Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
Come to order. This is the Bloomfield Township Design Review Board meeting. Wednesday, July 1,
[0:05]
26th at 2 p.m.
[0:09]
I'm Treasurer Michael Shostack, Supervisor Mike McCreeti's out of the office today.
[0:13]
Is there a motion to appoint a meeting chair?
[0:16]
I'm literally a point to Treasurer Michael Shostack to be the chair for this meeting. It's a sport.
[0:21]
Okay? We have support. All those in here, if you ever say aye.
[0:24]
Hi, and you posed, okay, so that passes.
[0:30]
In honor of America's impending 250th birthday,
[0:34]
why don't we all stand and see the pledge of allegiance?
[0:39]
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America,
[0:43]
to the Republic for which it stands,
[0:45]
one nation on the ground, indivisible with liberty and justice are all.
[0:51]
Thank you very much.
[0:53]
Okay. We'll begin with attendance.
[0:57]
As we said, Supervisor McCreedy is not here. We've got trustee
[1:00]
Neil Barnett filling in. At this time, I'll open the floor for public comment. If there's
[1:05]
anybody here to comment on any of the items on the agenda, if you are the person presenting
[1:12]
the item, you will have your opportunity later. I see no public comment, so I'm going to
[1:17]
public comment and move on. Item three approval of the minutes of the June 17th meeting.
[1:23]
Sir motion, some of the support. Motion and support. All those if you ever say aye.
[1:28]
Aye. Opposed. Okay. That passes. Let's move on to new items.
[1:32]
Beginning with signs. The first item is four three two three nine woodward avenue.
[1:37]
Good afternoon board. So the first item on today's agenda is four three two three nine woodward avenue.
[1:42]
It's property is located in the B2 district, and the applicant's little gem is looking to install a wall sign on the property.
[1:55]
The proposed wall sign complies with the township sign ordinance.
[1:59]
One wall sign is being proposed, which is permitted by the ordinance.
[2:03]
The maximum permitted Walsign area is 60 square feet and based on the street site facade measuring 42 feet by 24 feet
[2:14]
The applicant will be proposing a sign under the 60 square foot requirements being 22 square feet
[2:23]
There is no history of the Golden Crown which was the previous occupants but the nearby Bastion Gaming Center had a sign of 18 square feet for comparison
[2:33]
The sign will be located on the front facade, and we'll project eight inches from the building.
[2:40]
It will not extend above the roof line, and it will be internally illuminated with LED lighting.
[2:45]
There will be no exposed neon or flashing illumination.
[2:49]
The staff has reviewed the proposal for compliance with the touch of signed regulations and finds it acceptable.
[2:58]
Is there anybody here representing the little gym?
[3:00]
You have anything to add?
[3:02]
Just a little bit.
[3:04]
Pretty much.
[3:05]
Pretty much summed it all up right there.
[3:08]
Signs within the ordinance.
[3:10]
Simple all sign.
[3:13]
Any questions from board?
[3:14]
Have a question.
[3:15]
Where?
[3:17]
There's a sign on the door, too.
[3:19]
You guys consider that to be directional or a second sign.
[3:27]
So from the looks of it,
[3:29]
I did not catch that.
[3:31]
Do you know anything else?
[3:32]
like store hours identification of store hours as long as it's limited to the
[3:38]
hours of operation and the name of the business it's acceptable. So it has the
[3:44]
little gem same sort of thing as the sign and then probably looks like the
[3:48]
store hours just based on looking at this picture. And that's PBO's assessment of
[3:55]
that is that's directional it's not a second sign.
[3:57]
Right.
[3:59]
Okay.
[4:01]
Okay.
[4:01]
Any other questions?
[4:03]
No.
[4:03]
No.
[4:03]
That's that.
[4:04]
I'll make motion that way you prove it's presented.
[4:06]
Support.
[4:06]
Great motion.
[4:07]
Support.
[4:07]
All those in favor say aye.
[4:09]
Aye.
[4:09]
And he posed.
[4:10]
Okay.
[4:11]
That motion carries.
[4:12]
Thanks.
[4:13]
And the sign is approved.
[4:15]
Moving on to 2067 South Telegraph Road.
[4:29]
For 2067 South Telegraph Road.
[4:31]
We're looking at a wall sign for pure hockey.
[4:34]
Located in the B3 districts.
[4:37]
telegraph row north of square lake.
[4:43]
The applicant is requesting one wall sign as part of their sign proposal, a proposed sign
[4:48]
complies with the township's maximum wall sign area requirements.
[4:52]
The street site facade measures approximately 20 or 2,050 square feet, allowing up to 123 square
[5:00]
footage of sign.
[5:02]
The applicant is proposing a sign that will be 100 square feet, which is 5% of the street side facade.
[5:10]
For reference, the previous tenants, Hockey World, had an approved wall sign measuring 116 square feet.
[5:18]
The post sign will be installed on the front facade, it will project 12 inches from the building.
[5:22]
It will not extend above the roof line, and it will be internally illuminated with LED lighting.
[5:26]
The only issue staff identified is the
[5:33]
this logo in the middle, the circular logo measures
[5:38]
approximately 12.57 square feet and the illustration represents approximately 12 percent
[5:46]
of the scientific area which exceeds the limit for no more than 5 percent.
[5:51]
So they will need to go to the zoning board of appeals if the board finds it acceptable.
[5:57]
Any questions?
[5:59]
No, I mean, I find it actually, I think it's attractive, you know, I like the logo and
[6:06]
understand that it has to be approved by the CBA that business size.
[6:14]
Do you also represent them?
[6:15]
Yes, they do.
[6:16]
Excellent.
[6:16]
Anything you did?
[6:18]
No, just that we're, we're, well, under the allowable square footage of 120, the logo is slightly bigger
[6:25]
than allowed at 6%, at a 5%, if I present, so if it needs to go in front of ZBA for a variance,
[6:34]
then we'll have to do that, unless the board here can see fit that being under the square
[6:40]
footage that the sign is now and adding that little bit of square footage to a logo size,
[6:46]
then we could probably move forward without going to the ZBA.
[6:52]
I think that's a good idea, but I don't think that's within our authority.
[6:56]
I agree with you.
[6:58]
But since the sign overall is less than I have no problem with accepting the proposed sign as presented
[7:10]
in foreign to the ZBA support.
[7:13]
Okay.
[7:14]
One thing I'll add before I call for vote is that if we looked at the 120 square feet, which is the
[7:19]
actually be allowed to 12.57 is still exceeds 5% of that.
[7:24]
But I trust that the ZBA will consider it appropriate.
[7:30]
So, if we have a motion and we have support, all those in favor say aye, aye. And he opposed, okay? That passes. And the sign is approve pending ZBA approval.
[7:42]
Local House, too. The next item is.
[7:45]
Thank you.
[7:46]
Thank you.
[7:47]
I'd like to comment though, saying the pledge of allegiance was a lot easier than blown out 250 candles.
[7:55]
I want to enjoy the day.
[7:56]
Thank you, sir.
[7:57]
You have a good holiday.
[7:58]
Okay, item number three, two, one, seven, two, south, telegraph road.
[8:04]
So for this property, it's going to be the mocha house located in the new Calabat building.
[8:09]
I'd spoke to the applicant this morning.
[8:11]
They weren't able to attend the meeting, but I'll proceed with the proposal.
[8:16]
This property is located in the B1 local business district,
[8:22]
and they are proposing a wall sign.
[8:24]
The proposed wall sign complies with the township's maximum wall sign area requirements.
[8:31]
The street site facade measures 1,092 square feet, allowing for a maximum wall sign, not to
[8:38]
exceed 65 square feet.
[8:40]
The applicant is proposing a 39 square foot wall sign.
[8:45]
The sign will be located in the front facade, it will project six inches from the building.
[8:50]
It will not extend above the roof line, and it will be internally illuminated with LED channel letters.
[8:57]
The only issue step identified is the illustration in the middle.
[9:01]
The ordinance limits the illustration to 5% of the total sign area.
[9:06]
For a 39 square foot sign, the maximum permitted is 1.95 square feet.
[9:10]
And the applicant is proposing an illustration to be 3.9 square feet.
[9:15]
So if the board would find the sign acceptable,
[9:18]
who would have to go to the zoning board of appeals for consideration.
[9:22]
Can you describe what the illustration is?
[9:26]
It
[9:36]
looks like it's in the B.A.Y.T.
[9:41]
With a cup and then some lettering above it.
[9:45]
Looking at it, it almost looks like an old coin
[9:50]
or I can't really describe the meaning of it.
[9:55]
But there's no script from another language.
[10:02]
That's a good question I'd have to confirm with the applicant.
[10:10]
I don't know what our policy has been in the past about using non-English letters.
[10:16]
I don't know if that is.
[10:21]
No, either.
[10:23]
Yes.
[10:23]
Have we had a policy about that in the past?
[10:25]
No.
[10:26]
No policy or no we even love it.
[10:29]
It's never come up.
[10:32]
And if it is a word, I don't know what it is, which we should probably know, but we could see the A, we can ask that.
[10:37]
Yeah, we should be more traditional.
[10:42]
So G, A, Y, T.
[10:46]
B, A, Y, T.
[10:49]
It looks like T, I don't know if there's a T there.
[10:52]
Is it good T, maybe?
[10:53]
Sometimes the way I look at it, sometimes I just see the coffee cup and sometimes I see the T.
[10:58]
Yeah. I have a zoomed up on the.
[11:01]
Oh, yeah. Oh, that's all. Oh, yeah.
[11:02]
Yeah, that does.
[11:03]
There is a T there.
[11:04]
That doesn't look like writing to me up there, but I don't know.
[11:07]
It doesn't. Looks more designed-wise.
[11:09]
But good to get it clarified.
[11:11]
Yeah.
[11:12]
Okay.
[11:13]
So this is for it on what action it wants to take.
[11:18]
I'd go like a motion to accept the sign as presented
[11:21]
and forward to the ZBA for consideration with
[11:25]
special attention to the logo and it's writing and what it's a word and what it means.
[11:35]
And if it's a different language, yes.
[11:40]
Okay.
[11:40]
Support.
[11:41]
Okay.
[11:41]
We have a motion in support.
[11:42]
All those in favor say aye.
[11:46]
Aye.
[11:47]
And any opposed?
[11:49]
So let's move on.
[11:51]
That is approved.
[11:55]
We're moving on now to site improvements, and the first item is 4-1-1-3 telegraph road.
[12:04]
So, for the Devon-Squart Codominium Association, we'll get in the RM districts, right across the streets,
[12:11]
and they are looking for to do a site improvements along their frontage,
[12:16]
specifically requesting approval to restore the natural buffer by replacing sections
[12:23]
So the decorative brick wall lost during a windstorm earlier this year with some new shrubs
[12:28]
and small trees, specifically the proposed includes planting four standard maple trees ranging
[12:34]
between eight to 12 feet in height, between the cart ports and the former wall alignment.
[12:40]
No changes are proposed for the buildings, lighting, signage, parking or other site improvements.
[12:46]
What us today is John from the kind of minimum association to elaborate.
[12:52]
John, can you see your name? John Yurgy and you representing.
[12:56]
I represent the board for Devon Square.
[13:00]
I can talk about it.
[13:02]
Yeah, please.
[13:03]
So this is a sort of the eastern side or the western side of the property.
[13:09]
This wall you can see the white corner stones.
[13:13]
Corner areas are still standing.
[13:15]
One has the actual sign of the kind of minimum complex on it.
[13:18]
The dark green, I tried to represent the current bushes and trees that are there with
[13:25]
there much more mature than what we're proposing, obviously. And the orangeish, you can see sort
[13:31]
of a shrub, hedge, if you will, and four standard maples in orange that we would propose putting,
[13:39]
and they're just to present a little more of a block for the residents to see telegraph and
[13:44]
or anybody on telegraph looking in.
[13:50]
It's a telegraph to the cardboard is probably a 12-foot dip.
[13:56]
So you go down a hill.
[13:59]
So these would be on that hill as it rises up to the side
[14:03]
of the front or wall.
[14:08]
Any questions from the board?
[14:10]
That's a great idea.
[14:12]
Looks good.
[14:13]
An improvement in the action.
[14:15]
like a motion this is something we can approve here right time we don't
[14:20]
write it doesn't go anywhere it's all within it's just a slight improvement for
[14:23]
the dear be to consider in a motion we're not going to sell anything with the
[14:27]
bushes so we don't even motion to approve as a submit we have support all those
[14:36]
in favor say aye aye any opposed okay that motion carries and the site improvement is
[14:42]
approved thanks for going to help to get started on it
[14:46]
Well, in my proposal, I said we'd do it in the next 12 months. Okay. I'm really helpful. We can play it before the fall or in the fall
[14:54]
It takes so sure all right great. Thank you. Thank you
[15:00]
Moving on, item 2, 2, 1, 8, 4, south telegraph road.
[15:04]
So, for the piano, this is for the piano gallery, a long telegraph road near the call about building.
[15:10]
Due to the new building being constructed and a shared easement with their parking arrangements,
[15:18]
they are proposing to put up a new entrance along the new parking lots to provide additional access.
[15:26]
No changes are proposed to the building's use, lighting, signage or other site improvements.
[15:31]
It's simply this new entry door.
[15:36]
Where's there other door?
[15:38]
What do you see in the picture?
[15:40]
The other side,
[15:43]
yeah.
[15:43]
And facing south.
[15:46]
Oh, there it is.
[15:47]
Facing west.
[15:49]
Oh, no, no, no.
[15:50]
Yeah, it's facing south.
[15:52]
It's on the south side of the building.
[16:00]
You need to go anywhere other than the design.
[16:02]
Just the designer of the board.
[16:03]
I have no problems or questions.
[16:07]
Any action?
[16:08]
I need to be supported as a representative.
[16:10]
Before I prove it.
[16:11]
And we have motion and support all those in favor say I, I, I, and he opposed, okay.
[16:18]
That carries three to nothing.
[16:22]
That completes the site improvements moving on general business, is there any other
[16:27]
business that needs to come here for the DRB of the sign?
[16:29]
No, sir.
[16:29]
Okay.
[16:30]
Our next meeting date will be Wednesday, July 15th.
[16:33]
at 2 p.m. in this auditorium.
[16:36]
I wish everybody a safe and happy Independence Day
[16:40]
and happy birthday, America.
[16:43]
Okay, it's motion to adjourn.
[16:44]
I'm a little bit adjourned.
[16:45]
All right, we are adjourned.