[0:03] >> I'd like to call to order the parks and environmental committee meeting. [0:07] mr. Wilson, could you please call the roll? [0:10] >> councilman ford. >> present. [0:12] >> chair warren. >> present. [0:14] I think we have two meeting agenda items this morning. [0:17] the first one is going to be an overview for the council members to, I suppose, watch at their leisure [0:24] later today about what's going on in overton park and how things are working. [0:29] matt, I think we probably had you sort of spearheading this. [0:33] would you come up, grab a seat at the table, and as people come up to do whatever presentations y'all have today, [0:41] just come on up and sit at the table too. [0:44] tina, good to see you guys. [0:45] just name and address and organization for the record. [0:49] and I guess, mr. Walker, do you have anything you want to say starting off? [0:54] go right ahead, sir. [0:55] >> nick walker, parks director, city of memphis, 2599 avery avenue. [0:59] yeah, no, this was -- first of all I want to thank dr. Warren for asking for this presentation to come forward. [1:06] as both the chairman of the parks committee and [1:10] as an advocate for all of our [1:16] park x and it gives us an opportunity to highlight [1:19] successes as it [1:25] relates to manage properties and partnerships and it is a [1:30] wonderful example and probably one of the more complex examples of this [1:34] and not just in the region [1:43] but nationwide examples where you have multiple nonprofit entities [1:46] and city run facilities inside the property like overton [1:51] park. Like you, am interested to hear this and because of [1:56] our relationship it oversees the management agreement or in the [2:01] case of the metal museum the ground lease for the property [2:06] and, again, we do still operate the golf course that sits on the [2:13] property. I to hear a lot of this. I am excited [2:15] to hear updates from partners. With that I will turn [2:19] it over to matt thompson. [2:22] >> I want to thank you for calling everybody [2:26] and talking to them and thank you for organizing this. But go [2:30] ahead. [2:30] >> good morning, everyone. [2:34] I have a prepared statement that I would [2:40] like to --I have a prepared statement because [2:43] I want to encapsulate [3:04] -- and the golf course. Each of these [3:25] entities brings a unique experience, opportunities to our residents and [3:28] visitors creating a cultural recreation hub in our collective efforts [3:34] have been focused on fostering a spirit of collaboration [3:37] and unity. We do recognize the strength of this lies in our ability to work [3:40] together to support one another [3:45] and create an enriching experience for all who visit. Others [3:49] will elaborate on our joint successes. [3:56] but the aim is to make sure that overton park remains a [4:02] cherished and driving part of memphis and the amenities [4:05] are more [4:09] than just attractions but vital to the cultural and economic health of our [4:11] city and provide education [4:17] opportunities, promote physical and mental well-being and [4:19] offer space for community engagement. [4:20] as we look to the future, we look at enhancing this [4:23] and continue to [4:31] evolve the park to meet the needs of our community and [4:33] I would like to extend my gratitude for all of the entities that make it such [4:35] a special place and are shared commitment to excellence [4:40] and passion for serving the community are what drive us [4:42] forward so it is with pleasure that I introduce tina sullivan the [4:46] executive director of the conservancy who will [4:49] share more about our efforts and the exciting [4:53] future ahead for overton park. [4:56] >> [ inaudible - low volume ] [4:58] >> you have [5:02] to hit that input closer. [5:08] >> thank you for this opportunity and thank you for the [5:14] wonderful context. If you are walking across big river crossing [5:20] and you get to that point where you have 1 [5:22] foot in arkansas and one in tennessee, that is not overton [5:26] park. [5:27] you could travel from the zoo to the playground to the shell and not really [5:29] distinguish between these entities managed by [5:34] different nonprofit organizations. [5:35] the partners in overton [5:39] park lane into that and we operate under a shared [5:42] programmatic premise that we call the one [5:45] park vision and we do know that when you move through [5:50] the park, you're looking for your experience to [5:53] be seamless. We have been collaborating on ways [5:56] to make that park visitor experience feel [5:59] seamless and positive in every direction. Under this one [6:04] park vision, we have had a strong collaborative [6:07] approach that takes into account how we operate collaboratively and support [6:11] each other through operations, efficiency, and [6:14] security and how we develop and implement joint programming offerings, which [6:17] you will see as the [6:23] recent summer camp with the art garden and how [6:27] we could lift each other up through marketing efforts sharing social media [6:29] platforms and highlighting and celebrating [6:34] the respective events and functions, and then also how [6:38] we might greet you as a governing body together and seek [6:41] your help in furthering the [6:46] mission of overton park and her partners within it. What we [6:50] want to see is a unified vision for all of [6:53] our partners are enriching the visitor experience for [6:56] everybody who walks into one of our spaces. So now we [7:02] will ask some of our partners here to share [7:05] a little bit of detail and if I might introduce [7:08] natalie wilson and she manages the shell at overton park [7:14] and talk about some of the public safety [7:18] and security. [7:20] >> let the record [7:23] show that. [7:25] >> good morning. >> good morning. [7:30] natalie wilson, 1928 poplar avenue. [7:32] am thrilled to be here. [7:35] just as they spoke about, we are honored to be a part [7:38] of one [7:44] park. This is safe and positive, cohesive. It is logistically sound. [7:50] there are so many pieces to making sure of that. And one [7:56] of those --key pieces is what we call the park [8:09] patrol and we came together a year ago this month actually [8:14] in a mou with the memphis police department on the shelby [8:20] county's police apartment and the tennessee bureau of investigation [8:23] and homeland security who came together in support to us to say we [8:29] believe in the care of overton park and the visitors who [8:32] come here and we will come together every month [8:38] to understand --this but they also feel that it [8:53] is engaging and how the law enforcement agencies are working and [8:54] learning and meeting the families. [8:56] it is been incredible. [9:02] that is one piece to this one park vision and it's working [9:05] which we see the reducing of experiences in the park that could [9:07] be negative and we have more proactive safety and strategies in place that we share [9:10] with our programming. It is wonderful. [9:12] for me being the overton park shall we bring thousands [9:17] and for concerts. I can tell you that I see the work that a [9:24] family saying that I haven't been to a show in a [9:30] while but I feel more comfortable to come and I park and come in and [9:33] I see the safety precautions put in place in the appreciate it. [9:34] >> can you describe a little bit about [9:36] what protocols you are talking about and what has been done? [9:39] >> absolutely. Instances such as the perimeter in the park in the streets [9:42] and neighborhoods and the parking lot. We don't have a parking lot. [9:45] most of them park street side. We do have [9:48] patrols on the trails and in the park [9:52] and making sure the parking lots are safe and [9:58] walking on patrols, biking patrols and it is incredible. [10:03] every month, they are -- I can't say enough [10:07] about what the police are doing and the leadership of [10:15] colonel jackson. They are taking pride in the experience and it [10:17] is everybody's park but if we all don't come together and make [10:19] sure we expect that experience it isn't [10:25] guaranteed. So, yes, I can't stay enough but the strategies we continue [10:30] having enough every month. [10:31] >> that is with every group here [10:34] met individually? I guess the other question is, whether extra security [10:39] people hired for events and [10:46] things like that? If so, how much is that costing? [10:47] >> that is a good question. I could [10:50] speak for the shelf and I will let my partners talk about [10:52] other areas. For us we have a private entity that [10:55] comes in alongside the park patrol who are on the perimeter and [11:00] we have ramped up both security entities that are [11:03] in uniform but also in plain close to make sure [11:09] there is care around the [11:13] perimeter of this and inside but also looking at roof lines and [11:16] making sure all of the concerts from the backstage to front of house and [11:18] everywhere that people are and children [11:24] are running that people feel safe and we are proactive [11:27] but the cost of that for the shell is roughly $5000 a concert [11:30] for our security. [11:33] >> interesting. >> what about the zoo and what have they [11:36] been doing for [11:37] security? [11:38] >> we do a lot for security and we do [11:45] appreciate your asking. If you do remember, unfortunate events with [11:51] shooting that happened, we heard directly from our [11:57] members that -- a lot of them live in the [11:58] suburbs that they didn't want to come back [12:02] into town. We did see a significant reduction in [12:05] our attendance. So we have really worked on ramping [12:09] up security and trying to create a safe space [12:15] along with our park partners. As you know, parking is [12:17] limited at the zoo. When the lot is full, they extend [12:21] into the lot and if they don't feel safe, they won't [12:24] come. The short answer is two years ago we were spending about [12:29] $40,000 annually on security. And that is [12:33] off duty npd officers and [12:37] then at the close of this fiscal year we have [12:42] had spent $270,000 on security. I [12:47] will say, it is a tremendous increase and we hope it doesn't [12:51] last forever. But we do survey guests weekly and have heard directly [12:57] from them that they do feel safe at the zoo [13:00] and at the park and they see the patrols come through which is the [13:03] city and county as a [13:09] result of us working with them. [13:10] anyway, significant resources, but it is [13:14] working. [13:15] >> tina then zoe. [13:21] >> we mainly limit our private security operation to [13:23] special events in the park where we may have a critical mass of people [13:27] attending the festival and we need to [13:30] manage traffic and public safety generally. That is a few times [13:39] per year. Under $10,000. We have invested also in [13:40] park ranger staff. We believe that having that positive visible presence [13:45] in the park on the weekends when the park's busiest is [13:50] an impact and we also hear feedback from visitors [13:54] that that staffing presents makes people [13:58] feel safe and somebody is watching and taking care and maintaining the [14:03] space which creates a more positive experience. And then between that [14:05] and coordinating with the police and the sheriff's department, the two-way [14:06] munication between them and [14:10] our park partners has been helpful getting a heads up when something [14:15] is happening and it allows us to prepare and communicate. And with that I will [14:21] introduce zoe from the brooks museum. [14:22] >> thank you, [14:26] tina and thank you for inviting us and it is wonderful to be a part of [14:29] this park partnership and talk about the work we do together. My name is [14:32] zoe the executive director of the museum of [14:37] art and just to talk about security for a second before we talk about [14:41] other things, as a museum, security is a huge part of what [14:45] we do any significant portion of our operating budget. We also proactively [14:53] go out and walk around so we have eyes on things, but we also have been [14:56] really happy with the work we have been doing as a park [15:01] partnership with mpd and the sheriff's office. We do see them [15:04] in the park and we could see the [15:08] impact of their presence in terms of break-ins and activity. And then to [15:10] answer your question, we also bring in [15:16] extra security anytime we have a large-scale event. Etiquette [15:20] to talk about a fun thing, which is we all love working together. We proactively [15:25] look for opportunities to find connections [15:26] between our programming and build connections between art and nature, [15:31] animals, zoology, music and there is so much to [15:37] do together. It is something we have really enjoyed. Part of the benefit [15:40] of the regular meetings both to the [15:47] security team and we work closely together on programming and actively [15:49] look for ways that we connect anything the museum [15:54] is doing to what other partners are doing and vice versa and that has [15:58] been powerful as we have cross pollinated audiences [16:02] and built stronger I think the more people come the more they feel comfortable [16:04] in a setting and the more they understand [16:08] the park is theirs and that is what we are trying to do together. And if [16:11] you keep clicking through, these are images of recent projects we have [16:15] done together and one that we were really proud of as [16:19] we cohosted karaoke along with opc and the symphony and that [16:22] was a really fun festive [16:28] holiday evening. And if we click through again, and [16:33] just a few other images of recent things and maybe you can [16:37] see in the last slide to talk about the ultimate collaboration [16:39] which is this summer we were pleased to [16:42] work together on a summer camp and we partnered with [16:46] the art garden and we each took turns providing [16:51] an amazing in experience for a group of kids so this is a [16:53] pilot program and we also funded that this year and [16:58] really devoted a significant amount of materials and staff time [17:02] to it. But a wonderful collaboration with [17:05] the carpenter art garden. [17:07] >> this was a weeklong [17:08] camp? [17:09] >> right. >> what they did is they went and they went to [17:16] each program after they were bussed over [17:25] one day a week so one day was the zoo and one day was at the [17:27] brooks and one day I think and you can explain it better but that is the general idea? [17:29] >> we each took [17:37] turns taking this group and providing a [17:38] different experience so they all get a slice of the amazing opportunities that [17:42] are available in the park. [17:43] >> with the record show that [17:46] councilman green is present. [17:49] >> any questions? [17:52] >> I do want to chime in. [17:54] the one thing, unfortunately, the gulf manager is currently at the course [18:01] working but, patrick [18:06] is just as much a part of this programming is the partner [18:09] sure ships -- partnerships created through [18:16] the nature --of the kids that [18:34] come through the 25 summer camp programs and have them participate [18:37] in things at the brooks, the zoo and to participate in programming [18:42] taking place last summer. We had one of the family fun friday [18:46] events at overton park and had the closing ceremonies [18:49] at the shell. It is a wonderful opportunity [18:52] for us to always [18:56] remember, although this is not one of the 162 parks that [19:01] they operate, but the resources are available to [19:04] us every day. [19:10] not only are they available, but I do get phone calls from all [19:12] of these participants saying, how can we participate in the programming? [19:14] or extend or provide opportunities that you normally wouldn't have? So [19:16] we are appreciative of that. [19:19] >> let the record show that [19:25] chairwoman walker and white [19:31] are present. Is that the last speaker? [19:40] yes?'s -- we asked [19:52] to come back and give us specifically for those organizations [19:55] a vacancy with the problems are. [20:01] >> as we are working together in a [20:07] wonderful way as we have talked safety and [20:11] security and serving tens of thousands of [20:14] schoolchildren annually, we came up with three things for your consideration. [20:16] and this is in terms of support for us [20:19] collectively within the park. That is [20:25] just support for summer camp 2025. We do love what we do for [20:28] the children and how they make stops at all [20:34] of the amenities in the park and we would [20:40] love consideration for that, support for security technology. The [20:41] memphis police department has requested we install flock cameras that feed [20:45] directly into the npd system and the more we have around the city the better [20:47] that they can [20:51] serve us. They have suggested that we do that and [20:56] they aren't free. [21:02] we would love that support and finally for security [21:05] in general. It is expensive and we all do pay for [21:12] it individually. And we do want, as I said earlier, when people come to [21:14] the zoo, they may be coming to the [21:22] zoo and we are a big draw, but overflows are in [21:24] the park and they go eat lunch there. [21:26] they go to events afterwards. [21:27] they want to know that they are safe. [21:29] again, we have seen people safe --say they feel safe because [21:32] of the increased security. We are getting [21:35] this, but [21:39] encouragement and in shelby county to continue to [21:43] support us as a matter of security. Thank you. [21:47] >> thank you all for coming so bright and early and really impressed [21:52] that there are people who got here this morning. [21:54] thank you, councilmembers. Any questions for [21:58] these guys? I think we have one more item on [22:02] our agenda. Thank you. We appreciate it. [22:04] >> as they are wrapping up, I do [22:08] want to just say, memphis parks overseas 13 [22:16] things and 10 leases and one quarter of those agreements are inside this [22:19] park and soon to be two of those 10 leases are inside of [22:23] that park. They do vary about the level of engagement [22:30] across the board and we talked about this and the fruitfulness of those agreements. [22:32] so as a point of personal privilege I would like to [22:34] say that every single person sitting behind [22:38] me here has reached out multiple times [22:42] and more so than the contract demands and they have gone out of their way to [22:44] make sure that the partnership is strong and I would [22:47] like to again take [22:51] a second to say thank you to each and every one of them for their partnership, [22:53] friendship, and support. [22:56] >> thank you. [22:59] >> item number two is a question about the future [23:05] of the mud island park. Mr. Walker, I will turn that [23:10] over to you and this is requested by councilwoman [23:14] swearengen-washington . Do you have any [23:16] questions before you start? [23:17] >> thank you, chair. I would like to [23:20] share some pictures that I had taken on [23:26] a park visit on july 8. It is on the screen at [23:35] this time. [23:44] and the amphitheater still has [23:50] the seat numbers in there. I was really surprised at how beautiful the [23:56] park is. Beautiful. And as I was walking through [24:00] the park, I saw some people from out of [24:05] town and they stopped me and said what is going [24:08] on and what happened? And I said I don't [24:11] know but we are going to find out and we are [24:14] on top of it. [24:17] it is absolutely beautiful and that is the [24:20] pool area. I was surprised that the water was clean. [24:29] and there is a [24:35] thought that the park is abandoned. It really is a [24:38] beautiful park. Am hoping we can utilize it [24:41] more and be intentional, mr. Walker, with planning [24:44] activities, whether it be yoga or many concerts [24:52] or something, but some of the activities that we are having at other parks [24:53] if we could start with that [24:59] or planning some activities over there so [25:05] people will migrate over there and enjoy the park. [25:08] some of the areas it seems as if needed some [25:17] power washing. [25:28] it really was a beautiful experience , and I just wanted to share some [25:32] of the pictures. [25:38] and I also would like us is a counsel to go over there. [25:43] it is something you really just have to see [25:47] to believe. How beautiful it is. Okay. I yield the floor. [25:53] >> mr. [25:54] walker, go ahead. [25:55] >> I will be incredibly brief. [26:02] we had this conversation when councilwoman swearengen-washington [26:05] reached out to have a conversation, and truthfully, historically, [26:08] the connection between memphis parks [26:14] and the riverfront development corporation has varied [26:20] throughout administrations. The way that the [26:21] management agreement as written is that essentially the city appoints [26:23] a representative to interact [26:29] , and under the previous administration, that was not the parks director. [26:32] we have had conversations, and I believe in conversation [26:35] with counsel, they have been pretty clear that the [26:38] relationship between memphis parks and memphis river parks [26:41] partnership needs to strengthen. We have begun that work [26:47] with conversations we had about making sure that there is a more [26:50] regular cadence of participation on all of those things that I think truly [26:53] are a great idea. I'm glad we are having this phone right now. [26:59] at the end of the day, similar to the presentation that you just [27:02] saw from that conservancy , they are in this park every day. [27:08] and so in fairness to them, I think that [27:10] my goal was to get some feedback this morning from counsel and [27:14] then put on the council agenda in two weeks [27:19] a presentation from memphis river parks partnership to talk about [27:23] the vision , what is being done, what is being [27:26] done today, what will be done in the future, and what it will look like. [27:32] I don't have a whole lot to add this morning. [27:35] I appreciate the pictures and sort of the direction of where we would [27:38] like this conversation to go. [27:40] >> thank you, [27:41] mr. Walker. [27:43] I think the council, recently, we just placed [27:47] mrp p under parks jurisdiction. [27:50] can you explain how that and if it's us [27:53] as a parks department and national grants and things along that line , what [27:59] that does for us as a city? And then I [28:01] will take questions. [28:02] >> probably the quickest [28:06] way to describe it is particularly outdoors constituents [28:09] have talked to you about a study that is [28:15] done annually. It is called the 10 minute walking plan. [28:19] and there's actually two of them. [28:24] the parks court is sort of the number assigned to every municipality [28:27] in every jurisdiction that has a parks system. [28:33] parks traditionally has not been great. Part of that is we are [28:36] 300 square miles, and it is difficult to [28:39] have density of parks. [28:43] the important thing about it is that one of the things that [28:47] is factored into it is what your municipality spends on [28:50] the parks. And again, at the end of the day , the city is spending [28:57] $3 million on parks, but it is counted as a grant underneath the [29:00] mayor's office and not listed as a part of [29:03] the parks budget. [29:05] so by simply doing an accounting change to [29:09] reflect that, what we have done has shown [29:13] to funders and statewide entities and outside entities that the [29:18] parks budget looks more like what the parks budget actually is. [29:21] >> increasing our score does what forest? [29:27] >> anybody that has applied for a grant, there's [29:30] a narrative that goes along with that. [29:36] a nonprofit, whatever, should give us some money. [29:39] and one of those is to show the improvements that you [29:42] are making in terms of things like those scores. And so [29:48] by increasing our scores, and by increasing to accurately [29:51] represent what we spend on the parks, we are telling [29:56] other people that we value ourselves, and [29:58] they should in turn value us as well. [30:00] >> thank you. [30:01] let the record show that councilman logan is here . We [30:04] have two people in queue. The floor is yours. [30:09] >> thank you, chair. [30:11] good morning. Thank you councilwoman swearengen-washington for bringing [30:15] this up . We visit over there with that beautiful restaurant, mahogany, [30:18] that is over there. And the food is [30:24] absolutely delicious. [30:27] thank you for the pictures of your analyst. I walked over there [30:30] about a month or so ago, and I concur with everything [30:36] that councilwoman swearengen-washington has set as well. [30:42] but I want to clear up a myth. I don't know if it's [30:45] a myth, but I don't like to hear things and I don't have [30:48] a clear understanding. It's something about $4 [30:50] million that is floating around that was supposed to have been [30:54] given to m rrp or whatever to do something with. [30:59] can you explain that, if that's true or if that [31:02] isn't true? Was the city of memphis given any money? Was [31:05] this part of a package? Can you just kind of clear that up [31:08] so we can get a clear address handing , and [31:14] as my colleague has said, if we are going to invest or start something, [31:16] let's clear something up about these $4 million so I can get a [31:21] clear understanding . I need to understand that. [31:24] >> is a great question. [31:30] I will give just a general answer, and I will [31:33] rely on my friends from the finance office and the cro's office [31:36] to get more detail, and that I will make sure that a further [31:39] explanation is given in the explanation in two weeks. [31:45] as a part of accelerate memphis, there were $4 million identified for various project [31:50] at mud island. A lot of it had to do with lighting [31:54] and repairs, because a big focus of accelerate maintenance was deferred maintenance. [32:03] we can get for you a specific breakdown of what that is. The notes [32:06] I received from them to be able to answer some of these questions [32:09] --one of the last two improvement project that [32:11] was a part of that is the removing of the memphis belle structure [32:14] and improvements to the watershed walls , which are being paid for out of [32:20] those funds. I think that where confusion lies is that the [32:24] city council has set aside --I want to say it was $3 million [32:27] --for improvements to be made to mud island. [32:33] there was a pullback of some of that money in fy '23 [32:38] , and then the remainder of it was reallocated to [32:45] memphis fire and memphis parks in fy '24 . [32:53] and so there are two separate things. [32:54] they were given $4 million as a part of accelerate memphis. [32:57] I'm sure they will be happy to share with you what repairs were made to mud [33:00] island as a part of that, and again, there was $3 [33:05] million originally allocated for memphis parks that was [33:08] then reallocated to other projects through counsel action [33:12] --prior counsel action. [33:18] >> so were those repairs [33:23] made? I need to know if there's repairs were made. [33:28] thank you. [33:31] I see him. [33:36] >> I sensed it. >> I see him coming. Thank you. [33:40] always ready. That's what I love about you. [33:41] >> antonio adams, chief operating officer and -- [33:42] >> art davis, [33:48] chief operating officer for memphis parks. [33:49] >> is a part [33:55] of the overall accelerated office package, $4 million [33:57] was allocated to this writer parks. [33:58] part of these projects, [34:03] they were delineated out at all levels. [34:07] they talk about the packages and the projects that [34:10] were identified, and either under [34:14] contract, has been completed, or in progress right now. [34:21] >> so our city entered into a contract -- [34:34] direction on the projects. [34:37] we have contracted to all [34:43] but one of those projects. [34:46] it is the watershed repair. [34:48] and all others have been contracted. [34:49] all of them have been completed, except [34:52] for the belle structure and the repaving of [34:55] the parking lot that we are in the process of doing now. I [34:58] have a list of those. They include [35:03] the north courtyard pavers, parking lot, restaurant, pole light, signage, golf, [35:10] roof pavers, escalators, elevators. There [35:13] was an amount for river terrace. And belle [35:19] structure demo , wi-fi, and some work in [35:24] the museum and transfer of assets. [35:28] >> so all the work has been completed except for the belle structure? [35:37] >> and the repayment of the parking lot once that structure [35:40] is gone. Additional parking will be available across the mahogany [35:46] and the video installation that is happening. [35:49] >> okay. [35:51] I would like it in full detail to see what [35:55] it's look like. After this, I would like a tour of everything [35:58] you said that has been done. My colleagues said [36:01] that the bathrooms were locked. [36:04] >> we would have to check on that. [36:10] >> we would like to know why they are locked and would love to [36:13] know what the inside of those restrooms looks like. [36:14] >> absolutely. >> to yield the floor. Thank you. [36:19] >> thank you. Councilwoman swearengen-washington. [36:22] >> what is going on with the museum area? [36:25] >> last week, there was a fire sprinkler [36:30] head system --sprinkler head that was activated. [36:34] so there was a lot of water that was lost during that period so there was [36:40] prior damage. We had to go in, remove a lot of the [36:43] sheet rock on the second floor that [36:48] went down to the first floor, so the remediation of that [36:52] is being worked on at this point. [36:58] >> what is the plan in this area? [36:59] >> right now, general services is going to come over along [37:03] with contractors to mitigate the damage , and in the course, we will have [37:07] contractors move in. [37:13] we have a plan to bring appropriations to you this week. [37:18] we were just a little too late to get in. [37:22] we want to get on the next council's agenda [37:27] , moving with restoration. Because they do have a down [37:31] effect on the chillers as well. [37:34] you be able to repair the lines, and have some repairs as well. [37:40] it will be coming out of their cover line. [37:46] >> is that a plan ? [37:52] >> there is a lease, which is [37:58] an interactive experience. [38:00] they were to be open by the end of the year. [38:04] it may be the first of january. It's an immersive experience [38:10] that christopher wray is building , so we do have a lease on [38:15] that space. [38:16] >> thank you, councilwoman. [38:18] councilwoman walker. [38:20] >> thank you, mr. Chair. Okay. [38:25] thank you, mr. [38:28] chair. Good morning, everyone, and thank [38:29] you so much, councilwoman swearengen-washington for this . I have [38:34] some comments, and then I had a question . [38:43] so I don't know how many of you all are maxwell fans, but I have [38:46] been a big maxwell fan for years. [38:48] and the first time I saw maxwell, and I think the [38:52] first time I attended a concert at mud island was to see maxwell, [38:58] and the opening act was those two young ladies who had [39:01] little duet thing going. [39:04] but I just wanted to --I wanted you all to know that. I wanted to share [39:06] that. [39:07] >> thank you, councilwoman. [39:09] >> I have a lot of great memories at mud island [39:16] over the years, and even up to recent times. [39:18] when people say that individuals are being nostalgic [39:22] back in the day, in recent years, [39:27] I have attended lionel river, produced by dr. Phil boutin. [39:30] cgi entertainment, curtis gibbons. [39:34] tonya dyson , she is a local vocalist, producer, and [39:41] executive entertainer of the memphis collaborative over and souls bill. [39:46] when deja vu was at the river terrace, I celebrated my [39:48] birth day there, and I believe it was on a wednesday day and they were [39:51] already having jazz going on. And I do have pictures. [39:56] the mahogany river terrace --and so [40:02] I was part of a luncheon with the ladies several [40:05] months back , and attorney mccullough has done [40:08] an incredible job with the redesign. It is absolutely beautiful [40:14] . And in taking the tours many times that I have been [40:16] over there, I didn't know they had a rooftop. We [40:23] had to experience that as well. [40:26] I guess that said, with my comments and my question [40:29] is about the monorail. Have you all specifically [40:32] spoken to the monorail today? There [40:37] was a survey in the paper several years ago [40:41] about how people felt about the monorail, [40:45] and people said they didn't like being up in the air over [40:48] the water . But simultaneously, a lot of people do like the monorail, [40:50] and that was part of why [40:55] they liked it. The most recent thing I [40:59] found was in 2022, a few of our outlets reported with [41:02] the counselor given five -- $5.5 million specifically to the monorail. [41:08] can someone comment on the status of the monorail? [41:10] >> let me help you with [41:14] that, councilwoman. [41:16] the monorail is 1960s technology, and it is a [41:19] lot like --I have a lot of antique cars. [41:20] it is hard to find the parts. They don't [41:23] run on a regular basis. [41:38] because they look nice. [41:43] and the issue is, we have looked at this and [41:45] gone into detail about, what would it take to do that? It is way more [41:48] expensive to do it and that to keep it going [41:52] then we possibly could based on the technology. [41:56] if we wanted to take that thing down and [41:59] try to find a new technology that my work there, that might be something. [42:02] but using that whole technology would not [42:03] work. At least that is what we have been told [42:07] with the research that has been done. [42:08] but the record show that councilwoman easter-thomas [42:11] is also here. Do you have another question? [42:17] >> thank you , but I'm not done. [42:20] I think you for that. So what happened to the [42:25] $5 million, and do any of you want to comment on [42:29] the monorail? [42:34] >> I may be conflating the two, but I believe [42:38] that was tied up with the money that was reallocated. [42:41] I believe any funding that was set aside [42:43] for buddies, more work to be done on the monorail was reallocated [42:47] by council for other projects. [42:50] >> I concur with that recollection as well. [42:55] >> thank you for that. One moment, mr. Chair. [42:58] somebody might have been sending me something. [43:05] >> councilman jones is here. [43:08] >> so [43:14] --so in my notes here -- [43:20] so in my notes here, there were two different [43:23] allocations, 4 million from innovate memphis . Accelerate memphis. [43:29] and then that was separate from that. [43:32] >> the subsequent --so subsequent to accelerate [43:38] , the chair at the time did desire [43:44] to upgrade and identify upgrades to the monorail. Subsequent councilmembers [43:50] did reallocate those funds to other projects. So the [43:56] funds no longer existed as you identify. So the original intent, you [44:01] are correct . But the reallocations were made to [44:05] the project. [44:08] >> thank you for that. So the reallocation is being [44:11] made to other project. So if a plan was [44:13] requested --if a plan was requested, was there never a plan submitted, [44:19] and that's why the funds were reallocated? [44:26] >> a plan was requested, then the body decided [44:29] to go a different direction. And then the funds [44:31] were reallocated to different areas . [44:34] so that is why no plan was submitted. [44:38] >> to the body need permission to go in another direction? Are they [44:41] just took it upon themselves -- [44:44] >> you all are [44:49] the funding body. So until the funds are in our hands, we have no way [44:53] to act. So without funds, we can act. And so the body [45:01] decided to go in a different direction. [45:02] >> I'm not trying to beat a dead horse here, but it seems like [45:05] there would supposed to have been a plan for these [45:08] funds, and the plan never happened. So the funds [45:11] were reallocated . [45:14] >> the council voted -- [45:26] beneficial and [45:31] cost display too much, and so we did not do it. And we [45:35] reallocated those funds. [45:38] >> to yield the floor and I need to get [45:41] back to you. [45:42] thank you. [45:43] >> the floors councilwoman logan. [45:46] >> thank you, chair. [45:50] bringing this forward. Today's discussion -- [45:56] what I would like to ask , I am really [46:00] interested in seeing administrations comprehensive plan for [46:05] the riverfront an entire riverfront, riverside . [46:11] we have been focusing a lot on what is going on [46:18] with memphis river parks partnership, and rightly so. [46:25] but I can understand how the money got reallocated, because I'm not sure [46:27] if we needed to give that responsibility [46:30] to a nonprofit or another entity. [46:38] that is something that we need to come up with, in [46:42] my opinion, as an administration , council, however. [46:48] what do we want the riverfront to look like? What do we wanted to do? [46:51] what we wanted to be for the city of memphis [46:54] and the citizens? [46:58] what is that cost, and how long will it take? That type [47:02] of thing. We will continue to piecemeal all the [47:04] way down the riverfront, and people come in, they have come in [47:09] with the zip line part --somebody came in and did a [47:12] presentation on that. And right now, it looks like the river [47:15] parks partnership has done a remarkable job with that area that [47:21] they have, but I still don't see the vision of what is downtown [47:27] , what it looks like. [47:31] they have the wharf, and you know, they have a plan [47:36] and a purpose, a destination for their riverside. We [47:39] don't have that, and I haven't seen that plan. [47:45] you know, we keep the money --we can talk about the [47:48] monorail and all that, but we are throwing money into [47:54] an area or a project that has not been defined, and it is not [47:57] phased in. Were we going with it? [47:59] and so I don't think it is wise of us , I don't think it is prudent. I don't [48:06] think it is good management of the city's resources [48:09] for us to continue in this vein for anything, everything, wherever we are going [48:12] to invest dollars. So downtown , I want to make certain that we have [48:18] a holistic plan before we just start [48:21] accelerate dollars. I appreciate the effort [48:27] , but because it was no holistic comprehensive plan [48:29] for that entire way , it probably was just going to sit there until [48:33] somebody figured it out, and then they come [48:36] and pitch it, and it could have been [48:41] --you know, it could have been a plan, but I don't think [48:44] it is money well spent. If you could eke to if you all [48:46] have started one, thought about it, if that's a direction that you feel we [48:51] need to go in, how can we approach it? Can [48:54] you all come back to our next meeting with some information [48:57] with how we are going to move forward with [49:00] our riverfront? [49:01] >> councilman logan, before you got here, mr. Logan had said [49:05] that next meeting we are going to have a presentation looking at that [49:09] very thing. [49:12] >> that is good. I don't mean to interrupt, chairman, but that's [49:15] not what I'm looking for. I want administration to come and pitch some ideas, [49:20] and we together have a dialogue about what it looks [49:24] like, and then maybe include two were there will be some community [49:27] involvement later on in that type of thing. [49:33] so a long-term plan, like we did with memphis 3.0, that was for land-use [49:36] of the city, the more so for the riverfront. That's a great [49:38] resource. We have the most beautiful water --the most beautiful opportunity downtown. [49:45] so if you can use that, build on that, and [49:54] if it creates the money for us and revenue for people coming to visit [49:57] our riverfront, especially if we can tap into [50:00] our money. I mean, are water. [50:01] >> I have been asked by administration [50:06] to move us on, and we will continue this discussion [50:09] at our next meeting. I know I got a number of people in the queue. [50:12] please save those questions -- [50:13] >> I just ask next meeting for them to [50:14] come back. [50:15] >> we will work with river parks, because I'm [50:19] pretty sure that they have studies, and as director walker mentioned, [50:24] for -- [50:27] >> when we have the opportunity, we will [50:30] lay out a plan for an income plan, incorporating [50:33] what has been done in the past, and then [50:35] moving it to the future. We will relay it out [50:39] to you. A conference a plan by next week, maybe not. But charting [50:44] a course for the future, definitely. [50:47] >> okay. So if it's not, if you can let us [50:50] know when you're able to come back, you know, whether it's three months [50:51] or two months, we will -- [50:54] >> we will do. [50:57] >> we are now adjourned.