1
00:08:26,914 --> 00:08:29,116
a quorum is present. Oh oh I'm

2
00:08:29,116 --> 00:08:30,948
sorry Mister Mister our

3
00:08:30,948 --> 00:08:33,948
secretary please call the roll

4
00:08:35,422 --> 00:08:37,822
allen archuleta. Atkins bates

5
00:08:39,759 --> 00:08:42,159
bill burgess bradford cappiello

6
00:08:44,263 --> 00:08:46,663
chain dally dodd durazo

7
00:08:48,504 --> 00:08:50,904
galgiani glazer gonzalez grove

8
00:08:52,538 --> 00:08:54,938
hertzberg hill hueso title

9
00:08:58,243 --> 00:09:00,643
jackson jones leyva mcguire

10
00:09:01,246 --> 00:09:03,646
mitchell monning more locked.

11
00:09:04,285 --> 00:09:06,685
Well nielsen pan portantino

12
00:09:09,724 --> 00:09:12,724
roth rubio skinner stern stone

13
00:09:13,791 --> 00:09:16,462
number y. Caskey winner wilk

14
00:09:16,462 --> 00:09:18,799
this President A corpsman.

15
00:09:18,799 --> 00:09:20,600
Members are quorum is present

16
00:09:20,600 --> 00:09:22,633
work our members and our

17
00:09:22,633 --> 00:09:24,968
guests beyond the rail and in

18
00:09:24,968 --> 00:09:26,773
the gallery please rise will be

19
00:09:26,773 --> 00:09:28,505
led emperor today by our

20
00:09:28,505 --> 00:09:30,905
chopped in sister machiko

21
00:09:31,907 --> 00:09:32,408
gorman after which will be led

22
00:09:32,408 --> 00:09:35,408
in the pledge by senator

23
00:09:41,716 --> 00:09:43,485
archuleta. Select a center

24
00:09:43,485 --> 00:09:46,485
ourselves in God's presence one

25
00:09:46,919 --> 00:09:49,623
more time. As you come to the

26
00:09:49,623 --> 00:09:50,926
end of the session I leave you

27
00:09:50,926 --> 00:09:53,591
with the words of sister mary

28
00:09:53,591 --> 00:09:54,128
baptist russell who stature

29
00:09:54,128 --> 00:09:56,962
graces the lawn out there

30
00:09:56,962 --> 00:09:58,632
somewhere. To some young

31
00:09:58,632 --> 00:10:01,632
sisters who are just proclaim

32
00:10:01,665 --> 00:10:03,435
their final vows she said. You

33
00:10:03,435 --> 00:10:06,167
must not now imagine all is

34
00:10:06,167 --> 00:10:09,276
done. On the contrary you are

35
00:10:09,276 --> 00:10:11,875
just now beginning. So as you

36
00:10:11,875 --> 00:10:14,208
transition from the space we

37
00:10:14,208 --> 00:10:15,409
ask God's continual blessings

38
00:10:15,409 --> 00:10:17,981
on your endings and new

39
00:10:17,981 --> 00:10:20,381
beginnings. May you experience

40
00:10:20,717 --> 00:10:23,850
the God of surprises hidden in

41
00:10:23,850 --> 00:10:25,187
the pockets of your daily life.

42
00:10:25,187 --> 00:10:27,887
May you experience the God of

43
00:10:27,887 --> 00:10:29,825
generosity as you bring forth

44
00:10:29,825 --> 00:10:32,695
an abundance of insights and

45
00:10:32,695 --> 00:10:35,950
creativity. For improving our

46
00:10:35,528 --> 00:10:38,233
stays and our world. And May

47
00:10:38,233 --> 00:10:40,435
you experience the God of peace

48
00:10:40,435 --> 00:10:42,272
as your return home to new to

49
00:10:42,272 --> 00:10:45,439
when you read them of growth

50
00:10:45,439 --> 00:10:47,839
and transformation. And until

51
00:10:47,942 --> 00:10:50,378
you return to the senate floor

52
00:10:50,378 --> 00:10:52,447
at the appointed time May God

53
00:10:52,447 --> 00:10:56,647
hold you in the palm of God's

54
00:11:05,226 --> 00:11:08,229
hands a man. Better. God bless

55
00:11:08,229 --> 00:11:10,628
america I pledge of allegiance

56
00:11:10,628 --> 00:11:14,228
to the flag of the united

57
00:11:15,597 --> 00:11:17,968
states of america has. And one

58
00:11:17,968 --> 00:11:20,368
under our indivisible with

59
00:11:27,644 --> 00:11:29,648
liberty and justice for all.

60
00:11:29,648 --> 00:11:31,470
Thank you members as we all

61
00:11:31,470 --> 00:11:33,283
know we have gallagher be

62
00:11:33,283 --> 00:11:34,915
gathering here for our last day

63
00:11:34,915 --> 00:11:37,186
of legislation such legislative

64
00:11:37,186 --> 00:11:40,353
session today we have a lot of

65
00:11:40,353 --> 00:11:40,954
work there were gonna dress

66
00:11:40,954 --> 00:11:43,459
proves of before there will be

67
00:11:43,459 --> 00:11:45,392
none today. Messages from the

68
00:11:45,392 --> 00:11:46,162
governor will be deemed read

69
00:11:46,162 --> 00:11:47,964
messages from the assembly

70
00:11:47,964 --> 00:11:50,666
would be dealing deemed read.

71
00:11:50,666 --> 00:11:51,166
Reports from committee will be

72
00:11:51,166 --> 00:11:53,566
deemed read. Motions and

73
00:11:58,640 --> 00:12:00,308
resolutions. Without objection

74
00:12:00,308 --> 00:12:02,273
the senate journals for

75
00:12:02,273 --> 00:12:04,673
September ninth through the

76
00:12:06,436 --> 00:12:06,653
thirteenth two thousand

77
00:12:06,653 --> 00:12:09,182
nineteen will be approved as

78
00:12:09,182 --> 00:12:09,783
corrected by the minute clerk.

79
00:12:09,783 --> 00:12:13,253
Members now we're moving on to

80
00:12:13,253 --> 00:12:14,454
the daily file. Center

81
00:12:14,454 --> 00:12:14,988
hertzberg for what purpose

82
00:12:14,988 --> 00:12:16,553
thank you an emotion

83
00:12:16,553 --> 00:12:18,194
resolutions I quickly gets off

84
00:12:18,194 --> 00:12:20,920
the desk at the request of the

85
00:12:20,920 --> 00:12:22,130
authors please move file item

86
00:12:22,130 --> 00:12:23,564
number twenty six assembly

87
00:12:23,564 --> 00:12:25,597
measures seventeen twenty by

88
00:12:25,597 --> 00:12:28,597
assembly member a correo and

89
00:12:28,865 --> 00:12:30,350
file item forty a. B. Four

90
00:12:30,350 --> 00:12:32,973
fifty seven by assembly member

91
00:12:32,973 --> 00:12:33,572
quirk to the inactive file to

92
00:12:33,572 --> 00:12:35,703
less bills to work. Thank you

93
00:12:35,703 --> 00:12:36,304
this will note thank you. Now

94
00:12:36,304 --> 00:12:39,304
moving on to the consideration

95
00:12:40,377 --> 00:12:42,478
of the any other. Okay let's go

96
00:12:42,478 --> 00:12:43,412
I sorry senator leyva sorry is

97
00:12:43,412 --> 00:12:45,414
Mister President I was a little

98
00:12:45,414 --> 00:12:47,490
slow wasn't you I request

99
00:12:47,490 --> 00:12:48,918
unanimous consent to withdraw

100
00:12:48,918 --> 00:12:51,954
senate bill two sixty six from

101
00:12:51,954 --> 00:12:52,554
engrossing and rolling and hold

102
00:12:52,554 --> 00:12:56,154
the measure at the desk. Thank

103
00:12:56,491 --> 00:12:57,580
you. Any other items. To be

104
00:12:57,580 --> 00:12:59,458
addressed here under motions

105
00:13:00,997 --> 00:13:03,131
and resolutions. Seeing no

106
00:13:03,131 --> 00:13:04,320
further we're moving on doubts

107
00:13:04,320 --> 00:13:06,937
the consideration of the daily

108
00:13:06,937 --> 00:13:09,937
file we're gonna move first

109
00:13:10,204 --> 00:13:11,906
this assembly third reading.

110
00:13:11,906 --> 00:13:16,106
First up is item thirty two. Is

111
00:13:16,210 --> 00:13:20,410
the. Do we have a manager for

112
00:13:24,751 --> 00:13:25,552
that item. Why because you're

113
00:13:25,552 --> 00:13:29,152
you're a ready for item thirty

114
00:13:34,329 --> 00:13:36,259
two. Mister Clark please read.

115
00:13:36,259 --> 00:13:36,829
Assembly bill eight eighty one

116
00:13:36,829 --> 00:13:39,295
by assembly member bloom an

117
00:13:39,295 --> 00:13:40,633
acrylate housing. Through a

118
00:13:40,633 --> 00:13:43,330
college before george good

119
00:13:43,636 --> 00:13:44,336
morning this resident ab eight

120
00:13:44,336 --> 00:13:46,571
eight one six to reduce some of

121
00:13:46,571 --> 00:13:47,737
the barriers to eighty you

122
00:13:47,737 --> 00:13:49,608
construction by updating and

123
00:13:49,608 --> 00:13:51,676
clarifying the coat. The

124
00:13:51,676 --> 00:13:53,375
measure the several things

125
00:13:53,375 --> 00:13:55,216
first clarify some definitions

126
00:13:55,216 --> 00:13:56,818
of requirements including the

127
00:13:56,818 --> 00:13:58,349
definition of public transit

128
00:13:58,349 --> 00:13:59,751
and eighty use distance from

129
00:13:59,751 --> 00:14:01,519
transit and the types of

130
00:14:01,519 --> 00:14:03,855
existing structures the can be

131
00:14:03,855 --> 00:14:06,230
converted to eighty use second

132
00:14:06,230 --> 00:14:07,224
it removes provisions that have

133
00:14:07,224 --> 00:14:09,624
given cities and recently

134
00:14:10,658 --> 00:14:11,996
broad. Discretion for denying

135
00:14:11,996 --> 00:14:13,798
eighty you permits and finally

136
00:14:13,798 --> 00:14:15,632
it removes the owner occupancy

137
00:14:15,632 --> 00:14:17,801
requirement in the existing

138
00:14:17,801 --> 00:14:19,636
statute which unfairly subjects

139
00:14:19,636 --> 00:14:20,973
eighty use to requirement that

140
00:14:20,973 --> 00:14:23,406
does not exist for any other

141
00:14:23,406 --> 00:14:25,440
kind of housing. Could result

142
00:14:25,440 --> 00:14:27,444
needy use being demolished

143
00:14:28,546 --> 00:14:30,946
increase long term uncertainty

144
00:14:31,714 --> 00:14:33,480
around a units future. After it

145
00:14:33,480 --> 00:14:33,613
has been built the five year

146
00:14:33,613 --> 00:14:34,614
sunset to owner occupancy

147
00:14:34,614 --> 00:14:35,951
provision of the bill. Was

148
00:14:35,951 --> 00:14:38,152
added to give the legislature

149
00:14:38,152 --> 00:14:39,990
an opportunity to evaluate the

150
00:14:39,990 --> 00:14:42,390
impact removing that language

151
00:14:42,653 --> 00:14:45,659
could have ab eight eight one

152
00:14:45,659 --> 00:14:46,259
will help eighty use realize

153
00:14:46,259 --> 00:14:48,830
their full potential and with

154
00:14:48,830 --> 00:14:49,394
that I would urge an aye vote.

155
00:14:49,394 --> 00:14:52,394
Thank you any description of

156
00:14:53,232 --> 00:14:53,798
the bait on this item. Turning

157
00:14:53,798 --> 00:14:56,198
seen none instructor please

158
00:15:00,730 --> 00:15:03,730
call the roll. Allen. Archuleta

159
00:15:03,510 --> 00:15:06,911
I atkins aye bates nobel I

160
00:15:06,911 --> 00:15:10,511
porges. Bradford I can be at

161
00:15:14,386 --> 00:15:17,986
all. Chiang delhi. I dodd I

162
00:15:21,792 --> 00:15:24,792
dorado I galgiani. Glazer no

163
00:15:25,960 --> 00:15:28,960
gonzalez hi grow. Hertzberg I

164
00:15:33,500 --> 00:15:37,100
hill aye hueso. Tado I jackson.

165
00:15:37,236 --> 00:15:40,836
Jones no leyva. By mcguire by

166
00:15:41,974 --> 00:15:45,574
mitchell. Hi money by more lark

167
00:15:47,481 --> 00:15:51,681
I'm a real. Nielsen. By pan by

168
00:15:53,510 --> 00:15:56,510
portantino. I roth by rubio

169
00:15:57,789 --> 00:16:01,989
skinner aye stern no stone I am

170
00:16:03,261 --> 00:16:06,861
burke. By what caskey I winner.

171
00:16:07,232 --> 00:16:10,134
By wilk. Through I because he

172
00:16:10,134 --> 00:16:13,373
moves call. Now moving on to

173
00:16:13,373 --> 00:16:13,937
file item twenty five center

174
00:16:13,937 --> 00:16:16,337
mitchell was prepared Mister

175
00:16:20,610 --> 00:16:22,843
Secretary please read. Assembly

176
00:16:22,843 --> 00:16:23,444
bill five thirty nine by

177
00:16:23,444 --> 00:16:25,583
assembly member the mon an act

178
00:16:25,583 --> 00:16:27,800
relating to consumer loans.

179
00:16:27,800 --> 00:16:29,718
Mitchell for jurors thank you

180
00:16:29,718 --> 00:16:30,786
very much Mister President ab

181
00:16:30,786 --> 00:16:31,787
five three nine colleagues is

182
00:16:31,787 --> 00:16:33,787
an important consumer

183
00:16:34,220 --> 00:16:35,858
protection bill that from my

184
00:16:35,858 --> 00:16:38,590
perspective is years overdue.

185
00:16:38,590 --> 00:16:40,280
Because of our lacks lindy laws

186
00:16:40,280 --> 00:16:41,560
extremely high cost loans have

187
00:16:41,560 --> 00:16:43,598
exploded in california over the

188
00:16:43,598 --> 00:16:45,432
past decade. These loans are

189
00:16:45,432 --> 00:16:46,701
offered in payday and title

190
00:16:46,701 --> 00:16:48,198
loans stores and over the

191
00:16:48,198 --> 00:16:49,836
internet with loan amounts

192
00:16:49,836 --> 00:16:52,305
starting at twenty five hundred

193
00:16:52,305 --> 00:16:54,808
dollars to avoid the interest

194
00:16:54,808 --> 00:16:55,639
rate caps in existing law.

195
00:16:55,639 --> 00:16:58,639
These high cost loans at

196
00:16:58,747 --> 00:16:59,876
interest rates from one hundred

197
00:16:59,876 --> 00:17:01,814
to more than two hundred

198
00:17:01,814 --> 00:17:03,447
percent. And far too often

199
00:17:03,447 --> 00:17:05,248
consumers are unable to repay

200
00:17:05,248 --> 00:17:06,616
them. In fact the senate

201
00:17:06,616 --> 00:17:07,751
banking committee announces

202
00:17:07,751 --> 00:17:09,585
cited a study commissioned by

203
00:17:09,585 --> 00:17:11,540
high cost lenders that found

204
00:17:11,540 --> 00:17:13,454
that nearly 40% of their

205
00:17:13,523 --> 00:17:15,580
borrowers into in collections.

206
00:17:15,580 --> 00:17:16,796
This process result in damage

207
00:17:16,796 --> 00:17:18,130
credit rating for the consumer

208
00:17:18,130 --> 00:17:19,231
and can lead to their paycheck

209
00:17:19,231 --> 00:17:21,631
being garnished their bank

210
00:17:21,697 --> 00:17:23,596
account closed or their cars be

211
00:17:23,596 --> 00:17:25,567
repossessed. The authors of

212
00:17:25,567 --> 00:17:27,572
this bill have worked hard to

213
00:17:27,572 --> 00:17:29,435
find a compromise that could

214
00:17:29,435 --> 00:17:31,340
earn suport from both consumer

215
00:17:31,340 --> 00:17:32,974
groups and reasonable linda is

216
00:17:32,974 --> 00:17:34,943
a lie. And this bill is the

217
00:17:34,943 --> 00:17:37,113
result of those long

218
00:17:37,113 --> 00:17:38,780
negotiations. The bill is

219
00:17:38,780 --> 00:17:40,170
supported by a strong coalition

220
00:17:40,170 --> 00:17:41,113
of local government labor

221
00:17:41,113 --> 00:17:43,840
organizations religious

222
00:17:43,840 --> 00:17:44,821
organizations and veterans

223
00:17:44,821 --> 00:17:45,922
groups to support this effort

224
00:17:45,922 --> 00:17:47,321
including my own board of

225
00:17:47,321 --> 00:17:49,490
supervisors in los angeles

226
00:17:49,490 --> 00:17:52,260
county. After so any years of

227
00:17:52,260 --> 00:17:55,260
failed attempts to address this

228
00:17:55,393 --> 00:17:56,163
problem we ask you. To advance

229
00:17:56,163 --> 00:17:57,831
this important policy that will

230
00:17:57,831 --> 00:17:59,430
benefit both consumers and

231
00:17:59,430 --> 00:18:01,830
reasonable lenders alike I

232
00:18:02,905 --> 00:18:04,171
asked for an aye vote. Many

233
00:18:04,171 --> 00:18:05,838
additional description debate

234
00:18:05,838 --> 00:18:07,206
center y. Costly yes Mister

235
00:18:07,206 --> 00:18:09,473
President I rise today in

236
00:18:09,473 --> 00:18:10,674
support of ab five three nine

237
00:18:10,674 --> 00:18:13,440
as a co author and urge my

238
00:18:13,440 --> 00:18:13,478
colleagues to join me in

239
00:18:13,478 --> 00:18:15,350
standing up for our

240
00:18:15,350 --> 00:18:17,112
constituents no for too long a

241
00:18:17,112 --> 00:18:18,982
predatory lenders have held

242
00:18:18,982 --> 00:18:21,982
sway over this legislature and

243
00:18:22,130 --> 00:18:22,652
blocked attempts to set a rate

244
00:18:22,652 --> 00:18:24,888
caps. That prohibits them from

245
00:18:24,888 --> 00:18:26,560
charging you service fees from

246
00:18:26,560 --> 00:18:28,456
consumers when I started

247
00:18:28,925 --> 00:18:30,290
practicing bankruptcy law

248
00:18:30,290 --> 00:18:33,290
thirty five years ago the

249
00:18:34,197 --> 00:18:34,796
creditors fire say throughput

250
00:18:34,796 --> 00:18:37,796
charge 18% on a five thousand

251
00:18:38,310 --> 00:18:39,571
dollar loan. In we thought my

252
00:18:39,571 --> 00:18:42,636
God it's beyond that twelve to.

253
00:18:42,636 --> 00:18:43,667
10% that people would have I

254
00:18:43,667 --> 00:18:46,390
know all too well that these

255
00:18:46,390 --> 00:18:47,104
predatory loans soon turned

256
00:18:47,104 --> 00:18:49,760
into a mountain of debt that

257
00:18:49,760 --> 00:18:50,943
can never be repaid resulting

258
00:18:50,943 --> 00:18:52,478
in wage garnishment and bank

259
00:18:52,478 --> 00:18:54,114
levees which I've personally

260
00:18:54,114 --> 00:18:56,815
sought. To rein in on my own

261
00:18:56,815 --> 00:18:59,652
legislation I urge an aye vote

262
00:18:59,652 --> 00:19:00,251
on this long overdue piece of

263
00:19:00,251 --> 00:19:02,651
legislation. Thank you senator

264
00:19:05,210 --> 00:19:07,230
roth. Think of it President

265
00:19:07,230 --> 00:19:09,494
Colleagues I too am a co author

266
00:19:09,494 --> 00:19:11,329
of this measure because-these

267
00:19:11,329 --> 00:19:13,231
protections are sorely needed

268
00:19:13,231 --> 00:19:14,165
for all borrowers and that

269
00:19:14,165 --> 00:19:16,340
specifically includes are

270
00:19:16,340 --> 00:19:17,735
vulnerable veterans. You know

271
00:19:17,735 --> 00:19:19,571
federal law prohibits lenders

272
00:19:19,571 --> 00:19:21,138
from charging more than 36%

273
00:19:21,138 --> 00:19:23,305
interest to active duty

274
00:19:23,305 --> 00:19:24,675
military and their families.

275
00:19:24,675 --> 00:19:27,940
And the department of defense%

276
00:19:27,940 --> 00:19:28,253
fought very very hard for these

277
00:19:28,253 --> 00:19:30,378
protections because our service

278
00:19:30,378 --> 00:19:31,715
members frankly should not have

279
00:19:31,715 --> 00:19:33,484
any additional stress put on

280
00:19:33,484 --> 00:19:35,150
them by certain lenders this

281
00:19:35,150 --> 00:19:36,617
bill will ensure veterans and

282
00:19:36,617 --> 00:19:38,652
all californians are protected

283
00:19:38,652 --> 00:19:39,652
from unconscionable fees and

284
00:19:39,652 --> 00:19:41,854
interest rates. Which can

285
00:19:41,854 --> 00:19:43,827
frankly haunt them long after

286
00:19:43,827 --> 00:19:46,610
the principal amount has been

287
00:19:46,610 --> 00:19:46,595
paid off so please join me in

288
00:19:46,595 --> 00:19:48,995
supporting this very very

289
00:19:50,296 --> 00:19:50,832
important measure. Thank you

290
00:19:50,832 --> 00:19:53,232
any further discussion and

291
00:19:54,168 --> 00:19:56,107
debate senator dally. Thank you

292
00:19:56,107 --> 00:19:58,174
Mister President members I saw

293
00:19:58,174 --> 00:19:59,676
this bill in the assembly voted

294
00:19:59,676 --> 00:20:01,750
for and then I got put on

295
00:20:01,750 --> 00:20:02,677
baking when I got in the senate

296
00:20:02,677 --> 00:20:03,811
first time I've ever had the

297
00:20:03,811 --> 00:20:06,211
opportunity to serve under

298
00:20:06,447 --> 00:20:07,849
great chair by the way. This

299
00:20:07,849 --> 00:20:10,518
bill been amended some I think

300
00:20:10,518 --> 00:20:13,860
this is good for consumers it's

301
00:20:13,860 --> 00:20:14,852
abi supporting this bill today

302
00:20:14,852 --> 00:20:16,156
and I know that are a caucus

303
00:20:16,156 --> 00:20:17,192
housing oppose on the bill but

304
00:20:17,192 --> 00:20:18,858
I think this is the right thing

305
00:20:18,858 --> 00:20:21,594
to do for those who have been

306
00:20:21,594 --> 00:20:22,195
taking advantage of in many

307
00:20:22,195 --> 00:20:25,562
situations so I region I vote

308
00:20:25,562 --> 00:20:27,962
this bill. Center grove.

309
00:20:29,163 --> 00:20:31,103
Thank you I am rise in a-

310
00:20:31,103 --> 00:20:32,600
oppose opposition to this bill

311
00:20:32,600 --> 00:20:34,171
and-we have to think about

312
00:20:34,171 --> 00:20:35,939
where are people going to get

313
00:20:35,939 --> 00:20:37,708
credit. If you have bad credit

314
00:20:37,708 --> 00:20:39,943
and you have. Not fulfilled

315
00:20:39,943 --> 00:20:42,145
your obligations in the past of

316
00:20:42,145 --> 00:20:44,681
paying your bills. And making

317
00:20:44,681 --> 00:20:47,183
sure that your credit is good.

318
00:20:47,183 --> 00:20:48,584
Then you can't just expect. Of

319
00:20:48,584 --> 00:20:50,220
a in a financial institution to

320
00:20:50,220 --> 00:20:52,254
take a risk on you when you're

321
00:20:52,254 --> 00:20:54,590
a bad risk in the first place.

322
00:20:54,590 --> 00:20:56,258
The way people get out of that

323
00:20:56,258 --> 00:20:58,661
situation is they get the short

324
00:20:58,661 --> 00:20:59,795
term loans and yes they are a

325
00:20:59,795 --> 00:21:00,760
very high interest rate but

326
00:21:00,760 --> 00:21:02,498
once they go through that

327
00:21:02,498 --> 00:21:04,102
process. Then they go to. A

328
00:21:04,102 --> 00:21:06,340
regular financial institution

329
00:21:06,340 --> 00:21:07,502
and they go look. I used I had

330
00:21:07,502 --> 00:21:09,470
bad credit but over the last

331
00:21:09,470 --> 00:21:11,509
year I've maintain my payments.

332
00:21:11,509 --> 00:21:12,306
At this higher interest rate

333
00:21:12,306 --> 00:21:14,141
and the ease back into their

334
00:21:14,141 --> 00:21:16,310
credit rating so that they can.

335
00:21:16,310 --> 00:21:19,460
Establish a good credit again.

336
00:21:19,460 --> 00:21:20,514
But to require or cat people's

337
00:21:20,514 --> 00:21:22,216
interest rates and I realize

338
00:21:22,216 --> 00:21:23,951
that they do have high interest

339
00:21:23,951 --> 00:21:26,420
rates. But the bottom line is

340
00:21:26,420 --> 00:21:27,318
that. You if you cap it are

341
00:21:27,318 --> 00:21:29,223
they really going to take a

342
00:21:29,223 --> 00:21:31,790
risk and invest and let people

343
00:21:31,790 --> 00:21:33,595
have high risk loans. Out there

344
00:21:33,595 --> 00:21:35,394
so they can try to re establish

345
00:21:35,394 --> 00:21:36,697
their credit. You're asking the

346
00:21:36,697 --> 00:21:37,929
banks or their asking lending

347
00:21:37,929 --> 00:21:39,711
institutions are these

348
00:21:39,711 --> 00:21:41,332
organizations that land to

349
00:21:41,332 --> 00:21:43,198
these. Particular people that

350
00:21:43,198 --> 00:21:45,935
want. To re establish their

351
00:21:45,935 --> 00:21:47,970
credit after destroying it. For

352
00:21:47,970 --> 00:21:50,900
whatever reason. And to have

353
00:21:50,900 --> 00:21:51,140
that to have that cap and not.

354
00:21:51,140 --> 00:21:53,375
And not have a lending

355
00:21:53,375 --> 00:21:54,646
institution available for them

356
00:21:54,646 --> 00:21:55,875
to be able to access credit to

357
00:21:55,875 --> 00:21:57,613
rebuild their credit. Is

358
00:21:57,613 --> 00:22:00,613
something that I think will

359
00:22:01,984 --> 00:22:02,515
cause a detriment to harm. To

360
00:22:02,515 --> 00:22:06,115
them in the long term the

361
00:22:06,922 --> 00:22:08,890
future meyer j. No vote. Thank

362
00:22:08,890 --> 00:22:10,250
you senator dorado. Thank you

363
00:22:10,250 --> 00:22:13,161
Mister President I heard a lot

364
00:22:13,161 --> 00:22:14,362
about these. A payday. Loans

365
00:22:14,362 --> 00:22:16,300
and didn't have a very

366
00:22:16,300 --> 00:22:18,466
favorable attitude but I didn't

367
00:22:18,466 --> 00:22:19,300
think kind of thought the way

368
00:22:19,300 --> 00:22:21,430
my colleague just described

369
00:22:22,503 --> 00:22:24,305
that. It was an opportune for

370
00:22:24,305 --> 00:22:26,840
poor people to get access to

371
00:22:26,840 --> 00:22:29,109
some money but when I saw

372
00:22:29,109 --> 00:22:31,509
actual agreements. Copies of

373
00:22:32,546 --> 00:22:34,281
agreements. Where they had

374
00:22:34,281 --> 00:22:36,681
borrowed two thousand dollars

375
00:22:37,514 --> 00:22:38,819
maybe and it went up to ten and

376
00:22:38,819 --> 00:22:40,320
twelve thousand dollars was

377
00:22:40,320 --> 00:22:43,291
what they were actually going

378
00:22:43,291 --> 00:22:45,692
to pay back. I was floored I

379
00:22:45,692 --> 00:22:47,791
was shocked how could we take

380
00:22:47,791 --> 00:22:50,791
advantage of poor people that

381
00:22:50,829 --> 00:22:54,332
way that means they become for

382
00:22:54,332 --> 00:22:56,799
er indebted. And they can't

383
00:22:56,799 --> 00:22:59,668
keep up and that just seemed

384
00:22:59,668 --> 00:23:01,500
like a complete abuse so

385
00:23:01,500 --> 00:23:03,404
there's a difference between

386
00:23:03,404 --> 00:23:05,773
taking a risk and completely

387
00:23:05,773 --> 00:23:07,939
abusing of poor people and

388
00:23:07,939 --> 00:23:10,812
forcing them to stay in poverty

389
00:23:10,812 --> 00:23:11,381
for many more years so that's

390
00:23:11,381 --> 00:23:14,381
frankly what convinced me to

391
00:23:16,482 --> 00:23:17,951
support this bill. Senate allen.

392
00:23:17,951 --> 00:23:19,119
Thank you Mister President is

393
00:23:19,119 --> 00:23:21,120
one of also mention that we did

394
00:23:21,120 --> 00:23:22,792
put in the senate financial

395
00:23:22,792 --> 00:23:24,991
literacy in this bill so that

396
00:23:24,991 --> 00:23:26,292
we can educate those folks to

397
00:23:26,292 --> 00:23:28,258
what they're actually paying in

398
00:23:28,258 --> 00:23:29,128
a captive so I wanted to bring

399
00:23:29,128 --> 00:23:30,430
that point up I think it's

400
00:23:30,430 --> 00:23:31,661
critical it was it was

401
00:23:31,661 --> 00:23:32,768
something that I think those

402
00:23:32,768 --> 00:23:34,467
folks who are trying to get

403
00:23:34,467 --> 00:23:35,668
that the loans need to know

404
00:23:35,668 --> 00:23:37,990
what's gonna happen in and

405
00:23:37,990 --> 00:23:37,970
hopefully in the future we

406
00:23:37,970 --> 00:23:39,505
would teach these kind of

407
00:23:39,505 --> 00:23:40,639
things in school where the

408
00:23:40,639 --> 00:23:42,407
compounding interest as your

409
00:23:42,407 --> 00:23:43,574
friend if you're saving money

410
00:23:43,574 --> 00:23:46,100
and it your enemy if you're

411
00:23:46,100 --> 00:23:46,610
borrowing money no to the

412
00:23:46,610 --> 00:23:49,246
things. That people to borrow

413
00:23:49,246 --> 00:23:52,246
money needed no. Thank you

414
00:23:52,853 --> 00:23:53,750
senator senator cafiero. Thank

415
00:23:53,750 --> 00:23:55,685
you Mister President I want to

416
00:23:55,685 --> 00:23:57,170
rise in support of this bill

417
00:23:57,170 --> 00:23:59,220
and thank the author for her

418
00:23:59,220 --> 00:24:01,357
hard work on it this is not an

419
00:24:01,357 --> 00:24:02,558
easy space to do work in and

420
00:24:02,558 --> 00:24:06,158
the reason that it's not is

421
00:24:07,166 --> 00:24:09,465
that while we May not like the

422
00:24:09,465 --> 00:24:11,330
interest rates they get charged

423
00:24:11,330 --> 00:24:12,732
the bottom line is that people

424
00:24:12,732 --> 00:24:16,332
need access to money. And they

425
00:24:16,472 --> 00:24:19,410
need a regulated industry in

426
00:24:19,410 --> 00:24:20,773
order to be able to get access

427
00:24:20,773 --> 00:24:22,845
to that money otherwise if we

428
00:24:22,845 --> 00:24:24,479
close off all the alternatives

429
00:24:24,479 --> 00:24:27,916
they end up going to an

430
00:24:27,916 --> 00:24:30,215
unregulated market and so I

431
00:24:30,215 --> 00:24:31,452
want to just say that I really

432
00:24:31,452 --> 00:24:34,225
appreciate the hard work that

433
00:24:34,225 --> 00:24:35,956
went into this I appreciate the

434
00:24:35,956 --> 00:24:38,559
compromises that were made and

435
00:24:38,559 --> 00:24:42,159
I would. Encourage you to vote

436
00:24:42,362 --> 00:24:44,197
yes on this bi. The bill

437
00:24:44,197 --> 00:24:45,699
thank you any additional

438
00:24:45,699 --> 00:24:47,266
comments on this issues center

439
00:24:47,266 --> 00:24:48,634
mature you May cose thank you

440
00:24:48,634 --> 00:24:49,569
very much Mister President

441
00:24:49,569 --> 00:24:51,969
colleagues I would strongly

442
00:24:52,567 --> 00:24:55,567
suggest that we not. Paying

443
00:24:57,372 --> 00:25:00,972
that ninety the k. About credit.

444
00:25:01,712 --> 00:25:03,480
To a search or assume that you

445
00:25:03,480 --> 00:25:06,883
can earn credit by being taken

446
00:25:06,883 --> 00:25:09,883
advantage of. By someone who's

447
00:25:10,989 --> 00:25:11,621
going to charge you 2100% on a

448
00:25:11,621 --> 00:25:14,621
twenty five hundred dollar loan

449
00:25:14,922 --> 00:25:16,258
is just not the case. How many

450
00:25:16,258 --> 00:25:17,862
of us here on the floor know

451
00:25:17,862 --> 00:25:19,925
off the top of your head. The

452
00:25:19,925 --> 00:25:22,262
credit the interest rate you're

453
00:25:22,262 --> 00:25:23,364
paying on your home loan or the

454
00:25:23,364 --> 00:25:26,233
credit cards in your bill

455
00:25:26,233 --> 00:25:29,833
folder purse. How many of us

456
00:25:30,400 --> 00:25:32,372
have been laid or our debt

457
00:25:32,372 --> 00:25:34,405
ratio is increased and our

458
00:25:34,405 --> 00:25:35,842
interest rates have increased.

459
00:25:35,842 --> 00:25:36,776
Had it been proactive enough to

460
00:25:36,776 --> 00:25:38,780
make sure that you call that

461
00:25:38,780 --> 00:25:40,316
credit company or that loan

462
00:25:40,316 --> 00:25:42,315
holder to get that interest

463
00:25:42,315 --> 00:25:45,551
rate down and how quickly did

464
00:25:45,551 --> 00:25:47,530
that interest rate dropped. So

465
00:25:47,530 --> 00:25:49,722
to suggest that one of these

466
00:25:49,722 --> 00:25:52,858
loans is the best way to build

467
00:25:52,858 --> 00:25:54,123
credit I think is not accurate.

468
00:25:54,123 --> 00:25:55,662
If this bill passes will

469
00:25:55,662 --> 00:25:58,127
borrower still have access to

470
00:25:58,127 --> 00:25:59,233
credit. The answer is yes

471
00:25:59,233 --> 00:26:00,398
linder that support the bill

472
00:26:00,398 --> 00:26:02,565
are already serving the

473
00:26:02,565 --> 00:26:03,201
majority borrows who can't

474
00:26:03,201 --> 00:26:06,437
qualify for credit card or bank

475
00:26:06,437 --> 00:26:07,939
loans. The author has also

476
00:26:07,939 --> 00:26:09,644
heard from a number of lenders

477
00:26:09,644 --> 00:26:11,311
into his who were in opposition

478
00:26:11,311 --> 00:26:12,440
to the bill who stated that

479
00:26:12,440 --> 00:26:14,840
they'll reconfigure to comply

480
00:26:15,512 --> 00:26:16,430
with the bill why. Because they

481
00:26:16,430 --> 00:26:18,180
are clear that there is a

482
00:26:18,180 --> 00:26:20,982
market out there. Let's also

483
00:26:20,982 --> 00:26:21,583
not forget that more than one

484
00:26:21,583 --> 00:26:22,584
hundred thousand californians

485
00:26:22,584 --> 00:26:24,856
default in high cost loans each

486
00:26:24,856 --> 00:26:26,570
year. This bill will help to

487
00:26:26,570 --> 00:26:28,890
ensure that they have credit

488
00:26:28,890 --> 00:26:30,428
options in the future. Because

489
00:26:30,428 --> 00:26:30,892
their financial well being is

490
00:26:30,892 --> 00:26:33,892
not being ruined by on

491
00:26:34,280 --> 00:26:35,160
affordable loans. In the event

492
00:26:35,160 --> 00:26:37,231
that none of us have had the

493
00:26:37,231 --> 00:26:37,962
opportunity to have to secure

494
00:26:37,962 --> 00:26:38,901
one of these loans let me walk

495
00:26:38,901 --> 00:26:40,834
you through a real life

496
00:26:40,834 --> 00:26:43,834
scenario. Just so we're all

497
00:26:44,938 --> 00:26:46,907
clear before we cast our vote.

498
00:26:46,907 --> 00:26:49,307
Hey unnamedcar title loan

499
00:26:50,769 --> 00:26:51,344
company. Gave a gentleman alone

500
00:26:51,344 --> 00:26:52,931
for two thousand seven hundred

501
00:26:52,931 --> 00:26:55,931
dollars. With an apr oone

502
00:26:56,780 --> 00:26:59,255
hundred and 23% with a thirty

503
00:26:59,255 --> 00:27:00,215
five month term on the loan. By

504
00:27:00,215 --> 00:27:03,287
the end of the long term the

505
00:27:03,287 --> 00:27:03,854
borrower will pay eight

506
00:27:03,854 --> 00:27:06,254
thousand one hundred twenty

507
00:27:06,526 --> 00:27:09,526
three dollars in interest. A

508
00:27:10,257 --> 00:27:10,894
total of ten thousand eight

509
00:27:10,894 --> 00:27:13,894
hundred twenty three dollars to

510
00:27:14,130 --> 00:27:15,768
borrow twenty seven hundred.

511
00:27:15,768 --> 00:27:17,698
That makes sense you think

512
00:27:17,698 --> 00:27:18,532
that's appropriate or safe for

513
00:27:18,532 --> 00:27:21,532
or something that you would

514
00:27:21,774 --> 00:27:22,335
sign the bottom line when

515
00:27:22,335 --> 00:27:22,907
you're back was against the

516
00:27:22,907 --> 00:27:25,141
wall and you need to twenty

517
00:27:25,141 --> 00:27:28,110
seven hundred dollars. The loan

518
00:27:28,110 --> 00:27:30,176
is secured by the borrowers car.

519
00:27:30,176 --> 00:27:32,781
And in the fine print of the

520
00:27:32,781 --> 00:27:34,253
credit application they ask for

521
00:27:34,253 --> 00:27:37,853
a copy of the borrowers car

522
00:27:40,900 --> 00:27:41,157
keys. This borrower was lured

523
00:27:41,157 --> 00:27:43,525
into the store with signs that

524
00:27:43,525 --> 00:27:45,490
said they speak spanish however

525
00:27:45,490 --> 00:27:46,928
no employees spoke spanish and

526
00:27:46,928 --> 00:27:49,895
they gave him the loan

527
00:27:49,895 --> 00:27:52,330
documents all in english. Those

528
00:27:52,330 --> 00:27:55,633
are the kinds of scenarios this

529
00:27:56,971 --> 00:27:59,400
bill is attempting to. Address.

530
00:27:59,400 --> 00:28:00,971
I for one would never want a

531
00:28:00,971 --> 00:28:03,971
constituent of mine or family

532
00:28:03,973 --> 00:28:04,574
member to be taken advantage of

533
00:28:04,574 --> 00:28:07,574
when they were attempting. To

534
00:28:09,346 --> 00:28:11,100
deal with. Ordinary real life.

535
00:28:11,100 --> 00:28:14,860
Challenges as I tell ryan this

536
00:28:14,860 --> 00:28:17,586
call the dahle team. Most of us

537
00:28:17,586 --> 00:28:18,287
are one or two paychecks away

538
00:28:18,287 --> 00:28:21,723
from crises as a result of a

539
00:28:21,723 --> 00:28:22,288
health issue when the car

540
00:28:22,288 --> 00:28:25,888
breaks down or when the roof

541
00:28:26,898 --> 00:28:29,497
leaks. Everyone should have the

542
00:28:29,497 --> 00:28:31,435
opportunity to be able to keep

543
00:28:31,435 --> 00:28:33,100
their cars pay reasonable

544
00:28:33,100 --> 00:28:35,536
credit and be given the

545
00:28:35,536 --> 00:28:37,471
opportunity to truly in an

546
00:28:37,471 --> 00:28:39,871
honest sincere way build

547
00:28:40,241 --> 00:28:40,875
credit. To be able to take your

548
00:28:40,875 --> 00:28:43,677
their families and secure their

549
00:28:43,677 --> 00:28:45,182
futures. Lots of effort went

550
00:28:45,182 --> 00:28:47,417
into this bill in terms of

551
00:28:47,417 --> 00:28:48,646
negotiations I appreciate all

552
00:28:48,646 --> 00:28:51,321
the comments made by my

553
00:28:51,321 --> 00:28:51,955
colleagues in the floor and

554
00:28:51,955 --> 00:28:54,420
we're asking for an aye vote in

555
00:28:54,420 --> 00:28:55,686
ab five three nine. Thank you

556
00:28:55,686 --> 00:28:56,322
all discussion debate haven't

557
00:28:56,322 --> 00:28:59,922
see some sector please call the

558
00:29:01,430 --> 00:29:04,430
roll. Allen I archuleta. I

559
00:29:05,731 --> 00:29:08,731
atkins aye bates. Bell by

560
00:29:09,935 --> 00:29:12,335
porges bradford aye caballero

561
00:29:13,402 --> 00:29:17,420
by chiang aye daly aye dodd I

562
00:29:17,420 --> 00:29:20,420
dorado I galgiani. Glazer aye

563
00:29:21,312 --> 00:29:23,712
gonzalez by growth. Hertzberg

564
00:29:25,949 --> 00:29:30,149
aye hill aye hueso. For title I

565
00:29:30,186 --> 00:29:33,786
jackson by jones. No leyva aye

566
00:29:34,319 --> 00:29:37,319
mcguire aye mitchell. Hi money

567
00:29:38,693 --> 00:29:41,693
I'm more lark morale nielsen.

568
00:29:44,398 --> 00:29:47,998
No pan hi portantino aye roth

569
00:29:48,400 --> 00:29:52,000
aye rubio aye skinner aye stern

570
00:29:53,306 --> 00:29:56,906
aye stone no burke. Our county

571
00:29:57,877 --> 00:29:58,411
I winner hi wilk by. The sector

572
00:29:58,411 --> 00:30:00,811
please call absent members

573
00:30:03,880 --> 00:30:06,280
bates. For just. Galgiani

574
00:30:10,990 --> 00:30:15,190
growth no way so. More lock no

575
00:30:23,768 --> 00:30:24,335
morrell. Victor please call the

576
00:30:24,335 --> 00:30:27,335
absent members from one last

577
00:30:30,600 --> 00:30:33,600
shot bates. For just. Galgiani

578
00:30:38,750 --> 00:30:41,750
hueso. Morrell. Ice thirty four

579
00:30:41,548 --> 00:30:42,148
knows five. I'm sorry ice

580
00:30:42,148 --> 00:30:45,148
thirty knows five the measure

581
00:30:51,890 --> 00:30:53,959
passes. Members we are

582
00:30:53,959 --> 00:30:55,827
important nonsense pursuant to

583
00:30:55,827 --> 00:30:59,427
senate role forty three a vote

584
00:30:59,973 --> 00:31:00,191
by which a bill was passed me

585
00:31:00,191 --> 00:31:02,834
not be reconsidered on the

586
00:31:02,834 --> 00:31:05,234
last. Legislative day preceding

587
00:31:05,500 --> 00:31:07,671
antrum recess with that said

588
00:31:07,671 --> 00:31:10,671
members please pay attention to

589
00:31:18,213 --> 00:31:18,847
your votes for today. Turner

590
00:31:18,847 --> 00:31:19,414
mitchell for what purpose under

591
00:31:19,414 --> 00:31:23,140
most of the resolutions if I

592
00:31:24,520 --> 00:31:26,619
May. The granite. I'd like to

593
00:31:26,619 --> 00:31:27,820
move ab one hundred which is a

594
00:31:27,820 --> 00:31:29,658
budget trailer bill I don't

595
00:31:29,658 --> 00:31:33,258
have a file number to the

596
00:31:33,828 --> 00:31:36,432
inactive file. This will not.

597
00:31:36,432 --> 00:31:39,432
Ab one hundred. The budget

598
00:31:52,576 --> 00:31:54,576
trailer

599
00:32:00,687 --> 00:32:03,870
. It was like five

600
00:32:05,124 --> 00:32:06,695
hundred fifteen. The with a

601
00:32:06,695 --> 00:32:09,695
mister President Ignore what I

602
00:32:13,468 --> 00:32:17,668
just ask of you. Reverse do we

603
00:32:19,203 --> 00:32:20,640
know it. Reverse. Sir ways of

604
00:32:20,640 --> 00:32:21,242
what purpose under motions and

605
00:32:21,242 --> 00:32:22,907
resolutions Mister President I

606
00:32:22,907 --> 00:32:25,307
request. Mister President I

607
00:32:25,510 --> 00:32:28,510
read. I request silence thank

608
00:32:29,814 --> 00:32:32,214
you. I request unanimous

609
00:32:33,384 --> 00:32:34,215
consent to return senate bill

610
00:32:34,215 --> 00:32:35,216
for sixteen to the assembly for

611
00:32:35,216 --> 00:32:38,216
further action thank you Mister

612
00:32:38,622 --> 00:32:39,690
President this will note.

613
00:32:39,690 --> 00:32:41,425
Jenner mcguire one is resident

614
00:32:41,425 --> 00:32:45,250
thank you sir would you mind

615
00:32:45,832 --> 00:32:46,329
removing file item. Eighteen

616
00:32:46,329 --> 00:32:46,894
eighty three sixty nine

617
00:32:46,894 --> 00:32:49,894
assembly woman river. To the

618
00:32:51,267 --> 00:32:53,269
inactive file. Does will note.

619
00:32:53,269 --> 00:32:56,205
Is there any other actions

620
00:32:56,205 --> 00:32:56,839
under motions and resolutions

621
00:32:56,839 --> 00:33:01,390
if not we're gonna move back to

622
00:33:02,111 --> 00:33:05,800
simply third reading. Item next

623
00:33:05,800 --> 00:33:06,752
item up is item forty seven.

624
00:33:06,752 --> 00:33:07,285
Madam Protium you're prepared

625
00:33:07,285 --> 00:33:10,285
for that item Mister Clark

626
00:33:12,487 --> 00:33:13,960
please read. A some of the one

627
00:33:13,960 --> 00:33:13,689
eighty one by assembly member

628
00:33:13,689 --> 00:33:16,689
maienschein and act really to

629
00:33:17,900 --> 00:33:18,357
hazardous waste. Madam Protium.

630
00:33:18,357 --> 00:33:20,757
Thank you Mister President

631
00:33:21,393 --> 00:33:22,193
members are rise to present ab

632
00:33:22,193 --> 00:33:24,620
one eighty one on behalf of the

633
00:33:24,620 --> 00:33:25,830
assembly member maienschein.

634
00:33:25,830 --> 00:33:27,398
This bill reconciles a conflict

635
00:33:27,398 --> 00:33:28,930
between federal and state law

636
00:33:28,930 --> 00:33:31,330
by clarifying that military

637
00:33:31,333 --> 00:33:32,905
hazardous waste facilities are

638
00:33:32,905 --> 00:33:34,939
not required to pay advanced

639
00:33:34,939 --> 00:33:36,240
fees for permit applications to

640
00:33:36,240 --> 00:33:38,640
the california department of

641
00:33:38,845 --> 00:33:40,208
toxic. Substances control to be

642
00:33:40,208 --> 00:33:42,780
clear the military will still

643
00:33:42,780 --> 00:33:43,480
be required to pay all of the

644
00:33:43,480 --> 00:33:45,452
reasonable service charges

645
00:33:45,452 --> 00:33:47,318
associated with permit renewal

646
00:33:47,318 --> 00:33:49,830
and all other charges approved

647
00:33:49,830 --> 00:33:50,957
by specific appropriation or

648
00:33:50,957 --> 00:33:52,489
federal law. The bill is needed

649
00:33:52,489 --> 00:33:55,910
because a new legal conflict

650
00:33:55,910 --> 00:33:56,291
was brought about by a twenty

651
00:33:56,291 --> 00:33:58,590
sixteen trailer bill which

652
00:33:58,590 --> 00:33:59,992
created a new fee for service

653
00:33:59,992 --> 00:34:02,320
program requiring 25% of the

654
00:34:02,320 --> 00:34:03,497
cost to be paid up front. For

655
00:34:03,497 --> 00:34:05,497
hazardous waste facility

656
00:34:05,534 --> 00:34:07,199
permits the conflict is that

657
00:34:07,199 --> 00:34:08,430
federal law prohibits the

658
00:34:08,430 --> 00:34:10,568
military from engaging in

659
00:34:10,568 --> 00:34:12,771
advance payments. The military

660
00:34:12,771 --> 00:34:14,690
operates seven hazardous waste

661
00:34:14,690 --> 00:34:16,307
facilities throughout our state

662
00:34:16,307 --> 00:34:17,872
on a ten year permit timeline

663
00:34:17,872 --> 00:34:20,100
in support of the military's

664
00:34:20,100 --> 00:34:21,482
national security mission and

665
00:34:21,482 --> 00:34:23,247
to protect public health and

666
00:34:23,247 --> 00:34:25,820
safety. This bill is important

667
00:34:25,820 --> 00:34:26,918
because it specifically affects

668
00:34:26,918 --> 00:34:28,218
a naval base in my community

669
00:34:28,218 --> 00:34:30,320
where the permit is currently

670
00:34:30,320 --> 00:34:32,125
up for renewal. The hazardous

671
00:34:32,125 --> 00:34:33,924
waste facility on naval base

672
00:34:33,924 --> 00:34:36,159
coronado and city county treats

673
00:34:36,159 --> 00:34:38,961
and consolidates a variety of

674
00:34:38,961 --> 00:34:41,961
hazardous waste streams I would

675
00:34:44,567 --> 00:34:45,137
respectfully ask for your ibm.

676
00:34:45,137 --> 00:34:47,537
Any additional discussion or

677
00:34:47,837 --> 00:34:49,104
debate on this matter. Here in

678
00:34:49,104 --> 00:34:51,407
seen nine a Mister Secretary

679
00:34:51,407 --> 00:34:54,276
please call the roll allen. Hi

680
00:34:54,276 --> 00:34:57,276
archuleta aye atkins by bates

681
00:34:59,581 --> 00:35:03,181
hi bill. I porges. I bradford

682
00:35:03,251 --> 00:35:06,851
art hi cambiado I chiang aye

683
00:35:07,230 --> 00:35:09,757
daly aye dodd. By dorado aye

684
00:35:09,757 --> 00:35:12,157
galgiani aye glazer aye

685
00:35:12,727 --> 00:35:15,727
gonzalez by grow by hertzberg

686
00:35:18,802 --> 00:35:22,666
aye hill. I hueso by tado by

687
00:35:22,666 --> 00:35:25,666
jackson by jones. Leyva I

688
00:35:27,720 --> 00:35:28,704
mcguire hi mitchell. By monning

689
00:35:28,704 --> 00:35:32,304
by more lark time real I

690
00:35:35,780 --> 00:35:38,678
nielsen. I pan aye portantino I

691
00:35:40,152 --> 00:35:43,120
roth by rubio aye skinner aye

692
00:35:43,120 --> 00:35:46,720
stern aye stone aye amberg our

693
00:35:48,189 --> 00:35:48,790
cassie I wiener aye wilk hi.

694
00:35:48,790 --> 00:35:52,390
Sir could you please call the

695
00:35:53,658 --> 00:35:55,765
absent members. Jones by. All

696
00:35:55,765 --> 00:35:57,498
eyes forty no zero the measure

697
00:35:57,498 --> 00:36:00,298
passes now moving on the file

698
00:36:00,298 --> 00:36:00,868
item forty eight center pro tem

699
00:36:00,868 --> 00:36:03,700
are you prepared for this I

700
00:36:03,700 --> 00:36:05,873
don't Miss Sector please read

701
00:36:05,873 --> 00:36:06,409
assembly bill twelve ninety by

702
00:36:06,409 --> 00:36:08,409
assemblymember gloria. And

703
00:36:11,111 --> 00:36:13,460
actually in water. Interactions

704
00:36:13,460 --> 00:36:14,716
thank you Mister President. Are

705
00:36:14,716 --> 00:36:15,779
pure water san diego is the

706
00:36:15,779 --> 00:36:17,160
city of san diego's

707
00:36:17,160 --> 00:36:18,785
groundbreaking water supply

708
00:36:18,785 --> 00:36:19,986
program designed to supply one

709
00:36:19,986 --> 00:36:21,921
third of the city's water

710
00:36:21,921 --> 00:36:23,522
supply. This critically

711
00:36:23,522 --> 00:36:25,491
important project has been tied

712
00:36:25,491 --> 00:36:26,358
up and wasteful litigation that

713
00:36:26,358 --> 00:36:28,560
threatens the completion of our

714
00:36:28,560 --> 00:36:30,830
pure water. Project at a time

715
00:36:30,830 --> 00:36:31,930
when climate change and cycles

716
00:36:31,930 --> 00:36:33,765
of drought imperil our water

717
00:36:33,765 --> 00:36:35,368
security. Since June the

718
00:36:35,368 --> 00:36:36,699
project has been stalled due to

719
00:36:36,699 --> 00:36:38,570
litigation claiming the project

720
00:36:38,570 --> 00:36:39,905
violates proposition eight

721
00:36:39,905 --> 00:36:41,707
which is a twenty twelve local

722
00:36:41,707 --> 00:36:43,338
ballot measure. That prevents

723
00:36:43,338 --> 00:36:44,242
the city from mandating project

724
00:36:44,242 --> 00:36:46,242
labor agreements on

725
00:36:46,410 --> 00:36:48,144
construction except when

726
00:36:48,144 --> 00:36:50,778
required by state or federal

727
00:36:50,778 --> 00:36:52,349
law. Ab twelve ninety clarifies

728
00:36:52,349 --> 00:36:53,383
that the project is one for

729
00:36:53,383 --> 00:36:55,215
which state law requires

730
00:36:55,215 --> 00:36:56,752
project labor agreements and

731
00:36:56,752 --> 00:36:58,588
without this clarification the

732
00:36:58,588 --> 00:36:59,686
costs are projected to increase

733
00:36:59,686 --> 00:37:01,790
by four million dollars for

734
00:37:01,790 --> 00:37:03,625
each month of delay. Without

735
00:37:03,625 --> 00:37:05,794
legal certainty state funds for

736
00:37:05,794 --> 00:37:07,128
the project of well over six

737
00:37:07,128 --> 00:37:09,528
hundred million dollars already

738
00:37:10,896 --> 00:37:11,532
invested would be in peril. Ab

739
00:37:11,532 --> 00:37:13,100
twelve ninety in the pure water

740
00:37:13,100 --> 00:37:14,802
project to ensure our water

741
00:37:14,802 --> 00:37:17,802
reliability for the san diego

742
00:37:18,105 --> 00:37:21,705
region for decades to come. I

743
00:37:22,373 --> 00:37:23,100
respectfully ask your aye vote.

744
00:37:23,100 --> 00:37:25,245
Thank you any discussion debate

745
00:37:25,245 --> 00:37:28,116
on this item. Center stone good

746
00:37:28,116 --> 00:37:28,715
morning mr President

747
00:37:28,715 --> 00:37:30,715
Congratulations colleagues on

748
00:37:31,551 --> 00:37:34,551
the last day. Thirteen more

749
00:37:34,585 --> 00:37:37,585
hours of session I respectfully

750
00:37:38,556 --> 00:37:40,124
rise in opposition to sb twelve

751
00:37:40,124 --> 00:37:42,426
ninety sponsored by the union

752
00:37:42,426 --> 00:37:43,727
caucus of the state legislature.

753
00:37:43,727 --> 00:37:45,429
This bill will force the city

754
00:37:45,429 --> 00:37:48,665
of san diego to join a union

755
00:37:48,665 --> 00:37:50,330
project labor agreement. In

756
00:37:50,330 --> 00:37:52,766
order to receive state funding

757
00:37:52,766 --> 00:37:54,700
for their peer water project

758
00:37:54,700 --> 00:37:55,405
water would be an advance

759
00:37:55,405 --> 00:37:57,409
treatment facility that can

760
00:37:57,409 --> 00:37:59,809
produce thirty million gallons

761
00:38:00,607 --> 00:38:01,377
of purified water every day.

762
00:38:01,377 --> 00:38:02,948
Fighting for a third of san

763
00:38:02,948 --> 00:38:05,948
diego's drinking water. Which I

764
00:38:06,450 --> 00:38:07,319
think is very innovative. We've

765
00:38:07,319 --> 00:38:08,720
talked a lot about clean water

766
00:38:08,720 --> 00:38:10,490
on the floor this year so I'm

767
00:38:10,490 --> 00:38:11,450
curious why are now talking

768
00:38:11,450 --> 00:38:13,621
about stopping clean water from

769
00:38:13,621 --> 00:38:14,161
being delivered to millions of

770
00:38:14,161 --> 00:38:16,661
people in our state second

771
00:38:16,661 --> 00:38:17,289
largest city. But let me give

772
00:38:17,289 --> 00:38:20,889
you a little background on this

773
00:38:22,300 --> 00:38:25,300
bill. The people spoke but

774
00:38:27,234 --> 00:38:28,735
proposition eight passed by 58%

775
00:38:28,735 --> 00:38:30,103
in two thousand twelve none of

776
00:38:30,103 --> 00:38:31,604
the city's project opposed

777
00:38:31,604 --> 00:38:34,442
appeal a requirement but I

778
00:38:34,442 --> 00:38:35,307
guess the big lead labor union

779
00:38:35,307 --> 00:38:37,876
bosses didn't like what the

780
00:38:37,876 --> 00:38:40,412
people decide again the people

781
00:38:40,412 --> 00:38:41,430
aren't being listened to and

782
00:38:41,430 --> 00:38:41,580
say to california and frankly I

783
00:38:41,580 --> 00:38:44,446
think her get a little bit

784
00:38:44,446 --> 00:38:45,470
upset. So in November of two

785
00:38:45,470 --> 00:38:46,551
thousand eighteen the city of

786
00:38:46,551 --> 00:38:47,388
san diego in the big labor

787
00:38:47,388 --> 00:38:49,787
union bosses passed an

788
00:38:49,787 --> 00:38:51,286
ordinance that kept. Non union

789
00:38:51,286 --> 00:38:53,286
apprenticeships. And

790
00:38:53,891 --> 00:38:54,392
apprentices from working on

791
00:38:54,392 --> 00:38:57,392
three of the pure water

792
00:38:57,693 --> 00:38:59,861
projects. If big labor bosses

793
00:38:59,861 --> 00:39:01,620
couldn't convince the voters. I

794
00:39:01,620 --> 00:39:02,561
guess they figure they can

795
00:39:02,561 --> 00:39:03,133
intimidate the elected

796
00:39:03,133 --> 00:39:06,133
officials to give them their

797
00:39:06,768 --> 00:39:07,399
nguyen. But about a year later

798
00:39:07,399 --> 00:39:09,670
a lawsuit was filed against the

799
00:39:09,670 --> 00:39:12,507
big labor union bosses. The

800
00:39:12,507 --> 00:39:13,941
court ruled the city was wrong.

801
00:39:13,941 --> 00:39:16,941
and the forcing only union

802
00:39:17,144 --> 00:39:17,614
apprentices to be used violated

803
00:39:17,614 --> 00:39:20,140
the people's intent of

804
00:39:21,248 --> 00:39:21,718
proposition a-after that

805
00:39:21,718 --> 00:39:24,118
ruling legal knows of

806
00:39:24,651 --> 00:39:25,252
negotiations began. And they're

807
00:39:25,252 --> 00:39:28,852
still going on which brings me

808
00:39:28,919 --> 00:39:31,357
here today. Ab twelve mind use

809
00:39:31,357 --> 00:39:35,557
goal is to resolve a city legal

810
00:39:38,331 --> 00:39:40,634
dispute over. As they control

811
00:39:40,634 --> 00:39:42,334
this legislature this measures

812
00:39:42,334 --> 00:39:44,104
intent is to violate local

813
00:39:44,104 --> 00:39:46,574
control and the will of the

814
00:39:46,574 --> 00:39:50,774
voters in the name of big labor

815
00:39:50,976 --> 00:39:51,712
union bosses. How many bills

816
00:39:51,712 --> 00:39:54,311
are we going to see this year

817
00:39:54,311 --> 00:39:56,113
where the union caucus. Is more

818
00:39:56,113 --> 00:39:57,714
important to the voting members

819
00:39:57,714 --> 00:40:00,883
of this body than the citizens

820
00:40:00,883 --> 00:40:02,218
of the state of california. Ab

821
00:40:02,218 --> 00:40:04,954
told mine is nothing more than

822
00:40:04,954 --> 00:40:07,489
another agenda item for this

823
00:40:07,489 --> 00:40:07,823
legislature's famed unit caucus.

824
00:40:07,823 --> 00:40:09,458
Big labor's l

825
00:40:09,458 --> 00:40:10,226
big labor loss

826
00:40:10,226 --> 00:40:12,961
in san diego when they lost

827
00:40:12,961 --> 00:40:13,765
proposition eight. This bill is

828
00:40:13,765 --> 00:40:16,101
nothing more than a way for big

829
00:40:16,101 --> 00:40:18,600
labor bosses to go. To their

830
00:40:18,600 --> 00:40:20,201
friends on the legislature to

831
00:40:20,201 --> 00:40:22,874
change the rules after the fact

832
00:40:22,874 --> 00:40:25,406
to support. The will. Of the

833
00:40:25,406 --> 00:40:28,109
voters in san diego my friend

834
00:40:28,109 --> 00:40:30,911
you can honestly say that this

835
00:40:30,911 --> 00:40:32,120
is the will of the vote voters.

836
00:40:32,120 --> 00:40:33,747
And in some cases on issues

837
00:40:33,747 --> 00:40:35,113
you're agree with them. And

838
00:40:35,113 --> 00:40:37,851
some you just eggs nor there

839
00:40:37,851 --> 00:40:39,987
will. In another issues you

840
00:40:39,987 --> 00:40:41,870
just disagree with them on

841
00:40:41,870 --> 00:40:43,321
those issues the will of the

842
00:40:43,321 --> 00:40:45,860
people is just that you can

843
00:40:45,860 --> 00:40:46,457
pick and choose which issues

844
00:40:46,457 --> 00:40:47,610
you think the people got right

845
00:40:47,610 --> 00:40:48,927
and which ones you think they

846
00:40:48,927 --> 00:40:51,565
got wrong. If you're really a

847
00:40:51,565 --> 00:40:52,897
believer in local control. If

848
00:40:52,897 --> 00:40:54,299
you're really a believer that

849
00:40:54,299 --> 00:40:56,668
the citizens of the state

850
00:40:56,668 --> 00:40:58,969
really control this state you

851
00:40:58,969 --> 00:41:01,174
should vote no on this bill. If

852
00:41:01,174 --> 00:41:02,840
it passes it shows that this

853
00:41:02,840 --> 00:41:04,872
body cares more about taking

854
00:41:04,872 --> 00:41:05,443
care of the unions and their

855
00:41:05,443 --> 00:41:08,378
bosses than listening to the

856
00:41:08,378 --> 00:41:09,646
will of the people. In honor of

857
00:41:09,646 --> 00:41:09,806
the forty million people that

858
00:41:09,806 --> 00:41:10,880
-

859
00:41:10,880 --> 00:41:13,616
depend on us to make good

860
00:41:13,616 --> 00:41:14,217
decisions for them. And not for

861
00:41:14,217 --> 00:41:17,186
the unions I urge a no vote in

862
00:41:17,186 --> 00:41:18,821
ab twelve ninety. Thank you

863
00:41:18,821 --> 00:41:20,958
senator morlock. Thank you

864
00:41:20,958 --> 00:41:21,890
Mister President tie rise in

865
00:41:21,890 --> 00:41:24,791
opposition to a. B. Twelve

866
00:41:24,791 --> 00:41:26,791
ninety. Colleagues project

867
00:41:26,826 --> 00:41:29,640
labor agreements do not have a

868
00:41:29,640 --> 00:41:30,432
successful track record I will

869
00:41:30,432 --> 00:41:32,968
spareou the details but I can

870
00:41:32,968 --> 00:41:34,668
give you plenty. From the city.

871
00:41:34,668 --> 00:41:38,268
And county of san diego. Are

872
00:41:39,606 --> 00:41:41,206
currently. Some 10% of building

873
00:41:41,206 --> 00:41:44,206
contractors in san diego our

874
00:41:46,278 --> 00:41:49,278
union shops. Why shut out 90%

875
00:41:49,378 --> 00:41:50,883
of this industry. Especially as

876
00:41:50,883 --> 00:41:52,688
the good senator from temecula

877
00:41:52,688 --> 00:41:54,330
pointed out when san diego

878
00:41:54,330 --> 00:41:56,589
voters recently voted against

879
00:41:56,589 --> 00:41:58,989
requiring pla's unless forced

880
00:41:59,423 --> 00:42:02,930
to. The court upheld this

881
00:42:02,930 --> 00:42:05,930
ballot measure just last month.

882
00:42:05,796 --> 00:42:08,831
So if you fail at the ballot.

883
00:42:08,831 --> 00:42:10,566
And if you fail at the bench.

884
00:42:10,566 --> 00:42:14,333
You come to the banks of the

885
00:42:14,333 --> 00:42:17,205
sacramento river. And ask the

886
00:42:17,205 --> 00:42:19,707
legislature to do an end run.

887
00:42:19,707 --> 00:42:22,707
That my colleagues is classic

888
00:42:23,211 --> 00:42:25,113
special interest groups. Taking

889
00:42:25,113 --> 00:42:29,313
advantage of this body to do an

890
00:42:30,870 --> 00:42:31,752
end run we should be poor. And

891
00:42:31,752 --> 00:42:33,587
we should be independent and I

892
00:42:33,587 --> 00:42:35,522
respectfully request a no vote

893
00:42:35,522 --> 00:42:36,123
on a. B. Twelve ninety thank

894
00:42:36,123 --> 00:42:39,123
you Mister President thank you

895
00:42:40,910 --> 00:42:41,364
senator mitchell. Thank you

896
00:42:41,364 --> 00:42:42,997
very much Mister President I

897
00:42:42,997 --> 00:42:45,632
rise in support of ab two

898
00:42:45,632 --> 00:42:47,131
twelve ninety. But just wanted

899
00:42:47,131 --> 00:42:48,668
to acknowledge that I believe

900
00:42:48,668 --> 00:42:50,390
it was just yesterday our

901
00:42:50,390 --> 00:42:53,390
colleague from to macula during

902
00:42:55,113 --> 00:42:55,354
the debate on the-student

903
00:42:55,354 --> 00:42:56,277
built talked about. How he

904
00:42:56,277 --> 00:42:56,909
enjoyed the dip the debate and

905
00:42:56,909 --> 00:42:59,809
he wishes we'd had more of that

906
00:42:59,809 --> 00:43:00,810
kind of debate. And yet it's my

907
00:43:00,810 --> 00:43:02,147
very same college from to

908
00:43:02,147 --> 00:43:04,684
medical whose and gave the name

909
00:43:04,684 --> 00:43:06,718
calling at eleven thirte am

910
00:43:06,718 --> 00:43:07,385
the first hour of our session.

911
00:43:07,385 --> 00:43:08,724
Well I would hope that in the

912
00:43:08,724 --> 00:43:11,189
next thirteen hours that we can

913
00:43:11,189 --> 00:43:13,223
all. Of shy away from language

914
00:43:13,223 --> 00:43:14,922
thatgenerally lacks civility

915
00:43:14,922 --> 00:43:16,723
and engaging hearty debate on

916
00:43:16,723 --> 00:43:17,961
the policy issues that. Affect

917
00:43:17,961 --> 00:43:20,361
the forty million california

918
00:43:21,320 --> 00:43:22,466
residents with that I stand in

919
00:43:22,466 --> 00:43:24,703
support of ab twelve ninety.

920
00:43:24,703 --> 00:43:25,634
Thurstone thank you Mister

921
00:43:25,634 --> 00:43:27,736
President you know I've been

922
00:43:27,736 --> 00:43:29,571
kind of came in my comments on

923
00:43:29,571 --> 00:43:31,203
the floor over the past year

924
00:43:31,203 --> 00:43:34,440
but I bring up what I consider

925
00:43:34,440 --> 00:43:37,115
to be a proper description of a

926
00:43:37,115 --> 00:43:37,745
union caucus but I'm gonna tell

927
00:43:37,745 --> 00:43:40,748
you one thing that I strongly

928
00:43:40,748 --> 00:43:41,880
resent on this floor I strongly

929
00:43:41,880 --> 00:43:42,280
resent by two or three members

930
00:43:42,280 --> 00:43:44,280
-

931
00:43:45,188 --> 00:43:45,753
of this legislature lecturing

932
00:43:45,753 --> 00:43:47,919
to me like I'm one of their

933
00:43:47,919 --> 00:43:48,793
kids. You don't. I got a lot

934
00:43:48,793 --> 00:43:50,521
lectures when I was

935
00:43:50,521 --> 00:43:52,292
universities I got a few

936
00:43:52,292 --> 00:43:53,627
lectures from a jewish mom. But

937
00:43:53,627 --> 00:43:54,992
I don't need anybody on the

938
00:43:54,992 --> 00:43:57,130
floor the senate to lecture to

939
00:43:57,130 --> 00:43:58,827
me. About how I should defend

940
00:43:58,827 --> 00:43:59,428
the citizens of the state of

941
00:43:59,428 --> 00:44:01,366
california especially those of

942
00:44:01,366 --> 00:44:04,966
my district. And so I will

943
00:44:05,640 --> 00:44:08,640
continue. To advocate I have

944
00:44:08,840 --> 00:44:11,108
always displayed I think common

945
00:44:11,108 --> 00:44:13,480
courtesy to people on this

946
00:44:13,480 --> 00:44:15,446
floor I don't engage importer

947
00:44:15,446 --> 00:44:17,881
attack in order although I've

948
00:44:17,881 --> 00:44:18,482
been called a racist the

949
00:44:18,482 --> 00:44:19,516
following order order we run

950
00:44:19,516 --> 00:44:21,749
out for the one on the road%

951
00:44:21,749 --> 00:44:22,653
more and I'm just going to put

952
00:44:22,653 --> 00:44:24,821
up with it anymore Mister

953
00:44:24,821 --> 00:44:26,890
President. And further reasoner

954
00:44:26,890 --> 00:44:28,225
stone I'm calling you to order

955
00:44:28,225 --> 00:44:29,123
we're gonna yes seize with this

956
00:44:29,123 --> 00:44:31,158
right now that I just want you

957
00:44:31,158 --> 00:44:32,159
know Mister President that I'm

958
00:44:32,159 --> 00:44:33,894
not going to tolerate being

959
00:44:33,894 --> 00:44:36,130
lectured to anymore I had will

960
00:44:36,130 --> 00:44:37,131
be center stone we-heard loud

961
00:44:37,131 --> 00:44:41,331
and clear I'm not going to let

962
00:44:42,667 --> 00:44:45,667
the institution. Stone when I

963
00:44:45,839 --> 00:44:46,974
see President A quorum. We're

964
00:44:46,974 --> 00:44:47,974
asking all members to it here

965
00:44:47,974 --> 00:44:49,144
too a bit of stability into

966
00:44:49,144 --> 00:44:51,942
corn today this is our last day

967
00:44:51,942 --> 00:44:52,582
of session so. Yes Mister

968
00:44:52,582 --> 00:44:56,182
President or to bring public in

969
00:44:57,947 --> 00:44:59,951
caucus please thank you.

970
00:44:59,951 --> 00:45:01,723
Members were asking you to take

971
00:45:01,723 --> 00:45:03,154
your seats were asking you go

972
00:45:03,154 --> 00:45:07,354
back to your desk and sit down.

973
00:45:09,263 --> 00:45:11,263
Members. Members republican

974
00:45:25,672 --> 00:45:28,672
caucus in the box lounge

975
00:49:11,110 --> 00:49:13,110
. In a

976
00:49:15,111 --> 00:49:15,652
row for what purpose. As a

977
00:49:15,652 --> 00:49:18,520
republican leader point of

978
00:49:18,584 --> 00:49:20,984
personal privilege. Rendon you

979
00:49:22,584 --> 00:49:24,752
May proceed. The decorum in

980
00:49:24,752 --> 00:49:26,723
this house gets thrown out of

981
00:49:26,723 --> 00:49:28,692
whack by mainly one group one

982
00:49:28,692 --> 00:49:31,692
person. And my colleagues are

983
00:49:32,560 --> 00:49:34,950
done. And I'm here to tell you

984
00:49:34,950 --> 00:49:37,950
that decency and respect goes

985
00:49:38,132 --> 00:49:41,100
both ways. And when they have

986
00:49:41,100 --> 00:49:43,770
points on a bill that are valid

987
00:49:43,770 --> 00:49:45,703
and that are not out of order

988
00:49:45,703 --> 00:49:48,644
for you to bully them into a

989
00:49:48,644 --> 00:49:51,706
place of with your role lean

990
00:49:51,706 --> 00:49:54,706
eyes your smirks smiles. Your

991
00:49:55,246 --> 00:49:57,315
hostile looks to my members it

992
00:49:57,315 --> 00:49:58,886
is an acceptable for you to

993
00:49:58,886 --> 00:50:01,118
come on this side of the floor

994
00:50:01,118 --> 00:50:02,252
and come over to the desk of

995
00:50:02,252 --> 00:50:04,570
one of my members when the

996
00:50:04,570 --> 00:50:06,726
chair or the President. Is

997
00:50:06,726 --> 00:50:08,727
calling the house back to order

998
00:50:08,727 --> 00:50:12,590
is an acceptable and I'm asking

999
00:50:12,590 --> 00:50:14,461
you personally to refrain from

1000
00:50:14,461 --> 00:50:17,461
your contact center grow were

1001
00:50:18,135 --> 00:50:18,734
asking everyone to. The column

1002
00:50:18,734 --> 00:50:21,173
today so let's not single out

1003
00:50:21,173 --> 00:50:22,773
any in. Why with all due

1004
00:50:22,773 --> 00:50:23,739
respect Mister President I

1005
00:50:23,739 --> 00:50:25,640
think it's just one individual

1006
00:50:25,640 --> 00:50:28,442
who is causing that conflict on

1007
00:50:28,442 --> 00:50:29,976
the floor with no. No calling

1008
00:50:29,976 --> 00:50:31,976
out individual members senator

1009
00:50:31,976 --> 00:50:33,481
grow didn't name a person did

1010
00:50:33,481 --> 00:50:34,816
the same thing that she does to

1011
00:50:34,816 --> 00:50:37,750
us when she looks across the

1012
00:50:37,750 --> 00:50:39,385
floor senator grow work we're

1013
00:50:39,385 --> 00:50:41,253
gonna shoot to refrain from the

1014
00:50:41,253 --> 00:50:42,588
house okay. Again I would just

1015
00:50:42,588 --> 00:50:44,821
like to call the quorum in this

1016
00:50:44,821 --> 00:50:48,421
house and I would like the

1017
00:50:49,161 --> 00:50:52,161
bulleen to stop. Thank you.

1018
00:50:54,232 --> 00:50:57,232
Membership. Hello back on the

1019
00:50:57,436 --> 00:51:00,436
bill. If my colleagues would

1020
00:51:03,939 --> 00:51:07,539
allow. Ab twelve ninety and the-

1021
00:51:08,577 --> 00:51:11,840
I appreciate. I appreciate the

1022
00:51:11,840 --> 00:51:11,684
conversation and discussion I

1023
00:51:11,684 --> 00:51:15,884
can I can make points I would.

1024
00:51:16,170 --> 00:51:18,722
I would. Point of privilege

1025
00:51:18,722 --> 00:51:22,322
before I go into the language

1026
00:51:22,857 --> 00:51:24,629
or the bill. I have the

1027
00:51:24,629 --> 00:51:27,197
greatest of respect for every

1028
00:51:27,197 --> 00:51:29,399
individual in this chamber. We

1029
00:51:29,399 --> 00:51:31,370
have political and

1030
00:51:31,370 --> 00:51:32,902
philosophical agreements and

1031
00:51:32,902 --> 00:51:35,710
disagreements we always will

1032
00:51:35,710 --> 00:51:35,571
have. Where in the last day of

1033
00:51:35,571 --> 00:51:38,571
session. I will ask each

1034
00:51:39,508 --> 00:51:40,790
colleagues. To remember it's

1035
00:51:40,790 --> 00:51:43,879
going to be a long and tough

1036
00:51:43,879 --> 00:51:45,500
enough day as it is. And I you

1037
00:51:45,500 --> 00:51:46,448
know we can take these

1038
00:51:46,448 --> 00:51:48,848
conversations and to our

1039
00:51:49,287 --> 00:51:52,287
various cacuses as need be.

1040
00:51:52,320 --> 00:51:54,289
And I expect we will. But I

1041
00:51:54,289 --> 00:51:55,624
would just ask for us to move

1042
00:51:55,624 --> 00:51:58,196
along and let's get some work

1043
00:51:58,196 --> 00:51:59,828
done and after I do this really

1044
00:51:59,828 --> 00:52:01,693
important piece of legislation

1045
00:52:01,693 --> 00:52:03,397
to my county. I am happy to

1046
00:52:03,397 --> 00:52:05,330
engage in conversation off the

1047
00:52:05,330 --> 00:52:07,835
floor with any individual that

1048
00:52:07,835 --> 00:52:08,502
would like to come talk to me.

1049
00:52:08,502 --> 00:52:10,504
Mister President can I continue

1050
00:52:10,504 --> 00:52:13,240
with ab twelve night she May.

1051
00:52:13,240 --> 00:52:15,644
continue thank you the points

1052
00:52:15,644 --> 00:52:18,175
are that were made and I do

1053
00:52:18,175 --> 00:52:20,800
know that this issue. Are

1054
00:52:20,800 --> 00:52:21,348
related to how projects get

1055
00:52:21,348 --> 00:52:23,748
done in project labor

1056
00:52:24,214 --> 00:52:26,214
agreements and-how local

1057
00:52:26,223 --> 00:52:29,223
projects get done will always

1058
00:52:29,252 --> 00:52:30,790
be a matter of contention. On

1059
00:52:30,790 --> 00:52:33,791
this project I want to make a

1060
00:52:33,791 --> 00:52:35,759
couple of points. The san diego

1061
00:52:35,759 --> 00:52:38,492
county water authority is in

1062
00:52:38,492 --> 00:52:40,897
support and ask my assembly

1063
00:52:40,897 --> 00:52:43,436
member to bring this piece of

1064
00:52:43,436 --> 00:52:46,436
legislation forward. For a very.

1065
00:52:47,103 --> 00:52:49,169
Very simple reason. Bob for the

1066
00:52:49,169 --> 00:52:50,473
water authority which is made

1067
00:52:50,473 --> 00:52:53,473
up of representatives from the

1068
00:52:53,511 --> 00:52:54,510
cities. In the county of san

1069
00:52:54,510 --> 00:52:57,313
diego eighteen cities in the

1070
00:52:57,313 --> 00:52:57,880
county of san diego.

1071
00:52:57,880 --> 00:53:00,485
Participate are part of this

1072
00:53:00,485 --> 00:53:01,817
water authority. They have

1073
00:53:01,817 --> 00:53:03,653
engaged on this pure water

1074
00:53:03,653 --> 00:53:05,657
project to help san diego

1075
00:53:05,657 --> 00:53:08,657
become more water reliable and

1076
00:53:08,822 --> 00:53:10,827
self sustaining. We are the end

1077
00:53:10,827 --> 00:53:12,426
of the pipeline this project is

1078
00:53:12,426 --> 00:53:15,960
critically important to us in

1079
00:53:15,960 --> 00:53:16,529
terms of frankly not just for

1080
00:53:16,529 --> 00:53:17,430
the county and of san diego in

1081
00:53:17,430 --> 00:53:19,431
the region but to the state of

1082
00:53:19,431 --> 00:53:21,330
california the more. Self

1083
00:53:21,330 --> 00:53:23,533
reliant we are and we've done

1084
00:53:23,533 --> 00:53:24,901
incredible work in san diego my

1085
00:53:24,901 --> 00:53:26,269
colleagues on both sides of the

1086
00:53:26,269 --> 00:53:28,400
aisle know that our delegation

1087
00:53:28,400 --> 00:53:31,740
knows how much work san diego

1088
00:53:31,740 --> 00:53:33,474
has done on conservation

1089
00:53:34,410 --> 00:53:37,410
certainly on storage. By on

1090
00:53:38,181 --> 00:53:40,616
pure water on desalination we

1091
00:53:40,616 --> 00:53:42,851
have been very creative. This

1092
00:53:42,851 --> 00:53:44,853
project is important. The

1093
00:53:44,853 --> 00:53:47,125
resources to get this project

1094
00:53:47,125 --> 00:53:48,190
done more than six hundred

1095
00:53:48,190 --> 00:53:49,925
million dollars have come from

1096
00:53:49,925 --> 00:53:52,561
the state of california. The

1097
00:53:52,561 --> 00:53:53,895
state of california. Basically

1098
00:53:53,895 --> 00:53:55,967
in yes were responsible for

1099
00:53:55,967 --> 00:53:58,933
that I will own it basically

1100
00:53:58,933 --> 00:53:59,500
says that you have to be

1101
00:53:59,500 --> 00:54:02,500
willing to do project labor

1102
00:54:02,803 --> 00:54:04,571
agreements. We stand to lose

1103
00:54:04,571 --> 00:54:06,977
the six hundred million dollars

1104
00:54:06,977 --> 00:54:09,874
that we work so hard to get as

1105
00:54:09,874 --> 00:54:12,710
part of this project. And so we

1106
00:54:12,710 --> 00:54:15,182
can make it about are all kinds

1107
00:54:15,182 --> 00:54:17,284
of issues. Today I simply stand

1108
00:54:17,284 --> 00:54:18,485
here to tell you that we have a

1109
00:54:18,485 --> 00:54:20,253
project that is critically

1110
00:54:20,253 --> 00:54:22,724
important to our county and

1111
00:54:22,724 --> 00:54:24,924
their certainly seems to be

1112
00:54:24,924 --> 00:54:26,390
some discussion over the

1113
00:54:26,390 --> 00:54:28,790
language in our local

1114
00:54:30,441 --> 00:54:31,310
proposition. Proposition a from

1115
00:54:31,310 --> 00:54:33,399
twenty twelve if you look at

1116
00:54:33,399 --> 00:54:36,138
the analysis it says there is

1117
00:54:36,138 --> 00:54:38,370
nothing in measure a to impede

1118
00:54:38,370 --> 00:54:40,539
the provisions of this bill we

1119
00:54:40,539 --> 00:54:43,110
are simply trying to get our

1120
00:54:43,110 --> 00:54:44,608
project done. So for my

1121
00:54:44,608 --> 00:54:46,177
colleagues who want to look at

1122
00:54:46,177 --> 00:54:47,378
it multiple ways you will

1123
00:54:47,378 --> 00:54:49,481
continue to do that

1124
00:54:49,481 --> 00:54:50,850
philosophically what do support

1125
00:54:50,850 --> 00:54:53,215
project labor agreements or

1126
00:54:53,215 --> 00:54:55,148
not. I would also say I'm

1127
00:54:55,148 --> 00:54:56,349
pretty sure that there're are

1128
00:54:56,349 --> 00:54:58,687
projects that have gone well

1129
00:54:58,687 --> 00:55:00,656
and not well but-you know

1130
00:55:00,656 --> 00:55:02,694
examples of successful pla's

1131
00:55:02,694 --> 00:55:04,863
include the hoover dam disney

1132
00:55:04,863 --> 00:55:06,261
world. Our new state buildings

1133
00:55:06,261 --> 00:55:08,296
currently under construction at

1134
00:55:08,296 --> 00:55:09,197
twelfth and new courthouse

1135
00:55:09,197 --> 00:55:11,170
construction throughout the

1136
00:55:11,170 --> 00:55:12,865
state in one of our major

1137
00:55:12,865 --> 00:55:15,174
projects in san diego county

1138
00:55:15,174 --> 00:55:17,772
was under and to my colleague

1139
00:55:17,772 --> 00:55:19,840
from from the south bay in san

1140
00:55:19,840 --> 00:55:21,786
diego county. Remember as well

1141
00:55:21,786 --> 00:55:24,309
that we did a very successful

1142
00:55:24,309 --> 00:55:26,280
first time ever pl a project

1143
00:55:26,280 --> 00:55:27,281
through the water authority and

1144
00:55:27,281 --> 00:55:30,181
we saved money and the project

1145
00:55:30,181 --> 00:55:32,484
was done. By early not on time

1146
00:55:32,484 --> 00:55:33,655
but early so we can debate

1147
00:55:33,655 --> 00:55:36,385
those things we have examples

1148
00:55:36,385 --> 00:55:38,456
of good projects. That have

1149
00:55:38,456 --> 00:55:39,621
gotten done but today what I

1150
00:55:39,621 --> 00:55:41,993
would ask is that you support

1151
00:55:41,993 --> 00:55:43,361
my local community because we

1152
00:55:43,361 --> 00:55:44,826
are trying to get are pure

1153
00:55:44,826 --> 00:55:45,930
water project done which is

1154
00:55:45,930 --> 00:55:48,434
going to help our county be

1155
00:55:48,434 --> 00:55:50,100
more. Water sustainable self

1156
00:55:50,100 --> 00:55:52,500
sustainable and that's what

1157
00:55:52,870 --> 00:55:54,140
this measures about today so to

1158
00:55:54,140 --> 00:55:56,303
give the clarity so that we can

1159
00:55:56,303 --> 00:55:57,974
keep the resources and not

1160
00:55:57,974 --> 00:56:00,974
increase the cost of this

1161
00:56:01,542 --> 00:56:02,790
project I would ask for your

1162
00:56:02,790 --> 00:56:05,679
aye vote in support. Of my

1163
00:56:07,116 --> 00:56:08,855
local. Community in san diego

1164
00:56:08,855 --> 00:56:09,983
to get this project done. Thank

1165
00:56:09,983 --> 00:56:11,910
you all debate and discussion

1166
00:56:11,910 --> 00:56:12,922
haven't sees to Mister Sector

1167
00:56:12,922 --> 00:56:14,193
island mr to center jones.

1168
00:56:14,193 --> 00:56:14,823
Sorry mr President Has a bit

1169
00:56:14,823 --> 00:56:16,926
late getting my microphone up I

1170
00:56:16,926 --> 00:56:18,426
do want to rise in. Opposition

1171
00:56:18,426 --> 00:56:21,563
to ab twelve ninety as I've

1172
00:56:21,563 --> 00:56:22,963
shared on this for many time.

1173
00:56:22,963 --> 00:56:24,700
You know I come from a union

1174
00:56:24,700 --> 00:56:25,963
family and I try to support

1175
00:56:25,963 --> 00:56:27,800
local union products in efforts

1176
00:56:27,800 --> 00:56:30,167
when I can. And when the price

1177
00:56:30,167 --> 00:56:31,967
in the quality is competitive.

1178
00:56:31,967 --> 00:56:33,104
The problem with ab twelve

1179
00:56:33,104 --> 00:56:34,840
ninety is that it seeks to

1180
00:56:34,840 --> 00:56:35,373
force the project labor

1181
00:56:35,373 --> 00:56:38,176
agreement where one is not

1182
00:56:38,176 --> 00:56:39,841
needed or appropriate. Voters

1183
00:56:39,841 --> 00:56:41,947
in san diego have already made

1184
00:56:41,947 --> 00:56:43,381
the decision that p. L. A.'s.

1185
00:56:43,381 --> 00:56:45,880
Shall not be required improper

1186
00:56:45,880 --> 00:56:47,985
on public projects okay unions

1187
00:56:47,985 --> 00:56:49,153
shall not be senate district.

1188
00:56:49,153 --> 00:56:51,553
Unions shall not be

1189
00:56:51,754 --> 00:56:52,222
discriminated against. Nor

1190
00:56:52,222 --> 00:56:54,622
shall they be granted

1191
00:56:54,690 --> 00:56:56,592
favoritism. I can live with

1192
00:56:56,592 --> 00:56:58,124
that decision by the voters and

1193
00:56:58,124 --> 00:57:00,329
I'm mystified why this keeps

1194
00:57:00,329 --> 00:57:01,761
coming up and the major is so

1195
00:57:01,761 --> 00:57:04,761
against following the will of

1196
00:57:08,503 --> 00:57:10,401
the voters. The pure. Increases

1197
00:57:10,401 --> 00:57:12,801
water reliability and security

1198
00:57:13,673 --> 00:57:15,675
for years to come. Frivolous

1199
00:57:15,675 --> 00:57:16,375
legislation such as ab twelve

1200
00:57:16,375 --> 00:57:18,744
ninety will only increase

1201
00:57:18,744 --> 00:57:20,460
litigation which will continue

1202
00:57:20,460 --> 00:57:23,451
to delay the water the pure

1203
00:57:23,451 --> 00:57:24,520
water project I sincerely

1204
00:57:24,520 --> 00:57:28,252
urging no vote on a. B. Twelve

1205
00:57:28,918 --> 00:57:29,988
ninety thank you. Now this is

1206
00:57:29,988 --> 00:57:31,990
there any further discussion

1207
00:57:31,990 --> 00:57:33,324
debate on this item. If not

1208
00:57:33,324 --> 00:57:35,393
Madam Protium you can close

1209
00:57:35,393 --> 00:57:37,128
once again I will close one

1210
00:57:37,128 --> 00:57:40,128
more time by saying. The

1211
00:57:40,195 --> 00:57:42,166
resources in the additional

1212
00:57:42,166 --> 00:57:43,798
four million on a monthly basis

1213
00:57:43,798 --> 00:57:44,668
in the six hundred million

1214
00:57:44,668 --> 00:57:46,936
dollars that the county water

1215
00:57:46,936 --> 00:57:49,936
authority has gotten. If we

1216
00:57:51,770 --> 00:57:51,295
don't successfully deal with

1217
00:57:51,295 --> 00:57:51,908
this issue this costs will be

1218
00:57:51,908 --> 00:57:54,745
passed on to our rate payers.

1219
00:57:54,745 --> 00:57:56,783
And I will tell you that is not

1220
00:57:56,783 --> 00:57:58,180
something that I would like to

1221
00:57:58,180 --> 00:58:00,146
see happen in my county were

1222
00:58:00,146 --> 00:58:03,318
were cost we already are paying

1223
00:58:03,318 --> 00:58:06,318
costs to support. The self

1224
00:58:06,454 --> 00:58:08,454
storage conservation programs

1225
00:58:09,123 --> 00:58:11,580
this pure water program there's

1226
00:58:11,580 --> 00:58:14,225
a lot riding on this and I

1227
00:58:14,225 --> 00:58:15,765
would justsay. I really urge

1228
00:58:15,765 --> 00:58:17,228
your support on something and

1229
00:58:17,228 --> 00:58:19,132
that will save taxpayers

1230
00:58:19,132 --> 00:58:21,665
dollars and at the same time

1231
00:58:21,665 --> 00:58:24,650
honor our commitment. To

1232
00:58:24,904 --> 00:58:25,538
provide reliable water in san

1233
00:58:25,538 --> 00:58:29,738
diego county I ask for your aye

1234
00:58:30,120 --> 00:58:31,410
those. Gosh in a debate I've

1235
00:58:31,410 --> 00:58:33,543
species Mister Secretary please

1236
00:58:33,543 --> 00:58:36,543
call the roll allen. I

1237
00:58:39,182 --> 00:58:42,182
archuleta I atkins. Bates no.

1238
00:58:44,726 --> 00:58:47,592
Atkins I bell by burgess no

1239
00:58:47,592 --> 00:58:50,592
bradford I cambiado I chiang.

1240
00:58:53,554 --> 00:58:57,154
Daly dodd I dorado I galgiani

1241
00:59:00,236 --> 00:59:03,236
glazer. Gonzalez by growth no

1242
00:59:03,639 --> 00:59:07,139
hertzberg aye hill aye hueso by

1243
00:59:07,139 --> 00:59:10,739
tado by jackson hi jones. No

1244
00:59:13,379 --> 00:59:16,152
leyva. Hi mcguire hi mitchell

1245
00:59:16,152 --> 00:59:19,752
by money by more luck number

1246
00:59:20,290 --> 00:59:23,890
rail no nielsen no pan. By

1247
00:59:23,924 --> 00:59:26,924
portantino aye roth aye rubio

1248
00:59:27,892 --> 00:59:31,492
by skinner aye stern aye sto

1249
00:59:32,129 --> 00:59:36,329
no berg by what county I winner

1250
00:59:36,332 --> 00:59:37,670
by wilk no. Secure please

1251
00:59:37,670 --> 00:59:40,670
called up to members chiang.

1252
00:59:44,842 --> 00:59:45,876
Dally glazer. Ours twenty eight

1253
00:59:45,876 --> 00:59:47,978
knows nine then the measure

1254
00:59:47,978 --> 00:59:50,314
passes now members were moving

1255
00:59:50,314 --> 00:59:50,914
on to file item twenty senator

1256
00:59:50,914 --> 00:59:53,616
walker you prepare to take up

1257
00:59:53,616 --> 00:59:56,616
that item. Yes mr secretary

1258
01:00:00,393 --> 01:00:01,458
please read. Assembly

1259
01:00:01,458 --> 01:00:02,162
constitutional amendment

1260
01:00:02,162 --> 01:00:03,630
fourteen by assembly member

1261
01:00:03,630 --> 01:00:06,162
gonzalez an act relating to the

1262
01:00:06,162 --> 01:00:08,162
university of california.

1263
01:00:08,397 --> 01:00:10,730
Senator work. Thank you Mister

1264
01:00:10,730 --> 01:00:11,731
President and members on behalf

1265
01:00:11,731 --> 01:00:14,131
of assembly woman liberated

1266
01:00:14,167 --> 01:00:15,638
gonzalez fletcher I am proud to

1267
01:00:15,638 --> 01:00:17,773
introduce a ca fourteen as a

1268
01:00:17,773 --> 01:00:19,773
resolution tplace university

1269
01:00:20,278 --> 01:00:20,840
of california equal employment

1270
01:00:20,840 --> 01:00:23,240
opportunity standards on the

1271
01:00:23,779 --> 01:00:26,312
ballot. Each of you will be

1272
01:00:26,312 --> 01:00:26,877
sure vote on your own criteria.

1273
01:00:26,877 --> 01:00:29,852
For some of you the issue is

1274
01:00:29,852 --> 01:00:31,387
equity. The state auditor

1275
01:00:31,387 --> 01:00:33,586
reported to us in two thousand

1276
01:00:33,586 --> 01:00:35,986
and seventeen that outsourced

1277
01:00:36,288 --> 01:00:37,756
service workers women and men

1278
01:00:37,756 --> 01:00:40,262
who clean the toilets cut the

1279
01:00:40,262 --> 01:00:43,159
grass. Cook the food an empty

1280
01:00:43,159 --> 01:00:44,429
the bed pans earn on average

1281
01:00:44,429 --> 01:00:47,429
three dollars and eighty six

1282
01:00:47,732 --> 01:00:48,333
cents less per hour then you

1283
01:00:48,333 --> 01:00:51,569
see employees who do the exact

1284
01:00:51,569 --> 01:00:54,342
same work. The state auditor

1285
01:00:54,342 --> 01:00:54,939
found that most of the seven

1286
01:00:54,939 --> 01:00:56,607
thousand to nine thousand out

1287
01:00:56,607 --> 01:00:57,877
source service workers do not

1288
01:00:57,877 --> 01:00:59,874
have access to affordable

1289
01:00:59,874 --> 01:01:01,845
health insurance. And he's

1290
01:01:01,845 --> 01:01:02,346
californians are overwhelmingly

1291
01:01:02,346 --> 01:01:05,346
in the grants in african

1292
01:01:05,983 --> 01:01:07,515
americans. Others if you want

1293
01:01:07,515 --> 01:01:07,953
to make sure that this is an

1294
01:01:07,953 --> 01:01:09,917
issue worthy of a

1295
01:01:09,917 --> 01:01:11,388
constitutional amendment. I

1296
01:01:11,388 --> 01:01:13,890
will remind you that the last

1297
01:01:13,890 --> 01:01:15,828
constitutional minute we put on

1298
01:01:15,828 --> 01:01:16,325
the ballot. Was sca nine he

1299
01:01:16,325 --> 01:01:19,325
went to the ballot with

1300
01:01:20,992 --> 01:01:21,562
unanimous vote. Of this and

1301
01:01:21,562 --> 01:01:23,962
prep practically every every

1302
01:01:24,668 --> 01:01:25,700
senator on this floor. Past

1303
01:01:25,700 --> 01:01:27,168
said it was approved by the

1304
01:01:27,168 --> 01:01:28,705
voters that amended allowed

1305
01:01:28,705 --> 01:01:30,170
homeowners to install rain

1306
01:01:30,170 --> 01:01:31,636
water capture systems in their

1307
01:01:31,636 --> 01:01:34,360
homes without having those

1308
01:01:34,308 --> 01:01:34,810
systems add o increase

1309
01:01:34,810 --> 01:01:36,810
property tax assessment.

1310
01:01:37,875 --> 01:01:40,147
Valuations well there hasn't

1311
01:01:40,147 --> 01:01:41,782
been a single home there has

1312
01:01:41,782 --> 01:01:44,182
been many homeowners who've

1313
01:01:44,385 --> 01:01:44,953
taken advantage this property

1314
01:01:44,953 --> 01:01:47,720
did tax break today we hope

1315
01:01:47,720 --> 01:01:48,587
there will be. Others of you

1316
01:01:48,587 --> 01:01:49,687
might be concerned about ham

1317
01:01:49,687 --> 01:01:51,352
stringing you see medical

1318
01:01:51,352 --> 01:01:52,857
centers and denying them

1319
01:01:52,857 --> 01:01:55,920
necessary flexibility to meet

1320
01:01:55,920 --> 01:01:57,261
fluctuations in patient counts

1321
01:01:57,261 --> 01:01:59,950
other temporary staffing needs.

1322
01:01:59,950 --> 01:02:00,764
I want to direct you to your

1323
01:02:00,764 --> 01:02:03,831
attention to page five of the

1324
01:02:03,831 --> 01:02:05,202
aca we actually amended into

1325
01:02:05,202 --> 01:02:07,670
the measure uc's own per diem

1326
01:02:07,670 --> 01:02:10,600
employee policy to allow that

1327
01:02:10,600 --> 01:02:11,144
flexibility. And the senator

1328
01:02:11,144 --> 01:02:13,342
from santa ana added an

1329
01:02:13,342 --> 01:02:13,976
amendment to further guarantee

1330
01:02:13,976 --> 01:02:16,976
flexibility for you see medical

1331
01:02:18,647 --> 01:02:19,114
centers. In addition to equity

1332
01:02:19,114 --> 01:02:21,514
another concern that I

1333
01:02:24,287 --> 01:02:26,221
personally had was cost. An

1334
01:02:26,221 --> 01:02:27,856
analysis was conducted by mike

1335
01:02:27,856 --> 01:02:31,456
gymnast who many you know was

1336
01:02:31,529 --> 01:02:32,270
that the director of finance

1337
01:02:32,270 --> 01:02:34,427
for our last republican

1338
01:02:35,596 --> 01:02:37,596
governor arnold schwarzenegger.

1339
01:02:37,598 --> 01:02:40,107
In his analysis was clear that

1340
01:02:40,107 --> 01:02:41,703
he ca fourteen meets the

1341
01:02:41,703 --> 01:02:43,870
standards of republican fiscal

1342
01:02:43,870 --> 01:02:45,572
prudence. The increased cost of

1343
01:02:45,572 --> 01:02:47,541
wishing benefit parity for the

1344
01:02:47,541 --> 01:02:49,577
service workers is completely

1345
01:02:49,577 --> 01:02:50,943
offset by the savings in

1346
01:02:50,943 --> 01:02:53,112
overhead and still leaves

1347
01:02:53,112 --> 01:02:55,800
according to my chen s. Thirty

1348
01:02:55,800 --> 01:02:56,746
eight million dollars for any

1349
01:02:56,746 --> 01:02:58,746
overhead or administrative

1350
01:02:59,118 --> 01:03:00,519
costs you see might incur.

1351
01:03:00,519 --> 01:03:03,255
allow me to read the last

1352
01:03:03,255 --> 01:03:04,555
sentence of his analysis quote

1353
01:03:04,555 --> 01:03:06,358
we conclude that you see can

1354
01:03:06,358 --> 01:03:07,325
absorb the cost to be ca

1355
01:03:07,325 --> 01:03:09,127
fourteen within the amounts

1356
01:03:09,127 --> 01:03:11,527
currently budgeted for the

1357
01:03:11,595 --> 01:03:13,995
existing contracts in quote.

1358
01:03:14,980 --> 01:03:17,203
Senators the work has been done

1359
01:03:17,203 --> 01:03:18,439
this case is clear and clean

1360
01:03:18,439 --> 01:03:21,138
and if we have the powers of

1361
01:03:21,138 --> 01:03:23,342
body to adopt a ca fourteen. I

1362
01:03:23,342 --> 01:03:25,643
am confident we would. But that

1363
01:03:25,643 --> 01:03:27,411
power is reserved to the voters

1364
01:03:27,411 --> 01:03:31,110
so let's give the people who

1365
01:03:31,481 --> 01:03:31,916
elect us the chance to adopt

1366
01:03:31,916 --> 01:03:33,916
the equal employment

1367
01:03:35,452 --> 01:03:37,220
opportunity standard act.

1368
01:03:37,220 --> 01:03:37,783
Without a respectfully ask for

1369
01:03:37,783 --> 01:03:39,721
an aye vote thank you Madam

1370
01:03:39,721 --> 01:03:40,654
Project. Thank you Mister

1371
01:03:40,654 --> 01:03:42,889
President colleagues I rise

1372
01:03:42,889 --> 01:03:45,358
today in strong support of a ca

1373
01:03:45,358 --> 01:03:46,857
fourteen. Some May wonder why

1374
01:03:46,857 --> 01:03:48,728
the legislature's taken up the

1375
01:03:48,728 --> 01:03:51,661
issue and I think the answer to

1376
01:03:51,661 --> 01:03:53,467
that is simple we must. We must

1377
01:03:53,467 --> 01:03:54,967
because the state constitution

1378
01:03:54,967 --> 01:03:57,200
gives the uc regents power over

1379
01:03:57,200 --> 01:03:58,605
the university of california.

1380
01:03:58,605 --> 01:04:00,736
And it is the only way to

1381
01:04:00,736 --> 01:04:03,642
address an issue plaguing the

1382
01:04:03,642 --> 01:04:06,800
system. I and that is through a

1383
01:04:06,800 --> 01:04:07,343
constitutional amendment. We

1384
01:04:07,343 --> 01:04:09,548
must because working people

1385
01:04:09,548 --> 01:04:10,243
employed in our renowned

1386
01:04:10,243 --> 01:04:12,518
university system are getting

1387
01:04:12,518 --> 01:04:13,784
cut out of jobs. They're

1388
01:04:13,784 --> 01:04:16,185
getting cut out of the middl

1389
01:04:16,185 --> 01:04:18,419
class. Higher education is the

1390
01:04:18,419 --> 01:04:19,751
backbone of our middle class

1391
01:04:19,751 --> 01:04:21,822
and the university of

1392
01:04:21,822 --> 01:04:24,125
california is the crown jewel

1393
01:04:24,125 --> 01:04:25,789
of our higher education system.

1394
01:04:25,789 --> 01:04:27,627
But the uc undermines its

1395
01:04:27,627 --> 01:04:29,128
benefits to the middle class by

1396
01:04:29,128 --> 01:04:31,564
failing to provide stable a

1397
01:04:31,564 --> 01:04:33,964
stable lifestyle for the

1398
01:04:35,670 --> 01:04:37,470
workers that the uc depends on.

1399
01:04:37,470 --> 01:04:39,438
Over the last four years the uc

1400
01:04:39,438 --> 01:04:41,443
has contracted out thousands of

1401
01:04:41,443 --> 01:04:43,110
support services jobs for the

1402
01:04:43,110 --> 01:04:45,740
university it's an economic

1403
01:04:45,740 --> 01:04:46,678
decision seemingly made without

1404
01:04:46,678 --> 01:04:48,947
consideration of how these

1405
01:04:48,947 --> 01:04:51,450
choices made by the uc affect

1406
01:04:51,450 --> 01:04:53,119
the lives of their workers.

1407
01:04:53,119 --> 01:04:55,890
Each time the uc makes this

1408
01:04:55,890 --> 01:04:56,521
choice eliminates the stability

1409
01:04:56,521 --> 01:04:57,555
of a job that has health

1410
01:04:57,555 --> 01:04:59,555
benefits and aecure

1411
01:04:59,991 --> 01:05:02,391
retirement. The legislature has

1412
01:05:02,760 --> 01:05:04,950
tried to address this issue in

1413
01:05:04,950 --> 01:05:06,495
recent years with multiple

1414
01:05:07,196 --> 01:05:08,163
bills an audience unfortunately

1415
01:05:08,163 --> 01:05:10,599
none of this has led to the

1416
01:05:10,599 --> 01:05:11,463
university change let the

1417
01:05:11,463 --> 01:05:12,567
university to change its

1418
01:05:12,567 --> 01:05:14,472
behavior despite the clear

1419
01:05:14,472 --> 01:05:17,338
intent. And message sent by the

1420
01:05:17,338 --> 01:05:19,874
legislature. This is been an

1421
01:05:19,874 --> 01:05:21,309
issue for decades. The uc has

1422
01:05:21,309 --> 01:05:23,246
been contracting out and

1423
01:05:23,246 --> 01:05:23,778
attempting to circumvent its

1424
01:05:23,778 --> 01:05:26,778
own workers for more than

1425
01:05:27,140 --> 01:05:27,948
thirty years. Back in nineteen

1426
01:05:27,948 --> 01:05:29,781
eighty three ucla harden

1427
01:05:29,781 --> 01:05:31,510
outside custodial form to

1428
01:05:31,510 --> 01:05:33,510
service a gymnastics

1429
01:05:33,256 --> 01:05:35,122
championship. And threaten to

1430
01:05:35,122 --> 01:05:37,524
use contract estonians for the

1431
01:05:37,524 --> 01:05:39,857
nineteen eighty four olympics.

1432
01:05:39,857 --> 01:05:40,457
The hiring choices made in the

1433
01:05:40,457 --> 01:05:42,860
eighties were a short sighted

1434
01:05:42,860 --> 01:05:45,660
then as they are today. Farming

1435
01:05:45,660 --> 01:05:46,897
out low wage jobs resulted

1436
01:05:46,897 --> 01:05:48,668
workers being forced to live on

1437
01:05:48,668 --> 01:05:49,970
the friends and having to rely

1438
01:05:49,970 --> 01:05:51,837
on government subsidies and

1439
01:05:51,837 --> 01:05:53,507
health care. Choosing to

1440
01:05:53,507 --> 01:05:54,573
provide stable jobs on the

1441
01:05:54,573 --> 01:05:56,375
front in insures that people

1442
01:05:56,375 --> 01:05:57,209
can provide for their families

1443
01:05:57,209 --> 01:05:59,610
and have access to health

1444
01:05:59,610 --> 01:06:01,480
benefits retirement every uc

1445
01:06:01,480 --> 01:06:03,130
employees should have that

1446
01:06:03,130 --> 01:06:03,848
stability. They should be able

1447
01:06:03,848 --> 01:06:05,348
to raise their children to

1448
01:06:05,348 --> 01:06:06,516
flourish and hopefully one day

1449
01:06:06,516 --> 01:06:08,615
in role at one of our great

1450
01:06:08,615 --> 01:06:10,417
universities that is the

1451
01:06:10,417 --> 01:06:12,488
california dream that builds a

1452
01:06:12,488 --> 01:06:14,540
stronger middle class. We're

1453
01:06:14,540 --> 01:06:16,540
talking about nursing

1454
01:06:16,656 --> 01:06:17,726
assistants cooks custodian

1455
01:06:17,726 --> 01:06:19,726
sterile processing technicians

1456
01:06:20,930 --> 01:06:21,530
grounds keepers. These are the

1457
01:06:21,530 --> 01:06:23,398
workers doing the dirty tough

1458
01:06:23,398 --> 01:06:25,133
jobs the workers whose efforts

1459
01:06:25,133 --> 01:06:26,401
might not be top of the mind

1460
01:06:26,401 --> 01:06:28,839
when you think of you see arts

1461
01:06:28,839 --> 01:06:29,637
medical centers. But their

1462
01:06:29,637 --> 01:06:32,242
internal to the success of our

1463
01:06:32,242 --> 01:06:33,571
university system. The average

1464
01:06:33,571 --> 01:06:36,476
support service worker you see

1465
01:06:36,476 --> 01:06:37,770
is paid on average as I said

1466
01:06:37,770 --> 01:06:39,477
thirty eight thousand dollars

1467
01:06:40,113 --> 01:06:43,113
per year. Which is ironically

1468
01:06:43,183 --> 01:06:43,750
the average take home pay. For

1469
01:06:43,750 --> 01:06:46,750
the uc senior executives per

1470
01:06:48,955 --> 01:06:49,922
month. Will a ca hinder the

1471
01:06:49,922 --> 01:06:52,458
uc's ability to run their

1472
01:06:52,458 --> 01:06:55,270
medical centers I think the

1473
01:06:55,270 --> 01:06:56,929
manager of the bill responded

1474
01:06:56,929 --> 01:07:00,466
to that issue so I don't need

1475
01:07:00,466 --> 01:07:01,660
to go further into that. The

1476
01:07:01,660 --> 01:07:03,466
aca fourteen makes provisions

1477
01:07:04,333 --> 01:07:06,333
for those situations.

1478
01:07:07,873 --> 01:07:10,800
Contracting out has its place.

1479
01:07:10,800 --> 01:07:11,142
And this measure continues to

1480
01:07:11,142 --> 01:07:14,409
allow for per diem employees as

1481
01:07:14,409 --> 01:07:18,900
also was mentioned so I think

1482
01:07:18,916 --> 01:07:19,550
the university of california.

1483
01:07:19,550 --> 01:07:23,150
Should see what change needs to

1484
01:07:23,654 --> 01:07:24,722
happen now. It is a phenomenal

1485
01:07:24,722 --> 01:07:27,122
institution that we're all

1486
01:07:27,390 --> 01:07:28,594
proud to champion aca fourteen

1487
01:07:28,594 --> 01:07:30,259
interests that are private also

1488
01:07:30,259 --> 01:07:32,958
can extend to the uc's

1489
01:07:32,958 --> 01:07:34,862
practices as an employer.

1490
01:07:34,862 --> 01:07:36,397
Colleagues we passed a law this

1491
01:07:36,397 --> 01:07:38,800
week that holds corporations to

1492
01:07:38,800 --> 01:07:39,734
a higher standard and disallows

1493
01:07:39,734 --> 01:07:41,399
classifying employees as

1494
01:07:41,399 --> 01:07:44,380
contractors in order to skirt

1495
01:07:44,380 --> 01:07:45,372
fair wages and benefits. We

1496
01:07:45,372 --> 01:07:46,807
should hold the university of

1497
01:07:46,807 --> 01:07:49,807
california to the similar high

1498
01:07:52,746 --> 01:07:53,847
standards. In the end a ca

1499
01:07:53,847 --> 01:07:55,415
fourteen simply allows for the

1500
01:07:55,415 --> 01:07:57,279
voters of california to decide

1501
01:07:57,279 --> 01:07:59,417
what is best for the uc and its

1502
01:07:59,417 --> 01:08:02,417
workers and their families. On

1503
01:08:02,453 --> 01:08:03,870
a more personal note you know I

1504
01:08:03,870 --> 01:08:05,423
know it seems like I've already

1505
01:08:05,423 --> 01:08:07,991
talked a lot this morning. But

1506
01:08:07,991 --> 01:08:09,860
in fact I've managed only three

1507
01:08:09,860 --> 01:08:12,260
bills all district related

1508
01:08:13,163 --> 01:08:15,699
bills only three. And one major

1509
01:08:15,699 --> 01:08:18,380
bill the tenet protections bill

1510
01:08:18,380 --> 01:08:19,233
I am speaking on this one

1511
01:08:19,233 --> 01:08:20,970
because I believe it is

1512
01:08:20,970 --> 01:08:22,405
critically important if we're

1513
01:08:22,405 --> 01:08:24,707
going to take the actions that

1514
01:08:24,707 --> 01:08:27,210
we take here to support workers

1515
01:08:27,210 --> 01:08:29,715
I don't see how we cannot take

1516
01:08:29,715 --> 01:08:31,614
this action today and at least.

1517
01:08:31,614 --> 01:08:33,816
Give the voters of california

1518
01:08:33,816 --> 01:08:36,850
the opportunity to weigh in on

1519
01:08:36,850 --> 01:08:37,386
this issue they have that right

1520
01:08:37,386 --> 01:08:39,488
I would ask for your aye vote

1521
01:08:39,488 --> 01:08:41,625
on a ca fourteen. This is an

1522
01:08:41,625 --> 01:08:43,625
incredibly important measure.

1523
01:08:46,695 --> 01:08:49,695
You center our gelato. Thank

1524
01:08:49,898 --> 01:08:52,298
you thank yomister President.

1525
01:08:52,832 --> 01:08:56,605
I rise today is proud co author.

1526
01:08:56,605 --> 01:08:58,304
Ac a fourteen great leaders in

1527
01:08:58,304 --> 01:09:00,272
our nation are for services

1528
01:09:00,272 --> 01:09:01,974
have always made sure that our

1529
01:09:01,974 --> 01:09:04,242
soldiers holding the lowest

1530
01:09:04,242 --> 01:09:06,645
ranks are being taken of taking

1531
01:09:06,645 --> 01:09:09,516
care of each and every day we

1532
01:09:09,516 --> 01:09:11,380
say that again great leaders in

1533
01:09:11,380 --> 01:09:13,415
our nation's armed services

1534
01:09:13,415 --> 01:09:15,185
have always made sure that our

1535
01:09:15,185 --> 01:09:17,585
soldiers holding the lowest

1536
01:09:17,855 --> 01:09:20,855
ranks have always been taken

1537
01:09:21,391 --> 01:09:22,392
care of first. Leadership that

1538
01:09:22,392 --> 01:09:24,127
is being taught in our military

1539
01:09:24,127 --> 01:09:25,796
institutions emphasized that an

1540
01:09:25,796 --> 01:09:27,730
officer someone and leadership

1541
01:09:27,730 --> 01:09:29,600
position must always take care

1542
01:09:29,600 --> 01:09:31,967
of his subordinates first and

1543
01:09:31,967 --> 01:09:34,236
foremost the government we lead

1544
01:09:34,236 --> 01:09:36,972
it should do the same sadly our

1545
01:09:36,972 --> 01:09:39,372
university of california at

1546
01:09:40,420 --> 01:09:41,643
deviated from these core values.

1547
01:09:41,643 --> 01:09:42,975
Even if you're cooking cleaning

1548
01:09:42,975 --> 01:09:45,177
cutting the grass you're

1549
01:09:45,177 --> 01:09:48,283
working for the uc system you

1550
01:09:48,283 --> 01:09:49,484
should be paid as a uc employee.

1551
01:09:49,484 --> 01:09:50,816
terry runs on the principle of

1552
01:09:50,816 --> 01:09:52,122
equality and merit and so

1553
01:09:52,122 --> 01:09:54,322
should our university of

1554
01:09:54,322 --> 01:09:57,255
california system this is why I

1555
01:09:57,255 --> 01:09:57,825
urge an aye vote. Thank you

1556
01:09:57,825 --> 01:10:00,225
Mister President you senator

1557
01:10:00,995 --> 01:10:03,395
morlock. Thank you Mister

1558
01:10:05,365 --> 01:10:08,132
President. I rise in opposition

1559
01:10:08,132 --> 01:10:08,669
to a ca fourteen. It's sort of

1560
01:10:08,669 --> 01:10:11,669
comes into that who's your

1561
01:10:12,806 --> 01:10:13,440
daddy. Category is it gonna be

1562
01:10:13,440 --> 01:10:17,374
management or is it going to be

1563
01:10:17,374 --> 01:10:19,645
labor. Colleagues the uc system

1564
01:10:19,645 --> 01:10:20,245
had an unrestricted net deficit

1565
01:10:20,245 --> 01:10:23,845
the last two years of nineteen

1566
01:10:27,751 --> 01:10:28,357
billion dollars. This is due to

1567
01:10:28,357 --> 01:10:31,357
grting great benefits to its

1568
01:10:34,521 --> 01:10:37,521
workforce. Mainly the an. Paid

1569
01:10:37,624 --> 01:10:39,326
retiree medical liabilities. So

1570
01:10:39,326 --> 01:10:42,926
the uc system is facing fiscal

1571
01:10:44,431 --> 01:10:46,831
stress. Taking cost saving

1572
01:10:49,500 --> 01:10:50,101
outsourcing off the table. Will.

1573
01:10:50,101 --> 01:10:53,701
At the end result in increased

1574
01:10:53,768 --> 01:10:56,768
tuition. The moneyhas to come

1575
01:10:57,741 --> 01:11:00,430
from somewhere. No wonder the

1576
01:11:00,430 --> 01:11:02,879
uc system itself opposes ac

1577
01:11:02,879 --> 01:11:05,279
eight fourteen. The border

1578
01:11:05,548 --> 01:11:07,951
regions will point to this

1579
01:11:07,951 --> 01:11:09,953
legislature and the voters

1580
01:11:09,953 --> 01:11:11,954
should the proposition succeed

1581
01:11:11,954 --> 01:11:13,956
when it announces its next

1582
01:11:13,956 --> 01:11:15,457
tuition increase. And they will

1583
01:11:15,457 --> 01:11:19,570
have the right to do so.

1584
01:11:19,194 --> 01:11:19,795
Consequently. I believe the

1585
01:11:19,795 --> 01:11:22,528
voters will oppose the ballot

1586
01:11:22,528 --> 01:11:24,267
measure. But we should save

1587
01:11:24,267 --> 01:11:24,800
them the frustration of telling

1588
01:11:24,800 --> 01:11:27,200
sacramento to let managers

1589
01:11:28,804 --> 01:11:31,370
manage. I respectfully urge a

1590
01:11:31,370 --> 01:11:31,970
no vote on a ca fourteen thank

1591
01:11:31,970 --> 01:11:34,970
you Mister President thank you

1592
01:11:34,976 --> 01:11:36,608
center white house. Mister

1593
01:11:36,608 --> 01:11:39,800
President yesterday during the

1594
01:11:39,381 --> 01:11:41,717
prayer our own system michelle

1595
01:11:41,717 --> 01:11:44,118
gorman quoted from alice walker

1596
01:11:44,118 --> 01:11:46,753
in you May recall it was wake

1597
01:11:46,753 --> 01:11:48,188
up the world has changed. You

1598
01:11:48,188 --> 01:11:49,656
know we cannot in good

1599
01:11:49,656 --> 01:11:51,226
conscience tell private

1600
01:11:51,226 --> 01:11:53,226
industry to treat their

1601
01:11:53,226 --> 01:11:54,396
employers their employees as

1602
01:11:54,396 --> 01:11:56,796
employees and not independent

1603
01:11:56,862 --> 01:11:58,665
contractors while tolerating

1604
01:11:58,665 --> 01:12:00,200
the same behavior within our

1605
01:12:00,200 --> 01:12:02,402
own university of california

1606
01:12:02,434 --> 01:12:04,367
system. The fact that you see

1607
01:12:04,367 --> 01:12:06,271
itself estimates that this

1608
01:12:06,271 --> 01:12:08,271
constitutional amendment would

1609
01:12:09,405 --> 01:12:10,500
force them to increase wages

1610
01:12:10,500 --> 01:12:13,380
and benefit levels by at least

1611
01:12:13,380 --> 01:12:14,949
25% the that means that they're

1612
01:12:14,949 --> 01:12:16,481
under compensating hundreds of

1613
01:12:16,481 --> 01:12:18,881
contract workers for twenty

1614
01:12:18,919 --> 01:12:22,530
five percent. We need to combat

1615
01:12:22,530 --> 01:12:24,955
combat this down rules pressure

1616
01:12:24,955 --> 01:12:27,121
on wages in our own house I'm

1617
01:12:27,121 --> 01:12:30,721
also co author energy nay vote.

1618
01:12:35,594 --> 01:12:37,632
Thank you senator glazers.

1619
01:12:37,632 --> 01:12:41,136
Thank you a Mister President to

1620
01:12:41,136 --> 01:12:42,370
and members I know that the

1621
01:12:42,370 --> 01:12:45,409
sponsors of this measure in the

1622
01:12:45,409 --> 01:12:46,400
supporters come at this issue

1623
01:12:46,400 --> 01:12:48,673
with it with a good heart they

1624
01:12:48,673 --> 01:12:51,148
care about are working people

1625
01:12:51,148 --> 01:12:53,311
at the university and elsewhere

1626
01:12:53,311 --> 01:12:55,449
they want them to have a decent

1627
01:12:55,449 --> 01:12:56,283
level of pay and benefits and I

1628
01:12:56,283 --> 01:12:59,119
know that that's something that

1629
01:12:59,119 --> 01:13:00,751
I certainly share on I believe

1630
01:13:00,751 --> 01:13:03,423
everybody on the floor shares.

1631
01:13:03,423 --> 01:13:06,389
But this measure is a is a

1632
01:13:06,389 --> 01:13:08,494
drastic one. And if I could I'm

1633
01:13:08,494 --> 01:13:09,695
gonna reference the analysis

1634
01:13:09,695 --> 01:13:12,950
that's been provided each

1635
01:13:14,660 --> 01:13:17,666
member. On this. It's a this

1636
01:13:20,339 --> 01:13:20,906
one second. It says this that

1637
01:13:20,906 --> 01:13:23,906
it provides the region's for

1638
01:13:24,144 --> 01:13:25,377
the ca. May contract for

1639
01:13:25,377 --> 01:13:27,777
labor to perform support

1640
01:13:29,519 --> 01:13:30,881
services only if authorized to

1641
01:13:30,881 --> 01:13:33,480
do so by statute and only for

1642
01:13:33,480 --> 01:13:35,480
limited exceptions include

1643
01:13:35,949 --> 01:13:38,787
among other things a bonafide

1644
01:13:38,787 --> 01:13:40,125
emergency circumstance. So to

1645
01:13:40,125 --> 01:13:41,423
change from of the provisions

1646
01:13:41,423 --> 01:13:43,692
in this measure requires that

1647
01:13:43,692 --> 01:13:44,729
they have limited exceptions

1648
01:13:44,729 --> 01:13:47,599
and they have to do so by

1649
01:13:47,599 --> 01:13:48,266
statute and do so by statute

1650
01:13:48,266 --> 01:13:50,468
means that we actually have to

1651
01:13:50,468 --> 01:13:53,401
pass a law to allow. That

1652
01:13:53,401 --> 01:13:55,600
contracting out provisions. So

1653
01:13:55,600 --> 01:13:56,638
from my point of view. The

1654
01:13:56,638 --> 01:13:58,405
measure before us is a complete

1655
01:13:58,405 --> 01:13:59,673
ban on contracting out for a

1656
01:13:59,673 --> 01:14:00,878
wide range of services at the

1657
01:14:00,878 --> 01:14:02,878
university of california

1658
01:14:03,477 --> 01:14:05,379
campuses. And their hospitals

1659
01:14:05,379 --> 01:14:05,983
no matter how short term. An

1660
01:14:05,983 --> 01:14:08,983
expected or necessary they May

1661
01:14:10,251 --> 01:14:11,618
be. And as I said the only.

1662
01:14:11,618 --> 01:14:13,984
Significant section to that is

1663
01:14:13,984 --> 01:14:14,924
if they got statutory approval

1664
01:14:14,924 --> 01:14:17,857
that means they would be

1665
01:14:17,857 --> 01:14:18,625
legislation first to allow at

1666
01:14:18,625 --> 01:14:20,624
the hiring of short term

1667
01:14:20,624 --> 01:14:21,964
emergency hospital workers.

1668
01:14:21,964 --> 01:14:24,731
Like staffing up to respond to

1669
01:14:24,731 --> 01:14:25,331
a natural disaster can you

1670
01:14:25,331 --> 01:14:27,900
imagine them coming in asking

1671
01:14:27,900 --> 01:14:29,770
for a law. Do with that. It

1672
01:14:29,770 --> 01:14:32,170
requires the legislation to

1673
01:14:32,271 --> 01:14:32,871
train you see employees. On

1674
01:14:32,871 --> 01:14:35,271
safety improperly use special

1675
01:14:38,307 --> 01:14:39,742
equipment. It would require law.

1676
01:14:39,742 --> 01:14:41,847
For and to anticipated special

1677
01:14:41,847 --> 01:14:43,314
events I even when the

1678
01:14:43,314 --> 01:14:44,382
university has less than thirty

1679
01:14:44,382 --> 01:14:46,451
days to plan for it such as

1680
01:14:46,451 --> 01:14:48,784
speakers I campus require an

1681
01:14:48,784 --> 01:14:51,784
extra security and clean up.

1682
01:14:52,657 --> 01:14:53,190
And even requires legislation

1683
01:14:53,190 --> 01:14:55,623
for staff for some student

1684
01:14:55,623 --> 01:14:57,194
housing developments. The taken

1685
01:14:57,194 --> 01:14:58,260
away that flexibility on

1686
01:14:58,260 --> 01:15:00,260
clinical care staffing

1687
01:15:00,497 --> 01:15:02,366
decisions. From my point of

1688
01:15:02,366 --> 01:15:03,333
view is going to create impact

1689
01:15:03,333 --> 01:15:05,869
on vulnerable patients and by

1690
01:15:05,869 --> 01:15:07,730
the way 60% of. You see

1691
01:15:07,730 --> 01:15:10,730
patients are medi cal for

1692
01:15:12,339 --> 01:15:13,760
medicare. Supported now this

1693
01:15:13,760 --> 01:15:15,713
would only apply to university

1694
01:15:15,713 --> 01:15:16,245
of california not to any other

1695
01:15:16,245 --> 01:15:18,645
hospital or institution in

1696
01:15:18,951 --> 01:15:20,816
california. You see would have

1697
01:15:20,816 --> 01:15:21,317
to hire full time employees for

1698
01:15:21,317 --> 01:15:24,317
work he needs done only

1699
01:15:25,554 --> 01:15:26,155
occasionally. Turn of late you

1700
01:15:26,155 --> 01:15:26,655
see would have to decrease the

1701
01:15:26,655 --> 01:15:27,189
services it provides the

1702
01:15:27,189 --> 01:15:29,589
students. Patients and the

1703
01:15:31,459 --> 01:15:33,762
public. And think about this

1704
01:15:33,762 --> 01:15:34,298
you see with a with a should I

1705
01:15:34,298 --> 01:15:37,298
don't think they should be

1706
01:15:37,298 --> 01:15:38,531
forced. The hire workers for

1707
01:15:38,531 --> 01:15:39,632
things that they need done a

1708
01:15:39,632 --> 01:15:41,601
few times a year can you

1709
01:15:41,601 --> 01:15:43,900
imagine if your house you edit

1710
01:15:43,900 --> 01:15:45,400
cut a tree down. Do you have

1711
01:15:45,400 --> 01:15:46,672
the equipment to do that no you

1712
01:15:46,672 --> 01:15:50,900
have to hire somebody if you're

1713
01:15:50,900 --> 01:15:50,611
a business and in you're not in

1714
01:15:50,611 --> 01:15:52,770
the air conditioning business

1715
01:15:52,770 --> 01:15:53,479
but year conditions goes goes

1716
01:15:53,479 --> 01:15:55,113
down. Imagine having air

1717
01:15:55,113 --> 01:15:57,513
conditioning repair people on

1718
01:15:59,250 --> 01:15:59,584
on your staff all the time for

1719
01:15:59,584 --> 01:16:01,352
things that aren't even that

1720
01:16:01,352 --> 01:16:02,354
central core of your business.

1721
01:16:02,354 --> 01:16:04,525
So there are requirements in

1722
01:16:04,525 --> 01:16:05,123
here that. Really aren't a

1723
01:16:05,123 --> 01:16:07,523
fission and read significantly

1724
01:16:08,590 --> 01:16:10,461
raise costs. Thank you see and

1725
01:16:10,461 --> 01:16:11,995
its workers can bargain and

1726
01:16:11,995 --> 01:16:13,963
they do we they have collective

1727
01:16:13,963 --> 01:16:14,901
bargaining and they and they

1728
01:16:14,901 --> 01:16:16,832
have shown they have the

1729
01:16:16,832 --> 01:16:17,434
ability to close contracts you

1730
01:16:17,434 --> 01:16:19,601
see in its unions of

1731
01:16:19,601 --> 01:16:21,601
successfully close contracts.

1732
01:16:22,641 --> 01:16:24,305
With all the other unions. And

1733
01:16:24,305 --> 01:16:26,307
keep in mind. If the criticism

1734
01:16:26,307 --> 01:16:28,420
is somehow this contracting out

1735
01:16:28,420 --> 01:16:30,800
has led to a significant

1736
01:16:30,800 --> 01:16:30,609
decrease in you see employment

1737
01:16:30,609 --> 01:16:33,981
it's just the opposite that we

1738
01:16:33,981 --> 01:16:35,784
see. Union employment at the

1739
01:16:35,784 --> 01:16:36,348
university california's been

1740
01:16:36,348 --> 01:16:39,948
going up for many many years

1741
01:16:40,755 --> 01:16:43,388
not the opposite. Members we

1742
01:16:43,388 --> 01:16:43,988
have new members in leadership

1743
01:16:43,988 --> 01:16:48,188
at the board of regents I know

1744
01:16:48,192 --> 01:16:48,796
you know many of them. And they

1745
01:16:48,796 --> 01:16:52,396
have indicated to me that they

1746
01:16:55,363 --> 01:16:58,363
are committed. To creating a

1747
01:16:59,601 --> 01:17:02,100
fair contracting practice. And

1748
01:17:02,173 --> 01:17:03,404
I trusted that leadership that

1749
01:17:03,404 --> 01:17:04,805
the chair of the board of

1750
01:17:04,805 --> 01:17:06,841
regents is john for as a former

1751
01:17:06,841 --> 01:17:09,120
union leader and he has made it

1752
01:17:09,120 --> 01:17:09,779
clear that he wants the

1753
01:17:09,779 --> 01:17:12,179
university of california to

1754
01:17:13,479 --> 01:17:16,218
have the best contracting out

1755
01:17:16,218 --> 01:17:18,618
provisions standards of any

1756
01:17:19,221 --> 01:17:19,821
public institution in the

1757
01:17:19,821 --> 01:17:20,388
country and I think he should

1758
01:17:20,388 --> 01:17:23,358
be given that opportunity to

1759
01:17:23,358 --> 01:17:26,358
try. But a constitutional men

1760
01:17:27,522 --> 01:17:27,740
now. Could pass and it would be

1761
01:17:27,740 --> 01:17:29,280
permanent. Hi does set a

1762
01:17:29,280 --> 01:17:31,320
precedent. And it does create

1763
01:17:31,320 --> 01:17:32,265
the opportunity for many other

1764
01:17:32,265 --> 01:17:34,660
problems that we have

1765
01:17:34,660 --> 01:17:36,660
occasionally. With that

1766
01:17:36,235 --> 01:17:36,968
institution that somehow be now

1767
01:17:36,968 --> 01:17:38,968
subject to. Another

1768
01:17:39,705 --> 01:17:40,305
constitutional change could

1769
01:17:40,305 --> 01:17:42,906
happen every year could happen

1770
01:17:42,906 --> 01:17:43,874
every session. I think that we

1771
01:17:43,874 --> 01:17:45,743
should give the university an

1772
01:17:45,743 --> 01:17:48,312
opportunity to try to work

1773
01:17:48,312 --> 01:17:48,876
these issues out this this.

1774
01:17:48,876 --> 01:17:51,184
This constitutional ma'am it

1775
01:17:51,184 --> 01:17:52,482
doesn't have to be passed today

1776
01:17:52,482 --> 01:17:53,583
we could take this matter up in

1777
01:17:53,583 --> 01:17:55,852
January and have the same

1778
01:17:55,852 --> 01:17:57,290
result to the benefit that they

1779
01:17:57,290 --> 01:17:58,621
desire putting this measure on

1780
01:17:58,621 --> 01:18:00,954
the November ballot. So in

1781
01:18:00,954 --> 01:18:02,395
summary. We have collective

1782
01:18:02,395 --> 01:18:04,230
bargaining at the university

1783
01:18:04,230 --> 01:18:06,630
california hard fought. We

1784
01:18:06,829 --> 01:18:08,970
should allow that. Process to.

1785
01:18:08,970 --> 01:18:10,169
Resolve a lot of these issues

1786
01:18:10,169 --> 01:18:11,300
including this one. Number two

1787
01:18:11,300 --> 01:18:13,680
you see does have a degree of

1788
01:18:13,680 --> 01:18:14,903
it aye tanami. But the board

1789
01:18:14,903 --> 01:18:15,874
chair is made as kim is a clear

1790
01:18:15,874 --> 01:18:17,740
his commitment to have high

1791
01:18:17,740 --> 01:18:20,800
standards for contracting out

1792
01:18:20,800 --> 01:18:20,742
he should be given that chance.

1793
01:18:20,742 --> 01:18:22,844
And not addressing this bill

1794
01:18:22,844 --> 01:18:24,512
today doesn't. Stop the

1795
01:18:24,512 --> 01:18:25,747
conversation doesn't prevent

1796
01:18:25,747 --> 01:18:26,783
the results that this measure

1797
01:18:26,783 --> 01:18:29,783
desires which is a ballot

1798
01:18:31,210 --> 01:18:31,551
measure next of amber. And

1799
01:18:31,551 --> 01:18:32,185
because of those reasons I

1800
01:18:32,185 --> 01:18:34,424
think we should vote no on this

1801
01:18:34,424 --> 01:18:36,824
measure today. Thank you

1802
01:18:38,324 --> 01:18:39,292
senator galgiani. Thank you

1803
01:18:39,292 --> 01:18:41,930
Mister Chair members I rise in

1804
01:18:41,930 --> 01:18:43,950
support of this bill I was

1805
01:18:43,950 --> 01:18:44,263
around in the assembly when we

1806
01:18:44,263 --> 01:18:46,565
went through the budget crisis

1807
01:18:46,565 --> 01:18:48,901
in the uc system put employees

1808
01:18:48,901 --> 01:18:51,690
on furlough they increase

1809
01:18:51,690 --> 01:18:52,869
contracting out and they

1810
01:18:52,869 --> 01:18:55,841
reduced pay and they raised

1811
01:18:55,841 --> 01:18:58,674
tuition for students and within

1812
01:18:58,674 --> 01:19:01,110
a year. It was learned that

1813
01:19:01,110 --> 01:19:02,481
secretly they had given bonuses

1814
01:19:02,481 --> 01:19:04,349
to the tune of about three

1815
01:19:04,349 --> 01:19:06,889
point one million or they were

1816
01:19:06,889 --> 01:19:09,289
planningo four thirty eight

1817
01:19:09,724 --> 01:19:11,455
pop executive employees and

1818
01:19:11,455 --> 01:19:14,272
they were doing that after

1819
01:19:14,272 --> 01:19:16,827
having made raises to tuition

1820
01:19:16,827 --> 01:19:19,263
and for low's to employees that

1821
01:19:19,263 --> 01:19:20,797
was a blatant disregard and

1822
01:19:20,797 --> 01:19:22,766
disrespect for the employees

1823
01:19:22,766 --> 01:19:25,203
and in my view of the

1824
01:19:25,203 --> 01:19:27,367
legislature as well because we

1825
01:19:27,367 --> 01:19:29,208
agreed to the terms at that

1826
01:19:29,208 --> 01:19:30,880
time. Because of the fact that

1827
01:19:30,880 --> 01:19:33,537
the we were in our where we

1828
01:19:33,537 --> 01:19:35,537
were withhe economynk

1829
01:19:37,820 --> 01:19:38,513
this bill is necessary I trust

1830
01:19:38,513 --> 01:19:41,248
are former speaker who is now

1831
01:19:41,248 --> 01:19:42,683
on the board of regents to do a

1832
01:19:42,683 --> 01:19:45,318
great job and to do all that he

1833
01:19:45,318 --> 01:19:46,553
can while he is on the board

1834
01:19:46,553 --> 01:19:49,256
but just like this legislature

1835
01:19:49,256 --> 01:19:51,524
passes bills because sometimes

1836
01:19:51,524 --> 01:19:53,260
we have a governor that we feel

1837
01:19:53,260 --> 01:19:55,580
we can work with and trust and

1838
01:19:55,580 --> 01:19:56,829
other times we May not in the

1839
01:19:56,829 --> 01:19:58,364
future. This is a circumstance

1840
01:19:58,364 --> 01:20:01,200
where we need to look beyond

1841
01:20:01,200 --> 01:20:02,204
just was on the board at this

1842
01:20:02,204 --> 01:20:05,638
point in time but we need to

1843
01:20:05,638 --> 01:20:07,105
think about having a structure

1844
01:20:07,105 --> 01:20:07,973
there so that we don't see

1845
01:20:07,973 --> 01:20:10,709
things like this happen again

1846
01:20:10,709 --> 01:20:12,975
and we don't see. Things happen

1847
01:20:12,975 --> 01:20:14,212
on the backs of employees who

1848
01:20:14,212 --> 01:20:16,378
quite frankly are barely

1849
01:20:16,378 --> 01:20:19,978
getting by and just just making

1850
01:20:20,485 --> 01:20:21,520
enough only. To raise their

1851
01:20:21,520 --> 01:20:23,452
families I respectfully ask

1852
01:20:25,757 --> 01:20:28,757
your rival. Thank you senator

1853
01:20:30,270 --> 01:20:31,498
bates. Thank you Mister

1854
01:20:31,498 --> 01:20:32,396
President hi to reluctantly

1855
01:20:32,396 --> 01:20:32,894
rise in opposition to aca

1856
01:20:32,894 --> 01:20:33,664
fourteen the contracting

1857
01:20:33,664 --> 01:20:35,263
prohibitions contained in the

1858
01:20:35,263 --> 01:20:36,701
measure would have significant

1859
01:20:36,701 --> 01:20:38,248
and disastrous fiscal impacts

1860
01:20:38,248 --> 01:20:40,648
on the university in

1861
01:20:41,206 --> 01:20:42,173
specifically of the uc system

1862
01:20:42,173 --> 01:20:44,173
calculates the increased

1863
01:20:44,774 --> 01:20:45,841
operating costs almost a

1864
01:20:45,841 --> 01:20:47,309
hundred and seventy three

1865
01:20:47,309 --> 01:20:48,977
million dollars per year based

1866
01:20:48,977 --> 01:20:51,279
on the additional wage and

1867
01:20:51,279 --> 01:20:52,143
benefit premiums associated

1868
01:20:52,143 --> 01:20:54,150
with bringing carl this

1869
01:20:54,150 --> 01:20:56,351
contracted work in house. For

1870
01:20:56,351 --> 01:20:57,651
uc san diego which is not

1871
01:20:57,651 --> 01:20:59,319
directly in my district but

1872
01:20:59,319 --> 01:21:00,353
certainly in my egion they

1873
01:21:00,353 --> 01:21:01,788
estimate that this will

1874
01:21:01,788 --> 01:21:03,788
increase facilities maintenance

1875
01:21:04,724 --> 01:21:05,825
costs by twenty one point eight

1876
01:21:05,825 --> 01:21:07,194
almost twenty two million

1877
01:21:07,194 --> 01:21:09,598
dollars during the first year

1878
01:21:09,598 --> 01:21:10,861
of implementation in by six and

1879
01:21:10,861 --> 01:21:12,969
a half million for the

1880
01:21:12,969 --> 01:21:15,699
following years since uc san

1881
01:21:15,699 --> 01:21:16,936
diego must ensure funding for

1882
01:21:16,936 --> 01:21:19,336
our highest priority our

1883
01:21:19,873 --> 01:21:21,707
highest priority students these

1884
01:21:21,707 --> 01:21:23,175
additional costs will deal a

1885
01:21:23,175 --> 01:21:25,114
heavy financial blow to the

1886
01:21:25,114 --> 01:21:27,516
campus as a whole. And it's

1887
01:21:27,516 --> 01:21:29,814
medical enterprise and the cost

1888
01:21:29,814 --> 01:21:31,550
of tuition you see medical

1889
01:21:31,550 --> 01:21:32,985
centers on the california

1890
01:21:32,985 --> 01:21:35,385
hospital association are still

1891
01:21:36,187 --> 01:21:38,356
in opposition to a ca fourteen

1892
01:21:38,356 --> 01:21:39,359
stating it also threatens uc's

1893
01:21:39,359 --> 01:21:41,359
medical centers about

1894
01:21:41,824 --> 01:21:43,392
jeopardizing patient safety in

1895
01:21:43,392 --> 01:21:45,792
increasing healthcare costs the

1896
01:21:46,395 --> 01:21:47,363
uc healthcare system has a

1897
01:21:47,363 --> 01:21:48,397
special place in california's

1898
01:21:48,397 --> 01:21:50,565
health care plans gate

1899
01:21:50,565 --> 01:21:53,565
admission focused not only on

1900
01:21:53,871 --> 01:21:55,971
clinical care but also research

1901
01:21:55,971 --> 01:21:58,600
and education. Delivering for

1902
01:21:58,600 --> 01:21:59,972
patients and communities in

1903
01:21:59,972 --> 01:22:00,842
each of these areas relies upon

1904
01:22:00,842 --> 01:22:02,911
a robust staffing framework

1905
01:22:02,911 --> 01:22:05,311
that includes both direct

1906
01:22:05,347 --> 01:22:07,412
employees and contract staffing

1907
01:22:07,412 --> 01:22:09,383
the medical centers are often

1908
01:22:09,383 --> 01:22:12,383
the only level one trauma

1909
01:22:12,953 --> 01:22:13,720
centers in the region providing

1910
01:22:13,720 --> 01:22:16,120
the majority of highly

1911
01:22:16,159 --> 01:22:17,424
specialized services. Half of

1912
01:22:17,424 --> 01:22:19,226
all the transplant procedures

1913
01:22:19,226 --> 01:22:22,826
statewide in a quarter of the

1914
01:22:25,640 --> 01:22:25,632
severe burn care delivery. To

1915
01:22:25,632 --> 01:22:27,632
californians providing this

1916
01:22:31,669 --> 01:22:33,107
high level of. Should care

1917
01:22:33,107 --> 01:22:34,405
demands the delicate balance of

1918
01:22:34,405 --> 01:22:35,439
staffing resources without

1919
01:22:35,439 --> 01:22:36,400
having to come to this just

1920
01:22:36,400 --> 01:22:36,909
later with every special need

1921
01:22:36,909 --> 01:22:38,342
they might have. Without the

1922
01:22:38,342 --> 01:22:39,206
ability to supplement staffing

1923
01:22:39,206 --> 01:22:40,947
without coming back here with

1924
01:22:40,947 --> 01:22:41,945
contract labor these critical

1925
01:22:41,945 --> 01:22:43,790
services will be laid can

1926
01:22:43,790 --> 01:22:44,447
affect our access to care so on

1927
01:22:44,447 --> 01:22:46,447
behalf of california's

1928
01:22:46,447 --> 01:22:48,847
treasured university system. I

1929
01:22:49,152 --> 01:22:52,152
urge my senate colleagues to

1930
01:22:52,222 --> 01:22:55,222
oppose aca fourteen. Thank you

1931
01:22:56,992 --> 01:23:00,290
senator bill. Members so I rise

1932
01:23:00,290 --> 01:23:02,640
in support of a ca fourteen.

1933
01:23:02,640 --> 01:23:04,466
Members long ago well as a

1934
01:23:04,466 --> 01:23:06,365
students out of the state.

1935
01:23:06,365 --> 01:23:09,207
Students at the uc berkeley

1936
01:23:09,207 --> 01:23:11,740
asked us to attend a rally. For

1937
01:23:11,740 --> 01:23:12,207
the maintenance workers to get

1938
01:23:12,207 --> 01:23:15,207
the fair wages at the

1939
01:23:16,247 --> 01:23:18,483
university. I bring this up to

1940
01:23:18,483 --> 01:23:20,715
illustrate how long this issue

1941
01:23:20,715 --> 01:23:23,184
has of fair treatment of low

1942
01:23:23,184 --> 01:23:26,784
paid workers at the uc system

1943
01:23:27,321 --> 01:23:29,723
has been with us. To have this

1944
01:23:29,723 --> 01:23:31,425
on matt social services issue

1945
01:23:31,425 --> 01:23:35,250
hang over this state. For so

1946
01:23:35,280 --> 01:23:38,310
long. Is appalling and it is an

1947
01:23:38,310 --> 01:23:40,310
embarrassment. The common

1948
01:23:40,900 --> 01:23:43,200
excuse is to you let the

1949
01:23:43,200 --> 01:23:46,200
regents handle that has been

1950
01:23:46,639 --> 01:23:48,174
used many for many years. To

1951
01:23:48,174 --> 01:23:50,976
exclude these workers from fair

1952
01:23:50,976 --> 01:23:53,976
treatment by using the state

1953
01:23:54,420 --> 01:23:56,614
constitution as an excuse one

1954
01:23:56,614 --> 01:23:57,245
otherwise they would receive

1955
01:23:57,245 --> 01:24:00,245
better treatment under our laws

1956
01:24:00,651 --> 01:24:01,721
is discriminatory. I believe

1957
01:24:01,721 --> 01:24:04,422
the voters of california should

1958
01:24:04,422 --> 01:24:07,658
have the chance to correct the

1959
01:24:07,658 --> 01:24:10,658
unfairness. By supporting a ca

1960
01:24:12,863 --> 01:24:15,863
fourteen. As the students staff

1961
01:24:17,534 --> 01:24:18,802
teachers visitors walk through

1962
01:24:18,802 --> 01:24:20,370
the beautiful gardens and

1963
01:24:20,370 --> 01:24:23,370
buildings of the university of

1964
01:24:24,240 --> 01:24:26,640
california. What lessons are

1965
01:24:27,400 --> 01:24:29,440
learned by perpetuating this

1966
01:24:29,979 --> 01:24:30,513
unfairness to the workers who

1967
01:24:30,513 --> 01:24:32,913
work hard maintaining our

1968
01:24:36,540 --> 01:24:38,454
university. Martin luther king.

1969
01:24:38,587 --> 01:24:39,888
Said before the March on selma

1970
01:24:39,888 --> 01:24:43,488
how long will it take. He

1971
01:24:44,490 --> 01:24:47,226
answered how long not long. Now

1972
01:24:47,226 --> 01:24:49,595
that should be our answer. Let

1973
01:24:49,595 --> 01:24:52,297
us been towards justice. Let

1974
01:24:52,297 --> 01:24:55,297
the voters decide. It's been

1975
01:24:56,568 --> 01:24:59,504
too long urge support for a ca

1976
01:24:59,504 --> 01:25:02,504
fourteen thank you. Thank you

1977
01:25:03,174 --> 01:25:05,574
senator borders. Thank you

1978
01:25:06,345 --> 01:25:08,846
Mister President I think there

1979
01:25:08,846 --> 01:25:11,150
are really good people on both

1980
01:25:11,150 --> 01:25:11,615
sides of this issue I think

1981
01:25:11,615 --> 01:25:13,152
some of the points that have

1982
01:25:13,152 --> 01:25:15,856
been brought up by the

1983
01:25:15,856 --> 01:25:16,717
proponents of ac fourteen are

1984
01:25:16,717 --> 01:25:18,754
looking after in their

1985
01:25:18,754 --> 01:25:21,190
estimation the best interest of

1986
01:25:21,190 --> 01:25:23,190
workers in university

1987
01:25:23,955 --> 01:25:25,955
university california's system.

1988
01:25:26,160 --> 01:25:27,528
On the flip side I think there

1989
01:25:27,528 --> 01:25:29,528
are certainly compelling

1990
01:25:30,322 --> 01:25:32,812
arguments as to why I employees

1991
01:25:32,812 --> 01:25:33,831
should to. Or university should

1992
01:25:33,831 --> 01:25:36,231
have the ability and

1993
01:25:36,936 --> 01:25:38,634
flexibility to provide services

1994
01:25:38,634 --> 01:25:41,634
in contract for services as

1995
01:25:41,674 --> 01:25:43,674
needed because university

1996
01:25:44,342 --> 01:25:46,770
systems ebb and flow of the

1997
01:25:46,770 --> 01:25:48,142
needs change. On depending on

1998
01:25:48,142 --> 01:25:49,543
the economy we can expect that

1999
01:25:49,543 --> 01:25:52,140
even further specially as were

2000
01:25:52,140 --> 01:25:54,414
expecting our economy to

2001
01:25:54,781 --> 01:25:58,381
continue to slow down as cycles

2002
01:25:59,255 --> 01:26:00,620
or inevitable. What I'm hearing

2003
01:26:00,620 --> 01:26:01,757
though it. From folks who were

2004
01:26:01,757 --> 01:26:04,693
supporting a ca fourteen. Are

2005
01:26:04,693 --> 01:26:07,930
that. The bargaining unit

2006
01:26:08,835 --> 01:26:09,580
process has not been successful.

2007
01:26:09,580 --> 01:26:11,399
I would think that you've

2008
01:26:11,399 --> 01:26:13,670
already won today. However this

2009
01:26:13,670 --> 01:26:14,299
vote plays out because you

2010
01:26:14,299 --> 01:26:16,720
brought this issue to the

2011
01:26:16,720 --> 01:26:17,572
forefront to the height of

2012
01:26:17,572 --> 01:26:20,572
political awareness and I would

2013
01:26:21,139 --> 01:26:23,141
think that this. Just by virtue

2014
01:26:23,141 --> 01:26:25,950
of what has occurred today.

2015
01:26:25,950 --> 01:26:27,378
He's going to compel folks

2016
01:26:27,378 --> 01:26:29,580
within the regions within the

2017
01:26:29,580 --> 01:26:31,686
bargaining units to try to

2018
01:26:31,686 --> 01:26:32,754
reach an accommodation. And

2019
01:26:32,754 --> 01:26:36,220
I've always been of the opinion

2020
01:26:36,220 --> 01:26:38,760
that that win win common sense

2021
01:26:38,760 --> 01:26:41,760
and urgency are paired results

2022
01:26:41,928 --> 01:26:44,963
occur. And I think that can

2023
01:26:44,963 --> 01:26:45,564
occur right now. My colleague.

2024
01:26:45,564 --> 01:26:48,564
From down south had mentioned

2025
01:26:51,202 --> 01:26:51,736
earlier. This is a broad sword

2026
01:26:51,736 --> 01:26:54,736
being brought to a fairly

2027
01:26:55,472 --> 01:26:57,872
limited issue. To require

2028
01:26:59,900 --> 01:27:01,409
statutory authority. Or any

2029
01:27:02,212 --> 01:27:03,880
changes to occur in staffing.

2030
01:27:03,880 --> 01:27:06,386
It just seems terribly terribly

2031
01:27:06,386 --> 01:27:07,550
cumbersome and frankly it's a

2032
01:27:07,550 --> 01:27:09,555
fait accompli at that point it

2033
01:27:09,555 --> 01:27:12,560
just wouldn't happen so we have

2034
01:27:12,560 --> 01:27:13,689
new leadership at uc we've

2035
01:27:13,689 --> 01:27:15,391
we've gotten renewed

2036
01:27:15,391 --> 01:27:17,960
commitments that they want to

2037
01:27:17,960 --> 01:27:19,962
take in earnest another stab at

2038
01:27:19,962 --> 01:27:22,362
all reaching an accommodation

2039
01:27:22,365 --> 01:27:23,232
toward understanding of for the

2040
01:27:23,232 --> 01:27:25,369
bargaining units in terms

2041
01:27:25,369 --> 01:27:25,967
conditions of employment. Why

2042
01:27:25,967 --> 01:27:28,967
wouldn't we bring this matter

2043
01:27:29,705 --> 01:27:31,806
back. Let the individuals who

2044
01:27:31,806 --> 01:27:34,800
were tasked with reaching a

2045
01:27:34,800 --> 01:27:36,800
collective bargaining decisions

2046
01:27:36,446 --> 01:27:38,812
give them in another few months.

2047
01:27:38,812 --> 01:27:40,946
What it hurt if this issue were

2048
01:27:40,946 --> 01:27:44,546
brought back in January and I

2049
01:27:44,586 --> 01:27:47,190
asked that to the movers of

2050
01:27:47,190 --> 01:27:48,820
this legislation. What would be

2051
01:27:48,820 --> 01:27:50,688
the down fall we could take

2052
01:27:50,688 --> 01:27:52,624
this matter up in January all

2053
01:27:52,624 --> 01:27:54,661
other be enough time I suspect

2054
01:27:54,661 --> 01:27:56,528
to put it on on the ballot if

2055
01:27:56,528 --> 01:27:57,795
it it's still proved so I think

2056
01:27:57,795 --> 01:27:59,564
that is an option I've always

2057
01:27:59,564 --> 01:28:01,232
been the opinion that when

2058
01:28:01,232 --> 01:28:03,331
legislators panic bad policies

2059
01:28:03,331 --> 01:28:04,836
made. And I think gray here

2060
01:28:04,836 --> 01:28:08,169
we're in a situation where were

2061
01:28:08,169 --> 01:28:10,207
panicking and using a broad

2062
01:28:10,207 --> 01:28:13,807
sword on a discreet and limited

2063
01:28:14,800 --> 01:28:14,581
issue that frankly makes for

2064
01:28:14,581 --> 01:28:17,717
bad policy. So I think with

2065
01:28:17,717 --> 01:28:19,282
that. I would. I'm certainly

2066
01:28:19,282 --> 01:28:21,184
going to be recommending either

2067
01:28:21,184 --> 01:28:22,953
a no or a neutral on this to my

2068
01:28:22,953 --> 01:28:25,353
colleagues. Just because I

2069
01:28:25,354 --> 01:28:26,687
think that cooler heads can

2070
01:28:26,687 --> 01:28:29,392
prevail now this issue has been

2071
01:28:29,392 --> 01:28:31,329
brought to the forefront. And

2072
01:28:31,329 --> 01:28:32,961
let's give the and you see an

2073
01:28:32,961 --> 01:28:35,327
opportunity. With their new

2074
01:28:35,327 --> 01:28:36,497
leadership to find their

2075
01:28:36,497 --> 01:28:38,897
accommodations I know that

2076
01:28:38,899 --> 01:28:39,634
folks have said. Enough time

2077
01:28:39,634 --> 01:28:42,235
has passed and they've lost

2078
01:28:42,235 --> 01:28:45,235
confidence in the process. But

2079
01:28:46,383 --> 01:28:46,625
I think with new leadership.

2080
01:28:46,625 --> 01:28:46,783
There is renewed hope and I'd

2081
01:28:46,783 --> 01:28:48,708
like to give them that

2082
01:28:48,708 --> 01:28:50,708
opportunity colleagues I

2083
01:28:51,112 --> 01:28:53,813
respectfully ask for a no or

2084
01:28:53,813 --> 01:28:56,415
neutral any ca fourteen. Thank

2085
01:28:56,415 --> 01:28:57,614
you senator tank. Thank you

2086
01:28:57,614 --> 01:29:00,140
Mister President members high

2087
01:29:00,116 --> 01:29:03,716
rise in support of aca fourteen.

2088
01:29:03,820 --> 01:29:04,885
The uc system has over six

2089
01:29:04,885 --> 01:29:06,589
hundred administrators and

2090
01:29:06,589 --> 01:29:08,989
staff with reporters salaries

2091
01:29:09,192 --> 01:29:10,830
over half a million dollars.

2092
01:29:10,830 --> 01:29:13,498
That's more than twice what the

2093
01:29:13,498 --> 01:29:15,498
governor california makes.

2094
01:29:15,831 --> 01:29:17,735
Twenty fiscal years twenty

2095
01:29:17,735 --> 01:29:18,335
twelve twenty thirteen and

2096
01:29:18,335 --> 01:29:19,100
twenty fifteen twenty sixteen

2097
01:29:19,100 --> 01:29:21,236
the office of the presence aye

2098
01:29:21,236 --> 01:29:23,636
ministers spending increased by

2099
01:29:24,173 --> 01:29:24,776
20% or eighty million dollars.

2100
01:29:24,776 --> 01:29:28,376
And we can make sure janitors

2101
01:29:28,440 --> 01:29:31,440
are treated equally. The uc

2102
01:29:31,549 --> 01:29:32,180
system is publicly funded we

2103
01:29:32,180 --> 01:29:34,249
have an obligation to make sure

2104
01:29:34,249 --> 01:29:36,517
people are treated fairly. I

2105
01:29:36,517 --> 01:29:39,117
remember we are merely voting

2106
01:29:39,117 --> 01:29:41,188
to put this on the ballot. For

2107
01:29:41,188 --> 01:29:43,257
californians to decide. So with

2108
01:29:43,257 --> 01:29:46,857
that I encourage an aye vote.

2109
01:29:49,129 --> 01:29:51,529
Thank you senator cafiero.

2110
01:29:51,698 --> 01:29:53,934
Thank you Mister President I'd

2111
01:29:53,934 --> 01:29:56,903
like to follow up on on my

2112
01:29:56,903 --> 01:29:58,438
colleague from diamond bars.

2113
01:29:58,438 --> 01:29:59,873
Active and I want to broaden

2114
01:29:59,873 --> 01:30:02,700
the social reflection a little

2115
01:30:02,700 --> 01:30:05,641
bit because I am very proud to

2116
01:30:05,641 --> 01:30:08,445
be a co author of a ca fourteen

2117
01:30:08,445 --> 01:30:10,781
and-the reason that I made the

2118
01:30:10,781 --> 01:30:13,619
decision to become a co author

2119
01:30:13,619 --> 01:30:16,619
was after. Hearing and reading

2120
01:30:17,787 --> 01:30:19,522
about one of the universities.

2121
01:30:19,522 --> 01:30:23,122
At the actions that they had

2122
01:30:24,527 --> 01:30:26,162
taken against the work force to.

2123
01:30:26,162 --> 01:30:29,131
Basically lay them off and

2124
01:30:29,131 --> 01:30:31,660
bring in contract workers and I

2125
01:30:31,660 --> 01:30:32,869
was so appalled by that I just

2126
01:30:32,869 --> 01:30:35,835
felt compelled to do something

2127
01:30:35,835 --> 01:30:37,940
about it and how this gets back

2128
01:30:37,940 --> 01:30:39,809
to what what what I've worked

2129
01:30:39,809 --> 01:30:41,376
on and how it's important me is

2130
01:30:41,376 --> 01:30:43,545
this and I had a I have have a

2131
01:30:43,545 --> 01:30:44,544
bill that that that was over in

2132
01:30:44,544 --> 01:30:46,149
the assembly got over to the

2133
01:30:46,149 --> 01:30:48,548
assembly. That would have sus

2134
01:30:48,548 --> 01:30:51,550
started to set some targets for

2135
01:30:51,550 --> 01:30:53,149
california to reduce poverty in

2136
01:30:53,149 --> 01:30:56,550
our state and depending on

2137
01:30:56,550 --> 01:30:57,690
which report you read our

2138
01:30:57,690 --> 01:30:59,925
poverty level has stayed

2139
01:30:59,925 --> 01:31:02,161
between twenty and 25% for the

2140
01:31:02,161 --> 01:31:04,970
past ten or fifteen years and

2141
01:31:04,970 --> 01:31:06,364
it's gotten that way ecause

2142
01:31:06,364 --> 01:31:08,631
exactly because of what. My

2143
01:31:08,631 --> 01:31:11,169
good colleague from diamond bar

2144
01:31:11,169 --> 01:31:15,369
has talked about it is the fact

2145
01:31:15,406 --> 01:31:17,242
that the lower. Aid workers are

2146
01:31:17,242 --> 01:31:19,307
are laid off or the replaced by

2147
01:31:19,307 --> 01:31:21,245
contract workers who come in

2148
01:31:21,245 --> 01:31:23,140
and get no benefits they get no

2149
01:31:23,140 --> 01:31:26,140
retirement they get no health

2150
01:31:26,216 --> 01:31:27,453
insurance. They get no vacation

2151
01:31:27,453 --> 01:31:29,750
and sick leave pay and they're

2152
01:31:29,750 --> 01:31:31,255
required to work two or three

2153
01:31:31,255 --> 01:31:32,823
jobs in order to be able to

2154
01:31:32,823 --> 01:31:35,625
support their families. And at

2155
01:31:35,625 --> 01:31:38,428
the top you see huge bonuses

2156
01:31:38,428 --> 01:31:40,728
going out you see ceo's and

2157
01:31:40,728 --> 01:31:42,197
cfo's better earning in the

2158
01:31:42,197 --> 01:31:44,597
multiple millions of dollars.

2159
01:31:45,133 --> 01:31:46,200
And this is at the same time

2160
01:31:46,200 --> 01:31:48,600
that workers are getting

2161
01:31:49,102 --> 01:31:51,972
displaced and so. What aca is

2162
01:31:51,972 --> 01:31:53,504
the aca is attempting to do is

2163
01:31:53,504 --> 01:31:55,800
to stop that practice to say

2164
01:31:55,800 --> 01:31:57,770
this is not appropriate now are

2165
01:31:57,770 --> 01:31:58,445
there some things it. Probably

2166
01:31:58,445 --> 01:32:01,214
should be fixed absolutely no

2167
01:32:01,214 --> 01:32:04,680
bill is ever perfect but by the

2168
01:32:04,680 --> 01:32:05,651
same token when we say well.

2169
01:32:05,651 --> 01:32:07,319
You know maybe we should wait

2170
01:32:07,319 --> 01:32:08,784
till January and I get it that

2171
01:32:08,784 --> 01:32:11,784
probably makes some sense we

2172
01:32:12,421 --> 01:32:14,325
can also. Implore our newly

2173
01:32:14,325 --> 01:32:16,425
elected leadership. On the

2174
01:32:16,425 --> 01:32:20,565
board to get it right so that

2175
01:32:20,565 --> 01:32:20,806
this a ca doesn't need to end

2176
01:32:20,806 --> 01:32:23,863
up on the ballot. In in March

2177
01:32:23,863 --> 01:32:25,871
in November as well. I just you

2178
01:32:25,871 --> 01:32:27,690
know we have an opportunity. To

2179
01:32:27,690 --> 01:32:28,804
make a big difference in

2180
01:32:28,804 --> 01:32:31,103
people's lives and I think we

2181
01:32:31,103 --> 01:32:33,975
have to stand up and say our

2182
01:32:33,975 --> 01:32:36,375
lowest paid workers. Deserve

2183
01:32:36,911 --> 01:32:38,713
the opportunity I'm and I and I

2184
01:32:38,713 --> 01:32:39,214
got to say you know I'm from

2185
01:32:39,214 --> 01:32:42,214
I'm from a copper mining

2186
01:32:42,781 --> 01:32:45,860
family. And part of what they

2187
01:32:45,860 --> 01:32:46,954
organized for and they were

2188
01:32:46,954 --> 01:32:49,189
able to win after many many

2189
01:32:49,189 --> 01:32:51,192
years is a pension. Is the

2190
01:32:51,192 --> 01:32:52,760
opportunity to be able to earn

2191
01:32:52,760 --> 01:32:53,727
a living wage they could buy

2192
01:32:53,727 --> 01:32:54,961
their own homes. The

2193
01:32:54,961 --> 01:32:57,367
opportunity to have health care

2194
01:32:57,367 --> 01:33:00,132
and sick leave and vacation

2195
01:33:00,132 --> 01:33:02,937
leave all of those. Are the

2196
01:33:02,937 --> 01:33:03,700
benefits that we come to take

2197
01:33:03,700 --> 01:33:05,138
for granted in when you're

2198
01:33:05,138 --> 01:33:07,205
working in this temporary.

2199
01:33:07,205 --> 01:33:08,537
Country contracted kind of

2200
01:33:08,537 --> 01:33:09,908
environment you don't have

2201
01:33:09,908 --> 01:33:12,908
those kinds of protections and

2202
01:33:14,245 --> 01:33:18,445
so. I'm I'm very proud to be

2203
01:33:22,151 --> 01:33:22,615
able to stand. Happened to say

2204
01:33:22,615 --> 01:33:23,285
you know we have the

2205
01:33:23,285 --> 01:33:24,320
opportunity by the way my bill

2206
01:33:24,320 --> 01:33:24,953
in the assembly was held and

2207
01:33:24,953 --> 01:33:25,851
it's not going anywhere and-

2208
01:33:25,851 --> 01:33:26,388
and I'm I'm in a continue to

2209
01:33:26,388 --> 01:33:27,250
advocate and fight for it

2210
01:33:27,250 --> 01:33:28,260
because I think if you don't.

2211
01:33:28,260 --> 01:33:29,891
Set goals you never get there

2212
01:33:29,891 --> 01:33:31,993
and this is one of those we got

2213
01:33:31,993 --> 01:33:32,597
to get there we got to do this

2214
01:33:32,597 --> 01:33:34,293
right. It's so I respectfully

2215
01:33:34,293 --> 01:33:37,893
ask for your aye vote. Thank

2216
01:33:39,333 --> 01:33:41,733
you senator dorado. Colleagues

2217
01:33:43,271 --> 01:33:46,105
we are so proud. That we

2218
01:33:46,105 --> 01:33:47,342
deliver a first class education

2219
01:33:47,342 --> 01:33:49,875
for everyone who goes through

2220
01:33:49,875 --> 01:33:51,943
the uc system and I before I go

2221
01:33:51,943 --> 01:33:53,578
on I won it knowledge all my

2222
01:33:53,578 --> 01:33:56,347
sisters and brothers who are

2223
01:33:56,347 --> 01:33:59,917
here who work for us. On those

2224
01:33:59,917 --> 01:34:02,386
uc campuses. Because we deliver

2225
01:34:02,386 --> 01:34:04,388
first class education we need

2226
01:34:04,388 --> 01:34:07,388
to acknowledge the first class

2227
01:34:07,922 --> 01:34:10,197
work that is done and therefore

2228
01:34:10,197 --> 01:34:11,695
first class treatment. They

2229
01:34:11,695 --> 01:34:13,863
should be given to the men and

2230
01:34:13,863 --> 01:34:16,500
women who work so hard to help

2231
01:34:16,500 --> 01:34:18,900
our students succeed. Cheap

2232
01:34:20,303 --> 01:34:20,770
labor on our own state run uc

2233
01:34:20,770 --> 01:34:23,170
campuses should not be

2234
01:34:23,476 --> 01:34:25,876
acceptable. And sisters a

2235
01:34:27,910 --> 01:34:30,910
leagues. Taxpayers pay we pay

2236
01:34:31,814 --> 01:34:34,150
for it. Everyone who gets

2237
01:34:34,150 --> 01:34:36,550
contracted out. Doesn't make

2238
01:34:39,620 --> 01:34:41,656
enough to support their family.

2239
01:34:41,656 --> 01:34:44,656
They need then our social

2240
01:34:45,227 --> 01:34:46,628
service net to help them. What

2241
01:34:46,628 --> 01:34:49,431
I'm telling you I've just many

2242
01:34:49,431 --> 01:34:51,499
my live next to hard working

2243
01:34:51,499 --> 01:34:54,832
men and women who work for far

2244
01:34:54,832 --> 01:34:58,432
less than they deserve. Will be

2245
01:34:58,506 --> 01:35:00,710
for a hand up not a hand out.

2246
01:35:00,710 --> 01:35:03,473
Let's reward the hard work of

2247
01:35:03,473 --> 01:35:06,179
these men and women when I hear

2248
01:35:06,179 --> 01:35:08,182
the term used by someone of

2249
01:35:08,182 --> 01:35:10,582
flexibility that sounds like

2250
01:35:11,649 --> 01:35:13,451
the uber code forty nine basic

2251
01:35:13,451 --> 01:35:15,719
needs that working families

2252
01:35:15,719 --> 01:35:18,552
need. This problem has been

2253
01:35:18,552 --> 01:35:20,290
growing for decades and there's

2254
01:35:20,290 --> 01:35:22,292
more and more and more

2255
01:35:22,292 --> 01:35:24,970
subcontracting out and the

2256
01:35:24,970 --> 01:35:27,270
creation of cheap labor on our

2257
01:35:27,270 --> 01:35:30,270
campuses with all due respect

2258
01:35:30,166 --> 01:35:32,535
to a few new good leaders at

2259
01:35:32,535 --> 01:35:36,135
the board of regents. They are

2260
01:35:36,539 --> 01:35:37,940
not calling the shots. When

2261
01:35:37,940 --> 01:35:40,542
they need back up from us they

2262
01:35:40,542 --> 01:35:42,544
need back up from us to show

2263
01:35:42,544 --> 01:35:44,149
that we believe that all

2264
01:35:44,149 --> 01:35:46,281
working men and women should

2265
01:35:46,281 --> 01:35:48,520
have the decent good standard

2266
01:35:48,520 --> 01:35:50,385
of living. Colleagues ask for

2267
01:35:50,385 --> 01:35:53,385
your aye support. Thank you

2268
01:35:59,127 --> 01:36:01,250
senator roth. Thank you Mister

2269
01:36:01,250 --> 01:36:03,664
President colleagues this is a

2270
01:36:03,664 --> 01:36:06,767
difficult issue in an even more

2271
01:36:06,767 --> 01:36:08,935
difficult measure for me

2272
01:36:08,935 --> 01:36:11,438
frankly the easy thing to do

2273
01:36:11,438 --> 01:36:12,339
would be to just stop the issue.

2274
01:36:12,339 --> 01:36:14,174
Or to exceed to the pressure

2275
01:36:14,174 --> 01:36:15,608
from outside this building that

2276
01:36:15,608 --> 01:36:18,244
some of us have been feeling

2277
01:36:18,244 --> 01:36:18,709
over the last. Week or so

2278
01:36:18,709 --> 01:36:20,709
without providing any

2279
01:36:23,345 --> 01:36:25,619
explanation. For my concerns

2280
01:36:25,619 --> 01:36:29,870
about. The measure and not the

2281
01:36:29,870 --> 01:36:31,220
cause but I can't do that. I

2282
01:36:31,220 --> 01:36:32,860
owe you an explanation and more

2283
01:36:32,860 --> 01:36:34,592
importantly I the individuals

2284
01:36:34,592 --> 01:36:36,461
who were in our gallery in

2285
01:36:36,461 --> 01:36:38,730
those who hopefully are

2286
01:36:38,730 --> 01:36:41,130
watching outside this building.

2287
01:36:41,398 --> 01:36:44,340
An explanation for of my

2288
01:36:44,340 --> 01:36:47,340
concerns and an expression of

2289
01:36:48,575 --> 01:36:49,573
my support for a fix. Shortly

2290
01:36:49,573 --> 01:36:51,675
after I was elected if my

2291
01:36:51,675 --> 01:36:53,413
pmemory serves me right one of

2292
01:36:53,413 --> 01:36:56,344
the first picket lines and one

2293
01:36:56,344 --> 01:36:58,848
of the first worker protests. I

2294
01:36:58,848 --> 01:36:59,482
addressed was in asks me action.

2295
01:36:59,482 --> 01:37:02,482
At the university of california

2296
01:37:04,200 --> 01:37:04,490
riverside. I'm sure you can

2297
01:37:04,490 --> 01:37:07,354
imagine it was quite a

2298
01:37:07,354 --> 01:37:07,888
metamorphosis for a-labor

2299
01:37:07,888 --> 01:37:09,888
management attorney for

2300
01:37:10,794 --> 01:37:11,358
riverside.From riverside

2301
01:37:11,358 --> 01:37:14,358
strange how things change in

2302
01:37:14,898 --> 01:37:16,829
our lives. I participated in

2303
01:37:16,829 --> 01:37:18,967
that picket line because I

2304
01:37:18,967 --> 01:37:20,297
recognized at that time and I

2305
01:37:20,297 --> 01:37:22,268
continue to recognize that

2306
01:37:22,268 --> 01:37:24,380
prior administrations at the

2307
01:37:24,380 --> 01:37:26,438
university of california have

2308
01:37:26,472 --> 01:37:28,708
for decades failed to address

2309
01:37:28,708 --> 01:37:32,211
the concerns of some of uc's

2310
01:37:32,211 --> 01:37:35,211
most valuable. But lowest paid

2311
01:37:35,315 --> 01:37:37,715
employees concerns about pay

2312
01:37:37,749 --> 01:37:39,451
concerns about job displacement

2313
01:37:39,451 --> 01:37:41,851
concerns about benefits among

2314
01:37:45,123 --> 01:37:45,723
other issues. These are

2315
01:37:45,723 --> 01:37:48,723
certainly not the actions that

2316
01:37:48,960 --> 01:37:51,295
we expect. From anyone in

2317
01:37:51,295 --> 01:37:53,300
positions of authority in the

2318
01:37:53,300 --> 01:37:55,298
state of california so when I

2319
01:37:55,298 --> 01:37:56,833
reviewed the a. C. A. Fourteen

2320
01:37:56,833 --> 01:37:58,833
this propod constitutional

2321
01:37:59,100 --> 01:38:00,671
amendment I did so from that

2322
01:38:00,671 --> 01:38:03,710
perspective the perspective of

2323
01:38:03,474 --> 01:38:06,243
trying to help those who need

2324
01:38:06,243 --> 01:38:06,776
help the most. Because that's

2325
01:38:06,776 --> 01:38:10,976
what we try to do in this

2326
01:38:11,383 --> 01:38:12,481
capital. In doing so in a nod

2327
01:38:12,481 --> 01:38:14,616
to the proponents of this

2328
01:38:14,616 --> 01:38:15,181
measure I recognize the long

2329
01:38:15,181 --> 01:38:17,719
hours in the extremely hard

2330
01:38:17,719 --> 01:38:21,319
work. Put into trying to get

2331
01:38:21,923 --> 01:38:23,959
this thing right. Unfortunately

2332
01:38:23,959 --> 01:38:25,624
as I reviewed I noted some

2333
01:38:25,624 --> 01:38:26,394
structural deficiencies in this

2334
01:38:26,394 --> 01:38:28,794
measure that could cause

2335
01:38:29,196 --> 01:38:31,596
significant disruption and harm

2336
01:38:32,166 --> 01:38:32,697
from my perspective to the

2337
01:38:32,697 --> 01:38:34,697
university of california's

2338
01:38:35,100 --> 01:38:37,500
health care delivery system.

2339
01:38:37,638 --> 01:38:39,306
Seoul it's been said before but

2340
01:38:39,306 --> 01:38:41,174
I'll just highlighted what is

2341
01:38:41,174 --> 01:38:43,174
this proposed constitutional

2342
01:38:43,711 --> 01:38:45,212
amendment do at its core it

2343
01:38:45,212 --> 01:38:46,813
prohibits contracting for

2344
01:38:46,813 --> 01:38:48,323
services under some very very

2345
01:38:48,323 --> 01:38:50,323
limited circumstances. Let's

2346
01:38:51,715 --> 01:38:53,183
take a deeper look. The bill

2347
01:38:53,183 --> 01:38:55,183
this proposed constitutional

2348
01:38:55,185 --> 01:38:57,417
amendment covers all uc

2349
01:38:57,417 --> 01:38:59,550
contract workers paid to

2350
01:38:59,550 --> 01:39:01,455
perform support services at

2351
01:39:02,158 --> 01:39:03,457
various uc facilities including

2352
01:39:03,457 --> 01:39:05,394
uc medical centers clinics

2353
01:39:05,394 --> 01:39:07,394
research facilities and

2354
01:39:08,660 --> 01:39:09,565
laboratories so in addition to

2355
01:39:09,565 --> 01:39:11,767
impacting the availability of

2356
01:39:11,767 --> 01:39:12,970
workers at university campuses

2357
01:39:12,970 --> 01:39:14,968
we're also talking about

2358
01:39:14,968 --> 01:39:15,902
workers providing patient care

2359
01:39:15,902 --> 01:39:17,305
services that are you see

2360
01:39:17,305 --> 01:39:19,705
medical service around the

2361
01:39:19,739 --> 01:39:21,807
state our top tier hospitals

2362
01:39:21,807 --> 01:39:24,807
providing critical care. To our

2363
01:39:24,878 --> 01:39:26,610
most seriously ill. Are very

2364
01:39:26,610 --> 01:39:29,610
sick. And our most vulnerable

2365
01:39:30,518 --> 01:39:31,783
patients. In many cases we're

2366
01:39:31,783 --> 01:39:33,685
talking about providing care

2367
01:39:33,685 --> 01:39:34,956
and emergency basis that

2368
01:39:34,956 --> 01:39:36,723
frankly cannot be obtained

2369
01:39:36,723 --> 01:39:38,922
anywhere else in the state and

2370
01:39:38,922 --> 01:39:39,522
the patient's census at these

2371
01:39:39,522 --> 01:39:43,122
hospitals can very from day to

2372
01:39:45,920 --> 01:39:46,829
day. And even from our our. Are

2373
01:39:46,829 --> 01:39:47,831
you see medical centers need to

2374
01:39:47,831 --> 01:39:49,298
be able to respond to these

2375
01:39:49,298 --> 01:39:51,698
changes in critical patient

2376
01:39:51,801 --> 01:39:53,702
loads immediately right now not

2377
01:39:53,702 --> 01:39:55,537
next week because they must

2378
01:39:55,537 --> 01:39:58,340
accept patients that show up at

2379
01:39:58,340 --> 01:40:01,443
the door and provide care they

2380
01:40:01,443 --> 01:40:02,608
simply can't say wait a day or

2381
01:40:02,608 --> 01:40:06,208
two until we find someone. To

2382
01:40:07,314 --> 01:40:08,717
do so. So how does this

2383
01:40:08,717 --> 01:40:10,717
proposed constitutional

2384
01:40:11,351 --> 01:40:11,953
amendment force uc to deal with

2385
01:40:11,953 --> 01:40:14,854
that quickly moving target at

2386
01:40:14,854 --> 01:40:16,156
these health centers. You see

2387
01:40:16,156 --> 01:40:18,556
May contract for support

2388
01:40:18,658 --> 01:40:19,923
services only if contracting is

2389
01:40:19,923 --> 01:40:21,961
necessary to deal with

2390
01:40:21,961 --> 01:40:23,630
specified circumstances

2391
01:40:23,630 --> 01:40:24,831
outlined in this amendment

2392
01:40:24,831 --> 01:40:26,162
including the following. To

2393
01:40:26,162 --> 01:40:28,270
supply the university with a

2394
01:40:28,270 --> 01:40:30,270
licensed clinically trained

2395
01:40:30,805 --> 01:40:32,168
workers for a clinical registry.

2396
01:40:32,168 --> 01:40:33,603
How they use that's what they

2397
01:40:33,603 --> 01:40:35,507
used to get temporary workers

2398
01:40:35,507 --> 01:40:36,742
when their lists of part time

2399
01:40:36,742 --> 01:40:39,142
per diem workers are

2400
01:40:39,678 --> 01:40:40,813
insufficient. And to address a

2401
01:40:40,813 --> 01:40:42,417
bona fide emergency

2402
01:40:42,417 --> 01:40:44,382
circumstance which May include

2403
01:40:44,382 --> 01:40:46,318
but not be limited to insuring

2404
01:40:46,318 --> 01:40:48,222
the continuous operations of

2405
01:40:48,222 --> 01:40:49,587
emergency departments and

2406
01:40:49,587 --> 01:40:50,922
providing medical care to

2407
01:40:50,922 --> 01:40:52,922
address life threatening

2408
01:40:53,991 --> 01:40:54,492
situations during an emergency.

2409
01:40:54,492 --> 01:40:57,361
Among a few other listed

2410
01:40:57,361 --> 01:40:58,963
situations. The use of

2411
01:40:58,963 --> 01:41:00,297
contracting authorities to

2412
01:41:00,297 --> 01:41:02,266
secure workers to deal with

2413
01:41:02,266 --> 01:41:04,680
this bona fide emergency

2414
01:41:04,680 --> 01:41:05,135
circumstance or the use of a

2415
01:41:05,135 --> 01:41:07,700
registry to deal with the

2416
01:41:07,700 --> 01:41:09,360
critical personnel shortage is

2417
01:41:09,360 --> 01:41:10,709
only permitted if we first

2418
01:41:10,709 --> 01:41:12,740
authorized such action a bill

2419
01:41:12,740 --> 01:41:13,474
which we passed in this

2420
01:41:13,474 --> 01:41:15,145
legislature. And which is then

2421
01:41:15,145 --> 01:41:17,214
signed by the governor for

2422
01:41:17,214 --> 01:41:18,647
those who want to fact check me

2423
01:41:18,647 --> 01:41:21,149
on the point and I don't blame

2424
01:41:21,149 --> 01:41:22,350
you. Section nine point five c.

2425
01:41:22,350 --> 01:41:24,686
One states in pertinent part

2426
01:41:24,686 --> 01:41:26,887
the regents of the university

2427
01:41:26,887 --> 01:41:28,953
of california May contract for.

2428
01:41:28,953 --> 01:41:31,353
Contract labor to perform

2429
01:41:32,826 --> 01:41:35,226
support services only if

2430
01:41:36,593 --> 01:41:37,194
authorized to do so by statute.

2431
01:41:37,194 --> 01:41:38,631
Now they're very certainly

2432
01:41:38,631 --> 01:41:40,332
various levels a bona fide

2433
01:41:40,332 --> 01:41:42,301
emergencies but imagine having

2434
01:41:42,301 --> 01:41:43,869
to wait for our bill process in

2435
01:41:43,869 --> 01:41:45,670
order to respond to emerge any

2436
01:41:45,670 --> 01:41:46,837
emergency. Particularly in

2437
01:41:46,837 --> 01:41:49,470
emergency at a health care

2438
01:41:49,470 --> 01:41:51,778
facility. Not perhaps a list of

2439
01:41:51,778 --> 01:41:53,844
part time per diem employees.

2440
01:41:53,844 --> 01:41:56,844
Will be sufficient. But what

2441
01:41:57,146 --> 01:41:58,148
happens if it isn't. Clearly we

2442
01:41:58,148 --> 01:42:00,548
have to address worker

2443
01:42:00,651 --> 01:42:02,850
concerns. Clearly we have to

2444
01:42:02,850 --> 01:42:03,586
protect all workers including

2445
01:42:03,586 --> 01:42:05,654
those at uc particularly our

2446
01:42:05,654 --> 01:42:07,587
hardest working lowest paid and

2447
01:42:07,587 --> 01:42:09,425
most vulnerable because that's

2448
01:42:09,425 --> 01:42:11,627
our job and clearly the

2449
01:42:11,627 --> 01:42:14,270
university of california has

2450
01:42:14,196 --> 01:42:15,964
failed to do so for decades.

2451
01:42:15,964 --> 01:42:16,565
but this proposed

2452
01:42:16,565 --> 01:42:18,565
constitutional amendment just

2453
01:42:19,265 --> 01:42:20,602
doesn't work. Obviously we

2454
01:42:20,602 --> 01:42:21,736
can't predict the future

2455
01:42:21,736 --> 01:42:23,680
particularly with regard to

2456
01:42:23,680 --> 01:42:24,773
emergencies of the nature of

2457
01:42:24,773 --> 01:42:26,544
the required response but if

2458
01:42:26,544 --> 01:42:27,942
the proponents are wrong in

2459
01:42:27,942 --> 01:42:28,977
their predictions as to the

2460
01:42:28,977 --> 01:42:31,212
impact on are you see health

2461
01:42:31,212 --> 01:42:33,417
care delivery system. And this

2462
01:42:33,417 --> 01:42:34,150
new process with the language

2463
01:42:34,150 --> 01:42:37,150
that I've identified. Which is

2464
01:42:38,549 --> 01:42:40,521
flood. Needs to be changed. Our

2465
01:42:40,521 --> 01:42:43,900
effort to do so in the process

2466
01:42:43,900 --> 01:42:46,595
to do so will be herculean. And

2467
01:42:46,595 --> 01:42:48,594
we just can't waive it. There

2468
01:42:48,594 --> 01:42:49,664
has to be a better way in the

2469
01:42:49,664 --> 01:42:51,764
form of a constitutional

2470
01:42:51,764 --> 01:42:53,340
amendment to it to achieve the

2471
01:42:53,340 --> 01:42:54,833
objectives that are attempted

2472
01:42:54,833 --> 01:42:57,169
to be achieved here we need to

2473
01:42:57,169 --> 01:42:58,606
take better care and pay better

2474
01:42:58,606 --> 01:42:59,841
attention to the language when

2475
01:42:59,841 --> 01:43:02,141
we draft amendments to our

2476
01:43:02,141 --> 01:43:04,141
state constitution because-for

2477
01:43:06,211 --> 01:43:06,711
those of us. Certainly here we

2478
01:43:06,711 --> 01:43:09,111
know language frankly is

2479
01:43:11,582 --> 01:43:13,454
important. So unfortunately I

2480
01:43:13,454 --> 01:43:14,922
won't be able to support the

2481
01:43:14,922 --> 01:43:16,922
constitutional amendment as

2482
01:43:17,955 --> 01:43:19,525
drafted at this point however I

2483
01:43:19,525 --> 01:43:21,124
commit to working diligently

2484
01:43:21,124 --> 01:43:22,823
with the proponents the uc

2485
01:43:22,823 --> 01:43:24,861
regents in the administration

2486
01:43:24,861 --> 01:43:27,167
to pin down a permanent

2487
01:43:27,167 --> 01:43:28,262
solution to the issues is

2488
01:43:28,262 --> 01:43:29,663
assembly constitutional

2489
01:43:29,663 --> 01:43:30,864
amendment is attempting to

2490
01:43:30,864 --> 01:43:32,401
address in a more craft

2491
01:43:32,401 --> 01:43:33,970
carefully crafted

2492
01:43:33,970 --> 01:43:35,902
constitutional amendment and

2493
01:43:35,902 --> 01:43:38,972
stand ready to do so and have

2494
01:43:38,972 --> 01:43:39,507
been standing ready to do so

2495
01:43:39,507 --> 01:43:42,512
during the last week or so

2496
01:43:42,512 --> 01:43:44,611
we've been talking about this.

2497
01:43:44,611 --> 01:43:45,579
Obviously if this measure

2498
01:43:45,579 --> 01:43:47,248
passes today and is approved by

2499
01:43:47,248 --> 01:43:50,248
the voters well assuming I'm

2500
01:43:51,381 --> 01:43:52,689
still here. I'll do my best to

2501
01:43:52,689 --> 01:43:55,321
ensure that the fire and other

2502
01:43:55,321 --> 01:43:57,200
emergencies that we have indoor

2503
01:43:57,200 --> 01:43:58,358
and seemingly and deron

2504
01:43:58,358 --> 01:44:00,758
increasing basis month after

2505
01:44:02,270 --> 01:44:02,628
month. Coordinate with our

2506
01:44:02,628 --> 01:44:05,201
legislative schedule so we can

2507
01:44:05,201 --> 01:44:06,667
pass an appropriate bill. To

2508
01:44:06,667 --> 01:44:09,667
take care of these issues

2509
01:44:09,899 --> 01:44:10,435
before it gets worse. I'm

2510
01:44:10,435 --> 01:44:12,835
confident that we can

2511
01:44:12,935 --> 01:44:14,106
permanently fix this issue for

2512
01:44:14,106 --> 01:44:17,706
those impacted in in in a

2513
01:44:18,511 --> 01:44:19,144
constitutional amendment. Month

2514
01:44:19,144 --> 01:44:20,946
just not this way thank you for

2515
01:44:20,946 --> 01:44:23,816
your patience. Thank you center

2516
01:44:23,816 --> 01:44:26,216
stir. Thank you Mister

2517
01:44:30,657 --> 01:44:34,857
President. As a as a cal grad.

2518
01:44:35,592 --> 01:44:39,192
Go bears anybody. And as a

2519
01:44:39,727 --> 01:44:42,964
former teacher at ucla I have

2520
01:44:42,964 --> 01:44:45,200
deep affection for this system

2521
01:44:45,200 --> 01:44:45,833
I think it is the finest public

2522
01:44:45,833 --> 01:44:48,833
university system in the entire

2523
01:44:51,472 --> 01:44:55,720
world. And I don't intend. With

2524
01:44:55,646 --> 01:44:57,420
the vote here today. That we

2525
01:44:57,420 --> 01:44:59,177
break the university of

2526
01:44:59,177 --> 01:45:02,777
california in fact I think we

2527
01:45:03,645 --> 01:45:07,185
can strengthen it. I wanted to

2528
01:45:07,185 --> 01:45:10,785
address two issues one of which

2529
01:45:11,155 --> 01:45:12,356
is about money. If you look at

2530
01:45:12,356 --> 01:45:15,356
the fiscal analysis on this

2531
01:45:15,859 --> 01:45:16,524
measure it talk about a about a

2532
01:45:16,524 --> 01:45:17,861
hundred seventy two million

2533
01:45:17,861 --> 01:45:20,261
dollar impact of this

2534
01:45:22,336 --> 01:45:22,832
legislation. When you think

2535
01:45:22,832 --> 01:45:24,501
about the output of this

2536
01:45:24,501 --> 01:45:27,501
university system. The scale of

2537
01:45:29,272 --> 01:45:31,272
economic productivity the

2538
01:45:31,405 --> 01:45:34,405
social mobility that we could

2539
01:45:36,779 --> 01:45:38,814
possibly enable. I think that

2540
01:45:38,814 --> 01:45:42,810
is a more than fillable gap.

2541
01:45:42,810 --> 01:45:43,682
And in my view. We've been

2542
01:45:43,682 --> 01:45:46,820
short changing the university

2543
01:45:47,288 --> 01:45:49,757
california for too long. I am

2544
01:45:49,757 --> 01:45:53,357
very excited that we May be

2545
01:45:53,661 --> 01:45:55,429
passing a an education bonds.

2546
01:45:55,429 --> 01:45:56,630
That would put two billion

2547
01:45:56,630 --> 01:45:58,699
dollars in the higher education

2548
01:45:58,699 --> 01:46:00,467
going forward. We know the

2549
01:46:00,467 --> 01:46:02,936
buildings are starting to fail

2550
01:46:02,936 --> 01:46:05,336
there seismic issues university

2551
01:46:05,472 --> 01:46:08,472
california ucla and berkeley in

2552
01:46:09,375 --> 01:46:09,908
other campuses. But even on an

2553
01:46:09,908 --> 01:46:12,908
annual budget cycle we go

2554
01:46:13,410 --> 01:46:16,213
through every year. I think

2555
01:46:16,213 --> 01:46:18,214
voting for this measure entails

2556
01:46:18,214 --> 01:46:20,617
an obligation to step up to the

2557
01:46:20,617 --> 01:46:22,652
plate for this legislature. To

2558
01:46:22,652 --> 01:46:25,855
help fill this gap. But what I

2559
01:46:25,855 --> 01:46:28,823
wanna say is that. We should

2560
01:46:28,823 --> 01:46:30,891
not have to choose between. Our

2561
01:46:30,891 --> 01:46:32,790
workers fairly and having a

2562
01:46:32,790 --> 01:46:35,970
first class university system.

2563
01:46:35,970 --> 01:46:38,195
I think we can do both. I

2564
01:46:38,195 --> 01:46:40,536
showed up on campus. I first

2565
01:46:40,536 --> 01:46:42,602
year law school on bancroft in

2566
01:46:42,602 --> 01:46:43,330
member walking out to get a

2567
01:46:43,330 --> 01:46:44,571
bite to eat at the

2568
01:46:44,571 --> 01:46:46,669
international house which is

2569
01:46:46,669 --> 01:46:47,307
right up the street I saw these

2570
01:46:47,307 --> 01:46:50,900
folks in green. Standing out on

2571
01:46:50,900 --> 01:46:52,211
the street. I wondered who are

2572
01:46:52,211 --> 01:46:55,280
who are these people. So I

2573
01:46:55,280 --> 01:46:57,680
eight I started conversation

2574
01:46:58,950 --> 01:47:01,252
and it turns out. They're the

2575
01:47:01,252 --> 01:47:04,852
people who kept my school clean.

2576
01:47:05,230 --> 01:47:05,626
Made my campus safe. So I could

2577
01:47:05,626 --> 01:47:09,826
keep my head in the books they

2578
01:47:11,226 --> 01:47:13,626
grinded. And for students.

2579
01:47:14,233 --> 01:47:16,497
Faculty administrators or even

2580
01:47:16,497 --> 01:47:17,134
us is legislators to pretend

2581
01:47:17,134 --> 01:47:20,134
like those people are invisible

2582
01:47:23,473 --> 01:47:25,708
just wrong. So. When we vote

2583
01:47:25,708 --> 01:47:27,543
here today when I take this

2584
01:47:27,543 --> 01:47:31,143
vote I'll be thinking of those

2585
01:47:31,713 --> 01:47:32,250
people up the street. To work

2586
01:47:32,250 --> 01:47:36,117
day in and out to make our

2587
01:47:36,117 --> 01:47:38,188
system go. But I do not think

2588
01:47:38,188 --> 01:47:40,888
this is going to be. A fatal

2589
01:47:40,888 --> 01:47:43,288
blow. To the university

2590
01:47:44,856 --> 01:47:46,195
california. I think we can

2591
01:47:46,195 --> 01:47:48,228
actually establish the moral

2592
01:47:48,228 --> 01:47:48,728
high ground for this university

2593
01:47:48,728 --> 01:47:51,728
system and truly form a

2594
01:47:52,635 --> 01:47:54,300
partnership. That will require

2595
01:47:54,300 --> 01:47:56,271
some additional statutory work

2596
01:47:56,271 --> 01:47:57,970
on our part. I do think that

2597
01:47:57,970 --> 01:48:00,970
there are our needs for

2598
01:48:01,571 --> 01:48:03,971
enhanced flexibility. And that

2599
01:48:04,811 --> 01:48:05,444
express statutory authorization

2600
01:48:05,444 --> 01:48:08,981
to allow for the legislature to

2601
01:48:08,981 --> 01:48:11,484
step in. For a variety of

2602
01:48:11,484 --> 01:48:12,116
circumstances not only in the

2603
01:48:12,116 --> 01:48:14,116
circumstances that could

2604
01:48:14,619 --> 01:48:15,223
senator from riverside brought

2605
01:48:15,223 --> 01:48:17,852
up but also I believe in nine

2606
01:48:17,852 --> 01:48:20,723
point five g. Talks about the

2607
01:48:20,723 --> 01:48:22,959
for the purposes of this act. I

2608
01:48:22,959 --> 01:48:26,559
think there's going to be ample

2609
01:48:27,660 --> 01:48:27,663
flexibility for us here to step

2610
01:48:27,663 --> 01:48:28,266
up but we can't just take this

2611
01:48:28,266 --> 01:48:31,330
vote and walk away. To put our

2612
01:48:31,330 --> 01:48:32,934
money where our mouth. We have

2613
01:48:32,934 --> 01:48:36,534
to find a way statutorily to

2614
01:48:36,738 --> 01:48:37,275
make sure the system continues

2615
01:48:37,275 --> 01:48:40,275
to be excellent. And grows

2616
01:48:41,576 --> 01:48:44,576
itself. So I'll be supporting

2617
01:48:45,800 --> 01:48:47,115
the measure here today. But I

2618
01:48:47,115 --> 01:48:48,686
hope we can start to turn the

2619
01:48:48,686 --> 01:48:51,180
page and end this year of

2620
01:48:51,180 --> 01:48:53,554
enmity that is plague is

2621
01:48:53,554 --> 01:48:56,190
university for far too long. We

2622
01:48:56,190 --> 01:48:56,794
do not need to be at odds. And

2623
01:48:56,794 --> 01:49:00,930
there is a table somewhere we

2624
01:49:00,930 --> 01:49:01,898
can all sit down. And I hope

2625
01:49:01,898 --> 01:49:02,429
for my friends of the region's

2626
01:49:02,429 --> 01:49:05,429
or the leadership of this

2627
01:49:05,729 --> 01:49:08,729
university. They will take this

2628
01:49:08,935 --> 01:49:10,469
not as some review. But as a

2629
01:49:10,469 --> 01:49:13,706
charge the come to step up to

2630
01:49:13,706 --> 01:49:16,118
the plate. And find a way to

2631
01:49:16,118 --> 01:49:17,112
work with us to truly make this

2632
01:49:17,112 --> 01:49:20,712
university the gym that it is.

2633
01:49:24,616 --> 01:49:25,717
Thank you. Senator pat. Thank

2634
01:49:25,717 --> 01:49:28,180
you Mister President senators

2635
01:49:28,180 --> 01:49:31,254
side rise in support of this

2636
01:49:31,254 --> 01:49:33,890
aca I know that many people

2637
01:49:33,890 --> 01:49:36,226
here are graduates of the year

2638
01:49:36,226 --> 01:49:37,826
for the california and it had

2639
01:49:37,826 --> 01:49:39,528
certainly tremendous experience

2640
01:49:39,528 --> 01:49:41,928
there I actually unfortunately

2641
01:49:42,195 --> 01:49:44,168
have nots however I served as a

2642
01:49:44,168 --> 01:49:45,197
faculty member at the

2643
01:49:45,197 --> 01:49:46,601
university california I don't

2644
01:49:46,601 --> 01:49:48,604
know how many of you have

2645
01:49:48,604 --> 01:49:50,537
served on is affecting their

2646
01:49:50,537 --> 01:49:51,771
full time faculty member at the

2647
01:49:51,771 --> 01:49:53,342
mercy california. Affected been

2648
01:49:53,342 --> 01:49:54,909
told us of first full time

2649
01:49:54,909 --> 01:49:56,274
faculty member uc's ever been

2650
01:49:56,274 --> 01:49:58,674
elected to the state

2651
01:49:59,146 --> 01:50:02,146
legislature but if someone find

2652
01:50:02,249 --> 01:50:06,319
someone else let me know and I

2653
01:50:06,319 --> 01:50:07,587
stand support. Actually for.

2654
01:50:07,587 --> 01:50:10,189
Both as a former faculty member

2655
01:50:10,189 --> 01:50:10,790
and also as a physician because

2656
01:50:10,790 --> 01:50:13,259
I know many people brought up

2657
01:50:13,259 --> 01:50:15,310
the health systems. So

2658
01:50:15,310 --> 01:50:17,466
certainly as a faculty member I

2659
01:50:17,466 --> 01:50:20,466
think it's very important that

2660
01:50:20,568 --> 01:50:22,968
we teach our students. And set

2661
01:50:22,968 --> 01:50:25,234
a good example for them as to

2662
01:50:25,234 --> 01:50:28,343
how we do business. At our

2663
01:50:28,343 --> 01:50:30,609
state run university our state

2664
01:50:30,609 --> 01:50:31,209
university our premier that

2665
01:50:31,209 --> 01:50:34,209
crown jewel we call diversity

2666
01:50:34,310 --> 01:50:37,910
california. And so what kind of

2667
01:50:37,913 --> 01:50:40,913
example. Are we setting our

2668
01:50:41,287 --> 01:50:43,687
students when the university.

2669
01:50:45,322 --> 01:50:46,524
Decides to lay off employees

2670
01:50:46,524 --> 01:50:48,924
replacing the contract workers

2671
01:50:49,290 --> 01:50:51,263
or even higher contract workers

2672
01:50:51,263 --> 01:50:53,663
instead of expanding their

2673
01:50:56,403 --> 01:50:58,803
employment workforce. The. Now

2674
01:51:00,646 --> 01:51:00,801
certainly there are times when

2675
01:51:00,801 --> 01:51:02,370
there are temp yelp and there

2676
01:51:02,370 --> 01:51:04,439
it's outlined here that you May

2677
01:51:04,439 --> 01:51:05,270
have situations where you have

2678
01:51:05,270 --> 01:51:06,162
a certain event or something

2679
01:51:06,162 --> 01:51:08,642
where you May need some

2680
01:51:08,642 --> 01:51:10,508
flexibility but I think it is

2681
01:51:10,508 --> 01:51:12,613
important that we teach our

2682
01:51:12,613 --> 01:51:15,146
students and the learners who

2683
01:51:15,146 --> 01:51:17,684
are at the mercy california how

2684
01:51:17,684 --> 01:51:19,653
one can do business and yes we

2685
01:51:19,653 --> 01:51:20,156
hear is the legislature we have

2686
01:51:20,156 --> 01:51:22,556
a responsibility to help

2687
01:51:23,123 --> 01:51:23,757
support. Our university in a

2688
01:51:23,757 --> 01:51:25,792
way that allows them to adhere

2689
01:51:25,792 --> 01:51:27,794
to the values. I do appreciate

2690
01:51:27,794 --> 01:51:28,863
that my good friend to stocking

2691
01:51:28,863 --> 01:51:30,430
the bill from santa clarita has

2692
01:51:30,430 --> 01:51:32,565
pointed out that actually the

2693
01:51:32,565 --> 01:51:34,965
financial cost. Is actually

2694
01:51:35,101 --> 01:51:36,904
bearable within the university.

2695
01:51:36,904 --> 01:51:39,371
And so I do think as a faculty

2696
01:51:39,371 --> 01:51:42,208
member. Who wants to not only

2697
01:51:42,208 --> 01:51:45,208
just teach. My learners through

2698
01:51:47,941 --> 01:51:49,679
lectures are other educational.

2699
01:51:49,679 --> 01:51:51,414
All act. That we should set

2700
01:51:51,414 --> 01:51:53,490
that example and I think that's

2701
01:51:53,490 --> 01:51:53,617
critically important and this

2702
01:51:53,617 --> 01:51:56,617
idea of equity. Because what

2703
01:51:57,687 --> 01:51:59,210
this. Many does and many of you

2704
01:51:59,210 --> 01:51:59,688
spoke to the fact that by the

2705
01:51:59,688 --> 01:52:01,900
way I know that some people

2706
01:52:01,900 --> 01:52:02,791
said well is there a rush to

2707
01:52:02,791 --> 01:52:04,493
judgment here. I mean this is

2708
01:52:04,493 --> 01:52:06,163
an ongoing issue for a long

2709
01:52:06,163 --> 01:52:07,232
time I mean throughout my

2710
01:52:07,232 --> 01:52:09,610
entire time the legislature

2711
01:52:09,610 --> 01:52:12,610
before ever got the legislature

2712
01:52:13,204 --> 01:52:13,429
went. Before some of you are in

2713
01:52:13,429 --> 01:52:13,576
the legislature before I was in

2714
01:52:13,576 --> 01:52:14,335
the legislature I mean this is

2715
01:52:14,335 --> 01:52:15,772
not a rush to judgment this is

2716
01:52:15,772 --> 01:52:17,207
something we've been working on

2717
01:52:17,207 --> 01:52:18,443
for a very long time. And I

2718
01:52:18,443 --> 01:52:20,339
think it is important that we

2719
01:52:20,339 --> 01:52:22,100
set that example now I know

2720
01:52:22,100 --> 01:52:23,778
that many people also raise the

2721
01:52:23,778 --> 01:52:26,140
issue about the med center's.

2722
01:52:26,140 --> 01:52:27,812
And health care systems and-

2723
01:52:27,812 --> 01:52:29,282
other position you practiced

2724
01:52:29,282 --> 01:52:30,717
not only outpatient but also

2725
01:52:30,717 --> 01:52:32,520
information I did you know the

2726
01:52:32,520 --> 01:52:34,910
word attending that other

2727
01:52:34,910 --> 01:52:36,990
things. And believe me yes I

2728
01:52:36,990 --> 01:52:37,150
agree. The it goes up the-

2729
01:52:37,150 --> 01:52:37,298
-

2730
01:52:37,298 --> 01:52:37,452
-

2731
01:52:37,452 --> 01:52:38,895
-

2732
01:52:38,895 --> 01:52:40,861
out in terms of the demands

2733
01:52:40,861 --> 01:52:43,962
right I would also point out

2734
01:52:43,962 --> 01:52:46,362
that perhaps the biggest

2735
01:52:47,635 --> 01:52:49,234
limitation any capacity if some.

2736
01:52:49,234 --> 01:52:50,168
No major event happens is not

2737
01:52:50,168 --> 01:52:50,802
just staff. Although certainly

2738
01:52:50,802 --> 01:52:52,737
that's one place it's actually

2739
01:52:52,737 --> 01:52:53,835
the facility itself. And so we

2740
01:52:53,835 --> 01:52:56,874
have to think about the fact

2741
01:52:56,874 --> 01:52:58,750
that actually the-uc hospitals

2742
01:52:58,750 --> 01:53:00,790
we thought talk about me ever

2743
01:53:00,790 --> 01:53:00,844
very specialty programs. Those

2744
01:53:00,844 --> 01:53:02,914
are not the ones who are

2745
01:53:02,914 --> 01:53:04,612
suffering the large swings in

2746
01:53:04,612 --> 01:53:06,246
demand okay we're talking about

2747
01:53:06,246 --> 01:53:08,149
the merchants you room there's

2748
01:53:08,149 --> 01:53:10,551
a disaster or something. Right

2749
01:53:10,551 --> 01:53:11,152
we do have first of all plans

2750
01:53:11,152 --> 01:53:13,885
and that involves actually the

2751
01:53:13,885 --> 01:53:16,560
existing staff. So there there

2752
01:53:16,560 --> 01:53:18,759
is any we're we actually do

2753
01:53:18,759 --> 01:53:20,961
plan for and organized to

2754
01:53:20,961 --> 01:53:23,361
handle variations in patient

2755
01:53:23,596 --> 01:53:24,998
volume including even. Things

2756
01:53:24,998 --> 01:53:26,232
to happen to the virgin threw

2757
01:53:26,232 --> 01:53:27,965
me off there is a school bus

2758
01:53:27,965 --> 01:53:30,367
accidents we have we are we are

2759
01:53:30,367 --> 01:53:33,730
organized to respond to that

2760
01:53:33,730 --> 01:53:35,770
with existing staff now. There

2761
01:53:35,770 --> 01:53:35,975
is mention in the ac itself the

2762
01:53:35,975 --> 01:53:38,408
says if there's actually a

2763
01:53:38,408 --> 01:53:40,808
large scale emergency the

2764
01:53:41,616 --> 01:53:42,881
governor can declare and weak

2765
01:53:42,881 --> 01:53:45,550
and the university can't pull

2766
01:53:45,550 --> 01:53:46,518
in more people to do that the

2767
01:53:46,518 --> 01:53:48,520
handle that as well so

2768
01:53:48,520 --> 01:53:50,756
certainly if there is there is

2769
01:53:50,756 --> 01:53:52,894
it is a large scale events

2770
01:53:52,894 --> 01:53:54,590
where we do need. To bring in

2771
01:53:54,590 --> 01:53:57,590
many more people into the

2772
01:53:57,664 --> 01:54:00,664
facility there is that capacity

2773
01:54:01,699 --> 01:54:02,764
as well. So. Now maybe there

2774
01:54:02,764 --> 01:54:03,669
you know maybe we do need to

2775
01:54:03,669 --> 01:54:04,538
legislative fix if this is

2776
01:54:04,538 --> 01:54:06,801
passed by the voters and point

2777
01:54:06,801 --> 01:54:08,773
out this goes to the voters

2778
01:54:08,773 --> 01:54:11,500
but-I'd-it this is not. A

2779
01:54:11,500 --> 01:54:12,912
this aca is not going to

2780
01:54:12,912 --> 01:54:13,710
cripple. Are you see health

2781
01:54:13,710 --> 01:54:15,479
system to someone who's

2782
01:54:15,479 --> 01:54:18,479
actually worked there okay and

2783
01:54:20,783 --> 01:54:21,951
so. I think that this

2784
01:54:21,951 --> 01:54:23,951
resolutions important because

2785
01:54:24,622 --> 01:54:25,555
it resolves a problem that's

2786
01:54:25,555 --> 01:54:28,791
been going on for a long time

2787
01:54:28,791 --> 01:54:30,396
at uc. Clearly like any

2788
01:54:30,396 --> 01:54:32,396
constitutional amendment it's

2789
01:54:33,262 --> 01:54:36,198
gonna go to the voters but I am

2790
01:54:36,198 --> 01:54:38,733
also proud of the fact that. We

2791
01:54:38,733 --> 01:54:41,720
can also it has those spaces

2792
01:54:41,720 --> 01:54:42,137
within their for us to fine

2793
01:54:42,137 --> 01:54:44,840
tune the parts that need to be

2794
01:54:44,840 --> 01:54:46,409
fine tuned in there but I they

2795
01:54:46,409 --> 01:54:48,277
do want to just say again I

2796
01:54:48,277 --> 01:54:50,420
support this resolution because

2797
01:54:50,420 --> 01:54:51,512
as both a faculty member we'd

2798
01:54:51,512 --> 01:54:54,713
have to set the right example

2799
01:54:54,713 --> 01:54:56,359
analso as a physician I want

2800
01:54:56,359 --> 01:54:58,816
to see. Our staff the staff

2801
01:54:58,816 --> 01:55:01,119
that's actually taking helping

2802
01:55:01,119 --> 01:55:02,386
us take care to patients. We

2803
01:55:02,386 --> 01:55:04,322
need to be sure we have people

2804
01:55:04,322 --> 01:55:06,357
who both know what they're

2805
01:55:06,357 --> 01:55:07,758
doing. Right yelp believe not

2806
01:55:07,758 --> 01:55:09,259
if you're the person have to

2807
01:55:09,259 --> 01:55:11,280
clean up blood vomit unit you

2808
01:55:11,280 --> 01:55:12,640
actually sorry and-so that's

2809
01:55:12,640 --> 01:55:13,598
what happens in a hospital. You

2810
01:55:13,598 --> 01:55:14,331
know you you it's not you don't

2811
01:55:14,331 --> 01:55:15,866
just pull someone off the

2812
01:55:15,866 --> 01:55:19,466
street they need to not handle

2813
01:55:20,800 --> 01:55:20,262
it. It and but there should

2814
01:55:20,262 --> 01:55:21,390
also know that they're being

2815
01:55:21,390 --> 01:55:22,740
paid the same to gain the same

2816
01:55:22,740 --> 01:55:24,140
benefits they need to know that

2817
01:55:24,140 --> 01:55:25,174
everyone's in it together

2818
01:55:25,174 --> 01:55:26,642
that's how health system works

2819
01:55:26,642 --> 01:55:30,242
alot things work but that's how

2820
01:55:32,248 --> 01:55:32,781
health system work. And so this.

2821
01:55:32,781 --> 01:55:33,345
I think is important step

2822
01:55:33,345 --> 01:55:36,345
forward and I heard tonight.

2823
01:55:36,384 --> 01:55:37,279
Thank you. Thank you senator

2824
01:55:37,279 --> 01:55:38,190
jones. Thank you Mister

2825
01:55:38,190 --> 01:55:40,419
President fishing yeah you

2826
01:55:40,754 --> 01:55:43,656
recognize me. The you know it

2827
01:55:43,656 --> 01:55:45,826
sounds like this morning. We

2828
01:55:45,826 --> 01:55:48,194
have a lot of agreement. On the

2829
01:55:48,194 --> 01:55:48,894
floor here today that there are

2830
01:55:48,894 --> 01:55:49,795
some challenges with the

2831
01:55:49,795 --> 01:55:51,795
university of california

2832
01:55:53,200 --> 01:55:55,298
system. And y know that's

2833
01:55:55,298 --> 01:55:58,298
probably accurate. And I do

2834
01:55:58,602 --> 01:55:59,837
want to recognize and-the co

2835
01:55:59,837 --> 01:56:01,571
author of the senate co author

2836
01:56:01,571 --> 01:56:03,508
from santa three to. And his

2837
01:56:03,508 --> 01:56:06,409
work this year on this project

2838
01:56:06,409 --> 01:56:08,375
along with the assembly author.

2839
01:56:08,375 --> 01:56:11,975
In bringing this issue to us

2840
01:56:12,480 --> 01:56:15,480
and-making it known. And his

2841
01:56:17,186 --> 01:56:19,422
advocacy. For this today. But

2842
01:56:19,422 --> 01:56:20,422
the I think with the main

2843
01:56:20,422 --> 01:56:22,558
source of the disagreement on

2844
01:56:22,558 --> 01:56:25,194
this is were using a

2845
01:56:25,194 --> 01:56:27,594
sledgehammer. To solve a

2846
01:56:27,829 --> 01:56:30,829
problem that needs to be.

2847
01:56:31,800 --> 01:56:32,868
Solved with a scalpel and. I

2848
01:56:32,868 --> 01:56:34,669
appreciate the comment that was

2849
01:56:34,669 --> 01:56:37,238
made earlier in the debate

2850
01:56:37,238 --> 01:56:38,408
regarding first class workers.

2851
01:56:38,408 --> 01:56:40,708
and I do agree that the

2852
01:56:40,708 --> 01:56:43,108
university of california agree

2853
01:56:43,410 --> 01:56:45,816
deserves the very best at first

2854
01:56:45,816 --> 01:56:47,281
class workers and the

2855
01:56:47,281 --> 01:56:49,417
shortcomings their of on some

2856
01:56:49,417 --> 01:56:51,754
of the positionshat that

2857
01:56:51,754 --> 01:56:53,953
that. Comment was regarding.

2858
01:56:53,953 --> 01:56:55,452
But let me talk about some

2859
01:56:55,452 --> 01:56:58,452
first class workers that this

2860
01:56:58,628 --> 01:57:01,628
bill unfortunately as a sledge

2861
01:57:01,631 --> 01:57:04,631
hammer is gonna affect. And.

2862
01:57:04,695 --> 01:57:07,950
Most likely remove their

2863
01:57:07,365 --> 01:57:08,500
professionalism from. The uc

2864
01:57:08,500 --> 01:57:10,900
system this measure will

2865
01:57:11,236 --> 01:57:13,538
increase I has been argued is

2866
01:57:13,538 --> 01:57:14,509
already the high costs on

2867
01:57:14,509 --> 01:57:17,241
parents who want to send their

2868
01:57:17,241 --> 01:57:19,407
kids to uc. The savings at the

2869
01:57:19,407 --> 01:57:22,100
uc currently re real realizes

2870
01:57:22,100 --> 01:57:22,580
from con from contracting will

2871
01:57:22,580 --> 01:57:25,116
be gone. And they'll have to

2872
01:57:25,116 --> 01:57:25,717
make it up somewhere. And part

2873
01:57:25,717 --> 01:57:28,449
of it no doubt will be tuition

2874
01:57:28,449 --> 01:57:30,510
increases. As measure also

2875
01:57:30,510 --> 01:57:32,253
bring detrimental impacts to a

2876
01:57:32,253 --> 01:57:33,357
number of research programs.

2877
01:57:33,357 --> 01:57:35,392
And this is the first class

2878
01:57:35,392 --> 01:57:37,861
workers of which I started with

2879
01:57:37,861 --> 01:57:38,995
one example from my region of

2880
01:57:38,995 --> 01:57:41,728
the state is the university of

2881
01:57:41,728 --> 01:57:42,232
california a san diego scripts

2882
01:57:42,232 --> 01:57:44,632
into the institution of

2883
01:57:44,931 --> 01:57:46,269
oceanography. First this

2884
01:57:46,269 --> 01:57:48,271
measure would got scripts

2885
01:57:48,271 --> 01:57:50,730
ability to contract with call

2886
01:57:50,730 --> 01:57:50,608
qualified mariners to

2887
01:57:50,608 --> 01:57:53,800
supplement their full time

2888
01:57:53,542 --> 01:57:55,408
employees. Which is vital to

2889
01:57:55,408 --> 01:57:56,713
their mission of exploring our

2890
01:57:56,713 --> 01:57:58,878
oceans and studying things like

2891
01:57:58,878 --> 01:58:01,581
climate change sleep sea level

2892
01:58:01,581 --> 01:58:02,182
rise and storm surges which

2893
01:58:02,182 --> 01:58:05,870
they're doing very great work

2894
01:58:05,870 --> 01:58:05,882
on by the way. Yeah they don't

2895
01:58:05,882 --> 01:58:08,421
have enough mariners that can

2896
01:58:08,421 --> 01:58:10,956
set sail. That means that they

2897
01:58:10,956 --> 01:58:12,261
cannot conduct their research.

2898
01:58:12,261 --> 01:58:13,893
Script tires part time

2899
01:58:13,893 --> 01:58:16,830
temporary mariners on a per

2900
01:58:16,830 --> 01:58:17,397
diem basis from the university

2901
01:58:17,397 --> 01:58:19,397
national oceanographic labor

2902
01:58:20,799 --> 01:58:22,164
system. These are well

2903
01:58:22,164 --> 01:58:24,360
qualified and credentialed

2904
01:58:24,360 --> 01:58:27,200
mariners that urged choosing to

2905
01:58:27,200 --> 01:58:27,772
work in this part time system

2906
01:58:27,772 --> 01:58:30,172
stead of the traditinal

2907
01:58:30,911 --> 01:58:31,409
schedules that do not suit them

2908
01:58:31,409 --> 01:58:33,809
for whatever reason they

2909
01:58:34,120 --> 01:58:36,111
choose. But they don't student.

2910
01:58:36,111 --> 01:58:37,581
Additionally the temporary and

2911
01:58:37,581 --> 01:58:39,546
short term subcontractors that

2912
01:58:39,546 --> 01:58:41,187
help repairthe institute ships

2913
01:58:41,187 --> 01:58:43,890
will no longer be allowed

2914
01:58:43,890 --> 01:58:45,489
because they're projects often

2915
01:58:45,854 --> 01:58:47,622
take longer than ten days.

2916
01:58:47,622 --> 01:58:49,224
Script does not have the

2917
01:58:49,224 --> 01:58:51,893
expertise to fix their own

2918
01:58:51,893 --> 01:58:53,528
vessels. Nor do they have a the

2919
01:58:53,528 --> 01:58:56,497
a qualified shipyard in which

2920
01:58:56,497 --> 01:58:57,867
to make those repairs. The

2921
01:58:57,867 --> 01:59:00,267
subcontractors run their own

2922
01:59:00,368 --> 01:59:02,600
businesses and have no

2923
01:59:02,600 --> 01:59:02,503
intention of becoming employees

2924
01:59:02,503 --> 01:59:04,903
of the university system

2925
01:59:05,105 --> 01:59:07,505
california system. Have scripts

2926
01:59:08,211 --> 01:59:08,775
cannot contract with them they

2927
01:59:08,775 --> 01:59:11,775
have plenty of other clients

2928
01:59:11,948 --> 01:59:13,613
that will. The loss of

2929
01:59:13,613 --> 01:59:15,810
expertise will for scripts to

2930
01:59:15,810 --> 01:59:17,147
cut back on the number of ships

2931
01:59:17,147 --> 01:59:19,552
it sales and the number of

2932
01:59:19,552 --> 01:59:20,853
voyages it undertakes.

2933
01:59:20,853 --> 01:59:22,857
Consequently the store script

2934
01:59:22,857 --> 01:59:24,796
the storied strips institution

2935
01:59:24,796 --> 01:59:26,492
of oceanography will not be

2936
01:59:26,492 --> 01:59:29,492
able to fulfill its robust

2937
01:59:29,860 --> 01:59:31,728
research mission. And for those

2938
01:59:31,728 --> 01:59:33,829
reasons I agree with the as

2939
01:59:33,829 --> 01:59:35,498
good senator from riverside

2940
01:59:35,498 --> 01:59:38,434
that f we can come back next

2941
01:59:38,434 --> 01:59:39,769
year and use a scalpel instead

2942
01:59:39,769 --> 01:59:41,672
of a sledge hammer I think we

2943
01:59:41,672 --> 01:59:42,438
can solve the problems that

2944
01:59:42,438 --> 01:59:44,373
have been raised today I

2945
01:59:44,373 --> 01:59:47,373
original vote thank you sir.

2946
01:59:47,409 --> 01:59:48,310
Thank you senator leyva. Thank

2947
01:59:48,310 --> 01:59:49,911
you Mister President good

2948
01:59:49,911 --> 01:59:51,811
afternoon members I rise in

2949
01:59:51,811 --> 01:59:54,790
strong support and I rise and

2950
01:59:54,790 --> 01:59:56,248
I'm excited to be a co author

2951
01:59:56,248 --> 01:59:57,650
on this bill. I want to repeat

2952
01:59:57,650 --> 01:59:59,354
some of the comments that I

2953
01:59:59,354 --> 02:00:03,554
made when we heard this bill in

2954
02:00:03,892 --> 02:00:06,454
committee. You know who are we

2955
02:00:06,454 --> 02:00:09,657
as a group who are we as

2956
02:00:09,657 --> 02:00:11,459
legislators if we can allow. A

2957
02:00:11,459 --> 02:00:13,894
group of workers to be treated

2958
02:00:13,894 --> 02:00:16,650
as second class citizens. And

2959
02:00:16,650 --> 02:00:17,667
this is what I see this as is.

2960
02:00:17,667 --> 02:00:19,972
These are the people who make

2961
02:00:19,972 --> 02:00:21,637
the universities run sure we

2962
02:00:21,637 --> 02:00:23,505
need the teachers sure we need

2963
02:00:23,505 --> 02:00:24,737
administrators but if all the

2964
02:00:24,737 --> 02:00:26,808
folks that are in the gallery

2965
02:00:26,808 --> 02:00:27,773
with us today. And the hundreds

2966
02:00:27,773 --> 02:00:30,345
and thousands of more who

2967
02:00:30,345 --> 02:00:32,177
couldn't be here didn't show up

2968
02:00:32,177 --> 02:00:33,582
to work every day. The uc's

2969
02:00:33,582 --> 02:00:35,450
would close they wouldn't be

2970
02:00:35,450 --> 02:00:37,518
able to run so why is it that

2971
02:00:37,518 --> 02:00:40,154
we don't value them. Like we

2972
02:00:40,154 --> 02:00:41,220
value other people. And one of

2973
02:00:41,220 --> 02:00:42,924
the other things I think is

2974
02:00:42,924 --> 02:00:45,324
interesting and very concerning

2975
02:00:45,457 --> 02:00:47,270
to me. Is that we have our

2976
02:00:47,270 --> 02:00:48,966
future leaders getting an

2977
02:00:48,966 --> 02:00:50,864
education there and what are we

2978
02:00:50,864 --> 02:00:52,869
teaching them about other

2979
02:00:52,869 --> 02:00:55,502
people if we don't value all

2980
02:00:55,502 --> 02:00:57,570
work. This is about valuing all

2981
02:00:57,570 --> 02:01:00,600
work and making sure that

2982
02:01:00,600 --> 02:01:01,674
workers are paid a living wage.

2983
02:01:01,674 --> 02:01:03,209
First one to repeat ome of

2984
02:01:03,209 --> 02:01:04,478
things that I said. In

2985
02:01:04,478 --> 02:01:06,408
committee because I think it's

2986
02:01:06,408 --> 02:01:08,716
important. But I also want to

2987
02:01:08,716 --> 02:01:12,316
address a couple things I heard

2988
02:01:12,860 --> 02:01:13,780
I think I heard someone say

2989
02:01:13,780 --> 02:01:13,350
that. You know we're just we're

2990
02:01:13,350 --> 02:01:15,519
doing this and it should be

2991
02:01:15,519 --> 02:01:16,419
collectively bargained. But

2992
02:01:16,419 --> 02:01:17,487
it's my understanding and

2993
02:01:17,487 --> 02:01:19,589
someone collect correct me if

2994
02:01:19,589 --> 02:01:21,737
I'm wrong. They've been

2995
02:01:21,737 --> 02:01:23,593
negotiating for twelve years so

2996
02:01:23,593 --> 02:01:25,228
that's over a decade that this

2997
02:01:25,228 --> 02:01:26,896
issue has been trying to come

2998
02:01:26,896 --> 02:01:28,664
to resolution. I think that's

2999
02:01:28,664 --> 02:01:29,465
more than enough time and I

3000
02:01:29,465 --> 02:01:31,331
think it's high time that we do

3001
02:01:31,331 --> 02:01:33,602
something. We talk about

3002
02:01:33,602 --> 02:01:34,604
opportunities for students but

3003
02:01:34,604 --> 02:01:36,769
what about talking about

3004
02:01:36,769 --> 02:01:39,169
opportunities for the workers

3005
02:01:40,912 --> 02:01:41,130
at uc let's talk about doing

3006
02:01:41,130 --> 02:01:43,780
something for them the people

3007
02:01:43,780 --> 02:01:44,450
that make sure. Our young minds

3008
02:01:44,450 --> 02:01:46,313
are able to come to these

3009
02:01:46,313 --> 02:01:48,585
universities and be our future

3010
02:01:48,585 --> 02:01:51,585
leaders. The members it's with

3011
02:01:52,351 --> 02:01:52,952
great pride that I am a co

3012
02:01:52,952 --> 02:01:55,952
author and I respectfully ask

3013
02:01:57,287 --> 02:01:58,157
for your aye vote. Seeing no

3014
02:01:58,157 --> 02:02:00,123
other mike's up I believe

3015
02:02:00,123 --> 02:02:01,827
discussion has seized. Senator

3016
02:02:01,827 --> 02:02:02,761
what would you like to close I

3017
02:02:02,761 --> 02:02:04,663
would thank you Mister

3018
02:02:04,663 --> 02:02:05,697
President and I want to thank

3019
02:02:05,697 --> 02:02:07,963
all my colleagues for the

3020
02:02:07,963 --> 02:02:08,867
thoughtful and civil debate

3021
02:02:08,867 --> 02:02:11,102
this morning on on this

3022
02:02:11,102 --> 02:02:13,374
particular issue. The one thing

3023
02:02:13,374 --> 02:02:14,803
I'm very excited about no one

3024
02:02:14,803 --> 02:02:16,874
argued that this is not about

3025
02:02:16,874 --> 02:02:17,509
equity when we discuss

3026
02:02:17,509 --> 02:02:19,509
%-peducation

3027
02:02:19,977 --> 02:02:20,578
policy we always talk

3028
02:02:20,578 --> 02:02:23,147
about hope and opportunity for

3029
02:02:23,147 --> 02:02:24,417
our students. Ladies and

3030
02:02:24,417 --> 02:02:26,717
gentlemen we should have hope

3031
02:02:26,717 --> 02:02:28,555
and opportunity for all people.

3032
02:02:28,555 --> 02:02:30,621
And in this measure gets us one

3033
02:02:30,621 --> 02:02:33,621
step closer to having an

3034
02:02:34,240 --> 02:02:35,359
equitable society I like to

3035
02:02:35,359 --> 02:02:36,994
address. Some of the comments

3036
02:02:36,994 --> 02:02:39,930
that were made. This is not

3037
02:02:39,930 --> 02:02:42,980
about equity equity it must be

3038
02:02:42,980 --> 02:02:44,498
about implementation and cost.

3039
02:02:44,667 --> 02:02:47,670
Terms of implementation. If

3040
02:02:47,103 --> 02:02:48,537
there is an emergency the

3041
02:02:48,537 --> 02:02:50,537
emergency services act

3042
02:02:51,544 --> 02:02:53,743
supersedes this any any other

3043
02:02:53,743 --> 02:02:56,912
measure in the governor has the

3044
02:02:56,912 --> 02:03:00,790
right to call that. In in terms

3045
02:03:00,790 --> 02:03:03,679
of flexibility up turned to pay

3046
02:03:04,221 --> 02:03:04,439
again page five line thirty

3047
02:03:04,439 --> 02:03:05,420
nine see nothing in this

3048
02:03:05,420 --> 02:03:06,554
section shall preclude the

3049
02:03:06,554 --> 02:03:08,720
regents of the university

3050
02:03:08,720 --> 02:03:11,192
california or any campus or

3051
02:03:11,192 --> 02:03:12,460
other entity of the university

3052
02:03:12,460 --> 02:03:14,127
california from using per diem

3053
02:03:14,127 --> 02:03:15,629
university employees to

3054
02:03:15,629 --> 02:03:17,263
complement career in limited

3055
02:03:17,263 --> 02:03:18,800
position university employees.

3056
02:03:18,800 --> 02:03:21,100
What is necessary to maintain

3057
02:03:21,100 --> 02:03:23,302
staffing levels for temporary

3058
02:03:23,302 --> 02:03:25,904
and emergency periods. So that

3059
02:03:25,904 --> 02:03:27,271
does create flexibility and it

3060
02:03:27,271 --> 02:03:30,239
does address the mayor the

3061
02:03:30,239 --> 02:03:32,639
mariners situation with with

3062
02:03:33,578 --> 02:03:36,578
scraps. Ten and obviously the

3063
02:03:38,651 --> 02:03:40,187
medical staff. In terms of

3064
02:03:40,187 --> 02:03:42,187
fiscal accountability this

3065
02:03:43,318 --> 02:03:45,230
measure is prudent. I have a

3066
02:03:45,230 --> 02:03:46,692
whole list here of abuses at

3067
02:03:46,692 --> 02:03:48,191
the uc system has done in the

3068
02:03:48,191 --> 02:03:49,226
past I'm not going to go

3069
02:03:49,226 --> 02:03:52,429
through them yet since it's the

3070
02:03:52,429 --> 02:03:52,965
last day session but they

3071
02:03:52,965 --> 02:03:55,365
currently claim that these

3072
02:03:56,660 --> 02:03:57,197
contracts. Us five hundred

3073
02:03:57,197 --> 02:03:59,969
twenty three million dollars in

3074
02:03:59,969 --> 02:04:01,671
this abc a fourteen would later

3075
02:04:01,671 --> 02:04:04,308
on another a hundred seventy

3076
02:04:04,308 --> 02:04:06,407
two million dollars. Here's a

3077
02:04:06,407 --> 02:04:08,342
the fax our own senate

3078
02:04:08,342 --> 02:04:10,342
appropriations committee staff

3079
02:04:11,110 --> 02:04:12,880
and mike gymnast who was the

3080
02:04:12,880 --> 02:04:14,549
director of fiscal director for

3081
02:04:14,549 --> 02:04:15,985
governor schwarzenegger have

3082
02:04:15,985 --> 02:04:17,854
looked it looked at the

3083
02:04:17,854 --> 02:04:20,220
information and the total cost

3084
02:04:20,220 --> 02:04:20,751
of these labor contracts are

3085
02:04:20,751 --> 02:04:23,151
three hundred and thirteen

3086
02:04:23,593 --> 02:04:24,955
million dollars. We'll take you

3087
02:04:24,955 --> 02:04:27,590
see at their word that it's

3088
02:04:27,590 --> 02:04:27,791
gonna cost another a hundred

3089
02:04:27,791 --> 02:04:30,731
seventy two million so we add

3090
02:04:30,731 --> 02:04:32,640
that in. That's four hundred

3091
02:04:32,640 --> 02:04:32,629
eighty five million dollars

3092
02:04:32,629 --> 02:04:35,290
that's thirty eight million

3093
02:04:35,367 --> 02:04:37,269
dollars less. They claim

3094
02:04:37,269 --> 02:04:39,940
they're paying today so there's

3095
02:04:39,940 --> 02:04:41,506
not going to be any tuition.

3096
02:04:41,506 --> 02:04:44,506
Increases on this measure this

3097
02:04:44,873 --> 02:04:47,815
measure. At worst is face

3098
02:04:47,815 --> 02:04:50,215
fiscally even maybe potentially

3099
02:04:51,315 --> 02:04:53,750
even save money for the system.

3100
02:04:53,750 --> 02:04:56,583
And you know that the pro tem

3101
02:04:56,583 --> 02:04:58,384
in the senator from sensei talk

3102
02:04:58,384 --> 02:05:00,524
about how this is been an

3103
02:05:00,524 --> 02:05:03,524
ongoing battle for decades. For

3104
02:05:04,920 --> 02:05:07,920
decades. For me I love

3105
02:05:07,429 --> 02:05:07,999
basketball and I'm also old so

3106
02:05:07,999 --> 02:05:10,399
I remember basketball before

3107
02:05:10,698 --> 02:05:12,400
there was a shot clock. And I

3108
02:05:12,400 --> 02:05:14,699
personally am ucla basketball

3109
02:05:14,699 --> 02:05:16,671
fan but those who were older

3110
02:05:16,671 --> 02:05:18,739
remember dean smith and in

3111
02:05:18,739 --> 02:05:20,808
north carolina which is also

3112
02:05:20,808 --> 02:05:22,876
historical power. And will and

3113
02:05:22,876 --> 02:05:24,778
dean smith created the four

3114
02:05:24,778 --> 02:05:26,413
corners offense and what that

3115
02:05:26,413 --> 02:05:27,776
was because it was no shot

3116
02:05:27,776 --> 02:05:29,748
clock the minute he got the

3117
02:05:29,748 --> 02:05:31,249
lead. He put his people in the

3118
02:05:31,249 --> 02:05:32,651
corner and they would just

3119
02:05:32,651 --> 02:05:34,520
throw the ball around to keep

3120
02:05:34,520 --> 02:05:36,540
it from the opponents. Ladies

3121
02:05:36,540 --> 02:05:38,454
and gentlementhat's what the

3122
02:05:38,789 --> 02:05:40,190
uc regents have been doing for

3123
02:05:40,190 --> 02:05:42,457
four decades even playing four

3124
02:05:42,457 --> 02:05:44,764
corners with our workers and

3125
02:05:44,764 --> 02:05:46,730
it's wrong it's got to stop we

3126
02:05:46,730 --> 02:05:48,732
need to pass this measure today

3127
02:05:48,732 --> 02:05:49,869
and put them on the shot clock.

3128
02:05:49,869 --> 02:05:51,538
If they want to fix in for this

3129
02:05:51,538 --> 02:05:53,870
goes to voters they can do that

3130
02:05:53,870 --> 02:05:55,675
but we have to force their hand

3131
02:05:55,675 --> 02:05:57,640
there is no leadership. I have

3132
02:05:57,640 --> 02:05:59,642
a minutes about respect I still

3133
02:05:59,642 --> 02:06:01,212
come speaker prez and if

3134
02:06:01,212 --> 02:06:04,416
anybody can get it done he can

3135
02:06:04,416 --> 02:06:05,490
get it done but we're going to

3136
02:06:05,490 --> 02:06:08,448
give them externe courage me to

3137
02:06:08,448 --> 02:06:09,885
get it done. So with that this

3138
02:06:09,885 --> 02:06:11,500
is equitable. It's klay prudent

3139
02:06:11,500 --> 02:06:11,688
infirm my friends and my caucus

3140
02:06:11,688 --> 02:06:12,924
will talk about the best

3141
02:06:12,924 --> 02:06:15,230
government. Is a government

3142
02:06:15,230 --> 02:06:15,858
closest to the people. Nothing

3143
02:06:15,858 --> 02:06:18,224
is closer than letting the

3144
02:06:18,224 --> 02:06:20,494
voters make this decision. So

3145
02:06:20,494 --> 02:06:21,162
with that I respectfully ask

3146
02:06:21,162 --> 02:06:24,698
for an aye vote on a ca

3147
02:06:24,698 --> 02:06:27,698
fourteen. Thank you all debate

3148
02:06:27,801 --> 02:06:28,366
and discussion having seized

3149
02:06:28,366 --> 02:06:29,303
Mister Secretary please call

3150
02:06:29,303 --> 02:06:32,903
the roll on the side. Allen

3151
02:06:34,641 --> 02:06:37,641
archuleta I atkins aye bates

3152
02:06:38,440 --> 02:06:41,644
nobel I porges no bradford I

3153
02:06:42,682 --> 02:06:46,282
caballero. I chiang by daily no

3154
02:06:50,154 --> 02:06:53,754
dodd. No durazo hi galgiani. I

3155
02:06:54,522 --> 02:06:58,122
glazer no gonzalez hi growth no

3156
02:06:59,396 --> 02:07:02,996
hertzberg no hill aye hueso aye

3157
02:07:06,399 --> 02:07:09,338
auto. Hi jackson. Jones. No

3158
02:07:09,338 --> 02:07:12,338
leyva aye mcguire by mitchell

3159
02:07:15,311 --> 02:07:18,747
hi monning. More lock no morale

3160
02:07:18,747 --> 02:07:21,747
no nielsen no pan aye

3161
02:07:24,830 --> 02:07:26,483
portantino aye roth. Rubio.

3162
02:07:28,556 --> 02:07:31,556
Skinner aye stern aye stone.

3163
02:07:32,491 --> 02:07:35,491
November iowa caskey by wiener

3164
02:07:36,528 --> 02:07:37,664
aye wilk hi. Secretary please

3165
02:07:37,664 --> 02:07:40,664
call the absent members allen.

3166
02:07:48,373 --> 02:07:50,773
Jackson monning. Roth rubio.

3167
02:07:52,880 --> 02:07:54,460
Sir will move the call. Members

3168
02:07:54,460 --> 02:07:57,181
are we're going to take a

3169
02:07:57,181 --> 02:07:59,182
recess and we will reconvene at

3170
02:07:59,182 --> 02:08:00,750
three pm sharp at three pm

3171
02:08:00,750 --> 02:08:04,350
sharp the senate will be in

3172
02:08:07,419 --> 02:08:11,190
recess for the next two hours.

3173
02:08:15,433 --> 02:08:18,433
Center winner where are. The

3174
02:08:20,768 --> 02:08:21,900
first recognize senator wiener.

3175
02:08:21,900 --> 02:08:24,638
I thank you reserve reservoir

3176
02:08:24,638 --> 02:08:27,638
per prisoner winner the housing

3177
02:08:28,573 --> 02:08:29,310
committee will meet in room

3178
02:08:29,310 --> 02:08:30,809
thirty one ninety one sometime

3179
02:08:30,809 --> 02:08:32,313
between now and when we read to

3180
02:08:32,313 --> 02:08:34,680
me and if members could just be

3181
02:08:34,680 --> 02:08:37,120
available will let you now the

3182
02:08:37,120 --> 02:08:39,583
exact time with some notice out

3183
02:08:39,583 --> 02:08:43,183
of time. Thank you thank you.

3184
02:08:43,852 --> 02:08:46,852
Senator growth. Our members we

3185
02:09:00,403 --> 02:09:04,603
will be in recess to three john

3186
02:38:23,650 --> 02:38:24,182
.

3187
02:38:24,182 --> 02:38:25,585
Thirty three. Looking for

3188
02:38:25,585 --> 02:38:29,185
author I mean a manager floor

3189
02:38:30,687 --> 02:38:33,687
manager. Soon or is senator

3190
02:38:51,207 --> 02:38:54,207
nelson are will work. Bob

3191
02:41:48,730 --> 02:41:50,730
.

3192
02:41:51,301 --> 02:41:51,933
Center nielsen we out file item

3193
02:41:51,933 --> 02:41:54,933
thirty three if you're prepared

3194
02:41:59,442 --> 02:42:00,100
to take that up. He's ready

3195
02:42:00,100 --> 02:42:02,410
mmhm secretary government in

3196
02:42:04,211 --> 02:42:06,185
there please hurry. That Mister

3197
02:42:06,185 --> 02:42:07,784
President made late number sent

3198
02:42:07,784 --> 02:42:08,491
to my apologies if I've held up

3199
02:42:08,491 --> 02:42:11,491
this we're we're gonna Miss

3200
02:42:13,253 --> 02:42:15,653
Miss lottie today senator.

3201
02:42:16,160 --> 02:42:17,124
relative secretary of the dial.

3202
02:42:17,124 --> 02:42:18,193
Assembly bill sixty eight by

3203
02:42:18,193 --> 02:42:20,600
assembly member ting an act

3204
02:42:20,600 --> 02:42:22,763
relating to land use internal

3205
02:42:22,763 --> 02:42:25,267
since los yet to offer hold up

3206
02:42:25,267 --> 02:42:28,867
folks we're going to. Get going.

3207
02:42:29,602 --> 02:42:33,802
This is a bill has. That helps

3208
02:42:34,407 --> 02:42:37,343
what was it called the-it is a

3209
02:42:37,343 --> 02:42:40,943
the eighty use. A judge dais

3210
02:42:44,616 --> 02:42:48,153
into. Helpful in areas where we

3211
02:42:48,153 --> 02:42:51,153
have hi congestion. It's kind

3212
02:42:53,190 --> 02:42:54,825
of an intensive way of housing.

3213
02:42:54,825 --> 02:42:59,250
And it's been a big asset. In

3214
02:42:59,663 --> 02:43:02,663
the future. What's happened now.

3215
02:43:07,690 --> 02:43:07,600
The. Building of homes and

3216
02:43:07,600 --> 02:43:09,600
communities doesn't always

3217
02:43:11,436 --> 02:43:14,436
align. With the needs that

3218
02:43:15,609 --> 02:43:16,210
happens for many reasons. In

3219
02:43:16,210 --> 02:43:19,810
the war debts housing often is

3220
02:43:24,484 --> 02:43:27,484
not. The preferred housing. And

3221
02:43:27,755 --> 02:43:29,458
there are also barriers. To the

3222
02:43:29,458 --> 02:43:31,858
development of these housing

3223
02:43:36,229 --> 02:43:38,362
units. So the goal here. Is to

3224
02:43:38,362 --> 02:43:40,362
improve affordability. And

3225
02:43:43,867 --> 02:43:46,367
supply. In part by getting

3226
02:43:46,367 --> 02:43:49,967
units built more quickly. In a

3227
02:43:53,420 --> 02:43:56,420
lower cost. Many local agencies.

3228
02:43:57,780 --> 02:43:57,611
It appears on evenly. Those

3229
02:43:57,611 --> 02:44:00,110
barriers that prevent this

3230
02:44:01,112 --> 02:44:03,112
development. That's why

3231
02:44:03,386 --> 02:44:05,786
assembly member tang has

3232
02:44:07,751 --> 02:44:10,151
introduced this legislation. It

3233
02:44:10,892 --> 02:44:13,190
helps rapidly or more rapidly

3234
02:44:13,190 --> 02:44:15,590
increase density housing. In

3235
02:44:18,280 --> 02:44:21,280
urban areas. It allows the

3236
02:44:22,866 --> 02:44:24,866
construction of multiple.

3237
02:44:26,903 --> 02:44:29,303
Affordability housing unit. In

3238
02:44:29,507 --> 02:44:33,107
the eighty you area on single

3239
02:44:34,440 --> 02:44:34,542
family lots. Californians

3240
02:44:34,542 --> 02:44:36,942
therefore can build more

3241
02:44:39,820 --> 02:44:41,918
housing. It has had thus far.

3242
02:44:41,918 --> 02:44:43,918
Bipartisan support. There's

3243
02:44:45,618 --> 02:44:48,618
merit even. Although this bill

3244
02:44:48,893 --> 02:44:49,525
would not really apply to. The

3245
02:44:49,525 --> 02:44:52,525
little community of paradise it

3246
02:44:52,759 --> 02:44:54,327
was destroyed. But even before

3247
02:44:54,327 --> 02:44:57,927
the fire paradise was trying to

3248
02:44:58,831 --> 02:45:02,100
figure out how. To have more

3249
02:45:02,100 --> 02:45:03,838
multi family residences. In a

3250
02:45:03,838 --> 02:45:06,906
more confined area even in that

3251
02:45:06,906 --> 02:45:07,440
little small community. The

3252
02:45:07,440 --> 02:45:09,840
only twenty seven thousand

3253
02:45:11,844 --> 02:45:15,444
people. This bill will help in

3254
02:45:15,714 --> 02:45:19,914
that regard. I would ask an aye

3255
02:45:21,455 --> 02:45:23,855
vote. As another. Development

3256
02:45:25,523 --> 02:45:27,124
in the great continuum of doing

3257
02:45:27,124 --> 02:45:29,524
something about housing in

3258
02:45:29,928 --> 02:45:31,493
california that being accessory

3259
02:45:31,493 --> 02:45:33,893
units. There are more

3260
02:45:34,565 --> 02:45:36,565
affordable. Economic and

3261
02:45:40,304 --> 02:45:41,872
efficient. Thank senator center

3262
02:45:41,872 --> 02:45:43,943
y. Costly thank you Mister

3263
02:45:43,943 --> 02:45:47,110
President I to rise in support

3264
02:45:47,110 --> 02:45:49,900
of this bill the as the floor

3265
02:45:49,900 --> 02:45:51,409
manager has indicated there's

3266
02:45:51,781 --> 02:45:52,515
been and even barriers through

3267
02:45:52,515 --> 02:45:54,414
different jurisdictions

3268
02:45:54,414 --> 02:45:55,951
throughout the state on the

3269
02:45:55,951 --> 02:45:57,951
implementation of excess

3270
02:45:58,652 --> 02:46:00,389
redrawing unit work this that

3271
02:46:00,389 --> 02:46:02,525
this continue the important

3272
02:46:02,525 --> 02:46:04,425
work that we as a legislature

3273
02:46:04,425 --> 02:46:05,827
haves have done over the last

3274
02:46:05,827 --> 02:46:08,827
few years to develop accessory

3275
02:46:09,970 --> 02:46:10,186
dwelling units throughout the

3276
02:46:10,186 --> 02:46:11,730
state. Ab sixty eight

3277
02:46:11,730 --> 02:46:13,403
harmonizes income and completes

3278
02:46:13,403 --> 02:46:16,203
a suite of eighty you bills

3279
02:46:16,203 --> 02:46:17,605
including my bill sb thirteen

3280
02:46:17,605 --> 02:46:19,740
by removing these remaining

3281
02:46:19,740 --> 02:46:21,408
barriers to eighty you

3282
02:46:21,408 --> 02:46:24,800
construction in this bill we

3283
02:46:24,800 --> 02:46:26,210
include setbacks minimum lot

3284
02:46:26,210 --> 02:46:27,611
size an error and floor area

3285
02:46:27,611 --> 02:46:29,847
ratio requirements that have

3286
02:46:29,847 --> 02:46:31,884
been a barrier I will point out

3287
02:46:31,884 --> 02:46:34,251
my colleague from berkeley has

3288
02:46:34,251 --> 02:46:37,251
champion these ideas in an

3289
02:46:37,487 --> 02:46:39,887
alternative. Legislation I will

3290
02:46:41,161 --> 02:46:41,724
be voting. On a on this

3291
02:46:41,724 --> 02:46:44,124
important housing matter and

3292
02:46:45,320 --> 02:46:46,665
irish and I've of. Thank you

3293
02:46:46,665 --> 02:46:47,903
senator any additional

3294
02:46:47,903 --> 02:46:50,103
discussion debate on this item.

3295
02:46:50,103 --> 02:46:50,669
Internal so until it closed.

3296
02:46:50,669 --> 02:46:51,503
Thank you Mister President.

3297
02:46:51,503 --> 02:46:54,700
Laying down the senate this is

3298
02:46:54,700 --> 02:46:54,671
an example there are three

3299
02:46:54,671 --> 02:46:56,741
bills I think moving along and

3300
02:46:56,741 --> 02:46:58,941
it shows that. There can be

3301
02:46:58,941 --> 02:47:01,341
bipartisan cooperation on these

3302
02:47:02,878 --> 02:47:04,148
issues of great moment. These

3303
02:47:04,148 --> 02:47:05,781
three bills don't part the red

3304
02:47:05,781 --> 02:47:08,617
sea but they are all part and

3305
02:47:08,617 --> 02:47:09,985
parcel of that continuum of

3306
02:47:09,985 --> 02:47:10,452
success to provide more

3307
02:47:10,452 --> 02:47:12,452
affordable housing in

3308
02:47:14,823 --> 02:47:16,958
california. It also shows. A

3309
02:47:16,958 --> 02:47:18,993
linkage between urban and rural

3310
02:47:18,993 --> 02:47:21,731
words such concepts at least

3311
02:47:21,731 --> 02:47:25,876
can help the role as well as

3312
02:47:25,876 --> 02:47:27,468
urban areas I ask an aye vote.

3313
02:47:27,468 --> 02:47:29,437
Thank you. As you can see we're

3314
02:47:29,437 --> 02:47:30,704
short of several members on the

3315
02:47:30,704 --> 02:47:32,740
floor so we're gonna go to the

3316
02:47:32,740 --> 02:47:33,342
roll call one time and then

3317
02:47:33,342 --> 02:47:34,500
we'll place to mount on call.

3318
02:47:34,500 --> 02:47:37,605
The sector please call the roll.

3319
02:47:39,913 --> 02:47:42,913
Allen. Archuleta I atkins bates

3320
02:47:45,852 --> 02:47:48,852
bell hi porges effort I

3321
02:47:49,152 --> 02:47:52,152
caballero hi chiang. Delhi I

3322
02:47:53,695 --> 02:47:56,695
dodd. Also I galgiani aye

3323
02:48:01,650 --> 02:48:03,400
glazer. No gonzalez by growth.

3324
02:48:03,400 --> 02:48:07,000
Hertzberg aye hill aye hueso by

3325
02:48:11,207 --> 02:48:14,100
tado. Jackson. Jones no leyva.

3326
02:48:14,100 --> 02:48:17,100
Mcguire hi mitchell hi monning

3327
02:48:19,480 --> 02:48:23,800
by more lock rail. Nielsen aye

3328
02:48:23,950 --> 02:48:26,950
pan aye portantino. Roth by

3329
02:48:28,220 --> 02:48:31,622
rubio hi skinner aye stern. No

3330
02:48:35,260 --> 02:48:38,626
stone. No number ira caskey by

3331
02:48:39,166 --> 02:48:42,766
winner by wilk no. Sure no

3332
02:48:43,467 --> 02:48:46,906
somos a call. Next members were

3333
02:48:46,906 --> 02:48:49,750
moving on to file item thirty

3334
02:48:49,750 --> 02:48:51,475
four. Senator gonzalez he

3335
02:48:52,979 --> 02:48:55,379
prepared. This sector please

3336
02:48:57,122 --> 02:48:57,340
read assembly bill eleven

3337
02:48:57,340 --> 02:48:57,488
sixteen by assembly member

3338
02:48:57,488 --> 02:48:59,384
grayson an act relating to

3339
02:48:59,384 --> 02:49:00,786
firefighters internals me

3340
02:49:00,786 --> 02:49:03,786
center gonzalez I'm sorry thank

3341
02:49:03,822 --> 02:49:05,157
you. Mister President senators

3342
02:49:05,157 --> 02:49:06,858
I rise today to present

3343
02:49:06,858 --> 02:49:07,929
assembly bill eleven sixteen

3344
02:49:07,929 --> 02:49:09,327
which will establish statewide

3345
02:49:09,327 --> 02:49:11,329
standards for firefighter peer

3346
02:49:11,329 --> 02:49:12,628
support programs and provide

3347
02:49:12,628 --> 02:49:14,429
for confidential communication

3348
02:49:14,429 --> 02:49:15,899
between train peer support team

3349
02:49:15,899 --> 02:49:18,467
members and their fellow peace

3350
02:49:18,467 --> 02:49:19,707
officers is a companion measure

3351
02:49:19,707 --> 02:49:21,309
to the peace officer pete

3352
02:49:21,309 --> 02:49:22,474
support bill which passed off

3353
02:49:22,474 --> 02:49:24,105
this floor unanimously

3354
02:49:24,105 --> 02:49:25,878
yesterday emergency service

3355
02:49:25,878 --> 02:49:27,244
personnel working unpredictable

3356
02:49:27,244 --> 02:49:28,579
high stress environment second

3357
02:49:28,579 --> 02:49:30,143
taken overwhelming mental

3358
02:49:30,143 --> 02:49:31,281
emotional and physical toll a

3359
02:49:31,281 --> 02:49:32,810
survey co authored by

3360
02:49:32,810 --> 02:49:33,850
california professional

3361
02:49:33,850 --> 02:49:35,351
firefighters an nbc bay area

3362
02:49:35,351 --> 02:49:36,920
found that nearly one in six

3363
02:49:36,920 --> 02:49:38,421
firefighters. Has considered

3364
02:49:38,421 --> 02:49:39,721
suicide and first responders

3365
02:49:39,721 --> 02:49:42,721
are often reluctant to utilize

3366
02:49:43,930 --> 02:49:43,958
existing programs ab one one

3367
02:49:43,958 --> 02:49:45,260
six I will increase

3368
02:49:45,260 --> 02:49:47,250
availability and use of peer

3369
02:49:47,250 --> 02:49:48,128
support in crisis referral

3370
02:49:48,128 --> 02:49:49,998
services by allowing for

3371
02:49:49,998 --> 02:49:50,862
confidential communication

3372
02:49:50,862 --> 02:49:53,262
between train fare support

3373
02:49:54,665 --> 02:49:55,235
personnel and their fellow

3374
02:49:55,235 --> 02:49:57,235
firefighters. I respectfully

3375
02:49:59,103 --> 02:49:59,741
ask your aye vote. Any

3376
02:49:59,741 --> 02:50:02,141
additional discussion or debate

3377
02:50:02,809 --> 02:50:03,410
on this item. Cena Mister

3378
02:50:03,410 --> 02:50:06,410
Secretary please call the roll

3379
02:50:08,815 --> 02:50:11,215
allen. Archuleta I atkins.

3380
02:50:12,751 --> 02:50:16,351
Bates hi bill by burgess by

3381
02:50:17,900 --> 02:50:19,523
bradford aye aye caballero aye

3382
02:50:19,523 --> 02:50:22,523
chiang aye daly aye dodd.

3383
02:50:23,257 --> 02:50:26,257
Dorado aye galgiani aye glazer

3384
02:50:27,297 --> 02:50:30,297
aye gonzalez I grow hertzberg

3385
02:50:31,498 --> 02:50:35,304
aye hill aye hueso aye or tado

3386
02:50:35,304 --> 02:50:38,738
by jackson I jones. By leyva

3387
02:50:38,738 --> 02:50:41,377
aye mcguire aye mitchell aye

3388
02:50:41,377 --> 02:50:43,878
monning I'm more lock I'm real

3389
02:50:43,878 --> 02:50:46,878
aye nielsen aye pan aye

3390
02:50:48,748 --> 02:50:51,748
portantino. Roth aye rubio. I

3391
02:50:52,718 --> 02:50:56,220
skinner aye stern aye stone aye

3392
02:50:56,220 --> 02:50:59,622
amberg our cassie I wiener aye

3393
02:51:05,431 --> 02:51:08,431
wilk. By can I. Secretary

3394
02:51:16,206 --> 02:51:18,606
called absent members. Allen

3395
02:51:23,812 --> 02:51:26,812
atkins dot growth portantino I.

3396
02:51:26,815 --> 02:51:30,316
Consider moves the item next up

3397
02:51:30,316 --> 02:51:33,221
is file item thirty five ninety

3398
02:51:33,221 --> 02:51:35,693
senator dodd at his best.

3399
02:51:35,693 --> 02:51:39,293
Moving on to file item forty

3400
02:51:46,965 --> 02:51:48,700
once and dodd again. Let's see.

3401
02:51:48,700 --> 02:51:51,690
file I'm fifty twos senator

3402
02:51:51,690 --> 02:51:54,690
hill are you prepared. Which

3403
02:51:55,420 --> 02:51:59,242
one. I now forty one or forty

3404
02:51:59,511 --> 02:52:02,511
one. Yeah three are you

3405
02:52:03,214 --> 02:52:06,814
prepared for this item. Yeah I

3406
02:52:10,321 --> 02:52:13,321
would like you. What we're

3407
02:52:14,555 --> 02:52:18,155
doing forty one center help. No

3408
02:52:26,834 --> 02:52:31,340
dot to dot forty one. We don't

3409
02:52:31,774 --> 02:52:35,374
have used forty one on here.

3410
02:52:43,517 --> 02:52:44,118
Okay. For moving a file item

3411
02:52:44,118 --> 02:52:44,719
forty threes senator hertzberg

3412
02:52:44,719 --> 02:52:48,210
are you prepared for the sight

3413
02:52:48,210 --> 02:52:50,421
of. Mister Secretary please

3414
02:52:50,790 --> 02:52:51,325
read. Assembly bill seven

3415
02:52:51,325 --> 02:52:51,857
thirty by assembly member

3416
02:52:51,857 --> 02:52:54,857
berman and act really into

3417
02:52:56,729 --> 02:52:57,329
elections. Hertzberg when

3418
02:52:57,329 --> 02:53:00,299
you're ready thank you Mister

3419
02:53:00,299 --> 02:53:01,934
President. This measure by

3420
02:53:01,934 --> 02:53:04,300
assembly member berman seeks to

3421
02:53:04,300 --> 02:53:06,536
safeguard the integrity of our

3422
02:53:06,536 --> 02:53:08,535
elections a task that is not

3423
02:53:08,535 --> 02:53:09,838
only become more challenging

3424
02:53:09,838 --> 02:53:12,175
with the incredible advancement

3425
02:53:12,175 --> 02:53:14,310
in technology one of the most

3426
02:53:14,310 --> 02:53:15,444
troubling recentdevelopments

3427
02:53:15,444 --> 02:53:17,844
is the invention and

3428
02:53:19,115 --> 02:53:20,850
proliferation. Of deep fakes

3429
02:53:20,850 --> 02:53:23,250
which are extremely convincing

3430
02:53:23,852 --> 02:53:25,388
fabricated photos videos audio

3431
02:53:25,388 --> 02:53:27,589
recordings of someone appearing

3432
02:53:27,589 --> 02:53:29,324
to say or do something that

3433
02:53:29,324 --> 02:53:31,993
they did not. The ability to

3434
02:53:31,993 --> 02:53:34,162
tribute a speech and conduct to

3435
02:53:34,162 --> 02:53:36,633
a candidate is false with his

3436
02:53:36,633 --> 02:53:38,802
never even happened makes deep

3437
02:53:38,802 --> 02:53:41,802
takes a powerful and dangerous

3438
02:53:42,945 --> 02:53:43,304
new tool in the arsenal of

3439
02:53:43,304 --> 02:53:46,874
those who want to wage mission

3440
02:53:46,874 --> 02:53:48,876
formation campaigns. In January

3441
02:53:48,876 --> 02:53:50,744
our united states director of

3442
02:53:50,744 --> 02:53:52,777
national intelligence dan coats

3443
02:53:52,777 --> 02:53:54,414
warned the deep bakes will

3444
02:53:54,414 --> 02:53:56,282
probably be among the tactics

3445
02:53:56,282 --> 02:53:58,785
used to disrupt the twenty

3446
02:53:58,785 --> 02:53:59,889
twenty elections and with those

3447
02:53:59,889 --> 02:54:02,289
twenty twenty elections around

3448
02:54:02,589 --> 02:54:05,761
the corner. We must do more to

3449
02:54:05,761 --> 02:54:06,291
curb the proliferation of deep

3450
02:54:06,291 --> 02:54:08,691
fakes or other manipulated

3451
02:54:09,437 --> 02:54:09,996
media. The language of the bill

3452
02:54:09,996 --> 02:54:12,631
on the read it specifically

3453
02:54:12,631 --> 02:54:15,701
says. A deep take means that

3454
02:54:15,701 --> 02:54:18,700
that a maternal deceptive audio

3455
02:54:18,700 --> 02:54:20,770
or visual media to mean an

3456
02:54:20,770 --> 02:54:21,273
image or recording visual

3457
02:54:21,273 --> 02:54:23,673
recording that has been

3458
02:54:24,750 --> 02:54:25,110
intentionally manipulated. To

3459
02:54:25,110 --> 02:54:27,145
alter the appearance speech

3460
02:54:27,145 --> 02:54:28,346
your conduct of a candid so as

3461
02:54:28,346 --> 02:54:29,547
to create a significant

3462
02:54:29,547 --> 02:54:31,947
likelihood of causing a

3463
02:54:32,160 --> 02:54:33,151
reasonable person to understand

3464
02:54:33,151 --> 02:54:35,151
of experienced expression

3465
02:54:35,753 --> 02:54:36,954
expressive conduct content of

3466
02:54:36,954 --> 02:54:38,487
the image or recording in a

3467
02:54:38,487 --> 02:54:39,824
manner that is fundamentally

3468
02:54:39,824 --> 02:54:41,250
different. From the

3469
02:54:41,250 --> 02:54:42,893
understanding or experience

3470
02:54:42,893 --> 02:54:43,995
that a person would have had if

3471
02:54:43,995 --> 02:54:46,464
the person we're hearing or

3472
02:54:46,464 --> 02:54:47,364
seeing are the on altered

3473
02:54:47,364 --> 02:54:50,364
original version of the image

3474
02:54:50,400 --> 02:54:52,366
or recording. In this says that

3475
02:54:52,366 --> 02:54:55,366
you've got this this basically

3476
02:54:56,508 --> 02:54:56,727
says for some of the period of

3477
02:54:56,727 --> 02:54:57,473
sixty days of the election.

3478
02:54:57,473 --> 02:54:58,908
That makes it illegal. The last

3479
02:54:58,908 --> 02:54:59,742
thing I want to raise the

3480
02:54:59,742 --> 02:55:01,711
constitutional out alley the

3481
02:55:01,711 --> 02:55:03,346
issue and I want to raise. A

3482
02:55:03,346 --> 02:55:05,276
letter that was written by the

3483
02:55:05,276 --> 02:55:07,879
united states the u. S. C. C.

3484
02:55:07,879 --> 02:55:09,840
Berkeley school of law dean.

3485
02:55:09,840 --> 02:55:11,286
One sherman and ski and what he

3486
02:55:11,286 --> 02:55:12,517
said is with respect to the

3487
02:55:12,517 --> 02:55:14,388
constitutionality because x.

3488
02:55:14,388 --> 02:55:15,791
Important as we-try to deal

3489
02:55:15,791 --> 02:55:17,857
with these balances on the

3490
02:55:17,857 --> 02:55:20,930
floor. Although this bill would

3491
02:55:20,930 --> 02:55:22,963
regulate its its prohibition of

3492
02:55:22,963 --> 02:55:24,233
deep the it regulate speech. Is

3493
02:55:24,233 --> 02:55:25,165
prohibition of deep takes would

3494
02:55:25,165 --> 02:55:27,433
not violate the first

3495
02:55:27,433 --> 02:55:29,670
amendment. Fall speech at times

3496
02:55:29,670 --> 02:55:30,869
is protected but often the

3497
02:55:30,869 --> 02:55:31,805
government is allowed to

3498
02:55:31,805 --> 02:55:33,805
prohibited without running

3499
02:55:33,836 --> 02:55:36,141
afoul of the constitution. For

3500
02:55:36,141 --> 02:55:38,145
example lying in the court room

3501
02:55:38,145 --> 02:55:38,644
under oath perjury is not

3502
02:55:38,644 --> 02:55:39,545
protected by the first

3503
02:55:39,545 --> 02:55:41,945
amendment even though it

3504
02:55:42,479 --> 02:55:43,150
speech. The supreme court has

3505
02:55:43,150 --> 02:55:45,616
been clear. The false and

3506
02:55:45,616 --> 02:55:47,818
deceptive advertising has no

3507
02:55:47,818 --> 02:55:49,818
constitutional protection more

3508
02:55:50,319 --> 02:55:52,521
importantly the board has said

3509
02:55:52,521 --> 02:55:53,889
that speech which is defamatory

3510
02:55:53,889 --> 02:55:56,289
of public officials public

3511
02:55:57,527 --> 02:55:59,610
figures. Has not first abed but

3512
02:55:59,610 --> 02:56:02,610
protection. The speed of the-

3513
02:56:04,466 --> 02:56:08,660
ball sir axe. Out with reckless

3514
02:56:09,680 --> 02:56:09,868
disregard for the truth. Six in

3515
02:56:09,868 --> 02:56:10,975
the portents of preventing

3516
02:56:10,975 --> 02:56:11,574
wrongful harm to reputation and

3517
02:56:11,574 --> 02:56:12,871
protecting the marketplace of

3518
02:56:12,871 --> 02:56:14,308
ideas justifies. That liability

3519
02:56:14,308 --> 02:56:15,476
for fall speech ab seven thirty

3520
02:56:15,476 --> 02:56:17,845
the matter which we have before

3521
02:56:17,845 --> 02:56:19,447
us serve these purposes and use

3522
02:56:19,447 --> 02:56:21,281
this exact uses exact legal

3523
02:56:21,281 --> 02:56:22,449
standard. It prohibits deep

3524
02:56:22,449 --> 02:56:23,985
takes in the political realm

3525
02:56:23,985 --> 02:56:26,286
applies only when the false

3526
02:56:26,286 --> 02:56:27,880
images were knowingly or

3527
02:56:27,880 --> 02:56:28,689
recklessly created or

3528
02:56:28,689 --> 02:56:30,526
disseminate and disseminated.

3529
02:56:30,526 --> 02:56:32,560
The technology for deep takes

3530
02:56:32,560 --> 02:56:35,560
advancing quickly the law must

3531
02:56:35,695 --> 02:56:36,296
be kept up. And deal with the

3532
02:56:36,296 --> 02:56:39,330
serious problem I ask your aye

3533
02:56:39,330 --> 02:56:41,299
vote. Thank you senator verges

3534
02:56:41,299 --> 02:56:44,899
on this item. Thank you Mister

3535
02:56:45,372 --> 02:56:48,171
President. Couple of a quick

3536
02:56:48,171 --> 02:56:49,406
comments and we with your to

3537
02:56:49,406 --> 02:56:51,174
with your up to like to pose a

3538
02:56:51,174 --> 02:56:52,442
question to the author of in

3539
02:56:52,442 --> 02:56:55,211
her toward were to take

3540
02:56:55,211 --> 02:56:57,247
question certainly this is I

3541
02:56:57,247 --> 02:57:00,830
think very telling of our time

3542
02:57:00,830 --> 02:57:02,251
we need to protections of this

3543
02:57:02,251 --> 02:57:04,655
of this sort. And I think all

3544
02:57:04,655 --> 02:57:07,223
of us understand that there are

3545
02:57:07,223 --> 02:57:10,223
instances where people can blur

3546
02:57:10,993 --> 02:57:13,528
the lines between advocacy and

3547
02:57:13,528 --> 02:57:15,230
outright manipulation and the

3548
02:57:15,230 --> 02:57:17,106
first amendment being as it is

3549
02:57:17,106 --> 02:57:19,506
we've grown accustomed to

3550
02:57:19,511 --> 02:57:21,911
virtually everything but those

3551
02:57:22,701 --> 02:57:24,740
days. Are are are certainly I

3552
02:57:24,740 --> 02:57:25,840
think of in the past given the

3553
02:57:25,840 --> 02:57:28,144
technology that exists right

3554
02:57:28,144 --> 02:57:29,509
now in the interference that we

3555
02:57:29,509 --> 02:57:31,881
know that has occurred in the

3556
02:57:31,881 --> 02:57:33,714
last election it will can occur

3557
02:57:33,714 --> 02:57:35,250
in all future elections so I

3558
02:57:35,250 --> 02:57:37,650
think this is absolutely

3559
02:57:39,952 --> 02:57:42,952
essential my question to the

3560
02:57:44,356 --> 02:57:45,326
floor manager on this. Is. The

3561
02:57:45,326 --> 02:57:46,822
bonus will the onus May be on

3562
02:57:46,822 --> 02:57:48,392
the aggrieved party. To

3563
02:57:48,392 --> 02:57:50,792
vindicate themselves or will

3564
02:57:51,659 --> 02:57:54,659
the media outlet. That releases

3565
02:57:55,532 --> 02:57:57,534
it be the be those responsible

3566
02:57:57,534 --> 02:57:58,899
party. For the plight. To the

3567
02:57:58,899 --> 02:58:00,668
chair the plaintiff would have

3568
02:58:00,668 --> 02:58:01,500
to prove because it's something

3569
02:58:01,500 --> 02:58:03,704
like this if there was a

3570
02:58:03,704 --> 02:58:04,972
broadcaster whatever. They

3571
02:58:04,972 --> 02:58:06,507
would have to prove the

3572
02:58:06,507 --> 02:58:07,409
plaintiff in the case which

3573
02:58:07,409 --> 02:58:09,173
would not be the broadcaster

3574
02:58:09,173 --> 02:58:10,881
the news media it. Would have

3575
02:58:10,881 --> 02:58:13,160
to put would have to prove.

3576
02:58:13,160 --> 02:58:14,651
That those who broadcast this

3577
02:58:14,651 --> 02:58:16,250
or printed this did so with

3578
02:58:16,250 --> 02:58:17,615
actual malice so the burden

3579
02:58:17,615 --> 02:58:18,488
would be on the plaintiff in

3580
02:58:18,488 --> 02:58:19,519
the standard is about the

3581
02:58:19,519 --> 02:58:21,870
highest standard you could

3582
02:58:21,870 --> 02:58:22,622
make. Because it is very

3583
02:58:22,622 --> 02:58:24,427
challenging this this whole

3584
02:58:24,427 --> 02:58:26,560
thing we've got what technology

3585
02:58:26,560 --> 02:58:27,858
is just mind numbingly

3586
02:58:27,858 --> 02:58:29,629
difficult. Where we have these

3587
02:58:29,629 --> 02:58:31,831
very important principles of

3588
02:58:31,831 --> 02:58:32,896
free speech but we have them

3589
02:58:32,896 --> 02:58:34,266
being that they're being

3590
02:58:34,266 --> 02:58:35,201
recklessly disregarded

3591
02:58:35,201 --> 02:58:37,201
technology in foreign

3592
02:58:37,636 --> 02:58:38,774
government. So we have to

3593
02:58:38,774 --> 02:58:42,974
figure out. How to do it so

3594
02:58:43,172 --> 02:58:45,770
this appears to be a pretty

3595
02:58:45,770 --> 02:58:45,975
carefully crafted and narrower

3596
02:58:45,975 --> 02:58:48,790
than the offer one. Measure in

3597
02:58:48,790 --> 02:58:51,516
order to be respectful of those

3598
02:58:51,516 --> 02:58:53,516
constitution concern so.

3599
02:58:57,688 --> 02:58:58,356
Example. Imagine a in a steamed

3600
02:58:58,356 --> 02:59:00,961
leader in our community. Bob

3601
02:59:00,961 --> 02:59:02,900
hertzberg. All of a sudden is

3602
02:59:02,900 --> 02:59:05,262
put out there on facebook as

3603
02:59:05,262 --> 02:59:07,397
being pro republican. Ballot if

3604
02:59:07,397 --> 02:59:09,399
the with the facebook on

3605
02:59:09,399 --> 02:59:11,635
posting of that. Which facebook

3606
02:59:11,635 --> 02:59:14,441
be held to account are only it

3607
02:59:14,441 --> 02:59:17,874
would be through a news outlet

3608
02:59:17,874 --> 02:59:21,474
like a media source. No the

3609
02:59:21,611 --> 02:59:23,512
under the under the law the

3610
02:59:23,512 --> 02:59:25,212
under section two thirty of the

3611
02:59:25,212 --> 02:59:27,212
federal communications decency

3612
02:59:27,584 --> 02:59:28,684
act no social platforms our

3613
02:59:28,684 --> 02:59:30,355
platforms are immune from

3614
02:59:30,355 --> 02:59:32,188
liability under those theories

3615
02:59:32,188 --> 02:59:33,188
so that is pr empted by the

3616
02:59:33,188 --> 02:59:35,588
federal government. And they

3617
02:59:37,859 --> 02:59:38,426
are not otherwise liable or

3618
02:59:38,426 --> 02:59:40,327
this is definitely a step in

3619
02:59:40,327 --> 02:59:42,563
the right direction thank you.

3620
02:59:42,563 --> 02:59:43,300
Thank you center stone. Thank

3621
02:59:43,300 --> 02:59:45,232
you Mister President I

3622
02:59:45,232 --> 02:59:46,767
respectfully rise in opposition

3623
02:59:46,767 --> 02:59:49,390
to ab seven thirty and I think

3624
02:59:49,390 --> 02:59:50,504
that the california news

3625
02:59:50,504 --> 02:59:52,504
publishers association

3626
02:59:53,730 --> 02:59:55,473
encapsulates the reason quote

3627
02:59:55,845 --> 02:59:56,910
the inevitable result if a. B.

3628
02:59:56,910 --> 02:59:59,280
Seven thirty were to become law

3629
02:59:59,280 --> 03:00:00,913
would be a profound chilling

3630
03:00:00,913 --> 03:00:03,315
effect on political speech the

3631
03:00:03,315 --> 03:00:06,850
very thing. The first amendment

3632
03:00:06,850 --> 03:00:08,921
was designed to prevent for

3633
03:00:08,921 --> 03:00:09,485
those reasons supporting our

3634
03:00:09,485 --> 03:00:11,927
constitution or to note vote

3635
03:00:11,927 --> 03:00:13,558
and ab seven thirty. Thank you

3636
03:00:13,558 --> 03:00:15,123
any additional discussion or

3637
03:00:15,123 --> 03:00:16,460
debate on this item. Seen in

3638
03:00:16,460 --> 03:00:18,463
hearing nine sooner hertzberg

3639
03:00:18,463 --> 03:00:20,670
which ought to close. The point

3640
03:00:20,670 --> 03:00:21,201
thank you very much the point

3641
03:00:21,201 --> 03:00:24,134
about a chilling effect is

3642
03:00:24,134 --> 03:00:26,269
important. Very important there

3643
03:00:26,269 --> 03:00:28,400
is no question about that and

3644
03:00:28,400 --> 03:00:29,507
this is the real challenge that

3645
03:00:29,507 --> 03:00:31,273
e face with these new kinds of

3646
03:00:31,273 --> 03:00:32,843
technologies we saw the speaker

3647
03:00:32,843 --> 03:00:34,942
of the house in washington.

3648
03:00:34,942 --> 03:00:36,109
Being completely manipulated

3649
03:00:36,109 --> 03:00:38,178
through a video three million

3650
03:00:38,178 --> 03:00:39,913
people watch that and it looked

3651
03:00:39,913 --> 03:00:40,980
like it was accurate and today

3652
03:00:40,980 --> 03:00:43,880
the technology is even more

3653
03:00:43,880 --> 03:00:45,952
sophisticated. And so this

3654
03:00:45,952 --> 03:00:47,823
measure has been narrowed it is

3655
03:00:47,823 --> 03:00:49,155
best as you possibly can I

3656
03:00:49,155 --> 03:00:50,756
think that one sherman in skis

3657
03:00:50,756 --> 03:00:52,270
a point of view the dean of the

3658
03:00:52,270 --> 03:00:54,270
law school constitutional

3659
03:00:55,558 --> 03:00:56,159
scholar. The reason I read it

3660
03:00:56,159 --> 03:00:58,761
said it best because and very

3661
03:00:58,761 --> 03:00:59,731
sensitive to those issues. So

3662
03:00:59,731 --> 03:01:00,399
the argument is in so many of

3663
03:01:00,399 --> 03:01:01,933
these things we talked about on

3664
03:01:01,933 --> 03:01:02,667
this floor the last numbers

3665
03:01:02,667 --> 03:01:04,667
today's these delicate

3666
03:01:05,200 --> 03:01:07,172
balances. Balances in terms of

3667
03:01:07,172 --> 03:01:09,374
rights of folks and obligations

3668
03:01:09,374 --> 03:01:11,390
and responsibilities. And so

3669
03:01:11,390 --> 03:01:12,513
now we have this new issue

3670
03:01:12,513 --> 03:01:14,745
weapon ising the internet in

3671
03:01:14,745 --> 03:01:16,878
the way that. No one could ever

3672
03:01:16,878 --> 03:01:18,115
have imagined. And so how do

3673
03:01:18,115 --> 03:01:19,350
you deal with those kinds of

3674
03:01:19,350 --> 03:01:20,751
things how do you balance these

3675
03:01:20,751 --> 03:01:21,652
things that the framers of the

3676
03:01:21,652 --> 03:01:23,754
constitution never would have

3677
03:01:23,754 --> 03:01:25,255
ever dreamed of. And so the

3678
03:01:25,255 --> 03:01:26,490
question is I think as it's

3679
03:01:26,490 --> 03:01:28,393
narrowly drafted targets the

3680
03:01:28,393 --> 03:01:30,193
core political speech. Without

3681
03:01:30,193 --> 03:01:32,159
regard to legitimacy commentary

3682
03:01:32,159 --> 03:01:34,995
and criticism parody and satire

3683
03:01:34,995 --> 03:01:36,333
reenactments of real events.

3684
03:01:36,333 --> 03:01:38,000
The and the like tse types of

3685
03:01:38,000 --> 03:01:40,232
things are not being taken are

3686
03:01:40,232 --> 03:01:41,867
are not being drawn in this is

3687
03:01:41,867 --> 03:01:44,267
about where somebody engages

3688
03:01:44,606 --> 03:01:47,606
the malicious behavior. All on

3689
03:01:47,672 --> 03:01:49,420
the internet. And just is

3690
03:01:49,420 --> 03:01:51,440
completely false and takes the

3691
03:01:51,440 --> 03:01:52,479
situation where in the very

3692
03:01:52,479 --> 03:01:54,581
supreme court cases in the

3693
03:01:54,581 --> 03:01:56,947
public officials have been told

3694
03:01:56,947 --> 03:01:59,288
limited. To give new tools in

3695
03:01:59,288 --> 03:02:02,888
that regard and I think being

3696
03:02:03,756 --> 03:02:04,260
particularly sensitive. To

3697
03:02:04,260 --> 03:02:04,858
chill in fact I think it

3698
03:02:04,858 --> 03:02:07,858
strikes the right balance last

3699
03:02:09,425 --> 03:02:11,227
year I bought. Thank you hall

3700
03:02:11,227 --> 03:02:13,627
debate happen seized sector

3701
03:02:13,866 --> 03:02:16,866
please call the roll allen.

3702
03:02:16,972 --> 03:02:19,869
Archuleta aye atkins aye bates.

3703
03:02:19,869 --> 03:02:21,206
Bill by porges are bradford aye

3704
03:02:21,206 --> 03:02:24,806
aye aye caballero aye chiang I

3705
03:02:26,909 --> 03:02:30,509
daly. No dodd dorado galgiani I

3706
03:02:31,283 --> 03:02:33,417
glazer aye gonzalez I grow. No

3707
03:02:33,417 --> 03:02:37,170
hertzberg aye hill aye hueso I

3708
03:02:40,619 --> 03:02:43,427
tado. Jackson I jones no leyva.

3709
03:02:43,427 --> 03:02:46,427
I'm mcguire by mitchell aye

3710
03:02:48,463 --> 03:02:51,463
monning I'm more luck. Morrell.

3711
03:02:52,536 --> 03:02:56,136
No nielsen no pan by portantino

3712
03:02:56,606 --> 03:02:59,509
aye roth aye rubio aye skinner.

3713
03:02:59,509 --> 03:03:03,109
I stern aye stone November our

3714
03:03:07,682 --> 03:03:10,384
caskey. Winner. Hi wilk no.

3715
03:03:10,384 --> 03:03:13,384
Senator hurts moves a call.

3716
03:03:14,153 --> 03:03:14,789
Moving on now to file item

3717
03:03:14,789 --> 03:03:17,390
fifty two senator hill are you

3718
03:03:17,390 --> 03:03:19,240
prepared for this item. Thank.

3719
03:03:19,240 --> 03:03:21,424
You Mister Secretary please

3720
03:03:21,893 --> 03:03:22,294
rate assembly bill nine twenty

3721
03:03:22,294 --> 03:03:23,950
by assembly member

3722
03:03:23,950 --> 03:03:25,360
petrie-norris anak ruling of

3723
03:03:25,360 --> 03:03:26,761
health. Video thank you Mister

3724
03:03:26,761 --> 03:03:28,432
President colleagues as a

3725
03:03:28,432 --> 03:03:30,100
principal co author I proudly

3726
03:03:30,100 --> 03:03:33,390
present a. B. Nine twenty by

3727
03:03:33,390 --> 03:03:33,640
assembly woman petrie-norris

3728
03:03:33,640 --> 03:03:34,904
eighty nine twenty protection

3729
03:03:34,904 --> 03:03:37,304
substance abuse patients in

3730
03:03:37,473 --> 03:03:39,239
recovery by requiring all out

3731
03:03:39,239 --> 03:03:40,376
patient treatment programs to

3732
03:03:40,376 --> 03:03:42,344
be licensed with the department

3733
03:03:42,344 --> 03:03:44,113
of health care services.

3734
03:03:44,113 --> 03:03:45,981
Earlier this year this body

3735
03:03:45,981 --> 03:03:47,981
unanimously approved this

3736
03:03:48,852 --> 03:03:49,621
policy in my bill sb three

3737
03:03:49,621 --> 03:03:51,354
twenty five and I appreciate

3738
03:03:51,354 --> 03:03:53,689
our author senator from a

3739
03:03:53,689 --> 03:03:55,789
good senor from laguna gal.

3740
03:03:55,789 --> 03:03:56,923
This measure has known no known

3741
03:03:56,923 --> 03:03:58,923
opposition and unanimous

3742
03:03:59,495 --> 03:04:00,930
bipartisan support I

3743
03:04:00,930 --> 03:04:03,930
respectfully ask your aye vote

3744
03:04:04,300 --> 03:04:04,731
college. Q. Any further

3745
03:04:04,731 --> 03:04:05,731
discussion debate on this item

3746
03:04:05,731 --> 03:04:06,996
senator stone thank you Mister

3747
03:04:06,996 --> 03:04:09,201
President I strongly stand in

3748
03:04:09,201 --> 03:04:10,903
support of ab nine twenty it's

3749
03:04:10,903 --> 03:04:13,636
unfortunate that I had a bill.

3750
03:04:13,636 --> 03:04:15,400
That was I held in the assembly

3751
03:04:15,400 --> 03:04:16,808
appropriations that would of

3752
03:04:16,808 --> 03:04:18,213
put alcoholism but the land

3753
03:04:18,213 --> 03:04:19,611
from an act which is kind of

3754
03:04:19,611 --> 03:04:22,110
unfortunate but-this bill. I

3755
03:04:22,347 --> 03:04:25,830
think it's gonna stem the tide

3756
03:04:25,830 --> 03:04:26,714
of inappropriate therapies that

3757
03:04:26,714 --> 03:04:27,818
are out there that are robbing

3758
03:04:27,818 --> 03:04:28,852
people of their savings and

3759
03:04:28,852 --> 03:04:30,551
trying to help their loved

3760
03:04:30,551 --> 03:04:31,857
ones. This is the kind of

3761
03:04:31,857 --> 03:04:32,522
legislation that we need to

3762
03:04:32,522 --> 03:04:34,570
make sure we have honest

3763
03:04:34,570 --> 03:04:35,158
providers out there that are

3764
03:04:35,158 --> 03:04:38,528
trying to help people some of

3765
03:04:38,528 --> 03:04:39,128
the most difficult addictions.

3766
03:04:39,128 --> 03:04:42,128
Namely alcoholism in the state

3767
03:04:43,600 --> 03:04:44,664
and so I. Firmly requests and

3768
03:04:44,664 --> 03:04:46,837
high vote on maybe nine twenty.

3769
03:04:46,837 --> 03:04:48,171
Thank you senator bates. Thank

3770
03:04:48,171 --> 03:04:50,673
you Mister President on I'd

3771
03:04:50,673 --> 03:04:53,139
like to command to off the

3772
03:04:53,139 --> 03:04:54,540
floor manager and the author of

3773
03:04:54,540 --> 03:04:55,811
for putting this forward we've

3774
03:04:55,811 --> 03:04:57,944
been working so long now

3775
03:04:57,944 --> 03:04:59,278
through this legislature to try

3776
03:04:59,278 --> 03:05:01,347
to rainy and now those who

3777
03:05:01,347 --> 03:05:03,349
abuse the most vulnerable in

3778
03:05:03,349 --> 03:05:04,517
our society those who

3779
03:05:04,517 --> 03:05:06,517
unfortunately have become

3780
03:05:06,652 --> 03:05:08,418
addicted to some. Of substance

3781
03:05:08,418 --> 03:05:10,220
or another who are honestly

3782
03:05:10,220 --> 03:05:12,422
seeking treatment and find

3783
03:05:12,692 --> 03:05:15,920
themselves into very reputable

3784
03:05:15,940 --> 03:05:16,692
ob treatment centers that

3785
03:05:16,692 --> 03:05:19,598
really I use them merely

3786
03:05:19,598 --> 03:05:20,599
outside could checking our to

3787
03:05:20,599 --> 03:05:22,731
line their own pockets so we

3788
03:05:22,731 --> 03:05:24,806
think the author the floor

3789
03:05:24,806 --> 03:05:27,408
manager and it was my pleasure

3790
03:05:27,408 --> 03:05:29,142
and certainly all my-my honor

3791
03:05:29,142 --> 03:05:30,141
to be included with this

3792
03:05:30,141 --> 03:05:31,711
because we-continue our

3793
03:05:31,711 --> 03:05:34,376
efforts side there's still more

3794
03:05:34,376 --> 03:05:37,810
to be done. So without I give

3795
03:05:37,810 --> 03:05:38,613
it a hearty thumbs up and wish

3796
03:05:38,613 --> 03:05:41,130
everyone to strongly supported

3797
03:05:44,157 --> 03:05:44,688
thank you. Thank you any

3798
03:05:44,688 --> 03:05:46,688
further discussion debate

3799
03:05:48,889 --> 03:05:49,359
center start stern. Thank you

3800
03:05:49,359 --> 03:05:51,327
Mister Bradford mister

3801
03:05:51,327 --> 03:05:52,128
president sorry. There was

3802
03:05:52,128 --> 03:05:53,563
inadvertently removed is a co

3803
03:05:53,563 --> 03:05:55,765
author on this measure but I

3804
03:05:55,765 --> 03:05:56,366
just wanted to reiterated

3805
03:05:56,366 --> 03:05:59,235
hopefully I'm still co author

3806
03:05:59,235 --> 03:06:00,133
in spirit and trying to bring

3807
03:06:00,133 --> 03:06:01,871
some certainty back to the

3808
03:06:01,871 --> 03:06:04,170
community take care people who

3809
03:06:04,170 --> 03:06:05,407
suffering from addiction but-

3810
03:06:05,407 --> 03:06:07,312
protecting our neighborhoods as

3811
03:06:07,312 --> 03:06:08,172
well and making sure that

3812
03:06:08,172 --> 03:06:10,572
people actually have some

3813
03:06:11,800 --> 03:06:11,609
recourse for fraudulent action

3814
03:06:11,609 --> 03:06:12,679
in our community so with that

3815
03:06:12,679 --> 03:06:16,279
expect the as for aye vote.

3816
03:06:16,349 --> 03:06:17,447
Thank you tino further mike's

3817
03:06:17,447 --> 03:06:18,417
up senator hill would you like

3818
03:06:18,417 --> 03:06:20,190
to close thank you Mister

3819
03:06:20,190 --> 03:06:20,956
President I just appreciate the

3820
03:06:20,956 --> 03:06:22,124
good the comments from our good

3821
03:06:22,124 --> 03:06:23,686
friends and good senators for

3822
03:06:23,686 --> 03:06:26,610
their for their support their

3823
03:06:26,610 --> 03:06:27,995
commitment and their passion

3824
03:06:27,995 --> 03:06:30,126
for the best approach when

3825
03:06:30,126 --> 03:06:32,598
you're looking at recovery for

3826
03:06:32,598 --> 03:06:33,232
the substance abuse we see in

3827
03:06:33,232 --> 03:06:34,130
california respectfully ask for

3828
03:06:34,130 --> 03:06:37,130
live college thank you. Thank

3829
03:06:37,303 --> 03:06:40,303
you. Secretary please call the

3830
03:06:42,740 --> 03:06:45,740
roll allen. Archuleta by atkins

3831
03:06:47,110 --> 03:06:49,816
aye bates by bill by burgess I

3832
03:06:49,816 --> 03:06:51,885
bradford all right I cover euro.

3833
03:06:51,885 --> 03:06:55,485
I chiang aye daly aye dodd.

3834
03:06:58,485 --> 03:07:01,190
Durazo. Hi galgiani aye glazer

3835
03:07:01,190 --> 03:07:04,190
aye gonzalez hi grow. I

3836
03:07:07,831 --> 03:07:10,831
hertzberg aye hill. Hill. What

3837
03:07:12,103 --> 03:07:15,703
I hueso hi title. Jackson I

3838
03:07:16,700 --> 03:07:19,670
jones I leyva aye mcguire aye

3839
03:07:20,274 --> 03:07:23,274
mitchell aye monning hi more

3840
03:07:23,713 --> 03:07:27,444
lock I'm a real I nielsen. I

3841
03:07:27,444 --> 03:07:30,444
pan aye portantino. By roth.

3842
03:07:31,551 --> 03:07:35,151
Aye rubio aye skinner aye stern

3843
03:07:37,256 --> 03:07:41,456
by stone I am burke. By kelsey

3844
03:07:42,559 --> 03:07:45,598
I winner hi wilk. Hi. Sooner

3845
03:07:45,598 --> 03:07:48,968
hill moves the call next up is

3846
03:07:48,968 --> 03:07:49,535
file item fifty three senator

3847
03:07:49,535 --> 03:07:51,935
glazier you're prepared for

3848
03:07:52,306 --> 03:07:53,875
this measure. The secretary

3849
03:07:53,875 --> 03:07:55,210
when you're ready please rate

3850
03:07:55,210 --> 03:07:57,142
assembly bill ten eighty six by

3851
03:07:57,142 --> 03:07:58,309
assembly member bauer k. Hand

3852
03:07:58,309 --> 03:08:00,511
an act relating to parks and

3853
03:08:00,511 --> 03:08:01,616
recreation. Center glazer for

3854
03:08:01,616 --> 03:08:02,878
george thank you Mister

3855
03:08:02,878 --> 03:08:04,591
President members I'm pleased

3856
03:08:04,591 --> 03:08:05,680
to present this bill on behalf

3857
03:08:05,680 --> 03:08:07,752
of assembly woman the back of

3858
03:08:07,752 --> 03:08:09,150
our que han it's a bill that

3859
03:08:09,150 --> 03:08:09,920
would allow the department of

3860
03:08:09,920 --> 03:08:12,268
parks and recrtion to sell a

3861
03:08:12,268 --> 03:08:13,187
portion of the carnegie state.

3862
03:08:13,187 --> 03:08:15,587
Vehicle recreation area for

3863
03:08:17,424 --> 03:08:18,240
conservation purposes. If the

3864
03:08:18,240 --> 03:08:19,928
department determines it's in

3865
03:08:19,928 --> 03:08:20,627
the public's interest.

3866
03:08:20,627 --> 03:08:21,997
Currently there is an off

3867
03:08:21,997 --> 03:08:24,397
highway vehicle parked right

3868
03:08:26,968 --> 03:08:29,570
next door. Has been down in

3869
03:08:29,570 --> 03:08:31,703
recent years. This parcel this

3870
03:08:31,703 --> 03:08:33,777
expansion parcel has been.

3871
03:08:33,777 --> 03:08:36,214
Under litigation for quite some

3872
03:08:36,214 --> 03:08:38,110
time it's very controversial.

3873
03:08:38,110 --> 03:08:39,780
And this bill all it does is it

3874
03:08:39,780 --> 03:08:41,648
doesn't require a sale it says

3875
03:08:41,648 --> 03:08:42,249
that if the department.

3876
03:08:42,249 --> 03:08:44,649
Determines in their interests

3877
03:08:44,818 --> 03:08:46,190
that. Sale would be appropriate

3878
03:08:46,190 --> 03:08:47,754
to give them the ability to do

3879
03:08:47,754 --> 03:08:49,122
that. And keep in mind that we

3880
03:08:49,122 --> 03:08:50,992
have an advisory committee of

3881
03:08:50,992 --> 03:08:52,650
off road enthusiasts advising

3882
03:08:52,650 --> 03:08:54,360
the department is the off

3883
03:08:54,360 --> 03:08:55,162
highway. Vehicle commission and

3884
03:08:55,162 --> 03:08:56,362
so the department in

3885
03:08:56,362 --> 03:08:57,763
consultation of the commission

3886
03:08:57,763 --> 03:08:58,731
they make that determination.

3887
03:08:58,731 --> 03:09:00,633
This bill would give them the

3888
03:09:00,633 --> 03:09:01,834
opportunity to sell the

3889
03:09:01,834 --> 03:09:03,869
property now one of the

3890
03:09:03,869 --> 03:09:05,873
provisions of this bill is it

3891
03:09:05,873 --> 03:09:07,205
sets a minimum selling price.

3892
03:09:07,205 --> 03:09:10,780
Doesn't that just follow the

3893
03:09:10,780 --> 03:09:11,740
typical sales surplus land

3894
03:09:11,740 --> 03:09:14,179
protocols it says yes that's

3895
03:09:14,179 --> 03:09:15,213
what will happen but it can't

3896
03:09:15,213 --> 03:09:18,213
kill anything below than what

3897
03:09:18,482 --> 03:09:20,182
the purchase price wise. I want

3898
03:09:20,182 --> 03:09:21,955
to say that this measure

3899
03:09:21,955 --> 03:09:25,555
supported by city in and the

3900
03:09:26,960 --> 03:09:26,922
county of alameda. Because it

3901
03:09:26,922 --> 03:09:29,291
is special ecological value of

3902
03:09:29,291 --> 03:09:30,395
this parcel the sierra club the

3903
03:09:30,395 --> 03:09:32,394
native plant society the

3904
03:09:32,394 --> 03:09:35,994
audubon society of all come out

3905
03:09:36,267 --> 03:09:36,867
in support. Of this bill and

3906
03:09:36,867 --> 03:09:39,634
with that respectfully ask for

3907
03:09:39,634 --> 03:09:43,234
an aye vote. Thank you senator

3908
03:09:43,776 --> 03:09:45,973
borchers. Question for the

3909
03:09:45,973 --> 03:09:47,374
author our or of fields of for

3910
03:09:47,374 --> 03:09:50,460
manager please enter glazer we

3911
03:09:50,460 --> 03:09:51,776
to question happy to yes. Is

3912
03:09:51,776 --> 03:09:54,176
there any reversionary language

3913
03:09:54,314 --> 03:09:57,140
that should a purchaser assume

3914
03:09:57,140 --> 03:09:58,951
title that would keep them from

3915
03:09:58,951 --> 03:10:01,687
selling it to by any other

3916
03:10:01,687 --> 03:10:04,687
entity. And pocketing the fair

3917
03:10:05,890 --> 03:10:06,424
market value. I don't think

3918
03:10:06,424 --> 03:10:09,126
that the thank you for your

3919
03:10:09,126 --> 03:10:10,528
question there's no intention

3920
03:10:10,528 --> 03:10:12,894
to have that be the case it's

3921
03:10:12,894 --> 03:10:14,696
my understanding that there's a

3922
03:10:14,696 --> 03:10:16,366
rules in which we dispose of

3923
03:10:16,366 --> 03:10:17,870
surplus property the state.

3924
03:10:17,870 --> 03:10:19,771
Provides the opportunity for to

3925
03:10:19,771 --> 03:10:21,608
go to a public agencies first

3926
03:10:21,608 --> 03:10:23,206
so the idea that it could ever

3927
03:10:23,206 --> 03:10:24,306
be used for that type of

3928
03:10:24,306 --> 03:10:27,906
activity would be very low this

3929
03:10:28,246 --> 03:10:29,407
is rural land is not urban land

3930
03:10:29,407 --> 03:10:32,713
this is out in the hinterlands

3931
03:10:32,713 --> 03:10:33,948
of. Of alameda county I does it

3932
03:10:33,948 --> 03:10:35,483
have the traditional developing

3933
03:10:35,483 --> 03:10:36,848
rights one might expect in that

3934
03:10:36,848 --> 03:10:39,486
type of area so I don't think

3935
03:10:39,486 --> 03:10:41,122
that. Issue is really in play

3936
03:10:41,122 --> 03:10:43,522
and certainly the department

3937
03:10:44,427 --> 03:10:44,991
could take that into account if

3938
03:10:44,991 --> 03:10:47,460
they were to choose to buy.

3939
03:10:47,460 --> 03:10:48,561
Declare the land surplus. Are

3940
03:10:48,561 --> 03:10:50,898
my only concern is that when

3941
03:10:50,898 --> 03:10:53,298
you're dealing with a-land

3942
03:10:53,769 --> 03:10:55,637
like this. That if you're a-

3943
03:10:55,637 --> 03:10:58,404
bass line is the purchase price

3944
03:10:58,404 --> 03:11:00,804
but it's-that's twenty. Years

3945
03:11:01,407 --> 03:11:03,709
dated. Why they would be using

3946
03:11:03,709 --> 03:11:05,444
the fair market value today.

3947
03:11:05,444 --> 03:11:07,279
And the last would be a

3948
03:11:07,279 --> 03:11:08,683
reversionary clause that the

3949
03:11:08,683 --> 03:11:10,185
property of sold to a third

3950
03:11:10,185 --> 03:11:11,583
party or intent to be sold to a

3951
03:11:11,583 --> 03:11:13,952
third party would automatically

3952
03:11:13,952 --> 03:11:16,121
revert to the state. Of in or

3953
03:11:16,121 --> 03:11:17,157
some sort of conservancy I

3954
03:11:17,157 --> 03:11:19,123
would say this that if that was

3955
03:11:19,123 --> 03:11:19,688
ever an issue I've certainly

3956
03:11:19,688 --> 03:11:21,922
has my commitment and I'll

3957
03:11:21,922 --> 03:11:23,160
check with the author as well.

3958
03:11:23,160 --> 03:11:24,294
To make sure that that would

3959
03:11:24,294 --> 03:11:25,125
not that's not a purpose of

3960
03:11:25,125 --> 03:11:26,897
what this mean that measure

3961
03:11:26,897 --> 03:11:28,498
intends to do and we certainly

3962
03:11:28,498 --> 03:11:29,699
wouldn't want that to be the

3963
03:11:29,699 --> 03:11:31,301
result of a it's really an

3964
03:11:31,301 --> 03:11:33,403
attempt to. If they decide the

3965
03:11:33,403 --> 03:11:33,937
conflict has gone on too long

3966
03:11:33,937 --> 03:11:35,371
the hundreds of thousands

3967
03:11:35,371 --> 03:11:37,541
litigation has gone on for too

3968
03:11:37,541 --> 03:11:38,708
long. That that there's a that

3969
03:11:38,708 --> 03:11:41,708
it can be preserved in

3970
03:11:43,679 --> 03:11:44,281
conservation and permanently

3971
03:11:44,281 --> 03:11:44,844
that's really the goal to give

3972
03:11:44,844 --> 03:11:48,444
them that option. If they so

3973
03:11:49,881 --> 03:11:52,787
choose. Center stone. I think

3974
03:11:52,787 --> 03:11:53,321
it was fair if I if I May ask

3975
03:11:53,321 --> 03:11:55,355
the author of the lord for

3976
03:11:55,355 --> 03:11:56,689
manager question please. We

3977
03:11:56,689 --> 03:11:58,658
take a question yes thank you

3978
03:11:58,658 --> 03:12:00,759
center. And I'm just using my

3979
03:12:00,759 --> 03:12:02,959
recall here or the last time we

3980
03:12:02,959 --> 03:12:04,399
have this being discussed I was

3981
03:12:04,399 --> 03:12:06,598
opposed to it because if I

3982
03:12:06,598 --> 03:12:08,364
remember correct and I. Find

3983
03:12:08,364 --> 03:12:10,634
the to be corrected please

3984
03:12:10,634 --> 03:12:12,936
correct me. That it was hv fees

3985
03:12:12,936 --> 03:12:15,805
at were originally choir did

3986
03:12:15,805 --> 03:12:17,874
use to buy this property. If

3987
03:12:17,874 --> 03:12:19,540
that is the case and if nine

3988
03:12:19,540 --> 03:12:21,900
million dollars is in fact the

3989
03:12:21,900 --> 03:12:22,420
selling price of the property

3990
03:12:22,420 --> 03:12:24,475
with the nine million dollars

3991
03:12:24,475 --> 03:12:27,749
be returned to the a tree fun.

3992
03:12:27,749 --> 03:12:28,385
So we can mitigate the loss of

3993
03:12:28,385 --> 03:12:30,650
always she land in the state of

3994
03:12:30,650 --> 03:12:31,484
california. Thank you senator

3995
03:12:31,484 --> 03:12:32,620
for your question. And yes the

3996
03:12:32,620 --> 03:12:34,518
requirements of the bill is

3997
03:12:34,518 --> 03:12:35,825
that if the property was sold

3998
03:12:35,825 --> 03:12:37,230
again that's an option the

3999
03:12:37,230 --> 03:12:39,156
department would have. Not a

4000
03:12:39,156 --> 03:12:40,357
requirement of this bill. That

4001
03:12:40,357 --> 03:12:42,231
the funds to be returned to the

4002
03:12:42,231 --> 03:12:45,300
o. H. Be fine to be used for

4003
03:12:45,300 --> 03:12:46,132
only hd purposes. And so those

4004
03:12:46,132 --> 03:12:47,432
who are enthusiasts of the

4005
03:12:47,432 --> 03:12:49,702
sport in this bill is in no way

4006
03:12:49,702 --> 03:12:51,503
as-an attempt to a take away

4007
03:12:51,503 --> 03:12:53,503
that recreational opportunity.

4008
03:12:55,645 --> 03:12:55,886
You would you would get

4009
03:12:55,886 --> 03:12:56,711
resources that are locked down

4010
03:12:56,711 --> 03:12:57,976
now going for nothing. And he'd

4011
03:12:57,976 --> 03:12:59,747
be able to get those resources

4012
03:12:59,747 --> 03:13:01,179
back and hopefully find other

4013
03:13:01,179 --> 03:13:03,579
appropriate places to support

4014
03:13:04,382 --> 03:13:04,985
that activity in that would be

4015
03:13:04,985 --> 03:13:07,485
and that. And that's the bill

4016
03:13:07,485 --> 03:13:08,750
provides for that. Thank you.

4017
03:13:08,750 --> 03:13:11,150
Senator I appreciate you

4018
03:13:12,900 --> 03:13:13,339
answering the question. I think

4019
03:13:13,339 --> 03:13:15,280
it's very appropriate that

4020
03:13:15,280 --> 03:13:16,627
since each the funds to pay for

4021
03:13:16,627 --> 03:13:17,297
this property if it's to be

4022
03:13:17,297 --> 03:13:19,627
sold at the ocean go back into

4023
03:13:19,627 --> 03:13:21,932
the hv fun to maybe find more

4024
03:13:21,932 --> 03:13:22,531
appropriate to a piece of land

4025
03:13:22,531 --> 03:13:24,366
in the state of california we

4026
03:13:24,366 --> 03:13:25,301
know over twenty years said.

4027
03:13:25,301 --> 03:13:26,568
Things happen things become

4028
03:13:26,568 --> 03:13:28,137
either more urbanites are

4029
03:13:28,137 --> 03:13:29,804
things going to habitat as

4030
03:13:29,804 --> 03:13:30,771
we've seen in riverside county

4031
03:13:30,771 --> 03:13:32,840
where we have probably one of

4032
03:13:32,840 --> 03:13:33,844
the most progressive habitt

4033
03:13:33,844 --> 03:13:36,140
conservation plans in the

4034
03:13:36,140 --> 03:13:37,177
country with a hundred fifty

4035
03:13:37,177 --> 03:13:40,177
three thousand acres slated to

4036
03:13:40,545 --> 03:13:41,418
be put into conservation but as

4037
03:13:41,418 --> 03:13:43,781
a former each Vi

4038
03:13:43,781 --> 03:13:45,552
user and many

4039
03:13:45,552 --> 03:13:47,985
that use each piece of my

4040
03:13:47,985 --> 03:13:49,219
district. I'm pleased to hear

4041
03:13:49,219 --> 03:13:50,621
that the nine million dollars

4042
03:13:50,621 --> 03:13:54,136
will go back into the which the

4043
03:13:54,136 --> 03:13:56,259
fund I hope that if there is a

4044
03:13:56,259 --> 03:13:57,894
capital gain on this property

4045
03:13:57,894 --> 03:13:59,465
that the good senator will

4046
03:13:59,465 --> 03:14:00,834
maintain its commitment which I

4047
03:14:00,834 --> 03:14:02,569
believe that he will to make

4048
03:14:02,569 --> 03:14:05,269
sure that the hd fund hopefully

4049
03:14:05,269 --> 03:14:07,730
will be we made whole with that

4050
03:14:07,730 --> 03:14:10,730
appreciation and with that i

4051
03:14:12,409 --> 03:14:12,973
stand in support of. This

4052
03:14:12,973 --> 03:14:15,973
measure thank you. Thank you

4053
03:14:16,649 --> 03:14:18,114
senator white culture. I rise

4054
03:14:18,114 --> 03:14:18,751
as a-proud. Resident of

4055
03:14:18,751 --> 03:14:19,948
alameda county Mister President

4056
03:14:19,948 --> 03:14:20,750
rise since. Our in support of

4057
03:14:20,750 --> 03:14:21,384
this measure I think the

4058
03:14:21,384 --> 03:14:22,618
members of the senate chen the

4059
03:14:22,618 --> 03:14:24,851
understand that. Alameda county

4060
03:14:24,851 --> 03:14:27,890
has passed measure d. Which

4061
03:14:27,890 --> 03:14:29,580
limits the development on any

4062
03:14:29,580 --> 03:14:30,625
county open space. The one

4063
03:14:30,625 --> 03:14:32,394
housing units per hundred so

4064
03:14:32,394 --> 03:14:34,293
while this particular piece of

4065
03:14:34,293 --> 03:14:36,293
legislation. Doesn't have

4066
03:14:36,328 --> 03:14:38,566
revisionary language in it

4067
03:14:38,566 --> 03:14:40,302
there are there are in place

4068
03:14:40,302 --> 03:14:41,639
protection said that this.

4069
03:14:41,639 --> 03:14:43,639
Property will remain

4070
03:14:44,342 --> 03:14:45,840
essentially open space again I

4071
03:14:45,840 --> 03:14:47,809
think the floor manager. And

4072
03:14:47,809 --> 03:14:49,810
behalf of the author has. Has

4073
03:14:49,810 --> 03:14:51,810
highlighted the ecological

4074
03:14:52,780 --> 03:14:55,180
uniqueness of this property

4075
03:14:57,840 --> 03:14:59,355
which is the-being protected

4076
03:14:59,355 --> 03:15:00,688
under our current rules the sg

4077
03:15:00,688 --> 03:15:02,925
has the ability to give a

4078
03:15:02,925 --> 03:15:04,887
discount for open space land

4079
03:15:04,887 --> 03:15:06,793
and I think that the discussion

4080
03:15:06,793 --> 03:15:08,759
this vocal one with the sg

4081
03:15:08,759 --> 03:15:10,228
should measure passed this

4082
03:15:10,228 --> 03:15:11,495
house single wanting to gain

4083
03:15:11,495 --> 03:15:13,564
the governor's signature is

4084
03:15:13,564 --> 03:15:16,660
still be a discussion on the

4085
03:15:16,660 --> 03:15:18,501
value that open space also my

4086
03:15:18,501 --> 03:15:20,138
understanding that the

4087
03:15:20,138 --> 03:15:21,638
legislation is written right

4088
03:15:21,638 --> 03:15:24,941
now all the money will go to

4089
03:15:24,941 --> 03:15:26,607
the off road vehicle fund so if

4090
03:15:26,607 --> 03:15:28,778
there's any surplus that's-not

4091
03:15:28,778 --> 03:15:30,980
surplus by the negotiated.

4092
03:15:30,980 --> 03:15:32,446
Amount and this is will be fair

4093
03:15:32,446 --> 03:15:34,520
by in one of the arms is state

4094
03:15:34,520 --> 03:15:37,652
government so I plug the author

4095
03:15:38,195 --> 03:15:39,486
and the floor manager for the

4096
03:15:39,486 --> 03:15:40,870
hard work to persistent work on

4097
03:15:40,870 --> 03:15:42,889
this issue and I would urge an

4098
03:15:42,889 --> 03:15:43,660
aye vote. Thank you senator

4099
03:15:43,660 --> 03:15:44,493
jones thank you Mister

4100
03:15:44,493 --> 03:15:45,592
President and I do appreciate

4101
03:15:45,592 --> 03:15:47,461
the authors hard work on this

4102
03:15:47,461 --> 03:15:50,163
he's been very consistent on

4103
03:15:50,163 --> 03:15:52,234
that. Almost to a fault I think

4104
03:15:52,234 --> 03:15:54,167
and I just know I want to talk

4105
03:15:54,167 --> 03:15:55,204
to the process here. This

4106
03:15:55,204 --> 03:15:57,537
bill's been heard a couple of

4107
03:15:57,537 --> 03:16:00,306
times this year. It was held in

4108
03:16:00,306 --> 03:16:02,375
the assembly the senate bill

4109
03:16:02,375 --> 03:16:04,443
was here. Earlier version of

4110
03:16:04,443 --> 03:16:06,345
this and then all of a sudden

4111
03:16:06,345 --> 03:16:09,810
this week we have a jail break

4112
03:16:09,810 --> 03:16:11,818
on a. B. Ten eighty six. So is

4113
03:16:11,818 --> 03:16:14,818
concerned about the process on

4114
03:16:17,188 --> 03:16:17,753
this and-the. The just a

4115
03:16:17,753 --> 03:16:21,620
process and I would urge no

4116
03:16:21,620 --> 03:16:22,190
vote thank you. Traditions that

4117
03:16:22,190 --> 03:16:24,593
sort of looking for traditions

4118
03:16:24,593 --> 03:16:26,630
thank you. Any additional

4119
03:16:26,630 --> 03:16:28,430
discussion or debate on this

4120
03:16:28,430 --> 03:16:29,464
item he nine senator glazer

4121
03:16:29,464 --> 03:16:31,235
which ought to close thank you

4122
03:16:31,235 --> 03:16:32,667
Mister President let me close

4123
03:16:32,667 --> 03:16:35,667
and talking about the process

4124
03:16:35,672 --> 03:16:37,337
so. This bill in it at the

4125
03:16:37,337 --> 03:16:38,138
constance's this bill were

4126
03:16:38,138 --> 03:16:39,712
heard here in the senate a

4127
03:16:39,712 --> 03:16:40,276
couple times to different

4128
03:16:40,276 --> 03:16:41,341
hearings and was her on the

4129
03:16:41,341 --> 03:16:43,212
floor and passed out earlier

4130
03:16:43,212 --> 03:16:45,813
this year. And this particular

4131
03:16:45,813 --> 03:16:46,650
bills had three hearings in the

4132
03:16:46,650 --> 03:16:49,185
senate prior to the floor

4133
03:16:49,185 --> 03:16:51,153
discussion today. And for those

4134
03:16:51,153 --> 03:16:53,754
who are veterans all know that

4135
03:16:53,754 --> 03:16:55,650
a similar bill almost identical

4136
03:16:55,650 --> 03:16:56,492
was introduced in heard and

4137
03:16:56,492 --> 03:16:58,393
passed out of the senate a year

4138
03:16:58,393 --> 03:17:00,256
ago. So there's been quite a

4139
03:17:00,256 --> 03:17:01,657
lot of discussion on this bill

4140
03:17:01,657 --> 03:17:03,270
and it's almost exactly the

4141
03:17:03,270 --> 03:17:04,329
same form we have it today and

4142
03:17:04,329 --> 03:17:06,200
so I would are make the

4143
03:17:06,200 --> 03:17:07,295
argument that. This is that a

4144
03:17:07,295 --> 03:17:10,895
plot plenty of that vetting and

4145
03:17:12,238 --> 03:17:12,873
I think it's good it's. It's

4146
03:17:12,873 --> 03:17:15,442
for prefers take action on this

4147
03:17:15,442 --> 03:17:16,371
today and finally all that

4148
03:17:16,371 --> 03:17:17,143
hearing process I know we have

4149
03:17:17,143 --> 03:17:19,420
a lot of off road enthusiasts

4150
03:17:19,420 --> 03:17:21,175
in the senate. I myself.

4151
03:17:21,175 --> 03:17:21,776
haven't really gotten on one of

4152
03:17:21,776 --> 03:17:22,879
those bikes yet but I'm very

4153
03:17:22,879 --> 03:17:24,484
open to the idea just so you

4154
03:17:24,484 --> 03:17:25,715
know. Yeah and I know that

4155
03:17:25,715 --> 03:17:27,684
there's a worry that somehow

4156
03:17:27,684 --> 03:17:28,888
this is gonna. I take away

4157
03:17:28,888 --> 03:17:31,870
opportunities for those who

4158
03:17:31,870 --> 03:17:32,452
enjoy that sport. And many of

4159
03:17:32,452 --> 03:17:34,230
those folks live in my district

4160
03:17:34,230 --> 03:17:35,391
in the me just assure you that.

4161
03:17:35,391 --> 03:17:38,910
We have an off road. Vehicle

4162
03:17:38,910 --> 03:17:40,396
parked right next door. And

4163
03:17:40,396 --> 03:17:41,163
it's a great outlet one of

4164
03:17:41,163 --> 03:17:43,768
eight in the state. This

4165
03:17:43,768 --> 03:17:46,340
doesn't change that and anyway.

4166
03:17:46,340 --> 03:17:46,901
And that. Resolving this issue

4167
03:17:46,901 --> 03:17:49,206
and I hope the parks department

4168
03:17:49,206 --> 03:17:50,475
of parks can do that quickly.

4169
03:17:50,475 --> 03:17:51,444
Has the potential to bring a

4170
03:17:51,444 --> 03:17:54,309
lot more resources back into

4171
03:17:54,309 --> 03:17:58,509
the hd fine. So that that that

4172
03:17:58,847 --> 03:17:59,446
activity can be promoted. Where

4173
03:17:59,446 --> 03:18:00,180
it's appropriate in california

4174
03:18:00,180 --> 03:18:02,684
with that I respectfully ask

4175
03:18:02,684 --> 03:18:03,583
for either. Thank you all

4176
03:18:03,583 --> 03:18:04,184
debate inscription haven't

4177
03:18:04,184 --> 03:18:06,584
seized Mister Secretary please

4178
03:18:06,755 --> 03:18:09,755
call the roll. Allen I

4179
03:18:10,722 --> 03:18:13,722
archuleta aye atkins aye bates.

4180
03:18:14,426 --> 03:18:17,562
Bell by bridges no bradford aye

4181
03:18:17,562 --> 03:18:21,162
cambiado I chiang no daly no

4182
03:18:23,401 --> 03:18:26,835
dodd. I dorado aye galgiani aye

4183
03:18:26,835 --> 03:18:29,835
glazer aye gonzalez hi growth

4184
03:18:30,872 --> 03:18:34,472
no hertzberg aye hill aye hueso

4185
03:18:34,876 --> 03:18:38,476
by dato. Jackson I jones no

4186
03:18:41,315 --> 03:18:44,530
leyva. By mcguire hi mitchell.

4187
03:18:44,530 --> 03:18:47,653
Hi monning I'm more lock no

4188
03:18:48,390 --> 03:18:51,424
merrell no nielsen no pan aye

4189
03:18:51,424 --> 03:18:54,424
portantino aye roth aye rubio

4190
03:18:54,561 --> 03:18:58,161
aye skinner. I stern aye stone

4191
03:19:00,667 --> 03:19:04,267
by. Number our caskey by wiener

4192
03:19:07,506 --> 03:19:09,341
aye wilk. Glazer moves a call.

4193
03:19:09,341 --> 03:19:11,977
Members now we're moving back

4194
03:19:11,977 --> 03:19:13,178
to file item thirty five

4195
03:19:13,178 --> 03:19:14,746
senator daughter you prepare to

4196
03:19:14,746 --> 03:19:17,315
take up this item Mister

4197
03:19:17,315 --> 03:19:19,117
Secretary please rate assembly

4198
03:19:19,117 --> 03:19:20,180
bill six fifty one by assembly

4199
03:19:20,180 --> 03:19:21,917
member grayson an act relating

4200
03:19:21,917 --> 03:19:23,252
to air ambulance services your

4201
03:19:23,252 --> 03:19:25,287
daughter for george this

4202
03:19:25,287 --> 03:19:28,230
resident members as a co author

4203
03:19:28,230 --> 03:19:28,821
I'm happy percent ab six five

4204
03:19:28,821 --> 03:19:31,630
one on behalf of assembly

4205
03:19:31,630 --> 03:19:32,397
member tim grayson. Emergency

4206
03:19:32,397 --> 03:19:34,396
air ambulance providers are

4207
03:19:34,396 --> 03:19:36,698
essential part of the statewide

4208
03:19:36,698 --> 03:19:38,664
ems system they have also

4209
03:19:38,664 --> 03:19:40,201
provided critical life saving

4210
03:19:40,201 --> 03:19:42,100
support in recent fires and

4211
03:19:42,100 --> 03:19:43,902
earthquakes currently air

4212
03:19:43,902 --> 03:19:45,974
ambulance providers are funded

4213
03:19:45,974 --> 03:19:47,942
through emergency medical air

4214
03:19:47,942 --> 03:19:50,342
transportation act that's e.

4215
03:19:50,578 --> 03:19:54,778
Mada that fund is set to expire

4216
03:19:54,881 --> 03:19:57,780
on. December thirty first two

4217
03:19:57,780 --> 03:19:58,380
thousand eighteen. But ab six

4218
03:19:58,380 --> 03:19:59,351
fifty one will extend the

4219
03:19:59,351 --> 03:20:01,686
existing emergency medical air

4220
03:20:01,686 --> 03:20:03,658
transportation funding until

4221
03:20:03,658 --> 03:20:04,989
the next budget cycle while the

4222
03:20:04,989 --> 03:20:06,960
authored tends to find a long

4223
03:20:06,960 --> 03:20:08,461
term. Funding solution in the

4224
03:20:08,461 --> 03:20:10,795
coming year this bill provides

4225
03:20:10,795 --> 03:20:12,161
area notes with the services

4226
03:20:12,161 --> 03:20:13,331
the funding they need to

4227
03:20:13,331 --> 03:20:15,367
continue to provide this

4228
03:20:15,367 --> 03:20:16,465
lifesaving services in the

4229
03:20:16,465 --> 03:20:18,203
interim. The bill also

4230
03:20:18,203 --> 03:20:20,100
prohibits the ballot balance

4231
03:20:20,100 --> 03:20:22,500
billing practices for all

4232
03:20:23,872 --> 03:20:24,506
california patients thank you

4233
03:20:24,506 --> 03:20:27,975
and I respectfully ask for your

4234
03:20:27,975 --> 03:20:29,110
ibm. Any description debate

4235
03:20:29,110 --> 03:20:31,847
senator dally. Thank you Mister

4236
03:20:31,847 --> 03:20:33,778
President members. When you

4237
03:20:33,778 --> 03:20:35,716
visit to the first assembly

4238
03:20:35,716 --> 03:20:38,652
district it's very rule open as

4239
03:20:38,652 --> 03:20:40,154
many you've been out there and.

4240
03:20:40,154 --> 03:20:42,759
Let's is really your lifeline

4241
03:20:42,759 --> 03:20:44,725
if you get injured out there

4242
03:20:44,725 --> 03:20:45,827
and so we've worked on this

4243
03:20:45,827 --> 03:20:48,940
good senator from napa and I

4244
03:20:48,940 --> 03:20:49,596
and-assembly member grayson

4245
03:20:49,596 --> 03:20:51,201
have worked on this and this is

4246
03:20:51,201 --> 03:20:52,999
a short term fix it just keeps

4247
03:20:52,999 --> 03:20:55,134
on going. But we really need to

4248
03:20:55,134 --> 03:20:56,969
look at a long term solution to

4249
03:20:56,969 --> 03:20:57,534
area moses in california so I

4250
03:20:57,534 --> 03:21:00,534
respectfully ask for an aye

4251
03:21:01,208 --> 03:21:02,809
vote. Thank you thank you. Any

4252
03:21:02,809 --> 03:21:04,374
additional discussion or debate

4253
03:21:04,374 --> 03:21:06,548
on this item. Jeannie hearing

4254
03:21:06,548 --> 03:21:10,148
nine. Would you like to close

4255
03:21:11,650 --> 03:21:12,251
on this senator dodd. Drivers

4256
03:21:12,251 --> 03:21:15,851
Miss Sector we please call the

4257
03:21:17,322 --> 03:21:20,322
roll allen. By. Archuleta aye

4258
03:21:22,196 --> 03:21:25,326
atkins aye bates hi bill by

4259
03:21:25,326 --> 03:21:28,926
burgess by bradford I come a

4260
03:21:29,299 --> 03:21:32,337
euro I chiang aye daly aye dodd

4261
03:21:32,337 --> 03:21:35,337
I dorado aye galgiani aye

4262
03:21:35,871 --> 03:21:39,471
glazer aye gonzalez by grow by

4263
03:21:40,645 --> 03:21:43,645
hertzberg aye hill. Aye hueso.

4264
03:21:47,840 --> 03:21:50,684
Hi taco. Jackson jones by leyva

4265
03:21:53,121 --> 03:21:55,720
hi mcguire. Hi mitchell hi

4266
03:21:55,720 --> 03:21:57,257
monning I'm more lock I'm real.

4267
03:21:57,257 --> 03:22:00,257
I nielsen aye pan aye

4268
03:22:02,996 --> 03:22:05,996
portantino. Roth aye rubio aye

4269
03:22:06,320 --> 03:22:09,632
skinner aye stern aye stone aye

4270
03:22:13,104 --> 03:22:16,704
amberg. Ira caskey I wiener aye

4271
03:22:21,413 --> 03:22:22,546
wilk hi. Sector please call the

4272
03:22:22,546 --> 03:22:25,546
absent members tado jackson I.

4273
03:22:28,619 --> 03:22:30,620
Portantino. Center moves a call.

4274
03:22:30,620 --> 03:22:33,890
Next up center dot file item

4275
03:22:33,890 --> 03:22:36,290
forty one. Mister Secretary

4276
03:22:38,928 --> 03:22:39,359
please read. Assembly bill

4277
03:22:39,359 --> 03:22:41,759
seven forty four by

4278
03:22:41,797 --> 03:22:42,333
assemblymember aguiar-curry and

4279
03:22:42,333 --> 03:22:45,700
act really in health care

4280
03:22:45,700 --> 03:22:48,700
coverage center dot. Thank you

4281
03:22:48,303 --> 03:22:49,710
Mister President senators ab

4282
03:22:49,710 --> 03:22:51,471
seven forty four strengthens

4283
03:22:51,875 --> 03:22:53,774
strengthens non discrimination

4284
03:22:53,774 --> 03:22:55,710
statutes in existing telehealth

4285
03:22:55,710 --> 03:22:58,913
law to ensure that the health

4286
03:22:58,913 --> 03:23:00,315
care provider is reimburse for

4287
03:23:00,315 --> 03:23:02,820
the services delivered to an

4288
03:23:02,820 --> 03:23:05,218
enrollee three telehealth if

4289
03:23:05,218 --> 03:23:07,618
those same services. Are

4290
03:23:07,754 --> 03:23:09,920
covered in person. All

4291
03:23:09,920 --> 03:23:10,789
california should have access

4292
03:23:10,789 --> 03:23:12,624
to health care regardless of

4293
03:23:12,624 --> 03:23:15,240
their location and providers

4294
03:23:15,227 --> 03:23:17,429
should be incentivize to expand

4295
03:23:17,429 --> 03:23:18,730
their reach this bill does not

4296
03:23:18,730 --> 03:23:21,130
expand services that are

4297
03:23:21,363 --> 03:23:23,835
covered it only addresses the

4298
03:23:23,835 --> 03:23:26,835
modality used to provide those

4299
03:23:26,871 --> 03:23:28,272
covered services. Whether

4300
03:23:28,272 --> 03:23:29,874
providers he's a patient in

4301
03:23:29,874 --> 03:23:31,408
person or through a video

4302
03:23:31,408 --> 03:23:34,408
conference they should be paid

4303
03:23:34,442 --> 03:23:35,213
for that work. Ab seven forty

4304
03:23:35,213 --> 03:23:36,980
four were particularly help

4305
03:23:36,980 --> 03:23:38,382
californians in world

4306
03:23:38,382 --> 03:23:40,382
communities medically

4307
03:23:41,170 --> 03:23:43,420
underserved areas and those who

4308
03:23:43,420 --> 03:23:45,891
have been displaced by natural

4309
03:23:45,891 --> 03:23:47,724
disasters. I want to be clear.

4310
03:23:47,724 --> 03:23:49,726
This is not jt our world

4311
03:23:49,726 --> 03:23:51,361
issue we all have pockets in

4312
03:23:51,361 --> 03:23:52,791
our district were access to

4313
03:23:52,791 --> 03:23:55,191
essential health care is

4314
03:23:56,934 --> 03:23:57,178
limited. We should be doing

4315
03:23:57,178 --> 03:23:58,290
whatever we can to leverage

4316
03:23:58,290 --> 03:23:59,630
innovation and health care to

4317
03:23:59,630 --> 03:24:02,630
serve those populations. I ask

4318
03:24:02,636 --> 03:24:05,636
your aye vote. Thank you

4319
03:24:06,840 --> 03:24:08,705
senator dollars. The measure

4320
03:24:08,705 --> 03:24:09,943
President Members I also rise

4321
03:24:09,943 --> 03:24:11,308
if you happen to get in that

4322
03:24:11,308 --> 03:24:12,979
helicopter and then land at one

4323
03:24:12,979 --> 03:24:15,614
of our hospitals you May need

4324
03:24:15,614 --> 03:24:16,746
tell health in the rule area to.

4325
03:24:16,746 --> 03:24:18,517
Get your services so this is

4326
03:24:18,517 --> 03:24:19,654
very critical to rule areas I

4327
03:24:19,654 --> 03:24:21,720
know the good senator from the

4328
03:24:21,720 --> 03:24:23,155
north coast and I. Have a lot

4329
03:24:23,155 --> 03:24:26,188
of the places where we just

4330
03:24:26,188 --> 03:24:28,493
don't have the tech the docks

4331
03:24:28,493 --> 03:24:29,396
there and this this will allow

4332
03:24:29,396 --> 03:24:30,396
them to be able to service

4333
03:24:30,396 --> 03:24:32,497
those constituents out there

4334
03:24:32,497 --> 03:24:35,800
to. Telemedicine so I urge an

4335
03:24:35,800 --> 03:24:38,200
aye vote. In addition

4336
03:24:38,603 --> 03:24:39,202
discussion debate on this item.

4337
03:24:39,202 --> 03:24:42,802
Senator dodd would you like to

4338
03:24:44,311 --> 03:24:47,311
close. Okay was sector please

4339
03:24:48,740 --> 03:24:50,946
call the roll. Allen I

4340
03:24:50,946 --> 03:24:53,946
archuleta aye atkins aye bates.

4341
03:24:58,456 --> 03:25:01,323
Bill. By burgess hi bradford

4342
03:25:01,323 --> 03:25:04,692
aye aye caballero aye ting aye

4343
03:25:04,692 --> 03:25:08,292
daly aye dodd aye dorado I

4344
03:25:09,270 --> 03:25:11,427
galgiani. Hi glazer. Hi

4345
03:25:13,900 --> 03:25:16,300
gonzalez by growth. Rtzberg

4346
03:25:17,300 --> 03:25:21,203
aye hill aye hueso hi tado hi

4347
03:25:22,674 --> 03:25:25,610
jackson. Itunes I leyva aye

4348
03:25:25,610 --> 03:25:28,100
mcguire aye mitchell aye

4349
03:25:28,481 --> 03:25:32,810
monning by more lock. Rail no

4350
03:25:35,586 --> 03:25:37,323
nielsen. Pan aye portantino.

4351
03:25:37,323 --> 03:25:40,923
roth by rubio aye skinner aye

4352
03:25:44,628 --> 03:25:48,828
stern by stone by number five a

4353
03:25:51,660 --> 03:25:52,697
caskey aye wiener aye wilk by.

4354
03:25:52,697 --> 03:25:55,697
The sector please call the

4355
03:25:56,566 --> 03:25:58,966
absent members bates. Growth

4356
03:26:02,877 --> 03:26:05,277
more locked. Nielsen. Nielsen

4357
03:26:08,815 --> 03:26:09,349
aye portantino hi. Ice thirty

4358
03:26:09,349 --> 03:26:12,349
six knows one the measure

4359
03:26:37,602 --> 03:26:38,139
passes. Okay. Members were

4360
03:26:38,139 --> 03:26:41,139
moving back to motions and

4361
03:26:44,945 --> 03:26:46,945
resolutions. Centers jackson

4362
03:26:49,818 --> 03:26:51,419
are you prepared. The President

4363
03:26:51,419 --> 03:26:54,419
Under motions and resolutions I

4364
03:26:55,561 --> 03:26:56,530
request unanimous consent to

4365
03:26:56,530 --> 03:26:57,622
return sb one eighty two to the

4366
03:26:57,622 --> 03:27:00,220
assembly for further action.

4367
03:27:02,156 --> 03:27:02,660
Does will know. Any additional

4368
03:27:02,660 --> 03:27:05,600
items under motions and

4369
03:27:05,699 --> 03:27:07,698
resolutions. Hearing to none

4370
03:27:07,698 --> 03:27:09,466
were moving back to assembly

4371
03:27:09,466 --> 03:27:11,637
concurrence were moving to file

4372
03:27:11,637 --> 03:27:14,637
item three center winner are

4373
03:27:17,373 --> 03:27:19,773
you prepared. Mister Secretary

4374
03:27:21,144 --> 03:27:21,777
please you breed dyed senate

4375
03:27:21,777 --> 03:27:22,275
bill two sixty eight by senator

4376
03:27:22,275 --> 03:27:24,675
winner and actually new

4377
03:27:26,279 --> 03:27:29,251
elections winner. I thank you

4378
03:27:29,251 --> 03:27:32,251
very much Mister President how

4379
03:27:32,318 --> 03:27:34,756
colleagues sb to sixty eight is

4380
03:27:34,756 --> 03:27:37,492
a bill to ensure that when

4381
03:27:37,492 --> 03:27:38,894
parcel taxes in bonds from

4382
03:27:38,894 --> 03:27:40,929
local government entities go to

4383
03:27:40,929 --> 03:27:42,100
the voters that the voters have

4384
03:27:42,100 --> 03:27:44,100
complete and accurate

4385
03:27:44,997 --> 03:27:47,397
information about those ballot

4386
03:27:47,399 --> 03:27:49,399
measures under legislation

4387
03:27:50,400 --> 03:27:52,107
passed a few years ago. The

4388
03:27:52,107 --> 03:27:52,772
requirement is that in the

4389
03:27:52,772 --> 03:27:55,770
seventy five word ballot

4390
03:27:55,770 --> 03:27:57,477
question by governments are

4391
03:27:57,781 --> 03:28:00,144
required to put quorum court

4392
03:28:00,144 --> 03:28:02,916
how much people will pay the

4393
03:28:02,916 --> 03:28:05,782
problem is that four tiered

4394
03:28:05,782 --> 03:28:07,753
parcel taxes it's impossible to

4395
03:28:07,753 --> 03:28:08,921
fit that information within

4396
03:28:08,921 --> 03:28:10,355
seventy five words and for

4397
03:28:10,355 --> 03:28:12,290
bonds it's completely

4398
03:28:12,290 --> 03:28:14,725
speculative because you do not

4399
03:28:14,725 --> 03:28:15,963
know how much people will pay

4400
03:28:15,963 --> 03:28:17,831
until you actually sell the

4401
03:28:17,831 --> 03:28:20,231
bond at a particular interest

4402
03:28:20,231 --> 03:28:23,231
rate which is impossible to

4403
03:28:23,898 --> 03:28:27,498
predict at the time the voters

4404
03:28:28,538 --> 03:28:29,506
are voting. On the measure. Hi

4405
03:28:29,506 --> 03:28:30,240
sir sb two sixty eight will

4406
03:28:30,240 --> 03:28:31,338
address this problem. By moving

4407
03:28:31,338 --> 03:28:32,412
that information a require even

4408
03:28:32,412 --> 03:28:34,610
more information than currently

4409
03:28:34,610 --> 03:28:37,830
required and voter guide. And

4410
03:28:37,830 --> 03:28:38,378
by requiring a parenthetical

4411
03:28:38,378 --> 03:28:40,816
within the seventy five word

4412
03:28:40,816 --> 03:28:43,122
ballot question that will state

4413
03:28:43,122 --> 03:28:45,180
quote see voter guide for tax

4414
03:28:45,180 --> 03:28:46,388
rate information the voters

4415
03:28:46,388 --> 03:28:47,620
will be referred to the voter

4416
03:28:47,620 --> 03:28:49,758
guide it will be clear that

4417
03:28:49,758 --> 03:28:51,327
it's a tax. By and they will be

4418
03:28:51,327 --> 03:28:53,827
able to get all the information

4419
03:28:53,827 --> 03:28:56,229
they need and we will be able

4420
03:28:56,229 --> 03:28:57,864
to have comprehensible seventy

4421
03:28:57,864 --> 03:28:59,432
five word ballot questions and

4422
03:28:59,432 --> 03:29:01,340
cities and school districts and

4423
03:29:01,340 --> 03:29:03,200
counties will continue to be

4424
03:29:03,200 --> 03:29:05,402
able to have. Progressive

4425
03:29:05,971 --> 03:29:06,536
tiered parcel taxes I

4426
03:29:06,536 --> 03:29:09,536
respectfully ask for an aye

4427
03:29:10,342 --> 03:29:12,814
vote. Thank you any for the

4428
03:29:12,814 --> 03:29:14,120
description of it on this item.

4429
03:29:14,120 --> 03:29:15,847
Miss Secretary please call the

4430
03:29:15,847 --> 03:29:18,847
roll allen. Hi archuleta aye

4431
03:29:19,784 --> 03:29:22,784
atkins aye bates. Nobel I

4432
03:29:23,688 --> 03:29:26,688
porges hi bradford. I cambiado

4433
03:29:27,959 --> 03:29:32,159
I ting. No daly no dodd. I

4434
03:29:34,630 --> 03:29:36,463
dorado johnny no glazer.

4435
03:29:38,500 --> 03:29:41,500
Gonzalez hi growth no hertzberg.

4436
03:29:41,970 --> 03:29:45,570
I hill aye hueso hi title.

4437
03:29:48,977 --> 03:29:51,977
Jackson jones. No leyva aye

4438
03:29:52,147 --> 03:29:52,713
mcguire aye mitchell aye

4439
03:29:52,713 --> 03:29:55,113
monning aye moorlach number

4440
03:29:56,784 --> 03:30:00,384
rail. No nielsen no pan aye

4441
03:30:01,652 --> 03:30:04,652
portantino I roth. Rubio I

4442
03:30:07,564 --> 03:30:10,564
skinner I stern aye stone

4443
03:30:11,990 --> 03:30:14,699
November hi my county winner hi

4444
03:30:14,901 --> 03:30:15,635
wilk. No this is Miss Sector

4445
03:30:15,635 --> 03:30:18,635
please call the absent members.

4446
03:30:24,542 --> 03:30:27,542
Glazer tado. Jackson by roth.

4447
03:30:33,160 --> 03:30:34,517
Gorgeous I don't know. Price

4448
03:30:34,517 --> 03:30:35,985
twenty five knows twelve the

4449
03:30:35,985 --> 03:30:37,953
senate assembly member are

4450
03:30:37,953 --> 03:30:40,220
concurred and now we're moving

4451
03:30:40,220 --> 03:30:42,224
on to a file item for center on

4452
03:30:42,224 --> 03:30:44,124
burke I see he's ready Mister

4453
03:30:44,124 --> 03:30:45,594
Secretary you May read senate

4454
03:30:45,594 --> 03:30:47,327
bill six ninety six with

4455
03:30:47,327 --> 03:30:49,727
senator umberg enact really

4456
03:30:49,832 --> 03:30:50,363
into elections and declared

4457
03:30:50,363 --> 03:30:52,763
throughout the take effect

4458
03:30:52,965 --> 03:30:53,566
immediately on burke. Thank you

4459
03:30:53,566 --> 03:30:55,941
Mister President colleagues of

4460
03:30:55,941 --> 03:30:57,906
the-most rapidly growing

4461
03:30:57,906 --> 03:30:59,107
segment of the voter population

4462
03:30:59,107 --> 03:31:01,176
terms of registration is no

4463
03:31:01,176 --> 03:31:02,411
party preferenceunfortunately

4464
03:31:02,411 --> 03:31:04,790
there's a great deal of

4465
03:31:04,790 --> 03:31:05,358
confusion in california and we

4466
03:31:05,358 --> 03:31:07,159
are the only state that that

4467
03:31:07,159 --> 03:31:09,417
actually permits this on the

4468
03:31:09,417 --> 03:31:11,418
confusion exists because one of

4469
03:31:11,418 --> 03:31:11,986
the parties that one can

4470
03:31:11,986 --> 03:31:14,255
register for is called the

4471
03:31:14,255 --> 03:31:15,889
american independent party. A

4472
03:31:15,889 --> 03:31:17,794
great number of folks as was

4473
03:31:17,794 --> 03:31:19,592
illustrated in various polls

4474
03:31:19,592 --> 03:31:20,993
who register as american

4475
03:31:20,993 --> 03:31:22,462
independent party members

4476
03:31:22,462 --> 03:31:24,862
actually think the registering

4477
03:31:25,630 --> 03:31:27,131
as independence or what is now

4478
03:31:27,131 --> 03:31:28,636
termed as no party preference

4479
03:31:28,636 --> 03:31:30,232
that is not the case the

4480
03:31:30,232 --> 03:31:31,541
consequences of registering is

4481
03:31:31,541 --> 03:31:33,771
an american independent party

4482
03:31:33,771 --> 03:31:34,672
member when you think you're

4483
03:31:34,672 --> 03:31:36,440
registering as an actual

4484
03:31:36,440 --> 03:31:38,750
independent. One of the

4485
03:31:38,750 --> 03:31:39,674
consequences you can't vote so

4486
03:31:39,674 --> 03:31:41,409
for example in the democratic

4487
03:31:41,409 --> 03:31:43,409
primary presidential primary

4488
03:31:43,411 --> 03:31:46,810
for President With this bill

4489
03:31:46,810 --> 03:31:48,182
does is simply says that you

4490
03:31:48,182 --> 03:31:50,182
can't have a party that has the

4491
03:31:50,182 --> 03:31:52,286
word independent or decline to

4492
03:31:52,286 --> 03:31:53,524
state or no party preference or

4493
03:31:53,524 --> 03:31:55,556
variation of those words in the

4494
03:31:55,556 --> 03:31:57,124
designation. In order to make

4495
03:31:57,124 --> 03:31:59,526
sure that the folks who want to

4496
03:31:59,526 --> 03:32:00,763
register as independence that

4497
03:32:00,763 --> 03:32:03,931
they register as eight and are

4498
03:32:03,931 --> 03:32:06,366
no party preference person you

4499
03:32:06,366 --> 03:32:08,766
can't create misleading titles

4500
03:32:09,736 --> 03:32:11,771
that. Are for example connected

4501
03:32:11,771 --> 03:32:13,242
the democratic or republican

4502
03:32:13,242 --> 03:32:14,441
party you couldn't say you're

4503
03:32:14,441 --> 03:32:16,841
an american democratic party

4504
03:32:18,679 --> 03:32:19,644
member or a republican american

4505
03:32:19,644 --> 03:32:21,279
party member because that would

4506
03:32:21,279 --> 03:32:24,820
e confusing hello this bill

4507
03:32:24,820 --> 03:32:25,830
does is it simply says that you

4508
03:32:25,830 --> 03:32:27,382
May not use the word

4509
03:32:27,382 --> 03:32:30,382
independent decline to state or

4510
03:32:31,155 --> 03:32:31,656
no party preference in the

4511
03:32:31,656 --> 03:32:34,560
title. Of a-local party

4512
03:32:39,963 --> 03:32:40,664
tonight. Surgery prepare on the

4513
03:32:40,664 --> 03:32:41,965
yeah yeah very much should just

4514
03:32:41,965 --> 03:32:42,116
in support of the measure

4515
03:32:42,116 --> 03:32:43,130
-

4516
03:32:43,130 --> 03:32:44,234
before us senate romberg it you

4517
03:32:44,234 --> 03:32:46,470
know in in two thousand sixteen

4518
03:32:46,470 --> 03:32:47,370
the los angeles times to the

4519
03:32:47,370 --> 03:32:50,370
study. The story where they

4520
03:32:50,208 --> 03:32:51,608
found that. 73% of the people

4521
03:32:51,608 --> 03:32:53,543
who signed up for the american

4522
03:32:53,543 --> 03:32:55,144
independent party on mistakenly

4523
03:32:55,144 --> 03:32:57,800
thought that they were being on

4524
03:32:57,800 --> 03:32:58,681
affiliated goes to the point.

4525
03:32:58,681 --> 03:33:01,549
That was made in the

4526
03:33:01,549 --> 03:33:02,149
presentation about the

4527
03:33:02,149 --> 03:33:04,785
confusion and the only point I

4528
03:33:04,785 --> 03:33:07,323
want to add is. You don't. Fish

4529
03:33:07,323 --> 03:33:08,722
right to vote. All of the

4530
03:33:08,722 --> 03:33:11,191
things that we're doing around

4531
03:33:11,191 --> 03:33:13,393
voting. To enhance it to make

4532
03:33:13,393 --> 03:33:15,396
it easier to give people

4533
03:33:15,396 --> 03:33:17,597
options to participate in

4534
03:33:17,597 --> 03:33:19,599
everything that we do. Nothing

4535
03:33:19,599 --> 03:33:21,531
is more important than making

4536
03:33:21,531 --> 03:33:24,360
sure there's no confusion in

4537
03:33:24,360 --> 03:33:27,170
the process and when you have

4538
03:33:27,170 --> 03:33:28,171
73% of the people. Who actually

4539
03:33:28,171 --> 03:33:29,341
thought that they were a part

4540
03:33:29,341 --> 03:33:30,807
part of a note no party

4541
03:33:30,807 --> 03:33:33,450
preference when in fact this

4542
03:33:33,450 --> 03:33:34,546
party is the party that nominee

4543
03:33:34,546 --> 03:33:35,845
in nineteen sixty eight was

4544
03:33:35,845 --> 03:33:37,847
george wallace. I don't make

4545
03:33:37,847 --> 03:33:39,480
that for a statement about

4546
03:33:39,480 --> 03:33:40,151
whether on one side or the

4547
03:33:40,151 --> 03:33:41,250
other I just make it for a

4548
03:33:41,250 --> 03:33:43,850
statement that I suspected

4549
03:33:43,850 --> 03:33:44,255
people knew that. And knew what

4550
03:33:44,255 --> 03:33:45,790
the political philosophy of

4551
03:33:45,790 --> 03:33:47,225
that party was that used the

4552
03:33:47,225 --> 03:33:49,625
word independent. That there

4553
03:33:51,290 --> 03:33:51,593
was clear confusion I was

4554
03:33:51,593 --> 03:33:54,593
supported by the los angeles

4555
03:33:55,970 --> 03:33:57,532
times last year I vote. Thank

4556
03:33:57,532 --> 03:33:58,703
you senator morlock. Thank you

4557
03:33:58,703 --> 03:33:59,301
Mister President I rise in

4558
03:33:59,301 --> 03:34:02,301
opposition to senate bill six

4559
03:34:03,338 --> 03:34:06,400
nine six and. I wrote it this

4560
03:34:06,400 --> 03:34:08,404
morning before fashion started.

4561
03:34:10,151 --> 03:34:10,614
But I see sb six nine six as a

4562
03:34:10,614 --> 03:34:12,614
blatantly oppressive and

4563
03:34:13,180 --> 03:34:15,580
tyrannical maneuver. But what's

4564
03:34:18,452 --> 03:34:21,452
new. About strong arming in

4565
03:34:22,210 --> 03:34:23,891
this chamber call exist

4566
03:34:23,891 --> 03:34:25,860
legislature has gone after one

4567
03:34:25,860 --> 03:34:27,295
positions who are trying to

4568
03:34:27,295 --> 03:34:28,763
protect infants against

4569
03:34:28,763 --> 03:34:30,865
vaccines they May be severely

4570
03:34:30,865 --> 03:34:32,864
allergic to those who hunt

4571
03:34:32,864 --> 03:34:34,498
bobcats three spiritual

4572
03:34:34,498 --> 03:34:36,233
counselors who are perceived to

4573
03:34:36,233 --> 03:34:38,736
be addressing the topic of

4574
03:34:38,736 --> 03:34:40,105
conversion therapy for the for

4575
03:34:40,105 --> 03:34:42,940
industry in california five the

4576
03:34:42,940 --> 03:34:45,407
gig economy I'll stop there. It

4577
03:34:45,407 --> 03:34:46,941
only makes sense to go after.

4578
03:34:46,941 --> 03:34:47,675
An entire political party now I

4579
03:34:47,675 --> 03:34:49,610
not we're having such a good

4580
03:34:49,610 --> 03:34:51,120
role this year. This

4581
03:34:51,120 --> 03:34:53,183
legislature is bold in its

4582
03:34:53,183 --> 03:34:55,490
bullying go boulder global go

4583
03:34:55,490 --> 03:34:57,418
home I guess but this but this

4584
03:34:57,418 --> 03:34:57,985
is center mark we're gonna

4585
03:34:57,985 --> 03:35:01,585
shoes speak to the merits of

4586
03:35:01,889 --> 03:35:04,889
the bill. Thank you Mister

4587
03:35:07,864 --> 03:35:10,500
President do a great job. The

4588
03:35:10,500 --> 03:35:11,670
definition of bali is to seek

4589
03:35:11,670 --> 03:35:13,797
to harm intimidate or coerce

4590
03:35:13,797 --> 03:35:15,235
someone perceived as vulnerable.

4591
03:35:15,235 --> 03:35:17,270
Can decimate the a. I. P.'s

4592
03:35:17,270 --> 03:35:20,730
name because can but the optics

4593
03:35:20,730 --> 03:35:23,730
mac the political bullying. And

4594
03:35:23,809 --> 03:35:27,216
we make laws to stop bullying.

4595
03:35:27,216 --> 03:35:28,580
How ironic. Instead of

4596
03:35:28,580 --> 03:35:30,549
encouraging citizens to do a

4597
03:35:30,549 --> 03:35:32,384
little research take a civics

4598
03:35:32,384 --> 03:35:32,985
tutorial anything to prevent

4599
03:35:32,985 --> 03:35:34,985
them from embarrassing

4600
03:35:35,820 --> 03:35:36,421
themselves sacramento takes

4601
03:35:36,421 --> 03:35:39,290
away the potential because of

4602
03:35:39,290 --> 03:35:41,690
someone's looking inept. The

4603
03:35:41,757 --> 03:35:44,828
art of which we're asking to

4604
03:35:44,828 --> 03:35:45,429
speak to the merits of the bill.

4605
03:35:45,429 --> 03:35:48,368
Thank you Mister President one

4606
03:35:48,368 --> 03:35:50,801
of our Mister President. By

4607
03:35:50,801 --> 03:35:52,370
workplace sooner jones. Thank

4608
03:35:52,370 --> 03:35:54,536
you Mister President make you

4609
03:35:54,536 --> 03:35:55,673
point another point is I

4610
03:35:55,673 --> 03:35:56,570
understood that there was a

4611
03:35:56,570 --> 03:35:58,277
point of order on the other

4612
03:35:58,277 --> 03:35:59,373
side of the chambers I'm not

4613
03:35:59,373 --> 03:36:01,711
sure that the point of order

4614
03:36:01,711 --> 03:36:02,778
was recognized. And if the

4615
03:36:02,778 --> 03:36:05,313
person making the point of

4616
03:36:05,313 --> 03:36:05,880
order would like to rise and

4617
03:36:05,880 --> 03:36:06,514
give their point of order I

4618
03:36:06,514 --> 03:36:09,120
think that would be appropriate

4619
03:36:09,120 --> 03:36:11,989
for the chamber. Center jacqui

4620
03:36:11,989 --> 03:36:13,251
smith below is a point of order

4621
03:36:13,251 --> 03:36:15,556
this is not your main to the

4622
03:36:15,556 --> 03:36:16,590
essence of the bill we had a

4623
03:36:16,590 --> 03:36:18,489
discussion earlier this morning

4624
03:36:18,489 --> 03:36:19,529
about flame throwing

4625
03:36:19,529 --> 03:36:21,529
respectfully from the

4626
03:36:21,662 --> 03:36:24,620
opposition from the minority

4627
03:36:24,601 --> 03:36:26,499
leader wells well taken and it

4628
03:36:26,499 --> 03:36:27,902
has to be applied by both sides

4629
03:36:27,902 --> 03:36:30,300
I am objecting is a point of

4630
03:36:30,300 --> 03:36:32,338
order that the discussion now

4631
03:36:32,338 --> 03:36:34,340
is flame throwing against the

4632
03:36:34,340 --> 03:36:36,475
party in power it is not about

4633
03:36:36,475 --> 03:36:39,378
the issue in the bill entry.

4634
03:36:39,378 --> 03:36:39,847
Before us today and it's that

4635
03:36:39,847 --> 03:36:42,847
basis upon which I am

4636
03:36:56,250 --> 03:36:58,250
projection

4637
03:37:02,784 --> 03:37:04,784
. Thank you. The

4638
03:37:05,104 --> 03:37:05,668
point of order is well taken

4639
03:37:05,668 --> 03:37:06,235
and we're still gonna should

4640
03:37:06,235 --> 03:37:07,903
remain to the subject of the

4641
03:37:07,903 --> 03:37:10,903
bill. President I apologize for

4642
03:37:11,909 --> 03:37:12,875
the. Disturbance that I've

4643
03:37:12,875 --> 03:37:13,742
caused I did not mean to do

4644
03:37:13,742 --> 03:37:15,611
that I just want to make a

4645
03:37:15,611 --> 03:37:16,211
point of conclude by saying

4646
03:37:16,211 --> 03:37:18,611
that the american independent

4647
03:37:18,613 --> 03:37:21,613
party. Has been around longer

4648
03:37:24,120 --> 03:37:26,954
than many of us have been alive.

4649
03:37:26,954 --> 03:37:27,588
I think it's a strange tactic

4650
03:37:27,588 --> 03:37:31,188
Mister President I think it's a

4651
03:37:32,270 --> 03:37:34,162
shame. Thank you very much.

4652
03:37:34,162 --> 03:37:34,762
Thank you any further

4653
03:37:34,762 --> 03:37:37,762
discussion and debate on this

4654
03:37:39,598 --> 03:37:40,232
item yes. Yes. Consider borders

4655
03:37:40,232 --> 03:37:43,938
I concede so you might think it

4656
03:37:43,938 --> 03:37:45,640
was President. I have to admit.

4657
03:37:45,640 --> 03:37:48,439
When I look at party

4658
03:37:48,439 --> 03:37:50,374
designations I get confused.

4659
03:37:50,374 --> 03:37:51,509
When I see american independent

4660
03:37:51,509 --> 03:37:53,711
are the independent is it some

4661
03:37:53,711 --> 03:37:56,460
other organization the lot of

4662
03:37:56,460 --> 03:37:56,648
these things are misleading and

4663
03:37:56,648 --> 03:38:00,150
we had an issue not that long

4664
03:38:00,150 --> 03:38:03,486
ago on. How do we protect the

4665
03:38:03,486 --> 03:38:05,886
first amendment rights well

4666
03:38:06,591 --> 03:38:08,424
still preserving our-our our

4667
03:38:08,424 --> 03:38:09,389
democratic process or or the

4668
03:38:09,389 --> 03:38:11,789
integrity of the voting

4669
03:38:12,495 --> 03:38:15,193
process. It seems like we tried

4670
03:38:15,193 --> 03:38:18,193
to nearly tailor our solutions.

4671
03:38:18,368 --> 03:38:18,966
But this one seems to have the

4672
03:38:18,966 --> 03:38:21,966
opportunity that May have been

4673
03:38:22,906 --> 03:38:25,500
missed. Would it not have been.

4674
03:38:25,500 --> 03:38:28,500
More helpful to protect the

4675
03:38:28,174 --> 03:38:30,440
integrity of our process by

4676
03:38:30,440 --> 03:38:31,978
requesting or even mandating

4677
03:38:31,978 --> 03:38:34,383
for that matter I disclosure on

4678
03:38:34,383 --> 03:38:37,383
any forms that says the

4679
03:38:37,650 --> 03:38:39,385
american independent party is.

4680
03:38:39,385 --> 03:38:41,723
A party that doesn't

4681
03:38:41,723 --> 03:38:43,822
necessarily identify itself as

4682
03:38:43,822 --> 03:38:46,222
independent or some variation

4683
03:38:46,692 --> 03:38:48,591
thereof that informs the public

4684
03:38:48,591 --> 03:38:51,130
that the title the reading May

4685
03:38:51,130 --> 03:38:53,999
not be is as accurate as the

4686
03:38:53,999 --> 03:38:54,666
label that they're interpreting.

4687
03:38:54,666 --> 03:38:55,937
So what I'm what I'm getting at

4688
03:38:55,937 --> 03:38:58,738
with all of this is that there

4689
03:38:58,738 --> 03:39:01,206
is a solution to the problem

4690
03:39:01,206 --> 03:39:03,975
but the bill here. I don't

4691
03:39:03,975 --> 03:39:06,744
think it is it is satisfactory

4692
03:39:06,744 --> 03:39:09,280
so I guess I'm all allen here

4693
03:39:09,280 --> 03:39:12,416
that this is it this could be

4694
03:39:12,416 --> 03:39:13,170
the right step forward but it's

4695
03:39:13,170 --> 03:39:15,417
not drafted. Appropriately my

4696
03:39:17,155 --> 03:39:19,555
opinion. Thank you. Any

4697
03:39:20,724 --> 03:39:23,124
additional script senator bates.

4698
03:39:24,961 --> 03:39:25,530
Low mileage. Thank you Mister

4699
03:39:25,530 --> 03:39:28,530
President a question for the

4700
03:39:29,166 --> 03:39:31,566
author. Senator bob hertzberg

4701
03:39:31,567 --> 03:39:32,168
would you take the question I'm

4702
03:39:32,168 --> 03:39:35,304
certain will be the high point

4703
03:39:35,304 --> 03:39:37,103
of my day yes. Surveys and

4704
03:39:37,103 --> 03:39:38,542
messy because a good senator

4705
03:39:38,542 --> 03:39:41,642
from laguna miguel is asking it

4706
03:39:41,642 --> 03:39:42,741
right. Anyway I am I'm curious

4707
03:39:42,741 --> 03:39:44,743
as to whether the american

4708
03:39:44,743 --> 03:39:47,143
independent party as a

4709
03:39:47,281 --> 03:39:49,500
designation of a party exist

4710
03:39:49,500 --> 03:39:50,982
across the nation or just in

4711
03:39:50,982 --> 03:39:53,889
the state of california. But

4712
03:39:53,889 --> 03:39:54,454
just in the state of california

4713
03:39:54,454 --> 03:39:58,220
just from the thank you that

4714
03:39:58,220 --> 03:39:58,622
was my question. Thank you. Any

4715
03:39:58,622 --> 03:40:01,220
addition discussions debate on

4716
03:40:02,832 --> 03:40:03,396
this item. Nineteen nine center

4717
03:40:03,396 --> 03:40:05,698
on burke would you like to

4718
03:40:05,698 --> 03:40:08,698
close thank you Miss Present

4719
03:40:08,936 --> 03:40:11,137
and to further respond to my

4720
03:40:11,137 --> 03:40:14,137
good friend the senator from

4721
03:40:19,142 --> 03:40:20,512
laguna miguel. We're talking

4722
03:40:20,512 --> 03:40:23,820
about here today terms of a

4723
03:40:23,820 --> 03:40:24,416
party designation this this

4724
03:40:24,416 --> 03:40:26,816
bill is enjoyed bipartisan

4725
03:40:27,385 --> 03:40:28,987
support in the assembly in fact

4726
03:40:28,987 --> 03:40:31,189
I think is 20% the republican

4727
03:40:31,189 --> 03:40:32,957
caucus actually voted for it.

4728
03:40:32,957 --> 03:40:33,858
It is endorsed and supported by

4729
03:40:33,858 --> 03:40:35,791
the association of county

4730
03:40:35,791 --> 03:40:37,960
clerks and election officials

4731
03:40:37,960 --> 03:40:39,398
in it goes to our interests our

4732
03:40:39,398 --> 03:40:40,396
collective interests and in

4733
03:40:40,396 --> 03:40:42,310
ensuring that that voters

4734
03:40:42,310 --> 03:40:43,335
aren't misled. When you go to

4735
03:40:43,335 --> 03:40:45,436
the dmv and you have an

4736
03:40:45,436 --> 03:40:46,299
opportunity to choose a party

4737
03:40:46,299 --> 03:40:48,299
american independent party

4738
03:40:48,870 --> 03:40:51,176
starts is the first party. Of

4739
03:40:51,176 --> 03:40:52,738
using your independent. Can you

4740
03:40:52,738 --> 03:40:54,420
check american independent

4741
03:40:54,420 --> 03:40:55,209
party and that's why we've seen

4742
03:40:55,209 --> 03:40:57,248
at least I think that's what we

4743
03:40:57,248 --> 03:40:59,947
see in. Its growth being so

4744
03:40:59,947 --> 03:41:01,580
dramatic in the last few years.

4745
03:41:01,580 --> 03:41:03,754
If the party which is to be the

4746
03:41:03,754 --> 03:41:04,385
american party they May do so.

4747
03:41:04,385 --> 03:41:05,919
If they wish to be the

4748
03:41:05,919 --> 03:41:07,722
constitutional party which is

4749
03:41:07,722 --> 03:41:09,690
sort of their derivation other

4750
03:41:09,690 --> 03:41:10,824
states they May do so but what

4751
03:41:10,824 --> 03:41:12,926
they can't do is they can't

4752
03:41:12,926 --> 03:41:15,162
confuse voters. By choosing a

4753
03:41:15,162 --> 03:41:16,963
name that many people associate

4754
03:41:16,963 --> 03:41:18,599
with being independent when in

4755
03:41:18,599 --> 03:41:22,199
fact they are not. Here tonight

4756
03:41:22,970 --> 03:41:23,503
vote. Thank you August bait

4757
03:41:23,503 --> 03:41:24,535
inscription having season

4758
03:41:24,535 --> 03:41:27,535
sector please call the roll.

4759
03:41:29,410 --> 03:41:32,410
Allen archuleta by atkins aye

4760
03:41:35,679 --> 03:41:38,679
bates. Nobel hi burgess no

4761
03:41:40,353 --> 03:41:43,353
bradford I cambiado. I chiang

4762
03:41:44,421 --> 03:41:45,989
no daly no dodd I dorado aye

4763
03:41:45,989 --> 03:41:48,389
galgiani aye glazer aye

4764
03:41:51,831 --> 03:41:54,231
gonzalez. I growth. No

4765
03:41:55,295 --> 03:41:58,895
hertzberg aye hill aye hueso I

4766
03:41:59,238 --> 03:42:02,838
tado I jackson aye jones no

4767
03:42:03,405 --> 03:42:07,605
leyva. I am a choir hi mitchell.

4768
03:42:08,310 --> 03:42:11,310
Hi monning. I'm more luck

4769
03:42:12,684 --> 03:42:15,486
number rail no nielsen no pan

4770
03:42:15,486 --> 03:42:18,485
aye portantino aye roth aye

4771
03:42:18,485 --> 03:42:22,850
rubio aye skinner aye stern aye

4772
03:42:23,624 --> 03:42:26,624
stone. No burke caskey by

4773
03:42:27,562 --> 03:42:29,828
wiener aye wilk. No sooner

4774
03:42:29,828 --> 03:42:31,763
umberg moves a call next up is

4775
03:42:31,763 --> 03:42:33,529
file item five center leyva are

4776
03:42:33,529 --> 03:42:35,400
you prepared for this item she

4777
03:42:35,400 --> 03:42:37,566
is Mister Secretary you May

4778
03:42:37,566 --> 03:42:38,767
read senate bill two ten by

4779
03:42:38,767 --> 03:42:39,871
senator leyva an act relating

4780
03:42:39,871 --> 03:42:41,806
to be cooler air pollution

4781
03:42:41,806 --> 03:42:42,874
center leyva thank you Mister

4782
03:42:42,874 --> 03:42:44,840
President good afternoon

4783
03:42:44,840 --> 03:42:46,875
members sb two tennis back on

4784
03:42:46,875 --> 03:42:48,443
concurrence amendments taken in

4785
03:42:48,443 --> 03:42:49,477
the assembly member move the

4786
03:42:49,477 --> 03:42:51,312
opposition from the california

4787
03:42:51,312 --> 03:42:53,312
trucking association among

4788
03:42:53,445 --> 03:42:55,445
others specifically amendments

4789
03:42:57,482 --> 03:43:00,482
were taken to. Remove duplicate

4790
03:43:00,555 --> 03:43:01,926
duplicative testing regulations.

4791
03:43:01,926 --> 03:43:04,580
Cap the program be at thirty

4792
03:43:04,580 --> 03:43:05,123
sorry a little cold. Ensure the

4793
03:43:05,123 --> 03:43:07,194
legislature has tools for

4794
03:43:07,194 --> 03:43:08,699
accountability and oversight

4795
03:43:08,699 --> 03:43:10,664
provide reasonable pathways for

4796
03:43:10,664 --> 03:43:12,535
industry compliance we work

4797
03:43:12,535 --> 03:43:14,534
closely with cta the ag

4798
03:43:14,534 --> 03:43:16,538
community air quality of the

4799
03:43:16,538 --> 03:43:17,771
kids to help insure compliance

4800
03:43:17,771 --> 03:43:19,472
while improving the state's air

4801
03:43:19,472 --> 03:43:20,841
quality. I want to thank both

4802
03:43:20,841 --> 03:43:23,142
houses for all of their hard

4803
03:43:23,142 --> 03:43:25,110
work over the past three years

4804
03:43:25,110 --> 03:43:26,880
to make sb two ten a balanced

4805
03:43:26,880 --> 03:43:29,280
major than improves public

4806
03:43:31,150 --> 03:43:31,584
health and provides clean air

4807
03:43:31,584 --> 03:43:32,154
for all californians

4808
03:43:32,154 --> 03:43:35,154
respectfully ask for an aye

4809
03:43:37,220 --> 03:43:38,557
vote. Thank you sooner dally.

4810
03:43:38,557 --> 03:43:40,294
The measure present members I

4811
03:43:40,294 --> 03:43:42,861
have to rise in opposition and

4812
03:43:42,861 --> 03:43:44,362
I didn't have the opportunity

4813
03:43:44,362 --> 03:43:46,300
to wait until we have the

4814
03:43:46,300 --> 03:43:48,797
hearing yesterday on this bill

4815
03:43:48,797 --> 03:43:50,535
and as you know I am in the

4816
03:43:50,535 --> 03:43:52,102
trucking business and wanted

4817
03:43:52,102 --> 03:43:54,505
just share I know this bill's

4818
03:43:54,505 --> 03:43:55,108
going to get out but I want to

4819
03:43:55,108 --> 03:43:56,807
share with you what it's going

4820
03:43:56,807 --> 03:43:58,741
to how it's going to impact.

4821
03:43:58,741 --> 03:44:01,741
The small owner operator in

4822
03:44:01,844 --> 03:44:02,878
into in yup the little guy and

4823
03:44:02,878 --> 03:44:05,511
those who have been really

4824
03:44:05,511 --> 03:44:07,585
affected by ab five in in

4825
03:44:07,585 --> 03:44:10,585
recent legislation as well. The

4826
03:44:11,727 --> 03:44:12,387
reason that the cda is off is

4827
03:44:12,387 --> 03:44:13,390
because-the bill states that

4828
03:44:13,390 --> 03:44:16,570
if you have a brand new vehicle

4829
03:44:16,570 --> 03:44:18,259
you don't have to have. Your

4830
03:44:18,259 --> 03:44:20,161
smog check every two years you

4831
03:44:20,161 --> 03:44:23,330
get a for your pass. Most your

4832
03:44:23,330 --> 03:44:25,730
large trucking companies. Big

4833
03:44:25,736 --> 03:44:28,136
business. Least trucks any

4834
03:44:28,969 --> 03:44:29,570
leeson for four years but-

4835
03:44:29,570 --> 03:44:30,303
three or four hundred thousand

4836
03:44:30,303 --> 03:44:33,100
miles on them and then they

4837
03:44:33,100 --> 03:44:35,143
turn at least in. And they then

4838
03:44:35,143 --> 03:44:38,743
are sold typically do guys like

4839
03:44:39,285 --> 03:44:39,523
me who can't afford to buy a

4840
03:44:39,523 --> 03:44:41,311
new one. Even a used truck can

4841
03:44:41,311 --> 03:44:41,912
be round with the last one I

4842
03:44:41,912 --> 03:44:44,684
purchased was about a hundred

4843
03:44:44,684 --> 03:44:46,180
twenty thousand dollars.

4844
03:44:46,180 --> 03:44:48,418
Additionally if your check

4845
03:44:48,852 --> 03:44:50,854
engine light comes on. You're

4846
03:44:50,854 --> 03:44:52,756
gonna have to go get that that

4847
03:44:52,756 --> 03:44:54,157
you have seventy five days for

4848
03:44:54,157 --> 03:44:56,126
act to go get it checked but I

4849
03:44:56,126 --> 03:44:57,897
wanted to share with you that

4850
03:44:57,897 --> 03:45:00,530
there are like a hundred and

4851
03:45:00,530 --> 03:45:02,331
fifty sensors. On these trucks.

4852
03:45:02,331 --> 03:45:05,340
Now on the most recent truck

4853
03:45:05,340 --> 03:45:07,203
that I. Have purchased. I've

4854
03:45:07,203 --> 03:45:07,807
had it to the shop several

4855
03:45:07,807 --> 03:45:10,273
times because I've had a check

4856
03:45:10,273 --> 03:45:12,775
engine light on. In the truck

4857
03:45:12,775 --> 03:45:13,344
seem to be performing well. But

4858
03:45:13,344 --> 03:45:16,344
it's the sensor itself that

4859
03:45:17,913 --> 03:45:19,382
goes out. From six hundred to a

4860
03:45:19,382 --> 03:45:20,249
thousand dollars is the bill

4861
03:45:20,249 --> 03:45:22,818
every time I have to go in and

4862
03:45:22,818 --> 03:45:24,953
have that checked out. Now the

4863
03:45:24,953 --> 03:45:26,121
truck I used to own the older

4864
03:45:26,121 --> 03:45:29,900
trucks that we were able to

4865
03:45:29,900 --> 03:45:30,993
work on ourselves and run for

4866
03:45:30,993 --> 03:45:33,425
years without taking them to

4867
03:45:33,425 --> 03:45:34,664
the dealers. Did not have air

4868
03:45:34,664 --> 03:45:36,964
quality standards we have today

4869
03:45:36,964 --> 03:45:39,330
obviously. But the technology

4870
03:45:39,330 --> 03:45:40,865
now it's changed. Because that

4871
03:45:40,865 --> 03:45:42,660
technologies changed we don't

4872
03:45:42,660 --> 03:45:44,170
have the ability to be able to

4873
03:45:44,170 --> 03:45:47,170
work on our-vehicles as you

4874
03:45:47,373 --> 03:45:48,407
don't your own cars. And so the

4875
03:45:48,407 --> 03:45:50,140
dealers are all for this

4876
03:45:50,140 --> 03:45:52,245
because what does it do it it

4877
03:45:52,245 --> 03:45:53,542
requires you to go in and many

4878
03:45:53,542 --> 03:45:55,383
of you probably have noticed

4879
03:45:55,383 --> 03:45:56,578
that. If you have a car that

4880
03:45:56,578 --> 03:45:58,416
house the sensors that tell you

4881
03:45:58,416 --> 03:46:01,355
how much air is in the in the

4882
03:46:01,355 --> 03:46:02,353
tires it comes on your-dash

4883
03:46:02,353 --> 03:46:04,291
and you have to take it into

4884
03:46:04,291 --> 03:46:05,589
the tire shop. And many times

4885
03:46:05,589 --> 03:46:07,257
it May be just a cold morning

4886
03:46:07,257 --> 03:46:09,493
because it can debts are a hot

4887
03:46:09,493 --> 03:46:12,429
day where you're traveling or

4888
03:46:12,429 --> 03:46:13,333
the sensor goes out. They're

4889
03:46:13,333 --> 03:46:15,166
required by law to not leave

4890
03:46:15,166 --> 03:46:17,665
that that vehicle leave without

4891
03:46:17,665 --> 03:46:19,233
those check engine lights all.

4892
03:46:19,233 --> 03:46:20,568
Which drives acosta for

4893
03:46:20,568 --> 03:46:22,470
everybody even though it's just

4894
03:46:22,470 --> 03:46:23,804
simply a sensor there's nothing

4895
03:46:23,804 --> 03:46:26,173
wrong safety wise you can take

4896
03:46:26,173 --> 03:46:28,175
a gauge and check your tire and

4897
03:46:28,175 --> 03:46:30,480
many times on the trucks. The

4898
03:46:30,480 --> 03:46:31,780
sensor is the problem itself

4899
03:46:31,780 --> 03:46:32,460
it's not the problem with the

4900
03:46:32,460 --> 03:46:35,282
truck so this is going to

4901
03:46:35,282 --> 03:46:37,682
impact. Small operators more

4902
03:46:37,921 --> 03:46:40,170
than it is the big operators

4903
03:46:40,170 --> 03:46:41,491
and it's kind of obvious the-

4904
03:46:41,491 --> 03:46:43,423
promote more cells of trucks

4905
03:46:43,423 --> 03:46:45,255
and that's why the dealers and

4906
03:46:45,255 --> 03:46:47,627
those guys are happy about it

4907
03:46:47,627 --> 03:46:48,827
but they it's going to drive

4908
03:46:48,827 --> 03:46:50,630
the cost up of transportation

4909
03:46:50,630 --> 03:46:51,834
costs in california. Up in

4910
03:46:51,834 --> 03:46:54,497
there is in a minute in the

4911
03:46:54,497 --> 03:46:55,869
bill to the which I think is a

4912
03:46:55,869 --> 03:46:57,238
good part of the bill which I

4913
03:46:57,238 --> 03:46:59,571
will say is that it requires

4914
03:46:59,571 --> 03:46:59,718
out of state truckers to comply

4915
03:46:59,718 --> 03:47:01,314
-

4916
03:47:01,314 --> 03:47:02,571
with california law which will

4917
03:47:02,571 --> 03:47:03,771
help us be a little more

4918
03:47:03,771 --> 03:47:05,409
compared but the end of the

4919
03:47:05,409 --> 03:47:07,750
day. The small guys going to

4920
03:47:07,750 --> 03:47:08,309
get hurt and it's going to

4921
03:47:08,309 --> 03:47:12,509
drive the cost up of living in

4922
03:47:12,610 --> 03:47:13,180
products in california because

4923
03:47:13,180 --> 03:47:13,717
of this piece election so I

4924
03:47:13,717 --> 03:47:16,586
urge. No vote on this bill

4925
03:47:16,586 --> 03:47:20,490
thank you. Thank you any s.

4926
03:47:20,490 --> 03:47:21,860
Senator girl. Thank you Mister

4927
03:47:21,860 --> 03:47:22,121
President a question the author

4928
03:47:22,121 --> 03:47:24,156
yes turner which to question

4929
03:47:24,156 --> 03:47:25,488
absolutely I realize that there

4930
03:47:25,488 --> 03:47:27,529
is an exemption in the bill are

4931
03:47:27,529 --> 03:47:28,730
at there is a an inclusion in

4932
03:47:28,730 --> 03:47:29,461
the bill for out of state

4933
03:47:29,461 --> 03:47:31,326
truckers an out of state

4934
03:47:31,326 --> 03:47:34,326
vehicles that come from across

4935
03:47:34,329 --> 03:47:34,899
state lines is there a also an

4936
03:47:34,899 --> 03:47:37,669
inclusion for out of country

4937
03:47:37,669 --> 03:47:39,167
vehicles. Do you have to have

4938
03:47:39,167 --> 03:47:40,738
an operation you have to help

4939
03:47:40,738 --> 03:47:42,343
go through a smog check. In

4940
03:47:42,343 --> 03:47:43,941
order to receive an operating

4941
03:47:43,941 --> 03:47:45,407
permit in the state of

4942
03:47:45,407 --> 03:47:47,111
california and it would play

4943
03:47:47,111 --> 03:47:48,445
apply to any truck from

4944
03:47:48,445 --> 03:47:49,981
anywhere being driven in the

4945
03:47:49,981 --> 03:47:51,415
city california so if you can't

4946
03:47:51,415 --> 03:47:52,719
your for truck. Whether from

4947
03:47:52,719 --> 03:47:54,517
out of country whether it's

4948
03:47:54,517 --> 03:47:56,283
from out of state. Cannot pass

4949
03:47:56,283 --> 03:47:59,289
a smog check you will not be

4950
03:47:59,289 --> 03:47:59,823
able to register in california

4951
03:47:59,823 --> 03:48:01,759
and obtain an-operator's

4952
03:48:01,759 --> 03:48:04,759
permit. Thank you I appreciate

4953
03:48:04,826 --> 03:48:06,195
that on my own time. We pass

4954
03:48:06,195 --> 03:48:08,290
legislation in this building

4955
03:48:08,290 --> 03:48:09,863
over the fast past ten years

4956
03:48:09,863 --> 03:48:11,396
and it it deals with them you

4957
03:48:11,396 --> 03:48:12,633
know people's freedom like the

4958
03:48:12,633 --> 03:48:14,599
people in the balcony and also

4959
03:48:14,599 --> 03:48:16,300
people's freedom to operate a

4960
03:48:16,300 --> 03:48:18,539
business entering and do when

4961
03:48:18,539 --> 03:48:19,406
you. When you operate a

4962
03:48:19,406 --> 03:48:20,437
business and you have

4963
03:48:20,437 --> 03:48:22,308
legislation that comes through

4964
03:48:22,308 --> 03:48:23,246
just like my colleague from the

4965
03:48:23,246 --> 03:48:25,646
northern california area said

4966
03:48:25,676 --> 03:48:27,800
from beaver. We go from

4967
03:48:27,800 --> 03:48:28,715
cultural low carbon fuels we go

4968
03:48:28,715 --> 03:48:30,313
from low carbon feels ultra low

4969
03:48:30,313 --> 03:48:32,852
covered feels to alter alter to

4970
03:48:32,852 --> 03:48:34,453
non existent to now emissions

4971
03:48:34,453 --> 03:48:36,890
and the turnover rates for

4972
03:48:36,890 --> 03:48:38,225
these these the expense and the

4973
03:48:38,225 --> 03:48:39,555
turnover rates for these pieces

4974
03:48:39,555 --> 03:48:41,260
of equipment for business to

4975
03:48:41,260 --> 03:48:42,940
operate in the state of

4976
03:48:42,940 --> 03:48:44,940
california is completely

4977
03:48:44,465 --> 03:48:45,897
overwhelming. And so having

4978
03:48:45,897 --> 03:48:46,996
that in mind and that's the way

4979
03:48:46,996 --> 03:48:48,533
that businesses are now

4980
03:48:48,533 --> 03:48:49,568
struggling with making sure

4981
03:48:49,568 --> 03:48:50,833
that they comply with the

4982
03:48:50,833 --> 03:48:51,902
current rules under the air

4983
03:48:51,902 --> 03:48:53,340
resources board in the

4984
03:48:53,340 --> 03:48:55,434
equipment that they've already

4985
03:48:55,473 --> 03:48:58,307
bought it is not yet out of

4986
03:48:58,307 --> 03:49:01,907
compliance. I would urge a no

4987
03:49:04,510 --> 03:49:06,348
vote. Center her title. Thank

4988
03:49:06,348 --> 03:49:09,454
you Mister President you know I

4989
03:49:09,454 --> 03:49:10,788
want to start off by. Speaking

4990
03:49:10,788 --> 03:49:13,570
a little bit of truth and I

4991
03:49:13,570 --> 03:49:15,423
know that my colleague from

4992
03:49:15,423 --> 03:49:15,890
chino knows this very wall that

4993
03:49:15,890 --> 03:49:17,910
I've been a little bit

4994
03:49:17,910 --> 03:49:19,260
reluctant to be supportive of

4995
03:49:19,260 --> 03:49:22,260
this bill. Because the district

4996
03:49:22,367 --> 03:49:22,863
has you know that they're just

4997
03:49:22,863 --> 03:49:25,263
they have concerns about

4998
03:49:26,970 --> 03:49:29,370
additional. Regulation and one

4999
03:49:29,371 --> 03:49:31,771
not right but-I ultimately

5000
03:49:32,172 --> 03:49:32,973
decided to support this bill

5001
03:49:32,973 --> 03:49:35,842
because it's the right thing to

5002
03:49:35,842 --> 03:49:38,381
do. And it's the right thing to

5003
03:49:38,381 --> 03:49:39,710
do for my district mobile

5004
03:49:39,710 --> 03:49:42,581
source pollution is one of the

5005
03:49:42,581 --> 03:49:44,982
largest contributors to air. In

5006
03:49:44,982 --> 03:49:45,747
the southern central valley.

5007
03:49:45,747 --> 03:49:47,949
And it's a tough vote for me

5008
03:49:47,949 --> 03:49:48,689
but it's the right thing to do.

5009
03:49:48,689 --> 03:49:50,854
I am pleased to see the

5010
03:49:50,854 --> 03:49:51,688
amendments. That word that

5011
03:49:51,688 --> 03:49:54,880
address many of the

5012
03:49:54,589 --> 03:49:56,624
opposition's concerns. And this

5013
03:49:56,624 --> 03:49:57,696
bill I think strikes the right

5014
03:49:57,696 --> 03:49:59,663
balance and recognizes the

5015
03:49:59,663 --> 03:50:01,432
central role that heavy duty

5016
03:50:01,432 --> 03:50:03,263
trucks play in my district

5017
03:50:03,263 --> 03:50:04,767
while also reducing emissions.

5018
03:50:04,767 --> 03:50:06,839
Of harmful pollutants from

5019
03:50:06,839 --> 03:50:09,239
mobile sources. And without

5020
03:50:09,438 --> 03:50:12,875
colleagues I urge you to vote

5021
03:50:12,875 --> 03:50:14,444
I. On sb two sixty. Q. Any

5022
03:50:14,444 --> 03:50:16,844
additional discussion or debate

5023
03:50:17,376 --> 03:50:18,778
on this item. Cena more

5024
03:50:18,778 --> 03:50:20,580
microphones senator labor would

5025
03:50:20,580 --> 03:50:21,951
you like to close. Thank you

5026
03:50:21,951 --> 03:50:23,850
Mister President and thank you

5027
03:50:23,850 --> 03:50:24,519
to the good senator from saying

5028
03:50:24,519 --> 03:50:25,721
I appreciate that this is it

5029
03:50:25,721 --> 03:50:27,256
May be a tough blow for her

5030
03:50:27,256 --> 03:50:28,820
thank you very much. But what

5031
03:50:28,820 --> 03:50:30,127
I'd like to say members if this

5032
03:50:30,127 --> 03:50:32,256
is our third year we've been

5033
03:50:32,256 --> 03:50:33,429
working on this with everyone

5034
03:50:33,429 --> 03:50:35,128
involved with all the

5035
03:50:35,128 --> 03:50:36,862
stakeholders involved. And you

5036
03:50:36,862 --> 03:50:38,230
know what a good negotiation is

5037
03:50:38,230 --> 03:50:39,632
a good negotiations when

5038
03:50:39,632 --> 03:50:42,632
everybody walks away a little

5039
03:50:43,933 --> 03:50:44,533
bit happy a little bit unhappy

5040
03:50:44,533 --> 03:50:46,638
and that's the balance that we

5041
03:50:46,638 --> 03:50:47,839
have achieved here. All these

5042
03:50:47,839 --> 03:50:49,908
incredibly important but so was

5043
03:50:49,908 --> 03:50:51,709
our small businesses and that's

5044
03:50:51,709 --> 03:50:54,450
why we took every single

5045
03:50:54,450 --> 03:50:56,147
amendment that ag asked us to

5046
03:50:56,147 --> 03:50:57,813
take. Except for one and that

5047
03:50:57,813 --> 03:50:59,585
will go to the h. Q. Empty for

5048
03:50:59,585 --> 03:51:01,152
mobile sourcing to make sure

5049
03:51:01,152 --> 03:51:03,687
and they have committed the rb

5050
03:51:03,687 --> 03:51:05,453
has come a qb has committed. To

5051
03:51:05,453 --> 03:51:07,157
doing mbile source testing so

5052
03:51:07,157 --> 03:51:08,892
you don't have to drive a

5053
03:51:08,892 --> 03:51:10,629
hundred or two hundred miles.

5054
03:51:10,629 --> 03:51:12,231
To get your vehicletested. I

5055
03:51:12,231 --> 03:51:14,264
think this is a bill that does

5056
03:51:14,264 --> 03:51:15,650
what we all want to do here in

5057
03:51:15,650 --> 03:51:16,236
the state of california it what

5058
03:51:16,236 --> 03:51:18,680
we all want to do here on this

5059
03:51:18,680 --> 03:51:20,236
floor. That's to make sure that

5060
03:51:20,236 --> 03:51:22,710
businesses can still operate.

5061
03:51:22,710 --> 03:51:23,907
And be profitable but we also

5062
03:51:23,907 --> 03:51:24,944
still have clean air to breathe

5063
03:51:24,944 --> 03:51:26,373
you've heard me talk about when

5064
03:51:26,373 --> 03:51:27,974
I was a little girl. In the

5065
03:51:27,974 --> 03:51:29,382
seventies and you couldn't see

5066
03:51:29,382 --> 03:51:30,680
the mountains. And things have

5067
03:51:30,680 --> 03:51:32,248
gotten better the skies are

5068
03:51:32,248 --> 03:51:34,550
blue or but we also know that

5069
03:51:34,550 --> 03:51:36,190
the particulates are smaller.

5070
03:51:36,190 --> 03:51:37,320
And we have more work to do we

5071
03:51:37,320 --> 03:51:39,210
know that some of the worst air

5072
03:51:39,210 --> 03:51:40,355
quality is in the central

5073
03:51:40,355 --> 03:51:43,355
valley. And in the inland

5074
03:51:43,489 --> 03:51:44,859
empire this bill over ten years

5075
03:51:44,859 --> 03:51:47,364
will be the equivalent of

5076
03:51:47,364 --> 03:51:48,630
taking three hundred and

5077
03:51:48,630 --> 03:51:50,665
seventy five thousand. Ig

5078
03:51:50,665 --> 03:51:53,650
diesel trucks the works

5079
03:51:53,268 --> 03:51:56,868
polluters. Off of the street. I

5080
03:51:57,104 --> 03:51:57,605
thank you all very much for

5081
03:51:57,605 --> 03:51:58,169
your consideration and I

5082
03:51:58,169 --> 03:52:01,169
respectfully ask for an aye

5083
03:52:01,709 --> 03:52:02,478
vote. Thank you all debate

5084
03:52:02,478 --> 03:52:03,511
having sees Mister Secretary

5085
03:52:03,511 --> 03:52:06,511
please call the roll allen.

5086
03:52:07,848 --> 03:52:10,848
Archuleta I atkins aye bates

5087
03:52:12,520 --> 03:52:15,284
nobel I purchase no bradford I

5088
03:52:15,284 --> 03:52:18,884
caballero I chiang no daly no

5089
03:52:21,523 --> 03:52:24,523
dodd. I dorado. I galgiani.

5090
03:52:25,358 --> 03:52:28,958
Glazer I gonzalez hi grow no

5091
03:52:29,632 --> 03:52:33,232
hertzberg aye hill aye hueso by

5092
03:52:34,239 --> 03:52:37,839
tado I jackson aye jones. Leyva

5093
03:52:38,382 --> 03:52:41,382
aye mcguire hi mitchell by

5094
03:52:43,848 --> 03:52:45,582
money. I'm more lark no merrell.

5095
03:52:45,582 --> 03:52:48,582
No nielsen no pan aye

5096
03:52:51,917 --> 03:52:55,517
portantino I roth by rubio. I

5097
03:52:56,223 --> 03:52:59,823
skinner aye stern aye stone no

5098
03:53:00,270 --> 03:53:03,627
burke our caskey I wiener aye

5099
03:53:05,332 --> 03:53:06,733
wilk no leyva moves a call.

5100
03:53:06,733 --> 03:53:09,202
Members now we're moving on to

5101
03:53:09,202 --> 03:53:11,605
fall item six my senator hill

5102
03:53:11,605 --> 03:53:13,600
Mister Secretary please route.

5103
03:53:13,600 --> 03:53:14,140
Senate bill five fifty by

5104
03:53:14,140 --> 03:53:15,708
senator hill an act relating to

5105
03:53:15,708 --> 03:53:17,744
public utilities through hill

5106
03:53:17,744 --> 03:53:18,545
thank you Mister President sb

5107
03:53:18,545 --> 03:53:20,677
five fifty is back on

5108
03:53:20,677 --> 03:53:22,651
concurrence amendments adopted

5109
03:53:22,651 --> 03:53:24,418
in the assembly add a financial

5110
03:53:24,418 --> 03:53:25,651
threshold to cpuc

5111
03:53:25,651 --> 03:53:27,517
considerations of safety

5112
03:53:27,517 --> 03:53:29,540
standards and incorporate the

5113
03:53:29,540 --> 03:53:30,923
important clarifications

5114
03:53:30,923 --> 03:53:32,923
regarding cpuc review.

5115
03:53:33,125 --> 03:53:35,593
Negotiated after the passage of

5116
03:53:35,593 --> 03:53:36,527
ab ten fifty four earlier this

5117
03:53:36,527 --> 03:53:38,529
year this bill is received

5118
03:53:38,529 --> 03:53:40,929
bipartisan support has no

5119
03:53:40,993 --> 03:53:41,594
opposition I respectfully ask

5120
03:53:41,594 --> 03:53:44,198
your aye vote on concurrent to

5121
03:53:44,198 --> 03:53:44,829
the assembly of men. Any

5122
03:53:44,829 --> 03:53:46,500
further description of it on

5123
03:53:46,500 --> 03:53:48,101
the side of. The non Mister

5124
03:53:48,101 --> 03:53:51,101
Secretary please call the roll.

5125
03:53:54,974 --> 03:53:57,974
Allen archuleta aye atkins aye

5126
03:53:58,210 --> 03:54:01,510
bates hi bill hi porges. Hi

5127
03:54:01,510 --> 03:54:04,510
bradford I cambiado. Chiang by

5128
03:54:07,185 --> 03:54:10,785
daily. Dodd on side also. I

5129
03:54:11,689 --> 03:54:14,689
galgiani. I glazer aye gonzalez

5130
03:54:17,595 --> 03:54:21,195
hi grow. Hertzberg hi hill aye

5131
03:54:21,669 --> 03:54:25,269
hueso aye tado aye jackson aye

5132
03:54:25,302 --> 03:54:28,902
jones by leyva aye mcguire aye

5133
03:54:30,900 --> 03:54:33,900
mitchell aye monning I'm more

5134
03:54:34,381 --> 03:54:36,283
lock I'm real no. Nielsen no

5135
03:54:36,283 --> 03:54:37,981
pan aye portantino

5136
03:54:37,981 --> 03:54:39,981
aye roth aye

5137
03:54:44,530 --> 03:54:47,653
rubio. By skinner. I stern aye

5138
03:54:51,728 --> 03:54:54,728
stone. Hi amberg. Power caskey

5139
03:54:57,564 --> 03:54:58,164
aye wiener aye wilk hi. The

5140
03:54:58,164 --> 03:55:01,764
sector please call your up to

5141
03:55:01,868 --> 03:55:04,268
members allen. Caballero. Hi

5142
03:55:07,800 --> 03:55:09,410
dolly I growth hi

5143
03:55:09,410 --> 03:55:11,410
. Cedar hill

5144
03:55:12,480 --> 03:55:14,647
moves the call. Next up members

5145
03:55:14,647 --> 03:55:15,915
is file item seven senator

5146
03:55:15,915 --> 03:55:17,718
glazers are you prepared for

5147
03:55:17,718 --> 03:55:20,718
that item he is Mister

5148
03:55:21,861 --> 03:55:22,800
Secretary please read senate

5149
03:55:22,800 --> 03:55:22,238
bill six on I'm a senator

5150
03:55:22,238 --> 03:55:23,554
glazer and aquinnah professions

5151
03:55:23,554 --> 03:55:25,890
and vocations dinner dollars

5152
03:55:25,890 --> 03:55:28,280
are thank you Mister President

5153
03:55:28,280 --> 03:55:29,270
members this bill is the sunset

5154
03:55:29,270 --> 03:55:30,691
hill for the bureau of security

5155
03:55:30,691 --> 03:55:31,795
and investigative services.

5156
03:55:31,795 --> 03:55:32,799
Amendments taken in the

5157
03:55:32,799 --> 03:55:34,264
assembly did a variety of

5158
03:55:34,264 --> 03:55:36,664
things wanted increases the

5159
03:55:36,730 --> 03:55:38,000
private investigator fees in

5160
03:55:38,000 --> 03:55:39,167
accordance with an external

5161
03:55:39,167 --> 03:55:41,730
audit and at the request the

5162
03:55:41,730 --> 03:55:42,671
bureau without the proposed fee

5163
03:55:42,671 --> 03:55:44,542
increase the private

5164
03:55:44,542 --> 03:55:46,542
investigative account is

5165
03:55:48,676 --> 03:55:49,247
projected to become insolvent.

5166
03:55:49,247 --> 03:55:51,946
In this fiscal year. Display

5167
03:55:51,946 --> 03:55:52,480
the measure merges the. To find

5168
03:55:52,480 --> 03:55:53,748
and the private security

5169
03:55:53,748 --> 03:55:54,449
services fund. It aligns the

5170
03:55:54,449 --> 03:55:56,350
bureau statutes with the penal

5171
03:55:56,350 --> 03:55:56,884
code. And experience other

5172
03:55:56,884 --> 03:55:58,288
changes stemming from the

5173
03:55:58,288 --> 03:56:00,288
sunset review oversight

5174
03:56:02,589 --> 03:56:03,870
conducted by. Our art. Our

5175
03:56:03,870 --> 03:56:03,688
agency there's no known

5176
03:56:03,688 --> 03:56:05,592
opposition I respectfully ask

5177
03:56:05,592 --> 03:56:08,592
for either. Any for the

5178
03:56:09,263 --> 03:56:09,830
description of it on this item.

5179
03:56:09,830 --> 03:56:12,230
Three nine Mister Secretary

5180
03:56:12,529 --> 03:56:15,529
please call the roll allen.

5181
03:56:16,767 --> 03:56:19,767
Archuleta aye atkins aye bates.

5182
03:56:20,706 --> 03:56:24,306
Bell I five largest bradford I

5183
03:56:24,477 --> 03:56:28,770
caballero by chiang I daly dodd

5184
03:56:30,950 --> 03:56:34,550
hi dorado hi galgiani hi glazer

5185
03:56:34,920 --> 03:56:38,487
I gonzalez by grow by hertzberg

5186
03:56:38,487 --> 03:56:42,870
aye hill aye hueso higher tado

5187
03:56:42,560 --> 03:56:45,763
aye jackson aye jones I leyva

5188
03:56:45,763 --> 03:56:47,501
aye mcguire aye mitchell aye

5189
03:56:47,501 --> 03:56:49,901
monning aye moorlach aye

5190
03:56:51,735 --> 03:56:54,735
morrell aye nielsen. Aye pan

5191
03:56:54,937 --> 03:56:57,506
aye portantino. I roth aye

5192
03:56:57,506 --> 03:57:01,106
rubio aye skinner I stern aye

5193
03:57:03,842 --> 03:57:07,442
stone. I am burke our caskey

5194
03:57:07,715 --> 03:57:09,851
aye wiener aye wilk hi. Sector

5195
03:57:09,851 --> 03:57:12,851
please call the absent members

5196
03:57:18,634 --> 03:57:21,610
alan bates hi. Gorgeous daly.

5197
03:57:21,610 --> 03:57:23,296
Center glazer moves a call next

5198
03:57:23,296 --> 03:57:24,396
removing to three budget item

5199
03:57:24,396 --> 03:57:26,796
senator mature you're prepared

5200
03:57:27,564 --> 03:57:31,164
we have items eight. Nine and

5201
03:57:32,730 --> 03:57:35,730
ten. First up automate. Mister

5202
03:57:36,215 --> 03:57:36,433
Secretary please rate senate

5203
03:57:36,433 --> 03:57:36,579
bill one on nine by the

5204
03:57:36,579 --> 03:57:38,780
committee on budget fiscal

5205
03:57:38,780 --> 03:57:38,609
review and actually the state

5206
03:57:38,609 --> 03:57:39,240
budget making preparation

5207
03:57:39,240 --> 03:57:40,514
therefore to take effect

5208
03:57:40,514 --> 03:57:42,243
immediately but your bill

5209
03:57:42,243 --> 03:57:43,447
sooner but as cinema drum sir

5210
03:57:43,447 --> 03:57:45,150
thank you Mister President

5211
03:57:45,150 --> 03:57:47,184
colleagues sb one or not as the

5212
03:57:47,184 --> 03:57:48,321
budget bill junior and contains

5213
03:57:48,321 --> 03:57:50,321
technical and substantive

5214
03:57:50,518 --> 03:57:51,291
amendments to the twenty

5215
03:57:51,291 --> 03:57:52,622
nineteen budget act. The bill

5216
03:57:52,622 --> 03:57:53,921
does the following it includes

5217
03:57:53,921 --> 03:57:55,558
multiple items that were part

5218
03:57:55,558 --> 03:57:58,428
of the June budget agreement

5219
03:57:58,428 --> 03:57:59,598
including appropriating twelve

5220
03:57:59,598 --> 03:58:01,631
million dollars for a grant to

5221
03:58:01,631 --> 03:58:02,595
the county of stanislaus

5222
03:58:02,595 --> 03:58:03,903
emergency communications

5223
03:58:03,903 --> 03:58:05,871
equipment infrastructure

5224
03:58:05,871 --> 03:58:07,600
appropriating ten million to

5225
03:58:07,600 --> 03:58:08,905
the city of palm springs to

5226
03:58:08,905 --> 03:58:10,872
address homelessness related

5227
03:58:10,872 --> 03:58:12,375
needs adeline funding for child

5228
03:58:12,375 --> 03:58:14,276
care program so properly

5229
03:58:14,276 --> 03:58:16,676
reflect allowable federal fund

5230
03:58:18,419 --> 03:58:18,637
uses in addition this bill

5231
03:58:18,637 --> 03:58:19,117
includes items that were

5232
03:58:19,117 --> 03:58:20,451
inadvertently left out of the

5233
03:58:20,451 --> 03:58:21,749
gym budget or that address

5234
03:58:21,749 --> 03:58:23,585
circumstances that have arisen

5235
03:58:23,585 --> 03:58:25,653
since the passage of the June

5236
03:58:25,653 --> 03:58:26,387
budget. Such as appropriating

5237
03:58:26,387 --> 03:58:28,422
ten million for the california

5238
03:58:28,422 --> 03:58:30,822
health center grant program

5239
03:58:30,859 --> 03:58:32,727
providing to engine six point

5240
03:58:32,727 --> 03:58:34,294
one million for the salton sea

5241
03:58:34,294 --> 03:58:36,294
species conservation habitat

5242
03:58:36,930 --> 03:58:38,930
project appropriate fourteen

5243
03:58:39,397 --> 03:58:42,397
point nine million for overtime

5244
03:58:43,200 --> 03:58:46,200
costs at the department of

5245
03:58:46,837 --> 03:58:47,438
forestry and fire. Protection.

5246
03:58:47,438 --> 03:58:48,308
The bill makes this technical

5247
03:58:48,308 --> 03:58:50,708
non substantive amendments to

5248
03:58:51,553 --> 03:58:52,679
the twenty ninety budget act.

5249
03:58:52,679 --> 03:58:54,614
Any scription of eight on

5250
03:58:54,614 --> 03:58:55,180
this item hearing and seeing

5251
03:58:55,180 --> 03:58:57,580
none Mister Secretary please

5252
03:58:58,150 --> 03:59:01,150
call the roll allen. Archuleta

5253
03:59:02,553 --> 03:59:02,721
I atkins aye bates no bill0

5254
03:59:02,721 --> 03:59:04,721
I

5255
03:59:05,922 --> 03:59:08,322
bridges no bradford aye

5256
03:59:08,826 --> 03:59:12,426
caballero I chiang@@. No daly no

5257
03:59:13,796 --> 03:59:17,396
da. Hi dorado I galgiani aye

5258
03:59:18,135 --> 03:59:18,698
glazer aye gonzalez hi grow@. No

5259
03:59:18,698 --> 03:59:19,307
hertzberg

5260
03:59:19,307 --> 03:59:21,307
`

5261
03:59:21,739 --> 03:59:24,139
aye@ hill aye hueso

5262
03:59:25,407 --> 03:59:29,607
aye or tado I jackson by jones

5263
03:59:31,412 --> 03:59:33,800
no leyva@. Mcguire hi mitchell.

5264
03:59:33,800 --> 03:59:36,680
Hi monning I'm more lock no

5265
03:59:38,615 --> 03:59:42,215
morale no nielsen no pan aye

5266
03:59:42,425 --> 03:59:45,425
portantino aye roth aye rubio

5267
03:59:45,490 --> 03:59:49,900
aye skinner aye stern aye stone.

5268
03:59:51,630 --> 03:59:54,630
Number. Hi ira caskey aye

5269
03:59:55,200 --> 03:59:57,380
wiener aye wilk mr other please

5270
03:59:57,380 --> 04:00:00,380
call absent members allen leyva.

5271
04:00:03,730 --> 04:00:05,208
Hi stone. Yes sir mr moves call

5272
04:00:05,208 --> 04:00:08,808
next up is file item nine.

5273
04:00:09,810 --> 04:00:10,981
Mister Terry please route.

5274
04:00:10,981 --> 04:00:11,581
Senate bill one twelve by the

5275
04:00:11,581 --> 04:00:12,684
committee on but in fiscal

5276
04:00:12,684 --> 04:00:14,884
review an acting state

5277
04:00:14,884 --> 04:00:15,351
government and making progress

5278
04:00:15,351 --> 04:00:17,351
therefore take effect

5279
04:00:19,495 --> 04:00:19,713
immediately bill related but.

5280
04:00:19,713 --> 04:00:19,861
Senator mitchell thank you

5281
04:00:19,861 --> 04:00:21,861
Mister President colleagues

5282
04:00:22,425 --> 04:00:23,490
this is. The last bill we just

5283
04:00:23,490 --> 04:00:25,261
it was a budget bill junior we

5284
04:00:25,261 --> 04:00:26,893
are now moving into. Some of

5285
04:00:26,893 --> 04:00:30,493
the final trailer bill for this

5286
04:00:30,966 --> 04:00:31,530
year this is senate bill one

5287
04:00:31,530 --> 04:00:32,101
twelve which is the general

5288
04:00:32,101 --> 04:00:34,501
government clean up trailer

5289
04:00:34,604 --> 04:00:36,710
bill. It restores the to

5290
04:00:36,710 --> 04:00:38,600
general's authority to initiate

5291
04:00:38,600 --> 04:00:39,972
an audit or review policies

5292
04:00:39,972 --> 04:00:40,772
practices and procedures of the

5293
04:00:40,772 --> 04:00:42,477
apartment of corrections and

5294
04:00:42,477 --> 04:00:43,543
rehabilitation. And provides

5295
04:00:43,543 --> 04:00:44,810
authority to thinspector

5296
04:00:44,810 --> 04:00:46,514
general to provide.

5297
04:00:46,514 --> 04:00:48,840
Contemporanea oversight to the

5298
04:00:48,840 --> 04:00:49,750
department's revised process

5299
04:00:49,750 --> 04:00:51,784
for hanley in make complaints

5300
04:00:51,784 --> 04:00:53,318
prison employee misconduct. It

5301
04:00:53,318 --> 04:00:54,250
appropriate three point five

5302
04:00:54,250 --> 04:00:56,221
million on going to the office

5303
04:00:56,221 --> 04:00:57,425
of the inspector general. It

5304
04:00:57,425 --> 04:00:58,687
clarifies existing state law

5305
04:00:58,687 --> 04:01:00,225
with respect to the employment

5306
04:01:00,225 --> 04:01:01,259
verification process

5307
04:01:01,259 --> 04:01:03,196
administered by employees

5308
04:01:03,196 --> 04:01:04,725
consistent with federal law. It

5309
04:01:04,725 --> 04:01:06,196
updates the noise testing

5310
04:01:06,196 --> 04:01:08,129
standards for vehicle exhaust

5311
04:01:08,129 --> 04:01:09,399
systems and modifies existing

5312
04:01:09,399 --> 04:01:12,999
law to allow an individual who

5313
04:01:13,543 --> 04:01:13,771
was arrested or cited for a

5314
04:01:13,771 --> 04:01:13,930
violation of those standards.

5315
04:01:13,930 --> 04:01:15,369
The fix the violation and

5316
04:01:15,369 --> 04:01:16,603
provide proof of correction

5317
04:01:16,603 --> 04:01:19,300
instead of facing other

5318
04:01:20,509 --> 04:01:21,430
enforcement actions makes a

5319
04:01:21,430 --> 04:01:23,443
variety of other technical

5320
04:01:25,381 --> 04:01:26,185
changes ask for an aye vote.

5321
04:01:26,185 --> 04:01:27,583
Any description of it on the

5322
04:01:27,583 --> 04:01:30,352
site on him to none the

5323
04:01:30,352 --> 04:01:32,200
secretary please call the roll.

5324
04:01:32,200 --> 04:01:35,620
Allen hi archuleta I atkins aye

5325
04:01:37,896 --> 04:01:41,496
bates. No bill hi burgess no

5326
04:01:42,630 --> 04:01:45,663
bradford I calvet hero hi jane%

5327
04:01:46,233 --> 04:01:48,435
no daly no dodd hi dorado I

5328
04:01:48,435 --> 04:01:50,835
galgiani aye glazer aye

5329
04:01:53,741 --> 04:01:55,775
gonzalez I grow no hertzberg. I

5330
04:01:55,775 --> 04:01:59,975
hill aye hueso aye or tado hi

5331
04:02:01,781 --> 04:02:05,981
jackson. I jones no leyva. I am

5332
04:02:06,221 --> 04:02:08,755
a choir hi mitchell aye monning.

5333
04:02:08,755 --> 04:02:12,190
I'm more lock no morale no

5334
04:02:12,190 --> 04:02:15,190
nielsen no pan aye portantino.

5335
04:02:20,431 --> 04:02:24,310
Hi. Roth hi rubio. I skinner

5336
04:02:24,799 --> 04:02:27,799
aye stern aye stone November.

5337
04:02:32,640 --> 04:02:34,144
Our caskey I winner by wilk no.

5338
04:02:34,144 --> 04:02:35,676
Our eyes twenty nine knows

5339
04:02:35,676 --> 04:02:38,676
eleven the measure passes final

5340
04:02:40,717 --> 04:02:43,686
budget item is file item ten.

5341
04:02:43,686 --> 04:02:45,200
Sooner secretary please read.

5342
04:02:45,200 --> 04:02:45,821
Senate bill one thirteen by the

5343
04:02:45,821 --> 04:02:47,756
committee on budget fiscal

5344
04:02:47,756 --> 04:02:48,590
review and echoing housing and

5345
04:02:48,590 --> 04:02:49,391
make in preparation therefore

5346
04:02:49,391 --> 04:02:51,156
to take effect immediately bill

5347
04:02:51,156 --> 04:02:52,757
related budget senate mitchell

5348
04:02:52,757 --> 04:02:53,558
senate bill one thirteen is the

5349
04:02:53,558 --> 04:02:55,429
housing trailer bill and

5350
04:02:55,429 --> 04:02:56,899
contains statutory changes

5351
04:02:56,899 --> 04:02:58,396
necessary to implement the

5352
04:02:58,396 --> 04:03:00,133
twenty nineteen budget act. It

5353
04:03:00,133 --> 04:03:02,736
stays the legislative intent to

5354
04:03:02,736 --> 04:03:03,233
establish a trust the manage

5355
04:03:03,233 --> 04:03:04,633
three hundred thirty one

5356
04:03:04,633 --> 04:03:06,337
million in state funds that are

5357
04:03:06,337 --> 04:03:07,505
court order to provide borrower

5358
04:03:07,505 --> 04:03:09,176
relief and legal aid to

5359
04:03:09,176 --> 04:03:10,341
homeowners or renters and

5360
04:03:10,341 --> 04:03:12,543
provides for the transfer of

5361
04:03:12,543 --> 04:03:13,577
the required funds it clarifies

5362
04:03:13,577 --> 04:03:15,512
the application of certain

5363
04:03:15,512 --> 04:03:16,680
judicial and administrative

5364
04:03:16,680 --> 04:03:18,181
remedies for non compliance

5365
04:03:18,181 --> 04:03:19,216
with state housing element. It

5366
04:03:19,216 --> 04:03:20,619
allows the councils of

5367
04:03:20,619 --> 04:03:22,619
government that receive

5368
04:03:22,719 --> 04:03:24,424
planning funds provided the

5369
04:03:24,424 --> 04:03:25,859
nineteen budget act to spend up

5370
04:03:25,859 --> 04:03:27,190
225% of their phones prepare

5371
04:03:27,190 --> 04:03:28,928
for planning activities

5372
04:03:28,928 --> 04:03:29,759
required in the upcoming six

5373
04:03:29,759 --> 04:03:31,127
regional housing needs

5374
04:03:31,127 --> 04:03:34,127
assessment cycle and makes a

5375
04:03:34,794 --> 04:03:35,395
variety of technical and

5376
04:03:35,395 --> 04:03:38,395
conforming changes. We ask for

5377
04:03:39,802 --> 04:03:42,305
an aye vote. Thank you center

5378
04:03:42,305 --> 04:03:43,600
grow on the side of. Thank you

5379
04:03:43,600 --> 04:03:44,106
Mister President question of

5380
04:03:44,106 --> 04:03:46,742
the author majority to question

5381
04:03:46,742 --> 04:03:47,342
of course. Thank you how long

5382
04:03:47,342 --> 04:03:48,444
will it take for funding from

5383
04:03:48,444 --> 04:03:49,780
the stress to actually get in

5384
04:03:49,780 --> 04:03:52,678
the hands of homeowners to help

5385
04:03:53,951 --> 04:03:56,749
them. Well I don't know

5386
04:03:56,749 --> 04:03:58,350
offhand. If you needed before

5387
04:03:58,350 --> 04:03:59,290
we take a vote I'd be happy to

5388
04:03:59,290 --> 04:04:01,990
check with staff and find out.

5389
04:04:01,990 --> 04:04:03,570
That be great. My understanding

5390
04:04:03,570 --> 04:04:05,234
it's going to go into a trust

5391
04:04:05,234 --> 04:04:05,762
is going to be governed by

5392
04:04:05,762 --> 04:04:06,293
there'd be into the stock

5393
04:04:06,293 --> 04:04:08,296
market of the stock market

5394
04:04:08,296 --> 04:04:09,696
crashes. And something happens

5395
04:04:09,696 --> 04:04:10,765
to this funding stream we are

5396
04:04:10,765 --> 04:04:12,369
we get prepared to have the

5397
04:04:12,369 --> 04:04:13,401
general fund replaces three in

5398
04:04:13,401 --> 04:04:15,135
a thirty million dollars that

5399
04:04:15,135 --> 04:04:18,135
was originally stolen. From the

5400
04:04:21,542 --> 04:04:23,609
taxpayers. Center center meters

5401
04:04:23,609 --> 04:04:24,175
checking on your first question

5402
04:04:24,175 --> 04:04:27,175
so she's like frankie Mister

5403
04:04:46,950 --> 04:04:48,950
President. We have

5404
04:04:56,572 --> 04:04:58,572
. Find

5405
04:04:58,717 --> 04:05:01,200
everyone about the circumstance

5406
04:05:01,200 --> 04:05:03,780
of my colleague referenced to

5407
04:05:03,780 --> 04:05:04,880
taxpayer dollars being stolen

5408
04:05:04,880 --> 04:05:06,448
there was a court order that

5409
04:05:06,448 --> 04:05:08,253
declared the legislature needed

5410
04:05:08,253 --> 04:05:11,160
to set up the trust that's what

5411
04:05:11,160 --> 04:05:13,154
the trailer bill does to

5412
04:05:13,154 --> 04:05:14,255
establish the trust in January

5413
04:05:14,255 --> 04:05:15,723
hopefully through another

5414
04:05:15,723 --> 04:05:18,159
budget action so would take

5415
04:05:18,159 --> 04:05:19,257
effect immediately another

5416
04:05:19,257 --> 04:05:20,828
piece of legislation would have

5417
04:05:20,828 --> 04:05:22,997
to be introduced on that then

5418
04:05:22,997 --> 04:05:25,997
would allow the disbursement of

5419
04:05:26,535 --> 04:05:30,400
the of the funds so this

5420
04:05:30,400 --> 04:05:31,710
trailer bill. Establishes the.

5421
04:05:31,710 --> 04:05:31,772
Press fun another piece of

5422
04:05:31,772 --> 04:05:33,643
legislation will be

5423
04:05:33,643 --> 04:05:35,643
implemented. To actually

5424
04:05:36,676 --> 04:05:37,911
disperse the funds. At so I

5425
04:05:37,911 --> 04:05:39,846
can't answer your specific

5426
04:05:39,846 --> 04:05:40,446
question about how long it

5427
04:05:40,446 --> 04:05:42,215
would take but that's the time

5428
04:05:42,215 --> 04:05:45,215
frame that we're dealing with.

5429
04:05:45,685 --> 04:05:46,787
Thank you on my own time. I

5430
04:05:46,787 --> 04:05:49,191
think the information that you

5431
04:05:49,191 --> 04:05:50,323
presented is incorrect the

5432
04:05:50,323 --> 04:05:53,323
order does not require the

5433
04:05:54,467 --> 04:05:56,492
legislature to establish a

5434
04:05:56,492 --> 04:05:57,920
trust the order requires the

5435
04:05:57,920 --> 04:05:57,962
three nine thirty one million

5436
04:05:57,962 --> 04:05:59,867
dollars to be returned to the

5437
04:05:59,867 --> 04:06:00,765
homeowners. And senate

5438
04:06:00,765 --> 04:06:02,297
republicans have been

5439
04:06:02,297 --> 04:06:03,766
advocating for this return of

5440
04:06:03,766 --> 04:06:05,268
these funds were struck for

5441
04:06:05,268 --> 04:06:06,669
struggling homeowners since two

5442
04:06:06,669 --> 04:06:07,806
thousand and fifteen we've

5443
04:06:07,806 --> 04:06:08,771
heard stories of homeowners

5444
04:06:08,771 --> 04:06:09,939
that are still waiting

5445
04:06:09,939 --> 04:06:12,339
desperately for these funds

5446
04:06:12,675 --> 04:06:14,643
that were promised in the two

5447
04:06:14,643 --> 04:06:16,512
thousand and thirteen fourteen

5448
04:06:16,512 --> 04:06:18,114
budgets money was taken from

5449
04:06:18,114 --> 04:06:19,314
these holdovers and put in

5450
04:06:19,314 --> 04:06:21,216
different parts of the budget

5451
04:06:21,216 --> 04:06:23,510
but the majority party. This

5452
04:06:23,510 --> 04:06:25,510
group of individuals then went

5453
04:06:25,510 --> 04:06:26,219
to our then attorney general to

5454
04:06:26,219 --> 04:06:27,924
file a lawsuit this is

5455
04:06:27,924 --> 04:06:29,756
background on this and she

5456
04:06:29,756 --> 04:06:31,661
refused to follow lawsuit or

5457
04:06:31,661 --> 04:06:32,758
work with the administration to

5458
04:06:32,758 --> 04:06:34,426
return these three or thirty

5459
04:06:34,426 --> 04:06:36,262
one million dollars. So we

5460
04:06:36,262 --> 04:06:37,796
stood beside we as republicans

5461
04:06:37,796 --> 04:06:38,697
the national asian coalition

5462
04:06:38,697 --> 04:06:40,666
american coalition and the

5463
04:06:40,666 --> 04:06:41,868
national diversity coalition in

5464
04:06:41,868 --> 04:06:43,799
their admirable fight to get

5465
04:06:43,799 --> 04:06:44,970
these friends returned the

5466
04:06:44,970 --> 04:06:47,509
recently more got a court

5467
04:06:47,509 --> 04:06:49,508
judgment from the california

5468
04:06:49,508 --> 04:06:50,512
supreme court this is this

5469
04:06:50,512 --> 04:06:52,441
three nine thirty win one

5470
04:06:52,441 --> 04:06:55,113
million dollars was tended only

5471
04:06:55,113 --> 04:06:57,513
to help homeowners homeowners

5472
04:06:58,160 --> 04:06:58,983
and should be returned. For

5473
04:06:58,983 --> 04:07:00,184
people that were taking

5474
04:07:00,184 --> 04:07:02,219
advantage of during mortgage

5475
04:07:02,219 --> 04:07:04,119
and foreclosure crisis this

5476
04:07:04,119 --> 04:07:05,389
bill right here that we're

5477
04:07:05,389 --> 04:07:07,658
discussing today will invest

5478
04:07:07,658 --> 04:07:09,326
these funds an unknown ways and

5479
04:07:09,326 --> 04:07:12,128
not return this money to the

5480
04:07:12,128 --> 04:07:13,665
homeowners. This government did

5481
04:07:13,665 --> 04:07:15,532
not even take up the fight on

5482
04:07:15,532 --> 04:07:17,366
behalf of the people in order

5483
04:07:17,366 --> 04:07:18,200
to return this three nine

5484
04:07:18,200 --> 04:07:19,432
thirty one million dollars to

5485
04:07:19,432 --> 04:07:21,403
the people or the homeowners

5486
04:07:21,403 --> 04:07:23,538
the state of california to non

5487
04:07:23,538 --> 04:07:25,574
profits an african american

5488
04:07:25,574 --> 04:07:27,574
nonprofit indonesian nonprofit

5489
04:07:27,909 --> 04:07:29,678
led by a very strong woman

5490
04:07:29,678 --> 04:07:31,440
advocated and filed a lawsuit

5491
04:07:31,440 --> 04:07:33,213
against this. State of

5492
04:07:33,213 --> 04:07:35,151
california to get this money

5493
04:07:35,151 --> 04:07:38,151
back and they have written

5494
04:07:38,517 --> 04:07:41,350
oppose letter to this piece of

5495
04:07:41,350 --> 04:07:43,453
legislation today because it

5496
04:07:43,453 --> 04:07:45,622
does not return the money to

5497
04:07:45,622 --> 04:07:47,958
the homeowners it puts the plan

5498
04:07:47,958 --> 04:07:50,958
in a trust and establishes

5499
04:07:51,862 --> 04:07:53,862
another government.

5500
04:08:01,465 --> 04:08:03,203
Bureaucratic agency. I didn't.

5501
04:08:03,203 --> 04:08:04,871
motor fans ad this vote right

5502
04:08:04,871 --> 04:08:07,207
here today is just another

5503
04:08:07,207 --> 04:08:08,105
delay for these individuals and

5504
04:08:08,105 --> 04:08:10,613
the homeowners of the state of

5505
04:08:10,613 --> 04:08:12,978
california not to receive this

5506
04:08:12,978 --> 04:08:14,647
money and I urge a no vote.

5507
04:08:14,647 --> 04:08:17,647
Thank you any additional debate

5508
04:08:19,582 --> 04:08:20,553
senator bates. Thank you Mister

5509
04:08:20,553 --> 04:08:23,553
President I to rise in

5510
04:08:24,490 --> 04:08:25,924
opposition to ab one one three

5511
04:08:25,924 --> 04:08:27,895
as we know the state's ream

5512
04:08:27,895 --> 04:08:28,424
court ruled that the three

5513
04:08:28,424 --> 04:08:29,563
hundred thirty one million

5514
04:08:29,563 --> 04:08:31,399
dollars from the settlement

5515
04:08:31,399 --> 04:08:32,697
with the nation's largest

5516
04:08:32,697 --> 04:08:33,998
mortgage banks to how

5517
04:08:33,998 --> 04:08:35,998
california's homeowners

5518
04:08:36,567 --> 04:08:37,969
victimized by illegal lending

5519
04:08:37,969 --> 04:08:40,174
practices during the mortgage

5520
04:08:40,174 --> 04:08:42,275
mortgage crisis was unlawfully

5521
04:08:42,275 --> 04:08:43,939
taken by governor brown and his

5522
04:08:43,939 --> 04:08:45,643
financial officers and diverted

5523
04:08:45,643 --> 04:08:47,845
to the state's general fund.

5524
04:08:47,845 --> 04:08:48,343
This three hundred and thirty

5525
04:08:48,343 --> 04:08:50,484
one million dollars was

5526
04:08:50,484 --> 04:08:52,115
intended to only help

5527
04:08:52,115 --> 04:08:54,870
homeowners who were abused by

5528
04:08:54,870 --> 04:08:55,816
lenders during the mortgage and

5529
04:08:55,816 --> 04:08:57,387
foreclosure crisis and now we

5530
04:08:57,387 --> 04:08:59,620
are being asked to use it for a

5531
04:08:59,620 --> 04:09:01,858
myriad of other purposes as set

5532
04:09:01,858 --> 04:09:03,325
forth in the legislation better

5533
04:09:03,325 --> 04:09:05,594
again questionable given the

5534
04:09:05,594 --> 04:09:07,762
explicit rulings by the courts

5535
04:09:07,762 --> 04:09:08,899
this many should be directed to

5536
04:09:08,899 --> 04:09:11,166
a program that has been

5537
04:09:11,166 --> 04:09:13,468
extremely valuable called keep

5538
04:09:13,468 --> 04:09:15,169
your home california. The free

5539
04:09:15,169 --> 04:09:17,169
mortgage assistance program

5540
04:09:18,390 --> 04:09:18,573
that has helped more than

5541
04:09:18,573 --> 04:09:19,607
eighty four thousand nine

5542
04:09:19,607 --> 04:09:21,676
hundred and fifty homeowners

5543
04:09:21,676 --> 04:09:23,243
who face financial hardship in

5544
04:09:23,243 --> 04:09:24,484
worried about losing their home

5545
04:09:24,484 --> 04:09:26,747
the governor senior housing

5546
04:09:26,747 --> 04:09:28,315
adviser when she was executive

5547
04:09:28,315 --> 04:09:30,350
director of the california

5548
04:09:30,350 --> 04:09:31,883
housing finance agency stated

5549
04:09:31,883 --> 04:09:33,954
and I quote. Keep your home

5550
04:09:33,954 --> 04:09:35,253
california has been a very

5551
04:09:35,253 --> 04:09:37,253
effective program helping

5552
04:09:37,488 --> 04:09:39,888
homeowners deal with their

5553
04:09:41,526 --> 04:09:42,160
financial challenges and avoid.

5554
04:09:42,160 --> 04:09:45,760
Foreclosure as they get back on

5555
04:09:46,534 --> 04:09:47,398
their feet. End quote. Skews me

5556
04:09:47,398 --> 04:09:47,965
this state manage program

5557
04:09:47,965 --> 04:09:49,870
allows homeowners to avoid

5558
04:09:49,870 --> 04:09:51,802
foreclosure by providing as

5559
04:09:51,802 --> 04:09:54,105
much as a hundred thousand0

5560
04:09:54,105 --> 04:09:55,806
dollars in assistance keep your

5561
04:09:55,806 --> 04:09:57,341
home california provides a

5562
04:09:57,341 --> 04:09:59,420
second chance to struggling

5563
04:09:59,420 --> 04:10:00,712
homeowners. The keep your home

5564
04:10:00,712 --> 04:10:02,979
california program is presently

5565
04:10:02,979 --> 04:10:04,314
closed because all of the funds

5566
04:10:04,314 --> 04:10:04,884
that were provided to the state

5567
04:10:04,884 --> 04:10:05,551
of california

5568
04:10:05,551 --> 04:10:07,151
to prevent

5569
04:10:07,151 --> 04:10:09,850
foreclosures that was over

5570
04:10:09,850 --> 04:10:10,586
about two billion dollars. Have

5571
04:10:10,586 --> 04:10:11,588
already been provided to

5572
04:10:11,588 --> 04:10:13,492
approved homeowners are

5573
04:10:13,492 --> 04:10:15,357
committed to qualify to

5574
04:10:15,357 --> 04:10:16,626
homeowners this type of effort

5575
04:10:16,626 --> 04:10:18,600
that the margin mortgage

5576
04:10:18,600 --> 04:10:20,460
settlement was supposed to

5577
04:10:20,529 --> 04:10:22,197
fund. It already exists every

5578
04:10:22,197 --> 04:10:24,767
penny of this settlement money

5579
04:10:24,767 --> 04:10:26,932
should go to reinstate the keep

5580
04:10:26,932 --> 04:10:29,332
your home california program.

5581
04:10:29,537 --> 04:10:30,872
Ab one thirteen does not help

5582
04:10:30,872 --> 04:10:33,107
this were the program in most

5583
04:10:33,107 --> 04:10:34,808
of those affected by in the

5584
04:10:34,808 --> 04:10:37,744
short term by the mortgage

5585
04:10:37,744 --> 04:10:38,409
crisis I recommend a no vote

5586
04:10:38,409 --> 04:10:40,746
thank you Mister Craddick

5587
04:10:40,746 --> 04:10:43,982
sooner very to sb one thirteen.

5588
04:10:43,982 --> 04:10:47,582
Sb one thirteen oz senator y.

5589
04:10:47,787 --> 04:10:49,521
Kaski. President I rise in

5590
04:10:49,521 --> 04:10:51,556
support of the sb one thirteen

5591
04:10:51,556 --> 04:10:54,626
let's be clear if we vote no on

5592
04:10:54,626 --> 04:10:56,427
sb one thirteen nobody gets any

5593
04:10:56,427 --> 04:10:57,562
money. The three hundred and

5594
04:10:57,562 --> 04:10:59,765
thirty one million dollars

5595
04:10:59,765 --> 04:11:01,930
nothing happens it's fine to

5596
04:11:01,930 --> 04:11:04,101
criticize the slow motion of

5597
04:11:04,101 --> 04:11:06,206
state government. That's that's

5598
04:11:06,206 --> 04:11:07,207
fine but this is going to

5599
04:11:07,207 --> 04:11:09,910
transfer the money into the

5600
04:11:09,910 --> 04:11:11,910
national. Mortgage special

5601
04:11:12,790 --> 04:11:13,407
deposit fine and will proceed

5602
04:11:13,407 --> 04:11:14,478
in a timely manner as the

5603
04:11:14,478 --> 04:11:15,578
Chairman Of the budget

5604
04:11:15,578 --> 04:11:17,800
committee is said at the

5605
04:11:17,800 --> 04:11:18,715
beginning of January to make

5606
04:11:18,715 --> 04:11:20,350
sure that every penny of this

5607
04:11:20,350 --> 04:11:21,684
money goes to the people a

5608
04:11:21,684 --> 04:11:25,850
wrist. Who are entitled to a

5609
04:11:25,850 --> 04:11:28,850
region I vote. Thank you

5610
04:11:28,794 --> 04:11:31,163
senator nielsen. Mr leading

5611
04:11:31,163 --> 04:11:33,862
chen the senate I would. Urge a

5612
04:11:33,862 --> 04:11:36,298
no vote again. To me is this is

5613
04:11:36,298 --> 04:11:39,165
a trifling with our process a

5614
04:11:39,165 --> 04:11:42,165
complicated new system. That is

5615
04:11:42,971 --> 04:11:44,803
and will be risky. And going to

5616
04:11:44,803 --> 04:11:46,875
be directed funds if. That

5617
04:11:46,875 --> 04:11:48,109
would passed input into law

5618
04:11:48,109 --> 04:11:50,278
some of these funds will be

5619
04:11:50,278 --> 04:11:52,642
directed to areas that might

5620
04:11:52,642 --> 04:11:54,149
facilitate a certain sector.

5621
04:11:54,149 --> 04:11:56,184
They have an opportunity to

5622
04:11:56,184 --> 04:11:57,750
should curse of housing but it

5623
04:11:57,750 --> 04:11:59,651
is not what we've looked at

5624
04:11:59,651 --> 04:12:01,651
historically as providing

5625
04:12:02,621 --> 04:12:04,656
housing in california. It until

5626
04:12:04,656 --> 04:12:06,258
I think and I argue that it's

5627
04:12:06,258 --> 04:12:07,923
of corruption of the process

5628
04:12:07,923 --> 04:12:10,159
and manipulation of the

5629
04:12:10,159 --> 04:12:12,559
process. And therefore we

5630
04:12:13,300 --> 04:12:14,934
should vote no. Thanks center

5631
04:12:14,934 --> 04:12:16,735
nielsen center jones. I thank

5632
04:12:16,735 --> 04:12:19,570
you Mister President I have a

5633
04:12:19,570 --> 04:12:21,841
letter that the minority leader

5634
04:12:21,841 --> 04:12:23,677
received recently many of the

5635
04:12:23,677 --> 04:12:24,309
points of all of the points in

5636
04:12:24,309 --> 04:12:25,609
the letter actually have been

5637
04:12:25,609 --> 04:12:28,900
debated through the budget

5638
04:12:28,311 --> 04:12:30,677
process and the hearing process

5639
04:12:30,677 --> 04:12:33,115
I did want to quote just a

5640
04:12:33,115 --> 04:12:33,715
short part of it if I could

5641
04:12:33,715 --> 04:12:36,115
Mister Present have permission

5642
04:12:37,653 --> 04:12:39,256
to read. Are you are you asking

5643
04:12:39,256 --> 04:12:40,919
for perjury. Yes sir product

5644
04:12:40,919 --> 04:12:42,923
thank you. And I did get a

5645
04:12:42,923 --> 04:12:44,393
commitment. From the republican

5646
04:12:44,393 --> 04:12:45,526
leader that she will disperse

5647
04:12:45,526 --> 04:12:47,358
this letter to the other

5648
04:12:47,358 --> 04:12:49,320
members if the suit would like

5649
04:12:49,320 --> 04:12:50,632
to have it. But it's from the

5650
04:12:50,632 --> 04:12:52,632
national asian american

5651
04:12:53,533 --> 04:12:55,135
coalition. There see is a faith

5652
04:12:55,135 --> 04:12:58,135
but presidency is faith parties

5653
04:12:58,836 --> 04:13:00,437
to. And the opening paragraph

5654
04:13:00,437 --> 04:13:01,638
the national asian american

5655
04:13:01,638 --> 04:13:03,810
coalition and the national

5656
04:13:03,810 --> 04:13:05,810
diversity coalition. Reiterate

5657
04:13:05,845 --> 04:13:07,130
its fervent call for the

5658
04:13:07,130 --> 04:13:08,317
administrative and legislative

5659
04:13:08,317 --> 04:13:10,520
leaders of the state of

5660
04:13:10,520 --> 04:13:12,510
california. To do the right

5661
04:13:12,510 --> 04:13:13,352
thing in regards of the return

5662
04:13:13,352 --> 04:13:14,820
of the three hundred and thirty

5663
04:13:14,820 --> 04:13:16,688
one million dollars. To the

5664
04:13:16,688 --> 04:13:18,688
national mortgage special

5665
04:13:19,839 --> 04:13:21,526
deposit fund in m. S. D. F.

5666
04:13:21,526 --> 04:13:22,861
That is to utilize and disperse

5667
04:13:22,861 --> 04:13:25,630
the fun in a manner that will

5668
04:13:25,630 --> 04:13:26,434
not delay the original intent.

5669
04:13:26,434 --> 04:13:27,966
Of delivering aid and

5670
04:13:27,966 --> 04:13:30,366
assistance to homeowners in

5671
04:13:30,832 --> 04:13:32,140
distress. There's a-five

5672
04:13:32,140 --> 04:13:33,671
there's six points that they

5673
04:13:33,671 --> 04:13:37,271
make that up that all been

5674
04:13:38,730 --> 04:13:38,673
brought up. But I'll close with

5675
04:13:38,673 --> 04:13:41,445
just by reading the last point

5676
04:13:41,445 --> 04:13:42,780
number six. Homeowners have

5677
04:13:42,780 --> 04:13:43,311
already waited too long for

5678
04:13:43,311 --> 04:13:45,215
these settlement funds to

5679
04:13:45,215 --> 04:13:47,215
actually provide assistance.

5680
04:13:47,454 --> 04:13:49,485
This I needed investment scheme

5681
04:13:49,485 --> 04:13:51,885
appears to delay immediate

5682
04:13:52,870 --> 04:13:55,870
action and results. Instead of

5683
04:13:56,233 --> 04:13:56,472
this bill the state should

5684
04:13:56,472 --> 04:13:58,526
simply use the funds to

5685
04:13:58,526 --> 04:14:00,528
directly assist homeowners this

5686
04:14:00,528 --> 04:14:02,162
year. Mister President I ask

5687
04:14:02,162 --> 04:14:03,767
for a no vote on sb one

5688
04:14:03,767 --> 04:14:06,167
thirteen. Thank you center

5689
04:14:06,700 --> 04:14:08,971
stone. Thank you Mister

5690
04:14:08,971 --> 04:14:11,680
President this is a classic

5691
04:14:11,680 --> 04:14:13,871
governmental bait and switch

5692
04:14:13,871 --> 04:14:15,642
the state should not take money

5693
04:14:15,642 --> 04:14:18,178
that was legally obtained for

5694
04:14:18,178 --> 04:14:20,647
one purpose and then using it

5695
04:14:20,647 --> 04:14:22,215
for another purpose. You know.

5696
04:14:22,215 --> 04:14:23,185
We have a twenty two billion

5697
04:14:23,185 --> 04:14:25,418
dollar surplus in the state of

5698
04:14:25,418 --> 04:14:26,686
california. And it was an order

5699
04:14:26,686 --> 04:14:27,686
the said that this three

5700
04:14:27,686 --> 04:14:28,788
hundred and thirty one million

5701
04:14:28,788 --> 04:14:30,622
dollars that was supposed to be

5702
04:14:30,622 --> 04:14:33,224
used to help those that were

5703
04:14:33,224 --> 04:14:35,359
taken advantage of during the

5704
04:14:35,359 --> 04:14:38,198
mortgage crisis would get that

5705
04:14:38,198 --> 04:14:38,762
money and be able to. Hopefully

5706
04:14:38,762 --> 04:14:41,429
rebound to get back on their

5707
04:14:41,429 --> 04:14:42,500
feet. Look at our homeless

5708
04:14:42,500 --> 04:14:44,100
population in the state of

5709
04:14:44,100 --> 04:14:46,401
california look at our poverty

5710
04:14:46,401 --> 04:14:48,170
over eighteen percent. We

5711
04:14:48,170 --> 04:14:49,337
should be fast tracking this

5712
04:14:49,337 --> 04:14:50,271
three hundred and thirty one

5713
04:14:50,271 --> 04:14:51,973
million dollars and not putting

5714
04:14:51,973 --> 04:14:53,374
it into a special trust.

5715
04:14:53,374 --> 04:14:54,809
Because basically by putting in

5716
04:14:54,809 --> 04:14:56,410
this trust you're looking at

5717
04:14:56,410 --> 04:14:57,542
creating an endowment that's

5718
04:14:57,542 --> 04:14:58,143
not what the supplement said

5719
04:14:58,143 --> 04:15:00,470
we're not creating an

5720
04:15:00,470 --> 04:15:01,849
endowment. To use interest on

5721
04:15:01,849 --> 04:15:02,780
money to help a finite number

5722
04:15:02,780 --> 04:15:04,818
of people and I will say a

5723
04:15:04,818 --> 04:15:06,383
small finite of people. Rather

5724
04:15:06,383 --> 04:15:08,385
than a much larger group of

5725
04:15:08,385 --> 04:15:09,819
people the need to help today

5726
04:15:09,819 --> 04:15:11,457
not ten years from now are

5727
04:15:11,457 --> 04:15:12,928
citizens of the state of

5728
04:15:12,928 --> 04:15:14,693
california. Have waited seven

5729
04:15:14,693 --> 04:15:16,428
years. To get reimbursed for

5730
04:15:16,428 --> 04:15:18,297
the abuses that they suffered

5731
04:15:18,297 --> 04:15:19,631
in the state of california and

5732
04:15:19,631 --> 04:15:20,766
if the democrats in the

5733
04:15:20,766 --> 04:15:22,898
legislature that are holding

5734
04:15:22,898 --> 04:15:24,360
this money up. For that reason

5735
04:15:24,360 --> 04:15:25,139
let's stand for the forty

5736
04:15:25,139 --> 04:15:26,471
million people the state of

5737
04:15:26,471 --> 04:15:27,605
california especially those

5738
04:15:27,605 --> 04:15:29,107
they're taking advantage of

5739
04:15:29,107 --> 04:15:30,111
during the mortgage crisis.

5740
04:15:30,111 --> 04:15:31,740
Let's get to the money to the

5741
04:15:31,740 --> 04:15:33,613
rifle people so they can maybe

5742
04:15:33,613 --> 04:15:34,378
buy a home or rent a home and

5743
04:15:34,378 --> 04:15:36,148
get their cells off the

5744
04:15:36,148 --> 04:15:36,778
streets. I stand up for the

5745
04:15:36,778 --> 04:15:38,349
citizens of the state

5746
04:15:38,349 --> 04:15:41,349
california were heard in the

5747
04:15:41,452 --> 04:15:42,119
mortgage crisis. I hope you

5748
04:15:42,119 --> 04:15:45,124
will too by supporting us be

5749
04:15:45,124 --> 04:15:45,789
one one three. Thank you any

5750
04:15:45,789 --> 04:15:48,158
further discussion for bait on

5751
04:15:48,158 --> 04:15:49,494
this item. Hearing and seeing

5752
04:15:49,494 --> 04:15:52,397
on senator mitchell you May

5753
04:15:52,397 --> 04:15:54,430
close I to ask for support of

5754
04:15:54,430 --> 04:15:56,431
senate bill one one three thank

5755
04:15:56,431 --> 04:15:58,831
you Mister Secretary please

5756
04:15:59,298 --> 04:16:02,898
call the roll. Allen hi archie

5757
04:16:04,706 --> 04:16:08,906
let at aye atkins aye bates. No

5758
04:16:09,420 --> 04:16:12,376
bill hi porges no bradford I

5759
04:16:12,376 --> 04:16:15,976
kelly ghetto I chiang no dally

5760
04:16:17,784 --> 04:16:20,817
no dot. Hi dorado aye galgiani

5761
04:16:20,817 --> 04:16:23,559
aye glazer aye gonzalez by

5762
04:16:23,559 --> 04:16:27,159
grove no hertzberg aye aye aye

5763
04:16:28,160 --> 04:16:31,760
hill aye hueso hi tado. Hi

5764
04:16:33,165 --> 04:16:36,765
jackson by jones no leyva. I'm

5765
04:16:37,869 --> 04:16:40,705
acquire by mitchell aye monning

5766
04:16:40,705 --> 04:16:44,305
by more lock no morale. No

5767
04:16:45,143 --> 04:16:48,143
nielsen no pan by portantino

5768
04:16:51,716 --> 04:16:54,385
aye roth aye rubio. Skinner I

5769
04:16:54,385 --> 04:16:57,385
stern by stone November our

5770
04:17:00,357 --> 04:17:00,891
caskey I wiener aye wilk. No.

5771
04:17:00,891 --> 04:17:03,891
Six three please call the

5772
04:17:08,999 --> 04:17:11,999
absent members. Rubio rubio aye.

5773
04:17:13,403 --> 04:17:15,705
August twenty nine knows eleven.

5774
04:17:15,705 --> 04:17:17,807
Assemblymember tucker in our

5775
04:17:17,807 --> 04:17:19,409
next up is file item eleven a

5776
04:17:19,409 --> 04:17:21,544
sinner draws or you prepared

5777
04:17:21,544 --> 04:17:23,315
for this item yes Mister

5778
04:17:23,315 --> 04:17:25,470
Secretary please read senate

5779
04:17:25,470 --> 04:17:26,283
bill two eighty six by senator

5780
04:17:26,283 --> 04:17:28,951
jr also an act relating to

5781
04:17:28,951 --> 04:17:30,485
employment. Senator also thank

5782
04:17:30,485 --> 04:17:32,187
you Mister President senate

5783
04:17:32,187 --> 04:17:34,592
bill two eighty six amended in

5784
04:17:34,592 --> 04:17:35,924
the assembly addresses a labor

5785
04:17:35,924 --> 04:17:38,288
code issue regarding the

5786
04:17:38,288 --> 04:17:40,590
interpretation of section two a

5787
04:17:40,590 --> 04:17:41,892
one the discharge statute and

5788
04:17:41,892 --> 04:17:44,127
in what circumstances it should

5789
04:17:44,127 --> 04:17:46,298
apply in the context of workers

5790
04:17:46,298 --> 04:17:47,833
at baseball parks in the state

5791
04:17:47,833 --> 04:17:50,350
I worked with the management of

5792
04:17:50,350 --> 04:17:52,704
the teams the california labor

5793
04:17:52,704 --> 04:17:54,442
federation sca you teamsters

5794
04:17:54,442 --> 04:17:56,442
united here. California

5795
04:17:58,711 --> 04:17:59,246
appointment lawyers association.

5796
04:17:59,246 --> 04:18:01,646
The consumer attorneys and

5797
04:18:01,646 --> 04:18:02,444
others. To ensure the

5798
04:18:02,444 --> 04:18:04,844
clarification of this labor

5799
04:18:05,470 --> 04:18:06,821
code this is a well established

5800
04:18:06,821 --> 04:18:09,220
and well accepted practice

5801
04:18:09,220 --> 04:18:10,355
colleagues thank you and ask

5802
04:18:10,355 --> 04:18:13,560
for an aye vote in concurrence

5803
04:18:13,560 --> 04:18:14,158
with assembly amendments. Thank

5804
04:18:14,158 --> 04:18:17,640
you any further discussion and

5805
04:18:17,640 --> 04:18:18,495
debate on this item. Hearing

5806
04:18:18,495 --> 04:18:19,730
seen none of Mister Secretary

5807
04:18:19,730 --> 04:18:21,398
please call the roll. Allen @

5808
04:18:21,398 --> 04:18:23,398
hi

5809
04:18:25,268 --> 04:18:28,268
archuleta aye atkins aye bates

5810
04:18:29,305 --> 04:18:30,574
aye bell I will purchase.

5811
04:18:30,574 --> 04:18:32,508
Bradford hi I

5812
04:18:32,508 --> 04:18:34,908
have a hero I

5813
04:18:35,676 --> 04:18:39,276
chiang aye daly aye dodd aye

5814
04:18:40,514 --> 04:18:43,514
dorado I galgiani aye glazer

5815
04:18:44,751 --> 04:18:47,751
aye gonzalez I grow. Hertzberg

5816
04:18:48,189 --> 04:18:51,789
aye hill aye hueso higher tado

5817
04:18:51,828 --> 04:18:54,460
I jackson aye jones. I leyva

5818
04:18:54,460 --> 04:18:56,295
aye mcguire aye mitchell aye

5819
04:18:56,295 --> 04:18:58,695
monning aye moorlach aye

5820
04:19:01,100 --> 04:19:03,936
morrell. Aye nielsen aye pan

5821
04:19:03,936 --> 04:19:06,936
aye portantino aye roth aye

5822
04:19:07,676 --> 04:19:11,276
rubio aye skinner. I stern aye

5823
04:19:14,616 --> 04:19:17,616
stone. Number our caskey I

5824
04:19:18,616 --> 04:19:19,217
wiener aye wilk by. Sector

5825
04:19:19,217 --> 04:19:22,217
please call the absent members

5826
04:19:28,994 --> 04:19:29,557
porges. Hi rove. Stone. Ice

5827
04:19:29,557 --> 04:19:32,557
thirty eight no zero simply

5828
04:19:38,871 --> 04:19:41,136
members are concurred in.

5829
04:19:41,136 --> 04:19:41,770
Members should be prepared

5830
04:19:41,770 --> 04:19:45,970
we're gonna look to call on our

5831
04:19:58,218 --> 04:20:00,218
thirteen outstanding items

5832
04:20:25,577 --> 04:20:27,110
.

5833
04:20:27,110 --> 04:20:28,645
Part members if you're prepared

5834
04:20:28,645 --> 04:20:30,446
we're gonna start looking items

5835
04:20:30,446 --> 04:20:34,460
are going to start with file

5836
04:20:35,840 --> 04:20:35,651
item thirty two the author this

5837
04:20:35,651 --> 04:20:38,510
assemblyman bloom at Mister

5838
04:20:39,256 --> 04:20:42,256
Secretary please call the roll.

5839
04:20:47,162 --> 04:20:50,162
Allen. By burgess. Caballero I

5840
04:20:54,202 --> 04:20:56,602
chiang. Galgiani our growth.

5841
04:21:03,943 --> 04:21:06,943
Hueso. I jackson. Merrell rubio.

5842
04:21:14,416 --> 04:21:14,987
Wilk look no. Morrell no.

5843
04:21:14,987 --> 04:21:18,587
Secure call by up to members

5844
04:21:21,326 --> 04:21:23,726
burgess. Chiang growth. Jackson

5845
04:21:28,636 --> 04:21:30,904
grow by jackson. Rubio. Ice

5846
04:21:30,904 --> 04:21:31,769
thirty no six the measure

5847
04:21:31,769 --> 04:21:33,804
passes nexus file item thirty

5848
04:21:33,804 --> 04:21:34,371
three. The secretary when

5849
04:21:34,371 --> 04:21:37,371
you're ready please call the

5850
04:21:47,753 --> 04:21:51,353
roll. Allen. Hi atkins by bates

5851
04:21:54,423 --> 04:21:57,423
no purchase. Chiang dodd hi

5852
04:21:58,294 --> 04:22:00,620
growth. No

5853
04:22:00,620 --> 04:22:02,429
her tado by jackson

5854
04:22:02,429 --> 04:22:04,429
boards no@

5855
04:22:08,702 --> 04:22:10,702
. Jackson. Leyva I

5856
04:22:12,839 --> 04:22:15,239
more lock. Morrell no

5857
04:22:21,913 --> 04:22:22,547
portantino. Ms rubio area no.

5858
04:22:22,547 --> 04:22:25,547
Please call absent members want

5859
04:22:26,152 --> 04:22:29,152
more time chiang. Jackson more

5860
04:22:34,558 --> 04:22:36,290
lock portantino. I is twenty

5861
04:22:36,290 --> 04:22:39,290
six knows ten the measure

5862
04:22:39,970 --> 04:22:40,899
process nexus fall item thirty

5863
04:22:40,899 --> 04:22:42,440
four a. B. Eleven sixteen the

5864
04:22:42,440 --> 04:22:45,440
sector please call the roll.

5865
04:22:48,671 --> 04:22:52,271
Allen. Hi atkins I dodd. I

5866
04:22:54,943 --> 04:22:57,280
growth hi. Highs forty no zero

5867
04:22:57,280 --> 04:23:00,880
the measure passes. Next up is

5868
04:23:03,830 --> 04:23:03,683
file item forty three. Ab seven

5869
04:23:03,683 --> 04:23:06,683
thirty the sector please call

5870
04:23:10,550 --> 04:23:13,655
the roll allen. I bates. Dodd

5871
04:23:14,559 --> 04:23:18,159
by dorado. Her tado hi more

5872
04:23:24,650 --> 04:23:24,602
lock. What county. Ice twenty

5873
04:23:24,602 --> 04:23:27,602
nine no seven the measure

5874
04:23:30,340 --> 04:23:33,243
passes. Next up is file item

5875
04:23:33,243 --> 04:23:33,813
fifty two a. B. Nine twenty

5876
04:23:33,813 --> 04:23:36,213
Mister Secretary please call

5877
04:23:37,214 --> 04:23:41,414
the roll allen. Hi dodd. Hi her

5878
04:23:45,489 --> 04:23:46,857
tado. I am burke by. All eyes

5879
04:23:46,857 --> 04:23:49,857
forty no zero the measure

5880
04:23:50,726 --> 04:23:53,662
passes next up file item fifty

5881
04:23:53,662 --> 04:23:54,597
three ab ten eighty six Mister

5882
04:23:54,597 --> 04:23:57,597
Secretary please call the roll.

5883
04:24:04,373 --> 04:24:06,242
Bates no. Tado hi wilk no. All

5884
04:24:06,242 --> 04:24:09,242
eyes thirty knows ten the

5885
04:24:10,445 --> 04:24:12,782
measure passes. Next up file

5886
04:24:12,782 --> 04:24:13,415
item thirty five a. B. Six five

5887
04:24:13,415 --> 04:24:16,415
one. Researcher please call the

5888
04:24:24,391 --> 04:24:26,560
roll. Tado hi portantino. Hi

5889
04:24:26,560 --> 04:24:29,656
ice forty no zero the measure

5890
04:24:31,294 --> 04:24:33,632
passes. Except as file item for

5891
04:24:33,632 --> 04:24:37,232
sb six nine six. Please call

5892
04:24:41,136 --> 04:24:43,536
the absent members. Allen.

5893
04:24:50,847 --> 04:24:51,448
Allen hi. Our eyes thirty nine

5894
04:24:51,448 --> 04:24:54,215
twenty nine knows a levin on

5895
04:24:54,215 --> 04:24:57,215
the urgency eyes twenty nine

5896
04:24:57,651 --> 04:24:58,261
knows eleven on the item on the

5897
04:24:58,261 --> 04:25:01,261
measure is it assembly members

5898
04:25:01,428 --> 04:25:05,280
are concurred in. Next up is

5899
04:25:09,997 --> 04:25:13,737
file item five. S. B. Two ten.

5900
04:25:13,737 --> 04:25:16,737
Allen a rhetorical role allen.

5901
04:25:23,513 --> 04:25:26,149
by galgiani. Jones no. I ste

5902
04:25:26,149 --> 04:25:29,451
twenty eight nos eleven on the

5903
04:25:29,451 --> 04:25:32,451
concurrent. As it is certainly

5904
04:25:33,652 --> 04:25:36,652
members are concurred in. Next

5905
04:25:37,156 --> 04:25:40,592
up is file item six sb five

5906
04:25:40,592 --> 04:25:43,592
fifty. In this sector please

5907
04:25:46,498 --> 04:25:48,900
call absent members. Allen by.

5908
04:25:48,900 --> 04:25:51,300
Ice thirty eight nielsen

5909
04:25:54,775 --> 04:25:55,273
nielsen notify. Our eyes thirty

5910
04:25:55,273 --> 04:25:57,711
nine a nose one assembly

5911
04:25:57,711 --> 04:26:00,711
members are concurred in. Next

5912
04:26:01,779 --> 04:26:02,346
up is file item seven sb six oh

5913
04:26:02,346 --> 04:26:05,346
nine Miss Sector please call

5914
04:26:20,228 --> 04:26:22,628
after members. Allen hi

5915
04:26:35,209 --> 04:26:37,111
gorgeous. Hi our eyes forty.

5916
04:26:37,111 --> 04:26:40,146
Ice forty no zero the someone

5917
04:26:40,146 --> 04:26:42,913
members are concurred in. Last

5918
04:26:42,913 --> 04:26:45,418
but not least we have file item

5919
04:26:45,418 --> 04:26:45,985
eight sb one own nine Mister

5920
04:26:45,985 --> 04:26:48,985
Terry please call the absent

5921
04:26:55,162 --> 04:26:55,792
members. Allen hi stone. I was

5922
04:26:55,792 --> 04:26:57,997
twenty nine and knows ten that

5923
04:26:57,997 --> 04:26:59,567
the some limits are concurred

5924
04:26:59,567 --> 04:27:02,567
in. That completes our-on call

5925
04:27:07,406 --> 04:27:07,971
items gives a minute. Members

5926
04:27:07,971 --> 04:27:10,971
were movie back to assembly

5927
04:27:11,444 --> 04:27:13,844
third reading. File item

5928
04:27:27,586 --> 04:27:29,586
nineteen

5929
04:27:34,270 --> 04:27:34,529
. All right. By

5930
04:27:34,529 --> 04:27:36,929
changing plans right now

5931
04:27:50,941 --> 04:27:53,941
members it was a minute

5932
04:29:15,319 --> 04:29:17,319
. Our

5933
04:29:18,510 --> 04:29:19,792
members removing a to file item

5934
04:29:19,792 --> 04:29:20,355
forty four assembly third

5935
04:29:20,355 --> 04:29:23,355
reading sherri hill are you

5936
04:29:25,826 --> 04:29:27,962
prepared. This sector please

5937
04:29:27,962 --> 04:29:29,797
rate assembly bill seven fifty

5938
04:29:29,797 --> 04:29:32,797
four by assembly member grayson

5939
04:29:33,939 --> 04:29:34,160
an act relating to regional

5940
04:29:34,160 --> 04:29:34,332
notification centers. When

5941
04:29:34,332 --> 04:29:35,235
you're ready senator hill thank

5942
04:29:35,235 --> 04:29:37,474
you thank you Mister President

5943
04:29:37,474 --> 04:29:40,274
and colleagues. Is a co author

5944
04:29:40,274 --> 04:29:40,844
I'm happy to present ab seven

5945
04:29:40,844 --> 04:29:43,600
fifty four on behalf of

5946
04:29:43,600 --> 04:29:44,980
assembly member grayson. This

5947
04:29:44,980 --> 04:29:46,512
measure allows eight one one

5948
04:29:46,512 --> 04:29:48,882
centers to receive the most

5949
04:29:48,882 --> 04:29:50,383
current g. I. S. Mapping data

5950
04:29:50,383 --> 04:29:51,817
this will enable these centers

5951
04:29:51,817 --> 04:29:53,850
to fulfill their statutorily

5952
04:29:53,850 --> 04:29:55,988
mandated duty to protect

5953
04:29:55,988 --> 04:29:57,790
california's infrastructure. By

5954
04:29:57,790 --> 04:29:59,790
notifying underground facility

5955
04:30:00,325 --> 04:30:02,725
owners about nearby excavation

5956
04:30:03,364 --> 04:30:04,596
furthermore. Eighty seven fifty

5957
04:30:04,596 --> 04:30:06,898
four will require applications

5958
04:30:06,898 --> 04:30:08,269
for solar energy permits to

5959
04:30:08,269 --> 04:30:09,765
reference the existing

5960
04:30:09,765 --> 04:30:11,767
requirements to notify a

5961
04:30:11,767 --> 04:30:13,767
regional regional notification

5962
04:30:15,340 --> 04:30:18,340
center of that person's intent

5963
04:30:18,880 --> 04:30:19,480
to excavate before activating.

5964
04:30:19,480 --> 04:30:19,977
The bill will also require the

5965
04:30:19,977 --> 04:30:21,279
office of planning and

5966
04:30:21,279 --> 04:30:22,713
resources to add a reference to

5967
04:30:22,713 --> 04:30:24,681
which california solar

5968
04:30:24,681 --> 04:30:25,983
permitting guide book regarding

5969
04:30:25,983 --> 04:30:27,985
this requirement there's no

5970
04:30:27,985 --> 04:30:28,552
opposition to this measure. I

5971
04:30:28,552 --> 04:30:30,685
respectfully ask your rival

5972
04:30:30,685 --> 04:30:33,850
colleagues. Thank you any

5973
04:30:33,590 --> 04:30:34,758
discussion of it on this item.

5974
04:30:34,758 --> 04:30:36,493
This is a candidate for

5975
04:30:36,493 --> 04:30:37,294
unanimous roll call is there

5976
04:30:37,294 --> 04:30:39,694
any objection to using

5977
04:30:39,796 --> 04:30:42,796
unanimous roll call. On item

5978
04:30:43,720 --> 04:30:45,735
forty four. Hearing you see

5979
04:30:45,735 --> 04:30:49,335
nine. Eyes forty no zero the

5980
04:31:05,221 --> 04:31:08,821
measure passes. Next up is file

5981
04:33:01,595 --> 04:33:03,259
.

5982
04:33:03,259 --> 04:33:06,259
Our members rumored to file

5983
04:33:06,795 --> 04:33:07,362
item seventeen. Senator in

5984
04:33:07,362 --> 04:33:10,362
dollars are you prepared for

5985
04:33:10,563 --> 04:33:12,963
this item. Mister Secretary

5986
04:33:13,302 --> 04:33:13,899
please rate assembly bill one

5987
04:33:13,899 --> 04:33:14,466
seventy one by assembly member

5988
04:33:14,466 --> 04:33:16,766
gonzalez and act really into

5989
04:33:16,766 --> 04:33:18,137
employment. Sooner gonzalez

5990
04:33:18,137 --> 04:33:20,770
thank you Mister President and

5991
04:33:20,770 --> 04:33:21,307
members I rise to present ab

5992
04:33:21,307 --> 04:33:23,606
one seven one by assembly

5993
04:33:23,606 --> 04:33:24,376
member gonzalez ab one seventy

5994
04:33:24,376 --> 04:33:26,111
one protects victims of

5995
04:33:26,111 --> 04:33:27,112
workplace sexual harassment and

5996
04:33:27,112 --> 04:33:28,780
assaults by creating

5997
04:33:28,780 --> 04:33:30,517
retaliation protections under

5998
04:33:30,517 --> 04:33:32,419
the labor code. Establishing a

5999
04:33:32,419 --> 04:33:33,818
rebuttable presumption of

6000
04:33:33,818 --> 04:33:35,860
unlawful retaliation if an

6001
04:33:35,860 --> 04:33:37,486
employer takes an adverse

6002
04:33:37,558 --> 04:33:38,389
action against employee within

6003
04:33:38,389 --> 04:33:39,790
ninety days of the employers

6004
04:33:39,790 --> 04:33:41,725
knowledge of the employees

6005
04:33:41,725 --> 04:33:42,659
status as a victim of domestic

6006
04:33:42,659 --> 04:33:44,561
violence sexual assault for

6007
04:33:44,561 --> 04:33:45,896
stocking. A let's be clear

6008
04:33:45,896 --> 04:33:47,264
though vulnerable employees

6009
04:33:47,264 --> 04:33:48,999
mostly low wage working women

6010
04:33:48,999 --> 04:33:50,300
are often left behind in these

6011
04:33:50,300 --> 04:33:52,300
conversations around workplace

6012
04:33:53,690 --> 04:33:54,237
protections approximately 50%

6013
04:33:54,237 --> 04:33:55,205
of workers who experience

6014
04:33:55,205 --> 04:33:57,306
sexual harassment in the

6015
04:33:57,306 --> 04:33:58,539
workplace have not reported it

6016
04:33:58,539 --> 04:34:00,174
because of fear of retaliation

6017
04:34:00,174 --> 04:34:01,710
threats of. Our to pay

6018
04:34:01,710 --> 04:34:03,211
reduction as well as job loss

6019
04:34:03,211 --> 04:34:06,211
this bill would extend recovery

6020
04:34:06,512 --> 04:34:06,948
please protections victims of

6021
04:34:06,948 --> 04:34:07,513
sexual harassment I

6022
04:34:07,513 --> 04:34:10,513
respectfully ask for an aye

6023
04:34:12,819 --> 04:34:13,751
vote. Any further description

6024
04:34:13,751 --> 04:34:15,288
of the page on the site on.

6025
04:34:15,288 --> 04:34:17,122
Hearing seen none receptor

6026
04:34:17,122 --> 04:34:20,722
please call the roll allen. By

6027
04:34:21,696 --> 04:34:24,426
archuleta I atkins aye bates

6028
04:34:24,426 --> 04:34:28,260
well I bridges no bradford I

6029
04:34:29,200 --> 04:34:32,800
can be era. I chiang delhi.

6030
04:34:33,869 --> 04:34:36,869
Dodd. I dorado I galgiani.

6031
04:34:41,479 --> 04:34:43,780
Glazer. Gonzalez I growth. No

6032
04:34:43,780 --> 04:34:46,780
hertzberg aye hill aye hueso

6033
04:34:49,286 --> 04:34:52,886
buyer taco. Jackson by jones no

6034
04:34:53,623 --> 04:34:56,623
leyva time acquire by mitchell

6035
04:34:57,460 --> 04:35:01,600
hi money. I'm more lock. Number

6036
04:35:03,299 --> 04:35:06,899
rail. No nielsen no pan hi

6037
04:35:07,403 --> 04:35:11,300
portantino I roth aye rubio aye

6038
04:35:13,305 --> 04:35:16,905
skinner I stern aye stone. No

6039
04:35:17,979 --> 04:35:21,579
burke our caskey by winner. By

6040
04:35:24,922 --> 04:35:27,419
wilk no. We will not have any

6041
04:35:27,419 --> 04:35:29,819
disruption in the chamber.

6042
04:35:43,600 --> 04:35:45,600
Sergeants

6043
04:36:03,353 --> 04:36:05,353
. Rockets. I caucus

6044
04:36:07,355 --> 04:36:09,900
please. Bridge is going to be a

6045
04:36:09,900 --> 04:36:09,726
democratic caucus in a matter

6046
04:36:09,726 --> 04:36:13,326
allows will be in recess during

6047
04:36:15,596 --> 04:36:17,996
caucus. Bernie suspend roll

6048
04:36:18,696 --> 04:36:21,960
call for democratic caucus.

6049
04:36:21,566 --> 04:36:22,834
Republican senator growth thank

6050
04:36:22,834 --> 04:36:24,100
you Mister President republican

6051
04:36:24,100 --> 04:36:24,568
caucus in the matter many lack

6052
04:36:24,568 --> 04:36:24,722
our skis me the-

6053
04:36:24,722 --> 04:36:24,879
-

6054
04:36:24,879 --> 04:36:25,260
-

6055
04:36:25,260 --> 04:36:26,837
-

6056
04:36:26,837 --> 04:36:27,369
lounge

6057
04:36:27,369 --> 04:36:27,733
there will be a republican

6058
04:36:27,733 --> 04:36:27,880
caucus in the-

6059
04:36:27,880 --> 04:36:28,390
-

6060
04:36:28,390 --> 04:36:28,193
-

6061
04:36:28,193 --> 04:36:28,341
-

6062
04:36:28,341 --> 04:36:30,341
l

6063
04:37:39,566 --> 04:37:41,204
legislation left to do our I

6064
04:37:41,204 --> 04:37:43,705
want to thank speaker anthony

6065
04:37:43,705 --> 04:37:46,273
rendon hi he has been most

6066
04:37:46,273 --> 04:37:48,341
gracious to offer their

6067
04:37:48,341 --> 04:37:49,943
services in any way possible to

6068
04:37:49,943 --> 04:37:51,341
help us continue to do the

6069
04:37:51,341 --> 04:37:53,343
work. Most important I want to

6070
04:37:53,343 --> 04:37:55,743
thank my colleagues republican

6071
04:37:56,282 --> 04:37:58,682
and democratic colleagues and

6072
04:37:59,285 --> 04:38:01,685
your incredible staffs are

6073
04:38:04,223 --> 04:38:06,422
staff. Five. This is unusual

6074
04:38:06,422 --> 04:38:07,793
obviously but I have to say how

6075
04:38:07,793 --> 04:38:09,394
proud I am as the President Pro

6076
04:38:09,394 --> 04:38:11,897
tem of the senate. That we can

6077
04:38:11,897 --> 04:38:14,735
come together and focus on the

6078
04:38:14,735 --> 04:38:16,534
job and the work at hand and

6079
04:38:16,534 --> 04:38:17,136
continue to do what our

6080
04:38:17,136 --> 04:38:20,136
constituents sent us here. To

6081
04:38:24,106 --> 04:38:26,211
do. Thank you. I think you said

6082
04:38:26,211 --> 04:38:26,777
it pro tem it is with a heavy

6083
04:38:26,777 --> 04:38:27,414
heart that I can before you

6084
04:38:27,414 --> 04:38:29,312
guys and tell you that first of

6085
04:38:29,312 --> 04:38:32,315
all I'm deeply sorry for what

6086
04:38:32,315 --> 04:38:33,380
happened on the senate floor I

6087
04:38:33,380 --> 04:38:36,951
also want you to know that

6088
04:38:36,951 --> 04:38:40,551
violence of any type will not

6089
04:38:40,889 --> 04:38:43,889
be condoned. Or. Or tolerated

6090
04:38:44,392 --> 04:38:45,295
in any way shape or form by any

6091
04:38:45,295 --> 04:38:48,295
of es republican democrat it

6092
04:38:48,695 --> 04:38:50,230
doesn't matter. And the person

6093
04:38:50,230 --> 04:38:52,199
that is sam in question should

6094
04:38:52,199 --> 04:38:55,199
be. Prosecuted to the fullest

6095
04:38:56,536 --> 04:38:57,570
extent of the law. And I

6096
04:38:57,570 --> 04:38:58,104
support the you know the chp

6097
04:38:58,104 --> 04:38:59,808
officers that have are in

6098
04:38:59,808 --> 04:39:01,107
custody right now I do want to

6099
04:39:01,107 --> 04:39:04,707
echo the comments of the senate

6100
04:39:05,346 --> 04:39:05,975
pro tem intel and the entire

6101
04:39:05,975 --> 04:39:06,846
staff especially jody in the in

6102
04:39:06,846 --> 04:39:07,846
this our chief and-just

6103
04:39:07,846 --> 04:39:09,215
kimberly and everybody that was

6104
04:39:09,215 --> 04:39:10,149
named individually by the

6105
04:39:10,149 --> 04:39:12,697
senate pro tem and all of you

6106
04:39:12,697 --> 04:39:13,731
as our colleagues. That we are

6107
04:39:13,731 --> 04:39:15,170
able to come together even the

6108
04:39:15,170 --> 04:39:16,855
disagreements disappears they

6109
04:39:16,855 --> 04:39:20,550
were on the floor today earlier

6110
04:39:20,550 --> 04:39:21,928
between each of us we can still

6111
04:39:21,928 --> 04:39:24,928
come together adapting do what

6112
04:39:25,129 --> 04:39:29,310
needs to be done to finish the

6113
04:39:29,310 --> 04:39:29,932
people's business. So thank you.

6114
04:39:29,932 --> 04:39:32,340
Thank you so much let me not

6115
04:39:32,340 --> 04:39:33,300
forget to add our appreciation

6116
04:39:33,300 --> 04:39:34,703
and thanks to. The california

6117
04:39:34,703 --> 04:39:36,572
highway patrol. And all of law

6118
04:39:36,572 --> 04:39:37,720
enforcement it's busy doing the

6119
04:39:37,720 --> 04:39:39,710
work they need to do to

6120
04:39:39,710 --> 04:39:41,710
complete this investigation.

6121
04:39:41,107 --> 04:39:41,741
And with that we will get back

6122
04:39:41,741 --> 04:39:44,741
to work Mister President. Thank

6123
04:39:46,913 --> 04:39:50,513
you. Thank you Madam Pro tem

6124
04:39:52,418 --> 04:39:53,385
and with. Minority leader bob

6125
04:39:53,385 --> 04:39:54,555
we're going to go over some

6126
04:39:54,555 --> 04:39:55,920
house rules to our search

6127
04:39:55,920 --> 04:39:56,452
personal circumstances tonight

6128
04:39:56,452 --> 04:39:57,856
for those members who are

6129
04:39:57,856 --> 04:39:58,958
presenting bills will present

6130
04:39:58,958 --> 04:39:59,858
from the podium appear on the

6131
04:39:59,858 --> 04:40:01,159
riser those members who choose

6132
04:40:01,159 --> 04:40:04,129
to speak on a particular matter

6133
04:40:04,129 --> 04:40:05,263
we have microphones on both

6134
04:40:05,263 --> 04:40:06,764
sides of the house so choose

6135
04:40:06,764 --> 04:40:08,832
to. Line up if you choose or

6136
04:40:08,832 --> 04:40:10,934
stand up and be recognized at

6137
04:40:10,934 --> 04:40:12,669
the microphone if you choose to

6138
04:40:12,669 --> 04:40:14,370
speak on a particular matter

6139
04:40:14,370 --> 04:40:17,603
and we're gonna return back to

6140
04:40:17,603 --> 04:40:21,203
the daily file and we're moving

6141
04:40:23,679 --> 04:40:24,180
back to file item seventeen. Us

6142
04:40:24,180 --> 04:40:26,580
senator gonzalez are you

6143
04:40:30,840 --> 04:40:30,951
prepared. That's right will but

6144
04:40:30,951 --> 04:40:32,284
we we're we're we're taking a

6145
04:40:32,284 --> 04:40:34,454
roll call members were doing

6146
04:40:34,454 --> 04:40:36,956
roll call an item seventeen a.

6147
04:40:36,956 --> 04:40:37,525
B. Seven I mean one seven one.

6148
04:40:37,525 --> 04:40:39,925
Mister Secretary please call

6149
04:40:49,701 --> 04:40:52,701
the roll. Allen archuleta. Hi

6150
04:40:58,509 --> 04:41:02,109
atkins by. Eight no bell by

6151
04:41:07,510 --> 04:41:09,451
burgess. Yeah for just.

6152
04:41:10,854 --> 04:41:14,454
Bradford hi by words no borders

6153
04:41:21,361 --> 04:41:24,961
no. No hertzberg. I hill aye

6154
04:41:25,568 --> 04:41:29,168
aye aye hueso aye. Tado by

6155
04:41:33,944 --> 04:41:38,144
jackson. I jones no leyva hi I

6156
04:41:39,140 --> 04:41:42,140
mcguire hi mitchell hi hi

6157
04:41:44,118 --> 04:41:47,718
monning I'm more lark no morale

6158
04:41:48,589 --> 04:41:51,589
no nielsen no pan hi.

6159
04:41:54,895 --> 04:41:58,495
Portantino hi ross by rubio I

6160
04:41:59,669 --> 04:42:03,269
skinner aye stern aye stone no

6161
04:42:03,370 --> 04:42:06,370
number iowa county hi aye

6162
04:42:12,276 --> 04:42:15,276
wiener aye wilk no. Mister

6163
04:42:27,993 --> 04:42:28,627
President will call. Our

6164
04:42:28,627 --> 04:42:32,227
members were moving now to file

6165
04:42:34,297 --> 04:42:37,297
item fifty. Sir glazer you're

6166
04:42:37,870 --> 04:42:38,468
prepared for that item. One

6167
04:42:38,468 --> 04:42:42,680
hallmark were take time out be

6168
04:42:54,737 --> 04:42:56,737
free time out

6169
04:43:14,101 --> 04:43:15,806
. Some of. Our

6170
04:43:15,806 --> 04:43:17,300
members were make an exception

6171
04:43:17,300 --> 04:43:19,973
we're gonna announced a roll

6172
04:43:19,973 --> 04:43:22,973
call vote on item seventeen

6173
04:43:23,142 --> 04:43:25,378
it's twenty seven eyes nose can

6174
04:43:25,378 --> 04:43:26,120
at this moment the more the

6175
04:43:26,120 --> 04:43:29,682
item will be placed back on the

6176
04:43:29,682 --> 04:43:31,551
call. Senator glazer when

6177
04:43:31,551 --> 04:43:32,553
you're prepared Mister

6178
04:43:32,553 --> 04:43:34,953
Secretary please read item

6179
04:43:36,522 --> 04:43:37,924
fifty. Assembly bill forty

6180
04:43:37,924 --> 04:43:38,424
eight by assemblymember

6181
04:43:38,424 --> 04:43:40,824
o'donnell anak really to

6182
04:43:42,260 --> 04:43:44,363
education finance. Glazer this

6183
04:43:44,363 --> 04:43:45,229
presidente and members at first

6184
04:43:45,229 --> 04:43:47,950
as a point of personal

6185
04:43:47,950 --> 04:43:48,265
privilege to me thank everyone

6186
04:43:48,265 --> 04:43:50,868
for getting us organized again

6187
04:43:50,868 --> 04:43:51,469
to complete our business today

6188
04:43:51,469 --> 04:43:52,690
and-answer the because of the

6189
04:43:52,690 --> 04:43:54,369
bill that I'm going to present

6190
04:43:54,369 --> 04:43:55,935
to you. Present to you now.

6191
04:43:55,935 --> 04:43:57,906
Assembly bill forty eight

6192
04:43:57,906 --> 04:43:58,606
places a fifteen billion dollar

6193
04:43:58,606 --> 04:44:00,709
k. Through twelve through

6194
04:44:00,709 --> 04:44:02,544
higher education bond. On the

6195
04:44:02,544 --> 04:44:04,470
March twenty twenty dollars.

6196
04:44:04,470 --> 04:44:05,610
The bond includes nine billion

6197
04:44:05,610 --> 04:44:07,147
dollars for preschool through

6198
04:44:07,147 --> 04:44:07,782
grade twelve two billion

6199
04:44:07,782 --> 04:44:10,182
dollars for the california

6200
04:44:10,185 --> 04:44:10,951
community colleges. Two billion

6201
04:44:10,951 --> 04:44:12,619
dollars for the california

6202
04:44:12,619 --> 04:44:13,190
state university in two billion

6203
04:44:13,190 --> 04:44:15,756
dollars to the university of

6204
04:44:15,756 --> 04:44:17,540
california. Recent amendments

6205
04:44:17,540 --> 04:44:18,580
to this bill reflect changes

6206
04:44:18,580 --> 04:44:20,580
requested by the

6207
04:44:20,160 --> 04:44:22,160
administration. In consultation

6208
04:44:22,162 --> 04:44:24,328
with the authors office and

6209
04:44:24,328 --> 04:44:25,801
senate and assembly leadership.

6210
04:44:25,801 --> 04:44:27,303
The bill makes changes to the

6211
04:44:27,303 --> 04:44:28,635
k. Through twelve school

6212
04:44:28,635 --> 04:44:30,939
facility program including the

6213
04:44:30,939 --> 04:44:32,769
following. Increasing the state

6214
04:44:32,769 --> 04:44:33,970
match for low well districts

6215
04:44:33,970 --> 04:44:35,674
and districts with higher

6216
04:44:35,674 --> 04:44:38,444
percentage of low income foster

6217
04:44:38,444 --> 04:44:40,149
care. An e. L. Students. By

6218
04:44:40,149 --> 04:44:41,381
prioritizing the review of

6219
04:44:41,381 --> 04:44:43,381
certain applications including

6220
04:44:43,482 --> 04:44:45,283
health and safety. Applications

6221
04:44:45,283 --> 04:44:48,283
that remediate lead in drinking

6222
04:44:49,187 --> 04:44:49,779
water that provide. A priority

6223
04:44:49,779 --> 04:44:52,190
for lower well districts and

6224
04:44:52,190 --> 04:44:53,758
for overcrowded schools. By

6225
04:44:53,758 --> 04:44:56,194
allowing state bond funds to be

6226
04:44:56,194 --> 04:44:56,798
used for the construction of

6227
04:44:56,798 --> 04:44:57,595
preschool classrooms kitchens

6228
04:44:57,595 --> 04:44:59,831
in space for counselors and

6229
04:44:59,831 --> 04:45:01,826
nurses. By adjusting the cap on

6230
04:45:01,826 --> 04:45:03,668
local bonding to augment school

6231
04:45:03,668 --> 04:45:06,680
and community college districts

6232
04:45:06,102 --> 04:45:09,360
ability to raise local funds.

6233
04:45:09,360 --> 04:45:10,106
And also until January first

6234
04:45:10,106 --> 04:45:11,340
twenty twenty six the bill way

6235
04:45:11,340 --> 04:45:13,672
school impact fees for multi

6236
04:45:13,672 --> 04:45:15,179
housing projects located within

6237
04:45:15,179 --> 04:45:17,178
one a half a mile of a transit

6238
04:45:17,178 --> 04:45:19,614
stop. And reduces school impact

6239
04:45:19,614 --> 04:45:21,983
fees by 20% for other multi

6240
04:45:21,983 --> 04:45:22,984
family housing projects. And

6241
04:45:22,984 --> 04:45:25,619
finally here the bill also

6242
04:45:25,619 --> 04:45:26,587
spends level three fees until

6243
04:45:26,587 --> 04:45:28,856
January first twenty twenty

6244
04:45:28,856 --> 04:45:29,824
eight. Now ab forty eight also

6245
04:45:29,824 --> 04:45:31,658
provides funds for the

6246
04:45:31,658 --> 04:45:33,391
following programssmall school

6247
04:45:33,391 --> 04:45:35,192
district assistance testing

6248
04:45:35,192 --> 04:45:37,394
remediation of letting water.

6249
04:45:37,394 --> 04:45:39,200
Disaster assistance career

6250
04:45:39,200 --> 04:45:40,734
technical education and charter

6251
04:45:40,734 --> 04:45:41,970
schools. On the higher

6252
04:45:41,970 --> 04:45:43,870
education side the bill

6253
04:45:43,870 --> 04:45:46,238
prioritizes funding for uc and

6254
04:45:46,238 --> 04:45:48,641
csu projects. That address fire

6255
04:45:48,641 --> 04:45:49,745
and life safety seismic and

6256
04:45:49,745 --> 04:45:51,745
critical deferred maintenance

6257
04:45:52,445 --> 04:45:54,446
issues. And requires uc and csu

6258
04:45:54,446 --> 04:45:57,216
to adopt five year affordable

6259
04:45:57,216 --> 04:45:59,616
student housing plans. Members

6260
04:45:59,751 --> 04:46:00,982
the need is great. In fact much

6261
04:46:00,982 --> 04:46:03,153
greater than what is provided

6262
04:46:03,153 --> 04:46:07,190
in this bill. But this bond is

6263
04:46:07,190 --> 04:46:07,724
in is an important step forward

6264
04:46:07,724 --> 04:46:08,358
for all of our educational

6265
04:46:08,358 --> 04:46:11,358
institutions and there's an aye

6266
04:46:12,280 --> 04:46:14,230
vote. Any description of it on

6267
04:46:14,230 --> 04:46:17,230
the item senator morlock. Risk

6268
04:46:18,434 --> 04:46:21,170
President. Colleagues I rise in

6269
04:46:21,170 --> 04:46:22,738
opposition to a. B. Forty eight

6270
04:46:22,738 --> 04:46:24,373
colleagues I have some good

6271
04:46:24,373 --> 04:46:26,737
news and I have some bad news.

6272
04:46:26,737 --> 04:46:28,441
So start with the bad news.

6273
04:46:28,441 --> 04:46:30,176
California's unrestricted net

6274
04:46:30,176 --> 04:46:32,412
deficit grew by forty three

6275
04:46:32,412 --> 04:46:34,812
point eight billion dollars.

6276
04:46:34,814 --> 04:46:36,451
And the last year. The

6277
04:46:36,451 --> 04:46:38,484
unrestricted net deficit for

6278
04:46:38,484 --> 04:46:39,484
June thirty twenty seventeen

6279
04:46:39,484 --> 04:46:41,123
was a hundred and sixty nine

6280
04:46:41,123 --> 04:46:43,489
point five billion. For the

6281
04:46:43,489 --> 04:46:44,289
year ended June thirty twenty

6282
04:46:44,289 --> 04:46:46,455
eighteen it's now two hundred

6283
04:46:46,455 --> 04:46:48,657
and thirteen point three

6284
04:46:48,657 --> 04:46:49,807
billion dollars. The major

6285
04:46:49,807 --> 04:46:51,930
reason for the increase

6286
04:46:51,930 --> 04:46:52,130
colleagues was because the

6287
04:46:52,130 --> 04:46:54,130
government accounting standards

6288
04:46:54,464 --> 04:46:56,669
board that requires finally

6289
04:46:56,669 --> 04:46:58,368
that unfunded actuarial accrued

6290
04:46:58,368 --> 04:46:59,571
liabilities for retiree medical

6291
04:46:59,571 --> 04:47:01,470
plans be included on the

6292
04:47:01,470 --> 04:47:03,839
balance sheet. So in this last

6293
04:47:03,839 --> 04:47:05,807
year california's balance sheet

6294
04:47:05,807 --> 04:47:07,420
is more miserable by another

6295
04:47:07,420 --> 04:47:09,846
twenty five percent. The good

6296
04:47:09,846 --> 04:47:12,681
news is that there were three

6297
04:47:12,681 --> 04:47:13,281
states that there on restricted

6298
04:47:13,281 --> 04:47:16,281
that deficits group much more

6299
04:47:16,613 --> 04:47:17,153
than ours. Illinois grew by

6300
04:47:17,153 --> 04:47:19,553
forty eight point seven

6301
04:47:20,190 --> 04:47:22,452
billion. New jersey by sixty

6302
04:47:22,452 --> 04:47:23,220
five point two billion. And

6303
04:47:23,220 --> 04:47:26,220
taxes by seventy nine point

6304
04:47:26,158 --> 04:47:28,158
five billion. Traditionally

6305
04:47:28,428 --> 04:47:29,829
every year california's had the

6306
04:47:29,829 --> 04:47:31,829
largest unrestricted net

6307
04:47:32,197 --> 04:47:32,767
deficit always placing and

6308
04:47:32,767 --> 04:47:35,130
fifty of place but this year

6309
04:47:35,130 --> 04:47:36,401
there's some good news. Because

6310
04:47:36,401 --> 04:47:39,710
new jersey had such a large

6311
04:47:39,710 --> 04:47:40,271
increase it is now at two

6312
04:47:40,271 --> 04:47:42,371
hundred and fourteen point one

6313
04:47:42,371 --> 04:47:44,806
billion dollars it just edged

6314
04:47:44,806 --> 04:47:46,944
out california with the largest

6315
04:47:46,944 --> 04:47:48,112
on funded. Are should be

6316
04:47:48,112 --> 04:47:49,680
unrestricted net deficit be

6317
04:47:49,680 --> 04:47:50,684
this out by knows the word in

6318
04:47:50,684 --> 04:47:52,583
forty ninth place which is

6319
04:47:52,583 --> 04:47:53,848
probably where we should be

6320
04:47:53,848 --> 04:47:55,389
being a forty niner from long

6321
04:47:55,389 --> 04:47:57,388
beach state kinda cool but

6322
04:47:57,388 --> 04:47:59,156
texas a group to a hundred and

6323
04:47:59,156 --> 04:48:01,157
four point six billion. So if

6324
04:48:01,157 --> 04:48:03,691
you combine those four states

6325
04:48:03,691 --> 04:48:04,260
their unrestricted net deficits

6326
04:48:04,260 --> 04:48:05,995
total of three quarters of a

6327
04:48:05,995 --> 04:48:06,562
trillion dollars. Colleagues

6328
04:48:06,562 --> 04:48:08,962
california doesn't need more

6329
04:48:10,867 --> 04:48:13,335
debt. And if it is paid out of

6330
04:48:13,335 --> 04:48:15,237
the general fund as opposed to

6331
04:48:15,237 --> 04:48:16,569
prop ninety eight the interest

6332
04:48:16,569 --> 04:48:18,400
and principal payments will

6333
04:48:18,400 --> 04:48:20,740
crowd out other critical

6334
04:48:20,740 --> 04:48:21,644
program funding looking at

6335
04:48:21,644 --> 04:48:22,678
fifteen billion dollars you're

6336
04:48:22,678 --> 04:48:23,378
probably looking at another

6337
04:48:23,378 --> 04:48:26,314
eight hundred million dollars a

6338
04:48:26,314 --> 04:48:27,983
year. In interest and principal

6339
04:48:27,983 --> 04:48:30,383
payments colleagues we've also

6340
04:48:31,253 --> 04:48:32,684
seen the an inverted yield

6341
04:48:32,684 --> 04:48:34,886
curve arrive again I've dealt

6342
04:48:34,886 --> 04:48:37,258
with this in times past than it

6343
04:48:37,258 --> 04:48:39,560
did portends a recession is on

6344
04:48:39,560 --> 04:48:41,280
the horizon horizon adding it

6345
04:48:41,280 --> 04:48:43,365
so adding more bond payments

6346
04:48:43,365 --> 04:48:44,532
which are fixed costs to our

6347
04:48:44,532 --> 04:48:46,534
budget will be very imprudent

6348
04:48:46,534 --> 04:48:48,435
at this time. Consequently

6349
04:48:48,435 --> 04:48:50,703
regardless of how good the

6350
04:48:50,703 --> 04:48:52,170
causes for borrowing with too

6351
04:48:52,170 --> 04:48:53,305
much debt of all poll tax

6352
04:48:53,305 --> 04:48:55,305
system growing pension

6353
04:48:55,404 --> 04:48:56,174
contribution costs and a

6354
04:48:56,174 --> 04:48:58,900
potential recessionon the

6355
04:48:58,900 --> 04:48:59,710
horizon I would urge a no vote

6356
04:48:59,710 --> 04:49:00,948
in advice at this legislature

6357
04:49:00,948 --> 04:49:02,613
focus on paying cash for

6358
04:49:02,613 --> 04:49:04,450
improvements and setting funds

6359
04:49:04,450 --> 04:49:05,480
aside now for its future

6360
04:49:05,480 --> 04:49:07,321
maintenance just like we

6361
04:49:07,321 --> 04:49:08,756
require homeowners associations

6362
04:49:08,756 --> 04:49:11,755
to do. Thank you Mister

6363
04:49:11,755 --> 04:49:15,225
President and I urge a no vote

6364
04:49:15,225 --> 04:49:18,929
on a. B. Forty eight. Thank you

6365
04:49:18,929 --> 04:49:20,130
senator borders. Thank you

6366
04:49:20,130 --> 04:49:21,731
Mister President and I also

6367
04:49:21,731 --> 04:49:24,334
want to thank you for being as

6368
04:49:24,334 --> 04:49:26,169
nimble as you you have been in

6369
04:49:26,169 --> 04:49:29,769
making this this new venue work

6370
04:49:31,373 --> 04:49:31,974
out for all of us. A I have

6371
04:49:31,974 --> 04:49:34,744
great respect for my colleague

6372
04:49:34,744 --> 04:49:37,644
from the orange county. Now

6373
04:49:37,644 --> 04:49:40,644
however there are certain needs

6374
04:49:40,715 --> 04:49:42,161
that are essential in our state.

6375
04:49:42,161 --> 04:49:44,319
That at this point cannot be

6376
04:49:44,319 --> 04:49:47,319
satisfied by a general fund

6377
04:49:47,920 --> 04:49:50,191
expenditure. We have in under

6378
04:49:50,191 --> 04:49:51,920
this proposal we have two

6379
04:49:51,920 --> 04:49:52,260
billion they'll be going to

6380
04:49:52,260 --> 04:49:54,660
communicate all ages two

6381
04:49:54,758 --> 04:49:58,131
billion to uc's in two billion

6382
04:49:58,131 --> 04:49:58,765
to see issues on top of the

6383
04:49:58,765 --> 04:50:02,637
nine that would be going to the

6384
04:50:02,637 --> 04:50:05,170
k. Through twelve. I have some

6385
04:50:05,170 --> 04:50:07,500
serious reservations about some

6386
04:50:07,500 --> 04:50:10,500
of the poison pills. Better

6387
04:50:10,942 --> 04:50:11,673
that are in this. And the

6388
04:50:11,673 --> 04:50:15,273
question that I've had to ask

6389
04:50:15,713 --> 04:50:18,583
myself is the needs so great

6390
04:50:18,583 --> 04:50:20,840
that we must. Move this forward

6391
04:50:20,840 --> 04:50:22,656
and moving this forward is not

6392
04:50:22,656 --> 04:50:25,122
a legislative act in terminus

6393
04:50:25,122 --> 04:50:26,423
it is giving the voters the

6394
04:50:26,423 --> 04:50:28,659
opportunity to make a decision

6395
04:50:28,659 --> 04:50:30,358
on this issue. And I believe it

6396
04:50:30,358 --> 04:50:32,162
is my responsibility has

6397
04:50:32,162 --> 04:50:33,330
represent of the central valley

6398
04:50:33,330 --> 04:50:36,733
one of others one of many

6399
04:50:36,733 --> 04:50:37,300
others is to give this

6400
04:50:37,300 --> 04:50:40,300
opportunity to the voters in

6401
04:50:41,537 --> 04:50:43,674
california. I'm a big champion

6402
04:50:43,674 --> 04:50:44,671
of university california c.

6403
04:50:44,671 --> 04:50:46,909
Issues in our communicators

6404
04:50:46,909 --> 04:50:48,544
occasion systems. And the

6405
04:50:48,544 --> 04:50:50,944
infrastructure needs that we

6406
04:50:52,810 --> 04:50:53,352
have. Are much greater than our

6407
04:50:53,352 --> 04:50:56,352
general fund could ever muster

6408
04:50:56,752 --> 04:50:58,654
in any given year or even three

6409
04:50:58,654 --> 04:51:01,220
or four five years so out of

6410
04:51:01,220 --> 04:51:03,220
necessity this infrastructure

6411
04:51:03,224 --> 04:51:04,326
investment is necessary because

6412
04:51:04,326 --> 04:51:06,992
there is just simply no other

6413
04:51:06,992 --> 04:51:08,898
alternative. I am going to be

6414
04:51:08,898 --> 04:51:11,680
casting an aye vote I encourage

6415
04:51:11,680 --> 04:51:12,900
my colleagues to do the same.

6416
04:51:12,900 --> 04:51:15,506
Maybe not because they agree

6417
04:51:15,506 --> 04:51:17,573
with all of the provisions in

6418
04:51:17,573 --> 04:51:19,600
this piece of legislation. But

6419
04:51:19,600 --> 04:51:21,600
giving californians the

6420
04:51:22,379 --> 04:51:24,378
opportunity and the to vote on

6421
04:51:24,378 --> 04:51:25,646
this and the determination to

6422
04:51:25,646 --> 04:51:27,381
reach their own conclusion I

6423
04:51:27,381 --> 04:51:29,151
think is essential and that is

6424
04:51:29,151 --> 04:51:31,351
while be casting an aye vote in

6425
04:51:31,351 --> 04:51:34,351
favor are of higher education.

6426
04:51:34,454 --> 04:51:36,854
Thank you. Center hertzberg.

6427
04:51:38,923 --> 04:51:41,923
Thank you of. Mister President.

6428
04:51:42,620 --> 04:51:44,329
In the last twenty years. We

6429
04:51:44,329 --> 04:51:46,729
have authorized forty eight

6430
04:51:46,897 --> 04:51:49,297
billion dollars in facilities

6431
04:51:49,602 --> 04:51:50,631
bonds for k. Through fourteen

6432
04:51:50,631 --> 04:51:53,570
u. K. Through twelve community

6433
04:51:53,570 --> 04:51:55,305
colleges the issues and the uc

6434
04:51:55,305 --> 04:51:57,509
system make it sixty three

6435
04:51:57,509 --> 04:51:59,750
billion dollars of facilities.

6436
04:51:59,750 --> 04:52:00,210
Indeed there will be some debt

6437
04:52:00,210 --> 04:52:02,780
burden and I think what was

6438
04:52:02,780 --> 04:52:03,450
indicated by to hear million

6439
04:52:03,450 --> 04:52:05,145
dollars a year is probably

6440
04:52:05,145 --> 04:52:08,145
pretty accurate. And we now

6441
04:52:08,818 --> 04:52:09,417
have eighty one billion dollars

6442
04:52:09,417 --> 04:52:11,619
in state and local funding for

6443
04:52:11,619 --> 04:52:14,693
schools. But is every member in

6444
04:52:14,693 --> 04:52:17,492
this senate. And I think most

6445
04:52:17,492 --> 04:52:18,920
members a california understand

6446
04:52:18,920 --> 04:52:21,161
that education is the core of

6447
04:52:21,161 --> 04:52:22,530
upward mobility. To the matter

6448
04:52:22,530 --> 04:52:24,965
is that are you people foot

6449
04:52:24,965 --> 04:52:27,640
spending in k. To twelve is way

6450
04:52:27,640 --> 04:52:28,301
below what it should be. The

6451
04:52:28,301 --> 04:52:30,301
notion of modernizing

6452
04:52:30,467 --> 04:52:31,238
facilities that we have been

6453
04:52:31,238 --> 04:52:33,371
engaged in is something that is

6454
04:52:33,371 --> 04:52:34,272
critically important. And then

6455
04:52:34,272 --> 04:52:36,905
if you're gonna put a small

6456
04:52:36,905 --> 04:52:39,376
burden of debt what better

6457
04:52:39,376 --> 04:52:41,278
place to do that then for

6458
04:52:41,278 --> 04:52:42,813
education for upward mobility

6459
04:52:42,813 --> 04:52:43,945
for providing opportunities

6460
04:52:43,945 --> 04:52:45,349
when you look at every

6461
04:52:45,349 --> 04:52:46,283
economist left to right

6462
04:52:46,283 --> 04:52:48,118
wherever hey are on this

6463
04:52:48,118 --> 04:52:49,650
political spectrum it is all

6464
04:52:49,650 --> 04:52:51,154
about education is the core we

6465
04:52:51,154 --> 04:52:52,323
talk about it. In the

6466
04:52:52,323 --> 04:52:53,656
opportunity today with

6467
04:52:53,656 --> 04:52:55,221
modernizing these facilities

6468
04:52:55,221 --> 04:52:56,525
with new technologies and

6469
04:52:56,525 --> 04:52:58,927
things that we never dreamed of

6470
04:52:58,927 --> 04:53:00,696
before. Is just extraordinary

6471
04:53:00,696 --> 04:53:02,798
so this is the right thing to

6472
04:53:02,798 --> 04:53:05,834
do I stand in strong support of

6473
04:53:05,834 --> 04:53:08,901
this and I thank the author for

6474
04:53:08,901 --> 04:53:09,471
this authors in both houses for

6475
04:53:09,471 --> 04:53:12,471
this measure. Thank you sir

6476
04:53:12,907 --> 04:53:15,176
nielsen. Down on the senate

6477
04:53:15,176 --> 04:53:17,845
this unfortunate day. For the

6478
04:53:17,845 --> 04:53:20,614
state senate a historic day it

6479
04:53:20,614 --> 04:53:23,885
is also in this respect with

6480
04:53:23,885 --> 04:53:24,718
this bill a fortunate day. The

6481
04:53:24,718 --> 04:53:27,718
fortunate day where we can

6482
04:53:28,819 --> 04:53:29,322
stand up for the a priority I

6483
04:53:29,322 --> 04:53:31,722
think that generally all

6484
04:53:31,826 --> 04:53:33,959
californians hold. For the

6485
04:53:33,959 --> 04:53:36,959
public dollars in the state

6486
04:53:37,164 --> 04:53:37,730
public safety and education. I

6487
04:53:37,730 --> 04:53:41,330
believe is to remain at the

6488
04:53:42,660 --> 04:53:43,436
very top. I spent many many

6489
04:53:43,436 --> 04:53:45,000
years serving on the state

6490
04:53:45,000 --> 04:53:46,903
allocation board I got to learn

6491
04:53:46,903 --> 04:53:49,903
very up front and very

6492
04:53:59,460 --> 04:53:59,264
personally the plight of school

6493
04:53:59,264 --> 04:53:59,410
construction deferred

6494
04:53:59,410 --> 04:53:59,557
maintenance rehabilitation.

6495
04:53:59,557 --> 04:53:59,704
Throughout california through

6496
04:53:59,704 --> 04:54:01,886
trying times then. And even now.

6497
04:54:01,886 --> 04:54:04,450
Many of those facilities have.

6498
04:54:04,450 --> 04:54:07,450
Declined even more not having

6499
04:54:10,192 --> 04:54:10,725
been able to be. Rehabilitated.

6500
04:54:10,725 --> 04:54:12,491
Or have maintenance being

6501
04:54:12,491 --> 04:54:14,891
deferred that's a historic

6502
04:54:15,963 --> 04:54:17,465
problem. And though we have

6503
04:54:17,465 --> 04:54:19,865
declining enrollment in some

6504
04:54:20,131 --> 04:54:20,768
schools in california those are

6505
04:54:20,768 --> 04:54:23,735
generally schools that all have

6506
04:54:23,735 --> 04:54:25,735
huge. Deferred maintenance

6507
04:54:26,370 --> 04:54:29,420
challenge and we will have a

6508
04:54:29,420 --> 04:54:31,420
growing enrollment. Throughout

6509
04:54:34,900 --> 04:54:36,900
higher education. Historically

6510
04:54:36,883 --> 04:54:38,617
their capital outlay issues

6511
04:54:38,617 --> 04:54:40,487
deferred maintenance etcetera

6512
04:54:40,487 --> 04:54:43,487
have been funded through the

6513
04:54:44,188 --> 04:54:44,755
state wide bonds. Local

6514
04:54:44,755 --> 04:54:47,755
districts a region's do not

6515
04:54:48,525 --> 04:54:49,126
have the capability. To come up

6516
04:54:49,126 --> 04:54:51,161
with the amount of money that

6517
04:54:51,161 --> 04:54:53,363
is required. For k. Twelve

6518
04:54:53,363 --> 04:54:55,363
education. That higher

6519
04:54:58,701 --> 04:55:01,101
education. And the previous

6520
04:55:01,874 --> 04:55:02,508
bond that had been passed.

6521
04:55:02,508 --> 04:55:05,508
Because of the financial plight

6522
04:55:05,774 --> 04:55:06,344
of the state. Prior

6523
04:55:06,344 --> 04:55:08,280
administrations have been a

6524
04:55:08,280 --> 04:55:11,280
little tight. And getting money

6525
04:55:11,916 --> 04:55:14,949
out. That we've gone through a

6526
04:55:14,949 --> 04:55:17,349
long trough. Without having

6527
04:55:18,540 --> 04:55:19,588
another bonta for. And

6528
04:55:19,588 --> 04:55:21,988
without having sufficient money

6529
04:55:22,390 --> 04:55:25,990
to keep up. Allocated by that

6530
04:55:27,610 --> 04:55:30,230
board. Now is more time in a

6531
04:55:30,230 --> 04:55:33,230
timely than ever. Because the

6532
04:55:35,338 --> 04:55:36,802
need is greater. We all are

6533
04:55:36,802 --> 04:55:38,703
sensitive to the bonded

6534
04:55:38,703 --> 04:55:40,906
indebtedness of california but

6535
04:55:40,906 --> 04:55:42,343
that is not a product I argue

6536
04:55:42,343 --> 04:55:44,207
up k. Twelve education or

6537
04:55:44,207 --> 04:55:46,207
higher education construction

6538
04:55:47,179 --> 04:55:49,909
etcetera bonds. It is a

6539
04:55:49,909 --> 04:55:50,446
plethora of bonds that we have

6540
04:55:50,446 --> 04:55:53,446
lacked for many many other

6541
04:55:53,586 --> 04:55:56,586
purposes. Far less important in

6542
04:55:57,722 --> 04:55:59,855
education. Then I say in these

6543
04:55:59,855 --> 04:56:03,461
times we have got to harken. To

6544
04:56:03,461 --> 04:56:05,528
the highest of priorities. And

6545
04:56:05,528 --> 04:56:07,928
this most assuredly should

6546
04:56:08,463 --> 04:56:11,165
remain our highest priority. We

6547
04:56:11,165 --> 04:56:13,165
cannot sacrifice those

6548
04:56:14,100 --> 04:56:15,703
institutional facilities needs

6549
04:56:15,703 --> 04:56:17,572
for other other five or ten

6550
04:56:17,572 --> 04:56:19,504
years which is what we will

6551
04:56:19,504 --> 04:56:23,704
indoor if we do not. Pass this

6552
04:56:23,877 --> 04:56:25,980
measure. And then encourage our

6553
04:56:25,980 --> 04:56:28,380
citizens of california to

6554
04:56:28,448 --> 04:56:30,848
support the educational needs

6555
04:56:30,851 --> 04:56:33,820
of our youth. Our young people

6556
04:56:33,820 --> 04:56:36,357
and even our adults. One last

6557
04:56:36,357 --> 04:56:39,222
thing I am pleased that in the

6558
04:56:39,222 --> 04:56:41,297
last several days. The

6559
04:56:41,297 --> 04:56:43,697
community colleges have been

6560
04:56:44,133 --> 04:56:47,630
put back to the perry pursue

6561
04:56:47,630 --> 04:56:50,663
status they were a behind. Csu

6562
04:56:51,169 --> 04:56:53,903
and you see. They needed a

6563
04:56:53,903 --> 04:56:56,541
little bit more resources there

6564
04:56:56,541 --> 04:56:57,609
vital part and the master plan

6565
04:56:57,609 --> 04:57:00,609
that we reviewed in the

6566
04:57:00,678 --> 04:57:02,513
eighties set them equal the csu

6567
04:57:02,513 --> 04:57:04,414
and you see full partners in

6568
04:57:04,414 --> 04:57:06,685
the tripartite system of higher

6569
04:57:06,685 --> 04:57:09,840
education in california full

6570
04:57:09,840 --> 04:57:10,583
partners that being the case

6571
04:57:10,583 --> 04:57:14,183
I'm glad now they are full

6572
04:57:14,393 --> 04:57:14,923
partners in sharing some of the

6573
04:57:14,923 --> 04:57:17,923
proceeds from the bond. I

6574
04:57:18,827 --> 04:57:20,590
region I vote. Thank you is

6575
04:57:20,590 --> 04:57:21,660
there any further discussion

6576
04:57:21,660 --> 04:57:23,631
debate on this item. Hearing

6577
04:57:23,631 --> 04:57:25,660
seen on senator glazer would

6578
04:57:25,660 --> 04:57:26,738
you like to close this for

6579
04:57:26,738 --> 04:57:27,335
President Members thank you

6580
04:57:27,335 --> 04:57:28,636
thank you to the senators who

6581
04:57:28,636 --> 04:57:30,204
spoke appreciate the thoughtful

6582
04:57:30,204 --> 04:57:32,204
comments. Particular appreciate

6583
04:57:32,938 --> 04:57:33,842
the support from the us senator

6584
04:57:33,842 --> 04:57:35,940
from fresno the san fernando

6585
04:57:35,940 --> 04:57:38,780
valley and to hannah. And it

6586
04:57:38,780 --> 04:57:38,976
gives you a clear understanding

6587
04:57:38,976 --> 04:57:40,820
of the compromise and consensus

6588
04:57:40,820 --> 04:57:42,816
building that went into this

6589
04:57:42,816 --> 04:57:44,487
measure it enjoys bipartisan

6590
04:57:44,487 --> 04:57:45,889
support. And that happened

6591
04:57:45,889 --> 04:57:46,753
because of the great leadership

6592
04:57:46,753 --> 04:57:48,723
of our governor of our

6593
04:57:48,723 --> 04:57:49,757
President Pro tem speaker the

6594
04:57:49,757 --> 04:57:50,992
assembly and all the

6595
04:57:50,992 --> 04:57:52,530
stakeholders who were involved

6596
04:57:52,530 --> 04:57:53,758
in these discussions to bring

6597
04:57:53,758 --> 04:57:54,892
this measure before you. And

6598
04:57:54,892 --> 04:57:57,270
certainly I'd be remiss without

6599
04:57:57,270 --> 04:57:58,930
acknowledging the good work of

6600
04:57:58,930 --> 04:57:59,494
the education chair in the

6601
04:57:59,494 --> 04:58:01,465
assembly the joint authored

6602
04:58:01,465 --> 04:58:03,868
with me assembly member donald.

6603
04:58:03,868 --> 04:58:04,532
At the end of the day with this

6604
04:58:04,532 --> 04:58:06,770
measure the voters are going to

6605
04:58:06,770 --> 04:58:08,800
make the final decision. But we

6606
04:58:08,800 --> 04:58:09,275
all know as it has so

6607
04:58:09,275 --> 04:58:11,141
articulately been expressed

6608
04:58:11,141 --> 04:58:13,544
tonight the education of our

6609
04:58:13,544 --> 04:58:14,845
youth is the most important

6610
04:58:14,845 --> 04:58:17,680
thing that we do it is a

6611
04:58:17,680 --> 04:58:21,280
priority. I hope that you agree

6612
04:58:21,615 --> 04:58:22,215
I help the voters agree that I

6613
04:58:22,215 --> 04:58:25,215
respectfully ask for either in

6614
04:58:26,525 --> 04:58:27,655
ab forty eight. Thank you.

6615
04:58:27,655 --> 04:58:30,550
Mister Senator glazer mismas

6616
04:58:40,934 --> 04:58:43,934
secretary please call the roll.

6617
04:58:51,210 --> 04:58:54,210
Right. Gen. Allen hi hi

6618
04:58:54,214 --> 04:58:57,214
archuleta hi hi atkins aye

6619
04:58:58,318 --> 04:59:02,518
bates hi bill all right I just.

6620
04:59:03,540 --> 04:59:06,540
I bradford hi caballero I

6621
04:59:07,240 --> 04:59:10,624
chiang by daily. Dodd all right

6622
04:59:13,297 --> 04:59:16,131
bye dorado hi galgiani I glazer

6623
04:59:16,131 --> 04:59:19,131
I gonzalez by growth I

6624
04:59:20,680 --> 04:59:23,668
hertzberg aye hill aye hueso I

6625
04:59:27,390 --> 04:59:29,911
tado I. Jackson by jones no

6626
04:59:29,911 --> 04:59:32,911
leyva hi I'm mcguire aye

6627
04:59:34,315 --> 04:59:37,315
mitchell aye monning by more

6628
04:59:38,352 --> 04:59:41,952
luck no morrell. No nielsen aye

6629
04:59:42,623 --> 04:59:46,223
aye pan aye portantino aye roth

6630
04:59:48,698 --> 04:59:50,800
aye rubio. I skinner I stern

6631
04:59:50,800 --> 04:59:55,000
aye stone no number I've by by

6632
04:59:57,700 --> 05:00:00,670
county. Wiener aye wilk pot hi.

6633
05:00:01,275 --> 05:00:04,875
The sooner glazer moves a call.

6634
05:00:04,914 --> 05:00:05,874
Or ice thirty four knows for.

6635
05:00:05,874 --> 05:00:08,946
Next up members is file item

6636
05:00:08,946 --> 05:00:11,946
forty six. Senator galgiani are

6637
05:00:14,654 --> 05:00:16,754
you prepared for that. I don't.

6638
05:00:16,754 --> 05:00:19,154
Secretary can please read

6639
05:00:19,256 --> 05:00:20,954
assembly bill twelve ninety six

6640
05:00:20,954 --> 05:00:21,590
by assembly member gonzalez an

6641
05:00:21,590 --> 05:00:24,590
act relating to the underground

6642
05:00:27,762 --> 05:00:29,163
economy. When you're ready

6643
05:00:29,163 --> 05:00:31,566
center to galgiani thank you

6644
05:00:31,566 --> 05:00:32,667
Mister Chair members ab twelve

6645
05:00:32,667 --> 05:00:33,901
ninety six would establish the

6646
05:00:33,901 --> 05:00:36,901
tax recovery in the underground

6647
05:00:36,969 --> 05:00:38,971
economy true crime enforcement

6648
05:00:38,971 --> 05:00:40,505
program under the department of

6649
05:00:40,505 --> 05:00:43,720
justice for the purposes of

6650
05:00:43,720 --> 05:00:43,575
combat in the underground

6651
05:00:43,575 --> 05:00:45,575
economy. The underground

6652
05:00:46,110 --> 05:00:47,309
economy takes a toll. On some

6653
05:00:47,309 --> 05:00:49,111
of the most vulnerable people

6654
05:00:49,111 --> 05:00:51,182
in our society workers are

6655
05:00:51,182 --> 05:00:52,283
often subject to low wages and

6656
05:00:52,283 --> 05:00:53,852
consumers are exposed to

6657
05:00:53,852 --> 05:00:55,889
dangerous products that are

6658
05:00:55,889 --> 05:00:57,889
unregulated and May be harmful

6659
05:00:57,889 --> 05:00:59,587
to the health of an individual.

6660
05:00:59,587 --> 05:01:01,692
Ab twelve ninety six would

6661
05:01:01,692 --> 05:01:02,760
codify the true program which

6662
05:01:02,760 --> 05:01:04,662
will maintain multi agency

6663
05:01:04,662 --> 05:01:06,662
investigative teams and

6664
05:01:06,930 --> 05:01:09,399
sacramento and los angeles and

6665
05:01:09,399 --> 05:01:10,967
members this body has voted for

6666
05:01:10,967 --> 05:01:12,969
similar legislation the senate

6667
05:01:12,969 --> 05:01:14,904
has. Heretofore been called the

6668
05:01:14,904 --> 05:01:17,107
trace program and it was

6669
05:01:17,107 --> 05:01:18,305
supported I believe unanimously

6670
05:01:18,305 --> 05:01:20,844
and the legislature in the

6671
05:01:20,844 --> 05:01:23,844
past. Ab twelve ninety six

6672
05:01:24,214 --> 05:01:24,814
enjoys bipartisan support and I

6673
05:01:24,814 --> 05:01:27,814
respectfully ask for your aye

6674
05:01:28,480 --> 05:01:28,651
vote. Thank you is there any

6675
05:01:28,651 --> 05:01:31,651
discussion and debate on this

6676
05:01:33,153 --> 05:01:36,153
item. Scene nine mr secretary

6677
05:01:37,660 --> 05:01:40,855
please call the roll. Allen hi

6678
05:01:40,855 --> 05:01:43,797
archuleta art by atkins. By

6679
05:01:43,797 --> 05:01:46,463
bates hi bill all right hi

6680
05:01:46,463 --> 05:01:48,863
gorgeous I bradford aye

6681
05:01:51,300 --> 05:01:54,900
cambiado I chain I daly. Hi

6682
05:01:55,872 --> 05:01:59,472
dodd I dorado aye galgiani aye

6683
05:02:02,544 --> 05:02:05,544
glazer aye gonzalez by growth.

6684
05:02:05,747 --> 05:02:08,917
I hertzberg aye hill aye hueso

6685
05:02:08,917 --> 05:02:13,117
aye tado hi jackson I jones I

6686
05:02:14,960 --> 05:02:17,358
leyva. I mcguire hi mitchell.

6687
05:02:17,358 --> 05:02:20,958
Morning hi hi more luck hi

6688
05:02:22,661 --> 05:02:26,261
morrell. Aye nielsen aye pan hi.

6689
05:02:27,666 --> 05:02:31,266
No hi roth aye rubio aye

6690
05:02:32,604 --> 05:02:36,204
skinner aye stern aye stone by

6691
05:02:36,507 --> 05:02:39,507
number iowa caskey. Wiener hi

6692
05:02:39,880 --> 05:02:43,480
by wilk hi hi. Center galgiani

6693
05:02:44,148 --> 05:02:47,748
moves the call. The count is

6694
05:02:49,650 --> 05:02:52,500
thirty eight eyes zeronos.

6695
05:02:53,592 --> 05:02:54,191
We're moving on to file item

6696
05:02:54,191 --> 05:02:56,690
forty two senator also are you

6697
05:02:56,690 --> 05:02:57,530
prepared for this measure.

6698
05:02:57,530 --> 05:02:59,930
Mister Secretary will you

6699
05:03:00,630 --> 05:03:02,000
please read. Assembly bill

6700
05:03:02,000 --> 05:03:02,632
seventeen forty seven by

6701
05:03:02,632 --> 05:03:05,632
assembly member gonzalez an act

6702
05:03:06,202 --> 05:03:07,367
relating to law enforcement.

6703
05:03:07,367 --> 05:03:09,439
Whenever you're ready senator

6704
05:03:09,439 --> 05:03:11,839
dorado thank you Mister

6705
05:03:13,600 --> 05:03:15,208
President up members ab

6706
05:03:15,208 --> 05:03:17,112
seventeen forty seven. What

6707
05:03:17,112 --> 05:03:18,644
better prevent misuse of

6708
05:03:18,644 --> 05:03:20,644
statewide law enforcement

6709
05:03:20,846 --> 05:03:22,485
databases specifically the

6710
05:03:22,485 --> 05:03:24,219
california law enforcement

6711
05:03:24,219 --> 05:03:26,219
helical telecommunications

6712
05:03:26,621 --> 05:03:28,120
system class class is a law

6713
05:03:28,120 --> 05:03:30,120
enforcement communications

6714
05:03:30,991 --> 05:03:32,325
network available to all public

6715
05:03:32,325 --> 05:03:34,461
agencies of law enforcement

6716
05:03:34,461 --> 05:03:35,430
within the state it provides

6717
05:03:35,430 --> 05:03:37,399
all law enforcement and

6718
05:03:37,399 --> 05:03:39,364
criminal justice agencies with

6719
05:03:39,364 --> 05:03:41,764
the capability of obtaining

6720
05:03:41,800 --> 05:03:44,200
information directly from state

6721
05:03:44,802 --> 05:03:46,468
and federal of federal and

6722
05:03:46,468 --> 05:03:48,338
state computerized information

6723
05:03:48,338 --> 05:03:49,505
files. Recent reports of

6724
05:03:49,505 --> 05:03:51,340
uncovered that some federal

6725
05:03:51,340 --> 05:03:53,740
agencies have been accessing

6726
05:03:54,900 --> 05:03:56,409
state run databases concerning

6727
05:03:56,579 --> 05:03:58,579
information about individuals

6728
05:03:58,580 --> 05:04:01,116
with licenses that were made

6729
05:04:01,116 --> 05:04:02,521
available under ab sixty this

6730
05:04:02,521 --> 05:04:04,753
is a breach of public trust and

6731
05:04:04,753 --> 05:04:06,755
we must implement guidelines to

6732
05:04:06,755 --> 05:04:07,889
protect california residents

6733
05:04:07,889 --> 05:04:09,889
this bill requires

6734
05:04:09,961 --> 05:04:11,961
justification for inquiries

6735
05:04:12,460 --> 05:04:14,826
seeking information other than

6736
05:04:14,826 --> 05:04:16,697
criminal history information.

6737
05:04:16,697 --> 05:04:18,630
Available through clouds this

6738
05:04:18,630 --> 05:04:19,502
bill also authorizes the

6739
05:04:19,502 --> 05:04:21,135
attorney general to conduct

6740
05:04:21,135 --> 05:04:23,135
audits investigations to

6741
05:04:23,468 --> 05:04:25,468
monitor subscriber compliance

6742
05:04:25,841 --> 05:04:28,242
of clouds this bill is needed

6743
05:04:28,242 --> 05:04:29,106
to prevent state resources from

6744
05:04:29,106 --> 05:04:31,378
being used for federal

6745
05:04:31,378 --> 05:04:33,446
immigration enforcement it is

6746
05:04:33,446 --> 05:04:35,282
important that proper measures

6747
05:04:35,282 --> 05:04:37,417
are in place to justify

6748
05:04:37,417 --> 05:04:39,287
inquiries in clubs and allow

6749
05:04:39,287 --> 05:04:40,453
for audits and investigations

6750
05:04:40,453 --> 05:04:43,453
to take place that would

6751
05:04:44,857 --> 05:04:45,458
identify misuse. For these

6752
05:04:45,458 --> 05:04:48,458
reasons I respectfully ask for

6753
05:04:51,694 --> 05:04:53,633
an aye vote. Thank you any

6754
05:04:53,633 --> 05:04:54,268
discussion debate center stone.

6755
05:04:54,268 --> 05:04:55,667
Thank you mr President First of

6756
05:04:55,667 --> 05:04:56,235
all thank you for doing such a

6757
05:04:56,235 --> 05:04:56,867
great job in your adaptation

6758
05:04:56,867 --> 05:04:59,203
today in our staff thank you. I

6759
05:04:59,203 --> 05:05:00,372
rise today in opposition to

6760
05:05:00,372 --> 05:05:00,907
seventeen forty seven ab

6761
05:05:00,907 --> 05:05:02,238
seventeen forty seven will

6762
05:05:02,238 --> 05:05:03,273
prohibit california law

6763
05:05:03,273 --> 05:05:05,273
enforcement agencies from

6764
05:05:05,541 --> 05:05:06,943
sharing databases with former

6765
05:05:06,943 --> 05:05:08,943
federal immigration enforcement

6766
05:05:10,212 --> 05:05:11,460
agencies back in two thousand

6767
05:05:11,460 --> 05:05:13,460
seventeen this legislature

6768
05:05:13,449 --> 05:05:14,316
passed sb fifty four the place

6769
05:05:14,316 --> 05:05:16,885
guidelines on the sharing of

6770
05:05:16,885 --> 05:05:18,220
information to allow. Local law

6771
05:05:18,220 --> 05:05:19,870
enforcement agencies to

6772
05:05:19,870 --> 05:05:21,530
continue sharing information

6773
05:05:21,530 --> 05:05:22,891
regarding critical public

6774
05:05:22,891 --> 05:05:25,290
safety threats and federal law

6775
05:05:25,290 --> 05:05:26,628
enforcement agencies will also

6776
05:05:26,628 --> 05:05:27,893
limiting the use of information

6777
05:05:27,893 --> 05:05:29,893
solely for immigration

6778
05:05:31,502 --> 05:05:32,668
enforcement purposes sb fifty

6779
05:05:32,668 --> 05:05:33,701
four was highly controversial

6780
05:05:33,701 --> 05:05:35,805
and took many months of

6781
05:05:35,805 --> 05:05:38,139
negotiations to get various

6782
05:05:38,139 --> 05:05:40,539
peace officer organizations to

6783
05:05:40,744 --> 05:05:43,144
remove their opposition. Here

6784
05:05:43,476 --> 05:05:44,877
here we are two years later and

6785
05:05:44,877 --> 05:05:46,913
this same legislature is now

6786
05:05:46,913 --> 05:05:49,480
proposing a measure that has a

6787
05:05:49,480 --> 05:05:50,949
strikingly similar language to

6788
05:05:50,949 --> 05:05:53,949
what was once negotiated and

6789
05:05:54,486 --> 05:05:55,954
removed in sb fifty four again

6790
05:05:55,954 --> 05:05:58,354
promises made promises not

6791
05:05:58,487 --> 05:06:00,459
kept. It is the duty of our

6792
05:06:00,459 --> 05:06:02,460
peace officers to ensure the

6793
05:06:02,460 --> 05:06:04,620
safety of all californians

6794
05:06:04,620 --> 05:06:06,620
regardless of immigration

6795
05:06:06,199 --> 05:06:07,632
status peace officers must

6796
05:06:07,632 --> 05:06:10,320
collaborate with federal law

6797
05:06:10,170 --> 05:06:12,167
enforcement agencies to avert

6798
05:06:12,167 --> 05:06:14,939
very real threats posed by

6799
05:06:14,939 --> 05:06:16,939
foreign trans transnational

6800
05:06:18,342 --> 05:06:19,443
criminal cartels. Terrace and

6801
05:06:19,443 --> 05:06:21,843
other statewide and national

6802
05:06:21,979 --> 05:06:23,979
threats sharing information

6803
05:06:23,984 --> 05:06:26,720
helps to make sure that there

6804
05:06:26,720 --> 05:06:27,551
is success in operations

6805
05:06:27,551 --> 05:06:29,551
sharing information keeps

6806
05:06:31,754 --> 05:06:34,754
california safe. This bait and

6807
05:06:38,261 --> 05:06:39,532
switch is unconscious couple.

6808
05:06:39,532 --> 05:06:40,132
And for those reasons I urge a

6809
05:06:40,132 --> 05:06:42,296
no vote on ab seventeen forty

6810
05:06:42,296 --> 05:06:42,934
seven thank you for your time.

6811
05:06:42,934 --> 05:06:44,596
If you were gonna ask that you

6812
05:06:44,596 --> 05:06:46,504
can to keep. The voices down we

6813
05:06:46,504 --> 05:06:47,101
can read a really cares is hard

6814
05:06:47,101 --> 05:06:48,969
here center borders or-on the

6815
05:06:48,969 --> 05:06:51,435
side of. Thank you Mister

6816
05:06:51,435 --> 05:06:53,176
President in a-in dark irony

6817
05:06:53,176 --> 05:06:56,176
I'm looking at this proposed

6818
05:06:57,143 --> 05:06:58,750
legislation as-individuals and

6819
05:06:58,750 --> 05:07:00,413
law enforcement are we now

6820
05:07:00,413 --> 05:07:02,782
wearing handcuffs. That's what

6821
05:07:02,782 --> 05:07:05,351
this legislation does it hand

6822
05:07:05,351 --> 05:07:08,200
cuffs law enforcement to the

6823
05:07:08,200 --> 05:07:10,119
idea that we are taking. A year

6824
05:07:10,119 --> 05:07:12,519
burden of proof normally

6825
05:07:12,725 --> 05:07:14,596
reserved for the court room hey

6826
05:07:14,596 --> 05:07:16,928
now incorporating it into the

6827
05:07:16,928 --> 05:07:19,328
law enforcement process to

6828
05:07:22,467 --> 05:07:23,438
conduct investigations. This is.

6829
05:07:23,438 --> 05:07:27,380
This is an assault on. Law

6830
05:07:27,705 --> 05:07:30,705
enforcement process. And hi we

6831
05:07:31,272 --> 05:07:33,377
see a lot of bills. Some of the

6832
05:07:33,377 --> 05:07:35,760
more controversial but a what

6833
05:07:35,760 --> 05:07:38,760
I'm seeing repeatedly is this

6834
05:07:38,312 --> 05:07:41,200
idea that law enforcement is

6835
05:07:41,200 --> 05:07:42,786
guilty before presumed innocent.

6836
05:07:42,786 --> 05:07:44,387
When we should be reserving

6837
05:07:44,387 --> 05:07:47,387
that type of accountability for

6838
05:07:47,791 --> 05:07:48,428
those who are accused so I

6839
05:07:48,428 --> 05:07:51,361
would ask my colleagues to take

6840
05:07:51,361 --> 05:07:54,229
a close look at this. This is

6841
05:07:54,229 --> 05:07:56,229
handcuffing law enforcement.

6842
05:07:56,665 --> 05:07:58,665
Exchanging information that's

6843
05:07:59,334 --> 05:08:01,690
not what our system is about I

6844
05:08:01,690 --> 05:08:02,704
would encourage my colleagues

6845
05:08:02,704 --> 05:08:04,369
to vote no on this piece of

6846
05:08:04,369 --> 05:08:06,705
legislation there will be

6847
05:08:06,705 --> 05:08:08,341
others no doubt that will come

6848
05:08:08,341 --> 05:08:10,410
in this cycle or in the next

6849
05:08:10,410 --> 05:08:12,440
cycle but this I think crosses

6850
05:08:12,440 --> 05:08:14,345
the line and I ask you to

6851
05:08:14,345 --> 05:08:16,745
respect law enforcement's line.

6852
05:08:17,682 --> 05:08:20,149
I would urge a no vote. Thank

6853
05:08:20,149 --> 05:08:23,149
you any further discussion or

6854
05:08:23,523 --> 05:08:24,688
debate on this item. Senior

6855
05:08:24,688 --> 05:08:26,387
nine senator also would you

6856
05:08:26,387 --> 05:08:28,692
like to close thank you this

6857
05:08:28,692 --> 05:08:30,791
bill requires justification for

6858
05:08:30,791 --> 05:08:32,791
increased seeking information

6859
05:08:33,763 --> 05:08:35,698
other than criminal history

6860
05:08:35,698 --> 05:08:37,698
information available to

6861
05:08:39,201 --> 05:08:39,802
through class I would ask my

6862
05:08:39,802 --> 05:08:42,802
colleagues to support and ask

6863
05:08:43,506 --> 05:08:44,700
for an aye vote. Thank you all

6864
05:08:44,700 --> 05:08:46,408
debate having seized Mister

6865
05:08:46,408 --> 05:08:49,408
Kerr please call the roll.

6866
05:08:50,309 --> 05:08:53,909
Allen hi hi archuleta aye aye

6867
05:08:55,482 --> 05:08:58,251
atkins aye bates. No bell hi

6868
05:08:58,251 --> 05:09:01,851
burgess no bradford art I can

6869
05:09:03,550 --> 05:09:06,655
be yellow. Chiang no dally no

6870
05:09:09,598 --> 05:09:13,198
dodd. I dorado I galgiani aye

6871
05:09:14,166 --> 05:09:17,166
glazer aye gonzalez hi growth

6872
05:09:19,139 --> 05:09:22,739
no hertzberg aye hill aye hueso

6873
05:09:25,979 --> 05:09:28,979
aye furtado. Jackson by jones

6874
05:09:31,417 --> 05:09:33,852
no leyva hi mcguire hi mitchell

6875
05:09:33,852 --> 05:09:38,520
aye aye monning by more lock no

6876
05:09:39,218 --> 05:09:42,818
morale. No nielsen no pan aye

6877
05:09:44,993 --> 05:09:48,593
portantino I roth aye rubio aye

6878
05:09:50,297 --> 05:09:53,897
skinner aye stern aye stone no

6879
05:09:55,350 --> 05:09:58,350
number iraq ira caskey. Wiener.

6880
05:09:58,874 --> 05:10:02,474
I wilk I don't know. Third

6881
05:10:03,176 --> 05:10:03,777
arousal moves a call. Twenty

6882
05:10:03,777 --> 05:10:06,449
six all eyes eleven knows the

6883
05:10:06,449 --> 05:10:09,449
measures on call. Next up

6884
05:10:09,449 --> 05:10:10,830
members is item nineteen file

6885
05:10:10,830 --> 05:10:12,555
item nineteen center winner you

6886
05:10:12,555 --> 05:10:14,555
prepared. Mister Secretary

6887
05:10:19,910 --> 05:10:20,426
please rate. Assembly bill

6888
05:10:20,426 --> 05:10:20,926
seven fifty one by assembly

6889
05:10:20,926 --> 05:10:23,326
member o'donnell an act

6890
05:10:23,332 --> 05:10:25,732
relating to people assessment.

6891
05:10:27,320 --> 05:10:27,833
The winner when you're ready. I

6892
05:10:27,833 --> 05:10:29,935
thank you Mister President

6893
05:10:29,935 --> 05:10:32,335
colleagues to rise today to

6894
05:10:32,335 --> 05:10:33,308
present ab seven fifty one on

6895
05:10:33,308 --> 05:10:35,440
behalf of assembly member

6896
05:10:35,440 --> 05:10:36,939
o'donnell was so expand the

6897
05:10:36,939 --> 05:10:39,482
pathway to college by giving

6898
05:10:39,482 --> 05:10:41,145
eleventh grade students access.

6899
05:10:41,145 --> 05:10:42,914
To requiredentrance exam for

6900
05:10:42,914 --> 05:10:44,813
college currently students in

6901
05:10:44,813 --> 05:10:47,150
grades three through eight an

6902
05:10:47,150 --> 05:10:48,850
eleventh grader required to

6903
05:10:48,850 --> 05:10:50,485
take the smarter balanced

6904
05:10:50,897 --> 05:10:52,825
assessment this bill allows but

6905
05:10:52,825 --> 05:10:54,225
does not require a school

6906
05:10:54,225 --> 05:10:56,193
districts to administer a

6907
05:10:56,193 --> 05:10:58,629
college entrance exams such as

6908
05:10:58,629 --> 05:11:00,634
the sat or act ste the city

6909
05:11:00,634 --> 05:11:01,895
instead of the state required

6910
05:11:01,895 --> 05:11:04,330
assessment for eleventh grade

6911
05:11:04,330 --> 05:11:05,671
students ab seven fifty one

6912
05:11:05,671 --> 05:11:07,802
requires assessment to meet our

6913
05:11:07,802 --> 05:11:09,103
state academic standards. And

6914
05:11:09,103 --> 05:11:10,705
to ensure that accommodations

6915
05:11:10,705 --> 05:11:12,406
over be provided to english

6916
05:11:12,406 --> 05:11:13,571
learners and students with

6917
05:11:13,571 --> 05:11:15,612
disabilities as required by

6918
05:11:15,612 --> 05:11:17,670
federal law school districts we

6919
05:11:17,670 --> 05:11:18,745
need to get approval from the

6920
05:11:18,745 --> 05:11:20,800
us department of education

6921
05:11:20,800 --> 05:11:22,800
before administering the

6922
05:11:22,283 --> 05:11:23,614
college entrance exam and prove

6923
05:11:23,614 --> 05:11:24,888
that this assessment would meet

6924
05:11:24,888 --> 05:11:27,288
all state and federal

6925
05:11:27,590 --> 05:11:29,391
requirements ab seven fifty one

6926
05:11:29,391 --> 05:11:31,758
would reduce the-number of

6927
05:11:31,758 --> 05:11:32,889
tests the students are already

6928
05:11:32,889 --> 05:11:34,794
required to taking give

6929
05:11:34,794 --> 05:11:36,195
students and teachers more time

6930
05:11:36,195 --> 05:11:38,298
for instruction. Eleventh grade

6931
05:11:38,298 --> 05:11:40,990
is a busy year students are not

6932
05:11:40,990 --> 05:11:42,302
only taking the state required

6933
05:11:42,302 --> 05:11:45,104
tests but also a p. Tests and

6934
05:11:45,104 --> 05:11:45,937
college entrance exams over

6935
05:11:45,937 --> 05:11:48,337
forty school districts have

6936
05:11:51,206 --> 05:11:51,806
already implemented. A similar

6937
05:11:51,806 --> 05:11:54,806
policy I respectfully ask for

6938
05:11:57,514 --> 05:11:58,820
an aye vote. Thank you any

6939
05:11:58,820 --> 05:12:01,820
discussion or debate on this

6940
05:12:01,248 --> 05:12:02,755
item. In nineteen nine

6941
05:12:02,755 --> 05:12:05,755
secretary please call the roll.

6942
05:12:08,660 --> 05:12:11,660
Allen. Allen I archuleta aye

6943
05:12:12,926 --> 05:12:16,234
aye atkins aye bates. Hi bill

6944
05:12:16,234 --> 05:12:19,834
all right I porges I bradford

6945
05:12:22,138 --> 05:12:23,472
hi cambiado hi jane I daly. I

6946
05:12:23,472 --> 05:12:27,720
dodd I dorado I galgiani aye

6947
05:12:28,607 --> 05:12:31,607
glazer. Gonzalez hi growth. I

6948
05:12:32,280 --> 05:12:35,880
hertzberg by aye hill aye hueso

6949
05:12:37,217 --> 05:12:41,417
I her tado. I jackson hi I

6950
05:12:42,158 --> 05:12:44,958
jones hi leyva I am a choir. Hi

6951
05:12:44,958 --> 05:12:47,958
mitchell aye monning I'm more

6952
05:12:49,764 --> 05:12:53,868
lock I am a real hi nielsen aye

6953
05:12:53,868 --> 05:12:57,468
pan aye portantino aye roth aye

6954
05:12:58,690 --> 05:13:01,669
rubio aye skinner aye stern aye

6955
05:13:02,390 --> 05:13:05,390
stone hi number. Iowa kelsey

6956
05:13:07,642 --> 05:13:11,415
down no winner hi I wilk hi

6957
05:13:11,415 --> 05:13:14,510
please. Call me at seventeen

6958
05:13:14,510 --> 05:13:17,510
please call the absent members.

6959
05:13:17,822 --> 05:13:20,357
Glazer no. I thirty eight

6960
05:13:20,357 --> 05:13:22,193
members to. Ice thirty eight

6961
05:13:22,193 --> 05:13:24,557
knows to the measure passes

6962
05:13:24,557 --> 05:13:25,158
next up members is file item

6963
05:13:25,158 --> 05:13:28,758
fifty four why well one minute

6964
05:13:41,307 --> 05:13:43,307
I'm sure

6965
05:14:18,207 --> 05:14:20,207
. Members were gonna

6966
05:14:20,609 --> 05:14:23,108
let the call on file file item

6967
05:14:23,108 --> 05:14:23,645
fifty a. B. Forty eight. Mister

6968
05:14:23,645 --> 05:14:26,450
Secretary please call the

6969
05:14:29,546 --> 05:14:31,946
absent members. Dally. What

6970
05:14:40,126 --> 05:14:40,660
county hi I. The. I thirty four

6971
05:14:40,660 --> 05:14:43,660
thirty five knows for the

6972
05:14:56,901 --> 05:14:58,901
measure passes

6973
05:16:07,735 --> 05:16:09,735
. Our members

6974
05:16:10,905 --> 05:16:12,973
next item up is file item fifty

6975
05:16:12,973 --> 05:16:15,379
four senator mitchell are you

6976
05:16:15,379 --> 05:16:17,779
prepared she is Mister

6977
05:16:18,812 --> 05:16:21,150
Secretary please read. Assembly

6978
05:16:21,150 --> 05:16:21,646
assembly bill one seventy by

6979
05:16:21,646 --> 05:16:23,783
assembly member gonzalez an act

6980
05:16:23,783 --> 05:16:24,882
relating to employment. Your

6981
05:16:24,882 --> 05:16:25,585
itchell when you're ready

6982
05:16:25,585 --> 05:16:27,520
thank you very much Mister

6983
05:16:27,520 --> 05:16:29,756
President I rise to present

6984
05:16:29,756 --> 05:16:31,910
assembly bill one seventy by

6985
05:16:31,910 --> 05:16:33,359
assembly member gonzalez bill

6986
05:16:33,359 --> 05:16:35,695
that gives both large and small

6987
05:16:35,695 --> 05:16:38,950
newspapers an additional one

6988
05:16:38,332 --> 05:16:40,664
year to comply with the twenty

6989
05:16:40,664 --> 05:16:41,865
eighteen dynamix ruling. As we

6990
05:16:41,865 --> 05:16:43,900
all know our community

6991
05:16:43,900 --> 05:16:46,403
newspapers are hurting and in

6992
05:16:46,403 --> 05:16:48,104
serious jeopardy both large and

6993
05:16:48,104 --> 05:16:50,504
small publications are facing

6994
05:16:50,776 --> 05:16:51,641
challenges with the advertisers

6995
05:16:51,641 --> 05:16:54,143
moving to the internet and

6996
05:16:54,143 --> 05:16:54,708
online aggregators of news

6997
05:16:54,708 --> 05:16:57,108
cutting the local newspapers

6998
05:16:57,814 --> 05:16:58,545
out. Recently decied dynamix

6999
05:16:58,545 --> 05:17:00,945
decision by the california

7000
05:17:01,500 --> 05:17:01,684
supreme court adds to these

7001
05:17:01,684 --> 05:17:02,885
challenges by converting

7002
05:17:02,885 --> 05:17:04,885
newspaper carriers and

7003
05:17:05,530 --> 05:17:07,530
distributors from independent

7004
05:17:08,560 --> 05:17:09,461
contractors to employees. It's

7005
05:17:09,461 --> 05:17:10,761
the small community newspapers

7006
05:17:10,761 --> 05:17:12,461
that we all have in our own

7007
05:17:12,461 --> 05:17:14,861
areas newspapers that serve

7008
05:17:14,929 --> 05:17:16,564
rule california monolingual

7009
05:17:16,564 --> 05:17:18,735
communities it's the ethnic

7010
05:17:18,735 --> 05:17:19,967
papers that sells weeklies that

7011
05:17:19,967 --> 05:17:22,967
so many of our constituents

7012
05:17:23,738 --> 05:17:25,904
rely on to access critical news

7013
05:17:25,904 --> 05:17:27,739
every day. The jewish journal

7014
05:17:27,739 --> 05:17:30,341
culver city news beverly press

7015
05:17:30,341 --> 05:17:31,611
the korean times our weekly the

7016
05:17:31,611 --> 05:17:33,913
la set no those are just a

7017
05:17:33,913 --> 05:17:36,682
handful in my very own district

7018
05:17:36,682 --> 05:17:38,383
who I know will be impacted if

7019
05:17:38,383 --> 05:17:40,454
we don't take action and give

7020
05:17:40,454 --> 05:17:44,654
them time to figure out a way

7021
05:17:44,789 --> 05:17:48,256
to comply with the new. Supreme

7022
05:17:48,256 --> 05:17:49,428
court ruling hand state law.

7023
05:17:49,428 --> 05:17:51,950
This time will ensure that the

7024
05:17:51,950 --> 05:17:52,797
newspapers can adjust their

7025
05:17:52,797 --> 05:17:54,896
delivery methods to comply with

7026
05:17:54,896 --> 05:17:57,296
the law. Without facing

7027
05:17:57,437 --> 05:17:58,533
disastrous liability while also

7028
05:17:58,533 --> 05:18:00,534
ensuring that the newspaper

7029
05:18:00,534 --> 05:18:01,807
industry eventually complies

7030
05:18:01,807 --> 05:18:03,537
with dynamics and ensure that

7031
05:18:03,537 --> 05:18:05,879
the newspaper carriers are

7032
05:18:05,879 --> 05:18:07,877
fairly paid and protected by

7033
05:18:07,877 --> 05:18:10,877
california labor law. I asked

7034
05:18:13,130 --> 05:18:14,352
for an aye vote. Thank you any.

7035
05:18:14,352 --> 05:18:16,752
Discussion and debate center

7036
05:18:16,853 --> 05:18:20,453
bates I have a an amendment to

7037
05:18:20,453 --> 05:18:22,428
at the desk. Mr sector please

7038
05:18:22,428 --> 05:18:24,828
read the amendment amendments

7039
05:18:25,627 --> 05:18:27,930
by senator bates for that one

7040
05:18:27,930 --> 05:18:29,864
but you May proceed thank you.

7041
05:18:29,864 --> 05:18:30,999
Members are this amendment is

7042
05:18:30,999 --> 05:18:33,635
quite simple it would provide

7043
05:18:33,635 --> 05:18:35,403
an exemption for up for maybe

7044
05:18:35,403 --> 05:18:37,238
five for newspaper carriers or

7045
05:18:37,238 --> 05:18:39,600
newspaper distributors these

7046
05:18:39,600 --> 05:18:41,275
are local newspaper delivery

7047
05:18:41,275 --> 05:18:43,280
people for most this is a

7048
05:18:43,280 --> 05:18:44,478
supplemental source of income

7049
05:18:44,478 --> 05:18:45,780
many deliver multiple

7050
05:18:45,780 --> 05:18:47,412
newspapers on their routes

7051
05:18:47,412 --> 05:18:49,350
which is slow certainly on my

7052
05:18:49,350 --> 05:18:51,618
home. From the mercury news

7053
05:18:51,618 --> 05:18:55,520
group editorial let me read May

7054
05:18:55,520 --> 05:18:56,123
I read. Quote california

7055
05:18:56,123 --> 05:18:57,855
legislators should not in

7056
05:18:57,855 --> 05:18:59,490
danger newspapers lawmakers

7057
05:18:59,490 --> 05:19:01,328
debating the future of the gig

7058
05:19:01,328 --> 05:19:02,893
economy are threatening the for

7059
05:19:02,893 --> 05:19:04,928
staying ability of legacy

7060
05:19:04,928 --> 05:19:06,902
industries the sacramento bee

7061
05:19:06,902 --> 05:19:08,532
editorial stated by requiring

7062
05:19:08,532 --> 05:19:10,436
newspapers to extend employee

7063
05:19:10,436 --> 05:19:12,836
benefits and protections. To

7064
05:19:12,969 --> 05:19:13,742
all and newspaper carriers ab

7065
05:19:13,742 --> 05:19:15,772
five would make newspaper

7066
05:19:15,772 --> 05:19:17,772
delivery economically

7067
05:19:17,876 --> 05:19:19,445
economically impossible the

7068
05:19:19,445 --> 05:19:21,210
loss of prince revenue from

7069
05:19:21,210 --> 05:19:23,385
scrapping the print edition of

7070
05:19:23,385 --> 05:19:24,916
the paper with then deal a

7071
05:19:24,916 --> 05:19:26,986
severe blow to both the

7072
05:19:26,986 --> 05:19:28,986
newspaper industries viability

7073
05:19:29,251 --> 05:19:31,224
and their mission. A one year

7074
05:19:31,224 --> 05:19:33,791
delay is not sufficient we can

7075
05:19:33,791 --> 05:19:36,491
fix this specific problem with

7076
05:19:36,491 --> 05:19:37,998
ab five today we can adopt this

7077
05:19:37,998 --> 05:19:41,198
amendment it is simple it is

7078
05:19:41,198 --> 05:19:41,800
reasonable in s. Urgently

7079
05:19:41,800 --> 05:19:45,400
needed I urge your support of

7080
05:19:46,467 --> 05:19:47,468
this amendment. Mr majority

7081
05:19:47,468 --> 05:19:48,350
leader. But you Mister

7082
05:19:48,350 --> 05:19:50,370
President I move to lay the

7083
05:19:50,370 --> 05:19:53,637
members on the table. Miss Miss

7084
05:19:54,541 --> 05:19:57,541
sector please call the roll.

7085
05:20:01,548 --> 05:20:04,317
Alan. Archuleta hi by atkins by

7086
05:20:04,317 --> 05:20:07,917
bates no bell all right bye

7087
05:20:08,856 --> 05:20:11,856
forges. Bradrd hi kelly hero

7088
05:20:15,995 --> 05:20:19,595
by chiang. Daly no dodd I

7089
05:20:19,901 --> 05:20:23,501
dorado I galgiani I glazer I

7090
05:20:24,268 --> 05:20:27,268
gonzalez I grow. Hertzberg hi

7091
05:20:28,874 --> 05:20:32,710
aye hill aye hueso hi tado I

7092
05:20:32,710 --> 05:20:35,710
jackson I jones knows leyva.

7093
05:20:36,447 --> 05:20:39,447
Aye mcguire. Hi mitchell aye

7094
05:20:41,685 --> 05:20:45,285
monning by more lock. No morale

7095
05:20:46,950 --> 05:20:49,822
no nielsen no pan hi portantino.

7096
05:20:49,822 --> 05:20:53,422
I roth I'm aye rubio aye

7097
05:20:54,961 --> 05:20:57,961
skinner aye stern. Stone no

7098
05:20:59,665 --> 05:21:03,265
number I would county I wiener.

7099
05:21:04,434 --> 05:21:08,634
I wilk no no. Grow no. Chiang

7100
05:21:21,585 --> 05:21:23,985
no it is no

7101
05:21:28,910 --> 05:21:28,725
. I just twenty

7102
05:21:28,725 --> 05:21:29,692
seven knows eleven the minotaur

7103
05:21:29,692 --> 05:21:33,292
laid on the table. Center more

7104
05:21:34,363 --> 05:21:35,798
locked. Mister President like

7105
05:21:35,798 --> 05:21:37,831
to submit a set to for

7106
05:21:37,831 --> 05:21:39,666
amendments this sector please

7107
05:21:39,666 --> 05:21:42,660
read amendments by senator

7108
05:21:42,638 --> 05:21:46,600
morlock set to. Or log thank

7109
05:21:46,600 --> 05:21:48,406
you Mister President. Assembly

7110
05:21:48,907 --> 05:21:49,542
bill one seventy assist our

7111
05:21:49,542 --> 05:21:52,542
newspaper industry and that's a

7112
05:21:52,646 --> 05:21:54,850
possible. But it demonstrates a

7113
05:21:54,850 --> 05:21:55,345
flaw of ab five selecting

7114
05:21:55,345 --> 05:21:57,745
industries are not clear

7115
05:21:59,718 --> 05:22:01,886
factors. That's a greatly. As I

7116
05:22:01,886 --> 05:22:03,185
did earlier this week I request

7117
05:22:03,185 --> 05:22:05,585
a suspension of dynamax

7118
05:22:05,990 --> 05:22:08,390
operations west inc versus

7119
05:22:10,250 --> 05:22:10,625
superior court until January

7120
05:22:10,625 --> 05:22:12,563
one twenty twenty one it is a

7121
05:22:12,563 --> 05:22:14,198
reasonable request and I

7122
05:22:14,198 --> 05:22:15,903
request a no vote on the

7123
05:22:15,903 --> 05:22:18,903
majority leader's motion to lay

7124
05:22:25,508 --> 05:22:26,110
set to on the table. Hertzberg

7125
05:22:26,110 --> 05:22:28,411
thank you very much

7126
05:22:28,411 --> 05:22:30,213
anticipation of that but a

7127
05:22:30,213 --> 05:22:32,117
vacation I indeed moved to lay

7128
05:22:32,117 --> 05:22:34,581
the amendments on the table.

7129
05:22:34,581 --> 05:22:37,581
Sector please call the roll.

7130
05:22:39,755 --> 05:22:42,755
Allen. Archuleta aye aye atkins.

7131
05:22:45,759 --> 05:22:49,132
Hi bates. Bell. Bates nobel all

7132
05:22:49,132 --> 05:22:52,732
right by burgess no bradford I

7133
05:22:54,660 --> 05:22:57,666
caballero I chiang no daly no

7134
05:22:59,569 --> 05:23:03,169
dodd. Hi dorado I galgiani I

7135
05:23:03,742 --> 05:23:06,745
glazer hi gonzalez I grow fur

7136
05:23:06,745 --> 05:23:10,345
no hertzberg aye hill aye aye

7137
05:23:11,783 --> 05:23:15,983
aye hueso hi tado hi jackson by

7138
05:23:18,590 --> 05:23:20,825
jones. No leyva hi I'm mcguire.

7139
05:23:20,825 --> 05:23:24,600
Hi mitchell hi hi monning by

7140
05:23:24,600 --> 05:23:27,600
more lock no merrell. No

7141
05:23:29,301 --> 05:23:32,399
nielsen no pan hi by portantino.

7142
05:23:32,399 --> 05:23:35,999
I roth ira aye rubio aye

7143
05:23:36,938 --> 05:23:39,938
skinner aye stern. Stone. No

7144
05:23:41,639 --> 05:23:45,839
I'm burke act ia cathy hi I

7145
05:23:50,617 --> 05:23:53,765
wiener aye wilk no. Ice twenty

7146
05:23:53,765 --> 05:23:55,291
seven knows eleven the moment

7147
05:23:55,291 --> 05:23:57,890
are laid on the table. We're

7148
05:23:57,890 --> 05:23:58,524
now on the bill in chief is

7149
05:23:58,524 --> 05:24:00,924
there any additional discussion

7150
05:24:02,261 --> 05:24:05,861
of the bill in chief. Center

7151
05:24:06,402 --> 05:24:06,643
more mark are you. Yes center

7152
05:24:06,643 --> 05:24:09,430
morlock thank you Mister

7153
05:24:09,170 --> 05:24:10,869
President. Colleagues so

7154
05:24:10,869 --> 05:24:13,269
wednesday evening I proffered

7155
05:24:14,139 --> 05:24:16,700
an amendment to the for one

7156
05:24:16,700 --> 05:24:19,700
year the implementation of ab

7157
05:24:19,777 --> 05:24:20,311
five for the gig economy. I

7158
05:24:20,311 --> 05:24:23,311
lamented that ab five pick

7159
05:24:23,614 --> 05:24:24,215
winners and losers. Ab one

7160
05:24:24,215 --> 05:24:27,215
seventy proves my point thank

7161
05:24:28,989 --> 05:24:29,517
you. The owners of dynamics

7162
05:24:29,517 --> 05:24:31,822
have done the state a huge

7163
05:24:31,822 --> 05:24:34,492
disservice. They made a big

7164
05:24:34,492 --> 05:24:36,892
mistake. But government makes

7165
05:24:37,861 --> 05:24:39,362
mistakes to. When a salesman

7166
05:24:39,362 --> 05:24:40,831
comes in and convention to do

7167
05:24:40,831 --> 05:24:43,231
something that seems attractive

7168
05:24:43,997 --> 05:24:47,597
but is not appropriate can we

7169
05:24:48,350 --> 05:24:48,541
all say rta abuse. But a hodge

7170
05:24:48,541 --> 05:24:50,941
podge strategy makes the

7171
05:24:51,210 --> 05:24:53,210
legislature. A little

7172
05:24:54,311 --> 05:24:56,545
dysfunctional and maybe not

7173
05:24:56,545 --> 05:24:58,847
have a good grasp on income tax

7174
05:24:58,847 --> 05:25:00,749
and personal off personnel law

7175
05:25:00,749 --> 05:25:03,115
and therefore I suggest and

7176
05:25:03,115 --> 05:25:04,387
strongly recommend a nobody no

7177
05:25:04,387 --> 05:25:05,654
vote on ab one seventy thank

7178
05:25:05,654 --> 05:25:08,540
you Mister President. You

7179
05:25:08,823 --> 05:25:11,823
center dallas. Name is resident

7180
05:25:11,893 --> 05:25:13,664
members I also. Come up to rise

7181
05:25:13,664 --> 05:25:16,467
in opposition to this bill I

7182
05:25:16,467 --> 05:25:19,702
spoke in very high detail about

7183
05:25:19,702 --> 05:25:20,935
the dynamics case and-picking

7184
05:25:20,935 --> 05:25:23,935
winners and losers in. The

7185
05:25:24,171 --> 05:25:25,342
state assembly senate you know

7186
05:25:25,342 --> 05:25:27,271
mark twain quoted did never

7187
05:25:27,271 --> 05:25:30,577
pick a fight with people who

7188
05:25:30,577 --> 05:25:32,179
buy ink by the barrel. And I'm

7189
05:25:32,179 --> 05:25:35,170
not trying to pick a fight with

7190
05:25:35,170 --> 05:25:37,188
my local papers by any means.

7191
05:25:37,188 --> 05:25:38,854
But the problem here is that I

7192
05:25:38,854 --> 05:25:40,520
have a hospital that cannot

7193
05:25:40,520 --> 05:25:41,854
higher now an anesthesiologist

7194
05:25:41,854 --> 05:25:43,859
part time to come and do

7195
05:25:43,859 --> 05:25:46,689
surgery in my rule community

7196
05:25:46,689 --> 05:25:48,357
because we didn't exempts them.

7197
05:25:48,357 --> 05:25:48,958
Long with there's a physical

7198
05:25:48,958 --> 05:25:51,160
therapist along with infinite

7199
05:25:51,160 --> 05:25:52,394
truckers. There are really

7200
05:25:52,394 --> 05:25:54,300
thousands of people who need

7201
05:25:54,300 --> 05:25:56,430
this exemption and this

7202
05:25:56,462 --> 05:25:57,990
legislature's picking winners

7203
05:25:57,990 --> 05:26:00,990
and losers perfect example this

7204
05:26:00,769 --> 05:26:02,974
bill right here. We need to do

7205
05:26:02,974 --> 05:26:05,674
a visit a business exemption.

7206
05:26:05,674 --> 05:26:08,740
Yes was dynamax wrong

7207
05:26:09,478 --> 05:26:10,820
absolutely they were employees.

7208
05:26:10,820 --> 05:26:13,345
Then they ten ninety nine them

7209
05:26:13,345 --> 05:26:15,190
and made them. Contractors

7210
05:26:15,190 --> 05:26:16,217
there are several people out

7211
05:26:16,217 --> 05:26:17,148
there are in business that ten

7212
05:26:17,148 --> 05:26:19,419
ninety nine each other every

7213
05:26:19,419 --> 05:26:19,984
day such as myself I do the

7214
05:26:19,984 --> 05:26:22,922
same things with business to

7215
05:26:22,922 --> 05:26:25,220
business. We need to take this

7216
05:26:25,220 --> 05:26:27,220
serious and we need to exempt

7217
05:26:27,220 --> 05:26:28,224
the thousands of people who are

7218
05:26:28,224 --> 05:26:30,395
doing the right thing in

7219
05:26:30,395 --> 05:26:30,934
business to business. Fired a

7220
05:26:30,934 --> 05:26:33,832
no vote on this bill we're

7221
05:26:33,832 --> 05:26:35,263
gonna be doing this. All year

7222
05:26:35,263 --> 05:26:37,535
next year if we're gonna pick

7223
05:26:37,535 --> 05:26:38,603
one at a time. Let's fix it

7224
05:26:38,603 --> 05:26:39,701
right take care of all those

7225
05:26:39,701 --> 05:26:40,941
people who were doing business

7226
05:26:40,941 --> 05:26:42,702
to business. And go out to

7227
05:26:42,702 --> 05:26:43,238
those bad actors like dynamax.

7228
05:26:43,238 --> 05:26:45,841
And the people who are

7229
05:26:45,841 --> 05:26:46,441
exploiting workers absolutely.

7230
05:26:46,441 --> 05:26:48,443
But this is not going to work

7231
05:26:48,443 --> 05:26:51,377
we're gonna be doing this. All

7232
05:26:51,377 --> 05:26:54,377
next year genova. Thank you

7233
05:26:54,883 --> 05:26:57,283
center stone. Mister President

7234
05:26:57,819 --> 05:27:00,588
colleagues a. B. One seventy as

7235
05:27:00,588 --> 05:27:01,550
we know is a sister bill to ab

7236
05:27:01,550 --> 05:27:03,550
five exempts newspaper

7237
05:27:03,758 --> 05:27:04,926
distributors for one year. From

7238
05:27:04,926 --> 05:27:07,328
the dynamics application and I

7239
05:27:07,328 --> 05:27:09,897
share the same. Viewpoints is

7240
05:27:09,897 --> 05:27:10,461
my speaker right before our

7241
05:27:10,461 --> 05:27:12,568
from northern california at

7242
05:27:12,568 --> 05:27:15,568
that. We don't condone with

7243
05:27:16,736 --> 05:27:18,605
dynamics did. And to broad

7244
05:27:18,605 --> 05:27:19,973
brush can throw the baby out

7245
05:27:19,973 --> 05:27:21,875
with the bathwater as were

7246
05:27:21,875 --> 05:27:23,376
doing is going to hurt the

7247
05:27:23,376 --> 05:27:25,244
fifth largest economy in the

7248
05:27:25,244 --> 05:27:27,577
world although this bill does

7249
05:27:27,577 --> 05:27:29,150
marginal and temporary relief

7250
05:27:29,150 --> 05:27:30,483
to one of the many industries

7251
05:27:30,483 --> 05:27:31,717
negatively impacted by the

7252
05:27:31,717 --> 05:27:34,117
dynamics decision the fact

7253
05:27:34,520 --> 05:27:36,422
remains. That this bill

7254
05:27:36,422 --> 05:27:37,890
represents yet again another

7255
05:27:37,890 --> 05:27:40,559
car about for a favorite

7256
05:27:40,559 --> 05:27:41,459
industry ab one seventy as one

7257
05:27:41,459 --> 05:27:43,859
more example of the

7258
05:27:45,602 --> 05:27:47,980
legislature's pickinginners

7259
05:27:47,980 --> 05:27:48,833
and picking losers this measure

7260
05:27:48,833 --> 05:27:50,505
sister bill ab five provided

7261
05:27:50,505 --> 05:27:52,505
exemptions for many

7262
05:27:52,602 --> 05:27:54,404
professions. That have the

7263
05:27:54,404 --> 05:27:57,374
money to get lobbyist up here

7264
05:27:57,374 --> 05:27:59,472
and spend money and get the

7265
05:27:59,472 --> 05:28:01,847
desired outcome but it barely

7266
05:28:01,847 --> 05:28:03,412
scratches the surface of all of

7267
05:28:03,412 --> 05:28:05,213
the affected industries that

7268
05:28:05,213 --> 05:28:07,613
are gonna be negatively

7269
05:28:08,416 --> 05:28:09,160
impacted. By this bill.

7270
05:28:09,160 --> 05:28:10,551
California businesses need a

7271
05:28:10,551 --> 05:28:11,518
holistic approach to the

7272
05:28:11,518 --> 05:28:13,687
problems created by the

7273
05:28:13,687 --> 05:28:15,753
dynamics decision. We need a

7274
05:28:15,753 --> 05:28:16,954
method applies to all

7275
05:28:16,954 --> 05:28:18,892
industries in california not

7276
05:28:18,892 --> 05:28:21,428
just those fortunate enough to

7277
05:28:21,428 --> 05:28:24,430
get themselves added to the ab

7278
05:28:24,430 --> 05:28:25,565
five car about trade. The fact

7279
05:28:25,565 --> 05:28:28,268
that there's even a car about

7280
05:28:28,268 --> 05:28:30,000
train perfectly demonstrates

7281
05:28:30,000 --> 05:28:33,000
that the dynamax decision is

7282
05:28:33,103 --> 05:28:35,307
wrong in other words. Of the

7283
05:28:35,307 --> 05:28:37,130
author of ab tat ab one

7284
05:28:37,130 --> 05:28:39,342
seventies twenty nine ten

7285
05:28:39,342 --> 05:28:41,110
hearing I'm quoting her this is

7286
05:28:41,110 --> 05:28:42,314
the first time I'd ever carried

7287
05:28:42,314 --> 05:28:45,213
a bill that I am definitely

7288
05:28:45,213 --> 05:28:45,613
opposed to I would be lying if

7289
05:28:45,613 --> 05:28:48,130
I said this wasn't

7290
05:28:48,249 --> 05:28:50,618
heartbreaking for me. This May

7291
05:28:50,618 --> 05:28:51,319
be one of the few times I agree

7292
05:28:51,319 --> 05:28:53,319
with the assembly

7293
05:28:53,554 --> 05:28:55,954
appropriations chair ab one

7294
05:28:56,190 --> 05:28:59,190
seventy. Breaks my heart as

7295
05:29:08,329 --> 05:29:08,545
well just like the all powerful

7296
05:29:08,545 --> 05:29:08,693
chair of the assembly

7297
05:29:08,693 --> 05:29:08,840
appropriations committee I'm

7298
05:29:08,840 --> 05:29:08,991
opposed to the policy. Behind

7299
05:29:08,991 --> 05:29:09,138
the bill however. Because I am

7300
05:29:09,138 --> 05:29:09,292
in support of legislation that

7301
05:29:09,292 --> 05:29:10,698
helps businesses in the state

7302
05:29:10,698 --> 05:29:13,906
of california. I urge you to

7303
05:29:13,906 --> 05:29:16,240
vote yes on ab one seventy.

7304
05:29:16,240 --> 05:29:19,810
Thank you senator also. This is

7305
05:29:19,810 --> 05:29:22,210
very. Very confusing testimony

7306
05:29:25,185 --> 05:29:28,840
sometimes. I rise to support

7307
05:29:28,840 --> 05:29:31,218
this bill but I also rise to

7308
05:29:31,218 --> 05:29:34,123
raise concerns I agree home

7309
05:29:34,123 --> 05:29:36,228
port in the free press is an we

7310
05:29:36,228 --> 05:29:38,631
also want to make sure as those

7311
05:29:38,631 --> 05:29:39,431
businesses thrive at the

7312
05:29:39,431 --> 05:29:41,831
workers to deliver those

7313
05:29:43,330 --> 05:29:43,632
newspapers are given the proper

7314
05:29:43,632 --> 05:29:46,320
worker protections and working

7315
05:29:46,566 --> 05:29:47,903
conditions. His newspaper

7316
05:29:47,903 --> 05:29:49,437
delivery carriers of the ones

7317
05:29:49,437 --> 05:29:51,750
who wake up at two o'clock in

7318
05:29:51,750 --> 05:29:52,673
the morning to make sure the

7319
05:29:52,673 --> 05:29:55,175
papers are delivered by four

7320
05:29:55,175 --> 05:29:57,378
am. They did not get days off

7321
05:29:57,378 --> 05:30:00,443
the cars get damaged they must

7322
05:30:00,443 --> 05:30:00,913
cover many miles and gas all at

7323
05:30:00,913 --> 05:30:03,313
their own expense. So

7324
05:30:03,983 --> 05:30:06,190
colleagues. I rise to support

7325
05:30:06,190 --> 05:30:08,957
because this bill was amended

7326
05:30:08,957 --> 05:30:10,789
to include a one year delay.

7327
05:30:10,789 --> 05:30:13,189
From the dynamics requirements

7328
05:30:13,995 --> 05:30:16,395
for newspaper carriers. Because

7329
05:30:16,426 --> 05:30:20,262
of the one year I surprised to

7330
05:30:20,262 --> 05:30:22,668
support and urge your support.

7331
05:30:22,668 --> 05:30:25,198
Raza senator girl. Thank you

7332
05:30:25,198 --> 05:30:26,234
Mister President we're so glad

7333
05:30:26,234 --> 05:30:28,305
that the author is listen to

7334
05:30:28,305 --> 05:30:28,937
the senate republican caucus in

7335
05:30:28,937 --> 05:30:30,839
issue distillate for those

7336
05:30:30,839 --> 05:30:32,407
newspaper industries whose

7337
05:30:32,407 --> 05:30:34,807
livelihoods will be threatened

7338
05:30:35,800 --> 05:30:36,378
by ab five but those

7339
05:30:36,378 --> 05:30:38,778
independent contractors are not

7340
05:30:39,770 --> 05:30:40,479
alone. The their individuals

7341
05:30:40,479 --> 05:30:43,479
and other industries out there

7342
05:30:43,521 --> 05:30:44,385
still seeking a carve out of ab

7343
05:30:44,385 --> 05:30:45,987
five these included trucking

7344
05:30:45,987 --> 05:30:48,387
industry including single truck

7345
05:30:48,720 --> 05:30:50,591
owner operators brokers medical

7346
05:30:50,591 --> 05:30:51,428
professions low professionals

7347
05:30:51,428 --> 05:30:53,428
lab techs nurse

7348
05:30:53,994 --> 05:30:55,696
anesthesiologists. Optometrists

7349
05:30:55,696 --> 05:30:57,970
physical therapists respiratory

7350
05:30:57,970 --> 05:30:59,970
therapist massage therapist

7351
05:30:59,597 --> 05:31:01,270
social workers occupational sex

7352
05:31:01,270 --> 05:31:03,171
therapist speech therapist

7353
05:31:03,171 --> 05:31:04,904
behavioral serra but therapist

7354
05:31:04,904 --> 05:31:06,306
truck drivers repair person

7355
05:31:06,306 --> 05:31:08,238
caters taxi cab drivers

7356
05:31:08,238 --> 05:31:09,809
register professional foresters

7357
05:31:09,809 --> 05:31:11,210
license timber operators

7358
05:31:11,210 --> 05:31:13,210
interpreter interpreters

7359
05:31:16,790 --> 05:31:16,649
musicians rabbis franchisees.

7360
05:31:16,649 --> 05:31:20,249
In franchise or it's just to

7361
05:31:21,387 --> 05:31:21,854
name a few. That's why we

7362
05:31:21,854 --> 05:31:22,488
brought forth today's

7363
05:31:22,488 --> 05:31:23,550
amendments to this bill because

7364
05:31:23,550 --> 05:31:26,550
we assn instead of picking

7365
05:31:27,196 --> 05:31:27,416
winners and losers for this

7366
05:31:27,416 --> 05:31:27,568
body in this legislature to

7367
05:31:27,568 --> 05:31:28,957
create a delayed implementation

7368
05:31:28,957 --> 05:31:29,860
for all industries across the

7369
05:31:29,860 --> 05:31:31,993
board so that this bill can be

7370
05:31:31,993 --> 05:31:33,433
worked out proprly. But a vote

7371
05:31:33,433 --> 05:31:34,796
for this bill because it does

7372
05:31:34,796 --> 05:31:36,900
to a one year deal it does

7373
05:31:36,900 --> 05:31:38,401
provide a one year delay for

7374
05:31:38,401 --> 05:31:40,801
our newspapers that desperately

7375
05:31:41,138 --> 05:31:42,205
need it. But I want to

7376
05:31:42,205 --> 05:31:44,308
challenge you to think about

7377
05:31:44,308 --> 05:31:46,776
the fact that the intended

7378
05:31:46,776 --> 05:31:49,378
target of this bill the gig

7379
05:31:49,378 --> 05:31:51,183
economy bird left door dash.

7380
05:31:51,183 --> 05:31:54,830
Let's see door dash uber eats

7381
05:31:54,830 --> 05:31:55,651
postmasters x. Setter at. Those

7382
05:31:55,651 --> 05:31:57,352
people are not even gonna be

7383
05:31:57,352 --> 05:31:59,688
covered under this bill because

7384
05:31:59,688 --> 05:32:00,953
they have a legitimate argument

7385
05:32:00,953 --> 05:32:03,756
that hopefully will go to court

7386
05:32:03,756 --> 05:32:06,660
and win about being a platform

7387
05:32:06,660 --> 05:32:08,993
and not an employer you have

7388
05:32:08,993 --> 05:32:11,393
people that access aid.

7389
05:32:11,468 --> 05:32:13,231
Beautifully created platform

7390
05:32:13,231 --> 05:32:14,570
that allows you to get online

7391
05:32:14,570 --> 05:32:16,470
and figure out where people are

7392
05:32:16,470 --> 05:32:18,669
requesting services and then

7393
05:32:18,669 --> 05:32:19,806
gain resources by providing

7394
05:32:19,806 --> 05:32:21,541
services the people that use

7395
05:32:21,541 --> 05:32:22,976
the same platform so they're

7396
05:32:22,976 --> 05:32:24,430
not even drivers these people

7397
05:32:24,430 --> 05:32:25,945
don't even work for you bring

7398
05:32:25,945 --> 05:32:27,547
left and someone fortunately

7399
05:32:27,547 --> 05:32:28,848
they're probably a many a lot

7400
05:32:28,848 --> 05:32:30,883
of people out there that are

7401
05:32:30,883 --> 05:32:33,186
going to be hurt by this

7402
05:32:33,186 --> 05:32:35,123
particular piece of legislation

7403
05:32:35,123 --> 05:32:36,522
but I do applaud the author for

7404
05:32:36,522 --> 05:32:38,524
the one year xtension for the

7405
05:32:38,524 --> 05:32:39,895
newspaper industry because it's

7406
05:32:39,895 --> 05:32:41,894
desperately needed and I would

7407
05:32:41,894 --> 05:32:43,462
ask of for it a an aye vote on

7408
05:32:43,462 --> 05:32:44,930
this to supporter newspaper

7409
05:32:44,930 --> 05:32:46,865
friends. But these car about

7410
05:32:46,865 --> 05:32:48,990
sperm are and the ones that are

7411
05:32:48,990 --> 05:32:49,267
not the ones that are being

7412
05:32:49,267 --> 05:32:51,867
left out from this car about

7413
05:32:51,867 --> 05:32:54,867
training left at the station.

7414
05:32:56,409 --> 05:32:57,441
Are unacceptable. Thank you in

7415
05:32:57,441 --> 05:32:58,707
addition a-discussion or

7416
05:32:58,707 --> 05:32:59,477
debate on this item. Here

7417
05:32:59,477 --> 05:33:01,448
ninety nine center mitch which

7418
05:33:01,448 --> 05:33:02,710
ought to close I will Mister Up

7419
05:33:02,710 --> 05:33:04,150
President Just say with the

7420
05:33:04,150 --> 05:33:05,650
lateness of the hour and the

7421
05:33:05,650 --> 05:33:07,253
unique conditions in which were

7422
05:33:07,253 --> 05:33:09,990
all working I will briefly say

7423
05:33:09,990 --> 05:33:10,587
that. The point of ab one

7424
05:33:10,587 --> 05:33:13,587
seventy is not to renegotiate

7425
05:33:15,788 --> 05:33:16,325
ab five. Ab one seventy is a

7426
05:33:16,325 --> 05:33:19,896
one year carve out for the

7427
05:33:19,896 --> 05:33:21,698
newspaper industry. They are

7428
05:33:21,698 --> 05:33:23,209
strongly encouraged to step up

7429
05:33:23,209 --> 05:33:24,566
and do their work with all due

7430
05:33:24,566 --> 05:33:27,566
diligence within the one year

7431
05:33:28,707 --> 05:33:28,925
they are given because it is

7432
05:33:28,925 --> 05:33:30,806
not the author's desire nor

7433
05:33:30,806 --> 05:33:34,143
mine as the floor jacqui to see

7434
05:33:34,143 --> 05:33:36,809
a nother year where newspaper

7435
05:33:36,809 --> 05:33:38,978
carriers are abused and

7436
05:33:38,978 --> 05:33:41,313
mistreated by the people who

7437
05:33:41,313 --> 05:33:44,313
they have contracts with again

7438
05:33:45,450 --> 05:33:49,923
I ask for your aye vote. On the

7439
05:33:49,923 --> 05:33:50,889
bill bass stated ab one seventy.

7440
05:33:50,889 --> 05:33:51,820
Thank you all discussion debate

7441
05:33:51,820 --> 05:33:54,220
having seized Miss Sector

7442
05:33:55,894 --> 05:33:59,494
please call the roll. Allen hi

7443
05:34:00,261 --> 05:34:03,261
archuleta hi by atkins. Bates

7444
05:34:04,735 --> 05:34:08,372
hi hi bill I porges. I bradford

7445
05:34:08,372 --> 05:34:13,172
I cal yellow I chain I daly no

7446
05:34:13,847 --> 05:34:17,447
dodd. I dorado aye galgiani aye

7447
05:34:18,681 --> 05:34:22,281
glazer aye gonzalez I growth I

7448
05:34:23,500 --> 05:34:26,650
hertzberg aye hill aye hueso hi

7449
05:34:27,557 --> 05:34:31,757
tado I jackson. I jones I aye

7450
05:34:32,270 --> 05:34:35,270
leyva aye mcguire aye mitchell

7451
05:34:35,527 --> 05:34:38,298
aye monning I'm more lock.

7452
05:34:38,298 --> 05:34:41,898
Morrell hi nielsen all right I

7453
05:34:44,103 --> 05:34:47,703
pan hi portantino. I roth hi

7454
05:34:48,540 --> 05:34:51,376
aye rubio aye skinner aye stern

7455
05:34:51,376 --> 05:34:54,376
aye stone aye number iowa

7456
05:34:59,117 --> 05:34:59,651
caskey I wiener aye wilk hi.

7457
05:34:59,651 --> 05:35:02,651
Six please call the absent

7458
05:35:08,660 --> 05:35:09,193
members atkins. More lock. Ice

7459
05:35:09,193 --> 05:35:12,193
thirty seven knows one the

7460
05:35:17,565 --> 05:35:19,637
measure passes. Members were

7461
05:35:19,637 --> 05:35:20,238
gonna let the call on a few

7462
05:35:20,238 --> 05:35:23,838
items. It was just one second

7463
05:35:36,318 --> 05:35:38,318
here

7464
05:35:40,656 --> 05:35:43,291
. We're gonna look to call

7465
05:35:43,291 --> 05:35:43,858
an item seventeen ab one seven

7466
05:35:43,858 --> 05:35:46,258
one Mister Secretary please

7467
05:35:57,772 --> 05:36:00,720
call the roll. When. Secretary

7468
05:36:00,720 --> 05:36:01,907
please call the roll on item

7469
05:36:01,907 --> 05:36:04,907
seventeen ab one seven one.

7470
05:36:06,178 --> 05:36:09,178
Allen hi. Chain. Glazer glazer

7471
05:36:13,582 --> 05:36:17,182
I. Hi it's twenty nine knows

7472
05:36:30,265 --> 05:36:32,265
ten measure passes

7473
05:37:02,493 --> 05:37:04,493
. Members

7474
05:37:05,628 --> 05:37:09,228
were looking the call on item

7475
05:37:09,431 --> 05:37:10,320
forty two ab. Seventeen forty

7476
05:37:10,320 --> 05:37:11,402
seven Mister Secretary please

7477
05:37:11,402 --> 05:37:13,802
call the absent members.

7478
05:37:18,306 --> 05:37:21,306
Caballero tado. What caskey for

7479
05:37:25,382 --> 05:37:27,782
healthcare. Ice twenty seven

7480
05:37:38,961 --> 05:37:41,729
knows eleven the measure passes.

7481
05:37:41,729 --> 05:37:44,468
You're now looking call on file

7482
05:37:44,468 --> 05:37:45,630
item forty six ab twelve ninety

7483
05:37:45,630 --> 05:37:48,630
Mister Sector please call the

7484
05:37:49,390 --> 05:37:49,636
aprs. Twelve ninety six I'm

7485
05:37:49,636 --> 05:37:52,636
sorry twelve ninety six please

7486
05:37:53,390 --> 05:37:55,439
call the absent members.

7487
05:37:59,178 --> 05:38:02,178
Mitchell. Why caskey hi what

7488
05:38:03,486 --> 05:38:04,830
else the aye mitchell aye. The

7489
05:38:04,830 --> 05:38:07,683
ice forty no zero the measure

7490
05:38:09,522 --> 05:38:12,522
passes. One moment members as

7491
05:38:25,935 --> 05:38:29,535
we get our fall in order

7492
05:40:00,589 --> 05:40:01,956
.

7493
05:40:01,956 --> 05:40:04,425
Members were now moving to the

7494
05:40:04,425 --> 05:40:05,259
supplemental file this everyone

7495
05:40:05,259 --> 05:40:07,659
have supplemental file number

7496
05:40:08,930 --> 05:40:10,493
one. Will be concurrent

7497
05:40:10,495 --> 05:40:12,495
assembly amendments. Everyone

7498
05:40:24,845 --> 05:40:27,581
has the document. First item up

7499
05:40:27,581 --> 05:40:28,248
last fall item fifty five by

7500
05:40:28,248 --> 05:40:30,116
center mobile are you prepared

7501
05:40:30,116 --> 05:40:32,516
to make presentation which

7502
05:40:32,647 --> 05:40:35,647
secretary please read file item

7503
05:40:36,156 --> 05:40:37,357
fifty five. Senate bill three

7504
05:40:37,357 --> 05:40:39,223
forty four by senator require

7505
05:40:39,223 --> 05:40:42,126
an act really in your prepaid

7506
05:40:42,126 --> 05:40:44,126
mobile telephony services.

7507
05:40:44,228 --> 05:40:46,162
Mcguire to my check good

7508
05:40:46,162 --> 05:40:47,264
evening mr President Members sb

7509
05:40:47,264 --> 05:40:48,966
three four four provide a one

7510
05:40:48,966 --> 05:40:50,967
year sunset extension to allow

7511
05:40:50,967 --> 05:40:52,602
local governments collect on

7512
05:40:52,602 --> 05:40:54,138
local utility user taxes for

7513
05:40:54,138 --> 05:40:55,369
retail sales a prepaid wireless

7514
05:40:55,369 --> 05:40:57,209
telecommunication products and

7515
05:40:57,209 --> 05:40:58,307
services they're currently

7516
05:40:58,307 --> 05:40:59,108
hundred one cities in three

7517
05:40:59,108 --> 05:41:01,508
counties to collect these.

7518
05:41:02,678 --> 05:41:03,249
Local utility taxes since two

7519
05:41:03,249 --> 05:41:04,114
thousand sixteen that's when

7520
05:41:04,114 --> 05:41:06,845
the program was enacted twenty

7521
05:41:06,845 --> 05:41:07,446
four millions been collected sb

7522
05:41:07,446 --> 05:41:08,820
three four four one sure that

7523
05:41:08,820 --> 05:41:09,550
local governments are kept

7524
05:41:09,550 --> 05:41:10,919
whole while larger cleanup

7525
05:41:10,919 --> 05:41:13,884
language is worked out to line

7526
05:41:13,884 --> 05:41:14,485
state and local fees. Next year

7527
05:41:14,485 --> 05:41:16,522
would respectfully ask for an

7528
05:41:16,522 --> 05:41:18,558
aye vote. The discussion or

7529
05:41:18,558 --> 05:41:19,992
debate on this item. Meaning

7530
05:41:19,992 --> 05:41:21,227
hearing nine members this is

7531
05:41:21,227 --> 05:41:23,950
eligible for unanimous roll

7532
05:41:23,950 --> 05:41:25,298
call is there any objection of

7533
05:41:25,298 --> 05:41:28,898
a blind the unanimous roll call

7534
05:41:29,668 --> 05:41:30,270
the file item fifty five.

7535
05:41:30,270 --> 05:41:33,870
Eighty nine oz thirty nine no

7536
05:41:36,708 --> 05:41:37,242
zero the measure passes. Next

7537
05:41:37,242 --> 05:41:38,977
up is file item fifty six

7538
05:41:38,977 --> 05:41:41,977
senator wiener. Mr kerry please

7539
05:41:44,685 --> 05:41:45,249
rate. Senate bill one thirty

7540
05:41:45,249 --> 05:41:47,883
six by senator winner an act

7541
05:41:47,883 --> 05:41:49,823
relating to sentencing. Sure

7542
05:41:49,823 --> 05:41:50,685
winner thank you for thank you

7543
05:41:50,685 --> 05:41:52,657
very much Mister President

7544
05:41:52,657 --> 05:41:54,392
colleagues as to one thirty six

7545
05:41:54,392 --> 05:41:56,393
which passes chamber earlier.

7546
05:41:56,393 --> 05:41:59,229
Is back on concurrence this

7547
05:41:59,229 --> 05:42:01,132
legislation will repeal their

7548
05:42:01,132 --> 05:42:02,763
one year sentence enhancement

7549
05:42:02,763 --> 05:42:05,163
applied overwhelmingly to low

7550
05:42:05,735 --> 05:42:07,873
level. Felonies for a second or

7551
05:42:07,873 --> 05:42:09,873
subsequent felony conviction

7552
05:42:10,272 --> 05:42:11,204
this is the most common sense

7553
05:42:11,204 --> 05:42:13,604
enhancement and repealing it

7554
05:42:14,240 --> 05:42:16,410
will help us. To heal our state

7555
05:42:16,410 --> 05:42:17,745
from the mass incarceration

7556
05:42:17,745 --> 05:42:21,345
that has a inflicted so much

7557
05:42:21,447 --> 05:42:22,150
damage on our communities and

7558
05:42:22,150 --> 05:42:24,250
on our budget I respectfully

7559
05:42:24,250 --> 05:42:24,817
ask for an aye vote. Any

7560
05:42:24,817 --> 05:42:27,817
discussion or debate on this

7561
05:42:28,821 --> 05:42:31,230
item. Xenon is just I'm sorry

7562
05:42:31,230 --> 05:42:32,491
senator grow. Thank you Mister

7563
05:42:32,491 --> 05:42:34,250
President I rise in opposition

7564
05:42:34,250 --> 05:42:35,157
of this bill you know speaking

7565
05:42:35,157 --> 05:42:36,640
to our district attorney in

7566
05:42:36,640 --> 05:42:37,863
kern county she's very

7567
05:42:37,863 --> 05:42:39,130
concerned about domestic

7568
05:42:39,130 --> 05:42:42,130
violence and some issues that

7569
05:42:42,598 --> 05:42:44,369
that take our that will not

7570
05:42:44,369 --> 05:42:46,371
allow just returnees to pursue

7571
05:42:46,371 --> 05:42:47,436
an ad eight a sentence

7572
05:42:47,436 --> 05:42:49,237
enhancement for repeat

7573
05:42:49,237 --> 05:42:50,208
offenders of domestic violence

7574
05:42:50,208 --> 05:42:51,873
and that this chamber

7575
05:42:51,873 --> 05:42:52,643
continually says that they want

7576
05:42:52,643 --> 05:42:53,711
to protect women in these

7577
05:42:53,711 --> 05:42:55,649
incidents encampments

7578
05:42:55,649 --> 05:42:56,713
enhancements. Being taken away

7579
05:42:56,713 --> 05:42:58,713
with this particular piece

7580
05:42:58,713 --> 05:43:00,585
piece of legislation are not

7581
05:43:00,585 --> 05:43:01,716
helpful for our district

7582
05:43:01,716 --> 05:43:04,210
attorneys who continually to

7583
05:43:04,210 --> 05:43:05,553
oppose this bill because they

7584
05:43:05,553 --> 05:43:07,190
won't be able to add since

7585
05:43:07,190 --> 05:43:09,590
encampments to enhancements to

7586
05:43:10,993 --> 05:43:11,561
repeat offenders especially on

7587
05:43:11,561 --> 05:43:13,961
domestic violence issues I.

7588
05:43:14,795 --> 05:43:15,431
Urge a no vote. Thank you. Any

7589
05:43:15,431 --> 05:43:17,831
additional discussion or debate

7590
05:43:18,901 --> 05:43:20,268
on this item. Hearing seeing

7591
05:43:20,268 --> 05:43:22,202
none sir winner to like to

7592
05:43:22,202 --> 05:43:24,400
close I thank you thank you

7593
05:43:24,400 --> 05:43:26,977
Mister President I would like

7594
05:43:26,977 --> 05:43:28,408
to close and I we've been

7595
05:43:28,408 --> 05:43:30,979
hearing this alive from the

7596
05:43:30,979 --> 05:43:33,213
district attorney's and not the

7597
05:43:33,213 --> 05:43:35,184
senator from. The minority

7598
05:43:35,184 --> 05:43:37,584
leader to it's repeated at

7599
05:43:37,584 --> 05:43:39,984
which is completely inaccurate

7600
05:43:40,220 --> 05:43:42,855
there is a separate sentence

7601
05:43:42,855 --> 05:43:44,554
enhancement that is only for

7602
05:43:44,554 --> 05:43:46,158
repeat domestic violence

7603
05:43:46,158 --> 05:43:47,859
offenders repeat domestic

7604
05:43:47,859 --> 05:43:50,259
violence offenders receive a

7605
05:43:50,396 --> 05:43:52,261
sentence on top a new has been

7606
05:43:52,261 --> 05:43:53,598
on top of their sentence that

7607
05:43:53,598 --> 05:43:56,302
is typically one two or three

7608
05:43:56,302 --> 05:43:59,302
years longer. And in addition

7609
05:43:59,870 --> 05:44:01,400
if there is great bodily injury

7610
05:44:01,400 --> 05:44:02,975
as a result of that domestic

7611
05:44:02,975 --> 05:44:04,641
violence there is an additional

7612
05:44:04,641 --> 05:44:07,113
harsh enhancement on top of

7613
05:44:07,113 --> 05:44:08,678
that so I wanted to express my

7614
05:44:08,678 --> 05:44:09,943
disappointment at the district

7615
05:44:09,943 --> 05:44:11,914
attorney's continue to spread

7616
05:44:11,914 --> 05:44:13,616
this misinformation that the

7617
05:44:13,616 --> 05:44:15,180
method that repealing this will

7618
05:44:15,180 --> 05:44:16,451
mean no one has been for

7619
05:44:16,451 --> 05:44:18,451
repeat. Domestic violence

7620
05:44:18,655 --> 05:44:21,288
offenders there is a separate

7621
05:44:21,288 --> 05:44:23,688
harsher enhancement only for

7622
05:44:23,760 --> 05:44:24,958
people who are at repeat

7623
05:44:24,958 --> 05:44:26,626
convictions for domestic

7624
05:44:26,626 --> 05:44:27,761
violence the same is true of

7625
05:44:27,761 --> 05:44:29,362
child abuse because they've all

7626
05:44:29,362 --> 05:44:31,762
also spread that same

7627
05:44:36,369 --> 05:44:37,300
misinformation this. Is a good

7628
05:44:37,300 --> 05:44:40,603
bill and I respectfully ask for

7629
05:44:40,937 --> 05:44:43,937
your iphone. Thank you. Mister

7630
05:44:44,446 --> 05:44:46,481
Secretary please call the roll.

7631
05:44:46,481 --> 05:44:49,481
Allen hi archuleta hello no

7632
05:44:51,814 --> 05:44:54,814
atkins. Bates. No bell hi

7633
05:44:56,958 --> 05:45:00,558
gorgeous. No bradford hi come a

7634
05:45:04,396 --> 05:45:08,596
gyro I chain no dally no dodd.

7635
05:45:12,472 --> 05:45:16,720
Dorado hi hi galgiani no glazer.

7636
05:45:19,500 --> 05:45:22,500
Gonzalez I growth. No hertzberg.

7637
05:45:26,350 --> 05:45:30,550
I hill aye aye hueso tado no.

7638
05:45:31,619 --> 05:45:35,219
Jackson by jones. No leyva aye

7639
05:45:36,357 --> 05:45:38,556
mcguire aye mitchell. I

7640
05:45:38,556 --> 05:45:41,556
monning. Hi more lock. No

7641
05:45:45,996 --> 05:45:49,596
merrell no nielsen. No pan hi

7642
05:45:53,539 --> 05:45:56,539
portantino. Roth hi I rubio.

7643
05:45:59,750 --> 05:46:02,675
Skinner aye stern aye stone. No

7644
05:46:06,115 --> 05:46:09,715
number. No by caskey I winner.

7645
05:46:15,355 --> 05:46:17,590
I wilk no. Select sector please

7646
05:46:17,590 --> 05:46:20,590
call the absent members atkins.

7647
05:46:27,706 --> 05:46:31,906
Dodd no glazer. Wes so I rubio.

7648
05:46:37,276 --> 05:46:37,876
Portantino. One more time. And

7649
05:46:37,876 --> 05:46:38,449
mrs secretary please call the

7650
05:46:38,449 --> 05:46:41,382
roll the absent members one

7651
05:46:41,382 --> 05:46:43,782
more time. Atkins glazer

7652
05:46:52,190 --> 05:46:54,590
portantino rubio right. The

7653
05:47:02,738 --> 05:47:05,738
call twenty highs no sixteen.

7654
05:47:05,903 --> 05:47:07,174
Except members this fall item

7655
05:47:07,174 --> 05:47:08,773
fifty seven by center white

7656
05:47:08,773 --> 05:47:11,173
collar ski Mister Secretary

7657
05:47:11,509 --> 05:47:12,478
please read senate bill

7658
05:47:12,478 --> 05:47:14,709
thirteen messenger y. Caskey an

7659
05:47:14,709 --> 05:47:15,846
act relating to land use by

7660
05:47:15,846 --> 05:47:17,948
county thank you Mister

7661
05:47:17,948 --> 05:47:19,947
President through the diligent

7662
05:47:19,947 --> 05:47:21,986
work of the senate pro tense

7663
05:47:21,986 --> 05:47:23,986
office recent amendments

7664
05:47:24,422 --> 05:47:25,922
eliminate chapter in complex

7665
05:47:25,922 --> 05:47:27,858
with eighty you bills authored

7666
05:47:27,858 --> 05:47:29,492
by assembly members ting in

7667
05:47:29,492 --> 05:47:32,261
bloom I'd like to thank the pro

7668
05:47:32,261 --> 05:47:35,428
tem for her work on. Making

7669
05:47:35,428 --> 05:47:36,290
sure that sb thirteen was

7670
05:47:36,290 --> 05:47:38,504
approved this year and I asked

7671
05:47:38,504 --> 05:47:39,650
for an aye vote. Thank you any

7672
05:47:39,650 --> 05:47:40,666
further discussion debate on

7673
05:47:40,666 --> 05:47:43,660
this item. Secretary please

7674
05:47:47,730 --> 05:47:50,730
call the world. Allen. Hi

7675
05:47:53,490 --> 05:47:56,490
archuleta by atkins. Bates hi

7676
05:47:57,583 --> 05:48:01,183
hi bill hi porges. Bradford hi

7677
05:48:02,288 --> 05:48:06,488
I caballero I changed I daly hi

7678
05:48:07,894 --> 05:48:11,494
dodd. I dorado I galgiani. Hi

7679
05:48:14,899 --> 05:48:17,899
glazer no gonzalez our growth.

7680
05:48:19,837 --> 05:48:24,370
I by hertzberg hi hill aye aye

7681
05:48:26,309 --> 05:48:29,343
hueso hi hi tado hi jackson.

7682
05:48:29,343 --> 05:48:33,543
Jones I've hi leyva aye aye aye

7683
05:48:33,716 --> 05:48:36,716
mcguire hi mitchell hi monning.

7684
05:48:38,154 --> 05:48:41,820
I'm more lock. I'm a real hi by

7685
05:48:41,820 --> 05:48:45,692
nelson all right hi pan hi by

7686
05:48:45,692 --> 05:48:48,692
portantino aye roth aye rubio.

7687
05:48:52,665 --> 05:48:56,690
Skinner hi stern no stone I

7688
05:48:56,690 --> 05:49:00,269
amberg aye aye work owski hi I

7689
05:49:02,675 --> 05:49:03,242
wiener aye wilk no. Thirty

7690
05:49:03,242 --> 05:49:06,242
three three. Please call the

7691
05:49:06,976 --> 05:49:09,376
absent members atkins. Gorgeous

7692
05:49:16,988 --> 05:49:19,988
hi jackson. Rubio rubio no.

7693
05:49:20,530 --> 05:49:22,391
Five thirty four does. Ice

7694
05:49:22,391 --> 05:49:25,391
thirty four knows for the

7695
05:49:26,362 --> 05:49:28,731
sentiments are concurred in.

7696
05:49:28,731 --> 05:49:29,198
The other members is file item

7697
05:49:29,198 --> 05:49:31,233
fifty eight by senator

7698
05:49:31,233 --> 05:49:32,301
portantino he is prepared

7699
05:49:32,301 --> 05:49:34,701
Mister Secretary when you're

7700
05:49:35,837 --> 05:49:36,471
ready please rate senate bill

7701
05:49:36,471 --> 05:49:38,340
sixty one by senator portantino

7702
05:49:38,340 --> 05:49:40,141
anak really in a fire arms. Do

7703
05:49:40,141 --> 05:49:43,741
you know floor george thank you

7704
05:49:44,813 --> 05:49:45,380
Miss President members 5% sb

7705
05:49:45,380 --> 05:49:46,447
sixty one which is back on

7706
05:49:46,447 --> 05:49:48,249
concurrence the members taken

7707
05:49:48,249 --> 05:49:50,140
in the assembly. Make technical

7708
05:49:50,140 --> 05:49:51,953
changes an address chapter out

7709
05:49:51,953 --> 05:49:53,351
amendments I respectfully ask

7710
05:49:53,351 --> 05:49:55,200
for an aye votes the members

7711
05:49:55,200 --> 05:49:57,922
prohibit the sale of semi

7712
05:49:57,922 --> 05:49:59,757
automatic centerfire rifle to

7713
05:49:59,757 --> 05:50:01,492
any person under twenty one

7714
05:50:01,492 --> 05:50:02,362
years of age. And prohibited

7715
05:50:02,362 --> 05:50:04,295
person for making an

7716
05:50:04,295 --> 05:50:06,397
application to purchase more

7717
05:50:06,397 --> 05:50:08,132
than one semi automatic

7718
05:50:08,132 --> 05:50:09,867
centerfire rifle in any thirty

7719
05:50:09,867 --> 05:50:12,272
day period as you know these

7720
05:50:12,272 --> 05:50:14,103
are the weapons of choice. Of

7721
05:50:14,103 --> 05:50:16,360
some of those heinous violent

7722
05:50:16,360 --> 05:50:18,174
acts tha are just killing our

7723
05:50:18,174 --> 05:50:21,174
kids so let's prohibit the

7724
05:50:22,176 --> 05:50:22,811
centerfire rifles and limit the

7725
05:50:22,811 --> 05:50:24,980
purchased to one a month. Thank

7726
05:50:24,980 --> 05:50:26,247
you very much. Any discussion

7727
05:50:26,247 --> 05:50:29,216
or debate on this I don't.

7728
05:50:29,216 --> 05:50:31,616
Senator nelson present later

7729
05:50:32,222 --> 05:50:32,751
down the senate the assembly

7730
05:50:32,751 --> 05:50:35,751
amendments make a bad bill

7731
05:50:39,891 --> 05:50:40,525
worse. Argeneau vote. There's

7732
05:50:40,525 --> 05:50:43,261
no discussion or debate on this

7733
05:50:43,261 --> 05:50:44,962
item. Hearing and seeing on

7734
05:50:44,962 --> 05:50:46,765
center portantino to a close I

7735
05:50:46,765 --> 05:50:49,333
would like to close were also

7736
05:50:49,333 --> 05:50:52,333
closing the loophole on those

7737
05:50:53,270 --> 05:50:55,573
who are twenty one years old

7738
05:50:55,573 --> 05:50:56,443
prohibiting people younger than

7739
05:50:56,443 --> 05:50:58,709
twenty one from purchasing

7740
05:50:58,709 --> 05:50:59,309
these centerfire violent

7741
05:50:59,309 --> 05:51:01,678
weapons and I respectfully ask

7742
05:51:01,678 --> 05:51:02,246
for an aye vote. Thank you

7743
05:51:02,246 --> 05:51:04,646
Mister Secretary please call

7744
05:51:09,853 --> 05:51:12,853
the roll. Our. Miss Sector

7745
05:51:14,900 --> 05:51:17,690
please call the world. Allen I

7746
05:51:19,950 --> 05:51:22,695
am I archuleta I atkins bates.

7747
05:51:28,300 --> 05:51:30,903
Bates no no bell hi porges. No

7748
05:51:30,903 --> 05:51:33,903
bradford alright hi cover gyro

7749
05:51:36,111 --> 05:51:40,911
I chiang nope dally no dot hi I

7750
05:51:42,917 --> 05:51:44,886
dorado. Hi galgiani aye glazer

7751
05:51:44,886 --> 05:51:47,886
aye gonzalez hi growth. No

7752
05:51:50,991 --> 05:51:54,591
hertzberg. I aye hill aye hueso

7753
05:51:56,928 --> 05:52:01,128
hi tado hi jackson hi jones no

7754
05:52:01,164 --> 05:52:04,164
leyva time acquire hi mitchell

7755
05:52:04,168 --> 05:52:07,768
hi monning hi more lock no

7756
05:52:11,942 --> 05:52:14,942
morrell. No nielsen. Nielsen no.

7757
05:52:21,686 --> 05:52:25,886
It is a number. Well nielsen no.

7758
05:52:27,354 --> 05:52:30,954
Pan hi hi. Portantino aye roth.

7759
05:52:33,924 --> 05:52:37,524
Rubio. I skinner aye aye stern

7760
05:52:38,731 --> 05:52:42,331
aye stone November by y. Caskey

7761
05:52:44,360 --> 05:52:47,376
hi winner I wilk no. One can I

7762
05:52:47,376 --> 05:52:50,976
can go. The secular please call

7763
05:52:54,479 --> 05:52:56,815
the absent members atkins roth.

7764
05:52:56,815 --> 05:52:58,350
Ice twenty seven knows a love

7765
05:52:58,350 --> 05:53:01,350
in the assembly member are

7766
05:53:01,386 --> 05:53:03,354
concurred in next up is fall I

7767
05:53:03,354 --> 05:53:05,589
own item fifty nine by senator

7768
05:53:05,589 --> 05:53:07,989
leyva Mister Secretary. Please

7769
05:53:08,562 --> 05:53:10,396
read. Senate bill twenty four

7770
05:53:10,396 --> 05:53:11,295
by senator leyva and neck

7771
05:53:11,295 --> 05:53:13,197
ruling to public health and

7772
05:53:13,197 --> 05:53:13,664
making a preparation therefore.

7773
05:53:13,664 --> 05:53:16,640
Level thank you Mister

7774
05:53:17,334 --> 05:53:17,965
President. Good evening members

7775
05:53:17,965 --> 05:53:19,336
just like a really big

7776
05:53:19,336 --> 05:53:21,336
committee meeting except

7777
05:53:22,710 --> 05:53:23,339
better. So members I back 2%

7778
05:53:23,339 --> 05:53:24,507
senate bill twenty four which

7779
05:53:24,507 --> 05:53:26,507
is back from the assembly on

7780
05:53:26,507 --> 05:53:27,808
concurrence amendments taken in

7781
05:53:27,808 --> 05:53:29,810
the assembly were technical and

7782
05:53:29,810 --> 05:53:31,214
clarifying. It is clear by

7783
05:53:31,214 --> 05:53:33,548
recent efforts across the

7784
05:53:33,548 --> 05:53:35,130
country that access to abortion

7785
05:53:35,130 --> 05:53:37,513
women's rights in general are

7786
05:53:37,513 --> 05:53:39,148
under attack. Sb twenty four

7787
05:53:39,148 --> 05:53:40,322
college student right to access

7788
05:53:40,322 --> 05:53:41,951
act will continue to move

7789
05:53:41,951 --> 05:53:42,988
california and forward by

7790
05:53:42,988 --> 05:53:44,659
reaffirming the right of

7791
05:53:44,659 --> 05:53:46,491
college students to access to

7792
05:53:46,491 --> 05:53:47,892
abortion care without delay.

7793
05:53:47,892 --> 05:53:49,227
All californians including

7794
05:53:49,227 --> 05:53:50,862
college students should have

7795
05:53:50,862 --> 05:53:52,497
access to the full range and

7796
05:53:52,497 --> 05:53:54,331
choices of reproductive health

7797
05:53:54,331 --> 05:53:55,299
care so they can plan their

7798
05:53:55,299 --> 05:53:57,699
futures and achieve their

7799
05:53:57,938 --> 05:53:58,538
personal and professional

7800
05:53:58,538 --> 05:54:01,538
goals. I respectfully ask for

7801
05:54:02,539 --> 05:54:03,107
an aye vote. Thank you any.

7802
05:54:03,107 --> 05:54:06,107
Bates our discussion on this

7803
05:54:07,280 --> 05:54:09,910
item. Hearing seen none Mister

7804
05:54:09,910 --> 05:54:12,910
Secretary please call the roll.

7805
05:54:13,383 --> 05:54:16,983
Allen hi archuleta hi I atkins.

7806
05:54:20,690 --> 05:54:23,690
Bates. Nobel hi gorgeous. No

7807
05:54:25,327 --> 05:54:28,327
bradford hi caballero hi chain.

7808
05:54:31,667 --> 05:54:35,867
No daly no dodd hi dorado. I

7809
05:54:36,304 --> 05:54:39,304
galgiani aye glazer I gonzalez

7810
05:54:40,375 --> 05:54:43,975
by growth no hertzberg aye aye

7811
05:54:45,315 --> 05:54:48,915
hill aye hueso hi tado hi

7812
05:54:51,954 --> 05:54:55,554
jackson I jones no leyva. Aye

7813
05:54:56,591 --> 05:54:59,591
mcguire hi mitchell hi monning

7814
05:54:59,893 --> 05:55:03,493
I'm more lock no merrell. No

7815
05:55:03,599 --> 05:55:07,199
nelson of no pan I portantino

7816
05:55:07,765 --> 05:55:11,365
aye roth aye rubio by skinner

7817
05:55:12,803 --> 05:55:16,337
aye stern aye stone no number

7818
05:55:16,337 --> 05:55:19,937
iowa caskey hi aye wiener aye

7819
05:55:20,310 --> 05:55:23,310
wilk. Secretary please call the

7820
05:55:23,647 --> 05:55:26,470
absent members atkins. Wilk

7821
05:55:31,454 --> 05:55:33,656
wilk no. My eyes twenty eight

7822
05:55:33,656 --> 05:55:35,925
nos eleven the assembly member

7823
05:55:35,925 --> 05:55:38,325
meant amendments are concurred

7824
05:55:38,394 --> 05:55:39,828
in and Mr. I respectfully

7825
05:55:39,828 --> 05:55:42,829
request to submit a letter to

7826
05:55:42,829 --> 05:55:43,429
the journal on sb twenty fourth

7827
05:55:43,429 --> 05:55:45,399
this letter has been shown to

7828
05:55:45,399 --> 05:55:48,399
both sides. Are there any

7829
05:55:49,767 --> 05:55:52,767
objections to the lower. Almost

7830
05:55:53,843 --> 05:55:55,774
all one. We're caling a role

7831
05:55:55,774 --> 05:55:56,375
on the submissions a letter of

7832
05:55:56,375 --> 05:55:59,375
the journal Miss Sector please

7833
05:56:02,815 --> 05:56:06,415
call the roll. We're asking for

7834
05:56:07,884 --> 05:56:10,222
the middle of the. Earlier is

7835
05:56:10,222 --> 05:56:13,222
asking for aye vote senator

7836
05:56:13,692 --> 05:56:15,460
groves asking for no vote.

7837
05:56:15,460 --> 05:56:18,460
Sector please call the roll.

7838
05:56:20,664 --> 05:56:23,664
Alan. Archuleta aye aye atkins

7839
05:56:27,170 --> 05:56:30,540
bates. No fell hi porges. No

7840
05:56:30,540 --> 05:56:33,540
bradford hi kelly hero. Chiang

7841
05:56:36,112 --> 05:56:40,312
no dally no dodd. I dorado aye

7842
05:56:41,550 --> 05:56:44,550
galgiani. Hi glazer I gonzalez

7843
05:56:47,955 --> 05:56:50,955
hi growth. Growth no hertzberg

7844
05:56:53,394 --> 05:56:56,994
aye hill aye hueso by tado.

7845
05:56:58,532 --> 05:57:01,799
Jackson I jones no leyva aye

7846
05:57:01,799 --> 05:57:04,799
aye mcguire hi mitchell. By

7847
05:57:05,706 --> 05:57:09,306
morning by more lock no merrell

7848
05:57:09,941 --> 05:57:13,541
nope nielsen no pan hi by

7849
05:57:16,517 --> 05:57:19,517
portantino. Roth aye rubio. I

7850
05:57:21,385 --> 05:57:24,985
skinner aye stern aye stone. No

7851
05:57:25,522 --> 05:57:29,722
number I like owski hi I wiener

7852
05:57:30,193 --> 05:57:33,793
aye wilk no. Portantino aye for

7853
05:57:38,431 --> 05:57:39,401
title ii. Copyright by. The six

7854
05:57:39,401 --> 05:57:42,401
third please call the absent

7855
05:57:50,180 --> 05:57:52,511
members allen hi hi atkins.

7856
05:57:52,511 --> 05:57:56,111
Yeah he just stepped in the

7857
05:57:58,750 --> 05:58:01,750
door. Five twenty eight nos

7858
05:58:03,600 --> 05:58:05,460
eleven the motion carries.

7859
05:58:06,828 --> 05:58:08,593
Members next up is file item

7860
05:58:08,593 --> 05:58:09,194
sixty we're going to wait for a

7861
05:58:09,194 --> 05:58:12,194
minute but I'm getting senator

7862
05:58:25,245 --> 05:58:27,245
dr

7863
05:59:08,750 --> 05:59:10,922
. All right members. We have

7864
05:59:10,922 --> 05:59:13,922
fought for file item sty

7865
05:59:15,854 --> 05:59:17,592
Mister Secretary please rate.

7866
05:59:17,592 --> 05:59:18,126
Senate bill two thirty five a

7867
05:59:18,126 --> 05:59:20,526
senator dodd enact ruling

7868
05:59:21,262 --> 05:59:22,997
housing dot there's no

7869
05:59:22,997 --> 05:59:26,597
opposition sp two thirty five I

7870
05:59:27,532 --> 05:59:30,532
respectfully ask your aye vote.

7871
05:59:33,607 --> 05:59:34,207
This is. Members members this

7872
05:59:34,207 --> 05:59:36,341
is eligible for unanimous roll

7873
05:59:36,341 --> 05:59:36,908
call is there any objection.

7874
05:59:36,908 --> 05:59:39,908
Thirty nine zero the measure

7875
05:59:53,230 --> 05:59:55,230
passes

7876
06:00:28,487 --> 06:00:29,888
. Members were moving

7877
06:00:29,888 --> 06:00:30,889
back to motions rather

7878
06:00:30,889 --> 06:00:33,289
resolutions is there any

7879
06:00:33,962 --> 06:00:35,997
members senator hertzberg how

7880
06:00:35,997 --> 06:00:38,232
sir sir I'm sorry center toddle.

7881
06:00:38,232 --> 06:00:39,100
Thank you Mister President. At

7882
06:00:39,100 --> 06:00:42,100
the request of the author

7883
06:00:42,569 --> 06:00:43,171
please remove please move

7884
06:00:43,171 --> 06:00:45,172
assembly bill twelve that name

7885
06:00:45,172 --> 06:00:48,408
to be an active file. Assembly

7886
06:00:48,408 --> 06:00:52,800
bill twelve ninety nine. To be

7887
06:00:52,347 --> 06:00:55,347
an active file please. What

7888
06:00:55,546 --> 06:00:58,851
file item forty nine. Just one

7889
06:00:58,851 --> 06:01:00,715
note thank you thank you.

7890
06:01:00,715 --> 06:01:02,820
Synergy burke thank you very

7891
06:01:02,820 --> 06:01:04,956
much mr up President I request

7892
06:01:04,956 --> 06:01:06,123
unanimous consent to submit a

7893
06:01:06,123 --> 06:01:08,292
letter to the journal involving

7894
06:01:08,292 --> 06:01:10,358
ab twenty five both sides of

7895
06:01:10,358 --> 06:01:12,632
already seen it and I'm told

7896
06:01:12,632 --> 06:01:13,363
have approved this and thank

7897
06:01:13,363 --> 06:01:16,963
you the best on the-and will

7898
06:01:22,638 --> 06:01:24,705
for. Without objection. Any

7899
06:01:24,705 --> 06:01:26,705
additional motions and

7900
06:01:26,939 --> 06:01:29,339
resolutions yes service center

7901
06:01:31,744 --> 06:01:34,115
hueso I request consent to

7902
06:01:34,115 --> 06:01:37,715
submit a letter to the journal

7903
06:01:39,186 --> 06:01:42,186
regarding sb three one three.

7904
06:01:55,499 --> 06:01:57,499
Without objection

7905
06:02:01,241 --> 06:02:03,241
. Members are

7906
06:02:04,100 --> 06:02:04,576
in our movie to file item

7907
06:02:04,576 --> 06:02:07,576
twenty three center live are

7908
06:02:07,817 --> 06:02:08,814
you prepared for that item. She

7909
06:02:08,814 --> 06:02:10,916
is ready she's coming Mister

7910
06:02:10,916 --> 06:02:12,651
Secretary please rate. Assembly

7911
06:02:12,651 --> 06:02:13,652
bill ten sixty six by

7912
06:02:13,652 --> 06:02:15,553
assemblymember gonzalez an

7913
06:02:15,553 --> 06:02:16,880
accolade unemployment

7914
06:02:16,880 --> 06:02:18,488
compensation and making a

7915
06:02:19,561 --> 06:02:20,158
preparation there for. When

7916
06:02:20,158 --> 06:02:23,158
you're ready thank you Mister

7917
06:02:25,163 --> 06:02:27,832
President. Members we have an

7918
06:02:27,832 --> 06:02:29,000
opportunity to do something

7919
06:02:29,000 --> 06:02:31,135
today that we don't always have

7920
06:02:31,135 --> 06:02:33,770
an opportunity to do we many

7921
06:02:33,770 --> 06:02:36,206
times tip the scales in the

7922
06:02:36,206 --> 06:02:38,508
favor of large corporations and

7923
06:02:38,508 --> 06:02:40,642
large companies rarely do we

7924
06:02:40,642 --> 06:02:42,677
ever get to tip the scales in

7925
06:02:42,677 --> 06:02:45,210
the favor of workers today we

7926
06:02:45,210 --> 06:02:48,150
have an opportunity to do that

7927
06:02:48,150 --> 06:02:48,883
I rise 2% ab ten sixty six

7928
06:02:48,883 --> 06:02:50,551
which would provide

7929
06:02:50,551 --> 06:02:51,788
unemployment insurance for

7930
06:02:51,788 --> 06:02:54,188
striking and locked out

7931
06:02:55,220 --> 06:02:55,923
workers. Why is this important

7932
06:02:55,923 --> 06:02:58,560
why should we tip the scales in

7933
06:02:58,560 --> 06:03:00,395
favor of working people because

7934
06:03:00,395 --> 06:03:02,229
we do so much for corporations

7935
06:03:02,229 --> 06:03:04,563
we want corporations to be

7936
06:03:04,563 --> 06:03:06,670
successful absolutely but we

7937
06:03:06,670 --> 06:03:08,670
also want them to share their

7938
06:03:08,670 --> 06:03:09,300
money and their profits with

7939
06:03:09,300 --> 06:03:11,703
the people. That push the money

7940
06:03:11,703 --> 06:03:13,738
up to them. We know that

7941
06:03:13,738 --> 06:03:16,738
earlier this year actions last

7942
06:03:17,880 --> 06:03:18,742
year the President Of the

7943
06:03:18,742 --> 06:03:21,742
united states. Granted a tax

7944
06:03:21,779 --> 06:03:23,645
cuts to corporations. And we

7945
06:03:23,645 --> 06:03:26,280
were all told that that tax cut

7946
06:03:26,280 --> 06:03:28,218
would trickle down to workers

7947
06:03:28,218 --> 06:03:29,389
and that's not what happened we

7948
06:03:29,389 --> 06:03:31,622
know that these corporations

7949
06:03:31,622 --> 06:03:32,986
took that money and plowed back

7950
06:03:32,986 --> 06:03:35,858
into their shareholders and the

7951
06:03:35,858 --> 06:03:36,458
board members. I just want to

7952
06:03:36,458 --> 06:03:37,193
give you a couple examples of

7953
06:03:37,193 --> 06:03:39,995
what could have happened with

7954
06:03:39,995 --> 06:03:41,497
that money cvs could have given

7955
06:03:41,497 --> 06:03:43,265
every single one of their

7956
06:03:43,265 --> 06:03:45,665
workers and eighteen thousand

7957
06:03:46,134 --> 06:03:47,104
dollar raise but they didn't

7958
06:03:47,104 --> 06:03:49,504
eighteen thousand dollars when

7959
06:03:49,872 --> 06:03:50,638
you make minimum wage eighteen

7960
06:03:50,638 --> 06:03:52,609
thousand dollars is life

7961
06:03:52,609 --> 06:03:54,776
changing that can keep someone

7962
06:03:54,776 --> 06:03:56,410
out of losing apartment. That

7963
06:03:56,410 --> 06:03:58,579
can move a family out of a one

7964
06:03:58,579 --> 06:04:00,548
bedroom home apartment into a

7965
06:04:00,548 --> 06:04:02,148
three bedroom apartment. Home

7966
06:04:02,148 --> 06:04:04,500
depot could have also given

7967
06:04:04,500 --> 06:04:04,915
each one of their employees and

7968
06:04:04,915 --> 06:04:07,285
eighteen thousand dollar race

7969
06:04:07,285 --> 06:04:08,319
but they didn't mcdonald's

7970
06:04:08,319 --> 06:04:11,560
could have given everyone of

7971
06:04:11,560 --> 06:04:12,925
their workers worldwide a four

7972
06:04:12,925 --> 06:04:14,359
thousand dollar reyes and that

7973
06:04:14,359 --> 06:04:16,295
didn't happen because the money

7974
06:04:16,295 --> 06:04:17,762
never trickles down to the

7975
06:04:17,762 --> 06:04:19,897
workers the money stays with

7976
06:04:19,897 --> 06:04:21,461
the corporations and stays with

7977
06:04:21,461 --> 06:04:23,696
the shareholders and the board

7978
06:04:23,696 --> 06:04:24,431
members. Your price and okay

7979
06:04:24,431 --> 06:04:26,199
connie label what is this have

7980
06:04:26,199 --> 06:04:27,170
to do with locked out workers

7981
06:04:27,170 --> 06:04:29,990
let me tell you what it has to

7982
06:04:29,990 --> 06:04:30,670
do with locked out workers this

7983
06:04:30,670 --> 06:04:32,736
is very personal to me because

7984
06:04:32,736 --> 06:04:37,176
as most of you know I was a

7985
06:04:37,176 --> 06:04:38,141
labor union boss for many years

7986
06:04:38,141 --> 06:04:39,811
and I love that job because I

7987
06:04:39,811 --> 06:04:41,447
love representing workers

7988
06:04:41,447 --> 06:04:43,480
because I know that when people

7989
06:04:43,480 --> 06:04:45,384
have a job that can pay the

7990
06:04:45,384 --> 06:04:47,616
bills. Help all the communities

7991
06:04:47,616 --> 06:04:48,754
that we all live work and help

7992
06:04:48,754 --> 06:04:51,154
the constituents that we

7993
06:04:51,990 --> 06:04:54,159
represent in two thousand three

7994
06:04:54,159 --> 06:04:56,327
it was a long time ago. We knew

7995
06:04:56,327 --> 06:04:58,950
that bargaining was going to be

7996
06:04:58,950 --> 06:05:00,495
different with the grocery

7997
06:05:00,598 --> 06:05:01,666
stores are we represented the

7998
06:05:01,666 --> 06:05:03,666
three big corporations

7999
06:05:05,436 --> 06:05:07,710
albertsons ralphs vons. So what

8000
06:05:07,710 --> 06:05:09,173
we did as they were union

8001
06:05:09,173 --> 06:05:10,240
bosses is we went out and spoke

8002
06:05:10,240 --> 06:05:11,175
to all of our members and we

8003
06:05:11,175 --> 06:05:15,281
said he sent these are going to

8004
06:05:15,281 --> 06:05:17,681
be. Tough negotiations. What

8005
06:05:22,785 --> 06:05:24,540
you be ready. Right now you pay

8006
06:05:24,540 --> 06:05:24,618
nothing your healthcare you're

8007
06:05:24,618 --> 06:05:25,190
probably gonna have to start

8008
06:05:25,190 --> 06:05:25,792
paying a twenty five dollar

8009
06:05:25,792 --> 06:05:26,358
copay. And you don't remember

8010
06:05:26,358 --> 06:05:26,992
said they said we get it we

8011
06:05:26,992 --> 06:05:27,825
know this was before obamacare

8012
06:05:27,825 --> 06:05:29,628
this is before we saw increases

8013
06:05:29,628 --> 06:05:30,193
or decreases in health care.

8014
06:05:30,193 --> 06:05:30,759
This is when we were at the

8015
06:05:30,759 --> 06:05:32,831
bargaining table and we were

8016
06:05:32,831 --> 06:05:33,629
seeing. Double digit increases

8017
06:05:33,629 --> 06:05:34,964
in health care. The workers

8018
06:05:34,964 --> 06:05:37,131
understood and they said we're

8019
06:05:37,131 --> 06:05:37,732
ready we'll do what we need to

8020
06:05:37,732 --> 06:05:40,701
do were happy to pay a little

8021
06:05:40,701 --> 06:05:44,103
bit more. What we couldn't know

8022
06:05:44,103 --> 06:05:45,471
as a nion at that time. Was at

8023
06:05:45,471 --> 06:05:47,340
these three corporations were

8024
06:05:47,340 --> 06:05:48,408
planning a strike. They were

8025
06:05:48,408 --> 06:05:50,243
playing to put something on the

8026
06:05:50,243 --> 06:05:52,478
table that would be so

8027
06:05:52,478 --> 06:05:53,446
detrimental to these workers.

8028
06:05:53,446 --> 06:05:56,248
That would leave them no choice

8029
06:05:56,248 --> 06:05:57,783
but to go on strike. But we met

8030
06:05:57,783 --> 06:06:00,183
with thirty nine bargaining

8031
06:06:00,822 --> 06:06:02,200
sessions with these employers.

8032
06:06:02,200 --> 06:06:03,689
And after thirty nine

8033
06:06:03,689 --> 06:06:05,689
bargaining sessions.

8034
06:06:06,880 --> 06:06:07,158
Unfortunately we called a

8035
06:06:07,158 --> 06:06:09,961
strike and the members at all

8036
06:06:09,961 --> 06:06:10,528
voted on this. And what people

8037
06:06:10,528 --> 06:06:12,697
who don't work in the labor

8038
06:06:12,697 --> 06:06:13,167
movement don't know. Is that

8039
06:06:13,167 --> 06:06:16,167
when you have a multi

8040
06:06:16,369 --> 06:06:17,835
bargaining. Unit you have each

8041
06:06:17,835 --> 06:06:19,167
unit vote to go on strike but

8042
06:06:19,167 --> 06:06:20,104
that unit doesn't know which

8043
06:06:20,104 --> 06:06:21,873
one of them the strike might be

8044
06:06:21,873 --> 06:06:23,272
called against. And we make

8045
06:06:23,272 --> 06:06:24,673
that decision at the bargaining

8046
06:06:24,673 --> 06:06:26,375
table and it's usually the

8047
06:06:26,375 --> 06:06:27,976
employer that's the worst at

8048
06:06:27,976 --> 06:06:30,148
the table in this case it was

8049
06:06:30,148 --> 06:06:31,713
vaughn's up here it's safe way.

8050
06:06:31,713 --> 06:06:32,814
And the reason they were the

8051
06:06:32,814 --> 06:06:34,749
worst is because when we were

8052
06:06:34,749 --> 06:06:35,720
at the table. Some of the

8053
06:06:35,720 --> 06:06:38,120
comments they made were

8054
06:06:38,486 --> 06:06:39,530
comments like this I'll never

8055
06:06:39,530 --> 06:06:41,188
forget this woman su road

8056
06:06:41,188 --> 06:06:42,356
check. And she said. It's not

8057
06:06:42,356 --> 06:06:44,592
that we don't want that we

8058
06:06:44,592 --> 06:06:45,826
can't afford to give pay raises

8059
06:06:45,826 --> 06:06:47,995
we don't want to give pay

8060
06:06:47,995 --> 06:06:49,298
raises because a monkey could

8061
06:06:49,298 --> 06:06:53,498
do the job of all of our

8062
06:06:53,600 --> 06:06:54,165
employees. You imagine that

8063
06:06:54,165 --> 06:06:57,165
telling you thinking of your

8064
06:06:57,903 --> 06:06:58,738
employees as monkeys. So we

8065
06:06:58,738 --> 06:07:01,138
called the strike against

8066
06:07:01,473 --> 06:07:02,541
bonds. On October sixth third

8067
06:07:02,541 --> 06:07:05,377
of October eleventh of two

8068
06:07:05,377 --> 06:07:07,812
thousand three. I within twelve

8069
06:07:07,812 --> 06:07:09,780
hours albertsons and ralph had

8070
06:07:09,780 --> 06:07:10,948
locked out all of the workers

8071
06:07:10,948 --> 06:07:13,348
they retaliated against their

8072
06:07:13,820 --> 06:07:14,918
workers. And within twenty four

8073
06:07:14,918 --> 06:07:15,483
hours eight hundred fifty nine

8074
06:07:15,483 --> 06:07:17,220
picket lines have been

8075
06:07:17,220 --> 06:07:18,591
established in southern

8076
06:07:18,591 --> 06:07:20,824
california and what would

8077
06:07:20,824 --> 06:07:23,626
ultimately be the longest and

8078
06:07:23,626 --> 06:07:26,729
most cut costly strike in the

8079
06:07:26,729 --> 06:07:28,865
history of the united states.

8080
06:07:28,865 --> 06:07:31,700
The three ceos bird dillon and

8081
06:07:31,700 --> 06:07:32,768
johnston put out letters to all

8082
06:07:32,768 --> 06:07:35,674
of their workers and they said

8083
06:07:35,674 --> 06:07:36,271
we don't care strike as long as

8084
06:07:36,271 --> 06:07:39,408
you want. The offer will never

8085
06:07:39,408 --> 06:07:41,679
get better. But we kept hope

8086
06:07:41,679 --> 06:07:44,400
alive the offer would get

8087
06:07:44,400 --> 06:07:46,615
better and as the days and the

8088
06:07:46,615 --> 06:07:47,749
weeks and the months wore on.

8089
06:07:47,749 --> 06:07:49,951
It got harder and harder people

8090
06:07:49,951 --> 06:07:52,521
lost their cars people lost

8091
06:07:52,521 --> 06:07:54,880
their homes. In the third month

8092
06:07:54,880 --> 06:07:56,570
of the strike members ran out

8093
06:07:56,570 --> 06:07:57,222
of their benefits so for all of

8094
06:07:57,222 --> 06:07:59,422
us who are healthy that was

8095
06:07:59,422 --> 06:08:02,240
okay. But for the workers were

8096
06:08:02,240 --> 06:08:04,396
battling cancer cancer I will

8097
06:08:04,396 --> 06:08:05,399
never forget the I'll w. You

8098
06:08:05,399 --> 06:08:07,399
the longshoremen's union

8099
06:08:07,602 --> 06:08:09,367
stepped up. They found out

8100
06:08:09,367 --> 06:08:11,200
every single member who had

8101
06:08:11,200 --> 06:08:12,537
cancer and they paid their

8102
06:08:12,537 --> 06:08:14,405
healthcare premiums to make

8103
06:08:14,405 --> 06:08:15,810
sure that they wouldn't lose

8104
06:08:15,810 --> 06:08:17,442
their medical benefits while

8105
06:08:17,442 --> 06:08:19,277
they were battling cancer. But

8106
06:08:19,277 --> 06:08:20,542
you know what district it

8107
06:08:20,542 --> 06:08:22,613
blinded come down the picket

8108
06:08:22,613 --> 06:08:24,718
lines did come down because the

8109
06:08:24,718 --> 06:08:27,451
ofer did get better. On

8110
06:08:27,451 --> 06:08:28,850
February twenty seventh of two

8111
06:08:28,850 --> 06:08:30,287
thousand four after four and a

8112
06:08:30,287 --> 06:08:33,287
half months this pick the

8113
06:08:33,356 --> 06:08:34,194
picket lines came down. It's

8114
06:08:34,194 --> 06:08:34,791
still sometimes hard for me to

8115
06:08:34,791 --> 06:08:37,493
talk about it's very emotional

8116
06:08:37,493 --> 06:08:38,425
because no one goes on strike

8117
06:08:38,425 --> 06:08:40,563
unless they feel like they have

8118
06:08:40,563 --> 06:08:42,598
absolutely nothing else to do.

8119
06:08:42,598 --> 06:08:43,900
Our there's no other way out

8120
06:08:43,900 --> 06:08:46,900
people don't give up their

8121
06:08:47,571 --> 06:08:48,170
wages because they don't think

8122
06:08:48,170 --> 06:08:48,771
that they just know there's no

8123
06:08:48,771 --> 06:08:51,390
other way out their backs are

8124
06:08:51,390 --> 06:08:54,509
to the wall. I look at the

8125
06:08:54,509 --> 06:08:55,420
seventy thousand workers. Fifty

8126
06:08:55,420 --> 06:08:56,911
thousand of them who were

8127
06:08:56,911 --> 06:08:58,681
locked out of some of the

8128
06:08:58,681 --> 06:09:00,347
bravest people I will ever

8129
06:09:00,347 --> 06:09:01,881
know. And after the strike was

8130
06:09:01,881 --> 06:09:05,481
over what the company said to

8131
06:09:06,850 --> 06:09:07,353
us was. We plan to take a hit

8132
06:09:07,353 --> 06:09:09,190
because we wanted to break the

8133
06:09:09,190 --> 06:09:10,956
union. And what I never

8134
06:09:10,956 --> 06:09:13,560
understood about that statement

8135
06:09:13,560 --> 06:09:14,960
is when you break the union me

8136
06:09:14,960 --> 06:09:15,858
as the President Of the union

8137
06:09:15,858 --> 06:09:17,630
you're not breaking me. You're

8138
06:09:17,630 --> 06:09:19,310
trying to break all the workers

8139
06:09:19,310 --> 06:09:21,133
the people who work for you

8140
06:09:21,133 --> 06:09:22,534
every day and make money if

8141
06:09:22,534 --> 06:09:23,669
those workers don't show up to

8142
06:09:23,669 --> 06:09:25,170
work these corporations don't

8143
06:09:25,170 --> 06:09:26,404
make any money. So when you

8144
06:09:26,404 --> 06:09:28,239
want to break the union you're

8145
06:09:28,239 --> 06:09:29,338
not harming me you're harming

8146
06:09:29,338 --> 06:09:31,242
the workers that are doing the

8147
06:09:31,242 --> 06:09:34,115
job for you. Those companies

8148
06:09:34,115 --> 06:09:35,946
were willing to lose two

8149
06:09:35,946 --> 06:09:38,886
billion dollars an attempt to

8150
06:09:38,886 --> 06:09:41,886
break the union attempted to

8151
06:09:43,120 --> 06:09:44,354
retaliate. Against the workers.

8152
06:09:44,354 --> 06:09:45,589
Ab ten sixty six would do. What

8153
06:09:45,589 --> 06:09:48,392
tipped the scales. Just a

8154
06:09:48,392 --> 06:09:50,427
little bit to help workers. So

8155
06:09:50,427 --> 06:09:51,458
that if you were locked out you

8156
06:09:51,458 --> 06:09:53,458
can receive unemployment

8157
06:09:54,231 --> 06:09:56,960
benefits. Unemployment benefits

8158
06:09:56,960 --> 06:09:58,498
are only 26% of your actual

8159
06:09:58,498 --> 06:10:00,203
wages. If you're on strike

8160
06:10:00,203 --> 06:10:02,506
after four weeks you would be

8161
06:10:02,506 --> 06:10:04,474
entitled to receive

8162
06:10:04,474 --> 06:10:06,474
unemployment benefits. So

8163
06:10:06,909 --> 06:10:08,911
members. I just ask you today.

8164
06:10:08,911 --> 06:10:11,130
We're always so willing to tip

8165
06:10:11,130 --> 06:10:12,248
the scales in the favor of

8166
06:10:12,248 --> 06:10:14,550
corporations. Who never help

8167
06:10:14,550 --> 06:10:16,150
their workers. Today could we

8168
06:10:16,150 --> 06:10:17,986
tip the scales in the favor of

8169
06:10:17,986 --> 06:10:20,723
workers the people that we all

8170
06:10:20,723 --> 06:10:21,323
represent they're trying to

8171
06:10:21,323 --> 06:10:24,323
make ends meet. I respectfully

8172
06:10:25,193 --> 06:10:25,827
ask for an aye vote. Any

8173
06:10:25,827 --> 06:10:28,766
discussion debate on this items

8174
06:10:28,766 --> 06:10:31,666
center stone. Thank you Mister

8175
06:10:31,666 --> 06:10:33,200
President and colleagues and I.

8176
06:10:33,200 --> 06:10:34,203
I sit here in amazement when I

8177
06:10:34,203 --> 06:10:36,170
hear my colleague from chino

8178
06:10:36,170 --> 06:10:38,372
say that can we once tipped the

8179
06:10:38,372 --> 06:10:40,811
scales in the favor of unions

8180
06:10:40,811 --> 06:10:43,877
and union workers. And not in

8181
06:10:43,877 --> 06:10:46,277
favor of corporations. My

8182
06:10:47,380 --> 06:10:48,100
friends this is just another.

8183
06:10:48,100 --> 06:10:51,610
Another bill in the sequence of

8184
06:10:52,284 --> 06:10:53,619
union. Bills they were saying

8185
06:10:53,619 --> 06:10:55,821
part of the union caucus

8186
06:10:55,821 --> 06:10:58,454
priorities and it's just kind

8187
06:10:58,454 --> 06:11:01,454
of disconcerting to. Hear the

8188
06:11:01,690 --> 06:11:03,690
vilification of corporate

8189
06:11:04,195 --> 06:11:05,930
companies that do business in

8190
06:11:05,930 --> 06:11:08,930
the state of california that

8191
06:11:08,101 --> 06:11:08,666
contribute to us have been the

8192
06:11:08,666 --> 06:11:11,666
fifth largest economy in the

8193
06:11:11,931 --> 06:11:14,690
world. And you know it you talk

8194
06:11:14,690 --> 06:11:15,437
about the greed of corporations

8195
06:11:15,437 --> 06:11:17,406
well what do they do with their

8196
06:11:17,406 --> 06:11:19,875
profits. Most of them are

8197
06:11:19,875 --> 06:11:21,476
publicly held corporations and

8198
06:11:21,476 --> 06:11:24,476
many of our senior citizens

8199
06:11:25,800 --> 06:11:25,680
actually get dividends when

8200
06:11:25,680 --> 06:11:28,483
those companies do well. They

8201
06:11:28,483 --> 06:11:30,317
do well. And with the stresses

8202
06:11:30,317 --> 06:11:32,152
that are senior citizens have

8203
06:11:32,152 --> 06:11:34,552
today with social security

8204
06:11:34,758 --> 06:11:37,158
which barely pays a-living

8205
06:11:38,359 --> 06:11:40,759
wage and medicare supplements

8206
06:11:41,290 --> 06:11:41,628
that they have to pay for they

8207
06:11:41,628 --> 06:11:43,126
need this income so that they

8208
06:11:43,126 --> 06:11:46,126
don't become homeless. In their

8209
06:11:49,335 --> 06:11:50,340
golden years. Hero. I'll bet

8210
06:11:50,340 --> 06:11:53,572
you there's not one person in

8211
06:11:53,572 --> 06:11:55,707
here except me it is actually

8212
06:11:55,707 --> 06:11:58,206
owned a business that made it

8213
06:11:58,206 --> 06:12:00,577
union had unanimous loyalties

8214
06:12:00,577 --> 06:12:02,430
and served in the private

8215
06:12:02,430 --> 06:12:04,443
sector. Having twenty thousand.

8216
06:12:05,981 --> 06:12:07,515
Union members. And while I was

8217
06:12:07,515 --> 06:12:09,216
on the board of supervisors in

8218
06:12:09,216 --> 06:12:12,816
the city of temecula. Never had

8219
06:12:14,588 --> 06:12:15,919
one strike. Believe it or not.

8220
06:12:15,919 --> 06:12:18,919
Contrary to my rhetoric in

8221
06:12:19,590 --> 06:12:22,590
comments and marking the union

8222
06:12:22,228 --> 06:12:24,497
caucus this past week I've had

8223
06:12:24,497 --> 06:12:27,166
a very good relationship with

8224
06:12:27,166 --> 06:12:29,134
labor and my twenty seven years

8225
06:12:29,134 --> 06:12:31,137
of being an elected official.

8226
06:12:31,137 --> 06:12:32,975
And in my years of owning my

8227
06:12:32,975 --> 06:12:35,375
union pharmacies and having

8228
06:12:35,540 --> 06:12:36,740
employees with very little turn

8229
06:12:36,740 --> 06:12:38,474
around. Because there will

8230
06:12:38,778 --> 06:12:40,345
taking care of. But my friends

8231
06:12:40,345 --> 06:12:43,114
I must respectfully rise in

8232
06:12:43,114 --> 06:12:44,115
opposition to this bill. My

8233
06:12:44,115 --> 06:12:46,184
worry is that providing

8234
06:12:46,184 --> 06:12:46,785
unemployment benefits to

8235
06:12:46,785 --> 06:12:49,785
existing workers who choose to

8236
06:12:49,787 --> 06:12:51,555
go on strike. We would be

8237
06:12:51,555 --> 06:12:52,754
removing an incentive for the

8238
06:12:52,754 --> 06:12:55,357
employees to come to the

8239
06:12:55,357 --> 06:12:57,194
bargaining table and negotiate

8240
06:12:57,194 --> 06:12:59,633
in good faith for the more.

8241
06:12:59,633 --> 06:13:00,970
Unemployment insurance is not

8242
06:13:00,970 --> 06:13:02,497
for workers that have

8243
06:13:03,934 --> 06:13:05,771
voluntarily left a job. Ab ten

8244
06:13:05,771 --> 06:13:07,635
sixty six goes beyond that. And

8245
06:13:07,635 --> 06:13:10,350
provides these benefits to

8246
06:13:10,308 --> 06:13:11,908
workers that are still employed.

8247
06:13:11,908 --> 06:13:13,430
Unions already planned for

8248
06:13:13,430 --> 06:13:14,844
financial assistance for

8249
06:13:14,844 --> 06:13:17,244
striking members with striking

8250
06:13:17,714 --> 06:13:18,249
accounts funded by union dues

8251
06:13:18,249 --> 06:13:20,810
which always getting more

8252
06:13:20,810 --> 06:13:22,481
expensive and never coming

8253
06:13:22,915 --> 06:13:24,185
down. And special assessments.

8254
06:13:24,185 --> 06:13:25,787
Well I will admit that this is

8255
06:13:25,787 --> 06:13:26,923
a creative way for unions to

8256
06:13:26,923 --> 06:13:28,152
eliminate the need to create a

8257
06:13:28,152 --> 06:13:30,560
reserve for the striking

8258
06:13:30,560 --> 06:13:32,358
members. Thereby freeing up

8259
06:13:32,358 --> 06:13:34,300
much of their needed funds I

8260
06:13:34,300 --> 06:13:36,430
just don't believe. The

8261
06:13:36,696 --> 06:13:38,598
unemployment insurance program

8262
06:13:38,598 --> 06:13:41,598
was established to boost the

8263
06:13:41,734 --> 06:13:45,350
coffers of unions. This in all

8264
06:13:45,350 --> 06:13:46,372
likelihood. As many as of the

8265
06:13:46,372 --> 06:13:47,639
other pieces of union

8266
06:13:47,639 --> 06:13:50,273
legislation that we seen this

8267
06:13:50,273 --> 06:13:51,743
past week. Is in response to

8268
06:13:51,743 --> 06:13:52,848
the janice decision and I know

8269
06:13:52,848 --> 06:13:55,311
the unions are upset about the

8270
06:13:55,311 --> 06:13:57,160
chance decision. And this is a

8271
06:13:57,160 --> 06:14:00,252
way. For them to try to

8272
06:14:00,252 --> 06:14:02,652
overcome. Their disdain. For

8273
06:14:03,888 --> 06:14:06,288
that supreme court decision.

8274
06:14:06,691 --> 06:14:07,326
Again let's reserve our

8275
06:14:07,326 --> 06:14:09,862
employment funds for those that

8276
06:14:09,862 --> 06:14:12,697
are truly unemployed. Have lost

8277
06:14:12,697 --> 06:14:13,264
their jobs or been terminated.

8278
06:14:13,264 --> 06:14:17,464
For those reasons I ask a no

8279
06:14:17,902 --> 06:14:18,501
vote. Thank you any additional

8280
06:14:18,501 --> 06:14:21,501
discussion debate on this item

8281
06:14:22,469 --> 06:14:24,309
senator stern. Thank you Mister

8282
06:14:24,309 --> 06:14:27,309
President members I wanted to

8283
06:14:28,708 --> 06:14:31,711
add one. I wanted to add one

8284
06:14:31,711 --> 06:14:33,817
pieces of information to this

8285
06:14:33,817 --> 06:14:36,817
debate to the extent it's

8286
06:14:37,122 --> 06:14:39,522
helpful to understand. The

8287
06:14:40,986 --> 06:14:42,294
author's intent. A letter to

8288
06:14:42,294 --> 06:14:45,294
the journal was negotiated last

8289
06:14:45,824 --> 06:14:47,327
night. That is currently

8290
06:14:47,327 --> 06:14:49,427
pending at the assembly desk

8291
06:14:49,427 --> 06:14:51,565
should the bill will pass and

8292
06:14:51,565 --> 06:14:53,834
be heard on concurrence and

8293
06:14:53,834 --> 06:14:54,401
I'll just read permission to

8294
06:14:54,401 --> 06:14:57,570
read from this letter to the

8295
06:14:57,570 --> 06:14:59,570
journal. Permission granted

8296
06:15:00,740 --> 06:15:02,410
okay a to ensure successful in

8297
06:15:02,410 --> 06:15:04,441
the implementation of this

8298
06:15:04,844 --> 06:15:05,610
legislation it is my intent to

8299
06:15:05,610 --> 06:15:08,100
work with the administration

8300
06:15:09,380 --> 06:15:10,247
and edt. To review data on the

8301
06:15:10,247 --> 06:15:12,116
impacts of this policy change

8302
06:15:12,116 --> 06:15:14,782
on the u. I. Programs.

8303
06:15:14,782 --> 06:15:15,322
Including the interplay with

8304
06:15:15,322 --> 06:15:17,521
any labor dispute related

8305
06:15:17,521 --> 06:15:19,521
settlement agreements. And

8306
06:15:19,620 --> 06:15:20,927
whether this policy change

8307
06:15:20,927 --> 06:15:22,862
would impact fund's solvency in

8308
06:15:22,862 --> 06:15:25,629
any way as well as other

8309
06:15:25,629 --> 06:15:27,629
implementation details. Should

8310
06:15:29,733 --> 06:15:30,834
the policy change under ab ten

8311
06:15:30,834 --> 06:15:33,700
sixty six result in anything

8312
06:15:33,700 --> 06:15:35,710
more than a negligible impact

8313
06:15:35,710 --> 06:15:37,471
on the unemployment insurance

8314
06:15:37,473 --> 06:15:39,475
fund it is my intent that

8315
06:15:39,475 --> 06:15:41,475
additional legislative or

8316
06:15:42,344 --> 06:15:44,146
regulatory action be psued to

8317
06:15:44,146 --> 06:15:46,546
limit. Any adverse fiscal

8318
06:15:47,114 --> 06:15:49,482
impacts on the fund. I know

8319
06:15:49,482 --> 06:15:51,520
that this was a central issue

8320
06:15:51,520 --> 06:15:53,953
of concerned in terms of the

8321
06:15:53,953 --> 06:15:56,392
solvency of the fund and there

8322
06:15:56,392 --> 06:15:59,392
are there competing sets of

8323
06:15:59,489 --> 06:16:02,364
information about the impact of

8324
06:16:02,364 --> 06:16:04,230
this legislation but I thought

8325
06:16:04,230 --> 06:16:06,468
that clarifying the author's

8326
06:16:06,468 --> 06:16:09,400
intent should it pass and

8327
06:16:09,400 --> 06:16:09,468
arrive at the assembly would be

8328
06:16:09,468 --> 06:16:11,868
helpful in making your

8329
06:16:13,169 --> 06:16:13,769
decision. Thank you members. Do

8330
06:16:13,769 --> 06:16:15,541
any additional discussion

8331
06:16:15,541 --> 06:16:18,541
debates yes center moreau thank

8332
06:16:19,178 --> 06:16:19,677
you sir thank you very much. I

8333
06:16:19,677 --> 06:16:21,981
just want to make a few

8334
06:16:21,981 --> 06:16:23,584
comments about. But the

8335
06:16:23,584 --> 06:16:26,150
presentation of this bill as

8336
06:16:26,150 --> 06:16:27,221
well as some other bills.

8337
06:16:27,221 --> 06:16:29,220
Lincoln said that a house

8338
06:16:29,220 --> 06:16:31,560
divided will fall and it's

8339
06:16:31,560 --> 06:16:33,456
interesting when people make

8340
06:16:35,910 --> 06:16:37,460
their-arguments on this floor.

8341
06:16:37,460 --> 06:16:38,527
The pit a neighbor against

8342
06:16:38,527 --> 06:16:40,295
neighbor friend against friend

8343
06:16:40,295 --> 06:16:42,133
business against. Other

8344
06:16:42,133 --> 06:16:44,533
businesses and industries just

8345
06:16:44,796 --> 06:16:46,832
like ab five is a perfect

8346
06:16:46,832 --> 06:16:49,703
example of that winners verses

8347
06:16:49,703 --> 06:16:51,105
losers and now we pit employees

8348
06:16:51,105 --> 06:16:52,743
against employers just to be

8349
06:16:52,743 --> 06:16:54,808
able to get a bill through. And

8350
06:16:54,808 --> 06:16:56,546
again the unions are doing

8351
06:16:56,546 --> 06:16:59,310
damage to our country and our

8352
06:16:59,310 --> 06:17:01,782
state I'm convinced that and

8353
06:17:01,782 --> 06:17:03,452
this is becoming a union st and

8354
06:17:03,452 --> 06:17:05,385
we will lose more jobs and

8355
06:17:05,385 --> 06:17:08,922
counter that this bill as well

8356
06:17:08,922 --> 06:17:10,623
as ab five. And again I think

8357
06:17:10,623 --> 06:17:13,630
the point that I just wanna say

8358
06:17:13,630 --> 06:17:17,263
is I just think the way the

8359
06:17:17,297 --> 06:17:20,897
bill is presented it this body

8360
06:17:21,370 --> 06:17:21,900
tends to. Pet. People against

8361
06:17:21,900 --> 06:17:24,307
people so I spoke my piece

8362
06:17:24,307 --> 06:17:24,938
thank you very much. Thank you

8363
06:17:24,938 --> 06:17:27,909
any additional discussion of it

8364
06:17:27,909 --> 06:17:29,410
on the side of. Xenon surly

8365
06:17:29,410 --> 06:17:31,442
which ought to close thank you

8366
06:17:31,442 --> 06:17:33,476
Mister President of I've I feel

8367
06:17:33,476 --> 06:17:34,647
badly that two of the speakers

8368
06:17:34,647 --> 06:17:37,110
to not listen to anything that

8369
06:17:37,110 --> 06:17:38,945
I said. This is not about the

8370
06:17:38,945 --> 06:17:40,190
genesis asian I was talking

8371
06:17:40,190 --> 06:17:42,184
about an experience that

8372
06:17:42,184 --> 06:17:44,220
happened sixteen you years ago

8373
06:17:44,220 --> 06:17:47,220
well before the janice decision

8374
06:17:47,256 --> 06:17:50,930
ever came into being. And I was

8375
06:17:50,930 --> 06:17:51,493
not speaking about ab five and

8376
06:17:51,493 --> 06:17:53,362
you know I'm not hitting anyone

8377
06:17:53,362 --> 06:17:53,895
against each other I'm tying

8378
06:17:53,895 --> 06:17:56,970
to make sure that people

8379
06:17:56,970 --> 06:17:58,497
understand that working people

8380
06:17:58,500 --> 06:17:59,865
are living around us every day

8381
06:17:59,865 --> 06:18:02,865
that would working people don't

8382
06:18:02,937 --> 06:18:04,975
succeed none of us succeed. And

8383
06:18:04,975 --> 06:18:07,474
people you know I was in the

8384
06:18:07,474 --> 06:18:08,209
labor movement for thirty years

8385
06:18:08,209 --> 06:18:09,543
from the time I was a senior in

8386
06:18:09,543 --> 06:18:12,114
high school until I took this

8387
06:18:12,114 --> 06:18:14,800
job and in thirty years there

8388
06:18:14,800 --> 06:18:16,517
was one strike. Is a massive

8389
06:18:16,517 --> 06:18:17,946
strike but there was one strike

8390
06:18:17,946 --> 06:18:20,318
because people don't take it

8391
06:18:20,318 --> 06:18:23,318
lightly members do not choose

8392
06:18:23,985 --> 06:18:24,556
to give up everything because-

8393
06:18:24,556 --> 06:18:28,156
they think it's going to be

8394
06:18:30,425 --> 06:18:31,910
easy. And in a win win. The

8395
06:18:31,910 --> 06:18:32,166
call of my colleague from

8396
06:18:32,166 --> 06:18:32,932
temecula talks about a union

8397
06:18:32,932 --> 06:18:35,131
fund what's called a strike

8398
06:18:35,131 --> 06:18:36,366
fund and yes we do you junior

8399
06:18:36,366 --> 06:18:38,568
induced to put that away. But

8400
06:18:38,568 --> 06:18:40,536
in my local union which was

8401
06:18:40,536 --> 06:18:41,537
solvent and we were very frugal

8402
06:18:41,537 --> 06:18:43,739
with our money we had two

8403
06:18:43,739 --> 06:18:44,774
million dollars. We are never

8404
06:18:44,774 --> 06:18:46,275
going to be able to treat

8405
06:18:46,275 --> 06:18:48,112
compete with the corporation

8406
06:18:48,112 --> 06:18:50,714
who set aside two billion

8407
06:18:50,714 --> 06:18:52,948
dollars. To lose two million

8408
06:18:52,948 --> 06:18:54,516
versus two billion. So again

8409
06:18:54,516 --> 06:18:56,181
I'm just going to ask all of

8410
06:18:56,181 --> 06:18:58,520
you think about tipping the

8411
06:18:58,520 --> 06:19:00,155
scales towards workers today we

8412
06:19:00,155 --> 06:19:01,820
don't mind practicing corporate

8413
06:19:01,820 --> 06:19:03,691
welfare when we have

8414
06:19:03,691 --> 06:19:05,457
corporations. They teach their

8415
06:19:05,457 --> 06:19:08,429
employees how to go on welfare

8416
06:19:08,429 --> 06:19:08,996
and how to go on food stamps we

8417
06:19:08,996 --> 06:19:12,435
don't seem to have a problem

8418
06:19:12,435 --> 06:19:12,866
with that. Let's do something

8419
06:19:12,866 --> 06:19:13,434
for workers today I

8420
06:19:13,434 --> 06:19:16,434
respectfully ask for an aye

8421
06:19:17,771 --> 06:19:18,372
vote. Thank you all debate

8422
06:19:18,372 --> 06:19:20,772
having seize inspector please

8423
06:19:23,109 --> 06:19:26,109
call the roll. Allen archuleta

8424
06:19:30,748 --> 06:19:34,348
no atkins. Bates. No bell I

8425
06:19:34,485 --> 06:19:37,485
porges. No bradford arc I

8426
06:19:40,558 --> 06:19:43,558
caballero. Chain no dally no

8427
06:19:46,527 --> 06:19:49,527
dodd. No dorado. Hi galgiani.

8428
06:19:52,302 --> 06:19:55,302
Glazer. Gonzalez hi growth no

8429
06:19:59,108 --> 06:20:02,708
hertzberg. Hill no way so. Hi

8430
06:20:06,548 --> 06:20:10,180
dato. Jackson I jones. No leyva

8431
06:20:10,180 --> 06:20:13,618
I am mcguire I mitchell hi

8432
06:20:13,622 --> 06:20:16,622
monning. Hi more lock no

8433
06:20:19,724 --> 06:20:22,724
merrell no nielsen no pan.

8434
06:20:28,499 --> 06:20:30,899
Portantino roth. Rubio. Skinner

8435
06:20:35,300 --> 06:20:38,406
aye stern. I stone no number. I

8436
06:20:38,406 --> 06:20:42,606
work out see I winner aye wilk

8437
06:20:45,182 --> 06:20:46,251
no. Mister Secretary please

8438
06:20:46,251 --> 06:20:48,651
call thasome members allen.

8439
06:20:54,492 --> 06:20:56,892
Atkins. Zero galgiani glazer.

8440
06:20:59,527 --> 06:21:01,927
Hertzberg tado. Pan portantino.

8441
06:21:11,938 --> 06:21:12,471
Roth rubio. I'm sorry I fifteen

8442
06:21:12,471 --> 06:21:14,871
those fourteen with center

8443
06:21:28,751 --> 06:21:30,751
leyva most call

8444
06:21:35,325 --> 06:21:37,260
. Thank you next

8445
06:21:37,260 --> 06:21:37,860
up is file item thirty one

8446
06:21:37,860 --> 06:21:39,860
senator jackson's preparedness

8447
06:21:40,965 --> 06:21:42,765
sector please rate. Assembly

8448
06:21:42,765 --> 06:21:43,400
bill twelve a two by

8449
06:21:43,400 --> 06:21:45,800
assemblymember chao an accolade

8450
06:21:46,602 --> 06:21:48,700
to privacy. Jackson thank you

8451
06:21:48,700 --> 06:21:50,700
mister President Colleagues

8452
06:21:50,503 --> 06:21:52,507
this is a very straightforward

8453
06:21:52,507 --> 06:21:54,242
measure to address an issue

8454
06:21:54,242 --> 06:21:55,811
that affects every consumer in

8455
06:21:55,811 --> 06:21:58,112
the state of california which

8456
06:21:58,112 --> 06:22:00,281
is the buying and selling. Of

8457
06:22:00,281 --> 06:22:02,180
our personal information last

8458
06:22:02,180 --> 06:22:04,382
year we enacted the california

8459
06:22:04,382 --> 06:22:07,382
consumer privacy act and in

8460
06:22:07,488 --> 06:22:07,988
doing so this legislature gave

8461
06:22:07,988 --> 06:22:10,388
californians many of the

8462
06:22:14,962 --> 06:22:17,610
necessary. Thank you gave me a

8463
06:22:17,610 --> 06:22:18,532
are last year we by enacting

8464
06:22:18,532 --> 06:22:19,999
this legislation the california

8465
06:22:19,999 --> 06:22:22,333
consumer privacy act the

8466
06:22:22,333 --> 06:22:24,333
legislature gave californian

8467
06:22:25,800 --> 06:22:26,306
many of the necessary tools to

8468
06:22:26,306 --> 06:22:29,306
take charge of their personal

8469
06:22:29,876 --> 06:22:30,643
information. Strting January

8470
06:22:30,643 --> 06:22:32,944
one twenty twenty californians

8471
06:22:32,944 --> 06:22:34,913
will be able to exercise our

8472
06:22:34,913 --> 06:22:37,313
individual rights to monitor

8473
06:22:37,412 --> 06:22:40,350
and control how are data is

8474
06:22:40,350 --> 06:22:42,385
used sold. Or otherwise

8475
06:22:42,385 --> 06:22:44,387
exchange but these rights are

8476
06:22:44,387 --> 06:22:47,457
only as good as a consumers

8477
06:22:47,457 --> 06:22:48,557
power to enforce them and a key

8478
06:22:48,557 --> 06:22:51,161
component of taking charge is

8479
06:22:51,161 --> 06:22:52,362
to simply know. What businesses

8480
06:22:52,362 --> 06:22:54,762
are holding your personal

8481
06:22:55,631 --> 06:22:56,902
information. To that end this

8482
06:22:56,902 --> 06:22:59,604
bill seeks to ensure that data

8483
06:22:59,604 --> 06:23:01,303
brokers. To find generally as

8484
06:23:01,303 --> 06:23:03,105
businesses that are collecting

8485
06:23:03,105 --> 06:23:05,240
and selling the personal

8486
06:23:05,240 --> 06:23:06,375
information of consumers with

8487
06:23:06,375 --> 06:23:09,278
whom they have no direct

8488
06:23:09,278 --> 06:23:10,809
relationship. It will require

8489
06:23:10,809 --> 06:23:12,444
that these data brokers

8490
06:23:12,444 --> 06:23:13,748
register with the attorney

8491
06:23:13,748 --> 06:23:16,487
general so we know who they

8492
06:23:16,487 --> 06:23:17,954
are. The attorney general would

8493
06:23:17,954 --> 06:23:19,985
then be required to create a

8494
06:23:19,985 --> 06:23:22,385
registry and host that

8495
06:23:22,685 --> 06:23:24,358
information on its website. By

8496
06:23:24,358 --> 06:23:26,758
requiring data brokers to

8497
06:23:28,960 --> 06:23:31,696
register with the state we can

8498
06:23:32,698 --> 06:23:33,331
take a small legislative step.

8499
06:23:33,331 --> 06:23:34,163
That imposes minimal burdens on

8500
06:23:34,163 --> 06:23:34,702
the businesses that benefit

8501
06:23:34,702 --> 06:23:36,301
from the exchange of our

8502
06:23:36,301 --> 06:23:38,701
information and it power

8503
06:23:38,706 --> 06:23:40,771
consumers to exercise their

8504
06:23:40,771 --> 06:23:41,403
rights under the law with that

8505
06:23:41,403 --> 06:23:44,406
I respectfully ask for your aye

8506
06:23:44,406 --> 06:23:46,180
vote. Any description of it on

8507
06:23:46,180 --> 06:23:47,546
this I don't senator to burke.

8508
06:23:47,546 --> 06:23:48,946
Yeah I think it's a completely

8509
06:23:48,946 --> 06:23:51,346
consistent with the underlying

8510
06:23:51,749 --> 06:23:52,386
architecture and purpose in

8511
06:23:52,386 --> 06:23:55,986
framework. Of the privacy act I

8512
06:23:55,986 --> 06:23:56,620
ask your support. Thank you in

8513
06:23:56,620 --> 06:23:59,893
addition is scripture to bet on

8514
06:23:59,893 --> 06:24:01,491
this item. Xenon senator

8515
06:24:01,491 --> 06:24:03,259
jackson's ought to close this

8516
06:24:03,259 --> 06:24:05,995
thank you I agree I wish this

8517
06:24:05,995 --> 06:24:07,532
were stronger I wish we had. A

8518
06:24:07,532 --> 06:24:09,568
greater ability to know who

8519
06:24:09,568 --> 06:24:10,433
these data brokers are because

8520
06:24:10,433 --> 06:24:12,601
you're not people with whom we

8521
06:24:12,601 --> 06:24:14,737
have a direct relationship but

8522
06:24:14,737 --> 06:24:16,436
this is a good start to require

8523
06:24:16,436 --> 06:24:19,207
that the data brokers who do in

8524
06:24:19,207 --> 06:24:21,420
fact take and use and sell our

8525
06:24:21,420 --> 06:24:22,743
information. At least have to

8526
06:24:22,743 --> 06:24:24,945
register with the attorney

8527
06:24:24,945 --> 06:24:27,800
general so that we can then go

8528
06:24:27,800 --> 06:24:28,470
from there to try to find out

8529
06:24:28,470 --> 06:24:30,416
who they are and what they're

8530
06:24:30,416 --> 06:24:31,284
doing with that information

8531
06:24:31,284 --> 06:24:33,684
without I would respectfully

8532
06:24:33,750 --> 06:24:36,389
ask for your aye vote.

8533
06:24:36,389 --> 06:24:39,389
Researcher please call the roll.

8534
06:24:41,293 --> 06:24:44,293
Alan hi archuleta I atkins

8535
06:24:48,264 --> 06:24:51,264
bates. No bell by porges.

8536
06:24:52,402 --> 06:24:56,200
Bradford alright I cal gyro hi

8537
06:24:59,611 --> 06:25:02,980
change no daly no dodd I dorado.

8538
06:25:02,980 --> 06:25:05,980
Hi galgiani aye glazer hi

8539
06:25:07,652 --> 06:25:10,652
gonzalez I growth no hertzberg

8540
06:25:13,722 --> 06:25:17,525
aye aye hill. By with so I tado

8541
06:25:17,525 --> 06:25:21,125
hi jackson I jones. No leyva

8542
06:25:21,996 --> 06:25:24,996
aye mcguire hi mitchell hi

8543
06:25:26,570 --> 06:25:29,136
monning hi more lock no merrell.

8544
06:25:29,136 --> 06:25:32,136
No nielsen no pan aye

8545
06:25:36,278 --> 06:25:39,278
portantino. Roth I rubio. Aye

8546
06:25:39,612 --> 06:25:43,212
aye skinner aye stern aye stone

8547
06:25:44,830 --> 06:25:47,683
no number. What caskey hi I

8548
06:25:51,890 --> 06:25:51,623
winner aye wilk no no. Mister

8549
06:25:51,623 --> 06:25:52,791
Secretary please call the

8550
06:25:52,791 --> 06:25:55,191
absent members portantino I.

8551
06:26:01,528 --> 06:26:03,928
atkins gorgeous. The measure

8552
06:26:05,132 --> 06:26:08,732
passed ice twenty seven no nos

8553
06:26:21,515 --> 06:26:23,915
ten the measure passes

8554
06:26:54,546 --> 06:26:55,947
. Members

8555
06:26:55,947 --> 06:26:59,150
there was the error I is there

8556
06:26:59,150 --> 06:26:59,720
any objection to adding senator

8557
06:26:59,720 --> 06:27:03,320
umberg to the last roll call

8558
06:27:07,157 --> 06:27:07,758
yes. No there's no objection.

8559
06:27:07,758 --> 06:27:11,358
Ice twenty eight knows ten the

8560
06:27:24,200 --> 06:27:26,200
measure passes

8561
06:27:30,145 --> 06:27:31,876
. The everybody's.

8562
06:27:31,876 --> 06:27:33,547
Members we're just going to

8563
06:27:33,547 --> 06:27:35,140
suspend action for about five

8564
06:27:35,140 --> 06:27:36,816
or ten minutes so we can get to

8565
06:27:36,816 --> 06:27:39,919
the files from on both houses

8566
06:27:39,919 --> 06:27:40,553
and we just ask for you to stay

8567
06:27:40,553 --> 06:27:44,153
close by because we'll be ready

8568
06:27:52,262 --> 06:27:52,795
to roll shortly. We're asking

8569
06:27:52,795 --> 06:27:55,795
everybody stay put in the

8570
06:27:56,620 --> 06:27:56,663
committee room please. We're

8571
06:27:56,663 --> 06:27:57,133
not asking to go back to your

8572
06:27:57,133 --> 06:27:58,734
office and stay in the

8573
06:27:58,734 --> 06:28:01,134
committee rumor. Just outside

8574
06:28:15,190 --> 06:28:17,190
the hearing room

8575
06:39:09,975 --> 06:39:10,576
. All right.

8576
06:39:10,576 --> 06:39:14,176
Members were ready to get back

8577
06:39:14,379 --> 06:39:16,514
to work. We're ready to take up

8578
06:39:16,514 --> 06:39:18,914
upplemental five number two

8579
06:39:19,185 --> 06:39:23,385
our first item up is items file

8580
06:39:24,553 --> 06:39:25,870
item sixty one senator hill sb

8581
06:39:25,870 --> 06:39:27,656
two two two or you prepare

8582
06:39:27,656 --> 06:39:30,560
check senator hill. Miss

8583
06:39:30,292 --> 06:39:30,926
Secretary please read the bill

8584
06:39:30,926 --> 06:39:31,757
two twenty two by senator hill

8585
06:39:31,757 --> 06:39:33,793
an act relating to

8586
06:39:33,793 --> 06:39:34,499
discrimination berryhill thank

8587
06:39:34,499 --> 06:39:36,765
you Mister President calling

8588
06:39:36,765 --> 06:39:37,968
this be two twenty two will

8589
06:39:37,968 --> 06:39:38,633
protect our veterans and

8590
06:39:38,633 --> 06:39:40,268
military from housing

8591
06:39:40,268 --> 06:39:42,268
discrimination assemblymembers

8592
06:39:42,504 --> 06:39:43,572
made technical changes and add

8593
06:39:43,572 --> 06:39:45,972
chapter in language I

8594
06:39:46,340 --> 06:39:46,841
respectfully ask for aye vote

8595
06:39:46,841 --> 06:39:48,576
on. The concurrence of a

8596
06:39:48,576 --> 06:39:49,144
amendments in the assembly. Any

8597
06:39:49,144 --> 06:39:52,144
discussion or debate on this

8598
06:39:54,216 --> 06:39:57,216
item. Hearing see none. I'm

8599
06:40:00,952 --> 06:40:01,552
sorry. Our members we were

8600
06:40:01,552 --> 06:40:03,952
doing recall Mister Secretary

8601
06:40:07,727 --> 06:40:10,727
please call the world. Allen.

8602
06:40:12,998 --> 06:40:15,998
Archuleta I atkins bates bell.

8603
06:40:17,650 --> 06:40:20,650
Gorgeous. Bradford hi hi kelly

8604
06:40:28,426 --> 06:40:31,426
hero. Chiang. Chiang ari deli.

8605
06:40:33,830 --> 06:40:36,683
Dot mind hi dorado I galgiani

8606
06:40:45,224 --> 06:40:45,443
aye glazer aye gonzalez our

8607
06:40:45,443 --> 06:40:45,859
growth. Hertzberg aye hill aye

8608
06:40:45,859 --> 06:40:49,459
hueso hi tado. Hi jackson I

8609
06:40:50,496 --> 06:40:53,496
jones. Hi leyva aye mcguire.

8610
06:40:54,467 --> 06:40:57,467
Mitchell. Hi monning hi more

8611
06:41:02,274 --> 06:41:05,811
luck. Rail. Nielsen aye pan by

8612
06:41:05,811 --> 06:41:08,811
portantino aye roth aye rubio.

8613
06:41:12,181 --> 06:41:15,550
Skinner. I stern aye stone. I

8614
06:41:15,550 --> 06:41:18,550
number iowa caskey aye aye

8615
06:41:21,456 --> 06:41:22,527
wiener aye wilk aye I. Centers

8616
06:41:22,527 --> 06:41:26,000
will move the call twenty eight

8617
06:41:26,000 --> 06:41:28,167
zero. Next item up is I don't

8618
06:41:28,167 --> 06:41:29,601
file I'm sixty two by sir why

8619
06:41:29,601 --> 06:41:32,402
because he missed sector please

8620
06:41:32,402 --> 06:41:34,369
read senate bill three twenty

8621
06:41:34,369 --> 06:41:35,500
three by senator y. Caskey and

8622
06:41:35,500 --> 06:41:36,942
act really into common interest

8623
06:41:36,942 --> 06:41:38,841
developments. The white kaski

8624
06:41:38,841 --> 06:41:40,376
thank you Mister President

8625
06:41:40,376 --> 06:41:42,440
members sb at three two three

8626
06:41:42,440 --> 06:41:43,648
adds much needed parameters

8627
06:41:43,648 --> 06:41:45,648
around how homeowners

8628
06:41:46,110 --> 06:41:47,446
associations render elections

8629
06:41:47,446 --> 06:41:48,847
assembly members further

8630
06:41:48,847 --> 06:41:50,919
narrowed the bill and

8631
06:41:50,919 --> 06:41:51,519
incorporated language offered

8632
06:41:51,519 --> 06:41:54,519
by the administration I region

8633
06:41:55,152 --> 06:41:56,422
I vote. He hey did shoot

8634
06:41:56,422 --> 06:41:58,925
debater discussion on this I

8635
06:41:58,925 --> 06:42:01,925
don't. See nine Miss Sector

8636
06:42:03,927 --> 06:42:06,927
please call the roll. Alan.

8637
06:42:08,534 --> 06:42:11,534
Archuleta hi hi atkins. Eight

8638
06:42:13,537 --> 06:42:17,137
no bill hi burgess. Bradford I

8639
06:42:19,742 --> 06:42:22,742
caballero I chiang. Delhi. No

8640
06:42:24,346 --> 06:42:26,314
dodd aye aye dorado I galgiani

8641
06:42:26,314 --> 06:42:29,314
aye glazer aye gonzalez our

8642
06:42:33,210 --> 06:42:36,210
growth hertzberg. Hill hi I

8643
06:42:37,580 --> 06:42:41,858
with so I by tado hi jackson. I

8644
06:42:44,501 --> 06:42:47,501
jones. Note leyva aye mcguire.

8645
06:42:48,235 --> 06:42:51,235
Mitchell hi monning. I'm more

8646
06:42:52,804 --> 06:42:56,404
lock no morale no nielsen no

8647
06:42:56,546 --> 06:43:00,146
pan aye portantino aye roth aye

8648
06:43:03,552 --> 06:43:06,552
rubio. Skinner aye stern. Stone

8649
06:43:09,923 --> 06:43:14,123
one no. Number I have five a

8650
06:43:15,997 --> 06:43:18,162
caskey hi I winner hi wilk no.

8651
06:43:18,162 --> 06:43:20,363
ice twenty three knows eight

8652
06:43:20,363 --> 06:43:23,366
the measures on call next item

8653
06:43:23,366 --> 06:43:23,967
up is file item sixty three by

8654
06:43:23,967 --> 06:43:26,367
senator dodd Mister Secretary

8655
06:43:27,737 --> 06:43:28,340
please read. Senate bill for

8656
06:43:28,340 --> 06:43:31,940
forty two by senator dodd anak

8657
06:43:35,911 --> 06:43:38,911
ruling the state parks. What

8658
06:43:39,417 --> 06:43:43,617
time is very dot. This bill has

8659
06:43:44,419 --> 06:43:44,984
no novo tasker I both. Any

8660
06:43:44,984 --> 06:43:47,289
discussion or debate on this

8661
06:43:47,289 --> 06:43:50,889
item. Was six or please call

8662
06:43:52,861 --> 06:43:55,861
the roll. Allen archuleta I

8663
06:43:59,264 --> 06:44:02,264
atkins. Bates hi bill by

8664
06:44:02,637 --> 06:44:05,370
burgess hi bradford. I

8665
06:44:07,213 --> 06:44:10,813
callero I chiang I daly hi

8666
06:44:11,512 --> 06:44:15,112
dodd hi fi dorado aye galgiani

8667
06:44:15,749 --> 06:44:19,349
aye glazer aye gonzalez I grow.

8668
06:44:22,540 --> 06:44:25,654
I hertzberg. Hill aye aye hueso.

8669
06:44:26,258 --> 06:44:31,580
Hi tado by jackson I jones hi I

8670
06:44:32,980 --> 06:44:34,964
leyva. I'm acquire. Mitchell hi

8671
06:44:34,964 --> 06:44:38,669
fi monning I'm more luck hi I'm

8672
06:44:38,669 --> 06:44:42,869
a real aye nielsen aye pan aye

8673
06:44:44,750 --> 06:44:47,675
portantino. I roth I rubio aye

8674
06:44:49,780 --> 06:44:52,749
aye skinner aye stern aye stone.

8675
06:44:52,749 --> 06:44:56,349
Hi number I would county I

8676
06:45:01,591 --> 06:45:04,124
wiener aye wilk hi. Thirty six

8677
06:45:04,124 --> 06:45:07,290
our eyes no zero measures on

8678
06:45:07,290 --> 06:45:09,633
call next up is file item sixty

8679
06:45:09,633 --> 06:45:12,633
fives senator glazer. Yeah we

8680
06:45:17,669 --> 06:45:20,740
just. Sixty five sb six the six

8681
06:45:20,740 --> 06:45:22,610
yes six oh six. The sector

8682
06:45:22,610 --> 06:45:24,308
please read the bill six of six

8683
06:45:24,308 --> 06:45:27,308
by senator glazer and naturally

8684
06:45:28,448 --> 06:45:29,482
nay professions and vocations.

8685
06:45:29,482 --> 06:45:31,383
Glazer I thank you Mister

8686
06:45:31,383 --> 06:45:32,749
President members at. This that

8687
06:45:32,749 --> 06:45:33,920
bills back for concurrence

8688
06:45:33,920 --> 06:45:35,188
assembly member it's added a

8689
06:45:35,188 --> 06:45:36,856
sunset date for the board of

8690
06:45:36,856 --> 06:45:37,993
barber in cosmetology extended

8691
06:45:37,993 --> 06:45:39,924
the governor's authority to

8692
06:45:39,924 --> 06:45:40,558
appoint an executive office for

8693
06:45:40,558 --> 06:45:43,259
the board of vocational nursing

8694
06:45:43,259 --> 06:45:43,896
and psychiatric technicians. No

8695
06:45:43,896 --> 06:45:46,296
opposition respectfully ask for

8696
06:45:48,233 --> 06:45:48,798
either. Use caution rebate

8697
06:45:48,798 --> 06:45:51,798
hearing ting on Miss Sector

8698
06:45:52,569 --> 06:45:55,569
please call the roll. Allen

8699
06:45:55,905 --> 06:45:58,905
archuleta. I atkins bates hi

8700
06:46:01,510 --> 06:46:05,110
bill. I bridges are bradford hi

8701
06:46:06,482 --> 06:46:10,820
by caballero by chain I daly.

8702
06:46:10,153 --> 06:46:13,753
Dodd I dorado aye galgiani aye

8703
06:46:13,852 --> 06:46:17,452
glazer aye gonzalez by growth I

8704
06:46:19,270 --> 06:46:22,270
hertzberg. Hill aye aye hueso

8705
06:46:25,960 --> 06:46:28,696
aye tado. Jackson I jones. I

8706
06:46:30,134 --> 06:46:33,134
leyva aye mcguire. Mitchell aye

8707
06:46:34,410 --> 06:46:37,410
monning I'm more luck. Morrell

8708
06:46:38,678 --> 06:46:42,278
aye aye nielsen. No pan aye

8709
06:46:44,250 --> 06:46:47,250
portantino. I roth aye rubio

8710
06:46:48,217 --> 06:46:51,600
aye skinner aye stern aye stone

8711
06:46:51,600 --> 06:46:55,260
aye amberg I work out see I

8712
06:46:56,960 --> 06:46:57,528
wiener aye wilk hi. Daly aye

8713
06:46:57,528 --> 06:47:00,528
please call please call the

8714
06:47:01,331 --> 06:47:03,731
absent members hertzberg. Allen.

8715
06:47:07,134 --> 06:47:09,534
Atkins tado. Mcguire warlock

8716
06:47:14,476 --> 06:47:15,643
well I got thirty five. Then

8717
06:47:15,643 --> 06:47:17,313
remove the call members were

8718
06:47:17,313 --> 06:47:20,913
moving to file item sixty four

8719
06:47:23,284 --> 06:47:25,284
senator bradford. Yeah.

8720
06:47:27,510 --> 06:47:28,889
Whenever you're ready sir.

8721
06:47:28,889 --> 06:47:31,889
Sorry please read yeah senate

8722
06:47:33,610 --> 06:47:33,760
bill. Five ninety five a

8723
06:47:33,760 --> 06:47:35,796
senator bradford enact related

8724
06:47:35,796 --> 06:47:38,696
campus that are bradford thank

8725
06:47:38,696 --> 06:47:39,132
you Madam President sb five

8726
06:47:39,132 --> 06:47:40,366
nine five is backing

8727
06:47:40,366 --> 06:47:41,804
concurrence amendment simply

8728
06:47:41,804 --> 06:47:44,204
push back to implement

8729
06:47:44,403 --> 06:47:45,500
implementation date. At a co

8730
06:47:45,500 --> 06:47:46,570
author I respectfully ask for

8731
06:47:46,570 --> 06:47:49,570
your vote. Any discussion or

8732
06:47:50,574 --> 06:47:51,143
debate. Seeing and hearing them

8733
06:47:51,143 --> 06:47:53,543
Mister Secretary please call

8734
06:47:56,582 --> 06:47:59,582
the roll. Allen archuleta I

8735
06:48:01,686 --> 06:48:04,686
atkins bates. Bell I'm by

8736
06:48:04,790 --> 06:48:07,790
porges no bradford hi kelly

8737
06:48:10,728 --> 06:48:15,528
hero I chain no daly. Dot hi I

8738
06:48:16,331 --> 06:48:18,469
dorado I galgiani aye glazer

8739
06:48:18,469 --> 06:48:21,469
aye gonzalez I growth no

8740
06:48:23,908 --> 06:48:27,508
hertzberg. I hill. With so I

8741
06:48:31,512 --> 06:48:35,112
taco. Jackson I jones. No leyva

8742
06:48:36,552 --> 06:48:39,552
aye mcguire. Mitchell hi money

8743
06:48:40,253 --> 06:48:43,253
I'm more lock. Morrell no

8744
06:48:47,293 --> 06:48:50,293
nielsen. No pan aye portantino

8745
06:48:51,597 --> 06:48:55,197
I roth aye rubio aye skinner

8746
06:48:57,720 --> 06:48:59,938
aye stern aye stone no burke

8747
06:48:59,938 --> 06:49:03,538
I'd our caskey I winner. Hi

8748
06:49:06,878 --> 06:49:07,478
wilk I by. All the ice twenty

8749
06:49:07,478 --> 06:49:11,780
five no seven senator moves a

8750
06:49:23,563 --> 06:49:25,563
call

8751
06:49:32,602 --> 06:49:33,199
. Next up is follow up item

8752
06:49:33,199 --> 06:49:35,399
sixty six by senator more log

8753
06:49:35,399 --> 06:49:37,671
Mister Secretary please rate.

8754
06:49:37,671 --> 06:49:38,738
Senate bill seven fifty four by

8755
06:49:38,738 --> 06:49:39,306
senator more locked enact

8756
06:49:39,306 --> 06:49:41,141
really in a common interest

8757
06:49:41,141 --> 06:49:42,730
developments that are more

8758
06:49:42,730 --> 06:49:44,730
lock. Mister President

8759
06:49:45,840 --> 06:49:46,674
colleagues. Senate bill six

8760
06:49:46,674 --> 06:49:48,980
fifty four are provides

8761
06:49:48,980 --> 06:49:50,381
technical amendments that

8762
06:49:50,381 --> 06:49:53,381
address chapter in out issues

8763
06:49:54,986 --> 06:49:55,452
and it's on concurrence we have

8764
06:49:55,452 --> 06:49:56,190
had no no votes and I

8765
06:49:56,190 --> 06:49:59,190
respectfully ask for an aye

8766
06:50:01,692 --> 06:50:03,640
vote. Seven seven fifty four

8767
06:50:03,640 --> 06:50:04,259
seven fifty four sb seven five

8768
06:50:04,259 --> 06:50:07,363
four is there any discussion or

8769
06:50:07,363 --> 06:50:07,964
debate on this I don't. Ninety

8770
06:50:07,964 --> 06:50:10,964
nine secretary please call the

8771
06:50:12,602 --> 06:50:15,602
roll. Allen. March eleventh aye

8772
06:50:18,503 --> 06:50:21,175
aye atkins. Bates. Hi bill I

8773
06:50:21,175 --> 06:50:24,775
porges are bradford all right I

8774
06:50:27,130 --> 06:50:30,483
caballero by chain aye daly aye

8775
06:50:30,483 --> 06:50:33,483
dodd aye aye dorado. Galgiani

8776
06:50:33,719 --> 06:50:36,719
aye glazer aye gonzalez I

8777
06:50:37,356 --> 06:50:40,356
growth I hertzberg. Hill aye

8778
06:50:44,600 --> 06:50:47,660
hueso. I tado I jackson. Jones

8779
06:50:49,834 --> 06:50:52,834
jones hi labor. I mcguire.

8780
06:50:56,730 --> 06:50:59,730
Mitchell. Monning I'm more lock.

8781
06:51:00,642 --> 06:51:04,842
I'm a real aye nielsen aye pan

8782
06:51:05,470 --> 06:51:08,470
aye portantino. I roth aye

8783
06:51:08,387 --> 06:51:11,722
rubio aye skinner aye stern aye

8784
06:51:11,722 --> 06:51:15,922
stone. I amberg I am I what

8785
06:51:19,796 --> 06:51:23,396
caskey. Wiener. I wilk hi by

8786
06:51:25,167 --> 06:51:25,766
three thirty. Thirty two I

8787
06:51:25,766 --> 06:51:29,366
thirty to the guys know knows

8788
06:51:42,112 --> 06:51:44,512
the measures on call

8789
06:51:52,523 --> 06:51:53,857
. Members

8790
06:51:53,857 --> 06:51:55,826
we're gonna take a fifteen

8791
06:51:55,826 --> 06:51:57,293
minute recess this is time if

8792
06:51:57,293 --> 06:51:58,192
you need to run to your officer

8793
06:51:58,192 --> 06:52:01,164
handle any bridge the business

8794
06:52:01,164 --> 06:52:04,402
that we actually do it now. And

8795
06:52:04,402 --> 06:52:05,100
will be starting back up in

8796
06:52:05,100 --> 06:52:08,100
fifteen minutes will. We stand

8797
06:52:21,184 --> 06:52:23,184
in recess

8798
07:27:49,830 --> 07:27:50,433
. Down to forty two or

8799
07:27:50,433 --> 07:27:52,833
three would greatly appreciate

8800
07:28:06,479 --> 07:28:08,479
it

8801
07:31:35,567 --> 07:31:37,967
. Members were trying to

8802
07:31:41,506 --> 07:31:42,807
reconvene this the senate. We

8803
07:31:42,807 --> 07:31:45,710
have items that we would like

8804
07:31:45,710 --> 07:31:48,880
to take up our first item of

8805
07:31:48,880 --> 07:31:52,282
business is file item fifty one.

8806
07:31:52,282 --> 07:31:55,282
Give center skinner minute. To

8807
07:31:55,848 --> 07:31:58,848
present file item fifty one.

8808
07:32:03,458 --> 07:32:04,327
File item fifty one sb baby.

8809
07:32:04,327 --> 07:32:06,727
Fifty four. The secretary

8810
07:32:07,610 --> 07:32:08,399
please read assembly bill fifty

8811
07:32:08,399 --> 07:32:10,430
four by assembly member ting an

8812
07:32:10,430 --> 07:32:12,330
ackerley to recycling making a

8813
07:32:12,330 --> 07:32:12,900
preparation therefore and

8814
07:32:12,900 --> 07:32:14,434
clearing their throats take

8815
07:32:14,434 --> 07:32:16,434
facsimile thirty skinner

8816
07:32:17,390 --> 07:32:18,640
percent design yes red hat

8817
07:32:18,640 --> 07:32:21,400
thank you Mister President

8818
07:32:21,341 --> 07:32:23,407
members ab fifty four is an

8819
07:32:23,407 --> 07:32:27,700
urgency bill to help us deal

8820
07:32:28,681 --> 07:32:29,246
with the recent closure of our

8821
07:32:29,246 --> 07:32:30,683
two hundred for eighty four

8822
07:32:30,683 --> 07:32:33,683
recycling centers it would find

8823
07:32:36,155 --> 07:32:36,756
mobile recycling pilots in.

8824
07:32:36,756 --> 07:32:39,756
Areas impacted by the closures

8825
07:32:39,795 --> 07:32:40,360
and with that I ask your rivals.

8826
07:32:40,360 --> 07:32:43,462
Any discussion of the ban on

8827
07:32:43,462 --> 07:32:44,620
this I don't. Hearing seen on

8828
07:32:44,620 --> 07:32:47,620
the secretary please call the

8829
07:32:51,736 --> 07:32:54,736
roll. Alan. Archuleta hi by.

8830
07:32:57,500 --> 07:32:59,543
Atkins aye bates aye bell hi

8831
07:32:59,543 --> 07:33:02,543
porges are bradford hi kelly

8832
07:33:05,515 --> 07:33:08,453
hero I chiang I daly aye dodd

8833
07:33:08,453 --> 07:33:11,453
aye dorado aye galgiani aye

8834
07:33:15,225 --> 07:33:17,795
glazer. Aye gonzalez hi growth.

8835
07:33:17,795 --> 07:33:21,395
Hi hertzberg hi I hill aye

8836
07:33:21,931 --> 07:33:25,267
hueso aye entire tado I jackson

8837
07:33:25,267 --> 07:33:28,867
by jones. Hi leyva I'm acquire

8838
07:33:30,141 --> 07:33:32,875
by mitchell. Money. I'm more

8839
07:33:32,875 --> 07:33:37,750
luck I'm a real by nielsen aye

8840
07:33:38,925 --> 07:33:42,525
pan. By portantino hi aye roth

8841
07:33:42,552 --> 07:33:46,152
aye rubio aye skinner aye stern

8842
07:33:46,919 --> 07:33:50,519
aye stone. I amberg iraq owski

8843
07:33:54,496 --> 07:33:58,330
I winner I wilk I. The sector

8844
07:33:58,330 --> 07:34:01,330
please call the absent members.

8845
07:34:05,103 --> 07:34:06,838
Allen I mitchell. Call centers

8846
07:34:06,838 --> 07:34:09,675
skinner moves a call next item

8847
07:34:09,675 --> 07:34:12,676
up members is file item forty

8848
07:34:12,676 --> 07:34:13,312
four ab seven nine two centers

8849
07:34:13,312 --> 07:34:16,312
skinner you prepare for this

8850
07:34:16,313 --> 07:34:18,880
item yes I am our server was

8851
07:34:18,880 --> 07:34:22,480
forty five my God forty five.

8852
07:34:23,252 --> 07:34:26,188
Ab seven nine two. Mister

8853
07:34:26,188 --> 07:34:28,920
Secretary please call the roll

8854
07:34:28,920 --> 07:34:29,593
on file item forty five let me

8855
07:34:29,593 --> 07:34:32,357
percent for our low let me

8856
07:34:32,357 --> 07:34:33,829
percent first. I mean I'm sorry

8857
07:34:33,829 --> 07:34:36,670
please read the bill I'm sorry.

8858
07:34:36,670 --> 07:34:37,399
Assembly bill seven ninety two

8859
07:34:37,399 --> 07:34:37,998
by assemblymember ting an act

8860
07:34:37,998 --> 07:34:40,398
relating to recycling. Centers

8861
07:34:41,400 --> 07:34:43,800
skinner. Thank you Mister

8862
07:34:44,203 --> 07:34:46,603
President members. This bill.

8863
07:34:46,605 --> 07:34:48,420
Helps address the fact that our

8864
07:34:48,420 --> 07:34:50,420
recycling markets have

8865
07:34:50,775 --> 07:34:52,844
collapsed due to the countries

8866
07:34:52,844 --> 07:34:54,415
in asia that we used to rely on

8867
07:34:54,415 --> 07:34:55,716
to sell all of our recycling

8868
07:34:55,716 --> 07:34:58,516
products are not buying them

8869
07:34:58,516 --> 07:35:01,486
any longer. And so instead what

8870
07:35:01,486 --> 07:35:04,486
we expected to recycle are

8871
07:35:05,550 --> 07:35:07,959
filling our landfills this is a.

8872
07:35:07,959 --> 07:35:10,825
Bill that sends a market signal.

8873
07:35:10,825 --> 07:35:13,797
That will benefit our in state

8874
07:35:13,797 --> 07:35:16,630
plastic bottle of manufacturers

8875
07:35:16,630 --> 07:35:19,570
to help us close the route loop

8876
07:35:19,570 --> 07:35:21,501
in recycling. It establishes a

8877
07:35:21,501 --> 07:35:23,339
time frame for bottled beverage

8878
07:35:23,339 --> 07:35:25,739
manufacturers to achieve a

8879
07:35:25,942 --> 07:35:28,342
minimum recycled content. The

8880
07:35:28,577 --> 07:35:31,577
amendments that removed the low

8881
07:35:32,545 --> 07:35:34,327
the 75% content have pulled off

8882
07:35:34,327 --> 07:35:35,387
the following opposition the

8883
07:35:35,387 --> 07:35:38,200
cal chamber is no longer

8884
07:35:38,200 --> 07:35:39,855
opposed the manufacturing

8885
07:35:39,855 --> 07:35:41,658
association is no longer oppose

8886
07:35:41,658 --> 07:35:43,258
the international bottled water

8887
07:35:43,258 --> 07:35:45,360
association is no longer

8888
07:35:45,360 --> 07:35:48,360
opposed and nestle waters has

8889
07:35:48,528 --> 07:35:52,128
come board in support. And with

8890
07:35:52,565 --> 07:35:53,999
that I ask bureau vote. Any

8891
07:35:53,999 --> 07:35:55,771
discussion or debate on this

8892
07:35:55,771 --> 07:35:56,899
item center why college you

8893
07:35:56,899 --> 07:35:58,270
Mister President I rise in

8894
07:35:58,270 --> 07:36:00,172
support of the bill I want to

8895
07:36:00,172 --> 07:36:01,874
congratulate the author I was

8896
07:36:01,874 --> 07:36:03,709
sent successful last year in a

8897
07:36:03,709 --> 07:36:06,477
minimum content bill on in the

8898
07:36:06,477 --> 07:36:08,120
other house it's a it's a good

8899
07:36:08,120 --> 07:36:10,415
bill it starts us down the road

8900
07:36:10,415 --> 07:36:12,415
towards a-meeting minimum

8901
07:36:13,317 --> 07:36:15,717
requirements. Eminem content on

8902
07:36:15,956 --> 07:36:17,188
our products all right well I

8903
07:36:17,188 --> 07:36:19,588
understand that the seventy

8904
07:36:19,590 --> 07:36:22,626
five percent. Number had to be

8905
07:36:22,626 --> 07:36:25,729
removed it's gone it said it's

8906
07:36:25,729 --> 07:36:28,466
a good start in a I would urge

8907
07:36:28,466 --> 07:36:29,670
other members to vote I. Thank

8908
07:36:29,670 --> 07:36:31,269
you any additional discussion

8909
07:36:31,269 --> 07:36:31,802
or debate on this item. In

8910
07:36:31,802 --> 07:36:34,202
nineteen on center skinner

8911
07:36:35,905 --> 07:36:36,405
would you like to close. I

8912
07:36:36,405 --> 07:36:38,405
appreciate my colleagues

8913
07:36:42,979 --> 07:36:44,646
addition and a. I think the.

8914
07:36:44,646 --> 07:36:47,810
This is an economic development

8915
07:36:47,810 --> 07:36:50,218
bill as well as a waste

8916
07:36:50,218 --> 07:36:52,250
reduction bill in that it

8917
07:36:52,250 --> 07:36:54,650
stimulates the manufacturing in

8918
07:36:55,790 --> 07:36:56,392
state and across the country of

8919
07:36:56,392 --> 07:36:59,727
plastic bottles so with that I

8920
07:36:59,727 --> 07:37:02,126
ask for your aye vote. Thank

8921
07:37:02,126 --> 07:37:05,726
yous. Six third please call the

8922
07:37:06,499 --> 07:37:09,269
roll. Allen hi archuleta aye

8923
07:37:09,269 --> 07:37:12,869
aye atkins aye bates. Bell I

8924
07:37:13,440 --> 07:37:17,400
barges no bradford all right I

8925
07:37:18,244 --> 07:37:21,844
caballero. I chiang hi dolly I

8926
07:37:24,617 --> 07:37:27,685
dodd I dorado I galgiani aye

8927
07:37:27,685 --> 07:37:30,685
glazer aye gonzalez I growth.

8928
07:37:32,758 --> 07:37:35,758
Hertzberg. Hill aye hueso I

8929
07:37:39,865 --> 07:37:43,465
tado. No. Jackson I jones no

8930
07:37:43,834 --> 07:37:46,834
leyva aye mcguire aye mitchell

8931
07:37:46,837 --> 07:37:50,437
aye monning I'm more lock no

8932
07:37:52,410 --> 07:37:56,509
merrell no nielsen no pan hi hi

8933
07:37:56,509 --> 07:37:59,509
portantino. I roth aye rubio

8934
07:38:01,584 --> 07:38:05,184
aye skinner aye stern aye stone.

8935
07:38:05,785 --> 07:38:09,385
No number I would county I

8936
07:38:11,691 --> 07:38:12,224
wiener aye wilk by. Bob this

8937
07:38:12,224 --> 07:38:15,224
sector please call out to

8938
07:38:20,164 --> 07:38:20,796
members. Bates rove. Five

8939
07:38:20,796 --> 07:38:24,396
thirty one no seven the measure

8940
07:38:36,911 --> 07:38:38,911
passes

8941
07:38:43,319 --> 07:38:44,323
. Members were now

8942
07:38:44,323 --> 07:38:47,524
looking to call on file item

8943
07:38:47,524 --> 07:38:51,124
fifty one. I'm I'm sorry fifty

8944
07:38:54,663 --> 07:38:58,863
one sb. File item fifty six sb

8945
07:38:59,699 --> 07:39:00,339
one thirty six. Can remote

8946
07:39:00,339 --> 07:39:03,339
alright Miss Sector please call

8947
07:39:06,208 --> 07:39:10,408
the roll. Atkins I by glazer by

8948
07:39:18,756 --> 07:39:19,286
portantino. Rubio. Ice twenty

8949
07:39:19,286 --> 07:39:22,286
two no sixteen the measure

8950
07:39:27,827 --> 07:39:29,930
passes. Then I would assembly

8951
07:39:29,930 --> 07:39:32,330
member certain amendments are

8952
07:39:46,175 --> 07:39:48,175
concurred and

8953
07:40:53,806 --> 07:40:55,806
. Members were

8954
07:40:56,141 --> 07:41:00,341
look dean the call on file item

8955
07:41:00,745 --> 07:41:01,277
fifty one. Ab fifty four

8956
07:41:01,277 --> 07:41:03,677
secretary please call the

8957
07:41:08,487 --> 07:41:10,887
absent members. Mitchell. Our

8958
07:41:15,458 --> 07:41:19,580
mitchell I. Forty no zero on

8959
07:41:20,160 --> 07:41:20,661
the urgency. On the measure.

8960
07:41:20,661 --> 07:41:24,261
Ice forty no zero on the

8961
07:41:37,110 --> 07:41:39,510
measure the measure passes

8962
07:44:50,283 --> 07:44:51,590
.

8963
07:44:51,590 --> 07:44:53,723
Members removing back to

8964
07:44:53,723 --> 07:44:56,123
motions and resolutions senator

8965
07:44:57,960 --> 07:45:00,896
skinner. Yes I would like to

8966
07:45:00,896 --> 07:45:05,960
move file item twelve s. C. R.

8967
07:45:06,134 --> 07:45:09,734
Sixty one. To the inactive file.

8968
07:45:13,440 --> 07:45:15,413
And. I would also like to

8969
07:45:15,413 --> 07:45:19,130
submit a letter to the journal

8970
07:45:19,184 --> 07:45:22,850
for sb. Three thirty it is been

8971
07:45:22,850 --> 07:45:25,850
approved by both caucuses and

8972
07:45:27,322 --> 07:45:28,422
it races it just. Clear fires

8973
07:45:28,422 --> 07:45:31,422
an intention regarding sb three

8974
07:45:46,437 --> 07:45:48,437
thirty. Yeah objection

8975
07:45:59,983 --> 07:46:01,718
. Members

8976
07:46:01,718 --> 07:46:05,318
are there any other actions on

8977
07:46:05,420 --> 07:46:07,820
the motions and resolutions.

8978
07:46:21,835 --> 07:46:24,235
Hearing sheena thank you

8979
07:54:54,395 --> 07:54:55,193
.

8980
07:54:55,193 --> 07:54:58,193
Members are gonna look the

8981
07:54:59,197 --> 07:55:01,833
calls first up is file item

8982
07:55:01,833 --> 07:55:04,772
sixty one sb two two two Mister

8983
07:55:04,772 --> 07:55:07,772
Secretary please call the roll.

8984
07:55:13,475 --> 07:55:16,475
Allen. Atkins hi hi bates.

8985
07:55:22,219 --> 07:55:25,219
Rebel. By burgess. For just.

8986
07:55:28,489 --> 07:55:32,890
Caballero. Hi daly hi I growth.

8987
07:55:35,699 --> 07:55:38,699
Mcguire hi more luck morrell.

8988
07:55:40,904 --> 07:55:42,236
Rubio hi ruby I. Grow by.

8989
07:55:42,236 --> 07:55:44,636
Secretary please call the

8990
07:55:44,838 --> 07:55:47,838
absent members allen hi bates.

8991
07:55:54,282 --> 07:55:56,916
Burgess warlock. I. Zero highs

8992
07:55:56,916 --> 07:55:59,916
thirty six no zero assembly

8993
07:56:05,858 --> 07:56:08,494
member it's our concurred in.

8994
07:56:08,494 --> 07:56:11,597
The thing call on file item

8995
07:56:11,597 --> 07:56:12,966
sixty two sb three two three

8996
07:56:12,966 --> 07:56:15,366
Mister Secretary please call

8997
07:56:17,102 --> 07:56:20,102
absent members. Allen I atkins

8998
07:56:23,341 --> 07:56:26,941
by burgess. No chiang no growth

8999
07:56:30,480 --> 07:56:32,880
no hertzberg. Mcguire. Mcguire

9000
07:56:40,520 --> 07:56:41,550
hi rubio I stern. Hi stern aye.

9001
07:56:41,550 --> 07:56:41,588
those were cut the Mister

9002
07:56:41,588 --> 07:56:43,988
Sector please call absent

9003
07:56:46,359 --> 07:56:48,759
members. Hertzberg hi. Twenty

9004
07:56:50,865 --> 07:56:53,865
nine bills eleven limits are

9005
07:56:54,198 --> 07:56:54,763
ice twenty nine knows eleven

9006
07:56:54,763 --> 07:56:57,163
assembly member minutes are

9007
07:57:01,772 --> 07:57:03,638
concurred in. Our live the call

9008
07:57:03,638 --> 07:57:06,638
and follow file item sixty

9009
07:57:06,677 --> 07:57:09,846
three sb. Four four two my

9010
07:57:09,846 --> 07:57:11,846
correct. Excerpted sector

9011
07:57:12,449 --> 07:57:15,449
please call the absent members.

9012
07:57:17,553 --> 07:57:21,153
Allen hi hi atkins I hertzberg

9013
07:57:22,580 --> 07:57:22,756
by mcguire hi. Fourteen zero

9014
07:57:22,756 --> 07:57:24,293
the senate knows our current

9015
07:57:24,293 --> 07:57:26,395
ice forty no zero the assembly

9016
07:57:26,395 --> 07:57:27,697
member members are concurred in

9017
07:57:27,697 --> 07:57:31,297
next were lifting the call on

9018
07:57:35,370 --> 07:57:35,604
file item sixty four sb. Five

9019
07:57:35,604 --> 07:57:36,139
nine five six or please call

9020
07:57:36,139 --> 07:57:38,240
the absent members. These

9021
07:57:38,240 --> 07:57:40,640
people were. Following sixty

9022
07:57:44,278 --> 07:57:47,878
four five nine five. Allen aye

9023
07:57:49,892 --> 07:57:52,255
aye atkins aye bates no. Sally

9024
07:57:52,255 --> 07:57:56,455
are by hill all right by her

9025
07:58:04,333 --> 07:58:07,333
tado. Mcguire by more lock.

9026
07:58:08,264 --> 07:58:08,898
Thirty minutes are ice thirty

9027
07:58:08,898 --> 07:58:11,898
knows eight the some amendments

9028
07:58:18,941 --> 07:58:21,941
are concurred in. Nexus file

9029
07:58:24,115 --> 07:58:24,715
item sixty five sb six old six

9030
07:58:24,715 --> 07:58:27,715
please call the absent members

9031
07:58:31,988 --> 07:58:36,188
allen. Hi I atkins by tado. I

9032
07:58:36,297 --> 07:58:39,897
mcguire aye hi. Was known as

9033
07:58:40,196 --> 07:58:40,796
the ice thirty nine knows one

9034
07:58:40,796 --> 07:58:43,196
assembly moments are concurred

9035
07:58:52,372 --> 07:58:53,340
in. This fall item sixty six sb

9036
07:58:53,340 --> 07:58:53,940
seven five four Mister

9037
07:58:53,940 --> 07:58:56,340
Secretary please call the

9038
07:58:57,710 --> 07:59:00,710
absent members allen. I atkins

9039
07:59:01,983 --> 07:59:05,583
I to ross so. Hertzberg all

9040
07:59:05,682 --> 07:59:08,682
right I jackson. Mcguire I

9041
07:59:16,359 --> 07:59:16,864
mitchell. Black owski. I thirty

9042
07:59:16,864 --> 07:59:19,864
six no zero the assembly

9043
07:59:33,277 --> 07:59:35,677
moments are concurred in

9044
08:04:56,275 --> 08:04:58,275
.

9045
08:04:58,608 --> 08:05:02,208
Members were ready to take up

9046
08:05:02,548 --> 08:05:06,148
file item twenty few. Ab two

9047
08:05:06,249 --> 08:05:07,820
eighteen by senator jackson.

9048
08:05:07,820 --> 08:05:10,220
Senator jackson's ready Mister

9049
08:05:10,789 --> 08:05:12,194
Secretary please read. Assembly

9050
08:05:12,194 --> 08:05:14,128
bill two eighteen by assembly

9051
08:05:14,128 --> 08:05:15,994
member assembly member gonzalez

9052
08:05:15,994 --> 08:05:16,461
and act really to childhood

9053
08:05:16,461 --> 08:05:18,461
sexual assault senator

9054
08:05:18,927 --> 08:05:19,928
jackson's. Thank you Mister

9055
08:05:19,928 --> 08:05:21,928
President good morning

9056
08:05:23,835 --> 08:05:26,708
colleagues today I present to

9057
08:05:26,708 --> 08:05:29,507
you ab twenty two eighteen. By

9058
08:05:29,507 --> 08:05:30,805
assembly member gonzalez this

9059
08:05:30,805 --> 08:05:33,677
measure would extend the civil

9060
08:05:33,677 --> 08:05:34,245
stature it'll limitations for

9061
08:05:34,245 --> 08:05:36,645
victims of childhood sexual

9062
08:05:37,645 --> 08:05:39,783
assault. For mage twenty six to

9063
08:05:39,783 --> 08:05:42,452
age forty and in cases of the

9064
08:05:42,452 --> 08:05:45,286
late discovery from three years

9065
08:05:45,286 --> 08:05:46,523
after the discovery to five the

9066
08:05:46,523 --> 08:05:48,191
bill would also increase the

9067
08:05:48,191 --> 08:05:50,591
amount of damages recoverable

9068
08:05:50,998 --> 08:05:52,662
in instances where there was a

9069
08:05:52,662 --> 08:05:55,162
cover up. Which led to the

9070
08:05:55,162 --> 08:05:57,320
abuse and allow for short three

9071
08:05:57,320 --> 08:05:59,205
year window for past victims

9072
08:05:59,205 --> 08:06:01,303
who a slip through the cracks.

9073
08:06:01,303 --> 08:06:03,572
We know in the research clearly

9074
08:06:03,572 --> 08:06:06,141
shows that it can take decades

9075
08:06:06,141 --> 08:06:08,110
for most victims to be ready to

9076
08:06:08,110 --> 08:06:10,242
come forward to actually even

9077
08:06:10,242 --> 08:06:11,680
to recognize that this event

9078
08:06:11,680 --> 08:06:14,416
which shape in suppressing this

9079
08:06:14,416 --> 08:06:15,617
horrific event or events. Had

9080
08:06:15,617 --> 08:06:18,170
they been suppressing for

9081
08:06:18,789 --> 08:06:21,550
decades were in fact up part of

9082
08:06:21,550 --> 08:06:23,624
their lives and impacted a

9083
08:06:23,624 --> 08:06:25,159
great deal of their lives. It

9084
08:06:25,159 --> 08:06:27,430
is then when they come forward

9085
08:06:27,430 --> 08:06:29,830
but unfortunately the statute

9086
08:06:30,297 --> 08:06:34,497
does allow them to be able to

9087
08:06:35,269 --> 08:06:36,470
seek redress. So this denies

9088
08:06:36,470 --> 08:06:37,571
justice to victims it allows

9089
08:06:37,571 --> 08:06:39,642
the perpetrators of the abuse

9090
08:06:39,642 --> 08:06:41,509
in those complicit to continue

9091
08:06:41,509 --> 08:06:43,375
praying on children or

9092
08:06:43,375 --> 08:06:45,411
otherwise turning a blind eye

9093
08:06:45,411 --> 08:06:47,278
we all of heard the stories.

9094
08:06:47,278 --> 08:06:50,216
And the power that these

9095
08:06:50,216 --> 08:06:52,582
individuals have had over these

9096
08:06:52,582 --> 08:06:54,582
usually youngsters bringing

9097
08:06:55,315 --> 08:06:57,653
this abuse in the shame and-

9098
08:06:57,653 --> 08:06:59,653
difficulties connecting with

9099
08:06:59,889 --> 08:07:00,791
life and being able to live a

9100
08:07:00,791 --> 08:07:03,791
normal life. Until they go

9101
08:07:03,792 --> 08:07:06,295
through therapy. Which can take

9102
08:07:06,295 --> 08:07:07,598
some time so the last time

9103
08:07:07,598 --> 08:07:10,598
california open the window for

9104
08:07:12,268 --> 08:07:12,835
old cases. In twenty two

9105
08:07:12,835 --> 08:07:13,767
thousand three nine hundred

9106
08:07:13,767 --> 08:07:15,802
victims came forward the

9107
08:07:15,802 --> 08:07:18,700
exposed over two hundred and

9108
08:07:18,700 --> 08:07:19,273
fifty child molesters and save

9109
08:07:19,273 --> 08:07:21,173
thousands of children from

9110
08:07:21,173 --> 08:07:22,541
becoming future targets.

9111
08:07:22,541 --> 08:07:24,410
However we know there are many

9112
08:07:24,410 --> 08:07:25,814
who are still out there. Who

9113
08:07:25,814 --> 08:07:27,580
would not made the connection

9114
08:07:27,580 --> 08:07:29,120
between their abuse and current

9115
08:07:29,120 --> 08:07:31,412
psychological injury at the

9116
08:07:31,782 --> 08:07:33,116
time. Of the opening when they

9117
08:07:33,116 --> 08:07:34,887
would have qualified to be able

9118
08:07:34,887 --> 08:07:36,285
to bring these cases because of

9119
08:07:36,285 --> 08:07:38,570
our how our laws currently

9120
08:07:38,570 --> 08:07:39,222
written they will never have a

9121
08:07:39,222 --> 08:07:41,960
chance to come forward and

9122
08:07:41,960 --> 08:07:43,423
pursue legal crane claims. We

9123
08:07:43,423 --> 08:07:45,240
know we can never a race the

9124
08:07:45,240 --> 08:07:47,332
pain but this measure will

9125
08:07:47,332 --> 08:07:48,934
expand access to justice for

9126
08:07:48,934 --> 08:07:50,800
victims of childhood sexual

9127
08:07:50,800 --> 08:07:52,402
assault by granting the more

9128
08:07:52,402 --> 08:07:54,170
time to pursue their legal

9129
08:07:54,170 --> 08:07:56,337
remedies. This hopefully will

9130
08:07:56,337 --> 08:07:57,809
help expose perpetrators who

9131
08:07:57,809 --> 08:08:00,408
have been going on for years

9132
08:08:00,408 --> 08:08:02,853
and de decades abusing our most

9133
08:08:02,853 --> 08:08:05,713
vulnerable youth. And this will

9134
08:08:05,713 --> 08:08:06,314
hold them accountable I

9135
08:08:06,314 --> 08:08:09,314
respectfully ask for your aye

9136
08:08:12,519 --> 08:08:13,870
vote. Any description of the

9137
08:08:13,870 --> 08:08:14,355
bait on the side on senator

9138
08:08:14,355 --> 08:08:16,755
morlock. Thank you Mister

9139
08:08:18,526 --> 08:08:20,595
President. I agree with the

9140
08:08:20,595 --> 08:08:23,260
poor manager that are writing

9141
08:08:23,260 --> 08:08:23,871
the wrongs of past since is a

9142
08:08:23,871 --> 08:08:27,369
right justin and just thing to

9143
08:08:27,369 --> 08:08:28,903
do. And concur that the

9144
08:08:28,903 --> 08:08:30,903
psychological illness caused

9145
08:08:31,806 --> 08:08:34,644
by. Childhood sexual abuses is

9146
08:08:34,644 --> 08:08:35,941
not disputed. This harm

9147
08:08:35,941 --> 08:08:37,675
requires expensive and time

9148
08:08:37,675 --> 08:08:38,945
consuming counseling and

9149
08:08:38,945 --> 08:08:41,345
including for some spiritual

9150
08:08:41,809 --> 08:08:43,179
counseling colleagues there is

9151
08:08:43,179 --> 08:08:45,612
nothing more frustrating than a

9152
08:08:45,612 --> 08:08:48,612
self inflicted wound all the

9153
08:08:48,648 --> 08:08:50,880
more so if it is intentional.

9154
08:08:50,880 --> 08:08:51,286
Ab two one eight exposes

9155
08:08:51,286 --> 08:08:53,223
california strap school

9156
08:08:53,223 --> 08:08:53,955
districtthe potential lawsuit

9157
08:08:53,955 --> 08:08:55,957
settlements that are not

9158
08:08:55,957 --> 08:08:58,197
covered by insurance and in the

9159
08:08:58,197 --> 08:09:00,194
remote chance that they are.

9160
08:09:00,194 --> 08:09:00,662
We'll see insurance premium

9161
08:09:00,662 --> 08:09:02,662
skyrocket. Or carriers

9162
08:09:03,897 --> 08:09:05,800
disappear. We're already seeing

9163
08:09:05,800 --> 08:09:09,400
that with the homeowners in w.

9164
08:09:09,540 --> 08:09:10,373
You aye areas. Of california's

9165
08:09:10,373 --> 08:09:13,308
nine hundred and forty audited

9166
08:09:13,308 --> 08:09:14,572
school districts only 9510%

9167
08:09:14,572 --> 08:09:16,572
have positive unrestricted

9168
08:09:17,444 --> 08:09:19,278
depositions what further cuts

9169
08:09:19,278 --> 08:09:21,149
will have to be made. We should

9170
08:09:21,149 --> 08:09:24,149
not should the school districts

9171
08:09:24,451 --> 08:09:25,550
in the foot I urge a no vote.

9172
08:09:25,550 --> 08:09:28,586
On ab two one eight thank you

9173
08:09:28,586 --> 08:09:29,155
Mister President. The further

9174
08:09:29,155 --> 08:09:31,791
discussion or debate on this

9175
08:09:31,791 --> 08:09:33,759
item center skinner. Thank you

9176
08:09:33,759 --> 08:09:34,391
Mister President members I

9177
08:09:34,391 --> 08:09:37,991
speak in strong support of this

9178
08:09:39,696 --> 08:09:42,669
item. As a person who was

9179
08:09:42,669 --> 08:09:45,472
sexually abused as a child. And

9180
08:09:45,472 --> 08:09:49,720
while I never forgot about that

9181
08:09:50,940 --> 08:09:54,911
abuse I. Was on able to deal

9182
08:09:54,911 --> 08:09:58,511
with it or. Get myself the

9183
08:09:59,250 --> 08:10:00,859
therapy I needed I dispirited I

9184
08:10:00,859 --> 08:10:02,450
was not able to do so until I

9185
08:10:02,450 --> 08:10:05,354
was adult and in fact what

9186
08:10:05,354 --> 08:10:07,754
triggered. My ability to

9187
08:10:08,992 --> 08:10:11,693
confront it. Was when my own

9188
08:10:11,693 --> 08:10:12,600
daughter became the age that I

9189
08:10:12,600 --> 08:10:14,460
was when my bi

9190
08:10:15,393 --> 08:10:17,393
yu started. The

9191
08:10:18,535 --> 08:10:21,535
data shows. That most people

9192
08:10:23,139 --> 08:10:26,739
who were abused as children. It

9193
08:10:27,281 --> 08:10:27,518
happens because they they are

9194
08:10:27,518 --> 08:10:29,472
taken advantage of by someone

9195
08:10:29,472 --> 08:10:30,943
who they trust and they're not

9196
08:10:30,943 --> 08:10:33,214
in a setting in a householder

9197
08:10:33,214 --> 08:10:36,214
other setting where they feel

9198
08:10:37,713 --> 08:10:38,219
they are able. To convey what

9199
08:10:38,219 --> 08:10:41,219
happened to them and be

9200
08:10:41,753 --> 08:10:43,752
protected. And so you carry

9201
08:10:43,752 --> 08:10:45,626
that with yu which keeps you

9202
08:10:45,626 --> 08:10:47,260
from being able to convey it

9203
08:10:47,260 --> 08:10:49,492
and thus act to protect

9204
08:10:49,492 --> 08:10:52,492
yourself until the moment that

9205
08:10:52,591 --> 08:10:54,432
you are either in adequate

9206
08:10:54,432 --> 08:10:58,320
therapy. Or you break. That can

9207
08:10:58,867 --> 08:11:01,867
be. Thirty forty fifty years

9208
08:11:03,839 --> 08:11:06,543
after the abuse. So to deny

9209
08:11:06,543 --> 08:11:08,643
anyone from being able to seek

9210
08:11:08,643 --> 08:11:10,450
the appropriate damages to deal

9211
08:11:10,450 --> 08:11:12,214
with the consequences of that

9212
08:11:12,214 --> 08:11:15,814
abuse is wrong I stand in

9213
08:11:17,484 --> 08:11:20,751
strong support thank you. It is

9214
08:11:20,751 --> 08:11:23,230
still testimony senate bill.

9215
08:11:23,230 --> 08:11:24,891
Yes this this sir issue is been

9216
08:11:24,891 --> 08:11:27,891
legislated in the past I%

9217
08:11:27,991 --> 08:11:29,770
introduced the bill twice

9218
08:11:29,770 --> 08:11:32,466
vetoed twice by governor jerry

9219
08:11:32,466 --> 08:11:34,336
brown I hope our new governor

9220
08:11:34,336 --> 08:11:36,135
has a different opinion about

9221
08:11:36,135 --> 08:11:38,300
this issue and I your support

9222
08:11:38,300 --> 08:11:39,838
of this this this is a long

9223
08:11:39,838 --> 08:11:41,808
time coming with we've been

9224
08:11:41,808 --> 08:11:44,208
trying to get this bill

9225
08:11:44,208 --> 08:11:47,440
establish for the last. Eight

9226
08:11:47,440 --> 08:11:48,742
or nine years and arjun aye

9227
08:11:48,742 --> 08:11:51,451
vote on it it was a bi partisan

9228
08:11:51,451 --> 08:11:52,810
support we put on the

9229
08:11:52,810 --> 08:11:54,617
governor's desk I think two or

9230
08:11:54,617 --> 08:11:58,217
maybe three times and it was

9231
08:11:58,756 --> 08:11:59,323
always vetoed so let's get this

9232
08:11:59,323 --> 08:12:02,323
bill signed by the governor.

9233
08:12:02,622 --> 08:12:04,920
Arjun aye vote. Thank you any

9234
08:12:04,920 --> 08:12:06,920
additional witnesses. Testimony

9235
08:12:08,270 --> 08:12:08,699
and this on this issue. Here

9236
08:12:08,699 --> 08:12:10,400
nineteen nine center jackson

9237
08:12:10,400 --> 08:12:10,966
would you like to close this

9238
08:12:10,966 --> 08:12:15,166
thank you you know this is a

9239
08:12:15,470 --> 08:12:16,680
horrific. Crime that is been

9240
08:12:16,680 --> 08:12:19,500
perpetuated on for too many of

9241
08:12:19,500 --> 08:12:20,840
our young people. With the

9242
08:12:20,840 --> 08:12:23,840
complicity of groups like the

9243
08:12:26,878 --> 08:12:28,547
church. And it is beyond time

9244
08:12:28,547 --> 08:12:31,517
that we made it very clear that

9245
08:12:31,517 --> 08:12:33,151
these victims deserve their day

9246
08:12:33,151 --> 08:12:35,551
in court deserve their

9247
08:12:36,721 --> 08:12:38,759
vindication and their trust us.

9248
08:12:38,759 --> 08:12:40,222
It is a beyond times that we

9249
08:12:40,222 --> 08:12:41,423
make it very clear that we're

9250
08:12:41,423 --> 08:12:43,270
not going to condone or

9251
08:12:43,270 --> 08:12:45,427
tolerate this behavior going

9252
08:12:45,433 --> 08:12:47,431
forward. This bill helps those

9253
08:12:47,431 --> 08:12:50,980
victims try to heal and get the

9254
08:12:50,980 --> 08:12:50,568
justice they so rightly deserve

9255
08:12:50,568 --> 08:12:51,836
and with that I would

9256
08:12:51,836 --> 08:12:54,710
respectfully ask for your aye

9257
08:12:54,710 --> 08:12:55,272
vote. Thank you all debate and

9258
08:12:55,272 --> 08:12:57,272
discussion haven't seize

9259
08:12:57,708 --> 08:13:00,708
instructor please call the roll

9260
08:13:02,440 --> 08:13:05,388
on the side. Alan. Archuleta I

9261
08:13:05,388 --> 08:13:08,988
atkins aye bates. Bell right by

9262
08:13:10,160 --> 08:13:13,160
porges. Bradford hi I caballero

9263
08:13:16,260 --> 08:13:18,793
I chiang I daly. Dodd I dorado.

9264
08:13:18,793 --> 08:13:21,193
I galgiani aye glazeraye

9265
08:13:23,200 --> 08:13:25,600
gonzalez I growth. Hertzberg

9266
08:13:27,769 --> 08:13:31,107
aye hill aye hueso I tado. I

9267
08:13:31,107 --> 08:13:34,107
jackson I jones. Leyva I'm

9268
08:13:35,842 --> 08:13:38,842
acquire. Mitchell hi I'm money

9269
08:13:42,148 --> 08:13:45,148
I'm more lock morrell. Nielsen

9270
08:13:46,485 --> 08:13:50,850
aye pan aye portantino roth I

9271
08:13:52,123 --> 08:13:55,627
rubio aye skinner aye stern aye

9272
08:13:55,627 --> 08:13:58,263
stone all right by number. I

9273
08:13:58,263 --> 08:14:01,465
like owski hi by winner. Wilk

9274
08:14:01,465 --> 08:14:03,865
welcome. Peter jackson moves

9275
08:14:20,548 --> 08:14:24,148
call. Nine there are plenty of

9276
08:34:39,720 --> 08:34:41,720
.

9277
08:34:43,725 --> 08:34:46,724
We're gonna get back to work.

9278
08:34:46,724 --> 08:34:49,160
We're gonna take up sb one by

9279
08:34:49,160 --> 08:34:49,793
center atkins what out which

9280
08:34:49,793 --> 08:34:52,793
can be warped without reference

9281
08:34:57,765 --> 08:35:00,765
to file. The secretary. These

9282
08:35:02,441 --> 08:35:03,400
rich senate bill one by senator

9283
08:35:03,400 --> 08:35:06,400
atkins and hack relating to

9284
08:35:08,409 --> 08:35:09,412
public welfare. Atkins Mister

9285
08:35:09,412 --> 08:35:10,513
President thank you so much and

9286
08:35:10,513 --> 08:35:13,483
colleagues thank you so much

9287
08:35:13,483 --> 08:35:14,470
yet again for your patience. Sb

9288
08:35:14,470 --> 08:35:15,485
one an axe the california

9289
08:35:15,485 --> 08:35:16,119
environmental public health and

9290
08:35:16,119 --> 08:35:16,683
workers defense active twenty

9291
08:35:16,683 --> 08:35:17,554
nineteen. The assembly

9292
08:35:17,554 --> 08:35:18,424
amendments resolve numerous

9293
08:35:18,424 --> 08:35:19,422
concerns over the clean air

9294
08:35:19,422 --> 08:35:20,357
clean water worker safety an

9295
08:35:20,357 --> 08:35:22,357
endangered species provisions

9296
08:35:22,593 --> 08:35:23,425
of the bill. As amended sb one

9297
08:35:23,425 --> 08:35:24,993
makes federal baseline

9298
08:35:24,993 --> 08:35:27,362
standards for environmental and

9299
08:35:27,362 --> 08:35:29,362
worker protection enforceable

9300
08:35:29,631 --> 08:35:31,269
as a matter of state law only

9301
08:35:31,269 --> 08:35:32,801
when the current administration

9302
08:35:32,801 --> 08:35:35,473
in washington role in dc rolls

9303
08:35:35,473 --> 08:35:37,202
them back to be clear. Sb one

9304
08:35:37,202 --> 08:35:39,775
and we said this again and

9305
08:35:39,775 --> 08:35:41,876
again imposes no new

9306
08:35:41,876 --> 08:35:43,878
regulations or requirements on

9307
08:35:43,878 --> 08:35:46,800
business agriculture or the

9308
08:35:46,800 --> 08:35:47,445
state's economy it simply keep

9309
08:35:47,445 --> 08:35:48,246
some place the same standards

9310
08:35:48,246 --> 08:35:50,518
that have been in pace and in

9311
08:35:50,518 --> 08:35:52,620
some cases for decades. Before

9312
08:35:52,620 --> 08:35:54,422
the arrival of the new

9313
08:35:54,422 --> 08:35:55,456
administration in washington

9314
08:35:55,456 --> 08:35:58,580
and the roll backs that they

9315
08:35:58,580 --> 08:35:59,759
have pushed forward sb one is

9316
08:35:59,759 --> 08:36:01,428
supported by a broad cross

9317
08:36:01,428 --> 08:36:04,428
section of public health worker

9318
08:36:04,500 --> 08:36:05,650
safety in organized labor

9319
08:36:05,650 --> 08:36:07,650
business. And environmental

9320
08:36:11,100 --> 08:36:12,238
groups. I know that there have

9321
08:36:12,238 --> 08:36:13,472
been lake concerns raised by my

9322
08:36:13,472 --> 08:36:14,430
friends in the water in the ag

9323
08:36:14,430 --> 08:36:15,274
community over the potential

9324
08:36:15,274 --> 08:36:17,640
impact of the bill. On the

9325
08:36:17,640 --> 08:36:18,380
voluntary settlement agreements

9326
08:36:18,380 --> 08:36:19,611
and other actions to protect

9327
08:36:19,611 --> 08:36:21,947
bill to water. I would direct

9328
08:36:21,947 --> 08:36:23,949
my colleagues to page thirteen

9329
08:36:23,949 --> 08:36:25,584
line nineteen of the bill which

9330
08:36:25,584 --> 08:36:28,584
is expressly states that the

9331
08:36:29,726 --> 08:36:29,943
bill does not affect the

9332
08:36:29,943 --> 08:36:32,343
process by which those

9333
08:36:32,691 --> 08:36:33,302
agreements are entered into. I

9334
08:36:33,302 --> 08:36:35,896
acknowledge that this is a big

9335
08:36:35,896 --> 08:36:36,758
and important measure I think

9336
08:36:36,758 --> 08:36:37,695
we a living in times that

9337
08:36:37,695 --> 08:36:39,361
demand our urgent action to

9338
08:36:39,361 --> 08:36:40,960
protect our state's natural

9339
08:36:40,960 --> 08:36:43,660
resources our environment and

9340
08:36:43,660 --> 08:36:44,967
worker safety. I would ask for

9341
08:36:44,967 --> 08:36:47,690
your five vote in the

9342
08:36:47,690 --> 08:36:49,469
concurrence of the assembly

9343
08:36:52,607 --> 08:36:53,208
amendments thank you. Thank you

9344
08:36:53,208 --> 08:36:56,808
any description of it on this

9345
08:36:58,947 --> 08:37:00,500
issue center nielsen. This

9346
08:37:00,500 --> 08:37:02,183
President Ladies journal of the

9347
08:37:02,183 --> 08:37:03,386
senate I have to lose

9348
08:37:03,386 --> 08:37:05,386
vigorously oppose this

9349
08:37:05,419 --> 08:37:06,530
legislation is in a sense I

9350
08:37:06,530 --> 08:37:08,788
have been serving. In the state

9351
08:37:08,788 --> 08:37:10,354
legislature. It's rolling back

9352
08:37:10,354 --> 08:37:10,955
twenty years of progress

9353
08:37:10,955 --> 08:37:12,860
towards ending the water wars

9354
08:37:12,860 --> 08:37:15,260
in california. And will

9355
08:37:16,495 --> 08:37:18,697
reignite those water wars. It

9356
08:37:18,697 --> 08:37:21,650
ignores provisions of law that

9357
08:37:21,650 --> 08:37:21,696
indicate that human beings have

9358
08:37:21,696 --> 08:37:25,896
a water right in the state of

9359
08:37:25,936 --> 08:37:28,936
california. Seems to be a

9360
08:37:30,139 --> 08:37:30,772
hysteric reaction to things

9361
08:37:30,772 --> 08:37:34,372
that have gone on in washington

9362
08:37:37,679 --> 08:37:38,544
dc. And if that's it. It's

9363
08:37:38,544 --> 08:37:42,144
going to last a lot longer.

9364
08:37:42,781 --> 08:37:45,181
Meeting. The deficiencies and

9365
08:37:46,153 --> 08:37:49,753
the harm done here. Then a

9366
08:37:50,491 --> 08:37:52,891
federal administration. It will

9367
08:37:54,161 --> 08:37:55,795
do nothing to heal. Or to help

9368
08:37:55,795 --> 08:37:57,764
provide a water around to the

9369
08:37:57,764 --> 08:38:01,364
needy areas of california or to

9370
08:38:01,401 --> 08:38:03,801
replenish our groundwater. Or

9371
08:38:10,540 --> 08:38:14,740
to greece is. On the moment I

9372
08:38:14,780 --> 08:38:18,380
I'm. On the moment in the

9373
08:38:22,385 --> 08:38:25,985
comments the. Big of the that

9374
08:38:28,160 --> 08:38:30,862
was that are here. They are on

9375
08:38:30,862 --> 08:38:32,862
the amendmentsere senator.

9376
08:38:35,967 --> 08:38:39,300
Just make sure. Thank you of

9377
08:38:39,300 --> 08:38:40,973
senator dodd senator nelson v.

9378
08:38:40,973 --> 08:38:41,438
Just be germane to the bill to

9379
08:38:41,438 --> 08:38:42,380
speak to the member to

9380
08:38:42,380 --> 08:38:45,380
appreciate it thank you that's

9381
08:38:45,877 --> 08:38:46,876
what I'm doing. Nothing in that

9382
08:38:46,876 --> 08:38:50,810
that is in this bill that has

9383
08:38:50,810 --> 08:38:53,470
been amended. Will do anything

9384
08:38:53,470 --> 08:38:54,413
but fanning the flames. Of the

9385
08:38:54,413 --> 08:38:58,130
water wars and make it worse.

9386
08:38:58,953 --> 08:39:02,553
In california. The bill read a

9387
08:39:04,125 --> 08:39:06,491
few. Sections here if I May.

9388
08:39:06,491 --> 08:39:09,491
That creates private rights of

9389
08:39:15,202 --> 08:39:17,273
action. And many organizations

9390
08:39:17,273 --> 08:39:19,941
have come to the legislature

9391
08:39:19,941 --> 08:39:21,371
expressing their concerns.

9392
08:39:21,371 --> 08:39:23,771
Asking for some accommodations

9393
08:39:26,916 --> 08:39:27,444
of those concerns. And I would

9394
08:39:27,444 --> 08:39:31,440
say that the backs of been

9395
08:39:31,452 --> 08:39:33,873
rudely turned upon them. And

9396
08:39:33,873 --> 08:39:36,873
not accepted any suggestions to

9397
08:39:36,877 --> 08:39:39,277
improve this legislation. That

9398
08:39:40,619 --> 08:39:42,270
have been in good faith. What

9399
08:39:42,270 --> 08:39:43,526
talk about vuntary settlement

9400
08:39:43,526 --> 08:39:45,926
agreements what I'm talking

9401
08:39:47,897 --> 08:39:48,531
about is in the future. And but

9402
08:39:48,531 --> 08:39:52,131
based on provisions here in and

9403
08:39:53,615 --> 08:39:56,269
as amended. Who is going to

9404
08:39:56,269 --> 08:39:58,710
dare. Have voluntary agreements.

9405
08:39:58,710 --> 08:39:59,745
Because they cannot trust the

9406
08:39:59,745 --> 08:40:00,273
state that's one of the biggest

9407
08:40:00,273 --> 08:40:03,273
problems in this state and

9408
08:40:03,678 --> 08:40:04,646
nation today. The citizens

9409
08:40:04,646 --> 08:40:07,646
cannot trust government to keep

9410
08:40:08,351 --> 08:40:10,485
its word. At the agricultural

9411
08:40:10,485 --> 08:40:12,323
industry through the valleys of

9412
08:40:12,323 --> 08:40:15,323
california will be agree justly

9413
08:40:16,221 --> 08:40:19,824
harmed by this. One of the most

9414
08:40:19,824 --> 08:40:20,927
sweeping attacks. On the

9415
08:40:20,927 --> 08:40:23,327
agricultural industry that is

9416
08:40:24,998 --> 08:40:25,634
so dear to me. That I would

9417
08:40:25,634 --> 08:40:28,333
have experienced in my lifetime

9418
08:40:28,333 --> 08:40:30,733
is embodied. This legislation

9419
08:40:35,139 --> 08:40:37,800
as amended. I ask I in treat.

9420
08:40:37,800 --> 08:40:39,310
For the good of the generations

9421
08:40:39,310 --> 08:40:39,877
this isn't about now this is

9422
08:40:39,877 --> 08:40:42,877
about your children and your

9423
08:40:44,248 --> 08:40:46,830
grandchildren. In two thousand

9424
08:40:46,830 --> 08:40:46,686
and nine when we're negotiating

9425
08:40:46,686 --> 08:40:50,487
a new water plan for the state

9426
08:40:50,487 --> 08:40:51,291
of california. That was much on

9427
08:40:51,291 --> 08:40:54,570
our minds those who did the

9428
08:40:54,570 --> 08:40:55,792
negotiation. What would be the

9429
08:40:55,792 --> 08:40:58,792
water future for the state

9430
08:41:01,430 --> 08:41:02,290
everybody. Not just groups and

9431
08:41:02,290 --> 08:41:05,629
not just water for fish water

9432
08:41:06,599 --> 08:41:09,599
for everybody. In all species.

9433
08:41:10,332 --> 08:41:13,904
This will not get us there. It

9434
08:41:13,904 --> 08:41:16,307
is ill founded. A roll back the

9435
08:41:16,307 --> 08:41:18,505
progress that we have made. And

9436
08:41:18,505 --> 08:41:21,505
here we go reigniting. The

9437
08:41:27,250 --> 08:41:28,450
water wars. Any additional.

9438
08:41:28,450 --> 08:41:28,985
Version of it on the side on

9439
08:41:28,985 --> 08:41:31,385
senator borders. Thank you

9440
08:41:35,157 --> 08:41:38,157
Mister President. I think so

9441
08:41:38,794 --> 08:41:41,330
many of us good. Could find

9442
08:41:41,330 --> 08:41:44,200
issues with some of the

9443
08:41:44,200 --> 08:41:46,532
provisions in this legislation

9444
08:41:46,532 --> 08:41:48,703
soul are probably just pick one

9445
08:41:48,703 --> 08:41:52,303
or two. F. I made direct

9446
08:41:54,406 --> 08:41:56,777
questions to. The author.

9447
08:41:56,777 --> 08:41:59,177
Senator actions we take

9448
08:41:59,947 --> 08:42:00,680
question yes the abortion so

9449
08:42:00,680 --> 08:42:02,649
representing the central valley

9450
08:42:02,649 --> 08:42:03,717
I think you've heard from the

9451
08:42:03,717 --> 08:42:06,520
impassioned words of my

9452
08:42:06,520 --> 08:42:08,324
colleague waters a very

9453
08:42:08,324 --> 08:42:09,124
significant dynamic in our

9454
08:42:09,124 --> 08:42:11,190
region for obvious obvious

9455
08:42:11,190 --> 08:42:13,523
reasons. In one of the things

9456
08:42:13,523 --> 08:42:16,929
that we've had a very difficult

9457
08:42:16,929 --> 08:42:20,529
time dealing with is of course

9458
08:42:21,400 --> 08:42:22,468
the endangered species act. And

9459
08:42:22,468 --> 08:42:23,769
one of the provisions in here

9460
08:42:23,769 --> 08:42:27,369
that concerns me greatly is the

9461
08:42:28,875 --> 08:42:31,877
idea that. The fish and game

9462
08:42:31,877 --> 08:42:33,877
commission could adopt

9463
08:42:36,517 --> 08:42:39,517
regulations that add species to

9464
08:42:40,153 --> 08:42:41,856
that are on the endangered list.

9465
08:42:41,856 --> 08:42:42,787
Better federal action results

9466
08:42:42,787 --> 08:42:44,455
in a decrease of protection so

9467
08:42:44,455 --> 08:42:48,655
my question to you is would it

9468
08:42:49,930 --> 08:42:52,899
not be. Effective to monitor

9469
08:42:52,899 --> 08:42:55,299
the environmental concerns by

9470
08:42:55,498 --> 08:42:57,898
bring back any statutory

9471
08:42:58,101 --> 08:42:59,339
request that doesn't create a

9472
08:42:59,339 --> 08:43:01,739
baseline as this piece

9473
08:43:03,435 --> 08:43:05,835
legislation does. Given the

9474
08:43:06,740 --> 08:43:07,942
smelled issue the salmon issue

9475
08:43:07,942 --> 08:43:11,512
the dynamic and the changing in

9476
08:43:11,512 --> 08:43:13,847
the evolving science that this

9477
08:43:13,847 --> 08:43:15,415
kind of freezes in time would

9478
08:43:15,415 --> 08:43:18,385
not be more effective to bring

9479
08:43:18,385 --> 08:43:20,785
back any these considerations

9480
08:43:21,891 --> 08:43:24,891
to the legislature rather than.

9481
08:43:26,392 --> 08:43:28,261
Are creating a baseline. The

9482
08:43:28,261 --> 08:43:28,997
way this legislation is

9483
08:43:28,997 --> 08:43:30,967
proposed thank you for the

9484
08:43:30,967 --> 08:43:32,265
question and add to my

9485
08:43:32,265 --> 08:43:34,333
lleagues there were many many

9486
08:43:34,333 --> 08:43:37,320
amendments I in in. The process

9487
08:43:37,320 --> 08:43:40,320
of six policy hearings into

9488
08:43:40,340 --> 08:43:42,340
appropriations committees we

9489
08:43:42,539 --> 08:43:44,872
sought to address a number of

9490
08:43:44,872 --> 08:43:46,730
those concerns the baseline hi

9491
08:43:46,730 --> 08:43:48,411
I mean we are not changing

9492
08:43:48,411 --> 08:43:50,647
regulations we are adopting the

9493
08:43:50,647 --> 08:43:53,470
baseline we've added language

9494
08:43:53,490 --> 08:43:55,115
in the bill. To address the

9495
08:43:55,115 --> 08:43:55,952
best possible science that is

9496
08:43:55,952 --> 08:43:58,240
the concern that has been

9497
08:43:58,240 --> 08:44:00,353
expressed again and again we

9498
08:44:00,353 --> 08:44:02,858
added that into the language of

9499
08:44:02,858 --> 08:44:05,260
the bill at the request as we

9500
08:44:05,260 --> 08:44:07,426
did. Negotiations through the

9501
08:44:10,265 --> 08:44:12,470
process. Fishing game his given

9502
08:44:12,470 --> 08:44:13,701
discretion but it they have to

9503
08:44:13,701 --> 08:44:16,101
go through the regulatory

9504
08:44:17,690 --> 08:44:19,240
process to do any change we are

9505
08:44:19,240 --> 08:44:21,342
trying to have a baseline set

9506
08:44:21,342 --> 08:44:23,308
of standards we also talked

9507
08:44:23,308 --> 08:44:24,509
about into my other colleagues.

9508
08:44:24,509 --> 08:44:25,646
The voluntary settlement

9509
08:44:25,646 --> 08:44:28,415
agreements which gets to the

9510
08:44:28,415 --> 08:44:29,820
issue of your the bottom line

9511
08:44:29,820 --> 08:44:32,520
of your question which is

9512
08:44:32,520 --> 08:44:34,321
water. This bill doesn't impact

9513
08:44:34,321 --> 08:44:36,323
the voluntary cell agreements

9514
08:44:36,323 --> 08:44:40,523
we put it into the into the

9515
08:44:46,968 --> 08:44:48,832
language of. The bill it is so.

9516
08:44:48,832 --> 08:44:50,402
We really and truly did work in

9517
08:44:50,402 --> 08:44:51,804
good faith to try to address

9518
08:44:51,804 --> 08:44:54,239
those concerns. It's for in

9519
08:44:54,239 --> 08:44:55,807
terms of the discretion that

9520
08:44:55,807 --> 08:44:57,579
fish and game. Is given it's

9521
08:44:57,579 --> 08:44:58,813
frozen until fishing game is

9522
08:44:58,813 --> 08:45:01,183
able to review it's not

9523
08:45:01,183 --> 08:45:01,813
permanent so we are continuing

9524
08:45:01,813 --> 08:45:03,648
to do the review that's needed

9525
08:45:03,648 --> 08:45:04,115
to be done. And we are trying

9526
08:45:04,115 --> 08:45:06,187
to put into place the

9527
08:45:06,187 --> 08:45:06,718
protections that you have

9528
08:45:06,718 --> 08:45:09,718
outlined in terms of the

9529
08:45:10,210 --> 08:45:11,587
voluntary sell agreement. As it

9530
08:45:11,587 --> 08:45:14,587
relates also to the endangered

9531
08:45:16,461 --> 08:45:17,610
species act let me make May be

9532
08:45:17,610 --> 08:45:21,261
helpful follow up on this if I

9533
08:45:21,899 --> 08:45:23,167
man Mister President. When I

9534
08:45:23,167 --> 08:45:24,465
first moved to when I first

9535
08:45:24,465 --> 08:45:25,739
moved to fresno I had the

9536
08:45:25,739 --> 08:45:27,171
opportunity to clerk. For a

9537
08:45:27,171 --> 08:45:30,171
federal judge who is regarded

9538
08:45:30,174 --> 08:45:31,209
nationally as-the water judge.

9539
08:45:31,209 --> 08:45:32,976
In one of the things that we

9540
08:45:32,976 --> 08:45:34,644
experienced when we went

9541
08:45:34,644 --> 08:45:36,450
through all the litigations

9542
08:45:36,450 --> 08:45:38,450
involving. The endangered

9543
08:45:38,982 --> 08:45:41,982
species act was the biological

9544
08:45:42,385 --> 08:45:44,353
opinions. And what we realize

9545
08:45:44,353 --> 08:45:45,955
over time is that the gre

9546
08:45:45,955 --> 08:45:47,955
latitude the regulatory

9547
08:45:48,220 --> 08:45:49,255
authorities have in determining

9548
08:45:49,255 --> 08:45:51,255
their interpretation of

9549
08:45:51,457 --> 08:45:53,462
biological opinions which is

9550
08:45:53,462 --> 08:45:56,280
why the central valley has

9551
08:45:56,280 --> 08:45:58,428
spent years lobbying. The

9552
08:45:59,610 --> 08:46:02,610
federal authorities to re visit

9553
08:46:03,635 --> 08:46:05,403
their scientific interpretation.

9554
08:46:05,403 --> 08:46:06,502
And it is. Unfortunately come

9555
08:46:06,502 --> 08:46:09,741
to little avail but what I'm

9556
08:46:09,741 --> 08:46:11,410
concerned most about this is

9557
08:46:11,410 --> 08:46:13,680
that if we do succeed at the

9558
08:46:13,680 --> 08:46:16,924
federal level we will then lose

9559
08:46:16,924 --> 08:46:18,516
again at the state level. And

9560
08:46:18,516 --> 08:46:19,551
that is what I'm terribly

9561
08:46:19,551 --> 08:46:21,551
concerned about what this

9562
08:46:21,551 --> 08:46:24,551
legislation is that we have

9563
08:46:24,553 --> 08:46:25,154
fought for a decade or more

9564
08:46:25,154 --> 08:46:28,154
trying to get them to

9565
08:46:28,391 --> 08:46:30,791
understand. That the human

9566
08:46:31,793 --> 08:46:34,262
element is a key component in

9567
08:46:34,262 --> 08:46:36,262
understanding the environmental

9568
08:46:37,128 --> 08:46:38,990
concerns whereas before it was

9569
08:46:38,990 --> 08:46:40,467
only about let's say a delta

9570
08:46:40,467 --> 08:46:41,501
smelt. But we were trying to

9571
08:46:41,501 --> 08:46:43,638
make certain that there was a

9572
08:46:43,638 --> 08:46:44,271
human element that was

9573
08:46:44,271 --> 08:46:46,671
calculated in the environmental

9574
08:46:49,709 --> 08:46:50,243
impact. So now after a decade a

9575
08:46:50,243 --> 08:46:51,609
decade of fighting at the

9576
08:46:51,609 --> 08:46:53,716
federal level we could very

9577
08:46:53,716 --> 08:46:55,481
well see ourselves winning in

9578
08:46:55,481 --> 08:46:58,481
washington and then losing in

9579
08:46:58,585 --> 08:47:01,585
california. In I don't know

9580
08:47:02,686 --> 08:47:04,287
what. Just to come here and say

9581
08:47:04,287 --> 08:47:07,887
we should oppose this I think

9582
08:47:08,910 --> 08:47:10,950
is overly simplistic I think

9583
08:47:10,950 --> 08:47:12,698
that there are there are deep

9584
08:47:12,698 --> 08:47:15,980
systemic and fundamental by

9585
08:47:16,601 --> 08:47:17,937
errors in this legislation that

9586
08:47:17,937 --> 08:47:20,338
by virtue of that baseline on

9587
08:47:20,338 --> 08:47:21,539
does all the political work

9588
08:47:21,539 --> 08:47:23,308
that we have seen at the

9589
08:47:23,308 --> 08:47:24,976
federal level that could be of

9590
08:47:24,976 --> 08:47:27,481
great value to the agricultural

9591
08:47:27,481 --> 08:47:29,680
industry and in all those

9592
08:47:29,680 --> 08:47:31,680
interested parties involving

9593
08:47:33,751 --> 08:47:37,951
the water wars. So all in all

9594
08:47:38,655 --> 08:47:39,287
in my comment my comments here.

9595
08:47:39,287 --> 08:47:41,658
With one last question to you

9596
08:47:41,658 --> 08:47:42,626
if I May. There was in the

9597
08:47:42,626 --> 08:47:44,325
media reports that democrat

9598
08:47:44,325 --> 08:47:46,325
federal representatives

9599
08:47:46,765 --> 08:47:48,431
feinstein in others had

9600
08:47:48,431 --> 08:47:50,831
expressed grave concerns about

9601
08:47:51,265 --> 08:47:52,266
sb one. Have you address those

9602
08:47:52,266 --> 08:47:55,866
concerns or do you have a

9603
08:47:56,400 --> 08:47:56,503
response to. The letter that

9604
08:47:56,503 --> 08:47:59,503
was sent to your office

9605
08:48:02,579 --> 08:48:05,280
regarding sb one. Thank you.

9606
08:48:05,280 --> 08:48:08,141
Well hi I would say. The

9607
08:48:08,141 --> 08:48:10,141
discussions around the

9608
08:48:10,752 --> 08:48:13,752
endangered species act our as

9609
08:48:15,355 --> 08:48:17,526
it relates to water flows and

9610
08:48:17,526 --> 08:48:19,563
the voluntary settle agreements

9611
08:48:19,563 --> 08:48:21,661
has been long and discussion

9612
08:48:21,661 --> 08:48:24,862
and settled at at the state

9613
08:48:24,862 --> 08:48:25,262
level and the federal level

9614
08:48:25,262 --> 08:48:28,262
until we got a new

9615
08:48:29,868 --> 08:48:30,469
administration. These are these

9616
08:48:30,469 --> 08:48:33,469
are protections that have been

9617
08:48:34,439 --> 08:48:38,639
in place for. Forty years so I

9618
08:48:40,576 --> 08:48:43,848
will say. We a the but the

9619
08:48:43,848 --> 08:48:46,283
point is to be able to continue

9620
08:48:46,283 --> 08:48:48,585
to protect endangered species

9621
08:48:48,585 --> 08:48:51,354
that was the intent of the

9622
08:48:51,354 --> 08:48:52,489
federal administrations rolling

9623
08:48:52,489 --> 08:48:54,724
out that we have lived under

9624
08:48:54,724 --> 08:48:56,560
for quite awhile. Our delegate

9625
08:48:56,560 --> 08:48:58,228
and there are people in that

9626
08:48:58,228 --> 08:48:59,493
our representatives at the

9627
08:48:59,493 --> 08:49:01,464
federal level and our

9628
08:49:01,464 --> 08:49:03,766
delegation that want to see

9629
08:49:03,766 --> 08:49:05,501
those standards rolled back to

9630
08:49:05,501 --> 08:49:07,405
this is work that we have done

9631
08:49:07,405 --> 08:49:09,969
over a long period of time at

9632
08:49:09,969 --> 08:49:10,539
the state to protect some

9633
08:49:10,539 --> 08:49:12,939
endangered species and the

9634
08:49:13,973 --> 08:49:15,742
delta eco system. I don't see

9635
08:49:15,742 --> 08:49:17,380
that you find this issue being

9636
08:49:17,380 --> 08:49:19,380
determined along political

9637
08:49:20,246 --> 08:49:22,646
lines it's determined along

9638
08:49:22,647 --> 08:49:24,351
some geographical lines as it

9639
08:49:24,351 --> 08:49:27,351
relates to the issues and

9640
08:49:27,653 --> 08:49:29,688
concerns about water flows. So

9641
08:49:29,688 --> 08:49:30,856
we have debated these issues

9642
08:49:30,856 --> 08:49:34,456
time and time again at the

9643
08:49:35,526 --> 08:49:39,126
state level. And so I do

9644
08:49:41,429 --> 08:49:42,829
believe that. This is an

9645
08:49:42,829 --> 08:49:43,463
attempt to rollback.

9646
08:49:43,463 --> 08:49:45,201
Protections that we put in

9647
08:49:45,201 --> 08:49:46,466
place for our natural resources

9648
08:49:46,466 --> 08:49:48,204
are endangered species so that

9649
08:49:48,204 --> 08:49:53,400
is the point of a large part of

9650
08:49:56,342 --> 08:49:57,846
this legislation. I eight

9651
08:49:57,846 --> 08:49:59,648
democrats and republicans and

9652
08:49:59,648 --> 08:50:01,547
democrats don't always agree I

9653
08:50:01,547 --> 08:50:02,517
mean if it if it is a political

9654
08:50:02,517 --> 08:50:04,119
if you're saying this is a

9655
08:50:04,119 --> 08:50:06,385
political thing again see

9656
08:50:06,385 --> 08:50:08,385
administration obviously it

9657
08:50:08,656 --> 08:50:09,223
isn't it is about. The

9658
08:50:09,223 --> 08:50:11,223
protection immigrant rights

9659
08:50:15,729 --> 08:50:17,862
disagree. Hi and in terms of

9660
08:50:17,862 --> 08:50:19,799
addressing that issue rather

9661
08:50:19,799 --> 08:50:21,302
than have crossed debate. I

9662
08:50:21,302 --> 08:50:22,936
would just say that the very

9663
08:50:22,936 --> 08:50:25,336
reason this legislation is

9664
08:50:25,672 --> 08:50:28,672
necessary is to protect. Our

9665
08:50:28,744 --> 08:50:31,744
resources and maybe five there

9666
08:50:31,778 --> 08:50:33,943
are of political considerations

9667
08:50:33,943 --> 08:50:35,790
by democrats and republicans

9668
08:50:35,790 --> 08:50:37,682
who disagree but these things

9669
08:50:37,682 --> 08:50:39,283
have been debated. Of for well

9670
08:50:39,283 --> 08:50:41,452
over forty years in terms of

9671
08:50:41,452 --> 08:50:42,820
clean air clean water our

9672
08:50:42,820 --> 08:50:44,820
natural resources the

9673
08:50:44,990 --> 08:50:45,455
endangered species act and the

9674
08:50:45,455 --> 08:50:48,455
let the point of this

9675
08:50:48,660 --> 08:50:51,660
legislation is to. Keep those

9676
08:50:55,167 --> 08:50:58,980
protections in place. Or thank

9677
08:50:58,980 --> 08:50:58,638
you very much for answering the

9678
08:50:58,638 --> 08:51:01,638
my inquiries all my final

9679
08:51:02,471 --> 08:51:04,239
comment is. If ever there was a

9680
08:51:04,239 --> 08:51:04,857
piece of legislation that I

9681
08:51:04,857 --> 08:51:06,876
think could benefit from more

9682
08:51:06,876 --> 08:51:08,911
analysis in more discussn I

9683
08:51:08,911 --> 08:51:11,480
think you'd be sb one. This

9684
08:51:11,480 --> 08:51:12,981
would be a perfect candidate if

9685
08:51:12,981 --> 08:51:15,981
thisere rolled over into the

9686
08:51:15,983 --> 08:51:17,251
next legislative cycle. I leave

9687
08:51:17,251 --> 08:51:19,456
that to the vote count at the

9688
08:51:19,456 --> 08:51:21,322
end but I think more

9689
08:51:21,322 --> 08:51:22,789
consultation especially from

9690
08:51:22,789 --> 08:51:25,789
folks in the central valley

9691
08:51:25,892 --> 08:51:26,493
could make this a better piece

9692
08:51:26,493 --> 08:51:29,493
of legislation with more work

9693
08:51:32,498 --> 08:51:35,498
thank you. Thank you sinister.

9694
08:51:35,535 --> 08:51:36,536
Thank you Mister President. I

9695
08:51:36,536 --> 08:51:38,371
do appreciate the line of

9696
08:51:38,371 --> 08:51:39,905
questioning in the responses

9697
08:51:39,905 --> 08:51:41,275
the water chair the senate I

9698
08:51:41,275 --> 08:51:43,342
did want to weigh in is join

9699
08:51:43,342 --> 08:51:45,177
author this legislation. The

9700
08:51:45,177 --> 08:51:47,177
voluntary settlement agreements

9701
08:51:47,844 --> 08:51:48,782
that are currently. Under way

9702
08:51:48,782 --> 08:51:51,182
being negotiated that we've

9703
08:52:00,924 --> 08:52:01,198
actually appropriated funding

9704
08:52:01,198 --> 08:52:01,359
for in our budget this cycle. I

9705
08:52:01,359 --> 08:52:01,506
believe are not only critical

9706
08:52:01,506 --> 08:52:02,929
elements of our states water

9707
08:52:02,929 --> 08:52:05,929
strategy but. They are not

9708
08:52:06,833 --> 08:52:09,233
impeded by this legislation.

9709
08:52:09,298 --> 08:52:10,899
What it really comes down to is

9710
08:52:10,899 --> 08:52:13,299
whether you trust this

9711
08:52:14,690 --> 08:52:14,903
administration to implement

9712
08:52:14,903 --> 08:52:16,771
this legislation in a

9713
08:52:16,771 --> 08:52:19,171
meaningful fashion. That up

9714
08:52:20,942 --> 08:52:21,440
hold those agreements. Bit

9715
08:52:21,440 --> 08:52:23,440
interprets the baseline

9716
08:52:26,113 --> 08:52:27,851
standards and that. Interprets

9717
08:52:27,851 --> 08:52:29,382
existing law which already

9718
08:52:29,382 --> 08:52:31,382
applies the california

9719
08:52:31,417 --> 08:52:32,490
endangered species act for

9720
08:52:32,490 --> 08:52:35,490
instance to the central valley

9721
08:52:36,791 --> 08:52:37,992
project. There is plenty of

9722
08:52:37,992 --> 08:52:40,392
discretion under existing law

9723
08:52:40,493 --> 08:52:42,931
and of sb one passes to make

9724
08:52:42,931 --> 08:52:44,630
sure that we can find smart

9725
08:52:44,630 --> 08:52:45,965
negotiated solutions to

9726
08:52:45,965 --> 08:52:48,965
ensuring that central valley as

9727
08:52:49,167 --> 08:52:49,832
adequate water supply. That

9728
08:52:49,832 --> 08:52:51,936
agriculture is put in a

9729
08:52:51,936 --> 08:52:54,336
sustainable position. But that

9730
08:52:54,472 --> 08:52:58,720
we also don't under cut. An

9731
08:52:59,478 --> 08:53:01,420
extinct our most sacred

9732
08:53:01,420 --> 08:53:03,848
resources that we have here in

9733
08:53:03,848 --> 08:53:04,447
the california ecosystem. We

9734
08:53:04,447 --> 08:53:07,852
didn't want to get put in this

9735
08:53:07,852 --> 08:53:10,852
position. We got forced into

9736
08:53:12,423 --> 08:53:15,423
this legislation. And you May

9737
08:53:16,590 --> 08:53:18,590
call politics. But

9738
08:53:19,461 --> 08:53:19,995
unfortunately washington. Has

9739
08:53:19,995 --> 08:53:22,995
decided to single out this

9740
08:53:22,996 --> 08:53:26,596
state. And try to make an

9741
08:53:27,570 --> 08:53:30,572
example out of us. And this

9742
08:53:30,572 --> 08:53:31,206
legislation is not intended to

9743
08:53:31,206 --> 08:53:34,206
poke this administration in the

9744
08:53:35,113 --> 08:53:37,746
I'd. But it didn't intended is

9745
08:53:37,746 --> 08:53:40,614
status uncertainty to say that

9746
08:53:40,614 --> 08:53:42,317
we can't afford to go backwards.

9747
08:53:42,317 --> 08:53:44,784
And the track we were on was

9748
08:53:44,784 --> 08:53:45,423
working and is still can work

9749
08:53:45,423 --> 08:53:46,917
and I believe this governor can

9750
08:53:46,917 --> 08:53:49,917
make this legislation work. If

9751
08:53:50,256 --> 08:53:52,594
they put their minds to so I'll

9752
08:53:52,594 --> 08:53:53,459
be supporting this measure

9753
08:53:53,459 --> 08:53:55,462
today and I do appreciate the

9754
08:53:55,462 --> 08:53:57,462
pro tem's. Courageous

9755
08:53:57,630 --> 08:53:58,264
leadership in bringing this

9756
08:53:58,264 --> 08:54:01,264
forward in a tough conversation

9757
08:54:01,333 --> 08:54:04,300
that. We never wanted to have

9758
08:54:04,300 --> 08:54:05,371
to have in the first place. By

9759
08:54:05,371 --> 08:54:06,772
this insurance policy for the

9760
08:54:06,772 --> 08:54:09,772
greater good of the state's

9761
08:54:10,410 --> 08:54:11,746
natural resources. And

9762
08:54:11,746 --> 08:54:13,746
agriculture resources is

9763
08:54:17,512 --> 08:54:19,727
critically needed at this time.

9764
08:54:19,727 --> 08:54:21,116
Thank you center y. Cosby. Is

9765
08:54:21,116 --> 08:54:22,717
risen aye to rise in support of

9766
08:54:22,717 --> 08:54:24,600
this measure in and I echo my

9767
08:54:24,600 --> 08:54:24,989
good friend from southern

9768
08:54:24,989 --> 08:54:27,459
california we didn't bring this

9769
08:54:27,459 --> 08:54:29,259
on into our set upon ourselves

9770
08:54:29,259 --> 08:54:31,895
this is brought to us in I

9771
08:54:31,895 --> 08:54:34,895
would remind members that this

9772
08:54:35,465 --> 08:54:37,865
measure sunsets in twenty

9773
08:54:38,232 --> 08:54:41,232
twenty five and-my reading of

9774
08:54:42,360 --> 08:54:43,940
the floor analysis talks about

9775
08:54:43,940 --> 08:54:45,672
the-extra insurance you know.

9776
08:54:45,672 --> 08:54:47,810
Add to legal interpretation

9777
08:54:47,810 --> 08:54:49,810
provision regarding the

9778
08:54:51,347 --> 08:54:53,652
definitions of waste and water

9779
08:54:53,652 --> 08:54:54,885
of the state and-the power or

9780
08:54:54,885 --> 08:54:56,488
the authority that the

9781
08:54:56,488 --> 08:54:58,855
department of fish and game has

9782
08:54:58,855 --> 08:55:01,855
sos not to affect existing

9783
08:55:04,858 --> 08:55:07,258
interpretations we are simply.

9784
08:55:09,765 --> 08:55:11,595
Keeping the status quo and as a.

9785
08:55:11,595 --> 08:55:12,232
Self proclaimed progressive and

9786
08:55:12,232 --> 08:55:13,566
liberal in the city california

9787
08:55:13,566 --> 08:55:14,770
I thinks the keeping the status

9788
08:55:14,770 --> 08:55:17,269
quo is not a big stretch and I

9789
08:55:17,269 --> 08:55:19,371
would urge an aye vote. Thank

9790
08:55:19,371 --> 08:55:20,706
you senator growth thank you

9791
08:55:20,706 --> 08:55:22,808
Mister President I respectfully

9792
08:55:22,808 --> 08:55:24,730
rise in opposition of this bill

9793
08:55:24,730 --> 08:55:25,209
if this bill passes the senate

9794
08:55:25,209 --> 08:55:26,812
with its current amendments the

9795
08:55:26,812 --> 08:55:28,146
only hope for farmers and the

9796
08:55:28,146 --> 08:55:28,781
people who need food and fiber

9797
08:55:28,781 --> 08:55:31,987
is governor's some to veto this

9798
08:55:31,987 --> 08:55:33,515
bill. This problem policies

9799
08:55:33,515 --> 08:55:35,530
purposely designed to get even

9800
08:55:35,530 --> 08:55:35,990
with the administration for

9801
08:55:35,990 --> 08:55:37,425
striving to bring commonsense

9802
08:55:37,425 --> 08:55:40,425
back to clement water. A

9803
08:55:40,825 --> 08:55:42,227
science. And it's been stated

9804
08:55:42,227 --> 08:55:45,262
by the author and also another

9805
08:55:45,262 --> 08:55:47,601
member that spoke. That this is

9806
08:55:47,601 --> 08:55:49,600
forty years of this policy in

9807
08:55:49,600 --> 08:55:50,167
protection is been in place for

9808
08:55:50,167 --> 08:55:51,340
forty years but there's new

9809
08:55:51,340 --> 08:55:53,434
science out there that's

9810
08:55:53,603 --> 08:55:55,875
available. And that's why these

9811
08:55:55,875 --> 08:55:57,341
decisions were made. Sb one

9812
08:55:57,341 --> 08:55:58,571
with these amendments freezes

9813
08:55:58,571 --> 08:56:00,571
environmental science regarding

9814
08:56:00,973 --> 08:56:02,480
how best produced a rebound of

9815
08:56:02,480 --> 08:56:03,935
an endangered species and non

9816
08:56:03,935 --> 08:56:06,413
indigenous fish. In the delta

9817
08:56:06,413 --> 08:56:06,981
bay area ignores at least

9818
08:56:06,981 --> 08:56:08,749
fifteen years worth of new

9819
08:56:08,749 --> 08:56:10,481
science and data. The science

9820
08:56:10,481 --> 08:56:13,820
will be made permanent with

9821
08:56:13,820 --> 08:56:15,188
this be one twenty twenty five.

9822
08:56:15,188 --> 08:56:16,890
For the single fish sb one with

9823
08:56:16,890 --> 08:56:18,256
the amendments. Will continue

9824
08:56:18,256 --> 08:56:19,490
to practice preventing fresh

9825
08:56:19,490 --> 08:56:21,580
water from being captured and

9826
08:56:21,580 --> 08:56:23,460
stored for many families and

9827
08:56:23,460 --> 08:56:25,620
farmers. Before it flows into

9828
08:56:25,620 --> 08:56:26,997
the pacific ocean. During the

9829
08:56:26,997 --> 08:56:27,632
last drought it led to almost

9830
08:56:27,632 --> 08:56:28,762
five hundred thousand acres of

9831
08:56:28,762 --> 08:56:31,162
farmland coming out of

9832
08:56:31,536 --> 08:56:33,169
production. In twenty 5% of

9833
08:56:33,169 --> 08:56:35,380
mandatory water rushing for

9834
08:56:35,380 --> 08:56:37,370
families. With people in the

9835
08:56:37,370 --> 08:56:39,380
central valley and my colleague

9836
08:56:39,380 --> 08:56:40,440
and I serve. That don't have

9837
08:56:40,440 --> 08:56:42,378
running water in the porter

9838
08:56:42,378 --> 08:56:43,645
biliary and then also there's a

9839
08:56:43,645 --> 08:56:45,380
to lee tribe down there they

9840
08:56:45,380 --> 08:56:47,451
has to bring a truck to water

9841
08:56:47,451 --> 08:56:49,170
into their-the people that

9842
08:56:49,170 --> 08:56:51,453
they serve because water shut

9843
08:56:51,453 --> 08:56:52,354
off. Additional cuts to the

9844
08:56:52,354 --> 08:56:55,320
water supply in increase water

9845
08:56:55,320 --> 08:56:56,391
weights will continue. To rise.

9846
08:56:56,391 --> 08:56:57,325
Sb one with the amendments

9847
08:56:57,325 --> 08:56:59,193
prevent surface water

9848
08:56:59,193 --> 08:56:59,958
deliveries necessary to comply

9849
08:56:59,958 --> 08:57:02,358
with the sustainable ground

9850
08:57:02,463 --> 08:57:04,980
water. Management act which was

9851
08:57:04,980 --> 08:57:05,236
passed a few years ago which

9852
08:57:05,236 --> 08:57:07,968
mandates water extracted to the

9853
08:57:07,968 --> 08:57:09,506
pumping. Must be replaced with

9854
08:57:09,506 --> 08:57:11,539
an equal amount of rainfall. A

9855
08:57:11,539 --> 08:57:12,810
and it with an equal amount and

9856
08:57:12,810 --> 08:57:13,707
rainfall is not enough to

9857
08:57:13,707 --> 08:57:16,107
achieve this. And it's

9858
08:57:16,766 --> 08:57:17,409
estimated was cigna alone that

9859
08:57:17,409 --> 08:57:18,178
eight hundred thousand acres of

9860
08:57:18,178 --> 08:57:20,911
farmla wl go out of

9861
08:57:20,911 --> 08:57:23,911
production. I submit to my

9862
08:57:27,451 --> 08:57:28,190
colleagues at this is farm land.

9863
08:57:28,190 --> 08:57:31,190
That produces the food that

9864
08:57:41,233 --> 08:57:42,998
your constituents eat. An. The

9865
08:57:42,998 --> 08:57:44,466
american food supply as a loss

9866
08:57:44,466 --> 08:57:44,969
on the economic impact in job

9867
08:57:44,969 --> 08:57:46,499
loss will be staggering

9868
08:57:46,499 --> 08:57:48,607
especially for central valley

9869
08:57:48,607 --> 08:57:49,671
sb one with the amendments I

9870
08:57:49,671 --> 08:57:50,806
still believe rex voluntary

9871
08:57:50,806 --> 08:57:53,108
agreements were initiated to

9872
08:57:53,108 --> 08:57:55,377
comply with 40% of them paired

9873
08:57:55,377 --> 08:57:55,911
flows and planned approved a

9874
08:57:55,911 --> 08:57:57,175
plan that was approved in

9875
08:57:57,175 --> 08:57:57,812
December of two thousand

9876
08:57:57,812 --> 08:57:59,305
eighteen that alone is

9877
08:57:59,305 --> 08:57:59,875
estimated to take two hundred

9878
08:57:59,875 --> 08:58:00,979
forty thousand acres of farm

9879
08:58:00,979 --> 08:58:03,351
land out of production the

9880
08:58:03,351 --> 08:58:04,585
economic implacable on this

9881
08:58:04,585 --> 08:58:06,122
piece of legislation with the

9882
08:58:06,122 --> 08:58:06,724
amendments and that farm land

9883
08:58:06,724 --> 08:58:08,390
going out of production will

9884
08:58:08,390 --> 08:58:10,855
affect our schools. Are tax

9885
08:58:10,855 --> 08:58:12,857
revenue for fires are fire

9886
08:58:12,857 --> 08:58:13,537
chiefs are police chiefs

9887
08:58:13,537 --> 08:58:14,894
because when you don't have

9888
08:58:14,894 --> 08:58:16,363
land in production for food to

9889
08:58:16,363 --> 08:58:18,598
grow food there's not revenue

9890
08:58:18,598 --> 08:58:20,433
to pay taxes to support that

9891
08:58:20,433 --> 08:58:22,300
it's estimated that from merced

9892
08:58:22,300 --> 08:58:24,337
to bakersfield almost two point

9893
08:58:24,337 --> 08:58:26,438
two million people will a case

9894
08:58:26,438 --> 08:58:28,642
estimated that these entire

9895
08:58:28,642 --> 08:58:29,973
communities could be devastated

9896
08:58:29,973 --> 08:58:30,843
from merced temp to bakersfield

9897
08:58:30,843 --> 08:58:32,944
and in fact almost two million

9898
08:58:32,944 --> 08:58:34,744
people from san fran in the san

9899
08:58:34,744 --> 08:58:37,744
francisco bay area will also

9900
08:58:39,215 --> 08:58:42,215
lose. Water in c. Draconian

9901
08:58:46,723 --> 08:58:47,323
water reductions. Sb one in

9902
08:58:47,323 --> 08:58:48,458
these amendments takes affects

9903
08:58:48,458 --> 08:58:49,689
immediately any remains in

9904
08:58:49,689 --> 08:58:51,161
effect until the President

9905
08:58:51,161 --> 08:58:51,794
Trump's he leaves office and it

9906
08:58:51,794 --> 08:58:52,661
gives california's so

9907
08:58:52,661 --> 08:58:54,270
controller the vast amounts of

9908
08:58:54,270 --> 08:58:55,229
water prevents the federal

9909
08:58:55,229 --> 08:58:55,929
government's. Intervention

9910
08:58:55,929 --> 08:58:57,363
intervention assistance in

9911
08:58:57,363 --> 08:58:57,933
restoring balance for

9912
08:58:57,933 --> 08:59:00,933
beneficial water use for all

9913
08:59:03,340 --> 08:59:05,342
users. This is really. You know

9914
08:59:05,342 --> 08:59:06,543
the central valley is. We

9915
08:59:06,543 --> 08:59:07,142
produce the energy that the

9916
08:59:07,142 --> 08:59:07,976
californians in constituents

9917
08:59:07,976 --> 08:59:10,976
constituents use on a daily

9918
08:59:13,770 --> 08:59:15,348
basis. And we produce the food.

9919
08:59:15,348 --> 08:59:16,149
That your constituents eat and

9920
08:59:16,149 --> 08:59:17,114
we're gonna have to import more

9921
08:59:17,114 --> 08:59:19,152
oral because of bills were

9922
08:59:19,152 --> 08:59:19,785
passed earlier this week and

9923
08:59:19,785 --> 08:59:20,888
we're gonna have to import more

9924
08:59:20,888 --> 08:59:21,987
food if this bill passes.

9925
08:59:21,987 --> 08:59:22,555
Reading the analysis it just

9926
08:59:22,555 --> 08:59:24,656
came off the floor with the

9927
08:59:24,656 --> 08:59:26,355
amendments there's a private

9928
08:59:26,355 --> 08:59:29,600
right of action that was

9929
08:59:29,600 --> 08:59:30,696
mentioned earlier that allows a

9930
08:59:30,696 --> 08:59:31,564
private right action against

9931
08:59:31,564 --> 08:59:33,964
individuals and businesses that

9932
08:59:34,796 --> 08:59:35,397
allegedly cz emergency

9933
08:59:35,397 --> 08:59:38,397
regulations adopted by the or

9934
08:59:39,203 --> 08:59:40,271
be. The cost anticipatd for

9935
08:59:40,271 --> 08:59:40,871
this particular fee increases

9936
08:59:40,871 --> 08:59:43,271
between four hundred thousand

9937
08:59:43,506 --> 08:59:44,810
and three million annually.

9938
08:59:44,810 --> 08:59:45,908
There is anticipating a six

9939
08:59:45,908 --> 08:59:47,274
point eight million dollar in

9940
08:59:47,274 --> 08:59:48,844
special funds one going costs

9941
08:59:48,844 --> 08:59:49,476
are estimated potentially for

9942
08:59:49,476 --> 08:59:51,448
twenty five million dollars

9943
08:59:51,448 --> 08:59:53,149
annually the department of fish

9944
08:59:53,149 --> 08:59:54,114
and wildlife is estimated six

9945
08:59:54,114 --> 08:59:56,722
million for the first year and

9946
08:59:56,722 --> 08:59:58,722
implementation and eleven

9947
08:59:59,552 --> 09:00:00,689
million to on going cost. Their

9948
09:00:00,689 --> 09:00:02,424
resources board another state

9949
09:00:02,424 --> 09:00:04,824
agencies vested median eleven

9950
09:00:05,591 --> 09:00:06,161
million dollars plus twenty

9951
09:00:06,161 --> 09:00:06,695
five million dollars in the

9952
09:00:06,695 --> 09:00:08,430
general fund for the air

9953
09:00:08,430 --> 09:00:10,133
pollution fund the state water

9954
09:00:10,133 --> 09:00:11,799
resources control board says

9955
09:00:11,799 --> 09:00:12,567
it's anticipating the fiscal

9956
09:00:12,567 --> 09:00:14,100
impact about a million dollars

9957
09:00:14,100 --> 09:00:16,806
a spread across various sending

9958
09:00:16,806 --> 09:00:18,270
funding sources. The department

9959
09:00:18,270 --> 09:00:19,700
of justice's it's likely to

9960
09:00:19,700 --> 09:00:20,975
cost nearly three or fifty

9961
09:00:20,975 --> 09:00:21,542
thousand dollars annually and

9962
09:00:21,542 --> 09:00:23,942
the department of industrial

9963
09:00:26,179 --> 09:00:26,748
relations a d. R. Says it's.

9964
09:00:26,748 --> 09:00:29,748
About one point five million

9965
09:00:33,150 --> 09:00:34,387
dollars in range. It's a has x.

9966
09:00:34,387 --> 09:00:35,654
Significant fiscal impact on

9967
09:00:35,654 --> 09:00:37,857
our state but it has a bigger

9968
09:00:37,857 --> 09:00:39,925
impact. O your food supply.

9969
09:00:39,925 --> 09:00:41,223
And so I would respectfully ask

9970
09:00:41,223 --> 09:00:43,161
for a no vote. Thank you

9971
09:00:43,161 --> 09:00:44,496
centers action thank you very

9972
09:00:44,496 --> 09:00:46,131
much I'm I'm not sure would

9973
09:00:46,131 --> 09:00:47,610
bills the minority leaders

9974
09:00:47,610 --> 09:00:49,366
referring to but basically what

9975
09:00:49,366 --> 09:00:50,369
this bill does. As I understand

9976
09:00:50,369 --> 09:00:52,536
it and what the amendments to.

9977
09:00:52,536 --> 09:00:53,670
Is it says it requires the

9978
09:00:53,670 --> 09:00:56,670
state to adopt to be

9979
09:00:57,338 --> 09:00:59,738
regulation. Any federal air

9980
09:01:01,644 --> 09:01:03,880
standard that is weakened. So

9981
09:01:03,880 --> 09:01:04,716
what we've got now the highest

9982
09:01:04,716 --> 09:01:05,779
laws that already exist we're

9983
09:01:05,779 --> 09:01:07,352
going to protect. Because we

9984
09:01:07,352 --> 09:01:08,451
know this administration has

9985
09:01:08,451 --> 09:01:11,286
made a point to try to

9986
09:01:11,286 --> 09:01:13,286
undermine every environmental

9987
09:01:16,925 --> 09:01:17,526
law in the state. I am talking

9988
09:01:17,526 --> 09:01:21,726
to the issue and the issue was

9989
09:01:23,598 --> 09:01:25,998
the amendments. What's more

9990
09:01:31,440 --> 09:01:35,308
back in dc on you guys. It is

9991
09:01:35,308 --> 09:01:35,875
very we kinda like. We would

9992
09:01:35,875 --> 09:01:38,275
you haven't been recognize

9993
09:01:38,344 --> 09:01:40,776
first and we asked for decorum

9994
09:01:40,776 --> 09:01:44,976
and we ask not directed tax on

9995
09:01:45,251 --> 09:01:48,851
each other so visit. State your

9996
09:01:51,289 --> 09:01:55,489
point of order. Is being in the

9997
09:01:58,595 --> 09:02:01,465
nation. To maintain the higher

9998
09:02:01,465 --> 09:02:03,865
federal air standards. That

9999
09:02:04,132 --> 09:02:05,903
exist now if they are weakened

10000
09:02:05,903 --> 09:02:07,871
by the federal government that

10001
09:02:07,871 --> 09:02:09,706
is part of this bill so with

10002
09:02:09,706 --> 09:02:12,545
all due respect I would

10003
09:02:12,545 --> 09:02:15,175
appreciate it if those who. Are

10004
09:02:15,175 --> 09:02:17,447
talking about sb one would talk

10005
09:02:17,447 --> 09:02:19,749
about sb one and I'm talking

10006
09:02:19,749 --> 09:02:21,386
about the amendment it says we

10007
09:02:21,386 --> 09:02:22,854
will the department of

10008
09:02:22,854 --> 09:02:25,254
industrial relations and others

10009
09:02:25,652 --> 09:02:27,454
will adopt various protections

10010
09:02:27,454 --> 09:02:31,540
that were in place in federal

10011
09:02:31,526 --> 09:02:32,126
law or regulation as of January

10012
09:02:32,126 --> 09:02:33,461
twenty seventeen if they are

10013
09:02:33,461 --> 09:02:35,930
subsequently we can to or

10014
09:02:35,930 --> 09:02:39,401
repealed in other words we have

10015
09:02:39,401 --> 09:02:41,968
a baseline. We do not want to

10016
09:02:41,968 --> 09:02:43,736
our environmental laws eroded

10017
09:02:43,736 --> 09:02:45,504
below those bass lines whether

10018
09:02:45,504 --> 09:02:47,441
it's state law or whether it's

10019
09:02:47,441 --> 09:02:49,675
federal law that we have been

10020
09:02:49,675 --> 09:02:51,243
using that's what this bill is

10021
09:02:51,243 --> 09:02:52,778
all about that's what the

10022
09:02:52,778 --> 09:02:55,110
amendments are about and if I

10023
09:02:55,110 --> 09:02:56,615
could refer you. To the section

10024
09:02:56,615 --> 09:02:58,951
regarding a the amendment to

10025
09:02:58,951 --> 09:03:00,889
the private right of action it

10026
09:03:00,889 --> 09:03:03,685
doesn't create a new one each

10027
09:03:03,685 --> 09:03:05,256
assembly says that the provides

10028
09:03:05,256 --> 09:03:06,791
a private right of action to

10029
09:03:06,791 --> 09:03:09,191
enforce certain error water

10030
09:03:09,860 --> 09:03:11,927
standards within california if

10031
09:03:11,927 --> 09:03:13,998
the existing private right of

10032
09:03:13,998 --> 09:03:16,131
action within federal law or

10033
09:03:16,131 --> 09:03:17,738
regulation is weakened to or

10034
09:03:17,738 --> 09:03:19,670
repealed because we know that's

10035
09:03:19,670 --> 09:03:21,605
exactly what is going on in

10036
09:03:21,605 --> 09:03:23,574
washington we want to protect

10037
09:03:23,574 --> 09:03:25,606
our laws we want to protect our

10038
09:03:25,606 --> 09:03:27,440
state these notions. That the

10039
09:03:27,440 --> 09:03:31,150
world is going to come to an

10040
09:03:31,150 --> 09:03:35,840
end our food supply is going to

10041
09:03:35,840 --> 09:03:35,649
come to an end is trust falls.

10042
09:03:35,649 --> 09:03:36,419
This bill says we want to

10043
09:03:36,419 --> 09:03:38,121
protect the standards that are

10044
09:03:38,121 --> 09:03:38,722
in existence as of January

10045
09:03:38,722 --> 09:03:40,860
twenty seventeen before this

10046
09:03:40,860 --> 09:03:41,657
administration came in and

10047
09:03:41,657 --> 09:03:43,657
started undermining and

10048
09:03:44,260 --> 09:03:45,561
weakening those regulations.

10049
09:03:45,561 --> 09:03:47,831
That's what this bill does this

10050
09:03:47,831 --> 09:03:49,631
is totally on point because

10051
09:03:49,631 --> 09:03:52,267
what we're talking about is the

10052
09:03:52,267 --> 09:03:52,834
reduction in the weakening que

10053
09:03:52,834 --> 09:03:56,434
to fight your point of order

10054
09:03:57,706 --> 09:04:01,306
senator. Okay okay all over the

10055
09:04:01,376 --> 09:04:04,976
state. Water based on what you

10056
09:04:08,647 --> 09:04:10,384
guys. Thank you. Were you still

10057
09:04:10,384 --> 09:04:11,786
ste continues speak to the

10058
09:04:11,786 --> 09:04:13,530
member senator jackson thank

10059
09:04:13,530 --> 09:04:14,285
you I am speaking to the

10060
09:04:14,285 --> 09:04:16,590
amendments at least as they

10061
09:04:16,590 --> 09:04:19,193
exist here and it provides any

10062
09:04:19,193 --> 09:04:20,324
state regulation that's adopted

10063
09:04:20,324 --> 09:04:22,724
to ensure protections of

10064
09:04:24,562 --> 09:04:27,100
federal law so of January

10065
09:04:27,100 --> 09:04:27,635
twenty seventeen will sunset in

10066
09:04:27,635 --> 09:04:28,634
twenty twenty five we are

10067
09:04:28,634 --> 09:04:30,737
protect trying to protect the

10068
09:04:30,737 --> 09:04:32,402
environmental laws of the state

10069
09:04:32,402 --> 09:04:33,672
that's what this bill does

10070
09:04:33,672 --> 09:04:35,204
that's what these amendments do

10071
09:04:35,204 --> 09:04:36,941
I want to thank the author for

10072
09:04:36,941 --> 09:04:39,711
doing this we have spent

10073
09:04:39,711 --> 09:04:41,945
decades trying to create strong

10074
09:04:41,945 --> 09:04:43,614
environmental protections to

10075
09:04:43,614 --> 09:04:45,616
advance to protect the future

10076
09:04:45,616 --> 09:04:47,384
of our great state we do not

10077
09:04:47,384 --> 09:04:49,220
want them undemind. That's

10078
09:04:49,220 --> 09:04:52,687
what this bill does and I thank

10079
09:04:52,687 --> 09:04:53,257
the author for bringing in and

10080
09:04:53,257 --> 09:04:56,121
ask for your vote. Thank you

10081
09:04:56,121 --> 09:04:56,924
center hueso. Thank you Mister

10082
09:04:56,924 --> 09:04:59,126
President the point of order.

10083
09:04:59,126 --> 09:05:00,397
Basically confirmed in my mind

10084
09:05:00,397 --> 09:05:02,698
that the opposition doesn't

10085
09:05:02,698 --> 09:05:04,866
understand what this bill is

10086
09:05:04,866 --> 09:05:07,167
really about so. I was going to

10087
09:05:07,167 --> 09:05:07,934
get up and cal clarify but my

10088
09:05:07,934 --> 09:05:10,234
colleague from santa barbara

10089
09:05:10,234 --> 09:05:11,405
did a great job basically.

10090
09:05:11,405 --> 09:05:13,805
Explaining what this bill

10091
09:05:13,871 --> 09:05:15,475
actually does and we talk about

10092
09:05:15,475 --> 09:05:17,875
science coming out of

10093
09:05:18,110 --> 09:05:20,146
washington right now I'm sorry.

10094
09:05:20,146 --> 09:05:20,850
The science it had nothing

10095
09:05:20,850 --> 09:05:23,748
coming out of washington is

10096
09:05:23,748 --> 09:05:25,950
based o science right now. And

10097
09:05:25,950 --> 09:05:28,452
what they are attempting to do

10098
09:05:28,452 --> 09:05:30,852
here in california is

10099
09:05:31,855 --> 09:05:33,490
undermining our ability. To

10100
09:05:33,490 --> 09:05:35,658
solve problems that we have in

10101
09:05:35,658 --> 09:05:38,261
our state. The deal was salt

10102
09:05:38,261 --> 09:05:39,843
water intrusion that seal with

10103
09:05:39,843 --> 09:05:42,500
that deal with the protection

10104
09:05:42,500 --> 09:05:44,700
of endangered species that deal

10105
09:05:44,700 --> 09:05:46,802
with of subsidence it's also

10106
09:05:46,802 --> 09:05:48,466
affect the in. The production

10107
09:05:48,466 --> 09:05:51,204
of crops in our state.

10108
09:05:51,204 --> 09:05:53,904
Subsidence we voter on a bill

10109
09:05:53,904 --> 09:05:55,541
that's funding the frying canal

10110
09:05:55,541 --> 09:05:57,709
that is been affected by

10111
09:05:57,709 --> 09:05:59,309
subsidence we talk about. The

10112
09:05:59,309 --> 09:06:02,309
ground water management this is

10113
09:06:02,647 --> 09:06:03,647
a critical issue in california

10114
09:06:03,647 --> 09:06:06,550
and our survival of salt water

10115
09:06:06,550 --> 09:06:07,150
intrusion overtakes. Our water

10116
09:06:07,150 --> 09:06:09,720
supply in the entire valley

10117
09:06:09,720 --> 09:06:11,525
there goes all of agriculture.

10118
09:06:11,525 --> 09:06:13,891
Everything is destroyed this

10119
09:06:13,891 --> 09:06:14,991
also is an issue that deals

10120
09:06:14,991 --> 09:06:17,291
with our economy and our

10121
09:06:17,291 --> 09:06:19,562
ability to produce. Of food in

10122
09:06:19,562 --> 09:06:21,940
the state so. This is a very

10123
09:06:21,940 --> 09:06:23,699
important bill and I applaud

10124
09:06:23,699 --> 09:06:25,234
the author for taking on this

10125
09:06:25,234 --> 09:06:27,634
issue creating the baseline

10126
09:06:27,734 --> 09:06:30,734
this bill. Will not change

10127
09:06:34,780 --> 09:06:35,174
anything it will not but of. It

10128
09:06:35,174 --> 09:06:36,781
will not. Destroy our state's

10129
09:06:36,781 --> 09:06:39,683
ability to continue to produce

10130
09:06:39,683 --> 09:06:41,451
food but it will. Provide those

10131
09:06:41,451 --> 09:06:43,449
important protections maintain

10132
09:06:43,449 --> 09:06:45,353
them in place the one set of we

10133
09:06:45,353 --> 09:06:46,959
want we've worked for. For

10134
09:06:46,959 --> 09:06:49,324
decades to put in place to put

10135
09:06:49,324 --> 09:06:50,724
our state on a better path and

10136
09:06:50,724 --> 09:06:53,160
we are the largest agricultural

10137
09:06:53,160 --> 09:06:55,130
producer in the countries we-

10138
09:06:55,130 --> 09:06:57,365
things are going well war war

10139
09:06:57,365 --> 09:06:59,198
going in the right direction.

10140
09:06:59,198 --> 09:07:01,233
Science tells us that climate

10141
09:07:01,233 --> 09:07:03,436
change is real we gotta do our

10142
09:07:03,436 --> 09:07:05,271
part this administration's term

10143
09:07:05,271 --> 09:07:06,940
debt though that but what we

10144
09:07:06,940 --> 09:07:08,540
understand a in our community

10145
09:07:08,540 --> 09:07:11,207
here in california. And we're

10146
09:07:11,207 --> 09:07:12,911
fighting for our survival here

10147
09:07:12,911 --> 09:07:15,611
support this bill this is a

10148
09:07:15,611 --> 09:07:18,611
good bill. This bill supports

10149
09:07:19,784 --> 09:07:22,651
every aspect of our economy our

10150
09:07:22,651 --> 09:07:25,623
environment and our quality of

10151
09:07:25,623 --> 09:07:28,623
life please vote yes. To

10152
09:07:29,227 --> 09:07:30,294
senator mining. Your President

10153
09:07:30,294 --> 09:07:32,763
I also rise in support I want

10154
09:07:32,763 --> 09:07:34,329
to thank the pro tem for her

10155
09:07:34,329 --> 09:07:36,729
courage and leadership bringing

10156
09:07:36,900 --> 09:07:39,104
this forward a lot of the focus

10157
09:07:39,104 --> 09:07:41,406
on the amendments that we are

10158
09:07:41,406 --> 09:07:43,208
voting on has been on the

10159
09:07:43,208 --> 09:07:45,208
environmental standards that

10160
09:07:46,372 --> 09:07:48,743
were trying to protect. They do

10161
09:07:48,743 --> 09:07:50,578
have some affect potentially on

10162
09:07:50,578 --> 09:07:53,381
water issues but I just want to

10163
09:07:53,381 --> 09:07:55,781
focus. The future of

10164
09:07:57,385 --> 09:07:59,785
agriculture. Depends in large

10165
09:08:00,200 --> 09:08:02,923
measure on the work force that

10166
09:08:02,923 --> 09:08:05,158
cultivates and harvest the crop.

10167
09:08:05,158 --> 09:08:06,660
In this bill also seeks to

10168
09:08:06,660 --> 09:08:08,394
authorize the occupational

10169
09:08:08,394 --> 09:08:09,763
safety and health standards

10170
09:08:09,763 --> 09:08:11,898
board in the department of

10171
09:08:11,898 --> 09:08:14,298
industrial relations to adopt

10172
09:08:14,331 --> 09:08:16,731
via regulation any worker

10173
09:08:16,767 --> 09:08:18,806
protections that were in place

10174
09:08:18,806 --> 09:08:21,707
in federal law or regulation as

10175
09:08:21,707 --> 09:08:22,971
of January twenty seventeen and

10176
09:08:22,971 --> 09:08:25,371
were subsequently weakened or

10177
09:08:25,676 --> 09:08:27,779
repealed. I would submit that

10178
09:08:27,779 --> 09:08:30,179
worker healtand safe the

10179
09:08:30,214 --> 09:08:32,614
protection of worker protection

10180
09:08:33,180 --> 09:08:35,218
standards are also an equally

10181
09:08:35,218 --> 09:08:37,618
important component of this

10182
09:08:38,386 --> 09:08:40,823
bill and I urge your aye vote.

10183
09:08:40,823 --> 09:08:41,388
Thank you any additional

10184
09:08:41,388 --> 09:08:44,388
discussion or debate on this

10185
09:08:45,995 --> 09:08:48,640
item. Jean hearing on Madam Pro

10186
09:08:48,640 --> 09:08:48,629
tem would you like to close

10187
09:08:48,629 --> 09:08:51,533
thank you Mister President I

10188
09:08:51,533 --> 09:08:54,200
would. You know the whole

10189
09:08:54,200 --> 09:08:56,204
intent in point of this bill is

10190
09:08:56,204 --> 09:08:58,103
to protect us against roll

10191
09:08:58,103 --> 09:09:00,575
backs that are occurring. On

10192
09:09:00,575 --> 09:09:01,106
clean air clean water

10193
09:09:01,106 --> 09:09:03,106
endangered species worker

10194
09:09:04,120 --> 09:09:05,679
protections. Some of the

10195
09:09:05,679 --> 09:09:08,882
statements are I think a little

10196
09:09:08,882 --> 09:09:09,448
bit over broad our state I'm

10197
09:09:09,448 --> 09:09:12,382
I'm gonna make a few points

10198
09:09:12,382 --> 09:09:13,485
just to. Respond to some of the

10199
09:09:13,485 --> 09:09:15,485
comments and questions

10200
09:09:17,355 --> 09:09:19,900
hopefully. It because this is

10201
09:09:19,900 --> 09:09:22,825
such a large bill and we took

10202
09:09:22,825 --> 09:09:23,929
so many amendments. Our state

10203
09:09:23,929 --> 09:09:26,131
has lived and thrived under the

10204
09:09:26,131 --> 09:09:28,402
current esa limits the only

10205
09:09:28,402 --> 09:09:31,400
thing this bill affects again

10206
09:09:31,400 --> 09:09:34,400
is roll backs no new

10207
09:09:35,103 --> 09:09:37,507
regulations no hold science. As

10208
09:09:37,507 --> 09:09:39,900
it relates to the essay nothing

10209
09:09:39,900 --> 09:09:40,844
precludes new science from

10210
09:09:40,844 --> 09:09:42,412
being used we're just saying

10211
09:09:42,412 --> 09:09:44,614
that california will review the

10212
09:09:44,614 --> 09:09:47,751
science and just not trust that

10213
09:09:47,751 --> 09:09:48,983
the science coming. Out of the

10214
09:09:48,983 --> 09:09:51,287
fed's the fed federal

10215
09:09:51,287 --> 09:09:53,457
ministrations true and that's

10216
09:09:53,457 --> 09:09:54,210
why the final discretion rest

10217
09:09:54,210 --> 09:09:57,535
with fish and game. I would

10218
09:09:57,535 --> 09:10:00,399
point out. The at five in the

10219
09:10:00,399 --> 09:10:02,431
last several months. The

10220
09:10:02,431 --> 09:10:04,330
provisions were talking to that

10221
09:10:04,330 --> 09:10:06,371
are esstial to the

10222
09:10:06,371 --> 09:10:06,933
overarching purpose of the bill

10223
09:10:06,933 --> 09:10:09,333
particularly in response to

10224
09:10:10,970 --> 09:10:12,274
recent. The recent actions I

10225
09:10:12,274 --> 09:10:13,171
don't know how else to say it

10226
09:10:13,171 --> 09:10:15,571
out of the current

10227
09:10:15,842 --> 09:10:18,145
administration. Is to sideline

10228
09:10:18,145 --> 09:10:20,545
federal scientists and weakened

10229
09:10:21,148 --> 09:10:23,548
protections for several species

10230
09:10:23,749 --> 09:10:26,753
we saw that there was these the

10231
09:10:26,753 --> 09:10:27,986
new regulations were coming out

10232
09:10:27,986 --> 09:10:30,355
they were over written by the

10233
09:10:30,355 --> 09:10:32,325
federal administration. To get

10234
09:10:32,325 --> 09:10:34,489
new regulations because they

10235
09:10:34,489 --> 09:10:36,794
didn't like the regulations

10236
09:10:36,794 --> 09:10:38,862
were coming from the scientist.

10237
09:10:38,862 --> 09:10:40,498
The first place so they were

10238
09:10:40,498 --> 09:10:42,330
over written by the federal

10239
09:10:42,330 --> 09:10:44,340
administration that is absolute

10240
09:10:44,340 --> 09:10:46,603
evidence that there is an

10241
09:10:46,603 --> 09:10:49,300
attempt to actually override

10242
09:10:49,706 --> 09:10:52,309
the best science. People keep

10243
09:10:52,309 --> 09:10:54,644
asking me of our talking about

10244
09:10:54,644 --> 09:10:57,613
this bill as if we are trying

10245
09:10:57,613 --> 09:10:59,782
not to accept the newest. And

10246
09:10:59,782 --> 09:11:02,448
most updated science we just

10247
09:11:02,448 --> 09:11:05,448
saw evidence of exactly the

10248
09:11:08,759 --> 09:11:10,659
opposite out of. Washington.

10249
09:11:10,659 --> 09:11:11,993
The bill totally preserves full

10250
09:11:11,993 --> 09:11:13,828
discretion for our state

10251
09:11:13,828 --> 09:11:15,230
agencies to assess and apply

10252
09:11:15,230 --> 09:11:17,499
the most current science

10253
09:11:17,499 --> 09:11:19,400
available we put it in the bill

10254
09:11:19,400 --> 09:11:21,366
it's the language in the bill

10255
09:11:21,366 --> 09:11:25,566
it does not in any manner lock

10256
09:11:26,975 --> 09:11:28,425
in old science. References to

10257
09:11:28,425 --> 09:11:30,475
rushing a bill this bill has

10258
09:11:30,475 --> 09:11:32,414
been heard in an unprecedented

10259
09:11:32,414 --> 09:11:34,480
six policy committees three in

10260
09:11:34,480 --> 09:11:37,170
a each house it's been

10261
09:11:37,170 --> 09:11:39,417
reviewed. Extensively and when

10262
09:11:40,320 --> 09:11:40,820
you say stick to the amendments

10263
09:11:40,820 --> 09:11:43,220
there been seventy five

10264
09:11:44,691 --> 09:11:46,526
amendments to this bill. In

10265
09:11:46,526 --> 09:11:47,757
reference to the letters you

10266
09:11:47,757 --> 09:11:50,757
know there been more letters

10267
09:11:50,829 --> 09:11:53,229
from hi congressional members

10268
09:11:54,266 --> 09:11:55,366
to actually one in support. The

10269
09:11:55,366 --> 09:11:57,535
bill of the bill and one that

10270
09:11:57,535 --> 09:11:59,203
ask for amendments we've made

10271
09:11:59,203 --> 09:12:00,635
as I said amendments to address

10272
09:12:00,635 --> 09:12:02,807
the concerns raised in one

10273
09:12:02,807 --> 09:12:03,441
letter but we stayed faithful

10274
09:12:03,441 --> 09:12:06,713
to the support expressed by the

10275
09:12:06,713 --> 09:12:08,120
other. Sb one doesn't in any

10276
09:12:08,120 --> 09:12:10,412
manner affect the standards

10277
09:12:10,511 --> 09:12:12,883
that apply to the water system.

10278
09:12:12,883 --> 09:12:13,451
In california unless again

10279
09:12:13,451 --> 09:12:16,451
their rolled back that's the

10280
09:12:16,454 --> 09:12:18,789
whole point. Our system has

10281
09:12:18,789 --> 09:12:21,401
worked well for decades sb one

10282
09:12:21,401 --> 09:12:24,992
isn't the problem I think it's

10283
09:12:24,992 --> 09:12:27,531
the impact and attack. On the

10284
09:12:27,531 --> 09:12:30,931
forty years worth of work that

10285
09:12:30,931 --> 09:12:33,931
we have done with stakeholders

10286
09:12:34,432 --> 09:12:35,690
through agencies process. That

10287
09:12:35,690 --> 09:12:38,140
is what we're trying to protect

10288
09:12:38,140 --> 09:12:41,720
and I wouldn't. I have a great

10289
09:12:41,720 --> 09:12:42,412
deal of admiration and respect

10290
09:12:42,412 --> 09:12:45,780
for people in the agricultural

10291
09:12:45,780 --> 09:12:46,879
community which is why we met a

10292
09:12:46,879 --> 09:12:51,790
number of times and for many of

10293
09:12:51,820 --> 09:12:53,487
these. Amendments come from. It

10294
09:12:53,487 --> 09:12:56,210
pains me that we haven't been

10295
09:12:56,210 --> 09:12:59,210
able to come to agreement.

10296
09:12:59,458 --> 09:13:00,590
Personally are but this is the

10297
09:13:00,590 --> 09:13:03,659
crux of the discussion that we

10298
09:13:05,697 --> 09:13:06,799
have been having. For decades.

10299
09:13:06,799 --> 09:13:08,866
We talk about people who will

10300
09:13:08,866 --> 09:13:10,970
be impacted when we had the

10301
09:13:10,970 --> 09:13:13,170
last drought we almost lost the

10302
09:13:13,170 --> 09:13:15,570
entire salmon population in

10303
09:13:18,675 --> 09:13:20,176
parts of our state. Because we

10304
09:13:20,176 --> 09:13:21,709
needed that protection in place

10305
09:13:21,709 --> 09:13:24,109
we needed the endangered

10306
09:13:25,647 --> 09:13:26,249
species we have a you know

10307
09:13:26,249 --> 09:13:29,170
people like to talk about the

10308
09:13:29,170 --> 09:13:30,252
little fish the smel. Were

10309
09:13:30,252 --> 09:13:33,252
talking steel head trout were

10310
09:13:33,417 --> 09:13:35,817
talkin salmon were talking

10311
09:13:36,289 --> 09:13:37,979
resident killer whales. Bob

10312
09:13:37,979 --> 09:13:40,979
we're talking about the delta

10313
09:13:41,527 --> 09:13:43,831
ecosystem. I get the dialogue

10314
09:13:43,831 --> 09:13:46,831
and discussion I understand how

10315
09:13:46,896 --> 09:13:49,735
hard this is we are asking

10316
09:13:49,735 --> 09:13:51,306
frankly not to have a rush in

10317
09:13:51,306 --> 09:13:54,306
judgment on clean air clean

10318
09:13:55,242 --> 09:13:57,608
water. Worker protections the

10319
09:13:57,608 --> 09:13:59,811
endangered species or asking

10320
09:13:59,811 --> 09:14:03,278
not to have a rush to judgment

10321
09:14:03,278 --> 09:14:06,682
and redo in six months nine

10322
09:14:06,682 --> 09:14:09,785
months one year all of the work

10323
09:14:09,785 --> 09:14:11,720
that we have done for decades.

10324
09:14:11,720 --> 09:14:13,421
As californians and in fact

10325
09:14:13,421 --> 09:14:15,421
working with federal

10326
09:14:16,156 --> 09:14:18,156
administrations both democrats

10327
09:14:19,226 --> 09:14:20,794
and republicans so. I

10328
09:14:20,794 --> 09:14:23,563
appreciate the depth of feeling

10329
09:14:23,563 --> 09:14:25,465
here and I gotta tell yeah I'e

10330
09:14:25,465 --> 09:14:28,465
never felt more conflicted in

10331
09:14:29,169 --> 09:14:31,704
terms of all of the

10332
09:14:31,704 --> 09:14:34,104
stakeholders that feel feel

10333
09:14:34,307 --> 09:14:36,173
intimately the impact of what

10334
09:14:36,173 --> 09:14:38,747
this legislation is doing but

10335
09:14:38,747 --> 09:14:41,460
frankly it is because there was

10336
09:14:41,460 --> 09:14:42,612
the desire to try to roll back

10337
09:14:42,612 --> 09:14:45,120
components of the endangered

10338
09:14:47,221 --> 09:14:48,887
species act because. Are there

10339
09:14:48,887 --> 09:14:50,355
is something you that many

10340
09:14:50,355 --> 09:14:54,126
would like to see on done in

10341
09:14:54,126 --> 09:14:56,761
the first place so. I

10342
09:14:56,761 --> 09:14:59,161
respectfully ask my colleagues

10343
09:14:59,528 --> 09:15:00,965
to support this. I don't know

10344
09:15:00,965 --> 09:15:04,565
much more what we could have

10345
09:15:04,736 --> 09:15:07,736
done to address every concern.

10346
09:15:07,838 --> 09:15:10,674
In good faith I said I would we

10347
09:15:10,674 --> 09:15:13,740
worked incredibly hard and-I

10348
09:15:13,579 --> 09:15:15,344
would at this very early hour

10349
09:15:15,344 --> 09:15:18,344
in the morning on the

10350
09:15:19,315 --> 09:15:20,149
fourteenth. It'safter midnight

10351
09:15:20,149 --> 09:15:22,850
we're no longer on the

10352
09:15:22,850 --> 09:15:23,282
thirteenth that might be good

10353
09:15:23,282 --> 09:15:24,820
given the things that have

10354
09:15:24,820 --> 09:15:26,355
happened all day and into the

10355
09:15:26,355 --> 09:15:28,529
evening. But I would

10356
09:15:28,529 --> 09:15:30,796
respectfully ask my colleagues

10357
09:15:30,796 --> 09:15:32,761
for an aye vote on sb one we

10358
09:15:32,761 --> 09:15:33,995
should be incredibly proud of

10359
09:15:33,995 --> 09:15:36,328
the work that california has

10360
09:15:36,328 --> 09:15:38,650
done on all of these issues and

10361
09:15:38,650 --> 09:15:40,710
we May not always agree but

10362
09:15:40,710 --> 09:15:43,168
there has been a process. And

10363
09:15:43,168 --> 09:15:43,706
extensive process on each of

10364
09:15:43,706 --> 09:15:46,577
these areas. And this bill

10365
09:15:46,577 --> 09:15:48,806
reflects. Just the strong

10366
09:15:48,806 --> 09:15:50,511
support of that work hat we

10367
09:15:50,511 --> 09:15:52,280
have done I ask for your aye

10368
09:15:52,280 --> 09:15:53,878
vote. Thank you all debate

10369
09:15:53,878 --> 09:15:56,278
having seize the secretary

10370
09:15:56,615 --> 09:16:00,152
please call the roll. Allen I

10371
09:16:00,152 --> 09:16:03,152
archuleta. I aye atkins aye

10372
09:16:06,590 --> 09:16:10,190
bates. No bell by porges. No

10373
09:16:11,695 --> 09:16:14,695
bradford I caballero. No chiang.

10374
09:16:18,468 --> 09:16:22,668
No dally no dodd I dorado. By

10375
09:16:23,373 --> 09:16:26,373
galgiani no glazer. By gonzalez

10376
09:16:28,811 --> 09:16:32,411
hi growth no hertzberg aye hill.

10377
09:16:32,681 --> 09:16:36,881
Hi hueso I tado no jackson hi

10378
09:16:40,220 --> 09:16:42,990
jones. No leyva by mcguire hi

10379
09:16:42,990 --> 09:16:46,590
mitchell I by monning by more

10380
09:16:47,128 --> 09:16:50,728
lock no merrell no nielsen no

10381
09:16:53,100 --> 09:16:56,503
pan. I portantino I roth I

10382
09:16:56,503 --> 09:17:00,103
rubio aye skinner aye stern aye

10383
09:17:01,871 --> 09:17:05,471
stone. No number iowa caskey I

10384
09:17:15,190 --> 09:17:15,589
winner. Wilk no no. Yes. Twenty

10385
09:17:15,589 --> 09:17:17,989
five fourteen senator atkins

10386
09:17:31,836 --> 09:17:33,836
most the call

10387
09:18:24,282 --> 09:18:26,282
. Members your

10388
09:18:26,885 --> 09:18:30,485
dollar to call on file item

10389
09:18:32,688 --> 09:18:33,288
twenty three. Ab ten sixty six.

10390
09:18:33,288 --> 09:18:36,288
The secretary please call the

10391
09:18:43,734 --> 09:18:46,734
absent members. Allen by atkins

10392
09:18:49,390 --> 09:18:51,439
by caballero. Galgiani glazer

10393
09:18:55,545 --> 09:18:57,945
hertzberg. I tado. Pan

10394
09:19:06,222 --> 09:19:09,222
portantino I roth. Rubio. The

10395
09:19:13,136 --> 09:19:15,536
team. Nineteen yes fortinos.

10396
09:19:29,541 --> 09:19:33,141
Were put it back on call

10397
09:21:54,730 --> 09:21:56,730
.

10398
09:22:06,308 --> 09:22:06,455
Members were moving back to

10399
09:22:06,455 --> 09:22:06,603
motions and resolutions center

10400
09:22:06,603 --> 09:22:06,749
portantino. Thank you are

10401
09:22:06,749 --> 09:22:06,895
mister President Members I

10402
09:22:06,895 --> 09:22:07,889
respectfully request unanimous

10403
09:22:07,889 --> 09:22:09,487
consent to submit a letter to

10404
09:22:09,487 --> 09:22:10,688
the senate journal for senate

10405
09:22:10,688 --> 09:22:13,688
bill three twenty eight. The

10406
09:22:25,868 --> 09:22:27,603
objections. Without objection.

10407
09:22:27,603 --> 09:22:30,300
The additional motions and

10408
09:22:34,372 --> 09:22:36,212
resolutions at this time. Thank

10409
09:22:36,212 --> 09:22:39,812
you we're gonna take a little

10410
09:22:40,380 --> 09:22:42,686
five minute. When we have

10411
09:22:42,686 --> 09:22:44,649
senator dollars on the ballot

10412
09:22:44,649 --> 09:22:46,118
the condition of the file. How

10413
09:22:46,118 --> 09:22:47,619
many bills do we actually have

10414
09:22:47,619 --> 09:22:49,287
left we know that this is this

10415
09:22:49,287 --> 09:22:52,287
is not appropriate time where

10416
09:22:52,757 --> 09:22:54,600
motions and resolutions it's.

10417
09:22:54,600 --> 09:22:56,194
One thirty in the morning and

10418
09:22:56,194 --> 09:22:56,760
I'd I'd like to least kind of

10419
09:22:56,760 --> 09:23:00,360
get an idea you know what's

10420
09:23:01,165 --> 09:23:01,798
happening. This is a I just go

10421
09:23:01,798 --> 09:23:06,598
home if I don't want to vote on

10422
09:23:19,317 --> 09:23:21,217
these bills. I'm serious

10423
09:23:21,217 --> 09:23:22,820
.

10424
09:23:22,820 --> 09:23:25,885
Senator delaware we do not have

10425
09:23:25,885 --> 09:23:26,522
that information at this time

10426
09:23:26,522 --> 09:23:30,122
so. We're we're getting a short

10427
09:23:42,739 --> 09:23:44,739
little white

10428
09:26:49,242 --> 09:26:51,676
. I do a real quick

10429
09:26:51,676 --> 09:26:53,480
update work we have four minute

10430
09:26:53,480 --> 09:26:54,679
measure still to be dealt with

10431
09:26:54,679 --> 09:26:57,815
be dealt with this evening we

10432
09:26:57,815 --> 09:26:58,980
have one a. B. And three espys

10433
09:26:58,980 --> 09:27:01,687
but we're waiting for that

10434
09:27:01,687 --> 09:27:04,880
speech to come over so. We're

10435
09:27:04,880 --> 09:27:04,688
we're just going to be in a

10436
09:27:04,688 --> 09:27:07,880
temporary holding pattern into

10437
09:27:09,763 --> 09:27:10,394
we have. How those measures

10438
09:27:10,394 --> 09:27:11,962
here and we're here because of

10439
09:27:11,962 --> 09:27:13,300
the circumstances. And as you

10440
09:27:13,300 --> 09:27:14,601
we all know what happened

10441
09:27:14,601 --> 09:27:16,166
earlier today that pretty much

10442
09:27:16,166 --> 09:27:19,166
dictate put. Put us behind

10443
09:27:20,300 --> 09:27:20,837
schedule so having to relocate

10444
09:27:20,837 --> 09:27:24,437
and set up here so please

10445
09:27:37,140 --> 09:27:39,140
understand

10446
09:39:01,874 --> 09:39:03,713
. Mister Secretary

10447
09:39:03,713 --> 09:39:06,713
please call the absent members.

10448
09:39:15,320 --> 09:39:17,662
Member. Wiener by twenty. All

10449
09:39:17,662 --> 09:39:20,293
eyes twenty six note fourteenth

10450
09:39:20,293 --> 09:39:22,293
assembly member mber

10451
09:39:29,300 --> 09:39:32,900
amendments kurt and I can talk.

10452
09:39:33,740 --> 09:39:35,403
I don't twenty two ab two

10453
09:39:35,403 --> 09:39:35,940
eighteen will look to call his

10454
09:39:35,940 --> 09:39:38,340
secretary please call the

10455
09:39:41,609 --> 09:39:44,609
absent members. Allen hi bates.

10456
09:39:47,647 --> 09:39:50,470
Gorgeous dally grove jones

10457
09:39:54,453 --> 09:39:57,453
mcguire hi by morlock merrell

10458
09:39:57,492 --> 09:40:00,492
portantino what is this. Wiener

10459
09:40:01,260 --> 09:40:04,260
ab two eighteen. Return winner

10460
09:40:12,267 --> 09:40:12,774
I. And you know why. Five

10461
09:40:12,774 --> 09:40:15,774
thirty three no zero the

10462
09:40:29,350 --> 09:40:31,350
measure passes. Yeah

10463
09:41:40,817 --> 09:41:42,870
.

10464
09:41:42,870 --> 09:41:44,487
Cardmembers should we were

10465
09:41:44,854 --> 09:41:47,854
taking out file item twenty

10466
09:41:49,297 --> 09:41:51,197
seven. Ab twenty nine sooner or

10467
09:41:51,197 --> 09:41:53,429
later you're ready I'm ready

10468
09:41:53,429 --> 09:41:55,432
Mister Secretary please read.

10469
09:41:55,432 --> 09:41:56,335
Assembly bill twenty nine by

10470
09:41:56,335 --> 09:41:57,998
assembly member holden and

10471
09:41:57,998 --> 09:41:59,435
actually no highways. Early

10472
09:41:59,435 --> 09:42:01,370
this floor is yours thank you

10473
09:42:01,370 --> 09:42:02,802
Mister President members bear

10474
09:42:02,802 --> 09:42:05,307
with me my cold is kicked into

10475
09:42:05,307 --> 09:42:07,750
high gear I rise today to

10476
09:42:07,750 --> 09:42:08,310
present ab twenty nine a bill

10477
09:42:08,310 --> 09:42:09,478
that resolved the problem that

10478
09:42:09,478 --> 09:42:10,981
has been dividing the san

10479
09:42:10,981 --> 09:42:13,248
gabriel valley for far too

10480
09:42:13,248 --> 09:42:15,350
long. The bill really removes

10481
09:42:15,350 --> 09:42:17,516
the most disputed land of the

10482
09:42:17,516 --> 09:42:18,889
s. R. Seven ten from the

10483
09:42:18,889 --> 09:42:21,890
freeway and expressed code

10484
09:42:21,890 --> 09:42:23,570
express we code a line the law

10485
09:42:23,570 --> 09:42:24,692
with the desires of the cities

10486
09:42:24,692 --> 09:42:27,940
and the finalized caltrans iii

10487
09:42:27,940 --> 09:42:30,632
are. For to long the state has

10488
09:42:30,632 --> 09:42:31,195
attempted to determine what the

10489
09:42:31,195 --> 09:42:34,195
local community. Can do with

10490
09:42:35,305 --> 09:42:36,000
this area. I thank you Mister

10491
09:42:36,000 --> 09:42:36,837
President. Since they felt

10492
09:42:36,837 --> 09:42:38,236
ignored local residents took

10493
09:42:38,236 --> 09:42:40,974
the issue to court and a

10494
09:42:40,974 --> 09:42:42,175
decades long battle began. That

10495
09:42:42,175 --> 09:42:43,545
kept this land stagnant for

10496
09:42:43,545 --> 09:42:44,810
years while the rest of the

10497
09:42:44,810 --> 09:42:47,210
community grew and developed

10498
09:42:47,416 --> 09:42:49,312
around it. Last year la metro

10499
09:42:49,312 --> 09:42:51,712
caltrans to clear the-locally

10500
09:42:51,783 --> 09:42:53,818
preferred alternative. To be

10501
09:42:53,818 --> 09:42:55,550
traffic demand management not a

10502
09:42:55,550 --> 09:42:57,254
freeway this is reflected in

10503
09:42:57,254 --> 09:42:58,822
the finalized yeah they are now

10504
09:42:58,822 --> 09:43:00,388
all of the communities that

10505
09:43:00,388 --> 09:43:01,989
used to be at odds are in at

10506
09:43:01,989 --> 09:43:03,190
the table together. Discussing

10507
09:43:03,190 --> 09:43:05,650
how to move forward in a

10508
09:43:05,650 --> 09:43:06,266
unified fashion this is

10509
09:43:06,266 --> 09:43:08,666
something hat was unfathomable

10510
09:43:09,320 --> 09:43:09,999
just one year ago. Ab twenty

10511
09:43:09,999 --> 09:43:11,471
nine will allow them to build

10512
09:43:11,471 --> 09:43:13,471
affordable housing develop

10513
09:43:13,970 --> 09:43:15,605
green spaces create bike lanes

10514
09:43:15,605 --> 09:43:17,806
and dedicated bu routes

10515
09:43:17,806 --> 09:43:19,508
instead of crowded streets. Mix

10516
09:43:19,508 --> 09:43:21,377
to build mixed use spaces for

10517
09:43:21,377 --> 09:43:22,511
retail housing entertainment.

10518
09:43:22,511 --> 09:43:24,377
And whatever else the

10519
09:43:24,377 --> 09:43:25,414
communities decide the author

10520
09:43:25,414 --> 09:43:27,449
has worked closely with the

10521
09:43:27,449 --> 09:43:29,454
local governments caltrans la

10522
09:43:29,454 --> 09:43:31,554
metro. The la county board of

10523
09:43:31,554 --> 09:43:33,254
supervisors cal state la and

10524
09:43:33,254 --> 09:43:35,560
members on this floor to get

10525
09:43:35,560 --> 09:43:36,594
the bill to where it is today.

10526
09:43:36,594 --> 09:43:37,959
He has worked on for three

10527
09:43:37,959 --> 09:43:40,361
years to get to the point where

10528
09:43:40,361 --> 09:43:41,797
there is consensus on the goal

10529
09:43:41,797 --> 09:43:43,895
and no objections to the

10530
09:43:43,895 --> 09:43:45,320
language. Is a straightforward

10531
09:43:45,320 --> 09:43:46,267
bill that would mean a lot to

10532
09:43:46,267 --> 09:43:48,569
the residents of south

10533
09:43:48,569 --> 09:43:50,838
pasadena. And pasadena this

10534
09:43:50,838 --> 09:43:52,172
bill supported by local cities

10535
09:43:52,172 --> 09:43:53,908
also we would like to offer

10536
09:43:53,908 --> 09:43:56,443
thanks to the senators whose

10537
09:43:56,443 --> 09:43:58,175
districts are impacted by sr

10538
09:43:58,175 --> 09:44:01,175
seven ten north. Who engage

10539
09:44:01,948 --> 09:44:02,579
with the author on this issue

10540
09:44:02,579 --> 09:44:06,179
and I respectfully ask for your

10541
09:44:07,884 --> 09:44:08,485
aye vote. Any further

10542
09:44:08,485 --> 09:44:11,485
discussion and debate on this

10543
09:44:11,857 --> 09:44:13,259
item. Hearing insane nine

10544
09:44:13,259 --> 09:44:16,259
secretary please call the roll

10545
09:44:16,365 --> 09:44:19,970
allen hi hi archuleta aren't

10546
09:44:19,970 --> 09:44:22,697
aye atkins aye bates. Bell five

10547
09:44:24,868 --> 09:44:27,868
largest bradford hi I caballero

10548
09:44:34,850 --> 09:44:35,648
hi chain I daly. Dodd I dorado.

10549
09:44:35,648 --> 09:44:38,648
Galgiani glazer. I gonzalez by

10550
09:44:43,955 --> 09:44:46,955
growth. Hertzberg. Hill I by.

10551
09:44:48,190 --> 09:44:52,390
with so I've higher tado. Hi I

10552
09:44:53,428 --> 09:44:56,350
jackson I jones. Leyva hi I'm

10553
09:44:56,350 --> 09:44:58,435
mcguire aye mitchell aye

10554
09:45:01,202 --> 09:45:04,802
monning by more lock no merrell.

10555
09:45:07,140 --> 09:45:10,140
Nielsen no pan aye portantino.

10556
09:45:10,574 --> 09:45:14,174
Roth I'm by rubio aye aye

10557
09:45:15,679 --> 09:45:18,679
skinner aye stern aye stone.

10558
09:45:20,317 --> 09:45:23,917
Number hi iowa caskey by winner.

10559
09:45:29,757 --> 09:45:32,693
Wilk hi hi. Twenty six all eyes%

10560
09:45:32,693 --> 09:45:36,293
nose to the more mode measures

10561
09:45:48,839 --> 09:45:50,839
on call

10562
09:46:43,188 --> 09:46:43,655
. Members are gonna move

10563
09:46:43,655 --> 09:46:46,550
back to motions rather

10564
09:46:47,893 --> 09:46:49,428
resolutions. Manna pro tem

10565
09:46:49,428 --> 09:46:52,134
thank you Mister President I

10566
09:46:52,134 --> 09:46:54,396
rise to submit a letter to the

10567
09:46:54,396 --> 09:46:56,335
journal and this was is in

10568
09:46:56,335 --> 09:46:58,603
respect to sb one and the santa

10569
09:46:58,603 --> 09:47:00,506
clara project in ventura county

10570
09:47:00,506 --> 09:47:04,706
I would ask for. An aye vote.

10571
09:47:04,742 --> 09:47:06,210
Without objection. Thirty to

10572
09:47:06,210 --> 09:47:09,810
call call the roll call thank

10573
09:47:18,624 --> 09:47:21,240
you Mister Secretary. Please.

10574
09:47:23,859 --> 09:47:27,950
Sec please call the worl. Alan.

10575
09:47:27,950 --> 09:47:30,695
Archuleta art by so atkins hi.

10576
09:47:37,571 --> 09:47:39,406
The bass. Bell. By burgess no

10577
09:47:39,406 --> 09:47:42,406
bradford hi hi caballero. I

10578
09:47:48,281 --> 09:47:51,819
chiang. Delhi no dodd hi dorado

10579
09:47:51,819 --> 09:47:54,819
aye galgiani aye glazer aye

10580
09:47:56,725 --> 09:47:59,125
gonzalez by growth. Hertzberg

10581
09:48:01,460 --> 09:48:06,260
hi I hill aye hueso by tado hi

10582
09:48:06,331 --> 09:48:09,331
jackson. I jones. Leyva hi

10583
09:48:12,468 --> 09:48:14,372
mcguire. Hi mitchell by monning

10584
09:48:14,372 --> 09:48:17,372
hi more lock no merrell.

10585
09:48:21,341 --> 09:48:24,341
Nielsen. No pan by portantino.

10586
09:48:26,810 --> 09:48:30,281
Hi ross I rubio. I skinner aye

10587
09:48:31,319 --> 09:48:34,319
stern aye stone. Number our

10588
09:48:36,822 --> 09:48:40,422
cassie I winner. Wilk yeah no

10589
09:48:40,561 --> 09:48:41,163
now I allen aye. Circular

10590
09:48:41,163 --> 09:48:44,163
please call the absent members

10591
09:48:48,690 --> 09:48:51,690
bates. Change growth jones well

10592
09:48:54,844 --> 09:48:58,444
stone wiener. And the call was

10593
09:49:04,214 --> 09:49:04,784
the radio cam. As a-our. Hi

10594
09:49:04,784 --> 09:49:07,784
twenty eight knows five the

10595
09:49:21,310 --> 09:49:23,310
motion carries

10596
09:50:49,443 --> 09:50:51,443
. Members we're

10597
09:50:53,183 --> 09:50:56,149
gonna look the call on item

10598
09:50:56,149 --> 09:50:56,714
twenty seven ab twenty nine

10599
09:50:56,714 --> 09:50:59,114
Mister Secretary please call

10600
09:51:07,391 --> 09:51:09,428
the absent members. File item

10601
09:51:09,428 --> 09:51:12,428
twenty seven ab twenty nine.

10602
09:51:19,905 --> 09:51:22,905
Bates no gorgeous. Daly dorado.

10603
09:51:24,877 --> 09:51:27,877
Galgiani galgiani aye. Or just

10604
09:51:30,150 --> 09:51:32,415
die dorado growth. Hertzberg

10605
09:51:35,540 --> 09:51:37,454
bye bye jones. Morrell.

10606
09:51:44,493 --> 09:51:46,893
Portantino I stone. Wiener.

10607
09:51:49,798 --> 09:51:51,832
Yeah move the call. The ice

10608
09:51:51,832 --> 09:51:54,232
thirty knows three. Motions

10609
09:52:08,450 --> 09:52:10,450
back on call

10610
09:53:38,660 --> 09:53:40,660
. Colleagues we are

10611
09:53:41,426 --> 09:53:45,626
going to take up file item to.

10612
09:53:46,200 --> 09:53:47,402
Excuse me ab. Sb two eighteen

10613
09:53:47,402 --> 09:53:49,802
without reference to file

10614
09:53:50,539 --> 09:53:52,839
senator bradford colleagues ab

10615
09:53:52,839 --> 09:53:55,239
sb two eighteen without

10616
09:54:02,413 --> 09:54:05,413
reference to file. Sb two

10617
09:54:05,781 --> 09:54:07,781
eighteen senator bradford

10618
09:54:08,553 --> 09:54:09,321
resident sb two eighteen is

10619
09:54:09,321 --> 09:54:11,989
back on concurrent with a

10620
09:54:11,989 --> 09:54:14,989
similar excuse me my apologies

10621
09:54:15,595 --> 09:54:16,327
we need to read it first sb two

10622
09:54:16,327 --> 09:54:18,327
eighteen Mister Secretary

10623
09:54:19,132 --> 09:54:19,858
please read the bill to

10624
09:54:19,858 --> 09:54:21,630
eighteen by senator bradford

10625
09:54:21,630 --> 09:54:23,298
enact related discrimination

10626
09:54:23,298 --> 09:54:25,800
senator bradford the floor is

10627
09:54:25,800 --> 09:54:26,698
yours thank you members sb two

10628
09:54:26,698 --> 09:54:29,980
eighteen is back from

10629
09:54:29,170 --> 09:54:30,302
concurrent it deals with fee of

10630
09:54:30,302 --> 09:54:32,730
for one point point in in

10631
09:54:32,730 --> 09:54:34,410
discrimination it narrows the

10632
09:54:34,410 --> 09:54:35,676
bill down to only the county of

10633
09:54:35,676 --> 09:54:39,490
los angeles and it allows local

10634
09:54:39,490 --> 09:54:41,449
jurisdictions. To create their

10635
09:54:42,852 --> 09:54:45,118
own. All seize as it deals with

10636
09:54:45,118 --> 09:54:45,553
op employment and I

10637
09:54:45,553 --> 09:54:47,553
discrimination and I

10638
09:54:47,618 --> 09:54:49,155
respectfully ask for your vote.

10639
09:54:49,155 --> 09:54:49,722
Debate or discussion on this

10640
09:54:49,722 --> 09:54:51,424
item is there any debate or

10641
09:54:51,424 --> 09:54:53,824
discussion. Seeing and hearing

10642
09:54:55,364 --> 09:54:57,364
none. Mister Secretary please

10643
09:54:57,364 --> 09:55:00,364
call the roll allen. Hi

10644
09:55:03,436 --> 09:55:06,436
archuleta. I atkins aye bates.

10645
09:55:07,242 --> 09:55:10,242
Bell I porges. Origins bradford

10646
09:55:14,546 --> 09:55:18,146
hi I caballero. Chiang I daly.

10647
09:55:18,950 --> 09:55:22,550
Dodd I dorado I galgiani I

10648
09:55:23,354 --> 09:55:26,354
glazer I gonzalez by growth.

10649
09:55:30,960 --> 09:55:33,662
Hertzberg I hill. By hueso I

10650
09:55:33,662 --> 09:55:37,862
heard taco hi I jackson hi by

10651
09:55:39,701 --> 09:55:41,903
jones. Leyva hi by mcguire. By

10652
09:55:41,903 --> 09:55:44,903
mitchell by monning hi more

10653
09:55:47,875 --> 09:55:50,875
luck. Morrell. Nielsen aye pan

10654
09:55:53,314 --> 09:55:56,914
aye portantino. I roth by rubio

10655
09:55:58,221 --> 09:56:01,156
I skinner aye stern aye stone.

10656
09:56:01,156 --> 09:56:04,756
Number all right iowa caskey I

10657
09:56:05,289 --> 09:56:08,795
wiener aye wilk we're design hi

10658
09:56:08,795 --> 09:56:12,395
will hi please call the absent

10659
09:56:13,730 --> 09:56:17,330
members words I. Bates zero I

10660
09:56:21,240 --> 09:56:24,240
dally growth. Jones more lock.

10661
09:56:28,948 --> 09:56:31,948
Morrell stone. To call. Recall

10662
09:56:41,890 --> 09:56:43,600
has. Third moves to call. Of

10663
09:56:43,600 --> 09:56:46,600
the vote counted sights thirty

10664
09:57:02,470 --> 09:57:05,647
three no zero. Matters on call

10665
09:57:11,190 --> 09:57:11,585
.

10666
09:57:11,585 --> 09:57:14,585
Colleagues going to lift the

10667
09:57:15,455 --> 09:57:19,550
call on file. Item the twenty

10668
09:57:20,563 --> 09:57:21,161
seven ab. Twenty nine mr sector

10669
09:57:21,161 --> 09:57:24,161
please call the absent members

10670
09:57:27,504 --> 09:57:30,504
dolly. Dorado hi growth. Jones

10671
09:57:43,549 --> 09:57:46,549
rail. Stone wiener wiener what.

10672
09:57:48,852 --> 09:57:49,420
I was three by age thirty two

10673
09:57:49,420 --> 09:57:52,420
knows three measures back on

10674
09:58:05,502 --> 09:58:07,502
call

10675
09:59:19,132 --> 09:59:22,132
. On file live work item

10676
09:59:22,569 --> 09:59:23,136
twenty seven ab. Twenty nine

10677
09:59:23,136 --> 09:59:25,535
Mister Secretary please call

10678
09:59:25,535 --> 09:59:28,535
the absent members. Dally I

10679
09:59:30,676 --> 09:59:33,676
don't know growth jones rail

10680
09:59:39,887 --> 09:59:42,887
stone. I've thirty two notes

10681
09:59:56,265 --> 09:59:58,665
for the measure passes

10682
10:06:58,713 --> 10:07:00,713
. Members

10683
10:07:00,849 --> 10:07:03,818
who were going to take up sb

10684
10:07:03,818 --> 10:07:04,383
seven by senator portantino

10685
10:07:04,383 --> 10:07:05,324
without reference to follow

10686
10:07:05,324 --> 10:07:07,724
center portantino. Ready for

10687
10:07:10,561 --> 10:07:14,161
that measure. Area good food in

10688
10:07:26,642 --> 10:07:28,642
hand

10689
10:07:44,819 --> 10:07:46,819
. Mister Secretary please

10690
10:07:48,910 --> 10:07:50,424
read sb seven senate bill seven

10691
10:07:50,424 --> 10:07:51,300
by senator portantino an act

10692
10:07:51,300 --> 10:07:54,300
relating to state property and

10693
10:07:56,799 --> 10:07:59,199
highways. It's important to

10694
10:08:01,841 --> 10:08:04,106
know when you're ready. Thank

10695
10:08:04,106 --> 10:08:06,506
you Mister President members

10696
10:08:06,507 --> 10:08:07,675
presenting sb seven on

10697
10:08:07,675 --> 10:08:10,750
concurrency members taking the

10698
10:08:10,645 --> 10:08:13,450
assembly make. Many technical

10699
10:08:13,146 --> 10:08:14,881
clarifying changes they also.

10700
10:08:14,881 --> 10:08:15,484
Respect the california

10701
10:08:15,484 --> 10:08:17,160
department of transportation

10702
10:08:17,160 --> 10:08:19,752
for considering a freeway or

10703
10:08:19,752 --> 10:08:21,170
tunnel only after sixty years

10704
10:08:21,170 --> 10:08:22,722
does this bill put a stake in

10705
10:08:22,722 --> 10:08:24,854
the heart of the seven ten

10706
10:08:24,854 --> 10:08:26,250
tomalin my respect goes out to

10707
10:08:26,250 --> 10:08:28,193
some of the folks who are still

10708
10:08:28,193 --> 10:08:30,232
living who started this fight

10709
10:08:30,232 --> 10:08:31,492
sixty years ago. Who made us

10710
10:08:31,492 --> 10:08:33,129
all this happened it also

10711
10:08:33,129 --> 10:08:35,129
restricts caltrans from

10712
10:08:35,632 --> 10:08:37,731
considering a freeway tunnel

10713
10:08:37,731 --> 10:08:39,500
were gap closure hand it

10714
10:08:39,500 --> 10:08:41,304
prohibits the I. R. From being

10715
10:08:41,304 --> 10:08:44,371
used it also greatly helps the

10716
10:08:44,371 --> 10:08:45,240
non profits in the district. To

10717
10:08:45,240 --> 10:08:47,279
buy their properties including

10718
10:08:47,279 --> 10:08:49,440
around mcdonald house and a

10719
10:08:49,440 --> 10:08:51,444
technical garden into schools

10720
10:08:53,251 --> 10:08:53,752
it redefines had as January one

10721
10:08:53,752 --> 10:08:56,152
two thousand twenty four

10722
10:08:56,718 --> 10:08:58,723
portions of the seven ten. Part

10723
10:08:58,723 --> 10:08:59,556
included in the state freeway.

10724
10:08:59,556 --> 10:09:01,956
And most importantly it

10725
10:09:01,990 --> 10:09:03,925
authorizes the california

10726
10:09:03,925 --> 10:09:05,126
transportation commission. To

10727
10:09:05,126 --> 10:09:07,280
relinquish to the city of

10728
10:09:07,280 --> 10:09:08,429
pasadena the stops and that's

10729
10:09:08,429 --> 10:09:10,531
very important because pasadena

10730
10:09:10,531 --> 10:09:12,233
wants to. Deliver the stubs.

10731
10:09:12,233 --> 10:09:14,902
And no other bill no other bill

10732
10:09:14,902 --> 10:09:15,471
has that provision for pasadena

10733
10:09:15,471 --> 10:09:18,471
I respectfully ask for those

10734
10:09:18,939 --> 10:09:19,570
amendments to be concurred. Any

10735
10:09:19,570 --> 10:09:22,442
further discussion or debate on

10736
10:09:22,442 --> 10:09:24,111
this I don't. Hearing and

10737
10:09:24,111 --> 10:09:26,980
seeing on Miss Secretary please

10738
10:09:26,980 --> 10:09:29,980
call the roll allen. Hi

10739
10:09:33,190 --> 10:09:36,190
archuleta I atkins by bates.

10740
10:09:37,456 --> 10:09:39,124
Bill are by burgess. Bradford

10741
10:09:39,124 --> 10:09:42,724
all right I caballero I chiang

10742
10:09:45,629 --> 10:09:49,434
I daly. Dodd hi by dorado aye

10743
10:09:49,434 --> 10:09:51,834
galgiani aye glazer aye

10744
10:09:54,168 --> 10:09:57,168
gonzalez I growth. Hertzberg hi

10745
10:09:57,507 --> 10:10:01,107
hill aye hueso by tado. I

10746
10:10:04,880 --> 10:10:08,480
jackson. Hi by jones. Leyva aye

10747
10:10:09,448 --> 10:10:13,480
aye mcguire hi mitchell hi by

10748
10:10:14,723 --> 10:10:17,392
monning. Hi more lock. Morrell.

10749
10:10:17,392 --> 10:10:20,992
Nielsen aye aye aye pan aye

10750
10:10:21,997 --> 10:10:24,601
portantino aye roth aye rubio

10751
10:10:24,601 --> 10:10:27,601
aye skinner aye stern. Aye

10752
10:10:29,601 --> 10:10:33,801
stone. Number I work out ski I

10753
10:10:35,944 --> 10:10:39,544
wiener. Wilk will guy daly aye.

10754
10:10:42,413 --> 10:10:46,130
Is there. Ice thirty two no

10755
10:10:58,862 --> 10:11:01,862
zero the measures on call

10756
10:30:19,444 --> 10:30:21,444
.

10757
10:30:22,878 --> 10:30:26,478
Members were gonna let the call.

10758
10:30:27,249 --> 10:30:30,849
On file item twenty three ab

10759
10:30:31,119 --> 10:30:34,119
ten sixty six. The secretary

10760
10:30:36,210 --> 10:30:39,210
please call the roll. Caballero

10761
10:30:45,730 --> 10:30:48,730
galgiani. Glazer tado. Pan roth.

10762
10:30:52,369 --> 10:30:55,969
Rubio. Call the roll more time.

10763
10:30:59,344 --> 10:31:01,744
Caballero galgiani. Glazer the

10764
10:31:10,650 --> 10:31:12,390
auto. Pan roth rubio. Collapse

10765
10:31:12,390 --> 10:31:14,790
members one more time.

10766
10:31:21,596 --> 10:31:23,996
Caballero galgiani. Glazer tado.

10767
10:31:31,540 --> 10:31:33,707
Pan roth rubio. The end of the

10768
10:31:33,707 --> 10:31:36,707
call absent members one more

10769
10:31:38,578 --> 10:31:40,978
time calvet zero. Galgiani.

10770
10:31:49,759 --> 10:31:52,759
Glazer tado. Pan roth. Rubio

10771
10:31:58,561 --> 10:32:00,961
number. Nineteen ice nineteen

10772
10:32:02,765 --> 10:32:05,237
knows. Was fourteen the measure

10773
10:32:05,237 --> 10:32:07,637
fails without objection without

10774
10:32:14,613 --> 10:32:16,951
objection. No. The motion to

10775
10:32:16,951 --> 10:32:19,351
reconsider their motion to

10776
10:32:27,624 --> 10:32:30,624
reconsider. Is the first year

10777
10:32:43,437 --> 10:32:45,142
process. For next year yeah. Is

10778
10:32:45,142 --> 10:32:45,507
there objection to thirty two

10779
10:32:45,507 --> 10:32:47,507
members granting

10780
10:32:49,675 --> 10:32:51,649
reconsideration. We say nine

10781
10:32:51,649 --> 10:32:53,649
reconsideration is granite.

10782
10:33:08,628 --> 10:33:12,228
Zero five thirty two no zero

10783
10:35:54,908 --> 10:35:56,373
.

10784
10:35:56,373 --> 10:35:59,973
Members were gonna look to call

10785
10:36:00,247 --> 10:36:03,847
on file item twenty ac a

10786
10:36:04,584 --> 10:36:06,490
fourteen. Mister Secretary

10787
10:36:06,490 --> 10:36:09,490
please call the absent members.

10788
10:36:15,228 --> 10:36:17,628
Allen. Jackson monning. Roth

10789
10:36:20,486 --> 10:36:23,486
rubio. Please call out to

10790
10:36:24,970 --> 10:36:26,970
membership. Gallon jackson

10791
10:36:32,477 --> 10:36:34,278
monning roth rubio. Call the

10792
10:36:34,278 --> 10:36:36,678
absent members over allen.

10793
10:36:49,122 --> 10:36:49,724
Jackson morning roth rubio. I

10794
10:36:49,724 --> 10:36:52,724
three five twenty three twelve

10795
10:36:53,159 --> 10:36:55,559
knows twelve. Major fills.

10796
10:36:57,298 --> 10:36:59,298
Without objection.

10797
10:37:03,172 --> 10:37:03,736
Reconsideration is granted. One

10798
10:37:03,736 --> 10:37:07,336
I is there anyone knows zero

10799
10:37:20,155 --> 10:37:23,155
five thirty one no zero

10800
10:37:32,660 --> 10:37:34,660
.

10801
10:37:34,990 --> 10:37:36,499
members were looking the-call

10802
10:37:50,255 --> 10:37:52,255
on s. B.

10803
10:38:06,392 --> 10:38:07,698
But I reference to

10804
10:38:07,698 --> 10:38:11,132
file we're looking to call in

10805
10:38:11,132 --> 10:38:11,698
sb seven calling absent members

10806
10:38:11,698 --> 10:38:14,980
Mister Secretary please call

10807
10:38:17,868 --> 10:38:20,268
absent members. Bates gorgeous

10808
10:38:24,612 --> 10:38:27,612
growth jones morlock well stone

10809
10:38:34,389 --> 10:38:34,853
wiener. I want we are dry.

10810
10:38:34,853 --> 10:38:37,253
Three three nine zero

10811
10:38:40,250 --> 10:38:40,559
assemblymember. Ice thirty

10812
10:38:40,559 --> 10:38:42,959
three knows three assembly

10813
10:38:44,996 --> 10:38:45,498
member I'm sorry. I'm sorry I

10814
10:38:45,498 --> 10:38:46,640
thirty three no zero the

10815
10:38:46,640 --> 10:38:48,464
assembly member moments are

10816
10:38:54,909 --> 10:38:56,741
concurred in. All. Ccac without

10817
10:38:56,741 --> 10:39:00,341
reference to our looked in a

10818
10:39:01,160 --> 10:39:01,546
call on sb two eighteen ms

10819
10:39:01,546 --> 10:39:03,450
secretary please call the

10820
10:39:03,450 --> 10:39:05,850
absent members bates. Sally

10821
10:39:14,991 --> 10:39:17,600
growth jones lock rail stone.

10822
10:39:17,600 --> 10:39:17,624
Zero five thirty three no zero

10823
10:39:17,624 --> 10:39:20,240
the measure passes assembly

10824
10:39:36,276 --> 10:39:39,276
member talking. All you have

10825
10:39:52,240 --> 10:39:53,328
.

10826
10:39:53,328 --> 10:39:55,529
Members without objection the

10827
10:39:55,529 --> 10:39:58,280
following items will be moved

10828
10:39:58,280 --> 10:40:01,628
to than an active file file

10829
10:40:09,305 --> 10:40:09,872
item thirteen. Fourteen twenty

10830
10:40:09,872 --> 10:40:10,506
one twenty four twenty eight

10831
10:40:10,506 --> 10:40:13,506
thirty six sixteen twenty nine.

10832
10:40:17,680 --> 10:40:18,313
Thirty thirty one. Members

10833
10:40:18,313 --> 10:40:22,513
now the dust is clear Madam Pro

10834
10:40:22,615 --> 10:40:23,718
tem. As President Thank you

10835
10:40:23,718 --> 10:40:26,288
this would be the time were

10836
10:40:26,288 --> 10:40:26,719
typically the republican leader

10837
10:40:26,719 --> 10:40:29,719
and I would have the

10838
10:40:29,919 --> 10:40:31,457
opportunity does it. To express

10839
10:40:31,457 --> 10:40:34,757
our thanks to a number of

10840
10:40:34,757 --> 10:40:38,957
people. Hi it is clearly been a

10841
10:40:38,964 --> 10:40:40,796
unique I day one in which are.

10842
10:40:40,796 --> 10:40:43,470
Members who've been here a long

10843
10:40:43,470 --> 10:40:45,771
time you know that we haven't

10844
10:40:45,771 --> 10:40:47,906
experienced anything like this

10845
10:40:47,906 --> 10:40:50,639
so it's a first I would call it

10846
10:40:50,639 --> 10:40:52,176
an outward bound experience

10847
10:40:52,176 --> 10:40:55,176
with my colleagues only it's

10848
10:40:56,278 --> 10:40:56,878
inward bound this time. I want

10849
10:40:56,878 --> 10:40:59,383
to thank all of you for your

10850
10:40:59,383 --> 10:41:01,383
incredible patience. And

10851
10:41:01,852 --> 10:41:04,852
frankly your civility given the

10852
10:41:07,991 --> 10:41:09,629
circumstances clearly you know.

10853
10:41:09,629 --> 10:41:12,629
It's been a difficult difficult

10854
10:41:12,929 --> 10:41:14,297
week I want to exess our

10855
10:41:14,297 --> 10:41:17,297
thanks on behalf of the

10856
10:41:18,350 --> 10:41:21,350
republican leader and I. To

10857
10:41:22,171 --> 10:41:22,772
five our assistant. Secretary

10858
10:41:22,772 --> 10:41:26,372
of burning and melting and the

10859
10:41:38,987 --> 10:41:40,987
entire staff

10860
10:41:41,821 --> 10:41:44,221
. You needed a new

10861
10:41:46,364 --> 10:41:47,931
experience you now have one. To

10862
10:41:47,931 --> 10:41:50,860
the sergeants at our sergeant

10863
10:41:50,860 --> 10:41:52,333
of arms again what an

10864
10:41:52,333 --> 10:41:54,833
incredible job you've done for

10865
10:41:54,833 --> 10:41:56,499
us for the last several weeks

10866
10:41:56,499 --> 10:41:59,499
more than you typically would

10867
10:41:59,507 --> 10:42:01,537
be expected and have to do. To

10868
10:42:01,537 --> 10:42:02,106
the sergeants and special

10869
10:42:02,106 --> 10:42:05,706
services I need to say thank

10870
10:42:17,540 --> 10:42:20,540
you. Has members. We have

10871
10:42:20,930 --> 10:42:23,930
incredible staff and they are

10872
10:42:23,257 --> 10:42:26,630
still with us if not in this

10873
10:42:26,630 --> 10:42:28,565
chamber there in our offices

10874
10:42:28,565 --> 10:42:29,833
watching and waiting to make

10875
10:42:29,833 --> 10:42:33,305
sure they can help us finish

10876
10:42:33,305 --> 10:42:35,805
up. Appropriately as we end our

10877
10:42:35,805 --> 10:42:37,173
legislative year so we want to

10878
10:42:37,173 --> 10:42:40,151
say thank you to all of the

10879
10:42:40,151 --> 10:42:43,751
staff and the work that you

10880
10:42:52,685 --> 10:42:55,286
have done this year. Thank you.

10881
10:42:55,286 --> 10:42:58,192
And of course size thank you.

10882
10:42:58,192 --> 10:43:00,592
Madam Secretary the legislative

10883
10:43:01,996 --> 10:43:02,794
data center ldc five who are

10884
10:43:02,794 --> 10:43:05,194
obviously we couldn't do

10885
10:43:06,936 --> 10:43:07,832
anything without their work

10886
10:43:07,832 --> 10:43:09,834
their behind the scenes but

10887
10:43:09,834 --> 10:43:12,360
clearly in front of us all the

10888
10:43:12,360 --> 10:43:13,170
time as we do the work and

10889
10:43:13,170 --> 10:43:14,705
certainly let me send out

10890
10:43:14,705 --> 10:43:17,105
thanks to our legislative

10891
10:43:18,408 --> 10:43:19,743
counsel who I had written in

10892
10:43:19,743 --> 10:43:23,282
some notes how many pieces of

10893
10:43:23,282 --> 10:43:26,118
legislation. They have had to

10894
10:43:26,118 --> 10:43:27,751
take into account for us more

10895
10:43:27,751 --> 10:43:29,319
than two thousand I think if I

10896
10:43:29,319 --> 10:43:31,221
remember correctly we want to

10897
10:43:31,221 --> 10:43:34,457
send thanks to them and with

10898
10:43:34,457 --> 10:43:36,993
that colleagues I hope you make

10899
10:43:36,993 --> 10:43:38,228
it home and appreciate this

10900
10:43:38,228 --> 10:43:40,129
hard year that you've had

10901
10:43:40,129 --> 10:43:42,265
because regardless we have

10902
10:43:42,265 --> 10:43:43,501
accomplished a great deal here

10903
10:43:43,501 --> 10:43:45,935
for our residents for the

10904
10:43:45,935 --> 10:43:48,370
constituents. And so safe

10905
10:43:48,370 --> 10:43:50,437
travels home enjoy your

10906
10:43:51,435 --> 10:43:53,835
communities your families and

10907
10:43:55,108 --> 10:43:58,708
we will see you in January.

10908
10:44:01,717 --> 10:44:04,160
Mister President. Members we

10909
10:44:04,160 --> 10:44:08,216
are a turn for the two thousand

10910
10:44:20,533 --> 10:44:22,933
and nineteen legislative year