
tasked with our

2458
01:14:05,298 --> 01:14:07,298
responsibility

2459
01:14:10,570 --> 01:14:12,605
of 3956 units over the 8 year

2460
01:14:12,605 --> 01:14:14,605
period.

2461
01:14:14,974 --> 01:14:15,442
The rhna allocation is

2462
01:14:15,442 --> 01:14:17,442
further

2463
01:14:18,878 --> 01:14:20,980
divided into income levels.

2464
01:14:20,980 --> 01:14:22,516
There are four category, very

2465
01:14:22,516 --> 01:14:23,750
low, low, mod wrath rat and

2466
01:14:23,750 --> 01:14:24,718
above moderate.

2467
01:14:24,718 --> 01:14:27,118
These income categories are

2468
01:14:27,220 --> 01:14:29,756
based on the area median

2469
01:14:29,756 --> 01:14:33,660
income that is set by hcd for

2470
01:14:33,660 --> 01:14:35,660
each county.

2471
01:14:36,229 --> 01:14:39,229
The 2024ami for san mateo

2472
01:14:39,666 --> 01:14:40,567
county is 186 thousand 600

2473
01:14:40,567 --> 01:14:42,567
dollars.

2474
01:14:44,238 --> 01:14:46,638
Very low category is

2475
01:14:48,408 --> 01:14:51,408
30-50%ami, low is between

2476
01:14:52,879 --> 01:14:54,181
50-80%ami, moderate falls

2477
01:14:54,181 --> 01:14:56,283
between 80-120%ami and above

2478
01:14:56,283 --> 01:14:58,683
moderate is more tan 100%

2479
01:14:59,219 --> 01:15:02,819
ami, so you can see the

2480
01:15:02,923 --> 01:15:04,992
allotment for the total rhna

2481
01:15:04,992 --> 01:15:07,392
numbers of 3956, the majority

2482
01:15:07,528 --> 01:15:11,128
of which are uder the above

2483
01:15:14,235 --> 01:15:15,869
moderate category.

2484
01:15:15,869 --> 01:15:16,904
For 2024, the city is

2485
01:15:16,904 --> 01:15:18,904
reporting building permit

2486
01:15:20,700 --> 01:15:20,341
issuance for a total of 62

2487
01:15:20,341 --> 01:15:21,842
new

2488
01:15:21,842 --> 01:15:23,842
residential units.

2489
01:15:24,844 --> 01:15:26,480
This includes 6 sing m family

2490
01:15:26,480 --> 01:15:28,480
homes, 6 small multifamily

2491
01:15:29,483 --> 01:15:32,483
units which are units located

2492
01:15:32,786 --> 01:15:33,988
within 2-4 unit structures,

2493
01:15:33,988 --> 01:15:35,988
and 50adu's.

2494
01:15:36,791 --> 01:15:37,691
Again, new units that receive

2495
01:15:37,691 --> 01:15:39,691
building permit issuance

2496
01:15:40,662 --> 01:15:42,963
during the reported year are

2497
01:15:42,963 --> 01:15:44,399
what is counted towards the

2498
01:15:44,399 --> 01:15:46,399
current rhna allocation.

2499
01:15:47,268 --> 01:15:50,471
In addition to the new units

2500
01:15:50,471 --> 01:15:51,873
issued, a tet of 255 new

2501
01:15:51,873 --> 01:15:52,807
residential units were

2502
01:15:52,807 --> 01:15:55,109
finagled or received a

2503
01:15:55,109 --> 01:15:57,509
certificate of occupancy in

2504
01:15:59,781 --> 01:16:01,781
the 2024 reporting year.

2505
01:16:01,882 --> 01:16:02,584
The city also approved

2506
01:16:02,584 --> 01:16:02,951
planning entitlements for

2507
01:16:02,951 --> 01:16:03,718
five

2508
01:16:03,718 --> 01:16:04,953
new residential units during

2509
01:16:04,953 --> 01:16:06,953
the reporting year.

2510
01:16:08,690 --> 01:16:11,292
And the detailers for the

2511
01:16:11,292 --> 01:16:12,894
building permit issuance and

2512
01:16:12,894 --> 01:16:14,894
entitlements approved and

2513
01:16:15,230 --> 01:16:16,631
certificate of compliance

2514
01:16:16,631 --> 01:16:18,700
completion are found in

2515
01:16:18,700 --> 01:16:21,100
attachment 3 and 4 of the

2516
01:16:25,273 --> 01:16:26,874
staff report under table a-2.

2517
01:16:26,874 --> 01:16:27,576
So, this is the second year

2518
01:16:27,576 --> 01:16:29,576
of

2519
01:16:32,581 --> 01:16:33,148
the rhna cycle 6 eighty year

2520
01:16:33,148 --> 01:16:33,648
reporting cycle,

2521
01:16:33,648 --> 01:16:34,583
cumulatively,

2522
01:16:34,583 --> 01:16:37,452
the city is dewed building

2523
01:16:37,452 --> 01:16:38,620
perms for a total of 4.5% of

2524
01:16:38,620 --> 01:16:41,620
the expected housing units so

2525
01:16:41,989 --> 01:16:44,989
that's a total of 177 units

2526
01:16:46,280 --> 01:16:49,280
out of the 3956 units that

2527
01:16:50,332 --> 01:16:52,732
were allocated through rhna.

2528
01:16:53,735 --> 01:16:55,470
This is broken down into the

2529
01:16:55,470 --> 01:16:57,470
four income categories.

2530
01:16:57,539 --> 01:16:59,408
The city for above moderate

2531
01:16:59,408 --> 01:17:01,310
housing category, the city

2532
01:17:01,310 --> 01:17:01,743
issued building permits for

2533
01:17:01,743 --> 01:17:03,743
36

2534
01:17:04,279 --> 01:17:05,140
units or 1.9% of the rhna

2535
01:17:05,140 --> 01:17:06,181
allocation.

2536
01:17:06,181 --> 01:17:06,849
Moderate housing category,

2537
01:17:06,849 --> 01:17:08,500
the

2538
01:17:08,500 --> 01:17:08,450
city's issued building

2539
01:17:08,450 --> 01:17:10,450
permits

2540
01:17:11,987 --> 01:17:12,454
for 46 units or 6.4% of the

2541
01:17:12,454 --> 01:17:13,855
allocation.

2542
01:17:13,855 --> 01:17:15,924
For the low housing category,

2543
01:17:15,924 --> 01:17:16,357
the city has issued a

2544
01:17:16,357 --> 01:17:18,357
building

2545
01:17:20,295 --> 01:17:22,198
permit for 68 units or 13.5%

2546
01:17:22,198 --> 01:17:24,266
of the rhna allocation, the

2547
01:17:24,266 --> 01:17:25,667
very low housing category t

2548
01:17:25,667 --> 01:17:28,204
city has issued a building

2549
01:17:28,204 --> 01:17:28,704
permit for 27 units or 3.1%

2550
01:17:28,704 --> 01:17:30,704
of

2551
01:17:33,909 --> 01:17:35,344
the rhna allocation.

2552
01:17:35,344 --> 01:17:37,744
Thsz for the 2023 reporting

2553
01:17:38,281 --> 01:17:40,681
year ad then the 2024

2554
01:17:42,151 --> 01:17:43,986
reporting year, cumulatively.

2555
01:17:43,986 --> 01:17:45,188
In addition to reporting

2556
01:17:45,188 --> 01:17:47,588
housing production to date

2557
01:17:49,358 --> 01:17:51,427
during the reporting year, we

2558
01:17:51,427 --> 01:17:53,329
also provide information on

2559
01:17:53,329 --> 01:17:54,496
our program implementation

2560
01:17:54,496 --> 01:17:56,232
status, as mentioned, a large

2561
01:17:56,232 --> 01:17:58,632
component of the city's

2562
01:17:59,234 --> 01:18:01,700
housing element are goals,

2563
01:18:01,700 --> 01:18:01,971
policies and products that

2564
01:18:01,971 --> 01:18:03,372
direct decision making, most

2565
01:18:03,372 --> 01:18:05,508
of these programs are

2566
01:18:05,508 --> 01:18:06,676
implemented and monitored on

2567
01:18:06,676 --> 01:18:07,143
an ongoing basis, however

2568
01:18:07,143 --> 01:18:08,770
some

2569
01:18:08,770 --> 01:18:09,612
programs have deliverable

2570
01:18:09,612 --> 01:18:12,120
dates throughout the housing

2571
01:18:14,116 --> 01:18:16,116
element cycle.

2572
01:18:16,953 --> 01:18:18,421
For the 2024 reporting year,

2573
01:18:18,421 --> 01:18:20,230
7

2574
01:18:20,230 --> 01:18:20,890
programs were completed.

2575
01:18:20,890 --> 01:18:22,559
These were all completed

2576
01:18:22,559 --> 01:18:24,394
through the adoption of a

2577
01:18:24,394 --> 01:18:24,728
zoning text amendment that

2578
01:18:24,728 --> 01:18:26,396
the

2579
01:18:26,396 --> 01:18:28,364
council approved and adopted

2580
01:18:28,364 --> 01:18:30,364
last JUNE.

2581
01:18:30,700 --> 01:18:31,668
The zoning text amendment

2582
01:18:31,668 --> 01:18:33,668
included amended definitions

2583
01:18:34,637 --> 01:18:35,539
of certain uses such as

2584
01:18:35,539 --> 01:18:36,500
emergency shelter, addition

2585
01:18:36,500 --> 01:18:38,500
of

2586
01:18:38,774 --> 01:18:39,876
some new use classifications

2587
01:18:39,876 --> 01:18:41,377
including low barrier

2588
01:18:41,377 --> 01:18:42,145
navigation center and

2589
01:18:42,145 --> 01:18:44,145
permanent supportive housing

2590
01:18:46,383 --> 01:18:47,751
as well as updates to the

2591
01:18:47,751 --> 01:18:48,918
development uses allowed

2592
01:18:48,918 --> 01:18:50,918
within different zoning

2593
01:18:53,790 --> 01:18:55,626
districts per state mandate.

2594
01:18:55,626 --> 01:18:56,125
And that concludes staff's

2595
01:18:56,125 --> 01:18:57,260
presentation.

2596
01:18:57,260 --> 01:18:58,695
Both myself and billy are

2597
01:18:58,695 --> 01:18:59,830
available for any questions.

2598
01:18:59,830 --> 01:19:00,197
>> thank you, stephanie,

2599
01:19:00,197 --> 01:19:01,964
thank

2600
01:19:01,964 --> 01:19:03,600
you, billy.

2601
01:19:03,600 --> 01:19:04,670
I'll take questions from my

2602
01:19:04,670 --> 01:19:06,670
colleagues.

2603
01:19:06,669 --> 01:19:08,505
I have

2604
01:19:08,505 --> 01:19:09,673
>> I have a lot of questions

2605
01:19:09,673 --> 01:19:11,774
so I should probably go first

2606
01:19:11,774 --> 01:19:12,443
which is not a surprise to my

2607
01:19:12,443 --> 01:19:14,443
colleagues.

2608
01:19:16,880 --> 01:19:19,850
I'm going the help set up the

2609
01:19:19,850 --> 01:19:21,252
questions, so I think we have

2610
01:19:21,252 --> 01:19:23,387
to kind of paint the picture

2611
01:19:23,387 --> 01:19:25,220
here in terms of help

2612
01:19:25,220 --> 01:19:27,422
explaining the rhna process.

2613
01:19:27,558 --> 01:19:29,426
So, if we do a good faith

2614
01:19:29,426 --> 01:19:32,429
effort in trying to reach our

2615
01:19:32,429 --> 01:19:35,699
rhna goals and we don't hit

2616
01:19:35,699 --> 01:19:37,934
those numbers, what are the

2617
01:19:37,934 --> 01:19:38,603
ramifications of us not doing

2618
01:19:38,603 --> 01:19:40,603
that?

2619
01:19:40,638 --> 01:19:42,638
>> great question.

2620
01:19:43,574 --> 01:19:45,209
So, technically there is no

2621
01:19:45,209 --> 01:19:48,209
penalty for not meeting the

2622
01:19:48,479 --> 01:19:51,448
rhna numbers but there are

2623
01:19:51,448 --> 01:19:52,383
certain provisions sb35 that

2624
01:19:52,383 --> 01:19:54,383
MAY take effect.

2625
01:19:54,484 --> 01:19:54,819
If a certain percentage of

2626
01:19:54,819 --> 01:19:56,819
our

2627
01:19:58,223 --> 01:20:00,291
rhna allocation is not met,

2628
01:20:00,291 --> 01:20:02,360
midway through the reporting

2629
01:20:02,360 --> 01:20:04,429
or the rhna cycle.

2630
01:20:04,429 --> 01:20:04,762
And those would include --

2631
01:20:04,762 --> 01:20:06,762
and

2632
01:20:07,131 --> 01:20:07,899
I MAY call up tony rozzi for

2633
01:20:07,899 --> 01:20:09,899
help here.

2634
01:20:11,135 --> 01:20:14,135
But I believe they include

2635
01:20:15,807 --> 01:20:17,174
changing the process of

2636
01:20:17,174 --> 01:20:17,876
residential development

2637
01:20:17,876 --> 01:20:19,777
review

2638
01:20:19,777 --> 01:20:21,179
from discretionary to

2639
01:20:21,179 --> 01:20:23,148
ministerial if a certain

2640
01:20:23,148 --> 01:20:23,481
amount of affordable units

2641
01:20:23,481 --> 01:20:25,481
are

2642
01:20:25,750 --> 01:20:26,684
included in the overall

2643
01:20:26,684 --> 01:20:27,152
proposed residential

2644
01:20:27,152 --> 01:20:28,586
development.

2645
01:20:28,586 --> 01:20:30,221
>> so, in other words, if we

2646
01:20:30,221 --> 01:20:32,791
don't hit our numbers, a

2647
01:20:32,791 --> 01:20:34,192
developer can come in and

2648
01:20:34,192 --> 01:20:37,192
pretty much submit a project

2649
01:20:37,429 --> 01:20:38,797
and we would have to approve

2650
01:20:38,797 --> 01:20:40,799
it administrative, tony, do

2651
01:20:40,799 --> 01:20:43,401
you want to -- I really want

2652
01:20:43,401 --> 01:20:43,868
to be able to -- we

2653
01:20:43,868 --> 01:20:44,569
understand

2654
01:20:44,569 --> 01:20:45,360
these terms but I want to

2655
01:20:45,360 --> 01:20:47,360
make

2656
01:20:47,806 --> 01:20:48,173
sure the audience understands

2657
01:20:48,173 --> 01:20:50,740
this.

2658
01:20:50,740 --> 01:20:52,740
>> yeah.

2659
01:20:52,377 --> 01:20:52,911
Tony rozzi, deputy director

2660
01:20:52,911 --> 01:20:53,244
in

2661
01:20:53,244 --> 01:20:55,244
ecd.

2662
01:20:55,247 --> 01:20:56,314
I'm going to pull up this

2663
01:20:56,314 --> 01:20:57,816
slide because ithink it's

2664
01:20:57,816 --> 01:20:59,418
probably the best way to talk

2665
01:20:59,418 --> 01:21:01,418
through this.

2666
01:21:02,620 --> 01:21:03,722
And sb35 is not new, it

2667
01:21:03,722 --> 01:21:04,890
applied to us in the last

2668
01:21:04,890 --> 01:21:06,240
cycle.

2669
01:21:06,240 --> 01:21:07,893
At the end of year four,

2670
01:21:07,893 --> 01:21:08,293
midway through the rhna

2671
01:21:08,293 --> 01:21:10,196
cycle,

2672
01:21:10,196 --> 01:21:13,196
that 8 year period, they want

2673
01:21:13,264 --> 01:21:13,599
to know that you're on track

2674
01:21:13,599 --> 01:21:14,767
--

2675
01:21:14,767 --> 01:21:17,669
>> hang on, she can't hear

2676
01:21:17,669 --> 01:21:19,669
you.

2677
01:21:25,144 --> 01:21:26,779
>> sb35 applies and really

2678
01:21:26,779 --> 01:21:29,470
holds cities accountable for

2679
01:21:29,470 --> 01:21:31,784
how they're doing as far as

2680
01:21:31,784 --> 01:21:34,553
progress on their rhna cycle.

2681
01:21:34,553 --> 01:21:37,523
After year 4, w report back,

2682
01:21:37,523 --> 01:21:39,124
you know, have you met 50% of

2683
01:21:39,124 --> 01:21:39,492
your expected above moderate

2684
01:21:39,492 --> 01:21:41,260
units.

2685
01:21:41,260 --> 01:21:44,496
So, in this case, we have a

2686
01:21:44,496 --> 01:21:46,132
lot of above moderate units

2687
01:21:46,132 --> 01:21:47,650
assigned, almost over 1800,

2688
01:21:47,650 --> 01:21:49,650
so

2689
01:21:51,569 --> 01:21:54,600
we would want to see at least

2690
01:21:54,600 --> 01:21:56,342
900 units permitted by the

2691
01:21:56,342 --> 01:21:57,377
fifth year in our rhna cycle.

2692
01:21:57,377 --> 01:21:58,444
Separately, they want to know

2693
01:21:58,444 --> 01:22:00,847
how are you doing with your

2694
01:22:00,847 --> 01:22:02,849
low and very low units, so

2695
01:22:02,849 --> 01:22:04,917
that will be our very low and

2696
01:22:04,917 --> 01:22:07,317
our low, that's almost 1400

2697
01:22:07,787 --> 01:22:08,121
units so half of that would

2698
01:22:08,121 --> 01:22:09,422
be

2699
01:22:09,422 --> 01:22:09,755
700 units half way through

2700
01:22:09,755 --> 01:22:11,624
the

2701
01:22:11,624 --> 01:22:13,225
rhna cycle.

2702
01:22:13,225 --> 01:22:13,693
If you are on track and

2703
01:22:13,693 --> 01:22:15,693
you've

2704
01:22:16,896 --> 01:22:19,432
met both of those numbers,

2705
01:22:19,432 --> 01:22:21,432
sb35 doesn't apply.

2706
01:22:21,734 --> 01:22:23,368
It is not out of the question

2707
01:22:23,368 --> 01:22:25,672
that we might have a stronger

2708
01:22:25,672 --> 01:22:28,674
next cuple of years but it

2709
01:22:28,674 --> 01:22:30,276
really depends on the market,

2710
01:22:30,276 --> 01:22:32,112
tariffs, interest rates, all

2711
01:22:32,112 --> 01:22:32,512
of those things affect

2712
01:22:32,512 --> 01:22:33,513
whether

2713
01:22:33,513 --> 01:22:35,849
a developer pulls a permit or

2714
01:22:35,849 --> 01:22:37,717
not but that culd be a

2715
01:22:37,717 --> 01:22:38,686
trigger for sb35, like

2716
01:22:38,686 --> 01:22:41,860
stephanie said, allows a

2717
01:22:42,522 --> 01:22:44,758
project to be proposed that

2718
01:22:44,758 --> 01:22:46,760
has no discretionary review,

2719
01:22:46,760 --> 01:22:47,627
no ceqa, they do have to use

2720
01:22:47,627 --> 01:22:49,728
prevailing wage and they do

2721
01:22:49,728 --> 01:22:52,128
have to provide affordable

2722
01:22:54,701 --> 01:22:56,937
units, so it's not a free --

2723
01:22:56,937 --> 01:22:57,637
freebie for a developer but

2724
01:22:57,637 --> 01:22:58,738
it

2725
01:22:58,738 --> 01:22:59,706
limits a developer's

2726
01:22:59,706 --> 01:23:00,874
discretionary review.

2727
01:23:00,874 --> 01:23:02,709
Does that make sense?

2728
01:23:02,709 --> 01:23:03,430
>> yeah, that makes sense to

2729
01:23:03,430 --> 01:23:05,430
me.

2730
01:23:05,445 --> 01:23:05,979
So, let me dig a little

2731
01:23:05,979 --> 01:23:06,413
deeper

2732
01:23:06,413 --> 01:23:08,413
here.

2733
01:23:15,154 --> 01:23:16,790
So, when you say city report

2734
01:23:16,790 --> 01:23:17,157
building permits, you say

2735
01:23:17,157 --> 01:23:17,924
city

2736
01:23:17,924 --> 01:23:20,324
reported building permit and

2737
01:23:21,929 --> 01:23:23,764
is then you say planning

2738
01:23:23,764 --> 01:23:24,231
entitlements and I don't

2739
01:23:24,231 --> 01:23:26,231
think

2740
01:23:28,102 --> 01:23:28,468
the audience understands that

2741
01:23:28,468 --> 01:23:30,700
here.

2742
01:23:30,700 --> 01:23:31,371
For 62 residential units,

2743
01:23:31,371 --> 01:23:31,705
those are the numbers that

2744
01:23:31,705 --> 01:23:33,273
are

2745
01:23:33,273 --> 01:23:33,674
counted towards our rhna

2746
01:23:33,674 --> 01:23:35,674
numbers.

2747
01:23:35,808 --> 01:23:37,444
But when you say planning

2748
01:23:37,444 --> 01:23:39,444
entitlements, those numbers

2749
01:23:39,680 --> 01:23:41,820
are different.

2750
01:23:41,820 --> 01:23:42,383
Can yu briefly explain the

2751
01:23:42,383 --> 01:23:44,783
difference between those two.

2752
01:23:46,220 --> 01:23:46,754
>> yeah, I can and they can

2753
01:23:46,754 --> 01:23:48,754
--

2754
01:23:49,523 --> 01:23:50,690
in the life cycle o a

2755
01:23:50,690 --> 01:23:51,580
project, entitlements are

2756
01:23:51,580 --> 01:23:52,760
your

2757
01:23:52,760 --> 01:23:53,694
first stage, you go through

2758
01:23:53,694 --> 01:23:55,295
the planning commission,

2759
01:23:55,295 --> 01:23:56,998
perhaps city council and you

2760
01:23:56,998 --> 01:23:59,660
get entitled for the ability

2761
01:23:59,660 --> 01:24:01,168
to now build those units and

2762
01:24:01,168 --> 01:24:02,103
you've met your ceqa

2763
01:24:02,103 --> 01:24:04,503
obligations, you've met our

2764
01:24:04,638 --> 01:24:05,106
design standards and we have

2765
01:24:05,106 --> 01:24:06,174
a

2766
01:24:06,174 --> 01:24:08,574
very streamlined process for

2767
01:24:10,244 --> 01:24:11,412
these projects.

2768
01:24:11,412 --> 01:24:13,180
That's entitlement, now you

2769
01:24:13,180 --> 01:24:13,914
take those pretty

2770
01:24:13,914 --> 01:24:14,415
architectural drawings and

2771
01:24:14,415 --> 01:24:15,550
you

2772
01:24:15,550 --> 01:24:17,151
turn them into construction

2773
01:24:17,151 --> 01:24:20,151
drawings and that could take

2774
01:24:21,422 --> 01:24:22,991
as quick as 3-6 months, 18

2775
01:24:22,991 --> 01:24:24,158
months, you have up to three

2776
01:24:24,158 --> 01:24:24,491
years from your entitlement

2777
01:24:24,491 --> 01:24:26,227
to

2778
01:24:26,227 --> 01:24:26,628
get submitted for a building

2779
01:24:26,628 --> 01:24:28,290
permit.

2780
01:24:28,290 --> 01:24:28,463
Then you submit for a

2781
01:24:28,463 --> 01:24:29,530
building

2782
01:24:29,530 --> 01:24:31,165
permit, you go back and forth

2783
01:24:31,165 --> 01:24:32,467
with our plan check review,

2784
01:24:32,467 --> 01:24:34,536
with fire review, with

2785
01:24:34,536 --> 01:24:36,536
planning review.

2786
01:24:37,104 --> 01:24:39,274
When we issue that building

2787
01:24:39,274 --> 01:24:42,210
permit n that whatever year

2788
01:24:42,210 --> 01:24:44,812
that is which might be three

2789
01:24:44,812 --> 01:24:46,214
years after they're entitled,

2790
01:24:46,214 --> 01:24:47,782
we finally get credit in rhna.

2791
01:24:47,782 --> 01:24:49,718
Now the state wants us to

2792
01:24:49,718 --> 01:24:51,586
report, how did you do on

2793
01:24:51,586 --> 01:24:53,355
entitlements, do we we no if

2794
01:24:53,355 --> 01:24:55,290
you have stuff on the

2795
01:24:55,290 --> 01:24:56,758
pipeline, how are you doing

2796
01:24:56,758 --> 01:24:58,560
with issuing permits and now

2797
01:24:58,560 --> 01:25:00,194
can you tell us if you have

2798
01:25:00,194 --> 01:25:01,496
finagled those projects, are

2799
01:25:01,496 --> 01:25:04,650
they now down and people

2800
01:25:04,650 --> 01:25:04,499
living in them so that's the

2801
01:25:04,499 --> 01:25:06,368
reporting.

2802
01:25:06,368 --> 01:25:06,802
>> thank you for that

2803
01:25:06,802 --> 01:25:08,236
overview.

2804
01:25:08,236 --> 01:25:10,739
Here's what I'm looking at

2805
01:25:10,739 --> 01:25:12,741
these numbers, and tony, I

2806
01:25:12,741 --> 01:25:13,141
appreciate like the midway

2807
01:25:13,141 --> 01:25:13,775
report.

2808
01:25:13,775 --> 01:25:14,420
I don't know if yes

2809
01:25:14,420 --> 01:25:14,376
f wez

2810
01:25:14,376 --> 01:25:16,144
ear

2811
01:25:16,144 --> 01:25:17,790
going the hit that based on

2812
01:25:17,790 --> 01:25:19,514
what you're seeing right now.

2813
01:25:19,514 --> 01:25:19,914
That is the concern I'm

2814
01:25:19,914 --> 01:25:21,383
having.

2815
01:25:21,383 --> 01:25:22,518
And so did you want to jump

2816
01:25:22,518 --> 01:25:24,518
in?

2817
01:25:25,587 --> 01:25:26,788
>> I share your concern.

2818
01:25:26,788 --> 01:25:28,357
I will say tere are some

2819
01:25:28,357 --> 01:25:29,558
project that is are in

2820
01:25:29,558 --> 01:25:31,958
building permit review ready

2821
01:25:32,194 --> 01:25:35,794
to be issued that would tick

2822
01:25:35,864 --> 01:25:37,700
off our low and very low

2823
01:25:37,700 --> 01:25:39,768
inclusionary and very many

2824
01:25:39,768 --> 01:25:40,936
above moderate but it doesn't

2825
01:25:40,936 --> 01:25:42,936
feel super promising.

2826
01:25:44,406 --> 01:25:45,574
>> I'm looking behind me as

2827
01:25:45,574 --> 01:25:47,800
the puc projects that would

2828
01:25:47,800 --> 01:25:47,676
ramp up our numbers, right.

2829
01:25:47,676 --> 01:25:48,900
>> right.

2830
01:25:48,900 --> 01:25:50,900
Er

2831
01:25:51,146 --> 01:25:51,514
>> so, let me dig deeper,

2832
01:25:51,514 --> 01:25:53,382
when

2833
01:25:53,382 --> 01:25:54,617
I was looking at the

2834
01:25:54,617 --> 01:25:56,180
spreadsheet here, there were

2835
01:25:56,180 --> 01:25:58,860
some akronbacker ron anymore

2836
01:25:58,860 --> 01:26:01,686
which is lu, which means land

2837
01:26:02,324 --> 01:26:05,610
use, and it says 3.9 in terms

2838
01:26:05,610 --> 01:26:06,695
of the spreadsheet, that felt

2839
01:26:06,695 --> 01:26:07,430
with crating affordable and

2840
01:26:07,430 --> 01:26:09,699
workforce housing, I went

2841
01:26:09,699 --> 01:26:10,166
through all the data points

2842
01:26:10,166 --> 01:26:12,166
here.

2843
01:26:12,567 --> 01:26:14,102
They were talking about

2844
01:26:14,102 --> 01:26:15,537
working with the --

2845
01:26:15,537 --> 01:26:17,707
potentially working with the

2846
01:26:17,707 --> 01:26:18,141
school district about

2847
01:26:18,141 --> 01:26:19,275
building

2848
01:26:19,275 --> 01:26:19,575
affordable housing sites and

2849
01:26:19,575 --> 01:26:20,643
I

2850
01:26:20,643 --> 01:26:21,644
know the school district's

2851
01:26:21,644 --> 01:26:25,244
been looking at this and I

2852
01:26:25,448 --> 01:26:26,615
know we do have the city

2853
01:26:26,615 --> 01:26:28,615
council's sdaol district

2854
01:26:28,684 --> 01:26:30,520
liaison committee and I know

2855
01:26:30,520 --> 01:26:31,521
it's o one of the priorities

2856
01:26:31,521 --> 01:26:33,590
in turnover the school

2857
01:26:33,590 --> 01:26:36,910
district but they do have

2858
01:26:36,910 --> 01:26:37,460
sites in terms of fox ridge

2859
01:26:37,460 --> 01:26:39,362
and sarah vista that

2860
01:26:39,362 --> 01:26:41,130
potentially could be housing

2861
01:26:41,130 --> 01:26:43,299
sites, so I'm looking at my

2862
01:26:43,299 --> 01:26:44,900
colleagues who serve on tat

2863
01:26:44,900 --> 01:26:46,302
subcommittee to really see

2864
01:26:46,302 --> 01:26:47,737
what the school district's

2865
01:26:47,737 --> 01:26:49,439
plan on that is and I know

2866
01:26:49,439 --> 01:26:51,140
again one of the things they

2867
01:26:51,140 --> 01:26:52,542
mentioned and they have to

2868
01:26:52,542 --> 01:26:53,709
look at it but honestly

2869
01:26:53,709 --> 01:26:54,644
they've been saying they

2870
01:26:54,644 --> 01:26:56,279
support some sort of

2871
01:26:56,279 --> 01:26:58,648
development there but they're

2872
01:26:58,648 --> 01:27:00,283
dragging their feet.

2873
01:27:00,283 --> 01:27:01,584
And if we're going to build

2874
01:27:01,584 --> 01:27:02,619
affordable housing and

2875
01:27:02,619 --> 01:27:03,887
workforce housing, I want to

2876
01:27:03,887 --> 01:27:04,721
see a partnership with the

2877
01:27:04,721 --> 01:27:05,154
school district so I'm

2878
01:27:05,154 --> 01:27:06,122
looking

2879
01:27:06,122 --> 01:27:06,590
at my colleagues over there

2880
01:27:06,590 --> 01:27:07,957
in

2881
01:27:07,957 --> 01:27:08,358
termser of moving that

2882
01:27:08,358 --> 01:27:10,358
forward

2883
01:27:10,427 --> 01:27:11,894
and I think jefferson high

2884
01:27:11,894 --> 01:27:13,530
school district is a perfect

2885
01:27:13,530 --> 01:27:13,897
example of how you build

2886
01:27:13,897 --> 01:27:15,897
those

2887
01:27:16,132 --> 01:27:17,534
unit, it's such a successful

2888
01:27:17,534 --> 01:27:18,702
model that other school

2889
01:27:18,702 --> 01:27:20,804
districts ares following that

2890
01:27:20,804 --> 01:27:21,972
model, it's a nationally

2891
01:27:21,972 --> 01:27:22,306
recognized program in terms

2892
01:27:22,306 --> 01:27:23,140
of

2893
01:27:23,140 --> 01:27:24,541
what they're doing so I want

2894
01:27:24,541 --> 01:27:26,909
to lesh from them in terms of

2895
01:27:26,909 --> 01:27:27,277
what we can do forward.

2896
01:27:27,277 --> 01:27:29,277
Okay.

2897
01:27:29,913 --> 01:27:30,581
There was another one here,

2898
01:27:30,581 --> 01:27:32,581
it

2899
01:27:33,784 --> 01:27:35,485
says land use 2.1 which is

2900
01:27:35,485 --> 01:27:35,886
prioritized development near

2901
01:27:35,886 --> 01:27:37,886
transit.

2902
01:27:37,987 --> 01:27:39,156
And we during our housing

2903
01:27:39,156 --> 01:27:40,758
element cnversation, we did

2904
01:27:40,758 --> 01:27:42,393
talk about development aong

2905
01:27:42,393 --> 01:27:42,793
the el camino corridor

2906
01:27:42,793 --> 01:27:44,793
because

2907
01:27:44,894 --> 01:27:46,263
we have seen the development

2908
01:27:46,263 --> 01:27:48,198
on the caltrain corridor, but

2909
01:27:48,198 --> 01:27:49,199
this is kind of the next kind

2910
01:27:49,199 --> 01:27:50,767
of section where we have to

2911
01:27:50,767 --> 01:27:52,636
look at in terms of

2912
01:27:52,636 --> 01:27:54,238
development because when you

2913
01:27:54,238 --> 01:27:56,573
build along transit, you get

2914
01:27:56,573 --> 01:27:56,974
people who start using

2915
01:27:56,974 --> 01:27:58,309
transit

2916
01:27:58,309 --> 01:28:00,644
and I know other cities are

2917
01:28:00,644 --> 01:28:02,179
looking along the el camino

2918
01:28:02,179 --> 01:28:03,681
corridor in termer of

2919
01:28:03,681 --> 01:28:05,282
development so as we mover

2920
01:28:05,282 --> 01:28:06,500
forward in terms of

2921
01:28:06,500 --> 01:28:07,450
development, these are going

2922
01:28:07,450 --> 01:28:07,818
to be the sections we're

2923
01:28:07,818 --> 01:28:09,553
going

2924
01:28:09,553 --> 01:28:11,188
to be seeing and you can see

2925
01:28:11,188 --> 01:28:14,788
it now in terms of where

2926
01:28:15,590 --> 01:28:15,426
across from the san bruno

2927
01:28:15,426 --> 01:28:16,694
bart

2928
01:28:16,694 --> 01:28:18,694
station, tere's already

2929
01:28:19,363 --> 01:28:21,763
development and the century

2930
01:28:21,899 --> 01:28:23,300
plaza, that's going to be

2931
01:28:23,300 --> 01:28:23,668
housing, that's along the

2932
01:28:23,668 --> 01:28:25,369
bart

2933
01:28:25,369 --> 01:28:26,137
corridor along the samtrans

2934
01:28:26,137 --> 01:28:27,504
core dhao,'s something we're

2935
01:28:27,504 --> 01:28:28,840
going to be looking at in

2936
01:28:28,840 --> 01:28:30,840
terms of development.

2937
01:28:31,209 --> 01:28:33,578
And there was another thing

2938
01:28:33,578 --> 01:28:36,130
that says crt which I don't

2939
01:28:36,130 --> 01:28:38,182
know what crt stood fr.

2940
01:28:38,182 --> 01:28:40,182
>> creation.

2941
01:28:41,219 --> 01:28:42,754
>> okay, it said 3.1, review

2942
01:28:42,754 --> 01:28:44,889
of cmmercial and housing

2943
01:28:44,889 --> 01:28:46,324
linkage fees.

2944
01:28:46,324 --> 01:28:47,859
So, that was supposed to be

2945
01:28:47,859 --> 01:28:49,930
helping us in terms of

2946
01:28:49,930 --> 01:28:50,494
building development but for

2947
01:28:50,494 --> 01:28:52,330
me, the pipeline is starting

2948
01:28:52,330 --> 01:28:53,731
to slow down and there was a

2949
01:28:53,731 --> 01:28:54,799
initial conversation at or

2950
01:28:54,799 --> 01:28:55,266
housing subcommittee the see

2951
01:28:55,266 --> 01:28:56,301
what with

2952
01:28:56,301 --> 01:28:57,368
f we can do in

2953
01:28:57,368 --> 01:28:59,304
terms of speeding up the

2954
01:28:59,304 --> 01:28:59,638
process and I know waun one

2955
01:28:59,638 --> 01:29:01,638
of

2956
01:29:02,540 --> 01:29:03,308
the things, we did hire a

2957
01:29:03,308 --> 01:29:05,308
strategic economic consultant

2958
01:29:06,440 --> 01:29:06,944
to look at that in terms of

2959
01:29:06,944 --> 01:29:07,345
housing and commercial

2960
01:29:07,345 --> 01:29:07,712
linkage

2961
01:29:07,712 --> 01:29:09,712
fees.

2962
01:29:10,480 --> 01:29:11,416
I look forward to have that

2963
01:29:11,416 --> 01:29:14,416
conversation in terms of what

2964
01:29:14,453 --> 01:29:15,687
we want to d with that

2965
01:29:15,687 --> 01:29:17,687
particular fee.

2966
01:29:19,257 --> 01:29:20,191
So, with that, aisle leave

2967
01:29:20,191 --> 01:29:20,625
that in terms of the

2968
01:29:20,625 --> 01:29:22,227
questions.

2969
01:29:22,227 --> 01:29:22,828
>> thank you, councilmember,

2970
01:29:22,828 --> 01:29:24,329
any other questions?

2971
01:29:24,329 --> 01:29:25,300
>> I do have a question.

2972
01:29:25,300 --> 01:29:25,330
>> go ahead.

2973
01:29:25,330 --> 01:29:26,498
Er

2974
01:29:26,498 --> 01:29:26,864
>> so, how many housing

2975
01:29:26,864 --> 01:29:28,567
units

2976
01:29:28,567 --> 01:29:31,690
are in the pipeline and by

2977
01:29:31,690 --> 01:29:32,471
that, I mean entitled but not

2978
01:29:32,471 --> 01:29:36,710
yet permitted do, we have a

2979
01:29:37,209 --> 01:29:39,609
number that's the total?

2980
01:29:43,348 --> 01:29:45,517
>> so, for the 2024 reporting

2981
01:29:45,517 --> 01:29:45,951
year, five units were

2982
01:29:45,951 --> 01:29:47,951
approved

2983
01:29:48,754 --> 01:29:49,321
in the planning process have

2984
01:29:49,321 --> 01:29:49,822
received approved

2985
01:29:49,822 --> 01:29:51,557
entitlements.

2986
01:29:51,557 --> 01:29:54,590
We do have approved projects

2987
01:29:54,590 --> 01:29:56,459
from the previous years

2988
01:29:59,970 --> 01:30:01,970
including 7 south linden, 410

2989
01:30:01,167 --> 01:30:03,567
noor, 1477 huntington, all of

2990
01:30:07,473 --> 01:30:08,641
those have not pulled a

2991
01:30:08,641 --> 01:30:10,275
building permit yet, a couple

2992
01:30:10,275 --> 01:30:12,344
of them are on track to

2993
01:30:12,344 --> 01:30:13,312
possibly get their building

2994
01:30:13,312 --> 01:30:15,381
permits issued this next year

2995
01:30:15,381 --> 01:30:17,383
or during this year so we

2996
01:30:17,383 --> 01:30:17,750
would include them in the

2997
01:30:17,750 --> 01:30:18,818
2025

2998
01:30:18,818 --> 01:30:20,553
reporting and that's when we

2999
01:30:20,553 --> 01:30:21,187
would get the credit towards

3000
01:30:21,187 --> 01:30:23,187
rhna.

3001
01:30:24,690 --> 01:30:27,560
>> what's the number of those

3002
01:30:27,560 --> 01:30:28,961
units?

3003
01:30:28,961 --> 01:30:30,663
>> roughly 1500 units.

3004
01:30:30,663 --> 01:30:32,663
>> thank you.

3005
01:30:33,166 --> 01:30:35,734
And then I know the rate

3006
01:30:35,734 --> 01:30:36,669
limiting factor is mostly the

3007
01:30:36,669 --> 01:30:38,871
financing markets, so to the

3008
01:30:38,871 --> 01:30:39,872
best of your ability, if you

3009
01:30:39,872 --> 01:30:41,506
can characterize where we are

3010
01:30:41,506 --> 01:30:44,777
many the market right now, do

3011
01:30:44,777 --> 01:30:47,646
you see it improving, not

3012
01:30:47,646 --> 01:30:49,482
improving?

3013
01:30:49,482 --> 01:30:50,183
>> nell selander, economic

3014
01:30:50,183 --> 01:30:50,917
and

3015
01:30:50,917 --> 01:30:52,840
community development

3016
01:30:52,840 --> 01:30:54,484
director, what we're hearing

3017
01:30:56,989 --> 01:30:57,624
right now from some of the

3018
01:30:57,624 --> 01:30:58,560
larger developmental

3019
01:30:58,560 --> 01:30:59,759
directors

3020
01:30:59,759 --> 01:31:00,193
who are pulling their

3021
01:31:00,193 --> 01:31:02,193
building

3022
01:31:02,762 --> 01:31:04,631
permit and is sites now but

3023
01:31:04,631 --> 01:31:05,565
not yet pulled a building

3024
01:31:05,565 --> 01:31:07,166
permit for vertical

3025
01:31:07,166 --> 01:31:09,166
construction, it's not

3026
01:31:10,503 --> 01:31:12,903
interest rates, it's the

3027
01:31:14,107 --> 01:31:16,176
expected tariff wars and in

3028
01:31:16,176 --> 01:31:18,110
particular wood from canada,

3029
01:31:18,110 --> 01:31:19,879
so we even hve a project

3030
01:31:19,879 --> 01:31:21,130
that's not about to pull a

3031
01:31:21,130 --> 01:31:21,481
building permit but is doipg

3032
01:31:21,481 --> 01:31:23,830
a

3033
01:31:23,830 --> 01:31:26,830
lot of cost estimating and

3034
01:31:26,420 --> 01:31:28,488
that was contemplated as two

3035
01:31:28,488 --> 01:31:30,123
floors of concrete, so two

3036
01:31:30,123 --> 01:31:31,692
podium floors with four to

3037
01:31:31,692 --> 01:31:33,930
five stories of wood frame

3038
01:31:33,930 --> 01:31:33,994
construction above it and

3039
01:31:33,994 --> 01:31:35,994
they're now considering

3040
01:31:37,331 --> 01:31:38,698
pricing the whole building in

3041
01:31:38,698 --> 01:31:41,980
concrete because -- which

3042
01:31:41,501 --> 01:31:42,935
would be unheard of, three or

3043
01:31:42,935 --> 01:31:45,935
four or five years ago,

3044
01:31:46,673 --> 01:31:48,740
because of the volatility in

3045
01:31:48,740 --> 01:31:50,770
the timber markets because so

3046
01:31:50,770 --> 01:31:52,445
much of it comes from canada

3047
01:31:52,445 --> 01:31:54,748
and also because of fire

3048
01:31:54,748 --> 01:31:56,500
insurance and fire risk,

3049
01:31:56,500 --> 01:31:57,518
concrete buildings are less

3050
01:31:57,518 --> 01:32:00,120
risky in a a fire.

3051
01:32:00,120 --> 01:32:00,521
So, we MAY end up with

3052
01:32:00,521 --> 01:32:01,889
totally

3053
01:32:01,889 --> 01:32:04,289
different types of buildings

3054
01:32:04,558 --> 01:32:06,961
getting built in this sort of

3055
01:32:06,961 --> 01:32:08,863
economic cycle with the way

3056
01:32:08,863 --> 01:32:10,397
tariffs are and fire risk.

3057
01:32:10,397 --> 01:32:12,320
>> thank you, that's vry

3058
01:32:12,320 --> 01:32:13,200
interesting information.

3059
01:32:13,200 --> 01:32:15,200
>> thank you.

3060
01:32:15,369 --> 01:32:17,369
Any other questions?

3061
01:32:18,805 --> 01:32:20,908
>> there's one bright spot in

3062
01:32:20,908 --> 01:32:22,510
this, this table a, the

3063
01:32:22,510 --> 01:32:23,210
housing development

3064
01:32:23,210 --> 01:32:23,611
application submitted,

3065
01:32:23,611 --> 01:32:24,612
there's

3066
01:32:24,612 --> 01:32:26,914
four different projects and

3067
01:32:26,914 --> 01:32:30,651
what I noticed was that in a

3068
01:32:30,651 --> 01:32:33,521
couple of them are mid size,

3069
01:32:33,521 --> 01:32:36,290
one is 64 units, one is 70,

3070
01:32:36,290 --> 01:32:38,250
and those are all to be owner

3071
01:32:38,250 --> 01:32:40,194
occupied, is that correct?

3072
01:32:40,194 --> 01:32:40,661
So that would be 500

3073
01:32:40,661 --> 01:32:41,595
railroad,

3074
01:32:41,595 --> 01:32:43,595
the gateway project?

3075
01:32:44,565 --> 01:32:46,565
>> yes, the railroad

3076
01:32:46,834 --> 01:32:47,534
townhomes, and there's

3077
01:32:47,534 --> 01:32:49,534
another

3078
01:32:50,704 --> 01:32:52,704
project, 170, 180 south

3079
01:32:54,208 --> 01:32:54,775
spruce, approximately 64, 65

3080
01:32:54,775 --> 01:32:55,944
row houses.

3081
01:32:55,944 --> 01:32:57,779
>> I understand that's

3082
01:32:57,779 --> 01:32:59,181
happening in the south bay

3083
01:32:59,181 --> 01:33:00,782
where some developers are

3084
01:33:00,782 --> 01:33:02,183
looking at previously

3085
01:33:02,183 --> 01:33:03,318
approved

3086
01:33:03,318 --> 01:33:04,919
entitlements for multifamily

3087
01:33:04,919 --> 01:33:07,919
with greater height but it

3088
01:33:08,223 --> 01:33:08,690
looks like there might be

3089
01:33:08,690 --> 01:33:10,240
some

3090
01:33:10,240 --> 01:33:11,359
financial advantages maybe to

3091
01:33:11,359 --> 01:33:13,562
townhouses and it would be

3092
01:33:13,562 --> 01:33:14,495
wonderful if we had something

3093
01:33:14,495 --> 01:33:16,895
available for sale where

3094
01:33:17,264 --> 01:33:17,832
people could come into south

3095
01:33:17,832 --> 01:33:19,832
san francisco, iv

3096
01:33:20,769 --> 01:33:21,936
ets, --

3097
01:33:21,936 --> 01:33:22,804
invest, have a stake in the

3098
01:33:22,804 --> 01:33:23,738
action and stay here for a a

3099
01:33:23,738 --> 01:33:25,400
period of time.

3100
01:33:25,400 --> 01:33:26,508
One of the great

3101
01:33:26,508 --> 01:33:27,174
disappointments I had with

3102
01:33:27,174 --> 01:33:28,376
the

3103
01:33:28,376 --> 01:33:29,977
housing rental market, when I

3104
01:33:29,977 --> 01:33:30,312
hear the turn over rate can

3105
01:33:30,312 --> 01:33:32,800
be

3106
01:33:32,800 --> 01:33:33,482
as high as 30% annually, so

3107
01:33:33,482 --> 01:33:34,883
you have people that come and

3108
01:33:34,883 --> 01:33:35,250
visit us for a couple of

3109
01:33:35,250 --> 01:33:36,752
years

3110
01:33:36,752 --> 01:33:37,119
and then they go some place

3111
01:33:37,119 --> 01:33:38,186
else.

3112
01:33:38,186 --> 01:33:38,854
That's not a healthy

3113
01:33:38,854 --> 01:33:40,755
situation

3114
01:33:40,755 --> 01:33:41,889
for a community, so if this

3115
01:33:41,889 --> 01:33:43,292
becomes a trend, I think

3116
01:33:43,292 --> 01:33:45,127
there's some potential really

3117
01:33:45,127 --> 01:33:48,727
great news here where we have

3118
01:33:48,863 --> 01:33:49,964
properties for sale.

3119
01:33:49,964 --> 01:33:51,964
>> great.

3120
01:33:52,670 --> 01:33:53,468
So, this is why rhna's

3121
01:33:53,468 --> 01:33:56,468
important, so every city has

3122
01:33:56,805 --> 01:33:57,973
to do rhna, is that right?

3123
01:33:57,973 --> 01:33:59,341
Someone?

3124
01:33:59,341 --> 01:33:59,674
>> yeah, every jurisdiction

3125
01:33:59,674 --> 01:34:01,674
in

3126
01:34:02,344 --> 01:34:03,440
the state of california is

3127
01:34:03,440 --> 01:34:03,545
allotted a reap na

3128
01:34:03,545 --> 01:34:05,179
number.

3129
01:34:05,179 --> 01:34:05,514
>> and then what happens if

3130
01:34:05,514 --> 01:34:07,514
we

3131
01:34:10,286 --> 01:34:13,286
don't abide by the 3956 units?

3132
01:34:14,690 --> 01:34:17,900
>> again, as tony mentioned,

3133
01:34:17,993 --> 01:34:19,694
there is no penalty per se,

3134
01:34:19,694 --> 01:34:22,531
part of the rhna process is

3135
01:34:22,531 --> 01:34:24,600
making sure that a

3136
01:34:24,600 --> 01:34:25,967
jurisdiction's zoning ad

3137
01:34:25,967 --> 01:34:27,269
development standards can

3138
01:34:27,269 --> 01:34:28,770
allow for the construction of

3139
01:34:28,770 --> 01:34:30,172
that number.

3140
01:34:30,172 --> 01:34:31,339
>> let rerephrase that,

3141
01:34:31,339 --> 01:34:33,739
legally, what happens when

3142
01:34:35,440 --> 01:34:37,313
we're not there, what is our

3143
01:34:37,313 --> 01:34:38,447
state attorney general --

3144
01:34:38,447 --> 01:34:39,214
what

3145
01:34:39,214 --> 01:34:42,151
has he traditional has been

3146
01:34:42,151 --> 01:34:42,818
known to have done to some

3147
01:34:42,818 --> 01:34:44,818
cities?

3148
01:34:46,522 --> 01:34:49,659
>> I'll defer to tony on that.

3149
01:34:49,659 --> 01:34:50,126
>> I will say that in cases

3150
01:34:50,126 --> 01:34:51,961
of

3151
01:34:51,961 --> 01:34:52,428
jurisdictions that are sort

3152
01:34:52,428 --> 01:34:53,596
of

3153
01:34:53,596 --> 01:34:53,963
blatantly bad actor, they

3154
01:34:53,963 --> 01:34:55,431
have

3155
01:34:55,431 --> 01:34:56,799
gotten letters from the state

3156
01:34:56,799 --> 01:34:59,199
attorney letting them know

3157
01:34:59,703 --> 01:35:01,304
that they are at risk of

3158
01:35:01,304 --> 01:35:02,938
losing funding for roads,

3159
01:35:02,938 --> 01:35:04,140
funding for things that are

3160
01:35:04,140 --> 01:35:04,607
not housing related that a

3161
01:35:04,607 --> 01:35:06,607
lot

3162
01:35:08,177 --> 01:35:10,577
of cities rely on.

3163
01:35:10,947 --> 01:35:12,815
We have not always met our

3164
01:35:12,815 --> 01:35:14,684
income levels in rhna but we

3165
01:35:14,684 --> 01:35:15,840
have often met the lump

3166
01:35:15,840 --> 01:35:16,953
number

3167
01:35:16,953 --> 01:35:20,590
and we did in the last cycle.

3168
01:35:20,590 --> 01:35:23,293
It's just very, very hard to

3169
01:35:23,293 --> 01:35:24,928
get and fund the level of

3170
01:35:24,928 --> 01:35:26,162
affordable, very low and low

3171
01:35:26,162 --> 01:35:28,264
income unit that is are

3172
01:35:28,264 --> 01:35:30,990
projected on most cities and

3173
01:35:30,990 --> 01:35:31,268
that's where sb35 sort of

3174
01:35:31,268 --> 01:35:33,470
creates a carrot for

3175
01:35:33,470 --> 01:35:35,772
developers and frankly a

3176
01:35:35,772 --> 01:35:36,473
carrot for cities to be a

3177
01:35:36,473 --> 01:35:37,407
good

3178
01:35:37,407 --> 01:35:38,575
actor and streamline.

3179
01:35:38,575 --> 01:35:39,876
>> great.

3180
01:35:39,876 --> 01:35:42,145
And as mayor and I know that

3181
01:35:42,145 --> 01:35:44,614
my colleagues share this as

3182
01:35:44,614 --> 01:35:46,490
well, this is important.

3183
01:35:46,490 --> 01:35:46,351
This iss what we get elected

3184
01:35:46,351 --> 01:35:46,683
o

3185
01:35:46,683 --> 01:35:47,884
do.

3186
01:35:47,884 --> 01:35:49,953
When I hear individuals say

3187
01:35:49,953 --> 01:35:50,419
you all are hiding behind

3188
01:35:50,419 --> 01:35:52,419
your

3189
01:35:53,456 --> 01:35:54,391
rhna numbers or using that as

3190
01:35:54,391 --> 01:35:54,758
a justification to build,

3191
01:35:54,758 --> 01:35:56,758
this

3192
01:35:57,628 --> 01:35:58,995
is happening all across

3193
01:35:58,995 --> 01:36:00,597
california and in cities that

3194
01:36:00,597 --> 01:36:01,532
perhaps don't even have space

3195
01:36:01,532 --> 01:36:02,699
to build, right.

3196
01:36:02,699 --> 01:36:04,734
They still have a a rhna

3197
01:36:04,734 --> 01:36:05,936
number to meet and areap na

3198
01:36:05,936 --> 01:36:07,936
allocation.

3199
01:36:09,172 --> 01:36:11,475
Tony, can you describe what

3200
01:36:11,475 --> 01:36:13,875
the builders' remedy is?

3201
01:36:15,579 --> 01:36:16,980
>> the builders' remedy is a

3202
01:36:16,980 --> 01:36:19,980
trigger lw that goes into

3203
01:36:21,518 --> 01:36:23,153
effect if you do not have a

3204
01:36:23,153 --> 01:36:24,788
compliant and certified

3205
01:36:24,788 --> 01:36:25,889
housing element, so, you can

3206
01:36:25,889 --> 01:36:26,223
adopt a housing element but

3207
01:36:26,223 --> 01:36:28,223
it

3208
01:36:30,361 --> 01:36:32,363
can be grossly failed to meet

3209
01:36:32,363 --> 01:36:33,631
the standards that hcd is

3210
01:36:33,631 --> 01:36:35,499
looking at.

3211
01:36:35,499 --> 01:36:36,434
Hcd has to certify your

3212
01:36:36,434 --> 01:36:36,767
housing element, until they

3213
01:36:36,767 --> 01:36:38,302
do

3214
01:36:38,302 --> 01:36:40,137
and once the housing element

3215
01:36:40,137 --> 01:36:42,440
cycle has started and this is

3216
01:36:42,440 --> 01:36:43,373
affected a lot of

3217
01:36:43,373 --> 01:36:44,976
jurisdictions including us,

3218
01:36:44,976 --> 01:36:45,443
there's a window where

3219
01:36:45,443 --> 01:36:47,443
someone

3220
01:36:48,880 --> 01:36:49,213
can come in on essentially

3221
01:36:49,213 --> 01:36:49,747
any

3222
01:36:49,747 --> 01:36:50,810
parcel anywhere.

3223
01:36:50,810 --> 01:36:51,382
Er

3224
01:36:51,382 --> 01:36:53,382
>> any neighborhood.

3225
01:36:53,718 --> 01:36:55,386
>> and propose whatever they

3226
01:36:55,386 --> 01:36:56,754
want with streamlining and a

3227
01:36:56,754 --> 01:36:58,754
lot of clearance.

3228
01:36:59,900 --> 01:36:59,424
It doesn't happen often but

3229
01:36:59,424 --> 01:37:00,924
it

3230
01:37:00,924 --> 01:37:03,261
is certainly -- there are

3231
01:37:03,261 --> 01:37:04,194
examples in berkeley, santa

3232
01:37:04,194 --> 01:37:05,960
monica, southern california

3233
01:37:05,960 --> 01:37:05,462
where these projects have

3234
01:37:05,462 --> 01:37:05,797
been

3235
01:37:05,797 --> 01:37:06,931
pro

3236
01:37:06,931 --> 01:37:08,566
ep proposed and once you

3237
01:37:08,566 --> 01:37:10,868
propose it, you then have a

3238
01:37:10,868 --> 01:37:11,336
right to that project in

3239
01:37:11,336 --> 01:37:13,336
perpetuity.

3240
01:37:13,404 --> 01:37:13,838
That cn be frightening for a

3241
01:37:13,838 --> 01:37:15,573
community.

3242
01:37:15,573 --> 01:37:17,573
>> great.

3243
01:37:18,109 --> 01:37:18,877
This has been as a result of

3244
01:37:18,877 --> 01:37:20,845
additional housing, right, a

3245
01:37:20,845 --> 01:37:22,800
lot of folks say we're in a

3246
01:37:22,800 --> 01:37:23,714
housing crisis.

3247
01:37:23,714 --> 01:37:25,116
rhna is supposed to address

3248
01:37:25,116 --> 01:37:26,984
this but I also wanted to

3249
01:37:26,984 --> 01:37:28,353
point out that rhna is not

3250
01:37:28,353 --> 01:37:30,154
just building or approving

3251
01:37:30,154 --> 01:37:31,156
projects to build but the

3252
01:37:31,156 --> 01:37:33,556
other implementations of the

3253
01:37:33,892 --> 01:37:35,293
program such as you all

3254
01:37:35,293 --> 01:37:36,494
highlighted, the displacement

3255
01:37:36,494 --> 01:37:36,828
protections, the services,

3256
01:37:36,828 --> 01:37:38,229
the

3257
01:37:38,229 --> 01:37:40,532
energy efficiency, these are

3258
01:37:40,532 --> 01:37:41,199
also meant to preserve as

3259
01:37:41,199 --> 01:37:42,834
well

3260
01:37:42,834 --> 01:37:44,202
as sustain and promote

3261
01:37:44,202 --> 01:37:44,536
additional housing, so when

3262
01:37:44,536 --> 01:37:45,870
we

3263
01:37:45,870 --> 01:37:46,204
talk about -- I don't like

3264
01:37:46,204 --> 01:37:47,439
how

3265
01:37:47,439 --> 01:37:48,607
south san francisco is

3266
01:37:48,607 --> 01:37:49,730
changing, we don't really

3267
01:37:49,730 --> 01:37:50,642
have

3268
01:37:50,642 --> 01:37:51,877
a choice, folks, we need to

3269
01:37:51,877 --> 01:37:52,910
address housing.

3270
01:37:52,910 --> 01:37:53,278
Housing I important, we

3271
01:37:53,278 --> 01:37:55,278
could

3272
01:37:56,348 --> 01:37:57,516
certainly make it so that

3273
01:37:57,516 --> 01:37:59,884
there is affordablability in

3274
01:37:59,884 --> 01:38:01,180
south san francisco but these

3275
01:38:01,180 --> 01:38:02,887
are new implementations that

3276
01:38:02,887 --> 01:38:05,357
are like I said not just in

3277
01:38:05,357 --> 01:38:07,757
south san francisco but

3278
01:38:10,829 --> 01:38:11,697
anywhere you go I the state.

3279
01:38:11,697 --> 01:38:13,164
With that, do you have

3280
01:38:13,164 --> 01:38:13,499
something else?

3281
01:38:13,499 --> 01:38:14,566
>>.

3282
01:38:14,566 --> 01:38:16,234
F MR. Mayor, iped to

3283
01:38:16,234 --> 01:38:17,769
remind the audience, we just

3284
01:38:17,769 --> 01:38:18,736
recently passed an ordinance

3285
01:38:18,736 --> 01:38:19,104
that codified that if you

3286
01:38:19,104 --> 01:38:20,720
live

3287
01:38:20,720 --> 01:38:22,410
and work in south san

3288
01:38:22,410 --> 01:38:23,642
francisco that you would have

3289
01:38:23,642 --> 01:38:25,277
preferences, so I want to

3290
01:38:25,277 --> 01:38:27,145
remind folks, and also that

3291
01:38:27,145 --> 01:38:29,282
3800 number in terms of

3292
01:38:29,282 --> 01:38:31,682
residents, number of units,

3293
01:38:31,851 --> 01:38:33,485
they did an audit on that and

3294
01:38:33,485 --> 01:38:35,321
we apparently -- everyone

3295
01:38:35,321 --> 01:38:36,722
according to what their audit

3296
01:38:36,722 --> 01:38:37,890
said was understood counted,

3297
01:38:37,890 --> 01:38:38,357
so our numbers could have

3298
01:38:38,357 --> 01:38:40,357
been

3299
01:38:40,426 --> 01:38:42,762
a lot higher than that than

3300
01:38:42,762 --> 01:38:44,363
what we have and I serve on

3301
01:38:44,363 --> 01:38:45,964
abag which is the association

3302
01:38:45,964 --> 01:38:46,298
of bay aea governments and

3303
01:38:46,298 --> 01:38:48,298
we

3304
01:38:48,300 --> 01:38:48,768
are talking about the

3305
01:38:48,768 --> 01:38:50,768
numbers,

3306
01:38:51,237 --> 01:38:53,105
the rhna numbers, so I will

3307
01:38:53,105 --> 01:38:53,939
have a big part in terms of

3308
01:38:53,939 --> 01:38:56,420
what those numbers are going

3309
01:38:56,420 --> 01:38:58,578
to be for the region and so

3310
01:38:58,578 --> 01:39:00,345
the more we can do now t

3311
01:39:00,345 --> 01:39:01,814
better it is for us in terms

3312
01:39:01,814 --> 01:39:03,416
of what our rhna numbers ae

3313
01:39:03,416 --> 01:39:03,783
going to be for the next

3314
01:39:03,783 --> 01:39:05,783
cycle.

3315
01:39:07,787 --> 01:39:09,455
>> great, thank you,

3316
01:39:09,455 --> 01:39:09,889
councilmember, for that

3317
01:39:09,889 --> 01:39:10,623
addition.

3318
01:39:10,623 --> 01:39:11,357
This is a report only so no

3319
01:39:11,357 --> 01:39:11,891
action taken but do we have

3320
01:39:11,891 --> 01:39:13,793
public comments?

3321
01:39:13,793 --> 01:39:15,794
>> we have oe public

3322
01:39:15,794 --> 01:39:17,794
comment,

3323
01:39:22,340 --> 01:39:24,340
fianola?

3324
01:39:25,804 --> 01:39:27,804
>> good evening again,

3325
01:39:27,874 --> 01:39:29,874
councilmembers.

3326
01:39:31,244 --> 01:39:33,644
The regional housing needs

3327
01:39:33,780 --> 01:39:34,180
assessment numbers mean

3328
01:39:34,180 --> 01:39:36,180
nothing.

3329
01:39:36,215 --> 01:39:38,651
You should all know that.

3330
01:39:38,651 --> 01:39:41,651
It is surprising you don't

3331
01:39:43,590 --> 01:39:45,590
know this.

3332
01:39:47,930 --> 01:39:47,761
Who are you building equity

3333
01:39:47,761 --> 01:39:49,761
for?

3334
01:39:50,997 --> 01:39:54,597
All the tax credits from the

3335
01:39:56,350 --> 01:39:58,350
state.

3336
01:39:58,939 --> 01:39:59,306
For "affordable" housing

3337
01:39:59,306 --> 01:40:01,306
units

3338
01:40:03,911 --> 01:40:05,780
that after sometime the deed

3339
01:40:05,780 --> 01:40:06,713
restrictions go away.

3340
01:40:06,713 --> 01:40:08,314
They're no longer affordable.

3341
01:40:08,314 --> 01:40:10,714
Then who owns them.

3342
01:40:10,983 --> 01:40:11,317
Who are you building equity

3343
01:40:11,317 --> 01:40:13,317
for?

3344
01:40:13,787 --> 01:40:15,189
You are not building equity

3345
01:40:15,189 --> 01:40:17,189
for regular foils.

3346
01:40:18,580 --> 01:40:19,459
You

3347
01:40:19,459 --> 01:40:20,828
-- folks.

3348
01:40:20,828 --> 01:40:22,730
You're strapping everybody to

3349
01:40:22,730 --> 01:40:23,630
be debt slaves because you

3350
01:40:23,630 --> 01:40:23,897
are

3351
01:40:23,897 --> 01:40:26,897
borrowing on the strength of

3352
01:40:27,368 --> 01:40:29,203
us, the taxpayers, and we are

3353
01:40:29,203 --> 01:40:32,203
paying those tax credits, yu

3354
01:40:32,706 --> 01:40:33,440
do not need to build regional

3355
01:40:33,440 --> 01:40:33,774
housing assessment numbers

3356
01:40:33,774 --> 01:40:35,142
but

3357
01:40:35,142 --> 01:40:36,677
yes, we need house, housing

3358
01:40:36,677 --> 01:40:38,812
for sale that people can buy

3359
01:40:38,812 --> 01:40:39,146
and build equity in for

3360
01:40:39,146 --> 01:40:39,304
th

3361
01:40:39,304 --> 01:40:41,810
els

3362
01:40:41,810 --> 01:40:42,215
and is their fmly tos pass on

3363
01:40:42,215 --> 01:40:44,215
into the future.

3364
01:40:44,984 --> 01:40:46,653
Who are you building equity

3365
01:40:46,653 --> 01:40:47,121
for?

3366
01:40:47,121 --> 01:40:48,489
Yourselves.

3367
01:40:48,489 --> 01:40:50,591
Because those are the people

3368
01:40:50,591 --> 01:40:53,591
that come storming in here

3369
01:40:54,161 --> 01:40:55,496
when it's time for elections,

3370
01:40:55,496 --> 01:40:57,398
it's very interesting.

3371
01:40:57,398 --> 01:40:58,799
So, you'll get the votes.

3372
01:40:58,799 --> 01:41:00,434
But what about the people

3373
01:41:00,434 --> 01:41:02,303
you're supposed to represent

3374
01:41:02,303 --> 01:41:02,803
that vote in this

3375
01:41:02,803 --> 01:41:04,372
constituency.

3376
01:41:04,372 --> 01:41:06,507
You don't care about them.

3377
01:41:06,507 --> 01:41:07,441
You only care about using a

3378
01:41:07,441 --> 01:41:09,841
word that doesn't mean

3379
01:41:10,311 --> 01:41:12,246
anything because the word

3380
01:41:12,246 --> 01:41:12,579
affordable, everybody needs

3381
01:41:12,579 --> 01:41:14,579
to

3382
01:41:14,981 --> 01:41:17,981
know one unit of affordable

3383
01:41:18,152 --> 01:41:21,255
housing costs at least -- oh,

3384
01:41:21,255 --> 01:41:21,956
not including the recent

3385
01:41:21,956 --> 01:41:23,956
surge

3386
01:41:24,292 --> 01:41:27,292
in prices, 20% more to build

3387
01:41:27,296 --> 01:41:29,597
an affordable housing unit,

3388
01:41:29,597 --> 01:41:30,933
then.It does, a regular

3389
01:41:30,933 --> 01:41:32,734
house.

3390
01:41:32,734 --> 01:41:34,734
20% more than.

3391
01:41:35,336 --> 01:41:36,971
It is far -- it is much, much

3392
01:41:36,971 --> 01:41:37,439
more money to build

3393
01:41:37,439 --> 01:41:38,607
affordable

3394
01:41:38,607 --> 01:41:40,607
housing units.

3395
01:41:41,900 --> 01:41:41,442
The word affordable is the

3396
01:41:41,442 --> 01:41:42,910
big

3397
01:41:42,910 --> 01:41:44,679
cash cow that you're all

3398
01:41:44,679 --> 01:41:48,279
relying on that people do not

3399
01:41:48,450 --> 01:41:49,217
realize, it is unaffordable,

3400
01:41:49,217 --> 01:41:51,617
completely unaffordable to be

3401
01:41:51,920 --> 01:41:54,320
strapping the taxpayers with

3402
01:41:54,623 --> 01:41:57,623
the cost of building these

3403
01:41:58,260 --> 01:42:00,494
units when you should be

3404
01:42:00,494 --> 01:42:01,229
building for families and

3405
01:42:01,229 --> 01:42:02,310
people that they can build

3406
01:42:02,310 --> 01:42:03,965
equity in to pass on to their

3407
01:42:03,965 --> 01:42:05,367
families into the future.

3408
01:42:05,367 --> 01:42:06,300
It is shameful, it is

3409
01:42:06,300 --> 01:42:08,436
disgraceful that each of you

3410
01:42:08,436 --> 01:42:08,804
sit there and ride a wave

3411
01:42:08,804 --> 01:42:10,705
just

3412
01:42:10,705 --> 01:42:11,105
because of a word, words have

3413
01:42:11,105 --> 01:42:13,105
meaning.

3414
01:42:13,107 --> 01:42:16,378
Why don't you tell the people

3415
01:42:16,378 --> 01:42:18,313
what it means.

3416
01:42:18,313 --> 01:42:20,148
Be honest.

3417
01:42:20,148 --> 01:42:20,482
Where's your decency, all of

3418
01:42:20,482 --> 01:42:22,482
you.

3419
01:42:23,485 --> 01:42:25,485
Thank you.

3420
01:42:25,853 --> 01:42:28,323
>> any other comments from my

3421
01:42:28,323 --> 01:42:28,690
colleagues?

3422
01:42:28,690 --> 01:42:29,458
Okay.

3423
01:42:29,458 --> 01:42:31,458
Thank you.

3424
01:42:31,994 --> 01:42:33,661
>> we do need you to take

3425
01:42:33,661 --> 01:42:35,964
action to accept the general

3426
01:42:35,964 --> 01:42:38,167
plan and housing element and

3427
01:42:38,167 --> 01:42:39,768
annual progress reports and

3428
01:42:39,768 --> 01:42:40,535
authorize transmittal to the

3429
01:42:40,535 --> 01:42:41,971
california governor's office

3430
01:42:41,971 --> 01:42:44,730
of land use and climate

3431
01:42:44,730 --> 01:42:44,406
innovation and the cal torn

3432
01:42:44,406 --> 01:42:45,407
ya

3433
01:42:45,407 --> 01:42:46,410
department of housing and

3434
01:42:46,410 --> 01:42:47,810
community development.

3435
01:42:47,810 --> 01:42:48,744
>> aisle make that motion.

3436
01:42:48,744 --> 01:42:49,612
>> I would second that.

3437
01:42:49,612 --> 01:42:51,612
>> first and second.

3438
01:42:52,814 --> 01:42:53,282
Can I have a roll call,

3439
01:42:53,282 --> 01:42:53,982
please.

3440
01:42:53,982 --> 01:42:55,383
>> councilmember nagales?

3441
01:42:55,383 --> 01:42:56,752
>> yes.

3442
01:42:56,752 --> 01:42:57,486
>> vice mayor addiego?

3443
01:42:57,486 --> 01:42:57,820
>> yes.

3444
01:42:57,820 --> 01:42:58,621
Er

3445
01:42:58,621 --> 01:43:00,621
>> mayor flores?

3446
01:43:03,192 --> 01:43:03,893
>> yes.

3447
01:43:03,893 --> 01:43:05,494
>> councilmember coleman?

3448
01:43:05,494 --> 01:43:06,562
>> yes.

3449
01:43:06,562 --> 01:43:08,562
>> councilmember nicolas.

3450
01:43:08,731 --> 01:43:09,599
>> item 10 is a report regard

3451
01:43:09,599 --> 01:43:11,300
ago resolution approving

3452
01:43:11,300 --> 01:43:12,902
program guidelines and is

3453
01:43:12,902 --> 01:43:15,704
request for interest for the

3454
01:43:15,704 --> 01:43:17,373
launch local vie cant retail

3455
01:43:17,373 --> 01:43:19,373
activation pilot program.

3456
01:43:19,442 --> 01:43:21,842
10a is the resolution.

3457
01:43:22,311 --> 01:43:24,311
>> welcome, MS. Donner.

3458
01:43:34,724 --> 01:43:36,724
>> good evening.

3459
01:43:36,993 --> 01:43:38,610
>> good evening, mayor, vice

3460
01:43:38,610 --> 01:43:38,427
mayor, councilmembers, my

3461
01:43:38,427 --> 01:43:39,695
name

3462
01:43:39,695 --> 01:43:40,697
is kate tea donner,

3463
01:43:40,697 --> 01:43:42,980
management

3464
01:43:42,980 --> 01:43:42,432
analyst with the community

3465
01:43:42,432 --> 01:43:43,650
and

3466
01:43:43,650 --> 01:43:43,800
economic development

3467
01:43:43,800 --> 01:43:45,601
department, I'm pleased to

3468
01:43:45,601 --> 01:43:47,203
present to you the launch

3469
01:43:47,203 --> 01:43:47,671
local vacant retail

3470
01:43:47,671 --> 01:43:48,671
activation

3471
01:43:48,671 --> 01:43:51,710
pilot program, a creative

3472
01:43:51,574 --> 01:43:55,174
niche yat I ever designed to

3473
01:43:56,212 --> 01:43:56,980
revitalize vacant store front

3474
01:43:56,980 --> 01:43:57,681
ins south san francisco while

3475
01:43:57,681 --> 01:43:58,148
supporting emerging local

3476
01:43:58,148 --> 01:43:58,914
businesses.

3477
01:43:58,914 --> 01:44:00,160
Note the powerpoint published

3478
01:44:00,160 --> 01:44:01,651
in the agenda packet is not

3479
01:44:01,651 --> 01:44:03,286
the most updated version.

3480
01:44:03,286 --> 01:44:04,587
This presentation includes a

3481
01:44:04,587 --> 01:44:06,122
few minor enhancements and

3482
01:44:06,122 --> 01:44:07,157
printed copies of the updated

3483
01:44:07,157 --> 01:44:10,157
slides are available in the

3484
01:44:11,128 --> 01:44:11,862
back room.

3485
01:44:11,862 --> 01:44:12,196
Tonight staff recommends it

3486
01:44:12,196 --> 01:44:14,630
is

3487
01:44:14,630 --> 01:44:15,164
city council adopt a

3488
01:44:15,164 --> 01:44:17,367
resolution approving both the

3489
01:44:17,367 --> 01:44:18,969
program guideline and is the

3490
01:44:18,969 --> 01:44:20,837
request for interest or rfi

3491
01:44:20,837 --> 01:44:22,500
for the launch local program.

3492
01:44:22,500 --> 01:44:22,339
This approval will allow us

3493
01:44:22,339 --> 01:44:23,640
to

3494
01:44:23,640 --> 01:44:25,640
mover forward with

3495
01:44:26,843 --> 01:44:28,440
implementation and tenant

3496
01:44:28,440 --> 01:44:29,445
outreach.

3497
01:44:29,445 --> 01:44:31,314
this program was first

3498
01:44:31,314 --> 01:44:33,182
introduced as a study session

3499
01:44:33,182 --> 01:44:34,840
at the FEBRUARY 12 council

3500
01:44:34,840 --> 01:44:35,486
meeting.

3501
01:44:35,486 --> 01:44:37,870
It responds directly to the

3502
01:44:37,870 --> 01:44:38,210
economic and visual

3503
01:44:38,210 --> 01:44:39,890
challenges

3504
01:44:39,890 --> 01:44:41,191
created by persistent vacant

3505
01:44:41,191 --> 01:44:41,992
store fronts in our

3506
01:44:41,992 --> 01:44:42,693
commercial

3507
01:44:42,693 --> 01:44:44,260
corridors.

3508
01:44:44,260 --> 01:44:46,426
Launch local supports first

3509
01:44:46,664 --> 01:44:48,310
time brick and mortar

3510
01:44:48,310 --> 01:44:49,465
businesses through leases and

3511
01:44:49,465 --> 01:44:51,101
a tenant allowance up to 10

3512
01:44:51,101 --> 01:44:51,534
thousand dollars and targeted

3513
01:44:51,534 --> 01:44:53,404
outreach.

3514
01:44:53,404 --> 01:44:55,439
The intent is to lower

3515
01:44:55,439 --> 01:44:56,674
barriers to entry and pilot

3516
01:44:56,674 --> 01:44:59,674
retail concept that is have

3517
01:45:01,378 --> 01:45:02,279
long term potential.

3518
01:45:02,279 --> 01:45:03,948
Council provided thoughtful

3519
01:45:03,948 --> 01:45:05,150
and clear direction in

3520
01:45:05,150 --> 01:45:06,917
FEBRUARY which shaped the

3521
01:45:06,917 --> 01:45:07,384
final program before you

3522
01:45:07,384 --> 01:45:08,719
tonight.

3523
01:45:08,719 --> 01:45:09,953
You voiced support for

3524
01:45:09,953 --> 01:45:11,355
activation goals and

3525
01:45:11,355 --> 01:45:12,423
emphasized the importance of

3526
01:45:12,423 --> 01:45:13,924
prioritizing south san

3527
01:45:13,924 --> 01:45:15,526
francisco residents.

3528
01:45:15,526 --> 01:45:17,628
There was particular interest

3529
01:45:17,628 --> 01:45:18,529
in reactivating the former

3530
01:45:18,529 --> 01:45:20,398
barbershop space and concern

3531
01:45:20,398 --> 01:45:21,699
was raised about limiting

3532
01:45:21,699 --> 01:45:23,434
participation to a one year

3533
01:45:23,434 --> 01:45:24,601
lease term.

3534
01:45:24,601 --> 01:45:26,437
You also encouraged us to

3535
01:45:26,437 --> 01:45:27,838
create a model that private

3536
01:45:27,838 --> 01:45:29,606
property owners could adopt.

3537
01:45:29,606 --> 01:45:32,606
That input is reflected in

3538
01:45:33,511 --> 01:45:35,380
tonight's proposal.

3539
01:45:35,380 --> 01:45:37,181
I would also like to raise a

3540
01:45:37,181 --> 01:45:38,182
related item for council

3541
01:45:38,182 --> 01:45:40,180
discussion tonight.

3542
01:45:40,180 --> 01:45:42,119
Since the FEBRUARY 12 study

3543
01:45:42,119 --> 01:45:42,553
session, the city has

3544
01:45:42,553 --> 01:45:43,955
received

3545
01:45:43,955 --> 01:45:44,422
multiple inquiry from

3546
01:45:44,422 --> 01:45:46,291
existing

3547
01:45:46,291 --> 01:45:47,224
businesses, both local and

3548
01:45:47,224 --> 01:45:48,593
from neighboring cities,

3549
01:45:48,593 --> 01:45:50,461
interested in leasing the

3550
01:45:50,461 --> 01:45:51,830
grand avenue spaces at market

3551
01:45:51,830 --> 01:45:54,264
rate rent outside of the

3552
01:45:54,264 --> 01:45:55,667
launch local program.

3553
01:45:55,667 --> 01:45:57,268
One formal lease proposal has

3554
01:45:57,268 --> 01:45:57,969
already been submit and had

3555
01:45:57,969 --> 01:45:59,571
we

3556
01:45:59,571 --> 01:45:59,937
anticipate receiving another

3557
01:45:59,937 --> 01:46:01,439
soon.

3558
01:46:01,439 --> 01:46:03,642
Notably one of the interested

3559
01:46:03,642 --> 01:46:04,308
parties is an existing south

3560
01:46:04,308 --> 01:46:04,709
san francisco business

3561
01:46:04,709 --> 01:46:06,611
looking

3562
01:46:06,611 --> 01:46:08,780
to open a second location and

3563
01:46:08,780 --> 01:46:09,848
lease both of the city owned

3564
01:46:09,848 --> 01:46:11,716
storefronts on grand avenue

3565
01:46:11,716 --> 01:46:13,451
include lg the former

3566
01:46:13,451 --> 01:46:15,451
barbershop space.

3567
01:46:15,754 --> 01:46:16,388
Given this interest, staff is

3568
01:46:16,388 --> 01:46:16,888
requesting council's

3569
01:46:16,888 --> 01:46:18,290
direction

3570
01:46:18,290 --> 01:46:19,691
on whether to continue

3571
01:46:19,691 --> 01:46:21,492
reserving these spaces for

3572
01:46:21,492 --> 01:46:23,829
launch local or to consider

3573
01:46:23,829 --> 01:46:24,295
market rate lease proposals

3574
01:46:24,295 --> 01:46:26,295
separately?

3575
01:46:26,364 --> 01:46:26,832
Your input will help

3576
01:46:26,832 --> 01:46:28,832
determine

3577
01:46:29,501 --> 01:46:29,868
how we -- your input wll

3578
01:46:29,868 --> 01:46:30,969
help

3579
01:46:30,969 --> 01:46:32,771
determine how we proceed with

3580
01:46:32,771 --> 01:46:33,204
these spaces while we

3581
01:46:33,204 --> 01:46:35,204
continue

3582
01:46:36,740 --> 01:46:36,474
rolling out the broader

3583
01:46:36,474 --> 01:46:37,943
program.

3584
01:46:37,943 --> 01:46:40,440
The name launch local was

3585
01:46:40,440 --> 01:46:41,213
selected through a survey of

3586
01:46:41,213 --> 01:46:42,314
key stakeholders including

3587
01:46:42,314 --> 01:46:44,714
city staff, elected officials

3588
01:46:44,950 --> 01:46:46,151
and staff pr the renaissance

3589
01:46:46,151 --> 01:46:46,618
entrepreneurship center at

3590
01:46:46,618 --> 01:46:48,253
the

3591
01:46:48,253 --> 01:46:49,654
economic advancement center.

3592
01:46:49,654 --> 01:46:50,890
It reflects both the

3593
01:46:50,890 --> 01:46:51,256
program's

3594
01:46:51,256 --> 01:46:52,892
focus on local

3595
01:46:52,892 --> 01:46:54,460
entrepreneurship x the

3596
01:46:54,460 --> 01:46:55,761
opportunity for participants

3597
01:46:55,761 --> 01:46:57,496
to launch their first

3598
01:46:57,496 --> 01:46:57,963
physical

3599
01:46:57,963 --> 01:46:59,980
location.

3600
01:46:59,980 --> 01:47:01,266
It's memorable, energetic and

3601
01:47:01,266 --> 01:47:02,902
rooted in place.

3602
01:47:02,902 --> 01:47:05,902
Branding icluding a logo is

3603
01:47:07,373 --> 01:47:09,373
currently in development.

3604
01:47:09,442 --> 01:47:12,278
The program has four key

3605
01:47:12,278 --> 01:47:13,110
object tiers, first activate

3606
01:47:13,110 --> 01:47:14,313
underutilized retail spaces

3607
01:47:14,313 --> 01:47:16,313
in

3608
01:47:16,382 --> 01:47:18,382
south san francisco, 2,

3609
01:47:19,885 --> 01:47:22,221
support emerging for profit

3610
01:47:22,221 --> 01:47:23,222
businesses, particularly those

3611
01:47:23,222 --> 01:47:23,989
without a prior brick and

3612
01:47:23,989 --> 01:47:25,257
mortar presence, 3, encourage

3613
01:47:25,257 --> 01:47:26,625
unique and experiential

3614
01:47:26,625 --> 01:47:28,625
retail

3615
01:47:29,829 --> 01:47:30,996
or service concepts, and 4,

3616
01:47:30,996 --> 01:47:31,497
prioritize local

3617
01:47:31,497 --> 01:47:33,497
entrepreneurs

3618
01:47:34,267 --> 01:47:35,340
especially gaduates of the

3619
01:47:35,340 --> 01:47:36,335
renaissance entrepreneurship

3620
01:47:36,335 --> 01:47:38,735
center programs at the

3621
01:47:40,505 --> 01:47:41,874
economic advancement center.

3622
01:47:41,874 --> 01:47:43,508
Under this pilot, the city

3623
01:47:43,508 --> 01:47:44,744
will lease out ipsbacker its

3624
01:47:44,744 --> 01:47:47,446
own vacant retail spaces on

3625
01:47:47,446 --> 01:47:50,416
grand avenue and el camino

3626
01:47:50,416 --> 01:47:54,160
real at a discounted rate at

3627
01:47:57,156 --> 01:47:58,591
$1 per square foot.

3628
01:47:58,591 --> 01:47:59,240
The standard lease term is

3629
01:47:59,240 --> 01:48:00,894
one

3630
01:48:00,894 --> 01:48:03,294
year with performance based

3631
01:48:05,198 --> 01:48:07,198
options for renewal.

3632
01:48:08,768 --> 01:48:10,770
The rfi will open on APRIL 1

3633
01:48:10,770 --> 01:48:12,706
and close on APRIL 30.

3634
01:48:12,706 --> 01:48:13,639
All proposals must be

3635
01:48:13,639 --> 01:48:15,700
submitted electronically

3636
01:48:15,700 --> 01:48:16,175
through procure now.

3637
01:48:16,175 --> 01:48:18,575
We'll promote the opportunity

3638
01:48:19,179 --> 01:48:21,579
broadly through the city's

3639
01:48:21,681 --> 01:48:22,315
channels, the chamber of

3640
01:48:22,315 --> 01:48:23,490
commerce and the eac.

3641
01:48:23,490 --> 01:48:23,383
Materials will be available

3642
01:48:23,383 --> 01:48:24,718
in

3643
01:48:24,718 --> 01:48:25,840
english and spanish with

3644
01:48:25,840 --> 01:48:27,840
other

3645
01:48:30,556 --> 01:48:32,425
translations upon request.

3646
01:48:32,425 --> 01:48:33,960
eligible applicants must be

3647
01:48:33,960 --> 01:48:35,929
for profit businesses seeking

3648
01:48:35,929 --> 01:48:37,798
their first south san

3649
01:48:37,798 --> 01:48:38,498
francisco location, offering

3650
01:48:38,498 --> 01:48:39,700
a

3651
01:48:39,700 --> 01:48:41,670
retail or experiential s

3652
01:48:41,670 --> 01:48:41,468
frs

3653
01:48:41,468 --> 01:48:42,669
concept.

3654
01:48:42,669 --> 01:48:44,669
Demonstrating readiness and

3655
01:48:45,405 --> 01:48:46,106
capacity to operate including

3656
01:48:46,106 --> 01:48:48,106
financial sustainability,

3657
01:48:48,742 --> 01:48:49,676
priority will be given to

3658
01:48:49,676 --> 01:48:51,676
renaissance program graduates

3659
01:48:52,212 --> 01:48:55,212
aligning with their goal to

3660
01:48:55,215 --> 01:48:57,500
uplift local entrepreneurs.

3661
01:48:57,500 --> 01:48:57,518
The lease will be 12 months

3662
01:48:57,518 --> 01:48:59,518
in

3663
01:49:00,870 --> 01:49:01,254
duration with monthly sales

3664
01:49:01,254 --> 01:49:03,254
evaluations, structured as

3665
01:49:03,390 --> 01:49:03,724
triple net meaning tenants

3666
01:49:03,724 --> 01:49:04,792
are

3667
01:49:04,792 --> 01:49:06,792
responsible for property

3668
01:49:06,894 --> 01:49:07,361
taxes, insurance and

3669
01:49:07,361 --> 01:49:09,361
utilities

3670
01:49:09,563 --> 01:49:11,980
and tenant improvement costs

3671
01:49:11,980 --> 01:49:11,965
are reimbursed as a rent

3672
01:49:11,965 --> 01:49:13,601
credit, performance and

3673
01:49:13,601 --> 01:49:14,668
consistency will be evaluated

3674
01:49:14,668 --> 01:49:15,469
monthly and successful

3675
01:49:15,469 --> 01:49:17,469
tenants

3676
01:49:19,406 --> 01:49:21,976
MAY be invited to extend.

3677
01:49:21,976 --> 01:49:23,978
Tenants will pay a security

3678
01:49:23,978 --> 01:49:24,344
deposit of $2 per square

3679
01:49:24,344 --> 01:49:25,680
foot,

3680
01:49:25,680 --> 01:49:28,150
operate at least 7 hours a

3681
01:49:28,150 --> 01:49:29,650
day, five days a week, cover

3682
01:49:29,650 --> 01:49:31,319
costs for insurance,

3683
01:49:31,319 --> 01:49:32,920
utilities, garbage and

3684
01:49:32,920 --> 01:49:34,322
maintain shared spaces and

3685
01:49:34,322 --> 01:49:34,789
hold a valid city of south

3686
01:49:34,789 --> 01:49:36,789
san

3687
01:49:38,292 --> 01:49:39,928
francisco business license.

3688
01:49:39,928 --> 01:49:42,928
Proposals will be reviewed o

3689
01:49:43,865 --> 01:49:44,198
the following criteria,

3690
01:49:44,198 --> 01:49:45,320
str

3691
01:49:45,320 --> 01:49:45,933
epgt and creativity of

3692
01:49:45,933 --> 01:49:47,933
the

3693
01:49:48,690 --> 01:49:49,470
business concept, operational

3694
01:49:49,470 --> 01:49:50,304
and readiness, financial

3695
01:49:50,304 --> 01:49:52,106
sustainability and potential

3696
01:49:52,106 --> 01:49:54,106
community impact.

3697
01:49:56,440 --> 01:49:57,512
Finalists MAY be invited to

3698
01:49:57,512 --> 01:49:59,800
present a [Inaudible] Ad

3699
01:49:59,800 --> 01:50:00,782
participate in an interview.

3700
01:50:00,782 --> 01:50:02,884
The rfi will be issued on

3701
01:50:02,884 --> 01:50:03,718
APRIL 1 and proposals will be

3702
01:50:03,718 --> 01:50:05,119
due on APRIL 30.

3703
01:50:05,119 --> 01:50:06,154
Through the month of APRIL,

3704
01:50:06,154 --> 01:50:07,989
we'll be available to answer

3705
01:50:07,989 --> 01:50:08,790
questions and we plan to

3706
01:50:08,790 --> 01:50:10,790
announce the selected

3707
01:50:12,794 --> 01:50:14,395
businesses at the end of MAY.

3708
01:50:14,395 --> 01:50:15,864
There is no impact to the

3709
01:50:15,864 --> 01:50:17,864
general fund.

3710
01:50:18,900 --> 01:50:20,969
The program uses city owned

3711
01:50:20,969 --> 01:50:22,804
currently vacant space and is

3712
01:50:22,804 --> 01:50:23,772
recoups rent through tenant

3713
01:50:23,772 --> 01:50:25,373
spaces, the tenant payment

3714
01:50:25,373 --> 01:50:28,373
allowance is striated as rent

3715
01:50:28,676 --> 01:50:30,178
payment, the triple lease

3716
01:50:30,178 --> 01:50:32,480
structure ensures the city is

3717
01:50:32,480 --> 01:50:32,848
not absorbing additional

3718
01:50:32,848 --> 01:50:33,882
costs.

3719
01:50:33,882 --> 01:50:34,548
Launch local is an

3720
01:50:34,548 --> 01:50:36,418
opportunity

3721
01:50:36,418 --> 01:50:37,352
to support local

3722
01:50:37,352 --> 01:50:39,352
entrepreneurship, enhance the

3723
01:50:39,688 --> 01:50:41,323
vitality of our retail

3724
01:50:41,323 --> 01:50:41,690
corridors, create a model

3725
01:50:41,690 --> 01:50:43,391
that

3726
01:50:43,391 --> 01:50:43,825
privateer owners can

3727
01:50:43,825 --> 01:50:44,559
replicate.

3728
01:50:44,559 --> 01:50:46,559
Pending council approval

3729
01:50:46,662 --> 01:50:49,230
tonight, we will launch the

3730
01:50:49,230 --> 01:50:51,133
rfi on APRIL 1 and we gin

3731
01:50:51,133 --> 01:50:53,133
tenant outreach immediately.

3732
01:50:53,902 --> 01:50:56,380
As a reminder, we're also

3733
01:50:56,380 --> 01:50:58,438
seeking council's guidance on

3734
01:50:59,474 --> 01:51:01,176
how to present with the grand

3735
01:51:01,176 --> 01:51:01,909
avenue spaces outside the

3736
01:51:01,909 --> 01:51:02,845
launch local program, thank

3737
01:51:02,845 --> 01:51:03,979
you for your time and

3738
01:51:03,979 --> 01:51:05,147
attention and I'm happy to

3739
01:51:05,147 --> 01:51:06,810
answer any questions or

3740
01:51:06,810 --> 01:51:07,716
discuss next steps.

3741
01:51:07,716 --> 01:51:10,520
>> thank you, katie, greet

3742
01:51:10,520 --> 01:51:11,921
work on this, great

3743
01:51:11,921 --> 01:51:13,322
presentation, lots to unpack,

3744
01:51:13,322 --> 01:51:16,258
I'm sure my colleagues have

3745
01:51:16,258 --> 01:51:18,627
questions, so let's go with

3746
01:51:18,627 --> 01:51:20,627
councilman nicolas?

3747
01:51:21,897 --> 01:51:23,866
>> so, katie, on the market

3748
01:51:23,866 --> 01:51:27,466
rate, you said we will have

3749
01:51:28,437 --> 01:51:30,437
two, right?

3750
01:51:31,540 --> 01:51:33,376
And one is already an

3751
01:51:33,376 --> 01:51:34,243
established south city

3752
01:51:34,243 --> 01:51:36,243
business.

3753
01:51:36,545 --> 01:51:37,713
Pearly I think, you know,

3754
01:51:37,713 --> 01:51:38,881
since it's market rate and I

3755
01:51:38,881 --> 01:51:41,881
understand we would like to

3756
01:51:42,952 --> 01:51:44,120
preserve the historical look

3757
01:51:44,120 --> 01:51:45,654
of the barbershop, but from

3758
01:51:45,654 --> 01:51:47,523
my

3759
01:51:47,523 --> 01:51:51,600
point of view, a bird in hand

3760
01:51:51,600 --> 01:51:55,260
is worth two in the bush, but

3761
01:51:59,680 --> 01:51:59,836
I think there are still other

3762
01:51:59,836 --> 01:52:00,570
city city properties that we

3763
01:52:00,570 --> 01:52:02,438
can proceed with being the

3764
01:52:02,438 --> 01:52:05,438
pilot project fr the launch

3765
01:52:07,243 --> 01:52:08,110
local, is that correct?

3766
01:52:08,110 --> 01:52:09,745
>> it will just be the one on

3767
01:52:09,745 --> 01:52:11,147
el camino, correct, yeah.

3768
01:52:11,147 --> 01:52:11,513
>> are there others aside

3769
01:52:11,513 --> 01:52:11,948
from

3770
01:52:11,948 --> 01:52:13,883
these two?

3771
01:52:13,883 --> 01:52:15,385
>> those are the only

3772
01:52:15,385 --> 01:52:17,200
vacancies, yeah.

3773
01:52:17,200 --> 01:52:20,200
>> and then we will encourage

3774
01:52:20,290 --> 01:52:22,759
also the other ones that are

3775
01:52:22,759 --> 01:52:23,930
-- if we find out or if we

3776
01:52:23,930 --> 01:52:25,930
can

3777
01:52:28,932 --> 01:52:31,701
prove this is -- this is a

3778
01:52:31,701 --> 01:52:32,402
viable option for property

3779
01:52:32,402 --> 01:52:32,769
owners, have we talked to

3780
01:52:32,769 --> 01:52:33,503
some

3781
01:52:33,503 --> 01:52:34,300
of them and see what their

3782
01:52:34,300 --> 01:52:36,300
interests are?

3783
01:52:36,606 --> 01:52:38,441
>> we haven't talked to any

3784
01:52:38,441 --> 01:52:39,109
yet but that was our

3785
01:52:39,109 --> 01:52:41,109
intention

3786
01:52:42,279 --> 01:52:43,280
if this pilot program deems

3787
01:52:43,280 --> 01:52:44,914
successful and there was

3788
01:52:44,914 --> 01:52:47,170
interest from council to

3789
01:52:47,170 --> 01:52:48,384
expand it, we wuld look into

3790
01:52:48,384 --> 01:52:50,384
private property owners.

3791
01:52:50,520 --> 01:52:52,389
>> but I'm very supportive of

3792
01:52:52,389 --> 01:52:52,723
what you have outlined for

3793
01:52:52,723 --> 01:52:53,223
the

3794
01:52:53,223 --> 01:52:53,958
launch local.

3795
01:52:53,958 --> 01:52:55,292
>> thank you.

3796
01:52:55,292 --> 01:52:57,292
>> great, thank you.

3797
01:52:58,161 --> 01:52:59,829
Anyone ese?

3798
01:52:59,829 --> 01:53:00,163
>> I also am supportive of

3799
01:53:00,163 --> 01:53:01,932
the

3800
01:53:01,932 --> 01:53:03,366
program and we wanted to test

3801
01:53:03,366 --> 01:53:04,134
drive it with all the

3802
01:53:04,134 --> 01:53:06,534
properties w have available

3803
01:53:06,770 --> 01:53:07,237
but in the meantime, katie

3804
01:53:07,237 --> 01:53:09,237
was

3805
01:53:09,373 --> 01:53:10,808
kind enough to show the

3806
01:53:10,808 --> 01:53:11,174
property to a family that

3807
01:53:11,174 --> 01:53:12,408
I've

3808
01:53:12,408 --> 01:53:15,790
known for a dozen years who

3809
01:53:15,790 --> 01:53:16,246
are currently in business and

3810
01:53:16,246 --> 01:53:16,713
as the COUNCILWOMAN

3811
01:53:16,713 --> 01:53:18,713
Mentioned,

3812
01:53:18,782 --> 01:53:20,184
you know, a bird in the hand,

3813
01:53:20,184 --> 01:53:21,818
so it really speaks to the

3814
01:53:21,818 --> 01:53:22,185
viability of our downtown

3815
01:53:22,185 --> 01:53:24,185
that

3816
01:53:26,957 --> 01:53:28,792
somebody wants it right away

3817
01:53:28,792 --> 01:53:29,126
and you MAY or MAY not come

3818
01:53:29,126 --> 01:53:30,894
to

3819
01:53:30,894 --> 01:53:33,894
agreement on all the terms,

3820
01:53:34,264 --> 01:53:34,965
but the el camino is a whole

3821
01:53:34,965 --> 01:53:35,332
different challenge so it

3822
01:53:35,332 --> 01:53:37,332
will

3823
01:53:39,904 --> 01:53:40,371
be interesting to see who's

3824
01:53:40,371 --> 01:53:42,371
interested.

3825
01:53:44,108 --> 01:53:45,275
As far as the tenant

3826
01:53:45,275 --> 01:53:46,710
participation, it is -- a

3827
01:53:46,710 --> 01:53:48,346
dollar a square foot is a

3828
01:53:48,346 --> 01:53:48,813
great deal but all those

3829
01:53:48,813 --> 01:53:50,813
other

3830
01:53:50,915 --> 01:53:52,450
things add up rapidly too, so

3831
01:53:52,450 --> 01:53:54,384
it's quite a commitment for

3832
01:53:54,384 --> 01:53:56,154
someone coming out of a home

3833
01:53:56,154 --> 01:53:56,487
business or just a concept,

3834
01:53:56,487 --> 01:53:57,922
so

3835
01:53:57,922 --> 01:54:00,458
anyway, but generally I like

3836
01:54:00,458 --> 01:54:01,124
the idea and you were

3837
01:54:01,124 --> 01:54:03,124
wonderful in kpix.

3838
01:54:05,263 --> 01:54:06,263
>> thank you.

3839
01:54:06,263 --> 01:54:08,165
>> councilmember?

3840
01:54:08,165 --> 01:54:09,968
>> thanks, MR. Mayor, I agree

3841
01:54:09,968 --> 01:54:12,570
with my colleagues, I think

3842
01:54:12,570 --> 01:54:14,505
this is potentially a great

3843
01:54:14,505 --> 01:54:16,374
pilot program.

3844
01:54:16,374 --> 01:54:18,910
I think I kind of share the

3845
01:54:18,910 --> 01:54:20,440
concerns in terms of like el

3846
01:54:20,440 --> 01:54:20,444
camino real versus grand

3847
01:54:20,444 --> 01:54:22,444
avenue.

3848
01:54:23,114 --> 01:54:24,282
You know, one of the things I

3849
01:54:24,282 --> 01:54:27,282
was thinking about, you know,

3850
01:54:27,452 --> 01:54:29,621
if we place this business on

3851
01:54:29,621 --> 01:54:30,588
grand avenue, they do well,

3852
01:54:30,588 --> 01:54:31,790
eventually they have to

3853
01:54:31,790 --> 01:54:33,790
rotate

3854
01:54:34,225 --> 01:54:36,794
out or we could maybe extend

3855
01:54:36,794 --> 01:54:37,562
the lease as well, is that

3856
01:54:37,562 --> 01:54:39,562
another option?

3857
01:54:40,832 --> 01:54:44,269
The idea is to rotate to have

3858
01:54:44,269 --> 01:54:47,269
a -- not a rediscovering

3859
01:54:48,206 --> 01:54:49,841
involver -- revolving door,

3860
01:54:49,841 --> 01:54:51,977
but a pop up business, you

3861
01:54:51,977 --> 01:54:53,144
would help the tenant either

3862
01:54:53,144 --> 01:54:53,511
locate somewhere else, I

3863
01:54:53,511 --> 01:54:54,790
that

3864
01:54:54,790 --> 01:54:55,480
correct, or --

3865
01:54:55,480 --> 01:54:58,160
>> yes, we could do that.

3866
01:54:58,160 --> 01:54:59,684
>> okay, but at that point,

3867
01:54:59,684 --> 01:55:00,385
they're paying potentially

3868
01:55:00,385 --> 01:55:01,787
full market value?

3869
01:55:01,787 --> 01:55:03,787
>> correct.

3870
01:55:03,855 --> 01:55:04,755
>> and that potentially

3871
01:55:04,755 --> 01:55:05,924
could

3872
01:55:05,924 --> 01:55:07,325
be a problem as well because

3873
01:55:07,325 --> 01:55:08,260
they were paying a pretty

3874
01:55:08,260 --> 01:55:10,260
good

3875
01:55:10,329 --> 01:55:11,496
rate and hopefully they were

3876
01:55:11,496 --> 01:55:11,863
start in terms of saving

3877
01:55:11,863 --> 01:55:13,565
their

3878
01:55:13,565 --> 01:55:15,367
money and doing the right

3879
01:55:15,367 --> 01:55:16,834
business model so they're

3880
01:55:16,834 --> 01:55:18,170
reminded, hey, this is only

3881
01:55:18,170 --> 01:55:19,838
temporary, you're going to be

3882
01:55:19,838 --> 01:55:22,441
here, we want to establish

3883
01:55:22,441 --> 01:55:24,209
your business and then

3884
01:55:24,209 --> 01:55:25,611
potentially rotate out into

3885
01:55:25,611 --> 01:55:27,313
another location, so I think

3886
01:55:27,313 --> 01:55:29,614
that's going to be on you and

3887
01:55:29,614 --> 01:55:31,183
staff to say, okay, you could

3888
01:55:31,183 --> 01:55:32,418
have a good business model in

3889
01:55:32,418 --> 01:55:34,190
the sense, you have to get

3890
01:55:34,190 --> 01:55:34,353
ready for the full market,

3891
01:55:34,353 --> 01:55:36,353
you

3892
01:55:36,689 --> 01:55:39,792
know, so I kind of want -- a

3893
01:55:39,792 --> 01:55:42,528
long way of singing on what

3894
01:55:42,528 --> 01:55:43,696
are you asking them to help

3895
01:55:43,696 --> 01:55:45,197
them relocate, I know it's

3896
01:55:45,197 --> 01:55:47,132
early but I want you to be

3897
01:55:47,132 --> 01:55:49,132
thinking about that.

3898
01:55:49,201 --> 01:55:51,601
>> yeah, we haven't gotten

3899
01:55:51,637 --> 01:55:52,771
that far in that planning

3900
01:55:52,771 --> 01:55:55,574
process, but that's part of

3901
01:55:55,574 --> 01:55:56,274
the reason why we want to

3902
01:55:56,274 --> 01:55:56,975
prioritize renaissance

3903
01:55:56,975 --> 01:55:58,975
graduates because they've

3904
01:55:58,978 --> 01:56:00,978
gone

3905
01:56:02,615 --> 01:56:03,649
through an extensive business

3906
01:56:03,649 --> 01:56:04,750
class and, you know, city

3907
01:56:04,750 --> 01:56:06,385
staff will be available to

3908
01:56:06,385 --> 01:56:08,785
help them and renaissance

3909
01:56:09,188 --> 01:56:10,590
staff will be available to

3910
01:56:10,590 --> 01:56:12,224
help them, so, they learn

3911
01:56:12,224 --> 01:56:13,860
these skills of like if

3912
01:56:13,860 --> 01:56:16,362
they're even capable to be

3913
01:56:16,362 --> 01:56:17,297
running a brick and mortar

3914
01:56:17,297 --> 01:56:19,297
business ad hopefully

3915
01:56:20,233 --> 01:56:21,768
scavenging aving -- saving

3916
01:56:21,768 --> 01:56:23,803
some money e even if they

3917
01:56:23,803 --> 01:56:26,803
can't hit that market rate

3918
01:56:27,720 --> 01:56:28,641
rent, maybe it if it's 75%

3919
01:56:28,641 --> 01:56:29,909
market rate, so that's all

3920
01:56:29,909 --> 01:56:33,509
things we'll have to play out

3921
01:56:34,130 --> 01:56:35,882
when we see those numbers.

3922
01:56:35,882 --> 01:56:38,510
>> I look forward to it.

3923
01:56:38,510 --> 01:56:38,984
There is kind of the

3924
01:56:38,984 --> 01:56:40,386
interesting conversation of

3925
01:56:40,386 --> 01:56:41,687
talking to other landlords to

3926
01:56:41,687 --> 01:56:44,687
see if they're interested in

3927
01:56:44,724 --> 01:56:46,560
doing this kind of model.

3928
01:56:46,560 --> 01:56:49,429
Someone said they want a

3929
01:56:49,429 --> 01:56:49,896
permitted kind of tenant,

3930
01:56:49,896 --> 01:56:51,896
than

3931
01:56:51,998 --> 01:56:53,200
a temporary tenant but I'm

3932
01:56:53,200 --> 01:56:55,434
supportive of the concept.

3933
01:56:55,434 --> 01:56:57,404
>> thank you.

3934
01:56:57,404 --> 01:56:59,106
>> I think this I a great

3935
01:56:59,106 --> 01:57:01,408
idea and I wanted to thank

3936
01:57:01,408 --> 01:57:01,774
staff for having the

3937
01:57:01,774 --> 01:57:03,774
visionary

3938
01:57:03,844 --> 01:57:05,678
in them to present this to us

3939
01:57:05,678 --> 01:57:07,247
and to really activate these

3940
01:57:07,247 --> 01:57:08,414
vacant spaces so I'm ready to

3941
01:57:08,414 --> 01:57:10,116
mover forward with the pilot

3942
01:57:10,116 --> 01:57:11,652
program and I can't wait to

3943
01:57:11,652 --> 01:57:12,452
see which businesses move in.

3944
01:57:12,452 --> 01:57:13,420
>> thank you.

3945
01:57:13,420 --> 01:57:14,654
>> thank you, this is

3946
01:57:14,654 --> 01:57:15,922
exciting, this is the right

3947
01:57:15,922 --> 01:57:16,290
direction that we need to

3948
01:57:16,290 --> 01:57:18,290
head

3949
01:57:19,660 --> 01:57:20,861
not only for downtown but for

3950
01:57:20,861 --> 01:57:22,229
our entire city being a

3951
01:57:22,229 --> 01:57:23,163
creative out of the box

3952
01:57:23,163 --> 01:57:24,331
thinking, I really appreciate

3953
01:57:24,331 --> 01:57:26,200
the name too and looking

3954
01:57:26,200 --> 01:57:27,601
forward to the logo.

3955
01:57:27,601 --> 01:57:29,203
In the guidelines when you

3956
01:57:29,203 --> 01:57:30,837
determine who can apply, you

3957
01:57:30,837 --> 01:57:32,205
said for profit businesses

3958
01:57:32,205 --> 01:57:33,640
seeking first south city

3959
01:57:33,640 --> 01:57:34,574
location but you're also

3960
01:57:34,574 --> 01:57:36,176
mentioning this local one

3961
01:57:36,176 --> 01:57:36,876
would have a second south

3962
01:57:36,876 --> 01:57:38,512
city

3963
01:57:38,512 --> 01:57:39,813
location, so is that just a

3964
01:57:39,813 --> 01:57:40,814
caveat for that particular

3965
01:57:40,814 --> 01:57:42,814
case?

3966
01:57:42,916 --> 01:57:44,840
>> so, that's what we mean,

3967
01:57:44,840 --> 01:57:44,552
like, that's what we wanted

3968
01:57:44,552 --> 01:57:46,387
to

3969
01:57:46,387 --> 01:57:48,210
get some guidance on is do we

3970
01:57:48,210 --> 01:57:49,190
want to make an exception to

3971
01:57:49,190 --> 01:57:51,258
this program, do we really

3972
01:57:51,258 --> 01:57:54,258
want to reserve these spaces

3973
01:57:54,328 --> 01:57:55,996
for launch local or would we

3974
01:57:55,996 --> 01:57:58,650
like to have something that's

3975
01:57:58,650 --> 01:57:59,233
possibly a bit more secure

3976
01:57:59,233 --> 01:58:00,801
that's an established

3977
01:58:00,801 --> 01:58:03,201
business, can afford the

3978
01:58:04,472 --> 01:58:05,238
market rate rent and work on

3979
01:58:05,238 --> 01:58:07,638
lease negotiation terms with

3980
01:58:07,742 --> 01:58:09,109
them and then maybe we find a

3981
01:58:09,109 --> 01:58:12,109
different way, like w just

3982
01:58:12,380 --> 01:58:14,682
focus on el camino, do we

3983
01:58:14,682 --> 01:58:15,850
start maybe having talks with

3984
01:58:15,850 --> 01:58:17,251
private property owners?

3985
01:58:17,251 --> 01:58:19,651
>> because it doesn't really

3986
01:58:20,870 --> 01:58:20,788
fit into your name if it's

3987
01:58:20,788 --> 01:58:21,255
launch local, right.

3988
01:58:21,255 --> 01:58:21,555
>> correct.

3989
01:58:21,555 --> 01:58:22,457
Er

3990
01:58:22,457 --> 01:58:23,357
>> you have to rename it.

3991
01:58:23,357 --> 01:58:24,558
>> yes.

3992
01:58:24,558 --> 01:58:26,427
Er

3993
01:58:26,427 --> 01:58:28,827
>> I'm supportive like my

3994
01:58:29,931 --> 01:58:30,632
colleagues have said, I'm

3995
01:58:30,632 --> 01:58:32,632
open

3996
01:58:34,234 --> 01:58:35,503
to el camino, grand avenue we

3997
01:58:35,503 --> 01:58:35,870
could prioritize for our

3998
01:58:35,870 --> 01:58:37,870
local

3999
01:58:38,500 --> 01:58:39,700
businesses here that would

4000
01:58:39,700 --> 01:58:39,473
like to expand, right, or

4001
01:58:39,473 --> 01:58:40,174
have

4002
01:58:40,174 --> 01:58:42,174
a second location.

4003
01:58:46,247 --> 01:58:47,140
I think it fits with the nay

4004
01:58:47,140 --> 01:58:50,614
ture and khur and the fabric

4005
01:58:50,952 --> 01:58:53,352
of downtown and represented

4006
01:58:54,689 --> 01:58:57,689
in that sector of businesses.

4007
01:58:59,940 --> 01:59:00,729
I can't speak enough, their

4008
01:59:00,729 --> 01:59:02,564
program fully vets them and

4009
01:59:02,564 --> 01:59:03,732
fully prepares them, not only

4010
01:59:03,732 --> 01:59:05,533
in city permitting but in

4011
01:59:05,533 --> 01:59:07,135
marketing and being able to

4012
01:59:07,135 --> 01:59:09,104
launch and being able to

4013
01:59:09,104 --> 01:59:11,106
network and really sell and

4014
01:59:11,106 --> 01:59:12,400
equips them with the tools,

4015
01:59:12,400 --> 01:59:14,142
the important tools they need

4016
01:59:14,142 --> 01:59:15,677
to be a successful business

4017
01:59:15,677 --> 01:59:18,580
owner so that's the key for

4018
01:59:18,580 --> 01:59:21,830
me, being able to already

4019
01:59:21,830 --> 01:59:22,918
connect individuals that are

4020
01:59:22,918 --> 01:59:24,453
ready, are in the right

4021
01:59:24,453 --> 01:59:26,421
mindset and the space to move

4022
01:59:26,421 --> 01:59:28,556
forward and I think the lease

4023
01:59:28,556 --> 01:59:30,159
structure and the program

4024
01:59:30,159 --> 01:59:31,793
guidelines are extremely well

4025
01:59:31,793 --> 01:59:33,194
thought out, so I'm very

4026
01:59:33,194 --> 01:59:34,362
supportive of this, thank you.

4027
01:59:34,362 --> 01:59:34,730
Good job again, I appreciate

4028
01:59:34,730 --> 01:59:36,364
this.

4029
01:59:36,364 --> 01:59:37,800
>> I have one more question.

4030
01:59:37,800 --> 01:59:38,133
I was a little bit confused

4031
01:59:38,133 --> 01:59:40,133
by

4032
01:59:40,402 --> 01:59:41,804
some of the questions and the

4033
01:59:41,804 --> 01:59:44,106
answers to MR. Nagales.

4034
01:59:44,106 --> 01:59:48,306
So, if we have somebody go in

4035
01:59:50,445 --> 01:59:51,380
for that 12 months initially,

4036
01:59:51,380 --> 01:59:52,514
they're not automatically out

4037
01:59:52,514 --> 01:59:54,616
in month 13, are they?

4038
01:59:54,616 --> 01:59:56,180
>> no.

4039
01:59:56,180 --> 01:59:56,351
>> a very lng time ago, I

4040
01:59:56,351 --> 01:59:58,351
was

4041
01:59:59,540 --> 01:59:59,488
if business, the first yar

4042
01:59:59,488 --> 02:00:01,488
is

4043
02:00:01,590 --> 02:00:02,258
a xwlaoet blur, you can

4044
02:00:02,258 --> 02:00:04,258
barely

4045
02:00:06,562 --> 02:00:07,930
get your bearings the first

4046
02:00:07,930 --> 02:00:11,530
year, we want somebody to be

4047
02:00:11,834 --> 02:00:12,268
able to grow their roots in a

4048
02:00:12,268 --> 02:00:14,136
business.

4049
02:00:14,136 --> 02:00:15,700
>> yes.

4050
02:00:15,700 --> 02:00:17,440
>> nell selander here, I

4051
02:00:17,440 --> 02:00:19,108
wanted to add one thing, the

4052
02:00:19,108 --> 02:00:20,476
year check-in is a great

4053
02:00:20,476 --> 02:00:21,611
opportunity for us to make

4054
02:00:21,611 --> 02:00:23,478
sure they're oerating the

4055
02:00:23,478 --> 02:00:26,478
business they intended to, so

4056
02:00:26,582 --> 02:00:26,915
one of the big object tiers

4057
02:00:26,915 --> 02:00:28,915
of

4058
02:00:31,200 --> 02:00:34,200
the program is activation and

4059
02:00:36,959 --> 02:00:39,695
being more vibrant and what

4060
02:00:39,695 --> 02:00:40,463
can often happen with a

4061
02:00:40,463 --> 02:00:41,197
business that's struggling is

4062
02:00:41,197 --> 02:00:41,964
their hours get reduced and

4063
02:00:41,964 --> 02:00:42,598
reduced and maybe they start

4064
02:00:42,598 --> 02:00:43,733
using the space for a

4065
02:00:43,733 --> 02:00:46,503
different it is back office

4066
02:00:46,503 --> 02:00:49,506
for this or it's, you know,

4067
02:00:49,506 --> 02:00:51,774
it's nt what was intended by

4068
02:00:51,774 --> 02:00:53,376
the program, so the year

4069
02:00:53,376 --> 02:00:53,843
check-in and the monthly

4070
02:00:53,843 --> 02:00:55,110
sales

4071
02:00:55,110 --> 02:00:56,412
reports are really important

4072
02:00:56,412 --> 02:00:56,746
so that we're getting what

4073
02:00:56,746 --> 02:00:58,281
the

4074
02:00:58,281 --> 02:00:59,215
program is intended to

4075
02:00:59,215 --> 02:01:01,215
provide

4076
02:01:02,953 --> 02:01:04,520
which is active service or

4077
02:01:04,520 --> 02:01:05,522
retail and that year check-in

4078
02:01:05,522 --> 02:01:07,724
will be more about the

4079
02:01:07,724 --> 02:01:10,124
performance of the business

4080
02:01:11,294 --> 02:01:12,596
and can they afford market

4081
02:01:12,596 --> 02:01:14,640
rate today, but we want to

4082
02:01:14,640 --> 02:01:15,932
make sure we have that check

4083
02:01:15,932 --> 02:01:17,334
so we don't end up with

4084
02:01:17,334 --> 02:01:17,834
another space that's

4085
02:01:17,834 --> 02:01:19,168
underutilized.

4086
02:01:19,168 --> 02:01:19,435
>> I think it's interesting

4087
02:01:19,435 --> 02:01:21,435
to

4088
02:01:21,571 --> 02:01:22,739
see so much o the

4089
02:01:22,739 --> 02:01:24,141
construction, the commercial

4090
02:01:24,141 --> 02:01:25,775
development of the ground

4091
02:01:25,775 --> 02:01:27,144
floor has not been a roaring

4092
02:01:27,144 --> 02:01:30,744
success n the city of san

4093
02:01:32,115 --> 02:01:34,318
mateo, there's a doper called

4094
02:01:34,318 --> 02:01:35,652
essex na has a project on dep

4095
02:01:35,652 --> 02:01:36,587
ware avenue near 92, they

4096
02:01:36,587 --> 02:01:38,388
announced they're goipg the

4097
02:01:38,388 --> 02:01:39,623
leave their office space in

4098
02:01:39,623 --> 02:01:40,791
downtown san mateo and take

4099
02:01:40,791 --> 02:01:42,860
over the commercial space on

4100
02:01:42,860 --> 02:01:45,860
the ground floor to ativate

4101
02:01:46,397 --> 02:01:47,864
the other part of the retail

4102
02:01:47,864 --> 02:01:49,466
space, besides the 500 tenant

4103
02:01:49,466 --> 02:01:51,350
that is are in the building,

4104
02:01:51,350 --> 02:01:51,502
they're going to have a

4105
02:01:51,502 --> 02:01:52,903
couple

4106
02:01:52,903 --> 02:01:53,971
of 100 employees working in

4107
02:01:53,971 --> 02:01:55,506
the offices there.

4108
02:01:55,506 --> 02:01:55,873
Are we able to do the same

4109
02:01:55,873 --> 02:01:57,408
thing?

4110
02:01:57,408 --> 02:01:58,542
I know in the past, we had

4111
02:01:58,542 --> 02:02:00,611
some restrictions on what

4112
02:02:00,611 --> 02:02:02,947
could go in the ground floor

4113
02:02:02,947 --> 02:02:04,810
but are we ale to do

4114
02:02:04,810 --> 02:02:05,750
something similar where it

4115
02:02:05,750 --> 02:02:07,284
could b maybe an intense

4116
02:02:07,284 --> 02:02:09,684
office use to generate

4117
02:02:12,389 --> 02:02:13,758
activity on the street?

4118
02:02:13,758 --> 02:02:15,392
>> billy with planning

4119
02:02:15,392 --> 02:02:15,759
division, we have taken a

4120
02:02:15,759 --> 02:02:17,759
way,

4121
02:02:18,663 --> 02:02:20,330
any requirement for even

4122
02:02:20,330 --> 02:02:22,466
commercial space, it's more

4123
02:02:22,466 --> 02:02:25,102
about design, does it have an

4124
02:02:25,102 --> 02:02:26,437
active front, does it have

4125
02:02:26,437 --> 02:02:27,705
windows, it could be office

4126
02:02:27,705 --> 02:02:30,705
space, we don't require there

4127
02:02:31,476 --> 02:02:32,743
to be a certain percentage of

4128
02:02:32,743 --> 02:02:33,544
commercial space, it's all

4129
02:02:33,544 --> 02:02:34,945
design related.

4130
02:02:34,945 --> 02:02:36,581
>> before we were looking for

4131
02:02:36,581 --> 02:02:36,948
the retail experience and

4132
02:02:36,948 --> 02:02:38,948
that

4133
02:02:39,830 --> 02:02:40,985
has evaporated.

4134
02:02:40,985 --> 02:02:42,453
>> it could be a senior

4135
02:02:42,453 --> 02:02:43,210
center, it could be a

4136
02:02:43,210 --> 02:02:45,210
community center.

4137
02:02:45,123 --> 02:02:45,990
It could be a lot of things

4138
02:02:45,990 --> 02:02:47,990
happening, especially I

4139
02:02:48,192 --> 02:02:48,593
downtown and anywhere else.

4140
02:02:48,593 --> 02:02:50,593
Alright.

4141
02:02:50,762 --> 02:02:51,196
If I don't have any o

4142
02:02:51,196 --> 02:02:51,629
ir

4143
02:02:51,629 --> 02:02:52,363
other

4144
02:02:52,363 --> 02:02:54,232
comments or questions --

4145
02:02:54,232 --> 02:02:54,598
>> I just want to clarify

4146
02:02:54,598 --> 02:02:56,598
from

4147
02:02:57,202 --> 02:02:57,636
my understanding, is

4148
02:02:57,636 --> 02:02:59,404
council's

4149
02:02:59,404 --> 02:03:00,772
direction that the preference

4150
02:03:00,772 --> 02:03:01,473
-- are we hearing a

4151
02:03:01,473 --> 02:03:02,607
preference

4152
02:03:02,607 --> 02:03:03,740
for an established business

4153
02:03:03,740 --> 02:03:04,909
to

4154
02:03:04,909 --> 02:03:06,978
rent this retail space at

4155
02:03:06,978 --> 02:03:10,578
market rate or are you saying

4156
02:03:11,549 --> 02:03:12,517
we should give preference to

4157
02:03:12,517 --> 02:03:14,419
the launch local folks?

4158
02:03:14,419 --> 02:03:15,554
I'm trying to understand what

4159
02:03:15,554 --> 02:03:17,554
your preference is.

4160
02:03:18,623 --> 02:03:20,492
We would -- the el camino one

4161
02:03:20,492 --> 02:03:21,660
is vacant, that could be a

4162
02:03:21,660 --> 02:03:23,610
launch local, and in the

4163
02:03:23,610 --> 02:03:23,995
future, other city owned

4164
02:03:23,995 --> 02:03:25,163
properties could become

4165
02:03:25,163 --> 02:03:26,331
vacant, once we have the

4166
02:03:26,331 --> 02:03:28,731
guidelines and the framework

4167
02:03:30,350 --> 02:03:31,436
and we have one pilot in el

4168
02:03:31,436 --> 02:03:33,710
camino, I'm trying to get

4169
02:03:33,710 --> 02:03:33,705
whether we should pursue this

4170
02:03:33,705 --> 02:03:34,139
other opportunity for

4171
02:03:34,139 --> 02:03:36,740
somebody

4172
02:03:36,740 --> 02:03:37,475
that wants tos rent it at

4173
02:03:37,475 --> 02:03:38,343
market rate or hold those

4174
02:03:38,343 --> 02:03:40,743
spaces for launch local.

4175
02:03:40,946 --> 02:03:42,814
I want to be clear with that.

4176
02:03:42,814 --> 02:03:43,949
>> aisle reiterate, you can't

4177
02:03:43,949 --> 02:03:45,350
imagine smebody walking by

4178
02:03:45,350 --> 02:03:46,484
and somebody wants to do

4179
02:03:46,484 --> 02:03:48,153
market rate right now.

4180
02:03:48,153 --> 02:03:51,753
>> that's how I feel, and in

4181
02:03:53,492 --> 02:03:55,461
terms of making sure that the

4182
02:03:55,461 --> 02:03:56,494
historical effects, maybe the

4183
02:03:56,494 --> 02:03:58,894
historical society will be

4184
02:04:00,165 --> 02:04:00,598
pressed and we'll focus on

4185
02:04:00,598 --> 02:04:02,598
the

4186
02:04:02,902 --> 02:04:03,369
366 el camino, perhaps what

4187
02:04:03,369 --> 02:04:05,136
we

4188
02:04:05,136 --> 02:04:06,572
can do is perhaps the

4189
02:04:06,572 --> 02:04:08,941
renaissance graduates will be

4190
02:04:08,941 --> 02:04:11,941
-- because the place there,

4191
02:04:14,460 --> 02:04:16,682
there's a lab and a florist,

4192
02:04:16,682 --> 02:04:17,883
maybe something that will be

4193
02:04:17,883 --> 02:04:18,584
complementing to those

4194
02:04:18,584 --> 02:04:19,818
establishments that are

4195
02:04:19,818 --> 02:04:21,818
already in there.

4196
02:04:22,788 --> 02:04:24,390
i went to milty lab one day

4197
02:04:24,390 --> 02:04:25,791
and there's long line and a

4198
02:04:25,791 --> 02:04:27,660
long waiting list so I think

4199
02:04:27,660 --> 02:04:29,294
the business is tieing and

4200
02:04:29,294 --> 02:04:29,695
florist, it looks like

4201
02:04:29,695 --> 02:04:31,695
they're

4202
02:04:31,763 --> 02:04:32,932
doing business, so I think

4203
02:04:32,932 --> 02:04:34,932
from the renaissance

4204
02:04:35,340 --> 02:04:36,569
graduates, we can have a hand

4205
02:04:36,569 --> 02:04:38,704
in picking out all of those

4206
02:04:38,704 --> 02:04:40,305
that we will be doing the

4207
02:04:40,305 --> 02:04:42,308
launch local projects so that

4208
02:04:42,308 --> 02:04:44,110
we will be assured they will

4209
02:04:44,110 --> 02:04:46,110
be thriving.

4210
02:04:51,617 --> 02:04:53,486
>> got it, thank you so much.

4211
02:04:53,486 --> 02:04:54,521
>> that's not just one, it is

4212
02:04:54,521 --> 02:04:56,656
a huge space, hopefully that

4213
02:04:56,656 --> 02:04:57,924
is one of the tenants there,

4214
02:04:57,924 --> 02:05:00,827
hopefully we get that taken

4215
02:05:00,827 --> 02:05:02,662
care of too, right.

4216
02:05:02,662 --> 02:05:03,897
>> great, you have direction.

4217
02:05:03,897 --> 02:05:04,898
I think this is also

4218
02:05:04,898 --> 02:05:06,898
important

4219
02:05:08,201 --> 02:05:08,534
to note that it's good the

4220
02:05:08,534 --> 02:05:09,369
one

4221
02:05:09,369 --> 02:05:10,269
year check-in, provide data

4222
02:05:10,269 --> 02:05:10,837
for us, right.

4223
02:05:10,837 --> 02:05:11,705
That way request

4224
02:05:11,705 --> 02:05:12,839
f we can

4225
02:05:12,839 --> 02:05:14,473
make an informed decision.

4226
02:05:14,473 --> 02:05:15,909
I think after all this I a

4227
02:05:15,909 --> 02:05:16,242
pilot program so we're able

4228
02:05:16,242 --> 02:05:17,744
to

4229
02:05:17,744 --> 02:05:19,178
kind of finesse and tweak a

4230
02:05:19,178 --> 02:05:21,140
few things but for right now,

4231
02:05:21,140 --> 02:05:23,215
this is what we're -- I'm

4232
02:05:23,215 --> 02:05:24,317
hearing consensus from my

4233
02:05:24,317 --> 02:05:25,180
colleagues here.

4234
02:05:25,180 --> 02:05:25,684
Good?

4235
02:05:25,684 --> 02:05:27,530
Okay.

4236
02:05:27,530 --> 02:05:28,622
>> you need a motion?

4237
02:05:28,622 --> 02:05:29,423
>> let me check on public

4238
02:05:29,423 --> 02:05:30,857
comments first.

4239
02:05:30,857 --> 02:05:31,958
>> no pblic comments but we

4240
02:05:31,958 --> 02:05:34,358
do need a motion.

4241
02:05:35,962 --> 02:05:37,364
>> we do need a motion now.

4242
02:05:37,364 --> 02:05:37,898
>> I will make the motion, is

4243
02:05:37,898 --> 02:05:38,999
there a second?

4244
02:05:38,999 --> 02:05:40,233
>> I second.

4245
02:05:40,233 --> 02:05:42,336
>> thank you, piser and

4246
02:05:42,336 --> 02:05:43,503
second, roll call.

4247
02:05:43,503 --> 02:05:44,637
>> vice mayor yeasting goe?

4248
02:05:44,637 --> 02:05:45,339
>> yes.

4249
02:05:45,339 --> 02:05:45,805
>> councilmember coleman?

4250
02:05:45,805 --> 02:05:46,974
>> yes.

4251
02:05:46,974 --> 02:05:47,274
Er maifrjt yor flores?

4252
02:05:47,274 --> 02:05:48,809
.

4253
02:05:48,809 --> 02:05:49,510
Inger yes.

4254
02:05:49,510 --> 02:05:51,111
>> councilmember nagales?

4255
02:05:51,111 --> 02:05:51,812
>> aye.

4256
02:05:51,812 --> 02:05:52,746
>> councilmember nicolas?

4257
02:05:52,746 --> 02:05:54,746
>> aye.

4258
02:05:58,885 --> 02:06:00,520
>> moving on to item 11 is a

4259
02:06:00,520 --> 02:06:02,122
record regarding a resolution

4260
02:06:02,122 --> 02:06:03,657
approving an increase to the

4261
02:06:03,657 --> 02:06:06,570
south san francisco toe

4262
02:06:06,293 --> 02:06:07,694
services rates to the maximum

4263
02:06:07,694 --> 02:06:09,229
allowable toeing rate that is

4264
02:06:09,229 --> 02:06:09,763
are comparable to other

4265
02:06:09,763 --> 02:06:10,864
police

4266
02:06:10,864 --> 02:06:12,332
agencies in northern san

4267
02:06:12,332 --> 02:06:12,733
mateo

4268
02:06:12,733 --> 02:06:14,602
county.

4269
02:06:14,602 --> 02:06:16,300
And 11a is the resolution.

4270
02:06:16,300 --> 02:06:16,370
>> tla's why you all are here

4271
02:06:16,370 --> 02:06:18,370
today.

4272
02:06:19,730 --> 02:06:20,407
>> thank you, good evening,

4273
02:06:20,407 --> 02:06:22,900
councilmembers, my name is

4274
02:06:22,900 --> 02:06:23,611
adam plank, one of the

4275
02:06:23,611 --> 02:06:24,311
captains with the police

4276
02:06:24,311 --> 02:06:25,246
department.

4277
02:06:25,246 --> 02:06:27,246
Tonight my presentation

4278
02:06:27,314 --> 02:06:29,916
involves an overview of the

4279
02:06:29,916 --> 02:06:31,452
city's rotational tow

4280
02:06:31,452 --> 02:06:33,120
program

4281
02:06:33,120 --> 02:06:36,720
and a request to update those

4282
02:06:36,891 --> 02:06:37,324
fees ask the industry

4283
02:06:37,324 --> 02:06:38,960
standard

4284
02:06:38,960 --> 02:06:41,361
for city ins san mateo county.

4285
02:06:41,361 --> 02:06:43,761
The police department have

4286
02:07:00,480 --> 02:07:01,182
vehicles removed from the

4287
02:07:01,182 --> 02:07:02,317
[Inaudible] Insurance

4288
02:07:02,317 --> 02:07:02,784
requirements, alcohol and

4289
02:07:02,784 --> 02:07:04,185
drug

4290
02:07:04,185 --> 02:07:06,488
testing loosing kaix of where

4291
02:07:06,488 --> 02:07:08,155
those storage lots are,

4292
02:07:08,155 --> 02:07:09,757
response times, safeguarding

4293
02:07:09,757 --> 02:07:10,924
vehicles and following the

4294
02:07:10,924 --> 02:07:12,560
maximum rates that tow

4295
02:07:12,560 --> 02:07:13,261
companies can charge for

4296
02:07:13,261 --> 02:07:13,962
police generated tows are

4297
02:07:13,962 --> 02:07:15,597
some

4298
02:07:15,597 --> 02:07:17,597
of those regulations.

4299
02:07:19,267 --> 02:07:21,100
Those regulations ensure that

4300
02:07:21,100 --> 02:07:21,670
tow companies provide safe

4301
02:07:21,670 --> 02:07:22,437
quality service to our

4302
02:07:22,437 --> 02:07:23,738
community and their vehicles

4303
02:07:23,738 --> 02:07:24,673
are accessible and within

4304
02:07:24,673 --> 02:07:27,730
secured storage facilities if

4305
02:07:27,142 --> 02:07:28,310
south san francisco.

4306
02:07:28,310 --> 02:07:28,710
A police generated tow

4307
02:07:28,710 --> 02:07:30,710
request

4308
02:07:33,800 --> 02:07:33,481
can happen for a variety of

4309
02:07:33,481 --> 02:07:35,481
reasons.

4310
02:07:35,750 --> 02:07:36,918
And those could include a

4311
02:07:36,918 --> 02:07:39,318
vehicle that's blocking a

4312
02:07:39,488 --> 02:07:41,890
roadway and cannot be safely

4313
02:07:41,890 --> 02:07:43,124
moved, certain violations of

4314
02:07:43,124 --> 02:07:43,558
the vehicle code like

4315
02:07:43,558 --> 02:07:44,459
blocking

4316
02:07:44,459 --> 02:07:46,160
someone's driveway and we're

4317
02:07:46,160 --> 02:07:47,529
unable to get a hold of that

4318
02:07:47,529 --> 02:07:48,963
owner, parking in a a posted

4319
02:07:48,963 --> 02:07:50,565
construction zone, a marked

4320
02:07:50,565 --> 02:07:50,899
tow away zone and we can't

4321
02:07:50,899 --> 02:07:52,899
get

4322
02:07:53,368 --> 02:07:55,704
a hold of those owners and

4323
02:07:55,704 --> 02:07:56,400
also when certain cases when

4324
02:07:56,400 --> 02:07:57,720
a

4325
02:07:57,720 --> 02:07:57,539
driver's arrested, the

4326
02:07:57,539 --> 02:07:58,874
vehicle

4327
02:07:58,874 --> 02:07:59,408
can't safely remain parked at

4328
02:07:59,408 --> 02:08:01,408
the scene.

4329
02:08:03,912 --> 02:08:05,547
We do make attempts to locate

4330
02:08:05,547 --> 02:08:06,815
the owner and have the

4331
02:08:06,815 --> 02:08:08,417
vehicle

4332
02:08:08,417 --> 02:08:10,886
moved prior to it being towed

4333
02:08:10,886 --> 02:08:12,187
in the crcumstances where we

4334
02:08:12,187 --> 02:08:14,456
have that ability to make

4335
02:08:14,456 --> 02:08:15,157
that

4336
02:08:15,157 --> 02:08:16,392
decision.

4337
02:08:16,392 --> 02:08:18,126
Our mximum allowable tow

4338
02:08:18,126 --> 02:08:20,329
rates have been unchanged

4339
02:08:20,329 --> 02:08:22,164
since 2016 resulting in our

4340
02:08:22,164 --> 02:08:23,765
rates being the lowest of the

4341
02:08:23,765 --> 02:08:25,367
8 jurisdictions in northern

4342
02:08:25,367 --> 02:08:27,367
san mateo county.

4343
02:08:29,380 --> 02:08:31,438
Tow companies like other

4344
02:08:31,641 --> 02:08:33,641
businesses have expressed

4345
02:08:34,760 --> 02:08:35,711
experiences with increased

4346
02:08:35,711 --> 02:08:37,313
operational costs like rent,

4347
02:08:37,313 --> 02:08:37,780
equipment, fuel, insurance

4348
02:08:37,780 --> 02:08:39,780
and

4349
02:08:40,215 --> 02:08:41,217
labor costs, per our

4350
02:08:41,217 --> 02:08:43,217
municipal

4351
02:08:43,753 --> 02:08:46,153
code, those police maximum

4352
02:08:47,256 --> 02:08:49,792
allowable tow fees can be

4353
02:08:49,792 --> 02:08:50,493
adjusted after a review from

4354
02:08:50,493 --> 02:08:51,360
the police department and

4355
02:08:51,360 --> 02:08:51,828
after speaking to a

4356
02:08:51,828 --> 02:08:53,828
designated

4357
02:08:54,630 --> 02:08:54,497
representative of those tow

4358
02:08:54,497 --> 02:08:55,899
companies.

4359
02:08:55,899 --> 02:08:58,701
And conducting a survey of

4360
02:08:58,701 --> 02:09:00,503
what the other rotational tow

4361
02:09:00,503 --> 02:09:02,903
companies in northern san

4362
02:09:03,406 --> 02:09:05,410
mateo county cities charge.

4363
02:09:05,410 --> 02:09:08,144
The current fee in south san

4364
02:09:08,144 --> 02:09:09,512
francisco for a basic tow fee

4365
02:09:09,512 --> 02:09:10,546
is $225.

4366
02:09:10,546 --> 02:09:11,947
After meeting with the

4367
02:09:11,947 --> 02:09:14,284
representative of the tow

4368
02:09:14,284 --> 02:09:16,684
companies, we conducted a

4369
02:09:19,188 --> 02:09:20,356
survey, as you can se on the

4370
02:09:20,356 --> 02:09:23,356
chart, san francisco fees are

4371
02:09:23,993 --> 02:09:26,993
the lowest of those 8 cities

4372
02:09:27,564 --> 02:09:29,866
in northern san mateo county.

4373
02:09:29,866 --> 02:09:31,668
The srvey that we conducted

4374
02:09:31,668 --> 02:09:32,200
taking south san francisco

4375
02:09:32,200 --> 02:09:34,200
out

4376
02:09:35,237 --> 02:09:36,973
showed an average of $323 per

4377
02:09:36,973 --> 02:09:37,974
tow as being the average

4378
02:09:37,974 --> 02:09:40,374
levering south san francisco

4379
02:09:40,676 --> 02:09:44,413
in as one of the 8 -- the

4380
02:09:44,413 --> 02:09:45,348
average would be $311 per tow.

4381
02:09:45,348 --> 02:09:46,983
The tow companies in addition

4382
02:09:46,983 --> 02:09:48,384
to the survey, the tow

4383
02:09:48,384 --> 02:09:49,519
companies have proposed we

4384
02:09:49,519 --> 02:09:50,454
increase the basic tow

4385
02:09:50,454 --> 02:09:52,322
service

4386
02:09:52,322 --> 02:09:54,191
fee to $325 so they remain

4387
02:09:54,191 --> 02:09:55,259
comparable to other

4388
02:09:55,259 --> 02:09:56,590
jurisdictions in northern san

4389
02:09:56,590 --> 02:09:58,590
mateo cunty.

4390
02:10:00,264 --> 02:10:03,600
On our next slide, you will

4391
02:10:03,600 --> 02:10:06,236
see what those proposed rates

4392
02:10:06,236 --> 02:10:07,771
would be and the additional

4393
02:10:07,771 --> 02:10:09,539
services that are involved in

4394
02:10:09,539 --> 02:10:11,539
towing vehicles.

4395
02:10:11,608 --> 02:10:12,843
It's important to note that

4396
02:10:12,843 --> 02:10:15,312
most vehicles only require a

4397
02:10:15,312 --> 02:10:16,120
basic tow and a basic storage

4398
02:10:16,120 --> 02:10:16,947
fee.

4399
02:10:16,947 --> 02:10:17,881
On some occassions,

4400
02:10:17,881 --> 02:10:20,281
specialized equipment lke a

4401
02:10:21,118 --> 02:10:22,987
flat bed a dolly, or a more

4402
02:10:22,987 --> 02:10:24,822
heavy duty medium sized heavy

4403
02:10:24,822 --> 02:10:27,123
duty or super duty truck are

4404
02:10:27,123 --> 02:10:29,760
needed to safely remover a

4405
02:10:29,760 --> 02:10:31,862
vehicle, a bus, a larger

4406
02:10:31,862 --> 02:10:34,862
vehicle from the safe --

4407
02:10:35,650 --> 02:10:37,465
safely from the road.

4408
02:10:38,969 --> 02:10:40,604
On our next slide, if the

4409
02:10:40,604 --> 02:10:42,940
proposed fees were accepted

4410
02:10:42,940 --> 02:10:44,909
and approved, this would show

4411
02:10:44,909 --> 02:10:47,110
where south san francisco

4412
02:10:47,110 --> 02:10:48,412
would be with those adjusted

4413
02:10:48,412 --> 02:10:49,847
rates, it's not at the very

4414
02:10:49,847 --> 02:10:52,847
top, it's in the middle,

4415
02:10:53,170 --> 02:10:55,353
comparable with the other

4416
02:10:55,353 --> 02:10:57,221
agencies.

4417
02:10:57,221 --> 02:10:58,856
In speaking with a couple

4418
02:10:58,856 --> 02:10:59,190
other agencies in northern

4419
02:10:59,190 --> 02:11:00,258
san

4420
02:11:00,258 --> 02:11:01,893
mateo county, I learned that

4421
02:11:01,893 --> 02:11:02,260
there are other cities on

4422
02:11:02,260 --> 02:11:04,260
this

4423
02:11:05,563 --> 02:11:06,964
list that are looking to also

4424
02:11:06,964 --> 02:11:09,133
evaluate and adjust their

4425
02:11:09,133 --> 02:11:11,368
rates to keep them current

4426
02:11:11,368 --> 02:11:13,768
with the industry standard.

4427
02:11:14,138 --> 02:11:15,240
As noted in the staff report,

4428
02:11:15,240 --> 02:11:17,174
but worth mentioning tonight,

4429
02:11:17,174 --> 02:11:18,676
all all of the proposed fees

4430
02:11:18,676 --> 02:11:19,100
we're talking about do not

4431
02:11:19,100 --> 02:11:20,144
get

4432
02:11:20,144 --> 02:11:22,947
paid to the city, these are

4433
02:11:22,947 --> 02:11:24,348
paid to the tow truck

4434
02:11:24,348 --> 02:11:26,651
companies and for their

4435
02:11:26,651 --> 02:11:28,520
services in towing these

4436
02:11:28,520 --> 02:11:29,421
vehicles dependent upon the

4437
02:11:29,421 --> 02:11:31,421
circumstances.

4438
02:11:31,723 --> 02:11:33,910
So, in conclusion, the

4439
02:11:33,910 --> 02:11:34,926
rotational tow program

4440
02:11:34,926 --> 02:11:36,794
establishes a standard level

4441
02:11:36,794 --> 02:11:38,629
of service that tow companies

4442
02:11:38,629 --> 02:11:40,265
must provide, it's regulated,

4443
02:11:40,265 --> 02:11:42,334
when performing their police

4444
02:11:42,334 --> 02:11:44,402
generated tows, the maximum

4445
02:11:44,402 --> 02:11:46,938
allowable tow fees have been

4446
02:11:46,938 --> 02:11:47,873
unchanged since 2016 and

4447
02:11:47,873 --> 02:11:49,274
currently don't accurately

4448
02:11:49,274 --> 02:11:51,674
reflect the industry standard

4449
02:11:51,810 --> 02:11:52,978
for northern san mateo county.

4450
02:11:52,978 --> 02:11:54,379
It's recommended that city

4451
02:11:54,379 --> 02:11:55,781
council review and adopt the

4452
02:11:55,781 --> 02:11:57,182
proposed rate adjustments for

4453
02:11:57,182 --> 02:11:59,510
the maximum allowable fees

4454
02:11:59,510 --> 02:11:59,751
associated with police

4455
02:11:59,751 --> 02:12:01,751
generated tow services.

4456
02:12:02,287 --> 02:12:03,522
Thank you, that concludes my

4457
02:12:03,522 --> 02:12:05,522
presentation, I'm available

4458
02:12:05,557 --> 02:12:05,924
for questions and with me

4459
02:12:05,924 --> 02:12:07,250
here

4460
02:12:07,250 --> 02:12:07,826
tonight are a representative

4461
02:12:07,826 --> 02:12:08,260
from each of the tow

4462
02:12:08,260 --> 02:12:10,260
companies

4463
02:12:10,429 --> 02:12:11,496
if you have an operational

4464
02:12:11,496 --> 02:12:11,930
question or something

4465
02:12:11,930 --> 02:12:12,964
specific

4466
02:12:12,964 --> 02:12:14,990
that I wouldn't be able to

4467
02:12:14,990 --> 02:12:16,990
answer for you.

4468
02:12:16,234 --> 02:12:16,702
>> thank you, captain plank,

4469
02:12:16,702 --> 02:12:17,636
I

4470
02:12:17,636 --> 02:12:19,636
appreciate the presentation.

4471
02:12:21,506 --> 02:12:22,641
Any questions?

4472
02:12:22,641 --> 02:12:24,243
Councilmember nagales?

4473
02:12:24,243 --> 02:12:26,780
>> thank you.

4474
02:12:26,780 --> 02:12:27,479
I appreciate kind of just

4475
02:12:27,479 --> 02:12:28,614
understanding what the actual

4476
02:12:28,614 --> 02:12:29,140
increase is ging to be

4477
02:12:29,140 --> 02:12:31,140
paying

4478
02:12:32,451 --> 02:12:34,186
for because I wasn't quite

4479
02:12:34,186 --> 02:12:35,588
sure, like, I was looking at

4480
02:12:35,588 --> 02:12:36,755
it like, okay, aren't we

4481
02:12:36,755 --> 02:12:39,755
getting a better deal by

4482
02:12:40,860 --> 02:12:42,610
paying less I terms of the

4483
02:12:42,610 --> 02:12:43,429
rate but you answered the

4484
02:12:43,429 --> 02:12:44,530
question for me.

4485
02:12:44,530 --> 02:12:46,198
So, when someone goes in, I

4486
02:12:46,198 --> 02:12:47,600
want to understand the fees

4487
02:12:47,600 --> 02:12:49,234
here, so what you're asking

4488
02:12:49,234 --> 02:12:52,605
for the basic tow fees is

4489
02:12:52,605 --> 02:12:54,140
going to be 325 now, the

4490
02:12:54,140 --> 02:12:54,706
person would come in and pay

4491
02:12:54,706 --> 02:12:56,374
for that.

4492
02:12:56,374 --> 02:12:57,509
There was something about an

4493
02:12:57,509 --> 02:12:59,377
administrative fee on the

4494
02:12:59,377 --> 02:13:00,713
bottom of the attachment b,

4495
02:13:00,713 --> 02:13:01,247
there was an administrative

4496
02:13:01,247 --> 02:13:02,982
fee?

4497
02:13:02,982 --> 02:13:03,415
>> yes, on the bottom of the

4498
02:13:03,415 --> 02:13:04,170
tow form?

4499
02:13:04,170 --> 02:13:06,170
>> yes.

4500
02:13:08,200 --> 02:13:09,955
>> yes, that is a south city

4501
02:13:09,955 --> 02:13:11,724
of south san francisco fee

4502
02:13:11,724 --> 02:13:14,594
that's in our master fee

4503
02:13:14,594 --> 02:13:15,280
schedule for the processing

4504
02:13:15,280 --> 02:13:16,628
of

4505
02:13:16,628 --> 02:13:18,640
paperwork, the mailing of

4506
02:13:18,640 --> 02:13:21,640
notices when a vehicle gets

4507
02:13:22,100 --> 02:13:23,169
towed to the registered

4508
02:13:23,169 --> 02:13:25,138
owner, that's the

4509
02:13:25,138 --> 02:13:27,538
administrative costs that are

4510
02:13:27,640 --> 02:13:28,942
paid to the police department

4511
02:13:28,942 --> 02:13:31,342
when there's a police

4512
02:13:31,744 --> 02:13:33,246
generated tow.

4513
02:13:33,246 --> 02:13:34,647
>> so I want to get that

4514
02:13:34,647 --> 02:13:36,490
process correct, when

4515
02:13:36,490 --> 02:13:39,490
someone's car gets towed, not

4516
02:13:39,185 --> 02:13:40,787
only are they paying

4517
02:13:40,787 --> 02:13:41,154
potentially a $325 towing

4518
02:13:41,154 --> 02:13:43,154
fee,

4519
02:13:43,156 --> 02:13:43,890
but now they're paying this

4520
02:13:43,890 --> 02:13:44,758
administrative fee as well?

4521
02:13:44,758 --> 02:13:46,758
>> yes, that's correct.

4522
02:13:47,294 --> 02:13:47,661
And that's a vehicle release

4523
02:13:47,661 --> 02:13:49,529
fee.

4524
02:13:49,529 --> 02:13:49,829
>> which is $160 now.

4525
02:13:49,829 --> 02:13:51,829
Er

4526
02:13:52,566 --> 02:13:54,201
>> yes, it is.

4527
02:13:54,201 --> 02:13:54,634
>> okay, has there been a

4528
02:13:54,634 --> 02:13:56,269
time

4529
02:13:56,269 --> 02:13:56,603
when an individual has come

4530
02:13:56,603 --> 02:13:58,380
to

4531
02:13:58,380 --> 02:14:00,373
the towing company and sy I

4532
02:14:00,373 --> 02:14:00,740
can't pay for these fees,

4533
02:14:00,740 --> 02:14:01,308
it's

4534
02:14:01,308 --> 02:14:02,476
too high.

4535
02:14:02,476 --> 02:14:05,579
Is there like a payment plan

4536
02:14:05,579 --> 02:14:06,846
that a person can do in terms

4537
02:14:06,846 --> 02:14:09,215
of trying to release the

4538
02:14:09,215 --> 02:14:10,150
vehicle?

4539
02:14:10,150 --> 02:14:10,617
>> in speaking to at least

4540
02:14:10,617 --> 02:14:12,617
one

4541
02:14:13,987 --> 02:14:15,322
of the companies, they did

4542
02:14:15,322 --> 02:14:15,688
express an option case by

4543
02:14:15,688 --> 02:14:16,590
case

4544
02:14:16,590 --> 02:14:18,990
based on the circumstances

4545
02:14:19,426 --> 02:14:23,260
where a payment plan might be

4546
02:14:23,230 --> 02:14:25,332
an option but it's also

4547
02:14:25,332 --> 02:14:27,133
somewhat o a risky option if

4548
02:14:27,133 --> 02:14:28,569
the vhicle is being released

4549
02:14:28,569 --> 02:14:30,304
and there's an agreement that

4550
02:14:30,304 --> 02:14:32,304
doesn't get fulfilled.

4551
02:14:34,400 --> 02:14:34,807
>> now, the person's already

4552
02:14:34,807 --> 02:14:36,377
being penalized already, and

4553
02:14:36,377 --> 02:14:37,744
for those who are potentially

4554
02:14:37,744 --> 02:14:39,146
low income and having a

4555
02:14:39,146 --> 02:14:40,781
difficult time paying for

4556
02:14:40,781 --> 02:14:41,248
these fees, a lot of the

4557
02:14:41,248 --> 02:14:42,416
folks

4558
02:14:42,416 --> 02:14:45,452
rely on their vehicle to get

4559
02:14:45,452 --> 02:14:48,989
to work or to get to point a

4560
02:14:48,989 --> 02:14:49,390
to point b, so I'm just

4561
02:14:49,390 --> 02:14:50,390
trying

4562
02:14:50,390 --> 02:14:50,791
to understand what the

4563
02:14:50,791 --> 02:14:52,791
process

4564
02:14:52,893 --> 02:14:53,894
is in terms of if someone is

4565
02:14:53,894 --> 02:14:54,294
having a difficult time

4566
02:14:54,294 --> 02:14:54,996
paying

4567
02:14:54,996 --> 02:14:56,397
for it.

4568
02:14:56,397 --> 02:14:58,232
If the person can't pay for

4569
02:14:58,232 --> 02:15:00,167
it, the car is going to be in

4570
02:15:00,167 --> 02:15:03,167
storage and now they can't

4571
02:15:03,204 --> 02:15:04,772
travel, you know or I guess

4572
02:15:04,772 --> 02:15:05,772
they have to take public

4573
02:15:05,772 --> 02:15:08,772
transportation in this case z.

4574
02:15:09,143 --> 02:15:11,110
>> from speak toing the tow

4575
02:15:11,110 --> 02:15:11,679
companies, the tow fee and

4576
02:15:11,679 --> 02:15:13,679
any

4577
02:15:13,881 --> 02:15:15,881
associated storage fees

4578
02:15:16,751 --> 02:15:18,152
usually isn't the hurdle that

4579
02:15:18,152 --> 02:15:21,989
needs to get over in order to

4580
02:15:21,989 --> 02:15:24,580
get the car out.

4581
02:15:24,580 --> 02:15:24,659
Oftentimes, there is

4582
02:15:24,659 --> 02:15:26,160
associated expired

4583
02:15:26,160 --> 02:15:28,662
registration fee that is are

4584
02:15:28,662 --> 02:15:30,531
owed to dmv that ae required

4585
02:15:30,531 --> 02:15:31,232
to be paid in current prior

4586
02:15:31,232 --> 02:15:32,166
to

4587
02:15:32,166 --> 02:15:32,600
getting thing vehicle

4588
02:15:32,600 --> 02:15:34,600
released

4589
02:15:34,936 --> 02:15:37,336
and back to them.

4590
02:15:39,173 --> 02:15:40,108
Also if there are other

4591
02:15:40,108 --> 02:15:41,642
circumstances, a driver's

4592
02:15:41,642 --> 02:15:43,844
license if the registered

4593
02:15:43,844 --> 02:15:45,113
owner has a a dmv issue that

4594
02:15:45,113 --> 02:15:46,114
needs to be corrected, there

4595
02:15:46,114 --> 02:15:49,114
might be something that needs

4596
02:15:49,116 --> 02:15:51,185
to be handled at dmv prior to

4597
02:15:51,185 --> 02:15:52,854
going to the tow to address

4598
02:15:52,854 --> 02:15:55,357
the basic fee and storage.

4599
02:15:55,357 --> 02:15:56,791
>> thank you for answering

4600
02:15:56,791 --> 02:15:57,959
that, I wonder if this is a a

4601
02:15:57,959 --> 02:15:58,360
hindrance in trying to

4602
02:15:58,360 --> 02:16:00,294
release

4603
02:16:00,294 --> 02:16:00,762
the vehicle, but it sound

4604
02:16:00,762 --> 02:16:02,397
like

4605
02:16:02,397 --> 02:16:04,499
that's not the main issue.

4606
02:16:04,499 --> 02:16:05,934
Are they located in south san

4607
02:16:05,934 --> 02:16:07,535
francisco, these three

4608
02:16:07,535 --> 02:16:09,535
companies?

4609
02:16:11,606 --> 02:16:13,509
>> bob junior's is located on

4610
02:16:13,509 --> 02:16:16,509
south linden, action tow has

4611
02:16:16,944 --> 02:16:19,281
an office on north canal --

4612
02:16:19,281 --> 02:16:22,500
south canal and courtesy tow,

4613
02:16:22,500 --> 02:16:23,418
I'm drawing a blank.

4614
02:16:23,418 --> 02:16:23,785
On montgomery avenue jst

4615
02:16:23,785 --> 02:16:24,820
into

4616
02:16:24,820 --> 02:16:26,820
san bruno.

4617
02:16:27,656 --> 02:16:28,560
>> that means the fast

4618
02:16:28,560 --> 02:16:29,580
service

4619
02:16:29,580 --> 02:16:30,926
service when we need tem.

4620
02:16:30,926 --> 02:16:31,660
>> which is one of the

4621
02:16:31,660 --> 02:16:32,794
requirements, either within

4622
02:16:32,794 --> 02:16:33,895
south san francisco or a

4623
02:16:33,895 --> 02:16:34,263
certain distance from our

4624
02:16:34,263 --> 02:16:36,263
city

4625
02:16:36,498 --> 02:16:38,600
limit that is allows anyone

4626
02:16:38,600 --> 02:16:39,767
who's having their car towed

4627
02:16:39,767 --> 02:16:42,700
from our police department

4628
02:16:42,700 --> 02:16:44,470
doesn't have to travel

4629
02:16:44,740 --> 02:16:45,874
multiple cities away or be

4630
02:16:45,874 --> 02:16:46,609
inconvenienced in order to

4631
02:16:46,609 --> 02:16:48,210
access their car.

4632
02:16:48,210 --> 02:16:48,844
>> okay, thank you, I'm fine

4633
02:16:48,844 --> 02:16:49,278
with this now.

4634
02:16:49,278 --> 02:16:50,713
Thank you.

4635
02:16:50,713 --> 02:16:52,713
>> thank you.

4636
02:16:53,480 --> 02:16:54,683
Other questions?

4637
02:16:54,683 --> 02:16:56,683
Go ahead, COUNCILWOMAN.

4638
02:16:56,752 --> 02:16:59,288
>> captain plank, if a a car

4639
02:16:59,288 --> 02:17:01,657
is towed not because of te

4640
02:17:01,657 --> 02:17:02,570
owner's fault, say for

4641
02:17:02,570 --> 02:17:03,759
example

4642
02:17:03,759 --> 02:17:05,127
it's been car napped and

4643
02:17:05,127 --> 02:17:07,897
vandalized and it didn't get

4644
02:17:07,897 --> 02:17:10,232
to an owner until sometime

4645
02:17:10,232 --> 02:17:11,667
later, how -- are they still

4646
02:17:11,667 --> 02:17:12,301
liable to pay for all those

4647
02:17:12,301 --> 02:17:14,301
charges?

4648
02:17:17,539 --> 02:17:19,141
>> if a vehicle is recovered

4649
02:17:19,141 --> 02:17:19,808
stolen vehicle, if the

4650
02:17:19,808 --> 02:17:20,209
registered owner is the

4651
02:17:20,209 --> 02:17:21,577
victim

4652
02:17:21,577 --> 02:17:21,911
of a crime and it's towed as

4653
02:17:21,911 --> 02:17:23,911
a

4654
02:17:24,413 --> 02:17:27,417
result of that crime, our fee

4655
02:17:27,417 --> 02:17:30,417
at the police department can

4656
02:17:32,540 --> 02:17:33,456
be wavered by us vered --

4657
02:17:33,456 --> 02:17:33,956
wavered by us under those

4658
02:17:33,956 --> 02:17:35,900
circumstances.

4659
02:17:35,900 --> 02:17:36,960
The other fee that is are

4660
02:17:36,960 --> 02:17:37,427
assessed by the tow

4661
02:17:37,427 --> 02:17:38,361
companies,

4662
02:17:38,361 --> 02:17:38,794
if there's isurance

4663
02:17:38,794 --> 02:17:40,794
involved,

4664
02:17:41,164 --> 02:17:43,320
whether it's triple a or some

4665
02:17:43,320 --> 02:17:44,667
other type of insurance that

4666
02:17:44,667 --> 02:17:45,350
has coverage on whatever

4667
02:17:45,350 --> 02:17:45,734
other

4668
02:17:45,734 --> 02:17:46,102
circumstances happened, I

4669
02:17:46,102 --> 02:17:48,102
know

4670
02:17:48,671 --> 02:17:51,207
that that is an option for

4671
02:17:51,207 --> 02:17:51,941
what was described to me as a

4672
02:17:51,941 --> 02:17:53,309
reimbursement from those

4673
02:17:53,309 --> 02:17:54,778
companies, maybe an upfront

4674
02:17:54,778 --> 02:17:56,812
charge with the insurance

4675
02:17:56,812 --> 02:17:58,348
reimbursing at a later time,

4676
02:17:58,348 --> 02:17:59,816
but more specifically I might

4677
02:17:59,816 --> 02:18:02,840
need to refer to one of the

4678
02:18:02,840 --> 02:18:05,840
tow companies for how the

4679
02:18:07,357 --> 02:18:08,558
processing of the transaction

4680
02:18:08,558 --> 02:18:10,393
would be.

4681
02:18:10,393 --> 02:18:12,262
>> could we hve them come up

4682
02:18:12,262 --> 02:18:15,262
and give us the scenario

4683
02:18:17,634 --> 02:18:18,335
please, if you don't mind.

4684
02:18:18,335 --> 02:18:20,335
Good evening, welcome.

4685
02:18:21,104 --> 02:18:21,438
>> my name is brian banks,

4686
02:18:21,438 --> 02:18:23,438
the

4687
02:18:24,740 --> 02:18:25,475
opener of action towing.

4688
02:18:25,475 --> 02:18:27,770
So, probably 95% of the tows

4689
02:18:27,770 --> 02:18:27,544
that we are doing are

4690
02:18:27,544 --> 02:18:29,544
normally

4691
02:18:29,645 --> 02:18:30,480
not the situation you're

4692
02:18:30,480 --> 02:18:30,847
describing, they're only

4693
02:18:30,847 --> 02:18:32,115
about

4694
02:18:32,115 --> 02:18:33,617
5% of the tows we're doing.

4695
02:18:33,617 --> 02:18:33,984
The majority of the tows

4696
02:18:33,984 --> 02:18:35,485
we're

4697
02:18:35,485 --> 02:18:37,354
doing are people that have

4698
02:18:37,354 --> 02:18:39,456
violated laws, have not paid

4699
02:18:39,456 --> 02:18:40,824
their registrations, are

4700
02:18:40,824 --> 02:18:42,259
driving without driver's

4701
02:18:42,259 --> 02:18:44,828
licenses and in some cases

4702
02:18:44,828 --> 02:18:46,897
many of the cases the cars

4703
02:18:46,897 --> 02:18:47,898
we're towing, probably 50% of

4704
02:18:47,898 --> 02:18:48,264
the cases we're doing in

4705
02:18:48,264 --> 02:18:50,167
south

4706
02:18:50,167 --> 02:18:50,601
san francisco is abandoned

4707
02:18:50,601 --> 02:18:52,690
vehicles.

4708
02:18:52,690 --> 02:18:53,938
So, it MAY seem like a lot of

4709
02:18:53,938 --> 02:18:54,872
money to you guys as you're

4710
02:18:54,872 --> 02:18:55,239
processing this, what you

4711
02:18:55,239 --> 02:18:56,740
need

4712
02:18:56,740 --> 02:18:58,374
to understand is that more

4713
02:18:58,374 --> 02:19:00,774
than 50% of these vehicles,

4714
02:19:00,911 --> 02:19:02,546
probably more like 65 or 70

4715
02:19:02,546 --> 02:19:03,613
percent of these vehicles are

4716
02:19:03,613 --> 02:19:05,316
never being picked up.

4717
02:19:05,316 --> 02:19:05,750
You guys have done a

4718
02:19:05,750 --> 02:19:06,917
wonderful

4719
02:19:06,917 --> 02:19:07,251
job in south san francisco

4720
02:19:07,251 --> 02:19:08,819
and

4721
02:19:08,819 --> 02:19:09,754
being here tonight, this is

4722
02:19:09,754 --> 02:19:11,622
amazing and beautiful and

4723
02:19:11,622 --> 02:19:13,457
we're doing our part to help

4724
02:19:13,457 --> 02:19:15,326
keep your streets clean.

4725
02:19:15,326 --> 02:19:15,626
So, what we're asking for is

4726
02:19:15,626 --> 02:19:16,726
a

4727
02:19:16,726 --> 02:19:18,362
rate increase because of the

4728
02:19:18,362 --> 02:19:19,730
fact that our businesses,

4729
02:19:19,730 --> 02:19:21,132
you've heard it from your

4730
02:19:21,132 --> 02:19:22,660
planning department and

4731
02:19:22,660 --> 02:19:24,168
everybody else, things have

4732
02:19:24,168 --> 02:19:26,470
gone through the roof.

4733
02:19:26,470 --> 02:19:28,572
Metal for us is at a 7 year

4734
02:19:28,572 --> 02:19:29,941
low and so that's how we get

4735
02:19:29,941 --> 02:19:31,174
paid for these vehicle,

4736
02:19:31,174 --> 02:19:32,743
sometimes we might tow a car

4737
02:19:32,743 --> 02:19:34,579
where we have a driver goes

4738
02:19:34,579 --> 02:19:35,980
out and tows it, he's on the

4739
02:19:35,980 --> 02:19:38,649
job for an hour and a half,

4740
02:19:38,649 --> 02:19:40,180
two hours, we have to pay a

4741
02:19:40,180 --> 02:19:41,186
lien sale fee, we have to

4742
02:19:41,186 --> 02:19:41,886
store this vehicle for

4743
02:19:41,886 --> 02:19:43,886
upwards

4744
02:19:44,540 --> 02:19:45,423
of some cases, anywhere will

4745
02:19:45,423 --> 02:19:47,524
be a quick one will be 30 day

4746
02:19:47,524 --> 02:19:49,127
and is a long one will be 6

4747
02:19:49,127 --> 02:19:50,494
months, we're stringing in a

4748
02:19:50,494 --> 02:19:50,894
building, rents are not

4749
02:19:50,894 --> 02:19:52,894
cheap,

4750
02:19:53,331 --> 02:19:55,433
we discussed what it is a

4751
02:19:55,433 --> 02:19:58,433
square foot, especially for a

4752
02:19:58,603 --> 02:19:58,937
warehouse so, the expenses

4753
02:19:58,937 --> 02:20:00,438
are

4754
02:20:00,438 --> 02:20:01,639
enormous and most of the

4755
02:20:01,639 --> 02:20:03,274
vehicles are not being picked

4756
02:20:03,274 --> 02:20:04,209
up websinger eve seen

4757
02:20:04,209 --> 02:20:04,542
inflation of our equipment

4758
02:20:04,542 --> 02:20:06,542
has

4759
02:20:07,445 --> 02:20:08,613
gone up over 30% to buy a new

4760
02:20:08,613 --> 02:20:11,613
tow truck, our insurance is

4761
02:20:11,615 --> 02:20:13,484
going up on average just like

4762
02:20:13,484 --> 02:20:15,120
yours, I'm insurance on your

4763
02:20:15,120 --> 02:20:17,689
homes 20% a year tha,'s the

4764
02:20:17,689 --> 02:20:19,291
facts of what's going on, all

4765
02:20:19,291 --> 02:20:21,159
of these expenses are goipg

4766
02:20:21,159 --> 02:20:21,560
up, we're not trying to

4767
02:20:21,560 --> 02:20:23,495
punish

4768
02:20:23,495 --> 02:20:25,363
-- it looks like a lot of

4769
02:20:25,363 --> 02:20:26,231
money but we're not trying to

4770
02:20:26,231 --> 02:20:26,564
punish good people, we have

4771
02:20:26,564 --> 02:20:27,660
to

4772
02:20:27,660 --> 02:20:27,632
pay for the s

4773
02:20:27,632 --> 02:20:29,100
frs we provide

4774
02:20:29,100 --> 02:20:30,301
for the city and keeping your

4775
02:20:30,301 --> 02:20:30,668
streets clean s you guys

4776
02:20:30,668 --> 02:20:31,903
will

4777
02:20:31,903 --> 02:20:33,710
continue to mover forward and

4778
02:20:33,710 --> 02:20:33,538
have this beautiful city

4779
02:20:33,538 --> 02:20:35,538
where

4780
02:20:35,574 --> 02:20:37,242
people want to develop

4781
02:20:37,242 --> 02:20:38,343
apartment and is buildings

4782
02:20:38,343 --> 02:20:39,611
and

4783
02:20:39,611 --> 02:20:39,978
do business here, so the

4784
02:20:39,978 --> 02:20:41,978
other

4785
02:20:42,130 --> 02:20:44,183
answer to your question is

4786
02:20:44,183 --> 02:20:44,650
those 5%, most of those

4787
02:20:44,650 --> 02:20:45,384
people

4788
02:20:45,384 --> 02:20:45,784
do have insurance, like if

4789
02:20:45,784 --> 02:20:47,186
you

4790
02:20:47,186 --> 02:20:49,288
were in an accident and the

4791
02:20:49,288 --> 02:20:50,254
people that hit you did not

4792
02:20:50,254 --> 02:20:50,622
have insurance, you would

4793
02:20:50,622 --> 02:20:52,257
lean

4794
02:20:52,257 --> 02:20:54,660
on your insurance on that, if

4795
02:20:54,660 --> 02:20:56,762
there's accident and is your

4796
02:20:56,762 --> 02:20:57,162
car is stolen, the good

4797
02:20:57,162 --> 02:20:58,330
people

4798
02:20:58,330 --> 02:20:59,598
seem to pay the fees for the

4799
02:20:59,598 --> 02:21:00,999
bad people and there's no

4800
02:21:00,999 --> 02:21:02,134
other way around that but

4801
02:21:02,134 --> 02:21:03,535
providing they have good

4802
02:21:03,535 --> 02:21:05,938
insurance and follow the laws

4803
02:21:05,938 --> 02:21:07,339
that they have, normally the

4804
02:21:07,339 --> 02:21:08,307
insurance will come ad

4805
02:21:08,307 --> 02:21:10,442
reimburse them for their

4806
02:21:10,442 --> 02:21:12,440
expense and is most of the

4807
02:21:12,440 --> 02:21:14,346
time the insurance picks them

4808
02:21:14,346 --> 02:21:15,981
up, the people who do pick

4809
02:21:15,981 --> 02:21:18,981
them up primarily are the

4810
02:21:19,986 --> 02:21:21,821
people that have dui's,

4811
02:21:21,821 --> 02:21:23,923
expired reds, driving on a

4812
02:21:23,923 --> 02:21:26,323
suspended license, not good

4813
02:21:28,961 --> 02:21:29,294
behavior they're being pun

4814
02:21:29,294 --> 02:21:30,329
--

4815
02:21:30,329 --> 02:21:30,663
punished for a reason, this

4816
02:21:30,663 --> 02:21:32,663
is

4817
02:21:33,320 --> 02:21:34,634
another part of a punishment,

4818
02:21:34,634 --> 02:21:36,340
that's why we're asking for

4819
02:21:36,340 --> 02:21:38,136
more money, for the obvious

4820
02:21:38,136 --> 02:21:39,539
expenses we have, we've been

4821
02:21:39,539 --> 02:21:41,107
good partners to the city for

4822
02:21:41,107 --> 02:21:42,542
a long time, we asked for a

4823
02:21:42,542 --> 02:21:43,943
long period of time for

4824
02:21:43,943 --> 02:21:46,779
raises, ask you guys have

4825
02:21:46,779 --> 02:21:47,146
worked for us but we feel

4826
02:21:47,146 --> 02:21:48,614
this

4827
02:21:48,614 --> 02:21:49,810
is necessary, we hope you

4828
02:21:49,810 --> 02:21:50,116
take

4829
02:21:50,116 --> 02:21:51,451
this into consideration what

4830
02:21:51,451 --> 02:21:53,851
we're asking for tonight.

4831
02:21:55,588 --> 02:21:56,990
>> my name is steven, I'm

4832
02:21:56,990 --> 02:21:57,924
with

4833
02:21:57,924 --> 02:21:59,993
bob junior towing, we eer

4834
02:21:59,993 --> 02:22:02,128
been around a long time here

4835
02:22:02,128 --> 02:22:03,797
and bryan pretty much said

4836
02:22:03,797 --> 02:22:06,197
what's happening with our

4837
02:22:07,132 --> 02:22:07,967
towing companies and there's

4838
02:22:07,967 --> 02:22:08,300
two different entities when

4839
02:22:08,300 --> 02:22:10,300
it

4840
02:22:12,472 --> 02:22:15,909
comes to the towing, we want

4841
02:22:15,909 --> 02:22:17,430
to take care of the people

4842
02:22:17,430 --> 02:22:18,444
within south san francisco as

4843
02:22:18,444 --> 02:22:20,513
well as te people that are

4844
02:22:20,513 --> 02:22:23,490
coming through the city as

4845
02:22:23,490 --> 02:22:26,190
well and when we do that, it

4846
02:22:26,190 --> 02:22:26,352
is not easy for them, what

4847
02:22:26,352 --> 02:22:27,854
you

4848
02:22:27,854 --> 02:22:29,489
were saying, how do you pay

4849
02:22:29,489 --> 02:22:29,856
for it and what do you do

4850
02:22:29,856 --> 02:22:31,492
when

4851
02:22:31,492 --> 02:22:31,858
they come to you and all

4852
02:22:31,858 --> 02:22:33,858
those

4853
02:22:35,294 --> 02:22:36,296
types of things.

4854
02:22:36,296 --> 02:22:36,663
It's a tough situation we

4855
02:22:36,663 --> 02:22:37,864
have

4856
02:22:37,864 --> 02:22:38,598
to go through and every

4857
02:22:38,598 --> 02:22:38,932
scenario is different than

4858
02:22:38,932 --> 02:22:40,932
the

4859
02:22:41,601 --> 02:22:43,737
other one and we take a look

4860
02:22:43,737 --> 02:22:44,904
at each and every individual

4861
02:22:44,904 --> 02:22:46,206
within this city and also

4862
02:22:46,206 --> 02:22:47,474
outside the city when they

4863
02:22:47,474 --> 02:22:49,760
come here.

4864
02:22:49,760 --> 02:22:51,178
And it's a tough decision on

4865
02:22:51,178 --> 02:22:52,713
our end to make that decision

4866
02:22:52,713 --> 02:22:53,180
on how we're going to do this

4867
02:22:53,180 --> 02:22:55,180
with them.

4868
02:22:56,817 --> 02:22:59,653
We want to do it in a really

4869
02:22:59,653 --> 02:23:00,821
-- the expenses of this, it's

4870
02:23:00,821 --> 02:23:02,890
really expensive for them to

4871
02:23:02,890 --> 02:23:03,824
get the car released, go to

4872
02:23:03,824 --> 02:23:04,191
the police department and

4873
02:23:04,191 --> 02:23:06,191
have

4874
02:23:06,460 --> 02:23:08,462
that done as well, go to the

4875
02:23:08,462 --> 02:23:09,663
dmv, by the time they come

4876
02:23:09,663 --> 02:23:11,632
tows, they're pretty upset so

4877
02:23:11,632 --> 02:23:12,650
we want to make it as

4878
02:23:12,650 --> 02:23:13,434
pleasant

4879
02:23:13,434 --> 02:23:15,435
as we can for these folks and

4880
02:23:15,435 --> 02:23:16,604
make it to where they could e

4881
02:23:16,604 --> 02:23:16,937
either afford to get their

4882
02:23:16,937 --> 02:23:18,239
car

4883
02:23:18,239 --> 02:23:19,907
out, if not, then we have to

4884
02:23:19,907 --> 02:23:21,742
look at different options and

4885
02:23:21,742 --> 02:23:22,710
a lot of times the different

4886
02:23:22,710 --> 02:23:24,812
options that they don't come

4887
02:23:24,812 --> 02:23:26,460
to get their cars out, so

4888
02:23:26,460 --> 02:23:27,548
we're stuck with that.

4889
02:23:27,548 --> 02:23:29,817
We have to process the

4890
02:23:29,817 --> 02:23:32,620
vehicles like he was saying

4891
02:23:32,620 --> 02:23:34,188
and it's a low time with the

4892
02:23:34,188 --> 02:23:36,757
junk industry and all those

4893
02:23:36,757 --> 02:23:38,459
types of things and it's

4894
02:23:38,459 --> 02:23:38,893
getting tougher to do

4895
02:23:38,893 --> 02:23:40,361
business

4896
02:23:40,361 --> 02:23:42,361
with that.

4897
02:23:42,696 --> 02:23:44,640
It's pretty much what brian

4898
02:23:44,640 --> 02:23:45,233
was saying, the cost of the

4899
02:23:45,233 --> 02:23:46,167
rents and the insurance and

4900
02:23:46,167 --> 02:23:47,568
stuff like that.

4901
02:23:47,568 --> 02:23:47,934
>> thank you, I appreciate

4902
02:23:47,934 --> 02:23:49,934
that.

4903
02:23:50,538 --> 02:23:52,538
>> thank you.

4904
02:23:53,740 --> 02:23:55,410
>> good evening, my name is

4905
02:23:55,410 --> 02:23:57,478
gino with courtesy tow and it

4906
02:23:57,478 --> 02:23:58,880
pretty much sums it up, what

4907
02:23:58,880 --> 02:24:01,820
my other two colleagues have

4908
02:24:01,820 --> 02:24:02,917
said, insurance costs are

4909
02:24:02,917 --> 02:24:04,985
through the roof, prices of

4910
02:24:04,985 --> 02:24:06,387
newer trucks ask newer

4911
02:24:06,387 --> 02:24:08,787
equipment to stay doing

4912
02:24:09,290 --> 02:24:11,690
business in california, the

4913
02:24:12,761 --> 02:24:13,928
regulations of the def

4914
02:24:13,928 --> 02:24:15,530
regulations, retiring old

4915
02:24:15,530 --> 02:24:17,398
trucks, having to buy new

4916
02:24:17,398 --> 02:24:17,732
equipment, having to invest

4917
02:24:17,732 --> 02:24:19,267
in

4918
02:24:19,267 --> 02:24:21,267
new equipment, driver

4919
02:24:22,604 --> 02:24:24,604
education, safety programs,

4920
02:24:25,607 --> 02:24:28,700
workers compensation, it all

4921
02:24:28,543 --> 02:24:29,711
costs, so we expect cities

4922
02:24:29,711 --> 02:24:31,279
that we do business with to

4923
02:24:31,279 --> 02:24:31,780
kind of stay as competitive

4924
02:24:31,780 --> 02:24:32,481
as

4925
02:24:32,481 --> 02:24:34,481
possible.

4926
02:24:38,190 --> 02:24:39,154
It is unfortunate like my

4927
02:24:39,154 --> 02:24:40,988
colleagues said but the

4928
02:24:40,988 --> 02:24:43,988
insurance per truck per year

4929
02:24:44,125 --> 02:24:45,293
is 25 to 30 thousand dollars

4930
02:24:45,293 --> 02:24:46,894
per truck per year

4931
02:24:46,894 --> 02:24:47,963
televising's not many

4932
02:24:47,963 --> 02:24:49,464
companies souring, it's hard

4933
02:24:49,464 --> 02:24:52,134
to do business in california

4934
02:24:52,134 --> 02:24:52,901
bottom line and it's

4935
02:24:52,901 --> 02:24:53,234
unfortunate to say that but

4936
02:24:53,234 --> 02:24:54,502
we

4937
02:24:54,502 --> 02:24:54,903
have to stay with what's

4938
02:24:54,903 --> 02:24:56,804
working.

4939
02:24:56,804 --> 02:24:58,306
>> thank you.

4940
02:24:58,306 --> 02:24:58,907
>> any questions to the

4941
02:24:58,907 --> 02:25:00,907
operators?

4942
02:25:01,510 --> 02:25:02,444
>> the last time we loked at

4943
02:25:02,444 --> 02:25:04,444
this was 2016?

4944
02:25:04,579 --> 02:25:06,682
>> yes, that is correct.

4945
02:25:06,682 --> 02:25:07,140
>> so, are they willing to

4946
02:25:07,140 --> 02:25:09,140
not

4947
02:25:11,186 --> 02:25:12,354
come back for another 9 -- 8

4948
02:25:12,354 --> 02:25:13,988
years?

4949
02:25:13,988 --> 02:25:14,455
>> I wuld like to make a

4950
02:25:14,455 --> 02:25:16,570
suggestion.

4951
02:25:16,570 --> 02:25:17,693
I don't know if you guys are

4952
02:25:17,693 --> 02:25:18,394
open to this or not, with

4953
02:25:18,394 --> 02:25:19,929
most

4954
02:25:19,929 --> 02:25:21,290
agencies, we renew on an

4955
02:25:21,290 --> 02:25:22,310
annual basis and one of the

4956
02:25:22,310 --> 02:25:22,397
things I would suggest if

4957
02:25:22,397 --> 02:25:23,765
it's

4958
02:25:23,765 --> 02:25:25,367
possible and it's not too

4959
02:25:25,367 --> 02:25:25,734
late, we put some sort of

4960
02:25:25,734 --> 02:25:27,670
cola

4961
02:25:27,670 --> 02:25:28,370
in this for the district

4962
02:25:28,370 --> 02:25:29,839
we're

4963
02:25:29,839 --> 02:25:30,539
in, a cost of living

4964
02:25:30,539 --> 02:25:32,174
increase,

4965
02:25:32,174 --> 02:25:33,775
I think that -- if that was

4966
02:25:33,775 --> 02:25:34,210
the case, there would

4967
02:25:34,210 --> 02:25:35,277
probably

4968
02:25:35,277 --> 02:25:36,679
be no reason we would have to

4969
02:25:36,679 --> 02:25:40,249
come back and see you guys, I

4970
02:25:40,249 --> 02:25:42,484
think it's fair based on a

4971
02:25:42,484 --> 02:25:43,252
market value of what's going

4972
02:25:43,252 --> 02:25:44,190
on and the county we live in.

4973
02:25:44,190 --> 02:25:44,753
If we could do something like

4974
02:25:44,753 --> 02:25:45,870
that, I think it will save

4975
02:25:45,870 --> 02:25:47,870
you

4976
02:25:48,491 --> 02:25:50,359
guys 20 minutes of your time

4977
02:25:50,359 --> 02:25:51,293
fiver years from now we come

4978
02:25:51,293 --> 02:25:51,694
crying, I don't know if

4979
02:25:51,694 --> 02:25:52,194
that's

4980
02:25:52,194 --> 02:25:53,796
a possibility.

4981
02:25:53,796 --> 02:25:54,130
>> any other questions for

4982
02:25:54,130 --> 02:25:55,310
the

4983
02:25:55,310 --> 02:25:55,964
operators?

4984
02:25:55,964 --> 02:25:57,964
>> captain plank?

4985
02:25:58,334 --> 02:26:00,536
>> so, when we have a problem

4986
02:26:00,536 --> 02:26:02,337
on the street and we have

4987
02:26:02,337 --> 02:26:03,390
three operator, we rotate but

4988
02:26:03,390 --> 02:26:03,473
maybe somebody's not

4989
02:26:03,473 --> 02:26:04,474
available

4990
02:26:04,474 --> 02:26:06,109
so you bounce it to somebody

4991
02:26:06,109 --> 02:26:09,709
else o how does that work?

4992
02:26:10,460 --> 02:26:10,412
>> exactly, it's rotation

4993
02:26:10,412 --> 02:26:12,412
one,

4994
02:26:15,318 --> 02:26:16,519
two, three, you should --

4995
02:26:16,519 --> 02:26:17,186
>> you should start with

4996
02:26:17,186 --> 02:26:19,186
courtesy.

4997
02:26:19,789 --> 02:26:21,560
>> yeah, if we get to action

4998
02:26:21,560 --> 02:26:21,391
tow and they're unavailable

4999
02:26:21,391 --> 02:26:22,920
or

5000
02:26:22,920 --> 02:26:23,526
don't have the equipment

5001
02:26:23,526 --> 02:26:25,362
available to do it, we'll

5002
02:26:25,362 --> 02:26:27,631
bounce back to the next one

5003
02:26:27,631 --> 02:26:30,133
and then put them at the top

5004
02:26:30,133 --> 02:26:31,368
for the next rotation to keep

5005
02:26:31,368 --> 02:26:33,368
it balanced.

5006
02:26:36,206 --> 02:26:38,206
>> okay.

5007
02:26:38,574 --> 02:26:38,975
I'm interested, captain

5008
02:26:38,975 --> 02:26:40,975
plank,

5009
02:26:41,111 --> 02:26:42,179
on the police side of it, if

5010
02:26:42,179 --> 02:26:44,579
somebody comes home late

5011
02:26:45,582 --> 02:26:47,417
friday night and they park,

5012
02:26:47,417 --> 02:26:48,819
maybe they're blocking a

5013
02:26:48,819 --> 02:26:49,185
driveway maybe b a little

5014
02:26:49,185 --> 02:26:50,420
bit,

5015
02:26:50,420 --> 02:26:52,422
what kind of efforts do we

5016
02:26:52,422 --> 02:26:53,223
make to not make it an

5017
02:26:53,223 --> 02:26:55,223
automatic tow?

5018
02:26:56,459 --> 02:26:57,394
>> that's a great question.

5019
02:26:57,394 --> 02:26:59,262
Our intention and desire is

5020
02:26:59,262 --> 02:27:02,565
not to tow the vehicle, it

5021
02:27:02,565 --> 02:27:03,700
takes an officer out of s

5022
02:27:03,700 --> 02:27:05,700
frs

5023
02:27:05,702 --> 02:27:06,937
from anywhere from 25-45

5024
02:27:06,937 --> 02:27:08,338
minutes deal witching the

5025
02:27:08,338 --> 02:27:11,700
paperwork and hooking it up.

5026
02:27:11,700 --> 02:27:13,100
We have access to the license

5027
02:27:13,100 --> 02:27:14,411
plate shows where that car is

5028
02:27:14,411 --> 02:27:14,944
registered to, we make every

5029
02:27:14,944 --> 02:27:16,580
attempt --

5030
02:27:16,580 --> 02:27:17,981
>> woe would knock on a door

5031
02:27:17,981 --> 02:27:19,616
if we could?

5032
02:27:19,616 --> 02:27:22,616
>> we would, we would check

5033
02:27:23,320 --> 02:27:25,622
our database if we hve a

5034
02:27:25,622 --> 02:27:27,958
recent phone nmber, we wuld

5035
02:27:27,958 --> 02:27:29,326
try to contact tem in

5036
02:27:29,326 --> 02:27:29,960
multiple different avenues

5037
02:27:29,960 --> 02:27:31,960
until we've exhausted

5038
02:27:32,496 --> 02:27:33,397
everything and then we

5039
02:27:33,397 --> 02:27:34,980
ultimately would have to tow

5040
02:27:34,980 --> 02:27:36,980
the car.

5041
02:27:36,967 --> 02:27:38,680
It has to meet a criteria for

5042
02:27:38,680 --> 02:27:39,690
blocking that driveway too,

5043
02:27:39,690 --> 02:27:40,671
so

5044
02:27:40,671 --> 02:27:42,720
we'll evaluate, if it's

5045
02:27:42,720 --> 02:27:43,674
partially blocking the

5046
02:27:43,674 --> 02:27:45,743
driveway but the person can

5047
02:27:45,743 --> 02:27:48,790
still get out, we're likely

5048
02:27:48,790 --> 02:27:49,847
not going to tow that vehicle.

5049
02:27:49,847 --> 02:27:51,549
>> is that a different fine

5050
02:27:51,549 --> 02:27:54,618
for somebody, is there a fine

5051
02:27:54,618 --> 02:27:55,553
for that for a motorist that

5052
02:27:55,553 --> 02:27:57,189
partially blocks a driveway.

5053
02:27:57,189 --> 02:28:00,189
>> you can receive a ticket

5054
02:28:00,858 --> 02:28:03,270
for blocking a driveway and

5055
02:28:03,270 --> 02:28:05,270
that's a citation.

5056
02:28:05,129 --> 02:28:06,197
The -- if the person, I mean,

5057
02:28:06,197 --> 02:28:07,497
I just imagine after this

5058
02:28:07,497 --> 02:28:09,534
meeting, if I were to go home

5059
02:28:09,534 --> 02:28:11,169
and there was a car blocking

5060
02:28:11,169 --> 02:28:13,370
my driveway and nobody could

5061
02:28:13,370 --> 02:28:14,439
get a hold of it, my desire

5062
02:28:14,439 --> 02:28:17,909
would be for it to be towed

5063
02:28:17,909 --> 02:28:20,144
because I want to go home and

5064
02:28:20,144 --> 02:28:21,145
do my evening stuff and go to

5065
02:28:21,145 --> 02:28:21,479
work tomorrow so that would

5066
02:28:21,479 --> 02:28:23,470
be

5067
02:28:23,470 --> 02:28:25,470
my expectation.

5068
02:28:25,316 --> 02:28:26,317
>> I'm glad we make the front

5069
02:28:26,317 --> 02:28:27,652
end effort.

5070
02:28:27,652 --> 02:28:29,320
>> excellent point.

5071
02:28:29,320 --> 02:28:31,320
Go ahead.

5072
02:28:32,323 --> 02:28:34,723
>> so, the 225 is the 2016

5073
02:28:35,930 --> 02:28:38,290
amount and if we follow the

5074
02:28:38,290 --> 02:28:38,396
average inflation rate of

5075
02:28:38,396 --> 02:28:40,396
3.26

5076
02:28:41,266 --> 02:28:43,568
per year, that will be $300,

5077
02:28:43,568 --> 02:28:44,936
now, to address what you were

5078
02:28:44,936 --> 02:28:45,436
asking for, that if you can

5079
02:28:45,436 --> 02:28:46,804
do

5080
02:28:46,804 --> 02:28:49,174
it every year, I think that

5081
02:28:49,174 --> 02:28:51,843
will be for the next round,

5082
02:28:51,843 --> 02:28:53,444
right, and it depends also on

5083
02:28:53,444 --> 02:28:55,614
how your bandwidth to work

5084
02:28:55,614 --> 02:28:57,816
with them if that's what they

5085
02:28:57,816 --> 02:28:58,617
wanted to have an annual

5086
02:28:58,617 --> 02:29:00,617
inflationary cst.

5087
02:29:01,186 --> 02:29:02,587
But for now, we're just

5088
02:29:02,587 --> 02:29:04,987
talking about the suggestion

5089
02:29:05,591 --> 02:29:05,924
to increase it from 225 to

5090
02:29:05,924 --> 02:29:07,924
325

5091
02:29:08,460 --> 02:29:11,460
which is already higher than

5092
02:29:11,530 --> 02:29:14,399
if you compute for the annual

5093
02:29:14,399 --> 02:29:14,733
inflationary rate from 2016

5094
02:29:14,733 --> 02:29:16,733
to

5095
02:29:17,202 --> 02:29:18,504
2025, it should just be about

5096
02:29:18,504 --> 02:29:20,504
to $300.

5097
02:29:20,906 --> 02:29:21,707
>> we're okay with the 325 at

5098
02:29:21,707 --> 02:29:23,374
the moment.

5099
02:29:23,374 --> 02:29:23,842
>> that's what we're tlking

5100
02:29:23,842 --> 02:29:25,842
about.

5101
02:29:26,780 --> 02:29:27,178
I'm just telling you that

5102
02:29:27,178 --> 02:29:29,178
it's

5103
02:29:29,481 --> 02:29:31,481
$25 more than --

5104
02:29:31,817 --> 02:29:33,817
>> in addition.

5105
02:29:45,970 --> 02:29:45,798
>> [Inaudible].

5106
02:29:45,798 --> 02:29:47,798
>> thank you.

5107
02:29:50,536 --> 02:29:51,470
>> I did do the math, it

5108
02:29:51,470 --> 02:29:52,171
compounded as 28.8%, comes

5109
02:29:52,171 --> 02:29:53,572
out

5110
02:29:53,572 --> 02:29:55,441
to around $300.

5111
02:29:55,441 --> 02:29:56,375
>> captain plank, it says on

5112
02:29:56,375 --> 02:29:58,210
attachment a, if you believe

5113
02:29:58,210 --> 02:30:00,450
you have been unfairly

5114
02:30:00,450 --> 02:30:01,460
channeled, please contact

5115
02:30:01,460 --> 02:30:03,381
south city pd traffic

5116
02:30:03,381 --> 02:30:04,684
division, how many of those

5117
02:30:04,684 --> 02:30:05,751
have you been contacted in

5118
02:30:05,751 --> 02:30:07,530
what manner, I want to know

5119
02:30:07,530 --> 02:30:08,190
about performance and

5120
02:30:08,190 --> 02:30:10,419
accountability too about this.

5121
02:30:12,124 --> 02:30:12,525
>> I'm not aware of any

5122
02:30:12,525 --> 02:30:13,292
formal

5123
02:30:13,292 --> 02:30:15,692
complaints where someone had

5124
02:30:19,265 --> 02:30:22,134
called and said I'm being

5125
02:30:22,134 --> 02:30:25,134
overcharged or the most that

5126
02:30:25,171 --> 02:30:25,638
we would receive is if

5127
02:30:25,638 --> 02:30:27,638
someone

5128
02:30:27,740 --> 02:30:28,740
indicated that maybe there

5129
02:30:28,740 --> 02:30:30,740
was

5130
02:30:31,211 --> 02:30:33,279
a minor scratch or blemish on

5131
02:30:33,279 --> 02:30:35,140
a bumper might claim that

5132
02:30:35,140 --> 02:30:35,381
wasn't there prior to and

5133
02:30:35,381 --> 02:30:36,950
they

5134
02:30:36,950 --> 02:30:40,530
say it was as a result of a

5135
02:30:40,530 --> 02:30:41,687
tow but there's no price

5136
02:30:41,687 --> 02:30:42,121
gouging or delaying so

5137
02:30:42,121 --> 02:30:44,121
there's

5138
02:30:44,457 --> 02:30:45,825
an extra daily storage fee or

5139
02:30:45,825 --> 02:30:47,694
pushing it until after hours

5140
02:30:47,694 --> 02:30:48,600
so then there's an after

5141
02:30:48,600 --> 02:30:49,729
hours

5142
02:30:49,729 --> 02:30:50,960
fee added to it, I'm not

5143
02:30:50,960 --> 02:30:52,960
aware

5144
02:30:52,665 --> 02:30:53,366
of any of those taking place.

5145
02:30:53,366 --> 02:30:55,366
>> toy

5146
02:30:55,469 --> 02:30:57,537
f tows are considered

5147
02:30:57,537 --> 02:30:59,773
vehicle impounds as part of

5148
02:30:59,773 --> 02:31:00,540
what you do or how are those

5149
02:31:00,540 --> 02:31:02,174
classified sm

5150
02:31:02,174 --> 02:31:02,609
>> so, a vehicle impound

5151
02:31:02,609 --> 02:31:04,609
would

5152
02:31:04,911 --> 02:31:07,911
be if someone has a

5153
02:31:08,414 --> 02:31:09,583
restriction on their driver's

5154
02:31:09,583 --> 02:31:11,218
license, sspended, has proof

5155
02:31:11,218 --> 02:31:12,352
of service, is aware they

5156
02:31:12,352 --> 02:31:14,752
shouldn't be driving and

5157
02:31:14,922 --> 02:31:16,556
continues to drive, so, and

5158
02:31:16,556 --> 02:31:19,556
continue tos drive a car

5159
02:31:21,294 --> 02:31:23,230
that's registered to them.

5160
02:31:23,230 --> 02:31:23,630
So, that would be a 30 day

5161
02:31:23,630 --> 02:31:24,310
impound.

5162
02:31:24,310 --> 02:31:24,731
>> okay.

5163
02:31:24,731 --> 02:31:26,990
>> another impocketbacker

5164
02:31:26,990 --> 02:31:28,968
pound would be if someone has

5165
02:31:28,968 --> 02:31:29,303
multiple prior convictions

5166
02:31:29,303 --> 02:31:30,370
for

5167
02:31:30,370 --> 02:31:31,338
driving under the influence

5168
02:31:31,338 --> 02:31:32,740
and there was restrictions

5169
02:31:32,740 --> 02:31:34,375
that said they're not allowed

5170
02:31:34,375 --> 02:31:34,708
to drive or else that would

5171
02:31:34,708 --> 02:31:35,208
be

5172
02:31:35,208 --> 02:31:37,208
an impound.

5173
02:31:37,378 --> 02:31:38,279
The majority of the other

5174
02:31:38,279 --> 02:31:39,446
tows

5175
02:31:39,446 --> 02:31:40,381
we do are storage.

5176
02:31:40,381 --> 02:31:42,381
>> got it.

5177
02:31:43,184 --> 02:31:45,452
>> it doesn't have a set time

5178
02:31:45,452 --> 02:31:49,520
period that it needs to be

5179
02:31:50,924 --> 02:31:52,930
held at the tow yard if the

5180
02:31:52,930 --> 02:31:53,494
owner responds within 30

5181
02:31:53,494 --> 02:31:55,129
minutes from it being towed,

5182
02:31:55,129 --> 02:31:58,399
they can access the car and

5183
02:31:58,399 --> 02:32:00,568
get it out, the impound would

5184
02:32:00,568 --> 02:32:02,903
be a specific situation.

5185
02:32:02,903 --> 02:32:04,505
>> so, that includes dui

5186
02:32:04,505 --> 02:32:06,139
vehicles that are picked up

5187
02:32:06,139 --> 02:32:08,139
during ceck points?

5188
02:32:08,843 --> 02:32:10,311
>> no, it wouldn't.

5189
02:32:10,311 --> 02:32:11,245
That charge, I'm sorry, that

5190
02:32:11,245 --> 02:32:13,514
authority to tow that car

5191
02:32:13,514 --> 02:32:15,830
would be a storage, it would

5192
02:32:15,830 --> 02:32:17,684
be the driver's arrested and

5193
02:32:17,684 --> 02:32:19,870
we aren't able to lever it at

5194
02:32:19,870 --> 02:32:21,489
its current location, we do

5195
02:32:21,489 --> 02:32:23,558
leave the vehicles at their

5196
02:32:23,558 --> 02:32:25,193
resting point if they're

5197
02:32:25,193 --> 02:32:26,961
legally parked, if they're on

5198
02:32:26,961 --> 02:32:27,996
their street, we don't take

5199
02:32:27,996 --> 02:32:29,996
them automatically.

5200
02:32:31,933 --> 02:32:33,167
If it's parked in a tow away

5201
02:32:33,167 --> 02:32:33,568
zone and if we leave it

5202
02:32:33,568 --> 02:32:35,203
there,

5203
02:32:35,203 --> 02:32:35,569
it will be towed later on

5204
02:32:35,569 --> 02:32:37,272
that

5205
02:32:37,272 --> 02:32:37,572
night or if it's parked in a

5206
02:32:37,572 --> 02:32:39,572
a

5207
02:32:42,644 --> 02:32:42,977
road zone or in unsafe area

5208
02:32:42,977 --> 02:32:43,744
or

5209
02:32:43,744 --> 02:32:45,980
an area that's prone to have

5210
02:32:45,980 --> 02:32:47,480
higher vehicle burglaries or

5211
02:32:47,480 --> 02:32:48,115
crime, our community care

5212
02:32:48,115 --> 02:32:49,918
taking authority is to remove

5213
02:32:49,918 --> 02:32:50,318
the vehicle and have it

5214
02:32:50,318 --> 02:32:51,860
stored

5215
02:32:51,860 --> 02:32:52,721
safely until the person can

5216
02:32:52,721 --> 02:32:54,721
get it out.

5217
02:32:54,723 --> 02:32:55,991
So, not all arrests result in

5218
02:32:55,991 --> 02:32:57,759
a tow as well.

5219
02:32:57,759 --> 02:33:00,610
>> understood, thank you for

5220
02:33:00,610 --> 02:33:01,763
that clarification.

5221
02:33:01,763 --> 02:33:02,898
>> I don't mean to belabor

5222
02:33:02,898 --> 02:33:05,634
this, I think there is an

5223
02:33:05,634 --> 02:33:06,802
argument to be made an an

5224
02:33:06,802 --> 02:33:07,235
annual adjustment, maybe a

5225
02:33:07,235 --> 02:33:09,235
cpi

5226
02:33:09,438 --> 02:33:09,871
and we have something

5227
02:33:09,871 --> 02:33:11,871
similar,

5228
02:33:14,843 --> 02:33:15,577
I think every three years we

5229
02:33:15,577 --> 02:33:17,712
look at our scavenger rates

5230
02:33:17,712 --> 02:33:19,548
and we adjust to a percentage

5231
02:33:19,548 --> 02:33:21,383
of the cpi, and if we did

5232
02:33:21,383 --> 02:33:24,252
that, even though it wasn't

5233
02:33:24,252 --> 02:33:27,252
reaching the full expense, it

5234
02:33:27,922 --> 02:33:32,122
would allow us to go a number

5235
02:33:32,161 --> 02:33:35,761
of years, at in time, the

5236
02:33:35,831 --> 02:33:36,164
operators can come and ask

5237
02:33:36,164 --> 02:33:36,899
for

5238
02:33:36,899 --> 02:33:37,666
an increase if things felt

5239
02:33:37,666 --> 02:33:38,366
like they did now, so I think

5240
02:33:38,366 --> 02:33:39,434
we should can consider a

5241
02:33:39,434 --> 02:33:41,936
little quution the cpi, maybe

5242
02:33:41,936 --> 02:33:43,639
a percentage of the annual.

5243
02:33:43,639 --> 02:33:44,340
>> great.

5244
02:33:44,340 --> 02:33:46,740
>> I'm supportive of that

5245
02:33:47,743 --> 02:33:48,177
>> I want to hear from

5246
02:33:48,177 --> 02:33:49,311
everyone.

5247
02:33:49,311 --> 02:33:51,413
>> I'm fine with that.

5248
02:33:51,413 --> 02:33:53,413
>> okay.

5249
02:33:55,451 --> 02:33:56,819
>> do we do 60% on our

5250
02:33:56,819 --> 02:33:58,220
scavenger utility bill?

5251
02:33:58,220 --> 02:33:58,554
>> I did just look at tat

5252
02:33:58,554 --> 02:34:00,289
and

5253
02:34:00,289 --> 02:34:00,623
I would have to get back to

5254
02:34:00,623 --> 02:34:01,457
you.

5255
02:34:01,457 --> 02:34:02,624
That does sound correct.

5256
02:34:02,624 --> 02:34:03,793
>> okay.

5257
02:34:03,793 --> 02:34:05,793
>> councilmember?

5258
02:34:07,897 --> 02:34:09,640
>> so, tonight I was very

5259
02:34:09,640 --> 02:34:10,333
much prepared to vote no but

5260
02:34:10,333 --> 02:34:11,934
I

5261
02:34:11,934 --> 02:34:12,334
think based on sergeant

5262
02:34:12,334 --> 02:34:13,803
plank,

5263
02:34:13,803 --> 02:34:15,104
I'm a lot more comfortable

5264
02:34:15,104 --> 02:34:16,772
voting on this item, the

5265
02:34:16,772 --> 02:34:17,974
reason is I have experienced

5266
02:34:17,974 --> 02:34:21,210
being tow and had I have

5267
02:34:21,210 --> 02:34:22,378
others who have experienced

5268
02:34:22,378 --> 02:34:23,746
being towed in san francisco,

5269
02:34:23,746 --> 02:34:24,914
in san francisco, they're

5270
02:34:24,914 --> 02:34:27,160
looking for every reason to

5271
02:34:27,160 --> 02:34:27,649
tow a vehicle and it's

5272
02:34:27,649 --> 02:34:28,170
disgusting and predatory,

5273
02:34:28,170 --> 02:34:29,352
here

5274
02:34:29,352 --> 02:34:30,887
it looks like we're trying to

5275
02:34:30,887 --> 02:34:33,887
do everything but tow a

5276
02:34:34,423 --> 02:34:35,558
vehicle, only in the most

5277
02:34:35,558 --> 02:34:37,958
extreme circumstances which I

5278
02:34:37,961 --> 02:34:39,529
appreciate and I believe that

5279
02:34:39,529 --> 02:34:41,130
having a cpi adjustment

5280
02:34:41,130 --> 02:34:42,198
annually would make a lot of

5281
02:34:42,198 --> 02:34:44,466
sense, that way we don't have

5282
02:34:44,466 --> 02:34:47,466
to bring it back again.

5283
02:34:47,537 --> 02:34:48,537
>> sure, like brian had said,

5284
02:34:48,537 --> 02:34:50,874
some cities, I don't know

5285
02:34:50,874 --> 02:34:51,240
around here, I do know of

5286
02:34:51,240 --> 02:34:52,742
some

5287
02:34:52,742 --> 02:34:53,176
cities to do that, it's a

5288
02:34:53,176 --> 02:34:54,144
much

5289
02:34:54,144 --> 02:34:55,544
shorter presentation and much

5290
02:34:55,544 --> 02:34:57,714
more of an update, this is

5291
02:34:57,714 --> 02:34:59,215
what the new number is and,

5292
02:34:59,215 --> 02:34:59,549
yeah, I can look into that

5293
02:34:59,549 --> 02:34:59,916
for

5294
02:34:59,916 --> 02:35:00,950
sure.

5295
02:35:00,950 --> 02:35:02,950
>> thank you, captain.

5296
02:35:03,385 --> 02:35:04,870
do we have any public

5297
02:35:04,870 --> 02:35:05,488
comments?

5298
02:35:05,488 --> 02:35:06,656
>> no public comments, mayor.

5299
02:35:06,656 --> 02:35:08,656
>> thank you.

5300
02:35:09,459 --> 02:35:09,860
If not, I am looking for a

5301
02:35:09,860 --> 02:35:10,928
motion.

5302
02:35:10,928 --> 02:35:11,227
>> so moved.

5303
02:35:11,227 --> 02:35:12,896
Er

5304
02:35:12,896 --> 02:35:13,930
>> I'm sorry, mayor, just to

5305
02:35:13,930 --> 02:35:15,332
clarify waoe, doipg a motion

5306
02:35:15,332 --> 02:35:18,332
for the resolution with an

5307
02:35:18,434 --> 02:35:20,700
amendment to the item or --

5308
02:35:20,700 --> 02:35:21,238
>> everyone agrees to the

5309
02:35:21,238 --> 02:35:23,638
amendment, right, so yes.

5310
02:35:24,407 --> 02:35:24,941
>> eel -- I'll look to the

5311
02:35:24,941 --> 02:35:26,941
motion maker?

5312
02:35:27,244 --> 02:35:29,244
>> to the amendment?

5313
02:35:30,130 --> 02:35:31,181
If we really would like to go

5314
02:35:31,181 --> 02:35:32,849
for the 3.26 average

5315
02:35:32,849 --> 02:35:33,216
inflation, the amount of

5316
02:35:33,216 --> 02:35:35,216
money

5317
02:35:35,885 --> 02:35:36,220
from 2016 to 2025 is $300,

5318
02:35:36,220 --> 02:35:38,220
but

5319
02:35:38,422 --> 02:35:39,923
I'll just let it go and next

5320
02:35:39,923 --> 02:35:40,624
time maybe you will come to

5321
02:35:40,624 --> 02:35:42,624
us

5322
02:35:43,560 --> 02:35:45,462
and ask for a different one.

5323
02:35:45,462 --> 02:35:45,863
>> so you're making the

5324
02:35:45,863 --> 02:35:47,531
motion

5325
02:35:47,531 --> 02:35:50,330
just to adopt the proposed

5326
02:35:50,330 --> 02:35:50,767
fees with no automatic

5327
02:35:50,767 --> 02:35:52,767
inflationary adjustment?

5328
02:35:52,770 --> 02:35:54,400
>> and I'll second it but on

5329
02:35:54,400 --> 02:35:56,173
that question, we can come

5330
02:35:56,173 --> 02:35:56,473
back at any time and include

5331
02:35:56,473 --> 02:35:58,410
a

5332
02:35:58,410 --> 02:35:59,176
cpi, a percentage of cpi?

5333
02:35:59,176 --> 02:36:00,845
>> yes.

5334
02:36:00,845 --> 02:36:01,812
>> so for tonight we're

5335
02:36:01,812 --> 02:36:02,245
talking about what staff

5336
02:36:02,245 --> 02:36:03,648
presented?

5337
02:36:03,648 --> 02:36:04,348
>> correct.

5338
02:36:04,348 --> 02:36:05,248
>> okay, clarified, thank

5339
02:36:05,248 --> 02:36:05,583
you,

5340
02:36:05,583 --> 02:36:07,351
all.

5341
02:36:07,351 --> 02:36:08,519
>> perfect, I have a first

5342
02:36:08,519 --> 02:36:09,687
from councilmember nicolas a

5343
02:36:09,687 --> 02:36:10,154
second from vice mayor

5344
02:36:10,154 --> 02:36:10,454
addiego.

5345
02:36:10,454 --> 02:36:11,322
Er

5346
02:36:11,322 --> 02:36:12,523
>> roll call.

5347
02:36:12,523 --> 02:36:12,957
>> MAY xwrorbacker yo

5348
02:36:12,957 --> 02:36:13,290
r mrez

5349
02:36:13,290 --> 02:36:14,224
rez?

5350
02:36:14,224 --> 02:36:15,493
>> yes.

5351
02:36:15,493 --> 02:36:15,960
>> nicolas?Frjts aye.

5352
02:36:15,960 --> 02:36:16,594
>> addiego?

5353
02:36:16,594 --> 02:36:17,610
>> yes.

5354
02:36:17,610 --> 02:36:18,620
>> coleman?

5355
02:36:18,620 --> 02:36:18,529
>> yes.

5356
02:36:18,529 --> 02:36:19,696
>> nagales?

5357
02:36:19,696 --> 02:36:21,696
>> yes.

5358
02:36:21,933 --> 02:36:22,967
>> motion passes, thank you,

5359
02:36:22,967 --> 02:36:23,668
captain plank, thank you,

5360
02:36:23,668 --> 02:36:24,368
everyone, thank you,

5361
02:36:24,368 --> 02:36:26,700
gentlemen.

5362
02:36:26,700 --> 02:36:26,404
>> moving on to item number

5363
02:36:26,404 --> 02:36:28,404
12

5364
02:36:28,539 --> 02:36:31,539
is a report regarding an

5365
02:36:32,100 --> 02:36:34,100
ordinance amending title 6,

5366
02:36:35,680 --> 02:36:37,480
chapter 6.46 of the south san

5367
02:36:37,480 --> 02:36:39,448
francisco municipal code to

5368
02:36:39,884 --> 02:36:41,653
adopt by reference title 4,

5369
02:36:41,653 --> 02:36:42,887
chapter 4.98 of the san mateo

5370
02:36:42,887 --> 02:36:45,890
county ordinance code and

5371
02:36:45,890 --> 02:36:47,489
repealing in its entirety

5372
02:36:48,920 --> 02:36:50,920
title 6, chapter 6.47, sales

5373
02:36:50,394 --> 02:36:52,163
of flavored tobacco products,

5374
02:36:52,163 --> 02:36:54,980
pharmacy sales of tobacco

5375
02:36:54,980 --> 02:36:56,401
products and sales of

5376
02:36:56,401 --> 02:36:56,868
electronic smoking devices

5377
02:36:56,868 --> 02:36:58,269
prohibited.

5378
02:36:58,269 --> 02:37:00,138
Item 12a is the ordinance.

5379
02:37:00,138 --> 02:37:02,440
>> so you're really going to

5380
02:37:02,440 --> 02:37:02,906
kick it off the park here,

5381
02:37:02,906 --> 02:37:04,750
MS.

5382
02:37:04,750 --> 02:37:04,575
Fernandez as your last

5383
02:37:04,575 --> 02:37:05,943
presentation.

5384
02:37:05,943 --> 02:37:08,460
>> this is my parting gift to

5385
02:37:08,460 --> 02:37:10,460
all of you.

5386
02:37:10,810 --> 02:37:11,150
Good evening, councilmembers,

5387
02:37:11,150 --> 02:37:12,884
christina fernandez, your

5388
02:37:12,884 --> 02:37:14,753
deputy city manager, I'm here

5389
02:37:14,753 --> 02:37:17,322
tonight to provide an update

5390
02:37:17,322 --> 02:37:18,490
and seek your approval for

5391
02:37:18,490 --> 02:37:19,257
our

5392
02:37:19,257 --> 02:37:20,826
flavored tobacco regulations

5393
02:37:20,826 --> 02:37:23,462
such that they cmply with

5394
02:37:23,462 --> 02:37:26,462
recent changes to state law.

5395
02:37:26,631 --> 02:37:29,534
With me tonight, I have our

5396
02:37:29,534 --> 02:37:31,934
team, lieutenant sair wyatt,

5397
02:37:32,304 --> 02:37:34,704
shawn occur, from the

5398
02:37:35,730 --> 02:37:37,730
tobacco's county education

5399
02:37:37,910 --> 02:37:40,910
team, myra daoe yez ramirez

5400
02:37:41,180 --> 02:37:42,914
and director of public works,

5401
02:37:42,914 --> 02:37:44,749
bob, so I want to thank them

5402
02:37:44,749 --> 02:37:45,150
for their efforts during this

5403
02:37:45,150 --> 02:37:46,618
process.

5404
02:37:46,618 --> 02:37:49,180
So again we're seking

5405
02:37:49,187 --> 02:37:49,955
council's approval to amend

5406
02:37:49,955 --> 02:37:51,757
the tobacco retailer permit

5407
02:37:51,757 --> 02:37:52,691
and adopt the county's

5408
02:37:52,691 --> 02:37:54,691
ordinance by reference.

5409
02:37:55,461 --> 02:37:57,950
I'm also going to update you

5410
02:37:57,950 --> 02:37:58,300
on our retailer outreach and

5411
02:37:58,300 --> 02:38:00,430
education efforts and then

5412
02:38:00,599 --> 02:38:01,967
provide you with next steps

5413
02:38:01,967 --> 02:38:03,670
on

5414
02:38:03,670 --> 02:38:03,869
tobacco education and

5415
02:38:03,869 --> 02:38:05,700
engagement efforts.

5416
02:38:05,700 --> 02:38:05,470
So, one of the primary

5417
02:38:05,470 --> 02:38:07,339
reasons

5418
02:38:07,339 --> 02:38:09,875
for the city's efforts around

5419
02:38:09,875 --> 02:38:13,412
tobacco is due to the rise of

5420
02:38:13,412 --> 02:38:15,714
vaping by mouther, there's 15

5421
02:38:15,714 --> 02:38:17,483
thousand flavors online, 93%

5422
02:38:17,483 --> 02:38:20,483
of youth who started vaping

5423
02:38:21,153 --> 02:38:22,788
start witched a flavored

5424
02:38:22,788 --> 02:38:23,923
product, 96% of high school

5425
02:38:23,923 --> 02:38:26,923
students who vape use flavor

5426
02:38:27,326 --> 02:38:29,280
and is 9% of san mateo

5427
02:38:29,280 --> 02:38:29,962
high-schoolers vape.

5428
02:38:29,962 --> 02:38:31,597
Vaping requires nicotine salt

5429
02:38:31,597 --> 02:38:33,232
which is highly concentrated

5430
02:38:33,232 --> 02:38:33,699
and bad for developing

5431
02:38:33,699 --> 02:38:35,699
brains,

5432
02:38:36,702 --> 02:38:39,172
it can cause anxiety and many

5433
02:38:39,172 --> 02:38:40,306
other detrimental health

5434
02:38:40,306 --> 02:38:42,306
effects.

5435
02:38:42,374 --> 02:38:42,708
So just a little background

5436
02:38:42,708 --> 02:38:44,708
on

5437
02:38:45,878 --> 02:38:48,278
past actions, back in 2008,

5438
02:38:48,448 --> 02:38:49,849
the city adopted the county's

5439
02:38:49,849 --> 02:38:51,451
tobacco retailer permit

5440
02:38:51,451 --> 02:38:53,753
ordinance by reference and

5441
02:38:53,753 --> 02:38:55,855
that essentially said that we

5442
02:38:55,855 --> 02:38:58,255
were requiring all tobacco

5443
02:38:58,791 --> 02:39:00,590
retailers to maintain a valid

5444
02:39:00,590 --> 02:39:02,328
tobacco retailer permit and

5445
02:39:02,328 --> 02:39:03,496
that we would have the

5446
02:39:03,496 --> 02:39:05,496
county's environmental health

5447
02:39:05,564 --> 02:39:05,965
division enforce those

5448
02:39:05,965 --> 02:39:07,965
permits.

5449
02:39:08,368 --> 02:39:10,670
In 2012, we then passed an

5450
02:39:10,670 --> 02:39:12,405
ordinance prohibiting new

5451
02:39:12,405 --> 02:39:14,240
significant tobacco retailers

5452
02:39:14,240 --> 02:39:14,574
and a significant retailer

5453
02:39:14,574 --> 02:39:16,574
has

5454
02:39:17,477 --> 02:39:19,813
20% or more of their floor

5455
02:39:19,813 --> 02:39:21,681
area space and/or 50% or more

5456
02:39:21,681 --> 02:39:23,617
of their completed sales

5457
02:39:23,617 --> 02:39:24,384
transactions including

5458
02:39:24,384 --> 02:39:26,384
tobacco

5459
02:39:27,954 --> 02:39:29,954
products or paraphernalia,

5460
02:39:30,157 --> 02:39:30,957
back in no. 2019 when I came

5461
02:39:30,957 --> 02:39:33,727
on board, there was an

5462
02:39:33,727 --> 02:39:36,396
interest on behalf of council

5463
02:39:36,396 --> 02:39:37,998
to pursue a flavored tobacco

5464
02:39:37,998 --> 02:39:40,768
banser we pursued that, it

5465
02:39:40,768 --> 02:39:42,168
bans the sale of flavored

5466
02:39:42,168 --> 02:39:43,469
tobacco in all businesses

5467
02:39:43,469 --> 02:39:45,405
except for all adult retail

5468
02:39:45,405 --> 02:39:45,739
and he iser they only allow

5469
02:39:45,739 --> 02:39:47,274
21

5470
02:39:47,274 --> 02:39:47,607
and over on their premises

5471
02:39:47,607 --> 02:39:49,607
and

5472
02:39:49,743 --> 02:39:52,713
that was effect tier JANUARY

5473
02:39:52,713 --> 02:39:54,614
1, 2020.

5474
02:39:54,614 --> 02:39:56,517
So, there have been some

5475
02:39:56,517 --> 02:39:58,685
recent changes to state law

5476
02:39:58,685 --> 02:40:01,850
which would necessitate these

5477
02:40:01,522 --> 02:40:03,922
updates to our ordinance.

5478
02:40:04,958 --> 02:40:07,358
In 2022, voters upheld senate

5479
02:40:07,461 --> 02:40:09,563
bill 793 which prohibited e

5480
02:40:09,563 --> 02:40:12,563
cigarette and is apes and

5481
02:40:13,834 --> 02:40:16,170
other tobacco items listed on

5482
02:40:16,170 --> 02:40:18,170
the screen, methane

5483
02:40:18,239 --> 02:40:20,239
cigarettes, flavored blunt

5484
02:40:20,841 --> 02:40:22,710
wraps, loose leaf roll your

5485
02:40:22,710 --> 02:40:25,110
own tobacco, rolling papers,

5486
02:40:25,746 --> 02:40:27,814
flavored, and tobacco product

5487
02:40:27,814 --> 02:40:28,215
flavor enhances, it did

5488
02:40:28,215 --> 02:40:29,684
exempt

5489
02:40:29,684 --> 02:40:30,500
flavored premium sig gars

5490
02:40:30,500 --> 02:40:31,985
with

5491
02:40:31,985 --> 02:40:34,722
the wolesale price of $12 or

5492
02:40:34,722 --> 02:40:37,458
more and it also exempted

5493
02:40:37,458 --> 02:40:39,858
flavored loose leaf, pipe

5494
02:40:40,728 --> 02:40:42,960
tobacco and flavored sheik ka

5495
02:40:42,960 --> 02:40:45,960
hookah tobacco which MAY only

5496
02:40:46,234 --> 02:40:49,234
be sold in adult only

5497
02:40:49,637 --> 02:40:51,637
retailers.

5498
02:40:53,808 --> 02:40:56,208
Another couple recent bill,

5499
02:40:56,811 --> 02:40:58,946
ab3218 and sb1230, ab3218

5500
02:40:58,946 --> 02:41:01,182
creates an unflavored tobacco

5501
02:41:01,182 --> 02:41:01,649
list and that list is

5502
02:41:01,649 --> 02:41:03,551
supposed

5503
02:41:03,551 --> 02:41:03,984
to be released by the

5504
02:41:03,984 --> 02:41:05,252
attorney

5505
02:41:05,252 --> 02:41:06,354
general by the the end of the

5506
02:41:06,354 --> 02:41:07,589
this year, products not on

5507
02:41:07,589 --> 02:41:10,358
this list would be considered

5508
02:41:10,358 --> 02:41:12,358
a flavored product.

5509
02:41:14,362 --> 02:41:15,763
Sb1230 or the stop act

5510
02:41:15,763 --> 02:41:18,163
complements 3218 such that it

5511
02:41:19,534 --> 02:41:20,301
allows the state to seize

5512
02:41:20,301 --> 02:41:22,701
flavored tobacco products not

5513
02:41:22,804 --> 02:41:24,839
on that list and it imposes

5514
02:41:24,839 --> 02:41:27,239
civil penalties on retailers

5515
02:41:28,877 --> 02:41:30,780
and wholesalers.

5516
02:41:30,780 --> 02:41:33,780
So, in 2023, the city receive

5517
02:41:33,281 --> 02:41:35,349
add a let frer the county

5518
02:41:35,349 --> 02:41:37,686
saying, listen, thankers for

5519
02:41:37,686 --> 02:41:39,521
adopting the 2019 flavored

5520
02:41:39,521 --> 02:41:40,889
tobacco ban because our

5521
02:41:40,889 --> 02:41:41,256
ordinance was modeled on

5522
02:41:41,256 --> 02:41:43,224
that,

5523
02:41:43,224 --> 02:41:43,959
however, we did make

5524
02:41:43,959 --> 02:41:44,659
exceptionbacker exemptions

5525
02:41:44,659 --> 02:41:45,930
such that all the other

5526
02:41:45,930 --> 02:41:47,930
cities

5527
02:41:48,229 --> 02:41:49,698
throughout the county also

5528
02:41:49,698 --> 02:41:50,865
made exemptions so there's a

5529
02:41:50,865 --> 02:41:51,233
patch work of ordinances out

5530
02:41:51,233 --> 02:41:53,233
there.

5531
02:41:54,603 --> 02:41:56,438
In order to reduce logistical

5532
02:41:56,438 --> 02:41:58,306
challenges with enforcing

5533
02:41:58,306 --> 02:41:58,707
various city ordinances

5534
02:41:58,707 --> 02:42:00,609
around

5535
02:42:00,609 --> 02:42:00,976
tobacco, the county said

5536
02:42:00,976 --> 02:42:02,976
we're

5537
02:42:03,780 --> 02:42:04,580
going adopt a new tobacco

5538
02:42:04,580 --> 02:42:06,114
retailer ordinance and have

5539
02:42:06,114 --> 02:42:06,882
stronger enforcement, have

5540
02:42:06,882 --> 02:42:08,951
retail restriction and is

5541
02:42:08,951 --> 02:42:11,530
there will be proximity

5542
02:42:11,530 --> 02:42:12,921
restrictions for new retail

5543
02:42:12,921 --> 02:42:13,855
businesses and they really

5544
02:42:13,855 --> 02:42:15,390
encouraged cities to adopt

5545
02:42:15,390 --> 02:42:17,125
this so there's a more

5546
02:42:17,125 --> 02:42:17,660
streamlined approach to

5547
02:42:17,660 --> 02:42:18,260
enforcement and

5548
02:42:18,260 --> 02:42:20,260
administration

5549
02:42:21,764 --> 02:42:24,164
of the retailer program.

5550
02:42:25,701 --> 02:42:26,635
So, the new county tobacco

5551
02:42:26,635 --> 02:42:28,635
ordinance requirements, it

5552
02:42:28,671 --> 02:42:30,306
does clean up some of the

5553
02:42:30,306 --> 02:42:32,407
language such tat it aligns

5554
02:42:32,407 --> 02:42:34,977
with sate law, so tobacco

5555
02:42:34,977 --> 02:42:35,711
prugt is then defined to

5556
02:42:35,711 --> 02:42:37,279
include synthetic nicotine

5557
02:42:37,279 --> 02:42:39,414
which in the past it did not

5558
02:42:39,414 --> 02:42:40,215
and it also expands the

5559
02:42:40,215 --> 02:42:42,840
definition of electronic

5560
02:42:42,840 --> 02:42:44,484
smoking device to include

5561
02:42:45,121 --> 02:42:47,230
non-nicotine products.

5562
02:42:47,230 --> 02:42:48,724
It also has issues around

5563
02:42:48,724 --> 02:42:50,793
proximity of where new

5564
02:42:50,793 --> 02:42:53,193
retailers could be located

5565
02:42:53,763 --> 02:42:55,598
such that it prohibits new

5566
02:42:55,598 --> 02:42:56,532
tobacco permit for any

5567
02:42:56,532 --> 02:42:58,868
location within a thousand

5568
02:42:58,868 --> 02:43:01,868
feet of the youth populated

5569
02:43:02,172 --> 02:43:04,572
area that could include

5570
02:43:05,441 --> 02:43:07,310
schools, public rec centers,

5571
02:43:07,310 --> 02:43:08,678
libraries, child care

5572
02:43:08,678 --> 02:43:10,213
facilities, preschools, those

5573
02:43:10,213 --> 02:43:11,681
are all considered youth

5574
02:43:11,681 --> 02:43:13,349
populated areas.

5575
02:43:13,349 --> 02:43:13,683
It also prohibits the issue

5576
02:43:13,683 --> 02:43:15,683
of

5577
02:43:16,152 --> 02:43:18,552
new permits with locations

5578
02:43:22,920 --> 02:43:23,693
within 500 feet within an

5579
02:43:23,693 --> 02:43:24,427
existing tobacco retailer,

5580
02:43:24,427 --> 02:43:26,290
posting of retailers unless

5581
02:43:26,290 --> 02:43:27,430
they have a permit and it

5582
02:43:27,430 --> 02:43:29,650
updates such that it

5583
02:43:29,650 --> 02:43:31,134
streamlines with new state

5584
02:43:31,134 --> 02:43:34,734
laws by increasing the age of

5585
02:43:35,672 --> 02:43:36,105
21 years to purchase tobacco

5586
02:43:36,105 --> 02:43:37,674
products.

5587
02:43:37,674 --> 02:43:40,343
So what does this mean for

5588
02:43:40,343 --> 02:43:42,178
existing retailers?

5589
02:43:42,178 --> 02:43:44,578
Upon discussions with county

5590
02:43:45,449 --> 02:43:47,150
staff, we understand that if

5591
02:43:47,150 --> 02:43:48,217
retailers meet one of these

5592
02:43:48,217 --> 02:43:49,786
three requirements, they will

5593
02:43:49,786 --> 02:43:50,253
be designated as a

5594
02:43:50,253 --> 02:43:52,253
preexisting

5595
02:43:53,230 --> 02:43:54,391
business and not subject to

5596
02:43:54,391 --> 02:43:56,391
new proximity requirements.

5597
02:43:56,526 --> 02:43:59,263
So, if a retailer previously

5598
02:43:59,263 --> 02:44:01,164
held a a tobacco permit under

5599
02:44:01,164 --> 02:44:02,332
the county's environmental

5600
02:44:02,332 --> 02:44:03,267
health services, if they're

5601
02:44:03,267 --> 02:44:05,635
register witched the state's

5602
02:44:05,635 --> 02:44:07,704
department of tax and fee

5603
02:44:07,704 --> 02:44:09,306
administration as a tobacco

5604
02:44:09,306 --> 02:44:10,474
retailer or if they hold a

5605
02:44:10,474 --> 02:44:12,810
south city business license

5606
02:44:12,810 --> 02:44:14,644
and is listed aa tobacco

5607
02:44:14,644 --> 02:44:15,345
retailer, then they would be

5608
02:44:15,345 --> 02:44:16,447
considered a preexisting

5609
02:44:16,447 --> 02:44:16,747
business and not have to get

5610
02:44:16,747 --> 02:44:18,747
a

5611
02:44:19,583 --> 02:44:21,785
new permit and be subject to

5612
02:44:21,785 --> 02:44:24,785
the thousand feet and the 500

5613
02:44:26,724 --> 02:44:28,724
feet requirements.

5614
02:44:28,792 --> 02:44:31,128
So, the new county ordinance

5615
02:44:31,128 --> 02:44:32,630
also mandates fines for any

5616
02:44:32,630 --> 02:44:34,463
violations, it increases the

5617
02:44:34,598 --> 02:44:34,965
fines up to $500 for the

5618
02:44:34,965 --> 02:44:36,100
first

5619
02:44:36,100 --> 02:44:36,500
violation and up a to

5620
02:44:36,500 --> 02:44:38,402
a

5621
02:44:38,402 --> 02:44:39,636
thousand for all subsequent

5622
02:44:39,636 --> 02:44:40,938
violation, it requires permit

5623
02:44:40,938 --> 02:44:43,240
suspension if a a business is

5624
02:44:43,240 --> 02:44:45,342
found to have sold to someone

5625
02:44:45,342 --> 02:44:47,178
under 21 and it requires

5626
02:44:47,178 --> 02:44:48,479
on-site inspections by the

5627
02:44:48,479 --> 02:44:49,714
county's environmental health

5628
02:44:49,714 --> 02:44:52,114
services department at least

5629
02:44:52,984 --> 02:44:54,519
twice a year.

5630
02:44:54,519 --> 02:44:55,319
So, some retailer and

5631
02:44:55,319 --> 02:44:55,720
community engagement, I

5632
02:44:55,720 --> 02:44:57,720
really

5633
02:44:58,122 --> 02:44:59,156
want to thank pd for their

5634
02:44:59,156 --> 02:45:00,992
assistance here.

5635
02:45:00,992 --> 02:45:01,459
We mailed out business

5636
02:45:01,459 --> 02:45:03,940
letters

5637
02:45:03,940 --> 02:45:04,280
to approximately 100

5638
02:45:04,280 --> 02:45:05,663
businesses who we thought

5639
02:45:05,663 --> 02:45:07,663
might be affected.

5640
02:45:09,100 --> 02:45:10,501
We also did three information

5641
02:45:10,501 --> 02:45:13,501
sessions, two in person and

5642
02:45:14,305 --> 02:45:15,506
one virtual and we also did

5643
02:45:15,506 --> 02:45:16,641
an

5644
02:45:16,641 --> 02:45:18,343
online tobacco retailer

5645
02:45:18,343 --> 02:45:19,744
survey, we targeted that with

5646
02:45:19,744 --> 02:45:22,460
the ecd distribution list we

5647
02:45:22,460 --> 02:45:23,714
have online and we also did

5648
02:45:23,714 --> 02:45:24,415
some social media posts

5649
02:45:24,415 --> 02:45:25,850
around

5650
02:45:25,850 --> 02:45:27,719
the survey encouraging folks

5651
02:45:27,719 --> 02:45:29,719
to take it.

5652
02:45:30,255 --> 02:45:31,656
And we also did in person

5653
02:45:31,656 --> 02:45:33,424
retailer visits such that we

5654
02:45:33,424 --> 02:45:34,658
visited about half of the

5655
02:45:34,658 --> 02:45:35,126
retailers that we have on

5656
02:45:35,126 --> 02:45:37,126
file

5657
02:45:38,763 --> 02:45:40,164
and we went and we spoke with

5658
02:45:40,164 --> 02:45:42,564
businesses and informed them

5659
02:45:43,680 --> 02:45:44,903
of the upcoming changes and

5660
02:45:44,903 --> 02:45:46,504
let them know how this could

5661
02:45:46,504 --> 02:45:47,439
potentially affect their

5662
02:45:47,439 --> 02:45:49,241
business and answered any

5663
02:45:49,241 --> 02:45:50,474
questions they MAY have,

5664
02:45:50,474 --> 02:45:50,942
overall most of the

5665
02:45:50,942 --> 02:45:52,942
businesses

5666
02:45:54,179 --> 02:45:56,140
said we haven't sold flavored

5667
02:45:56,140 --> 02:45:57,416
tobacco in four or five years.

5668
02:45:57,416 --> 02:45:59,751
There were questions around

5669
02:45:59,751 --> 02:46:02,487
sofm the other products such

5670
02:46:02,487 --> 02:46:03,588
as like flavored cigars, I

5671
02:46:03,588 --> 02:46:04,590
guess folks had questions

5672
02:46:04,590 --> 02:46:06,458
about that.

5673
02:46:06,458 --> 02:46:07,659
And so, yeah, overall, folks

5674
02:46:07,659 --> 02:46:09,494
didn't seem to really have

5675
02:46:09,494 --> 02:46:10,862
questions and they all seemed

5676
02:46:10,862 --> 02:46:13,262
to indicate they were

5677
02:46:14,466 --> 02:46:14,800
compliant with existing state

5678
02:46:14,800 --> 02:46:16,800
law.

5679
02:46:17,970 --> 02:46:21,570
So, for the next steps, you

5680
02:46:21,907 --> 02:46:23,509
know, currently chapter 20 of

5681
02:46:23,509 --> 02:46:25,909
our money code [Inaudible]

5682
02:46:26,110 --> 02:46:27,112
Chapter 20 is referenced in

5683
02:46:27,112 --> 02:46:28,981
chapter 6.47 which will be

5684
02:46:28,981 --> 02:46:30,816
repealed if this is approved

5685
02:46:30,816 --> 02:46:32,318
tonight, just to ensure

5686
02:46:32,318 --> 02:46:32,651
consistency the throughout

5687
02:46:32,651 --> 02:46:34,651
our

5688
02:46:35,954 --> 02:46:37,122
municipal code, staff will be

5689
02:46:37,122 --> 02:46:38,570
bringing chapter 4.20 to the

5690
02:46:38,570 --> 02:46:39,191
planning tuition for their

5691
02:46:39,191 --> 02:46:40,593
review and back the city

5692
02:46:40,593 --> 02:46:41,527
council for their review and

5693
02:46:41,527 --> 02:46:42,928
approval.

5694
02:46:42,928 --> 02:46:44,563
That being said, separate and

5695
02:46:44,563 --> 02:46:45,698
apart from that, I this

5696
02:46:45,698 --> 02:46:46,132
ordinance is approved

5697
02:46:46,132 --> 02:46:47,600
tonight,

5698
02:46:47,600 --> 02:46:49,201
we would go for a second

5699
02:46:49,201 --> 02:46:50,836
reading on APRIL 9 and this

5700
02:46:50,836 --> 02:46:52,471
would then be effective 30

5701
02:46:52,471 --> 02:46:52,838
days from that reading so

5702
02:46:52,838 --> 02:46:54,838
we'd

5703
02:46:55,841 --> 02:46:57,543
think about MAY 7.

5704
02:46:57,543 --> 02:46:58,100
And so with that, the team

5705
02:46:58,100 --> 02:46:59,879
and

5706
02:46:59,879 --> 02:47:01,470
I are here, happy to answer

5707
02:47:01,470 --> 02:47:02,914
any questions you MAY have.

5708
02:47:02,914 --> 02:47:05,314
>> thank you, christina, I

5709
02:47:06,252 --> 02:47:08,252
appreciate the presentation.

5710
02:47:09,222 --> 02:47:11,222
Questions?

5711
02:47:11,724 --> 02:47:12,859
>> I was going to say the

5712
02:47:12,859 --> 02:47:15,259
presentation was so complete

5713
02:47:15,795 --> 02:47:16,229
and prfect that I have no

5714
02:47:16,229 --> 02:47:17,463
questions.

5715
02:47:17,463 --> 02:47:19,332
Great finish.

5716
02:47:19,332 --> 02:47:20,299
>> I have just one or two

5717
02:47:20,299 --> 02:47:21,901
questions, I think it's

5718
02:47:21,901 --> 02:47:23,503
appropriate the first thing

5719
02:47:23,503 --> 02:47:25,138
that I passed with your help

5720
02:47:25,138 --> 02:47:28,738
happens to be the last thing

5721
02:47:29,208 --> 02:47:30,609
you're presenting here.

5722
02:47:30,609 --> 02:47:33,580
At the time, we had a

5723
02:47:33,580 --> 02:47:35,415
discussion back in 219 about

5724
02:47:35,415 --> 02:47:36,115
the businesses that will be

5725
02:47:36,115 --> 02:47:37,284
exempt.

5726
02:47:37,284 --> 02:47:38,551
At the time, there were two,

5727
02:47:38,551 --> 02:47:39,452
now there's one from my

5728
02:47:39,452 --> 02:47:40,119
reading o the staff report,

5729
02:47:40,119 --> 02:47:40,820
correct?

5730
02:47:40,820 --> 02:47:42,656
>> that's correct.

5731
02:47:42,656 --> 02:47:42,989
>> they would still be able

5732
02:47:42,989 --> 02:47:44,989
to

5733
02:47:47,794 --> 02:47:49,129
operate based upon the -- I

5734
02:47:49,129 --> 02:47:50,970
guess the criteria,

5735
02:47:50,970 --> 02:47:51,310
grandfathered in.

5736
02:47:51,310 --> 02:47:51,364
Thefrjt would still be able

5737
02:47:51,364 --> 02:47:52,432
to

5738
02:47:52,432 --> 02:47:52,899
operate but anything that

5739
02:47:52,899 --> 02:47:54,301
they

5740
02:47:54,301 --> 02:47:57,301
had that MAY be flavored,

5741
02:47:58,338 --> 02:47:58,704
there are some businesses

5742
02:47:58,704 --> 02:48:00,674
that

5743
02:48:00,674 --> 02:48:01,574
are maybe not compliant with

5744
02:48:01,574 --> 02:48:01,975
our existing ordinance,

5745
02:48:01,975 --> 02:48:03,477
right,

5746
02:48:03,477 --> 02:48:04,911
so it's maybe time to kind of

5747
02:48:04,911 --> 02:48:06,480
do some education and some

5748
02:48:06,480 --> 02:48:08,314
outreach just to make sure

5749
02:48:08,314 --> 02:48:09,716
they're above board with the

5750
02:48:09,716 --> 02:48:11,484
current ordinance but I will

5751
02:48:11,484 --> 02:48:13,820
say that that business would

5752
02:48:13,820 --> 02:48:14,788
not hen be able to sell

5753
02:48:14,788 --> 02:48:17,124
flavored tobacco, they can

5754
02:48:17,124 --> 02:48:18,492
stay in business and sell

5755
02:48:18,492 --> 02:48:19,893
unflavored tobacco but they

5756
02:48:19,893 --> 02:48:20,593
could not sell flavored

5757
02:48:20,593 --> 02:48:22,229
tobacco.

5758
02:48:22,229 --> 02:48:22,896
>> that was kind of the

5759
02:48:22,896 --> 02:48:23,330
conversation that the

5760
02:48:23,330 --> 02:48:24,531
previous

5761
02:48:24,531 --> 02:48:26,320
council had in terms of

5762
02:48:26,320 --> 02:48:27,901
making

5763
02:48:27,901 --> 02:48:29,690
sure that we are not damage

5764
02:48:29,690 --> 02:48:30,537
thing or hurting their

5765
02:48:30,537 --> 02:48:33,307
business in a sense because

5766
02:48:33,307 --> 02:48:33,640
that was a big topic amongst

5767
02:48:33,640 --> 02:48:35,640
us.

5768
02:48:36,577 --> 02:48:37,978
And so I kind of wanted

5769
02:48:37,978 --> 02:48:39,580
clarification on there's like

5770
02:48:39,580 --> 02:48:42,149
signage sometimes I see that

5771
02:48:42,149 --> 02:48:42,850
sells -- that says flavored

5772
02:48:42,850 --> 02:48:44,850
tobacco being sold.

5773
02:48:45,152 --> 02:48:48,152
Is that now being restricted

5774
02:48:50,624 --> 02:48:51,392
in terms of advertisement?

5775
02:48:51,392 --> 02:48:51,792
I'm trying to understand how

5776
02:48:51,792 --> 02:48:52,559
that --

5777
02:48:52,559 --> 02:48:54,594
>> yeah, so, as I understand

5778
02:48:54,594 --> 02:48:56,994
the new county ordinance,

5779
02:48:57,832 --> 02:48:58,599
unless you have a valid

5780
02:48:58,599 --> 02:49:00,367
tobacco retailer permit, you

5781
02:49:00,367 --> 02:49:00,801
would not be able to

5782
02:49:00,801 --> 02:49:02,200
advertise

5783
02:49:02,200 --> 02:49:04,200
tobacco products.

5784
02:49:04,772 --> 02:49:07,730
>> so, if you had a valid

5785
02:49:07,730 --> 02:49:09,473
license to sell flavored

5786
02:49:09,710 --> 02:49:10,744
tobacco, you are able to have

5787
02:49:10,744 --> 02:49:12,513
that signage?

5788
02:49:12,513 --> 02:49:12,780
>> so, flavored tobacco is

5789
02:49:12,780 --> 02:49:14,780
not

5790
02:49:15,116 --> 02:49:15,483
going to be allowed to be

5791
02:49:15,483 --> 02:49:17,483
sold

5792
02:49:17,552 --> 02:49:20,822
anywhere, so I think that if

5793
02:49:20,822 --> 02:49:22,223
they wanted to advertise like

5794
02:49:22,223 --> 02:49:24,592
cigarettes, they could, and

5795
02:49:24,592 --> 02:49:26,194
honestly if they want to

5796
02:49:26,194 --> 02:49:27,594
advertise flavored tobacco,

5797
02:49:27,594 --> 02:49:29,664
they probably could but I

5798
02:49:29,664 --> 02:49:31,733
don't see if they would if

5799
02:49:31,733 --> 02:49:33,601
they couldn't sell it but I

5800
02:49:33,601 --> 02:49:34,903
guess technically they could.

5801
02:49:34,903 --> 02:49:36,204
I don't know if you have

5802
02:49:36,204 --> 02:49:38,720
comments on that.

5803
02:49:38,720 --> 02:49:40,374
>> okay, I see those signage

5804
02:49:40,374 --> 02:49:41,309
and I always felt like that

5805
02:49:41,309 --> 02:49:42,900
should be restricted, okay.

5806
02:49:42,900 --> 02:49:43,611
>> yeah.

5807
02:49:43,611 --> 02:49:44,779
>> and then could we talk

5808
02:49:44,779 --> 02:49:46,779
about the county

5809
02:49:46,881 --> 02:49:49,184
implementation, so now we are

5810
02:49:49,184 --> 02:49:49,551
going from our own pd in

5811
02:49:49,551 --> 02:49:50,585
terms

5812
02:49:50,585 --> 02:49:52,985
of education and enforcement

5813
02:49:59,227 --> 02:50:00,829
now to the county.

5814
02:50:00,829 --> 02:50:01,329
>> it's twofold t the city

5815
02:50:01,329 --> 02:50:02,464
can

5816
02:50:02,464 --> 02:50:04,900
still enforce, we are looking

5817
02:50:04,900 --> 02:50:06,401
to to the county to do those

5818
02:50:06,401 --> 02:50:08,690
site inspections twice a year

5819
02:50:08,690 --> 02:50:10,469
and to enforce where

5820
02:50:10,739 --> 02:50:12,107
appropriate but definitely I

5821
02:50:12,107 --> 02:50:12,406
know pd will definitely have

5822
02:50:12,406 --> 02:50:14,406
a

5823
02:50:14,743 --> 02:50:15,677
hand in code enforcement and

5824
02:50:15,677 --> 02:50:17,413
code enforcement will also

5825
02:50:17,413 --> 02:50:17,813
have a hand in this th

5826
02:50:17,813 --> 02:50:19,448
and

5827
02:50:19,448 --> 02:50:21,516
once we adopt this, we're

5828
02:50:21,516 --> 02:50:22,840
looking at pushing out

5829
02:50:22,840 --> 02:50:24,840
education first.

5830
02:50:25,821 --> 02:50:27,455
I know lieutenant sair dotty

5831
02:50:27,455 --> 02:50:29,291
was successful in obtaining

5832
02:50:29,291 --> 02:50:31,691
state department of jstice

5833
02:50:32,270 --> 02:50:32,728
tobacco grant for money to do

5834
02:50:32,728 --> 02:50:34,630
outreach and education.

5835
02:50:34,630 --> 02:50:35,731
I don't know, lieutenant, if

5836
02:50:35,731 --> 02:50:36,980
you want to make a comment

5837
02:50:36,980 --> 02:50:38,980
here.

5838
02:50:38,434 --> 02:50:40,736
>> please, come on up.

5839
02:50:40,736 --> 02:50:42,804
>> good ever wantoning, yes,

5840
02:50:42,804 --> 02:50:44,873
the department of justice

5841
02:50:44,873 --> 02:50:45,207
tobacco grant we received,

5842
02:50:45,207 --> 02:50:47,207
our

5843
02:50:49,411 --> 02:50:51,847
primary goal is to provide

5844
02:50:51,847 --> 02:50:52,614
education since the

5845
02:50:52,614 --> 02:50:53,282
implementation of the grant,

5846
02:50:53,282 --> 02:50:54,383
we have gone out to the

5847
02:50:54,383 --> 02:50:54,817
businesses, provided

5848
02:50:54,817 --> 02:50:56,817
pamphlets

5849
02:50:57,119 --> 02:50:57,519
and information on our

5850
02:50:57,519 --> 02:50:59,519
current

5851
02:50:59,988 --> 02:51:00,423
muni code on tobacco

5852
02:51:00,423 --> 02:51:02,423
products,

5853
02:51:02,525 --> 02:51:05,327
checked t see that they were

5854
02:51:05,327 --> 02:51:08,970
in guidelines with our muni

5855
02:51:08,970 --> 02:51:10,132
code, so should we adopt the

5856
02:51:10,132 --> 02:51:10,466
new muni code, we would go

5857
02:51:10,466 --> 02:51:12,466
out

5858
02:51:13,402 --> 02:51:14,537
and implement the new muni

5859
02:51:14,537 --> 02:51:16,172
code, povide eucation, we

5860
02:51:16,172 --> 02:51:17,606
would not be enforcing it at

5861
02:51:17,606 --> 02:51:18,390
this time and just ensure

5862
02:51:18,390 --> 02:51:19,207
that

5863
02:51:19,207 --> 02:51:21,607
all the businesses understand

5864
02:51:22,678 --> 02:51:25,114
that the muni code, so our

5865
02:51:25,114 --> 02:51:26,149
primary action is education

5866
02:51:26,149 --> 02:51:27,750
before enforcement.

5867
02:51:27,750 --> 02:51:28,184
>> now I've seen the

5868
02:51:28,184 --> 02:51:30,860
education

5869
02:51:30,860 --> 02:51:30,453
process when we implemented

5870
02:51:30,453 --> 02:51:32,422
this.

5871
02:51:32,422 --> 02:51:34,891
I started seeing the flavored

5872
02:51:34,891 --> 02:51:36,959
tobacco getting taken away

5873
02:51:36,959 --> 02:51:40,559
like for like the wall fronds

5874
02:51:42,980 --> 02:51:42,799
or the 7th [Hr-e/]-elevens

5875
02:51:42,799 --> 02:51:43,500
where they were primarily

5876
02:51:43,500 --> 02:51:43,866
being sold, I was seeing

5877
02:51:43,866 --> 02:51:44,300
those

5878
02:51:44,300 --> 02:51:46,169
taken out.

5879
02:51:46,169 --> 02:51:48,671
The last question is the

5880
02:51:48,671 --> 02:51:50,306
hookah tobacco, the ordinance

5881
02:51:50,306 --> 02:51:50,740
says if that's still

5882
02:51:50,740 --> 02:51:52,740
permitted

5883
02:51:55,946 --> 02:51:58,714
if a business that's I guess

5884
02:51:58,714 --> 02:51:59,816
allowed 21 -- 21 or older on

5885
02:51:59,816 --> 02:52:02,352
the premise, if you're a

5886
02:52:02,352 --> 02:52:05,352
business that has that, you

5887
02:52:05,354 --> 02:52:07,691
can still continue as long as

5888
02:52:07,691 --> 02:52:09,920
an adult -- I don't want to

5889
02:52:09,920 --> 02:52:10,227
use your terminology in terms

5890
02:52:10,227 --> 02:52:11,728
of 21 and ogler.

5891
02:52:11,728 --> 02:52:12,829
>> we're adopt thing county's

5892
02:52:12,829 --> 02:52:14,464
ordinance which is stricter

5893
02:52:14,464 --> 02:52:16,265
than the state law such that

5894
02:52:16,265 --> 02:52:17,934
hookah would not be allowed.

5895
02:52:17,934 --> 02:52:18,335
>> okay.

5896
02:52:18,335 --> 02:52:19,703
alright.

5897
02:52:19,703 --> 02:52:23,303
That's all I have, thank you.

5898
02:52:23,674 --> 02:52:25,674
>> great, thank you.

5899
02:52:25,776 --> 02:52:27,411
>> so, I do have a question,

5900
02:52:27,411 --> 02:52:29,545
well, I I do sup or the the

5901
02:52:29,545 --> 02:52:31,214
ordinance but my question is

5902
02:52:31,214 --> 02:52:33,614
flavored tobacco has been

5903
02:52:33,784 --> 02:52:35,819
banned if for sometime now

5904
02:52:35,819 --> 02:52:38,288
statewide and yt when I go

5905
02:52:38,288 --> 02:52:39,323
out, there I see flavored

5906
02:52:39,323 --> 02:52:41,323
tobacco everywhere.

5907
02:52:43,494 --> 02:52:45,195
And so my question is, is it

5908
02:52:45,195 --> 02:52:48,195
an isue of enforcement, how

5909
02:52:50,701 --> 02:52:51,402
come it's still so pervasive

5910
02:52:51,402 --> 02:52:53,402
outside?

5911
02:52:56,373 --> 02:52:56,674
>> yeah, I mean, I don't know

5912
02:52:56,674 --> 02:52:58,674
,

5913
02:52:59,176 --> 02:53:01,111
I mean I would say that maybe

5914
02:53:01,111 --> 02:53:02,947
it's enforcement, you know,

5915
02:53:02,947 --> 02:53:06,547
maybe it's, yeah, wi eel pull

5916
02:53:07,251 --> 02:53:09,286
it off the shelf and then a a

5917
02:53:09,286 --> 02:53:10,540
month a a so and put it back

5918
02:53:10,540 --> 02:53:10,888
up, that kind of thing, but I

5919
02:53:10,888 --> 02:53:12,550
can't really speak to why

5920
02:53:12,550 --> 02:53:12,490
it's

5921
02:53:12,490 --> 02:53:14,358
pervasive.

5922
02:53:14,358 --> 02:53:15,526
I would assume it is probably

5923
02:53:15,526 --> 02:53:17,926
just enforcement and just

5924
02:53:18,462 --> 02:53:19,864
being consistent in

5925
02:53:19,864 --> 02:53:20,164
enforcement

5926
02:53:20,164 --> 02:53:22,164
.

5927
02:53:22,166 --> 02:53:24,100
>> and once we provide the

5928
02:53:24,100 --> 02:53:24,334
education to the retailers,

5929
02:53:24,334 --> 02:53:26,334
we

5930
02:53:26,337 --> 02:53:27,538
can also do more town halls

5931
02:53:27,538 --> 02:53:29,373
and invite retailers to

5932
02:53:29,373 --> 02:53:31,909
educate them on the new muni

5933
02:53:31,909 --> 02:53:33,277
code and the laws.

5934
02:53:33,277 --> 02:53:35,346
We would provide a time for

5935
02:53:35,346 --> 02:53:35,947
them to understand it, make

5936
02:53:35,947 --> 02:53:36,414
sure everyone is in

5937
02:53:36,414 --> 02:53:38,414
accordance

5938
02:53:41,190 --> 02:53:41,786
with it and then we can do

5939
02:53:41,786 --> 02:53:43,654
impact inspections similar to

5940
02:53:43,654 --> 02:53:45,657
what we do with our abc grant

5941
02:53:45,657 --> 02:53:46,791
where we go out, we make sure

5942
02:53:46,791 --> 02:53:48,760
they're following all of the

5943
02:53:48,760 --> 02:53:49,127
laws that they have to do

5944
02:53:49,127 --> 02:53:51,127
with

5945
02:53:51,329 --> 02:53:52,730
their license with abc, so we

5946
02:53:52,730 --> 02:53:53,932
could d inspections at these

5947
02:53:53,932 --> 02:53:54,398
retailers to make sure

5948
02:53:54,398 --> 02:53:56,268
they're

5949
02:53:56,268 --> 02:53:57,869
following the guidelines for

5950
02:53:57,869 --> 02:53:59,370
the tobacco products, so that

5951
02:53:59,370 --> 02:54:01,840
is an option we would be able

5952
02:54:01,840 --> 02:54:02,874
to have with that.

5953
02:54:02,874 --> 02:54:04,843
>> sure, thank you.

5954
02:54:04,843 --> 02:54:07,440
>> what's the timeline that

5955
02:54:07,440 --> 02:54:07,379
you allow tem to -- while

5956
02:54:07,379 --> 02:54:09,180
the

5957
02:54:09,180 --> 02:54:10,815
law implements that phase-in,

5958
02:54:10,815 --> 02:54:12,884
what -- is it varying or do

5959
02:54:12,884 --> 02:54:14,860
you work with each one, what

5960
02:54:14,860 --> 02:54:16,486
does it look like?

5961
02:54:17,321 --> 02:54:18,256
>> obviously we don't want to

5962
02:54:18,256 --> 02:54:19,324
go --

5963
02:54:19,324 --> 02:54:20,559
>> tat's exactly what I'm

5964
02:54:20,559 --> 02:54:22,194
going to.

5965
02:54:22,194 --> 02:54:24,594
>> education has always been

5966
02:54:27,232 --> 02:54:27,566
at the forefront of all of

5967
02:54:27,566 --> 02:54:29,467
our

5968
02:54:29,467 --> 02:54:30,536
grants, with abc as well, so

5969
02:54:30,536 --> 02:54:33,272
we -- the easiest way is to

5970
02:54:33,272 --> 02:54:33,672
kind of explain our abc

5971
02:54:33,672 --> 02:54:35,730
grant,

5972
02:54:35,730 --> 02:54:35,874
for instance we do these

5973
02:54:35,874 --> 02:54:36,240
impact inspections and we

5974
02:54:36,240 --> 02:54:38,240
will

5975
02:54:39,879 --> 02:54:41,279
go out to or retailers, our

5976
02:54:41,279 --> 02:54:44,279
licensees two or three time

5977
02:54:44,550 --> 02:54:46,184
sos the first time we'll go

5978
02:54:46,184 --> 02:54:48,584
over, make sure they're

5979
02:54:48,721 --> 02:54:49,621
following all of the

5980
02:54:49,621 --> 02:54:50,550
regulations for their

5981
02:54:50,550 --> 02:54:51,623
license,

5982
02:54:51,623 --> 02:54:53,240
make sure if they need to

5983
02:54:53,240 --> 02:54:54,793
update anything websinger ear

5984
02:54:54,793 --> 02:54:56,280
write things down, give them

5985
02:54:56,280 --> 02:54:57,762
some pamphlet and is go out

5986
02:54:57,762 --> 02:54:59,797
maybe a month later, check,

5987
02:54:59,797 --> 02:55:00,732
hey, did you fix these things

5988
02:55:00,732 --> 02:55:01,330
we talked about, if they

5989
02:55:01,330 --> 02:55:02,568
still

5990
02:55:02,568 --> 02:55:03,680
need to make some

5991
02:55:03,680 --> 02:55:04,202
corrections,

5992
02:55:04,202 --> 02:55:04,570
we'll write them town and

5993
02:55:04,570 --> 02:55:06,104
then

5994
02:55:06,104 --> 02:55:07,740
come out maybe a couple of

5995
02:55:07,740 --> 02:55:09,341
months later and then if

5996
02:55:09,341 --> 02:55:12,211
they're still not doing it,

5997
02:55:12,211 --> 02:55:15,211
maybe we'll start giving a

5998
02:55:16,820 --> 02:55:17,717
citation or we'll contact abc

5999
02:55:17,717 --> 02:55:18,500
to come out and do it that

6000
02:55:18,500 --> 02:55:20,500
way

6001
02:55:20,486 --> 02:55:22,788
so we'll give them plenty of

6002
02:55:22,788 --> 02:55:24,390
opportunities to correct the

6003
02:55:24,390 --> 02:55:25,591
behavior because they are

6004
02:55:25,591 --> 02:55:27,326
businesses in our city so we

6005
02:55:27,326 --> 02:55:27,727
do want to work with them.

6006
02:55:27,727 --> 02:55:29,727
>> okay.

6007
02:55:29,929 --> 02:55:31,831
Thank you.

6008
02:55:31,831 --> 02:55:33,831
Anyone else, questions?

6009
02:55:34,867 --> 02:55:36,468
I just wanted to know,

6010
02:55:36,468 --> 02:55:38,504
christina, you sent letters

6011
02:55:38,504 --> 02:55:39,739
for this community meeting to

6012
02:55:39,739 --> 02:55:41,707
100 businesses, how many of

6013
02:55:41,707 --> 02:55:42,307
those were tobacco retailers

6014
02:55:42,307 --> 02:55:44,307
approximately?

6015
02:55:44,644 --> 02:55:47,647
>> well, we only have -- so,

6016
02:55:47,647 --> 02:55:49,549
on the book, we have about 45

6017
02:55:49,549 --> 02:55:52,549
tobacco retailers so we sent

6018
02:55:52,585 --> 02:55:54,687
it to the 45 but tlen to

6019
02:55:54,687 --> 02:55:55,210
anyone else who MAY be sort

6020
02:55:55,210 --> 02:55:55,654
of

6021
02:55:55,654 --> 02:55:57,654
associated with it.

6022
02:55:58,424 --> 02:56:00,260
>> but I wanted to highlight

6023
02:56:00,260 --> 02:56:01,294
that no tobacco retailers

6024
02:56:01,294 --> 02:56:01,728
attended any of the three

6025
02:56:01,728 --> 02:56:03,630
meetings.

6026
02:56:03,630 --> 02:56:05,164
>> we had cmmunity members

6027
02:56:05,164 --> 02:56:08,164
come and speak about tobacco

6028
02:56:08,401 --> 02:56:10,637
and how they weren't fans of

6029
02:56:10,637 --> 02:56:11,972
tobacco but we did not have

6030
02:56:11,972 --> 02:56:12,372
any retailers, we had a

6031
02:56:12,372 --> 02:56:13,707
little

6032
02:56:13,707 --> 02:56:14,174
more luck with the surveys

6033
02:56:14,174 --> 02:56:15,108
but

6034
02:56:15,108 --> 02:56:15,474
the surveys indicate that

6035
02:56:15,474 --> 02:56:17,474
most

6036
02:56:18,211 --> 02:56:19,646
folks are compliant with the

6037
02:56:19,646 --> 02:56:20,881
lasers already.

6038
02:56:20,881 --> 02:56:22,282
>> alright.

6039
02:56:22,282 --> 02:56:22,715
Any other questions or

6040
02:56:22,715 --> 02:56:24,618
comments?

6041
02:56:24,618 --> 02:56:25,840
If not, do we have public

6042
02:56:25,840 --> 02:56:26,953
comments?

6043
02:56:26,953 --> 02:56:27,654
>> we do not, mayor.

6044
02:56:27,654 --> 02:56:29,654
>> alright.

6045
02:56:30,423 --> 02:56:32,259
>> before you make -- ask for

6046
02:56:32,259 --> 02:56:34,327
a motion, just one procedural

6047
02:56:34,327 --> 02:56:36,396
point, state law is a little

6048
02:56:36,396 --> 02:56:37,998
bit different when adopting

6049
02:56:37,998 --> 02:56:40,100
the code of another agency by

6050
02:56:40,100 --> 02:56:41,167
reference which is what we're

6051
02:56:41,167 --> 02:56:42,169
doing tonight, you'll still

6052
02:56:42,169 --> 02:56:43,336
introduce it.

6053
02:56:43,336 --> 02:56:45,439
When it comes back, the

6054
02:56:45,439 --> 02:56:46,607
ordinance will not be on

6055
02:56:46,607 --> 02:56:47,400
consent for the second

6056
02:56:47,400 --> 02:56:48,909
reading

6057
02:56:48,909 --> 02:56:51,780
we're required to hold a

6058
02:56:51,780 --> 02:56:52,646
public hearing, so you'll

6059
02:56:52,646 --> 02:56:53,881
still -- there will still be

6060
02:56:53,881 --> 02:56:54,314
two meetings for the

6061
02:56:54,314 --> 02:56:55,549
adoption,

6062
02:56:55,549 --> 02:56:56,917
rather than it appearing on

6063
02:56:56,917 --> 02:56:58,318
consent, it will be a public

6064
02:56:58,318 --> 02:56:59,954
hearing at the second reading.

6065
02:56:59,954 --> 02:57:00,454
>> thank you for that

6066
02:57:00,454 --> 02:57:02,454
clarification.

6067
02:57:02,489 --> 02:57:03,923
With that, do I have a motion?

6068
02:57:03,923 --> 02:57:04,525
>> so moved, MR. Mayor.

6069
02:57:04,525 --> 02:57:05,926
>> I'll second.

6070
02:57:05,926 --> 02:57:06,960
>> I have a first and a

6071
02:57:06,960 --> 02:57:07,861
second, can I have a roll

6072
02:57:07,861 --> 02:57:09,861
call?

6073
02:57:09,963 --> 02:57:10,598
>> vice mayor addiego,

6074
02:57:10,598 --> 02:57:12,990
councilmember nagales?

6075
02:57:12,990 --> 02:57:12,633
>> yes.

6076
02:57:12,633 --> 02:57:14,633
>> mayor flores?

6077
02:57:14,634 --> 02:57:15,335
>> yes.

6078
02:57:15,335 --> 02:57:17,335
>> councilmember nicolas?

6079
02:57:18,439 --> 02:57:20,730
>> yes.

6080
02:57:20,730 --> 02:57:21,800
>> councilmember [Inaudible]

6081
02:57:21,800 --> 02:57:22,142
>> aye.

6082
02:57:22,142 --> 02:57:22,710
>> thank you, I appreciate

6083
02:57:22,710 --> 02:57:23,420
everyone staying.

6084
02:57:23,420 --> 02:57:25,420
Er

6085
02:57:26,847 --> 02:57:28,716
>> moving on to items from

6086
02:57:28,716 --> 02:57:29,500
council, committee reports

6087
02:57:29,500 --> 02:57:30,318
and

6088
02:57:30,318 --> 02:57:31,519
announcements, item 13 is

6089
02:57:31,519 --> 02:57:33,540
consider sending letters of

6090
02:57:33,540 --> 02:57:35,540
support for various

6091
02:57:35,188 --> 02:57:36,624
legislative items.

6092
02:57:36,624 --> 02:57:37,524
>> alright.

6093
02:57:37,524 --> 02:57:39,159
Sharon?

6094
02:57:39,159 --> 02:57:40,940
>> sure, I would be happy to

6095
02:57:40,940 --> 02:57:42,940
speak to this.

6096
02:57:44,231 --> 02:57:46,567
we've provided you with fiver

6097
02:57:46,567 --> 02:57:49,567
-- five letters of support,

6098
02:57:50,271 --> 02:57:52,406
there were deadlines we need

6099
02:57:52,406 --> 02:57:53,740
today meet, a couple of these

6100
02:57:53,740 --> 02:57:53,841
letters have been spent.

6101
02:57:53,841 --> 02:57:56,110
Our practice has been to copy

6102
02:57:56,110 --> 02:57:57,512
council or seek your support,

6103
02:57:57,512 --> 02:57:58,179
so I've got five of them

6104
02:57:58,179 --> 02:58:00,179
here,

6105
02:58:02,583 --> 02:58:05,253
the frst one is regarding

6106
02:58:05,253 --> 02:58:07,253
congressionally directed

6107
02:58:09,157 --> 02:58:09,524
spending for samtrans and

6108
02:58:09,524 --> 02:58:11,920
this

6109
02:58:11,920 --> 02:58:13,492
is to different legislators,

6110
02:58:14,295 --> 02:58:15,463
then we have one here for --

6111
02:58:15,463 --> 02:58:17,463
three different legislators

6112
02:58:17,799 --> 02:58:19,799
on

6113
02:58:20,802 --> 02:58:22,802
that one, oneshorline

6114
02:58:23,404 --> 02:58:25,804
resilience plan support as

6115
02:58:29,878 --> 02:58:32,278
well as licensing exemption

6116
02:58:32,914 --> 02:58:35,160
and one for weta, and I would

6117
02:58:35,160 --> 02:58:36,518
just add, I'm very supportive

6118
02:58:36,518 --> 02:58:37,840
of doing these letters in

6119
02:58:37,840 --> 02:58:39,840
that

6120
02:58:39,421 --> 02:58:39,888
we often ask these agencies

6121
02:58:39,888 --> 02:58:41,289
to

6122
02:58:41,289 --> 02:58:43,580
write up support letters when

6123
02:58:43,580 --> 02:58:44,559
we're submitting a grant so

6124
02:58:44,559 --> 02:58:45,960
it's reciprocal that we

6125
02:58:45,960 --> 02:58:47,361
support other agencies when

6126
02:58:47,361 --> 02:58:48,763
they're seeking funding so we

6127
02:58:48,763 --> 02:58:50,399
want to mke sure council is

6128
02:58:50,399 --> 02:58:52,701
aware of these letters and

6129
02:58:52,701 --> 02:58:54,770
doesn't have any issues with

6130
02:58:54,770 --> 02:58:56,672
us issuing these?

6131
02:58:56,672 --> 02:58:58,307
>> any comments on these?

6132
02:58:58,307 --> 02:58:58,673
>> for these letters?

6133
02:58:58,673 --> 02:59:00,673
Okay.

6134
02:59:01,777 --> 02:59:03,412
I did want to note there are

6135
02:59:03,412 --> 02:59:04,346
other current bills going

6136
02:59:04,346 --> 02:59:05,948
through committee, initial

6137
02:59:05,948 --> 02:59:06,415
committee in the state

6138
02:59:06,415 --> 02:59:08,415
legislature.

6139
02:59:11,553 --> 02:59:15,153
One of them is assembly bill

6140
02:59:18,194 --> 02:59:18,561
6530 -- 650 from dianne

6141
02:59:18,561 --> 02:59:19,561
papin

6142
02:59:19,561 --> 02:59:22,561
in relation to the housing

6143
02:59:22,898 --> 02:59:23,966
element, I don't know if if

6144
02:59:23,966 --> 02:59:25,834
staff is willing to share on

6145
02:59:25,834 --> 02:59:26,836
that so we can give direction

6146
02:59:26,836 --> 02:59:28,836
for support.

6147
02:59:30,272 --> 02:59:31,440
Nell, you're in the back.

6148
02:59:31,440 --> 02:59:32,307
>> MR. Mayor, are you asking

6149
02:59:32,307 --> 02:59:32,842
for support for that bill

6150
02:59:32,842 --> 02:59:33,142
right now?

6151
02:59:33,142 --> 02:59:35,142
.

6152
02:59:36,579 --> 02:59:37,513
Inger correct, yes.

6153
02:59:37,513 --> 02:59:37,913
>> christina's probably

6154
02:59:37,913 --> 02:59:39,913
better

6155
02:59:41,583 --> 02:59:42,451
suited to answer this.

6156
02:59:42,451 --> 02:59:43,180
>> I apologize, bring her

6157
02:59:43,180 --> 02:59:45,180
back.

6158
02:59:45,321 --> 02:59:46,622
>> it's a spot bill and so we

6159
02:59:46,622 --> 02:59:49,220
don't have legislate iever

6160
02:59:50,993 --> 02:59:51,427
language yet to respond to or

6161
02:59:51,427 --> 02:59:52,961
support.

6162
02:59:52,961 --> 02:59:53,996
We went in a little bit of a

6163
02:59:53,996 --> 02:59:55,264
circle here because we could

6164
02:59:55,264 --> 02:59:57,734
not find the legislation, I

6165
02:59:57,734 --> 02:59:58,934
guess this is why, when it

6166
02:59:58,934 --> 03:00:00,770
appears, we can bring it your

6167
03:00:00,770 --> 03:00:02,770
way.

6168
03:00:02,839 --> 03:00:05,808
>> yeah, so, to be able to

6169
03:00:05,808 --> 03:00:07,744
support at the level of

6170
03:00:07,744 --> 03:00:08,611
providing additional runway,

6171
03:00:08,611 --> 03:00:08,944
additional space for cities

6172
03:00:08,944 --> 03:00:10,713
to

6173
03:00:10,713 --> 03:00:12,282
be able to be compliant and

6174
03:00:12,282 --> 03:00:13,216
be

6175
03:00:13,216 --> 03:00:15,484
able to provide compliance

6176
03:00:15,484 --> 03:00:17,884
with the housing element

6177
03:00:18,870 --> 03:00:19,322
should they not be able to at

6178
03:00:19,322 --> 03:00:21,322
that level too.

6179
03:00:21,691 --> 03:00:23,326
In addition, since it is

6180
03:00:23,326 --> 03:00:24,940
agendized as a letter of

6181
03:00:24,940 --> 03:00:26,494
support, colleagues, some of

6182
03:00:27,430 --> 03:00:27,831
you might be hearing or

6183
03:00:27,831 --> 03:00:29,831
seeing

6184
03:00:30,000 --> 03:00:31,534
our second state senator

6185
03:00:31,534 --> 03:00:33,534
scott

6186
03:00:35,400 --> 03:00:35,705
wiener is supporting a

6187
03:00:35,705 --> 03:00:37,240
regional transportation

6188
03:00:37,240 --> 03:00:37,607
measure that potentially

6189
03:00:37,607 --> 03:00:38,908
could

6190
03:00:38,908 --> 03:00:41,908
support and bring in support

6191
03:00:42,145 --> 03:00:44,714
for san mateo county to

6192
03:00:44,714 --> 03:00:45,480
support caltrain as well as

6193
03:00:45,480 --> 03:00:47,480
to

6194
03:00:47,840 --> 03:00:49,840
support bart.

6195
03:00:50,420 --> 03:00:53,190
at this level, I wouldn't be

6196
03:00:53,190 --> 03:00:53,590
able to, sky, bring in

6197
03:00:53,590 --> 03:00:55,126
support

6198
03:00:55,126 --> 03:00:55,859
because one of our

6199
03:00:55,859 --> 03:00:56,193
councilmembers is connected

6200
03:00:56,193 --> 03:00:57,461
to

6201
03:00:57,461 --> 03:00:57,928
that, is that correct, if I

6202
03:00:57,928 --> 03:00:59,362
wanted to --

6203
03:00:59,362 --> 03:01:00,264
>> he would just rcuse

6204
03:01:00,264 --> 03:01:01,899
himself.

6205
03:01:01,899 --> 03:01:03,500
>> okay, well, we're looking

6206
03:01:03,500 --> 03:01:05,702
for and when I was talking to

6207
03:01:05,702 --> 03:01:07,370
the city manager, many of

6208
03:01:07,370 --> 03:01:10,370
these agencies are looking to

6209
03:01:10,107 --> 03:01:11,241
not be part of this regional

6210
03:01:11,241 --> 03:01:12,876
transportation measure and

6211
03:01:12,876 --> 03:01:13,377
only three counties instead

6212
03:01:13,377 --> 03:01:14,277
of

6213
03:01:14,277 --> 03:01:16,677
four counties, however, the

6214
03:01:18,115 --> 03:01:18,582
bill has now been designed

6215
03:01:18,582 --> 03:01:20,582
for

6216
03:01:20,984 --> 03:01:22,119
counties or cities to be able

6217
03:01:22,119 --> 03:01:24,119
to opt in.

6218
03:01:24,822 --> 03:01:26,890
If san mateo county wants to

6219
03:01:26,890 --> 03:01:26,557
opt in to b able to

6220
03:01:26,557 --> 03:01:28,557
participate.

6221
03:01:28,926 --> 03:01:29,326
I think as a city that

6222
03:01:29,326 --> 03:01:31,326
heavily

6223
03:01:31,428 --> 03:01:33,297
is supported by caltrain as

6224
03:01:33,297 --> 03:01:34,231
well as -- or has the

6225
03:01:34,231 --> 03:01:34,598
influence of caltrain and

6226
03:01:34,598 --> 03:01:36,300
bart.

6227
03:01:36,300 --> 03:01:38,336
This is important for us.

6228
03:01:38,336 --> 03:01:40,771
This is a measure that

6229
03:01:40,771 --> 03:01:43,771
potentially would be able to

6230
03:01:44,700 --> 03:01:46,760
support a path to potentially

6231
03:01:46,760 --> 03:01:47,110
relieve the debt that

6232
03:01:47,110 --> 03:01:48,846
caltrain

6233
03:01:48,846 --> 03:01:51,246
currently has and bart

6234
03:01:51,615 --> 03:01:52,350
currently has.

6235
03:01:52,350 --> 03:01:52,817
There's mixed opportunities

6236
03:01:52,817 --> 03:01:54,817
right now.

6237
03:01:55,520 --> 03:01:57,355
I think where we stand is I

6238
03:01:57,355 --> 03:01:57,688
believe samtrans board will

6239
03:01:57,688 --> 03:01:59,456
be

6240
03:01:59,456 --> 03:02:01,590
taking a position of I, a

6241
03:02:01,590 --> 03:02:03,459
position on this ballot

6242
03:02:04,328 --> 03:02:05,496
measure or potential ballot

6243
03:02:05,496 --> 03:02:07,980
measure, a senate bill right

6244
03:02:07,980 --> 03:02:09,734
now next week and I wanted to

6245
03:02:09,734 --> 03:02:11,603
see if there's interest so

6246
03:02:11,603 --> 03:02:13,137
that our city manager could

6247
03:02:13,137 --> 03:02:14,873
express not a position

6248
03:02:14,873 --> 03:02:17,873
particular but just to say,

6249
03:02:19,177 --> 03:02:22,177
hey, tink about thens --

6250
03:02:23,448 --> 03:02:24,248
city ins north county, daly

6251
03:02:24,248 --> 03:02:24,615
city, south san francisco

6252
03:02:24,615 --> 03:02:25,783
that

6253
03:02:25,783 --> 03:02:27,852
we have caltrain and bart, we

6254
03:02:27,852 --> 03:02:28,787
have to be at the table, we

6255
03:02:28,787 --> 03:02:30,454
can't completely be excluded

6256
03:02:30,454 --> 03:02:32,524
aout of a potential funding

6257
03:02:32,524 --> 03:02:34,792
mechanism that will support

6258
03:02:34,792 --> 03:02:35,860
contra costa, al la immediate

6259
03:02:35,860 --> 03:02:38,963
da and san francisco and not

6260
03:02:38,963 --> 03:02:39,931
be at the table when these

6261
03:02:39,931 --> 03:02:41,333
discussions are potentially

6262
03:02:41,333 --> 03:02:42,467
funding support would come

6263
03:02:42,467 --> 03:02:44,467
through.

6264
03:02:45,203 --> 03:02:45,870
That is potentially what this

6265
03:02:45,870 --> 03:02:47,870
regional transportation

6266
03:02:49,474 --> 03:02:49,808
measure would look like right

6267
03:02:49,808 --> 03:02:50,875
now.

6268
03:02:50,875 --> 03:02:53,275
Any questions or any

6269
03:02:53,444 --> 03:02:54,779
additions

6270
03:02:54,779 --> 03:02:57,148
from my colleagues, jump in.

6271
03:02:57,148 --> 03:02:58,917
>> so, I believe we have --

6272
03:02:58,917 --> 03:03:01,860
there's no language for ab650

6273
03:03:01,860 --> 03:03:02,554
that we should have a more in

6274
03:03:02,554 --> 03:03:04,954
depth discussion on ab650

6275
03:03:05,791 --> 03:03:07,826
because I know that it can go

6276
03:03:07,826 --> 03:03:09,270
in various directions.

6277
03:03:09,270 --> 03:03:11,330
For sb63, I think it's

6278
03:03:11,330 --> 03:03:13,232
important we continue to

6279
03:03:13,232 --> 03:03:15,632
collaborate with our regional

6280
03:03:16,502 --> 03:03:16,869
partners for some sort of

6281
03:03:16,869 --> 03:03:18,570
deal

6282
03:03:18,570 --> 03:03:18,937
that makes sense for san

6283
03:03:18,937 --> 03:03:19,872
mateo

6284
03:03:19,872 --> 03:03:20,806
county but ensures we are

6285
03:03:20,806 --> 03:03:22,806
getting funding and

6286
03:03:24,776 --> 03:03:26,378
contributing to the funding

6287
03:03:26,378 --> 03:03:29,140
that would save caltrain and

6288
03:03:29,140 --> 03:03:31,150
bart from the fiscal cliff

6289
03:03:31,150 --> 03:03:34,119
that they are facing because

6290
03:03:34,119 --> 03:03:37,119
we are potentially going to

6291
03:03:38,157 --> 03:03:41,157
see massive, massive cuts o

6292
03:03:43,762 --> 03:03:47,362
the entire system of bart and

6293
03:03:47,533 --> 03:03:49,234
I think it needs to be known

6294
03:03:49,234 --> 03:03:49,568
that 43% of transit riders

6295
03:03:49,568 --> 03:03:51,568
who

6296
03:03:51,770 --> 03:03:55,370
start in san mateo county end

6297
03:03:56,275 --> 03:03:56,675
up outside of san mateo

6298
03:03:56,675 --> 03:03:57,676
county.

6299
03:03:57,676 --> 03:03:58,844
That is a fakts.

6300
03:03:58,844 --> 03:04:00,713
We can't just have -- and I

6301
03:04:00,713 --> 03:04:04,149
know this is a great council

6302
03:04:04,149 --> 03:04:05,451
and we understand this but

6303
03:04:05,451 --> 03:04:06,486
with the county as an

6304
03:04:06,486 --> 03:04:08,886
audience, we have to

6305
03:04:09,288 --> 03:04:09,689
understand that public

6306
03:04:09,689 --> 03:04:11,570
transit

6307
03:04:11,570 --> 03:04:11,391
does not start and stop in

6308
03:04:11,391 --> 03:04:12,258
san

6309
03:04:12,258 --> 03:04:14,658
mateo, it is regional.

6310
03:04:16,495 --> 03:04:18,965
We need to be part of the

6311
03:04:18,965 --> 03:04:19,665
solution that saves public

6312
03:04:19,665 --> 03:04:20,330
transit in the region but

6313
03:04:20,330 --> 03:04:21,301
also

6314
03:04:21,301 --> 03:04:23,436
ensures that it is the most

6315
03:04:23,436 --> 03:04:25,436
seamless experience possible.

6316
03:04:27,640 --> 03:04:30,276
There are some south in the

6317
03:04:30,276 --> 03:04:31,644
county who believe that only

6318
03:04:31,644 --> 03:04:33,790
caltrain is worth saving.

6319
03:04:33,790 --> 03:04:33,513
There are twice as many

6320
03:04:33,513 --> 03:04:35,513
riders

6321
03:04:35,782 --> 03:04:37,851
on bart than there are

6322
03:04:37,851 --> 03:04:39,719
caltrain in san mateo county.

6323
03:04:39,719 --> 03:04:41,354
And there are many people who

6324
03:04:41,354 --> 03:04:41,754
take caltrain and then

6325
03:04:41,754 --> 03:04:43,223
connect

6326
03:04:43,223 --> 03:04:47,160
to bart to get to their place

6327
03:04:47,160 --> 03:04:49,963
of work or connect to other

6328
03:04:49,963 --> 03:04:52,832
areas and so we need to

6329
03:04:52,832 --> 03:04:54,701
strongly express that we want

6330
03:04:54,701 --> 03:04:55,168
to continue san mateo

6331
03:04:55,168 --> 03:04:56,570
county's

6332
03:04:56,570 --> 03:04:56,969
collaboration in this transit

6333
03:04:56,969 --> 03:04:58,969
measure.

6334
03:05:00,390 --> 03:05:01,474
I think right now we are at a

6335
03:05:01,474 --> 03:05:02,876
cross roads where we could be

6336
03:05:02,876 --> 03:05:06,476
included or we could not be

6337
03:05:07,781 --> 03:05:09,448
include -- included and the

6338
03:05:09,448 --> 03:05:11,351
recent involvement that some

6339
03:05:11,351 --> 03:05:14,540
of our county's leaders have

6340
03:05:14,540 --> 03:05:14,388
had with mtc and with bart

6341
03:05:14,388 --> 03:05:15,822
has

6342
03:05:15,822 --> 03:05:17,558
been very antagonistic that

6343
03:05:17,558 --> 03:05:19,559
has led us to where we are

6344
03:05:19,559 --> 03:05:22,229
today and it's a shame but

6345
03:05:22,229 --> 03:05:22,996
right now it is a time for

6346
03:05:22,996 --> 03:05:24,298
leadership and collaboration

6347
03:05:24,298 --> 03:05:25,466
and we have to work on a deal

6348
03:05:25,466 --> 03:05:27,334
that makes sense that ensure

6349
03:05:27,334 --> 03:05:28,935
that is our public transit

6350
03:05:28,935 --> 03:05:31,238
agencies are well funded for

6351
03:05:31,238 --> 03:05:33,107
the people of san mateo

6352
03:05:33,107 --> 03:05:35,107
county.

6353
03:05:35,175 --> 03:05:36,110
So I would support a more in

6354
03:05:36,110 --> 03:05:36,477
depth discussion on that as

6355
03:05:36,477 --> 03:05:37,478
well.

6356
03:05:37,478 --> 03:05:39,478
Thank you.

6357
03:05:39,613 --> 03:05:41,613
>> anyone else?

6358
03:05:43,350 --> 03:05:44,840
>> I couldn't say it any

6359
03:05:44,840 --> 03:05:45,886
better, councilmember coal

6360
03:05:45,886 --> 03:05:47,654
hanh and I think that is

6361
03:05:47,654 --> 03:05:48,489
classic south county versus

6362
03:05:48,489 --> 03:05:50,570
north county, not an

6363
03:05:50,570 --> 03:05:51,925
appreciation for what we're

6364
03:05:51,925 --> 03:05:52,259
all about and what we bring

6365
03:05:52,259 --> 03:05:53,327
to

6366
03:05:53,327 --> 03:05:55,327
the table.

6367
03:05:59,233 --> 03:06:00,634
>> so, I'm not impinging --

6368
03:06:00,634 --> 03:06:01,335
jumping into this

6369
03:06:01,335 --> 03:06:02,503
conversation, there was

6370
03:06:02,503 --> 03:06:03,904
another bill that I was

6371
03:06:03,904 --> 03:06:04,238
talking about and it has to

6372
03:06:04,238 --> 03:06:06,238
do

6373
03:06:07,141 --> 03:06:08,509
with public comment and it

6374
03:06:08,509 --> 03:06:10,244
would basically require that

6375
03:06:10,244 --> 03:06:10,644
for every city council

6376
03:06:10,644 --> 03:06:12,644
meeting

6377
03:06:13,814 --> 03:06:15,182
that you would have to allow

6378
03:06:15,182 --> 03:06:17,582
for online participation and

6379
03:06:17,752 --> 03:06:19,153
for that person to be allowed

6380
03:06:19,153 --> 03:06:21,153
for public comment.

6381
03:06:23,191 --> 03:06:24,359
Am I pretty much -- and we

6382
03:06:24,359 --> 03:06:26,294
experienced wat happened and

6383
03:06:26,294 --> 03:06:29,294
I had a conversation with

6384
03:06:29,998 --> 03:06:31,998
nick

6385
03:06:33,500 --> 03:06:34,669
nicolo, our lobbyist up in

6386
03:06:34,669 --> 03:06:37,690
sacramento, and he was

6387
03:06:38,873 --> 03:06:39,173
interested in what happened,

6388
03:06:39,173 --> 03:06:41,900
I

6389
03:06:41,900 --> 03:06:42,877
requested to the city manager

6390
03:06:42,877 --> 03:06:43,878
to do a letter on what

6391
03:06:43,878 --> 03:06:45,580
happened that night, there's

6392
03:06:45,580 --> 03:06:47,515
an interest in doing this, I

6393
03:06:47,515 --> 03:06:49,217
would like to see us doing

6394
03:06:49,217 --> 03:06:50,151
that moving forward, not

6395
03:06:50,151 --> 03:06:50,484
taking a position about it

6396
03:06:50,484 --> 03:06:51,319
but

6397
03:06:51,319 --> 03:06:51,820
explaining to the author,

6398
03:06:51,820 --> 03:06:53,654
this

6399
03:06:53,654 --> 03:06:54,322
is what we experienced when

6400
03:06:54,322 --> 03:06:55,957
we

6401
03:06:55,957 --> 03:06:56,724
allow for public comment

6402
03:06:56,724 --> 03:06:57,792
happening on vao

6403
03:06:57,792 --> 03:06:58,527
m where we

6404
03:06:58,527 --> 03:07:00,394
really couldn't control it.

6405
03:07:00,394 --> 03:07:02,394
>> thank you, councilmember,

6406
03:07:02,431 --> 03:07:03,198
really important point and I

6407
03:07:03,198 --> 03:07:04,332
appreciate you bringing that

6408
03:07:04,332 --> 03:07:05,934
up as well.

6409
03:07:05,934 --> 03:07:08,770
Just to separate, more just

6410
03:07:08,770 --> 03:07:10,639
tracking and monitoring on

6411
03:07:10,639 --> 03:07:11,340
ab650, I'm hearing support

6412
03:07:11,340 --> 03:07:12,274
for

6413
03:07:12,274 --> 03:07:14,674
the regional transit masure

6414
03:07:15,710 --> 03:07:16,744
on that and then sending a

6415
03:07:16,744 --> 03:07:18,280
letter to illustrate what

6416
03:07:18,280 --> 03:07:18,613
occurred here and how that

6417
03:07:18,613 --> 03:07:20,613
has

6418
03:07:20,616 --> 03:07:21,983
affected south san francisco.

6419
03:07:21,983 --> 03:07:22,917
MADAM City manager, do you

6420
03:07:22,917 --> 03:07:23,885
have enough direction?

6421
03:07:23,885 --> 03:07:26,285
>> I do, thank you.

6422
03:07:26,521 --> 03:07:27,523
>> alright, thank you.

6423
03:07:27,523 --> 03:07:28,657
Next agenda item, thank you,

6424
03:07:28,657 --> 03:07:30,292
colleagues.

6425
03:07:30,292 --> 03:07:31,727
>> moving on to closed

6426
03:07:31,727 --> 03:07:34,329
session, item number 14 is a

6427
03:07:34,329 --> 03:07:34,797
conference with legal

6428
03:07:34,797 --> 03:07:35,497
counsel,

6429
03:07:35,497 --> 03:07:36,431
anticipated litigation,

6430
03:07:36,431 --> 03:07:38,431
initiation of litigation

6431
03:07:40,568 --> 03:07:41,637
pursuant to government code

6432
03:07:41,637 --> 03:07:43,339
section 54956.9d4, one

6433
03:07:43,339 --> 03:07:45,207
potential case.

6434
03:07:45,207 --> 03:07:46,141
Item 15 is conference with

6435
03:07:46,141 --> 03:07:48,141
real property negotiators,

6436
03:07:49,845 --> 03:07:50,979
pursuant to government code

6437
03:07:50,979 --> 03:07:52,979
section 54956.8, properties,

6438
03:07:53,549 --> 03:07:56,549
parcels on sign hill, south

6439
03:08:05,694 --> 03:08:08,940
san francisco, apn numbers

6440
03:08:13,669 --> 03:08:16,690
012-351-020, 012-351-030,

6441
03:08:21,277 --> 03:08:23,677
012-024-060, 012-024-070,

6442
03:08:25,614 --> 03:08:28,140
012-04-080, 012-024-090,

6443
03:08:30,486 --> 03:08:31,187
012-024-100, 012-024-110 and

6444
03:08:31,187 --> 03:08:32,822
012-024-120.

6445
03:08:32,822 --> 03:08:33,990
agency negotiators, nell

6446
03:08:33,990 --> 03:08:35,391
selander, economic and

6447
03:08:35,391 --> 03:08:36,793
community development

6448
03:08:36,793 --> 03:08:38,228
director, greg mediati, parks

6449
03:08:38,228 --> 03:08:40,628
and recreation director and

6450
03:08:40,997 --> 03:08:42,631
sky woodruff, city attorney.

6451
03:08:42,631 --> 03:08:43,800
Negotiating parties, syme

6452
03:08:43,800 --> 03:08:45,201
venture partners lp, under

6453
03:08:45,201 --> 03:08:46,836
negotiation, price and terms.

6454
03:08:46,836 --> 03:08:47,137
>> thank you, everyone, have

6455
03:08:47,137 --> 03:08:48,471
a

6456
03:08:48,471 --> 03:08:49,105
good evening, we're adjourned

6457
03:08:49,105 --> 03:08:51,700
to closed session.

6458
03:08:51,700 --> 03:08:52,775
Thank you.

6459
03:08:52,775 --> 03:08:55,175
(Meeting adjourned to closed