[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:09] Okay, excuse me, I'd like to call to where the March 17th Board of Supervisors meeting was done with the [0:15] pledge of allegiance. [0:34] In 1991, he received an officer, an offer to join the Chester County Commands [0:39] team. [0:40] He retired from the Police Department in September of 1996, and following his retirement, he served [0:45] his true friend supervisor from 2001 to 2009. [0:49] He's done many great works at the Township over the years in service. [0:53] He also had a public access television show for many years, and many of you may know. [0:58] Unfortunately, he passed away this past fall, and we wanted to add him to our wall of [1:03] water tonight with the Board's permission, and hopefully if his family is here, I'd like [1:07] to let him stand up and give them some recognition for his many, many years of service. [1:11] So if you can just put your hand up, that'd be great. [1:13] Thank you so much for this job. [1:24] And in addition, there's some wonderful little photographs that's different people from [1:28] this township had from his service and different things he's done over the years, so feel [1:32] free to take a look at that as well. [1:34] And if we could get a motion from the board to authorized staff to put his name on the wall [1:38] I wonder that would be great. [1:39] The thanks bill. [1:40] I just want to just in case people didn't add up that all those dates, that's four decades [1:44] of service to the township. [1:46] So he's been, I mean, he's very deserving of being on the wall and giving everything [1:50] he's done the township. [1:50] He went to school here, he went to St. Monica's elementary school, met his wife here, the [1:56] group of racist children, Berwin, so this is a hard core, a true different [2:00] internship person who has served us incredibly well and I'm really excited to [2:04] actually offer the motion to have him on the wall of honor in a true different [2:08] country building, so I'm going to offer the motion to I hear a second, second. [2:12] All in favor say aye, aye, any opposed? Motion carries. Congratulations and thank you. [2:31] I think it's up to you, we have a new police officer. [2:34] I appreciate the board's time and the public's time. [2:37] Once again, we've had a recent retirement, [2:41] and we went through our candidate list, [2:44] and we were able to identify a candidate. [2:45] We were very interested in, and we did the background investigation, [2:51] and came out to flying colors. [2:54] At this time of like introduce Officer Ian, Joseph Richardson, [2:59] Income one up to front is a girlfriend Tiana's going to call the Bible form. [3:04] Tonight we have Judge, retired district magistrate John Bailey, once again a former [3:10] tri different township, Lieutenant Commander here. [3:14] He's going to do the formal swearing in. [3:18] Also, Richardson will begin his field training program actually began today under direction [3:22] of Sergeant Scott Costa. [3:24] He is a lifelong resident of Chester County, Pennsylvania. [3:27] He is a 2019 graduate of West Chester East High School, and later attended Alverning University [3:32] in Reading, where he majored in criminal justice, and earned a bachelor's of arts degree [3:37] in May of 2023 graduating in Cum Laude. [3:41] While completing the reading, he entered the Reading Police Academy, and I completed his [3:45] basic training there in the summer of 2023, and then he was hired by the Lower South [3:50] of Internship, Kirsten Farm, where he's been employed until joining the two different [3:55] Tennessee Police Department. [3:57] Joining us today are his parents, Joe and Kelly, sister, Kari and McKenzie and a whole host [4:04] of friends and family and also all friends from the Department. [4:08] Congratulations in and congratulations to you all. [4:12] Thank you. [4:24] I, Ian Richardson, the Indulio Pointed Patrolman, [4:31] with a different touch of police department in Chester County, Pennsylvania. [4:38] You're selling these swear to firm. [4:40] You're selling these swear to firm. [4:41] That'll support the Bay Indefact, the Constitution and the United States of America, [4:49] and the Constitution laws of this Commonwealth that I will. [4:53] Do I might term of employment with a different amount of police department before I might do it with fidelity? [5:03] In my position is metrolment. [5:07] I will uphold obey and enforce the law without consideration. [5:14] So a person's race, color, sex, religious greed, sexual orientation, age, national origin. [5:23] And that's what we're going to have to do. [5:27] That's what we're going to do. [5:34] It's just fine, Ian Stayer. [5:37] I'm just fine by Lieutenant Jim Slaveman. [5:39] I'm just going to fix that. [5:54] What's again Newtune Jim Slaveman was here to present the badge. [5:58] Captain Moehyer. [5:59] Somewhere in the city of Sergeant Ryan Scott. [6:03] Corporal Guasparo, Corporal Milton. [6:06] And good old list of awful. [6:07] But thank you all for being here. [6:09] I appreciate thanks for boarding. [6:10] this time in a public spot. [6:13] Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. [6:14] Congratulations on another officer. [6:15] It's fantastic. [6:18] Of announcements, property owners are reminded [6:20] that annual stormwater inspections and reports are [6:23] due on or before April 1st, 2025. [6:26] The challenge efforts received a number of reports [6:28] from property owners. [6:30] And we thank those who have already submitted their reports [6:32] to remind others of the upcoming April deadline [6:34] for its 2025 inspection reporting. [6:38] And we go to approval of minutes or here a motion to approve the minutes of the February 18, [6:42] 20, 25 public meetings. [6:51] Any board comments or questions? [6:53] Public comments or questions? [6:55] All in favor say aye. [6:57] Any opposed? [6:57] The motion meetings are approved. [7:01] Touch of business. [7:02] The board met an executive session prior to this meeting to discuss legal and personnel matters. [7:08] We go to supervise the liaison reports. [7:10] Supervisor Holt, no report tonight. [7:15] President Gossie? [7:16] Yes. [7:18] The, the, the, the, the different township historical commission met last week. [7:23] David Blackburn, who's a heritage preservation coordinator for Chester County. [7:28] Join us this special. [7:30] Discussing how the county can support our local historical preservation efforts. He highlighted best practices, strategic planning, and available county resources. [7:41] The Commission is also organizing a North Berlin neighborhood walk in either May or June. All residents will be welcome. [7:48] Announcements and details will be made available through the Township E. Newsletter and social media. [7:54] Other ongoing initiatives include developing an interactive historical map, planning for America [8:01] to 50 to different and exploring the development of a true different heritage center at [8:06] Tupor Thai House, the next historical commission meeting is scheduled for April 10th at 7 p.m. [8:13] I also filled in for a supervisor basker for the last environmental advisory council EAC meeting in February. [8:20] They reported a successful cleanup at Valley Ford Elementary on President's Day with EAC members and 15 national honor society volunteers collecting 10 bags of trash. [8:34] Future cleanups, including at Hillside Elementary and ways to reduce school litter, we're discussed. [8:40] The EAC is surveying parks for long-term tree and shrub planting, coordinating with public [8:46] works on water sources and researching grants. [8:50] They're also working with pen environment on educational materials about gas powered leaf [8:55] flowers. [8:56] The EAC Express support for the residential conversion ordinance change discussed at the Planning [9:02] Commission, and they considered how to start researching potential zoning updates to accommodate [9:07] EV charging stations, and Aqua Essentials Grant Presentation is scheduled for Tuesday, April 29, [9:15] at 630, at the Stratford Library focused on stream bank restoration and stormwater management. [9:22] The next meeting will be held on March 25th. Thank you. [9:26] Thank you very much. Supervisor Humble is not here tonight. [9:30] But in her absence, I'm going to ask for a motion to reappoint Gail and Day, Chris Robbie, [9:35] and Diane Vaughn, to the park and record where you're in motion. [9:40] So move here a second. [9:43] Any comment from the board? [9:45] Comment from the public. [9:47] All in favor say aye. [9:49] Aye. [9:49] Any opposed? [9:50] Motion carries. [9:51] Congratulations and thank you for your service to the community. [9:53] We appreciate it. [9:55] Thank you. [9:56] Thank you. [9:57] Yes. [9:57] I have three reports this evening. [10:01] First of pension trustees, pension trustees, [10:03] Medal in February 26 for their quarterly review of the police pension fund and the 457 plan [10:11] for non-uniform employees and the OPEB trust. [10:14] After examining fourth quarter and other performance information, the trustees concluded that [10:19] no significant changes in investment strategy were currently needed. [10:23] The trustees will monitor, will continue to monitor the continuing uncertain economic and [10:30] to determine if any significant changes in investment strategy become necessary. [10:36] The next meeting of the pension trustees is on May 14. [10:40] Second report is the Planning Commission. [10:42] A Planning Commission met on February 20th and considered two applications. [10:47] First, the Planning Commission recommended to the Board of Supervisors, [10:51] The approval of the application by 435 Devon Park Drive partners proposing an amendment to the [10:59] trittiffin zoning ordinance, which would allow existing office buildings in the L-I-Zoning [11:06] District. [11:07] That's the limited industrial zoning district. [11:10] To be converted to multifamily residential use, subject to certain restrictions and would [11:16] also provide a definition of such conversion use. [11:19] Lastly, the Planning Commission consider an application for three outdoor. [11:25] Pedal courts, with associated offices at 341 East Connoisseur, [11:31] the road zone C1, the Planning Commission discussed the proposal with the applicant, [11:37] and continued the application to a subsequent meeting. [11:40] The next meeting of the Planning Commission is on March 20. [11:46] My last report is on the libraries where I was there for Supervisor Baskar, who was [11:57] away. [11:59] The library's Board of Trustees met on February 27th here, or some highlights from that [12:04] meeting. [12:05] Spacey Stone was elected Vice President as part of her 2024 library report, Library Director [12:14] Mallory Hoffman noted that our libraries offered 1,679 programs in 2024 enjoyed by 3,296 attendees [12:29] thanks to our children and pay only libraries dedicated staffs for their success of their [12:42] the library visits were continuing strong from 2024 where as were paper circulation and [12:50] e-circulation. All in all, for difference libraries remain our community centers and places [12:59] for lifetime learning. Here are a few remaining highlights of that meeting. The new book [13:06] drop, has been installed, and is operating. [13:11] The friends of the Trittiffin Public Library had another successful book donation day in February [13:19] receiving 4,000 books. [13:23] Now, I'd like to, it's my pleasure, to move the appointment of Praveen Cheat Shelly to the [13:36] of trust fees. [13:38] Do I have a second? [13:40] Second. [13:45] Excuse me? [13:46] Yes. [13:47] Faster. [13:48] Faster with us. [13:49] I didn't see that. [13:51] Okay. [13:51] We have a motion. [13:54] Do we have any board comments? [13:59] Any resident comments? [14:02] All in favor? [14:04] Aye. [14:06] Any opposed? [14:06] Any opposed? [14:09] Welcome. [14:10] Welcome to the Board of Trustees. [14:13] Provene. [14:13] This is great. Thank you. [14:17] And do I hear a motion? [14:18] Do I hear a motion to adopt a resolution? [14:21] 2025-10, for claiming national libraries week? [14:26] So moved. [14:26] I make a motion. [14:27] Wait, we just clarify, though. [14:30] That's, you're moving ahead in the agenda, is that right? [14:32] I'm moving ahead in the agenda to keep the library stuff all together. [14:35] Understood, that's item K. You just went to clarify for everybody. [14:38] That's what we're doing, yeah. [14:39] We're here. [14:41] Is our motion your second. [14:43] Thank you. [14:44] Any comment? [14:46] Sure. [14:48] So, every of the American Library Association [14:51] designates a week as National Library Week [14:54] with a different theme each year. [14:56] This is the same. [14:58] Drought to the Library is very. [15:01] Over the years, after different libraries and straffed and failurely have become so much more than books as noted by superversive voice arcades report, the community centres have bring people together with programming, makerspace, library of things, museum classes, and so much more. [15:18] Resignating April 6th to 12th National Library Week, I want to extend a special thanks to the staff who make it possible and the members of the Library Board of Trustees and the Library Foundation as well. [15:32] As far as the friends of the two different public library who give so much of their time and talent to make our libraries special. Thank you everyone. [15:43] Thank you, supervisor Baskar. [15:45] Any other comment from the board? [15:47] Any public comment? [15:49] This is a roll call vote? [15:51] Oh, [15:56] oh, [16:02] oh. [16:02] You just summarized that the library provided valuable services [16:05] to the community that it's more than just books. [16:07] It's a maker space. [16:08] It's other programming that are valuable to all the residents [16:12] in the community not just children, but all the way [16:14] through adults. [16:15] And this is important way of recognizing it. [16:19] So that helps. [16:22] any other comment? [16:26] This is a roll call vote, supervisor holds? Yes. Aye. [16:30] So, how's it going? Aye. So, how's your voice hockey? Aye. [16:33] It's a Johnston pew. Aye. Do we have supervisor Baskar anymore? [16:38] Yeah, I'm here. Aye. [16:39] And I vote aye. Motion carries. Thank you. [16:44] Thanks for the comment. I'm really sure you can hear out there. Thanks. [16:50] Now, we go to Supervisor Johnston Pue. [16:55] I do not have any reports, but I do have a motion to appoint Ed Swiny to the Zooming Hearing Board as an alternate member. [17:10] Any comments from the board? [17:13] Comments from the public? [17:16] Well, if he was the I, any opposed? [17:21] Motion carries. [17:22] Thank you. [17:24] That's the liaison report. [17:26] Now we get a report. [17:27] Yeah. [17:28] Can I just jump in for a moment? [17:31] I don't have a liaison report. [17:33] I'd like to thank Dr. Garcia and Supervisor Waisauki for covering for me. [17:37] And I also have an EEC update from [17:40] and Murphy, if the EEC, which is that [17:44] stream bank restoration and stormwater management, [17:47] permitting and techniques. [17:48] There is a presentation on Tuesday, April 29, [17:51] at 6.30 p.m. at the three different public library. [17:54] and Cory Trego and Black brain restoration specialist and environmental scientists, Kenneth Fleming would be presenting. [18:02] This is a free program, so please register to attend in person, [18:05] virtually at the luxury website. [18:09] Also, the annual Crabic Creek Macro-Invertible Studies on Sunday, April 27th, [18:14] 1-2-30pm and there are many student volunteers for the 3 EAC March Service projects. [18:21] they would accrued it through the Conestoga Science teacher, Amy Hawkins, and we'd like to [18:26] extend thanks to all of them, and thank you, I'm done. [18:32] Thank you, Supervisor Baskar. [18:33] It is hard to hear, I wish I would agree, that was tough. [18:39] With that, now we go to the re-apportionment committee update, Mr. Anastand. [18:51] All right. [18:53] Good evening. [18:54] All right, so the re-apportionment committee met on February 24th. [18:58] It was our second meeting. [19:00] We took a number of actually key show that [19:04] share the screen over there. [19:09] Thank you. [19:10] So we looked at a bunch of different plans [19:14] that we looked at. [19:16] As a reminder from last meeting, supervisor meeting, [19:19] we discussed the various criteria we're looking at [19:22] to redo the boundaries of the supervisors [19:26] is who have either the West, Middle, or East regions. [19:31] And because right now the populations are off. [19:34] So what we did was we looked at the various plans. [19:39] We basically we generated all the ones [19:43] that are within a standard maximum standard deviation, [19:46] or a standard maximum variance, excuse me. [19:49] And we looked at basically all them quickly, [19:53] and we looked at them with our criteria. [19:55] I just as a reminder, our criteria are the regions that have to be contiguous. [19:59] In other words, all the precincts have to touch each other within one region. [20:02] Regents have to be compact. [20:04] You guys would know that the opposite of that would look like a very gerrymandered one. [20:07] If they're not compact and they look like they either dive into each other or they go off [20:12] in little strings or things like that. [20:15] We made sure that we're trying to look at neighborhoods if we're keeping neighborhoods intact [20:20] with these maps. [20:22] And also we're looking for minimum disruption to the current maps so that people who have [20:28] get to vote for certain supervisors now would continue to be able to do that and you know [20:37] have those communities together. [20:39] And so we looked at these various maps if we just like them really quickly. [20:45] Just give you an idea of whoops. [20:49] Kind of give you an idea of what some of them look like. [20:51] These are the various maps. [20:53] Maps, you can kind of see what they kind of look like. [20:58] So we discussed these various maps. [21:00] And what we decided was, out of these maps, [21:04] we liked 10, 11, and 12 the most. [21:08] And so what we did is just make this easier for other people at home. [21:12] And for other people who are here now and want to look at it at home, [21:17] we kind of pulled them off, and now we're labeled A, B, and C [21:20] for 10-11 and 12. [21:23] By the way, for people who want to look at this at home, [21:26] just so you can find it quickly. [21:27] If you go to a different website, go to the Board of Supervisors, [21:37] and under the Board of Sweight, actually projects, [21:40] or the project, it's a reinforcement committee. [21:41] It's right here on the left. [21:43] Look at reinforcement committee. [21:46] And then, it will discuss the reinforcement committee. [21:49] These are the criteria that I discussed. [21:52] And then at the bottom is a link to the site that I'm on right now, so we can look at it, [21:57] how I'm going to play with this sort of, see what you like and what you don't like. [22:00] So 10, 11, 12, just want to go over them very, very quickly. [22:03] So 10, all the mass away are contiguous, so we don't have to go over that. [22:08] We like this one because it's very compact. [22:14] The maximum deviation, if you look at the bottom left, you'll see that it is 5.52% which is pretty good. [22:21] Most of the neighborhoods are intact. [22:23] That criteria is pretty good. [22:25] The chess broke us together. [22:26] High school areas together. [22:28] M5 and M6 were... [22:30] We try to keep them together, they're separated. In terms of disruption, this one has a little bit more disruption to it, because M1, M5, W4 and W5 will be moved from their current region to a new region. [22:45] So as a decent amount of disruption, if you look at Plan 11, this is the least compact. You kind of see how like strings along. It's like winding, so they're not as compact together. [22:59] Again, the maximum deviation is still pretty good, 6.24%, neighborhoods are intact, this separates [23:08] Chesterbrook, that's one neighborhood that's not kept intact. [23:13] This one, though, has the least disruption to the current map today. [23:19] The only precinct that changes is W3, so we like that aspect of this map, and then finally [23:24] for plan 12. This one also has a good maximum deviation to 4.13. This one keeps [23:36] some neighborhoods together, but some apart, chestwork stays together, pure road gets split [23:40] up, and M5 and M6 are also separated. [23:45] Unfortunately, this one has lots of changes to the [23:48] map. There's five different precincts that are moving around. So that's one thing we [23:52] like about it. The committee is going to meet again to kind of, we're kind of focusing on these [24:00] three right now. So again, you can look at these three yourself. If you'd like, you can [24:04] get feedback to the Board of Supervisors at BOS at different.org. And we greatly appreciate [24:10] your feedback. Is there anything else to do with the historic of our home real charter? And [24:15] began discussing the various sections. And we also talked about whether we wanted to break the [24:19] chartered to different groups. It was decided we were going to work on it as one committee [24:23] and develop a report that we can provide to the public as we start to delve into the [24:27] sections. We've met most recently on February 27th, reviewed the the [24:32] Tanship Auditor section as well as the role of the Tanship Manager and the [24:36] Wardens, a part of the charter and we're beginning to develop a redline [24:40] document which will be shared with the public as we delve into the next section. [24:44] So within the next month we should have a redline document for the public to take a look [24:49] And we'll have a report as we move forward in terms of some recommendations. [24:52] And the main focus really is also to look at some of the language within the document [24:57] to make it more general neutral and bring it up to speed for some of the modern technology things [25:02] that we're dealing with in terms of advertising. [25:04] So those have been to the main focus of the work so far. [25:07] And we'll have more information as we begin to work through the process. [25:10] Happy to answer any other questions. [25:11] Thank you, Mr. Barton. [25:12] Any questions on the board? [25:14] I'm a smart and I would encourage the committee to look into the possibility of requiring [25:20] one, at least one supervisor from being from the minority part. [25:26] So I actually that did come up in our first or second meeting. [25:30] And as a group, they felt that we could certainly talk about it more as a public as well [25:35] with a group felt that wasn't necessary at the township level, because we have general elections [25:39] And there are three or three at large and four, three districts and four supervisor for a large supervisor, so it was based on the voting. [25:46] The committee felt that we were going to add that to the charter at this time. [25:49] Just a recommendation, again, the Board of Supervisors will have to final call on that. [25:53] But we did discuss as one of the possibilities. [25:59] Any other comments? Any public comment? [26:08] Thank you. [26:09] I will admit to not having been able to hear everything that you said. [26:14] So I'm sure I missed something. I'll look at the video and I will catch up. [26:17] I just want to know what provisions you're making for public participation before it's finally revealed as a document to be voted on, which... [26:29] Yep, so we're going to, and our next meeting, we're going to talk about that. [26:33] We wanted to get some working document created that we could share with the public. [26:38] So, just really done some minor editing and changing anything that we proposed as terms of larger changes will be part of our presentation. [26:44] and we're going to develop the public presentation as we move forward. [26:49] So we're going to meet again this month. [26:51] So I expect our April meeting and the Board of Surveys will have a more detailed information [26:55] on where we'll have public open houses on it. [26:57] But there will be a public participation as well. [26:59] This is very important. [27:01] It's the guide for the Department for the Township. [27:04] And people need to be involved because I'm sure people have ideas that they have not had an opportunity [27:10] to voice yet. [27:11] And with problems, I'm sure, and I'll let people know that there is an opportunity, as you know I will, to do so. Thank you very much. [27:33] Okay, Arthur's address is 16 painters Lane. I want to emphasize what to supervise our whole set about a minority party member of the at large. [27:43] As one of those minority members in the community, I feel my input is valued and would like to know that it's even more valued by having someone specifically with that focus. [27:53] and in a time where we're trying to value diversity and bring different sides together, [27:59] I think that's an excellent idea and wanted to just bring that up even more so I think [28:04] we do it at the county level and I think local politics is even more important to have as [28:11] diverse and very of the number of people sitting at the board level. Thank you. [28:24] Any other public comment? [28:27] Thank you Mr. Martin. [28:28] So, here are a motion to authorize staff to advertise for receive bids for the Willis [28:32] Wood Press Upper Wheatly Stonewater Project. [28:35] So moved. [28:36] Your second. [28:38] Mr. Bergo. [28:40] Chairman Miller and members of the board tonight were asking the boards authorization to advertise [28:45] and receive bids for this Willis Wood Press an Upper Wheatly Stonewater Project. [28:49] As the board is aware, this project has been under design for several years. [28:54] We are finishing the bid documents as we speak, and we expect to be ready to put this out the bid in early April. [29:02] The township has this identified in their 2025-2026 budget. [29:06] We do us she have funding from general obligation bonds as well as $1.88 million worth of an art grant that we received last year. [29:16] The project includes stormwater drainage improvements on wood crest, [29:20] And it also includes them on Willis with a large stormwater basin proposed and as well as upper-weedly road and Arlin circles. [29:29] So we have a variety of improvements in a regionalized neighborhood to help reduce stormwater. [29:34] We're asking the board's authorization so we can prepare and get ready to authorize them in April. [29:41] Thank you Mr. Burgess. [29:42] Can I say the question about the screen can supermiss basket or participate real always here? I don't see on it. We see [29:49] No, okay, we had that we had the map up before so thanks. Thanks. I was unsure. I appreciate it. I'm any any supervisor comments or questions [30:01] Public comments or questions? [30:04] On Fifth, aye, aye, aye, aye, aye, aye. [30:07] Those motion carries. [30:09] So your motion to approve change order number 1 for the Contention Lane Bridge Project. [30:14] Mr. Byr, I will first along to your motion. [30:17] Some moved. [30:18] Second. [30:21] Second. Second. Mr. Berge? [30:23] Chairman Miller, members of the board. The following request for the Contention Lane Wooden Bridge. [30:28] change order, request number one for Lancaster County timber frames in the amount of $3,800. [30:35] As everybody knows, we had completed that emergency repairs for that project, but as part of the work, [30:41] when the contractor took a part the wooden deck surface and the curb and the guide rail, [30:45] they found that the old curb was deteriorated and they needed to replace that, so they did get us an estimate. [30:51] And we did review that internally and speak with Joe Duraco. [30:56] The cost associated with that were very, basically well within limits of what they would [31:02] be. [31:02] We did authorize the contractor to finish work because it was holding them up from completing [31:07] the project. [31:08] So this is a retroactive request and we are asking the board to approve that amount. [31:12] It was a necessary expense for the project. [31:16] Thank you Mr. Burgoy. [31:16] Any supervisor? [31:17] Comments? [31:17] questions. Public comments are questions. All in fair say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion carries. [31:26] Motion to approve a further letter of support and permission for the Township Engineer to participate [31:32] in a steering committee for the Villanova University University of Sheffield in UK proposed [31:37] Icarus inflow control retention in urban stormwater grant Mr. Bergo. [31:43] Chair and Miller, members of the board. [31:46] The following request is for a different township to become a partner, providing a partner, [31:51] a letter of support, and for myself to partner, I've been asked to partner as part of their [31:57] team. [31:58] They are a Villanova University as a partner at the University of Sheffield in UK to try to [32:03] obtain the grant, doing research on stormwater, basically control measures, several of the kind [32:09] things that we have done in the past here in the township where we have roadside infiltration [32:14] facilities and rain gardens and things like that to evaluate how that water is flowing [32:18] on the roadway and how it can more effectively be captured and controlled by inlets and inlet [32:24] control devices. So they're going to be doing a three-year study if they get the grant and doing [32:29] research both in the UK as well as at Villanova and as a partner we have opportunities where they [32:34] might be able to do some field research here in the township and then I would be attending some of [32:38] steering committee meetings over that three-year period. [32:41] It's super interesting. [32:42] I enjoy hearing motion. [32:45] Thank you. [32:45] You're a subwoofer. [32:47] Any board comment or questions? [32:49] How did this come about, actually? [32:50] I'm curious. [32:51] How did we get involved in this? [32:52] It's super interesting. [32:54] Dr. Bridget Wazik is the professor from Villanova. [32:58] I know in her from my affiliations with Villanova, so we see her periodically for conferences, [33:04] some of her conferences, and she had reached out to me. [33:07] She's reaching out to some other state and county officials and some other folks the partner with her on this grant. So she asked me that [33:13] You know, she thought it would be a good candidate for the touch up to match up and she reached out. [33:17] Thanks, Mr. Berger. Any public comment questions? [33:21] Any other surprises? [33:22] All in favor say aye. [33:24] Aye. [33:24] Aye. [33:24] Any opposed motion carries. [33:26] Motion to approve change order number one for the Glenn Avenue Pump Station Project Mr. Fitzgerald. [33:33] Thank you Mr. Chairman and members of the board. [33:35] We're currently seeking change order number one for the Glen Avenue Pumstation for MGK, who's [33:40] due to our contractor doing the work. [33:43] Total for the change order is $15,727. [33:47] The first part was for unforeseen rock removal costs for $6,585 in the second part was adding [33:54] an additional shut off valve on the force main work ties into the aqua force main for $9,142. [34:17] Thank you, Mr. Chair, Madam members of the board, staying consistent, what we did with [34:19] Motion to authorize dates for alcohol sales for the township community events in 2025. [34:24] Mr. Duraco. [34:25] Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the Board. [34:29] Staying consistent, what we did with last year, we're seeking an authorization to have [34:34] some sales at both board movie nights, the summer concert series, as well as community [34:40] day. [34:41] All the dates are listed in the memo. [34:45] Thank you, Mr. Durocco, we're here in motion. [34:48] Thank you. [34:50] Any comments or questions? [34:52] Thank you. [34:53] Rako, answer me a question. Who is doing the selling? Is it we purchase the alcohol or is [35:02] we bring in different vendors trying to think of who she normally uses? [35:10] La Cobra does a lot. They come in, you know, everybody who's selling alcohol is [35:18] They're, you know, they have all the certification, but everything you need to do to serve alcohol, they do. [35:23] We, you know, public work sets up like a beer garden, so to speak, in the park that we ask people to stay in when they have alcohol. [35:32] So that's how we do it. [35:35] Thank you. [35:35] It reminds us who benefits. [35:38] All that, so a portion of the proceeds from the sale go back to the park's foundation. [35:44] It's a benefit for the temperature. [35:46] It's really what it's about. [35:48] Any other comments from the supervisors? [35:49] Public comment? [35:51] Won't you ever say aye? [35:52] Aye. [35:53] Any opposed? [35:54] Motion carries? [35:55] Motion to authorize a survey of alcohol. [35:57] It's the three events that's a different public library. [35:59] Mr. Duraco. [36:00] Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [36:02] Members of the board. [36:03] There's three events that the library is looking at. [36:05] Have alcohol at the coming up. [36:08] Actually in a couple of weeks, Tuesday, April, [36:11] the book buzz, and then there's the donor reception as well as the adult party, which is [36:18] their golf thing. Again, consistent with what we've done in the past, so we'll have [36:23] to answer any questions. [36:26] Thank you, Dr. Emotion. [36:28] Submoved. [36:28] In a second? [36:30] Second. [36:31] Thank you. Any comments from the board? Any public comments? [36:46] Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the Board. [36:50] Staff is seeking authorization to approve the contract with Clean Net. [36:54] The cost to clean the libraries was $52,048. [36:59] Staff has reviewed the beds and found that acceptable. [37:02] And we're happy to answer any questions for your motion [37:09] Second [37:10] Any comment from the board [37:12] Public comment [37:14] I do have a question [37:17] I do get a question [37:18] You need to come up to the microphone [37:22] I do have a question to rock out is this for both libraries or is this just for a strafford both? [37:30] Okay, thank you. [37:45] Roll and Johnson, just was wondering, how many bids did we get on that? [37:52] Six. [37:53] The lowest was 52,048, the highest, which we potentially think is a typo, was 278,625. [38:02] Okay, so we had, I'm sorry, I missed the numbers. [38:05] The low bid was clean net of 52,048, the high bid, which we think probably had a typo [38:13] was 278,665. The majority of the bid's four of the bid's ranged from 56 to 72,000. [38:26] Thank [38:28] you. [38:37] We're talking about the 278,000 bid. We think the two was mistaken. [38:43] Most of the authorised the contract payment extension associated with the Berlin Fire Station [38:49] core states could be structured administration and statement that you actually vote. [38:54] All we can vote. [38:55] Oh, sorry. [38:56] Sorry, we'll prove it. [38:58] Sorry about that. [39:00] All of them say aye. [39:02] Aye. [39:02] Any opposed? [39:03] Motion carries. [39:04] You're sorry about that. [39:06] Motion authorised the contract payment extension is associated with the Berlin Fire Company core [39:10] state's construction administration, Mr. Duraco. [39:14] Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [39:15] Members of the Board. [39:16] Staff is looking to authorize and approve. [39:20] Formerly Bernard and who's the architect for the 23-bridge Avenue Project. [39:25] Now they're known as course dates. [39:28] The cost is $36,500 total. [39:31] Our portion of that would be $27,000 around $27,000. [39:38] This is, again, there's been a lot [39:40] additional work that's been required. [39:42] Staff had a pretty pointed phone call with the architect, originally, we've gotten the price [39:48] down from where he came in at and was requesting, overall the cost, the architect, the overall [39:55] project is less than 6%, which, again, staff reviewed and found that to be within reason. [40:04] So, we're pushing along, again, the buildings on track to be finished sometime later this [40:10] So, that's why we're asking for authorization and approval. [40:14] Yeah, thanks, Mr. Draco. [40:15] Enjoy your motion. [40:17] We are second. [40:18] Second. [40:20] Any board comments or questions? [40:22] Public comments or questions? [40:25] All in favor say aye. [40:27] Aye. [40:27] Aye. [40:27] Any opposed? [40:28] Motion carries. [40:30] Motion to approve proposals for Sally port door upgrades. [40:33] Mr. Fitzgerald. [40:35] Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the board. [40:37] Staff request and replacement for the Sally port doors. [40:40] use by the police department, for anybody who doesn't know, they're just opening great doors [40:43] over on the side. [40:45] So in bad weather, high winds or whatever the police officers are out there trying to do [40:49] their job. [40:51] And basically out in the elements, the doors, we've had nothing but problems with them. [40:57] Our gross company states we should be replacing them, so we want to replace them with solid [41:02] doors so we can try to control the environment a little bit better. [41:04] We contacted J. Door, who is a co-stars contractor. [41:09] If they're priced to replace the doors with insulator doors, [41:12] who's $39,149, and we also need to do electrical upgrades [41:17] for lights inside of there, for $3600 from taking to electric. [41:21] We're going to tell the project to $42,749, [41:25] which is under the estimated cost that we're included in a $25 budget. [41:29] I'll be happy to answer any questions. [41:31] Thank you, Ms. Fitzgerald. [41:32] Do I hear a motion? [41:33] So moved. [41:34] Do we hear a second? [41:35] Second. [41:37] Any board comments or questions? [41:39] I got a question. [41:40] One was that when were the other doors put on? [41:44] They are the original doors when the building was built. [41:51] Any public comments or questions? [41:55] Olon Feve say aye. [41:56] Aye. [41:57] Any opposed? [41:58] Motion carries. [41:59] Motion is approved proposal from Duke's root control for Sanctuary's sewer line services [42:04] Mr. Fitzgerald. [42:05] Thank you Mr. Chairman, members of the Board, [42:07] staff requesting Board approval for our 2025 root control [42:11] problem, program with due true control. [42:15] Unfortunately, this is our largest of the three-year cycle, [42:18] where we treat 36,173 feet of sanitary sewer pipe. [42:22] What this does is, it's like a phone that goes inside the lines [42:26] and it kills the tree roots to save us on a lot of blockages. [42:32] The price for this under co-stars is $7,3136. [42:37] We come out of the sewer fund and I'll be happy to answer any questions. [42:42] Thank you, Mr. Fitzgerald. Do I hear a motion? [42:46] Second. Second. [42:48] Any board comments or questions? [42:50] Public comments or questions? [42:52] Well, if I was AI, I opposed motion carries. [42:57] Motion to authorize advertisement of a public hearing on Tuesday April 1st, 2025 at 7 p.m. [43:03] for a special meeting of the Board of Supervisors to consider and possibly enact [43:07] an ordinance to exercise the power of eminent domain to require all or a portion of the [43:12] real property located at 355 Chase Road for a public park or recreational use by the general [43:17] public. [43:18] Mr. McKenna. [43:19] Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [43:20] The Board and the Public will recall that we had a similar motion at the Board's meeting last [43:25] month. Since that time, we have continued to do the due diligence on the property, which [43:33] is rather complex given the way the Chesterbrook community was developed. It is a long [43:39] time ago and finding all of the information has taken a good bit of time, each of the [43:44] communities were developed separately. So what we were recommending and what this before [43:50] the board tonight was a small change to the ordinance language, which requires a reauthorization. [43:55] the original ordinance that was before you was for just a portion of the property. [44:01] Right now it is now drafted to say all or a portion of as the due diligence continues. [44:08] It gives the board the option to do so particularly once it comes up for a vote in the [44:13] appraisal it gets completed so because that's a change and likely to be considered a [44:18] material change to the ordinance. We have to reauthorize and re-advertise the ordinance, [44:25] which is now scheduled for a special hearing on April 1st. Otherwise, there's no change [44:29] to the ordinance. Everything is still proceeding as we announced that last month's meeting. [44:35] Mr. McKinnon, do I hear a motion? [44:38] So, second, thank you. Any board time that's your questions? [44:43] Mr. Chair, I understand we're going to have to procedurally for tonight and have the special meeting [44:47] in April, but I don't think I'll be able to attend, but regardless, I would like to say that [44:53] us the Lord having to go through this process again, we haven't voted on it yet, but [44:59] angers me too. [45:00] Absolutely no end. The public is going to have to end up paying a speculative developer for his very bad bet of $1.2 million. [45:12] And the bet was at this board would change the zoning of a recreational conservation parcel to multi-dwelling family housing. [45:22] The developer demanded, in this board, multiple boards, that they approved 40 plus houses in a five-acre parcel and already compact area. [45:34] We, of course, said no. [45:36] We said no multiple times. [45:39] He understood this, and he thought that they were going to just wait it out for years and years in years to pass until this property simply became [45:51] a wasteland, and that we'd have to do something about it, and then we would approve his plan. [45:56] That was the developer's plan. [46:00] The board was willing to negotiate and talk and enter into good faith negotiations, [46:06] and see what can be done. [46:07] The developer did not want to do that. [46:10] Refuse. [46:11] He wanted his 40 plus units and 10 figure payday. [46:16] All right. [46:17] Well, the developers now going to be taking millions of dollars of public tax fair funds. [46:25] His hope to satisfy his bad bet. [46:29] We've already heard it from his council. [46:32] He's coming against the township for millions beyond what the 1.2 he paid for, which is already [46:38] way too much for a parcel that could only fit one house. [46:44] This is going to cost the township, hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees. [46:49] Years of litigation is going to entail. [46:52] And that's fine. [46:53] That's about all that's what we'll have to do. [46:57] Regardless, it's focused on what this is. [47:00] A greedy developer, trying to extort millions of dollars of taxpayer funds. [47:07] So get ready for it. [47:08] Please come out to the hearings and say, [47:12] for shame, for shame, for shame against the sky. [47:15] It's really ridiculous. [47:17] Thank you. [47:28] Thanks. [47:28] Any other board comments? [47:31] Public comment? [47:39] Should one, come on, I guess, one person. [47:40] We'll have one of our tools. [47:41] Well, next. [47:44] Our authors address the 16 painters lane. [47:48] Supervisor Holtner, an agreement on a lot of items, apparently, this evening, and I share [47:52] your frustration with the situation conferring us. [47:55] I wanted to come forward because of the change in the agenda. [48:02] It's someone who looks forward to enjoying the opportunity of what's on this facility right now. [48:06] That's not accessible to residents. [48:08] I've been talking to a lot of pickable fans and a lot of tennis fans. [48:12] And we would love to see the facility back and available. [48:16] Granted, it might take some time. [48:18] Hopefully, not as long as it's taken us to get here. [48:21] But I didn't know if anyone had showed up to who were pickable fans in particular. [48:24] I wanted them to have a chance to just say, hey, we support as frustrating as this is and [48:31] I encourage you to stick to your guns on this. [48:35] Something else I wanted to bring forward, you know, I was involved with the bike park project [48:39] a couple of years ago and we got in the praisel for the three-quarter acre parcel. [48:44] Now, this was on township property which is more indeed restricted. [48:47] But that was, as I recall, something like 50,000 dollars an acre. [48:51] So, even the 600,000 number I've seen thrown around sounds high, but again, these are people, [48:59] this person is someone who just wants to deal, wants to pressure and I would encourage [49:04] Board to stay in firm, do what you need to, to train get the best value for the taxpayers, [49:10] but we would like the facility back available to the public and I know the residents would [49:14] love to see it not becoming any more of an ice order than it already is. [49:19] So thank you for your efforts going forward. [49:24] Thanks, Eric. [49:30] Any other public comment? [49:32] Ms. Clark? [49:35] Good evening. [49:36] This is Carol Clark, resident of Tridifferent. [49:39] I have a request regarding this agenda item prior to your moving forward with the public hearing [49:48] where you may actually make a vote at that time. [49:52] I was wondering, when will you have a make available to the public the details of your [49:56] investigations, the inquiries, the analyses, and the results. [50:00] There are especially interested in what estimates you have for the acquisition, for the development, [50:06] and the maintenance costs of this property, and I would greatly appreciate the opportunity [50:11] to preview these and these numbers prior to the hearing so that we can have an informed discussion [50:17] and make the appropriate decisions either at that public hearing or in a future public hearing. [50:24] Thank you so much. [50:27] Thank you, Mr. McKenna. [50:31] So on the township of Maine inside, that's up to staff. [50:33] I don't know. [50:35] Once the appraisal is complete and becomes public record, [50:38] we will have that information available. [50:40] We're not yet at that point. [50:43] Hopefully, hopefully, by the special meeting, [50:46] that's the goal is to have it available by that time. [50:49] Yeah. Okay, thanks. [50:51] I mean, Ms. Clark, just to be clear, [50:52] we're going to disclose information as we have it. [50:54] I'm not going to negotiate in public with the developer because at the end of the day, this will be in a [50:59] negotiated agreement as Mr. Holtz said. [51:01] This probably has been court at some point, but we'll share the information we have when we have it. [51:07] Under the public comment. [51:19] There we go. [51:20] Richard O'Hack, 1564 over in a place. [51:24] I completely support Carol's request for a really clear analysis of all the options we have. [51:34] We could put a Pickable Court in Wilson Farm Park, a maintain it under our existing part maintenance [51:41] agreement. We can enforce the township regulations on this property to ensure it conforms [51:49] with all the ordinances for upkeep. But most important on October 1, you will be voting on an [52:04] But in fact, it will be a completely open-ended liability for the township. [52:11] This developer is going to take you through the courts, add in for an item, [52:15] and we have Mr. White Socky reporting on our market experts who are talking about uncertain market conditions. [52:24] The economy is about to fall off a cliff and we're entering into an... [52:30] No complete open commitment. I think that is not responsible management, and I look forward to hearing [52:37] all the, what was its investigation inquiry and analysis. So thanks. [52:49] Thank you. Any other public sure? [52:57] I haven't read it recently, but the municipality's planning code to my recollection seems to do [53:09] to the public. This is very important to people to remember and we really have to work hard [53:16] to oppose this kind of thing. And I think the one thing, the one idea that the board and I [53:23] feel that this board will probably consider this very carefully, this whole thing as you obviously [53:28] have been regarding people developing land in the township, the township does not owe a developer [53:39] a profit. It doesn't owe the developer a profit. And a lot of developers seem to think [53:47] that they do, that you do. And the minister, as I said, the municipality's plan is called [53:53] to support that idea. I think everybody we need is many people as possible and there [54:00] seem to be a lot of people here which is very nice to see usually the developer and [54:05] his attorneys outnumber the audience. And we just have to keep that kind of stuff in [54:10] one. Thank you so much. [54:12] Thank you. [54:21] Hi, I'm Jennifer Kay. I live in Green Hills. I grew up here. I was a member of Pegapost pretty [54:27] much my whole life. I learned to play tennis there. Please make it into a park. Please [54:33] Please leave the eye sore that it's become has been just really really hard to watch over the years and this seems like a problem the township could have fixed a long time ago, and it chose not to lead into the situation that we're in now. [54:46] I know that there's a lot of economic considerations to be made, and I hear the frustrations. [54:52] But fixing this as an open space is the right thing to do for Chesterbrook and the residents who've had to live with this mess for so long. Thank you. [54:59] Thank you. [55:12] Hello. [55:13] I could carpenter 1330 Hayward Road. [55:15] Two comments. [55:18] I don't know anything about eminent domains, so I can't, but I do understand a little bit [55:23] that it's supposed to be fair market value. [55:25] And so fair market value is not necessarily what somebody can perceive or contrive or guess [55:32] it. [55:33] So, totally support the fact that we hopefully can keep that a little bit of pain. [55:37] And the other thing common I want to make is just a share quote that you're probably all aware [55:43] of from Evan Burke. [55:46] All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men and women do nothing. [55:53] So thank you for doing something. [56:03] Any other public comment? [56:10] All favors say, we have a motion, we have a proper motion, proper second, all favors say [56:15] I. [56:17] Aye. [56:17] Any opposed? [56:18] Motion carries. [56:20] Motion to authorize advertising of public hearing on Monday April 21, 2025 to consider and [56:26] possibly adopt an ordinance prohibiting commercial vehicles and trailers on public streets. [56:31] She's fatigued. [56:33] Certain situations were brought to the police department or traffic safety unit with regards [56:38] to commercial vehicles, dumpsters, and other vehicles like that parked on public streets. [56:47] And, of course, we're trying to address resident concerns. [56:50] We found that the ordinance is that we're on the books for us, and we're not really sufficient [56:55] to address these concerns to the neighbor's satisfaction. [56:59] The traffic committee or traffic safety unit did some research from neighboring jurisdictions, [57:05] working with the solicitor. [57:06] They have a draft ordinance, which is before you, which will be posted, and then be discussed [57:10] at the next meeting for consideration. [57:14] That's all I have. [57:15] I'm going to build with any questions. [57:16] You know, thanks Chief Biddy. Do I hear a motion? [57:18] Go move for your second. [57:22] Any board comments or questions? [57:24] I do have one. [57:26] Yeah, good. I was going to say something good. [57:27] Chief, I thank you. [57:29] Because this has been a problem that has came up ever since I got on this board, and it's been over a year. [57:35] So I appreciate the work that you and the rest of the folks have done to try to help to get this result. [57:42] I know it may not be the best situation for everyone, but I think that it will help. [57:49] Because it's not good with people having huge trucks and dumpsters on the street and [57:55] you can't see up and down the street, you know, you're blocking people's driveways and things [58:01] don't need to so I appreciate everything that you did to work on this. [58:05] Thank you. [58:08] Yeah, thanks. [58:08] I was going to have the same thing basically. [58:09] We appreciate the hard work that it's taken. [58:11] and present the residents going forward to talk about the problem to get it in front of us [58:14] to then, you know, we hear it eventually and we can do things so that's a good example of us taking action. [58:19] Obviously government does take some time, but we are proceeding. [58:23] Any other cumistenboard public comment? [58:28] Well, favor say aye. [58:30] Any opposed? [58:30] Motion carries. [58:32] Motion to authorize advertising of public hearing on Monday, April 21, 2025 to consider and possibly adopt [58:38] the Zoni ordinance amendment to allow the conversion of existing office building to a multi-family [58:43] dwelling in the limited industrial district. [58:47] Mr. McPherson. [58:48] Thank you, Chairman Miller, members of the board. [58:50] The township did receive a petition from an applicant to make a zoning amendment as you [58:56] discuss in the narrative there. [58:59] So I could certainly answer any questions you have on the ordinance, but obviously tonight's [59:04] motion is to schedule the public hearing to have the majority of that conversation. [59:10] No, thank you. [59:11] Do I hear a motion? [59:13] Do I hear a second? [59:16] Any board commenter questions? [59:19] Public commenter questions? [59:21] Sure. [59:30] There we go. [59:31] What is the status of this quote draft? [59:35] How finished is it? [59:37] And what flexibility do you have in making alterations? [59:41] But once it's advertised, it's not to be changed, but, I'm sorry, once it's advertised, [59:46] we don't make changes unless we have to reauthorize. [59:48] We have to re-advertise it. [59:49] So we're approving it tonight to be advertised. [59:52] We would then consider it at the next meeting. [59:54] Yes, I understand the process. [59:57] But it's almost in the question. [59:58] The actual... [1:00:00] Specific document that you're talking about, the ordinance. What is, excuse me, what is its status? Is it a final document [1:00:09] at this point? Is it the way you want to present it to the public? [1:00:14] We're voting right now to present it to the public, so yes. [1:00:17] I know you're voting to present it, so I presume that it is in a form that you want to present. [1:00:23] It sounds like a silly question, but I'm just looking for detailed information. [1:00:29] Yeah, the way the process works is we are. [1:00:32] Now it's final. [1:00:33] I was really kind of hoping that we could have some flexibility at this moment. [1:00:39] Because there are a couple of points that I would like to mention. [1:00:44] And I think I've mentioned them earlier. [1:00:45] And I'd like to repeat them on purpose. [1:00:47] It says only item A on the ordnance graph states only an office building existing at the [1:01:00] time of enactment of this ordinance may be converted to multifamily dwelling. [1:01:07] The developer who presented the amendment has already stated that most office buildings do not [1:01:15] admit themselves to being adaptable to housing requirements, which eliminates practically [1:01:24] every office building in the township. [1:01:26] The one that we're talking about on Devin Park Drive is an unusual apparently circumstances [1:01:30] and anomaly. [1:01:32] Now, if the ordinance were written with the public in mind to say all office buildings, [1:01:44] well, [1:01:44] Let me say that it should include new office building construction. [1:01:52] If you present the opportunity for a person for a developer to build a building that could be you made use of in two ways. [1:02:04] You say it reduces limitations on the use of the building and it allows for the possibility of a change of direction for that particular building. [1:02:16] We had a developer a couple of months ago who wanted to build a wall wall in a parking lot because he was losing money on his office building. [1:02:24] If the office building were convertible to housing, he might have just said, well, let's make apartments out of it. [1:02:31] If the idea being that a new construction could be conceived not only as an office building, but as possible conversion to an apartment building. [1:02:43] which opens the up, just creates more possibilities. [1:02:48] It creates more flexibility. [1:02:50] Thanks. [1:02:50] I understand what you're saying. [1:02:52] I'm sorry. [1:02:53] I understand what you're saying. [1:02:54] I appreciate your input. [1:02:55] I didn't hear the last thing. [1:02:57] I'm sorry. [1:02:57] I appreciate your input. [1:02:58] Thank you. [1:03:01] But there's absolutely no way of changing that point. [1:03:04] At this point. [1:03:05] The second point is that I have actually spoke with a developer. [1:03:09] And I do understand the problem of upgrading to storm water management, upgrading to current standards, which is what would be ideal. [1:03:21] You can't always do that. I do understand that. Now, we did discuss the possibility of making alterations in the current system that would make it more suitable to current conditions. [1:03:33] For example, if a pipe allows a flow of 500 cubic feet of water per minute, it could be reduced [1:03:40] to allow a flow of 300 cubic feet per minute. [1:03:44] Perhaps, now I'm speaking hypothetically, of course, I'm not engineering engineer. [1:03:48] I don't know what the details involve. [1:03:51] Even raising a level of the outlet pipe from the bottom of a retention basin to the top of [1:03:56] the retention basin means the basin will hold the water longer and allow the stormwater [1:04:02] to dissipate before that base. [1:04:07] Now, you see, these are things that I don't know what people are thinking about when they write [1:04:10] these things, but they really have to think further, tangentially, and ways of solving these [1:04:19] problems. [1:04:19] Is there any way now, I guess it's too late now to make these changes? [1:04:23] Well, the stormwater specific question is really a planning commission question. [1:04:27] So once we start against the development, that's one that we'll be talked about. [1:04:30] not in the zoning ordinance, right? [1:04:32] I mean, Erin, you want to speak to that for a second? [1:04:34] Yeah, I mean, this, yes. [1:04:35] I mean, we did talk about this, his comments, [1:04:38] in the planning commission. [1:04:40] And the way that I think, think of this is, [1:04:42] this is a use change, right? [1:04:44] So the developers not proposing any building. [1:04:47] It's literally taking what they have now [1:04:50] and repurposing it. [1:04:53] Everything that we have in our stormwater ordinance [1:04:55] deals with new construction, there isn't really [1:04:59] like a use requirement for a stormwater in that case in the stormwater ordinance, so it would [1:05:06] be something completely different, I guess, you know, the developer's proposed removing [1:05:12] some of the parking, and he's going to add opens probably, and he, and, and, and, [1:05:16] maybe it's surface. [1:05:17] Right, his proposal, you know, just to, you know, he owns a lot, well, he doesn't own a lot. [1:05:22] He has a lease for the land under the Pico lines there, which isn't technically his property, [1:05:28] the original ordinance had a 10% reduction of impervious. [1:05:33] He did have to move it back to five because of that issue because he doesn't actually own [1:05:39] that. [1:05:39] He's still going to do that. [1:05:40] So he's converting that parking lot area back to a park area under the lines, but it [1:05:45] won't, you know, it doesn't really count towards his lot. [1:05:49] No, we understand that. [1:05:51] I do understand that. [1:05:53] I know what you're talking about. [1:05:54] I recognize that I understand and I understand what his problems are all [1:05:58] with the parking lot and all of that kind of thing. [1:06:01] But the problem is, what are we going to do in the future? [1:06:04] And if you write this stuff with the future in mind, for example, [1:06:09] we've had more 500 year storms in the past 20 years, [1:06:12] and we've had in the last 100. [1:06:15] Yet the stormwater ordinance still talks about a 100 year storm [1:06:19] as the maximum. [1:06:21] We're just not thinking beyond what we already know. [1:06:26] This is the problem with, well, I will say that. [1:06:28] It's not necessary. [1:06:29] But we do need to think about this kind of stuff when we write these ordinances. [1:06:34] What is going to happen in the future? [1:06:38] People who think that it seems like, never mind, I would say that either. [1:06:42] But it's a little frustrating to see that things are presented before they seem to be complete. [1:06:50] And I would hope that this would, that the development subcommittee will put on the agenda. [1:06:57] and I'm sure it will to review the stormwater ordinance to make sure that some of these points [1:07:03] are installed there in as soon as possible. I know you can do it. I know you can do it. Thank you. [1:07:13] Thank you. [1:07:14] Yeah, well, we're seeing, yeah, we can do it from here. We can do it from here. Oh, [1:07:20] Good. Thank you. Any other public comments? [1:07:30] Just quickly, disappointing that we couldn't get some kind of stormwater management improvements. [1:07:38] I understand, obviously, the issues that go into the decision there. A question that Mr. Coonan's question raised. [1:07:48] If someone wanted to build a residential building in a limited industrial district, could they do that? [1:07:57] I mean, this is not a conversion unrelated to them. [1:07:59] No, they could not. [1:08:00] They could not. [1:08:01] And they couldn't do it in office either. [1:08:04] Like, some of the other buildings he was talking about [1:08:06] converting their in the office zoning district, [1:08:08] which wouldn't permit us. [1:08:10] This is, I would say we thought, like, a new one, [1:08:12] so that you're someone not down the building. [1:08:15] They have to be an ordinance change and, like, [1:08:18] what's in here. [1:08:19] Okay, thanks. [1:08:23] What's your cash change, [1:08:28] George? [1:08:28] Since the mic is on, I'll speak in favor of this. [1:08:31] And as a taxpayer, I've been frustrated for the 11 and most 12 years I've lived in [1:08:38] a different touch about the number of commercial buildings that remain empty. [1:08:42] This is a problem and life is changing. [1:08:45] We need housing for people, we don't need office space, and I think this is a wonderful example [1:08:50] of government providing some flexibility, and why it may only pertain to one specific [1:08:54] individual now, developers are very creative people, and people are looking to find ways to [1:09:00] solve this problem of converting these buildings into usable housing. [1:09:04] So I applaud you for considering this step, and I hope it will lead to more housing, more [1:09:10] used property, less property being left vacant, and I do believe the issue of stormwater [1:09:18] risk address, there's a 5% allowance so that there is some consideration there. [1:09:23] So again, thank you for your positive consideration of this. [1:09:26] Thank you. Any other public comment? [1:09:31] Board comment we're done? [1:09:32] A long favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed motion carries? [1:09:38] Now we go to board member at new matters, any board member new matters? [1:09:44] Any citizen new matters? Sure. [1:09:50] Thank you once again, and I really didn't intend to come up with this [1:09:53] this frequently, but Mr. Fitzgerald said something during his discussion of the root control [1:10:02] in the sanitary sewer system. [1:10:06] Clearly, there are roots getting into the sanitary sewer system, [1:10:10] otherwise you wouldn't have to remove them. That means there are holes in the system. [1:10:16] Now, basically, it comes through the joints, it's just a little roots that end up coming through [1:10:21] to join, so it's not old, it's not old, well there are openings otherwise the roots couldn't [1:10:27] get in, I understand what you're saying, but still there is a void in the sewer system somewhere [1:10:36] otherwise the root could not have gotten in, roots don't go where they don't want, they don't [1:10:41] they have to do a lot too much work to make happen, they go around stones they don't go through [1:10:47] Okay? We know that if we can see that in the forest. So my question is, once the roots are removed or killed and they [1:10:55] rot away or removed or whatever you do with them, how do you repair all of those voids? [1:11:01] A lot of times what we end up doing we go when we weren't a program now where we do patching and we do like three patches a month. [1:11:10] As we go through our system, we also do, we're doing sliplining now, the CIPP project, you hear about, we bring up, so we go through the worst areas and that's what we're doing. [1:11:23] Okay, I understand that you should do. [1:11:24] I have a system for closing for repairing leaks and I find a thing. [1:11:30] Yeah, Mr. Kooner, he also has a process to understand how much excess water is actually getting into the system. [1:11:35] So when it becomes, you know, he's measuring how much excess water is getting in the system from outside and then he knows when to go and do repairs in those areas, so I think we're doing a really good job of handling this whole part of the system. [1:11:48] Yeah, this isn't something that we just started. This been going on for years, so we're just continually going in and as we do video inspections of the areas, we take a look at the worst ones and we put patches on himself from the inside. [1:12:03] Thank you very much. [1:12:04] Thank you. [1:12:05] Any other citizen matters? [1:12:15] I was reminded by Mr. Boyzaki as comment about the pension board trustees. [1:12:20] And for some random reason I can't remember what. [1:12:22] I was looking at the website a few weeks ago, [1:12:25] and there are no minutes from the board of trustees since 2022. [1:12:31] Is there some policy decision about that? [1:12:37] Trisha and I will check that and make sure it's updated. [1:12:39] Thank you. [1:12:46] Probably lack of interest. [1:12:47] You're probably the first one to identify that we weren't showing up. [1:12:51] I don't know. [1:12:52] It's not a highlight. [1:12:54] Yeah. [1:12:54] Any other, oh, we get a highlight. [1:12:57] I don't think so. [1:12:57] Any other citizen new matters? [1:12:59] Sure. [1:13:06] Proach the bench or not. [1:13:08] Sure. [1:13:26] My name is Richard Stratton. [1:13:27] I own a property of 1411 for when Paley rode in Paley. [1:13:32] My neighbor at 94 Glen Avenue has bamboo on the property line, and most of the time it is a fire hazard in dry weather. [1:13:48] And what we saw in California, I don't want to happen to my house. [1:13:51] So I spent at least 40 hours annually trying to trim it back and it's costly to get [1:14:02] it all the way. [1:14:05] I've been doing it for 15 years and I'd like to see a township ordinance coming [1:14:12] to effect to prevent, you know, an issue like this. [1:14:17] Again, I think it's a fire hazard, and I like to see the township take up an ordinance [1:14:24] to prevent bamboo, at least that close to a property line, that the bamboo is only 15 feet [1:14:32] from my house, and in weather it creates a cave effect where, you know, it falls on the house, [1:14:43] and harms the shingles as well, so I'm hoping, you know, you can find me with some relief from this issue. [1:14:55] Thanks for the photos. [1:14:56] Who's actually touching your house? [1:14:58] Yes. [1:14:59] Yeah. [1:15:00] And as your question, have you talked to the neighbors about them cutting it or having to cut down on your sides and it's just on their side? I mean, yes, I have twice over the past 15 years. [1:15:16] Do they have a problem with you cutting it down? No, when it goes over my fence line, I can cut it. [1:15:29] But the way it works is it can be upright is 38 feet high in most locations, and if we have [1:15:37] in climate weather it'll come down. [1:15:39] Wait, yeah, lean on the property. [1:15:41] So if I'm understanding you right, you would have, you would like for it to be cut down [1:15:47] completely. [1:15:48] Yeah, I'd like to remove, because it's a continual issue. [1:15:52] Okay. [1:15:53] Yeah, so there was a township ordinance that prevented that, you know, that was all the issue. [1:16:01] So I can see that there are, I just did a quick look to know does anyone have ordinances about [1:16:08] Bamboo and I see that they do, like Radner has one. So I think it would be worth having the ordinance committee, [1:16:15] just do a little look knowing that some neighboring townships have some kind of restrictions. [1:16:22] So that's something we can look into. [1:16:24] We'll take it up in the audience community and see what is done. [1:16:29] I mean, the pictures are super helpful, by the way. [1:16:31] Yeah, thank you. [1:16:32] I think, in this case, pictures were as a thousand words. [1:16:36] I couldn't. [1:16:38] No, I didn't really get it. [1:16:40] So now that I see it, I don't know. [1:16:41] I get his point. [1:16:42] I was like, is it really a problem? [1:16:44] You know, I'm making certain as like July or August, [1:16:47] where it can be extremely dry. [1:16:49] If it catches fire, my house is going. [1:16:55] So I can tell you, we'll take it up at the Oregon Subcommittee and see what can [1:17:01] Or can't be done here. [1:17:03] Thank you very much. [1:17:04] Thank you. [1:17:08] Any other resident new business or citizen new business? [1:17:12] All right. [1:17:12] Seeing none, the next meeting is scheduled for April 21, 2025. [1:17:16] We're here motion to adjourn. [1:17:18] Go ahead. [1:17:19] Oh, I'm sorry, we have a special meeting on April 1st. [1:17:23] Thank you. [1:17:24] Shoot. [1:17:24] Thank you for reminding me of that. [1:17:27] The next meeting is April 1st at 7pm. [1:17:28] I'll be the special meeting. [1:17:30] And then the next regular meeting is at 21st. [1:17:33] Do I hear a motion to adjourn? [1:17:35] Second. [1:17:36] All in favor, aye.