[This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person -- it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.] [0:18] Yeah. [0:23] There are a couple of agendas up here. If anyone doesn't have one. Is 545 until [0:36] my 30th and I'm going to follow up the point of civil authority and the Westminster [0:41] to order a first item or the second item is the PCA with a publicization left in a chair [0:50] and a vice chair. But I [0:55] will pay the nomination as a chair. So I nominate Sarah Waldo's chair. [1:01] But I can't. [1:03] I can't see. [1:05] So. [1:07] Susan seconded. Thank you. [1:13] So well, there are more nominations. [1:16] Yeah, so well, those has been nominated for chair at the PCA. [1:23] All those in favor. [1:24] Hi. [1:27] So well, I think you're taking over this meeting now. [2:07] I don't know. [2:09] Oh, maybe, of course they're awesome. [2:11] No, I don't. [2:12] Yes, they're very mean, so I do not mean anything. [2:19] I'm doing that. [2:25] They're showing us, and they're giving you the details of the way. [2:32] But you're not sharing with them. [2:35] We're, that's right. [2:36] Well, yeah, then, I'm worried. [2:37] Yeah, yeah, like what he said, they said, more than my capital. [2:45] Janette, a packet? [2:47] Yes, it is. [2:50] Thank you. [2:53] So no one has any other mention? [2:55] Yes. [2:56] Do you have a message? [2:57] I do that. [2:58] Yeah. [2:59] You can start now and do that. [3:00] It's very good. [3:02] Good. [3:03] I've got to use some stuff. [3:05] First time. [3:24] So [3:29] the next item on the agenda is the election of a vice chair, so I will take an [3:42] I know many can I nominate? [3:45] Sure, I can. [3:46] I nominate Susan. [3:47] I love. [3:48] Let's try to share. [3:52] Oh, we sat and did. [3:53] I'm sorry. [3:54] Thank you. [3:55] Any other. [3:57] The nominations? [4:00] Yeah. [4:00] Yeah. [4:01] Yeah. [4:02] Yeah. [4:04] Okay. [4:07] All those in favor of. [4:10] I'm sorry. [4:10] The nominee for Vice Chair, Susan Farlow, Ms. Saad, anyone opposed? [4:18] Okay, I guess the Chief Susan, sorry. Thank you. Thank you, Susan. [4:24] The next item on our agenda is the acceptance of the October 24th meeting minutes. [4:37] So I don't know if everybody has had a chance to review that. [4:46] Everybody ready to accept. [4:50] So all those in favor of accepting the minutes of the October. [4:56] I have two different dates here. [5:00] Okay, wait a minute. [5:02] October 28th, and on the agenda, it's October 28th, I have my air, it's actually 28. [5:09] Okay, so minutes on the agenda was the 28th, so that's the 28th. [5:17] Okay, you think the meeting was the 24th? [5:20] On the agenda, it says the three different days, the lawyer, really blocking it here. [5:26] What day was that? [5:29] Okay. [5:31] All those in favor of the minutes, [5:32] 17 minutes of whatever day that is. [5:36] That's awesome. [5:39] Checking out yet. [5:40] Well, actually if you weren't at that meeting, [5:42] you can't approve or disapprove. [5:45] So those towards the meeting and just being on set. [5:48] Okay. [5:49] Approved. [5:52] Okay. [5:53] So it's in the business. [5:56] Well, what is the checklist on number five? [6:00] The checklist is, can you put out a notice to the BCA? [6:07] Any motives that have moved from the town should be challenged. [6:13] And so I traded up and he said, he mailed it, asked the BCA if they approved me sending [6:23] the challenge letters. [6:24] There were very few responses. [6:25] So I can't really challenge voters without a BCA. [6:31] It's a state statute that will BCA challenge voters. [6:34] So I really can't do it. [6:37] It's supposed to be 30 days before any election. [6:40] I still have plenty of time to challenge voters, [6:42] but you can flash to the wall with a checklist and a review. [6:48] Do you have a list of ones that have moved? [6:50] One of the whole checklist. [6:51] No, no, I don't have. [6:52] Yeah, not that. [6:54] So when we get to check, yeah, we go through and see who passed away, because I'm going to say that we've all been there. [7:00] I can't vote. [7:01] Right. [7:01] And then we look at it and say he moved away. [7:05] No, we said new blood. [7:07] But normally on the list of several people who passed away, that the old one is going to call, join, come up. [7:13] Well, generally, you get a death certificate. [7:17] So I, that's what your biggest common mistake and I do purge voters that have died that have passed away. [7:25] So do you want us to review this now? Is that the plan? I printed them, but maybe it's better to send you a list of what the deadline. [7:36] Yes, yes. [7:37] Yes, yes. [7:38] But we're getting the case of EIA is, I mean, for an election, yeah, but definitely want [7:45] to review it, kind of what to tell you more of that. [7:48] I have to do it, yeah, and without it's, without a scientific, scientific. [7:53] So I think it's 90 days, feet, for the, I think we have a no-member. [7:58] I've done it. [7:59] We've done it. [7:59] We've done it. [8:00] collection. He says, hey, Rick. I'm always lonely. Oh, no. I think I'm a list of those people [8:10] that came back through the mail that we're challenging and to see what everyone thinks. [8:18] And then we would just respond to you like we're going to leave. Right. And the other [8:22] the other thing usually challenge is if you haven't voted, if a voter hasn't voted within two [8:27] years to challenge those people also seems maybe extreme but you know we haven't voted [8:34] an election in two years then we challenge them. [8:37] Ten years. [8:39] Is that a state regulation? [8:40] Really? [8:41] Yes. [8:41] Yes. [8:42] Yes. [8:42] Yes. [8:42] Yes. [8:42] Yes. [8:42] Yes. [8:42] Yes. [8:44] Yes. [8:45] You might have done that before my time, which is something I've dropped it down into. [8:52] It's a statue now, if you haven't voted, it's a shadow. [8:58] Yeah, it's not going to say anything. [9:01] And what are you going to say about it? [9:03] How will your life go through? [9:05] Right, it's two elections. [9:07] I think it's two general elections. [9:08] So it's probably actually four years that you've not voted. [9:20] I have the checklist here. I don't have that. I don't have a condo. Okay. Okay. [9:29] I just have four. Yeah. So if you said you're going to send us the list of the checklist. [9:36] I was a specialist of the challenges of those that are deceased. [9:43] We can get in this. [9:45] But not the whole checklist. [9:47] I can give you a, this is the whole checklist right here. [9:51] There are four of them, but you're not going to send the whole checklist. [9:53] I can send you the whole checklist if you want. [9:55] How do you know some of this food? [9:58] We usually get a ballot back. [10:01] Oh, the ballots from the November election came back as non-deliberate calls. [10:06] And you also view them back. [10:08] You should use the tech to send the tech for love. [10:10] They came back and go on with that evidence. [10:13] That's a good one. [10:14] Kelly doesn't give me that information, but it could be. [10:17] That's for that. [10:19] You've been already in the email form. [10:20] You sent me the whole business email to me. [10:23] The list. [10:23] No, sure. [10:25] The whole, if it's already in the email form, [10:27] I don't have to print it, but I'm sure it's good. [10:28] Yeah. [10:29] I can do that. [10:31] Yeah. [10:38] Okay. [10:39] Okay. [10:48] So, okay. [10:49] Now, with the checklist with you, everybody's good on that. [10:55] Yes. [10:55] Thank you. [10:56] Okay. [10:57] So, we have a new business. [10:58] So, we have a new business. [10:59] to have the assessment appeal from great River Hydro and I guess we don't have that so [11:05] soon here. [11:06] And she's not. [11:07] I wasn't sure about other business. [11:09] She's attending by Zoom, oh, it's not on yet. [11:16] The notices went out on the 21st of July. [11:19] It was delivered to West Little Mass, but someone has to sign for it and no one signed for the [11:27] who turned into a big bastard. So she was actually here talking today to the [11:31] listeners. Yes, so. She knows about the meeting. Well, I don't, she does know about the meeting now [11:40] because I emailed her, but I'm not sure if she knew about it when she talked to Rachel and John today. [11:47] Well, we're going to do a video next year. But she wasn't really, she came in, she said she just [11:53] one's in Lewis face-to-face to have, you know, personal relationship that I'm just believing [11:59] and I'm experiencing. [12:01] So it should be a little bit of explanation of their understanding of the situation. [12:08] It wasn't really that, but it was just trying to be really sizable for some of us to just [12:16] sit and show the visit that I think was coincidentally, but on the same day, this was meeting as I [12:23] So she said, you know, especially when I may be there, I don't want you to see the last class of it. [12:29] It's my email for this morning, because I have not received, we turned, we see we passed that from the post office. [12:36] It was delivered on the 24th. She said she had not received it. She asked me to send her the meeting notice and the procedure list I did. [12:46] She asked if she could attend by zoom. [12:48] And I said, she's like, she doesn't show up with her. [12:55] From Rachel, I bet we would or you would decide on what she wrote, but she doesn't have [13:04] to attend. [13:05] That applicant is not required to attend it. [13:08] Right. [13:08] They submitted whatever material that they need. [13:12] As to two. [13:16] Right. [13:16] So. [13:17] Where are the people who are required to post an English music. [13:21] It's just. [13:22] It's. [13:22] When you explain. [13:25] It's not. [13:26] I don't feel. [13:27] Um, they. [13:28] They. [13:29] What. [13:29] I need to know their presence. [13:32] Did you read this? [13:34] Yeah, that's good. [13:38] I think I'll just talk it just a little louder. [13:40] I can try to go to the course. [13:41] I don't know. Maybe you could stand out. [13:44] So I look forward to it. [13:45] Yes, you can. [13:45] So I cannot adequately explain to you what flow [13:52] which is minute is because I don't really understand it. [13:58] It's something like if there should be a flood [14:01] that's caused by a dam that's under the auspices of great river hydro that affects the [14:07] parts of the land that are in Westminster. They've essentially paid us in advance by [14:12] aimless taxes for this piece of land for any of the sudden damage that's been done. [14:25] So they've [14:28] and how much they might be valid that is far beyond the scope of the board of [14:33] listeners. It's beyond the scope of our contracting assessor. I will show [14:37] them with in 2012 to 2013 a state of Vermont hired a qualified assessor to do [14:49] the whole grave of our high school project, all up and down, there's a whole connecting [14:56] in the world for thousands of people. [15:00] And the state provided town with the value that that president was on suceley was the public. What was on you son suceley? Okay, I don't remember his first name. It's an individual. And he gave this value of $1,569, I mean, $6,1,569, right? [15:29] of donors. And so the state told the various towns, this is the, this is the value that this [15:35] ancestral was identified. And each town had the discretion to take that, evaluate the value [15:42] that they have been in all along. And again, visitors of Westminster didn't take the new number, [15:50] They checked the $10,000 value that had been on there since before Great River Hydro, [15:57] owned that project. I don't know what I understood. I was thinking of that and what year was [16:03] that? Since when was there two? I couldn't find. [16:06] In 2013, what happened when 2013, they came in and said that we made them the state because [16:14] The way the gravity works, they got putty, water went off higher than the belt, but the [16:19] ministry of water came to blow up hill, but they came along and said it's about 100 foot [16:24] plane level. It was 100 years, but like where I worked at ATG, it was always just below the [16:31] floor. They came back in and said, oh, no, we're off. I think it's going to give me right. I think [16:36] it was almost 10 feet. And we even said, well, this is going to devastate, because now we're building [16:42] in the land for a lot less, because now we have some plants, so we've been arguing [16:46] about all that farm land that is because of the data that all that land is worth a lot [16:54] of us. [16:54] And that's what they're trying to come back to saying, OK, the Westminster is not getting [16:59] the two types it should, because it's way under value because that is the value of the land [17:05] and the wetland. [17:06] If there's longer reasons, wetland, does the dams make it wetland? [17:09] You see what I'm saying? [17:11] I don't know. [17:11] That always makes me think of a way. [17:13] Why have we not looking for some help from the day [17:17] and because they're the ones that devag are all [17:19] that propped in that's kind of where I saw a company. [17:24] Right, but the listers at that moment said, [17:27] well, we're going to keep the $10,000 value. [17:31] Nothing really happened in between. [17:34] And then this year, for the first time, [17:36] the state of Vermont provided the all the towns with all of our need to values. [17:43] So we are not where we've got a chart that said for, you know, [17:48] the non-powers this much and the various solar projects that values this. [17:54] And we're just supposed to plug these numbers in being both [17:59] environment with the state and a grant of having to do this should be valid. I took [18:05] and just put those numbers in and of course the difference between 10,000 and a million [18:11] in five, plus it was noticeable. [18:17] And so, [18:17] I think that's it. [18:19] Oh no. [18:21] And, but, but so, [18:24] River Hydro didn't attend the grievance hearings. [18:28] They sent a letter, [18:30] which I guess has a population that allowed to be allowed [18:34] to come. [18:35] So I talk to many people in the Department of Taxes [18:40] because I know where we are going, whether we should allow agreements or not, I don't really [18:45] understand. I wasn't the one who gave the value and so somewhat frustratingly the state, [18:58] nobody at the state, nobody in the department of taxes would say to me, it should be this [19:03] value, you should keep this value, you should deny the agreements, they said all we can do is provide [19:08] information, you can't recommend what you should do. And, in fact, so what I then decided was, [19:17] there was a nine-degree one, so it could move forward in the process, and somebody at a higher [19:23] pay rate than the afforded listers would have to figure out what to do. So that's made less [19:28] clear again. So is it one of the 1.5 million men to the town? It's about $38,000, sometimes it's [19:37] per year, right? So if we had changed that number in 2013, it would have added up quite a bit [19:45] over the years, just for one year it's not changed enough, but if we change it to that now, [19:52] it stays that for some time, right? So you'll be able to pay it in a few minutes. [19:57] We have, right, people. And they've made it right. It isn't a number that you've made up. [20:05] We didn't make it last but we did the number that it came to the sweatboard then and we were told we'd had to vote for them. [20:12] So when we voted then we found out afterwards we're just led by them because the towns in the rancher didn't change because they didn't want to lower the value of their property. [20:22] So we're going to happen the blood level we hired from on on the chemical river that moved on the rancher and never got an answer we weren't allowed to change the battery. [20:31] So, it all changed when this happened, we're going to like, that need like Faith IV had [20:37] to build a building up higher, but so you'll loosen that fire and wind and all that that [20:43] can't be developed or, so you pay for it, so it's like it is, but it's in blood zones, [20:47] you know, it doesn't matter how, so we're losing all that extra revenue, just the way to make [20:52] out of it. [20:53] No, but so the other thing that I could tell you was that Westminster is not the only town [20:57] either to have decided against changing their value in terms of 13 in the state [21:04] provided about rule number or to now be in the face of protest for a great [21:12] way to fight them. So other towns are also pregnant with this and the state. So [21:18] here's what I'm hoping, what happens is that the court of civil society will reject [21:24] back to their appeal, and it will move along to a process where we'll negotiate with them. [21:34] We will get actual information. [21:36] If all they say in their letters, they're going to keep it at 10,000. [21:39] They don't explain why 10,000 is the right value. [21:42] And more than we can explain, I can explain to you why I'm going to make it five. [21:47] This is the right number. [21:48] and sort of make people who we actually know to talk about [21:51] for lots of kind of hard moments for something. [21:55] And what Rick or her high notes want, [21:57] so really, is to be able to know [21:59] over a several new fluid, [22:02] what their tax liabilities are going to be. [22:05] They're not necessarily stuck on the 10,000. [22:08] They just don't want it to do suddenly a million. [22:11] They want to know what's going to be, [22:13] and what they hope that's a talent [22:15] the so-called well-styled agreement with a three or five-year agreement with them, [22:19] whatever the established as the correct value. The one out of piece of information is in 2016, [22:27] the town of Waterford was in this boat, and they got a different part, [22:34] different not-sensors that I can't remember both the assessors, but they came up with a different [22:38] model for how to value this is logic in the human situations and they came to a [22:46] agreement with the town who are third but somewhere in between, they're in that [22:51] office and I wish we were exactly the same as ours, but it was a similar leap [22:55] high rather than a thing. So they, right now I grow up, is claiming that the 2013 method [23:04] that was used is not legitimate. [23:08] This is a state court allowed a lot of firms to pay, [23:12] they can make some in favor of it, [23:15] instead of the cost of the children to pay. [23:18] So that's positive, I don't know. [23:20] And they can go. [23:21] They can continue on with their appeal. [23:23] If you deny it here, they can go. [23:25] Yes, the states and to trade. [23:27] Don't want to go to court. [23:28] They don't think it's worth asking court cost [23:31] of their name for cost for how much of this for one year they just want to deal with it. They want [23:37] to get it settled for once and for all. So I think I don't know if I have to pull out to move that [23:42] but I would move that and just deny it and then go take it to the next step and get the original [23:48] But I think she's not on here, so I don't think you can, I mean, they're not from here to be present. So yeah, but the healing wasn't until 6.30. So I don't know. So no, I thought he was at six. [24:08] No, I think it is. [24:21] We have to still have an inspection committee to go out and to move from back in 30 days but can't just say nothing. [24:35] Now, we have to actually have the discussion committee go out with us in that in 30 days [24:43] with us. [24:43] I mean, it's going to be and then we don't. [24:49] It's not going to be a session or anything. [24:51] Well, I have to go. [24:52] Now, go over. [24:53] That's. [24:53] Yeah. [24:54] Yeah. [24:56] I understand that. [24:58] Usually. [24:58] That's generally the case. [25:00] No. [25:00] you know, I was there. We booked up and that's very good. They have to do that. [25:07] Wait a minute, just one person at a time that happens. So they have a comment. [25:11] I think in which office fairly or we can end it up going the board of board and board of [25:17] board of boards to board the board of board of board. You got your discretion for [25:19] many of those still following the wall. [25:22] And I would think that we're going to end up on what the inspection committees [25:27] was trying to find, maybe some of the issues that I was one point, the other point was like [25:33] Dombra said, and then a quake where we're hiding on a list, we're just kind of sat down, [25:38] mulled over to stop, came in with a prize, and then the, yes, the one before the [25:43] select board was subject to regulatory tool. So that's another point that I have to know. [25:49] But we still think that's only not to have that in selection. [25:52] to things now, I think that's an all-way thing. [25:55] It's important. [25:56] But we have a flood map. [25:58] So normally, when you take the flood map, [26:01] and you say, here's all the land and flood. [26:03] So let's say it comes back to a 180-yard curse or something. [26:06] You can get all the real term, say, there's a 180-yard [26:10] curse or flood, what is a piece of land [26:12] and flood, flood zone, where it's compared to some [26:16] Buddhism, plus it. [26:18] And that's a good way to at least look at it. [26:21] I think land is the land. [26:23] It's just, it's just a question on that land, [26:26] that deviance, what do you like, [26:27] when you put a valley blood in? [26:29] That's such a good, for a valley matter. [26:31] It's a good, good tax value. [26:34] Well, yes, but we don't, [26:36] so we have a lower tax. [26:38] What there's in the people, [26:39] from the substance values to lower tax. [26:41] Right, see what I'm saying? [26:43] They're gonna come along and say, [26:44] all that land, we're not getting up past [26:46] because it's in blood. [26:48] Right, right, right. [26:49] So now the height will say, [26:50] But we're the ones that cause it to be in the flood zones or we're going to subsidize what what's the difference between [26:57] Office roll and all around there. They're on the flood phone. They're laying this so they're paying less tax [27:02] 10 for a per acre in what's the difference if it wasn't the flood phone [27:07] But I don't think you're looking at everything. You're looking at the charts [27:10] That's what's missed and kind of figure out how many acres is in designated in flood zone [27:15] It's gonna know if you're going for a hard or a lot for so much around it [27:18] If that's the point of where they're going to be, [27:19] the number of them, I'm sure they're going to listen [27:21] to what it's worth. [27:23] They can negotiate with you, get out of it. [27:25] Okay. [27:26] I think there's a point of order. [27:29] The other student, just as the diversity is an example, [27:32] they didn't go before you can see it. [27:34] Yes. [27:35] But when you're in the type of algorithm, [27:38] it has a tunnel for you to see it. [27:40] So we have to follow our perceptions, right? [27:43] I think that means how everybody [27:45] doing that. And then come back as a warning for getting our name or whatever we decide. [27:52] Because dummers didn't just make a deal with all this terms. Is that how that is there? [27:57] I'm a select board, right? So they get a board group. There's a great guide role set down in kind of [28:03] theme. Okay. So according to the BCAA and the BCAA sent out an inspection, I think that because they [28:12] We have now made a formal appeal to the CA, right? [28:15] We have to follow our normal decision. [28:17] So, okay. [28:18] Yes. [28:19] That's even. [28:20] But it does, it does seem very logical [28:22] that the inspection would actually be an inspection of maps, [28:27] because we're not, yeah. [28:28] No one walking to Albladfield for the Alblad mayor, [28:32] but we are, we're actually looking at maps. [28:36] So the inspection is rather sitting down to the next. [28:41] I'm looking at the flood map asking what that acreage is that asking, as you said, what [28:49] the difference is in tax value between in-blood and in-blood and then that would represent [28:55] what they're centrally by the value that they are taped in. [29:00] And it's quite possible that we don't know, and we can just deny it so that it has spiritual [29:07] that goes to the next step too, which we did at one point, there are solar [29:12] environments first into town. I don't know, when we read all of that, we weren't [29:18] equipped as if we stayed to understand the value of that and just denied it. I'm [29:22] at it further on and we let the state decide. So we have a couple of choices here [29:30] whether to have our inspection committee get a hold of these maps and talk to a wheelchair [29:39] or whatever wheelchair that committee selects to figure out those numbers or just deny it [29:49] because we're not pardon me. There is no commitment but to give the list. No, there is a put [29:56] to know how they're allowed. Yeah. Yeah, that's the direction. Maybe. Yeah. The BC. [30:00] They put together an inspection committee of the minimum of three people. When you have a tax appeal, that committee, it's not the listers percent, that committee goes out and does an inspection. So that, if we appoint, if that committee is appointed, that committee is responsible for getting these maps and getting a, you know, a bit of contrasting [30:29] land values. So what we're trying to do is get rid of $10,000 to do a million [30:34] fine. I don't think we're trying to do that. I think yeah. We're a million fine right now. [30:41] Yeah. What we're trying to do is satisfy the requirements. To this point, we've got this table in [30:48] place. So thanks. I'm hearing that there is a possibility of denial because we don't [30:59] have expertise on the PCA feel that that might be the way to go. I don't want to, yeah. I don't [31:09] want to, to integrate anybody's ability to learn this really, really quickly. I do question, [31:17] I mean it seems to me that there's a lot of expertise that is needed in order to, in order to, [31:26] to fairly evaluate this question. [31:29] And I myself do not feel like I had it. [31:33] Trying to point out though, [31:35] it's really between the list of the listers [31:39] would not be on the committee [31:41] because they're the ones that set the link. [31:44] So the committee, what we're here for now [31:47] is to vote on what's fair whether the list is correct [31:50] or they're correct for somewhere in the middle. [31:53] So yeah, so either, [31:54] I think our choice is either go with what the list would say in 1.5 for a [31:59] reformer committee to do a little more research and come back in Zunga. [32:05] Right, that's John. [32:07] I mean I think we have to form a committee. [32:09] I think that's probably true. [32:10] Yeah. [32:10] Right. [32:12] So I think we should form a committee. [32:15] And then instead of committee then do whatever they want to do. [32:20] I guess they come back and tell us they check their maps. [32:23] they did, maybe there is a research and a list or that. [32:27] There we go for the meeting and then we vote on whatever [32:33] we're going to accept and not. [32:35] Well, I think so right now I'm going to feel a little confused [32:41] about what our options are. [32:43] It's our options just the committee and have them do the research. [32:49] Or do we say the BCA is not, [32:52] doesn't have the expertise to really approach this, but Peggy, you said that it [32:58] happened differently in the days ago before the VCA, the one that had happened. [33:04] So I think the fact that they came to us as a tax appeal, yeah, that we have to [33:12] follow our procedure. That's what we do with what the committee recommends on a [33:20] greater board, then that's what we decided to do then. So it could be denied. It could be denied. [33:28] Give us a thing here. We're not able to, we're denying a base based on our connect. [33:34] We have no knowledge of anything yet, but I think the next we need to be to this [33:39] inspection. So if we deny it, then we automatically go to a committee. No, it sounds like we can't deny it. [33:47] I can't deny we have to have a committee. [33:50] That's how the positions are. [33:50] Okay, so then that becomes our only one option. [33:53] Right. [33:53] At this point, it's a committee of minimum of three people. [33:58] And then that committee will decide how they want to do this. [34:02] I mean, I think if you just sort of imagining, [34:07] like if you involve a realtor, [34:11] how are they going to have to pay that realtor [34:13] to make these assessments? [34:17] It is not a matter of real or your sale value, it's a matter of practical value, it's a [34:25] matter of how much do we appraise something in the blood zone and not the blood zone. [34:31] So, could the shoe mix that assessment? [34:33] We have, we already do that. [34:35] We are already appraised up at certain amounts, at cultural length, at blood zone and not [34:45] So that's the difference. [34:47] That figure times number eight originally. [34:50] Essentially it's pretty simple product. [34:53] Thank you. [34:54] I give you a lot of big news. [34:56] You know, if people are not full, they normally, you know, [34:59] they're going to do it in a while. [35:00] They normally come in and defend their number. [35:03] See what I'm saying? [35:04] They're coming in and going, it's not $10,000. [35:07] But it's, you know, $750,000. [35:09] They have not given us anything back. [35:12] So this is a little bit, because normally we get some shoots, okay? [35:17] Here's the list, here's what they are, where we can pick a number. [35:21] In this case, we cut these into our number. [35:24] That's why I'm gonna think you've got to go with a committee. [35:26] But it also shows you, I think they might think that the 1.25 is right. [35:31] Or the, or no. [35:32] Or no. [35:41] So I think we're at the point where we need to appoint a committee to pursue this and we need a minimum of three. [35:52] So I'm getting just a fact when it is risked, Windsor is another town that they have a [35:59] PO from BCA too. So they have, I'm not sure that's out of the question to chat with Windsor, [36:07] the town of Windsor, BCA. It really is. The thing is like rocking them won't do because they're above [36:14] the Dan, but they don't have the same environment. As you can get below, right below the Dan, the town [36:20] there's more of them than more of the people. [36:22] So if you're a river, you're probably [36:24] in the right hand, and you know, they're above the date, [36:27] where, what were they being completed? [36:30] Well, that's so one thing that Johnson and Duke went down [36:34] was we're the last 10, the Dan Burnley, [36:38] was the Dan that's affected the old folk content show. [36:43] And it says, well, just below the next one, [36:46] and there's this thing, we're the least, [36:49] with the mist, with the mist, with the picture that they want, and the graph, you need to [36:53] find out the yellow. [36:54] But that is actually incorrect. [36:57] The level of the grain of the water passable to burn down was not the same level as the [37:06] water that flooded Alan Brothers. [37:08] And it's because the actual flow, how much you'd state out of the upriver dam, graded a, [37:15] It really was going very fast between Westminster and Vernon, representing a lot of feet of fall. [37:24] And so the flood level, coming up to Gidells here, was a lot higher out to than the top of the [37:40] as if you were a sail pool water. [37:44] This was active sleep. [37:45] This is okay because we think there's some really expert [37:49] like hydrologists who just needed even to understand how the system works. [37:56] It's not just that we can excuse me. [37:57] I'm getting all the right words. [38:00] The hydro, the great word of hydro representative is here. [38:04] Really says so. [38:06] So I guess we can start from after all this. [38:22] Can [38:44] you hear us? [38:45] I can hear you. [38:51] Hello. [38:52] Hello, okay, [38:58] so we're going to welcome you to this meeting. [39:02] Are you here to represent Great River Hydro? [39:05] Is that correct? [39:06] That is correct. [39:07] And are you Jocelyn? [39:09] I am. [39:11] Okay. [39:13] Okay. [39:14] Well, the board of civil authority is here and the listers and, yeah, that's who's present in the room for this hearing. [39:22] So, I would like to, first of all, I need to have the applicant, which is you, take [39:37] out the following oath, or there to do that, okay. [39:42] So, under the pains and penalties of perjury, do you solemnly swear that the evidence you gave [39:48] in the cause under consideration shall be the whole truth and nothing but the truth. [39:54] Yes. Okay. Thank you for that. And at this point I also need to ask the board if there's any [40:03] conflict of interest that exists or exparte communication that's taking place about this hearing. [40:17] Okay, did you receive a copy of the board's rules of procedure? [40:24] Yes. [40:26] And do you have any questions about that? [40:28] I do not. [40:29] Okay, good. [40:31] Okay. [40:32] So I would like to ask you to identify this statutory abatement category [40:41] that the abatement request is made under. So there is a [40:47] visit check. I want that abatement category is [40:58] you'll have time. [41:02] Just a second, remember look at my [41:03] chair out there. Yeah. [41:05] It's not held better than in these little places. [41:09] So this is, oh, I'm sorry, it has to be a sign. [41:12] It was looking inside. [41:13] And he's there with me. [41:14] This is my first time around this. [41:16] Okay, so it's actually, so, okay. [41:21] All right, I'm sorry. [41:23] The next, after the requested, [41:28] this was in a conflict of interest. [41:30] The next step is to ask the listers [41:34] to introduce the property on appeal [41:36] by describing the property in its present valuation, [41:39] which we already, [41:41] I mean, we actually spoke about that before you made a meeting, but we're able to do that again. [41:51] So, I can tell this year that this easement has been valued $10,000. [41:58] This year, the State Department of Taxes and Value Towns with the utility assessments rather than us getting involved [42:10] from each other's dreadful death, and they provided this [42:14] money that they had, thus, and the valuation for his [42:18] parcel that I was $10,000 a month ago in the museum. [42:21] And it was based on a 2013 brazil at the state [42:27] contractor for the whole way that I was in the system. [42:31] And so the listeners have, I guess, [42:39] the discretion to accept that number and not accept it, but because it was beyond our knowledge [42:46] to know what the assessment should be, and exactly on the knowledge and the time of the [42:50] show, after after the Fraser, after the conversations with people related to taxes, the minister [42:59] decided to use the state's number and can provide it in its own way in the head, so that we [43:08] We used to this step because it felt so hard to judge whether this is that or not. [43:18] Thank you for that. [43:23] And [43:27] can you, Jocelyn, please present the evaluation and your supporting evidence that, according to your field? [43:39] Yes. So the letter that we provided for the appeal stated that we are opinion is that there is no change in value. [43:51] And our opinion is that because while we understand that the town or the board of listeners is being told by the state of Vermont to change the value. [44:02] So in one single year for a value to change by over 15,000% is un-proportional and truly [44:15] unfair to any taxpayer, our property taxes went from $240 to $42,000 and I don't think [44:29] any other taxpayer in the community would agree to be treated that way. I looked [44:36] at the land schedule that the listers provided. It's a land schedule from 2013 and in [44:42] that land schedule it shows at most a 35% increase in value from one year to [44:49] the next. So 15,000% seems a little out of bounds and just to give a little [44:56] background to the board as to whoop flowage ease. [45:00] These flowed easements were acquired by our predecessor during the time when the Vernon Dam was constructed [45:09] and planned. Those flowed easements were to protect the company from being sued by other taxpayers. [45:19] At this point in time, when these were acquired, there was the hydroelectric facility was not [45:27] federally regulated. At this point in time, the dam and hydroelectric facility are federally regulated. [45:35] Therefore, the Federal Power Act, which is a part of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's rules [45:44] and laws, they preempt any ability that a landowner could sue us because we are governed by a federal [45:55] license. Therefore, any of the properties that have this flowage easement on them could [46:03] not sue the facility because we have the right and our FERC license to operate the facility [46:09] of a certain elevation. And we comply with that and anytime we were to not comply with [46:16] that, FERC would find us or they would tell us, you know, there would be some repercussions. [46:23] any time the operating level does exceed what we were allowed, it is typically during a time when there is a natural disaster or a flood, which is beyond our control. [46:37] We don't control when Mother Nature drops a couple feet of water, we just move the water as best we can. [46:45] And so the report that the state is referencing is referencing about a 1,046 acres of flowage [46:58] easements. So these are easements over somebody else's land. In most cases those landowners are [47:07] able to use the land as they see fit because we impact their land very minimally. [47:14] It is typically within the 100-year flood zone, meaning that there is a 1% chance annually [47:21] that they could flood. [47:24] And the way that we are being valued is at $1500 per acre. [47:31] When I looked at the land schedule, it caps out at 48 acres or $1,600 an acre. [47:39] So that means whatever the land is being taxed, it's almost double-diped because we're [47:48] being taxed $1,500 acre, the other taxpayer is being taxed $1,600 acre, so we are paying [47:56] almost as much as somebody that actually owns the land. [48:00] We don't own any land, we just have the right to flow water on the land if we must. [48:07] And so, go ahead. [48:11] Question? [48:12] With Jocelyn? [48:13] Wait a minute. [48:14] We're going to have questions when she's completed. [48:16] Okay. [48:17] We'll have Jocelyn. [48:18] Okay. [48:19] I'm almost done. [48:21] But in all, it is our opinion that because of this preemption and because of the fact that [48:30] we are federally licensed, there shouldn't be any change in value, though the state is dictating [48:36] it, we don't want to fight with the town about this, we would like to reach a reasonable [48:44] resolution where we are paying our fair share of property taxes but not at a 15,000% increase. [48:55] And so we would like to find a middle ground between what the town has and what we have to [49:02] to reach a reasonable resolution [49:03] while we can still pay our proportionate amount [49:07] of property taxes in Westminster. [49:10] We enjoyed being a part of the community. [49:13] I was talking to the listers about just introducing myself. [49:18] Many of our employees live and go to Westminster daily. [49:23] We don't want to have any conflicts, [49:26] but we also can't walk away from a $15,000 increase. [49:30] it's just unfair and so that's the end of it. [49:39] Thanks. [49:39] Thank you for that. [49:42] So I have the next step here is to ask the listeners to respond to the information presented by the appellant. [49:57] Well, again, I would just say it's, it's, you know, I'm not training to have any food, what this [50:04] even should be, belly then. We have to use the number that the state provides. [50:13] Because we don't, we have nobody's system to depend on. [50:16] number. And I'm happy that Great Britain either reminds us to talk to anybody [50:23] surely with us, which is kind of a civil conversation with us in a way. [50:28] But at this point, the listeners don't have any differences. [50:33] In a sense, [50:35] accepting or not accepting either the 10,000 or a little more million plus. [50:40] us, we just don't have the housing issues, and I have, so now, uh, that's questions from [50:46] the UCA. [50:48] You'd be on state-advager, um, sweatboard. [50:51] I would like to know, for how many years prior to 2013, uh, or prior to now, the flow [50:58] into easement was valued at $10,000. [51:00] When was the $10,000 value established? [51:03] and what was the value when the Vernon Dam was installed in the early 19th [51:10] session? [51:12] I can get the number just one second for how long it's been at 10,000 [51:18] dollars as for what the value was when Vernon Dam was constructed. [51:27] I don't have [51:36] there was no monetary value exchanged between the company and the landowner. [51:45] It was a... [51:47] What I am referencing here is you're worried about a rapid increase in value. [51:58] What I am suspecting is that change in value represents nearly as [52:05] centuries worth of change in land value unless you can demonstrate otherwise. It's quite possible [52:14] that it's at $10,000 for a very long time. [52:21] So I show that it's been $10,000 since 2015 prior to [52:26] that. It was $11,500 within the realm of the 10,000 going back. [52:36] But the way to value [52:39] an easement per appraisals is what is the land worth without the easement? So valuing the actual [52:49] landowner's property and then valuing what a willing buyer would pay for that property [52:59] with the easement on it and the difference between what the willing buyer would pay with the easement [53:06] Subtracted by the value of the property without the easement is the value of the easement. [53:15] And from what I've experienced and looked at, a lot of the land along the kind of care [53:24] river is farmland. [53:25] It is the best farmland in New England. [53:29] And whoever is buying those properties to use it for farmland doesn't care that there's [53:35] an easement on it. They're using it for the production of their farm. [53:42] And so the impacts [53:44] of the easement is nil because they're still willing to use that land and pay what it [53:53] costs for that land to be able to farm it because it's fantastic land. [53:59] It may be fantastic land, but it's flooded damages to crops. Does the flooding easement result in some flooding? [54:11] Not under our operations. If there is flooding, it is typically because of a natural disaster. [54:23] What our dams do when we have high water, they're ultimately invisible. [54:30] We just pass water through them. [54:33] We are actually helping communities with less flooding because we're moving the water [54:40] out of the way. [54:42] We are not creating the flooding or else it would be flooded every single day from our operations. [54:49] Our FERC license does not allow that. [54:54] That would not seem to be the implication of something called the flooding easter. [54:58] It's a flow of Jesus. It's the right to flow if necessary. [55:03] It is not the right to flood indefinitely. [55:09] I have a question from Craig. [55:11] Thank you. [55:12] I'll keep being a landowner there. [55:15] I was strong with this agreement, everything we've said. [55:18] What is? [55:18] It's a privilege yes to farmland, but when only you can only use a farmland, so out on the [55:25] west news, and we're talking about taxes, it's taken to get off taxes because it can never [55:30] be any pamphlet homes, we can't do anything, and it's all over your dam and your blood. [55:35] Second part, if you said there's not our fault, yes, it is, we've got to pull the boards up [55:39] and flood it every year because you don't have enough data on it. It's all coming from [55:44] Bellas Ball. Ben doing this, Ben there all my life. Watch our place get flooded all the time. [55:50] Okay, so yes, it lowers the value of that all of that land because everybody knows that flood [55:57] and meanwhile all that land does not pay in the tax it should have to the town of West [56:02] Minister because everybody looks at it all and don't want this because it floods every once in a while. [56:08] My big argument is the state of Vermont and new people are really smart people. [56:14] The state of Vermont was smart enough to come up with a formula and to come back and [56:18] say, here there are mathematical formulas instead of 1.5 million. [56:22] I can't understand why two people haven't come back and said, no, they're formula is wrong. [56:27] Because they can pick 1.5 million out of the air and just say, here it is. [56:31] they came up with a system that said this is how they get you. [56:36] And personally, one of those committees should go and ask the state to do it. [56:39] How do you get there? [56:41] Because they came up with their number. [56:43] Do people have to come up with any number? [56:44] And I don't blame you because you've been all these years, [56:46] but I'll get what I'll pay to your fair share, okay? [56:50] But they come back and say it's 10,000. [56:52] Even though the reason was 10,000 because the listeners didn't know what to do [56:56] with it and just lowered it even from the 11,000. [56:59] But I can't believe that you guys can't calculate a form of that for the same form of a state of use and just agree with a number. [57:07] I'm with you on that, but to come here and pick a number out of the sky, it's just a bunch of ways to die. [57:16] Is the farmland in a floodplain? [57:21] It is within the 100-year floodplain. It is supposed to be it's in an area that is okay to flood. [57:31] it is that way up and down the river. People don't build houses in flood [57:38] plains because it may flood. It had a 1 to 10% chance of flooding depending on [57:46] where you are. If the farmland was not flooded, would it be as great as... would [58:03] Hey, can you just agree with you? [58:05] Okay. [58:07] 10 free and 7 free, maybe. [58:09] But right now in that farmland floods, [58:12] our farmers who is hundreds of thousands of dollars, [58:15] hundreds of thousands of dollars in loss crops from flooding. [58:21] Yeah, Susan Harlow. [58:22] Susan Harlow. [58:22] Yeah, Susan Harlow. [58:25] And yeah, sometimes you can't, [58:26] because the water from the river, [58:29] sometimes contaminates the farmland, [58:31] and you can't use it, or you can use it, but there are disease pathogens in there. [58:39] So that lowers the value of the property. So yeah, we don't look forward to [58:45] our frontline being pleasant, really. Now we have a good idea. [58:52] Maybe historically, that's how that was rich. [58:57] So I don't know if you would build. Yeah, but it's really different than I know. [59:03] So I was being contaminated and taken away, basically top solace being put on. [59:11] So there was another hand, another hand, okay, sorry, pegging can. [59:16] So Chas, I've just been clarity. [59:19] In West nature, there's 28 acres who sell that have been missing. [59:23] No, the 48 acres was what was capped in the land schedule. [59:28] So it only lists to a maximum of 48 acres when it's estimating the value, so that was the highest number that I could use for comparison. [59:39] And your company does not have a bigger value of this. [59:46] You're not putting forth a figure for us to consider. [59:52] We propose that it's the same. [59:55] We propose that it stays the same. [1:00:06] Any other questions from the BCA? [1:00:13] Well, have you anything else to ask? No, I'm else that. [1:00:22] Well, I think we've heard all the testimony that we need. I mean, questions answered. Sure, no more questions. Okay, so. [1:00:31] So, at [1:00:35] this point, I think we're all set with you and I very much appreciate your coming [1:00:42] by Zoom to the meeting, and we're going to. [1:00:45] I would be interested when the inspection is going to be as I would like to partake. [1:00:51] Okay. [1:00:52] We'll definitely let you know that's part of our job there, is to do a lot of these forms [1:00:58] that we especially look so close. [1:01:02] Okay. [1:01:04] Okay. Thanks. [1:01:05] We will. [1:01:06] We will notify you by email. [1:01:09] Is that out of that? [1:01:11] Yes. [1:01:11] Thank you. [1:01:12] Thanks very much. [1:01:14] Thank you. [1:01:15] Thank you. [1:01:15] Thank you. [1:01:22] Okay. [1:01:23] Do we need a motion? [1:01:25] Well, we need a motion to avoid the inspection committee at this point. [1:01:31] Did you want to make a motion another? [1:01:34] Oh, I didn't know whether we needed a motion to deny a appeal, a metapote, a point inspection committee, or whether the first step was to point the first step is to appoint the inspection community. [1:01:51] So, okay. [1:01:53] So, we might like to lay on the committee. [1:01:59] Is there a second to mass motion? [1:02:01] Yes. [1:02:01] Yes, Matt, second name. [1:02:03] Oh, Matt. [1:02:04] You made it. [1:02:05] I made it. [1:02:05] Oh, my second name. [1:02:07] Thank you. [1:02:10] Okay. [1:02:12] Thank you. [1:02:14] So you're looking for me. [1:02:16] I'm looking. [1:02:16] I'm looking for you. [1:02:19] I'm going to be on the committee. [1:02:21] Okay. [1:02:22] Thanks, Matt. [1:02:28] Well, I guess I'll hold on to it. [1:02:30] Thanks. [1:02:31] Okay. [1:02:33] Yeah. [1:02:33] And I hope that has been a good thing. [1:02:35] It's almost something I will be able to pass. [1:02:36] Yeah, and she'll come with us. [1:02:38] She'll come with us. [1:02:39] So that's the thing, sir. [1:02:41] Thank you for your new attorney. [1:02:42] Thank you very much. [1:02:43] The whole thing. [1:02:44] I recommend, yes, that they can maybe [1:02:47] try to get the original documentation [1:02:50] and or communicate with someone to see. [1:02:53] But that's a 2013, whatever the model or method [1:02:56] that we use at that point, when the state [1:03:04] and then that they get to the 2016 war for the 4Ks that established a different mechanism [1:03:15] for calculating the further chip. [1:03:18] Waterford mechanism, as well as the 2013 state of remote mechanism for establishing the [1:03:29] phoenixism. Right, because they're saying whatever however they did it in 2013 that that has been [1:03:38] I don't know, maybe irrelevant, or more. [1:03:45] By the law. [1:03:46] So children, not the proper way by this court case that was occurred in 26 and out of 26. [1:03:53] And do they, is there any logical, yearly inflation in that land value to the interest [1:04:01] of the soul? [1:04:02] So, I mean, everyone knows this in the way that, thatraisal works and the not is, we have [1:04:11] a tabloid repraisal. [1:04:13] At least the same she's mentioned, the landspot, the landspotual is, you know, how this, [1:04:19] about this quality of land is not followed by peps. [1:04:23] This quality of land is not followed by loa, this quality of land is not followed by seed. [1:04:27] And then that stays at the same thing their schedule sports is like, you know, their quality [1:04:34] or their room says, you know, attacking everything. Those multipliers stay the same until the [1:04:41] next time, like, you praise them. So here, if you build a brand new house today, or face [1:04:47] other than the venue, face, it's value right now at the 2013 not-get-value for one of the [1:04:55] Yes! [1:04:56] Very good. [1:05:00] Thank you very much. [1:05:21] Thank you. [1:05:22] for a moment, we have quite close to that issue. [1:05:24] Thank you. [1:05:24] Thanks, Rebecca. [1:05:26] Right, so I think it was from incidents that we did either [1:05:30] in 2013 and was moving on with the state, [1:05:34] joining 13 by the state. [1:05:35] But it's going to be constant. [1:05:37] It's going to be constant. [1:05:38] OK, unless there's another event that was to be. [1:05:42] But we need that. [1:05:45] We can hopefully have an answer to help us get that information [1:05:49] from the state, and I don't know how we get the water for it. [1:05:55] Well, I assume it's about a public record. [1:05:59] Yeah. [1:06:00] It's a court case. [1:06:06] for one of the cities and towns offered a lot of help. [1:06:10] And all of a sudden, [1:06:11] there are many research people jump to. [1:06:14] There's a little bit of information. [1:06:24] We have our committee unless somebody else would [1:06:27] like to join the committee as well. [1:06:33] We need one more. [1:06:35] Is there a volunteer? [1:06:38] Nice to have somebody else. [1:06:39] You know, it's just. [1:06:46] Okay, so we got the time when we saw we're going to, well, [1:06:52] what we're supposed to do in this situation is to inspect the property and set a date and a time set by the chair to inspect the property and reported findings back to the BSA, but we're not really going to do that because we're not going to go out and inspect property. [1:07:07] We're going to do our digging into research. [1:07:10] Well, we could do my time for getting information from the state. [1:07:19] Right. [1:07:20] We could be doing our math research as here. [1:07:27] It's not. [1:07:28] I don't think it's going to be put down there. [1:07:35] So I think that we need to set update to recess not more than 30 days from now to bring [1:07:46] our information back to the board. [1:07:50] So yes, didn't she also ask that she would like to be a part of that inspection? [1:07:54] question. She wants to know the date of the question. Yeah, yeah. So I think that you've [1:07:58] got to. Okay. Something. All right. So we have to have something available to her. What [1:08:04] sort of time for it? 30 days from within 30 days from. So how do we get her if we're just [1:08:14] doing research and we're not actually. Well, we get research to get information from the [1:08:20] state. Yeah. And then we have our own flood control maps in our town. Yeah. And she already [1:08:30] has the acreage. It was a 1041 or something she mentioned, the flowage, the acreage covered [1:08:37] by the flowage usage of the thousands and some of them. And which makes me suspect this [1:08:44] 10,000 since 1921 and so we we want to be prepared. I don't think we need to find much more than what you [1:09:02] We were suggested that we know how the state is taxable. [1:09:09] But there are a lot of years. [1:09:11] Just before we wrinkle on this, I'm not sure that we can go out and find a vision. [1:09:18] Like when we vote, like others, they were not supposed to get what the listeners tell us. [1:09:26] And we have what the panel tells us. [1:09:28] We're not supposed to go out and find the trial. [1:09:30] Yeah, you know, you're right on that. [1:09:32] Yeah, I think that you're that's kind of like you get a hard place here because we can't really. [1:09:38] We're always supposed to take the testimony. [1:09:40] You go from the right and that's supposed to go fine. [1:09:43] Right. [1:09:44] Okay. [1:09:44] So I don't know if that's something that we could do or anything. [1:09:47] Well, we have the testimony of the acreage. [1:09:49] How should it store us? [1:09:51] Yeah. [1:09:51] That's a lot. [1:09:52] Okay. [1:09:54] And I don't know if you can call the state and say any information. [1:09:58] I don't know what to say about how to use the testimony in this room, not, you know, [1:10:05] call up somebody and say, can you give us more information? [1:10:09] Or not? [1:10:10] They have 100-year math. [1:10:12] That's what we always knew. [1:10:14] However, without the letter, we should do more research. [1:10:18] We can. [1:10:19] When it went over to the underneath, it went over to 100-year, and so then we had came back. [1:10:24] And it does affect it because all my companies had to change their insurance because they went to a 500 because all the lower planes now got flooded and they said they wouldn't because it was more than they said, oh, so we said, what's going to be around sure, but that all that [1:10:41] I do the reformer of the value in your way, but all of a sudden to go from a [1:10:46] engineer to a 500, because it cost more for a little shirt. [1:10:51] Okay, then Adrian, you... Sure, I would like to suggest that because this is [1:10:58] an assessment that's based on information, it's not based on [1:11:04] walk-in particular structures, etc., that that is part of the inspection that this committee needs to undertake. [1:11:16] The committee needs to inspect the formulas, the maps, the easements, etc., etc., and would also suggest that in accumulating this information, [1:11:31] and you can sort of parcel out who's going to pursue what. [1:11:35] And then you get together and talk about what you've learned. [1:11:40] And then that might be the day at which you invite Jocelyn in, [1:11:49] or you may have this information. [1:11:56] You can organize it and then you invite Jocelyn in and say, [1:12:03] I'm going to make a suggestion before we go on with this, that we don't set a date [1:12:10] in a time yet, and someone on this board contacted them out of the league of cities and towns [1:12:18] and asked them what is the legal way to proceed with this, because we've never done this [1:12:24] We've dealt with property with, you know, comps and the property owner says this and we go out and we look at it. [1:12:33] It's been really pretty cut dry other than the solar event, the solar field. [1:12:38] I don't know how that ever turned out, but I think we need to, we need to get some advice on this. [1:12:45] I would believe that if we asked for advice or asked for the formula, and kept it sealed [1:13:00] as we're until the inspection thing, and they view it as part of the inspection as we [1:13:15] need to know who's they. I'm just saying that, yeah, I don't think that it's under that you [1:13:24] are understanding that word asset as the VCA receives information testimony that were only [1:13:33] permitted to use what we've got here. We can't call, we can't look at maps, we can't really do that [1:13:42] in to extend our input of our information. [1:13:49] Like if somebody came to us, for instance, [1:13:51] and they said their tax rate was too high, [1:13:54] we couldn't look at comps in the area. [1:13:57] Outside of this, you can only look at what the listers provide [1:14:01] and what the appellant provides us. [1:14:05] And then we go out and do the inspection. [1:14:08] Yes. [1:14:10] But I'm sorry. [1:14:10] I asked because I haven't been conscious pain really. [1:14:13] Isn't the inspection itself is it the information that we're not just going and standing somewhere [1:14:20] in contact with about where evidence in our evidence, you're actually looking at some structure [1:14:25] or some place. [1:14:27] And I said, the fact that in this case that there is no physical structure to look at means [1:14:36] So, the thing that you have to look at is a chart, sort of. [1:14:41] Now, I strongly disagree. [1:14:43] I'll throw one out, take down those, okay? [1:14:47] They would have to take their land out of the flood zone, [1:14:50] and see if they can tell you, they would get a well [1:14:52] over $1 million more, so they're profitable [1:14:55] and you're supposed to go to the flood zone, isn't it? [1:14:57] I understand that. [1:14:58] I'm not substituting. [1:15:00] And so the environment, yeah, that's kind of, but there's structure, there is, there's whatever is in that path, whatever they are. Well, like I said, I would really like to ask the Vermont League of Citizens and Founders, how do we see before we proceed. So I, yes, I mean, I hate to interrupt that. They're out here. Okay. So I'm going to recess this and. Would ask somebody to contact. [1:15:29] I'm not research. [1:15:30] No, not research. [1:15:32] So contact the Vermont League of Citizens and Towns and fine. [1:15:35] Okay. [1:15:36] Well, it's it's advice. It's legal advice. [1:15:39] All right. So, Jeanette, we'll do that. [1:15:42] How do we, I'm sure we're a little bit worried about 30, [1:15:45] the 30th day, or you know, [1:15:47] how do we get the job done? [1:15:52] Well, we get the advice. [1:15:53] We get the advice. [1:15:55] And then we, I get, we will reconvene. [1:15:58] Somehow, I guess, maybe we could do that by Zoom. [1:16:03] I mean, it was only, I don't know, this is new stuff for me. [1:16:08] And I think everybody on the board of civil authority [1:16:13] needs to read the parameters, her tasks, accessibility, [1:16:21] or, you know, along the way. [1:16:23] And I want anybody to have a comment about that. [1:16:29] Okay. So the date. Yeah. And within 30 days. Right. So I say within, well, Jeanette, [1:16:39] when do you think you can run this information of having them on me? [1:16:43] I'll try. I'll try. Pardon me. I'll try for two hours. [1:16:47] Okay. So. [1:17:06] So we're saying, so that has [1:17:08] fallen to your point. Yeah. [1:17:10] Well, I don't know what you want [1:17:12] me to do. [1:17:13] Just recess to net well, [1:17:15] Genette is appointed to, [1:17:17] and you get this down to [1:17:18] to. [1:17:19] to pursue with Vermont Legal Cities and Towns and we will recess this meeting in two weeks or one week. [1:17:30] One week. How does that work? [1:17:38] Okay, so I am calling this meeting to be recessed until one week from today, [1:17:48] which is anybody of a calendar. [1:17:51] This part of speaking recess, you still haven't. [1:17:53] Right. Okay. The BCI is applauding. [1:17:56] We're assessing this and now we're going to open [1:18:00] for the board of a meeting. Yes. [1:18:02] The chat is August 6th. [1:18:05] August 6th. Thank you. [1:18:08] And we won't even touch about how to do that. [1:18:12] We're going to set up the meeting [1:18:15] and have it available by Zoom. [1:18:18] Okay. Yes, thank you. [1:18:21] Yeah, no. [1:18:26] Okay, so now they're going to [1:18:30] Are you going to go through that? [1:18:31] I'm going to go through that. [1:18:32] I think so. [1:18:33] Thank you. [1:18:38] Do you know? [1:18:40] Yes, there are. [1:18:42] I think there are. [1:18:45] There are really, very different. [1:18:47] That's right. [1:18:49] That's right. [1:18:49] No, we don't. [1:18:51] Oh, I'm sorry. [1:18:54] You don't know? [1:19:00] I'm sorry, I don't have an excellent package. [1:19:03] I've given them all out. [1:19:08] So I believe we also have to be organized that many people, so I didn't realize how [1:19:15] to lead. [1:19:17] That's the only way to go. [1:19:18] Okay, person. [1:19:19] Well, the abatement committee is a majority of the BCA. [1:19:26] They're sitting on the minimum of 12 people, or so what do we have? [1:19:30] Who's on the BCA? [1:19:31] I can touch your hand. [1:19:32] So everyone here is on the BCA. [1:19:34] Okay, so yeah, [1:19:38] we're here. [1:19:39] I'm good. [1:19:40] Are you? [1:19:41] You're not on the BSA. [1:19:45] I'm not sure. [1:19:46] I'm not sure. [1:19:46] I'm not sure. [1:19:47] I'm not sure. [1:19:49] I'm not sure. [1:19:50] I'm not sure. [1:19:51] We're good. Okay. Oh, all right. So let me go to this position. [1:20:15] Okay. I hereby can be in the [1:20:18] the the seating of the tax evadement is here. And I'm [1:20:27] just sitting here. [1:20:31] So I'm opening the hearing [1:20:33] and the applicant is Rebecca Saunders and the [1:20:45] property location is 1.13 on road in [1:20:52] Westminster before the cut means beyond the rest. And the parcel ID is 0.013.000. [1:21:04] zero zero. And so [1:21:11] Rebecca Saunders is here. And I'm not under under under okay. So I would like [1:21:22] any the applicant and any witnesses to are you a witness as well to this case. Yes you yes you are [1:21:31] Okay. So I'd like the applicant and witness to take the following oath. Under the pains and penalties [1:21:37] of virtually, do you solemnly swear that the evidence you give and cause under consideration [1:21:44] shall be the hope for nothing but the truth? [1:21:49] And does anybody on the Board of Civil Authority have [1:21:53] of any conflict of interest, in this case. [1:22:00] So Rebecca, have you received a copy [1:22:03] of the board's rules and procedures [1:22:06] and do you have any questions about how [1:22:08] we're proceeding to a new inquiry? [1:22:19] I'll set you understand how we're going down to okay. [1:22:22] And can you identify which of the statutory categories [1:22:29] your abatement is being made under. [1:22:34] That would be, that's on the first page of your [1:22:38] application. Oh, I don't have the application with me. Oh, thank you. Oh yes, the [1:22:47] taxes and charges. We're first and so unable to pay a charge and a first and [1:22:52] information for this. Okay. Could you all understand that? Did everybody hear that? [1:22:59] And have it? Okay. All right. So Rebecca, would you like you to present your evidence and [1:23:13] anything you would like to offer about your place? Oh, inside of order. [1:23:22] You're [1:23:22] Well, one [1:23:28] thing that did occur to me today was that if I had a payment plan without penalties and interest with help, um, hey, [1:23:41] I, what else to add that I've already said, um, this, the gist of it all is that because of a lot of contract of fraud scams, I got into big financial trouble. [1:23:54] seven years ago, and I haven't quite managed to get out. Maybe the answer to the side of it all. [1:24:01] And then when my taxes doubled, I was hit kind of harder because I had not yet paid my last taxes. [1:24:09] And I think the next year I'll be able to payish things, you know, things to study. But this year [1:24:19] is really tough because I don't have a home stator credit for this year, but I had $200 [1:24:26] on stator credit because our home milestone stator thing got listed wrong many years [1:24:32] ago, it got $7.25, but I was never getting proper home stator credit for my house which has [1:24:41] evaluation of 247 something thousand which I managed to make up for the contractor for [1:24:51] I'm by getting loans and all that and I think that my homestay credit would have been pretty [1:24:59] nice. I mean this year is pretty good for next year but it's not for this year. You know [1:25:04] how the year is behind the year. So this year is the tough one. I'm caught up with everything [1:25:10] except this year. And I'm going to have to take out a loan because I get a nice loan for [1:25:18] lower interest than I would be paid on a payment plan. [1:25:24] And so that's what I'm asking for a [1:25:26] reduction for this year. And then because if I had the proper homestead credit, I would probably be okay. [1:25:34] But it never did because of the various mistakes that I think I explained. [1:25:39] I can explain the mistakes if anybody wants to hear them. [1:25:44] I think you should go ahead and do that because I've got a great number of the people who [1:25:47] were not here for your previous experience. [1:25:51] I'll check. [1:25:52] So the problem really started with the contractor fraud. [1:25:54] Can everybody hear? [1:25:56] Yeah. [1:25:56] Can you correct them? [1:25:57] My contractor fraud scams really disasters and for which there's no help. [1:26:01] It was blue narrowed to everybody asking for help, everybody from the governor on down. [1:26:08] And there's really nothing you can do about that. [1:26:12] Because even if you take a contractor to court, they don't have to pay anything and they [1:26:15] all know that. [1:26:16] They all know that. [1:26:16] They all know that. [1:26:17] You know, just in the States. [1:26:19] And that's true. [1:26:20] So that's what got me in the big trouble. [1:26:23] And meanwhile, what happened was I had a trailer that was on my property that I had a trailer [1:26:29] and then a sort of outbuilding, garage-y kind of thing. [1:26:33] The trailer got removed and we had the proper things [1:26:37] for a Charlie level got the permit [1:26:40] and he helped me with all that. [1:26:42] But it wasn't listed properly. [1:26:44] And so it was listed. [1:26:45] I was paying taxes for a trailer for many years. [1:26:50] But then when the trailer was removed in 2020, [1:26:55] that was really paying taxes on a building [1:26:57] it wasn't there as my loss was being constructed because I had loans to finally we finally got some [1:27:03] kind of decent contractors that took a long time and the house was finally finished in 24 last year. [1:27:14] So okay so then the homestead credit was not accurate and the house list thing was not accurate because [1:27:20] we got that fixed there were two problems the listing was was at 50% of homestead value is that a [1:27:26] 100% because of a mistake. Who knows? I might have made it somehow. I called the building a studio and it seemed like it was a [1:27:37] art studio, which it wasn't. It's just one of those some things you do. You name something and then it bites you later. So once I got the 100% listing, things got better, but since [1:27:49] The home value is very low even though my home by that point was getting a little bit more valuable. [1:27:56] I wasn't getting the right credit. [1:27:59] Does that make sense? It's so complicated. [1:28:06] So, and then, of course, everybody got the tax increase. I got a double. I got from 3000 something to 6000. [1:28:13] And I had just arranged to pay the 3,000 kind of got it paid and then I get here was 6,000 and I just didn't have it [1:28:22] I don't have to be patient in 36,000, the property will get less [1:28:27] Yeah, the property tax was double, I'll tell you what [1:28:31] Yeah, the last year the property tax is double [1:28:39] So, you know, about 3,000, 426,000, [1:28:44] do you know the things that are going on? [1:28:46] So, you know, that on double visit was a reasonable [1:28:49] obligation, or increase as well percentage. [1:28:52] But it would be, you know, the big double fit of this year, [1:28:57] is no problem from the state. [1:28:59] Yeah. [1:28:59] We had only $200 of the credit. [1:29:02] Yeah. [1:29:02] And we have now $6,000 to pay. [1:29:06] Right. [1:29:06] So the next year, the homestay credit is pretty good, and that's manageable. [1:29:12] But for this year, it's not. [1:29:13] And for the years in the past, it hasn't really been more than one year. [1:29:16] I think it was $130 on the years, $200, $25. [1:29:19] It was a mistake, and it all got fixed. [1:29:22] I don't understand why the education state tax payment was so long. [1:29:30] That's that double mistake. [1:29:32] That's why it's so confusing. [1:29:33] Well, yeah, but that it's something I'm going to state you made because that's calculated from your income tax. [1:29:43] It was listed incorrectly. [1:29:48] Yeah, but that's based on your income. [1:29:52] But the education tax credit is calculated by the state. [1:30:08] So, what's income and property value, let's see the property value, it was very, very low, because [1:30:15] delicious for them is a trailer. And then when the property went up, this somehow this got [1:30:20] fitted. It's just too much test with your income forms. Now, what they've told me is, it's [1:30:30] property, and they told me that the more valuable your property is, the bigger your credit [1:30:37] is. [1:30:38] Excuse me. [1:30:40] Rachel has it. [1:30:42] Yes. [1:30:42] The value of your property went up. [1:30:46] The new building. [1:30:50] So, yes, your education said credit would have been so much more than that, but your value would [1:30:59] higher, so the taxes would be higher. So they don't be back in trailers to $1,000. That's [1:31:07] a lot. There's a lot more children than the taxes. Really what happens is you pay to look [1:31:12] like the unit of the trailer, and that alerted Mr. Safer's office in the fact that we have received [1:31:20] it earlier. I think Tyler has been assessing the value of $1,000 to $1,000. That's why the [1:31:27] But the thing is, we did, I didn't get any homestead credit for that, but look at the difference between us. [1:31:34] So my point, I don't understand why you didn't know. [1:31:38] Nobody seems to know, but look at it for this year. [1:31:41] That's pretty nice. [1:31:43] Well, that's certainly more like it, but it's 2,200 and something. [1:31:49] But it's applied for next year, so that's my big product. [1:31:52] But that's a lot of number, but we don't find out what to do. [1:31:55] And that's not something we're just afraid of. [1:31:57] It doesn't make any sense to move that to the channel. [1:32:00] I don't know what to do. [1:32:01] Yeah, we call the, you know, that's people, many, [1:32:05] and everyone that say, well, it's down. [1:32:07] And then we go to town, it says, oh, it's state, you know, [1:32:11] you cannot, it's like the bill 6,000 something for this year. [1:32:15] You can have it. [1:32:16] And it's huge amount of money. [1:32:18] It's suddenly double. [1:32:20] You're going to have any help from the state. [1:32:22] That's why we appeal to consider to reduce impact because we don't have money to pay. [1:32:28] We deal with, you know, the frauds, the knowing help us, we conducted, we send letters to everyone [1:32:34] to start to the town, to the governor, to the police, to everyone, zero response, zero. [1:32:42] Because my question is, why is it this, with the same property, the same evaluation, this coming [1:32:50] year, I get $2,200 off the electric at $233 off. That's my question, and as I said, I understand [1:33:02] it's based on when you file your income tax and you're declaring your homestead. You can [1:33:10] If they can't figure it out, then send the figure to the panel. [1:33:14] That's huge difference. [1:33:16] My answer was, I'm an actual defective student. [1:33:19] I had a dream with you. [1:33:20] I don't know what you're saying. [1:33:21] So we'd take your income data. [1:33:23] The SEVCA. [1:33:26] Emily, Emily, I forgot what I was saying right now, [1:33:31] but I think of it as SEVCA does it. [1:33:33] It has done it for a couple of years. [1:33:36] OK, I had mine done by SEVCA. [1:33:39] and they were not going to file a homestead declaration. [1:33:49] Why so? [1:33:51] Because of their income. [1:33:53] Oh, okay. [1:33:54] And I said, you have to file the same declaration. [1:33:58] Yes. [1:33:59] They didn't understand me. [1:34:02] Because the more your house is worth a bigger, you get homestead. [1:34:07] That's what they told me, they told me that it was based on the amount of thought in different [1:34:16] houses. [1:34:17] Because I kept telling me I was based in the value of the public. [1:34:20] But unfortunately, the public knows that it's not just in the system. [1:34:24] You know, some tell me, yeah, what? [1:34:27] If we had the credits for this first year, that from the state, you know, the second year [1:34:33] We can pray that they will be fired from 3,000 to 6,000, suddenly, you know, we want [1:34:41] to emergency room because we got help prizes to receive the bill, we were as strong [1:34:46] as it was. [1:34:50] Yes, you can, you refile taxes for a previous year, I think it's the elect that was in [1:34:57] spend. So what would you read? Yes, I sent her all the last text bills, all but everything [1:35:09] from 9, 5, 2021, which is about when I guess the 21, 22 year, it was the year that the [1:35:17] property was removed, the change and all that. And she's looking at it if I haven't heard [1:35:22] anything. But, because of what, when I called the state, the value of the house they said [1:35:28] really was a factor. My low income is a factor too. I mean, I can't prove my house incredibly [1:35:35] and get more money because I have my income is fixed. So, it has to do with income and [1:35:41] the other one too. And the more finances worth, supposedly, the more you get back. [1:35:46] No, I'm sorry. [1:35:50] I'm sorry. [1:35:50] All right, don't do that, but it's not accurate. [1:35:54] What's it do, what's it do? [1:35:57] It is, it sounds like it would be blocked. [1:36:00] It's to be filed your state's taxes [1:36:02] with a correct homestead declaration for the prior year. [1:36:07] I don't even know how. [1:36:09] Hopefully it's that they don't even help you with that. [1:36:12] That might help you and logically [1:36:17] would give you the same credit for this year, [1:36:21] and hopefully, that process will work. [1:36:27] Anything I should find, like that OTC or whatever that is, [1:36:30] we can also use, does anybody have better support for that? [1:36:34] No, because they give credit from the last year [1:36:38] for the past year and the past year was based on the law, [1:36:43] like on the trailer, on the lower value property. [1:36:46] working. So this year, maybe, you know, this was based on the previous. So that's this [1:36:52] section in between two, you know, it doesn't, it doesn't, it does not help, be asked, it [1:36:59] will not help. [1:37:00] Well, because two years we used to go, but the year before, you know, one time I use a turbo [1:37:06] tax, and one time I use an OTC, whatever the thing is, you feel the mean that, that three [1:37:11] help for indexes if you're retired, and we always go in the hundreds, two hundred, two hundred, [1:37:18] thirty-three, but the highest credit we ever got. [1:37:22] You're going from F and half of it, it's 140, something thousand hours, probably, that's [1:37:31] awfully low. [1:37:32] Yeah, sure. [1:37:33] Thank you. [1:37:34] Could you have some? [1:37:35] Yes. [1:37:35] You said that if you had an abatement of the penalty, [1:37:41] it's not interest, that would make the difference. [1:37:43] What do you have? [1:37:44] So do you have that figure? [1:37:47] Oh no, I've done from last, I mean, I can get it. [1:37:49] I have it from the past year or two, I've been on a payment plan, [1:37:53] with a lot of penalties and interest. [1:37:55] It was maybe $30 a month, but penalty and then interest [1:38:00] was another couple dollars a month. [1:38:03] Our loan is cheaper, believe it or not, getting a loan bank loan is cheaper than paying the [1:38:07] reserve in Texas. [1:38:10] We have to put it in the side of the bill. [1:38:12] Do you have a two-minute bill? [1:38:13] This is the bill. [1:38:13] Yeah, well we just got from... [1:38:15] Yes, that's it. [1:38:19] That's it. [1:38:20] This is what makes me... [1:38:21] You're not... [1:38:21] It's the patient who does request a 50% debatement in your... [1:38:25] That was... [1:38:25] He craved. [1:38:26] That is what you're... [1:38:27] That's what I'm... [1:38:28] That's what I'm trying to do. [1:38:29] Then I think... [1:38:30] Then I think you get to this year... [1:38:31] I'm going to have to... [1:38:32] I'm going to have to... [1:38:32] next year it will be okay. It won't be great, it will be okay. [1:38:37] My income goes up, but [1:38:38] it varies. It's a social security and a pension from my job. So it's fixed. [1:39:00] Is [1:39:11] everybody looking at, looked at the property tax? It's quite looking, somebody was [1:39:17] of the plattery to see them, yeah. [1:39:21] I sent Emily at SOCA, all my last, like, [1:39:25] past four years of touch things, [1:39:28] so she could try to figure it out from her angle, [1:39:31] but it's what happened. [1:39:35] I just assumed it was because the homes [1:39:38] that Chris was not listed properly. [1:39:41] It was this is 50%, and then when I got that changed, [1:39:44] 100%, it was listed as a trailer or logo. [1:39:49] There was no building for a while. [1:39:51] Yeah, we don't really need to go back to the history of this room. [1:39:54] No, just I did deal with that with the current issue. [1:39:59] I think it changed R&M and the creation of the fashionization. [1:40:03] Right, that's true. [1:40:04] Yeah, that's true. [1:40:05] Certainly, you all know that the education that went up is a little bit [1:40:11] value, say the same, the education, say all the different things I'm good at. [1:40:17] Well, my income was more or less the same. [1:40:20] Where did you get that? [1:40:22] I didn't follow the rules. [1:40:23] Yeah. [1:40:24] The whole system. [1:40:25] The whole system. [1:40:26] Now, if I collect correctly, it's because the property [1:40:30] the value increase and within the state [1:40:33] give you from the last year, it give you the credit. [1:40:37] They're going to give you this year a credit for your credit. [1:40:40] So, Junet, it was very confusing because they give you [1:40:46] credit based on the last year of your property value. [1:40:51] It's confusing, but you know, that's, [1:40:54] so we stuck this year with this huge bill, [1:40:57] and we did not have proper tax credit from the state. [1:41:04] For the next year, we have a new bill, [1:41:06] we give us because now it's a new value of the house, [1:41:10] so we give you the credit. [1:41:12] So the problem is generated by essentially revealing the house. [1:41:18] Yes. [1:41:19] And that increases the taxable value and but your what the money you got back from the state [1:41:29] was based on what you paid when the tax were low and you didn't have. [1:41:32] Yes, exactly. [1:41:33] So you were only getting a credit for the taxable value, except when you had the trailer. [1:41:38] Yes. [1:41:38] and now the house is there and your taxes are gone up and every item of that is reasonable [1:41:46] except for the staggering. Yes. Yes. That the increase of taxes comes in a year before [1:41:57] the money that's supposed to help you pay for the taxes. Yes. So you're even if all taxes are [1:42:05] file correctly, and all valuations of the property directly, it's the staggering. [1:42:11] Yes. [1:42:12] Absolutely. [1:42:13] When you fill the house, the first year, yes, you're stuck, yes, that's what I was [1:42:19] saying. [1:42:20] Yes, that's the only one here. [1:42:22] What you're paying for now, yes, is when you're, that's what you don't have. [1:42:25] Yes. [1:42:26] If we can't throw her, if we have the 1,000 state credit, they'll be fine, we can't do that. [1:42:36] This is not like it's doubled, but without any state credit. [1:42:41] You've had something to say Rachel. [1:42:42] It's just going to point out that this is going to happen after the family has been assessed. [1:42:45] the African-American group's value goes up which is one that the [1:42:49] town will receive an upset planet. This is going to have their [1:42:54] upset planet, Jeff I, Alpenade based on my previous [1:42:59] weirdist value. So, the government far says that the town [1:43:03] was the same situation last year. [1:43:09] So the first year we've had [1:43:11] shop in the next year, it has to go down to sleep and it's a problem with it, it's a [1:43:17] very bad experience, it's not so exciting. So I'm looking at it. So, two years ago, nothing [1:43:23] I'm going to take a second. [1:43:25] This is the third year. [1:43:26] Before the town is open for the federal one and join the board 24. [1:43:30] I got to ask right here. [1:43:32] I'm going to have to see if it's. [1:43:34] And what the 150 is the same homestead. [1:43:37] The next year went up. [1:43:39] Now last but very. [1:43:40] Nothing. [1:43:41] In nothing's changed. [1:43:42] I was next three years. [1:43:43] Except they got. [1:43:44] At least two or the same. [1:43:47] Yeah. [1:43:48] I'm just. [1:43:48] So I'm saying here, it was repainted in July, [1:43:53] it was until the end of the year, right? [1:43:56] Oh, I think this is true. [1:43:58] Well, this is a mandate. [1:44:01] So, yeah, I don't know yet. [1:44:03] Oh, I see. [1:44:03] Well, from 100 and it's something to 233. [1:44:06] Right. [1:44:07] I want to see the listing error about things. [1:44:09] Sorry, good. [1:44:10] Well, Mr. Free, yeah. [1:44:11] No, Mr. Free. [1:44:12] But the year before was pretty low, too. [1:44:14] And he's right. [1:44:15] So the three years has been kind of low, it wasn't even lower at the time. [1:44:24] I wasn't like to know if anybody on the BCAA has any more questions for Rebecca about her [1:44:32] situation, her request, etc., [1:44:39] you know, okay. [1:44:42] Thank you, Emma. [1:44:43] Okay. Okay. Don't have a problem with the value of this, the town reset the budget. Yeah. [1:44:51] You're trying to put it free, but when they rent it, when they want different parts, you show them that. [1:44:55] Oh, no, because it's, no. That's like, you're having no money. No, that's not important. [1:45:00] I would like to even improve the law if I could. But I forgot to say, oh, I could also show you all tax returns. So that you see, there's no change much change in the end call. Well, we don't really, that's not really part of our. I wanted to be honest. There is no big, I have a Sunday, I said, we'll wear a lot of money that is a report. I don't. Okay. So I. [1:45:29] I suggest that we close the hearing unless you have any more information to offer or any [1:45:35] other questions from the board. [1:45:38] And we will enter a deliberative session now and we will issue a written decision within [1:45:49] 30 days. [1:45:52] Okay. [1:45:58] Thank you for coming in, thank you for you're waiting for, I appreciate your efforts. [1:46:07] Thanks. [1:46:17] Okay. [1:46:17] Okay, we've said that. What are you saying? I would say that's a very unintended consequence of [1:46:24] the homestead tax credit, you know, based on income that comes to people, that you have this [1:46:32] year staggering. So, in their case, hey, as you point out, affect a lot of people. Yeah. [1:46:38] It'll affect everybody who builds a new house, who has the same income on the property [1:46:44] the year before and now they got a homestead benefit on an empty property and then built a house on it. [1:46:54] And then their taxes go down when they start getting the homestead tax credit. [1:47:00] But the way is calculated now. [1:47:03] It's everybody hard for sure. [1:47:04] it. [1:47:06] What we might consider doing for them might be it something that a lot of people might [1:47:15] be in that same boat. Yeah. Oh, sort of scary. Yeah. So with that in mind, what we decide [1:47:23] now will set a precedent. [1:47:28] So she also mentioned a payment plan. Is she [1:47:35] paying in plans or is that by counting down? Okay. So she was suggesting a payment plan without [1:47:48] interest and penalties. And I don't know how does that need to go before the [1:47:55] select board to request that. But yes, we are currently working on right now, [1:48:02] because if someone to the next question, this now will be the person who was before, [1:48:08] how long we spread it out. Okay. Should it come back before the [1:48:18] I think this board has the discretion, yes, to be in a role in the task of yes, and that is an interest. This board can say, they shouldn't have plans and things this, this, this task earlier. [1:48:38] We're just going to take off $20,000 and we'll never, just rush it out the world, they can. [1:48:43] If it were the mistake, you're going to work in the ground, or you didn't do the value, the argument, that's why when you said, I don't have a problem with the list that you did, it's two, four, seven. [1:48:53] Don't have a problem with it in this income, really fucking, that's not an argument. [1:49:00] She's a bit of a hardship, though. [1:49:02] The catapult is one of the categories that they are part of. [1:49:05] The part of this is the catapult she's involved. [1:49:07] She's gender. [1:49:08] So that's what she said. [1:49:10] Or it's not bad. [1:49:13] Or it's not bad. [1:49:14] I mean, what people wish to do. [1:49:16] I mean, people in them have made a increase in their in their property, [1:49:23] which results in a higher tax rate. [1:49:28] And then subsequently, a year later, a higher reimbursement from the state, you guys didn't. [1:49:35] I mean, that was just our response to the tax bill. [1:49:38] So we, who may have some questions about it? [1:49:41] I mean, seeing the tax bill, that's fun. [1:49:44] But I do think I can take your comment about the rest of it. [1:49:50] Because the time when the price of disabilities comes, it's such a good thing. [1:49:54] you think because we're so far behind the lockdown. [1:49:57] So it's not that everyone's taxes are going to go up. [1:50:01] But for that first year, who's hitting the homestead credit [1:50:05] is going to get much less based on their current, [1:50:08] their new evaluation because it's going to be based [1:50:13] on the previous year, so the first year. [1:50:16] I can't keep my money out of that. [1:50:18] Sorry, it's both a solid evaluation. [1:50:20] evaluation of the house? [1:50:21] Is that final step that we're going to raise human credit? [1:50:25] Is it not based on the value of the value of the percentage? [1:50:28] It's a percentage of the value. [1:50:30] So if you have just $4,000, $90,000 with $2,000, [1:50:36] you're going to say credit within handbox. [1:50:39] If you have $1,000,000 house, you're still [1:50:41] going to say, well, that you're totally [1:50:44] not so credit-based on the percentage. [1:50:46] So the formula is based on the income and your value. [1:50:49] I don't know why you're here. [1:50:52] I don't know why you're here. [1:50:53] I don't know why you're here. [1:50:54] But I feel like it's so much. [1:50:57] Somebody's responsibility. [1:50:59] For war and the task is in this town. [1:51:01] They get to be a valuable. [1:51:03] They are going to get blindsided with. [1:51:07] Oh, well, well, you're going to be dumbed [1:51:09] because they're not going to be prepared to pay it. [1:51:12] Probably very well. [1:51:13] No, that's because if everybody went up, [1:51:15] the dad would be going to go off the date. [1:51:17] I mean, everybody in our community, [1:51:19] all of them, they're all out. [1:51:20] They still get done, they still have a clot, [1:51:22] an X amount of pastures, that's sure. [1:51:25] That's true, of course. [1:51:26] You know, all of them. [1:51:26] It's pretty overall going down in the virus, [1:51:29] it's larger, but an individual person who's getting a homestead [1:51:33] credit is going to get, [1:51:35] let me say credit for some of the previous [1:51:37] previous valve, [1:51:39] which is going to give him much lower for that. [1:51:41] Sure, sure. [1:51:42] But it was a lot at a fall. [1:51:45] So everyone is going to get a change of value notice. [1:51:49] Virtually every single person who owns property [1:51:52] wasn't going to get a change of value that way is always right. [1:51:55] But it tells you what your value and the change. [1:51:57] It doesn't tell you what your taxes are going to be. [1:52:00] You don't know that until after grievances. [1:52:03] You don't know that it's your taxes. [1:52:05] I tell the grand, but one grand was done. [1:52:07] And that's what we're going on right now. [1:52:09] It is how much of the brand is known because that brand is divided into the builder. [1:52:14] Okay. [1:52:15] And right now, we're going to say that people that you were at all time, [1:52:19] I believe we've got it. [1:52:21] And we've got to be careful what we're doing. [1:52:23] We're working hard. [1:52:24] It's not like we're out of the world enough. [1:52:26] $900,000. [1:52:27] Like that. [1:52:28] The link with taxes is not based on per issue. [1:52:32] No. [1:52:32] It's not necessarily based on changes in valuation. [1:52:37] anything is based on COVID and she's not there at practice of not paying [1:52:45] once that. So it came from that. [1:52:48] So how would everyone feel? Even in this chapter of the castling [1:52:53] present and given that she stated that if the evaded panel is an interest [1:52:59] instead of a payment plan that would help her, how would everybody feel about following [1:53:05] That with everybody feels comfortable with that. [1:53:09] It's a kind of a wish. [1:53:11] So it's a kind of a wish. [1:53:13] It's a kind of wish. [1:53:13] It's a kind of wish. [1:53:13] But I still think somebody should give their accounts and go back and give their tax [1:53:18] and stuff correctly. [1:53:19] I think the seat there is not just not going to drive it to a suit. [1:53:22] I think so. [1:53:23] I think so. [1:53:23] Your tax may have been done correctly. [1:53:26] That small amount she got was based on the trailer. [1:53:29] Okay. [1:53:30] And even though the house was already there, now she's [1:53:34] paying taxes on the house that's already there that year, but the amount that we don't [1:53:41] get or almost did right is based on the trailer. So the first year, you build anything. [1:53:48] If you first year, you double your size in the house with a vision. The state doesn't [1:53:54] help you only based on the prior year. And that becomes almost like construction at first [1:54:02] year, you have to pay extra until state formula. Which arguably is dragged out a year [1:54:09] behind is really putting the top building up. Open that, you get that money from the state [1:54:17] because the town cat, if you go to the town, I don't know if you consider that. [1:54:22] You want the bathroom over there. You just want the bathroom. [1:54:28] Okay, so I would like to go back to Peggy's suggestion. And I'll consider that a motion to proceed in that direction that we can also. [1:54:43] That was okay. [1:54:44] Anything's an interest and advise it is set up a payment plan with Kelly. [1:54:50] That's who she should go to. [1:54:51] Was that right? [1:54:52] Yes. [1:54:52] Stayed people here or town people. [1:54:54] Okay. [1:54:56] And yes, we also have to. [1:54:58] When we're bathing her interest in challenges. [1:55:02] Has she already paid that? [1:55:04] If she has, how does she receive those funds as a credit? [1:55:10] I don't know, that's the other question, I thought it's not so hard to be baked and all these [1:55:17] inches. [1:55:18] And if they've already been paid, this should get tough for you to find a way that should [1:55:24] get someone else some time ago and say it's about equally annoying or it'll get up. [1:55:30] The process is equally easy or hard to give somebody a credit against a future payment versus [1:55:39] is cutting them a check or something like that, that they didn't think they were saying [1:55:42] were you okay with me? [1:55:43] They didn't do that. [1:55:44] Okay, sure. [1:55:45] What? [1:55:46] I have a little problem because they were living in the house and getting charged for [1:55:51] a trailer. [1:55:53] So they already had the house there. [1:55:56] The only reason why this fall happened was they came in to the listers and said that we [1:56:01] didn't take their trailer off because they got rid of it. [1:56:04] So then we sent the title over there as a full house and then they had the houses already [1:56:09] there. So it was kind of like, I don't like the, it's like a [1:56:13] double dip, you know, because if they had not gone in on the [1:56:17] trailer, they wouldn't have known that they had the house [1:56:21] there. They would be paying on the trailer or until the new [1:56:23] appraisal. And they wouldn't have told us that they weren't the [1:56:27] one coming to us saying that they put the house there. We [1:56:31] said that the reason why we found that out was because they [1:56:35] complained because their trailer wasn't taken off. [1:56:38] So we thought you got a memo of an L-fidget practice because the mistress who were coming [1:56:42] in during the part of the pension then, when then we got a new appraisal right after [1:56:47] that in the list that the previous appraisal at L had, did completely get transferred over to [1:56:56] toddler. [1:56:57] So what about the bills in this state? [1:56:59] I would actually think that you would have to try those acts that are really great. [1:57:03] So, I think they had a building permit for the house. [1:57:11] So, right, and because it was overlooked during the pandemic, it is not. [1:57:20] I think that that overturns the double dipping problem. [1:57:28] I mean, that's not their fault. [1:57:30] They got a permit, they told the town that they were building this house. [1:57:36] Town didn't know, and in church, but not because town wasn't formed, but because the town forgot. [1:57:44] They have this land, but they don't want to stay in town anymore. [1:57:50] In the same situation, also nearer. [1:57:52] Right, just a year earlier. [1:57:54] So, yeah, we're going to leave this kind of confused. [1:57:58] Yeah, we're not leaving. [1:58:00] I'm going to get in of it. [1:58:01] Not confused. [1:58:01] One more, in the early days of the war, [1:58:03] some cats can go collect the money. [1:58:05] And if you came back and made a vaping, [1:58:07] that you're going to give them an X credit, [1:58:10] then Kelly can take the credit and be done with it. [1:58:12] But so go and say that we're going to wave this and wave that. [1:58:15] We would have to come back again and try to figure out [1:58:18] what that dollar amount is. [1:58:20] Because, if you'd fare the Kelly, [1:58:21] We've got to act and say this is the credit you got to get to their account then set up papers, you know, didn't work with it. [1:58:29] But we're going to leave and say we're going to just give her exit and nobody know who's going to calculate it. [1:58:35] And then there's a week, none of us are going to really know when we meet tonight how much money that is. [1:58:41] I think we can trust Kelly to figure out the penalties and interests. [1:58:44] That's right. [1:58:45] It's kind of urgent. [1:58:48] I mean, if that cut and drive, what a penalty isn't what I'm using, that's not, I'm just [1:58:53] thinking. [1:58:54] I mean, you never pay for that. [1:58:56] But I didn't put it in there. [1:58:57] I didn't let go. [1:58:59] Yeah, back right up. [1:59:00] Well, you know, when you talked about cutting someone, you check. [1:59:03] It's already behind on their taxes. [1:59:05] It's got services for a few plowed. [1:59:09] They're actually being picked up. [1:59:11] They're making payments and I understand. [1:59:13] But are we going to see you're going to go bad, you're going to wave their penalties and [1:59:17] interests in color, but Jack, me that sounds, I don't know, it's fun for you to have [1:59:23] wealth, you know. But these people do seem to be willing to pay their taxes. They pay their [1:59:31] taxes previously. She stated that she feels comfortable paying their taxes, going forward with the [1:59:39] I don't think is the sort of thing that we give them a check and they run away and don't [1:59:45] pay their taxes. [1:59:46] No, I'm saying go from, okay, from right now, from this day forward, this is the way [1:59:50] we're going to have them. [1:59:51] But we're not going to retroactively go back and decide to cut you and check for the last [1:59:57] Here's a... [2:00:00] May, maybe that's what wasn't being said, that's the way I took it. When we said we were going to [2:00:08] kind of a check for what they've already paid for, penalties and dyes. I think she's only [2:00:13] delinquent for this year's taxes that have been passed, but I don't know. [2:00:18] Twenty-four, twenty-five tenants. Twenty-four, twenty-five tenants is what is, so we could [2:00:24] would specify to forgive the penalties of interest on 24-25 taxes, if there is some. [2:00:35] So penalty is, once you miss your tax payment, you get a 10% penalty, and it's like 8% [2:00:43] depends on what you want. [2:00:44] It's something like that, right? [2:00:45] I mean, it's kind of worth one, it's a lot less in a second because it's yielding for [2:00:49] second one, you don't need to know the second one, you get hit a lot harder in [2:00:54] February because you also didn't do it in September. It's a formula but it's [2:01:01] never more than eight percent. I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know. [2:01:06] It has a source of calculus by the year, by the day, by the month, [2:01:10] months, months, months, months, months, months, months. [2:01:17] If you don't make a February, then there's a penalty, and then there's a, I think both [2:01:22] three of these are not for it, you know what I'm saying? [2:01:25] So they give you a chance because you just got the bill and you forgot to pay it if we, [2:01:29] it's like we're overpassed that one out there, and like you guys changed that, in the September [2:01:34] 1, we would wave sometimes the penalty right up front because everybody's a little late, [2:01:39] but there's no excuse to be late in February. [2:01:42] You see what I'm saying, because you now had that bill the long night, and at the present [2:01:47] where it didn't, there was more and more penalty than more of an injury. [2:01:53] If you said there was $900,000 per bill, the length of the data will be a little more time [2:01:58] work on it. [2:02:00] So, she's not the only one that has all the money on the taxes, but she's going through [2:02:05] the process and coming to us and asking for a process to help her with it. [2:02:10] that other people are five years out on taxes. [2:02:15] Quite a lot of them. [2:02:17] And they aren't coming to us at all. [2:02:21] And we have not gone through a tax sale process [2:02:24] and all that to force it. [2:02:28] We're heading that direction now. [2:02:30] But that is, we are doing a lot. [2:02:33] This process is a lot cheaper and much more quiet. [2:02:36] She's coming to us. [2:02:37] 20. [2:02:38] Sorry. [2:02:40] I like it. I like the texture. I mean, so far, we've done 27 contracts since we just [2:02:47] started and realized we're listening. So Kelly's been working hard at it. We're trying [2:02:51] to work with these people to get caught up. I hate to send us a president that we're all [2:02:56] saying, hey, wait a minute, go to the big CA and they'll turn around and help you out with it. [2:03:01] On the other hand, is it what she's asking for is help. Then it could go to Kelly. We could [2:03:08] maybe a slight floor could you, we say, hey, we won't charge her, but each one's a little different. [2:03:13] If you sit down with them, you try to do a contract with them. In the end, the long run, [2:03:18] you're trying to help them out, collect their money. So we have a motion before. We have a motion [2:03:25] before. Yeah, yeah. Can you state that again, please? I make a motion that we have a bait for [2:03:33] interest in penalties for the tax year 2025 and encourage her to set up a payment plan [2:03:40] going forward. There's a 24-25. 24-25. Okay, so she would, I'm just trying to see how this, [2:03:48] so she would go to, so we would abate her interest, so we would find out what those amounts are [2:03:55] and credit her for the, for her, to her payment plan or maybe the first. [2:04:02] You see what I'm saying? [2:04:04] No. [2:04:04] She's already been charging. [2:04:06] Well, she's trying to make the [2:04:07] motions that we weighed those charges. [2:04:10] Does that make sense? [2:04:11] Yes. [2:04:12] Has she paid them? [2:04:12] No. [2:04:13] No. [2:04:14] Okay. [2:04:14] She's already calculated out of that. [2:04:17] Here's the penalty. [2:04:18] Here's the fine. [2:04:19] Plus you ask the tax. [2:04:21] Cali could instantly just say, okay, [2:04:23] let's just give her that you ask the tax. [2:04:24] Really? [2:04:25] Right. [2:04:26] That's good. [2:04:26] She hasn't paid anything yet. [2:04:28] That's what you're saying? [2:04:29] Yeah. [2:04:30] But the last time I knew, that's what I was talking about, but Kelly would know all about that. [2:04:34] I couldn't understand it. [2:04:36] Right. [2:04:36] Kelly would insist, okay, you're going to all, we waved it, get out, and it's going to be a [2:04:43] calendar year too, because if anything, then it's going to happen again in the month of the year. [2:04:48] That's it. [2:04:48] That's it. [2:04:49] Yes, she would, Kelly would calculate about that. [2:04:52] If she called and said, how much I owe, Kelly would say, you owe this month plus you owe the [2:04:59] interest, but this isn't a precedent then, it's been done before. It's, we never [2:05:04] wait there. No more than I know. Whenever we, that's what I never, I never, I never [2:05:09] wait there before. But it is in the board. Yes, miss the things. Yeah, we can be that. There's [2:05:16] a visit. Oh, yeah, you could go back to the, I don't think it's like we'll have to [2:05:22] evolve. No, there's no, it doesn't have to be involved. As Rachel said, we make the [2:05:27] decision there, and that's how it goes in. [2:05:30] The decision is, as they forget, it's got the clear that we're only taken away the [2:05:35] credit. [2:05:35] If they've already said, hey, I want the money, because they gave it, no, it's not money, [2:05:39] it's our credit. [2:05:41] Right? [2:05:42] Right. [2:05:45] Right. [2:05:45] Right. [2:05:45] Right. [2:05:48] Right. [2:05:49] Right. [2:05:50] So is that starting now or is that starting at the beginning of the tax? [2:05:55] No, it's a question. [2:05:55] It's going to be last year. [2:05:57] Last year's right? [2:05:58] Yeah, sorry. [2:05:59] It's already humilating. [2:05:59] 24, 25. [2:06:00] The last year. [2:06:01] Maybe the new one. [2:06:03] The new one. [2:06:03] Just the new one. [2:06:04] It's 25. [2:06:05] The new one. [2:06:05] The new one. [2:06:06] The new one is a thousand-tater effecting till September 10. [2:06:10] Okay. [2:06:11] So she can't include me whether instead a the last year. [2:06:15] All your penalty. [2:06:16] Everything. [2:06:16] You're still always the best. [2:06:17] How do you want to do the payment plan and then how will we handle the next year? [2:06:21] Okay. [2:06:22] That's way to go ahead. [2:06:23] My understanding is we have a motion on the floor to vote whether or not we are going to remove the penalties and interest from last year's tax. [2:06:38] Yeah. [2:06:39] Bill. [2:06:39] Correct. [2:06:41] Okay. [2:06:41] Anybody would like to second gun? [2:06:43] This is already second. [2:06:44] was Susan did okay all right so let's vote okay all in favor of that plan please say [2:06:55] I anybody opposed to that so that was unanimous okay so this is a really [2:07:13] We said, you'll abstain, John. [2:07:15] OK, thank you. [2:07:16] That's it. [2:07:16] OK. [2:07:18] We've happened a little while. [2:07:19] Thank you. [2:07:20] So this last one is quite straightforward. [2:07:23] Yeah, it's been a long time. [2:07:27] Oh, well, please. [2:07:29] Stephen O'Wars, the party's going on. [2:07:31] Oh, this success is really good. [2:07:35] It's a camp that we're in. [2:07:37] I was found in the Spanish, but the value of that piece of the Torah is fairly large in the [2:07:45] past. [2:07:46] We counted the random numbers. [2:07:48] They're not. [2:07:51] We counted that. [2:07:52] We counted that. [2:07:55] So what's the value of the... [2:07:57] Yeah, the only thing that's perfect is... [2:08:01] It's 40, 40, 100, so. [2:08:03] Okay. [2:08:03] So that's the only thing that's perfect is the refesting rate. [2:08:06] And now we're going to... [2:08:07] and I can't do the math, like if it's the taxes on, [2:08:10] before the one-numbering, as the one-numbering. [2:08:15] So I think when you do that, you do, okay. [2:08:18] And I use the non-holstead rate [2:08:20] because it's not that the cash rate is, [2:08:23] it should be not that fair. [2:08:24] Which is 2.7540 times 4,100, [2:08:29] it shows up under it in $12.99 on the one-assass. [2:08:32] That'd be good. [2:08:33] And it's that for the cash. [2:08:36] The plan is that it burned on March 30th for the same thing that we close our accounting for things is April 1st. [2:08:49] So I wasn't ignoring the one day. [2:08:52] Oh, I can't stand there. [2:08:55] It's just starting from March 1st. [2:08:59] That's 20, 16 steps. [2:09:02] The 25, 26 steps, okay. [2:09:04] And then this a lot of understand this clearly. [2:09:06] Is there's you will automatically do it next year until the cabins back out? [2:09:10] We'll take it off. [2:09:12] We'll take it all right. [2:09:12] First, next year, time we will go and see if there's anything different. [2:09:17] So we're only doing out of here for that one. [2:09:19] We'll take care of it. [2:09:20] This is this side. [2:09:22] So you're debating this chart. [2:09:23] This year or this year. [2:09:25] There's this year. [2:09:28] Okay,ieron six. [2:09:32] Thank it. [2:09:33] I Francic says. [2:09:33] So that's the story of this. [2:09:34] They I had was sentenced. [2:09:36] The case what? [2:09:39] Annoying. [2:09:40] We've made them look for you last year. [2:09:43] Yay. [2:09:44] Board the council about $119. [2:09:47] indicating um. [2:09:50] That's nice. [2:09:51] Thanks. They might be a problem with that. Yeah, she made a point to say it was 331. So I can put the [2:09:59] proposed that you ignore that one day, but I think they're they're looking for the last year also. [2:10:04] I don't know that. Is she asking me the best? [2:10:07] It never goes from the day. Well, I've done enough of these burns to the ground. We've always [2:10:11] credit. We always credit from the day whatever percentage was left in that year. So it was only one [2:10:17] one day less than that year. So it wouldn't be a pain for me. It'd only be a little [2:10:21] more than 30% of it. You know how much time it was for me to deny that stuff. [2:10:30] Yeah. [2:10:33] There's definitely a taxable man. They burdened it up in the house. [2:10:38] You bought it because of the grandson up there. Do you think I'm working? [2:10:41] You haven't wanted to. I want two years later. [2:10:45] And does that happen? [2:10:47] No, it's not. [2:10:48] We've calculated. [2:10:49] No, not a few. [2:10:50] We've calculated. [2:10:52] That's only for a tie. [2:10:54] No, actually. [2:10:55] I think we should put the doll in that. [2:10:56] I don't know. [2:10:57] It is actually burned. [2:10:58] Oh, I want to land there. [2:11:00] Don't you? [2:11:01] We saw it. [2:11:02] It's all in the head. [2:11:04] It's worth it. [2:11:05] There's a timber's burned. [2:11:07] There's nothing. [2:11:08] There's nothing there. [2:11:09] Well, we'll just say, we've reword that. [2:11:11] Without the dollar. [2:11:12] So you're making a motion that we [2:11:16] automated his tax on his camp for [2:11:19] we lower the value of his property by [2:11:21] $41,000. [2:11:22] What you're saying? [2:11:23] $41,000 or anywhere. [2:11:25] On the side. [2:11:26] Yeah. [2:11:27] By the valuation of the camp, [2:11:29] it's no longer. [2:11:30] That's the yeah. [2:11:31] We lower the valuation of the property. [2:11:32] But yeah, and then leave it up to them to say by [2:11:34] valuations. [2:11:34] Okay. [2:11:35] Yeah, but $4,100. [2:11:38] Okay. [2:11:39] Okay. [2:11:40] Is there anybody made that? [2:11:41] Tax here. [2:11:41] So, um, maybe we should have a new emotion. [2:11:46] Oh, yeah, I'm it because I'm reading them all already. [2:11:48] Yeah. [2:11:49] Make a motion that we lower it. [2:11:52] See you more. [2:11:52] It's factory. [2:11:53] Like there were you $100 for the fiscal year. [2:11:56] 2024. [2:11:58] 25. [2:11:58] Catch you. [2:12:00] I don't know. [2:12:00] I don't know. [2:12:00] I don't know. [2:12:01] I don't know. [2:12:02] I'm not partial. [2:12:04] I'm not. [2:12:05] We'll. [2:12:06] We'll. [2:12:07] We'll. [2:12:07] That's the model. [2:12:10] have bill ran list and file narrows and emissions with was [2:12:13] elected for that. And it's a counter program will calculate [2:12:18] what the value is. They still have come back. And then [2:12:22] we'll have the mission. We're going to be going. We should [2:12:24] be tax pay. Okay. But we can we're just going to tell him that [2:12:29] we've we've agreed to lower his valuation for the tax year [2:12:32] year 2025-26 by the appraised value of that cabin, which was $4,100, and then he will [2:12:40] be receiving a new tax bill. [2:12:44] Okay, so good enough. [2:12:45] All those grants on this, but I'm done. [2:12:49] Good luck. [2:12:51] Is there a second? [2:12:52] Sorry. [2:12:53] Thank you, Janice. [2:12:55] Okay. [2:12:56] I think that at this point, we can close this together. [2:12:59] All of them. [2:13:00] We have to vote. [2:13:02] We have to vote. [2:13:03] All of those in favor. [2:13:05] Hi. [2:13:07] John. [2:13:09] John is on board. [2:13:10] You're good. [2:13:11] On that. [2:13:11] Okay. [2:13:12] Did you hear that? [2:13:14] Great. [2:13:15] Thank you. [2:13:15] Okay, people. [2:13:16] I think I'm going to close this meeting today. [2:13:18] I think it was adjourned. [2:13:19] Yeah. [2:13:20] I think it was adjourned. [2:13:21] Yeah. [2:13:22] Good job, sir. [2:13:23] Good job. [2:13:24] Good job. [2:13:25] And we reconvene in a week. [2:13:27] Yes. [2:13:28] By Zoom. [2:13:29] Yes, we can do that by yourself. [2:13:30] I have to figure out how to post it. [2:13:32] Or we can put it in person. [2:13:35] Or we can put it in person. [2:13:37] I think we could do that. [2:13:38] I'm going to do. [2:13:39] And then we can help them out for us. [2:13:40] It's managed to do that. [2:13:42] Yeah, right.