[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:24] Board of Appeals will come to order. Thursday, September 24th, 2026, first order of business, acceptance of the minutes from August 27th meeting. [0:36] Motion made in second, all those in favor. Chair votes, aye, the motion passes. So for those of you who have been here before the way the zone in Board of Appeals works, petitioner presents the case. After the petitioner presents the case, we'll go to public input, ask to hear from those in favor. After those in favor, we'll hear from those in opposition. [0:54] After those in opposition, we'll go back to the petition to answer any questions or concerns that might have. [1:01] But please make sure, if you want to be heard, you do so at the appropriate time. [1:06] We'll read off the names and case numbers for tonight's meeting. [1:10] Let us know if you have case number 3852, Valkin, 24 Lane Street for the petitioner. [1:15] Is there any opposition? [1:17] That will be the second case this evening. [1:19] case number 3853, Susa, Philippe, Wei, property ID 46-337 for the petitioner. [1:28] Is there any opposition? [1:30] That will be the first case this evening. [1:33] Case number 3854, Dream to Realty LLC 160 Bay Street for the petitioner. [1:40] Is there any opposition? [1:42] That will be the third case this evening. [1:44] And the fourth case this evening, case 3855 to Susa 5.3, for the petitioner. [1:52] Is there any opposition? [1:54] Okay. [1:55] So we're ready to get right to know it here. [2:00] Case number 353, Susa, Felipe Wei, property ID 46-337. [2:07] A special permit from Section 440, attachment one of the zone ordinance to allow two families in a suburban residential [2:14] It's also a district attorney, Brianna Carrera. [2:19] Would excuse myself. [2:22] Thank you. [2:27] Mr. Fitzgerald, will you be speaking? [2:29] Only if I'm asked questions. [2:31] Okay. [2:32] So whether it has some money or about to give the truth, [2:34] or talk about the truth, so I hope you're good. [2:35] I do. [2:36] Name an address for the record please. [2:37] We're at Fitzgerald, SFG Engineering, [2:39] 28 Main Street and Lakeville Project Engineer. [2:42] You're welcome. [2:43] Tell us what you want to do. [2:44] Good evening attorney, Brianna Carrera, [2:46] with an office at 123 Broadway in Taunton. [2:48] if I could just share my screen with you. [3:02] Oh, wait, hold on. [3:03] I would help if I connected this too. [3:04] I only plugged it in. [3:05] That's my fault I apologize. [3:10] That would just work. [3:14] Okay, thank you. [3:16] We are here tonight representing Mr. Susa. [3:18] Unfortunately, he cannot join us here tonight [3:21] regarding a two family use special permit [3:23] for Felipe Wei in time. [3:26] And this is a portion of parcel 46-337. [3:30] So I say a portion of that parcel [3:33] because if you were to look this up [3:34] on the GIS. Unfortunately, the GIS is not accurate or up-to-date for this parcel, so you'll [3:38] see what you have highlighted here. Our parcel is actually a portion of it. It's around [3:43] here. Correct me if I say anything incorrect, Brad. But our parcel is around here. It's about [3:50] diagonally across the street from this parcel here. Our client purchased this in 2002. There [3:56] was a confirmatory deed in 2003. The law is referenced as parcel 4 on those deeds. [4:04] I'm [4:04] But I just wanted to clarify and make sure that that was clear to everyone. [4:09] So we are in the suburban residential zoning district where adjacent to the urban residential district, [4:14] so you can see right across the street is where the urban district is. [4:18] The purpose of the suburban residential district as this ward is well aware is to establish and [4:23] preserve areas for residential development while maintaining the atmosphere of open space. [4:27] Based off of the size of the lot that we have for you tonight in the proposal, [4:31] So we suggest that we are meeting those objectives. [4:34] The law consists of 39,024 square feet of area and the minimum for this district is 25,000 square feet. [4:42] The minimum lot size for this is actually exceeding 14 by 14,000, so we have 14,000 additional square feet in area over what's required. [4:52] We also exceed the minimum frontage, so frontage for this district is 125 feet, we have 238.71 feet of frontage. [5:00] So we're exceeding the minimum frontage by 113 feet here. [5:04] So it's a rather large lot, certainly in comparison to the minimums required. [5:09] And we feel is more than adequate to accommodate a two-family use. [5:14] When looking at the surrounding neighborhood, there are at least four to five other two-family homes in the immediate vicinity. [5:21] If you see here, shown in blue, we have white, when you enter on to fleet bayway right there on the left, there is a two-family home. [5:29] If you continue down, this is a garage, I believe, that belongs to this two family. [5:34] And then you have a triplex, which I'll get to in a moment. [5:37] And then the street over, we have three two family homes and an eight unit condo building. [5:43] And then you have some of course spread out a little bit further away. [5:47] Aside from those, there's really all vacant land that is adjacent to this parcel. [5:52] So you have the remaining land that's vacant here that's owned by another but our client does not own this land that surrounds our parcel. [6:00] And I believe that the butter that owns this property also owns the single-family home here. [6:05] That land, I know you can't see it on this board, but on here you can see the vacant land behind our parcel goes to railroad tracks. [6:13] So the railroad tracks are in the rear and then anything that's developed over there there is across on the other side of the railroad tracks. [6:21] You also have all vacant lands on this side as well, but you see here along the triplex and [6:27] And then you have a U.S., the U.S. military reserve center. [6:30] So really, those are the adjacent abutters across the street. [6:33] You have a newly developed triplex. [6:36] So this is a visual, if it helps a little bit. [6:39] This is the beginning of Fleepeway. [6:41] And as you're going down the street, this is the two family that I had mentioned. [6:45] The first house you come across, I believe it has an elder street address. [6:48] And then you can see a little bit here. [6:50] This is the garage and the shed that I had referenced a moment ago. [6:54] And if you continue down the road, the only other structures developed on this way at this time is this [7:00] Triplex three family home. [7:02] So my understanding, Brad, if you want to correct me if I'm wrong, I believe this is our parcel of land that we're [7:08] talking about here, which is pretty much across the street from the Triplex. [7:12] That's correct. [7:13] And if you go down Felipe way, there's a turn around at the end, but there's no other developed properties on this street. [7:19] Excuse me. [7:21] Yes. [7:21] Do you go back to the other picture? [7:23] Sure. [7:23] That's a three-family correct? [7:25] Yes, yeah. [7:26] Because when I went down there, I just wanted to verify that. [7:29] Yes, yep, it's a newly constructed triplex, three-family. [7:36] So, and looking at comparison to the surrounding parcel. [7:40] So again, ours is 39,000 square feet or 0.895 acres. [7:45] The vast majority of the abutting developed properties that are here are much smaller. [7:50] are in size, the parcels with two families or multi-family homes are all around 0.3 acres. [7:56] So they're roughly around 15,000 square feet. [7:59] So we exceed most if not all of those multi-family lots that are in the area by at least 15,000 square feet. [8:06] This is also almost double in area compared to the largest duplex homes, which I believe would be this one here, [8:13] or the two family here on the edge of Leapay way. [8:17] So we're almost double in area for those. [8:18] So we propose that we have more than enough space here for a two-family home. [8:23] It's certainly much larger than the lots in the area. [8:27] So the reasons that we're asking you to grant the special permits tonight. [8:31] First off, this law conforms to all of the zoning dimensional requirements. [8:35] So we are not here for any variances whatsoever. [8:37] As I mentioned, we are exceeding all of the minimums here tonight. [8:41] So they could technically do a single family by right here. [8:44] But we are here for a two-family to conform to the surrounding neighborhood that we have here. [8:48] and what's already on the street. [8:50] They would be two townhouse style condominiums, so two units, one duplex. [8:56] And it would be similar in style to what was already built across the street for the triplex. [9:00] We suggested this is in harmony with the general purpose of the ordinance and [9:04] also the purpose of the district. [9:06] Certainly because we have a lot of space still left over in this lot, we're not over saturating the lot. [9:12] And there's some wetlands too as well that of course have protections that will have to file with the conservation. [9:18] But we also are just, we are doing a residential use with preserving some space there. [9:24] The proposal would also provide a more affordable option than most single-family homes on the market. [9:30] I know not everyone agrees or likes to hear that, but they are certainly more affordable than a lot of the single-family homes and there's a need for them. [9:36] I did speak with the real estate agent that sold the triplex lots across the street. [9:41] I believe they sold within 10 days as what he had told me so there is certainly a need for [9:47] for these types of townhouse units. [9:50] And then lastly, we would be utilizing city water and sewer. [9:53] So our client had actually done a roadway improvement plan and was able to improve the road and also bring utilities, which they're working on finishing. [10:01] This would certainly help finance that, but there would be cities, sewer, and water for the two families as well, bringing in more income to the city. [10:09] So for those reasons, we ask that you approve the special permit we're here for any questions that you have and we thank you for your time. [10:16] Thank you for your thorough presentation. [10:19] Questions, comments from the board? [10:23] Okay, here in none. [10:25] We'll recruit to the propositions, [10:28] because I do have some questions, but all of them. [10:32] Okay, thank you, Mr. Ratman. [10:34] All right. [10:35] Any questions? [10:37] Please, and thank you. [10:40] Your bottoming comments, board of health. [10:43] The lot will be serviced by municipal water and sewer. [10:45] All dwellings must comply with the minimum standards [10:48] and it's a fitness for human habitations. [10:50] He stands very cold, chapter two. [10:52] From the city planner, he has no comment [10:55] on the seminar request. [10:57] From the city engineer, no objections from him. [11:02] Water, common city water is available [11:03] from the existing Indian city water, man-out-fully Bayway. [11:06] Plans are required and need to be sent to D.P.W. [11:09] for water service, gay vows and curb stops. [11:12] D.P.W. permits are required [11:13] including city license contract [11:14] or road open and and or trench. [11:16] D.P.W. specifications apply including pressure test and materials installation and new water [11:22] meter with updated radio frequency unit and respect and approval, prior notice is required [11:27] before any say water work is to be performed and inspection will be required before that [11:32] done. [11:33] From the conservation agent, the applicant will need to file a nose content with a conservation [11:39] commission as a proposed project is within the 100-foot buffer to bordering vegetated wetlands. [11:45] And from the DPW, no objection to the variance request and fired upon him and he's reviewed [11:54] the plans and determined that sufficient fired upon and access does exist. [11:58] Thank you, Madam Secretary. [12:00] All right, let's know for the questions or comments, open it up to the public. [12:04] Is there anyone here who would like to speak in favor? [12:07] Anyone who would like to speak in favor here and not? [12:10] Is there anyone who would like to speak in opposition? [12:15] Any anybody would like to speak in opposition? [12:18] Now's the time, [12:22] all set? [12:26] If you could go over the microphone, please, and give us your name and address for the record. [12:31] Thank you. [12:39] Raise your right hand. [12:41] So, other testimony about to give the truth to the whole truth, not the truth to all of you, God? [12:45] Yes, sir. [12:46] Name and address for the record, please. [12:47] My name is Attorney Bill Brown. [12:49] My address is up in Wayne, with mass. [12:52] it's my daughter, Shilism Hiding Street. The concern she has is over the [12:59] development down there. They wouldn't have been notified when the original [13:03] hearing was going up there to put that roadway in there and there, you and it [13:08] directly abuts it. The reason we're here tonight is she gave me this stuff a [13:14] little bit late coming down and they were of the concern that that house was [13:17] going to go right in next to they a lot. And it appears for me looking at the [13:23] plan here that it's going to be a good distance away from it. So I don't think [13:27] she's got a concern with that. There was some concern and some talk about where [13:32] the property line was there. And I'll be looking into that down the road. But as far [13:39] as that house, I don't think it's really going to affect them right now. [13:42] All [13:44] right. All right. Thank you so much. [13:49] Anybody else would like to speak in opposition? [13:52] Hearing none. Mr. Accomend, do you have your comments that you were kindly reserving? [14:00] I went down there. Since there is a road of improvement and there are several duplexes and at least one triplex. [14:10] I just didn't believe my eyes because I thought I told them duplexes but I did see the triplex. [14:17] If Proposition 7 passes with the state, that particular property could end up with a minimum [14:27] of four single family houses. [14:30] So the proposal today will eliminate that and only have a duplex, because I noticed [14:38] The fire end has wetlands which have blocked one and the way the layout is getting an ADU would [14:48] be a little difficult also. [14:50] So I think utilization for that neighborhood is really going to be only a duplex so. [14:56] And I think, put the single film in. [15:11] The other side is a lot more. So if any problems, I don't see any problems they're going to have with, have building a house in that location. [15:25] So I've driven down Eldridge Street thousands of times and never gone down Felipe Wayne or the adjacent Wayne and I too was [15:34] Pleasantly surprised with the number of duplexes and multi-family. So it does seem like something that fits and is [15:43] consistent with the rest of the neighborhood [15:46] Anybody else have any other comments? [15:48] Okay need a motion [15:51] Okay motion was made and I need a second [15:55] Okay, motion was made in second-aid on the motion. Mr. Apeman. Yes, Mr. Joyce. Yes. Chair votes. Yes, Mr. Faria. [16:03] Mr. Dordority passes 5-0. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Have a great night. Thank you. [16:10] Okay, second case this evening. Case 3-5-2, Larkin, 24 Laneed Ways Street. [16:17] The variance from section 440-602, 440 attachment 3 of the zone ordinance to allow the development of a lot having zero feet of frontage and a lot with, instead of 150 feet of frontage and 100 feet lot with, but having a 15 foot wide right of way for access. [16:54] I need to make a disclosure on this ethics purposes, the petitioner on this case is a co-worker of mine, so I need to make that disclosure, I do believe that I can sit in here this and partially so I will be sitting on the case. [17:11] Thank you, Mr. Joyce. [17:14] All right, thank you, Mr. Chairman. [17:16] Again, Scott Farrier, representing Tom Lackin. [17:19] Tom's hoping to construct a home at 24 Laneway Street. [17:24] I have it called up, I'm looking at a blank block behind you, Mr. Chairman, but I think over there you guys can see everything, so. [17:32] So the property at 24 Laneway Street has zero frontage. [17:38] the reason we're here for a variance, we have adequate lot area, adequate setbacks to meet all the zoning requirements. [17:45] The lot has zero frontage. [17:47] Laneway Street is a private road that comes off of Burt Street. [17:51] Our lot is abutted by a segregation at golf course to the east and [17:57] then number 27 Smith, number 27 Laneway Street owned by the Smiths pretty much surrounds our property. [18:04] Our property was taken out of the larger property back in 1925. [18:09] So over 100 years ago, the property was taken out of the parent property, and [18:15] deeded at the time to a family member with zero frontage on laneway street, but [18:19] getting access to laneway street through a right of way. [18:23] So that right of way from the subject property to laneway street was in use from 1925 until I believe 2016. [18:31] the home on 2016, exploded and burned to the ground in a set vacant sense then since 2016. [18:41] Mr. Lackin is, I'm going to try to click to the plan. [18:46] Mr. Lackin is proposing to build a single family home meeting all the zoning setbacks smaller than the former footprint. [18:55] The former footprint is shown in red. [18:57] It was quite a large home, about 4,000 square feet. [19:01] Mr. Lackin is building a smaller house, single family home within that form of footprint. [19:08] The septic system was replaced relatively recently, so it has a current septic system. [19:15] We did go to the Conservation Commission back a couple of months ago and received conservation approval. [19:20] As we do, a butt to segregation at River, we have, in addition to wetlands, we have riverfront concerns that we had to hash out with the Conservation Commission. [19:29] So we've already taken care of that. [19:32] So again, in this instance, our hydrochip is certainly the size and the shape of the lot, peculiar lot layout having zero frontage being created that way over 100 years ago, is our hydrochip. [19:48] The home certainly fits within the character of the neighborhood as there was a house there for 90 years until the fire. [19:56] So, I think we're in meeting with the character of the neighborhood, and I think the fact that we have zero frontage on a 100-year-old lot meets the hardship requirement, Mr. Jim. [20:11] I'd be happy to answer any questions. [20:13] Questions, comments from the Board? Mr. Dardick? [20:15] Yes. Thanks. So this existing driveway you're showing your plan. Is that the existing driveway or is it that red line existing? [20:24] No, it's the existing driveway that you clearly have in mind. Right. Yep. [20:29] Okay. So it's a gravel driveway. Exactly. A gravel driveway comes off of Laneway Street. [20:37] And there was a foundation there before. There was a house there for 90 years. Right. [20:44] And when you need a variance? [20:46] Well, it's been over 10 years since the House burned. [20:49] So any grandfather protection, the house had or the lot had with zero front edges lost. [20:55] I figured if you have two years or three years to build on a grandfathered lot. [20:59] So because it's that vacant for 10 years at this point, it's no longer grandfathered as we understand it. [21:06] Well, I don't, I don't, that's, I guess if that's the law, that's the law that we agree with it, because I think that it was there, [21:13] there was a foundation there, and it's an existing right way to get into the property, that it should be in fact a lot. [21:21] I understand. [21:22] All right. [21:24] That's one of the other questions. [21:25] Thank you. [21:26] Thank you, Mr. Dardy. [21:27] Mr. Ackerman? [21:29] I think it's important that a guy made a sentence, a letter. [21:34] I think that should be read, and then I'll have some questions and some responses once the letter's read. [21:45] Just so to confirm, there is a requirement that you have to deal with in a certain period of time, [21:54] and if you don't, you lose the grid for other rights. [21:57] So, I know it's difficult, I mean, but the property is sat there, so that's why they're here tonight. [22:08] And the most important thing I think, once the letter's read, is that you've already got conservation approval. [22:16] You want the conservation, because a lot, it's in the letter. [22:20] Once the letter's read, you'll understand why I'm saying that. [22:25] I think that's what I said to him in due time, so we'll read the letter when the time [22:35] is appropriate. [22:36] Anybody else have any other questions, comments, Mr. Quarer? [22:42] Thank you, Mr. Chair. [22:44] Although I'm not voting on this, I had a little concern in the beginning when I heard that [22:48] there was absolutely no frontage, but now that you've explained it makes all the sense [22:51] in the world to me. [22:52] Thank you. [22:53] Thank you. [22:56] Mr. Erno. [22:57] Questions? [23:00] Communications. [23:01] Ones up. [23:05] From the Board of Health, the lot will be serviced by an onsite septic system and private [23:10] well. [23:10] All dwellings must comply with the minimum standards of fitness for human habitation, state sanitary [23:15] code, chapter 2. [23:18] From the city planner, he has no comment on the seminar request from the DPW, no objections [23:24] questions from the, I'm sorry, the engineer, no objections from the engineering department. [23:30] From the water department, city water is available from the existing 8-inch city water made on Laneway Street. [23:36] And they require the standard plans are required and they need to be sent into the DPW for water service, [23:41] gate valve and curb stops. [23:43] DPW permits are required, including city license contractor, road opening and or trench. [23:48] DPW specifications apply, including any backlog devices must be inspected by the plumber or [23:54] our city inspector, prior notice is required before any city water work is to be performed and inspections will be required before that fill in. [24:02] From the conservation agent, there are no conservation issues regarding the concerns for the variance. [24:08] There is an approved order of conditions with this project issued on August 19, 26. [24:14] Once the project is completed and the site is established, a certificate of compliance will need to be filed to close it out. [24:20] From [24:23] the GPW commissioner, no objection to the variance request, and then here's the letter from the neighbor. [24:35] Okay. [24:36] It's from Aaron and Karen Smith. [24:41] This communication is a response to the notice of the aforementioned here. [24:45] And first of all, I would like to thank the Board for the notice of the public hearing and the opportunity [24:49] to be a part of the process, the better off of our system of government rests upon the ability of the citizens, [24:55] citizens free to be part of this process. [24:58] Based on the proposed bearings, exemptions listed in the ZBA's communications and [25:02] the tax letter provided by myself outlined in the historical narrative based on my family's ownership of the [25:08] abut in property since 1962, we respectfully request the ZBA as a delirited body to consider the fallen. [25:18] It would appear that it would appear to be reasonable to request that the 15-foot [25:23] right-away be clearly marked in the field so that all parties may be allowed [25:27] to review the right-away and determinist legitimacy. [25:32] This would be especially important at the beginning and the end of the right-away. [25:38] Liability, hold harmless, agreement, deed modification. [25:42] Based on the attachment occasion that has outlined the various concerns over the last 64 years, [25:49] I have concern regarding implied liability with regard to detailed, [25:54] regard to severe weather events to include flooding and high-impact snow events. [25:59] Both deeds should include detailed verbiage that outlines and protects the owners of 27 Laneway Street. [26:05] Both current and future from any and all liability to any and all the properties that are generally [26:11] West of the Sarah-guesset River, damn, this would include the large parcel and a three [26:16] others tied to it. To be clear, these concerns are not about me and my family. [26:20] This is about potential assumed liability and perpetuity, not for a week, not for [26:25] a month or two, or a year, but forever. We cannot accept any liability that could [26:30] potentially be tied to these properties and will vigorously defend the property [26:35] from said liability. Other liabilities. The right-of-way traverse, [26:40] Travis is through our property as heavily wooded with moderate tree growth on both sides. [26:45] The right-of-way will have to be cleared to the extent needed to prevent the trees from blockade access [26:50] to the 24 laneway street property should they come down for any reason. [26:54] In addition, there is potential liability related to impact for future buildings, [26:59] power lines, and people walking along the right-of-way and border in areas. [27:03] These areas should be addressed so that these concerns be mitigated to an agreeable extent. [27:10] Expense sharing related to access maintenance, since the current and future owners of 27 laneway street and [27:17] the associated Weston facing properties will be responsible for all costs related to the upkeep and [27:22] inspections of the sale against River Dam. [27:24] I feel it is reasonable for there to be a formal agreement that outlines some monetary contribution [27:30] to an escrow account held for the purpose of these expenses. [27:34] The concept is fairly straightforward. [27:36] a 24-laneway contributes to wear and tear of the robbery, which includes the dam. [27:41] 24-laneway also has a vested interest in maintaining the dam, therefore they should [27:46] contribute to the expenses. [27:48] I cannot see how this would be anything but fear. [27:53] In conclusion, I would like to once again thank the ZBA and the Conservation Commission [27:57] for the opportunity to bring these matters to light. [28:00] And I sincerely encourage the Board and the Commission to carefully consider the proposal [28:05] to provide all deliberative discussions outlined in all the circumstances that have been [28:10] brought forward. [28:11] And as a point of reference, since we are not the ones requesting these variances, [28:16] we should not be required to address them. [28:19] The participants should address them. [28:20] In addition, we realize that some of these issues are generally not the preview of the ZBA. [28:25] However, I feel that they should be a matter of record. [28:29] These points made here are fair and reasonable based on the actual conditions and historical [28:33] Oracle events as outlined in this separate document, because this is all I got. [28:41] Thank you so much. [28:43] Madam Secretary, Mr. Ackerman, do you want to comment? [28:46] I'm going to wait until we get, if the native speak, that I get some questions of the engineer. [28:54] Anybody here would like to speak in favor? [28:57] Anyone like to speak in favor here and on, is there anybody here who would like to speak in opposition? [29:02] Okay, come on down to the microphone. [29:24] My name is Aaron Smith. [29:25] I live at 27 Laneway Street. [29:27] Raise your hand. [29:28] So are the testimony. [29:30] Let's give the truth, the whole truth. [29:31] So I hope you got it. [29:32] Yes. [29:35] Cameron. [29:36] Thank you. [29:36] Name an address for the record, please, ma'am. [29:38] Oh, Karen Smith, 27 Laneway Street taught in Mass. [29:43] Oh, no. [29:47] Okay. [29:48] Thank you for inviting me to speak this evening. [29:51] I appreciate the opportunity. [29:53] I will be as brief as possible, I'm sure that you folks want to get home to your families. [30:00] Although somewhat unrelated to the decision today, the historical record matters as it relates to the project. [30:08] Let me say for the record that I have no opposition to responsible development within the city, responsible development fuels the local economy and funds city services. You as the deliberative body make critical decisions regarding many projects. My assumption is that most of them are fairly straightforward and require you to lay out a few conditions that will mitigate the [30:31] concerns, I assure you this project is not that. [30:37] There is a due diligence issue. [30:39] The original home was tragically lost in 2015. [30:42] Since that time, the property has been on and off the market several times. [30:48] It is well documented that with the current state of the real estate, boom, that [30:52] listing times for building lots are very short. [30:57] It would seem fairly apparent to any potential buyer, [31:03] that access to and from the property is unusual to say the least. [31:08] Some of the questions a reasonable person might ask would be who owns the road? [31:15] Who maintains the road? [31:18] Where is the right of way? [31:19] Where does it begin and end? [31:21] If the water level rises near the home, will it be impacted? [31:25] Can I get to my house during severe events? [31:28] I ask these questions, because I've lived there for 62 years, and every one of those things has been a problem. [31:35] No questions were posed to me regarding the project prior to where we are now. [31:42] My assumption is, and a question I would ask is, maybe we were thinking we were just going to be able to fly this thing under the radar. [31:50] That's not going to happen. [31:51] This project and the deed should include language related to flood liability, access [31:57] and maintenance agreements, and clearly agreed upon and added to the property [32:02] records of both parcels. [32:05] There is only one way in and one way out of this property. [32:10] Should that access become impaired for any reason, that responsibility, if alleged, to be [32:19] The under-my control will be my concern related to 24 laneway street. [32:27] Sometime in the late 1920s, a one-and-a-half acre parcel was separated from a 250-acre [32:33] parcel as a result of a marriage between the chafes and the gambles. [32:39] I do not know why an odd-shaped parcel, basically on the river, was pulled out of a 250-acre [32:46] or parcel, and I don't think we'll ever know that. [32:51] The parcel now known as 24 Laneway Street is bounded easterly by the Segregants at River. [32:57] The couple decided to build the structure very close to the River's edge, most likely for [33:03] us aesthetic reasons. [33:05] The front door was 35 feet from the River's edge at mean water level. [33:11] The water level fluctuates wildly, sometimes as far as 45 feet away from the front door, [33:20] under drought conditions, to as close as 25 feet away, under flooding conditions. [33:26] During extreme flooding conditions, such as the 2005 dam crisis in Taunton, [33:31] water levels did creep much closer than 25 feet to the front door. [33:37] We all know that a new project of this scope, as originally conceived in 1920, would be virtually [33:44] impossible in 2026. [33:47] In 2026, there would be concerns regarding the proximity of the river, the ACEC, [33:54] setbacks, septic systems, well water, et cetera. [33:57] In the 1920s, I am fairly confident that the permit approval process was either non-existent [34:05] or very limited. [34:07] Due to the size and shape of the property, and its proximity to the segregants at River, [34:12] structure placement options are very limited. [34:17] Over the last 60 years, the home has had issues due to its proximity to the water line. [34:24] These include soil wash out. [34:27] Soil wash out is a process that involves continual intrusion of water in an area, [34:35] and as the water level rises and falls, silt washes out of the soil structure and leaves a void. [34:42] Over time, this can form a large void against the foundation or under a foundation. [34:50] When this occurs, failures can happen. [34:55] This was happening to the previous structure throughout its life. [34:59] At one point, the ground level against this foundation for the original house had sunk [35:03] about 18 inches at the entire perimeter of the home, meaning you had a soil level here, [35:12] you had a soil level here originally against the foundation, it was down 18 inches. [35:17] Again, due to the soil wash out. [35:18] This was obviously a major structural concern since the river elevation routinely [35:25] rises above the foundation floor. [35:28] There is no practical way to engineer this out of the equation. [35:33] Water intrusion into the cellar is another factor, or was another factor. [35:38] Pumps were installed in the cellar to control water intrusion. [35:41] This may be marginally effective to some degree under drought or even mean water levels. [35:47] But this was an essentially an exercise in futility, pumping water in a circle when there [35:53] is power under river flood stage. [35:58] There is no pump that can keep up with it. [36:01] Then we come to liability and litigation. [36:03] Should the project move forward, there will be problems, and there will always be problems. [36:11] If there is some sort of failure related to flooding or soil wash out, the legal process will [36:18] begin. [36:19] First, the insurer of 24-laneway will look at the associated costs and repairs, see the [36:25] high numbers, and start looking to point the finger elsewhere. [36:30] Most likely at the engineer and the builder first, then they will look at various aspects [36:34] of pathways to project completion, and at some point I will be brought into that, simply [36:41] because I control the segregants at River Dam. [36:48] These are the simple facts of 2026, we all know it. [36:52] We live in a very litigious society. [36:55] I must defend the property from this scenario. [36:58] I have no choice here. [36:59] This is in perpetuity forever. [37:02] It's not about me, not about my family. [37:04] It's about a hundred and ten acre piece of property [37:06] that is going to have assumed liability in perpetuity. [37:12] You as a deliberative body have the authority [37:14] to require an impersonal third-party review chosen by this body to review and advise this body, of the project paid for at the petitioner's expense. [37:28] This will ensure that the project, as proposed, is reasonable, responsible, and prudent. [37:33] It will also allow you to review and require appropriate conditions for the project. [37:38] I am sure that the project plans are accurate and complete. [37:42] However, they may be unknowingly incomplete or inaccurate as they were proposed from [37:52] the perspective of the petitioner and reviewed not by a third party. [37:57] In conclusion, I have a simple question. [38:00] It was a mistake to build this home 100 years ago and we're going to do it again, albeit [38:08] using improved construction methods. [38:10] In the end, there are three things. [38:13] There are known unknowns, unknown unknowns, and known [38:17] knowns. [38:18] It is clear that this is an example of a known, unknown. [38:22] We all know that there will be future flooding events. [38:26] It is unknown when or how bad they will be. [38:32] Southeast and New England, weather runs in cycles [38:34] approximately in a 20-year cycle. [38:36] If you start with a hurricane of 38 and carrying on [38:39] through the hurricane of the 50s include Hurricane Carol, the [38:42] blizzard of 78, the dam crisis of 2005, the blizzard of 2026, [38:48] sprinkle in Hurricane Bob and Halloween storm of 1991, [38:51] and you've had some doosies. [38:54] We have survived the wall down there, mainly through planning [38:58] and hard work. [39:01] If we ignore the history, we're doomed to repeat the mistake. [39:04] The true issue here is related to dam and the access across the dam and the control [39:14] of the dam and the liability to my property, [39:19] and I appreciate your time. [39:24] Thank you. [39:25] I'd just like to add something, in regards to the House, that was there at one time. [39:34] It was not built per se as a house. [39:38] It was basically built by the gambles to be like kind of a guest home. [39:46] It was very large. [39:47] It had a ballroom because I remember it going over there in 93. [39:52] It had a huge ballroom and all along up above on the second floor were [39:58] little rooms that people could stay because the gambles that lived in our house originally, [40:05] they had a cattle, they raised cattle and I think dairy cows, and they would have quite [40:15] a few visitors coming up because they were from Virginia, they would have visitors come [40:19] up, and that's where they would like to put them over at that 24-lane way. [40:27] So I think that part of the reason that they never really got involved with all specific [40:34] things is that they just needed a place for people to kind of an overflow. [40:40] And I know this only because of people that have come to the farm that have used to work [40:45] for the gambles way back when, I mean I'm sure the person has passed away because he was [40:51] like 80 when I was like 50, but they worked at the fine and all. [40:56] So he would tell us, you know, all about the place. [41:01] So I don't think originally it was for a regular living dwelling. [41:08] And over the years, the people that have stayed there have never stayed there for very long [41:15] because of all the problems with the house. [41:17] The last people that lived there were at Burnt Down. [41:22] They had two pumps in the house running 24-7, and that's why one of the reasons why the [41:30] house Burnt Down is because they got a, they're always losing electricity. [41:36] They got a generator run by propane, and they didn't run the wires of the propane correctly, [41:46] And that's how it burned down is we had in February the snow in the ice off the roof caused the [41:55] Pipes to burst and go all the propane go into the off [42:00] cell [42:00] And when somebody went to take a shower just blew up the house [42:06] So I mean it's had its problems. It is a beautiful spot. I don't blame anybody for wanting to be there, but [42:13] They you know they got to realize that they could run into that [42:16] Because no one's ever been happy there. [42:18] As many people there, they like being there at first, [42:22] and then it was just a headache for everybody, but just to be [42:26] aware, and the thing is basically what my husband, [42:30] he doesn't mind if somebody builds their lives there, [42:33] but he just doesn't want to be responsible over the years [42:36] to have to do anything more than what we do already. [42:43] For taking care of things to make sure this isn't like that, [42:46] because now there's someone else out there. [42:50] So. [42:51] Thank you so much, ma'am. [42:52] Okay. [42:53] Appreciate your comment. [42:54] Thank you. [42:55] Anybody else would have liked to speak in opposition? [42:59] Mr. Farrier, you're on. [43:01] Thank you. [43:03] Really the only thing I have to, I guess, to respond, Mr. Chairman, is the environmental [43:09] concerns, the concerns about the flooding of the Segregance at River. [43:12] That's exactly why we went to conservation first before we came to you folks in the [43:17] The flood elevation of the Segregants at River, set by FEMA, is elevation 90. [43:22] Our finished floor is going to be 17 feet above that. [43:26] Elevation 107, our basement floor is going to be 9 feet above it. [43:29] So the basement floor is 9 feet above the flood elevation. [43:32] So I think we've got, knowing that's the flood elevation, knowing the history of the area, [43:39] and knowing that there could be some basement and flooding issues. [43:43] That's why we've got to house that fire up in the air. [43:46] So certainly a nine-foot buffer between the flood elevation and the basement floor were pretty comfortable and confident with that and again, that's exactly why we went to conservation to give the Conservation Commission a chance to review or I think in in in this case where it is along the river, it's a little bit more complicated with the DEP regulation, so it goes through a pretty good review from DEP as well, so so we feel like it's been vetted pretty well at this point, environmentally, Mr. Chairman. [44:17] Mr. Farrer, is that street private all the way from Birch Street, all the way down? [44:24] Yes, correct. [44:25] And who maintains that street now? [44:27] I believe Mr. Smith does. [44:30] There is nothing formal in our deed that speaks to any maintenance, but Mr. Smith does take care of it. [44:39] It's a private way. [44:42] So I think like most private ways, the butters own up to the center line. [45:00] I know this would be pretty well. [45:03] Mr. Dardy, I'll stop. It's an unaccepted public way. It's not private agreement. Mr. Accomman. [45:12] First, I want to thank the individuals that coming up for us interviews. [45:26] Yes, sir. You're a certified engineer. Your company is registered with the state qualified. You went to conservation, [45:42] which was a very smart move. [45:44] move, because if you didn't, and you came here first, we'd probably tell you to go there, [45:49] and then come back. [45:50] It was Tom's idea to go to conservation first. [45:53] That was very bright. [45:56] He's smart. [45:56] You're talking about a 4,000 square foot half. [46:01] I'm rounding off and cutting it half down to 2,000. [46:05] We have major new building codes from the Commonwealth of Mass in the city of Taun, which [46:16] this house were complied to. [46:19] The city engineer will be monitoring the development as far as the engineering aspect. [46:28] The building department will monitor the actual structure. [46:32] It [46:35] is a right-away for what you're showing. [46:43] In your mind, have you found any written notification of the right-away where there was [46:52] agreements made? [46:54] So now it becomes a civil matter between the two parties. [47:01] This board is only responsible to look at. [47:05] is there access there is a legal right away which is shown and you said it's [47:13] registered and the city the partners will monitor the actual structure and [47:20] construction of the whole property conservation at many points and I haven't [47:28] We've seen the conservation decision, but we got a very good conservation board, [47:36] a monitor and a very stringent on conservation issues. [47:42] Being along the waterway, you've got to also meet DEP requirements. [47:49] I, along with my colleague at Carrera, I first looked at this, [47:55] are going to be a long night because I'm going to be really asking questions and probably [48:02] be negative. But after reading everything, and it was very detailed letter and a very [48:09] detailed explanation here, two very important points come. Most of them are conservation [48:18] issues, which was handled. If they approved it, the move forward, I'm not going to be [48:25] there to challenge, you know, what conservation done. I go along whatever their decision is. [48:33] I know the city departments are going to monitor the construction and look out things. [48:39] fight apartment gave approval they can get there that's what counts so to me it [48:48] comes down to now being a civil matter determined what agreement could be [48:54] made between the two parties and this board has never and I've been on the board [49:00] But almost 31 years of jumped in and ordered that you have to do this and do that. [49:10] We've recommended please sit down, try to work things out, and I'm going to say please [49:16] sit down and try to work things out. [49:18] But we don't have the authority to tell you you have to do X, Y and Z, and we don't have [49:25] authority tell the owner to do that's why you'd see that's again that's what the courts are that's [49:33] what neighbors do so in light of that you've [49:41] been here before I know you're firm I know you're [49:45] going to be monitoring this will based on the 2026 requirements not previous requirements when [49:54] And this was done. [49:56] So again, when I first looked at it, I was a definite no. [50:01] But again, as I dug into it, I became a marginal no. [50:06] And after knowing the conservation approved and looking into the matter, I'm sorry for [50:14] the Smiths, but I've become a positive yes. [50:16] and I think the main draw says if this board approves it, I think the owner and the Smiths should [50:29] get together and try to work out something legally that can be done because this board does not have [50:35] that authority. [50:40] Thank you, Mr. O'Connor. Mr. Dardy? [50:45] So I have to assume, I'm not going to assume what I asked, this right away, is it not part of a deed, is it not a deed it's right away going into the property? [50:56] The right-of-way off of Laneway Street, correct? [50:58] Okay, yes. [51:00] And Laneway is a public non-exceptive role, according to Mr. Smith. [51:07] Correct. [51:07] And are there any other houses on the street? [51:09] I think if you look here, just the three houses way up in the front, off of Burt Street, but they do front-off of Laneway, so they're at three houses. [51:18] Yeah. [51:22] Thank you. [51:22] Mr. Joyce, how many? [51:25] I don't have any comments I know. [51:28] Mr. Turner, all set. [51:30] Yeah, I'll set. [51:31] Okay. [51:33] All right, gentlemen, well, we've motion will prove motion. [51:40] Motion will prove as presented was made by Mr. Dardy. [51:44] Do I have a second? [51:44] Second. [51:45] Second. [51:46] Okay, motion made and second. [51:47] Any further discussion? [51:49] Okay, here and on, on the motion, Mr. Doherty. [51:52] Yes. [51:53] Mr. Farah. [51:54] Yes. [51:54] Chair votes. [51:55] Yes, Mr. Joyce. [51:56] Yes. [51:56] Mr. Ackerman. [51:57] Yes. [51:58] It's approved. [51:59] Five-nothing. [52:00] Thank you. [52:00] Thank you. [52:01] Good luck. [52:02] Good night. [52:04] Okay, next case. [52:06] Streams to Realty LLC. [52:08] 168. [52:09] A street. [52:09] Case number three. [52:10] Five-four. [52:11] A variance from section 440. [52:13] attachment three of the zone ordinance will allow the reconstruction of a two-family [52:17] dwelling on the existing foundation having a front yard setback of 18 feet seven inches [52:24] from north out instead of 25 to raise your right hand please, so the testimony you're [52:32] about to give the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so I hope you got it. [52:35] Yes. [52:35] Name an address for the racket? [52:37] Jason Barrow, 69-12-Fev. [52:40] Roger. [52:40] Tell us who you want to do, sir. [52:44] I'm going to read off this, yeah, of course. [52:46] Good evening, my name is Jason Guerrell. [52:49] I'm here to request that in front of your setback relief, so I can continue to re-construction of the existing two family dwell in at 160 Bay Street. [52:57] During demolition, the work went further than originally planned because the existing civil play and surround structural components will be on repair. [53:03] The bill department advised me that my options were to remove the portion of the foundation within the setback, demolished the existing foundation and relocate the structure, or request relief from this board. [53:16] Removing or relocating the existing foundation will create a substantial financial hardship and require significant redesign and additional construction. [53:25] This property is also a corner lock so the front yard setback applies to both the front and side of the structure. [53:33] A typical interior lock would generally have a 15 foot side setback but this property requires 25 feet setback along that side. [53:42] The existing structure has approximately 18 feet which would normally be sufficient if this was not a corner lock. [53:50] I am requesting relief to continue rebuilding the two family dwelling using the existing foundation location. [53:57] I believe the corner lock conditions create a unique hardship and [54:00] granting this relief will allow the property to be safely completed in return to productive residential use. [54:07] Thank you for your consideration. [54:09] Thank you, I drove by that today along with all the others and I noticed that your lock was exceptionally clean. [54:14] And you're going to be, it's going to be first floor, second floor, or it's going to be, it's going to be two-and-a-half stories, so first floor, second floor, and half a story on the top. [54:26] Any other questions from any other board members? [54:28] Yeah, so are you going to increase this square-flange over the new building? [54:33] Yeah, so initially what was permitted to do, I'm keeping the same, I'm not changing the plans from the permit. [54:39] And it's just since we was trying to keep the existing first floor and the framing on the first floor and the sole plate, but by the time we got on the brick exterior, we realized we wasn't going to be able to save it. [54:53] So once we get to that point, then it brings me to here because I guess it's no longer grandfather in for the use. [55:08] Any questions from anyone else? [55:11] Department, comments, please, Madam Secretary. [55:17] From the Board of Health, a lot will be serviced by Miss World Water and Sewer. [55:21] All dwellings must comply with the minimum standards of fitness for human habitation, state [55:26] standard code 2. [55:29] City planner has no comment on the request. [55:33] From the engineer, no objection from the engineer's office, from the Water Department, [55:39] City Water Services, the existing buildings, no comments at this time. [55:43] From a conservation, there's no conservation concerns regarding the sweatshirt permit. [55:49] And then from DPW, no objection to the plan, but the restored bulkhead nearest to North [55:56] to have appears to be closer than the 18.7 variance request. [56:07] See the little bump out? [56:09] Yeah. [56:10] That bump out has to meet setbacks, too. [56:12] Let me just point this out. [56:14] I didn't notice that. [56:15] Then we measured that when we was enough. [56:17] Is that the problem? [56:17] Probably the bulk energy that have to be removed, [56:20] that you have to have to have probably re-avitized. [56:22] Yeah. [56:23] So we advertised from the 18 point. [56:25] No, but then we measured it when we was in a... [56:30] When I came in, we measured the bulkhead on the map. [56:34] Did a scale roller or something? [56:35] Yes, you used the... [56:37] Hold on, let me look at... [56:39] Well, that's the engineer I'm not going to... [56:42] Is the bulkhead on any now? [56:44] Yeah, existing. [56:49] So you have to be... [56:51] 25 to 9. [56:52] It can't be. [56:53] If the house is only 18. [56:55] It was there before. [57:00] It's... [57:00] So the house, the measurement is 18. [57:02] Yeah, but I remember I came when I came in and we measured it because see how the house is on an angle [57:07] So like it opens up as it goes now [57:09] But if it's obviously oh, let me look and see I have a clue in here if it's yeah, you know how you say that [57:15] Yeah, I thought we'd double check it before we go more than we don't have to re-abitize [57:24] Because I thought Kevin was here. I wasn't sure you got hung up later on. Yeah, we don't want you to get hung up [57:30] No, no, no, no, it's a comeback here. We get my scale up [58:12] Now we say that I think we did yeah [58:21] I remember we did cuz I I noticed it too [58:24] Well, no, I think it's, I [58:30] have to guess, I think, well, my glass is maybe 18 or 17, that's [58:36] 15, 16, 17. [58:40] It's cool. [58:41] Yeah. [58:45] But it could be close. [58:46] If you were, I mean, if you can fly, I think the planets are really kind of all the engineers. [58:52] But he used to, he's an engineer, he said, you'd have a question now. [58:55] He pointed out. [58:56] So the lot does work, so it could be, maybe you didn't. [59:03] It's something that you could sort of all later on either make an adjustment or modification [59:08] or you can come back, I'm sure if you come back, you know, you'd have to advertise correctly [59:15] but if the board won, they could wave the seat. [59:23] Yeah, just, well, is this the answer for both? [59:26] You'd have to try to breathe. [59:28] Would I have to make it? [59:30] Can I ask you a question if we don't vote tonight and it's continued a month it's [59:35] not going to affect you. [59:36] Yes. [59:39] No, it's a good question. [59:41] He wants to vote. [59:42] Now would I be able to keep it within that if 18? [59:46] Exactly. [59:47] Yeah. [59:47] I can make that one. [59:48] I can make that one advertised for us. [59:50] So if you advertise 18 and a half feet, you have to be with me. [59:52] Yeah, I can make anything outside of that. [59:54] It's going to be an issue. [59:55] Okay. [59:56] Now we're fine. [59:57] Understood. [59:57] Yeah, all right, so we [1:00:00] Any questions? From Mr. Jackson, I just want to make sure to do that. I did okay, yeah. Then the others was fired. Fire department reviewed and determined that fire department access does exist. [1:00:16] Thank you, Madam Secretary. Anyone here who would like to speak in favor, here are none. Anyone who would like to speak in opposition, need a motion. [1:00:26] Okay, a motion made and seconded. On the motion, Mr. Opperman. [1:00:31] and no problem with the project, actually uncomfortable voting with a major question there. [1:00:42] If he's understanding over the next few days that he's verifies that they need it advertised [1:00:53] that he should be informed that he has to come back next month. [1:00:57] Or he could choose to modify that. [1:00:59] He can modify the plan. He told us he understands what that I'm not [1:01:07] Asked to change anything. I'm just just wanted to bring it up to so I can vote years on this. Okay [1:01:15] So is that your vote Mr. Ackler? Yeah, it'll be yes. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Ackler [1:01:19] That was the longest just in the history of [1:01:25] Mr. Joyce. [1:01:27] Yes. [1:01:28] Chair votes, yes. [1:01:29] Mr. Faria. [1:01:30] Yes. [1:01:30] Mr. Daredi. [1:01:31] Yep. [1:01:31] To approve five nothing congratulations. [1:01:34] Thank you. [1:01:34] I made a further motion that should he have to come back to the fee be wait. [1:01:39] Okay. [1:01:39] Do I hear a second? [1:01:41] If he has to come back, that will waive the fee. [1:01:45] So motion made in second. [1:01:46] All those in favor? [1:01:48] Signify by saying aye. [1:01:49] The Chair votes aye. [1:01:50] motion passes, five and nothing. [1:01:52] Appreciate it. [1:01:53] Have a good night. [1:01:54] Sorry. [1:01:55] You too, thanks. [1:01:56] Okay. [1:01:57] Case number three, five, five. [1:01:59] DeSousa, five, Dartmouth Street. [1:02:01] A variance from section 440, attachment three. [1:02:03] And a special permit from section 440-503. [1:02:07] The zone ordinance will allow the extension [1:02:09] of a pre-existing on-conforming structure [1:02:11] by allowing 820 square foot one-story addition. [1:02:16] Well, the Waco doghouse have an 4.7-side yard setback instead of 15. [1:02:27] Raise your hand, sir. [1:02:31] My right hand. [1:02:36] It's where the testimony you're about to give the truth, all truth, all truth, so help [1:02:40] you, God. [1:02:41] Yes. [1:02:41] Name and address for the record? [1:02:43] John DeSooza, the North County Book. [1:02:47] Okay, you're on, Mr. DeSooza. [1:02:55] I'm here as the engineer from North County Group. [1:02:58] I do not own the house. [1:03:11] All right. [1:03:13] So back in 2018, we originally submitted the plan to this board and we received an approval for the expansion of the house and at that time was presented to the board that my clients looking to do a master suite on the backside of the house. [1:03:37] Unfortunately, my client, the funds ended up being a little tight, and I never got constructed. [1:03:45] So we're looking to come back in front of the board to reactivate the previous approval. [1:03:52] And we're going to look to add the master bedroom on the backside of the house. [1:03:59] The lot's only 66 feet wide when it was created. [1:04:03] It's got almost 9900 square feet. [1:04:06] It's one of the old time original lots [1:04:08] for the downtown area. [1:04:12] Everything else is a stain as there's a two coat garage [1:04:16] on the backside. [1:04:17] There's a blue patio area and a shed all over there [1:04:23] and there's plenty of a parking on the lot itself. [1:04:29] The house currently sits at 4.7 feet off of the north-west of Leeville property line [1:04:39] and the expansion of the house is not getting any closer to that. [1:04:44] The bulkhead, which is basically almost in the middle of the house right here, is getting [1:04:50] located to the back of the house over on the northwest corner of the house. [1:04:58] So, if the board has any questions, I'd be more than happy to answer. [1:05:04] Mr. Dard, would you have a question about the application? [1:05:08] Yeah, yeah, they're already built. [1:05:10] No. [1:05:12] So, there's a current permit right now for the enclosure of the, what used to be the [1:05:20] Rear porch, because that's getting converted over to kitchen space. [1:05:25] So there is an act of a building permit for that, and no variances were required for that. [1:05:32] Mr. Turner, any questions, Mr. Farrell? [1:05:37] Any questions, Mr. Joyce? [1:05:39] This is a three-family structure, correct the existing? [1:05:42] No, only two. [1:05:44] It looks like a three-family, because originally what happened is they used to rent out the first floor. [1:05:50] the people that owned it, lived on the second floor, and the third floor was the bedrooms for the second floor. [1:05:57] So it's listed as a two and it's still a two-family. [1:06:04] Okay. [1:06:06] Thank you, Mr. Joyce, Mr. Ackerman. [1:06:08] Any questions? [1:06:09] Comments? [1:06:11] Mr. Carrera? [1:06:13] Yes. [1:06:15] Comments? [1:06:16] Comments? [1:06:17] I'm sorry. [1:06:18] What a health. [1:06:19] All dwellers, let's comply with this minute. [1:06:22] Mememam's theme is a fitness for human habitation, state sanary quo chapter two. [1:06:27] From the city planner, I have no comments on the seminar requests from the engineer. [1:06:34] You know objections. [1:06:37] From the water department, the city water services just in building, and we're just going to comments from the conservation. [1:06:43] There are no conservation uses regarding the request. [1:06:46] and from the DPW, no objection, and then the fire, [1:06:53] I can get it. [1:06:55] No comment. [1:06:57] Okay. [1:06:58] Thank you, Madam Secretary. [1:07:00] Is there anyone here who would like to speak in favor? [1:07:04] Anyone who would like to speak in opposition? [1:07:07] Okay, here are none. [1:07:15] Motion was made to approve this presented. [1:07:17] Need a second. [1:07:19] Okay, motion made and seconded on the motion, Mr. Dardy. [1:07:24] Yes, Mr. Farrier. [1:07:25] Yes. [1:07:26] Chair votes, yes. [1:07:27] Mr. Joyce. [1:07:28] No. [1:07:29] Mr. Ackerman. [1:07:30] Yes. [1:07:31] Motion passes for the one to approve. [1:07:34] All right, thank you. [1:07:34] Congratulations. [1:07:37] Okay, if there's no other business, motion to adjourn. [1:07:49] All those in favour? [1:07:51] Aye. [1:07:53] Thank you, everybody. Have a good night.