Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:03]
Meeting of the Michigan Board of State canvassers for the 24th today, 25th, or September 25th, 2026 is called to order. Good morning. Another full room. It's great to see everybody this morning. We've got a very limited agenda. I guess we start right out with a consideration of the meeting minutes for the August 24th, 2026 meeting.
[0:31]
move to approve. Second.
[0:34]
It's been moved and approved. All in favor?
[0:37]
Aye. Opposed? No.
[0:41]
Okay. So before we continue here, we have items two, three, four, and five.
[0:48]
Are all petitions regarding this vision, correct?
[0:55]
So there's a couple ways we can do this, but here's how we're going to do it.
[0:59]
I'm going to ask Director Brader to read each of those four and then he's going to read
[1:07]
those all at once.
[1:09]
We still have to, we still have to vote on each of them individually, but just so that
[1:13]
we don't end up with a lot of wasted time and repeats.
[1:16]
We're going to read them all at once and then as a reader, you're the only one here speaking
[1:23]
for it.
[1:24]
We'll then have you come up, let you talk to it, and then once you're finished, then the board will deliberate individually on each of the four and take motions.
[1:34]
Does that work for you?
[1:36]
Work for everybody here?
[1:46]
We're going to actually vote on each of the four, but we're going to read all four of them at once, and then we will have the discussion with you.
[1:54]
You can speak, but you are in fact speaking to all four.
[1:57]
So if you speak to one individually, let us know when you talk to that so that we can mark it.
[2:04]
Perfect.
[2:06]
Director Brader, would you read through the petitions?
[2:11]
Yes, recall number one.
[2:14]
The reasons for recall printed on the petition are between July 24th, 2025 and June 3rd, 2026.
[2:21]
Antrim County clerk, Victoria Bishop changed several voter status codes in the qualified voter file to cancel.
[2:26]
For example, Bishop changed six voter records in Mansellona Township to cancel on January 9th,
[2:31]
January 13th, January 23rd, January 27th, January 29th, and April 16th, 2026.
[2:38]
The reasons for recall printed on the recall petition number two are between July 24th, 2025, and June 3rd, 2026.
[2:46]
Interim County clerk for Victoria Bishop changed voter status codes and the qualified voter file to cancel.
[2:50]
For example, Bishop changed six voter records in Mancillin Township to cancel on January 9th, January 13th, January 23rd, January 27th, January 29th, and April 16th, 2026.
[3:01]
The Township clerks responsible for those voter records had not asked Bishop to make those changes on their behalf.
[3:07]
The reasons for recouper into the on position number three are on January 9th, January 13th, January 23rd, January 27th, January 29th, and April 16th, 2026.
[3:18]
Interim County clerk Victoria Bishop changed the voters status codes of six
[3:21]
mansellon and township voters in the qualified voter file to cancel the reasons
[3:26]
were recouple printed on position number four our January 9th January 13th
[3:31]
sorry let me start over on January 9th January 13th January 23rd January 27th
[3:37]
January 29th and April 16th 2026. Interim County clerk Victoria Bishop changed
[3:41]
the voters status codes of six mansellon and township voters in the qualified
[3:44]
by the voter file to cancel.
[3:46]
The township clerk is responsible for those records,
[3:48]
had not asked Bishop to make those changes on their behalf.
[3:59]
You state your name and spell it for the clerk,
[4:01]
and also you have to push the little button at the base,
[4:04]
but you know all that.
[4:07]
You've been here before.
[4:09]
Thank you.
[4:12]
My name is Ashley Arita, A-S-H-L-E-Y.
[4:17]
Arita is A-R-E-E-D-A.
[4:29]
Thank you, board members.
[4:30]
at the center of all four petitions are six voter records, six states, one township, and one
[4:39]
resulting status. Council. Council states that this board is not deciding whether the
[4:46]
changers were authorized or wise and is not conducting a trial on whether every allegation
[4:53]
is true, and we agree. But much of the opposition asks the board to accept Bishop's legal
[5:01]
justification for one of the six changes and turn that defense into a reason to reject
[5:09]
all four petitions. As unclear, a defense is not ambiguity. Bishop's detailed response
[5:20]
Once identifies the six mancelona records, the six states, the April 16 deceased voter record,
[5:29]
and the township request issue, her ability to present such a specific defense strongly
[5:37]
supports the conclusion that the conduct is identifiable.
[5:42]
Council argues that the April 16 change was required because it involved a deceased
[5:48]
voter, but Michigan law distinguishes between the county clerk initiating the deceased
[5:56]
voter process and the township clerk reviewing the information and completing the cancellation.
[6:04]
These petitions describe a change to cancel, not simply the initiation of township review.
[6:12]
Even if Bishop believes that change was justified, disagreement about justification does not make the action unclear, turning to the individual formations.
[6:26]
Petition 1 describes the broader course of conduct, provides a fixed time period, and identifies 6 dated men's aloneer examples.
[6:35]
Petition 2 identifies the same course and adds the factual circumstances that the responsible
[6:43]
township clerks had not requested the changes.
[6:47]
This is additional factual context, not a declaration that the conduct was illegal.
[6:56]
Petition 3 and 4 eliminate the open-ended objection entirely, both contain a closed set.
[7:04]
But exactly six voters, six states, Mancelona Township, the qualified voter file, and the
[7:13]
resulting status cancel.
[7:16]
Petition 4 adds the fact that responsible Township clerk had not requested those changes.
[7:24]
Whether Bishop believes a request was legally necessary is a defense to the conduct, not
[7:32]
uncertainty about what happened. Council sites and earlier petition involving the Secretary
[7:39]
of State. That petition mentioned two different processes, investigation and resolution, and
[7:47]
did not clearly identify which one was being challenged. There is no comparable either or problem
[7:55]
here. Petitions three and four expressly include all six changes. Council also raises
[8:04]
a placement objection, specific to petition two. If the board believes that creates a
[8:13]
form issue, it should address that petition separately. It proves no basis to reject petitions
[8:20]
1, 3, or 4.
[8:23]
Finally, the differences between the differences identified
[8:28]
in petition 3 involve punctuation, capitalization,
[8:33]
and formatting.
[8:34]
They do not change a date, voter, action, or status.
[8:39]
I agree that the board should reproduce the exact approved
[8:43]
language in its determination.
[8:45]
That resolves the administrative concern
[8:48]
and without turning a comma into a clarity defect.
[8:52]
These petitions give the board several formulations to consider.
[8:58]
A concern about one version should not be transferred
[9:01]
to a different version that eliminates it.
[9:05]
And we're not asking this board to endorse a recall today.
[9:10]
Approval only means that the words are factual in form
[9:14]
are sufficiently clear and eligible to move forward through the process.
[9:20]
The board decides whether the words are clear.
[9:24]
If that standard is met,
[9:26]
Antrim County voters decide the merits.
[9:29]
I respectfully ask the board to evaluate each petition independently,
[9:35]
and approve every version that satisfies the law.
[9:39]
Thank you very much.
[9:42]
Board members, do you have questions or comments for?
[9:47]
I do.
[9:48]
I have Mr. Rita.
[9:50]
You may have noticed in opposing counsel's documents over the past couple of days,
[9:55]
he accused you of not filing things timely.
[9:58]
Right.
[9:59]
Could you explain to us and we can check with the board.
[10:02]
But I trust you when things were filed and sure what he's referring to.
[10:06]
Sure.
[10:07]
So the first date of our initial entire filing packet was sent out on September 14, I believe.
[10:16]
And then I sent out additional supplemental materials on September 19 via email.
[10:25]
I believe there were a couple of days in between when the original email that I sent the board
[10:35]
was then forwarded to the Victoria Bishop's Council.
[10:43]
So I think he received it a bit later than when I actually sent it on the 19th.
[10:52]
Okay.
[10:53]
So you didn't send in any other evidence or documents after the 19th?
[10:57]
No.
[10:57]
No.
[10:59]
Okay.
[10:59]
Thank you.
[11:02]
Mr. Rita, you want us to consider each of these and make a determination on each.
[11:09]
If we determine that one was clear, do you still want the other three?
[11:15]
I do.
[11:16]
I think that would be great.
[11:18]
That way we would have multiple options to choose from one we go back and meet with the
[11:26]
committee.
[11:27]
If that's okay with you all.
[11:30]
Yes,
[11:34]
so it's my understanding that if we approve four or three, whatever, you would then decide which one you prefer and that would be the one that is submitted to the bureau when you are circulated.
[11:49]
Exactly.
[11:50]
Okay.
[11:50]
I
[11:54]
do note I did read a correspondence from Ms. Bishop's attorney who is, as you say,
[12:03]
saying that one of the cancellations was one that she was required to make because the voter was deceased.
[12:11]
That's right.
[12:13]
I think whether that's true or not, it doesn't make it unclear.
[12:19]
Exactly.
[12:20]
So clarity is not necessarily truthfulness, which is a strange thing about recall, but we're
[12:30]
looking for clarity and not necessarily accuracy.
[12:36]
So it could be factually clear, and if, in fact, she had the obligation herself to do that,
[12:45]
that would be her defense.
[12:47]
Is that what you're saying?
[12:48]
Yes.
[12:49]
Yes.
[12:49]
If she had the obligation herself to do that, she could make that known during the recall process.
[12:58]
But either way, it is clear, we make it very clear to Ms. Bishop and to the voters.
[13:11]
That these are, right, changes that she made in the vote of my vote, whether they, whether she should have or not have,
[13:18]
That's not the issue, the issue is that she did, at least that's my understanding, right?
[13:25]
Yes.
[13:29]
Okay.
[13:29]
You folks have, you want to discuss, can we maybe take these, now we do have to actually look at them individually, can we take these one by one?
[13:39]
If we look at the first petition, which is item two on your agenda,
[13:47]
discussion?
[13:51]
I believe that it's clear.
[13:52]
In fact, I would say at this point in our discussion that I think all four of the petitions
[13:59]
are clear. Each of them sets forth actions taken by the officer whose recall is sought,
[14:10]
specifically identifies those actions. So I think each of them is clear.
[14:18]
But I know we have to rule on each and Ms. Rita wants us to consider each and so she submitted
[14:26]
them to us and we need to do that.
[14:28]
Thank you.
[14:30]
Ms. Kelly?
[14:31]
Yeah, I agree the first reason for recall is clear and I believe it's factual as well.
[14:53]
I'm actually inclined to might you know we all get favorite right so rather than talk about clarity first of all
[14:58]
I would say the ones that are
[15:00]
We are the most clear to me are the second and the fourth.
[15:09]
I also believe that the first one is, the first petition is also clear. The only one that I would probably look sideways that is the third where it simply, to me, it's just, it's not clear enough.
[15:28]
Yeah, I tend to agree.
[15:30]
I mean, the one that I think is the best is the second one.
[15:33]
But I know we're going through them individually.
[15:35]
But to me, that one gives the most evidence and gives the most information for a signer
[15:45]
to understand what's going on.
[15:47]
Okay.
[15:48]
I would also, I would like to make one point just so it's on the record with Ms. Bishop's
[15:54]
attorney who was concerned about our 48-hour rule and you've already spoken a
[15:59]
little to that but I do want to clarify that as one as an individual board member
[16:03]
reviewing all of this material I didn't look at your at your pieces that had
[16:09]
come in from the from the township clerks. Sure. Not not not
[16:13]
ostensibly not because it was 48 hours but because I had everything I needed
[16:17]
already so I do want to put that on there because I know this Bishop's attorney
[16:23]
had specifically called that out and lately we seem to be considering the 48 hour rule in a lot of meetings.
[16:34]
So, yeah, that's on the record.
[16:37]
If we have any more conversation on these that we need to make, that we need to.
[16:43]
No, I don't.
[16:45]
Do you folks feel like we're ready to just work through the motions?
[16:48]
Yes.
[16:49]
And I would ask for a motion for item 2, which is petition number 1.
[16:56]
I move that the Board of State canvassers determine that the reasons for recall printed on petition number 1, submitted by Ashley Arita against Andrewm County Clerk Victoria Bishop on September 14th, 2026.
[17:09]
our factual and sufficiently clear and based on Bishop's conduct in office because it sets for specific
[17:18]
actions, which he took on specific dates.
[17:23]
Support.
[17:25]
And moved and supported, all in favor?
[17:27]
Aye.
[17:28]
Aye.
[17:31]
No opposing, I would ask.
[17:32]
We move on to petition number two.
[17:35]
Do I have a motion?
[17:39]
I move that the Board of State canvassers determine that the reasons for recall printed on
[17:44]
petition to submitted by Ashley Gerrida against Antrim County Clerk Victoria Bishop on September 14th, 2026, are factual and sufficiently clear and based on Bishops Conducting Office, because the language provides states and reasons for Victoria Bishop's I'm going to strike that I move that the Board of State canvassers determine that the reasons for recall printed on petition.
[18:14]
commission one submitted by Ashley
[18:16]
Eureda against Antrim County
[18:18]
clerk Victoria Bishop on September
[18:20]
14, 2026 are factual and sufficiently
[18:24]
clear and based on Bishop's conduct
[18:26]
in office because dates are provided
[18:29]
and the conduct is provided very
[18:33]
clearly.
[18:35]
Excuse me.
[18:36]
Did I hear you say petition one?
[18:38]
Oh, we have to redo that when we're
[18:40]
not.
[18:40]
We've already voted on petition one.
[18:42]
I did say that.
[18:59]
I moved at the Board of State canvassers determined that the reasons for recall printed
[19:03]
on petition two submitted by Ashley Eureda against Antrim County clerk Victoria Bishop
[19:09]
on September 14, 2026, our factual and sufficiently clear and based on Bishop's conduct and office
[19:16]
because dates are provided and the conduct is provided clearly.
[19:21]
And moved.
[19:22]
I would second that.
[19:23]
Yes.
[19:24]
And moved and seconded.
[19:26]
Hall in favor?
[19:28]
Aye.
[19:30]
Being that there are no opposed, we will move on to petition three.
[19:34]
Do I have a motion?
[19:39]
Well, we're going to do this again.
[19:41]
Are you...
[19:42]
Let me ask you a question before you try to read a motion.
[19:44]
Are you also having an issue with the material on your screen that it's not there for this meeting?
[19:50]
No, I'm not.
[19:51]
Okay, just making sure.
[19:52]
Or do you don't need Mr. Percasey's machine for that?
[19:56]
Yes, I do.
[20:01]
Yeah, that's fine.
[20:02]
I think technical issues.
[20:04]
So bear with it or so, yeah.
[20:06]
This is what happens when you submit for petitions at once.
[20:09]
Okay.
[20:11]
Yeah, okay.
[20:13]
I move that the Board of State canvassers determine that the reasons for recall printed on Petition 3 submitted by Ashley Eureda against
[20:20]
Annterham County Clerk Victoria Bishop on September 14, 2026 are factual and sufficiently clear and based on Bishops Conduct and Office because dates are provided and the conduct is provided clearly.
[20:34]
I have a second.
[20:35]
Second.
[20:38]
It's been moved and seconded all in favor.
[20:42]
I'm actually going to oppose this one so I'll be a nay on number three.
[20:52]
I'm sorry.
[20:52]
Just to be clear, that means it fails, even though it's two to one because you're correct from you are correct.
[20:59]
Yeah,
[21:02]
it leaves us with one petition, petition number four, do I have a motion?
[21:18]
I move that the Board of State canvassers determine that the reasons for
[21:21]
recall printed on petition four submitted by Ashley Aureda against
[21:25]
Antrim County clerk Victoria Bishop on September 14, 2026 are factual and
[21:32]
sufficiently clear and based on Bishop's Conduct and Office because the dates
[21:36]
have been provided, and the conduct provided is clear.
[21:41]
Second.
[21:43]
And moved and seconded, all in favor?
[21:45]
Aye.
[21:46]
Aye.
[21:47]
Motion passes.
[21:50]
You've got three out of four.
[21:51]
Before we move on to something else, just a quick comment.
[21:57]
Sure.
[21:58]
You've got three out of four.
[21:59]
Please only use one.
[22:01]
Yes.
[22:02]
I know that's obvious, but I guarantee you, if you come back
[22:06]
Can you have split petitions and you've used two of three and you have signatures on both?
[22:12]
I can already tell you how the board will react.
[22:15]
Yes.
[22:16]
Okay.
[22:16]
Thank you.
[22:17]
All right.
[22:18]
Thank you for driving home.
[22:19]
Thank you for the time today, truly.
[22:21]
Thank you.
[22:22]
Thank you.
[22:22]
Your third trip.
[22:25]
Right, safely.
[22:26]
Thank you.
[22:28]
You have a nice ride back, I think, though.
[22:29]
Isn't all sunshine up there?
[22:30]
Beautiful.
[22:33]
Mm-hmm.
[22:41]
Thank you.
[22:45]
We are on item number six, public comment.
[22:51]
Is there any public comment coming through the line?
[22:55]
No, all right, Mr. Wolff
[23:03]
needs you to turn on the microphone at the base and state your name and spell it for the clerk.
[23:13]
Good morning, I am Alan Wolff, A-L-L-E-N-W-O-L-F.
[23:19]
I am a citizen of Michigan and a taxpayer in Antrim County for more than 40 years.
[23:27]
Thank you for your decision today.
[23:29]
Our president has pointed to Michigan specifically Antrim County as a hotbed of election fraud.
[23:35]
In reality, there was no widespread misconduct in 2020 as he alleged.
[23:43]
So his MAGA Confederates needed to create some and along comes Ms. Victoria Bishop.
[23:50]
Due to the absence of rank choice voting, Ms. Bishop got the Republican nomination with
[23:55]
a minority of the vote in 2024 and ran in the general election unopposed on the ballot.
[24:01]
Since being elected, the voters of Antrim County have become aware that they made a huge
[24:06]
mistake.
[24:07]
As a result of federal bankruptcy proceeding after her election, where she and her husband
[24:13]
and gave sworn testimony, we learned that she had filed any 24 and ran in the general election unopposed on the ballot.
[24:22]
Since being elected, the voters of Antrim County have become aware that they made a huge mistake.
[24:28]
As a result of federal bankruptcy proceeding after her election, where she and
[24:33]
her husband gave sworn testimony, we learned that she had filed a can't false campaign finance report.
[24:40]
She falsely claimed her husband made loans and donations to her campaign of about $15,000.
[24:46]
In a corrected filing, she claimed to have been the donor herself of $10,000 in cash
[24:53]
to her campaign in excess of a $20 legal limit and could provide no paper trail of the
[25:00]
source of the funds.
[25:02]
She admits that she hadn't filed tax returns on her radio station business or personally
[25:08]
as far back as she could remember. She admitted that she had paid no taxes and failed to keep any business records or tax records.
[25:16]
She was found to be in contempt of court and ordered to pay fines and costs of about $12,000 which had to be garnished from her wages as a clerk.
[25:27]
If that wasn't enough, it has been widely reported that she gave her husband a twice convicted felon unsupervised access to her clerk's office and her computer.
[25:38]
According to media reports, she is mailed out about 1,800 cancellation of verification
[25:43]
postcards with multiple deficiencies to voters.
[25:47]
She has made at least 160 changes to the QVF that she was not authorized to make.
[25:53]
She defended her actions with a newspaper ad, paid for by taxpayers like me, claiming that
[25:59]
she had a mandate for the people and she basically didn't have to follow the law.
[26:03]
The Bureau of Elections has found her conducts so
[26:07]
egregious that they've removed her access to the qualified voter file until
[26:11]
she gets trained and pledges to follow the law.
[26:15]
She has not met those requirements or even pledged to do so.
[26:19]
Just last week, she claimed to be too busy working on the election
[26:24]
to respond to a FOIA request until after the November election.
[26:28]
The citizens of Antrim County want her gone.
[26:32]
The reputation of every other honest law-abiding clerk in the state is being
[26:37]
tarnished by allowing Victoria Bishop to remain in office any longer.
[26:43]
Miss Bishop couldn't even bother to show up in person here to any one of these three
[26:47]
hearings.
[26:48]
The delays caused by Miss Bishop's objections has pushed this recall campaign into a
[26:54]
position where the signatures will need to be collected in the middle of winter in a
[27:02]
difficult. But I can tell you this, the citizens of
[27:05]
Antrim County will ultimately succeed. I do want to thank the board for its
[27:10]
decision today and for the time to allow me to make this statement. Thank you
[27:14]
very much. Welcome sir. Thank you. Thank you.
[27:23]
This
[27:24]
captain.
[27:31]
Wonderful to see you back. If you would state your name and
[27:35]
install it for the clerk after you turn the microphone on.
[27:44]
My name is Lisa Kepatina, L.I.S.A., C.A.P.A., T.I.N.A.
[27:51]
Good morning.
[27:51]
Before you start, can I ask you a question?
[27:53]
You filled out two sheets.
[27:54]
I did.
[27:55]
How about if I...
[27:56]
How about...
[27:57]
You wanted to speak on six and item number seven.
[28:01]
Do you mind if you speak on six and then continue your conversation into seven and we'll segue into that part of the agenda with your speech?
[28:09]
That actually works out better for me, thank you.
[28:12]
That works.
[28:13]
Good morning Chair House Camp, Vice Chair Gerwitz, member Cummings, and the rest of your team.
[28:19]
Per an earlier request, I am providing the steps taken by Wayne County to support him
[28:24]
Tramick during the August primary in light of issues that occurred last November.
[28:30]
Our Board of Canvacers drafted a letter to all Wayne County clerks providing guidance to facilitate a smooth canvas.
[28:37]
We asked their consideration in areas where process details are essential.
[28:43]
We also suggested implementing a system to ensure the security of ballot storage throughout
[28:49]
the entire election cycle and recommended sharing that plan with their staff as an additional
[28:56]
level of security to mitigate chain of custody concerns.
[29:00]
On July 23rd, it was emailed to all clerks and their deputy clerks.
[29:05]
Our Deputy Director, Jennifer Redmond, conducted a comprehensive three-hour inspector training
[29:12]
on July 22nd.
[29:14]
I attended that training as an observer during which former inspectors, again, raised
[29:21]
allegations of cheating and election malfeasance in prior elections.
[29:25]
Both actions permitted and those prohibited during the voting process were reiterated by
[29:31]
her, and guidance was provided if concerns arose.
[29:34]
She returned to Ham Tramick for early voting training and offered her assistance with any other of their needs.
[29:42]
Ham Tramick clerk Sammy Elhady reassigned experienced inspectors to the leadership positions for increased oversight and accuracy.
[29:52]
A special chair training was held on July 29th, which I also observed.
[29:57]
On election day at the ham tray.
[30:00]
Amendment counting board. I understand a representative from the state, Carol Pierce, was present during, was present early, excuse me, during the major tabulator malfunction. Later in the day, another individual who identified himself as a New York attorney, working with the state was also present. I was present for most of the closing procedures. Last November,
[30:25]
However, him-traumatic had one election day precincts and two AV counting boards found
[30:30]
not recountable.
[30:32]
In the August primary, Clerk Elhadys' team completed a successful and smooth canvas.
[30:39]
Congratulations to him, his team, and to the inspectors that volunteered to serve.
[30:44]
As to any other steps taken by the county or the state, I am unaware of them.
[30:49]
I am also unaware of any action or update from the prosecutor regarding the November allegations of fraud nor the many suspicious ballots, ballot markings noted during the hand recount to my knowledge the county has not yet been contacted.
[31:08]
Thank you for your continued attention to this matter.
[31:11]
there. Thank you very much. Could I ask you for to stay for some questions here?
[31:18]
Okay. No, I'm before you move on to new business. Yes. I want to. We were given public comment
[31:26]
in our packet and I want to respond. I'm going to let you do that. But let's. Right. We
[31:31]
won't six and seven are kind of soft boundaries. Okay. That's it. But do you. Do you have questions
[31:38]
I really appreciate your coming and giving this report and the attention that you have paid.
[31:47]
You said that you are unaware of other actions that have been taken by the Bureau or the county.
[31:52]
Correct.
[31:53]
Are there other actions that you think should be taken?
[31:58]
I'm just not sure what you meant by bringing that up.
[32:01]
What I meant by that was it is almost a year, we're going on a year where we had presented information from the public that came, and there has still been no update or resolve, and it is my understanding as of the last conversation in the primary, that the ballots that we indicated looked very suspicious during the hand recount are still sitting in the same place.
[32:31]
that they were. So, that, I guess, is the part that I think is relevant.
[32:36]
So, you have been waiting for some criminal investigation or for some investigation
[32:42]
which might lead to a criminal action against some people.
[32:49]
I guess what I'm looking for is an update on whether that investigation is, in fact,
[32:54]
happening in regards to the fact that we submitted our
[33:03]
witness to things that looked
[33:05]
unusual during that hand recount.
[33:08]
Yeah. It is really good to hear what the Wayne County Board of Canvas is just on.
[33:13]
And I really appreciate your report and I'm impressed with that and grateful with the fact
[33:20]
that you have gone to these trainings because I think it's really critical.
[33:23]
I do learn a lot every time I go, I went through multiple throughout our county and every time I go, I learned something new.
[33:33]
And it is good to hear that the Hamptramic primary was conducted in accordance with the rules.
[33:41]
So, you know, that's, and since we're all worried about what's going to happen in November everywhere including Hamptramic, that's very good to hear.
[33:49]
there. And thank you for that. Director Brader, do you have a?
[33:55]
Well, so there's the forward looking and there's the back we're looking at. So in terms
[33:59]
of the investigation, we don't have any other information about what has happened with
[34:03]
that. I think we've referred everything we had many months ago. So that's from our standpoint
[34:08]
where it's said, I understand there are still some matters that need to be resolved with
[34:12]
respect to the judges order. Also, the ballots need to be counted, that were previously
[34:18]
and not counted, so I'm not sure exactly where that stands and how that would affect
[34:21]
criminal investigation.
[34:22]
In terms of the administration side, I mean as as the scavenging noted, we did have one
[34:26]
of the most senior expert members of our team there.
[34:30]
And that was following conversations that we had had with the clerk's office about improving
[34:34]
their procedures.
[34:35]
So it sounds like that's moving in the right direction, which is great to hear.
[34:38]
We're going to continue to work with them.
[34:41]
We obviously have a limited number of staff, so we cannot have our staff at local election
[34:47]
locations all day, typically, but we're going to continue to provide support to them through November.
[34:53]
And other jurisdictions didn't weigh in and around the state as well, that might need some help for various reasons.
[34:59]
Does that help with your questions?
[35:01]
It does, and two Director Brader's point, the most recent ruling by the Appellate Court is that those 37 need to be tabulated.
[35:11]
We're still waiting to hear about the process for that, but I guess for me,
[35:16]
that's what becomes so important in regards to any investigation because those
[35:23]
37 that we have not seen were subject to the same, I guess, the same process
[35:37]
or they could be included in those precincts where the unusual markings on
[35:42]
ballots occurred. So if we were told, you know what, we've investigated. There's no issue here.
[35:50]
To me, it empowers the decision and makes me feel more comfortable about going forward
[35:55]
with that process, knowing that everything has been investigated.
[36:02]
Okay.
[36:06]
Do we have anything from the Attorney General's Office to add to that?
[36:15]
Well, things referred for criminal investigation is a different division from me.
[36:19]
so I'm aware that I believe that we are investigating things to do with
[36:25]
HM Tremac, but I'm not aware of the status of that. And if there's no news
[36:29]
from our department, it means we're still looking at it. So that is an active
[36:32]
investigation. From what I recall that there is we have an effective active
[36:37]
investigation into some of the HM Tremac voting issues.
[36:44]
We'll continue to be here
[36:45]
and monitor it for you as well.
[36:47]
I mean, through your eyes.
[36:50]
And you also know how to reach all of us.
[36:52]
I do.
[36:54]
In multiple ways.
[36:56]
Uh-huh.
[36:57]
I would add one more thing before you move on
[37:00]
and that is, we really appreciate the effort
[37:02]
that you and your team, your board members have done.
[37:10]
You bring a lot of credit to the process.
[37:13]
Yes.
[37:14]
Wayne County does a really good job.
[37:17]
You walk in the door and it doesn't appear partisan at all and we're there to do a job
[37:22]
and everybody seems to feel the same way.
[37:25]
Speaks loudly for the fair and transparent elections in Michigan.
[37:31]
Go ahead.
[37:32]
Had something that I had the privilege of serving on the Wayne County Board for about, I don't
[37:36]
know, six or eight months before I was appointed to this position and I was really impressed
[37:42]
with the work that the Wayne County staff did.
[37:46]
It's a big job, it's much bigger job than any other county has.
[37:52]
There were 900 and some precincts and so one goes in and sees these enormous aisles
[38:00]
of poll books which have to be reviewed and which are meticulously reviewed.
[38:07]
So it's a big job and they do it well.
[38:10]
I think you'd be rather overwhelmed, walking in now with early voting, voting
[38:20]
centers, and absentee counting boards, the magnitude of data that comes in, we
[38:28]
don't have space for anymore, so it's piles. We have levels. Thank you. Thank you
[38:37]
for your time. Thanks for taking time to come over. Do you want me to sit down and come
[38:40]
like what do you want me to do for part two? I'm sorry? For part two, the other one.
[38:47]
No, you can move on. You know what you do have part two. Go ahead. Okay.
[38:53]
Okay.
[38:57]
Members of the board. As a county canvasser and Michigan voter, I feel compelled to also
[39:03]
express my confusion regarding the standards of accountability that were applied to affidavits
[39:09]
during the recent review of American for Citizens Boating Petition.
[39:14]
What I witnessed during the Board's discussion was more than a disagreement over individual
[39:19]
signatures.
[39:21]
For me it raised a broader question, are we applying consistent standards when determining
[39:26]
whether a voter's identity and signature are valid?
[39:30]
As I understand the process, ballot proposal signatures undergo QVF review.
[39:35]
When a signature is rejected, the promoter is given an opportunity to rehabilitate.
[39:41]
In several ACV cases, that rehabilitation was extensive, and the state subsequently
[39:47]
acknowledged the signatures as valid.
[39:50]
Yet despite statements made during discussions that were, there should be a really high bar
[39:57]
to remove signatures.
[39:59]
These signatures are real voters, and I'm not a handwriting expert.
[40:04]
members nevertheless rejected signatures because the rehabilitation occurred outside the 48-hour rule.
[40:12]
Our Michigan election system recognizes the importance of allowing voters to cure deficiencies.
[40:19]
Absentee voters may cure a rejected signature within a statutory time frame.
[40:24]
Move ballots postmarked by election day may be received up to six days after the election.
[40:30]
Likewise, a voter who arrives at a precinct without photo ID may sign an affidavit and cast a regular ballot.
[40:39]
As of today, the number of Wayne County voters using affidavits has increased significantly from 221 in the August of 25 primary to 961 in August of 2026.
[40:55]
Thousands of voters statewide have similarly used this process.
[41:00]
In the ACV case, signatures were subjected to additional verification, yet rejected because
[41:06]
the supporting documentation was submitted outside an administrative deadline.
[41:13]
Meanwhile, Michigan law provides voters multiple mechanisms to establish identity or cure deficiencies
[41:20]
when casting a ballot.
[41:21]
The contrast is striking to me.
[41:23]
I'm not suggesting deadlines be ignored, deadlines matter, procedures matter, election
[41:31]
integrity matters, but consistency matters too.
[41:36]
If a signature has been substantially verified, it is reasonable to ask whether a procedural
[41:42]
deadline should outweigh evidence establishing its validity, and if a more stringent standard
[41:49]
is applied to a petition signature than to establishing the identity of a person actually
[41:56]
casting a ballot. The public deserves to understand why. My concern is not simply whether
[42:02]
these particular signatures were accepted or rejected. It is whether the principles of
[42:08]
verification, accountability, and fairness are being applied consistently throughout our
[42:15]
our elections.
[42:16]
Thank you.
[42:18]
Thank you.
[42:25]
And in that comment was under general, that was public comment.
[42:29]
It's okay.
[42:30]
No.
[42:33]
Procedural.
[42:34]
You had item number seven, Mark, which you talked about with Hamtramic as new business.
[42:38]
And it's okay.
[42:39]
I'm going to regard them all together here.
[42:41]
Is that fair?
[42:43]
Ms. Cummings, you wanted to address public comment.
[42:47]
Right.
[42:47]
So we received an email from a Michigan resident named Paula Kenzu and we
[42:56]
received two emails, actually one on Friday, September 4th, let me get the date of
[43:04]
the other one. It was to myself, I think she was trying to include everybody on
[43:08]
the board, but didn't have correct address email addresses for a few of you.
[43:16]
And then
[43:17]
And essentially she was upset about the voting that occurred for Americans for citizen voting
[43:28]
and she called me out for a comment and I made about not having time to read some material.
[43:34]
So I just wanted to respond to these emails.
[43:39]
So I want to start with that I agree with much of what Ms. Kenzu has stated.
[43:44]
being a member of the Michigan Board of State canvassers comes with a lot of
[43:49]
responsibility. It is an honor to have been appointed by Governor Whitmer and I
[43:54]
take this opportunity very seriously. The Board has rules and policies that
[43:59]
help maintain consistency and fairness. Rule 168.844 provides that parties may
[44:06]
file written arguments with the Board at least 48 hours before the date of the
[44:11]
hearing. There is an accompanying rule, 1.6.846, which requires that members of the public
[44:19]
must submit materials to the board at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. The rule also
[44:24]
provides that the board shall not consider material received after the 48-hour deadline.
[44:31]
That is the rule I followed on August 24th, 2026, when deciding not to consider the material
[44:37]
that was being presented to us that morning.
[44:40]
That is what I was referring to when I indicated
[44:43]
we did not have time to read the additional material
[44:45]
that was presented to us that day.
[44:48]
Not only did we not have time,
[44:50]
but we are also bound by our rules not to consider it.
[44:54]
It would have been unfair if we did.
[44:56]
The opposing party was not allowed to do so.
[44:59]
In fact,
[45:00]
We refuse to entertain evidence, the opposing party submitted that was late. We have done so in the past, and I will continue to do so, unless told otherwise. Notably, the Bureau's report and staff recommendation that day was that the board determined the petitions insufficient. After reviewing every piece of timely evidence, coming to Lansing prior to the meeting and reviewing signatures, listening to seven hours of arguments that occurred during the meeting.
[45:29]
meeting, I agreed with a bureau that the petitions were insufficient.
[45:35]
I agree that the Americans for Citizen Voting was painfully close.
[45:39]
It was a very difficult day, but that is not the fault of the board or those of us on
[45:44]
the board who voted no.
[45:46]
That is the fault of Americans for Citizen Voting.
[45:49]
The failure of this sloppy petition rests solely on edge shoulders.
[45:55]
And that's all I want to say.
[45:58]
Thank you.
[45:59]
Thank you.
[46:05]
Director Brader or Mr. Fracassi addressing to either one of you gentlemen.
[46:11]
It's been a pretty eventful month since we were, is that do I get the award for understatement
[46:18]
there? It's been a fairly eventful month and Director
[46:26]
Brader or Mr. Fracassi addressing
[46:32]
It's been a pretty eventful month since we were, is that do I get the award for understatement there?
[46:40]
It's been a fairly eventful month and I would like to open up the floor to either review both of you
[46:52]
to share any thoughts, any updates, any, we've had two court opinions,
[47:00]
One from the U.S. Supreme Court, I have to tell you, I mentioned to my wife Renee, I said,
[47:08]
at one point I wanted to become an attorney long, long, long time ago, and Congressman
[47:14]
Vanderjack was kind enough to write me a letter to get into law school, and he said, maybe
[47:18]
someday you'll be in front of the U.S. Supreme Court.
[47:21]
The fact that our transcripts are now on the court's website is not quite the same, but
[47:30]
the goal certainly has been achieved, and just so you know I've taken it off of my bucket list.
[47:36]
Do you gentlemen have anything you'd like to add to where we are and?
[47:44]
Yeah, so I appreciate that.
[47:45]
I was going to talk during other business also about the House Committee, which I'll talk about
[47:50]
a second.
[47:50]
So, I mean, yes, we, it is not unusual for there to be litigation after the board's decisions on petitions and on initiative petitions specifically that's happened in the past.
[48:05]
I think that these, this case was different, one, because the US Supreme Court was involved, and two, just because of how close the determination was.
[48:18]
and obviously people on both sides felt very strongly about it.
[48:23]
So I think in responding to, in reviewing the briefing in the cases, and both those with
[48:30]
the resuminant on behalf of all the parties, and also just some of the public discussion
[48:39]
about a couple of things, one thing that's more to keep in mind is that we get basically
[48:47]
one shot at developing our procedures every two-year cycle.
[48:50]
So after we go through an election cycle, we review the board's determinations on specific
[48:57]
matters that maybe hadn't come up before, or maybe that the current board handles in
[49:02]
a slightly different way than the past boards.
[49:04]
We also are obviously looking at court decisions that come through, like the Wickman decision
[49:08]
which came through that changed the procedures that we had in place, and then also rulemaking
[49:13]
and legislation.
[49:13]
So what we attempt to do is basically review all the issues that came up during a cycle,
[49:21]
make sure those are all reflected in the manual and the board's materials,
[49:25]
bring that to the board for approval, and then use that for the upcoming election cycle.
[49:30]
And we'll certainly do that for this cycle as well.
[49:33]
I think one example where we had a petition process with some strong feelings
[49:40]
things like this was the 2022 gubernatorial issue in the primary, that led to us to moving
[49:47]
to random sampling for the statewide officers, which I think was ultimately a good change
[49:53]
that helped us resolve some of these issues differently, even though obviously the folks
[49:57]
that were not, you know, regardless of how they felt about the determination that was made
[50:03]
in the past cycle, making those changes allowed us to hopefully handle these more clearly
[50:08]
in the future.
[50:09]
So I think in this case, the board definitely should consider all the feedback that it's received,
[50:16]
and we can look at going to next cycle how the board wants to address some of these things.
[50:21]
That's obviously within the confines of the election law and the administrative rules,
[50:27]
which brings me to the last point, which is that we do have the state house that's convened to select committee reviewing this process,
[50:37]
which I know you're all aware of, they've started meeting, they did have a meeting on Monday of
[50:42]
this week I believe with the representatives from American for citizen voting. I understand they're
[50:48]
also requesting to hear from Michigan money out of politics and then they have also sent a lot of
[50:56]
requests to the Department of State slash Bureau of Elections which we are in the process of responding
[51:00]
to. We are going to be providing a lot of information to them. There's also some things that we have
[51:06]
questions about that will continue to work with them on.
[51:09]
So, I mean, I'm sure there will continue to be strong feelings that are expressed as a part of that process.
[51:15]
But ultimately my hope would be that we can look at some process changes that we can make to provide as much clarity as we can and consistency as we can.
[51:28]
The board, of course, has already tried to push legislative changes.
[51:32]
is the board was very active and the Bureau was supporting the board in that effort to try to get some changes made to the election law that I think if they had been enacted might have helped resolve some of the issues that we faced, that it was not enacted, so one thing that could potentially come out of this is another effort to pass some legislation that could address some of these issues, but regardless of what comes out of that, I think it's going to be important for the board outside of the context of considering a specific petition, but just the petition process broadly to get the
[52:02]
best possible set of requirements we can in place.
[52:06]
Once we do that, you know, inevitably what we find is that we may have addressed some
[52:11]
of the issues they came up with in the past cycle, but now there are new issues that come
[52:14]
up that the board has to deal with on the fly.
[52:16]
And of course we have very talented and motivated attorneys that are looking for, you know, making
[52:21]
the best argument they can for their clients, and so that's always pressing the board to
[52:25]
consider new issues or issues in new context.
[52:28]
So, I think the best that we can do is apply the procedures that we have in place to the positions that come before us and then after the fact look at, you know, what went well and what people weren't happy about and see to what extent we should make changes to help address those things in the future.
[52:44]
So, that's where our focus is going to be and hopefully, you know, will come out of this with a process that works as well as possible for everybody involved.
[52:53]
Thank you, Director Breater.
[52:55]
I would add to that, I guess, two points.
[52:57]
One is at least during my tenure on the board, I've watched the Bureau and the Board and
[53:03]
participated in a constant review of how we conduct business.
[53:11]
And we have always looked at this as being something where we try to be fair.
[53:15]
And the other point being is that during the last election cycle we were actually part
[53:24]
of discussions and the state house working closely with us.
[53:29]
We were part of discussions and we attended a hearing for a package of legislation that
[53:35]
significantly improved process.
[53:38]
And I know that that was a bipartisan, truly a bipartisan effort.
[53:43]
And both Republicans and Democrats in both House and Senate came together, put aside any differences,
[53:50]
impact and past significant benefits, legislation that would have significant benefits.
[54:03]
That legislation was vetoed and that's outside of our conversation.
[54:08]
But the point that I'm trying to make is that the legislature has, we have worked with them.
[54:13]
And I think good things have come out and good things will come out in the future.
[54:19]
So that being the case, is there any other business to come before this board?
[54:27]
I have something that I would like to address.
[54:31]
People are worried, of course, about the administration of the election in November.
[54:37]
And we have a role to play, and our role is certification, and I have heard concerns
[54:49]
expressed about whether any counties might fail or refuse to certify.
[54:58]
And so I think it is important just to clarify the certification issue.
[55:08]
It is the obligation of the county boards of Canvacers to certify the results in each county.
[55:16]
And they have to do that within a statutory period of time, 14 days, I believe.
[55:23]
One thing that people need to understand, that we understand, is that if the county fails to certify, it is the obligation of the state board to certify, and the county is then required to provide them all of its materials and the county canvassers are required to come themselves to the state board to assist the state board.
[55:51]
in completing that canvas.
[55:55]
There has, remember, Chair House Camp, you've noted that there has been legislative changes.
[56:02]
One that was not vetoed was a change to make in the provision regarding the county canvas.
[56:12]
It was clarified to specifically say, and this was in a 24 piece of legislation.
[56:22]
It is the ministerial clerical and nondiscretionary duty of each board of county canvassers and all of the members to certify the election results based solely on the statement of returns from the election day precincts early voting sites and absent voting county boards.
[56:40]
So it is to the extent that it wasn't clear before, it is absolutely clear now that the decision regarding certification is one which is not a discretionary one nor is our decision discretionary.
[56:58]
The county results come to us.
[57:02]
They get all tallied up and we say, yep, that's it.
[57:06]
And it is our job to be the final vote for certifying
[57:15]
the election and then actually giving
[57:19]
to each of the elected officials the impromotor.
[57:23]
We signed so many certifications.
[57:29]
So I think it is important, you know,
[57:32]
there are not many people here, but people do watch.
[57:35]
I'm surprised to hear sometimes that somebody is actually
[57:38]
watched, but it is important that that be clearly understood
[57:45]
by the general public.
[57:47]
That this is not something where anyone in the process
[57:51]
says, well, maybe this time I won't certify.
[57:54]
It will be certified.
[57:56]
And I know that other people with election responsibility
[58:03]
are looking very carefully to make sure
[58:06]
that there is not interference with the elections.
[58:11]
And I have great confidence in the election administration
[58:18]
in Michigan.
[58:19]
Again, I have seen it from various levels in precincts and
[58:28]
counting boards here.
[58:30]
I've seen what the Bureau does.
[58:32]
I know what the Bureau does.
[58:33]
And I have absolute confidence that it will be a fairly run
[58:38]
election.
[58:42]
Thank you, voice chair.
[58:45]
Anything else we need to chat about?
[58:48]
That being said, it is five minutes.
[58:51]
minutes to 12, 4 minutes to 12, we are adjourned.