1
00:00:02,676 --> 00:00:03,277
Interesting. Hurry now. Okay.

2
00:00:03,277 --> 00:00:03,477
Good evening, everyone. I

3
00:00:03,477 --> 00:00:04,478
m

4
00:00:04,478 --> 00:00:04,636
going to call tonight

5
00:00:04,636 --> 00:00:06,113
s

6
00:00:06,113 --> 00:00:08,148
Temecula City Council meeting

7
00:00:08,148 --> 00:00:08,315
to order at six pm Welcome.

8
00:00:08,315 --> 00:00:09,850
It

9
00:00:09,850 --> 00:00:11,752
s nice to see everyone here

10
00:00:11,752 --> 00:00:12,319
this evening. Tonight

11
00:00:12,319 --> 00:00:12,686
s

12
00:00:12,686 --> 00:00:13,720
invocation. We

13
00:00:13,720 --> 00:00:14,856
re going to

14
00:00:14,856 --> 00:00:16,391
invite up Sylvester Scott.

15
00:00:16,391 --> 00:00:16,925
Welcome this evening and then

16
00:00:16,925 --> 00:00:17,191
flag salute. We

17
00:00:17,191 --> 00:00:19,191
re going to

18
00:00:20,128 --> 00:00:23,498
have the Boy Scouts of America

19
00:00:23,498 --> 00:00:27,980
Troupe won 48 come up and do

20
00:00:33,410 --> 00:00:36,311
our flex sleep, so join us.

21
00:00:36,311 --> 00:00:38,711
Although merciful GOD Although

22
00:00:38,880 --> 00:00:41,280
hard, mighty in powerful.

23
00:00:42,984 --> 00:00:43,719
Although most kind father These

24
00:00:43,719 --> 00:00:45,854
servants have gathered together,

25
00:00:45,854 --> 00:00:48,854
turning to the Plicating by

26
00:00:49,240 --> 00:00:50,159
threshold. Desire and buying

27
00:00:50,159 --> 00:00:53,759
endless bounty is from my great

28
00:00:54,300 --> 00:00:56,699
assurance. They have no purpose.

29
00:00:56,699 --> 00:00:57,667
Save thy good pleasure. They

30
00:00:57,667 --> 00:01:00,667
have no intention save service

31
00:01:01,404 --> 00:01:02,504
to the world of humanity. Oh

32
00:01:02,504 --> 00:01:04,874
GOD make this assembly to

33
00:01:04,874 --> 00:01:07,274
radiance. Make the hearts

34
00:01:07,944 --> 00:01:09,944
merciful. Confirmed the

35
00:01:09,980 --> 00:01:11,448
bounties of the Holy Spirit.

36
00:01:11,448 --> 00:01:14,351
And, then with the power from

37
00:01:14,351 --> 00:01:16,751
heaven. Bless them with

38
00:01:18,121 --> 00:01:19,422
heavenly minds. Increase their

39
00:01:19,422 --> 00:01:21,958
sincerity. So that was all

40
00:01:21,958 --> 00:01:24,358
humility and contrition. They

41
00:01:24,662 --> 00:01:26,300
MAY turn to buy kingdom. And be

42
00:01:26,300 --> 00:01:29,300
occupied with service to the

43
00:01:29,633 --> 00:01:30,968
world of humanity. MAY each and

44
00:01:30,968 --> 00:01:34,371
one each one become a radiant

45
00:01:34,371 --> 00:01:37,971
candle. Made each one become a

46
00:01:37,975 --> 00:01:39,476
billion stars. MAY each one

47
00:01:39,476 --> 00:01:40,611
become beautiful and color and

48
00:01:40,611 --> 00:01:43,611
redolent of fragrance and the

49
00:01:43,848 --> 00:01:47,448
Kingdom of GOD. All kind father.

50
00:01:50,210 --> 00:01:51,990
For thy blessings. Considering

51
00:01:51,990 --> 00:01:54,390
not our shortcomings. Shelter

52
00:01:56,594 --> 00:01:59,970
us. Under the eye protection.

53
00:01:59,970 --> 00:02:02,697
Remember, not our sins. Hell s

54
00:02:04,136 --> 00:02:07,736
with my mercy. We are weak.

55
00:02:08,240 --> 00:02:08,507
That was mighty We are poor.

56
00:02:08,507 --> 00:02:10,507
Bell aren

57
00:02:12,744 --> 00:02:14,946
t rich. We are sick.

58
00:02:14,946 --> 00:02:18,546
How are the physician? We are

59
00:02:21,554 --> 00:02:22,550
needy. Now our most generous Oh

60
00:02:22,550 --> 00:02:24,223
GOD and hours without

61
00:02:24,223 --> 00:02:26,623
Providence. There are the

62
00:02:28,795 --> 00:02:31,795
powerful There are the giver.

63
00:02:52,190 --> 00:02:54,419
The art the beneficent.

64
00:02:57,658 --> 00:03:00,580
Everyone, please rise. Even

65
00:03:00,627 --> 00:03:01,329
uniform salute the flag. If not

66
00:03:01,329 --> 00:03:04,131
put your right hand over your

67
00:03:04,131 --> 00:03:08,331
heart. Join me in the Pledge of

68
00:03:08,703 --> 00:03:09,571
Allegiance. Ready begin. I

69
00:03:09,571 --> 00:03:12,407
pledge of allegiance to the

70
00:03:12,407 --> 00:03:14,476
flag of the United States of

71
00:03:14,476 --> 00:03:17,779
America and to the Republic for

72
00:03:17,779 --> 00:03:19,247
which it stands One nation

73
00:03:19,247 --> 00:03:19,881
under GOD, indivisible with

74
00:03:19,881 --> 00:03:22,881
liberty and justice for all.

75
00:03:28,324 --> 00:03:30,259
Two. Thank you very much. MADAM

76
00:03:30,259 --> 00:03:32,261
City clerk. MAY we please have

77
00:03:32,261 --> 00:03:34,864
the roll call. Yes Council

78
00:03:34,864 --> 00:03:35,430
member Alexander here, Council

79
00:03:35,430 --> 00:03:37,830
member Brown Here Council

80
00:03:38,734 --> 00:03:38,898
office here. Mayor shrank. I

81
00:03:38,898 --> 00:03:40,898
m

82
00:03:42,404 --> 00:03:42,638
here, Stuart. Thank you very

83
00:03:42,638 --> 00:03:43,872
much we

84
00:03:43,872 --> 00:03:45,410
ll move into

85
00:03:45,410 --> 00:03:46,976
presentations are first

86
00:03:46,976 --> 00:03:48,111
presentation this evening is is

87
00:03:48,111 --> 00:03:48,978
by David Preciado of I

88
00:03:48,978 --> 00:03:50,880
d Bailey

89
00:03:50,880 --> 00:03:51,114
regarding our city

90
00:03:51,114 --> 00:03:52,415
s annual

91
00:03:52,415 --> 00:03:54,415
comprehensive financial report.

92
00:03:56,919 --> 00:03:59,422
Welcome. Thank you. Alright, so

93
00:03:59,422 --> 00:04:00,490
good evening. My Name is David

94
00:04:00,490 --> 00:04:01,357
prosciutto you might have had

95
00:04:01,357 --> 00:04:02,526
David Showalter on the docket

96
00:04:02,526 --> 00:04:02,690
there at some point, but I

97
00:04:02,690 --> 00:04:04,294
ve

98
00:04:04,294 --> 00:04:07,164
been here on his behalf. He was

99
00:04:07,164 --> 00:04:10,267
in an arc in an accident can be

100
00:04:10,267 --> 00:04:10,934
here. However. I was the audit

101
00:04:10,934 --> 00:04:12,934
manager overseeing the

102
00:04:14,972 --> 00:04:16,240
financial statement audit. Um

103
00:04:16,240 --> 00:04:18,410
So are our responsibility as

104
00:04:18,410 --> 00:04:20,345
the auditor was to express an

105
00:04:20,345 --> 00:04:22,247
opinion as to whether or not

106
00:04:22,247 --> 00:04:24,415
the financial statements were

107
00:04:24,415 --> 00:04:25,160
presented fairly part of our

108
00:04:25,160 --> 00:04:27,160
audit included the

109
00:04:27,151 --> 00:04:27,418
consideration of the city

110
00:04:27,418 --> 00:04:28,853
s

111
00:04:28,853 --> 00:04:30,354
internal controls for the

112
00:04:30,354 --> 00:04:31,890
purpose of determining our

113
00:04:31,890 --> 00:04:34,890
audit procedures and not to

114
00:04:34,659 --> 00:04:37,590
provide Ah assurance concerning

115
00:04:37,362 --> 00:04:40,362
those internal controls. Um in

116
00:04:40,465 --> 00:04:42,200
the audit process. We gather

117
00:04:42,200 --> 00:04:44,600
evidence from inquiries with

118
00:04:45,203 --> 00:04:47,603
staff verification with third

119
00:04:47,739 --> 00:04:49,739
parties vouching transactions

120
00:04:51,420 --> 00:04:51,543
to supporting documentation and

121
00:04:51,543 --> 00:04:53,780
performing analytical

122
00:04:53,780 --> 00:04:54,480
procedures. So basedn The

123
00:04:54,480 --> 00:04:56,880
evidence that was gathered

124
00:04:58,840 --> 00:04:59,752
during the audit. We issued a

125
00:04:59,752 --> 00:05:01,870
unmodified opinion over the

126
00:05:01,870 --> 00:05:03,122
financial statements and this

127
00:05:03,122 --> 00:05:03,823
is a clean opinion and is the

128
00:05:03,823 --> 00:05:06,823
highest level of assurance that

129
00:05:08,160 --> 00:05:08,394
we can provide. So Ah. The

130
00:05:08,394 --> 00:05:10,394
auditor

131
00:05:10,396 --> 00:05:12,632
s report also contains

132
00:05:12,632 --> 00:05:14,968
a emphasis of matter Paragraph

133
00:05:14,968 --> 00:05:15,201
So, This paragraph draws the

134
00:05:15,201 --> 00:05:16,136
reader

135
00:05:16,136 --> 00:05:16,836
s attention to the

136
00:05:16,836 --> 00:05:19,236
implementation of a new

137
00:05:19,706 --> 00:05:22,706
accounting standard. Uh so this

138
00:05:22,776 --> 00:05:24,878
standard is related to leases.

139
00:05:24,878 --> 00:05:26,579
So the impact of the standard

140
00:05:26,579 --> 00:05:26,846
on the city

141
00:05:26,846 --> 00:05:28,114
s financial

142
00:05:28,114 --> 00:05:29,684
statements is included as a

143
00:05:29,684 --> 00:05:29,849
footnote disclosure, so that

144
00:05:29,849 --> 00:05:31,849
s

145
00:05:32,186 --> 00:05:35,550
footnote number 18. Uh um, our

146
00:05:35,550 --> 00:05:36,900
opinion Within the auditor

147
00:05:36,900 --> 00:05:36,957
s

148
00:05:36,957 --> 00:05:39,593
report is not affected with

149
00:05:39,593 --> 00:05:40,260
regards to this matter, so we

150
00:05:40,260 --> 00:05:43,260
still have a clean unmodified

151
00:05:44,698 --> 00:05:44,898
opinion. Um So moving on here.

152
00:05:44,898 --> 00:05:46,898
There

153
00:05:47,335 --> 00:05:49,735
s certain balances within

154
00:05:49,771 --> 00:05:51,873
the financial statements that

155
00:05:51,873 --> 00:05:53,608
are derived from estimates, so

156
00:05:53,608 --> 00:05:53,874
those balances are related to

157
00:05:53,874 --> 00:05:55,874
the city

158
00:05:56,611 --> 00:05:57,812
s pension and other

159
00:05:57,812 --> 00:05:59,812
post employment benefit

160
00:06:01,820 --> 00:06:03,251
liabilities and are both based

161
00:06:03,251 --> 00:06:05,353
upon valuations from actuaries,

162
00:06:05,353 --> 00:06:07,355
So. These balances are

163
00:06:07,355 --> 00:06:07,923
sensitive based upon the inputs

164
00:06:07,923 --> 00:06:10,923
that the actuaries are are

165
00:06:11,693 --> 00:06:13,595
using. Ah So, for example, the

166
00:06:13,595 --> 00:06:16,598
discount rate if it moves up or

167
00:06:16,598 --> 00:06:19,167
down 1%. It could have a huge

168
00:06:19,167 --> 00:06:21,436
difference on the net pension

169
00:06:21,436 --> 00:06:23,172
liability or liability. So.

170
00:06:23,172 --> 00:06:24,774
That relationship has been

171
00:06:24,774 --> 00:06:25,942
disclosed as a separate

172
00:06:25,942 --> 00:06:27,176
footnote, so that

173
00:06:27,176 --> 00:06:28,945
s footnote

174
00:06:28,945 --> 00:06:29,245
Number nine for the city

175
00:06:29,245 --> 00:06:31,245
s

176
00:06:31,280 --> 00:06:33,820
pension and footnote, number,

177
00:06:33,820 --> 00:06:34,250
14 for other posts and claim

178
00:06:34,250 --> 00:06:36,650
other post employment benefit

179
00:06:38,120 --> 00:06:41,120
liabilities. Um So moving on

180
00:06:41,157 --> 00:06:42,626
here. There were no corrected

181
00:06:42,626 --> 00:06:44,940
or uncorrected misstatements

182
00:06:44,940 --> 00:06:45,595
identified during our audit,

183
00:06:45,595 --> 00:06:46,796
and there were no disagreements

184
00:06:46,796 --> 00:06:49,196
with management during the

185
00:06:50,330 --> 00:06:51,268
course of the audit. All city

186
00:06:51,268 --> 00:06:51,935
staff were extremely

187
00:06:51,935 --> 00:06:54,304
professional during the entire

188
00:06:54,304 --> 00:06:56,600
audit. They were super helpful

189
00:06:56,600 --> 00:07:00,110
and were a huge part in the

190
00:07:00,110 --> 00:07:01,120
success of the audit. Um To

191
00:07:01,120 --> 00:07:01,712
conclude I on behalf of my

192
00:07:01,712 --> 00:07:03,214
Bailey. I

193
00:07:03,214 --> 00:07:04,915
d just like to thank

194
00:07:04,915 --> 00:07:06,383
you all for allowing us to

195
00:07:06,383 --> 00:07:08,180
serve as your auditor and we

196
00:07:08,180 --> 00:07:11,618
look forward to serving in the

197
00:07:12,656 --> 00:07:13,257
future and That concludes my

198
00:07:13,257 --> 00:07:15,427
remarks. Okay so nervous

199
00:07:15,427 --> 00:07:17,429
appeared. Well you could

200
00:07:17,429 --> 00:07:18,964
everyone behind you was

201
00:07:18,964 --> 00:07:21,364
thoroughly enthralled with the

202
00:07:21,699 --> 00:07:22,100
drawing the auditors, you kids.

203
00:07:22,100 --> 00:07:24,100
I mean it

204
00:07:24,669 --> 00:07:25,670
s the best. Now. We

205
00:07:25,670 --> 00:07:26,905
Appreciate you, David, and that

206
00:07:26,905 --> 00:07:29,541
and the team and we appreciate

207
00:07:29,541 --> 00:07:31,242
the finance team as well. Are

208
00:07:31,242 --> 00:07:34,242
there any questions or comments

209
00:07:35,247 --> 00:07:36,549
for Okay. You got off easy

210
00:07:36,549 --> 00:07:39,218
tonight. Take care. Thank you.

211
00:07:39,218 --> 00:07:39,818
Thanks. Okay. We

212
00:07:39,818 --> 00:07:41,320
ll go ahead

213
00:07:41,320 --> 00:07:42,388
and move to our annual joint

214
00:07:42,388 --> 00:07:43,121
meeting in City Council in the

215
00:07:43,121 --> 00:07:43,292
Planning Commission. We

216
00:07:43,292 --> 00:07:44,756
re

217
00:07:44,756 --> 00:07:46,825
going to actually reschedule

218
00:07:46,825 --> 00:07:47,326
this item for a future meeting.

219
00:07:47,326 --> 00:07:49,326
And. We

220
00:07:49,529 --> 00:07:50,130
ll move into our board

221
00:07:50,130 --> 00:07:50,307
and commission reports and

222
00:07:50,307 --> 00:07:52,307
we

223
00:07:52,532 --> 00:07:54,400
ll go ahead and start with

224
00:07:54,400 --> 00:07:55,969
Community Services Commission

225
00:07:55,969 --> 00:07:56,936
chair. Sizemore Europe. Good

226
00:07:56,936 --> 00:07:58,738
evening, Mayor Schlink Mayor

227
00:07:58,738 --> 00:08:00,306
pro tem Stewart and City

228
00:08:00,306 --> 00:08:01,808
Council members. I am Kathy

229
00:08:01,808 --> 00:08:04,210
Sizemore! I am the chairperson

230
00:08:04,210 --> 00:08:04,911
for the Community Services

231
00:08:04,911 --> 00:08:06,647
Commission. We are Commission

232
00:08:06,647 --> 00:08:08,816
of five. We have our newest

233
00:08:08,816 --> 00:08:10,951
commissioners Ernest Castro. We.

234
00:08:10,951 --> 00:08:11,752
Have you on hawks Jeff

235
00:08:11,752 --> 00:08:14,555
Kingsburg. Gary Audie is our

236
00:08:14,555 --> 00:08:16,290
vice chair and myself. The

237
00:08:16,290 --> 00:08:18,158
purpose of our commission is to

238
00:08:18,158 --> 00:08:19,920
review and make recommendations

239
00:08:19,920 --> 00:08:21,461
on topics related to the parks

240
00:08:21,461 --> 00:08:22,829
and rec element of the general

241
00:08:22,829 --> 00:08:24,465
plan and to provide parks and

242
00:08:24,465 --> 00:08:26,100
rec services and programming

243
00:08:26,100 --> 00:08:27,969
for the community. Next slide.

244
00:08:27,969 --> 00:08:30,271
Our Last meeting was on Monday,

245
00:08:30,271 --> 00:08:33,271
FEBRUARY, the 13th We approved

246
00:08:33,407 --> 00:08:35,276
the action minutes for the

247
00:08:35,276 --> 00:08:38,780
JANUARY 9th meeting. We also

248
00:08:38,780 --> 00:08:39,714
had a presentation from Stacy

249
00:08:39,714 --> 00:08:41,783
Fox in public works on some

250
00:08:41,783 --> 00:08:43,218
playground equipment and safety

251
00:08:43,218 --> 00:08:44,319
servicing projects. We have

252
00:08:44,319 --> 00:08:46,540
some really fun upgrades and

253
00:08:46,540 --> 00:08:48,256
remodels come into some of our

254
00:08:48,256 --> 00:08:51,256
parks in 2023 1 of the items

255
00:08:51,393 --> 00:08:52,961
that all of our commissioners

256
00:08:52,961 --> 00:08:54,262
Very complimentary about and

257
00:08:54,262 --> 00:08:54,863
recognized was the

258
00:08:54,863 --> 00:08:56,531
accessibility and inclusion

259
00:08:56,531 --> 00:08:56,965
that is involved in these

260
00:08:56,965 --> 00:08:57,732
Parker models. It

261
00:08:57,732 --> 00:08:59,350
s really

262
00:08:59,350 --> 00:09:02,635
Going to be really be something

263
00:09:03,639 --> 00:09:05,107
else. We also had a very

264
00:09:05,107 --> 00:09:06,842
thorough discussion of our

265
00:09:06,842 --> 00:09:09,242
community of our commissions.

266
00:09:09,645 --> 00:09:10,713
Mission. Um. What We were were

267
00:09:10,713 --> 00:09:12,615
organized to do and our

268
00:09:12,615 --> 00:09:13,482
priorities. We talked a lot

269
00:09:13,482 --> 00:09:15,170
about what our priorities are

270
00:09:15,170 --> 00:09:17,854
going to be in our vision for

271
00:09:17,854 --> 00:09:19,255
the upcoming year and we are

272
00:09:19,255 --> 00:09:20,890
looking forward to sharing that

273
00:09:20,890 --> 00:09:22,692
with you at our annual meeting,

274
00:09:22,692 --> 00:09:24,270
which will be on MARCH 14th.

275
00:09:24,270 --> 00:09:25,128
And. I did want to include

276
00:09:25,128 --> 00:09:27,263
something that just keeps

277
00:09:27,263 --> 00:09:28,198
coming up meeting after meeting

278
00:09:28,198 --> 00:09:31,340
all of our commissioners are

279
00:09:31,340 --> 00:09:32,350
just very involved in all the

280
00:09:32,350 --> 00:09:33,938
elements of community services

281
00:09:33,938 --> 00:09:36,400
and something that keeps coming

282
00:09:36,400 --> 00:09:37,308
up is just accolades for the

283
00:09:37,308 --> 00:09:38,542
staff. Just good experiences

284
00:09:38,542 --> 00:09:39,677
with the staff and all the

285
00:09:39,677 --> 00:09:41,679
different events and services

286
00:09:41,679 --> 00:09:42,713
that we participate in. We will

287
00:09:42,713 --> 00:09:43,847
be having our next meeting,

288
00:09:43,847 --> 00:09:47,284
which will be on Monday, MARCH

289
00:09:47,284 --> 00:09:47,918
13th. Thank you. Thank you very

290
00:09:47,918 --> 00:09:48,820
much. Cheers, Sizemore. We

291
00:09:48,820 --> 00:09:49,620
ll

292
00:09:49,620 --> 00:09:52,620
move on to our planning

293
00:09:53,425 --> 00:09:55,326
Commission chair, Truly Trejo.

294
00:09:55,326 --> 00:09:57,395
Hello. I have a short report

295
00:09:57,395 --> 00:10:00,932
tonight. We met a couple weeks

296
00:10:00,932 --> 00:10:03,134
ago I on FEBRUARY 15th. Um, for

297
00:10:03,134 --> 00:10:06,734
revocation of a c p. And

298
00:10:06,738 --> 00:10:07,905
tomorrow night we meet at six

299
00:10:07,905 --> 00:10:09,408
pm to, um, hear information on

300
00:10:09,408 --> 00:10:09,608
a resolution. So. That

301
00:10:09,608 --> 00:10:11,608
s all I

302
00:10:12,144 --> 00:10:12,611
have tonight. Thank you thank

303
00:10:12,611 --> 00:10:13,745
you very much. We

304
00:10:13,745 --> 00:10:15,745
ll go ahead

305
00:10:16,515 --> 00:10:17,516
and move on, Um to our Public

306
00:10:17,516 --> 00:10:19,916
Traffic Safety Commission and

307
00:10:20,652 --> 00:10:23,652
chair Carter welcome. Mr Mayor,

308
00:10:25,557 --> 00:10:29,157
City Council. Can you chair Can,

309
00:10:31,731 --> 00:10:33,566
You, Turn on your mic. Start

310
00:10:33,566 --> 00:10:36,502
again. Good evening, Mr Mayor,

311
00:10:36,502 --> 00:10:39,238
Council members and city staff.

312
00:10:39,238 --> 00:10:41,600
Public safety traffic. Public

313
00:10:41,600 --> 00:10:42,808
Traffic Safety Commission

314
00:10:42,808 --> 00:10:43,910
consists of five commissioners

315
00:10:43,910 --> 00:10:46,310
Commissioner Ackerman myself as

316
00:10:47,481 --> 00:10:50,830
the chair David Maddox is the

317
00:10:50,830 --> 00:10:51,251
co chair j. J, James Richardson

318
00:10:51,251 --> 00:10:53,190
and Bradley Sullivan. We meet

319
00:10:53,190 --> 00:10:54,988
the fourth Thursday of each

320
00:10:54,988 --> 00:10:56,122
month where we review and make

321
00:10:56,122 --> 00:10:58,522
recommendations to the council

322
00:10:58,625 --> 00:11:00,260
on topics related to speed

323
00:11:00,260 --> 00:11:02,290
zones. Stop signs signals

324
00:11:02,290 --> 00:11:03,970
pavement market markings.

325
00:11:03,970 --> 00:11:05,497
Traffic design and engineering

326
00:11:05,566 --> 00:11:07,702
along with other items as

327
00:11:07,702 --> 00:11:09,403
directed. Our Last meeting was

328
00:11:09,403 --> 00:11:12,403
FEBRUARY 23rd last week last

329
00:11:13,707 --> 00:11:14,975
Thursday. Our first item on the

330
00:11:14,975 --> 00:11:16,677
agenda. Jennifer Hennessy, the

331
00:11:16,677 --> 00:11:17,945
director of finance, conducted

332
00:11:17,945 --> 00:11:19,714
an annual budget engagement

333
00:11:19,714 --> 00:11:20,982
session designed to engage

334
00:11:20,982 --> 00:11:23,982
commission members early in the

335
00:11:25,620 --> 00:11:26,254
development of the 23 24 annual

336
00:11:26,254 --> 00:11:28,254
operating capital Improvement

337
00:11:28,723 --> 00:11:30,558
Program budget process. We were

338
00:11:30,558 --> 00:11:32,727
given an opportunity to provide

339
00:11:32,727 --> 00:11:33,561
feedback to support programs,

340
00:11:33,561 --> 00:11:35,930
projects and events which the

341
00:11:35,930 --> 00:11:36,632
council will review during

342
00:11:36,632 --> 00:11:39,320
their upcoming budget workshop

343
00:11:39,968 --> 00:11:42,400
in MAY. This was just a

344
00:11:42,400 --> 00:11:45,274
receiver and file item which we

345
00:11:45,274 --> 00:11:48,100
received and filed. Uh, item

346
00:11:48,100 --> 00:11:49,845
number two on our agenda. City

347
00:11:49,845 --> 00:11:52,581
staff provided a thorough stop

348
00:11:52,581 --> 00:11:54,384
control analysis regarding the

349
00:11:54,384 --> 00:11:55,785
feasibility of implementing

350
00:11:55,785 --> 00:11:57,420
always stop controls in

351
00:11:57,420 --> 00:11:59,489
pedestrian crossings and peole

352
00:11:59,489 --> 00:12:00,623
Street and Main Street to

353
00:12:00,623 --> 00:12:02,325
address concerns of excessive

354
00:12:02,325 --> 00:12:05,280
speeding and lack of pedestrian

355
00:12:05,280 --> 00:12:07,280
crossings. The recommendation

356
00:12:07,230 --> 00:12:09,265
from staff was to recommend to

357
00:12:09,265 --> 00:12:10,766
the City Council to adopt a

358
00:12:10,766 --> 00:12:12,766
resolution establishing those

359
00:12:13,169 --> 00:12:15,839
multi way steps controls at

360
00:12:15,839 --> 00:12:16,406
that intersection and also have

361
00:12:16,406 --> 00:12:18,406
staff implements striped

362
00:12:19,900 --> 00:12:21,900
pedestrian crosswalks.

363
00:12:22,546 --> 00:12:22,846
Commission voted 50 to approve

364
00:12:22,846 --> 00:12:23,513
the staff

365
00:12:23,513 --> 00:12:23,714
s recommendation, and

366
00:12:23,714 --> 00:12:24,481
that

367
00:12:24,481 --> 00:12:28,810
s all we had any questions.

368
00:12:28,518 --> 00:12:29,220
Any questions? Thank you

369
00:12:29,220 --> 00:12:31,620
Alright? Appreciate you? Thank

370
00:12:31,889 --> 00:12:33,157
you s. Okay, our public

371
00:12:33,157 --> 00:12:34,926
safety report brought to you

372
00:12:34,926 --> 00:12:36,427
this evening by Chief Creator

373
00:12:36,427 --> 00:12:37,728
welcome Good Evening Mayor

374
00:12:37,728 --> 00:12:40,128
Council members, staff and

375
00:12:40,298 --> 00:12:41,599
community members. A little bit

376
00:12:41,599 --> 00:12:41,832
different. Look on the report

377
00:12:41,832 --> 00:12:42,567
that I

378
00:12:42,567 --> 00:12:43,000
m doing this month. It

379
00:12:43,000 --> 00:12:44,869
s

380
00:12:44,869 --> 00:12:45,102
a new year and we

381
00:12:45,102 --> 00:12:47,102
re turning

382
00:12:47,806 --> 00:12:48,473
the page. This report goes

383
00:12:48,473 --> 00:12:48,974
through Operation prevention,

384
00:12:48,974 --> 00:12:50,542
training and emergency

385
00:12:50,542 --> 00:12:52,542
management. I

386
00:12:52,811 --> 00:12:54,812
ll give you the

387
00:12:54,812 --> 00:12:58,830
breakdown for last year or last

388
00:12:58,830 --> 00:12:58,683
month in JANUARY 2023. The

389
00:12:58,683 --> 00:13:02,283
calls ran in the city of

390
00:13:02,620 --> 00:13:05,200
Temecula. Total of 828 calls

391
00:13:06,225 --> 00:13:09,825
ran in the city. 66 of those

392
00:13:10,295 --> 00:13:12,295
were traffic collisions. 586

393
00:13:12,331 --> 00:13:15,101
for medical related calls, Um

394
00:13:15,101 --> 00:13:16,101
nine fires in the city and a

395
00:13:16,101 --> 00:13:19,101
bunch of ringing alarms while

396
00:13:20,239 --> 00:13:21,974
false alarms. Um So breaking

397
00:13:21,974 --> 00:13:22,842
that down. I know that we do

398
00:13:22,842 --> 00:13:24,577
have a ringing alarm ordinance

399
00:13:24,577 --> 00:13:26,446
in the city. But. You could see

400
00:13:26,446 --> 00:13:27,981
that still holding that too.

401
00:13:27,981 --> 00:13:30,583
That is good for us at the Fire

402
00:13:30,583 --> 00:13:32,983
department. And. We appreciate

403
00:13:33,887 --> 00:13:36,723
the city support. Um in that

404
00:13:36,723 --> 00:13:38,424
ordinance next page. Here. You

405
00:13:38,424 --> 00:13:39,193
can see what you

406
00:13:39,193 --> 00:13:39,960
re running, Uh,

407
00:13:39,960 --> 00:13:42,960
stations are running in each

408
00:13:45,532 --> 00:13:47,532
district. Station 90 to 95 84

409
00:13:49,103 --> 00:13:50,770
12 and 73 then Corresponding

410
00:13:50,770 --> 00:13:53,400
under the station and yellow is

411
00:13:53,400 --> 00:13:53,807
a number of calls ran. Out of

412
00:13:53,807 --> 00:13:56,807
those stations in the city

413
00:14:00,682 --> 00:14:03,484
limits. Next page. Moving on to

414
00:14:03,484 --> 00:14:05,860
fire prevention. Uh, Plan

415
00:14:05,860 --> 00:14:08,860
checks and reviews or still

416
00:14:09,357 --> 00:14:12,357
really busy 529 for last month.

417
00:14:12,360 --> 00:14:14,360
New construction inspections

418
00:14:14,596 --> 00:14:15,697
395 anyone spec shins 3 59,

419
00:14:15,697 --> 00:14:19,340
which are mandated by the state

420
00:14:19,340 --> 00:14:21,570
of California. And. Then we had

421
00:14:21,570 --> 00:14:24,439
27 folks come in to our counter

422
00:14:24,439 --> 00:14:27,439
for public inquiries. Next page,

423
00:14:29,845 --> 00:14:31,470
please. Alright r t. C c

424
00:14:31,470 --> 00:14:33,816
program of volunteers here in

425
00:14:33,816 --> 00:14:36,816
the city did 210 training hours.

426
00:14:38,254 --> 00:14:38,888
They received two applications

427
00:14:38,888 --> 00:14:41,924
have one new volunteer in the

428
00:14:41,924 --> 00:14:44,924
program. They had six volunteer

429
00:14:45,940 --> 00:14:47,963
meetings and to training events

430
00:14:47,963 --> 00:14:49,232
cpr Aid program. We had four

431
00:14:49,232 --> 00:14:51,632
classes. Stop bleeding program.

432
00:14:52,369 --> 00:14:53,670
We had one course. Ah

433
00:14:53,670 --> 00:14:55,372
healthcare provider bls program

434
00:14:55,372 --> 00:14:57,474
cpr in the city. We had one and

435
00:14:57,474 --> 00:15:00,577
that was a research for a city

436
00:15:00,577 --> 00:15:03,577
employee. And, then our heart

437
00:15:03,813 --> 00:15:05,382
our Heart Saver First Aid

438
00:15:05,382 --> 00:15:06,684
program. We had three courses

439
00:15:06,684 --> 00:15:09,520
in the city. The real highlight

440
00:15:09,520 --> 00:15:12,556
here. Is a Great Oaks high

441
00:15:12,556 --> 00:15:13,791
school. We did a hands on cpr

442
00:15:13,791 --> 00:15:16,791
and stop the bleed training

443
00:15:17,928 --> 00:15:20,231
there. With t c sd Aquatics

444
00:15:20,231 --> 00:15:20,831
Temecula Valley Hospital in the

445
00:15:20,831 --> 00:15:23,231
bio Inland Valley Medical

446
00:15:24,903 --> 00:15:27,303
Center. Ramona Valley Hospital

447
00:15:27,772 --> 00:15:31,372
and the school district. So. We

448
00:15:32,176 --> 00:15:34,546
were able to teach 1600. Kids

449
00:15:34,546 --> 00:15:36,348
and adults at the school on the

450
00:15:36,348 --> 00:15:38,483
importance of cpr and how to do

451
00:15:38,483 --> 00:15:40,184
it properly and also our stop

452
00:15:40,184 --> 00:15:42,421
The Bleed program, which has

453
00:15:42,421 --> 00:15:43,855
been on the forefront, I think

454
00:15:43,855 --> 00:15:44,990
You know locally with with some

455
00:15:44,990 --> 00:15:45,157
of the mass shootings we

456
00:15:45,157 --> 00:15:46,425
ve had

457
00:15:46,425 --> 00:15:47,659
people want to know this stuff,

458
00:15:47,659 --> 00:15:49,361
and I think it

459
00:15:49,361 --> 00:15:50,729
s good that our

460
00:15:50,729 --> 00:15:51,196
community knows that. So here

461
00:15:51,196 --> 00:15:53,196
s

462
00:15:53,698 --> 00:15:55,700
some pictures from that event.

463
00:15:55,700 --> 00:15:56,902
Um, I think it was well

464
00:15:56,902 --> 00:15:58,136
attended. You can see the stop

465
00:15:58,136 --> 00:16:00,907
the bleeding the hands on cpr

466
00:16:00,907 --> 00:16:02,642
being done. And on the big

467
00:16:02,642 --> 00:16:02,976
screen there in the gym. That

468
00:16:02,976 --> 00:16:04,976
s

469
00:16:06,378 --> 00:16:08,778
given instructions as well.

470
00:16:13,119 --> 00:16:15,321
Next page. For emergency

471
00:16:15,321 --> 00:16:16,390
management in JANUARY, the

472
00:16:16,390 --> 00:16:17,558
local has admitted mitigation

473
00:16:17,558 --> 00:16:19,559
plan is working its way through

474
00:16:19,559 --> 00:16:20,494
the Planning commission. It is

475
00:16:20,494 --> 00:16:23,494
currently at Cal os for

476
00:16:25,799 --> 00:16:26,867
approval. Um Mercy manager

477
00:16:26,867 --> 00:16:29,867
attended pdo class and media

478
00:16:29,870 --> 00:16:31,271
relations. Ah, the emergency

479
00:16:31,271 --> 00:16:33,390
operation plan is still pending

480
00:16:33,390 --> 00:16:36,177
Approval to be placed on the

481
00:16:36,177 --> 00:16:37,945
city Council to be adopted. And.

482
00:16:37,945 --> 00:16:41,480
You could see where we are on

483
00:16:41,480 --> 00:16:41,716
our grants and claims.

484
00:16:41,716 --> 00:16:44,116
Community presentations to and

485
00:16:44,418 --> 00:16:46,454
then we have a backpack program

486
00:16:46,454 --> 00:16:48,210
for having a go bag at home in

487
00:16:48,210 --> 00:16:50,230
the essentials that you would

488
00:16:50,230 --> 00:16:51,260
need in case of emergency. So

489
00:16:51,260 --> 00:16:53,260
yourself sufficient for 24

490
00:16:53,950 --> 00:16:56,950
hours. 320 of those have been

491
00:16:56,331 --> 00:16:58,700
distributed year to date. The

492
00:16:58,700 --> 00:17:01,203
last storms were in management

493
00:17:01,203 --> 00:17:04,803
watch and at normal level. Can

494
00:17:06,700 --> 00:17:08,778
we go back to slide, please.

495
00:17:08,778 --> 00:17:12,548
One thing I want to do? We had

496
00:17:12,548 --> 00:17:13,315
a survivor of cpr. Where, um

497
00:17:13,315 --> 00:17:15,715
Our firefighters were directly

498
00:17:16,118 --> 00:17:18,530
involved in saving a life and i

499
00:17:18,530 --> 00:17:19,488
want to invite Stephanie natter

500
00:17:19,488 --> 00:17:21,891
here and her husband, Dylan to

501
00:17:21,891 --> 00:17:23,492
come up and share their story.

502
00:17:23,492 --> 00:17:23,993
If you would. I think it

503
00:17:23,993 --> 00:17:25,862
s

504
00:17:25,862 --> 00:17:28,464
important to see that chain of

505
00:17:28,464 --> 00:17:29,990
survival from our 911?

506
00:17:29,990 --> 00:17:31,990
Dispatcher given instructions

507
00:17:33,336 --> 00:17:34,537
to Dealing over the phone to

508
00:17:34,537 --> 00:17:35,905
our firefighters showing up and

509
00:17:35,905 --> 00:17:38,905
giving excellent care. To the

510
00:17:38,908 --> 00:17:39,475
hospital. Being able to save

511
00:17:39,475 --> 00:17:40,510
her life, so I

512
00:17:40,510 --> 00:17:42,910
ll let her share

513
00:17:43,781 --> 00:17:45,282
her story. Thank you. Welcome.

514
00:17:45,282 --> 00:17:46,450
Thank you. Thank you and good

515
00:17:46,450 --> 00:17:47,984
evening. Thank You, too. Chief

516
00:17:47,984 --> 00:17:49,920
Creator for giving me this

517
00:17:49,920 --> 00:17:52,920
opportunity to share my story.

518
00:17:52,990 --> 00:17:55,990
My name is Stephanie Natter.

519
00:17:56,360 --> 00:17:59,360
And on SEPTEMBER 20th 15th.

520
00:18:00,300 --> 00:18:00,197
2022 at 10 34 am I died? I

521
00:18:00,197 --> 00:18:02,197
m 39

522
00:18:02,767 --> 00:18:05,236
years old. With. No prior

523
00:18:05,236 --> 00:18:07,605
health conditions. I played

524
00:18:07,605 --> 00:18:10,700
sports all my life growing up.

525
00:18:10,700 --> 00:18:13,607
And I stayed active. And. My

526
00:18:15,379 --> 00:18:16,314
heart just stopped. I went into

527
00:18:16,314 --> 00:18:16,547
cardiac arrest. I didn

528
00:18:16,547 --> 00:18:18,547
t have a

529
00:18:19,751 --> 00:18:20,752
heart attack. Many people know

530
00:18:20,752 --> 00:18:21,386
the difference. But. Some of

531
00:18:21,386 --> 00:18:22,540
you MAY not, And I

532
00:18:22,540 --> 00:18:24,540
d like to

533
00:18:26,580 --> 00:18:26,825
share the difference. The,

534
00:18:26,825 --> 00:18:27,959
American Heart Association

535
00:18:27,959 --> 00:18:29,227
States. Heart attack occurs

536
00:18:29,227 --> 00:18:32,263
when the blood flow to the

537
00:18:32,263 --> 00:18:34,933
heart is stopped. Heart attack

538
00:18:34,933 --> 00:18:37,333
is a circulation problem.

539
00:18:37,437 --> 00:18:39,104
Cardiac arrest occurs when the

540
00:18:39,104 --> 00:18:41,504
heart malfunctions and stop

541
00:18:42,308 --> 00:18:43,900
speeding unexpectedly. Cardiac

542
00:18:43,900 --> 00:18:46,900
arrest is an electrical problem.

543
00:18:46,479 --> 00:18:48,981
That morning was just like any

544
00:18:48,981 --> 00:18:50,783
other morning. I got my kids

545
00:18:50,783 --> 00:18:53,119
ready for school made my

546
00:18:53,119 --> 00:18:54,221
husband breakfast, and I went

547
00:18:54,221 --> 00:18:57,123
upstairs and laid back in bed.

548
00:18:57,123 --> 00:18:59,125
I was on the phone with my best

549
00:18:59,125 --> 00:18:59,292
friend who is an er nurse.

550
00:18:59,292 --> 00:19:01,292
We

551
00:19:02,529 --> 00:19:03,329
re catching up about. The

552
00:19:03,329 --> 00:19:05,729
previous days and sharing

553
00:19:06,132 --> 00:19:07,534
stories. I made an instagram

554
00:19:07,534 --> 00:19:07,834
post of my son

555
00:19:07,834 --> 00:19:09,736
s water polo

556
00:19:09,736 --> 00:19:13,730
game the night before. And. My

557
00:19:13,730 --> 00:19:16,730
heart just stopped. I stopped

558
00:19:16,109 --> 00:19:16,777
responding to Jill. And she

559
00:19:16,777 --> 00:19:18,812
immediately knew something was

560
00:19:18,812 --> 00:19:22,412
wrong. She heard me take my

561
00:19:22,716 --> 00:19:23,384
last breath. And immediately

562
00:19:23,384 --> 00:19:26,384
conferenced my husband in on

563
00:19:26,787 --> 00:19:29,157
the phone call. Coincidentally.

564
00:19:29,157 --> 00:19:30,291
He was downstairs with no

565
00:19:30,291 --> 00:19:32,260
meetings to attend for work,

566
00:19:32,260 --> 00:19:36,826
and it was able to come up to

567
00:19:37,232 --> 00:19:38,766
our bedroom. He came up and

568
00:19:38,766 --> 00:19:42,366
found me laying in our bed

569
00:19:43,204 --> 00:19:44,405
lifeless in blue. And at that

570
00:19:44,405 --> 00:19:48,605
point, he knew he had to do

571
00:19:49,378 --> 00:19:52,978
something. He put me down on

572
00:19:54,783 --> 00:19:56,185
the floor and call 911. He was

573
00:19:56,185 --> 00:19:58,530
led for nine minutes doing

574
00:19:58,530 --> 00:20:00,453
chest compressions by the

575
00:20:01,456 --> 00:20:03,856
dispatcher until help arrived.

576
00:20:04,600 --> 00:20:06,460
At that point engine 96 92

577
00:20:08,531 --> 00:20:10,133
arrived at our home. And they

578
00:20:10,133 --> 00:20:13,350
took over chest compressions. I

579
00:20:13,350 --> 00:20:14,203
was shocked six times by an a d

580
00:20:14,203 --> 00:20:19,300
and received an I o port in my

581
00:20:19,275 --> 00:20:21,675
shin After 30 minutes, I

582
00:20:21,845 --> 00:20:22,546
regained a pulse and was

583
00:20:22,546 --> 00:20:24,546
transporte Temecula Valley

584
00:20:26,490 --> 00:20:28,618
er. Once. I arrived there. I

585
00:20:28,618 --> 00:20:30,554
coat it again. And received

586
00:20:30,554 --> 00:20:33,554
four more shocks. And was

587
00:20:35,425 --> 00:20:37,761
intubated. A few hours later, I

588
00:20:37,761 --> 00:20:41,961
was moved to icu. Where I coded

589
00:20:42,600 --> 00:20:43,233
again. Against cpr was

590
00:20:43,233 --> 00:20:46,233
administered and I was brought

591
00:20:47,405 --> 00:20:51,142
back. At that point I was put

592
00:20:51,142 --> 00:20:54,142
on 100% life support. For five

593
00:20:54,445 --> 00:20:58,645
days. After five days I woke up

594
00:21:00,618 --> 00:21:01,286
with No broken ribs. No

595
00:21:01,286 --> 00:21:03,286
neurological disorders deficits.

596
00:21:07,826 --> 00:21:11,426
And, no motor skill issues. I

597
00:21:11,796 --> 00:21:13,933
was alive and able Because of

598
00:21:13,933 --> 00:21:17,903
cpr done by my husband and the

599
00:21:17,903 --> 00:21:20,303
first responders. After day 10

600
00:21:20,806 --> 00:21:24,276
at day 10 I was discharged and

601
00:21:24,276 --> 00:21:25,510
walked out of the hospital. A

602
00:21:25,510 --> 00:21:28,414
couple of weeks after being

603
00:21:28,414 --> 00:21:30,282
home. My family, close friends

604
00:21:30,282 --> 00:21:33,882
and I were able to reunite.

605
00:21:35,688 --> 00:21:38,688
With 96 92. As well as the

606
00:21:38,725 --> 00:21:38,991
dispatcher. And. We

607
00:21:38,991 --> 00:21:40,991
re able to

608
00:21:43,830 --> 00:21:46,132
think them And hug them. Ensure

609
00:21:46,132 --> 00:21:49,132
gratitude for The role that

610
00:21:49,436 --> 00:21:50,971
they played. Each member of

611
00:21:50,971 --> 00:21:53,207
that crew was vital in my

612
00:21:53,207 --> 00:21:55,607
survival. And necessary that

613
00:21:59,880 --> 00:22:02,983
day. Hmm, a few of the medics

614
00:22:02,983 --> 00:22:03,717
even told me that Their

615
00:22:03,717 --> 00:22:04,484
outcomes aren

616
00:22:04,484 --> 00:22:06,587
t always this way

617
00:22:06,587 --> 00:22:07,789
and that they have never had a

618
00:22:07,789 --> 00:22:11,325
survivor be able to hug or

619
00:22:11,325 --> 00:22:14,325
thank them. That Day will

620
00:22:14,529 --> 00:22:15,229
forever be special for me. I

621
00:22:15,229 --> 00:22:16,997
m

622
00:22:16,997 --> 00:22:18,266
grateful to my best friend for

623
00:22:18,266 --> 00:22:20,234
the intuition and sense to hear

624
00:22:20,234 --> 00:22:20,901
something that was wrong. I

625
00:22:20,901 --> 00:22:22,901
m

626
00:22:22,937 --> 00:22:24,206
grateful for my husband, who

627
00:22:24,206 --> 00:22:27,206
was home and started cpr

628
00:22:29,578 --> 00:22:30,450
immediately. I am grateful. For,

629
00:22:30,450 --> 00:22:32,450
the experienced and

630
00:22:32,180 --> 00:22:34,580
knowledgeable medics. That came

631
00:22:35,817 --> 00:22:36,184
to my home. I

632
00:22:36,184 --> 00:22:37,419
m grateful for a

633
00:22:37,419 --> 00:22:41,190
hospital that is close by and

634
00:22:41,824 --> 00:22:42,992
our town. That Also gave

635
00:22:42,992 --> 00:22:43,154
amazing care and we

636
00:22:43,154 --> 00:22:45,154
re

637
00:22:46,329 --> 00:22:48,230
compassionate to my family. I

638
00:22:48,230 --> 00:22:50,766
am grateful for the skilled

639
00:22:50,766 --> 00:22:51,333
nurses and doctors as well. I

640
00:22:51,333 --> 00:22:52,334
m

641
00:22:52,334 --> 00:22:54,436
grateful to be here and to be

642
00:22:54,436 --> 00:22:56,772
able to share my story to share

643
00:22:56,772 --> 00:22:59,172
the awareness. And educate

644
00:23:01,378 --> 00:23:02,278
people. About saving people

645
00:23:02,278 --> 00:23:03,346
s

646
00:23:03,346 --> 00:23:06,490
lives with the cpr How

647
00:23:06,490 --> 00:23:06,750
important it is. I

648
00:23:06,750 --> 00:23:08,585
m grateful

649
00:23:08,585 --> 00:23:09,953
to be able to be a mom to my

650
00:23:09,953 --> 00:23:11,121
two kids and to be able to

651
00:23:11,121 --> 00:23:13,890
share my story with you guys

652
00:23:13,890 --> 00:23:15,157
today. I

653
00:23:15,157 --> 00:23:17,557
d like to acknowledge.

654
00:23:19,630 --> 00:23:21,932
96 They are now extended family.

655
00:23:21,932 --> 00:23:23,767
They

656
00:23:23,767 --> 00:23:26,167
re here today supporting

657
00:23:27,938 --> 00:23:29,473
me and as well as my husband.

658
00:23:29,473 --> 00:23:33,730
They saved my life and the

659
00:23:33,645 --> 00:23:34,312
chain of survival works. Heroes

660
00:23:34,312 --> 00:23:36,114
are just ordinary people who

661
00:23:36,114 --> 00:23:39,830
know what to do. You never know.

662
00:23:39,830 --> 00:23:42,830
When the first responder is

663
00:24:14,320 --> 00:24:15,721
going to be you. Thank you.

664
00:24:15,721 --> 00:24:17,356
Stephanie. Thank you for

665
00:24:17,356 --> 00:24:18,891
feeling comfortable enough to

666
00:24:18,891 --> 00:24:21,694
share that story with us and

667
00:24:21,694 --> 00:24:21,927
and, um And admit I

668
00:24:21,927 --> 00:24:22,862
m holding

669
00:24:22,862 --> 00:24:24,430
back tears when you start

670
00:24:24,430 --> 00:24:25,966
talking about your Children and

671
00:24:25,966 --> 00:24:27,701
your family and things like

672
00:24:27,701 --> 00:24:28,435
that, and how important um,

673
00:24:28,435 --> 00:24:31,371
community is to each and every

674
00:24:31,371 --> 00:24:31,536
one of us so Thank you? We

675
00:24:31,536 --> 00:24:32,572
re

676
00:24:32,572 --> 00:24:32,736
glad and fortunate that you

677
00:24:32,736 --> 00:24:33,840
re

678
00:24:33,840 --> 00:24:37,440
here with us this evening. So

679
00:24:37,577 --> 00:24:39,679
thank you. That concludes my

680
00:24:39,679 --> 00:24:42,679
report. Thank you very much

681
00:24:44,785 --> 00:24:47,880
chie creator. Okay only

682
00:24:47,880 --> 00:24:47,955
uplifting public comments this

683
00:24:47,955 --> 00:24:48,589
evening, folks. We

684
00:24:48,589 --> 00:24:50,589
ll move into

685
00:24:50,891 --> 00:24:51,959
public comments for non agenda

686
00:24:51,959 --> 00:24:54,128
items. MADAM City clerk. Do. We

687
00:24:54,128 --> 00:24:55,796
have any public comments this

688
00:24:55,796 --> 00:24:56,697
evening, Mr Mayor. We have

689
00:24:56,697 --> 00:24:58,832
several public comments on

690
00:24:58,832 --> 00:24:59,233
agendas, items and non agendas

691
00:24:59,233 --> 00:25:00,334
items, So we

692
00:25:00,334 --> 00:25:01,836
ll take non

693
00:25:01,836 --> 00:25:03,371
agendas items at this time.

694
00:25:03,371 --> 00:25:04,739
Each speaker is limited to

695
00:25:04,739 --> 00:25:05,340
three minutes. The rules are

696
00:25:05,340 --> 00:25:07,842
provided for in the printed

697
00:25:07,842 --> 00:25:10,244
agenda. The. First speaker is

698
00:25:10,244 --> 00:25:13,244
Kathy Sizemore to be followed

699
00:25:20,856 --> 00:25:23,256
by Joseph Komarovsky. Welcome.

700
00:25:23,292 --> 00:25:25,600
Thank you. Good evening. Mayor

701
00:25:25,600 --> 00:25:26,929
Schwank Mayor Pro tem Stuart

702
00:25:26,929 --> 00:25:28,831
City Council members and our

703
00:25:28,831 --> 00:25:29,431
executive staff, But most

704
00:25:29,431 --> 00:25:31,431
importantly, residents of

705
00:25:32,367 --> 00:25:33,802
Temecula. I am Kathy Sizemore.

706
00:25:33,802 --> 00:25:35,103
I am the incoming District

707
00:25:35,103 --> 00:25:36,940
Committee chair for the talk

708
00:25:36,940 --> 00:25:39,209
about scouting District of Boy

709
00:25:39,209 --> 00:25:39,776
Scouts of America serving youth

710
00:25:39,776 --> 00:25:42,176
and adults in southwest

711
00:25:42,845 --> 00:25:43,900
Riverside County. But tonight.

712
00:25:43,900 --> 00:25:45,900
I

713
00:25:45,140 --> 00:25:46,449
m here as an Assistant Scout

714
00:25:46,449 --> 00:25:48,618
master for Temecula Boy Scout

715
00:25:48,618 --> 00:25:51,618
Troop 1 48 chartered by the vfw

716
00:25:51,621 --> 00:25:53,157
post 40 89 I am a privileged to

717
00:25:53,157 --> 00:25:54,625
be attending this meeting

718
00:25:54,625 --> 00:25:56,460
tonight with scouts from

719
00:25:56,460 --> 00:25:56,760
Temecula Strip 1 48. They

720
00:25:56,760 --> 00:25:58,760
re

721
00:25:58,795 --> 00:26:00,397
all working on the citizenship

722
00:26:00,397 --> 00:26:01,965
in the community Merit badge.

723
00:26:01,965 --> 00:26:02,699
And over the past eight weeks,

724
00:26:02,699 --> 00:26:04,935
These scouts have learned what

725
00:26:04,935 --> 00:26:08,438
it takes to be a good citizen

726
00:26:08,438 --> 00:26:10,838
in their community. Including

727
00:26:10,908 --> 00:26:12,900
what their rights, their duties

728
00:26:12,900 --> 00:26:13,578
and their obligations are as

729
00:26:13,578 --> 00:26:14,278
citizens of our city. They

730
00:26:14,278 --> 00:26:15,279
ve

731
00:26:15,279 --> 00:26:15,880
discovered what our city is

732
00:26:15,880 --> 00:26:16,280
known for, and they

733
00:26:16,280 --> 00:26:17,415
ve learned

734
00:26:17,415 --> 00:26:20,718
a little bit about Temecula is

735
00:26:20,718 --> 00:26:21,752
history. We have also learned

736
00:26:21,752 --> 00:26:21,919
about some local issues, and

737
00:26:21,919 --> 00:26:23,854
we

738
00:26:23,854 --> 00:26:25,890
ve had a very engaging

739
00:26:25,890 --> 00:26:26,490
discussion about the future

740
00:26:26,490 --> 00:26:28,326
Temecula Skatepark and they

741
00:26:28,326 --> 00:26:30,729
shared with me some of their

742
00:26:30,729 --> 00:26:31,362
ideas about potential action

743
00:26:31,362 --> 00:26:33,762
supports opportunities in our

744
00:26:33,899 --> 00:26:35,667
city. As part of their mayor

745
00:26:35,667 --> 00:26:37,135
badge. They will be completing

746
00:26:37,135 --> 00:26:38,270
eight hours of community

747
00:26:38,270 --> 00:26:40,670
service, benefiting a local

748
00:26:40,672 --> 00:26:41,573
nonprofit in our city. Tonight.

749
00:26:41,573 --> 00:26:43,275
They had the opportunity to

750
00:26:43,275 --> 00:26:44,342
meet with Mayor Swink to

751
00:26:44,342 --> 00:26:47,342
Tourist City Hall and learned

752
00:26:47,580 --> 00:26:49,782
about local government. Serving

753
00:26:49,782 --> 00:26:52,840
all youth, Both boys and girls

754
00:26:52,840 --> 00:26:52,818
scouting with Boy Scouts of

755
00:26:52,818 --> 00:26:55,818
America is thriving in Temecula.

756
00:26:59,859 --> 00:27:02,327
In 2022 867. To make it a youth

757
00:27:02,327 --> 00:27:04,431
participated and b s a programs

758
00:27:04,431 --> 00:27:06,320
which includes, um are 15

759
00:27:06,320 --> 00:27:08,802
scouting units. We have packs

760
00:27:08,802 --> 00:27:09,969
troops and we have fire Police,

761
00:27:09,969 --> 00:27:10,670
Highway patrol and medical

762
00:27:10,670 --> 00:27:14,270
explorer posts here in the city.

763
00:27:15,241 --> 00:27:15,642
Last year, 44 Temecula Scouts

764
00:27:15,642 --> 00:27:16,420
achieve scouting

765
00:27:16,420 --> 00:27:17,243
s highest rank

766
00:27:17,243 --> 00:27:19,345
of Eagle scout. Just a sample

767
00:27:19,345 --> 00:27:20,581
of some of the scouting Eagle

768
00:27:20,581 --> 00:27:22,581
Scout projects We

769
00:27:22,616 --> 00:27:23,183
ve had

770
00:27:23,183 --> 00:27:24,719
benefiting Temecula

771
00:27:24,719 --> 00:27:27,688
organizations and we did a al

772
00:27:27,688 --> 00:27:29,523
Box and five birdhouses for

773
00:27:29,523 --> 00:27:30,858
migratory birds for the Rose

774
00:27:30,858 --> 00:27:33,858
Haven heritage Rose Garden. We

775
00:27:34,610 --> 00:27:35,195
also had an Eagle Scout. Create

776
00:27:35,195 --> 00:27:37,595
six composting containers for

777
00:27:38,266 --> 00:27:39,267
the Rose Garden. Temecula

778
00:27:39,267 --> 00:27:40,968
Valley Unified School District,

779
00:27:40,968 --> 00:27:41,137
st, Thomas and st Catherine

780
00:27:41,137 --> 00:27:43,137
s

781
00:27:43,671 --> 00:27:45,390
Church are just some of the

782
00:27:45,390 --> 00:27:46,140
beneficiaries and Temecula of

783
00:27:46,140 --> 00:27:47,909
Eagle Scout projects last year.

784
00:27:47,909 --> 00:27:49,510
I want to say thank you to

785
00:27:49,510 --> 00:27:51,120
mayor shrank for meeting with

786
00:27:51,120 --> 00:27:52,446
our scouts tonight and helping

787
00:27:52,446 --> 00:27:54,248
each of these scouts be

788
00:27:54,248 --> 00:27:54,849
prepared to be better citizens

789
00:27:54,849 --> 00:27:57,849
in future leaders in their

790
00:27:59,955 --> 00:28:01,990
community. Thank you. The. Next

791
00:28:01,990 --> 00:28:02,524
speaker is Joseph Kamburov ski

792
00:28:02,524 --> 00:28:05,524
to be followed by Jim

793
00:28:13,200 --> 00:28:13,235
McLaughlin. Welcome. Greetings

794
00:28:13,235 --> 00:28:14,904
I

795
00:28:14,904 --> 00:28:17,904
m Joseph Komarovsky and, yes,

796
00:28:17,940 --> 00:28:20,760
uplifting comments only. I

797
00:28:20,760 --> 00:28:21,770
first want to thank the City

798
00:28:21,770 --> 00:28:22,511
Council and city staff and i

799
00:28:22,511 --> 00:28:23,980
want to congratulate Mr Calvez

800
00:28:23,980 --> 00:28:26,480
for winning your race, Mr Brown

801
00:28:26,480 --> 00:28:26,682
for winning your race, Mr

802
00:28:26,682 --> 00:28:29,510
Schwank for getting voted in

803
00:28:29,510 --> 00:28:30,287
Mayor. Mr Stewart and Mrs

804
00:28:30,287 --> 00:28:31,521
Alexander for hanging in there

805
00:28:31,521 --> 00:28:34,891
and thank you all for serving

806
00:28:34,891 --> 00:28:35,510
our wonderful city. Um. I

807
00:28:35,510 --> 00:28:35,531
m I

808
00:28:35,531 --> 00:28:35,694
m

809
00:28:35,694 --> 00:28:37,127
on I

810
00:28:37,127 --> 00:28:39,329
m here tonight on behalf

811
00:28:39,329 --> 00:28:40,130
of neighborhood drop in on a

812
00:28:40,130 --> 00:28:41,364
fellow board member PRESIDENT,

813
00:28:41,364 --> 00:28:43,600
Vice, PRESIDENT Adam and Alex

814
00:28:43,600 --> 00:28:45,535
are back there with me. Um, we

815
00:28:45,535 --> 00:28:47,404
are as what we would say, and

816
00:28:47,404 --> 00:28:48,873
skater and server terms very

817
00:28:48,873 --> 00:28:49,874
stoked at what

818
00:28:49,874 --> 00:28:51,874
s on your

819
00:28:51,942 --> 00:28:52,510
consent. Um, you know, calendar

820
00:28:52,510 --> 00:28:54,510
tonight, the consultant

821
00:28:56,247 --> 00:28:57,810
agreement for a new skate park.

822
00:28:57,810 --> 00:28:59,150
Um. Yes, and we

823
00:28:59,150 --> 00:29:01,150
re very pleased

824
00:29:01,285 --> 00:29:03,287
and were greatly appreciative

825
00:29:03,287 --> 00:29:05,357
of your efforts. Remember me

826
00:29:05,357 --> 00:29:06,658
and Adam met with Zach Year and

827
00:29:06,658 --> 00:29:07,759
a half ago. And we didn

828
00:29:07,759 --> 00:29:08,827
t know

829
00:29:08,827 --> 00:29:10,962
what to expect. When. We said,

830
00:29:10,962 --> 00:29:12,764
we really need a new skate park

831
00:29:12,764 --> 00:29:14,199
and then he had me at. I was

832
00:29:14,199 --> 00:29:15,266
thinking about doing something

833
00:29:15,266 --> 00:29:16,701
like Prince Park and I was

834
00:29:16,701 --> 00:29:18,169
stunned and it showed me the

835
00:29:18,169 --> 00:29:21,272
depth and breadth of, um Our

836
00:29:21,272 --> 00:29:23,342
mayor. Um that that is an

837
00:29:23,342 --> 00:29:23,642
amazing skate park. And, So. I

838
00:29:23,642 --> 00:29:24,944
think you

839
00:29:24,944 --> 00:29:27,179
ll be pleased that

840
00:29:27,179 --> 00:29:28,714
you chose chosen Spohn Ranch as

841
00:29:28,714 --> 00:29:29,414
a potential designer or does

842
00:29:29,414 --> 00:29:33,140
the designer for the Skate Park?

843
00:29:34,987 --> 00:29:39,787
Um Yes. And what else do I got?

844
00:29:42,940 --> 00:29:42,334
Let me see. I think I think

845
00:29:42,334 --> 00:29:44,334
that

846
00:29:45,431 --> 00:29:47,533
s about it. Um Thank you

847
00:29:47,533 --> 00:29:48,835
so much, Everybody. Thank you.

848
00:29:48,835 --> 00:29:50,536
Next speaker. The next speaker

849
00:29:50,536 --> 00:29:53,536
is Jim McLaughlin to be

850
00:29:55,341 --> 00:29:57,778
followed by Bob Cal. Welcome

851
00:29:57,778 --> 00:29:58,812
good evening Council members,

852
00:29:58,812 --> 00:29:59,580
City staff and citizens. My

853
00:29:59,580 --> 00:29:59,780
name is Jim McLaughlin. I

854
00:29:59,780 --> 00:30:01,780
ve

855
00:30:01,782 --> 00:30:03,150
been a resident of two macular

856
00:30:03,150 --> 00:30:04,351
for about 15 years I attended

857
00:30:04,351 --> 00:30:05,510
the last City council meeting

858
00:30:05,510 --> 00:30:05,251
two weeks ago because I hadn

859
00:30:05,251 --> 00:30:06,286
t

860
00:30:06,286 --> 00:30:07,688
been in a while and I was

861
00:30:07,688 --> 00:30:09,723
interested in getting to know

862
00:30:09,723 --> 00:30:09,923
the new kids on the block. I

863
00:30:09,923 --> 00:30:10,690
wasn

864
00:30:10,690 --> 00:30:12,920
t that long ago that Mayor

865
00:30:12,920 --> 00:30:13,393
Schwank was the new kid on the

866
00:30:13,393 --> 00:30:16,490
block, and so I was kind of

867
00:30:16,490 --> 00:30:16,659
checking him out to the most

868
00:30:16,659 --> 00:30:17,932
interesting part of the meeting

869
00:30:17,932 --> 00:30:19,500
for me was the last discussion,

870
00:30:19,500 --> 00:30:20,901
the one about putting a vote

871
00:30:20,901 --> 00:30:21,903
for term limits on the ballot

872
00:30:21,903 --> 00:30:22,470
Now on that issue. I don

873
00:30:22,470 --> 00:30:23,871
t feel

874
00:30:23,871 --> 00:30:25,606
strongly. Either way. I know

875
00:30:25,606 --> 00:30:26,540
there are compelling narratives

876
00:30:26,540 --> 00:30:27,708
for both sides. I listened to

877
00:30:27,708 --> 00:30:28,876
the discussion and there was

878
00:30:28,876 --> 00:30:30,144
little real pushback at first,

879
00:30:30,144 --> 00:30:30,611
a phrase uttered more than once

880
00:30:30,611 --> 00:30:32,346
was. Well, I don

881
00:30:32,346 --> 00:30:33,281
t have a

882
00:30:33,281 --> 00:30:34,716
problem with it shrank when we

883
00:30:34,716 --> 00:30:35,984
went last and brought up his

884
00:30:35,984 --> 00:30:36,952
arguments against her term

885
00:30:36,952 --> 00:30:38,320
limits, and I found those he

886
00:30:38,320 --> 00:30:40,121
had some pretty valid points

887
00:30:40,121 --> 00:30:41,356
after his comments. So. I

888
00:30:41,356 --> 00:30:41,957
thought Okay, now I know a

889
00:30:41,957 --> 00:30:44,259
little bit more about Mayor

890
00:30:44,259 --> 00:30:45,994
Swang. 20 also acknowledge his

891
00:30:45,994 --> 00:30:47,262
belief that if it were put on

892
00:30:47,262 --> 00:30:50,166
the ballot today, people would

893
00:30:50,166 --> 00:30:51,500
vote in favor of term it term

894
00:30:51,500 --> 00:30:53,135
limits Following his comments I

895
00:30:53,135 --> 00:30:53,936
heard council member office

896
00:30:53,936 --> 00:30:55,504
referred to that comment that

897
00:30:55,504 --> 00:30:56,605
people would vote in favor and

898
00:30:56,605 --> 00:30:58,941
that that was all he needed to

899
00:30:58,941 --> 00:31:00,776
hear. I think that was a direct

900
00:31:00,776 --> 00:31:02,478
quote. I have two problems with

901
00:31:02,478 --> 00:31:02,678
that one is it sounds like you

902
00:31:02,678 --> 00:31:04,212
weren

903
00:31:04,212 --> 00:31:04,413
t even considering the

904
00:31:04,413 --> 00:31:05,470
mayor

905
00:31:05,470 --> 00:31:06,348
s arguments. You cherry

906
00:31:06,348 --> 00:31:07,784
picked what you would agree

907
00:31:07,784 --> 00:31:10,687
with your point of view and

908
00:31:10,687 --> 00:31:11,200
dismissed the rest. Second, you

909
00:31:11,200 --> 00:31:11,354
believe that

910
00:31:11,354 --> 00:31:11,921
s what

911
00:31:11,921 --> 00:31:13,490
s popular

912
00:31:13,490 --> 00:31:13,657
is more important than what

913
00:31:13,657 --> 00:31:14,324
s

914
00:31:14,324 --> 00:31:14,924
best as in. Well, if that

915
00:31:14,924 --> 00:31:16,226
s

916
00:31:16,226 --> 00:31:17,227
what the people want. We should

917
00:31:17,227 --> 00:31:18,270
give it to them. I think most

918
00:31:18,270 --> 00:31:18,761
would agree that that

919
00:31:18,761 --> 00:31:20,129
s not

920
00:31:20,129 --> 00:31:20,295
always a good idea. It

921
00:31:20,295 --> 00:31:22,295
s

922
00:31:22,665 --> 00:31:23,199
certainly no way to lead In a

923
00:31:23,199 --> 00:31:24,533
representative form of

924
00:31:24,533 --> 00:31:27,504
government. We elect people to

925
00:31:27,504 --> 00:31:28,639
do the work of studying the

926
00:31:28,639 --> 00:31:30,507
issues considering the validity

927
00:31:30,507 --> 00:31:31,442
and merit of the alternative

928
00:31:31,442 --> 00:31:31,642
alternatives and then to choose

929
00:31:31,642 --> 00:31:33,642
what

930
00:31:33,944 --> 00:31:34,511
s best. I know from

931
00:31:34,511 --> 00:31:35,712
personal experience that

932
00:31:35,712 --> 00:31:36,880
putting yourself in a

933
00:31:36,880 --> 00:31:39,280
leadership position for there

934
00:31:39,917 --> 00:31:40,784
to be any hope of being

935
00:31:40,784 --> 00:31:42,784
effective, requires self

936
00:31:42,920 --> 00:31:44,880
reflection and growth, which is

937
00:31:44,880 --> 00:31:44,257
often very uncomfortable, but

938
00:31:44,257 --> 00:31:46,257
it

939
00:31:47,458 --> 00:31:47,759
s also high leaders are

940
00:31:47,759 --> 00:31:48,159
forged. It

941
00:31:48,159 --> 00:31:50,610
s humbling and I

942
00:31:50,610 --> 00:31:52,300
find humility to be an

943
00:31:52,300 --> 00:31:53,364
admirable quality in a leader.

944
00:31:53,364 --> 00:31:54,498
I wish you well, I really do

945
00:31:54,498 --> 00:31:57,602
all of you and I. Thank you for

946
00:31:57,602 --> 00:31:59,700
your attention. Thank you next

947
00:31:59,700 --> 00:32:00,906
speaker. The. Next speaker is

948
00:32:00,906 --> 00:32:05,106
Bob Cal to be followed by Dario

949
00:32:07,312 --> 00:32:09,712
Bianchi. Welcome. Hello there,

950
00:32:12,751 --> 00:32:13,919
Um I have a couple of things to

951
00:32:13,919 --> 00:32:15,954
say, Um Sheriff Bianco has been

952
00:32:15,954 --> 00:32:16,588
under attack by the state

953
00:32:16,588 --> 00:32:17,856
dictators and I

954
00:32:17,856 --> 00:32:19,658
d like to ask

955
00:32:19,658 --> 00:32:22,562
that there be a resolution in

956
00:32:22,562 --> 00:32:23,596
behalf of him support him and

957
00:32:23,596 --> 00:32:25,996
instead of the investigation,

958
00:32:27,166 --> 00:32:29,201
this, uh This, um, crazy

959
00:32:29,201 --> 00:32:31,601
investigation that people are

960
00:32:31,604 --> 00:32:31,871
putting upon him. Uh and And if

961
00:32:31,871 --> 00:32:33,871
you don

962
00:32:33,973 --> 00:32:37,573
t know it, it is crazy.

963
00:32:38,440 --> 00:32:40,213
So please have a resolution to

964
00:32:40,213 --> 00:32:42,616
support Chad Bianco in in in

965
00:32:42,616 --> 00:32:44,684
fighting the state on this.

966
00:32:44,684 --> 00:32:44,860
Appreciate it if you did that.

967
00:32:44,860 --> 00:32:45,986
It

968
00:32:45,986 --> 00:32:46,154
s like anything is that I

969
00:32:46,154 --> 00:32:47,487
don

970
00:32:47,487 --> 00:32:50,990
t know how the governor can

971
00:32:50,990 --> 00:32:53,294
have such power. But Hmm today.

972
00:32:53,294 --> 00:32:53,994
He, um, scheduled an end to

973
00:32:53,994 --> 00:32:55,362
Covid so we don

974
00:32:55,362 --> 00:32:57,164
t have any

975
00:32:57,164 --> 00:32:59,266
covered anymore. No emergency?

976
00:32:59,266 --> 00:32:59,567
No. Nothing to worry about.

977
00:32:59,567 --> 00:33:01,368
Yeah, that

978
00:33:01,368 --> 00:33:03,300
s what the governor

979
00:33:03,300 --> 00:33:04,438
says. Yeah. So having said that

980
00:33:04,438 --> 00:33:06,340
we used to have a we used to

981
00:33:06,340 --> 00:33:08,942
meet over here once a month.

982
00:33:08,942 --> 00:33:11,613
Our club. And. I like to do

983
00:33:11,613 --> 00:33:14,182
that again if we can do that,

984
00:33:14,182 --> 00:33:15,216
so I would like to Somebody

985
00:33:15,216 --> 00:33:18,186
could have resolution or a

986
00:33:18,186 --> 00:33:19,521
motion or something to Allow

987
00:33:19,521 --> 00:33:22,257
non profits or other groups,

988
00:33:22,257 --> 00:33:24,125
too. Have that room across the

989
00:33:24,125 --> 00:33:25,326
way Conference center. Um,

990
00:33:25,326 --> 00:33:28,926
Since there is no state of

991
00:33:29,598 --> 00:33:30,465
emergency anymore. A little

992
00:33:30,465 --> 00:33:33,369
history. Um, well, oh, a friend

993
00:33:33,369 --> 00:33:33,669
of mine. Ah or any Huntington

994
00:33:33,669 --> 00:33:35,669
s

995
00:33:37,206 --> 00:33:37,873
beach. They just passed a flag

996
00:33:37,873 --> 00:33:39,341
law either just allowing

997
00:33:39,341 --> 00:33:42,341
official flags. I know this

998
00:33:42,611 --> 00:33:44,981
comes up later in the item, 12,

999
00:33:44,981 --> 00:33:46,416
but, um An old friend of mine.

1000
00:33:46,416 --> 00:33:48,451
He used to be a state senator

1001
00:33:48,451 --> 00:33:50,887
and Assemblyman. They just made

1002
00:33:50,887 --> 00:33:52,355
it so that only official

1003
00:33:52,355 --> 00:33:53,389
American state flags can be

1004
00:33:53,389 --> 00:33:54,557
flown. So. You can

1005
00:33:54,557 --> 00:33:55,892
t have a

1006
00:33:55,892 --> 00:33:56,610
Confederate flag. You can

1007
00:33:56,610 --> 00:33:58,610
t

1008
00:33:58,361 --> 00:33:59,962
have the the any kind of weird

1009
00:33:59,962 --> 00:34:03,562
flag up there. You just have.

1010
00:34:05,536 --> 00:34:08,672
Normal flag. Um In the in the

1011
00:34:08,672 --> 00:34:10,774
state in our state. We have 58

1012
00:34:10,774 --> 00:34:13,100
counties. We have 480 cities

1013
00:34:13,100 --> 00:34:14,611
with, uh most of them will

1014
00:34:14,611 --> 00:34:17,110
probably over 400 having less

1015
00:34:18,782 --> 00:34:20,782
than 100 100,000 people. Um 120

1016
00:34:20,918 --> 00:34:23,318
over MARCH charter cities.

1017
00:34:24,956 --> 00:34:27,191
Charter cities have a

1018
00:34:27,191 --> 00:34:29,493
Embellishment to them that they

1019
00:34:29,493 --> 00:34:29,894
How the power over municipal

1020
00:34:29,894 --> 00:34:30,895
affairs. There

1021
00:34:30,895 --> 00:34:31,228
s a question on

1022
00:34:31,228 --> 00:34:32,563
that, and I

1023
00:34:32,563 --> 00:34:35,563
d like you to look

1024
00:34:36,330 --> 00:34:36,534
at YouTube. Home rule in

1025
00:34:36,534 --> 00:34:36,834
California cities, It

1026
00:34:36,834 --> 00:34:38,203
s put

1027
00:34:38,203 --> 00:34:38,374
them on the league of Cities.

1028
00:34:38,374 --> 00:34:38,770
It

1029
00:34:38,770 --> 00:34:40,539
s the best thing I

1030
00:34:40,539 --> 00:34:42,107
ve ever

1031
00:34:42,107 --> 00:34:44,509
seen on it, Um, talks about the

1032
00:34:44,509 --> 00:34:47,178
power of a general city like

1033
00:34:47,178 --> 00:34:48,130
you have here in the power of a

1034
00:34:48,130 --> 00:34:50,915
charter city and what the

1035
00:34:50,915 --> 00:34:52,170
charter City has a lot more

1036
00:34:52,170 --> 00:34:54,252
power against the state. The

1037
00:34:54,252 --> 00:34:54,954
dictatorship of the state.

1038
00:34:54,954 --> 00:34:57,122
Thank you very much Thank you.

1039
00:34:57,122 --> 00:35:00,122
Next speaker. Next speaker is

1040
00:35:05,297 --> 00:35:07,697
Dario Bianchi. Welcome. Thank

1041
00:35:10,636 --> 00:35:11,503
you. Good evening. Um, so let

1042
00:35:11,503 --> 00:35:13,503
s

1043
00:35:13,906 --> 00:35:16,142
start to be non David. Since

1044
00:35:16,142 --> 00:35:19,790
there is division in this

1045
00:35:19,790 --> 00:35:20,647
country and very concerned

1046
00:35:20,647 --> 00:35:22,515
about that, okay, and to do so

1047
00:35:22,515 --> 00:35:26,715
we have to talk about one of

1048
00:35:26,953 --> 00:35:27,587
the most divisive. Issue today.

1049
00:35:27,587 --> 00:35:30,891
For the last five years at

1050
00:35:30,891 --> 00:35:33,891
least. Critical theory is part

1051
00:35:36,397 --> 00:35:37,640
of a system of Marxist related

1052
00:35:37,640 --> 00:35:39,464
social terrorists developed by

1053
00:35:42,603 --> 00:35:44,338
academics. That is at least a

1054
00:35:44,338 --> 00:35:46,738
defamatory claim that America

1055
00:35:47,842 --> 00:35:50,242
is systematically racist. Okay?

1056
00:35:50,345 --> 00:35:50,645
I know something about that My

1057
00:35:50,645 --> 00:35:51,790
wife, She

1058
00:35:51,790 --> 00:35:53,790
s African American,

1059
00:35:56,284 --> 00:35:57,485
okay? The perceptive critical

1060
00:35:57,485 --> 00:36:00,485
race theory have now burst

1061
00:36:02,456 --> 00:36:03,991
outside. The University and

1062
00:36:03,991 --> 00:36:04,793
permeate our corporation,

1063
00:36:04,793 --> 00:36:06,793
government military and

1064
00:36:09,598 --> 00:36:11,998
especially our school. Under

1065
00:36:14,690 --> 00:36:16,370
the guise of code words such as

1066
00:36:16,370 --> 00:36:16,605
equity, anti racism, inclusion

1067
00:36:16,605 --> 00:36:18,605
inflation, leftist today

1068
00:36:20,675 --> 00:36:21,276
prome Critical race theory

1069
00:36:21,276 --> 00:36:23,276
perceptive through American

1070
00:36:26,482 --> 00:36:28,482
institutions. They profoundly

1071
00:36:28,618 --> 00:36:30,820
radical elements of critical

1072
00:36:30,820 --> 00:36:33,890
race terrorist springs from

1073
00:36:33,890 --> 00:36:35,858
Marxist segment of the academic

1074
00:36:35,858 --> 00:36:38,258
left alongside Other extreme

1075
00:36:40,230 --> 00:36:41,798
school of thought. According to

1076
00:36:41,798 --> 00:36:42,799
critical race theory. All

1077
00:36:42,799 --> 00:36:43,433
Western civilization,

1078
00:36:43,433 --> 00:36:44,734
especially America is infused

1079
00:36:44,734 --> 00:36:47,734
to the court with white

1080
00:36:50,206 --> 00:36:53,206
supremacist. So my idea would

1081
00:36:53,376 --> 00:36:55,711
be this We have the ready

1082
00:36:55,711 --> 00:36:57,711
Commission race equity.

1083
00:36:58,449 --> 00:37:00,651
Diversity inclusion. I suggest

1084
00:37:00,651 --> 00:37:02,486
to the City Council to change

1085
00:37:02,486 --> 00:37:05,486
the race equality. In diversity.

1086
00:37:07,157 --> 00:37:10,757
There will be fair. There will

1087
00:37:11,895 --> 00:37:12,630
be non divisive. Because equity

1088
00:37:12,630 --> 00:37:16,230
and inclusion is divisive to us.

1089
00:37:17,200 --> 00:37:18,103
To my family. To the American

1090
00:37:18,103 --> 00:37:19,437
people, So I

1091
00:37:19,437 --> 00:37:21,837
m asking you to

1092
00:37:22,840 --> 00:37:24,342
take a stand on this and do not

1093
00:37:24,342 --> 00:37:25,900
divide the United states as

1094
00:37:25,900 --> 00:37:28,609
much as we are already. Thank

1095
00:37:30,148 --> 00:37:31,282
you. Thank you Next speaker.

1096
00:37:31,282 --> 00:37:33,682
That concludes in person

1097
00:37:34,720 --> 00:37:35,754
comments I do have to email

1098
00:37:35,754 --> 00:37:37,220
comments and we still have time

1099
00:37:37,220 --> 00:37:37,192
in the 30 minutes, so we

1100
00:37:37,192 --> 00:37:39,192
ll go

1101
00:37:39,291 --> 00:37:41,727
ahead and read those two

1102
00:37:41,727 --> 00:37:44,727
comments into the record. The

1103
00:37:45,197 --> 00:37:47,299
first is from Rick Reese, and

1104
00:37:47,299 --> 00:37:50,299
it was also submitted verbatim

1105
00:37:54,207 --> 00:37:55,674
by Rich Handy. This. Commentary

1106
00:37:55,674 --> 00:37:55,844
regards multiple topic, So

1107
00:37:55,844 --> 00:37:57,760
let

1108
00:37:57,760 --> 00:37:58,778
s get directly to the

1109
00:37:58,778 --> 00:38:00,112
points on FEBRUARY 28th. The

1110
00:38:00,112 --> 00:38:02,314
governor is scheduled to end

1111
00:38:02,314 --> 00:38:03,716
the Covid 19 State of emergency

1112
00:38:03,716 --> 00:38:05,985
for California if the city of

1113
00:38:05,985 --> 00:38:07,521
Temecula still has an emergency

1114
00:38:07,521 --> 00:38:10,490
resolution, in effect due to

1115
00:38:10,490 --> 00:38:12,692
the very likely Wuhan, China

1116
00:38:12,692 --> 00:38:13,694
originated. Covid 19 virus lab

1117
00:38:13,694 --> 00:38:15,929
leak caused pandemic. The now

1118
00:38:15,929 --> 00:38:17,164
is the time to retire or vacate

1119
00:38:17,164 --> 00:38:18,765
this emergency resolution. Our

1120
00:38:18,765 --> 00:38:21,368
city needs a return to normalcy

1121
00:38:21,368 --> 00:38:23,169
and an end to this indefinite

1122
00:38:23,169 --> 00:38:24,404
and seemingly forever state of

1123
00:38:24,404 --> 00:38:26,140
emergency just as a point of

1124
00:38:26,140 --> 00:38:28,209
order, it has become very

1125
00:38:28,209 --> 00:38:29,744
apparent that past references

1126
00:38:29,744 --> 00:38:31,445
to this lab creative lab

1127
00:38:31,445 --> 00:38:33,614
created pandemic as the China

1128
00:38:33,614 --> 00:38:34,882
virus actually have a lot of

1129
00:38:34,882 --> 00:38:36,160
truth. The Technical Chinese

1130
00:38:36,160 --> 00:38:37,218
Communists have earned this

1131
00:38:37,218 --> 00:38:38,853
distinction. Let them bear the

1132
00:38:38,853 --> 00:38:39,353
burden of this truth with no

1133
00:38:39,353 --> 00:38:40,954
apologies on America

1134
00:38:40,954 --> 00:38:42,491
s part.

1135
00:38:42,491 --> 00:38:43,625
Next in regards to item 12. It

1136
00:38:43,625 --> 00:38:46,940
is imperative for the City

1137
00:38:46,940 --> 00:38:47,662
Council to stand up for local

1138
00:38:47,662 --> 00:38:49,364
control of city zoning and to

1139
00:38:49,364 --> 00:38:52,133
push back against the sp nine

1140
00:38:52,133 --> 00:38:53,969
and sb 10 paragraph by

1141
00:38:53,969 --> 00:38:54,702
Sacramento, much like a

1142
00:38:54,702 --> 00:38:56,702
totalitarian political borough,

1143
00:38:56,738 --> 00:38:57,706
the governor and the

1144
00:38:57,706 --> 00:38:59,642
Legislature seizing local

1145
00:38:59,642 --> 00:39:00,543
control and centralizing that

1146
00:39:00,543 --> 00:39:01,710
power and Sacramento City

1147
00:39:01,710 --> 00:39:02,811
councils have become little

1148
00:39:02,811 --> 00:39:03,112
more than rubber stamps for

1149
00:39:03,112 --> 00:39:04,780
Sacramento

1150
00:39:04,780 --> 00:39:06,315
s edicts. The

1151
00:39:06,315 --> 00:39:07,850
Council should also emulate

1152
00:39:07,850 --> 00:39:09,918
cities like San Marcos del Mar

1153
00:39:09,918 --> 00:39:12,318
Renter Center, Margarita and

1154
00:39:13,155 --> 00:39:14,456
many others by supporting the

1155
00:39:14,456 --> 00:39:15,858
brand wing Mendoza tripartisan

1156
00:39:15,858 --> 00:39:17,494
Land use initiative. Please do

1157
00:39:17,494 --> 00:39:20,494
not waver to Sacramento by

1158
00:39:20,497 --> 00:39:21,998
Falling for their planned and

1159
00:39:21,998 --> 00:39:22,432
promoted accessory dwelling

1160
00:39:22,432 --> 00:39:22,732
units. Sacramento

1161
00:39:22,732 --> 00:39:24,732
s paragraph

1162
00:39:24,834 --> 00:39:25,702
is a dystopian attempt at bad

1163
00:39:25,702 --> 00:39:28,104
urban planning that utilizes a

1164
00:39:28,104 --> 00:39:28,871
cookie cutter approach to all

1165
00:39:28,871 --> 00:39:29,572
of California

1166
00:39:29,572 --> 00:39:31,572
s geographically

1167
00:39:32,308 --> 00:39:34,100
and culturally diverse cities

1168
00:39:34,100 --> 00:39:35,612
and communities. If anything

1169
00:39:35,612 --> 00:39:38,315
this politburo like approach to

1170
00:39:38,315 --> 00:39:39,183
urban planning is in reality,

1171
00:39:39,183 --> 00:39:40,684
anti diversity. Their scheme

1172
00:39:40,684 --> 00:39:41,452
seeks Top down conformity of

1173
00:39:41,452 --> 00:39:43,587
communities that are as

1174
00:39:43,587 --> 00:39:44,521
different as the desert. Is to

1175
00:39:44,521 --> 00:39:46,156
the mountains and as different

1176
00:39:46,156 --> 00:39:48,825
as a beach community is to our

1177
00:39:48,825 --> 00:39:50,593
wine country. Lastly, in

1178
00:39:50,593 --> 00:39:51,995
regards to business item number

1179
00:39:51,995 --> 00:39:53,498
14 concerning a ballot measure

1180
00:39:53,498 --> 00:39:55,660
to establish city Council term

1181
00:39:55,660 --> 00:39:56,400
limits. This should indeed move

1182
00:39:56,400 --> 00:39:58,136
forward to the voters. Yet

1183
00:39:58,136 --> 00:39:59,437
there also seems to be the need

1184
00:39:59,437 --> 00:40:00,705
to properly define what

1185
00:40:00,705 --> 00:40:02,540
constitutes a city Council term

1186
00:40:02,540 --> 00:40:05,543
of office if a vacancy occurs

1187
00:40:05,543 --> 00:40:06,210
and is filled by a council

1188
00:40:06,210 --> 00:40:08,120
appointee to fulfill the

1189
00:40:08,120 --> 00:40:10,480
remaining 44 months in office,

1190
00:40:10,480 --> 00:40:11,716
should this 44 months. Count as

1191
00:40:11,716 --> 00:40:12,150
a full term or shouldn

1192
00:40:12,150 --> 00:40:13,685
t even

1193
00:40:13,685 --> 00:40:15,153
shorter term of office of say,

1194
00:40:15,153 --> 00:40:16,688
two years minus one day be

1195
00:40:16,688 --> 00:40:18,490
considered as a partial term

1196
00:40:18,490 --> 00:40:19,958
that qualifies the number 23

1197
00:40:19,958 --> 00:40:21,260
more full terms. These

1198
00:40:21,260 --> 00:40:23,695
potential wrinkles need to be

1199
00:40:23,695 --> 00:40:25,630
addressed. If. This has not

1200
00:40:25,630 --> 00:40:26,598
already been considered in the

1201
00:40:26,598 --> 00:40:27,166
council needs to further

1202
00:40:27,166 --> 00:40:28,634
deliberate otherwise, the

1203
00:40:28,634 --> 00:40:30,200
council member in theory could

1204
00:40:30,200 --> 00:40:31,637
serve a less than four year

1205
00:40:31,637 --> 00:40:32,872
partial term than be elected

1206
00:40:32,872 --> 00:40:35,641
and re elected to end up

1207
00:40:35,641 --> 00:40:37,420
serving 14 15 or close to 16

1208
00:40:37,420 --> 00:40:38,611
years in office. Thank you for

1209
00:40:38,611 --> 00:40:41,611
your time and attention and

1210
00:40:41,914 --> 00:40:44,914
godspeed to the Chinese people.

1211
00:40:46,820 --> 00:40:48,688
And, then the last, um Comment

1212
00:40:48,688 --> 00:40:51,658
emailed in is from Polly

1213
00:40:51,658 --> 00:40:52,659
Steinbeck. Women are regularly

1214
00:40:52,659 --> 00:40:54,394
getting drugged and local

1215
00:40:54,394 --> 00:40:55,561
Temecula bars and the owner

1216
00:40:55,561 --> 00:40:57,330
should be looked into. I would

1217
00:40:57,330 --> 00:40:57,964
like to submit a public comment

1218
00:40:57,964 --> 00:41:00,967
on this matter to the City

1219
00:41:00,967 --> 00:41:03,571
Council. Mr Mayor. That is all

1220
00:41:03,571 --> 00:41:05,439
of the in person and emailed

1221
00:41:05,439 --> 00:41:06,707
comments for non agendas items

1222
00:41:06,707 --> 00:41:08,409
and we

1223
00:41:08,409 --> 00:41:09,420
ll take the items. The

1224
00:41:09,420 --> 00:41:12,420
comments on agenda items at

1225
00:41:12,613 --> 00:41:15,130
that time. Correct. Correct.

1226
00:41:15,215 --> 00:41:16,183
Thank you okay? Moving on to

1227
00:41:16,183 --> 00:41:17,351
our city council reports to any

1228
00:41:17,351 --> 00:41:17,551
of my colleagues have anything

1229
00:41:17,551 --> 00:41:19,551
they

1230
00:41:20,822 --> 00:41:24,422
d like to report out. Yes.

1231
00:41:26,294 --> 00:41:29,294
Council member Brown Yeah. I

1232
00:41:29,931 --> 00:41:31,599
just wanted to highlight that

1233
00:41:31,599 --> 00:41:31,799
MARCH 1st Tomorrow starts

1234
00:41:31,799 --> 00:41:33,101
Women

1235
00:41:33,101 --> 00:41:33,267
s History month, So,

1236
00:41:33,267 --> 00:41:34,702
You

1237
00:41:34,702 --> 00:41:37,102
re invited. Everyone is

1238
00:41:37,506 --> 00:41:41,106
invited to come out MARCH 9th

1239
00:41:41,410 --> 00:41:44,479
at six pm to hear the council

1240
00:41:44,479 --> 00:41:44,813
chambers to hear the

1241
00:41:44,813 --> 00:41:45,247
commissioner

1242
00:41:45,247 --> 00:41:45,514
s proclaim. MARCH

1243
00:41:45,514 --> 00:41:47,349
is women

1244
00:41:47,349 --> 00:41:47,882
s history month and

1245
00:41:47,882 --> 00:41:50,282
there you was received

1246
00:41:50,686 --> 00:41:53,860
presentations. And, then also

1247
00:41:53,880 --> 00:41:53,956
hear from speakers that will

1248
00:41:53,956 --> 00:41:54,256
raise awareness to women

1249
00:41:54,256 --> 00:41:55,859
s

1250
00:41:55,859 --> 00:41:58,940
history month as well as speak

1251
00:41:58,940 --> 00:42:00,797
to some of the work that still

1252
00:42:00,797 --> 00:42:04,500
needs to be done in regards to

1253
00:42:04,500 --> 00:42:05,301
gender equality. Thank you?

1254
00:42:05,301 --> 00:42:08,301
Thank you very much. Council

1255
00:42:09,338 --> 00:42:10,773
member, Alexander Alrighty.

1256
00:42:10,773 --> 00:42:12,943
Well. Thank you so much first

1257
00:42:12,943 --> 00:42:14,144
to the Sheriff department. I

1258
00:42:14,144 --> 00:42:16,713
had a, uh, another ability to

1259
00:42:16,713 --> 00:42:17,414
go on a ride along over the

1260
00:42:17,414 --> 00:42:19,850
weekend. This time I was able

1261
00:42:19,850 --> 00:42:20,350
to go with the metro team again.

1262
00:42:20,350 --> 00:42:21,151
Mostly probably weren

1263
00:42:21,151 --> 00:42:22,652
t here.

1264
00:42:22,652 --> 00:42:23,587
The last meeting, so I try to

1265
00:42:23,587 --> 00:42:24,354
go on these things about

1266
00:42:24,354 --> 00:42:26,754
quarterly every couple of

1267
00:42:27,157 --> 00:42:27,624
months just to get a feel as to

1268
00:42:27,624 --> 00:42:28,158
what? Uh what

1269
00:42:28,158 --> 00:42:30,940
s going on here

1270
00:42:30,940 --> 00:42:31,329
in the city with our here in

1271
00:42:31,329 --> 00:42:32,129
old town and in different areas

1272
00:42:32,129 --> 00:42:32,396
and see if there

1273
00:42:32,396 --> 00:42:34,396
s any gaps

1274
00:42:35,433 --> 00:42:37,168
that MAY be I can see where we

1275
00:42:37,168 --> 00:42:38,836
can kind of fill in together.

1276
00:42:38,836 --> 00:42:40,838
So. I just I had a great ride

1277
00:42:40,838 --> 00:42:42,873
along I was even able to I had

1278
00:42:42,873 --> 00:42:44,708
the opportunity to go down and

1279
00:42:44,708 --> 00:42:46,744
see the police station right

1280
00:42:46,744 --> 00:42:48,346
here, right next here to City

1281
00:42:48,346 --> 00:42:49,214
Council, um to City Hall, and

1282
00:42:49,214 --> 00:42:50,782
it was wonderful and it was

1283
00:42:50,782 --> 00:42:53,385
just good to see that these

1284
00:42:53,385 --> 00:42:55,153
guys have a place to kind of

1285
00:42:55,153 --> 00:42:56,621
start and stop from its kind of

1286
00:42:56,621 --> 00:42:58,423
close to home somewhere to be

1287
00:42:58,423 --> 00:42:59,323
able to detain the individuals

1288
00:42:59,323 --> 00:43:00,910
until they can get the

1289
00:43:00,910 --> 00:43:01,590
paperwork done, So. I just want

1290
00:43:01,590 --> 00:43:04,620
to say thank you to staff for

1291
00:43:04,620 --> 00:43:04,997
getting that done. Great job to

1292
00:43:04,997 --> 00:43:05,731
everybody for putting that all

1293
00:43:05,731 --> 00:43:06,365
together. It was really good,

1294
00:43:06,365 --> 00:43:07,990
and I believe it

1295
00:43:07,990 --> 00:43:09,990
s really going

1296
00:43:10,690 --> 00:43:12,204
to help our public safety

1297
00:43:12,204 --> 00:43:14,306
overall that also being said We

1298
00:43:14,306 --> 00:43:16,141
had a probably one of our first

1299
00:43:16,141 --> 00:43:18,177
in a while Public Traffic

1300
00:43:18,177 --> 00:43:20,577
Safety commission meetings with

1301
00:43:21,246 --> 00:43:22,982
myself, Um, Mr Carter and, um,

1302
00:43:22,982 --> 00:43:24,951
Mr Maddox as well Commissioners

1303
00:43:24,951 --> 00:43:26,619
and it was and also I think you

1304
00:43:26,619 --> 00:43:30,219
were in there as well, right?

1305
00:43:30,990 --> 00:43:32,625
Yeah, the two of us we, myself

1306
00:43:32,625 --> 00:43:34,660
and Cinnamon City City Council

1307
00:43:34,660 --> 00:43:36,195
member Alphas. We were able to

1308
00:43:36,195 --> 00:43:37,330
have the conversation as to how

1309
00:43:37,330 --> 00:43:38,631
to move forward with this

1310
00:43:38,631 --> 00:43:39,800
commission and really all of

1311
00:43:39,800 --> 00:43:41,635
them moving forward with how

1312
00:43:41,635 --> 00:43:42,336
the City Council and the staff

1313
00:43:42,336 --> 00:43:44,271
can work together, so I just

1314
00:43:44,271 --> 00:43:45,939
want to thank you both for

1315
00:43:45,939 --> 00:43:47,307
coming in and speaking with us.

1316
00:43:47,307 --> 00:43:48,142
Just look forward to having

1317
00:43:48,142 --> 00:43:49,843
more meetings and just giving

1318
00:43:49,843 --> 00:43:51,311
like we spoke about more goals

1319
00:43:51,311 --> 00:43:51,945
as to how everything is going

1320
00:43:51,945 --> 00:43:54,945
to be structured with the

1321
00:43:55,150 --> 00:43:55,282
commission. Ah, the last bit. I

1322
00:43:55,282 --> 00:43:57,282
guess I

1323
00:43:57,652 --> 00:43:58,119
m Just going to ask a

1324
00:43:58,119 --> 00:43:58,519
city manager? I don

1325
00:43:58,519 --> 00:43:58,695
t know if

1326
00:43:58,695 --> 00:44:00,210
it

1327
00:44:00,210 --> 00:44:01,556
s a better time now or later.

1328
00:44:01,556 --> 00:44:02,323
I know somebody during comments

1329
00:44:02,323 --> 00:44:04,592
had asked about the state of

1330
00:44:04,592 --> 00:44:06,561
the city or the city emergency

1331
00:44:06,561 --> 00:44:07,862
for the state. Where. Do we

1332
00:44:07,862 --> 00:44:09,960
fall on that if do we fall

1333
00:44:09,960 --> 00:44:12,696
under the state is that get

1334
00:44:13,401 --> 00:44:15,671
canceled? Cover 19. Temecula is

1335
00:44:15,671 --> 00:44:17,472
not under a state of emergency.

1336
00:44:17,472 --> 00:44:17,672
Okay. Thank you very much and

1337
00:44:17,672 --> 00:44:18,340
that

1338
00:44:18,340 --> 00:44:18,540
s all. Yeah, I think

1339
00:44:18,540 --> 00:44:20,242
that

1340
00:44:20,242 --> 00:44:22,577
s all I have. Thank you.

1341
00:44:22,577 --> 00:44:23,512
Thank you very much. Nothing

1342
00:44:23,512 --> 00:44:24,780
else from any of my colleagues

1343
00:44:24,780 --> 00:44:24,980
and I have nothing this evening,

1344
00:44:24,980 --> 00:44:26,980
so we

1345
00:44:27,415 --> 00:44:28,449
ll move on to our consent

1346
00:44:28,449 --> 00:44:29,317
calendar. All matters listed

1347
00:44:29,317 --> 00:44:31,520
under consent are considered to

1348
00:44:31,520 --> 00:44:32,421
be routine and all will be

1349
00:44:32,421 --> 00:44:33,880
enacted by one roll call vote.

1350
00:44:33,880 --> 00:44:34,457
I. Don

1351
00:44:34,457 --> 00:44:36,792
t number one is a waive

1352
00:44:36,792 --> 00:44:38,661
reading of title and text of

1353
00:44:38,661 --> 00:44:40,229
all ordinances and resolutions,

1354
00:44:40,229 --> 00:44:41,330
including included in the

1355
00:44:41,330 --> 00:44:44,330
Agenda Item two has approved

1356
00:44:44,333 --> 00:44:46,469
action minutes of FEBRUARY 14th

1357
00:44:46,469 --> 00:44:47,436
2023 Item, number three is

1358
00:44:47,436 --> 00:44:48,838
approved list of demands Item

1359
00:44:48,838 --> 00:44:50,540
Number four, is approved First

1360
00:44:50,540 --> 00:44:51,808
amendment to agreement with

1361
00:44:51,808 --> 00:44:53,510
proactive Fire Design and

1362
00:44:53,510 --> 00:44:54,811
Consulting Inc for Fire

1363
00:44:54,811 --> 00:44:57,211
Department Plan Review Service

1364
00:44:57,614 --> 00:44:57,781
for fiscal year 2022 2023 I.

1365
00:44:57,781 --> 00:44:59,716
Don

1366
00:44:59,716 --> 00:45:00,583
t Remember five, is

1367
00:45:00,583 --> 00:45:01,985
approved Consultant Agreement

1368
00:45:01,985 --> 00:45:04,187
with Community Works Design

1369
00:45:04,187 --> 00:45:07,187
Group for the Ronald Reagan

1370
00:45:08,792 --> 00:45:10,861
Sports Park skatepark pw 22-76

1371
00:45:10,861 --> 00:45:11,729
is approved Agreements for on

1372
00:45:11,729 --> 00:45:12,729
call excavation, backfill and

1373
00:45:12,729 --> 00:45:14,729
grading maintenance services

1374
00:45:15,650 --> 00:45:17,465
for fiscal year 2023 through

1375
00:45:17,868 --> 00:45:20,268
2028. Number seven is approved

1376
00:45:20,471 --> 00:45:21,105
increase to the professional

1377
00:45:21,105 --> 00:45:22,940
services contingency

1378
00:45:22,940 --> 00:45:25,340
authorization for the Margarita,

1379
00:45:26,845 --> 00:45:29,447
a recreation center project tw

1380
00:45:29,447 --> 00:45:31,820
17-21 and Item. Number eight is

1381
00:45:31,820 --> 00:45:31,816
approved plans and

1382
00:45:31,816 --> 00:45:32,517
specifications and authorized

1383
00:45:32,517 --> 00:45:34,517
solicitation of construction

1384
00:45:35,520 --> 00:45:36,530
bids for the Mary Phillips

1385
00:45:36,530 --> 00:45:38,530
Senior Center Outdoor

1386
00:45:39,890 --> 00:45:41,960
Recreation Project p w 22-8.

1387
00:45:41,960 --> 00:45:43,295
And item number nine is except

1388
00:45:43,295 --> 00:45:45,197
improvements and file notice of

1389
00:45:45,197 --> 00:45:46,865
completion for the Senate

1390
00:45:46,865 --> 00:45:48,300
gratuitous pedestrian bicycle

1391
00:45:48,300 --> 00:45:50,300
Trail extension and

1392
00:45:52,571 --> 00:45:54,971
interconnect Project pw 08-04.

1393
00:45:55,274 --> 00:45:55,974
I will entertain a motion and a

1394
00:45:55,974 --> 00:45:58,510
second motion to approve second.

1395
00:45:58,510 --> 00:46:02,710
Okay. We have a motion in the

1396
00:46:08,788 --> 00:46:10,923
second. Let us vote. Okay and

1397
00:46:10,923 --> 00:46:13,323
that passes 50 before recess

1398
00:46:13,326 --> 00:46:14,600
and move on to our Temecula

1399
00:46:14,600 --> 00:46:15,561
Community Services district

1400
00:46:15,561 --> 00:46:16,997
meeting. We do have an addendum

1401
00:46:16,997 --> 00:46:17,497
to the agenda and I

1402
00:46:17,497 --> 00:46:18,966
d like to

1403
00:46:18,966 --> 00:46:20,533
hand it off to our city

1404
00:46:20,533 --> 00:46:22,836
attorney at this time for a

1405
00:46:22,836 --> 00:46:24,838
brief staff report. Yes, Mr

1406
00:46:24,838 --> 00:46:26,540
Mayor and members of the City

1407
00:46:26,540 --> 00:46:27,307
Council. Um, as you know, the

1408
00:46:27,307 --> 00:46:29,442
city experienced some very

1409
00:46:29,442 --> 00:46:30,844
heavy rains over the weekend,

1410
00:46:30,844 --> 00:46:32,746
and there were a couple of

1411
00:46:32,746 --> 00:46:35,746
places where there were some

1412
00:46:36,417 --> 00:46:37,752
substantial damage to storm

1413
00:46:37,752 --> 00:46:38,852
drains and two roadways. The

1414
00:46:38,852 --> 00:46:41,252
Brown Act normally requires

1415
00:46:41,655 --> 00:46:43,190
that all items be listed on the

1416
00:46:43,190 --> 00:46:44,925
agenda except in emergency

1417
00:46:44,925 --> 00:46:47,925
situations such as this, so

1418
00:46:48,129 --> 00:46:49,663
staff is recommending that you

1419
00:46:49,663 --> 00:46:52,100
Adopting a motion that would

1420
00:46:52,100 --> 00:46:53,935
add an agenda item to the

1421
00:46:53,935 --> 00:46:55,437
agenda as a late action item

1422
00:46:55,437 --> 00:46:59,370
finding that the need to take

1423
00:46:59,341 --> 00:47:01,643
immediate action to repair

1424
00:47:01,643 --> 00:47:03,278
these storm damages is requires

1425
00:47:03,278 --> 00:47:06,800
immediate action and that that

1426
00:47:06,800 --> 00:47:06,748
issue came to the attention of

1427
00:47:06,748 --> 00:47:08,550
the city after the agenda was

1428
00:47:08,550 --> 00:47:09,919
posted. And that

1429
00:47:09,919 --> 00:47:11,919
s authorized

1430
00:47:12,988 --> 00:47:13,889
by government code section

1431
00:47:13,889 --> 00:47:15,570
54954.2. So that would be the

1432
00:47:15,570 --> 00:47:17,359
initial action that you take.

1433
00:47:17,359 --> 00:47:18,394
And then I. Think. After that

1434
00:47:18,394 --> 00:47:19,895
Mr Thomas will explain what has

1435
00:47:19,895 --> 00:47:20,295
occurred. And. Then. There

1436
00:47:20,295 --> 00:47:21,496
s a

1437
00:47:21,496 --> 00:47:23,896
resolution providing for the

1438
00:47:25,501 --> 00:47:26,936
emergency work to be done. Okay.

1439
00:47:26,936 --> 00:47:29,500
Any questions of staff from

1440
00:47:29,500 --> 00:47:31,740
council members right now. Okay?

1441
00:47:31,740 --> 00:47:33,740
Um, I

1442
00:47:33,760 --> 00:47:36,760
ll entertain a motion to

1443
00:47:36,790 --> 00:47:38,481
that item to the agenda. Second

1444
00:47:38,481 --> 00:47:39,215
No a motion first and then a

1445
00:47:39,215 --> 00:47:40,516
second motion. Okay. Okay, so

1446
00:47:40,516 --> 00:47:44,116
we have emotion in a second.

1447
00:47:49,493 --> 00:47:51,395
Let us vote. Okay that passes

1448
00:47:51,395 --> 00:47:52,462
50, and now we can come to that

1449
00:47:52,462 --> 00:47:54,131
island and I will turn it over

1450
00:47:54,131 --> 00:47:56,466
to our public works Director

1451
00:47:56,466 --> 00:47:57,968
Pat Thomas. Thank you mayor

1452
00:47:57,968 --> 00:47:59,770
shrink so the events that

1453
00:47:59,770 --> 00:48:01,538
occurred over the weekend where

1454
00:48:01,538 --> 00:48:02,907
we had we found a couple of

1455
00:48:02,907 --> 00:48:04,142
sinkholes and a few locations

1456
00:48:04,142 --> 00:48:06,777
where storm drains are located.

1457
00:48:06,777 --> 00:48:08,679
One of those is on Margarita

1458
00:48:08,679 --> 00:48:10,214
Road just north of salon away

1459
00:48:10,214 --> 00:48:11,549
on the west side of Margarita

1460
00:48:11,549 --> 00:48:11,816
Road, and we we

1461
00:48:11,816 --> 00:48:12,416
ve televised

1462
00:48:12,416 --> 00:48:13,551
that storm drain have found

1463
00:48:13,551 --> 00:48:14,818
that the storm buried actually

1464
00:48:14,818 --> 00:48:15,853
did collapse and so will need

1465
00:48:15,853 --> 00:48:17,188
to replace a portion of that

1466
00:48:17,188 --> 00:48:18,289
storm drain. There

1467
00:48:18,289 --> 00:48:20,192
s actually a

1468
00:48:20,192 --> 00:48:20,826
road closure in place at that

1469
00:48:20,826 --> 00:48:21,360
location right now, so that

1470
00:48:21,360 --> 00:48:23,261
s

1471
00:48:23,261 --> 00:48:26,164
one of the areas that is

1472
00:48:26,164 --> 00:48:29,670
included, and the second area

1473
00:48:29,670 --> 00:48:31,202
is at the eastern and of

1474
00:48:31,202 --> 00:48:32,136
Santiago Road, where where it

1475
00:48:32,136 --> 00:48:32,471
ends, basically from from in

1476
00:48:32,471 --> 00:48:34,471
Ezra, there

1477
00:48:34,806 --> 00:48:35,874
s a storm drain

1478
00:48:35,874 --> 00:48:37,376
that again crosses Santiago

1479
00:48:37,376 --> 00:48:38,644
Road that collapsed with the

1480
00:48:38,644 --> 00:48:40,979
rains that needs to be repaired

1481
00:48:40,979 --> 00:48:41,647
and replaced. And so we

1482
00:48:41,647 --> 00:48:43,647
re

1483
00:48:45,318 --> 00:48:46,752
asking the council to adopt a

1484
00:48:46,752 --> 00:48:48,354
resolution declaring these

1485
00:48:48,354 --> 00:48:49,655
emergency condition to exist

1486
00:48:49,655 --> 00:48:50,623
and exempting us from the

1487
00:48:50,623 --> 00:48:52,358
bidding requirements so that we

1488
00:48:52,358 --> 00:48:54,294
can move forward with directly

1489
00:48:54,294 --> 00:48:55,962
repairing and replacing the

1490
00:48:55,962 --> 00:48:57,230
storm drains so that concludes

1491
00:48:57,230 --> 00:48:58,298
staff report. Okay, Thank you

1492
00:48:58,298 --> 00:49:01,868
any questions of staff on this

1493
00:49:01,868 --> 00:49:03,870
item? Nope. Okay. No questions

1494
00:49:03,870 --> 00:49:04,971
Mr City Attorney. Do we need to

1495
00:49:04,971 --> 00:49:05,305
read the resolution. We, don

1496
00:49:05,305 --> 00:49:06,390
t

1497
00:49:06,390 --> 00:49:07,474
Okay, so I

1498
00:49:07,474 --> 00:49:09,750
ll entertain a

1499
00:49:09,750 --> 00:49:12,120
motion to motion and a second

1500
00:49:12,120 --> 00:49:12,846
to approved. Sorry. I can

1501
00:49:12,846 --> 00:49:13,547
t

1502
00:49:13,547 --> 00:49:17,747
motion and a second let us vote.

1503
00:49:22,790 --> 00:49:24,240
Okay. I

1504
00:49:24,240 --> 00:49:24,257
m not seeing anything.

1505
00:49:24,257 --> 00:49:24,892
I don

1506
00:49:24,892 --> 00:49:25,559
t think anyone saying

1507
00:49:25,559 --> 00:49:28,559
anything on our screens. There

1508
00:49:31,966 --> 00:49:33,735
we go. Okay and that passes 50.

1509
00:49:33,735 --> 00:49:36,237
Okay. Thank you, everyone for

1510
00:49:36,237 --> 00:49:38,339
Indulging us on that item. Okay.

1511
00:49:38,339 --> 00:49:39,608
I will recess the Temecula City

1512
00:49:39,608 --> 00:49:41,943
Council meeting and turn it

1513
00:49:41,943 --> 00:49:44,450
over to PRESIDENT Stewart for

1514
00:49:44,450 --> 00:49:46,445
the Community Services district

1515
00:49:46,949 --> 00:49:48,583
meeting and I will open the

1516
00:49:48,583 --> 00:49:49,718
Temecula Community Service

1517
00:49:49,718 --> 00:49:50,352
district meeting. MADAM

1518
00:49:50,352 --> 00:49:50,514
Secretary, Please note. We

1519
00:49:50,514 --> 00:49:51,620
re

1520
00:49:51,620 --> 00:49:54,756
all still her. Do we have any

1521
00:49:54,756 --> 00:49:54,923
public comments. Alright, so

1522
00:49:54,923 --> 00:49:56,158
we

1523
00:49:56,158 --> 00:49:58,193
re onto our consent calendar,

1524
00:49:58,193 --> 00:49:59,461
which is item number 10

1525
00:49:59,461 --> 00:50:01,861
approved action minutes of

1526
00:50:03,465 --> 00:50:04,834
FEBRUARY 14th 2023. Some of the

1527
00:50:04,834 --> 00:50:05,668
second Kid

1528
00:50:05,668 --> 00:50:08,680
s been moved and

1529
00:50:14,477 --> 00:50:16,779
seconded. Please vote. Alright

1530
00:50:16,779 --> 00:50:18,779
that passes, 50 director

1531
00:50:18,981 --> 00:50:20,981
reports. Nothing tonight

1532
00:50:22,520 --> 00:50:23,253
Perfect. General manager.

1533
00:50:23,253 --> 00:50:25,653
Nothing further, Mr PRESIDENT,

1534
00:50:26,220 --> 00:50:29,220
Right. So anything from the

1535
00:50:29,250 --> 00:50:29,693
board members? Nothing. I will

1536
00:50:29,693 --> 00:50:32,662
adjourn this meeting till the

1537
00:50:32,662 --> 00:50:32,826
next one. Okay. And with that

1538
00:50:32,826 --> 00:50:34,826
I

1539
00:50:35,980 --> 00:50:35,665
m going to reconvene the

1540
00:50:35,665 --> 00:50:36,533
Temecula Public Financing

1541
00:50:36,533 --> 00:50:38,100
Authority. MADAM City clerk.

1542
00:50:38,100 --> 00:50:39,537
Please note. We are all still

1543
00:50:39,537 --> 00:50:41,172
here. Do. We have any public

1544
00:50:41,172 --> 00:50:42,106
comments? Okay, we

1545
00:50:42,106 --> 00:50:44,750
ll go ahead

1546
00:50:44,750 --> 00:50:45,542
and move on to consent item 11

1547
00:50:45,542 --> 00:50:47,211
approved action minutes of

1548
00:50:47,211 --> 00:50:47,373
FEBRUARY 14th 2023, i

1549
00:50:47,373 --> 00:50:49,790
ll

1550
00:50:49,790 --> 00:50:51,882
entertain a motion to approve

1551
00:50:51,882 --> 00:50:52,883
motion second Okay. We have a

1552
00:50:52,883 --> 00:50:57,830
motion in a second. Let us vote.

1553
00:51:02,661 --> 00:51:03,261
Okay in that passes. 50

1554
00:51:03,261 --> 00:51:04,462
executive directors report

1555
00:51:04,462 --> 00:51:05,463
nothing and I, MR. Chair Thank

1556
00:51:05,463 --> 00:51:07,732
you board of directors anything?

1557
00:51:07,732 --> 00:51:09,534
Okay. We

1558
00:51:09,534 --> 00:51:11,934
re gonna head and

1559
00:51:13,605 --> 00:51:16,800
adjourn the tp. A meeting to

1560
00:51:16,800 --> 00:51:17,810
our tech Macula City council

1561
00:51:17,810 --> 00:51:19,845
meeting and we have a public

1562
00:51:19,845 --> 00:51:21,413
hearing for item number 12.

1563
00:51:21,413 --> 00:51:23,813
Adopt Ordinance amending title

1564
00:51:23,849 --> 00:51:25,918
five and 17 of the Temecula

1565
00:51:25,918 --> 00:51:27,453
municipal Code pertaining to

1566
00:51:27,453 --> 00:51:28,420
massage establishment accessory

1567
00:51:28,420 --> 00:51:29,488
dwelling units. Carwash

1568
00:51:29,488 --> 00:51:31,560
flagpole. Height limits

1569
00:51:31,560 --> 00:51:33,393
conditional use permits parking

1570
00:51:33,393 --> 00:51:34,961
garage standards. Open Space

1571
00:51:34,961 --> 00:51:35,728
zoning designation live

1572
00:51:35,728 --> 00:51:36,462
entertainment, alcohol,

1573
00:51:36,462 --> 00:51:37,363
beverage manufacturer and

1574
00:51:37,363 --> 00:51:39,763
active and passive recreation

1575
00:51:41,470 --> 00:51:41,716
and find that this ordinance is

1576
00:51:41,716 --> 00:51:41,887
exempt from the California

1577
00:51:41,887 --> 00:51:43,436
Environmental Quality Act

1578
00:51:43,436 --> 00:51:44,937
sequel pursuant to Seek. What

1579
00:51:44,937 --> 00:51:46,937
guidelines section 15061 b

1580
00:51:48,141 --> 00:51:52,341
three That was a lot will have

1581
00:51:53,780 --> 00:51:54,414
a staff report, please. Good

1582
00:51:54,414 --> 00:51:56,814
evening, Mr Mayor, Council

1583
00:51:57,150 --> 00:51:57,784
members. Money is Mark will be

1584
00:51:57,784 --> 00:52:00,784
presenting this item for you

1585
00:52:00,888 --> 00:52:04,358
today. As you mentioned this is

1586
00:52:04,358 --> 00:52:06,126
lr 22-0182 amending titles five

1587
00:52:06,126 --> 00:52:07,862
and 17 of the Temecula

1588
00:52:07,862 --> 00:52:08,763
Municipal Code a little bit of

1589
00:52:08,763 --> 00:52:10,763
background that Temecula

1590
00:52:10,798 --> 00:52:12,266
municipal code as originally

1591
00:52:12,266 --> 00:52:13,668
adopted in 1990 since its

1592
00:52:13,668 --> 00:52:14,802
adoption that Temecula City

1593
00:52:14,802 --> 00:52:16,370
Council has periodically made

1594
00:52:16,370 --> 00:52:18,305
amendments to various sections

1595
00:52:18,305 --> 00:52:19,440
of the code to improve its

1596
00:52:19,440 --> 00:52:19,940
clarity, correct discrepancies,

1597
00:52:19,940 --> 00:52:21,742
improved processes and

1598
00:52:21,742 --> 00:52:23,277
implement state law. This

1599
00:52:23,277 --> 00:52:25,413
proposed ordinance would amend

1600
00:52:25,413 --> 00:52:27,516
title five business license and

1601
00:52:27,516 --> 00:52:29,384
regulations and title 17 Zoning

1602
00:52:29,384 --> 00:52:30,819
Temecula Municipal Code. Little

1603
00:52:30,819 --> 00:52:31,887
bit of the history of the

1604
00:52:31,887 --> 00:52:33,822
ordinance. This ordinance was

1605
00:52:33,822 --> 00:52:35,900
presented to the Planning

1606
00:52:35,900 --> 00:52:35,724
Commission Municipal Code

1607
00:52:35,724 --> 00:52:37,724
maintenance subcommittee on

1608
00:52:38,626 --> 00:52:40,562
NOVEMBER 2nd of 2022. And. This

1609
00:52:40,562 --> 00:52:42,331
item was presented to the full

1610
00:52:42,331 --> 00:52:44,731
Planning Commission on NOVEMBER

1611
00:52:45,902 --> 00:52:47,690
16th 2022 resolution number

1612
00:52:47,690 --> 00:52:47,636
22-34 was adopted, Recommending

1613
00:52:47,636 --> 00:52:50,360
City Council approved the

1614
00:52:50,606 --> 00:52:51,774
ordinance. Staff presented the

1615
00:52:51,774 --> 00:52:54,174
City Council General Plan

1616
00:52:54,376 --> 00:52:55,778
update ad hoc subcommittee on

1617
00:52:55,778 --> 00:52:58,470
JANUARY, 24th and staff briefed

1618
00:52:58,470 --> 00:52:59,616
the mayor and remaining council

1619
00:52:59,616 --> 00:53:00,250
members individually on

1620
00:53:00,250 --> 00:53:01,851
FEBRUARY, 14th and FEBRUARY

1621
00:53:01,851 --> 00:53:03,851
16th. Everyone

1622
00:53:03,853 --> 00:53:05,288
s seen this. So

1623
00:53:05,288 --> 00:53:05,488
jump right into the changes.

1624
00:53:05,488 --> 00:53:06,756
There

1625
00:53:06,756 --> 00:53:09,359
s a few of them, starting

1626
00:53:09,359 --> 00:53:10,326
with Title five. Specifically

1627
00:53:10,326 --> 00:53:10,994
dealing with massage

1628
00:53:10,994 --> 00:53:12,994
establishments and the

1629
00:53:12,996 --> 00:53:13,830
exemptions to them. This would

1630
00:53:13,830 --> 00:53:15,331
clarify that massage

1631
00:53:15,331 --> 00:53:16,534
establishment that chair

1632
00:53:16,534 --> 00:53:18,468
massage businesses are only

1633
00:53:18,468 --> 00:53:21,468
exempt from the maximum number

1634
00:53:22,551 --> 00:53:22,782
of massage establishments and

1635
00:53:22,782 --> 00:53:23,874
no conversion of chair. Massage

1636
00:53:23,874 --> 00:53:24,541
businesses are permitted a new

1637
00:53:24,541 --> 00:53:26,941
massage business license would

1638
00:53:27,177 --> 00:53:28,412
be required. And for operations

1639
00:53:28,412 --> 00:53:29,847
of this obviously massage

1640
00:53:29,847 --> 00:53:31,348
establishments. It would

1641
00:53:31,348 --> 00:53:33,116
require all massage businesses

1642
00:53:33,116 --> 00:53:34,786
to establish and maintain a

1643
00:53:34,786 --> 00:53:36,120
dedicated telephone physically

1644
00:53:36,120 --> 00:53:37,322
located at the business and is

1645
00:53:37,322 --> 00:53:39,722
capable of dialing out

1646
00:53:41,859 --> 00:53:43,859
specifically to 911. Jumping

1647
00:53:44,295 --> 00:53:45,296
into title 17 are open Space

1648
00:53:45,296 --> 00:53:47,296
Conservation district would

1649
00:53:47,965 --> 00:53:48,632
modify the open space

1650
00:53:48,632 --> 00:53:49,900
conservations only designation

1651
00:53:49,900 --> 00:53:51,837
definition to include passive

1652
00:53:51,837 --> 00:53:53,338
recreational uses and limit

1653
00:53:53,338 --> 00:53:54,373
profit profit generating

1654
00:53:54,373 --> 00:53:55,841
activity to unlimited term for

1655
00:53:55,841 --> 00:53:58,243
the schedule of permitted uses

1656
00:53:58,243 --> 00:53:58,710
for open space and open space

1657
00:53:58,710 --> 00:53:59,678
conservation zoning

1658
00:53:59,678 --> 00:54:00,946
designations. We

1659
00:54:00,946 --> 00:54:02,648
re going to

1660
00:54:02,648 --> 00:54:03,248
include bicycle paths as a

1661
00:54:03,248 --> 00:54:04,283
permitted use, and we

1662
00:54:04,283 --> 00:54:05,884
re going

1663
00:54:05,884 --> 00:54:06,919
to clarify that communication

1664
00:54:06,919 --> 00:54:08,286
and microwave installations are

1665
00:54:08,286 --> 00:54:11,886
not permitted in any open space

1666
00:54:13,259 --> 00:54:13,926
zoning designation. Title 17

1667
00:54:13,926 --> 00:54:14,930
continues for our definitions.

1668
00:54:14,930 --> 00:54:15,995
We

1669
00:54:15,995 --> 00:54:16,863
re going to consolidate

1670
00:54:16,863 --> 00:54:18,297
guesthouse and secondary

1671
00:54:18,297 --> 00:54:19,932
dwelling unit with that of the

1672
00:54:19,932 --> 00:54:21,633
accessory dwelling unit, or 80

1673
00:54:21,633 --> 00:54:24,690
you and expand that definition

1674
00:54:24,690 --> 00:54:24,537
of a d you to include any

1675
00:54:24,537 --> 00:54:25,471
efficiency unit and

1676
00:54:25,471 --> 00:54:26,907
manufactured home in accordance

1677
00:54:26,907 --> 00:54:28,208
with state law. We

1678
00:54:28,208 --> 00:54:29,776
re going to

1679
00:54:29,776 --> 00:54:31,545
add definitions for recreation

1680
00:54:31,545 --> 00:54:31,978
uses active and recreation uses

1681
00:54:31,978 --> 00:54:32,779
passive and we

1682
00:54:32,779 --> 00:54:34,414
re going to

1683
00:54:34,414 --> 00:54:35,882
modify the definition of

1684
00:54:35,882 --> 00:54:37,150
alcoholic beverage manufacturer

1685
00:54:37,150 --> 00:54:38,951
to include the accessory use of

1686
00:54:38,951 --> 00:54:40,153
a single food truck at their

1687
00:54:40,153 --> 00:54:41,154
location, subject to the

1688
00:54:41,154 --> 00:54:42,889
requirements of Riverside

1689
00:54:42,889 --> 00:54:45,289
County Ordinance number 580 and

1690
00:54:46,660 --> 00:54:48,595
the Temecula Municipal Code.

1691
00:54:48,595 --> 00:54:49,296
All right title, 17 continued

1692
00:54:49,296 --> 00:54:49,463
for our approved specific plans.

1693
00:54:49,463 --> 00:54:50,531
We

1694
00:54:50,531 --> 00:54:52,990
re just going to update the

1695
00:54:52,990 --> 00:54:54,680
numbers of the adopted specific

1696
00:54:54,680 --> 00:54:54,602
plans to include uptown

1697
00:54:54,602 --> 00:54:56,537
Temecula and the Altair

1698
00:54:56,537 --> 00:54:58,372
specific plans. And then for

1699
00:54:58,372 --> 00:55:00,541
our schedule of permitted uses

1700
00:55:00,541 --> 00:55:00,774
for pdo is number four in pdo

1701
00:55:00,774 --> 00:55:02,477
10. We

1702
00:55:02,477 --> 00:55:04,877
re going to implement

1703
00:55:06,810 --> 00:55:06,748
the requirement of ordinance

1704
00:55:06,748 --> 00:55:08,283
2022-6 there Live Entertainment

1705
00:55:08,283 --> 00:55:08,950
Ordinance. This was previously

1706
00:55:08,950 --> 00:55:11,350
passwords implementing it for

1707
00:55:14,550 --> 00:55:15,423
these two pos. Title 17

1708
00:55:15,423 --> 00:55:15,790
continued for a residential

1709
00:55:15,790 --> 00:55:16,291
districts. We

1710
00:55:16,291 --> 00:55:18,226
re going to

1711
00:55:18,226 --> 00:55:18,861
remove the guesthouse as an

1712
00:55:18,861 --> 00:55:20,861
approved residential accessory

1713
00:55:21,563 --> 00:55:23,320
Use 80 us will be used in this

1714
00:55:23,320 --> 00:55:24,266
place and for residential

1715
00:55:24,266 --> 00:55:24,867
accessory structures. We were

1716
00:55:24,867 --> 00:55:26,335
removed Guesthouse and the

1717
00:55:26,335 --> 00:55:28,504
associated note from the table

1718
00:55:28,504 --> 00:55:30,205
80 years will be used instead.

1719
00:55:30,205 --> 00:55:32,708
And for the schedule permitted

1720
00:55:32,708 --> 00:55:36,308
uses for pdo number two, We

1721
00:55:36,787 --> 00:55:37,300
removed Guesthouse and

1722
00:55:37,300 --> 00:55:37,200
secondary dwelling unit and add

1723
00:55:37,200 --> 00:55:41,150
a d u is an approved by right

1724
00:55:41,150 --> 00:55:41,551
accessory use. Right. And for a

1725
00:55:41,551 --> 00:55:43,520
t u standards we

1726
00:55:43,520 --> 00:55:43,820
re going to

1727
00:55:43,820 --> 00:55:45,254
require all utility equipment

1728
00:55:45,254 --> 00:55:46,856
such as window heating or

1729
00:55:46,856 --> 00:55:48,791
cooling devices be screened

1730
00:55:48,791 --> 00:55:49,292
from public view, and then it

1731
00:55:49,292 --> 00:55:51,160
would incorporate the

1732
00:55:51,160 --> 00:55:52,662
requirement of a b 3 45, which

1733
00:55:52,662 --> 00:55:55,662
is the separate conveyance of

1734
00:55:55,766 --> 00:55:57,234
the u. S. For. Our. Conditional

1735
00:55:57,234 --> 00:55:58,680
use permits were going to

1736
00:55:58,680 --> 00:55:59,603
require all establishments that

1737
00:55:59,603 --> 00:56:01,772
have a c u p that includes the

1738
00:56:01,772 --> 00:56:03,307
on site consumption of alcohol

1739
00:56:03,307 --> 00:56:04,641
to physically post their c u p

1740
00:56:04,641 --> 00:56:07,410
to include conditions of

1741
00:56:09,879 --> 00:56:10,413
approval on site. Right for a

1742
00:56:10,413 --> 00:56:10,781
supplemental development

1743
00:56:10,781 --> 00:56:11,249
standards. We

1744
00:56:11,249 --> 00:56:12,650
re going to

1745
00:56:12,650 --> 00:56:15,500
clarify that the existing

1746
00:56:15,419 --> 00:56:17,755
separation from a car wash and

1747
00:56:17,755 --> 00:56:18,789
residential property is to the

1748
00:56:18,789 --> 00:56:20,258
residential property line,

1749
00:56:20,258 --> 00:56:21,492
inclusive, inclusive of all

1750
00:56:21,492 --> 00:56:22,126
vacuum equipment. Air

1751
00:56:22,126 --> 00:56:22,960
compressors. Any motors are

1752
00:56:22,960 --> 00:56:25,960
pretty much anything that makes

1753
00:56:25,960 --> 00:56:25,930
noise. And then we

1754
00:56:25,930 --> 00:56:27,310
re going to

1755
00:56:27,310 --> 00:56:28,834
implement parking garage

1756
00:56:28,834 --> 00:56:30,569
standards. These are safety

1757
00:56:30,569 --> 00:56:31,636
standards dealing with lighting,

1758
00:56:31,636 --> 00:56:33,636
visibility, signage, fencing

1759
00:56:36,575 --> 00:56:38,430
and not design guidelines. Okay

1760
00:56:38,430 --> 00:56:38,210
flagpoles. We have two sections.

1761
00:56:38,210 --> 00:56:39,677
We

1762
00:56:39,677 --> 00:56:41,179
re going to be amending for

1763
00:56:41,179 --> 00:56:42,213
our flagpole height limit.

1764
00:56:42,213 --> 00:56:44,649
There was a discrepancy in the

1765
00:56:44,649 --> 00:56:46,619
code. We had one The reference

1766
00:56:46,619 --> 00:56:48,530
to 75 ft flagpole height limit,

1767
00:56:48,530 --> 00:56:48,216
in one reference to 50. We

1768
00:56:48,216 --> 00:56:49,655
re

1769
00:56:49,655 --> 00:56:52,655
correcting that and we went

1770
00:56:54,627 --> 00:56:56,161
with the 50 ft height limit. So

1771
00:56:56,161 --> 00:56:57,196
for our planning and zoning

1772
00:56:57,196 --> 00:56:58,631
approval authority. We

1773
00:56:58,631 --> 00:56:59,899
re gonna

1774
00:56:59,899 --> 00:57:00,699
require all modifications, all

1775
00:57:00,699 --> 00:57:03,990
modification applications to a

1776
00:57:03,269 --> 00:57:04,204
c. You go before a public

1777
00:57:04,204 --> 00:57:06,106
hearing for consideration, then

1778
00:57:06,106 --> 00:57:07,807
for our schedule of permitted

1779
00:57:07,807 --> 00:57:08,375
uses for commercial office and

1780
00:57:08,375 --> 00:57:08,775
industrial uses. We

1781
00:57:08,775 --> 00:57:09,909
re gonna

1782
00:57:09,909 --> 00:57:11,878
correct a reference for adult

1783
00:57:11,878 --> 00:57:12,278
business. This doesn

1784
00:57:12,278 --> 00:57:13,313
t change

1785
00:57:13,313 --> 00:57:13,980
adult businesses at all. We

1786
00:57:13,980 --> 00:57:15,281
re

1787
00:57:15,281 --> 00:57:17,216
simply changing a reference of

1788
00:57:17,216 --> 00:57:17,684
the citizenry can go to the

1789
00:57:17,684 --> 00:57:19,684
right section. That

1790
00:57:21,288 --> 00:57:22,220
s it. So

1791
00:57:22,220 --> 00:57:23,857
our secret determination staff

1792
00:57:23,857 --> 00:57:24,357
has determined that the

1793
00:57:24,357 --> 00:57:26,357
proposed ordinance is

1794
00:57:26,794 --> 00:57:27,594
categorically exemp. From, the

1795
00:57:27,594 --> 00:57:29,162
California Environmental

1796
00:57:29,162 --> 00:57:31,365
Quality Act Sequa to pursuant

1797
00:57:31,365 --> 00:57:32,333
to title 14 Chapter three

1798
00:57:32,333 --> 00:57:34,733
California Code of Regulations

1799
00:57:36,970 --> 00:57:38,438
section 15061 b three Staff

1800
00:57:38,438 --> 00:57:39,340
recommendation is that staff

1801
00:57:39,340 --> 00:57:41,276
recommended the City council

1802
00:57:41,276 --> 00:57:43,244
introduced and read by title

1803
00:57:43,244 --> 00:57:43,404
only the proposed ordinance.

1804
00:57:43,404 --> 00:57:44,879
I

1805
00:57:44,879 --> 00:57:47,879
m available for any questions.

1806
00:57:48,449 --> 00:57:49,684
All, right. Thank you for the

1807
00:57:49,684 --> 00:57:52,840
presentation. Any questions. Um,

1808
00:57:52,153 --> 00:57:53,521
Stuart. Um. So. Have we ever

1809
00:57:53,521 --> 00:57:55,656
had a flagpole higher than 50

1810
00:57:55,656 --> 00:57:58,930
ft in the city of Temecula. We

1811
00:57:58,930 --> 00:57:59,628
do south End of town by the 76

1812
00:57:59,628 --> 00:58:01,763
the jack in the box at the end

1813
00:58:01,763 --> 00:58:03,650
down there that one is well in

1814
00:58:03,650 --> 00:58:04,799
excess. Um. This would not

1815
00:58:04,799 --> 00:58:06,335
require any Flagpole that is

1816
00:58:06,335 --> 00:58:08,370
above that height limit to be

1817
00:58:08,370 --> 00:58:09,905
taken down, modified in any way

1818
00:58:09,905 --> 00:58:10,739
it would be considered legal

1819
00:58:10,739 --> 00:58:11,940
nonconforming and could exist

1820
00:58:11,940 --> 00:58:12,102
in perpetuity as long as it

1821
00:58:12,102 --> 00:58:14,102
s

1822
00:58:15,645 --> 00:58:16,345
maintained. Okay. Any other

1823
00:58:16,345 --> 00:58:17,246
questions? I have a couple of

1824
00:58:17,246 --> 00:58:19,415
questions. Thank you so much by

1825
00:58:19,415 --> 00:58:20,149
the way for the presentation.

1826
00:58:20,149 --> 00:58:21,384
Of course. Okay. So when I

1827
00:58:21,384 --> 00:58:22,318
think mine was kind of the same

1828
00:58:22,318 --> 00:58:23,753
thing with the flagpole because

1829
00:58:23,753 --> 00:58:24,353
I know that over there, I

1830
00:58:24,353 --> 00:58:24,920
believe it

1831
00:58:24,920 --> 00:58:25,120
s a garrison flag.

1832
00:58:25,120 --> 00:58:26,550
That

1833
00:58:26,550 --> 00:58:29,550
s on that flagpole in

1834
00:58:30,590 --> 00:58:32,429
itself. Um I. Guess. Just why

1835
00:58:32,429 --> 00:58:33,730
are we making it lower? Is

1836
00:58:33,730 --> 00:58:34,898
there any specific reasons?

1837
00:58:34,898 --> 00:58:37,330
Because I. Look at it. Just,

1838
00:58:37,330 --> 00:58:37,367
you know once we get lower on

1839
00:58:37,367 --> 00:58:37,934
anything, it

1840
00:58:37,934 --> 00:58:39,690
s hard to bring it

1841
00:58:39,690 --> 00:58:40,437
back up to you know, maybe if

1842
00:58:40,437 --> 00:58:43,206
somebody wants to come in and

1843
00:58:43,206 --> 00:58:44,240
put in 75 ft flag. No, we are.

1844
00:58:44,240 --> 00:58:45,608
There was no reason we went

1845
00:58:45,608 --> 00:58:47,443
with the conservative of the

1846
00:58:47,443 --> 00:58:50,800
two numbers and that was it was

1847
00:58:50,800 --> 00:58:51,110
a discrepancy and we went with

1848
00:58:51,110 --> 00:58:54,351
that. Okay. Is there. I can add

1849
00:58:54,351 --> 00:58:55,819
a little bit too that, um

1850
00:58:55,819 --> 00:58:57,221
Typically everything we do. We

1851
00:58:57,221 --> 00:59:01,421
like to analyze the heck out of

1852
00:59:01,558 --> 00:59:02,693
it and have this very, you know,

1853
00:59:02,693 --> 00:59:04,693
articulated justification, And

1854
00:59:04,895 --> 00:59:05,863
in this case, there was just

1855
00:59:05,863 --> 00:59:08,863
Two separate allowances in the

1856
00:59:09,401 --> 00:59:10,935
code, and we picked 50 ft to be

1857
00:59:10,935 --> 00:59:13,371
reasonable. Um, if the council

1858
00:59:13,371 --> 00:59:15,206
would like to raise that lower,

1859
00:59:15,206 --> 00:59:15,406
it said, no limit. I mean

1860
00:59:15,406 --> 00:59:16,508
that

1861
00:59:16,508 --> 00:59:17,976
s really up to the council.

1862
00:59:17,976 --> 00:59:19,243
We just had a discrepancy in

1863
00:59:19,243 --> 00:59:21,145
the code, and we needed to

1864
00:59:21,145 --> 00:59:23,816
clarify it. So. We chose 50 ft.

1865
00:59:23,816 --> 00:59:24,820
We thought that was reasonable,

1866
00:59:24,820 --> 00:59:24,583
and that

1867
00:59:24,583 --> 00:59:26,852
s really it. Thank you.

1868
00:59:26,852 --> 00:59:28,487
Is that something that we want

1869
00:59:28,487 --> 00:59:29,688
to have a conversation about,

1870
00:59:29,688 --> 00:59:30,689
Maybe just leaving it because

1871
00:59:30,689 --> 00:59:31,923
there was some people that you

1872
00:59:31,923 --> 00:59:33,359
know if it

1873
00:59:33,359 --> 00:59:34,590
s 75, the max We can

1874
00:59:34,590 --> 00:59:34,560
just leave it. I. Don

1875
00:59:34,560 --> 00:59:34,726
t think

1876
00:59:34,726 --> 00:59:35,627
it

1877
00:59:35,627 --> 00:59:37,596
s really hurting anybody And

1878
00:59:37,596 --> 00:59:39,231
what? How awesome to be able to

1879
00:59:39,231 --> 00:59:39,498
see the American flag at 75 ft

1880
00:59:39,498 --> 00:59:41,340
up. That

1881
00:59:41,340 --> 00:59:41,567
s what I say So. I

1882
00:59:41,567 --> 00:59:41,743
know what you

1883
00:59:41,743 --> 00:59:41,910
re you

1884
00:59:41,910 --> 00:59:43,910
re

1885
00:59:44,103 --> 00:59:47,103
gentleman thought is I like 75

1886
00:59:49,776 --> 00:59:51,430
ft. I like no limit. Amen.

1887
00:59:51,430 --> 00:59:53,746
Build a fire. I like if they

1888
00:59:53,746 --> 00:59:53,917
can put 500 ft flagpole. Let

1889
00:59:53,917 --> 00:59:55,748
s

1890
00:59:55,748 --> 00:59:56,649
do it. Okay. Should we should

1891
00:59:56,649 --> 00:59:59,190
we do it, Luke said. We could

1892
00:59:59,190 --> 01:00:03,219
do no limit. I mean, no limited.

1893
01:00:03,223 --> 01:00:06,159
You might have some issues with

1894
01:00:06,159 --> 01:00:06,827
the faa with put that in the

1895
01:00:06,827 --> 01:00:07,600
resolution, I don

1896
01:00:07,600 --> 01:00:08,662
t have a

1897
01:00:08,662 --> 01:00:10,297
problem with it. I mean it.

1898
01:00:10,297 --> 01:00:11,364
Clearly it was just picking a

1899
01:00:11,364 --> 01:00:11,598
number and that

1900
01:00:11,598 --> 01:00:13,598
s fine.

1901
01:00:16,304 --> 01:00:17,338
Absolutely. 75 75. Well. I mean

1902
01:00:17,338 --> 01:00:17,506
no limit is better than and if

1903
01:00:17,506 --> 01:00:19,400
we

1904
01:00:19,400 --> 01:00:21,842
re going to be better than

1905
01:00:21,842 --> 01:00:22,430
we should be better than Well.

1906
01:00:22,430 --> 01:00:24,430
What

1907
01:00:26,514 --> 01:00:27,381
s your thought? 75 or

1908
01:00:27,381 --> 01:00:30,381
Lucas. No limit problematic or

1909
01:00:30,518 --> 01:00:31,118
do we have to have it looks

1910
01:00:31,118 --> 01:00:31,283
like, uh, it

1911
01:00:31,283 --> 01:00:31,919
s it

1912
01:00:31,919 --> 01:00:33,888
s hard to say,

1913
01:00:33,888 --> 01:00:35,890
but, yeah, no limit probably

1914
01:00:35,890 --> 01:00:36,358
would end up causing some

1915
01:00:36,358 --> 01:00:38,758
problems somewhere along the

1916
01:00:40,562 --> 01:00:42,163
line, so I think 75 more than

1917
01:00:42,163 --> 01:00:42,464
reasonable that

1918
01:00:42,464 --> 01:00:43,998
s extremely

1919
01:00:43,998 --> 01:00:46,398
high maintenance over 75 years

1920
01:00:46,901 --> 01:00:47,535
to be. Yeah, you need

1921
01:00:47,535 --> 01:00:47,707
helicopter at a certain point

1922
01:00:47,707 --> 01:00:49,370
you

1923
01:00:49,370 --> 01:00:50,538
re gna have to put lights

1924
01:00:50,538 --> 01:00:52,207
on it. You know Warren aircraft

1925
01:00:52,207 --> 01:00:52,370
and things like that, So. Okay,

1926
01:00:52,370 --> 01:00:54,370
I

1927
01:00:54,810 --> 01:00:55,770
m 75 with me. Okay. We

1928
01:00:55,770 --> 01:00:56,579
re

1929
01:00:56,579 --> 01:00:59,314
good with that, Um, I just got

1930
01:00:59,314 --> 01:01:00,783
a couple of just just from my

1931
01:01:00,783 --> 01:01:02,651
understanding Also. So with the

1932
01:01:02,651 --> 01:01:05,320
massage parlors and we we know

1933
01:01:05,320 --> 01:01:07,423
obviously this has been an

1934
01:01:07,423 --> 01:01:10,260
ongoing thing. Why? Why, do you

1935
01:01:10,260 --> 01:01:11,961
Are? We going to specifically

1936
01:01:11,961 --> 01:01:12,829
Keilar Ordinance to the massage

1937
01:01:12,829 --> 01:01:14,664
parlor for a phone. Is there

1938
01:01:14,664 --> 01:01:15,665
anybody else who has to have

1939
01:01:15,665 --> 01:01:17,133
that same thing or like having

1940
01:01:17,133 --> 01:01:17,967
a phone in there? Or what does

1941
01:01:17,967 --> 01:01:19,302
that look like? It was

1942
01:01:19,302 --> 01:01:20,203
primarily because of the

1943
01:01:20,203 --> 01:01:21,638
enforcement actions going on

1944
01:01:21,638 --> 01:01:23,720
throughout the city. There was

1945
01:01:23,720 --> 01:01:24,641
times when the police code

1946
01:01:24,641 --> 01:01:26,677
enforcement building and safety

1947
01:01:26,677 --> 01:01:28,178
fire would show up during

1948
01:01:28,178 --> 01:01:28,979
normal hours of operation and

1949
01:01:28,979 --> 01:01:30,814
the business would appear

1950
01:01:30,814 --> 01:01:32,182
closed and there was no way to

1951
01:01:32,182 --> 01:01:33,417
physically reach them inside.

1952
01:01:33,417 --> 01:01:34,551
Their contact number would

1953
01:01:34,551 --> 01:01:36,386
bring to a cell phone or

1954
01:01:36,386 --> 01:01:37,200
business line, not at the

1955
01:01:37,200 --> 01:01:38,655
location and they could just

1956
01:01:38,655 --> 01:01:40,624
they were not home. So. This

1957
01:01:40,624 --> 01:01:41,525
way. We can have that the phone

1958
01:01:41,525 --> 01:01:41,725
inside ringing and we know that

1959
01:01:41,725 --> 01:01:42,659
they

1960
01:01:42,659 --> 01:01:43,930
re going to physically be

1961
01:01:43,930 --> 01:01:44,195
there. There

1962
01:01:44,195 --> 01:01:46,595
s also a safety

1963
01:01:47,265 --> 01:01:47,932
issue for any business involves

1964
01:01:47,932 --> 01:01:49,434
physical contact between people

1965
01:01:49,434 --> 01:01:51,836
do we ever do we have that with

1966
01:01:51,836 --> 01:01:52,737
other other other, Um

1967
01:01:52,737 --> 01:01:55,137
Organizations or businesses as

1968
01:01:55,440 --> 01:01:57,208
well to be able to have that in

1969
01:01:57,208 --> 01:01:59,110
there as well to proposing it

1970
01:01:59,110 --> 01:02:01,413
for for these massage

1971
01:02:01,413 --> 01:02:02,648
establishments. There was an

1972
01:02:02,648 --> 01:02:03,415
actual, very specific incident,

1973
01:02:03,415 --> 01:02:05,183
where a gentleman went to

1974
01:02:05,183 --> 01:02:07,619
cardiac arrest and no one in

1975
01:02:07,619 --> 01:02:10,856
the facility had a phone. So.

1976
01:02:10,856 --> 01:02:12,457
We have a very specific reason

1977
01:02:12,457 --> 01:02:13,691
for for requiring it in this

1978
01:02:13,691 --> 01:02:13,860
circumstance so we hadn

1979
01:02:13,860 --> 01:02:15,327
t

1980
01:02:15,327 --> 01:02:17,629
analyzed any other business

1981
01:02:17,629 --> 01:02:18,296
type. Just massage

1982
01:02:18,296 --> 01:02:19,599
establishments. Okay, alright

1983
01:02:19,599 --> 01:02:19,966
and my last one, and I

1984
01:02:19,966 --> 01:02:21,167
m done

1985
01:02:21,167 --> 01:02:22,969
just it was brought up about

1986
01:02:22,969 --> 01:02:25,771
the a. D. U. S, if you can do

1987
01:02:25,771 --> 01:02:26,872
me a favor and just kind of

1988
01:02:26,872 --> 01:02:30,472
discuss what that is in detail.

1989
01:02:30,543 --> 01:02:32,878
Ah! How did the state in itself.

1990
01:02:32,878 --> 01:02:34,460
Do they have any control over

1991
01:02:34,460 --> 01:02:34,547
that? Um why are we doing Why

1992
01:02:34,547 --> 01:02:36,683
are we doing what we

1993
01:02:36,683 --> 01:02:37,784
re doing?

1994
01:02:37,784 --> 01:02:40,754
Well, yes. So going back to

1995
01:02:40,754 --> 01:02:44,624
just a few years ago, Eight eu

1996
01:02:44,624 --> 01:02:45,759
laws started to be issued by

1997
01:02:45,759 --> 01:02:47,759
the state Legislature.

1998
01:02:48,161 --> 01:02:50,561
Essentially. Those laws Make 80

1999
01:02:50,663 --> 01:02:52,265
us by right use within the city

2000
01:02:52,265 --> 01:02:55,636
of Temecula. So anyone who has

2001
01:02:55,636 --> 01:02:56,470
a home can do an 80 You state

2002
01:02:56,470 --> 01:02:56,637
dictated that and that

2003
01:02:56,637 --> 01:02:56,800
s that

2004
01:02:56,800 --> 01:02:58,472
s

2005
01:02:58,472 --> 01:02:58,639
the law of the land. So what

2006
01:02:58,639 --> 01:03:00,574
we

2007
01:03:00,574 --> 01:03:04,111
re doing here tonight is is

2008
01:03:04,111 --> 01:03:05,579
not in any way. Um, uh,

2009
01:03:05,579 --> 01:03:07,130
changing or attempting to

2010
01:03:07,130 --> 01:03:10,130
circumvent or anything to do

2011
01:03:10,384 --> 01:03:13,221
with the primary laws that make

2012
01:03:13,221 --> 01:03:13,388
a tus permitted uses. What

2013
01:03:13,388 --> 01:03:15,388
we

2014
01:03:15,523 --> 01:03:17,491
re doing is clarifying in

2015
01:03:17,491 --> 01:03:21,691
the code. Um, so over time that

2016
01:03:22,130 --> 01:03:24,131
the code has Ah had definitions

2017
01:03:24,131 --> 01:03:25,600
for guesthouse and accessory

2018
01:03:25,600 --> 01:03:28,000
dwelling unit and efficiency

2019
01:03:28,135 --> 01:03:31,106
unit and Granny flat and second

2020
01:03:31,106 --> 01:03:33,208
home and all these different

2021
01:03:33,208 --> 01:03:35,377
definitions for what is

2022
01:03:35,377 --> 01:03:35,611
essentially the same thing. So

2023
01:03:35,611 --> 01:03:37,611
what we

2024
01:03:37,746 --> 01:03:38,280
re proposing is to take

2025
01:03:38,280 --> 01:03:39,148
all those individual

2026
01:03:39,148 --> 01:03:41,883
definitions and just call them

2027
01:03:41,883 --> 01:03:43,518
80 us. Part of that is required

2028
01:03:43,518 --> 01:03:45,200
by the state. But we took it a

2029
01:03:45,200 --> 01:03:46,255
little further to capture all

2030
01:03:46,255 --> 01:03:47,590
of the other definitions that

2031
01:03:47,590 --> 01:03:49,759
we want, You know all the other

2032
01:03:49,759 --> 01:03:51,594
designations that we want to

2033
01:03:51,594 --> 01:03:53,329
create a consistent definition

2034
01:03:53,329 --> 01:03:55,198
for, um and and that does a

2035
01:03:55,198 --> 01:03:56,866
couple of things it also it

2036
01:03:56,866 --> 01:03:58,434
makes it the code easier to use

2037
01:03:58,434 --> 01:03:58,668
for the public. They can

2038
01:03:58,668 --> 01:03:59,902
t get

2039
01:03:59,902 --> 01:04:01,136
what am I doing a granny flat,

2040
01:04:01,136 --> 01:04:02,305
or am I doing a guest house or

2041
01:04:02,305 --> 01:04:03,740
my doing an 80 you It

2042
01:04:03,740 --> 01:04:05,142
s all the

2043
01:04:05,142 --> 01:04:06,610
same thing effectively is all

2044
01:04:06,610 --> 01:04:09,146
the same thing, so it makes it

2045
01:04:09,146 --> 01:04:11,281
easier. It makes it easier for

2046
01:04:11,281 --> 01:04:13,830
staff to administer, and it

2047
01:04:13,830 --> 01:04:15,719
also allows staff and the city

2048
01:04:15,719 --> 01:04:17,287
to get credit under our arena

2049
01:04:17,287 --> 01:04:18,155
numbers at the state when an 80

2050
01:04:18,155 --> 01:04:19,389
you is created because we have

2051
01:04:19,389 --> 01:04:21,826
as you all know Rena numbers

2052
01:04:21,826 --> 01:04:25,426
and we need to make progress

2053
01:04:25,907 --> 01:04:26,131
towards the satisfaction of

2054
01:04:26,131 --> 01:04:26,287
those. And. We need

2055
01:04:26,287 --> 01:04:27,732
them to be actually defined as

2056
01:04:27,732 --> 01:04:30,367
an 80 you in the code for us to

2057
01:04:30,367 --> 01:04:31,935
be able to tell the state and a

2058
01:04:31,935 --> 01:04:32,970
d u was created here and we get

2059
01:04:32,970 --> 01:04:33,270
credit for it. It

2060
01:04:33,270 --> 01:04:33,671
s called the

2061
01:04:33,671 --> 01:04:34,400
Guesthouse If it

2062
01:04:34,400 --> 01:04:36,400
s called this

2063
01:04:36,139 --> 01:04:37,341
that or the other thing, Um, we

2064
01:04:37,341 --> 01:04:38,643
will be much harder for us to

2065
01:04:38,643 --> 01:04:38,804
get credit for it. So. That

2066
01:04:38,804 --> 01:04:39,878
s

2067
01:04:39,878 --> 01:04:41,112
another reason we wanted to

2068
01:04:41,112 --> 01:04:44,149
just make everything that is an

2069
01:04:44,149 --> 01:04:47,218
80 you Defined as an a d u Okay?

2070
01:04:47,218 --> 01:04:49,287
All right? I do have one

2071
01:04:49,287 --> 01:04:50,488
question on the I d. You are

2072
01:04:50,488 --> 01:04:51,222
manufactured homes currently

2073
01:04:51,222 --> 01:04:54,222
allowed in single family zoning.

2074
01:04:54,726 --> 01:04:57,529
They are and as an a d you they

2075
01:04:57,529 --> 01:04:58,230
would be as well. Is there a

2076
01:04:58,230 --> 01:05:00,630
minimum square foot requirement.

2077
01:05:00,933 --> 01:05:01,567
It is the minimum of an

2078
01:05:01,567 --> 01:05:03,469
efficiency unit. I believe it

2079
01:05:03,469 --> 01:05:04,303
s

2080
01:05:04,303 --> 01:05:04,936
125 square feet, but I could

2081
01:05:04,936 --> 01:05:08,536
get back with you the exact

2082
01:05:08,641 --> 01:05:10,576
answer. And just pertaining to

2083
01:05:10,576 --> 01:05:11,243
this specific ordinance if

2084
01:05:11,243 --> 01:05:13,546
approved a manufactured home

2085
01:05:13,546 --> 01:05:14,280
and be approved as an ado,

2086
01:05:14,280 --> 01:05:16,115
Currently it is separate than a

2087
01:05:16,115 --> 01:05:17,517
do you you have to get a permit

2088
01:05:17,517 --> 01:05:18,818
for manufactured home on a

2089
01:05:18,818 --> 01:05:21,120
single families own property

2090
01:05:21,120 --> 01:05:23,489
rather now, just being a d u

2091
01:05:23,489 --> 01:05:24,457
under one umbrella right now,

2092
01:05:24,457 --> 01:05:25,910
state law allows the

2093
01:05:25,910 --> 01:05:25,791
manufactured home. We

2094
01:05:25,791 --> 01:05:26,993
re just

2095
01:05:26,993 --> 01:05:28,628
updating our code to reflect

2096
01:05:28,628 --> 01:05:29,495
that so they could come in

2097
01:05:29,495 --> 01:05:30,163
right now, with a manufactured

2098
01:05:30,163 --> 01:05:33,763
home as an 80 you under state

2099
01:05:34,535 --> 01:05:36,170
law. Thank you. Okay. Any more

2100
01:05:36,170 --> 01:05:37,571
questions? Alright. Seeing,

2101
01:05:37,571 --> 01:05:37,771
then this is a public hearing,

2102
01:05:37,771 --> 01:05:39,720
so we

2103
01:05:39,720 --> 01:05:40,440
re gonna open the public

2104
01:05:40,440 --> 01:05:42,676
hearing for comments. MADAM

2105
01:05:42,676 --> 01:05:43,443
City clerk. Do. We have any

2106
01:05:43,443 --> 01:05:46,443
public speakers? Yes, we have

2107
01:05:46,546 --> 01:05:48,140
one in person comment and then

2108
01:05:48,140 --> 01:05:50,485
one emailed. Comment in person.

2109
01:05:50,485 --> 01:05:54,850
Comment is from Bob Cal. Okay.

2110
01:06:00,528 --> 01:06:02,430
Welcome. Hello. Um. I came here

2111
01:06:02,430 --> 01:06:03,998
with the idea that this was on

2112
01:06:03,998 --> 01:06:06,301
the bus bill that had all this

2113
01:06:06,301 --> 01:06:09,237
new stuff in it, And I came to

2114
01:06:09,237 --> 01:06:12,237
understand that it is actually

2115
01:06:14,700 --> 01:06:14,910
changing certain items in in

2116
01:06:14,910 --> 01:06:16,110
the bill or the the law. The

2117
01:06:16,110 --> 01:06:18,346
Ordinance, and I just looked at

2118
01:06:18,346 --> 01:06:18,546
how many items around here and

2119
01:06:18,546 --> 01:06:20,546
there

2120
01:06:21,549 --> 01:06:21,750
s uh well, let me see.

2121
01:06:21,750 --> 01:06:23,319
There

2122
01:06:23,319 --> 01:06:27,519
s a lot and it goes from

2123
01:06:28,624 --> 01:06:29,425
the one 19 items. From

2124
01:06:29,425 --> 01:06:31,425
everything from flagpole

2125
01:06:32,828 --> 01:06:34,530
Heights, too. To 80 years for

2126
01:06:34,530 --> 01:06:37,566
the uses the thing that caught

2127
01:06:37,566 --> 01:06:41,766
my eye caught The Eye of Rick

2128
01:06:43,306 --> 01:06:43,544
Review wrote something on this.

2129
01:06:43,544 --> 01:06:44,274
It

2130
01:06:44,274 --> 01:06:45,508
s uh, it was it

2131
01:06:45,508 --> 01:06:47,508
s time to

2132
01:06:48,110 --> 01:06:49,446
really stand up as every city

2133
01:06:49,446 --> 01:06:51,810
in California should do against

2134
01:06:51,810 --> 01:06:52,150
the state mandate. If you don

2135
01:06:52,150 --> 01:06:52,682
t

2136
01:06:52,682 --> 01:06:54,918
stand up now. What mandate,

2137
01:06:54,918 --> 01:06:59,118
will they Put down on this next

2138
01:06:59,189 --> 01:07:02,126
Um This. This changes the law

2139
01:07:02,126 --> 01:07:05,529
in here to to governance code

2140
01:07:05,529 --> 01:07:08,529
section 65 852. Point to as the

2141
01:07:10,934 --> 01:07:11,935
same as Mhm. To me amended from

2142
01:07:11,935 --> 01:07:12,369
time to time, so it doesn

2143
01:07:12,369 --> 01:07:14,369
t

2144
01:07:14,538 --> 01:07:14,872
actually give you any power at

2145
01:07:14,872 --> 01:07:15,673
all. You

2146
01:07:15,673 --> 01:07:16,474
re just rubber

2147
01:07:16,474 --> 01:07:17,909
stamping something that state

2148
01:07:17,909 --> 01:07:19,430
is telling you to do. So why

2149
01:07:19,430 --> 01:07:21,412
are you even voting on it? Why

2150
01:07:21,412 --> 01:07:22,460
are you here? If. You

2151
01:07:22,460 --> 01:07:22,213
re if

2152
01:07:22,213 --> 01:07:22,847
you

2153
01:07:22,847 --> 01:07:24,148
re not if you

2154
01:07:24,148 --> 01:07:26,148
re if you

2155
01:07:28,252 --> 01:07:29,420
have to vote on on this 80 you

2156
01:07:29,420 --> 01:07:29,588
then Because. You

2157
01:07:29,588 --> 01:07:29,753
re you

2158
01:07:29,753 --> 01:07:30,288
re

2159
01:07:30,288 --> 01:07:31,890
gonna MISS Funding or you

2160
01:07:31,890 --> 01:07:33,890
re or

2161
01:07:35,173 --> 01:07:35,413
you

2162
01:07:35,413 --> 01:07:35,581
re going to have the state

2163
01:07:35,581 --> 01:07:35,747
Come in as I

2164
01:07:35,747 --> 01:07:36,227
ve been told. Well,

2165
01:07:36,227 --> 01:07:40,665
why not? Two of you Just say no.

2166
01:07:40,665 --> 01:07:42,867
To this particular piece of it.

2167
01:07:42,867 --> 01:07:43,368
And. The three. Pass it and it

2168
01:07:43,368 --> 01:07:44,870
still passes. I don

2169
01:07:44,870 --> 01:07:46,870
t want it

2170
01:07:48,273 --> 01:07:49,775
to pass, but I think you have

2171
01:07:49,775 --> 01:07:49,975
more power than you think.

2172
01:07:49,975 --> 01:07:51,975
There

2173
01:07:52,110 --> 01:07:53,680
s other studies in this

2174
01:07:53,680 --> 01:07:54,247
state that would do that are

2175
01:07:54,247 --> 01:07:56,647
standing up against these

2176
01:07:57,550 --> 01:07:59,552
mandates. These dictates the

2177
01:07:59,552 --> 01:08:02,552
what will they dictate Netflix?

2178
01:08:05,570 --> 01:08:06,592
I just want to know. Um You

2179
01:08:06,592 --> 01:08:06,892
Know Section three on Page

2180
01:08:06,892 --> 01:08:07,259
three. It

2181
01:08:07,259 --> 01:08:08,962
s. It

2182
01:08:08,962 --> 01:08:09,329
s already in

2183
01:08:09,329 --> 01:08:09,490
there, and it

2184
01:08:09,490 --> 01:08:11,490
s It

2185
01:08:11,565 --> 01:08:13,565
s every

2186
01:08:14,667 --> 01:08:15,936
Conservationists in this In

2187
01:08:15,936 --> 01:08:16,960
this room, including myself.

2188
01:08:16,960 --> 01:08:16,636
I

2189
01:08:16,636 --> 01:08:19,360
m a conservationist, believe

2190
01:08:20,574 --> 01:08:21,708
. Um environmental

2191
01:08:21,708 --> 01:08:24,108
findings The City Council

2192
01:08:24,802 --> 01:08:25,980
hereby finds that this

2193
01:08:25,980 --> 01:08:28,215
ordinance is exempt. From the

2194
01:08:28,215 --> 01:08:28,949
requirements of the California

2195
01:08:28,949 --> 01:08:30,818
Environmental Quality Act

2196
01:08:30,818 --> 01:08:33,487
pursuant to title 14 of the

2197
01:08:33,487 --> 01:08:35,589
California Code of Regulations.

2198
01:08:35,589 --> 01:08:37,191
It actually supersedes itself.

2199
01:08:37,191 --> 01:08:38,359
How can it Law one law

2200
01:08:38,359 --> 01:08:39,260
supersedes another without a

2201
01:08:39,260 --> 01:08:39,827
court case going on. There

2202
01:08:39,827 --> 01:08:41,495
s

2203
01:08:41,495 --> 01:08:41,862
got to be some fight back here

2204
01:08:41,862 --> 01:08:42,463
if you don

2205
01:08:42,463 --> 01:08:42,730
t fight back,

2206
01:08:42,730 --> 01:08:43,698
somebody

2207
01:08:43,698 --> 01:08:44,999
s got to fight back to

2208
01:08:44,999 --> 01:08:47,702
other cities that are staying

2209
01:08:47,702 --> 01:08:49,670
up against this. This law. Um I

2210
01:08:49,670 --> 01:08:51,139
hope that you stand up against

2211
01:08:51,139 --> 01:08:52,207
the two or at least you put a.

2212
01:08:52,207 --> 01:08:52,373
Few of you Stand up and say, I

2213
01:08:52,373 --> 01:08:54,309
don

2214
01:08:54,309 --> 01:08:55,109
t want to support this

2215
01:08:55,109 --> 01:08:55,410
particular thing. I understand

2216
01:08:55,410 --> 01:08:56,211
that there

2217
01:08:56,211 --> 01:08:57,378
s a lot of other

2218
01:08:57,378 --> 01:08:58,613
things in this ordinance that

2219
01:08:58,613 --> 01:08:58,880
are good. I don

2220
01:08:58,880 --> 01:09:00,880
t think it

2221
01:09:01,830 --> 01:09:01,684
should have been put in all in

2222
01:09:01,684 --> 01:09:04,840
one ordinance should have

2223
01:09:04,920 --> 01:09:08,520
broken out. Just my opinion. Go

2224
01:09:08,590 --> 01:09:10,793
back to the charter City idea.

2225
01:09:10,793 --> 01:09:12,561
You have in that ability to

2226
01:09:12,561 --> 01:09:14,961
stand up against municipal

2227
01:09:14,997 --> 01:09:17,934
codes at the state level if you

2228
01:09:17,934 --> 01:09:18,768
created a charter city You have

2229
01:09:18,768 --> 01:09:21,771
as much power or more power

2230
01:09:21,771 --> 01:09:24,907
than the state does. That power

2231
01:09:24,907 --> 01:09:27,907
came from a law at 18 59.

2232
01:09:28,878 --> 01:09:29,779
Excuse me 18 79 20 years of

2233
01:09:29,779 --> 01:09:30,146
state controlled the cities

2234
01:09:30,146 --> 01:09:30,513
until the city

2235
01:09:30,513 --> 01:09:32,913
s took the state

2236
01:09:34,784 --> 01:09:38,210
back. So. I just recommend that

2237
01:09:38,210 --> 01:09:39,656
You When. You look at this boat

2238
01:09:39,656 --> 01:09:41,425
knowing that particular item.

2239
01:09:41,425 --> 01:09:42,792
You can feel the rest just on

2240
01:09:42,792 --> 01:09:46,229
the rest. Oh, and by the way,

2241
01:09:46,229 --> 01:09:46,429
when you have a flagpole,

2242
01:09:46,429 --> 01:09:47,497
there

2243
01:09:47,497 --> 01:09:50,133
s plenty of flight both

2244
01:09:50,133 --> 01:09:53,733
bigger than 50 ft where I live.

2245
01:09:54,572 --> 01:09:54,872
But In the law. I noticed that

2246
01:09:54,872 --> 01:09:55,540
already it

2247
01:09:55,540 --> 01:09:57,308
s codified as single

2248
01:09:57,308 --> 01:09:58,743
flag of the United States of

2249
01:09:58,743 --> 01:10:00,811
America because you can fly a

2250
01:10:00,811 --> 01:10:04,810
flag. Okay. You can fly a, uh,

2251
01:10:04,810 --> 01:10:05,490
American flag. And two of the

2252
01:10:05,490 --> 01:10:07,251
following flags shall be

2253
01:10:07,251 --> 01:10:08,185
allowed per parcel or center.

2254
01:10:08,185 --> 01:10:08,552
Okay. So we

2255
01:10:08,552 --> 01:10:10,552
re talking about,

2256
01:10:12,924 --> 01:10:14,292
you know, um City property or

2257
01:10:14,292 --> 01:10:14,792
public property or private

2258
01:10:14,792 --> 01:10:15,126
property. I don

2259
01:10:15,126 --> 01:10:17,526
t know is it

2260
01:10:17,562 --> 01:10:19,364
say? I don

2261
01:10:19,364 --> 01:10:20,650
t know if it means

2262
01:10:20,650 --> 01:10:23,650
the public property or private

2263
01:10:24,602 --> 01:10:25,570
property. Anyway, um, so the

2264
01:10:25,570 --> 01:10:26,471
state of California or any

2265
01:10:26,471 --> 01:10:29,308
other state of the United

2266
01:10:29,308 --> 01:10:31,143
States. So If I want to fly a

2267
01:10:31,143 --> 01:10:34,143
Mississippi flag? I can fight

2268
01:10:34,513 --> 01:10:36,913
flam Mississippi flag. The

2269
01:10:37,483 --> 01:10:37,916
Hawaiian flag, a Alaskan flood.

2270
01:10:37,916 --> 01:10:39,418
Um, maybe somebody

2271
01:10:39,418 --> 01:10:41,253
s here from

2272
01:10:41,253 --> 01:10:42,554
out of town. You, get another

2273
01:10:42,554 --> 01:10:45,554
country to it. Red China.

2274
01:10:46,592 --> 01:10:47,327
Etcetera. A minister Haliti or

2275
01:10:47,327 --> 01:10:49,727
official flag of other

2276
01:10:53,333 --> 01:10:53,933
countries. Flags of national An

2277
01:10:53,933 --> 01:10:54,801
internationally recognized

2278
01:10:54,801 --> 01:10:55,568
organizations and corporate

2279
01:10:55,568 --> 01:10:55,869
flex. Something

2280
01:10:55,869 --> 01:10:57,869
s wrong with

2281
01:10:57,904 --> 01:11:01,504
that law. Thank you. Thank you

2282
01:11:02,475 --> 01:11:04,678
Next speaker. And. That was the

2283
01:11:04,678 --> 01:11:06,847
only income it speaker and then

2284
01:11:06,847 --> 01:11:09,450
we have one. Email comment from

2285
01:11:09,450 --> 01:11:11,850
Jessica Christopher. I believe

2286
01:11:11,919 --> 01:11:12,786
it is as to item number 12. I

2287
01:11:12,786 --> 01:11:14,655
believe it is unconstitutional

2288
01:11:14,655 --> 01:11:15,889
for the state to tell local

2289
01:11:15,889 --> 01:11:17,224
government what zoning we

2290
01:11:17,224 --> 01:11:18,759
should have. I understand the

2291
01:11:18,759 --> 01:11:21,159
difficulty that opposing sb

2292
01:11:21,262 --> 01:11:22,296
nine and sb 10 posed to our

2293
01:11:22,296 --> 01:11:23,531
coffers. I think the work

2294
01:11:23,531 --> 01:11:25,366
around that is presented is

2295
01:11:25,366 --> 01:11:26,834
likely the best that can be

2296
01:11:26,834 --> 01:11:28,302
done, But I don

2297
01:11:28,302 --> 01:11:30,302
t like section

2298
01:11:31,906 --> 01:11:33,341
15 17.23 point 050 e two The

2299
01:11:33,341 --> 01:11:34,208
parking limitations, maybe an

2300
01:11:34,208 --> 01:11:36,100
excellent way to minimize the

2301
01:11:36,100 --> 01:11:37,345
impact of these two horrible

2302
01:11:37,345 --> 01:11:38,747
bills. In the long run, I

2303
01:11:38,747 --> 01:11:40,449
believe it would benefit the

2304
01:11:40,449 --> 01:11:41,483
city to fight these bills. Sb

2305
01:11:41,483 --> 01:11:45,830
nine, being the worst of the

2306
01:11:45,787 --> 01:11:47,255
two And section 19 see flags

2307
01:11:47,255 --> 01:11:48,823
number two, a single flag of

2308
01:11:48,823 --> 01:11:50,392
the United States of America

2309
01:11:50,392 --> 01:11:52,494
and two of the following flags

2310
01:11:52,494 --> 01:11:54,796
shall be permitted per parcel

2311
01:11:54,796 --> 01:11:56,465
or center sections. A b c d.

2312
01:11:56,465 --> 01:11:58,670
Even though this is I believe

2313
01:11:58,670 --> 01:12:00,603
geared to business. I think it

2314
01:12:00,603 --> 01:12:01,504
is unacceptable and an attack

2315
01:12:01,504 --> 01:12:03,572
on freedom of speech. A company

2316
01:12:03,572 --> 01:12:04,873
should be encouraged to fly the

2317
01:12:04,873 --> 01:12:06,675
United States flag and it

2318
01:12:06,675 --> 01:12:08,477
should be above others but to

2319
01:12:08,477 --> 01:12:11,180
say what other flags and how

2320
01:12:11,180 --> 01:12:12,816
many are unacceptable. Item

2321
01:12:12,816 --> 01:12:13,716
number 14 concerning a ballot

2322
01:12:13,716 --> 01:12:16,116
measure to establish city

2323
01:12:16,119 --> 01:12:17,654
Council term limits. I want to

2324
01:12:17,654 --> 01:12:18,688
commend City Council members

2325
01:12:18,688 --> 01:12:19,489
Alexander Cafes and Stewart for

2326
01:12:19,489 --> 01:12:20,223
hearing the city

2327
01:12:20,223 --> 01:12:21,391
s people and

2328
01:12:21,391 --> 01:12:22,492
voting for this. I would only

2329
01:12:22,492 --> 01:12:24,227
say that if someone is

2330
01:12:24,227 --> 01:12:25,762
appointed to an open City

2331
01:12:25,762 --> 01:12:27,300
council seat that it be

2332
01:12:27,300 --> 01:12:28,298
clarified and minimize so that

2333
01:12:28,298 --> 01:12:30,234
they serve the least amount of

2334
01:12:30,234 --> 01:12:30,901
time possible. Mr mayor. That

2335
01:12:30,901 --> 01:12:32,436
s

2336
01:12:32,436 --> 01:12:34,739
all the comments that we have

2337
01:12:34,739 --> 01:12:36,140
on this item. Okay. Fantastic.

2338
01:12:36,140 --> 01:12:39,760
Um, Mr City Attorney Do. You

2339
01:12:39,760 --> 01:12:40,578
need to read the ordinance.

2340
01:12:40,578 --> 01:12:42,312
Actually, I do not starting on

2341
01:12:42,312 --> 01:12:43,580
JANUARY 1st of this year, the

2342
01:12:43,580 --> 01:12:44,281
state Legislature passed a law

2343
01:12:44,281 --> 01:12:45,649
saying we don

2344
01:12:45,649 --> 01:12:48,490
t have to read

2345
01:12:48,720 --> 01:12:50,188
the titles so long as the city

2346
01:12:50,188 --> 01:12:51,220
has the ordinance on its

2347
01:12:51,220 --> 01:12:53,324
website and online so everybody

2348
01:12:53,324 --> 01:12:55,260
can read it so Fantastic big

2349
01:12:55,260 --> 01:12:57,195
change from But we

2350
01:12:57,195 --> 01:12:58,596
ve had to do

2351
01:12:58,596 --> 01:12:59,230
in the past. Okay. I appreciate

2352
01:12:59,230 --> 01:12:59,631
that. Alright. I

2353
01:12:59,631 --> 01:13:00,498
ll entertain a

2354
01:13:00,498 --> 01:13:03,498
motion to approve item number

2355
01:13:04,502 --> 01:13:07,239
12. So moved second motion a

2356
01:13:07,239 --> 01:13:08,173
second. Let us vote City clerk.

2357
01:13:08,173 --> 01:13:09,700
Quick question for you if there

2358
01:13:09,700 --> 01:13:11,109
is something from this item

2359
01:13:11,109 --> 01:13:12,778
that I want to sustain from or

2360
01:13:12,778 --> 01:13:15,914
just give a reason for doing

2361
01:13:15,914 --> 01:13:20,114
that is now the time. Okay. Can

2362
01:13:20,152 --> 01:13:20,619
I do that? Mayor. Absolutely Go

2363
01:13:20,619 --> 01:13:21,219
ahead. So. Um I

2364
01:13:21,219 --> 01:13:21,586
ll tell you I

2365
01:13:21,586 --> 01:13:23,423
m

2366
01:13:23,423 --> 01:13:24,891
going to be totally honest

2367
01:13:24,891 --> 01:13:26,559
these things as I looked at him

2368
01:13:26,559 --> 01:13:29,428
over the last week are a couple

2369
01:13:29,428 --> 01:13:30,563
of days. Um, I was able to dig

2370
01:13:30,563 --> 01:13:31,964
in today. Having some

2371
01:13:31,964 --> 01:13:34,133
individuals come from the our

2372
01:13:34,133 --> 01:13:36,602
city and the area. Rick Reese

2373
01:13:36,602 --> 01:13:37,503
brought some stuff up. Um.

2374
01:13:37,503 --> 01:13:39,472
Everybody should know where I

2375
01:13:39,472 --> 01:13:41,742
stand as far as state control.

2376
01:13:41,742 --> 01:13:42,142
I have never wanted the state

2377
01:13:42,142 --> 01:13:43,810
s

2378
01:13:43,810 --> 01:13:45,812
control here. We actually had a

2379
01:13:45,812 --> 01:13:46,346
meeting today as far as having

2380
01:13:46,346 --> 01:13:46,947
the state

2381
01:13:46,947 --> 01:13:47,881
s control come into

2382
01:13:47,881 --> 01:13:48,648
our city, and I

2383
01:13:48,648 --> 01:13:49,316
m quite sick of

2384
01:13:49,316 --> 01:13:49,983
it, and I

2385
01:13:49,983 --> 01:13:51,384
m going to I have

2386
01:13:51,384 --> 01:13:53,253
been standing and I will stand

2387
01:13:53,253 --> 01:13:54,721
as a city Council member. No

2388
01:13:54,721 --> 01:13:55,822
matter What that this is our

2389
01:13:55,822 --> 01:13:56,448
city, and we know what

2390
01:13:56,448 --> 01:13:57,257
s best

2391
01:13:57,257 --> 01:14:00,728
for our city and for our

2392
01:14:00,728 --> 01:14:02,830
housing. Coming from what the

2393
01:14:02,830 --> 01:14:03,764
count of the The comments came

2394
01:14:03,764 --> 01:14:03,965
today. I understand what

2395
01:14:03,965 --> 01:14:05,299
they

2396
01:14:05,299 --> 01:14:08,299
re saying, because if we

2397
01:14:08,436 --> 01:14:10,337
continue to Oh, allow this

2398
01:14:10,337 --> 01:14:12,406
stuff and the language to come

2399
01:14:12,406 --> 01:14:14,975
into our city. We are We are

2400
01:14:14,975 --> 01:14:15,343
basically giving a thumbs up.

2401
01:14:15,343 --> 01:14:16,778
My staff doesn

2402
01:14:16,778 --> 01:14:18,346
t excellent job.

2403
01:14:18,346 --> 01:14:19,648
Um And. So I want to thank you

2404
01:14:19,648 --> 01:14:20,348
guys for all you

2405
01:14:20,348 --> 01:14:22,170
re doing, but

2406
01:14:22,170 --> 01:14:23,518
I will be sustaining or I will

2407
01:14:23,518 --> 01:14:25,587
sustain from nine just because

2408
01:14:25,587 --> 01:14:26,421
I feel as a council member. I

2409
01:14:26,421 --> 01:14:28,523
would need more information in

2410
01:14:28,523 --> 01:14:29,624
order to be able to move

2411
01:14:29,624 --> 01:14:32,427
forward to give that a good

2412
01:14:32,427 --> 01:14:33,129
thumbs up or thumbs down. But

2413
01:14:33,129 --> 01:14:33,662
for everything else. I

2414
01:14:33,662 --> 01:14:35,662
d like

2415
01:14:36,365 --> 01:14:37,799
to go and say yes to your gonna

2416
01:14:37,799 --> 01:14:39,868
abstain from item number nine?

2417
01:14:39,868 --> 01:14:44,680
Yes. Kid, I get a point of

2418
01:14:44,740 --> 01:14:46,740
clarification. Absolutely. Um

2419
01:14:49,578 --> 01:14:51,147
Okay. So Luke Is this not Just

2420
01:14:51,147 --> 01:14:51,848
a cleanup in language. This is

2421
01:14:51,848 --> 01:14:52,715
not. We

2422
01:14:52,715 --> 01:14:55,115
ve already approved all

2423
01:14:55,284 --> 01:14:57,954
this stuff correct. Yeah. I

2424
01:14:57,954 --> 01:14:58,688
mean if it comes to 80 us to

2425
01:14:58,688 --> 01:15:00,688
use our it

2426
01:15:00,723 --> 01:15:01,858
s in state law. So,

2427
01:15:01,858 --> 01:15:03,260
Regardless of what our

2428
01:15:03,260 --> 01:15:04,660
municipal code said. 80 use are

2429
01:15:04,660 --> 01:15:07,296
allowed. This is just to like I

2430
01:15:07,296 --> 01:15:09,233
said. This is just a

2431
01:15:09,233 --> 01:15:09,867
definitional thing. So, so

2432
01:15:09,867 --> 01:15:11,301
consistency and definitions.

2433
01:15:11,301 --> 01:15:11,568
This argument has already been

2434
01:15:11,568 --> 01:15:13,303
done. We

2435
01:15:13,303 --> 01:15:14,738
re just changing the

2436
01:15:14,738 --> 01:15:16,340
wording to make it simpler and

2437
01:15:16,340 --> 01:15:18,740
more understandable. To the

2438
01:15:19,420 --> 01:15:20,110
public. Yes. That and so we can

2439
01:15:20,110 --> 01:15:21,678
get credit at the state. Farina

2440
01:15:21,678 --> 01:15:22,212
got it. I just wanted to make

2441
01:15:22,212 --> 01:15:22,846
that clear. It

2442
01:15:22,846 --> 01:15:24,381
s it seems like

2443
01:15:24,381 --> 01:15:26,250
people have the wrong

2444
01:15:26,250 --> 01:15:26,411
impression that somehow we

2445
01:15:26,411 --> 01:15:28,319
re

2446
01:15:28,319 --> 01:15:28,519
pushing through a dus when

2447
01:15:28,519 --> 01:15:30,519
that

2448
01:15:31,656 --> 01:15:33,424
s already been done, so

2449
01:15:33,424 --> 01:15:36,424
Okay. Thank you councilor would

2450
01:15:37,328 --> 01:15:38,796
like to to abstain from Okay?

2451
01:15:38,796 --> 01:15:42,601
Yeah, and I think that you know,

2452
01:15:42,601 --> 01:15:43,402
some of this stuff is the the

2453
01:15:43,402 --> 01:15:43,568
elicit a certain reaction when

2454
01:15:43,568 --> 01:15:44,202
we

2455
01:15:44,202 --> 01:15:45,437
re just trying to clean this

2456
01:15:45,437 --> 01:15:47,906
up to make it easier on staff

2457
01:15:47,906 --> 01:15:50,108
and easier on the community, So

2458
01:15:50,108 --> 01:15:51,376
okay, entertain a motion to

2459
01:15:51,376 --> 01:15:53,645
approve item number 12. Some of

2460
01:15:53,645 --> 01:15:55,460
Second Okay, so we have the

2461
01:15:55,460 --> 01:15:59,246
motion in a second. Let us vote.

2462
01:16:07,893 --> 01:16:10,463
Okay. So that passes 50, with a

2463
01:16:10,463 --> 01:16:10,696
noted abstentions. Okay. We

2464
01:16:10,696 --> 01:16:12,696
re

2465
01:16:13,432 --> 01:16:15,670
moving on to the business

2466
01:16:15,670 --> 01:16:16,535
section of our calendar. We

2467
01:16:16,535 --> 01:16:18,935
have remember 13, which is

2468
01:16:19,806 --> 01:16:20,473
review fiscal year 2023 24

2469
01:16:20,473 --> 01:16:20,707
budget policies and priorities

2470
01:16:20,707 --> 01:16:22,475
and I

2471
01:16:22,475 --> 01:16:24,678
ll go ahead and pass this

2472
01:16:24,678 --> 01:16:27,113
over to director Hennessy for a

2473
01:16:27,113 --> 01:16:27,747
staff report. Thank you. Good

2474
01:16:27,747 --> 01:16:30,147
Evening Mayor, City Council

2475
01:16:30,850 --> 01:16:32,819
members. The item before you

2476
01:16:32,819 --> 01:16:33,820
Tonight is an agenda item that

2477
01:16:33,820 --> 01:16:35,956
we do each year at the

2478
01:16:35,956 --> 01:16:36,824
beginning of our budget process.

2479
01:16:36,824 --> 01:16:38,580
Um, I

2480
01:16:38,580 --> 01:16:40,458
ll provide a brief

2481
01:16:40,461 --> 01:16:40,961
background will do a budget

2482
01:16:40,961 --> 01:16:41,362
process overview. I

2483
01:16:41,362 --> 01:16:42,930
ll give you

2484
01:16:42,930 --> 01:16:43,263
the key highlights of the

2485
01:16:43,263 --> 01:16:44,431
current year

2486
01:16:44,431 --> 01:16:44,598
s budget, and then

2487
01:16:44,598 --> 01:16:46,598
we

2488
01:16:46,700 --> 01:16:48,702
ll review some budget

2489
01:16:48,702 --> 01:16:50,570
priorities and budget policies.

2490
01:16:50,570 --> 01:16:53,374
That have been previously set

2491
01:16:53,374 --> 01:16:55,443
by prior councils. So each year

2492
01:16:55,443 --> 01:16:57,812
at the beginning of our budget

2493
01:16:57,812 --> 01:17:00,470
process, we bring this item to

2494
01:17:00,470 --> 01:17:03,647
you. It is in accordance with

2495
01:17:04,319 --> 01:17:05,386
our government Finance Officers

2496
01:17:05,386 --> 01:17:07,786
Association best practices and

2497
01:17:08,222 --> 01:17:09,457
what it includes is basically

2498
01:17:09,457 --> 01:17:11,260
increasing the engagement of

2499
01:17:11,260 --> 01:17:11,726
the council commissions in the

2500
01:17:11,726 --> 01:17:14,126
public throughout the budget

2501
01:17:14,429 --> 01:17:17,429
process. Do, a financial policy

2502
01:17:18,900 --> 01:17:21,300
review. I use of other forms of

2503
01:17:21,300 --> 01:17:22,971
communication, so they want an

2504
01:17:22,971 --> 01:17:24,940
increase in videos and social

2505
01:17:24,940 --> 01:17:27,543
media and the like throughout

2506
01:17:27,543 --> 01:17:28,377
our budget documents and then

2507
01:17:28,377 --> 01:17:30,713
do strategic planning process.

2508
01:17:30,713 --> 01:17:33,816
Uh and we have that outlined in

2509
01:17:33,816 --> 01:17:34,917
our budget document and as well

2510
01:17:34,917 --> 01:17:35,819
as include performance measures.

2511
01:17:35,819 --> 01:17:36,986
They are now mandatory. The

2512
01:17:36,986 --> 01:17:39,986
City is always included them,

2513
01:17:41,770 --> 01:17:41,308
but they are now mandatory as

2514
01:17:41,308 --> 01:17:42,425
part of this program. Um and

2515
01:17:42,425 --> 01:17:43,590
the city has incorporated to

2516
01:17:43,590 --> 01:17:45,459
these requirements into our

2517
01:17:46,496 --> 01:17:49,660
process. Each year. In JANUARY,

2518
01:17:49,660 --> 01:17:51,101
We begin our budget process by

2519
01:17:51,101 --> 01:17:52,168
reviewing the current year

2520
01:17:52,168 --> 01:17:54,104
revenues and expenditures and

2521
01:17:54,104 --> 01:17:55,805
then we also update our five

2522
01:17:55,805 --> 01:17:58,740
year financial projections. And.

2523
01:17:58,740 --> 01:17:59,743
Then in FEBRUARY. We. Bring to

2524
01:17:59,743 --> 01:18:01,144
you the council, the mid Year

2525
01:18:01,144 --> 01:18:03,414
Budget Update for the current

2526
01:18:03,414 --> 01:18:03,981
year and then we kick off the

2527
01:18:03,981 --> 01:18:05,649
next year

2528
01:18:05,649 --> 01:18:07,751
s budget and Capital

2529
01:18:07,751 --> 01:18:10,151
Improvement program process. Um,

2530
01:18:10,154 --> 01:18:12,723
during the months of MARCH and

2531
01:18:12,723 --> 01:18:13,924
APRIL staff develops the

2532
01:18:13,924 --> 01:18:15,924
proposed annual operating

2533
01:18:16,600 --> 01:18:16,260
budget and c I p And then

2534
01:18:16,260 --> 01:18:17,270
that

2535
01:18:17,270 --> 01:18:19,597
s presented to the council

2536
01:18:19,597 --> 01:18:23,340
at the Budget Workshop in MAY,

2537
01:18:23,340 --> 01:18:23,702
and that is your opportunity to

2538
01:18:23,702 --> 01:18:25,837
review the proposed budget and

2539
01:18:25,837 --> 01:18:26,471
c, I p and then provide any

2540
01:18:26,471 --> 01:18:26,634
comments or changes that you

2541
01:18:26,634 --> 01:18:28,634
d

2542
01:18:28,773 --> 01:18:29,774
like to see incorporated into

2543
01:18:29,774 --> 01:18:31,342
the adopted budget, which was

2544
01:18:31,342 --> 01:18:33,511
presented at the first meeting

2545
01:18:33,511 --> 01:18:35,847
in JUNE of each year. And then

2546
01:18:35,847 --> 01:18:38,170
throughout the remainder of the

2547
01:18:38,170 --> 01:18:39,952
year, JULY through DECEMBER, um,

2548
01:18:39,952 --> 01:18:41,754
finance works with departments

2549
01:18:41,754 --> 01:18:43,889
to do ongoing analysis

2550
01:18:43,889 --> 01:18:45,991
reviewing budget actuals for

2551
01:18:45,991 --> 01:18:46,825
both revenues and expenditures

2552
01:18:46,825 --> 01:18:49,225
and identifying any adjustments

2553
01:18:49,428 --> 01:18:53,331
that would be needed to be made

2554
01:18:53,331 --> 01:18:55,680
at the future Mid year process.

2555
01:18:55,680 --> 01:18:56,903
Um budget adjustments for

2556
01:18:56,903 --> 01:18:57,570
existing funding can be made

2557
01:18:57,570 --> 01:18:59,570
administratively throughout the

2558
01:19:00,339 --> 01:19:01,641
. But any additional

2559
01:19:01,641 --> 01:19:04,410
appropriations or new funding

2560
01:19:04,510 --> 01:19:06,450
must be approved by council.

2561
01:19:06,450 --> 01:19:07,246
There are several key

2562
01:19:07,246 --> 01:19:08,381
deliverables throughout the

2563
01:19:08,381 --> 01:19:09,782
budget process, the first of

2564
01:19:09,782 --> 01:19:11,851
which is the preliminary budget,

2565
01:19:11,851 --> 01:19:13,987
and this is an internal

2566
01:19:13,987 --> 01:19:15,189
document that contains all of

2567
01:19:15,189 --> 01:19:15,389
the departmental requests

2568
01:19:15,389 --> 01:19:16,623
that

2569
01:19:16,623 --> 01:19:17,824
s developed in the MARCH

2570
01:19:17,824 --> 01:19:18,250
APRIL time frame, and then

2571
01:19:18,250 --> 01:19:19,693
that

2572
01:19:19,693 --> 01:19:22,162
s presented to the city

2573
01:19:22,162 --> 01:19:22,963
manager who reviews that and

2574
01:19:22,963 --> 01:19:23,930
then makes his recommendations

2575
01:19:23,930 --> 01:19:26,299
into what we call the proposed

2576
01:19:26,299 --> 01:19:27,634
budget. And the proposed budget

2577
01:19:27,634 --> 01:19:30,538
is what is presented at the MAY

2578
01:19:30,538 --> 01:19:32,573
budget workshop. To, the

2579
01:19:32,573 --> 01:19:34,750
council and then finally, the

2580
01:19:34,750 --> 01:19:36,410
adopted budget is presented

2581
01:19:36,410 --> 01:19:37,979
again in the first meeting in

2582
01:19:37,979 --> 01:19:40,948
JUNE, as I mentioned and then

2583
01:19:40,948 --> 01:19:42,249
also part of the budget process

2584
01:19:42,249 --> 01:19:43,718
that happens currently, and

2585
01:19:43,718 --> 01:19:44,852
FEBRUARY and MARCH are the

2586
01:19:44,852 --> 01:19:45,986
budget engagement sessions that

2587
01:19:45,986 --> 01:19:47,540
are held with each commission

2588
01:19:47,540 --> 01:19:48,456
and board, which you heard

2589
01:19:48,456 --> 01:19:50,225
earlier tonight. Last Week We

2590
01:19:50,225 --> 01:19:50,926
met with the Public Traffic

2591
01:19:50,926 --> 01:19:52,493
Safety Commission, and tomorrow

2592
01:19:52,493 --> 01:19:55,493
we meet With another commission.

2593
01:19:57,499 --> 01:19:58,266
So shifting gears to give you

2594
01:19:58,266 --> 01:20:01,266
the budget highlights. This was

2595
01:20:01,303 --> 01:20:03,505
as of the mid year budget that

2596
01:20:03,505 --> 01:20:03,671
was provided in FEBRUARY. Um,

2597
01:20:03,671 --> 01:20:04,205
we

2598
01:20:04,205 --> 01:20:06,442
re focusing right here on

2599
01:20:06,442 --> 01:20:06,642
the General Fund, which is the

2600
01:20:06,642 --> 01:20:08,277
city

2601
01:20:08,277 --> 01:20:10,446
s primary operating fund.

2602
01:20:10,446 --> 01:20:11,447
And on this slide. You can see

2603
01:20:11,447 --> 01:20:13,515
that our revenues are expected

2604
01:20:13,515 --> 01:20:15,884
to exceed $111 million this

2605
01:20:15,884 --> 01:20:19,484
year. The book of which comes

2606
01:20:19,969 --> 01:20:23,260
from sales tax. And then on the

2607
01:20:23,260 --> 01:20:24,594
chart here, the black line

2608
01:20:24,594 --> 01:20:26,596
reflects revenues and the blue

2609
01:20:26,596 --> 01:20:26,796
bars reflect expenditures. And

2610
01:20:26,796 --> 01:20:28,796
what

2611
01:20:29,532 --> 01:20:30,200
s notable here is that the

2612
01:20:30,200 --> 01:20:31,634
revenues exceed the

2613
01:20:31,634 --> 01:20:33,703
expenditures each and every

2614
01:20:33,703 --> 01:20:34,904
year, indicating that we are

2615
01:20:34,904 --> 01:20:36,306
structurally balanced. Um not

2616
01:20:36,306 --> 01:20:38,541
only in the current fiscal year,

2617
01:20:38,541 --> 01:20:39,175
but for the next five years

2618
01:20:39,175 --> 01:20:40,744
through our projections, and

2619
01:20:40,744 --> 01:20:42,579
then you can also see in the

2620
01:20:42,579 --> 01:20:45,516
black lion there that it levels

2621
01:20:45,516 --> 01:20:47,916
out between fiscal year 22 23

2622
01:20:50,521 --> 01:20:52,689
next fiscal year. And that is

2623
01:20:52,689 --> 01:20:53,757
anticipation of a potential

2624
01:20:53,757 --> 01:20:55,580
economic contraction or really,

2625
01:20:55,580 --> 01:20:57,562
just leveling out of our of the

2626
01:20:57,562 --> 01:20:58,196
majority of our revenue sources

2627
01:20:58,196 --> 01:21:01,796
which are tied to the local

2628
01:21:03,340 --> 01:21:04,435
economy. Expenditures of the

2629
01:21:04,435 --> 01:21:06,604
General fund will total a

2630
01:21:06,604 --> 01:21:08,706
little over 93 million for this

2631
01:21:08,706 --> 01:21:10,140
fiscal year, the book of which

2632
01:21:10,140 --> 01:21:12,540
is dedicated towards public

2633
01:21:12,743 --> 01:21:13,544
safety with our police and fire

2634
01:21:13,544 --> 01:21:15,847
contracts, noted there and then

2635
01:21:15,847 --> 01:21:17,182
public works makes up 20%. And

2636
01:21:17,182 --> 01:21:20,182
that includes not only the

2637
01:21:20,618 --> 01:21:21,653
public works staffing, but also

2638
01:21:21,653 --> 01:21:22,354
several contractual services,

2639
01:21:22,354 --> 01:21:25,256
um, approved earlier tonight as

2640
01:21:25,256 --> 01:21:25,624
an example. And, the

2641
01:21:25,624 --> 01:21:26,725
administration

2642
01:21:26,725 --> 01:21:28,725
s 14% community

2643
01:21:28,827 --> 01:21:31,227
development, 9% and then non

2644
01:21:33,199 --> 01:21:34,934
departmental is is 1%. And.

2645
01:21:34,934 --> 01:21:37,690
Then this slide illustrates

2646
01:21:37,690 --> 01:21:37,670
what the available fund

2647
01:21:37,670 --> 01:21:40,700
balances within the General

2648
01:21:41,140 --> 01:21:41,707
fund. So at the end of the

2649
01:21:41,707 --> 01:21:41,869
current fiscal year, it

2650
01:21:41,869 --> 01:21:43,642
s

2651
01:21:43,642 --> 01:21:45,642
projected to reach $37.1

2652
01:21:49,381 --> 01:21:50,850
million. And of that 37 point

2653
01:21:50,850 --> 01:21:52,485
1,000,018 37.0.6 million is

2654
01:21:52,485 --> 01:21:55,485
dedicated for the reserve for

2655
01:21:55,522 --> 01:21:56,790
economic and certainty. And 4.6

2656
01:21:56,790 --> 01:21:58,158
million for the secondary

2657
01:21:58,158 --> 01:22:00,293
reserve, and both of those are

2658
01:22:00,293 --> 01:22:01,260
reserved levels that are set by

2659
01:22:01,260 --> 01:22:01,428
budget policy, and we

2660
01:22:01,428 --> 01:22:02,962
ll

2661
01:22:02,962 --> 01:22:03,630
discuss that in a little while,

2662
01:22:03,630 --> 01:22:05,598
Um, But it

2663
01:22:05,598 --> 01:22:07,334
s important to note

2664
01:22:07,334 --> 01:22:10,334
that those reserves have never

2665
01:22:11,205 --> 01:22:11,639
have never been tapped into, um

2666
01:22:11,639 --> 01:22:11,872
throughout the city

2667
01:22:11,872 --> 01:22:12,106
s history

2668
01:22:12,106 --> 01:22:14,106
that I

2669
01:22:16,110 --> 01:22:17,577
m aware o. Not That

2670
01:22:17,577 --> 01:22:19,977
leaves about 13 million in

2671
01:22:20,414 --> 01:22:21,982
available fund balance. And.

2672
01:22:21,982 --> 01:22:23,383
One item to note on the chart,

2673
01:22:23,383 --> 01:22:24,853
so the fund balance is

2674
01:22:24,853 --> 01:22:26,540
reflected in the blue bars and

2675
01:22:26,540 --> 01:22:29,540
then the black line reflects

2676
01:22:30,158 --> 01:22:31,726
the Levels of reserve funding

2677
01:22:31,726 --> 01:22:33,628
and then the yellow diamond

2678
01:22:33,628 --> 01:22:35,697
reflects the desired level of

2679
01:22:35,697 --> 01:22:37,598
reserve funding. So We are

2680
01:22:37,598 --> 01:22:39,000
meeting our reserve are desired

2681
01:22:39,000 --> 01:22:39,968
level of reserves each year

2682
01:22:39,968 --> 01:22:42,368
throughout the five year

2683
01:22:42,671 --> 01:22:45,400
forecast, as well as historical

2684
01:22:45,400 --> 01:22:47,442
And the drop in fund balance

2685
01:22:47,442 --> 01:22:49,842
between fiscal years 21 22 the

2686
01:22:51,346 --> 01:22:52,848
current fiscal year. Relates to

2687
01:22:52,848 --> 01:22:54,382
a recently adopted budget

2688
01:22:54,382 --> 01:22:55,417
policy related to our debt

2689
01:22:55,417 --> 01:22:56,451
strategy. Pay down, which I

2690
01:22:56,451 --> 01:22:57,152
have a few slides coming up

2691
01:22:57,152 --> 01:23:00,152
that illustrates where we are

2692
01:23:01,858 --> 01:23:03,493
on that. And. Then we have our

2693
01:23:03,493 --> 01:23:05,893
five year capital improvement

2694
01:23:06,295 --> 01:23:07,497
program. Um, currently we have

2695
01:23:07,497 --> 01:23:09,497
106 separate projects totaling

2696
01:23:11,000 --> 01:23:11,300
a little over $801 million. Of

2697
01:23:11,300 --> 01:23:13,300
that there

2698
01:23:14,637 --> 01:23:16,505
s 518 Million yet to

2699
01:23:16,505 --> 01:23:18,505
complete with 283 million

2700
01:23:19,900 --> 01:23:21,544
already completed. And we break

2701
01:23:21,544 --> 01:23:23,647
out our capital improvement

2702
01:23:23,647 --> 01:23:24,448
program into different

2703
01:23:24,448 --> 01:23:25,115
categories. Circulation

2704
01:23:25,115 --> 01:23:27,515
infrastructure parks and rec

2705
01:23:27,517 --> 01:23:28,285
and then started which is also

2706
01:23:28,285 --> 01:23:30,530
affordable housing. So our

2707
01:23:30,530 --> 01:23:34,253
total c I. P again is little

2708
01:23:36,427 --> 01:23:38,329
over $801 million So budget

2709
01:23:38,329 --> 01:23:40,197
priorities are determined, Um

2710
01:23:40,197 --> 01:23:41,766
Through or they linked to our

2711
01:23:41,766 --> 01:23:42,700
strategic plan known as the

2712
01:23:42,700 --> 01:23:45,502
Quality of Life Master Plan and

2713
01:23:45,502 --> 01:23:46,703
the q. L m, p, As, you know,

2714
01:23:46,703 --> 01:23:49,103
recently updated to include 1/7

2715
01:23:50,374 --> 01:23:52,110
Corps value. So. We have all

2716
01:23:52,110 --> 01:23:53,745
seven core values identified

2717
01:23:53,745 --> 01:23:56,145
throughout the budget document.

2718
01:23:56,781 --> 01:23:57,716
In, the form of performance

2719
01:23:57,716 --> 01:24:00,116
measures and capital projects

2720
01:24:00,485 --> 01:24:02,654
all linked back to a specific

2721
01:24:02,654 --> 01:24:03,922
core value. And that is how we

2722
01:24:03,922 --> 01:24:05,823
ensure that the application of

2723
01:24:05,823 --> 01:24:06,900
our resources are in line with

2724
01:24:06,900 --> 01:24:08,900
the city

2725
01:24:09,394 --> 01:24:09,581
s core values. There

2726
01:24:09,581 --> 01:24:11,530
s

2727
01:24:11,530 --> 01:24:13,799
several tools that we utilize

2728
01:24:13,799 --> 01:24:15,334
when we start to build the

2729
01:24:15,334 --> 01:24:16,680
operating budget in the capital

2730
01:24:16,680 --> 01:24:18,437
Improvement program budget, the

2731
01:24:18,437 --> 01:24:19,905
first of which are carry overs

2732
01:24:19,905 --> 01:24:21,706
from the prior year. So what

2733
01:24:21,706 --> 01:24:22,941
that includes the city programs

2734
01:24:22,941 --> 01:24:25,577
or projects that were started

2735
01:24:25,577 --> 01:24:25,978
in the previous fiscal year

2736
01:24:25,978 --> 01:24:26,278
that maybe weren

2737
01:24:26,278 --> 01:24:27,981
t completed.

2738
01:24:27,981 --> 01:24:29,282
We ensure that the funding for

2739
01:24:29,282 --> 01:24:30,549
those projects are carried over

2740
01:24:30,549 --> 01:24:32,180
into the new fiscal year. So

2741
01:24:32,180 --> 01:24:35,180
that we can bring those

2742
01:24:35,387 --> 01:24:36,856
projects to completion. And,

2743
01:24:36,856 --> 01:24:38,558
then we do. Um every every so

2744
01:24:38,558 --> 01:24:39,859
often we do community

2745
01:24:39,859 --> 01:24:41,394
satisfaction surveys and we

2746
01:24:41,394 --> 01:24:43,629
received that feedback from the

2747
01:24:43,629 --> 01:24:45,199
community and that helps

2748
01:24:45,199 --> 01:24:46,466
influence what programs and

2749
01:24:46,466 --> 01:24:47,801
projects are most important to

2750
01:24:47,801 --> 01:24:49,937
the community and were

2751
01:24:49,937 --> 01:24:50,971
scheduled to do another one

2752
01:24:50,971 --> 01:24:52,973
next fiscal year to reach out

2753
01:24:52,973 --> 01:24:54,841
to the community. And. Then we

2754
01:24:54,841 --> 01:24:57,770
do the board and commissioned

2755
01:24:57,770 --> 01:24:57,811
feedback as I mentioned before

2756
01:24:57,811 --> 01:24:58,779
and then we

2757
01:24:58,779 --> 01:24:59,479
ll incorporate that

2758
01:24:59,479 --> 01:25:00,714
feedback into the proposed

2759
01:25:00,714 --> 01:25:03,551
budget that will come forward

2760
01:25:03,551 --> 01:25:05,319
to you in MAY. And then a

2761
01:25:05,319 --> 01:25:06,554
variety of departments have

2762
01:25:06,554 --> 01:25:08,156
program and services Master

2763
01:25:08,156 --> 01:25:08,989
plans, so the programs and

2764
01:25:08,989 --> 01:25:10,624
projects that are identified in

2765
01:25:10,624 --> 01:25:12,193
those master plans are weaved

2766
01:25:12,193 --> 01:25:13,627
into the either the operating

2767
01:25:13,627 --> 01:25:15,496
budget or the capital

2768
01:25:15,496 --> 01:25:16,931
Improvement Program budget,

2769
01:25:16,931 --> 01:25:18,499
whichever is, um most relevant.

2770
01:25:18,499 --> 01:25:20,101
And. Then. Finally the

2771
01:25:20,101 --> 01:25:22,501
different City Council policies,

2772
01:25:23,972 --> 01:25:25,207
which will review next So the

2773
01:25:25,207 --> 01:25:27,175
budget and fiscal policies.

2774
01:25:27,175 --> 01:25:29,711
Policies are part of the annual

2775
01:25:29,711 --> 01:25:31,946
operating budget, and they are

2776
01:25:31,946 --> 01:25:33,915
adopted each year in JUNE.

2777
01:25:33,915 --> 01:25:35,483
There are several policies that

2778
01:25:35,483 --> 01:25:36,718
impact the development process

2779
01:25:36,718 --> 01:25:38,921
of the budget, which will

2780
01:25:38,921 --> 01:25:40,322
highlight here. Um, one of

2781
01:25:40,322 --> 01:25:43,922
which is the fund balance and

2782
01:25:45,728 --> 01:25:46,896
reserve policy. The Measure s

2783
01:25:46,896 --> 01:25:48,531
appropriation policy priorities,

2784
01:25:48,531 --> 01:25:49,231
contingency planning, and then

2785
01:25:49,231 --> 01:25:52,831
the debt or liability paid out

2786
01:25:54,690 --> 01:25:55,705
strategy. So the fund balance

2787
01:25:55,705 --> 01:25:57,640
and reserve policy. Uh, we have

2788
01:25:57,640 --> 01:25:59,420
a few charts or a few slides

2789
01:25:59,420 --> 01:25:59,709
here that illustrate the

2790
01:25:59,709 --> 01:26:02,109
different components of fund

2791
01:26:03,846 --> 01:26:06,516
balance. Um, the fund balance

2792
01:26:06,516 --> 01:26:08,510
is the accumulation of savings

2793
01:26:08,510 --> 01:26:09,819
year to year when revenues

2794
01:26:09,819 --> 01:26:10,530
exceed expenditures. And they

2795
01:26:10,530 --> 01:26:11,721
made it

2796
01:26:11,721 --> 01:26:12,389
s made up of four

2797
01:26:12,389 --> 01:26:14,789
primary components, the first

2798
01:26:15,125 --> 01:26:16,760
of which is the reserve for

2799
01:26:16,760 --> 01:26:19,160
economic uncertainty, and this

2800
01:26:19,730 --> 01:26:22,130
reflects 20% of the general

2801
01:26:23,667 --> 01:26:24,635
fund operating expenditures.

2802
01:26:24,635 --> 01:26:26,635
The Secondary reserve

2803
01:26:27,370 --> 01:26:28,972
represents 5% of the General

2804
01:26:28,972 --> 01:26:30,972
fund operating expenditures.

2805
01:26:31,876 --> 01:26:33,144
And, then the third category is

2806
01:26:33,144 --> 01:26:34,712
a signed fund balance, so this

2807
01:26:34,712 --> 01:26:35,460
is a portion of the fund

2808
01:26:35,460 --> 01:26:36,481
balance that

2809
01:26:36,481 --> 01:26:38,481
s committed to

2810
01:26:39,117 --> 01:26:39,917
future obligations. So capital

2811
01:26:39,917 --> 01:26:41,917
Improvement Program projects

2812
01:26:42,320 --> 01:26:43,954
are the primary example. There.

2813
01:26:43,954 --> 01:26:46,354
And, then finally available

2814
01:26:46,891 --> 01:26:47,559
fund balance, So that is the

2815
01:26:47,559 --> 01:26:49,559
uncommitted, remaining balance

2816
01:26:49,895 --> 01:26:51,330
left within the general fund

2817
01:26:51,330 --> 01:26:53,730
after accounting for those

2818
01:26:55,600 --> 01:26:57,200
other three categories. So. The

2819
01:26:57,200 --> 01:26:57,202
available General Fund balance

2820
01:26:57,202 --> 01:26:58,837
or it

2821
01:26:58,837 --> 01:27:01,237
s also sometimes called

2822
01:27:01,239 --> 01:27:03,175
the unassigned fund balance.

2823
01:27:03,175 --> 01:27:05,244
Councils previous councils have

2824
01:27:05,244 --> 01:27:06,179
said the appropriation

2825
01:27:06,179 --> 01:27:06,345
priorities for these funds, Um

2826
01:27:06,345 --> 01:27:07,580
it

2827
01:27:07,580 --> 01:27:10,580
s important to consider that

2828
01:27:10,650 --> 01:27:11,750
these are one time funds, so

2829
01:27:11,750 --> 01:27:12,852
the appropriation priorities

2830
01:27:12,852 --> 01:27:15,852
reflect that, so the first

2831
01:27:16,389 --> 01:27:18,324
priority would be to spend any

2832
01:27:18,324 --> 01:27:19,291
available fund balance on

2833
01:27:19,291 --> 01:27:22,291
public safety equipment or non

2834
01:27:23,630 --> 01:27:25,630
recurring programs. Second

2835
01:27:25,398 --> 01:27:27,330
would be to, uh, deposit the

2836
01:27:27,330 --> 01:27:28,768
funds into asset management

2837
01:27:28,768 --> 01:27:29,635
reserves and asset management

2838
01:27:29,635 --> 01:27:32,350
reserves are separate funds

2839
01:27:33,600 --> 01:27:33,673
that are set up somewhat like

2840
01:27:33,673 --> 01:27:35,308
savings accounts where it

2841
01:27:35,308 --> 01:27:37,610
accumulates funds so that when

2842
01:27:37,610 --> 01:27:38,945
an asset such as a vehicle or a

2843
01:27:38,945 --> 01:27:40,348
large piece of equipment when

2844
01:27:40,348 --> 01:27:41,182
that reaches the end of its

2845
01:27:41,182 --> 01:27:43,284
useful life, the funds are

2846
01:27:43,284 --> 01:27:46,187
there to replace that asset.

2847
01:27:46,187 --> 01:27:47,554
The third priority is Capital

2848
01:27:47,554 --> 01:27:49,423
improvement projects. The

2849
01:27:49,423 --> 01:27:51,250
fourth is the reduction of

2850
01:27:51,250 --> 01:27:53,327
unfunded liabilities related to

2851
01:27:53,327 --> 01:27:54,995
the Calpers pension. Or open,

2852
01:27:54,995 --> 01:27:57,465
which stands for other post

2853
01:27:57,465 --> 01:27:58,600
employment benefits. And then

2854
01:27:58,600 --> 01:28:01,600
the fifth is reduction or

2855
01:28:03,671 --> 01:28:06,671
avoidance of city debt. Ah,

2856
01:28:07,208 --> 01:28:08,710
measure s when it was passed in

2857
01:28:08,710 --> 01:28:10,710
2016 became effective in 2017

2858
01:28:11,912 --> 01:28:13,810
and the council at that time

2859
01:28:13,810 --> 01:28:15,810
adopted these appropriation

2860
01:28:15,717 --> 01:28:17,686
guidelines for the spending of

2861
01:28:17,686 --> 01:28:19,588
measure us, the first of which

2862
01:28:19,588 --> 01:28:20,989
is public safety. The, Second

2863
01:28:20,989 --> 01:28:22,391
is asset management and then

2864
01:28:22,391 --> 01:28:24,226
capital improvement projects

2865
01:28:24,226 --> 01:28:25,460
and then finally, community

2866
01:28:25,460 --> 01:28:26,728
services or general services.

2867
01:28:26,728 --> 01:28:28,563
And you can see from the page

2868
01:28:28,563 --> 01:28:31,133
chart here. The majority of the

2869
01:28:31,133 --> 01:28:32,168
funding for measures is going

2870
01:28:32,168 --> 01:28:34,168
towards capital projects

2871
01:28:35,104 --> 01:28:36,205
currently, um, but when we

2872
01:28:36,205 --> 01:28:38,141
appropriate when we appropriate

2873
01:28:38,141 --> 01:28:40,276
measures in the budget, we

2874
01:28:40,276 --> 01:28:41,544
first ensure that public safety

2875
01:28:41,544 --> 01:28:44,280
is fully funded. Uh and then

2876
01:28:44,280 --> 01:28:45,314
our asset management. And then

2877
01:28:45,314 --> 01:28:46,849
capital projects and then

2878
01:28:46,849 --> 01:28:47,416
community services. So. We

2879
01:28:47,416 --> 01:28:48,117
follow these appropriation

2880
01:28:48,117 --> 01:28:48,384
guidelines when we

2881
01:28:48,384 --> 01:28:50,530
re building

2882
01:28:50,530 --> 01:28:52,756
the budget document. And then

2883
01:28:52,756 --> 01:28:54,825
as time goes on, and the cost

2884
01:28:54,825 --> 01:28:55,558
of public safety and community

2885
01:28:55,558 --> 01:28:57,327
services increases that will

2886
01:28:57,327 --> 01:29:00,927
leave less and less over time

2887
01:29:02,232 --> 01:29:03,833
for capital projects. We also

2888
01:29:03,833 --> 01:29:06,570
have a policy for contingency

2889
01:29:06,570 --> 01:29:08,970
planning. And. Basically. This

2890
01:29:09,607 --> 01:29:10,541
lays out the, um the use of our

2891
01:29:10,541 --> 01:29:10,741
secondary reserve. So when

2892
01:29:10,741 --> 01:29:12,741
there

2893
01:29:12,943 --> 01:29:15,846
s a one time event, such

2894
01:29:15,846 --> 01:29:18,820
as a state mandated payment or

2895
01:29:18,820 --> 01:29:20,351
natural disaster, we would tap

2896
01:29:20,351 --> 01:29:22,520
into the secondary reserve

2897
01:29:22,520 --> 01:29:23,354
first and fully exhaust that

2898
01:29:23,354 --> 01:29:23,854
reserve before utilizing the

2899
01:29:23,854 --> 01:29:25,854
reserve for economic

2900
01:29:27,358 --> 01:29:28,426
uncertainty. And for ongoing

2901
01:29:28,426 --> 01:29:30,795
fiscal constraints. So an

2902
01:29:30,795 --> 01:29:33,498
example of this would be if we

2903
01:29:33,498 --> 01:29:35,667
lost a major business that was

2904
01:29:35,667 --> 01:29:39,237
a major sales tax generator. Um,

2905
01:29:39,237 --> 01:29:41,105
we would utilize the secondary

2906
01:29:41,105 --> 01:29:41,840
Reserve first before using the

2907
01:29:41,840 --> 01:29:42,708
reserve for economic

2908
01:29:42,708 --> 01:29:43,109
uncertainty, But there

2909
01:29:43,109 --> 01:29:44,176
s a

2910
01:29:44,176 --> 01:29:46,745
limitation to only use those

2911
01:29:46,745 --> 01:29:49,181
reserves for a two year budget

2912
01:29:49,181 --> 01:29:51,584
cycle, so that would give the

2913
01:29:51,584 --> 01:29:53,180
city enough time to reduce its

2914
01:29:53,180 --> 01:29:54,286
itsxpenditures in rehab in

2915
01:29:54,286 --> 01:29:57,890
reaction to the loss of that

2916
01:29:57,890 --> 01:29:58,524
revenue item. And then, as I

2917
01:29:58,524 --> 01:29:58,690
mentioned earlier, the city

2918
01:29:58,690 --> 01:30:00,126
s

2919
01:30:00,126 --> 01:30:01,995
never tapped into its reserves,

2920
01:30:01,995 --> 01:30:03,596
either through the great

2921
01:30:03,596 --> 01:30:05,996
recession or through Covid.

2922
01:30:07,433 --> 01:30:08,968
Recently. And the last policy

2923
01:30:08,968 --> 01:30:10,436
that a highlight here is the

2924
01:30:10,436 --> 01:30:11,170
one that was just adopted in

2925
01:30:11,170 --> 01:30:12,705
DECEMBER, and it

2926
01:30:12,705 --> 01:30:14,140
s our debt

2927
01:30:14,140 --> 01:30:15,975
liability, pay down strategy

2928
01:30:15,975 --> 01:30:18,145
and the goal that was adopted

2929
01:30:18,145 --> 01:30:20,447
is to have the city become debt

2930
01:30:20,447 --> 01:30:24,470
free in a seven year timeframe.

2931
01:30:24,510 --> 01:30:25,520
Um. We will do this by

2932
01:30:25,520 --> 01:30:27,520
utilizing available fund

2933
01:30:27,154 --> 01:30:28,555
balance in combination with the

2934
01:30:28,555 --> 01:30:31,258
pension trust balance and any

2935
01:30:31,258 --> 01:30:33,860
future savings that the payoff

2936
01:30:33,860 --> 01:30:35,563
of these debts create. And. It

2937
01:30:35,563 --> 01:30:37,198
will become a snowball effect

2938
01:30:37,198 --> 01:30:38,766
where all the savings will be

2939
01:30:38,766 --> 01:30:38,966
incorporated into the next

2940
01:30:38,966 --> 01:30:40,701
year

2941
01:30:40,701 --> 01:30:43,370
s pay down strategy. And

2942
01:30:43,370 --> 01:30:45,740
we have four main types of debt.

2943
01:30:45,740 --> 01:30:46,440
We had a loan on this on this

2944
01:30:46,440 --> 01:30:49,440
building here. The Civic Center

2945
01:30:50,478 --> 01:30:51,579
loan. Alone on the Margarita

2946
01:30:51,579 --> 01:30:51,738
Recreation center that

2947
01:30:51,738 --> 01:30:52,180
s

2948
01:30:52,180 --> 01:30:54,180
currently under under

2949
01:30:54,616 --> 01:30:56,840
construction. And. Then we have

2950
01:30:56,840 --> 01:30:58,484
two unfunded liabilities, one

2951
01:30:59,870 --> 01:31:00,288
for pension and one for open,

2952
01:31:00,288 --> 01:31:02,224
which is basically retiree

2953
01:31:02,224 --> 01:31:02,891
health that was offered, um

2954
01:31:02,891 --> 01:31:06,610
many, many years ago to city

2955
01:31:06,610 --> 01:31:06,628
employees. And you can see the

2956
01:31:06,628 --> 01:31:07,863
annual outstanding amounts

2957
01:31:07,863 --> 01:31:11,463
there as well as the annual

2958
01:31:12,368 --> 01:31:15,104
payments. And this is what the

2959
01:31:15,104 --> 01:31:18,700
plan includes, as far as the

2960
01:31:18,700 --> 01:31:19,341
payoff schedule, Um to date, we

2961
01:31:19,341 --> 01:31:21,110
have paid off the Civic Center

2962
01:31:21,110 --> 01:31:21,677
loan at 12.9 Million. We

2963
01:31:21,677 --> 01:31:23,179
ve

2964
01:31:23,179 --> 01:31:24,813
paid off the mrc loan at five

2965
01:31:24,813 --> 01:31:26,615
million. And we

2966
01:31:26,615 --> 01:31:28,615
ve put 7.25

2967
01:31:30,754 --> 01:31:32,422
million towards our Unfunded

2968
01:31:32,422 --> 01:31:35,910
liability for pension. Uh. This

2969
01:31:35,910 --> 01:31:36,559
is another way to illustrate

2970
01:31:36,559 --> 01:31:36,826
that so annual savings. Um, you

2971
01:31:36,826 --> 01:31:38,826
know, we

2972
01:31:39,562 --> 01:31:41,130
ll start around 1.6

2973
01:31:41,130 --> 01:31:42,765
Million. But by year eight. We

2974
01:31:42,765 --> 01:31:43,566
will be saving on an annual

2975
01:31:43,566 --> 01:31:46,566
basis a little over eight

2976
01:31:47,438 --> 01:31:48,872
million. And, then, as the

2977
01:31:48,872 --> 01:31:49,740
natural attrition of these

2978
01:31:49,740 --> 01:31:52,276
debts occur, that number will

2979
01:31:52,276 --> 01:31:53,744
come down. Um. But today

2980
01:31:53,744 --> 01:31:53,903
through the measures that we

2981
01:31:53,903 --> 01:31:55,879
ve

2982
01:31:55,879 --> 01:31:56,780
done since DECEMBER. Is,

2983
01:31:56,780 --> 01:31:59,750
illustrated by the Black line

2984
01:31:59,750 --> 01:32:01,920
here, and it shows that we at

2985
01:32:01,920 --> 01:32:04,956
this point in time, have paid

2986
01:32:04,956 --> 01:32:05,590
off both loans. And a portion

2987
01:32:05,590 --> 01:32:07,692
of our pension obligations so

2988
01:32:07,692 --> 01:32:09,160
we have By next year because

2989
01:32:09,160 --> 01:32:12,760
that will be four fiscal year

2990
01:32:13,298 --> 01:32:15,733
we will have $3 million In

2991
01:32:15,733 --> 01:32:17,502
savings on an annual basis and

2992
01:32:17,502 --> 01:32:19,671
then next year, the plan is to

2993
01:32:19,671 --> 01:32:22,174
pay off the open so that black

2994
01:32:22,174 --> 01:32:25,174
line will continue to increase

2995
01:32:27,880 --> 01:32:28,112
and increase as time goes on.

2996
01:32:28,112 --> 01:32:29,447
There

2997
01:32:29,447 --> 01:32:30,382
s also some fiscal policy

2998
01:32:30,382 --> 01:32:32,351
metrics that are included in

2999
01:32:32,351 --> 01:32:33,819
the budget policies that we

3000
01:32:33,819 --> 01:32:35,287
would like, um, for for your

3001
01:32:35,287 --> 01:32:37,123
input on tonight whether to

3002
01:32:37,123 --> 01:32:39,792
keep these at this level or

3003
01:32:39,792 --> 01:32:40,926
whether or not you would

3004
01:32:40,926 --> 01:32:42,928
suggest any changes. Um, so I

3005
01:32:42,928 --> 01:32:43,462
mentioned are reserved for

3006
01:32:43,462 --> 01:32:43,634
economic uncertainty. It

3007
01:32:43,634 --> 01:32:45,634
s

3008
01:32:47,366 --> 01:32:47,933
currently set at 20% of

3009
01:32:47,933 --> 01:32:49,933
operating Expenditures.

3010
01:32:51,360 --> 01:32:52,400
Secondary Reserve is set at 5%.

3011
01:32:52,400 --> 01:32:54,400
Capital Improvement projects

3012
01:32:54,675 --> 01:32:56,743
threshold is $30,000 or greater,

3013
01:32:56,743 --> 01:32:57,344
Um, and it has to have a long

3014
01:32:57,344 --> 01:33:00,344
term lifespan will be non

3015
01:33:02,182 --> 01:33:03,583
recurring. And. Then. We have

3016
01:33:03,583 --> 01:33:05,318
staffing metrics related to

3017
01:33:05,318 --> 01:33:07,120
police and fire are fire

3018
01:33:07,120 --> 01:33:07,721
staffing. Metric is four

3019
01:33:07,721 --> 01:33:10,121
firefighters per engine or

3020
01:33:10,590 --> 01:33:12,726
truck. Police staffing as

3021
01:33:12,726 --> 01:33:16,326
stated in the general plan is

3022
01:33:17,965 --> 01:33:20,365
one officer per 1000 people.

3023
01:33:20,734 --> 01:33:23,504
And. Then we have thresholds

3024
01:33:23,504 --> 01:33:26,504
related to what qualifies as

3025
01:33:26,740 --> 01:33:28,676
being, um, an asset to Add to

3026
01:33:28,676 --> 01:33:29,711
the asset replacement fund and

3027
01:33:29,711 --> 01:33:30,145
for fleet and equipment. It

3028
01:33:30,145 --> 01:33:32,145
s

3029
01:33:32,413 --> 01:33:33,381
any item that is over $10,000

3030
01:33:33,381 --> 01:33:36,784
and has at least a three year

3031
01:33:36,784 --> 01:33:37,152
lifespan. And for technology

3032
01:33:37,152 --> 01:33:38,586
equipment. It

3033
01:33:38,586 --> 01:33:39,287
s anything over

3034
01:33:39,287 --> 01:33:42,287
5000 with a three year lifespan.

3035
01:33:43,290 --> 01:33:46,160
And. Then. We have a separate

3036
01:33:46,160 --> 01:33:47,396
policy that relates to the

3037
01:33:47,396 --> 01:33:49,796
pension trust contribution. So

3038
01:33:50,990 --> 01:33:52,234
each year after we closed the

3039
01:33:52,234 --> 01:33:55,838
books we are eligible to put in

3040
01:33:55,838 --> 01:33:58,106
30%. Of our general fund

3041
01:33:58,106 --> 01:33:59,942
operating surplus. Um, limited

3042
01:33:59,942 --> 01:34:00,104
to $2 million per year. That

3043
01:34:00,104 --> 01:34:01,176
s

3044
01:34:01,176 --> 01:34:04,176
currently how the how the

3045
01:34:06,182 --> 01:34:07,249
policy reads. And. Then. We

3046
01:34:07,249 --> 01:34:08,284
have signature delegation

3047
01:34:08,284 --> 01:34:10,520
authorities in the budget

3048
01:34:10,520 --> 01:34:10,753
policies as well the city

3049
01:34:10,753 --> 01:34:11,754
manager

3050
01:34:11,754 --> 01:34:12,355
s contract and

3051
01:34:12,355 --> 01:34:14,355
agreement signing authority

3052
01:34:15,324 --> 01:34:17,260
currently stands at 100,000, as

3053
01:34:17,260 --> 01:34:19,595
well as his settlement

3054
01:34:19,595 --> 01:34:20,830
authority and then the

3055
01:34:20,830 --> 01:34:22,633
emergency authority is

3056
01:34:22,633 --> 01:34:23,867
unlimited. Um and that waves

3057
01:34:23,867 --> 01:34:24,635
the public works bidding

3058
01:34:24,635 --> 01:34:25,202
requirements, and we saw that

3059
01:34:25,202 --> 01:34:28,202
as the added agenda item

3060
01:34:31,475 --> 01:34:32,876
tonight. So its staff

3061
01:34:32,876 --> 01:34:34,144
recommendation to have the

3062
01:34:34,144 --> 01:34:35,479
council affirm the city

3063
01:34:35,479 --> 01:34:37,470
s core

3064
01:34:37,470 --> 01:34:39,283
values and budget priorities as

3065
01:34:39,283 --> 01:34:40,284
well as the budget policies and

3066
01:34:40,284 --> 01:34:40,585
fiscal policy metrics. Thank

3067
01:34:40,585 --> 01:34:42,353
you and I

3068
01:34:42,353 --> 01:34:43,487
ll Be available for

3069
01:34:43,487 --> 01:34:44,889
any questions you might have.

3070
01:34:44,889 --> 01:34:45,156
All right? Thank you very much.

3071
01:34:45,156 --> 01:34:46,290
Okay. I

3072
01:34:46,290 --> 01:34:49,600
ll go ahead and open it

3073
01:34:49,600 --> 01:34:49,660
up for questions. Council

3074
01:34:49,660 --> 01:34:51,629
member, Alexander Anything

3075
01:34:51,629 --> 01:34:53,730
council member Van Mayor part.

3076
01:34:53,730 --> 01:34:55,900
Tim Stewart. Yes. Go ahead.

3077
01:34:55,900 --> 01:34:59,700
Okay. So could you go back to

3078
01:34:59,700 --> 01:35:01,390
the slide that has the fire

3079
01:35:01,390 --> 01:35:01,339
contract costs on there,

3080
01:35:01,339 --> 01:35:01,706
because it

3081
01:35:01,706 --> 01:35:03,706
s very deceptive

3082
01:35:04,142 --> 01:35:05,410
when they look at that $11

3083
01:35:05,410 --> 01:35:05,571
million, it looks like we

3084
01:35:05,571 --> 01:35:07,571
re

3085
01:35:09,114 --> 01:35:09,914
paying our fire. Incredibly

3086
01:35:09,914 --> 01:35:11,549
cheap and so I

3087
01:35:11,549 --> 01:35:13,451
d like to the

3088
01:35:13,451 --> 01:35:14,653
public to actually have

3089
01:35:14,653 --> 01:35:16,322
clarification on that. Correct.

3090
01:35:16,322 --> 01:35:20,522
Um, let me get to that slide.

3091
01:35:22,294 --> 01:35:25,970
Yes, we We reflect once I get

3092
01:35:25,970 --> 01:35:25,288
there. We reflected the city

3093
01:35:25,288 --> 01:35:27,288
s

3094
01:35:28,330 --> 01:35:28,195
cost for that. I think it

3095
01:35:28,195 --> 01:35:29,568
s

3096
01:35:29,568 --> 01:35:31,671
this one? Yeah. So fire is

3097
01:35:31,671 --> 01:35:33,406
shown here at 11.2 Million, and

3098
01:35:33,406 --> 01:35:34,207
that reflects the costs that

3099
01:35:34,207 --> 01:35:37,807
are charged by the county to

3100
01:35:39,145 --> 01:35:41,247
the city. Um. The county of

3101
01:35:41,247 --> 01:35:43,716
Riverside has a structural fire

3102
01:35:43,716 --> 01:35:44,818
tax credit that is collected

3103
01:35:44,818 --> 01:35:45,840
through everybody

3104
01:35:45,840 --> 01:35:47,840
s property

3105
01:35:47,487 --> 01:35:49,723
tax bills. That money goes to

3106
01:35:49,723 --> 01:35:51,240
the county and the county

3107
01:35:51,240 --> 01:35:53,293
applies the tax credit first

3108
01:35:53,293 --> 01:35:54,895
and builds us the remainder. So

3109
01:35:54,895 --> 01:35:55,596
the tax credit in this fiscal

3110
01:35:55,596 --> 01:35:58,596
year is between nine and $10

3111
01:35:58,699 --> 01:36:00,701
million. So the true overall

3112
01:36:00,701 --> 01:36:03,670
cost of the fire department is

3113
01:36:03,670 --> 01:36:06,390
closer to 20 to $21 million. So.

3114
01:36:06,390 --> 01:36:06,708
Thank you for? I neglected to

3115
01:36:06,708 --> 01:36:10,308
clarify that so thank you for

3116
01:36:10,711 --> 01:36:12,713
that. Okay. Anything else? Not

3117
01:36:12,713 --> 01:36:13,448
questions, counselor. Alphas

3118
01:36:13,448 --> 01:36:14,282
anything? Nothing. Okay,

3119
01:36:14,282 --> 01:36:15,216
Fantastic And thank you again

3120
01:36:15,216 --> 01:36:16,617
for the presentation, and we

3121
01:36:16,617 --> 01:36:18,419
all had one on ones and

3122
01:36:18,419 --> 01:36:18,578
subcommittees on that. So we

3123
01:36:18,578 --> 01:36:20,578
ve

3124
01:36:21,188 --> 01:36:22,923
seen it many, many times. So

3125
01:36:22,923 --> 01:36:25,270
Good stuff ok at this time ago

3126
01:36:25,270 --> 01:36:25,727
and entertain a motion to

3127
01:36:25,727 --> 01:36:26,128
approve. Oh. I

3128
01:36:26,128 --> 01:36:27,290
m sorry. Um. Do

3129
01:36:27,290 --> 01:36:30,629
we have any public comments on

3130
01:36:31,366 --> 01:36:31,833
this item? No. We don

3131
01:36:31,833 --> 01:36:33,401
t have

3132
01:36:33,401 --> 01:36:35,360
any public comments on this

3133
01:36:35,360 --> 01:36:35,637
item. Okay, Thank you. Um we

3134
01:36:35,637 --> 01:36:36,605
ll

3135
01:36:36,605 --> 01:36:37,906
go ahead and entertain a motion

3136
01:36:37,906 --> 01:36:41,420
to approve. I would like to

3137
01:36:41,420 --> 01:36:44,420
have a little discussion first.

3138
01:36:46,515 --> 01:36:49,285
Of course. Yes. Okay, So, um I

3139
01:36:49,285 --> 01:36:52,285
For reasons a couple more

3140
01:36:52,488 --> 01:36:55,925
agenda items away. Um I think

3141
01:36:55,925 --> 01:36:59,295
we need to start a separate

3142
01:36:59,295 --> 01:37:02,895
Fund for a police station or

3143
01:37:04,467 --> 01:37:06,867
public safety. Um ah.

3144
01:37:07,737 --> 01:37:10,273
Infrastructure. And So ah, And

3145
01:37:10,273 --> 01:37:12,842
while we have these years that

3146
01:37:12,842 --> 01:37:13,510
because if if and when we do

3147
01:37:13,510 --> 01:37:14,444
build a police station, I don

3148
01:37:14,444 --> 01:37:16,112
t

3149
01:37:16,112 --> 01:37:18,215
want to have debt. I want to

3150
01:37:18,215 --> 01:37:19,816
build it for cash, So I want to

3151
01:37:19,816 --> 01:37:23,530
build a fund now, while we have

3152
01:37:23,530 --> 01:37:25,122
the money To, uh, to be able to

3153
01:37:25,122 --> 01:37:25,389
do that, to be able to say, you

3154
01:37:25,389 --> 01:37:27,240
know, we

3155
01:37:27,240 --> 01:37:28,959
ve got the 10 million

3156
01:37:28,959 --> 01:37:30,427
or 15. Whatever it takes to

3157
01:37:30,427 --> 01:37:33,163
build that station. I want to

3158
01:37:33,163 --> 01:37:34,198
be able to, um To have that

3159
01:37:34,198 --> 01:37:34,377
built up and and because I

3160
01:37:34,377 --> 01:37:36,367
don

3161
01:37:36,367 --> 01:37:39,700
t want to put any more debt

3162
01:37:39,700 --> 01:37:42,670
on the city are the citizens

3163
01:37:43,441 --> 01:37:48,241
and so, um I would like to see

3164
01:37:48,880 --> 01:37:53,380
a line item for, uh, a public

3165
01:37:53,380 --> 01:37:53,278
safety infrastructure. Um, you

3166
01:37:53,278 --> 01:37:53,436
know, we own all our fire

3167
01:37:53,436 --> 01:37:53,596
stations. In fact the one we

3168
01:37:53,596 --> 01:37:54,386
don

3169
01:37:54,386 --> 01:37:55,120
t own where we have a

3170
01:37:55,120 --> 01:37:55,387
separate fund Right now we

3171
01:37:55,387 --> 01:37:56,922
re

3172
01:37:56,922 --> 01:37:59,891
building up to buy that when

3173
01:37:59,891 --> 01:38:02,891
the state makes it available,

3174
01:38:04,363 --> 01:38:07,132
So. We have a very robust Fire

3175
01:38:07,132 --> 01:38:07,766
infrastructure, but we have

3176
01:38:07,766 --> 01:38:09,969
literally nothing for police

3177
01:38:09,969 --> 01:38:10,169
other than the new station

3178
01:38:10,169 --> 01:38:12,400
that

3179
01:38:12,400 --> 01:38:14,540
s here in city Hall. Um,

3180
01:38:14,540 --> 01:38:19,340
so I would like to see a fund.

3181
01:38:20,646 --> 01:38:21,347
Um For that. Okay, Fair enough.

3182
01:38:21,347 --> 01:38:21,508
Anyone else think conversation.

3183
01:38:21,508 --> 01:38:22,548
I

3184
01:38:22,548 --> 01:38:22,781
ll. Just add onto that, you

3185
01:38:22,781 --> 01:38:23,716
know it

3186
01:38:23,716 --> 01:38:25,151
s thinking about you

3187
01:38:25,151 --> 01:38:25,451
know how these items are a

3188
01:38:25,451 --> 01:38:26,453
little They

3189
01:38:26,453 --> 01:38:27,654
re tied together,

3190
01:38:27,654 --> 01:38:27,816
obviously, but I do think it

3191
01:38:27,816 --> 01:38:29,816
s

3192
01:38:29,923 --> 01:38:31,191
I Appreciate you bringing that

3193
01:38:31,191 --> 01:38:32,325
for now? Um, because the

3194
01:38:32,325 --> 01:38:34,361
earlier we get on that the

3195
01:38:34,361 --> 01:38:36,960
easier it is on staff and, um

3196
01:38:36,960 --> 01:38:37,397
and if we do go down the road,

3197
01:38:37,397 --> 01:38:38,131
the conversation and I

3198
01:38:38,131 --> 01:38:39,650
ve been

3199
01:38:39,650 --> 01:38:40,200
thinking about, um, you know,

3200
01:38:40,200 --> 01:38:42,602
some funding sources, and I

3201
01:38:42,602 --> 01:38:44,705
think you know, we could look

3202
01:38:44,705 --> 01:38:45,873
to s r o share with tv, usd and

3203
01:38:45,873 --> 01:38:46,707
And. Maybe. That

3204
01:38:46,707 --> 01:38:48,442
s the funding

3205
01:38:48,442 --> 01:38:50,678
source for for something like

3206
01:38:50,678 --> 01:38:52,313
this to to reinvest back in the

3207
01:38:52,313 --> 01:38:55,582
city, So okay, um Thank you

3208
01:38:55,582 --> 01:38:57,417
anything else? No. Okay, so we

3209
01:38:57,417 --> 01:38:57,918
have a motion and a second. Do?

3210
01:38:57,918 --> 01:38:58,986
We. Don

3211
01:38:58,986 --> 01:38:59,587
t think we did

3212
01:38:59,587 --> 01:39:02,587
entertain a motion in the

3213
01:39:02,824 --> 01:39:03,910
second? Promotion I

3214
01:39:03,910 --> 01:39:05,910
ll second.

3215
01:39:15,102 --> 01:39:15,341
Okay, let us vote. Mine didn

3216
01:39:15,341 --> 01:39:17,341
t

3217
01:39:18,706 --> 01:39:18,974
populate. Looks like not

3218
01:39:18,974 --> 01:39:20,974
everyone

3219
01:39:21,210 --> 01:39:22,578
s coming up on the

3220
01:39:22,578 --> 01:39:23,646
screen Council member Brown.

3221
01:39:23,646 --> 01:39:27,246
Are you in the affirmative. Yes.

3222
01:39:30,285 --> 01:39:31,553
Okay. So that passes 50. Okay.

3223
01:39:31,553 --> 01:39:33,622
Thank you. Everyone will move

3224
01:39:33,622 --> 01:39:34,623
to item number 14 is adopted

3225
01:39:34,623 --> 01:39:36,492
resolution submitting to the

3226
01:39:36,492 --> 01:39:37,594
voters a ballot measure that

3227
01:39:37,594 --> 01:39:39,295
proposes to establish term

3228
01:39:39,295 --> 01:39:41,464
limits for City council members

3229
01:39:41,464 --> 01:39:43,232
and maybe have a staff report.

3230
01:39:43,232 --> 01:39:45,935
Please MADAM City clerk. Yes,

3231
01:39:45,935 --> 01:39:46,669
Mr Mayor. Um and we have a

3232
01:39:46,669 --> 01:39:49,669
slide presentation that will go

3233
01:39:50,306 --> 01:39:54,506
ahead and put up. So we are

3234
01:39:55,212 --> 01:39:56,790
back two weeks later with the

3235
01:39:56,790 --> 01:39:58,790
proposed resolution and

3236
01:39:58,749 --> 01:40:00,417
ordinance Next slide, please.

3237
01:40:00,417 --> 01:40:01,685
So as a reminder this city

3238
01:40:01,685 --> 01:40:04,685
Council gave us direction under

3239
01:40:04,788 --> 01:40:06,289
government code section 36 50

3240
01:40:06,289 --> 01:40:09,192
to be which actually permits

3241
01:40:09,192 --> 01:40:11,280
the city Council to go ahead

3242
01:40:11,280 --> 01:40:11,929
and proposed by initiative

3243
01:40:11,929 --> 01:40:13,331
proposal to limit the number of

3244
01:40:13,331 --> 01:40:15,633
terms a member of the City

3245
01:40:15,633 --> 01:40:17,701
Council MAY serve on the city

3246
01:40:17,701 --> 01:40:19,503
Council. Um and any of these

3247
01:40:19,503 --> 01:40:22,503
proposals to limit the number

3248
01:40:23,975 --> 01:40:26,770
of terms. They are applicable

3249
01:40:26,770 --> 01:40:26,245
prospectively only and they

3250
01:40:26,245 --> 01:40:27,278
don

3251
01:40:27,278 --> 01:40:29,114
t become operative unless

3252
01:40:29,114 --> 01:40:30,348
the electors of the city at a

3253
01:40:30,348 --> 01:40:32,117
regularly scheduled election,

3254
01:40:32,117 --> 01:40:34,753
go ahead and pass that so next

3255
01:40:34,753 --> 01:40:37,220
slide, please. So again. The

3256
01:40:37,220 --> 01:40:39,230
four points that we need to be

3257
01:40:39,230 --> 01:40:42,260
aware of. Is that the City

3258
01:40:42,260 --> 01:40:43,461
Council in fact, can propose an

3259
01:40:43,461 --> 01:40:45,300
initiative. The proposal is not

3260
01:40:45,300 --> 01:40:47,433
effective until voted upon and

3261
01:40:47,433 --> 01:40:49,435
passed by the residents by a

3262
01:40:49,435 --> 01:40:51,437
majority. The proposal must be

3263
01:40:51,437 --> 01:40:53,837
on a regularly scheduled

3264
01:40:53,973 --> 01:40:54,640
election, and it is again

3265
01:40:54,640 --> 01:40:56,640
prospectively not retroactively.

3266
01:40:59,278 --> 01:41:02,140
Next slide, please. So, the

3267
01:41:02,140 --> 01:41:04,500
City Council on FEBRUARY 14th

3268
01:41:04,500 --> 01:41:05,952
2023 went ahead and gave staff

3269
01:41:05,952 --> 01:41:08,555
direction to the council did

3270
01:41:08,555 --> 01:41:09,689
wish to have term limits for

3271
01:41:09,689 --> 01:41:12,240
City council members. The

3272
01:41:12,240 --> 01:41:14,160
proposal was to have a term

3273
01:41:14,160 --> 01:41:17,430
limit of three terms four years

3274
01:41:17,430 --> 01:41:20,233
per term for 12 year total. The

3275
01:41:20,233 --> 01:41:21,340
council was fine with breaks in

3276
01:41:21,340 --> 01:41:22,102
the service as long as the 12

3277
01:41:22,102 --> 01:41:25,702
year total was a lifetime limit.

3278
01:41:26,340 --> 01:41:27,841
And. The Council went ahead and

3279
01:41:27,841 --> 01:41:30,241
proposed placement on the

3280
01:41:32,679 --> 01:41:32,980
NOVEMBER 2024 ballot. Two items

3281
01:41:32,980 --> 01:41:33,947
that weren

3282
01:41:33,947 --> 01:41:35,947
t discussed on

3283
01:41:37,351 --> 01:41:39,220
FEBRUARY 14 2023 was

3284
01:41:39,220 --> 01:41:40,455
appointments versus election

3285
01:41:40,455 --> 01:41:42,857
and partial terms. So, the city

3286
01:41:42,857 --> 01:41:43,691
attorney, and I went ahead and

3287
01:41:43,691 --> 01:41:45,293
included standard language

3288
01:41:45,293 --> 01:41:46,940
addressing the two items

3289
01:41:46,940 --> 01:41:48,196
included in the proposed

3290
01:41:48,196 --> 01:41:49,163
ordinance for City Council

3291
01:41:49,163 --> 01:41:50,698
consideration, Of course the

3292
01:41:50,698 --> 01:41:52,333
City Council tonight can give

3293
01:41:52,333 --> 01:41:54,733
us direction otherwise. Next

3294
01:41:55,803 --> 01:41:58,473
slide, please. Now what you

3295
01:41:58,473 --> 01:42:00,709
will see there is on the very

3296
01:42:00,709 --> 01:42:02,210
last sentence, but we have

3297
01:42:02,210 --> 01:42:04,210
incorporated is standard

3298
01:42:04,513 --> 01:42:07,249
language from other cities that

3299
01:42:07,249 --> 01:42:08,830
address partial terms and

3300
01:42:08,830 --> 01:42:09,718
appointments versus election.

3301
01:42:09,718 --> 01:42:12,821
So. What we have mentioned is

3302
01:42:12,821 --> 01:42:15,240
if any person is appointed or

3303
01:42:15,240 --> 01:42:16,859
elected to a partial term of

3304
01:42:16,859 --> 01:42:18,728
office of two years or less

3305
01:42:18,728 --> 01:42:19,362
that the term shall be shall

3306
01:42:19,362 --> 01:42:22,164
not be counted towards the

3307
01:42:22,164 --> 01:42:24,233
three Term limits. So in other

3308
01:42:24,233 --> 01:42:26,368
words, if you have occupied the

3309
01:42:26,368 --> 01:42:28,370
seat for two years or less,

3310
01:42:28,370 --> 01:42:28,838
regardless of whether it is an

3311
01:42:28,838 --> 01:42:30,272
appointment, or regardless of

3312
01:42:30,272 --> 01:42:31,241
whether it is an election, it

3313
01:42:31,241 --> 01:42:34,841
will not count towards the term

3314
01:42:35,211 --> 01:42:35,912
limits. And again That is

3315
01:42:35,912 --> 01:42:38,312
pretty standard language. Next

3316
01:42:38,815 --> 01:42:40,350
slide, please. So for next

3317
01:42:40,350 --> 01:42:41,818
steps. Um, what we will be

3318
01:42:41,818 --> 01:42:44,854
asking is that the City Council

3319
01:42:44,854 --> 01:42:45,522
go ahead and adopt the proposed

3320
01:42:45,522 --> 01:42:47,522
resolution regarding term

3321
01:42:47,891 --> 01:42:49,393
limits. We will go ahead and

3322
01:42:49,393 --> 01:42:50,261
notify the Riverside, Riverside

3323
01:42:50,261 --> 01:42:52,129
County registrar of voters that

3324
01:42:52,129 --> 01:42:55,266
we will have a local ballot

3325
01:42:55,266 --> 01:42:57,666
measure on the NOVEMBER 2024

3326
01:42:58,350 --> 01:43:00,370
ballot we will in the summer of

3327
01:43:00,370 --> 01:43:01,471
2024 when we consolidate our

3328
01:43:01,471 --> 01:43:03,307
General municipal election. We

3329
01:43:03,307 --> 01:43:05,175
will also consolidate the local

3330
01:43:05,175 --> 01:43:05,976
ballot measure election at that

3331
01:43:05,976 --> 01:43:08,546
time, the term limit measure

3332
01:43:08,546 --> 01:43:11,115
will be voted upon by the

3333
01:43:11,115 --> 01:43:12,817
residents of Temecula in

3334
01:43:12,817 --> 01:43:14,319
NOVEMBER 2024. If, a majority

3335
01:43:14,319 --> 01:43:16,200
of the voters pass it. The

3336
01:43:16,200 --> 01:43:17,588
measure will go into effect, 10

3337
01:43:17,588 --> 01:43:18,957
days after the City Council

3338
01:43:18,957 --> 01:43:21,893
declares the results of the

3339
01:43:21,893 --> 01:43:22,293
NOVEMBER 5th 2024 election.

3340
01:43:22,293 --> 01:43:23,562
Typically. That

3341
01:43:23,562 --> 01:43:24,663
s after a 30

3342
01:43:24,663 --> 01:43:25,970
Day canvas period, so it

3343
01:43:25,970 --> 01:43:26,999
s at

3344
01:43:26,999 --> 01:43:28,700
that first meeting in DECEMBER.

3345
01:43:28,700 --> 01:43:31,103
Where we declare our results

3346
01:43:31,103 --> 01:43:33,710
and then it would be effective

3347
01:43:33,710 --> 01:43:33,739
10 days after so that concludes

3348
01:43:33,739 --> 01:43:34,139
Staffs presentation, and we

3349
01:43:34,139 --> 01:43:35,874
re

3350
01:43:35,874 --> 01:43:37,242
happy to ask any answer any

3351
01:43:37,242 --> 01:43:39,770
questions or take any further

3352
01:43:39,770 --> 01:43:40,412
direction that you would like.

3353
01:43:40,412 --> 01:43:41,748
Okay. Thank you any questions

3354
01:43:41,748 --> 01:43:43,683
of staff from City Council? I

3355
01:43:43,683 --> 01:43:44,750
have one question just popped

3356
01:43:44,750 --> 01:43:46,486
up. Actually. I know we had a

3357
01:43:46,486 --> 01:43:47,186
good discussion about this

3358
01:43:47,186 --> 01:43:50,186
earlier. I. Guess my question

3359
01:43:50,556 --> 01:43:54,260
is Since a term limit is, I

3360
01:43:54,260 --> 01:43:54,927
guess, two years and above,

3361
01:43:54,927 --> 01:43:55,895
right? What if somebody was to

3362
01:43:55,895 --> 01:43:56,362
do let

3363
01:43:56,362 --> 01:43:58,865
s say six months or a

3364
01:43:58,865 --> 01:44:00,633
year How many times. Can they

3365
01:44:00,633 --> 01:44:02,302
do that. So if we have somebody

3366
01:44:02,302 --> 01:44:02,471
that comes in, for instance,

3367
01:44:02,471 --> 01:44:03,704
let

3368
01:44:03,704 --> 01:44:04,805
s say they get appointed

3369
01:44:04,805 --> 01:44:05,376
for a year and then let

3370
01:44:05,376 --> 01:44:06,373
s say,

3371
01:44:06,373 --> 01:44:08,410
maybe GOD forbid the next time

3372
01:44:08,410 --> 01:44:09,209
they get sick or something

3373
01:44:09,209 --> 01:44:10,644
happens. Do we also want to put

3374
01:44:10,644 --> 01:44:11,611
a limit on how many times they

3375
01:44:11,611 --> 01:44:12,779
can come back within that

3376
01:44:12,779 --> 01:44:15,150
shorter amount of time of the

3377
01:44:15,150 --> 01:44:18,615
two years. Does that make sense?

3378
01:44:22,156 --> 01:44:23,491
Um. It does we? That seems like

3379
01:44:23,491 --> 01:44:23,824
a very rare occurrence so far

3380
01:44:23,824 --> 01:44:24,125
in this city

3381
01:44:24,125 --> 01:44:25,392
s history, we

3382
01:44:25,392 --> 01:44:27,940
ve

3383
01:44:27,940 --> 01:44:28,262
pretty much just had a vacancy

3384
01:44:28,262 --> 01:44:29,563
occurs because the council

3385
01:44:29,563 --> 01:44:31,365
member is appointed to higher

3386
01:44:31,365 --> 01:44:32,733
office where there might be a

3387
01:44:32,733 --> 01:44:33,501
resignation of Stewart

3388
01:44:33,501 --> 01:44:33,702
s. We

3389
01:44:33,702 --> 01:44:35,702
haven

3390
01:44:35,937 --> 01:44:38,600
t had the experience, nor

3391
01:44:38,600 --> 01:44:39,741
am I aware of cities that

3392
01:44:39,741 --> 01:44:40,742
routinely have an experience

3393
01:44:40,742 --> 01:44:43,142
with multiple appointments of

3394
01:44:43,277 --> 01:44:44,446
the same person. If the council

3395
01:44:44,446 --> 01:44:45,180
would like to give us direction

3396
01:44:45,180 --> 01:44:46,348
on that we

3397
01:44:46,348 --> 01:44:46,614
re happy to take it.

3398
01:44:46,614 --> 01:44:47,150
And that

3399
01:44:47,150 --> 01:44:47,582
s the thing I

3400
01:44:47,582 --> 01:44:48,583
ve never

3401
01:44:48,583 --> 01:44:50,285
heard of that. I

3402
01:44:50,285 --> 01:44:52,285
m just saying,

3403
01:44:53,622 --> 01:44:54,423
like the there you go like the

3404
01:44:54,423 --> 01:44:55,958
what if, And so what if we just

3405
01:44:55,958 --> 01:44:56,892
put it in there and just say

3406
01:44:56,892 --> 01:44:59,795
Okay, this is maybe you can do

3407
01:44:59,795 --> 01:45:00,129
one of those and or whatever we

3408
01:45:00,129 --> 01:45:01,163
decide. Don

3409
01:45:01,163 --> 01:45:01,396
t. I don

3410
01:45:01,396 --> 01:45:01,797
t see the

3411
01:45:01,797 --> 01:45:02,597
need and we don

3412
01:45:02,597 --> 01:45:03,332
t have to. I

3413
01:45:03,332 --> 01:45:04,933
just thought of it. I was like,

3414
01:45:04,933 --> 01:45:05,601
I just want to make sure we

3415
01:45:05,601 --> 01:45:06,168
re

3416
01:45:06,168 --> 01:45:06,602
covering all bases. I

3417
01:45:06,602 --> 01:45:07,970
especially if you

3418
01:45:07,970 --> 01:45:09,572
ve got a

3419
01:45:09,572 --> 01:45:10,439
really qualified candidate like

3420
01:45:10,439 --> 01:45:12,208
a gene Wonderlic to be able to

3421
01:45:12,208 --> 01:45:14,477
come in and fill that gap until

3422
01:45:14,477 --> 01:45:16,913
the next election cycle. Why,

3423
01:45:16,913 --> 01:45:18,214
not keep using them. I mean or

3424
01:45:18,214 --> 01:45:18,372
her So, for instance, Maybe I

3425
01:45:18,372 --> 01:45:19,682
m

3426
01:45:19,682 --> 01:45:20,116
Just not explaining myself,

3427
01:45:20,116 --> 01:45:21,840
Right? So. Let

3428
01:45:21,840 --> 01:45:22,852
s say I get

3429
01:45:22,852 --> 01:45:26,452
appointed for a year. Okay, Um

3430
01:45:27,157 --> 01:45:28,250
and then I come back in and I

3431
01:45:28,250 --> 01:45:30,994
get elected because I I was I

3432
01:45:30,994 --> 01:45:31,895
did that great of a job and

3433
01:45:31,895 --> 01:45:33,430
then I get sick and then so I

3434
01:45:33,430 --> 01:45:35,650
like I have to take myself off

3435
01:45:35,650 --> 01:45:36,533
the dais because of whatever

3436
01:45:36,533 --> 01:45:38,201
illness or whatever that MAY be,

3437
01:45:38,201 --> 01:45:39,970
And, then I want to run again.

3438
01:45:39,970 --> 01:45:41,171
Like. How is are we? Are? We

3439
01:45:41,171 --> 01:45:42,380
okay with that to let them

3440
01:45:42,380 --> 01:45:42,205
continue to run, And if we are,

3441
01:45:42,205 --> 01:45:44,205
it

3442
01:45:44,409 --> 01:45:48,790
s fine. I just want to just

3443
01:45:48,790 --> 01:45:48,913
take a look at that. So okay

3444
01:45:48,913 --> 01:45:50,381
running, then just keep running.

3445
01:45:50,381 --> 01:45:50,548
I. Just. Want to make sure that

3446
01:45:50,548 --> 01:45:52,548
we

3447
01:45:52,984 --> 01:45:53,150
re covering all bases so we

3448
01:45:53,150 --> 01:45:54,552
can

3449
01:45:54,552 --> 01:45:55,987
t cover. Obviously, every

3450
01:45:55,987 --> 01:45:56,287
situation that ever comes up.

3451
01:45:56,287 --> 01:45:56,888
But if it

3452
01:45:56,888 --> 01:45:57,154
s less than two years,

3453
01:45:57,154 --> 01:45:58,189
and that

3454
01:45:58,189 --> 01:45:58,489
s what we decide on. I

3455
01:45:58,489 --> 01:45:59,156
think that

3456
01:45:59,156 --> 01:46:01,156
s totally fine.

3457
01:46:01,760 --> 01:46:03,829
Sounds good. Okay. Any other

3458
01:46:03,829 --> 01:46:05,797
questions of staff. Okay. If,

3459
01:46:05,797 --> 01:46:06,465
Not. Are there any public

3460
01:46:06,465 --> 01:46:07,332
comments on this item? There

3461
01:46:07,332 --> 01:46:08,900
are no public comments on this

3462
01:46:08,900 --> 01:46:10,168
item. We did have public

3463
01:46:10,168 --> 01:46:12,204
comments that were incorporated

3464
01:46:12,204 --> 01:46:12,704
on this item from previous

3465
01:46:12,704 --> 01:46:13,939
comments. Alright, we

3466
01:46:13,939 --> 01:46:14,639
ll go and

3467
01:46:14,639 --> 01:46:17,242
entertain a motion and a second.

3468
01:46:17,242 --> 01:46:20,842
I will motion second. Let us

3469
01:46:31,523 --> 01:46:31,690
vote. Council member brand.

3470
01:46:31,690 --> 01:46:33,580
It

3471
01:46:33,580 --> 01:46:36,696
s not working. Is it in the

3472
01:46:36,696 --> 01:46:37,330
affirmative, affirmative. Okay,

3473
01:46:37,330 --> 01:46:39,666
that passes 50. Thank you,

3474
01:46:39,666 --> 01:46:40,800
Everybody. All right, moving on

3475
01:46:40,800 --> 01:46:42,369
to our departmental reports.

3476
01:46:42,369 --> 01:46:44,270
These are all receiving file

3477
01:46:44,270 --> 01:46:45,572
will move to our items for

3478
01:46:45,572 --> 01:46:46,773
future agendas. Item, number

3479
01:46:46,773 --> 01:46:48,274
one is considered creation of

3480
01:46:48,274 --> 01:46:50,109
ad hoc subcommittee to discuss

3481
01:46:50,109 --> 01:46:51,411
to make the police department

3482
01:46:51,411 --> 01:46:55,611
at the request of Mayor pro Tim

3483
01:46:55,716 --> 01:46:57,851
Stewart. Alright MISTER Mr

3484
01:46:57,851 --> 01:47:00,851
Mayor. We have several public

3485
01:47:01,789 --> 01:47:04,692
comments on all of these and we

3486
01:47:04,692 --> 01:47:06,960
do have a total limit of 15

3487
01:47:06,960 --> 01:47:08,929
minutes. So can we go ahead and

3488
01:47:08,929 --> 01:47:10,932
here just from all four

3489
01:47:10,932 --> 01:47:13,401
speakers at this point that are

3490
01:47:13,401 --> 01:47:13,601
in person? Um. If that is the

3491
01:47:13,601 --> 01:47:14,169
mayor

3492
01:47:14,169 --> 01:47:17,138
s. Well, That Seems a

3493
01:47:17,138 --> 01:47:19,700
reasonable okay. Um. So at this

3494
01:47:19,700 --> 01:47:22,607
point, I will go ahead and

3495
01:47:22,643 --> 01:47:24,780
again. All the speakers have

3496
01:47:24,780 --> 01:47:24,345
Three minutes each, so we

3497
01:47:24,345 --> 01:47:26,345
ll

3498
01:47:26,847 --> 01:47:29,847
have Laurel Lamont to be

3499
01:47:32,554 --> 01:47:32,789
followed by Briana Mason. Hi so

3500
01:47:32,789 --> 01:47:34,789
I

3501
01:47:36,158 --> 01:47:37,693
m just here to encourage vote

3502
01:47:37,693 --> 01:47:38,860
for yes to place affordable

3503
01:47:38,860 --> 01:47:41,860
housing rent control on the

3504
01:47:43,598 --> 01:47:44,199
agenda. Going forward. I don

3505
01:47:44,199 --> 01:47:46,199
t

3506
01:47:47,403 --> 01:47:48,971
see us taking any extreme

3507
01:47:48,971 --> 01:47:51,240
action to help renters right

3508
01:47:51,240 --> 01:47:53,750
now. Obviously I show up for

3509
01:47:53,750 --> 01:47:55,750
attainable homeownership often.

3510
01:47:55,978 --> 01:47:56,145
And all things housing. We

3511
01:47:56,145 --> 01:47:57,546
re

3512
01:47:57,546 --> 01:47:58,748
drowning out here, and there

3513
01:47:58,748 --> 01:48:00,748
s

3514
01:48:01,283 --> 01:48:02,918
no sense of urgency and I know

3515
01:48:02,918 --> 01:48:04,888
city staff is designed to

3516
01:48:04,888 --> 01:48:05,500
advise you because you can

3517
01:48:05,500 --> 01:48:06,690
t

3518
01:48:06,690 --> 01:48:07,357
know everything if you need to

3519
01:48:07,357 --> 01:48:10,193
borrow some housing books have

3520
01:48:10,193 --> 01:48:10,460
plenty I can lend out. Um, but

3521
01:48:10,460 --> 01:48:11,528
you can

3522
01:48:11,528 --> 01:48:13,928
t know everything. So,

3523
01:48:13,930 --> 01:48:15,899
you have to rely on city staff.

3524
01:48:15,899 --> 01:48:16,599
Please do not take it to a

3525
01:48:16,599 --> 01:48:18,902
subcommittee. Please Do not let

3526
01:48:18,902 --> 01:48:21,405
it go to a subcommittee to sit

3527
01:48:21,405 --> 01:48:23,741
for a year. We Need Renters

3528
01:48:23,741 --> 01:48:23,902
need action Now we need we

3529
01:48:23,902 --> 01:48:25,843
re

3530
01:48:25,843 --> 01:48:26,844
long out before ever owning a

3531
01:48:26,844 --> 01:48:29,480
home here if ever going to be

3532
01:48:29,480 --> 01:48:29,680
able to own a home here and

3533
01:48:29,680 --> 01:48:30,180
there

3534
01:48:30,180 --> 01:48:31,248
s no home security and

3535
01:48:31,248 --> 01:48:32,490
rent There

3536
01:48:32,490 --> 01:48:34,449
s no home security

3537
01:48:35,452 --> 01:48:36,954
in it. We

3538
01:48:36,954 --> 01:48:39,570
ve created the access

3539
01:48:39,570 --> 01:48:41,860
to the lesser earning workforce

3540
01:48:41,860 --> 01:48:44,529
in the employment we have not

3541
01:48:44,529 --> 01:48:46,364
built for those employees. We

3542
01:48:46,364 --> 01:48:48,400
need some housing, security

3543
01:48:48,400 --> 01:48:49,367
housing security is exists in

3544
01:48:49,367 --> 01:48:49,734
affordable housing, rent

3545
01:48:49,734 --> 01:48:50,869
control. That

3546
01:48:50,869 --> 01:48:51,300
s a start. Let

3547
01:48:51,300 --> 01:48:53,300
s

3548
01:48:53,370 --> 01:48:53,205
please put it on the agenda.

3549
01:48:53,205 --> 01:48:55,205
Let

3550
01:48:55,708 --> 01:48:59,308
s not push it to a

3551
01:48:59,611 --> 01:49:00,445
subcommittee. Your staff is not

3552
01:49:00,445 --> 01:49:02,815
recognizing Erin Adams told me

3553
01:49:02,815 --> 01:49:04,950
in an email when the concerts

3554
01:49:04,950 --> 01:49:05,818
happened that you know where I

3555
01:49:05,818 --> 01:49:06,180
live was a choice. It

3556
01:49:06,180 --> 01:49:08,180
s not a

3557
01:49:09,221 --> 01:49:12,221
choice. We have an affordable

3558
01:49:12,458 --> 01:49:12,624
overlay zone for a reason. We

3559
01:49:12,624 --> 01:49:14,561
don

3560
01:49:14,561 --> 01:49:15,562
t have equitable housing

3561
01:49:15,562 --> 01:49:17,300
within your pretty pre planned

3562
01:49:17,300 --> 01:49:17,296
communities. I

3563
01:49:17,296 --> 01:49:17,597
ve seen it

3564
01:49:17,597 --> 01:49:19,597
before. I

3565
01:49:19,699 --> 01:49:19,866
m saying it again.

3566
01:49:19,866 --> 01:49:21,167
We

3567
01:49:21,167 --> 01:49:21,367
re not included. We

3568
01:49:21,367 --> 01:49:23,367
ve been

3569
01:49:23,936 --> 01:49:24,370
excluded. We weren

3570
01:49:24,370 --> 01:49:26,370
t

3571
01:49:27,940 --> 01:49:28,107
incorporated in the design.

3572
01:49:28,107 --> 01:49:29,208
Let

3573
01:49:29,208 --> 01:49:29,375
s talk about the start.

3574
01:49:29,375 --> 01:49:31,144
Let

3575
01:49:31,144 --> 01:49:31,311
s give us housing security.

3576
01:49:31,311 --> 01:49:33,311
Let

3577
01:49:33,513 --> 01:49:33,780
s put it on the agenda and

3578
01:49:33,780 --> 01:49:35,349
then let

3579
01:49:35,349 --> 01:49:37,749
s start talking about

3580
01:49:38,618 --> 01:49:39,219
attainable home ownership and

3581
01:49:39,219 --> 01:49:40,554
equitable opportunities in

3582
01:49:40,554 --> 01:49:43,554
existence of housing. And home

3583
01:49:43,890 --> 01:49:44,191
ownership. That

3584
01:49:44,191 --> 01:49:46,191
s my public

3585
01:49:47,828 --> 01:49:49,960
comment. Thank you. Thank you

3586
01:49:49,960 --> 01:49:52,960
next speaker. The. Next speaker

3587
01:49:53,000 --> 01:49:55,400
is Brianna Mason. Welcome.

3588
01:49:55,503 --> 01:49:56,304
Hello. Um, I

3589
01:49:56,304 --> 01:49:57,672
m going to

3590
01:49:57,672 --> 01:50:00,941
introduce myself as a person to

3591
01:50:00,941 --> 01:50:01,208
you before I make a demand. I

3592
01:50:01,208 --> 01:50:03,208
m,

3593
01:50:03,544 --> 01:50:03,706
a longtime resident of Temecula.

3594
01:50:03,706 --> 01:50:04,912
I

3595
01:50:04,912 --> 01:50:06,214
m, also resident in the old

3596
01:50:06,214 --> 01:50:07,916
town to make low affordable

3597
01:50:07,916 --> 01:50:09,916
housing. I

3598
01:50:10,850 --> 01:50:10,652
m, a single mother

3599
01:50:10,652 --> 01:50:10,952
to a disabled child. I

3600
01:50:10,952 --> 01:50:12,687
m a

3601
01:50:12,687 --> 01:50:15,457
caregiver to my 88 year old

3602
01:50:15,457 --> 01:50:16,591
grandmother. Um. I

3603
01:50:16,591 --> 01:50:16,925
m in social

3604
01:50:16,925 --> 01:50:18,393
work I

3605
01:50:18,393 --> 01:50:19,928
ve actually served for

3606
01:50:19,928 --> 01:50:22,328
child protective services here

3607
01:50:22,630 --> 01:50:22,797
for seven years in Temecula if

3608
01:50:22,797 --> 01:50:24,400
you

3609
01:50:24,400 --> 01:50:25,734
ve had Children or

3610
01:50:25,734 --> 01:50:27,203
grandchildren, and this goes

3611
01:50:27,203 --> 01:50:27,603
out, and I

3612
01:50:27,603 --> 01:50:29,471
ve probably service

3613
01:50:29,471 --> 01:50:31,173
their classmates helped their

3614
01:50:31,173 --> 01:50:33,420
parents to get over obstacles.

3615
01:50:33,420 --> 01:50:35,442
Mental health issues. Substance

3616
01:50:36,512 --> 01:50:37,813
abuse. Um Currently I work

3617
01:50:37,813 --> 01:50:39,315
under grant for the Office of

3618
01:50:39,315 --> 01:50:39,478
victims of crime, So. I

3619
01:50:39,478 --> 01:50:40,415
m

3620
01:50:40,415 --> 01:50:42,815
helping our community members

3621
01:50:42,919 --> 01:50:43,553
who are victims of various

3622
01:50:43,553 --> 01:50:45,553
crimes, domestic violence,

3623
01:50:46,956 --> 01:50:47,890
things like tha. Um. I want to

3624
01:50:47,890 --> 01:50:49,826
empower members of our

3625
01:50:49,826 --> 01:50:50,693
community and I need to start

3626
01:50:50,693 --> 01:50:51,270
with myself. I

3627
01:50:51,270 --> 01:50:52,495
m Very nervous

3628
01:50:52,495 --> 01:50:55,298
right now, So I apologize, but

3629
01:50:55,298 --> 01:50:57,634
I need to start with myself. Um

3630
01:50:57,634 --> 01:50:59,360
no one gets into social work

3631
01:50:59,360 --> 01:50:59,536
for the money. We all know that

3632
01:50:59,536 --> 01:51:01,380
And. I

3633
01:51:01,380 --> 01:51:02,572
m not rich in money, but

3634
01:51:02,572 --> 01:51:05,742
I am rich and how I care for

3635
01:51:05,742 --> 01:51:06,510
others and how I care for my

3636
01:51:06,510 --> 01:51:08,450
community. My special needs son

3637
01:51:08,450 --> 01:51:10,180
and I currently live in a

3638
01:51:10,180 --> 01:51:12,580
roughly 500 square foot, one

3639
01:51:12,649 --> 01:51:13,951
bedroom apartment. And. We soon

3640
01:51:13,951 --> 01:51:17,288
MAY not be able to afford even

3641
01:51:17,288 --> 01:51:18,790
living there. I represent a

3642
01:51:18,790 --> 01:51:19,223
social class who It

3643
01:51:19,223 --> 01:51:20,858
s taking

3644
01:51:20,858 --> 01:51:23,610
care of our Children, but also

3645
01:51:23,610 --> 01:51:26,430
taking care of our parents and

3646
01:51:26,430 --> 01:51:27,832
our grandparents. Excuse me.

3647
01:51:27,832 --> 01:51:28,266
And. We

3648
01:51:28,266 --> 01:51:31,266
re doing the best we

3649
01:51:32,970 --> 01:51:33,672
can. With an economy that is

3650
01:51:33,672 --> 01:51:37,109
working against us. It is no

3651
01:51:37,109 --> 01:51:38,143
longer Good for us to even go

3652
01:51:38,143 --> 01:51:40,545
to college. What is the point.

3653
01:51:40,545 --> 01:51:41,179
We come out with student debt.

3654
01:51:41,179 --> 01:51:42,130
And then we can

3655
01:51:42,130 --> 01:51:43,115
t even afford a

3656
01:51:43,115 --> 01:51:43,276
home in the community we

3657
01:51:43,276 --> 01:51:45,276
ve

3658
01:51:45,884 --> 01:51:46,251
grown up in So I

3659
01:51:46,251 --> 01:51:48,251
m asking that

3660
01:51:50,756 --> 01:51:52,591
you add Rent control and

3661
01:51:52,591 --> 01:51:52,758
affordable housing. Please.

3662
01:51:52,758 --> 01:51:53,626
We

3663
01:51:53,626 --> 01:51:55,127
re begging you. We are not

3664
01:51:55,127 --> 01:51:57,329
here with our hands out asking

3665
01:51:57,329 --> 01:51:59,650
for anything. We are just

3666
01:51:59,650 --> 01:52:01,734
asking to be able to live here

3667
01:52:01,734 --> 01:52:05,237
and we are not And a social

3668
01:52:05,237 --> 01:52:06,505
class right now. We are too

3669
01:52:06,505 --> 01:52:09,209
rich for assistance. But, we

3670
01:52:09,209 --> 01:52:12,809
are 24 poor to afford a home

3671
01:52:14,714 --> 01:52:18,314
here to rent here. Please help

3672
01:52:20,320 --> 01:52:22,155
us. Please help us. Thank you.

3673
01:52:22,155 --> 01:52:23,890
Specter here. The. Next speaker

3674
01:52:23,890 --> 01:52:28,900
is Brian Nash to be followed by

3675
01:52:31,832 --> 01:52:32,132
Daniel Kit. Welcome. How

3676
01:52:32,132 --> 01:52:32,833
s it

3677
01:52:32,833 --> 01:52:33,500
going? Um? I

3678
01:52:33,500 --> 01:52:35,900
m not gonna top

3679
01:52:36,360 --> 01:52:37,571
that. Thank you for being so

3680
01:52:37,571 --> 01:52:40,541
honest about all of this, Um

3681
01:52:40,541 --> 01:52:40,808
Jessica You said a few minutes

3682
01:52:40,808 --> 01:52:42,900
ago. It

3683
01:52:42,900 --> 01:52:45,900
s nice that the police

3684
01:52:46,470 --> 01:52:47,749
have somewhere Close to home

3685
01:52:47,749 --> 01:52:49,684
that they can spend, um, you

3686
01:52:49,684 --> 01:52:52,120
know, between work and home in

3687
01:52:52,120 --> 01:52:52,320
regard to the police station.

3688
01:52:52,320 --> 01:52:53,388
That

3689
01:52:53,388 --> 01:52:56,388
s what these guys are

3690
01:52:57,191 --> 01:52:57,358
asking for as well. Um, so

3691
01:52:57,358 --> 01:52:57,925
let

3692
01:52:57,925 --> 01:52:59,561
s talk around control. Got

3693
01:52:59,561 --> 01:52:59,722
an m b a from a top school.

3694
01:52:59,722 --> 01:53:01,722
I

3695
01:53:02,231 --> 01:53:02,765
ve spent my career in

3696
01:53:02,765 --> 01:53:03,532
financial services. I

3697
01:53:03,532 --> 01:53:05,868
understand investments as well

3698
01:53:05,868 --> 01:53:07,436
as anybody in this room. I get

3699
01:53:07,436 --> 01:53:07,803
why rent control feels like

3700
01:53:07,803 --> 01:53:08,837
something that

3701
01:53:08,837 --> 01:53:09,605
s challenging.

3702
01:53:09,605 --> 01:53:11,740
Something to bury in a

3703
01:53:11,740 --> 01:53:14,140
subcommittee. Something to do

3704
01:53:14,209 --> 01:53:15,711
away with this quickly and

3705
01:53:15,711 --> 01:53:16,312
quietly as possible, but

3706
01:53:16,312 --> 01:53:18,140
investments sometimes takes

3707
01:53:18,140 --> 01:53:20,683
formal ways We might not

3708
01:53:20,683 --> 01:53:21,884
necessarily consider By

3709
01:53:21,884 --> 01:53:24,284
imposing rent controls you

3710
01:53:27,356 --> 01:53:28,570
invest in our communities. You.

3711
01:53:28,570 --> 01:53:29,258
Invest our small businesses.

3712
01:53:29,258 --> 01:53:30,493
Hell even in the mega

3713
01:53:30,493 --> 01:53:33,229
corporations that make up a lot

3714
01:53:33,229 --> 01:53:34,697
of this area. Simply by helping

3715
01:53:34,697 --> 01:53:35,766
to provide all ready and

3716
01:53:35,766 --> 01:53:38,166
willing workforce proximal to

3717
01:53:38,869 --> 01:53:39,870
the people that they serve. We

3718
01:53:39,870 --> 01:53:41,304
already see the downsides of a

3719
01:53:41,304 --> 01:53:43,473
lack of run control. You

3720
01:53:43,473 --> 01:53:45,800
literally just saw it. People

3721
01:53:45,800 --> 01:53:46,276
are traveling from all over the

3722
01:53:46,276 --> 01:53:46,441
place to work jobs that can

3723
01:53:46,441 --> 01:53:48,245
t

3724
01:53:48,245 --> 01:53:48,445
cover their bills. While.

3725
01:53:48,445 --> 01:53:50,445
There

3726
01:53:50,480 --> 01:53:52,315
s some that MAY happily

3727
01:53:52,315 --> 01:53:53,617
boast about driving from GOD

3728
01:53:53,617 --> 01:53:56,617
knows where in California to

3729
01:53:57,822 --> 01:53:58,756
for a job. Who does that now?

3730
01:53:58,756 --> 01:53:58,929
The math just sometimes doesn

3731
01:53:58,929 --> 01:54:00,929
t

3732
01:54:02,260 --> 01:54:03,527
work. So. What happens? Workers

3733
01:54:03,527 --> 01:54:05,529
drop out of the labor force,

3734
01:54:05,529 --> 01:54:07,310
and we all feel it. This means

3735
01:54:07,310 --> 01:54:09,433
it takes longer for any of us

3736
01:54:09,433 --> 01:54:11,135
to get anything done. How. Much

3737
01:54:11,135 --> 01:54:12,370
productivity are each of us

3738
01:54:12,370 --> 01:54:14,406
losing every single week

3739
01:54:14,406 --> 01:54:15,440
waiting just a simple extra

3740
01:54:15,440 --> 01:54:18,440
couple minutes a day at

3741
01:54:19,177 --> 01:54:21,112
Starbucks or wherever As, the

3742
01:54:21,112 --> 01:54:23,581
man who took the man with the

3743
01:54:23,581 --> 01:54:24,849
yellow hat on his spirit Quest

3744
01:54:24,849 --> 01:54:27,352
in curious George, Very monkey,

3745
01:54:27,352 --> 01:54:27,552
Christmas, sai. It

3746
01:54:27,552 --> 01:54:29,210
s about

3747
01:54:29,210 --> 01:54:31,357
time. Time is an investment.

3748
01:54:31,357 --> 01:54:31,590
None of us think too much about

3749
01:54:31,590 --> 01:54:33,525
But it

3750
01:54:33,525 --> 01:54:34,293
s super important. More

3751
01:54:34,293 --> 01:54:35,394
time means more gets done,

3752
01:54:35,394 --> 01:54:35,561
which is good for all of us.

3753
01:54:35,561 --> 01:54:37,496
It

3754
01:54:37,496 --> 01:54:38,630
s good for Temecula. Let

3755
01:54:38,630 --> 01:54:39,999
s

3756
01:54:39,999 --> 01:54:40,699
also talk briefly about

3757
01:54:40,699 --> 01:54:42,501
Temecula, as young people were

3758
01:54:42,501 --> 01:54:43,402
aware of the brain drain that

3759
01:54:43,402 --> 01:54:44,636
happens after kids graduate

3760
01:54:44,636 --> 01:54:45,705
from high school around here or

3761
01:54:45,705 --> 01:54:47,273
maybe even a couple of years of

3762
01:54:47,273 --> 01:54:47,436
tuition Free college. Wouldn

3763
01:54:47,436 --> 01:54:49,436
t

3764
01:54:49,642 --> 01:54:52,312
be rad if we actually attracted

3765
01:54:52,312 --> 01:54:53,346
them to stay. And build

3766
01:54:53,346 --> 01:54:54,547
businesses or careers locally,

3767
01:54:54,547 --> 01:54:56,849
something that we have failed

3768
01:54:56,849 --> 01:54:58,617
miserably at forever. And all

3769
01:54:58,617 --> 01:55:01,487
it takes is actually making the

3770
01:55:01,487 --> 01:55:02,221
area remotely affordable. But

3771
01:55:02,221 --> 01:55:03,257
again. I know investing. I know

3772
01:55:03,257 --> 01:55:05,192
what people want to see? So

3773
01:55:05,192 --> 01:55:07,594
here we go. Rent control can

3774
01:55:07,594 --> 01:55:10,197
mean $5200 per year per person

3775
01:55:10,197 --> 01:55:11,498
per commuter. Imagine what the

3776
01:55:11,498 --> 01:55:13,567
people could do with that.

3777
01:55:13,567 --> 01:55:14,901
Think of the benefits to say

3778
01:55:14,901 --> 01:55:16,370
all down Temecula restaurants.

3779
01:55:16,370 --> 01:55:17,904
The Economic benefit is

3780
01:55:17,904 --> 01:55:18,805
undeniable if you wish to look

3781
01:55:18,805 --> 01:55:21,442
beyond a handful of wealthy

3782
01:55:21,442 --> 01:55:22,910
investors. So before we bury

3783
01:55:22,910 --> 01:55:23,411
rent control in some nebulous

3784
01:55:23,411 --> 01:55:23,644
committee. I think it

3785
01:55:23,644 --> 01:55:24,612
s

3786
01:55:24,612 --> 01:55:25,780
important that we actually

3787
01:55:25,780 --> 01:55:26,814
consider the trade off that

3788
01:55:26,814 --> 01:55:28,749
will lack around control

3789
01:55:28,749 --> 01:55:30,251
actually has on the growth of

3790
01:55:30,251 --> 01:55:30,451
Temecula. I believe it

3791
01:55:30,451 --> 01:55:32,451
s worth

3792
01:55:33,420 --> 01:55:34,922
serious consideration. Thanks.

3793
01:55:34,922 --> 01:55:36,257
Thank you next speaker are last

3794
01:55:36,257 --> 01:55:39,857
in person speaker is Daniel Kit.

3795
01:55:51,239 --> 01:55:52,374
Welcome. Good Evening. City

3796
01:55:52,374 --> 01:55:54,175
Council members, Mr Mayor Mayor

3797
01:55:54,175 --> 01:55:55,811
Pro tem and city staff. Thank

3798
01:55:55,811 --> 01:55:57,460
you for giving me this

3799
01:55:57,460 --> 01:55:58,748
opportunity to speak with you

3800
01:55:58,748 --> 01:56:00,820
this evening regarding the

3801
01:56:00,820 --> 01:56:00,816
formation of the ad hoc

3802
01:56:00,816 --> 01:56:03,190
committee to form a standalone

3803
01:56:03,190 --> 01:56:03,686
fire department. My name is

3804
01:56:03,686 --> 01:56:05,187
Daniel Kit and I

3805
01:56:05,187 --> 01:56:06,722
m, one of the

3806
01:56:06,722 --> 01:56:07,590
deputy district vice presidents

3807
01:56:07,590 --> 01:56:09,424
representing Cal fire. I f f

3808
01:56:09,424 --> 01:56:11,961
local to 881 in the Riverside

3809
01:56:11,961 --> 01:56:12,796
district. In my day job as we

3810
01:56:12,796 --> 01:56:13,663
call it. I

3811
01:56:13,663 --> 01:56:15,565
m, an engineer

3812
01:56:15,565 --> 01:56:16,232
paramedic assigned to our

3813
01:56:16,232 --> 01:56:18,632
county hazardous materials team

3814
01:56:19,602 --> 01:56:20,770
in Winchester. I wanted to take

3815
01:56:20,770 --> 01:56:23,720
this opportunity to speak on

3816
01:56:23,720 --> 01:56:24,574
the behalf of the 50 plus local

3817
01:56:24,574 --> 01:56:26,974
+281 members we represent in

3818
01:56:27,610 --> 01:56:29,450
the Temecula City contract. Cal

3819
01:56:29,450 --> 01:56:31,482
Fire, Riverside County fire and

3820
01:56:31,482 --> 01:56:31,982
local to anyone have enjoyed a

3821
01:56:31,982 --> 01:56:33,982
positive, prosperous

3822
01:56:34,518 --> 01:56:35,920
relationship with the city of

3823
01:56:35,920 --> 01:56:37,521
Temecula for decades. Temecula

3824
01:56:37,521 --> 01:56:38,589
contract is our flagship

3825
01:56:38,589 --> 01:56:41,425
schedule a contract in this

3826
01:56:41,425 --> 01:56:42,693
unit and in the state. In 2000

3827
01:56:42,693 --> 01:56:43,694
at the direction of the City

3828
01:56:43,694 --> 01:56:45,262
Council working with Cal fire

3829
01:56:45,262 --> 01:56:48,399
local to it. 81 and Cal Fire

3830
01:56:48,399 --> 01:56:50,340
management. Temecula is one of

3831
01:56:50,340 --> 01:56:51,436
the first cities in Riverside

3832
01:56:51,436 --> 01:56:52,136
County to add paramedics for

3833
01:56:52,136 --> 01:56:55,136
the protection of his residence.

3834
01:56:56,741 --> 01:56:58,943
In 2005, Riverside County, The

3835
01:56:58,943 --> 01:57:00,278
City Council approved and was

3836
01:57:00,278 --> 01:57:02,113
the first contract in Cal fire

3837
01:57:02,113 --> 01:57:04,248
Riverside County Fire to have

3838
01:57:04,248 --> 01:57:07,260
industry standard for o l s

3839
01:57:07,260 --> 01:57:07,719
municipal staffing on all city

3840
01:57:07,719 --> 01:57:10,719
fire engines. This brought the

3841
01:57:10,789 --> 01:57:12,457
city in line with industry

3842
01:57:12,457 --> 01:57:13,580
standard for als municipal

3843
01:57:13,580 --> 01:57:16,580
staffing on all city fire

3844
01:57:16,161 --> 01:57:17,228
engines. All. This was achieved

3845
01:57:17,228 --> 01:57:19,398
through the local control that

3846
01:57:19,398 --> 01:57:21,633
the City Council has

3847
01:57:21,633 --> 01:57:22,167
Cooperative fire protection is

3848
01:57:22,167 --> 01:57:23,690
the biggest benefit of

3849
01:57:23,690 --> 01:57:25,469
contracting with Cal Fire,

3850
01:57:25,805 --> 01:57:27,406
Riverside County Fire At any

3851
01:57:27,406 --> 01:57:29,976
given time 24 hours a day

3852
01:57:29,976 --> 01:57:31,577
Temecula is able to call on any

3853
01:57:31,577 --> 01:57:33,746
of Cal fire. Riverside County

3854
01:57:33,746 --> 01:57:35,448
fires 82 advanced life support

3855
01:57:35,448 --> 01:57:37,783
paramedic engine companies. A

3856
01:57:37,783 --> 01:57:39,251
trunk of a truck companies, six

3857
01:57:39,251 --> 01:57:41,988
urban search and Rescue Task

3858
01:57:41,988 --> 01:57:43,356
force is a full time staff os

3859
01:57:43,356 --> 01:57:45,192
type one hazmat team over a

3860
01:57:45,192 --> 01:57:46,493
dozen wild land fire engines

3861
01:57:46,493 --> 01:57:48,395
and the largest aerial

3862
01:57:48,395 --> 01:57:48,895
firefighting fleet in the world,

3863
01:57:48,895 --> 01:57:50,895
including tankers and

3864
01:57:51,398 --> 01:57:52,899
helicopters. Heavy equipment

3865
01:57:52,899 --> 01:57:53,533
such as Dozers and potentially

3866
01:57:53,533 --> 01:57:55,933
dozens of firefighting hand

3867
01:57:56,102 --> 01:57:57,738
crews. All of this is thanks to

3868
01:57:57,738 --> 01:57:58,720
your the City council

3869
01:57:58,720 --> 01:57:59,607
s

3870
01:57:59,607 --> 01:58:01,242
dedication to the citizens of

3871
01:58:01,242 --> 01:58:01,876
Temecula and the Professional.

3872
01:58:01,876 --> 01:58:04,276
Firefighters sworn to protect

3873
01:58:04,545 --> 01:58:06,213
them. In addition to all the

3874
01:58:06,213 --> 01:58:07,648
services above the five fire

3875
01:58:07,648 --> 01:58:08,782
stations serving the city of

3876
01:58:08,782 --> 01:58:11,485
Temecula are integrated part of

3877
01:58:11,485 --> 01:58:12,753
this community. Whether it be

3878
01:58:12,753 --> 01:58:15,390
dinner with a firefighter fire

3879
01:58:15,390 --> 01:58:16,858
station tours. High school

3880
01:58:16,858 --> 01:58:17,859
career Expos or the Fire

3881
01:58:17,859 --> 01:58:19,260
Explorer program for use

3882
01:58:19,260 --> 01:58:20,295
interested in pursuing a career

3883
01:58:20,295 --> 01:58:21,796
in the fire service. The

3884
01:58:21,796 --> 01:58:23,665
members of the Cal Fire,

3885
01:58:23,665 --> 01:58:25,266
Riverside County Fire and local

3886
01:58:25,266 --> 01:58:27,680
281 or 100% committed to the

3887
01:58:27,680 --> 01:58:28,970
citizens of Temecula. Our local

3888
01:58:28,970 --> 01:58:29,637
to 881 Professional

3889
01:58:29,637 --> 01:58:31,105
firefighters are some of the

3890
01:58:31,105 --> 01:58:32,975
best in the world and I would

3891
01:58:32,975 --> 01:58:35,644
put them up against any fire

3892
01:58:35,644 --> 01:58:36,645
department any day. In closing.

3893
01:58:36,645 --> 01:58:37,780
I would like to again. Thank

3894
01:58:37,780 --> 01:58:39,581
you for your time and for

3895
01:58:39,581 --> 01:58:40,783
letting me speak to you this

3896
01:58:40,783 --> 01:58:42,618
evening that Temecula City

3897
01:58:42,618 --> 01:58:44,119
Council has time and time again

3898
01:58:44,119 --> 01:58:45,721
shown its commitment to public

3899
01:58:45,721 --> 01:58:46,988
safety and its dedication to

3900
01:58:46,988 --> 01:58:48,990
Cal fire Riverside County fire

3901
01:58:48,990 --> 01:58:49,658
and we look forward to that

3902
01:58:49,658 --> 01:58:51,658
continued relationship. Thank

3903
01:58:53,129 --> 01:58:54,597
you. Thank you. MADAM City

3904
01:58:54,597 --> 01:58:56,766
clerk there anymore speakers,

3905
01:58:56,766 --> 01:58:57,666
Mr Mayor. We do not have any

3906
01:58:57,666 --> 01:59:00,666
other in person speakers. I

3907
01:59:01,904 --> 01:59:03,306
will say I have a number of

3908
01:59:03,306 --> 01:59:06,306
email comments so that emails

3909
01:59:07,744 --> 01:59:09,646
received from Uh Mark Darcy in

3910
01:59:09,646 --> 01:59:13,246
regards to the fire item and

3911
01:59:13,250 --> 01:59:16,250
the emails received from Sarah

3912
01:59:16,486 --> 01:59:18,886
Patton. Tammy Meyer, Lorne

3913
01:59:19,560 --> 01:59:20,590
Fournier Martha Howard,

3914
01:59:20,590 --> 01:59:22,590
Jennifer, Cornelius, Atlanta

3915
01:59:23,126 --> 01:59:23,927
Salyer and Melissa Bourbon is

3916
01:59:23,927 --> 01:59:25,396
regarding the affordable

3917
01:59:25,396 --> 01:59:27,796
housing rec control measure.

3918
01:59:28,199 --> 01:59:28,933
They will all be put into the

3919
01:59:28,933 --> 01:59:31,369
record. Okay? I appreciate that.

3920
01:59:31,369 --> 01:59:32,637
Okay Well, now move into item

3921
01:59:32,637 --> 01:59:34,405
number one, which is considered

3922
01:59:34,405 --> 01:59:35,406
creation of ad hoc subcommittee

3923
01:59:35,406 --> 01:59:36,507
to discuss to make a police

3924
01:59:36,507 --> 01:59:38,609
department at the request of

3925
01:59:38,609 --> 01:59:41,609
the airport. Tim Swart. You.

3926
01:59:41,646 --> 01:59:44,783
Now have the floor. Okay, so

3927
01:59:44,783 --> 01:59:46,918
basically I had a great meeting

3928
01:59:46,918 --> 01:59:48,353
with Sheriff Bianco on this

3929
01:59:48,353 --> 01:59:50,788
issue, and a couple of things

3930
01:59:50,788 --> 01:59:54,388
came out of it. He clarified

3931
01:59:54,893 --> 01:59:58,196
that Um. Our officers do not

3932
01:59:58,196 --> 02:00:00,766
have to leave. Macula if they

3933
02:00:00,766 --> 02:00:03,135
promote, which is was a big

3934
02:00:03,135 --> 02:00:04,236
sticky point for me. I I

3935
02:00:04,236 --> 02:00:06,639
understand that was a policy of

3936
02:00:06,639 --> 02:00:07,472
the previous sheriff. And so,

3937
02:00:07,472 --> 02:00:08,474
um, I didn

3938
02:00:08,474 --> 02:00:10,900
t realize that the

3939
02:00:10,900 --> 02:00:11,430
current sheriff does not have

3940
02:00:11,430 --> 02:00:14,643
that policy in place. So that

3941
02:00:15,614 --> 02:00:17,282
was a huge thing for me. Um,

3942
02:00:17,282 --> 02:00:19,586
also, he expressed. He totally

3943
02:00:19,586 --> 02:00:20,887
supports the idea of us having

3944
02:00:20,887 --> 02:00:24,487
our own police station in in

3945
02:00:24,858 --> 02:00:25,225
Temecula. And. He

3946
02:00:25,225 --> 02:00:27,225
s got. He

3947
02:00:27,227 --> 02:00:29,495
just built a police station in

3948
02:00:29,495 --> 02:00:31,164
a group of Valley, so that was

3949
02:00:31,164 --> 02:00:32,131
very encouraging to hear that

3950
02:00:32,131 --> 02:00:33,333
cost, and that

3951
02:00:33,333 --> 02:00:35,733
s why I wanted

3952
02:00:37,710 --> 02:00:38,339
to, um, put it in our budget

3953
02:00:38,339 --> 02:00:41,740
thought of a police station

3954
02:00:41,740 --> 02:00:42,420
within the city of Temecula. Um

3955
02:00:42,420 --> 02:00:42,943
So. I

3956
02:00:42,943 --> 02:00:43,410
m. I

3957
02:00:43,410 --> 02:00:44,978
m literally

3958
02:00:44,978 --> 02:00:46,613
withdrawing the idea of

3959
02:00:46,613 --> 02:00:50,500
starting our own pd, but I want

3960
02:00:50,500 --> 02:00:51,385
to push forward the idea of

3961
02:00:51,385 --> 02:00:51,652
bringing our sheriff

3962
02:00:51,652 --> 02:00:53,652
s officers

3963
02:00:55,560 --> 02:00:55,323
inside our city limits. Ah. I

3964
02:00:55,323 --> 02:00:56,190
feel That

3965
02:00:56,190 --> 02:00:58,590
s something that we

3966
02:01:01,290 --> 02:01:03,931
need to do as a city to show

3967
02:01:03,931 --> 02:01:06,931
our, um dedication to public

3968
02:01:07,100 --> 02:01:08,736
safety and, um and instead of

3969
02:01:08,736 --> 02:01:10,606
having a commuter police force

3970
02:01:10,606 --> 02:01:11,306
will have a police force that

3971
02:01:11,306 --> 02:01:14,306
actually exists within the city

3972
02:01:15,177 --> 02:01:15,811
of Temecula. So. That

3973
02:01:15,811 --> 02:01:15,970
s. That

3974
02:01:15,970 --> 02:01:16,344
s

3975
02:01:16,344 --> 02:01:18,790
where I

3976
02:01:18,790 --> 02:01:18,380
m going with that, as

3977
02:01:18,380 --> 02:01:19,381
far as I

3978
02:01:19,381 --> 02:01:20,215
m concerned, I

3979
02:01:20,215 --> 02:01:22,215
ve

3980
02:01:22,717 --> 02:01:26,154
talked to San Diego p. D

3981
02:01:26,154 --> 02:01:27,823
lieutenant, and he was talking

3982
02:01:27,823 --> 02:01:28,991
about the Incredible Um uh,

3983
02:01:28,991 --> 02:01:29,525
Time that they

3984
02:01:29,525 --> 02:01:31,525
re having with

3985
02:01:32,328 --> 02:01:35,310
attrition down in San Diego

3986
02:01:35,310 --> 02:01:37,633
that they have, literally even

3987
02:01:37,633 --> 02:01:39,101
if they filled their academy up

3988
02:01:39,101 --> 02:01:41,404
and every single guy passed,

3989
02:01:41,404 --> 02:01:44,404
they would still go negative

3990
02:01:44,874 --> 02:01:46,643
every year as far as how many

3991
02:01:46,643 --> 02:01:49,312
officers are terming out, you

3992
02:01:49,312 --> 02:01:49,512
know injury, um So I don

3993
02:01:49,512 --> 02:01:51,512
t want

3994
02:01:51,615 --> 02:01:53,216
the city to be in that kind of

3995
02:01:53,216 --> 02:01:53,383
a situation. So. That

3996
02:01:53,383 --> 02:01:54,117
s that

3997
02:01:54,117 --> 02:01:54,451
s

3998
02:01:54,451 --> 02:01:54,717
something i

3999
02:01:54,717 --> 02:01:55,318
m. I

4000
02:01:55,318 --> 02:01:55,486
m thinking I

4001
02:01:55,486 --> 02:01:55,885
don

4002
02:01:55,885 --> 02:01:57,253
t want to. I don

4003
02:01:57,253 --> 02:01:57,921
t want to

4004
02:01:57,921 --> 02:02:00,921
go down that route because

4005
02:02:00,990 --> 02:02:03,527
recruitment Is going to be a

4006
02:02:03,527 --> 02:02:04,762
lot harder than first

4007
02:02:04,762 --> 02:02:05,663
anticipated, and that was

4008
02:02:05,663 --> 02:02:07,663
something sheriff Bianca

4009
02:02:07,731 --> 02:02:10,670
pointed out, and I was able to

4010
02:02:10,670 --> 02:02:10,668
verify with several other

4011
02:02:10,668 --> 02:02:10,968
agencies. So, Um there

4012
02:02:10,968 --> 02:02:12,469
s is

4013
02:02:12,469 --> 02:02:13,837
just a huge struggle right now

4014
02:02:13,837 --> 02:02:17,775
to get anybody to want to do,

4015
02:02:17,775 --> 02:02:18,750
Um Policing work. So, um so I

4016
02:02:18,750 --> 02:02:20,750
m

4017
02:02:21,646 --> 02:02:23,715
in favor of keeping our shares

4018
02:02:23,715 --> 02:02:26,384
but keeping them inside our

4019
02:02:26,384 --> 02:02:28,319
city limits by building a

4020
02:02:28,319 --> 02:02:30,319
police station, creating

4021
02:02:31,220 --> 02:02:32,690
ownership, creating. Um, um

4022
02:02:32,690 --> 02:02:36,290
Just a better sense of public.

4023
02:02:37,629 --> 02:02:39,164
Um Appreciation and or

4024
02:02:39,164 --> 02:02:40,198
ownership, so That

4025
02:02:40,198 --> 02:02:40,363
s Where I so

4026
02:02:40,363 --> 02:02:42,363
I

4027
02:02:42,901 --> 02:02:45,170
m literally going to remove

4028
02:02:45,170 --> 02:02:48,106
the idea of creating our own pd,

4029
02:02:48,106 --> 02:02:49,241
But I want to kind of shift

4030
02:02:49,241 --> 02:02:52,241
into the police station model.

4031
02:02:54,212 --> 02:02:55,615
Okay? So. Is that a wholesale

4032
02:02:55,615 --> 02:02:58,151
removal of this? Yes. You want

4033
02:02:58,151 --> 02:02:59,886
to modify it to anything? Are,

4034
02:02:59,886 --> 02:03:01,754
you good with the current

4035
02:03:01,754 --> 02:03:04,154
public safety subcommittee we

4036
02:03:04,190 --> 02:03:04,357
have handling this. I mean, I.

4037
02:03:04,357 --> 02:03:04,590
Don

4038
02:03:04,590 --> 02:03:05,858
t think I

4039
02:03:05,858 --> 02:03:08,858
m on it, but I

4040
02:03:09,528 --> 02:03:10,263
would I would want I think a

4041
02:03:10,263 --> 02:03:12,263
separate subcommittee city

4042
02:03:13,467 --> 02:03:16,467
manager? What would you Say

4043
02:03:17,871 --> 02:03:21,641
about this. Yeah, we have a We

4044
02:03:21,641 --> 02:03:22,509
have a dedicated And this this

4045
02:03:22,509 --> 02:03:23,577
probably, um will be in

4046
02:03:23,577 --> 02:03:26,346
conflict with what you just

4047
02:03:26,346 --> 02:03:29,946
said. But. We have a dedicated,

4048
02:03:37,291 --> 02:03:39,660
um Had hock subcommittee. Is

4049
02:03:39,660 --> 02:03:41,328
that the surplus lands, public

4050
02:03:41,328 --> 02:03:44,928
safety ad hoc and in reading

4051
02:03:46,600 --> 02:03:48,600
the description The

4052
02:03:48,770 --> 02:03:50,639
subcommittee will work with

4053
02:03:50,639 --> 02:03:50,906
staff to evaluate and discuss

4054
02:03:50,906 --> 02:03:52,906
the city

4055
02:03:53,341 --> 02:03:54,420
s public safety

4056
02:03:54,420 --> 02:03:56,420
operations, opportunities for

4057
02:03:56,411 --> 02:03:57,212
efficiencies and other related

4058
02:03:57,212 --> 02:03:58,747
matters. This includes

4059
02:03:58,747 --> 02:03:59,748
evaluating alternatives to the

4060
02:03:59,748 --> 02:04:00,348
police base of operations

4061
02:04:00,348 --> 02:04:03,348
located at the South West

4062
02:04:04,552 --> 02:04:05,287
Station. Um And I Think Mayor

4063
02:04:05,287 --> 02:04:07,223
Pro tem. That

4064
02:04:07,223 --> 02:04:07,423
s what you

4065
02:04:07,423 --> 02:04:07,590
re

4066
02:04:07,590 --> 02:04:09,590
you

4067
02:04:09,658 --> 02:04:09,825
re asking for your correct

4068
02:04:09,825 --> 02:04:11,825
You

4069
02:04:11,994 --> 02:04:13,762
re not currently listed on

4070
02:04:13,762 --> 02:04:16,162
that council members, Alexander

4071
02:04:16,532 --> 02:04:17,733
and cafes are assigned to that

4072
02:04:17,733 --> 02:04:20,169
subcommittee, So I think that

4073
02:04:20,169 --> 02:04:21,200
would be something the council

4074
02:04:21,200 --> 02:04:21,870
needs to discuss. I don

4075
02:04:21,870 --> 02:04:23,870
t know

4076
02:04:24,730 --> 02:04:26,142
that you need to solve that. At

4077
02:04:26,142 --> 02:04:27,810
this moment. But. If this

4078
02:04:27,810 --> 02:04:28,844
becomes an agenda item in two

4079
02:04:28,844 --> 02:04:29,120
weeks. Ts something that

4080
02:04:29,120 --> 02:04:31,120
you

4081
02:04:31,247 --> 02:04:34,384
re going to need to Think

4082
02:04:34,384 --> 02:04:36,285
about if we want to assign

4083
02:04:36,285 --> 02:04:38,285
something completely different,

4084
02:04:38,855 --> 02:04:41,191
or if stew you want to replace

4085
02:04:41,191 --> 02:04:41,592
somebody on that ad hoc

4086
02:04:41,592 --> 02:04:42,693
subcommittee that

4087
02:04:42,693 --> 02:04:44,610
s also

4088
02:04:44,610 --> 02:04:44,361
available to the subcommittee.

4089
02:04:44,361 --> 02:04:45,796
But. We

4090
02:04:45,796 --> 02:04:47,970
re going to be looking

4091
02:04:47,970 --> 02:04:50,970
for council direction if this

4092
02:04:52,202 --> 02:04:54,705
goes forward Mhm. So So. Do. I

4093
02:04:54,705 --> 02:04:56,390
have to bring it back again Or

4094
02:04:56,390 --> 02:04:59,310
can we take it from here and

4095
02:04:59,310 --> 02:04:59,911
put it right on the agenda

4096
02:04:59,911 --> 02:05:00,878
recommendation Barring Peter

4097
02:05:00,878 --> 02:05:02,180
telling me we can

4098
02:05:02,180 --> 02:05:04,180
t do this.

4099
02:05:05,716 --> 02:05:09,798
This is more you Mayor Pro tem

4100
02:05:09,798 --> 02:05:10,330
Clarifying your future agenda

4101
02:05:10,330 --> 02:05:10,888
item, not the actual agenda

4102
02:05:10,888 --> 02:05:11,520
item itself, So. I

4103
02:05:11,520 --> 02:05:12,657
m

4104
02:05:12,657 --> 02:05:13,257
comfortable as long as you

4105
02:05:13,257 --> 02:05:13,924
re

4106
02:05:13,924 --> 02:05:15,527
clarifying for your colleagues

4107
02:05:15,527 --> 02:05:15,727
benefit What. It is that

4108
02:05:15,727 --> 02:05:17,229
they

4109
02:05:17,229 --> 02:05:17,796
re voting on this evening.

4110
02:05:17,796 --> 02:05:19,198
What. It is they

4111
02:05:19,198 --> 02:05:20,565
re not voting

4112
02:05:20,565 --> 02:05:22,330
on this evening and then voting

4113
02:05:22,330 --> 02:05:23,768
up or down If you want to see

4114
02:05:23,768 --> 02:05:23,930
this? Come back in two weeks.

4115
02:05:23,930 --> 02:05:25,470
I

4116
02:05:25,470 --> 02:05:27,470
m comfortable. In

4117
02:05:29,341 --> 02:05:32,341
clarification. What were you We

4118
02:05:32,545 --> 02:05:36,145
would be voting on is bringing

4119
02:05:36,282 --> 02:05:39,882
this back as only a discussion

4120
02:05:40,119 --> 02:05:41,200
and a police station model

4121
02:05:41,200 --> 02:05:44,323
versus a, um stand up p d. Okay.

4122
02:05:44,323 --> 02:05:44,723
And and and let

4123
02:05:44,723 --> 02:05:44,890
s just assume,

4124
02:05:44,890 --> 02:05:45,724
let

4125
02:05:45,724 --> 02:05:46,258
s play this out. Let

4126
02:05:46,258 --> 02:05:47,726
s that

4127
02:05:47,726 --> 02:05:50,664
this gets approved and it gets

4128
02:05:50,664 --> 02:05:51,298
on the agenda. We can have the

4129
02:05:51,298 --> 02:05:52,165
discussion about it

4130
02:05:52,165 --> 02:05:53,333
s just

4131
02:05:53,333 --> 02:05:53,867
appropriate for this current

4132
02:05:53,867 --> 02:05:54,734
subcommittee. And if we

4133
02:05:54,734 --> 02:05:56,236
d like

4134
02:05:56,236 --> 02:05:58,404
to make changes, and we could

4135
02:05:58,404 --> 02:05:58,805
do so at that time, right, so

4136
02:05:58,805 --> 02:05:59,806
we don

4137
02:05:59,806 --> 02:06:01,207
t necessarily have to

4138
02:06:01,207 --> 02:06:01,369
create anything new. We. Don

4139
02:06:01,369 --> 02:06:02,175
t

4140
02:06:02,175 --> 02:06:03,276
we already have the

4141
02:06:03,276 --> 02:06:05,676
infrastructure in place, so

4142
02:06:05,879 --> 02:06:06,746
Okay? I think we

4143
02:06:06,746 --> 02:06:08,882
re good, but I

4144
02:06:08,882 --> 02:06:10,851
want to open it up to any

4145
02:06:10,851 --> 02:06:11,285
questions of the balance of the

4146
02:06:11,285 --> 02:06:12,386
council if anyone

4147
02:06:12,386 --> 02:06:14,386
s insured, Mr

4148
02:06:15,923 --> 02:06:16,657
Mayor Pro tem. I do, um You had

4149
02:06:16,657 --> 02:06:18,580
mentioned earlier in the

4150
02:06:18,580 --> 02:06:18,625
meeting, and I think it can

4151
02:06:18,625 --> 02:06:20,260
t

4152
02:06:20,260 --> 02:06:22,329
get lost in this conversation

4153
02:06:22,329 --> 02:06:24,131
as it has your voting and you

4154
02:06:24,131 --> 02:06:24,298
want to bring stuff back. It

4155
02:06:24,298 --> 02:06:25,633
s

4156
02:06:25,633 --> 02:06:26,901
a little confusing, but I think

4157
02:06:26,901 --> 02:06:30,872
the mayor pro tem has kind of

4158
02:06:30,872 --> 02:06:31,839
like a two Really two things

4159
02:06:31,839 --> 02:06:33,141
that are connected.

4160
02:06:33,141 --> 02:06:35,376
Interconnected. One is the ad

4161
02:06:35,376 --> 02:06:37,745
hoc and the discussion on a

4162
02:06:37,745 --> 02:06:37,945
police station. And. Then,

4163
02:06:37,945 --> 02:06:39,945
There

4164
02:06:40,348 --> 02:06:41,883
s a correlating financial

4165
02:06:41,883 --> 02:06:43,385
policy. City Council policy

4166
02:06:43,385 --> 02:06:45,220
related to that action. I would

4167
02:06:45,220 --> 02:06:48,156
envision both of those being

4168
02:06:48,156 --> 02:06:48,590
part of any future staff report

4169
02:06:48,590 --> 02:06:49,191
for this council

4170
02:06:49,191 --> 02:06:51,191
s discussion.

4171
02:06:52,494 --> 02:06:52,694
Indirection. That makes sense,

4172
02:06:52,694 --> 02:06:53,395
doesn

4173
02:06:53,395 --> 02:06:56,995
t it would have to be.

4174
02:06:57,432 --> 02:06:58,330
Yeah. So, Mr mayor for

4175
02:06:58,330 --> 02:06:59,534
clarifying purposes, your

4176
02:06:59,534 --> 02:07:01,871
motion that you would be voting

4177
02:07:01,871 --> 02:07:03,840
up or down is whether or not to

4178
02:07:03,840 --> 02:07:06,342
consider the creation of an ad

4179
02:07:06,342 --> 02:07:07,430
hoc subcommittee to discuss the

4180
02:07:07,430 --> 02:07:08,410
Temecula sheriff

4181
02:07:08,410 --> 02:07:10,112
s station and

4182
02:07:10,112 --> 02:07:12,512
any related funding mechanisms.

4183
02:07:13,482 --> 02:07:18,282
Would you like to see that on a

4184
02:07:18,922 --> 02:07:21,291
future agenda? Yes, okay. So

4185
02:07:21,291 --> 02:07:21,858
entertain, So we have a motion

4186
02:07:21,858 --> 02:07:22,590
motion second it and let

4187
02:07:22,590 --> 02:07:24,590
s vote.

4188
02:07:33,360 --> 02:07:33,970
Council member Brown. Are you

4189
02:07:33,970 --> 02:07:36,370
in the primitive affirmative.

4190
02:07:39,900 --> 02:07:39,510
Thank you. Okay and that passes

4191
02:07:39,510 --> 02:07:41,110
50, and we

4192
02:07:41,110 --> 02:07:43,114
ll see that in two

4193
02:07:43,114 --> 02:07:44,915
weeks. Okay item number two is

4194
02:07:44,915 --> 02:07:45,549
considered creation of ad hoc

4195
02:07:45,549 --> 02:07:47,418
subcommittee to discuss

4196
02:07:47,418 --> 02:07:48,485
Temecula Fire department at the

4197
02:07:48,485 --> 02:07:51,485
request of council member cafes.

4198
02:07:51,888 --> 02:07:53,191
You have the floor. So when i

4199
02:07:53,191 --> 02:07:55,994
initially proposed this about a

4200
02:07:55,994 --> 02:07:57,429
month or so ago, my initial

4201
02:07:57,429 --> 02:07:59,397
thought was working alongside

4202
02:07:59,397 --> 02:08:00,732
Cal fire on strike teams and

4203
02:08:00,732 --> 02:08:02,233
different assignments. I always

4204
02:08:02,233 --> 02:08:03,768
thought that Cal fire deserve

4205
02:08:03,768 --> 02:08:04,969
more. And when I mean my

4206
02:08:04,969 --> 02:08:06,710
dessert more. I mean, I believe

4207
02:08:06,710 --> 02:08:08,390
that they deserve more pay, and

4208
02:08:08,390 --> 02:08:09,975
they deserve more Time off Cal

4209
02:08:09,975 --> 02:08:10,676
fire compared to a lot of

4210
02:08:10,676 --> 02:08:12,311
municipal departments work more.

4211
02:08:12,311 --> 02:08:13,110
And they aren

4212
02:08:13,110 --> 02:08:14,413
t compensated for

4213
02:08:14,413 --> 02:08:16,810
the work that they do. So when

4214
02:08:16,810 --> 02:08:16,682
I proposed this, my initial

4215
02:08:16,682 --> 02:08:17,182
thought was that

4216
02:08:17,182 --> 02:08:18,150
s what I

4217
02:08:18,150 --> 02:08:18,317
wanted for Cal fire and that

4218
02:08:18,317 --> 02:08:19,385
s

4219
02:08:19,385 --> 02:08:20,652
what I wanted for our

4220
02:08:20,652 --> 02:08:22,287
firefighters here in the city

4221
02:08:22,287 --> 02:08:24,689
of Temecula, But after doing my

4222
02:08:24,689 --> 02:08:26,125
own research of my own do

4223
02:08:26,125 --> 02:08:29,125
diligence. I realized that that

4224
02:08:29,129 --> 02:08:29,295
is something that Necessary

4225
02:08:29,295 --> 02:08:31,295
Let

4226
02:08:31,530 --> 02:08:32,331
s above Temecula City

4227
02:08:32,331 --> 02:08:32,565
councils around of authority,

4228
02:08:32,565 --> 02:08:33,900
and I

4229
02:08:33,900 --> 02:08:36,569
ve come to the conclusion

4230
02:08:36,569 --> 02:08:37,236
that Cal fire and more

4231
02:08:37,236 --> 02:08:38,938
specifically, Riverside County

4232
02:08:38,938 --> 02:08:40,540
fire provides the best fire and

4233
02:08:40,540 --> 02:08:41,407
emergency services to the

4234
02:08:41,407 --> 02:08:43,509
residents of Temecula and

4235
02:08:43,509 --> 02:08:45,546
therefore I will not be moving

4236
02:08:45,546 --> 02:08:47,514
forward with my request for

4237
02:08:47,514 --> 02:08:49,914
subcommittee for Temecula Fire

4238
02:08:50,160 --> 02:08:52,416
Department. Okay. Thank you

4239
02:08:52,753 --> 02:08:54,321
very much, noted. Okay. Item

4240
02:08:54,321 --> 02:08:55,355
number three. Consider Rent

4241
02:08:55,355 --> 02:08:56,523
Control Ordinance for

4242
02:08:56,523 --> 02:08:57,658
affordable housing at the

4243
02:08:57,658 --> 02:09:00,580
request of council members,

4244
02:09:00,293 --> 02:09:03,131
Stuart, you have the floor. All.

4245
02:09:03,131 --> 02:09:04,732
Right. So this is really

4246
02:09:04,732 --> 02:09:07,235
something that I just wanted to

4247
02:09:07,235 --> 02:09:08,350
daylight. And I I

4248
02:09:08,350 --> 02:09:10,350
m. I really

4249
02:09:11,272 --> 02:09:14,872
want to ask our city manager?

4250
02:09:15,209 --> 02:09:18,512
To come back and give a report

4251
02:09:18,512 --> 02:09:21,216
on what rent controls and what

4252
02:09:21,216 --> 02:09:23,616
does affordable housing. Look

4253
02:09:24,152 --> 02:09:25,487
like inter macula from from our

4254
02:09:25,487 --> 02:09:27,422
investment, you know, because

4255
02:09:27,422 --> 02:09:30,892
we have invested a lot of money

4256
02:09:30,892 --> 02:09:32,327
in the city of Temecula. Uh, in

4257
02:09:32,327 --> 02:09:35,327
affordable housing, and so and

4258
02:09:35,397 --> 02:09:37,800
what did the covenants look

4259
02:09:37,800 --> 02:09:40,736
like on the actual managers of

4260
02:09:40,736 --> 02:09:43,672
the buildings and the property

4261
02:09:43,672 --> 02:09:47,243
owners, and so I? For me it was

4262
02:09:47,243 --> 02:09:49,144
more just to clarify. What is

4263
02:09:49,144 --> 02:09:49,478
in place right now, so because

4264
02:09:49,478 --> 02:09:50,790
you can

4265
02:09:50,790 --> 02:09:51,130
t talk about something,

4266
02:09:51,130 --> 02:09:51,647
if you don

4267
02:09:51,647 --> 02:09:51,914
t know the answer,

4268
02:09:51,914 --> 02:09:52,514
and that

4269
02:09:52,514 --> 02:09:53,582
s and that

4270
02:09:53,582 --> 02:09:55,352
s what I

4271
02:09:55,352 --> 02:09:57,253
feel like. You know the

4272
02:09:57,253 --> 02:10:00,900
discussion was going on is, you

4273
02:10:00,900 --> 02:10:02,490
know MISS Lamont wants

4274
02:10:05,328 --> 02:10:07,197
something. And I need to know

4275
02:10:07,197 --> 02:10:09,732
what and I need the public to

4276
02:10:09,732 --> 02:10:09,899
know what we can and what we

4277
02:10:09,899 --> 02:10:11,899
can

4278
02:10:12,369 --> 02:10:12,736
t do. And. So, I. I

4279
02:10:12,736 --> 02:10:14,104
m just

4280
02:10:14,104 --> 02:10:16,874
asking us to have our city

4281
02:10:16,874 --> 02:10:19,610
manager. Or whoever he assigns

4282
02:10:19,610 --> 02:10:23,210
to come back and explain how

4283
02:10:23,914 --> 02:10:26,517
the covenants Ah, on, um, the

4284
02:10:26,517 --> 02:10:26,680
affordable housing. And. What

4285
02:10:26,680 --> 02:10:28,352
s

4286
02:10:28,352 --> 02:10:30,889
in the pipeline. What do we

4287
02:10:30,889 --> 02:10:32,824
have? What? How?Re we

4288
02:10:32,824 --> 02:10:34,258
affecting this community who

4289
02:10:34,258 --> 02:10:35,793
who basically feels faceless.

4290
02:10:35,793 --> 02:10:38,496
How, are we addressing their

4291
02:10:38,496 --> 02:10:39,731
needs? At a city level with

4292
02:10:39,731 --> 02:10:39,997
because I know we

4293
02:10:39,997 --> 02:10:40,665
re doing a

4294
02:10:40,665 --> 02:10:41,265
lot, but I don

4295
02:10:41,265 --> 02:10:42,233
t think the

4296
02:10:42,233 --> 02:10:42,967
public knows we

4297
02:10:42,967 --> 02:10:45,367
re doing a lot

4298
02:10:45,837 --> 02:10:48,640
so I would like to have that

4299
02:10:48,640 --> 02:10:50,275
report. Just the daylight, all

4300
02:10:50,275 --> 02:10:51,576
the information just so when

4301
02:10:51,576 --> 02:10:53,378
you know when we talk about

4302
02:10:53,378 --> 02:10:54,179
rent control We

4303
02:10:54,179 --> 02:10:55,113
re going to

4304
02:10:55,113 --> 02:10:58,713
find out. We already have it,

4305
02:10:58,750 --> 02:11:01,153
But I want that to come from

4306
02:11:01,153 --> 02:11:03,880
the city manager talking about

4307
02:11:03,880 --> 02:11:05,625
exactly what? What we have in

4308
02:11:05,625 --> 02:11:05,791
place already and Um So. That

4309
02:11:05,791 --> 02:11:07,260
s

4310
02:11:07,260 --> 02:11:08,494
what I

4311
02:11:08,494 --> 02:11:10,529
m, asking the council to

4312
02:11:10,529 --> 02:11:10,863
Take. This a little farther.

4313
02:11:10,863 --> 02:11:12,863
Alright, I

4314
02:11:12,932 --> 02:11:15,168
ll open up for any

4315
02:11:15,168 --> 02:11:15,801
quick questions from balance of

4316
02:11:15,801 --> 02:11:15,968
the council. Um, So. I

4317
02:11:15,968 --> 02:11:17,968
m not

4318
02:11:18,904 --> 02:11:19,305
seeing any So in instead you

4319
02:11:19,305 --> 02:11:20,906
re

4320
02:11:20,906 --> 02:11:22,976
asking, you know, not for rent

4321
02:11:22,976 --> 02:11:23,443
Control ordinance, but a

4322
02:11:23,443 --> 02:11:23,977
presentation on that

4323
02:11:23,977 --> 02:11:24,577
s what I

4324
02:11:24,577 --> 02:11:25,912
m

4325
02:11:25,912 --> 02:11:28,480
asking affordable housing and

4326
02:11:28,480 --> 02:11:29,249
right. Okay. Um I mean that

4327
02:11:29,249 --> 02:11:29,416
seems reasonable and I know

4328
02:11:29,416 --> 02:11:30,850
we

4329
02:11:30,850 --> 02:11:32,452
ve done them past meetings,

4330
02:11:32,452 --> 02:11:32,752
and I know, I

4331
02:11:32,752 --> 02:11:33,453
m even ready

4332
02:11:33,453 --> 02:11:35,588
Commission has seen him as well.

4333
02:11:35,588 --> 02:11:36,856
But. It

4334
02:11:36,856 --> 02:11:38,158
s definitely something

4335
02:11:38,158 --> 02:11:39,860
that it wears on your heart.

4336
02:11:39,860 --> 02:11:41,462
When you hear these stories,

4337
02:11:41,462 --> 02:11:41,729
and and I think it

4338
02:11:41,729 --> 02:11:43,729
s important

4339
02:11:44,198 --> 02:11:45,633
that we communicate that back

4340
02:11:45,633 --> 02:11:48,569
to the community, so I would

4341
02:11:48,569 --> 02:11:48,902
certainly support that, and Um.

4342
02:11:48,902 --> 02:11:50,404
I guess I

4343
02:11:50,404 --> 02:11:52,804
ll make the motion

4344
02:11:53,400 --> 02:11:53,674
motion so emotions you consider

4345
02:11:53,674 --> 02:11:53,841
So actually, Mr Mayor, You

4346
02:11:53,841 --> 02:11:55,750
don

4347
02:11:55,750 --> 02:11:58,480
t need to have a motion on

4348
02:11:58,480 --> 02:11:59,581
that and what I heard from

4349
02:11:59,581 --> 02:12:01,616
mayor pretension. Frank Stewart

4350
02:12:01,616 --> 02:12:03,551
is that he is pulling that item

4351
02:12:03,551 --> 02:12:05,153
and instead directing the city

4352
02:12:05,153 --> 02:12:08,753
manager to go ahead and bring

4353
02:12:09,791 --> 02:12:09,991
back a presentation. Okay? And.

4354
02:12:09,991 --> 02:12:11,991
That

4355
02:12:12,460 --> 02:12:13,261
s even cleaner process.

4356
02:12:13,261 --> 02:12:13,461
Okay, fantastic. Doesn

4357
02:12:13,461 --> 02:12:13,761
t work

4358
02:12:13,761 --> 02:12:14,950
since you

4359
02:12:14,950 --> 02:12:14,597
re since you

4360
02:12:14,597 --> 02:12:15,564
re

4361
02:12:15,564 --> 02:12:17,650
voting isn

4362
02:12:17,650 --> 02:12:18,534
t working. Okay? And.

4363
02:12:18,534 --> 02:12:19,802
Last item is Adam for is

4364
02:12:19,802 --> 02:12:20,669
considered the process for

4365
02:12:20,669 --> 02:12:22,604
placement of future agenda

4366
02:12:22,604 --> 02:12:25,841
items at the request of myself.

4367
02:12:25,841 --> 02:12:27,276
So, um You know when I first

4368
02:12:27,276 --> 02:12:29,611
came onto council, Um, you know

4369
02:12:29,611 --> 02:12:31,747
there was this. This feeling of

4370
02:12:31,747 --> 02:12:33,750
you would have to communicate

4371
02:12:33,750 --> 02:12:34,417
with your colleagues, right? I

4372
02:12:34,417 --> 02:12:36,953
remember sitting, you know for

4373
02:12:36,953 --> 02:12:38,388
the first First few meetings

4374
02:12:38,388 --> 02:12:39,880
and sort of understanding that

4375
02:12:39,880 --> 02:12:39,789
the dynamics of what it

4376
02:12:39,789 --> 02:12:41,423
s like

4377
02:12:41,423 --> 02:12:42,258
to work with the team and, um

4378
02:12:42,258 --> 02:12:44,930
and if there were some things

4379
02:12:44,930 --> 02:12:45,695
that I wanted to bring forward

4380
02:12:45,695 --> 02:12:47,463
and and I would I would reach

4381
02:12:47,463 --> 02:12:49,499
out to another council member

4382
02:12:49,499 --> 02:12:50,670
and and and say, Hey, I

4383
02:12:50,670 --> 02:12:51,902
ve got

4384
02:12:51,902 --> 02:12:54,400
this idea, you know? Would you

4385
02:12:54,400 --> 02:12:55,505
mind co sponsoring this with me

4386
02:12:55,505 --> 02:12:56,340
in bringing that forward? Um

4387
02:12:56,340 --> 02:12:58,508
and that worked, You know, I

4388
02:12:58,508 --> 02:12:59,509
think that was six or

4389
02:12:59,509 --> 02:13:01,509
historically, the unwritten

4390
02:13:02,145 --> 02:13:03,213
rules and we we we had to come

4391
02:13:03,213 --> 02:13:04,810
into an age is a city and

4392
02:13:04,810 --> 02:13:04,248
create policy, and I think it

4393
02:13:04,248 --> 02:13:04,848
s

4394
02:13:04,848 --> 02:13:07,848
important that we did create

4395
02:13:08,119 --> 02:13:09,587
the Policy, but but I see some

4396
02:13:09,587 --> 02:13:11,189
problems with it, and I think

4397
02:13:11,189 --> 02:13:12,890
Um, if we could have this

4398
02:13:12,890 --> 02:13:13,925
discussion at the council level,

4399
02:13:13,925 --> 02:13:15,893
we could address some of them,

4400
02:13:15,893 --> 02:13:17,962
Um, you know, and and just

4401
02:13:17,962 --> 02:13:20,310
really not to go too deep into

4402
02:13:20,310 --> 02:13:20,765
this, But, um, you know,

4403
02:13:20,765 --> 02:13:23,167
oftentimes we can start with

4404
02:13:23,167 --> 02:13:23,367
our city manager like that.

4405
02:13:23,367 --> 02:13:23,867
That

4406
02:13:23,867 --> 02:13:25,867
s important relationship

4407
02:13:25,904 --> 02:13:28,306
that we have, so we should work

4408
02:13:28,306 --> 02:13:29,875
with that, Um, we do have many

4409
02:13:29,875 --> 02:13:30,842
subcommittees. And. Um. We

4410
02:13:30,842 --> 02:13:32,778
heard the nefarious, you know,

4411
02:13:32,778 --> 02:13:34,946
send it to a subcommittee thing,

4412
02:13:34,946 --> 02:13:35,747
and I see the exact opposite of

4413
02:13:35,747 --> 02:13:39,347
that we can spend valuable time.

4414
02:13:39,684 --> 02:13:40,151
Looking at things through the

4415
02:13:40,151 --> 02:13:40,518
subcommittee. There

4416
02:13:40,518 --> 02:13:42,518
s various

4417
02:13:43,355 --> 02:13:45,755
other avenues for bringing

4418
02:13:46,325 --> 02:13:48,600
items to to To an agenda. The

4419
02:13:48,600 --> 02:13:49,628
most important is trying to

4420
02:13:49,628 --> 02:13:51,230
build consensus right and

4421
02:13:51,230 --> 02:13:51,964
obviously not building

4422
02:13:51,964 --> 02:13:52,998
consensus with everyone. But if

4423
02:13:52,998 --> 02:13:54,767
I want to bring something

4424
02:13:54,767 --> 02:13:56,602
forward, I want to have a

4425
02:13:56,602 --> 02:13:57,670
conversation with at least one

4426
02:13:57,670 --> 02:14:00,140
other colleague and say, Hey,

4427
02:14:00,140 --> 02:14:01,700
um, you know, What. Do. You

4428
02:14:01,700 --> 02:14:02,308
think about this, You know. Am

4429
02:14:02,308 --> 02:14:03,430
I in the right lane. And you

4430
02:14:03,430 --> 02:14:04,410
might say, yeah, that

4431
02:14:04,410 --> 02:14:05,679
s what I

4432
02:14:05,679 --> 02:14:06,713
could doodle stop, or you might

4433
02:14:06,713 --> 02:14:06,882
be like, Okay. That

4434
02:14:06,882 --> 02:14:07,490
s that

4435
02:14:07,490 --> 02:14:08,815
s

4436
02:14:08,815 --> 02:14:09,480
normal. Um So. That

4437
02:14:09,480 --> 02:14:10,950
s really

4438
02:14:10,950 --> 02:14:11,351
the conversation I want to have

4439
02:14:11,351 --> 02:14:12,385
about this? We

4440
02:14:12,385 --> 02:14:13,186
re having folks

4441
02:14:13,186 --> 02:14:14,387
come to the podium and say, I

4442
02:14:14,387 --> 02:14:15,788
want you to do this? I want you

4443
02:14:15,788 --> 02:14:15,955
to put an item on and we

4444
02:14:15,955 --> 02:14:17,358
re

4445
02:14:17,358 --> 02:14:17,523
sort of reacting to that We

4446
02:14:17,523 --> 02:14:19,326
re

4447
02:14:19,326 --> 02:14:21,395
spending a lot of time on these

4448
02:14:21,395 --> 02:14:23,197
future agenda items and we have

4449
02:14:23,197 --> 02:14:26,166
an infrastructure in place to

4450
02:14:26,166 --> 02:14:27,667
handle a bulk of this. These

4451
02:14:27,667 --> 02:14:29,136
asked, so I would just ask that

4452
02:14:29,136 --> 02:14:30,270
we place this on the future

4453
02:14:30,270 --> 02:14:33,340
engine item, we can have the

4454
02:14:33,340 --> 02:14:34,742
discussion and tighten up. Our

4455
02:14:34,742 --> 02:14:36,244
council policy at a future

4456
02:14:36,244 --> 02:14:36,420
meeting. So with that That

4457
02:14:36,420 --> 02:14:36,711
s my

4458
02:14:36,711 --> 02:14:37,780
motion, I

4459
02:14:37,780 --> 02:14:39,478
ll entertain a secon

4460
02:14:39,947 --> 02:14:44,147
Okay. We have a second Let us

4461
02:14:45,653 --> 02:14:46,120
vote. Affirmative. Yeah. We

4462
02:14:46,120 --> 02:14:46,854
have a one man. Let

4463
02:14:46,854 --> 02:14:48,854
s see. Yeah.

4464
02:14:52,828 --> 02:14:54,329
Okay, and that fastest 50. Okay.

4465
02:14:54,329 --> 02:14:55,264
Thank you everyone. City

4466
02:14:55,264 --> 02:14:56,331
managers report. Um, Yeah, MR.

4467
02:14:56,331 --> 02:14:59,901
Mayor. I just have a kind of

4468
02:14:59,901 --> 02:15:01,436
want to do a quick commercial

4469
02:15:01,436 --> 02:15:03,138
here. We don

4470
02:15:03,138 --> 02:15:04,840
t often talk about

4471
02:15:04,840 --> 02:15:06,975
a business incubator. The City

4472
02:15:06,975 --> 02:15:07,542
of Temecula has a business

4473
02:15:07,542 --> 02:15:08,343
incubator. It

4474
02:15:08,343 --> 02:15:09,812
s located over on

4475
02:15:09,812 --> 02:15:10,880
the West side. It

4476
02:15:10,880 --> 02:15:11,881
s doing

4477
02:15:11,881 --> 02:15:14,881
amazing things and something we

4478
02:15:16,852 --> 02:15:17,586
refer to it as t v e two.

4479
02:15:17,586 --> 02:15:17,987
Temecula Valley Entrepreneur

4480
02:15:17,987 --> 02:15:18,721
exchange, So I

4481
02:15:18,721 --> 02:15:20,356
m just going to

4482
02:15:20,356 --> 02:15:21,824
do a quick little commercial

4483
02:15:21,824 --> 02:15:22,910
for those that aren

4484
02:15:22,910 --> 02:15:23,859
t familiar

4485
02:15:23,859 --> 02:15:27,459
with what goes on there. You

4486
02:15:27,697 --> 02:15:29,432
can see on this slide here, um,

4487
02:15:29,432 --> 02:15:31,334
just like shark tank. We do

4488
02:15:31,334 --> 02:15:33,734
quick pitch competitions where

4489
02:15:35,171 --> 02:15:37,400
we coach folks that are

4490
02:15:37,400 --> 02:15:38,800
according investment into a

4491
02:15:38,800 --> 02:15:39,900
idea. Entrepreneurial spirit.

4492
02:15:39,900 --> 02:15:39,776
You can see there

4493
02:15:39,776 --> 02:15:41,776
s an in

4494
02:15:41,945 --> 02:15:43,480
person event there on APRIL

4495
02:15:43,480 --> 02:15:45,880
12th from 11 30 to 1. Next

4496
02:15:48,119 --> 02:15:49,553
slide, please. Um. We also

4497
02:15:49,553 --> 02:15:51,155
cater to veterans and I know

4498
02:15:51,155 --> 02:15:52,789
this is very important and so

4499
02:15:52,789 --> 02:15:53,991
you can see there. There

4500
02:15:53,991 --> 02:15:55,991
s a

4501
02:15:56,994 --> 02:15:57,995
list of sessions supporting our

4502
02:15:57,995 --> 02:15:59,163
veterans population and

4503
02:15:59,163 --> 02:16:01,163
starting a business

4504
02:16:02,330 --> 02:16:02,667
understanding your market

4505
02:16:02,667 --> 02:16:04,667
economics. Financing your

4506
02:16:05,703 --> 02:16:06,404
venture. Um a number of classes

4507
02:16:06,404 --> 02:16:08,804
and opportunities. Next slide,

4508
02:16:09,307 --> 02:16:10,842
please. Here

4509
02:16:10,842 --> 02:16:12,544
s another list of

4510
02:16:12,544 --> 02:16:13,211
just some random programs that

4511
02:16:13,211 --> 02:16:16,113
we picked that are coming up

4512
02:16:16,113 --> 02:16:17,148
and the next couple of weeks

4513
02:16:17,148 --> 02:16:19,148
marketing campaign strategy.

4514
02:16:19,618 --> 02:16:23,218
These are this is free advice.

4515
02:16:23,455 --> 02:16:24,323
This is free business advice

4516
02:16:24,323 --> 02:16:26,425
taught by legitimate business

4517
02:16:26,425 --> 02:16:27,893
owners that know their their

4518
02:16:27,893 --> 02:16:29,361
stuff. How to do business with

4519
02:16:29,361 --> 02:16:29,522
the city of Temecula. If you

4520
02:16:29,522 --> 02:16:31,522
re

4521
02:16:33,365 --> 02:16:35,433
interested, how to become one ur Valued contractors and

4522
02:16:35,433 --> 02:16:39,330
so attend a session on MARCH

4523
02:16:39,639 --> 02:16:39,839
16th next slide. And. Lastly.

4524
02:16:39,839 --> 02:16:40,840
Here

4525
02:16:40,840 --> 02:16:42,642
s some other practical

4526
02:16:42,642 --> 02:16:44,944
programs that are being offered

4527
02:16:44,944 --> 02:16:45,110
later in MARCH, whether it

4528
02:16:45,110 --> 02:16:46,412
s

4529
02:16:46,412 --> 02:16:48,810
ocean certification or

4530
02:16:48,810 --> 02:16:50,149
employment law, just a lot of

4531
02:16:50,149 --> 02:16:51,150
really great programs. Mary is

4532
02:16:51,150 --> 02:16:51,484
our incubator manager over

4533
02:16:51,484 --> 02:16:52,518
there. She

4534
02:16:52,518 --> 02:16:54,588
s doing a great job.

4535
02:16:54,588 --> 02:16:56,890
I know I send all the updates

4536
02:16:56,890 --> 02:16:58,225
to the City Council, but for

4537
02:16:58,225 --> 02:16:58,925
the general public and for our

4538
02:16:58,925 --> 02:17:01,925
business community, it is a

4539
02:17:03,330 --> 02:17:03,764
hidden gem. That sometimes

4540
02:17:03,764 --> 02:17:04,564
forgotten that it

4541
02:17:04,564 --> 02:17:06,466
s available

4542
02:17:06,466 --> 02:17:07,868
and out there. So with that, Um

4543
02:17:07,868 --> 02:17:09,436
I appreciate the opportunity to

4544
02:17:09,436 --> 02:17:11,404
show that this evening, Okay

4545
02:17:11,404 --> 02:17:12,540
thank you very much. Mr City

4546
02:17:12,540 --> 02:17:14,410
manager, Mr City attorney.

4547
02:17:14,410 --> 02:17:15,376
Anything this evening. I have

4548
02:17:15,376 --> 02:17:16,777
nothing further. GOD. Darn it.

4549
02:17:16,777 --> 02:17:18,120
i was looking forward to

4550
02:17:18,120 --> 02:17:21,382
hearing you Talk a little bit.

4551
02:17:21,382 --> 02:17:22,116
I do have a long list of topics

4552
02:17:22,116 --> 02:17:23,818
I could Okay. No. All, Right.

4553
02:17:23,818 --> 02:17:23,984
Thank you, sir. Okay with that

4554
02:17:23,984 --> 02:17:25,786
we

4555
02:17:25,786 --> 02:17:27,688
ll go ahead and move to our

4556
02:17:27,688 --> 02:17:29,191
adjournment if we could put up

4557
02:17:29,191 --> 02:17:30,758
a quick slide. Um, this is Ted

4558
02:17:30,758 --> 02:17:33,795
Hoffman. He is the mayor pro

4559
02:17:33,795 --> 02:17:35,497
tem of the city of Norco. And,

4560
02:17:35,497 --> 02:17:38,600
sadly, Ted passed in his sleep

4561
02:17:38,600 --> 02:17:40,335
just a few days ago. We We have

4562
02:17:40,335 --> 02:17:43,138
served. Many of us has served

4563
02:17:43,138 --> 02:17:47,338
with Ted over the years. Um and

4564
02:17:47,743 --> 02:17:50,346
he is a gem. He was a gem. Um.

4565
02:17:50,346 --> 02:17:51,280
He was obviously a value to

4566
02:17:51,280 --> 02:17:52,848
regional leader. The time I

4567
02:17:52,848 --> 02:17:54,416
served with him on Arte. He

4568
02:17:54,416 --> 02:17:55,918
always had poignant questions

4569
02:17:55,918 --> 02:17:57,286
and very thoughtful comments.

4570
02:17:57,286 --> 02:18:00,220
And. He always did what he

4571
02:18:00,220 --> 02:18:01,824
thought was best for Norco and

4572
02:18:01,824 --> 02:18:04,127
the citizens of Riverside

4573
02:18:04,127 --> 02:18:05,462
County. So with that we will be

4574
02:18:05,462 --> 02:18:07,196
adjourning are meeting this

4575
02:18:07,196 --> 02:18:07,864
evening in memory of Ted

4576
02:18:07,864 --> 02:18:08,000
Hoffman MAY arrest in peace,