City Council Special Meeting

Brisbane, CA · · More Brisbane, CA meetings · More California meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[5:43] Thank you, City Clerk. You are seated at the City Council, special meeting of October 6, 2026. This is also
[5:53] Baylands Public Hearing Number 3, calling the meeting to order at 5.33pm. Would you join me in the
[6:19] City Clerk, roll call, please.
[6:22] Council member Davis.
[6:25] Council member Kern.
[6:26] Here.
[6:27] Council member Lens.
[6:29] Council member O'Connell.
[6:30] Here.
[6:30] And Mayor Mackin.
[6:31] I am here.
[6:33] Can I get a first and second to adopt the agenda
[6:35] as it stands, please?
[6:37] So moved.
[6:38] Second.
[6:39] All in favor.
[6:41] The one opposed.
[6:42] Motion carries.
[6:44] This is a continuation of the public hearing series.
[6:48] So we don't need to open a public hearing.
[6:52] And we welcome the public to comment or ask questions during tonight's hearing.
[6:57] Please, please, please, please. You must fill out a form.
[7:00] There are on the chairs. You can also get one from our city clerk.
[7:03] Speakers will have four minutes for each topic.
[7:06] There's a timer on the screen that you can use for references you speak.
[7:10] And I will add, it's extremely important for speakers to stay on topic.
[7:16] if you don't stay on top, I will stop you.
[7:19] We've had some meandering and I've kind of let everybody
[7:22] meander, but please, please, try to stay on top.
[7:28] If a speaker continues to ignore the rules,
[7:30] You'll be warned. You may be precluded from speaking on any other items tonight. So internally, the council, we've had some feedback and from the public about the two public hearings today, we're always trying to make things better.
[7:45] And I'd like to have a short discussion about the meetings.
[7:49] And I'd like to start about the meeting schedule.
[7:53] I'll call on each council member.
[7:55] I'd like to hear your feedback on how this is going for you,
[7:59] whether the schedule works, any feedback that you have,
[8:04] I think would be helpful.
[8:05] Starting with council member current.
[8:09] Schedules acceptable to me, and no other feedback at this time.
[8:13] Mayor Pro Tim, Davis.
[8:19] Well,
[8:21] I definitely think it's been a heavy lift to have the intensity of meetings that we've had, for example, we had a week where we had a hearing on a Tuesday, a council meeting on a Thursday and then another hearing on Tuesday, and so it's not much time in between to prepare and read the level of documents that we need to read.
[8:45] Um, that being said, you know, I'm cognizant of the fact that we want to get this adopted
[8:53] and come into compliance with what HCD expects of us so we can get our housing element
[9:00] research applied. So I'm really amenable to grinding and getting it done. Um, so I see a,
[9:11] I see challenges with the current schedule but I also see challenges in slowing things down and the ramifications that that could have so.
[9:24] Okay.
[9:24] The council member Lens.
[9:26] Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor.
[9:29] So yeah, I grew with you, Madison, that one week where we had a hearing on a Tuesday and then a council meeting on Thursday was pretty rough.
[9:39] There's also other meetings that we have, and you only add it all up.
[9:45] It makes it difficult to be at your best to provide the quality to the community.
[9:55] But there's also the community being able to participate.
[9:59] And there's a lot of information in these documents to read.
[10:04] People do their their research outside of what's in these documents
[10:10] I mean these are these are public hearings. They're called a public here for reason. So
[10:18] You know, I would like for us to
[10:21] space the meetings a little bit better. I know that the next hearing is on the 15th and then we come back on the 19th and
[10:32] I would prefer maybe
[10:34] Not have that meeting on the 19th, maybe make it if we can later in the week just with that we have more time.
[10:43] I think if we're continuing to make progress
[10:46] that we're respecting the process
[10:50] that if we finish some time in the near future, that we will be okay in regards to HCD.
[11:01] Council Member O'Connell?
[11:07] I'm happy with the schedule as it is.
[11:08] And I've cleared my schedule to make room for it.
[11:13] Okay, thank you.
[11:17] So I'm going to point out just a couple of facts
[11:19] because I get the emails and phone calls from everybody.
[11:23] I'm the complaint department.
[11:26] From October 6th to the 15th meeting was eight days.
[11:30] If you take away two weekends, it was six days
[11:33] between meetings.
[11:33] From the 15th to the 20th, I'm sorry it's the 20th, not the 19th answer, is 4 days.
[11:42] Take away the weekend, those meetings are 2 days apart.
[11:46] From the 20th to the 26th is 5 days. Take away the 2 weekend days, it's 3 days between those public hearings.
[11:55] Then we have a little bit more time between the 26th and November 9th,
[12:00] 13 days, but the reality with the two days on the weekend is nine business days.
[12:06] I'm very concerned about my capacity,
[12:10] capacity of staff. I really have a great deal of respect for all my colleagues going, yeah, let's let's go for it.
[12:18] But I'm also concerned about public participation. Are you really all going to show up every three, four, five days?
[12:25] And I haven't had a weekend often months, so my capacity to be on top of material and being prepared for these meetings is diminishing.
[12:37] And I feel irresponsible because of that.
[12:40] I don't think that that's a good participation.
[12:46] And so I don't know, maybe we should also hear from staff,
[12:53] I think on some of these, having
[12:55] two days or three days, between meetings is unacceptable.
[13:00] I do not expect the public to show up that where they're coming every week, three days.
[13:05] Oh, I need to go to that public hearing, and I want all of you here.
[13:09] This is your community, this is your plan, this is your future.
[13:13] And we want to make it right, and I don't even see how the property owners agents here can prepare where they're asked questions and they have to come back with some research and some answers.
[13:25] We all want to make this something that we can be proud of.
[13:31] So that's my two cents. Any comments?
[13:36] Staff, comments?
[13:38] City manager?
[13:41] Thank you.
[13:42] What I've gleaned from the conversation this evening is we continue to move forward.
[13:47] There may be some opportunities to do some late movement of meetings particularly later in the year that excuse me later in the month.
[13:58] So that doesn't affect.
[14:00] So we don't have meetings for five days apart.
[14:02] So we'll take a look at that.
[14:03] That's what I've understood tonight.
[14:04] Thank you.
[14:06] The other topic is the duration of the meetings and of her near full on this.
[14:12] So part of our Gungho Gusto of the Council and the staff is, by God, if we're here to
[14:19] midnight, we need to do it.
[14:22] And then I get the speaker slips and people are sitting here till 9, 9, 9, 30, 10 p.m.
[14:29] And then I see people just leaving and discussed because they filled out, they sat here all
[14:35] they never got a chance to talk. So do we really want to keep going till 10 o'clock at night and keep extending the meeting or do we want to set a hard stop and just say we get done?
[14:46] What we get done because also with the public doesn't realize is sometimes the council has a short meeting before this.
[14:53] So we're here for five, six hours straight by the time it hits nine o'clock. We're really toast. It's hard.
[15:00] It's very, very hard. Not to mention, all the hours you had the day, days before, two, three days between the meetings, and I've had lots of 4am nights getting up the next morning too.
[15:12] So, what about the timing? Council member Kern, duration of the meeting, what time would you stop the meeting?
[15:19] Please rotate your questions. Thank you.
[15:23] Rotate the questions. Oh, you don't want to be first.
[15:26] Rotate the questions, please. Thank you.
[15:28] Oh, okay.
[15:29] I found some member O'Connell.
[15:31] For me, it really depends on the subject and how involved the community is and whether
[15:36] we're reaching breaking point when we've had a two-hour meeting before, but I'm happy to
[15:45] try to stay within the timeframe and try to limit the amount of intercourse that we have
[15:50] on the dius and with staff and try to be as mindful as we can of the time.
[15:55] So when you say, stay the course, what does that mean in terms of how late we go?
[16:03] I think it really depends on the evening and how the audience still is and how involved we can be.
[16:12] I'm not going to say 9 o'clock and we're done no matter what.
[16:15] I think that sometimes it is imperative that we keep going with a conversation.
[16:21] And so I would rather try to stop on time.
[16:25] But if warranted, I don't mind extending the meeting
[16:29] a little bit.
[16:30] OK, Council Member Lens?
[16:32] Yeah, and I feel the same way if we can keep the meeting
[16:37] within that three hour window that we put out to the public.
[16:41] I think that's ideal.
[16:44] I think it would be mindful of that.
[16:46] But as you're saying, Council Member McConnell,
[16:48] You get into the heat of the matter, you're on a roll, you don't want to cut something off and then have to finish at the next meeting.
[17:01] So, extending the meeting for a little bit is fine, extending the meeting say over an hour to two hours.
[17:08] I think that is excessive and we should not do that.
[17:12] So if I may ask you for a clarification, you said three hour window, that's eight thirty.
[17:17] It is a theory and that's what we publish,
[17:22] publicize, is a three hour meeting.
[17:25] Obviously, it's the council's pleasure to extend the meeting
[17:28] and we've done it many times.
[17:31] And I think when it's appropriate, we should extend it,
[17:35] but not extend it because we can
[17:37] and have it be longer than what the public is anticipating.
[17:45] Okay.
[17:46] We are pro-tum.
[17:50] Well, we intentionally started the meetings at 5.30, knowing that they would probably take
[17:57] more than three hours.
[17:59] We always publish a meeting as being three hours.
[18:02] That's always our intention with council meetings too.
[18:05] I think it's perfectly fine to go till 9 or 9.30.
[18:09] We used to have our council meetings started 7.30, and we would go to 9.30, like, no problem.
[18:13] But I am cognizant of the fact that there are people here that want to speak, and they, you know, last time they waited several hours.
[18:22] So I'm amenable to letting the public go first and ask questions if there are questions that they have right off the bat.
[18:29] I think that's fine.
[18:32] And, but I know some people really, they are inspired with questions based on the exchange that council has with staff.
[18:39] So there's, you know, you would be getting less of that, but this conversation alone is probably taking
[18:49] this 20 minutes of this meeting. So I wouldn't, I don't think that we need to say right now that there's a
[18:55] hard and fast rule on how long it takes. I think it's really imperative that we move through this material
[19:01] at a steady pace and there is a challenge to balance, you know, the intensity of the material
[19:12] and, you know, the time frame that we have to really get this finish. So I'm, you know,
[19:18] I'm aware that there are constraints there, but we just need to get a moving.
[19:25] Okay, and I will point out that this conversation was requested by the council for tonight.
[19:31] So, if it's 20 minutes or 30 minutes, you requested it.
[19:34] That's why we're doing it.
[19:36] Council member current.
[19:37] So, only 18 minutes.
[19:41] I feel that we have a tremendous task in front of us in a large body of work.
[19:46] And it has been chunked out in fairly reasonable chunks.
[19:49] I agree.
[19:49] These are big chunks.
[19:51] I think we need to stop once we delivered a product
[19:54] instead of carrying something in part to the next meeting,
[19:57] carried in a hole to the next meeting because we're having people join us from the public believing
[20:02] that they're going to be participating on a particular topic. So, you know, like the last meeting
[20:07] we're carrying over some questions and we already got some questions and I think that that's just
[20:12] sort of money's the water. So I think clean breaks are very important, topically speaking.
[20:17] Thank you. Yeah, I would agree with you, Councilmember Kernt. So I think from my point of view
[20:23] when we hit 930 as a regular council meeting.
[20:27] That's kind of about where we start seeing the exit
[20:30] door opening up and people leaving.
[20:33] Because I know some of you get up at 5, 6, 7 AM.
[20:36] You may have to go to work.
[20:38] It's tough.
[20:40] All right.
[20:41] So you have all their email addresses
[20:43] and the city manager, please send your comments.
[20:48] We've also had numerous requests from the public
[20:50] to have an opportunity to speak in general
[20:52] about the Baylands Public Hearing. Since since we don't have an oral communications
[20:56] on the agenda for these hearings, I'm going to allow some general comments before we start this
[21:02] meeting. Please fill out a speaker card handed to the city clerk in order to be recognized.
[21:08] These are not dealing with tonight's topic just in general. Anyone have general comments?
[21:18] Clark.
[21:24] Thank you, Madam Mayor. City Council. Kind of weird being on this side of the
[21:30] dias, actually, you know, I found through the years I'm a better listener than I am
[21:34] a speaker. So I wrote down what I want to talk about. So when I served on this
[21:42] Council, I often felt that when it came to the baylands that there was a gun
[21:46] our head. There was the enormous pressure to reach an agreement and Madison, you'll remember
[21:53] in former Senator Jerry's Hill's office that you and I were there and it was very short of
[21:59] chair throwing and that was due to a draft of threat of a draft legislation pressure for development
[22:09] and there were very real concerns there about what could happen. It was being did not find its own
[22:15] forward. Measure J.J. was negotiated in that atmosphere. It was accepted by
[22:22] those state legislators who threatened us with the draft legislation and you know who
[22:29] they are.
[22:30] It was the Senator Jerry Hill, Senator Scott Weiner, and our own, now City Attorney of San Francisco, David Chu, Philetean, and Kevin Mullin, our now congressperson.
[22:54] Yeah, can you move closer to the mic there having trouble hearing you? Can you hear it okay now? Is that good?
[23:00] All right, anyway, but whatever pressures existed in, measured J.J. became something much
[23:08] more important.
[23:09] It became our promise to the people of Brisbane.
[23:12] We asked our residents to accept housing on the baylands and we told them what protections
[23:17] would accompany that development, and the voters trusted us.
[23:23] They approved measured J.J., and that boat matters.
[23:26] I'm not here tonight to undo it, and I'm not asking the Council to reconsider whether there
[23:32] should be housing on the baylands.
[23:34] The voters made that decision and measure J.J. and its housing provisions are now the
[23:39] law in Brisbane.
[23:41] But the rest of measure J.J. matters just as much.
[23:44] The housing was not just the only promise we made.
[23:48] We promised that the site would be fully remediated and safe, especially for the housing
[23:53] and that no soil would be moved without testing to the city standards.
[23:59] We promised a reliable water supply would be secured before development and a city
[24:04] would prohibit use of our limited water, which is about 1 million gallons a day and I'm
[24:09] pretty sure that that's all used up with the recent development of Sierra Point.
[24:17] We promised enforceable schedules for landfill closure with real consequences if those schedules
[24:23] were not met in financial guarantees if they were delayed or stopped.
[24:28] We promised energy neutrals sustainable development as a beacon of what the future
[24:33] can be.
[24:34] We promised that the development would provide a net fiscal benefit to brisbanding every
[24:39] year.
[24:40] And we promised this specific plan for the entire baylands that would put those protections
[24:48] into effect.
[24:49] And I'll give this to the city clerk when I'm done.
[24:54] Those were not side issues.
[24:56] Those were just part of a bargain we presented to the voters.
[25:01] And along with myself and three of you who are currently there
[25:04] and had a mayor, you were on the Planning Commission
[25:07] and former mayor, Karen Cunningham,
[25:11] was the city council at the time.
[25:15] Looking at this plan, I do not see those questions
[25:18] answered in a way that gives me the confidence that all of measure J.J. is being implemented.
[25:24] Too many important matters appear to remain unresolved, deferred to later agreements,
[25:31] later studies, later financing plans, or later decisions. The meeting schedule, which I'm glad
[25:37] that you talked about at the beginning, but the meeting schedule that you currently have seems to
[25:41] aggressive to adequately address these issues. I know the pressures facing this council
[25:48] are substantial. I remember those pressures very well. But measure JJ should not be viewed
[25:55] as an obstacle that the city needs to work around. Measure JJ should be the city's roadmap.
[26:03] Before approving this specific plan, I asked you to take our questions and the public questions
[26:11] and answer each one clearly.
[26:14] If those answers are not in the plan today,
[26:17] put them in there before you approve it.
[26:19] The voters kept their part of the bargain.
[26:22] Now, it is our responsibility to keep ours.
[26:26] And most importantly, show us our choices.
[26:31] The EIR Analyze analyzes seven alternatives,
[26:35] yet most of what the public has been formally presented
[26:38] is the planned staff recommends. There should be a presentation of all seven alternatives set
[26:45] forth in EIR. There are real choices there. Staff recommended the EIR alternative plan that
[26:52] has 2,200 homes and 6,5 million square feet of commercial. But the public should be presented
[26:59] with all seven alternatives, especially number seven with its reduced density and lower maximum
[27:07] building heights. Alternative 7 is found by the EIR to be environmentally superior alternative.
[27:15] It is 400 fewer homes and 200 million square feet less the commercial and eight stories
[27:22] residential instead of 20 to 22 story towers. Remember the Geneva towers,
[27:29] Ikeler wonder.
[27:31] That's what it reminds me of. Okay, those are very different visions of
[27:35] being. I'm not standing here to say which one is right. I'm standing. I'm saying show all seven
[27:41] alternatives fully to you, the council, and to the public. This is about the future of Brisbane.
[27:49] Then as we move forward, we still have to keep the promises under JJ, a reliable water supply,
[27:55] not using our Brisbane water, a final landfill closure and responsibility adherence to our
[28:01] sustainability framework, phased and required infrastructure that keeps pace with development,
[28:09] financial protections, and the city, and its current and future residents.
[28:17] In clear accountability, so Brisbane is never left holding the back.
[28:23] They are intended to make
[28:24] sure that when development comes, we build the Brisbane, we promised our voters, we would build.
[28:30] I know the pressure you are under, I really felt it and I know you're feeling it now, but
[28:37] when we face pressure before we trusted the people in Brisbane and we put Measure JJ before
[28:43] them, they understood the difficult choices and together we found a way forward.
[28:48] That was accepted by our legislators.
[28:51] We can do that again.
[28:53] Share this decision with the community, uphold Measure JJ, show Brisbane, the choices,
[28:58] trust the community to be part of the solution. We found a way forward together once, and I believe we can and will do it together again.
[29:08] Thank you very much for allowing me to speak.
[29:15] Anybody else? General comments.
[29:18] Karen, can you hand them down next?
[29:23] Good evening Madam Mayor and City Council and everybody who's here, especially our residents.
[29:32] I have a bunch of questions from last week that we didn't get to because it was ten o'clock
[29:38] and I had to follow over and leave.
[29:41] So what do I do with those questions?
[29:42] That's my just think about that for a second.
[29:45] Anyway, thank you, Clark, for what you said.
[29:50] That was part of what I was going to speak with you about last week.
[29:54] I was on the planning commission when the turbulent times of measure J.J.
[30:00] First arrived on the scene. I was dragged off the planning commission right after being voted before I was even put on the dice and taken into those closed session meetings. To say this was turbulent times in Brisbane is an understatement of epic proportions. This was one of the most painful things I've ever had to witness and be part of in my entire life. So to think that we are up against some more obstacles at this point is an understatement.
[30:32] However,
[30:35] the people did agree to vote on Measure J.J. based on the promises that we made them.
[30:43] And what we need to do is we need to act swiftly, but with the precision of a brain surgeon to get through this,
[30:54] and to get through it in the way that the people of Brisbane voted for.
[30:58] The goal is pretty simple, a strongest specific plan says that what it means and means what it says.
[31:05] And we need to faithfully carry Measure JJ forward. We need to strengthen the specific plan.
[31:11] Close the gaps, remove the ambiguities, and make sure that there are no holes in any protections that the voters adopted in Measure JJ.
[31:24] The rest of it is things that I didn't get to say last week, so we'll figure out when I can probably say those.
[31:31] And just want to say, none of this was aspirational.
[31:35] I see that written down, and it makes me absolutely crazy.
[31:39] None of it was aspirational.
[31:41] This was very prescriptive.
[31:43] The people spoke, and they said, what they wanted, and we need to deliver that.
[31:47] Thank you.
[31:48] Thank you.
[31:49] Oh, City Clerk. I didn't catch who's the other one. We have Dan, Michelle Salman, Glenn or Dan. Dan again. Okay. Michelle Salman, Michael Barnes and then Linda Salman. Okay. Dan.
[32:08] Thanks for letting me come speak. My name is Dan Griffiths. I'm a resident of Brisbane. I've lived here about three years.
[32:17] I also run theater just over the line in San Francisco across from the Baylands Project site.
[32:31] I'm supportive of developing this part of the city.
[32:35] I think it's a great idea.
[32:38] I know it has a lot of clunky things that have to be dealt with,
[32:42] but the other parts of the Bay, along the Bay, have been developed pretty great.
[32:48] I don't think any of those are destroying people's lives or anything, but I think it would
[32:57] be nice to be able to get up from here and ride a bicycle and drive down a visitation valley
[33:03] where I used to live.
[33:05] When I lived in this valley I'd kind of haunted Brisbane all the time for some reason I'm
[33:09] drawn to this place and I want to live here I think it's amazing and I think having
[33:14] I go down to the train town all the time and walk down to with my daughter and stuff
[33:18] if there was a bike path through there,
[33:20] that's an undeveloped, like, amazing part of Brisbane.
[33:23] Lots of other places have, like, paths and things
[33:26] that, you know, do cool stuff.
[33:28] Like, we need more cool stuff on this part
[33:30] of the larger bay area.
[33:32] Like, they can't just be over there's
[33:35] the biz valley in Brisbane and the dump, you know,
[33:38] we need to really consider that we could develop it.
[33:42] Because it brings arcs this way
[33:44] And we can have arts that come into also Brisbane from San Francisco and the other way around.
[33:52] It's kind of nice to, when I first moved to, I thought, oh no, is this place complete,
[33:57] the isolated, but then I kind of found out both of my worlds are connected to the other
[34:01] through this project.
[34:04] And I love Brisbane.
[34:06] It's a great place.
[34:06] I mean, if I could buy 10 houses here, I would, but I, you know, I rent here.
[34:11] I'm not even a property owner, but I go to all the businesses here and I watch the hardware store
[34:17] clothes and I watch the foot traffic dwindle and no matter how many events you throw in the
[34:22] park that's not going to bring enough people to keep the businesses open. So then when you're
[34:26] going to be, you're going to be like a bedroom community with no businesses in it. And if you can't
[34:31] sustain those businesses, it's not going to work out. So having arts and different things moving
[34:36] from both places. We need to be kind of more connected. I'm looking forward to learning everything
[34:43] I can find out about this project because it's newer to me. I don't know the ins and
[34:47] outs of it. I certainly haven't been around as long as some of the people thinking about
[34:54] the environmental impact. I know that there is one. I know that there's soil there that needs to
[35:00] be removed. Now that I know that I'm probably not going to go creep around in there anymore,
[35:06] I've been going down there and walking around, I went to the train station, I just recently
[35:10] found out it's where they used to repair trains.
[35:12] Like that's amazing.
[35:13] If part of that could be there, across from seven miles, it would change this whole into
[35:19] the city.
[35:20] San Francisco has whole maps that don't even have visitation valley on them and that's one of
[35:27] their actual neighborhoods, right?
[35:29] They just are like whatever.
[35:31] It's not on the, like, maps that you can buy in the tourist areas of the city.
[35:36] Brisbane, nobody knows that's here.
[35:38] It's a secret place.
[35:40] And I know that that's cool, and it protects everything, but it has to be, you know, brought together.
[35:46] But thank you. I don't want to go too long.
[35:47] Okay. Thank you.
[35:49] Michael Barnes?
[35:50] I thought it was mine.
[35:51] Is it Michelle?
[35:52] Michelle?
[35:53] Michelle?
[35:53] Michelle?
[35:54] Michelle, it is you.
[35:57] I was paying attention to the order because it was my suggestion.
[36:01] I was a chair for no-one measure JJ and it was very difficult to do that because I was in
[36:08] disagreement with some of my best friends but I went to every house and talked to have people
[36:15] and measure JJ one by ten percent and there we are and I have an extremely high expectation
[36:24] of the city, the council, the leaders, honoring everything that Mr. J.J. states.
[36:33] Thank you, Clark, for what you said. I mean, it was a tough thing. I mean, Clark's been
[36:37] my one of my best expenses kindergarten, and we were like this over Terry. You, you know,
[36:45] because I didn't agree with the state and the county and the city bullying us about housing
[36:51] on the site, this toxic, and that was my number one concern, and it still is my number one concern,
[36:59] and I wish this room had been packed last night to hear the representatives from DTSC and Regional
[37:05] Water Quality Control Board. Talk about where we are now, how much further we have to go,
[37:11] the things that have not been examined, the things in the dump it was mostly they did it by historical
[37:17] records manifest, they trust those. You know, it's a little scary. It is scary. What we're about to do. And I do think we should ratchet back and do alternative seven the least amount of impact.
[37:30] I don't think we should take to the max. And it's going to be probably, you know, my lifetime will probably be over by the time that this is actually built, being built.
[37:40] But we have a responsibility to the future. And that's what I'm really concerned about. So please do your very best work. And one of the things that we could do to make these meetings shorter, I spent months and months reading the first program EIR, then the first draft EIR on the specific plan and the first specific plan and the second specific plan.
[37:59] second. I know it's a lot of work. I've read it all, you know, and all along, I
[38:07] have saying, I hope you guys are reading it. I hope you guys are looking at it. I mean,
[38:11] Cliff, the last meeting spent a total of over an hour, an hour, an hour to an hour and a half,
[38:17] speaking, just you. Okay, that's really hard for especially for people who have already read it
[38:23] and are familiar with it. And we want to get on and talk about the things that are unresolved. And so
[38:28] I will be here. I will be here to the best of my ability to participate. But I hope that you all,
[38:34] you know, do your homework and that you go back and watch last night's meeting if you weren't here in
[38:38] person. Thank you very much. It is available. Thank you, Carolyn. She had to walk me through making
[38:42] seeing where it was available. Thank you. Michelle is referring to BBK ahead of meeting last night with
[38:49] DTSC and Regional Water Quality Control Board. And it is, I believe, on the city website for anyone who'd
[38:55] to watch the broadcast.
[38:57] Michael Barnes.
[39:05] Even in the Bayer Council, my name is Michael Barnes.
[39:08] I've been busy and resident in 2008.
[39:12] I think I was sitting in that chair right there
[39:14] when I came out in favor of housing on the baylands.
[39:17] That was a decade before Measure J.J. was passed.
[39:19] Because I couldn't figure out where
[39:21] those people who would work out there would live.
[39:26] Then more recently, you got a head of a proposal
[39:28] to buy a water from Merced.
[39:31] And I believe that fell apart because you couldn't
[39:32] to figure out a way to transfer the water from or said to Brisbane.
[39:36] But if you go to the state of California and ask them to pressure these intervening agencies,
[39:42] if the water is still available, I'm sure the state of California understands that there is no housing without water.
[39:48] You may try to work with the legislature rather than against it.
[39:56] And finally, I proposed the fiscal analysis of the Bayoland's project when I was in the city council because you can't do this in and in
[40:05] Sequa, we just went outside of it and made a requirement that the Bayoland's project would benefit Brisbane fiscal and wouldn't bankrupt us and I think that's part of Major JJ too.
[40:15] I really think that Major JJ is important as Clark has said and it also talks about energy neutrality and I agree with the analysis of one of the other residents.
[40:26] to present that it doesn't seem to be energy neutral right now.
[40:30] Thank you.
[40:31] Thank you.
[40:31] And the last one is, Linda's an innocent,
[40:44] dear honored and
[40:45] beleaguered counsel.
[40:47] It's amazing that we're finally doing this talking about the overall
[40:52] what, what, I'm sorry, I've seen a little machine down here, what's
[40:56] happening here.
[41:00] And I was on the, on the, on the planning commission that wrote
[41:05] the 1994 General Plan, most of which is still kind of hanging out, which gave the
[41:11] context, some quest owners an incredible capacity to build something that was marvelous
[41:19] in terms of the FARs.
[41:22] And they came back eventually with a designer and architect.
[41:27] I don't remember his name, I've asked staff a couple times what his name was, but the whole
[41:33] of the city of Brisbane loved it and said yes, let's do it and it was like, you know,
[41:38] just one one one one huge building that had space for art and events and things like that.
[41:45] And then it was taken away because everybody was pushing or we have to have houses houses.
[41:54] There's a difference between housing like what is being offered right now and I would call them
[42:02] Welling units, apartments, things that working people can afford.
[42:08] If Pegasus people were concerned about wealth, we have businesses out here, we're not
[42:13] going to have dwelling units for all the people who are going to work there and transit.
[42:17] People who have lots and lots of money who want to buy fancy houses don't take public
[42:23] transit.
[42:24] They all have cars, several of them, so that's one issue, there's a lot of issues.
[42:29] There are other alternatives to the one we're looking at right now, which somehow, and I don't know what to say about it.
[42:39] I know Council's gone to one direction because of whatever has been recommended, but I'm not sure if that's really the best and safest things for us.
[42:47] we have unknown toxic on this area. We have an incomplete EIR that we're being asked to
[42:56] certify all for pressures for more and more houses. Brisbane is a very small town and now we're
[43:05] being asked to become again a more big, huge city. California is trying to wipe out small towns.
[43:11] We've already lost our central valley to suburbia.
[43:16] California does not have enough water
[43:19] to have the housing we have right now.
[43:22] I don't know where they think they're gonna get this water.
[43:24] I mean, Colorado River is a drier for L.A.
[43:28] I mean, really, we have other issues.
[43:30] I environmental issues.
[43:32] This is a very, very fragile economy economy, I shouldn't say.
[43:36] I should say, place to live
[43:39] in terms of rising sea levels,
[43:42] liquefaction, earthquakes, fires, et cetera.
[43:48] To ask us to put fancy homes on a five foot clay cap
[43:53] that I just learned last yesterday, last night,
[43:57] it's not going to be clean clay, but it's going to be stuff that's already there.
[44:03] The natural fill in the area of which is largely contaminated and they said we're going to clean it up and we're not going to use the stuff that's contaminated
[44:13] We'll be able to sort it out maybe more or less
[44:17] It's not good enough. It's really not good enough. A five foot clay cap and you're going to build fancy houses on it and you're showing the pictures of trees and gardens
[44:26] Doesn't work. What about the wetlands? The job of the wetlands is to absorb rising sea
[44:34] levels and floods. That is what we have had here protecting our little hamlet, our
[44:42] little city. One of the reasons why we're kind of up above the sea level more or less, but
[44:48] even right here right now where we are was marshland when I was a child. People don't seem
[44:54] realized. Of course we are. One of the reasons that the old county road is the shape it is.
[45:00] Is that was the shoreline?
[45:03] I'm going to be 78 years old. That wasn't that long ago. Do you think Mother Nature will have a hand and what we're going to do? Are we going to defy Mother Nature and try and do something that's not going to be safe? Who's going to be responsible?
[45:21] We need to have more public input, I feel than what we had. We've been silenced. You get a chance to talk and then you're hush.
[45:30] And my view, the owner, has no intention whatsoever to do anything with this property.
[45:37] They simply want the permits so they can sell it for more money.
[45:43] I would suggest that any permits we give, any agreement we give, any okay to any kind
[45:48] of a specific plan is limited to that owner only period.
[45:54] No more stuff like we had on the Northeast Ridge with Crockerland immediately selling things to Brookfield who ignored everything that we were supposed to do there.
[46:06] I say be careful, don't do it, okay? So if we do find a come to an inclusion for a decent safe jump specific plan for this area, it's only for this owner.
[46:21] If somebody else wants to buy it and come in, they can start over again.
[46:26] I don't know if you realize the financing, how they're planning to do it,
[46:30] but it's not very sturdy.
[46:34] Warning.
[46:36] Again.
[46:38] Okay, thank you.
[46:41] All right, we're moving back into our topics.
[46:44] So the last public hearing on September 29th, we adjourn the meeting.
[46:48] Some Council members still had questions for staff on the topic we were on land use and plan designs.
[46:56] That encompasses the following sub-topics, distribution and intensity of land uses,
[47:03] location of open spaces and amenities, interface with sea level rise.
[47:08] And the second topic from the last meeting was design topics,
[47:13] which encompasses objective standards and design guidelines and the roundhouse.
[47:24] Ingrid, do you still have slips from last week?
[47:29] So for the people who are here who,
[47:32] if you already spoke last time,
[47:35] please don't fill out another slip,
[47:37] but if you were one of the few you left and you had a question,
[47:41] if you would give Ingrid a slip,
[47:43] we'll get to you.
[47:44] But I want to first continue with the council questions.
[47:49] We're not going to go by the topic.
[47:51] So I'm going to throw a whole ball of wax all in one.
[47:54] Any of those subheadings are fair game if you want to talk about any of them in any order
[47:59] because we already kind of did that.
[48:01] And I will call on each council member.
[48:04] I ask you to limit to one question.
[48:07] I'll go back down the dice again.
[48:09] Never be able to keep getting chances, but one question at a time if you would please
[48:14] So city clerk if you could gather speaker slips and
[48:21] Let's just start
[48:24] Tell some member Kern you don't always get to go first. Let's have you go for that this meeting is mixed up this meeting there
[48:31] We're gonna make sure you get to go first
[48:34] So the question I have is a carryover
[48:36] Many people know that I'm a former resident of the city of San Francisco
[48:40] I live for a number of years on Berry Street.
[48:43] Berry Street is the street in Mission Bay
[48:45] that directly dead ends into Oracle Park.
[48:51] My question, staff already has a copy of this question.
[48:54] I sent it to them in advance, but my question is,
[48:57] Mission Bay, also known as Selma in San Francisco,
[49:00] is often cited as a model for the bay lands.
[49:03] But high density corridors like Berry Street,
[49:05] face constant curb and traffic lane congestion
[49:08] from tenant move in and move out.
[49:10] this is a densely populated area. This becomes extreme around the first of the months and don't even
[49:15] add a ballgame to that when Lisa's turn over. How specifically does the bail-ins plan account
[49:21] for off-street loading base, staging areas, and curb management to handle these monthly peak
[49:27] turnover cycles, very specific to tenants, not just general deliveries.
[49:40] Thank you, council member.
[49:42] I'm Matt going with vampires, so we could start the transportation portion early here in
[49:46] responding. There are several sections that describe how driveway and loading operations would
[49:53] work, including day one activities. The examples that you're citing are great, and they really
[49:59] they lead San Francisco to change how they entitle their own projects by requiring what they
[50:05] call driveway and loading operations plan that create clear designs standards and procedures
[50:12] So that any new developments that come in have to follow them to, for example, make sure that they reserve spaces on the street for those types of loading activities or they have to be able to show how they can accommodate them within the project site itself.
[50:28] So within the Bayland specific plan takes a note from that, and includes clear standards for designing driveways, designing for loading operations, and having a clear protocol for example if complaints arise that they're not following it, there's a clear procedure for how to address that.
[50:51] So that's embedded within the specific plan chapter six, and as well as within the
[50:59] supplemental design guidelines that are in the transportation impact analysis report,
[51:04] which is cited as a part of the mitigation measures.
[51:10] Thank you.
[51:14] Yep.
[51:14] Councilmember Lens.
[51:17] I asked a lot of questions during that last hearing and all my questions came out during
[51:24] that hearing.
[51:25] So I don't have any questions regarding this particular topic.
[51:29] Okay, thank you, Fair enough.
[51:31] Council Member O'Connell?
[51:34] I don't have any questions on those topics.
[51:37] Okay, Mayor Pro Tem Davis.
[51:40] At a future meeting,
[51:41] can staff provide council with a final accounting
[51:44] of 157 acres identified as open space-slush open area,
[51:51] showing separately what acreage is permanent habitat
[51:55] conservation, what is publicly accessible, parkland, what is recreational, open space,
[52:05] and what is privately controlled open areas. So maybe a map that's shaded with figures
[52:15] for each. So we just can see comparatively how much each section comes out to be on its own
[52:23] would be great.
[52:30] I'm just going to go back since you, do you have, you have no further questions?
[52:34] I don't know. No, not at this time. Okay, so let's just go back through the same route.
[52:41] Madam Mayor, could we just clarify, council member, did this is?
[52:44] Sure.
[52:47] There is figure, maybe five, five, one, one in the specific plan. I want to see if that.
[52:55] Okay, let me see.
[52:56] is responsive so we can pull that out and specifically present on it at a future meeting, but if you're looking for other information
[53:04] we want to make sure we get that to you.
[53:05] By one one, but it would be good to, oh oh two point one two.
[53:13] Maybe you could just add total figures.
[53:18] So for like combined community fields and Bay Trail,
[53:22] Because those are active recreation areas, just to have like totals.
[53:27] Yeah, we can, we can put it up.
[53:30] Yeah, that would be more clarity around that would be good.
[53:35] Thank you.
[53:35] Okay, thanks for clarifying.
[53:38] Okay, so I have a question regarding the roundhouse.
[53:43] In the specific plan, there's a summary of the page and turn bowl in the appendix,
[53:47] as you know, it's a beautiful study about rehabilitation of the roundhouse, repurposing the renovation.
[53:54] It's really impressive. I was very, very impressed. It preserves historic attributes, it
[54:00] re-invisions new spaces within that. And then it also says rehabilitation of the roundhouse is
[54:07] essential to the character of roundhouse park and the district. Who, and this is probably a question
[54:14] and for the Bayland's crew here.
[54:17] Who do you envision taking on this restoration?
[54:20] And should we safely assume that the floor plans and features
[54:23] in that appendix are an exact blueprint
[54:27] of what to expect as the final product,
[54:29] if you could feel that question?
[54:36] Is it, in other words, is it prescriptive
[54:38] or is it just an idea?
[54:43] And who would actually do that renovation?
[54:48] Good evening, Madam Mayor, council members, Stephanie Shikowski, the bail-ins, the vote-manink.
[54:55] The page and turn-ball presentation that's, we've included in the specific plan.
[55:03] Yeah, that's a real plan.
[55:08] And because it's the roundhouse, I mean, it has to be preserved as the roundhouse.
[55:12] that we have a whole adaptive reuse program for it,
[55:16] that would be how it would be financed.
[55:18] I know we have a financing whole session coming up,
[55:24] but we envision it as being financed by our typical private funders,
[55:32] equity funders, CFDs, HOAs, and commercial associations
[55:37] that would be funding into that.
[55:40] There are also maybe the ability to use some of the public art funds for the project.
[55:45] It will also be self-sustaining because if you read the whole description, it does have plans for shops and coffee houses and restaurants inside there and active uses.
[55:57] So, you know, theaters, things that could raise revenue for the long-term maintenance of the project.
[56:04] But yeah, the financing would be a whole stack of funds that would put it together.
[56:09] Yeah, and we left the round house and it's great and not only is it being preserved, but it's also being connected with that long linear park that goes through the whole project.
[56:22] Set the answer.
[56:23] Thank you.
[56:24] Council member Kern, you're up.
[56:27] No further questions.
[56:28] Okay.
[56:29] Mayor, pro timid.
[56:30] Yes.
[56:33] So the finally AR says the site specific review process is intended to be flexible enough to accommodate.
[56:39] changing recreational needs over time. I just want to make sure that that flexibility is
[56:44] preserved within this specific plan, and it was also wondering what authority the city would
[56:50] have to require a different type of recreational or community amenity than those shown in
[56:56] the illustrative plans. I'm not saying that we would, but we may say, oh, it's global warming,
[57:03] and it's so hot now and we need another pool. Is there that flexibility there to change
[57:14] recreational amenity in that way?
[57:20] Actually that would probably be a development agreement.
[57:23] Item versus just an open space item. So I would take that exit. That's probably not a great example,
[57:29] but
[57:31] just overall question I think is still worth responding to.
[57:39] So it's the, the most responsive portion of this is described in chapter nine of the EIR.
[57:47] So as each park open space and trail area is proposed in connection with future development.
[57:56] There are site-specific improvement plans that are required for those open spaces.
[58:01] And then the parks and recreation committee is actually delegated authority under the specific plan
[58:07] to review those site-specific approvals and issue permits for the site-specific improvements
[58:16] as part of that open-space plan and then they would be doing that, applying the framework
[58:22] and policy direction of the specific plan.
[58:25] Okay. All right.
[58:30] Be sure CalTrain Station Plaza, the specific plan shows in
[58:36] illustrative concept, diagram, and I wonder it again a question for the
[58:41] Baylands crew. Is there an awareness that San Francisco planning has a
[58:46] document called the Bayshore Multimodal Facility Study, and since you're on
[58:55] with them because they have four alternative concepts.
[59:00] Have you had any dialogue with them?
[59:13] Also, I don't know if we're getting in transportation,
[59:15] do you have some slides to share on that topic when we're ready for it?
[59:18] So on the Bayshore Caltering Station Plaza,
[59:23] we have not discussed exact design with them at this time.
[59:26] However, we have had initial discussions with SF planning
[59:30] and SFMTA about regional coordination
[59:33] around some of the infrastructure related to transportation and so the
[59:37] plausible probably come into play there and once we get to the point of
[59:42] actually putting forward a design loop will obviously have to coordinate with
[59:45] those relevance stakeholders to make sure we're meeting their policy
[59:49] objectives. I think you need to talk to them because they have different ways of
[59:54] approaching the station to even your talking roads. Sure and so that's that's
[59:58] critical.
[1:00:00] Have an advance.
[1:00:03] Mayor Prochem, may I have another question?
[1:00:05] Yes. This is something we briefly talked about between staff and I and maybe at another meeting.
[1:00:14] But I think it's good to have something just a little bit more clear.
[1:00:19] So given the environmental history of the Baylands, and the fact that remediation and
[1:00:23] Folklosure are regulated by agencies other than Brisbane. Could we secure permanent public
[1:00:31] access, maintenance and utility easements for infrastructure, open space, parks, et cetera?
[1:00:37] While the underlying property remains privately owned and the responsibility of the landfill
[1:00:42] cap remediation and any future environmental failures remains with the responsible property owner
[1:00:49] or other legally responsible party.
[1:00:52] I know we've kind of talked about this,
[1:00:54] so sorry for asking this again,
[1:00:57] but it would be great if that is possible
[1:01:00] to come back maybe with some language
[1:01:03] of how we could make that very defined
[1:01:06] in the specific plan.
[1:01:08] Yeah, so the short answer is yes, it is possible
[1:01:11] to do dedications for open space
[1:01:16] that are privately owned and publicly accessible
[1:01:19] and then work out different different types of ownership structures, meat and
[1:01:24] disagreements and operating agreements for how the public has access to those
[1:01:31] spaces without the city needing to take fee title to the property itself and
[1:01:37] all the reliability that's associated with that.
[1:01:40] We can if the direction from the council is to explore having that be a
[1:01:49] the Tory way of taking the open space and providing public access. We can bring forward some
[1:01:55] language for you to consider around that. Thank you. Again in the Land Use section, there's
[1:02:02] a section about affordable housing program. It's very interesting because it talks about phasing
[1:02:09] to ensure timely delivery of the required affordable units. It mentions 15% affordable and
[1:02:18] I recall Stephanie, you in the first public hearing talked about that your staff here, you're not a developer, your development managers, so you're an agent of the property owner, and that you would be working perhaps in partnership with other developers.
[1:02:36] So I was trying to think this through ever since that meeting and when I came upon this section.
[1:02:44] If you have neighborhoods that are going to be built by multiple developers,
[1:02:48] how do you plan to deliver that affordable housing in a timely basis?
[1:02:53] Because in the same section, it talks about a goal of 514 affordable units.
[1:02:59] And I don't need to reiterate, but I will, the emphasis in the Bay Area on this project having not just housing, but affordable housing.
[1:03:10] So how will you go about if that is the goal to deliver it in a timely basis with multiple developers?
[1:03:18] How are you going to do that? Or can you tell us anything about that?
[1:03:27] And again, we have a hearing on phasing coming up in the very near future, but we are required
[1:03:36] under the Brisbane and in our specific plan, the 15 percent inclusionary, and we are planning
[1:03:42] for that in a phased fashion. So for example, the Bayshore District, if that's the first phase that
[1:03:49] through, that's 210 units of affordable housing, and so we would plan for that. Often
[1:04:01] these affordable, there's a combination of the four rent and the four sale. The four rent
[1:04:07] is almost always projects that are done by the nonprofit affordable community. And so the way
[1:04:15] that this has worked on other projects.
[1:04:18] And again, I'd like to use the Bay Meadows project,
[1:04:21] as an example, because it's a fairly recent example
[1:04:24] of a master plan mixed use community
[1:04:28] that's been built out in San Mateo.
[1:04:31] There, the developer in the city partnered
[1:04:34] with Bridge Housing to build the affordable units
[1:04:37] on that project.
[1:04:38] And that's typically how it works,
[1:04:41] is that the private developer who's building the housing
[1:04:45] We'll partner with a for-profit, I'm sorry, a non-profit, a for-profit housing developer because they can access all of the federal state and local grant and funds that are available for those projects.
[1:05:01] Conceptually, that's how it works, and we'll talk more about that in the phasing.
[1:05:05] Right, theoretically, if you have different developers and it could go over 10 years, it could go 20 years doing different housing neighborhoods.
[1:05:15] Are you going to prioritize completing all of those affordable units first?
[1:05:22] First.
[1:05:24] And if you have maybe some more expensive market rate, are we going to see the completion of the affordable housing before we get into other neighborhoods?
[1:05:36] Well, I think the way that we've talked about the phasing is like the first phase, the
[1:05:40] visual district, you know, would have it's full, you know, housing commercial and affordable
[1:05:46] component to it.
[1:05:50] It would not be advisable to make sure that the affordable goes first,
[1:05:55] and the affordable nonprofits will tell you that they have been under those kinds of
[1:06:01] development agreements in the past, and it just doesn't work for them. Because often it takes
[1:06:07] them a few years to put that very complicated stack together. When you know it includes
[1:06:13] $1 and lots of state grants and state bonds, and it takes anywhere from two to four years
[1:06:20] for them to actually put that stack together. If the private market is ready to go, you don't want
[1:06:24] hold that up. So you want the commitments for the housing, but you don't want to say, oh,
[1:06:29] and you can't build this until the affordable goes first. So you want to be flexible, but you
[1:06:34] want to make sure that, you know, it's all planned for. But the nonprofits will tell you that,
[1:06:39] yeah, they're not big fans of being told you have to go first, because they struggled to put
[1:06:45] their capital stack together. Okay. So the ambitious goal of 514, we're not sure when that would
[1:06:52] completed. Well, it'll be completed in phases. The project at 2,200 units is a 15%
[1:07:00] inclusion area. That's 330 units. The 514 is taken from the housing element. Those are goals
[1:07:07] for the city. So that's something that we need, we would need to discuss. Okay. Thank you. Yeah.
[1:07:15] matter of merit. Yes, if I may. And this is to staff. Isn't affordable housing only
[1:07:25] attributed by density? It's not what it really costs.
[1:07:31] That is true when you're doing the planning and the housing element, so when the housing element creates the obligation to plan for housing, you can assume that housing that is zoned for a particular density will be developed at an affordable rate, so you can plan for that in your housing element.
[1:07:53] When development permits are actually issued, and you report that on your annual progress
[1:08:01] report to each CD, that you then report the actual sales price or rental price of that
[1:08:12] unit, whether those are lower income, moderate income, or above moderate income.
[1:08:18] So it depends at what stage in the process you're looking, whether you can pursue it will
[1:08:23] affordable based on density that works during the housing element process and then later
[1:08:28] during actual development, the actual rents or what matter.
[1:08:36] So there's two different measurements of what HCDs considers affordable housing by density
[1:08:44] only and sales price later when something is actually built whether it really is affordable.
[1:08:52] and I'll get into the financing another time.
[1:09:00] Okay.
[1:09:01] Mayor Proto?
[1:09:04] I have three questions left.
[1:09:06] Just so you have an idea.
[1:09:09] During the EIR comment period,
[1:09:11] commenters asked whether each person should establish a site specific groundwater baseline before development
[1:09:17] so that the city could track changing groundwater conditions over time.
[1:09:21] The final EIR concluded that this wasn't necessary because the project wide modeling
[1:09:26] showed no significant impact at six and a half to six point nine feet of sea level rise.
[1:09:33] Does the specific plan contain any ongoing groundwater monitoring?
[1:09:38] I mean, I'm assuming that the regulatory bodies are monitoring the groundwater for contaminants,
[1:09:45] but I'm hoping that we would be tracking the groundwater
[1:09:48] So that we could trigger a mechanism that will allow the city to detective actual conditions
[1:09:56] differ from our assumptions given the rate at which sea level is rising.
[1:10:10] Unfortunately, since we ran out of time at our last meeting,
[1:10:15] our sea level rise and
[1:10:16] groundwater expert wasn't available for this evening's meeting.
[1:10:20] So if we can circle back to that and clean it up in connection with either the
[1:10:25] remediation or phasing discussion, we'll bring that back to you.
[1:10:31] I have no more questions.
[1:10:32] So you're on.
[1:10:33] I'll be right next to you.
[1:10:34] Okay.
[1:10:35] So another sea level rise question.
[1:10:36] Sorry.
[1:10:37] I'll just state it.
[1:10:38] Yeah.
[1:10:39] If you say it for the record and then we'll have that.
[1:10:44] Maybe you might know.
[1:10:46] So the final EIR responded to CalTrans is comment about using the 2030 sea level rise projections.
[1:10:54] by explaining that the specific plans 6.5 to 6.9 foot 2100 analysis is within approximately
[1:11:03] a half of foot of the 2030 projection reference by cauterans.
[1:11:12] And building or infrastructure project constructed later in the build out, how does the
[1:11:20] Pacific Plan ensure that a applicable 100-year projection is actually re-evaluated at that
[1:11:27] time that the project is constructed rather than simply relying on today's 2100 assumptions.
[1:11:33] So again, thinking about the future or thinking that this project will take several years
[1:11:37] if not several decades potentially to build out, I just want to make sure that there's
[1:11:42] something in there that's allowing flexibility to analyze addressing conditions?
[1:11:51] Yeah, and that the infrastructure section does address the ongoing application of updated
[1:12:00] standards, particularly with respect to sea level rise and flood level to ensure that there
[1:12:08] our current standards being applied to development permits,
[1:12:12] as those are coming through at that time.
[1:12:17] And the last question is about the roundhouse.
[1:12:21] So if programming of the roundhouse is allowed to change,
[1:12:26] what limitations this specific plan placed on that future use.
[1:12:29] So for example, it's a roundhouse ultimately
[1:12:32] was used primarily for a restaurant or a cafe
[1:12:35] as the applicant said tonight or event venue,
[1:12:37] are there requirements that preserve some kind of public museum, educational and cultural or community
[1:12:45] component, so that the public always has some level of access. So they might not want to
[1:12:51] visit the roundhouse to patronize a specific business, but they might want to be able to access
[1:12:57] that space to appreciate his historical significance. And so is there anything in there that ensures
[1:13:06] that this will always not just be business driven, but an asset to the community.
[1:13:19] We have our, I believe we have our historic resource consultant online, so if we could,
[1:13:26] her name is Kathy, bring her on as a panelist, and then she can answer the question.
[1:13:32] I am actually already a panelist.
[1:13:34] Thank you.
[1:13:36] Yes.
[1:13:36] So, just to make sure that I understand the question,
[1:13:40] are we trying to clarify that potential future uses
[1:13:45] are not solely business driven,
[1:13:47] but rather that there will be a historic interpretation element
[1:13:51] to the roundhouse in future uses?
[1:13:55] Correct.
[1:14:01] The ER requires that the historic preservation component
[1:14:07] go through design review
[1:14:10] through planning commission, which will be required to get approvals for future adaptive reuse
[1:14:19] under the Secretary of Interior Standards guidelines.
[1:14:24] So at that point, those kinds of decisions would be made.
[1:14:27] I don't, obviously, I will defer to planning, but I don't believe that there is an explicit statement requiring the historic
[1:14:34] interpretation to element to the building as part of the adaptive readers.
[1:14:41] I know looking at a museum was listed as a potential use,
[1:14:44] which I had concerns that how could you require a museum
[1:14:49] that may not be able to sustain itself with patrons,
[1:14:54] but I think that having some kind of space, your mark.
[1:15:00] Whether it's dressed in exhibit, that's always open and costs nothing. You know, I imagine there'll be things that you will find as you're doing your restoration that could be put on display in old photos.
[1:15:12] So you just think paying homage to the roundhouse and how special it is is essential, you know, just some kind of area.
[1:15:24] Definitely, and if I may comment on that, to clarify, Stephanie's point a little bit.
[1:15:31] So the roundhouse is intended to mostly be a public amenity, so it is intended to be this
[1:15:37] open air amphitheater that uses the steel beams of the roundhouse,
[1:15:43] as sort of the frame of that structure, and then of course all of that will include a public park.
[1:15:49] So, really public access is at the heart of the plan for the roundhouse.
[1:15:53] So, when Stephanie mentioned like a restaurant cafe, that would probably be like a small component of that space.
[1:15:59] So, if you think about if you go to somewhere like, um, you know, like even in Golden Gate Park,
[1:16:05] they might have a little kiosk where you can get coffee and snacks and things like that.
[1:16:10] So, I think that's more of the intention rather than converting the entire roundhouse structure into a standalone restaurant.
[1:16:16] And then definitely agree with you on maintaining some educational signage, whether that's
[1:16:22] a full-blown museum or, you know, some publicly available plaques.
[1:16:26] We've actually done a lot of that in our offices, which were the former Schleiglock building.
[1:16:31] If you ever want to come visit, you can see we salvaged a lot of old signage and things
[1:16:35] like that from the Schleig factory and have that displayed throughout the building.
[1:16:38] Awesome.
[1:16:39] Thank you.
[1:16:39] Those are all my questions.
[1:16:41] All right.
[1:16:42] Now, I have some slips here.
[1:16:44] Let me first just read off the names, and I want you to be honest with me if you spoke on this topic, the last public hearing.
[1:16:52] This is not a time to speak again. This is continuing over for people who did not get the chance to speak because they left the previous public hearing.
[1:17:03] So the slips I have are for Clark Conway, Karen Cunningham, Dan, Linda Salman, and Michelle Salman.
[1:17:15] So Clark Conway, I don't see here, Karen Cunningham. I know you were here, I remember.
[1:17:24] I'm old, I had to go home, I was too tired.
[1:17:28] So, I think my comments, slash questions, relate to both the land use and design plans.
[1:17:39] I'm just going to hack and back just a little bit, when this all came about in the beginning,
[1:17:47] we had deiramas and various layouts that we got to play with.
[1:17:54] we got to look at, we got to look at what, you know, what was maybe being proposed.
[1:18:01] And I, for one, found them incredibly helpful.
[1:18:07] If there's a chance that we can do this, maybe, you know, out at the Baylands office site.
[1:18:14] So people can go and look at what is being proposed.
[1:18:17] Well, what are we really talking about here?
[1:18:19] because from a physical perspective, that brings me then to the question of somewhere and I do apologize, I don't know what page this is on in the EIR.
[1:18:32] There is a mention of 50 feet of fill.
[1:18:36] And I think many people in Brisbane are going to want to know what the heck does that look like.
[1:18:41] For example, you know, what does it look like from being up on the top of Humboldt looking down on the baylands?
[1:18:49] What does that 50 feet of fill look like?
[1:18:51] Are we excavating and then bringing it up to 25 feet?
[1:18:54] What does it look like?
[1:18:55] And also, you know, we're talking about the roundhouse.
[1:18:59] And then, what does that look like if we drive down Bayeshall Boulevard?
[1:19:03] If we're talking about, is there a 50 foot retaining wall to the east of Bayeshall?
[1:19:11] as we're driving. What do these things look like? I think that would be really super important.
[1:19:17] We're talking about working on this expeditiously and I think if people have something that they can
[1:19:24] go look at as we're moving through this process it's going to make the process go faster as well.
[1:19:31] So I think they are the most important things from what I fell asleep on last time and I'll leave it
[1:19:38] Okay,
[1:19:41] Dan, I think Dan left.
[1:19:46] Linda Salman, you're still here.
[1:19:55] I'm still here, and we got to chance to speak on a little bit
[1:19:59] about what was going on, but we were in the middle of the whole thing.
[1:20:05] And so I suggested that we wait until everything was done and had a chance
[1:20:10] to still speak about what was being decided, but it doesn't
[1:20:15] like like we're there, so I'm not really sure.
[1:20:19] And it says now land use and design plans.
[1:20:22] This whole thing, I'm sorry, it's very confusing to me.
[1:20:25] But in terms of topic, transportation, all these different topics
[1:20:30] are you saying that we've already decided about everything that's going on?
[1:20:36] Are these things that are still coming up?
[1:20:38] I mean, I'm sorry, the things just
[1:20:40] I think they've gotten to be a bit of a jumble for me in terms of asking for public comment
[1:20:47] in the middle of not of doing something and now asking for that same public comment
[1:20:52] again when I'm done I'm not maybe I can clarify right now if you if you if you have
[1:20:58] comments or questions on anything on land use and the design plans those were the two topics
[1:21:05] from the last public hearing. Either one. This would be the time. I didn't see any design plans talked about last time or anything else.
[1:21:16] It seemed like we were, you called for public hearing because it was getting late and you wanted people to have a chance to speak.
[1:21:24] But it's hard to have a chance to speak on something when you haven't seen the presentation. Thank you.
[1:21:30] Okay, I've got Michelle on land use and design plans.
[1:21:38] Some of you that was said last night made me question, is Lizarre the Lizarre fuel site
[1:21:45] part of the whole project in is it owned by the same owners, because they said something
[1:21:52] last night that made me think that it might not be because they weren't doing soil testing
[1:21:58] there. So that's a question you don't have to answer right this second, but I would like to know.
[1:22:03] And on land use, you know, in 2018 after Mr. J.J. passed the Greg Vilken in the Baylands,
[1:22:13] whatever they were called in, hosted a charat, I guess, with this public. And land use was pretty
[1:22:21] much decided by where you stuck your little sticker everywhere. And one of the things that I think
[1:22:27] is probably not where we should.
[1:22:30] Have them, is where the community fields are. And the reason I think that is that used to be a very active wetland, and actually if you go through the tunnel during the wet season, you'll find that it's still a very active wet area, but when BDI decided to bring in a huge amount of gravel and start a tree nursery there, they pretty much destroyed a lot of the wetland that was there by the where the old railroad tracks came through the tunnel.
[1:23:00] But that is a wet area and will get wet again when it starts being used.
[1:23:07] And also there's not any adequate parking in that area because machinery, it's bordered
[1:23:13] on one side by base shore and machinery and equipment on the other side.
[1:23:18] And the firehouse and the nursery on the one end, and I saw a seal on the other plus the
[1:23:23] railroad tunnel.
[1:23:24] And, you know, people drive to take their kids to soccer, to take their kids to baseball, to take their kids.
[1:23:32] I mean, a lot of times it's a problem with the pool when they have soccer.
[1:23:36] And out of town soccer matches.
[1:23:38] So I'm concerned about that.
[1:23:39] I'm concerned about the Alizarre area.
[1:23:43] I'm concerned about where they plan for school, but I've already talked about that.
[1:23:48] And then on design plans, I was thinking about 22 story buildings.
[1:23:52] And of course, we just saw a lot of film from 9-11.
[1:23:57] And 22 stories is really high.
[1:24:00] And you have to have really a different kind of fire equipment
[1:24:02] and fire department to handle a 22-story building,
[1:24:06] as opposed to a 12-story building.
[1:24:07] And I just think that's really very high
[1:24:09] with the risk of earthquake and fire.
[1:24:15] And then on the roundhouse, I just want to make sure
[1:24:17] that everybody is really, really aware
[1:24:19] the warehouse is now GPS-wise it might be the same but it's not going to be at the level
[1:24:27] where it is now it will be completely taken apart this was my understanding in 2018 completely
[1:24:35] taken apart brick by brick the area would be covered with a cap and protective soil because it's
[1:24:42] extremely toxic area and will be rebuilt higher up I don't know how much higher up at that time it
[1:24:48] 30 feet. So when you're envisioning all of that, this is why Karen's idea of having a three
[1:24:55] dimensional model of what it's going to look like would be very helpful for people. It's not
[1:25:00] going to be where it is now. So get that in your head, it will be a completely different structure,
[1:25:05] kind of like the roundhouse that's along the embarcadero that doesn't look anything like a railroad
[1:25:10] aroundhouse. Hopefully this one will still look like a railroad aroundhouse. Thank you.
[1:25:15] So, could we have a staff clarification on, I don't know how to say it, last, last
[1:25:20] area, the Missouri, the fuel, what is it, Missouri, thank you, if that, clarify if
[1:25:27] that is part of this project.
[1:25:42] So, the site is within the specific plan batteries, and it is also not one of those sites that's
[1:25:46] called that as kind of these existing use areas that were originally not part of the
[1:25:51] specific plan, but this one is in the specific plan, those are if you'll say it and I do
[1:25:55] believe it is owned by BDR, whichever entity, you know, sign
[1:26:00] quest on text, where else? So the answer is yes. Correct. Okay. And the developer, owner,
[1:26:12] crew, could you tell us is the, is the roundhouse from what we saw in the
[1:26:17] appendix? It doesn't talk about deconstructing and moving. Could you clarify that?
[1:26:21] is it being deconstructed?
[1:26:23] I know that was mentioned years ago.
[1:26:25] I remember that, about literally brick by brick
[1:26:28] taking in a part and reassembling elsewhere.
[1:26:35] And that was to match the elevation of the dirt.
[1:26:40] Excuse me, Madam Mayor.
[1:26:41] If you read the page and termed all there are two alternatives
[1:26:48] for rehabbing the roundhouse.
[1:26:50] And one of them does have a brick by brick,
[1:26:53] re-construction.
[1:26:58] But that's not been decided yet today. Which path will we will take?
[1:27:03] And book, sorry. And is the other just demolish rebuild with no, it was the same to the same.
[1:27:15] No, no, no, no. It's a historic site so you can't demolish it. I think Greg was like
[1:27:24] said in the past. If you wanted it brick by brick and it all put together, that was one option,
[1:27:34] that would take a significant amount more money as opposed to just rebuilding it to the same
[1:27:39] blueprint that it was before, but not using all the same materials. Obviously there's a lot of holes
[1:27:46] that you'd have to fill, but yeah. But right now the plan, there are two separate plans in the
[1:27:54] is not a total rehab or not a total tear down and redo.
[1:28:01] It is a restructuring of a brick by brick by that material.
[1:28:05] And that is a slightly more expensive prospect
[1:28:08] than the one of just rehabbing the existing roundhouse.
[1:28:14] And we can bring this back if this is a topic.
[1:28:18] We can talk more about the actual two alternatives
[1:28:21] or page and term ball, we weren't prepared to discuss it tonight, but we have lots of
[1:28:27] great slides and we can have a discussion on that, a brief one.
[1:28:31] I think one of the confusions here is if you're moving dirt, it's the roundhouse, and
[1:28:36] end up down in a lower elevation if it just is rehabbed where it is versus moving it, which
[1:28:44] They're a way to see malination.
[1:28:46] And those are clarify what you're asking.
[1:28:49] I've started with that.
[1:28:50] The toxic remediation.
[1:28:52] Okay.
[1:28:52] They can't hear you anyway.
[1:28:55] It's okay, Michelle.
[1:28:57] She's going to follow up question.
[1:28:58] Madam Mayor is about toxic remediation in both of those areas.
[1:29:03] Those are I feel which last night they mentioned that they'd not testing there.
[1:29:08] And it's not specifically mentioned in the EIR.
[1:29:12] and the roundhouse being an highly contaminated area, which was why they had talked about lifting
[1:29:20] it up, or if you leave it in place exactly where it is, how are you going to mitigate the
[1:29:28] amount of toxins there? That's my real concern. Okay, I think that those will also probably
[1:29:34] come up under remediation now to Brown brought those up.
[1:29:39] Yeah, okay.
[1:29:40] But it affects it.
[1:29:41] Yes, understood.
[1:29:44] Michael Barnes, I have you on design plants here.
[1:29:49] Michael Barnes, Brisbane resident.
[1:29:50] I'm reacting to aerial of mountain watches request last meeting to maintain the Mission
[1:29:56] Blue Nursery Native Plant and Nursery in its present location.
[1:30:00] I don't think that's necessarily a great idea. I think that actually the nursery could be on, you know, the old tire dump, for instance, because none of those plants are actually grown in the ground. They're all grown up on tables and it's not that I don't like the nursery. I'm actually the person who conceived of the nursery. I was on the city council at the time and I knew the right people to talk to and I actually made that deal happen to get the need of plant nursery.
[1:30:29] built in Brisbane. So I'm pro nursery, but that the land that it sits on now is clean, and I think
[1:30:37] you have ball fields or something scheduled for that. I think those are better uses. There's
[1:30:41] so little actually clean land in this Baylands development that I think you should use it for
[1:30:47] those kind of sensitive receptors that might want to be out there in the dirt. And the nursery
[1:30:52] will be just fine on remediate land because again, they're not growing plants in the soil of the
[1:30:59] on tables. Thank you. Okay. All right, that concludes unless anyone council, I believe we have concluded the recap of our last public hearing so we can move on to tonight's.
[1:31:17] The two topics for tonight are transportation and transit topics and the second topic is Bayshore Mobility Plan.
[1:31:25] The first topic I'll break it down into the sub-headings, which are street sections, interface
[1:31:32] with regional transportation network, and finally the Geneva Avenue extension.
[1:31:39] And I already had a couple of questions from people about anything having to do with
[1:31:44] just general circulation.
[1:31:47] You can fit that under street sections or regional transit, I think, would probably suffice
[1:31:53] unless it specifically is related to Geneva Avenue Extension.
[1:31:59] So if the members of the public would fill out speaker slips if you haven't already,
[1:32:05] and I failed to mention any members of the public at home, you would have to raise your hand
[1:32:10] in Zoom.
[1:32:12] The UCD clerk will add you to a speaker card, but right now, I would like to proceed with
[1:32:19] staff report on circulation and the Bayshore mobility plan, please.
[1:32:27] All right, thank you, uh, good evening, Honorable Mayor and council members.
[1:32:30] Uh, let's see if you get the slides up.
[1:32:32] And, uh, well, we'll have to shift it up on the fly a little bit because of the,
[1:32:36] the mayor's ball of wax from right here.
[1:32:37] We had kind of something else in mind, but we can, uh,
[1:32:41] speed ahead some of these slides.
[1:32:42] So let's get the presentation up.
[1:32:46] All right, let's go ahead.
[1:32:50] More, more slides.
[1:32:53] we can go ahead I think to we can pass the summary we kind of talked on that we already
[1:33:00] passed land use let's go to slide
[1:33:05] for the transportation topics because we're going to
[1:33:09] hand it over to Matt going right away and get going
[1:33:15] great thank you Jeremiah and Council
[1:33:19] yeah so once again I'm not going with fair and peers and so we did the EIR transportation analysis
[1:33:24] for the city. So here to present on transportation and circulation topics next slide. So first
[1:33:31] just the overall roadway network of the of the Baylands includes both regional kind of
[1:33:40] three routes as well as like local streets and really trying to identify a hierarchy of streets that
[1:33:46] allows people to move through easily two places like 101 as well as to their final destinations
[1:33:52] recognizing those are different types of streets. And within each street typology, there are standards
[1:33:59] for pedestrian, bicycle, transit facilities, vehicle facilities, as well as the broader
[1:34:04] public realm functions. Next slide. And so when we're thinking about how access within the site
[1:34:12] will be provided, you have your primary or regional arterial, which is the Geneva Long Anticipated
[1:34:19] of Avenue Extension that's been identified for a long time as a part of the general plan and this
[1:34:24] will provide a really critical route to in from Highway 101 and allow some of those trips that
[1:34:30] are currently using Bay Shore from San Francisco and Daily City, for example, to have a more
[1:34:35] direct route to the freeway with a little, so that's going to have the highest level of traffic,
[1:34:43] as well as higher speeds generally, although with 30 mile an hour design speeds,
[1:34:47] ensure that they conform with CalTrans standards for this type of environment.
[1:34:52] Then you have your minor arterial circulation with including total road being rebuilt as
[1:34:56] well as a zero point parkway extension that will connect Geneva Avenue to Lagoon Road.
[1:35:03] Within the west of CalTraining area, you have your collector road network that will have a
[1:35:10] little bit higher her traffic allowing for people to get to in from their destinations.
[1:35:16] And then at the very bottom, you have your local roadway network in your green streets.
[1:35:20] And the local roadway network in green streets are really where your local access is provided via driveways.
[1:35:26] So slower speeds, fewer vehicles, and particularly on the green streets,
[1:35:31] it follows design standards from the state and federal level,
[1:35:37] just making sure that at functions with slower speeds,
[1:35:40] 15 mile our speed limits really one block access. It's really just they don't really go anywhere. So really providing that.
[1:35:47] Just a hyper local access for for people at that level. Next slide.
[1:36:02] I don't know if staff heard that. We've had a request to clean. We zoom in on that. So people can see the detail.
[1:36:13] Is that enough?
[1:36:15] Nope. Nope. We might have to shut off the captions too.
[1:36:25] don't know if the council heard, but we could turn off the captions, and that will make it bigger.
[1:36:31] But because we've been including the captions, there you go.
[1:36:37] Great. Well, I'll let this sit here for a moment.
[1:36:41] So you can digest it.
[1:36:44] And then I'd like to shift to the next slide, which is bicycle network, which has a similar type of hierarchy of sorts.
[1:36:55] Organized all around the principle that people who are writing bicycles should be able to ride on a low-stress facility where anyone can feel comfortable.
[1:37:05] But you do have those facilities such as tunnel avenue or Geneva that provide through routes through the site plan.
[1:37:13] And so you can imagine that tunnel avenue, for example, with a new classware facilities would provide a comfortable straight through fast route for people traveling through the community.
[1:37:23] world and you have kind of or you then you have things like the class one day trail that would be
[1:37:30] More for recreational users and include a mix of people walking, biking, using other mobility devices.
[1:37:38] Design to modern, bait trail trail design standards that are really focused on ensuring safety for people walking, biking, using e-bikes, making sure that people don't, for example, go too fast on those types of facilities through designs and other restrictions.
[1:37:54] And then at the bottom, you have your class one internal trail that would connect down to
[1:37:59] Bayland to Central Brisbane and your green shared streets as well, providing that hyper
[1:38:05] local access, I mentioned earlier. Next slide.
[1:38:11] And on the transit network, you have, of course,
[1:38:13] your CalTransation, providing the best regional transit access, and then you have the G3rd,
[1:38:19] Sam Trans and the planned ESOS BRT that would provide the connections to other neighboring jurisdictions
[1:38:28] as well as Sam Trans connecting down to Central Brisbane and then you have your local shuttle routes
[1:38:33] that are planned as a part of the specific planet itself. Those would be coordinated as well with the
[1:38:39] TDM plan required compliance required community dot org type shuttles that that wouldn't need to
[1:38:47] both the project site and and for as being and the high quality transit services that are available.
[1:38:53] Next slide. So just thinking about how how this site connects to regional destinations,
[1:39:00] you really have your in terms of how the roadway and trail network works. You have your regional connections,
[1:39:06] multivotable connections via Geneva Avenue, being your kind of biggest connection there.
[1:39:12] They sure internal and zero point are serving in their own roles with the pay trail, connecting
[1:39:17] into, you know, safer Cisco and down a zero point via other kind of planned connections.
[1:39:23] And then you have a Main Street Class One Trail that would provide safe routes to school
[1:39:28] access between the proposed middle school and the students who live in Baylands and going
[1:39:34] to the Bay Short Heights neighborhood elementary school.
[1:39:38] And then once again, that internal, that's a little bit larger, great, thanks.
[1:39:43] And then your internal trail network that connects kind of down the car free-spying
[1:39:48] down the middle of the specific plan area down into town.
[1:39:53] Next slide.
[1:39:58] So just briefly on the Geneva Avenue extension, as this is really one of the most critical
[1:40:04] additions, as I mentioned, as shown here, you would have a consistent cross-section within
[1:40:10] And this is what's shown in the 2026 specific plan.
[1:40:13] Chris, consistent cross-section with four vehicle travel lanes,
[1:40:17] and then two BRG lanes down the middle to provide that plan,
[1:40:20] BRK service with stops within the specific plan area itself.
[1:40:26] And this would be once again connecting over a new bridge,
[1:40:30] over Cal train, and then to the plan,
[1:40:33] to the Planned Candlestick interchange rebuild as planned through the by county study from about a little over a decade ago.
[1:40:45] Next slide.
[1:40:48] Now shifting gears from the specific plan to the BASHOR mobility plan, so this is a city-led effort,
[1:40:54] looking at the city's general plan, and there are wide variety of goals here there,
[1:41:00] save the mobility plan to just improve connectivity and improve the road as a local street
[1:41:06] compared to a regional role. And so just thinking about this one primary goal is called out
[1:41:12] in the general plan for reducing base shores roles, regional cut-through traffic, really recognizing
[1:41:18] that there's, you know, serves today primarily regional route, there's continued growth around and
[1:41:23] what can be short, what can the city do to reduce that role? So today you have six North South
[1:41:31] lanes, I'm just looking at base shore and tunnel and then next slide. If you were to include the
[1:41:39] base full base shore modality plan, which would include a road diet down to two lanes on base shore
[1:41:45] and then plus the tunnel avenue and the extension of Sierra Point Parkway and and the Geneva Avenue
[1:41:51] extension, you can see, you know, just maintaining that in yourself, connectivity, but shifting the load
[1:41:57] back from, from Bayshore to Sierra Point Parkway and Highway 101, and then Genie Vatic
[1:42:05] extension, most importantly, providing that most direct connection for folks that are currently using
[1:42:09] Bayshore. Next slide.
[1:42:14] So the staff recommendation is for full implementation of the Bayshore
[1:42:18] mobility plan, and that includes both mitigations for safety improvements as well as the road diet
[1:42:23] from four to two lanes south of Geneva, Avenue, and then things like class one path, safer
[1:42:30] crossings, other, other improvements as well. And so just thinking about the future, really,
[1:42:36] this is the the critical issue that's been identified in studies going back to the prior
[1:42:42] palean ZIR and the general plan where you know, regional, those things really at the heart of
[1:42:49] impacted by regional growth and regional growth is going to continue to add traffic to
[1:42:54] be sure and really local traffic has never expected to exceed two lanes and so this
[1:43:02] would be one way to encourage drivers who are driving through the city to shift back to 101.
[1:43:08] Next slide and
[1:43:12] the Planning Commission recommended just focusing just adopting only the safety
[1:43:16] related mitigation measures as a part of the be sure mobility plan. There's many different
[1:43:21] components, road diet, just being one of them, and studying whether the continuous class one
[1:43:27] path or sidewalk could be done without the lane reduction. And so this approach would address
[1:43:33] the project's impacts. It would improve crossings, for example, at Main Street, for the
[1:43:37] safe routes of school access and crossing at Geneva as well, as well as adding features to slow
[1:43:44] vehicles, but just broader speed, kind of speeding issues or regional cut-through traffic could
[1:43:50] still be an issue in the future.
[1:43:53] But without a road diet, you would continue
[1:43:56] to be able to have at least at minimum a sidewalk
[1:43:59] if not a pathway on most of the sections,
[1:44:01] at least that are not constrained.
[1:44:04] And while adding things like protective intersections
[1:44:06] for people walking and biking across the street,
[1:44:09] high visibility crossings, with medians,
[1:44:11] and other features that have been identified in past studies,
[1:44:14] such as the city's local road safety plan
[1:44:16] and Sam Tran's bus stop and proven plans.
[1:44:21] And so with that, that's,
[1:44:23] we've sent my presentation today.
[1:44:25] Okay, thank you very much.
[1:44:27] And I understand the applicant staff has also
[1:44:31] a report to make.
[1:44:32] Katie's at you.
[1:44:44] I'm going to get this slide up.
[1:44:47] Hi again.
[1:44:47] I'm Katie Lok Sunday with the Bayland's team
[1:44:50] and I'm also joined with representatives
[1:44:53] from Nelson Nygard, who are the transportation planners
[1:44:56] that worked on the specific plane.
[1:45:01] So if we go to the next slide.
[1:45:05] So I actually have a video here. To like to start our presentation tonight with this video which provides actually a more detailed 3D rendering of the bail-ans.
[1:45:18] And as you watch this video, I think one of the things that comes through is how much thought has gone into the bail-ans.
[1:45:24] This is a large, complicated site and from the beginning our goal has been to create a place that feels like a collection of beautiful, interconnected neighborhoods with walkable streets, welcoming public spaces, connections to transit and a strong relationship between the built environment and the landscape.
[1:45:43] That vision has benefited from some of the most respected voices in urban design.
[1:45:49] Peter Calthorpe served as the lead designer for the Baylands and his vision shaped the specific plan.
[1:45:55] He is one of the founders of the new urbanism movement, which prioritizes walkable neighborhoods,
[1:46:00] a mix of uses, and places designed for people rather than cars.
[1:46:05] He is also recipient of the Urban Land Institute, J.C. Nichols Prize for Visionaries in Urban Development,
[1:46:12] which is one of the field's most significant honors.
[1:46:16] That expertise has also been complemented by other highly respected design firms,
[1:46:21] including Gensler and O.J.B. Landscape Architecture,
[1:46:25] who we had with us at last week's meeting.
[1:46:28] But what matters more than the names or the awards is the experience
[1:46:33] that we're planning for at the bail-ins.
[1:46:36] This project will deliver thousands of new homes in a variety of new commercial
[1:46:40] and retail spaces, all will establish unique character for each neighborhood.
[1:46:46] And as we go back to the slides, I'll just make a few more comments on that aerial image.
[1:46:52] I hope that you can see that the attention that is given not only to the buildings, but also to
[1:46:57] the spaces in between the sidewalks, plazas, parks, trails, and gathering spaces, all the things that
[1:47:04] determined how a community feels. Of course, a rendering can only show so much, and the
[1:47:11] balans will evolve over many years, and new buildings will be refined as the project
[1:47:15] develops. And that is why specific plans are such important tools. They set the framework
[1:47:20] to guide future development. And as you'll hear about more tonight, the balans' specific plan
[1:47:25] establishes a strong foundation for a place that's walkable, connected, sustainable, and built
[1:47:31] to a high standard of design.
[1:47:35] So tonight we'll be discussing the circulation network,
[1:47:38] which is built to accommodate all travel purposes and modes
[1:47:41] and this plan is informed by the city's bicycle and pedestrian master plan,
[1:47:45] and it's consistent with the goals in the Brisbane General Plan's circulation element.
[1:47:51] The network has five goals which you can see here on the slide
[1:47:55] and you've probably heard us refer to this project as a transit oriented development many times
[1:48:01] and this map really demonstrates why, not only is there a
[1:48:04] caltrain station in the middle of the valence, but the
[1:48:07] project is also served by Sam Trans, Unibus, UniliteRail, and
[1:48:13] commute.org. When you combine this transit rich location with
[1:48:17] new circulation features at the valence, we have an incredible
[1:48:20] opportunity to improve commutes, reduce submissions, and
[1:48:24] reduce our car usage as a whole. Next slide, please.
[1:48:31] So creating an
[1:48:32] entirely new roadway network at the Baylands gives us an unusual opportunity to design
[1:48:36] streets around community experience, rather than just moving cars from point A to point
[1:48:42] B. Geneva Avenue is a great example that you just heard about. The extension creates a major
[1:48:47] new East West connection through the Baylands, but it is designed to still accommodate people
[1:48:53] walking, biking, taking transit and also driving. The Geneva Avenue design also recognizes
[1:49:00] that this regional arterial roadway will pass alongside homes in neighborhood destinations
[1:49:05] and the plan therefore incorporates landscaping, generous pedestrian areas, protected
[1:49:10] bicycle facilities, and carefully design crossings to prioritize pedestrian safety and maintain
[1:49:17] the walkable neighborhood environment. As you move away from Geneva, the character of the streets
[1:49:22] deliberately changes. Again, you just heard a little bit about this, but the collector
[1:49:26] streets such as Bayland's Boulevard, Main Street, Campus Parkway, these all distribute traffic throughout
[1:49:32] the project at slower speeds while providing sidewalks and protected bicycle facilities.
[1:49:39] The Bayland's roadway network also introduces a new street type. These are called green shared streets.
[1:49:45] These slow streets provide access to residences and prioritize pedestrian and bicycle uses
[1:49:51] while still allowing for some vehicle access. As you can see in this rendering,
[1:49:55] which is on the bottom right side of the slide, these curbless streets use signature
[1:50:01] paving as well as landscaping and street furniture to create a sense of ease and comfort.
[1:50:08] And then another new element of the 2026 specific plan that you just heard about is the
[1:50:14] Bayshore Mobility Plan. And although this plan was studied as part of the secret process
[1:50:18] for the Baylands, I do want to clarify that this was a city proposal and it is not part
[1:50:24] of these specific plan project that BDI had proposed.
[1:50:29] Next slide, please.
[1:50:33] The same attention to safety and our roadway design
[1:50:35] carries throughout the broader bicycle and pedestrian
[1:50:38] network.
[1:50:39] The balance is a comprehensive system of on and off-street
[1:50:43] bikeways, running north-south and east-west.
[1:50:47] These won't enable people to safely ride bicycles
[1:50:50] and other mobility devices for everyday trips.
[1:50:53] The table on the slide explains some of the bicycle facility types.
[1:50:58] All of these put safety first, but the design varies based on location.
[1:51:02] So for example, busier roadways, such as the extension of Geneva Avenue,
[1:51:06] were protected by lanes to provide physical separation between bikes and moving vehicles.
[1:51:13] Connectivity is a central theme that you will hear a lot about tonight,
[1:51:17] and the bicycle network is a core part of that.
[1:51:19] These bike paths provide connectivity not only throughout the bailings, but they also connect people to existing bike networks, and they facilitate trips to downtown Brisbane, adjacent neighborhoods, and to the Bayshore Cal Transdation.
[1:51:32] I also want to note that recent data from transportation research record shows that building a low-stress connected bike network is the most reliable way to increase ridership.
[1:51:46] And that's why the bail-ins is designed to feel safe and comfortable for all users whether you need to drive or you want to try biking or getting around on foot.
[1:51:57] Next slide please.
[1:51:59] I'll some sorry for my voice.
[1:52:02] The balance is, as I mentioned, designed to strengthen connections to the region's extensive
[1:52:06] transit network.
[1:52:07] And as part of the strategy, new shuttle routes will integrate the balance into existing routes
[1:52:13] that connect to Brisbane transit.
[1:52:15] There are also five mobility hubs within the balance that are intended to provide both first
[1:52:21] and last mile transportation solutions.
[1:52:24] So if you look at the little circles that are on the slide here on the map
[1:52:30] One example could be that someone exits the Bay Short CalTransation. They could walk to that micro-mobility, or that mobility hub, excuse me, at the Cal Train Plaza, and then from there they could either pick up the shuttle, or they could get some sort of mobility device, like a bike share or a scooter to get to their final destination.
[1:52:52] This is also a key part of the Transportation Demand Management Program, which will provide public infrastructure and programming that enables people to be less dependent on cars.
[1:53:02] Some examples of TDM measures also include bike parking facilities, subsidized transit passes, and undubundled parking.
[1:53:10] So, taken all together, this plan is intended to really reduce reliance on cars and provide a comfortable and safe environment for people to get around in any way that they'd like to.
[1:53:22] Because the next slide, that will wrap up my presentation for tonight.
[1:53:27] Thank you for listening and we are happy to take any questions that you have.
[1:53:31] Thank you.
[1:53:31] Thank you, Katie.
[1:53:33] So again, in this particular topic, we're going to divide it into three sections.
[1:53:38] The first section, I'll just read them all first, first section will be on street sections.
[1:53:45] The second section will be on interface with regional transportation network.
[1:53:51] The third will be on the Geneva Avenue extension.
[1:53:54] We'll start with street sections and Mayor Protem Davis, you're up with your first, again,
[1:54:01] if we could each ask one question at a time.
[1:54:07] This one's a little bit long, so apologies in advance.
[1:54:12] But first of all, I just want to thank
[1:54:15] the developer for that presentation,
[1:54:17] because this is really the best example.
[1:54:25] I feel that you've given of what the future development
[1:54:29] might look and feel like and just to kind of have that sort of drone, style, footage. I think
[1:54:39] really gives much more of a sense of what we may be able to expect compared to just renderings.
[1:54:47] So thank you for putting that together. I do have a fundamental concern about the concept of green
[1:54:53] streets. They seem really cool and I'd love for them to work. I just, I'm concerned about
[1:55:02] streets as places where pedestrians, bicyclists, and vehicles are all mixing within the same space.
[1:55:10] And I don't think that this is necessarily an appropriate pedestrian environment for the
[1:55:21] I have no problem with traffic calming and 15 mile per hour targets to reduce speeds, but I don't think they really changed the fact that the pedestrians and moving vehicles are asked being asked to occupy the same space.
[1:55:37] And so if this is the council's pleasure, I would like to see us consider removing the concept of the green shared streets and provide more conventional separated pedestrian facilities on the streets with clearly defined space for vehicles and by schools and pedestrians.
[1:56:00] So, and I know that I can see why you've wanted to include this.
[1:56:11] I know that there have been other places that this has been done in the country, and there were some significant issues.
[1:56:19] So, yeah, it just is concern for me.
[1:56:22] Okay.
[1:56:23] Thank you.
[1:56:25] Council Member Kern.
[1:56:29] Thank you so much.
[1:56:30] I, in general, just have some concerns about the green shared streets.
[1:56:36] I know that I've experienced archival street in the city of Chicago, which was turned into sort
[1:56:44] of a commercial retail retrofit to make space for their night markets, if they got rid
[1:56:49] of curbs, they got rid of sidewalks, everything just sort of flows together.
[1:56:54] Like Mayor Pro Tem Davis said, it is an amazing concept, and I enjoy visiting there when I'm in Chicago, but I don't know how that works in a neighborhood with children present and children running about and combining that with cars by schools and any other mobility devices.
[1:57:11] So it was just a comment, not really a question. Thank you.
[1:57:16] Okay. Councilmember Lens.
[1:57:19] Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:57:20] Um, yeah, in regards to the green shared streets, if you would mind providing some examples of neighborhood type green shared streets, I hear what you're saying counts of memory curve about, uh, you know, activating more of a retail kind of environment. Um, so that that would be great.
[1:57:42] So my question is in regards to the bicycle sharing.
[1:57:46] So Katie, you did mention about bicycle sharing and in the sustainability framework, it talks
[1:57:51] about bicycle sharing a lot, but I didn't really see it in the specific plan, maybe I missed
[1:57:57] it.
[1:57:58] So, but it sounds like that is something that you're going to be implementing.
[1:58:04] And then if you wouldn't mind sharing with us how you would do that.
[1:58:08] Yeah, bike sharing is a key part of that TDM program that I mentioned, so transportation to band management
[1:58:15] usually offers a menu of options for folks to be less reliant on cars, and a bike share is a big part of that.
[1:58:23] How the bike share actually is implemented could be done in a lot of different ways.
[1:58:27] So for example, we could, you know, extend an existing bike share program into the bail-ins,
[1:58:32] we could create a new program, and that could be funded through sponsorships,
[1:58:36] like if you've seen the lift bikes or things like that,
[1:58:39] there's a lot of different ways
[1:58:40] you can go about operating that program,
[1:58:42] but bike sharing is definitely planned
[1:58:45] to be incorporated as part of the development
[1:58:47] so that folks can do that first and last mile
[1:58:51] transportation, as I mentioned.
[1:58:52] Got it, okay, so that'll be a part of your TDM plan,
[1:58:57] not the cities, right?
[1:58:58] Is that separate?
[1:59:00] Is that a new question just for staff
[1:59:02] in regards to the bicycle sharing?
[1:59:07] So the city has a required set of TEM program measures and then the developer, the specific
[1:59:15] plan does identify additional measures as well that they are proposing to just fulfill
[1:59:20] the vision as you just heard from there.
[1:59:24] If you give me a second, I can double check whether Bikeshare was in the city's required
[1:59:28] one or not.
[1:59:30] Okay.
[1:59:30] Thank you.
[1:59:32] Do you want us to move on while you look that up or is that at hand?
[1:59:42] I can have it as with 20 seconds.
[1:59:45] 20 seconds we can wait.
[1:59:47] It's also in the TDM measure that's in the specific plan chapter 6.
[1:59:53] I see it on page 6, 46.
[1:59:56] About bike share and shared micro mobility would be one of the physical features used.
[2:00:00] As TDM, including a shared fleet of bikes, cargo bikes and scooters, four multi-mobile trips through the planning area.
[2:00:12] Is that a consideration or something that is a shell?
[2:00:18] So it's not, I was able to confirm, it's not within the cities because there is no no program right now in San Mateo County.
[2:00:25] So Brisbane can't require it as a TDM measure, but from what you've heard from the developer,
[2:00:34] like that's one of their key strategies that would be, I guess you'd call it an optional
[2:00:39] strategy, but to fulfill the vision and also to hit the targets that they've identified in terms
[2:00:47] of reducing the amount of traffic the project generates.
[2:00:50] Thank you. Thank you for incorporating that.
[2:00:53] Council Member O'Connell?
[2:00:56] Thank you.
[2:00:57] I found the video interesting.
[2:01:01] It did show CalTrain tracks at grade with the development.
[2:01:07] And in our specific plan,
[2:01:12] and I might be looking at the older one,
[2:01:16] 6-21,
[2:01:17] it shows CalTrain tracks at grade with frontage road in the development. So I don't
[2:01:25] understand how if they are raising the level of where buildings are going to be
[2:01:34] and putting them on pads and all that, how CalTrain tracks are at grade.
[2:01:44] So do we
[2:01:44] have an answer for that?
[2:01:50] And is it the developers responsibility to pay for
[2:01:53] train to become at grade.
[2:02:08] We would like to look into this little further and this could be part of our
[2:02:13] phasing discussion in the next meeting. Great, thank you. Okay. I'm going to go back to the green
[2:02:21] streets and I'm going to kind of parlay off before it was already been said and reading it, it's a
[2:02:28] wonderful, interesting concept, I could see it in a city with very short blocks with very
[2:02:35] little traffic.
[2:02:37] And my concern is UPS FedEx Amazon, postal service vehicles, and there's no parking or
[2:02:43] loading zones.
[2:02:44] So they're going to double park and then you're going to have people with their chase lounges
[2:02:49] in the other lane.
[2:02:50] And my bigger fear is, since we have these arterials north south, some existing and some
[2:02:59] ones, the people who will discover these streets for short cuts and the danger that that would
[2:03:05] pose to the pedestrian. So mine is kind of a comment and kind of again request to revisit this.
[2:03:14] I think maybe just considering the area and everything surrounding it, he's still kind of
[2:03:20] industrial and we're putting kids in the street. I'm not sure it's going to be something that would be
[2:03:28] available there. So that's the question comment from me. We're moving back again to
[2:03:33] Matt and Mary, we do have a response if you would like to just get a little more information on that.
[2:03:41] Yeah, so a couple things. The design standards for one do require this follows FHWA guidelines
[2:03:48] require two things. One, a separated ADA accessible pathway so you can think of that as your
[2:03:54] So pedestrians will always have a place to be outside of the next upper, the next area.
[2:04:03] And secondly, it also includes loading, parking and loading within the street.
[2:04:10] So you can imagine that there is a 20 foot right away that probably will move from one side of the street to the other,
[2:04:16] using a traffic calming feature called horizontal deflection,
[2:04:21] making sure that cars are not driving straight through easily and on the other side there
[2:04:27] will be space for planting those space for bike parking loading parking and the city would
[2:04:36] enforce double parking in the same way as any other street so yeah it would be it would be a
[2:04:42] legal for for Amazon vehicles to be double parking in the in the next area okay thank you very much
[2:04:51] Back to questions, Council Member O'Connell, you're teed up first.
[2:05:01] Again, on the green streets, some of them show emptying onto main streets that are not part of the specific plan.
[2:05:13] And in the specific plan, they were talking 84 cars per hour.
[2:05:22] 1,000 cars per 24 hours average on these green streets, which is 84 cars per hour using a 12-hour period, which is 2 per minute.
[2:05:34] When we had our, as an antidote, when we had our Halloween event, we closed off our streets so kids could be in the street and use them.
[2:05:46] So, I don't understand how those two things work when they're anticipating one car every two minutes in their analysis per page 6-18.
[2:06:04] So, to clarify that, so the 1000 vehicle threshold is the maximum that the city would.
[2:06:09] So there is a mitigation measure built into the EIR that describes using both what FHWA has
[2:06:17] recommended for these types of residential shared streets that are, you know, kind of in many
[2:06:22] cities across the country.
[2:06:24] And so they have a threshold for making sure that you don't exceed 1,000 vehicles and you
[2:06:29] don't exceed 15 miles per hour.
[2:06:32] The city of San Francisco has been using that as a threshold for slow streets, for example,
[2:06:37] which are quite a bit wider, as you're probably aware,
[2:06:40] because they're reversing existing streets.
[2:06:42] So they have to do a lot more to make sure
[2:06:45] that there aren't 1,000 vehicles in 15 miles an hour.
[2:06:48] They've done extensive studies that have showed collisions
[2:06:51] have dropped substantially since they implemented those programs
[2:06:55] because cars are moving very slowly.
[2:06:57] Cars know that they, when they're there,
[2:06:59] they're in a shared space.
[2:07:01] So there is quite a bit of evidence out there
[2:07:03] about these and studies about these types of streets
[2:07:06] I just wanted to bring to your attention and and a mitigation measure that the city would be required to monitor safety on those streets.
[2:07:15] Thank you.
[2:07:18] Mayor Pro time Davis.
[2:07:21] I don't have any more on streets at the street sections.
[2:07:27] Council Member Kahn.
[2:07:30] No further questions on streets? Councilmember Lens. Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[2:07:39] So, all right. So, page 30, the same billy frame where it talks about free shuttle service, connecting central Brisbane, the Northeast Ridge and Sierra Point with the bay on land.
[2:07:51] an emerald around in Emoryville has a shuttle. It goes from 6 to 10, money through Friday and Saturdays 8 to 10 and an on Sundays from 9 to 7.
[2:08:07] So in the specific plan, it's 6.5.1, the valians shut around, it has a map.
[2:08:20] And the schedule is pretty similar to the commute.org schedule.
[2:08:28] So I'm just kind of curious, it makes it sound like you're providing the shuttle for us,
[2:08:34] but it really seems like it's just kind of overlaying the commute.org shuttle at the same time.
[2:08:42] So if you in line kind of clarifying that, like, how is it different?
[2:08:52] If we could maybe bring back up the slide with the shuttle map on it, I'm sorry, I think it was slide six maybe.
[2:09:03] But to answer your question, there's the shuttle routes are going to be serving different purposes.
[2:09:10] Here, yes, I think we, sorry, it's a little small, so it's a little hard to read.
[2:09:14] So, yes, there's an existing commute.org shuttle that will connect into the bail-ins,
[2:09:21] but also there's plans for a bail-ins-specific shuttle, which will run, you know, as you
[2:09:25] can see, not only within the bail-ins, but it'll also go to downtown Central Brisbane,
[2:09:31] as well, to connect folks there.
[2:09:34] So these are our different shuttle's, and they will operate in different ways.
[2:09:38] And, of course, we've suggested a phased out approach to the shuttle, because on, you
[2:09:43] You know, day one, we're not going to have the demand for the full shuttle capacity, so that
[2:09:49] will ramp up as if we have more commuters and more folks living at the Baylands and there's
[2:09:54] more demand for the shuttle.
[2:09:56] Yeah.
[2:09:56] Yeah.
[2:09:56] The framework, though, it calls out for shuttle's also going to the Northeast Ridge and also going to
[2:10:02] SharePoint, you know, making those connections.
[2:10:06] So I'm just curious why that wasn't a part of your shuttle route.
[2:10:13] schedule. And I understand that right there are different
[2:10:17] shettles. I mean, one's going to be a commit.
[2:10:19] Orc Shuttle and another one's going to be a BLN's one,
[2:10:22] but this route that you're showing here, you can see it's
[2:10:26] as it impacts Brisbane, both of the most parts,
[2:10:30] have for a little part of downtown Brisbane.
[2:10:34] It's kind of serving the same people.
[2:10:36] Yeah, I think I'd have to look into that a little bit more
[2:10:39] since the ridge and sear point aren't part of the specific planned project area, they're obviously
[2:10:44] not featured on this map, but we can dig into that a little bit and chat with staff about
[2:10:49] what the existing shuttle connections are with those areas. That'd be great and it also says that
[2:10:56] the shuttle route shall be implemented before a certificate of occupancy is issued for more than 50%
[2:11:03] have a permitted commercial floor area.
[2:11:06] So I'm just curious, what if there's 49% bill?
[2:11:13] Is that 50% triggers to do the route?
[2:11:19] If you don't do the 50%, you're not obligated.
[2:11:26] So yeah, what there's several layers of obligations here,
[2:11:32] the project is going to be held to. Okay. The first thing that the project is going to be
[2:11:38] obligated to any individual buildings will have to contribute to commute.org shuttles
[2:11:44] and as a part of their TDM program. And so that's a required part of the city's program.
[2:11:51] And so what you can imagine and what has happened in many other communities. I'll use Berlin
[2:11:56] game as an example, where as new development comes online, they are increased the frequency
[2:12:02] of their shuttle services, they update their routes, their shuttles are not fixed, they serve
[2:12:10] as the man flows and so you can imagine as the demand would increase, they would have
[2:12:15] a responsibility for Kumi.org would adjust their shuttle to serve the project.
[2:12:20] So what the obligations with respect to the Bayland specific shuttle, which presumably they
[2:12:26] would select an operator to do that, other developments have selected community.org but what
[2:12:34] you just heard from the developers that it could be something separate as well. So there
[2:12:39] will be obligations in kind of zero through 50 but what the specific one says is that by the
[2:12:46] 50th occupancy you need to have these routes in place.
[2:12:50] Okay. So I think you answered my question. So obviously commute.org is going to be, you
[2:13:00] know, doing the route. They're doing it now, whether the bail-and-skissive
[2:13:19] That's that's correct. Okay, just having that clarification. Thank you. Yeah, thanks. Okay
[2:13:26] Okay, it's my turn. I'm gonna come back to Green Street
[2:13:29] You mentioned a 15 mile an hour speed limit and from my tenure on the planning commission
[2:13:35] I believe I was told unless it's changed a 15 mile per hour speed limit is
[2:13:41] Uninforceable in the state of California could someone verify that for me, please
[2:13:47] A 15 mile an hour speed limit is enforceable in certain situations such as in school zones,
[2:13:54] alleyways, and similar types, and you know the type of shared street that is designed to
[2:13:59] hear.
[2:13:59] So San Francisco enforces 15 mile an hour speed limits on their slow streets is the easiest
[2:14:04] comparable example.
[2:14:07] So the way that this is proposed would fit that criteria.
[2:14:11] That is correct.
[2:14:11] it falls the design standards from the State of California and from the FHWA for this type
[2:14:17] of facility.
[2:14:18] Okay.
[2:14:19] Very good.
[2:14:19] Thank you.
[2:14:20] You're welcome.
[2:14:21] You're welcome.
[2:14:22] I'm just going to verify again, Davis and Kern no questions on this.
[2:14:30] Okay.
[2:14:30] I have shadow questions.
[2:14:33] We're going to name that.
[2:14:34] Next.
[2:14:34] It's actually the shuttle was another section.
[2:14:37] Oh, I'm sorry.
[2:14:38] I kind of jumped ahead of us because I have shadow questions.
[2:14:40] I didn't I didn't know that was in one of those things. I was kind of regional transit. Oh, okay. I think there's a next section.
[2:14:50] Got it got more on street sections. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. All right. I wasn't sure about that. So
[2:14:56] all right. So Mister JJ talks about
[2:15:00] I mean, I'm sorry. The sustainable framework talks about, you know, having detail plan reducing personal parking and incorporating car share programs and shared parking, you know, between uses.
[2:15:18] But in the specific plan, it has 6.7 has 11,000 Austria parking spaces. So I was just wondering how the maximum.
[2:15:29] the parking maximums were calculated,
[2:15:32] because that just seems like a lot if we're talking about
[2:15:35] having a transit public transit
[2:15:37] oriented development.
[2:15:44] Which is one of the developed
[2:15:44] to explain the framework first.
[2:15:47] Sure.
[2:15:48] I might bring up Megan from Nelson Nagar
[2:15:50] to speak about that.
[2:15:52] We actually have a pretty innovative
[2:15:55] parking plan that actually is is very limited
[2:15:58] on parking with the intent of
[2:16:00] reducing the number of vehicle trips on the bail-ins, but I'll let Megan talk about it a little
[2:16:05] bit more.
[2:16:10] Hi, everyone.
[2:16:11] Megan, we are from Nelson-Neguard, supporting the bail-ins.
[2:16:15] And I can tell you a little bit about how the parking framework was developed and if I'm
[2:16:23] not addressing the question specifically, let me know, but back in several years ago, when
[2:16:30] the TDM measures and parking management concept
[2:16:36] we're being developed, the team looked at all
[2:16:39] of the different land uses that were being proposed
[2:16:41] and looked at the kind of standard widely recognized
[2:16:49] parking generation numbers that are used across the country
[2:16:56] that come from ITE and then identified what would be considered a baseline number of parking
[2:17:04] spaces for those land uses and then paused and identified a preference for reducing the
[2:17:13] baseline based on wanting to reduce trip generation overall and to keep all of the development
[2:17:20] plans consistent with the goals and values around transit oriented development and went through
[2:17:29] a few different scenarios of different transportation demand management measures that could
[2:17:33] be used to reduce parking, referred to some of the kind of research-based calculations
[2:17:39] about how much each measure could reduce parking demand for different land uses, and then landed
[2:17:45] on a 43% reduction and so that 11,000 cap for the entire development represents the total
[2:17:54] number of parking spaces for all of the different districts in the development with a little
[2:17:59] bit of buffer rounded up to a nice round number that gets to about 41% lower than baseline assuming
[2:18:07] that those different transportation demand management measures are put into place so that parking
[2:18:13] demand can be reduced at each of those building types, and that's a mix of things that have
[2:18:18] already been talked about tonight, like making it easier for people to just choose to
[2:18:23] get around without a car, internal trip capture, having an X of land uses so that people
[2:18:28] who live in the development don't need to use a car to get everywhere within this development,
[2:18:34] having connections outside, different, you know, modes available at the mobility hubs that
[2:18:40] mentioned and then parking management, unbundling parking, like Katie mentioned also, so that
[2:18:48] people have to opt into parking for different uses. It's not automatically included because
[2:18:54] automatically including parking encourages people to use cars for all their trips. And those things
[2:19:00] can apply at residential office retail and so on. And there's opportunities to phase the building
[2:19:09] of parking, so there can be slightly higher ratios early in the early phases of development
[2:19:15] to accommodate the parking demand might be higher at the points where not all of those
[2:19:24] TDM measures are fully robust and in place, and more people are choosing driving for some
[2:19:31] of their trips.
[2:19:32] And then as more development comes online, the ratio of parking to new development can
[2:19:37] down to reach that total maximum of 11,000.
[2:19:42] All right.
[2:19:42] Thank you.
[2:19:42] Thank you.
[2:19:42] That was very detailed.
[2:19:45] Council Member O'Connell?
[2:19:48] So this, and this is a question, I think, for the developer.
[2:19:54] So that means when you're talking about uncoupling parking, so a home or an apartment may not have parking
[2:20:03] with the building you'd have to buy it separate. That's what uncoupled parking means.
[2:20:11] Not quite, so there is accommodations to have parking as part of residential units.
[2:20:16] So for example, if you've a town home, there may be one or two parking spaces associated with that type of housing.
[2:20:24] But the unbundled parking specifically is generally around commercial retail uses.
[2:20:30] potentially some for like the apartment, high-density residential. So we're having these big parking
[2:20:36] garages rather than preserving the entire parking garage for one user, where, you know,
[2:20:41] maybe it's really full doing the day and then at night everyone goes home and then you have this
[2:20:44] empty parking garage. So instead those garages are intended to be unbundled where anyone who's running
[2:20:51] errands, someone who's going to work, all have access to that same space, and that can be managed
[2:20:57] through, you know, certain reservations, or paid parking, things like that.
[2:21:04] And then you also just mentioned that the parking is higher at the beginning of the build,
[2:21:09] which means that the homes are going to get the parking, and later there will be less parking
[2:21:15] available.
[2:21:16] So there's actually a district-based cap so that 11,000 parking stalls is for the entire development,
[2:21:24] But each district also has its own parking, actually sorry if we wouldn't mind bringing the slides up again towards the end I have a few reference slides and in there I think I have a chart with the district caps.
[2:21:38] But so exactly we don't want to have all the parking get absorbed in those first couple phases of development and then there's no parking left for the end so if you keep going towards the end of this deck.
[2:21:51] There, oh, back one more.
[2:21:54] So, as you can see,
[2:21:55] BASHOR district has 1,150.
[2:21:59] Roundhouse district, 1,200.
[2:22:02] So, those are probably going to be primarily dedicated to
[2:22:06] residences.
[2:22:07] And then, you have more in the Ice House Hill district,
[2:22:09] where you have more commercial and same on the campus east.
[2:22:12] And I should make a little
[2:22:13] Astroxia note.
[2:22:14] This chart actually came from our 2025 developer proposed
[2:22:19] specific plan and so that maybe could correct me this may have shifted slightly as some
[2:22:25] of the land uses have been adjusted in the 2020-26 staff recommended specific.
[2:22:31] Thank you. Okay, I have a question on this
[2:22:40] under roadway performance standards, and this is talking about
[2:22:45] bass shore and it was it was talking about changes in design speeds along bass shore could
[2:22:54] improve mobility within the city and I just I wondered that particular wording did anybody
[2:23:04] taken to consideration that San Mateo County and C.C.C.C.C put together the smart lanes which
[2:23:12] are actually going to offload traffic from 101 on to Bayshore?
[2:23:20] Yes, yes. That's under emergency situations. It would be used to divert. But Bayshore is still
[2:23:27] not a state-owned facility. Bayshore is owned by the city of Brisbane. So the city of Brisbane
[2:23:34] has decisions such as how much of a role it should serve in terms of being an attractive
[2:23:43] route for every day travel on compared to the freeway. But we would have no control
[2:23:51] my knowledge of the smart corridor and lanes are if if there's an extreme slowdown on 101,
[2:23:58] they will start those electronic signboards saying you can divert this way off onto surface streets
[2:24:06] was was what I was given as an orientation on those smart lanes and I know that we would have
[2:24:13] control to say, oh, no, you can't get off in prison being.
[2:24:18] Do we know?
[2:24:22] In those emergency scenarios, it would be under Cal Trans that they would initiate that.
[2:24:28] I have looked at the agreements, the draft agreement we haven't authorized, but there's nothing
[2:24:34] in the language that says that we cannot change the configuration of, be sure.
[2:24:39] So we could still reduce, not say I'm not proposing we do that right now, I'm just saying we still have control over what that network looks like.
[2:24:47] I understand, I'm really just questioning the wisdom of doing that knowing that we could have an onslaught of traffic.
[2:24:54] That's a good not seen before.
[2:24:56] It's a good question.
[2:24:59] Well, that's my point.
[2:25:00] All right, we're back to Councilmember Lens.
[2:25:06] We have more questions.
[2:25:08] Yeah, I have one more.
[2:25:10] So 6.6, it talks about TDM coordinator,
[2:25:15] who we were responsible for overseeing all TDM activities within the Baylands,
[2:25:19] including monitoring and reporting.
[2:25:21] So I'm just curious, is this a full-time position?
[2:25:25] And it's also, is it a city position?
[2:25:28] It's
[2:25:34] the type of position, and community.org has manages the interface with TDM coordinators,
[2:25:42] and it's the type of position that for smaller projects, it's typically shared, and then
[2:25:47] as you grow, it becomes, yes, a much more responsible position.
[2:25:52] The specific plan does not designate who it is, but, you know, community.org has a standard
[2:25:59] process for onboarding or TDM coordinators and making sure that that is that they're responsible.
[2:26:05] Okay, and then the the VTN standards they were based on 2020, which is during the pandemic.
[2:26:12] So that doesn't seem like a good base year.
[2:26:16] pre pre-Pemben, demo conditions? Yeah the the the last time C-Cag updated their model information is based on you know
[2:26:26] 2019 through January 2020 basically so when it's referring to 2020 it's it's pre-Pemben,
[2:26:32] conditions. It is pre-Pemben, I got it. Sorry for the confusion. All right because it does say 2020 and it doesn't say
[2:26:37] pre-Pemben, I understood. Okay, thank you. Okay, Councilmember好 call.
[2:26:46] think my questions either are going to come under financing and or when we discuss the
[2:26:56] Geneva Avenue, which is another subject matter.
[2:26:59] Okay, so I have two more on street sections.
[2:27:03] My next question is, I believe and so don't quote me, I believe the latest statistics show
[2:27:10] It's San Mateo County is 64 or 65% seniors, and we've talked about mobility within the
[2:27:18] balans and affordable housing and using bicycles.
[2:27:23] What provisions are being made for seniors to have mobility in the balans?
[2:27:32] The entire project will be compliant with ADA standards for folks who get around with
[2:27:39] other types of mobility devices, and of course, maybe not all folks are going to write
[2:27:43] bike, but there are options for other ways of getting around either through shuttles that
[2:27:50] probably have ADA compliant accessibility options.
[2:27:57] And there's also opportunities for some
[2:28:00] of the affordable housing to potentially serve seniors. And sometimes in those cases those
[2:28:04] housing developments may have additional measures to help seniors get around.
[2:28:11] So referencing an early early or question about the schedule kind of mirroring commute.org.
[2:28:18] It does this not kind of point to the need for the shuttle to run more frequently.
[2:28:25] As you're not going to have seniors going around.
[2:28:27] Well, I think so of your seniors who are living at the Baylands.
[2:28:31] They will have the options to take the Baylands shuttle also to get around to the existing retail and other services within the Baylands.
[2:28:39] And so again, the goal of a mixed use community is that folks can run errands, and they can go to work,
[2:28:47] although seniors may or may not be going to work, and do all that within the area.
[2:28:53] And then, of course, that they need to travel outside of the bailings.
[2:28:57] There are ample opportunities to do that through transit and through other ways that aren't biking or things that might be difficult.
[2:29:03] Am I reading this that you are making a commitment to frequency of that shuttle?
[2:29:08] So we have outline schedules in the specific plan.
[2:29:12] I don't have them in front of me right now,
[2:29:14] but there is a schedule outline for both phase one and phase two.
[2:29:19] And we could probably bring that up for you.
[2:29:21] Actually, I have it if you, I can read it to you.
[2:29:23] That's a great thing.
[2:29:24] So yeah, phase one on weekdays.
[2:29:27] It's 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. with a maximum of 15 minute headways.
[2:29:32] And then on weekends, that would be 10 to 5 on demand.
[2:29:36] And then if there was enough demand for it, it would expand to a fixed route with fixed
[2:29:43] headways like there are on weekdays.
[2:29:45] For phase two, it's 6 a.m. to 9 a.m. and then forward a 6 p.m. with one hour headways
[2:29:52] That's the east side, more the employment-based shuttle, and 10-5 on-demand service on weekends.
[2:30:00] But that fees one shuttle that Katie was describing, the weekday service does have a 15 minute headway
[2:30:06] maximum and this could be short or depending on demand.
[2:30:09] Thank you, Eric, very much.
[2:30:12] Is that a particular point of buildout?
[2:30:15] Yes, so the fees one obligation as council member Lens was pointing up before is triggered
[2:30:22] at 50% occupancy of commercial for area within the ice house hill district.
[2:30:30] is the trigger to be at that level of service and as Matt was describing and
[2:30:35] response to the question, the TDM plan might have incremental service earlier
[2:30:42] than that. That's the trigger for delivery. If the commercial hasn't been
[2:30:46] built, if it's just homes, they don't need to have any shuttles. Correct. That's
[2:30:52] not, they would not have hit the trigger for that phase one shuttle. I don't
[2:30:57] Matt, if there's an interim delivery of not described there, I mean there's several references to
[2:31:06] on-demand shuttles as well. It says, in on-demand shuttle is the type of, you know, that you call if you need, there's one in the
[2:31:14] Bay view that operates right now in San Francisco, but in on-demand strategy allows shuttle operators to scale up as
[2:31:21] and shifts and grows and eliminates how, yeah, time of day and location.
[2:31:27] So note note fixed route services are called for in the, in the
[2:31:31] valance plan until that threshold that he described, that there are other strategies
[2:31:36] that are identified in decades.
[2:31:41] Thank you.
[2:31:42] Council member Lens?
[2:31:45] No more questions that are.
[2:31:46] Okay.
[2:31:46] So I have just one more.
[2:31:50] We saw, thank you for the video, with all the 3D views, and then you ended with a slide
[2:32:01] that showed active transportation networks.
[2:32:04] Could we possibly put that slide up again?
[2:32:31] I'm sorry, what page am I going to?
[2:32:33] It was near the end, Angel, it has a heading active transportation network.
[2:32:40] I think that actually might have been my second slide.
[2:32:45] That should the map.
[2:32:45] There we go.
[2:32:48] Since we've never seen this before.
[2:32:51] I mean, this is the first time for all of us seeing this view.
[2:32:54] And it shows where we can clearly see streets.
[2:32:59] What I wanted to ask is, does this show the Schlake Lock development?
[2:33:06] It does.
[2:33:06] Yes.
[2:33:06] So this map is from our website, and so thank you for clarifying that.
[2:33:12] We do consider the bail-ins to be both the, we call it kind of bail-in-sports and bail-in-sales.
[2:33:17] So that includes our, I think, approximately 48, or it's a property, the former Schleglock
[2:33:21] Property and San Francisco.
[2:33:23] We call that the Leeland Square neighborhood, and it's intended to be the northernmost
[2:33:27] neighborhood of the bail-ins.
[2:33:29] And then that will flow into the broader frizz-fane bail-ins, which of course is the more
[2:33:34] significant portion of the development. And so when you see that yellow
[2:33:38] immunity, that is referring to the T3, so like the Arlita stop, for example,
[2:33:43] right in front of the former Schlag lock office building, which is now office building.
[2:33:49] And then the development continues until sunny day all where the county line is.
[2:33:56] And could you point out where that is? It's where the second,
[2:34:00] So the second mini block rectangle is Sunnydale and that's the end of the Schlaglock development.
[2:34:09] Yeah, that's the sample.
[2:34:10] Everything to the left all the way up to the V is all the Schlaglock development.
[2:34:16] Are there streets in there?
[2:34:17] It doesn't, I don't really, there are.
[2:34:20] So to be existing streets in visitation valley for the most part will continue through the development.
[2:34:27] So that's why we call it Leeland Square.
[2:34:30] Leeland Avenue is a kind of corridor where there's a lot of retail activity in Viz Valley.
[2:34:36] And so Leeland will continue through the development.
[2:34:39] So we'll sunny Dale on sunny Dale.
[2:34:41] We'll have a turnaround at the CalTrain, Plaza, I'm testing my memory.
[2:34:46] I think a couple of the other streets will also continue through the development.
[2:34:52] So it goes then signalized intersections on Bayshore since if we look south, where we start in the Brisbane portion,
[2:35:01] there are no arterioles that cut straight through on each of those blocks.
[2:35:06] And I should clarify those streets that cut through will not go past the Cal Train.
[2:35:11] So they will end in the development.
[2:35:15] So those won't be a cut through to get to like 101, for example, the way to need that will be.
[2:35:19] but going west will they will they intersect with basure? Yes. So are those all going to be
[2:35:27] signalized? Yes. So they're currently signalized? Right. And so I imagine they will become a
[2:35:33] four-way intersection. Okay. So there's there's maybe three or four arterials that are going to
[2:35:40] cross, slag lock to basure. Sunny Dale, Leeland, and I don't know what deal. And I think I think
[2:35:46] Maybe Raymond, again, I don't have the Schleglock plans in front of me.
[2:35:49] I'd have to refer back to them.
[2:35:51] But I think Raymond has a traffic island that blocks it from base short.
[2:35:55] You can turn right if you're going south, but I don't think you can go.
[2:35:59] You can't exit Raymond.
[2:36:01] I don't believe.
[2:36:02] Perhaps not.
[2:36:03] But again, I don't have that plan in front of me.
[2:36:05] Right.
[2:36:06] No, I'm not trying to put you on the spot.
[2:36:07] I'm just trying to visualize how this interfaces with all the the transportation.
[2:36:12] So thank you very much.
[2:36:13] I appreciate that.
[2:36:15] All right.
[2:36:15] I think that concludes the street sections, and we have a question from the public, Michael Barnes, on street sections.
[2:36:29] Michael Barnes, Brisbane resident, formality, I'm going to be talking about bicycle network on the valence,
[2:36:36] but I'm currently the chair of the San Mateo County Bicycle Pedestrian Advisory Committee,
[2:36:40] who we oversee the unincorporated parts of San Mateo County.
[2:36:43] I'm not speaking in that capacity, I'm speaking in the capacity as a private citizen of Brisbane.
[2:36:48] So, most people who do not write bicycles cite the danger of automobiles and trucks as a reason why.
[2:36:54] To actually encourage bicycling requires isolation of bicyclists from motor vehicles to the greatest extent possible.
[2:36:59] Thankfully, the empty canvas of the baylands allows us to maximize bicyclists protections.
[2:37:06] The specific plan recognizes this issue, the specific plan states that the baylands will include a network of protected bikeways that provide physical separation from moving vehicles.
[2:37:14] This type of bikeway reduces the level of stress and improves comfort for more types of bicyclists and therefore contributes to an increase in bicycle volumes and mode share
[2:37:24] Connections are also made to the existing bike network to facilitate trips to downtown Brisbane adjacent neighborhoods
[2:37:30] And to increase connectivity to the bayshire couch transportation.
[2:37:36] So I agree with all of that. And I think that it also mentions on page 34 of the PDF of the specific plan that landscaping provides added protection from vehicles. I agree with this. Let's use landscaping to protect bicyclists. A number of the figures, cross sections of the streets have,
[2:37:59] A lane of motor vehicles, then flanked by a bicyclist, a class 2 bike lane, and then a row of vegetation landscaping trees and then pedestrians.
[2:38:13] I think kind of the overarching vision I'd have is to swap the position of the trees with a bike lane so that the motor vehicles then have trees on their right and then a bike lane and then pedestrian facilities.
[2:38:28] And if it's being proposed this way in specific, specific plan to protect pedestrians from bicycles you can merely put in a fence between the two of you if you're uncomfortable with that.
[2:38:41] But the real hazard is cars and trucks hitting bicyclists.
[2:38:49] So intersections with both bicycles and motor vehicles should be avoided.
[2:38:53] intersections are deadly to bicyclists. And class two bike lanes are exactly what
[2:38:58] reluctant bicyclists cite for not riding on the street. Class two bike lane is
[2:39:03] paint or I don't know, this idea of a curb, you know, between a bicyclist and a
[2:39:09] car being a protection. I'm not sure I buy into it, especially if it's a
[2:39:12] rolled curb, a lot of the curbs in this project are rolled. And I think that's just
[2:39:16] to encourage cars to park in the bike lane.
[2:39:19] So, you know, maybe there's reasons,
[2:39:22] engineering reasons for that, but that's my take.
[2:39:27] I thought that Class II bike lane is being proposed
[2:39:30] for BASHA or Boulevard, which is what we have now,
[2:39:33] and that's why he's reluctant cyclists don't use it.
[2:39:36] I think you should also include in tables 6.4.2,
[2:39:42] Class II bike lane definition, it's not in there.
[2:39:46] I'd like to point out that tunnel road, or I'm running out of time, I'm going to leave you
[2:39:51] a copy of my comments, tunnel road I think should be a class for a bike facility on the
[2:39:58] east, on the west side of tunnel road, 10 times as many bicyclists use tunnel road to
[2:40:04] go from San Francisco to South City and beyond as used Bayshore.
[2:40:08] So I did account 20 years ago in order to figure out where we should put our bike to work
[2:40:14] day, energizer station.
[2:40:16] And I did accounts, and then we actually had an energizer station on-base or boulevard.
[2:40:22] And consistently, 10 times more bicyclists use tonal road as use-base shore.
[2:40:28] I think you should get rid of the vegetated median strips between the traffic lanes and
[2:40:33] dedicate that road with to protect bicyclists. I like, I like Sierra Point Parkway,
[2:40:42] Visitation Creek, and Lagoon Road. Those are exactly sorts of streetscapes that I'm
[2:40:46] talking about. Those are great.
[2:40:49] I'm out of time. The front is road. Six foot buffers should
[2:40:54] be a bike lane and if possible include the Caltering right of way. Anyway, I will leave my
[2:41:00] the rest of my comments with the city clerk.
[2:41:04] And before you depart, I have a question for you.
[2:41:07] When you talked about swapping the trees with the bike lane,
[2:41:10] do you not create another hazard for the bicyclist?
[2:41:14] Because any bicyclist who wants to turn left
[2:41:17] is not seen because they're obscured by the trees.
[2:41:21] And then they'd be pulling in front of cars
[2:41:23] that wouldn't even see them coming over.
[2:41:25] Well, I think that the sections show a bowdouts and and protected bicycle
[2:41:33] Cueing lines at corners where they'd be crossing streets. I don't I don't see that as a problem
[2:41:39] Well, I mean if you were at an intersection you have a bicycle into your right
[2:41:43] Sometimes the bicyclists have to try to get all the way over. They're waiting for cars to cut across
[2:41:49] I don't know if that's how it works that that was just when you when you mentioned that
[2:41:54] I was just concerned about trees obscuring the bicyclists.
[2:41:58] You could use bushes, though.
[2:42:00] I think it mean you could do some kind of more prominent barrier
[2:42:05] right between something that's maybe not as tall,
[2:42:10] so there would still be visibility of a bike.
[2:42:12] Is that what you were suggesting?
[2:42:14] I'm suggesting, putting landscaping or bearish physical barriers
[2:42:18] between automobiles and bicycles.
[2:42:20] I don't care what it is.
[2:42:22] And site distances are all accommodated in the specific plan as is, you know, all those of the corners that kind of stuff I don't think.
[2:42:29] I think that intersections are a problem, but there as engineered as it can be in the specific plan.
[2:42:35] So I'm concerned about people writing encouraging people to ride bicycles.
[2:42:38] I mean, we've known this for 20, 30, 40 years that people who don't commute by bicycle are afraid of vehicles, and they don't feel comfortable on class two bike.
[2:42:47] So that's what classes four is so good.
[2:42:49] And I heard the consultant say tunnels class four,
[2:42:51] but I thought that figure 3.6.3.20 mean 12
[2:42:55] showed by queens on either side of tunnel
[2:42:57] road next to the vehicle lane.
[2:43:01] So it'd be nice if I could get answers
[2:43:03] to some of this stuff at some point.
[2:43:05] If you could pass it onto staff then they can.
[2:43:09] I don't care, I'd let you on that.
[2:43:10] Thanks Michael.
[2:43:13] Sure you have a follow up question.
[2:43:14] Yeah, just based on what Michael is saying. I mean, to be there's his suggestions make a lot of
[2:43:21] sense, particularly about having a more distinct barrier between cars and bike lanes. And so
[2:43:29] I just didn't know there is some practical reason why maybe it's not that way right now. And if that's
[2:43:38] that could we could re-evaluate and bring back at a later time so that we are making this as
[2:43:46] bike friendly as possible because I think it really at the core of what all of us are looking to
[2:43:51] accomplish, right, is to have this be a development in which people aren't relying on vehicles so
[2:43:58] much. They're using transit. They're biking. They're walking. There's a lot of connectivity and so
[2:44:04] we're going to achieve that, and that also supports our sustainable goals too.
[2:44:10] If we're going to achieve that, then we need to make biking really viable option for people.
[2:44:18] So, is it enough?
[2:44:20] Yeah, sure.
[2:44:20] Happy to answer that.
[2:44:21] I mean, in terms of what the specific planning includes, includes clear standards that all the
[2:44:28] class for facilities, which I can confirm tunnel road, it would be a separated class for facility with
[2:44:34] a raised buffer consistent with the NACDO design's urban bike weight design guide, and so that's really what this
[2:44:42] the specific plan is based on is making sure that all the facilities provide that low stress, all ages and abilities separated, physically separated, not just a payment line from cars, including at intersections, every single intersection with bikes.
[2:45:00] And a class for facility would be a protected intersection. And so that allowed pork rides that protected space for bikes to wait while they cross, so that they're not having to mix with vehicles for sample at intersection.
[2:45:14] So that the bikeways don't kind of end before the intersection.
[2:45:18] In terms of like swapping the landscape with the kind of the raised buffer, I don't think that there's necessarily anything prohibiting that the that's the type of design review that
[2:45:29] You know, when streets are being designed, they have to be designed to the standards, I'm not sure that this visit plan would include that, but that's certainly something that we could look at.
[2:45:41] Yeah, I'll just emphasize that yeah, there's engineering design phase of when streets get designed and and that's why it relies heavily on setting best practices like the design good.
[2:45:53] Thank you very much. You know, I have a follow-up question metomer. We'll just roll quick on that. So it could
[2:46:00] Could the council require that all bike lanes within the project area have separation from cars?
[2:46:09] That's already part of the plant. So okay, so all bike lanes. Yeah, there's there. There are not any class two facilities
[2:46:17] That's why they're actually not does defined
[2:46:19] within the specific plan because
[2:46:22] Um, yeah, just following kind of modern modern, great safety standards. They all have to be separated physically
[2:46:28] from cars. Okay, great. Thank you. I just wanted to clarify that. All right. We move on to questions from the public. First, when I have it online, Roland LeBron.
[2:46:44] Yeah, this is Roland. I actually lowered my hand for streets. I'll come back on the Geneva and uh, connections. Thank you.
[2:46:54] Okay, thank you.
[2:46:57] Next one I have is Linda Salman.
[2:47:09] By sickles and pedestrians do not mix well.
[2:47:13] You can go look up where I was living recently and
[2:47:17] all few years back in Santa Rosa, Sebastopol area where people designed wonderful
[2:47:24] pathways with bicycles and pedestrians and which resulted in the death of a number of pedestrians.
[2:47:32] just go check it out. It doesn't work. Okay, Emmett Cunningham.
[2:47:43] I'll try and be brief. I've got four
[2:47:44] five comments here.
[2:47:48] First of all, Shared Green Street. Foster City has some specifically, I think,
[2:47:53] Foster Square Lane. So if you want, you can go down there and look at it and then contact the city
[2:47:57] and see if there's they've had any problems. Take a look. Might be useful. Might give you a second one.
[2:48:03] 15 mile an hour enforcement, this has been available for quite a while, California City Code
[2:48:09] 22352, it's available, we can use it, we can use it in our city, you have to adopt it,
[2:48:15] but we've been unwilling to actually enforce such a thing or produce such an enforcement
[2:48:20] for it.
[2:48:21] So, why would we believe that we'd do it someplace in the new area?
[2:48:25] I'd like to see if I'd love to believe that we would do that 15 mile an hour enforcement
[2:48:28] by the way, because there's several streets in town right now which really deserve it, you
[2:48:34] all know who they are, which do you say are? You've tucked on that one, bike sharing. This
[2:48:40] has been incredibly successful in Mountain View. It's shocking how well it works, a small
[2:48:46] number of bikes, a large number of bikes with Google get moved around thousands of miles a day,
[2:48:52] literally. They go to and from and they get people from one side of the campus to the other,
[2:48:57] and the campus is four and five miles long.
[2:49:01] So it's amazing, just for your information,
[2:49:05] the percentage of seniors in Brisbane
[2:49:06] is around 46% just a little bit under.
[2:49:10] Less but not least, and thank you on the comment
[2:49:12] about Class 4 by Claims, please do that.
[2:49:14] I'll cross the board.
[2:49:15] There was a comment earlier, which really
[2:49:17] set my ears on Edge, which was high visibility road markings,
[2:49:20] which is exactly what we have on Bayshore coming
[2:49:23] into town from South San Francisco,
[2:49:25] And it is exactly the location why I stopped
[2:49:27] commuting on a bike.
[2:49:29] When I worked in South San Francisco,
[2:49:31] it was incredibly dangerous.
[2:49:32] I was having at least one really close call every week
[2:49:37] no matter what I did.
[2:49:38] So it didn't work then.
[2:49:40] The high visibility stuff doesn't make you feel any more comfortable
[2:49:43] on a bike now.
[2:49:44] Classful would do wonders.
[2:49:46] Thank you.
[2:49:47] Thank you.
[2:49:48] All right, that concludes our questions from the public
[2:49:51] on this topic.
[2:49:52] I'm calling that much of my sheet for a week.
[2:49:57] Yeah, I really need severed.
[2:50:00] Well, or you could mark it.
[2:50:01] I didn't see you marked for all the sections.
[2:50:05] But if you have a question, come on up here.
[2:50:10] So if I'm trying to mind, listen to Slow Street in San Francisco,
[2:50:13] Baker Street, and Paige.
[2:50:17] And it's Slow Street's give a sense of ease to people
[2:50:22] using the Slow Street to where they just
[2:50:25] of ignore the fact that there's a car behind them or next to them and I'm concerned about that.
[2:50:31] So, and then also, the, what Emmett said about bicycles and peoples together in the same way,
[2:50:38] I've been hit twice by a bicycle messenger. Once on a sidewalk and once in a crosswalk.
[2:50:44] And so I'm kind of concerned and then also wanted to make sure that on these
[2:50:52] bikes for some people who don't you know ride two wheelbikes and like I don't know
[2:50:57] they met my cargo bikes but maybe that's what they're talking about and then like
[2:51:02] electric scooter chairs like the kind of my dad used to drive around are will there be room for
[2:51:08] that because thank you said a 20 foot ride away but the current city streets are supposed to be
[2:51:14] a 50 foot ride away but I don't know those are questions that if it really is multimodal
[2:51:22] green streets or whatever streets they're using that it includes being able to use an electric
[2:51:28] cart that people ride around in and three wheel bicycles and that is safer. All use. Thank you.
[2:51:38] And I did find your slip Michelle. It's just the way where the the check was. I didn't see it
[2:51:44] as being it's right over the floor so I read it as the next one but it's all there I got it now.
[2:51:50] Thank you for bringing that up.
[2:51:53] All right, we're moving on to the next section.
[2:51:55] Now, Interface,
[2:52:02] it doesn't show it on this topic.
[2:52:04] It's basically a number six, topic six, yeah, you're on a different topic.
[2:52:12] Okay, Interface with Regional Transportation Network.
[2:52:16] Council questions, let's start with Mayor Potem Davis.
[2:52:25] Confirming Interface with Regional Transit.
[2:52:29] Thank you very much.
[2:52:30] Right. So I want to make sure. So in reference to the shuttle transportation feature, I'm curious
[2:52:39] who is responsible for operating and funding that service, in perpetuity. Is that the, is the operator,
[2:52:47] identified at a later time, but the developer is supposed to fund that or
[2:52:57] thank you, Mayor
[2:53:03] as part of the specific plans part of the TDM program or shuttles, that's yet funded by the developer
[2:53:09] and or by the fees collected over the course of the project.
[2:53:17] Shuttles, you know, the TDM program
[2:53:19] requirements as well, that's also a requirement to be funded by the developers as well. So that would
[2:53:24] include, yeah, community dot org type shuttle services, adjustments, increase frequency.
[2:53:29] And I, this is just a comment, but in Council Member Lens brought this up, but I think it's worth reiterating.
[2:53:37] It would be really nice if you could put a stop at the ridge.
[2:53:39] I think the ridge is constantly feeling like they are not served and that they are geographically
[2:53:48] distance from the rest of us and kind of forgotten.
[2:53:50] And so, you know, Brisbane will be kind of in these three distinct areas.
[2:53:59] We have the ridge and central Brisbane.
[2:54:01] We have crocker in the middle and then we have Bayshore and then the baylands.
[2:54:05] And so it'd be really nice if your shuttle network would really take into consideration the ridge
[2:54:12] and they're desired to be able to access all the amazing things that will be at the baylands.
[2:54:17] So, I just wanted to reiterate an interest in a stop there.
[2:54:22] Okay. Thank you. Councilmember Kern.
[2:54:27] Thank you so much.
[2:54:32] So I just want, I just want to make a statement that I'm a huge fan of all five mobility hubs and super energized by their potential existence.
[2:54:39] I do wish there was one little closer to central Brisbane and the rich to service those areas.
[2:54:44] My question is pretty specific.
[2:54:47] And normally, I try and give staff a heads up on these, you're not getting a heads up, this is a live question here, sorry about that.
[2:54:53] The subject is the Bayland specific plan dated March 26, chapter 6, circulation, page 6-70, figure 6.8.9, Geneva Avenue at Bayland's Boulevard.
[2:55:05] The context of my question is as follows, I recently had the luxury of observing transit operations in both India and the Philippines where mismatch vehicle and platform designs routinely force passengers tags it directly into active vehicular traffic.
[2:55:21] I want to ensure that we proactively address potential design conflicts in the baylands before plans are locked in.
[2:55:27] In Chapter 6, Circulation Page 6 at 70,
[2:55:31] configure 6.8.9, which I just referenced,
[2:55:35] it depicts a roadway cross section for Geneva Avenue at Baylands Boulevard,
[2:55:39] featuring a planted median labeled number one,
[2:55:44] a center transit lane labeled number five,
[2:55:47] an immobility hub slash bus stop platform labeled number eight.
[2:55:51] As drawn, this center running configuration requires passenger entrance
[2:55:56] and egress on the left side of the vehicle. However, the standard fleets for Sam
[2:56:03] Trans and other regional transportation operators currently operate with passenger
[2:56:07] boarding doors exclusively on the right side. I apologize Katie, you started to
[2:56:12] head down this path a little earlier, but here are my three questions. Number one,
[2:56:17] whose responsibility is it? The city, project applicant or Sam Trans, to ensure that transit
[2:56:22] buses serving the Spain and the Baylands are equipped and configured for left-side passenger
[2:56:27] boarding and exiting. That's question one. Question two on the same topic in same scenario,
[2:56:34] has SAM trans-reviewed and formally concurred with this center platform roadway geometry
[2:56:39] and what is the mechanism to guarantee compatible dual-sided or left-door transit fleets are
[2:56:45] secured prior to service rollout? In question three on the same topic, if regional transit providers
[2:56:51] can not commit to specialize multi-door buses for this route. How will the roadway cross-section
[2:56:57] be re-engineered to ensure riders exit safely onto protected platforms rather than facing
[2:57:02] exposure to oncoming traffic? Thank you.
[2:57:08] Happy to answer that. The specific plan describes that
[2:57:11] there's two options for the Geneva Avenue BOT system, a side running transit stop source
[2:57:16] are running. So I think that that figure itself is illustrative of the center running facility.
[2:57:25] And that else where in, you know, when in the standards for Geneva Avenue, for example,
[2:57:30] it describes, um, transit facilities could be sideboarding transit with one transit only lane,
[2:57:36] you know, in a boarding area on the side or the center running lane. That would be subject to regional
[2:57:44] the transit providers, the BRG facility was included in the by county study as something
[2:57:51] that would be a joint initiative between the counties of San Francisco, San Mateo, the
[2:57:58] part of the different parties to it, including the city of Brisbane.
[2:58:04] Thank you.
[2:58:05] Before we go on, I just want to point out your question was totally relevant to the regional
[2:58:12] transportation network, but I just want to make sure everyone knows we're not in the Geneva
[2:58:16] Avenue Extension. Your your example was very relevant, so thank you for
[2:58:22] that. Oh, Councilmember Lens, you're next. All right,
[2:58:30] so in the
[2:58:32] same boat of Framework, it talks about having a comprehensive
[2:58:36] transportation study. It's part of the IAR process. Also talks about
[2:58:41] communicating with San Francisco, you know, to connect the systems
[2:58:45] between San Mateo County and San Francisco.
[2:58:50] So in 2013 there was a by county transportation study, which evaluated items such
[2:58:58] as U.S. 101, Candlestick, Interchange, Geneva Avenue Extension, the BRT to the east side
[2:59:06] one-on-one, third-seat-light rail extension, and a base-horstation reconfiguration.
[2:59:15] So if you wouldn't mind just sharing your communication with San Francisco and what have
[2:59:23] been the discussions regarding these particular topic items?
[2:59:30] Sure, that's a great question.
[2:59:32] So we have had very recent conversations with SF planning and SFMTA to discuss this exact topic
[2:59:39] the by-county study, your public works director join us for that meeting as well, so we have
[2:59:45] ongoing dialogue with them. Obviously, the by-county study informed the specific plan, especially
[2:59:52] those BRT lanes that Matt was just describing, but it is also 13-year-old study, so there is
[2:59:58] acknowledgement of that.
[3:00:00] In the EIR, and I believe in the revised specific plan as well, that that is something that all parties may need to revisit as we move from this planning stage into implementation, so especially the questions that Council Member Kerr was bringing up about the loading and the way the BRT lanes would function potentially on Geneva.
[3:00:19] Those are the types of discussions that we will have to revisit with the appropriate transit agencies and other relevant stakeholders.
[3:00:26] And determine if that by county study needs to be updated or if we're able to just work out kind of the implementation with those same parties that participated in the study 13 years ago.
[3:00:38] Yeah, you know the items that I listed obviously you write the studies from 2013.
[3:00:47] But those are items that would be relevant to today.
[3:00:52] And those are all incorporated into the specific plan currently.
[3:00:58] Okay, I don't see things such as the candlestick interchange.
[3:01:04] So the candlestick interchange is considered as part of the transportation analysis.
[3:01:09] For the bail-ins, however, that interchange is not part of the specific plan area.
[3:01:14] So therefore it's not included in the specific plan.
[3:01:18] But I'm sure from fair and peers could also speak about their transportation analysis.
[3:01:23] Yeah, I have that in my Geneva Avenue extension questions.
[3:01:27] But you know, there's other things to do like the Third Street Light Rail extension and a reconfiguration of the multi-more of the station.
[3:01:37] So I'm going to just though this out there to you.
[3:01:41] Would you be open to say having some kind of transportation form you talk about
[3:01:47] the different transit agencies,
[3:01:52] Congressman Mullins going to be in Brisbane. I think next week,
[3:01:56] you know, Congressman Mullin represents not just Brisbane,
[3:01:59] but also vis-valley, you know, perhaps having the Congressman, you know,
[3:02:04] convenes some kind of transportation forum to evaluate funding, you know,
[3:02:17] in evaluating that and looking at that by county study together.
[3:02:24] We're always happy to meet with the congressman's office and discuss these things, of course,
[3:02:29] all of those projects that you mentioned have regional significance and therefore also have
[3:02:33] regional implications for all of the different stakeholders who have to pay their fair share
[3:02:37] and participate in the planning and implementation of those projects. Of course, as a relevant
[3:02:42] party, we're happy to participate in those discussions.
[3:02:44] Absolutely. Yeah, you know, and you think about it. I mean, it's the site's expensive and in so many different areas and so by looking for ways to partner together.
[3:02:57] Make sense, but that doesn't happen unless you have conversations. Sure.
[3:03:01] All right. Thank you.
[3:03:02] Councilmember O'Connell.
[3:03:05] No.
[3:03:06] No further questions to this section.
[3:03:08] Okay. I have one.
[3:03:10] If I can find it here.
[3:03:15] Okay.
[3:03:21] Do we have a motion to extend the meeting and how about we say we'll just make it an hour
[3:03:29] and then see where we're at.
[3:03:31] Summute.
[3:03:33] Second.
[3:03:34] All in favor.
[3:03:35] Hi.
[3:03:36] Anyone opposed?
[3:03:38] Okay.
[3:03:40] specific plan talks about active transportation network and it mentions in accordance with the
[3:03:46] Brisbane bicycle and pedestrian master plan. What was the year of the last update to that plan?
[3:03:55] Could someone answer that?
[3:03:59] I think it's rather old. 2017. I believe so have we given any thought to the
[3:04:12] is the most up-to-date document that we have.
[3:04:15] We separately from this project,
[3:04:17] we're looking at doing it up-date of that document,
[3:04:21] but that is yet to be certain.
[3:04:23] Okay.
[3:04:25] All right.
[3:04:27] Let's go back then to Councilmember O'Connell.
[3:04:31] You have no more questions?
[3:04:33] Not on the section now.
[3:04:36] Mayor Pro Tem Davis.
[3:04:38] Just a quick question, so we have, you know, the TDM, Shuttle Service, and those are aimed
[3:04:48] at achieving certain transportation performance.
[3:04:52] What happens if those don't actually achieve the anticipated results we're looking for and
[3:04:58] is there a mechanism that we could use to require additional action?
[3:05:06] Great question.
[3:05:06] Um, so community dot org has, uh, through the TM, they're counting my TDM program has a monitoring program that they have set up, and so they, they do, they oversee routine monitoring throughout the, throughout the, throughout the, throughout the county, Brisbane, although has adopted its own ordinance, um, is working with community dot org to facilitate that type of monitoring for local projects. So they would be responsible for, helping the, the city do that type of monitoring in coordination with the TDM coordinator through surveys and,
[3:05:36] and there are other typical things that they gather.
[3:05:40] I'll just add on that the city.
[3:05:42] We already have partnership with Community Network.
[3:05:45] They have this one community platform,
[3:05:47] which is really that kind of monitoring program,
[3:05:50] and we do submit.
[3:05:52] We don't submit, but we use that platform to monitor projects
[3:05:55] that are currently subject to RTD-Mordinates.
[3:05:58] Thank you.
[3:06:01] Council Member Kern.
[3:06:05] No additional questions.
[3:06:06] Okay, then let's see.
[3:06:09] Council Member Lens. I'm ready to move on,
[3:06:13] sit you need to have a minute. Okay, so I have one more question.
[3:06:18] Under regional transportation network,
[3:06:22] it says Brisbane currently has two free shuttle bus routes.
[3:06:26] And that is I'm calling attention that is factually incorrect.
[3:06:31] The two routes were consolidated into one.
[3:06:34] So the specific plan needs to reflect that.
[3:06:38] That's the end of my questions also.
[3:06:41] So we have, let's see the public.
[3:06:43] Madam Mayor, would you be amenable to a five-minute break?
[3:06:46] Sure.
[3:06:46] That would be great.
[3:06:47] Let's do a break and we'll come back with public questions.
[3:06:50] Thank you.
[3:14:42] Second session. And we're on public questions. First, when I have Karen cutting him, is she still here? No. Okay. Next, when I have Ron Colona,
[3:14:59] after Ron.
[3:15:00] I'll have Michelle Linda Salman. Okay? Go ahead, Ron.
[3:15:09] Okay.
[3:15:11] What started this, her initiated, might be concerned about the transportation linkages.
[3:15:19] When they had the Bank of America site, what are we going to do with that? How are we going to be used?
[3:15:24] And I thought, well, now that I'm associated with the seniors
[3:15:28] intimately, unfortunately,
[3:15:32] the concerns of the seniors who
[3:15:35] aren't going to be using many of the bike paths,
[3:15:38] aren't going to be doing so many walks in all this other stuff.
[3:15:43] It seemed like a hub in that general area that
[3:15:47] link, getting a cross-base sure, which I guess you could, and I'm thinking of a smaller
[3:15:57] vehicle, not shovels, shuttles for what I've noticed of them, don't accommodate that
[3:16:05] many people on any one trip.
[3:16:08] You see one or two people that are never, never full of individuals.
[3:16:14] So why did what does they had smaller vehicles?
[3:16:18] Battery operated vehicles.
[3:16:20] They could link, especially, you know, as seniors,
[3:16:28] that wanted to say go to the Marine of Parks,
[3:16:30] you're going to have several parks in the Marine and now.
[3:16:33] How do they get there?
[3:16:35] If they wanted to go to these other parks,
[3:16:37] you've been talking about the Roundhouse Park,
[3:16:43] other on-site parks all through the place, as also, you know, the transfer spots, you know,
[3:16:51] the bay train, the bus stops and the other things. These could all be useful for getting
[3:16:56] seniors to various places. And they're more likely to use this stuff than the people that are
[3:17:05] like or show whatever.
[3:17:11] The V of A site is, I mean, that's an important, that's just got
[3:17:15] me thinking about it. But I'm thinking if you got to smaller vehicles, they don't have
[3:17:21] to be, you've got to get somewhere between being street legal, I guess, and being of the
[3:17:29] size,
[3:17:33] but you know like the way modes you've seen those light blue colored extended, you
[3:17:39] know something something that could have taken the number of people that would probably
[3:17:44] be using it, Macs and loading them on and going to more multiple sites. I mean you could take
[3:17:53] that vehicle up into the ridge, you could take it into the inner city, you could take it out to the
[3:17:59] So,
[3:18:02] the other thing that was thing about is that, well, if we use these smaller vehicles
[3:18:07] and they're presumably, they're absolutely going to be battery charged.
[3:18:15] But what about all these parking facilities within sight?
[3:18:21] There's no reason to not have panels that could be used for charging these vehicles overnight,
[3:18:30] so they'd be ready to go wherever they're being scheduled to go that day.
[3:18:39] And one thing I noticed, I thought of this year's ago, but I had not heard of it until recently
[3:18:45] that in Australia, for the side of the panels weren't only on the roofs, they were also
[3:18:51] on a building sighting. And we have some hydroisers that are going to be, you know, with a
[3:18:57] south facing, but to get more charging that you need.
[3:19:04] So, well that's it. Yeah, you how you
[3:19:08] would integrate all these notions. I don't have a clue. But I just thought that'd be a nice
[3:19:15] answer to a lot of problems. Thank you. Thank you. Online, we have Roland.
[3:19:32] Roland, your
[3:19:33] there we go. Yeah, thank you. I met a mayor and council. Is this a appropriate time to
[3:19:40] talk about the interface between Caltrained and the Geneva Avenue extension? Or should I
[3:19:45] wait until the next item? I think I would wait until Geneva Avenue extension. We'll do thank you.
[3:19:53] Okay, so I just want to follow up on Ron's comment. Okay, so I'm sorry. There we go.
[3:20:02] Yeah, so I want to follow up on Ron's comment about potentially on-demand smaller shuttles say in Central Brisbane and North East Ridge connecting to the proposed shuttle that the developer is proposing.
[3:20:25] Is that, is that shown anywhere in this specific plan, or mentioned?
[3:20:32] It's not not shown.
[3:20:33] No, specifically, but yeah.
[3:20:36] Okay, but that could be something that could be implemented.
[3:20:41] Okay, if you want, I thought I saw something in there, but it does very briefly.
[3:20:47] If you went mine.
[3:20:48] Yeah, if you look at table 6.5.1 proposed Bayland's shuttle routes,
[3:20:54] There's a reference to the shuttle being provided at specific intervals on weekdays or in some cases on demand service on weekends.
[3:21:10] Yeah, so, you know, people had an app on their smartphone and they could request that and catch the shuttle and then come to the designated shuttle route and then get on the shuttle.
[3:21:24] Okay, that sounds like something that could possibly be done.
[3:21:28] All right, thank you.
[3:21:30] All right, we go on to the next section.
[3:21:32] Geneva Avenue Extension Council questions.
[3:21:36] Let us start with Mayor Pro Tem Davis.
[3:21:42] I just have one question in this section.
[3:21:48] And provided the council is on board.
[3:21:52] I'd like for us to consider removing references in the specific plan that establish future
[3:21:58] ownership or specific funding mechanism for major infrastructure, such as Geneva Avenue Extension,
[3:22:05] and I think that the specific plan should establish the transportation improvements that
[3:22:10] are necessary to support the development, but I don't think that it should predetermine
[3:22:14] the city's ownership of those facilities or what financing mechanism will be used to deliver them.
[3:22:21] And those are really implementation and financing decisions that should be addressed through a development agreement
[3:22:26] or other appropriate actions as a project moves forward.
[3:22:30] And I would ask staff to revise table 8.2.1, so that it identifies the improvement and its role in the transportation system, but does not state city owned or EIFE funded as predetermined outcomes. And I don't know if that's, I mean, I know they're kind of listed, maybe it's listed as ways these might be funded. I think I don't want that table to be misunderstood as this is for sure.
[3:23:00] sure how it's going to be funded.
[3:23:04] So I know there is a little caveat below that.
[3:23:12] So I think
[3:23:13] it's clear what you're saying. I understand what you're saying. So yeah, that's less
[3:23:18] of a question and more of a staff direction and of course the rest of the council would have
[3:23:23] to be on board with that change. But to me, I really am concerned about anything that prescribes
[3:23:29] ownership for the city or outlines that the city may be collaborating and finance it.
[3:23:38] Okay. Thank you. Council Member O'Connell.
[3:23:45] So, too. And this is maybe a bit esoteric, but the Geneva Avenue extension is serving
[3:23:54] not only the project and creating a way to get over the tracks, but it's also serving the larger
[3:24:03] community.
[3:24:07] If it doesn't get built, what will we need to do to meet our the goals of the
[3:24:17] circulation and the TDM goals? And can, because of this project and that it serves other
[3:24:29] communities besides just this project, can we require that the developer pays for that
[3:24:43] in the specific plan?
[3:24:53] So complicated questions, maybe the city attorney and I can try to take this one on.
[3:25:01] So the specific plan and EIR identify that it would need to be completed as a part of the phase one construction.
[3:25:10] So, west of Caltering Tracks to support that level of growth and so that's the extent of the EIR analysis is based on that needing to be in place as a mitigation measure and that would mean it would need to be developed or funded.
[3:25:31] I'll turn out in the city turning fell and maybe we're delving into the financing portion
[3:25:40] of it, but it's really my concern that if it doesn't get developed and if this developer
[3:25:49] is selling little sections off to be built in phases that which phase is going to pay that.
[3:25:58] I mean, which block of housing or commercial is going to pay for that,
[3:26:03] because that's going to be tremendous amount of money.
[3:26:10] But what is, and I'm relating it back to what are ramifications of them not doing it are.
[3:26:18] Once 80% of phase 1's built,
[3:26:29] and you can come back with that.
[3:26:30] Yeah, we'll have to go through the mitigation monitoring program a little bit,
[3:26:33] you sought a part to give you a more comprehensive answer.
[3:26:37] Okay, thank you.
[3:26:39] Hey, Council Member Lens.
[3:26:42] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[3:26:44] Can we pull up figure 6.3.2.
[3:26:49] That's the one that's got Geneva and it's, I guess it's maybe going towards, it says,
[3:26:57] Geneva Avenue Bridge and Geneva Avenue Frontage Road.
[3:27:08] It's on my slides, so if. Yes, we saw it. Is it a clerk? Yeah, I'm trying to talk into the city manager here. Sorry.
[3:27:29] you know it's slide number?
[3:27:36] Yeah, it's going to be keep going keep going. It's two more. One more. There you go.
[3:27:43] Okay, there you go. All right, if we can't make that one bigger, that'd be great.
[3:27:54] Well, maybe that's just, okay, there we go. Thank you. So,
[3:27:57] So looking at the bottom picture, so we have six lanes, two lanes going west, two lanes going east,
[3:28:07] and then we have the two BRT lanes in the center.
[3:28:12] So when it crosses over the train tracks, how do we funnel these six lanes underneath the 101 to get out to candlestick?
[3:28:25] So that's where Geneva Avenue would connect to the new candlestick interchange, and I understand
[3:28:35] that this is a really complicated part of the regional transportation connections here.
[3:28:40] But the candlestick interchange, as envisioned through the Byte County Study, was identified
[3:28:47] as a mitigation measure, and that the Bayolans, as identified in the Byte County Study,
[3:28:52] would need to contribute its fair share towards that project, you know, which candlestick
[3:28:57] development in San Francisco also contributes to. So that is where the Geneva Avenue
[3:29:03] as proposed by the developer would then connect into that new interchange.
[3:29:11] Did you have a company do you do that today?
[3:29:14] We did the traffic analysis of the different scenarios I just described of what would happen
[3:29:22] if you build a Geneva Avenue with or without the
[3:29:24] canals are going to change.
[3:29:25] Yeah, do you have some renderings that show us?
[3:29:27] I mean, right now, we just have a cut off bridge,
[3:29:30] and that's it.
[3:29:31] It's a bridge to go where we're going to reach the nowhere.
[3:29:33] We know there were no no rendering.
[3:29:35] We didn't prepare any renderings for the EIR analysis.
[3:29:39] It's it's it's reference, there were, you know,
[3:29:41] designs prepared for the by county study and the follow up
[3:29:45] projects study report,
[3:29:46] call trans projects that they report those completed in 2015.
[3:29:49] Now, what the EIR identifies is that because of change conditions since 2013 and 2015.
[3:30:00] The by-counting study and the project study report will all need to be updated to reflect current kind of traffic and travel conditions through this area.
[3:30:11] So what we did is we analyzed, okay, would the prior
[3:30:16] as proposed candlestick interchange that has, you know, this funding by-counting funding agreement with that address, the significant impacts in the project.
[3:30:26] The answer is yes. And that part of the process is a region regionally significant coordinated
[3:30:34] program as you were referring to earlier as part of these conversations that will need to be updated
[3:30:39] for final design and through CalTrans standard process, because CalTrans has a standard process,
[3:30:46] that is, of course, outside of the city's control to dictate. Yeah, there's another slide that you
[3:30:53] code, and it had, maybe it was yours, Katie, or it chose that, you know, there's a little
[3:31:00] arrow.
[3:31:00] Yeah, if you go off, and then it goes underneath the freeway.
[3:31:06] But when you look at this, I mean, if this is what you're building, and then this is what
[3:31:11] could happen if you don't get people to come together and work something out, that doesn't
[3:31:18] seem possible.
[3:31:19] So, can you maybe just step me through that, your point again, and if there's a question
[3:31:26] in there, sorry.
[3:31:27] Yeah, so I'm trying to grasp what's being shown to us and what we're going to approve.
[3:31:37] So we have six lanes going across the tracks and they're going to continue east.
[3:31:45] there's a there's a you know kind of very simple diagram that shows the arrows and
[3:31:51] word things go and one of the arrows goes underneath the freeway coming from Geneva.
[3:31:59] So I'm just trying to square that up how does that happen if you don't have the
[3:32:06] partnership from all of the you know the the regional players.
[3:32:12] Yeah, I mean, it's fundamentally like a two-part project that would need to happen.
[3:32:19] You know, what the developer and the specific plan shows is that at ends, the genu-at
[3:32:24] have an extension ends at the existing intersection of Alonan and Badey, which is a three-legged
[3:32:30] intersection today, and theoretically you could put forth like there, but the problem, the challenge
[3:32:37] that we identified in the EIR. And that's why the rebuilding interchange is a part of the
[3:32:44] mitigation strategies because it's not proposed by the project. So there is a mechanism now
[3:32:51] for same as what candlestick has to do. Candlestick can control rebuilding the interchange
[3:32:57] by the city of San Francisco, required that candlestick contribute their fair share to rebuilding
[3:33:02] you know, can also can build the horny wayside of things, but then they can't do the interchange.
[3:33:10] So it's mirroring what candlestick EIR did on the other side.
[3:33:18] I mean, really what you're showing us is basically an infeasible genieva avenue extension bridge.
[3:33:29] And I guess maybe you could use part of Geneva Avenue extension as it, you know, say West of the tracks, but that after that, it's, you can't, you know, why would you build it?
[3:33:43] Unless you, you know, you could make the connection to the other side.
[3:33:47] Yeah, and that's, and that's where that regional project, that's, yes, that's, yes, this is the complicated nature of it.
[3:33:54] theoretically, you know, you could build, build the structure while
[3:33:57] candlestick is being, you know, move forward as well, create a connection to the existing
[3:34:03] intersection. What we found is that that, you know, that's probably going to be overloaded
[3:34:08] pretty quickly. I mean, that's, this is, this is, this is the crux of the problem that the
[3:34:11] Pirate EIR identified for, for Bayland's, to as well as, so this is, this is really just,
[3:34:17] consistent kind of framework from both the per EIR, the by county study, the
[3:34:24] candlestick EIR,
[3:34:28] that this EIR relied on.
[3:34:31] Okay, so I'm sorry, you know, if I just want to ask just one more question.
[3:34:37] If we got one per county, I'll come on one, I know you guys should ask the question on this
[3:34:45] Thank you so much.
[3:34:48] You guys checked off quite a few questions that I had already on here.
[3:34:52] So I guess Matt, let me just ask you this real fundamental, super basic question.
[3:34:58] Can the candlestick exchange exist without the Geneva Avenue extension?
[3:35:07] Can the candlestick interchange exist without the Geneva Avenue extension?
[3:35:16] It's in old prior planning documents, the two of them have been identified together, so that that's not something that we studied as a part of this project.
[3:35:28] Okay, that was a very fundamental question, I get it.
[3:35:31] So I'm going to reverse the question and say, can the Geneva Avenue extension exist without the candlestick exchange?
[3:35:38] I'm going to guess you're going to say yes, and I'm going to guess that that means the traffic coming off the extension will be routed on to a lawn away and then a harming way and then on through the existing on ramp.
[3:35:49] It going northbound exactly and as I just described like that creates a challenging situation.
[3:35:59] Okay, thank you. I don't have any other questions.
[3:36:02] So I'm going to parlay off of what's just been put on the table.
[3:36:09] We have a specific plan to approve and we're being asked to approve this Geneva extension
[3:36:16] which really could completely transform into something else based upon CalTrans and a
[3:36:30] even be approving the design other than a concept.
[3:36:39] Because essentially what you are approving right now, you know, what the specific plan outlines is that
[3:36:46] there are two travel lanes in each direction.
[3:36:49] You have separated facility, you know, by competitive facilities on either side,
[3:36:53] and you provide the BRT lanes as called for in prior regional planning studies.
[3:36:59] So there's, there's no, you know, kind of like engineering design associated with it.
[3:37:03] there's an alignment, there's enough detail that you can analyze, you know, what the environmental impacts would be.
[3:37:11] Were those configurations something that were in the by-county study? Because I know they did look at Geneva.
[3:37:20] Was it that configuration with the double-decker and the way the lanes are laid out?
[3:37:26] I think maybe that, I don't know if the applicant wants to speak.
[3:37:30] To this, like how they changed the design of Geneva, but it's slightly different, but and that's why one of the reasons why the PSR would need to be updated.
[3:37:40] The overall configuration, though, of what we what I just mentioned, that is the same.
[3:37:46] There were four lanes previously for vehicle traffic. There are two BRT lanes down the middle and there have been plans of how you then connect the BRT under the freeway and allow the.
[3:37:59] You know, vehicle traffic to go over under Highway 101.
[3:38:06] So again, I'm going to come back to this.
[3:38:08] It seems to me we should be approving a concept of some vagaries of lanes and connections
[3:38:15] without a final design that has an illustration that may be completely obsolete.
[3:38:24] because we're approving a design, is there's an illustration and I would feel personally
[3:38:32] more comfortable in approving a concept noting that this is to be determined by a by
[3:38:38] county study rather than specifics that may all change.
[3:38:47] I think that is kind of what just to re-emphasize what Matt had said that is more or less
[3:38:53] with the specific plan is it's the lame configuration and the expert in how the street
[3:39:00] would work, but it's not the engineering for it, it's not the actual design of that infrastructure,
[3:39:08] that that is something that would happen later as part of you know the process that you were just
[3:39:14] describing so I'm I guess I'm not sure what you what component of it you would prefer
[3:39:22] not be in the plan if we could be more clear about that than we can I would mostly I'd like
[3:39:38] it's a by-county study, and count trams, they're going to determine what it looks like.
[3:39:43] I'd be more comfortable if it just said if we didn't compass theoretically blah, blah, blah, blah.
[3:39:51] Then showing something specific that may never even end up exactly like that, if we could just kind of tone it down.
[3:40:01] If I may add a little bit to this.
[3:40:04] So reiterating what was just said that it is a concept before you and it's not a completely
[3:40:09] designed.
[3:40:10] I think the what the stocking it's doing is looking at the potential impacts as far as the
[3:40:14] EIR itself is concerned to make sure that what is being proposed at a concept level doesn't
[3:40:21] we capture whatever those impacts are as part of our review.
[3:40:25] When when you move forward when this moves forward at some point in your right it might
[3:40:30] change a little bit.
[3:40:32] That's something that's going to be up to by county.
[3:40:34] So San Mateo County, Interdisco City and County.
[3:40:38] But I think what we're trying to make sure is that we have covered whatever
[3:40:42] of those potential impacts of that improvement would be with related to
[3:40:46] this specific plan.
[3:40:49] And that's still going to be something that needs to be flushed up.
[3:40:52] I don't disagree with what you're saying.
[3:40:54] And maybe there's some maybe we can maybe there's some language
[3:40:56] tweak in the specific plan that make that a little bit more clear.
[3:40:59] Yeah, thank you.
[3:41:01] Okay. Back to questions. Council member Kern, your first.
[3:41:08] Thank you. I guess my only remaining
[3:41:10] question is to the applicant. Do you or do you not need the Geneva extension bridge to
[3:41:17] start? I'm not sure this is not an inquiry. Sounds like it is, but do you or do you not need
[3:41:22] that bridge in order to remediate and build infrastructure and all of the work that you
[3:41:28] have to do?
[3:41:38] Yeah, if I understand the question correctly, we do not need the bridge for the remediation
[3:41:43] of either the landfill or the real yard site.
[3:41:50] The bridge is a regional transportation project, was studied in 2013 by the by county and
[3:41:56] just to be also clear in that study.
[3:41:59] The Geneva bridge is part and parcel with the 101 exchange, not sure if we have our
[3:42:12] engineer online, but I don't think those two pieces have to go together. I don't think there's
[3:42:20] a good way to bring the Geneva over the railroad tracks and then down as you suggested
[3:42:27] on to Harnyway, it's just too complicated.
[3:42:31] So the whole concept in 2013 was this regional transportation plan.
[3:42:36] And to be clear, that was a by-county study.
[3:42:39] It also studied, it also claimed states that...
[3:42:45] And the reason the study was done was because the 100-point shipyard,
[3:42:49] candlestick, Schleg, Baylands, Brisbane,
[3:42:53] were all coming into the pipeline,
[3:42:55] and there was an estimated number of travel trips and people living there and that there would be no need for any of this if none of those projects ever happened.
[3:43:08] Second thing in that study was it was a fair share program.
[3:43:13] So, for the Geneva extension, I believe the Bayland's project has about a 34% share of the Geneva extension.
[3:43:25] The other large shares are San Francisco San Francisco County, San Mateo County, and the other large developments.
[3:43:37] So, okay.
[3:43:38] I mean, so what I'm hearing is this.
[3:43:40] question again council member current.
[3:43:43] Who knew are you going to get it so what I'm hearing is that the
[3:43:49] bridge is never constructed it doesn't impact you at all.
[3:43:52] You're going to move forward with your infrastructure projects building
[3:43:55] houses multi use commercial you don't need the bridge to do any of that.
[3:43:59] We do not need the bridge for that.
[3:44:00] It is a regional transportation project.
[3:44:03] Okay. Thank you for that.
[3:44:06] Mayor Pro Tim Davis.
[3:44:07] I don't have any more questions for this section.
[3:44:14] Council Member O'Connell.
[3:44:17] Mine's going to be a three-prong and I don't really expect an answer until you can
[3:44:25] come back.
[3:44:27] What is the mitigation requirements for the candlestick project?
[3:44:33] the Schleglock project, and how do they, how do their mitigation measures for those two projects affect
[3:44:46] if candlestick and the Geneva Bridge ever get built?
[3:44:53] And so are they in violation of their mitigation measures if it doesn't, just like we
[3:44:58] would be invalid.
[3:45:00] Should of our mitigation measures, if it doesn't. And then this third problem would be when I was back on C-Cag a decade ago, maybe more.
[3:45:16] They had a project list for the interchange projects that were under consideration or wish lists.
[3:45:24] And there was two that affected Brisbane three, actually.
[3:45:31] The bridge over 101, the Baszure Exit, Cal Palace Exit,
[3:45:40] Serapoint, Interchange, and the Campbell Stick Interchange.
[3:45:45] And they were all considered so far down the bottom of the project list
[3:45:51] as far as CCAG was saying that they will never get built was basically what CCAG said.
[3:46:00] To me, when I was there, that those projects were in the North County and they did not have priority for CCAG as a whole.
[3:46:12] I don't know if we can find out if those projects have moved up their list and also what mitigation has been asked of Schlaglock project or Bayland's North, whatever you want to call it, and the Candlestick project and how that might affect if those two ever go through on our project.
[3:46:43] few questions there so let me move try to move slowly here I said I didn't need a response
[3:46:49] tonight I think it might need a little but I mean if you can I can speak to briefly
[3:46:58] C.Cag's processes for example when they do prioritization ties approved projects you know is
[3:47:05] would be one of the things that they need for something that is a development driven project
[3:47:10] and so it's yeah this these inner changes are not going to get prioritized until you have
[3:47:16] a proof projects that require it. So until San Francisco pushes or or Brisbane or into the
[3:47:25] balans are approved because the balans is what is why one of the reasons you know it's all
[3:47:31] projects within this, the by county agreement, right?
[3:47:38] And the, yeah, I mean, the kind of sick,
[3:47:43] EIR identifies as a mitigation measure. And so, yes, the city of San Francisco is responsible for ensuring that the kind of sick development falls through on their obligations to contribute to that project.
[3:48:02] and finish leg lock has a role too as well. They have a fair share responsibility as well.
[3:48:10] I'd prefer a little more in depth when we can get it. But thank you.
[3:48:15] Of course.
[3:48:17] Councilmember Lens?
[3:48:18] Yes.
[3:48:20] Stephanie.
[3:48:23] So,
[3:48:24] I'm trying to remember.
[3:48:26] I thought that there were some renderings of that exchange
[3:48:30] And that the Geneva Avenue extension just stayed on pillars, right, it was just a podium that that then just continued east.
[3:48:42] So, to where? To over, you know, to the exchange?
[3:48:46] Yeah, connect to that to the one on it.
[3:48:49] Yeah, that's the grand plan.
[3:48:51] Yeah, and over to exactly.
[3:48:52] It's been grand.
[3:48:53] Fine, those renderings, I think it would be helpful if you could.
[3:48:58] I know you're saying that they don't exist, but I thought I could have swore there were some renderings.
[3:49:03] Councilmember Lens, you are correct.
[3:49:05] I think in some of our workshopping over the years we BKF are engineers presented some kind of conceptual sketches.
[3:49:15] And there were a couple of different options.
[3:49:22] Okay.
[3:49:23] for you. But they were conceptual. I know, and I get it. I mean, this kind of gives us an
[3:49:29] understanding of, like, what, what, what, what the scope would be? Yeah. Yes, I can, I can
[3:49:35] find those. Um, okay. But I think, you know, I think it's, they're not in our specific
[3:49:42] plan because it's Katie said it's not a part of our specific plan that the Geneva extension
[3:49:48] the bridge obviously is in the middle of our project. So, so we have to talk about it and we have
[3:49:53] to describe it and it's, it's, it is conceptual in our, in our design. It's not a hardened
[3:50:03] fast design, but it was, you know, a collaborative effort over many years for our transportation
[3:50:09] people in the various agencies and to put those, that, what you're seeing in the specific plan
[3:50:17] in there but it is conceptual and it hinges on a lot which is you know all these other
[3:50:23] developments happening and to create the need for it and and just remember that it's
[3:50:31] a fair share project meaning the county both counties and all the cities and all the
[3:50:38] developers have a fair share both in the Geneva bridge extension and in the 101 and in
[3:50:44] And I'll seven of the priority projects that are discussed in the 2013 by county, and I think
[3:50:50] we've all kind of agreed that that plan does need updating.
[3:50:58] Yeah, you know, again, not having the Geneva Avenue extension going all the way to the
[3:51:03] 101.
[3:51:04] Yes.
[3:51:05] Basically, any development that occurs in the Bayon Lands, when people go south, they're going to travel
[3:51:12] on, be sure and go through Brisbane. So that's going to be a major impact to our city. So
[3:51:20] having the extension go all the way across to the 101, it leads the eights that. It's a great
[3:51:27] proposal on such a great project, nobody's debating. Yes. I think we're just debating timing
[3:51:35] and need and fair share.
[3:51:41] I don't think it's so much a debate,
[3:51:43] but really, what do we need to have the talk?
[3:51:46] We need to have those conversations
[3:51:48] and in world together.
[3:51:50] Okay, okay.
[3:51:53] You do realize archaeology is part of sequest so
[3:51:56] you're finding old renderings as part of your job.
[3:51:59] You never thought of that.
[3:52:00] Probably a mitigation.
[3:52:02] I think.
[3:52:04] All right.
[3:52:05] back on the question round. Councilmember O'Connell. I'm done for tonight.
[3:52:14] Okay. Councilmember
[3:52:14] Kern. No further questions. Councilmember Lens. I am done on this particular item.
[3:52:23] Okay. So, M.I. So, we have public question comments. First one, I have.
[3:52:30] Have you here, Roland?
[3:52:32] Online.
[3:52:36] Thank you. I'm at a Mayan Council and I'm glad you left me to last item. So what I'd like to do is to speak to the current proposal, to connect a basic
[3:52:47] country station to Geneva Avenue via a shuttle. It's such an alternative that provides a direct connection between
[3:52:57] Calthrain and Geneva Avenue by doubling the length of the Calthrain platforms to 140 feet
[3:53:05] and shifting the entire station 7 feet south to intersect intersect with the Geneva
[3:53:13] Avenue Accenture overpass. If regards to elevations, the Calthrain tracks remain at the current
[3:53:21] great, but those sides of the tracks rise to the same level as the Overpass, which ends
[3:53:28] a Beijing level with the Bayland development.
[3:53:32] This change in elevation introduces an opportunity to eliminate the current counter-trained
[3:53:39] building more, that cuts the baylands in east and west halves.
[3:53:44] By opening up multiple opportunities to build open space for even buildings, above the
[3:53:51] and then I don't even have the slides but the last slide is actually a 15-year-old
[3:53:57] journalist in Switzerland, in Switzerland, so in Geneva I have the
[3:54:03] cut frame and a platform but that slide is missing escalators or
[3:54:10] inklinators connecting both sides of Geneva I have new to the cut frame
[3:54:21] regional resilience. If rail traffic in the San Francisco tunnels is interrupted. And it does
[3:54:28] so by providing massive capacity for transwers to and from immune, can even
[3:54:36] same trans buses and a light rail for people to get unaware of the final destinations.
[3:54:42] In mass but not least, I would like to circle back to the comment on the last week about
[3:54:48] accelerating the delivery of the overpass section of the Geneva Abni extension and use this
[3:54:55] overpass to eliminate 80 to 90 percent of truck miles travel up and down our terminal Abni
[3:55:03] has going to be proposed. Please consider the construction of the overpass section only
[3:55:10] I'll see potential mitigation metro. Thank you.
[3:55:15] All right. Thank you. Next Michelle Salman, you're online.
[3:55:24] I kind of agree with what Roland just said, because I'm looking at the map right now.
[3:55:30] And the rail tracks bisect this project east and west.
[3:55:36] And right now there's no overcross across those railroad tracks except for the tunnel avenue bridge.
[3:55:44] And this without building the overpass doesn't need to connect to the freeway, but without building some kind of overpass over the train tracks.
[3:55:55] This is really kind of two separate developments, so it's not like cohesive at all.
[3:56:01] And I don't see how they're going to do that.
[3:56:02] So I didn't really agree with where I'm sorry, Stephanie, but I don't understand how you could not have to have an overpass to make this project work over the railroad tracks.
[3:56:14] Because then that does that mean people who worked on the east side could only access it from 101 and people on the west side could only access it from Old Bay Shore.
[3:56:27] I mean, it just doesn't work without an overpass.
[3:56:30] So something needs to be figured out there.
[3:56:34] Indeed, an overpass would definitely cut down on a lot of traffic.
[3:56:39] Thank you.
[3:56:41] Okay, Linda Samman.
[3:56:44] Do we have Linda online?
[3:56:46] Nope.
[3:56:48] Okay.
[3:56:49] Then we move on to...
[3:56:52] That's it.
[3:56:53] Actually, there's two cards from Linda.
[3:56:57] All right.
[3:56:59] We've exhausted Geneva Avenue Extension.
[3:57:02] We'll now move on to Bayshore Mobility Plan.
[3:57:06] Questions.
[3:57:07] Starting with Council Member O'Connell.
[3:57:10] It's 926 and I don't feel obligated or obliged to extend the meeting any longer.
[3:57:18] I agree with that too. We're at a break, so I think it was at 930. I think we should
[3:57:25] have that item be moved to the next meeting.
[3:57:28] Okay, so council member Kern, your opinion?
[3:57:32] You know, I just want to plow through the agenda and keep going. However, this is a logical
[3:57:36] time to break at this point. If we're going to do that. And Mayor Plotum, just curious for
[3:57:42] next meeting. How many questions give or take does everyone have? I actually only have
[3:57:47] a statement about this. I don't really have a question. Do you all have a lot of questions about
[3:57:52] this item? No, I don't. But I have a couple. Especially as it relates to the last, I don't know we
[3:57:59] discussed. I don't have questions, but if this is a public hearing, we have lost our public. Yeah,
[3:58:05] No, it's just for the next time.
[3:58:07] I'm just trying to gauge how robust this conversation will be
[3:58:12] at the next meeting.
[3:58:14] We have three slips from the public.
[3:58:16] Someone who stayed Charles Spencer has stayed for this.
[3:58:20] We also have David Brown.
[3:58:22] David, are you here?
[3:58:23] Yes, we just stayed David.
[3:58:24] How the comments then?
[3:58:26] First.
[3:58:27] Sure, let's do the public on it.
[3:58:29] All right, David, let's start with you.
[3:58:32] I'll make a motion to extend the meeting 10 minutes.
[3:58:37] Second.
[3:58:38] All in favor?
[3:58:39] Aye.
[3:58:39] Aye.
[3:58:40] Anyone opposed?
[3:58:41] Okay.
[3:58:42] David, you're on.
[3:58:49] Good evening.
[3:58:50] Madam Mayor and council members.
[3:58:55] Thank you for squeezing me in.
[3:58:58] I've been a Brisbane resident for over 34 years.
[3:59:03] And I'm doing courage to attend last week's, as well as this week's meeting on the Baylands.
[3:59:11] I feel a lot of gratitude for the intelligence, hard work and skill involved in so many
[3:59:19] people, and working hard to create a world-class development with minimal environmental impact
[3:59:26] in the Baylands and I want to also bake kudos to the development team for the video as a documentary
[3:59:35] filmmaker I really appreciate what's involved with a production like that. But as you well
[3:59:43] know along with many of my colleagues we have concerns and I'd like to start with one
[3:59:50] from Brisbane's own environmental impact statement on the Baylands.
[3:59:56] At peak rating of the Baylands.
[4:00:00] Sight, the number of hall trucks would, quote, almost wholly occupied, the inbound tunnel Avenue Bridge, substantially reducing emergency vehicle access.
[4:00:13] This is a cause for serious concern for me. This environmental impact report is analyzing 640 round trip, truck calls a day, including 160 during a peak hour, nearly three a minute,
[4:00:29] for approximately 34 months, just think about what that means on tunnel avenue on tunnel bridge.
[4:00:38] These aren't wide roads with large shoulders where trust can simply pull over when they hear a siren.
[4:00:47] Tunnel avenue is also our evacuation route provides access to existing businesses along tunnel and going south towards Sierra Point.
[4:00:56] So what happens when there's a fire, what happens when someone needs an ambulance, what happens
[4:01:05] if Brisbane needs to be evacuated?
[4:01:10] Now, at the queuing of the trucks without electric trucks and I've done some research
[4:01:16] electric trucks are coming down the pike, but there's not a lot of them yet.
[4:01:23] And without electric trucks, they'll be serious diesel, engine noise and exhaust along with dust and increased traffic noise.
[4:01:35] Proposal is nearly three truck calls a minute during peak calls.
[4:01:41] So I would just request the staff to do a little bit more research on the likelihood of hundreds of electric trucks being available when they're needed.
[4:01:53] 30 for months is only an estimate. Construction schedules, as you folks know, have a way
[4:02:00] of becoming longer. I submit the no community should be asked to endure years of this level
[4:02:06] of truck traffic, noise, dust, and interference with emergency access, simply to accommodate
[4:02:15] a development project. Development has to accommodate the safety of the community.
[4:02:20] It would develop or has the right to put people's lives in jeopardy.
[4:02:26] So I said before this plan is approved, the city should require their developer to provide
[4:02:32] a holly root or a viable conveyor plan that minimizes our daily environment.
[4:02:41] I'm sorry, maintains our daily environment and preserves emergency access at all times.
[4:02:48] Thank you.
[4:02:48] Thank you, Charles Spencer.
[4:02:59] I would like to thank the Council of hosting this meeting.
[4:03:02] My name is Charles Spencer and I'm a Brisbane resident.
[4:03:04] I have two questions.
[4:03:05] Not sure the best place to ask these questions, but the first.
[4:03:09] The combined development of the Bayland's visitation valley,
[4:03:13] chemistry park, with or without the road diet,
[4:03:16] has potential to strangle Brisbane,
[4:03:18] central Brisbane, retail, and its soft capital infrastructure.
[4:03:23] What economic analysis have you done to demonstrate the impact on Brisbane with all this
[4:03:31] development?
[4:03:32] Second question, what are the plans for pedestrian and sidewalk safety from throughout
[4:03:40] the length of Bayshore, as it parallels Brisbane?
[4:03:46] Thank you.
[4:03:47] Thank you.
[4:03:49] Michelle Salmon, last one.
[4:03:52] on line.
[4:03:56] There we go. Sorry, I had to wait to be muted. I am very much against the
[4:04:01] base or mobility plant plan, taking it down to one lane in each direction would truly put
[4:04:08] the city of Brisbane at high risk. And it would be a traffic jam all the time with the amount of trucks
[4:04:15] going in and out of Amazon, the amount of trucks going in and out of Crocker industrial park,
[4:04:20] the traffic coming off of Guadalupe Canyon Parkway and the future traffic from the baylands.
[4:04:29] And even the Geneva extension, I still think there will be a tremendous amount of traffic on
[4:04:35] old Bayshore because if you're at the intersection of Geneva and Bayshore and you want to go south
[4:04:42] on one and one, the Geneva extension actually wants you to go east by northeast before you can
[4:04:50] self, whereas the inclination is to just go south, because Old Bay Shore goes south, southeast,
[4:04:57] south, to where you want to be. And without the Geneva extension, I, it's just not going
[4:05:05] to work, but also with the Geneva extension, it's not going to make Bay Shore any less traffic.
[4:05:11] There's going to be more traffic than ever, because the population growth, access, traffic,
[4:05:16] Oh, and God forbid, we should approve the Corey project,
[4:05:19] which will add even more trucks coming in and out
[4:05:22] that need to use Bayshore to access Crocker Industrial Park.
[4:05:27] So I understand the,
[4:05:31] La, La, La, wonderful part of the Bayshore Mobility Plan
[4:05:38] and having all these different,
[4:05:41] taking it down to two lanes to slow it down.
[4:05:43] It won't slow it down.
[4:05:44] bring it to a standstill. So please take that off the table and yeah I'd love to have
[4:05:52] safe pedestrian and bike path next to Old Bay Shore but I also don't want a row of cars just
[4:06:00] stop there all the time and environmentally because they're going so slow and still down traffic
[4:06:05] it is definitely going to increase our greenhouse gas emissions having the Bay Shore lack of mobility
[4:06:12] Thank you so much and sorry for staying so late.
[4:06:18] Okay, thank you, Michelle.
[4:06:19] So we are table in council questions until the next meeting.
[4:06:27] And this meeting is a good question.
[4:06:30] Madam, I'd say one question.
[4:06:33] One second.
[4:06:34] You have to continue the public hearing.
[4:06:37] I'll make a motion to continue the meeting to.
[4:06:41] October 15th, I'm sorry. October 15th, October 15th at 5.30 p.m.
[4:06:48] All right. And then I just second.
[4:06:50] Just so. All in favor.
[4:06:53] Hi. So I just want to just to, you know, to see if there's any objections, you know,
[4:07:00] last, you know, maybe the last year and we talked about having a peer review for the onsite
[4:07:05] industry study and just you know just giving counsel I mean it stopped direction to move forward
[4:07:11] that so just if there's if there's there is any objections to to move forward with that.
[4:07:18] Councilmember O'Connell? I think that the study is
[4:07:21] is a stale enough that we wouldn't want to just peer-review it.
[4:07:28] So it is okay.
[4:07:32] Councilmember Kern, your opinion? I object until I see an estimate of labor and cost to do that. Thank you.
[4:07:42] And projected timeline. That's how I mean, you don't have to feel the way. Okay, so staff, can you come back to us with answers next meeting? Timeline, cost, and what was the other staffing?
[4:07:59] We are working.
[4:07:59] Time and money.
[4:08:00] That's it.
[4:08:01] Time and money.
[4:08:02] We're working on obtaining a proposal so we'll be able to report that back to you.
[4:08:05] But I think the consensus is we're potentially looking at on the on news study,
[4:08:11] not a peer review, right?
[4:08:14] And maybe not a new study.
[4:08:16] Maybe not.
[4:08:20] Okay.
[4:08:21] Kevin, were you going to say something?
[4:08:23] Oh, just the estimate we were pursuing was for a peer review.
[4:08:27] So this is a little different.
[4:08:28] we can keep both. It was my,
[4:08:37] it seems that a peer review of an old study is as much work as a new
[4:08:47] study. I don't know. It's too late in the day for me to, I haven't had it explained
[4:08:53] enough to meet to authorize, to do.
[4:08:56] Let's just come back with both recommendations.
[4:08:59] That will solve the problem.
[4:09:04] All right.
[4:09:04] This meeting is adjourned at more one minute,
[4:09:07] come on, more than one minute, 9.37 pm.
[4:09:10] Yeah, I gave us till 9.40.
[4:09:11] OK.
[4:09:12] Oh, wow.
[4:09:14] OK.
[4:09:14] We're there.
[4:09:15] Let's talk a little bit.