Agenda
[0:19]
Call to Order
[0:24]
Roll Call
[4:00]
Election of Officers
[1:01]
Approval of Last Month's Minutes
[12:28]
2024 Closings Summary
[37:59]
White-Nose Syndrome in Bats in Boulder County: BCPOS Response and Internal Management
[1:20:47]
Public Comment Period for Items Not on Agenda
[1:54:00]
POSAC Members Comment Period for Items Not on Agenda
[1:58:12]
Director's Update
[2:00:50]
Adjournment
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:01]
Recording in progress.
[0:12]
Recreation last year. Okay, we're ready to go. Thank you.
[0:15]
We are calling to order the parks and Open Space
[0:18]
Advisory committee for January 23, 2025. We will do the
[0:26]
roll call, which. Is right here. Drew adams. Present. Trace
[0:35]
Baker? Present. Carol Byerly? Present. All of it's Gerald. Janet
[0:41]
George? Present. Christine Johnson? Here. Tony Lewis? I'm here. Jackson
[0:47]
Mueller? Present. Eric Turner? Here. Full house. Nice job, everyone.
[0:55]
Nice to have everyone here. Okay. I'm going to switch
[1:01]
this up for a minute and do approval of previous
[1:04]
meeting minutes. Do we have a motion to approve? Last
[1:09]
month. Trace Baker, Postac. I want to bring up. A
[1:13]
minor typo. I know what it is. Or maybe it's
[1:20]
a different one. Section 4.2. I'm sorry, section 4.2. Question
[1:29]
that other media outreach is. Being planned. Should that be?
[1:34]
What? Question. That's not mine. Does anybody know?
[1:46]
I found another typo. And. It was just in the.
[1:52]
I think the public comment. That just needs to be
[2:01]
proofread. There's one place where. I'm trying to find it
[2:06]
now with my new glasses, and I'm not going. To
[2:09]
find it. But. I would just ask that in the
[2:16]
public comment period for items not on the agenda. That
[2:21]
it just be proofread. All right, Carol. I was not
[2:28]
at the meeting, but I looked at the video and
[2:32]
I saw a typo. On the year's highlights. And that
[2:38]
video that summarized the years highlights had a typo, and
[2:41]
the word is sunset. But it was sus net. So
[2:47]
FYI, I'll tell it to the ether, but there was
[2:50]
a typo. In the cool video summarizing all the details.
[2:59]
Okay, thank you. Is there another typhoon? No. Typos? Polyfits,
[3:05]
jail? I just want to say that. I think the
[3:08]
newer format. With a little more information, a little more
[3:14]
narrative of what was discussed is perfect. It's really between
[3:20]
that being brief and yet having the information there. So
[3:23]
I really appreciate that. That's great. Agreed. Yeah, I think
[3:27]
we've all found it to be much. More helpful. Okay,
[3:31]
so noting those changes. Second with that. Okay with those
[3:37]
changes. All in favor? Aye, those. Carol and I were
[3:44]
not there, so we did not vote. And me also.
[3:54]
Great. On our agenda is the election of officers.
[4:04]
And this is something we do usually. At the first
[4:08]
meeting of the year and. Are you guys ready to
[4:13]
elect officers? Trace Baker post hack. May I suggest that
[4:21]
we postpone the election of officers? Until the first regular
[4:26]
meeting after the county commissioners select postac members. For 2025.
[4:34]
Because I know that we've received some emails saying that.
[4:38]
It might be February or March before the commissioner's act,
[4:43]
and I know that there are some people here. Who?
[4:47]
They've said they are not returning. I don't know if
[4:51]
we're allowed to make this change. To our bylaws or
[4:58]
whatever it is that says we have to. Do officers
[5:02]
today? But it makes sense. Yeah, we can, by vote,
[5:07]
change that. I think that's perfectly allowable. Let me just
[5:13]
ask about the time frame. So we have several members.
[5:20]
Reapplying for another term. We have one member who. Is
[5:28]
calling it. And. We might not have. People in their
[5:36]
seats with confirmation until. March or April. Right. So I
[5:43]
just want to make sure I understand. Your time frame
[5:47]
trace. Would you think? Election of officers once the dust
[5:51]
has settled and everybody's in their position. That's what I'm
[5:55]
putting up for discussion. I just want to make sure
[5:58]
that. Got the cadence right. So it may be an
[6:02]
election of officers in March or April, depending on. How
[6:06]
that goes. Okay, Carol. Caroly pose. I think that's a
[6:11]
good idea. Because. We aren't really comprised yet and wait
[6:18]
until the new POS act is comprised and then we
[6:21]
choose our own officer. I think it's a good idea.
[6:26]
Other comments? Thoughts? Janet yeah, Janet. George Postac I think
[6:29]
it's a good idea this time. I think we have
[6:31]
four, which is almost half of us, that might be
[6:34]
up for reappointment. So I think it's a really good
[6:37]
idea this time. With the numbers. Great other thoughts. Yes.
[6:47]
The only thing I'm thinking is introduce yourself. We're not
[6:51]
a Friday. Is that if you wait until the new
[6:56]
people are seated, you would be asking them to vote.
[7:00]
For officers that they've never met before. So there's that
[7:05]
consideration. Excellent point. Maybe we just shouldn't have officers at
[7:10]
all. Make it a free for all. Other thoughts.
[7:22]
Derek, you're kind of a government guy. I will confess.
[7:25]
I've reviewed that the bylaws do say. And they were
[7:28]
only recently, in 2020, approved that we shall elect our
[7:32]
officers at the first meeting. Of the year. I don't
[7:35]
think staff would prevent us from delaying that a month
[7:38]
or two. We're not proposing to change our bylaws.
[7:53]
Christine and then Jackson. Christine johnson posak. I don't know
[7:59]
if I'm out of order asking this. But. Who? On
[8:06]
the current Posac is applying to comeback. Trace baker. I
[8:13]
am. Drew adams? I am. I think that's the extent.
[8:20]
So right now, Jackson's seat is up and he is
[8:23]
not reapplying. If I'm correct, confirmed. And Paula is not
[8:27]
reapplying. So we have two coming back and two who
[8:31]
are Xing. Okay, that's helpful to know presumed coming back.
[8:37]
They've applied. It's true. Who would like to come back?
[8:40]
Let me just say. Yeah, you never know. Jackson hits
[8:43]
them. Yeah. I would like to discuss potentially voting today,
[8:48]
and then you could revote in March or April. You
[8:53]
could do both. Well, dare turn. And I guess I
[8:57]
tend to agree. We have this as the first time
[9:00]
in months. We have all of us here. I appreciate
[9:07]
Renata's comment that. A new set of pos act really
[9:11]
doesn't have the experience. Of each other. To, I think,
[9:16]
meaningfully. Vote. I guess I would support a vote tonight.
[9:25]
If that's the consensus. Trace. Trace Baker. Yeah. The discussion
[9:33]
is convincing me that we should. Continue to vote tonight.
[9:39]
Other thoughts. True? Yeah. I mean, reading the bylaws. It
[9:45]
actually says will not even shall. Elect from among its
[9:49]
members the chair and vice chair at the first meeting
[9:51]
of each year. The fiscal year or the calendar. Gregorian
[10:00]
which count. Counter. Paula. Paula Fitzgerald. I just want to
[10:07]
remind people that last year there was election of an
[10:10]
officer who was not reappointed. And so then it necessitated
[10:15]
going back and doing that election again. So I see
[10:19]
some value in waiting until everybody's on the board. But
[10:22]
I also agree that. Nice to know who you're voting
[10:27]
for in kind of their record and all that, so.
[10:30]
I'm going to throw that back to you guys because
[10:32]
you'll be the ones living. I nominate. Paula for. Chair.
[10:43]
Well. Let me ask you for tonight. Is there any
[10:52]
dissent in voting for officers tonight that you're strongly, so
[10:56]
strongly convinced we should wait. That you would like to
[11:01]
make that case. Carol Byerly Posak, I propose that we
[11:06]
extend. Our current confirmation of us terror and Janita's co
[11:13]
chair. Until we are newly comprised and then revisit it.
[11:20]
And have another vote. We don't have to depose anybody.
[11:26]
I think either of us would be happy to be
[11:27]
deposed, however. Let's see. I guess.
[11:38]
What I'm thinking is we actually have to vote on
[11:41]
that, though. Because there has to be a motion. I
[11:43]
would second it. So is that a motion that was
[11:46]
my imotion. I will make that a motion that we
[11:49]
retain our current chair and current co chair. Until. The
[11:54]
membership has been reformed. Great. Is there a second? A
[11:59]
second? Okay. Any further discussion? All in favor? Aye. Opposed?
[12:08]
Okay, the motion passes, and Janet and I will remain
[12:12]
in our officer roles until a more thoughtful crew comes
[12:16]
along. This could be dangerous. Monarchy. Exactly. I have no
[12:25]
executive, okay? So next, do we have Janice Wisman? Good
[12:33]
evening. Pos can you hear me? Yes. All right. Great.
[12:37]
I'm Janice Wisman. I'm the real estate division manager, and
[12:40]
I'm here to give you our 2024 closing summary, which
[12:44]
also functions as our annual report. For the real estate
[12:46]
division and before. I get started. I want to do
[12:51]
what we often do or have been trying to do
[12:53]
every time that we bring. An acquisition proposal to you
[12:57]
and read the department's land commitment. It's more than a
[13:00]
land acknowledgment. I just want to point that out and
[13:02]
say that this is a commitment. For our department to
[13:06]
do our work differently from now into the future. We've
[13:08]
been doing this commitment now for a couple of years
[13:11]
at least. To recognize all the cultures and people who
[13:14]
have contribute to this special place. So I would like
[13:17]
to. If you would indulge me, I'll just read it
[13:20]
so we get it. On the record. So for much
[13:23]
longer than parks and open spaces. History of stewarding open
[13:26]
space the land in this community has been important to
[13:29]
the diverse indigenous communities that continue to live here. We
[13:33]
are partnering with indigenous people to make meaningful changes to
[13:36]
how we do our work. That include indigenous people, incorporate
[13:39]
their perspectives and honor their land stewardship, legacy parks and
[13:43]
open space operates within modern legal constructs of land ownership.
[13:47]
To steward Boulder county open space and accomplish these efforts
[13:50]
on behalf of our community. So thank you for that.
[13:54]
And now I will not read slides going forward. But
[13:58]
I want to give you some highlights, and then we'll
[14:00]
look at a few of the more interesting deals we
[14:03]
did this year. So in 2024. We had a total
[14:07]
of 646 acres that we acquired, including water rights as
[14:11]
well. In 15 different acquisitions. We acquired 15 building rights,
[14:17]
which is important for our open space program, because by
[14:19]
removing building rights, from the land, you prevent the development
[14:22]
from happening. And we had a net investment of just
[14:26]
over $11.9 million. And I would like to revisit some
[14:31]
of those acquisitions, one that we are very excited about
[14:35]
is the Wall street mill. If you've been up to
[14:38]
Wall street and. This is just next to, down the
[14:44]
road a little bit from the assay office. This was
[14:47]
only a one acre acquisition, and it only cost $63,000.
[14:50]
But we now own the entire mill. The county previously
[14:54]
owned half of the mill, and it was very difficult,
[14:57]
if not impossible. To do any cultural preservation of that
[15:00]
mill site. So now we do own. The whole mill.
[15:02]
It's also sound, so there's nothing that needs to be
[15:05]
done. Right now. But if something does need to be
[15:08]
done, the county can proceed with the project. The Highlands
[15:12]
camp was one that was not brought to you because
[15:15]
it was a donation, and it was a 294 acre
[15:17]
property. It's up by Allens park, and the donation was
[15:21]
of a conservation easement to the Estas Valley land Trust.
[15:26]
The county assisted with project costs and has a backup
[15:29]
holder position in case the Estes Valley land trust ever
[15:32]
decides they can't hold the easement anymore. We don't yet.
[15:35]
Know the value of that. It's been appraised and. There
[15:40]
is a tax season process for them to make sure
[15:43]
they get that donation appraised. And do whatever it is
[15:45]
they want to do to claim their tax benefits. This
[15:48]
property is real interesting because. It has solid view, protection,
[15:52]
corridor aspects to it, and it's part of the indian
[15:55]
peaks. Environmental conservation area. Those are both features in the
[15:59]
Boulder county comprehensive plan. Can I ask a question? Carol
[16:05]
byr, Lee Posak. If we. Are not. It's not about
[16:12]
the money. But if it's a donation, I would. Be
[16:15]
interested in knowing. What additional lands are being brought into
[16:19]
the county program. I think. We try to let you
[16:24]
know about those as they happen. I haven't been to
[16:27]
a few of the meetings this year, so I'm not
[16:28]
sure exactly if that happened this year. But. Okay, I
[16:31]
guess I didn't recognize that. Okay. Because that'll change the
[16:36]
map. Yes, it does. Yes. And then we had a
[16:40]
second donation this year, and it was a fee title
[16:42]
donation. We're calling this the elk draw property, and it's
[16:45]
40 acres up next to the Tucker property just west
[16:48]
of Netherland and Colorado open lands owned that property, and
[16:52]
they retained a conservation easement over it, but gave the
[16:55]
ownership over to the county, and the county will manage
[16:57]
that property in. Conjunction with the Tucker property. The Boulder
[17:02]
County Comprehensive Plan identifies this property as having indian peaks
[17:05]
environmental conservation area features as well as significant natural communities
[17:10]
and the Arapaho ranch and Tucker homestead critical wildlife habitat
[17:14]
areas. And we believe the donation value, and that was
[17:17]
about $200,000. And then we had another elk property. We
[17:22]
were trying to name things, not for people, and this
[17:24]
is in a different part of the property or part
[17:27]
of the county. Excuse me. We had the elk tracks
[17:29]
property, which is a 36 acre piece, and it is
[17:32]
on Highway 72 in Cole Creek. Canyon. It's on the
[17:35]
north side of the road, and it nearly abuts Reynolds
[17:38]
ranch. There's a little slive. Sliver of force service in
[17:41]
between this property and Reynolds Ranch. We bought that for
[17:45]
the fair. Market value of $535,000. You hopefully remember this
[17:48]
one because we did bring it. To you. And the
[17:52]
comprehensive plan identifies this as having view protection quarter features.
[17:57]
It's also part of the Magnolia Environmental Conservation Area. Has
[18:02]
importance for the Winnagar ridge Elkurd migration corridor and significant
[18:06]
natural communities, and it also provides the future. But completely
[18:11]
unplanned and nothing being planned at the moment, but. The
[18:14]
potential for a trail connection to Reynolds Ranch if the
[18:16]
county were to ever desire to do that. A property
[18:20]
that is just west of Hygiene and north of 66.
[18:23]
It's about a mile west of Hygiene, and this is
[18:26]
an aerial photo that the realtor provided for us. And
[18:29]
I thought that was a nice picture to show you
[18:31]
because it puts this in context with Rabbit Mountain. It's
[18:35]
101 acres. It was a $2,975,000. Acquisition. And came with
[18:42]
several shares of a significant priority, ditch water rights, that
[18:45]
we wanted to acquire as well. The fields are irrigated
[18:49]
and very highly productive. And this one is identified as
[18:53]
having agricultural lands of statewide importance. Prebble's meadow jumping. Mouse
[18:58]
suitable contiguous habitat in what's identified as zone three. For
[19:02]
them, it's got the highway 66 view protection corridor. It's
[19:07]
actually part of the Rabbit Mountain Environmental conservation area. Even
[19:10]
though you can see it's a little distance. Away, and
[19:13]
it is part also of the Rabbit Mountain B, one
[19:15]
high biodiversity area. And then the one that. Was the
[19:21]
very interesting and fun and wonderful acquisition for the year,
[19:25]
really the highlight of the year. Was the Haystack Mountain
[19:27]
property. This lies on the south side of Oxford Road.
[19:31]
It's southeast of Table Mountain. You can't see Table Mountain
[19:33]
in this picture, but this is. Another realtor picture that
[19:35]
I thought was good shows the feeder canal passing by
[19:39]
on the south. End of the property. It's about 106
[19:42]
acres. We paid $6.2 million for this. This one was
[19:47]
an auction that the county had to participate in. I
[19:50]
think Terese told you. About this after it happened. It
[19:53]
was a very interesting process and ended up being a
[19:57]
live auction that finished in Hong Kong. With a live
[19:59]
auctioneer, so it was quite fun. And then this property
[20:04]
does have such importance to our community as a natural
[20:07]
landmark. It's designated as such in the county's comprehensive plan.
[20:12]
And it has other resources on the property, and so
[20:14]
it's closed for resource protection and is not open to
[20:17]
the public. Janice, Trace Baker, Postac. Could you give us
[20:21]
some examples of what the resources are? That need protection.
[20:26]
I'm sorry, I can't. I don't have those with. Me
[20:28]
right now. Okay? Thank you. Thank you. And, Janice, before
[20:32]
you get off the slide, can you just give us
[20:34]
a sense of where the boundary goes on the backside
[20:37]
of that property. Yeah. So what you're looking at, this
[20:42]
is looking kind of northeast. And if you look at
[20:47]
Haystack Mountain, over the hill and down on the other
[20:50]
side, Oxford Road runs along there. I don't think you
[20:53]
can quite see it in this picture. Oxford Road runs
[20:56]
generally east and west, and that Oxford Road is the
[20:59]
north edge of the property. Okay, great. Thank you. Yes.
[21:02]
And I can also say that this property used to
[21:04]
be part of the haystack mountain golf course, which is
[21:07]
south of the canal, and some of it you can
[21:08]
see in the photo there. Thank you. All right. And
[21:14]
then those are the acquisitions that I wanted to highlight.
[21:18]
There were more because we did 15 altogether. I gave
[21:21]
you a list of those. I know that list is
[21:22]
a little bit. Dense. But hopefully you could expand it
[21:28]
on your computers and read it. Feel free to ask
[21:31]
me questions. About it if you would like, but I'd
[21:33]
like to highlight another section on that list. Are the
[21:35]
dispositions that we do. And as you know, a lot
[21:37]
of times we have to respond to a taking from
[21:40]
a condemning authority. But we also do dispositions when it
[21:44]
makes sense for open space purposes, and I wanted to
[21:46]
highlight this one, which is an amended easement we did
[21:49]
with Broomfield for the Lakelink. Trail that runs through part
[21:53]
of Ruth Roberts park. And there was erosion happening in
[21:56]
the drainage. You can see here, and they needed a
[21:58]
little more area to control the erosion. And the prior
[22:02]
easement that they had for the trail was just a
[22:04]
30 foot wide street. Width and they needed more of
[22:07]
a polygon in this area. So we were able to
[22:10]
amend that easement, and then now they can do the
[22:13]
erosion control. That they need to do into the future.
[22:16]
And then another major area of our work is working
[22:20]
on oil and gas activity that happens on open space.
[22:25]
And I know that you understand this, but some members
[22:28]
of the public may not, so I'm going to explain
[22:29]
that this activity is occurring on open space because these
[22:32]
leases were typically in place. They were in place, typically
[22:36]
decades before the county acquired the properties. Most of the
[22:39]
leases started back in nineteen seventy eight, seventy nine, eighty,
[22:42]
eighty one in that time frame. And our staff lead
[22:46]
our department in the real estate division, lead our department's
[22:48]
oil and gas team, which includes a plant ecologist, a
[22:51]
wildlife biologist and someone from the ag resources division. And
[22:55]
then, when needed, somebody from the trails crew and trails
[22:58]
groups to evaluate the operator's needs. And right now, really
[23:03]
what's happening is they just are coming onto. These well,
[23:05]
pads insights to do maintenance. And there were 14 groups
[23:10]
of maintenance projects this year that involved work on 258
[23:16]
different wells, some of that number. That 258 is multiple
[23:20]
times coming back because they would do different kinds of
[23:22]
maintenance. On each property, each wellhead. And then pad site.
[23:29]
Also, that also involves work on non county open space.
[23:33]
Because our department is the one that has the expertise
[23:36]
on how to minimize the impacts to the land and
[23:38]
how to reclaim and restore things. And so. Our oil
[23:41]
and gas team serves as the county's resource experts for
[23:45]
that work. Altogether, we're able to minimize the impacts and
[23:49]
reclaim things and help landowners who have wells. On their
[23:53]
private land. And then the last major group of our
[24:00]
work that we do is our conservation easement program. And
[24:02]
they again monitored 450 easements. That's typically about how many
[24:06]
they can do every year, which is a little over
[24:09]
50% of our 848 easements that we have that require
[24:13]
monitoring. There are some other interests in our program that
[24:17]
we manage, like deed restrictions or restrictive covenant. They're not
[24:21]
technically conservation easements, but they're part of what we manage
[24:23]
to make. Sure the landowners are abiding by the restrictions
[24:26]
on their property, and then the county also has granted
[24:30]
conservation easements out to our partners on open space properties,
[24:35]
and there are. 154 of those. So all told, our
[24:39]
program. Manages about 1046 conservation easement. And similar types of
[24:45]
interest. Nice. Christine, you have a question? Christine Johnson Posak
[24:49]
I really appreciated the document that you gave us ahead
[24:53]
of time that came. With the agenda, and I found
[24:58]
this part of it to be really eye opening. I
[25:01]
don't. Think I had understood the degree to which you
[25:04]
are involved with this, and I was curious. What does
[25:07]
it look like? When you are doing monitoring. What? Does
[25:12]
the monitoring visit entail? I assume you're going to a
[25:15]
property and looking for. Something. Sure, I'll be happy to
[25:18]
describe that. And before I get into that, I can
[25:21]
also share that for context. This represents about 40,000 acres
[25:26]
of our 107,000 acre holdings, so it's. Significant. They're private
[25:30]
properties. But the landowners who are there now, or their
[25:33]
prior landowners, restricted their uses, so. They vary, and some
[25:38]
of these are about 300 of them that were done
[25:40]
through land use processes. And then quite a few that
[25:43]
were done through our own acquisitions and donations and things
[25:46]
like that. So each easement is different, but they all
[25:49]
do some sort of development restriction, and then they also
[25:52]
do some sort. Of natural resource or other type of
[25:56]
protection. So we have to look at each one, and
[25:59]
what we do is we have a rotational scheme. Set
[26:02]
up so that. If you're headed out to monitor for
[26:05]
the day, you have a group of eight to ten,
[26:08]
maybe twelve or 15 at the most. Easements to monitor
[26:11]
it depends on the size of them and where you
[26:13]
are in the county, you can monitor quite a few
[26:16]
ones on the planes. In a day. Whereas up in
[26:18]
the mountains you might be just monitoring one property. And
[26:22]
we send notices out to the landowner to say that
[26:25]
we are, and we usually do that. Early in the
[26:27]
year, and we say you're on the schedule for monitoring
[26:29]
this year. We plan to come out and do a
[26:32]
monitoring visit. Would you please let your tenants know if
[26:34]
you have tenants. And if you would like to be
[26:37]
there when we come, give us a call. We're happy
[26:40]
to arrange a visit while you're there, but. The county
[26:42]
does have the right to go out, and we literally
[26:45]
can't arrange 450 visits. So we set it up that
[26:49]
way to just say, tell us if you need to
[26:52]
be there. And if you want to be there. It
[26:54]
also gives them an opportunity. If they have questions for
[26:56]
us, sometimes they can call and talk. To us ahead
[26:58]
of time or afterwards or whatever. And then we go
[27:02]
out and we have a buddy system so that nobody's
[27:05]
going by. Themselves in the mountains because we want to
[27:07]
be safe and make sure everybody, if you're climbing over
[27:11]
logs and things. You don't want to have a medical
[27:14]
issue if you break. Your leg or something and be
[27:16]
by yourself. So we have protocols for how we do
[27:18]
the site. Visits, but then we go in a count.
[27:21]
County vehicle. You can see the equipment in the picture
[27:24]
here. That is just basically a backpack with a GPS.
[27:28]
Some information about the conservation easement, and they've got a
[27:32]
sense of the property boundaries. And they're going out to
[27:35]
look for changes, primarily. We typically have these properties well
[27:40]
documented, with photographs and aerials as well. So we know
[27:45]
what's out there to start with. Most of the properties
[27:47]
have baseline reports. The ones that got assigned to our
[27:52]
department. Just going way back when I started. On June
[27:56]
1, 2005. So I'm coming up on my 20th anniversary.
[27:59]
I was tasked with starting our program. And we had
[28:03]
about 550 easements. And after we got that going for
[28:06]
about a year, the commissioners said, why don't you monitor
[28:09]
and manage all of the land use process easements? As
[28:12]
well. And those came to us with no baselines, but
[28:16]
we did have baseline data, so. We did have title
[28:19]
work, we had assessor data. We had all kinds of
[28:22]
things from the. Land use record, but not an official
[28:24]
baseline report. But we do use that baseline report that
[28:27]
talks. About uses and what's allowed and intentions, and you
[28:31]
look at the conservation easement document. As well as past
[28:35]
photographs. And so you compare all of that to what
[28:38]
you're seeing. Today to see if there are changes and
[28:41]
if those changes are allowed by the terms of the
[28:44]
conservation easement, and then if they're not, then there are
[28:46]
a lot of follow up. Conversations. And various resolutions to
[28:51]
issues that they might find. And the program uses volunteers
[28:55]
as well, of which trace is a longtime volunteer. Paula
[28:59]
has volunteered. I volunteered for a couple of seasons already,
[29:02]
which we very much appreciate. It's such an amazing program,
[29:06]
and it's such a great opportunity to volunteer. Tracy, did
[29:09]
you want to add anything to it? Do you have
[29:11]
trace Baker Postac? And at least as volunteers. We're given
[29:18]
a geo referenced map on our phone. And so that
[29:23]
will allow us to respect the boundaries. And then there
[29:28]
is a protocol that we follow where. We will. Make
[29:33]
either photographs of changes that we observe. Or reference photographs.
[29:40]
And. Those are geolocated on the map so you can
[29:46]
get a precise idea of where the photograph was made.
[29:50]
And. Some of the. Places are very rugged. A lot
[29:58]
of them are old mining claims. But there's steep terrain,
[30:04]
lots of bear droppings out there. So it's a fun
[30:09]
program. Questions, Janet. Just a quick question for clarification. So
[30:18]
when you say photograph changes or document changes, Do you
[30:23]
mean changes that the owner might have made, or does
[30:26]
that include natural kind of changes? To. Well, we do
[30:30]
see all of them, but the ones that are of
[30:31]
concern are the ones the owner made. Okay, that's what
[30:34]
I thought. If the flood comes through and damages the
[30:39]
property, we can't and don't make the landowner put things
[30:41]
back because that's just too expensive to do. But we
[30:44]
do want to make sure that they're staying within their
[30:46]
building envelopes for allowed buildings. They're not getting too close
[30:50]
to riparion areas, or they're supposed to not have buildings.
[30:52]
And that sort of thing. Yeah, but these document things
[30:55]
like a flood that. Would come through. Okay, we do.
[31:00]
Other questions. Great general firely. What percentage of problems do
[31:08]
you find? Is it, like, virtually none, or is it.
[31:12]
It's. Virtually none. Now. It's not very many. When I
[31:15]
first started, it was a lot because people were asking
[31:18]
me. Well, who are you? What are you doing here?
[31:22]
What are you doing here and why? I don't have
[31:24]
a. Conservation easement, that sort of thing, because the county
[31:27]
had not had a monitoring program before. But now, because
[31:31]
we're out there almost every other year on each property,
[31:35]
People are used to it. They know. What the restrictions
[31:38]
are and. It's a very solid relationship, usually with the
[31:42]
landowners. So thank you for your interest in that program.
[31:49]
And then to end with, I just want to let
[31:50]
you know about a couple of staffing. Changes. Don Derso,
[31:54]
who has been our person to present all of our
[31:56]
condemnations with you. He was in a term position and
[32:00]
that term position expired and he was ready to retire.
[32:04]
So we don't have his position, and we don't have
[32:06]
Don, unfortunately. But he has retired and we wish him
[32:10]
well, and we do miss him. We do have a
[32:12]
new staff member, though, because Michael Sylvester. Who I don't
[32:17]
have in this picture because he hadn't joined us at
[32:18]
this. Point, but. He has just joined our team from
[32:22]
the county attorney's office and. He is the designee on
[32:26]
staff to receive all the oil and gas maintenance requests
[32:28]
for the county, and then he coordinates with public health
[32:32]
and community planning and permitting and other departments as well.
[32:36]
As parks and open space. On those requests. So he's
[32:40]
coming onto our team. He's taking over the internal. Team
[32:43]
coordination role that we have as well. And then that
[32:46]
will allow Megan Green, as one of our real estate
[32:49]
specialists who's been doing that to work on some other
[32:51]
things. And we're trying to do a little shuffling. To
[32:53]
try to fill what Don was doing. So you're going
[32:56]
to see more of our other land officers doing the
[32:58]
work that Don was doing. But we're very glad that
[33:02]
Michael has joined us, and he's going to be. Handling
[33:05]
primarily oil and gas activity for us. That's great. That's
[33:09]
all I have. Thank you very much. Are there any
[33:13]
members of the public here who want to speak on.
[33:18]
The topic of the closings. And Nick, do we have
[33:21]
anybody online? For those members that are on attending on
[33:26]
zoom. If you want to make comments on the current
[33:28]
agenda item. Please use the raise hand feature and we
[33:31]
can call on you. I am not seeing any raised
[33:35]
hands. Great. Thank you. Derek. Did you have any? Yeah,
[33:38]
I had. A question, Derek Turner. And I guess I
[33:41]
wanted to go back to the very first thing you
[33:43]
presented on which is the land commitment, and I thought.
[33:49]
It'd be appropriate. If there's anything you could tell us
[33:51]
about. Which efforts from this last year to live up
[33:57]
to this commitment ways you partnered and worked with indigenous
[34:02]
communities. I can do that because this is a real
[34:05]
estate division, so I'm going to do that from that
[34:07]
perspective, if that's okay. So one of the things I
[34:11]
mentioned as I was going through is we're no longer
[34:13]
using landowner names for naming properties, and that's something we
[34:16]
implemented a couple of years ago. And it's continuing to
[34:20]
be a successful way to honor. The land, really, and
[34:25]
not necessarily the people who typically, a lot of the
[34:29]
landowners. Are members of the white culture. Not all of
[34:32]
them are, but a lot of them are. And that's
[34:36]
why in this commitment, we talk about the fact we
[34:38]
have to use real estate principles and landownership, et cetera.
[34:43]
But it's a broader way to acknowledge. What the land
[34:47]
brings. And to be more cognizant of the value of
[34:52]
that land to the open space. Program. I am also
[34:56]
doing that. And every year I've been doing a volunteer
[34:59]
naturalist training session. To sort of kick off that training
[35:04]
that we do. It's several weeks long, and I bring
[35:07]
in the history of the area and how our program
[35:10]
got started. And. I have been augmenting what I have
[35:15]
been doing in that space for several years now. To
[35:18]
try to recognize those who were here before us. And
[35:22]
kind of how things have happened. And the fact that,
[35:25]
for example, people from the city of Longmont and Boulder
[35:29]
county mustard and went to the Sand Creek massacre and
[35:32]
participated in it. So bring in all that kind of
[35:35]
history, including all the. Western doctrine. Of discovery and expansion
[35:42]
and how that all works. So that's something that I've
[35:45]
adopted and we've been doing my team. Then, as I
[35:49]
mentioned, we've been doing this acknowledgment before every POsAC meeting
[35:53]
and every board of commissioner. Hearing on a land acquisition
[35:57]
or even a disposition project. So that members of the
[36:00]
public know that we care about this, and this is
[36:04]
a commitment that we are using because it's short enough
[36:08]
to put in a memo doesn't take too long to
[36:10]
read, but accomplishes the purpose for what we're doing without
[36:14]
taking too much of the public meeting and hearing space,
[36:19]
but our department, as. A whole. Has a longer land
[36:23]
commitment. That is really about thinking on a daily basis
[36:26]
how you can do things differently. So one of the
[36:30]
other things that you'll be hearing about is we've been
[36:33]
working on. My group's been working on. The flood buyout
[36:36]
properties. There were 45 of those that got bought out.
[36:41]
With FEMA and HUD funding after the 2013 flood, our
[36:45]
department adopted a lot of those into open space, and
[36:47]
they were part of our open space program, but some
[36:50]
of them. Are just lots in a subdivision. And we
[36:54]
don't feel it like Boulder county is. The best owner
[36:57]
of those properties, necessarily. And so last May, we advertised
[37:02]
16 of those is being available for new owners. They
[37:06]
have to abide by the deed restrictions that require that
[37:09]
they be used only for open space purposes, and we've
[37:12]
been working since then to develop through both an equity
[37:16]
lens in general. And then. Just also trying to make
[37:20]
sure we do outreach to cultures who don't necessarily. Find
[37:25]
it easy to hear about things that parks and open
[37:28]
space is doing to make sure that we had some
[37:29]
robust outreach before. As we launch that program. And we
[37:34]
had a two month window for application, so we tried
[37:36]
to make sure that that outreach was done early, so
[37:41]
those are some of the examples. Thanks. I appreciate that.
[37:44]
Thank you and great. Presentation and congratulations on a very
[37:48]
successful year. Looks like. Well, thank you. And thank you
[37:51]
for your support. Your recommendations are really important to the
[37:53]
commissioners and. To staff as well. Thank you. Thank you,
[37:56]
Janice. Okay. Susan, would you like to come up and
[38:01]
talk to us about white notice syndrome?
[38:20]
And I was just up at Blue Jay Mines. So
[38:24]
it's prime on my mind. Okay.
[38:35]
Okay. All right, so I'm Susan Spalding. I'm the environmental
[38:41]
senior specialist with Boulder. County open space and also a
[38:45]
wildlife biologist. So today I'm going to give an update.
[38:48]
On Whiteno syndrome in Boulder county. So I've structured the
[38:52]
presentation today to cover Batson. Boulder county what species we
[38:56]
have and how. Do we know? Our past and present
[39:01]
monitoring efforts in the wildlife program. And with the arrival
[39:04]
of Whiteno syndrome, into Boulder County. Our internal management, coordination
[39:09]
and response. So if you have questions as I go
[39:12]
through the presentation, please. Just go ahead and ask. I
[39:16]
also want to mention that we have other staff here
[39:17]
today to help answer questions. Such as education, Outreach and
[39:22]
our reckon facilities group. Okay. So before we go any
[39:27]
further, let's talk about bats. So they are beyond amazing
[39:31]
as you guys probably know they have a super long
[39:33]
lifespan, which most people are surprised by. They're highly social
[39:41]
and they develop long term associations, like friendships with other
[39:44]
bats. They've. Been documented visiting neighboring roof sites, and they
[39:49]
hang out with a different individual bat and then they
[39:52]
go back to their original roof site, and no one
[39:54]
really knows why they do this, but. It really seems
[39:56]
like they're hanging out and having conversation. So most bats
[39:59]
give birth to only one pup per year. And you
[40:02]
can see the x ray. Image there. So very slow
[40:07]
reproduction, which is why, when their populations are impacted, it
[40:10]
takes a very long time. To recover. So worldwide there
[40:14]
are 1480 species, so that means they make up 25%
[40:19]
of all living. Mammal species. So the only other order
[40:23]
that. Has more species is rodents, which make up 45%.
[40:29]
So if you're a mammal today, you have a 75.
[40:33]
Percent chance of being either a bat or a rodent.
[40:37]
Yeah. So bats evolve from shrews, which are not rodents.
[40:41]
They are in the order Insectivora. Along with hedgehogs and
[40:46]
moles. And truths actually have primitive echolocation capabilities, but nothing
[40:52]
compared to like, what bats have. So what is echolocation?
[40:56]
So basically, the bats are screaming at the top of
[40:59]
their lungs. With their vocal cords. And if we could
[41:03]
hear it, it's as loud as a smoke detector. And
[41:06]
that's. 120 decibels recorded within six inches of the bat
[41:10]
itself, so it's probably pretty loud out there for animals
[41:13]
that can hear them. So their eyesight is good to
[41:17]
excellent and they don't use it much at night. Due
[41:21]
to the darkness, obviously, but they also have some ability
[41:24]
to detect color as well. So any bat biologist will
[41:29]
tell you that they are amazingly complex on so many
[41:31]
levels, and I hadn't even mentioned their physiological capabilities, including
[41:36]
how they control their heart rates, how they. Hibernate. Their
[41:39]
crazy immune systems. And how they physically catch their food.
[41:45]
There are so many things, and, of course, the benefits
[41:47]
they provide to humans. And our crop production. They eat
[41:51]
a lot of insects and save, or I should say,
[41:54]
assist. The farming community, like 23 billion per year. It's
[42:00]
pretty incredible. Okay, so bats in Boulder county. So Colorado
[42:07]
is home to 20 species of baths, and of these
[42:10]
20 species, 14 are known hibernators, and the other six
[42:14]
migrate south for the winter. So not all bats hibernate.
[42:21]
That's important information because hibernating bats are the species that
[42:23]
are suffering from widenose syndrome. Okay, so now let's zero
[42:27]
in on Boulder county bats of the 20. Species in
[42:30]
Colorado. There are twelve species in Boulder county. And later
[42:34]
on I'm going to show you a list of the
[42:36]
species we actually have. Okay, so how do we know
[42:40]
what bats are in Boulder county and on open space
[42:42]
specifically? First? Off. We've been very fortunate that through our
[42:46]
small grants program and our non funded research, program. Dr.
[42:49]
Rick Adams from the University of Northern Colorado has been
[42:53]
serving and tracking bats on open space for about 20
[42:56]
years. He's a globally renowned researcher, and we're lucky to
[43:01]
have him locally. He's basically. His research is how we
[43:05]
know. Who's on our properties, and that helps us make
[43:10]
management recommendations. So over the years, Rick has conducted misnating
[43:14]
and telemetry work. Also egress surveys from historic structures. He's
[43:19]
looked at that responses to different forestry management techniques and
[43:22]
also fire response. He's kept track of elevation, migratory movements
[43:27]
using. Acoustic monitoring techniques. Say these acoustic monitors record back
[43:32]
calls, and then you can analyze them using software to
[43:34]
determine species. He's also come to open space several times
[43:38]
to talk to our department about bats in general, so
[43:40]
that we all understand. Altogether. He's an amazing bat ambassador.
[43:48]
I just want to mention here, too, that our wildlife
[43:50]
open space program has purchased acoustic monitors in the last
[43:53]
couple of years. So now we have ten and we're
[43:55]
pretty excited because we're going to repeat what Rick has
[43:57]
done over these 20 years to continue that data through
[44:01]
the years. Okay, so let's look at threats to bats
[44:04]
in Colorado overall. So energy development is like wind
[44:14]
turbines, extermination and eviction, as people typically in their homes.
[44:19]
Or elsewhere. There's rangeline management, which basically refers to riparian
[44:24]
corridor management because bats need streamside vegetation for insects and
[44:29]
other things. Pesticides. Forest fires and forest management that impacts
[44:35]
the habitat directly. Recreation is basically human disturbance, climate change,
[44:41]
which means less water on the landscape and habitat alterations.
[44:46]
And disease, including Lygno syndrome. So I just want to
[44:50]
mention here that the Colorado bat working group has threats.
[44:54]
Matrix that's. Pertinent to each bat species in Colorado, and
[44:58]
it kind of goes through all the threats that are
[45:00]
listed here and how they impact individual species. So, for
[45:05]
example, direct impacts. Of wind turbine engines. They pose an
[45:11]
immediate threat to migratory bat species like Hori bats and
[45:14]
silverhead bats. These guys are migratory, like I said. And.
[45:20]
It's been discovered that it's not the blades that actually
[45:22]
hit the bats, it's the change in air pressure and
[45:25]
that changing air pressure. Basically explodes their lungs. So that's
[45:31]
tough. It kills up to 150,000 hori bats, for instance,
[45:34]
every year. Actually, Susan, is that nationally? Nationally, yeah. Horrible.
[45:39]
Distributed across the nation. 1 second Jackson Molar Post I've
[45:46]
been doing a lot of work with compensatory mitigation with
[45:50]
energy. Have you had any success or explored. Compensation from
[45:55]
wind turbines and other energy? That's an excellent question. I
[45:58]
don't know. Yeah, I can follow up. Okay. So anyway,
[46:03]
I just wanted to mention all these threats, kind of.
[46:05]
Layered up in white nose syndrome is another one of
[46:07]
those threats. Yeah. Susan jan. George posack. As far as
[46:12]
recreation, can you give us an example of what kind
[46:15]
of recreation is a threat? To bats. Yes, I mentioned
[46:19]
liberian corridors and how important they are for bats. Let's
[46:23]
just talk about the tricolored bat. Those guys have their
[46:26]
pups and trees in Riperian. Corridors. And so, during the
[46:30]
puppering season, when. The young are not. They can't fly
[46:34]
yet, so they're just hanging out in the trees. If
[46:37]
people are underneath the trees. You can't see that they're
[46:40]
there. You don't know they're. Very cryptic, and you might
[46:43]
be making noise or the dogs barking or something, and
[46:46]
those bats might. Get scared and fall out of the
[46:48]
tree. So that's an example of how humans can affect
[46:51]
bats with recreation. Okay. All right, so let's talk about
[47:00]
white nose syndrome. It's a new species that was discovered
[47:06]
after it arrived here in the US. It is called
[47:09]
pseudo chimneys destructins, or PD for short, and it was
[47:14]
unknown to science. Before it arrived in the US, but
[47:17]
it did come. From Europe and Asia. So PD reproduces
[47:22]
using sexually created spores, as you would expect from a
[47:25]
fungus. They also send out reproductive vessels, non sexually called
[47:30]
arthrokinidia. So fungus is a very interesting organism, right? But
[47:38]
in any case, both of these vessels are long lived
[47:40]
in the environment, and they can be easily spread. They're
[47:43]
tiny by air currents, humans, water and other animals. We
[47:49]
do know that the fungus stops growing above 68 degrees
[47:53]
and it doesn't like it. Cooler than 40 degrees, which
[47:56]
is kind of exactly what the fat's like. So no
[47:59]
other animals, including humans, are known to have gotten white.
[48:01]
No syndrome other than bats. So what's interesting is PD
[48:06]
does not need a bat to grow. They're in. The
[48:08]
cave environment. It's in the cave environment, and it just
[48:11]
takes advantage of the bat. Being there. It's kind of
[48:14]
a devastating coincidence, really. So incective, bats experience the fungus
[48:20]
growing into their cellular structure. Including their circulatory system and
[48:24]
their skin, and it's very painful, and it wakes the
[48:27]
bats up. And if they're in hibernation when they wake
[48:30]
up. They're depleting their critical fat reserves. This can lead
[48:35]
to starvation. Before it gets to be spring, they leave
[48:38]
the cave and find food. But if it's the dead
[48:41]
of winter, they leave the cave, they freeze, or they
[48:43]
can't find food and. They starve. Okay, so here's a
[48:48]
big old slide. So we have 47 species of bats
[48:52]
in the US and Canada. So those half are susceptible
[49:00]
to white no syndrome because they hibernate in caves as
[49:02]
part of their life cycle. Again. Remember, not all bad's
[49:06]
hypernate. Some are migratory, similar to birds. So twelve of
[49:10]
these 47 species have experienced 95% to 100% declines. And
[49:17]
of these twelve, six are in Boulder county, where white
[49:20]
no syndrome is just showing up. So. Again, we have
[49:23]
20 species in Colorado, and of those, twelve are in
[49:26]
Boulder county. And of those twelve. Six are known to
[49:29]
be impacted by Whiteno syndrome. So half the species in
[49:34]
Boulder county are in immediate danger of flight no syndrome.
[49:37]
Susan Paula Fitzgerald. So we know six species are affected.
[49:45]
Are the other species? Potentially going to. Is it just
[49:49]
a matter of time? Or do they have some sort
[49:53]
of resistance? So if you look at the species listed
[49:57]
there, The top species are known to die from white
[50:02]
nose syndrome. Like, they get it, it grows on their
[50:05]
fur, they die. The second list there. Is. The fungus
[50:10]
is on them. It's been confirmed to be on the
[50:12]
bat, but it. Doesn't seem to. Grow and cause them
[50:17]
harm. So those bats, whatever sort of bacterial or fungal.
[50:25]
Communities on their fur and skin. Somehow PD doesn't get
[50:29]
a hold. And some bets we don't know yet. You
[50:32]
can see here, like the California Myodus. Which is not
[50:35]
in Boulder county, but it's in Colorado. It probably is
[50:39]
going to be affected, but it hasn't been yet, so
[50:41]
it's unknown. Yeah. And it's interesting because that second. List.
[50:48]
Say, like, the townsend's bigger that. They might. Well, this
[50:53]
does happen in our historic structures where we have other
[50:55]
bats and I'll. Talk about that in a minute, but
[50:57]
they might go and hang out with another species of
[51:01]
bat that is susceptible. They've got it on there fur.
[51:04]
They leave it on the wall. Or they touch noses
[51:07]
or whatever so they can actually spread it back to
[51:09]
bat. So, yeah, the good question. Okay. Now let's go
[51:17]
back to how devastating this disease is. Again, it's killed
[51:19]
over. 90% of northern long eared, little brown and tricolored
[51:24]
bat populations in the eastern US in fewer than ten
[51:28]
years. So again, we can see what could happen. Do
[51:33]
you guys have any more questions about that? Okay. So
[51:39]
let's talk about the timeline of when widenose syndrome came
[51:42]
to Colorado in February. Of 2024. There was a little
[51:49]
brown bat. That's a type of bat. It was turned
[51:53]
in by a rehabber and it tested. Positive for white
[51:56]
nose syndrome. And then from March through the end of
[52:00]
June 2024, an additional 58 bats of eight species. Were
[52:05]
submitted to the CPW health lab via rehabbers and the
[52:08]
public. So we started noticing dead bats on the ground,
[52:12]
and people were telling CPW about it, and. Turning them
[52:15]
in. So of those, an additional 32 bats tested positive
[52:19]
for white nose syndrome. Including fringed myodus, which I'll talk
[52:24]
about in a second. And one big brown bat. So
[52:28]
I should mention that at least two of these baths
[52:30]
were rehabbed and released so that's kind of a bright
[52:32]
spot. If you can get them early enough, they can
[52:35]
be saved. And there are signs of slow recovery in
[52:39]
some parts of the Midwest. Suggesting that some bats may
[52:43]
be developing natural immunity, but again, that they're slow reproduction
[52:48]
and all the other challenges. We're just crossing our fingers.
[52:52]
Susan polyfits Gerald again. So question. I had a bat
[52:56]
in my backyard last year. Middle of the day, down
[52:59]
on the ground called animal control. Became quite responsibly, but
[53:05]
wondering. Are animal control trained in white bat syndrome to
[53:11]
test for that so that you guys can keep a
[53:13]
handle on that, as well as rabies and some of
[53:16]
the more things we think of. More commonly, yeah. So
[53:19]
depending on the time of year that that bat was
[53:21]
found, was it summer? Was it summer? Yeah. They may
[53:25]
not have turned it into CPW. Huff lab because of
[53:28]
the time of year. Like if you find bats early
[53:32]
spring or winter, that's when they're leaving hibernation areas because.
[53:37]
They're itchy and running out of food storage, fat storage.
[53:40]
So they leave their hibernation. Sites. So that's when animal
[53:45]
control would probably turn it into CPW. The health lab,
[53:49]
so they're kind of trained in. Oh, definitely. Yeah, they're
[53:53]
coordinated. Susan trace Baker, Postac. You said that bats have
[53:59]
been. Successfully rehabilitated. What is the treatment? That's my next
[54:06]
slide. Okay. So. This map is updated. This is from
[54:14]
the whiteness syndrome.org website. And it's updated all the time.
[54:21]
And I just wanted to show you because it shows
[54:22]
how Colorado. Now has white nose syndrome, and you can
[54:26]
see that the colors denote whether whiteness syndrome has actually
[54:30]
been detected on a bat or if its PD has
[54:33]
been detected, but no white nut syndrome. On a bat.
[54:37]
Has been confirmed yet, so I wanted to show you
[54:40]
that. And then zooming in on Colorado. These are the
[54:44]
counties. And their status currently. So right now, Route, Laramer,
[54:51]
Boulder, Douglas, El Paso, Ataro, Otero, Bacca counties have confirmed
[54:57]
PD in the past two years. And again, the dots
[55:00]
show PD positive, but no white, no. Syndrome has been
[55:03]
detected yet. Okay, so treatments. What can we do?
[55:13]
There's no silver bullet, which is what researchers are figuring
[55:16]
out. It's got to be many different things layered up.
[55:21]
So here's some things that have been researched. By folks
[55:25]
to see how effective they are. So again, they have
[55:29]
to be effective safe for bats and other animals and
[55:31]
also the environment. So that's another consideration, but biological? Techniques,
[55:39]
they can stimulate the growth of beneficial microorganisms that either
[55:42]
attack or secrete substances that attack PD. Or compete with
[55:47]
PD in other ways. Probiotics, they can apply a probiotic
[55:52]
mix of bacteria and fungi naturally found on bat wings
[55:56]
to kill or weaken. PD Kaidovan is a naturally derived
[56:00]
antifungal agent. With wound healing and antiinflammatory properties. It decreases
[56:06]
infection rates and limits tissue damages. Then bacteria. You can
[56:11]
apply strains of bacteria that have antifungal activity properties. UV
[56:16]
light. You can kill the spores with uv light. Of
[56:21]
certain wavelengths. Just a note on that. This is an
[56:25]
example of if you put a uv light in a
[56:28]
cave. What else were you killing with that light? So
[56:30]
again, this applies to all these. And then a vaccine,
[56:35]
which is being developed now. Delivers a protective. Immune response.
[56:41]
And I'm going to play this little clip here. I
[56:43]
hope it works. This is a little brown bat getting
[56:48]
a very big dose of vaccine. And this was in
[56:51]
July. Of 2024. And this is CPW at work. I'm
[56:57]
going to play it again. Yeah, he's just like. I
[57:07]
mean, that's a huge pipette for him, but that's the
[57:09]
amount they need to give him. And I'm going to
[57:12]
talk more about that vaccine trial. Whatever the vehicle is,
[57:16]
it must be very tasty. Yeah, actually, I didn't ask.
[57:19]
I don't know. I'm playing it again. One more time.
[57:28]
Okay. He kind of has to take it. Okay.
[57:40]
All right, so just a bit more on CPW's current
[57:42]
vaccination effort. So this happened up in Larmer county in
[57:49]
2024. 200 bats were captured at a site that's known
[57:53]
to have. These are little brown bats. And there's a
[57:55]
huge colony up there. 200 bats were captured and 100
[57:58]
were given either a vaccine or a placebo. All the
[58:02]
bats received wing bands. All were pit tagged for mark
[58:06]
recapture. Studies this year that are going to happen. The
[58:11]
effort is being done in other states as well, using.
[58:15]
Similar methodology, including Wyoming, Idaho, Montana, West Virginia and Wisconsin.
[58:20]
So that's a really good coordinated effort. So, again, giving
[58:25]
these vaccines to the bats, you have to do it
[58:27]
by hand, but they're. Thinking of other ways to distribute
[58:30]
the vaccine, such as an aerial spray or they've talked
[58:34]
about maybe. Smearing it on the wall of the cave
[58:39]
and the bats land on it and then lick. It
[58:40]
off their fur, so there's some ideas being bantered about.
[58:45]
So of interest. The vaccine uses a modified raccoon pox
[58:48]
virus to deliver the fungal. Antigens. And this is the
[58:54]
same process that's been used for plague vaccine for blackfooted.
[58:58]
Ferrets and prairie dogs. And we at open space have
[59:01]
been using that vaccine since 2016. On our prairie dogs.
[59:07]
And that's been successful. So crossing fingers for the bats.
[59:12]
Okay, so current internal management practices. At BCPos. So what
[59:19]
are we doing at open space? Both in response to
[59:21]
whiteness. Syndrome, but also for bats in general. So these
[59:25]
two structures that are shown on this slide. Have multiple
[59:29]
species maternity colonies inside them. That's why I put them
[59:33]
on the slide. So the top one is called the
[59:36]
Rocky Mountain mammoth, and the one on the bottom is
[59:39]
a. Barn structure at Myers Gulch, which seems to be
[59:42]
a summer roost for bats. So for many years, we've
[59:48]
been focused on what we can do to basically make
[59:50]
bats. Lives easier knowing that they are threatened by many
[59:53]
different things. And now, especially in light of white no
[59:58]
syndrome. So climate change, as we talked about, is one
[1:00:02]
threat to bats. And one aspect of this is less
[1:00:04]
water on the landscape. So Rick Adams bringing him, and
[1:00:09]
again, he's done a lot of research at Highlevelley. Ranch
[1:00:12]
in gear canyon, specifically. And one of his studies telematured.
[1:00:16]
He misnetted and then telemetured. Different species and found that
[1:00:20]
there's a fringed meiotis maternity colony up in these palisades
[1:00:24]
up in Gear Canyon. And so we have three different
[1:00:27]
species of maternity. Colonies in this palisade, which is a
[1:00:30]
rock facing slope. Sorry. A rock palisade. And so what
[1:00:39]
we found is that. With less water on the landscape.
[1:00:44]
We decided to try this, and this is a linear
[1:00:46]
water feature. For the bats to water from, because when
[1:00:50]
you have a maternity colony, those female mother bats, they're
[1:00:53]
nursing their pups all day long, and so when they
[1:00:56]
emerge at night, they're basically little raisins. They are just
[1:01:00]
dry. Right. And so they need to find water immediately.
[1:01:03]
And so to make it easier and to keep it
[1:01:05]
available longer into the summer. This is the idea with
[1:01:08]
this linear feature. We're calling it a bat trough. And
[1:01:11]
we used youth core to build it, and they loved
[1:01:13]
it, and we taught them about bats. And it's fed
[1:01:16]
by gear creek like I said so the water percolates
[1:01:18]
back into. Gear Creek, but it does get held for
[1:01:21]
a little bit longer, and it doesn't have the vegetation
[1:01:24]
in the way of the bats. So right after we
[1:01:27]
built that, We asked Rick to put up an acoustic
[1:01:30]
monitor. So that's when an acoustic monitor looks. Like. And
[1:01:34]
those fringe meiotis. The maternity colony that I was talking
[1:01:36]
about. Those guys that's. The big graph there, so they
[1:01:40]
used it immediately, and. Often. So basically, they could come
[1:01:44]
right out of their roost and go straight to this
[1:01:47]
water. So we only know of two friends of Myodius
[1:01:51]
maternity colonies. In Boulder county, they don't use historic structures,
[1:01:56]
they use rock faces. So it's really hard to find
[1:01:59]
them. So when we do find them, we treat them
[1:02:01]
very carefully. For instance, we had a forestry project that
[1:02:05]
was going on in Deer Canyon. And we buffered the
[1:02:10]
maternity colony by a lot so that they would still
[1:02:13]
have their forging habitat intact right outside their roost. Okay.
[1:02:19]
We're going to continuously monitor this area. Okay, so another
[1:02:23]
thing we've been doing for many years is the installation
[1:02:25]
of specialized escape. Ramps in stock tanks. And in spring
[1:02:33]
development. So bats use stock tanks for water, and they
[1:02:37]
often get stuck as we know, sometimes lots of animals
[1:02:40]
get stuck in stock tanks, so these escape ramps help
[1:02:43]
the animals swim. Around the edge, and then they find
[1:02:46]
it and they crawl out. So currently we have 30
[1:02:49]
fabricated. Metal escape ramps and then five constructed rock ramps.
[1:02:58]
Another thing I want to mention on this slide is
[1:02:59]
that our tenants all received so our agricultural tenants all
[1:03:03]
received a letter back in mid 2024 from uS outlining
[1:03:08]
the arrival of Whiteno syndrome. What it is, what it
[1:03:11]
means, what to do if you find a dead bat,
[1:03:12]
because. They have a lot of barn structures and things
[1:03:14]
on our agricultural properties. And that letter went out to
[1:03:18]
all of our 60 tenants. Okay, so another big part
[1:03:21]
of our program is managing historic structures that house bats.
[1:03:26]
So this is the blue jay mine up near Jamestown.
[1:03:28]
It houses a maternity colony of bats, but also was
[1:03:30]
receiving a lot of public access that was kind of
[1:03:33]
unmanaged. They were lighting fires in the structure and. Doing
[1:03:40]
other dangerous things. So we all work together in the
[1:03:44]
department and our grands crew formalized the site with the
[1:03:48]
fencing you see there that was put up. And eno.
[1:03:54]
Created an installed interpretive signage to tell the public what
[1:03:57]
the property is, and it also mentions the bats and
[1:04:02]
our buildings and historic preservation closed that hoist house entrance.
[1:04:07]
And then the wildlife group, we created that signage. So
[1:04:12]
we close those windows so that the bats could still
[1:04:15]
come in and out, and then we interpreted it for
[1:04:17]
the public to hopefully understand that there are bats in
[1:04:19]
there. So moving forward with this site in relation to
[1:04:22]
Whitenose syndrome. We're investigating the collection of guano. Samples, which
[1:04:26]
can tell you if you have the fungus, because the
[1:04:30]
fungus survives through the digestive. System. Yeah. I just want
[1:04:38]
to mention, too, that anytime. We enter these structures for
[1:04:42]
any reason, we'll try to do it after the puppearing.
[1:04:45]
Season. But also we have a decontamination protocol. That we
[1:04:49]
are working on now across the department. It's basically 70%
[1:04:53]
isopropyl alcohol solution that you spray. Okay. And is that
[1:05:01]
decontamination for the people working on it, or is this
[1:05:04]
for other bats. Oh, that's for the people. Okay. Yeah,
[1:05:08]
if we could decontaminate the bats. Okay, so this is
[1:05:12]
the cardinal mill, and you guys have a lot of.
[1:05:14]
You have been up. There. It hosts several species of
[1:05:16]
maternity colonies. It's pretty big time for bats. So what?
[1:05:20]
We've done for many years is conduct public tours. We
[1:05:23]
do it later in the season. After the puffering seasonist
[1:05:26]
pup ring is mostly done. We've also conducted egress surveys
[1:05:31]
to determine how late in the season the bats are
[1:05:33]
still there. So we've also done thermal imaging surveys. You
[1:05:39]
can see in one of the photos are the little
[1:05:41]
slats on the ceiling are really hard to see the
[1:05:43]
bats in there. They tuck themselves into these lofts and
[1:05:47]
so with thermal. Imaging we can get a better sense
[1:05:49]
of where they are. So that was helpful, and we
[1:05:53]
did that through. A contractor. But we also have started
[1:05:59]
to conduct maintenance outside the puppering season. So anything buildings
[1:06:03]
and historic preservation. Do they typically wait until the end
[1:06:06]
of the season? As far as possible. So the species
[1:06:09]
in the cardinal mill, we've got long legged myodus, which
[1:06:13]
is. Not typically found in human built structures and. They're
[1:06:19]
also really highly disturbed by a human presence. That particular
[1:06:22]
species we have little brown bats. And again, those guys
[1:06:25]
have lost 95% of their population in the eastern United
[1:06:28]
States because of white no syndrome, and they are petitioned
[1:06:31]
for listing right now. Federally. We also have small footed
[1:06:35]
myodus, which is third most rare species. In Boulder county
[1:06:39]
by numbers. And right now, it's not clear that that
[1:06:42]
species are going to be impacted by whiteness syndrome. So
[1:06:45]
people are kind of waiting. They are western species, so
[1:06:47]
we're not sure. Yet. And then big brown bats are
[1:06:50]
also in this structure. So, moving forward, in response to
[1:06:54]
whitenose, syndrome. We're discussing this year's public access and whether
[1:06:57]
to wait a year. Or to not visit the structure,
[1:07:00]
or if we do, wait until mid September after the
[1:07:02]
young have dispersed. And if we do this, we will
[1:07:05]
require decontamination of all visitors and staff. And then. We'll
[1:07:12]
continue to monitor doing egress surveys and acoustic monitoring at
[1:07:15]
this site and that first picture with the circled areas
[1:07:19]
on the cardinal, that's the egress sites. Where they're all
[1:07:22]
coming out at night. So we've identified those important exit
[1:07:26]
areas. Susan paula fitzgerald again. Has it been found that
[1:07:31]
white nose syndrome transfers from bats to people? No, it
[1:07:35]
doesn't. No. Doesn't affect humans. Okay, so back to the
[1:07:42]
Rocky Mountain mammoth. This is another historic structure with several
[1:07:45]
species using for maternity colonies. It's also used as a
[1:07:51]
migratory roof site for species such as townspoons bigard bats.
[1:07:56]
This is of interest to me because my family owned
[1:07:58]
this property for about 100 years. So we started conducting
[1:08:02]
bat surveys around 2006, which was before the county owned
[1:08:06]
it. In 2009, the county purchased this site. Its historical
[1:08:11]
significance. And it's now in the National Historic Register, thanks
[1:08:16]
to the county. It's the most well maintained. Preserved shaft
[1:08:24]
house in all of Boulder county. Like it didn't get
[1:08:27]
picked apart for Barnwood. Somehow because our family was there.
[1:08:31]
So anyway, for Whitenose syndrome again, this structure. Is intermittently
[1:08:37]
visited for Hard Rock mining tour and we're going to
[1:08:41]
wait. We already have been waiting until later in the
[1:08:44]
season to do those, but this is again, more discussions
[1:08:47]
amongst our group as Whitenous syndrome is here. Are we
[1:08:50]
going to visit it this year? If we do are
[1:08:53]
we going to decontaminate and when are we going to
[1:08:55]
visit? Janet, you have a question? Yeah. Janet George Posack.
[1:09:03]
So when you're talking about Ruse and this building and
[1:09:06]
the one before. How many individuals are we talking about?
[1:09:10]
Adults. Stick with that hundreds. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Interesting. Yeah.
[1:09:18]
And actually, on that note, the CPW vaccine. It may
[1:09:22]
be unrelated to Janice, but this picture on the left,
[1:09:26]
what are we looking at there? Is there a bad
[1:09:28]
hiding in there that I should be looking for? Well,
[1:09:30]
there is a bat. There, but you can't see him.
[1:09:33]
Yeah, that shows they tuck themselves up into those little.
[1:09:36]
Crevices. You don't see it. I see a bunch. But
[1:09:43]
you can hear them. It's pretty interesting when you sneak
[1:09:46]
around outside of this structure. In the middle of the
[1:09:48]
summer. You can hear the young talking to their moms.
[1:09:51]
It's. Just squeaky, squeaky, squeaky. There's a lot of them.
[1:09:55]
Yeah. Susan pulls or Janet George again, Postac. So if
[1:10:00]
there's hundreds of bats in a couple of these places,
[1:10:02]
is there some monitoring? You can do to detect any
[1:10:05]
changes in population numbers. That's a great question. We can
[1:10:10]
monitor using those acoustic monitors. We can do passes per
[1:10:14]
night. So relative activity of a site and then we
[1:10:18]
can identify to species, so it's. Kind of the activity
[1:10:21]
in general, we can monitor. We can't count the bats,
[1:10:25]
necessarily. With that process, but we can get a general
[1:10:30]
sense. So with acoustic monitor. What percentage of the population
[1:10:36]
decline or increase would you need to actually detect it?
[1:10:39]
Are we talking 30%, 50%. But I'm just wondering. Say
[1:10:48]
you record 100,000 calls, right? And then. Say half of
[1:10:55]
those are analyzable due to the quality of the recording.
[1:11:01]
That's pretty consistent. Across. All the software analysis. So what
[1:11:09]
am I trying to tell you? Not all car calls
[1:11:13]
are identifiable. Identifiable? But it's pretty consistent which ones are.
[1:11:22]
What percentage of the calls are from each individual species,
[1:11:25]
so I think you could detect even up to a
[1:11:28]
10% decline because we have the baseline data already. We've
[1:11:32]
done acoustic monitoring. There already. So. Yeah, I hope that
[1:11:36]
helps. Yeah. Thanks. That's really good. And a wild population
[1:11:40]
to be able to detect that small of a change.
[1:11:42]
Yeah, so good job. Okay. Thanks. Yeah. Okay. Well, I
[1:11:47]
wanted to say, in addition, that we've been poking at
[1:11:50]
CPW to be part of their vaccine trial. This could
[1:11:53]
be a spot for that. And so could the cardinal
[1:11:55]
because it's easily accessible by the researchers. There's a lot
[1:11:58]
of bat. Bats. So we'll see. I don't know. Crossing
[1:12:02]
our fingers again. Okay. All right, so this is our
[1:12:09]
internal team. We have our white nose syndrome response team,
[1:12:15]
and basically we've convened all workgroups. That might interface with
[1:12:18]
bats or bad habitat. We've started by discussing. What we
[1:12:24]
already do for bats within each workgroup and what Whitenose
[1:12:27]
syndrome will mean. For our future management actions. We also
[1:12:31]
have CPW come and give us an overview on Wyno
[1:12:34]
syndrome altogether so that we understand it and ask questions
[1:12:37]
as a group. So again, the department understands the importance
[1:12:41]
of bats and this severe threat and our overarching goal
[1:12:44]
is to again make their lives easier while Whiteno syndrome
[1:12:47]
arrives and probably is going to wreak havoc. We're also
[1:12:51]
coordinating with the city of Longmont, City, Boulder, OSFP on
[1:12:55]
their strategies. Too, to kind of inform and learn from
[1:12:57]
each other. So we're hoping to not assist the spread
[1:13:01]
of spores by again using those decontamination. Protocols. And we're
[1:13:07]
also committed to limiting disturbance, especially in these first few
[1:13:11]
years. Of it's here now. We're also going to be
[1:13:16]
on the lookout for dead bats very soon, because, again,
[1:13:18]
this is the time of year that they might start
[1:13:20]
showing up. And we're developing an eternal response team to
[1:13:25]
collect any dead bats and get them out. To the
[1:13:27]
CPW Health lab. Susan tony lewis with postac I'm curious
[1:13:32]
if this came from. Europe and asia. How long has
[1:13:37]
it been there and what treatments have they figured out?
[1:13:41]
What have we learned from her continents across the sea.
[1:13:46]
Yeah, the bats there are immune to it. They're not
[1:13:49]
really. Impacted, really. They've probably coevolved with it for thousands
[1:13:54]
and thousands of years, so. It's there. It's there? Yeah,
[1:13:57]
it's part of the system. It hadn't been identified. Because
[1:14:00]
it's just a fungus among lots of fungus. But when
[1:14:04]
it came here, it had no competition. No resistance, right?
[1:14:17]
Like a wall joke. So public involvement. So at this
[1:14:22]
time of year, again, this is when we might start
[1:14:24]
seeing dead bats. And as they arouse early from hibernation
[1:14:29]
through the infection. So CPW has a bat hotline to
[1:14:32]
report dead bats, where you can send an email with
[1:14:35]
any sort of questions or concerns. And again, the color
[1:14:40]
of that working group has a conservation plan, which is
[1:14:42]
also super helpful in understanding how to help the bats.
[1:14:48]
And spread the word. Talk to your neighbors. A lot
[1:14:50]
of its education about the importance of bats. And changing
[1:14:53]
the attitude that that's, you know what? They're not scary.
[1:14:57]
They're incredibly important for us as humans and for the
[1:14:59]
ecosystem. Yeah. Susan, one other question. Talk to us about
[1:15:07]
bat boxes, right? Yeah. Actually, I'm glad you said that.
[1:15:10]
I'm. Just kind of curious if that's a good thing,
[1:15:12]
bad thing. How do you view that? With the white
[1:15:15]
nose syndrome as well. I think it's a good thing
[1:15:18]
again to try to make bats lives easier, right? We
[1:15:21]
actually talked about with our building and historic preservation group
[1:15:26]
is they be willing to build sort of larger structures
[1:15:29]
that would house bats. And they're totally down with that,
[1:15:34]
so we're going to try that. Eventually. But. It doesn't
[1:15:40]
have to be like a bat boxy stick on the
[1:15:41]
side of a house. It can be an actual, like,
[1:15:43]
a shed structure. With certain little heidi holes and nooks
[1:15:46]
and things for the bats. Great. Yeah. Trace Baker post
[1:15:51]
sack. Susan. That was an excellent, detailed presentation. I loved
[1:15:56]
all the photographs. Great. So. Thank you. My question. One
[1:16:01]
of your slides. Had a picture of the continental us.
[1:16:07]
And Mexico and Canada with infected areas. And I noticed
[1:16:12]
that those areas are not contiguous. And so. How does
[1:16:18]
the syndrome propagate across those very large areas? That's a
[1:16:24]
great question. You're right. You're saying some counties don't have
[1:16:27]
it. There was, like, none in Idaho. Yeah. There. That's
[1:16:34]
the picture. Well, wait. Nevada? Yes. So basically it showed
[1:16:41]
up in New York in 2006. It's been moving across.
[1:16:46]
The country ever since. So it's now arriving in the
[1:16:48]
west. So that explains Idaho and Nevada and Utah, arizona.
[1:16:52]
It just hasn't gotten there yet, and we're hoping it
[1:16:54]
doesn't. Okay. That's why I wanted to mention Utah, because
[1:16:56]
that's pretty. Bad that it showed up there. In Florida?
[1:17:00]
I can't explain, other than it's warm and they don't.
[1:17:03]
Hibernate. Probably in Florida. We don't have a lot of
[1:17:05]
hibernating. Batch in Florida. And then some of those areas
[1:17:09]
probably don't have suitable hibernation areas for bats. You need
[1:17:16]
that substrate. You need mines, you need caves. Carl's bed
[1:17:20]
caverns. Got white nose bat. Where is that? Mexico. It
[1:17:28]
sure looks like it. Yeah, I think I heard that.
[1:17:31]
It's recently confirmed. That Christine Johnson Post act.
[1:17:43]
That makes me wonder what kind of federal resources and
[1:17:47]
federal coordination there is. And to what extent people are
[1:17:53]
looking for it, or are we on our own and
[1:17:55]
just. Working within the county and with CPW. Maybe someone
[1:18:01]
else knows that. I don't know. I don't think the
[1:18:04]
federal response it took a long time for the feds
[1:18:06]
to get. Interested. I think if you tie it back
[1:18:10]
to the damage to humans. In fact, here's something that
[1:18:14]
was released last year. So in the county's back east
[1:18:17]
that have white no syndrome and all these die offs.
[1:18:24]
It's been shown that farmers have to use 35% more
[1:18:27]
chemicals and pesticides and that has been. A direct connected
[1:18:32]
the dots directly to an increase in infant mortality. 8%
[1:18:37]
increase. So that's a pretty stark tie in. And you
[1:18:41]
would hope that that would get federal. Response. I'm sure
[1:18:45]
there's money. I don't know why it's not like they're
[1:18:48]
pouring money into this because bats are critical for us.
[1:18:53]
I don't want to misspeak. I'm not all that knowledgeable
[1:18:56]
about it. But I mentioned that a couple of species.
[1:19:02]
Are supposed to be listed soon. Like the tricolored bat
[1:19:04]
with the fish and Wildlife Service. And my guess is
[1:19:06]
that's on hold for a while, which means I won't.
[1:19:08]
Get that kind of federal protection, unfortunately. Right now. I
[1:19:13]
mean, it was supposed to be listed a year ago.
[1:19:15]
I don't know. What the hold up is. Yeah. Other
[1:19:20]
questions. Susan paula fitzgerald, so I know this is just
[1:19:25]
one. Of many things on your plate that you're monitoring,
[1:19:33]
you're studying. You're trying to mitigate certain things, and I
[1:19:38]
just want to applaud your efforts, because this is huge.
[1:19:41]
This is a big project, and I hope you have
[1:19:44]
staffing. And I know you probably have support from parks
[1:19:49]
and open space, but I'm just impressed. By. Here. You've
[1:19:55]
been given this. In just very recent years. And being
[1:20:00]
able to manage everything together is a big thing. To
[1:20:04]
you and good luck on it. Thank you. Other comments.
[1:20:12]
Thank you, Susan. That was a great presentation. We really
[1:20:15]
appreciate it. Thank you. Is there anybody here in the
[1:20:19]
audience that wanted to comment on this agenda item? See?
[1:20:25]
None. Nick, is there anybody online? I'll give a second
[1:20:29]
for anybody on the zoom call. If you would like
[1:20:31]
to make a public comment for this agenda item, please
[1:20:34]
use the raise hand feature. I am not seeing any
[1:20:38]
raised hands. Great. Thank you, Nick. Thank you, Susan. Thank
[1:20:41]
you. Okay, we're going to move to public comment period
[1:20:48]
for items not on the agenda and I think we
[1:20:51]
have some folks here in the audience. That were planning
[1:20:54]
to speak to us. Would you like to come up
[1:20:59]
and talk to us? Anybody? I have a list, it
[1:21:03]
looks like. I think, Nick, that you gave me is
[1:21:06]
Cindy Johnson. And then deborah kanette, eileen, carmen, janie.
[1:21:18]
Is that your whole crew? They're not all here. Some
[1:21:21]
people. Were giving me their minutes online. I thought they
[1:21:27]
had to be here. I don't know. Did they have
[1:21:29]
to be here? Who knows? I think what would be
[1:21:33]
helpful if you're pooling time. To just cap it at
[1:21:37]
ten minutes. Would be great. I think I can do
[1:21:41]
that. Thank you. And if you'll state your name. And
[1:21:45]
where you live in Boulder county. No address, specific information,
[1:21:49]
just like where generally. Last time I was here. There's
[1:21:53]
only five of you. I know. Nice to see you.
[1:21:56]
It's a little overwhelming. Thank you. My name is Cindy
[1:22:02]
Johnson, and I'm from Boulder County. I am here to
[1:22:06]
continue our discussion. Could you please hold the microphone just
[1:22:09]
a little bit closer? To you. Thank you. You have
[1:22:12]
to get really close to these. I am here to
[1:22:16]
continue our discussion on horse communities. Thoughts and concerns on
[1:22:20]
the cancellation of our public open writing sessions in the
[1:22:23]
winter months. One day a week at the Boulder county
[1:22:26]
fairground. As you know, there are hundreds of historical equine
[1:22:31]
activities and event. Events. And agricultural events taking place at
[1:22:35]
the fairgrounds. We no doubt will be working together in
[1:22:39]
the future on these events and therefore we wish to
[1:22:41]
keep our relationships good and amicable with you. We respect
[1:22:48]
your commitment to parks and open space, but want to
[1:22:50]
make sure the decisions concerning the fairgrounds were made. With.
[1:22:56]
Accurate information. And adequate public input. The information we have
[1:23:01]
received leads us to believe this decision was driven by
[1:23:05]
staff without connecting with the actual stakeholders who are affected
[1:23:09]
by this decision. To begin, the horse community would like
[1:23:13]
some answers. To our questions, and I know you can't
[1:23:16]
answer them at this time, but maybe we could have
[1:23:18]
an audience later. First question. We submitted a petition. With
[1:23:26]
over 100 signatures signed by Boulder county residents. This is
[1:23:30]
just a copy of it. A lot of these people
[1:23:32]
were in the indoor arena attending an equine event when
[1:23:35]
we collected the signatures. They were shocked. We gave the
[1:23:39]
petition to the county commissioners to share with you and
[1:23:43]
review. Or comment. Our question is. Did you see it?
[1:23:48]
If so, what was your response, and did it mean
[1:23:52]
anything to you and Cindy? Could I ask? When you
[1:23:55]
gave it to the commissioners. In September, I believe. Okay.
[1:24:00]
Thanks. You bet. What are your reasons for the second
[1:24:04]
one is what are your reasons for closing the only
[1:24:06]
public indoor riding session one day a week. We were
[1:24:09]
told that there were not enough staff. Is that true.
[1:24:13]
When we wrote letters to you, Pozack staff responded. Another
[1:24:18]
reason they gave us was you had a tight budget.
[1:24:22]
And quote and the amount of revenue it generates. And
[1:24:25]
staff time does not add up to keeping it open
[1:24:27]
and that you are not going to change your opinion.
[1:24:31]
End quote. We pay a minimum usage fee along with
[1:24:35]
our taxes for this service. With all due respect, this
[1:24:38]
public writing session is supposed to be a community service.
[1:24:42]
Open space is a beautiful example of the gift, community
[1:24:45]
service that you already give us, and we so appreciate
[1:24:48]
it. So how is this any different is what I'm
[1:24:51]
asking. Can you tell us what is currently scheduled in
[1:24:55]
the indoor arena on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays. We were
[1:24:59]
informed it was for doing maintenance on equipment. Is that
[1:25:03]
true? And if that is. So don't you have an
[1:25:05]
operations facility? And I'm certainly hoping you're not using the
[1:25:09]
indoor arena as a garage. Okay, number four, with all
[1:25:14]
the information and knowledge you have gained over the last
[1:25:16]
six months from our communications with you. Have you decided
[1:25:20]
that now is the time to take some favorable action
[1:25:23]
before the winter is over. I have been passionately trying
[1:25:26]
to find a simple solution for all of this. I'm
[1:25:30]
so determined, it prompted me to do some research on
[1:25:33]
my own with other fairgrounds and how they handle open
[1:25:36]
writing sessions. By contrast, I discovered our neighbors at Jefferson
[1:25:41]
county fairgrounds have used a practical approach that can serve
[1:25:45]
as an example of a best practices solution. The events
[1:25:49]
coordinator schedules open ride dates based on how many of
[1:25:52]
the 900 equine events that are going on and chooses
[1:25:55]
a slow day? During the week to offer open ride.
[1:25:59]
She then contacts her operations manager and they get it
[1:26:01]
ready. She said it's no big. Deal and that it
[1:26:04]
takes them one day to prepare the arena for usage.
[1:26:07]
They also have a John Deere tractor, just like our
[1:26:10]
fairgrounds has. And they say it's old and they only
[1:26:13]
do maintenance on it two times a month or as
[1:26:16]
needed. We would like to know what is going on
[1:26:19]
in the indoor arena again Tuesday, Wednesdays and Thursdays. I
[1:26:22]
went by there today and there was nothing going on.
[1:26:24]
It looked immaculate. It looked clean and it was ready
[1:26:27]
for horses. Surely there must be one of those three
[1:26:31]
weekdays that Rebecca and Joe could schedule three or four
[1:26:33]
times a month for public open ride if Boulder wants
[1:26:37]
to. Pride itself on being an inclusive community. We need
[1:26:40]
to change our current model and practices to include this
[1:26:43]
essential part of our agricultural heritage. Without it, we are
[1:26:47]
being exclusive, which will cause us to lose touch with
[1:26:49]
our roots. I have a whole diatribe of stuff I
[1:26:53]
was going to say to you. Still have five minutes
[1:26:57]
and 40. I'll continue. So this isn't our first rodeo,
[1:27:03]
and this is just a bump in. A bump in.
[1:27:05]
The road to us. But we remember. 25 years ago,
[1:27:09]
I stood in front of you. When open space was
[1:27:12]
worried about the possibility that hordes of people would be
[1:27:15]
using open space. So we needed to work together on
[1:27:19]
how to make it sustainable for all users. We spent
[1:27:22]
countless hours helping Pozac, agonizing over all sorts of concerns
[1:27:28]
to preserve our horse communities. Rights and others to ride
[1:27:31]
and enjoy open space. We were told many things that
[1:27:35]
we proved not to be true. Here are just a
[1:27:38]
few to give you an example. Horses cause social trails.
[1:27:42]
Not true. Horses have 4ft that land in different places.
[1:27:45]
Unlike a bicycle tread that creates a social trail with
[1:27:48]
a single line. Number two. Horses are a threat to
[1:27:51]
wildlife. Not true. We simply explain the predator prey relationship.
[1:27:56]
Horses are prey animals, just like wildlife. They are not
[1:27:59]
a threat. Dogs are. However, they are predators. Horses. Spread
[1:28:03]
noxious weeds. Not true. Horses avoid them in the pasture
[1:28:07]
and it would be irresponsible if we, the stewards of
[1:28:09]
our. Horses and the land fed them weeds. We do
[1:28:13]
not feed our horses noxious weeds. Therefore, they don't pass
[1:28:16]
them. Okay. Let's see. Well. I'm not sure where it
[1:28:26]
went. But anyway, truly, I believe. Together. Oh. As a
[1:28:30]
result, my involvement with open space. I became an open
[1:28:33]
space mountain guide volunteer. Trail guide on horseback. We are
[1:28:37]
the eyes and ears for open space. Continuing to protect
[1:28:40]
it, I would like to keep my herd of horses
[1:28:42]
healthy, sound and in shape so I may continue this.
[1:28:45]
Labor of love. In the indoor riding arena. The horse
[1:28:49]
community has had the opportunity to speak publicly since August
[1:28:53]
to the county commissioners three times. We've been before them
[1:28:57]
when we her first heard of the cancellation, and this
[1:28:59]
is our second time in front of PoSac. We honestly
[1:29:02]
can't. Think of a reasonable cause to shut down. Open
[1:29:05]
rise. We can't even use your outdoor. Arena when there
[1:29:08]
is snow like today on the ground. I drove by
[1:29:11]
it today and it's. Covered with snow. However, the parking
[1:29:13]
lot is immaculate and perfectly plowed. So truly. I believe
[1:29:20]
together we can create a clear. And easy path to
[1:29:25]
a reasonable solution where we all can benefit. Don't you?
[1:29:29]
We just. Need to adopt a few neighboring practices and
[1:29:32]
be creative to make it easier for the staff to
[1:29:35]
implement. For example, an open ride could be offered any
[1:29:38]
of those three days. Where the arena is not currently
[1:29:42]
being used. They just need to choose. There's so much
[1:29:45]
flexibility in this plan. All we are asking for is
[1:29:48]
the opportunity to try this again. Let's go back to
[1:29:51]
the drawing board. Don't you agree? It's such an easy
[1:29:54]
fix we can do. This. So, in closing, I'll leave
[1:29:56]
you with this final thought on the best way to
[1:29:59]
proceed. And. I am specifically requesting that you decide. Tonight,
[1:30:09]
if possible, to reopen the. Boulder fairgrounds public indoor arena
[1:30:14]
to open ride in winter months three or four times
[1:30:17]
a month this is only with respect to open. Rides
[1:30:22]
which benefit our four h kids and the horse community
[1:30:26]
at large. You have heard from hundreds of concerned constituents.
[1:30:30]
It's time for action. And as my son would say,
[1:30:35]
Mom. Pull up your cowboy boots and get her done.
[1:30:38]
Thank you. Thank you, Cindy. I really appreciate your comments.
[1:30:42]
Sure, that'd be great. Absolutely. Thank you. Absolutely. Thank you
[1:30:47]
for coming. Do we have other folks here that would
[1:30:52]
like to speak as well? Okay, we'll get to those.
[1:30:59]
I just want to make sure your fan base here,
[1:31:01]
okay? Nick. Do we have folks who are ready to
[1:31:07]
speak on zoom? Yeah. For anybody on zoom, use the
[1:31:10]
raise hand feature. We got a Howard reinstain I'm. Going
[1:31:13]
to allow you to talk, Howard. You'll unmute yourself and
[1:31:17]
you'll. Have three minutes. And if you'll please introduce yourself
[1:31:21]
and where you live. Thank you. My name is howard.
[1:31:27]
Einstein. And I don't live in Boulder County. I live
[1:31:29]
in Adams county. But I have been fortunate enough to
[1:31:34]
have utilized Boulder county open space. As well as the
[1:31:39]
Boulder county indoor fairground facilities. For 25 years. And I
[1:31:45]
certainly appreciate that you allow out of county people to
[1:31:48]
do that as well. And certainly as an out of
[1:31:52]
county person who doesn't pay Boulder county taxes, I have
[1:31:56]
no problem with paying an additional fee to be able
[1:31:59]
to utilize both your open space, but your indoor riding
[1:32:03]
at this time of year. I just want to support
[1:32:06]
all of the things that Cindy said. Colorado and Boulder
[1:32:11]
county and other counties have always been. Agriculture equestrian. Based.
[1:32:20]
Sort of counties. They started that way. The equestrian business.
[1:32:24]
The equestrian heritage is strong in Boulder county, strong with
[1:32:29]
those of us across the state, and we would like
[1:32:33]
an opportunity to be able to continue. To support that
[1:32:37]
heritage and those traditions in your community. At your indoor
[1:32:42]
arena and would appreciate. You. Reestablishing open sessions, open writing
[1:32:51]
sessions for the public. As Cindy said, three or four
[1:32:55]
times a week, one day a week. And allow those
[1:33:00]
of us in the Boulder county community, as well as
[1:33:04]
the extended community, to continue to utilize that wonderful facility.
[1:33:10]
And. Help. Boulder county equestrians. Thank you. Thank you, Howard.
[1:33:17]
Nick others. Let's go to Heather Middleton. Great heather.
[1:33:27]
Are you on? Can you hear me? Yeah, I can.
[1:33:31]
Great. Hi. And I live in Boulder county, and I'm
[1:33:35]
here to advocate for keeping open writing available. At the
[1:33:39]
Boulder County Fairgrounds Indoor horse arena. My daughter recently joined
[1:33:46]
four h and as newcomers to the community, How valuable.
[1:33:53]
However, I've also noticed how few kids seem to be
[1:33:57]
involved, especially in the horse project. One likely reason. Is
[1:34:06]
that for months of the year, kids can't. Due to
[1:34:11]
the weather, having a public facility like the fairgrounds for
[1:34:15]
open writing could make a huge difference in repainting kids
[1:34:19]
in the gram. And encouraging new families to join. I
[1:34:25]
was fortunate to have a friend guide us into forage.
[1:34:30]
Families who don't have that connection. Instead of expanding fostering
[1:34:35]
opportunities for youth, it feels resources are being. Moved for
[1:34:42]
affordable. Community based programs like for. Heather, we're losing you.
[1:34:54]
Your connection is bad, I think.
[1:35:05]
Heather, can you hear us? I can hear. Her. We're
[1:35:12]
getting a very broken. Oh, shoot. You have
[1:35:22]
been to the. City could finish. Can you hear me?
[1:35:30]
We're getting bits and pieces. Yes. I will sign off.
[1:35:38]
I agree with everything Cindy said. And. Hope that we
[1:35:44]
can find a solution. Thank you. Nick. Who else?
[1:35:53]
I'm going to give one more second for more hands.
[1:35:58]
I don't see any. Rhonda nicole. Okay. Rhonda.
[1:36:12]
There she is. Rhonda, are you with us?
[1:36:21]
I'm here now. Awesome. Do you want to introduce yourself?
[1:36:25]
And you have three minutes for comment. Okay. How about
[1:36:35]
now? I'm 72 years old and I'm still riding my
[1:36:44]
horses and enjoying the Colorado agriculture community. I am a
[1:36:49]
native Colorado. I have used the Boulder county fairground indoor
[1:36:53]
arena for decades and I remember the Powow rodeo grounds
[1:37:00]
like it was yesterday. It was torn down in the
[1:37:03]
late seventy s and the fairgrounds were moved to Longmont.
[1:37:06]
Where it has been utilized beautifully ever since. And. I'm
[1:37:11]
really grateful for that. But suddenly the indoor arena was
[1:37:15]
not available. For winter. Open writing. I don't know the
[1:37:20]
reason for closing the winter open riding program. When I
[1:37:25]
found out the program was closed. I spent several hours
[1:37:31]
collecting signatures for a petition that was given to the
[1:37:35]
county commissioners. This petition opposed the closing of the open
[1:37:39]
ride. These signatures were from the horse community collected at
[1:37:44]
riding clinics. And horse events. Every single person asked me,
[1:37:50]
why is Boulder county closing the indoor arena? Several of
[1:37:55]
my friends in our horse community have appeared at your
[1:37:58]
parks and open space meetings. And have attended the county
[1:38:04]
commissioners meetings, and it presented this petition of 120 signatures
[1:38:09]
in opposition to closing the arena, and we can certainly
[1:38:14]
get more if you need them. We have reached out
[1:38:18]
to Boulder county for answers, and we would love to
[1:38:21]
have a discussion. For some kind of compromise. So far,
[1:38:26]
we have had no answers or discussion on the satisfactory
[1:38:30]
resolution. I'm really frustrated that the horse community. Is denied
[1:38:36]
this community service by our government. With no genuine discussion.
[1:38:42]
Please. I would love to have an answer soon. Thank
[1:38:47]
you. Thank you, Rhonda. Nick, do we have anybody else
[1:38:52]
online? I am not seeing any other hands raised. Okay.
[1:39:02]
Comments thoughts from Posec. Carol. Carol byerly posac. I'm trying
[1:39:11]
to understand. The sequence of events here because. It sounds
[1:39:17]
like the county commissioners have already made decisions about funding
[1:39:21]
for this. And usually we see things before. They act.
[1:39:28]
And so we are kind of disarmed in a way.
[1:39:32]
And so I'm wondering. If. That, and I haven't seen
[1:39:39]
the petition. And apparently they've been speaking to the county
[1:39:45]
commissioners, but. This is new to us as of last
[1:39:49]
month. We did actually hear a little bit about. When
[1:39:54]
we talked about the fairgrounds. Fairground? Sorry. Probably October, I'm
[1:39:59]
guessing. Jared, do you have much of a memory of
[1:40:04]
sequence of events and where we're at? With all this.
[1:40:09]
Yeah, Tony, we do have one more comment. Bring pam
[1:40:17]
andringa. Great. Pam. Two. And introduce yourself and take three
[1:40:23]
minutes. Absolutely. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Thank
[1:40:28]
you. I'm Pam Andringa, and. I live in Boulder county,
[1:40:31]
unincorporated. And I just want to thank all of you,
[1:40:35]
first of all, for amazing work that you do. And
[1:40:39]
the amazing care for those little bats that are suffering.
[1:40:43]
And preserving the riding opportunities that we do have in
[1:40:46]
open space. It's really great to see that you've made
[1:40:50]
a lot of efforts in that. Area, and also with
[1:40:53]
the help of Cindy and all the other equine community
[1:40:56]
that. Has persevered to keep those opportunities available. I think
[1:41:00]
one of the frustrations initially. When we were hearing kind
[1:41:04]
of the final closure of the Boulder county fairgrounds for
[1:41:07]
open riding. Was that? There wasn't enough money in the
[1:41:13]
budget to keep it open, although they had no way.
[1:41:17]
Of telling us or reporting. What it costs to keep
[1:41:21]
it open. And then. The complication was also that the
[1:41:26]
tractor wasn't working properly. And. It just seemed like a
[1:41:33]
bit of an excuse that hadn't really been investigated. And
[1:41:37]
so it felt a little premature to be able to
[1:41:39]
say that there wasn't enough. Money to keep it open.
[1:41:44]
And that there wasn't enough equipment and it was too
[1:41:46]
much work. Where? Every other. Community fairground that I've investigated.
[1:41:54]
They have even more open opportunities to ride. And it
[1:41:59]
doesn't seem to be a very big issue, and it
[1:42:01]
doesn't seem to be an expense that can't be managed.
[1:42:05]
And so I think that was part of the frustration
[1:42:07]
with the community that it seems sort of short sighted.
[1:42:12]
And. Narrowly envisioned by a small group of people. And
[1:42:18]
it wasn't necessarily. Open discussion. So I think that was
[1:42:24]
a lot of the confusion or the frustration, and then
[1:42:27]
just the loss of that great opportunity to be able
[1:42:30]
to maintain. People's horses during the winter months when it's
[1:42:34]
not feasible to ride outside and what I just want
[1:42:38]
to add for sure as well is that. You don't
[1:42:42]
see a lot of usage of that open opportunity, but
[1:42:45]
the usage that you do have is widespread throughout the
[1:42:50]
equine community because every one of the people that are
[1:42:52]
involved in riding there. Are outreach people that are helping.
[1:42:59]
With. Four H and with other community projects. And community
[1:43:03]
services. And for them to be able to keep the
[1:43:08]
ability to ride and keep their horses manageable. And help,
[1:43:11]
as Cindy said. Also. With open space management. From the
[1:43:15]
equine perspective, it's really critical that they have that opportunity.
[1:43:19]
So I just hope that it can be reconsidered. Thank
[1:43:21]
you very much. Thank you. I appreciate your comments. I
[1:43:26]
really appreciate you all coming in and talking to us
[1:43:29]
both in person and online, and I really appreciate the
[1:43:33]
respectful way you've come to us. And very thoughtful comments.
[1:43:42]
I would like to. Task staff with giving us an
[1:43:48]
update. And kind of a history. Of this issue from
[1:43:54]
back in October, I think it was, when we had
[1:43:58]
the fairgrounds manager come and I apologize. I can't remember
[1:44:01]
his name. Joe. Joe. Walk us through. The public comment,
[1:44:09]
the decisions recommended by staff, the decisions. We incorporated into
[1:44:17]
approval of the new fairgrounds contracts and operating procedures. And
[1:44:23]
then through the county commissioner. Timeline to understand. How all
[1:44:28]
this got done because I think it would be a
[1:44:30]
great refresher for all. Of us especially. And. I can't
[1:44:38]
imagine that we couldn't have a conversation and try to
[1:44:42]
find some. Way. Of making some middle ground here. So.
[1:44:50]
I feel like for us on Postac, we need to
[1:44:52]
get back to the place of understanding. The decisions and
[1:44:56]
timeline and the reasons. And then I think we would
[1:45:01]
love to have that conversation. So if we could do
[1:45:05]
that, we have a February 27 meeting. And maybe, I
[1:45:13]
don't know if we have time, if you have time
[1:45:15]
to do any. Of that legwork before our retreat. We
[1:45:22]
could talk, maybe offline about that, but it might be
[1:45:24]
nice to be able. To. Juice this a little bit.
[1:45:29]
Trace. Trace baker. Posac. In addition to the topics that
[1:45:36]
Tony just asked for, There is. A possible or perceived
[1:45:44]
breakdown in communication. Between staff and the public and would
[1:45:51]
like to have that addressed also. Yeah. I think that's
[1:45:57]
part of what I'm just searching for, to understand in
[1:45:59]
the timeline of decision making. And public input. So that
[1:46:05]
whole kind of process timeline. True. And then paula drew
[1:46:11]
adams posak. Was mentioned in the presentation that some of
[1:46:15]
the surrounding counties are able to offer open riding opportunities.
[1:46:21]
For their residents. So I'd like to extend the request
[1:46:24]
to have a comparison to some of the surrounding. County.
[1:46:30]
Equine opportunities that might exist, what their costs breakdown might
[1:46:34]
be, and in addition to that, what number of hours
[1:46:37]
they provide. And I would also add on there what
[1:46:41]
methods they use to stay in contact with their members.
[1:46:44]
And their participants in their arenas because it sounds as
[1:46:47]
if. This is just something that we've heard echoed through
[1:46:51]
several of these meetings with the same topic where there
[1:46:54]
is a breakdown in the communication. The perception was that
[1:46:57]
the members were communicated with but then we heard, I
[1:47:01]
think it was two sessions ago, where we had a
[1:47:04]
very large audience. Of participants from riders who were saying
[1:47:07]
the first they ever heard about it is when they
[1:47:09]
attempted to. Ride and they noticed that the gates were
[1:47:12]
shut, so to speak. We also discussed once before about
[1:47:16]
the financial concerns about the maintenance issues for the tractor
[1:47:20]
and some of these other items, and I believe Therese
[1:47:22]
spoke a little bit about their budget of what they
[1:47:25]
might have. So there might be an opportunity for us
[1:47:27]
to look and see what are the budgetary? Constraints that
[1:47:30]
they might have for their operational cost and potentially some
[1:47:33]
of the other types of inf. Infrastructure and capital improvements
[1:47:35]
that maybe they want to put forth to the community
[1:47:37]
to say maybe there's a way for the community. If
[1:47:40]
you really want to see this continue, there could be
[1:47:43]
a shared cost or another opportunity to say if there
[1:47:45]
needs to replace the tractor or maybe there's a goFundMe
[1:47:49]
type of activity that could happen on your side to
[1:47:51]
encourage this type of facility to stay open if. It's
[1:47:55]
an operational cost concern. Thanks, Paula. Thanks. Paula Fitzgerald. Posek.
[1:48:02]
And to just reiterate a little bit, What we talked
[1:48:06]
about last month. It sounds like there definitely was a
[1:48:10]
communication breakdown. I think it was a little bit. Of
[1:48:14]
lack of information, possibly, from what I hear from the
[1:48:17]
county's part, but also possibly not an activation or a
[1:48:22]
collection of the members part to really participate in those
[1:48:26]
sessions. Which. Were to the wise. Those are the times
[1:48:30]
to speak up beforehand rather than later. I'd mentioned that
[1:48:35]
there's some very talented staff on public process. In Boulder
[1:48:40]
county and that hopefully sharing some of. Their best practices
[1:48:46]
for outreach would be a benefit in this situation. One
[1:48:50]
thing that. Has come up in my mind since then.
[1:48:54]
Is that not too many months ago, we saw a
[1:48:56]
master plan for the fairgrounds. With a lot of. Very
[1:49:01]
fancy and beautiful improvements to the fairgrounds. And yet we
[1:49:07]
can't even keep something. As basic. As a once a
[1:49:12]
week ride throughout the winter months. Open. So I would
[1:49:17]
pass the county to look at those kinds of master
[1:49:21]
plan efforts. Because if you lead a master plan effort
[1:49:26]
too far ahead, Of when it's actually going to be
[1:49:31]
implemented. You may have lost your whole support group by
[1:49:36]
the time that implementation happens, and it's sort of to
[1:49:39]
me, a wasted effort. So I'd suggest that. A good
[1:49:47]
evaluation be done on affordability? Before a master plan and
[1:49:52]
process has taken place. And then looking for ways. Of
[1:49:58]
maintaining something. As strong for the agricultural community. To me,
[1:50:03]
this seems like. Sort of central. Focus of a fairgrounds
[1:50:10]
anywhere is to have these kinds of opportunities, especially for
[1:50:14]
forage kids. I mean, that's kind of our future farmers
[1:50:17]
and our future people. And it seems like. We do
[1:50:22]
a lot of. Head nodding about how we need to
[1:50:26]
provide. For our kids and give them good, healthy activities.
[1:50:32]
And yet we can't afford this. Anyway. I will be
[1:50:38]
gone when this happens. But. I think it's a worthwhile
[1:50:43]
topic to discuss in the future and keep in front
[1:50:46]
of the commissioners who apparently have made the decision for
[1:50:49]
this year. But maybe we can get it ahead of
[1:50:53]
next year. And try to get something back in place.
[1:50:58]
Thank you, Janet. Yeah. I'd like to see a little
[1:51:03]
more detail on just how much does it cost to
[1:51:06]
have one day of open writing. I heard it was
[1:51:09]
12 hours long. Maybe there's an option to make it
[1:51:12]
shorter. I mean, how many times do you have to
[1:51:14]
drag the arena? I don't think they're. Out there every
[1:51:17]
hour dragging the arena twice. Okay, but to just hear
[1:51:20]
from Joe. And some dollar figures. On just how much
[1:51:24]
this really would cost. Staff time. Does somebody actually be
[1:51:31]
there the whole time? I know when I used to
[1:51:33]
do it, and it was probably 25 years ago, 20
[1:51:36]
years ago. I don't think anybody was really watching us.
[1:51:39]
That closely. Yeah. So I'd like to see just a
[1:51:42]
little more detail. I mean, what does it really cost.
[1:51:46]
The county to have one day a week, and it's
[1:51:47]
not even all year long. I think it's, what, November
[1:51:51]
through April, May. Yeah. And if there's some compromise, some
[1:51:56]
places that make sense, you could even cut cost. Christine.
[1:52:01]
Christine johnson. Drew. Asked. A lot of. The requests that
[1:52:09]
I wanted to make, and I just want to underscore
[1:52:12]
what he said. And to go into the level of
[1:52:19]
detail that's feasible, detail is helpful. I think another issue
[1:52:25]
that came up. During. The presentation and then during the
[1:52:32]
discussion. Is whether or not. There's adequate time. During the
[1:52:39]
week and. I think it would be useful to know.
[1:52:44]
Again, how many hours it takes, how many hours prep
[1:52:48]
takes, and what the normal schedule or a typical schedule.
[1:52:55]
For the facility is particularly in the winter. To have
[1:52:59]
a sense. Of. What is the availability, particularly on days
[1:53:05]
when it looks like it's empty? Okay. I think we
[1:53:11]
beat this horse to death. But. I hope. Staff
[1:53:21]
plainly there's a lot more detail around process and understanding
[1:53:26]
of how this could work that we would like to
[1:53:29]
engage in a conversation about that. And I think we'd
[1:53:33]
really like to engage with the community in that conversation
[1:53:36]
as well. So I'm happy to work a little bit
[1:53:39]
offline with staff to make sure we tee up, making
[1:53:42]
sure we get all the right information. For us to
[1:53:45]
have that discussion and to ensure that we have a
[1:53:47]
good discussion with the community. So thank you all for
[1:53:50]
coming in. Really appreciate it. Nick, do we have anybody
[1:53:54]
else online and any other topics? From the public. No
[1:54:01]
other hands raised. Great. We're going to move to PosTC
[1:54:04]
members comment period for items not on the agenda, and
[1:54:08]
I'm going to start since I'm still cherry. Didn't get
[1:54:11]
rid of me. This meeting, you could have. And. I
[1:54:17]
want to just first thank everybody for being here tonight.
[1:54:20]
I really appreciate it. And it's a good group of
[1:54:23]
really caring people. And it's really nice to all be
[1:54:26]
together. It's hard, given everybody's schedules and other commitments, paid
[1:54:31]
jobs and kind of problems. Like that. But it's really
[1:54:36]
great to have everyone here, and I really appreciate all
[1:54:38]
the time you all have put into this. There have
[1:54:42]
been some very long sessions, some very hard sessions, and
[1:54:45]
you've always approached it. With humility and grace. And someone
[1:54:51]
who epitomizes that more than anyone is Paula Fitzgerald. And
[1:54:55]
I really want to thank you for your six years
[1:54:57]
of service to post that and for bringing me into
[1:55:00]
this. Which I may never forgive you for. Now. I
[1:55:06]
just really appreciate that a lot. And Jackson, I know
[1:55:11]
you're taking off, not. Getting returned this time, and thank
[1:55:16]
you for your service. It's been great to have you.
[1:55:18]
And your perspective here. Absolutely. We have two other members
[1:55:22]
who are asking to be returned, and I hope that
[1:55:26]
that is the case. We don't ever know what the
[1:55:31]
county commissioners are going to do. That. I think from
[1:55:35]
my perspective, I really hope that's the case. Other comments
[1:55:40]
from Postac members on any agenda items. Paula. Thank you,
[1:55:47]
Tony. That was very sweet. And I just wanted to
[1:55:50]
give a shout out to the county staff. You are
[1:55:54]
a huge resource. I mean, your knowledge is so extensive,
[1:55:59]
the way you work with the public and between. Yourselves
[1:56:02]
to try to coordinate so that everybody's on the same
[1:56:05]
page working together. It's really admirable. And I think. It's
[1:56:12]
obviously a benefit to all the projects you work on
[1:56:14]
and all the issues you take on. And I also.
[1:56:19]
Want to thank fellow members here. It's a great group
[1:56:23]
of people. Part of me is like, okay, I'm ready
[1:56:27]
to be done. Time for new energy here. But it's
[1:56:32]
been a pleasure, and I've learned a tremendous amount. I
[1:56:36]
hope to keep involved with some of the other things,
[1:56:39]
like the conservation easement, monitoring and maybe some other opportunities.
[1:56:45]
But anyway. I think a couple of the things. The
[1:56:49]
county does so well. Besides our information given for these
[1:56:54]
meetings. And the good presentations and the knowledge of the
[1:56:58]
staff are the field trips. I mean, those are just
[1:57:02]
fantastic opportunities. And for some of the members who. Have
[1:57:07]
jobs still. Come on. Get your priority straight. But they
[1:57:14]
are wonderful opportunities to learn and to see some of
[1:57:17]
these beautiful sites that we've purchased. And manage. With county
[1:57:22]
dollars. Anyway, keep up the good work. Thank you. Thank
[1:57:27]
you, Paula. Really appreciate it. Other comments Jackson Tony Jackson
[1:57:31]
Mueller Post act I want to follow up with Paul
[1:57:33]
is about learning. I know. The application window is closed,
[1:57:38]
but to Cindy and others that may still be online,
[1:57:43]
please consider applying. I learned a ton about civics. And
[1:57:48]
decision making at the county. And learning about the parks
[1:57:52]
and open space department that I wasn't aware of just
[1:57:55]
from my own little bubble of using. There's so much
[1:57:57]
more out there to learn about, so. I just wanted
[1:57:59]
to put that plug for the next window. That's awesome.
[1:58:05]
Thanks. Okay. We have our new director giving us the
[1:58:11]
director report tonight. You should be acting. You should just
[1:58:16]
do whatever you want since you're acting. Good evening. Post
[1:58:23]
act Jarrett Roberts, acting director. Teresa's out at least till
[1:58:26]
Monday. I have a few updates. It's pretty short. First
[1:58:31]
update, Aguan wanted you all to. Know that the soil
[1:58:34]
health grants came in and we had 15 grants for
[1:58:37]
over 350k. For things like compost and soil amendments, and
[1:58:41]
we hope those agreements will be out by late. February.
[1:58:45]
With all the fires that are going on. I'm in
[1:58:46]
California. I'm sure fire is on all of our minds.
[1:58:48]
So wanted a quick update that there have been burdens.
[1:58:52]
West of lions. You may have seen those. Those are
[1:58:54]
controlled burns. And then we are considering and looking. At
[1:58:56]
doing burns at Highle and hall the next coming days
[1:59:01]
with the sheriff's office. So that's on your radar. We
[1:59:05]
just completed. A study with no coat, places to look
[1:59:09]
at our illegal trails, and we came in with just
[1:59:11]
over 60 miles from that study. That's not to say
[1:59:14]
that's comprehensive of the entire area. But it's what came
[1:59:19]
in from that study on parks and open space land
[1:59:22]
we're hoping to put together a presentation and bring that
[1:59:24]
to you in the next couple post act. Meetings. And
[1:59:28]
then just a reminder that you all have the retreat.
[1:59:30]
Coming up on February 1, the public part of that
[1:59:33]
starts at 1015, and then you all will be there
[1:59:36]
a little bit earlier. I think the agenda has been
[1:59:37]
sent to you. And then, yeah, just in response to
[1:59:42]
the feedback about the fairgrounds, just a reminder that Joe
[1:59:45]
was here Jalafala last time. And if you look back
[1:59:47]
at the notes there, there. Are some answers to some
[1:59:49]
of the questions that were brought up, so I don't
[1:59:52]
want to reiterate those, but I will bring that up
[1:59:54]
with Teresa and Joe and we'll see if we can
[1:59:56]
figure out some way to continue that discussion. Awesome. Thank
[1:59:59]
you. Great. Thank you very much. Anything else from Posek?
[2:00:07]
Sorry. I know where you want to go. Are we
[2:00:09]
sharing any firefighters or anything with California? Sorry, guys. It
[2:00:17]
depends if you eat parks and open space or fire
[2:00:20]
departments around. Bolton county. Like Wildland. Yeah. So, Stefan Reinhard,
[2:00:26]
resource management division manager. So the sheriff's office has a
[2:00:30]
fire crew, and it's a county cooperative, and. So they
[2:00:34]
have sent a couple of engines and we're there. But
[2:00:39]
no park staff. Some of the fire departments have sent
[2:00:44]
staff in and. Thanks, Stefan. Sorry. Good question. That's a
[2:00:50]
good question. All right, thank you all. We're done.