BHS: Board of Education Meeting August 24, 2026

Bloomfield Hills School District, MI · · More Bloomfield Hills School District, MI meetings · More Michigan meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[0:05] All schools Board of Education can take attendance please.
[0:10] Sure. Looks like Trustee Southland is not here, Trustee Hill.
[0:16] Yep, so I think Trustee Southland will be late, but Trustee Hill is definitely out.
[0:23] So we'll go to item 2A, which is the board committee reports and kind of west.
[0:28] Feel free to go in the order.
[0:30] Yeah, I think let's start with strategic planning. If we can Jason and then we'll go to finance
[0:36] operations and finalize with the curriculum and instruction.
[0:44] Yeah, the agenda for the strategic
[0:45] planning committee. So give me a minute on that one. Okay, well let's jump into finance
[0:50] operations and if that's
[1:00] oh I thought I had I thought I had a little bit
[1:04] and
[1:13] I mean I'll talk about the finance community so
[1:18] most of what we talked about is
[1:20] putting together a cadence for the rest of the year starting in September
[1:25] regarding having and we'll talk about it later in terms of the goals having monthly updates
[1:31] looking at a budget, comparing budget tax all, and then each month kind of monitoring it
[1:38] and seeing what we do toward the end of the year, which is the ultimate goal, which I
[1:42] know we spoke about last year and we'll talk about goals this year as to get to a balanced
[1:47] budget. So we spent most of the time talking about that. So having that in effect starting
[1:54] it's September and then a couple of other things that I'm trying to bring up.
[2:03] You can send it here.
[2:11] Get up.
[2:12] Yeah, I'm just trying to get up here.
[2:15] You could, yeah, you could talk.
[2:16] Yeah, so we did give some construction updates as well regarding the buildings.
[2:22] That was also in the board update.
[2:25] So I am happy to report that we are making solid progress on all of the summer projects this year.
[2:33] One thing we are asking for approval tonight, which is 9B, is additional contingency on
[2:39] bid package number 13, the robotics renovation, if you recall, we did have additional budget for
[2:48] that for the for the electrical requirements of the robotic section. They have ran through that
[2:57] project, and $30,000 will complete that.
[3:02] I will tell you, that's specific to that project.
[3:05] Overall, the contingency is very healthy.
[3:08] We'll be getting quite a bit of that contingency money back.
[3:13] So that is one action item tonight.
[3:16] David, I can go through that.
[3:17] I have it.
[3:17] I have it up now.
[3:19] It came up.
[3:19] So construction, just can we update is both.
[3:23] So obviously we're here going through,
[3:26] you know, what's going on here. Conan parking lot, the parking lot is projected well, should be completed actually this week should be completed.
[3:35] The BHHS tennis course, resurfaced of the courts, you know, to where I was thinking fine, you know, has been finished, you know, for the season BHHS and South Hills roofing roofing projects,
[3:47] at South Hills Middle School of all high schools, continually to progress on schedule, anyone who's
[3:53] been in the high school, the BHHS staircase, you know, that's been completed, so, you know,
[3:59] that project schedule to be open with the school opening right after Labor Day, and then
[4:08] Superintendent West talked about the robotics contingency, and then the only other thing we need
[4:15] talk about as a community and then as a board is what are we going to do long-term.
[4:22] This is a big discussion east over and low in pine tennis courts.
[4:25] So right now, east over and low in pine tennis courts, they're at a place now where either
[4:31] as a decision we need to complete and these are not being used right now because east over
[4:39] and low in pine, it's being used mostly by our communities, not being used by our students.
[4:43] I mean, in theory it could be used by our students because, you know, we have two middle school programs and then a married out of high school programs, you know,
[4:51] vars VA, vars VB, and a JV program, but to resurface both of those courts to be playable would be millions.
[5:00] So it's either that or do we decide as a board potentially to repurpose those areas.
[5:07] So that's a discussion that we're going to have to decide what we're going to do.
[5:12] I don't think, and I don't know, Superintendent West, we talked about this in the committee meeting.
[5:16] If the township would be willing to put, look into it and put money in the past, the township
[5:22] is not that any sort of recreation, I want to draw anything to do it recreation in their budget.
[5:28] So either we're going to have to take it on or we're going to have to look to what we can do to repurpose it.
[5:33] So, there was deep discussion and my takeaway was that administration is going to do this and I think this lens itself great to the community engagement piece of the strategic plan as well with decisions like this.
[5:49] So, administration has already begun a process by which we're collecting and gathering information or will be to bring back to the Finance and Operations Committee a comprehensive
[6:02] of detail, perhaps a recommendation,
[6:07] but the information we think is needed
[6:09] and the committee thought was needed
[6:10] to make a informed decision on that.
[6:14] These are arbitrary timelines
[6:16] where we're looking at potential late fall,
[6:21] early winter type timeframe,
[6:24] but as Trustee Collins said,
[6:28] these are in pretty dire condition,
[6:30] our maintenance and operations team. I did we had a discussion after that meeting and it's a full
[6:38] replacement. It's past resurface. Both courts need a full replacement. So that is, that's one
[6:47] of those projects, one of those things that's going to lend itself nicely to getting community feedback.
[6:52] So the board can make an informed decision on whether or not to invest or invest. Or alternative
[6:57] of solutions such as public public partnership, public private partnerships and those are all things
[7:03] we're exploring as well. So Karen, Jake and Mike are our small committee and they're exploring
[7:13] all different types of information and options.
[7:18] One of the things and just since it is I brought up in our committee we as a board we need to
[7:26] consider, and I'd like to make a recommendation, because we're...
[7:30] On this in the past, is if we look at the BHAJ staircase. So, going historical to how this came about, writing, we're big into student voice, student initiatives, it was a student who presented, I believe this was probably 40 years ago, to the finance committee, a proposal for the staircase, did extensive research in terms of,
[8:00] of the need presented to it and then it got, you know, it was considered and I think
[8:08] that stood in and we can contest out of the students on your superintendent but sent numerous
[8:15] follow-ups with administration, central office, moreover short, it got passed and it got built.
[8:22] So my thought was is that we named the staircase after that stood up and on the path they
[8:29] have in the high school, they have named like Charlie Hollereth, you know, they have named
[8:35] things against people before and I think it would be a good thing to name this for the
[8:42] student who really pushed this to get this to flourishing. So I know that it's a policy
[8:48] decision right? Yeah, just a, it is, it's squarely with the board's realm, it's governed
[8:55] by policy 6,09, so that's something that you guys can explore as a board.
[9:05] Policy available to read right now.
[9:09] So I have it up if you want me to read it.
[9:11] Sure.
[9:12] Says the Board of Education shall name or rename school district facilities and properties.
[9:17] Persons wishing to have a district property or facility named renamed and in particular
[9:21] manner, or named rename to honor, or memorialize an individual significant to the district.
[9:27] Shalsamada written request to the board.
[9:29] The board shall weigh a minimum of three months before action is taken on the request.
[9:34] In considering any such request the board will consider the following criteria and additional
[9:38] to other relevant considerations.
[9:41] One, if the individual was or is a resident or staff member of the district, or two,
[9:46] if the individual made a significant contribution to the well-being of the district, students
[9:51] community and or society in general. There is no corresponding administrative regulation that
[9:58] goes along with that. Do we have a written request in fairness to Paul? I think you brought
[10:08] this up before and there was a written request so he put it in an email I think and I don't think
[10:14] there was any action. I don't remember the discussion previously that it's vague to me but
[10:21] If you want to consider my, you know, a written request, then I guess that would be a written request.
[10:30] So, thank you for the written request.
[10:32] It says we need three months to think about it, decide, talk about it.
[10:37] Is that my understanding correct based on the policy?
[10:42] That's what it says.
[10:44] So we eat a minimum of three months before action is taken on their request.
[10:48] I don't know when my email was.
[10:51] I couldn't have been three months ago.
[10:55] It's happening, and then...
[10:56] I would imagine there's probably some...
[10:58] A Vermont wait, so if somebody has an issue with it or something,
[11:02] they can raise it versus an email that nobody publicly knew about.
[11:06] I don't know if this is the start of the three months before.
[11:09] So let's say this is the start.
[11:11] Because we really haven't talked about it.
[11:12] Right, that's been publicly.
[11:13] So let's say this is the start of the three months request.
[11:16] All right, I could put the emails there, the right no question, and I guess the point is what else do we need to do to put it out there for
[11:26] Sunday, April 26
[11:29] Who was an email to me in turn, and I don't were there other students that were
[11:38] Significantly involved in
[11:40] pushed it pushing this I can't remember I don't even know if it was happened live
[11:44] it was. It was. I mean work. Rick would know. Eddie Sherman was the one that
[11:54] always engaged with us. I picked up this as you said it was going on long before.
[11:59] A couple years before I did she her persistence was such a you know we we
[12:06] engaged with her last year, I talked to the high school, and we talked about this when we
[12:12] approved the project. So I'm not aware of any big push from the student body. It was
[12:19] specifically this one student.
[12:26] Only of one of their naming that I can recall, and it's a former board member who served for
[12:33] 22 years or 25 years and in recognition of that service, she received a naming opportunity.
[12:43] I don't know if this really is at the same level to be honest with you, but I do appreciate
[12:48] that she helped get this project moving in to fruition.
[12:54] I'm just concerned that every year we'll have a new student body, so every year, if someone
[12:59] pushes through a project or we naming something after that student?
[13:04] Well, I think the reason why I thought about naming this is something, I mean this is something unique that I doubt will be happening every year.
[13:14] Well, I mean this is probably something that rarely will ever happen again where a student pushes for a project to be done and the project went through and he built a staircase because of the student.
[13:26] And I don't think in the 10 years of it on the board, I've ever students have done great things but ever to this extent where there's a tangible item that can be linked to a specific student.
[13:37] I can't think of anything else.
[13:38] all the more to students, if it was adding an email.
[13:44] Yeah, I was just looking at the slideshow from 2024,
[13:48] where they got sent to the full board in 2024.
[13:55] And they, in 2024, and that's the two people in there.
[13:59] So that was only my thing, too.
[14:00] It was like, I don't know the level.
[14:02] But I don't remember who pushed what,
[14:04] but I'm looking at it and seeing two people.
[14:06] So that's my only concern is I wouldn't want it.
[14:09] I don't mean, and I can't be the two of them, that's my question, is why not, like why not name lots of things?
[14:18] You introduce this, this is about community building, and I can assure everyone if he's built involved in belonging.
[14:23] We have lots of things that we named, and then we renamed why not.
[14:27] I think courage is our students to get involved, to be active, to push for what they want.
[14:34] Doesn't cost us anything to name something, and then we'll always rename it.
[14:37] The cost thing is there's something every time on a blackout, you know, sign something just probably a little
[14:43] Or just didn't just probably a little plaque right nothing to the extent of
[14:48] The great things in the comment on this staircase right
[14:54] We have a foundation that has money
[14:57] Okay, so I do I guess I'll address this
[15:01] What is the criteria we're going to use? And it could get interesting. This is squarely within the board's purview, but
[15:19] I would just caution the board, whether it's this or whatever, where does that request?
[15:27] And how do we need a lot more parameters than that policy to, I think, govern this appropriately?
[15:40] Because it could open us up and I don't want to, it could open us up to conversations we might not want to have.
[15:50] And again, to your point, Paul, this maybe you're establishing it.
[15:55] It's first time in 10 years that you've experienced something like this.
[15:59] So I don't have a strong opinion other than I just caution the board if we're going to open up the naming of anything and the why not scenario that it could become cumbersome for the community.
[16:13] I mean, that would only say, when we go with that angle, I mean, it took probably seven years to start a hall of fame.
[16:21] And we had the same conversations like, you know, what's the criteria who gets in, what about the people who feel, you can't not do something that's great.
[16:32] That's going to promote community, student involvement, and make students feel special by what people may perceive as,
[16:43] Why not me? I've never in my experience. I mean, right, you were all in jobs. People get promoted.
[16:50] You don't not promote someone because you worried about the people who aren't getting promoted.
[16:56] So I would caution going that route saying, we're worried about something that we don't even know what we're worried about.
[17:04] I mean, a student spent 24 or three years.
[17:09] Like we want to encourage students to, right, if they have a passion, spent three years.
[17:14] I was shocked to be honest, when you said it was being a girl, I was shocked.
[17:17] I mean, I'm just, nothing, nothing.
[17:18] I'm just saying, I've oldest, I mean, I'm just saying.
[17:20] So students, that three years and was on it, like, came up with a proposal, presented, followed up,
[17:27] followed up again, followed up again, followed up again, followed up again, and it happened.
[17:32] I just think it's a, it's a good precedent to say.
[17:36] I'm not disagreeing with that at all that this isn't an incredible work that these two students, it sounds like, you know, achieved and pushed through and got our attention.
[17:49] But most organizations have some kind of policy that's a little bit more granular, like how to get a naming, how to put some of them.
[17:58] You know, they look at their background, they look at what they, some of the criteria in our policy actually are helpful, you know, do they make a significant
[18:05] I don't even know the wording in the policy, but significant difference, is this a significant difference to our community?
[18:15] From a safety perspective in high school.
[18:17] This is like someone who's achieved great things and sports or musicals or whatever AP, you know, there's a whole host of other criteria.
[18:27] I could think of that would make someone significant.
[18:31] So, if we don't want to go there, I mean, I think if we don't want to go there, because of whatever reason,
[18:38] I mean, people can argue, like the name you already have in the high school, like, right, we have the Holleris, whatever, right, people can name.
[18:47] You could always go for anything that's been named against somebody and go with what was a criteria for that.
[18:54] It did. It's a great thing. He was a principal for years in the building. I think that person, that structure, if it wasn't for that person, that structure would have never been built.
[19:07] And it's creating a safety, so that's the reason why I think it would make sense to name it.
[19:14] But if the board is not to do it, the board is not to do it.
[19:21] starting now to kind of think about it, bring it up for the questions, I think, feel free
[19:28] to, we can talk policy and it might be helpful to distribute that policy just so that
[19:33] we've all got it.
[19:34] This may even be a, you know, opportunity to really look at the policy and say, is this sufficient?
[19:38] And it's not, I don't know, but we've got three months to go through our own thought process
[19:46] of how we feel about this particular request about the policy in general.
[19:50] And then we can come back in three months and actually have a decision and don't worry and say, this is how we feel.
[19:58] So let's, to Lindsey's earlier point, I would ask what the intentions of that policy is, is it relates to the three-month time frame and what the board's expectation is on feedback that you're expecting.
[20:15] if there's any administrative work that needs to be done and regards to that, I would
[20:21] like some clarity around what that expectation is to get what feedback we would be looking
[20:27] for and so you guys can make it the best informed decision at the end of the three months
[20:34] time period. So that's my only request as we want to. And if we want to suggest this is the written
[20:43] request and the three month time frame is starting now, we can, we can perhaps move this
[20:51] to the committee meetings too.
[20:53] Yep.
[20:55] My request would be to have all the names we currently have, so you understand they're
[21:00] background, the history of those names I know by our as far in for instance was named after
[21:05] a board member, I'd love to know other names and why they were named.
[21:10] If you stand in the, to Paul's point, if you stand in the common area of the high school and you just do a 360, you will see at least three or four different
[21:24] for the radio station,
[21:28] Hall of Roles.
[21:29] And ingrid.
[21:30] Ingrid.
[21:30] Ingrid Day.
[21:31] So do you have an annual annual?
[21:33] I think the college is a little too.
[21:35] Oh, I do.
[21:36] And then each building certainly, I don't know, the history behind all of the names of the school buildings.
[21:42] We have like, back to the name of some of them.
[21:45] And see it's with names on them.
[21:47] Usually that's associated with you.
[21:48] If somebody has opposed to you do something that actually benefits other than monetarily.
[21:53] I know.
[21:53] We have bricks, we have bricks, we have pk on one of the seats and the one at the first row.
[22:00] We name pk a lot of things that has been done because people give money.
[22:05] And we certainly want to encourage people to give money.
[22:07] But giving service is also a value we're trying to teach our children.
[22:11] Our students giving service is just as good as giving money.
[22:16] So, something to think about.
[22:24] for like a few days I know that I get those once or twice a year like if you want to honor this and
[22:34] Those are pretty funny. They want to pop on somewhere. So, might want to build an attendance like what the what your vision for that might be.
[22:44] Because those are some way of a war miracle. Yeah, I forgot who that was. Who did the theater? There's something right in the back. Like a little plaque on. I forgot who it was. If you don't, if you know what I'm talking about.
[23:04] But
[23:07] it is incredible this service project I agree with both of you. So I hope no one in the community thinks we're not really appreciative of the students work
[23:17] We really are it's incredible that we're going to make people safer in the long term
[23:25] Faster than I love seeing.
[23:27] Making Google twice on the stairs now.
[23:29] I'm not proud into the one thing up and down.
[23:33] So.
[23:34] I don't know.
[23:35] I don't know.
[23:36] I don't know.
[23:36] I don't know.
[23:38] The high school administration is,
[23:41] I think we're working on the logistics.
[23:45] Okay.
[23:53] I think we're working on the logistics.
[23:55] So the first thing we talked about,
[23:57] which I think all the committees address separately,
[24:00] is the second reading of the wireless communication device.
[24:03] policy. It's been underway for a while now. I think we voted on it last
[24:08] board meeting. Generally, the administration staff educators have done a great
[24:13] job in kind of formalizing it at each grade level thinking about what's
[24:17] appropriate. We walked through it. Didn't really have much to say in addition to
[24:24] what's already in the screen timing classroom. Kind of rules that we're
[24:31] pushed other than dealing with kind of how we're going to deal with the YOD and locking down
[24:38] devices, given the day to day and age where you restrict phone use, but every computer
[24:43] can attach itself to a phone, Apple, Google, PC, otherwise. So there's still some software
[24:49] hardware issues to think about, but that I think the overall plan was discussed with everyone.
[24:57] I don't know what other committees discussed about it, but it made it through ours without
[25:03] I think any changes.
[25:06] We also talked about action steps in goal three of the strategic plan, which is the team-rooted
[25:13] and caring collaboration.
[25:15] Joe walked us through those various different initiatives and action steps.
[25:19] I don't believe we had any changes to the bullets on there.
[25:24] We talked about the importance of having these things be comfortable and measurable and to have accountability
[25:32] But no specific comments or feedbacks on goal 3 and our understanding was the other goals were being addressed by other committees.
[25:41] And this is short me. So that's about it.
[25:46] Curriculum instructions. So we talked about the upper elementary science curriculum that's going to come up for board approval.
[25:53] sometime in the fall. So there's a link in the agenda. If you want to kind of dive deeper into
[26:02] what that curriculum is before we get to the approval, you can check that out.
[26:09] What is for grades three through through your five has been through sounds to me like a rigorous
[26:15] process of getting, you know, piloting, getting feedback from teachers and all of that
[26:20] great stuff, and they landed on Boss as the one that we'll be bringing forward later in the fall.
[26:29] And then we spent some time talking about the literacy curriculum resources and 35M funding.
[26:36] So the team has done an amazing job securing funding over $900,000.
[26:43] I think this over the last two years.
[26:46] So that's remarkable and great helps our budget out considerably and has gotten us to be able to move completely to the science of reading, which is exciting and wonderful and for all of K through five.
[27:00] So then coming up on the agenda tonight is approval for some additional add-on options for that curriculum.
[27:10] And then we also talked about the wireless device policy and I think sound similar to Jason
[27:17] talking about BYOD and maybe taking a look at that in the fall where we want to go with that.
[27:25] And then the last one was the strategic plan goals 1 and 2.
[27:30] I don't know if we're going to I don't know if we got to get to deep into those but I don't
[27:36] if there's going to be another opportunity for feedback on the action steps on those.
[27:42] Yeah, we're going to talk about strategic planning update next too.
[27:54] I don't know if we want to talk about the rankings stuff to you that we didn't get to talk about that in the committee,
[27:59] but I know there's been interesting and things on.
[28:02] Yeah, there's been a lot of discussion and I don't want to dive too.
[28:06] I do want to get to strategic planning and then spend a considerable amount of time making sure our
[28:12] or our superintendent board goals are discussed,
[28:16] because there's a lot of good discussion to be had there.
[28:21] The U.S. news and world rankings came out
[28:24] and it always peaks the interests of communities.
[28:29] And certainly as peak the interest of the board,
[28:32] and Todd has been very responsive.
[28:35] We put together some additional information in,
[28:38] and Paul, I don't know,
[28:39] your specific inquiry as for some comparative data. There was a link within that that provided the
[28:45] information that was requested. So we can redistribute that information and then there's some additional
[28:53] information I'll put in a protocol that Lindsay as the chair has been privy to. So just for the
[29:02] The public, we're 30 for ranked 31st, that's up from 35th last year on 39th and two years
[29:10] ago, and there's been considerable amount of analysis done on those rankings, and Todd
[29:19] continues to work with our high school in particular in the areas in which we know that
[29:25] improvement can increase our rankings, that being mathematics, and we know we know science
[29:32] as well. So there's additional conversations to be had. I will tell you, I find it's unique
[29:37] because different communities are all different. I have seen people all touting and celebrating
[29:43] they're ranking as 236 and I've seen people excited about their ranking in the 50s and 60s.
[29:52] There's high expectations here and that's why we love this place and we want to make sure
[29:57] that we're providing the best education I do.
[30:00] You think, and this isn't showing away from accountability,
[30:05] it is a piece of data that informs practice,
[30:11] that informs, that informs results.
[30:14] And we are committed to continuing to analyze that and look at practice and figure out how we get better and that's what we're committed to do.
[30:22] And that's how we use that data.
[30:25] The questions that we've been asked have allowed us to take a different lens in a deeper look
[30:29] into some of this and we can have as deep of a conversation as you would like.
[30:36] I think the overarching thing is how do we continue to improve?
[30:40] How do we benchmark ourselves against districts and how do we learn from those districts on
[30:46] what they may be doing differently to make us better?
[30:49] And those are conversations that are productive and those are conversations that we are willing to have.
[30:55] We're all networked in our different areas.
[30:59] And we talk to our colleagues all the time and there's someone to know what we're doing and we're wanting to know what others are doing.
[31:07] And that's what that's where the work goes from here.
[31:10] It's embedded.
[31:11] I do believe that it's embedded in our strategic plan, which we'll talk about.
[31:16] And as kind of a diagnostic, if you will, about our health of our academic programming,
[31:25] but it's not the only thing. So that's where I don't know where you want to go with it,
[31:32] if you want to go a Q&A here or ask some specific questions and we can try and answer what we can
[31:39] here. Yeah, I'll go through. So yes, recognizing, we've increased, recognizing, there's many other
[31:47] prominence that make a district, great besides the ranking, but, and I know of it, I've
[31:52] asked this over the course of the last card, those how many years, six, seven years. One,
[31:59] there is obviously a risk of losing students, right? You know, chair of the finance committee,
[32:06] It is a parameter, whether we like it or not, it is a parameter that a lot of people and I've talked to numerous people over the course of years and numerous people over the course of last couple of weeks. Unfortunately, it's a parameter that people look at.
[32:21] You know, the ranking in terms of where people are looking to live. So that's where I'm against.
[32:27] what I want to see, which I didn't get in the board of Dates, what are the areas that make it up,
[32:34] is it, and I've dug a little, is it math, science, graduation rates, college readiness,
[32:42] underserved in terms of their growth, what are the five or six areas or seven areas that make up
[32:49] this ranking, where do we fall compared to peers that are in the top 20? Is it, you know,
[32:59] all throw out X district, what I'll throwing them, is X district 70% in math, and where 47,
[33:06] is X district, you know, 99% graduation rate, where 96, you know, so that's what I'm looking for
[33:13] in terms of looking where the areas that we lack compared to those districts and then to the point what can we do to increase those or maybe we can't.
[33:27] I don't know, but that's where I read the board update to be honest and maybe it's just me didn't understand it.
[33:33] I'm just saying, that's simply, I want to see what are the parameters, 20%, 30% makes
[33:40] it up, where we stand, where we stand against comparative districts, and where have we
[33:45] run the last six years, has it all gone up, and that's why our rankings got up, or has
[33:51] some stuff gone up, college readiness as an example.
[33:54] I know that we've focused on that the last couple years, taking and passing APA is the definition
[34:02] and in those scores of college ready.
[34:05] So I understand that, but the other areas.
[34:07] That's what I'm looking for.
[34:09] And I would like the academic committee
[34:10] to spend time on that.
[34:12] And I don't know if the academic already
[34:14] wants to have any questions and comments on that.
[34:20] Thank you, appreciate it.
[34:21] Thank you, sir.
[34:22] In death.
[34:23] And so I think those might go out to the board
[34:26] as a whole soon.
[34:27] So maybe that will address some of the questions you're asking.
[34:31] And we can continue to follow up and have additional dialogue
[34:34] in the committee meetings, too.
[34:36] Now the specifics that you just asked for, I would suggest, and I don't know if others had
[34:41] an opportunity to see it within the, there's a link within there, and perhaps it was
[34:45] missed, and maybe not clearly stated, that it says U.S. 26, 27, or 26-world rankings.
[34:53] There's a link there.
[34:54] It's actually, it's actually a spreadsheet that details the calculated scores and puts the
[35:02] operating schools there and their scores with it.
[35:06] Did you use it when I listed out?
[35:08] Math science.
[35:10] So how is it?
[35:10] So how is it?
[35:10] Yeah.
[35:11] It's an API past, mathematics, proficiency, reading, science, graduation rate.
[35:17] So those are the sixth criteria.
[35:19] It gives our score.
[35:20] It gives a score comparatively to the districts that we should be evaluating right in our area
[35:28] geographically, as well, Todd's.
[35:30] But this, Todd's team has put this all together.
[35:32] I will tell you just today, because I want to be clear about something we are not trying
[35:38] away from improvement methods.
[35:42] Todd actually spent today at the high school talking about math instruction and it should
[35:51] be a goal as is all instruction, but math instruction in particular when we look at the proficiency
[35:57] rating and it's comparative to other other districts, there's room to evaluate our practice
[36:04] there and look at what we're doing.
[36:06] We know and we've talked about it since I've been here, the progression of eighth graders
[36:11] taking algebra and the increase in that and those statistics where I think provided
[36:16] as well and we've seen the results of those.
[36:20] Okay, we also know cohort are different, right?
[36:24] So some achievement at higher rates than others.
[36:28] So we factor that in as well.
[36:31] So it does give us a volume of information
[36:36] that we can really dig into.
[36:38] And we look at the participation rates,
[36:41] and I think somebody asked it today,
[36:42] the participation rates in our AP and IB programs
[36:46] and exams, and then the passage of those, yes,
[36:49] you to yes. Thank you. And we got to get you that information.
[36:57] So we'll
[36:58] compile all that information. So the entire board has that information. But
[37:02] take your point again, you know, I don't know what the ranking would be. We can
[37:10] predict where our ranking will be based on the core data because it's two years
[37:15] and careers and we do anticipate next year we're going to get better and maybe the following
[37:23] year that might drop a little bit again based on the information that we have at this time.
[37:27] Well, we don't know is that that from the end of the year.
[37:30] So, it is going to be, I think it's going to be an annual discussion, and I do think it gives us an opportunity to look, but in the aggregate, macro view, we look at math instruction and what we're doing and how we can prepare kids early on, we just invested heavily in the professional development and in the purchase of new elementary math curriculum, we believe that will have an impact as we prepare kids for the middle school.
[37:59] and high school math experience, and then we'll continue to value our AP and IB offerings
[38:07] and how we best prepare kids for those those pathways as well.
[38:13] So, graduation rate, I think, I also are particularly very nicely that if we're going to, if we're going to really
[38:22] We need to put ourselves on an equal playing field, right, and we know some of our competitors
[38:29] if you all are public institutions the way that they code some of the programming and some of the
[38:35] alternate pathways is different, and that's something that we're evaluating and looking into as well.
[38:41] So all of that to be said, it does give us plenty of things to look at and evaluate as we try to prepare ourselves better.
[38:50] it really needs to do in our focus needs to continue to be that within the confines of our strategic plan.
[38:57] So we're just saying, and I don't know what that last comment meant.
[39:02] So in graduation rate, when you're saying coding, I don't know what that means.
[39:05] Coding to different pathways, all of the districts to do it like we're 96, some of the districts to 99.
[39:11] So we have 4% or students that are not graduating and the ones that are graduating 99%.
[39:16] So our data will include all of our programs.
[39:20] are in that alternative education program,
[39:24] spowers, it would include Weing Lake.
[39:27] I think that's a good example.
[39:30] Because any time that we see 96%.
[39:32] That's also that like that isn't, that isn't
[39:35] matching with how we think the students are
[39:38] harassing.
[39:39] And this is Sarah and the sort of seeing the role
[39:41] and offices this year.
[39:43] I asked her to go back and look at those students
[39:45] specifically and we had some students that were
[39:47] to do, uh, any correctly, we're willing, we can improv that over in that program, which on their
[39:52] directory, there are not supposed to drag away, we're planning a keeping them until 26,
[39:58] or until age 26.
[40:00] So we have to make sure that those get a code correctly in, uh, enrollment office, and then the
[40:04] other piece of that, well, where it was, I believe it was reference to names, and then we
[40:08] don't have an alternative, the education school code, like most comprehensive high schools
[40:13] and visitors to our size, where that data sets
[40:16] sits separately from the high school.
[40:18] And it's fair to do that, because we have students
[40:21] that are in alternate high school pathways,
[40:24] so we don't code them that way in our data sets.
[40:27] So that means in another research that data sets,
[40:31] it's separately for that alternate of those alternative pathways
[40:34] in our district.
[40:35] That's all underneath the umbrella of the high school.
[40:38] And we're talking about really fine margins here,
[40:40] If we're talking about ranking, and those nuances in the way we co-stutants, that can have average per cent.
[40:49] Right, we're getting a class of 350 is nice to it.
[40:53] Right, so there's seven coding issues that I can get.
[40:57] I mean, the reality is, and I know we all agree with this, you know, that these primers are unfair.
[41:05] But I'm just saying.
[41:06] I think these are good.
[41:07] I mean, hyper-relp, healthy, healthy, healthy people that are opening up a look and saying
[41:11] I'm going to move to this place because someone's five or 31, but unfortunately that's
[41:16] the reality.
[41:17] So if there are some coding flaws, they didn't need to look at it, they're coding flaws,
[41:21] they need to look at all these parameters, what are we doing?
[41:24] Some of them, they just need, obviously, you know, one of them.
[41:29] But if there's like that and AP, making, I mean, people taking any AP exam and passing is not
[41:35] into the world. I'm not just saying that's their definition of
[41:39] college right, is that. So, you know, I'm just, that's, that's
[41:44] awesome. And how people say, we know the recipe. We also govern the
[41:48] number one high school and the state, which is I. So, we know, and we
[41:57] know the restrictions we have as it relates to building that and
[42:05] And that's through math placement. We can't do that necessarily what we do. It is building a curriculum that tries to develop our learners.
[42:16] So every learner can be set up as a potential.
[42:19] And that's what we're going to commit to continuing to do well, making sure that we really evaluate where we can get better.
[42:26] So this actually, and we're going to energize us.
[42:30] I mean, it energizes us today, and a little bit, it's sure there's some some productive
[42:36] show and there's some frustration that comes along with challenging ourselves in different
[42:41] ways.
[42:41] But this is the kind of, these are the good conversations where we can set it down with our
[42:46] administration.
[42:47] We can set it down with our teacher leaders and our unions, and the alcohol else around that.
[42:52] And AA do believe that it's embedded within the work that we just came up with.
[42:56] And it's, so it's a good conversation.
[42:58] And I look forward to it again next July, on this one, though.
[43:03] I don't think it's in your work. I'm just a little bit.
[43:05] I wouldn't like it as discussed regularly in any academic committee.
[43:10] It should be whether it's coding, whether it's math, whether it's graduated,
[43:14] which is a whole graduation race, science.
[43:17] It should be part of, you know, in and in.
[43:21] And then, and then, and then, report out to the rest of the board.
[43:24] I think that's part of the future discussion.
[43:27] what is the information, what is the dashboard, those those type of things that we're going to do?
[43:35] You ask us to know that we already know, because it is two or three years old.
[43:41] We don't need them to tell us.
[43:43] We want them to get better.
[43:45] But in terms of, are we seeing an impact from the change we made?
[43:51] We get that fast in the 80s, so it's more of...
[43:54] And that's what we hear, we'll look like next year.
[44:00] Yeah.
[44:00] We just don't know everybody else, but we have no fears in the world.
[44:04] Right, you just don't know what it's like.
[44:07] We don't know, we don't know, we don't know, we don't know.
[44:08] We don't know if we're all in that kind of change drastically.
[44:10] There's something to fear in that.
[44:12] I mean, it's not...
[44:13] To the forest, you like he said.
[44:15] It's like the thing with a stick,
[44:17] I don't know, I'm at the AP and to get that.
[44:20] I think we did really good work before.
[44:23] Yeah, yeah, we worked on access, so making classes more accessible to more students from being
[44:31] Gates, we increased participation, so more kids were taking the class of taking, taking me.
[44:38] But the last piece is really just success.
[44:41] Okay, so not getting there, they're engaged and how to help them get more.
[44:45] If that's the piece we want, right, because like APA stands, for example, three plus,
[44:50] I think what I have and maybe I didn't go back to that exalt spreadsheet but 77% is so to get higher than that it takes.
[45:00] You know, straightening to me, straightening to those those difficult words, you're able to succeed, but yes, it's a constant goal every single year that will know a lot more faster than US world.
[45:13] And even like niche, we're like we're 15 there, but we don't sit there and track niche.
[45:20] You know what I mean? I think if we do a good job, we're supposed to be doing anyway, like those rankings will improve our control.
[45:26] We don't have to wait for that, we already know.
[45:28] So, when you get into the granular data,
[45:31] we'll say an opportunity to talk to Mr. Irman,
[45:33] although we have our students, there's a sadder plot.
[45:37] And we know we can target, and we can also target instruction.
[45:43] And when we talk about embedding this into the strategies within our strategic,
[45:48] when we talk about enhancing high quality tier one instruction.
[45:51] Okay, Todd, as focus,
[45:56] Todd's the whole job of the LLC is committed to that work.
[46:01] Okay, and when we talk about both four,
[46:03] getting academic return on our investments,
[46:06] how do we invest in our mathematical growth?
[46:11] And I've already raised some creative ideas
[46:14] in which we might need to take some of the intentional investment
[46:17] toward toward that area.
[46:19] So, this is where alignment comes in, this is where this plan becomes activated and where
[46:25] alignment and data can tell the story and then we can add that.
[46:30] So, excited about those type of conversations and that's real throughout this plan and these
[46:35] discussions welcome to you to be head through committees and I look forward to it.
[46:41] So, anything else on?
[46:43] I just wanted to make a comment because I emailed you as well about it, and to Paul's point,
[46:49] unfortunately, people want a quick snapshot of how we're doing, and they look at ranking,
[46:54] unfortunately.
[46:55] But that's how all institutions get it right.
[46:57] They all get it right.
[46:59] Everything that's ranked, unfortunately, that's what people care about.
[47:02] When they're decide, we're going to move what's at a quality education, and I guess the only
[47:07] point I want to make is that it's hopeful to keep in mind these things that they're looking
[47:11] at to improve as the better each one and as a trustee and just keep it in mind that I'm gonna
[47:19] save for very long but as a new board is working, made it to look at it over time like
[47:26] every three months so see how everything's going and at your point it's all data but some of
[47:33] new data I don't know if like passing the AP exam is that looked in two years prior as well
[47:41] I mean, this is the first time I've really looked at this so I feel a little bit on and forms unfortunately now
[47:48] So I don't know if that's how you felt to Paul. It was kind of like, oh
[47:52] What I felt is like it's at a point and right where if we knew that there were coding issues two years ago
[48:00] Then our ranking may have been 24 if we address so we just need to address these areas
[48:08] best we can
[48:11] under circumstances, so each year, we're progressing the way we need to be, because the feeling
[48:19] from our community, right, wrong and different, is there's no, and maybe this is what, you
[48:24] know, I mean, there's no reason why we, as a district with the community we have, should
[48:29] not be in the top 20. That is a feeling, right, wrong and different. That's the feeling
[48:34] our community going back, and that's why I pulled it, and at one time, so we can't blame
[48:39] the merging of the high schools, and the overall was two, and Loser was eight, in 2011.
[48:45] And that's what people are falling back to.
[48:47] And the overall was two, Loser was eight, now worth $30.
[48:49] Well, and I think in the top 20s, you look at the data and then look at our demographic
[48:54] data, too, and particularly one of the best measures to look at that when you're looking
[48:59] the rankings is what the economic disadvantage rate is. That's a good way. That's a good indicator
[49:05] to see if it's like demographics. And so I think top 20 is very reasonable. I think that's
[49:11] our target is to get within that. It is difficult to go back to the time that you were talking about
[49:16] because at that time, Bluefield Hills was getting credit for all the IA scores. And so those were
[49:21] coming. Those weren't restricted and it's only what that time. But Rochester or I mean,
[49:28] And then, and then other districts are, for example, Birmingham.
[49:31] Other districts are good example, too, where, like, you might, and that's probably the one critique I would give for the US news rankings.
[49:38] Because I do think the categories are particularly fair, but what it doesn't do is it doesn't give a district average.
[49:46] So, like, as you compare it to other districts, they might have two or three high schools with some above us and some below.
[49:52] So when you average that data set, it's actually not very different than Bloomfield Hills.
[49:58] So unfortunately, you can't do it.
[50:00] You can't click another tab on there to see like district rankings.
[50:04] It's only just by high school because it could have two or three high schools with some above and some below.
[50:09] And oftentimes, that's based on the differences just geographically where they sit.
[50:14] You know, the growth point had South Hills was high and the North Hills was not as high.
[50:20] So sort of average?
[50:22] Because we have one high school where the average of the whole entire community, where you would see those differences with our middle schools and all entries that we would have some higher than others based on.
[50:31] Some of the unique needs that we have in each place.
[50:34] But I think top 20 is very fair.
[50:37] There are several moves that we can take in order to get their science, proficiency is a particular challenge for us right now where, and sometimes where the disconnect is, there are some community members that really value.
[50:50] you, the rankings, but they know for their individual child, in science proficiency, as one
[50:55] of those DMs stuff, that it doesn't have an impact on their child's college admissions.
[51:02] So like, sometimes just struggle with like they're being a measure in there that maybe
[51:06] isn't valued in a certain way. But that's something that Sarah is preparing for right now.
[51:11] She's good-pointing quite a bit of data together in plants on meeting with the science department
[51:16] the question right is the schools that are harder than us like what what are they like
[51:24] do they just value science more than I don't know what is the story you know like
[51:29] let me say well it doesn't but you know and I'll pick on Troy great Troy's what do
[51:34] they value it more than we do is I'm just I don't understand I don't know no I'm
[51:41] saying, but what, you know, that's my point when we're comparing others, like if you were
[51:46] talking to the company, you know, like why are these 60, I'm just making up not why 70%
[51:49] and we're 56, like what, you know, what are they doing that we're not?
[51:54] And those are conversations that we can have and look into through our networks and try to learn
[52:00] learn from one another.
[52:01] And then Committee hopefully we can have, you know, for other touchpoints, there's something
[52:05] on each of these individual categories and kind of follow what steps we're doing, taking
[52:11] to address any of them.
[52:13] Use the cells like there's a lot of students on the outskirts that could make a difference
[52:18] with these.
[52:19] If there's nine students for a tier point that they haven't graduated, what if you just
[52:22] get two that could have a huge effect if there's so so many minor things in this ranking.
[52:30] Graduation rates, any time that it's not sitting at an IDA, or 99, we probably have a coding error that within the enrollment office.
[52:39] And the reason why I would leave room for like 98%, and 99% is because sometimes what happens is the way that people accounting data gets tracked.
[52:49] If a student doesn't enroll into another public school, then NDE might assume that that student has dropped out.
[52:56] But sometimes you might get a child that goes to like a private school and moves out of state.
[53:00] So there's always like a little bit of data in there that maybe by the time a transfer is an MDE,
[53:06] they can't, like they just don't know where that other student went.
[53:10] For the most part, we always get student records when a student leaves our district and every now and then,
[53:16] you know, that doesn't always happen so we're not able to record that.
[53:19] But I think we were probably able to have that cleaned up for this next cycle for this year
[53:24] and then also looking at ways for us to code our alternative high school programming
[53:30] allowed to.
[53:34] That's correct.
[53:35] That's correct.
[53:36] That's correct.
[53:37] Just real quick.
[53:40] I know Lindsey touched on, but then there is, we are asking, are seeking approval tonight.
[53:45] That's on the agenda for GEOs of volume of readings.
[53:50] So we were looking for that tonight.
[53:52] Where are there any questions about those curriculum eases?
[53:56] Okay.
[53:57] No.
[53:59] Let's move to the strategic planning update.
[54:04] We just hit on a lot of what I wanted to discuss.
[54:08] This is just an update because what we talked about in each of the respective committees
[54:14] is that we understand that there's still work to be done.
[54:18] We've developed the goals and initiatives which have been improved by the board.
[54:21] The action steps become more, more administrative of how are we going to accomplish these things.
[54:29] We did spend varying amounts of time in each committee on the action steps and digging into them a little bit.
[54:39] And we are well aware that what the next step is putting the accountability structure or the results and responsibilities structure around
[54:51] this. What we've committed to is to come back to the committees in September and building that out.
[54:58] This will also lead itself to our conversation about my goals. So we need to develop the
[55:05] measureables, the metrics, the dashboard around what these goals, how we're going to measure
[55:16] schools. And, you know, the private sector would call them KPIs, and that's appropriate.
[55:26] But what, you know, what are they going to look like, and what are we going to actually
[55:30] measure? A lot of the feedback has been, you know, we want quantitative measurements. In
[55:39] education, that's certainly inappropriate when we can talk about scores and budgets and
[55:44] there's numbers associated with that. But some of it is qualitative in nature and some of it
[55:51] is, are we doing it or aren't we? And we can have those discussions in the respective committees
[55:59] and then come back in September and October with the goal and you'll see it in the the superintendent's
[56:06] October 30, by October 31st, we'll have a comprehensive plan for both the strategic plan and
[56:17] goals subject to the conversations tonight.
[56:21] So, it wasn't my goal to go through each of these action steps tonight.
[56:24] We've been able to do that in committee.
[56:27] I am, I will tell you where we're going to and I'll say this in my superintendent remarks
[56:32] tonight. We're launching this strategic plan as it relates to the goals and initiatives
[56:37] next Monday. Next Tuesday. And I'm very excited about that. We've done a lot of work here.
[56:46] I think we're targeting the right areas. We have the right emphasis and we have something
[56:50] that will drive us in a strategic way for the next few years. And I think it will be fluid and
[56:58] adjustable as well, and we'll be able to adapt to the information and the data that we're going to measure and make
[57:06] improve continual improvement. So that's where we're at with that. Again, goals 1 and 2 are running through the curriculum and instruction committee.
[57:18] 3 is through the Strategic Planning Committee and goal 4 is through the Finance and Operations Committee
[57:24] with the goal for the discussion meeting to have the chairs report out what we came up with
[57:32] and administration to develop what it's actually going to look like.
[57:38] Any major questions on that?
[57:48] The next steps look like.
[57:49] So the next steps are to, in committee, the administration is working collaboratively right now to bring back to committees something for us to collaborate and respond to.
[58:01] What those KPIs will look like for each goal area.
[58:06] Again, there's so much in here.
[58:10] We need to caution ourselves about, you know, too many,
[58:15] to overwhelm ourselves or our community.
[58:19] But how can we make meaningful measurements
[58:22] to tell the one, hold ourselves accountable,
[58:26] to continue our improvement, and to tell our story.
[58:30] And be able to use that data to target and modify the plan
[58:37] as we move forward.
[58:39] That's consistent with the message that I want to talk about here.
[58:43] any other questions regarding strategic planning?
[58:51] Okay.
[58:53] They go into the goals and I do deeply.
[58:57] This is genuine. I deeply appreciate the feedback from those of you who read the superintendent's
[59:03] goals. What I've done? I have a revised proposal. I've printed what I'm dubbing polls proposal and I've
[59:14] incorporated your feedback as well, Lindsey, and then I revise proposal for each of you.
[59:20] So you will have a side-by-side analysis and then I want to just talk through these and
[59:28] kind of highlight if you get the pencil.
[59:31] So there's one that says superintendent district-wide smart goals and then there's one that says
[59:38] falls proposal.
[59:46] If you could Rebecca would get one as well. And then Jason, if you guys could.
[59:53] They're in the meeting room. Oh, they're in the meeting room.
[59:56] Okay, so you have them electronically too, because these are for...
[1:00:04] So, here's a couple things I just want to preface with these. One, I wholeheartedly agree that we need quantifiable measures. Okay, and there's no doubt about it. And I would, I readily admit that the first proposal lacked substantive measures. So, I am in total agreement that we need to get there. I do want to distinguish between the superintendent goals.
[1:00:32] I want to distinguish between the goals in the scorecard.
[1:00:38] We need from a governance standpoint to really focus on what are our key areas of emphasis and focus.
[1:00:46] And my original draft was based off of one of the work that we've been doing.
[1:00:50] The strategic plan is needs to be embedded in any of the superintendent's goals.
[1:00:55] I think we've accomplished that.
[1:00:57] The other two areas come directly from my evaluation last year, which was community engagement and financial stewardship, which also both happened to be riddled and embedded into the strategic plan.
[1:01:15] So if there's a word that we're probably going to overuse, or I'm going to overuse this year, it's going to be alignment.
[1:01:21] Okay, everything we're doing, our agendas and some of you have pointed this out, our agendas
[1:01:28] setting, our internal agendas, our cabinet meetings, our principal meetings, all of
[1:01:33] it's going to have a lens around what, what goal area are we focused on, what initiative,
[1:01:40] 1.1.
[1:01:41] I already saw it, this year, Todd's already built out his calendar for this year and it's
[1:01:48] This is 2.2, we're talking about 2.2 here and what does that mean about student engagement?
[1:01:55] So I'm excited about that alignment.
[1:01:58] I want what my goal would be tonight is my revision proposes perhaps a fewer measures with greater accountability.
[1:02:10] So I want to take a look at both side by side and then just come to a reconciliation.
[1:02:15] The other thing I am a little bit more keen on is, again, and I appreciate Paul, your evaluation standards that you, you put out highly effective effective developing and an effective and I can appreciate that method, but I want the board to remember that this is this piece, my, our goals are a piece of an overarching evaluation and it's only 15% of that evaluation.
[1:02:43] So I would kindly recommend that it be consistent with that rubric, which is effective developing and needing support.
[1:02:53] And it aligns with that, and then I want to orient it because Paul, I do appreciate you putting the 45 percent, 25 percent and 30 percent.
[1:03:03] I want to have conversation around the efficacy of that proposal as it relates to just being 15% of the overall proposal and how we might come to some sort of understanding about how we actually are going to measure that.
[1:03:21] So, if we want, we do have about 26 minutes if you guys want to take.
[1:03:26] Sometimes they're both on the computer to just evaluate and then we can maybe 10 minutes from now take
[1:03:34] Discuss where we want to go with them to finalize
[1:03:40] them. Is that fair
[1:03:48] guys read my email all right there?
[1:03:51] So you need me to overarachingly comment on what I
[1:03:55] Put together or has everyone read it?
[1:03:59] These are for me. These I just put them in charge
[1:04:03] I mean, I looked at it, so I haven't looked at the vision yet, and my overarching theme,
[1:04:10] which, say, is where articulated is, goals need to have measurables, and I appreciate
[1:04:17] you putting together the goal that I think you recognize.
[1:04:19] Now, we need some vegetables, and when we get to superintendent evaluation, we have to measure something.
[1:04:26] Now, the academic piece, right, one of the things I embed in here, again, we can go to this
[1:04:31] I mean, again, well, the board, but that's also embedded growth in, you know, in what, you
[1:04:38] know, I suggested, which at the end of the year we had a hard time coming up with a measurable
[1:04:44] growth community engagement.
[1:04:46] So, you know, it had some criteria, we just talked about it, regarding things we're looking
[1:04:51] at, community feedback, it's great to send out community feedback, but right, it's getting
[1:04:57] it back, seeing the ciphering it and then developing action planning and that and then the budget
[1:05:03] getting to a balanced budget, monitoring it throughout the year at any point in time when
[1:05:09] we're monitoring it, we see it discrepancy, what are we doing action plan, I mean, so, and
[1:05:15] then student achievement, I think last year we talked about this, which is fine, I think last
[1:05:20] year, right, the academic committee focused on putting together what the KPI's or the growth
[1:05:25] strategy was and I think now we need to action it like what are going to be our
[1:05:31] criteria in terms of growth based on those whatever the measurables that
[1:05:37] he has spent the year that's the theme in the three areas you know here that I
[1:05:42] think as a district to make sure that we're you know holding the district
[1:05:49] accountable with measurables that was my theme.
[1:05:56] So the good news is there was
[1:05:57] to disagreement on the U3 overarching. The feedback wasn't okay. These goal areas are appropriate.
[1:06:07] We agree on that. How do we make them smarter? How do we put measurements and timelines
[1:06:14] in place and then how are we going to evaluate that standard? And I don't think there's
[1:06:20] not major discrepancies. We set down today as a cabinet to go through this and say, okay,
[1:06:27] What's reasonable, how do we set ourselves up for success?
[1:06:30] And I do very much like the goal areas.
[1:06:34] I think it will focus our work in a line up
[1:06:36] with the strategic plan and coming up with those standards
[1:06:42] and those measurables are part of the work
[1:06:45] in the next month, month and a half is my proposal.
[1:06:48] I do want to mention one other thing.
[1:06:51] And this is important to me.
[1:06:52] And I think you and I had this conversation.
[1:06:54] And I fully appreciate the financial stewardship
[1:06:59] and forecasting.
[1:07:00] And you'll see my language differs a little bit.
[1:07:02] In the fact that I really want to move away
[1:07:06] from the balanced budget emphasis,
[1:07:15] and more to we
[1:07:17] already have a board policy of 15% fun balance,
[1:07:22] maintaining a 15th inherent in that is financial stewardship. So you guys already set that
[1:07:28] And why I say this?
[1:07:30] And I know this is public. It has a very, when we talk about goals 2 and 3 or mostly goal 3. It has a very significant impact on the culture of a district when your constant emphasis, when our constant emphasis is budget, budget balance, you know, we hear feedback, the feedback is okay, all they care about is money.
[1:07:57] And it really impacts the day-to-day functioning of the district.
[1:08:04] And given the reductions that we made last year, there's already a heightened fear amongst the district,
[1:08:13] which we're going to be quite frankly battling as we launch the strategic plan.
[1:08:18] And I think we get to the same thing.
[1:08:21] You know, with the reliability word, financial reliability, we want reliable numbers, we want
[1:08:29] a cadence of reporting, we want a structure that lends ourselves to good information and
[1:08:36] making adjustments without, with the underlying policy that's already in place of 15% fund balance
[1:08:44] and maintaining that, as opposed to the scents that,
[1:08:48] what are we going to do?
[1:08:49] And maybe it's semantics, maybe it's not,
[1:08:52] but I can tell you in practice and in culture,
[1:08:56] it has a detrimental impact.
[1:08:59] So, friendly, as you evaluate the language,
[1:09:03] that's used between the two.
[1:09:06] Yeah, I mean, we get a greater disagree on that.
[1:09:08] I think the fun balance policy, which is there,
[1:09:12] That's 16, you know, our front-bound policy is to prevent and help us when there are surprises and last year we had a surprise and we're lucky enough to be able to
[1:09:24] Eek in this surprise, you know, any organization with a public private, your goal should be revenue minus expenses equals zero.
[1:09:36] I'm sorry, I mean, you can't go into any year with the idea is, you know, we're going to operate potentially at a loss.
[1:09:46] That should be the ultimate goal is going into, and then anything, you know, at the end of the year, that becomes a surplus.
[1:09:53] That's great, goes into the rainy day fund, you know, the fund balance, but the goal should be at the beginning of the year revenue.
[1:09:59] minus expenses, you should not be budgeting to budget over revenue, right?
[1:10:06] Something happens, we're not aware, we're interested in it, so I'll leave the district,
[1:10:11] I mean, you know, but I'm saying that should be the ultimate goal.
[1:10:14] I mean, I don't think we've ever built a budget with the expectation that we're intentionally
[1:10:18] going to go to the red. I think anything that's happened has been, but that's the whole concept
[1:10:24] of a goal of a balanced budget is revenue, minus expensive, but that's all I'm saying.
[1:10:32] In your goal, that should be the goal.
[1:10:34] Go shouldn't be well.
[1:10:36] All right, plus or minus 700, I mean, we can't have that as a goal.
[1:10:40] Because I create angst.
[1:10:43] I mean, the reality is that we should be expensing to our revenue
[1:10:48] and then building a foundation on that.
[1:10:51] not, you know, I mean, it's unfortunate what's the result
[1:10:54] when we're having to go down when we lose 300,
[1:10:58] you know, 200 kids, or the roads are going down,
[1:11:01] but you can't, you don't want to be in a position
[1:11:04] where a future boards are left with recurring,
[1:11:10] where it's eventually by year four,
[1:11:13] definitely going to go below the fun balance.
[1:11:15] You have to get to that.
[1:11:16] I think that's what I think.
[1:11:17] That's why it's in here, and I agree,
[1:11:20] that three-year forecasting is important in the overarching goal of maintaining a 15 percent
[1:11:28] fund balance. That also provides flexibility with the variability that occurs within school
[1:11:35] budgeting. And that's why, you know, the balance budget I'm just telling you the negative
[1:11:43] connotation that has around that. And I don't disagree with you in practice. And that's certainly
[1:11:48] what we aim for, but given the verabilities and we don't know our revenues for a certain period
[1:11:53] of time, I think that's why in rightly so, the board put in an overarching 15% fund balance
[1:12:00] because it captures the board's desire to maintain fiscal responsibility and stewardship over
[1:12:09] the resources that we have. And if we never had that policy over the course, and I'm in on the
[1:12:13] last decade. And we had that in last year where we were, we wouldn't have had the ability
[1:12:20] to say, all right, we could fund a million, five, and still be a million, five, sure. I'm
[1:12:26] just saying, and feel like, you know, okay, you know, we can go into the next year as opposed to
[1:12:32] some of the districts that have been in financial crisis. I think having, you know, one
[1:12:39] years or things are sometimes up, sometimes down, you know, fluctuations that's
[1:12:45] understandable and time. But if we're assuming there's a structure, if there's
[1:12:49] a structural issue that we're just ignoring, which I'm not saying we are. But like
[1:12:53] that's the concern, you don't want to have a target that keeps us from just letting
[1:12:58] a structural issue continue on to until we get to the 15% and that have to have massive cuts.
[1:13:05] Which I think is what was behind all of the changes that were made, right?
[1:13:11] So structurally, I think we're trying to say how to ensure we're utilizing our resources
[1:13:17] that we have in the most effective and efficient way without, you know, saying what we really
[1:13:24] like this program or we like this thing, but you know, a budget for it, I think we have gone
[1:13:29] through that exercise, pretty extensively.
[1:13:36] So you're doing it gradually, you know, it's also fine.
[1:13:39] We don't have to, if we know we're going to get there to the balanced, you know, budget
[1:13:43] or plus or minus, you know, that's fine too, just don't want to have it continue to be
[1:13:49] a problem.
[1:13:53] I'm saying we need to make sure our semantics and our, um, the
[1:14:01] work, coincides with the culture we're trying to create too. And because it would be a far cry
[1:14:07] to, and I'm waiting on the numbers to suggest, at 19% from balance that we're somehow,
[1:14:15] you know, financially irresponsible or whatever. And so it's just, it's just a caution. I
[1:14:22] provide an alternative to that, that I think aligns with most of it, but I also think the emphasis
[1:14:31] is going to, we're going to need to change a little bit, regardless of how the goal ends
[1:14:38] up. And so we can have further dialogue on that as well.
[1:14:45] What
[1:14:49] I'm hearing is that if you emphasize a decline in enrollment in the budget all the time
[1:14:57] at this meeting, it's going to hurt everyone's feeling.
[1:15:00] I'm working here because they're going to jump ship. Thinking that recruitment assistance comes a lot more difficult.
[1:15:09] Yes. Well, I'm just speaking as an employee myself, if I heard that constantly as a leadership visit, the point, I'd be like, I don't really want to work here anymore, you know, it does hurt morale. And we are leaders of this organization.
[1:15:24] And you're the main leader, and I appreciate what you're saying.
[1:15:29] So I'm hearing what that, and maybe you can consider just a change in the language.
[1:15:35] Again, having a, I don't know how having a balanced budget is a cultural negative.
[1:15:41] I mean, I'm not saying, right, when it comes down to negotiations, we want to pair it.
[1:15:47] And we have right, we pair a teachers fairly, both at the bottom and the top level.
[1:15:52] I think we're proud of being on a top-paying districts, but I don't see any organization that says you want your revenue to
[1:16:00] match your expenses to be something that would be a cultural negative across any organization.
[1:16:06] I think they would be like, yes, that makes sense. Physical stewardship makes complete sense.
[1:16:11] So I disagree a hundred percent.
[1:16:15] Okay, well, but we're not talking about a corporate, I mean, I work in a corporate number
[1:16:20] I went to and I agree that that is how we see it, but we're talking about selling products
[1:16:26] or services or whatever, versus like getting grants and money from a government, we don't even
[1:16:31] know what it's going to be sometimes for months at a time, and people are doing their very best
[1:16:36] to proactively try to manage finances in a way that is conservative and appropriate.
[1:16:45] And again, we had a really weird year with things that happened, but one of the big things
[1:16:51] that happened was something that was like, you know, done with insurance and kind of something
[1:16:56] that no one was really forecasting really well in a way that more could be forecasted well.
[1:17:03] I mean you don't know, I guess my problem is if we're always chasing a balanced budget and we say
[1:17:10] we get to the end and we have something crazy that happens and it's minus 300 like now what's
[1:17:16] our rationale because it wasn't zero that it's a complete loss and we're going to ding
[1:17:21] him and you know I just don't I think yes we need to be looking every single month and I
[1:17:25] think you guys do that you're in the subcommittee so it is suspect that we should know in general
[1:17:31] things are happening and Rick's team stays on top of that to manage it, but to constantly
[1:17:38] have to be balanced budget when we're also saying we have to hit this specific number
[1:17:44] on US news and we have to do this. And then it's continuous improvement. Yeah, we want to
[1:17:50] get to a point of success, but I just my fear on that is if we're always saying balanced
[1:17:56] budget and we don't hit it. Then what does that mean?
[1:17:59] That means we need it. Like we did last year. We need it into our rainy day fund and to Lindsey's point,
[1:18:06] we don't want to be in a structural recurring deficit. That's what a value budget is. Is that we're not in a structural deficit
[1:18:13] where each year, which it's recurring, right? You know, we have 85% is our is basically people, right?
[1:18:26] structural deficit, then eventually it's going to get to a point where we're going to be in a crisis.
[1:18:31] I've been fortunate, been on the board 10 years, who've never been on a crisis.
[1:18:36] So to go to a balanced budget means we're financially stable, we're looking at it and
[1:18:40] we're not in a structural deficit where we're going to wake up when they aim to like some
[1:18:44] other districts where they have to lay off 30-40 percent of their workforce because the
[1:18:50] I mean, you know, you know, you know,
[1:18:52] fish clearly responsible over the course of a series of years.
[1:18:55] That's what I'm saying.
[1:18:57] Yeah, I guess I just feel like we've done a considerable amount
[1:19:00] of work to get us there.
[1:19:01] And so to me, when I hear make a balanced budget,
[1:19:03] it's like some huge monumental shift for this team,
[1:19:06] not this team, but that team to do versus keep managing.
[1:19:11] Your finances every month and if there are issues,
[1:19:14] we bring them up and figure it out,
[1:19:15] which is a part of the goal is to manage the budget
[1:19:19] and actuals, which I think was called out specifically, but just actuals, which is a normal
[1:19:23] thing for any organization. But when we say,
[1:19:29] the syntax in me is different. When you say,
[1:19:32] we need to create a zero budget or whatever it is. Like that sounds like a big lift and shift,
[1:19:37] which we just kind of did. And so I have concerns about that, about that language.
[1:19:43] Yeah, I'm trying to contextualize this. Are we talking about when we're creating a budget,
[1:19:48] it should be balanced. And then over time, if it shifts, then we adjust to it, or we're talking
[1:19:52] about, you start the year with the budget that's not balanced, because we have a fun balance.
[1:19:56] I'm going to understand what we're talking about here in this conduct.
[1:19:59] Yeah, and this contacts is, our goal should be that we start off at the end of the year that we're
[1:20:07] going to get to a balanced budget. And if there's things that happen, like happened last year,
[1:20:12] and we go to our fun balance, and we use that in reserve, and that's why I want to keep it
[1:20:18] that's 16%. So the goal should be, you know, we, again, best of our knowledge with all the information we have is revenues is going to, the end of the year revenue minus expenses will be zero.
[1:20:29] And then things will happen, you know, so something will happen, a grandma will come in, whatever it would be, and we go into the rainy day fund.
[1:20:36] And if so happens, it's a year that amounts to balance budget more comes in, goes into the rainy day fund.
[1:20:42] So what's the differentiating line between the two proposals that doesn't do that?
[1:20:50] I didn't see any major, I think it's the implementation.
[1:20:55] I just want to be cautious and it was a word of caution for me that we need to.
[1:21:01] And if you look at 4.3 in our strategic plan, there is, we have worked to do on how we're going to articulate financial stewardship as well.
[1:21:12] And perhaps that's where this work lies, because, yes, we need, I think we all agree stewardship
[1:21:19] is important in revenue-equaling expenditures.
[1:21:22] But I think there's also an awareness that, to your point, we're a school district, the
[1:21:27] variability is that occur, our a little bit unique.
[1:21:32] We don't have control, we don't have direct control of our revenue source, and expenditures
[1:21:37] we can't always adapt based on the services we have to provide at a given point in time.
[1:21:43] So the budget that's developed is just a goal and a snapshot in time and to your point
[1:21:50] and I think the good work and that you've identified and I think identified you've
[1:21:55] agreed to is that what is the cadence of reporting, what is the structure of reporting,
[1:22:02] what are the indicators we're going to look at for financial health and that's important.
[1:22:07] the routine. We're annually audited.
[1:22:13] So that's one indicator. We give monthly reports. That's
[1:22:16] another indicator. So we had the information available. But what is it in the committees that we're
[1:22:24] going to want to look at to make sure that we're meeting those standards? And one thing that was
[1:22:30] Are particularly, is this variance percentage of, you know, what, what did we say we're going to have and what did we actually had?
[1:22:37] We do that annually. Is there an opportunity to do that, uh, some I annually, perhaps?
[1:22:44] I think, did you?
[1:22:45] I sort of with the original one in this one, the difference is when I say balanced budget first, you could not like think about it.
[1:22:51] You could monitor the budget and say, yep, we're not, you know, we're not, you know, million five and a whole two million a month.
[1:22:56] It's fine, but if you're like a million five and a whole two million a whole two million a whole two million
[1:23:01] I mean that's monitoring it, but if your goal is to what we did last year to a balanced budget
[1:23:07] Then you look internally on what are things that are going to be as in, you know
[1:23:12] I mean everything's disruptive, least disruptive, whether it's what we did with the, you know, the farming
[1:23:18] I'm just saying programs to get us to
[1:23:20] Right-sized and I think that we should always be guaranteed getting to right-sized as as an organization
[1:23:31] If you're a for so focused on a balanced budget that you okay, you're a little off now
[1:23:36] We have to have this drastic action
[1:23:38] Is that
[1:23:39] We're a family cross the fear and that's the that's the environment that's
[1:23:43] It's unintentionally created when we have such an emphasis on it.
[1:23:48] And look, I can administratively adapt the messages and still adhere to a goal.
[1:23:55] And I guess I'm indicating that that's what I'm going to do.
[1:24:00] But I also, from the governance standpoint, into your point, what we say here and what we do
[1:24:12] culture of the district and the feedback I've gotten is that that was that's the
[1:24:20] large emphasis and that's all we care about. Now if anybody listens to tonight
[1:24:25] they know we also care about student success academic rigor all of those
[1:24:29] things so people will cherry pick with you know further narrative but I know
[1:24:37] part of the governance is budget so you guys can't show you from that
[1:24:41] responsibility nor can I, but I'm just the emphasis of it is something that we need to
[1:24:46] challenge ourselves on if we don't want to work against ourselves as it relates to culture.
[1:24:52] I think the reality, whether the organization or the community or whoever is listening,
[1:24:57] it's unfortunate,
[1:24:59] but each year and we did a forecast for losing students.
[1:25:03] I mean, the reality is that whether it's growth rate, people moving out, people not staying,
[1:25:10] what we're living students, budget is an important part.
[1:25:13] So we can do the things that we need to do.
[1:25:17] And there are a couple of years,
[1:25:19] and I've been on the board for a decade,
[1:25:21] a couple of years that we got a lot of money.
[1:25:23] They're going to cut, you know, that has stopped.
[1:25:26] And now we're managing to what we're getting from Lansing
[1:25:30] and we're managing to decrease enrollment.
[1:25:33] So we have to focus on it.
[1:25:35] So we can pay our teachers, one of the highest in Oakland County
[1:25:39] if not the state of Michigan.
[1:25:41] So we have to focus internally on what can we do
[1:25:43] to make sure we can pay our 85% which is, you know,
[1:25:49] our staff competitively or not what they deserve.
[1:25:54] So.
[1:25:54] So we only have four minutes before that, how do you want to,
[1:26:00] how do we want to, again, there's not,
[1:26:03] I don't think there's necessarily material difference.
[1:26:06] I do want you guys to talk about the evaluation standard,
[1:26:10] because that is concerning to me.
[1:26:14] And then the smart key measures in such I am open.
[1:26:20] I mean, this is a collaborative effort.
[1:26:22] The superintendent contract, I appreciate that we've
[1:26:27] got it down to three, and alignment with the contract.
[1:26:31] And I think we're in the three right areas.
[1:26:37] And we can figure out how to finalize that.
[1:26:41] I think last year we did the board did approve the officially approved, is that right, Rebecca?
[1:26:49] Officially approved it, so at the appropriate time, I want to know.
[1:26:53] Now, contractually, it's also, and we can talk about the reconciliation of this.
[1:26:57] It requires us to have established goals by February, my contract is.
[1:27:03] I don't know where that time, I do know where that time line comes from, but that's not the
[1:27:07] timeline that we've established, and I think this is more appropriate.
[1:27:12] So I think we're in the right ballpark, I think we can finalize these in the next month.
[1:27:19] You guys have them.
[1:27:21] We're also, I think the committee meetings will allow for more discussion around the
[1:27:27] actual metrics within the strategic plan that might align better with this.
[1:27:34] Yeah, I mean, these are your goals.
[1:27:36] I want you to feel like they're, you know.
[1:27:38] Just a clarification.
[1:27:38] They're our goal.
[1:27:39] I mean, it does require board entertainment goals and I do appreciate the feedback and the work
[1:27:46] that's been done with them.
[1:27:47] I think we've enhanced them through this conversation.
[1:27:49] I think we've enhanced them through the dialogue that occurred.
[1:27:52] So, and I think we're in material agreement.
[1:27:57] So, you're okay on the goals itself,
[1:28:02] like the criteria, this is 15 percent,
[1:28:04] what's the other 85 percent?
[1:28:07] The other domain areas.
[1:28:09] Which governments?
[1:28:13] Governance.
[1:28:13] These are communications,
[1:28:17] strategic staff.
[1:28:21] It's the rubric.
[1:28:22] the growth and I don't know the growth is part of it, but it's the
[1:28:26] evidence of performance that we provide through the matrix and non-studying
[1:28:31] growth that we went through in junta and we do not have any flexibility in
[1:28:35] pumping that's something it's it's a prescribed form of a 15% or this
[1:28:39] superintendent goals you guys adopted the it makes the or the M.A.
[1:28:43] Yeah, so it was a matter of this and then just changing this to 15% is what you'd be happy
[1:28:50] Yeah, there's some some something. It's exciting. I would encourage you to look through I think there's
[1:28:55] differences
[1:28:56] Get the different sheening elements kind of laid out because it's hard to there's a lot here
[1:29:01] Yeah, hard to look at and say even with the red line. It's gonna be all red
[1:29:05] I could be good to
[1:29:07] Understand what differences are and the rationale so differences
[1:29:09] It's like four versus six
[1:29:12] Why
[1:29:17] It would have been nice to have a red line, yeah, three, yeah, we can provide that.
[1:29:22] Red line plus an understanding of what the difference is.
[1:29:26] Yep, yep.
[1:29:27] I will get that out to the board.
[1:29:36] Yeah, let's see how we can have some time review it and go through it.
[1:29:41] I don't know if it's something to bring through the committee, so that we can have discussion between
[1:29:46] you know, and then we'll die of alcohol.
[1:29:47] Cause I don't want to wait.
[1:29:48] Yeah, I think we'll month.
[1:29:49] We'll go go die of alcohol.
[1:29:50] Yeah, I want to make sure you guys are comfortable going and die.
[1:29:53] I don't want to re-hash the social media.
[1:29:54] Make sure you're comfortable in September, leading into that meeting to take action.
[1:30:00] And I think, again, I think we can get there. I don't think there's terrell, but we'll provide that. Thank you, Jason.
[1:30:07] Okay. All right.
[1:30:10] Let's take a few minutes recess to get set up for the second part of this.
[1:30:15] We'll come back.
[1:30:26] The August 24th, regular meeting of Bloomfield Hill Schools Board of Education.
[1:30:30] We're going to add a 3A, which is a pledge of allegiance, so if everybody can stand up.
[1:31:01] Good
[1:31:09] evening members of the board superintendent and administration. It's my pleasure to be here to recognize Bluefield Hill
[1:31:16] school student, Lillian Tang, stand right here. So the reason I get to recognize Lillian
[1:31:25] tonight is because she was the winner of the Sutton Foster Awards at the Morton Center
[1:31:30] in East Lansing back in May 31, based on the adjudication by the Sutton Foster Award Judges
[1:31:36] who attended the Bloomfield Hills High School, 2025, fall music, all the Hello Girls, Lillian
[1:31:43] received the nomination to attend the annual workshop audition and showcase at the Morton
[1:31:47] Center in East Lansing, Michigan.
[1:31:50] The showcase consisted of high school musical theater
[1:31:52] nominees from all across the state of Michigan.
[1:31:56] Lillian then competed on the national stage
[1:31:58] after winning at the state level.
[1:32:00] There's a male winner in a female winner
[1:32:02] that could to move on to the national competition.
[1:32:04] So she traveled then to New York City
[1:32:07] to compete in the Jimmy Awards as the female nominee
[1:32:11] from the state of Michigan joining students
[1:32:13] from across the nation who won similar awards ceremonies
[1:32:17] with in their home states. So the Jimmy Awards took place on June 22nd in Lillian
[1:32:22] represented not only Bluefield Hills High School and did a fantastic job, but also the
[1:32:28] entire state of Michigan, finishing as one of the top students in the competition. So we are
[1:32:34] extremely honored and proud of her accomplishments. So please join me in recognizing Lillian Tang
[1:34:16] didn't have to watch the Facebook, it was really good, it was great, it makes
[1:34:25] me feel
[1:34:26] kind of underwhelming with my Q80 theater performance as I did, I didn't get on the national
[1:34:33] stage, but there's still time, I've never seen ever, we'll go to item five, which is
[1:34:42] superintendents report. Yes, just a quick few brief reports annual registration is open.
[1:34:50] I'll be HS families should complete annual registration each summer. We encourage anyone
[1:34:55] within coming kindergarten or DK students to complete the online enrollment process and we look forward
[1:35:00] to welcoming them on our first day of school, which is in a couple of weeks. It is very important that
[1:35:07] families do take the time to do this in register as we are in the planning mode of
[1:35:11] setting classes and such, so it's a imperative that we know who's coming.
[1:35:21] Welcome back to the IA. It's been a great welcome back with the IA students and staff
[1:35:26] last week. They enjoyed their first days of school and things are off to a roaring start,
[1:35:32] so excited to have them back and in action. We'll welcome our staff back, all of our staff back
[1:35:38] Tuesday, September 1st, we look forward to the gathering in the district, the entire district team
[1:35:45] for our annual welcome back day. I'll be sharing the presentation to set the tone and launch our
[1:35:52] strategic plan. So, very excited. I think you've all been invited to that. Hopefully, you can
[1:35:59] make it out. Well, I think our teams are in action right now, but our kids will be in action that
[1:36:06] two will have some performances and it's eyes a energizing day. So looking forward to that.
[1:36:13] And then after that we will welcome our kids back on Tuesday, September 8th and I am very excited
[1:36:18] about that. As excited as we get to end the school year, we get equally as excited to start the
[1:36:23] school year. So many good things on the horizon. Our kids are already, as I mentioned,
[1:36:29] they're already at it with their co-curricular and extracurricular activities. I age back in action
[1:36:33] And just so much to be excited for launching our strategic plan and focusing on Bloomfield Hill School's future.
[1:36:41] So looking forward to it and looking forward to launching it next week.
[1:36:49] Item six is the board president report.
[1:36:53] I don't have too much.
[1:36:54] I just wanted to kind of follow up.
[1:36:56] We had a good discussion earlier with with regard to the rankings specifically US news.
[1:37:02] So we all kind of talked about the fact that Bloomfield Hills got ranked 31st.
[1:37:09] So some people say, well I want this or why I can't be this and I think that's it's
[1:37:15] important to go a little further and say what have we done and two years ago we were
[1:37:20] 39th the year prior we were 35th now we're 31st so it's an eight point jump.
[1:37:30] And for people that look at that ranking and see a number, it's important, I also know that behind that number is data sets that are older.
[1:37:39] And a lot of factors that don't go into it that I think makes Bloomfield Hills high school and our whole community, amazing whether it's our arts or robotics, the teachers that we have, the administrators, we don't know any of that.
[1:37:54] we just know the data that's in our report, and we all, we had a good discussion about this
[1:37:58] earlier about the data that we know that's there, and we're tracking that a lot faster
[1:38:02] than U.S. News tracks it certainly. We track it way faster. We're not two to three years
[1:38:10] older. And it's also not something that we say we're just satisfied with a number, and
[1:38:17] we don't have room for improvement. We know we do. We think there's opportunities that we can
[1:38:22] amazing things, but not necessarily a chase a number, but to improve educational outcomes
[1:38:29] for our students. We did that by creating more access in terms of classes, in terms of having
[1:38:38] more students take an AP exam, which was a challenge before. We just didn't have that kind of
[1:38:43] a culture where students were said, you know, we're told rather to take this class, and then
[1:38:47] also sign up for this exam. It's really important you should take it and it'll help you
[1:38:51] your college career we didn't have that we do now and we've seen the the result of that so
[1:38:56] I think kudos to our administrators our teachers our students everybody that's working on this
[1:39:03] it is certainly a work in progress it's an important goal for us as a board so I just I want people
[1:39:09] in the community to see that number and wonder to know that it's just one thing we look at we look at a
[1:39:15] lot more we look at what happens every single day our teachers look at how to ensure that our
[1:39:21] students, every single student is reaching their full academic capabilities and potentials.
[1:39:29] Encouraging, it's great to see that, great to see improvement.
[1:39:32] And I think it's a good point for us to look at in terms of our strategic plan and what we're going.
[1:39:37] So I just wanted to comment on that a little bit since we had a good rich discussion.
[1:39:42] We'll go out at 7, public comment. I don't think there's anyone here.
[1:39:47] So we'll go on to item A, which is the consent agenda trustee noble.
[1:39:54] Well, I assume I don't have a chance to get all the documentation ahead under consent agenda.
[1:40:00] So I'm going to move the Board of Education to approve the recommendations detailed in the consent agenda as presented.
[1:40:10] Yep, so there are a number of things there.
[1:40:13] Any discussion about any of the items in the consent agenda?
[1:40:17] No, we'll move to a vote.
[1:40:19] All those in favour?
[1:40:20] All right.
[1:40:21] Pass these five zero.
[1:40:23] I'm going to board business, which is 9A.
[1:40:26] They request to approve K5 Literacy adoption.
[1:40:30] Can I get a motion?
[1:40:31] I move the Board of Education to approve the volume,
[1:40:34] reading, NGOs, decodables, curriculum adoption, and to purchase the resources to support
[1:40:39] the program in the amount of $238,601 in 91 cents to be paid from the general fund,
[1:40:46] supported by a 35M funding as presented.
[1:40:51] I was like that.
[1:40:53] All right.
[1:40:55] I know this was talked about rather from the curriculum
[1:40:59] and instruction committee, and you, obviously,
[1:41:01] had time to dig into that and present your recommendation
[1:41:06] to approve this.
[1:41:07] Is there any other discussion about this?
[1:41:10] One thing I've been
[1:41:14] nourishing of the funds
[1:41:15] is for the access to the electronic geos discoverable
[1:41:20] the coding system. It does look like that's not something that people spend more than 2.5
[1:41:27] hours on a week, which is kind of what we're allowed for the lower elementary school.
[1:41:32] Looks like a fantastic program that students can utilize both at home and in school.
[1:41:36] So I just thought that was still consistent with kind of what our plans are and look like a great program.
[1:41:47] I'm spawning to a text, I, I, the one thing I didn't bring up, I should have brought it before, and you guys spelled it out with 35M, the funding for this.
[1:42:02] In terms of length of time, like for the program versus funding, I mean, I know we never know how, if it's recurring and how often or do we have any kind of idea of, like, how long this would be used and what we could expect in the future for funding for something like this.
[1:42:18] Yeah,
[1:42:21] how did that go? Arts and letters a little bit more. These, which we approved back in June of the grant,
[1:42:27] the 35 that the school year 206 was much larger than what we were anticipated.
[1:42:32] Okay. So these are some of the add-up things, which is going to be more of like a one-time cost.
[1:42:38] So we won't be coming back for them, but the arts and letters, we do want to, there is a reoccurring cost for that.
[1:42:46] and soon as 35, and the school year 27 comes out,
[1:42:51] what we will do is we'll try to book yours two and three
[1:42:53] four into that.
[1:42:55] Just like we did with Core 95, if you remember,
[1:42:58] we were able to back-rank with solar,
[1:43:00] we were able to do four years worth of Core 95,
[1:43:03] and it has more consumables.
[1:43:05] Okay.
[1:43:05] Arts and letters as I have as many consumables,
[1:43:08] but there are, there's a subscription fee.
[1:43:10] So as soon as we know more about 35,
[1:43:13] and the school year 27,
[1:43:14] And we'll try to, depending on how large that opportunity is,
[1:43:18] I'll try to put here's two, three, and extend that out as far as possible.
[1:43:23] For any
[1:43:26] other questions, all right, move to a vote, all is in favor?
[1:43:31] Aye.
[1:43:32] Passes five, zero, go to nine B, which is the request to approve additional contingency bid package 13 for robotics renovations.
[1:43:40] It's our motion.
[1:43:45] third chain.
[1:43:47] It completes the Bloom and West World Partics Relevations.
[1:43:50] paid for the Bonphin represented. All
[1:43:53] right. Any
[1:43:54] discussion on a nine B. All
[1:43:58] right. We're
[1:43:58] going to vote always in favor. All right.
[1:44:01] Pass this 500.
[1:44:03] On to 9 C,
[1:44:04] which is the request for final reading. And adoption of board policy
[1:44:08] updates. So your motion. I've
[1:44:11] heard the board application
[1:44:12] approve.
[1:44:12] to change the board policy, or recommend it by legal counsel as presented.
[1:44:18] Any discussion?
[1:44:19] I know we've all had a chance very thoroughly to look at this.
[1:44:23] So, and I know people had a dialogue.
[1:44:25] I appreciate that being able to get your questions out there.
[1:44:27] Anything else on that update prior to approval?
[1:44:33] I think we've looked at this several times.
[1:44:35] It's consistent with what the statutory requirements are.
[1:44:38] I think a lot of thought has been going into this.
[1:44:40] And then beyond just this policy going into the implementation,
[1:44:45] I think there's been a lot of great work on that.
[1:44:47] So I appreciate it, everything we have men's definitely doing.
[1:44:49] Yeah, the committees have done a great job of taking to this deeper than what we could do here.
[1:44:56] At the board table, I think, so that's really helpful in those situations.
[1:45:00] All right, all those in favor? I've done passes 5-0, and we'll go to item 10 unless there's any other, no good. All right, I don't have any adjournment. Thank you.