Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
Mr. Phil,
[0:03]
Mr. Prashera. President. Ms. Frosheck.
[0:09]
Sharon is here. As is for the record, Mr. NAP. We do have a quorum. Okay, just a little bit up front. The meeting here is actually to go through and explain the budget process where we start a stand now. What we're doing in terms of cuts for the referendum.
[0:34]
random and looking to get people to understand the need to understand the information and hopefully
[0:41]
get out to vote to see what we can do here. So that's part of what we're looking to do tonight.
[0:49]
The next section is actually public session and what I would like to do if it's okay
[0:54]
is defer that until after the meeting. I think it would be more beneficial if we talk about things
[1:01]
and then we look to have the public comment on it if that's okay.
[1:06]
So as long as my board members are okay with that, I'm going to defer number four
[1:10]
until the after the public or the open session that we have.
[1:18]
Okay.
[1:19]
Makes sense.
[1:21]
Okay.
[1:22]
For the record we have, I have sent the detailed budget, the summary budget,
[1:29]
And the list of current cuts from the original proposal to all the board members, that information is now posted on the insomnia.org under the Board of Education budget section.
[1:42]
So if people are looking to see what's out there, it is out there and posted.
[1:47]
And we will be talking about that now.
[1:50]
So as we originally started our budget process, which probably went back to last October with our last finance person, Chuck Carey, we started out with once, I should say, of about $4.2 million.
[2:09]
And we knew that was unrealistic and we move things down and basically categorize things that we need to do to continue on.
[2:18]
And pretty much at the path and the speed that we're going forward with our education.
[2:25]
And the essence of that, you know, with wages and benefits was about a 2.5 percent increase
[2:33]
over last year, which was about 600,000.
[2:37]
Our utility is our increasing, our energy costs and sewer use costs and other things.
[2:43]
We're going up 13%, and that was about $120,000 of our increase.
[2:49]
Special ed costs and transportation, or regular and special ed.
[2:55]
This increase is significant, it's over 20%, about 1.3 million, the bus contract being
[3:02]
renewed.
[3:04]
We're not finalized yet, but I believe it's going to be about an 8% increase overall in
[3:09]
transportation. And that would put it at about 125,000 on the regular bus
[3:18]
contract increase. And the rest is on the special education transportation, which
[3:23]
is multifaceted. And the special ed costs themselves, which is the most
[3:29]
significant portion of this increase. And that number with those those things
[3:37]
basically added up to about two million dollars. And so we came in with a request for 1.98 million
[3:44]
dollars, I believe. And the most significant piece was going to be the special ed costs. So
[3:53]
we've put that out. The people voted in the referendum and in the first go around they voted
[4:01]
down both the city and the Board of Education. And as we moved forward, there was discussions
[4:07]
back and forth with the city and the Board of Ed. And we submitted some items for reduction
[4:16]
in our budget, but it would seem that at the Board of Alderman meeting, especially with the number
[4:23]
of parents and students that spoke in favor of the Board of Ed, I think the Board of Alderman
[4:28]
and maybe decided it might be best to leave that at as it is at that point and it actually got
[4:33]
defeated again and to a worse extent. So we're now at a point where as we discuss,
[4:42]
we're proposing a list of $400,000 in cuts to the proposed budget to bring it down to
[4:50]
You know, I've got to turn a $1.58 million increase over last year.
[4:59]
The list of cuts that we're proposing and we want to discuss, and excuse me, I've
[5:05]
got a lot of open things on my desk right now.
[5:08]
So let me just shuffle things around and pose.
[5:13]
some of the cuts that we're talking about include about 82,000 for no new AP math and science textbooks for the high school students about a $14,000 loss of middle school ELA consumables
[5:30]
$28,000 reduction in basic student supplies crayons paper musical instruments art supplies
[5:37]
20,000 in after school programs elementary and middle about 50,000 in no full-time
[5:46]
lead security. We had someone retire and we've opted not to fulfill that at
[5:50]
this time. So a security person will not be replaced. 11,000 to cancel
[5:57]
subscription for the online math programs, Camille and Tang. Looking at 45,000
[6:04]
elimination of all middle school sports. You know we've just really started those programs back up
[6:10]
after COVID and but you know again it's after school things we're trying not to hit anything
[6:15]
that's affecting the the educational piece of this. 25,000 elimination of high school junior
[6:23]
varsity sports sports equipment uniforms refs trainers transportation.
[6:32]
23,000 dollars reflects math
[6:34]
subscription. Again, program aids for our student literacy and fluency and math.
[6:44]
$55,000 cuts to building maintenance and repairs that we had. We've deferred a lot and we do
[6:49]
some every year. We've got, you know, a lot of things going on in our building. So it's a partial
[6:55]
cut back on some of the things that we would want to do to have our building maintain during the year.
[7:01]
and 52,000 elimination of all the technology upgrade purchases we had planned for the year.
[7:07]
So those are things in track one. Dr. Debaco and his team went through. I know he spoke to all
[7:14]
of the principals and I'm going to let Dr. Joe talk just a little bit about some of these cuts and
[7:20]
what that impact is. And we can start talking a little bit about where, you know, if this doesn't
[7:26]
the past where we're going to land,
[7:28]
and some of the things that we're going to need
[7:29]
to put on the table for the next variation on this thing.
[7:33]
So, Dr. Joe, if you will.
[7:36]
Good evening, everyone.
[7:38]
As Mr. Bashar just shared,
[7:40]
it's the cuts that are being proposed
[7:43]
are not exciting for me or for anyone.
[7:48]
Some of these things are things that we look forward to,
[7:53]
such as sporting activities, which I love
[7:56]
and I know our students care about, we do have, when it comes to AP textbooks, if we had to go
[8:03]
another year before we had to get them, you know, they said, you know, we could do that.
[8:08]
We did just say, you know, when it comes to the math online subscriptions,
[8:14]
that they were very useful and very helpful, especially during the pandemic.
[8:19]
But now that we've purchased new math curriculum, the amount of usage has decreased.
[8:25]
are they great? Yes. Are they maybe a luxury at this time? Yes. These are not ideal cuts and
[8:35]
one thing I do want to share with everyone here is that my hope is one day that the state says
[8:42]
that we should get some money in excess cost money. If that was to happen, we could probably absorb
[8:50]
some of these cuts if that was ever happened. We're not going to know that to the end of legislative
[8:54]
of session. But in the meantime, we've had to make some real decisions as far away from the
[9:01]
classroom as possible, as far away from teaching and learning as possible, as far away from people that
[9:09]
directly interact with children when it comes to learning literacy, learning how to read, learning how
[9:14]
to do math. Presently, we have to take a look at our average class size in our elementary schools
[9:20]
is 22 students. People said, you know, this head count, you know, let's get one teacher at
[9:26]
an elementary school class will make every class from 29 students. That's not a school system
[9:32]
any of us want for our students. I'm not trying to threaten. I'm not trying to scare. We're just trying
[9:39]
to cut things that could be perceived as a luxury item. Nice to have items. In a perfect world,
[9:47]
I think they're ideal for a complete school experience, but we're trying to make these
[9:54]
in proposals as far away from inside the classroom as possible.
[10:00]
At once again, they're not ideal.
[10:03]
Building maintenance, we have buildings, I mean, our middle school is close to 90 years
[10:09]
old and it needs some love. There are building maintenance things that maybe
[10:18]
we could put off and these are these are these hard family decisions meeting
[10:23]
with every department saying what could we maybe put off a year if we had to
[10:28]
do and and there are things that what could we bring back if we were ever able to
[10:35]
have a couple extra dollars because pretty much these things when you put it
[10:42]
out there they're going to happen but if we're ever able to get some money
[10:47]
from the state we could probably pull some of these things back and that's
[10:51]
what I would like some people to understand but if this referendum doesn't go
[10:56]
through and these cuts happen and we have to make further cuts I there's not
[11:01]
bringing anything back. It's more things are going to go and it's going to get deeper into more
[11:07]
staffing. It could be personnel at all levels at in all places. Things that we just have to also be
[11:14]
cognizant of is that our high school is going to be going through our knee-ask accreditation. You do
[11:20]
want an accredited high school. So there's things that we can and can't cut. There's things that we can
[11:25]
and can't do. But if this referendum doesn't go through, the next around, there's no way
[11:32]
to cut 1.2 million, 1.4 million without headcount. And that's something I'm afraid of.
[11:45]
And it's something that's been worrisome, it's been bothersome, it's something that's been
[11:49]
and weighing heavy on myself,
[11:51]
because our kids deserve better, they deserve it.
[11:55]
And I would love everyone to come out
[11:58]
and do everything they can do
[12:00]
to make sure that the kids get exactly what they need.
[12:03]
So it's been day after day meeting with every department,
[12:08]
meeting with the finance director,
[12:11]
meeting with my assistant super and trying to determine
[12:14]
what things with, if they had to go not ideal,
[12:18]
But in the meantime, if we could ever, ever get this referendum in the past, if we've got some what things could we also bring back. It's a very thoughtful way. It's not ideal.
[12:29]
But it's something that if these cuts do happen, I'm not staying in a threatening way. I say it in the saddest way. It's, it steps backwards. It's us taking multiple steps backwards.
[12:43]
And it's it's going to get dire and it's going to put us in a situation that it's not good for our kids in for our school district and.
[12:54]
Sorry rich for getting me to talk sad, but that's the truth that's the that's the next step and I don't want to get to that next step.
[13:03]
I don't think anyone does, but look, as we go through this, I guess I want to explain
[13:12]
some of the processes that are internal and external to this whole thing, so because
[13:19]
part of what I'm hearing is people don't understand, people don't hear it, I'm here today to talk
[13:26]
as long as anybody wants to talk about how this budget process works and the things that
[13:32]
are affecting why and what goes on.
[13:34]
So I'm biased, okay.
[13:37]
I see from the inside all the good things that have occurred.
[13:42]
You know, we have this tailored to cities,
[13:45]
you know, we're sort of inner city,
[13:47]
but we're sort of bedroom community.
[13:49]
And things that are going on here are really amazing.
[13:54]
We've got some really good administration,
[13:56]
teachers, support staff.
[13:58]
There are things happening here.
[14:00]
When you have kids going to South Korea to work on STEM projects with other students internationally.
[14:08]
We had some students just go to China.
[14:11]
We've been invited to transport over to Portugal and Hungary for international exchange of students and ideas and staff.
[14:21]
These things don't happen to everybody.
[14:23]
These are things that are happening here which is assigned to me that there's something magical happen in here.
[14:31]
And part of that is because of the support from our mayor and our board of
[14:36]
alderman and our taxpayers to help help do some of these things, but there's
[14:42]
something going on here that cutting back on the budgeting will
[14:47]
put will curtail them and will have some major impact on some of the things. Now
[14:52]
I went to Yukon as a kid. I've had two kids graduate from Yukon. My grandson is at
[14:57]
You've gone, I know how difficult it is.
[15:00]
Just to get into UConn, we had 32 seniors apply to UConn this year and 30 of them were accepted. That's just unbelievable. And it's a sign and shows what really is going on in our school system. So there's so much going on. I wish more people would come to our board of ed meetings. You know, if we have five people outside of the stew or the school community there, it's a lot.
[15:28]
But you would hear all the wonderful things that are that's going on in our student population and how much it's really, really worth the effort to see what's going on.
[15:39]
And you know sometimes if it's if it's not broke, don't fix it.
[15:43]
So, you know, maybe a lot of people just kind of know that it's working and we don't really have to administer to it, but today we do.
[15:51]
This is where we are now with budgeting and we have some things.
[15:54]
So within the budget process, you know, we've been through some of the things that we're going to have to cut now that we're putting up on the table. We're going to submit to the Board of Alderman.
[16:04]
There's a list being worked on now by Dr. de Bacco and his team of what's the next step, but it'll probably be if this doesn't pass if we don't get the people out to vote.
[16:14]
This will probably be another four to five hundred thousand dollars on the next go around.
[16:18]
And so it could get devastating on some of the cuts.
[16:22]
We're going to talk about that with the members but I'd like to get into some of the other
[16:26]
pieces of this puzzle which are ECS, which is our educational cost sharing.
[16:32]
Now we are an alliance district and as such since 2009 we've been an alliance district.
[16:39]
What that means on the city side is that the amount of money that the state gives to the
[16:46]
city to help fund this operational budget, the one that people are voting on now, has not
[16:52]
changed since 2009. That number, $15 million, $31,668, has been the same for the last 18 years.
[17:05]
And in that time, our budget has gone up between $13 and $14 million. And every nickel of that,
[17:12]
that $14 million has come from the taxpayers of the city of
[17:16]
Ansonia from the taxes collected by the city of Ansonia.
[17:21]
Now, the way that's written for alliance,
[17:24]
any increases to the ECS go to the Board of Education
[17:30]
and are used as a grant.
[17:32]
They need to be approved by the state.
[17:36]
They cannot be used for anything that supplants the existing
[17:40]
budget.
[17:41]
So you can't use it to pay for a teacher if you're already paying for that teacher, you can't use it to increase their salaries or buy insurance or pay for the electricity or do anything that would be included in the normal operating budget that's currently being done.
[17:58]
Now that number is somewhere between five and six million dollars is going up a million dollars this year.
[18:05]
because the ECS is going up, but that Reliance District grant will need to be approved by the state and last year it didn't get approved until November.
[18:15]
I've seen it go as far as February before we've gotten final approval to spend that money before they will give it to us, which makes it difficult to kind of base and judge how you're going to budget your things and pay for things.
[18:28]
But that being said, at least November last year is where we got it.
[18:34]
That this year, that million dollars that we're looking at extra,
[18:38]
it's being utilized to offset the SR, ARP SR grants that we've had for several years.
[18:46]
Last year or the current year, it was two million dollars.
[18:49]
We're losing that grant, that's going away.
[18:52]
And so the million dollar increase we're getting from our, for our Alliance district
[18:56]
will be moving significant portion or parts of that SR grant to the alliance grant and it will
[19:04]
also be used to sustain some of the increases. Now in that alliance grant, you know, part of the
[19:09]
requirement of the state is that all you need is half-day kindergarten. Well, some years ago the
[19:15]
city decided we want full decay. It's important. And so because it's not required by the state,
[19:22]
they allowed us to use some of that alliance money to pay for half of the
[19:27]
kindergarten teachers, their salaries and their benefits. So that's a big portion
[19:32]
of what's in that alliance grant and that is sustainable and every year we have
[19:37]
to sustain those numbers. But there's other things that are in there also but it's
[19:41]
been an ongoing thing for 18 years. Problem is any increases to the operating
[19:47]
budget that we currently use must be funded by our taxpayers locally.
[19:52]
And so that hurts.
[19:54]
The Alliance money, again, explains some of what that's all about, but we were one of
[20:02]
30 districts, then it went to 33 districts, and I think it was up to 35 or 36 districts
[20:08]
that were listed as Alliance.
[20:10]
There's discussion now of actually reducing the number of Alliance districts, and actually
[20:16]
going to call them some priority district. And they will bring that number down if the
[20:22]
legislation goes through and it's not fully passed yet. So this is only on the table,
[20:27]
down to 15. Ansonian Derby were both still listed in that group of 15, along with
[20:35]
Stamford, Bridgeport, Norwa, New Haven, Waterbury, Hartford, New London, Meriden, and all the
[20:46]
big cities. And then he and Sonja Derby were little. And it hurts us more because of that
[20:52]
that we're alliance. If they would, in my opinion, if they would allow us to take that ECS
[20:59]
money, filter it through on the operating budget side, we would be in much better shape.
[21:04]
But these are hopes we need to jump through and we do what we need to do, but it puts more of a burden on our taxpayers.
[21:12]
The loss of grants, I talked about it, we're losing $2 million in grants and we're picking up $1 million in grants.
[21:19]
I was kind of worried about the federal grants, but I'm being told at this time, really not a lot of discussion of cancellation of our IDEA grants and our Title I and those kinds of grants from federal government.
[21:32]
so that's good news. The excess special education money. This is the big piece of this puzzle.
[21:43]
Our sped costs and excuse me, let me find the right spot here. Our special education costs
[21:51]
have increased dramatically over the last four years. And it's not just us, it's statewide.
[21:58]
the state has been fighting with this, there's legislation that it's in committee that they may give more money to special education, but it's going to certainly put it outside the fiscal card rails, and so I'm sure once it gets to the floor, there's going to be arguments back and forth, and we have no idea where that will land, and that would resolve much of this problem.
[22:21]
If that were to, if they were to give more money for the excess special aid, but how excess special aid works is this.
[22:30]
The city is required to spend four and a half times our average student cost in insomnia. It's around $20,000 average cost.
[22:40]
So at four and a half times, we need to pay the first $90,000 out of our operational budget for any student that is in excess of that or anything for any student even up to that.
[22:55]
But we have probably 60 students above that $90,000 threshold.
[23:01]
told. Last year, that number that we submitted as excess on over and above the $90,000 was
[23:09]
over $3.5 million. Now, the state's statute says their state will reimburse us for 100%
[23:17]
of anything over that excess cost, but that does not happen. Historically, we get about 72%
[23:24]
of that back. So that means for some of these students the city is paying $90,000 plus 30% of
[23:33]
some of the extras on most of the students in that category. Now our special education it could be
[23:42]
from very minor to very severe we have approximately over 500 students that have
[23:48]
designation of special education. That numbers increased by 10% this year. We
[23:54]
started the year at about 440. We're now up to over 500 students. I know a two or
[24:04]
three-week period in March. We had, I believe, 20 new students sign up for the
[24:18]
special education paperwork that we must adhere to.
[24:22]
These are things we can't budget for and it happens a lot.
[24:25]
So as part of this process, you know, we've probably had,
[24:30]
what, 250 people that have entered the Antsonia school system
[24:35]
in the last, since September, probably close to just as many that
[24:40]
have left our district in that same time frame.
[24:43]
But in that time frame, about almost half have come from
[24:47]
New Haven, Bridgeport, and Waterbury, same level of dirt level that we have or lower than ours, but
[24:56]
It's people are looking to come to Ansonia. I think because of the great
[25:02]
Educational system that that we're presenting out there
[25:05]
So this sped money is not being
[25:09]
Reimbursed to the city and in the last three years
[25:15]
net special education costs, which is after we apply the excess special education grant
[25:23]
against them, we've won from $4.1 million in the 22-23 year to a projection of next year
[25:32]
of $25.26 to $5.8 million. That's a $1.7 million increase over the last three years.
[25:42]
And
[25:43]
three to five to six hundred thousand dollars more per year over what we're
[25:49]
budgeting based on our ending numbers from the prior year. And that's causing us
[25:55]
to put freezes on all of our spending in other areas as early as November. So
[26:02]
it's not that we're overspending. We're not spending frivolously. We're doing
[26:08]
whatever we can. We've done we've brought in our vendors. We've reduced contract
[26:13]
costs as best we can. Our bus contract that we're looking at 8%, I think
[26:18]
Milford went up 20%. Others were going up 15%. We've been very good with our
[26:25]
bus company and they've been very good with us. We've tried to do different
[26:29]
things to save money. But the special education piece, that transportation is
[26:34]
different and that has caused us some severe pain in the numbers. And I think
[26:41]
I guess part, part and parcel to COVID.
[26:43]
When COVID hit, we didn't have as much people,
[26:47]
have as many people go out for special education.
[26:51]
And as such, the school districts saved money.
[26:55]
And what our school district did with that money
[26:58]
for two years running, our school district returned to the city
[27:01]
a million dollars in each year for the two years
[27:06]
during COVID because we didn't spend it
[27:09]
done, special education. Look, our job is to work with our city
[27:13]
because our city works with us. And we felt it appropriate to
[27:17]
refund that money to the city to help them do what they need it
[27:21]
to do on their own. And they've been very good to us when we
[27:24]
needed money, they've been able to give us money to help our
[27:28]
program move forward. But since that happened, there were many
[27:31]
companies that were small that went out of business because
[27:34]
there was no transportation companies. And some of the other
[27:40]
The vendors for providing services for special education went out of business and with a reduced amount of vendors.
[27:49]
Well, you know, supply and demand, the cost went up and it's been going up all across the state. It's not just here.
[27:57]
If I'm understanding correctly, and again, I'm only going by what I've heard, the state puts a block of money for our special ed costs in their budget.
[28:10]
And when all the cities apply, they will participate on a percentage base of what has been allocated.
[28:19]
Last year they told us it was going to be close to 91% we would get.
[28:22]
that. Well, there was such an increase, and I heard almost 25% increase from the prior
[28:29]
year statewide of the applications for a special ed, excess special ed that they came back
[28:35]
and said, oh, it's only going to be 61%, which would have had a $600,000 whole for us this
[28:41]
year. Luckily, the legislatures came together. They voted to put an additional 41 million in,
[28:49]
and even though the governor vetoed it,
[28:51]
they went back and they took it from a different source
[28:54]
of funding, that money came back.
[28:56]
We ended up with about our 72%.
[28:59]
We had actually budgeted about 78.
[29:01]
So last year's or current year's budget
[29:03]
is probably a few hundred thousand dollars short.
[29:06]
But again, we compensate by cutting off other areas
[29:10]
in order to make the special education numbers work.
[29:13]
We don't know what they're gonna do next year.
[29:16]
they're talking that they want to put more money in.
[29:19]
I would love to see and put more money in,
[29:21]
but I can't budget that money
[29:23]
until we know what they're gonna do.
[29:27]
So it could be that we do and that they do that
[29:30]
and we've already stated if we get extra special ed money,
[29:34]
after we would reallocate for things
[29:38]
that we may have to cut now,
[29:40]
we would return the money to the city.
[29:42]
We're okay with that.
[29:43]
We're not trying to make the taxpayers pay more than they need to, but we can't base our budget off of maybe so I've seen the state legislature say yes to this and tomorrow it's no you just can't do it so I'm going in my mind.
[30:00]
With historical 72%, that's what we put in our budget for the excess special reimbursement. And we're basing it off of this year's number of 345 million that we're going to submit. It may be more problem. While I'm hoping that the special ed costs will plateau. But it could be higher because we just don't know what happens with our transitional population of students coming in and out so much. So those are the big hits. Those are some of the things that are there.
[30:27]
here. Just again, the money that Board of Ed receives for our operational budget comes
[30:36]
from our taxpayers, our Board of Aldermen, our mayor, and we're very thankful for all
[30:42]
they've done for us. We have a great thing going here for our students. They are learning.
[30:48]
We have replaced a number of our curriculums, our teachers are just excited about their curriculum.
[30:59]
They're working together.
[31:01]
And just there are some very, very good things going on here that it would be sad if we can't get this passed in this next referendum.
[31:12]
So right now I'm going to bring it out to my board members to see if anyone has any questions, thoughts, concerns that they would like to share at this point in time.
[31:22]
I know I've had the mic here, so I'll let you guys come and talk here. Please do.
[31:34]
Well, I know that our teachers have not received pink slips in five years and that's something that I want to see continue.
[31:46]
It's very important to our community, it's very important to the kids.
[31:52]
And Sharon, you bring up a good point with that, in that in years past with all of the
[31:57]
pink slips, which are required by contract, if we plan on laying someone off.
[32:05]
What that has done in the past, it said to the teachers, well, I got to go find a new job.
[32:11]
And so it was a probably a 25% maybe more I don't even know of our teaching force would come in and go out and the people that we were able to get back in, they knew that what was going on here.
[32:29]
And so it was, we didn't get the cream of the crop coming in as teachers.
[32:35]
And since we've been able to level the playing field with the wage structure,
[32:43]
and present some of the things that we've got going on here,
[32:50]
we've got teachers that want to come here, and teachers are telling their friends,
[32:56]
Hey, this is a good place to come and teach because there's a lot going on here. There's a lot of good things going on
[33:02]
so the good point about that, you know, it's not just the pink slips. It's the teacher stabilization. You know, if we have four, three or four or five teachers in a year that are
[33:13]
leaving at the end of the year. It's usually for reason and it's not because they just don't want to be here. They're excited to be here. So that's a good point.
[33:25]
Dave, Chris, you got
[33:26]
anything you want to bring up?
[33:30]
No, Rich. Actually, you did a very good job explaining all the key points,
[33:35]
the major points. And I'm interested to hear some of the comments from the public as well.
[33:41]
And maybe we could have some more discussion after that. Sure. I want to first, I'm going to ask
[33:46]
any of our administrators, Mr. Bergen, Dr. Dr. Tobacco, anything that you may want to bring up about
[33:56]
But this discussion before we move into the public section of this,
[34:03]
I think you did a great
[34:05]
job.
[34:06]
I think you did a great job as far as going through everything, all the steps that we've
[34:11]
taken and all the issues that we have with the state and hoping for reimbursement and being
[34:18]
promised but not given.
[34:22]
Well, I've done this for 40 years and I know the state.
[34:28]
And, you know, what the only person I can really count on are the people here in
[34:33]
Antsonia and that that's kind of what's been going on. And if we get something from
[34:37]
the state, I would ride that would be great. When I like to see things different or
[34:41]
better, yep, had they had the ECS money come to the city to be allocated to the
[34:47]
to the board of ed that million dollars instead of going to the alliance side. You
[34:52]
know what, that would have been half of what almost half of what we dashed for.
[34:58]
You
[34:58]
that we have going on but you know it would be great if some things were different but these are
[35:04]
the cards we have and that's what kind of what we're going to play so okay I will open up to the
[35:09]
public and see Dave go ahead Dave yeah you've done a great job explaining what's going on can you
[35:18]
please let us know if this next vote comes back like the previous votes what would happen then
[35:27]
and how important it is for everybody to get out there and vote for the existing budget.
[35:39]
Well, there's a list floating around. I don't know. Dr. Joe, you want to do what you want me to do it?
[35:45]
Well, I can tell you the next step goes into staffing. That's where it doesn't look pretty.
[35:53]
No, and to be honest, I could tell you one saying that stuff publicly to everybody. It made it real. I made it real for me kind of really got me upset.
[36:03]
We've we've made a lot of steps forward here and and so on. We're doing exceptional things. I've great kids, I've great families.
[36:10]
I have I'll put my teachers up against anyone in the state. Our administrators are doing the omens work as well and to say it out loud.
[36:22]
It kind of hurt was very sad because we've made so many steps forward.
[36:28]
There's talk about excellent programming.
[36:31]
When I see kids going to Sokorski,
[36:33]
when I see kids getting internships at Butterfly,
[36:37]
when I see our students presenting it,
[36:39]
the CVA events, I am going to be a judge
[36:43]
at a mock trial on Tuesday to see our students do
[36:47]
absolutely incredible things and make us proud
[36:50]
on a daily basis.
[36:52]
The next level of cuts, it's, you're gonna get into the flesh.
[36:56]
You're going to get into people and it gets into headcount and it's not easy with contracts. There's
[37:04]
There's other things that come into play bumping and movement. It's
[37:10]
It'll
[37:12]
It'll put us backwards. It's going to if we want to keep this ship moving in the right direction and moving forward
[37:18]
We can't stress enough how important it is for everybody to get out there and vote and
[37:24]
And for
[37:29]
this budget,
[37:32]
yes, I think Stephanie Acasio, board member, I asked her to unmute
[37:37]
if they she wanted to share.
[37:40]
Thank you, Jill.
[37:41]
I was just, you know, to go off of what you were just saying, I mean, I think for a lot
[37:47]
of people, you know, they can't see it.
[37:51]
It's almost like it's, they can't touch it, they can't feel it, but I think they need
[37:56]
to hear these things, I think we need to know how deep this is going to go. I mean, there's
[38:02]
so many places that have, you know, just not, I don't want to, you know, talk badly on other
[38:08]
places, but their teachers aren't at the same level as ours. Our teachers are winning awards,
[38:13]
they're doing great things. Are the administrative staff just everyone in our school district is
[38:20]
just doing so well and doing the best that they can.
[38:24]
And as a board member, as a mother, as an Ansonia resident,
[38:31]
paying taxes, owning a home, and having one child graduating
[38:37]
high school and having one child starting, I came back to Ansonia
[38:43]
for this, for our school district, for my children.
[38:47]
And so, I think people really need to understand because I think we kind of get for like just a lack of a better word, a little lost in the sauce there.
[38:59]
But I we need to be explained that we use the money for what is what's necessary.
[39:05]
And I think people start getting lost in other things and they don't have answers to other questions that they have.
[39:10]
And so our education is going to suffer from that.
[39:17]
And I feel like we're just separate from other things,
[39:21]
even though it's tied in, if that makes sense.
[39:26]
And I don't know.
[39:27]
We really need to stress the importance of our children,
[39:31]
our teachers, and just doing what we can to go forward.
[39:36]
I mean, I know that I it was pouring rain. I waited as long as I could. I had surgery on my spine all of this and I walked down to the armory to vote, you know, it's like you got, we got to push you got to make the effort.
[39:51]
We got to get out there. We got to, we got to do what we have to do to get this rectified.
[39:58]
I'm hopeful that we can get as much information to the people that they want so that they can
[40:02]
make an informed decision and go out there and vote the way they feel that they think
[40:07]
they should vote.
[40:08]
So thank you so much.
[40:10]
Rich, can I ask one more question, Rich?
[40:13]
Yeah.
[40:13]
It's Chris.
[40:15]
Excuse me.
[40:16]
I just want to clarify or be clarified by itself that this referendum that's going next
[40:22]
Friday, that'll be the third, so should our budget fail.
[40:26]
We revert back to the 24-25 budget or current year's budget, and if I'm right based upon
[40:34]
what's just called the $2 million original ask we had it, it was $1.819 as you said.
[40:40]
We're essentially starting the next year, or our next budget cycle in a hole at a $2 million
[40:46]
deficit.
[40:47]
Is that correct?
[40:48]
I actually asked that question today and should this fail there will be another vote I'm told in in early June and maybe even a fifth.
[40:58]
Okay, all right, I was going to be a question.
[40:59]
We continue to move forward if we don't have one by July 1st.
[41:03]
We revert to last year's budget.
[41:06]
But we can still continue to vote on budgets going forward and they would then send an additional bill out, but they would bill out it last year's rates for July 1.
[41:17]
So, that's my understanding of how the process works, but again, this is all new.
[41:22]
This is the first time we've done this, so take it with a grain of salt.
[41:27]
Okay.
[41:28]
Thank you.
[41:29]
Okay.
[41:30]
Anybody else?
[41:31]
Or should we go to public?
[41:35]
We good to go?
[41:38]
Okay.
[41:39]
Now, just as a note, there's a thing at the bottom of your Zoom.
[41:44]
If you're there, it's called a React.
[41:46]
And I believe there's something in there that, let me click on it, says, raise your hand.
[41:50]
So if you would like to swap that little button at the bottom under the React icon has a
[41:57]
raise your hand and that will let us know that you want to talk.
[42:00]
So Nancy Monaco, I see you up first.
[42:03]
Are we able to mute?
[42:05]
There we go.
[42:06]
Hi, how are you?
[42:07]
Thank you so much for the presentation.
[42:10]
It was a really important presentation.
[42:12]
I really appreciate it.
[42:14]
I have two questions.
[42:15]
So the first one is, you know, I reading everything that the students that are the last
[42:22]
public hearing.
[42:23]
First of all, I love the virtual meeting.
[42:24]
I prefer it at my video only person, so I appreciate the virtual meeting, but the kids
[42:30]
I heard were incredible advocates.
[42:32]
I'm hoping that we can learn from them and maybe take the advocacy to the state because
[42:37]
truly, the state really is under funding, and it's really sad to see on social media.
[42:44]
and, you know, I don't know if it's because it's political, like, you know, what it is, what the background is, but there's this false narrative going around that in fiscal year 26, we're going to be fully funded.
[42:55]
And that's insulting, I think, to every single student in Indian school to have to read that or to have to hear it or for that false narrative to be fun, because it's continuously been underfunded.
[43:08]
And the compounding factors of that underfunding over decades is so damning and that to just pretend like it doesn't exist is horrible.
[43:19]
And what I don't want is for the state to think, well, the people in Ansonia don't understand this.
[43:24]
So we don't really have to fund them.
[43:26]
Like the state of Connecticut has a constitutional obligation to these children.
[43:30]
And I want to put their feet to the fire and let them know that we're upset that they continuously underfund us.
[43:35]
So whatever advocacy you guys need, tag my kids, tag me whatever you need because those
[43:43]
kids are brilliant at the every single school, those kids deserve the same thing that every
[43:49]
other kid in more affluent towns is given but we have to fight for.
[43:54]
So I just want to hope that we do that on a state level.
[43:57]
The second thing I have a question on is if the special ed funding comes in over that
[44:07]
73 percent, do you guys have a plan for what gets, like is there a priority to what gets
[44:14]
funded?
[44:15]
Is it, you know, how are you going to do that?
[44:18]
Okay.
[44:21]
Advocacy?
[44:22]
Yeah, we'd love to see it.
[44:23]
I'm not sure how to do it necessarily.
[44:25]
That's kind of more from our political people, I would think,
[44:29]
but I think they've heard our plea over the time.
[44:34]
And the state has, the state is doing what they need to do
[44:38]
to keep their boat afloat, just like we need to do
[44:42]
what we need to do to keep our boat afloat.
[44:44]
So I understand it, but it's not a one size fits all
[44:49]
for various districts.
[44:50]
And, you know, we are an anomaly where one of the smallest cities in the state were the
[44:56]
10th most populated city in the state.
[45:00]
You know, we're severely distressed municipalities. There's just so many variables that, you know, one size does not fit all, but it would be nice that if we can maybe open dialogue with the state on the spread. Again, if we had knowledge today, we would put that number in if we could know exactly what they were going to give us and we would reduce our request. And so if money does come in after the fact, you know, in my way of thinking that it would be
[45:29]
the discussion with the board and Dr. DeBacco,
[45:32]
but probably at this point would reinstate any cuts
[45:35]
we've had to make based on the referendum
[45:39]
and then anything in excess of that,
[45:42]
I've already told the city administration
[45:45]
that we would just leave it at the bottom line
[45:47]
for the end of the year.
[45:49]
You know, we're not out there to do anything to hurt the city.
[45:52]
We want to help the city.
[45:54]
The request we have now is pretty much where we need to be
[45:59]
But if we were to get additional funds, we would work to have that go back to the city so that they could turn around and use it as part of the funding for next year. That would be the plan for that.
[46:13]
So, and, you know, before I forget, I'm remiss. I know Valley Indie. I heard his live streaming this and I thank them for being able to get this out.
[46:25]
So that more people can hear and play back on this because it's really important for people to know and understand exactly what's going on with the numbers and, you know, we've had.
[46:36]
And we're on three different financial people, and Eric is on tonight's doing very well.
[46:43]
But we've had three people in the last three years, and it's been kind of hectic.
[46:47]
We're starting to get a very good handle on all of the line items and the numbers, and
[46:52]
we're still working through those.
[46:55]
But the information flow should be better going forward.
[46:58]
That is my hope.
[47:00]
Don't.
[47:01]
Thank you.
[47:02]
Rich, can I say, that was really, that was very well said, what Nancy had said.
[47:07]
To her point, we're doing testimony year after year.
[47:13]
Dr. Joe's going up to Hartford.
[47:15]
I submitted several letters of testimony, you know, when at some point is the state
[47:21]
going to say, you know, this is going through every city and every town in Connecticut are
[47:29]
are being subject to say these cuts.
[47:32]
When are these testimonies going to be listed for heard?
[47:36]
Thank you.
[47:37]
Thank you, Nancy.
[47:40]
Okay. Thanks, Sharon.
[47:44]
Bev, you got your hand up, I see.
[47:46]
I don't know if there's others, but Bev Tidmars.
[47:49]
Can you name and address for the record please?
[47:53]
Can we unmute Bev Tidmars?
[47:55]
I believe so.
[47:57]
There we go.
[47:58]
There we are.
[47:59]
Bev Tidmars, 77 Westfield Avenue.
[48:02]
I just, I want to commend the board members, Dr. DeBacco, Dr.
[48:08]
Mr. Bergen for allowing the board to give us the transparency for a budget.
[48:18]
Most people in the community really don't have a clue as to what the budget is spent on.
[48:24]
And I was on the board of ed for many, many years, quite a few years ago.
[48:29]
and I know how difficult it can be when you start getting into talking about
[48:36]
cutting staff, cutting people, cutting programs. So I think these last few
[48:41]
years with the current board and the current administration have done more than
[48:47]
a commendable job of getting programs together for the students that they can
[48:54]
experience work programs and doing extremely well academically that they're
[49:01]
getting into colleges. So I just, I'm really impressed and I, you know, you
[49:09]
try to talk it up as best you can with the people in the community. I, you
[49:13]
know, I'm retired, my husband's retired, we're senior citizens, I guess you
[49:17]
could say, but, you know, very supportive of education. And, you know, if our
[49:24]
taxes went up so be it. So I just felt the need to comment on this. And I agreed with Nancy
[49:32]
Monaco from what she was saying as well that those are excellent points to be made. And you
[49:40]
know, we certainly can continue on with that. But thank you.
[49:44]
Thank you, Beth.
[49:49]
Is there anyone else from the public that wishes to speak?
[49:51]
Do you see Matt Huff, the name and address for the record place?
[49:59]
Are we on mute, Matt?
[50:05]
Hi, Matt Huff, President of the Ansonia Federation of Teachers.
[50:08]
I'm actually at an AFT Connecticut meeting working with legislators on how to better fund
[50:15]
schools.
[50:16]
My point of confusion is, and I just actually checked with our lobbyists currently based
[50:21]
on the formula.
[50:22]
Ansonia is going to get our complete ECS funding.
[50:25]
It is fully funded, it may not be enough, but based on the formula, that is what the
[50:32]
formula says.
[50:33]
We are working with them to make proposals to change some of the special education costs
[50:39]
funding that are hopefully healthy in Sonia, but I just did want to clarify that everything
[50:45]
from the state shows that we are fully funded, at least from the current formula.
[50:50]
The issue is that because of the alliance grant, our hands are tight, and that's two very
[50:55]
different things. I want people to understand that. That, you know, as Richie already explained
[50:59]
very well, you know, that so much of the money comes under specific controls, and that's
[51:05]
where we have an issue. But we are working with the state understands. There's actually a large
[51:11]
special education group meeting every single day trying to change the way special education
[51:16]
is funding. There's also proposals to add a special education waiting to the ECS formula,
[51:22]
which would help us. The problem is they can't figure out their budget. They can't agree,
[51:27]
so we're stuck waiting on them. So I just wanted to clarify, I thank you for all the compliments
[51:31]
towards our staff, our teachers are amazing, and right now people are not leaving. They want to work
[51:36]
in Ansonia. I love my colleagues. I don't want to go back to where we were several years ago,
[51:42]
where we had to lay off numerous teachers, and thank you for all of your hard work.
[51:47]
Thank you, Matt.
[51:49]
And yeah, just to follow up with Matt, the fully funding.
[51:54]
Yeah, that is for the ECS portion of it.
[51:58]
And I don't know.
[51:58]
I think it's, they, they base it off a student count.
[52:01]
And it's on or around $11,000 per student.
[52:06]
Something to that.
[52:07]
In fact, it's kind of complex.
[52:08]
And I don't fully understand it.
[52:10]
So please bear with me on that.
[52:11]
But the problem is not the fully funding of the ECS.
[52:15]
the problem is that the city, the one that is funding this budget that we're talking about tonight,
[52:21]
gets zero increase for the last 18 years. All of the money goes into the alliance grant
[52:27]
and it is specifically, it has to be spent on things that the state approves and it does not
[52:36]
take away from anything or it can't be spent on anything that's in the current operating budget
[52:42]
And that that is a problem that that's the the major problem is if if they would allow us to just take that
[52:49]
That alliance money and filter it right back through to the
[52:56]
Operating budget the citizens and the board would probably be in a much better place, but again, that that's
[53:03]
The advocacy that need that's needed in Hartford to get the changes like that needed. So thanks Matt
[53:10]
I see Beth Lynch has a hand up
[53:19]
Hi Rich. I don't know if you had a chance to look at your phone. I did send you the section of the charter that pertains to non adoption of the budget and what happens.
[53:28]
So if you wanted to share that.
[53:32]
Wow. Okay. A lot of them.
[53:38]
Okay. Give me one second. Let me just read what you're saying here.
[53:44]
The non adoption of the budget is not adopted by June 20th, the city shall send out real estate tax bills based on the same taxation figures and adjusted mill rate of the prior fiscal year, which would include adjustments for the new revenues debt service and legal obligations for the next fiscal year, which begins July 1.
[54:05]
After the complete budget is passed, the balance of the real state plus personal property motor vehicle, tax bills should be sent out based on a charge brought after the referendum vote.
[54:14]
So, yeah, again, that kind of leads into I think we would have the possibility of another road on June 5th and maybe one after that.
[54:22]
And at that point, if it wasn't passed, we would revert to the prior years budget till such time as a budget is approved.
[54:28]
and then we would rebuild for the additional amount.
[54:33]
So thanks, Ben.
[54:36]
Is there anybody else that would like to share, comment?
[54:44]
Thomas Egan, I see your hand up.
[54:47]
I'm speaking, well, 253 Main Street, in Sonia.
[54:53]
I've reviewed this proposed $403,000 in school budget cuts
[54:57]
and let me be clear, these are not just numbers
[55:01]
on a spreadsheet.
[55:03]
These are direct hits to the kids' futures.
[55:10]
No new AP math or science textbooks.
[55:14]
To me, that just says, telling our bright students here and so on,
[55:18]
they don't deserve to compete with, say, Shelton or Derby.
[55:22]
Now, cutting these after-school programs and middle school sports,
[55:25]
and that's leaving working families without support and teenagers,
[55:30]
leaving them without instruction.
[55:31]
Let's be real. We all know what happens when teenagers are left with nothing to do.
[55:38]
No full-time school safety officer. In this day and age, that's borderline reckless.
[55:45]
You know, eliminating these tech upgrades that's like telling our kids to compete in the 24th
[55:50]
century world using an equipment from when I went to high school. Personally, I think that's just a
[55:54]
little absurd.
[55:57]
I understand we have limited funds. This is where we're making the cuts. I think the
[56:02]
priorities are broken. And I think a city that cuts its schools isn't saving money. It's earning its own future.
[56:10]
Our city spends a lot of money on other things, I think,
[56:14]
embalancing all the budgets and whatnot. I think there could be cuts on the other side before cuts are made here.
[56:20]
I'm seeking. Thank you.
[56:24]
Thank you. It just kind of dovetail into that should be noted that the special
[56:32]
led portion of the expenditures is can't be cut to the same extent as other things can be,
[56:40]
so it tends to be one-sided. There may be some things, especially that we might be able to,
[56:46]
to curtail, but based on the requirements by the state, we can't really cut a lot of that,
[56:53]
so more of the cuts, even though they're out there, they're going to be cut on the regular
[56:59]
side of things. So, I see a hand up, Meg, name and address for the record, please.
[57:07]
Meg Perel, 103 Rock and Avenue. I had a question, so I went to both times the voting, and so there
[57:17]
were the two questions about the city's budget. It wasn't high enough or low enough, and then the
[57:21]
education one. So I wanted to understand as far as the city side what exactly is covered
[57:31]
with that portion of it so that I understand when I thought the education budget was too low
[57:38]
so but I want to understand the other side of it so I know kind of how it's all splitting up I guess.
[57:47]
Although I kind of know the city side of things, I'm here as Board of
[57:53]
Ed and to talk about Board of Ed side budget. So I guess I don't know how to
[58:00]
answer that question exactly. I just like question is what exactly was that
[58:06]
question asking like when they were saying is it too high or too low like too
[58:10]
higher to low for what, like,
[58:12]
for the city or I'm not sure that it's the best question.
[58:20]
I've heard people said I voted no because I wanted it higher.
[58:24]
And that is not necessarily the best answer.
[58:27]
The question I believe states, if you voted no,
[58:30]
you think it's too low or too high.
[58:33]
And so it kind of defeats, you know,
[58:37]
If you vote, no, the budget's going to probably end up getting cut even further on the next one, not go up unless it was the majority of people saying it was too low.
[58:49]
So that was not the case in this thing. So most people think things were too high and so the next round they're usually cutting, but specific answers to the city side budget.
[58:59]
I'm going to defer that to I think Board of Alderman has a meeting one day night and those questions
[59:05]
probably be more pertinent at that point for us we're discussing ours we're going to have
[59:10]
a quick vote to if our board is in agreement to send these to are the Board of Alderman for their
[59:15]
review they make the final decisions on what will be presented on the next referendum but thank you
[59:22]
any other questions is
[59:26]
there anyone else in the public that would wish us to address the board
[59:29]
May
[59:34]
I see Stacey Espicito?
[59:39]
Yes, Stacey Espicito, 46-row-and-see, right?
[59:42]
I had some questions in regards to the proposal on the Lowering of the Budget.
[59:49]
Is there anything that the taxpayers can do to prevent these cuts from the students?
[59:58]
I mean, unfortunately,
[1:00:00]
Secondly, they're the ones that are taking the hit here in it and to echo Nancy's sentiment. Like, we're taking away from the city essentially by not putting the money back into our goods. So what the hand we do to prevent or to help get this next budget pass or, you know, eliminate risk. What can we do to prevent all of the loss of sports after flock to these AP classes being caught for these kids with this
[1:00:33]
guess the simple answer to that is there needs to be more yes votes than no votes on the referendum questions.
[1:00:43]
You know, the ideal that's I guess that's the simplistic answer to it.
[1:00:48]
We, you know, we need to educate people to what it is that we're talking about, what the implications are.
[1:00:55]
And to get as many people as we can to get out to vote whatever way they decide they want to vote, but I think, you know, more people that vote with understanding what the process and what the potential risks are will help that matter.
[1:01:12]
So I guess that's the simple answer. I don't have anything else really. I can say to that.
[1:01:19]
I just want to mention going back to Meg's point and I think we talked about it at our meeting last night was there were some confusion that we think some people may have voted no because they thought it was too low rather than yes.
[1:01:35]
and I'm in an on Stacey's comment, again, if I'm not mistaken, we're submitting the new
[1:01:42]
budget with the $403,000 cut, whatever it may be, and those are the cuts you would
[1:01:48]
just talked about and explained earlier. Stacey's question is how do we avoid that? Well,
[1:01:53]
I guess going forward, if we pass this budget to the alderman and they go ahead and pass it,
[1:01:59]
Even if it's voted yes at the next rep or random, if the budget is approved, it's going
[1:02:04]
to be approved with the 403,000-hour cuts.
[1:02:08]
Therefore all these cuts on the paper are going to have to happen.
[1:02:11]
The only way that we could avoid those was it would be to present the same number that
[1:02:16]
we have then and the voters vote yes for them.
[1:02:21]
That's the only way I see to preserve any of these proposed cuts that we wouldn't have to
[1:02:26]
do it.
[1:02:26]
We'd have to present the budget as it has been in the first two repulence
[1:02:31]
But I would you know, you know, I'm wise how do we fight you know by wide margins?
[1:02:37]
So I think we're kind of kind of just there. I I don't think that's a realistic option at this point
[1:02:45]
In my opinion and you know what I'm not
[1:02:49]
It hurts me it pains me to suggest that we have to make cuts
[1:02:54]
but we need a budget. We really need a budget that's not the same as last year so at this point
[1:03:01]
it's whatever we need to do to get the budget passed as soon as possible with the minimum amount
[1:03:08]
of cuts and again I'm hopeful that the state will actually do something on excess special ed that
[1:03:16]
will help this in the long run but at this point I don't know any other thing to say on that so
[1:03:23]
but thank you, Stacy, is that it? You all set?
[1:03:29]
Okay. I see Nancy again but let's try
[1:03:35]
see Davis first if we can and we'll come back.
[1:03:41]
Hi, I'm Christine Davis. I'm a
[1:03:43]
resident of Ansonia, 121 Ford Street in Ansonia. I've been a teacher at Ansonia High
[1:03:49]
School for 27 years. I'm a lifelong resident of Ansonia. I would like to
[1:03:55]
comment on Stacy's question. In this stage, I really do believe that we should move to social
[1:04:02]
media, Stacy, where we can have a presence, encourage our family members who are 18 and
[1:04:09]
over and our insomnia residents to vote. I also encourage our seniors, our seniors at
[1:04:18]
and Sonia High School who are 18 and over to vote.
[1:04:22]
We all know that the best way to invest in a city
[1:04:26]
is to put the money into education.
[1:04:29]
It's how we entice people to come to Ansonia
[1:04:32]
and live in Ansonia and we really do need
[1:04:35]
to start putting our resources into our schools
[1:04:39]
sustaining our programs and making Ansonia public schools
[1:04:44]
even greater than they are today.
[1:04:48]
Thank you. Thank you, Christine.
[1:04:53]
Nancy, you had your hand up. I don't know where you would do
[1:04:56]
like to speak again.
[1:05:00]
Okay. Nancy Monaco. Thank you. I just wanted to comment because I do think
[1:05:06]
there's a solution. If this vote, if this goes to referendum and it gets approved with these cuts,
[1:05:13]
we understand those cuts are going to be made. And I guess our hope is that that's the best case
[1:05:19]
scenario that these cuts are made, because if it doesn't get passed, we're looking at teachers being laid off, which nobody wants.
[1:05:26]
But the solution is this. The solution is advocacy at the state level so that the special education funding comes through, because what I heard you say, Mr.
[1:05:34]
Pashara, was that if that funding comes through, many of these cuts will be reinstated. And that's truly that everyone should be pounding on the state reps door on the state senator's door to say we are not
[1:05:48]
not okay with you under funding our kids.
[1:05:52]
So that's the advocacy, that's the solution.
[1:05:55]
And it should have been the solution for the last three decades.
[1:06:01]
And I know I'm preaching to the choir because I know you guys have been doing it.
[1:06:04]
And I know I've seen it, I've seen the testimony, I know you guys have been doing it, and I thank
[1:06:08]
you for it.
[1:06:09]
Like I really do because I know that you guys are at your wit's end, but it's the advocacy
[1:06:12]
that we need from everybody else at that level because it's, and Sonya can show up, and Sonya
[1:06:18]
shows up for Antonia. Antonia shows up for the ballot. Antonia is incredible. But I think it's this
[1:06:23]
false narrative that they think the state is doing what they need to do for us when they're not.
[1:06:30]
I don't disagree with you. I think that we could be better supported. And it's not really big
[1:06:37]
changes or differences. There's just there's more than one way to do what they're doing to help us.
[1:06:43]
But I don't know how we get that to happen. Again, you know, they are operating under their
[1:06:49]
fiscal guardrails and you know they're doing what they need to do to make sure that things are
[1:06:54]
working for them and it's not always the best for every municipality so okay understood
[1:07:04]
is there anyone else that would like to address the board now's the time to ask any questions you
[1:07:10]
have because you know this is not a common occurrence to have this kind of a thing going on here
[1:07:15]
I don't know how many people we got now still in the 70s out there. Would anybody else like to address the board third
[1:07:30]
and final time with anyone else like to address the board on the budget referendum.
[1:07:36]
We have Diane Strowman.
[1:07:41]
You have to know Diane Strowman 66 high street and Sonya Connecticut and I have been here for 74 years.
[1:07:49]
going through the public schools and going through the high school,
[1:07:53]
I'll graduate you from ASONIA High School, you know I'm listening to
[1:07:59]
everyone and it just sounds like we're preaching to the choir because those of
[1:08:05]
us who are here are supportive of the Board of Education, our goal should be how
[1:08:12]
do we get out, think about how do we get out to those individuals who are not
[1:08:16]
online, may not have the ability to be online, especially some of the seniors.
[1:08:23]
How do we advocate for them to understand and know the importance of what's happening
[1:08:31]
for the seniors?
[1:08:33]
And I'm certainly one of them.
[1:08:35]
You see a tax increase in your panic because you don't know the unknown.
[1:08:40]
No. One question I would have, Rick, is do we know based on the current cuts that are
[1:08:47]
before us? And what the city is proposing, do we know what that means as far as a tax
[1:08:53]
increase regarding the mill rate?
[1:08:58]
Yeah, I don't want to speak for the city on their side of it, but a mill is approximately
[1:09:04]
$1.4 million, ours would be a $400,000 cut and I don't want to talk out of school, but I've heard that the city may be proposing a 0% increase, which would be another 300, so I would guess it's about a 0.5 million decrease from where we were before, wherever that was.
[1:09:27]
Okay, and I think somehow or other people should know that because I think every time they're
[1:09:33]
going to vote and I'm up there so I see people who are coming into vote and a lot of them
[1:09:39]
are the seniors, a lot of them are the seniors and I think what they're thinking is how this
[1:09:45]
is impacting them.
[1:09:46]
So one, I think somehow through some marketing, through something that we should try and
[1:09:55]
educate the seniors on what that actually means. Also, a thinking of who we're talking about advocacy,
[1:10:03]
you know, maybe bringing together our PTOs and having them help and getting the word out
[1:10:13]
up to the community as a whole regarding the vote and what that means and how it will impact
[1:10:22]
act, as we say, you know, the children are our future. And I, because I think people
[1:10:28]
are afraid they don't know what, what this is going to mean. And somehow we have to,
[1:10:34]
you know, get them calm and, and, and to educate them on actually what it means. I tend
[1:10:41]
to see on a day to day basis, you know, how, how our teachers are working. We have the best,
[1:10:47]
I know we have the best teachers anywhere in this date. I watch them and I go home sometimes
[1:10:52]
I say, Lord, I couldn't do what they do.
[1:10:55]
You know, they're teaching, they're social workers,
[1:10:59]
they're moms, they're dads, they're everything.
[1:11:03]
And it shows, it shows with the children, you know,
[1:11:07]
saying that they'd have to increase the classrooms,
[1:11:10]
the number of children in the classroom.
[1:11:13]
When you have so many different personalities,
[1:11:15]
so many different issues that are going on,
[1:11:18]
it's definitely gonna impact our children.
[1:11:21]
and it'll impact the future of the children.
[1:11:24]
So, you know, I'm just thinking on advocacy side,
[1:11:28]
you know, if there could be a group or a committee
[1:11:29]
or if those who are, you know, let's get the word out,
[1:11:32]
let's figure out how we can best communicate to folks,
[1:11:36]
to make them aware of what it means,
[1:11:41]
how they can help, you know,
[1:11:44]
how they can keep us from going backwards
[1:11:46]
because that's exactly what'll happen
[1:11:48]
if we have to continue make other cuts.
[1:11:50]
But anyway, so moved.
[1:11:52]
They don't know yet.
[1:11:55]
Just so people are where we, you know,
[1:11:59]
we as people are boarded board members,
[1:12:02]
the staff, we have to be careful.
[1:12:05]
We can't go out and advocate directly
[1:12:08]
to the people on how to vote.
[1:12:11]
There's a lot of rules and regulations.
[1:12:13]
So, you know, we have to be careful on exactly
[1:12:16]
what we do and say to whomever.
[1:12:19]
but you know this discussion is was you know prompted I kept hearing from my board members
[1:12:25]
people don't know what it is don't know what our budget is they want to understand it so I
[1:12:30]
said okay let's let's do this zoom so this is about letting people know and understand
[1:12:36]
what the process is you know a lot of intelligent people out there they can make up their own minds
[1:12:41]
but we need to be careful just how we present so thank you for your time Diane I see Nina
[1:12:47]
I got her hand up,
[1:12:57]
we mute, unmute, need a fix, please?
[1:13:09]
I asked her to unmute.
[1:13:11]
Nina, you gotta click the button I think to unmute.
[1:13:32]
Okay, we'll come back to Nina, Meg.
[1:13:38]
So as far as like with the advocacy that everyone's talking about,
[1:13:41]
I know the board can't tell people how to vote,
[1:13:44]
but as far as like the general public,
[1:13:47]
not even telling people how to vote,
[1:13:48]
but just giving people information and the education on it,
[1:13:52]
Like, is this something where we can do phone calls?
[1:13:55]
Is this something where we can doorknack?
[1:13:57]
Is this something where we can set up tables at like the sporting events and the different
[1:14:01]
things going on in the city in the town so that people can get this information?
[1:14:06]
Yes, as long as you're not affiliated with the city or the schools, you are able to do whatever
[1:14:12]
you'd like to do.
[1:14:14]
Okay.
[1:14:15]
So, yeah, we just, we're, there's laws governing, you know,
[1:14:19]
of municipal people from applying pressure to students or you know we just have to be very careful
[1:14:26]
on how and what we say and do so yeah the hope is to get people out there to know and understand
[1:14:33]
what we are presenting and talk to people and hopefully get as many people out there as we can
[1:14:40]
to vote that's really the goal. So would it be possible to have like a one-pager like written
[1:14:47]
enough by someone on the board that kind of explains everything.
[1:14:51]
So that's something that we would have to give out to people.
[1:14:58]
I can ask about that.
[1:15:00]
Okay, I will ask council to make sure that we're not overstepping our bounds, but I believe that we are able to do that. But I would like to verify that first. Yeah, just to correct information and we're not. Yeah, you can, you know, we'll try to put. There's a, there, we, again, we posted a bunch of stuff out on the Ansonia.org website under the Board of Ed's budget area. And most of what we're talking about tonight is there, but if there's something specific, I'm sure if you contact central office, we can tell you whether we can or can't and what we can give you. Okay.
[1:15:29]
Okay. Okay. Thank you. Nina, are you able to unmute? Yeah. Yeah. I came up to Chris's
[1:15:39]
because I was clicking the unmute button and wasn't working. I don't know why. So, sorry
[1:15:43]
about that. Nina fifth, sixth year, Aqua Avenue, Antonio. I think Diane kind of asked the question
[1:15:51]
I was thinking, is there, do we even know or we may not know until Monday, I guess, if between
[1:15:59]
these cuts and whatever potential cuts or changes the city is going to make could that bring it down
[1:16:06]
below the percentage that we're trying to get to if you will to avoid another referendum.
[1:16:14]
Do we have any idea if we're going to even come somewhat close to that or again we won't know until
[1:16:21]
Monday. Again I don't want to talk for the finance side but I'll put my finance hat on for a minute
[1:16:28]
it and tell you, I don't think so.
[1:16:30]
That number, again, it's not all about the expense side,
[1:16:35]
we have a revenue issue with the motor vehicle reduction
[1:16:38]
in revenues and others.
[1:16:40]
So it would be a very small amount of money increase
[1:16:45]
for both Board of Ed and City,
[1:16:47]
a very small amount of money
[1:16:49]
that would put us below the threshold.
[1:16:51]
So that's probably a no, but again,
[1:16:54]
I don't want to speak for the board.
[1:16:56]
and I'll remind people again Monday night the Board of Alderman should be
[1:17:00]
meeting I believe they have a meeting schedule and they will ultimately be
[1:17:06]
talking about their side and what our recommendations to them would be you know
[1:17:12]
similar to what we had a week or so ago they will make the final decisions on this
[1:17:17]
so if there's other questions or finance side or city side questions you'll have
[1:17:22]
the opportunity to ask them those questions. Okay, thank you. And then another, as far as the advocacy
[1:17:29]
and getting the word out, I guess. And I think Meg just brought something up
[1:17:35]
as well as far as a one-pager. And Diane brought up the seniors that seem to be a lot of the voters
[1:17:42]
coming out, is there a way potentially, legally, to get someone down to the senior
[1:17:52]
center and maybe talk to the seniors and explain things to them so that they
[1:17:58]
understand what is going on. And I get it from their perspective, but also, you
[1:18:06]
know, their seniors that are living here more than likely, they have raised their
[1:18:10]
children here. So when their children were in school, other seniors were paying the taxes
[1:18:17]
for their children. And, you know, Chris and I, we no longer have any children in the school
[1:18:23]
system. We have no grandchildren in the school system, but we're still willing to make that payment
[1:18:29]
because when our kids were there, actually, I should say when my husband and Chris was in the
[1:18:34]
schools people did that for them so and I'm not trying to be nasty and saying that but I think they
[1:18:42]
just need to be educated on the cost of all the increases just like their cost of living so does
[1:18:50]
education go up and everything else so it may just be something if someone could get down there
[1:18:56]
and talk to them if they could set up a meeting or something um to give some some more information to
[1:19:03]
understand why it is what it is. Okay, we'll take that and we'll ask about that also.
[1:19:09]
Thank you. I'll go down there if you need me. Thanks.
[1:19:16]
Okay, Beth, I saw your hand up before. I
[1:19:19]
don't want to bypass you. Are you interested in talking again or no?
[1:19:27]
Okay.
[1:19:27]
Okay. Sorry. Are you? Oh, are you? Did you? Yeah, I'm okay. Thank you. Okay. Thanks.
[1:19:34]
Yeah. Okay. I see. Ed Wiener has a hand up.
[1:19:39]
Hi, everybody.
[1:19:42]
Dr. DeBacco, Mr. G. Allisus,
[1:19:44]
hello. They beat Derby.
[1:19:48]
I have a question in regards to explaining everything to the senior,
[1:19:53]
to senior, you know, community that lives in town, I went to vote with Ali and her best friend,
[1:20:00]
and they were completely confused. Now, they're seniors at the high school, they're 18 years old,
[1:20:05]
they're able to vote, but they don't know what they're doing because everyone's,
[1:20:12]
everything's going out to them, they're cutting, they're cutting, they're taking away
[1:20:15]
yourself, they're taking away sports, they're taking away this, but they don't truly understand why and how
[1:20:20]
they're supposed to vote. So I know the board of ed and you guys are doing a great job trying to give
[1:20:26]
them what they have and keep what they have and give them more but they really like the people
[1:20:33]
that we need voting and we need more people voting truly don't understand the questions that are
[1:20:39]
there on the ballot because I even myself and my husband got confused. It's a new process for us
[1:20:48]
And I completely understand and it's similar to what they have, I guess, in Seymour and I kind of they kind of probably put that in there to follow that that same pattern, but again, it's not a cut.
[1:21:02]
You know, the board of Alderman did not cut this. Okay. The people voted no to the budget.
[1:21:09]
And so we need to be careful and cognizant that we're not blaming the board of
[1:21:14]
all of them and they're doing what they need to do budget pass go also and
[1:21:19]
very happy to see the students up there expressing their their their thoughts
[1:21:24]
on all the different programs that we're going and that is really great that
[1:21:28]
they some of those kids just amazed me and they reinforced my love for this
[1:21:35]
this, this, uh, and so on your school district. Um, but yes, the, the process is, is a little
[1:21:42]
confusing, even for the adults and, you know, I'll pass that along. Maybe we can put out
[1:21:48]
some kind of, uh, how to vote thing a little bit better and, and kind of get there and do that.
[1:21:54]
So I'll note that and see what we can do on that. Okay. And, and I appreciate that. And just
[1:22:00]
as a side note, you know, a lot of people, you know, I'm very lucky to be the mom of Alliana
[1:22:05]
to be her mom. And you know, because she's involved in the boys and girls club, which is huge
[1:22:12]
in this city, which helps a lot of parents. She won you through the year. So she's actually going
[1:22:17]
to the Capitol next week after she does mock trial. And then, you know, she's going to be in front
[1:22:24]
of the governor. She's going to be in front of Senate and she's going to be in front of the people
[1:22:27]
that are supposed to do what they're supposed to do for our state. And I can guarantee you she will
[1:22:33]
bringing this up. Because even though she's graduating, you know, like she said at the
[1:22:39]
other meeting, she doesn't want to see her brother and his friends not have what she's had.
[1:22:46]
So I think it is a lot about, you know, because did we see a rise in voters for the second vote?
[1:22:52]
Because if it's the same people, it's like when I was volunteering for Little League and Tier,
[1:22:56]
if you have the same parents who do the same thing, you're not going to get much change.
[1:23:02]
Yeah, so did we see a difference in voters? Did we see it go up at all? Well, we did not in this last one, and I don't know. I'm hopeful that the next one will.
[1:23:13]
You know, if I follow the sea, see more, I think they had 700 more voters on their second election than they had in their first one.
[1:23:20]
And that's the hope is to get information out and get more people to come out and vote
[1:23:25]
on it.
[1:23:25]
But, you know, I don't know the answer to that question, but for those that don't know,
[1:23:35]
Edwin is daughter Alliana is a student representative on our Board of Education, and she is a, I think
[1:23:41]
she's going to Rutgers if I recall.
[1:23:44]
Yes, yes, she's very, very, very good, so very happy for her.
[1:23:49]
Thank you.
[1:23:49]
Thank you. Thank you. That's that's all. Rich, it's great. Yeah, I think what I'm hearing but
[1:23:56]
be wrong is the question is confusing. And I don't know the legalities of how to put the question
[1:24:03]
on there, but maybe even I think maybe that is a too high, is it too low? Can can that be taken off
[1:24:09]
of the ballot? Maybe it's part of the charter, the exact on how the question will be posed.
[1:24:16]
It would have to be more instruction on that, but I believe it's being done based on specifics in the charter.
[1:24:24]
Okay.
[1:24:25]
All right.
[1:24:26]
But I'll verify that.
[1:24:28]
With downstairs, but I believe that to be true.
[1:24:31]
Thank you, sir.
[1:24:38]
Okay. Anyone else from the public wish to address the board?
[1:24:43]
I think there was another handout. I don't know where it went.
[1:24:47]
Is there any anyone else from the public that wishes to address the board?
[1:24:51]
for it.
[1:24:56]
Third and final time, anyone from the public wish to address the board?
[1:25:03]
Okay.
[1:25:04]
Hearing none, seeing none, public session is now closed. I want to thank everyone for coming out. I want to thank our board members.
[1:25:11]
I'd like to, we've talked about these different things. Come back to my board members and say, is there anything that you want to do that change anything or modify anything that we're going to do?
[1:25:22]
Or shall we just go to entertain a motion to approve the recommended cuts to be sent to the Board of Wallerman for their Monday night meeting.
[1:25:32]
I'll make that motion, Rich.
[1:25:34]
We have a motion on the floor from Dave now.
[1:25:38]
Chris Vips will second that motion.
[1:25:41]
Is there any discussion on that before we move forward?
[1:25:46]
Okay, all those in favor signify by saying aye.
[1:25:49]
Aye.
[1:25:50]
I pose, staying, that motion carries, so we will send that list of recommended cuts to the Board of Alderman for their Monday meeting, any other discussion before we close the meeting them.
[1:26:05]
Anybody want to say anything? Dr. Joe, you want to have anything or are you all good?
[1:26:10]
but I'm not good, but I just want to say I appreciate
[1:26:15]
the love and support for our students,
[1:26:18]
the city of Ansonia, our kids.
[1:26:20]
If this is just compelling and makes us all want to work harder
[1:26:23]
and make us all do the right thing.
[1:26:25]
So I thank everybody very much for tuning in.
[1:26:28]
I appreciate it greatly.
[1:26:29]
Thank you.
[1:26:31]
All right.
[1:26:32]
Anyone else?
[1:26:34]
Okay. I will entertain a motion to adjourn.
[1:26:44]
Thank you all most of the all in favor. I thank you everyone for coming I appreciate your time and effort. Thank you.