[0:09] Mr Speaker you have a quot wait just a
[0:13] second Senator
[0:28] Reeves
[0:58] e e
[1:56] told
[2:09] Mr Sergeant at Arms close the doors and
[2:12] invite the members
[2:14] in the minister of the day is Dr Fred
[2:18] Shackleford he is a guest of Senator
[2:21] Rose will the members and guests please
[2:23] stand for the invocation and thereafter
[2:26] for the Pledge of Allegiance led by
[2:28] Senator Rose
[2:30] Senator Rose you're recognized to
[2:33] introduce our minister of the day and to
[2:35] lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance and
[2:37] the salute to the Tennessee
[2:40] flag Senator
[2:42] Rose thank you Mr Speaker this may be
[2:44] the most unconventional introduction
[2:47] this chamber has ever heard Dr shafford
[2:51] I do not have your bow in front of me
[2:54] so so here we
[2:58] go this gentleman is a dear friend of
[3:01] mine he serves a uh are you at uh
[3:06] Ellendale I got at endale Baptist Church
[3:09] in
[3:11] Bartlett uh he has served as president
[3:13] of the Tennessee Baptist convention I
[3:15] have no idea how many children he has or
[3:18] wife but let me just tell you he is a
[3:19] man of God he leads with
[3:21] Integrity uh and Dr sha I apologize to
[3:24] you that I don't have your bow so Mr
[3:28] Speaker that's the best do today the
[3:30] shorter the bio the more important the
[3:33] per the
[3:35] person Dr Shackleford you're recognized
[3:38] for the invocation wife Jennifer three
[3:42] boys's thank you Father God we just
[3:46] thank you for getting us up today for
[3:48] the breath that is in our lungs and the
[3:51] life that you sustain us
[3:53] with Lord we just pray your blessings on
[3:56] everyone gathered in this chamber and
[4:00] Lord certainly your wisdom for this
[4:02] assembly that's gathered on the
[4:04] floor and Lord we we pray for those
[4:07] across our state who are hurting those
[4:08] who been in the path of natural
[4:11] disasters have need Lord we pray that
[4:15] your people would step in to address
[4:17] those needs according to your will and
[4:19] according to your
[4:20] plan and father we just pray for those
[4:23] uh across our state who put themselves
[4:26] in arms way for our benefit I think
[4:29] about responders and police officers and
[4:32] many others and Lord we just pray all
[4:36] this for the glory of name state of
[4:41] Tennessee amen thank you Dr shackford
[4:45] Senator Rose i al to the flag of the
[4:50] United States of America and to the for
[4:54] it stands one
[4:57] nation indivisible with liy and justice
[5:01] for
[5:03] all white stars on the field of blue God
[5:07] keep them true it is pride love we flag
[5:13] of
[5:14] Tennessee rooll call Mr
[5:22] clerk Mr clerk take the
[5:26] rooll two members are present pursuant
[5:29] to AR arle 2 Section 11 of the
[5:31] Constitution of the state of Tennessee
[5:34] the Senate has a
[5:35] quorum and is now in
[5:43] session if if I could have your
[5:45] attention just for a moment and ask I'll
[5:49] ask you to stand in silent prayer uh Jim
[5:52] Tracy one of our former
[5:55] Senators had recent surgery and we're
[5:59] praying for quick recovery and I'll ask
[6:01] Senator Reeves to lead us in
[6:11] prayer Senator
[6:14] Rees father God uh we ask a special
[6:17] prayer on um our friend a former
[6:20] colleague in this chamber Senator Jim
[6:23] Tracy father he was my predecessor in
[6:25] this role and just love by so many
[6:27] people father I pray for his Contin
[6:29] recovery from his recent surgery father
[6:32] be with his wife Trina and their boys
[6:35] and Lord I just pray you might surround
[6:37] him with love and support uh during this
[6:39] time of recovery and that his recovery
[6:41] might be quick and complete and again
[6:43] father we lift up Jim Tracy in the Name
[6:44] of Christ
[6:46] amen thank you Senator
[6:48] Reeves Senator
[6:52] Hatcher thank you Mr Speaker when I was
[6:56] uh elected state senator I was told that
[6:59] the Senate was a family and that was
[7:01] proven this past week I want to thank
[7:04] everyone that has called and and text
[7:07] and and lifted up a prayer for me this
[7:09] past week I I thank you all very much
[7:11] for
[7:12] everything thank you Senator
[7:20] hatch and let's see you had a house
[7:23] joint
[7:25] resolution it's number 359 Senator hatch
[7:29] moves to suspend the rules it's proper
[7:32] motion is there objection it's properly
[7:35] seconded I see no objection the rules
[7:38] are suspended this was for an officer
[7:42] that was
[7:43] shot uh in Blunt
[7:46] County in Monroe County in Monroe County
[7:49] I'm sorry and uh without objection all
[7:52] members voting in the affirmative will
[7:54] be added Senator Hatcher moves
[7:57] resolutions properly seconded
[8:01] is there objection to the vote I see
[8:03] none all in favor we'll be on the board
[8:06] we'll vote I when the bell rings those
[8:09] opposed to vote no let every member cast
[8:11] their vote when the bell rings has every
[8:13] member voted Senator robberts votes I Mr
[8:17] clerk take the vote I 32 no
[8:20] n house joint resolution having received
[8:23] the house joint resolution 359 having
[8:27] received a constitutional majority I
[8:29] declare it passed without objection
[8:31] motion reconsider is hereby table
[8:35] Senator
[8:37] Campbell uh thank you Mr Speaker is it
[8:39] okay to have a statement or announcement
[8:42] or do we need to wait yeah it it'll be
[8:45] coming up just a little later oh
[8:47] wait I'll call on you then thank
[8:53] you next order Mr clerk introduction of
[8:57] bills leader Johnson you're
[9:00] recognized thank you Mr Speaker members
[9:02] good afternoon proper notice having been
[9:04] given I move that pursuant to Senate
[9:05] rule 32 in Article 2 Section 18 of the
[9:07] Constitution of the state of Tennessee
[9:09] Senate Bill 1458 be passed on first
[9:12] consideration Senate Bill
[9:17] 1458 without objection Senate Bill 1458
[9:21] passes first consideration without
[9:23] objection motion reconsider it goes to
[9:26] the table next order Mr Clerk
[9:30] house bills on first consideration
[9:32] leader Johnson you're recognized thank
[9:34] you Mr Speaker proper notice having been
[9:36] given I move the pursuant to Senate rule
[9:37] 32 and Article 2 Section 18 of the
[9:39] Constitution of the state of Tennessee
[9:41] house bills 501 1133 1143 1320 and all
[9:45] bills received today pass first
[9:46] consideration be referred to the
[9:47] appropriate standing committee
[9:48] designated or held on the clerk's desk
[9:50] without objection the house bills are
[9:52] introduced past first consideration and
[9:54] are held on the clerk's desk without
[9:57] objection motion reconsider
[9:59] by
[10:00] table next order Mr clerk Senate bills
[10:03] on second consideration leader Johnson
[10:05] you're recognized thank you Mr Speaker
[10:08] proper notice having been given I move
[10:09] the pursuant to Senate rule 33 and
[10:11] Article 2 Section 18 of the Constitution
[10:12] of the state of Tennessee Senate bills
[10:14] 1448 through 1457 pass second
[10:17] consideration be referred to the
[10:19] appropriate standing committee
[10:19] designated or held on the clerk's desk
[10:21] without objection the Senate bills pass
[10:23] second consideration are referred to the
[10:26] appropriate standing committee's
[10:28] designated or held on the clerk's desk
[10:31] without objection motion reconsider is
[10:33] hereby table next order Mr clerk
[10:36] introduction of
[10:37] resolutions leader Johnson you're
[10:39] recognized thank you Mr Speaker proper
[10:41] notice having been given I move the
[10:42] pursuant to Senate Rule 21 Senate joint
[10:44] resolutions 229 through 235 and Senate
[10:48] resolutions 54-56 be introduced passed
[10:51] on first consideration held on the
[10:52] clerk's desk without objection the
[10:54] resolutions are introduced passed on
[10:56] first consideration and are held on the
[10:59] Clerk's desk without objection motion
[11:01] reconsider is hereby table next order Mr
[11:10] clerk leader Johnson you're recognized
[11:13] thank you Mr Speaker proper notice
[11:15] having been given a move of pursuant to
[11:16] Senate Rule 21 Senate joint resolutions
[11:18] 217 through 228 Senate resolutions 46-
[11:22] 53 house joint resolution 17 319 through
[11:26] 329 and 359 lie over be referred to the
[11:29] appro standing committee designated or
[11:30] held on the clerk's desk having laid
[11:33] over the resolutions are referred to the
[11:35] appropriate standing committee's
[11:36] designated or held on the clerk's desk
[11:40] without objection the motion reconsider
[11:42] is hereby table next order Mr clerk
[11:45] unfinished business and notices Senator
[11:50] Campbell notices uh thank you Mr Speaker
[11:53] I just wanted to tell everybody that the
[11:55] coolest girls in the room are right
[11:56] above my head it's Girl Scout Troop
[11:59] number 164 from Percy Priest and they
[12:02] have uh gotten many badges this year and
[12:04] last year uh last week got their
[12:06] peaceful protest badges if you all would
[12:08] stand up and be recognized that'd be
[12:10] great we'd like to welcome you to the
[12:12] [Applause]
[12:19] Senate glad to have you with
[12:24] US senator
[12:27] Crow thank you Mr Speaker we're really
[12:29] proud today to have with us Master Ward
[12:33] Richie Jenny's son who's a page with us
[12:36] today and he's sitting back there
[12:37] dressed up and looking Dapper Ward we're
[12:39] really proud stand up we're proud to
[12:41] have you with us today welcome oh
[12:48] wow Senator pod and then I have Senator
[12:51] Lamar and then Senator Massie and then
[12:53] Senator Jackson and senator seal Senator
[12:57] pody thank you Mr speaker members I have
[13:00] a guest with me
[13:01] today yes and members let me tell you a
[13:03] little bit of History here uh this
[13:06] family can traced back to uh the late
[13:10] 1800s when their family was actually
[13:13] there was a sergeant that was a
[13:15] policeman here in this area she's been
[13:17] here five generations she she can trace
[13:19] her family back she is actually in the
[13:22] thoroughbred horse business she's right
[13:23] here in Dava County please make welcome
[13:26] chrisen
[13:27] meny glad to have you with us thank
[13:31] you Senator
[13:37] Lamar thank you Mrs speaker first I just
[13:40] want to say I'm modeling the cutest
[13:41] jacket that Senator Bailey has gotten us
[13:44] thank you so much and it's very warm in
[13:47] this moment I love it um but I wanted to
[13:50] take this moment on behalf of the the
[13:52] Senate Democrat Caucus to say a happy
[13:54] birthday to our communications director
[13:57] Mr Brandon put Brees happy birthday
[13:59] Brandon we appreciate all that you do
[14:01] for
[14:01] [Applause]
[14:05] US senator Bailey sen Bailey thank you
[14:10] very much for the jackets they're
[14:12] they're very
[14:16] timely thank you Senator
[14:20] Massie thank you Mr Speaker and I have
[14:23] two pages for the day actually we have
[14:25] four but um Senator brick chairman brick
[14:29] and Senator s are helping me host um and
[14:32] actually they're all four members of the
[14:34] junior Roc program at U Union County
[14:39] High School so they're Senator seals um
[14:42] pay um constituents but they actually
[14:45] helped me in my reelection campaign
[14:47] going door knocking so first I'm going
[14:50] to introduce two of them and then the
[14:51] other two will introduce theirs but I
[14:54] have Kaylee beer here and she is uh a
[14:58] junior at Union County High School she
[15:02] uh has one sibling she likes math
[15:04] history and she likes to fish hunt do
[15:07] play basketball run and work out and
[15:09] then also participate in the Junior ROTC
[15:12] program a number of us we helped sponsor
[15:15] the stair climb uh the that curates 911
[15:20] and we helped sponsor um we made sure
[15:23] Union County was sponsored but all the
[15:25] area schools in the Knoxville area are
[15:27] sponsored and I know the lieutenant
[15:29] Governor helps helps with that and
[15:30] several others have but um so this is
[15:33] Kayla if you'll make me help her feel
[15:39] welcome glad to have you with us Kaye I
[15:42] know so then I have on my left uh I have
[15:46] Zach Wagner he is a twin you may notice
[15:49] when you when you do and he is a
[15:52] sophomore uh at Union County High School
[15:55] he is uh he has one brother who's with
[15:58] us and a sister um and um his favorite
[16:03] subjects are the njrc and math and he
[16:07] likes Sports piano skating and door
[16:09] knocking for Senator Massie no no that
[16:12] was that wasn't on there um and uh and
[16:16] then before they introduce us to I have
[16:18] their escorts down here for the day I
[16:21] have Kathy R and Leslie Leslie Grossman
[16:24] over here and Kathy is my campaign
[16:27] manager and helps me a lot and Leslie
[16:29] and I've been we've been friends for
[16:31] many many moons so if you'll help me
[16:34] make the two of them and Zach feel
[16:36] welcome that be Zach glad to have you
[16:38] with
[16:41] us and let me go to Senator Briggs and
[16:45] then I'll come back to you
[16:47] and Senator chairman Briggs you
[16:51] recognize yeah thank you very much Mr
[16:53] Speaker I have Miguel Wagner who's the
[16:55] other half of the twin team and uh he's
[16:59] also from Union County and uh was lent
[17:02] to us today by senator seal because uh
[17:04] they live in Senator Seal's District uh
[17:07] he's at Union County High School in the
[17:09] 10th grade uh his brother Zach who we
[17:11] just met and also has a sister Erica he
[17:14] also uh likes and does very well in math
[17:18] and his favorite things and activities
[17:19] are track soccer and
[17:22] guitar Miguel good to have you with us
[17:25] let's give him a hand
[17:30] senator seal thank you Mr Speaker before
[17:32] I introduce my page I'd like to draw the
[17:35] members attention to the gallery I have
[17:37] a couple of district attorney generals
[17:39] here Jared effer and Jimmy Dunn I
[17:41] believe they're above me here if they
[17:43] just stand and let us make feel
[17:45] welcome glad to have you with
[17:48] us and I and Mr Speaker I also have some
[17:51] constituents from Jefferson County
[17:53] Carson Newman College if they just stand
[17:55] over here and let's make them feel
[17:57] welcome as well
[18:01] it's a great school glad to have you
[18:03] with us Mr Speaker my page of the day is
[18:06] Mr Blake Copic he is a resident of Union
[18:09] County and attends Union County High
[18:11] School where he's a senior he is the son
[18:13] of Chris and Hanley Copic he has three
[18:16] siblings Taylor Trevor and Carter his
[18:19] favorite favorite subject is English and
[18:22] he loves being on the lake in the
[18:24] summertime and he believes he has the
[18:26] best senator in this chamber
[18:30] would you agree with
[18:31] that say
[18:35] yes I believe I believe you took the
[18:39] fifth thank you senator
[18:42] seal Senator
[18:45] Jackson thank you Mr Speaker and I
[18:46] appreciate it uh I too wanted to uh
[18:49] remember that uh recognize our district
[18:51] attorney generals there's several of
[18:53] them here today some from my district
[18:55] and I think other districts if y'all
[18:56] would stand and we would like to welcome
[18:57] you here today da if you please would
[19:00] stand thank
[19:09] you glad to have you all with us thank
[19:11] you Senator Jackson Senator Crow did you
[19:16] have Senator
[19:18] Bing thank thank you Mr Speaker in the
[19:21] gallery and I can't see them but decab
[19:23] County leadership is here Suzanne
[19:25] Williams with the chamber is with him if
[19:28] y'all would please stand and we would
[19:30] make them welcome thank you glad to have
[19:33] youall with
[19:37] US senator
[19:39] harbarger thank you Mr Speaker uh as one
[19:42] of the youngest members in this chamber
[19:45] I thought it only appropriate that I
[19:47] bring everyone's attention to the
[19:49] gallery to recognize AARP Tennessee for
[19:52] their commitment to enhancing the
[19:54] quality of life for tennesseans age 50
[19:57] and older so when in out get with these
[20:00] ladies I want to invite my colleagues to
[20:02] join me in welcoming uh state director
[20:04] Mia mcneel and Mya McRee and AARP
[20:08] volunteers from across Tennessee thank
[20:10] you
[20:12] AARP thank
[20:17] you thank you Senator AR
[20:22] barer next order Mr clerk Mr Speaker to
[20:26] S count as consent count memorialized in
[20:29] resolutions Senator
[20:32] Powers you're recognized thank you Mr
[20:36] Speaker Mr Speaker spread upon the
[20:38] member's desk is a consent calendar of
[20:41] memorializing and congratulating
[20:43] resolutions if there are no changes or
[20:46] objections I move adoption any changes
[20:52] objections I see none the consent
[20:55] calendar having been properly moved un
[20:57] seconded all those in favor the consent
[20:59] calendar vote I when the bell rings
[21:02] those opposed will vote no let every
[21:04] member cast their vote when the bell
[21:05] rings low Senator low votes I Mr clerk
[21:10] take the vote eyes 32 no n the consent
[21:14] calender having received a
[21:15] constitutional majority I declare it
[21:17] passed without objection motion
[21:19] reconsider is hereby table next order Mr
[21:23] clerk we have consent counter number two
[21:24] of General bills and Sub of resolutions
[21:28] chairman Powers you're recognized thanks
[21:31] again Mr Speaker also spread upon the
[21:34] member's desk is consent calendar number
[21:36] two of General bills at the request of a
[21:40] member Senate Bill 281 is bumped and
[21:43] re-referred to calendar if there are no
[21:46] other changes or objections I move
[21:49] adoption any changes
[21:52] objections consent calendar number two
[21:55] haven't been properly moved and seconded
[21:58] all those favoring the consent calendar
[22:00] vote I when the bell rings those opposed
[22:02] to vote no let every member cast their
[22:03] vote when the bell rings as every member
[22:06] voted does any member wish to change
[22:07] their vote Mr clerk take the vote eyes
[22:11] 32 no Nate consent calendar number two
[22:14] having received a constitutional
[22:16] majority I declare passed without
[22:18] objection motion reconsider is hereby
[22:21] table representative
[22:25] berid glad to is dead at his desk his
[22:29] old desk glad to have you with
[22:33] us you want to come up here and pass a
[22:36] few bills pass the offering plate
[22:40] maybe thank you Mr Speaker it's good to
[22:42] be home it's good to be back where
[22:44] government actually works for the people
[22:46] and uh I just want to thank you for
[22:48] being a a great friend to me when my mom
[22:50] and daddy were still on this Earth You
[22:52] would always get up and give your seat
[22:53] up to my mama and somebody let Daddy sit
[22:56] here beside me and there you're the
[22:57] first person to call me when daddy left
[22:59] this Earth so thank you brother I
[23:01] appreciate you and it is very good to be
[23:03] home and I just want to tell y'all we're
[23:05] decentralizing government you're going
[23:06] to get a lot more of it and get
[23:10] ready good to have you with
[23:15] US senator Crow Miss biger I would just
[23:18] reminisce a little bit uh in the old
[23:20] days come on up here any the old days
[23:23] bring your drink with you too Senator
[23:25] Crow I'm just reminiscing that yeah in
[23:29] the in the old days when when Tim was
[23:31] here and his daddy used to come on the
[23:33] floor we all would uh be in awe of his
[23:37] service to our country he was one of
[23:39] those that cared more about our Liberty
[23:40] and freedom than he did his own life and
[23:42] we used to say that about him he was a
[23:44] tunnel rat Tim's daddy was a tunnel rat
[23:46] on okanawa he used to go in those
[23:49] tunnels with nothing but a
[23:52] 45 and risk all those booby traps and
[23:55] things like that I spent years on
[23:56] okanawa myself and not not in World War
[23:59] II but but uh to to to to PR to practice
[24:03] before to practice before going over to
[24:05] the Vietnam War but we were proud of him
[24:08] and every time he was on the floor we
[24:09] made that clear thank thank you for his
[24:12] service say next order Mr cler next
[24:16] order Mr clerk Mr Speaker to senat on
[24:18] regular counter item number one Senate
[24:20] joint resolution 25 by Senator Johnson
[24:22] on third and final consideration Mr
[24:24] Speaker the resolution was read for the
[24:25] third time on March 13th 2025 is up
[24:28] final vote
[24:30] tonight leer Johnson you're recognized
[24:33] thank you uh Mr Speaker members we had
[24:35] the third and final reading of Senate
[24:37] joint resolution 25 on Thursday I
[24:41] deferred it to today for a vote and I'm
[24:43] grateful for the body's uh consideration
[24:45] I'd like to list a few things for for
[24:47] your consideration I'm going to ask you
[24:49] what these have in common second deegree
[24:51] murder an act of terrorism grave torture
[24:55] aggravated rape of a child aggravated
[24:58] statutory
[24:59] rape fac facilitation of rape of a child
[25:03] rape aggravated sexual battery
[25:06] continuous sexual abuse of a child these
[25:09] are just a few things that have
[25:10] something in common what these things
[25:13] have in common is the fact that a judge
[25:15] is prohibited from denying bail to
[25:18] someone who is charged with one of these
[25:21] heinous offenses and that requirement
[25:23] doesn't come from statute it comes
[25:25] ladies and gentlemen from our
[25:27] constitution you see the Tennessee
[25:29] Constitution mandates that all
[25:30] defendants except those charged with
[25:33] capital defenses must be granted bail
[25:35] regardless of their danger to the
[25:37] community this constitutional provision
[25:39] prevents judges from detaining even the
[25:41] most violent offenders allowing them to
[25:43] reenter society and commit additional
[25:46] crimes while awaiting trial Senate joint
[25:49] resolution 25 proposes to correct this
[25:52] dangerous Gap by allowing judges to deny
[25:55] bail for a narrowly defined set of
[25:58] severe offenses including terrorism
[26:01] second-degree murder aggravated rape
[26:03] grave torture this proposed amendment
[26:05] would ensure that only defendants For
[26:07] Whom the proof of guilt is evident and
[26:09] the presumption great can be held
[26:12] without bail pres which would prevent
[26:14] misuse of judicial discretion currently
[26:17] dangerous criminals with Financial
[26:19] Resources can buy their way out of jail
[26:21] while Indigent defendants accused of
[26:23] lesser crimes remain detained simply
[26:26] because they cannot afford bail
[26:28] preventative detention has been upheld
[26:30] by the United States Supreme Court in US
[26:33] versus solo 1987 as a constitutional and
[26:37] necessary tool for protecting the public
[26:39] the federal bail Reform Act of 1984
[26:42] which denies bail to highrisk defendants
[26:45] in certain cases has been used
[26:46] successfully for decades without
[26:49] constitutional challenges at least 23
[26:52] other states have modernized their
[26:53] constitutions to permit permit
[26:56] preventative detention for serious or
[26:59] repeat violent offenses bringing their
[27:01] laws in line with modern Public Safety
[27:04] needs Tennessee remains one of only 18
[27:07] states that still adhere to an outdated
[27:09] capital offenses only standard which
[27:12] makes it an outlier in addressing
[27:14] pre-trial Public Safety risks in
[27:17] numerous tragic incidences cases across
[27:19] Tennessee violent offenders released on
[27:22] bail have committed additional crimes
[27:24] including murder domestic violence and
[27:27] sexual assault a bureau of Justice
[27:29] statistics study found that 12% of
[27:31] convicted violent felons in major uh
[27:35] major urban areas were out on pre-trial
[27:37] release when they committed their
[27:39] additional
[27:41] crimes Senate joint resolution 25 would
[27:44] allow judges permissively to use their
[27:47] discretion to deny bail only in cases
[27:50] where they determine a defendant poses a
[27:52] significant
[27:53] risk of future harm ensuring that all
[27:56] other cases remain eligible for
[27:59] Prevail fears of mass incarceration are
[28:02] some of the arguments I've heard against
[28:03] this amendment are unfounded this
[28:05] amendment is designed to impact only the
[28:07] most serious offenders who pose an
[28:09] immediate threat to Public Safety the
[28:12] Tennessee District Attorney's Conference
[28:13] has called this the most the single most
[28:16] important Public Safety measure in years
[28:18] here in the state of
[28:20] Tennessee I want to be clear members
[28:22] Senate joint resolution 25 does not
[28:25] eliminate bail even for those most
[28:27] heinous cases it gives our judges the
[28:29] discretion to deny bail when they deem
[28:32] it in the interest of Public Safety when
[28:35] there is someone who is before them
[28:36] charged with a serious crime or crimes
[28:39] and potentially has a violent criminal
[28:41] history it allows the judges to have the
[28:44] discretion to detain those people
[28:47] pre-trial this amendment will make
[28:49] Tennessee's Criminal Justice System more
[28:50] fair more modern and most importantly it
[28:53] will make our communities safer by
[28:55] keeping these violent people off our
[28:57] streets while they await trial uh Mr
[29:00] speaker thank you appreciate the body's
[29:02] Indulgence that was a bit of a lengthy
[29:04] explanation but this is an extremely
[29:05] important matter I move adoption of
[29:08] Senate joint resolution 25 on third or
[29:11] final consideration the motion is for
[29:13] adoption on third and final
[29:14] consideration of Senate joint resolution
[29:17] 25
[29:22] discussion Senator Crow and then Senator
[29:26] bowling
[29:29] Mr Speaker this this is one of those
[29:31] bills one of those
[29:32] resolutions that our Das want some of my
[29:37] judges don't my Bales bondman don't like
[29:40] it there's much of it I like some of it
[29:42] I don't like but the more I've thought
[29:45] about it and The more I've studied it
[29:48] and talked with both sides the more I
[29:51] realize that kind of like the uh Lottery
[29:55] Bill we had years ago I was number 17 on
[29:58] on that and I didn't want a
[29:59] lottery but I wanted my people to have
[30:01] the right to vote on this I didn't want
[30:03] to take that away and so I guess in the
[30:07] interest of uh being honest to everyone
[30:11] uh for those that
[30:13] I was was talking with when I opposed
[30:16] this pill this
[30:17] resolution uh and however now support it
[30:21] how I I would apologize to those that uh
[30:24] that I had told that I was not
[30:26] supportive of it however I think in the
[30:30] interest of of of my constituents I'm
[30:33] going to vote for this so they can have
[30:34] that opportunity that privilege to say
[30:36] yes or no themselves just like we did on
[30:38] the lottery and uh that's where I am
[30:43] thank you Senator Crow Senator
[30:46] bowling thank you Mr Speaker um I'm
[30:50] rising as someone who had opposed this
[30:53] and I have told many people that I
[30:54] opposed this and uh I have found out
[30:58] some information I did not consider and
[31:01] had not known prior to now and what I
[31:05] have found out is that it is judicial
[31:07] discretion it is not a guarantee that
[31:09] they will withhold the bail this would
[31:11] be a heinous crime this would be uh
[31:14] something to a child torturing a child
[31:16] these are these are people that should
[31:18] not be and if there has to be a
[31:20] preponderance of evidence and there has
[31:22] to be uh other factors that would allow
[31:26] them to not give of bail but also one of
[31:30] the things that I have considered
[31:32] because there are so many facts pro and
[31:35] con in this I think this is one of the
[31:38] things that needs to go before the
[31:39] people of the state of Tennessee which
[31:41] our yes vote will allow for the people
[31:44] of Tennessee at the next goral election
[31:47] this would be on the ballot for them to
[31:49] make the
[31:50] determination thank you Senator bowling
[31:53] further
[31:55] discussion I see none
[31:59] I'm sorry Senator
[32:02] Gardenhire thank you Mr Speaker with a
[32:04] sponsor yield sponsor
[32:07] Yi I have absolutely no arguments with
[32:11] the premise of this
[32:14] resolution I have no
[32:17] problem with locking these people up and
[32:20] throwing away the key on the on the
[32:23] issues that you brought up
[32:29] when I ran in
[32:31] 2012 the major theme of my campaign was
[32:34] the unintended
[32:37] consequences and I've tried to maintain
[32:39] that stance all these 12 or 13
[32:45] years last
[32:47] August this
[32:50] body gave roughly $130 million give or
[32:54] take
[32:55] five to mental health professionals
[32:59] in our special session because we felt
[33:01] like we had to do something I didn't
[33:03] vote for
[33:06] it as far as I know it did no
[33:09] good we still had another school
[33:11] shooting after we magnanimously gave the
[33:15] money
[33:16] away we took $30 million from a trust
[33:19] fund that Senator Watson had set up a
[33:20] couple years ago to help build a
[33:23] prison in the
[33:26] state to help fund that $130 million
[33:29] plus or
[33:31] minus to build a new prison it's roughly
[33:34] about 450 to $500
[33:39] million I've heard absolutely nothing
[33:43] from
[33:44] anybody on how we're going to pay for
[33:49] this when it hits the
[33:51] fan nothing
[33:55] crickets today in judiciary we had a
[33:58] senator offer a bill to build a juvenile
[34:03] prison $238
[34:06] million in West
[34:09] Tennessee we had an offic of the Court
[34:11] when they did their budget came to us
[34:14] and I asked him specifically I said how
[34:16] many new prisoners do you think this
[34:21] will be put in our jails and they said
[34:25] probably no new prisoners
[34:28] let me repeat that no new
[34:32] prisoners but there always a
[34:36] butt sometimes I'm the butt but in this
[34:39] case it was a butt they'll just stay
[34:44] longer and we'll have to pay for it
[34:47] Corrections came to
[34:51] us and I asked them I said what's your
[34:54] vacancy that you have in your prison oh
[34:57] we've got 20% vacancies
[35:01] 20 and I said why that's not what I'm
[35:05] hearing well
[35:08] uh we can't hire correction
[35:12] officers we can't pay them
[35:15] enough it's a tough job and they don't
[35:18] stay long and so that's why we've got
[35:21] 20% vacancies
[35:32] the
[35:37] Das I've had my
[35:40] Das outline why they're not for
[35:44] it Marin
[35:47] County C bowling just issued $6 Million
[35:50] worth of
[35:52] bonds to expand their
[35:55] jails why there's a
[35:59] trend in this
[36:01] state of an increase in a certain type
[36:05] of
[36:06] prisoners
[36:10] females and it's
[36:12] expensive to rebuild and retool a a jail
[36:16] to take care of that
[36:21] population and if we're going to pass
[36:24] something like this again let me be
[36:26] perfectly
[36:28] clear I don't argue with the intent of
[36:31] what we're trying to
[36:33] do but when we had the first
[36:35] reading and we had a second
[36:40] reading and when we had it
[36:43] committee I called on the
[36:46] administration to come forward with some
[36:48] ideas on how they're going to pay for
[36:50] this
[36:51] thing when it comes du and if it passes
[36:55] in the next Governor's election
[36:59] nobody in this body has talked about how
[37:02] we're going to pay for this thing when
[37:03] we put these people which deserve it in
[37:06] jail for a long time that's the
[37:09] unintended
[37:11] consequence of a good
[37:14] idea and until somebody shows me how
[37:17] they're going to set aside the
[37:19] money to take care of these things that
[37:23] I'm not going to support it I'm not
[37:25] going to be
[37:26] there when all of a sudden our local
[37:29] County commissions and City
[37:32] commissions and
[37:33] sheriffs start saying hey Senator we
[37:37] need more money for jail well we don't
[37:39] have it because we're taking care of
[37:40] something
[37:41] else so I ask all of y'all to think long
[37:44] and hard about the unintended
[37:48] consequence of this legislation and this
[37:51] resolution thank you Mr speaker thank
[37:53] you Senator
[37:55] gire Senator yarboro
[38:00] uh thank you Mr
[38:02] Speaker and I I share the our colleagues
[38:06] from Hamilton's concerns about the the
[38:09] Practical consequences of
[38:11] this I I think that it is it is it is
[38:15] fool hearty to think that you can
[38:18] do this significant of a
[38:21] change in the way that every courthouse
[38:25] in the state works and every jail in the
[38:28] state works and that there's not going
[38:30] to be actual
[38:33] consequences uh we know that this is I
[38:36] mean most likely going to lead to the
[38:39] exact problem that our colleague from
[38:41] Hamilton just raised in terms of
[38:42] additional cost that we're not actually
[38:45] raising to the voters here even if it
[38:49] you know in addition to the jail aspect
[38:51] to do this sort of
[38:55] process the way that this is a allowed
[38:57] under federal law to do more to have
[39:00] more offenses they require right to
[39:03] councils and
[39:06] cross-examinations and lengthier
[39:09] processes than what we typically do in
[39:12] Tennessee on pre-trial so he going to
[39:14] significantly unless we are going to be
[39:17] willing to spend a lot more on District
[39:20] Attorneys on public
[39:23] defenders on local Criminal Courts on
[39:27] County jails and sheriffs like we
[39:29] shouldn't be pushing this
[39:32] forward just
[39:35] period but I think the more important
[39:38] reason is that there's just some Powers
[39:40] the government shouldn't
[39:42] have
[39:44] and like when we come in this room and
[39:47] take that oath we take an oath not to
[39:49] abridge the rights of people and this
[39:52] limits the rights of people right now as
[39:55] it has been since this state was
[39:58] founded Constitution says that
[40:02] everybody has this right and we are
[40:05] taking that right
[40:07] away uh that was in our original 1796
[40:12] Constitution the exact same language is
[40:14] adopted in the 1834 Constitution adopted
[40:18] again in the 1870
[40:20] Constitution throughout all the
[40:22] amendments in the 20th century no no no
[40:24] changes were
[40:25] made and actually goes back even further
[40:28] than this like the right to bail goes
[40:30] back to the Magna
[40:32] Carta but this particular version should
[40:36] be should mean something to us like the
[40:38] exact language that we use comes from
[40:41] North Carolina and from
[40:42] Pennsylvania and actually it comes
[40:46] from people who came to the United
[40:49] States who were themselves subject to
[40:52] religious persecution and were held
[40:54] improperly by the by the crown
[40:58] held in prison because of their
[40:59] religious beliefs and it was fundamental
[41:02] to what they thought government could
[41:05] and couldn't do to say
[41:08] that the say
[41:11] so of like a couple of government of of
[41:14] a judge and a prosecutor isn't enough
[41:16] for someone to give up their
[41:19] Liberty they required something more
[41:21] than that they required that there be
[41:24] some sort of process where a jury your
[41:27] peers found that there was evidence to
[41:30] against you before the government could
[41:32] could take you away from your family and
[41:35] from your freedom and I don't think we
[41:37] should be moving in the opposite
[41:38] direction than that it's just that
[41:41] simple and I I don't think that this is
[41:44] this is not there have been states that
[41:46] have made adjustments to this
[41:48] constitutional provision but I don't
[41:50] think there's any that have gone as
[41:52] broadly as this I mean this is not a
[41:55] narrow change this adds
[41:59] 73 or so offenses to a list and it
[42:03] doesn't say that bail may be denied it
[42:05] says like there's no right to bail in
[42:08] those consequences in those
[42:09] circumstances no
[42:12] right
[42:14] and I think we should think long and
[42:17] hard before we push forward
[42:20] on curtailing the rights of the people
[42:23] that we represent thank you Mr speaker
[42:25] thank you senator ybur I have Senator
[42:28] Campbell and Senator Lamar Senator
[42:31] Campbell uh thank you Mr Speaker will
[42:33] the sponsor yield sponsor yields uh to
[42:36] the sponsor how how is Terrorism defined
[42:40] in this
[42:42] bill Senator Johnson leader Johnson to
[42:46] respond thank you Mr Speaker this is not
[42:48] a bill this is a resolution proposing to
[42:51] amend the Tennessee Constitution uh
[42:53] terrorism is defined in statute it's in
[42:56] the Green books back I'll be happy to
[42:57] get one of the books and find it for you
[42:59] but it it's it's not defined in the
[43:03] bill sen lore Senator Campbell excuse me
[43:07] thank you Mr Speaker thanks you're right
[43:08] of course it's a it's a resolution um
[43:11] well I I think the ambiguous nature of
[43:14] the definition of terrorism which is the
[43:16] unlawful use of force or violence
[43:18] against persons or property to
[43:20] Intimidator cor government is
[43:23] problematic in this instance along with
[43:26] the 7 three um offenses that fall under
[43:30] the egis of the
[43:31] 85%
[43:33] definition
[43:34] so I guess I would just say that along
[43:37] with um prior um colleagues of mine I
[43:41] agree that this undermines the
[43:43] fundamental tenants of jurist prudence
[43:45] in American government which is that you
[43:47] have a right to bail you have a right to
[43:49] Fair trial and and I think this is a
[43:52] slippery slope and um and I also do
[43:55] worry greatly that this is going to
[43:57] um hamper us financially because we
[44:00] already have a problem um with avoing uh
[44:04] maintaining our carceral state so um so
[44:08] I will be voting against this Bill thank
[44:09] you Mr speaker thank you Senator
[44:11] Campbell Senator
[44:15] Lamar thank you Mr
[44:17] Speaker I would just like to raise a
[44:19] couple of points Mr Speaker that are
[44:21] raised in committee about the bill of
[44:23] why I think this is a dangerous
[44:25] precedence that we're setting with this
[44:27] particular piece of legislation I think
[44:29] all of us as members of the Tennessee
[44:31] general assembly and the Senate agree
[44:34] that we want all of our communities be
[44:35] safe we agree with Public Safety and we
[44:37] agree with accountability and all of us
[44:40] have efforts in order to approve the
[44:42] Justice systems where we're holding bad
[44:43] folks accountable but also making sure
[44:46] we create a Tennesse for those who make
[44:47] mistakes and get the opportunity to
[44:49] correct themselves now the ability to
[44:51] access bail is one of the fundamental
[44:53] rights that we give citizens in this
[44:55] state because of the understanding you
[44:57] are innocent until proven guilty now
[45:00] essentially what this particular
[45:02] Constitution this resolution does if
[45:04] passed on the ballot is holding people
[45:07] in jail for 73 crimes before they're
[45:12] actually proven to be guilty now as
[45:15] stated in Senate Judiciary Committee Mr
[45:18] Speaker it was said that there is not
[45:21] one state in the country that has a
[45:23] blanket Constitutional Amendment like
[45:25] this did not that gives judges the
[45:27] ability to not bail for 73 crimes we
[45:30] will be the
[45:32] first so we have no
[45:35] idea the implications this will cause
[45:38] because no other state has a
[45:40] constitutional amendment to do this for
[45:42] 73
[45:43] crimes secondly this per this will
[45:47] inhibit someone who may be
[45:49] innocent from being a for being able to
[45:53] continue their lives so Mr Speaker if
[45:55] you have an individual who is being
[45:57] charged with one of the 73 crimes in a
[46:00] particular piece of legislation and that
[46:02] judge denies
[46:04] bail they could lose their business
[46:07] their home their family and there's no
[46:10] restitution for them if they hold were
[46:12] being held and end up being found not
[46:17] guilty what this bill also doesn't
[46:20] really talk about the increase in
[46:22] property tax that individuals will
[46:25] experience because of the incre increase
[46:27] in jail prop uh jail population we were
[46:30] in fact increased property taxes now if
[46:32] you lived in Shelby County we're already
[46:34] debating an increase in tax in order to
[46:37] fund the rebuilding of our jail because
[46:39] it's overcrowded it's outdated and we
[46:42] cannot already house the people that we
[46:45] have in there so what we see what's
[46:48] happening in New Jersey which doesn't
[46:50] have this Constitutional Amendment but
[46:51] does have some sort of
[46:53] law with the same level of synergy they
[46:57] have increased property taxes and it's
[46:59] still not enough to fund the increase in
[47:01] prisoners that we see in jail based on
[47:05] that piece of legislation where it's now
[47:07] having unintended
[47:09] consequences I also think that people in
[47:12] the public when they read this
[47:14] legislation on the ballot first and
[47:16] foremost I don't think the fiscal note
[47:18] doesn't reflect the actual cost that
[47:21] this will experience for taxpayers
[47:24] because it's not talking about the
[47:26] increase in jail
[47:28] funding but secondly Mr Speaker when
[47:31] it's on the ballot it's not going to
[47:33] actually list all the crimes that are
[47:36] being considered in this legislation it
[47:39] reads the one through six and then line
[47:42] number seven talks about all the 60 plus
[47:47] crimes under truth and sentencing so for
[47:51] voters they're going to be reading this
[47:54] resolution on a ballot thinking it's
[47:56] only focusing on those six crimes that
[47:59] are listed explicitly they are going to
[48:02] be unaware of all the other crimes under
[48:04] truth and sentencing which means they
[48:07] cannot actually place a correct vote
[48:10] because it will not list all the crimes
[48:13] that this bill is going to
[48:16] cover SEC uh in addition judges can
[48:20] already set a bill so high for those
[48:23] violent offenders that they cannot get
[48:25] out
[48:27] in addition to that you have an inequity
[48:31] on discretion by the judges based on
[48:34] where you live so if we're thinking
[48:36] about all 73 of these crimes and Shelby
[48:41] there may be a judge that denies bail
[48:43] for this crime but if you go to [ __ ]
[48:45] County this judge won't or if you go to
[48:47] suar County this judge can or if you go
[48:51] to Knox County this judge can't so
[48:56] you're only going to be denied bail
[48:58] based on what county you're in and how
[49:01] they see fit based on this crime versus
[49:04] our current system now allows judges to
[49:08] set a high enough bail for their most
[49:10] serious crimes so it creates an inequity
[49:13] in our justice system again there is not
[49:17] one state in this country that has this
[49:21] not one we are going to be forced to put
[49:24] millions of dollars into building new
[49:30] jails we're supposed to be a state that
[49:32] holds people accountable but not [ __ ]
[49:35] taxpayers with constantly using our
[49:37] money to build more
[49:39] prisons so while I understand we all
[49:42] care about Public Safety trust me I care
[49:45] just like many of all of you but denying
[49:48] bail for 73 crimes and not giving voters
[49:51] the truth behind what all the crimes are
[49:55] to me is a disservice to the voters who
[49:58] will be voting on this piece of
[49:59] legislation it's a disservice to the
[50:02] voters because it's not telling them the
[50:04] accurate costs and the consequences and
[50:08] once you do this and you see that it's
[50:11] not going to
[50:12] work it's going to take a lot to undo
[50:15] the mistakes that we could potentially
[50:17] be making with this piece of legislation
[50:19] I appreciate my colleagues listening
[50:21] thank you Mr speaker thank you chairman
[50:24] Lamar further discussion
[50:27] is there objection to the
[50:29] question I see none without
[50:32] objection I'll ask Senator John Johnson
[50:35] to close leader Johnson to close excuse
[50:38] me thank you Mr Speaker and thank you
[50:40] members for the uh for the for the
[50:42] discussion couple of final points here I
[50:45] I I respect and appreciate the
[50:47] conversation and several members brought
[50:48] up the the the issue of
[50:51] cost members our number one job up here
[50:54] is Public Safety it is Public Safety and
[50:58] it is to equip our court systems with
[51:00] the tools they need to keep our communi
[51:02] safe and unfortunately they don't have
[51:04] those tools right now or all that they
[51:07] need they're hamstrung by the
[51:09] Constitution when the Constitution was
[51:12] first ratified in
[51:14] 1796 it did have this language but you
[51:17] know what stealing a horse was a capital
[51:20] offense there were other capital
[51:22] offenses that were recognized as capital
[51:24] offenses but today
[51:27] because the Supreme Court has ruled that
[51:29] the only capital offense is first-degree
[51:31] murder because of the language in our
[51:33] constitution our judges hands are tied
[51:36] and they can't deny bail to those most
[51:39] violent of
[51:41] criminals now if you look at the data
[51:43] and I have and people a lot smarter than
[51:46] me have studied this issue and I'm sure
[51:48] many of you have seen some of the data
[51:50] as well actually don't
[51:53] anticipate thankfully that many more
[51:55] people to be incarcerated pre-trial
[51:58] because of denial of bail thankfully
[52:01] there aren't that many crimes they do
[52:03] happen but this is not going to lead
[52:05] lead to a massive overrun of our jails
[52:08] who runs our jails in the state of
[52:10] Tennessee judges no our Sheriff's do
[52:14] guess who endorses this amendment guess
[52:17] who endorses in addition to our district
[52:19] attorneys the sheriff's
[52:21] Association they believe the juice is
[52:23] worth a squeeze if it means they have to
[52:25] put a few more people in their jails to
[52:27] keep them from reoffending and harming
[52:29] our fellow citizens they think it's
[52:31] worth it but I will say I'm part of the
[52:34] budget discussions up here every year if
[52:37] we end up having to appropriate some
[52:38] more money then let's do it we will but
[52:41] let's satisfy that number one
[52:43] responsibility we have as members of
[52:45] this general assembly and that is to
[52:47] keep our communi safe and to empower our
[52:49] partners and law enforcement the
[52:51] district attorneys and our judicial
[52:53] system with the tools that they need
[52:55] right now their hands are tied
[52:58] another point that was made which I
[53:00] think is fairly insulting to the people
[53:02] of Tennessee is that they won't
[53:04] understand this amendment I believe they
[53:06] will I believe that the people of
[53:08] Tennessee are smart enough to read this
[53:11] amendment and understand it read the
[53:12] language understand what it means and I
[53:15] believe when they do fully understand it
[53:17] they will overwhelmingly ratify this
[53:19] amendment and that's how our process
[53:21] works members I'm asking you to vote for
[53:24] this resolution we're not going to amend
[53:25] our constit ution today you know what
[53:27] we're going to do we're going to let our
[53:29] constituents the people of Tennessee
[53:31] decide if they want our judges to be
[53:33] empowered to keep these most violent of
[53:35] violent people off the streets when
[53:37] they're convicted or rather when they're
[53:39] charged with a crime pre-trial that's
[53:41] it's that simple that's what Senate
[53:43] joint resolution 25 does I'd be grateful
[53:45] for a favorable consideration Mr Speaker
[53:48] renew my
[53:49] motion Senator Johnson renews his motion
[53:52] for passage on Senate joint resolution
[53:54] 25 all those favoring it will vote I
[53:58] those opposed will vote no let every
[54:00] member cast their vote when the bell
[54:03] rings has every member
[54:07] voted does any member wish to change
[54:09] their vote Mr clerk take the vote eyes
[54:13] 23
[54:15] n6 Senate joint resolution 25 having
[54:19] received a constitutional majority I
[54:21] declare it passed without objection
[54:23] motion reconsider is hereby table
[54:29] next bill Mr clerk item two sen Bill 191
[54:32] by Senator Taylor on third and final
[54:34] consideration Senator Taylor you
[54:36] recognized on Senate Bill
[54:39] 191 thank you Mr speaker now that we've
[54:41] got that out of the way um I would move
[54:45] consideration of Senate Bill 191 for
[54:47] third and final consideration that's a
[54:49] proper motion properly seconded
[54:52] amendments Mr
[54:54] clerk speaker no amendments are follow
[54:59] Senator Taylor on the bill thank you
[55:01] thank you Mr Speaker this bill comes to
[55:03] us from the comp Controllers Office and
[55:05] basically what this bill will do is it
[55:08] will mandate that the comp controllers
[55:10] will provide approval for local
[55:12] governments that issue high-risk debt
[55:15] and it reclassifies certain debt to be
[55:18] included in the high-risk category it
[55:21] also um adds Municipal energy
[55:23] authorities to the definition of local
[55:25] governments uh for the purposes of this
[55:27] bill and then lastly this bill updates
[55:30] the law to exclude certain federal
[55:33] lending programs for from the balloon
[55:35] indebtedness so basically this will
[55:38] allow government to work better by uh
[55:41] requiring local governments who want to
[55:43] issue high-risk debt to get uh approval
[55:46] from the com controller's office in in
[55:48] order to do that last thing I'll say Mr
[55:50] Speaker I would have come to this with
[55:52] this bill sooner but the uh gentleman
[55:55] from clay County was camped out at the
[55:57] comp controller's office for about 3
[55:59] days to get his little bill with the
[56:01] training wheels on it that was his first
[56:03] bill and preventing me from bringing
[56:06] this one sooner thank you Mr speaker
[56:08] thank you Senator Taylor discussion on
[56:10] Senate Bill
[56:12] 191 objection to the question I see none
[56:16] we'll be voting on Senate Bill 191 those
[56:18] members in favor of Senate Bill 191 vote
[56:21] I when the bell rings so supposed to
[56:23] vote no let every member cast a vote
[56:25] when the bell rings has every member
[56:27] voted does any member wish to change
[56:29] their vote Mr clerk take the vote I 29
[56:33] no Senate Bill 191 having received a
[56:36] constitutional majority I declare it
[56:38] passed without objection motion
[56:40] reconsider is hereby table next bill Mr
[56:51] clerk we on item number three cill 196
[56:54] by Senator Wally on third and final
[56:55] consideration Senator Wally you
[56:57] recognized on Senate Bill
[56:59] 196 Mr speaker thank you very much Mr
[57:02] Speaker at the request of a colleague I
[57:04] would like to move this bill to Thursday
[57:07] next without objection Thursday next
[57:11] next bill Mr clerk item four C Bill 224
[57:14] by Senator Taylor on third and final
[57:16] consideration Mr Speaker the house bill
[57:17] is on the desk Senator Taylor you're
[57:19] recognized on Senate Bill
[57:21] 224 thank you Mr Speaker I would move to
[57:25] conform the subtitute to the house house
[57:29] bill 62 that's proper motion properly
[57:33] seconded is there objection without
[57:36] objection we're on House Bill 62 Senator
[57:39] Taylor moves adoption it's properly
[57:41] seconded amendments Mr clerk amendment
[57:45] number one Senate Health and Welfare
[57:47] committee
[57:49] Amendment where did Chairman Crow go
[57:52] Senator hail Senator hail on amendment
[57:55] number one I believe it's in the House
[58:00] Bill thank thank you Mr Speaker U move
[58:03] to withdraw without objection withdrawn
[58:08] on the bill Senator
[58:10] Taylor thank you Mr Speaker this bill
[58:13] comes to us from the University of
[58:14] Memphis and uh years ago athletic
[58:18] trainers were allowed to engage in the
[58:20] practice of uh dry needling for their
[58:24] athletes fast forward if you years it
[58:26] was an attorney general's opinion that
[58:28] ultimately said that um that dry
[58:30] needling was beyond the scope of
[58:33] athletic trainers so what we're
[58:35] attempting to do uh with this bill Mr
[58:37] Speaker is to bring athletic trainers
[58:40] into the same category with physical
[58:42] therapists and occupational therapist as
[58:44] it relates to dry needling this bill
[58:47] will require that board of athletic
[58:48] trainers to to develop uh comp
[58:52] competency requirements and minimum
[58:54] standards and it will also approve what
[58:56] schools will uh be engaged in uh
[58:58] teaching uh dry needling for the
[59:01] continuing education and that's
[59:03] basically what this bill does is giving
[59:05] athletic trainers the ability to do what
[59:06] they once could do as it relates to dry
[59:09] needling thank you Mr Speaker discussion
[59:11] on the
[59:12] bill see none objection to the question
[59:16] there is none we'll be voting on Senate
[59:19] Bill excuse me House Bill 62 those
[59:22] members favoring House Bill 62 will vote
[59:25] I when the bill r
[59:26] those opposed to vote no Senator white
[59:28] votes I has every member voted does any
[59:32] member wish to change their vote Mr
[59:34] clerk take the vote I 31 no n House Bill
[59:38] 62 having received a constitution
[59:40] majority I declare it passed without
[59:43] objection motion reconsider is hereby
[59:45] table next bill Mr
[59:48] clerk Senator yarboro excuse me thank
[59:51] you Mr Speaker PA just if I be
[59:53] recognized out of order like to
[59:55] introduce a special guest with us who's
[59:57] here today uh we have Senator Mark Daly
[1:00:01] who is uh the chair of the senate for in
[1:00:04] Ireland uh the Republic of Ireland and
[1:00:06] is a good friend of ours here in
[1:00:08] Tennessee uh the my my my house of
[1:00:13] representatives co-chair of the American
[1:00:15] Irish legislative caucus is here with
[1:00:18] him and we're welcoming him him today I
[1:00:21] hope you get a chance to meet Mark he is
[1:00:22] a great guy and has really a lot of
[1:00:26] effort into building relationships
[1:00:28] between Ireland and the state of
[1:00:30] Tennessee uh that our people have always
[1:00:33] had but give given the whiskey and the
[1:00:35] and the and the music and The Beautiful
[1:00:38] People but uh we're trying to deepen
[1:00:41] those ties to Commerce and other things
[1:00:43] and so he has been a great friend of
[1:00:45] ours and so I hope you'll stop by and
[1:00:47] meet him there's a reception in the
[1:00:48] legislative Library when we adjourn so
[1:00:51] if we could just welcome him today thank
[1:00:54] you thank you glad to they have you with
[1:01:00] us thank you Senator Ybor appreciate
[1:01:04] that next order Mr clerk autum five C
[1:01:07] Bill 231 muster
[1:01:09] arberry Thursday
[1:01:12] next item number six C Bill 233 by
[1:01:15] Senator arberry without objection
[1:01:17] Thursday
[1:01:20] next item seven Senate Bill 239 by
[1:01:23] Senator Taylor on third and final
[1:01:25] consideration Senator Taylor you're
[1:01:27] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:01:29] 239 thank you Mr
[1:01:32] Speaker I would like to move uh for
[1:01:35] third and final consideration Senate
[1:01:37] Bill 239 that's proper motion properly
[1:01:40] seconded amendments Mr clerk amendment
[1:01:42] number one Senate Judiciary Committee
[1:01:44] Amendment Senator Garden H you
[1:01:47] recognized thank you Mr Speaker
[1:01:49] Amendment one changes the reporting
[1:01:52] deadline from January 1st of 2026 to
[1:01:55] January 31st
[1:01:57] 2026 with that I move amendment number
[1:01:59] one for adoption and yield to the
[1:02:01] sponsor for any additional questions
[1:02:03] that's a proper motion properly seconded
[1:02:08] discussion OB objection to the question
[1:02:11] I see none all in favor of amendment
[1:02:14] number one say
[1:02:16] I oppose nay you
[1:02:20] adopt on the bill as amended
[1:02:23] discussion objection to the question
[1:02:26] I see none Senator Taylor renews his
[1:02:29] motion we'll be voting on Senate Bill
[1:02:31] 239 on third and final consideration
[1:02:34] those members in favor of Senate Bill
[1:02:36] 239 vote I when the bell rings those
[1:02:39] opposed to vote no let every member
[1:02:41] guess their vote with when the bill
[1:02:43] Rings sen white votes
[1:02:48] I Mr clerk take the vote I 29 no n
[1:02:53] Senate Bill 239 having received the con
[1:02:55] tion majority I declare it passed
[1:02:58] without objection motion reconsider is
[1:03:00] hereby table next bill Mr clerk automate
[1:03:03] C Bill 240 by Senator Taylor on third
[1:03:05] and final consideration speak of house
[1:03:07] bill is on the desk Senator Taylor you
[1:03:09] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:03:12] 240 thank you Mr Speaker and I would
[1:03:16] move to conform and substitute the house
[1:03:17] bill
[1:03:19] 207 that's a proper motion properly
[1:03:21] seconded is there objection without
[1:03:23] objection we're on House Bill
[1:03:27] 207 Senator Taylor moves adoptions
[1:03:30] properly seconded amendments Mr clerk
[1:03:32] amendment number one Senate Judiciary
[1:03:34] Committee amendment is in the house bill
[1:03:36] chairman Gardenhire thank you Mr Speaker
[1:03:38] I move to withdraw without objection
[1:03:42] withdrawn on the bill Senator Taylor
[1:03:45] thank you Mr Speaker uh this bill uh
[1:03:49] actually does a couple of things one
[1:03:51] organized retail crime is a continued
[1:03:54] problem uh not only in Tennessee but but
[1:03:57] nationally uh a hundred billion dollar a
[1:04:00] year is lost to organized retail crime
[1:04:02] Nationwide $500 million is lost to
[1:04:06] private businesses in uh Statewide and
[1:04:09] the state is losing $117 million a year
[1:04:12] in loss tax revenue what this bill will
[1:04:15] do Mr Speaker is if passed it will amend
[1:04:19] the current code to add additional
[1:04:20] definitions to organized retail crime
[1:04:23] statute it also will amend the current
[1:04:26] code to add enhancement for engaging in
[1:04:28] the destruction of property or the using
[1:04:31] of a weapon during the commission of
[1:04:33] organized retail crime simply put Mr
[1:04:35] Speaker this bill updates the code to
[1:04:37] match the 2025 criminal and with that I
[1:04:40] would ask for a favorable vote Senator
[1:04:43] Taylor renews his motion
[1:04:47] discussion objection to the question I
[1:04:50] see none we'll be voting on House Bill
[1:04:53] 207 on third and final consideration
[1:04:55] those members favoring House Bill 207 to
[1:04:58] vote I when the bell rings those opposed
[1:05:00] to vote no let every member cast their
[1:05:02] vote when the bell rings do every member
[1:05:05] voted Senator Roberts votes ey do
[1:05:08] Senator Crow votes ey does any member
[1:05:11] wish to change their vote Mr clerk take
[1:05:13] the vote I 31 n Senate Bill 207 having
[1:05:18] received a constitution majority I
[1:05:20] declare it passed without objection
[1:05:22] motion reconsider is hereby table next
[1:05:25] Bill Mr clerk Mr Speaker the Senate's on
[1:05:28] item number nine Senate Bill 298 by
[1:05:30] Senator Roberts Senator Roberts you're
[1:05:32] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:05:34] 298 thank you Mr Speaker uh the chairman
[1:05:37] of Finance had some questions about this
[1:05:39] bill and asked me if I could roll it and
[1:05:41] uh if I may I'd like to roll it for two
[1:05:43] weeks two weeks if I may please without
[1:05:46] objection two weeks next bill Mr
[1:05:50] clerk Mr Speaker the Senate's on item
[1:05:53] number 10 Senate Bill 305 by senator
[1:05:55] Briggs Senator Briggs you're recognized
[1:05:58] on Senate Bill
[1:05:59] 305 uh thank you very much Mr Speaker
[1:06:02] I'd like to move Senate Bill 305 for
[1:06:05] third and final consideration that's
[1:06:08] proper motion properly seconded
[1:06:09] amendments Mr clerk amendment number one
[1:06:12] by the Senate state and local government
[1:06:13] committee Senator Briggs you're
[1:06:15] recognized on Amendment one uh thank you
[1:06:17] very much Mr Speaker amendment number
[1:06:19] one rewrites the bill and it prohibits a
[1:06:22] religious organization that receives
[1:06:24] States funds from denying a person
[1:06:27] benefits to excluding a person from
[1:06:30] participating in or discriminating
[1:06:32] against a person on the basis of
[1:06:34] religion who would otherwise be eligible
[1:06:36] for the program or
[1:06:41] activity you've heard the amendment
[1:06:43] discussion on the
[1:06:45] amendment see none objection to the
[1:06:48] question there is none on the amendment
[1:06:50] all in favor say
[1:06:52] I on the those opposed
[1:06:56] nay amendment number one's adopted on
[1:06:59] the bill as amended
[1:07:04] discussion objection to the question I
[1:07:06] see none Senator BRS she wish wish to
[1:07:09] close I renew my motion Senate Briggs
[1:07:11] renes his motion we'll be voting on
[1:07:13] Senate Bill 305 on third and final
[1:07:16] consideration those members in favor of
[1:07:18] Senate Bill 305 vote I when the bell
[1:07:21] rings those opposed to vote no let every
[1:07:23] member cast their vote when the bell
[1:07:25] rings is every member voted does any
[1:07:27] member wish to change their vote Mr
[1:07:29] clerk take the
[1:07:30] vote I 30 no n Senate Bill 305 having
[1:07:35] received a constitutional majority I
[1:07:37] declare it passed without objection
[1:07:40] motion reconsider is hereby table next
[1:07:44] bill Mr clerk Mr Speaker the Senate's on
[1:07:46] item number 11 Senate Bill 384 by
[1:07:48] Senator Taylor Senator Taylor you
[1:07:50] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:07:53] 384 thank you Mr Speaker I would move uh
[1:07:56] for third and final consideration Senate
[1:07:58] Bill 384 that's proper motion properly
[1:08:01] seconded amendments Mr clerk amendment
[1:08:03] number one by the Senate state and local
[1:08:04] government committee Senator Briggs
[1:08:06] you're recognized on amendment number
[1:08:08] one thank you Mr Speaker amendment
[1:08:10] number one moves the effective date to
[1:08:12] July 1 2025 move to adopt amendment
[1:08:15] number one that's a proper motion
[1:08:18] properly seconded
[1:08:19] discussion objection to the question I
[1:08:22] see none all in favor of amendment
[1:08:24] number one say I those oppos nay you
[1:08:30] adopt on the bill Senator
[1:08:34] Taylor thank you Mr Speaker what this
[1:08:38] bill uh what it will do is currently an
[1:08:42] extended stay
[1:08:43] hotel collects the lodging tax for uh
[1:08:49] people who are staying in that hotel if
[1:08:51] it's less than 30 days then the hotel
[1:08:55] operator has to refund that lodging tax
[1:08:57] back to the customer if they stay Beyond
[1:09:00] 30 days because it's an extended stay
[1:09:02] hotel they don't pay any lodging tax at
[1:09:04] all this bill will basically allow
[1:09:08] municipalities to keep that first 30
[1:09:11] days of uh lodging tax uh from the
[1:09:15] extended state hotel and it remains
[1:09:17] unchanged what happens after day 31
[1:09:19] which is that uh they get to stay
[1:09:21] without a tax that's basically what this
[1:09:23] will do and it will allow the municipal
[1:09:25] ities to be able to collect that
[1:09:27] Municipal TA or that loding tax for the
[1:09:29] first 30 days you you've heard the
[1:09:32] discussion and Amendment on the bill is
[1:09:35] are there
[1:09:36] questions objection to the question I
[1:09:39] see none we'll be voting on Senate Bill
[1:09:42] 384 on third and final consideration
[1:09:44] those members favoring Senate Bill 384
[1:09:47] will vote I when the bell rings those
[1:09:49] opposed to vote no let every member cast
[1:09:51] their vote when the bell
[1:09:53] rings Jack senor Jackson votes I Senator
[1:09:57] Massie votes I Mr clerk take the
[1:10:01] vote eyes 30 no
[1:10:04] n Senate Bill 385 having received a
[1:10:07] constitutional majority I declare it
[1:10:09] passed without objection motion
[1:10:11] reconsider is hereby take next bill Mr
[1:10:15] clerk Mr Speaker the Senate's on item
[1:10:17] number 12 Senate Bill 416 by Senator
[1:10:19] hail speaker ha you're recognized on
[1:10:22] Senate Bill
[1:10:23] 416 thank you Mr Speaker
[1:10:26] leas face a conflict in the law as they
[1:10:28] seek out the highest quality materials
[1:10:31] to use in their virtual schools today a
[1:10:34] requirement exists for any school to use
[1:10:36] textbooks from the list approved by the
[1:10:38] textbook commission unfortunately there
[1:10:41] aren't products on textbooks commission
[1:10:44] commission approved lists that are
[1:10:46] appropriate for use in the virtual
[1:10:47] school setting this is issue was brought
[1:10:50] to me by my own District seen a conflict
[1:10:53] firsthand this bill will bring clar for
[1:10:55] districts until we can get a permanent
[1:10:57] solution in place with that Mr Speaker I
[1:11:00] move Senate Bill 416 on third and final
[1:11:03] consideration bring up Amendment that'll
[1:11:05] make the bill speaker L move Senate Bill
[1:11:07] 416 it's properly seconded amendments Mr
[1:11:10] clerk amendment number one by the Senate
[1:11:12] education committee chairman Massie
[1:11:14] you're recognized on Senate education
[1:11:17] commit excuse me Senator
[1:11:19] why thank you Mr Speaker this amendment
[1:11:22] requires virtual schools to use
[1:11:24] curriculum and materials that meet or
[1:11:26] exceed the State Board of education's
[1:11:30] academic standards and prohibits the the
[1:11:34] approval of a waiver to use materials
[1:11:36] that do not meet these standards
[1:11:38] furthermore the amendment ensures that
[1:11:40] virtual schools maintain the right to
[1:11:42] apply for a waiver for unapproved M
[1:11:45] materials provided these materials are
[1:11:47] shown to meet the state standards move
[1:11:50] to adopt motion is to adopt discussion
[1:11:55] is there objection to the question I see
[1:11:57] none all in favor of Education committee
[1:12:01] amendment number one say I those oppos
[1:12:05] nay you adopt on the bill as amended
[1:12:11] discussion is there objection to the
[1:12:14] question I see
[1:12:16] none Senator hail renews his motion
[1:12:19] we'll be voting on Senate Bill 416 on
[1:12:22] third and final consideration those
[1:12:24] members in favor Senate Bill 416 is
[1:12:27] amended vote I when the bell rings those
[1:12:29] opposed vote no let every member cast
[1:12:32] their vote when the bell
[1:12:35] rings Senator Bailey votes I Senator
[1:12:38] Campbell votes
[1:12:40] I Mr clerk take the vote eyes 32 no a
[1:12:46] Senate Bill 416 having received a
[1:12:48] constitutional majority I declare it
[1:12:50] passed without objection motion
[1:12:52] reconsider is hereby table
[1:12:55] next bill Mr clerk Mr Speaker of the
[1:12:58] Senate on item number 13 Senate Bill 421
[1:13:01] by Senator
[1:13:02] Reeves sen Reeves you're recognized on
[1:13:05] Senate Bill
[1:13:07] 421 thank you thank you Mr Speaker roll
[1:13:10] Senate Bill 421 to Thursday March
[1:13:13] 27th without objection Senate Bill 421
[1:13:17] is rolled till Thursday March
[1:13:21] 22nd next bill Mr clerk Mr Speaker this
[1:13:25] senat on item number 14 Senate Bill 4
[1:13:27] 440 by Senator w-e Senator Wally you
[1:13:30] recognize on Senate Bill
[1:13:32] 440 thank you very much Mr Speaker Mr
[1:13:35] Speaker I would move passage of Senate
[1:13:37] Bill 440 on third and final
[1:13:38] consideration that's proper motion
[1:13:40] properly
[1:13:42] seconded Senator Wally an explanation on
[1:13:45] the bill thank you Mr Speaker Senate
[1:13:48] Bill 440 comes from afflac you know the
[1:13:51] duck uh coach Saban coach Prime this is
[1:13:55] a bill that makes a change to the
[1:13:56] expected benefit insurance also known as
[1:13:59] supplemental insurance and does not
[1:14:00] touch major medical insurance expected
[1:14:04] benefit insurance is an insurance
[1:14:05] product that pays a policy holder money
[1:14:07] to cover loss wages due to an accident
[1:14:09] or illness and doesn't go directly to
[1:14:12] the health care provider it's designed
[1:14:14] to fill Financial gaps left by major
[1:14:16] medical insurance and help in unplanned
[1:14:18] unexpected events like cancer heart
[1:14:20] attack or Hospital stay the policy
[1:14:23] holder can use the money for co-pay
[1:14:25] bills Child Care mortgage payments
[1:14:27] anything they wish Mr Speaker this bill
[1:14:30] clarifies and distinguishes supplemental
[1:14:32] products from major medical and that
[1:14:34] supplemental insurance does not cover
[1:14:36] mandates that major medical insurance
[1:14:39] covers so with that Mr Speaker pending
[1:14:42] any questions I would renew my motion
[1:14:44] for passage that's Pro proper
[1:14:47] motion
[1:14:50] discussion objection to the
[1:14:52] question I see none we'll be voting on
[1:14:56] Senate Bill 440 on third and final
[1:14:58] consideration those members in favor of
[1:15:00] Senate Bill 44 440 will vote I when the
[1:15:03] bell rings those opposed to vote no let
[1:15:05] every member cast the vote when the bell
[1:15:08] rings Senator Bailey votes I and Mr
[1:15:11] clerk take the vote eyes 32 no n Senate
[1:15:16] Bill 440 having received a
[1:15:18] constitutional majority I declare it
[1:15:20] passed without objection motion
[1:15:22] reconsider is here by table
[1:15:27] at one time we speaker Wilder used to
[1:15:31] say when they used the Senate used to be
[1:15:34] able to receive Donald Duck orange juice
[1:15:37] or grapefruit juice that when Donald
[1:15:40] Duck came to the legislature the
[1:15:42] legislature went quack quack
[1:15:46] quack no telling what was in it quack
[1:15:50] quack next bill Mr clerk item 15 C Bill
[1:15:54] 449 by Senator Massie on third and final
[1:15:56] consideration chairman Massie you're
[1:15:58] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:16:00] 449 um thank you Mr Speaker and I move
[1:16:04] Senate Bill 449 on third and final
[1:16:07] consideration in order to bring up the
[1:16:09] amendment that's a proper motion
[1:16:10] properly seconded amendments Mr clerk
[1:16:13] amendment number one Senate Health and
[1:16:14] Welfare committee Amendment chairman
[1:16:16] Crow you recognized on Amendment one
[1:16:19] thank you Mr
[1:16:21] Speaker amendment I do have amendment
[1:16:23] number one and it rewrites the bill it
[1:16:27] enacts the fertility treatment and
[1:16:29] contraceptive protection act establishes
[1:16:32] the right of an individual to engage in
[1:16:34] activities associated with fertility
[1:16:36] treatment and contraception in the state
[1:16:39] it affirms the right of Health Care
[1:16:41] Providers to
[1:16:42] perform and the right of a person to
[1:16:45] receive or use fertility treatment and
[1:16:48] contraceptives in the state so without
[1:16:51] objection I would move to adopt it does
[1:16:54] make the bill without objection please
[1:16:55] sir and defer to the sponsor Senator
[1:16:58] grow moves adoption of amendment number
[1:17:00] one's properly seconded discussion on
[1:17:03] Amendment one yeah objection to the
[1:17:07] question all I see none all in favor of
[1:17:10] amendment number one say I oppose nay
[1:17:14] you
[1:17:16] adopt on the bill is there
[1:17:20] discussion objection to the question I
[1:17:23] see none Senator Mass renews her motion
[1:17:25] we'll be voting on Senate Bill 449 on
[1:17:29] third and final consideration those
[1:17:31] members favoring Senate Bill 449 will
[1:17:34] vote I when the bell rings those opposed
[1:17:36] to vote no let every member cast their
[1:17:39] votee when the bell rings is every
[1:17:40] member voted does any member wish to
[1:17:43] change their vote Mr clerk take the vote
[1:17:46] eyes 29 no n Senate Bill 449 having
[1:17:51] received a constitutional majority I
[1:17:52] declare it passed with without objection
[1:17:55] the motion reconsider is here by table
[1:17:59] next bill Mr
[1:18:01] clerk item 16 Cate Bill 5 17 by Senator
[1:18:05] acry without objection Thursday
[1:18:08] next next bill Mr clerk item 17 Senate
[1:18:11] Bill 541 by Senator Stevens on third and
[1:18:14] final consideration chairman Stevens
[1:18:16] here recognized on Senate Bill
[1:18:19] 541 thank you Mr Speaker this bill needs
[1:18:22] a little more consideration little more
[1:18:24] time to just State let's send it back to
[1:18:27] calendar without
[1:18:29] objection
[1:18:31] calendar next bill Mr
[1:18:36] clerk item 18 c Bill 547 my Senator
[1:18:40] Stevens on third and final consideration
[1:18:42] chairman Stevens you recognized on
[1:18:44] Senate Bill
[1:18:46] 547 thank you Mr Speaker I move Senate
[1:18:49] Bill 547 on third and final
[1:18:52] consideration that's a proper motion
[1:18:54] proper
[1:18:56] seconded Senator Stevens on the
[1:18:59] bill thank you Mr Speaker uh upon
[1:19:02] approval by Third 2third majority vote
[1:19:05] of the county legislative body this bill
[1:19:08] would authorize Criminal Court to charge
[1:19:10] $2 $12 sorry excuse me
[1:19:13] $12.50 in every misdemeanor and felony
[1:19:17] cost bill for multicounty judicial
[1:19:20] districts the funds allocated to would
[1:19:22] be allocated to the district attorney
[1:19:24] general's conference
[1:19:25] to provide supplemental funding for each
[1:19:28] office in that Judicial District for
[1:19:30] single County districts the funds would
[1:19:33] be remitted to the County government the
[1:19:35] receiving District Attorney General
[1:19:37] would that's uh that receives the funds
[1:19:39] is required to report the funding to the
[1:19:42] conference no later than June uh January
[1:19:44] 1st the district attorney general is
[1:19:46] required to conference is required to
[1:19:49] file a more comprehensive report by
[1:19:51] February 15th to the Senate Judiciary
[1:19:54] chair house criminal justice chair and
[1:19:56] both Finance chairs this fund uh and
[1:20:01] legislation mirrors a similar funding
[1:20:04] mechanism that the public defenders
[1:20:05] conference has uh and and with that
[1:20:08] explanation I'm glad to take
[1:20:11] questions questions on Senate Bill
[1:20:15] 547 is there objection to the question I
[1:20:19] see none we'll be voting on Senate Bill
[1:20:21] 547 on third and final consideration
[1:20:24] those members favoring Senate Bill 547
[1:20:27] to vote I when the bell rings those
[1:20:29] opposed to vote no let every member cast
[1:20:32] their vote when the bell rings s member
[1:20:34] voted does any member wish to change
[1:20:36] their vote Mr clerk take the vote uh 25
[1:20:41] five n Senate Bill 547 having received a
[1:20:45] constitutional majority I declare it
[1:20:47] passed without objection motion
[1:20:49] reconsider is here by table next bill Mr
[1:20:52] clerk item 19 C Bill 5 ready2 by Senator
[1:20:56] acry without objection Thursday
[1:20:59] next next bill Mr clerk autum 20 Senate
[1:21:03] Bill 689 by Senator white on third and
[1:21:06] final consideration chairman white
[1:21:07] you're recognized on Senate Bill
[1:21:11] 689 thank you Mr Speaker this
[1:21:13] legislation as amended would complete
[1:21:16] the merger of tsac and tck
[1:21:20] together I I REM renew my motion on
[1:21:23] third and final consideration
[1:21:25] sen white moves adoption of Senate Bill
[1:21:28] 689 properly seconded amendments Mr
[1:21:31] clerk amendment number one Senate
[1:21:32] education committee Amendment chairman
[1:21:34] Wyatt on amendment number one thank you
[1:21:37] Mr Speaker Amendment one completes a
[1:21:39] merger of TAC and TC and delete
[1:21:41] scholarship programs that are no longer
[1:21:43] in use I move to adopt motion is for
[1:21:46] adoption
[1:21:48] discussion objection to the question I
[1:21:52] see none All In favor of amendment
[1:21:56] number one say I oppose nay you
[1:22:00] adopt on the bill
[1:22:04] discussion is there objection to the
[1:22:07] question I see none Senator white renews
[1:22:09] her motion we'll be voting on Senate
[1:22:11] Bill 689 is amended on third and final
[1:22:14] consideration those members favoring
[1:22:16] Senate Bill 689 will vote I when the
[1:22:19] bill Rings those opposed to vote no let
[1:22:21] every member mcer vote when the bill
[1:22:24] right sen low votes I Mr clerk take the
[1:22:29] vote I
[1:22:31] 3118 Senate Bill 689 having received a
[1:22:35] constitution majority I declare it
[1:22:37] passed without objection motion
[1:22:39] reconsider is hereby table next bill Mr
[1:22:42] Clerk
[1:22:55] item number 21 Senate Bill 703 by
[1:22:57] Senator Massie on third and final
[1:22:59] consideration Senator Massie you
[1:23:00] recognized on Senate Bill 703 thank you
[1:23:04] Mr Speaker and I move Senate Bill 703 on
[1:23:07] third and final consideration in order
[1:23:10] to bring up the amendment that's prop
[1:23:13] motion properly seconded amendments Mr
[1:23:18] clerk Senator Massie on amendment number
[1:23:21] one thank you Mr Speaker this bill as
[1:23:25] Rewritten uh the amendment does set up a
[1:23:28] Tasser study to to do a deep dive on our
[1:23:32] transportation infrastructure funding uh
[1:23:35] the the the relying totally on the gas
[1:23:39] tax with the gas tax being deete a
[1:23:42] depleting Revenue source is not working
[1:23:45] and so this will look at all re
[1:23:49] potential Revenue sources all potential
[1:23:52] needs that we're going to have in
[1:23:53] transportation
[1:23:55] and then bring the results back to us um
[1:23:58] by September 30th
[1:24:00] 2026 so we can look how to uh work to
[1:24:04] fix our transportation funding structure
[1:24:08] uh to meet the needs of tennesseans
[1:24:09] going forward I move the amendment
[1:24:13] Senator Massi moves the Amendments been
[1:24:17] properly seconded discussion on the
[1:24:21] amendment is there objection to the
[1:24:23] question
[1:24:25] I see none all those in favor of
[1:24:28] Transportation amendment number one say
[1:24:31] I oppose nay you adopt on the bill as
[1:24:35] amended
[1:24:38] discussion objection to the question see
[1:24:42] none sir Massie renews her motion we'll
[1:24:45] be voting on Senate Bill 703 on third
[1:24:48] and final consideration those members
[1:24:50] favoring Senate Bill 703 vote I when the
[1:24:53] bell rings those oppos to votee no let
[1:24:55] every member cast their vote when the
[1:24:58] bell rings is every member voted does
[1:25:00] any member wish change their vote Mr
[1:25:02] clerk take the
[1:25:07] vote Senate Bill 703 having received a
[1:25:11] constitution majority I declare it
[1:25:13] passed without objection motion
[1:25:15] reconsider is hereby table next bill Mr
[1:25:18] clerk item 22 City Bill 718 by Senator
[1:25:21] Taylor on third and final consideration
[1:25:23] Senator Taylor you're Rec recognized on
[1:25:25] Senate Bill
[1:25:27] 718 thank you Mr Speaker I would move
[1:25:29] for third and final consideration Senate
[1:25:31] Bill 718 that's prop motion properly
[1:25:34] seconded amendments Mr
[1:25:37] clerk amendment number one Senate
[1:25:39] Judiciary commit
[1:25:41] Amendment chairman Gardenhire you
[1:25:43] recognized on amendment number one thank
[1:25:46] you Mr Speaker Amendment one requires a
[1:25:48] juvenile court to use a dedicated
[1:25:50] courtroom within the Detention Facility
[1:25:53] for the delinquent
[1:25:55] proceedings if one is available it also
[1:25:57] clarifies that the bill only applies to
[1:25:59] Shelby County with that I move amendment
[1:26:02] number one for adoption and yield to the
[1:26:04] sponsor for any additional questions
[1:26:07] that's a prop motion proberly
[1:26:09] seconded on the amendment Judiciary
[1:26:13] number one all in favor say I oppose nay
[1:26:18] you adopt amendment number one on the
[1:26:20] bill as amended
[1:26:22] discussion is there objection
[1:26:25] Senator Kyle you're recognized thank you
[1:26:28] Mr Speaker I'd like to put my comments
[1:26:29] on the record I think um the sponsors
[1:26:32] well aware um this particular situation
[1:26:36] has been on the front page of our news
[1:26:38] leading stories down there in Shelby
[1:26:41] County for quite some time it was
[1:26:44] between the sheriff and the juvenile
[1:26:46] court
[1:26:47] judge on transporting juveniles where to
[1:26:51] hold the court or where Court can be be
[1:26:54] held for these
[1:26:55] juveniles I think that this bill would
[1:26:58] tip the scales of justice and as long as
[1:27:01] that lawsuit is going on I think that
[1:27:04] this is premature to bring this bill
[1:27:07] because I would hate for this body to be
[1:27:09] accused of tipping the scales uh and a
[1:27:13] ongoing piece of legislation I do not
[1:27:16] want want to
[1:27:19] uh infringe on what the sponsor wants to
[1:27:22] do but I think we need to be aware that
[1:27:25] this is presently in the
[1:27:28] courts thank you thank you Senator Kyle
[1:27:31] further discussion on the
[1:27:34] bill I see none is there objection to
[1:27:37] the question there is none we be voting
[1:27:40] on Senate Bill 718 as amended on third
[1:27:43] and final consideration those members
[1:27:45] favoring Senate Bill
[1:27:47] 718 vote I when the bell rings those
[1:27:50] opposed vote no let every member cast
[1:27:52] their vote when the bell rings is every
[1:27:54] member voted does any member wish to
[1:27:56] change change their vote Mr clerk take
[1:27:59] the
[1:28:04] vote Senate Bill 718 having received the
[1:28:07] Constitutional majority I declared
[1:28:09] passed without objection motion
[1:28:11] reconsider is hereby
[1:28:16] table speaker hail
[1:28:40] these two bills are Senator Jagger so we
[1:29:12] we're on Mr clerk next item item 23 sen
[1:29:16] 745 747 by Senator
[1:29:20] joer without objection to the heel
[1:29:25] Mr clerk next item item 24 City Bill 749
[1:29:28] by Senator jger without objection to the
[1:29:34] hill Mr Clark item 25 C Bill 790 by
[1:29:38] Senator Bailey on third and final
[1:29:39] consideration Mr speak the house bill is
[1:29:41] on the desk Senator Bailey you
[1:29:42] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:29:44] [Music]
[1:29:46] 790 thank you Mr Speaker I move to
[1:29:49] conform and substitute to the house bill
[1:29:51] that's a proper motion by Senator Bailey
[1:29:54] conform and substitute Senate Bill 790
[1:29:57] to House Bill
[1:29:59] 1095 Senator Bailey
[1:30:01] moves House Bill 1095 on third and final
[1:30:05] consideration Senator Bailey you're
[1:30:07] recognized thank you thank you Mr
[1:30:09] Speaker um members this bill has
[1:30:11] Statewide application but primarily
[1:30:14] affects two uh resort areas in my
[1:30:18] district in Cumberland County being Lake
[1:30:20] tany and Fairfield Glade there is a
[1:30:24] between the local sheriff's department
[1:30:26] as well as their uh police um private
[1:30:30] police forces that they have that
[1:30:32] protect those two communities this uh
[1:30:35] legislation will allow them to be post
[1:30:38] certified officers called special
[1:30:40] deputies uh to be able to answer calls
[1:30:43] for the county as well as act in an
[1:30:46] official police um actions needed in the
[1:30:51] community that's an explanation of the
[1:30:53] bill you've heard an explanation of the
[1:30:56] bill Mr clerk
[1:30:59] amendments can be amendment is in the
[1:31:01] house bill Senator Gardenhire you're
[1:31:03] recognized thank you Mr Speaker I move
[1:31:05] to withdraw without objection withdrawn
[1:31:08] we're back on the
[1:31:09] bill as
[1:31:11] amended questions on the bill discussion
[1:31:14] on the
[1:31:16] bill seeing none you heard an
[1:31:18] explanation are you ready to
[1:31:21] vote Senator Bailey renews his motion on
[1:31:24] House Bill 1095 Third and final
[1:31:26] consideration all in favor vote I when
[1:31:28] the bell rings those oppose vote
[1:31:34] no is every member
[1:31:39] voted Mr Clark eyes 31 no n House Bill
[1:31:44] 1095 having having received
[1:31:47] Constitutional Amendment it's declared
[1:31:49] passed without objection motion Rec
[1:31:51] consider goes stable Mr clerk next time
[1:31:53] it item 26 Senate Bill 816 by Senator
[1:31:57] low on third and final consideration
[1:31:58] Senator low you're recognized on Senate
[1:32:00] Bill 816 thank you Mr Speaker I move 816
[1:32:04] for final
[1:32:05] consideration that's a proper motion
[1:32:07] proper second on Senate Bill 816 Mr
[1:32:10] clerk amendment number one Senate
[1:32:12] Commerce and labor committee Amendment
[1:32:13] Senator Bailey you're recognized thank
[1:32:15] you Mr Speaker Amendment one makes it a
[1:32:17] violation of the consumer protection act
[1:32:20] of
[1:32:20] 1977 to falsely imply to a consumer that
[1:32:24] they are involved in a civil lawsuit or
[1:32:27] criminal prosecution in order to
[1:32:29] pressure them into paying for related
[1:32:31] Services cost fines penalties or other
[1:32:33] fees I move passage and will defer to
[1:32:36] the sponsor for further explanation
[1:32:38] you've heard an explanation of chairman
[1:32:41] any questions on the
[1:32:43] amendment seeing none are you ready to
[1:32:45] vote all in favor say I oppose no we
[1:32:50] adopt back on the bill as amended sen L
[1:32:53] you recognize C Bill 816 thank you Mr
[1:32:56] Speaker as many of you may know the
[1:32:58] fraud industry is an increasing industry
[1:33:01] every year it moved from 23 to 24 from a
[1:33:04] 1010 billion industry to a 12. half
[1:33:06] billion doll industry uh this has been
[1:33:08] exacerbated with tools that are
[1:33:10] technologically based like um artificial
[1:33:13] intelligence the availability of texting
[1:33:15] texting in our Consumer Protection Law
[1:33:18] there currently is not a statute that
[1:33:20] addresses those who fraudulently claim
[1:33:23] people are subject to parties to a an
[1:33:26] existing lawsuit or a criminal
[1:33:28] prosecution and this would simply add
[1:33:30] that to the consumer protections act act
[1:33:32] and I stand for any available questions
[1:33:35] you've heard an explanation of the
[1:33:37] Senate Bill 816 by Senator low as
[1:33:40] amended any
[1:33:44] questions seeing none Senator low renews
[1:33:47] his motion on Senate Bill 816 all in
[1:33:49] favor vote I when the bell rings all
[1:33:51] those opposed vote no
[1:33:54] is every member voted is any member wish
[1:33:56] to change their vote Mr
[1:33:59] clar eyes 32 no n sen Bill 816 having
[1:34:04] received Constitution majorities
[1:34:06] declared passed without objection motion
[1:34:08] R consider goes table next item Mr
[1:34:11] Clark item 27 Senate Bill 849 by Senator
[1:34:15] Lamar on third and final consideration
[1:34:17] Senator Lamar you recognized on Senate
[1:34:18] Bill
[1:34:20] 849 thank you Mr Speaker I would like to
[1:34:22] move Senate Bill 84 49 on third and
[1:34:24] final consideration that's a proper
[1:34:27] motion proper
[1:34:29] second cator Lamar would you like to
[1:34:31] describe Senate Bill 849 do we have an
[1:34:34] amendment Mr clerk have amendment number
[1:34:36] one Senate Health and Welfare committee
[1:34:38] Amendment chairman Crow you're
[1:34:39] recognized thank you Mr Speaker this
[1:34:41] amendment does rewrite the bill it
[1:34:43] requires Department of Health to
[1:34:44] collaborate with an organization to
[1:34:47] create or identify a continuing
[1:34:49] education program for the purpose of
[1:34:51] providing Health Care Professionals
[1:34:53] under the board of medical examiners or
[1:34:55] Board of osteopathic examination and the
[1:34:57] board of uh examiners in Psychology to
[1:35:01] uh information or training relative to
[1:35:04] maternal mental health requires each
[1:35:07] board to accept such courses as credit
[1:35:09] toward continuing education if
[1:35:11] successfully completed requires each
[1:35:14] board to periodically update any
[1:35:16] curriculum developed for maternal mental
[1:35:18] health to account for new research move
[1:35:20] to adopt without
[1:35:23] you you've heard an explanation of
[1:35:26] Health amendment number one any
[1:35:29] discussion is proper motion proper
[1:35:30] second on Amendment any discussion on
[1:35:32] the
[1:35:33] amendment Senator Briggs you're
[1:35:35] recognized uh does the sponsor yield
[1:35:38] sponsor of the amendment or of the
[1:35:41] bill well I think I'll better direct it
[1:35:43] to the bill sponsor to the bill sponsor
[1:35:46] since the amendment makes the bill she
[1:35:48] she yields you're recognized Senator BR
[1:35:50] the question I had is the it mentioned
[1:35:54] the boards that will be form formulating
[1:35:57] this course now these are national
[1:35:59] boards other than the Tennessee Board of
[1:36:01] medical examiners and uh I guess my
[1:36:05] question is what Authority do we in the
[1:36:08] Tennessee legislature have to dictate
[1:36:10] what a national board uh what a national
[1:36:13] board does CH Lamar you're recognized
[1:36:17] thank you Mr Speaker what this bill does
[1:36:19] is the Department of Health already has
[1:36:21] a course on maternal mental health there
[1:36:23] will offer this course and give it to
[1:36:26] them so that if you are one of the
[1:36:28] professionals listic it's one of the
[1:36:30] courses you can choose from for your
[1:36:33] continuing education credit so it's not
[1:36:35] mandating it's just adding to the list
[1:36:37] of courses you could choose from for
[1:36:39] your CTE credits Senator Briggs you
[1:36:42] recognized uh does the sponsor yield
[1:36:43] again sponsor yields uh okay so this is
[1:36:47] not going to be mandatory presently
[1:36:50] every physician has to do two hours
[1:36:54] of
[1:36:55] CMEs on opiate issues because of the
[1:36:59] opiate crisis we've had that's mandatory
[1:37:01] for your license this is not a mandatory
[1:37:04] course for all
[1:37:05] Physicians okay good thank you very
[1:37:08] much uh no sir it's not mandatory it's
[1:37:11] just if you want to take it you can take
[1:37:13] it any additional question Senator
[1:37:15] Tinley you're
[1:37:17] recognized thank you Mr Speaker no
[1:37:19] question just a comment I just think we
[1:37:21] should leave it up to the various board
[1:37:23] boards to determine what type CME they
[1:37:26] feel like their various uh members need
[1:37:29] to take and not be telling them from the
[1:37:32] general assembly what to do thank you Mr
[1:37:34] speaker thank you Senator Hensley we're
[1:37:36] on the bill as amended any additional
[1:37:39] questions or comments on the
[1:37:41] bill sen Lamar would you like to close
[1:37:45] we're on the amendment excuse me all in
[1:37:48] favor of the amendment say I oppose no
[1:37:52] we adopt we back on the bill as amended
[1:37:54] you've heard an explanation of the bill
[1:37:57] as amended
[1:38:00] questions I see none Senator Lamar would
[1:38:03] you like to renew your motion or would
[1:38:04] you like to close uh just want to
[1:38:06] reiterate make sure I answered uh
[1:38:08] Senator Bri's question is optional I
[1:38:10] would like to renew my motion and ask
[1:38:11] for a favorable
[1:38:13] vote all in favor we vote I when the
[1:38:17] bell rings all opposed vote no
[1:38:24] Mr clerk i 27 no n s Bill 849 having
[1:38:29] received constitute majority is clared
[1:38:32] pass motion reconsidered goes to
[1:38:36] table Mr clerk next item item 28 Senate
[1:38:40] Bill 1140 by Senator Crow on third and
[1:38:42] final consideration Senator Crow you're
[1:38:44] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:38:46] 1140 thank you Mr Speaker do we have
[1:38:49] amendments we do Senator crow move
[1:38:51] Senate Bill 1140 on Third and Fin
[1:38:53] consideration proper motion proper
[1:38:55] second Mr clerk Amendment amendment
[1:38:57] number one Senate energy Agricultural
[1:38:58] and natural resources committee
[1:38:59] Amendment chairman Reeves you're
[1:39:01] recognized thank you Mr Speaker
[1:39:03] amendment number one rewrites the bill
[1:39:05] to authorize the executive director of
[1:39:07] The Fish and Wildlife Commission or the
[1:39:09] executive director's design to issue
[1:39:12] temporary group hunting event permits
[1:39:14] for not for-profit organizations that
[1:39:17] sponsor and pay for a hunting event
[1:39:19] experience at no cost to a veteran with
[1:39:21] any percentage service connected ability
[1:39:24] and with that Mr Speaker I move adoption
[1:39:27] of amendment number one and yield of the
[1:39:28] sponsor for additional information
[1:39:30] Senator re R moves energy amendment
[1:39:33] number one prop per motion second
[1:39:36] discussion on the
[1:39:39] amendment I see none you ready to vote
[1:39:42] all in favor say I oppos no we adopt
[1:39:46] we're back on the amendment Senate Bill
[1:39:49] 1140 is amended questions on the bill
[1:39:53] for the
[1:39:56] sponsor I see none Senator Crow renews
[1:39:59] his motion on Senate Bill 1140 all in
[1:40:02] favor vote I when the bell rings those
[1:40:04] supposed to vote no Mr
[1:40:09] Clark Mr clerk take the vote eyes 30 no
[1:40:13] a Senate Bill 11:40 having received a
[1:40:16] constitutional amendment is declared
[1:40:18] passed that objection Mo reconsider
[1:40:22] stable Senator Bolan you're
[1:40:28] recognized Senator Bolan recorded as
[1:40:33] I Mr clerk next item Mr Speaker of the
[1:40:36] Senate's on item number 29 Senate Bill
[1:40:38] 734 by Senator pod Senator pod you
[1:40:41] recognize on Senate Bill
[1:40:43] 734 thank you Mr Speaker what Senate
[1:40:45] Bill 734 does this is a local issue
[1:40:48] concerning only davidon County there's
[1:40:50] been a tax on uh some of our hotel
[1:40:54] motels and this is going to extend it
[1:40:56] for another six years with that our
[1:40:58] renew Senate Bill 734 and third and
[1:41:00] final
[1:41:01] consideration sen toot move Senate Bill
[1:41:04] 734 on third and final consideration
[1:41:06] proper motion with proper second you've
[1:41:08] heard an explanation of the bill
[1:41:10] question on the
[1:41:13] bill I see none are you ready to vote
[1:41:17] sir toot you're recognized sir toot
[1:41:20] renews this motion all in favor vote I
[1:41:22] when the bell rings suppos vote
[1:41:25] no is every member voted any member wish
[1:41:28] to change their
[1:41:29] vote Mr clerk take the
[1:41:39] vote I 31 no
[1:41:42] n for having received Constitution
[1:41:45] majority declared pass that objection
[1:41:48] motion to Recons goes
[1:41:49] table next item Mr Clark
[1:42:09] speaker on item number 30 cill 1031 by
[1:42:12] Senator Bley on third and final
[1:42:13] consideration speaker the house bill is
[1:42:15] on the desk Senator bowan you're
[1:42:17] recognized on Senate Bill
[1:42:20] 1031 thank you Mr chairman uh
[1:42:23] um this is a little bit different
[1:42:25] because we had uh passed Amendment one
[1:42:28] and two accepted those and now the house
[1:42:32] has passed the bill they had combined
[1:42:34] amendments one and two so we I would
[1:42:38] like to conform and substitute to the
[1:42:41] house bill
[1:42:43] 1157 as identical to our bill with a
[1:42:46] combination of the two
[1:42:48] amendments Senator Boling uh makes a
[1:42:51] motion on Senate bill 1031 to conform
[1:42:54] substitute House Bill 1157 that's proper
[1:42:57] motion proper second Senator Bolan moves
[1:43:00] House Bill 1157 on third and final
[1:43:03] consideration amendments Mr clerk
[1:43:06] speaker amendments number one and number
[1:43:07] two are previously adopted on Senate
[1:43:09] Bill 1031
[1:43:13] on speaker those amendments are
[1:43:15] identical to house amendment number one
[1:43:20] and our law will be performed a
[1:43:22] substitute to the house bill
[1:43:26] Bill
[1:43:28] okay speaker MCN you recognized could we
[1:43:32] move to reconsider our action and
[1:43:34] adopting both those amendments and in
[1:43:37] effect take them off I'll yield to
[1:43:40] Senator Watson Senator Watson you're
[1:43:43] recognized thank you Mr we could um by
[1:43:47] conforming and substituting to the house
[1:43:49] bill it essentially strips out the two
[1:43:52] amendments that we had formally uh
[1:43:55] adopted and so the clerk assures me that
[1:43:58] by conforming and substituting we're in
[1:44:01] wear in a good a good parliamentary
[1:44:06] posture any additional clarification on
[1:44:10] that okay Senator bowling would you like
[1:44:13] to explain spill 1157
[1:44:18] as adopted from the house thank you m
[1:44:22] chair this bill is the one that we
[1:44:24] discussed last week and we had a couple
[1:44:26] of questions on it but it is restoring
[1:44:29] trust and public health messaging and uh
[1:44:32] it was our amendment made the bill and
[1:44:34] that amendment is included in the house
[1:44:36] bill so I do ask that we now conform it
[1:44:39] substitute I appreciate your vote
[1:44:41] Senator Bolan renews her motion on House
[1:44:44] Bill 1157 any additional
[1:44:47] questions for the sponsor seeing none
[1:44:50] all in favor vote I when the bell rings
[1:44:52] those suppos vote no Mr
[1:44:59] Clark sever member voted any member wish
[1:45:02] to change their
[1:45:04] vote Mr clerk take the vote i 26 six n
[1:45:08] House Bill 1157 hav't received
[1:45:10] constitutional amendment constitutional
[1:45:14] vote is declared passed without
[1:45:16] objection motion reconsiders here by
[1:45:20] table Mr clerk speaker we're back on
[1:45:23] item number three excuse me 23 Senate
[1:45:25] Bill 747 by Senator joer on third final
[1:45:27] consideration Senator Jer you're
[1:45:29] recognized on Senate Bill 747 thank you
[1:45:32] Mr Speaker I move Senate Bill 747 on
[1:45:36] third and final consideration for the
[1:45:38] purpose of bringing up an amendment to
[1:45:40] The
[1:45:40] Bill thank you Mr chairman uh that's
[1:45:44] proper motion on Senate Bill 747 proper
[1:45:47] second Mr Clark
[1:45:49] amendments amendment number one Senate
[1:45:51] Health and Welfare committee Amendment
[1:45:56] is it in the house
[1:45:59] bill okay on the sen
[1:46:11] Bill let's see Mr Speaker it does
[1:46:13] rewrite the bill extends the ground
[1:46:15] ambulance service provider Assessment
[1:46:17] Act of June to June
[1:46:20] 3026 extends from 30 business days to 45
[1:46:23] calendar days the time period in which
[1:46:25] an ambulance provider must pay an
[1:46:27] assessment to the division of ten care
[1:46:30] requires the office of emergency
[1:46:31] services to provide the commissioner of
[1:46:34] the Department of Health and with full
[1:46:36] access to ambulance run reports
[1:46:38] maintained by the office it also
[1:46:41] authorizes the commissioner to provide
[1:46:43] the division with ambulance run report
[1:46:46] data and additional requested data as
[1:46:49] needed to ensure the assessment program
[1:46:51] remains in compliance with state and
[1:46:53] federal
[1:46:55] laws uh fiscal impact remains unchanged
[1:46:58] so with that Mr Speaker I would uh move
[1:47:01] we adopt amendment number one please sir
[1:47:05] Senator Crow moves Health amendment
[1:47:07] number one proper motion proper second
[1:47:10] you've heard an explanation of the
[1:47:11] amendment any discussion on the
[1:47:15] amendment seeing none are you ready to
[1:47:18] vote all in favor say I oppos no the
[1:47:21] eyes car we ad ADT we're back on the
[1:47:24] bill as amended Senator joer you're
[1:47:26] recognized thank you Mr Speaker the
[1:47:29] ground ambulance assessment uh bill is
[1:47:32] merely an extension of the current
[1:47:34] assessment which has been in place by
[1:47:36] the legislature since 2018 the uh CMS
[1:47:40] requires now that we approve it annually
[1:47:42] and that is why we are here today
[1:47:44] discussing this bill this bill will uh
[1:47:48] allow assessment of our ambulance
[1:47:50] services throughout the state that money
[1:47:52] is used to leverage federal dollars it
[1:47:55] brings back money to our ambulance
[1:47:57] services on a rate of $2 to one uh I
[1:48:01] move the bill I respectfully renew my
[1:48:04] motion Mr Speaker Senator jger renews
[1:48:07] his motion on Cate Bill 747 this proper
[1:48:10] motion explanation of the bill any
[1:48:14] discussion are you ready to vote all in
[1:48:17] favor vote I when the bell rings all
[1:48:19] those oppos votee no
[1:48:23] SE vot
[1:48:27] i m
[1:48:28] clerk uh it's 32 no names Senate Bill
[1:48:33] 747 Haven received
[1:48:35] Constitution
[1:48:37] um constitutional vote is approved
[1:48:42] motion reconsider goes table kind of
[1:48:45] lost my thought there a little bit you
[1:48:47] get in a rhythm and if you lose the
[1:48:49] Rhythm you just stay out of place so so
[1:48:52] okay let's move forward here
[1:48:57] um Senator low we're going to come back
[1:48:59] to you in just a
[1:49:01] moment next item M item 24 Senate Bill
[1:49:04] 749 by Senator Jagger on third and final
[1:49:07] consideration speaking of house bills on
[1:49:08] the desk Senator Jagger You're
[1:49:10] recognized on Senate Bill 749 thank you
[1:49:13] Mr Speaker I will move to conform to the
[1:49:15] house bill that's a proper motion
[1:49:18] Senator Jagger
[1:49:20] moves to conform Senate bill 747 to
[1:49:23] House Bill
[1:49:25] 908 Senator jger moves House Bill 708 on
[1:49:30] third and final consideration proper
[1:49:32] motion proper second Senator Jer you're
[1:49:35] recognized on House Bill 9008 thank you
[1:49:38] uh Mr Speaker this bill has brought to
[1:49:41] Me by The Mortgage Bankers of Tennessee
[1:49:44] it is a bill that applies only to non-
[1:49:46] depository Banks Banks that's Bankers
[1:49:50] that specialize in in the second
[1:49:52] mortgage if you please what there are
[1:49:54] different there are multiple indexes
[1:49:57] speaker that govern the interest rate on
[1:50:01] SE uh second mortgages or what we would
[1:50:04] refer to in the statute as subordinate
[1:50:07] Mor mortgages as well uh one of the
[1:50:10] indexes uh this bill will change one of
[1:50:13] those indexes uh and replace the 30-year
[1:50:17] treasury yeld with a more uh modern uh
[1:50:21] index the average prime rate offer
[1:50:24] excuse me average Prime offer rate uh
[1:50:28] this bill was done in uh with assistance
[1:50:31] from the the
[1:50:35] the the commissioner of financial excuse
[1:50:38] me the commissioner of financial
[1:50:40] institutions all but I must say even
[1:50:43] though they have helped us with the
[1:50:44] language in the bill they are deferred
[1:50:46] on the bill uh what this bill does by
[1:50:49] conforming to a more uh modern uh index
[1:50:53] it expands the opportunity for folks to
[1:50:57] uh have an uh uh a chance to have
[1:51:02] perhaps have a subordinate loan a a home
[1:51:05] equity loan for example which is
[1:51:07] becoming popular among senior citizens
[1:51:10] uh and it uh uh it it is restricted in
[1:51:13] that it would have to it applies only to
[1:51:17] mortgages that are in excess of 15 years
[1:51:21] uh and I would I think it is really good
[1:51:25] uh for the economy that that we make
[1:51:27] this change and and expand this
[1:51:30] opportunity to uh many of our
[1:51:36] tennesseans thank you Mr chairman cator
[1:51:40] yarboro you're recognized uh thank you
[1:51:42] Mr Speaker if sponsor will yield sponsor
[1:51:45] yields uh thank you uh the sponsor Mr
[1:51:48] Speaker referenced to Second mortgages
[1:51:50] and subordinate loans but as
[1:51:53] as I read the statute this would it
[1:51:56] applies to any home loan which means any
[1:51:59] any loan that's secured by real estate
[1:52:02] owned and
[1:52:03] occupied for residential purposes that's
[1:52:06] you know over 15 so typically it's the
[1:52:08] 15 and 30-year mortgage uh is is is that
[1:52:14] correct Senator Jager you're right thank
[1:52:16] you the bill says I'm looking at Section
[1:52:19] 1 a which what you may be referencing it
[1:52:22] reference is home loans in the uh at
[1:52:25] that in that paragraph there and it was
[1:52:27] my reference to the home equity type
[1:52:30] loans Senator
[1:52:32] Ybor uh thank you Mr Speaker and
[1:52:38] does so I looked the so the commissioner
[1:52:42] of financial institutions publishes I
[1:52:44] think every week pursuing to this
[1:52:47] statute what the the maximum mortgage
[1:52:51] rate
[1:52:53] that Tennessee you know people that
[1:52:55] issuing mortgages in Tennessee can issue
[1:52:58] right now that's set at
[1:53:02] 88.5% the one that we would be
[1:53:06] adopting which is the what is the rate
[1:53:09] that we use for all other for other
[1:53:11] loans and it's also published on the
[1:53:14] site and that's
[1:53:15] 11.5%
[1:53:18] today uh and I am I I am I'm at least
[1:53:23] hesitant Mr Speaker to uh to do
[1:53:27] something that opens door for mortgage
[1:53:31] rates in the state to be three
[1:53:33] percentage points higher than what they
[1:53:35] are currently so when you think about
[1:53:38] three three points on a 30 or 15 or 30-y
[1:53:41] year mortgage that's that's that's real
[1:53:44] money Mr Speaker that is uh that's the
[1:53:47] difference between people being able to
[1:53:48] afford houses and not and uh we are are
[1:53:52] cautious about doing things that affect
[1:53:55] cost here people's homeowners cost and I
[1:53:58] am I'm at least worried that that we are
[1:54:02] we are opening the door to to a rate
[1:54:04] that doesn't actually reflect the needs
[1:54:07] here uh the the current rate as it's
[1:54:11] set is I mean the more the current
[1:54:14] market rate in Tennesse for what you can
[1:54:18] get with good credit is under
[1:54:20] 7% the one that but the maximum is about
[1:54:24] two points higher so there's still room
[1:54:26] for the market to have higher rates for
[1:54:28] people with less good
[1:54:31] credit but the difference between having
[1:54:34] a maximum set at 8.5 and a maximum set
[1:54:37] at
[1:54:38] 11.5 is a big difference and I I'm I'm
[1:54:43] hesitant to do that today Mr Speaker and
[1:54:45] want to at least Express that caution to
[1:54:47] the body that we should be careful
[1:54:49] before doing something that that could
[1:54:51] lead to people paying higher mortgage
[1:54:54] cost thank you Senator yor Senator
[1:54:56] Oliver you're recognized thank you Mr
[1:54:59] Speaker and um I want to Echo my
[1:55:01] colleagues sentiments and points that
[1:55:04] were raised um regarding interest rates
[1:55:07] in Tennessee um I I find it very
[1:55:11] concerning even though we may phrase
[1:55:13] this bill as a cleanup bill in the
[1:55:15] statute but in reality what this bill
[1:55:18] could do is have really unintended
[1:55:20] consequences in lifting up up um and
[1:55:23] raising the interest rates for people
[1:55:26] who already feel particularly folks in
[1:55:28] my district and Davidson County you
[1:55:31] already feel that home ownership is Out
[1:55:32] Of Reach um because of the rising cost
[1:55:36] of housing right now and so it this puts
[1:55:41] a significant burden where these where
[1:55:44] these interest rates to go up to double
[1:55:46] digits it puts a significant burden on
[1:55:49] families trying to purchase a home in
[1:55:51] Tennessee
[1:55:53] so I just want to raise that concern
[1:55:56] that for large counties in Tennessee uh
[1:55:59] housing is a true problem affordability
[1:56:02] is a problem and this could lead to
[1:56:05] really unintended consequences to have
[1:56:07] mortgage rates in double digits up to
[1:56:10] 11.5% we haven't seen those rates in 30
[1:56:13] years in this state since 1994 so uh I
[1:56:17] just want to raise that caution and that
[1:56:19] and I don't think I can support this
[1:56:21] Bill thank you Mr speak thank you
[1:56:22] Senator
[1:56:23] Oliver any Senator joerger you
[1:56:26] recognized thank you Mr Speaker I
[1:56:28] appreciate the input from my colleagues
[1:56:33] in the Senate and I would be hastened to
[1:56:35] add that the market does fluctuate I
[1:56:38] would not expect the rate to be that
[1:56:39] high at tall for example we put our file
[1:56:42] together just a few days ago the rate
[1:56:43] was
[1:56:45] 7.5% it fluctuates daily and the we are
[1:56:49] only and the rate is affected by uh
[1:56:52] multiple indices and we are changing one
[1:56:55] of those indices to make it more current
[1:56:57] which on the recommendation of the
[1:56:59] mortgage banking industry uh and to I I
[1:57:03] think to suggest the astronomical
[1:57:06] increase that my colleagues have
[1:57:08] suggested is uh
[1:57:12] U uh I I I don't think that comports
[1:57:16] with the facts that as I know them and
[1:57:18] which I have presented to this body uh I
[1:57:21] what I do know is that this will make
[1:57:23] this of subordinate loans more available
[1:57:28] to people in Tennessee for things like a
[1:57:31] a second mortgage on the house uh for
[1:57:33] home equity a home equity loan okay
[1:57:37] Senator Lamar you're
[1:57:41] recognized thank you Mrs speaker will
[1:57:44] the sponsor yield sponsor yields my
[1:57:47] question to the sponsor is currently
[1:57:49] what's the prime rate now and if your
[1:57:51] bill passes with the 4% increase what
[1:57:55] will it then shoot the prime rate up to
[1:57:59] be chairman Jagger You're recognized uh
[1:58:02] I it was uh 7 point it was 7.5 when we
[1:58:06] prepared the file but that was March
[1:58:08] 11th and we're checking now to find the
[1:58:10] answer for the the
[1:58:13] senator today's
[1:58:19] rate Catal Lamar you're recognized asked
[1:58:22] thank you according to the Department of
[1:58:24] financial institutions it is
[1:58:27] 8.5% of the
[1:58:29] annual if I'm not mistaken with his
[1:58:32] legislation it will be a fourpoint jump
[1:58:35] from increase from
[1:58:40] 8.56 that's a lot of money and when we
[1:58:43] thinking
[1:58:44] about folks who are trying to buy homes
[1:58:48] a four point increase in that rate will
[1:58:52] make it unaffordable for people to buy
[1:58:55] homes currently so my suggestion is that
[1:59:00] we don't do this we want to encourage
[1:59:02] home ownership in Tennessee and this
[1:59:05] bill will make it harder for people to
[1:59:07] afford to buy homes thank you thank you
[1:59:10] Senator Lamar any additional questions
[1:59:14] discussion for this
[1:59:17] chair chairman joerger you're
[1:59:20] recognized s senator
[1:59:24] Roberts thank you Mr Speaker if the
[1:59:26] sponsor would yield for a question
[1:59:27] please sponsor yields I may have missed
[1:59:31] this and you may have given an answer to
[1:59:32] it before but but if we're replacing the
[1:59:35] 30-year treasury
[1:59:37] yield uh as the index that we're using
[1:59:40] and replacing it with a 30e average
[1:59:43] Prime offer rate um which one of those
[1:59:47] today is higher than the other and by
[1:59:51] how much
[1:59:53] chairman Jer
[1:59:56] I the average Prime offer rate is I
[2:00:00] don't believe that I said that it was at
[2:00:02] 30 uh uh was at the same rate that the
[2:00:07] uh current 30-year treasury yield would
[2:00:10] be uh the the lower of the two they
[2:00:12] would be close but the lower of the two
[2:00:14] would be the current rate the average
[2:00:16] prime rate Senator Roberts you
[2:00:20] recognized thank you Mr speaker I'm uh
[2:00:23] what I'm trying to do is I'm trying to
[2:00:25] understand because when you look at the
[2:00:26] bill
[2:00:27] itself and you look at the redline
[2:00:29] version of the bill it says the maximum
[2:00:32] effective rate of interest perom is set
[2:00:35] an amount equal and it crosses out two
[2:00:38] percentage points and replaces it with
[2:00:40] four percentage
[2:00:42] points and then it also changes the
[2:00:46] basis that those points are added to so
[2:00:48] in other words we go
[2:00:50] from having
[2:00:52] the
[2:00:53] 30-year treasury yield plus
[2:00:56] two to the 30e average Prime offer rate
[2:01:00] plus four and I'm just trying to
[2:01:03] understand what the difference is
[2:01:04] between those two because that you know
[2:01:08] that's obviously going to be a
[2:01:10] significant amount of money to somebody
[2:01:13] so I'm just trying to understand what
[2:01:15] this Baseline is and how it how how it's
[2:01:19] different Senator Watson your Rec
[2:01:23] recognized thank you Mr Speaker members
[2:01:27] um this has become confusing to members
[2:01:30] and if the sponsor would uh so that we
[2:01:32] can get a a little bit more time to
[2:01:35] understand exactly what's happening here
[2:01:36] if the sponsor would roll this to
[2:01:40] Thursday cator Jagger you're happy to do
[2:01:42] that because we want to make sure
[2:01:44] everybody has a clear understanding the
[2:01:45] bill so I'm very happy to do that that
[2:01:48] objection Thursday next
[2:01:52] Senator low you're
[2:01:54] recognized thank you Mr Speaker uh can I
[2:01:57] be recognized out of
[2:01:59] order that objection you're recognized
[2:02:02] Mr Speaker uh Senate Bill 318 was
[2:02:04] introduced and enacted the Tennessee
[2:02:06] genomic security and IND Orting
[2:02:08] harvesting act and organ harvesting act
[2:02:11] uh Mr Speaker this bill was both on the
[2:02:13] Senate and the house house calendar on
[2:02:14] Monday the house transmitted a message
[2:02:17] with the wrong house bill number after
[2:02:19] it passed as a result the Senate did not
[2:02:21] have the opport Unity to conform and
[2:02:23] substitute to that house bill therefore
[2:02:26] uh the Senate needs to cure this error
[2:02:28] by reconsidering the passage of the bill
[2:02:30] and pass the house version so Mr Speaker
[2:02:32] I move we lift the T from the table the
[2:02:34] motion to reconsider Senate Bill 318 sen
[2:02:38] Senator low moves to LIF from the table
[2:02:41] uh motion is to
[2:02:43] reconsider all those in favor say I
[2:02:46] oppose no the motion prevails Senator
[2:02:50] low you're recognized Mr Speaker speaker
[2:02:52] I move we reconsider Senate Bill 318
[2:02:54] Senator low moves to reconsider Senate
[2:02:56] Bill 318 all those in favor say I I
[2:03:00] oppos no the motion
[2:03:03] prevails Senator L you're recognized
[2:03:06] thank you Mr Speaker I move we conform
[2:03:08] and substitute House Bill
[2:03:11] 395 Senator L moves to conform
[2:03:13] substitute House Bill 395 all those in
[2:03:16] that's a proper motion proper second all
[2:03:18] those in favor say I I oppose no the
[2:03:21] motion
[2:03:24] prevails Senator loow thank you Mr
[2:03:26] Speaker I move passage of House Bill 395
[2:03:29] for third and final consideration that's
[2:03:31] a proper motion proper
[2:03:34] second seeing no discuss Senator Watson
[2:03:37] you're
[2:03:38] recognized thank you just for memory
[2:03:40] purposes can the gentleman just remind
[2:03:42] us I know this bill has already passed
[2:03:44] this body but just remind us exactly
[2:03:45] what we were passing Senator low you're
[2:03:48] recognized thank you Mr Speaker uh the
[2:03:50] house version that we're passing is
[2:03:52] pretty much follows along with the
[2:03:53] Senate version we already passed it is
[2:03:55] the bill that prevents foreign
[2:03:58] adversaries or prevents uh medical
[2:04:01] institutions in the state of Tennessee
[2:04:02] from rendering DNA to foreign
[2:04:04] adversaries for genome mapping or org
[2:04:06] organ harvesting you've heard an
[2:04:09] explanation of the bill any additional
[2:04:12] questions concerning that we are on
[2:04:14] House Bill 395 Senator low renews his
[2:04:17] motion all in favor vote I when the bell
[2:04:19] rings those oppos vote no is every
[2:04:22] member voted is any member wish to
[2:04:24] change their
[2:04:28] vote Mr
[2:04:30] clerk i 27 no NES House Bill 395 had
[2:04:34] received Constitution majority Clarity
[2:04:37] pass without objection motion reconsider
[2:04:39] goes to
[2:04:40] table Senator Hensley you're
[2:04:45] recognized thank you Mr Speaker I move
[2:04:47] to suspend the rules for the immediate
[2:04:50] introduction and consideration of hjr
[2:04:54] 376 this is a resolution to honor and
[2:04:57] congratulate the 2025 mu day quain Kobe
[2:05:02] Fritz you've Senator Henley moves to
[2:05:06] suspend the
[2:05:08] rules for the mediate consideration hjr
[2:05:11] 376 all those in favor say I oppose no
[2:05:15] the eyes carry the rules are suspended
[2:05:17] Senator Hensley moves hjr 376 you've
[2:05:21] heard an explan of
[2:05:23] that all in
[2:05:26] favor say
[2:05:28] I oppos no eyes Carri we
[2:05:33] adopt Mr clerk reports from committees
[2:05:38] reports from chairman Watson you're
[2:05:43] recognized thank you Mr Speaker members
[2:05:45] if it please the Senate I need to
[2:05:47] suspend the rule
[2:05:49] 838 to add the Tennessee Arts commission
[2:05:52] budget hearing that was inadvertently
[2:05:54] left off the finance Ways and Means
[2:05:56] Committee scheduled for tomorrow so uh
[2:05:58] move suspension of rule
[2:06:01] 838 chairman Watson moves to suspend the
[2:06:05] rule
[2:06:07] 838 to allow the Tennessee Arts
[2:06:09] commission be added to finance Ways and
[2:06:11] Means agenda for
[2:06:14] Tuesday that objection all in favor say
[2:06:18] I oppose no the eyes Carri we adopt
[2:06:22] Senator Watson you're recognized thank
[2:06:25] you Mr uh speaker I yield to Chairman
[2:06:28] Hensley uh for an explanation on the uh
[2:06:31] Revenue subcommittee chairman hinley
[2:06:33] you're
[2:06:34] recognized thank you Mr Speaker just
[2:06:36] remind members that the revenue
[2:06:39] subcommittee will meet tomorrow for its
[2:06:41] final meeting of the Year immediately
[2:06:44] following full finance committee please
[2:06:47] note that any bills which the sponsor
[2:06:49] does not show to present in committee or
[2:06:52] any unamended caption bills will be
[2:06:55] referred out to full Finance with a
[2:06:58] negative recommendation thank you Mr
[2:07:00] speaker thank you chairman Hensley
[2:07:01] chairman Stevens you're
[2:07:04] recognized thank you Mr Speaker reminder
[2:07:07] members that the deadline for filing
[2:07:09] appropriation amendments is 2 pm on
[2:07:11] Thursday March
[2:07:13] 27th please file your amendments with
[2:07:16] John cerr in the finance Ways and Means
[2:07:19] office on this St Patrick R's day some
[2:07:22] of you may be thinking that you're going
[2:07:24] to have the Luck of the
[2:07:26] Irish but the value of a fourleaf clover
[2:07:29] ain't what it used to
[2:07:32] be we're on reports from
[2:07:39] committees Senator Crow chairman Crow
[2:07:42] you're recognized
[2:07:54] thank you Mr Speaker I do want to remind
[2:07:57] everyone that the last day to put bills
[2:07:58] on notice for the year in the Senate
[2:08:00] Health and Welfare committee will be
[2:08:02] Wednesday March 19th by 2 pm March 19th
[2:08:05] 2 pm thank
[2:08:08] you we're on reports from
[2:08:11] committees any additional reports I see
[2:08:14] none Mr clerk next item statements and
[2:08:16] announcements statements and
[2:08:18] announcements ler Johnson you're
[2:08:20] recognized thank you Mr Speaker members
[2:08:22] I have a praise report to share with you
[2:08:25] our dear friend and chief
[2:08:26] sergeant-at-arms Ronnie towns wanted to
[2:08:29] extend his gratitude and his thanks for
[2:08:31] your prayers your texts your calls your
[2:08:33] good wishes uh Ronnie underwent surgery
[2:08:36] on Thursday uh he is resting comfortably
[2:08:38] he'll be in the hospital for a little
[2:08:40] while longer but he looks forward to
[2:08:41] getting back here with us as soon as he
[2:08:43] possibly can so please continue to keep
[2:08:45] him in your thoughts and prayers thank
[2:08:47] you Mr speaker thank you Mr leader
[2:08:49] chairman mcy you recognized thank you Mr
[2:08:52] Speaker I've got two announcements um
[2:08:55] tomorrow the capital commission will be
[2:08:57] hosting their breakfast and books um
[2:09:00] from 7:30 to 8:30 and 8C they will have
[2:09:03] a complimentary emboss study B Bible
[2:09:07] with your name and your district and the
[2:09:09] state seal on there for you to pick up
[2:09:12] along with um some breakfast and then on
[2:09:16] Thursday um I'm pleased to announce
[2:09:19] habitat will be having their leg
[2:09:21] islative reception across the hall
[2:09:23] beginning at
[2:09:25] 8:15 and uh as a member of the state
[2:09:29] board I would like to invite everyone to
[2:09:31] go across the hall before they come in
[2:09:33] here uh to um to see their local
[2:09:37] affiliates and to thank habitat for all
[2:09:40] they do Statewide thank you Mr speaker
[2:09:42] thank you chairman Mass M
[2:09:44] Clark speaker we have notice from the
[2:09:46] house Cate Bill 715 by Senator Taylor
[2:09:48] has been returned from the house amended
[2:09:50] and Cate Bill 7 4 by Senator Massie has
[2:09:53] been returned from the house
[2:09:54] amended thank
[2:09:56] you we're on statements and
[2:09:58] announcements any additional ones I see
[2:10:02] none Senator Johnson you're recognized
[2:10:05] forment motion thank you Mr Speaker
[2:10:07] members if there's nothing further for
[2:10:09] the good of the order I move the Senate
[2:10:11] stand in adjournment until 8:30 a.m.
[2:10:13] Thursday next all those in favor is any
[2:10:16] AD journey to 8:30 a.m. Thursday next
[2:10:18] say I all those opposed say no Sen is
[2:10:21] returned to 8:30 a.m. Thursday
[2:10:28] next yes