Agenda
Agenda: https://brisbaneca.api.civicclerk.com/v1/Meetings/GetMeetingFileStream(fileId=12569,plainText=false)
Full agenda packet (agenda plus every staff report and attachment): https://brisbaneca.api.civicclerk.com/v1/Meetings/GetMeetingFileStream(fileId=12570,plainText=false)
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[13:44]
City Council special meeting. Can you hear me now? Okay. I think we need some new microphones.
[13:56]
Again, welcome. You are at the
[13:58]
Brisbane special meeting of September 14th, calling this meeting to order at 540. My apologize. My
[14:08]
apologies were a little bit late. We had a meeting before this. Let's start out with the pledge of
[14:13]
I hope you'll join me.
[14:18]
Ladies and gentlemen.
[14:34]
Okay, we have a full house of council members here tonight.
[14:37]
No one attending remotely.
[14:39]
So city clerk.
[14:40]
Could we have a roll call?
[14:41]
Council member Davis.
[14:43]
Here.
[14:44]
Council member Kern.
[14:46]
Council member Lens.
[14:47]
Council member O'Connell.
[14:49]
Here.
[14:49]
And Mayor Mackin.
[14:50]
Here.
[14:52]
Can I get a first and second to adopt the agenda as it stands?
[14:56]
Some moved.
[14:56]
Second.
[14:57]
All in favor.
[14:58]
Hi.
[14:59]
Hi.
[15:00]
We move on to the public hearing portion. And I have a couple things I'd like to say. I'm really pleased to see the room full tonight. You know, I heard a couple things recently about how we've had a plan on the table for 25 years in Brisbane. And I just have to dispel that myth because there have been a lot of different ideas on this property. And I don't know if everyone knows that. There hasn't just been one plan on the table.
[15:30]
There's been a series of changes and modifications.
[15:35]
The property out there is very, very complex,
[15:38]
and I hear it referred to as a garbage dump.
[15:41]
It was a garbage dump, and by today standards,
[15:44]
what we call hazardous waste dump at the same time.
[15:47]
And that entails a lot of special care
[15:52]
in order to make things feasible for a development.
[15:55]
So it's important.
[15:57]
I hope that with these public hearings, you'll learn way more about this instead of big generalizations.
[16:05]
And a lot of people, overall this time, we've had a succession of different employees from the developer side.
[16:13]
And it's been tough for everyone to keep up because there have been so many changes.
[16:18]
Unfortunately, I look at some of the delays were really very consequential and helpful because we learned so much more that we didn't know at the beginning.
[16:29]
And one of the most important things is we have a commitment to make a very good development and make a development that's successful.
[16:39]
You can't do that if you don't understand what you're dealing with.
[16:44]
So, maybe just for a little levity here, you know, years ago when I looked online and there were ideas, the property owner had purchased the property, there were many unusual plans that were being considered.
[17:02]
The first one was it was going to be a financial center with skyscrapers and it was going to be bigger and taller than San Francisco.
[17:09]
up. And that was taken off the table. And then it was going to be an amusement park. It was
[17:15]
going to go into rival Disneyland. And that was taken off the table. And then there was going
[17:21]
to be, it was going to be almost like an event center with the world's tallest man made waterfall.
[17:26]
And that was taken off the table. So I'm not saying this to say that nobody knew what to do.
[17:33]
I'm saying it so that you understand,
[17:36]
there's been lots of different approaches,
[17:38]
thoughtful approaches, very innovative approaches
[17:41]
to say what can be done there?
[17:45]
You're dealing with a toxic site,
[17:47]
you're dealing with bay water that was filled
[17:51]
with all kinds of refuse and dirt from surrounding hills.
[17:55]
And it requires special accommodations
[17:58]
to make that either livable or usable for the long term.
[18:04]
So we are all committed in Brisbane to a positive outcome, and I consider all of you here as collaborators,
[18:13]
because our staff, our legal team, our consultants, the developer, the council.
[18:21]
We're not all experts, and we are always the best of the sum of our parts. We need your input.
[18:28]
I also just want to dispel another myth.
[18:31]
It's very easy to go to a city and say to someone.
[18:35]
Are you in favor of this?
[18:36]
And someone says no, or oh yes I am.
[18:39]
You're going to find both.
[18:42]
I think it's very unfair to say just because a couple people say they're in favor
[18:47]
or not in favor that that characterizes a whole city.
[18:50]
That's not applicable here.
[18:52]
Things have changed over time.
[18:54]
The plans have changed.
[18:55]
And the plans have changed for a reason.
[18:58]
And we've been doing that collaboration with the developer.
[19:01]
That's why we have a new plan on the table.
[19:04]
So I hope tonight, we can be respectful,
[19:08]
even if we disagree, and that we can understand
[19:14]
that all the opinions are valid.
[19:16]
We need to hear what you have on your mind.
[19:20]
We need to hear some of you are experts in different fields.
[19:24]
We need to hear that information.
[19:25]
We need to hear your concerns, we need to hear your brilliant ideas and the hairbrane schemes, too, with your concerns, your anxieties, all of it.
[19:35]
We have the developers team here tonight. They are not the property owners. They are the employees of the development team.
[19:45]
team. They are here also to answer your questions. You can ask card questions. They've had hard
[19:51]
questions before. Our staff is here tonight. They can answer your hard questions as well.
[19:57]
If there's something that is asked tonight that either the staff or the developer can't answer
[20:02]
and they need to get back to you, we will come back to you at another meeting in the future with the
[20:08]
to those questions. So we're not trying to place the developer or stump the staff. Please
[20:16]
understand some things. We want to give you a correct answer or a comprehensive answer rather than
[20:23]
trying to answer off the top of our heads. So that being said also, we normally have a two minute
[20:30]
limit for speakers. We've doubled that for these public hearings. Tonight we have three topics on
[20:36]
agenda, so what we're going to do is we'll have a staff presentation, we'll have a presentation
[20:42]
by the developer, and then we'll go into the first topic, solely the first topic. The council
[20:49]
will get to ask some questions, we'll open the public hearing, and then all of you and anyone
[20:56]
online, you'll get to ask your questions or make your comments pertaining to that first topic.
[21:04]
Then we'll go on to the second topic in the same vein with the Council asking questions and then the public able to comment or ask questions as well.
[21:14]
And by doing that, I hope that this works in that it's very common where someone says something and it sparks in your mind. Oh, that makes me think of something else.
[21:26]
So you're welcome to then comment, but we would appreciate when you make your comments or
[21:33]
questions stick to the topic that we're discussing, because we'll get to your other topics later.
[21:39]
You are welcome to speak on all three topics when those come up, but each time they'll be
[21:46]
no raised hands or people just coming up to the podium.
[21:49]
We want to keep it orderly.
[21:50]
We're trying to preserve first-in first-out on the podium, fill out a speaker card,
[21:56]
hand it to our city clerk at the end of the diasover there. There's seat. That's angry.
[22:03]
And that way we can kind of keep it orderly. All right. That being said,
[22:09]
I'm going to read our caveat about public hearings. We welcome speakers providing public
[22:15]
comment during tonight's public hearing, but please be advised it's a limited public form.
[22:19]
What does that mean? It's important for speakers to stay on topic. On topic are those matters that are within the subject matter jurist.
[22:30]
Section of the city. Speakers will have four minutes for each topic. The topics are measure number one, measure jj and the general plan requirements to govern the bayland specific plan, topic number two, measure jj and the general plan requirements to govern the bayland specific plan.
[22:51]
Number three, air quality and greenhouse gas impacts and associated mitigation measures identified in the EIR.
[23:00]
And I think we have a problem.
[23:02]
One of these was copied twice.
[23:06]
Topic number two city clerk.
[23:09]
Could you please clarify?
[23:17]
I can look it up as well.
[23:18]
Topic number two is the specific plan sustainability program and designing for ongoing energy neutrality.
[23:26]
Okay. Thank you. So following these rules helps ensure the City Council can get to all the items on tonight's agenda, including hearing public comments on items. If a speaker, please don't go there.
[23:39]
If you fail to follow these rules, you're disrupting the meeting and you'll be warned. And if you continue to ignore the rules or if you're otherwise disruptive, your opportunity to speak will be ended and you may be recruited from speaking on other items tonight. We don't want to go there. We want to learn from each other tonight.
[23:57]
So, that being said, the first item is the considerations of the bail-and-specific plan.
[24:09]
We're going to look at Measure J.J. and the General Plan requirements that govern the bail-and-specific plan.
[24:16]
Could we have a staff report, please?
[24:19]
Yes, thank you. Good evening, Honorable Mayor and Council.
[24:21]
Is my volume good for everyone?
[24:24]
Sounds great.
[24:24]
up here. Okay, just let me know if I need to speak louder.
[24:30]
We are, oh, thank you so much, Molly.
[24:33]
So, good evening, everyone, as the mayor noted in her introductory remarks over the past 20
[24:38]
plus years, the council planning commission and Brisbane Community at large have engaged very
[24:43]
thoughtfully and carefully in a variety of planning efforts related to the future of this large and
[24:49]
highly visible site in Brisbane, which has the mayor mentioned as a former landfill and really
[24:54]
So tonight they Council will be holding the first in a planned series of public hearings on the Brisbane Bayland
[25:00]
Specific Plan and other related approvals which together will establish a regulatory framework for build out of a new mixed use neighborhood in the city
[25:09]
Next slide please
[25:14]
Thank you
[25:16]
So tonight's presentation will be structured in the three different segments the first segment will provide an overview of the specific plan
[25:23]
general plan requirements that apply to the specific plan and summarize the commission's review
[25:28]
of the specific plan that concluded last month. The second segment will address the plan's
[25:33]
relationship to the 2015 sustainability framework for the balance. The third segment will provide
[25:39]
a brief overview of more technical aspects of the project related to air quality greenhouse gas
[25:44]
emissions and energy impacts that were evaluated in the EIR. After staff's presentation,
[25:49]
as the mayor noted, there will be an opportunity for the applicant,
[25:52]
Bayland's development coordinator, BDI, to address the Council,
[25:56]
followed by comment periods tailored to each of the three segments in the presentation.
[26:01]
Next slide, please.
[26:04]
So we'd like to start with saying some expectations for
[26:06]
a Council will be doing tonight and that future anticipated hearings.
[26:11]
So again, tonight is the first in a series of anticipated hearings on the specific plan
[26:15]
EIR and other related approvals. They're organized around Measure J. J's requirements.
[26:19]
We discussed that on September 3rd.
[26:23]
Tonight and at subsequent topic focused hearings, staff is looking for council comments and feedback on the topics that are highlighted tonight.
[26:32]
At the end of each topic focused meeting, we're hoping to have some clarity on council's direction or feedback on each topic,
[26:38]
which will then inform a final recommendation for the council to consider at the concluding hearing.
[26:44]
This would also be accompanied by an errada or a summary of proposed changes to the specific
[26:49]
plan that aligns with that direction from council or captures needed clarifications that
[26:54]
staff or council may identify. So again, to be clear, we're not looking for council to take
[26:59]
any votes or a prompt take formal action on the project tonight. Next slide, please.
[27:08]
Okay, so next
[27:09]
will briefly review the specific plan.
[27:12]
Next slide, please.
[27:17]
So, as I noted, the Brisbane Bayland specific plan
[27:20]
will be the regulatory framework
[27:21]
to guide development over time
[27:24]
within the Bayland sub area of the city
[27:26]
consistent with the city's general plan.
[27:28]
The specific plan balances policy direction
[27:30]
with future adaptability by outlined in the specific land uses,
[27:35]
infrastructure needs, and other design requirements
[27:39]
that would apply to future development.
[27:40]
The plan establishes regulations that would allow development of 1,800 to 2,200 residential units in the northwest quadrant of the site.
[27:49]
6.5 million square feet of commercial office retail, life science office campuses, 500,000 square feet of hotel uses, a middle school variety of utilities, sustainable infrastructure elements, including water recycling, water storage, switching substation, battery storage and a solar farm.
[28:11]
And 157 acres devoted to conservation, restoration, and enhancement as habitat, as well as active and passive recreation parks and recreational improvements.
[28:24]
Next slide, please.
[28:28]
Just to kind of clarify some terms, so the 2026 staff recommended plan will refer to it just simply as the specific plan.
[28:35]
That's what the council is considering this evening.
[28:38]
It was published in May of this year, along with the final EIR, the 2026 specific plan is evaluated in the final EIR as a modified alternative one, and it's solved the 2026 specific plan, it revises a specific plan submitted by BDI, the applicant, in 2025, that 2025 plan was evaluated in the EIR as the project. Next slide, please.
[29:08]
There are a number of other related city approvals required to implement the specific plan.
[29:16]
The first I'll mention is the development agreement, so this is required by the general plan and measure jj.
[29:23]
The development agreement will define the scope of the project's vested rights and phasing requirements.
[29:29]
It will also define public benefits and any other contributions necessary to satisfy measure jj.
[29:34]
The Development Agreements currently in process, it will be reviewed by the Planning Commission before being considered by the City Council.
[29:42]
Another related approval is approval of a water agreement between the City and Cal Water to extend Cal Water Service area to the Baylands.
[29:50]
Those would be subject to city council review and approval before site development, consistent with measure JJ.
[29:59]
Another item is...
[30:00]
Future relocation of Fire Station 81. From its existing site on Beishore to a new facility on Valley Drive.
[30:07]
This is called for in the ELO and this would be subject to future approval by both North County Fire Authority and the City Council.
[30:16]
And finally, the city would need to issue permits for actual site development. So this would include creating permits, subdivision and parcel map for approvals, entitlement permits, such as design permits for commercial and housing development permits for residential.
[30:29]
and, of course, building permits for structures themselves.
[30:34]
Now I'm going to hand the presentation over to Jeremiah Robbins, who's a senior planner with the city.
[30:38]
He's going to dive into the commission's review of the specific plan.
[30:45]
All right, good evening. Next slide please.
[30:49]
All right, tonight we'll briefly summarize how the planning commission evaluated the specific plan and the final ER and highlight the commission's final recommendations to the city council. Next slide.
[31:00]
The Planning Commission review began with two public workshops on May 28th and June 11th.
[31:06]
These provided an overview of the specific plan and the final EIR.
[31:10]
The public hearings began after the workshops, beginning on June 25th and continuing until July 23rd
[31:16]
at the third public meeting on July 23rd and after receiving extensive public comment, the public hearing was closed.
[31:23]
A false meeting was held on August 13th, where the Commission deliberated and finalized their recommendation to this council.
[31:29]
The Commission's recommendation summarized on this slide was as follows.
[31:34]
One, certify the final EIR and adopt the 2026 specific plan subject to the following
[31:40]
additional considerations.
[31:42]
Improve transparency in remediation, reporting, and establish an energy audit, enforcement mechanism.
[31:48]
Require conditional use permits for BIOSafety level 3 and above lab uses, enhance circulation safety, especially on class 1, bike and pedestrian facilities and expand shuttle service, retain the mission blue nursery in its current location, support open space conservation easements, and incorporate staff July 23 clarifying edits to both chapter 3 and 9.
[32:13]
2, adopt the elements of the Bayshore Mobility Plan that directly implement mitigation measures identified within the final EIR.
[32:21]
Any other elements of the plan, such as the Bayshore Boulevard Road Diet, were not recommended to be adopted.
[32:28]
However, the Commission also recommended further study of a continuous pedestrian by school facility or sidewalk along Bayshore without implementing the road diet.
[32:36]
Next,
[32:40]
we'll outline Measure JJ's requirements for the Bayland-specific plan, since Measure JJ
[32:45]
shapes tonight's discussion, especially around sustainability, transportation, environmental
[32:50]
remediation, and water supply.
[32:52]
Next slide.
[32:56]
As most of us, like we recall, Measure JJ is the voter approval amendment to Brisbane's
[33:01]
general plan that passed in November 2018 with 55% voter approval.
[33:06]
It set the allowable amount and type of development within the Baylands and also incorporated
[33:11]
requirements to protect the city from mitigatable impacts associated with the project.
[33:17]
These additional requirements are organized into topics, and we'll be referring to them
[33:21]
as measure JJ topics throughout the presentation.
[33:24]
These measure JJ topics directly correlate to the language incorporated into the general plan
[33:29]
under policy BL1 and also table 1.4.1 of the Baylands specific plan.
[33:35]
The following topics which we will discuss that future hearings include a sustainability framework
[33:41]
on going energy neutrality, comprehensive remediation and landfill closure planning, demonstrated
[33:47]
reliable water supply before development moves forward, revenue positive development for
[33:53]
the city, habitat protection and open space preservation, roundhouse protection and adaptive
[33:59]
reuse, sea level rise resilience planning, transportation and transit program.
[34:04]
And as a point of information, measure J.J. Topic 3K, which will be discussed in devs on October 6,
[34:12]
has been completed as of 2025. This detail was not reflected in the specific plan general plan
[34:18]
measure J.J. consistency table or attachment three to the council's report tonight. Next slide.
[34:26]
The specific plan incorporates sustainability throughout the plan to demonstrate consistency with measure J.J.
[34:31]
These measures emphasize long-term operational performance, including energy neutrality, low-carbon mobility, resilient water systems, and ecological stewardship.
[34:41]
The foundation for these requirements originates in the city's 2015 Sustainability Framework.
[34:47]
The next slide outlines how that framework informed the major JJ and intern shape the specific plan.
[34:54]
In 2015, the city council accepted a sustainability framework for the balance prepared by integral
[35:00]
group.
[35:01]
That's now in Troba, in collaboration with the balance sustainability committee.
[35:05]
The framework is based on one planet living principles.
[35:09]
One planet living is a set of 10 principles developed by a bioregional and designed to achieve
[35:14]
an ecological footprint based on the resources available on Earth, hence one living
[35:19]
planet, or using one planet living.
[35:21]
It includes the social and economic aspects of sustainability as essential elements to achieving
[35:27]
sustaining harmony between development and nature.
[35:32]
For tonight's discussion, it is important to consider Measure JJ did not reference sustainability
[35:36]
alone.
[35:37]
It was intentionally aligned with the Framework's 10-1 planet living principles to ensure
[35:42]
balance development that almost ecological footprint is sustainable.
[35:46]
This slide summarizes the connection between the Framework and Measure JJ.
[35:50]
zero carbon buildings, zero waste,
[35:52]
and materials, and food,
[35:54]
along with chapter four of the specific plan
[35:55]
and measure JTA topic 3G.
[35:58]
Sustainable transport aligns with topic 3B,
[36:01]
sustainable water aligns with topics 3B and 3J.
[36:05]
Open space and habitat align with topic 3H,
[36:09]
culture and heritage align with topic 3I,
[36:12]
economic vitality, recreation, health, safety,
[36:15]
and happiness align with topics 3D,
[36:17]
And three E, with the specific plans of land use, circulation and open space chapters,
[36:25]
general plan policy BL1, which incorporates
[36:27]
we have a requirement of measure J.J. directly into the general plan direct, directs the base of specific plans to sustainability program,
[36:35]
to incorporate the sustainably framework principles and advance energy neutrality on an ongoing basis.
[36:41]
At this time, I'm happy to introduce Eric Hallway from ESA, who will review the specific plans of sustainability components in more detail.
[36:50]
Thank you, Jeremiah.
[36:53]
Can you hear me?
[36:57]
We can hear you.
[36:58]
Yes, thank you.
[36:58]
Thank you.
[37:01]
So I'll be providing a brief,
[37:02]
a high-level review of the sustainability provisions
[37:05]
of this specific plan based on chapter 4.
[37:10]
Next slide, please.
[37:12]
So as staff just noted,
[37:14]
the plans approach to achieving sustainability
[37:16]
is based on the principles established
[37:18]
at Bayland's sustainability framework.
[37:20]
And the policies and regulations in the sustainability chapter of the plan are organized based on these principles next slide, please.
[37:30]
Requirements in the sustainability chapter addressing zero-carbon buildings as a principle, next slide.
[37:37]
Include a requirement that commercial buildings must achieve lead-gold certification for building design and construction and a requirement that residential projects must achieve green-point certification.
[37:49]
This chapter also establishes the requirement that a hundred percent of the electricity used by
[37:54]
development in the Plain area must be generated from renewable sources, including a minimum
[37:59]
of 85,000 megawatt hours of onsite solar generation it build out.
[38:06]
Natural gas usage is prohibited in residential and commercial buildings, and buildings must be
[38:11]
designed to achieve the most stringent building efficiency performance standards in
[38:20]
the
[38:20]
In addition, Chapter 7 infrastructure, the plan describes proposed electrical system improvements, including a solar energy field and the delivery of a utility scale battery storage facility, which would help the project take better advantage of the renewable energy generated on site.
[38:36]
Next slide.
[38:39]
Requirements in the sustainability chapter addressing sustainable transportation, next slide.
[38:46]
Include the requirement that all bail-ins residents and tenants have access to amenities through the bicycle networking, including a variety of recreational civic and convenience uses.
[38:56]
A comprehensive transportation demand management program is required to reduce vehicle trips and vehicle miles traveled.
[39:03]
An overall plan-wide cap of 11,000 off-street vehicular parking spaces is established, and the on-site shuttle system described in chapter 6 is required to zero missions.
[39:14]
Now, sustainable transport is also enabled the regulations and other chapters, next slide.
[39:21]
That includes Chapter 2, Land Use Program and Planning Districts, which provide for a diverse
[39:25]
mix of uses and for higher density uses, clustered in your transit, in order to enable
[39:30]
bail-inous residents, workers, and visitors to take more trips using active modes of transportation
[39:36]
and reduce vehicle miles traveled.
[39:38]
And Chapter 3, Development and Design Standards for their supports walkability through
[39:43]
testing oriented building and parking design regulations, such as entry requirements and
[39:49]
active ground floors. Next slide.
[39:54]
And chapter six establishes the multimodal people oriented
[39:58]
street network designed to support walking biking transit and vehicles rather than prioritizing
[40:03]
any single mode. This chapter establishes how the transportation network must be integrated with
[40:09]
open space network include transit connections and include design guidelines to ensure that
[40:15]
new streets have facilities that support different modes of travel.
[40:19]
Next slide.
[40:22]
Now, requirements in the Sustainability Tractor addressing open space and habitat.
[40:27]
Next slide.
[40:29]
Include a requirement to dedicate over 148 acres of land area for recreation, habitat restoration,
[40:35]
and conservation.
[40:36]
This chapter includes requirements for bird safe building design, and it includes requirements for landscaping to be designed for climate adaptation, sea level rise, biodiversity, and long-term resilience.
[40:51]
The requirements in the sitting ability chapter related to the remaining principles include
[40:56]
the requirements to establish a zero waste program, the requirement to construct a water recycling facility,
[41:03]
and the requirement for buildings and landscaping to be designed to minimize water use,
[41:07]
or habit the use of potable water for non-potable uses, and manage storm water with a network of green infrastructure.
[41:15]
And finally, this chapter includes a requirement for development to use local and sustainable materials
[41:22]
and a requirement for the project to provide a space for a smaller than farm and community garden
[41:29]
as well as a farmers market to provide access to local and sustainable food.
[41:34]
This chapter requires support for culture and heritage through the restoration and adaptive reuse of the roundhouse
[41:40]
and a public art program.
[41:43]
Finally, this chapter supports economic vitality, equity and ecology by requiring development that is a net revenue positive on an annual basis, and requiring a mix of housing types, sizes, and density to serve diverse income levels.
[41:58]
Now I'm going to hand it over to my colleague Brian Schuster to discuss air quality greenhouse gas emissions in energy.
[42:07]
Great, hello council members. Members of the public. I'm going to talk a little bit about the
[42:13]
finally IAR's air quality greenhouse gas emissions and energy analysis. It's like
[42:20]
a couple
[42:21]
of a quick summary on the impacts that the finally IAR found for the Brisbane Vailant
[42:24]
Specific Plan. These are the lessons significant impacts. So for air quality, creating inconsistencies
[42:30]
with the San Francisco Bay Area Clean Air Plan, greenhouse gas effect on regional GHD emissions,
[42:35]
which is impact GC2 and energy resources consume energy resources in a wasteful and efficient
[42:42]
or unnecessary way, impact the N1 and create an inconsistency with programs, plans, ordinances
[42:48]
and policies for renewable energy and energy efficiency which is EN2.
[42:53]
So these impacts were less than significant and no mitigation is required.
[42:57]
Next slide.
[42:59]
Three impacts were found to be less than significant with mitigation, so that means that
[43:07]
For air quality we have two exposure sensitive receptors to pollutant concentrations.
[43:12]
This is a health risk.
[43:14]
Talks at our contaminated exposure.
[43:16]
AQ2 and odors exposure to odors, which is AQ3.
[43:21]
And for greenhouse gas emissions, this is impact GH3,
[43:24]
which is created in consistency with applicable plans policies and standards.
[43:30]
Next slide.
[43:32]
We have one significant and unavoidable impact in the IR for these topics.
[43:36]
and that is for air quality, which is the missions of criteria air pollutants for non-attainment,
[43:41]
pollutants both for the project and for accumulative. That's impact a Q1.
[43:47]
Slide?
[43:50]
Okay, so go into a little more detail on air quality impacts and mitigation measures.
[43:55]
Next slide.
[43:58]
Impact a Q1, which was found to be, which was the one significant and unavoidable
[44:02]
impact in these topic areas, is the regional criteria pollutant missions. So these are
[44:07]
Reactive organic gases, oxides, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter.
[44:13]
So this evaluated those pollutants, those mass emissions from construction and operational activities.
[44:18]
Those emissions exceeded the air districts thresholds.
[44:22]
So the IR requires a suite of mitigation for construction, soil movement and operational emissions to reduce those emissions.
[44:29]
And you can see a summary of those here.
[44:32]
Clean equipment, soil movement technology to reduce
[44:35]
trucking emissions, things like clean emergency generators, EV charging, and so forth.
[44:41]
However, with these mitigation measures, the project still exceeds the air district's thresholds,
[44:47]
and so this remains significant and unavoidable.
[44:51]
Next slide.
[44:53]
Impact 2 is health risk, so this is exposure of sensitive receptors, which are children, people.
[45:00]
With medical conditions, child care facilities, residents generally, to projects, tax commissions, which includes
[45:08]
diesel, particulate matter, and small fine particulate matter, or PN2.5. The analysis looked at both offsite, so near by offsite, residents, as well as future on-site residents at the project site.
[45:22]
So, the mitigation measures here include all of the measures in AQ1, as well as Merve 13
[45:29]
filtration and required for all residential and school buildings, with implementation of
[45:34]
all of those measures, the impact is reduced to less than significant.
[45:39]
Next slide,
[45:42]
just a few air quality FAQs here, so what controls dust, there are stormwater
[45:49]
pollution prevention plans and also the air districts required best management practices
[45:54]
to reduce future to dust which are required and the MMRP interest
[45:57]
compliance of those.
[46:00]
The diesel generators are required by California Building Code,
[46:04]
despite the projects robust suite of backup battery power,
[46:09]
and they'll only be used during emergencies, so not data data usage.
[46:15]
And then finally data centers are not permitted uses under the specific plan,
[46:19]
nor are logistics warehouses, so the analysis and the EIR did not.
[46:24]
consider those emissions. Great, next slide.
[46:32]
We have two GHG impacts. One is two GHG-2, which is regional GHG emissions.
[46:38]
This looks at whether locating Bayland's developments at the site,
[46:42]
would increase regional emissions across the 9 County Bay Area area,
[46:46]
compared with that, basically, the build out of that development without the plan.
[46:53]
And so, because of the project's translocation, mix of uses, TOD, and TDM program, it would produce lower, per capita, significantly lower, per capita VMT, which is vehicle miles traveled.
[47:08]
In other words, the project would produce fewer mobile emissions versus the regional non-project scenario.
[47:16]
And so, from this perspective, the project does not produce a significant impact.
[47:21]
Next
[47:23]
slide.
[47:27]
Finally, GHE3 looks at Consistency's Consistency with applicable climate plans and standards.
[47:34]
So, Bay Area Air Districts thresholds, their Sequel thresholds for greenhouse gas, Consistency with Carb's latest scoping plan, and local policies including MTCs transit oriented communities policy.
[47:47]
This measure required a few mitigation measures, including residential density, minimum for area ratio and lower parking ratios along with a requirement to install EV charging at the site, which meets Cal Green's tier 2 voluntary requirements with those measures.
[48:05]
This impact is less than significant.
[48:10]
Just a few more notes on next slide please.
[48:13]
Some of the project's features beyond the sustainability features that Eric mentioned to reduce greenhouse gas emissions are incorporated into the sustainability framework, including low global warming potential refrigerants, preferred parking for alternative fuel and right share vehicles, zero emission shuttle operations, and wastewater reclamation facility, utilizing 100% renewable fuels, and then all these specific plan design features that Eric summarized, including all electric buildings, lead design, and so forth, also ridiculous.
[48:43]
emissions at the project site. Okay, next slide. And just a few more in energy, and then I'm done.
[48:52]
Next slide. So, impact EN1 looks at the projects construction and operational
[48:58]
energy demand. These include all sources of energy, and buildings, vehicles, gasoline,
[49:03]
diesel, and natural gas electricity, and so forth. Because of the project's advanced
[49:08]
energy efficiency and sustainability designs, as has been mentioned, the project would have
[49:14]
lower per capita energy use, then regional, regional,
[49:18]
then typical regional development,
[49:20]
and would comply with all,
[49:21]
or would not produce wasteful or inefficient consumption
[49:26]
of energy, and then also factors
[49:30]
into the projects on site solar distributed utility
[49:33]
scale solar and batteries.
[49:36]
Next slide.
[49:38]
Impact the N2 looks at conflict with energy plans,
[49:41]
including Calgary and Co, Title 24,
[49:43]
as being Energy Code, General Plan, and Regional Plan Bay Area.
[49:48]
The project would comply with these requirements
[49:51]
and is consistent with Plan Bay Area.
[49:55]
So the finding here is less insignificant.
[49:58]
Next slide.
[50:00]
Finally, a short bulletless summary of some of the features
[50:03]
that reduce energy demand from mobile energy gasoline diesel
[50:07]
through transit oriented land use.
[50:12]
TDM, Trail Service, Shuttle Service, all electric buildings on the building side and efficient
[50:17]
building design on site renewable generation.
[50:20]
This is the large solar field, plus this should be the solar across the site, distributed
[50:24]
battery storage, and EV charging infrastructure to reduce gasoline, vehicle emissions, and
[50:32]
energy.
[50:33]
Reduce gasoline consumption.
[50:36]
All right.
[50:37]
Next slide.
[50:38]
And I think I'm done.
[50:39]
Thank you, Brian.
[50:42]
Okay.
[50:42]
Next slide, please.
[50:47]
So, at we noted at the top of the meeting, staff is not looking for council to make a final recommendation tonight or vote tonight.
[50:54]
But we are sharing staff's overall recommendation on the project, just for informational purposes.
[51:00]
That recommendation at this time is to approve the project entitlements, which consists of a variety of general plan amendments,
[51:08]
adoption of the specific planet itself, adoption of amendments to the zoning, ordinance, approval
[51:14]
of the Bacial Mobility Plan, as well as certification of the final EIR, and attended to that,
[51:22]
the Council would need to adopt findings of fact in a statement of overwriting considerations,
[51:27]
as well as adopting mitigation monitoring and reporting program. So just for information. Next slide,
[51:34]
please.
[51:38]
Next slide. Thank you. So I wanted to show here before we jump into the comment period,
[51:46]
just the projected future hearing dates and anticipated topics consistent with what council
[51:51]
saw on September 3rd. As we discussed at that time, this is a framework so ultimately if council
[51:58]
feels it needs to be adjusted in terms of topics council can provide that direction to staff. Next slide,
[52:05]
please.
[52:08]
Okay, so this concludes staff presentation. At this time, the applicant BDI is prepared
[52:15]
to address Council on topics highlighted in tonight's staff report. And then following
[52:19]
BDI's comments as the mayor noted, staff is prepared to receive Council feedback or questions
[52:27]
in three segments on a topic by topic B.C.
[52:30]
Which is shown here on the slide, those three topics. The first we'd be asking for comments on would be regarding measure, jj, and general plan consistency.
[52:39]
The second topic would be sustainability measures of the specific plan.
[52:44]
And the third and final topic would be those technical items that Brian just reviewed, air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and energy impact analysis from the EAR.
[52:56]
After Council feedback or questions on that particular topic, the Council can invite the public to make comments on that topic as well.
[53:04]
And again, as noted by the mayor, I'll just repeat it if any questions are posed by the public.
[53:09]
Staff will make note of them and provide answers as we're able at the end of the meeting.
[53:14]
So depending on the question, we may need more time to provide a complete answer to any questions that are received.
[53:22]
And then finally, before we jump into that, I just want to know at the end of the comment segment tonight, staff is recommending that the council continue the public hearing to a special meeting on September 29th.
[53:35]
I thought 30 PM to continue review of the plan in the air topics.
[53:40]
So I will end there. And again, the applicant is prepared to address council this time.
[53:53]
Ingrid, are you driving?
[53:58]
Okay.
[54:01]
Got it.
[54:02]
Thank you.
[54:03]
Good evening.
[54:05]
Mayor Maclin, Honourable City Council members.
[54:08]
My name is Stephanie Shakovsky.
[54:09]
I'm representing the Baylands Development.
[54:12]
Ink this evening.
[54:16]
And although I've only been with the Baylands organization for about four years,
[54:20]
my history with the Baylands goes back 20 years.
[54:24]
And Mayor, if you will indulge me just a minute,
[54:27]
I do want to give a little bit of my background.
[54:32]
I am a contaminant hydrologist by training.
[54:35]
I have nearly 30 years of research, policy and advocacy
[54:40]
in helping communities redevelop contaminated properties.
[54:45]
I started my career with the United States Geological Survey
[54:48]
in Memble Park at their research facility
[54:51]
where we studied the movement of contaminants in soil and groundwater.
[54:56]
And then I then made the brilliant move to go to Sacramento and I worked for the state legislature.
[55:04]
I was going to bring the scientific method to Sacramento, where I worked for the state legislature on policy and law regarding redeveloping contaminated properties.
[55:15]
Then for 15 years, I ran a nonprofit called the Center for Creative Land Recycling, that works with communities, municipalities, for profit and nonprofit developers who are working to redevelop contaminated land.
[55:27]
And at C. Claire, our first priority is always making sure that the redevelopment is absolutely safe for future residents and visitors.
[55:37]
My first experience with the Brazilian bail-ins was in 2005, and Honorable Mayor, you forgot
[55:45]
a couple of other ideas that had been floated for, and one of them was the Opera House
[55:51]
and the 49ers' Stadium,
[55:56]
however, in 2005 was when the application for this particular project
[56:04]
was submitted.
[56:05]
So it has been 20 years, the major difference between the 2005 and we are still working off that same 2005 application tonight.
[56:15]
The major difference between the 2005 application and what is before us this evening in essence was that original application had 4400 homes designed for the bailouts.
[56:32]
But shortly after the application went in, my non-profit came and worked with the city of
[56:38]
Brisbane and bringing a series of graduate architectural student design sherets from
[56:44]
UC Berkeley to Brisbane, working with the city of Brisbane.
[56:50]
And that time I worked very closely with the city manager, Clay Holstein,
[56:57]
and the
[56:58]
my radar since 2005. So in 2022, after measure J.J. passed and after the pandemic, I jumped
[57:07]
at the opportunity to join the bail-ins team to bring this long plan, long-awaited project
[57:12]
to reality. So after 20 years, I find myself a little speechless that I'm standing here
[57:21]
finally tonight requesting approval of the specific plan, but I promise I'll try to stay
[57:28]
composed and find my voice this evening.
[57:34]
Just a little table setting, I just want to make
[57:38]
it obvious that the bail-in is not a collection of parcels with zoning applied to them.
[57:43]
It is a fully realized vision for how people will live work, move and gather, organize
[57:50]
around a very robust open space system anchored by the base or calterine station and designed
[57:55]
by renowned architect and urban planner Peter Calthorpe to function as a sustainable inter-connected
[58:02]
neighborhood. There are four distinct planning districts. This is a staff pointed out earlier,
[58:09]
woven together by 148 acres of public open space, a comprehensive bicycle and pedestrian network,
[58:15]
multiple transit connections. Next slide
[58:23]
and one more. Next slide.
[58:31]
I think it's
[58:32]
useful to talk to use some case studies and some models as we work through the
[58:38]
process here and the next in the upcoming hearings.
[58:44]
The bail-ins has a very unique
[58:46]
history of industrial uses that do require careful planning but when it comes to
[58:51]
Environmental cleanup, land use zoning, and financial feasibility, I want to be very clear that
[58:57]
we are not charting new territory here.
[59:01]
Brisbane has been here before with the redevelopment of the former landfill at Sierra
[59:05]
Point, under the same regulatory agencies that will oversee the bailouts in the same local
[59:13]
government oversight.
[59:15]
While the Baylands is clearly more ambitious in its scope than Sarah Point, the tools that
[59:23]
we will be using collectively are proven and the approach is well-established.
[59:31]
Another development worth discussing as we move through the process is Mission Bay.
[59:36]
Mission Bay once a collection of, again, like the Baylands old railyards and vacant industrial
[59:41]
properties.
[59:41]
Today it's one of the nation's premier life science districts home to thousands of residents major employees and billions of dollars of private investment.
[59:51]
That transformation began in the late 1990s and is now a complete neighborhood and the assessed value of
[1:00:00]
Shembei has increased 340% over its pre-development baseline, from land that was essentially worthless
[1:00:07]
as a closed industrial site to one of the most valuable neighborhoods in San Francisco.
[1:00:13]
Lastly, I want to talk about Bay Meadows, and this is a development that we will be returning
[1:00:19]
to in future hearings, because I think it's the closest and most relevant case study for the
[1:00:28]
to use community next to a hills that the hills, they all,
[1:00:32]
counter-instation, that took 20 years to fully build out.
[1:00:35]
They were approved in 2005, and they just, last month, put their last two commercial
[1:00:44]
parcels under contract. So it is now fully built out. Although it's not a brownfield
[1:00:51]
like Mission Bay or Sierra Point, like all previous developed urban land, it did require
[1:01:00]
cleanup, the three underground storage tanks, legacy herbicides pesticides, led in arsenic
[1:01:06]
in the soil, and significant asbestos removal. So, not on the category of Mission Bay or
[1:01:21]
cleanups that need to be carried out before the site can be properly reused, been done successfully many times
[1:01:28]
before, and it was done successfully at Bay Meadows. Bay Meadows is considered a huge redevelopment
[1:01:34]
success by the city of San Mateo, by the developer, and more importantly by the community
[1:01:41]
who now live and work at the Bay Meadows development.
[1:01:46]
What this council is being asked to to support
[1:01:49]
Tonight is an application of a well-tested framework of environmental regulations,
[1:01:55]
zoning rules, financial feasibility that are better understood more thoroughly investigated
[1:02:01]
and rigorously planned than its predecessors like Mission Bay, C.R. Point, or Bay Meadows,
[1:02:06]
at their equivalent stages of development.
[1:02:11]
Can I get the next slide, please?
[1:02:16]
So before staff pulls out the cane, I do want to get two tonight's agenda items,
[1:02:21]
which is compliance with measure jj and the specific plan.
[1:02:29]
I just want the council and the Brisbane community to know that from the land use program to the sustainable sustainability framework.
[1:02:37]
Every aspect of the specific plan has been carefully designed to comply with the requirements of measure jj.
[1:02:45]
I won't go into the detail regarding the consistency because the city has the city staff has
[1:02:52]
presented that to you and is on a good job describing it in the specific plan and measure
[1:02:57]
JJ consistency table also known as attachment three in the staff in the in your package
[1:03:03]
tonight.
[1:03:08]
But what distinguishes the bail-ins from most other developments is that its sustainability standards
[1:03:15]
are not guidelines.
[1:03:18]
And this is an important point. They are development requirements.
[1:03:24]
100% of the site's electricity will come from renewable sources with energy generated
[1:03:29]
on-site annually from a 55-acre solar farm rooftop panels, parking canobies, and significant
[1:03:35]
battery storage. We believe that we have met both the letter and the spirit of energy neutrality
[1:03:43]
and measure JJ. And we also believe this council has
[1:03:48]
the opportunity to support a development that will be a model of sustainable development
[1:03:52]
and energy efficiency in California. Can I get the next slide, please? Molly?
[1:04:05]
One more?
[1:04:10]
GHGs.
[1:04:14]
The California Air Resources Board Carb, the state agency and charge of
[1:04:20]
quality and GG reductions has made it clear that California cannot meet its climate targets
[1:04:26]
unless people drive less. And the only way to reduce driving is to build homes near jobs and transit.
[1:04:36]
The state of California is so confident in their theory that they spend their own
[1:04:42]
and trade carbon offset funds on that program. Through it's affordable housing and sustainability
[1:04:50]
community grant program the state provides grant funds to housing and jobs near transit.
[1:04:58]
In other words, transit-oriented development is not a source of the mission the state wants to
[1:05:05]
of set. Transit oriented development is the offset. Carb has made it clear that the bail-ins project is consistent with the state's climate action plan and could be eligible for funding from its cap and trade dollars that go to its grant programs.
[1:05:25]
I think lastly, the city's EIR, and has already been discussed by city staff, also answers
[1:05:31]
this question directly, concluding that, quote, the project would result in a net reduction
[1:05:36]
in regional GHG emissions overall.
[1:05:40]
Next slide, please.
[1:05:47]
So in closing, I just, again, I want to emphasize that the bail-ons reflects 20 years
[1:05:53]
of planning, environmental review, community engagement, and choices about what kind of city
[1:05:59]
Brisbane wants to be. It says that Brisbane is ready to take its place as a city that confronts
[1:06:06]
the housing shortage, restores its ecological assets, builds around transit, and holds itself
[1:06:15]
to the highest standards of sustainable development. This is the decision before this council.
[1:06:20]
Now I thank you for your time and attention and we look forward to a productive
[1:06:24]
conversations over the course of these approval hearings. Thank you. Thank you very much,
[1:06:28]
I would definitely appreciate that.
[1:06:31]
All right.
[1:06:32]
We're team up.
[1:06:34]
Now the council will be able to ask questions and
[1:06:38]
Reminder this is on measure jj and general plan requirements.
[1:06:42]
Only as topic number one.
[1:06:45]
Let's start.
[1:06:46]
I also want to thank staff and all the consultants for your presentation tonight.
[1:06:51]
I really appreciate the detail on everything.
[1:06:54]
Mayor Pro Tem Davis, would you like to start?
[1:07:00]
You know, I actually would like to start on energy use.
[1:07:03]
So, we're going to start with...
[1:07:06]
You want to...
[1:07:07]
You want to just wait with questions then until we get to that topic.
[1:07:13]
I mean, I have measured jj questions.
[1:07:15]
Okay, so I can do those.
[1:07:17]
But I will help you to go first on energy use.
[1:07:20]
Let's just stick to topic number one.
[1:07:23]
Um,
[1:07:26]
so, this was seven.
[1:07:30]
Plan includes a table showing how it complies with each of the measure, measure, jj tenants and general plan,
[1:07:40]
bail-ins provisions. And so for the public, some of this is included in the staff report. Some of this was discussed
[1:07:45]
at the Planning Commission meeting, but I think it's important to have the public hear these answers live tonight.
[1:07:53]
So, can staff explain what the city is actually determining when it finds that the specific plan is consistent with a general plan provision, and does consistency mean that the specific plan contains provisions addressing the subject, or does consistency mean that the substantive requirement or objection objective,
[1:08:23]
of the general plan provision will actually be achieved.
[1:08:35]
Thank you, Council Member.
[1:08:36]
This is Eric Foltz with the City Attorney's Office.
[1:08:39]
So the question of plan consistency,
[1:08:42]
I think depends on the standard that is in play.
[1:08:47]
So the top line standard is that a specific plan
[1:08:52]
and all development that flows from that must be consistent with the general plan,
[1:08:57]
meaning that it doesn't frustrate the corpis of those policies and the general plan here
[1:09:04]
and it was amended by the voters to incorporate all of the policies of J.J.
[1:09:09]
So the measure J.J. policies must be advanced.
[1:09:15]
They can't be frustrated and they're purpose by the plan or by development that follows.
[1:09:20]
However, courts that interpret and review a city council's determination of consistency
[1:09:29]
recognize that it's the city council's job to weigh and balance competing priorities
[1:09:35]
within a plan that it may not be possible to achieve every component of the general plan
[1:09:42]
or every policy and that it is the city council's obligation and responsibility to weigh
[1:09:48]
balance those conflicting measures and make an overall consistency determination.
[1:09:54]
The one exception to that is for policies that are fundamental, mandatory, and clear,
[1:10:02]
that are so prescriptive, that have mandatory words like shell and must.
[1:10:09]
Of course, depending on their context, we'll look at those types of policies and say that those are
[1:10:18]
and subsequent development projects implement those policies specifically.
[1:10:24]
Thank you.
[1:10:28]
So of the measure of JJ and BL.1A through pay requirements, which are actually enforceable
[1:10:37]
development standards in the specific plan and which objectives, policies or commitments
[1:10:43]
that depend on future discretionary decisions.
[1:10:47]
And for anything that is not enforceable development standard, what mechanism ensures that the commitment will actually be implemented as the balans develops over potentially decades by different developers.
[1:11:05]
So
[1:11:08]
I think that is the specific plan is one of those tools that the development standards adopted within the specific plan.
[1:11:17]
Ultimately, we should be standards that are able to be both mandatory on future development,
[1:11:26]
and that when they're carried out will accomplish those policy goals that are in Measure J.J.
[1:11:32]
Here, the Council also has the opportunity to enter into a development agreement with the
[1:11:40]
property owner that will give an additional level of protection in addition to the regulatory
[1:11:46]
powers in the specific plan. There can be a contractual agreement that binds future owners
[1:11:55]
as well would run with the land, but that can give additional commitments to help implement
[1:12:02]
and provide oversight for those policies in Measure J.J., and we'll get into more detail
[1:12:11]
on some of those Measure J.J. policies around sustainability and in the future meetings
[1:12:16]
will dive into some of the oversight mechanisms for other Measure J.J. policies like fiscal
[1:12:23]
positivity, remediation, and those types of topics as well.
[1:12:28]
Thank you.
[1:12:29]
I'm just a couple more here.
[1:12:31]
Some measure JJ establishes requirements for the bail-ins as a whole, and individual
[1:12:37]
projects will come forward through the development applications, I presume, and so at what
[1:12:43]
point does the city determine whether a proposed project is consistent with the specific plan
[1:12:49]
and measure JJ and including its cumulative effect on the balance and then to add to that
[1:13:00]
can a future project be approved if when combined with previously approved development
[1:13:05]
it causes the balance as a whole to fall short of the measure JJ requirement.
[1:13:15]
Well, I guess there would be some RB would be there would be safeguards that would be in place before that.
[1:13:24]
So the specific plan should be the framework that enables development to occur up to the levels
[1:13:33]
contemplated within J.J. and to advance those policies and requirements that are expressed in measure J.J.
[1:13:40]
So then when individual projects are coming forward with an application for a subdivision map or to do design review or to get a use permit for those uses, the city would still need to evaluate those future specific development proposals for consistency with the specific plan and consistency with the general plan including measure jj.
[1:14:07]
So if the, well, a future development project that willing consistent with those standards that could provide a basis to deny that, that future specific development project.
[1:14:21]
So, and if actual development ultimately does not achieve a measure JJ requirement that the city determined this specific plan was consistent with, what authority does the city have to require corrective action?
[1:14:37]
and is there a specific monitoring, enforcement, or amendment mechanism, either in the specific
[1:14:45]
plan or development agreement for that situation?
[1:14:50]
Well, again, I think the answer would depend on which specific policy was in question.
[1:14:56]
And the top line defense would be to...
[1:15:00]
Not a proof of a project that we're inconsistent with the plans and the mandatory development standards.
[1:15:07]
After a plan has been approved and developed, it depends on the specific measure J.J. policy about how that would be monitored on an ongoing basis.
[1:15:22]
It's great. Those are my major JJ questions. Thank you. Thank you. Council Member Lads.
[1:15:31]
Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:15:35]
Stephanie, would you mind come to the podium please?
[1:15:41]
You know what? Okay. How's that? Is that better?
[1:15:43]
I'm trying to put my mouth to the mic. Here we go.
[1:15:47]
All right. How you doing, Stephanie?
[1:15:50]
Okay. Thank you. Council Member.
[1:15:53]
Nice, you know, that was great that you were talking about the history, you know, there's a lot of people who were in your shoes.
[1:16:01]
Many I'm sure would love to be in your position right now, they put a lot of time and effort into it. Maybe not. Maybe they wouldn't want to be in your shoes.
[1:16:09]
But, you know, they, you know, worked with the city, the community, put forth the BDI's vision initially.
[1:16:20]
You know, that's interesting and you said that, yeah, you weren't, you just became an employee
[1:16:25]
a few years ago about four years ago, but you that you had been working, you know, so to speak,
[1:16:31]
connected to the payments.
[1:16:33]
And I remember when those cowbergly students did do that, I guess, assignment, all right,
[1:16:41]
provided their input and I have to say it was excellent. The council thought the feedback and the
[1:16:51]
passion that they put into wanting to see the balance be a model for sustainable development.
[1:17:00]
You know, it had an impact. Thank you for being a part of that.
[1:17:11]
We're talking a lot about
[1:17:11]
When measure JJ was on ballot, UPC BDI endorsed it.
[1:17:17]
So I'm curious, if measure JJ was on the ballot,
[1:17:21]
this November would be D.I. endorsed the measure.
[1:17:34]
I think so, yes, I mean, I think we have gotten to a plan
[1:17:37]
that is, that is, yeah, that we've worked for, you know,
[1:17:42]
for the last eight years now since measure
[1:17:46]
JJ since JJ passed. But yeah, I think we've gotten to a place with the, with the,
[1:17:53]
with measure JJ and we're very comfortable with the specific plan.
[1:17:57]
Okay. Okay. Great. Great. Yeah.
[1:17:59]
You know, because when measure JJ passed all the requirements,
[1:18:04]
we're put into the general plan, right? And so the specific plan has to be consistent with the general plan.
[1:18:12]
I have the BLNs 2026, specific plan right here, do you feel that it's consistent with general plan?
[1:18:25]
Yes, that is the staff's recommendation and report and we concur with that.
[1:18:36]
That is consistent.
[1:18:37]
Okay, great.
[1:18:38]
I'm just kind of like understanding
[1:18:40]
where the floor is, you know, where we stand,
[1:18:43]
so I appreciate providing that information to me.
[1:18:49]
Okay, so,
[1:18:54]
you know, when I think of this endeavor
[1:18:58]
that we're on, I think of it a lot,
[1:19:02]
like the Lord of the Rings, you know,
[1:19:04]
there's these three books, right?
[1:19:05]
The first book is, you guys,
[1:19:07]
putting forth your specific plans, which enabled us to then have the draft, EIR, and then staff taking the plan, and then creating this specific plan, which then allowed us to create the final environmental document.
[1:19:25]
And then that third book really is the public, the planning commission provided the first
[1:19:33]
several chapters.
[1:19:34]
And now it's the council, right?
[1:19:36]
This is going to write that final book, you know, with all of us.
[1:19:42]
You know, when you think of Flora Rings, right?
[1:19:46]
There was that ring, the thing that bound everybody together.
[1:19:50]
You know, here it's really measured JJ.
[1:19:55]
We all of us, we're all bound to uphold what is in the ballot measure because the public voted for it.
[1:20:05]
Granted, you know, it was tough.
[1:20:07]
45% of the population did not, or the voting community did not vote for it.
[1:20:13]
But 55% did, and it became the law of the land.
[1:20:17]
So, you know, you're going to be hearing a lot from me in regards to measure JJ, because
[1:20:24]
I have an obligation, right, I have an oath to the public to uphold that measure which is now
[1:20:33]
in our general plan.
[1:20:36]
So, I just wanted to get a little bit of an understanding.
[1:20:40]
And there was, in our packet, there was a list of property owners,
[1:20:49]
and I was surprised,
[1:20:51]
right, this long list here of all these folks that are property owners.
[1:20:55]
And so I'm just curious,
[1:21:01]
do we have a map of where these owners are located?
[1:21:06]
It is not in your package, but I believe a map exists, and just to be clear, that is the entire
[1:21:14]
bail-in-specific plan area, which includes a lot of parcels that we don't own, as you
[1:21:21]
see there.
[1:21:22]
Yeah.
[1:21:23]
Okay.
[1:21:23]
I think it would be helpful from staff if we could just get a better understanding of where all
[1:21:34]
own. And I'm assuming that there's written documentation from property owners that maybe
[1:21:44]
you're, you know, in your plan development is occurring on their land. Is that, is that happening?
[1:21:51]
I'm just, some of the land that is owned by these folks is it in the, in the city plan? No,
[1:22:00]
Okay, so it's not so and then Sun Quest is the the soul owner of the property that we're evaluating
[1:22:10]
for a specific plan. Okay, okay. Good and then you know because that can you just give us some some past projects that Sun Quest has completed in the U.S.
[1:22:26]
Say it last 10, 20 years.
[1:22:33]
Well, not off the top of my head, but I believe it was some quest to build the condos that are adjacent to executive park.
[1:22:45]
Same ownership, not sure if it was the same actual entity, but yeah, if you're familiar with those condos over.
[1:22:54]
They're called,
[1:22:58]
I forget, point, a pay point around us.
[1:23:03]
Are you familiar with us?
[1:23:04]
Yeah.
[1:23:05]
No, I sometimes all run over there on the...
[1:23:08]
Yeah.
[1:23:11]
I've seen those condos before.
[1:23:14]
Okay, so this is something...
[1:23:16]
This is a project that St. Quest had built.
[1:23:20]
Yes.
[1:23:22]
Yes.
[1:23:23]
Okay. All right.
[1:23:24]
Yeah, there is a difference between an owner, a developer, I'm not sure what the question is directly, I mean Sun Quest is not a developer, they're a land owner, they bring a development partner.
[1:23:36]
So there was development partnership on those condominiums.
[1:23:39]
Yeah, okay, all right, okay, all right.
[1:23:42]
So yeah, yeah, if you wouldn't mind just kind of explain like how that process works, you know, like you would go out and get partners or
[1:23:50]
Yeah.
[1:23:51]
Yeah.
[1:23:51]
They all want the project to be billed.
[1:23:57]
Right.
[1:23:58]
So let me use an example because I think it's one that I want to keep coming back
[1:24:02]
to because it's very relevant, privately owned property in San Mateo called the Bay
[1:24:09]
Meadows Race Track.
[1:24:10]
That was purchased by one owner called Stockbridge.
[1:24:14]
Stockbridge then brought in a master developer called Wilson Meany.
[1:24:19]
We'll send me any plans, the development, and brought in different developers for the foresail section of bail-ins.
[1:24:31]
They developed the rental parcels.
[1:24:35]
They brought in a partner at Bridge to build the affordable.
[1:24:39]
They brought in a...
[1:24:41]
They didn't bring them in, but there was a request for a private high school, which was built on the Bay Meadow.
[1:24:47]
So these deals are always very, you know,
[1:24:50]
we're multi-layered, they're most structured.
[1:24:52]
So some quest is not, you know, they are the owner.
[1:24:55]
They will not be the person actually doing the development.
[1:24:57]
They will bring in a master developer.
[1:24:59]
And then that master developer will actually, you know,
[1:25:02]
likely be bringing in expert retail developers
[1:25:07]
in housing multifamily, affordable, commercial.
[1:25:12]
Oh, got it, got it, got it.
[1:25:14]
OK.
[1:25:16]
All right, thank you for that.
[1:25:17]
Yeah.
[1:25:18]
Yeah.
[1:25:18]
That's it for now.
[1:25:20]
I'll let other council members ask questions.
[1:25:22]
I'll come back later.
[1:25:23]
Madam Mayor.
[1:25:24]
OK.
[1:25:24]
Council member O'Connell?
[1:25:29]
Really, my interest is in other sections.
[1:25:32]
But in the matter of item J.J.
[1:25:36]
and this is directed to staff, if a condition is in J.J.
[1:25:42]
is reflected in the specific plan, it's enforceable by right by the city and if it's something
[1:25:52]
that is in a development agreement, it's enforceable through contractual law with the developer.
[1:26:02]
Is that the correct way to look at it?
[1:26:06]
We would have to use the courts to enforce the development
[1:26:09]
agreement, where we can use our permit system to enforce something that's in the specific
[1:26:15]
plan.
[1:26:16]
I think that depends on the way that a development agreement were framed.
[1:26:20]
It's quite common to have rights and obligations in a development agreement be a little bit
[1:26:27]
more self-enforcing, for example, a certain commitment would need to be fulfilled by the developer
[1:26:35]
the four particular time was reached and before they could get a second-chonch and building permits, for example.
[1:26:44]
So that makes it a little bit easier for a city to enforce compliance if it has the remedy built into the development agreement to pause development or
[1:26:56]
your time future development approvals to the delivery of those obligations that are
[1:27:04]
in the development agreement.
[1:27:06]
Yeah, and if I could just add in and we have some examples out in the
[1:27:09]
viewpoint of recently developed projects, so both the Genesis Marina Project and the
[1:27:13]
shore, which were developed in the last five years, also had development agreements that
[1:27:20]
provided additional assurances and benefits to the public, for example, I'm thinking of
[1:27:26]
requirement for Genesis, Marina, to be lead, gonna save, gold. I'm hoping that's correct.
[1:27:35]
I may, it may be silver. But that was something that the development agreement imposed.
[1:27:39]
So when staff was reviewing the building permit application and the revised design
[1:27:44]
permit application, that carried over and, you know, they needed to demonstrate compliance
[1:27:49]
with that as a standard essentially, but it was imposed on the DA versus like a condition
[1:27:53]
of approval or another component of the design permit itself.
[1:27:59]
So just to point that we have local examples,
[1:28:02]
or recent examples, we're both the entitlement
[1:28:05]
to the approvals, we're kind of hand-in-hand with the DA.
[1:28:08]
When staff is reviewing an actual project.
[1:28:12]
Thank you.
[1:28:13]
And then I just wanted to follow up and make sure
[1:28:17]
that from Stephanie that I got the correct interpretation
[1:28:23]
of Councilmember Lens' questions.
[1:28:27]
On the list of property owners that's within our packet,
[1:28:31]
on page 150 of 151, there's many, many property owners,
[1:28:37]
and you're saying none of these are part of what you're planning to build on,
[1:28:42]
that are not owned by you.
[1:28:44]
I'd have to check them out.
[1:28:47]
A lot of those are very small parcels that are owned by other people,
[1:28:51]
So, yeah, but I'd have to check them up and I can get back to you on that.
[1:28:56]
Okay, yeah, thank you.
[1:28:58]
It's all my questions at this point.
[1:29:01]
Through the marathon, staff could address that question as well.
[1:29:05]
So, I do want to clarify the list of owners that was attached to the packet.
[1:29:09]
It was attached to the public notice.
[1:29:11]
It included both owners of property within the specific plan area.
[1:29:16]
It also included owners within 300 feet of the property.
[1:29:19]
so that was a clarification that we need to make the list was not titled properly.
[1:29:24]
So I hope that's clear so it was a list that included owners within the specific plan area
[1:29:29]
as well as owners within 300 feet. We used that list to generate the noticing.
[1:29:35]
That makes it actually much clearer that it was titled incorrectly because
[1:29:41]
some of these names on this I believe I know they're not in the specific plan.
[1:29:49]
but who knows what else they may own.
[1:29:53]
In chapter one of the specific plan has a
[1:29:57]
the exact map that Council Member Lens was asking.
[1:30:00]
For which highlights within the specific plan area, which properties are not owned by some quest. For example, there's a parcel that recology owns. And those are maps on a figure in chapter one in the specific plan.
[1:30:15]
Yeah, it's figure 1.6.1, that's on page 1-15, the specific plan.
[1:30:21]
But not into nice package.
[1:30:24]
Well, the specific plan is attached and linked from tonight's staff report, but correct
[1:30:31]
we didn't pull it out as an attachment.
[1:30:33]
Okay, does that?
[1:30:34]
It is on page 1-15 of the specific plan and it's figure 1.61 land ownership.
[1:30:44]
Okay, thank you.
[1:30:47]
Can I just remember, Kern?
[1:30:50]
Thank you so much.
[1:30:51]
I've got a few regarding JJ consistency and anybody can take the answer to this question.
[1:31:02]
What happens to the development of cow water fails to secure final regulatory approvals from water service?
[1:31:12]
Mr. JJ requires there to be a guaranteed permanent source of water before development activities occur.
[1:31:21]
So if that's not through Cal Water, it would be incumbent upon the property owner to secure water rights through a different mechanism before any development could occur.
[1:31:33]
Thank you, Eric.
[1:31:35]
Next question is, what legal penalties apply if actual post construction energy use ends up being higher than the onsite solar production?
[1:31:48]
In the current version of the plan, there are no penalties.
[1:31:54]
Thank you.
[1:31:56]
In last but not least, we are seeing so many changes on this front, so many changes in the predictions.
[1:32:01]
how we'll see level rise defenses be updated over time at the state flood projections change
[1:32:06]
before the year 2100.
[1:32:10]
And for that we can see if we have an initial answer from or consultant team.
[1:32:17]
We do have expert environmental scientists from ESA, however the sea level rise will be a
[1:32:26]
Pacific topic at one of our future hearings, we'll do a much deeper dive on that, so we might
[1:32:32]
not have all of the answers for you on that one this evening.
[1:32:36]
Great, thank you. Those are all my questions at this time.
[1:32:38]
Alright, thank you. I have a couple of quick questions.
[1:32:45]
Because this seems to be brought up in many
[1:32:48]
circles. If staff could respond to this, there have been people asking why within this project,
[1:32:56]
we have a commercial development of 6.5 million square feet and why we would insist on commercial
[1:33:04]
in a development rather than just making it all housing.
[1:33:11]
Was the similar circular answer is that Measure J.J. provides for both housing and commercial
[1:33:20]
development. So that was the mix that was approved by the voters. However, some of the logic behind
[1:33:28]
incorporating that level of commercial development was to help meet the other policy
[1:33:34]
goal of Measure J.J. to have a development that's fiscally positive to the city on an
[1:33:40]
ongoing basis. Residential Lee and Uses tend to demand more public services and can cost
[1:33:49]
more to service than they generate in tax revenue or other revenues to the city by other
[1:33:57]
commercial developments, such as retail offices, hotels, can generate additional tax revenue
[1:34:06]
and other fees that will help the development long-term be discreet positive to the city.
[1:34:13]
And also, frankly, likely be fiscally positive for the developer, so there's sufficient
[1:34:19]
economic return to help finance the level of cleanup and infrastructure that's needed to
[1:34:26]
have any development occur at the B-Lens?
[1:34:30]
So I'd just like to further clarify.
[1:34:32]
So I also hear, if you just built housing all over the project,
[1:34:37]
you'll, as a city, have this windfall of tons of property tax.
[1:34:44]
So if I'm to go back to what you said,
[1:34:47]
property tax loan would not be sufficient to carry the weight of
[1:34:53]
services that would be required and also to make this development feasible for the development?
[1:35:02]
That, that likely is is correct and we're still working through with the city's
[1:35:08]
expert real estate economists to help put some more detailed numbers to that and some of our
[1:35:16]
future meetings will be reporting back on on those results, but that is our understanding, yes,
[1:35:21]
And certainly when the program of Measure J.J. was being discussed back in 2018, the city's
[1:35:28]
economist, Kaiser Marston, did weigh in and sit at the time, feel that that land use
[1:35:38]
mix would be fiscally positive for the city.
[1:35:44]
Proof of a reliable water supply prior to site development, what exactly characterizes the first
[1:35:51]
step as site development? Is it remediation? Is it infrastructure? Is it an application for permits for housing or commercial development?
[1:36:06]
Yeah, so it's not especially defined in measure J.J. but city practice would be to treat the first issuance of a building permit as site development activity that required that what are what are source.
[1:36:18]
So, a building permit would be for commercial or residential?
[1:36:22]
Correct.
[1:36:22]
That's correct.
[1:36:25]
So, would this present a potential conundrum if there was infrastructure and remediation and no water?
[1:36:36]
And is that legal under the tenets of California State Law to move ahead on all of
[1:36:46]
those steps without having a water source?
[1:36:54]
I'm going to move forward on which steps I'm sorry, I didn't totally follow you.
[1:36:57]
We're going to create a subdivision within the state of California.
[1:37:02]
I believe, and I can't cite it for you.
[1:37:04]
I believe there may be some state laws that require you to say, here's the water source
[1:37:08]
that's going to be used for this development.
[1:37:11]
Well there was a water supply assessment prepared, even in connection with the EIR, and
[1:37:19]
And yes, you're right every development that's subject to secret and proposes at least 500 housing units or an equivalent amount of commercial development has to go.
[1:37:30]
The thorough water supply assessment to make sure that there is adequate water infrastructure to supply the future development early.
[1:37:40]
In the process, there's approval issued long before there's development activity.
[1:37:45]
Here, Cal Water did provide an early will serve letter, there's a water supply assessment
[1:37:55]
prepared in connection with the EIRR, and then measure JJ provides an additional requirement
[1:38:01]
to have those firm water rights, again, before any development can begin to occur.
[1:38:07]
Okay, so that's before any development can occur is before a permit application is submitted for housing or commercial development.
[1:38:19]
I believe a permit could be applied for, but a building permit wouldn't be issued until that requirement were satisfied.
[1:38:28]
Okay, and the reason I'm asking is because over the duration of various incarnations that have come before,
[1:38:35]
is being on this project. There have been different water sources indicated. And so I just,
[1:38:41]
I wondered if, in fact, a will serve constitute as a legally binding document.
[1:38:48]
Well, there's, it is, that's a good question. Well, we'll, he's got a part a little bit, but there's
[1:38:53]
not a final contract to provide water service to future development at this time. That's something
[1:39:02]
that still needs to be secured and approved before,
[1:39:06]
again, before that site development activity can occur.
[1:39:09]
Okay, and I bring this up because in Brisbane,
[1:39:11]
we have no extra water for anyone here who doesn't know that.
[1:39:17]
My other question, and Stephanie, this one is for you.
[1:39:21]
So, partying off of Councilmember Lens' question
[1:39:25]
about property owner versus developers,
[1:39:29]
we knew universal paragon.
[1:39:32]
And now it's BDI, has universal paragon disappeared, and is it now BDI?
[1:39:40]
And so if you are the developer, are you the sole developer, is this something where you
[1:39:45]
would be partnering with other developers, we're just trying to figure out who's doing
[1:39:50]
what?
[1:39:50]
And we're still figuring it out too, right, men and men.
[1:39:53]
So we, BDI, Balanced Development Inc, is the entitlement and and and and property management
[1:40:03]
arm of some quest.
[1:40:06]
You PC was the former same same role.
[1:40:13]
I'm not exactly sure I wasn't around for the history and the change, but yeah, I think you can
[1:40:19]
You can, I think, for purposes of this discussion, forget about UPC.
[1:40:24]
It is, it is Baylands of Altman Inc.
[1:40:27]
Who is the entitlement and property management
[1:40:30]
arm for some quest.
[1:40:35]
Again, the way we envision this happening
[1:40:39]
as it does with all of these very large sites,
[1:40:42]
particularly privately owned.
[1:40:44]
Mission Bay is a little different
[1:40:45]
because that was mostly city owned properly.
[1:40:49]
So that's why I keep going back and referring to the Bay Meto's project, which was about, you know, a hundred acre site owned by a one-owner stock bridge, who brought in a master developer called Wilson Meaney, Wilson Meaney then brought in retail developers,
[1:41:06]
shay homes and tri-point did the housing at Baymetto's bridge housing, did the affordable
[1:41:16]
housing and Losimini actually built the commercial. So it's it's often a very, you know,
[1:41:25]
it's a stack of a master developer and then bringing in a lot of retail developers either, you know,
[1:41:36]
So you're saying that that's something that BDI would employ as well?
[1:41:41]
There's no other way to.
[1:41:43]
Okay.
[1:41:44]
To develop these large complicated sites.
[1:41:47]
You do need the retail developers.
[1:41:50]
Those are the Shay Holmes and the commercial developers who do this kind of work day in and day out.
[1:41:56]
As, you know, Councilmember Lens pointed out,
[1:41:59]
our company is not a development arm.
[1:42:01]
we don't develop, we own property, and then we sell it,
[1:42:04]
or we bring in other people to develop it.
[1:42:08]
Council member, I'll comment.
[1:42:09]
I have a follow-up question, but not for Stephanie,
[1:42:14]
for staff, you know, I do have a follow-up question
[1:42:16]
for Stephanie though, but I could do it after yours.
[1:42:19]
Okay, let's count some member of the council.
[1:42:20]
Go ahead.
[1:42:21]
I just wanted to ask staff, when you said that
[1:42:25]
there has to be a water agreement,
[1:42:28]
A guarantee before any building permits are issued, you also set water and infrastructure.
[1:42:35]
So does the infrastructure have to be built or guaranteed to that project before it can be approved?
[1:42:45]
You said the word infrastructure, so I'm wondering if that's included.
[1:42:51]
Can I ask the clear fine question?
[1:42:52]
unless you know. Okay. So are you asking does a water supply agreement need to be provided prior
[1:42:59]
to infrastructure being developed on site? No, as can you rest. Does infrastructure need to be
[1:43:05]
provided before a building permit is approved? Got it. Water infrastructure. There has to be a
[1:43:22]
part of the building permit that was being issued so it's possible that within this specific
[1:43:29]
plan water would be built out water infrastructure would be built out to just supply each
[1:43:38]
individual section as building permit was issued
[1:43:49]
or would all the water infrastructure
[1:43:51]
where we put in place before they started issuing building permits.
[1:43:58]
I think it would be unusual to see a site of this scale have all of the infrastructure
[1:44:03]
being installed up front.
[1:44:05]
It's more common to phase it along with development typically the way that the city
[1:44:13]
regulates that is through a subdivision improvement agreement or a public improvement agreement
[1:44:20]
where the improvements have to be that will serve the particular development have to be identified
[1:44:28]
and bonded for and delivered in connection with the development that it will serve.
[1:44:35]
So bonded for you means city provided?
[1:44:38]
No, the developer.
[1:44:41]
Developer provided. Okay, thank you.
[1:44:45]
Council Member Lens?
[1:44:46]
Yeah, I just have to follow up on your question to Stephanie's assessment, might come
[1:44:51]
up please.
[1:44:53]
So you're going to learn the planning commission, hearings, and our hearing.
[1:44:59]
There's the specific...
[1:45:00]
And then there's the development agreement, right? And the DA is a contract between the city and who on your side. Is it Sunquest? Is it?
[1:45:11]
Well, no, it's BDI. We're acting as the agent for or Sunquest.
[1:45:15]
Okay. So you have the authority you've given you've shown fruit to staff that you have.
[1:45:22]
Yes. It's a big contract, right? So we need to make sure we dot all our eyes across all our T's.
[1:45:27]
Yes. Okay, so that's in writing. Our CEO will be yeah, signing the development agreement. Okay. With, you know, obviously, feedback from the ownership. Yeah, yeah, I'm just
[1:45:42]
Authorized. This is authorized. I was authorized and then first right you have a contract and you hope that each side upholds contract and right, you know, not all contracts. Go as planned. So we just need to know
[1:45:58]
information. Okay, great. Thank you. Anyone else on council? No. Okay. I do have just
[1:46:07]
one question, matter mayor for staff. Go ahead. And that is in regards to fiscal
[1:46:13]
impacts on page 11.
[1:46:19]
So, Ray is talking about revenue positive for the city on
[1:46:30]
And this analysis is undergoing peer review by the city's consultant, Kaiser Marston associate.
[1:46:37]
So where are you with that and when will that be available to the council?
[1:46:44]
That review is still ongoing.
[1:46:47]
I'm not sure.
[1:46:49]
To the manager has any other more accurate response other than we are still working with Kizimar.
[1:46:54]
Yeah, thank you.
[1:46:55]
Through the chair.
[1:46:56]
Jeremy got a city manager.
[1:46:58]
We're having an internal conversation.
[1:46:59]
or monitor discuss next steps related to scope.
[1:47:05]
Once we resolve that issue with Kaiser Marston,
[1:47:09]
it would take approximately four weeks
[1:47:11]
to get a product back from them.
[1:47:14]
And then I'm curious.
[1:47:16]
So in this paragraph, it talks about being revenue-positive.
[1:47:21]
But will we also have fiscal analysis
[1:47:23]
identifying projected costs for remediation
[1:47:27]
infrastructure such as water, roads, open space, and then how those costs will be paid
[1:47:34]
and by who. Are we going to have like that complete fiscal analysis?
[1:47:44]
That's not doing a full performance for the development is not part of the economists
[1:47:50]
Let's go right now,
[1:47:53]
but the specifically and contemplates mixture of financing sources, which
[1:48:00]
could include obviously private investment, state grants, and funding sources, as well
[1:48:09]
as the opportunity to bond with community financing district, a Meloruce CFD, or an infrastructure
[1:48:18]
refinancing, just direct, and those are mechanisms that will be discussing in more detail
[1:48:26]
in connection with the revenue positive partner.
[1:48:29]
Exactly.
[1:48:30]
The revenue and the development of the development degree.
[1:48:34]
I wasn't planning to bring it up because I know that we'll be discussing in other areas.
[1:48:39]
But this is kind of like a team you up, right?
[1:48:42]
You know, to have some kind of fiscal analysis of those areas.
[1:48:45]
I mean, obviously, not angry, you know,
[1:48:49]
granular detail, but just having a general understanding
[1:48:52]
for the council so that as we move into other parts
[1:48:56]
of discussion, we have that information available.
[1:49:01]
Okay, thank you.
[1:49:04]
I'm kind of quick follow up on that, please.
[1:49:06]
So considering that Kaiser Marston needs a, you know,
[1:49:11]
an additional four weeks, at least,
[1:49:14]
I imagine that the hearing that we'll have exploring, you know, and that positive for the city
[1:49:24]
is going to be after that four weeks.
[1:49:28]
We're not going to have that discussion without that information.
[1:49:30]
No, I don't think that the discussion would make any sense without that information.
[1:49:34]
I just, I don't remember exactly what the date of that meeting is, so I just want to make sure it's more than four weeks.
[1:49:42]
So if we have to adjust the schedule, we'll do so.
[1:49:45]
I think it's a good further record.
[1:49:47]
It's projected for October 15, which is about a month away.
[1:49:51]
Well, it's tight.
[1:49:52]
So I mean, we were definitely going to need to have time to review that analysis.
[1:49:56]
And the public needs time to review that analysis before we can have an informed
[1:50:01]
conversation on that date.
[1:50:03]
So we may need to plan ahead and do some adjusting.
[1:50:08]
Correct.
[1:50:09]
It's also possible that the consultant could finish a deliverable more quickly, well, emphasize
[1:50:14]
there need to be efficient.
[1:50:19]
Any other council questions?
[1:50:22]
All right.
[1:50:23]
I have some slips.
[1:50:25]
We're still on this topic.
[1:50:26]
If you've heard a lot about this topic, so if anyone else anticipates wanting to make a comment
[1:50:34]
or ask a question, if you haven't filled out a slip, would you please do so now just on
[1:50:39]
topic, which is can you restate? Yes, this topic is measure JJ and the general plan requirements
[1:50:45]
to govern the Bayland's specific plan. Not a mayor, perhaps you did not miss it, but I think
[1:50:51]
you mean to open the public hearing. I'm going to in a second. I didn't get there yet. Okay, so I
[1:50:58]
see some people filling out slips and I'll remind just for this first go around anyone online,
[1:51:04]
go in the chat, feature on Zoom, City Clerk will be there, they'll create the
[1:51:12]
speaker slip for us and put you in the queue to speak. That being said, I'm gonna open
[1:51:18]
the public hearing now, and the first slip I have is from Arnold, Galaga. I'm sorry if I'm
[1:51:26]
mispronouncing name Arnold, but yes sir, if you could step up to the podium please, thank you.
[1:51:34]
Yes, my name is Arnold Galarza at CGA L-A-R-Z-A and I own the property at 3840
[1:51:45]
bassure boulevard and I noticed that my name was on the
[1:51:51]
balan's list of owners
[1:51:54]
but my partial is not
[1:51:58]
so my partial number is
[1:52:04]
007 553 050 and it's not on the list. I'm not even across the street from the project.
[1:52:15]
And I just wanted my name to be deleted and have a record showing that.
[1:52:22]
Julia, could you respond to that, please?
[1:52:25]
Sure. So we acknowledged, I think.
[1:52:30]
15 minutes or so ago that the attachment that Mr. Colars' name appeared on was mistitled. It represents not only owners within the specific plan area, but also owners of property within 300 feet of the specific plan area, which is properties within 300 feet.
[1:52:47]
So we acknowledge publicly that he's not an owner of land within the specific plan area, the name of his name appears on the list as he is an owner within 300 feet.
[1:52:57]
I hope that.
[1:52:58]
But I have my name removed from that list.
[1:53:03]
Julie, he's requesting his name to be removed from the list.
[1:53:09]
We have to provide notice to property owners within 300 feet.
[1:53:14]
So we can make sure that the list is titled properly.
[1:53:17]
But would continue to provide that notice to property owners within 300 feet.
[1:53:25]
That'd be fine. I just need it. I just need my name removed.
[1:53:30]
Okay. All right. Thank you. Any further problems with that serve? You would contact our planning department.
[1:53:37]
Don't square that for you. Okay. All right. Thank you.
[1:53:40]
Thank you. Next one I have is Paul Buscal.
[1:53:53]
Paul Buscal. There's been resident. Thank you. Council and everybody here tonight.
[1:53:59]
Um, I just wanted to bring up things I brought up in the past regarding J.J., and, you know,
[1:54:08]
it would have been a super fun site, had housing been mentioned back in the day, but
[1:54:13]
housing was never mentioned.
[1:54:14]
That's why it's a brown field.
[1:54:16]
With that said, I said out of the draft environmental impact report committee, the EIR, the
[1:54:23]
that approached heard you guys, came to meetings, the developers, the builders, and you know
[1:54:35]
this is at least 10 years down the road. So I have an idea for the housing. I'll start there.
[1:54:43]
I'd like to see us amend the general plan and how the housing moved to the lower portion of
[1:54:51]
adjacent to infrastructure, base or main street. We can make the connection to Guadalupe
[1:54:58]
in the park, like people wanted to see. We could get funding to maintain the butterfly habitat
[1:55:06]
that's above the properties. Just like we did a density transfer of Brisbane to give property owners
[1:55:14]
right to build more density because of their habitat that had value, we should give the developer
[1:55:20]
or density transfer right for hazardous areas that they moved housing out of the Baylands and
[1:55:28]
put it into a property, something we could do now get the housing built. And for some of
[1:55:34]
you that might not know that a hot issue about the housing in the Baylands is none of those
[1:55:40]
the kids are going to be in the Brisbane School District. They're in the Basior School District.
[1:55:45]
That's not okay. We can't have a city that has children in their community that are in a different
[1:55:51]
school district like that. That's a hostile school district. I'll say that publicly.
[1:55:59]
So, with that said,
[1:56:04]
a general pandemic could look at that. We need to pump the brakes on this development.
[1:56:08]
And now we have candlestick being, I mean,
[1:56:13]
they're moving fast tracking on candlestick.
[1:56:15]
Maybe a lot of the infrastructure in the bayonets
[1:56:17]
was going to have to do as far as the connectors to the highway
[1:56:20]
could be accomplished through that development.
[1:56:23]
Maybe they could bring high pressure water,
[1:56:25]
like San Francisco has for their firefighting,
[1:56:27]
which two thirds of the water that's going to be required for the bayonets
[1:56:32]
is supposed to be for firefighting.
[1:56:34]
And we don't need to see.
[1:56:35]
That's everything, the high pressure system can do for the Baylands development.
[1:56:40]
They're talking about bringing in the transit into the Baylands.
[1:56:45]
Developments near transit, most people that live in those developments don't use the transit
[1:56:50]
because it's not frequent enough to get their cars and have to drive to where they're going.
[1:56:55]
So these transit-oriented developments don't really fly.
[1:57:01]
Let's bring something big here, let's bring a big event center, you know, the state tried to
[1:57:06]
come in with high speed rail, another thing that the latest project, then they tried to do
[1:57:13]
excessive condemnation, take it more on them and need it. Once the state comes in, there's
[1:57:18]
no planning department in Brisbane that can have any say in a state development data centers,
[1:57:27]
whatever they want to do, so we have to be careful. We need to pump the brakes, cow water,
[1:57:36]
is not a reliable source. So just go water, turn out if you want to do a development agreement
[1:57:42]
with or whatever it is with cow water, maybe instead of relying on one water source coming
[1:57:52]
into the bayonets from Cal Water, you have 44 inch mean and a 60 inch water mean from
[1:57:58]
head-touchy, and to Mayor Mackinant's point, yes, there is enough water, a lot bit, for
[1:58:05]
Brisbane, however, if we could accomplish, like I had mentioned to the bayonets, creating
[1:58:11]
a non-political water tank, or having our own high pressure water system that we pump bayonets
[1:58:17]
like say I've just got those full of high pressure fire fighting systems so thank you
[1:58:23]
oh was that it I didn't see the clock I didn't even think you started yet
[1:58:28]
no okay thank you thank you thank you thank you for letting me read but please
[1:58:34]
come to breaks on this week we need to look at this from a different standpoint nowadays
[1:58:40]
especially with candlestick going on okay thank you next one I have is
[1:58:48]
Randall Vennable?
[1:58:57]
I'm sitting in the council, my name is Randall Vennable.
[1:59:00]
I'm a business owner here in Fritz Bay, and I'm a homeowner, probably say.
[1:59:08]
Three years ago, I realized that when I moved to Fritz Bay, that just like my business
[1:59:14]
changes, revolutionary, and it's also revolutionary.
[1:59:18]
And what I found about Brisbane that really made my decision to move here was as a business for 30 years, I remember going into Brisbane hardware.
[1:59:32]
And you guys probably all know Billy, Billy his father, second generation.
[1:59:36]
I walked up to him and I said, hey, I just moved into the neighborhood and my business.
[1:59:42]
I'm looking for credit and he said, you know, shook my hand, he says, you already have
[1:59:47]
the credit.
[1:59:49]
And so that was what made me feel like small town Brisbane was important, and I'm glad I
[1:59:55]
moved here.
[1:59:55]
I'm very happy to be a citizen.
[1:59:57]
So the revolutionary part of this is...
[2:00:00]
Tenages are revolutionary, and not everybody is going to let. Not everybody is going to appreciate it, but it has to come in time. I think the JJ project is going to be good for this city. It's going to be good for our business. I really hope that the project, however, does include our small business. And small businesses are important. Small businesses are like to sell in my house, my business, other businesses. We need to have a place. So hopefully the project doesn't move us out and keeps us.
[2:00:29]
part of this community. Thank you.
[2:00:35]
Thank you, Tom Wagner.
[2:00:45]
The steam counsel, thank you for allowing me to just address you guys. I'm not going
[2:00:49]
to go into all the reasons that I support the project, but I'm just asking for your support
[2:00:55]
for Mr. JJ and the specific plan, and I thank you for your consideration.
[2:01:02]
Thank you, Mr. Wagner. Mary Rogers.
[2:01:12]
Good evening. I'm here because I
[2:01:15]
I would sat through all of the planning commission meetings regarding
[2:01:20]
Be sure a boulevard getting sliced the road diet down to two lanes,
[2:01:25]
and I was surprised to see staff recommending the mobility project as is.
[2:01:33]
So I'm hoping that you don't approve that.
[2:01:37]
But if you happen to approve that, road diet,
[2:01:40]
I would like to see the following analysis.
[2:01:45]
Traffic needs to be monitored, street by street.
[2:01:49]
We all know the chaos on visitation in San Bruno, as of today.
[2:01:53]
Can you imagine that with the Baylands Project and all the traffic coming through town?
[2:02:03]
Conduct to baseline traffic counts before implementation.
[2:02:07]
So residents in the city can't objectively measure any changes afterward.
[2:02:11]
A count for the full Baylands build out when evaluating potential traffic impacts, rather than modeling only current conditions.
[2:02:20]
Set measurable thresholds for cut-through traffic, speeding noise and pedestrian safety, with a commitment to take corrective action of these thresholds are exceeded.
[2:02:30]
Report the results publicly and provide residents with the meaningful opportunity to review and respond to the data.
[2:02:37]
So that's one thing.
[2:02:40]
Secondly, you did bring up looking at the fiscal impact of this big project.
[2:02:49]
It's important that council see the net positive.
[2:02:53]
It's revenue, less expenses.
[2:02:56]
So expenses are going to have to be modeled out.
[2:02:59]
You guys should not be signing on the dotted line until you take a look at the numbers.
[2:03:03]
And what that really means to the city of Brisbane, that's very important, at least put a
[2:03:09]
stake in the ground and have that analysis done before you sign on the dotted line.
[2:03:14]
And then thirdly, I'm surprised of all the questions that Council has been asking staff
[2:03:21]
and back and forth.
[2:03:23]
As this is a huge project, this impacts Brisbane, this is going to change Brisbane.
[2:03:28]
And I'm surprised that some of those questions have not been answered prior to this meeting.
[2:03:34]
I mean, we are close to signing this agreement.
[2:03:38]
And some of these questions are pretty basic.
[2:03:40]
We should already know this.
[2:03:43]
So please be on top of it.
[2:03:46]
Thank you.
[2:03:49]
Thank you, Mary.
[2:03:52]
Linda Salman.
[2:04:04]
Well, I think if I had been here when JJ was going on,
[2:04:07]
would not have passed. I would have got at least 6% people against it. But anyway, we have all
[2:04:14]
kinds of problems, I think. One is the ownership. So if some requests the same as context,
[2:04:20]
I'm not really sure. If that's the same owner. If they've actually changed owners or just
[2:04:24]
changed their name. But one of the problems we had on the Northeast Ridge is as soon as we passed,
[2:04:30]
said we'd go for permits. They sold everything to Brookfield, which then Brookfield ignored
[2:04:35]
all the things that they were supposed to do, which is why I sued them. But anyway,
[2:04:41]
so we have to have some kind of protection in terms of what's happening, who's responsible,
[2:04:47]
is that the owner is the owner still, tonnex, what's going on. And so for the property, everything
[2:04:53]
sold, everything, any kinds of constrictions, whatever has to go with it. And then let's see,
[2:05:01]
It says to be just major JJ, so the EIR itself, I don't know if that's part of major JJ but to me it is and it's inadequate.
[2:05:11]
First of all, the tank farm down below is not considered. That's super explosive.
[2:05:16]
I don't know what's going to happen. If you have one road to get there with a fire department, it's not our fire department is not going to be able to get there.
[2:05:24]
We have the glue factory, the race courses, other things that have existed there where they're
[2:05:29]
planning to build homes that are not considered, none of the talks that are dealt with.
[2:05:37]
And then, how can you have gardens on clay caps?
[2:05:41]
One of the things that hasn't been talked about, they talk about sea level rise, but they
[2:05:45]
haven't talked about liquid faction in the case of earthquakes.
[2:05:48]
I'm sorry, it's not going to happen.
[2:05:51]
You've got a five-foot clay cap. You have an earthquake. It's going to disappear. And you're not going to want children on it.
[2:06:01]
Twenty-three years ago, writing in the 1994 General Plan, I gave enough FARs where they could build infrastructure that was commercial along Bayshore with dwelling units of above for the people who work there.
[2:06:20]
not for kids playing on toxic soil and I really think that needs to be considered. As to water,
[2:06:26]
we don't have enough water even for the houses that exist in California. Now, and there's no
[2:06:32]
way you're going to get more water from anything anywhere else. You're going to put a desolination plan
[2:06:39]
there? Plant? I don't think so. It's not going to happen. So there's a lot of stuff that's still going
[2:06:45]
that's still not possible to do. And we talk about electricity, I guess, we'll wait for the
[2:06:52]
sustainable building measures topic number two, but we have problems here that still have not
[2:06:57]
been dealt with. And I'm just asking you please to go over everything with a fine tooth comb,
[2:07:04]
because it's not at all settled as far as I'm concerned. And believe me. We give him plenty of
[2:07:13]
to build something 32 years ago, and they didn't.
[2:07:19]
Ms. Hammond, would you like your question answered about
[2:07:22]
context, I believe, certainly could respond to that.
[2:07:26]
That would be great.
[2:07:34]
I can, please don't quote me on this, but I believe Tuntex has been completely dissolved in some
[2:07:42]
questions that honor the Brisbane bailouts.
[2:07:45]
Okay, thank you.
[2:07:49]
I have a dog chest share, I believe.
[2:08:04]
Good evening, Mayor Macton. Fellow council members and staff, thank you for giving me the opportunity
[2:08:09]
to speak this evening. My name is Doug Cheshire, I'm a field representative for Carpenter's
[2:08:12]
2017 here in San Mateo County, where I represent over 1200 members here in San Mateo County,
[2:08:18]
but over 36,000 in Northern California alone. I'm here tonight to ask that you approve
[2:08:24]
to excuse me, affirm that the specific plan is consistent with the Measure J.J. and the General
[2:08:29]
Plan. And for nearly two decades, this development is set idol waiting for this moment.
[2:08:37]
The Baylands is a once-in-a-generational development that will create
[2:08:40]
and advanced jobs throughout its lifetime and beyond.
[2:08:46]
Right here in Brisbane and throughout San Mateo County,
[2:08:49]
that being said, partnering with a responsible union contractor,
[2:08:53]
the Bayland team is providing an opportunity
[2:08:54]
that many developers leave out of the equation,
[2:08:57]
and that is committing to the community and those who build it.
[2:09:01]
That commitment comes, excuse me,
[2:09:02]
that commitment will create jobs with livable wages, healthcare,
[2:09:06]
retirement benefits with apprenticeship opportunities,
[2:09:08]
to local construction workers that include minorities, women, at risk youth.
[2:09:15]
Ensuring that they will develop the skills necessary to have a successful life-long career in the construction industry.
[2:09:22]
That alone will leave lasting impacts on working families right here in Brisbane and throughout the region for decades to come.
[2:09:28]
This development will also provide 2,200 units of much-needed housing in walkable neighborhoods with increased connectivity with parks
[2:09:35]
and trails helping meet the city's housing needs.
[2:09:39]
I'd like to thank City staff and the applicant team for their hard work in crafting such a well thought out development.
[2:09:45]
This is not just another project.
[2:09:47]
This is the moment.
[2:09:49]
Please move this project forward.
[2:09:50]
Thank you.
[2:09:52]
Thank you.
[2:09:54]
Thank you, gentlemen.
[2:09:57]
Nancy Lachs-Mana.
[2:10:05]
Good evening, Mayor and Council members.
[2:10:08]
I have been here also all of these years and grew up in visitation valley.
[2:10:13]
So I'm well versed in knowing what this property has been 60 years ago, closed the dump.
[2:10:21]
We actually are family home, looked down upon it from the hill far near Schleglock.
[2:10:27]
I'm thrilled that you said early on, prefacing this conversation, Ms. Mackin, that we're
[2:10:34]
all looking for a positive outcome.
[2:10:35]
The voters of Brisbane, even though it was a 55-45 gap, it was actually 21 percent more
[2:10:43]
people voted for the project than didn't.
[2:10:48]
So I hope that you will continue with that spirit that this is what the people of Brisbane
[2:10:54]
voted on eight years ago and truly want and need and require that measure JJ does exactly
[2:11:02]
what all of you are demanding.
[2:11:03]
It meets the requirements, not just the guide pose, so the goal pose or whatever you want
[2:11:08]
to call it.
[2:11:09]
So I really appreciate what you've done.
[2:11:12]
I also appreciate what the Planning Commission has done voting unanimously to move this
[2:11:17]
forward to you to this point.
[2:11:20]
Long overdue, but I totally get what we've done and I support you in what you have required
[2:11:27]
of this process.
[2:11:30]
We believe that this is really the moving forward for Brisbane, or at least I believe that
[2:11:37]
this moving forward for Brisbane as it was written in Measure J. J. Thank you.
[2:11:43]
Thank you, Nancy. Emily Wagnersa.
[2:12:01]
Good evening, Mayor. Council members. My name is Emily.
[2:12:11]
I'm
[2:12:11]
a 25-year resident might be able to guess my age from that.
[2:12:17]
I believe that community expansion right now in Brisbane should be viewed as an opportunity
[2:12:21]
to build a stronger, more diverse and economically resilient city.
[2:12:28]
This growth can bring meaningful benefits to our community such as new housing, new businesses,
[2:12:33]
new jobs, and increased opportunities for all of us as my career and my independence grows.
[2:12:40]
I would love to be able to continue living and working in our city as our community grows,
[2:12:47]
thoughtful development, which seems to be the goal here, can also attract employers, strengthen
[2:12:53]
our local economy, and provide the infrastructure and services that we need as a growing community.
[2:13:00]
I understand that growth should never come at the expense of safety or quality of life,
[2:13:06]
and as someone who spends a lot of time on different projects sites,
[2:13:09]
plans change. They change all the time. New recommendations and resources are required to keep the health and safety of everyone at the utmost importance.
[2:13:20]
I believe if we keep safety as our priority, this project will responsibly thus be successfully developed.
[2:13:27]
We should remember that responsible growth is not about choosing development over community, which would mean advocating for growth at any cost.
[2:13:34]
but more so it's about finding a balance that allows our city to move forward while also
[2:13:39]
protecting the people who call it home. Thank you. Thank you.
[2:13:48]
Lizzie,
[2:13:48]
the tapia tapia.
[2:13:54]
Hi, Lizzie. Come on up here.
[2:13:58]
Hi everyone. Good evening council members.
[2:14:01]
My name is Lizzie Tapia. I'm the president of the United Hero Local 2. The hotel and food
[2:14:06]
service workers union. Local 2 has commented over the last few months about multiple
[2:14:11]
aspects of this project. Today we want to focus on one issue that is of utmost importance to our members,
[2:14:19]
which is the quality of permanent jobs of the project and how that relates to the issue of
[2:14:23]
sustainability. According to the ballot question from measure JJ, the Bayland's development
[2:14:30]
must abide by Brisbane's sustainability framework principles. The sustainability framework for
[2:14:36]
the Bayland states throughout the San Francisco Bay area, the possibility of being able to live
[2:14:41]
where you work is an option that many working class people can no longer achieve.
[2:14:46]
The framework notes that one of the factors driving the affordability crisis
[2:14:50]
is the lack of jobs that pay well enough to keep up with the cost of living.
[2:14:55]
So what are jobs that pay well enough to keep up with the cost of living?
[2:15:00]
We believe their jobs with affordable family health care. Jobs that have living wages, jobs that have retirement security. All of those are factors in addressing affordability.
[2:15:11]
The developer of this project has reached out to us, and we're talking with them about this very issue. Our members care deeply about bringing good jobs to Brisbane.
[2:15:20]
As you contemplate this project, we hope you'll keep our concerns in mind. Thank you.
[2:15:24]
Thank you. Michelle Salman.
[2:15:37]
Michelle Salman, Brisbane resident, contrary to what people might think.
[2:15:41]
And spell my name correctly.
[2:15:44]
Contrary to what people might think, I am not opposed to the project overall.
[2:15:50]
And it is going to move forward.
[2:15:53]
But I'm very concerned about the toxins.
[2:15:57]
I'm very concerned about where things are going to be placed.
[2:16:01]
I'm very concerned about the viability over all for the city of Brisbane, and I'm also concerned that it will be taking place at the same time as a potential project in the query.
[2:16:13]
But one of the things that there were several things, and one of them is that I'm still not comfortable with the draft EIR or the EIR.
[2:16:23]
There are data gaps that were not addressed, and there are questions that were put forth, you know, in 1925 we started using
[2:16:32]
let it gas, and we used let it gas until 1992.
[2:16:38]
There is significant lead deposition all along old base shore and all along Highway 101 that has not been
[2:16:46]
studied in the EIR.
[2:16:48]
There are other data gaps, and I've brought them up, and they really have an impact on where we place things, for instance, a school.
[2:17:00]
So I am very concerned about that, and so as we move forward, my number one thing is that whatever we do is safe.
[2:17:08]
I also was really unclear about the answer about the water.
[2:17:14]
Before they break ground, do they have to have a water source for the entire project or is it going to be
[2:17:22]
a piecemeal?
[2:17:23]
Because water is going to become more and more scarce as we move forward.
[2:17:29]
That's pretty obvious when you look at climate change and you look at current trends and
[2:17:34]
the sustainability barriers that we are surpassing every day that we will not be able to go
[2:17:39]
back on.
[2:17:40]
And so if we proceed with this, I do want to make sure that we have all water that is needed for this project committed before we start.
[2:17:50]
Because one of the things in measure JJ is that has to be a full sustainable plan and fully, you know, like pays for itself.
[2:18:00]
And then the other thing is they were talking about GHG emissions per capita.
[2:18:07]
What capita number are they using for that?
[2:18:10]
The current one, the expected one, the one that includes population growth that's continuing
[2:18:17]
to happen.
[2:18:19]
So there are a lot of things it's still, is it going to be absolutely safe for future
[2:18:23]
residents?
[2:18:24]
Well, we darn well better make sure that it is because we don't want people dying out
[2:18:29]
we don't want them dying to live on the bail-ins.
[2:18:34]
And so that's the part that I take seriously.
[2:18:36]
And I don't want these nice workers to get sick,
[2:18:39]
working with toxic materials and toxic dust.
[2:18:42]
I don't want people who are going to live out there or work out there,
[2:18:46]
get sick and get cancer.
[2:18:48]
Oh, yeah, they're going to need medical insurance.
[2:18:51]
You know, we don't need another toxic site.
[2:18:55]
And this is why remediation is really, really important.
[2:18:58]
We really need to focus on making this as clean and safe as we possibly can and if we can't make a clean and safe
[2:19:07]
For people to live there and work there. Well, that's a problem. Thank you. And also
[2:19:13]
It is not comparable to the three projects that Stephanie brought up. Those were very different things. Each project is unique and
[2:19:22]
This is particularly the Sarah Point project. That was a planned
[2:19:26]
Diked, layered, manifested, and titled 27 closed landfill.
[2:19:32]
That is a way different thing than what we're talking about here.
[2:19:35]
I just really want to make that clear.
[2:19:37]
Thank you.
[2:19:37]
Sam, would you like your question answered about the water?
[2:19:41]
I would like my question answered.
[2:19:43]
And the other thing I think that might be this up is if when you say who's coming up,
[2:19:47]
you could say who's going to be next after them so they're all prepared and ready to go.
[2:19:51]
Go faster.
[2:19:53]
So staff the question that she asked was about whether the water had to be secured for the entire site or if that could be done in phases for different.
[2:20:04]
Yeah, because it's done piecemeal.
[2:20:06]
I don't think we're going to get the water and we'll never get the project to where it is revenue positive for the city of Brisbane and we'll be left hanging.
[2:20:15]
So, Measure J.J. does require the reliable water supply to support proposed uses within the
[2:20:23]
Baylands prior to site development, so that does suggest that the water contract has to
[2:20:28]
cover adequate supply for all future development before any development begins.
[2:20:36]
Thank you.
[2:20:36]
We need to make sure that is really locked in, and we really need to make sure on this entire
[2:20:41]
I think that we dot our eyes and cross our teeth and you have brought up some very
[2:20:45]
astute questions tonight and so I have the people who have come and spoke.
[2:20:50]
So let's take note and tighten our belts and get this done but let's get it done right.
[2:20:55]
Okay, thank you, Michelle.
[2:20:56]
So the next speaker card I have is for Alley and you're going to hate me,
[2:21:02]
Saperman.
[2:21:03]
I'm not sure if I'm saying it right.
[2:21:05]
And Clara, you will be after her.
[2:21:09]
Clara Johnson will be after that.
[2:21:19]
Good evening, Mayor, and City Council members. My name is Ellie Saberman, very close. On behalf
[2:21:23]
of the Housing Action Coalition, we support the Bayland's specific plan as an implementation
[2:21:27]
of Measure J.J., the General Plan and Amendment Brisbane voters approved in 2018 specifically
[2:21:33]
to make this development possible. Forers gave the city a clear mandate. Up to 2,200 homes
[2:21:40]
and 7 million square feet of commercial space on the site. That mandate has been sitting on
[2:21:44]
for years while Brisbane's housing element fell out of compliance with the law.
[2:21:49]
The specific plan before you tonight is how the city finally delivers on what voters
[2:21:52]
already approved. We are due to adopt a plan that says faithful to measure JJ's framework
[2:21:57]
while giving the project enough flexibility to actually get built over the decades it will take
[2:22:02]
to construct. A plan that technically satisfies Measure JJ on paper but can't attract financing
[2:22:08]
or survive changing market conditions is not honor the voters intent either. It's time to
[2:22:14]
vote into an approved bill double plan. Thank you.
[2:22:17]
Okay, thank you.
[2:22:19]
Claire Johnson.
[2:22:23]
And after Claire, we'll have Karen Cunningham.
[2:22:37]
I just wanted to say thank you for all of the comments and questions I was gratified by hearing what you wanted to know, and I appreciate the health with the auditory problem, and that you have a lot of people for a minute, so I think that really makes a difference for the public.
[2:22:58]
And I think we need to keep looking at JJ.
[2:23:02]
I certainly have needed to look at it over and over because it contains the instructions
[2:23:07]
for what many members of the public are saying that it is needed.
[2:23:11]
The problem is that the current version of the FER does not comply with those instructions.
[2:23:16]
If you follow what JJ requires, then this whole enterprise will be in much better shape.
[2:23:23]
In my opinion, you should choose the environmentally superior alternative for the sake of
[2:23:28]
environment and the community. The document presented here states that overall the
[2:23:34]
environmentalist superior alternatives has fewer impacts on the physical
[2:23:39]
environment and that to me means it's straightforward. You don't have to question
[2:23:44]
that if the document itself states it I think we're all on the same page. I ask you
[2:23:58]
can think reflect and that you can make a decision not under not so much pressure.
[2:24:05]
I agree with the person who said that it's hard when you're also working on the
[2:24:09]
core project in a TIR stage and it's difficult because everything else continues without
[2:24:16]
abating the needs on your time and the staff's time and the public's time.
[2:24:25]
I think there will be a better project if you do slow down and the project can be well overseen by the city in a logical, safer and controlled way.
[2:24:36]
Our integrity as a city will be preserved and our future will be assured.
[2:24:40]
In addition, the base norm mobility plan, the part of that I object to is the road diet.
[2:24:48]
And if we get that road diet, then we're all going to be suffering long-term gastric difficulties.
[2:24:56]
I wanted to ask, I recall that the Sun Quest was a wholly owned subsidiary of UPC.
[2:25:05]
Now, I believe that universal paragon was a subsequent name of context, so I'm not sure
[2:25:15]
of that.
[2:25:16]
But I think there are BDI and Sunquest, wholly owned subsidiaries of universal paragon Inc,
[2:25:24]
or of another yet unnamed corporation.
[2:25:28]
I think that I'd sure like to know that.
[2:25:30]
And I thought that the infrastructure had to be a water infrastructure, had to be provided for the entire project.
[2:25:39]
And I'm going to be the basic infrastructure in order that, maybe I'm wrong, and I'd like to know, or perhaps it was for an entire phase.
[2:25:50]
But I thank you very much for listening and I congratulate you with how much trouble you're going to have.
[2:25:58]
make a decision.
[2:26:00]
So Miss Johnson, you had two questions in there.
[2:26:03]
Yeah.
[2:26:03]
One you asked if Sunquest was a wholly owned subsidiary of Universal Paragon.
[2:26:10]
So maybe Stephanie can answer that for you.
[2:26:12]
And the other question you had was that the water structure.
[2:26:17]
So I'm assuming you're talking pipes versus water.
[2:26:20]
I'm talking about the main pipes that's required for a water supply to take off from.
[2:26:26]
It seems like that would be a lot to build at the beginning, but I recall that people, we all kept saying it's for the entire project.
[2:26:37]
I believe that sort of says in the general plan somewhere.
[2:26:39]
Okay, so let's find out for you.
[2:26:41]
Thank you very much.
[2:26:42]
Thank you.
[2:26:44]
So Stephanie, could you address the Sunquest Paragon connection?
[2:26:50]
Hi, I'm Katie.
[2:26:51]
low-accent day director of community relations for BDI and I'll touch on this a little bit.
[2:26:56]
We're going to do a little more research on the history of the corporate structure.
[2:27:00]
I've been with a company about two years, Stephanie's been with it about four years and
[2:27:04]
as you all know this has been going on for 20 years so the structure of course has evolved over time.
[2:27:10]
But as Stephanie mentioned we are the development entitlement entity on the actual
[2:27:17]
operations of the development as it proceeds later on will most likely happen with partnerships
[2:27:23]
with BDI. But we can look into all the various names that have been going on for the past 20 years
[2:27:29]
and get back to you. Okay, we appreciate that. Thank you. And staff, if you could address the water
[2:27:35]
infrastructure question. So we touched on this a little bit earlier, but going back to
[2:27:44]
measure J.J., it does talk about how each increment of development shall be provided with
[2:27:51]
appropriate transportation infrastructure, site amenities, other infrastructure, which are
[2:27:59]
to be provided at developers' cost and I think that it's the same mechanism that we were
[2:28:04]
discussing before that as a phase of development is approved. The infrastructure to support that
[2:28:12]
would be provided and, again, bonded for and provided in connection with that development.
[2:28:21]
And if I'm not capturing the city side of that process perfectly, I'll defer to our public
[2:28:30]
works director to add another layer of technical expertise to my answer.
[2:28:38]
Thanks, Eric.
[2:28:39]
Yes, so essentially when we have a phase of development, whatever this size is,
[2:28:43]
that first phase, whether it's all of it, half of it, whatever it ultimately comes through.
[2:28:50]
City staff would look at that, I mean it's not just City staff here, we'll talk about fire suppression,
[2:28:55]
all of that, so all the utilities would be looked at from that perspective, is it going to meet the demand?
[2:29:00]
Not just for service, but also for fire flow.
[2:29:04]
In case of emergency, even if something else doesn't build out,
[2:29:07]
so it's really subjective to what that their initial phase looks like,
[2:29:10]
and it would be sized up appropriately.
[2:29:13]
Mains, all of that would be in place to at least serve that.
[2:29:16]
I wouldn't expect a developer to not want to dig up a pipeline and
[2:29:20]
upsized it in the future so you'd likely go in with the larger size
[2:29:24]
that's necessary up front.
[2:29:26]
But again, it's really subjective to what that initial phase would
[2:29:29]
really look like before we can make an determination of what
[2:29:32]
the needs to be in place.
[2:29:34]
One little clarification with that.
[2:29:36]
So if you're in remediation phase, how do you get water supply for dust suppression?
[2:29:43]
That would, I mean there's multiple ways, you could get a lot of times you would get a
[2:29:48]
hydrant meter to perfect construction water, you could have an temporary connection to an
[2:29:52]
existing service, yes, that would still need to be done, and it would have to be by a suffered
[2:29:57]
means.
[2:29:58]
Okay, thank you.
[2:30:00]
I have Karen Cunningham, and afterwards I have Frank Cohen.
[2:30:07]
Good evening, Madam Mayor, City Council. First of all, I was one of the authors of measure J.J. as you know, but the people sitting behind us might not. So I have some real concerns that we stick to what we voted for.
[2:30:25]
It was a very horrible time in Brisbane, it was a horrible time for the City Council, it was a horrible time for the people.
[2:30:35]
In Brisbane, we felt we were torn in a thousand different directions.
[2:30:38]
But ultimately, Measure J.J. came through.
[2:30:41]
I have 25 questions.
[2:30:43]
Just kidding, just five.
[2:30:47]
Stephanie, you're happy, right?
[2:30:48]
You appreciate that good things.
[2:30:50]
Okay, so I'm going to quote Measure J.J.
[2:30:55]
And my questions, such so you can know that the things I say here are actually in measure
[2:31:01]
JJ and you can go and check it.
[2:31:03]
So one of the things before I study is, you know, there was financial responsibility for
[2:31:08]
this entire project, who should be responsible for implementing and maintaining the approved
[2:31:13]
landfill closure and remediation plans.
[2:31:16]
We still do not have any testing that was ever done for Mercury.
[2:31:23]
And we know that there was hospital waste out of the baylands,
[2:31:29]
and what was that hospital waste?
[2:31:31]
Mercury is the momentous correct, and we haven't done any testing for that.
[2:31:34]
So that's just off measure JJ, and then I will continue.
[2:31:38]
So who should be responsible for implementing and maintaining the approved landfill closure and remediation plans?
[2:31:44]
Measure JJ says.
[2:31:46]
A clear schedule for landfill closure and site remediation to be completed and enforcement mechanisms such as fines, permit, suspension, etc. if the schedule is not maintained.
[2:31:59]
The developer must also provide assurances, guaranteeing on-going remediation performance and site management.
[2:32:06]
The current proposal does not reflect this. And I could go on but I'm going to run out of time so I want.
[2:32:12]
Excuse me. I also had questions about the water supply, obviously, that is super important.
[2:32:19]
I think it's been clarified, but Measure JJ says, a reliable water supply approved by the
[2:32:24]
city of Brisbane to support the proposed users within the Baylands shall be secured prior
[2:32:30]
to site development. I had much more to say about that, but I'll leave that as well. And who
[2:32:36]
should ultimately pay for public infrastructure and services that are acquired? Measure JJ
[2:32:41]
says each development phase must include all necessary transportation improvements, utilities,
[2:32:48]
infrastructure and amenities as determined by the city and be entirely funded by the developer.
[2:32:54]
The project must be a revenue positive in the city at all times with project generator revenue
[2:32:59]
exceeding city costs during every phase of the full build out. The current proposal does not reflect
[2:33:07]
this and I've got more information I'll come back to you with at a later time.
[2:33:15]
Questions from Mr. J. J. how to produce the positive revenue.
[2:33:21]
Mr. J. J. says the Baylands Development Show will be a revenue positive to the city on
[2:33:25]
an annual basis where all city costs, for example, annual operating costs, maintenance and replacement
[2:33:31]
of equipment, facilities, infrastructure, cultural resources and habitat production and management
[2:33:36]
etc., are exceeded by the project-generated revenues to the city.
[2:33:41]
Example, the city's general fund, enterprise fund, special funds, etc.
[2:33:45]
During all phases of development upon final buildout, that is not reflected in the current
[2:33:52]
proposal.
[2:33:55]
There's also questions about the annual development plan.
[2:33:59]
Each development phase must include all necessary transportation improvements, utilities,
[2:34:04]
infrastructure and amenities as determined by the city and be entirely funded by the developer.
[2:34:11]
We have not mentioned anywhere who is responsible and I see in some of the things that
[2:34:16]
we've got in the current proposal that some of this stuff might get back to the home
[2:34:20]
and is out on the bail-ins.
[2:34:22]
That was not what we proposed.
[2:34:24]
So there's my questions and a couple of comments.
[2:34:28]
I can provide you, we've actually the five pages of information that I'm citing here.
[2:34:33]
Thanks for listening.
[2:34:35]
So Ms. Cunningham, do you want these questions to address?
[2:34:38]
I don't think they can be addressed right now.
[2:34:40]
I mean, I'm looking at the current proposal.
[2:34:42]
That's not what's in the current proposal.
[2:34:44]
That's why I'm asking the questions.
[2:34:46]
So I think those questions, the contemplation by you and by staff,
[2:34:51]
and not just some perfunctory answer right now in the dice.
[2:34:54]
Okay.
[2:34:55]
All right. Thank you.
[2:34:58]
Frank Cohen, and after Frank, we will have Emmett Cunningham.
[2:35:06]
Hi everyone. I'm Ed, I'm a renter at 284 Mendocino Street, just up the alleyway from here.
[2:35:14]
Been here for three years and I absolutely love it. One of the fun things is to drive on Lagoon Road.
[2:35:22]
It's been a repaved repeatedly, yet today it has substantial dips and rises because the underlying landfill continues to settle.
[2:35:30]
The EIR predicts as much as 30 inches of settlement in the former landfill and 38 inches in the former rail yard, potentially occurring over decades.
[2:35:43]
What specifically will be done differently underneath the new Bayland streets that will prevent them from becoming another lagoon road?
[2:35:51]
And who bears the cost of repairing those streets and underground utilities 10, 20 or 30 years after construction?
[2:35:57]
I do have a second issue to raise, so the Brisbane's public arts ordinance requires
[2:36:07]
qualifying private development to contribute 1% towards public art.
[2:36:13]
Earlier Bayland's drafts reduced that to 1.5%.
[2:36:19]
I think that the staff deleted that half percent language in the 2026 specific plan, but
[2:36:25]
I don't see an explicit 1% requirement replacing it.
[2:36:29]
Can staff confirm on the record that Bayland's development
[2:36:33]
will be subject to a full 1% requirement
[2:36:36]
under chapter 15.85 with no exemption, reduction, credit,
[2:36:41]
or alternative calculation created by the specific plan
[2:36:45]
or development agreement?
[2:36:47]
That's my question.
[2:36:49]
And if the intent is the full 1%, why not just state 1%
[2:36:54]
explicitly in the specific plan.
[2:36:57]
Would you like those questions answered?
[2:36:59]
Sure.
[2:36:59]
All right.
[2:37:00]
So the first question.
[2:37:02]
It's dealing with the subsidence 30 to 38 inches.
[2:37:07]
Staff, you want to take that on?
[2:37:10]
That's very helpful for paying for those fixes.
[2:37:12]
OK.
[2:37:12]
So we're talking about you mentioned underground infrastructure
[2:37:15]
and also what would be different from the current roadways
[2:37:21]
that we've seen some settling,
[2:37:29]
they're working on it.
[2:37:39]
If we don't have the full answer, we can always bring that back. Sometimes things are not as simple as they seem.
[2:37:47]
So, of course, we rather have a good response. I see our director of public works is going to.
[2:37:55]
I mean, as far as the development, the infrastructure transportation that work, all of that would be part of the development itself to do long term maintenance responsibilities would be subject to
[2:38:10]
ownership and maintenance responsibilities that have to be fully developed. It could be city oversight could be through another financial means, but that hasn't been determined yet.
[2:38:22]
Okay, and your second question was about the 1% towards public arts staff, could you address
[2:38:29]
that, please?
[2:38:31]
Sure.
[2:38:33]
So staffs recommended specific plan that you're considering in chapter 4, section 410, requires
[2:38:39]
a bail-ins public art program to be prepared and implemented that is consistent with the
[2:38:48]
85 of the municipal code,
[2:38:53]
heard that the resident is asking could, you know, we just explicitly
[2:38:56]
state with that. The current requirements of that program are certainly you could opt to
[2:39:03]
make that change when you ultimately take action on a specific plan. I would just mention that,
[2:39:09]
you know, referencing the ordinance itself is kind of an evergreen best practice because if the
[2:39:15]
things up being changed in the future then you know it's not going to necessarily conflict
[2:39:19]
with the specific plan. But anyway it is a requirement in chapter 4 that it comply with
[2:39:25]
the program which does presently have that requirement.
[2:39:29]
So I would urge you to state the one first step.
[2:39:33]
All right. Thank you.
[2:39:36]
Thank you.
[2:39:36]
Emmett, Cunningham. And after Emmett we have Wilbur M.
[2:39:44]
Hello. First of all thanks to everybody who's been working on this. It is a very long list.
[2:39:48]
I want to begin to try to say thank you to everybody.
[2:39:52]
Councilman curves.
[2:39:53]
I love your question about penalties.
[2:39:55]
Without penalties for not actually meeting requirements,
[2:39:57]
the proposal turns into a gentleman's agreement.
[2:40:01]
And thus, how do we enforce it?
[2:40:03]
How do we do that for solar?
[2:40:04]
How do we do that for financial?
[2:40:06]
How do we do that for water?
[2:40:07]
Are there any penalties on these things?
[2:40:09]
I think it's a great question.
[2:40:10]
I think we just need to take a one step further.
[2:40:14]
Next one.
[2:40:15]
How long does this do these billing permits last?
[2:40:17]
And I'm concerned about us waiting for 10 years after we actually give somebody a building permit to do something and that we actually get this thing moving instead of just hanging on.
[2:40:29]
I didn't see any kind of language in there that actually pushes them to meet a schedule that is set in stone already.
[2:40:36]
are a good schedule. People can expect. It says that they need to meet a schedule, but it
[2:40:43]
doesn't say what that schedule is once you actually have everything written down. I'm sort
[2:40:48]
of trying to say let's get this moving and make sure they hold it on schedule. We've been
[2:40:54]
burned by this kind of stuff in town before, or somebody happens to have an open-ended permit
[2:40:58]
for a very, very long time, and it didn't expire, so I didn't have an expiration date,
[2:41:03]
so they continued not doing something for years.
[2:41:08]
Let the next one, what happens if the actual water usage
[2:41:11]
exceeds the amount guaranteed by cow water
[2:41:14]
or whoever provides the water guarantee?
[2:41:18]
It's a simple question.
[2:41:20]
We're assuming that we are perfect in making our estimates
[2:41:23]
of the amount of water that's gonna get used.
[2:41:25]
I don't know about you,
[2:41:26]
but when planning these kinds of things,
[2:41:28]
I've been wrong, work, times, and I've been right.
[2:41:31]
So maybe you guys are way better than I am,
[2:41:33]
or maybe they are.
[2:41:36]
Anyway,
[2:41:38]
lastly,
[2:41:42]
quoting, each development phase must include necessary transportation improvements,
[2:41:46]
utilities, infrastructure and amenities as determined by the city, and entirely funded by
[2:41:50]
the developer.
[2:41:52]
It brings up a very simple question that sort of conflicts with what I was hearing earlier.
[2:41:56]
Does this mean no CFDs or mellow routes?
[2:41:59]
CFDs are passed on the residents and business owners, is this contrary to the phrase entirely funded by the developer?
[2:42:07]
Seems like they are.
[2:42:10]
I mean, ultimately, Meloruz is just an extra $600 a month to the property owner, or whatever the number is, depending on the size scenario, it's probably going to be in that area.
[2:42:20]
So all of a sudden those home prices are going to go up
[2:42:25]
in terms of, you know, the price of the homes
[2:42:27]
can be stable, but the actual cost of owning that home
[2:42:31]
is going to be much higher.
[2:42:34]
That's not sustainable, that's not sort of a surprise.
[2:42:39]
I'm going to push you guys to clarify that CFDs
[2:42:43]
are not passed on to the residents,
[2:42:45]
like it was actually commented on earlier.
[2:42:48]
If you want to answer our can answer those questions,
[2:42:50]
I'd be delighted.
[2:42:53]
So your first question.
[2:42:58]
Penalties.
[2:42:59]
Yes.
[2:43:00]
For permits.
[2:43:01]
How, first of all, how long do building permits last?
[2:43:06]
And I would tea that one up by saying,
[2:43:08]
I know there are extensions granted.
[2:43:10]
Different cities have different ideas on that.
[2:43:13]
Could we address that first?
[2:43:17]
Sure.
[2:43:18]
So a building permit once issued as a term of one year.
[2:43:21]
Any time there's an inspection, that's automatically extended by a year.
[2:43:29]
There are, well, so yeah, I'll keep my answer there.
[2:43:33]
Is that helped?
[2:43:35]
That does help.
[2:43:36]
I just want to make sure that we're making,
[2:43:38]
we have infrastructure in place to make sure things get moving forward at a consistent pace
[2:43:42]
and that they take those permits out in a timely manner.
[2:43:45]
Penalties.
[2:43:47]
Penalties.
[2:43:48]
I didn't see any talk about penalties in there about not meeting the requirements.
[2:43:51]
So, basically, if they don't be through requirements, oh, well, whatever.
[2:43:57]
When you say requirements, could you clarify what your requirements are?
[2:44:02]
If the solar, if the solar, if there's a requirement for 100% of the amount of energy
[2:44:06]
used in the bail-in-speed up in solar, what if the amount of energy used is an excessive
[2:44:10]
that, what are the penalties?
[2:44:13]
What are the penalties of not being financially even like the city is not getting as much
[2:44:18]
is they expected. What are the penalties for water if we don't happen to have enough water
[2:44:25]
secured and we actually go over our water usage. If there's no penalty involved,
[2:44:31]
oh well, so we made it a guess and we were wrong and too bad. So sad, tough to be you.
[2:44:38]
So you're looking for what are the consequences of not meeting the elements? I think that's a legal
[2:44:44]
question. Perhaps. Yeah, a lot of these are topics that are going to be discussed at future meetings.
[2:44:50]
We have specific meetings set aside to talk about the fiscal positivity infrastructure.
[2:44:58]
So there will be a lot more detail on those.
[2:45:00]
provisions at our future meetings.
[2:45:04]
We think that the plan is set up to be prospective so that, for example,
[2:45:15]
buildings are required to have integrated and distributed onsite energy generation. They're required to meet certain energy
[2:45:23]
requirements, standards, those are things that can be enforced very clearly up front,
[2:45:31]
there are requirements to incorporate in the development, the penalty for not
[2:45:35]
complaint with those would be that you don't get your permit issued and that section of
[2:45:39]
the development doesn't go forward. So those types of mechanisms are already structured in
[2:45:46]
the plan. As we mentioned, in response to counsel questions at the beginning of the meeting,
[2:45:52]
The plan doesn't currently have a penalty-construct baked in for what happens if a future
[2:46:01]
homeowner uses more energy than we're currently projecting or we're going to penalize
[2:46:06]
that person.
[2:46:07]
There's not a great, you know, mechanism to do that, but that's not currently recommended
[2:46:13]
as part of the plan, but that's something that we can discuss and further detail with
[2:46:21]
And the final question was about Meloruz districts, if staff for everyone here can explain what that means and see if these.
[2:46:32]
And actually I understand what Meloruz are.
[2:46:34]
What I don't understand is the fact that we would be taking out Meloruz, which passes on the cost to the homeowner or the business people,
[2:46:43]
when in fact the text on JJ says, and be entirely funded by the developer.
[2:46:47]
I just want to make sure everyone understands what we're talking about since you brought it up.
[2:46:55]
Eric, you want to try to feel that?
[2:46:57]
Or Julia?
[2:47:01]
Yeah, I mean, so a CFD is, yeah, it's a way to create revenue to fund infrastructure by borrowing
[2:47:13]
against future assessed property values, and as the speaker said, there are assessments
[2:47:21]
placed against developed property that pay the future owners will pay in order to
[2:47:30]
service the debt that was incurred to put the infrastructure in as an initial matter.
[2:47:39]
I guess it's a little philosophical about whether a developer is paying for something, or a future homeowner is paying for something, money is sort of fungible if they weren't passing it through via a mellow roost, then the sales price potentially would have to be higher to make up for the cost of providing that infrastructure.
[2:48:05]
So I guess it starts to get a little abstract about exactly what that means.
[2:48:11]
I think one way to look at the provisions of Measure J. J.
[2:48:16]
And the concept that we're trying to stick to is that it's not an increasing new costs
[2:48:26]
that drain the public fist or that the city is being out of it.
[2:48:33]
it's general fund, or that the taxpayers as a whole are exposed to, so it's a little bit
[2:48:40]
of a different structure and more targeted to raising revenue to pay for the infrastructure
[2:48:45]
specific in this development area.
[2:48:48]
I think part of the question also was that, if I got this right, is that Measure JJ was
[2:48:54]
requiring that these transportation, utilities, infrastructure be developed or funded, and I believe
[2:49:04]
Mr. Cunningham was pointing out that a mella roost is not developer funded. It's homeowner funded is that is that correct what you're asking?
[2:49:12]
Okay,
[2:49:15]
yeah, I mean that I don't know what else that's the question I think I just answered
[2:49:19]
What you said was basically that the money is fungible and the way you the somebody's going to be paying one way the other and
[2:49:26]
It really basically says that we're bypassing that portion of the
[2:49:30]
measure J.J., which says, and be entirely funded by the developer, which would we passed
[2:49:36]
on to the homeowners or business people, but the mechanism by which it's passed on is up
[2:49:42]
for debate.
[2:49:43]
It's what you're saying.
[2:49:47]
I don't know, Mayor, if there's a specific question, we can ask, but I don't know that you
[2:49:51]
want us.
[2:49:53]
I think I have something that I think might cut through is this legal's interpretation that
[2:50:01]
JJ saying that it's entirely funded by the developer, the intent between entirely funded
[2:50:08]
by the developer is such that the cost burden is doesn't fall on Brisbane as a city or residents
[2:50:19]
that don't live there, current residents, and that entirely funded by the developer could
[2:50:26]
include a mellow ruse because those costs don't fall on the city budget, it's not on the city
[2:50:35]
budget, it's not on taxpayers that don't live who haven't chosen to live at the development
[2:50:41]
is that what I'm because I think we're having a difference of interpretation, so I'm trying
[2:50:46]
to clarify.
[2:50:47]
Yeah, I'm just trying to figure out if that's legal's interpretation of what entirely funded
[2:50:53]
the developer is as opposed to maybe what Mr. Connie Hems' interpretation means.
[2:51:00]
Well, yeah, I mean, it's up to Council to decide what the interpretation is. I think what you just said is a perfectly reasonable interpretation.
[2:51:08]
There are many possible interpretations of this and the point of this is what is the interpretation and what is it's not clear.
[2:51:17]
I'll step back.
[2:51:17]
City attorney. Yeah, we should get back and forth. Okay. Correct. Okay. Thank you.
[2:51:25]
All right. Next we have Wilbur M. And after Wilbur M, we will have Laverissa.
[2:51:34]
Wilbur, are you here?
[2:51:36]
This is the online. Oh, I'm sorry. That's why I don't see you. Go ahead Wilbur.
[2:51:51]
Good evening, Mayor Mackin and Brisbane City Council members and staff, can you hear me clearly?
[2:51:59]
I hope that's the only question I'll be asking.
[2:52:01]
Thank you for the opportunity for a public comment.
[2:52:04]
My wife Anna and I are both small business owners and San Francisco's
[2:52:07]
go to visitation Valley neighborhood right across the Brisbane City line. I was born in Hawaii,
[2:52:13]
my wife as Pacific Islander also, and we represent the Pacific Islander Cultural District
[2:52:17]
designation within our Leavens Merchants Circle, which also includes Business Owners
[2:52:23]
Cannon Kelly McCord of Mission Blue Cafe, and over 2,000 small business owners along the corridor.
[2:52:30]
That while tonight's meeting focus is the Brisbane Baylands, the broader baylands development includes the future
[2:52:36]
Leeland Main Street economic quarter in this valley of southeast San Francisco. Leeland and several other streets will be extended from this valley into the bayland.
[2:52:45]
So we have a shared and vested interest in this project, especially in light of last week's candlestick groundbreaking for additional San Francisco housing.
[2:52:53]
So on behalf of the Leland merchants, we are urging and excited for you to vote tonight
[2:53:00]
to move forward with Bailin's final environmental impact report and specific plan.
[2:53:04]
Our hope is that approval and Brisbane can really help unlock momentum for the San Francisco
[2:53:09]
side of the project as well.
[2:53:11]
There will be, you know, obviously many new residents, workers, visitors, event participants
[2:53:17]
and attendees in both Brisbane and San Francisco, which will create more demand for local
[2:53:22]
restaurants, cafes, shop, small businesses and other neighborhood serving businesses.
[2:53:28]
And so as the Bayland develops, it can really provide space for additional small businesses
[2:53:33]
to open expand, to serve the growing community, close to transit, parks, workplaces, housing.
[2:53:41]
And so this project has significant regional impact for the southeast of San Francisco small business
[2:53:46]
committee and we ask that you think of us as you make your recommendations. Thank you so much for your time. Thank you.
[2:53:53]
Larissa.
[2:53:55]
Larissa online as well.
[2:54:01]
Okay.
[2:54:01]
Larissa.
[2:54:03]
Can you hear me? Yes, we can hear you go ahead.
[2:54:07]
Okay. Thank you.
[2:54:07]
Good evening, Mayor Mack and Briss Bay and City Council members. My name is Larissa Open.
[2:54:11]
I'm the Marketing Communications Operations Manager for the San Mateo County Economic Development Association.
[2:54:18]
also known as Amcita. For more than 70 years,
[2:54:22]
Amcita has worked to support a strong economy and thriving communities throughout
[2:54:26]
San Mateo County. I'm here to speak and support the Bayland's project because we
[2:54:31]
believe in the transformative opportunity it represents for Brisbane,
[2:54:36]
San Mateo County, and the broader region. The Bayland's will deliver much-needed housing
[2:54:41]
create thousands of jobs and provide new community amenities. All near high-quality
[2:54:47]
public transit and powered by renewable energy. We recognize that analyzing a project of
[2:54:53]
the size and extraordinary effort and we commend the city of Brisbane for their commitment
[2:54:58]
to public engagement and careful planning. After more than 20 years of public engagement,
[2:55:04]
there are analysis and environmental review. We would very much appreciate the city moving forward
[2:55:09]
with this long-awaited project. We respectfully encourage the Brisbane City Council to recommend
[2:55:16]
certification of the final EIR and adoption of the economically viable specific plans of
[2:55:23]
these benefits can finally become a reality.
[2:55:25]
Thank you.
[2:55:27]
Thank you very much.
[2:55:29]
We've reached the end of our slips.
[2:55:31]
I'd like to ask staff would you like a five-minute break?
[2:55:35]
Let's take a five-minute break please let's not turn it into 15.
[2:55:39]
Five minutes stretch your legs will be back for the second topic.
[2:55:43]
Thank you.
[3:07:48]
Thank you everyone. We're at a three-hour mark, and that being said, we would need a motion from the council to extend the meeting. My suggestion is we try for an hour and see where it lands. If someone would like to make that motion, please.
[3:08:06]
I'll make that motion to extend the meeting until 9.30.
[3:08:09]
Second all in favor. Hi. Hi. Okay, that carries. We're moving on to the second section, which is the specific plans to sustainability measures.
[3:08:24]
Madam Mayor, if you wouldn't mind, there were some comments that were made at the last section.
[3:08:40]
Okay.
[3:08:41]
in the introduction you commented on the road diet and how this was something that the planning
[3:08:46]
commission did not support implementation of and so I'm just wondering did I hear that staff
[3:08:53]
is supportive of that recommendation or you were just noting that they made that recommendation.
[3:09:01]
Staff's recommendation as we summarized earlier was adoption of the mobility plan
[3:09:06]
and which currently includes the Rhode Diet provision,
[3:09:11]
but correct the planning commission recommended,
[3:09:14]
elimination of that component of the availability plan.
[3:09:17]
Okay, thank you for your microphone.
[3:09:19]
And then one thing that we've heard from public scale
[3:09:22]
for many years has been about the Levison property.
[3:09:26]
So I think it's important to just get some more information
[3:09:29]
about the likelihood that his suggestion could occur.
[3:09:33]
So could you do me a favor and let me know
[3:09:35]
how many acres the Levison property is?
[3:09:40]
Sure, that property is just under 22 acres.
[3:09:45]
Okay, and then for the properties
[3:09:47]
slated for development on the balans for housing,
[3:09:52]
how many acres would just the housing be?
[3:09:56]
A little over 50.
[3:09:58]
Okay, so by that assessment,
[3:10:00]
if there was a transfer,
[3:10:04]
just even no density transfer just they even transfer from 50 acres to 22 acres we would
[3:10:12]
see the density on the levson property have to double more than double in order to accommodate
[3:10:20]
1,800 to 2,200 units.
[3:10:24]
I think it's fair to say that and I would also just note that the levson properties included
[3:10:29]
in the Habitat Conservation Plan for the San Bruno Mountain area, which would also have a
[3:10:37]
tad on it that would reduce the developable area as also encumbered by some easements that
[3:10:42]
further reduce the developable area. So, total size 22 acres but developable size probably
[3:10:48]
much less than that. So we're talking like skyscrapers to fit if we were trying to fit all
[3:10:55]
housing there and it's to take a higher density, much higher density, secondly, if that was
[3:11:02]
something that we explored and let's say we acted upon that, do you presume that it would
[3:11:08]
be likely that the state would then say, oh, now there's all this land, there's continues to be
[3:11:15]
land available on the baylands, so now with your new housing needs allocation, you seem to still have
[3:11:24]
all of this developable land at your fingertips.
[3:11:28]
So we could conceivably give you another number of 1500 units
[3:11:32]
or 1800 units because you clearly still have some place
[3:11:36]
for those units to go.
[3:11:39]
It's a good question.
[3:11:40]
I'm not going to pretend to know all of the intricacies
[3:11:43]
that go into the arena.
[3:11:46]
I would imagine that any site in the Bay Area,
[3:11:49]
that's adjacent to a transit station,
[3:11:51]
which the Baylands does have a Cal train station.
[3:11:55]
would probably be identified in future regional housing
[3:11:59]
applications as a priority development site of some kind.
[3:12:06]
So, I can't predict the future, but I would point out that it probably
[3:12:10]
remain a site that would lead to assumptions of development potential in that process.
[3:12:17]
Okay. And then one other thing, Karen cutting him brought up testing for mercury. And I just, I know this is really not covered in tonight, but do we know if we've tested for mercury out there?
[3:12:35]
We can look at the, we can bring that back under remediation.
[3:12:39]
Well, I was going to say yes, we are scheduled to discuss remediation out of future remaining.
[3:12:43]
In fact, that meeting would be October 6, so we can certainly address it then, but we
[3:12:49]
can look at the wraps and see if we can come up with an answer before the Internet's meeting
[3:12:55]
if not then certainly we can address it at that future meeting.
[3:12:59]
Okay, great.
[3:12:59]
That's it for me, Madam Mayor.
[3:13:02]
So, topic two, moving on is sustainability measures of the specific plan, and I would note that
[3:13:10]
In the staff report, we have energy use and sustainability together, although I see energy
[3:13:16]
is now under topic 3.
[3:13:21]
So we've made a bit of a change in how we're approaching this.
[3:13:25]
I just want to be sure.
[3:13:31]
Because topic 3's air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and energy impacts,
[3:13:39]
and I have
[3:13:39]
topic 2 as sustainability measures of the specific plant. Correct? So I can clarify through
[3:13:48]
the mayor, if please. So energy and atrocities of a part of the sustainability discussion.
[3:13:58]
So they can be addressed during this section. Okay, so the last section is when the technical aspects.
[3:14:05]
So the energy impact that Mr. Schuster had reviewed in his presentation.
[3:14:12]
Would you, if you had the energy impacts, would be under topic two or three?
[3:14:18]
I guess I should have said more clearly, it's a bit more nuanced.
[3:14:21]
So the provision in the measure jj for energy neutrality can be addressed with this topic two.
[3:14:30]
And then topic three is reserved for questions or comments on the technical aspects of the EAR which evaluated
[3:14:36]
Equality impacts,
[3:14:39]
greenhouse gas emission impacts and energy impacts.
[3:14:45]
So, topic two sustainability measures that also includes energy neutrality.
[3:14:51]
That being said, if anyone filled out a slip and you were going to talk about energy neutrality,
[3:14:57]
You might want to fill out another slope.
[3:15:00]
Or this section. That being said, we start with council questions as the last time, and I have council member
[3:15:08]
Kern. You have questions you'd like to start with.
[3:15:14]
You know, Mayor Mack, and I think it's better that we start with our subcommittee members and have them
[3:15:19]
go through their questions first, as they have been had long into this material. And I think it will answer some of the other
[3:15:27]
on some other questions. Okay. If you're suggesting I do rotate all the council members so we
[3:15:32]
don't start with the same people. I know. I know. Are you suggesting we start with the-
[3:15:36]
I think we should start with the subcommittee. Is the subcommittee okay with that? Yeah. Okay.
[3:15:43]
All right. Council member Davis? Sure. Mayor Proofem Davis or should say. Oh no problem.
[3:15:50]
So I know there's was a lot of discussion about energy neutrality, the planning commission,
[3:15:56]
And we just got to do it again.
[3:15:59]
So I know you probably answer a lot of these questions.
[3:16:01]
Some of them are addressing the staff report.
[3:16:04]
We should still go through the song and dance.
[3:16:06]
Because I think it's really important.
[3:16:10]
So in volume 4 of the EIR 4.11-1 volume 2.
[3:16:18]
Oh, no, sorry, it's volume 2.
[3:16:20]
The EIR4, Chapter 4, 11-1.
[3:16:26]
There's the definition of energy neutral.
[3:16:28]
It states energy neutral means generating sufficient energy on site to meet the specific plans demand for energy on the annual basis for buildings.
[3:16:37]
Outdoor lighting, streetlights, traffic signals, landscape irrigation, non-commercial, on-site electrical.
[3:16:43]
electric vehicle charging whose energy is metered as part of onsite buildings and all onsite
[3:16:51]
infrastructure such as operation of the onsite water storage tank and the water recycling
[3:16:56]
facility. Would you agree that this is the correct definition of energy neutral?
[3:17:10]
Well, I think that the EIR used a especially conservative definition because it was
[3:17:18]
analyzing through a very particular lens looking for potential physical impacts related to
[3:17:26]
the way the project uses energy. When you look at the language of Measure J.J., where it
[3:17:33]
just uses the term energy neutrality without it being defined and then read that in the context
[3:17:40]
of the sustainability framework. A lot of the sustainability framework talks about energy
[3:17:46]
use from buildings a little bit more narrowly, and so there's a broader interpretation
[3:17:57]
that the council could look to you should it want to when interpreting and applying
[3:18:02]
Mr. JJ.
[3:18:05]
Okay, so that brings me to the Baylands and that on-site energy consumption analysis.
[3:18:12]
this is a table in appendix one. Any energy resources technical report. It's on 4.11-7.
[3:18:27]
So it's it's in the appendix of volume two. So in looking at the numbers, it says a full
[3:18:34]
specific plan build out the estimated on site electricity consumption is 172,882 megawatt hours per year and then in the next column of the table it says the estimated on site electricity generation is ninety two thousand four hundred and forty five megawatt hours per year.
[3:18:59]
And the percentage of bail-and-selectrical demand met by on-site generation is classified
[3:19:07]
as 53.5 percent.
[3:19:12]
So then looks like based on that, you know, 47% of the project's energy would need to be supplemented
[3:19:20]
the grid and I just want to first confirm if that 92,000 figure is that encompassing all of the
[3:19:32]
on-site generation or just a solar farm because the applicant did talk about, you know,
[3:19:39]
shade structures with solar and rooftops with solar and so I'm just wondering if all of that is
[3:19:46]
business in the 92,000.
[3:19:52]
I'm seeing nods.
[3:19:53]
Yeah, sorry. The 92 encompasses the distributed solar and the solar field.
[3:19:58]
Okay, so I just under making sure I'm understanding like the report correctly.
[3:20:05]
47% of the projects energy needs would need to be supplemented by the grid.
[3:20:11]
Is that correct?
[3:20:12]
In the EIR's definition of energy neutrality, which you did summarise, including those,
[3:20:17]
uses EV charging water reclamation and so forth, looking purely at on-site consumption
[3:20:26]
over the course of a calendar year, it build out compared to on-site generation over the
[3:20:32]
same time period, assuming there are some caveats about which code we're complying with in the
[3:20:47]
that plans requirements for the buildings, however, yes, based on, given those assumptions
[3:20:54]
done in the EIRs modeling, 53% would be generated on site.
[3:21:00]
So then on page 17 of the Sustainability Framework, it states, the project will be designed
[3:21:05]
to produce its entire annual energy needs, meaning that it will likely produce more than
[3:21:11]
it uses in the summer, feeding power to the nearby community.
[3:21:15]
Load separate from these categories, such as industrial process loads, will also be met with onsite renewable energy sources if they are electric.
[3:21:27]
To staff feel that a site that generates 53.5% of its estimated electrical needs on site is consistent with the sustainability framework.
[3:21:38]
And in turn, consistent with measure JJ, which states under G, the required specific plan for the balance shall include a sustainability program for new development and consistent with the principles of the sustainability framework.
[3:21:53]
for the Brisbane Balean's final report accepted by the City Council on November 5, 2015.
[3:21:58]
Balean's development shall be designed so as to be energy neutral on ongoing basis.
[3:22:04]
So just to recap the question, does staff feel that a site that generates 53.5% of its estimated electrical needs on site is consistent with the state's sustainability framework and measure JJ.
[3:22:17]
Well, it's ultimately up to a council to make the determination of consistency, but I think that there are definitely paths to support that determination if you wanted to make it.
[3:22:30]
First, the figures that you were just talking about don't give any credit for onsite energy storage and the use of batteries, which can help decrease reliance on the grid.
[3:22:45]
in addition to when there's times of oversupply like in the summer the project could even
[3:22:53]
be feeding into the grid. Measure JJ does reference consistency with certain sections
[3:23:02]
of the sustainability framework, but the sustainability framework also talks about ways
[3:23:09]
to incorporate carbon neutrality throughout the project and throughout the way that the project
[3:23:15]
uses energy. It is, it gives a menu of options, including on-site production, including options
[3:23:27]
for off-site production for using clean energy purchased from the grid to meet the energy
[3:23:33]
demands. So there's not a single narrow path that is mandated.
[3:23:41]
Good. Thank you. So to talk about this sustainability framework, it allows offsite
[3:23:50]
renewable energy to fill a gap.
[3:23:55]
So, but it of course it identifies that as kind of being
[3:23:58]
of last preference. What is the required accounting standard for determining whether that
[3:24:04]
combination actually achieves energy neutrality, like, and are we going to, is there some kind of ongoing mechanism in which we're going to be tracking how much is being supplemented by the grid versus how much.
[3:24:20]
I mean, we have projections, but are we going to be tracking this on an ongoing basis?
[3:24:26]
So that was one of the recommendations from the Planning Commission, was to add in different
[3:24:34]
tracking mechanisms, there are some different sort of options and backend reporting that
[3:24:42]
are started to be explored in the staff report, though I think staff's ultimate recommendation
[3:24:47]
as the most effective way to ensure energy efficiency is prescriptive upfront standards about designing
[3:24:59]
the buildings to the highest applicable energy efficiency standards to having the, as much
[3:25:07]
on-site distributed production as is feasible and to supplement with renewable energy from the
[3:25:15]
as needed in those sorts of upfront requirements, or just, they're easier to administer.
[3:25:25]
They're easier for the city to quantify and understand the impact of that front, doing,
[3:25:35]
but yeah, there still could be some options for back-end tracking if that's the direction
[3:25:42]
the council wants to go.
[3:25:43]
So, okay, and, you know, looking at how, looking at Westlight and future residents that live at the Baylands, they made choose not to have 100% renewable energy that eco 100 option.
[3:26:09]
I think the opt-out rate is two and a half percent, I think, for Westlight in general. I don't know what it is. Is it all
[3:26:17]
I would say going forward that Westlight will be a hundred percent renewable at this time, that's goal, but within a couple years that will be a reality.
[3:26:29]
Based on contracts that are already in place, but the sites have to be constructed.
[3:26:36]
So if people opt out, it's such a small percentage that we don't think that that would tip the scales really much.
[3:26:44]
It's kind of what I'm trying to figure out.
[3:26:46]
It was being 90, 98% now on that slide.
[3:26:50]
Okay, good.
[3:26:57]
So
[3:27:04]
I think the rest of the stuff that the questions I have are really about consistency and I know that that's really for us to evaluate whether something is consistent.
[3:27:13]
And part of my questions are just kind of trying to gauge a staff's perspective and if there's something that maybe we're missing.
[3:27:25]
Is there some kind of tests that staff has undertaken as a pertain to the specific plan and how it addresses each of the 10 principles?
[3:27:36]
Or does the applicant have to demonstrate that substantive sustainability outcomes contemplated by the framework will be achieved?
[3:27:45]
Just like how much of this is really on us and how much of it is on them and the back end.
[3:27:54]
I think I'm trying to figure out, you know, I want to, it goes back to your previous comment about
[3:27:59]
you try to build as much in upfront and do we see there being kind of wiggle room in the specific plan as written
[3:28:11]
That maybe doesn't have a standard strong enough to accomplish consistency with the principles.
[3:28:25]
Things that are measurable and accountable versus just more desires.
[3:28:33]
Well,
[3:28:38]
I think staff's recommendation is that the plan is consistent with measure JJ, including
[3:28:45]
the way that it references and incorporates the sustainability framework, including those
[3:28:50]
principles.
[3:28:52]
Though if there are specific, either accountability measures or quantifiable standards that
[3:28:59]
counsel would like to direct staff to incorporate and we certainly can do that too.
[3:29:04]
Okay, those are all my questions on energy.
[3:29:10]
Okay, Tom, some member lands.
[3:29:13]
Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[3:29:18]
All right, I'm just going to repeat the same thing that Tom, some member heard.
[3:29:22]
Dave has said the required specific plan for the BLN,
[3:29:25]
shall include a sustainability program for new development,
[3:29:28]
consistent with the principles of the sustainability framework for the
[3:29:33]
of things, balans, balans development shall be designed as to be energy neutral on an ongoing
[3:29:40]
basis. So, my question for staff, is there an energy subsufficiency detailing how the development
[3:29:49]
over time will become energy neutral on an ongoing basis so that we have this information,
[3:29:55]
and we've come up with these numbers.
[3:29:57]
Is there some kind of study that was,
[3:30:00]
On to extrapolate that information.
[3:30:07]
Well, the EIO doesn't include the energy projections that were summarized.
[3:30:15]
So, how did we get to those projections?
[3:30:18]
That's what I mean. It'd be nice if there was a study that, you know, showed, hey, you build these homes to be energy self-sufficient.
[3:30:27]
maybe these bigger ones, they can only do so much and we've got the solar farm and yeah.
[3:30:33]
Sure, we have our technical experts here who can walk us through some of that methodology on how that work is done.
[3:30:40]
We do have a study though, that's my question, is there's like a document that we can go to?
[3:30:46]
Sure, I'll do my best to address that.
[3:30:48]
What we do have, which is the basis for the EIR's energy analysis as well as
[3:30:52]
Um, air quality and greenhouse gas pertinent energy use is a 2023 Thornton, a study energy study for the bail-ins, which was, I believe, commissioned by a BDI and the numbers that council member Davis cited come from that study, the amount of solar generation and onsite consumption for buildings, EV charging infrastructure and so forth comes from that study.
[3:31:17]
It was done compliant with 2022 Cal Green Code, which is now been superseded and will be superseded again very soon.
[3:31:27]
It does not contemplate or consider the lead and green point rate at standards of the sustainability plan.
[3:31:32]
It's some other provisions of the sustainability plan.
[3:31:34]
So from that extent it is outdated from energy and is conservative.
[3:31:38]
There hasn't been an update to that study since 2023 that also doesn't reflect your question about ongoing,
[3:31:45]
like ongoing research, right? As buildings are built and codes are updated and solar becomes
[3:31:51]
more efficient and so on and so forth. There is not currently a mechanism in place to do that.
[3:31:58]
Okay,
[3:32:01]
so that particular study, you said that it's in the EIR. Yeah, it's a reference in the EIR.
[3:32:07]
Okay, reference, but you can get the whole doc. Oh, yeah, it's in the, yeah, it's in the administrative record, put the EIR.
[3:32:12]
Okay, yeah, and then do we have a master infrastructure plan as it relates to energy generation?
[3:32:24]
You know, indicating like how the, you know, how the infrastructure will be built, how it would be
[3:32:30]
finance, you know, and when it would be constructed, like, there are time lying because, you know,
[3:32:37]
there's see, you have this development, phasing going on, how do you ensure that you're building
[3:32:44]
the infrastructure, I want to just, you know, is that all married up?
[3:32:50]
Well, the specific timing and phasing mechanisms are intended to be defined in the development
[3:33:00]
agreement, so as we continue to make progress on that, we'll be able to define those with a little
[3:33:05]
bit more precision.
[3:33:06]
Okay. All right. I have some questions coming out of the sustainability framework.
[3:33:15]
So let's see.
[3:33:20]
Okay. In regards to the solar farm. So Stephanie, if you would mind coming up, please,
[3:33:28]
I have a question in regards to that.
[3:33:33]
Yes, come to me. Yeah. So as far as the greater timeline,
[3:33:39]
When were you planning to build the solar farm?
[3:33:44]
In regards to in relation to the other development?
[3:33:49]
So currently, the solar farm is part of our phase two development.
[3:33:59]
Phase one will consist of moving all of the imported soil from the landfill site, from the east side to the west side.
[3:34:09]
to raise the site out of the hundred-year flood zone some extra height for
[3:34:17]
sea level rise and a five-foot clean cap. That process it will be a phase
[3:34:23]
development over time. Those amounts have to come down before we can put the
[3:34:29]
solar farm in. So the solar farm will be phased at a later probably with phased to
[3:34:35]
What we're contemplating right now. Okay, so you're saying that phase one doesn't have any
[3:34:41]
Buildings it's just moving dirt from one into the other. Well, that's your that's your that's your grading and you're early infrastructure
[3:34:47]
Yeah, okay, so it'll be yeah, I mean, so it'll be houses and okay, so okay
[3:34:53]
Someone does include houses. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yes, include commercial as well
[3:34:59]
Yes, God willing. Yes, that's the whole plan is there will be phasing of both the housing and the commercial
[3:35:05]
throughout the phase one.
[3:35:09]
There's some terms in this specific plan,
[3:35:12]
which maybe should agree on some terminology here,
[3:35:15]
but we can talk about phase one as the whole west side,
[3:35:19]
the rail yard site, and phase two,
[3:35:22]
the landfills.
[3:35:24]
Okay, I just wanted to just declare that you're not contemplating
[3:35:27]
building the solar farm until after some homes,
[3:35:32]
it had been built.
[3:35:32]
I guess maybe the entire west side has been built.
[3:35:34]
because we don't have the, yeah, we can't, we,
[3:35:37]
where the solar farm is currently contemplated
[3:35:39]
in a specific plan is where the soil mountains are.
[3:35:43]
So the soil mountains have to come down,
[3:35:46]
we can be moved to the west side,
[3:35:48]
and then once that land is down,
[3:35:50]
then the landfill cap can go in and the solar farm can go in.
[3:35:55]
God, yeah.
[3:35:56]
Okay, so since the homes and the commercial on the west side
[3:36:03]
won't receive any of the energy from the solar farm until later, are the homes that are being
[3:36:10]
built? Are they going to be energy self-sufficient? Well, they will all have, the plan has solar,
[3:36:18]
rooftop solar, and battery on every year. Yeah, I know that, but I'm like, you know, I was,
[3:36:27]
I was looking at this one project up in Davis, and granted it was smaller, it was only, I think,
[3:36:32]
1200 homes.
[3:36:34]
The sales significant size.
[3:36:37]
And you know, that site generated about 87% of its own energy needs, which is a lot higher than what was,
[3:36:45]
you know, contemplated in the EIR.
[3:36:50]
So, you know, obviously, if the homes are more energy sufficient, I mean, efficient,
[3:36:56]
And they are designed that way, right?
[3:36:59]
That's right.
[3:36:59]
Yeah.
[3:37:00]
You know, is that something that you have contemplated?
[3:37:06]
You know, having houses just be, you know, like, hey, you don't have to have a PG&E bill?
[3:37:11]
I mean, I think that would be a pretty good, you know,
[3:37:14]
selling point for homes if you didn't have a PG&E bill.
[3:37:18]
Just kind of sure if you had been thinking about that.
[3:37:21]
Yes, of course.
[3:37:23]
I'm not.
[3:37:24]
I'm
[3:37:27]
not convinced that we can, with...
[3:37:30]
Out the full solar farm, that each individual home or individual building is going to be self-sufficient.
[3:37:40]
And because the solar farm is coming at a later phase.
[3:37:45]
But yeah, maybe we get that out there to say, no, it's right.
[3:37:49]
So I'm curious, on the battery storage facility, right? The 30-minute a lot.
[3:37:56]
So, yeah, so when I was watching the planning commission meetings, you know, there was going to be this private, I guess 250 megallop and I saw on the staff report that it could be up to 500 megallot.
[3:38:09]
It's great, you know, if you're doing, you know, having battery storage, but I'm just kind of curious, you know, who, like who owns that, that 30 watt energy, you know,
[3:38:22]
make a lot energy, like it's generated on site and then during the day and it goes there like so who owns that and how is it?
[3:38:29]
Then you're talking about our local, so we have a one, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, that would be owned by the development.
[3:38:35]
It would be owned by the development, okay, and same thing with the solar farm owned by the development.
[3:38:40]
Yes, okay.
[3:38:41]
Could be, I mean, could be a private partnership, but right now it's contemplated that it would be, yeah.
[3:38:47]
And how would any of that energy be sold?
[3:38:52]
The energy is sold through a very complex contract with PG&E.
[3:38:57]
The larger utility scale battery that you mentioned is,
[3:39:01]
And that is actually through a contract with the state independent grid and PG&E.
[3:39:11]
So that's also a complicated and complex structure there.
[3:39:18]
All right.
[3:39:18]
So on page 16, it does talk about requiring buildings to maximize onsite solar generation.
[3:39:28]
And so I'm glad that, you know, you're contemplating that and, you know, you're going to work with staff.
[3:39:37]
You know, as Council Member Davis, you know, I said, you know, on page 17, it talks about the project will be designed to produce its entire annual energy needs.
[3:39:46]
Obviously, you know, that's a pretty tall order.
[3:39:51]
But, you know, having some kind of study that kind of shows, okay, this is how you can strive for it.
[3:39:58]
And then perhaps, as technology gets better, that we can pivot and continue to be less reliant
[3:40:08]
on the grid.
[3:40:09]
Even though we are taking in alternative energy, we're taking it 100% renewables.
[3:40:14]
That doesn't mean that you can be subjected to brownouts.
[3:40:17]
So, that is, you know, okay, so, okay, not, thank you, okay, let's see,
[3:40:33]
you know, just in the framework, it talks about other alternative energy sources, right, you a thermal, you know, using bio gas from potential water, I mean, yeah, water treatment facility, is that something that you and your team had, you know, thought about and
[3:40:50]
Perhaps. I believe councilmember if you read the Thornton and said he
[3:40:56]
Study the water balance study. No, that's the brown and cold while water balance stuff. Okay. The Thornton and said he is the energy
[3:41:04]
Okay, study. Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah, it's okay. So it does mention other all it looks at all
[3:41:10]
Yes, it looked at everything in the in the sustainability framework and makes an and makes an opinion on it
[3:41:16]
Yeah, it makes an opinion on it. Okay. Yeah, I apologize for not
[3:41:20]
Have you read all of those studies?
[3:41:22]
I'm sure.
[3:41:23]
I'm sure.
[3:41:23]
My bad.
[3:41:25]
But I will get on it tomorrow.
[3:41:27]
Yes.
[3:41:31]
Okay.
[3:41:36]
All right.
[3:41:36]
I have questions in the staff report.
[3:41:40]
If I would, if it's okay with the metomer, I'd like to go back to that after
[3:41:45]
other council members have had a chance to ask questions.
[3:41:49]
On this topic.
[3:41:50]
On this topic.
[3:41:51]
Yeah, or should I continue, or?
[3:41:54]
I want to make sure that I answered your question,
[3:41:58]
which was, you know, if the solar farm is not up
[3:42:02]
when the first homes or commercial development go in,
[3:42:05]
are we still considering that energy neutral?
[3:42:07]
I believe, and I don't want to put words in your mouth,
[3:42:10]
but I believe that was the question you were trying to ask,
[3:42:11]
and I think the answer is yes,
[3:42:14]
because of the construction of the buildings
[3:42:17]
because each building will have its own solar and battery, and also we will be requiring everyone to
[3:42:25]
participate in the Westlight 100% energy renewable. So yes, from from day one, I just want to
[3:42:31]
make it clear that even though the solar farm is enough, we still consider the first, we would consider,
[3:42:38]
hopefully you would consider the first development, energy, energy neutral.
[3:42:42]
Yeah, definitely taking it all in and that's why I'm asking the question so I can get an understanding
[3:42:48]
You know from you
[3:42:51]
You know, I was
[3:42:54]
Part of my preparation. I was reading the luminary and there was a great article, Katie. Thank you
[3:43:01]
And so
[3:43:03]
You know, just talking about the sustainability model. You don't from one planet living in that. Yeah, that commitment and
[3:43:10]
And yeah,
[3:43:15]
you know, you know, talking about, you know, demonstrating how principles
[3:43:21]
from a zero carbon energy to sustainable water can be successful, successfully put into
[3:43:28]
practice, the balance builds on these proven approaches, you know, it talks about how
[3:43:35]
the one planet living principles are science-based, right?
[3:43:38]
And so, when we were putting together the framework, there was one rule that we could not
[3:43:45]
break.
[3:43:46]
And that was to apply something that did not exist, right?
[3:43:50]
So we had to, everything that's in that framework, right, our best practices.
[3:43:55]
So there, you know, I know that there's, you know, some folks that say, oh, well, it's aspirational.
[3:44:00]
Also, it's, you know, maybe it's a wish list.
[3:44:04]
That's not the intent.
[3:44:05]
The intent was to try and achieve a standard
[3:44:10]
that's above just the basics.
[3:44:13]
And you're doing, you know, I think a good job of it.
[3:44:17]
I think, you know, part of my role as a council member
[3:44:21]
is to try and get you to push me a little bit more, right?
[3:44:25]
Because I think that it makes every, you know, I think that makes the overall development better.
[3:44:32]
And obviously, you know, as we've talked about,
[3:44:35]
measure JJ was passed by the voters, right? And the frameworks in measure JJ.
[3:44:40]
And thus, you know, things need to be consistent. And so, you know, my number one,
[3:44:46]
like, you know, called action, is to fulfill what people voted for.
[3:44:52]
So I'm just a, yeah, and I think in my opening comments, I've stated that with, with.
[3:45:00]
Thought we made the best effort, above and beyond the best effort to make sure that our specific plan was consistent with the measure JJ because it was a voter initiative.
[3:45:11]
And I think the staffs present the staff report tonight and their consistency table also, I think, shows that we're consistent, but happy to continue the dialogue.
[3:45:24]
Yeah, great happy to hear recommendations that you know, we have an already considered
[3:45:29]
Absolutely, I think we've considered everything
[3:45:34]
Okay, thank you Stephanie
[3:45:37]
All right, yeah, I have other questions. I'll come back later. I'm that mayor. Okay
[3:45:41]
Come some member O'Connell.
[3:45:46]
Thank you
[3:45:48]
You know, I'm I'm having a little bit of difficulty with the
[3:45:52]
Faising where we're doing
[3:45:57]
Did you want me to pause?
[3:46:01]
I thought I was getting a hand signal from you.
[3:46:05]
No, I guess not.
[3:46:08]
The guy who's looked, I'm sorry.
[3:46:12]
I have a little issue with the sustainability goals
[3:46:16]
when it comes to the solar generation
[3:46:20]
and that with the solar generation solar farm
[3:46:25]
that's slated for zone 2 phase 2
[3:46:32]
There's still not going to be meeting their on-site generation, even with that.
[3:46:38]
And so if we're looking at a 2030, 50-year buildup.
[3:46:46]
So if we're not going to get done with phase one for 10, 15, 20 years,
[3:46:53]
they're going to be so far in the whole on sustainability on generation on electric
[3:46:59]
if they're not planning to put that solar farm
[3:47:01]
until they cap the landfill, and so how is it that we can make sure
[3:47:12]
that they're going to be creating onsite generation beyond what
[3:47:22]
their initial needs are when homes may be able to come close to onsite
[3:47:32]
sustainable generation with their rooftop solar businesses very seldom can and so I don't
[3:47:40]
see how they're going to be meeting their sustainable sustainability goals within
[3:47:45]
measure JJ if that solar farmer's not done until the land fills closed and we have
[3:47:53]
no I know that's in a later section that we're going to be dealing with phasing and how we
[3:48:01]
come up with the financials on this and that's really where my major, major, major concerns
[3:48:09]
with this project are.
[3:48:13]
But I also have concerns about the sustainability of closing the landfill after homes
[3:48:22]
are on the other side. And what that's going to look like with digging out the, um,
[3:48:32]
um, and capping that landfill. And I don't know how that reflects in our sustainability
[3:48:37]
goals, as far as what that trucking is going to look like and how we offset that, the staff
[3:48:45]
and if any ideas of how we're offsetting that portion of the sustainability program,
[3:48:53]
I'm asking
[3:48:55]
to esoteric of question.
[3:49:21]
I guess we can spend a little bit of time thinking about how to provide a more thoughtful
[3:49:27]
response, but I guess what, what are, can you say a little bit more about the specific
[3:49:33]
concern and the information that you're looking for so we can target that response for you?
[3:49:40]
Again, I think it's more in the next section where we talk about greenhouse gas and mitigation
[3:49:46]
for air quality and things of that nature, how they're going to, you know, I know that those
[3:49:52]
are impacts that we cannot, that will be significant. But if we're doing this project in a phase
[3:49:59]
one and phase two, we're a lot of the earth moving and compaction is going to be happening after
[3:50:07]
there's residence there. It doesn't seem that that's a very sustainable or healthy goal,
[3:50:14]
And those impacts are going to be immeasurable to the residents that are going to be there.
[3:50:23]
I see, I understand thanks.
[3:50:25]
There's kind of the discussion of sustainability from an energy neutrality perspective, right?
[3:50:32]
And then there's sustainability from greenhouse gas emissions, air quality impacts.
[3:50:38]
Noise, noise, of course.
[3:50:40]
So that's all part of sustainability.
[3:50:41]
So apologies for not understanding the question. In the EIR, so we have the IAR evaluates our quality impacts to
[3:50:51]
It evaluates
[3:50:53]
Regional emissions like greenhouse gas, so just the amount of tons of pollution coming out of
[3:50:58]
construction trucks
[3:51:00]
Offer equipment and
[3:51:02]
Operational activities like vehicles and
[3:51:05]
stationary sources and so forth and then it also looks at exposure
[3:51:09]
of residents to toxic air contaminants from desol, mostly desol, combustion, and particular
[3:51:18]
matter, both fugitive and exhaust space.
[3:51:23]
So for the health risk impact, the exposure, like the human health effect of those emissions
[3:51:29]
from trucking from off-road construction equipment, those impacts are mitigated to a less
[3:51:34]
and significant level with a whole slew of mitigation measures.
[3:51:38]
So, tier 4, low-emitting, construction equipment,
[3:51:42]
cleaner, on-road trucks, meaning certain standards.
[3:51:44]
So all the soil hauling trucks have to be zero-mission
[3:51:47]
or very low-emission.
[3:51:48]
There's also a provision to include an electric conveyor system
[3:51:53]
to move soil from east to west that would have no emissions.
[3:51:57]
There are filtration standards on homes.
[3:52:00]
There's dust suppression.
[3:52:01]
and there are tier 4 generators and cleaner generator controls, it's a long list of things
[3:52:06]
that would reduce those health risk exposure impacts for residents to ongoing construction
[3:52:12]
by the thresholds using the EIR at least to a less significant standard.
[3:52:19]
Okay, so when my questions are going back to the greenhouse gas, can I continue with this line
[3:52:24]
even though I'm sort of crossing borders?
[3:52:27]
It, that's actually the next top.
[3:52:30]
I know. Can we finish this one? Okay, then I will. I'm done because okay. Council member Kurt.
[3:52:40]
Thank you so much again. All good questions. My question is around specifically mobility and emissions.
[3:52:50]
We're going to be some sort of a valuation on the replacement of it says 2.2.82 tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per employee regarding their commuting and commuting reduction being a transit hub.
[3:53:05]
How will we measure that if it's, if the only thing I can think about measuring that it would be self-reported, how are we going to figure that out if that's actually a tanned?
[3:53:14]
Could
[3:53:19]
you please cite that figure again and where it appears?
[3:53:22]
Sure, it's under mobility and emissions.
[3:53:27]
It's the replacement of 0.282 tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per employee per annual commute cap.
[3:53:35]
This is under the transportation demand management guidelines.
[3:53:39]
I'm just wondering how we're going to measure that at that point.
[3:54:04]
Can you give us a...
[3:54:06]
Other questions we can look that up for your...
[3:54:09]
My question is for Stephanie, if you don't mind, you're doing a great job tonight,
[3:54:17]
so I've
[3:54:17]
had the opportunity to tour two water treatment plants over the last two weeks.
[3:54:22]
I've learned a variety of things about water recycling.
[3:54:26]
One of them was from an engineer very recently that said, you were not allowed to call it
[3:54:29]
toilet to tap any longer, that's an old term, so I'm pretty fascinated by that.
[3:54:34]
But in terms of the phasing, we keep going back to the phasing and I understand that, in terms
[3:54:39]
of the water treatment facility, can you just tell us a little bit about what phase that will
[3:54:44]
come in because you're going to need water to recycle, right? And at some point you're going to
[3:54:48]
have to switch off fresh water to move over to water recycling, you're going to have to have
[3:54:52]
enough volume in which to recycle that. And I understand, right, there's human usage water. We can
[3:54:57]
turn that into a couple of different things. And there's also storm water runoff that we can use
[3:55:00]
too. So I'm just curious what your thoughts are on that. Is it okay if I answer a question that's
[3:55:06]
on the agenda tonight?
[3:55:10]
We do have a whole session on water coming up.
[3:55:13]
But Council member Cronen.
[3:55:15]
It's in the same of the program work.
[3:55:17]
I mean, all right, you got me.
[3:55:20]
I will tell you where we are today on.
[3:55:24]
We committed in art originally to a water recycling facility for the bailouts.
[3:55:33]
And in the meantime, we were, as we were searching for a water supply,
[3:55:41]
Cal Water came to the city and to us and said, hey, we have, you know, we have, they have SFPUs.
[3:55:49]
They have a big bucket of SFPUs, C, H, H, H, H, H, H, H.
[3:55:54]
And what they ask us to participate in and we have a letter of intent with them, but what
[3:56:03]
we ask them to participate, what they ask us to participate in was increasing the doubling
[3:56:09]
the size of our water recycling facility that in exchange for them supplying us potable
[3:56:15]
water, for drinking water, for the Baylands project, and they would like the water recycling facility
[3:56:30]
wasn't coming on until we had enough actual sewer water to recycle, and then our initial
[3:56:40]
proposal that was I think it hits it about 20% of development, both commercial M and commercial.
[3:56:49]
We would actually have enough sewer water.
[3:56:52]
Cal water proposal would like to start that water recycling facility on day one.
[3:57:00]
It was a catch.
[3:57:01]
you know. Because we don't have any sewer for them so that they would be ideally taking
[3:57:10]
water from the city of Brisbane's current system and the base sewer or cemetery districts,
[3:57:19]
and using that and recycling the water there so that they have, so the water recycling facility
[3:57:26]
is up and running early, that we're still working on that structure of that actual deal, but
[3:57:39]
did I ask you a question?
[3:57:43]
I think it's good.
[3:57:44]
Did you actually, yeah, so our water recycling facility, if the cow water deal doesn't
[3:57:52]
happen, our water recycling facility would come in at about 20, 20, 20 percent development
[3:57:57]
when we have actually have. Yeah, the cow water deals and other is another, has a different
[3:58:05]
structure to it. It would happen sooner. And they are, did you happen to tour the West Bay Sanitary
[3:58:12]
water recycling facility in Geran Heights? The one down in San Mateo and the one at Google,
[3:58:19]
Baby, it's called baby.
[3:58:21]
Oh, yeah, those are very small.
[3:58:22]
Yes.
[3:58:23]
They're very small.
[3:58:24]
Small footprint for sure.
[3:58:26]
Yes.
[3:58:26]
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[3:58:27]
West space sanitary is done.
[3:58:29]
Half MGD water is second facility at Sharon Heights.
[3:58:34]
And they're in the process of developing a 1MGD, which would be what we are talking
[3:58:39]
out with cow water at the meta site in the mo park.
[3:58:47]
Yeah.
[3:58:48]
Thank you.
[3:58:51]
Can I can I follow up on that?
[3:58:54]
Is the proposed water recycling treatment center on the landfill?
[3:59:01]
Yes.
[3:59:03]
How could that be done if the landfill is not clear?
[3:59:05]
and then Northern, oh well, so the landfill closure plan can I answer question that's not
[3:59:11]
on the agenda here, because we have a whole session on remediation later, but it's the
[3:59:16]
same ability, I know, I answered council member currents question, part of the framework.
[3:59:22]
You got me.
[3:59:27]
What was the question? How can it be? How can it be? How can land fill is not closed?
[3:59:36]
The landfill closure plan and the clean up plans for the really hard site are, they will proceed with each increment of development.
[3:59:50]
So the, and the water recycling facility is in the northern part of the landfill, not the soil amounts are all in the southern part of the, of the landfills.
[4:00:00]
The northern part is fairly flat. So we could put the water refus cycling facility in, it would have to, that those acreages, same with the battery storage, those acreages would have to comply with Title 27 closure.
[4:00:17]
Yes.
[4:00:19]
Okay. Thank you. Yeah. And the landfill closure plan would proceed also with each increment of development.
[4:00:27]
And that's was approved by both the county and the water board.
[4:00:34]
And it is quite difficult for landfills of the size to go through that kind of phase closure.
[4:00:42]
Thank you.
[4:00:42]
But we can talk more about that when we immediately welcome to that.
[4:00:45]
Part of the county.
[4:00:46]
Thank you.
[4:00:48]
And we can double back to the question that we were looking at the tickets a second to
[4:00:53]
find the metric and the sustainability framework that we're asking about.
[4:00:57]
It is one of the recommended key performance indicators, which I'm looking at page 35 of the
[4:01:04]
framework.
[4:01:05]
It does use that same metric that you talked about, study progress towards GHG emissions
[4:01:10]
of 0.282 tons per employee per year.
[4:01:15]
It is qualified by the language that says these are not meant as prescriptive requirements,
[4:01:20]
but as methods that may be appropriate to help achieve the goals of the principles and the
[4:01:26]
measure J.J. requires consistency with the goals of the principles of the sustainability
[4:01:32]
framework.
[4:01:33]
However,
[4:01:36]
we don't have the precise CO2 port in plea, it will take a little bit of time to
[4:01:44]
tease that out of the data from the EIR, the EIR compiled.
[4:01:51]
for greenhouse gas emissions based on all travel patterns, commuters,
[4:01:59]
shoppers, other sorts
[4:02:00]
of trip to me and I'm going to show a regional reduction in GHG emissions related to
[4:02:07]
VMT from the project.
[4:02:09]
However, we think it is likely that once we have the opportunity to aggregate that number
[4:02:15]
out that we would be below that threshold that's established in the 2015 Sustainability Framework
[4:02:22]
given improvements that have been made in EV adoption, fuel efficiency, and other vehicles.
[4:02:28]
So we think that it'll take a little bit of time to divide that out of the model for you,
[4:02:35]
but we think that we'll have a good number that compares favorably to what's in the sustainability
[4:02:40]
framework when that's done. Thanks, Eric. And my mind, I was even thinking about the EV
[4:02:45]
option. Thank you. Thank you.
[4:02:47]
Is that all your questions?
[4:02:49]
Those are my questions.
[4:02:52]
Exactly. We are at very on the precipice of the end of our one hour extension of the meeting.
[4:03:00]
Council's pleasure.
[4:03:02]
We want to extend another hour.
[4:03:04]
I mean, no, but it's not unrealistic to think that this is going to get done in a half hour.
[4:03:10]
So, I think we need to extend for an hour.
[4:03:15]
Yes, sir.
[4:03:16]
Is that a motion?
[4:03:18]
Yeah.
[4:03:18]
10 second. All in favor?
[4:03:20]
Hi.
[4:03:21]
Anyone opposed?
[4:03:22]
Okay.
[4:03:25]
So, our one hour will be at 1029.
[4:03:31]
My question is sustainability.
[4:03:34]
I'm going to parlay off of councilmember Lens who talked about
[4:03:39]
Electrical power and the comment was made if there was a lot of energy generated that maybe the residents wouldn't have to pay anything.
[4:03:53]
And so this is kind of a question and statement at the same time in that normally was solar because early solar adopters.
[4:04:07]
Their goal was to put so much solar on their home that they would pay nothing.
[4:04:11]
And PG&E learned, wait a minute, we're not doing that.
[4:04:15]
And so you saw distribution costs appear on the bill, along with other itemized things.
[4:04:23]
And that was NEM1, and we're now in NEM2, and that's already closed, and we're in NEM3.
[4:04:33]
And so usually when you propose solar, PG&E has to approve the amount of solar.
[4:04:42]
So if they anticipate that you're going to be putting mega-solar, they'll say, no, no,
[4:04:48]
you can't install all that.
[4:04:49]
We won't connect it all.
[4:04:51]
So that you do end up paying something.
[4:04:54]
That being said, it kind of leads into my question in that, and we'll see if there's a question
[4:05:02]
in here. When you look at the sustainability with solar farms and solar on the buildings and
[4:05:10]
battery storage, the other misconception that people have is well if we just generate tons of
[4:05:18]
this energy, it's all going to go to the grid and they're going to be so happy. And now the grid,
[4:05:24]
there's so much solar case, though, which is the California system operators going, no, no, no,
[4:05:30]
We can't in the daytime we get tons, it's at night, we don't get energy, there's no sunlight.
[4:05:37]
So during the daytime they're now trying to slow down what's coming their way because they can't take it on.
[4:05:45]
Which brings us to batteries.
[4:05:47]
And so here's my question in that.
[4:05:50]
How did you come up with the size of batteries?
[4:05:53]
and you're talking about distributed energy resources, familiar west light is a program that they're
[4:06:00]
promoting. How did you come up with calculations on these batteries based on what you don't have
[4:06:08]
anybody living there and you're coming up with a battery size. And so it parlies off what our
[4:06:23]
the usage is more and and there's no perfect assurance but I'm just curious how the calculations
[4:06:30]
came about because I didn't see a study and maybe I missed something. So staff I don't know if
[4:06:38]
you want to field that question
[4:06:47]
in that also I would point out for Council Member Lens. All those
[4:06:51]
residences and businesses will still have separate metering. They're not going to just be on
[4:06:57]
developers meet or giving them free energy. Even if there's way more energy produced, I don't
[4:07:04]
believe the developer plans to just give free electricity to everybody all the time. Correct?
[4:07:13]
I mean, I don't quite understand how you're going to parse that out because you do have certain
[4:07:18]
electrical needs infrastructure. I get that. And if you're operating water recycling facility,
[4:07:25]
you're going to need energy for that, but I want to dispel any myths that
[4:07:30]
Because there's going to be a giant solar farm that it's community owned, which is not because you clarified that you own it.
[4:07:37]
This isn't going to necessarily translate to people living there getting only distribution costs on their PG&E bill.
[4:07:48]
Is that correct?
[4:07:52]
And maybe this is premature to, you may have to come back on that.
[4:07:56]
I'm trying to find out how you came up with
[4:08:00]
to calculations for all of this.
[4:08:04]
Anybody?
[4:08:07]
But staff can provide some context, perhaps, right?
[4:08:11]
Yeah.
[4:08:12]
As far as the calculation of battery storage,
[4:08:15]
I would point you to the same Thorton Tomiseti report that we use in the
[4:08:20]
EIR to calculate the project's energy balance,
[4:08:23]
the 2023 report, which does look at,
[4:08:26]
has a phasing plan of Balean's energy consumption over buildout, looking at the various districts
[4:08:33]
being built out through the buildout horizon and the amount of community solar building solar
[4:08:40]
or community battery building battery also being built to kind of smooth the duck curve that you
[4:08:45]
mentioned. That is the one place that I'm aware of where battery size was contemplated to try to
[4:08:51]
achieve as close to that energy neutrality goal as possible.
[4:08:57]
And if you don't know who are the tenants in the commercial sector, you have no idea what
[4:09:03]
their energy consumption is, that's where my brain is rattling, sorry, because I'm saying
[4:09:10]
it's a moist finger to the wind, calculation kind of.
[4:09:19]
Yeah, I think it's a little bit more than a moist finger.
[4:09:21]
Okay, good, kind of about that, but I do not, I do not have the fort and time of
[4:09:27]
study in front of me, but it did take in and they analyze the specific plan, you know,
[4:09:35]
all the commercial and all the residential and the types of residential and they use
[4:09:39]
industry standards on, you know, what is a typical office use, what is a typical biotech lab
[4:09:46]
use. And so it was a very detailed study that came up with the estimates for the battery
[4:09:54]
and the distributed battery. And you also very correct about where we are right now in California
[4:10:01]
on our grid. We have done a really good job of sending a lot of solar and a lot of wind to
[4:10:06]
the grid. And the grid is having to drop a lot of that right now. And that's where the batteries
[4:10:14]
coming. Exactly. That's why the battery is very important. Both are distributed. Our distributed
[4:10:20]
battery on side and on individual buildings as well as the utility scale battery that we're
[4:10:26]
planning for. Very important to, to, you know, the overall grid. You know, whether anybody's going to
[4:10:33]
have a zero PG&E bill anymore, that I cannot, that's hard to, to guess. Our, but our goal was to,
[4:10:42]
you know, try to meet the goal of energy neutrality in Mr. JJ and I think we've gotten
[4:10:49]
there with the plan that we've put forward to you tonight. But you are, are you asking
[4:10:54]
great questions? Yeah, and they are, and a lot of the, the actual studies that you're
[4:11:00]
asking about are in the Thornton, the study, and we can get that to you. It was, but believe
[4:11:08]
it was appended in the EIR, but it's sometimes hard to connect with.
[4:11:14]
I totally appreciate that nobody's gotten through all of the studies.
[4:11:18]
I don't know.
[4:11:19]
I don't know.
[4:11:23]
I've been calling it out.
[4:11:26]
None at all.
[4:11:27]
One thing, if you could clarify, and that was Councilmember O'Connell asking you about building
[4:11:33]
the water recycling facility and the when that phase goes in and you indicated in the
[4:11:41]
northern part but what I didn't quite get clearly out of that was so if it's not on the
[4:11:47]
east side it's not phase two that's is that correct if it's not on the east side it's not
[4:11:55]
phase well you mentioned that phase well the water recycling facility if we do the
[4:12:02]
health care water. It would be in early phase. Yeah. When I say phase two, I'm really talking
[4:12:08]
about we would call we have two and a half million square feet of commercial on the landfill site.
[4:12:16]
No. I guess when I talk about the phasing, I'm really talking about the construction.
[4:12:22]
Okay. I guess a lot of this super infrastructure. I'm sorry I didn't mean to interrupt you.
[4:12:26]
No, I guess what I'm trying to get at is whether that facility would be in place when
[4:12:33]
the first thrones are built, which facility are we talking about.
[4:12:36]
The water recycling.
[4:12:42]
Again, the cow water deal does contemplate very early.
[4:12:49]
The water recycling facility would go early and quite likely before the first housing, but
[4:12:56]
not. We haven't worked that we haven't worked the deal out totally yet with
[4:13:01]
Cal Water. If it's our recycling facility that we committed to under the
[4:13:06]
sustainability principles that would have to wait until we were 20% built out
[4:13:11]
because we don't have any sewer we don't have any water to recycle so we need a
[4:13:15]
certain amount of water to actually run a water recycling facility so that would
[4:13:19]
be so yeah there's two sort of scenarios here that we've that have been
[4:13:24]
to play it in our one is our recycling facility, a smaller facility just for the baylands
[4:13:32]
and then the cow water larger, one million gallons per day water recycling facility that would
[4:13:38]
come online earlier. Okay, and my concern there is what Councilmember O'Connell served with also
[4:13:45]
is just that the timeline and you know just something get built and then it takes 10 years before
[4:13:51]
that facilities constructed, so I guess we don't really know.
[4:13:56]
Yeah, and I think we'll work this out on, you know, as we get closer to, you know, really
[4:14:01]
hatching out the phasing of that project, but we also need to make sure that, you know, as we
[4:14:06]
work through that, we need flexibility, because we need flexibility to respond to market
[4:14:10]
conditions. So, you know, it's a little, it's a complicated puzzle, and we're going to
[4:14:15]
talk later, much later, and we're hearing about the phasing, but these are all great
[4:14:19]
questions and yeah we do want to we do want to talk about when things get put in place
[4:14:27]
but we also need to keep in mind yeah project feasibilities and market being sensitive to market
[4:14:35]
conditions okay thank you that's my question slips number
[4:14:47]
one I have here is Mr. Paul
[4:14:49]
scale. And second I have is Nicole.
[4:14:54]
Nicole and you have slip
[4:14:56]
sprang them up if you have Nicole and Darren are no longer.
[4:15:00]
All right, the meeting. Nicole's no longer here with us and Darren. No. And we're Darren, no longer here with us. No matter Mary, so we have Paul Pascal and Anthony Walker. Okay.
[4:15:16]
And then Linda Linda's after Anthony. Okay. So in order, I have Paul Anthony Walker, Linda
[4:15:29]
Michelle. Thanks, Michelle Susan Brandt. That's what I have. Okay. Paul.
[4:15:37]
you're on and I don't think she's here.
[4:15:43]
Oh yeah, Ellie's here. Number seven.
[4:15:49]
I don't
[4:15:56]
think I had Ellie on this topic.
[4:15:59]
Is it a court?
[4:16:01]
I have a doubt for number two also.
[4:16:04]
Oh yes.
[4:16:05]
Okay.
[4:16:06]
My mistake.
[4:16:07]
Yes. Okay. Sorry, Ellie.
[4:16:09]
We got you back.
[4:16:09]
and then Clara, Clara just admitted.
[4:16:11]
And Clara just admitted, okay.
[4:16:15]
All right, Paul, sorry about that.
[4:16:17]
Go ahead.
[4:16:18]
Okay, thank you, Council.
[4:16:20]
And I really appreciate the questions you asked.
[4:16:25]
I learned something new today.
[4:16:29]
I shouldn't just be having these comments.
[4:16:32]
I should be asking questions that way.
[4:16:35]
They could be answered.
[4:16:36]
Because every time I come up with comments,
[4:16:39]
I just get nods and walk back to my seat, but I realize tonight when you ask it in the form
[4:16:46]
out of a question, then I get a little bit to your.
[4:16:50]
So, one of the questions I have tonight is that other usual comments that I've been having
[4:16:57]
are, how can we move forward with this complex situation when there's still wording in there
[4:17:07]
that mitigation measures will be done when feasible.
[4:17:12]
I mean, come on, who's going to determine if it was feasible or not?
[4:17:17]
That's fine, okay.
[4:17:18]
I mean, that in itself should be enough for us to just put the brakes on, not to slow this
[4:17:23]
process down.
[4:17:25]
So I don't want to agree with that.
[4:17:27]
So I would like some clarification on what that actually means and the other thing is
[4:17:39]
When mitigation measures will be done when feasible
[4:17:42]
That could leave this community on the hook for a lot of stuff down the road
[4:17:48]
bonds
[4:17:49]
things at future generations of Brisbane and you're gonna have to pay off to
[4:17:55]
Sixth the problems and I don't want to be a
[4:17:58]
care and there's no care ends in here, but I
[4:18:02]
Probably shouldn't say that. I'm sorry
[4:18:04]
That taste but I don't want to be a
[4:18:09]
falling type of person but there's a lot of stuff going on here and I know everybody's
[4:18:16]
worked very hard for the last 20 years on the issues but when we have words like
[4:18:23]
mitigation measures will be the one feasible on every topic that leaves that's a huge loophole
[4:18:31]
and I can't believe that's still in the EIR and another thing that I'm concerned about
[4:18:39]
is when we talk about open space, as most people know, open space is just public property.
[4:18:45]
There's no value in it for environmental value or anything more than just public space.
[4:18:53]
Now, that puts a burden on the city, 25% open space in the bailouts, because now we're
[4:19:00]
responsible for the 25% open space and who knows what we're going to be left with, mitigation
[4:19:06]
measures were done or what done. One of the other concerns I have is wording in the document
[4:19:17]
that refers to open space and or open areas. As you know, open areas are private property
[4:19:28]
and usually have public access, but nothing more than bonds, parking lots,
[4:19:33]
These ways whatever it is it's private property, but in the document it says open space and or open areas
[4:19:41]
So the word and the meaning and order me means
[4:19:46]
Nothing has to happen to get all just be
[4:19:50]
Open area private property and no open space so
[4:19:58]
I've been doing this up for years.
[4:20:01]
I mean, when I sat on the draft environmental impact report committee, that was the one thing
[4:20:06]
that I could find in the documents that was relevant to something I could relate to, as opposed
[4:20:12]
to having all these professionals and other people that are evaluating these things that
[4:20:16]
are pretty complex,
[4:20:20]
but when you put a couple simple words in the sentence, and if it's
[4:20:24]
overlooked. Once you sign the document to approve it, it's a done deal. So we can be left
[4:20:30]
holding the bag and I don't know how it got to this point. I really don't. There's a
[4:20:40]
lot of stuff that we've just been going through the motions and sometimes it feels like
[4:20:45]
a dog and pony show and I know you guys have been putting your time and effort into it,
[4:20:50]
it. It's a big deal. And so the comments you made about, well, is this going to be
[4:20:57]
ready? When this is happening? There are no guarantees. And so if we can't even guarantee
[4:21:03]
if mitigation measures will be done, what it is, the whole document. Thank you.
[4:21:11]
So Mr.
[4:21:12]
Bruce Gow, would you like your questions answered?
[4:21:17]
Yes. I don't need to stand here because
[4:21:19]
that's yet to my comment or questions.
[4:21:23]
Okay.
[4:21:23]
Let's take you.
[4:21:24]
Yes.
[4:21:25]
Yes, I will.
[4:21:26]
Okay.
[4:21:26]
So your first question was,
[4:21:30]
mitigation measures done when feasible?
[4:21:32]
What does that actually mean?
[4:21:34]
Terrible.
[4:21:35]
Your consequences.
[4:21:36]
Who decides?
[4:21:37]
Well, feasible is a specific defined term in sequence.
[4:21:43]
That an action is capable of being achieved in a reasonable period of time.
[4:21:49]
taking into account cost political realities, environmental, legal, social and technological
[4:21:57]
limitations. When you make findings about the EIR, you will make findings that the
[4:22:05]
mitigation measures are feasible, secret requires you to adopt all feasible mitigation
[4:22:13]
measures to reduce project impacts to the extent that it is feasible to do so.
[4:22:19]
So, the word feasible is all over the EIR, the comment is correct, but the mitigation measures
[4:22:26]
themselves that are included in the EIR are the mitigation.
[4:22:30]
Decision measures that have been identified as feasible. So, ultimately, if Council follows the Planning Commission's recommendation and staff's recommendation to certify the EIR, make those findings, and adopt the mitigation monitoring program, you will be adopting enforceable mitigation measures and finding that those mitigation measures are feasible to comply with.
[4:22:58]
Did that answer your question?
[4:23:09]
So, thank you.
[4:23:11]
No, it didn't.
[4:23:13]
Okay, so just being aware of time.
[4:23:16]
Oh yeah, I'll be quick.
[4:23:17]
Okay.
[4:23:18]
Yeah, I didn't need a big explanation,
[4:23:21]
but it says when feasible.
[4:23:24]
It doesn't say that these items have been determined to be feasible.
[4:23:29]
It says that each item is stated to be done when feasible.
[4:23:35]
Well, that's all by comment was not, I didn't need to understand the term of feasibility.
[4:23:41]
I just met how we could allow it something to be stated when feasible.
[4:23:46]
That was my comment, or inquiry question.
[4:23:55]
And the other question he had was open space versus open areas.
[4:24:01]
And he pointed out there was a lack of guarantees, it says where it says open space or open
[4:24:07]
areas.
[4:24:10]
Is that a statement though?
[4:24:12]
Is there a question of the question?
[4:24:13]
Well, I think the question in there was,
[4:24:15]
Is it allowable to be either or?
[4:24:18]
Is that the question?
[4:24:27]
Does it have either?
[4:24:29]
Yes, it could be either or.
[4:24:33]
And and or open areas.
[4:24:36]
So open space and or open area.
[4:24:39]
Now if it said open area and or open space.
[4:24:44]
And or.
[4:24:47]
You wouldn't allow it to be just open space if it said and or open space just like we wouldn't allow it just to be open area if it says and or open areas and or it's either or is was my question.
[4:25:03]
It's like there's either or possibility.
[4:25:07]
So could you restate the question because are you are you making a point as a statement or are you asking a question to be clarified with that?
[4:25:15]
I think yeah, I'm asking for the question to be not not clarified but
[4:25:20]
Is there a possibility that if it says and or that it could be the or instead of the ant?
[4:25:27]
Who has the discretion to decide is that question?
[4:25:30]
Yeah, thank you.
[4:25:31]
I guess
[4:25:40]
I would need additional clarification
[4:25:42]
Which document exactly the Mr. Buscoise referring to?
[4:25:47]
So just looking at the sustainability framework itself.
[4:25:51]
The portion addressing open space and habitat addresses provisions for significant open space and open areas.
[4:25:58]
So I'm seeing some language there in the sustainability framework.
[4:26:01]
If we're talking about the specific plan itself, we can address where in the specific plan that's addressed.
[4:26:08]
Sounds like BDI may be prepared to address it as well.
[4:26:10]
If I may, again, Katie with the Bayland's team,
[4:26:14]
this is actually a question that we've received several times.
[4:26:17]
I think it originates from the language in Measure JJ.
[4:26:20]
There's a table and it says 25% of developable area must be open space slash open area.
[4:26:28]
And so we do get this question a lot.
[4:26:30]
Like, are you just going to count, you know,
[4:26:32]
median strips and plasas as open space?
[4:26:35]
And the short answer is no.
[4:26:36]
If you were to count both open space and open area is a very significant portion of the project,
[4:26:44]
but when we're talking about true open space as defined in the general plan that the public
[4:26:49]
accessible, as real, habitat benefits, et cetera, it is that is more than 25% of the
[4:26:56]
developable land.
[4:26:57]
And I'll also say that does not include the solar farm, that does not include the lagoon,
[4:27:02]
And that calculation was also done taking into account the acreage that will be lost to a sea level rise.
[4:27:09]
So maybe that's something that would be worthwhile clarifying.
[4:27:15]
Well, I think what Paul's getting at is clarifying ownership.
[4:27:19]
It's part of that and maintenance, right?
[4:27:22]
So open space, I think, being a city's ultimate responsibility to our potentially our
[4:27:32]
property versus open area of being publicly accessible space, that's privately owned
[4:27:39]
and maintained.
[4:27:41]
I think that's really something that this is going to get hashed out in a later,
[4:27:51]
you know,
[4:27:52]
Who's owning what and who's you know ultimately liable and who's gonna maintain and all that
[4:28:00]
I see that being a down the road thing
[4:28:04]
Yeah, I would agree with them
[4:28:07]
Anthony Walker
[4:28:20]
Good evening everybody. I appreciate you hanging in
[4:28:25]
I'm a little bit loopy myself, so I'm gonna get through this
[4:28:30]
So, I'm Anthony Walker, Brisbane resident.
[4:28:34]
I submitted a longer written comment.
[4:28:38]
It encouraged you to read it if you haven't.
[4:28:41]
So, but tonight I wanted to focus on one specific topic from that letter.
[4:28:48]
And that was very simply, we already have guiding documents to tell us what the Bayland is supposed to do, how it's supposed to work.
[4:28:57]
And, yeah, I really hope that we should follow them.
[4:29:02]
So, you know, measure JJ as part of the general plan, and it says that the Bay line sustainability
[4:29:08]
program shall be consistent with sustainability framework, and that the development shall be designed,
[4:29:15]
so it's to be energy neutral on and on going basis.
[4:29:17]
And I think that designed part of it is really important.
[4:29:20]
And the framework tells us what that means, the project should produce its own annual energy
[4:29:27]
needs, and for any shortfall, it establishes an order, right, maximize onsite generation
[4:29:33]
first, evaluate additional generation within Brisbane's second, and then, and only then
[4:29:40]
produce renewable procurement, renewable electricity from the grid to fill any remaining gap.
[4:29:47]
I do feel like that second leg there is being entirely skipped over.
[4:29:51]
I haven't heard any discussion of off-site renewable anything in Brisbane.
[4:30:01]
I want to bring up that at the Planning Commission's August 13 meeting, the August 7th Memorandum prepared by ESA, was introduced after the close of the public hearing as attachment 5, and it advances an interpretation of the project that, you know, generating roughly half of its electricity on site, and purchasing the remainder can nevertheless satisfy JJ's requirement for ongoing neutrality.
[4:30:30]
I respectfully believe that that interpretation is inconsistent with both the voter-adopted
[4:30:36]
language and the sustainability framework that Maserjaje expressed expressly incorporates.
[4:30:42]
The current plan would generate 53% of its electricity on site, and calling the rest energy neutral
[4:30:48]
because future occupants will promise to buy renewable power from the grid.
[4:30:54]
that may make it elect the electricity carbon-free, but on paper, but it does not make the
[4:31:04]
the development energy neutral. The framework treats procurement as a fallback, not the definition,
[4:31:11]
and these are not interchangeable concepts. Renewable energy is not the same as energy neutrality.
[4:31:16]
They're different questions.
[4:31:20]
So, you know, I think this is where we have to be really careful about moving the goal posts, right?
[4:31:27]
ESA's own March 2025 energy resources, technical report, said forthrightly that the project would consume more electricity than it generates at every stage of buildout and would therefore not be energy neutral.
[4:31:43]
And the underlying balance has not changed.
[4:31:47]
What has changed is the interpretation of what energy neutrality means.
[4:31:53]
Right, and that's not a minor technical verification.
[4:31:58]
You know, I would say if the city believes that the voter adopted requirement should now mean something materially different
[4:32:06]
from what the framework NESA's earlier analysis thought it should, you know, that's a consequential policy decision that really should be explicitly before this council.
[4:32:21]
You know, not something to quietly become city policy through a late stage consultant that random.
[4:32:28]
You know, and I have over so I will cut myself off there.
[4:32:31]
So before you disappear, I don't know if you had a question in there, but are you suggesting that
[4:32:39]
or asking,
[4:32:42]
would the purchase of off-site production suffice for energy neutrality?
[4:32:50]
In other words, the developer can purchase part of a project in the Arizona Desert that generates electricity
[4:32:58]
and they have a contract for that.
[4:33:00]
Well, actually, no, I wasn't asking that question, because I think the sustainability framework
[4:33:08]
expressly says, no, you can't do that. It has to be in Brisbane. It's quite clear about that.
[4:33:14]
Okay, so not on the bail-ins, but could be in another place in Brisbane.
[4:33:17]
Offside in Brisbane. Okay, in City Limitson upwards, okay.
[4:33:21]
And it doesn't necessarily, you know, I think that maybe, you know, sort of a mental blocker
[4:33:29]
maybe that, oh, well, we need a giant open field somewhere that, you know, to put a second solar
[4:33:34]
farmer, something like that may come off as, you know, oh, that's invisible, but there's no
[4:33:40]
reason you couldn't put distributed solar all over Brisbane, for example, and have the same
[4:33:45]
effect.
[4:33:46]
If it's measured in, it's got to be an offset, a certain number of kilowatts kilowatts
[4:33:51]
I was produced to meet a shortfall, right, then there are many ways to do that.
[4:33:58]
Got you. I know I got you. Right. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much
[4:34:04]
Okay, I said develop or something real quick. If you want to mine sure fast how big is your property at zero point?
[4:34:13]
I'm sorry can you repeat because a big is your property at zero point how many acres?
[4:34:23]
Don't quote me, but I think it's about seven seven
[4:34:27]
Okay
[4:34:28]
Do you think that could be a place for some off-site? I mean
[4:34:36]
off-site energy generation.
[4:34:42]
It is our belief that our current plan with the solar farm that
[4:34:46]
we're building in all the solar and the battery storage meets and exceeds the definition
[4:34:51]
of energy neutrality.
[4:34:58]
Did you have further question on that? No, I mean, it was a really
[4:35:03]
an answer to my question, but okay. In the salmon.
[4:35:18]
Well, it's well past my bedtime, so I might
[4:35:20]
I'd be very coherent, but I see lots of problems.
[4:35:25]
Back when we did the first assessment in 332 years ago about what was happening in the bay
[4:35:36]
lands, I think it was pretty clear that we weren't wanting to have single family homes on
[4:35:45]
toxic soil with clay caps or anything else, because they were showing pictures of beautiful
[4:35:50]
gardens growing out of these things and people having growing their food on toxic soil and
[4:35:55]
it was like not possible. So, I still contend that that's not feasible. So, back to
[4:36:03]
cause, so sustainability. First of all,
[4:36:10]
we had decided the reason we did the FARs the way they
[4:36:13]
in the 1994 General Plan is that the buildout could be commercial with above it, dwelling
[4:36:25]
units, apartments, condos, you could buy it or rent it, and above that solar panels.
[4:36:33]
And maybe in between if they wanted, they could put hydroponic gardens, something of that
[4:36:40]
And everything would be sustainable and would be pretty much at the north end of it and not at the most toxic area of the baylands of you know below ice house fill and so on and so forth and
[4:36:55]
We felt that that was pretty good idea. Well apparently the owners of the property decided that that was not good and so they were
[4:37:04]
You know, screw you. We're not going to do it. We're going to do change this and do that and we're going to come up with another plan.
[4:37:12]
Well, the other, the new plan has, for houses, fancy homes that are going to cost a fortune for people who want to live there.
[4:37:20]
And guess what, those people are not going to, they're going to want to do their way. They're going to want to have sonas and swimming pools and all kinds of other things going on.
[4:37:30]
It's going to be a real problem. So I think that we really need to come back and rethink this whole project, the way it's happening, the way they're presenting it right now.
[4:37:40]
I really don't think that it's liable and it's not ever going to be an original.
[4:37:44]
I'd like to know when they decided how much water people needed, when they decided how much electricity they're going to need,
[4:37:51]
And all these other factors, because things have changed drastically, and they will continue to change even more as we go forward.
[4:38:01]
So, to me, the most flexible thing is to begin, if they want to begin building, to begin building under where the slade lock is, where there's some ground you can get under.
[4:38:12]
Okay, and start slowly building those businesses across from Bayshore that would have dwelling units up above
[4:38:22]
for not not having kids on toxic soil. That is just unknown. It's not going to happen. We cannot do it.
[4:38:30]
I can go on and on, but I'm really tired and we'll save the other comments for later.
[4:38:36]
Thank you, Linda. Michelle Salmon. Is Michelle still here?
[4:38:42]
She might be on my mind.
[4:38:43]
Michelle.
[4:38:45]
Okay, go ahead, Michelle.
[4:38:48]
I saw my knee.
[4:38:50]
You know, I have to say the Anthony Walker spot on.
[4:38:54]
We worked really hard on this sustainability framework in the original program EIR.
[4:39:02]
And I think that we need to hold the line on that because robbing Peter to pay Paul
[4:39:10]
environmentally globally isn't going to cut it.
[4:39:14]
And if we can't produce enough energy to be energy-neutral, then maybe we need to resize
[4:39:21]
the development in terms of the, you know, 6.5 million square feet of commercial space.
[4:39:31]
because that is part of what this is about, you know, I think that over development is an issue.
[4:39:41]
I don't think we should downsize the housing, because that's obviously a hot point and a big need.
[4:39:47]
But downsizing the entire development so that it can be energy neutral on site is important and the other thing is, you know.
[4:39:59]
Thinking outside the box is not that bad of an idea. Prismain is 19 something square miles and everybody's like
[4:40:06]
Oh, that's lots and lots and lots and lots of room
[4:40:09]
But only 3.1 to 3.5 of it is land and I think you're well aware of that about a mayor. Yes, I am
[4:40:17]
Is very steep, but
[4:40:21]
We do have 19 square miles to work with and since the big dirt pile has already ruined in
[4:40:28]
windsurfing, we ever could have complicated, you know, between used to be windsurfing
[4:40:35]
in candlestick. Point was like the best windsurfing place in the bay, not anymore, because
[4:40:41]
of the big dirt pile. But once that dirt pile goes down, we're going to have more wind. And in
[4:40:47]
general, we have a lot of wind there already. And maybe we should think about back, you know, back
[4:40:53]
a little bit and do some wind generation and put some windmills out on the bay and generate
[4:41:00]
some energy and maybe even some solar panels out there. It's not very well it's not very deep
[4:41:07]
now it's going to get deeper. But you know we made a commitment to sustainability on this project
[4:41:14]
and I think we need to honor that commitment and I think to do that we need to think outside the
[4:41:23]
do our part to stop up that. And that's part of why this was done this way with the sustainability
[4:41:31]
framework. And so I think that's one of the most important things that we can honor in this whole agreement.
[4:41:36]
And I just want to acknowledge the amount of incredible work that everybody's done on this, you know.
[4:41:45]
And I think everybody kind of wants the same ultimate goal, a safe, sustainable project that can last
[4:41:52]
a hundred years into the future. So let's all work towards that and think outside the box
[4:41:59]
and make sure that it's sustainable for Brisbane. It's sustainable for the planet. It's sustainable for
[4:42:06]
the, you know, for everybody. So thank you. And good night. Thank you, Michelle. I set me.
[4:42:15]
Alley.
[4:42:30]
Alley, say for me on behalf of the Housing Action Coalition. Thank you for staying late. We desperately
[4:42:34]
need the housing. The Baylands is one of the best sustainability opportunities in San
[4:42:39]
Mateo County and for the housing extra couch rain on a site that badly needs environmental
[4:42:43]
remediation regardless of what gets built there. Approving this project is what finally triggers
[4:42:48]
the cleanup of a former real yard in landfill that has sat contaminated for decades. That remediation
[4:42:55]
will follow the same rigorous regulated process that a safely transformed Brownfields across
[4:43:00]
California, including Mission Bay here in the Bay area, which went from
[4:43:04]
real yards and fell to a thriving neighborhood with homes, hospitals,
[4:43:09]
research institutions, and parks. Delay does not protect the site. It just extends
[4:43:14]
the time that contamination sits on a dress. We urge the Council to move forward
[4:43:18]
with a radiation and the public benefits that come with it so it can actually
[4:43:22]
begin. Thank you.
[4:43:24]
Now, did you have any comment on sustainability?
[4:43:28]
Yes, this is all on environmental sustainability.
[4:43:31]
All right, thank you.
[4:43:33]
Susan Brandon.
[4:43:41]
Oh, I mean, and you work so incredibly part.
[4:43:45]
And you have a little baby that's going to wake up at six o'clock in the morning.
[4:43:50]
Yes, you want mommy.
[4:43:52]
And thank you all, really.
[4:43:54]
And I hope that this is addressing sustainability.
[4:43:56]
But first of all, as I understood the cow water plan, it was that the city of Brisbane would get the toilet to tap.
[4:44:08]
And that the baylands, because that's how they have to set it up, would get the fresh water.
[4:44:17]
That's my first question.
[4:44:20]
Then my other question is, I'm just wondering, when you talk about East, the soil, and
[4:44:24]
the East moving to the West, so this is contaminated soil when it gets to the West, what
[4:44:31]
happens to it?
[4:44:33]
That's my second question.
[4:44:35]
And then my last question is, let's say 20 years down the road, there's a significant incidence
[4:44:44]
of cancer with the residents of the balance, do they, are they going to turn around and sue
[4:44:51]
the city of Brisbane? Because that would be the end of Brisbane.
[4:44:57]
Those are my questions.
[4:45:00]
Each question, number two, since my flying fingers, we're trying to show our view. The contaminated soil. When it goes, it's moved from the east to the west. But then where does it go? I mean, and Brisbane owns it.
[4:45:15]
Because it's contaminated soil, and it can't just vaporize. What happens to it?
[4:45:22]
Okay. Thank you. So, first question you had.
[4:45:25]
You were assuming Brisbane would get the toilet to tap the balans would get the fresh water.
[4:45:33]
Yeah, could we have staff respond to that, please?
[4:45:38]
That that's the cow water plan that they're offering.
[4:45:46]
I heard it from a very reliable source.
[4:45:49]
I don't want to just go disclose the name, but woo.
[4:45:55]
Okay, so I just want to clarify that there is no present plan for a toilet to tap facility in the Bayland's project.
[4:46:06]
So what the specific plan calls for is a recycled water facility that would generate non-putable water for non-putable uses.
[4:46:15]
So toilet to tap, facilities, literally mean it's treatment of wastewater, some kind of
[4:46:22]
that results in potable water, meaning water that can be consumed, right?
[4:46:27]
So that's not contemplated in a specific plan.
[4:46:30]
At all.
[4:46:31]
But maybe it's, maybe, how water is contemplating this.
[4:46:37]
That is not something that's not directly tied into the baylands system.
[4:46:43]
Yeah.
[4:46:44]
Could you talk about that?
[4:46:44]
It may be not hiding in everybody's hands project yet, but that this is what they can offer
[4:46:50]
because they can't build a sewage treatment plant in time for the co-inside with the one
[4:47:02]
construction.
[4:47:03]
Well, okay, I don't want to get too deep into issues on my expert on, but my general knowledge
[4:47:07]
of those types of treatment facilities that are treating, again, wastewater and producing
[4:47:11]
a portable water is those are it would not be constructed faster or more cheaply or at a
[4:47:19]
lesser scale than a what is contemplated in the plant which is a water recycling facility
[4:47:22]
that's not generating portable water and again I'll just say we have no there's no plan or
[4:47:28]
proposal on the table at this time for a toilet to tap facility in the baylands
[4:47:37]
and I'm not sure
[4:47:39]
What else?
[4:47:40]
Yeah.
[4:47:40]
Not sure.
[4:47:41]
I'll do some more.
[4:47:43]
Check it.
[4:47:44]
Okay.
[4:47:45]
So your other question was, contaminated soil moving east west is that better, sorry.
[4:47:52]
We need a longer microphone.
[4:47:54]
Contaminated soil moving east west where does it go?
[4:47:58]
Yeah.
[4:47:59]
I mean, when it moves from east to west, so when it lands in the west, then what
[4:48:03]
happens to this contaminated soil?
[4:48:06]
Develop or you want to answer that?
[4:48:09]
What was it there?
[4:48:12]
The third.
[4:48:14]
If 20 years down the road, there's a cancer cluster as such.
[4:48:19]
Also just to clarify, the soil that was going to be moved is clean soil.
[4:48:23]
It's all been tested and is clean stockpile soil.
[4:48:28]
There wouldn't be moving contaminated soil from the east to the west.
[4:48:33]
Just to correct that.
[4:48:34]
On top of the toxic site would just be covered over.
[4:48:39]
But I think I heard it one meeting by like five feet of soil or something.
[4:48:44]
We'll go through the whole remediation plan and cap at the meeting designated for that
[4:48:50]
topic.
[4:48:50]
We'll have this specific next verse for that.
[4:48:52]
And many other studies that show that you cannot cap a toxic site like the baylands.
[4:48:59]
It is impossible.
[4:49:01]
The toxins will reach into the soil and into the groundwater and you can't.
[4:49:07]
And I will bring to the next meeting all the documentation that you, you know, would address this.
[4:49:15]
And someone on his way out said to me, don't worry.
[4:49:20]
This will never happen.
[4:49:22]
This just keeps getting turned over from developer to developer to developer.
[4:49:28]
And it's never going to be built.
[4:49:29]
Susan, the microphone, but also in terms of time.
[4:49:34]
can we count on you to show up when we get to that chapter? Yes. Okay, and you asked about a cancer
[4:49:40]
cluster in 20 years as let's say down the road there's a significant who's liable. Yeah, okay,
[4:49:49]
anybody want to take that one? Well the property owner would be liable. They're they're responsible
[4:49:58]
for they own the property they're responsible for complying with the cleanup orders and
[4:50:03]
applying with the regulatory agencies, mandates on how to remediate the soil to the extent
[4:50:13]
there's liability if they didn't clean it up correctly or they didn't comply with those orders.
[4:50:18]
That's the property owner.
[4:50:20]
That's not the city, no.
[4:50:23]
The developer.
[4:50:25]
What say the developer moved to Cambodia?
[4:50:29]
The property owner, the successor and interest.
[4:50:34]
The owner, but let's say that in the contracts for these residents, that there's something built into the contracts that says,
[4:50:44]
It stipulates who would be responsible because it's built on a toxic site.
[4:50:49]
I think maybe when we do the chapter and remediation again, this is, this is the time we'll bring that one up again.
[4:50:56]
But not, okay, yes.
[4:50:58]
Thank you.
[4:51:00]
Clara Johnson.
[4:51:02]
We're not gonna make 1030.
[4:51:16]
I guess I'd have a comment.
[4:51:18]
And, you know, AB can sue anybody.
[4:51:21]
So there's nothing stopping someone.
[4:51:24]
Regardless of what was just said
[4:51:26]
and I'm not, I'm not, I mean,
[4:51:29]
disputing that, but anybody can sue anybody.
[4:51:38]
In terms of energy,
[4:51:42]
A battery only stores energy in the, I beg your pardon, what am I doing wrong?
[4:51:47]
In the mic, I guess they can't hear you in the back.
[4:51:50]
There you go.
[4:51:51]
How we go, are we going?
[4:51:54]
The battery can only store energy.
[4:51:57]
And this was in a letter that was sent to the planning commission.
[4:52:01]
And if I was very, you know, a battery does only storage at the energy.
[4:52:06]
And that very little energy is added because of the time of day production and use of it,
[4:52:13]
but it's not an energy producer.
[4:52:16]
It might produce a little energy, but I thought that was relevant.
[4:52:21]
And the whole idea of having built into the needs of electrical needs, I would think that
[4:52:29]
You
[4:52:30]
Things that have additional energy savings that are planned, would already have taken that into account
[4:52:38]
when they were stating what the energy needs over the project. You can't count it again, as a savings.
[4:52:48]
So, you can't double count that.
[4:52:52]
And if only 47% of neutral is not neutral. That's no
[4:52:58]
near what's needed. And arguing about the phrasing or in one part of the law or not, one
[4:53:06]
other part of the law, it's kind of like the B can't fly. Let's believe what we can actually
[4:53:14]
understand. You so you need more solar acreage, what about the wind? And I think it would be
[4:53:22]
great if you could just keep thinking, how can we do it? And it's kind of that not
[4:53:26]
except that 40% of neutral is neutral.
[4:53:31]
And I wondered, if this was the first time
[4:53:34]
that the city council had heard of this idea
[4:53:37]
of by cow water of doubling the amount of the size
[4:53:42]
of the recycling facility and exchanged for providing
[4:53:47]
portable water.
[4:53:49]
And the impacts of this are really, I have to really
[4:53:51]
think about that.
[4:53:52]
It's that what does it do to the relationship
[4:53:54]
with the SFPUC. What about the added toxic, the doubling I would say of the toxic byproducts
[4:54:01]
of this facility and those exist? You're also putting a facility that produces something toxic
[4:54:10]
on the balance and isn't there a portion of somewhere in the general plan not in JJ which talks
[4:54:16]
about not having facilities that are toxing, producing, toxin producing on that toxic
[4:54:24]
land.
[4:54:25]
I'm not positive of that, but I think that, I recall that from somewhere.
[4:54:30]
And I've been told that the real road isn't allowing the conveyor belt to move over its
[4:54:37]
tracks.
[4:54:38]
And if that's true, then we're going back to 1200 trips a day, and it's impact and congestion,
[4:54:44]
And now on top of the candlestick project,
[4:54:49]
that whole idea of moving it, I don't want it to be impossible, but it seems like it's impossible without significant impacts, either by the trucks or by the inability to figure out how to get the conveyor belt from where the dirt is to where you want the dirt to go.
[4:55:08]
And what would the energy and water needs of the project, if you were to use the environmental
[4:55:16]
these superior alternative, I thought that in an EIR was supposed to compare that was the purpose
[4:55:25]
of the alternatives. But I don't, and it's maybe my problem for not having well-readed well enough,
[4:55:31]
is that where are the impacts, if you were to use that environmentally superior alternative?
[4:55:42]
Claire, do you have more? I'm just kind of figuring out, well I did have the question about
[4:55:48]
if it was the first time that you'd heard about this doubling of the recycling facility.
[4:55:55]
I think that sounds like a question for the another time.
[4:56:00]
subcommittee. Okay, well thank you very much. And that is all I had at this time.
[4:56:04]
I'd different. Thank you. Thank you for different. Okay. So when we do the water section,
[4:56:11]
Clara, we will come back. Come back on that topic. Okay. I have no more speaker cards.
[4:56:20]
City clerk, do we have anybody else online? No more than I don't know about. Okay.
[4:56:26]
On to staff report, topic three, air quality and greenhouse gas impacts and energy impact analysis.
[4:56:34]
Are we going to extend this meeting?
[4:56:37]
We're not at the point yet.
[4:56:39]
Madam, I have two quick questions on this before we move on.
[4:56:43]
And so the third and Thomas, Eddie, steady.
[4:56:47]
Did I get it correct?
[4:56:48]
Yes.
[4:56:50]
Two names.
[4:56:51]
Four ten.
[4:56:52]
Thomas, Eddie.
[4:56:54]
So this is for staff.
[4:56:55]
So that particular study. Was it just accepted or did you challenge the study and make suggestions that then were incorporated into the specific plan?
[4:57:12]
One moment to confer.
[4:57:14]
Council Member Lens, could you clarify again what that study is on?
[4:57:18]
This is the energy generation study that I didn't read.
[4:57:28]
Thank you.
[4:57:34]
I guess this study just calculates energy, I'm not sure that it did you do something like the study came from the developer and
[4:57:48]
staff took the study and said okay thank you very much and then based upon that study then
[4:57:54]
made suggestions in the specific plan or I mean you put information to the specific plan.
[4:58:01]
Well, I guess maybe the technical team can speak to it.
[4:58:05]
It was an input to the modeling that was done
[4:58:07]
for the energy use and the EIR.
[4:58:14]
Yeah, that's correct.
[4:58:15]
It was one of the many documents that went into the models
[4:58:22]
for the models that we used to determine impacts
[4:58:25]
for the various sections in air quality GHD and energy.
[4:58:28]
We did not, yes, they did not peer review.
[4:58:30]
OK, that's where I'm getting at.
[4:58:32]
I'm just wondering if there was peer review
[4:58:33]
that that did not occur not a formal not a formal period. I don't know. Okay. And then
[4:58:43]
yeah, I'll just bring it up here tonight. It's definitely a few of my coming up. You know, when
[4:58:48]
I want to say that that was in the first planning commission workshop maybe it was the second one
[4:58:53]
and you had dressed the planning commission in regards to saying how proud you guys were to do lead
[4:59:02]
gold and then the green point, uh, you know, uh, rated checklist for residential.
[4:59:09]
Um, you know, in the framework, it does talk about,
[4:59:14]
making lead platinum.
[4:59:16]
And I mean, I don't see you said like that was,
[4:59:19]
when you were addressing the, the commission like that,
[4:59:21]
this was the floor and so I see you nodding.
[4:59:23]
I mean, is, is, is platinum something you, you, you were considering.
[4:59:28]
Um, I'm going to have to get back to you on that.
[4:59:30]
Because we did, yeah, and I don't remember the decision the full decision was made, but
[4:59:38]
and we don't have our lead expert here tonight with us, but it's a good question. So the question,
[4:59:46]
just so I'm clear, and we get back to you is, why didn't we, oh, is that any of those,
[4:59:52]
platinum? Yeah, I'm sure we did. Okay. And we'll get back to you on that. Perfect. Thank you so much. Okay,
[4:59:58]
Just those two gentlemen.
[5:00:00]
Okay. So now we're closer to our time, which is 1029, do we wish to extend the meeting?
[5:00:10]
Well, do we wish to finish GHG and air quality? Because I mean, here's my worry. When you start rolling over topics, like the next one is massive.
[5:00:22]
actually don't think that considering how tonight went with the material that we
[5:00:27]
covered tonight and looking at the what is covered in the next one and the
[5:00:33]
amount of material that we're going to have to read to be prepared for that
[5:00:37]
meaning I don't think we're going to make it even through that. So if we're
[5:00:41]
rolling over tonight you start having this domino effect of having, you know, and
[5:00:49]
this not being done in a timely manner. So I would not like to be here longer. However, I think that
[5:00:56]
the trade-off of rolling subjects over and over is going to cause a domino effect that we
[5:01:04]
can't afford. So my suggestion would be to send to 11 and try our best, but I'd really like to just
[5:01:11]
fully wrap up this section so we can move on to the next thing. Since we've extended the meeting twice,
[5:01:18]
Can we extend the meeting to 1130 and if we finish early?
[5:01:23]
We finish early.
[5:01:24]
That's one hour that we've been utilizing each time.
[5:01:27]
Is someone going to make the motion?
[5:01:35]
I make motion.
[5:01:36]
Do I have a second for anyone?
[5:01:39]
I'll second.
[5:01:40]
All in favor?
[5:01:41]
All in favor?
[5:01:41]
I'm going to post?
[5:01:43]
No.
[5:01:43]
OK.
[5:01:46]
Third topic.
[5:01:46]
Air quality and greenhouse gas impacts and energy impact analysis.
[5:01:52]
I'm sorry. Madam Mayor, there's been a request from staff to take. We'll call it a three minute break.
[5:01:57]
Okay. Okay. I get to go for that. Okay. Let's take an end up being five.
[5:10:12]
Do we have everybody back? Yes. OK. Resuming the meeting.
[5:10:20]
So, Madam Mayor, I mean, I know that we took the break and we're going to resume the meeting.
[5:10:27]
You know, it is 1030, you know, just thinking that it's been five hours for the public hearing.
[5:10:34]
We had a close session meeting that was, you know, another hour.
[5:10:38]
And one of the, one of our constituents that left, she said, hey, you know, it's going
[5:10:45]
to be tough for the public to continue this, you know, to stay present as we do this
[5:10:51]
meeting.
[5:10:52]
And I think for our own kind of being able to be on our top of our game that we should stop
[5:11:01]
the meeting now and find and put this at the at the top of our next meeting, even though
[5:11:09]
I know that it's also going to have a lot of, you know, heavy in the subject matter.
[5:11:19]
Tell us, remember, Kern, your thoughts?
[5:11:23]
I don't disagree at it's getting late, but I guess to staff.
[5:11:29]
So we have communicated to the public that we are going to do sessions, five sessions and
[5:11:33]
We've chunked out the topics.
[5:11:35]
What do we need to do from a flexibility standpoint is we started justing as we're moving
[5:11:40]
forward on this.
[5:11:41]
Is there certain notices that we have to give, is there a certain process that we need
[5:11:45]
to follow, can we add sessions, what's the notice to add a session, et cetera, how does
[5:11:50]
it work?
[5:11:51]
Julie, is that you?
[5:12:03]
We can add a session.
[5:12:07]
Thank you.
[5:12:13]
So we've noticed this is a special meeting, you have, we anticipate it and what we communicated
[5:12:20]
with the public was that you'd be continuing to date certain, as long as you're allowed
[5:12:27]
to do that without re-noticing the meeting through any sort of formal legal process, we
[5:12:32]
can certainly do outreach to make sure people know about it, but you have the flexibility
[5:12:36]
to decide when to continue it and and how to do that. As long as you continue it to a time
[5:12:44]
and date certain before you adjourn to me.
[5:12:48]
It's all one public hearing and it can take you,
[5:12:52]
you could have wrapped it up in two hours tonight. It could take you 24 more meetings. It's one public
[5:12:58]
hearing if you continue to at the end of the hearing, continue it. I wouldn't recommend 24.
[5:13:03]
I heard that a little bit of tone there.
[5:13:07]
So my next question on that same topic here,
[5:13:09]
a very process oriented.
[5:13:11]
So do we to come from our mayor
[5:13:13]
program Davis's question about the next meeting
[5:13:15]
being very content heavy?
[5:13:18]
Should we be evaluating that meeting now currently
[5:13:21]
knowing that we might be moving the air quality
[5:13:23]
and greenhouse gas topic to that meeting?
[5:13:26]
Let me tell you what's on that meeting.
[5:13:27]
Land use plan, location of open spaces and amenities.
[5:13:32]
Interface with sea level rise, design topics, objected standards and design guidelines, the roundhouse,
[5:13:38]
mobility plan, which underneath mobility plan is street sections,
[5:13:42]
interface with regional transportation network and Geneva Avenue extension.
[5:13:46]
That's one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine subjects.
[5:13:52]
We have this, we've done two tonight.
[5:13:54]
There is no way we're going to make it through the next one.
[5:13:57]
If you roll this one into the next one, you're going to get way more comments.
[5:14:01]
Not that's the comments, not that we don't have time for comments, but that room now is going to be packed with people who are there for other items that are now going to start talking about this because they're already there in the room.
[5:14:16]
I have two questions for GHG slash air quality.
[5:14:20]
I don't know what everyone else has. There's only a few members of the public. I think maybe we can get it done in like 20 minutes.
[5:14:25]
But like that already the next one is already probably two meetings. I think we should actually look at it now and scale it down now.
[5:14:34]
There's no way we're getting through that if we're doing the same structure. So, like we're already falling off of our schedule immediately.
[5:14:44]
If I may, if I may with the slips, I believe Anthony Walker left and Linda Salmon left. I have three slips and those people are here.
[5:14:54]
So maybe we should just prioritize public comment first.
[5:15:00]
I spoke. What do you need to do to?
[5:15:10]
I think that at this point staff and myself and I'm not sure about the members of the audience have sort of reached their limit on how much information you can absorb and what's reality on playing back the meeting and watching it or getting constructive use out of it.
[5:15:30]
But I'll go either way.
[5:15:32]
I mean,
[5:15:36]
I think we've passed our real useful limit
[5:15:40]
for getting public participation
[5:15:42]
when the room has cleared out,
[5:15:45]
except for 90% staff.
[5:15:48]
So we could make a suggestion
[5:15:50]
that the Bayland subcommittee convened with staff
[5:15:54]
on how to structure the next meeting,
[5:15:59]
which is on September 29th.
[5:16:04]
I believe.
[5:16:06]
Yeah.
[5:16:07]
We could do that.
[5:16:08]
We do have a meeting with the subcommittee scheduled this week.
[5:16:13]
And they could discuss the topics and come up with a proposal for how to publicize what
[5:16:22]
will be covered at the next meeting.
[5:16:23]
We could hold on to these slips if we're rolling over.
[5:16:27]
Sure.
[5:16:30]
Be happy to do that.
[5:16:31]
I don't believe rolling this over is going to be a super, super, super long part of the next meeting.
[5:16:39]
But I echo Mayor Protem's concerns about how many items are on that next meeting.
[5:16:46]
I think it's ambitious and we're very ambitious, but perhaps the attention span would not be what we want.
[5:16:55]
and the same with the public, we want the public participation and it's obvious that there's only so much people can handle.
[5:17:04]
Well, there's also so much overlap that a lot of topics got discussed tonight by people that may want to talk about them again.
[5:17:14]
And a lot of my questions, almost all my questions were not on this particular subject matter.
[5:17:20]
some of it had some overlap, but I think that we're going to continue to have that overlap
[5:17:25]
and have people asking questions that are not on that topic group.
[5:17:30]
And I would just say as a comment, my own comments, sorry, I won't go on and on.
[5:17:34]
I think this has been very productive because the public is getting the answers, the developer.
[5:17:39]
I've been very gracious answering those questions, so it's kind of promoting the type of
[5:17:45]
a poor that we want so that we we understand what the public's asking, what the developer
[5:17:51]
responds to and having staff. So that being said,
[5:17:59]
we want to make sure that everybody's
[5:18:00]
really engaged when they're here from the public to staff to us as well.
[5:18:05]
Correct. It's about quality. Yeah. Yeah. So I would ask for then perhaps a motion, we would
[5:18:15]
Can you this to September 29 with the idea that we will do greenhouse gases the next meeting?
[5:18:24]
Could I have a motion?
[5:18:26]
I'll make a motion to extend the meeting to September 29 and also to look at the possibility
[5:18:33]
of scheduling an additional meeting in a reasonable timeframe after that to catch up.
[5:18:40]
Do I have a second?
[5:18:43]
All in favor, if I may sorry before the vote, I just want to clarify that the motion was to continue the public hearing until September 29, yes?
[5:18:52]
Great.
[5:18:53]
Very good.
[5:18:53]
Yes.
[5:18:55]
I know it's late.
[5:18:56]
Thank you.
[5:18:57]
Continue the public meeting to September 29.
[5:19:01]
At 530.
[5:19:03]
At 530.
[5:19:03]
At 530.
[5:19:05]
Very good.
[5:19:05]
Okay.
[5:19:06]
All in favor.
[5:19:07]
Hi.
[5:19:08]
Anyone opposed? No. Okay. Thank you everyone. You are heroes. Your diligence. Thank you so much