1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:06,480
Let's start with self-introductions name and your district,

2
00:00:06,480 --> 00:00:09,279
as I call to order this first meeting

3
00:00:09,279 --> 00:00:11,679
in the Dooley Reconstituted Joint Select Committee

4
00:00:11,679 --> 00:00:13,119
on Civic Health.

5
00:00:13,119 --> 00:00:15,320
Senator Mazzall.

6
00:00:15,320 --> 00:00:18,519
Ron Mazall, 10th legislative district.

7
00:00:18,519 --> 00:00:20,280
Senator.

8
00:00:20,280 --> 00:00:23,760
Representative Hall.

9
00:00:23,760 --> 00:00:25,559
Zach Hall represent the fifth list

10
00:00:25,559 --> 00:00:28,320
that a district in East King County.

11
00:00:29,647 --> 00:00:33,048
Tom Dan, that represents the 13th legislative district.

12
00:00:33,048 --> 00:00:34,847
Senator Rachelli.

13
00:00:34,847 --> 00:00:38,807
Senator Marcus Richelli, third legislative districts, Spokane.

14
00:00:38,807 --> 00:00:41,527
Representative Ty.

15
00:00:41,527 --> 00:00:46,188
Meline Ty, representative of the 41st legislative

16
00:00:46,188 --> 00:00:49,768
district, Senator Harris.

17
00:00:49,768 --> 00:00:52,448
Paul Harris, 17th district to East Clark County,

18
00:00:52,448 --> 00:00:53,847
Scamania, Click-A-Tat,

19
00:00:53,847 --> 00:00:56,567
Goldendale, and keeps going.

20
00:00:58,112 --> 00:01:02,192
Sir, when I represented it went even further, went all the way to the Bend County

21
00:01:02,192 --> 00:01:08,671
line. So no complaining. Oh, come on, Come on. Seriously. Representative Simmons.

22
00:01:12,031 --> 00:01:16,912
I representative Simmons from the 23rd legislative district. Welcome one and all.

23
00:01:16,912 --> 00:01:22,671
Thank you. We do in fact have a quorum now. I do want to acknowledge the presence of

24
00:01:23,183 --> 00:01:28,983
Dr. Julia Carboni from the Rockleshouse Center should be making a presentation later.

25
00:01:28,983 --> 00:01:36,924
But before we do that, as a matter of course, I think our authorizing current resolution

26
00:01:36,924 --> 00:01:42,664
requires us to name vice chairs, the one from each chamber.

27
00:01:42,664 --> 00:01:49,183
Last year we had Senator Mazal, thank you, and Representative Darvar.

28
00:01:48,304 --> 00:01:51,304
I have actually talked to a couple of members.

29
00:01:51,304 --> 00:01:52,983
If you all want to go a different direction,

30
00:01:52,983 --> 00:01:56,403
that's entirely up to you and I'm fine on that.

31
00:01:56,403 --> 00:02:01,144
But I thought we should stay consistent with one from each party,

32
00:02:01,144 --> 00:02:07,063
one for each chamber and hopefully some other diversity.

33
00:02:07,063 --> 00:02:11,104
I've reached out and talked about Senator Rachelli and

34
00:02:11,104 --> 00:02:15,144
to Representative Bernard from the House to see if they'd be willing.

35
00:02:15,144 --> 00:02:16,544
They both said yes.

36
00:02:16,800 --> 00:02:22,159
But again, if somebody's got a better idea, that would be fine.

37
00:02:22,159 --> 00:02:26,319
Open into discussion or motion up to you.

38
00:02:26,319 --> 00:02:29,199
I make a motion for those two.

39
00:02:29,199 --> 00:02:30,639
I'll second it.

40
00:02:30,639 --> 00:02:33,199
We'll be seconded that Senator Rachelli

41
00:02:33,199 --> 00:02:37,280
and representing Barnard made named vice chairs.

42
00:02:37,280 --> 00:02:42,319
Is there any further discussion? All those in favor signify by saying aye.

43
00:02:42,319 --> 00:02:43,520
Aye

44
00:02:48,015 --> 00:02:53,616
The ayes have it. Thank you very much. So, especially for the benefit of the new members,

45
00:02:53,616 --> 00:03:00,656
which include reps, hall, tie, and Simmons and Senator Harris, I guess,

46
00:03:02,336 --> 00:03:06,816
I thought that what we would begin with is just kind of an overview of who we are and where we've

47
00:03:06,816 --> 00:03:15,135
come from, so that the members have a bit of a sense of it, is you will all recall

48
00:03:15,711 --> 00:03:22,192
The concurrent resolution extending this was adopted this year and in fact the membership was

49
00:03:22,192 --> 00:03:30,032
expanded because of some prior interest expressed by members. What's important to know is that the

50
00:03:30,032 --> 00:03:38,831
Joint Select Committee is a part of a constellation of efforts to advocate for improved civic health

51
00:03:42,960 --> 00:03:50,960
The most important element of that, perhaps, was the formation of the Project for Civic Health,

52
00:03:50,960 --> 00:03:54,960
which was a partnership between the Office of Lieutenant Governor,

53
00:03:54,960 --> 00:03:58,960
the Evans School at the University of Washington,

54
00:03:58,960 --> 00:04:04,960
the Ruckel's House Center, which is a WSU and UW operation,

55
00:04:04,960 --> 00:04:11,960
and the Henry M. Jackson Foundation. Those four partners were formed actually back in.

56
00:04:11,759 --> 00:04:18,439
in 1923. And an awful lot of the efforts, including the creation of this

57
00:04:18,439 --> 00:04:25,439
General Committee came out of those efforts and those discussions. I want

58
00:04:25,439 --> 00:04:28,959
to back up and give you a sense of all the activities of

59
00:04:29,319 --> 00:04:33,040
the Project for Civic Health, because we are in fact a part of that. They're

60
00:04:33,040 --> 00:04:36,680
not our umbrella entity, but they're kind of at the center of

61
00:04:36,680 --> 00:04:38,040
the spokes of The Wheel.

62
00:04:38,624 --> 00:04:46,384
Uh, we formed then several years ago and conducted two statewide summits on this topic,

63
00:04:46,384 --> 00:04:51,983
the first of which was several hundred people and Rhett and Robert, I don't remember which.

64
00:04:51,983 --> 00:05:00,223
We conducted six intense focus groups of highly diverse participants around the state to get

65
00:05:06,656 --> 00:05:14,415
a report based on all that called Common Ground for the Common Good, which is available to you all.

66
00:05:14,415 --> 00:05:19,136
It's been sent to most of you in the past. I highly recommend it. It is an excellent piece

67
00:05:19,136 --> 00:05:25,935
of work, and very, very sadly, the woman who wrote that, who was a long time fixture in

68
00:05:33,648 --> 00:05:39,848
There was a poll conducted at RBS of attitudes about civic health.

69
00:05:39,848 --> 00:05:43,408
Those results were shared with all the members of the legislature.

70
00:05:43,408 --> 00:05:50,048
It included, sadly, the fact that people self-report that nearly one in four Washingtonians have

71
00:05:50,048 --> 00:05:56,848
stopped speaking altogether to either a friend or a family member, quote, because of politics.

72
00:06:01,728 --> 00:06:08,048
We have a regular newsletter that goes to hundreds of people and organizations throughout the state.

73
00:06:09,487 --> 00:06:15,567
And then some of the most important work I think we've done was to develop the three tenets

74
00:06:16,208 --> 00:06:21,487
of healthy civic engagement. And these have all been communicated to you before, but I want

75
00:06:21,487 --> 00:06:26,848
to remind you what they are because they're our touchstones. They are engaged respectfully,

76
00:06:30,672 --> 00:06:34,672
They disagree constructively.

77
00:06:34,672 --> 00:06:43,672
We in fact have asked for people to sign a pledge affirming their commitment to those three tenants and hundreds and 100s of people have.

78
00:06:43,672 --> 00:06:45,672
They do that through our website.

79
00:06:45,672 --> 00:06:49,672
So some of the things that have come out of.

80
00:06:49,672 --> 00:06:52,672
The project include the joint select committee.

81
00:06:58,704 --> 00:07:14,704
But the acronym stands for Washington collaborative elected leaders Institute. Thank you. The Rockwell's house center directly inspired by the project formulated a plan to work with city council people from throughout the state.

82
00:07:14,704 --> 00:07:21,704
Basically to help them work better across differences and collaborate more effectively.

83
00:07:26,831 --> 00:07:32,031
a resounding success. The University of Washington has formed a civic

84
00:07:32,031 --> 00:07:36,031
health initiative and it's more complicated than I could possibly

85
00:07:36,031 --> 00:07:42,831
explain. Dean Jody Sandford is a part of that.

86
00:07:42,831 --> 00:07:46,911
The Rocosale Center also engages in something called

87
00:07:46,911 --> 00:07:50,591
Communities of Practice, which are regular salons or

88
00:07:50,591 --> 00:07:54,831
group discussions and communities to discuss these kinds of things.

89
00:07:54,959 --> 00:08:02,000
The Joint Select Committee itself, as you will all recall, was the sponsor of orientation

90
00:08:02,000 --> 00:08:09,120
efforts two years ago after the election for new members in which we brought in an excellent

91
00:08:09,120 --> 00:08:15,120
speaker from the Institute for Civil Discourse who had worked with legislatures throughout

92
00:08:15,120 --> 00:08:17,040
the country.

93
00:08:23,375 --> 00:08:28,615
for civic health of the legislature and as such,

94
00:08:28,615 --> 00:08:30,855
an immediate aftermath of

95
00:08:30,855 --> 00:08:33,035
the tragic assassinations of

96
00:08:33,035 --> 00:08:35,735
the elected officials in Minnesota issued

97
00:08:35,735 --> 00:08:38,196
a statement about it.

98
00:08:38,196 --> 00:08:40,895
Looking forward, the project for

99
00:08:40,895 --> 00:08:42,975
civic Health is now out in

100
00:08:42,975 --> 00:08:47,216
the field soliciting micro grant applications,

101
00:08:47,216 --> 00:08:50,495
small two to $5,000 micro grants,

102
00:08:52,303 --> 00:09:08,303
Community groups want to have an event at which they can bring this issue to the forefront in their community and elevate its profile and talk about what is needed, what action steps are needed in order to promote more civic health.

103
00:09:08,303 --> 00:09:17,303
So I just wanted to put all of that in perspective for you that this joint select committee operates within that constellation of efforts.

104
00:09:17,279 --> 00:09:26,279
Inspired by it in park and we kind of frankly have a synergistic fee off of one another effort and sometimes the lines that.

105
00:09:26,279 --> 00:09:41,279
Separate us become pretty blurred because we're all a part of the same overall effort. So with that, I want to just stop and see if any of you have any questions about how we got to where we were at.

106
00:09:49,967 --> 00:09:53,967
I was a tenant governor. Do you say anything? I

107
00:09:53,967 --> 00:10:00,368
was thinking about this. Because I could. There's a couple of things I got. I'm only kidding.

108
00:10:00,368 --> 00:10:05,567
I am only getting. Thank you, Paul.

109
00:10:08,128 --> 00:10:13,488
I have exactly the same question, Senator Harris. That's like seriously, but then it got what.

110
00:10:18,768 --> 00:10:25,967
The 17th legislative district tends to elect the honorees to people being back a very long

111
00:10:25,967 --> 00:10:41,488
period of time. Okay. So, next item of agenda, a presentation by Dr. Carboni. Now, as I said,

112
00:10:45,807 --> 00:10:50,607
One of the ways that that is played out is that there is a group that Julie will explain

113
00:10:51,648 --> 00:10:55,927
that engages in things a thing called Citizens Assembly

114
00:10:56,648 --> 00:11:01,967
They do this all over literally the world, but including in the country and she'll explain that more

115
00:11:02,447 --> 00:11:07,687
They needed somebody to kind of bless it from within state government earlier

116
00:11:08,528 --> 00:11:11,888
And I raised my hand because Julie asked me to

117
00:11:12,687 --> 00:11:14,687
So that she could begin

118
00:11:14,447 --> 00:11:20,607
getting involved in it. But now they are talking with her about the prospect of holding one of

119
00:11:20,607 --> 00:11:33,488
these citizen assemblies in Washington state. And our purpose here today is to see what your

120
00:11:33,488 --> 00:11:39,567
reaction is, to it, and if you've got any particular feedback for Julia,

121
00:11:43,216 --> 00:11:45,216
For such an activity

122
00:11:47,655 --> 00:11:49,895
Ron do you have your hand up or

123
00:11:50,855 --> 00:11:52,696
me, you know

124
00:11:52,696 --> 00:12:00,296
See a white hand there on your no, it's a tree in the background. No, It's in. The foreground. There's oh, I don't have a hand

125
00:12:01,895 --> 00:12:07,615
Yeah, your glasses check lately. Yes, okay. I'm done. Hey, welcome

126
00:12:08,255 --> 00:12:11,615
We are we did self-introductions at the beginning if you

127
00:12:12,111 --> 00:12:16,111
Be so kind. Indicate your name and your legislative district.

128
00:12:20,111 --> 00:12:23,111
Sure, um, for Andy, Donnie, I'm.

129
00:12:23,111 --> 00:12:27,111
We're up in the 44th legislative District in beautiful Snohomish County.

130
00:12:27,111 --> 00:12:30,111
And I am still having technical issues, but I, am here.

131
00:12:30,111 --> 00:12:35,111
We can see you and hear you find and welcome to the joint select committee on civic health.

132
00:12:35,111 --> 00:12:37,111
We are delighted to have you.

133
00:12:37,111 --> 00:12:41,111
Dr. Carboni take it away, please.

134
00:12:41,087 --> 00:12:46,048
All right, I'm going to share my screen, but while I am getting that up,

135
00:12:46,048 --> 00:12:51,567
I just wanted to give you a little bit of context on this presentation.

136
00:12:51,567 --> 00:12:55,087
I promise I will go through fairly quickly.

137
00:12:55,216 --> 00:13:16,216
So last year we were invited to be part of a delegation of states that included Pennsylvania, Utah, Kentucky, and Maryland to learn about citizen assemblies in the United States modeled after some work that's being done in EU, but also in smaller regional governments and Brussels and parts of Belgium.

138
00:13:16,216 --> 00:13:20,216
And I'll talk a little bit more about what a citizen assembly is.

139
00:13:20,048 --> 00:13:26,847
But I served as the designee for the lieutenant governor's office to go and learn about these

140
00:13:26,847 --> 00:13:32,288
citizen assemblies and think about how they might fit into the project for civic health.

141
00:13:32,288 --> 00:13:38,528
And so I'll go through that, but I just want to preface this with, you know,

142
00:13:39,471 --> 00:13:47,192
Part of this comes out of the desire from legislators to have more public participation

143
00:13:47,192 --> 00:13:51,351
as found in the Evans report that the Lieutenant Governor mentioned before.

144
00:13:51,351 --> 00:13:53,231
And so this is another form of public

145
00:13:53,231 --> 00:14:00,432
participation and is not meant to supplant the role of legislators in any way.

146
00:14:00,432 --> 00:14:04,672
And then the other thing I want to say is I'm not asking for money today.

147
00:14:04,672 --> 00:14:08,991
We're just looking for a blessing to potentially move forward with doing some design.

148
00:14:09,248 --> 00:14:13,087
on this. We have some funders who are potentially interested in funding this,

149
00:14:13,087 --> 00:14:17,888
so I just want to say that upfront because I know that we're coming into a very rough budget

150
00:14:17,888 --> 00:14:24,207
environment. So again, why this and why now? The committee's own findings.

151
00:14:24,207 --> 00:14:35,248
So, again the report that was commissioned by the Joint Select Committee on Civic Health.

152
00:14:29,072 --> 00:14:34,432
that was performed by the Evans School found that there was a significant lack of trust both within

153
00:14:34,432 --> 00:14:37,711
the legislature but also between the public and the legislator. And there

154
00:14:37,711 --> 00:14:42,351
was one recommendation that, there needed to be more avenues for public participation

155
00:14:42,991 --> 00:14:47,631
so that folks who weren't just the usual suspects could come and be a part of the

156
00:14:51,024 --> 00:15:06,024
We also thought this was an opportune time because SCR 8406 reauthorizes the committee through January of 2029 and so this could be an opportunity for the joint select committee and civic health to have sort of a signature initiative.

157
00:15:06,024 --> 00:15:20,024
And so what we would like to talk about is a statewide citizens initiative potentially in 2027 that is advisory to the legislature and to this committee on the topic of this community choosing and I'll talk more about that in just a second.

158
00:15:20,495 --> 00:15:23,936
So, what is the Citizens' Assembly?

159
00:15:23,936 --> 00:15:29,336
Often this is confused with things like community assemblies or other types of gatherings that

160
00:15:29,336 --> 00:15:30,735
bring folks together.

161
00:15:30,735 --> 00:15:36,056
A Citizens Assembly is different in that it's a representative group of randomly chosen

162
00:15:36,056 --> 00:15:37,056
people.

163
00:15:39,744 --> 00:15:44,543
public body that they're working with to develop a collective informed proposal on a particular

164
00:15:44,543 --> 00:15:52,703
policy issue. So, for example, in the EU, the most recent EU citizens assembly focused on AI

165
00:15:52,703 --> 00:15:59,183
governance in The European Union, and there were representatives from all European union

166
00:15:59,183 --> 00:16:03,903
member states coming together over a course of time to make recommendations to the

167
00:16:05,679 --> 00:16:11,279
This didn't mean that the EU government had to accept the recommendations instead they received

168
00:16:11,279 --> 00:16:17,440
them and agreed to at least respond to them even if it was we can't do that because of X, Y, and Z.

169
00:16:18,159 --> 00:16:33,159
What was really powerful about this assembly, beyond just engaging people in the public process, was we started to see relationships develop among participants across various nations, including those that have historically not gotten along with each other.

170
00:16:33,159 --> 00:16:41,159
And so they were really modeling these three core tenets of the project for civic health to engage with respect, seek common ground and disagree constructively.

171
00:16:42,607 --> 00:16:54,368
We know from research by Feed A North America and others that this results in lasting improved perceptions of public policy, of government, and of fellow citizens.

172
00:16:54,895 --> 00:17:13,895
And so instead of the assembly starts with a lottery, so selection by sortition, a clear remit or question for the group to consider, and then adequate time typically this occurs in person over a number of weekends or a couple of days together sometimes with virtual pieces in between.

173
00:17:13,895 --> 00:17:17,895
And then we also see as part of this.

174
00:17:18,000 --> 00:17:24,960
a diverse information so often that the participants themselves will make requests of the information

175
00:17:24,960 --> 00:17:30,960
that they might need to make a recommendation. There's shared learning so the groups learn

176
00:17:30,960 --> 00:17:37,440
together and you know whatever sort of preconceived notions they come in with, they learn together

177
00:17:42,880 --> 00:17:48,960
This is a deliberation and not a debate, and the group issues a final report that includes,

178
00:17:50,240 --> 00:17:54,880
you know, how folks felt about the issue as a group, including minority positions.

179
00:17:55,440 --> 00:18:00,000
The final hallmark of this is responsiveness of the legislative or governmental body that

180
00:18:00,000 --> 00:18:04,880
commissioned the report. And again, this isn't about agreeing to do everything that a citizen

181
00:18:04,880 --> 00:18:11,839
assembly says, but it's about creating a relationship with citizens. In examples that we observed,

182
00:18:12,304 --> 00:18:25,304
In Belgium we saw that there were opportunities for legislators to say hey that's not sort of within our set of competencies and this is why we can't address it. So there's also learning about the legislative process that happens.

183
00:18:25,304 --> 00:18:36,304
This has been done over 700 times across the world. It's just starting to catch on in the United States. There's currently is an assembly happening in Connecticut right now.

184
00:18:35,471 --> 00:18:38,832
And then we've had some smaller examples, which I'll talk about in a second, of

185
00:18:38,832 --> 00:18:43,231
where regional, county, or city governments. But what we have seen in 34 countries is an

186
00:18:43,231 --> 00:18:47,551
80,000 plus people have participated in Ireland,

187
00:18:47,551 --> 00:18:53,711
which is most famous example. A citizen assembly actually created a language for

188
00:18:53,711 --> 00:18:57,711
constitutional amendment for referendum for constitutional amendments. What's really

189
00:19:04,880 --> 00:19:11,200
access and on gay marriage and so when the groups got together they didn't necessarily

190
00:19:11,200 --> 00:19:16,079
change the minds of all the people in the group but they did come together and practice these

191
00:19:16,079 --> 00:19:20,480
three principles engaging with respect seeking common ground and disagreeing constructively

192
00:19:21,039 --> 00:19:25,599
and what people said about the process was that they felt like they better understood their

193
00:19:31,008 --> 00:19:36,288
Another notable thing about this is that the person who organized this, his name is Art

194
00:19:36,288 --> 00:19:41,968
O'Leary, so that at the end of their citizen assembly, he had the group of 100 people actually

195
00:19:41,968 --> 00:19:47,647
vote on it to see how they would come out. And it matched the referendum vote of the entire

196
00:19:48,607 --> 00:19:54,367
population of Ireland within a percentage point. So this was pretty representative.

197
00:19:54,367 --> 00:19:58,448
And again, it wasn't to necessarily change people's minds. It was to create language

198
00:20:00,304 --> 00:20:04,223
And then also just set up these these types of relationships. It was wildly successful

199
00:20:04,903 --> 00:20:08,263
And we've also seen this in North America in particularly in Canada

200
00:20:08,544 --> 00:20:14,263
There were some climate citizen assemblies and then we see it in smaller areas cities things like this listed here

201
00:20:15,064 --> 00:20:17,223
repal

202
00:20:17,223 --> 00:20:19,903
Thank you. Is this what Snohomish County just did?

203
00:20:20,912 --> 00:20:33,912
Yes, no, they did a citizen assembly. It was on a much smaller scale. And the report for that will be coming out fairly soon. There were some things that we might do differently.

204
00:20:33,912 --> 00:20:45,912
But yes, this is essentially what they do. They send out the invitations to random sample of the population, and then they brought them together to talk about AI use and snow.

205
00:20:49,615 --> 00:20:52,736
I'm having a hard time on occasion hearing you.

206
00:20:52,736 --> 00:20:58,016
Okay. Let me see if I can make this closer. Is that better?

207
00:20:58,016 --> 00:21:01,016
Yes. We also turned it up on this end.

208
00:21:01,016 --> 00:21:04,016
Oh, okay. I was going to say I won't move, but maybe I'll use your sound.

209
00:21:07,455 --> 00:21:11,776
the version of Citizens Assembly in Snohomish, did you?

210
00:21:11,776 --> 00:21:16,935
We did not conduct the Snuhomich Citizen Assembly.

211
00:21:16,935 --> 00:21:19,895
We do, they did partner with Feed A North America

212
00:21:19,895 --> 00:21:22,935
for the evaluation piece, and so that evaluation

213
00:21:22,935 --> 00:21:24,175
will be coming in soon.

214
00:21:24,175 --> 00:21:27,976
Feed a North Americas, the group that hosted our delegation

215
00:21:27,976 --> 00:21:30,296
with other states to learn about citizen assembly,

216
00:21:30,296 --> 00:21:31,576
so, that's the connection.

217
00:21:32,271 --> 00:21:37,271
And they have expertise and also connections to the FDA Europe.

218
00:21:37,271 --> 00:21:55,271
So why, why Washington? Why civic health? So the lieutenant governor has already outlined quite a bit of this information, which came from the poll, the L.A. research poll and that Washingtonians have seen an increase in sort of.

219
00:21:55,536 --> 00:21:59,855
not civic health, right? So worried about the future of democracy, stop talking to friends and

220
00:21:59,855 --> 00:22:06,016
family. And so sort of as an antidote to that, what we have seen in research on those who've

221
00:22:06,016 --> 00:22:11,695
participated in citizens assemblies and other places is increased trust from government or

222
00:22:11,695 --> 00:22:15,215
in government. So up by almost it's almost doubled.

223
00:22:18,448 --> 00:22:23,728
More empathy for differing perspective. So this is what we're trying to do in the project for civic health. We're not necessarily trying

224
00:22:23,728 --> 00:22:28,208
To change people's minds about how they think about politics or policy issues

225
00:22:28,208 --> 00:22:29,367
But we are trying

226
00:22:29,367 --> 00:22:34,248
To think how can we come together and create these human connections and practice the principles and what?

227
00:22:34,248 --> 00:22:39,208
We've seen over and over again and citizen assemblies as people living these ideals and changing

228
00:22:39,887 --> 00:22:41,087
them in

229
00:22:41,087 --> 00:22:43,488
The process and how? They view government

230
00:22:44,336 --> 00:22:56,336
One thing I just, I want to continue to say is that, you know, the citizen assembly isn't about getting to consensus on an issue. There are votes and the minority views are recorded alongside the majority views.

231
00:22:56,336 --> 00:23:07,336
Washington has had a number of things that have already happened that support sort of doing this now. So there's been a climate assembly.

232
00:23:07,968 --> 00:23:20,968
Which was run by a nonprofit. There was no legislative commitment to respond. But this was fairly successful community assembly where it wasn't a statistically representative sample of the population.

233
00:23:20,968 --> 00:23:25,968
But it was a group that came together in sort of a deliberative process.

234
00:23:33,359 --> 00:23:36,359
Climate Commitment Act and climate change.

235
00:23:36,359 --> 00:23:44,359
Members here were not chosen by lottery until it wasn't a representative sample and there were lots of reasons to do that which I can talk about later.

236
00:23:44,359 --> 00:23:50,359
And then the Snohomish County Assembly on AI was the latest example, which was just touched on a second ago.

237
00:24:02,960 --> 00:24:08,240
the group that comes together as representative of the state of Washington. The other states

238
00:24:08,240 --> 00:24:14,480
that are a part of our delegation with Feed A North America to learn about citizens assemblies

239
00:24:14,480 --> 00:24:20,319
are Maryland, Pennsylvania, Utah, and Kentucky. They are in varying stages of hosting citizen

240
00:24:20,319 --> 00:24:25,920
assemblies in their states, including some capacity building academies with feed A

241
00:24:25,920 --> 00:24:31,200
North American, really learning about designing a question and more about the process.

242
00:24:32,607 --> 00:24:35,647
And so it works, you know, sortition works.

243
00:24:35,920 --> 00:24:42,480
we have random invitation, we invite 10 to 30,000 people hoping to whittle down to 100.

244
00:24:42,480 --> 00:24:47,200
We invite so many people because we want to have a stratified lottery that to make sure that

245
00:24:47,200 --> 00:24:53,279
whatever group comes together is representative of folks in the state of Washington and isn't

246
00:24:53,279 --> 00:24:58,240
over sampled on any particular demographic characteristic. As we saw in The Republic of

247
00:24:58,240 --> 00:25:03,680
Ireland, which has about five and a half million people, 100 people came to the same conclusion

248
00:25:05,231 --> 00:25:09,392
you know, electorate in the state of or in

249
00:25:09,392 --> 00:25:13,511
the country of Ireland. And so if you design the process really well and bring

250
00:25:13,511 --> 00:25:17,551
together a representative sample, you're likely to get results that would yield

251
00:25:17,551 --> 00:25:24,951
to the entire population. So we would want to stratify a number of different

252
00:25:24,951 --> 00:25:29,432
things on the advice of this group and we can talk more about that but we don't

253
00:25:29,432 --> 00:25:31,872
have to know.

254
00:25:30,400 --> 00:25:38,400
So the way this looks, what we're thinking here, and this is completely open to, you know, change.

255
00:25:39,152 --> 00:25:44,112
But we were thinking that it might be a great idea if this group wants to,

256
00:25:44,112 --> 00:25:48,192
as to continue, is to start thinking about what a remit or a question might

257
00:25:48,192 --> 00:25:53,951
be and to do a workshop with Feed A North America late this year to early next year,

258
00:25:53,951 --> 00:25:59,071
and then to actually set in motion the process in spring of 2027 and

259
00:25:59,071 --> 00:26:05,311
then have learning and deliberation sessions over the late spring, early

260
00:26:08,432 --> 00:26:11,271
to the legislature involved 2027.

261
00:26:11,271 --> 00:26:12,672
And again, the legislator,

262
00:26:12,672 --> 00:26:13,951
the committee would receive it,

263
00:26:13,951 --> 00:26:15,832
but would not be bound to saying,

264
00:26:15,832 --> 00:26:17,172
yes, we're going to do everything you said,

265
00:26:17,172 --> 00:26:19,912
but they would just be responsive to it.

266
00:26:20,943 --> 00:26:31,943
So our question today is what is the interest in this type of participatory process, what kinds of questions would you want to representative group of Washingtonians to take up.

267
00:26:31,943 --> 00:26:34,943
And so it could be just broad topics.

268
00:26:34,943 --> 00:26:39,943
And then how would the committee be involved in setting the remit and designing the process.

269
00:26:46,784 --> 00:26:49,403
Also to say that, you know, if you go forward,

270
00:26:49,403 --> 00:26:50,743
this isn't agreeing to do it.

271
00:26:50,743 --> 00:26:51,703
It allows us to go

272
00:26:51,703 --> 00:26:53,864
forward to potential funders to

273
00:26:53,864 --> 00:26:57,624
say the legislature is potentially on board

274
00:26:57,624 --> 00:27:00,304
and we can start designing the process.

275
00:27:01,144 --> 00:27:04,064
Comments.

276
00:27:06,983 --> 00:27:09,463
Bernard, we were doing

277
00:27:09,463 --> 00:27:12,263
self-introductions earlier by district as well.

278
00:27:12,263 --> 00:27:13,743
By the way, congratulations.

279
00:27:13,743 --> 00:27:15,064
You're the new vice chair.

280
00:27:15,503 --> 00:27:18,463
of the joint select meeting of Civic Health.

281
00:27:18,463 --> 00:27:20,663
We elected you in your absence,

282
00:27:20,663 --> 00:27:22,703
maybe because of your absences,

283
00:27:22,703 --> 00:27:28,943
but staff introduction, please, Steph.

284
00:27:28,943 --> 00:27:33,344
Stephanie Barnard, I am House of Representatives

285
00:27:33,344 --> 00:27:34,784
for the 8th Legislative District.

286
00:27:34,784 --> 00:27:36,844
Thank you very much and I apologize.

287
00:27:36,844 --> 00:27:38,983
I struggled to get onto the meeting today.

288
00:27:38,983 --> 00:27:41,144
I don't know what-

289
00:27:40,640 --> 00:27:47,759
the problem was, but I'm glad I am here now. I wasn't added as a panelist until I think it was

290
00:27:47,759 --> 00:27:53,440
like 18 minutes after the hour. So I, I not quite sure what I did wrong. But here I

291
00:27:53,440 --> 00:27:56,160
am now and thank you very much for voting on.

292
00:27:56,160 --> 00:27:58,160
I thought the presentation was great.

293
00:27:58,960 --> 00:28:01,680
I just came back from climate week in New York City.

294
00:28:04,880 --> 00:28:07,220
was so pleased to be invited to

295
00:28:07,220 --> 00:28:09,640
be in New York City and also

296
00:28:09,640 --> 00:28:11,859
pleased serve on the National

297
00:28:11,859 --> 00:28:13,619
Caucus of Environmental Legislators.

298
00:28:13,619 --> 00:28:15,440
It got me thinking about

299
00:28:15,440 --> 00:28:16,279
I was invited

300
00:28:16,279 --> 00:28:18,700
to speak about electrification in front of.

301
00:28:18,700 --> 00:28:21,220
I mean, I can't say that I

302
00:28:21,220 --> 00:28:23,880
was the only Republican but in

303
00:28:23,880 --> 00:28:25,039
New New york for climate wake,

304
00:28:25,039 --> 00:28:28,480
but I felt like it and you know,

305
00:28:30,496 --> 00:28:34,736
but it was such an honor, it's such a honor. So this kind of reminds me of something like that,

306
00:28:34,736 --> 00:28:41,455
where I didn't have a problem. I felt like everyone there was extremely respectful and

307
00:28:41,455 --> 00:28:45,455
they were extremely interested in hearing from someone from the other side of the aisle

308
00:28:46,736 --> 00:28:52,175
about electrification and different environmental issues.

309
00:28:52,175 --> 00:28:55,056
I can't say, you know, I don't use the word,

310
00:28:59,728 --> 00:29:03,627
But I think there are ways of having these conversations.

311
00:29:03,627 --> 00:29:13,048
I'm some of the examples that you had mentioned, Julia, were good.

312
00:29:13,048 --> 00:29:16,768
But we can talk about natural resources,

313
00:29:16,768 --> 00:29:19,048
we talk the environment,

314
00:29:19,048 --> 00:29:21,208
we talked about electrification,

315
00:29:21,208 --> 00:29:23,048
AI data centers, something like that.

316
00:29:23,048 --> 00:29:25,087
Ithink the program that

317
00:29:25,087 --> 00:29:26,768
you've set forward, at least in

318
00:29:26,768 --> 00:29:28,367
the example that is shared with us.

319
00:29:29,200 --> 00:29:32,200
I would love to see something like that happen.

320
00:29:32,200 --> 00:29:36,720
And I think we can do it in a way that can be meaningful

321
00:29:36,720 --> 00:29:40,440
for everyone involved and it doesn't have to be controversial.

322
00:29:40,440 --> 00:29:43,359
I mean, you had brought up the abortion

323
00:29:43,359 --> 00:29:44,519
and I I, I

324
00:29:44,519 --> 00:29:46,240
think that's something we want to avoid.

325
00:29:46,240 --> 00:29:51,240
But, but I do think there are plenty of things like,

326
00:29:51,960 --> 00:29:55,319
I consider myself an environment like I can love the environment.

327
00:29:55,632 --> 00:29:57,672
I want to take good care of it.

328
00:29:57,672 --> 00:30:01,991
I think if we can wrap ourselves around some common ground

329
00:30:01,991 --> 00:30:04,791
and meet and have discussions about potentially

330
00:30:04,791 --> 00:30:07,951
our concerns with AI and data centers or electrification

331
00:30:07,951 --> 00:30:09,192
or whatever the case may be, I

332
00:30:09,192 --> 00:30:11,751
think it's really, really important

333
00:30:11,751 --> 00:30:13,271
to have those conversations.

334
00:30:13,271 --> 00:30:16,271
And I just I had a question for you, Julie,

335
00:30:16,271 --> 00:30:20,471
and that is so you pick from a lottery

336
00:30:20,471 --> 00:30:22,311
and is that of people that.

337
00:30:23,152 --> 00:30:26,672
like voters or how do you, how is that lottery,

338
00:30:26,672 --> 00:30:32,352
how you pick or who's the lottery made up of? That's my question.

339
00:30:32,352 --> 00:30:37,791
So the lot of is made-up of voters from across the state and it's possible that we could do

340
00:30:37,791 --> 00:30:46,832
adult Washingtonians and we would then send an invitation out and

341
00:30:47,344 --> 00:30:53,663
you would get responses back and we would then take those responses and stratify the sample to

342
00:30:53,663 --> 00:30:58,703
make sure that we had representation from all 39 counties and then we can decide what other

343
00:30:58,703 --> 00:31:03,743
demographic characteristics we might want to sample on to make that sure we were representing

344
00:31:03,743 --> 00:31:10,064
the state of Washington so the group looks like the State. So voters and people that actually voted

345
00:31:13,375 --> 00:31:24,375
Dr. Carbone, before we get to Rep. Paul and Rep Pie, who have their hands up, just to make sure that people understand what the expectation is here.

346
00:31:24,375 --> 00:31:33,375
Two questions. One, there was that graphic on the bottom of one of your slides that said we're not asking for any money today.

347
00:31:39,647 --> 00:31:44,387
Some point because they got no money just to be clear. I've heard that

348
00:31:46,248 --> 00:31:47,748
We're not asking for money

349
00:31:47,748 --> 00:31:50,867
So we have been doing some fundraising around this and we

350
00:31:50,867 --> 00:31:55,548
Have a couple of funders who are interested in doing this potentially as a pilot in Washington state

351
00:31:55,788 --> 00:31:58,748
The idea is that you know this type of innovative

352
00:32:00,336 --> 00:32:15,336
The thing that the state hasn't done before is probably best suited for philanthropy to fund in the beginning and that if the State really thinks this is worthwhile and meaningful could potentially fund it in future, but we're not looking for that right now.

353
00:32:15,336 --> 00:32:16,336
We will do it.

354
00:32:16,336 --> 00:32:20,336
Or this citizens assembly, you're, not, looking, for any money.

355
00:32:20,336 --> 00:32:23,336
No, no money to.

356
00:32:23,336 --> 00:32:26,336
Aside from.

357
00:32:26,336 --> 00:32:28,336
This committee's.

358
00:32:29,584 --> 00:32:32,624
on development of the remit as an example.

359
00:32:32,624 --> 00:32:41,023
Is there an expectation that members would have to attend these multiple meetings as well?

360
00:32:41,023 --> 00:32:43,423
No, not necessarily. I mean,

361
00:32:43,423 --> 00:32:45,023
there have been models where that happened.

362
00:32:45,023 --> 00:32:47,824
So in Brussels, regional government,

363
00:32:48,096 --> 00:32:50,256
the folks do attend, the legislators do

364
00:32:50,256 --> 00:32:52,016
attend and part of that is to build

365
00:32:52,016 --> 00:32:53,855
relationships and help educate folks on

366
00:32:53,855 --> 00:32:56,336
the legislative process. But we could

367
00:32:56,336 --> 00:32:57,855
definitely design it without and so

368
00:32:57,855 --> 00:32:59,296
between the Ruckel's House Center and

369
00:32:59,296 --> 00:33:00,736
our Project for Civic Health Corps

370
00:33:00,736 --> 00:33:02,976
partners we can design the process

371
00:33:02,976 --> 00:33:04,895
under your advisement. They wouldn't have

372
00:33:04,895 --> 00:33:06,895
to if they didn't want to. No.

373
00:33:06,895 --> 00:33:08,895
Doesn't come with the package. Rep. Hall.

374
00:33:12,096 --> 00:33:14,096
Yeah thank you. I think it's a really

375
00:33:14,400 --> 00:33:19,519
Interesting idea worth exploring. It reminds me a lot of, you know, I come to the legislature by way of

376
00:33:20,400 --> 00:33:25,839
the Esterquosity Council and we did a lotta community task forces where this sounds very similar

377
00:33:25,839 --> 00:33:31,599
where we would stand up a task force for a particular issue. We did three while I was on council,

378
00:33:31,599 --> 00:33:38,000
one around long-term capital financing for like buildings, another around

379
00:33:38,784 --> 00:33:51,784
a particular building and we would it's not representative so it was not randomly selected as people would apply and then there would be specific remit set by the city council and the group.

380
00:33:51,680 --> 00:33:55,519
would come up with the process by which they'll make decisions, things like that, like all of that

381
00:33:55,519 --> 00:34:00,720
is kind of left up to them and then a recommendation is then sent to the legislative body. And we

382
00:34:00,720 --> 00:34:06,480
always found that really helpful and interesting. I think the only caution that I see in this space,

383
00:34:06,480 --> 00:34:11,039
and again, I thing is a great idea. We should we should look into it more is

384
00:34:13,599 --> 00:34:18,719
anyone who has done this before, is there ever the temptation just outsource some of like the

385
00:34:20,447 --> 00:34:25,407
We are the legislature, right? We're selected by the voters to dig into the big problems,

386
00:34:25,407 --> 00:34:31,728
right. So I think just making sure we're aware of that tension maybe would be helpful, like

387
00:34:31,728 --> 00:34:35,327
making, sure, we are not taking the biggest problems and saying, you know what,

388
00:34:35,327 --> 00:34:39,807
we just going to take this out of our responsibility and give it to someone else.

389
00:34:39,807 --> 00:34:42,208
Because that's why we were paid to answer big questions.

390
00:34:44,559 --> 00:34:48,480
I was going to say this isn't meant to supplant the legislature at all, but it's just, you know,

391
00:34:48,480 --> 00:34:53,039
it is an opportunity to get more feedback. And so the issues that rep Bernard mentioned are

392
00:34:53,039 --> 00:34:58,239
certainly big ones in the state of Washington where it might be useful to hear citizens.

393
00:35:06,704 --> 00:35:11,704
I am supportive of the idea. I wanted to start with that.

394
00:35:11,704 --> 00:35:20,704
I have have various conversation with you lieutenant governors and just kind of like a quick touch base with Dr.

395
00:35:31,295 --> 00:35:39,775
Bellevue which occupy both the 41st and the 48th legislative district. The latest information that

396
00:35:45,023 --> 00:35:54,063
eligible voters are deemed born outside the United States, outside, like born in another country,

397
00:35:55,103 --> 00:36:01,264
and in my conversation through various engagement, whether through the CDAPL view,

398
00:36:03,599 --> 00:36:12,000
other non-profits really looking at the ideas of feeding kids, feeding elders, all of that.

399
00:36:12,000 --> 00:36:20,639
We've learned that people believe civics mean following the laws, stay away from cops.

400
00:36:23,039 --> 00:36:25,440
And that's that, and that civicks.

401
00:36:25,695 --> 00:36:30,335
and live peacefully.

402
00:36:30,335 --> 00:36:34,815
And I have shared with both you and Dr. Capone

403
00:36:34,815 --> 00:36:38,856
that I had the interest of organizing

404
00:36:38,856 --> 00:36:41,896
within the east side of King County,

405
00:36:42,896 --> 00:36:47,255
really the question of what is civics

406
00:36:47,255 --> 00:36:50,416
and how do we engage in that conversation

407
00:36:50,416 --> 00:36:51,255
so that

408
00:36:51,887 --> 00:36:58,268
up and down across how do we move that conversation so we have more

409
00:36:58,268 --> 00:37:07,128
season engaging and so I am I'm very interested in the idea and I would love

410
00:37:07,128 --> 00:37:14,447
for us to really digging in and figuring out how to engage up

411
00:37:12,800 --> 00:37:19,760
public because we are simply the representative of the public and if we don't get a public that

412
00:37:19,760 --> 00:37:29,599
engage with us, then all of a sudden, from my perspective, we do not truly represent the large

413
00:37:34,735 --> 00:37:50,735
And so, one thing I would say about that is that the Citizen Assembly can definitely help with that engagement, but the Ruckles Health Center will also have a toolkit for legislators sometime in October on public engagement that it is not necessarily as formal of a process with

414
00:38:04,320 --> 00:38:07,320
How to better engage with folks in your districts.

415
00:38:07,320 --> 00:38:09,320
Senator, Charlie.

416
00:38:09,320 --> 00:38:14,320
Thank you, Mr 10 governor.

417
00:38:14,320 --> 00:38:19,320
I think I have some similar comments to wrap tie.

418
00:38:19,320 --> 00:38:24,320
Around the civic engagement piece, but I was just wondering, along with this.

419
00:38:24,320 --> 00:38:28,320
I mean, it's a great tool to then again, maybe educate folks who aren't even

420
00:38:28,320 --> 00:38:33,320
participating who don't react to self selecting in.

421
00:38:34,175 --> 00:38:40,896
I think in addition to respectful discourse and just having a broader discussion on what

422
00:38:40,896 --> 00:38:45,615
the public square is and what is our kind of shared commitment to that, I

423
00:38:45,615 --> 00:38:48,255
think one of the interesting pieces by doing this I

424
00:38:48,255 --> 00:38:53,775
think you have also a hope to talk about the why, not just to get good feedback from

425
00:38:53,775 --> 00:39:00,735
folks who maybe aren't engaging as much as they should be or want to be because of barriers but

426
00:39:02,880 --> 00:39:06,719
our collective commitment. I think we've kind of

427
00:39:06,719 --> 00:39:09,599
strayed away from this and it seems like a good tool

428
00:39:09,599 --> 00:39:14,079
to also spur that on. So I'd be interested in that piece as well

429
00:39:14,079 --> 00:39:16,400
because there's a whole bunch of people that won't, if it, you know, I don't know

430
00:39:16,400 --> 00:39:19,440
how big the ascent, it sounds like, generally for something like this,

431
00:39:19,440 --> 00:39:21,920
you'd need to be trying to get to like 100 people. Is that what I heard?

432
00:39:21,920 --> 00:39:22,559
Yeah, yeah.

433
00:39:22,559 --> 00:39:23,679
So there are tons of

434
00:39:23,679 --> 00:39:26,480
people, like why are they even doing this

435
00:39:26,480 --> 00:39:29,440
Washington state? So that's, that was kind

436
00:39:32,768 --> 00:39:40,168
I think the topic is something that would be really interesting for this group to try

437
00:39:40,168 --> 00:39:41,168
and navigate through.

438
00:39:41,168 --> 00:39:42,168
Yeah.

439
00:39:42,168 --> 00:39:43,168
Thank you.

440
00:39:43,168 --> 00:39:45,128
Senator Harris, you had your hand up.

441
00:39:45,128 --> 00:39:46,128
Yes.

442
00:39:46,128 --> 00:39:47,927
Thank You Lieutenant Governor.

443
00:39:47,927 --> 00:39:53,128
I wasn't sure as kind of where Marcus or Senator Rachelli was going at the end is the

444
00:39:53,128 --> 00:39:55,807
topic to me is of interest.

445
00:39:55,807 --> 00:40:00,447
Representative Barnard mentioned a couple things, but I have a data center in my area

446
00:40:01,679 --> 00:40:06,059
construction that had its own power that was producing, it's going to produce its

447
00:40:06,059 --> 00:40:08,280
own, power. It was a hydro project that

448
00:40:08,280 --> 00:40:12,519
was going pump water up in self-storage and water from the Columbia River.

449
00:40:12,519 --> 00:40:18,300
It's very self sustaining. Data centers to me would be an interesting topic. So

450
00:40:18,300 --> 00:40:26,519
they stopped what they were going do to do, due to last session, and are going

451
00:40:30,688 --> 00:40:44,688
Uh, I think the misunderstanding, uh, at least on my end, um, as I studied more at every golf course uses as much water as a data center and I'm a golfer I maybe we should start shutting down golf courses. I don't know. Um, so,

452
00:40:44,688 --> 00:40:45,688
um.

453
00:40:45,688 --> 00:40:51,688
I just think that that, that to me is an interesting topic. So just one of many, and sure.

454
00:40:51,688 --> 00:40:52,688
Yeah, definitely.

455
00:41:00,208 --> 00:41:05,208
interest in this overall idea.

456
00:41:05,208 --> 00:41:13,208
And so I want to quickly go through those that haven't spoken and just get an indication from rep debt.

457
00:41:15,208 --> 00:41:22,208
Thank you, Lieutenant Governor. So, you know, I find an interesting concept and I agree with actually everyone who has spoken here.

458
00:41:24,896 --> 00:41:30,896
You know, one is how are we going to engage folks who right now absolutely don't trust the government and even more

459
00:41:30,896 --> 00:41:35,976
They don t trust us as legislators, okay, and and no matter what seemed like what we do

460
00:41:35,976 --> 00:41:38,936
They'll find a reason that we should be thrown out somehow

461
00:41:39,016 --> 00:41:44,815
But and I don' t know how we open those lines of communication and maybe this is a way

462
00:41:44,815 --> 00:41:47,235
I'm sitting here thinking about how can we

463
00:41:47,775 --> 00:41:54,775
Uh, do this, uh, not for carbonyl, and get people who engage with us and tell us what's really happening within themselves.

464
00:41:54,775 --> 00:41:55,775
Uh.

465
00:41:55,775 --> 00:42:06,775
Uh and that would be my concern. So I have a town hall in a, in where I live in Moses Lake and 30,000 plus people here and 20 people show up.

466
00:42:06,775 --> 00:42:07,775
Okay.

467
00:42:07,775 --> 00:42:09,775
I am a Town Hall in.

468
00:42:10,447 --> 00:42:15,648
Cleallum where there's I don't know less than 2,000 people live and there'll be 200 people show up

469
00:42:15,728 --> 00:42:21,547
Okay, so how do you how you get around that people in the small rural areas need to be more engaged in their country?

470
00:42:21,547 --> 00:42:26,887
And what is going on than the people and the cities and that's but our majority of people living in urban areas, right?

471
00:42:26,887 --> 00:42:33,768
So how did we correct that nut I that that concerns me and and I was sitting here thinking oh

472
00:42:35,327 --> 00:42:38,847
You know, we want to do something like this. So, how we take

473
00:42:39,168 --> 00:42:46,847
ourselves as a body and use that as an example to the people we want to come

474
00:42:46,847 --> 00:42:51,088
and explain this idea to. How do we show them that we're doing what we

475
00:42:51,088 --> 00:42:56,927
want them to do? You know, does that make sense a little bit?

476
00:42:56,927 --> 00:42:59,887
Yeah, absolutely.

477
00:42:59,280 --> 00:43:03,840
Yeah, and I think that, you know, a lot of this comes down to the design and the technical

478
00:43:03,840 --> 00:43:07,039
expertise to get folks in the room and then to keep them there.

479
00:43:07,039 --> 00:43:11,840
Another thing that I didn't say but is usually a part of the equation is that folks are compensated

480
00:43:11,840 --> 00:43:18,000
for their time as part this and so that becomes incentive to bring folks to that table.

481
00:43:23,088 --> 00:43:30,407
could be another another thing that we say here's how we rebuild civic health, right? And, you know, part of it is we've worked with electives. We've

482
00:43:30,407 --> 00:43:35,088
worked, um, with community leaders, and this is going to, to the public.

483
00:43:36,967 --> 00:43:38,088
Senator Missal.

484
00:43:40,527 --> 00:43:45,447
Well, my mind's kind of running all over the place on this. I think this

485
00:43:45,447 --> 00:43:46,847
is a great platform.

486
00:43:48,271 --> 00:43:52,271
We really have a big job of public education.

487
00:43:52,271 --> 00:43:55,271
A lot of people don't understand what we do.

488
00:43:55,271 --> 00:43:58,271
They don t understand how government works.

489
00:43:58,271 --> 00:44:04,271
And they are quick to run to their corners and just shout.

490
00:44:04,271 --> 00:44:07,271
So I think this is a great opportunity.

491
00:44:07,271 --> 00:44:13,271
The challenge is going to be how to expand this from 100 people to 8 million.

492
00:44:13,903 --> 00:44:21,583
That's where we really, that's our goal in the end is $8 million.

493
00:44:21,583 --> 00:44:25,583
So, rep Donahue.

494
00:44:25,583 --> 00:44:28,784
Thank you.

495
00:44:28,784 --> 00:44:31,623
Oh, sorry.

496
00:44:31,623 --> 00:44:40,704
I had similar concerns to Representative Dent on how we get people to trust us to be willing

497
00:44:42,239 --> 00:44:48,079
I do like the fact that there is compensation for participation.

498
00:44:48,079 --> 00:44:56,239
I'm wondering if it's done in a way that helps mitigate some of the challenges

499
00:44:56,239 --> 00:45:00,239
for people to participate or if its...

500
00:45:01,103 --> 00:45:08,204
So what I'm thinking is if you've got children and you need child care is is whatever is offered to participate?

501
00:45:08,664 --> 00:45:14,463
sufficient to be able to actually have that childcare or does it only actually

502
00:45:17,103 --> 00:45:22,304
Benefit those who already don't have those barriers in place, so I am a little curious about

503
00:45:24,143 --> 00:45:26,143
How

504
00:45:25,295 --> 00:45:30,976
how we'd handle equity within there to make sure that everybody has a voice and also just,

505
00:45:30,976 --> 00:45:34,735
you know, sometimes the people that we need to hear from the most are the ones who trust us the

506
00:45:34,735 --> 00:45:41,295
least and back to um, reference point, getting them to trust is to actually be willing to participate

507
00:45:41,295 --> 00:45:45,856
seems like it could be difficult and so I'm just curious how that would happen. Overall, I think

508
00:45:45,856 --> 00:45:49,695
it's a great idea to get as many people in a room as possible who are willing have a conversation

509
00:45:52,255 --> 00:45:58,856
I know somebody who was involved in the project in Snohomish County and she will not stop talking about it.

510
00:45:58,856 --> 00:46:04,135
Like, it was really a positive experience for her to be able to

511
00:46:04,135 --> 00:46:08,695
be in a room full of other people who were just people.

512
00:46:11,335 --> 00:46:14,655
It made her feel like she was more of the process, part of

513
00:46:14,655 --> 00:46:19,056
the progress and had a voice and I think that did that for a lot of people

514
00:46:20,079 --> 00:46:24,280
And, and so many have lost that lately. So, overall, I think it's a good idea. I

515
00:46:24,280 --> 00:46:31,079
think there's some probably little bits that I'd be concerned about. But, um, yeah, no,

516
00:46:31,079 --> 00:46:36,480
yeah. Cool. And I would say, like, we would,

517
00:46:36,480 --> 00:46:39,199
we will work those into a proposal, the equity issues,

518
00:46:39,199 --> 00:46:40,719
the sort of how do you get people to trust.

519
00:46:40,719 --> 00:46:44,559
And so we're looking for the blessing to like write that up and present it to you.

520
00:46:49,360 --> 00:46:51,679
It reminds me of my new favorite adage.

521
00:46:51,679 --> 00:46:58,920
I had the great privilege last week to hang around on multiple occasions, retired Secretary

522
00:46:58,920 --> 00:47:06,159
of Defense and four-star General Jim Mattis from Tri-Cities, who quoted a Mid-Eastern

523
00:47:06,159 --> 00:47:15,480
proverb, trust walks into the room, but gallops out by which it's slow to build.

524
00:47:17,967 --> 00:47:21,967
Final word on the overall rep Simmons.

525
00:47:21,967 --> 00:47:28,967
Hi, thank you for having me and I'm excited to join this.

526
00:47:28,967 --> 00:47:40,967
I, you know, just got back. Actually, I went to Philadelphia with one of my Republican colleagues and we were in a three day intensive policy discussion.

527
00:47:41,023 --> 00:47:47,583
on very controversial issues and trying to find common ground and one of the things that came up

528
00:47:47,583 --> 00:47:53,264
is that, you know, politics were like politicians and there's so many external pressures

529
00:47:54,224 --> 00:48:01,903
on us and the role of, y'know, campaigns and things like that really impact what we're trying

530
00:48:01,903 --> 00:48:07,744
to do here. And at that convening though, there was no video recording,

531
00:48:10,592 --> 00:48:17,952
a place where we could actually build trust and be honest and talk to each other. And, you know,

532
00:48:17,952 --> 00:48:24,992
even here today, like TBW is here, so sometimes it limits our ability to really talk about the

533
00:48:24,992 --> 00:48:30,512
issues and the role of external pressures in finding common ground when,

534
00:48:31,152 --> 00:48:37,952
you other people are watching, for example. So I hope that there's safe places for people to engage.

535
00:48:38,480 --> 00:48:43,840
and talk about, you know, the world that we want and how we find common ground without

536
00:48:45,360 --> 00:48:47,280
in light of the external pressures that

537
00:48:47,280 --> 00:48:52,639
we face as elected officials as well. I think that's really important and I hope we can

538
00:48:52,639 --> 00:48:55,679
have those conversations in an honest way without,

539
00:48:57,280 --> 00:49:06,320
you Know, other people watching, so.

540
00:49:00,480 --> 00:49:05,440
Yeah, that'll be part of the design and that's one of things we would do a little bit differently than Snohomish County and we

541
00:49:05,440 --> 00:49:10,840
would not invite the media and at the outset that there might be opportunities later once the group has gelled. But yeah,

542
00:49:10,840 --> 00:49:12,199
that definitely consideration.

543
00:49:12,224 --> 00:49:13,224
Thank you.

544
00:49:13,224 --> 00:49:17,503
Rep. Simmons, you and I will take offline our slightly different perspectives on the

545
00:49:17,503 --> 00:49:22,103
constructive role that TVW has played in the life of the legislature.

546
00:49:22,103 --> 00:49:26,264
No, no, I love TV W, the tenant, Governor Heck,

547
00:49:26,264 --> 00:49:28,704
I do and you're like a founder and

548
00:49:28,704 --> 00:49:32,943
I loved it and yeah, watch TV w all the time.

549
00:49:32,943 --> 00:49:34,503
It's the only channel I want.

550
00:49:34,503 --> 00:49:37,184
Okay, okay, just kidding.

551
00:49:37,184 --> 00:49:38,864
Here's what I hear.

552
00:49:40,496 --> 00:49:45,496
That is a general concept. This group is supportive of pursuing this idea.

553
00:49:45,496 --> 00:49:52,496
My question to you, Dr. Carbone is what would be the next steps. I also think in here.

554
00:49:52,496 --> 00:50:00,496
That engaging this group in developing the question or the remit, as you call it, term of art.

555
00:50:00,496 --> 00:50:04,496
Would be something that they would like to do. We don't have time to.

556
00:50:06,128 --> 00:50:11,128
But what would you suggest for next steps going forward?

557
00:50:11,128 --> 00:50:14,128
So we will write up a proposal,

558
00:50:14,128 --> 00:50:16,128
including how we might come to remit.

559
00:50:16,128 --> 00:50:20,128
And we'll do that in partnership with our colleagues at Feed A North America.

560
00:50:20,128 --> 00:50:23,128
We'll come back to this group for the next step,

561
00:50:23,128 --> 00:50:28,128
including potentially a workshop on building that remitt to make sure it's reflective of the group.

562
00:50:28,128 --> 00:50:35,128
But next up is we're be in touch with the proposal as to how this will work and what's next.

563
00:50:35,344 --> 00:50:39,304
Thank you very much, Dr. Cardboardin, very,

564
00:50:39,304 --> 00:50:40,503
very munch.

565
00:50:40,503 --> 00:50:45,184
So we have one final item of business to come before us

566
00:50:45,184 --> 00:50:46,744
that I wanted to bring before you,

567
00:50:46,744 --> 00:50:54,864
which is the idea of this group co-signing a letter

568
00:50:54,864 --> 00:50:59,503
to the Fort Caucus leadership and administrative leadership,

569
00:50:59,503 --> 00:51:00,903
basically,

570
00:51:00,896 --> 00:51:27,896
Advocating, affirming, supporting the idea that new member orientation at a minimum going forward should always include some effort at working across differences like we did two years ago when we brought in the Institute for civil discourse.

571
00:51:27,728 --> 00:51:33,967
It's my point of view, frankly, that in order for us to achieve this, in a political culture,

572
00:51:33,967 --> 00:51:37,648
which isn't particularly incentivizing that, which we seek,

573
00:51:37,648 --> 00:51:42,447
that it's something that we have to embed in the culture of this place.

574
00:51:42,447 --> 00:51:47,168
And one of the ways to do that is to regularly remind people,

575
00:51:47,168 --> 00:51:53,648
this should be a part of how we instruct new members as they arrive,

576
00:51:56,800 --> 00:52:00,400
and uphold the institution.

577
00:52:00,400 --> 00:52:03,239
I would propose, if you all are in favor of that, that I

578
00:52:03,239 --> 00:52:07,440
would write a draft letter and circulate it to you,

579
00:52:07,440 --> 00:52:09,760
but it would be of a general nature.

580
00:52:09,760 --> 00:52:13,159
I don't think that we should be micromanaging

581
00:52:13,159 --> 00:52:16,519
the exact approach that either the chambers take

582
00:52:16,519 --> 00:52:18,639
and they do take different approaches,

583
00:52:18,639 --> 00:52:22,760
but that the general concept be one that is supportive.

584
00:52:22,760 --> 00:52:23,760
Senator Ricelli?

585
00:52:24,496 --> 00:52:31,135
Yeah, I'm very supportive. I just wanted to add I do also think there's a gap to think when we're talking about the two

586
00:52:31,135 --> 00:52:36,976
There's no number of appointees that come in that I that we see just in general orientation get lost

587
00:52:36,976 --> 00:52:39,936
So I'd just I like to put that in the back of our minds about how we

588
00:52:40,655 --> 00:52:45,856
Try to is that they get rolled forward maybe to this next one because they didn't have that opportunity

589
00:52:45,856 --> 00:52:50,496
So, just, i just flag that um as a good. Thank you. We can yeah

590
00:52:53,487 --> 00:53:04,447
Rob Ty? Yes, I just wanted to share just in case this information has not been shared with you,

591
00:53:04,447 --> 00:53:10,367
at least in the House. As you know, Lieutenant Governor, in The House, we do, especially,

592
00:53:12,032 --> 00:53:20,192
House as a whole, but in the House Democratic Caucus, we do have very specific and well-runed.

593
00:53:20,192 --> 00:53:28,251
In fact, our team just present at NCSL to share at the national space of how we welcome and

594
00:53:36,559 --> 00:53:45,139
here after the election, of course, and as you might know, the House in the last three

595
00:53:45,139 --> 00:53:54,119
years has formed what we call an ESJ team, equity and social justice team working to ensure

596
00:53:59,695 --> 00:54:04,496
thought through of how to answer the very question, supporting

597
00:54:04,496 --> 00:54:08,416
legislators so that they become successful at what they do

598
00:54:08,416 --> 00:54:13,976
representing their people. So that is in the process that we

599
00:54:13,976 --> 00:54:19,856
are currently working to to write it out, share with our

600
00:54:19,856 --> 00:54:21,175
caucus members.

601
00:54:21,648 --> 00:54:24,927
So I want you to have that in the sense of the work

602
00:54:24,927 --> 00:54:26,967
in The House Democratic Caucus.

603
00:54:26,967 --> 00:54:31,527
And I am not in opposing potentially have

604
00:54:31,527 --> 00:54:36,608
that letter, but I would say maybe more conversation

605
00:54:36,608 --> 00:54:41,608
with the team that's working on that proposal going forward.

606
00:54:43,608 --> 00:54:44,447
Thank you.

607
00:54:44,447 --> 00:54:45,288
Rep Donahy.

608
00:54:50,159 --> 00:54:53,159
Thank you. I just wanted to know for what Senator

609
00:54:53,159 --> 00:54:58,760
Rachelet was speaking about rolling into them for a point to use rolling

610
00:54:58,760 --> 00:55:01,960
into the next class. That's kind of what we're doing now. You'll get an

611
00:55:01,960 --> 00:55:08,880
abbreviated an abbreviate orientation if you come in in between in

612
00:55:08,880 --> 00:55:14,719
between year and then the majority of that stuff does happen with the

613
00:55:14,719 --> 00:55:19,679
next last coming in. So that is how it's set up right now or at least

614
00:55:19,887 --> 00:55:25,248
that because that's what happened when I came in and that is what I keep saying going on. So I think

615
00:55:25,807 --> 00:55:31,487
in that respect, we would be good at making sure that everybody was still lived into it.

616
00:55:33,248 --> 00:55:33,967
Thank you.

617
00:55:35,056 --> 00:55:39,335
But thank you, uh, so I think it's a great idea to do that

618
00:55:39,335 --> 00:55:42,795
You know the biggest concern that I see with all of us

619
00:55:43,456 --> 00:55:49,016
Or with how the how to bodies function is we have new people come in and they've never been here

620
00:55:49,016 --> 00:55:53,376
And so they'd been off the campaign trail and on campaign Trail is different than being a legislator

621
00:55:53,376 --> 00:55:57,496
Okay, and so, they think that's what a legislature is is to throw rocks all the time

622
00:55:57,735 --> 00:56:04,615
So I thank doing something like this, but you know and also how do we how we pair people up?

623
00:56:04,992 --> 00:56:08,152
with a mentor. I was just thinking, what if you had a

624
00:56:08,152 --> 00:56:11,871
mentor from across the Ohio when you first came in to spend the

625
00:56:11,871 --> 00:56:16,512
first week with to talk about how this place works. And I

626
00:56:16,512 --> 00:56:22,032
remember my first few weeks in the legislature, everybody in

627
00:56:22,032 --> 00:56:24,911
the body reached out and said, if he needed anything.

628
00:56:25,231 --> 00:56:38,231
We're here to help you. Uh, I don't see that so much now with some of the newer members that may be something like it. I just think it's an excellent idea to encourage communication and collaboration between the all the members.

629
00:56:38,231 --> 00:56:44,231
I like thank you for the comments.

630
00:56:44,231 --> 00:56:49,231
Does anybody have any strong reservations about this?

631
00:56:54,384 --> 00:57:04,384
I'm going to ask for a show of hands of those of you who would support me drafting a letter and circulating it to you along the lines that I have attempted to describe.

632
00:57:04,384 --> 00:57:09,384
If you think that's a good idea, would you raise your hand please.

633
00:57:09,384 --> 00:57:13,384
Okay, thank you very very much.

634
00:57:13,384 --> 00:57:17,384
That was all that was on our formal agenda. I want to open it up.

635
00:57:17,384 --> 00:57:21,384
You're looking to be doing this something.

636
00:57:23,376 --> 00:57:29,615
I want to open it up in case anybody has any questions or comments about anything

637
00:57:29,615 --> 00:57:34,576
in general. We're at the bewitching hour but then again we started a couple of minutes late.

638
00:57:38,815 --> 00:57:41,856
I just wanted to ask if rep dent would be my mentor.

639
00:57:45,695 --> 00:57:46,896
You could do better.

640
00:57:50,239 --> 00:57:54,719
Hey, I got, but I gotta tell a little story about that. When I was first there on a senator,

641
00:57:54,719 --> 00:58:00,719
Shelley came to me and he had this bill around this, the medical school in Spokane around WSU.

642
00:58:00,719 --> 00:58:01,679
And he says,

643
00:58:01,728 --> 00:58:04,728
This is a good deal and I was young and everybody told me, no,

644
00:58:04,728 --> 00:58:05,927
no. You don't sign bills.

645
00:58:05,927 --> 00:58:07,527
Say you really know what's going on in space.

646
00:58:07,527 --> 00:58:10,128
You have somebody on the other cross the aisle and he said, listen,

647
00:58:10,128 --> 00:58:12,027
he says, this is good for your district.

648
00:58:12,027 --> 00:58:13,927
It's good frost sign here.

649
00:58:14,128 --> 00:58:15,027
And, you know, it was a

650
00:58:15,027 --> 00:58:15,728
good thing to do.

651
00:58:15,728 --> 00:58:16,728
He did lead me.

652
00:58:16,927 --> 00:58:17,768
He didn't lead

653
00:58:17,768 --> 00:58:21,527
me astray, but he took the time to explain to me that it

654
00:58:21,527 --> 00:58:21,728
was

655
00:58:21,728 --> 00:58:21,827
a

656
00:58:21,827 --> 00:58:23,228
good idea for me to sign on.

657
00:58:23,228 --> 00:58:23,427
And it

658
00:58:23,427 --> 00:58:23,927
was.

659
00:58:25,827 --> 00:58:26,327
Thank you.

660
00:58:26,527 --> 00:58:26,728
I

661
00:58:26,728 --> 00:58:27,128
was

662
00:58:27,775 --> 00:58:32,335
That was a fun one. I also remember when with the same exact bill, Norm Johnson,

663
00:58:34,576 --> 00:58:39,376
twisted a lot of arms on three bills he was working on before his signature got onto that

664
00:58:39,376 --> 00:58:46,416
WCU bill. So thank you for not putting me through that. Senator Harris, before we go,

665
00:58:46,416 --> 00:58:52,976
I just want to mention that same event I was at last week, which I met, General Mattis,

666
00:58:57,231 --> 00:59:02,231
who was obviously exceedingly competent in all that she did.

667
00:59:02,231 --> 00:59:05,231
And imagine my surprise when she told me that

668
00:59:05,231 --> 00:59:07,231
she was your daughter.

669
00:59:07,231 --> 00:59:09,231
Thanks after her mother.

670
00:59:13,231 --> 00:59:17,231
You're muted, Paul, but maybe that's a good thing.

671
00:59:21,231 --> 00:59:23,231
You have no, you have, no volume.

672
00:59:23,231 --> 00:59:25,231
I don't know what's going on there. Listen.

673
00:59:25,568 --> 00:59:28,367
Especially to the new members. Thank you.

674
00:59:28,367 --> 00:59:32,367
Thank. You. We welcome you with open arms and a strong embrace.

675
00:59:32,367 --> 00:59:36,768
We're delighted to have you we obviously will be back to you on.

676
00:59:36,768 --> 00:59:40,128
Uh, the citizens assembly thing and.

677
00:59:40,128 --> 00:59:43,728
At some point with a draft letter, which I think we need to send.

678
00:59:43,728 --> 00:59:46,527
Fairly soon because they're pretty neat, but.

679
00:59:46,527 --> 00:59:50,527
Developing their plans for it. They should already.

680
00:59:53,039 --> 00:59:56,960
You all have a great rest of the day. Thank you very much meeting adjourned