[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:01] Call to order, public comment, meeting of the 20th birthday commission on Tuesday, July 14th, 2026. It is 6.01 p.m. [0:15] The meeting will be video recorded and archived on the 10th birthday township website, which is www.twp.com. And the public also encourage to access the archived video recording of the meeting on the township website. [0:31] website on your document library meetings and to provide comments about line below. Meeting [0:40] will be also live stream on the Township website and the public has encouraged to access [0:47] the meeting on the Township website's live stream webpage, which is www.twtwp.com forward slash [0:58] live streaming video age that ASPX. All documents are on file and available for public inspection. We have roll call. [1:12] Yes, Mr. Harris. Here, Mr. Newton. Here, Mr. King. Here, Mr. Dworkin. Here. [1:18] Mr. Richner had a personal commitment. At the last minute was unable to attend. Mr. Woods had a work commitment. [1:26] At the last minute was unable to attend Mr. Miles had a previous engagement and was unable to attend notified us well in advance, but you do have a quorum and I do it anticipate Mr. Schrader being here shortly. [1:44] Mr. [1:51] Chair, we have first Mr. Chair if you could swear in Mr. Newton. [1:58] I'm [2:03] going to say it's a good one. [2:16] This is O. The lobby is effective January 1, 2026. [2:21] Throughout December 31, 2033, you would repeat after me. [2:25] I am going to say your name. [2:27] I partly didn't say a second. [2:29] Do solemnly swear or affirm? [2:31] Do solemnly swear or affirm? [2:32] that I will support the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of Ohio. [2:41] And the Constitution of the State of Ohio. [2:43] And we'll faithfully discharge the duties. [2:46] And we'll faithfully discharge the duties of the office of a regular member. [2:51] Of the office of a regular member. [2:53] Of the zoning commission of Tundra or Township. [2:55] And of the zoning commission of Toys of Work Township. [3:01] And then if you could each co-sign. [3:03] Next, [3:34] we have Mr. Chair to swear in Mr. Dworkin. [3:39] That's just for you to swear in Mr. Dworkin to an alternate term. [3:47] This [3:50] will be both as effective January 1st, 2026 to December 31st, 2026 to be active in I and your name. [3:59] and I, Ed very work with salt and smallvir, [4:02] Salami with for grant.... [4:05] I will support the Constitution of the United States [4:08] and I will support the Constitution of the United States [4:11] and the constitution of the state of Ohio [4:13] and the Constitution of the state of Ohio [4:15] through these great starsand duties [4:17] and the fakely discharged of duties [4:20] in terms of stamina and capability [4:23] the office of one all-t 식으로 member [4:25] of the zoning commission of upward time [5:26] We move to approval of minutes, our regular meeting of May 12, 2026 take a few moments to [5:34] I'm going to skip that over. [6:28] I'm over to the group of minutes. [6:30] Stay there, Tuesday. [6:32] Okay, well, second. [6:35] Thank you. [6:36] It was moved by Mr. Newton, seconded by Mr. Dworkin, [6:40] to approve the regular minutes of May 12th, 2026. [6:44] We'll call on that motion. [6:45] Mr. Dworkin? [6:47] For a minute. [6:48] Mr. Newton? [6:50] Yes. [6:51] Mr. Harris? [6:52] Yes. [6:52] Mr. King. [6:53] Yes. [6:53] Motion carries unanimously. [6:54] Firstly, [6:56] next on the agenda is a whole business. [6:59] It provides application for senior residential development and for SRD approval. [7:04] For times farm, they 172 attached independent living senior dwelling units on 40, 285 plus or minus acres. [7:13] Located at 79, 57, Darryl Row, personal number 6, 2, 0, 0, 0, 8, 2, 2. [7:19] Unplated. [7:19] on the east side of Darrow Road, North of Marwell Boulevard, and South of [7:24] Transport Road. The applicant and owner is 7957 Darrow Road, LLC, P.O. Box, 1-1-0-2, [7:34] Shard, Nohi-O-4-4-0-2-4. The zoning commission review commenced on May 2nd, 2023. [7:43] The zoning commission public hearing opened on July 11th, continued on August 1st [7:49] and August 21st and closed on August 21st, all in 2023. [7:56] Zoning Commission, additional public hearing, [7:58] open and closed on November 26th, 2024. [8:02] Zoning Commission, continue review on September 18th, [8:06] October 3rd, October 24th, and November 14th, [8:10] all in 2023. [8:12] Zoning Commission, continue review on January 2nd, [8:16] February 6th, April 2nd, May 7th, January 9th, excuse me, July 9th, July 30th, August 13th, September 17th, September 24th, October 1st, October 15th, October 29th, November 12th, November 26th, and December 10th, all in 2024. [8:41] The zoning commission continues with you on May 12th, 2026, the zoning commission approved determination of eligibility on October 3rd, 2023. [8:55] The zoning commission approved the preliminary SRD plan on December 10th, 2024, and discussion regarding review of the application and next steps. [9:07] So as we move forward, where are we sitting? [9:13] Thank you, Mr. Chair. [9:15] Members, the Commission just to review when you had your last meeting on May 12th, you [9:20] had received application materials at that meeting. [9:24] You asked some initial questions. [9:26] You heard from the applicant and you also heard from the public. [9:30] It was the conclusion at the end of the meeting that in light of the application, just having [9:35] been received that the zoning commission preferred some time to deliberate on that. [9:40] And so the review was continued to tonight's meeting on July 14th. [9:47] No additional information has been submitted, no additional information was anticipated. [9:53] The applicant may have some additional comments to make, clarification to provide or questions [9:59] to answer from the previous meeting if you allow. [10:02] And my suggestion would be to proceed with comments from the applicant, questions from the commission, and then comments from the public if you choose. [10:13] Sure. [10:24] Good evening. My name is John Slater. I'm a legal counsel at the applicant. My address is 950. May [10:31] now I'm in Cleveland, Ohio, 441-3. Thank you for your time and consideration as [10:36] Matt. On as Matt is indicated at the last meeting we spent over two hours [10:43] going through the materials that were submitted and we're here for final plan [10:48] approval. [10:51] All the materials that you received the last meeting were received [10:54] weeks before and timely, but you did need additional time. We did not have an [10:59] objection to that. So we really have nothing further to add. I know you wanted [11:04] more time to review, and we're here to answer whatever questions you may have. [11:08] In particular, we have our engineer here, Chris Schmidt, from David Tree. We have [11:15] our architect, Bob Johnson, who's with us. And also Rick Summers is one of the owners [11:23] of the property and representative of it. I know that, and this is not necessarily related [11:29] to our plan, but during the last meeting, an issue came up about securing the house that [11:35] was there. And I know that, you know, I mean, that was an issue somewhat unrelated to preliminary [11:43] approval, but they asked about our approach to how we're dealing with it. [11:47] And I want Mr. Summers just to respond and give you an update where that is. [11:51] It's been addressed, but just for your benefit. [11:55] I think it's important because there's a good question asked in the audience. [11:58] Thank you. [11:59] First of all, I apologize. [12:00] For how it came off, we immediately got to the meeting, we're in touch with Mr. [12:06] Kegler. [12:06] We've secured the house. [12:08] We've been in constant contact with Mr. Kegler, he has a cell number, and we are addressing [12:13] We probably aren't going to move forward with demolition in the next 30 to 60 days. [12:18] But it has been addressed, and I apologize for how it was handled at the beginning. [12:22] Thank you. [12:23] Thank you. [12:25] We also did have, I think, some of the time we had to break in, run the garage door, [12:30] which has padlocked and closed. [12:32] Sheriff called us, we caught him this weekend. [12:35] The sheriff's also inspected it in the air, and once we secured it, [12:39] asked us to also post test passings on which we did, and they indicated they're going to increase patrols. [12:46] So, again, that's a secondary issue, but I know the members of the public were concerned, [12:52] and they were also the issues raised. [12:56] So, again, apology for the reaction to it. [13:00] Obviously, as you know, this has been good on since 2023, [13:04] And we, you know, on our side, want to focus on the relevant issue, which is this final [13:10] plan approval. [13:12] And just real quick, as it relates to final plan approval, there's really, there was one [13:18] issue that came up at the last meeting, and that relates to an item that one of the conditions [13:24] not to be completed. [13:26] And that's the street lights. [13:27] We have proof that the utility company doesn't have the downlighting that you requested and you want that within the record. [13:36] But there was a comment that maybe this might be appropriate for modification, not have street lights for 100% fine with that. [13:44] If you decide you want to have that modification, then that's fine. [13:49] audit five won't have the street lights as discussed we had a discussion on [13:54] that point also our lights are it's not where individuals control them the [14:00] ones that are on the garage they indicate it so I'm like a normal or some [14:04] internal lights off and if that's concern of the neighbors we have no problem not [14:08] having street lights are most of the neighborhoods dealt because they're not [14:11] necessary so that's one issue that's item 10 the other really the other issue is [14:17] architecture. We provided an objection letter and an issue around that, so we're asking [14:24] for approval without those additional architectural requirements. And what that means, we still [14:30] are doing enhanced architectural requirements, but just not all the way around the buildings. [14:37] We pointed out that, and I gave a legal opinion that there's not authority for the township [14:43] to do that. And so we don't think you have the right to force us to do it. And second of all, [14:52] we don't think they're necessary. On a large portions property, you've got a ravine, [14:57] repair and air is conservation. [15:00] Area. And to have stone or brick all the way around the house one, even our adjoining adjacent woodlands or other things that don't have those types of architectural features doesn't make sense. We do have no, as we do another developments, you know, along the main streets and other areas where you can primarily see them. And again, this is a private drive otherwise. So that being said, the real issue is, you know, we're asking either approval without that upgraded architectural or approval, if you decide, [15:29] condition to on meeting that requirement or goes all the way around. That really is what [15:33] the issue should be tonight. We still object to doing that and we'll decide how we deal [15:40] with it just for the record we do. And we've also asserted in our letter, you know, there's [15:46] some other objections and container objections that we've raised in the past that we're preserving. [15:52] But other than that, it's really hopefully what we're here to address and whatever [15:55] questions you have. Thank you very much. Thank you. [16:04] We're going to move forward to a new business. [16:08] No questions from the commission and then public comment regarding the application if you [16:13] if you choose to enter to. Thank you. Thank you. So any commission members have any questions for [16:19] the applicant? [16:36] Yeah, no questions. [16:44] Chairman, I would simply point out that in terms of the [16:47] architectural treatment, something that the applicant agreed to before, something they [16:52] agreed to under drawings. And I think it's a matter of integrity and reputation. I think [17:02] we should insist on that. And if we move to final approval that we include that as a part [17:10] of it, then it becomes a matter for the applicant to take up with the trustees. So I would [17:17] I would leave it here based on that matter. [17:23] Mr. Kegler, in your letter of May 4th, you said there were four unmet conditions. [17:31] One of them is number 14, I think, locations and typical details for Pios, is that still on [17:39] open item? [17:52] At the time that I wrote the letter on May 4th, at the end of the letter I said condition [17:58] 14 can be met by changes to the plans made by the engineer so I saw that as a minor minor item [18:05] so if there were a motion it would be just to continue that condition so that the [18:13] outstanding item can be met I don't think that the applicant has any issues with meeting that [18:17] it was just an item that I caught and it might even be something that I missed but I would [18:23] I couldn't imagine that it couldn't be resolved here, right? [18:26] We have no objection to that. [18:28] We think we've addressed it, but if not, it just needs to be added to the plan, but [18:32] I believe we've already done that after you're missing detail and you have no direction to [18:37] address the action. [18:41] All the way around. [19:01] And then the cost savings of not panning would have liked it. [19:06] We don't carry your way, so how does cost would we save that in the street lights to [19:28] I believe the savings from streetlights would be significantly higher than that. [19:33] The cost to install a streetlight, the higher quality streetlight that the township requires [19:38] anywhere between $3,000 and $5,000 per street light, then Ohio Edison requires a [19:44] connection fee on top of that. I don't remember the total some total of street [19:48] lights, but I think that it would be in the well over $100,000 if not in 2D hundreds [19:54] of thousands. [20:00] Actually the question Mr. Kegler just I know there was concerns [20:05] There's has to be some concerns about the destiny requirements, as I've been satisfied and as I've been able to let the required destiny requirements. [20:17] Yeah, I believe the density requirements were addressed at the time of preliminary approval. [20:21] either [20:32] the commission or the... or the... [20:35] Not really, I mean at this stage you need to vote, you can either approve it, you can [20:43] deny it, or you can approve it with conditions. [20:46] And you know the attorneys can argue back and forth, I understand, attorneys, slaters, arguments, [20:53] I'll defend whatever you decide. [20:56] So that's all I can say at this point, I'll answer any questions you might have. [21:01] Yeah. [21:01] Thank you. [21:03] Mr. Chairman, I do have two more questions. [21:06] Traffic has been something that a number of residents have brought up as a key issue. [21:12] I went back and looked at the traffic study and the observations that the actual data collection [21:20] was done on October 29th, 2019. [21:25] That's like almost seven years ago with my math is right. [21:30] There has to be some expiration date up from that standpoint. [21:37] I just can't believe that a traffic observations that old would still be valid. [21:44] Particularly, it's pre-COVID. [21:47] The world changed, traffic patterns changed after COVID. [21:50] That's all I have to do on my opinion, but I'm one person who tries to get out on that road. [21:57] It's significantly more difficult. [22:00] I believe that the applicant has decided not to install a bridge in order to come out of the traffic light. [22:10] I wonder why that's the applicant's decision rather than the state DOT or something like that, but that's above my pay grade. [22:20] But it just seems to me that the traffic study did come out and say, [22:26] opposed it a D minus grade at the time. [22:31] And I just think that that absolutely has to be redone. [22:41] And I do have one other point. [22:43] I came across something to in turn of what to run off and things like that. [22:49] that the Army Corps Permit, the letter dated July 14th, 2022, page 1, the third paragraph, [23:00] the Army Corps Permit was valid until March 14th, 20th, 20th, 20th, 20th, 20th, 20th, 20th. [23:29] That's actually a separate request for a presentation that was submitted. [23:34] The request was submitted prior to the last meeting and the commission agreed to hear [23:38] presentation and that's scheduled to be heard under old business or excuse me [23:42] under new business as you move [23:50] forward. Can we move forward into new business [23:53] and honest participation following that? Well, first before you do anything just [24:02] regarding a couple of the comments that were made the applicant I'm sure can [24:08] either through its traffic engineer either verify or re-verify or submit some sort of documentation [24:18] in response to Mr. King's request. [24:22] Secondly, they could do the same regarding the issue, [24:26] regarding the core of engineers' letter. I believe that I can't recall specifically [24:29] that they did go back to the core at some point in time when something else had expired [24:34] and they did verify some sort of continuance of it, so if that's the case then this is [24:38] spec they could do the same. Now, if the commission is of the mind to favorably consider [24:45] a modification for streetlights or a modification to not require streetlights, there's a requirement [24:53] for streetlights, so the modification would be to weigh that requirement and not require [24:57] streetlights. If the commission's in the mind of the mind to favorably consider that I [25:02] I would, it's run through my mind that I would suggest having some language and the modification [25:09] that it be subject to the provision of the security lighting or whatever it is that they [25:14] typically provide. [25:15] I don't have that in front of me, so I need some time to draft that. [25:20] Regarding the architectural requirements, I believe Mr. King had summarized what I would [25:28] have said, which is the contrary to the applicant's assertions regarding whether architectural [25:34] requirements are valid or not. [25:39] They were proposed and they were agreed to by the applicant as a condition to preliminary [25:44] plan approval. [25:45] I think I mentioned at the last meeting that had the applicant asserted the same and said [25:50] they did not agree to it at the time of preliminary plan approval. [25:54] It's quite possible. Nobody knows for sure that the commission's decision could have been different regarding the preliminary plan. We can't go back in time and determine that. [26:02] So in light of the fact that they agreed to do it previously and they were well on their way to complying before they decided not to do that. [26:13] It would be my recommendation to continue the conditions that were required as part of preliminary approval. [26:20] So that would be of the four conditions that remain 3 and 4 relate to the architecture 14. [26:29] I mentioned, I'll go back to 14 in a second, 11 or excuse me, 10 is the street lighting. [26:37] That would, if that goes away, in my opinion it should be replaced by a modification language to be drafted. [26:44] and I would need time to do that and that would leave including conditions three and four regarding architecture and then I did check back my notes. [26:55] The issue regarding condition 14 was that I could not find on the plans where a trailhead detail was located and they did actually... [27:08] I can't remember before or before or after the meeting because there's a lot going on at the time they did [27:14] provide the engineer did [27:16] Contact me and let me point at me on the sheets where it was. I just missed it. So condition 14 [27:23] Has been met so [27:25] When you get to if you get to the point of a motion on [27:29] Final plan approval at a minimum you might have additional conditions. I don't know [27:35] But I would suggest at a minimum continuing conditions [27:39] 3 and 4 and if you choose to replace condition 10 with a modification, that it be subject to a modification to be drafted. [27:49] In light of the three of the five regular members are not here this evening. [27:55] Your next meeting is in three weeks and if at the end of the consideration of this evening, if you're at a point where you think you may be ready to consider some sort of a motion, [28:07] If I have some sort of direction on that, I could draft something that you could consider at your next meeting. [28:13] I have everyone, I don't mean to put you on the spot. [28:16] I've everyone confirmed to attend six of seven to attend at the next meeting, except for Mr. Dworkin, who was unavailable. [28:23] So I did pre-confirm that and we did also pre-confirm this location as well. [28:28] But that would be, in terms of, the presentation was to be handled under as new business afterwards. [28:39] But I would suggest if the commissions of the mine to entertain public comment regarding the application [28:47] before you decide what you're going to do, at least. [28:52] And certainly if you wish to then take new business before you decipher it, do you [28:56] could do that as well? [29:18] First of all, to begin with, obviously, this has been going on [29:23] on a long time. The issues that have been raised here, first of all, as it relates [29:31] to the traffic study, if you want to make that a condition that you provide a [29:37] verification. I think that's fine and sufficient because of the timing. I mean, oh God controls [29:44] that as authority over it, whether we, and they're going to have to live before it for [29:49] any less. And we still have to go through and do final engineering and go through the county [29:55] for all those approval to handle everything else. We're here for zoning site planning. [30:00] So, that can be a condition that you can add to it. And we can also confirm, I did reach out to my client who confirmed with our environmental consultant that we still have time as it relates to under the wetlands permit that's there. But that's an additional penis to confirm it, or if it needs to be renewed, that can be a condition. But again, I don't think a reason for delay. And just like some of the other requirements, the D restrictions and everything else. [30:29] I mean, there's no reason to continue [30:32] with another month about what he has streetlights around. [30:36] One is the utility will not have the downlighting. [30:40] So either allow that or you have a proof of modification [30:44] where you eliminate the streetlights with confirmation [30:47] that there's security lighting be there. [30:50] And your legal counsel, your attachive manager [30:53] can draft acceptable language for the trustees. [30:57] But again, to wait that long, we think it's, you know, at this point is an appropriate. [31:04] We've waited from the last meeting to get to this point. [31:06] There's no new submissions. [31:08] And then now we have, I saw Husky concepts or whatever's report that they provided. [31:15] They asked for a new agenda item, new business, but that's a subterfuge. [31:20] It's basically, they want to read, it was about your zoning code, which doesn't exist anymore. [31:27] And it goes through what we've spent literally years and spent money on experts who are otherwise dealing with these issues. [31:37] And we've already got a preliminary approval, we've been through it. [31:39] And again, there's a point where a decision needs to be made. [31:45] So we're asking for a decision on this old business matter. [31:48] I think it's inappropriate to then go to a new business item or further delay. [31:53] I mean, the fact of the matter is we're asking [31:56] they can make a decision and make a decision tonight on this. [32:00] We've been patient. [32:02] We've all been through this. [32:03] I know it has been easy for any of us. [32:08] But again, another month, another month, it just goes on. [32:11] And this has been significant. [32:13] We talked about before to say, you know, [32:15] the reason we didn't ask for these architectural partners [32:17] was that we did agree to it initially. [32:20] The night it came up, they said, no warning, by the way, by the way, we put them all [32:24] the way around. [32:26] I clients said, sure, that's not a problem, well. [32:28] Then we went through the drip line issues. [32:31] We had to redesign the entire development, literally change units to all that to save six [32:37] or seven trees. [32:38] And these weren't like old trees that are a hundred years old, or redwoods, or just regular [32:42] trees. [32:42] And we suggested, let's just add more trees near the woodlands. [32:46] Some places were up to me make sense, but no. [32:49] So we had to go through a whole redesign, and it's been things like that that have cost significant money, [32:55] which is practically having stone behind these homes, where up against a repairing corridor, [33:04] where you have to be at the precondition to see the other house. [33:07] I mean, some of these things are, I mean, at a point, it doesn't make sense. [33:11] So that's why we're not doing it to try to, we got this or step or not be, you know, honest with the honest things. [33:17] And we're doing it because we just don't think it makes sense. [33:21] So maybe eliminate the requirement that the architecture will be along those areas and [33:26] maybe that, but that's something we can deal with with the trustees. [33:29] We raise that objection. [33:30] And again, I plead to you, we've been here long enough, I'm sure. [33:35] We've all been through it and we would like to see the decision one way or another so we [33:39] can move on. [33:40] Thank you. [34:18] That [34:22] was a motion by Mr. Newton, seconded by Mr. King, move on to new business for the [34:29] moment. [34:33] on roll call on that motion, Mr. Newton, Mr. Harris, Mr. King, Mr. Dorkin, motion carries [34:40] unanimously. [34:45] That's excellent. [34:46] I'll see [34:51] June 27th, 2026 request to present, dated April 8th, 2026, zoning commission [34:58] discussion on May 12th, 2026, zoning commission approval first, on May 12th, 2026, to present [35:05] on July 14th, 2026, with information to be submitted to weeks prior to the meeting with [35:11] presentation limit limited to 30 minutes. Is there a representative? [35:19] You [35:22] would approach the, oh, my name is Steve Hummel. I'm the principal of Huston Concepts [35:44] I'm going to go over here for sure I don't mind if you buy my information right here. [35:53] Maybe, maybe you could, yeah, so people can kind of see what's going on. [35:58] I guess I just didn't set up quite properly. [36:02] You got a fault. [36:04] You want me to move my way around? [36:05] Yeah, that's my fault. [36:07] You know, I'm going to be an audience participant since this is all about me. [36:12] I mean, to be sub-perfuge here. [36:15] I just want to get out some facts the way I see them. [36:18] Again, I have to see a couple of cultural engineers, a master's degree in agricultural [36:28] engineering, they income the University of Kentucky, specializing in swollen water, spend [36:35] time at the EPA, Ohio EPA, and they're consulting from the Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, [36:49] I have worked on all aspects of landfill design from grading, to stormwater management, [36:57] to set them to college youth, so I think I can kind of maybe make my way through this [37:03] a little bit. [37:05] You know, this presentation is good, I'm going to read a little bit, I was in the field a [37:10] I'm going to address the valuation implications of geotechnical, high-religial, and high-religial principles [37:17] as they pertain to the zoning resolution of twins per township, which is a special emphasis [37:22] placed on the most recent adoption and subsequent revocation of chapter 5. [37:28] I heard something about it no longer in the code, that's a problem in my mind, but it is not in the code. [37:34] But I was going to look at that chapter and I wanted to review this chapter [37:39] because there's only one applicant that actually had gotten [37:42] a preliminary plan of approval prior to replication [37:45] or maybe other replication. [37:50] I stated earlier that I'm going to talk [37:51] about three different areas. [37:53] You'll have to call the grading, [37:55] the hydroverological and the hydrology. [37:59] So the mass grading, I mean, I've got some, [38:02] if you've got a copy of this, I indicate section numbers. [38:08] I know you just got it maybe today or yesterday, I don't know, it had been a nice chance to take a look at this more. [38:17] Basically, when we go to his saying, now that we got the grading plan, now we can apply this to the zoning code. [38:25] Because there's things in the zoning code that you just don't see until you can see the grading plan. [38:30] And we got that with the latest submission. [38:32] So a lot of these things that you weighed in on earlier on, [38:35] You really couldn't weigh in on without the grading plan in hand. [38:39] Whether that was, you know, we just got it. [38:43] We got it in October and we finally booked that in January and this is when I started getting [38:48] some of this information because once I got the grading plan that I could really take a good [38:53] look at this, it was degrading for LAMP those. [38:56] So now I can look at the contours prior to development and then after development and you [39:03] You can see right here, and that's what a lot of these things are. [39:07] These are a cut and fill of pre-imposed development, which may not seem important, but it is [39:12] important based on some of the things that we're looking at and zoning. [39:16] In other words, how much can you disturb a site? [39:19] What's considered open space on a site? [39:22] Things of that nature. [39:23] Where can you build? [39:24] If you can't build on a ridge, and they're creating ridges here against my property, they [39:30] will be creating a ridge. [39:32] And so these are some of the things when I talk about changing the contours of the land [39:38] and how they could run contrary to the zoning code, a couple of the zoning inspections, [39:42] 25, 1, 25, 5A, 20.2I and 17.15, that all talks about changing the contours for roads and [39:53] not being able to build on a ridge. [39:56] And basically if you look at the grading and I know you don't have a fronted post-development [40:01] there's a ridge down here where this is my conservation easement and it basically [40:06] to drain the straps off this way and this way so there's a slight ridge there. [40:10] Well they accentuated that ridge right there and this is what we got now. [40:18] We've got a plateau and this is my property over here and now the ridge has been [40:24] accentuated in height and by six feet to build a plateau to stick a park inside [40:29] on top of. So now they're creating a larger ridge and you're not even supposed to build [40:34] on a ridge. So this is what they're doing and they're moving a lot of the earth out by [40:39] excavating imponds. They need this fill and the only way that they can put in this mass [40:45] development with all these roadways is to do this excavation. Not yet if you got to do excavation [40:53] on the sun, but you do two retention basins that are close to that rock, dog, and death [41:00] they need to fill and how I point that out is basically the ponds are barrel pits. [41:07] Now we're all concerned about our groundwater and it might be more well suited if we put [41:13] basins and dry basins or basins that drain out where you have a good soil profile to allow [41:19] some of that water percolate through before it gets to our groundwater yet they're digging deep [41:24] to deep basins in phase two and those basins in phase two are what's required to get the [41:32] fill they need to build the roadways they need. If they didn't dig basins that deep they never [41:39] have to build the roads and [41:44] that's phase two and these are the times they're getting close to bedrock [41:50] there. And you know what, you get close to bedrock that any contaminants in the stormwater [41:55] can easily travel into the bedrock. And this is what we're concerned about because we [42:00] all have well water on old mill. And you know what, according to 2514, which talks about [42:07] utilities, the developer didn't provide us with the ability to get utilities, even though [42:13] it says it in section 2514, from a standpoint, the homeowner to develop your property [42:20] would be to enhance your property, would be to have the ability to get water and sewer [42:25] just like they're putting on this site. [42:28] We're adjacent landholders. [42:30] So these are some of the questions that we see. [42:34] The second one is mass grading and the site may run contrary to specific requires of the [42:39] zoning code. [42:40] Assuming there's a natural ridge, okay, I've talked about that, and that's in the back toward [42:44] me. [42:45] They're really bringing up the site there. [42:49] In other words, we're not working with the layout of land as it talks about in this SRD. [42:53] We're working with open spaces, trying to work roads in with the layout of land. [42:58] That's not what's happening here. [42:59] When you look at my cotton fields, and I've got probably 20 all these different lines [43:04] that criss-cross across here are cotton fields at space two, that's phase one. [43:11] And all those cotton fields indicate there's a fair amount of excavation one, not like [43:17] putting a man through it, but certainly contrary to what this development's all about. [43:22] Along here, they're putting in over a thousand feet of retaining wall. Why? Because they [43:27] have to change to create immediately. That's what a retaining wall is for. And so, that [43:33] is to get the road in, they're putting retaining walls in. When they talk about all this stuff [43:39] with putting a facade around everybody, we're down here as a time-rommel's house in this [43:45] area. This is where they were having trouble. And this is where they were going to put the [43:52] buildings on foundations, which wasn't, we didn't have that as a requirement. That one [43:56] had been allowed. So then they went back and built a retaining wall. See, they're jammed [44:01] up. There wasn't about trees here and there. It's about the 50-foot buffer. They can't [44:05] make the grade to the 50-foot buffer point. This is what this was all about. I called [44:09] three treaties, four treaties. It was about that they couldn't meet that 50-foot buffer. [44:16] So they put a retaining wall next to Rome. Now this is what they just wanted. Just not [44:21] before it. They changed it. Mr. Johnson changed it from foundations, then to a retaining wall, [44:27] shorten the units. Mind you, those four units, I don't believe, are six units over by [44:33] Rommels were considered in the original modification about changing areas, footer areas, another [44:41] it's floor space area, they changed the size of those buildings to make it work I believe. [44:47] We did not provide modification for that and so that's a whole motor issue, they can't [44:53] meet with them, promise. That's just for the side. [44:58] So, I mean, that's... [45:12] I can't see how that would be considered open space. If you look at the definition of open space, that certainly does not meet definition when you look at somebody's cut and bills where the basins are. [45:31] There is not one inch of ground in this area that has not been disturbed and reconfigured, [45:39] but disturbed. [45:40] There's no virgin ground. [45:41] It's not like open space field. [45:43] No, it's highly disturbed, highly disturbed, and I've gotten cut and built, and we can go [45:49] through these later. [45:50] These don't lie. [45:51] I did. [45:52] Before elevations and elevations, this is science folks. [45:56] This does not lie. You can't make games about what I did here. This tells it all. [46:02] And if I were to actually done the cotton field volumes, I would have calculated that they needed this fill to build these roles. [46:09] So anyways, that's that. The grading of the site may be a public safety hazard. [46:16] I want to get to this. It's very important. [46:19] Now they said, well we haven't done stormwater or work per se because the engineering department hasn't seen it. [46:25] but they did show us by their high-tour grading where the emergency spillways are. [46:31] Because emergency spillways are done with open channel, which shows up on grading. [46:36] See? [46:37] Now, the principal spillway, that's a pipe and half. [46:41] Emergency spillways, grading. [46:44] And the emergency spillway runs right down through these two basins of Asian 1092, 1092 [46:50] runs out this way, and then out toward here. [46:54] The sanitary sewer list station is at elevation 1092. [46:58] Four apartment buildings are at elevation 1092, [47:04] that basin vector 1092. [47:07] Now, if we get a heavy storm and it over tops, that emergency spillway has to do its job. [47:13] That means it's going to flood up in the apartments, it's going to get into the sanitary sewer [47:16] list station, and it's going to end up in our well water. [47:19] Now that's a public hazard, according to section 1.1, 1.1, public safety hazard. [47:27] It's right there. [47:29] This doesn't lie. [47:30] They can say that they didn't do the storm water work out yet. [47:33] No, they didn't do the particular out-of-the-wait for that from some economy engineer, but they did [47:37] do this. [47:38] I see it. [47:40] And if you got knowledge of grading, you know what you're looking at, and I know what I'm [47:45] looking at. [47:49] I'm sorry. [47:49] I'm just talking about how it is folks. [47:52] This project should be denied on its face and shame on the people because of the mediation [47:58] process. [47:58] I don't mean that digress. [48:00] The mediation process says people working in good faith as [48:08] an engineer, [48:12] design something [48:12] like that. [48:24] This is with facing and not conflict with purpose of facing. [48:28] Placing out of San Terciu of this station and property management facilities here and here. [48:38] How do you get to it? [48:39] And phase two, you've got to build your road beds. [48:42] That's why they got to ask you to pause. [48:44] That's when you're going to paint your roads. [48:46] How are you going to get to the list station [48:47] without a paint road? [48:49] Are they going to bring your dune barbie [48:50] in the sanitary sewer department to get in there? [48:53] How do you get to the maintenance facility in phase two? [48:55] We do have phasing on this job. [48:57] You can't get to phase two without building your roads [49:00] to do these necessary things. [49:02] That runs counter to phasing. [49:04] Phasing doesn't read that way. [49:05] I'm [49:10] going to go to the highland people [49:13] a lot of the clone pair, [49:19] bearing corridors, varying widths, and go over sections. [49:23] These corridors have explicit regulations placed on them, and it's alluded to, and other sections [49:30] allude to their authority, sections 22, 25b, 25b, 8b, 1. [49:37] Due to the steep streamed bank slopes on the crickets lake located on the north side, [49:48] the steep slopes. [49:49] If anybody in high blocks is properly before many hand-eye, I notice properly, I know it. [49:57] Prior to walk this site, the zoning inspector, everyone of you guys that sit on this board, [50:02] should walk this site, the engineer should have walked this site. [50:05] People don't notice the garage door still open, that's been secured by the way. [50:10] Still open. Let's see, see that blue line? That indicates that the repair is on. That's third, [50:18] That's 24% slope in there, 28% slope in here, now you're getting into something where [50:25] you've got to add the repair in zone. [50:28] That takes out what did I say in here, 11C, 11D, 13A, B, C, D, 16A, 16B, 16C. [50:38] Because the steep slope is your own average, the applicant said 7% slope might be up here [50:44] Where it's by the road or degraded it an application says for offense on time's farm for offense [50:50] What you're gonna put a fence there? Is this what you did? No, no, no, you don't take averages [50:55] There's 28% slow right there and if you reach after 22 22.2 we have authority [51:04] You guys right in front of authority [51:06] to deny [51:08] give no approvals [51:11] when they encroach on repairing corridors and you have the backing of the [51:16] Summit County Prosecutors Office in the full authority of that office right [51:34] there [51:34] that [51:43] golds that goes down by Randy Willers that's really steep that's a [51:50] repair in zone and I contend and I've walked that site that their repair in zone [51:54] should carry all the way across the project has been farmed into but in reality things [52:00] Things have changed, but that would be construed in my mind from a technical aspect as a [52:05] repair and so on. [52:06] It just didn't truncate there. [52:08] I blocked that. [52:09] So no, it traveled all the way across and through the woodlands back in here. [52:14] So whatever. [52:15] But they said it's there. [52:16] I would argue that a little bit. [52:18] What have you? [52:18] It doesn't matter right there that basins in a repair and so on. [52:22] Those three things that deny this [52:42] is not subjective. [52:43] What's [52:45] this? It is not subtracted. What's the word? This is seven great science class could do this. [52:53] I'm going to tell you the science in seventh grade is his homily guy right. [52:58] And that's the other side. It's [53:05] all important. [53:15] 204 units. First looked at this in the bowl to 204 units. [53:21] Oh my gosh. That's a 25 seven. [53:25] They're very simple. Very simple calculate. [53:30] I guess that's some of the great signs, even today's date. [53:38] We're going to talk about 257, talk about gross area, [53:42] environmental features area, modified gross area, net building area, [53:46] four or three things. [53:47] And [53:50] here is 85% of the modified gross area. [53:55] And where the modified gross area is, you know, [53:59] mine is taken away from the gross area. [54:03] When you look at the EFA definition, [54:07] It talks about it basically, and you can read it if you've got the zoning code, which [54:12] is hard to find chapter 25 actually now. [54:15] It's really hard. [54:16] You can't find it online anymore, but whatever. [54:19] But [54:27] the update definition, basically, and the developers' plans, which this [54:37] one here, [54:45] what [54:45] they came up with was, we'll get to that. [54:47] What [54:51] I'm going to say is, as she's showing her pair of insons, open space basins, 50-foot [54:57] perimeter, buffer gas lines, et cetera, I come up with an EFA phase one, phase two, and [55:04] total sight. [55:06] Okay, now there could be some subjective argument in that EFA number, okay, [55:18] acres. [55:19] We've got, like, your [55:22] area inson, a lot of creeks, a lot of steep gulches, a lot of woods, [55:27] a lot of open space, there were vacions, all this stuff, you can't, that's EFA. [55:32] According to definition, that's EFA, read it, simple. [55:39] You can't have your cake and eat it too, folks. [55:43] EFA, one, two, and EFA, total 19 point, my name. [55:47] The gross area, according to the survey, which I had a heck of a time getting that survey, [55:52] just remember going chain and length, could never get it, could never get it, they never [55:57] or did consolidate that survey that the guy did, [56:00] some of the pins didn't match mine. [56:02] My survey had done so many times [56:04] for my conservation easement. [56:06] I bought it, I'm probably, [56:07] but that's neither here nor there. [56:10] Gross area according to developers plans, [56:12] phase one, 19, 287, phase two, 298, [56:16] total phase 40, 285, okay. [56:20] So now we can go ahead and do the simple calculation [56:23] with one other little caveat here, [56:25] which is unit 8 for step 25's purposes. [56:36] Test line unit counts as .2 units as fins attached, which we don't have any [56:41] details. So .2 dwelling units, according to the definition of .257 F, the [56:47] achievable density, I don't know who calculated it for you guys, is calculated by [56:53] dividing that billable area by .2. That's how you get it, because two tenths, [57:01] So I did it in the calculation, here we go, here we go, we're, so overall density would be 0.85g minus 8 times that, [57:13] divided by 0.02, so overall density of days 1, 61.5 units, rounded up to 62, rounded down to 61, whatever. [57:23] a road density phase two 71.5 units. So a road density of the entire site, 133 units, [57:35] 133. Now, what do we have? [57:47] Continued? Sure. Five of the developers 10 [57:55] for one 72 units. [57:58] I got 61. For two, the phase two hundred units, [58:06] 175 units. Now they reach the [58:08] 175 unit number, [58:13] environmental factors area of 0.49, [58:26] look at this, [58:35] it's a seemingly low [58:39] transmission on that subject and [58:43] do about that when [58:56] the seventh grader could have come [58:57] up with a number of much less than 100. [59:04] And feeling with this is a resident, a concern [59:06] resident, for five years as well. You know, I haven't dumped the money into it, but that's [59:11] what you do with [59:14] all of this thing. And I'm concerned, [59:31] permanent water pool, where vegetation [59:33] is used to close to 8 feet and with the floor elevation near the bedrock versus dry basins [59:39] where an enhanced water quality prior to being introduced into the groundwater should [59:44] be investigated. [59:45] And I give some numbers, some section numbers. [59:47] And we just saw about trying to treat the stormwater as well. [59:51] Why do we dig that? [59:52] So we know, I explained that to you earlier, the hydrological impact on downstream flows from [59:58] in the development. [59:59] A J- [1:00:00] Section 2, the land of properties and the structure should be evaluated, especially when a list [1:00:05] station is downstream of the stormwater management facility, like I pointed out, over here, [1:00:14] I know. That's important. And we're talking about stormwater quality, and it is talked [1:00:20] about there. You need to make an assessment on that, which they never did. [1:00:27] Sorry about that, [1:00:28] Okay guys, everybody wait for it. [1:00:32] I won't go. [1:00:36] You know that's, sorry Mr. Chair, just so Mr. Humble's aware in fairness, five minutes [1:00:42] of the original 30 minutes are remaining. [1:00:44] I appreciate your clock in the end now. [1:00:48] Actually the commission said the time I did not. [1:00:51] I've finished up a part of the comment if I have to. [1:00:54] The hydrological impact, groundwater, the surrounding residents to the North and East of [1:01:00] of frozen development rely solely on well water for their consumption. [1:01:04] This being said, any impacts on the quality and quantity of groundwater [1:01:07] in the vicinity of rivers can pass on our water supply. [1:01:11] To mitigate the safeguard against the potential pollution of this commodity, [1:01:15] careful consideration of all the design features should be thoroughly evaluated [1:01:18] prior to approvals, which had been talked about. [1:01:21] We never got it okay from the groundwater people we hired out. [1:01:25] With that section's 1-1, 25-1, 25-4, 25-5-A and 25-5-D, also [1:01:35] stated in section 25-14 that the [1:01:38] Vellper shall provide access to utilities for adjacent property owners for development [1:01:42] upgrades to their problem. [1:01:44] I brought that up before. [1:01:46] Husky concepts assume sanitary sewer and water are construed as utilities. [1:01:52] I would construe those as utilities. [1:01:56] Did anybody get offered utilities on all of them? [1:01:59] That's adjacent identities. [1:02:01] An additional source of groundwater contamination potential is added to the plant after [1:02:06] the preliminary plant approval. [1:02:08] By the way, if they added these little basins in, they're called retention cells. [1:02:14] Right here and right here, ones in the repairing zone, ones here. [1:02:19] Why? [1:02:19] We're worried about groundwater recharging, yeah, good water groundwater recharging, somebody [1:02:23] threw those in. [1:02:25] And they're calling them bioretension cells. [1:02:27] Now folks, I would argue that that's not really how our attention to self-function, because [1:02:33] those things are dug to below, if you look at the elevations, they're dug below the [1:02:40] stream bed elevation, which means they're below the stream bed, which means that's where [1:02:45] groundwater comes in and out, they're that deep, you're going to crack it into bedrock to [1:02:49] do that. [1:02:50] You're just introducing pollutants potentially into there. [1:02:53] A borrowed pension cell would have vegetation on top, it would have a good tilt of soil, [1:02:59] you know, like a wetlands, that's our retention, that's how it functions, that's not that, [1:03:06] that's just a place that added pollutants potentially. [1:03:11] The main stormwater basins and phase two are dug to adopt approaching bedrock, thus creating [1:03:16] an enhanced pathway for surface water and their groundwater via the highly fractured [1:03:21] chair and conglomer, Fedrock, the geologic formation throughout Ohio P.A. [1:03:26] Maryland. [1:03:27] Why big basins of D? [1:03:29] Electologically speaking, dry basins, basins, atoms, true power, tantrum basins [1:03:34] would serve much better for an environmental standpoint based on the set of [1:03:38] circumstances that hand on sky concerning adjacent properties. [1:03:43] Tantral, reason, worn out by the numerous cut fill analysis. [1:03:49] I did 20 cut fills, like I said, these fellows know, or the engineer knows, what you do with those, and how you do it. [1:03:58] I did enormous amount of those, and basically the developer needs these permanent holes because they're basically digging borrow pits. [1:04:10] They need the fill. [1:04:11] They needed to do this big amount of excavating. [1:04:17] So, I'm going to just say at the end, [1:04:19] it summaries a current design criteria based on current zoning [1:04:22] resolution in twinsburg township. [1:04:24] And best management practices are inedible in various respects. [1:04:29] And at least one case, the repair and corridor relations, [1:04:35] the full weight of the summer conference prosecutor's office [1:04:37] is available to aid in a resolution where all parties are acting [1:04:42] in good faith which is a conditional sign language. Now, 7% slope. I'm not going to say [1:04:49] anybody did anything with purpose and intent, but what I'm saying is an engineer. There's [1:04:56] best management practices, work, perform care, and I'm not going to go out on a good faith [1:05:03] road. All I can say is when those three things, when popping off of there, when I was talking [1:05:09] about gold overall density, and we took over around that, I think other residents asked [1:05:14] about that. [1:05:16] Right there. [1:05:17] I [1:05:21] have to deny. [1:05:22] I'm just saying, if you deny, there's no one other bite of the apple. [1:05:25] See, when the mediation process reaches, you all should have read very carefully up front [1:05:29] here. [1:05:30] Not just the attorney in L.U. because it's common language, they were given the opportunity [1:05:37] to never revision. [1:05:38] They should have gone long in heart. [1:05:39] Basically, they said they changed a lot of stuff and they might change some stuff on [1:05:43] But this footprint was always the same, basically always the same that footprint was. [1:05:51] So he's never road coming through here and they couldn't get it in because they're repairing it. [1:05:55] So they're going to put the sprinklers there. [1:05:57] Now, as anybody asked about, is there anything in there that says, [1:06:01] if they're not willing to do the facade, what about that expensive commercial sprinklers? [1:06:05] That were in order for them not to put a second road in. [1:06:08] Funny [1:06:15] to put them commercial sprinklers in. [1:06:17] If they're not willing to do the facade, are they going to do the sprinklers? [1:06:20] Let's make sure there's enough of what I said here that I I mean that's just me I [1:06:26] can't see anything else but to say tonight it's tonight and if it's if you [1:06:32] gotta come to a different conclusion members [1:07:13] or other persons a consideration of [1:07:16] others who may wish to be heard all speakers will be asked to limit their [1:07:19] comments and questions to five minutes. A person may speak again subject to the [1:07:24] of the chair. Once all comments and questions have been received by the commission, the chair [1:07:30] may allow for questions to be answered by the committee. [1:07:35] Written comments will be considered at committee and provided that they are received, not later [1:07:39] than 4 p.m. on the date of the meeting. Written comments may be submitted by email to [1:07:44] at www.twp.com by FACS at 330-9636-8164-Mail to 1790 Enterprise Parkway, [1:07:56] it turns out to be a lot of 44087. [1:08:02] As you stand to speak, please give your name and address, [1:08:06] and please direct everything towards the front. [1:08:13] Mr. Harris, question first. [1:08:15] Matt Eppley could not be here tonight, and he asked one of us, one of his neighbors to [1:08:22] present on his behalf. [1:08:23] Could I do that on his behalf? [1:08:26] Yes, that I think. [1:08:27] Has now come to a 4-foot mic time. [1:08:30] Okay. [1:08:30] Okay. [1:08:31] For Matt Eppley, and I'm paraphrasing, but he's very concerned about the access to a property [1:08:40] when there's only one ingress and one ingress and the roads are narrow. [1:08:45] And the type radius turns also prohibit getting a lot of EMS equipment in and out. [1:08:56] So switching now, my name is Lynn Clark. [1:08:59] I live at 2485, old, no road. [1:09:04] Comment that I've got question that I've got observation. [1:09:08] However you want to categorize it. [1:09:09] is we paid the township trustee paid to have a hydrogeologic consultant come out and they [1:09:17] concluded until we see the detailed plans, we don't know if there's a risk to ground [1:09:21] water contamination or not. It would be a huge mistake to move forward without them certifying [1:09:31] we've reviewed the detailed plans and we found them to be safe. [1:09:36] Number two, a couple of weeks ago, they are two before 4th of July, loud, loud explosion. [1:09:51] And I'm sure everybody is very aware of that. [1:09:53] I thought my neighbors were just celebrating a little bit early, but the thing that I have [1:10:00] not heard addressed whatsoever is what are we going to do about the gas line safety, both on this property [1:10:08] and how are we going to safely navigate the proposed drilling of the sewer line [1:10:19] through the country club because they've got a very large main going through [1:10:24] the country club. [1:10:29] I'm sure nobody wants to have another gas explosion and I [1:10:33] don't think whatever the rules say that this should be approved until everybody [1:10:41] has consensus. Now, Twinsburg City has banned this horizontal drilling. Hudson has banned the [1:10:50] horizontal drilling and since the sewer line has to be horizontal drilled through the golf course [1:10:58] why we even look at this if they can't have sewerage for that facility. [1:11:11] The last thing, of course, [1:11:13] This is these permits from the Corps of Engineers don't necessarily happen and they [1:11:23] do not happen overnight just because you would like them to. [1:11:29] Again, like Steve, been a professional environmental engineer for 50 years, worked with regulatory [1:11:39] agency's everywhere. Nothing happens overnight. [1:11:46] It is relative to find it very [1:11:50] disturbing. The applicant offers up years these improvements to enhance the [1:11:55] desire ability of this to the community and then they pull back on that [1:12:00] promise and you just wonder what else are they going to pull back on. [1:12:15] Thank you for [1:12:16] I kind of want to piggyback on what Lynn was just saying there about the architectural. [1:12:21] I agree with Mr. King or Mr. Cable, that it should keep that condition and force them to [1:12:27] do that. [1:12:28] I think it's important to go back as to why that was important to us and I think it's [1:12:33] residents. [1:12:34] We all looked at Wilcox Meadows and if you look around Wilcox Meadows, it's like a barracks. [1:12:40] No one wants to live next to that. [1:12:41] It was really unsightly to see and we didn't want that to happen here. [1:12:45] So those were some of the reasons that the public came up and you guys put that [1:12:48] condition in an aggregate. Now the lawyers can tell you whether or not they're [1:12:53] stopped or waved at that argument that it's you know about 40 to do it. That's [1:12:58] up the lawyers it's not potentially later so I think you guys should keep that. As [1:13:03] far as the lighting less lights the better you know for me as an adjacent home [1:13:08] order. You know, I just do a way of that. Last thing I just say is I want to thank Steve for his [1:13:15] compassion is advocacy and same thing with me. [1:13:27] 2520 on the road. [1:13:31] I felt the state did a really good [1:13:33] job with his presentation. It was very well thought out. Again, I am concerned now more so. [1:13:42] I don't live as close to the proposed development but it's only a few hundred feet away. [1:13:49] So my groundwater might well also be affected. [1:13:54] I also have a stream that goes through the property [1:13:58] and that will also be contaminated here. [1:14:01] So it would affect me directly if there is some runoff [1:14:04] or if there's a storm like we typically have in the area [1:14:07] where on that idea swells by about two feet. [1:14:13] My neighbor who's not here, but I know that is basically [1:14:16] gets flooded every now and then. So he would have sewage within his base. So I'm very concerned [1:14:25] about the aspects that Steve has pointed out. And if you do have the authority tonight, [1:14:36] it seems to me it is the right thing to do just based on the signs that it was presented. [1:14:46] That's a, I'll [1:14:53] take it a little time, that was not hydrologic anyways, but as far as the lighting issue. [1:15:00] I agree. The less likes the better. This is Steve Hummel. 2500, no, no, no, let's not. Sorry. I agree. [1:15:09] Less likes the better, but the thing about it is the way we went by the modification issue. [1:15:15] You know, I mean, when you read it in there under traditional use, it says number one, [1:15:20] All outdoor luminaries must be used in this kind of development of the units, too. [1:15:31] It doesn't just mean street lights, so, you know, to me it's like to allow them to [1:15:37] put lights from Ohio Edison in, that would require the modification. [1:15:43] Not the other way around, see, I think it was at that work, and the issue with Ohio [1:15:49] Now, Edison, I get it, if you want to use Ohio Edison, it's fine, but not get it in [1:15:53] the township code. [1:15:54] It talks about the utility, but this is a private property, folks. [1:15:58] This is not like a public subdivision, anybody could put that in as long as the U.L.C. [1:16:06] rated now. [1:16:07] I mean, they could get any kind of lighting, Ohio Edison will do the work in charge of you, [1:16:11] but they don't have to provide the lighting as long as it's safe. [1:16:15] Is it costly? [1:16:16] Yeah, those kind of lights are more costly. [1:16:18] And so that's the one thing, the other thing I'd like to speak on a little bit is the gas lines. [1:16:23] I mean, not only, you know, on some of them cut and fills, they're getting, there's a six inch main that goes through this property [1:16:32] and there's some ones that feed off the wells. [1:16:35] There's a well they cut through north and south, the six inch main runs kind of along the woodlands. [1:16:41] There's an access road there. [1:16:42] You have to be 50 feet away from that with your units. [1:16:50] I mean, even though it's a gravel dirt road, whatever, that still has to have a 50 foot [1:16:54] tuffer. [1:16:55] They don't provide that there. [1:16:57] And that tank front is in there as being left in there. [1:17:00] You've got to be a hard feet away from that. [1:17:03] You know, a hard feet away from that tank front with your buildings and the well itself, [1:17:09] even if it's plugged or not, you have to be a hard foot away from that. [1:17:12] It is not on those apartments when I got out there there within 15-20 feet of the plug [1:17:18] well if it's even plugged. [1:17:19] The other thing I wanted to impress upon you is that the guy that owned that private [1:17:24] system no longer owns it so any kind of relationship he had with the developer may not be the same [1:17:31] as the new gas triller that got the new owner because we are on all over here or some of us [1:17:37] got like letters and this guy's trying to get wells going and so you know he's got [1:17:46] to make gas line going across there. Now I'm showing on that I think I have a [1:17:50] major assumption forward deep down the gas flow run across the property blow [1:17:54] frost line. There's some cotton fill in that and I mean I thought why like I said [1:17:58] we're there within a foot of that six inch maybe by that scabane. Now let's say the [1:18:07] guy says, hey, I'm not going home and I'm going to really get my system going again. [1:18:16] He could say, [1:18:17] I've got a 20 foot easement. You're not moving earth. I'm patching that. This whole design [1:18:24] would be over. What I'm saying is, when you look at the gradient and cut and fill that, if he said [1:18:30] 20 foot, a thousand feet, where it runs to your property, you've got to lead that along. [1:18:37] You might as well just throw those in the garbage can and start over. They can't start over. [1:18:42] These are all of the things where the mediation is important. It's not like this chap is in our zoning code anymore. [1:18:49] And this is like, you guys have got to know this. Okay, it's private individuals and this is what we always hear like with the sewer and this and that. [1:18:57] But if you have no letter, you don't know this guy can say no. Thanks, but no badge. We're going to be running an ad. We don't want you digging around it. We don't want you creating around it. [1:19:06] And so, those are the things that are very important. [1:19:10] My especially everyone has had, and I think that that and then the issue with agriculture [1:19:18] getting back to, you know, my property is zoned out, it's, I have a CFA on my property [1:19:24] and it's like, you know what? [1:19:26] You can't be changing the drainage on my land, the way they've got this graded, now when [1:19:31] water comes off, near that third basin back there where the Santeres who are left stationed [1:19:35] is the way they changed the whole grade, I used to have about, I'd say maybe a quarter [1:19:41] acre or a half acre at the most have run up for their property coming out of mine. Now [1:19:46] there's more. [1:19:49] This is the change in grade is another issue in the zoning that we didn't [1:19:54] know about until we looked at the grading plans. So all those things, and now I think that's [1:19:59] section 17, and it's in conditional use of grade. You can't change drainage on somebody's land. [1:20:04] I don't know, I'm just a hydrology, but you can't actually change the drainage pattern. [1:20:09] And that's what they've done on the back of my land, just because it's an easing. [1:20:12] You don't get to do it when I'm doing that work. [1:20:15] And so those things, I mean, it goes against the cold. [1:20:20] I mean, I just can't, I just, I'm just telling what I see, and I can't say anymore. [1:20:27] I mean, I don't make this stuff up. [1:20:28] I see what I see now, I might be off a little bit, but I'm giving you my assessment. [1:20:33] That's the assessment. I'm not doing this because, yeah, I'm a concerned resident. [1:20:38] So these are all the things that I know. I've done a lot of review when I worked in Chambers [1:20:45] for Pennsylvania. We were a concept engineer for a lot of little townships in Pet P.A. and [1:20:50] I reviewed a lot of stuff. And I was always a stickler. There's nothing wrong with that. [1:20:57] I just appreciated it. And I'm going to let it go. [1:21:06] If you want fairway Boulevard cuts in Ohio, four, four, two, three, six, I am the president [1:21:12] of the Fairway Home Fundamenting Association and as you all know, if you live in the area, [1:21:19] the explosion, the gas explosion happened affected quite a few number of our moms too. [1:21:26] Not just the ones in the woodland, we're very sorry about the three homes that were destroyed [1:21:30] entirely. [1:21:32] We have three homes directly behind the gas explosion hall in the other two that had sustained [1:21:39] really substantial damage. [1:21:44] We don't even know if they're going to, two of them are going to be able to be repaired. [1:21:48] So maybe they may have to be torn down. [1:21:50] Not for sure. [1:21:55] And we have 14 homes in our condominium association that are in transfer of tanship [1:22:00] and two others that are not part of our company in the association, that's them. [1:22:04] It's 16 homes. They're in Cleansburg, Shack Township, and back up to the woodlands. [1:22:12] And we have probably a total of about 12 to 14 homes that have sustained some sort of damage. [1:22:20] Not the extensive damage, but it's sustained structural damage too. [1:22:26] I bring all this up because for the fairway home's division we have two ways in and out. [1:22:34] We have fairway boulevard by open numbers and down the road of peace we have Renhaven. [1:22:40] So none of our people were stuck there if they had to be. [1:22:45] I need to turn about the woodlands when that gas explosion happened, all I could think of [1:22:49] It's like, they've all got one way out. [1:22:51] Let's say we're going to run out the back, [1:22:53] you know, through the yards. [1:22:56] And this development will have the same problem. [1:22:59] They're going to have one way in and one way out, [1:23:02] and I've had a problem with that from the start. [1:23:05] I really think it should be by the light that transfered [1:23:08] road. [1:23:09] I know it's got the reasons not to put it there, [1:23:11] but that's where that should have been. [1:23:13] I appreciate what Mr. Clark said and to him, Mr. Eckley, [1:23:17] about the inability to get in and out. [1:23:22] And also, Mr. Clark runs up the gas line, [1:23:26] which happens to go through mine ever good. [1:23:29] Okay, it's a massive gas line, [1:23:31] and it does go into the country club's property, [1:23:34] which is exactly where they want to put that sewer line [1:23:36] across the back of part of our property. [1:23:41] Hopefully Hudson City will continue to keep [1:23:45] What they've already put in about not allowing that directional drilling so they won't be able to put it in through that way. [1:23:51] I don't know where they're going to put it. That's an issue they're going to have to deal with. [1:23:56] I appreciate the time. Thank you. [1:24:06] I was marking off the $21.89. [1:24:13] First I'm going to echo the safety issue. [1:24:16] I was in my house a block and a half away when the explosion happened. [1:24:21] You really should consider that because what was sued afterward was chaos on one narrow [1:24:28] street going down. [1:24:30] Fortunately, there were minimal injuries and no casualties. [1:24:35] Had it been even worse, I can't imagine how they were going to cross because people wanted [1:24:41] to get out and hurt to me, they told me to get out and it was chaotic. [1:24:45] Okay, high on the house, around the corner, 150 yards away from there, I've ran to make [1:24:52] sure my corner attendance now wonders that I'm okay, it was chaos there. [1:24:58] There's no room in an alley with a one-way. [1:25:01] Okay, second point. [1:25:05] Mr. Kepler made the comment that the density requirements were met at the time of the preliminary approval. [1:25:13] I've attended a number of meetings, we've brought up density, we've asked what the density [1:25:19] calculation is, aside from the applicant, it's never been addressed. [1:25:24] On May 12th I couldn't attend, I asked Mr. Schrader virtually what the density calculation [1:25:32] was. [1:25:32] You said you didn't know and you don't want to do it, and when we've asked in the past it's [1:25:39] never come up. [1:25:40] So thank you, Mr. Hummel, for at least taking us through. [1:25:43] I don't understand how you can take it to a boat [1:25:47] until we have a representative party [1:25:50] for the township outside of the township [1:25:53] that shows us what the density calculation really is. [1:25:57] Mr. Hummel just represented that it's 24% different. [1:26:04] That's significant. [1:26:06] 24%. [1:26:07] Okay. When you build a house, you have to meet all the requirements. How are we having [1:26:16] conditional requirements in lieu of approval ahead of time? I don't understand that. As a [1:26:22] private citizen, you have to meet all the requirements up front in the approval process. So we should [1:26:29] to ask the same about the applicant, to meet all of the requirements. [1:26:36] I do want to ask this question. [1:26:40] Before we bring anything like this to a vote, I think the public needs to feel confident [1:26:51] that there's no conflict of interest before a vote takes place. [1:26:57] So, I'd like to raise a hand. Who on his own in commission, including Mr. Kegler, has [1:27:05] an active township, conflict of interest document on record in the office sign. [1:27:15] Well, that's something we'll go through as we answer all these questions. We won't do [1:27:19] a raise of hands or anything along those lines, but that question will be logged and as we [1:27:23] answer these questions. We'll put that to be answered as well, because if you don't, I have the [1:27:31] Tomship Conflict of Interest document here and I would sincerely ask you to consider sign in [1:27:40] front of the public, if you don't have one. [1:27:51] Thank you, Mr. King. Lintbark 2485 will no [1:27:54] wrote, there was one additional comment I wanted to add because I heard the oath of office [1:28:01] tonight twice. And it says, we're going to hold the laws of the state as well. Ohio [1:28:07] revised code 6111 says, drainage patterns cannot be changed to Steve's comment earlier. [1:28:16] If he's going to get more run-off or less run-off, then he currently has. That would [1:28:24] would be a violation of 61 to let. [1:28:27] But [1:28:38] it's participation portion of the day's meeting. [1:28:49] Thank you, Mr. Chair. [1:28:51] Here [1:28:54] with the document that Mr. Marchando is referring to, [1:28:59] so if you can pass it along, we'll be happy to take a look [1:29:03] at it, have attorney Schrader look at it, see. [1:29:05] I'd like to see it too. [1:29:08] I represent about 50% of the university [1:29:11] more of these things. [1:29:12] Thank you. [1:29:13] A few of the comments that had been passed along, both during the new business presentation [1:29:22] as well as during public comments here, that I believe would be worthy of the commission's [1:29:30] consideration, just in my opinion, one would be Mr. Clark's earlier comment about the township's [1:29:37] tighter geology consultant certify whether it would be possible for them to certify something [1:29:45] in relation and as a result of the plans that have been subsequently submitted, I think [1:29:51] that it could certainly be arranged that the plans that are now in the township's possession [1:29:57] and we can engage that consultant to just... [1:30:00] To take a look at those, the way they did before, and provide any additional comments, if that's the will of the commission. In addition, the comments during new business about the buyer retention cells within the riparian quarter appreciate Mr. Hummel, bringing, bringing that to the attention, I would need to consult with some of some water to see if that is a permissible, permissible improvement. [1:30:29] within the repairing corridor regarding, [1:30:38] we already, several people, [1:30:40] people mentioned the Corps of Engineers Permits and also the Mr. King's comments [1:30:48] about the traffic study and [1:30:53] then there were comments made about the street [1:30:55] lights, the comments that were made about the sanitary installation and excavation [1:31:02] for the sanitary installation that would be something that would be under the purview [1:31:07] of some county department of sanitary sewer services as well as within the purview [1:31:13] of the city of Hudson where it goes through the boundaries through the city of Hudson [1:31:18] so the township does not have jurisdiction over that I did want to clarify there were some [1:31:24] comments that whose [1:31:34] first initial is S. Oh, [1:31:39] that was Steve, sorry. Mr. Hummel's comments [1:31:43] was about the gas lines and safety. I think the gas lines, Mr. Hummel, I can't read my [1:31:48] own notes. The gas lines, I believe the gas lines, Mr. Hummel was talking about where [1:31:53] the gas lines on the property. And they go from the oil and gas wells to the, both out [1:32:01] to the pressure station out at 91. [1:32:05] They also, there are service lines that also serve other properties along Old Mill Road [1:32:11] and elsewhere, I don't know if Mr. Grione is one of them, but a few others are as well. [1:32:18] But this Newton from the Fairways made comments about a line, a gas line, I believe, the line [1:32:27] that Ms. Newton is referring to as a different gas line, that is a high pressure gas line. [1:32:31] that goes along the boundary between Hudson and [1:32:36] Twinsburg Township. [1:32:38] If you get to Okan Embers, right at the boundary line, [1:32:43] and you look in either direction, you can see that the trees are cleared for miles, [1:32:48] and that there are two pipelines in that area. [1:32:50] One is originally like a San oil pipeline, and the other is, [1:32:55] they're both transcontinental, and they're both high pressure. [1:32:57] It's always been explained to me that if you touched one of those, you know, everyone within miles would be gone. [1:33:07] But they've been there for 50 or more years, but that's the way it is. That's what those colored things are sticking out of their ground. [1:33:16] That's why whenever somebody puts their playground equipment on top of it, we have a little knock on the door and says, hey, you might want to move that out of there. [1:33:24] It's not good for the kids to be playing there, but those were two comments from two different people about two different gas lines. [1:33:30] I just want to make sure there was no confusion about that. Back to Mr. Humbles comments about the gas lines, the oil and gas wells in the township that were owned by most recently by D&D energy. [1:33:44] D&D energy were sold in the fall to a new company and the applicant has represented in the past that they. [1:33:54] They've made arrangements or would make arrangements with the owner of the wells to plug or cap the wells or whatever would be permitted. [1:34:03] And I think some reconformation of that would be, they've already represented it on the plans. [1:34:10] But certainly I've spoken with the owner, the new owner of the wells. I haven't spoken with them about that, but that's something that could be confirmed as well. [1:34:23] The issues regarding, just as since it was raised regarding the explosion and everything [1:34:31] that happened a few weeks ago and what adjacent communities have done regarding some [1:34:38] call it directional drilling, some call it horizontal drilling, there's different names [1:34:41] for it. [1:34:42] But the township went further than that to cover all excavation period with a shovel and not just drilling but everything else. [1:34:53] But it applies within township rights of way. [1:34:56] It does not apply on private property. [1:34:58] That's why we've worked with all the homeowner associations to make them aware of what the townships done [1:35:03] and encourage them to do the same thing on their private roads as well. [1:35:15] And last [1:35:21] comment that Mr. Clark had made about our rise code 6111, I think that's more [1:35:28] of a legal question and we can certainly get to the bottom of that and whether there's [1:35:34] a violation that's been alleged and whether that is something that is actually a current [1:35:40] or not. [1:35:43] But back to my original comments to you after you asked questions and before you went to [1:35:53] new business and then public comment, we came into this meeting with the information [1:36:02] that you received a month or so ago. And four of 16 conditions to be addressed. One was [1:36:13] addressed. That was my mistake. That was the one regarding something on the plan so [1:36:17] that I just didn't see. The condition regarding street lighting is something that if you're [1:36:23] of the mind not to require it, that it would be, it could be handled as a modification. [1:36:28] but with language in it regarding security lighting and [1:36:32] requiring that that security lighting be down-directed as is required but [1:36:38] also as was alluded to by and Mr. Homo's comments. The remaining two [1:36:45] architectural comments I would still recommend that those be continued and but [1:36:51] there were additional items that were raised this evening first in Mr. [1:36:58] other kings earlier comments, but then secondly in the wealth of comments that came after [1:37:03] that. Those included the verifying or re-verifying or whatever the terminology would be, the [1:37:12] traffic study, the verifying [1:37:19] or re-verifying or re-certifying the Corps of Engineers wetland [1:37:23] permit letter that had an expiration date of March of this year. [1:37:30] Investigation regarding the improvements that are shown within the riparian corridor [1:37:35] and then engaging hydrogeology consultant if it's the purview of the commission to [1:37:45] recertify that or review the information that's been subsequently submitted and as I mentioned [1:37:52] earlier even just with the conditions that were before you and the modification that might [1:37:57] have been proposed if you weren't even considering anything else, I was suggesting that some time [1:38:05] to draft potential motion for the commission's consideration. But there's been a few additional [1:38:12] items that have been brought up for consideration this evening that I'd be happy to look into and [1:38:18] trying to get that information for your next meeting. Your next meeting is, less time [1:38:22] than it would normally be between now or between your meetings. Your meetings are typically [1:38:26] four to five weeks apart. Your next meeting because it will be earlier will be only three [1:38:31] weeks from tonight. As I mentioned earlier, six of seven confirmed at this location confirmed. [1:38:38] It would be my recommendation rather than when we in December of 24 when you did preliminary [1:38:46] plan approval we came I had a review but if you remember we did we drafted a [1:38:51] motion at the meeting and basically the term that's been related to me was [1:39:00] that it was on the fly and sometimes when you do things on the fly no matter [1:39:05] how diligent you are you you try to be sometimes not everything gets covered and [1:39:12] And I think that it would be owed to the commission to have something prepared in writing [1:39:18] for your consideration. [1:39:20] But those are just my comments based on what had been brought forward. [1:39:28] Many of the items regarding the runoff and anything relating to storm water management would [1:39:41] be something that would be under the purview of the county engineer's office as part [1:39:46] of the review of the stormwater management plan. [1:39:50] But those were only notes, I'll be happy to answer any questions that you might have. [1:40:05] Mr. Chairman, it was uncomfortable when we did pull-emory approval, did a lot of that on the [1:40:10] fly. [1:40:11] That was a pull-emory approval. [1:40:12] This was final approval, we had one chance to get it right. [1:40:15] I think we have a number of things that various parties need to circle back on. [1:40:24] Traffic study, Army Permit, I'm willing on my part for Mr. Kegler's spend time to modify the exterior lighting and come up with a modification for that that would be included. [1:40:39] that we could vote on but I'd like to see that and I'm sure the applicant would [1:40:45] like to see that as well. [1:40:49] I'm sorry I must have flunked seventh grade [1:40:51] science. I had a hard time following. I went back through documents after our last [1:40:58] meeting because of the comments about density, looked at density, open space, [1:41:08] So [1:41:14] I'm looking at documents given to us at the last meeting, you're welcome to take a look at my document. [1:41:21] It's page 4 of 12 and is titled as the Open Space and Reparion Setback Plan. [1:41:35] I'm looking at the stormwater management area. [1:41:39] There's a note there, Open Space 2.83 acres. [1:41:43] Are you indicating that entire space is 2.83 acres or is the entire space larger than that? [1:42:01] That under the zoning regs that that would be correct because open spaces for the enjoyment of the residents [1:42:12] and you certainly can enjoy something that's 8 to 10 feet deep. [1:42:18] I mean, it's like having only property on your opinion. [1:42:21] People can enjoy a pod if it has a fountain, if it looks nice and has nice features to it. [1:42:27] That's just an opinion. [1:42:28] I think my opinion counts. [1:42:32] If you own property on the south side of the Grand Canyon on the north side, [1:42:36] it doesn't mean that the Grand Canyon is open space in my opinion. [1:42:39] So, I think it would be prudent for you to take this document and to include notations [1:42:52] on what is included in your density calculation because you have another note, you or your [1:43:02] company. Property, open space, 16.14 acres on the north side. I understand that [1:43:11] repairing areas can be counted as open space, but I think there's been enough [1:43:17] discussion, and then at the next meeting we can take that information, tie it to [1:43:24] what the township expert comes up with and understand where we are in terms of [1:43:31] about density and open space. [1:43:32] I think that's an important question. [1:43:35] And I don't think we've gotten an answer to that so far. [1:43:46] I think Mr. Schrader had a comment. [1:43:48] Yeah, if I might just two things. [1:43:49] First on that one, I think that's a good idea. [1:43:54] I would suggest that from planning standpoint, [1:43:57] the reason attorneys don't figure out density [1:43:59] is that's not our wheelhouse. [1:44:02] But a planning standpoint, planners do that. [1:44:07] And one of the things on a density is certain case law probably has in fact defined what counts as density. [1:44:15] My guess is that the Grand Canyon would count as open space since it's a natural park. [1:44:20] But one of the things we could do for you is between Robin and I, [1:44:24] we can figure out what the courts have said counts as that particular use. [1:44:30] Mr. Washington, I've never seen this. [1:44:34] This is dated 2020. [1:44:36] That would mean if this is an official zoning commission [1:44:38] documented sometime in the last six years, [1:44:42] it would have been generated by the zoning commission. [1:44:46] I've never seen it. [1:44:48] A lot of me never have seen it. [1:44:49] What did you get this thing? [1:44:51] I got it online. [1:44:53] A line from the township? [1:44:55] Yes. [1:44:57] I obtain the document. [1:45:00] Was it online from the township, or from where? I don't recall exactly where the source is from. Okay. I'm not trying to cross-example. My guess is what I would like to understand is regardless of the date of the document. Has everyone's under the commission, under a non-conflict agreement? We don't require a non-conflict agreement. There's a state law that requires that you not vote as a public official. [1:45:30] If you have a conflict of interest, this actually does a pretty good job of aligning [1:45:34] a conflict of interest. [1:45:37] But the impression I got, and I'm not accusing you of anything, but it almost sounded [1:45:45] like this is something that these folks were supposed to sign as being a member of the [1:45:50] zoning question. [1:45:52] And I wanted Mr. Kank to see it because maybe it is something that we... [1:45:59] I was just going to ask you to represent the legal aspect of the township. [1:46:05] Is there any reason why we wouldn't have a conflict of interest on record for all public positions? [1:46:12] Well, [1:46:15] when they assume their position as an elected official or as a member of these [1:46:22] boards, they become subject to Ohio's law without signing the government. [1:46:28] I understand that. [1:46:29] But my question. [1:46:29] But I think that would be useful to get a concept or an idea because a lot of times when [1:46:35] you put a neighbor on a board, they don't necessarily know what those mean. [1:46:39] I mean, that doesn't do, for example, one of the difficulties is it says if you have an interest in, and one of the problems is if you're a neighbor of one of these things, there can be an argument in actually, [1:47:03] I don't think he does, but he does, and that's what attorneys argue about, I don't understand. [1:47:14] So you've got to be a little careful about those definitions or only saints would be allowed. [1:47:20] I think what this states is a conflict of interest where there's a financial gain. [1:47:28] And that's the problem. [1:47:30] And if I have a property and something, let me finish. [1:47:33] And I'll let you finish. [1:47:35] Because I may have been a record youth for all of my life. [1:47:38] One of the problems is if I own property and some add value of it, [1:47:45] then that could be interpreted as a financial thing. [1:47:50] That's all I wanted to say. [1:47:52] What I'm going to say was this strictly comes [1:47:56] added from a standpoint of financial gain. [1:48:01] Members of public committees within towns [1:48:05] draw from the public of that town. [1:48:09] They represent the town and the residents [1:48:13] in either close proximity or from afar of that time, it makes it the diversity of the committee [1:48:21] that gives you the true representation. [1:48:23] Right. [1:48:24] Right. [1:48:25] Thank you. [1:48:26] It's important, still, that I'm just the attorney. [1:48:30] It's the attorney. [1:48:31] 40 trustees decided they wanted to require all their employees and appointees to something like that. [1:48:39] God bless them. [1:48:40] That's unto them. [1:48:40] And that ain't a bad document. [1:48:44] But all I was getting at was, as I said here, [1:48:48] I got the impression that somehow that was something [1:48:50] that would have already been adopted [1:48:52] and everybody was supposed to sign it. [1:48:54] And I don't think it is. [1:48:55] Well, have you seen that thing before? [1:48:57] I haven't, but it doesn't necessarily mean [1:48:58] it's not out there somewhere. [1:48:59] So I'll be happy to look into it [1:49:01] and see if it's something that's important. [1:49:03] So thank you. [1:49:03] I have to ask, is there anyone on the committee [1:49:07] and Mr. Kepler in front of the public that would object to the document like that. [1:49:14] What they haven't seen in here? [1:49:16] Yeah, I had a few documents. [1:49:18] I couldn't say whether I would object to it or not, but on its face, I don't see anything. [1:49:23] And I said, I don't know the board as well. [1:49:25] I'll sign a copy for myself. [1:49:27] I don't have a problem with it, but I have to see the document. [1:49:31] Okay. [1:49:31] And Mr. Kepler. [1:49:33] And Mr. Kepler? [1:49:33] It's I'll be happy to look into what's required because what it really comes back to is not necessary [1:49:39] What's on a on a document, but what's required under state law and that's what we rely on mr. Schrader for so we'll be happy to take the document [1:49:46] You provided take a look at it [1:49:51] No problem. I don't have a conflict of interest. I [1:49:57] don't think any of them do either by the way [1:50:00] But I don't know that with such a heated [1:50:05] issue. I think it's important that the public has peace of mind. [1:50:09] I respect your opinion and I appreciate you bringing that up and I have a question about the code [1:50:16] as word and I just cross-talk care. I mean, we can almost add to that and say we've been [1:50:23] working on this. We're going to move forward. We cross-talk, we're going to have this one [1:50:27] I asked a question. [1:50:28] Would it be a conflict of interest to review of the code you wrote? [1:50:41] Do you have any other questions to write or to me to slip it? [1:50:44] No, I can't. [1:50:45] I wonder what it does. [1:50:46] I can see Rob review. [1:50:47] I would move that we move this to the next regular schedule of the A. [1:50:51] I would like to make you on it, if I could, you could ask. [1:50:55] Well, he's the applicant, I think. [1:50:56] We're far ahead of this meeting, so you're going to comment on something we are unaware of right now, or just more that we have already documented. [1:51:07] Well, there's been multiple statements about this application, the project, all those issues, and I just want to, you know, for the record again. [1:51:17] We went through the issue over the legal descriptions of the property, and went back, even the [1:51:25] good eligibility analysis of the determination about the density permitted. [1:51:32] This was literally right two years ago. [1:51:36] We brought in experts to address these hydrology issues that are really important, but if I [1:51:42] 133 million in Rusty's. [1:51:44] So this is part of my now re-open and go through all the stuff. [1:51:51] We've got time for it. [1:51:53] Back in October, we had the plans and I don't know, [1:51:56] I don't know, I don't know, but I can get it all down to where I got it in the floor. [1:52:00] I can get it all down to where I got it in the floor. [1:52:02] And I do believe Mr. King has a constant interest. [1:52:05] I do believe he does. [1:52:06] I objected to it. [1:52:07] I don't bring it up on the floor. [1:52:08] because a hundred and three versus two hundred and four or thirty-five, you're wrong. [1:52:14] The 133 units, as you were saying, has weakened us. [1:52:17] No, we will answer that question, John. [1:52:20] No, but because you're wrong. [1:52:22] I would ask. [1:52:23] Dan, let's bail this and it will be denied. [1:52:25] And nobody you robbed didn't bring it up tonight in the comments. [1:52:28] We asked the bodies skirt around about that city. [1:52:31] Hey, stop. [1:52:33] Don't tell me anything. [1:52:33] Don't tell me anything. [1:52:38] We're going to cause this entire meeting to be moved, so we're going to, we're going to, [1:52:43] a journal thing, just, just let you talk about, thank you all very much. [1:52:48] So we would like you to sit in the night, but it's 137 by the next meeting. [1:52:54] That's wrong. [1:52:55] At that point, if you have your information, you can ask for a bill on that. [1:52:58] Again, this is going on. [1:53:01] That's all we're asking. [1:53:01] And we've literally spent tens of thousands of dollars on experts about these issues, and we can get in the technical conduit of the comments on the excavating. [1:53:12] It's, you cannot gauge elevation over virgin soil. What is this property? It's a farmland. It's been farm. It's currently farm. [1:53:21] Right. So all these now we're going to get back and rerun through these definitions, [1:53:26] redo preliminary hearing, redo, that's all I'm saying. We want to decision one or another [1:53:31] if you want to take to the next meeting or objecting but do it but just to have us go through [1:53:36] this again and again and again. There's a respectful disagreement on these issues. [1:53:41] That's why I have a board here to make a decision. Thank you. And if you're here to go forward [1:53:48] forward. And do you know we are legal because we have no more questions to ask. Although we have a motion could you [1:53:59] be motion? Right. [1:54:02] Did Mr. King made a motion to I'll try and paraphrase to continue review the application to the next [1:54:09] meeting August 4th at 6 p.m. here at the same location in order to allow the items that [1:54:18] I had described earlier to be addressed with information brought forward at that time. [1:54:23] And to prepare for consideration a final approval documents with all requirements listed. [1:54:38] And I would also ask that you leave the rest of this week open to receive comments from any one of the commissioners that want to send something to you for you to consider including in that final document just because we're kind of new sense here. [1:54:54] Okay. Thank you. Is there a second to the motion? [1:55:01] I'm sorry. I couldn't hear what was that, dude. [1:55:04] August 4th, three weeks from tonight. [1:55:08] So that was a motion by Mr. King, seconded by Mr. Dworkin to continue consideration to [1:55:13] the next meeting on August 4th for the items that were described by me and subsequently [1:55:20] supplemented by Mr. King earlier to be cleaned up in writing in the minutes. [1:55:27] We'll call on that motion, Mr. Harris. [1:55:29] Yes. [1:55:29] Mr. King. [1:55:30] Yes. [1:55:30] Mr. Gwarkin? Mr. Newton? Yes. Motion carries unanimously. The [1:55:47] understanding that [1:55:49] necessary information that we could add to the baroque presented to the board [1:55:54] preparation for both. [1:55:58] This meeting is adjourned. You can adjourn it yourself. [1:56:02] Okay, this meeting is adjourned at a 757 p.