[3:43] everyone would please have their [3:45] seats members and those in the [3:47] back. I'm gonna call the [3:49] meeting to order. The committee [3:50] clerk has taken a silent roll [3:51] call and a quorum has been [3:52] established [3:55] there being a quorum established [3:56] I recognize the co-chair for a [3:58] motiondamir, I move that the [4:01] minutes from the meeting held on [4:03] August 9,2026 be approved. The [4:05] question is on the motion that [4:07] the minutes from August 9,2026 [4:08] be approved. all those in favor [4:08] say aye. [4:11] those opposed no in the opinion [4:13] of the chair the ayes have it. I [4:14] declare the motion adopted. [4:17] the next item on the agenda is a [4:18] presentation on the success of [4:19] the underderwood Smith teaching [4:21] scholarship from Doctor Sarah [4:24] Tucker, Chancellor of the WvHEPc [4:25] Good morning Chancellor. Good [4:27] morning Mrs Chairman. thank you [4:28] all for having me here today and [4:29] I am really excited to get to [4:31] present about this particular [4:35] scholarship today. Um, in2019 [4:37] you all made some pretty [4:39] significant changes to the [4:40] Underwood Smith Teacher [4:41] scholarship programme. You [4:43] increased that grant award. [4:44] let me go through [4:44] it quickly. [4:47] well essentially you made [4:49] this the most competitive [4:50] scholarship in the state of West [4:53] Virginia and so the idea was how [4:55] do weta attract and retain [4:57] teachers to the state of West [4:58] Virginia. How do we make sure [5:01] that they stay instate teaching [5:03] in high demand fields. And so [5:05] what you did was you provided a [5:09] grant for25 teachers per cohort [5:10] annually. so when we have all [5:12] four cohorts that's100 students [5:12] at a time [5:15] It's10,000 dollars a year up [5:19] to40,000 dollars. It is a [5:21] stackable scholarship so if a [5:23] student gets promise they still [5:25] get10,000 dollars for Underwood [5:27] Smith. If they get HEgp they [5:28] still get10,000 dollars for [5:28] Underwood Smith. [5:33] It requires students to teach in [5:35] the state for five years after [5:36] they graduate [5:39] they have to be a teacher in a [5:41] high needs field. the high needs [5:42] field is identified in code [5:45] that special education, [5:48] mathematics, science or early [5:48] childhood education [5:52] or elementary education I'm [5:52] sorry [5:57] the students move through four [5:59] rounds of a selection process. [6:00] so the first round is to apply [6:01] for the scholarship [6:04] The second round they have GPA [6:06] and test scores applied we start [6:07] whittling down the number of [6:11] students. then we bring in an [6:12] outside committee that outside [6:15] committee scores an essay that [6:16] each of the students write about [6:17] why they want to become a [6:19] teacher and then we whittle that [6:21] group down to about30 to40 [6:23] students and then we get to [6:25] that30 to40 we say take your [6:26] essay and turn it into a video. [6:30] and explain to us why you want [6:32] to become a public school [6:32] teacher in west Virginia. [6:35] and they do that and then we [6:36] select25 students at the end. [6:41] so far our first cohort [6:42] graduated from college in2024. [6:47] So far we have42 Underwood Smith [6:49] teaching scholars who are [6:51] currently teaching in a West [6:53] Virginia classroom in and public [6:55] education. Now why42 and not50. [6:57] While some students went to [6:59] graduate school. Some students [7:01] got into the teaching field and [7:02] they were freshmen and they were [7:03] like you know what I don't want [7:05] to do this anymore so they [7:07] changed majors just like you [7:08] know you would see normally but [7:10] we have42 students who are [7:12] currently teaching in the state [7:12] of west Virginia [7:14] so I want to talk with you a [7:16] little bit about the pipeline of [7:19] these students. So in2024 we [7:22] had111 eligible applicants [7:23] who we did not award [7:24] 111 [7:29] of those111 students 94 [7:31] eventually enrolled in a public [7:33] higher education institution in [7:35] West Virginia. Now I am certain [7:37] that more of those enrolled in a [7:38] private school I'm certain more [7:39] of those went out of state. I [7:40] just can't measure how many [7:41] there were. I know that 94 [7:43] enrolled in a public higher [7:44] education institution in West [7:44] Virginia. [7:48] In2025 we actually had220 [7:48] applicants. [7:49] 220 [7:56] of the22167 were eligible. The [7:57] majority of those who were not [8:00] eligible were actually college [8:00] students [8:03] who decided they wanted to go [8:04] into the teaching field [8:07] but this program is for high [8:09] school students who are entering [8:10] college [8:13] so we had to limit a number of [8:14] those students because they were [8:15] not eligible based on that [8:19] criteria alone. So167 eligible [8:21] applicants were not awarded the [8:22] Underwood Smith scholarship [8:26] of those118 enrolled in a public [8:28] West Virginia higher education [8:30] institution. We then went on and [8:33] looked to see what fields they [8:35] were going into and the vast [8:36] majority of those students all [8:37] enrolled in teacher education [8:39] when they matriculated on to [8:41] college. So I give you these [8:42] numbers because these students [8:43] are serious this is what they [8:44] want to do for their vocation [8:47] they're not just students who [8:48] are sitting around thinking oh [8:49] let me apply for every [8:51] scholarship under the sun. These [8:53] are students who really want to [8:55] go into the teaching profession. [8:57] um, and you know this this [8:58] scholarship is terrific but [9:00] we're all obviously limited in [9:01] the number of students that we [9:02] can award. [9:07] So as of this state we've had57 [9:09] underderwood Smith scholars who [9:11] have graduated.gain, we have42 [9:12] that are teaching in West [9:13] Virginia classrooms some of that [9:15] lag between the42 and57 [9:18] is that a lot of these students [9:20] participate in therow your own [9:21] program that you all know about [9:24] through K1w2. So they're getting [9:26] dual credits in teacher [9:27] education while they're still in [9:29] high school so we had a number [9:30] of students who graduated early [9:34] and who just haven't had time [9:35] to get into the teaching [9:37] profession yet so we'll see [9:38] these numbers go up this fall [9:39] and we can see how many more [9:40] students go in. [9:43] we also have 8 of our graduates [9:44] who have gone on to a [9:44] master'sgre program in [9:44] education. [9:48] So where are the42 working [9:51] Currently they're working in22 [9:53] different counties you can see [9:55] in your map the spread across [9:56] the state it's a pretty good [9:56] spread. [9:59] we have students in lots of [10:02] counties from the you know far [10:03] west to the far east to the [10:04] northern panhandle to the [10:05] southern part of the state. [10:07] in some of those counties we [10:09] have multiple students so that's [10:11] why they're only22 and not42, [10:13] but I expect that this spread [10:15] will continue to grow as we have [10:16] more and more students graduate. [10:21] so now I'm gonna do something a [10:22] little different. those of you [10:23] who are used to seeing me in [10:24] front of you know that I'm very [10:25] data heavy. I'm about to be very [10:27] not data heavy because I want [10:29] you to see the students that I [10:31] get to see and I want you to see [10:33] how amazing they are and how [10:35] dedicated they are. So this is [10:36] Lauren Marquardt, Lauren [10:37] graduated from Wheeling Park [10:39] High School gowheeling. Anyone [10:40] hears from wheeling? I am. [10:43] she we did an interview with [10:45] Lauren to see what was [10:46] important about the Underwood [10:48] Smith scholarship for her. why [10:50] it was important in her life and [10:51] in her graduation. She of course [10:52] talked about the financial [10:53] assistance [10:55] but she also talked about the [10:57] confidence that it built in her [10:58] decision to become a teacher. [11:00] We don't just give these [11:01] kids10,000 dollars a year. [11:04] We bring them in as a cohort. we [11:05] make them feel special. we have [11:07] a banquet every year for them [11:09] where they come and learn about [11:11] what they're about to embark on. [11:12] We give them a mentor teacher [11:13] and that mentor teacher works [11:15] with them for four years. That [11:17] teacher helps them understand [11:19] how to apply what they're [11:20] learning in the classroom to the [11:21] actual classroom where they're [11:22] going to be teaching. [11:25] And Lauren had a particularly [11:27] good mentor and she talked a lot [11:29] about how that connection with [11:30] her mentor helped her in the [11:30] classroom when she got there. [11:33] how it gave her the freedom to [11:35] be to be able to focus on being [11:36] the best teacher she could be. [11:39] and then really interestingly [11:40] because of this scholarship [11:42] Lauren was able to graduate not [11:43] just with a bachelor's degree [11:44] but also with a master's degree [11:46] with $0 in debt. [11:53] So one of her quotes that she [11:54] provided us was that it reminded [11:55] me that teaching is an important [11:57] profession and motivated me to [11:59] work even harder to become the [12:00] kind of educator my students [12:01] deserve. [12:05] Today Lauren is a second grade [12:06] teacher in Suncrest Elementary [12:06] School in Morgantown. [12:09] she says that the investment [12:12] that you all made in her in [12:12] going to college [12:15] is going to be an investment in [12:16] all of the students that she [12:16] teaches in the future. [12:19] She's building relationships [12:21] with students and families and [12:22] helping the young people of West [12:22] Virginia recognize their own [12:23] potential. [12:27] Now I want you to meet Sam. [12:30] Sam moved to McDowell County at [12:31] the age of 9 [12:32] his [12:35] concentration and focus of [12:38] interest has been on creating [12:39] math and he wants to be a math [12:40] and history teacher in McDowell [12:41] County. [12:45] um, so Sam told us his story and [12:46] his video you remember the [12:47] fourth round is that students [12:49] provided videos they are amazing [13:06] OK. so here's why I want to be a [13:06] teacher [13:09] When I was 9 years old my family [13:12] moved from Ohio to McDowell [13:12] County, West Virginia. [13:16] to serve in the mission field to [13:17] bring teachers to McDowell [13:18] County an area that desperately [13:19] needed them [13:23] when I moved here I instantly [13:24] fell in love with the community. [13:25] I fell in love with the people, [13:26] I fell in love with the area. [13:28] my dream is to teach in Mcdowell [13:29] County schools [13:33] I could really serve to a need. [13:35] If I get the scholarship I would [13:36] use it to be able to go to a [13:38] school in Parkersburg and I [13:39] would be able to get my [13:40] education degree and double [13:40] major in history and math. [13:43] both of those areas we need [13:45] teachers desperately in our [13:46] community [13:49] I'm going to adapt a very [13:50] relational teaching style. I [13:51] love developing relationships [13:52] with people [13:56] if you don't know someone it's [13:56] very hard to learn from them [13:59] my upbringing has taught me to [14:00] be a caring and loving person. [14:03] you never know what a person has [14:04] been through in their life so [14:05] you cannot just judge a person [14:07] based on their appearance or how [14:09] they may act in a certain [14:10] situation you have to truly know [14:10] them [14:13] in the classroom I want to have [14:14] a very powerful personality. [14:17] when I speak I want kids to be [14:18] able to understand that I have [14:19] something important to say and I [14:20] want them to be drawn to me [14:23] in my teaching style I also plan [14:25] to be very hands on one thing [14:27] that I feel is very undervalued [14:29] especially in math is relating [14:30] math concepts to real world. [14:33] I want to stress that I'm not [14:35] just here to take this40,000 [14:36] dollars, spend my five years in [14:37] west Virginia and there just bol [14:38] to some other place. I've really [14:39] been touched by this community [14:42] down here my goal is to live and [14:42] just give back to as much as [14:43] possible. [14:45] just know that if you give me [14:47] the scholarship it will not be [14:48] wasted and you can look back for [14:50] years to come with pride knowing [14:51] that you were able to positively [14:52] affect southern west Virginia [14:52] and McDow County. [14:53] thank you. [15:11] Hi, my name is Isabellaoge and [15:12] I'm a [15:20] So todayamm is living on his [15:21] dream. He has returned to [15:22] McDowell County [15:25] he is teaching in Riverview High [15:26] School and he is a math teacher. [15:27] it's pretty remarkable [15:31] going to give you one more [15:32] student [15:34] and one more video. I have [15:35] hundreds of these it took a lot [15:37] to figure out which two to show [15:39] you. I figured you didn't have [15:40] enough time to watch hundreds of [15:41] them so I chose two that I [15:42] thought were or we chose two [15:42] that we thought were pretty good [15:45] this is Bailey Bailey was in [15:47] the2024 cohort of students so [15:49] she is still in college [15:52] Bailey's passion is for helping [15:53] special needs students because [15:55] their older brother has autism [15:57] and she wanted to make sure that [15:59] teachers for kids who had autism [16:01] were able to reach them the same [16:02] way that some of his teachers [16:02] were able to reach him. [16:04] and so let me show you Bailey's [16:05] video. [16:09] I may not have been born here [16:10] but I've lived here since I was [16:12] one in West Virginia will always [16:13] be my home. I want to make an [16:15] impact on the kids teaching [16:17] elementary special education [16:18] right here in the great state of [16:20] west Virginia. We interrupt this [16:21] program to bring you a special [16:22] report [16:25] justin we've just gotten word [16:27] that Baileiger of Bruce and [16:28] Mose, West Virginia is going to [16:29] make a huge difference in this [16:31] state by becoming a top educator [16:32] in the field of elementary [16:34] special education with more on [16:35] this developing story let's get [16:36] right to the sourceurer herself [16:37] Bailey [16:40] hi, thank you. Several months [16:41] ago I committed to West Virginia [16:43] University and will be majoring [16:45] in elementary education with [16:46] minors in special education [16:48] inequine therapy. I have a [16:49] passion for teaching because [16:51] I've always loved kids and [16:52] particularly those with special [16:54] needs. My older brother has [16:55] autism and was diagnosed right [16:57] before I was born. I've grown up [16:59] seeing his struggles and want to [17:01] be the one to help kids like him [17:03] be successful. It's personal for [17:04] me. I care too much not to help. [17:06] Many people feel that you need [17:07] to be a leader in order to be an [17:09] effective teacher. your thoughts [17:10] on that? Yes. [17:13] I'm a natural leader. I'm the [17:13] coditor in chief on my yearbook [17:15] and work with the younger staff [17:17] to teach them everything that [17:18] goes into producing our [17:19] yearbook. I am also the [17:21] secretary for my FFfa chapter [17:22] and I helped lead the [17:26] I understand that you are a [17:28] finalist for the prestigious [17:30] underwoodsmith teaching scholars [17:31] programme. Why do you feel you [17:32] deserve this award? [17:35] I don't plan on teaching in west [17:36] virginia for five years. I plan [17:37] on teaching in west virginia my [17:38] entire career. [17:39] I'm not becoming a teacher for [17:41] the schedule I'm becoming a [17:43] teacher for the students. I feel [17:45] like it helps students reach the [17:46] greatest potential for figuring [17:46] out [17:49] every child learns the same and [17:51] it's necessary to figure out [17:52] what works best for each [17:52] student. [17:53] I have the patience [17:58] Are there any other ways you [17:58] will help your future students [17:59] be successful? [18:02] Oh yes, I want to make school [18:04] fun and interesting so my [18:05] students are excited with [18:07] special ed no two days are the [18:09] same. I will thrive in this type [18:10] of situation and I know I can [18:11] help my students flourish. [18:13] Many people say they have [18:15] someone they look up to that has [18:16] shown them the type of teacher [18:17] they want to be. Do you have a [18:18] specific person that stands out [18:19] for you? [18:22] absolutely it's Miss Saggs my [18:24] yearbook teacher. She's shown me [18:26] what being a teacher really is [18:27] she cares so much for all of her [18:29] students and she shows it in so [18:31] many ways she makes learning so [18:32] much fun [18:34] I want to be that teacher, the [18:36] teacher that makes kids excited [18:36] to come to school and learn. [18:39] Bailey, thank you for sharing [18:41] your story. Best of luck to you. [18:42] Now back to our regular [18:42] scheduled program [18:47] According to Oxford [18:56] So Bailey did an interview on [18:57] Talkline after she was [18:59] selected and she said it's [19:01] really big because I'm actually [19:03] putting myself through college [19:04] it's going to help me so much to [19:04] have this scholarship. [19:11] and as you heard the iveyear [19:13] commitment doesn't affect me [19:14] because I plan to stay in West [19:15] Virginia. I love it here and I [19:16] want to see improvement. [19:19] So this presentation is really [19:21] just sort of a victory lap for [19:23] all of you. I want to thank you [19:24] for this scholarship I want to [19:25] thank you for providing these [19:27] students the opportunities that [19:29] you have provided them. I want [19:31] you to know what a trickledown [19:33] effect these scholarships are [19:35] going to have on our future [19:36] students here in west Virginia [19:38] and the kids that are going to [19:39] come after them and that are [19:40] going to be taught by these [19:40] incredible educators [19:43] I also know that we hear lots of [19:45] negative things about West [19:46] Virginia. look at these kids [19:49] they're amazing. I mean these [19:51] are amazing students and we have [19:52] hundreds of them that apply [19:53] every year that all want to stay [19:55] here and all want to teach and [19:57] all want to do better for the [19:58] state of West Virginia I hope [20:00] that they inspire you as much as [20:01] they inspire me every time [20:04] we get to get together with [20:04] these students [20:07] at the end of at the banquet [20:08] that we do every year our [20:09] masters of ceremony a woman [20:11] named Michelle Marlowe puts [20:12] together a quote [20:15] that she gives to the teachers [20:17] to try to inspire that cohort of [20:18] teachers for the you know the [20:19] rest of their teaching career [20:21] and so I thought this quote was [20:22] really poignant. This is the [20:23] quote for this year [20:25] Education is not the filling of [20:26] the pail but the lighting of a [20:27] fire. [20:29] that's what this scholarship has [20:31] done for these students the [20:33] scholarship has lit a fire [20:34] underneath them to be better [20:36] teachers and hopefully it will [20:38] light a fire under them as they [20:39] teach and their students as they [20:40] teach [20:43] um, to work harder to try harder [20:45] and to be better west virginians [20:46] so thank you all I'm happy to [20:46] answer [20:57] Thank you chancellor very much [20:58] great presentation I'm wondering [20:59] if you might be able to come [21:00] back to us with some [21:05] madede a decision that they want [21:15] associated with that certainly [21:19] these students leaving high [21:20] school maybe [21:23] grow your own program but [21:43] go through that transition. Yep [21:47] are there further questions for [21:48] the chancellor? [21:50] the cochair has a question. [21:51] Chancellor Tucker. [21:53] can you tell me I [22:10] to help [22:13] ur r ent ly no but could I [22:14] figure it out? Yes. [22:16] I will thank you [22:21] that are there further questions [22:22] for the [22:24] delegate Hornby [22:26] thank you madam Chair [22:30] Unlike the vice chair I I don't [22:31] understand the the the financing [22:33] out can you explain with with [22:35] where the financing comes from [22:37] and it does the legislature [22:39] provide you with yearly funding [22:40] for this scholarship we [22:43] top of my head I'm trying to [22:45] think of what that is. I don't [22:46] know. I'll find out they will [22:47] find out for you in just a [22:48] second we have an annual [22:52] appropriation that funds um,25 [22:55] students per cohort. so we have [22:57] at any given time once the [22:58] program is up and running100 [22:58] students. [23:01] roughly a million dollars per [23:02] year [23:02] roughly [23:08] and you have over200 [23:12] roughly applicants that are [23:13] eligible every single year. Last [23:16] year we had220 applicants of [23:19] those167 were eligible because [23:21] the difference between the167 [23:23] and the220 was largely that they [23:24] were students who were enrolled [23:25] in college and the eligible [23:26] applicants have to be a high [23:27] school senior. [23:29] you think that [23:33] allowing those students that are [23:34] already in college who are [23:35] looking to get into the teaching [23:39] career program would be [23:42] beneficial to to to the program [23:45] to allow that eligibility do it [23:47] it's a matter of without an [23:49] increase of cost it's a it's a [23:51] matter of what you restrict [23:52] right? So [23:53] it would come down to the budget [23:57] thank you chancellor it thank [23:58] you madam Chair thank you [23:58] delegate. Are there further [23:59] questions for the chancellor? [24:01] it's1.48 million ann [24:05] Thank you thank you very much [24:11] The next item on the agenda, [24:13] I do believe we have several [24:15] people here to speak so if [24:16] everyone that plans to speak at [24:17] the podium could just make their [24:18] way down, that would be [24:18] great. [24:27] So the next item on the agenda [24:28] is Reshore West Virginia which [24:30] is reshoring opportunities in [24:31] Westvirginia and we have several [24:33] people here to speak what [24:35] I'll have each of you do is if [24:36] you could please just state your [24:37] name and title when you step up [24:39] to the podium so everybody knows [24:40] who is speaking [24:43] Mr. Bisssett, will you start? OK [24:51] And you may begin whenever [24:53] you're ready. awesome. good [24:54] morning. My name is Bill Bissett [24:55] I'm president of the weststerio [24:57] Manufacturers association. great [24:59] to be with you today I wanna [25:00] thank the members of the joint [25:00] committee as well as its [25:01] leadership for allowing us to [25:03] present reshore West Virginia to [25:05] you some of you heard about it [25:07] but I think it's an important [25:08] program not just to grow [25:10] manufacturing in west Virginia [25:11] which I think is in all of our [25:13] interests but also a way to give [25:15] my members the building blocks [25:17] the materials that they need to [25:18] make their products [25:19] which is critical [25:22] that's literally one of the most [25:23] biggest cons one of the biggest [25:25] concerns I hear from my members [25:27] is supply chain issues or [25:29] markets and either way Reshore [25:31] westrginia really benefits us in [25:32] that way you'll hear a lot more [25:33] about this in a moment but I [25:35] also want thank delegate [25:35] Laurie Whitman for her interest [25:37] in this because there's an [25:38] interesting educational [25:39] component to this program which [25:40] is what brings us here today [25:45] so when President Trump took [25:47] office a new word was [25:48] injected into the collective [25:49] consciousness and that word was [25:50] tariffs [25:53] and some of my members were very [25:54] concerned some of them were very [25:55] supportive oferrets because they [25:57] have a domestic to the United [25:59] States supply chain and market [26:01] so it affected our membership [26:02] very differently [26:05] but that said the concern was it [26:06] created a lot of uncertainty [26:08] which business much like us [26:08] individuals do not like [26:11] and that uncertainty was driven [26:13] by litigation by the on and off [26:15] nature of a tariffs by a [26:17] changing landscape that seemed [26:19] to continue but when you have a [26:20] challenge how can you turn that [26:20] into an opportunity? [26:23] and the way you do that is [26:24] finding a person with expertise. [26:25] finding a person that has that [26:26] granular knowledge of the issue [26:29] who could help us take advantage [26:31] of it and benefit West Virginia [26:33] and that person is Ed Ryan he's [26:35] a west virginian he's educated [26:36] from Mars University and he has [26:38] a tremendous knowledge not only [26:38] of US customs [26:40] but international logistics [26:43] and what I'm especially proud [26:45] about Rehore West Virginia is Ed [26:47] brings this to westvirginia he's [26:49] lived out of state he's returned [26:50] home we're happy to have him [26:52] here but when I met with him [26:53] more than a year ago he started [26:55] explaining how we connect our [26:56] manufacturers with each other [26:58] instate [27:01] to not only supply the materials [27:03] they need but also possibly sell [27:05] their products in state as well [27:07] in short it's much better that [27:09] we get these materials from Clay [27:10] County than China. [27:13] how do we do that and what's [27:14] interesting about manufacturing [27:15] a lot of my members don't know [27:17] another manufacturer 20 minutes [27:19] away we're probably the closest [27:21] thing to an interconnection of [27:23] manufacturing our association in [27:25] the state but using technology [27:27] using the custom codes using [27:29] many things that Ed understands [27:30] very very well he's assembled [27:31] this team that I think allows us [27:33] to not only benefit [27:34] manufacturing the state and [27:34] economic development [27:37] but also train the next [27:38] generation [27:39] in how they can work in this [27:40] field and benefit our state as [27:41] well [27:42] without further ado Ed Ryan [27:47] Thank you Bill [27:50] just a special thanks to [27:50] delegate [27:53] Diman for allowing us to [27:57] our our story [28:01] just being a teacher and being a [28:04] delegate at the same time [28:05] what an amazing balance I know [28:06] you're probably missing your [28:09] thank them for us for your [28:11] service here at the capitol [28:13] I'm met Ryan I'm the founder [28:17] of Reshore West Virginia I [28:18] wanna to talk to you about our [28:18] course [28:20] I'm so excited about the [28:21] educational offering that [28:23] we're providing through Reshore [28:25] West Virginia and I think the [28:27] best way for me to do that is to [28:28] give you several different [28:30] through so I've brought up [28:34] a bunch of my friends and [28:37] partners to talk to you about [28:39] Reshore West Virginia and the [28:40] educational piece and how they [28:43] serve to be a part of that so [28:44] with that I'd like to [28:46] ask Mr Matt Turner to come up [28:47] from higherducation [28:48] Policycommission [28:53] Thank you Ed. thank you chairs [28:55] and members speaking on [28:56] behalf of the higher education [28:58] Policy commission, I'm not sure [29:00] if it's evident yet but Ed has a [29:02] tremendous amount of enthusiasm [29:03] for the state and certainly for [29:05] this project and he's [29:06] challenging us he really is and [29:09] trying to adapt platforms [29:10] that were not initially [29:12] intended for one of his academic [29:14] programs to to make it happen [29:15] and we continue to work with him [29:16] but [29:18] you know this is a real [29:19] opportunity for the state [29:19] building a workforce that [29:21] understands the economics and [29:24] practical skills that are [29:25] bringing manufacturing supply [29:27] chains back home and we [29:28] certainly believe this is [29:29] something that west Virginia [29:30] higher education should support [29:32] so as I said our statewide [29:34] online platform our online [29:35] learning platform is called [29:37] WVrocks. it was designed for [29:39] returning students and has [29:40] helped so many countless [29:43] students who are entering [29:43] higher education again through [29:45] the region's bachelor of artts [29:46] program to to [29:47] try to get them on a the fast [29:49] forward track so that they can [29:51] complete their degrees and we're [29:52] working with Ed and his team to [29:56] use that platform to try to make [29:57] his coursework that will help [29:59] students understand the [30:01] reassuring concept to make that [30:02] available statewide. he's [30:03] already successfully implemented [30:05] it at at least one of our [30:05] schools I think what two is that [30:08] rightd University of Charleston [30:11] and and Wvu and we're trying to [30:12] adapt our platform to make that [30:13] a statewide option for that so [30:17] that work continues but we [30:18] really are thrilled with Ed's [30:19] enthusiasm for this and bringing [30:21] the right partners together and [30:22] we're we're proud to support [30:22] this this effort and [30:25] look forward to continuing to [30:27] work with the reshore project to [30:28] see how we can open this up to [30:29] even more institutions across [30:30] the state so we're we're pleased [30:32] to support that and and eager to [30:33] see what the next steps are [30:34] thank you all [30:39] Um, next I'd like to bring up [30:43] Doctor John Saldanaha, Doctor [30:45] Saldanaha is the chair of the [30:47] supply chain management program [30:48] at West Virginia University. [30:48] Johnn. [30:55] Good morning John Saldanna, [30:56] professor of supply chain Man [30:59] andc's chair of global supply [31:00] chain Man. [31:00] so [31:03] listening to Ed when he first [31:05] pitched this to me I said you [31:06] know this is perfect because in [31:07] this current s business [31:09] environment strategic sourcing [31:10] is particularly challenging [31:14] The long established trade [31:15] routes that we have currently [31:17] have been altered by [31:18] geopolitical forces [31:20] we have taken for granted supply [31:20] sources [31:23] existing decades that are now [31:25] risky due to historic [31:26] restructuring of tradegre [31:26] agreements [31:29] consumer demand has also become [31:31] much harder to predict due to [31:32] constantly changing markets [31:37] so the only certainty in today's [31:38] business environment is [31:39] uncertainty. [31:42] the supply chain management [31:43] program at the Chambers College [31:45] of Business is very proud of our [31:48] graduates100% place and rate at [31:51] global brand name ins companies [31:53] like General Electric, General [31:55] Motors including companies here [31:57] in our state toyota Lockheed [31:59] Martin. We also very proud of [32:00] our graduates being placed at [32:03] high impact institutions like [32:05] Georgetown Carnegie Mellon [32:06] after they graduate. [32:09] sayingying this we believe that [32:10] the potential of Reho West [32:11] Virginia's coursework [32:13] to contribute to our students [32:15] career successes in this new [32:16] business of mind with is [32:16] critical. [32:21] today supply chain mans consider [32:23] supply chains as malleable [32:24] they're not fixed anymore. [32:26] because of this unreliable [32:26] sourcing [32:30] and accelerated clock speed of [32:30] market changes that happen [32:34] all of these give rise to [32:35] requirement for new sources of [32:36] supply. [32:39] so going back to the literature [32:41] I looked at what are the [32:41] advantages of reassuring [32:44] over the relatively low cost of [32:44] offshore sources of supply. [32:49] Most importantly is lower cost [32:50] of supply chain logistics [32:51] obviouslyviously lower [32:53] transportation costs but most [32:54] importantly the [32:55] removal of the layers of [32:56] bureaucracy [32:59] that are embedded in executing [33:00] global sourcing decisions [33:03] reassuring also reduces the [33:05] distances to our sources which [33:06] makes our manufacturers in west [33:07] Virginia [33:09] more agile and more responsive [33:10] to [33:15] So we view the reassuring west [33:16] Virginia co that we did [33:18] in spring semester of2026 as a [33:19] living lab [33:22] the course provided our students [33:23] an experiential learning [33:25] opportunity to work on complex [33:27] problems that supply chain [33:27] managers are working on [33:28] currently. [33:31] so as we all know experiential [33:32] learning is the most effective [33:35] mode of pedagogy that we all [33:36] want to strive for in higher [33:36] education [33:38] so I supervised a group of [33:39] students who worked on one such [33:40] project this past semester. [33:43] first the students had to frame [33:44] the objective [33:47] and articulate the project [33:48] deliverables then they had to [33:49] formulate an implementation plan [33:53] they also had to execute the [33:54] plan [33:56] they had to develop a [33:56] methodology [34:01] be able to identify data analyze [34:02] the data and then arrive at the [34:03] project deliverables. [34:06] Most importantly the students [34:06] had carefully think through [34:09] how they could communicate these [34:11] findings in a compelling and [34:12] concise report to the managers [34:13] who they were working with [34:18] The report and subs subsequent [34:19] presentation to the organis [34:21] organization's managers needed [34:22] to clearly convey the [34:23] deliverables along with the [34:24] sourcing strategy [34:27] and the plan along with [34:27] assessment of post [34:29] implementation risks and [34:30] rewards. [34:33] so at every stage of the [34:34] cappstone project whether in [34:37] reading comprehension whether in [34:39] writing oral communication [34:41] project management, mathematical [34:42] modeling students were [34:43] challenged to develop an [34:44] analytical mindset. [34:44] so [34:48] this was a real boon for our [34:48] students [34:51] when they interviewed with [34:53] potential employers the [34:54] employers saw the value that [34:54] they brought to Westvirginia [34:55] firms [34:58] so this value in delivering [35:00] theoretically theoreticallyrin [35:01] rigorous scientific analysis [35:03] supported by Reho Westvirginia's [35:05] platform supports firm's [35:07] decision making calculus to [35:09] build reliable and competitive [35:10] sources of supply here in [35:10] westvirginia. [35:15] So I believe this coursework has [35:16] the potential of building a [35:17] virtue cycle of helping west [35:19] Virginia firms improve their [35:20] strategic sourcing [35:22] while also building a pipeline [35:23] of talented supply chain [35:25] managers trained in strategic [35:27] sourcing from west Virginia [35:29] manufacturers that in turn [35:31] builds more business for other [35:32] Westvirginia manufacturers. [35:35] so we are supply chain [35:35] management programme at West [35:37] Virginia University is grateful [35:38] to partner with Ed Ryan [35:40] in his effort to generate new [35:40] business for West Virginia [35:41] manufacturers. [35:44] This partnership also achieves [35:45] West Virginia University's land [35:46] grant mission [35:48] to improve the economic [35:49] prosperity of the residents of [35:50] Westvirginia. [35:53] in doing so we believe that West [35:54] Virginia could become an example [35:55] for the rest of the country [35:57] we can demonstrate how to [35:59] leverage the current business [36:01] environment to encourage greater [36:03] manufacturing capacity in west [36:05] Virginia and thereby also build [36:07] the US domestic manufacturing [36:08] capacity that we have lost over [36:09] the last half century. [36:09] thank you [36:17] Thank you Dr. Saanha next I'd [36:19] like to bring up two speakers [36:21] from Marshall University, Derek [36:22] Scarborough from the [36:29] Thank you Ed and thanks members [36:30] for having me. My name is Derek [36:31] Scarborough. I'm the director of [36:32] Marshall's Advanced [36:33] Manufacturing Center. [36:35] the advanced manufacturingent at [36:37] Marshall is a very externally [36:39] focused applied engineering [36:41] workforce development arm of [36:43] marshall that works with [36:43] business all across the state [36:47] last year we did projects [36:49] with358 companies and many of [36:52] those are workforce training [36:54] engineering custom tooling kind [36:56] of projects but many of them are [36:59] also supply chain issues helping [37:02] companies find sources for [37:04] certain services or products [37:07] they need and also helping [37:09] smaller companies figure out how [37:11] to get into a larger supply [37:13] chain so we try to work both [37:14] sides of the equation there and [37:15] help [37:17] companies develop business [37:19] opportunities especially close [37:22] to home and what Bill said about [37:25] many companies not knowing about [37:28] resources in their backyard you [37:30] know we have many examples of [37:31] where we connected a larger [37:33] company with a machine shop in [37:35] the same county that had never [37:37] talked to each other before and [37:38] now they're supplying parts to [37:41] each other it's great but what [37:43] excites me about what Ed is [37:44] doing with Reshore west Virginia [37:49] is he's bringing his expertise [37:51] and export import knowledge [37:54] along with a powerful set of [37:55] data [37:59] that folks like us and these [38:00] other organizations can use [38:03] in applied work directly with [38:07] businesses in your districts [38:08] to help them realize [38:10] opportunities opportunities to [38:11] sell and source [38:14] more products in the area [38:17] and these classroom projects [38:19] that are happening with the [38:20] student teams working on Reshore [38:23] you know they're going to be [38:26] able to dig into specific [38:26] examples [38:28] specific companies [38:31] and help go through that data [38:33] withedd's expertise to look for [38:35] those opportunities and then [38:37] organizations like mine can [38:39] perhaps come in to say all right [38:42] we've identified this business [38:43] that's got this capability that [38:45] makes this widget that this [38:47] company across the state buys [38:52] from Asia and help them maybe [38:53] get up to certification [38:56] train additional workers so they [38:58] can expand capacity what have [39:01] you so it's a a good way to grow [39:03] an economy helping existing [39:04] businesses find more [39:07] we're all in very excited to be [39:08] part of this [39:14] Thank youerrek next from [39:16] Marshall University I'd like to [39:16] ask Kit Sowards to come up [39:23] thank you madam Chair and the [39:24] members of the committee for [39:24] this opportunity [39:30] marshall and also the associate [39:31] director of the Appalachian [39:32] Transportation Ins [39:42] re sh or ing actct as part of [39:43] that initial study we determined [39:46] that there was roughly $680 [39:49] million of products using2025 to [39:51] date data that could reasonably [39:53] be reassured in West Virginia [39:54] we've been working with Reshore [39:55] West Virginia since that effort [39:57] to examine that for the [39:59] entire13state Appalachian [40:00] regional commission. [40:02] footprint and that work [40:03] continues we see a lot more [40:11] our efforts so far have really [40:12] made us understand that we just [40:13] can't look at what products [40:18] that's only the starting point [40:19] what we really wanted to [40:21] question is how do we turn that [40:22] information into a disciplined [40:25] it starts with [40:41] harmonized tariff schedule data [40:42] allows [40:45] but also what trade def [40:55] from there we'd use economic [40:56] impact [42:27] our outreach and help manu [42:37] that's where our research can [42:38] make reshoring a practical [42:50] So this is one of my first [42:51] students from University of [42:55] Charleston I wanna give a [42:56] special shout out he couldn't be [42:58] here today but he gave me my [42:59] first chance to teach in the [43:00] un [43:05] thank you doctorRoth for that [43:06] opportunity with that I'd [43:09] like to ask Kelton Bobbitts to [43:10] come up and talk about his [43:23] Morning everybody my name is [43:25] Kelton Bowitz. I am an MBA [43:27] student at the University of [43:29] Charleston and anybody that [43:30] knows me knows I am a very proud [43:30] Westvirginian [43:33] grew up infayette County no more [43:34] than5 minutes away from the [43:35] Newriver Gorge Bridge and [43:36] haven't grown up in such a [43:37] beautiful part of the state I [43:39] got to experience so many of the [43:40] great things our state has to [43:42] offer. but I also got to [43:43] experience some of its [43:45] challenges so to better [43:46] understand these challenges I [43:46] went to the University of [43:47] Charleston double major business [43:48] man and political science [43:52] and decided to pursue my MBA in [43:54] my first semester in my MBA [43:57] career I got the opportunity to [43:59] take Ed's course and it was a [44:00] little daunting and I didn't [44:01] know if I was getting in over my [44:01] head. [44:04] but I was I spent hours and [44:06] hours looking over data, looking [44:07] at manufacturers in West [44:09] Virginia really trying to [44:11] piece it together in a way that [44:12] could produce something valuable [44:13] and while it was difficult and [44:15] challenging that's exactly why I [44:17] was able to grow from the [44:17] experience and that's why it was [44:19] so valuable to me because I [44:21] learned more about tariffs, [44:23] international trade and the [44:24] domestic manufacturing in west [44:26] Virginia than I did in any class [44:27] in undergrad and the reason why [44:28] was simple [44:30] it's because we were focused on [44:32] solving a real problem outside [44:32] the classroom [44:35] what we did in the research was [44:37] we took an industry select a [44:39] business within that industry [44:41] figureed out what that business [44:42] imported and asked a very [44:42] practical question. [44:45] can that be manufactured in west [44:46] Virginia [44:49] If yes then we ran a comparative [44:50] analysis of the domestic [44:53] manufacturing cost to the landed [44:55] or imported costs and to make [44:56] the research as actionable as we [44:58] could we made an implementation [44:58] plan [45:00] very different than just writing [45:01] a paper for a grade. [45:03] interestingly enough through [45:04] some of my connections in [45:05] economic development I was able [45:07] to send my research to some [45:09] individuals in that field now [45:11] did they do anything with my [45:12] research I don't know but [45:15] what I do know is this is that [45:18] they now have an option that [45:18] they didn't have before [45:21] and I think that's what makes [45:23] this course so valuable because [45:24] I know I've had friends and I'm [45:25] sure many of you have [45:26] experienced this as well who [45:27] have wanted to stay in west [45:29] virginia they wanted to work in [45:30] west Virginia raise families in [45:31] west Virginia but they weren't [45:33] able to not because they didn't [45:34] want to but rather they [45:35] struggled to find the [45:36] opportunity here. [45:38] and that to me is a tragedy [45:41] and I also think that's where [45:42] this course can add value [45:44] because I'm just one student [45:47] doing one piece of research but [45:49] imagine if hundreds of students [45:50] across this state were asking [45:51] the same questions that I was [45:53] asking in my research going [45:54] through the data, looking at [45:56] manufacturers trying to find [45:57] that opportunity. Not every [45:59] piece of research is going to be [46:00] a major breakthrough and some of [46:01] it might not even be used but [46:03] that's ok because somebody some [46:05] student is bound to find [46:06] something that'll change West [46:07] Virginia for the better [46:11] and to me that's a win for [46:13] everybodyudents gain real skills [46:14] knowledge and abilities [46:17] manufacturers gain ideas in west [46:19] virginians ultimately gain [46:20] opportunity. [46:22] so if there's anything that I [46:23] would like the committee to take [46:25] away from my experience as a [46:26] student that's been through this [46:26] course it's this [46:29] students are learning real [46:31] knowledge and skills while [46:32] having the potential to solve [46:33] real problems [46:35] I'd encourage this committee to [46:37] support giving other students [46:38] the opportunity that I've had to [46:39] give back to the communities I [46:41] care so much about because I [46:42] believe that the best thing that [46:43] you can get from a college [46:45] experience is not simply a [46:46] degree but rather the ability to [46:47] look at a problem [46:50] figure it out and have the [46:51] confidence that your work can [46:53] make a difference and for me [46:54] that's exactly what this course [46:55] did [46:56] thank you so much for your time [47:02] he got an A if you're wondering [47:07] yeah amazing yeah so our last [47:09] our last speaker I want I [47:11] want you all to hear from [47:11] who's the beneficiary of all [47:12] this [47:14] and that's our westvirginia [47:17] manufacturers we had the [47:18] opportunity to work in our [47:18] second [47:21] with one of our state's greatest [47:22] man [47:26] if you've not heard of [47:27] rubberlight, hopefully today [47:29] we'll shed some light on some [47:31] of the amazing things that we're [47:33] making in our state so with that [47:34] Jeff Gord [47:42] Well it's it's my pleasure to be [47:43] here in front of you and I'm [47:45] struggling with whether I talk [47:47] about all the great things that [47:48] rubberlight does. [47:49] or all the great things I've [47:55] Mr Ryan's the one that [47:56] invited me here so I'm going to [47:57] try to stick to that but rubber [47:59] lights are relatively small [48:01] company in terms of people and [48:03] size about a half a million [48:04] square feet under roof in [48:04] Huntington [48:06] and about165 employees [48:09] but we're big in global [48:11] footprint and product footprint. [48:12] We export to about 20 different [48:13] countries [48:16] I'm sure that most of you [48:19] probably use a product that has [48:20] rubber light materials in it [48:23] and we like to look at rubber [48:24] lead as one of the best kept [48:25] secrets in west virginia [48:28] but we don't necessarily need to [48:30] be a secret in west virginia and [48:30] this was a great opportunity [48:35] for us when Ed came to me and [48:36] our president [48:40] Brad Mayo and pitched what [48:41] reshore west virginia was [48:45] we thought this is brilliant [48:46] they're taking just volumes and [48:49] volumes of data import export [48:51] data and translating that into [48:53] materials that we could sell [48:57] in our state materials that [48:58] we're exporting to Malaysia [48:59] China [49:03] Australia and indeed our [49:04] largest customer is in Malaysia. [49:07] and and we thought well this is [49:09] brilliant. it seems to make a [49:10] lot of sense so he's mining the [49:13] data the materials people are [49:14] bringing into west Virginia and [49:15] just saying look rubber light [49:16] makes [49:20] and so we had the good fortune [49:22] of being part of a capstone [49:22] project with [49:25] students from Drctor Saana's [49:26] class [49:29] and I can't tell you how [49:30] impressed I was with [49:35] did a study without our help [49:37] without any insight from us, [49:39] using the reshore West Virginia [49:42] methods our methodologies I [49:43] should say and I'm sure a little [49:45] bit of Mr. Ryan's talent and [49:46] insight and [49:49] they put together an amazing [49:50] study [49:54] that was just found was very [49:57] accurate and found an absolute [49:59] custom potential customer that [50:01] we've actually had in our sites [50:03] for many years but found it [50:05] challenging to compete with the [50:06] foams that are made [50:12] supply chain [50:15] but I'll tell you rubber [50:17] light is a company that does not [50:19] chase nickels and dimes at the [50:22] expense of dollars. so we are [50:25] almost solely US based in terms [50:27] of our raw materials buying our [50:29] building blocks for the [50:30] polymers that we make all [50:31] domestically. [50:34] we use a few specialty catalysts [50:36] and things that come from places [50:36] because no one else makes them [50:40] but basically all of our carbon [50:41] building blocks come from the [50:43] United States and even one [50:45] product line it's all west [50:48] virginia. The one side of the [50:49] reaction is made in New [50:50] Martinsville the other side's [50:51] maden South Charleston and [50:53] they're we're putting them all [50:55] together to make a line of [50:57] highly specialized technical irs [50:59] that are used in processes [51:01] that is it's quite an [51:02] innovative piece of material. [51:05] so anyway, back to the the [51:07] cappstone project. The students [51:11] we had the opportunity to host [51:13] them at at uhrubberli they came [51:14] down we gave them tours [51:16] they knew what they were looking [51:17] at as they were looking through [51:19] there was it was they were [51:20] they did their homework [51:23] and and they're their study and [51:25] the the quality of of the output [51:27] of that capstone project I was I [51:28] was impressed [51:30] and honestly I'm kind of a hard [51:33] guy to impress so I wasn't [51:33] expecting too much and so [51:37] I have no dog in this fight but [51:39] I do know that supply chain [51:41] security is our bread and [51:42] butter. That's Rubberli's bread [51:43] and butter and the more young [51:45] people know or the people coming [51:47] into the workforce understand [51:51] the criticality of supply chain [51:52] the better off all of our [51:53] companies are going to be [51:55] you know sustainability is a [51:56] word that's kicked around a lot [51:59] in my industry in the [52:01] chemicals and polymer industry, [52:03] but the primary sustainability [52:05] is security of supply and that's [52:07] where we live that is our bread [52:08] and butter. So through C covid [52:09] we didn't lose a beat [52:13] some of our lo much larger peers [52:14] in the industry they did why? [52:16] sourcing of materials [52:20] to save those nickels and dimes [52:22] and and that's something that [52:23] that rubber light does not do so [52:25] I encourage you to learn a [52:26] little bit about rubber light [52:27] and what we do. I thank you for [52:29] those that already do advocate [52:32] for us, uh, uh, such as [52:33] Billissett here in the west [52:35] Virginia Manufacturers [52:36] association for ed for Marshall [52:39] University we get quite a few [52:40] of our technical resources out [52:43] of Marshall we use an [52:45] informal internship program. [52:47] I've hired 3 engineers,2 [52:48] chemists [52:51] multitude of technicians [52:51] staff out of Marshall [52:53] University. it's a nice [52:54] resource to have [52:57] thank you again. good luck. [53:03] thank you all [53:05] for taking the time to to come [53:06] in today [53:11] so as as as you heard today [53:12] this is our mission [53:15] rubber light's a great [53:21] about1,000 manufacturers [53:25] we want to introduce [53:33] about4.9 [53:39] we're gonna do that through the [53:40] reshor [53:45] so this coming semester at WU [53:46] I've got [53:49] reshoring opportunities in west [53:51] Virginia I want thank [53:53] doctorctor Saldanaha for his [53:55] partnership and mentoring me to [53:58] become an adjunct instructor [54:00] I never dreamed of being a a [54:03] college professor but I think [54:05] the necessity of the opportunity [54:06] demands it so [54:09] I'm inspired by students like [54:11] Kelton who can get up here and [54:13] and tell you his story and [54:14] show you [54:21] so we're gonna be running the [54:23] reshoring opportunities in west [54:25] Virginia of course at Wvu but [54:26] then we look to expand that [54:27] so I would ask [54:33] man to assist us in bringing [54:35] that course to universities both [54:38] private and public across the [54:38] great state of westvirginia [54:41] we see an opportunity for [54:42] hundre [54:49] and pour in at that same level [54:50] that Kelton has [54:57] One product one import [54:57] opportunity [55:01] So with that I'd like to [55:07] Any questions [55:15] thank you [55:17] I really appreciate this [55:18] presentation [55:21] have you guys looked at access [55:23] to capital once you've done the [55:24] research on saying here's a [55:26] here's a need and the demand [55:28] level in West Virginia it can be [55:28] met [55:31] now you need an entrepreneur [55:32] who's going to be able to go out [55:33] and access capital is where is [55:34] that next step addressed yet? [56:06] So when you're when you're [56:07] talking to banks is it across [56:09] the state is it just a couple of [56:10] them you don't have to tell us [56:11] which one they are and the [56:12] reason I ask is because [56:15] in my private life there's a [56:17] lot of banking relationships we [56:18] have and when things those needs [56:19] come up they will sometimes [56:21] reach out and say hey you might [56:22] want to look into this type [56:22] thing [56:26] I would encourage that part of [56:27] it because I was there's there's [56:29] a million ideas and you guys are [56:30] really going through and and [56:31] getting the plan to implement an [56:32] idea [56:34] in one of the biggest challenges [56:35] I think we face once we get to [56:36] that spot in west Virginia is [56:37] having [56:40] access to capital to get it done [56:40] here [56:41] so it's [56:45] if if you're finding barriers as [56:47] you go along along that path [56:48] it'd be I'd be interested in [56:48] hearing what those barriers are [56:59] right thank you gentlemen very [57:00] much. [57:03] Is there any other business to [57:04] come before the committee [57:08] OK they bring no further [57:09] business before the committee. I [57:10] recognize the co-chair. madamir, [57:11] I move that the meeting be [57:13] adjourned. All those in favor [57:14] say aye. [57:16] those opposed no in the opinion [57:17] of the chair the ayes have it [57:18] the meeting is adjourned. Thank [57:19] you everyone.