[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:52] I mean, we'll call this Plan Commission meeting to order and begin with the pledge of allegiance. [1:15] All [1:18] right, let's start with the next item, which is roll call. [1:26] Commissioner Mark Mazzoni, Commissioner Martin Nicholas, here. [1:30] Commissioner Brian Palmer, chair, Darrell Parkham, President. [1:34] All right, so this is our time for you, not agenda public comment. [1:37] As we have no public, we will move on to number four, which is conflicts of interest. [1:43] As anyone here, that has a conflict of interest with tonight's agenda. [1:48] But I can't ask them, but I don't know. [1:50] I'm going to give you one. [1:52] All right. [1:53] So we'll go on to the regular agenda. [1:54] This is tabled from May 18th for additional review from the city [1:57] Botanists. This is the tree cutting permit for family truck repair. [2:01] That's six hundred Northweed Boulevard. [2:04] And so I think everybody here has received and read through and reviewed [2:08] the report from the city botanist. [2:10] Is there any discussion amongst the commissioners regarding that report and the contents there up? [2:19] Nancy doesn't want to cut down the tree anywhere, so I mean it's not really a fair. [2:24] I've dealt with Nancy. [2:28] The Robert is our city tree specialist and has been for many years and I think that his recommendations are still valid recommendations. [2:41] So, he does not want to cut down a tree by right, right, right? [2:45] Those particular trees, I read it, he doesn't feel that they need a house or what? [2:52] Sorry. [2:52] That's what he says. [2:53] That doesn't think it's in the way the building is. [2:56] So the way the report was in, that I read it was that the botanists had proposed that the [3:02] original claim from the applicant was for fire prevention and that proper living of those [3:07] trees would pose less mitigate to pose less threat if any of fire issues based on his observation [3:15] of other items in the property. Specifically, here he states piles of tires as a fire hazard. [3:22] So Israel by the property several times, last couple of weeks since receiving the report. [3:27] There are piles of tires. There are tires outside the gate use for signage in the frontage. [3:33] Posts and things like that as well as just random piles of tires and so [3:37] Looking at it from [3:39] The proposed fire prevention issue. I have to agree with the botanist report that those tires pose a higher threat than the the trees do [3:48] But again the tires can be removed without permit. So [3:53] And looks like we we do have [3:56] Someone here to to speak on that side would love to hear [4:02] I'm sorry I forgot the staff report before we move on. [4:06] So in front of you on the Dias is the staff report. [4:12] It's been brought to the city's attention the applicant has retained services [4:16] from a registered professional forester. [4:19] The staff still recommends denial of the tree removal on the request by the [4:29] The RFP's recommendation is recommending approval for those removal of trees. [4:37] So we are saying if the RFP is stating that the trees are diseased and dying, which is what [4:44] the registered professional forester is stating, that if you were to approve upon her, [4:50] which you have not reviewed her report, but if you were to approve on her recommendations, [4:55] We would request that the conditions of approval be that the city is requiring the applicant to follow all written conditions provided by the registered professional forester. [5:05] Pertaining to the removal of the trees, the property survey requirements, logs, etc. [5:10] The applicant is required to resubmit a tree-cutting permit to the city of weed reflecting the actual number of trees to be removed as indicated on the RPF's report. [5:20] and include a copy of the said report with the application. [5:26] So we didn't get a copy of it. [5:28] No sir. [5:28] The trees are the [5:33] trees on the, not a, not a, they're property though. [5:38] The trees on the other side, right? [5:40] She stated that Cal Trans trees, trimming of the trees have allowed beetles to come in, [5:47] which is causing an issue. [5:50] I don't, I do not have a report yet, though. [5:52] Yeah, if you can't go down, go down, go down. [5:54] No, that's why they need to have a survey done, because the property lines are unknown. [5:59] Which I have that report here, not the survey though. [6:02] Not the survey yet. I have been in contact with the, [6:06] No, the trees cannot be removed until the property is surveyed. [6:12] So at this point, we're not able to make a decision until we receive that survey then is it? [6:19] At this point, you would be denying the tree cutting removal [6:22] at for the reasons that they have on the application, which is attached to this, which does [6:28] say fire prevention and visibility for new shop sign. You would be denying the tree cutting [6:34] permit for that, but you would be approving a tree cutting permit pending that they follow [6:41] all written conditions by the RPS, and we have to have the survey filed with the city. They have [6:48] do everything, they have to resubmit application and the RPF's report along with the survey. [6:55] Question. [6:57] Who's going to monitor that information? [7:00] Well, that would probably be public works in the building department. [7:04] The code enforcement. [7:08] And how do we get it? [7:10] We don't know about the parkingway. [7:13] The good question. [7:16] We have a fence put up because we have a property line. [7:19] already there in our dimensions of our property, the trees that are stated outside of our property. [7:32] We have to get a surveyer to see if the fence was not pushed back enough, so some of where the fence [7:43] is could be our property also. [7:48] Yeah, so the trees that are on our property, that is in our [7:54] are the ones closest to the shop. [7:58] Now, those are the ones that are invested with these beetles [8:02] as the forestry lady have stated, [8:05] same as CalChans. [8:07] I have her report here if, [8:10] no one to pass it to you. [8:12] So, we in CalChans, there was approximately this. [8:17] I don't think CalChans would really, [8:19] I don't know if they would monitor that. [8:20] I have no idea. [8:21] I'm not sure. [8:22] I would think that they would know what the pins are and the lines are when they purchase the property. [8:27] I would think so. [8:29] So counter-transvention, also known when they're at. [8:32] So if nobody else does, when they're at the state, they're going to buy them. [8:36] That's why they need to hire a surveyor to go out and survey their property. [8:41] And that is a requirement. [8:43] That is the requirement of the registered for usur. [8:47] Okay. [8:48] So, it sounds like we have two issues here. [8:50] One is the trees and the culture and property, which may or may not be in [8:53] festive. [8:54] These beetles, but also the trees that are firmly have been, that we know are on [8:59] your property that are, at this point, you're saying are in festive with [9:03] said beetles, for sure. [9:05] Correct. [9:05] The question is we have to make sure that the trees that they're wanting to [9:09] take down are not culture and trees. [9:12] That's what the surveyer needs to come out. [9:14] Okay. [9:14] Well, this, I'm sorry, excuse me, the surveyor for the trees that we're questioning that [9:20] our, that may or may not be ours, is on the back end of the property, not on the side. [9:27] That's, that's not what Danielle told me. [9:29] She said a surveyor needs to come out because they cannot remove a counter-industry. [9:34] What do you mean on the back end of it? [9:36] Like, toward the freeway side? [9:37] On the freeway side, like, towards motel six, or is it closer into your actual business? [9:42] I'm talking about the trees that were questionable [9:47] are where the sign is on the back of the building. [9:51] On the other side of the fence. [9:54] Yes, it's just right there. [9:55] Those are the ones over there. [9:57] Yes, and the ones that are on the side of the shop, [10:00] where you, when I walked in, you guys were stating about the tires, [10:03] which were removed to where there's nothing around those tires. [10:09] And those are the trees that are infested, the most with this beetle she was speaking about. [10:17] That's all that back side, right? [10:19] That's the one thing. [10:19] Where the container is, the back side, the closest to you. [10:22] That is the last meaning we were at when we were not getting along very well. [10:27] That was the side that I was saying, those are the trees that probably need to remove for your signage. [10:33] And then you have a signage now on the back side, right, like towards I can see it from the freeway, right? [10:40] You guys they put some on the building on the building. [10:44] But you never had a survey. [10:47] No. [10:49] When did you, when did you get that report that we haven't seen? [10:53] How, how? [10:53] I just got this report. [10:56] Oh, did they do it? [10:57] Did she do it the person? [10:59] She contacted the city on Monday. [11:00] Okay. [11:04] So it's never another party to serve it. [11:07] Not the memo, right? [11:11] I have to serve. [11:12] I can't cut that. [11:13] I don't know what's going to do. [11:14] I don't think it's going to. [11:16] But see, I should count as we're doing it. [11:17] Aren't they still doing the mass removal trees? [11:20] Or they've already done it there. [11:22] They've already done it. [11:23] That's all they're going to do. [11:23] They've already done it there. [11:25] They've already done it there. [11:26] Yeah. [11:27] That's what they were doing that. [11:28] So we can't legally make a decision as a commission on this permit [11:33] until the survey is completed then. [11:35] That's one of the forester's recommendations [11:38] is it has to be surveyed, that would be a city, [11:40] also requirement that it would need to be surveyed. [11:43] We would not be able to go out [11:44] because we cannot authorize them [11:46] to cut down a tree on CalTrans property. [11:48] God, shrimp. [11:50] But we had a job as you could survey it. [11:53] Apparently they're pretty busy. [11:56] So we have contact to survey [11:58] and we're just waiting for him to come out. [12:02] We still can act on this particular permit, because this permit is talking about for fire protection and visibility. [12:10] That's right. [12:10] The two trees. [12:12] That's right. [12:14] But who's talking to the two trees and the other trees? [12:17] I don't know. [12:18] Well, I don't know that we need to know that at this particular point, because I think we need to deny this particular permit. [12:29] So we're not cutting anybody's trees down. [12:32] So are you're denying the permit on with waiting and having them have their have their land surveyed and then [12:39] resubmit the application for what the forest is saying okay before we go to a discussion [12:45] motion I think we need to give the applicant a chance to present any other information that they may have [12:53] Well, until we get a survey out for the trees that are in the back of the building, [13:05] the [13:05] ones that are closest to the shop building are our trees. [13:10] And those are the ones that are most infested with this beetle, our multiple beetles that [13:16] stated in her report. [13:21] Yeah, I don't really have much to say about that then. [13:29] So, uh... [13:29] Yeah, she looked at all the trees there, and went around on the other side of the fence on [13:39] the [14:10] And I believe the foresters requesting a surveyer that comes out. [14:19] I don't know what you've got to talk about the two trees that they're asking for in the [14:27] regional threat. [14:28] Would you have a survey when you put it in the building? [14:34] CalTrans came out. [14:36] There was a survey for the front of the property to put in our driveway, so we had that survey [14:42] then. [14:43] But I do not, I don't believe it was for the whole property all around. [14:49] It was just from Motel 6 to, it's far out to the highway there and then back in. [15:00] Uh-huh. Yes. [15:02] And said that, have you on your property? [15:05] Yes. [15:05] Oh, they didn't put stakes down? [15:07] They put stakes in the front of the property side. [15:09] I don't understand. I believe not. [15:13] Oh. [15:14] I think you were surveyed. You haven't been by three points. [15:23] All right. Well, is there any further discussion in the commission? [15:26] Or are there any greater make motions? [15:35] And if the trees, you know, are truly invested in, and disease and dying, [15:40] that something that can be administratively approved it would not have to come back to the commission. [15:47] And number two, I thought anybody else brought me in to the city of Winnie was allowed to [15:52] you would do treaties a year that they have more than 20 can take care of around the [15:57] population. One, two, a year to five, I thought that was a grand event. [16:01] Their first application was not for that, their first application was for this, so that's what we're [16:05] discussing. I did after the our last meeting and denied due to this application. [16:13] Actually being submitted. Yes. Okay. [16:18] So can I pass these two guys about her report? [16:22] I'm I'm. [16:23] There's really. [16:25] See you. [16:26] Okay. [16:30] How many copies do you have? [16:31] I have for copies. [16:37] Yeah, no. [16:46] I don't know. [16:47] I don't know. [16:47] I don't know. [16:49] I don't know. [16:49] I don't know. [16:49] I don't know. [16:50] I don't know. [16:50] But I think yeah, I know. [16:51] I think I can't make a decision on that part of it. [16:55] Right now, I have to go home. [16:59] The servant. [17:01] Yes, Danielle stated that that was going to be a requirement that she spoke with them on. [17:06] Yeah. [17:06] I think that's about to think going. [17:08] As long as it's within their boundary lines, and they are actually [17:12] disease and dying, it can be administratively approved. [17:15] Yes. [17:15] Mm-hmm. [17:16] I think [17:23] the motion to react to the magnification that for the [17:29] abundance of the trees that are talking about in Germany. [17:33] I'll make a motion for the lead, the two trees that they requested in the coming first, as soon as I get a service. [17:39] Is they have to get a survey? They cannot remove any trees because they don't, yeah. [17:43] And staff denied removal of the trees based on their request for signage, because that's not a, that's not a reason to remove trees. [17:53] So we have a motion to deny the permit request, do we have a second? Second? All those in favor? [17:59] Hi. Hi. All opposed? Motion carries tonight the permit and we'll review, likely to [18:07] see we'll review upon the survey. [18:11] Okay, so next the item we have is the approval of [18:13] the minutes from May 2018. Are there any corrections or comments on the minutes? [18:19] What did you explain to you? You probably don't have to come back to us. [18:23] Yes. [18:23] You're going to survey. [18:24] That's not enough property. [18:25] You've been following any great traffic real quick, don't you? [18:29] You don't even, you don't even have to see Craig. [18:31] Just get it surveyed, bring the survey report, [18:33] and a new tree cutting application saying how many, [18:37] how many is indicated here that you need to take out. [18:40] So bring that into me. [18:42] Yeah, okay. [18:42] But that also, though, is that if they're deceased, right? [18:54] If they are diseased, it can be administratively approved, if they are not diseased. [19:04] Yes. [19:08] Thank you. [19:12] Okay. [19:12] So we will accept the minutes as approved since there are no corrections. [19:16] comments. The next item is the commissioners reports. [19:24] Okay, and the last item we have is [19:26] an additional staff reports. I will be out of town in August for our regular meeting. I'll [19:34] be moving my son to college in Oklahoma. So we may not have an August meeting if I can't get [19:41] someone to fill in for me. Who could you get to fill in for [19:53] me? Quit. Quit's better these beans. [20:01] All right, well congratulations on the going off the college and now I'll accept the motion to adjourn. [20:11] Make a motion to adjourn. [20:14] All right, we have a motion to second all in favor. [20:17] All right, meeting this adjourned.